DOSSIER PEDAGÒGIC EDUCA AMB L’ART SESSIÓ 6 CONTINGUTS: RELAXACIÓ DIDÀCTICA ARTÍSTICA Elaborat per Elisenda Martí ('8&$$0%/·$57 5(/$;$&,Ð &RQIHUqQFLDDFjUUHFG·(OLVHQGD0DUWt 3UHVHQWDFLy eVLPSRUWDQWTXHDTXHVWDDTXHVWDWHPjWLFDV·KDJLLQFOzVHQDTXHVWFXUVMD TXH WDQW HQV SHUPHWUj HVGHYHQLU PLOORUV SHUVRQHV FRP VHU ERQV SURIHVVLRQDOV$PEDTXHVWDVHVVLyGHVFREULUHPTXHDWUDYpVGHOD5HOD[DFLy L GH OD 5HVSLUDFLy GLVSRVDUHP G·HLQHV SHU YLXUH L H[HUFLU OD QRVWUD IHLQD G·XQDPDQHUDPpVJUDWLILFDQW &RPKLYDLJDUULEDU 'HVSUpVG·KDYHUIHWHOVPHXVHVWXGLVPXVLFDOVLXQLYHUVLWDULVYDLJFRPHQoDU DFRQqL[HUPHWRGRORJLHVDFWLYHV GHSHGDJRJLDPXVLFDO7RWHVW·HQVHQ\HQD FDQWDU GLULJLU HWF 3HUz O·~QLFD TXH HP YD SDUODU GH 5HOD[DFLy L HOV VHXV JUDQVEHQHILFLVYDVHUODPHWRGRORJLD0DUWHQRW0DOJUDWTXHpVEjVLFDPHQW XQDSHGDJRJLDPXVLFDOHOVHXFUHDGRUSHQVDYDTXHXQERQPHVWUHKDGHVHU FRQVFLHQW GHOV VHXV HVWDWV DQtPLFV MD TXH Wp XQD WRWDO UHVSRQVDELOLWDW GDYDQW GHOV DOXPQHV /·DFWLWXG GHO SURIHVVRU LQIOXHQFLD OD GHOV DOXPQHV ,JXDOPHQWSHUFDQWDURWRFDUXQLQVWUXPHQWKLKDG·KDYHUXQFRQWUROPHQWDO LItVLF3HUDTXHVWVPRWLXVYDLJHVWXGLDUDIRQVDTXHVWDPHWRGRORJLD (O PqWRGH $OH[DQGHU WDPEp YD FRQGLFLRQDU PROW OD PHYD WUDMHFWzULD SURIHVVLRQDO (QV SDUOD GH OD XWLOLW]DFLy MXVWD GH O·HQHUJLD SHU UHDOLW]DU ϭ TXDOVHYRODFFLy$OH[DQGHUYDHVFULXUHODVHYDWqFQLFDYRFDOLFRUSRUDOFRP DFRQVHTqQFLDG·XQHVDIRQLHVUHLWHUDGHVTXHSDWLDTXDQDFWXDYDG·DFWRU $PEHOVDQ\VKHDQDWGHVFREULQWTXHDOOzPpVLPSRUWDQWpV&20(06(172 &20 6( 6(17(1 (/6 868$5,6 1R WDQW VL DSUHQHQ D DILQDU R D GHVFREULU O·LQWqUYDOGHWHUFHUD(OVUHVXOWDWVYpQHQVROV 8QD UHIOH[Ly TXH HP IDLJ VRYLQW pV TXH HQFDUD DFWXDOPHQW O·HGXFDFLy HVWj EDVDGD HQ FRQWLQJXWV PDMRULWjULDPHQW LQWHOĊOHFWXDOV 1R DSUHQHP D JHVWLRQDUOHVQRVWUHVHPRFLRQVQLSHQVDPHQWV 3HUTXqODQHFHVVLWHP 'HV TXH QHL[HP OHV SRUV WLPLGHVD LQVHJXUHWDWV EDL[D DXWRHVWLPD HWF HQV SURYRTXHQ FRQWUDFFLRQV PXVFXODUV SqUGXD G·HQHUJLD FDQVDPHQW L GHVLOĊOXVLy /·DQJRL[DLO·HVWUqVIDQTXHSHUGHPODFDSDFLWDWGHUHVSLUDUFRUUHFWDPHQW /D 5HOD[DFLy GyQD HLQHV SHU FRQWLQXDU LOĊOXVLRQDWV L DPE HQHUJLD (QV SHUPHW VHU PROW FRQVFLHQWV GHOV QRVWUHV HVWDWV HPRFLRQDOV L PHQWDOV 0LWMDQoDQWOD5HVSLUDFLySRWHQFLDUHPHOSHQVDPHQWSRVLWLXLUHFXSHUDUHPOD QRVWUDHQHUJLDLDOHJULD6RPPpVHPRFLyTXHUDy +LKDXQDLQWHUGHSHQGqQFLDHQWUHODUHVSLUDFLyLOHVHPRFLRQV/DUHVSLUDFLy SRWFDQYLDUXQDHPRFLyLDOFRQWUDUL Ϯ EMHFWLXVSULQFLSDOV • $SUHQGUHDUHOD[DUVHHQVLWXDFLRQVG·HVWUqVSHUVRQDOLODERUDO • 0LOORUDUODFDSFLWDWG·DXWRFRQWUROHPRFLRQDO • $XJPHQWDUO·DXWRHVWLPD • 5HIRUoDUODPRWLYDFLyODLOĊOXVLyLHOSODHUGHFRPXQLFDU • 3UHQGUH FRQVFLqQFLD GH OD LPSRUWjQFLD GH OD SUzSLD VDOXW ItVLFD ² SVtTXLFD²HPRFLRQDO$SUHQGUHDFXLGDUVH • 6XSHUDUIDFWRUVGHGHVHTXLOLEUL • 6HQWLUTXHVRPDPRVGHQRVDOWUHVPDWHL[RV • 6HQWLUHOEHQHVWDULQWHUQSHUWDQWPLOORUDUOHVQRVWUHVDFFLRQV • $FFHSWDUWRWDOOzTXHSHQVHPLVHQWLPVHQVHFXOSDELOLW]DFLRQV • 'HVHQYROXSDU OD FUHDWLYLWDW 6HJRQV (VWDQLVODR %DFKUDFK OHV LGHHV DSDUHL[HQHQODIDVHJDPPDRVLJXLTXDQHOFHUYHOOHVWjWUDQTXLO 4XLQVEHQHILFLVHQVGyQD 3ULQFLSDOPHQW DPE OD VHYD SUjFWLFD PLOORUHP OD TXDOLWDW GHO QRVWUH HVWDWLQWHULRU 0~VLFD PLOORUD OD QRVWUD DXGLFLy LQWHUQD 3HUFHEHP HOV VRQV /HV FRUGHVYRFDOVHVIOH[LELOLW]HQ 'DQVD PLOORUD OD SHUFHSFFLy PXVFXODU L QHUYLRVD 3UHGLVSRVLFLy DO PRYLPHQW ϯ 7HDWUH PHPzULD LQWHUQD GHO WH[W &RQQH[Ly DPE HO SHUVRQDWJH D LQWHUSUHWDU 3HUFHSFLy GHOV HVWDWV PXVFXODUV L QHUYLRVRV $TXHVWD SHUFHSFLy SHUPHWXQFDQYLHQHOFOLPDLQWHULRUDL[zpVGLIHUHQWDO·HVIRUoGH YROXQWDW)HUOHVFRVHVSHUTXqHQVDJUDGHQ (QVSHUPHWGHVHQYROXSDUQRVG·XQDPDQHUDPpVQDWXUDO /·DFXPXODFLy GH FRQHL[HPHQWV ~QLFDPHQW LQWHOĊOHFWXDOV QRPpV GHVHQYROXSD XQD SDUW GH OD SHUVRQD 3HU WDQW OD SHUVRQD pV OD VXPDGHOVHVWDWVLQWHOĊOHFWXDOVPpVHOVHVWDWVQHUYLRVRV (Q OORF GH OOXLWDU FRQWUD HOV FRQIOLFWHV OD UHOD[DFLy HQV SHUPHW DSOLFDUPLWMDQVTXHKDUPRQLW]HQHOVQRVWUHVHVWDWVSVLFRILVLROzJLFV $&&(37$&,Ð &RQQHFWDUDPEHOSUHVHQW 4XDQKRDSOLTXHP" +LKDWqFQLTXHVGHPHGLWDFLyTXHDFRQVHOOHQSUDFWLFDUKRSHOPDWtRDEDQV G·DQDUDGRUPLUeVPROWFRUUHFWHSHUzHOPLOORUpVSRVDUKRHQSUjFWLFDD TXDOVHYROPRPHQWPHQWUDHVSHURO·DXWRE~VDO·DXODSDUODQWDPEDOJ~HWF ([HUFLFLV ,QVSLUDWV HQ OD WqFQLFD GH UHOD[DFLy VHJRQV 0DUWHQRW L OD SUzSLD H[SHULqQFLDSHUVRQDO ϰ ([HUFLFL5HVSLUDFLyDEGRPLQDO$VVHJXWV3UHQGUHFRQVFLqQFLDGHOFRVLGH ODVHYDSRVLFLy5HDOLW]DUUHVSLUDFLRQVSURIXQGHVGHL[DQWTXHO·DLUHHQWUH LVXUWLVXDXPHQW ([HUFLFL$VVHJXWV%HOOXJDUHOFDSHQGDYDQWDODYHJDGDTXHWUHLHPO·DLUH FDSHQGDUUHUDDOPDWHL[PRPHQWTXHLQVSLUHP ([HUFLFL $VVHJXWV ´/D EROD G·HQHUJLDµ 3RVDUHP OHV PDQV FRP VL WLQJXpVVLPXQDSLORWDGDYDQWGHOQRVWUHSLW$O·LQVSLUDUVHSDUDUHPOHVPDQV LDO·H[SLUDUDMXQWDUHPOHVPDQVVHPSUHPDQWHQLQWODSLORWDLPDJLQjULD ([HUFLFL 5HOD[DFLy GH EDVH $VVHJXWV 9LVXDOLW]DU XQ UHFRUUHJXW GHVFHQGHQWDOOODUJGHOQRVWUHFRV )URQWFDUDFXLUSLOyVXOOVERFD &HUYLFDOVFROOHVSDWOOHV %UDoRVPDQVGLWV 7zUD[HVTXHQD $EGRPHQ]RQDOXPEDU *OXWLVJHQLWDOV &DPHVLFXL[HVGLWVGHOSHX ([HUFLFL(OGREOHSqQGXO'UHWV$QDUGREOHJDQWHOFRVFDSHQGDYDQWL D XQDGLVWjQFLDLQWHUPLWMDSXMDUHOVEUDoRVDJXDQWDUORVLGHVSUpVDEDQGRQDU VHDOPRYLPHQWQDWXUDOFRPVLIRVVLQXQVSqQGXOVGHUHOORWJH ϱ ([HUFLFL5HOD[DFLyDPEP~VLFD'UHWV(VFROWDUXQDDXGLFLySHUH[HPSOH O·jULD´9RLTXHVDSHWHµGH´/HV1RFHVGH)tJDURµGH:$0R]DUW,PDJLQDU TXH VRP SLQWRUV L EHOOXJXHP OHV QRVWUHV PDQV H[SUHVVDQW L VHQWLQW LQWHULRUPHQWODP~VLFD$O·DFDEDUVHXUHLGHPDQDUTXLQRTXLQVFRORUVHOV VXJJHUHL[DTXHVWDP~VLFDSDLVDWJHLVHQWLPHQW 5HIOH[LRQV $EDQV GH GHPDQDUKR DOV QRVWUHV XVXDULV KHP GH FRPHQoDU SHU QRVDOWUHV PDWHL[RV L FUHXUH IHUPDPHQWHQ OD VHYD LPSRUWjQFLD/D 5HVSLUDFLy HV SRW FRPHQoDUSHULPLWDFLy3URSRVDUTXHVLJXLQHOOVTXLSRUWLQXQDP~VLFD ([SHULqQFLD DPE HOV DOXPQHV GH OD 8QLYHUVLWDW %ODQTXHUQD &DGD DOXPQH SRUWDYDXQDP~VLFDTXHOLDJUDGDYD/DIHLDHVFROWDUDOVFRPSDQ\VEXVFDQW VHQWLPHQWVFRORUVPRYLPHQWVFRUSRUDOV(QSRVWHULRUVDXGLFLRQVSDVVjYHP D XQ QLYHOO PpV LQWHOĊOHFWXDO OD GHVFREHUWD G·HOHPHQWV PXVLFDOV FRPSjV WLPEUHVG·LQVWUXPHQWVIUDVHVPHOzGLTXHV 6HJXLQWHOPHVWUDWJHGH0DUWHQRW´3ULPHUO·HVSHULWGHVSUpVO·LQWHOĊOHFWHµ ϲ %,%/,2*5$),$:(%*5$),$,5()(5Ë1&,(6 /,LEUHV • $ER]]L3DROR(O$%&GHODUHODMDFLyQ(G0DUWtQH]5RFD • %DFK(YD'DUGHU3HUH6HGXHL[WHSHUVHGXLU(GLFLRQV5RVD 6HQVDW • %\UQH5RQGD7KH6HFUHW(G8UDQR • &UX]&DPLOR/DOH\GHOD$WUDFFLyQ(G7DOOHUGHOe[LWR • &XHQFD0DWHR$QWRQLR0LVLyQ6HUHQLGDG6RIURORJtD&D\FHGLDQD 5HODMDFLyQ'LQiPLFD(G0DQGDOD • 'DODL/DPD6DELGXUtDHPRFLRQDO(G.DLURV • 'DYLV0FND\\(VKHOPDQ7pFQLFDVGH$XWRFRQWUROHPRFLRQDO(G 0DUWtQH]5RFD • 'H/DVVXV5HQp&RPROOHJDUDVHUW~PLVPR(G,EHULD • 'LVSHQ]D-RH'HVDUUROODWXFHUHEUR(G/D(VIHUDGHORV/LEURV • '\HU:D\QH:(OSRGHUGHODLQWHUDFFLyQ(G'HEROVLOOR • '\HU:D\QH:,QVSLUDFLyQHQFXHQWUDWXYHUGDGHUDHVHQFLD(G 3DOP\UD • (OOLV$OEHUW8VWHGSXHGHVHUIHOL]7HUDSLDUDFLRQDOHPRWLYD FRQGXFWXDOSDUDVXSHUDUODDQVLHGDG\ODGHSUHVLyQ(G3DLGyV • *ROHPDQ'DQLHO.DXIPDQ3DXO\5D\0LFKDHO(OHVSLULWXFUHDWLYR (G(GLFLRQHV% • *ROHPDQ'DQLHOODLQWHOLJHQFLDHPRFLRQDO(G%DQWDP%RRNV • *ROHPDQ'DQLHO'DODL/DPD/HVHPRFLRQVLODVDOXW'LjOHJVDPEHO 'DODL/DPD(G6/3DJHV(GLWRUV$QLHO • +HQGULFNV*D\$SUHQGHDDPDUWHDWLPLVPR(G2EHOLVFR • +LFNV(VWKHU\-HUU\(OLQFUHtEOHSRGHUGHODVHPRFLRQHV(G8UDQR • +LFNV(VWKHU\-HUU\(O9yUWLFH(G8UDQR • +LFNV(VWKHU\-HUU\3LGH\VHWH'DUi(G8UDQR • -RQJHZDUG-DPHV1DFLGRVSDUD7ULXQIDU$QiOLVLV7UDQVDFFLRQDO\ *HVWDOW(G$GGLVRQ:HVOH\,EHURDPHULFDQD • .DWLH%\URQ$PDUORTXHHV(G8UDQR • .ULVKQDQGD'U7KRPDV7UREH'HODFRGHSHQGHQFLDDODOLEHUWDG(G *XODDE • .ULVKQDPXUWL8*(OSHQVDPLHQWRHVWXHQHPLJR(G*XODDE • .EOHU5RVV(.HVVOHU'DYLGOHFFLRQHVGH9LGD(G/XFLpUQDJD ϳ • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • /RQJ%DUU\6yORHOPLHGRPXHUH(G*XODDE /RZHQ$OH[DQGUH%LRHQHUJpWLFD(G'LDQD 00DUWHQRWL6DwWR&KULVWLQH6HUHOD[HU(G$OELQ0LFKHO 1DUDQMR&ODXGLR/DYLHMD\1RYLVLPD*HVWDOW(G&XDWURYLHQWRV 2UU/HRQDUG5HELUWKLQJUHVSLUDFLyQFRQVFLHQWH(G1XHYD(UD 2VKR$PRU9LGD5LVD(G3ODQHWD'H$JRVWLQL 2VKR(PRFLRQHV(G(GDG 2VKR0DGXUH](G*ULMDOER 3XQVHW(GXDUGR(OYLDMHDOD)HOLFLGDGODVQXHYDVFODYHVFLHQWtILFDV 5&DXWHOD-RVHSK*URGHQ-XQH(MHUFLFLRVGHUHODMDFLyQ(G 0DUWtQH]5RFD 5&DXWHOD-RVHSK*URGHQ-XQH7pFQLFDVGHUHODMDFLyQ(G0DUWtQH] 5RFD 5DPyQ&RUWpV)HUUDQ/DLVODGHORVIDURV(G5%$ 5D\6RQGUD&HOHEUDQGRODUHVSLUDFLyQ(G1HR3HUVRQ 5LEHLUR/DLU$\~GDWHSDUDDOFDQ]DUORTXHTXLHUHVHQODYLGD(G 8UDQR 5RMDV0DUFRV/XLV/DDXWRHVWLPD(G(VSDVD 5RMDV0DUFRV/XLV/DIXHU]DGHORSWLPLVPR(G5RGHVD 6DPVy5DLPRQ&LWDHQODFLPD(G2EHOLVFR 6HUYDQ6FKUHLEHU'DYLG&XUDFLyQ(PRFLRQDO(G&DLURV 6KDUPD5RELQ6(OPRQMHTXHYHQGLyVX)HUUDUL(G'HEROVLOOR 7ROOH(FNKDUW(OSRGHUGHO$KRUD(G*DLD 3jJLQHVZHE • KWWSZZZDEUDKDPKLFNVFRP • KWWSZZZFODXGLRQDUDQMRQHW • KWWSZZZNXQJIXZHERUJ • KWWSZZZOHRQDUGRUUFRP • KWWSZZZOXLVURMDVPDUFRVFRP • KWWSZZZRVKRJXODDEFRP • KWWSZZZVRIURORJLDFRP • KWWSZZZMXQWRVSRGHPRVFRP ϴ 3HOĊOtFXOHV'RFXPHQWDOVL&RQIHUqQFLHV • &XHQWRVSDUDSHQVDU-RUJH%XFD\ • 'HVDUUROODWXFHUHEUR-RH'LVSHQ]D • (OSRGHUGHOD,QWHQFLyQ'U:D\QH:'\HU • (OVHFUHWRGHOD/H\GHOD$WUDFFLyQ(VWKHU\-HUU\+LFNV • (O6HFUHWRGHOD/H\GHOD$WUDFFLyQ,,(VWKHU\-HUU\+LFNV • (QFXHQWUDHOSURSyVLWRGHWXYLGD&RQIHUHQFLD(FNKDUW7ROOH • +R\HPSLH]DWRGR'LULJLGDSRU%HUWUDQG7DYHUQLHU • /D%HOOH9HUWH(O3ODQHWD/LEUH&ROLQH6HUUHDX0DQJD+RPH9LGHR • /DQXHYDFRQFLHQFLD&RQIHUHQFLD(FNKDUW7ROOH • /DVQXHYHUHYHODFLRQHVODSHOtFXOD%DVDGDHQHO%HVW6HOOHUGH -DPHV5HGILHOG • 0HGLWDFLyQKR\8QDLQWURGXFFLyQDODPHGLWDFLyQVHJ~Q26+2 'LULJLGDSRU/LVEHWK3HWWHUVHQ • 0HQWHV%ULOODQWHVHQEXVFDGHOD)HOLFLGDG • 3HQVDQWHQHOVDOWUHV'RFXPHQWDOGH79 • 3LHQVDFRPRXQJHQLR5DLPRQ6DPVy • 7KH6HFUHW%DVDGDHQHOOLEURGH5KRQGD%\UQH • ¢<W~TXpVDEHV"5DPWKD V6FKRRORI(QOLJKWHQPHQW ϵ ('8&$$0%/·$57 ','­&7,&$$57Ì67,&$ &RQIHUqQFLDDFjUUHFG·(OLVHQGD0DUWt 3UHSDUDFLySUqYLDGHODVHVVLyDUHDOLW]DU 9LVXDOLW]DFLy $EDQVGHSUHSDUDUHOVFRQWLQJXWVGHODVHVVLyTXHYROHPSURSRVDUMD VLJXLQ UHODFLRQDWV DPE P~VLFD WHDWUH R GDQVD HQV FDO XQD HVWRQD G·LPDJLQDU O·HVSDL RQ KR IDUHP HOV PDWHULDOV DPE HOV TXDOV WUHEDOODUHP L HO TXH pV PpV LPSRUWDQW 3(16$5 $0%/(6 3(5621(6 D OHV TXDOV YD GHVWLQDGD OD VHVVLy /HV FDUjFWHUtVWLTXHV GHO JUXS VL pV QRPEUyV R QR OD VHYD KRPRJHQHwWDW KHWHURJHQHwWDW L HQ FRQFUHW DTXHOOV XVXDULV TXH SHU OHV VHYHV FDUDFWHUtVWLTXHV LQIOXLUDQ HQ OHV DFWLYLWDWV 8Q JUXS KHWHURJHQL VHPSUH VHUj PpV HQULTXLGRU PDOJUDW TXHDSULRULHQVSRWUHVXOWDUPpVGLItFLOGHGLQDPLW]DU 3HU H[HPSOH SHUVRQHV DPE XQ JUDX G·DWHQFLy OLPLWDW GLILFXOWDWV PRWULXV HGDW HVWDW HPRFLRQDO HWF 1R GHPDQDU UHV TXH HOOV QR SXJXLQIHU 6·KDQ GH WUREDU D JXVW SDUWLFLSDQW 'HV GHO SULPHU PRPHQW KDQ GH WHQLU OD LPSUHVVLy TXH VXSHUHQ OHV GLILFXOWDWV L TXH DOOz TXH IDQ pV VDWLVIDFWRUL(OUHVXOWDWYLQGUjVRO&DGDGLDpVXQDILQDOLWDW ϭ 7HQLU HQ FRPSWH O·HVSDL 6L pV JUDQ PROW SOH GH PREOHV EXLW VL KL WRFDHOVROVLpVXQDDXODVRUROORVDHWF (OV SDUHOOV DXGLRYLVXODV 2Q HVWDQ FROĊORFDWV $ SRGHU VHU KDXULHQ G·HVWDU GDYDQW HQ XQ OORF RQ GHVSUpV TXDQ HOV PDQLSXOHP SRJXHP PDQWHQLU HO FRQWDFWH YLVXDO DPE OHV SHUVRQHV DPE OHV TXDOV HVWHP WUHEDOODQW 7RWDL[zQRSRUWDPDVVDHVWRQDpVSHQVDUKLL XELFDUVHPHQWDOPHQW HQO·HVSDLRQIDUHPODVHVVLy 3URJUDPDFLy +HFRQVLGHUDWTXHHQDTXHVWHVMRUQDGHVHGXFDWLYHVV·KDGHVHQYROXSDW XQ WLSXV GH IRUPDFLy EjVLFDPHQW VHQVRULDO 2 VLJXL HQ HO FDV GH OD P~VLFD V·KDQ YLVFXW HOV HOHPHQWV PXVLFDOV G·XQD PDQHUD YLYHQFLDO VHQVHHQWUDUHQODQRWDFLyPXVLFDO ,JXDOPHQW KD VXFFHwW DPE OD GDQVD L HO WHDWUH /D GHVFREHUWD GHO OOHQJXDWJHYHUEDOLFRUSRUDOV·KDEDVDWHQO·H[SHULPHQWDFLySUzSLD /·HGXFDFLy VHQVRULDO GH OD P~VLFD FRPSRUWD HOV VHJHQWV EORFV GH FRQWLQJXWVTXHHQDTXHVWHVMRUQDGHVDTXtV·KDQWUHEDOODW - &DQoyLYHX - $XGLFLyUHFRQHL[HPQWG·LQVWUXPHQWVTXDOLWDWVVRQRUHVUtWPLTXHV PHOzGLTXHVKDUPzQLTXHVHWF - ,QVWUXPHQWV Ϯ /D'DQVDWDPEpHVSRWLQFORXUHFRPXQFRQWLQJXWDHGXFDUMDTXHpVXQ DVSHFWHJOREDOTXHLQFLGHL[SOHQDPHQWHQODIRUPDFLyPXVLFDO&RRUGLQDFLy ODWHUDOLWDWULWPHIUDVHLJH[SUHVVLyJHVWXDOHWF 7RWV DTXHVWV FRQWLQJXWV HQV SRUWHQ DO FRQHL[HPHQW GHOV HOHPHQWV GH OD P~VLFDVRULWPHPHORGLDLKDUPRQLD &DQoyYHXDXGLFLyLQVWUXPHQWVLGDQVDpVOD EDVH VHQVRULDOGHODP~VLFD $PE DTXHVW WUHEDOO PpV HQGDYDQW HV SRGUj DFFHGLU D XQD HGXFDFLy PpV LQWHOĊOHFWXDOTXHHQVSRUWDUjDOOOHQJXDWJHPXVLFDO &RP GHLD (GJDU :LOOHPV O·HGXFDFLy GHO VR REUH OD SHUFHSFLy DXGLWLYD (O ULWPH HGXFD HOV VHJPHQWV FRUSRUDOV L OHV LQGHSHQGqQFLHV JHVWXDOV TXH DMXGHQDO·DSUHQHQWDWJHGHODWqFQLFDLQVWUXPHQWDO$WUDYpVGHODPHORGLD FXOWLYHP OHV HPRFLRQV OD VHQVLELOLWDW /·KDUPRQLD LQFLGHL[ HQ OD SDUW PpV LQWHOĊOHFWXDOGHODSHUVRQD /D FDSDFLWDW FUHDWLYD WDPEp OD SRGHP GHVHQYROXSDU DPE OD FRQVWUXFFLy G·LQVWUXPHQWV1RFDOGLUDPEODLQWHUSUHWDFLyGHFDQoRQVMDVLJXLDPEXQ LQVWUXPHQWRFDQWDGHV (OV FRQWLQJXWV SURSLV GH O·DUW WHDWUDO L GH OD GDQVD HOV WUREDUHP HQ HOV GRVVLHUVFRUUHVSRQHQWV ϯ 0HWRGRORJLD (OV XVXDULV DSUHQGUDQ GH YRVDOWUHV SHU WDQW HVWDUHX IHQW XQD PHWRGRORJLD VHQVRULDOEDVDGDHQ ,0,7$&,Ð DPE OHV YRVWUH SURSRVWHV HOOV XV LPLWDUDQ &RSLDUDQ HO JHVW O·HQWRQDFLyGHODYHXHOVVRQVLHOVULWPHV /D LPLWDFLy pV DTXHVW SURFHGLPHQW TXH GXUDQW PROWV VHJOHV KD VHUYLW SHU WUDQVPHQWUH HOV FRQHL[HPHQWV DUWtVWLFV /·HVFULSWXUD PXVLFDO QR YD DSDUqL[HUILQVO·(GDWPLWMDQD 0ROWHVFXOWXUHVDFWXDOVHVWUDQVPHWHQG·DTXHVWDPDQHUD 5(&21(,;(0(17pVHOPRPHQWGHO·DXGLFLyeVO·LQVWDQWGHOUHFRQHL[HPHQW GHOV WHPHV PHOzGLFV WLPEUHV G·LQVWUXPHQWV HWF eV HO PRPHQW GH OD LQWHULRULW]DFLy (Q GDQVD LPDJLQDUWH HOV PRYLPHQWV VDEHU TXLQV VyQ (Q WHDWUHLPDJLQDUWHHOSHUVRQDWJH(QSLQWXUDYLVXDOLW]DUODWHYDREUDHWF 5(352'8&&,Ð,03529,6$&,ÐHVGyQDHQHOPRPHQWTXHIDVSHUWXPDWHL[ DOOz TXH WHQV LQWHULRULW]DW (Q P~VLFD FDQWDU VHQVH PRGHO WRFDU XQ LQVWUXPHQWFRPSRQGUHXQDP~VLFDHWF(QGDQVDFRPELQDUDPEH[SUHVVLy HOV JHVWRV SURSLV G·XQD GDQVD L HQ WHDWUH OD LQWHUSUHWDFLy SHUVRQDO G·XQ SHUVRQDWJHRVLWXDFLyMDVLJXLDPEHOOOHQJXDWJHRUDORJHVWXDO 'HVSUpV G·KDYHU WULDW HO FRQWLQJXW D GHVHQYROXSDU D OD VHVVLy L HO VHX SURFHGLPHQWWLQGUpHQFRPSWH ϰ &ROORFDFLyGHOVXVXDULV /HV DFWLYLWDWV WULDGHV SHU OD VHVVLy GH P~VLFD WHDWUH R GDQVD KDQ G·HVWDU FRUUHFWDPHQWH[SOLFDGHV$WHQFLyDODSRVLFLyHVSDFLDOGHOVXVXDULV6HJRQV TXLQHV DFWLYLWDWV YD Ep OD URGRQD R OD IRUPD G·8 /HV GXHV RUJDQLW]DFLRQV VyQ DFROOLGRUHV SHUz GHL[HP XQ FDPS YLVXDO ODWHUDO VHQVH GRPLQDU 3HU FDQWDUEpLFRQFUHWDPHQWODIRUPDFjQRQLDYHXVODSRVLFLyGHILOHVGyQD PROWERQUHVXOWDW eV LPSRUWDQW FRP V·HVFROWD DOOz TXH HOV WUDQVPHWHP 3URSRVDUHP XQD FRUUHFWD SRVLFLy GHO FRV 4XH OHV RUHOOHV HVWLJXLQ HQFDUDGHV GH FDUD DO SRQHQW &RPRUJDQLW]RODVHVVLy" $PE WRW DTXHVW PDWHULDO YLVXDOLW]DFLy SURJUDPDFLy PHWRGRORJLD L FROĊORFDFLyGHOVXVXDULVHVSRWGRQDUIRUPDDODVHVVLy1RFDOUHFRUGDUTXH pVQHFHVVDULDSXQWDUVHFXURVDPHQWHQXQGLDULSHUVRQDOO·HVTXHPDGHOTXH IDUHP 3ODQWHMRH[HPSOHVGHVHVVLRQV ([HPSOHVHVVLyPXVLFDO eVXQDVHVVLyVHQVRULDODPEPROWDLPLWDFLy(VSRWFRPHQoDUSHU ([HUFLFLVG·DWHQFLyRQHVGHPDQDSUHFLVLyVRQRUDUtWPLFDLPRWULX $TXHVWV H[HUFLFLV IXQFLRQHQ D TXDOVHYRO HGDW L VLWXDFLy 7HQHQ XQ FRPSRQHQW O~GLF LPSRUWDQW L DJUDGHQ 7DPEp DMXGHQ D FUHDU VLOHQFL ϱ &RQVLVWHL[HQSLFDUIzUPXOHVGHULWPHGHSXOVDFLRQVFDQYLDQWHOOORFGHOD SHUFXVVLy ([HUFLFLVGHYHX$PEO·DPELHQWG·DWHQFLyLVLOHQFLSRGUHPFRQWLQXDUOD LPLWDFLyDPEH[HUFLFLVGHYHXLUHVSLUDFLyVLUHQHVUHVVRQjQFLHVLPLWDFLRQV GHVRQVHWF $SUHQHQWDWJH GH OD FDQoy $UD MD HVWDQ D SXQW SHU DSUHQGUH XQD FDQoy QRYDODTXHHVFUHJXLTXHSRWDQDUEpLDJUDGDU3HUHQVHQ\DUODXWLOLW]DUp ODLPLWDFLy7DPEpUHSDVVDUQHDOJXQDDOWUDG·DSUHVD 'HSHQHQWGHFRPUHDFFLRQLHOJUXSGHVSUpVGHODFDQoyHVSRW FRQWLQXDU DPE XQD DXGLFLy IHU HVFROWDU XQD SHoD PXVLFDO RQ KL KD HOHPHQWV SHU GHVFREULU3HUzO·DPELHQWKDGHVHUSURSLFL'HYHJDGHVYDEpIHUDOJXQMRF UtWPLF VRQRU R PHOzGLF 4XH V·KDJLQ G·DL[HFDU EHOOXJDUVH &RQWLQXDU O·DWHQFLySHUzG·XQDDOWUDPDQHUDPpVO~GLFD6HJRQVODPHYDH[SHULqQFLD HOV FRQWHV PXVLFDOV GRQHQ PROW GH MRF D OD FUHDWLYLWDW L LPDJLQDFLy L DJUDGHQPROW 6LFRQVLGHUHXTXHHVWDQPRWLYDWVLWUDQTXLOVSRGHPFRQWLQXDUDPEO·DXGLFLy PXVLFDOVLDEDQVQRV·KDSURSRVDW$FDEDUDPEXQDDFWLYLWDWO~GLFDTXHQR GHPDQLWDQWDFRQFHQWUDFLy 'DQVD)LQDOLW]DUDPEPRYLPHQWVXEVWLWXLQWHOMRFPXVLFDOWDPEppVXQD RSFLyDGHTXDGD ϲ ([HPSOHVHVVLRQVWHDWUHLGDQVD 5HFRUGDUHOTXHHOVDOWUHVSRQHQWVXVKDQGLW ([HUFLFLVG·DWHQFLyODFRPHQoDULDLJXDOMDTXHSHUH[SOLFDUDOOzTXHHVIDUj WDPEpQHFHVVLWHPHOVLOHQFL ([HUFLFLV G·HVFDOIDPHQW YHX L FRV QRUPDOPHQW HV IDQ D SDUWLU GH OD LPLWDFLy &RQWLQJXWV SURSLV GH OD PDWqULD JUXL[ GH OD VHVVLy ([HUFLFLV G·LQWHULRULW]DFLyUHSURGXFFLyLQWHUSUHWDFLyLLPSURYLVDFLy &ORHQGD XQ MRF PRWLYDGRU UHSDVVDU DOJXQ H[HUFLFL TXH HOV YD DJUDGDU HWF/DYLVXDOLW]DFLyG·XQYLGHR 1RVDOWUHVVRPHOVFRQGXFWRUVGHODVHVVLySHUWDQWSRGHPLQWURGXLUWUHXUH RDIHJLUWRWHVDTXHOOHVDFWLYLWDWVTXHHQXQPRPHQWGHWHUPLQDWHQVVHPEOHQ RSRUWXQHVPRWLYDGRUHVLTXHIDQFUpL[HUHOVQRVWUHVXVXDULV (VWRQDDEDQVGHODVHVVLyHQHOSURSLOORF 0LOORUDUULEDUDOOORFRQIDUHPODVHVVLyDPEWHPSV$MXGDPROWDUHOD[DUVHL D OD YHJDGD D FRQFHQWUDUVH 6L HO PDWHL[ GLD QR pV SRVVLEOH GHL[DUKR SUHSDUDWHOGLDDEDQV ϳ 2UJDQLW]DFLyGHO·HVSDL 2UGHQDU OHV FDGLUHV R PRELOLDUL GH OD PDQHUD TXH QRVDOWUHV QHFHVVLWHP 3HQVHPFRPVHVHQWLUDQHOVXVXDULVTXDQDUULELQ8QHVSDLRUGHQDWLYHQWLODW pVPROWPpVDFROOLGRU$WHQFLyDOVROTXHSRWHQOOXHUQDU &RPSURYDFLyGHOVDSDUHOOVDXGLRYLVXDOV 6·KDG·DVVDMDUQHHOIXQFLRQDPHQW4XDQWHVYHJDGHVHQVKDSDVVDWTXHHQHO PRPHQW GH SUpPHU HO ERWy QR IXQFLRQD ,QWHQWDU WHQLUKR FROĊORFDW GH PDQHUDTXHSXJXHPGRPLQDUDPEODPLUDGDHOQRVWUHDXGLWRUL 3UHSDUDFLyGHOPDWHULDO ,JXDOTXHHOVDSDUHOOVGHPXOWLPqGLDFRQYpUHSDVVDUORVDFRQVFLqQFLD4XH Q·KLKDJLSHUWRWKRPTXHHVWLJXLQHQFRQGLFLRQVFRPHOVWUDQVSRUWDUpTXL HOVUHSDUWLUjHWF(O PDWHULDOPpVHQJUHVFDGRUGHL[DUORSHUHOILQDOGHOD VHVVLy )UXLW GH OD PHYD H[SHULqQFLD GHL[R SHO ILQDO GH OD FODVVH HOV LQVWUXPHQWV GH SHUFXVVLy GH VR LQGHWHUPLQDW $WHQFLy DTXHVW PDWHULDO pV PROW VRUROOyV 1R FRPHQoDU D SHUFXWLU O·LQVWUXPHQW ILQV TXH WRWKRP HQ WLQJXL 7UHEDOOSHUVRQDO 'HL[DUXQDHVWRQDSHUUHOD[DUQRVPHQWDOPHQWLItVLFDPHQW$OJXQVH[HUFLFLV SUHYLV GH UHVSLUDFLy DMXGHQ PROW D REVHUYDU HO QRVWUH HVWDW PHQWDO FRPSURYDU VL WHQLP QHJXLW 3DUDXOHV FRP DFFHSWDFLy FRQILDQoD DPE QRVDOWUHV JDQHV GH FRPSDUWLU HWF DMXGHQ D VHQWLUQRV HQFRUDWMDWV ϴ H[HUFLFLV GH UHOD[DFLy 0DUWHQRW $TXHVW WUHEDOO SHUVRQDO SRW FRQWLQXDU DPEXQHVFDOIDPHQWGHODYHX &RPDTXHOOTXHV·KDSUHSDUDWXQH[DPHQDEDQVGHFRPHQoDUODVHVVLyKHP GHIHUXQUHSjVPHQWDOGHWRWDOOzTXHIDUHP$MXGDPROWDOVXVXDULVO·HQOODo G·DFWLYLWDWVVHQVHOODFXQHVWRWFRPXQDXQLWDW 'XUDQWODVHVVLy (VTXHPDPHQWDOGHOWUHEDOODUHDOLW]DU $ OD YHJDGD TXH SURSRVHP OHV DFWLYLWDWV L REVHUYHP FRP HV GHVHQYROXSHQ KHP GH SHQVDU O·DFWLYLWDW VHJHQW $OOz TXH HOV ID WLUDU HQGDYDQW 0ROW JUDGXDOPHQWDQDUSXMDQWHOJUDXGHGLILFXOWDW 2EVHUYDFLyGLUHFWD /·REVHUYDFLy GH OHV SHUVRQHV pV IRQDPHQWDO 6HU VHQVLEOHV DO VHX HVWDW G·DWHQFLy VL HVWDQ FDQVDWVVL DOOz TXH SURSRVHP pV DGHTXDWHWF 3HUWDQW VHU XQ ERQ FRQGXFWRU LPSOLFD VHU PROW IOH[LEOH FDQYLDU G·DFWLYLWDW DPE UDSLGHVDVLV·REVHUYDTXHGHVFRQQHFWHQ(VFROOLUEpHOJUDXGHGLILFXOWDW 5HFXUVRVSVLFROzJLFVSHUVRQDOV 7RWVHOVTXHWUHEDOOHPDPESHUVRQHVVDEHPHOTXHFRVWDPDQWHQLUO·DWHQFLy L PRWLYDFLy GHOV QRVWUHV XVXDULV 4XH FRQWHQWV TXH HVWHP TXDQ YHLHP TXH DOOz TXH HOV SURSRVHP IXQFLRQD L FRP GHSULPHL[ TXDQ DTXHOOD PHUDYHOORVD VHVVLyTXHHQVKDYtHPSUHSDUDWQRVXUWFRPQRVDOWUHVHVSHUjYHP ϵ $PEHOVDQ\VTXHSRUWRDO·HQVHQ\DPHQWSXFDILUPDUTXHWDQWSRVLWLXpVXQD VLWXDFLy FRP XQD DOWUD /D SULPHUD HQV DMXGD D YHULILFDU TXH DOOz TXH SURSRVHPIXQFLRQD LODVHJRQDHQVHPSHQ\DPLOORUDULDEXVFDU VROXFLRQV 3RGHU FRPHQWDU OHV GLILFXOWDWV DPE DOWUHV FRPSDQ\V pV XQ UHFXUV PHQWDO H[WUDRUGLQDUL 3HUWDQWGDYDQWODGLILFXOWDWFDOFHQWUDUQRVHQQRVDOWUHVPDWHL[RVUHVSLUDU SDFLHQWPHQW LQWHQWDU QR HPSLSDUVH QL SHUGUH HO FRQWURO +L KD PROWV IDFWRUV GH O·HQWRUQ TXH QR SRGHP FRQWURODU HQ FDQYL HO QRVWUH LQWHULRU Vt TXHHOSRGHPREVHUYDU+RUHVXPLULDDPEDFFHSWDFLyGHODVLWXDFLy+LKD HO SURYHUEL ´IHQW L GHVIHQW DSUqQ O·DSUHQHQWµ L DPE HGXFDFLy QRVDOWUHV VHPSUHHVWHPDSUHQHQW 8QDDFWLYLWDWTXHHQXQJUXSKDHVWDWXQq[LWHQXQDOWUHQRIXQFLRQD 9DEpJXDUGDUDTXHOODFDUWDDIDYRUQRVWUH XQH[HUFLFLUtWPLFG·LPLWDFLy HVFROWDUDTXHOODDXGLFLyTXHVDEHPTXHHOVDJUDGDHWF IHU VLOHQFL UHVSLUDU FRQVFLHQFLDU TXH DPE VRUROO L FULWV QR WUHEDOOHP Ep HWF ϭϬ &ORHQGD +DJLDQDWFRPKDJLDQDWVLHQFDUDGLVSRVHPG·DOJXQDHVWRQDDQLPDDFDEDU DPE XQD DFWLYLWDW JOREDO (Q DTXHVW FDV DFDEDU FDQWDQW R UHSDVVDQW XQD GDQVDDL[zHQVGHL[DFRQWHQWV $EDQV GH TXH PDU[LQ SRGHP DFRPLDGDUQRV GRQDQWORV OHV JUjFLHV L GHVLWMDUORV XQD ERQD VHWPDQD eV XQD PDQHUD GH FRPXQLFDU HQHUJLD L SRVLWLYLVPH 7UHEDOODUDPEQHQVHWSURSRUFLRQDXQJUDQGLQDPLVPH0DOJUDWTXHSRGHP WHQLUODVHQVDFLyTXHDTXHOODFODVVHQRKDIXQFLRQDWHOOVQRKRYLXHQLJXDO TXHQRVDOWUHV(QODVHJHQWVHVVLySRGHPWRUQDUDFRPHQoDUFRPVLUHVQR KDJXpVSDVVDW$L[zHWGRQDjQLPVLDXWRHVWLPD 'HVSUpVGHODVHVVLy $QjOLVL $PEXQDPELHQWWUDQTXLOLVHUqDJDIHPHOQRVWUHHVTXHPDGHWUHEDOOLDQHP PDUFDQWDOOzTXHV·KDGXWDWHUPHLDOOzTXHQReVLPSRUWDQWIHUXQDDQjOLVL IUHGD$ODYHJDGDTXHSHQVHPHQDOOzTXHQRKDDQDWFRPYROtHP0ROWHV YHJDGHV WRW SHQVDQWKL VXUWHQ DOWUHV HVWUDWqJLHV TXH PROWHV YHJDGHV HQV DQLUDQ Ep 'XUDQW OD VHVVLy SRGHP VHQWLUQRV EORTXHMDWV QR WUREDU DOJXQ REMHFWHHWF3HUDTXHVWPRWLXODUHIOH[LySRVWHULRUpVLPSRUWDWtVVLPD ϭϭ $QRWDFLRQV (QFDUD TXH WLQJXHP HOV GRVVLHUV L HOV DSXQWV SHU FRQVXOWDU VHPSUH YD Ep HVFULXUH HO SURSL GLDUL $SXQWDU WRWV DTXHOOV H[HUFLFLV TXH KDQ IXQFLRQDW 0pVHQGDYDQWSRWVHUKRFRQVXOWDUHP 3URSRVWHVG·DFWLYLWDWV eV XQ ERQ PRPHQW MXVW GHVSUpV G·DFDEDU OD VHVVLy L TXDQ HVWHP IHQW O·DQjOLVL SHQVDU DPE OD SURSHUD VHVVLy 3HU H[HPSOH VL QR KH IHW DTXHOOD DXGLFLy HO GLD VHJHQW FRPHQoDU SHU DTXHOOD DFWLYLWDW R VL KH GLW ´OD SURSHUD VHVVLy SRUWHX FDSVHV EXLGHV«µ DSXQWDUKR L SUHSDUDUKR SHU OD SURSHUDVHVVLy8QDFODVVHHWGyQDSHXDXQDDOWUD &RQVHOOVSHGDJzJLFVGH0DXULFH0DUWHQRW 1R SXF GHL[DU GH IHU SDOqV HOV FRQVHOOV SHGDJzJLFV GH 0DXULFH 0DUWHQRW SHGDJRJ PXVLFDO FUHDGRU G·XQD PHWRGRORJLD GH IRUPDFLy PXVLFDO XQD GH OHVPpVUHOOHYDQWVGHOVHJOH;;-RKHHVWDWDOXPQDG·HOOLSHQVRTXHP·KD LQIOXHQFLDW PROWtVVLP HQ OD PHYD SUjFWLFD GLjULD 6REUHWRW D QR SHUGUH OD LOĊOXVLy 8V HOV DQLUp GLHQW WDO FRP HOV WUREDUHX HQ HO VHX OOLEUH 35,1&,3,6 )21$0(17$/6'()250$&,Ð086,&$/,/$6(9$$3/,&$&,Ð ϭϮ ´1RV·HQVHQ\DDOOzTXHVHVDSVLQyHOTXHXQpVµ $L[zHQVGyQDWUDQTXLOĊOLWDWMDTXHPROWHVYHJDGHVWHQLPDTXHOODSRUGHQR IHUKREpGHVLHQVDEUHPRQRHWF7HQLUJDQHVGHIHUKRSRVDULOĊOXVLyL HPSDWLD DPE HOV QRVWUHV SXSLOV pV PpV LPSRUWDQW TXH VDEHU HO WUDFWDW G·KDUPRQLD &XOWLYDUODFRQILDQoD 5HEUH D OHV SHUVRQHV DPE XQ VRPULXUH FRQILDW 6RPULXUH HQV SURYRFD HQHUJLD LQWHJUD L HTXLOLEUD $ HOOV HOV SURYRFD REHUWXUD G·RwGD H[WHQVLy D OHVFRUGHVYRFDOVLDILQDUDQPLOORU$OOXQ\DODSRULODLQVHJXUHWDW &DQWDUFRVWDLPpVDOVDGXOWV([WHULRULW]DUODYHXpVFRPPRVWUDUDOJXQD FRVDPROWtQWLPD 'DQVDUEHOOXJDUHOFRVWRWVVDEHPODYHUJRQ\DTXHPROWHVYHJDGHVDL[zHQV SURYRFD ,QWHUSHWDUWHDWUDOPHQWHQVQHJXLWHMDVLQRKLHVWHPDFRVWXPDWV 3HGDJRJLDSRVLWLYD 5HPDUFDUWRWDOOzTXHHVWjEp5HVVDOWDUDOOzTXHpVVDWLVIDFWRUL7RWV·DQLUj PLOORUDQW1RVDOWUHVWHQLPODPHQWDPESHQVDPHQWSRVLWLXSHUPDQHQW ϭϯ (VFROOLUEpHOJUDXGHGLILFXOWDW 6XSHUDU HO SULPHU H[HUFLFL G·XQD VqULH DMXGD D VHQWLUVH Ep L SRWHQFLD O·DXWRHVWLPD4XHHOOVVHVHQWLQTXHVyQFDSDoRVGHIHUP~VLFDGHGDQVDU GHIHUWHDWUH &RPHQoDUSHUXQQLYHOOIjFLOLDQDUDXJPHQWDQWODGLILFXOWDW 5HFRUGHPTXHHOYHUGDGHUSODHUQHL[LQWHULRUPHQWO·H[WHULRULW]DFLyGHO·DUW pV SRVWHULRU 3ULPHU HQV PHUDYHOOHP DPE O·REUD G·DUW GHVSUpV LQWHQWHP FRSLDUODLILQDOPHQWVRPFUHDGRUV 3URIXQGLWDWHQO·HVIRUo 6LO·DFWLYLWDWLQWHUHVVDO·HVIRUopVLQWHQVLQDWXUDO /·DFWLYLWDWKDGHVHUFXUWDVLQyO·HVIRUoHVYDGHJUDGDQWLHVSHUGODXQLWDW 1RPpV HVFROWDUj XQD SDUW G·HOO IHQzPHQ QDWXUDO G·DXWRGHIHQVD FRQWUD OD IDWLJD /·HVIRUoHQSURIXQGLWDWHVWUDQVIRUPDHQVXSHUILFLDOLDL[zSRWHVGHYHQLUXQ FRVWXP 5HVSRQVDELOLWDWGHOSURIHVVRU 1RVDOWUHVVRPHOVUHVSRQVDEOHVQRFXOSDEOHVGHOIXQFLRQDPHQWGHODVHVVLyL GHOHVOODFXQHVTXHSRGHQH[LVWLU6LHVEXVTXHQFDXVHVH[WHUQHVODQRVWUD SHGDJRJLDQRDYDQoDUjPDLDYXLSORXHVWDQQHJXLWRVRVHWF 6L GHVSUpV GH OD VHVVLy IHP O·DQjOLVL KXPLO GHO GHVHQYROXSDPHQW VHJXU TXH SRGUHPWUREDUUHPHLVLHLQHVSHUPLOORUDU ϭϰ 0ROWG·RUGUH 7HQLUPqWRGHLRUJDQLW]DFLyHQHOWUHEDOO 1RDMXQWDUWUHVGLILFXOWDWVDODYHJDGD ([HPSOHDO·KRUDG·DSUHQGUHXQDFDQoyOOHWUDPHORGLDLH[SUHVVLy 6L DSUHQHP XQD GDQVD ODWHUDOLWDW FRRUGLQDFLy VLQFURQLW]DFLy DPE OD P~VLFDH[SUHVVLy 6L KHP G·DFWXDU DSUHQGUH HO WH[W UHFLWDUOR DPE VHQWLW PRYLPHQWV HVFqQLFVFRRUGLQDFLyDPEHOVDOWUHVSHUVRQDWJHV 4XDOVHYROGLILFXOWDWQRYDKDGHSUHVHQWDUVHVRODLV·KDGHUHSURGXLUODSHU LPLWDFLy (QODYLGDHQVSDVVDLJXDOPDVVDGLILFXWDWVHQVHVWUHVVDHQFDQYLXQDFRVD GDUUHUD O·DOWUH HQV ID DYDQoDU PpV L HO TXq pV LPSRUWDQW VHQWLUQRV FzPRGHV 'HVJUDQDUO·DSUHQHQWDWJHSDVSHUSDV'HPROWVHQ]LOODPpVFRPSOLFDW ([HUFLFLVMRF 'HL[DUOHVDFWLYLWDWVPpVO~GLTXHVTXHQRQHFHVVLWHQWDQWDFRQFHQWUDFLySHO ILQDO ϭϱ 3URSRVWDGLGjFWLFD 'HOOOLEUH´(OSREOHGHYHQWLGHIXVWDµYROLDSUHVHQWDUYRVOD´6LPIRQLDGHO UHOORWJHµ GH -+D\GQ +H SUHSDUDW XQD FRUHRJUDILD VREUH DTXHVWD YHUVLy (VWj SHQVDGD SHU QHQV GH 3 L &, SHUz YRVDOWUHV SRGHX DJDIDU OD LGHD L DGDSWDUODDOVYRVWUHVXVXDULV 3RWSUHVHQWDUVHHQIRUPDGHFRQWH&RQYHUWLUVHHQUHOORWJH (VSHURTXHDTXHVWDUHIOH[LyXVKDJLSURSRUFLRQDWHLQHVSHUWUHEDOODUPLOORUL DPEPpVFRQVFLqQFLD 0ROWHVJUjFLHVSHUODYRVWUDDWHQFLyLFROĊODERUDFLy ϭϲ