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• 8+!4%$1%!34!%#&61!#!?&K1+!#>4,+3!4C!D,<;&2!&+24>1'!#;;!124+4>&2!C#234%6!674,;$! <1!3#P1$!&+K1%61;-!34!371&%!1;#692&3-!4C!6,DD;-!@5#>61-!5,;1A! • =#%<4+!3#P![4,;$!<1!>#+$#31$!1K1+!&C!2;&>#31!27#+?1![1%1!+43!#+!&66,1! =K(/#.-#.0)+()0T(.0)+(MNOORQIRRUS( =K($)0&40.4(L1E(.0)+(MNOPIQIRNRS( ( 0! E.04%3#&0"(V:#26"+(:%5%4+&4W(( • 8>D461!=\(!3#P!#+$!%1$,21!;#<4%!#+$!2#D&3#;!3#P16! • F4>1!&+$&2#31!+13!<1+1S3!4C!37&6!D4;&2-!@1U?U!:4,;$1%!/]]^'!B#%%-!/]]^A!! • =4,;$!#;64!<1!,61$!34!D#-!<#2J!D,<;&2!$1<3!@5#,6271%!(./)A!#+$!<%4#$1+!371! 3#P!<#61!&+!24,+3%&16![&37!;#%?1!&+C4%>#;!61234%!@"#%J#+$-#!(./)A!!! • B%4<;1>6G! /A _D6743!4C!62&1+9S2!$1<#31!&+24+2;,6&K1! (A \>&36!27#;;1+?1!C4%!?4K1%+>1+36!34!$1#;![&37!3#P!24>D1994+!#+$!>#&+3#&+! &+31%+#94+#;!24>D199K1+166! )A B%4$,29K&3-R1+7#+2&+?!&+C%#63%,23,%1!&+K163>1+36!4,3!4C!624D1! • :&K1+!+11$6!C4%!&+C%#63%,23,%1!&+K163>1+36'!D%4<#<;-!+43!4D9>#;!34!C,;;-! %12-2;1!2#%<4+!%1K1+,16!<-!;4[1%&+?!4371%!3#P16! ^! X&8.0$).2/)2.+(%&5+$),+&)( A0B#6(0&4(=4+&*#8+.>($26,%<+4( • N27&1K1!,+&K1%6#;!1+1%?-!#22166!<-!(.).G!_F`!)aR0/!<;+!D1%!-1#%!@5&#7&!13!#;U!(./(A! • b:%1#3!24+K1%?1+21c!4C!?;4<#;!71#;37!63#+$#%$6!<-!(.)^G!#<4,3!_F`!0.!<;+!D1%!-1#%! @*#>164+!13!#;U!(./)A! a! E0,%&'()0T(/#,-+33#&( • F,<693,94+!1;#692&3-!$131%>&+16!d%1;#9K1! SP1$+166b!4C!C466&;!%164,%216! • L#234%!3#P16!$&634%3!371!*.,$/,$#-"/+)! #;;42#94+! • =#D&3#;!>4<&;&3-!$&634%36!371!*.,$//$0*".+)! #;;42#94+!!37%4,?7!3#P!24>D1994+! • =#D&3#;!3#P!>4%1!D%4+1!34!3#P!24>D1994+! 37#+!2#%<4+!3#P!,+$1%!D;#,6&<;1!D#%#>131%6! • 8+C%#63%,23,%1!S+#+21$!<-!2#%<4+!3#P16! #e%#236!&+f4[!4C!D%&K#31!2#D&3#;!#+$!3#>16! &+31%31>D4%#;!#+$!&+31%%1?&4+#;!$&634%94+6!!!! ?.0&B$>(=4+&*#8+.(0&4(Y+$$,0&&(M%&(-.+-0.03#&S( g! @0'&%)24+(#8(/0.6#&(.+&)( • L466&;!%164,%21!%1+36!$12%1#61![&37! 2;&>#31!D4;&2-!#><&94+! • L4%!#!?;4<#;;-!4D9>#;!2#%<4+!D%&21'! 4K1%R24>D1+6#94+!<-!2#%<4+!%1+3! @hD1%>&3!D%&21!4%!3#P!i!1>&66&4+6A! • =#%<4+!%1+3!#DD%4D%&#31$!$4>1692#;;-! K&#!#,294+1$!D1%>&36!4%!3#P! I#,1%!13!#;U!@(./)A! • H4,;$!#;64!D%4K&$1!%164,%216!34!#$$%166! 2;&>#31!&66,16!+43!3#2J;1$!<-!#!2#%<4+! D%&21'!1U?U!3127+4;4?-!D4;&2-!#+$! #$#D3#94+! j! !"#$%&'()*+(+,%$$%#&(-.%/+('0-( GH)!;I! F"#60"(#-3,0"(( /0.6#&(-.%/+! 51>#&+&+?!?#D!W!&+3;U!+1?49#94+6( =4R<1+1S36!@#&%!T,#;&3-'!1+1%?-!#22166'!132UA( B&?4,K&#+!3#P!&+31%+#;&Q&+?!!"#$%&'(')*#+,$(*#-+',%( "#2%4R124+4>&2!1V2&1+2-( O#P!>#+$#31$!<-!3714%-!4C!4D9>#;!3#P#94+! N$$%1661$!<-G! X4>1692!>&+&63%&16!4C!S+#+21!Y!124+4>-!Y!$1K1;4D>1+3! X4>1692!>&+&63%&16!4C!371!1+K&%4+>1+3! ]! 8+31%+#94+#;!=;&>#31!Z1?49#94+6! =&*0&/%&'(,0/.#Q+/#&#,%/(+_/%+&/D(`()*+(-#.a#"%#(+b+/)( • N?1+36!4K1%R&+K163!&+!SP1$!@%1+3R<1#%&+?A!C#234%6!@6,27!#6!C466&;!C,1;6'!;#+$!A! #+$!,+$1%&+K163!&+!D%4$,29K1!2#D&3#;!C4%>#94+!@M$1+74C1%!13!#;U!(./)A! • O7&6!$&634%94+!2%1#316!124+4>&2!&+1V2&1+2&16!#+$!6;4[6!$4[+!124+4>&2! ?%4[37!@"#e#,27!13!#;U!(./)A! • k1+21'!3#P#94+!4C!2#%<4+!1>&66&4+!#+$Y4%!;#+$!2#+!%1$,21!37&6!&+1V2&1+2-! @F&1?>1&1%!13!#;U!&+!D%1D#%#94+A!34!#27&1K1!4D9>#;!<#;#+21!4C!D4%l4;&4! • ;-3,0"%)DZ(72.+(.0)+(#8(3,+(-.+8+.+&/+(+[20"()#(.+)2.&$(#8(( .%$BQ8.++(0$$+)>($#/%0">(-.%50)+>(&0)2.0">(0&4(*2,0&(/0-%)0"( • # = r = FK ( KS , KP, KH , KN ) ! "KS = FK ( KS , KP, KH , KN ) ! "KP = S P \#/%0"(.0)+(#8(.+)2.&(+[20"(8#.(0""(8#.,$(#8(/0-%)0"(M%9+9(W&#(0.6%).0'+( /#&4%3#&]S>(#)*+.^%$+()*+.+(%$(#5+.Q(#.(2&4+.Q%&5+$),+&)9( l p + =h p p /.! =&*0&/%&'(,0/.#Q+/#&#,%/(+_/%+&/D(`()*+($-%""#5+.(0.'2,+&)( • !N+!4D9>&692!D1%6D129K1!%1?#%$6!?%11+!3127+4;4?&16!#6!#!D431+9#;!<#6&6!C4%!#! m:%11+!8+$,63%&#;!51K4;,94+n!@F31%+!(..]A! • !5121+3!1K&$1+21!6,??163!7&?71%!3127+4;4?-!6D&;;R4K1%6!4C!?%11+!3127+4;4?&16! @X1271Q;1D%o3%1!13!#;U!(./)A! @X1271Q;1D%o3%1!13!#;U!(./)A :#D!<13[11+!2;1#+!#+$!$&%3-!6D&;;R4K1%6!4K1%!9>1! //! \#/%0"(.+)2.&$(#8(%&8.0$).2/)2.+(%&5+$),+&)$( X&8.0$).2/)2.+(\)#/B$(5+.$2$(=/#&#,%/(F.#^)*( X&8.0$).2/)2.+(\)#/B$(5+.$2$(X&/#,+(X&+[20"%)D( !0"4+.c&(d(\+.5e&(IRRf( • MK1+!374,?7!&+C%#63%,23,%1!&6!,+$1%D%4K&$1$!<-!371!>#%J13'!37&6!,+$1%R D%4K&6&4+!$416!+43!+12166#%&;-!+11$!34!<1!#$$%1661$!<-!D,<;&2!4[+1%67&D! • N;31%+#9K1!#%%#+?1>1+36!&+2;,$1!1U?U!6,<6&$&16'!K4,271%6'!#,294+&+?!4C! 24+3%#236p! • M>D&%&2#;!1K&$1+21!4C!1V2&1+2-!4C!D,<;&2!K6U!D%&K#31!&+C%#63%,23,%1!>&P1$! /(! !"#$%&'()*+(+,%$$%#&(-.%/+('0-( GH)!;I! F"#60"(#-3,0"(( /0.6#&(-.%/+! 51>#&+&+?!?#D!W!&+3;U!+1?49#94+6( =4R<1+1S36!@#&%!T,#;&3-'!1+1%?-!#22166'!132UA( B&?4,K&#+!3#P!&+31%+#;&Q&+?!!"#$%&'(')*#+,$(*#-+',%( "#2%4R124+4>&2!1V2&1+2-( O#P!>#+$#31$!<-!3714%-!4C!4D9>#;!3#P#94+! N$$%1661$!<-G! X4>1692!>&+&63%&16!4C!S+#+21!Y!124+4>-!Y!$1K1;4D>1+3! X4>1692!>&+&63%&16!4C!371!1+K&%4+>1+3! /)! 8+31%+#94+#;!=;&>#31!Z1?49#94+6! • MK1+!&C!24,+3%&16!<17#K1!&+!#! D,%1;-!61;S67!>#++1%'!371-! [4,;$!4D9>#;;-!&>D461!#!D%&21! 4+!2#%<4+!34!&+31%+#;&Q1!371! $#>#?1!371&%!1>&66&4+6!&+f&23! 4+!371>61;K16! • O71!7&?71%!371!$#>#?16'!&U!1U! 371!%&271%!4%!371!>4%1!D4D,;4,6! #!24,+3%-'!371!7&?71%!371! %16,;9+?!2#%<4+!D%&21! Prof. Ottmar Edenhofer, PIK, MCC, TU Berlin, and IPCC q!4C!?;4<#;;-!4D9>#;!2#%<4+!D%&21! X&)+.&0"%g%&'(4#,+$3/(%,-0/)$( @r166>#++'!,+D,<;&671$A! /0! !"#$%&'()*+(+,%$$%#&(-.%/+('0-( GH)!;I! F"#60"(#-3,0"(( /0.6#&(-.%/+! 51>#&+&+?!?#D!W!&+3;U!+1?49#94+6( =4R<1+1S36!@#&%!T,#;&3-'!1+1%?-!#22166'!132UA( B&?4,K&#+!3#P!&+31%+#;&Q&+?!!"#$%&'(')*#+,$(*#-+',%( "#2%4R124+4>&2!1V2&1+2-( O#P!>#+$#31$!<-!3714%-!4C!4D9>#;!3#P#94+! N$$%1661$!<-G! X4>1692!>&+&63%&16!4C!S+#+21!Y!124+4>-!Y!$1K1;4D>1+3! X4>1692!>&+&63%&16!4C!371!1+K&%4+>1+3! /^! 8+31%+#94+#;!=;&>#31!Z1?49#94+6! !#Q6+&+h)$( • !!I16&$16!%1$,2&+?!:k:!1>&66&4+6'!61K1%#;!#$$&94+#;!<1+1S36G! • N><&1+3!#&%!T,#;&3-!@Z1>13!(./.A! • B,<;&2!3%#+6D4%3'!%1$,21!24+?1694+!#+$!,%<#+!6D%#[;!@=%1,3Q&?!#+$!k1! (..jA! • O127+4;4?-!6D&;;R4K1%6!@*#s1!#+$!F3#K&+6!(..^A!! ! • =#61!63,$-!1K&$1+21!6,??1636!37#3!C4%!>#+-!24,+3%&16!37161!>49K#94+6![1%1! >4%1!&>D4%3#+3!37#+!1+K&%4+>1+3#;!24+21%+6!C4%!371!#$4D94+!4C!2;&>#31! D4;&2-'!1U?U! • 8+$&#G!M+1%?-!612,%&3-!@X,<#67!(./)A! • t&13+#>G!M+1%?-!1V2&1+2-'!124+4>&2!%163%,23,%&+?!@u&>>1%'!*#J4<'! F312J1;'!6,<>&e1$A! /a! @2"3Q4%5%4+&4(-+.$-+/35+(`(\D&+.'%$3/(-#"%/%+$( McCollum, et al. (2013) • ",;9D;1!4<v129K16'!1U?U!2;&>#31!27#+?1!@==A'!S62#;!<1+1S36'!1+1%?-!612,%&3-!@MFA'! D4;;,94+Y71#;37!@BkA! • F-+1%?&692!%1;#94+67&D6! • 51$,21$!#$$1$!24636!4C!6,DD;1>1+3#%-!D4;&2&16!C4%!4371%!4<v129K16! • =;&>#31!>&9?#94+!&6!63%#31?&2!1+3%-!D4&+3!34!#27&1K1!#+!#%%#-!4C!?4#;6! /g! !"#$%&'()*+(+,%$$%#&(-.%/+('0-( GH)!;I! F"#60"(#-3,0"(( /0.6#&(-.%/+! 51>#&+&+?!?#D!W!&+3;U!+1?49#94+6( =4R<1+1S36!@#&%!T,#;&3-'!1+1%?-!#22166'!132UA( B&?4,K&#+!3#P!&+31%+#;&Q&+?!!"#$%&'(')*#+,$(*#-+',%( "#2%4R124+4>&2!1V2&1+2-( O#P!>#+$#31$!<-!3714%-!4C!4D9>#;!3#P#94+! N$$%1661$!<-G! X4>1692!>&+&63%&16!4C!S+#+21!Y!124+4>-!Y!$1K1;4D>1+3! X4>1692!>&+&63%&16!4C!371!1+K&%4+>1+3! /j! 8+31%+#94+#;!=;&>#31!Z1?49#94+6! X&)+.&03#&0"(&+'#303#&$( w \x1+!#%?,1$!37#3!,+&;#31%#;!#294+!&6!24,+31%1$!<-!C%11R%&$&+?!@I#%%1e!/]]0'! =#%%#%4!#+$!F&+&62#;24!/]])A! w 5121+3!%161#%27!7#6!674[+!37#3!S%63!>4K1%!1>&66&4+!%1$,294+6!2#+!<1! 63%#31?&2!24>D;1>1+36!&+631#$!4C!6,<693,316!@M$1+74C1%!13!#;U!(./)A! ! • O127+4;4?-!6D&;;R4K1%6!#+$!;1#%+&+?!<-!$4&+?!@k1#;!#+$!O#%,&!(..jA! ! • @8>D1%C123A!#;3%,&6>!#+$!%12&D%42&3-!@r#+?1!#+$!t4?3!(..)A! ! • F&?+#;&+?!4C![&;;&+?+166!34!D#-!@*#J4<!#+$!r166>#+!(./(A! w =4+$&94+#;&3-!%,;16!24,;$!#23!#6!#+!&+21+9K1!34!&+2%1#61!#><&94+! /]! X&)+.&03#&0"(&+'#303#&( w I-!&31%#9K1!D%4216616'!,+&;#31%#;!#294+6! >&?73!%16,;3!&+!>4%1!?;4<#;!244D1%#94+! @M$1+74C1%'!L;#276;#+$'!F3#K&+6'!F34[1! (./)A! w _+&;#31%#;!#294+6!24,;$!C4%>!371!<#6&6! 4C!#!7-<%&$!#?%11>1+3!@M$1+74C1%!13!#;U! (./)A! w 8+31%+#94+#;!#?%11>1+3!#6!&+693,94+!34! 244%$&+#31!+#94+#;!D4;&2&16'!67#%1! &+C4%>#94+'!#+$!#23!#6!#!C42#;!D4&+3!C4%! 1PD123#94+6! w =4+$&94+#;&3-!24,;$!#23!#6!#+!&+21+9K1! 34!&+2%1#61!#><&94+! M$1+74C1%'!L;#276;#+$'! F3#K&+6'!F34[1!(./)! (.! iQ!2)(XZ(?%.$)(,#5+.(/*0""+&'+$( • !0.6#&(Y+0B0'+G!5121+3!%161#%27!S+$6! • Iy7%&+?1%!13!#;U!@(./(AG!^R/]q!@>1$&#+!/(qA! • N;64!+1?#9K1!;1#J#?1!D466&<;1! • B46&9K1!3127+4;4?-!6D&;;R4K1%6!@I4661z!13!#;U!(..]A! • =%4[$&+?!4,3!4C!$&%3-!2#D&3#;!@=#%<4+1!13!#;U!(./)A! • 8+31%RC,1;!6,<693,94+!&+!37&%$!24,+3%&16!@I#,1%!13!#;U!(./)A! • O#&;4%1$!D4;&2&16!2#+!%1$,21!;1#J#?1! • O%#$1!>1#6,%16!@*#J4<'!F312J1;'!M$1+74C1%'!C4%3724>&+?A! • L%11!#;;42#94+!4C!64>1!1>&66&4+!D1%>&36!@k1D<,%+!(./)A! • !#$)$Z!! • "4$1;&+?!&+$&2#316!>4$1%#31!24636!C%4>!#!D1%&4$!4C!>4$1%#31! ,+&;#31%#;!2#%<4+!D%&2&+?! • X1;#-&+?!?;4<#;!#?%11>1+3!<-!/^!-1#%6![4,;$!%#&61!24636!4C!#27&1K&+?! (/! 0^.DD>!=\(R4+;-!<-!#3!;1#63!7#;C!@*#J4<!13!#;U!(./(A! iQ!2)(XXZ(E*+(.#"+(#8()+/*&#"#'D( Kriegler et al. (2013) RoSE project • X1K1;4D>1+3!4C!+1[!3127+4;4?&16!#+$!;1#%+&+?!1s1236!2%,2&#;!C4%!3127+4;4?-! D4%l4;&4!#+$!>&9?#94+!24636! • N!D%&21!4+!2#%<4+!&6!+12166#%-'!<,3!+43!6,V2&1+3!W!4D9>#;;-!24>D;1>1+31$!<-! 3127+4;4?-!D4;&2&16! ((! iQ!2)(XXXZ(\#,+(-#"%3/0"(+/#&#,D(/#&$%4+.03#&$( • =&+.'DQ%&)+&$%5+(%&42$).%+$(R!64>1!24>D1+6#94+!C4%!;461%6{! • !0.6#&(-.%/+(%,-0/)$(#&(+[2%)DG! • =#%<4+!D%&21!+43!+12166#%&;-!%1?%166&K1!@5#,627!(.//A! • =#+!<1!>#$1!D%4?%166&K1!<-!;4[1%&+?!3#P16!&+!#![#-!37#3!<1+1S36!;4[! 1#%+1%6!@"132#;C!13!#;U!(./.A!4%!D%4K&$1!&+C%#63%,23,%1!37#3!<1+1S36!371>! >4%1!37#+!4371%6! • M+6,%1!<,-R&+!4C!J1-!63#J174;$1%6!<-!4[+1%67&D'!1U?U!&+6D&%1$!<-!D%4D1%3-! 4[+&+?!$1>42%#2-!@"1#$1!/]0aA!! • I1+1S36!4C!2#%<4+!D%&2&+?!674,;$!<1!1P#>&+1$!&+!#!,2"3Q#6j+/35+(8.0,+^#.B( %4431$!&+![1;C#%1!3714%-!@*#J4<!#+$!M$1+74C1%'!6,<>&e1$A! ()! \).+&')*(#8()*+(&0..035+( Co-benefits Pigouvian tax Macro-economic efficiency Optimal taxation b|O}71!2#%<4+!3#P!&6!+43!#!C%11!;,+27U! k4[1K1%'!p'!&3!69;;!>&?73!<1!#!>1#;![4%37! D#-&+?!C4%~c!@:4,;$1%!(./)A! Co-benefits Pigouvian tax Macro-economic efficiency Optimal taxation b`/..Wa..!<&;;&4+!#++,#;;-!<-!(.).!&+! %1$,21$!D4;;,94+!24+3%4;!#+$!1+1%?-!612,%&3-! 1PD1+$&3,%16Uc!@"2=4;;,>!13U!#;!(./(A! w X&s1%1+3!D14D;1!>#-!7#K1!K1%-!$&s1%1+3!#66,>D94+6!4C!D7-6&2#;!#+$!124+4>&2! >127#+&6>6!#6![1;;!#6!$&s1%1+3!D%1C1%1+216! w 13'!371-!69;;!>#-!#?%11!4+!#!>4%1!4%!;166!6&>&;#%!2#%<4+!D%&21! w M;#<4%#94+!4C!<1+1S36!&+!>,;9D;1!$&>1+6&4+6!#;;4[!&$1+9C-&+?!%#+?1!4C! #221D3#<;1!D%&216!#+$!$416!+43!+11$!34!%1;-!4+!#!6&+?;1!mJ&;;1%!#%?,>1+3n! (0! E*+(%,-#.)0&/+(#8(.#62$)($/%+&3h/(-#"%/D(045%/+( Scientists as “cartographers” of viable policy alternatives En d A End B End C Start Adaptiert von http://www.trail.ch/gallery/albums/trail/graubunden/fuorcla-surlej/corvatsch-fuorcla-surlej-val-roseg-09_09_2006-img_2598.jpg (^! !#&/"2$%#&$( • 1,6%3#&(#8(%&)+.&03#&0"(/"%,0)+(-#"%/D(.##)+4(%&(4#,+$3/(0,6%3#&$( • :#,+$3/(/"%,0)+(-#"%/D(+,6+44+4(%&(6.#04+.(-26"%/(-#"%/D(/#&/+.&$( • :#,+$3/(,2"3Q4%5%4+&4(-+.$-+/35+Z( • \D9>#;!3#P#94+'!$4,<;1!$&K&$1+$'!3#>&+?!2#D&3#;!3#P!24>D1994+! • 8>D%4K&+?!>#2%4R124+4>&2!1V2&1+2-'!&+K163>1+3!4C!%1K1+,1!&+!#%1#6![&37!7&?7163! 642&#;!%13,%+!! • 51$,294+!4C!=\(!1>&66&4+6!>&9?#316!2;&>#31!27#+?1! • B46&9K1!6-+1%?&16![&37!4371%!&66,16!6,27!#6!#&%!D4;;,94+!#+$!3127+4;4?-!6D&;;R4K1%6! • E*+$+(/#&$%4+.03#&$(,%'*)(&#)(0/*%+5+('"#60""D(#-3,0"(/0.6#&(-.%/+>( 62)(*+"-()#(/"#$+()*+('0-(0&4(0450&/+(%&)+.&03#&0"(&+'#303#&$( • J#62$)($/%+&3h/(-#"%/D(045%/+()*0)(#2)"%&+$()*+(#-3#&($-0/+(0&4( %4+&3h+$(^%&&+.$(0&4("#$+.$(%$(/.2/%0"( (a!