)LZQIVI[MZyIUMRWZY]MÅRMUW[]VIPWZIXIZIUI }IVIa\MIKWUXI}M4MWVWZW.TI^QIaIPWZI\M^I[I\WUIZ M[MKINuKWV*MZ\I /WVbITW§9]MXI[I'\MKWVWbKWLM[LMVQ}IMZM[MTUM RWZIUQOWLM;MZOQW 6ILI )LZQIVI XWVQuVLW[M MV XQM a [MV\nVLW[M I [] TILW ;QVW[]KMLMVILIMV\WVKM[XWZY]u\QMVM[]VOM[\W\IV OZI^Ma\]^WbM[\nIXIOI[QVKWV\IZKWVY]MVW\MI\ZM^M[I UQZIZUMITW[WRW[ 7PPPPP [M UM WT^QLIJI TW WJ[MZ^ILWZI Y]M MZM[ XWZ ITOWM[\]LQI[X[QKWTWOyI[]XWVOWY]MVW\MX]MLWMVOI}IZ /WVbITW¨PIJTIaIPM^MVQLWXWZTW[ZM[]T\ILW[LMUQ[ IVnTQ[Q[ a VW UM XQMV[W UIZKPIZ [QV MTTW[ )LZQIVI ÅR~ [][ MVWZUM[WRW[VMOZW[MV/WVbITWIT\QMUXWY]M[]LMTOILW K]MZXW[MIKWUWLIJIMVTI[QTTIa]VUMKP~VLMXMTWTIKIyI XWZTIKIZI)LZQIVIWJ[MZ^~K~UW/WVbITW[MXWVyIMVXQM a[MLQZQOyIPIKQITI^MV\IVIV]VKITMPIJyI^Q[\W\IVI[][\I LW[] a[]K]MZXWZWJ][\WLIJIVTIQUXZM[Q~VLMY]M PIJyI LM[IXIZMKQLW \ZI[ TI XZMWK]XIKQ~V a MT UQMLW Y]M TM LIJIMVNZMV\IZ[MIIY]MTTIKWV^MZ[IKQ~V-T[QTMVKQWIXMVI[ L]Z~]VW[[MO]VLW[Y]MXIZI)LZQIVIN]MZWVM\MZVW[+WV XI[WTMV\W/WVbITW[MIKMZK~ITI[QTTIY]MM[\IJIITTILWLM )LZQIVIa[M[MV\~LMV]M^WI[]TILW 5QZI)LZQIVI^IUW[I\WUIZVW[]VKINuTW[\ZM[aUI }IVIK]IVLW^MVOI[KWV.TI^QIW4MWVWZPIJTIUW[LM\][ IVnTQ[Q[ 6W M[\Wa PIZ\I LM \IV\W UQ[\MZQW PIJTI a LQUM TW Y]M [MI5MM[\WaMUXMbIVLWIMVNILIZ )LZQIVI°°°XWZNI^WZ°KTI^IVLW[][WRW[OZQ[M[MVMT ZW[\ZWLM)LZQIVIa\WUnVLWTILMTIUIVW /WVbITWVQY]MUMM[\]^QMZIU]ZQMVLWM[JWbIVLW]VI TM^M[WVZQ[I-TZW[\ZWLM/WVbITW[M^WT^Q~LMXQMLZIa[WT\~ TIUIVWLM)LZQIVI 5M M[\Wa U]ZQMVLW §-V [MZQW' ¨)VLI aI JQKPW UITW V]VKIU]MZM§>MZLIL' -V\][IVnTQ[Q[PMUW[LM\MK\ILW]VV]UMZWM`IOMZILI UMV\MMTM^ILWLMTM]KWKQ\W[XWZM[WTW[MV^yMIUQKWTMOILMT PW[XQ\ITXIZIZMXM\QZTW[a^WT^MZIIVITQbIZTW[ *QMVaM[W§Y]u[QOVQÅKI' )LZQIVI°LMJMZyI[LMM[\IZIKWUXI}ILIXWZ\]IJ]MTI W\]PMZUIVI 8MZWVWTWM[\WaaVWTW^WaIM[\IZI[yY]MPIJTILM]VI UITLQ\I^Mb -[W [QOVQÅKI Y]M \QMVM[ TM]KMUQI LQRW KWV ]V PQTW LM ^WbXMZWKWUMVbIVLWMT\ZI\IUQMV\WK]IVLWIV\M[M`Q[\MV U]KPI[XW[QJQTQLILM[MZM[RW^MVaN]MZ\M 4M]KMUQIXWZM[WUM[QMV\W\IVLuJQTaKIV[ILI ;QM[]V[yV\WUI AUIZMILIaPMXMZLQLWXM[W ;Q XMZW K]IVLW MUXMKMUW[ MT \ZI\IUQMV\W \M [MV\QZn[ UMRWZ 5MRWZ°°°KWV^WbIXIOILI ;Q§-[\I[JQMVY]QMZM[\WUIZITOW';QY]QMZM[^IUW[I LIZ]VXI[MWa\WUIUW[]VKINuN]MZI 6WKWV^WbKWV\]VLMV\MaÅZUM >ITM TTIUIZM I 5IZ\yVMb XIZI Y]M OM[\QWVM \] QVOZM[W M[\I[MUIVI /WVbITWPMLQKPWVW )LZQIVIVW\MMV\QMVLW§)Y]M\MZMÅMZM[KWVVW' 6WUM^WaIXWVMZY]QUQW\MZIXQI §9]M'6WLMM[WVILI\QMVM\ZI\IUQMV\WaTWXWVLZMUW[ 6WXMZLWVI[uY]MUMY]QMZM[U]KPWaY]MMZM[KWUW LMTINIUQTQIZMK\QÅKWMZM[LMTINIUQTQIUMKWVWKM[LM[LM U]aXMY]M}IXMZWIY]yLMKQLWaW-[UQ^QLIaM[UQK]MZ XWaTWY]MUMY]MLMY]QMZW^Q^QZTWKWUWLQKM;QVI\ZIIUQ UIVMZI )LZQIVI)LZQIVIKWUWUuLQKWaKWUWIUQOWVW\MTW IKWV[MRW ;QVWUMXWVOW\ZI\IUQMV\W§K]nV\W\QMUXW\MVOW' =VW[[MQ[UM[M[KWUWU]KPW -VMTZW[\ZWLM)LZQIVI[MLQJ]RW]VIIUIZOI[WVZQ[I4I LMKQ[Q~VM[\n\WUILIVWXQMV[W[WUM\MZUMIY]QUQWY]QMZW ^Q^QZTWY]MUMY]MLM\ZIVY]QTIaMVXIbMVKI[IZWLMILI LMUQ[KW[I[aUQ[[MZM[Y]MZQLW[aVWMV]VPW[XQ\ITZWLMI LILMM`\ZI}W[/WVbITWUM^WaIUWZQZaaWa[WTWaW[Wa TIY]MLMKQLW5]KPI[OZIKQI[XWZ\]LMTQKILMbI,IUM]V JM[WY]MUM^WaaI\MPMZWJILWJI[\IV\M\QMUXW =VI[]I^MJZQ[ITIIJZIb~KWVL]Tb]ZIIT[ITQZITIKITTM TI \IZLM M[\IJI TTMOIVLW I [] ÅV ]V KQMTW \M}QLW LM Ib]T a VIZIVRILM[XMLyIITLyIXIZILIZXI[WITIVWKPM#)LZQIVI [][XQZ~KWVN]MZbITTMV~[][X]TUWVM[LMTIQZM^QKQILWLMTI KQ]LILUQZ~I[]ITZMLMLWZaXMV[~Y]MTI\IZLMMZILMUI [QILWJWVQ\IXIZIMV\MZIZ[M]VILMY]M^IIUWZQZ\WLWMZI Z]QLWMTQZa^MVQZLMTW[\ZIV[MV\M[\WLWTWY]MTIZWLMIJI MZI^QLI+WUMVb~IKIUQVIZ[QVZ]UJWaVW\~MV[]QV\MZQWZ ]VIM[XMKQMLMIVO][\QI;WTWXWLyI^MZ]VW[MVWZUM[WRW[ ^MZLM[]VI[WVZQ[I\ZQ[\MaÅVOQLI\WLWMTTWMV]VZW[\ZWJM TTWJZWVKMILWXWZMT[WT/IJZQMTUQY]MZQLW/IJZQMTK~UW \MMKPWLMUMVW[TI^Q[\I[MTMV]JT~aVW\WY]M]VI[IZLQMV \M[TIOZQUI[ZM[JITIJIVXWZ[]UMRQTTI[ =VIV]JMLMP]UWJTIVY]MKQVW[ITQ~LMTIJWKILM4MW VWZITIXIZY]MMT[]I^MJITIVKMWLMTIUMKMLWZITIIKWU XI}IJI LMR~ MT X]ZW [WJZM MT KMVQKMZW Y]M \MVyI IT TILW a KWVUIVWLQ[\ZIyLIIKIZQKQ~I5I]ZQKMY]MLWZUQ\IJIMV[] ZMOIbWMTOI\WZWVZWVM~aUQZ~I[]L]M}ILMZMWRW]VZ]QLW Y]M^MVyILMTNWVLWLMTXI[QTTWTM[WJZM[IT\~a[ITQ~KWZZQMVLW MVLQZMKKQ~VITIPIJQ\IKQ~VLM)LZQIVI 0WTIIIIIIIIIIII5I]ZQKM\MPMLM[XMZ\ILW]VIJWTQ\I LMXMTWOZQ[aJTIVKI[IT\WITIKIUIaKWUMVb~IWTQ[Y]MIZ TI UITM\I KWV K]ZQW[QLIL >MV IY]y KIZQ}WWWWWWWW Y]M \M ^WaIKWUMZIJM[W[)LZQIVI[M[MV\~aX][WI5I]ZQKMMV []ZMOIbWIKIZQKQnVLWTWKWVL]Tb]ZIXZMXnZI\MY]MMVJZM^M VW[UIZKPIUW[ 5I]ZQKM[MbINWLMTW[JZIbW[LM)LZQIVI[MLQZQOQ~ITI X]MZ\IIJQMZ\Ia[ITQ~LMV]M^WITXI[QTTW[MO]QLWXWZ)LZQI VI )J]MTITIUITM\IaIM[\IXZMXIZILI4MWVWZ[MTM^IV\~ KWVTMV\Q\]LLMTIUMKMLWZILMRIVLWLMV]M^WMTX]ZWMVMT KMVQKMZWa[MIKMZK~I[]VQM\IKWVOM[\WXZMWK]XILW4IT]b LMTUMLQWLyIMV\ZIJIKWVN]MZbIXWZMTIUXTQW^MV\IVITLMT [IT~V §4WTTM^I[\WLW' ;yIJ]MTIILMUn[UMUIZKPWI+]LQTTMZWMQZuQ[I^Q[Q \IZUM +TIZWKIZQ}WVW^IUW[IXMZUQ\QZY]MXI[M[M[\W[WTI I]VY]M\MMUXM}M[MVM`KT]QZVW[ ¨7PPPPPPP)J]MTIAITWPMUW[LQ[K]\QLWPI[\ITI[I KQMLILUQZILM.TI^QIa;MZOQW[IJQIY]MQJIIZMIKKQWVIZ \ITaKWUWTWPIVPMKPW#5QXWJZMPMZUIVIaUQK]}ILW [WV]VW[QV\ZIV[QOMV\M[aKWVTIUMV\MKMZZILIIXM[IZLM[] MLILXMZW\VWIJ]MTI;QMUXZMPMUW[KWVMK\ILW[WUW[ QO]ITM[°°LQRWKWV]VPQTWLM^Wb 9]MZQLIVQ}I[Wa\]IJ]MTIM[VWZUITY]MUMXZMWK]XM WY]uXZM\MVLM[Y]MUMY]MLM\IVIVKPIMV\MZnVLWUMLM Y]M\QMVM[TM]KMUQIaLMY]MVWXQMV[I[T]KPIZ <M TW PM LQKPW UQT ^MKM[ I]VY]M /WVbITW LQOI Y]M [y \MVOW XW[QJQTQLILM[ VW M[ KQMZ\W VW[ M`XTQKIZWV MV MT PW[ XQ\ITMT\QXWLMTM]KMUQIY]MXILMbKWaM[KWUWTIT]KPILM ,WV9]QRW\MKWV\ZITW[UWTQVW[LM^QMV\WaVWY]QMZWXI[IZ UQ[T\QUW[UM[M[MVMTPW[XQ\ITT]KPIVLWKWV\ZIITOWY]MM[ QVM^Q\IJTMY]QMZW^Q^QZLQ[NZ]\IZLMTI[XMY]M}I[KW[I[LMTI ^QLIXI[IZM[\M\QMUXWMVM[MT]OIZUnOQKWXIZIUyZMK\Q ÅKWXIZIVW[W\ZI[Y]MM[+]LQTTMZW#)J]MTIVMKM[Q\WPIKMZ ]VJITIVKMLMUQ^QLIM[\IVLWTKQLIM[QUXWZ\IV\MXIZIUy IKW[\]UJZIZUM I TI MVNMZUMLIL a IKMX\IZTI ¨-V\QuVLMUM XWZNI^WZ 5Q^QLIKTIZWY]M\MMV\QMVLWaXMZL~VIUMM[\WaXZW aMK\IVLW UQ[ UQMLW[ MV \Q [M Y]M Y]QMZM[ M[\IZ [WTI a Y]M 5I]ZQKM\MK]QLIZI\WLW[TW[ÅVM[LM[MUIVIQZMUW[IXI [IZTW[KWV\QOW 6W\MWT^QLM[LM-T^QZIY]MVW[M[MXIZIZILMUyaIM[ \Wa^QMVLWTI[XMTMI[aMVNILW[KWVMTTIaK~UWVW5I\QTLM a5IV]MT -[WUMLMRIU]KPWUI[\ZIVY]QTIUQVQ}I (/$',Ð6 )KIZQKQ~ MT nTJ]U LM NW\W[ Y]M \MVyI MV\ZM TI[ UIVW[ KWVUIVW\WZXMTWIJZQ~aKWUMVb~IUQZIZTI[NW\W[8I[M~ [][P]VLQLW[WRW[XWZTI[QVV]UMZIJTM[NW\W[Y]MKWV\MVyI ·+]IV\W[ ZMK]MZLW[ [M LQRW )LZQIVI )TTy M[\IJIV XIXn a UIUn[WVZQuVLWTMMTIJ]MTW8I]TWTIIJ]MTI4MWVWZMTTIa .TI^QILMXMY]M}I[)TTyM[\IJIQVUWZ\ITQbILI]VIM\IXILM []^QLI)TTyM[\IJI.TI^QIMVMTLyILM[]OZIL]IKQ~V.TI^QI KWV;MZOQWMTLyILM[]JWLI.TI^QIKWV@IVIMVMTPW[XQ\IT .TI^QIa;MZOQWKWV[][MO]VLWPQRWZMKQuVVIKQLWMVTIKI[I LM +]LQTTMZW ¨9]u \QMUXW[ \IV NMTQKM[ -ZI KWUW ZM^Q^QZ MT XI[ILW XMZW TW Y]M XI[I VW ^]MT^M a IPWZI [M MVKWV\ZIJI MV]VXZM[MV\MQVKQMZ\W]VXZM[MV\MY]MXZM[MV\yIY]MU]a XZWV\WTTMOIZyII[]ÅV4IMVNMZUMLILPIJyI[MO]QLW[]K]Z [WVWZUITaM[\IJITTMOIVLWI[]ZMK\IÅVIT;IJyIY]MU]a XZWV\WM[\IZyIZWLMILILM[][[MZM[Y]MZQLW[Y]MU]aXZWV\W IJIVLWVIZyI[]K]MZXWUI\MZQITXIZI^WTIZUn[TQOMZIIM[M [Q\QWLWVLMTIM[\IJIVM[XMZIVLWKWVTW[JZIbW[IJQMZ\W[[][ XILZM[aMTIJ]MTW 4I\IZLMM[\IJITTMOIVLWI[]ÅV=VIPMZUW[I\IZLMLM W\W}WMVTIY]MMT[WTJI}IJILMWZWMTXIQ[IRM)LZQIVIUQZ~ TI[KI[I[KWTOILI[MVTIUWV\I}IMT^QMRW5]MTTMLM+]LQTTM ZWMT5]MTTMV]M^W1V\MV\~OZI^IZMV[]UMUWZQI\WLWTW Y]MM[\IJIXI[IVLW4W[XM[KILWZM[LMZMOZM[WI[][PWOIZM[ TI ITMOZM ITOIZIJyI Y]M XZWL]KyIV KWV [][ KWV^MZ[IKQWVM[ 1V\MV\~ ZM\MVMZ XIZI [QMUXZM MT KZWUI\Q[UW LM TW[ nZJWTM[ ^M[\QLW[LM^MZLMWKZMUIZZ~VY]MKWUMVbIJIVIXMZLMZ [][^M[\QL]ZI[5QZ~MTKQMTW\M}QLWLMWZWaMTUIZ[]IUILW UI[+IV\nJZQKW)LZQIVIMV\Z~MVKI[IaKWVXI[WTMV\Wa \ZIJIRW[WMV\Z~MVMT[IT~V;MLMR~KIMZMVMT[WNnKMZKILMTI ^MV\IVIMKP~TIKIJMbIXIZII\Zn[aKMZZ~TW[WRW[ ;MWaMZWV]VW[XI[W[Y]MJIRIJIVTI[M[KITMZI[.TI^QI[M XIZ~ITMV\ZIZMVMT[IT~VaUQZ~I[]PMZUIVI5QZ~[]K]MZ XW NZnOQT a JQMV NWZUILW [] XMTW VMOZW LMZZIUILW XWZ MT [WNnaKWUWMT[WTZWRQbWR]O]M\MIJIKWVuTLnVLWTM]VKWTWZ QV\MV[W .TI^QI[MIKMZK~I[]PMZUIVIaTM\WU~TIUIVW ·8MZLWVI\MPMLM[XMZ\ILW ·6WM[\IJIXMV[IVLW ·8MV[IVLW§MVY]u'·.TI^QIWJ[MZ^~Y]MTIMVNMZUMLIL VWPIJyI[QLWKIXIbLMZWJIZTMMTJZQTTWaTIN]MZbILM[]UQ ZILI ·-VY]MXZWV\WUMUIZKPIZu ·)LZQIVIVWLQOI[M[W ·§)Y]QuVQV\MV\I[MVOI}IZ.TI^QI'<[IJM[Y]MM[\W[M M[\nIKIJIVLW ·6WUMO][\IWyZ\MPIJTIZI[y)LZQIVIUMXWVM[\ZQ[\M ·6WY]QMZWY]M\MXWVOI[\ZQ[\M8ZWV\WM[\IZuKWVXIXna UIUnaKWVMTIJ]MTW§\\MIK]MZLI[LMMTTW[' ·;yMZIVUIZI^QTTW[W[ ·)PWZI \MVLZu TI WXWZ\]VQLIL LM KWVWKMZTW[ +]IVLW MTTW[U]ZQMZWVaW\MVyILW[I}W[aVWZMK]MZLWIXMVI[VILI .TI^QIVWX]MLWKWV\QV]IZPIJTIVLWKWV[]PMZUIVI]V V]LWMVTIOIZOIV\ILMTnOZQUI[a[WTTWbW[[MTWQUXMLyI ·)LZQIVI§VMKM[Q\I[ITOW'>WaI^MZI5I\QTLM·LQRWKWV ]VPQTWLM^Wb LyI Y]M KWVWKQ~ TI MVNMZUMLIL LM )LZQIVI [M LM[^IVMKyIV XWZ]VUWUMV\WMVTIW[K]ZQLILLMTIVWKPMKMZ -T KPQIZ TI[\QUMZW LM TI[ OI^QW\I[ MT U][QKIT a [MLIV\M U]ZU]TTWLMTUIZTMXZWXWZKQWVIJIV[MZMVQLIL;MZMVQLIL XIZIXMV[IZ[MZMVQLILXIZI\WUIZLMKQ[QWVM[8MV[~MV8I] TWMVTWPMZUW[WY]MPIJyI[QLW[]IUWZaMVTI[]MZ\MY]M PIJyI\MVQLWLMMVKWV\ZIZTWLM^Q^QZ]VOZIVIUWZaKWU XIZ\QZ]VW[I}W[UIZI^QTTW[W[KWVuT8I]TWN]MUQIUQOWUQ IUIV\MUQM[XW[WUQKWUXI}MZW;QMUXZMUMMV\MVLQ~a KWUXZMVLQ~jTN]MMTPWUJZMY]M[QMUXZMJ][Y]ua\]^MTI []MZ\MLMMVKWV\ZIZ )T XI[MIZ [][ KIV[ILW[ a TTWZW[W[ WRW[ XWZ IY]MT QLyTQKW XIQ[IRM Y]M [M XZM[MV\IJI LMTIV\M LM MTTI TI []I^M T]b LMT I\IZLMKMZMTU]ZU]TTW[MLIV\MLMTI[WTI[Y]MMZIQVR][\ITM IKWUXI}IZyIPI[\IMTÅVITLM[][LyI[I]VY]MITUMVW[KWV )LZQIVIX]LWXI[IZTW[T\QUW[UM[M[LM^QLIaLM[XMLQZ[M VWKWUWKWV[]Y]MZQLW2WIWa[]PQRI4W[XILZM[LM)LZQI VI[MPIJyIVU]MZ\WMVIKKQLMV\M+WVLM[QLQI[MITMR~LMTI ^MV\IVIIJQMZ\Ia[MLMR~KIMZMVMT[QTT~VTI\IZLM[MM[\IJI LM[XZMVLQMVLW KWV KPQ[XMIV\M[ ZIaW[ LM T]b Y]M MV\ZIJIV XWZTI^MV\IVIXQV\IVLWMVMTKQMTWIb]TNZIVRI[LM^Q^W[KW TWZM[-T[WTKWUWKIJITTMZWIVLIV\MKWUMVbIJIIZM\QZIZ[M XIZILIZXI[WI[]LIUITIT]VI4MWVWZZM[XQZ~XZWN]VLI UMV\MaKWVUIVWÅZUM[IK~]VX]ZWLMTJWT[QTTWLM[]KPI Y]M\IKZ]b~TI[XQMZVI[aMTKZ]RQLWLMTI\MTITMLQJ]R~]VI \yUQLI[WVZQ[IMVMTZW[\ZW,MZMXMV\M2WIWM[\IKWVMTTII []UMUWZQIZMOZM[~MTUWUMV\WMVMTUQMV\ZI[PIJTIJIVMV ]VI[WTMILIUI}IVILMW\W}W]V\MY]QMZW[MKWT~MVTIKWV ^MZ[IKQ~V 4MWVWZ LQW ]VI []I^M KITILI IT X]ZW NWZUIVLW ]VIV]JMJTIVY]MKQVII[]ITZMLMLWZTW[WRW[OZQ[M[LM2WIW TIUQZIJIVM`XMK\IV\MMTTI[WVZyWaTMJM[~ AW\IUJQuV\MY]QMZWLQRW4MWVWZKWVLMKQ[Q~V AY]u^IUW[PIKMZ >Q^QZMTUWUMV\WLQ[NZ]\IZMT]VWLMTW\ZWaKWVW KMZVW[ §;QO]M[KWVM[II^MZ[Q~VITUI\ZQUWVQW' ;Q\aaWV]VKI[MZMUW[]VIXIZMRILMVW^QW[\ZILQ KQWVITM[\[QMUXZMPI[[QLWUQUMRWZIUQOWMZM[M[IXMZ[W VITIXZQUMZIaMVWKI[QWVM[TIVQKIY]MUMIXM\MKMPIKMZ XIZ\yKQXMLMUQ[KW[I[#MZM[UQIUIV\M[QVZM[MZ^I[KWVWKM[ KILI]VWLMUQ[UI[yV\QUW[LM[MW[[WTIUMV\M\MZM[KIXIb LMMVKMVLMZTIT]bY]MQT]UQVIUQUQZILITW[LW[\MVMUW[ O][\W[[QUQTIZM[IÅKQWVM[XMZW[WUW[]VVW[W\ZW[KWV^MZ [IVLWKILIK]IT[]QVLQ^QL]ITQLIL -T[WTPIJyILMRILWXI[WTQJZMI[]LIUITIT]VI]VI[]I ^MT]bJTIVKIQV]VLIJITIPIJQ\IKQ~V4MWVWZ[MTM^IV\~a MVKMVLQ~]VTnUXIZIY]MM[\IJIMVMT[MKZM\MZLM)LZQIVI +WVXI[WTMV\WXMZWÅZUM[MLQZQOQ~ITIXIZ\MLMIJIRWLM TIKI[IMV\Z~MVTIKWKQVIa[M[QZ^Q~]VIKWXI^QVWJTIV KW IT []JQZ LM V]M^W TI[ M[KITMZI[ TI UILMZI KZ]RQ~ JIRW [][ XQM[ MV\Z~ LM V]M^W MV TI PIJQ\IKQ~V LM )LZQIVI a [M LMRWKIMZMVMT[QTT~VLMRWTIKWXIMVMT^MTILWZa\WU~LM V]M^WMT5WV\MKZQ[\WY]MPIJyILMRILWMVMTKMVQKMZW8WZ TI^MV\IVIIJQMZ\IMV\ZIJI]VINZM[KIJZQ[IaMTU]ZU]TTW LMTM`\MZQWZY]MXWKWIXWKWQJILMRIVLWXI[WIT[QTMVKQW LMTIVWKPM4MWVWZ[MZMUW^Q~MVMT[QTT~V[M[]UMZOQ~MV TW[ZMK]MZLW[LMTXI[ILWLMZMXMV\M]VIRW^MVKQ\ILMTOILI IT\I a KWV MT KIJMTTW VMOZW a ITJWZW\ILW [M XZM[MV\~ IV\M MTTI¨K]nV\W[I}W[PIJyIVXI[ILWIY]MTTI4MWVWZRW^MVVW QUIOQVIJITI[XuZLQLI[Y]MQJII\MVMZMV[]^QLI;QMUXZM N]M TI ZMJMTLM LM TI NIUQTQI ]VI ZQ[I XyKIZI [M LQJ]R~ MV []IZZ]OILWZW[\ZWUQMV\ZI[IKMZKIJITIKWXII[][TIJQW[ ML]KILIMV]VINIUQTQIUWRQOI\IMVKWZ[M\ILIaZIVKQILM TI^QMRI>M\][\I-TTIV]VKI[MPIJyIKWUXWZ\ILWKWUWTI[ [M}WZQ\I[LMTIuXWKIN]MTIXZQUMZIMVTTM^IZXIV\ITWVM[MV N]UIZaTWUn[M[KIVLITW[WLM\WLWMTVMOIZ[MIKI[IZ[Ma LMKQZI[][XILZM[Y]M[MQJII^Q^QZKWV2WIW=VIQVUMV[I [WVZQ[IQT]UQV~[]ZW[\ZWIY]MTTWN]MITOW\MZZQJTMXIZI[][ XILZM[]VILM[OZIKQI[]UILZM[WTW[IJyILMKQZ"Y]uLQZnV UQIUQOI[LMTI~XMZIaTI[LMTKQZK]TWLMXWM[yIa[]XILZM KWV OM[\W [M^MZW TM LQRW Y]M VQVO]VI PQRI []aI ^Q^QZyI LM M[MUWLWIV\MTIVMOI\Q^I\IRIV\MLMKI[IZ[M[MUIZKPIZWV I ^Q^QZ I 8IZy[ L]ZIV\M \ZM[ UIZI^QTTW[W[ I}W[ LM TQJMZ\IL KWVWKQUQMV\WaLM[K]JZQUQMV\WNWZUIVLW]VVW[W\ZW[QV LM[\Z]K\QJTMXMZWKWV[MZ^IVLW[QMUXZMTIQVLQ^QL]ITQLILLM KILI]VW 4IUMV\WY]MUQKWUXZMV[Q~VTTMO]M\IZLMXMZW\MXZW UM\W Y]M MV M[\I I^MV\]ZI \] IJ]MTI [MZn \] K~UXTQKM \] KWVÅLMV\M]V[MKZM\WMV\ZMTI[LW[ ,MTXQ[WQVNMZQWZTMTTMO~]VI^WbNIUQTQIZY]MTTIUIJI" ¸4MWVWZ ¸;y 5I\QTLM []JM M[\Wa IZZQJI ¸4M^IV\nVLW[M a KM ZZIVLWTI^MV\IVI ¸¨0WTIY]MZQLIUyI§+~UWM[\n[' ¸§+~UW\M^I5I\QTLM'¸ ¸*QMV Y]MZQLI JQMV ¸ 8MZW VW UM PI[ KWV\M[\ILW §+~UW\MMVK]MV\ZI[' ¸1V\MV\IVLW IKW[\]UJZIZUM I TI V]M^I [Q\]IKQ~V ¨4I MKPW\IV\WLMUMVW[ ¸4W [u 6W[W\ZW[ TI M`\ZI}IUW[ U]KPy[QUW -T XWKW \QMUXWY]MTI\]^QUW[KMZKIN]MUIZI^QTTW[W;QMV\W]V^IKyW QVUMV[WIT^MZTIKI[IKMZZILIa\IV\ZQ[\M ¸§+~UW[MMVK]MV\ZI5IV]MT' ¸5]aIXMVILWuTTIKWV[QLMZIJIKWUWTIPQRIY]MV]V KI\]^QUW[ ¸;yUQY]MZQLIVQ}IMZIU]aL]TKM ¸;y¸-VMT\QUJZMLM^WbLM5I\QTLM[MXWLyIIXZMKQIZ ]VIOZIV\ZQ[\MbI ¸+ZMyVWMVKWV\ZIZW[IY]y ¸5IV]MTM[\n\MZUQVIVLW]VIT\QUIM[K]T\]ZIXIZITI V]M^IKWTMKKQ~V-`XWVLZnMV*IZKMTWVI ¸5MITMOZWU]KPW ¸-[\n[U]aXnTQLI>MVIKI[IVMKM[Q\I[\WUIZITOWKI TQMV\M ¸6W OZIKQI[ .TI^QW a ;MZOQW M[\nV I X]V\W LM ^MVQZ I J][KIZUM0IVQLWITKMUMV\MZQWaWVWPM\MVQLW[]ÅKQMV\M ^ITWZ ¸@IVIa-VWT§\IUJQuV^QVQMZWV' ¸6W-[\nVMVuXWKILMM`nUMVM[aVWM[J]MVWXIZI MTTW[\IV\I\ZQ[\MbI;WTW\QMVMV\ZMKMaWKPWI}W[)LMUn[I )LZQIVIVWTMO][\IZyI ¸§9]uXQMV[I[PIKMZKWVTIKI[I' ¸6W [u 5M LI XMVI LM[PIKMZUM LM MTTI M[\n TTMVI LM ZMK]MZLW[¸4W[WRW[LM4MWVWZILY]QZQMZWV^QLIXWZ]VW[ [MO]VLW[¸9]Qbn[MIPIJQ\ILIXWZITO]QMV ¸§;Q'§8WZY]QuV' ¸8WZ]VIUQOWLM)LZQIVI $5,(/ ;][ [MV[]ITM[ TIJQW[ LQJ]RIJIV ]VI L]TKM [WVZQ[I MV TI Y]M[Q]VW[MÅRIJI]VXWKW[MXWLyIIXZMKQIZY]MVWMZI Un[Y]M]VIUn[KIZIY]MUITIUMV\MWK]T\IJIMTKIV[IV KQWaTI\ZQ[\MbILM[][WRW[<MVyI]VW[MVWZUM[WRW[^MZLM[ Y]M KWV\ZI[\IJIV XMZNMK\IUMV\M KWV [] XQMT UWZMVI a [] XMTW KI[\I}W )ZQMT [M MVKWV\ZIJI ZWLMILW LM OMV\M# \WLI MTTITQOILILQZMK\IWQVLQZMK\IUMV\MITU]VLWLMTIU[Q KIM[QUXZM[KQVLQJTMMVTIXZM[MV\IKQ~VLM]VV]M^WLQ[KW ;M IKMZK~ IT JIZ MV J][KI LM ]VI KWXI a ]V T]OIZ LWVLM XWLMZM[\IZ\ZIVY]QTW-VTW[T\QUW[UM[M[PIJyINWZbILW U]KPW[]K]MZXWa[]UMV\M8ZQUMZWTIKWUXW[QKQ~VLMTI[ KIVKQWVM[aTW[XW[\MZQWZM[IZZMOTW[LM[X]u[TIOZIJIKQ~Va K~UWVWTIXZM[MV\IKQ~VLMTV]M^WLQ[KWaTIXZWUWKQ~V VQUn[VQUMVW[Y]M]VIOQZILM\ZM[UM[M[XWZ)UuZQKI 4I\QVI <WUWTIKWXIaKWUMVb~IIJZQZ[MXI[WMV\ZMTIOMV\M[] QV\MVKQ~VMZITTMOIZITI\MZZIbIaLQ[NZ]\IZLMTIUIZI^QTTW[I ^Q[\ILM4W[ÎVOMTM[Y]MLM[LMITTy[MXWLyILQ^Q[IZ8MZWMV UQ\ILLMT\ZIaMK\WVW\~Y]M]VIUIVWTMWXZQUyIMTPWUJZW KWVN]MZbIaTW[IT]LIJIMN][Q^IUMV\M ¸¨)ZQMTUQUn[[QVKMZIMVPWZIJ]MVI]VLQ[KWNIV\n[\Q KWTTMVWLM[MV\QUQMV\W )ZQMTZMKWZZQ~KWVTIUQZILIIT[]RM\WY]MM[\IJILMTIV\M LMuTVWPIKQMVLWMTUMVWZM[N]MZbWXIZIZMKWZLIZY]QuVMZI IY]MTQVLQ^QL]WLMWRW[[IT\WVM[a^WbINMUQVILI ¸§6WUMZMK]MZLI[';Wa/MVIZW5uVLMb<MPMMV\ZM ^Q[\ILWMV]VXIZLMWKI[QWVM[ ¸¨)P8MZLWVIVWTWOZWZMKWZLIZ\M ¸;y\MMV\ZM^Q[\uMV5u`QKWK]IVLWIVMZI[]VVQ}W LMWVKMI}W[aKWUMVbIJI[\]KIZZMZI4IW\ZIMV\ZM^Q[\I N]MK]I\ZWI}W[LM[X]u[K]IVLWZMOZM[I[\MI5u`QKWKWVMT [MO]VLWX]M[\WMVMTNM[\Q^ITLM;IV:MUWLMJIRWLMTJZI bW¨+IZIUJIU]KPIKPWPIaY]M^MZTWY]MPI[KIUJQILW LM[LMMTQVQKQWLM\]KIZZMZI¸+]IVLW\M[QMV\M[JQMVKWV TWY]MPIKM[aKZMM[MVMTTWMTM[N]MZbWaMT[IKZQÅKQWVW\M QUXWZ\IV )ZQMTQV\MV\WKWV\QV]IZKWV[]QLMIQVQKQITTTMOIZITI\M ZZIbI)[yY]MKWUMVb~IKIUQVIZ ¸5I}IVIKWUQMVbI[TIOQZI§^MZLIL' ¸;yKWUQMVbIMV5QIUQa\MZUQVIZnMV)ZOMV\QVI ¸8]M[VW\MMV\ZM\MVOWUn[<MLM[MWU]KPWu`Q\W ¸/ZIKQI[¸)ZQMTIKWUXI}W[]IOZILMKQUQMV\WKWV]V [QU]TIKZWLM[WVZQ[IY]MQT]UQV~[]IVO]TW[WZW[\ZW ¸=VIKW[IUn[1KyI/~UMb§<MIKWUXI}IZnMVTIOQZI' ¸-TZW[\ZWLM/MVIZWVWXWLyIWK]T\IZY]MLMTIZM[X]M[\I LM)ZQMTXWLyI[ITQZ]VIM`KT][Q^I¸;MPIKWUMV\ILWY]M [WQ[U]aIUQOW[ -TZW[\ZWLM)ZQMTVWIJIVLWV~TIXMK]TQIZ[WVZQ[Ia[QU XI\yIY]MTWKIZIK\MZQbIJIV ¸+]IVLW\MVOIY]MKWU]VQKIZITOWTWKWU]VQKIZuXMZW UQMV\ZI[\IV\WVWY]QMZWY]MVILQM[MMV\ZWUM\IMVUQ^QLI XZQ^ILI ¸-[WM[]VI]\WXyIKWVTIY]M\WLW[TW[NIUW[W[[W}nQ[ ¸ LQRW LnVLWTM INMK\]W[IUMV\M ]VI[ XITUILQ\I[ MV TI M[ XITLI¸XMZWVW\MWT^QLM[Y]MLMJQLWI\]XZWNM[Q~VMZM[ ·6W-[\WaLM[MIVLW\MZUQVIZKWV\WLWM[\W ·A§Y]uM[\WLWM[\W' ·<WLW-TLQ[KWTI[M[Q~VNW\WOZnÅKI° ·ÙT\QUIUMV\M\MVW\WZIZW,M[KMV\ZILW6WXWVM[XI [Q~VMVTWY]MPIKM[ ·§-[Y]uVMKM[Q\WXWVMZITOW'AWKZMyIY]MKWVTIQUIOMV Y]M UM PIJuQ[ NIJZQKILW LM[LM VQ}W a Y]M \IV PnJQTUMV\M PIJuQ[ [IJQLW IUWTLIZ [MOV QJIV XI[IVLW TW[ I}W[ ·KWV \WVW[IZKn[\QKWaKTI^IVLW[][WRW[MV<Q\W·MZI[]ÅKQMV\M ·;y<]QUIOMVM[N]VLIUMV\ITXMZWVMKM[Q\IUW[]VUy VQUWLMMV\][QI[UWXWZ\]XIZ\M ·<Q\W§)TO]VI^Mb\MPI[XZMO]V\ILW[QUMKWVWKM[ZMIT UMV\M' ·9]u \WV\MZyI <M KWVWbKW LM[LM VQ}W a MV \WLW[ M[\W[ I}W[VWVW[PMUW[[MXIZILWV]VKI ·§)TO]VI^Mb\MPI[XZMO]V\IVLWXWZY]uUQUQZILIM[ W[K]ZIa\ZQ[\M' ·6W VW \M MV\QMVLW )ZQMT §8WZ Y]u UM XZMO]V\I[ \WLW M[\W' ·7T^yLITW-[\WaKIV[ILW ·;y\M^MVLZnJQMVLQ[\ZIMZ\M-[\IVWKPMI[Q[\QZMUW[UM RWZ LQKPW I[Q[\QZn[ I TI XZM[MV\IKQ~V LMT V]M^W XMZN]UM LM 7TOILMTI8M}I ·6W6QPIJTIZVWM[\WaKWVnVQUW ·8]M[\MVLZn[Y]MM[\IZTW0MIKWZLILWKWVMTZMXZM[MV \IV\M LM ]VI V]M^I UWLMTW Y]M VMKM[Q\I XZWUWKQ~V Y]M [MZn\]IKWUXI}IV\MaLMM[\INWZUITMXZWXWZKQWVIZn[X] JTQKQLILOZI\]Q\Ia^MVLMZnVMTMVKIV\WLM)ZQMTIV\MTW[LM Un[ ·6WPI[MV\MVLQLWVILILMTWY]M\MPMLQKPW§^MZLIL' ;IJM[K]nTM[\]XZWJTMUI<Q\WY]MVWY]QMZM[M[K]KPIZ;] JQMVLWKILI^MbUn[TI^WbaXWVQuVLW[MLMXQMMVNZMV\MLM <Q\W· -ZM[ ]V MOWy[\I Y]M [~TW XQMV[I MV [y UQ[UW 6W \M QUXWZ\ITWY]M[QMV\MTIXMZ[WVI[~TW\MQUXWZ\IMTyLWTWY]M PI[KZMILW ·)ZQMT\ZIVY]QTybI\M-[\n[KIV[ILWaVW[IJM[TWY]MLQ KM[ ·8WZNI^WZLMRILM\ZI\IZUMKWUWI]VIUIZQWVM\I;y[u TWY]MLQOW;y[uTWY]M[QMV\W8MZWV]VKIPIJyI\MVQLWMT ^ITWZ[]ÅKQMV\MXIZIM`\MZQWZQbIZTW0I[\IIPWZIVWPM\MVQLW MT^ITWZLMIKMX\IZY]MUQUQZILIM[MTZMÆMRWLM]VITUI ^IKyI=VITUILMXIXMTY]MVW^ITMVILI ·*QMVaI\MPI[LM[IPWOILW+WV\QV]MUW[KWVTI[M[Q~V ·5M^Wa ·§9]u'6WX]MLM[QZ\M ·;yX]MLW6MKM[Q\WLM[KWVMK\IZLM\WLWTWY]MUMZWLMI ·6WX]MLM[QZ\M\QMVM[ÅZUILW]VKWV\ZI\W -T PWZQbWV\M KWUMVbIJI I LQJ]RIZ[M XWZ ]VI TM^M TyVMI UIT^IY]MIV]VKQIJIY]MMTLyIM[\IJILM[XQLQMVLWITIVW KPM =VI VWKPM MV TI Y]M )ZQMT XMV[~ U]KPW =VI VWKPM MVTIY]MQV\MV\~ZMKWZLIZTWY]M\MVyIWT^QLILW=VIVWKPM MVTIY]MZMKWZL~[][[]M}W[LMVQ}W=VIVWKPMMVTIY]M ^WT^Q~IM[K]KPIZTW[LQ[KW[LM[]XILZM=VIVWKPMMVTIY]M IVITQb~ [][ [MV\QUQMV\W[ Un[ XZWN]VLW[ M[W[ [MV\QUQMV\W[ Y]M\MVyIWT^QLILW[=VIVWKPMMVTIY]MLMKQLQ~Y]MVMKM[Q \IJI]VIM`XIV[Q~VLMKWVKQMVKQI)ZQMTUQZ~TIKIZXM\IY]M M[\IJI R]V\W I TI UITM\I a ZMKWVWKQ~ Y]M ]VI LM[KWVWKQLI KWVWKyI[][[MV\QUQMV\W[Un[XZWN]VLW[=VW[[MV\QUQMV\W[ Y]MuTQOVWZIJI=VILM[KWVWKQLILMTIY]MVW[IJyIVQ[] VWUJZMPIJyITWOZILWZM^WT]KQWVIZ[]U]VLWQV\MZQWZ=VI LM[KWVWKQLI KWV ]VI []\QT L]Tb]ZI PIJyI TWOZILW PIKMZTM KWUXZMVLMZY]MMTyLWTWPIJyILM^WZILWITPWUJZM0IJyI TWOZILW[MUJZIZMVuTTIK]ZQW[QLILLMLQ[NZ]\IZTI[XMY]M}I[ KW[I[LMTI^QLIKWUWI[Q[\QZITUIZI^QTTW[WM[XMK\nK]TWLM ^MZIUIVMKMZ:MKZMIZTI^Q[\IMVM[IQVÅVQ\IOIUILMKWTWZM[ XQV\ILW[IKIXZQKPWXWZTIVI\]ZITMbI )ZQMTUM\Q~TIKIZXM\IMVTIUITM\ITIKMZZ~aKWVMVMZOyI a LMKQ[Q~V [ITQ~ LM TI KI[I +WV []UW K]QLILW XIZI VW [MZ LM[K]JQMZ\W XWZ [][ XMZZW[ O]IZLQIVM[ 0uK\WZ a /WVbITW KZ]b~MTRIZLyVa[]ÅO]ZI[MN]VLQ~KWVTIM`XTW[Q~VLMKWTW ZM[Y]MMVM[MUWUMV\W[MM[\IJIXZWL]KQMVLW (/&$172'(/$9,(-$9(7867$ ·)J]MTI VW UM PI[ KWUMV\ILW VILI LM \] ^QIRM I 4W[ ÎVOMTM[·.TI^QIKTI^~[][QVUMV[W[WRW[^QWTM\I[MVTIÅO]ZI LM[]IJ]MTI ·6WPIaVILIY]MKWUMV\IZ-[\WaU]aUIaWZaTW[T\Q UW[IKWV\MKQUQMV\W[UMPIVOWTXMILWMVTWUn[XZWN]VLW LMUQITUI6MKM[Q\IJIKIUJQIZLMIUJQMV\M)TMRIZUMLM \WLW ·;y Y]MZQLI IJ]MTI ·8I[nVLWTM MT JZIbW XWZ MVKQUI LMT PWUJZW·-[\IVQVQK]ITIU]MZ\MLM)LZQIVIAWKZMyIY]M PIJyIIXZMVLQLWIKWV^Q^QZKWVTIU]MZ\MXMZWTIU]MZ\MLM )LZQIVI UM PI LMUW[\ZILW Y]M VW ,MJQLW I UQ XZWNM[Q~V KWUWMVNMZUMZIM[\WaU]aNIUQTQIZQbILIKWVMTTI8MZWIV\M[ aI^Q^QUW[[]XZM[MVKQIU]aLMKMZKI8ZQUMZWN]MTIU]MZ\M LMXIXnaUIUnMVIY]MTPWZZQJTMIKKQLMV\MIuZMWjZIUW[ U]a VQ}I[ aW \MVyI V]M^M I}W[ a )LZQIVI LW[ +ZMW Y]M I M[I MLIL VW \QMVM[ TI KIXIKQLIL []ÅKQMV\M XIZI KWUXZMVLMZ TWY]MM[W[QOVQÅKI8MZWINWZ\]VILIUMV\MW[\MVyIUW[I^W [W\ZW[·4IT]b[MÅT\ZIJIXWZTI^MV\IVILQJ]RIVLWMVMT[]MTW LMTIPIJQ\IKQ~VTILMTOILI[QT]M\ILM.TI^QI·,M[X]u[N]MTI U]MZ\MLMTIJ]MTW1VM[XMZILIUMV\M]VQVNIZ\W[MTWTTM^~MV ]VKIT]ZW[WLyILMTUM[LM2]TQW·.TI^QI[MIZZWLQTT~aIXWa~ TIKIJMbIMVMTZMOIbWLM[]IJ]MTI\IXQbnVLWTWKWV[]VMOZW aWVL]TILWXMTW·AIPWZI)LZQIVI§;IJM['IJ]MTIaWIL UQZIJIaILUQZWIUQPMZUIVIaTINWZUIK~UW[M\WU~[] MVNMZUMLIL-TTI[QMUXZM[]XWTWY]MY]MZyIaK~UWY]MZyI Y]MN]M[M[]^QLI-[WTIIKWUXI}~PI[\ITIPWZILM[]U]MZ\M ·;yUQVQ}I·)KIZQKQnVLWTMMTXMTW·)LZQIVIMZI\WLW ]VKIZnK\MZ ·5MM[\WaIKWZLIVLWK]IVLWMVTI[NZyI[\IZLM[LMQV^QMZ VWTTMOnJIUW[I\MZQLI[LMNZyWLMTKWTMOQWa\VW[M[XMZIJI[ KWVTIUMZQMVLIXZMXIZILIMVNZMV\MLMTPWOIZ)TKITWZLMTI T]UJZMaIUMVQbILWXWZTITT]^QIY]MMT^QMV\WXZMKQXQ\IJI KWVTW[KZQ[\ITM[VW[KWV\IJI[K~UWW[KWVWKQ[\MQ[MTIJ]MTW a\,MTINIUQTQIY]M\MVyIUW[ITTy ·¨+~UWXI[IMT\QMUXW8IZMKMY]MN]MIaMZK]IVLW\QZu[][ KMVQbI[LM[LMMTKMZZWLM=ZKIMV:yW-V[]IUILIKQ]LIL :MK]MZLWKWV[]UIKTIZQLILMTLyIY]MTWKWVWKy.]MKMZKILM TI=VQ^MZ[QLILLM,MZMKPWjTUMXZMO]V\~XZMKQ[IUMV\MXWZ M[I]VQ^MZ[QLIL)Uy[MUMM[KIX~]VI[WVZQ[IITWyZ[]IKMV\W \IVL]TKMaTMQVLQY]uY]MM[\nJIUW[LMTIV\MLMMTTI ·;yAuTIXZM[]ZILIUMV\M\MLQWTI[OZIKQI[a[MUIZKP~A \\MN]Q[\MXIZI\][KTI[M[MVTI.IK]T\ILM/MWOZINyIM0Q[\WZQI ·-NMK\Q^IUMV\M·=VIMVWZUM[WVZQ[ITMQT]UQV~TIKIZI· AXMV[uY]MRIUn[^WT^MZyII^MZIIY]MTI\ZIK\Q^WU]KPIKPW LMWRW[OZQ[M[aIKMV\WL]TKMaUMTW[W ·8MZWK]IT[MZyI\][WZXZM[IIT^MZTWXWZTI\IZLM[MV\ILW MVNZMV\MLM\QMVTIJQJTQW\MKI ·¨A Y]u O]IXW M[\IJI KWV [][ OINI[ a ZWLMILW XWZ ]V UWV\~VLMIJ]ZZQLW[TQJZW[LM,MZMKPW ·9]uJWVQ\WIJ]MTI ·;y.TI^QI0M\MVQLWTIOZIV[]MZ\MLMPIJMZKWVWKQLWa PIJMZ^Q^QLWKWVMTOZIVIUWZLMUQ^QLI)]VY]M§\VW\M Y]MRIZn[' ·6WaW\IUJQuVPM\MVQLWM[I[]MZ\M4W[]XMLM[LMTI XZQUMZI^MbY]MTW^QMVTIKTI[MXZnK\QKILM)VI\WUyI6]M[ \ZI[UQZILI[[MKZ]bIZWVaN]MUnOQKW ·9]MZWUnV\QKW<MLQZyI)LZQIVIMV\WVWO]I[~V MVNMZUMLILVWXMZLQ~MVVQVOVUWUMV\WTIQV\MOZQLILaTI KIXIKQLILLMLMKQ[Q~V ·§9]uMVNMZUMLIL\MVyI' 4MWVWZ[][XQZ~aKWV^WbIXIOILIKWV\M[\~ ·4M]KMUQI,MKQLQ~VW[WUM\MZ[MIT\ZI\IUQMV\WLMY]Q UQW\MZIXQI,MKyIY]MY]MZyI^Q^QZTW[T\QUW[UM[M[TKQLIa [QV[]NZQZTW[LM^I[\ILWZM[MNMK\W[LMT\ZI\IUQMV\W-[W[T\Q UW[UM[M[TW[XI[~MVTIKI[ILM+]LQTTMZW ·§+]LQTTMZW' ·;y+]LQTTMZWM[]VX]MJTWLMXM[KILWZM[XZMKQW[W[Q\]I LWKMZKILM)^QTu[+]IVLWTI[VQ}I[MZIVXMY]M}I[yJIUW[ LM^IKIKQWVM[ITTy)8I]TWTMNI[KQV~MTT]OIZVILIUn[^MZTW ·§9]u\QMVMVITTyNIUQTQIZM[' ·6W=VI^QMRIKI[IMVMTJIZZQWLMTI:QJMZI=VIKI[I Y]M)LZQIVILMKWZ~I[]UIVMZIaY]MM[]VKTIZWZMÆMRWLM MTTI=VIKI[I[Q\]ILIMVTIXIZ\MUn[XQV\WZM[KILM+]LQTTM ZWaLM[LMTIK]IT[MX]MLM^MZMTUIZ ·)V\M[LMQZUM§XWLZyI^Q[Q\IZTIKI[I' ·¨8WZ[]X]M[\W<M^WaILIZTI[TTI^M[a[Q\MO][\IX]MLM[ Y]MLIZ\MMVMTTI\WLWMT\QMUXWY]MY]QMZI[ ·§,M^MZLIL' ·;y4IKI[IM[\nKMZZILIaTM^MVLZnJQMVITO]QMVY]MTI PIJQ\M·7XZQUQuVLWTMKIZQ}W[IUMV\MTIUIVW =VI[^WKM[Y]MTTMOIJIVLMTM`\MZQWZTM[IKIZWVLMT\ZIV Y]QTWaXZWN]VLW[]M}WLMTIVWKPM0IKyI\QMUXWY]MVW LWZUyI\IVJQMV;IT\~LMTIKIUIa[MI[WU~ITI^MV\I VI ZMKQJQMVLW MT [IT]LW ITMOZM LMT [WT ;] UQZILI J][K~ MV\ZM MT XQV\WZM[KW XIQ[IRM LM KI[I[ a M[KITMZI[ LM XQMLZI Y]M [MZ^yIV LM IKKM[W I TI[ KI[I[ KWTOILI[ 5QZ~ PIKQI TI XTIbIa[MLMTMQ\~KWVMTQZa^MVQZLMTIOMV\M8MZWTI[^WKM[ KWV\QV]IJIV /IJZQMT IJZQ~ TI ^MV\IVI a [M MVKWV\Z~ KWV LW[U]RMZM[LMMLILUMLQIVIY]MXIZMKyIVUIV\MVMZ]VI IUQ[\W[IKWV^MZ[IKQ~VMTM^IVLWMT\QUJZMLM[][^WKM[;M IXWa~LQ[KZM\IUMV\MMVMTITNuQbIZLMTI^MV\IVIMQV\MV\~ KWUXZMVLMZTWY]MM[\IJIVLQKQMVLW ·§9]u\QXI[~]5IV]TQVI' ·8W[UQZIXIY]MT][MXI[)V\WVIaIM[INyILM>ITQIV \y XWZY]Q LQ`Q Y]Q MT [W] UWb] QJI KWV W\ZI ZIXIbI ,M[ KITb~][Q]VIUILZM}IaIZQU~]UQY]QXW]UUn[Y]QML] \]MZ\I ·¨AI^MVIQIXI^IZ~V§6WVIZZQI[\Q]VIUWZZILI' ·§-TY]MQ'<QZMQUMITXQ[IUI[]M[OIZWT]}MTTIVIKIZI 6WM]KWVWbVQV[]UI ·8W[IPWZIMTUWb]PILM`ITTI ·;QTILM`IY]MTILMQ`M )ZQMT[QO]Q~TIKWV^MZ[IKQ~VMV\ZMI[WUJZILWaLQ^MZ\Q LW)[WUJZILWXWZMTMTM^ILW\WVWLM[][^WKM[aLQ^MZ\QLW XWZMT[QVO]TIZTMVO]IRMY]MM[\IJIV]\QTQbIVLWaY]MTMMZI XZnK\QKIUMV\MQVKWUXZMV[QJTM;QV\Q~Y]M[]K]MZXWQVMZ\M [MVMOIJII[MXIZIZ[MLMTI^MV\IVIPI[\IVW[IJMZLMY]u QJITIKWV^MZ[IKQ~VLMIY]MTTI[LW[U]RMZM[Y]M\IUJQuVTI M[KMVQÅKIJIVKWVOM[\W[8I[ILW[]VW[UQV]\W[KWUXZMV LQ~OZIKQI[I[]UyUQKIY]MTIU]RMZLMTILMZMKPI)V\W VIKWV\IJIITILMTIQbY]QMZLI5IV]TQVITWY]MTMPIJyI XI[ILWKWVTIPQRILM]V\IT>QITIV\yXWZK]TXILMTVW^QWLM TIPQRILMM[\M[M}WZ /IJZQMT LM[X]u[ LM MV\MZIZ[M I UMLQI[ LM TI KWV^MZ [IKQ~V LM TI[ LW[ U]RMZM[ KMZZ~ TI ^MV\IVI a UQZ~ TI PI JQ\IKQ~V LM[WZLMVILI KWV \WLW [] MY]QXIRM \QZILW XWZ MT []MTW4IXZQUMZIQUXZM[Q~VY]MTMXZWL]RWM[\I^Q[Q~VN]M LMXIb[MZMVQLIL\ZIVY]QTQLILaTQJMZ\IL4QJMZ\ILPWa[M [MV\yITQJZM\IVTQJZMY]MVW[IJyIY]uPIKMZ4QJZMLMO]IZ LIM[XITLI[LMXZWL]K\WZM[LM\WLITIOMV\MY]MM[\IJII []ITZMLMLWZWUMRWZLQKPWITZMLMLWZLM)ZQMT-VUMLQW LM \WLW IY]MT LM[WZLMV KWUXZMVLQ~ Y]M M[M LyI M[\IJI IJZQMVLW]VIV]M^IM\IXILM[]^QLI *IR~ TI[ M[KITMZI[ -T ^M[\yJ]TW M[\IJI IOZILIJTMUMV\M QT]UQVILWXWZ]VIJTIVY]y[QUIT]bY]M[MÅT\ZIJIXWZTW[ KZQ[\ITM[LMTIX]MZ\ILM[LMMTM`\MZQWZ-T^M[\yJ]TWM[\IJI LMKWZILWKWV^IZQW[K]ILZW[XQV\ILW[IT~TMW;QVL]LIIT O]VW[XQV\ILW[XWZ)LZQIVI-V]VM`\ZMUW[MMVKWV\ZIJI ]VXMZKPMZWLMUILMZILMM[\QTWXZW^MVbITaR][\WITW\ZW TILW LMT ^M[\yJ]TW ]V WZQOQVIT XIZIOMZW 6ILI Un[ [ITQZ LMT ^M[\yJ]TW [M MVKWV\ZIJI ]V IUXTQW [IT~V KWV IUXTQI[ KZQ[\ITMZI[aLM[LMMTK]IT[MXWLyI^MZMTUIZ4W[U]MJTM[ MZIVLMM[\QTWXZW^MVbITaMVUMLQWLMT[IT~V[MMVKWV\ZI JIQV[\ITILI]VIIV\QO]IM[\]NILMTM}I4ILMKWZIKQ~VMZI [MVKQTTIXMZWK]QLIVLWTW[Un[XMY]M}W[LM\ITTM[ ,M[LMMT[IT~V[MIKKMLyIITIKWKQVI=VIKWKQVIIUXTQI aIU]MJTILIKWV]VKWV[Q[\MV\MJIVKWaUM[ILMKI[\I}W -V]VM`\ZMUW[MMVKWV\ZIJI]VIPMZUW[IITIKMVI,M[LM TIKWKQVI[MXI[IJII]VXMY]M}WK]IZ\WMVMTY]M[MMV KWV\ZIJITITI^ILWZIaTI\IJTILMXTIVKPIZ /IJZQMT^WT^Q~[WJZM[][XI[W[aUQZ~TWT\QUWLMTXQ[W LMIJIRWTIPIJQ\IKQ~VLMQV^Q\ILW[a]VXMY]M}WK]IZ\WLM JI}W;]JQ~LMV]M^WTI[M[KITMZI[-VMTXQ[WLMIZZQJIPIJyI LW[PIJQ\IKQWVM[aW\ZWK]IZ\WLMJI}W=VIPIJQ\IKQ~VMZITI Y]MuTPIJyIWK]XILW4IW\ZIXMV[~Y]M[MZyITILM)LZQIVI XMZW[MMY]Q^WK~KMZKILMTK]IZ\WLMJI}WLM[K]JZQ~]VI[ XMY]M}I[M[KITMZI[LMKIZIKWTY]MTIVWKPMIV\MZQWZVWPIJyI ^Q[\W4IK]ZQW[QLILTWMUX]R~a[MMVKWV\Z~MVTIPIJQ\IKQ~V LM)LZQIVI;QVL]LIITO]VIMZITIUn[PMZUW[ILMTIKI[I 8WZ[]T]OIZZMKWOQLWZMKWZL~Y]MMTTITWUMVKQWVIJIMV[] TIZOIKIZ\I-ZIM[XIKQW[I-V]VM`\ZMUW[MMVKWV\ZIJI]VI IUXTQIKIUILMKI[\I}Wa]VIUM[IKIUQTTI^M[\QLIKWVTW[ UQ[UW[\WVW[LMTMLZML~V-TZM[\WLMTIPIJQ\IKQ~VM[\IJI WK]XILWXWZ]V[WNn]VIIUXTQIUM[I[MUJZILILMXIXMTM[ ]VIOZIVM[\IV\MZyIKWVTQJZW[aITNWVLW]VKIJITTM\Ma]VI XMY]M}IUM[IKWV\WLW[TW[]\MV[QTQW[VMKM[IZQW[XIZIXQV\IZ ,M[LMTI^MV\IVI[MXWLyILQ[NZ]\IZLM]VIUIOVyÅKI^Q[\I LM+]LQTTMZWaK~UWVWLMTUIZ,MTJZI^WUIZ+IV\nJZQKW /IJZQMT Y]ML~ OZI\IUMV\M [WZXZMVLQLW M QUXZM[QWVILW 4IKI[ITMPIJyIKI]\Q^ILWLM[LMMTXZQUMZUWUMV\W<WLI MTTITMXZWL]KyI\ZIVY]QTQLILa[MZMVQLIL-ZI]VIKI[IKW Y]M\IaIKWOMLWZIMVTIY]MVWM`Q[\yIVOZIVLM[T]RW[XMZW KWV\MVyIMTMVKIV\WLMTI[MVKQTTMbaTIVI\]ZITQLIL=VIKI[I MVTIY]M[MXWLyIVIXZMKQIZXMY]M}W[LM\ITTM[aY]MTMLI JIV]VMVKIV\WU]aXMZ[WVITaM[XMKQIT;QVL]LIITO]VII )LZQIVITMMVKIV\IJIVTI[ÆWZM[aM[W[MXWLyIIXZMKQIZMV TW[V]UMZW[W[KMV\ZW[aÆWZMZW[Y]MM`Q[\yIVMVTIKI[I 4TM^IJIUn[LMY]QVKMUQV]\W[KIUQVIVLWXWZIY]MTTI JMZQV\WLMKI[I[M[KITMZI[LMXQMLZIaKITTMR]MTI[[QV[ITQLI /IJZQMT LM[K]JZQ~ KWV IOZILW Y]M MV TW Un[ XZWN]VLW LM []XMZ[WVIIVKWV[MZ^IJITIKIXIKQLILLMI[WUJZWLM]V VQ}W-TI[WUJZWY]MTMXZWL]KyIIY]MT[QVO]TIZXMZWPMZUW [WT]OIZKWVTI[KI[I[KWTOILI[MVTIUWV\I}ITI[M[KITMZI[ LMXQMLZITW[JITKWVM[ILWZVILW[KWVZWXIY]MKWV\ZQJ]yIV ILIZKWTWZQLWaXMZ[WVITQLILITXIQ[IRMaMVITO]VWLMMTTW[ KWUXIZ\QMVLWXZW\IOWVQ[UWKWVTIJTIVY]y[QUIKWTILI]VI M[XMKQMLMXMKM[Y]M/IJZQMTVWMV\MVLyIXWZY]uTW[KWT OIJIVI[MKIZKWUW[QN]MZIV]VIXZMVLIUn[LMTIKWTILI 5QZ~LQ[\ZIyLIUMV\MMTZMTWRaKWUXZWJ~Y]MTI\IZLMM[\IJI TTMOIVLWI[]ÅVaY]M[QVWTWOZIJI[ITQZLMM[\MTIJMZQV\W[M TMPIZyILMVWKPMXIZIQZITKMUMV\MZQW)TXI[IZLMTIV\MLM ]VJITK~VILWZVILWKWVQVV]UMZIJTM[OMZIVQW[^QWI]VI [M}WZIY]MTMWJ[MZ^IJIaLMKQLQ~XMLQZTMIa]LI ·*]MVI[\IZLM[[M}WZI·/IJZQMT^QWI]VI[M}WZILM]VW[ [M[MV\IaKQVKWI}W[KWV]VIXQMTM`\ZMUILIUMV\MUWZMVIa K]Z\QLIXWZMT[WTaMTUIZY]MTMUQZIJILMIZZQJIIJIRWKWV ]VW[WRW[M`XMK\IV\M[aTTMVW[LMK]ZQW[QLIL ·;y§TTIUnJI[UQ' ·;y[M}WZI9]QMZWQZITKMUMV\MZQWXMZW\MUWY]MUMPM XMZLQLW ·+TIZWJW]UWb]\I[MVTIKITTM®;IT[QX]MLM[¯0I[I\MV LMUQ[]JM\WLI[M[I[M[KITMZI[MITTyM[nITWY]MJ][KI[ ·/ZIKQI[[M}WZI ·,MVILIJW]UWb] /IJZQMT[QO]Q~ TI[ QV[\Z]KKQWVM[ Y]MTMIKIJIJIVLMLIZ UQMV\ZI[MV[]ZW[\ZW[MLQJ]RIJI]VIMVWZUM[WVZQ[I+ITTM ;IT[QX]MLM[KWUWXIZIMVKWV\ZIZTI[ITQLI)Y]MTTI[M[KITM ZI[[MPIKyIVQV\MZUQVIJTM[aKILI^MbMZIVUn[M[\ZMKPI[a [QV]W[I[XMZW\WLITIQVKWUWLQLILLMTKIUQVWTIKWUXMV[I JITIJMTTMbILMTXIQ[IRM=VXIQ[IRMXQV\ILWMVIb]Ta^MZLM MTIb]TLMTKQMTWaLMTUIZ]VIb]TLMTUIZILWZVILWKWVMT JTIVKWLMTI[WTI[Y]MXZWL]KyIVTIJZI^]ZILMT+IV\nJZQKW =V XIQ[IRM XQV\ILW MV Ib]T a ^MZLM VW ]V ^MZLM [QVW ]VI OIUIQVÅVQ\ILM^MZLM[-T^MZLMLMTI[UWV\I}I[LMTW[XZI LW[LMTW[nZJWTM[]V^MZLM[ITXQKILWXWZKWY]M\I[\yUQLI[ a[MVKQTTI[ÆWZM[[QT^M[\ZM[aMV\WLIIY]MTTIM`XZM[Q~VLMKW TWZQLW+]LQTTMZW[]ZOyIIT\Q^WaWZO]TTW[WMV\ZM\IV\IJMTTMbI VI\]ZIT-V\WLWMTZMKWZZQLW/IJZQMTVW[MPIJyIXTIV\MILW VQVO]VIK]M[\Q~V[QUXTMUMV\M[MPIJyITQUQ\ILWILMRIZ[] UMV\MMVJTIVKWaMUXIXIZ[MLM\WLWTWY]MTWZWLMIJI -ZIIPWZIK]IVLWIL^QZ\Q~Y]MM[\IJITTMOIVLWI[]LM[ \QVW+]IVLW[QV\Q~Y]M]VKW[Y]QTTMWTMZMKWZZQ~MTK]MZXW ;MMVKWV\ZIJIMV]V[Q\QWUIZI^QTTW[WaLM[QVO]TIZJMTTMbI XWZTI[KWVÅLMVKQI[LM]VILM[KWVWKQLIY]MKWVWKyIZI[OW[ LM[]XMZ[WVITQLILY]MuTUQ[UWLM[KWVWKyI+I[Q[QVLIZ[M K]MV\I[MMVKWV\Z~MVTIX]MZ\ILMTKMUMV\MZQW,]JQ\I\Q^W MV\Z~aVW[]XWY]uJ][KIZ4MWVWZVWPIJyI[QLWU]aM` XTyKQ\I[QUXTMUMV\M[MPIJyITQUQ\ILWILMKQZY]MMV\MZZIZWV [][ZM[\W[MV+]LQTTMZW/IJZQMT[IK~MVKWVKT][Q~VY]MMV \WVKM[LMJyIJ][KIZ]VI\]UJIMVTIY]MÅO]ZIZIMTVWUJZM LM )LZQIVI >ITLu[ 4W QV\MV\~ KWV ^IZQI[ \]UJI[ XMZW [QV u`Q\W-TT]OIZTMM[\IJIMUXMbIVLWIXWVMZVMZ^QW[WLMKQ LQ~LQZQOQZ[MI]VOZ]XWLMU]RMZM[Y]MM[\IJIVIZZMOTIVLW ]VI\]UJI-[\I[U]aIUIJTMUMV\MTMQVLQKIZWVY]MMZITI T\QUITIY]M[MMVKWV\ZIJIKMZKILM]VW[KI[\I}W[Y]M[M ^MyIVITNWVLW+WVXI[WTQOMZW[MLQZQOQ~PIKQITI\]UJILM )LZQIVIXMZWVWMVKWV\Z~VILIY]M[MTMXIZMKQMZI+MZKI LMTW[KI[\I}W[VWPIJyIVILI[QVL]LIITO]VIVWTMPIJyIV MV\MVLQLW/IJZQMTM[\IJILQ[X]M[\WIZMVLQZ[MK]IVLWLQ^Q[~ ]VIZJ][\WY]MVWIKMZ\IJIILQ[\QVO]QZ4IK]ZQW[QLILPQbW Y]M[MIKMZKIZIaI[yN]MKWUWMVKWV\Z~TI\]UJILM)LZQI VI-TIZJ][\WY]MPIJyILQ^Q[ILWMZI]VZW[ITKWVU]T\Q\]L LMKIX]TTW[ZWRW[-VTI\QMZZIX]LW^MZ]VIXTIKI $'5,$1$ )LZQIVIUQY]MZQLI)LZQIVIMV\]MUXM}WLMY]MLQ[ NZ]\MLMTI[XMY]M}I[KW[I[LMTI^QLIPI[KWV[MO]QLWY]MUM LMKQLIIKWKQVIZ /IJZQMTWa~Y]MITO]QMVTTIUIJIITIX]MZ\I)JIVLWV~ []XMY]M}WUWV~TWOWaIJZQ~TIX]MZ\IKWVLMKQ[Q~V ·§9]uNIM[UQWVM}W' /IJZQMTY]ML~U]a[WZXZMVLQLWITMVKWV\ZIZ[MKWVIY]M TTIU]RMZY]MTMMZINIUQTQIZaITIK]ITVWMV\MVLyIU]aJQMV ·8MZL~V[M}WZI6WTIMV\QMVLW ·0M^Q[\WY]MTIKI[IM[\nPIJQ\ILIaPM^MVQLWI[IT]LIZ ITI[M}WZI4MWVWZ ·4MWVWZVWM[\n-[\WaaW[WTW -T^QZIUQZ~I/IJZQMTKWVK]ZQW[QLILaM`\ZMUWLM[KIZW LMIZZQJIIIJIRW ·¨)P ·AW[Wa]VIUQOWLM)LZQIVI8MZWXI[M /IJZQMT[QO]Q~I-T^QZIY]MMV\Z~a[MLQZQOQ~IT[IT~V ·5MITMOZIY]MTIKI[IM[\uPIJQ\ILILMV]M^WAWKWVW KyII)LZQIVILM[LMXMY]M}I))LZQIVIaI\WLITINIUQTQI ·;QuV\M[MXWZNI^WZ§4MIXM\MKM\WUIZITOW' ·6WVUQWVM}W§AY]uM[\n[[WTW' ·;y0MTTMOILWPIKMXWKWaM[\WaLQ[NZ]\IVLWLMM[\MJMTTW X]MJTW·/IJZQMT[MXZMO]V\IJIY]QuVMZIIY]MTTIU]RMZY]M TMM[\IJI[WUM\QMVLWI]VQV\MZZWOI\WZQW ·<MXZMO]V\IZn[Y]QuV[Wa§^MZLIL' ·8]M[[y ·+WUW \M LQ`Q aW KWVWKyI I )LZQIVI XMZW ILMUn[ [Wa PMZUIVILM5IV]MT-T^MKQVWLMMVNZMV\M ·)VVWPM\MVQLW\QMUXWLMKWVWKMZIUQ[^MKQVW[ ·8]M[[y4W[^MKQVW[LMMVNZMV\M[WVUQPMZUIVWaUQK] }ILI-TTW[M[\]^QMZWVU]aKMZKILM)LZQIVIMVTW[T\QUW[ UM[M[Y]MM[\]^WIY]y /IJZQMTUQZ~KWVLQ[KZMKQ~VMTZMTWR ·§<QMVM[XZQ[I' ·-[\IJIIX]V\WLM[ITQZLMKWUXZI[<MVOWTILM[XMV[I ^IKyIaTIQV\MVKQ~VLMIXZMVLMZIKWKQVIZ ·§-TY]MQ'·5]aM`\ZI}ILI ·+WKQVIZ<MVOWY]MKWUMZ§VW' ·AI^MVIKnXI^WZWVAWX]MLW^MVQZM\NIKMZTI[KW[I[ LMTIKI[I /IJZQMTUQZ~MVLQZMKKQ~VIIY]MTTI[M}WZIY]MVWPIJTI JIOZQ\IJIaOM[\QK]TIJILM]VIUIVMZIM`IOMZILI ·+ZMWY]MVWM[]VIJ]MVIQLMI9]QMZWIXZMVLMZIKWKQ VIZaLQ[NZ]\IZLMMTTW -T^QZIKTI^~[][VMOZW[aJZQTTIV\M[WRW[MV/IJZQMT ·8W[UQZI^IUW[>IVIKMZZIZ\M·4M^IV\nVLW[MaMU