La sialoendoscipia en el tratamiento de los procesos salivares obstructivos CT2014/03 CONSULTAS TÉCNICAS CONSULTAS TÉCNICAS /DVLDORHQGRVFRSLDHQHOWUDWDPLHQWRGHORV SURFHVRVVDOLYDOHVREVWUXFWLYRV 6DQWLDJRGH&RPSRVWHODPD\RGH 'LUHFFLyQDYDOLDW 0/XLVD/ySH]*DUFtD $XWRU *HUDUGR$WLHQ]D0HULQR 'RFXPHQWDFLyQ 7HUHVD0HMXWR0DUWt Xunta de Galicia Consellería de Sanidade Axencia de Avaliación de Tecnoloxías Sanitarias de Galicia Santiago de Compostela 2014 DYDOLDW &RQVXOWD7pFQLFD 3DUDFLWDUHVWHLQIRUPH $WLHQ]D0HULQR*/DVLDORHQGRVFRSLDHQHOWUDWDPLHQWRGHORVSURFHVRVVDOLYDOHV REVWUXFWLYRV 6DQWLDJR GH &RPSRVWHOD &RQVHOOHUtD GH 6DQLGDGH $[HQFLD GH $YDOLDFLyQ GH 7HFQROR[tDV 6DQLWDULDV GH*DOLFLD DYDOLDW 6HULH $YDOLDFLyQ GHWHFQROR[tDV&RQVXOWDV7pFQLFDV&7 5(9,6,Ð1(;7(51$ (VWH LQIRUPH KD VLGR VRPHWLGR D XQ SURFHVR GH UHYLVLyQ H[WHUQD /D $[HQFLD GH $YDOLDFLyQGH7HFQROR[tDV6DQLWDULDVGH*DOLFLDDYDOLDWDJUDGHFHD'-RVH/XLV/ySH] &HGU~Q -HIH GHO 6HUYLFLR GH &LUXJtD 0D[LORIDFLDO GHO &RPSOHMR +RVSLWDODULR 8QLYHUVLWDULRGH$&RUXxD\D'-RVHS5XELR3DODXGHO6HUYLFLRGH&LUXJtD0D[LORIDFLDO GHO +RVSLWDO &OLQLF L 3URYLQFLDO GH %DUFHORQD VX FRODERUDFLyQ GHVLQWHUHVDGD \ ORV FRPHQWDULRVDSRUWDGRV (O FRQWHQLGR GHO SUHVHQWH LQIRUPH HV UHVSRQVDELOLGDG H[FOXVLYD GH OD $[HQFLD GH $YDOLDFLyQGH7HFQROR[tDV6DQLWDULDVGH*DOLFLDVLQTXHODFRODERUDFLyQGHORVUHYLVRUHV H[WHUQRVSUHVXSRQJDSRUVXSDUWHODFRPSOHWDDFHSWDFLyQGHOPLVPR (O SUHVHQWH LQIRUPH HV SURSLHGDG GH OD $[HQFLD GH $YDOLDFLyQ GH 7HFQROR[tDV 6DQLWDULDVGH*DOLFLD(VWHGRFXPHQWRSXHGHVHUUHSURGXFLGRSDUFLDORWRWDOPHQWH SDUDXVRQRFRPHUFLDOVLHPSUHTXHVHFLWHH[SOtFLWDPHQWHVXSURFHGHQFLD 'HFODUDFLyQGHLQWHUHVHVHODXWRUGHFODUDODQRH[LVWHQFLDGHFRQIOLFWRVGHLQWHUpV HQODHODERUDFLyQGHHVWHLQIRUPH $[HQFLDGH$YDOLDFLyQGH7HFQROR[tDV6DQLWDULDVGH*DOLFLDDYDOLDW 'LUHFFLyQ;HUDOGH,QQRYDFLyQH;HVWLyQGD6D~GH3~EOLFD &6DQ/i]DURVQ 6DQWLDJRGH&RPSRVWHOD 7HOpIRQR)D[ 'LUHFFLyQHOHFWUyQLFDKWWSDYDOLDWVHUJDVHV &RUUHRHOHFWUyQLFRDYDOLDW#VHUJDVHV 'HSyVLWR/HJDO& 3XEOLFDFLyQH[FOXVLYDHQLQWHUQHW $;(1&,$'($9$/,$&,Ð1'(7(&12/2;Ì$66$1,7$5,$6'(*$/,&,$ ,QGLFH Ì1',&( /,67$'(7$%/$6 /,67$'(),*85$6 5(680(1 6800$5< ,1752'8&&,Ð1 $1$720Ì$'(/$6*/É1'8/$66$/,9$/(6 (3,'(0,2/2*Ì$<(7,23$72*(1,$ ',$*1Ð67,&2 75$7$0,(172 7UDWDPLHQWRTXLU~UJLFR 6LDOROLWRWULFLDH[WHUQDPHGLDQWHRQGDVGHFKRTXH 6LDOROLWRWULFLDLQWUDFRUSyUHDPHGLDQWHRQGDVGHFKRTXH 5DGLRORJtDLQWHUYHQFLRQLVWD 6,$/2(1'26&23,$ 5 5 7 9 11 11 12 13 14 14 14 15 15 15 2%-(7,92 19 0e72'26 21 5(68/7$'26 5(9,6,Ð1'(/$/,7(5$785$ &5,7(5,26'(6(/(&&,Ð1'(/26$57Ì&8/26 (;75$&&,Ð1'('$7266Ì17(6,6'(/$,1)250$&,Ð1<&/$6,),&$&,Ð1'(/26(678',26 5(68/7$'26'(/$%Ô648('$<6(/(&&,Ð1'((678',26 &$5$&7(5Ì67,&$6*(1(5$/(6'(/26(678',26 ()(&7,9,'$'<6(*85,'$''(/$7e&1,&$ ',6&86,Ð1 0(72'2/2*Ì$'(/26(678',26</,0,7$&,21(6 3$3(/'(/$6,$/2(1'26&23,$(1(/75$7$0,(172'(/$3$72/2*Ì$2%6758&7,9$6$/,9$/ ,1',&$&,21(6'(/$7e&1,&$&267(<&859$'($35(1',=$-( 21 22 22 23 23 23 24 35 35 35 39 &21&/86,21(6 43 $1(;26 45 $1(;2(675$7(*,$6'(%Ô648('$%,%/,2*5É),&$ $1(;21,9(/(6'((9,'(1&,$'(/6,*1 $1(;2(678',26(;&/8,'26 %,%/,2*5$)Ì$ 45 47 49 51 /$6,$/2(1'26&23,$(1(/75$7$0,(172'(/26352&(6266$/,9$/(62%6758&7,926 /LVWDGHWDEODV\ILJXUDV /,67$'(7$%/$6 7DEOD&ULWHULRVGHLQFOXVLyQ\H[FOXVLyQGHHVWXGLRV 7DEOD 3RUFHQWDMH GH UHVROXFLyQ GH OD REVWUXFFLyQ VDOLYDO WUDV VLDORHQGRVFRSLD FRQ \ VLQDERUGDMHTXLU~UJLFR /,67$'(),*85$6 )LJXUD$QDWRPtDGHODVJOiQGXODVVDOLYDOHV\VXVFRQGXFWRV )LJXUD6LDORHQGRVFRSLR )LJXUD&HVWDGH'RUPLDDELHUWD )LJXUD'LDJUDPDGHIOXMRGHORVHVWXGLRVLQFOXLGRVHQODUHYLVLyQ )LJXUD$QiOLVLVFRQMXQWRGHODSURSRUFLyQGHp[LWRWUDVVLDORHQGRVFRSLD )LJXUD$QiOLVLVFRQMXQWRGHODSURSRUFLyQGHp[LWRWUDVWpFQLFDFRPELQDGD /$6,$/2(1'26&23,$(1(/75$7$0,(172'(/26352&(6266$/,9$/(62%6758&7,926 5HVXPHQ 5(680(1 ,QWURGXFFLyQ /D VLDORHQGRVFRSLD HV XQD WpFQLFD GLDJQyVWLFRWHUDSpXWLFD PtQLPDPHQWH LQYDVLYD TXH SHUPLWH OD YLVXDOL]DFLyQGLUHFWDGHOFRQGXFWR VDOLYDO PHGLDQWH OD LQWURGXFFLyQ GH XQ HQGRVFRSLR GH SHTXHxR FDOLEUH ,QLFLDOPHQWH XWLOL]DGD FRQ SURSyVLWR GLDJQyVWLFR HQ OD DFWXDOLGDG VH UHDOL]D FRQ ILQHV WHUDSpXWLFRVSDUDHOWUDWDPLHQWRGHODSDWRORJtDVDOLYDOREVWUXFWLYD 2EMHWLYR(YDOXDUODHIHFWLYLGDG\VHJXULGDGGHODVLDORHQGRFRSLDFRPRWpFQLFD GLDJQyVWLFDWHUDSpXWLFDHQHOPDQHMRGHSURFHVRVVDOLYDOHVREVWUXFWLYRV 0pWRGRV6HUHDOL]yXQDE~VTXHGDGHODOLWHUDWXUDFLHQWtILFDVLQOtPLWHWHPSRUDO \ KDVWD DEULO GH HQ ODV EDVHV GH GDWRV 0HGOLQH (PEDVH +7$ '$5( 1+6((' &RFKUDQH 'DWDEDVH ,0( ,%(&6 ,6, :HE RI .QRZOHGJH 5HFROHFWD 'LDOQHW \ HQVD\RV FOtQLFRV HQ PDUFKD 'H ORV DUWtFXORV UHVXOWDQWHV VH VHOHFFLRQDURQ ~QLFDPHQWH DTXHOORV TXH FXPSOLHURQ ORV FULWHULRV GH VHOHFFLyQ SURFHGLpQGRVH SRVWHULRUPHQWH D OD H[WUDFFLyQ GH GDWRV \ D XQD VtQWHVLV GH OD HYLGHQFLD /RV HVWXGLRV VH FODVLILFDURQ VHJ~Q VX FDOLGDG PHWRGROyJLFD GH DFXHUGRFRQODHVFDODGHO6,*1 5HVXOWDGRV\GLVFXVLyQ 6H LQFOX\HURQ HVWXGLRV WRGRV HOORV VHULHV GH FDVRV GH WLSR SURVSHFWLYR \ UHWURVSHFWLYR DOJXQRV GH HOORV FRQ OLPLWDFLRQHV PHWRGROyJLFDV TXH SRGUtDQ DIHFWDUDORVUHVXOWDGRVGHHIHFWLYLGDG\VHJXULGDG(ODQiOLVLVFRQMXQWRGHORV HVWXGLRVHQORVTXHODWpFQLFDGHVLDORHQGRVFRSLDVHUHDOL]yGHIRUPD~QLFD SURFHGLPLHQWRVPXHVWUDXQDHIHFWLYLGDGGHUHVROXFLyQGHODREVWUXFFLyQVDOLYDO GHO PLHQWUDV TXH FRQ OD WpFQLFD FRPELQDGD UHDOL]DGD HQ HVWXGLRV FRQ FDVL VLDORHQGRVFRSLDV IXH GHO (Q HO FDVR GH OD VLDOROLWLDVLV H[LVWHQ OLPLWDFLRQHV DO WDPDxR GH ORV FiOFXORV VDOLYDOHV TXH SXHGHQ VHU H[WUDtGRV PHGLDQWH SLQ]DV R FHVWLOODV VLHQGR GH KDVWD GH PP HQ HO FDVR GH JOiQGXODV VXEPDQGLEXODUHV \ GH PP HQ SDUyWLGDV (Q WDPDxRV VXSHULRUHV SXHGHQ VHU QHFHVDULDV WpFQLFDV DOWHUQDWLYDV FRPR OD OLWRWULFLD LQWUD R H[WUDFRUSyUHD OD FLUXJtD WUDQVRUDO \ OD FLUXJtD WUDQVRUDO DVLVWLGD SRU HQGRVFRSLD /D VLDORHQGRVFRSLD VH UHDOL]D JHQHUDOPHQWH GH IRUPD DPEXODWRULD FRQ DQHVWHVLD ORFDO HQ OD GLDJQyVWLFD \ FRQ VHGDFLyQ R DQHVWHVLD JHQHUDO HQ OD WHUDSpXWLFD &RPR FXDOTXLHU WpFQLFD LQWHUYHQFLRQLVWD OD VLDORHQGRVFRSLD WLHQH XQDFXUYD GH DSUHQGL]DMHTXHSRGUtDRVFLODUHQWUHORV\SURFHGLPLHQWRV &RQFOXVLRQHV /D HYLGHQFLD FLHQWtILFD GLVSRQLEOH DFHUFD GH OD HIHFWLYLGDG \ VHJXULGDGGHODVLDORHQGRVFRSLDVHEDVDHQHVWXGLRVREVHUYDFLRQDOHVDOJXQRVGH HOORV FRQ OLPLWDFLRQHV PHWRGROyJLFDV $ SHVDU GH HOOR ORV UHVXOWDGRV VRQ FRQVLVWHQWHV UHVSHFWR GH OD HIHFWLYLGDG GH OD WpFQLFD D OD KRUD GH UHVROYHU OD REVWUXFFLyQVDOLYDOVLHQGRGHOFXDQGRVHXWLOL]DVRODRGHOVLVHUHDOL]D GH IRUPD FRPELQDGD $GHPiV OD VLDORHQGRVFRSLD GLVPLQX\H GH IRUPD LPSRUWDQWH HO Q~PHUR GH VLDORDGHQHFWRPtDV UHDOL]DGDV VLHQGR VXV HIHFWRV DGYHUVRV SRFR IUHFXHQWHV \ GH EDMD JUDYHGDG 6XV SULQFLSDOHV LQGLFDFLRQHV VRQ VLDOROLWLDVLV VLDORDGHQLWLV UHFXUUHQWH FUyQLFD SDURWLGLWLV UHFXUUHQWH MXYHQLO VLDORDGHQLWLVLQGXFLGDSRULRGRUDGLRDFWLYR\HVWHQRVLVSRUVtQGURPHGH6M|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ÌQGLFH 0pGLFR (VSDxRO ,QGLFH %LEOLRJUiILFR(VSDx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|JUHQ VV\QGURPH /$6,$/2(1'26&23,$(1(/75$7$0,(172'(/26352&(6266$/,9$/(62%6758&7,926 ,QWURGXFFLyQ ,1752'8&&,Ð1 /DVLDORDGHQLWLVHVXQWUDVWRUQRFRP~QTXHFXUVDFRQGRORUHLQIODPDFLyQ GH OD JOiQGXOD VDOLYDO DIHFWDGD \ TXH SXHGH SURJUHVDU RFDVLRQDOPHQWH D LQIHFFLyQFUyQLFD\IRUPDFLyQGHDEFHVRV3XHGHVHUGHELGDDP~OWLSOHVFDXVDV LQFOX\HQGR FiOFXORV HVWHQRVLV SRU WHMLGR FRQHFWLYR LQWUDGXFWDO WUDVWRUQRV DOpUJLFRV GHVKLGUDWDFLyQ HIHFWR DGYHUVR GH IiUPDFRV HQIHUPHGDGHV DXWRLQPXQHV \ PiV UDUDPHQWH WXPRUHV 7DPELpQ HVWiQ HQ ULHVJR DTXHOORV SDFLHQWHVDWUDWDPLHQWRFRQLRGRUDGLRDFWLYRGHELGRDFiQFHUWLURLGHRGHELGRD TXHODH[FUHFLyQGXFWDOGHOLRGRSXHGHSURYRFDULQIODPDFLyQ\ILEURVLV /D OLWLDVLV VDOLYDO R VLDOROLWLDVLV FRQVLVWH HQ OD SUHVHQFLD GH FiOFXORV R VLDOROLWRV HQ ODV JOiQGXODV VDOLYDOHV (VWDV FRQFUHFLRQHV KDELWXDOPHQWH GH VDOHV PLQHUDOHVGHFDOFLRSXHGHQSURGXFLUREVWUXFFLyQPHFiQLFDGHODJOiQGXODVDOLYDO RGHVXFRQGXFWRH[FUHWRUFRQLQIODPDFLyQORFDO\GRORUGXUDQWHODPDVWLFDFLyQ PRPHQWRHQHOTXHVHLQFUHPHQWDODSURGXFFLyQGHVDOLYD /DV HVWHQRVLV GXFWDOHV SXHGHQ VHU ORFDOL]DGDV R GLIXVDV \ VH REVHUYDQ SULQFLSDOPHQWHHQODSDURWLGLWLVMXYHQLOUHFXUUHQWHHQHOVtQGURPHGH6M|JUHQ\ HQ OD VLDORDGHQLWLV LQGXFLGD SRU UDGLDFLyQ \D VHD GHVSXpV GH UDGLRWHUDSLD H[WHUQD R FRPR HIHFWR DGYHUVR GHO WUDWDPLHQWR FRQ LRGR UDGLRDFWLYR SDUD HO FDUFLQRPD GH WLURLGHV DXQTXH H[LVWH XQ SRUFHQWDMH HQ HO TXH VX FDXVD HV GHVFRQRFLGD $QDWRPtDGHODVJOiQGXODVVDOLYDOHV 'HDFXHUGRDVXWDPDxRHLPSRUWDQFLDIXQFLRQDOODVJOiQGXODVVDOLYDOHVVH GLYLGHQ HQ PD\RUHV R SULQFLSDOHV SDUyWLGD VXEPDQGLEXODU \ VXEOLQJXDO \ PHQRUHVRVHFXQGDULDVILJXUD Figura 1$QDWRPtDGHODVJOiQGXODVVDOLYDOHV\VXVFRQGXFWRV )XHQWH7RPDGRGH)D]LRHWDO /$6,$/2(1'26&23,$(1(/75$7$0,(172'(/26352&(6266$/,9$/(62%6758&7,926 DYDOLDW &RQVXOWD7pFQLFD • *OiQGXOD SDUyWLGD VH ORFDOL]D ELODWHUDOPHQWH HQ OD IRVD UHWURPDQGLEXODU SRUGHEDMRGHOFRQGXFWRDXGLWLYRH[WHUQRSRUGHWUiVGHODUDPDDVFHQGHQWH GHO PD[LODU LQIHULRU \ SRU GHODQWH GH OD DSyILVLV PDVWRLGHV \ GHO P~VFXOR HVWHUQRFOHLGRPDVWRLGHR /D JOiQGXOD SHVD DOUHGHGRU GH JUDPRV \ OD DWUDYLHVDQ HVWUXFWXUDV LPSRUWDQWHV HO QHUYLR IDFLDO OD YHQD UHWURPDQGLEXODU \ OD DUWHULD FDUyWLGD H[WHUQD \ HO LQLFLR GH VXV UDPDV WHUPLQDOHV (O FRQGXFWR GH 6WHQRQ PLGH FP GH ORQJLWXG \ PP GH GLiPHWURPHGLR\VHRULJLQDHQODFDUDDQWHULRUGHODJOiQGXOD\VHDFRPSDxD HQ VX UHFRUULGR GH UDPDV GHO QHUYLR IDFLDO \ GH OD DUWHULD WUDQVYHUVDO GH OD FDUD • *OiQGXOD VXEPDQGLEXODURVXEPD[LODU HV XQDJOiQGXOD VDOLYDOGH IRUPD LUUHJXODUFRQXQWDPDxRSDUHFLGRDOGHXQDQXH]\XQSHVRDOUHGHGRUGHORV JU 6H DORMD ELODWHUDOPHQWH HQ OD FHOGD VXEPD[LODU ORFDOL]DGD HQ OD SDUWH SRVWHULRUGHOVXHORGHODERFD(OFRQGXFWRGH:KDUWRQVDOHGHOD]RQDPHGLD GHODJOiQGXOD\WLHQHFPGHORQJLWXG\PPGHGLiPHWUR3HQHWUDHQHO KLDWR VXEPD[LODU DFRPSDxDGR SRU XQ YDVR YHQRVR \ ORV QHUYLRV KLSRJORVR \ OLQJXDO • *OiQGXODVXEOLQJXDOHVODPiVDQWHULRU\SHTXHxDGHODVJOiQGXODVVDOLYDOHV PD\RUHV\VHVLW~DHQHOVXHORGHODERFDSRUGHEDMRGHODPXFRVDEXFDO\D FDGD ODGR GHO IUHQLOOR OLQJXDO 5HVXOWD GH OD XQLyQGHXQD SHTXHxD VHULH GH JOiQGXODV \ VX SHVR QR H[FHGH ORV JU ([LVWHQ GH D FRQGXFWRV VXEOLQJXDOHV PHQRUHV GH :DOWKHU TXH GHVHPERFDQ HQ SDSLODV VLWXDGDV HQ ORVSOLHJXHVVXEOLQJXDOHV(OPiVYROXPLQRVR\DYHFHV~QLFRHVHOFRQGXFWR VXEOLQJXDO PD\RU GH 5LYLQXV R %DUWKROLQR TXH VH DEUH HQ HO VXHOR GH OD ERFD • *OiQGXODVVDOLYDOHVPHQRUHVVRQSHTXHxDV\QXPHURVDV\VHGLVWULEX\HQHQ OD PXFRVD \ VXEPXFRVD GH OD FDYLGDG RUDO 6HJ~Q VX ORFDOL]DFLyQ VH GHQRPLQDQODELDOHVEXFDOHVPRODUHVSDODWLQDVJORVRSDODWLQDV\OLQJXDOHV • &RQGXFWRVVDOLYDOHVHOGLiPHWURGHORVFRQGXFWRVRVFLODHQWUH\PP VHJ~QHOWLSRGHJOiQGXOD(QODJOiQGXODVXEPDQGLEXODUHORVWLXPHVGH PP \ HO FRQGXFWR GH PP (Q OD SDUyWLGD HO RVWLXP HV GH PP \ HO FRQGXFWRGHPPPPDQLYHOGHOP~VFXOREXFFLQDGRU (SLGHPLRORJtD\HWLRSDWRJHQLD /D VLDOROLWLDVLV HV OD SULQFLSDO FDXVD GH ODV HQIHUPHGDGHV VDOLYDOHV REVWUXFWLYDV HVWDQGR LQYROXFUDGD HQ HO GH ORV FDVRV \ MXVWLILFDQGR DOUHGHGRU GHO GH OD SDWRORJtD GH ODV JOiQGXODV VDOLYDOHV SULQFLSDOHV (VWXGLRVSRVWPRUWHPPXHVWUDQXQDSUHYDOHQFLDGHFiOFXORVVDOLYDOHVHQHO GH OD SREODFLyQ JHQHUDO DXQTXH OD LQFLGHQFLD GH FiOFXORV VDOLYDOHV VLQWRPiWLFRV VH KD HVWLPDGR HQ FDVRV SRU PLOOyQ \ DxR FRQ XQD SUHYDOHQFLDFOtQLFDGHO (VPiVIUHFXHQWHHQYDURQHVFRQSLFRVGHLQFLGHQFLDHQWUHORV\ORV DxRVVLHQGRUDUDHQQLxRVFRQVyORXQGHORVFDVRVHQJUXSRGHSREODFLyQ $;(1&,$'($9$/,$&,Ð1'(7(&12/2;Ì$66$1,7$5,$6'(*$/,&,$ ,QWURGXFFLyQ /D VLDOROLWLDVLV DIHFWD HQ XQ GH ORV FDVRV D OD JOiQGXOD VXEPDQGLEXODU \ JHQHUDOPHQWH GH IRUPD XQLODWHUDO VLQ SUHIHUHQFLD SRU XQ GHWHUPLQDGRODGR(OWDPDxRPHGLRGHORVFiOFXORVVXEPDQGLEXODUHVHVGH PP DXQTXH VH KDQ GHVFULWR VLDOROLWRV JLJDQWHV /D PD\RUtD GH ORV FiOFXORV VH ORFDOL]DQ HQ HO WHUFLR GLVWDO GHO FRQGXFWR D QLYHO GHO KLOLR GH OD JOiQGXOD (O GH ORV FDVRV RFXUUHQ HQ OD JOiQGXOD SDUyWLGD \ HO UHVWDQWHHQODVJOiQGXODVVDOLYDOHVPHQRUHV /RV IDFWRUHV HWLRSDWRJpQLFRV WUDGLFLRQDOHV DVRFLDGRV D OD IRUPDFLyQ GH FiOFXORVVRQODREVWUXFFLyQODUHGXFFLyQGHOIOXMRVDOLYDOGHVKLGUDWDFLyQFDPELR HQHOS+VDOLYDODVRFLDGRFRQLQIHFFLyQRURIDUtQJHD\GHWHULRURODGHVROXELOLGDG GHORVFULVWDORLGHV$GHPiVGHODVKLSyWHVLVFOiVLFDV0DUFKDOHWDOKDQ VXJHULGRODWHRUtDUHWUyJUDGDGHODOLWRJpQHVLVSRUODTXHODPLJUDFLyQGHVGHOD FDYLGDG RUDO D ORV FRQGXFWRV GH ODV JOiQGXODV GH UHVWRV GH FRPLGD EDFWHULDV R FXHUSRVH[WUDxRVIDFLOLWDUtDQODIRUPDFLyQGHFiOFXORV 'LDJQyVWLFR (OGLDJQyVWLFRGHODVLDOROLWLDVLVVHSXHGHUHDOL]DUPHGLDQWHXQDUDGLRJUDItD HVWiQGDUDXQTXHHQHOGHORVFDVRVQRUHYHODFiOFXORVUDGLROXFLHQWHV LQWUDJODQGXODUHV R GH SHTXHxR WDPDxR 3RU VX SDUWH OD WRPRJUDItD D[LDO FRPSXWDUL]DGD HVWi OLPLWDGD SRU HO KHFKR GH TXH ORV FiOFXORV SXHGHQ TXHGDU RFXOWRV VL ORV FRUWHV WRPRJUiILFRV VRQ DQFKRV \ TXH SXHGH QR SUHFLVDU OD ORFDOL]DFLyQGHVLDOROLWRVHQORVFRQGXFWRV5HFLHQWHPHQWHVHKDLQWURGXFLGR ODWRPRJUDItDFRPSXWDUL]DGDGHKD]FyQLFR&%&7TXHLPSOLFDXQDPHQRUGRVLV GHUDGLDFLyQSDUDHOSDFLHQWH/DXOWUDVRQRJUDItDUHSUHVHQWDHQODDFWXDOLGDGXQD H[FHOHQWH WpFQLFD GLDJQyVWLFD GH SULPHU QLYHO \ HQ PDQRV H[SHUWDV SXHGH GHWHFWDUFiOFXORVGXFWDOHVGHDOPHQRVPPFRQXQDSUHFLVLyQGH/D HFRJUDItDGRSSOHUHQFRORUWDPELpQVHKDFRQVLGHUDGR~WLOHQSDFLHQWHVFRQHVWD SDWRORJtD 5HFLHQWHV DYDQFHV HQ WHFQRORJtD ySWLFD KDQ OOHYDGR DO GHVDUUROOR GH OD VLDORHQGRVFRSLD XQ QXHYR PHGLR GH GLDJQyVWLFR GH YLVXDOL]DFLyQ GLUHFWD GH FiOFXORV LQWUDGXFWDOHV TXH KD WHQGLGR XQ SXHQWH HQWUH HO GLDJQyVWLFR GH VRVSHFKD FOtQLFD GH REVWUXFFLyQ VDOLYDO \ ODV OLPLWDFLRQHV GH OD UDGLRORJtD FRQYHQFLRQDO/DPLQLDWXUL]DFLyQGHOLQVWUXPHQWDODFRUGHDOGLiPHWURPHGLRGH ORV FRQGXFWRV H[FUHWRUHV GH ODV JOiQGXODV VDOLYDOHV PD\RUHV SHUPLWH XQD H[SORUDFLyQFDVLFRPSOHWDGHOVLVWHPDGXFWDOGHODPD\RUtDGHORVSDFLHQWHVQRV UHIHULUHPRVDHOODHQXQDSDUWDGRHVSHFtILFR /DV HVWHQRVLV GHO FRQGXFWR VDOLYDO HV OD VHJXQGD FDXVD PiV IUHFXHQWH GH VLDORDGHQLWLVREVWUXFWLYD\DGLIHUHQFLDGHODVLDOROLWLDVLVDIHFWDFRQIUHFXHQFLD DOVLVWHPDGXFWDOGHODSDUyWLGD\SULQFLSDOPHQWHDPXMHUHV*HQHUDOPHQWH VRQ UHVXOWDGR GH OHVLRQHV GHO HSLWHOLR GXFWDO VHFXQGDULDV D LQIHFFLRQHV UHFXUUHQWHV R WUDXPDV FDXVDGRV SRU VLDOROLWRV R SURFHGLPLHQWRV TXLU~UJLFRV DXQTXHWDPELpQVHKDQGHVFULWRHVWHQRVLVFRQJpQLWDV/RVKDOOD]JRVGH OD VLDORJUDItD LQGLFDQ TXH OD HVWHQRVLV GHO FRQGXFWR VDOLYDO UHSUHVHQWD HQWUH XQ GHORVFDVRVGHLQIODPDFLyQUHFXUUHQWHGHODSDUyWLGD\GHO HQHOFDVRGHODJOiQGXODVXEPDQGLEXODU /$6,$/2(1'26&23,$(1(/75$7$0,(172'(/26352&(6266$/,9$/(62%6758&7,926 DYDOLDW &RQVXOWD7pFQLFD /D VLDORJUDItD HV HO PpWRGR GLDJQyVWLFR KDELWXDO GH ODV HVWHQRVLV GH FRQGXFWRVLHQGRFRQVLGHUDGDHO´SDWUyQRURµ$XQTXHHOVLDOR7$&KDVLGR WDPELpQSURSXHVWRSDUDHOGLDJQyVWLFRGHDQRPDOtDVGHOVLVWHPDGXFWDOSUHVHQWD XQDVHULHGHOLPLWDFLRQHV/DVLDORJUDItDPHGLDQWH501KDVLGRLQWURGXFLGD UHFLHQWHPHQWH FRPR PHGLR GLDJQyVWLFR GH ODV HVWHQRVLV GHO VLVWHPD GXFWDO \ SUHVHQWD ODV YHQWDMDV GH TXH QR SUHFLVD FRQWUDVWH UDGLROyJLFR QL FDQXODFLyQ GXFWDO QR LUUDGLD DO SDFLHQWH \ SXHGH VHU UHDOL]DGD FRQ LQIHFFLyQ DJXGD GH OD JOiQGXOD 7UDWDPLHQWR 7UDWDPLHQWRTXLU~UJLFR (OWUDWDPLHQWRTXLU~UJLFRGHORVWUDVWRUQRVVDOLYDOHVREVWUXFWLYRVFRQVLVWH HQXQDGLODWDFLyQGXFWDOFRQLQFLVLyQ\GLVHFFLyQHQHOFDVRGHFiOFXORVGLVWDOHV DOJXQDV YHFHV VHJXLGR GH PDUVXSLDOL]DFLyQ FRQ HO ULHVJR GH HVWHQRVLV SRVWRSHUDWRULD R GH VLDORDGHQHFWRPtD HQ HO FDVR GH VLDOROLWRV SUR[LPDOHV KLOLDUHVRLQWUDSDUHQTXLPDWRVRV /D VLDORDGHQHFWRPtD FRQWLQ~D VLHQGR OD SULQFLSDO LQGLFDFLyQ SDUD OD VLDOROLWLDVLVDSHVDUGHSUHVHQWDUFRPSOLFDFLRQHVSRVWRSHUDWRULDVIUHFXHQWHVTXH LQFOX\HQOHVLRQHVQHUYLRVDVVtQWRPDVUHFXUUHQWHVGHELGRDFiOFXORVUHWHQLGRVHQ HOFRQGXFWR\UHVXOWDGRVHVWpWLFRVQRVDWLVIDFWRULRV (Q HO FDVR GH FiOFXORV HQ OD JOiQGXOD SDUyWLGD OD SDURWLGHFWRPtD WRWDO FRQVHUYDGRUDVHFRQVLGHUDODPHMRURSFLyQTXHODSDURWLGHFWRPtDVXSHUILFLDOFRQ HO ILQ GH HYLWDU UHFXUUHQFLDV 7UDV XQD SDURWLGHFWRPtD ODV SULQFLSDOHV FRPSOLFDFLRQHV VRQ OD SDUiOLVLV SHUPDQHQWH GHO QHUYLR IDFLDO SpUGLGD VHQVLWLYDHQODGLVWULEXFLyQGHOQHUYLRDXULFXODU\VtQGURPHGH)UH\ 7UDVXQDUHVHFFLyQGHODJOiQGXODVXEPDQGLEXODUH[LVWHULHVJRGHSDUiOLVLV SHUPDQHQWH GH OD UDPD PDQGLEXODU PDUJLQDO GH OHVLyQ GHO QHUYLR KLSRJORVRRGHOQHUYLROLQJXDO2WUDVSRVLEOHVFRPSOLFDFLRQHVLQFOX\HQ VHFXHODV HVWpWLFDV ItVWXODV VDOLYDOHV VLDORFHOHV KHPDWRPDV H LQIHFFLyQ GH OD KHULGD (Q ODV DQRPDOtDV GXFWDOHV HO WUDWDPLHQWR KDELWXDO HV OD GHULYDFLyQ TXLU~UJLFD GHO IOXMR VDOLYDO FRQ OD FUHDFLyQ GH XQ QXHYR FRQGXFWR H[FUHWRU SUR[LPDODODHVWHQRVLVRVLDORGRFRSODVWLD 6LDOROLWRWULFLDH[WHUQDPHGLDQWHRQGDVGHFKRTXH /D VLDOROLWRWULFLD HV XQ PpWRGR QR LQYDVLYR GH IUDJPHQWDFLyQ GH FiOFXORV VDOLYDOHV FRQ HO ILQ GH IDYRUHFHU VX VDOLGD HVSRQWiQHD D WUDYpV GHO FRQGXFWR VDOLYDO R SRU OD LQGXFFLyQ GH OD VDOLYDFLyQ PHGLDQWH iFLGR FtWULFR X RWURV VLDODJRJRV /DV RQGDV GH FKRTXH SXHGHQ VHU GH RULJHQ SLH]RHOpFWULFR R JHQHUDGDV SRU WpFQLFDV HOHFWURPDJQpWLFDV &RQ OD OLWRWULFLD SLH]RHOpFWULFD ,URHWDOKDQGRFXPHQWDGRODGHVDSDULFLyQGHFiOFXORVHQXQGHORV FDVRV\DOLYLRGHORVVtQWRPDVHQXQ(QODOLWRWULFLDHOHFWURPDJQpWLFDOD IUHFXHQFLDGHORVSXOVRVRVFLODHQWUH\KHUFLRV\SRUVHVLyQVHDGPLQLVWUDQ QR PiV GH RQGDV GH FKRTXH /D PRQLWRUL]DFLyQ XOWUDVRQRJUiILFD FRQWLQXD $;(1&,$'($9$/,$&,Ð1'(7(&12/2;Ì$66$1,7$5,$6'(*$/,&,$ ,QWURGXFFLyQ SHUPLWH OD YLVXDOL]DFLyQ GLUHFWD GHO JUDGR GH IUDJPHQWDFLyQ GXUDQWH HO WUDWDPLHQWR\HYLWDUOHVLRQHVHQHOWHMLGRFLUFXQGDQWH 6LDOROLWRWULFLDLQWUDFRUSyUHDPHGLDQWHRQGDVGHFKRTXH (QHVWDPRGDOLGDGODVRQGDVGHFKRTXHDOFDQ]DQODVXSHUILFLHGHOFiOFXOR D WUDYpV GH XQD VRQGD GH OLWRWULFLD FRORFDGD HQ HO LQWHULRU GHO FRQGXFWR VDOLYDO EDMRJXtDHQGRVFySLFD 5DGLRORJtDLQWHUYHQFLRQLVWD 8WLOL]DYDULDVWpFQLFDVSDUDODH[WUDFFLyQRHOLPLQDFLyQGHFiOFXORVWDQWR GHSDUyWLGDFRPRVXEPDQGLEXODUHVLQFOX\HQGRHOXVRGHEDORQHVGHDQJLRSODVWLD FRURQDULD H[WUDFWRUHV KHOLFRLGDOHV R FDWpWHUHV GH HPEROHFWRPtD EDMR FRQWURO IOXRURVFySLFR $FWXDOPHQWH OD H[WUDFFLyQ GH FiOFXORV PHGLDQWH JXtD IOXRURVFySLFD VH FRQVLGHUD OD PHMRU RSFLyQ WHUDSpXWLFD HQ UDGLRORJtD LQWHUYHQFLRQLVWD \ HVWi LQGLFDGD HQ FiOFXORV PyYLOHV VLWXDGRV HQ ODV SRUFLRQHV PHGLD \ SUR[LPDO GHO VLVWHPD GXFWDO VXEPDQGLEXODU \ HQ FiOFXORV GHO FRQGXFWR SDURWtGHR /RV SRUFHQWDMHV RVFLODQ HQWUH HO \ HO \ ORV IUDFDVRVHVWiQUHODFLRQDGRVFRQODQRLGHQWLILFDFLyQGHOFiOFXOR\ODSUHVHQFLDGH FiOFXORV ILMRV R LQDOFDQ]DEOHV /DV SULQFLSDOHV FRPSOLFDFLRQHV GHVFULWDV LQFOX\HQLQIODPDFLyQJODQGXODUHLQIHFFLRQHV 6LDORHQGRVFRSLD 3HUPLWH OD YLVXDOL]DFLyQ GLUHFWD GHO FRQGXFWR VDOLYDO PHGLDQWH OD LQWURGXFFLyQ GH XQ HQGRVFRSLR GH SHTXHxR FDOLEUH D WUDYpV GHO FRQGXFWR H[FUHWRUGHODJOiQGXODVDOLYDO,QLFLDOPHQWHXWLOL]DGDFRQSURSyVLWRGLDJQyVWLFR HQ OD DFWXDOLGDG HV UHDOL]DGD FRQ ILQHV WHUDSpXWLFRV HQ FDVRV GH SURFHVRV VDOLYDOHV REVWUXFWLYRV 6H XWLOL]D GH IRUPD KDELWXDO HQ VLDOROLWLDVLV SULQFLSDOPHQWHVLODXELFDFLyQGHOFiOFXORHVWiHQHVWUHFKDUHODFLyQFRQHOQHUYLR OLQJXDO HQ HVWHQRVLV YLVLEOHV SRU XOWUDVRQLGRV R VLDORJUDItD \ HQ LQIODPDFLRQHV UHFXUUHQWHV /DWpFQLFDIXHGHVFULWDSRUSULPHUDYH]HQSRU.DW]TXHXWLOL]y XQ HQGRVFRSLR IOH[LEOH GH PP GH GLiPHWUR SDUD H[WUDHU FiOFXORV VDOLYDUHV 'HVGH HQWRQFHV VH KDQ GHVDUUROODGR VLDORHQGRVFRSLRV UtJLGRV VHPLUUtJLGRV \ IOH[LEOHV GH GLIHUHQWHV GLiPHWURV \ HTXLSDGRV FRQ FDQDOHV GH WUDEDMR H LUULJDFLyQ'HDFXHUGRFRQHVWXGLRVDQDWyPLFRVHOFDOLEUHQRGHEHVHUPD\RUGH PPSDUDHYLWDUODQHFHVLGDGGHXQDLQFLVLyQSUHYLDGHOFRQGXFWR (QODDFWXDOLGDGORVVLDORHQGRVFRSLRVPiVXWLOL]DGRVVRQORVGHQRPLQDGRV ´DOOLQRQHµ TXH SXHGHQ VHU XWLOL]DGRV SDUD SURFHGLPLHQWRV GLDJQyVWLFRV R WHUDSpXWLFRVHOLPLQDQGRODQHFHVLGDGGHFDPELDUGHLQVWUXPHQWRFRPRRFXUUtD FRQORVVLDORHQGRVFRSLRVGHXVRP~OWLSOH/RVKD\GLVSRQLEOHVHQFXDWURWDPDxRV • GH PP SHUPLWH OD H[SORUDFLyQ GH FRQGXFWRV SHGLiWULFRV R FRQ HVWHQRVLV • GH PP SXHGH XWLOL]DUVH FRQ SURSyVLWR WDQWR GLDJQyVWLFR FRPR WHUDSpXWLFR\GLVSRQHGHXQFDQDOGHWUDEDMRGHPP /$6,$/2(1'26&23,$(1(/75$7$0,(172'(/26352&(6266$/,9$/(62%6758&7,926 DYDOLDW &RQVXOWD7pFQLFD • GH PP HV HO VLDORHQGRVFRSLR XQLYHUVDO \ SHUPLWH HQGRVFRSLDV GLDJQyVWLFDV \ WHUDSpXWLFDV GH FRQGXFWRV VXEPDQGLEXODUHV R SDURWtGHRV 6XFDQDOGHWUDEDMRGHPPSHUPLWHHOSDVRGHFHVWLOODVGHH[WUDFFLyQ GH FiOFXORV R ILEUDV GH OiVHU DXQTXH HV HVWUHFKR SDUD HO SDVR GH GLODWDGRUHVGHEDOyQRIyUFHSV • GHPPSHUPLWHHOXVRGHIyUFHSVDXQTXHSRGUtDQRVHUYLUHQHOFDVR GH FRQGXFWRV HVWHQRVDGRV R HQ JOiQGXODV SDUyWLGDV GHELGR D OD HVWUHFKD OX]GHOFRQGXFWRGH6WHQRQ (QORVVLDORHQGRVFRSLRVORVFDQDOHVGHWUDEDMRVRQGH\PP SDUDORVGLiPHWURVH[WHUQRVGH\PPUHVSHFWLYDPHQWHHOFDQDOGH LUULJDFLyQGHPPHQWRGRVHOORV/DORQJLWXGUHDOGHWUDEDMRHVGHFP\ SUHVHQWDQXQDDQJXODFLyQGLVWDOGH /D VLDORHQGRVFRSLD GLDJQyVWLFD VH UHDOL]D KDELWXDOPHQWH FRQ DQHVWHVLD ORFDO \ OD WHUDSpXWLFD FRQ DQHVWHVLD ORFDO R JHQHUDO (O LQVWUXPHQWDO VH FRPSRQH GH VRQGDV GH GLiPHWURV FUHFLHQWHV SLQ]DV GH GLVHFFLyQ WLMHUD DQJXODGD SLQ]DV GH ELRSVLD VLDORHQGRVFRSLR GH GRV FDQDOHV GH PP \ GH PP \ IXHQWH GH OX] (O SULPHU SDVR GHO SURFHGLPLHQWR HV GLODWDU HO FRQGXFWR SDUD LQWURGXFLU HO VLDORHQGRVFRSLR OR TXH VH SXHGH KDFHU PHGLDQWH FDWpWHUHV R VRQGDV ODFULPDOHV SDSLORWRPtD VLDOROLWRWRPtD DELHUWD R GLVHFFLyQ PLFURTXLU~UJLFD GH OD SRUFLyQ DQWHULRU GXFWDO /D GXUDFLyQ PHGLD GH OD VLDORHQGRVFRSLD GLDJQyVWLFD R WHUDSpXWLFD HV UHVSHFWLYDPHQWH GH \ PLQXWRV'XUDQWHHOSURFHGLPLHQWRHOOXPHQGXFWDOVHULHJDFRQXQDVROXFLyQ VDOLQD LVRWyQLFD FRQ HO ILQ GH PDQWHQHU OD GLODWDFLyQ \ SHUPLWLU HO DYDQFH GHO HQGRVFRSLR /D ~QLFD FRQWUDLQGLFDFLyQ DEVROXWD GHO SURFHGLPLHQWR HV OD REOLWHUDFLyQ FRPSOHWD GHO FRQGXFWR TXH OR KDFH LPSHQHWUDEOH \ ORV HIHFWRV DGYHUVRV PiV IUHFXHQWHVVRQLQIODPDFLyQJODQGXODUWUDQVLWRULDHVWHQRVLVGXFWDO R ODFHUDFLRQHV UHWHQFLyQ GH OD FHOGLOOD H[WUDFWRUD LQIHFFLRQHV SDUHVWHVLDWHPSRUDOGHOQHUYLROLQJXDOUiQXODLDWURJpQLFD \VDQJUDGR Figura 26LDORHQGRVFRSLR )XHQWH7RPDGR:LOVRQHWDO $;(1&,$'($9$/,$&,Ð1'(7(&12/2;Ì$66$1,7$5,$6'(*$/,&,$ ,QWURGXFFLyQ 6LDORHQGRVFRSLDWHUDSpXWLFDSDUDODVLDOROLWLDVLV 3DUD OD H[WUDFFLyQ R IUDFFLRQDPLHQWR GH FiOFXORV VH XWLOL]DQ SLQ]DV PLQLIyUFHSV FDWpWHUHVEDOyQ GH )RJDUW\ \ FHVWDV GH 'RUPLD FHVWDV IRUPDGDV SRU R PiV KLORV UHXWLOL]DEOHV \ FRQ GLVWLQWDV PRUIRORJtDV HQ VX H[WUHPR GLVWDO SDUD FDSWXUDU FiOFXORV R SDUD DFRSODUODV D XQ OLWRWULSWRU PHFiQLFR (VWRV GLVSRVLWLYRVSXHGHQLQWURGXFLUVHDWUDYpVGHOFDQDOGHWUDEDMRGHOHQGRVFRSLRR GHIRUPDSDUDOHODDOPLVPR/DVFHVWDVGH'RUPLDHVWiQGLVSRQLEOHVHQWDPDxRV GH\PP 3XHGH UHDOL]DUVH XQD VLDOROLWRWULFLD LQWUDFRUSyUHD PHGLDQWH RQGDV GH FKRTXH R OiVHU KROPLR SDUD IUDJPHQWDU HO FiOFXOR DQWHV GH XWLOL]DU SLQ]DV R FHVWLOODV H[WUDFWRUDV GH FiOFXORV GH 'RUPLD /RV SRUFHQWDMHV GH p[LWR GH HVWD WpFQLFD VRQ GHO SDUD FiOFXORV VXEPDQGLEXODUHV \ GHO SDUD FiOFXORV GH SDUyWLGD /D VLDORHQGRVFRSLD WDPELpQ HV HIHFWLYD SDUD H[WUDHU WDSRQHVGHPRFRFXHUSRVH[WUDxRVSyOLSRV\WHMLGRGHJUDQXODFLyQ Figura 3&HVWDGH'RUPLDDELHUWD )XHQWH7RPDGR:LOVRQHWDO $QWH OD H[LVWHQFLD GH JUDQGHV FiOFXORV SXHGH VHU QHFHVDULR UHDOL]DU XQD WpFQLFD FRPELQDGD TXH LQFOX\H XQD VLDORHQGRVFRSLD SDUD YLVXDOL]DFLyQ \ ORFDOL]DFLyQ GHO FiOFXOR VHJXLGD GH SDSLORWRPtD DSHUWXUD GHO GXFWR R LQFLVLyQ LQWUDRUDO R H[WHUQD VLQ HVFLVLyQ JODQGXODU FRQ SRVWHULRU UHSDUDFLyQ R PDUVXSLDOL]DFLyQGHOGXFWR 6LDORHQGRVFRSLDWHUDSpXWLFDSDUDODVHVWHQRVLVGXFWDOHV /DV HVWHQRVLV VRQ PiV FRPXQHV HQ OD JOiQGXOD SDUyWLGD (Q HVWHQRVLV GXFWDOHV SHTXHxDV PHQRUHV GH OD PLWDG GHO GLiPHWUR GHO FRQGXFWR OD XWLOL]DFLyQ GH VROXFLyQ VDOLQD D SUHVLyQ GXUDQWH OD VLDORHQGRVFRSLD HV JHQHUDOPHQWH VXILFLHQWH SDUD ORJUDU VX GLODWDFLyQ 6LQ HPEDUJR HQ ODV HVWHQRVLVJUDYHVHVQHFHVDULRLQVHUWDUXQFDWpWHUFRQXQEDOyQPHQRUGHPPGH GLiPHWUR H LQIODUOR GXUDQWH VHJXQGRV KDVWD XQ Pi[LPR GH PP SDUD SRVWHULRUPHQWH GHVLQIODUOR \ YROYHUOR D LQIODU (Q RFDVLRQHV VH XWLOL]D XQ FRUWLFRLGH LQWUDGXFWDO \ OD LQVHUFLyQ GH XQ VWHQW SDUD HYLWDU UHFXUUHQFLDV (O WUDWDPLHQWRHQGRVFySLFRGHODVHVWHQRVLVWLHQHXQDWDVDGHp[LWRGHO /$6,$/2(1'26&23,$(1(/75$7$0,(172'(/26352&(6266$/,9$/(62%6758&7,926 2EMHWLYR 2%-(7,92 • (YDOXDU OD HIHFWLYLGDG \ VHJXULGDG GH OD VLDORHQGRFRSLD FRPR WpFQLFD GLDJQyVWLFDWHUDSpXWLFDHQHOPDQHMRGHSURFHVRVVDOLYDOHVREVWUXFWLYRV /$6,$/2(1'26&23,$(1(/75$7$0,(172'(/26352&(6266$/,9$/(62%6758&7,926 0pWRGRV 0e72'26 5HYLVLyQGHODOLWHUDWXUD 6H UHDOL]y XQD E~VTXHGD GH OD OLWHUDWXUD FLHQWtILFD VLQ OtPLWH WHPSRUDO \ KDVWDDEULOGHHQODVVLJXLHQWHVEDVHVGHGDWRV ,QIRUPHVGHHYDOXDFLyQGHODVDJHQFLDVGHWHFQRORJtDVVDQLWDULDV o ,1$+7$KWWSZZZLQDKWDRUJ o +7$KWWSZZZQKVFUG\RUNDFXN %DVHVGHGDWRVGHUHYLVLRQHVVREUHHIHFWLYLGDG\SUR\HFWRVHQFXUVR o '$5(KWWSZZZ\RUNDFXNLQVWFUGZHOFRPHKWP o 1+6(('KWWSZZZ\RUNDFXNLQVWFUGZHOFRPHKWP 5HYLVLRQHVVLVWHPiWLFDV o %DVHGHGDWRV&RFKUDQHKWWSZZZXSGDWHVRIWZDUHFRP %DVHVGHGDWRV o 0('/,1(21/,1(KWWSZZZQFELQOPQLKJRY o (0%$6(21/,1(KWWS o ,%(&6KWWSEYVLVFLLLHV(EDVHVKWPO o ,6,:HERI6FLHQFHKWWSDFFHVVLVLSURGXFWVFRP)(&<7 o ,0(KWWSEGGRFFVLFHV,0(%$6,6LPHZHEGRFX6) 5HSRVLWRULRV o 5HFROHFWDKWWSZZZUHFROHFWDQHWEXVFDGRU o 'LDOQHWKWWSGLDOQHWXQLULRMDHV (QVD\RVFOtQLFRV o ,QVWLWXWR1DFLRQDOGH6DOXGGH86KWWSFOLQLFDWULDOVJRY /DV HVWUDWHJLDV GH E~VTXHGD HVSHFtILFDV SDUD FDGD XQD GH ODV EDVHV GH GDWRV VH PXHVWUDQ HQ HO DQH[R 'H PRGR DGLFLRQDO VH UHFRJLy LQIRUPDFLyQ JHQHUDOORFDOL]DGDDWUDYpVGHOEXVFDGRU*RRJOH$FDGpPLFRKDVWDDEULOGH (O UHVXOWDGR GH HVWDV E~VTXHGDV IXH YROFDGR HQ XQ JHVWRU GH UHIHUHQFLDV ELEOLRJUiILFDV (QG1RWH ; FRQ HO ILQ GH HOLPLQDU ORV GXSOLFDGRV \ IDFLOLWDU OD JHVWLyQ GRFXPHQWDO 7UDV OD OHFWXUD GH ORV UHV~PHQHV GH ORV DUWtFXORV UHVXOWDQWHVVHUHDOL]yXQDVHOHFFLyQGHHVWXGLRVPHGLDQWHXQDVHULHGHFULWHULRV TXHVHGHWDOODQHQHOVLJXLHQWHDSDUWDGR\SRVWHULRUPHQWHXQDUHYLVLyQPDQXDO GHODELEOLRJUDItDUHIHULGDHQORVPLVPRV /$6,$/2(1'26&23,$(1(/75$7$0,(172'(/26352&(6266$/,9$/(62%6758&7,926 DYDOLDW &RQVXOWD7pFQLFD &ULWHULRVGHVHOHFFLyQGHORVDUWtFXORV /DVHOHFFLyQGHORVDUWtFXORVVHUHDOL]yFRQIRUPHDORVVLJXLHQWHVFULWHULRV SUHYLDPHQWHHVWDEOHFLGRVWDEOD Tabla 1: &ULWHULRVGHLQFOXVLyQ\H[FOXVLyQGHHVWXGLRV $VSHFWR &ULWHULRGHH[FOXVLyQ &ULWHULRGHLQFOXVLyQ (VWXGLRVGHXQVRORFDVRUHYLVLRQHV QDUUDWLYDV 'LVHxRGHO HVWXGLR 5HYLVLRQHVVLVWHPiWLFDVPHWDQiOLVLVHQVD\RVFOtQLFRV DOHDWRUL]DGRVHVWXGLRVFXDVLH[SHULPHQWDOHVHVWXGLRVGH FRKRUWHVHVWXGLRVGHFDVRV\FRQWUROHVVHULHVGHFDVRV 7LSRGH SXEOLFDFLyQ $UWtFXORVRULJLQDOHVGHLQYHVWLJDFLyQLQIRUPHVGH HYDOXDFLyQGHWHFQRORJtDVVDQLWDULDV 3REODFLyQGH HVWXGLR 3DFLHQWHVVLQUHVWULFFLRQHVUHVSHFWRDHGDGRVH[RFRQ SDWRORJtDVDOLYDOREVWUXFWLYD 1LQJXQR 7DPDxR PXHVWUDO (VWXGLRVFRQPiVGHSDFLHQWHV (VWXGLRVLQIHULRUHVHQQ~PHUR ,QWHUYHQFLyQ 6LDORHQGRVFRSLDWHUDSpXWLFDWDQWRSDUDVLDOROLWLDVLVFRPR SDUDLQIODPDFLRQHVUHFXUUHQWHV 2WUDVWpFQLFDV &RPSDUDFLyQ &XDOTXLHURWUDWpFQLFDWHUDSpXWLFD 0HGLGDVGH UHVXOWDGR 5HVROXFLyQGHODREVWUXFFLyQVDOLYDOHIHFWRVDGYHUVRV\ RWUDVYDULDEOHVHQUHODFLyQFRQODHIHFWLYLGDG\VHJXULGDG GHODWpFQLFD 2WUDVYDULDEOHV ,GLRPD &DVWHOODQRLQJOpVIUDQFpVSRUWXJXpVLWDOLDQR 2WURVLGLRPDV &DUWDVDOGLUHFWRUDUWtFXORVGHRSLQLyQ HGLWRULDOHVFRPXQLFDFLRQHVD FRQJUHVRV )XHQWHHODERUDFLyQSURSLD ([WUDFFLyQGHGDWRVVtQWHVLVGHODLQIRUPDFLyQ\FODVLILFDFLyQGHORV HVWXGLRV /DH[WUDFFLyQGHGDWRVVHUHDOL]yVLJXLHQGRXQDPHWRGRORJtDVLVWHPiWLFD\ HQKRMDVGLVHxDGDVHVSHFtILFDPHQWH/RVHVWXGLRVVHFODVLILFDURQVHJ~QODFDOLGDG PHWRGROyJLFD GH ORV PLVPRV \ VLJXLHQGR XQD MHUDUTXtD GH PD\RU D PHQRU LPSRUWDQFLD GH DFXHUGR FRQ OD HVFDOD GHO 6FRWWLVK ,QWHUFROOHJLDWH *XLGHOLQHV 1HWZRUN 6,*1 DQH[R /RV DQiOLVLV HVWDGtVWLFRV \ JUiILFRV VH UHDOL]DURQ PHGLDQWHHOSURJUDPDLQIRUPiWLFR6WDWV'LUHFW6WDWV'LUHFW/LPLWHG $;(1&,$'($9$/,$&,Ð1'(7(&12/2;Ì$66$1,7$5,$6'(*$/,&,$ 5HVXOWDGRV 5(68/7$'26 5HVXOWDGRVGHODE~VTXHGD\VHOHFFLyQGHHVWXGLRV /D E~VTXHGD ELEOLRJUiILFD DSRUWy UHIHUHQFLDV GH ODV TXH HVWDEDQ GXSOLFDGDV 'H HQWUH ORV UHV~PHQHV UHVWDQWHV VH LGHQWLILFDURQ UHYLVLRQHV VLVWHPiWLFDV VHOHFFLRQiQGRVH OD HODERUDGD SRU 6WU\FKRZVN\ HW DO HQ SRUVHUODPiVDFWXDOL]DGD\GHPD\RUFDOLGDG(VWDUHYLVLyQLQFOX\y DUWtFXORVHQORVTXHODVLDORHQGRVFRSLDVHXWLOL]yVRODRGHIRUPD DG\XYDQWHDXQDERUGDMHTXLU~UJLFRFRPRWUDWDPLHQWRGHWUDVWRUQRVREVWUXFWLYRV VDOLYDUHVHQDGXOWRV 7UDV UHDOL]DU XQD OHFWXUD GH ORV UHV~PHQHV UHVWDQWHV VH VHOHFFLRQDURQ QXHYRVDUWtFXORVQRLQFOXLGRVHQODUHYLVLyQDQWHULRUGHORVTXHFXPSOLHURQORV FULWHULRV GH LQFOXVLyQ HVWDEOHFLGRV ILJXUD (Q HO DQH[R ILJXUDQ ORV HVWXGLRVH[FOXLGRV\VXVFDXVDV Figura 4: . 'LDJUDPDGHIOXMRGHORVHVWXGLRVLQFOXLGRVHQODUHYLVLyQ 5HYLVLyQELEOLRJUiILFD ,0(,%(&6 &RFKUDQH +7$ 3XE0HG (PEDVH :HERI6FLHQFH (OLPLQDFLyQGHGXSOLFDGRV UHIHUHQFLDVELEOLRJUiILFDV 5HYLVLyQVLVWHPiWLFD DWH[WRFRPSOHWR $57Ì&8/26 HOLPLQDGRV $57Ì&8/26 18(926,1&/8Ì'26 &DUDFWHUtVWLFDVJHQHUDOHVGHORVHVWXGLRV /RVHVWXGLRVLQFOXLGRVFRUUHVSRQGLHQWHVDODUHYLVLyQVLVWHPiWLFDGH 6WU\FKRZVN\ HW DO \ SXEOLFDGRV SRVWHULRUPHQWH VRQ GH FDUiFWHU REVHUYDFLRQDO FRQFUHWDPHQWH VHULHV GH FDVRV WDQWR GH WLSR SURVSHFWLYR FRPR UHWURVSHFWLYR ÔQLFDPHQWH XQ HVWXGLR FRPSDUy ORV UHVXOWDGRV FOtQLFRV HQ GRV SHULRGRVDQWHV\GHVSXpVGHLQWURGXFLUODWpFQLFDGHVLDORHQGRVFRSLD /$6,$/2(1'26&23,$(1(/75$7$0,(172'(/26352&(6266$/,9$/(62%6758&7,926 DYDOLDW &RQVXOWD7pFQLFD (OQ~PHURGHSDFLHQWHVIXHPX\YDULDEOHRVFLODQGRHQWUH\HQOD UHYLVLyQ GH 6WU\FKRZVN\ HW DO \ HQWUH \ HQ OD DFWXDOL]DFLyQ SRVWHULRU+D\TXHGHVWDFDUTXHHOQ~PHURGHSDFLHQWHVLQFOXLGRVQRVLHPSUHVH FRUUHVSRQGLy FRQ HO GH VLDORHQGRVFRSLDV UHDOL]DGDV DVt HQ DOJXQRV FDVRV HO Q~PHURGHSDFLHQWHVIXHVXSHULRUGHELGRDTXHDOJXQRVSDFLHQWHVQRUHFLELHURQ WUDWDPLHQWRWUDVVHUUHDOL]DGDXQDVLDORHQGRVFRSLDGLDJQyVWLFDHQRWURVFDVRVHO Q~PHURGHSURFHGLPLHQWRVIXHVXSHULRUDOGHSDFLHQWHVGHELGRDUHDOL]DUORVHQ RFDVLRQHV GH IRUPD ELODWHUDO \ HQ RWURV FRPR HO HVWXGLR GH 1DKOLHOL GH VyOR VH GHVFULEHQ SURFHGLPLHQWRV D SHVDU GH TXH HO Q~PHUR GH SDFLHQWHVLQFOXLGRVHVGH 6H KD REVHUYDGR TXH DOJXQRV HVWXGLRV LQFOXLGRV QR GHVFULEHQ DGHFXDGDPHQWHORVFULWHULRVGHVHOHFFLyQGHSDFLHQWHVQLGHVXVFDUDFWHUtVWLFDV\ HQ RFDVLRQHV ODV WpFQLFDV GHWUDWDPLHQWRXWLOL]DGDV R ORV UHVXOWDGRV REWHQLGRV ORTXHSRGUtDLQIOXLUDODKRUDGHVLQWHWL]DUHLQWHUSUHWDUORVUHVXOWDGRV5HVSHFWR DO OXJDU GH UHDOL]DFLyQ OD WpFQLFD VH OOHYy D FDER HQ GLYHUVRV SDtVHV SULQFLSDOPHQWH$OHPDQLD,VUDHO(8$&KLQD)UDQFLD3RORQLD \RWURV3RU~OWLPRSRGUtDH[LVWLUXQVRODSDPLHQWRGHSDUWLFLSDQWHVHQORV HVWXGLRV GH $UGHNLDQ \ D =HQN \ =HQN .OHLQ\$UGHNLDQ\HQWUHORVGH<XD\<X (IHFWLYLGDG\VHJXULGDGGHODWpFQLFD (Q OD WDEOD VH PXHVWUDQ ODV SULQFLSDOHV FDUDFWHUtVWLFDV GH ORV HVWXGLRV LQFOXLGRVHQHVWDUHYLVLyQFRPRQ~PHURGHSDFLHQWHVJOiQGXODDIHFWDGDFDXVD GHODREVWUXFFLyQ\WDPDxRGHOFiOFXOR$GHPiVGHOSRUFHQWDMHGHUHVROXFLyQGH OD REVWUXFFLyQ VDOLYDO \ GH ORV HIHFWRV DGYHUVRV UHJLVWUDGRV HQ OD FROXPQD GH WUDWDPLHQWR VH HVSHFLILFD VL HQ HO HVWXGLR VH KD XWLOL]DGR ~QLFDPHQWH OD VLDORHQGRVFRSLD WHUDSpXWLFD R XQD WpFQLFD FRPELQDGD $ HIHFWRV GH HVWD UHYLVLyQSRUVLDORHQGRVFRSLDWHUDSpXWLFDVHHQWLHQGH • HQ HO FDVR GH OD VLDOROLWLDVLV DTXHOOD TXH LQFOX\H OD XWLOL]DFLyQ GH SLQ]DVPLQLIyUFHSVFDWpWHUHVEDOyQ\FHVWDVGH'RUPLD\TXHSXHGH WDPELpQ LQFOXLU XQD VLDOROLWRWULFLD H[WUDFRUSyUHD R LQWUDFRUSyUHD FRQ RQGDVGHFKRTXHROiVHU • HQ SUHVHQFLD GH HVWHQRVLV GXFWDOHV LQFOX\HOD XWLOL]DFLyQ GH VROXFLyQ VDOLQD DSUHVLyQ GH FDWpWHUHV FRQEDOyQ PLFURFHSLOORV LUULJDFLyQ GH FRUWLFRLGHLQWUDGXFWDOHLQVHUFLyQGHVWHQW /D GHQRPLQDGD WpFQLFD FRPELQDGD LQFOXLUtD OD XWLOL]DFLyQ GH OD VLDORHQGRVFRSLD SDUD YLVXDOL]DFLyQ \ ORFDOL]DFLyQ GHO FiOFXOR FRQ SDSLORWRPtD DSHUWXUD GHO GXFWR R LQFLVLyQ LQWUDRUDO R H[WHUQD VLQ HVFLVLyQ JODQGXODU \ UHSDUDFLyQRPDUVXSLDOL]DFLyQGHOGXFWR (QWRWDOVHLQFOX\HURQSURFHGLPLHQWRVGHVLDORHQGRVFRSLDGHORVTXH FRUUHVSRQGLHURQDVLDORHQGRVFRSLDWHUDSpXWLFD\DWpFQLFDFRPELQDGD (O IXHURQ UHDOL]DGRV VREUH OD JOiQGXOD VXEPDQGLEXODU \ HO UHVWR VREUH OD SDUyWLGD ÔQLFDPHQWH XQ HVWXGLR LQFOX\y SURFHGLPLHQWRV GH VLDORHQGRVFRSLD HQ JOiQGXODVVDOLYDOHV $;(1&,$'($9$/,$&,Ð1'(7(&12/2;Ì$66$1,7$5,$6'(*$/,&,$ SDF 603 SDF 3 SDF 603 SDF 60 SDF 3 .RFK $OHPDQLD 0F*XUN 5HLQR8QLGR 5DLI ,VUDHO 1DKOLHOL ,VUDHO .RFK $OHPDQLD 1' 1' /$6,$/2(1'26&23,$(1(/75$7$0,(172'(/26352&(6266$/,9$/(62%6758&7,926 x(VWHQRVLV x6LDOROLWRV x6LDOROLWRV x6LDOROLWLDVLV x6LDOROLWRV x6LDOROLWRV(VWHQRVLV 2EWUXFFLyQWLSR HVItQWHU SDF 603 =LHJOHU $OHPDQLD x6( x6HJXLP1' x6(OLWRWULFLDLQWUDFRUSyUHD x6HJXLP1' x6(OiVHUHQHUJtD QHXPiWLFDIyUFHSV x6HJXLPP x6(IUDJPHQWDFLyQ x6HJXLPP x6(IUDJPHQWDFLyQ x6HJXLP1' x6(OiVHU x6HJXLPP 7UDWDPLHQWRUHDOL]DGR VHJXLPLHQWRP x1LQJXQR x/LJDGXUDGHOGXFWR x3HUIRUDFLyQFRQGXF :DUWKRQ x1LQJXQR x)DOVDYtD x3HUIRUDFLyQGXFWDO x%ORTXHRGHODFHVWD x,QIODPSHUVLVWHQWH x(VWHQRVLV xSDF x6tQWRPDVOHYHVGH VLDORDGHQLWLV x1LQJXQR (IHFWRVDGYHUVRV HVFLVLyQJODQGXODU x1LQJXQR x,QIODPJUDYH x7&JOREDO x3DUHVWHVLDVQHUYLROLQJXDO x 'XFWRSRVWHULRU x6DQJUDGR x +LOLR x)RUPDFLyQQXHYRVFiOFXORV x &RQP~OWFiOFXORV x(VFLVLyQJODQGXODU x6( x7& x6( x6( x7& x6( x6( x6( x6( x6( x6( 5HVROXFLyQGHOD REVWUXFFLyQVDOLYDO UD]yQ x6(SUHGQLVRORQDLQWUDGXFWDO VHPDQDOVHP x6( x6HJXLP1' x7&WpFQLFDGHGLODWDFLyQ GXFWDOGXFWDOVWUHWFKLQJH LQFLVLyQWUDQVRUDO x6HJXLPP x6( !SDF x7& SDF x6HJXLPP x6(/(& 1' x6HJXLP1' x7&,QFLVLyQSUHDXULFXODUH LQFLVLyQDWUDYpVGHOD IDVFLDSDURWtGHD x6HJXLPP x6(OiVHU<$*SLQ]DV x6HJXLPP 1' x6LDOROLWRV60 (VWHQRVLV 6LDORDGHQLWLV&(3 SDF 603 =HQN $OHPDQLD x6LDOROLWRV602WURV 1' SDF 3 SDF 60 SDF 60 0DUFKDO )UDQFLD 0DUFKDO )UDQFLD &KX +RQJ.RQJ x6LDOROLWRV603 2WURV603 1' x6LDOROLWRV60 (VWHQRVLV SDF 603 $U]R] (VSDxD x6LDOROLWRV60 &iOFXORPP 1' SDF 60 .|QLJVEHUJHU $OHPDQLD 7LSRGHREVWUXFFLyQ x6LDOROLWRV3(VWHQRVLV 3yOLSRV 3DFLHQWHVQ VLDORHQGRVFRSLDVQ\ ORFDOL]DFLyQ (VWXGLRSDtV Tabla 2:3RUFHQWDMHGHUHVROXFLyQGHODREVWUXFFLyQVDOLYDOWUDVVLDORHQGRVFRSLDFRQ\VLQDERUGDMHTXLU~UJLFR 5HVXOWDGRV SDF 603 SDF 603$PEDV SDF 3 SDF 60 SDF 603 SDF 6036/ SDF 603 SDF 603 SDF 3 SDF 3 SDF 3 3DSDGDNL (8$ :DOYHNDU (8$ <X &KLQD <XD &KLQD /LX &KLQD 1DKOLHOL ,VUDHO 1DKOLHOLD ,VUDHO :DOYHNDU (8$ $UGHNLDQ ,VUDHO .DUDYLGDV ,VUDHO(8$ .RFK $OHPDQLD 3DFLHQWHVQ VLDORHQGRVFRSLDVQ\ ORFDOL]DFLyQ (VWXGLRSDtV DYDOLDW x6LDOROLWLDVLV x6LDOROLWLDVLV7DSRQHV PRFR x(VWHQRVLV~QLFD P~OWLSOH x6LDOROLWLDVLV x(VWHQRVLV x6LDOROLWRV 6LDORDGHQLWLV x6LDOROLWRV x6LDOROLWRV602WURV x6LDOROLWRV603 ,QIODPDFLyQ 6LDORDGHQLWLV,RGR x6LDOROLWRV3yOLSRV (VWHQRVLV0RFR x6LDOROLWRV2WURV 7LSRGHREVWUXFFLyQ 1' 1' 60 3 1' 1' 1' 1' 1' &iOFXORPP x7& x6( x6( x6( x7& x6( x6( x6( x7& x7& x3HUIRUDFLyQGXFWR x/LJDGXUDGXFWR x3DURWLGLWLVDJXGD x(VWHQRVLVVLQWRPiWLFD x5HWHQFLyQIUDJPHQWRGH FiOFXOR x&LFDWUL]YLVLEOH x/HVLyQHVWUXFWXUDOGXFWR x1' x&LVWRFHOH x,QIODPDFLyQ x,QIHFFLyQ x5iQXOD x(VFLVLyQJODQGXODU x3DUHVWHVLDVWUDQVLWRULDV QHUYLROLQJXDO x,QIHFFLyQ x6DQJUDGR x5iQXOD x(VWHQRVLVGXFWDO x/RVPLVPRVTXHHQHO DQWHULRU x&RPSOLFDFLRQHVPHQRUHV SDUHVWHVLD WHPSRUDOGHOQHUYLROLQJXDO HLQIODPDFLyQUHFXUUHQWH x,QIODPDFLyQ xJUDYHVOHYHV x3DUHVWHVLDVWUDQVLWRULDV QHUYLROLQJXDO x$UWUDOJLD$70 (IHFWRVDGYHUVRV HVFLVLyQJODQGXODU &RQVXOWD7pFQLFD $;(1&,$'($9$/,$&,Ð1'(7(&12/2;Ì$66$1,7$5,$6'(*$/,&,$ x7&,QFLVLyQSUHDXULFXODU x6HJXLPP x7&,QFLVLyQSUHDXULFXODU x,QFLVLyQIDFLDO x6HJXLPP x6(LUULJDFLyQGLODWDGRU VWHQWV x6( x6HJXLP1' x7&LQFLVLyQLQWUDRUDO x6HJXLPP x1' x6HJXLP1' x6(IUDJPHQWDFLyQ x6HJXLP1' x6(OLWRWULSWRUEDOyQ x6HJXLPP x6( x6HJXLP1' x6(IUDJPHQWDFLyQVWHQW x7& x6HJXLPP x1' x6HJXLP1' 5HVROXFLyQGHOD REVWUXFFLyQVDOLYDO UD]yQ x6(OLWRWULFLDOiVHU x6( x6HJXLPP 7UDWDPLHQWRUHDOL]DGR VHJXLPLHQWRP SDF 603 SDF 603 SDF 60 SDF 60 SDF 603 SDF 603 SDF 60 SDF 603 SDF 1DKOLHOL ,VUDHO 6HUEHWFL 7XUTXtD 6X &KLQD <X &KLQD :DOODFH (8$ %RZHQ (8$ &DSDFFLR ,WDOLD 'DQTXDUW 'LQDPDUFD *LOOHVSLH (8$ 1' x6LDOROLWLDVLV(VWHQRVLV $PERV 6LDORDGHQLWLV x6LDOROLWLDVLV(VWHQRVLV 66M|JUHQ x6LDOROLWLDVLV 6LDORDGHQLWLV 6tQGURPH6M|JUHQ x6LDOROLWLDVLV 1' 9DULDEOH 9DULDEOH &iOFXORPP x6LDOROLWLDVLV x6LDOROLWRV2WURV x6LDOROLWLDVLV x6LDOROLWRV603 2WURV x6LDOROLWRV 7LSRGHREVWUXFFLyQ /$6,$/2(1'26&23,$(1(/75$7$0,(172'(/26352&(6266$/,9$/(62%6758&7,926 3DFLHQWHVQ VLDORHQGRVFRSLDVQ\ ORFDOL]DFLyQ (VWXGLRSDtV x6(FRUWLFRLGHVWHQWWR[LQD ERWXOtQLFD x7& x6HJXLPP x6(OiVHUGLODWDFLyQ x7& x([FOXLGRV x6HJXLPPVHPP x7&,QFLVLyQWUDQVRUDO x6HJXLPP x6(OiVHUKROPLR x7& x6HJXLPP x6(OLWRWULSWRUH[WHUQR x7&GLODWDFLyQGXFWDOGXFWDO VWUHWFKLQJSDUDFiOFXORV 60RLQFLVLyQH[WUDRUDOSDUD 3 x6HJXLPP x6(/(&OiVHUKROPLR x7& x6HJXLP1' x7&6LDOROLWHFWRPtDDELHUWD DVLVWLGDSRUHQGRVFRSLD x6HJXLPP x6(OLWRWULSWRU x6HJXLPP x7&,QFLVLyQWUDQVRUDO60 DERUGDMHH[WHUQR3 x6HJXLPP 7UDWDPLHQWRUHDOL]DGR VHJXLPLHQWRP x1LQJXQR x1LQJXQR (IHFWRVDGYHUVRV HVFLVLyQJODQGXODU x7& x,QIHFFLyQ x3DUHVWHVLDVWUDQVLWRULDV QHUYLROLQJXDO x&LVWRFHOH x6( x,QIODPDFLyQ x6HFFLyQSDUFLDOGHOQHUYLR OLQJXDO x7& x(VWHQRVLVUHFXUUHQWH x5RWXUDFHVWD x6( x)tVWXODVDOLYDUHQ7& x7& x7DVDJOREDO x(VFLVLyQ x(GHPDVXHORERFD x7& x3DUHVWHVLDVOLQJXDOHV x/HVLyQQHUYLROLQJXDO x([FOXLGRVVLDORHQGRVF x6(JOREDO x9tDIDOVD x 6LDOROLW x6DQJUDGR x (VWHQRV x5RWXUDFHVWD x,QIHFFLyQ x3HUIRUDFLyQGHOFRQGXFWRGH :KDUWRQR6WHQVRQ x6(JOREDO x7&JOREDO x6LDORDGHQLWLVSRUUHWHQFLyQ x6LDOROLWLDVLV6(7& GHFiOFXOR x3DUHVLDGHOQOLQJXDO x(VWHQRVLV6(7& x(VFLVLyQJODQGXODU VLDOROLWLDVLV HVWHQRVLV x6( x7& x6( x7& 5HVROXFLyQGHOD REVWUXFFLyQVDOLYDO UD]yQ 5HVXOWDGRV SDF 603 SDF 603 SDF 603 SDF 60 SDF 3 SDF 603 SDF 603 /XHUV $OHPDQLD 0DUHVK (8$ 'XUEHF )UDQFLD .RFK $OHPDQLD .RFKD $OHPDQLD 5DVPXVVHQ 'LQDPDUFD =HQN $OHPDQLD 3DFLHQWHVQ VLDORHQGRVFRSLDVQ\ ORFDOL]DFLyQ (VWXGLRSDtV DYDOLDW x6LDOROLWLDVLV 1' 1' 1$ x(VWHQRVLV(VWHQ GLVWDOHV(VWHQѿ PHGLR(VWHQѿ SUR[(VWHQ GLIXVDV x6LDOROLWLDVLV(VWHQRVLV $PEDV2WURV 1RSDWRORJtD 1RSRVLEOH x6LDOROLWLDVLVWHUDSLD GHUHVFDWHWUDVIDOOR SUHYLRHQFiOFXORVQR PyYLOHVR!PP 1$ 1' x6LDOROLWLDVLV(VWHQRVLV 1RDQRUPDOLGDG 2WURV x(VWHQRVLV 6( (VFLVLyQ &iOFXORPP x6LDOROLWLDVLV 7LSRGHREVWUXFFLyQ x1' x(VFLVLyQJODQGXODU x6(JOREDO x e[LWR x e[LWRSDUFLDO x )UDFDVR x6(JOREDO x 6( x 6(/(&3 x /(&3 x 6(/(&R7& x7&JOREDO x6(VWHQWVOiVHUKROPLR x6HJXLPP x6(6(/(&/(& x7& x6HJXLPP $;(1&,$'($9$/,$&,Ð1'(7(&12/2;Ì$66$1,7$5,$6'(*$/,&,$ x9LDIDOVD x3UREOHPDVHTXLSR x6DQJUDGR x(GHPDOLQJXDO x6tQFRSH x,QIHFFLyQ x(VWHQRVLV x6(LUULJDFLyQFRUWLFRLGH x7& x7&FLUXJtDWUDQVRUDO x6HJXLPP x1' x(VFLVLyQJODQGXODU x6(JOREDO x7&JOREDO x (VW6(7& x (VW6(7& x (VW6(7& x5HVHFFLyQJODQGXODU FRQHVWHQRVLVGLIXVDV x3HUIRUDFLyQGXFWDO x(GHPDGHVXHOR x,QIHFFLyQ x)UDFDVRFDQDOL]DFLyQGHO GXFWR60 x6LDODGHQLWLV x6(JOREDO x &RUWLF x 'LODWDF x7& x6(JOREDO x 6LDOROLWLDVLV x (VWHQRVLV x 1RDQRUPDOLGDG x6(JOREDO x ([WUDFFRPSOHWD x ([WUDF3DUFLDO x1' x(VFLVLyQJODQGXODU (IHFWRVDGYHUVRV HVFLVLyQJODQGXODU &RQVXOWD7pFQLFD x6(FRUWLFRLGHLQWUDGXFWDO x7&LQFLVLyQLQWUDRUDO x6HJXLP1' x6(OiVHUGHWXOLR x6HJXLPP x6( x6HJXLP!P x6(JOREDO x6( x1RWUDWDPLHQWR x6HJXLP1' 5HVROXFLyQGHOD REVWUXFFLyQVDOLYDO UD]yQ 7UDWDPLHQWRUHDOL]DGR VHJXLPLHQWRP SDF 60 SDF 3 SDF 603 SDF 603 SDF 603 SDF 603 SDF 3 SDF 603 SDF 603 .RSHF 3RORQLD .RSHFD 3RORQLD .RSHFE 3RORQLD .UROO $OHPDQLD 9DVKLVKWD (8$ $UGHNLDQ ,VUDHO $UGHNLDQD ,VUDHO ,DQRYVNL 1XHYD=HODQGD .OHLQ ,VUDHO 1' x6LDOROLWLDVLV(VWHQRVLV $PEDV x6LDOROLWLDVLVFRQ FiOFXORVGHJUDQ WDPDxR 1$ x(VWHQRVLV~QLFD P~OWLSOHWDSyQGH PRFR 1' x6LDOROLWLDVLVRFXOWD (VWHQRVLV 6LDORDGHQLWLV $QRPDOtDGXFWDO 1' x6LDOROLWLDVLV(VWHQRVLV 6LDORDGHQLWLV 2WURV x6LDOROLWLDVLVP~OWLSOH 1$ 1' 1' &iOFXORPP x(VWHQRVLV x6LDOROLWLDVLV x6LDOROLWLDVLV(VWHQRVLV 7LSRGHREVWUXFFLyQ /$6,$/2(1'26&23,$(1(/75$7$0,(172'(/26352&(6266$/,9$/(62%6758&7,926 3DFLHQWHVQ VLDORHQGRVFRSLDVQ\ ORFDOL]DFLyQ (VWXGLRSDtV x7& x7&LQFLVLyQLQWUDRUDO60R DERUGDMHIDFHOLIW PRGLILFDGR3 x6HJXLPP x1' x6(JOREDO x 6LDOROLW x (VWHQRVLV x7& x6(LUULJDFLyQFRUWLFRLGH x7& x6HJXLPP x(VWHQRVLVFRQ HVFLVLyQJODQGXODU x5iQXOD x3HUIRUDFLyQGXFWDO x,QIHFFLyQ x5iQXODSRVWRSHUDWRULD x(VFLVLyQJODQGXODU x3HUIRUDFLyQFRQGXFWR x(VFLVLyQJODQGXODU x6( x6( x7& x6( x1' x1' x0HGLFLyQVXEMHWLYDGH PHMRUtD x,PSRUWDQWH x/HYH x1RPHMRUtD x6(JOREDO x 6LDOROLWLDVLV x (VWHQRVLV x1' x1' x(VFLVLyQJODQGXODU (IHFWRVDGYHUVRV HVFLVLyQJODQGXODU x6(JOREDO x7& x6( x7& 5HVROXFLyQGHOD REVWUXFFLyQVDOLYDO UD]yQ x6(LUULJDFLyQFRUWLFRLGH x6HJXLPP x6LDOROLWLDVLV x6(7& (VFLVLyQ x(VWHQRVLV x6( x6HJXLPP x6(VWHQWVLUULJDFLyQGH HVWHURLGHVWR[LQD ERWXOtQLFD x6HJXLPP x6(LUULJDFLyQFRUWLFRLGH x7& x6HJXLPP x6(VWHQW x6HJXLPP x6( x7& x6HJXLPP x6(6(/(& x7& x6HJXLPP 7UDWDPLHQWRUHDOL]DGR VHJXLPLHQWRP 5HVXOWDGRV 3DFLHQWHVQ VLDORHQGRVFRSLDVQ\ ORFDOL]DFLyQ 7LSRGHREVWUXFFLyQ &iOFXORPP 7UDWDPLHQWRUHDOL]DGR VHJXLPLHQWRP 5HVROXFLyQGHOD REVWUXFFLyQVDOLYDO UD]yQ (IHFWRVDGYHUVRV HVFLVLyQJODQGXODU &RQVXOWD7pFQLFD $;(1&,$'($9$/,$&,Ð1'(7(&12/2;Ì$66$1,7$5,$6'(*$/,&,$ x6(JOREDO x6(LUULJDFLyQOiVHUKROPLR x7&JOREDO 3KLOOLSV SDF x6LDOROLWLDVLV x7& x 6(OiVHU x(VWHQRVLVGXFWDO (8$ 603 x6HJXLPP x 3DSLORWRPtD x 7& x6(JOREDO SDF x(VWHQRVLVFRQHVFLVLyQ 6LRQLV x6(VWHQWVOiVHU<$* x 6( x6LDOROLWLDVLV(VWHQRVLV JODQGXODU 603 ORVGHOiVHU 5HLQR8QLGR x6HJXLPP x 6(OiVHU x(VFLVLyQJODQGXODU x (VWHQRVLV ^ŝĂůŽĞŶĚŽƐĐŽƉŝĂ ƚĞƌĂƉĠƵƚŝĐĂ ƉĂƌĂ ůĂ ƐŝĂůŽůŝƚŝĂƐŝƐ͗ ŝŶĐůƵLJĞ ůĂ ƵƚŝůŝnjĂĐŝſŶ ĚĞ ƉŝŶnjĂƐ͕ ŵŝŶŝĨſƌĐĞƉƐ͕ ĐĂƚĠƚĞƌĞƐͲďĂůſŶ LJ ĐĞƐƚĂƐ ĚĞ ŽƌŵŝĂ LJ ƉƵĞĚĞ ŝŶĐůƵŝƌ ƵŶĂ ƐŝĂůŽůŝƚŽƚƌŝĐŝĂ ŝŶƚƌĂĐŽƌƉſƌĞĂ ŵĞĚŝĂŶƚĞ ŽŶĚĂƐ ĚĞ ĐŚŽƋƵĞ Ž ůĄƐĞƌ͘ ^ŝĂůŽĞŶĚŽƐĐŽƉŝĂƚĞƌĂƉĠƵƚŝĐĂƉĂƌĂĞƐƚĞŶŽƐŝƐĚƵĐƚĂůĞƐ͗ŝŶĐůƵLJĞůĂƵƚŝůŝnjĂĐŝſŶĚĞƐŽůƵĐŝſŶƐĂůŝŶĂĂƉƌĞƐŝſŶ͕ĚĞĐĂƚĠƚĞƌĞƐĐŽŶďĂůſŶ͕ŵŝĐƌŽĐĞƉŝůůŽƐ͕ĐŽƌƚŝĐŽŝĚĞŝŶƚƌĂĚƵĐƚĂůĞŝŶƐĞƌĐŝſŶĚĞƐƚĞŶƚ͘ dĠĐŶŝĐĂĐŽŵďŝŶĂĚĂ͗ŝŶĐůƵLJĞƐŝĂůŽĞŶĚŽƐĐŽƉŝĂƉĂƌĂǀŝƐƵĂůŝnjĂĐŝſŶLJůŽĐĂůŝnjĂĐŝſŶĚĞůĂŽďƐƚƌƵĐĐŝſŶ͕ƐĞŐƵŝĚĂĚĞƉĂƉŝůŽƚŽŵşĂ͕ĂƉĞƌƚƵƌĂĚĞůĚƵĐƚŽŽŝŶĐŝƐŝſŶŝŶƚƌĂŽƌĂůŽĞdžƚĞƌŶĂ;ƐŝŶĞƐĐŝƐŝſŶŐůĂŶĚƵůĂƌͿ͕ƐĞŐƵŝĚŽĚĞƌĞƉĂƌĂĐŝſŶŽ ŵĂƌƐƵƉŝĂůŝnjĂĐŝſŶĚĞůĐŽŶĚƵĐƚŽ͗͘ĐƵĞƌƉŽĞdžƚƌĂŹŽ͖>͗ůŝƚŽƚƌŝĐŝĂĞdžƚƌĂĐŽƌƉſƌĞĂ͖ŵ͗ŵĞƐĞƐ͖E͗ŶŽĚĞĐůĂƌĂĚŽ͖^͗ƐŝĂůŽĞŶĚŽƐĐŽƉŝĂ͖^D͗ƐƵďŵĂŶĚŝďƵůĂƌ͖W͗ƉĂƌſƚŝĚĂ͖d͗ƚĠĐŶŝĐĂĐŽŵďŝŶĂĚĂ͖ΎůƐĞŐƵŝŵŝĞŶƚŽĞƐŵĞĚŝĂŽ ŵĞĚŝĂŶĂLJƌĂŶŐŽ͖ΎΎ>ĂƌĂnjſŶĞŶƵŶŽƐĐĂƐŽƐĞƐƚĄƌĞĨĞƌŝĚĂĂƉĂĐŝĞŶƚĞƐLJĞŶŽƚƌĂƐĂŐůĄŶĚƵůĂƐƐĂůŝǀĂůĞƐͿ͘ (VWXGLRSDtV DYDOLDW 5HVXOWDGRV 'HILQLFLyQGHUHVXOWDGRV $XQTXHQRGHILQLGRHQDOJXQRVDUWtFXORVHQJHQHUDOVHFRQVLGHUyp[LWRGHO WUDWDPLHQWRDODUHVROXFLyQGHODREVWUXFFLyQFRQDXVHQFLDGHVtQWRPDVGXUDQWH HO VHJXLPLHQWR (O IUDFDVR VH GHILQLy D OD LPSRVLELOLGDG GH UHDOL]DU HO SURFHGLPLHQWR OD SHUVLVWHQFLD GH VtQWRPDV R FXDQGR KXER TXH UHFXUULU D OD HVFLVLyQJODQGXODU 6LDORHQGRVFRSLD~QLFD 6H LQFOX\HURQ HVWXGLRV HQ ORV TXH OD WpFQLFD GH VLDORHQGRVFRSLD VH UHDOL]y GH IRUPD ~QLFD SURFHGLPLHQWRV +XER XQD JUDQ YDULDELOLGDG D OD KRUD GH XWLOL]DU GLVSRVLWLYRV FRPR SLQ]DV PLQLIyUFHSV FDWpWHUHVEDOyQ FHVWDV GH'RUPLD\VLDOROLWRWULFLD(ODQiOLVLVFRPELQDGRGHODSURSRUFLyQGHp[LWRVHQOD UHVROXFLyQGHODREVWUXFFLyQIXHGHO,&(ODQiOLVLV GHODKHWHURJHQHLGDGPRVWUyXQD4GH&RFKUDQHGHGI 3\XQD , LQFRQVLVWHQFLD GHO ,& OR TXH LQGLFD TXH HO SRUFHQWDMH GH YDULDFLyQ HQWUH HVWXGLRV HV GHELGR D KHWHURJHQHLGDG PiV TXH DO D]DUILJXUD Figura 5: . Análisis conjunto de la proporción de éxito tras sialoendoscopia Proportion meta-analysis plot [random effects] Königsberger, 1993 0,69 (0,49, 0,85) Arzoz, 1996 0,89 (0,71, 0,98) Marchal, 2001 0,85 (0,73, 0,94) Marchal, 2002 0,82 (0,73, 0,89) Chu, 2003 1,00 (0,72, 1,00) Zenk, 2004 1,00 (0,74, 1,00) Ziegler, 2004 0,87 (0,75, 0,95) Koch, 2005 0,86 (0,71, 0,95) Raif, 2006 1,00 (0,81, 1,00) Koch, 2008 0,76 (0,56, 0,90) Papadaki, 2008 0,89 (0,81, 0,95) Walvekar, 2008 0,74 (0,49, 0,91) Yu, 2008 0,81 (0,58, 0,95) Yu, 2008a 0,84 (0,68, 0,94) Liu, 2009 0,53 (0,43, 0,64) Nahlieli, 2009 0,87 (0,82, 0,91) Nahlieli, 2009a 0,81 (0,75, 0,86) Ardekian, 2010 0,82 (0,72, 0,89) Nahlieli, 2010 1,00 (0,82, 1,00) Serbetci, 2010 0,83 (0,70, 0,92) Yu, 2010 0,83 (0,73, 0,91) Bowen, 2011 0,29 (0,10, 0,56) Danquart, 2011 0,51 (0,39, 0,62) Gillespie, 2011 0,33 (0,20, 0,48) Luers, 2011 0,57 (0,42, 0,71) Maresh, 2011 0,84 (0,66, 0,95) Durbec, 2012 0,81 (0,69, 0,90) Koch, 2012 0,39 (0,31, 0,47) Koch, 2012a 0,22 (0,14, 0,31) Rasmussen, 2012 0,67 (0,58, 0,75) Zenk, 2012 0,88 (0,84, 0,92) Kopec, 2013 0,63 (0,50, 0,74) Kopec, 2013a 0,83 (0,64, 0,94) Kopec, 2013b 0,78 (0,65, 0,89) Kroll, 2013 0,78 (0,60, 0,91) Vashishta, 2013 0,88 (0,76, 0,96) Ardekian, 2014 0,86 (0,71, 0,95) Ardekian, 2014a 0,86 (0,73, 0,94) Ianovski, 2014 0,73 (0,60, 0,83) Phillips, 2014 0,45 (0,27, 0,64) Sionis, 2014 0,90 (0,74, 0,98) combined 0,76 (0,71, 0,82) 0,0 0,2 0,4 0,6 0,8 1,0 proportion (95% confidence interval) /$6,$/2(1'26&23,$(1(/75$7$0,(172'(/26352&(6266$/,9$/(62%6758&7,926 DYDOLDW &RQVXOWD7pFQLFD 7pFQLFDFRPELQDGD /D WpFQLFD FRPELQDGD VH UHDOL]y HQ HVWXGLRV FRQ XQ WRWDO GH SURFHGLPLHQWRV /DV WpFQLFDV HPSOHDGDV YDULDURQ GHVGH OD SDSLORWRPtD R OD DSHUWXUDGHOGXFWRPHGLDQWHLQFLVLyQLQWUDRUDOKDVWDLQFLVLRQHVSUHDXULFXODUHVR DWUDYpVGHODIDVFLDSDURWtGHD(ODQiOLVLVFRPELQDGRGHODSURSRUFLyQGHp[LWRV HQ OD UHVROXFLyQ GH OD REVWUXFFLyQ IXH GHO ,& (O DQiOLVLV GH OD KHWHURJHQHLGDG PRVWUy XQD 4 GH &RFKUDQH GH GI 3 \ XQD , LQFRQVLVWHQFLD GHO ,& OR TXH LQGLFD TXH HO SRUFHQWDMH GH YDULDFLyQ HQWUH HVWXGLRV HV GHELGR D KHWHURJHQHLGDG PiV TXHDOD]DUILJXUD Figura 6: . Análisis conjunto de la proporción de éxito tras técnica combinada Proportion meta-analysis plot [random effects] Ziegler, 2004 1,00 (0,72, 1,00) McGurk, 2006 0,88 (0,47, 1,00) Nahlieli, 2007 0,96 (0,92, 0,98) Liu, 2009 0,93 (0,81, 0,99) Walvekar, 2009 0,90 (0,68, 0,99) Karavidas, 2010 0,99 (0,92, 1,00) Koch, 2010 0,89 (0,52, 1,00) Nahlieli, 2010 0,95 (0,82, 0,99) Serbetci, 2010 0,75 (0,19, 0,99) Su, 2010 0,94 (0,73, 1,00) Wallace, 2010 1,00 (0,59, 1,00) Bowen, 2011 0,71 (0,44, 0,90) Capaccio, 2011 0,99 (0,94, 1,00) Gillespie, 2011 0,70 (0,51, 0,84) Koch, 2012 0,96 (0,89, 0,99) Koch, 2012a 0,86 (0,76, 0,93) Zenk, 2012 0,95 (0,93, 0,97) Kopec, 2013 0,88 (0,68, 0,97) Kopec, 2013a 1,00 (0,48, 1,00) Ardekian, 2014 0,60 (0,15, 0,95) Ianovski, 2014 1,00 (0,63, 1,00) Klein, 2014 1,00 (0,91, 1,00) Phillips, 2014 0,50 (0,16, 0,84) combined 0,91 (0,88, 0,94) 0,0 0,2 0,4 0,6 proportion (95% confidence interval) 0,8 1,0 6HJXLPLHQWR (OVHJXLPLHQWRGHORVSDFLHQWHVIXHPX\YDULDEOHVLHQGRODPHGLDGH PHVHV\RVFLODQGRHQWUHORVPHVHV\ORVDxRV(QJHQHUDOORVUHVXOWDGRVVH PRVWUDURQ FRPR PHGLD R PHGLDQD \ UDQJR DXQTXH HQ RFDVLRQHV VyOR VH HVSHFLILFyXQVRORWpUPLQR $;(1&,$'($9$/,$&,Ð1'(7(&12/2;Ì$66$1,7$5,$6'(*$/,&,$ 5HVXOWDGRV (IHFWRVDGYHUVRV\IUDFDVRGHODVWpFQLFDV (QJHQHUDOORVHIHFWRVDGYHUVRVGHVFULWRVIXHURQGHFDUiFWHUOHYH\HQXQ SHTXHxR SRUFHQWDMH /RV SULQFLSDOHV IXHURQ VLDORDGHQLWLV SHUIRUDFLyQ GXFWDO R FUHDFLyQ GH IDOVD YtD HVWHQRVLV GXFWDO OLJDGXUD GHO FRQGXFWR SDUHVWHVLDV SRU OHVLyQGHOQHUYLROLQJXDOHGHPDGHVXHORUiQXODLQIHFFLyQVDQJUDGRIRUPDFLyQ GHQXHYRVFiOFXORVRUHWHQFLyQGHIUDJPHQWRV\SUREOHPDVFRQHOHTXLSRFRPR URWXUDREORTXHRGHODFHVWD (Q HO WRWDO GH HVWXGLRV LQFOXLGRV VH FRQWDELOL]DURQ XQ WRWDO GH VLDORDGHQHFWRPtDV FRUUHVSRQGLHQGR D XQ GH ORV SURFHGLPLHQWRV ,& DXQTXHFRQXQDDPSOLDYDULDELOLGDGHQWUHHVWXGLRVGHVYLDFLyQHVWiQGDU GH /$6,$/2(1'26&23,$(1(/75$7$0,(172'(/26352&(6266$/,9$/(62%6758&7,926 'LVFXVLyQ ',6&86,Ð1 0HWRGRORJtDGHORVHVWXGLRV\OLPLWDFLRQHV 1R H[LVWHQ HQVD\RV FOtQLFRV DOHDWRUL]DGRV TXH HYDO~HQ OD HILFDFLD GH OD VLDORHQGRVFRSLD HQ HO WUDWDPLHQWR GH OD SDWRORJtD REVWUXFWLYD GH ODV JOiQGXODV VDOLYDOHV HQ FRPSDUDFLyQFRQ RWUDV PRGDOLGDGHVGH WUDWDPLHQWR $Vt WRGRV ORV HVWXGLRVLQFOXLGRVHQHVWDUHYLVLyQVRQGHFDUiFWHUREVHUYDFLRQDOFODVLILFDGRVHQ HO QLYHO GH OD HVFDOD GHO 6,*1 DQH[R /D SULQFLSDO OLPLWDFLyQ GH HVWH WLSRGHHVWXGLRVHVODDXVHQFLDGHXQJUXSRGHFRPSDUDFLyQDSURSLDGR\DXQTXH SHUPLWHQ IRUPXODU KLSyWHVLV QR LQIRUPDQ VREUH OD DVRFLDFLyQ UHDO HQWUH ODV YDULDEOHVREVHUYDGDV $OJXQRV GH ORV HVWXGLRV LQFOXLGRV SUHVHQWDQ OLPLWDFLRQHV PHWRGROyJLFDV TXHSRGUtDQDIHFWDUDORVUHVXOWDGRVGHHIHFWLYLGDG\VHJXULGDG • ,QDGHFXDGDGHVFULSFLyQGHORVFULWHULRVGHVHOHFFLyQGHSDFLHQWHV\GHVXV FDUDFWHUtVWLFDV • ,QDGHFXDGDGHVFULSFLyQGHODVWpFQLFDVGHWUDWDPLHQWRXWLOL]DGDV • 5HDOL]DFLyQ GH ORV HVWXGLRV HQ SREODFLRQHV KHWHURJpQHDV GH SDFLHQWHV GLIHUHQWH WLSR GH SDWRORJtD GH WLSR GH REVWUXFFLyQ GH WDPDxR GH FiOFXORVGHWUDWDPLHQWRVSUHYLRVUHFLELGRVHWF • 1RHVSHFLILFDFLyQGHVLKXERHQPDVFDUDPLHQWRHQOD UHFRJLGDGHGDWRVR HQVXHYDOXDFLyQ • )DOWDGHLQIRUPDFLyQVREUHHOSHULRGRGHVHJXLPLHQWR\ODSURGXFFLyQGH SpUGLGDV • (QRFDVLRQHVGHILFLHQWHGHVFULSFLyQGHORVUHVXOWDGRVREWHQLGRVVLQSRGHU YHULILFDUORVDSDUWLUGHGDWRVLQGLYLGXDOHV • (QPXFKRVFDVRVQRVHKDFHPHQFLyQGHODIXHQWHGHILQDQFLDFLyQQLH[LVWH GHFODUDFLyQGHFRQIOLFWRVGHLQWHUpV 3DSHO GH OD VLDORHQGRVFRSLD HQ HO WUDWDPLHQWR GH OD SDWRORJtD REVWUXFWLYDVDOLYDO (O WUDWDPLHQWR WUDGLFLRQDO GH OD VLDORDGHQLWLV FUyQLFD VH KD FHQWUDGR HQ PpWRGRV TXH LQFUHPHQWHQ HO IOXMR GH VDOLYD FRPR EHEHU PXFKD DJXD FKXSDU FDUDPHORViFLGRVROLPRQHV\DSOLFDUFRPSUHVDVFDOLHQWHVRPDVDMHDODJOiQGXOD DIHFWDGD6LHVWDVPHGLGDVIUDFDVDQHOWUDWDPLHQWRVHUiHQPXFKDVRFDVLRQHV OD HVFLVLyQ JODQGXODU FRQ HO ULHVJR GH OHVLRQHV YDVFXODUHV QHUYLRVDV \ GH FLFDWULFHVQRHVWpWLFDV 6LQHPEDUJRQRVLHPSUHHVQHFHVDULDODH[WLUSDFLyQGHODJOiQGXOD\DVt HVWXGLRV DQDWRPRSDWROyJLFRV PXHVWUDQ TXH IUHFXHQWHPHQWH OD JOiQGXOD HV QRUPDO H[FHSWR SRU OD REVWUXFFLyQ \ TXH SRGUtD YROYHU D XQ IXQFLRQDPLHQWR /$6,$/2(1'26&23,$(1(/75$7$0,(172'(/26352&(6266$/,9$/(62%6758&7,926 DYDOLDW &RQVXOWD7pFQLFD QRUPDO FXDQGR GLFKD REVWUXFFLyQ VH UHVROYLHVH $GHPiV HV LPSRUWDQWH FRQRFHUTXHFXDQGRVHHVFLQGHXQDJOiQGXODVXEPDQGLEXODUODSURGXFFLyQJOREDO GHVDOLYDHQWUHFRPLGDVVHUHGXFHHQXQSURYRFDQGRTXHHQWUHXQ\ XQ GH ORV SDFLHQWHV SUHVHQWHQ VHTXHGDG GH ERFD *HQHUDOPHQWH OD HVFLVLyQ GH OD JOiQGXOD SDUyWLGD QR FDXVD GLFKD VHTXHGDG GHELGR D TXH OD VHFUHFLyQ VDOLYDO GH UHSRVR QR VH PRGLILFD VXVWDQFLDOPHQWH DXQTXH VH KDQ LQIRUPDGRRWUDVFRPSOLFDFLRQHVJUDYHVFRPRGDxRGHOQHUYLRIDFLDO /D VLDORHQGRFRSLD VH KD GHVDUUROODGR FRQ HO SURSyVLWR GH RIUHFHU XQD WpFQLFD PtQLPDPHQWH LQYDVLYD \ GH SUHVHUYDFLyQ JODQGXODU \ HQ ORV ~OWLPRV DxRVKDWUDQVIRUPDGRHOPDQHMRGHOSDFLHQWHFRQSDWRORJtDVDOLYDOREVWUXFWLYD SURSRUFLRQDQGR XQ HQIRTXH UHODWLYDPHQWH QXHYR \ SURPHWHGRU DO SHUPLWLU OD YLVXDOL]DFLyQGLUHFWDGHOVLVWHPDGXFWDOODHOLPLQDFLyQGHFiOFXORVODGLODWDFLyQ GH HVWHQRVLV \ OD LUULJDFLyQ GH ORV FRQGXFWRV VDOLYDOHV HQ FLHUWDV HQIHUPHGDGHV LQIODPDWRULDV /D VLDORHQGRVFRSLD GLDJQyVWLFD VHUtD VXVFHSWLEOH GH VHU UHDOL]DGD HQ XQ PD\RUQ~PHURGHSHUVRQDVTXHODWHUDSpXWLFDTXHFRPRKHPRVYLVWRHQJOREDOD XWLOL]DFLyQ GH RWURV GLVSRVLWLYRV SLQ]DV PLQLIyUFHSV FHVWLOODV GH H[WUDFFLyQ GH FiOFXORV HWF \ GH SURFHGLPLHQWRV FRPR OD OLWRWULFLD H[WUD R LQWUDFRUSyUHD 'HVWDFDUWDPELpQHOSDSHOGHODVLDORHQGRVFRSLDGLDJQyVWLFDDOSHUPLWLUH[SORUDU HOHSLWHOLRGHUHYHVWLPLHQWRGHORVFRQGXFWRVVDOLYDOHV\HQRFDVLRQHVHQFRQWUDU FiOFXORV QR GLDJQRVWLFDGRV SRU RWURV PpWRGRV GH H[SORUDFLyQ UDGLRJUDItD WRPRJUDItDFRPSXWDUL]DGDRHFRJUDItD (Q UHODFLyQ DO SDSHO GH OD VLDORHQGRVFRSLD FRPR PHGLR GH SUHVHUYDFLyQ JODQGXODU UHVDOWDU HO HVWXGLR UHDOL]DGR SRU .RSHF HW DO HQ HO TXH VH FRPSDUy HO WUDWDPLHQWR GH OD VLDOROLWLDVLV VXEPDQGLEXODU DQWHV \ GHVSXpV GH GLVSRQHU GH OD WpFQLFD VLDORHQGRVFySLFD HQ OD SUiFWLFD FOtQLFD $QWHV GH VX LQWURGXFFLyQ IXHURQ WUDWDGRV SDFLHQWHV GH ORV TXH D VH OHV UHDOL]y XQD LQFLVLyQ WUDQVRUDO \ DO UHVWR XQD HVFLVLyQ JODQGXODU 3RVWHULRUPHQWH WUDWDURQSDFLHQWHVGHORVTXHDVHOHVH[WUDMRHOFiOFXOR~QLFDPHQWH PHGLDQWH VLDORHQGRVFRSLD D IXH QHFHVDULD XQD WpFQLFD FRPELQDGD GH VLDORHQGRVFRSLD H LQFLVLyQ WUDQVRUDO \ VyOR HQ FDVRV IXH QHFHVDULD XQD HVFLVLyQGHODJOiQGXOD (IHFWLYLGDG\VHJXULGDGGHODWpFQLFD (O DQiOLVLV FRQMXQWR GH ORV HVWXGLRV HQ ORV TXH OD WpFQLFD GH VLDORHQGRVFRSLD VH UHDOL]y GH IRUPD ~QLFD SURFHGLPLHQWRV PXHVWUD XQD HIHFWLYLGDGGHUHVROXFLyQGHODREVWUXFFLyQVDOLYDOGHOPLHQWUDVTXHFRQOD WpFQLFDFRPELQDGDUHDOL]DGDHQHVWXGLRVFRQFDVLVLDORHQGRVFRSLDVIXH GHO LQFOX\H VLDORHQGRVFRSLD SDUD YLVXDOL]DFLyQ \ ORFDOL]DFLyQ GH OD REVWUXFFLyQ VHJXLGD GH SDSLORWRPtD DSHUWXUD GHO GXFWR R LQFLVLyQ LQWUDRUDO R H[WHUQD VLQ HVFLVLyQ JODQGXODU VHJXLGD GH UHSDUDFLyQ R PDUVXSLDOL]DFLyQ GHO FRQGXFWR 6LQHPEDUJRHVWRVUHVXOWDGRVGHEHQWRPDUVHFRQSUHFDXFLyQGHELGRDOD EDMDFDOLGDGGHORVHVWXGLRVLQFOXLGRV\DODKHWHURJHQHLGDGTXHVHLQWURGXFHDO FRPELQDUHVWXGLRVFRQSRFDXQLIRUPLGDGHQVXVSREODFLRQHVRHQODPHWRGRORJtD $;(1&,$'($9$/,$&,Ð1'(7(&12/2;Ì$66$1,7$5,$6'(*$/,&,$ 'LVFXVLyQ 2WUR SXQWR GpELO HV OD YDULDELOLGDG REVHUYDGD HQ OD LQVWUXPHQWDFLyQ \ HQ ORV GLVSRVLWLYRVDFFHVRULRV$XQTXHDOJXQRVHVWXGLRVUHDOL]DURQXQVHJXLPLHQWRGHORV SDFLHQWHV FRQVLGHUDGR DGHFXDGR HQ RWURV FDVRV IXH PX\ HVFDVR QR SXGLHQGR YDORUDUODHIHFWLYLGDG\VHJXULGDGGHODWpFQLFDDODUJRSOD]R ,URHWDOREWXYLHURQPHMRUHVUHVXOWDGRVHQXQHVWXGLRREVHUYDFLRQDO SURVSHFWLYR\PXOWLFpQWULFRTXHHYDOXyORVUHVXOWDGRVGHOPDQHMRPtQLPDPHQWH LQYDVLYRGHFiOFXORVVDOLYDOHVHQSDFLHQWHV/RVDXWRUHVREVHUYDURQXQDWDVD GH p[LWR GHO FRQ OLWRWULFLD H[WHUQD GHO PHGLDQWH VLDORHQGRVFRSLD \ FHVWLOODVRPLFURIyUFHSVGHH[WUDFFLyQ\GHOFRQFLUXJtDLQWUDRUDOVLHQGROD WDVD GH HVFLVLRQHV JDQGXODUHV GHO (VWH HVWXGLR QR IXH HOHJLEOH SDUD OD LQFOXVLyQHQODUHYLVLyQVLVWHPiWLFDUHDOL]DGDSRU6WU\FKRZVN\HWDOGHELGR DTXHQRWRGRVORVSDFLHQWHVIXHURQVRPHWLGRVDXQDVLDORHQGRVFRSLD\ODSULPHUD OtQHD GH WUDWDPLHQWR IXH OD OLWRWULFLD H[WUDFRUSyUHD FRQ RQGDV GH FKRTXH R XWLOL]DFLyQ GH FHVWLOODV GH H[WUDFFLyQ R PLFURIyUFHSV EDMR JXtD IOXRURVFySLFD UDGLROyJLFDRVLDORHQGRVFySLFD 3DUD 1DKOLHOL \ %DUXFKLQ XQ SXQWR FUXFLDO HV OD H[LVWHQFLD GH GLIHUHQFLDVHQWUHODVLDOROLWLDVLVVXEPDQGLEXODU\SDURWtGHD(QPXFKRVFDVRVHO GHVDUUROOR GH FiOFXORV HQ OD JOiQGXOD SDUyWLGD HV VXEVHFXHQWH D XQD KLVWRULD SUHH[LVWHQWH GH SDURWLGLWLV FUyQLFD UHFXUUHQWH (Q JHQHUDO VH FRQVLGHUD TXH ORV FiOFXORV VLJXHQ \ QR SUHFHGHQ D OD SDURWLGLWLV FUyQLFD (VWR VLJQLILFD TXH HQ OD JOiQGXOD SDUyWLGD OD HOLPLQDFLyQ GH OD REVWUXFFLyQ QR VLHPSUH VLJQLILFD OD FXUDFLyQ VLHQGR LPSUHVFLQGLEOH HO VHJXLPLHQWR D ODUJR SOD]R GHO SDFLHQWH \ SRVLEOHPHQWHHOUHDOL]DUXQDVHJXQGDVLDORHQGRVFRSLD6LQHPEDUJRODJOiQGXOD VXEPDQGLEXODU WLHQH XQ H[FHOHQWH SRWHQFLDO GH FXUDFLyQ SRU OR TXH OD HOLPLQDFLyQ GH OD REVWUXFFLyQ GHO VLVWHPD GXFWDO JHQHUDOPHQWH VLJQLILFD OD UHVROXFLyQGHOFXDGUR )DFWRUHVTXHDIHFWDQDODHIHFWLYLGDG (OWDPDxRGHOFiOFXORHVXQIDFWRUUHODFLRQDGRFRQ HOUHVXOWDGRILQDOGHO SURFHGLPLHQWRGHPDQHUDTXHFRQFiOFXORVJUDQGHVHOp[LWRVXHOHVHUPHQRU 3RURWUDSDUWHH[LVWHQOLPLWDFLRQHVDOWDPDxRGHORVFiOFXORVVDOLYDOHVTXH SXHGHQ VHU H[WUDtGRV PHGLDQWH SLQ]DV R FHVWLOODV VLQ WpFQLFDV DGLFLRQDOHV GH IUDJPHQWDFLyQ $Vt OD VLDORHQGRVFRSLD PHGLDQWH FHVWLOODV GH H[WUDFFLyQ RIUHFH EXHQRVUHVXOWDGRVHQODHOLPLQDFLyQGHFiOFXORVGHKDVWDGHPPHQHOFDVRGH JOiQGXODV VXEPDQGLEXODUHV \ GH PP HQ SDUyWLGDV 6H KD REVHUYDGRXQPD\RUSRUFHQWDMHGHp[LWRFXDQGRHOFRFLHQWHHQWUHHOWDPDxRGHO FiOFXOR\HOGLiPHWURGHOFDQDOGHOHQGRVFRSLRHVEDMR /RVFiOFXORVPD\RUHVGHPPVLWXDGRVSURIXQGDPHQWHHQHOKLOLRRILMRV HQ SHTXHxDV GLYLVLRQHV GHO GXFWR VXHOHQ VHU GH GLItFLO H[WUDFFLyQ \ SDUD HVWRV FDVRV VH KDQ SXHVWR HQ PDUFKD WpFQLFDV DOWHUQDWLYDV FRPR OD OLWRWULFLD LQWUD \ H[WUDFRUSyUHD OD FLUXJtD WUDQVRUDO \ OD FLUXJtD WUDQVRUDO DVLVWLGDSRUHQGRVFRSLD /DHOLPLQDFLyQGHFiOFXORVPHGLDQWHOLWRWULFLDH[WHUQDHVPiVHIHFWLYDHQ ODJOiQGXODSDUyWLGDTXHHQODVXEPDQGLEXODU\GHDFXHUGRFRQOD /$6,$/2(1'26&23,$(1(/75$7$0,(172'(/26352&(6266$/,9$/(62%6758&7,926 DYDOLDW &RQVXOWD7pFQLFD OLWHUDWXUD KDVWD HO GH ORV SDFLHQWHV FRQ OLWLDVLV SDURWtGHD SXHGHQ VHU WUDWDGRV H[LWRVDPHQWH /RV FiOFXORV PD\RUHV GH PP GHGLiPHWURHLPSDFWDGRVHQODSDUHGGHOGXFWRWLHQHQSRFDVSUREDELOLGDGHVGH VHU HOLPLQDGRV ~QLFDPHQWH PHGLDQWH VLDORHQGRVFRSLD 6LQ HPEDUJRSXHGHQVHUIUDJPHQWDGRVPHGLDQWHOLWRWULFLDH[WHUQD\SRVWHULRUPHQWH H[WUDtGRVPHGLDQWHVLDORHQGRVFRSLD 2WURVDXWRUHVWDPELpQUHFRPLHQGDQUHDOL]DUOLWRWULFLDDQWHVGHLQWHQWDUOD H[WUDFFLyQ GH FiOFXORV PD\RUHV GH PP HQ HO FRQGXFWR VXEPDQGLEXODU R GH PP HQ HO FRQGXFWR SDURWtGHR KDELpQGRVH VXJHULGR TXH OD IRUPD \ RULHQWDFLyQ GHO VLDOROLWR SXHGHQ VHU SUHGLFWLYRV GHO p[LWR GH OD H[WUDFFLyQ HQGRVFySLFD (Q OD JOiQGXOD VXEPDQGLEXODU OD WHQGHQFLD HV D WUDWDU ORV FiOFXORV DORMDGRVHQODSDUWHPHGLDRSUR[LPDOGHOFRQGXFWRPHGLDQWHLQFLVLyQWUDQVRUDO PHMRU TXH FRQ OLWRWULFLD PLHQWUDV TXH HQ OD SDUyWLGD VH SUHILHUH OD OLWRWULFLD GHELGR DO ULHVJR GH OHVLyQ GHO QHUYLR IDFLDO \ D OD QHFHVLGDG GH XQ DERUGDMH TXLU~UJLFRH[WHUQR 6HJXULGDGGHOSURFHGLPLHQWR &RPR\DVHDSXQWyHQHODSDUWDGRGH5HVXOWDGRVHODQiOLVLVFRQMXQWRGH ORV HVWXGLRV LQFOXLGRV HQ HVWD UHYLVLyQ PRVWUy XQDWDVD GHHVFLVLyQ JODQGXODU GHO VLHQGR ORV HIHFWRV DGYHUVRV UHJLVWUDGRV SRFR IUHFXHQWHV \ GH EDMD JUDYHGDG (Q OD OLWHUDWXUD ODV FRPSOLFDFLRQHV JUDYHV FRQ OD VLDORHQGRVFRSLD WDPELpQVRQSRFRIUHFXHQWHV$Vt0DUFKDOHWDOQRREVHUYDURQQLQJXQDSDUiOLVLV IDFLDO QL KHPRUUDJLDV HQ PiV GH SURFHGLPLHQWRV UHDOL]DGRV VREUH JOiQGXODV SDUyWLGDVRVXEPDQGLEXODUHV &RPR\DVHKDYLVWRODVSULQFLSDOHVFRPSOLFDFLRQHVGHODVLDORHQGRVFRSLD VRQ ODV SDUHVWHVLDV OLQJXDOHV HGHPD GH VXHOR UiQXOD LQIHFFLyQ VDQJUDGR SHUIRUDFLyQGXFWDOOLJDGXUDGHOFRQGXFWRHWF 8Q HIHFWR DGYHUVR KDELWXDO GH OD VLDORHQGRVFRSLD HV OD VLDORDGHQLWLV R LQIODPDFLyQ JODQGXODU SRVWRSHUDWRULD TXH JHQHUDOPHQWH VH UHVXHOYH HQ KRUDV 6LQ HPEDUJR HQ ORV SURFHVRV VXEPDQGLEXODUHV HV LPSRUWDQWH WHQHU HVWH KHFKRHQ FRQVLGHUDFLyQ GHELGR D TXH ODLQIODPDFLyQ SXHGH FRPSURPHWHU OD YtD DpUHD (Q FRQVHFXHQFLD FXDQGR VH UHDOL]DQ SURFHGLPLHQWRV ELODWHUDOHV GH OD JOiQGXOD VXEPD[LODU HV LPSRUWDQWH H[DPLQDU OD JOiQGXOD \ OD FDYLGDG RUDO GHVSXpVGHUHDOL]DUHOSURFHGLPLHQWRHQXQODGR\GHWHUPLQDUVLHVVHJXURSDUD HO SDFLHQWH FRQWLQXDU FRQ OD JOiQGXOD FRQWUDODWHUDO 2WUD FRPSOLFDFLyQ UHODWLYDPHQWH IUHFXHQWH HV HO GHVDUUROOR GH HVWHQRVLV SRVWRSHUDWRULD TXH VH SURGXFHKDELWXDOPHQWHSRUXQGDxRHVWUXFWXUDOGHOFRQGXFWRRODSDSLODGXUDQWH HO SURFHGLPLHQWR (Q HVWRV FDVRV OD FRORFDFLyQ GH XQ VWHQW SRGUtD SUHYHQLU OD DSDULFLyQ GH OD HVWHQRVLV 3RU ~OWLPR RWUDV FRPSOLFDFLRQHV LQFOX\HQ OD LQFDSDFLGDG SDUD H[WUDHU HO FiOFXOR FRQ UHWHQFLyQ GH IUDJPHQWRV \ SUREOHPDV FRQHOHTXLSRFRPRODURWXUDRHOEORTXHRGHODFHVWD $;(1&,$'($9$/,$&,Ð1'(7(&12/2;Ì$66$1,7$5,$6'(*$/,&,$ 'LVFXVLyQ &DOLGDGGHYLGD\VDWLVIDFFLyQGHORVSDFLHQWHV /D SDWRORJtD REVWUXFWLYD GH ODV JOiQGXODV VDOLYDOHV VH DVRFLD FRQ XQ GHWHULRUR GH OD FDOLGDG GH YLGD GH ORV SDFLHQWHV DIHFWDGRV ,DQRYVNL HW DO OOHYDURQDFDERXQHVWXGLRHQHOTXHPLGLHURQODFDOLGDGGHYLGDGHSDFLHQWHV VRPHWLGRV D SURFHGLPLHQWRV GH VLDORHQGRVFRSLD PHGLDQWH HO FXHVWLRQDULR *ODVJRZ %HQHILW ,QYHQWRU\ *%, GH SUHJXQWDV XWLOL]DGR KDELWXDOPHQWH HQ SURFHGLPLHQWRVGH25//RVDXWRUHVREVHUYDURQTXHODVLDORHQGRVFRSLDJHQHUyHQ ORV SDFLHQWHV OD SHUFHSFLyQ GH XQ LPSRUWDQWH EHQHILFLR WDQWR HQ SDWRORJtD OLWLiVLFDFRPRHVWHQyWLFD 3RUVXSDUWH\HQSDFLHQWHVVRPHWLGRVDVLDORHQGRVFRSLD.UROOHWDO PLGLHURQ OD FDOLGDG GH YLGD PHGLDQWH HO FXHVWLRQDULR 6) )RUP +HDOWK 6XUYH\ \ OD VDWLVIDFFLyQ FRQ HO SURFHGLPLHQWR PHGLDQWH XQD HQFXHVWD /RV DXWRUHV REVHUYDURQ XQD LQIOXHQFLD QHJDWLYD HQ OD FDOLGDG GH YLGD GH IDFWRUHV FRPRHOVHUMRYHQRXQDODUJDGXUDFLyQGHORVVtQWRPDV\XQDDOWDVDWLVIDFFLyQHQ DTXHOORVFDVRVHQORVTXHVHHYLWyODHVFLVLyQJODQGXODU ,QGLFDFLRQHVGHODWpFQLFDFRVWH\FXUYDGHDSUHQGL]DMH /DV LQGLFDFLRQHV GH OD VLDORHQGRVFRSLD VRQ WRGRV DTXHOORV SURFHVRV REVWUXFWLYRV H LQIODPDWRULRV GH ODV JOiQGXODV VDOLYDOHV TXH VXHOHQ LQFOXLU ODV VLJXLHQWHVSDWRORJtDV • • • • • 6LDOROLWLDVLV 6LDORDGHQLWLVUHFXUUHQWHFUyQLFD 3DURWLGLWLVUHFXUUHQWHMXYHQLO 6LDORDGHQLWLVLQGXFLGDSRULRGRUDGLRDFWLYR (VWHQRVLVSRUVtQGURPHGH6M|JUHQ 1R H[LVWHQ FRQWUDLQGLFDFLRQHV HVSHFtILFDV GH OD WpFQLFD /DV SULQFLSDOHV OLPLWDFLRQHV WpFQLFDV VRQ OD SUHVHQFLD GH FiOFXORV VDOLYDOHV HQ XQD ORFDOL]DFLyQ JODQGXODUPX\SRVWHULRURXQFDQDOILEURVDGRGHUHGXFLGRGLiPHWURTXHLPSLGDHO DYDQFHGHOHQGRVFRSLR2WUDVGLILFXOWDGHVTXHVHSXHGHQHQFRQWUDUVRQGHELGDVD HVSDPR GHO FRQGXFWR HGHPD DFRGDPLHQWR GHO PLVPR R PDOSRVLFLyQ GH ORV LQFLVLYRVLQIHULRUHVTXHSXHGHQHQWRUSHFHUODWpFQLFD(QRFDVLRQHVXQGXFWRGH UHFRUULGR VLQXRVR SXHGH SRQHU FLHUWDV OLPLWDFLRQHV D ORV VLDORHQGRVFRSLRV VHPLUUtJLGRV IXQGDPHQWDOPHQWH HQ FXUYDWXUDV SURQXQFLDGDV DXQTXH ORV DFWXDOHV GLVSRVLWLYRV ´DOOLQRQHµ \ OD YDULHGDG GH WDPDxRV SHUPLWHQ OD H[SORUDFLyQGHFDVLWRGRVORVFRQGXFWRVVDOLYDOHV /DVLDORHQGRVFRSLDDOVHUPtQLPDPHQWHLQYDVLYDVHUHDOL]DJHQHUDOPHQWH GH IRUPD DPEXODWRULD FRQ HO SDFLHQWH SUHIHUHQWHPHQWH UHFRVWDGR OD SRVLFLyQ VHQWDGDVHDVRFLDFRQXQDXPHQWRGHOULHVJRGHVtQFRSHYDVRYDJDO &RPR UHJOD JHQHUDO OD VLDORHQGRVFRSLD GLDJQyVWLFD VH UHDOL]D EDMR DQHVWHVLDORFDOGHODSDSLOD\GHOVLVWHPDGXFWDO'HVSXpVGHODLQWURGXFFLyQGHO /$6,$/2(1'26&23,$(1(/75$7$0,(172'(/26352&(6266$/,9$/(62%6758&7,926 DYDOLDW &RQVXOWD7pFQLFD VLDORHQGRVFRSLR VH SXHGH UHDOL]DU XQD DQHVWHVLD GHO VLVWHPD GXFWDO PHGLDQWH XQD LUULJDFLyQ GH [LORFDtQD R OLGRFDtQD (Q HO FDVR GH OD VLDORHQGRVFRSLD LQWHUYHQFLRQLVWDRWHUDSpXWLFDODGHFLVLyQGHSHQGHUiGHOQLYHOGHGLILFXOWDGGH FDGDFDVRHQSDUWLFXODUSXGLHQGRRSWDUVHSRUXQDVHGDFLyQRLQFOXVRDQHVWHVLD JHQHUDO &RVWHGHODWpFQLFD 6HJ~QGDWRVDSRUWDGRVSRUODHPSUHVDGHGLVSRVLWLYRVGHHQGRVFRSLD.DUO 6WRU] FRQ IHFKD HO FRVWH GH XQ VLVWHPD VLDORHQGRVFRSLD GLDJQyVWLFRWHUDSpXWLFD VHUtD GH ½ ½ LQFOXLGR GH ,9$ TXH FRUUHVSRQGHUtDD • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • ÐSWLFDVHPLIOH[LEOHGHYLVLyQIURQWDOPP ÐSWLFDVHPLIOH[LEOHGHYLVLyQIURQWDOPP 6LVWHPDGHVXMHFFLyQFRQ]yFDOR\EUD]RDUWLFXODGR &DEOHGHOX]GHILEUDySWLFDPP 3LQ]DVH[WUDFFLyQFXHUSRVH[WUDxRVPP 3LQ]DVSDUDELRSVLDPP &HVWDGH'RUPLDDODPEUHVPP &HVWDGH'RUPLDDODPEUHVPP &HVWDGH'RUPLDDODPEUHVPP 0LFURSHUIRUDGRUSDUDFiOFXORVVDOLYDUHV &DWpWHUEDOyQPPXQLG 3LQ]DVDQDWyPLFDVDFRGDGDV 3LQ]DVTXLU~UJLFDVDFRGDGDV 7LMHUDVDQJXODGDVSDUDFRQGXFVDOLYDOHV 3LQ]DVKHPRVWiWLFDV %XMtDVPP 'LODWDGRU %DQGHMDPHWDOXQLG &HSLOORGHOLPSLH]DXQLGPP &HSLOORGHOLPSLH]DXQLGPP ½ ½ ½ ½ ½ ½ ½ ½ ½ ½ ½ ½ ½ ½ ½ ½ ½ ½ ½ ½ &XUYDGHDSUHQGL]DMH $ SHVDU GH VHU XQD WpFQLFD PtQLPDPHQWH LQYDVLYD OD VLDORHQGRVFRSLD UHTXLHUHXQDSUHQGL]DMHSUHYLRSDUDREYLDUORVSRWHQFLDOHVULHVJRVGHSHUIRUDFLyQ RGHGDxRYDVFXODURQHUYLRVR 6WHFN HW DO UHYLVDURQ UHWURVSHFWLYDPHQWH VLDORHQGRVFRSLDV GLDJQyVWLFDV TXH IXHURQ GLYLGLGDV HQ JUXSR $ IRUPDGR SRU ODV SULPHUDV \ JUXSR%ODVUHVWDQWHV6HREVHUYDURQGLIHUHQFLDVVLJQLILFDWLYDVHQWUHDPERV $;(1&,$'($9$/,$&,Ð1'(7(&12/2;Ì$66$1,7$5,$6'(*$/,&,$ 'LVFXVLyQ JUXSRVHQHOIDOORGHFDWHWHUL]DFLyQGHODSDSLODHOJUXSR$YVHOJUXSR %HOIUDFDVRGHFRPSOHWDUHOH[DPHQYV\ODQHFHVLGDGGHUHSHWLUOD SUXHEDYV/DWDVDJOREDOGHFRPSOLFDFLRQHVIXHGHOHQHOJUXSR$ \GHOHQHO%3DUDORVDXWRUHVODFXUYDGHDSUHQGL]DMHGHODWpFQLFDVHUtDGH SURFHGLPLHQWRV /XHUVHWDOHVWXGLDURQSURFHGLPLHQWRVGHVLDORHQGRVFRSLDVGHODV TXH HO IXHURQ GLDJQyVWLFDV \ HO UHVWRWHUDSpXWLFDV VLHQGR HO WLHPSR PHGLR GH OD LQWHUYHQFLyQ GH PLQXWRV 7UDV ORV SULPHURV SURFHGLPLHQWRV VH REVHUYyXQDPHMRUDVLJQLILFDWLYDHQHOWLHPSRUHTXHULGRSDUDODLQWHUYHQFLyQTXH YROYLy D UHSHWLUVH WUDV ORV SULPHURV FRQ XQD FRQWLQXD GLVPLQXFLyQ KDVWD ORV ~OWLPRVSDFLHQWHV3DUDHVWRVDXWRUHVVHQHFHVLWDQDOPHQRVFDVRVSDUDOOHJDU DWLHPSRVGHLQWHUYHQFLyQVDWLVIDFWRULRVFRQFRQWLQXDPHMRUDKDVWDHVWDELOL]DUVH GHVSXpVGHFDVRV 3RU ~OWLPR SDUD ,UR HW DO OD VLDORHQGRVFRSLD WHUDSpXWLFD GHEHUtD VHU UHDOL]DGD HQ FHQWURV HVSHFLDOL]DGRV FRQ XQD FREHUWXUD GH SREODFLyQ GH DOUHGHGRU PLOORQHV GH SHUVRQDV OR TXH SURSRUFLRQDUtD OD H[SHULHQFLD QHFHVDULDSDUDXWLOL]DUFRQp[LWRHVWHPpWRGRPtQLPDPHQWHLQYDVLYRV /$6,$/2(1'26&23,$(1(/75$7$0,(172'(/26352&(6266$/,9$/(62%6758&7,926 &RQFOXVLRQHV &21&/86,21(6 • /D VLDORHQGRVFRSLD HV XQD WpFQLFD GLDJQyVWLFRWHUDSpXWLFD PtQLPDPHQWH LQYDVLYD TXH SHUPLWH OD YLVXDOL]DFLyQ GLUHFWD GHO FRQGXFWR VDOLYDO \ HO WUDWDPLHQWRGHSDWRORJtDVDOLYDOREVWUXFWLYDFRQSUHVHUYDFLyQJODQGXODU • /DHYLGHQFLDFLHQWtILFDGLVSRQLEOHDFHUFDGHODHIHFWLYLGDG\VHJXULGDGGH HVWD WpFQLFD VH EDVD HQ HVWXGLRV REVHUYDFLRQDOHV DOJXQRV GH HOORV FRQ OLPLWDFLRQHVPHWRGROyJLFDV • $SHVDUGHHOORORVUHVXOWDGRVVRQFRQVLVWHQWHVUHVSHFWRGHODHIHFWLYLGDG GHODWpFQLFDDODKRUDGHUHVROYHUODREVWUXFFLyQ VDOLYDOVLHQGRGHO FXDQGR VH XWLOL]D GH IRUPD ~QLFD R GHO VL VH UHDOL]D FRPELQDGD FRQ FLUXJtD $GHPiV OD VLDORHQGRVFRSLD GLVPLQX\H GH IRUPD LPSRUWDQWH HO Q~PHUR GH VLDORDGHQHFWRPtDV VLHQGR VXV HIHFWRV DGYHUVRV SRFR IUHFXHQWHV\GHEDMDJUDYHGDG • /DVSULQFLSDOHVLQGLFDFLRQHVGHODVLDORHQGRVFRSLDVRQ o o o o o 6LDOROLWLDVLV 6LDORDGHQLWLVUHFXUUHQWHFUyQLFD 3DURWLGLWLVUHFXUUHQWHMXYHQLO 6LDORDGHQLWLVLQGXFLGDSRULRGRUDGLRDFWLYR (VWHQRVLVSRUVtQGURPHGH6M|JUHQ • (QHOFDVRGHODVLDOROLWLDVLVH[LVWHQOLPLWDFLRQHVDOWDPDxRGHORVFiOFXORV VDOLYDOHVTXHSXHGHQVHUH[WUDtGRVPHGLDQWHSLQ]DVRFHVWLOODVVLHQGRGH KDVWD GH PP HQ HO FDVR GH JOiQGXODV VXEPDQGLEXODUHV \ GH PP HQ SDUyWLGDV (Q WDPDxRV VXSHULRUHV SXHGHQ VHU QHFHVDULDV WpFQLFDV DOWHUQDWLYDVFRPRODOLWRWULFLDLQWUDRH[WUDFRUSyUHDODFLUXJtDWUDQVRUDO\ ODFLUXJtDWUDQVRUDODVLVWLGDSRUHQGRVFRSLD • /D VLDORHQGRVFRSLD VH UHDOL]D JHQHUDOPHQWH GH IRUPD DPEXODWRULD FRQ DQHVWHVLDORFDOHQODGLDJQyVWLFD\FRQVHGDFLyQRDQHVWHVLDJHQHUDOHQOD WHUDSpXWLFD • &RPR FXDOTXLHU WpFQLFD LQWHUYHQFLRQLVWD OD VLDORHQGRVFRSLD WLHQH XQD FXUYDGHDSUHQGL]DMHTXHSRGUtDRVFLODUHQWUHORV\SURFHGLPLHQWRV /$6,$/2(1'26&23,$(1(/75$7$0,(172'(/26352&(6266$/,9$/(62%6758&7,926 $QH[RV $1(;26 $QH[R(VWUDWHJLDVGHE~VTXHGDELEOLRJUiILFD %$6(6'('$726(63(&,$/,=$'$6(15(9,6,21(66,67(0É7,&$6 +7$UHI 6LDOHQGRVFRS 6LDORHQGRVFRS 25 &RFKUDQHUHI 6LDOHQGRVFRS 6LDORHQGRVFRS 25 &RFKUDQH/LEUDU\3OXVB5HFXUVRVHQHVSDxROUHI 6LDOHQGRVFRS 6LDORHQGRVFRS 25 %$6(6'('$726*(1(5$/(6 0('/,1(3XEPHGUHI 6LDOHQGRVFRS 6LDORHQGRVFRS 25 (0%$6(2YLGUHI 6LDOHQGRVFRS 6LDORHQGRVFRS 25 OHWWHU25HGLWRULDO25&RQJUHVV25&RQIHUHQFH253URFHHGLQJ250HHWLQJ 127 :HERIVFLHQFH:HERI.QRZOHGJHUHI 76 6LDOHQGRVFRS 76 6LDORHQGRVFRS 25([FOXGH/HWWHU25&RQIHUHQFH253URFHHGLQJV25(GLWRULDO /$6,$/2(1'26&23,$(1(/75$7$0,(172'(/26352&(6266$/,9$/(62%6758&7,926 DYDOLDW &RQVXOWD7pFQLFD ,0(ÌQGLFH0pGLFR(VSDxROH,%(&6UHI 6LDOHQGRVFRS 6LDORHQGRVFRS 25 5HSRVLWRULRVUHI • 5HFROHFWD 6LDOHQGRVFRSLD VLDORHQGRVFRSLD VLDORHQGRVFRS VLDORHQGRVFRSLFVLDORHQGRVFRSLHVUHI • 'LDOQHW 6LDOHQGRVFRSLD VLDORHQGRVFRSLD VLDORHQGRVFRS VLDORHQGRVFRSLFVLDORHQGRVFRSLHVUHI VLDORHQGRVFRS\ VLDORHQGRVFRS\ %$6(6'('$726'((16$<26&/Ì1,&26 &OLQLFDOWULDOVJRYUHI 6LDOHQGRVFRS 6LDORHQGRVFRS 25 $;(1&,$'($9$/,$&,Ð1'(7(&12/2;Ì$66$1,7$5,$6'(*$/,&,$ $QH[RV $QH[R1LYHOHVGHHYLGHQFLDGHO6,*1 1LYHOHVGHHYLGHQFLD 0HWDQiOLVLVUHYLVLRQHVVLVWHPiWLFDVGHHQVD\RVFOtQLFRVRHQVD\RVFOtQLFRV GHDOWDFDOLGDGFRQPX\SRFRULHVJRGHVHVJR 0HWDQiOLVLVUHYLVLRQHVVLVWHPiWLFDVGHHQVD\RVFOtQLFRVRHQVD\RVFOtQLFRV ELHQUHDOL]DGRVFRQSRFRULHVJRGHVHVJR 0HWDQiOLVLVUHYLVLRQHVVLVWHPiWLFDVGHHQVD\RVFOtQLFRVRHQVD\RVFOtQLFRV FRQDOWRULHVJRGHVHVJR 5HYLVLRQHVVLVWHPiWLFDVGHHVWXGLRVGHFRKRUWHVRGHFDVRV\FRQWUROHVR HVWXGLRV GH SUXHEDV GLDJQyVWLFDV GH DOWD FDOLGDG HVWXGLRVGHFRKRUWHVR GH FDVRV \ FRQWUROHV GH SUXHEDV GLDJQyVWLFDV GH DOWD FDOLGDG FRQ ULHVJR PX\ EDMR GH VHVJR \ FRQ DOWD SUREDELOLGDG GH HVWDEOHFHU XQD UHODFLyQ FDXVDO (VWXGLRV GH FRKRUWHV R GH FDVRV \ FRQWUROHV R HVWXGLRV GH SUXHEDV GLDJQyVWLFDVELHQUHDOL]DGDVFRQEDMRULHVJRGHVHVJR\FRQXQDPRGHUDGD SUREDELOLGDGGHHVWDEOHFHUXQDUHODFLyQFDXVDO (VWXGLRVGHFRKRUWHVRGHFDVRV\FRQWUROHVFRQDOWRULHVJRGHVHVJR (VWXGLRVQRDQDOtWLFRVFRPRLQIRUPHVGHFDVRV\VHULHVGHFDVRV 2SLQLyQGHH[SHUWRV )XHQWH 6FRWWLVK ,QWHUFROOHJLDWH *XLGHOLQHV 1HWZRUN )RUPLQJ JXLGHOLQH UHFRPPHQGDWLRQV (Q 6,*1$JXLGHOLQHGHYHORSHHUVKDQGERRN(GLQEXUJK6,*1 /$6,$/2(1'26&23,$(1(/75$7$0,(172'(/26352&(6266$/,9$/(62%6758&7,926 $QH[RV $QH[R(VWXGLRVH[FOXLGRV 5HIHUHQFLDELEOLRJUiILFD 6FKQHLGHU+.RFK0.XQ]HO-*LOOHVSLH0% *UXQGWQHU3,UR+HWDO-XYHQLOHUHFXUUHQW SDURWLWLVDUHWURVSHFWLYHFRPSDULVRQRI VLDOHQGRVFRS\YHUVXVFRQVHUYDWLYHWKHUDS\ /DU\QJRVFRSH)HE 5D]yQGHH[FOXVLyQ 1RDSRUWDQLQJXQDGHODV YDULDEOHVGHUHVXOWDGR LQFOXLGDV =HQN - .RFK 0 0DQWVRSRXORV . .OLQWZRUWK 1 6FKDSKHU 0 ,UR + 7KH VLJQLILFDQFH RI H[WUDFRUSRUHDO VKRFN ZDYH OLWKRWULSV\ LQ VLDOROLWKLDVLVWKHUDS\+QR ,GLRPDQRFRQWHPSODGR 6WHFN-+%HUWHOOL+'+RHSSQHU&$9ROSL( 9DVFRQFHORV(&:KDWLVWKHOHDUQLQJFXUYHRI VLDORHQGRVFRS\" 2WRODU\QJRORJ\ +HDG DQG 1HFN6XUJHU\8QLWHG6WDWHV3 &RPXQLFDFLyQD&RQJUHVR 5XELR3DODX - &DVWUR&RUPHQ]DQD 9 )HUUHU )XHUWHV $ *DUFLD'LH] ( 0DUWL3DJHV & 6LHLUD*LO 5 6LDORHQGRVFRS\ 6XUJLFDO WHFKQLTXHDQGWUHDWPHQWSURWRFROLQDVHULHV RI SDWLHQWV ,QWHUQDWLRQDO -RXUQDO RI 2UDO DQG 0D[LOORIDFLDO 6XUJHU\ &RPXQLFDFLyQD&RQJUHVR 3KLOOLSV -' :LWKURZ . /DVHUDVVLVWHG OLWKRWULSV\ LQ WKH PLQLPDOO\ LQYDVLYH WUHDWPHQW RI VLDOROLWKLDVLV 2WRODU\QJRORJ\ +HDGDQG1HFN6XUJHU\8QLWHG6WDWHV 33 &RPXQLFDFLyQD&RQJUHVR 0RGHVW0&*DOLQDW/5DELQRZLW]0&XUU\- 5RVHQ ' &RJQHWWL '0 6LDOHQGRVFRS\ RXWFRPHV $ VWXG\ RI RYHU QRUWK DPHULFDQ SDWLHQWV IRU EHQLJQ VDOLYDU\ JODQG GLVRUGHUV 2WRODU\QJRORJ\ +HDG DQG 1HFN 6XUJHU\8QLWHG6WDWHV3 &RPXQLFDFLyQD&RQJUHVR 0DPDLV & :LOOLDPV & 'DYLHV . 0XQLU 1 6KHKDWD16LDOHQGRVFRS\DXGLW,QWHUQDWLRQDO -RXUQDORI6XUJHU\ &RPXQLFDFLyQD&RQJUHVR /$6,$/2(1'26&23,$(1(/75$7$0,(172'(/26352&(6266$/,9$/(62%6758&7,926 DYDOLDW 5HIHUHQFLDELEOLRJUiILFD &RQVXOWD7pFQLFD 5D]yQGHH[FOXVLyQ .RSHOLRYLFK'1DKOLHOL2&RPELQHGH[WHUQDO OLWKRWULSV\ DQG HQGRVFRSLF WHFKQLTXHV IRU DGYDQFHG VLDOROLWKLDVLV FDVHVORQJ WHUP UHVXOWV ,QWHUQDWLRQDO -RXUQDO RI 2UDO DQG 0D[LOORIDFLDO6XUJHU\ &RPXQLFDFLyQD&RQJUHVR &KXDQJTL<X&KL</LQJ\DQ=6LDOHQGRVFRSLF ILQGLQJV LQ SDWLHQWV ZLWK REVWUXFWLYH VLDODGHQLWLV ORQJWHUP H[SHULHQFH %U - 2UDO 0D[LOORIDF6XUJ 1RDSRUWDQLQJXQDGHODV YDULDEOHVGHUHVXOWDGR LQFOXLGDV *DOOR $ 0DUWHOOXFFL 6 'H 9LQFHQWLLV 0 *DOOLSROL & 5RVDWR & %HQHGHWWL )1 6LDORHQGRVFRSLF ILQGLQJV LQ QRQOLWKLDVLF VLDORDGHQLWLV2WRODU\QJRORJ\+HDGDQG1HFN 6XUJHU\8QLWHG6WDWHV3 &RPXQLFDFLyQD&RQJUHVR &URVKHU 5 0RKDPPHG$OL 5 %ORUH & 6LDOHQGRVFRS\5HVXOWVRID\HDUSURVSHFWLYH VWXG\ %ULWLVK -RXUQDO RI 2UDO DQG 0D[LOORIDFLDO6XUJHU\6 &RPXQLFDFLyQD&RQJUHVR =HQN-.OLQWZRUWK1%R]]DWR$,UR+.RFK 0 6LDOHQGRVFRS\ LQ WKH WUHDWPHQW RI RYHU VLDOROLWKV 2WRODU\QJRORJ\ +HDG DQG 1HFN6XUJHU\ &RPXQLFDFLyQD&RQJUHVR *LOOHVSLH 0% .RFK 0 ,UR + =HQN - (QGRVFRSLF$VVLVWHG *ODQG3UHVHUYLQJ 7KHUDS\ IRU &KURQLF 6LDODGHQLWLV $ *HUPDQ DQG 86 &RPSDULVRQ $UFK 2WRODU\QJRO +HDG 1HFN6XUJ>$UWLFOH@6HS 1RDSRUWDQLQJXQDGHODV YDULDEOHVGHUHVXOWDGR LQFOXLGDV $;(1&,$'($9$/,$&,Ð1'(7(&12/2;Ì$66$1,7$5,$6'(*$/,&,$ %LEOLRJUDItD %,%/,2*5$)Ì$ 1. Fazio SB, Emerick K. UpToDate. Salivary gland stones [Internet]. Wolters Kluwers [actualizado 2 ene 2013; citado 28 mar 2014]. aprox. 2 pantallas. Disponible en: http://www.uptodate.com.mergullador.sergas.es:2048/contents/salivary-glandstones?source=search_result&search=sialoendoscopia&selectedTitle=1~1 2. Zenk J, Hosemann WG, Iro H. Diameters of the main excretory ducts of the adult human submandibular and parotid gland: a histologic study. Oral Surg Oral Med Oral Pathol Oral Radiol Endod. 1998;85(5):576-80. 3. Marchal F, Dulguerov P, Becker M, Barki G, Disant F, Lehmann W. Specificity of parotid sialendoscopy. Laryngoscope. 2001;111(2):264-71. 4. Epker BN. Obstructive and inflammatory diseases of the major salivary glands. Oral Surg Oral Med Oral Pathol. 1972;33(1):2-27. 5. Rauch S, Gorlin RJ. Diseases of the salivary glands. En: Gorlin RJ, Goldman HM, eds. Thoma’s Oral Pathology. 6 ed. St Louis: Mosby; 1970. p. 997-1003. 6. Escudier MP, McGurk M. Symptomatic sialoadenitis and sialolithiasis in the English population, an estimate of the cost of hospital treatment. Br Dent J. 1999;186(9):463-6. 7. McGurk M, Escudier MP, Brown JE. Modern management of salivary calculi. Br J Surg. 2005;92(1):107-12. 8. Lustmann J, Regev E, Melamed Y. Sialolithiasis. A survey on 245 patients and a review of the literature. Int J Oral Maxillofac Surg. 1990;19(3):135-8. 9. Nahlieli O, Eliav E, Hasson O, Zagury A, Baruchin AM. Pediatric sialolithiasis. Oral Surg Oral Med Oral Pathol Oral Radiol Endod. 2000;90(6):709-12. 10. Bodner L. Salivary gland calculi: diagnostic imaging and surgical management. Compendium. 1993;14(5):572-86. 11. Bodner L. Giant salivary gland calculi: diagnostic imaging and surgical management. Oral Surg Oral Med Oral Pathol Oral Radiol Endod. 2002;94(3):3203. 12. Ledesma-Montes C, Garces-Ortiz M, Salcido-Garcia JF, Hernandez-Flores F, Hernandez-Guerrero JC. Giant sialolith: case report and review of the literature. J Oral Maxillofac Surg. 2007;65(1):128-30. /$6,$/2(1'26&23,$(1(/75$7$0,(172'(/26352&(6266$/,9$/(62%6758&7,926 DYDOLDW &RQVXOWD7pFQLFD 13. Capaccio P, Bottero A, Pompilio M, Ottaviani F. Conservative transoral removal of hilar submandibular salivary calculi. Laryngoscope. 2005;115(4):750-2. 14. Marchal F, Kurt AM, Dulguerov P, Lehmann W. Retrograde theory in sialolithiasis formation. Arch Otolaryngol Head Neck Surg. 2001;127(1):66-8. 15. Yuasa K, Nakhyama E, Ban S, Kawazu T, Chikui T, Shimizu M, et al. Submandibular gland duct endoscopy. Diagnostic value for salivary duct disorders in comparison to conventional radiography, sialography, and ultrasonography. Oral Surg Oral Med Oral Pathol Oral Radiol Endod. 1997;84(5):578-81. 16. Koch M, Zenk J, Bozzato A, Bumm K, Iro H. Sialoscopy in cases of unclear swelling of the major salivary glands. Otolaryngol Head Neck Surg. 2005;133(6):863-8. 17. Yoshimura Y, Inoue Y, Odagawa T. Sonographic examination of sialolithiasis. J Oral Maxillofac Surg. 1989;47(9):907-12. 18. Ariji Y, Yuasa H, Ariji E. High-frequency color Doppler sonography of the submandibular gland: relationship between salivary secretion and blood flow. Oral Surg Oral Med Oral Pathol Oral Radiol Endod. 1998;86(4):476-81. 19. Ngu RK, Brown JE, Whaites EJ, Drage NA, Ng SY, Makdissi J. Salivary duct strictures: nature and incidence in benign salivary obstruction. Dentomaxillofac Radiol. 2007;36(2):63-7. 20. Brown AL, Shepherd D, Buckenham TM. Per oral balloon sialoplasty: results in the treatment of salivary duct stenosis. Cardiovasc Intervent Radiol. 1997;20(5):337-42. 21. Rose SS. A clinical and radiological survey of 192 cases of recurrent swellings of the salivary glands. Ann R Coll Surg Engl. 1954;15(6):374-401. 22. Patey DH. Inflammation of the Salivary Glands with Particular Reference to Chronic and Recurrent Parotitis. Ann R Coll Surg Engl. 1965 Jan;36:26-44. 23. Marchal F, Dulguerov P. Sialolithiasis management: the state of the art. Arch Otolaryngol Head Neck Surg. 2003;129(9):951-6. 24. Becker M, Marchal F, Becker CD, Dulguerov P, Georgakopoulos G, Lehmann W, et al. Sialolithiasis and salivary ductal stenosis: diagnostic accuracy of MR sialography with a three-dimensional extended-phase conjugate-symmetry rapid spin-echo sequence. Radiology. 2000;217(2):347-58. $;(1&,$'($9$/,$&,Ð1'(7(&12/2;Ì$66$1,7$5,$6'(*$/,&,$ %LEOLRJUDItD 25. Dulguerov P, Marchal F, Lehmann W. Postparotidectomy facial nerve paralysis: possible etiologic factors and results with routine facial nerve monitoring. Laryngoscope. 1999;109(5):754-62. 26. Hald J, Andreassen UK. Submandibular gland excision: short- and long-term complications. ORL J Otorhinolaryngol Relat Spec. 1994;56(2):87-91. 27. Beahrs OH. The Facial Nerve in Parotid Surgery. Surg Clin North Am. 1963;43:973-7. 28. Capaccio P, Torretta S, Pignataro L. The role of adenectomy for salivary gland obstructions in the era of sialendoscopy and lithotripsy. Otolaryngol Clin North Am. 2009;42(6):1161-71. 29. Mandel L, Kaynar A. Surgical bypass of submandibular duct stricture. Oral Surg Oral Med Oral Pathol Oral Radiol Endod. 1999;88(5):532-3. 30. Iro H, Schneider T, Nitsche N, Waitz G, Ell C. Extracorporeal piezoelectric lithotripsy of salivary calculi. Initial clinical experiences. Hno. 1990;38(7):251-5. 31. Escudier MP, Brown JE, Drage NA, McGurk M. Extracorporeal shockwave lithotripsy in the management of salivary calculi. Br J Surg. 2003;90(4):482-5. 32. Iro H, Zenk J, Waldfahrer F, Benzel W, Schneider T, Ell C. Extracorporeal shock wave lithotripsy of parotid stones. Results of a prospective clinical trial. Ann Otol Rhinol Laryngol. 1998;107(10 Pt 1):860-4. 33. Ottaviani F, Capaccio P, Rivolta R, Cosmacini P, Pignataro L, Castagnone D. Salivary gland stones: US evaluation in shock wave lithotripsy. Radiology. 1997;204(2):437-41. 34. Brown JE. Minimally invasive techniques for the treatment of benign salivary gland obstruction. Cardiovasc Intervent Radiol. 2002;25(5):345-51. 35. Drage NA, Brown JE, Escudier MP, McGurk M. Interventional radiology in the removal of salivary calculi. Radiology. 2000;214(1):139-42. 36. Yoshino N, Hosokawa A, Sasaki T, Yoshioka T. Interventional radiology for the non-surgical removal of sialoliths. Dentomaxillofac Radiol. 1996;25(5):242-6. 37. Marchal F, Becker M, Dulguerov P, Lehmann W. Interventional sialendoscopy. Laryngoscope. 2000;110(2 Pt 1):318-20. 38. Nahlieli O, Baruchin AM. Endoscopic technique for the diagnosis and treatment of obstructive salivary gland diseases. J Oral Maxillofac Surg. 1999;57(12):1394-401; discussion 401-2. /$6,$/2(1'26&23,$(1(/75$7$0,(172'(/26352&(6266$/,9$/(62%6758&7,926 DYDOLDW &RQVXOWD7pFQLFD 39. Katz P. [Endoscopy of the salivary glands]. Ann Radiol (Paris). 1991;34(12):110-3. 40. Luers JC, Stenner M, Schinke M, Helmstaedter V, Beutner D. Tolerability of sialendoscopy under local anesthesia. Ann Otol Rhinol Laryngol. 2012;121(4):26974. 41. Nahlieli O, Baruchin AM. Long-term experience with endoscopic diagnosis and treatment of salivary gland inflammatory diseases. Laryngoscope. 2000;110(6):988-93. 42. Wilson M, McMullen K, Walvekar RR. Sialendoscopy: Endoscopic Approach to Benign Salivary Gland Diseases. Advances in Endoscopic Surgery. Prof. Cornel Iancu (Ed.), 2011. ISBN: 978-953-307-717-8, InTech. Disponible en: http://www.intechopen.com/books/advances-in-endoscopicsurgery/sialendoscopyendoscopic-approach-to-benign-salivary-gland-diseases. 43. Nahlieli O, Nakar LH, Nazarian Y, Turner MD. Sialoendoscopy: A new approach to salivary gland obstructive pathology. J Am Dent Assoc. 2006;137(10):1394-400. 44. Nahlieli O, Shacham R, Yoffe B, Eliav E. Diagnosis and treatment of strictures and kinks in salivary gland ducts. J Oral Maxillofac Surg. 2001;59(5):484-90; discussion, 90-2. 45. Jiang L, Zhang Y, Liu DG, Zhang L, Zhang ZY, Yu GY. [Sialoendoscopicallyassisted sialolithectomy for the hilar stones of the Wharton's duct]. Zhonghua Kou Qiang Yi Xue Za Zhi. 2012 Mar;47(3):157-9. 46. National Institute for Health and Clinical Excellence. Interventional procedure overview of therapeutic sialendoscopy. Interventional Procedures Programm (IPG218). Manchester: NICE; 2007. Disponible en: http://www.nice.org.uk/nicemedia/live/11289/31716/31716.pdf. 47. Lizaur Ajuria B, Barona Dorado C, Leco Berrocal MI, Fernández Cáliz F, Martínez González JM. Sialoendoscopia en las patologías obstructivas de las glándulas salivales. Científica dental: Revista científica de formación continuada. 2012;9(2):75-80. 48. Canzi P, Occhini A, Pagella F, Marchal F, Benazzo M. Sialendoscopy in juvenile recurrent parotitis: a review of the literature. Acta Otorhinolaryngol Ital. 2013 Dec;33(6):367-73. 49. Strychowsky JE, Sommer DD, Gupta MK, Cohen N, Nahlieli O. Sialendoscopy for the management of obstructive salivary gland disease: a systematic review and meta-analysis. Arch Otolaryngol Head Neck Surg. 2012 Jun;138(6):541-7. $;(1&,$'($9$/,$&,Ð1'(7(&12/2;Ì$66$1,7$5,$6'(*$/,&,$ %LEOLRJUDItD 50. Konigsberger R, Feyh J, Goetz A, Kastenbauer E. Endoscopically-controlled electrohydraulic intracorporeal shock wave lithotripsy (EISL) of salivary stones. J Otolaryngol. 1993;22(1):12-3. 51. Arzoz E, Santiago A, Esnal F, Palomero R. Endoscopic intracorporeal lithotripsy for sialolithiasis. J Oral Maxillofac Surg. 1996;54(7):847-50; discussion 51-2. 52. Marchal F, Dulguerov P, Becker M, Barki G, Disant F, Lehmann W. Submandibular diagnostic and interventional sialendoscopy: new procedure for ductal disorders. Ann Otol Rhinol Laryngol. 2002;111(1):27-35. 53. Chu DW, Chow TL, Lim BH, Kwok SP. Endoscopic management of submandibular sialolithiasis. Surg Endosc. 2003 Jun;17(6):876-9. 54. Zenk J, Koch M, Bozzato A, Iro H. Sialoscopy--initial experiences with a new endoscope. Br J Oral Maxillofac Surg. 2004;42(4):293-8. 55. Ziegler CM, Steveling H, Seubert M, Muhling J. Endoscopy: a minimally invasive procedure for diagnosis and treatment of diseases of the salivary glands. Six years of practical experience. Br J Oral Maxillofac Surg. 2004 Feb;42(1):1-7. 56. McGurk M, MacBean AD, Fan KF, Sproat C, Darwish C. Endoscopically assisted operative retrieval of parotid stones. Br J Oral Maxillofac Surg. 2006;44(2):157-60. 57. Raif J, Vardi M, Nahlieli O, Gannot I. An Er:YAG laser endoscopic fiber delivery system for lithotripsy of salivary stones. Lasers Surg Med. 2006 Jul;38(6):580-7. 58. Nahlieli O, Shacham R, Zagury A, Bar T, Yoffe B. The ductal stretching technique: an endoscopic-assisted technique for removal of submandibular stones. Laryngoscope. 2007;117(6):1031-5. 59. Koch M, Iro H, Zenk J. Role of sialoscopy in the treatment of Stensen's duct strictures. Ann Otol Rhinol Laryngol. 2008;117(4):271-8. 60. Papadaki ME, McCain JP, Kim K, Katz RL, Kaban LB, Troulis MJ. Interventional sialoendoscopy: early clinical results. J Oral Maxillofac Surg. 2008;66(5):954-62. 61. Walvekar RR, Razfar A, Carrau RL, Schaitkin B. Sialendoscopy and associated complications: a preliminary experience. Laryngoscope. 2008 May;118(5):776-9. /$6,$/2(1'26&23,$(1(/75$7$0,(172'(/26352&(6266$/,9$/(62%6758&7,926 DYDOLDW &RQVXOWD7pFQLFD 62. Yu CQ, Yang C, Zheng LY, Wu DM, Zhang J, Yun B. Selective management of obstructive submandibular sialadenitis. Br J Oral Maxillofac Surg. 2008 Jan;46(1):46-9. 63. Yu C, Zheng L, Yang C, Shen N. Causes of chronic obstructive parotitis and management by sialoendoscopy. Oral Surg Oral Med Oral Pathol Oral Radiol Endod. 2008;105(3):365-70. 64. Liu DG, Zhang ZY, Zhang Y, Zhang L, Yu GY. Diagnosis and management of sialolithiasis with a semirigid endoscope. Oral Surg Oral Med Oral Pathol Oral Radiol Endod. 2009;108(1):9-14. 65. Nahlieli O. Endoscopic surgery of the salivary glands. Alpha Omegan. 2009;102(2):55-60. 66. Walvekar RR, Bomeli SR, Carrau RL, Schaitkin B. Combined approach technique for the management of large salivary stones. Laryngoscope. 2009 Jun;119(6):1125-9. 67. Karavidas K, Nahlieli O, Fritsch M, McGurk M. Minimal surgery for parotid stones: a 7-year endoscopic experience. Int J Oral Maxillofac Surg. 2010 Jan;39(1):1-4. 68. Koch M, Bozzato A, Iro H, Zenk J. Combined endoscopic and transcutaneous approach for parotid gland sialolithiasis: indications, technique, and results. Otolaryngol Head Neck Surg. 2010 Jan;142(1):98-103. 69. Nahlieli O, Shacham R, Zaguri A. Combined external lithotripsy and endoscopic techniques for advanced sialolithiasis cases. J Oral Maxillofac Surg. 2010 Feb;68(2):347-53. 70. Serbetci E, Sengor GA. Sialendoscopy: experience with the first 60 glands in Turkey and a literature review. Ann Otol Rhinol Laryngol. 2010 Mar;119(3):155-64. 71. Su YX, Liao GQ, Zheng GS, Liu HC, Liang YJ, Ou DM. Sialoendoscopically assisted open sialolithectomy for removal of large submandibular hilar calculi. J Oral Maxillofac Surg. 2010 Jan;68(1):68-73. 72. Wallace E, Tauzin M, Hagan J, Schaitkin B, Walvekar RR. Management of giant sialoliths: review of the literature and preliminary experience with interventional sialendoscopy. Laryngoscope. 2010 Oct;120(10):1974-8. 73. Yu C, Yang C, Zheng L, Wu D. Endoscopic observation and strategic management of obstructive submandibular sialadenitis. J Oral Maxillofac Surg. 2010 Aug;68(8):1770-5. $;(1&,$'($9$/,$&,Ð1'(7(&12/2;Ì$66$1,7$5,$6'(*$/,&,$ %LEOLRJUDItD 74. Ardekian L, Shamir D, Trabelsi M, Peled M. Chronic obstructive parotitis due to strictures of Stenson's duct--our treatment experience with sialoendoscopy. J Oral Maxillofac Surg. 2010 Jan;68(1):83-7. 75. Bowen MA, Tauzin M, Kluka EA, Nuss DW, DiLeo M, McWhorter AJ, et al. Diagnostic and interventional sialendoscopy: a preliminary experience. Laryngoscope. 2011 Feb;121(2):299-303. 76. Capaccio P, Clemente IA, McGurk M, Bossi A, Pignataro L. Transoral removal of hiloparenchymal submandibular calculi: A long-term clinical experience. European Archives of Oto-Rhino-Laryngology. 2011 July;268(7):1081-6. 77. Danquart J, Wagner N, Arndal H, Homoe P. Sialoendoscopy for diagnosis and treatment of non-neoplastic obstruction in the salivary glands. Dan Med Bull. 2011 Feb;58(2):A4232. 78. Gillespie MB, Intaphan J, Nguyen SA. Endoscopic-assisted management of chronic sialadenitis. Head and Neck. 2011 September;33(9):1346-51. 79. Luers JC, Grosheva M, Stenner M, Beutner D. Sialoendoscopy: prognostic factors for endoscopic removal of salivary stones. Arch Otolaryngol Head Neck Surg. 2011 Apr;137(4):325-9. 80. Maresh A, Kutler DI, Kacker A. Sialoendoscopy in the diagnosis and management of obstructive sialadenitis. Laryngoscope. 2011 Mar;121(3):495-500. 81. Durbec M, Dinkel E, Vigier S, Disant F, Marchal F, Faure F. Thulium-YAG laser sialendoscopy for parotid and submandibular sialolithiasis. Lasers Surg Med. 2012 Dec;44(10):783-6. 82. Koch M, Iro H, Kunzel J, Psychogios G, Bozzato A, Zenk J. Diagnosis and gland-preserving minimally invasive therapy for Wharton's duct stenoses. Laryngoscope. 2012 Mar;122(3):552-8. 83. Koch M, Iro H, Klintworth N, Psychogios G, Zenk J. Results of minimally invasive gland-preserving treatment in different types of parotid duct stenosis. Arch Otolaryngol Head Neck Surg. 2012 Sep;138(9):804-10. 84. Rasmussen ER, Arndal H, Rasmussen SH, Wagner N. Steady progress seen in endoscopic surgery on major salivary glands. Dan Med J. 2012 Nov;59(11):A4525. 85. Zenk J, Koch M, Klintworth N, Konig B, Konz K, Gillespie MB, et al. Sialendoscopy in the diagnosis and treatment of sialolithiasis: a study on more than 1000 patients. Otolaryngol Head Neck Surg. 2012 Nov;147(5):858-63. /$6,$/2(1'26&23,$(1(/75$7$0,(172'(/26352&(6266$/,9$/(62%6758&7,926 DYDOLDW &RQVXOWD7pFQLFD 86. Kopec T, Wierzbicka M, Szyfter W, Leszczynska M. Algorithm changes in treatment of submandibular gland sialolithiasis. Eur Arch Otorhinolaryngol. 2013 Jul;270(7):2089-93. 87. Kopec T, Szyfter W, Wierzbicka M. Sialoendoscopy and combined approach for the management of salivary gland stones. Eur Arch Otorhinolaryngol. 2013 Jan;270(1):219-23. 88. Kopec T, Szyfter W, Wierzbicka M, Nealis J. Stenoses of the salivary ductssialendoscopy based diagnosis and treatment. Br J Oral Maxillofac Surg. 2013 Oct;51(7):e174-7. 89. Kroll T, Finkensieper M, Sharma SJ, Guntinas-Lichius O, Wittekindt C. Shortterm outcome and patient satisfaction after sialendoscopy. Eur Arch Otorhinolaryngol. 2013 Nov;270(11):2939-45. 90. Vashishta R, Gillespie MB. Salivary endoscopy for idiopathic chronic sialadenitis. Laryngoscope. 2013 Dec;123(12):3016-20. 91. Ardekian L, Klein HH, Araydy S, Marchal F. The use of sialendoscopy for the treatment of multiple salivary gland stones. J Oral Maxillofac Surg. 2014 Jan;72(1):89-95. 92. Ardekian L, Klein H, Al Abri R, Marchal F. Sialendoscopy for the diagnosis and treatment of juvenile recurrent parotitis. Rev Stomatol Chir Maxillofac Chir Orale. 2014 Feb;115(1):17-21. 93. Ianovski I, Morton RP, Ahmad Z. Patient-perceived outcome after sialendoscopy using the glasgow benefit inventory. Laryngoscope. 2014 Apr;124(4):869-74. 94. Klein H, Ardekian L. The treatment of large sialoliths by sialendoscopic combined approach. J Oral Maxillofac Surg. 2014 Apr;72(4):737-43. 95. Phillips J, Withrow K. Outcomes of Holmium Laser-Assisted Lithotripsy with Sialendoscopy in Treatment of Sialolithiasis. Otolaryngol Head Neck Surg. 2014 Mar 5. 96. Sionis S, Caria RA, Trucas M, Brennan PA, Puxeddu R. Sialoendoscopy with and without holmium:YAG laser-assisted lithotripsy in the management of obstructive sialadenitis of major salivary glands. Br J Oral Maxillofac Surg. 2014 Jan;52(1):58-62. 97. Berini-Aytes L, Gay-Escoda C. Morbidity associated with removal of the submandibular gland. J Craniomaxillofac Surg. 1992;20(5):216-9. $;(1&,$'($9$/,$&,Ð1'(7(&12/2;Ì$66$1,7$5,$6'(*$/,&,$ %LEOLRJUDItD 98. Su YX, Xu JH, Liao GQ, Zheng GS, Cheng MH, Han L, et al. Salivary gland functional recovery after sialendoscopy. Laryngoscope. 2009 Apr;119(4):646-52. 99. Cunning DM, Lipke N, Wax MK. Significance of unilateral submandibular gland excision on salivary flow in noncancer patients. Laryngoscope. 1998;108(6):812-5. 100. Chaushu G, Dori S, Sela BA, Taicher S, Kronenberg J, Talmi YP. Salivary flow dynamics after parotid surgery: a preliminary report. Otolaryngol Head Neck Surg. 2001;124(3):270-3. 101. Baptista PM, Gimeno-Vilar C, Rey-Martinez JA, Casale-Falcone M. Sialoendoscopia: una nueva alternativa en el tratamiento de la patología salival. Nuestra experiencia. Acta Otorrinolaringol Esp. 2008 Mar;59(3):120-3. 102. Iro H, Zenk J, Escudier MP, Nahlieli O, Capaccio P, Katz P, et al. Outcome of minimally invasive management of salivary calculi in 4,691 patients. Laryngoscope. 2009 February;119(2):263-8. 103. Nahlieli O, Baruchin AM. Sialoendoscopy: three years' experience as a diagnostic and treatment modality. J Oral Maxillofac Surg. 1997;55(9):9128;discussion 9-20. 104. Marchal F, Chossegros C, Faure F, Delas B, Bizeau A, Mortensen B, et al. Salivary stones and stenosis. A comprehensive classification. Rev Stomatol Chir Maxillofac. 2008 Sep;109(4):233-6. 105. Capaccio P, Ottaviani F, Manzo R, Schindler A, Cesana B. Extracorporeal lithotripsy for salivary calculi: A long-term clinical experience. Laryngoscope. 2004 June;114(6):1069-73. 106. Marchal F. A combined endoscopic and external approach for extraction of large stones with preservation of parotid and submandibular glands. Laryngoscope. 2007 Feb;117(2):373-7. 107. Zenk J, Koch M, Iro H. Extracorporeal and intracorporeal lithotripsy of salivary gland stones: basic investigations. Otolaryngol Clin North Am. 2009 Dec;42(6):1115-37, Table of Contents. 108. Iro H, Dlugaiczyk J, Zenk J. Current concepts in diagnosis and treatment of sialolithiasis. Br J Hosp Med (Lond). 2006;67(1):24-8. 109. Katz P. New techniques for the treatment of salivary lithiasis: sialoendoscopy and extracorporal lithotripsy: 1773 cases. Ann Otolaryngol Chir Cervicofac. 2004 Jun;121(3):123-32. /$6,$/2(1'26&23,$(1(/75$7$0,(172'(/26352&(6266$/,9$/(62%6758&7,926 DYDOLDW &RQVXOWD7pFQLFD 110. Koch M, Zenk J, Iro H. Diagnostic and interventional sialoscopy in obstructive diseases of the salivary glands. Hno. 2008 Feb;56(2):139-44. 111. Nahlieli O, Shacham R, Bar T, Eliav E. Endoscopic mechanical retrieval of sialoliths. Oral Surg Oral Med Oral Pathol Oral Radiol Endod. 2003 Apr;95(4):396402. 112. Walvekar RR, Carrau RL, Schaitkin B. Endoscopic sialolith removal: orientation and shape as predictors of success. Am J Otolaryngol. 2009 MayJun;30(3):153-6. 113. Iwai T, Matsui Y, Yamagishi M, Hirota M, Mitsudo K, Maegawa J, et al. Simple technique for dilatation of the papilla in sialoendoscopy. J Oral Maxillofac Surg. 2009 Mar;67(3):681-2. 114. Steck JH, Bertelli HD, Hoeppner CA, Volpi E, Vasconcelos EC. What is the learning curve of sialoendoscopy? Otolaryngology - Head and Neck Surgery (United States). [Conference Abstract]. 2013;1):P81. 115. Luers JC, Damm M, Klussmann JP, Beutner D. The learning curve of sialendoscopy with modular sialendoscopes: a single surgeon's experience. Arch Otolaryngol Head Neck Surg. 2010 Aug;136(8):762-5. $;(1&,$'($9$/,$&,Ð1'(7(&12/2;Ì$66$1,7$5,$6'(*$/,&,$ Consellería de Sanidade Innovación e Xestión 31 Análise e Estudos E La sialoendoscopia en el tratamiento de los procesos salivares obstructivos da Saúde Pública