Núm. 5.503 / 02.05.2007 Conselleria de Cultura, Educació i Esport 17852 Conselleria de Cultura, Educación y Deporte RESOLUCIÓ de 13 d’abril 2007, de la Direcció General de Patrimoni Cultural Valencià i Museus de la Conselleria de Cultura, Educació i Esport, per la que s’incoa expedient per a l’actualització i adaptació parcial de la Secció Primera de l’Inventari General del Patrimoni Cultural Valencià, en matèria de patrimoni arquitectònic i mediambiental, i s’obri període d’informació pública. [2007/5039] RESOLUCIÓN de 13 de abril 2007, de la Dirección General de Patrimonio Cultural Valenciano y Museos de la Conselleria de Cultura, Educación y Deporte, por la que se incoa expediente para la actualización y adaptación parcial de la Sección Primera del Inventario General del Patrimonio Cultural Valenciano, en materia de patrimonio arquitectónico y medioambiental, y se abre periodo de información publica. [2007/5039] La disposició addicional quarta de la Llei 4/1998, d’11 de juny, del Patrimoni Cultural Valencià, introduïda a través de la modificació de la Llei 5/2007, de 9 de febrer, determina que la conselleria competent en matèria de cultura elevarà al Consell, per a la seua aprovació per Decret i amb un informe previ favorable de dos institucions consultives, la relació de béns que han comptat amb expedient per a la seua declaració com béns d’interés cultural amb anterioritat a l’entrada en vigor de la Llei 4/1998, d’11 de juny, del Patrimoni Cultural Valencià, amb assignació de la Secció de l’Inventari General del Patrimoni Cultural Valencià en què hagen de ser inscrits, en atenció al seu valor cultural. Amb este fi, pel Servici de Patrimoni Arquitectònic i Mediambiental, dins del seu àmbit d’actuació, des d’esta Direcció General s’ha procedit a elaborar el corresponent informe–proposta que té com a principal objectiu la culminació dels procediments declaratius de determinats béns immobles que reunixen valors culturals manifestos i amb un ampli reconeixement social, i que, per distintes circumstàncies, en l’actualitat es troben pendents de la seua definitiva inscripció en la Secció Primera de l’Inventari General del Patrimoni Cultural Valencià. En esta adaptació de l’Inventari General del Patrimoni Cultural Valencià no es pot obviar el fet que els procediments per a la declaració d’estos immobles van ser incoats en aplicació de lleis anteriors a la vigent Llei 4/1998, d’11 de juny, del Patrimoni Cultural Valencià, i que no contemplaven les distintes figures de catalogació introduïdes amb l’entrada en vigor de la Llei Valenciana. Per tant, en la inscripció d’estos béns en l’Inventari General del Patrimoni Cultural Valencià se’ls assignarà la categoria que millor s’adeqüe a la seua naturalesa. La disposición adicional cuarta de la Ley 4/1998, de 11 de junio, del Patrimonio Cultural Valenciano, introducida a través de la modificación de la Ley 5/2007, de 9 de febrero, determina que la conselleria competente en materia de cultura elevará al Consell, para su aprobación por decreto y previo informe favorable de dos instituciones consultivas, la relación de bienes que han contado con expediente para su declaración como bienes de interés cultural con anterioridad a la entrada en vigor de la Ley 4/1998, de 11 de junio, del Patrimonio Cultural Valenciano, con asignación de la Sección del Inventario General del Patrimonio Cultural Valenciano en la que deban ser inscritos, en atención a su valor cultural. Con este fin, por el Servicio de Patrimonio Arquitectónico y Medioambiental, dentro de su ámbito de actuación, de esta Dirección General se ha procedido a elaborar el correspondiente informe–propuesta que tiene como principal objetivo el culminar los procedimientos declarativos de determinados bienes inmuebles que reúnen valores culturales manifiestos y con un amplio reconocimiento social, y que, por distintas circunstancias, en la actualidad se encuentran pendientes de su definitiva inscripción en la Sección Primera del Inventario General del Patrimonio Cultural Valenciano. En esta adaptación del Inventario General del Patrimonio Cultural Valenciano no se puede obviar el hecho de que los procedimientos para la declaración de estos inmuebles fueron incoados en aplicación de leyes anteriores a la vigente Ley 4/1998, de 11 de junio, del Patrimonio Cultural Valenciano, y que no contemplaban las distintas figuras de catalogación introducidas con la entrada en vigor de la Ley Valenciana. Por tanto, en la inscripción de estos bienes en el Inventario General del Patrimonio Cultural Valenciano se les asignará la categoría que mejor se adecue a su naturaleza. Asimismo, para hacer efectiva la plena aplicación de las medidas de protección y fomento que para los Bienes de Interés Cultural contempla la Ley, y en ejecución de la misma, se procede a dotarlos de su correspondiente ámbito de afección o entorno de protección. Ello sin perjuicio de la posterior complementación de cada expediente a las restantes determinaciones exigidas por la Ley 4/1998, de 11 de junio, del Patrimonio Cultural Valenciano, incluida la obligación de los Ayuntamientos de redactar los preceptivos planes de protección de estos inmuebles, a través de los cuales podrán introducirse justificados reajustes en estas delimitaciones. Otro de los objetivos del presente procedimiento de actualización y adaptación parcial de las secciones Primera y Segunda del Inventario General del Patrimonio Cultural Valenciano es, en cumplimiento de lo previsto en la citada disposición adicional cuarta de la Ley 4/1998, de 11 de junio, del Patrimonio Cultural Valenciano, dar pleno reconocimiento legal a las declaraciones culturales efectuadas entre los años 1936 y 1939 y no convalidadas o restablecidas posteriormente. Este reconocimiento conlleva, de igual manera, su inscripción en el Inventario General del Patrimonio Cultural Valenciano con asignación de su correspondiente entorno de protección. Por último, se procede a sistematizar terminológicamente las denominaciones de las categorías de los Bienes de Interés Cultural declarados con anterioridad a la entrada en vigor de la Ley 4/1998, de 11 de junio, del Patrimonio Cultural Valenciano, para su adaptación a las vigentes. A tal efecto se adjunta una tabla de equivalencias nominativas de aplicación general, se detallan aquellos bienes cuyo cambio de categoría no se sujeta a dicha correspondencia, definiendo específicamente aquellos que, como consecuencia de esta nueva asignación, verán variado su régimen tutelar. En virtud de lo expuesto, esta Dirección General, en el ejercicio de las atribuciones que le otorga el Decreto 183/2004, de 1 de octubre del Consell, por el que se aprueba el Reglamento Orgánico y Función de la Conselleria de Cultura, Educación y Deporte, acuerda: Així mateix, per a fer efectiva la plena aplicació de les mesures de protecció i foment que per als Béns d’Interés Cultural contempla la Llei, i en execució de la mateixa, es procedix a dotar-los del seu corresponent àmbit d’afecció o entorn de protecció. Això sense perjudici de la posterior complementació de cada expedient a les restants determinacions exigides per la Llei 4/1998, d’11 de juny, del Patrimoni Cultural Valencià, inclosa l’obligació dels Ajuntaments de redactar els preceptius plans de protecció d’estos immobles, a través dels quals podran introduir-se reajustaments justificats en estes delimitacions. Un altre dels objectius del present procediment d’actualització i adaptació parcial de les seccions Primera i Segona de l’Inventari General del Patrimoni Cultural Valencià és, en compliment del que preveu l’esmentada disposició addicional quarta de la Llei 4/1998, d’11 de juny, del Patrimoni Cultural Valencià, donar ple reconeixement legal a les declaracions culturals efectuades entre els anys 1936 i 1939 i no convalidades o restablides posteriorment. Este reconeixement comporta, de la mateixa manera, la seua inscripció en l’Inventari General del Patrimoni Cultural Valencià, amb assignació del seu corresponent entorn de protecció. Finalment, es procedix a sistematitzar terminològicament les denominacions de les categories dels Béns d’Interés Cultural declarats amb anterioritat a l’entrada en vigor de la Llei 4/1998, d’11 de juny, del Patrimoni Cultural Valencià, per a la seua adaptació a les vigents. A este efecte s’adjunta una taula d’equivalències nominatives d’aplicació general, es detallen aquells béns el canvi de categoria dels quals no se subjecta a la dita correspondència, definint específicament els que, com a conseqüència d’esta nova assignació, veuran variat el seu règim tutelar. En virtut d’allò que s’ha exposat, esta Direcció General, en l’exercici de les atribucions que li atorga el Decret 183/2004, d’1 d’octubre del Consell, pel que s’aprova el Reglament Orgànic i Funció de la Conselleria de Cultura, Educació i Esport, acorda: Núm. 5.503 / 02.05.2007 17853 Primer Incoar expedient per a l’actualització i adaptació parcial de la Secció Primera de l’Inventari General del Patrimoni Cultural Valencià, en matèria de patrimoni arquitectònic i mediambiental. Amb este fi s’establixen tres Annexos a la present resolució, que formen part de la mateixa, i en els que s’enumeren els immobles a inscriure en la Secció Primera de l’Inventari General del Patrimoni Cultural Valencià, amb la categoria i les correccions terminològiques oportunes. En el quart annex es descriuen succintament els immobles i els seus valors culturals així com s’assignen els corresponents àmbits d’afecció o entorns de protecció. Primero Incoar expediente para la actualización y adaptación parcial de la Sección Primera del Inventario General del Patrimonio Cultural Valenciano, en materia de patrimonio arquitectónico y medioambiental. Con este fin se establecen tres Anexos a la presente resolución, que forman parte de la misma, y en los que se enumeran los inmuebles a inscribir en la Sección Primera del Inventario General del Patrimonio Cultural Valenciano relativa a los Bienes de Interés Cultural, con la categoría y las correcciones terminológicas oportunas. En el cuarto Anexo se describen sucintamente los inmuebles y sus valores culturales así como se asignan los correspondientes ámbitos de afección o entornos de protección. Segon Sol·licitar, en compliment d’allò que s’ha exigit per la disposició addicional quarta de la Llei 4/1998, d’11 de juny, del Patrimoni Cultural Valencià, l’informe del Consell Valencià de Cultura i de la Reial Acadèmia de Belles Arts de Sant Carles. Segundo Solicitar, en cumplimiento de lo exigido por la disposición adicional cuarta de la Ley 4/1998, de 11 de junio, del Patrimonio Cultural Valenciano, el informe del Consell Valencià de Cultura y de la Real Academia de Bellas Artes de San Carlos. Tercer D’acord amb el que preveu l’article 86 de la Llei 30/1192 de Règim Jurídic de les Administracions Públiques i Procediment Administratiu Comú, obrir un període d’informació pública, a fi que totes les persones que tinguen interés puguen examinar l’expedient durant el termini d’un mes a partir de la publicació de la present resolució en el Diari Oficial de la Comunitat Valenciana. L’expedient estarà a disposició dels interessats en la Direcció General de Patrimoni Cultural Valencià i Museus, Servici de Patrimoni Arquitectònic i Mediambiental, de la Conselleria de Cultura, Educació i Esport, Avinguda de Campanar, número 32, de València. Tercero Conforme a lo previsto en el artículo 86 de la Ley 30/1992, de Régimen Jurídico de las Administraciones Públicas y del Procedimiento Administrativo Común, abrir un período de información pública, a fin de que cuantas personas tengan interés puedan examinar el expediente durante el plazo de un mes a partir de la publicación de la presente resolución en el Diari Oficial de la Comunitat Valenciana. El expediente estará a disposición de los interesados en la Dirección General de Patrimonio Cultural Valenciano y Museos, Servicio de Patrimonio Arquitectónico y Medioambiental, de la Conselleria de Cultura, Educación y Deporte, Avenida de Campanar, número 32, de Valencia Quart Que la present resolució amb els seus annexos es publique en el Diari Oficial de la Comunitat Valenciana. Quart Que la presente resolución con sus anexos se publique en el Diari Oficial de la Comunitat Valenciana. València, 13 d’abril de 2007.– El director general de Patrimoni Cultural Valencià i Museus: Manuel Muñoz Ibánez. Valencia, 13 de abril de 2007.– El director general de Patrimonio Cultural Valenciano y Museos: Manuel Muñoz Ibánez. Núm. 5.503 / 02.05.2007 17854 ANNEX I / ANEXO I Relació d’immobles amb expedient incoat amb anterioritat a l’entrada en vigor de la Llei 4/1998, d’11 de juny, a inscriure en la Secció Primera de l’Inventari General del Patrimoni Cultural Valencià. Relación de inmuebles con expediente incoado con anterioridad a la entrada en vigor de la Ley 4/1998, de 11 de junio, a inscribir en la Sección Primera del Inventario General del Patrimonio Cultural Valenciano. Municipi / Municipio ALCALÀ DE XIVERT Denominació /Denominación Pub. DOGV Església Parroquial de Sant Joan Baptista i Torre Campanar Pub. BOE BIC Categoria incoació / Categoría incoación 19/02/1982 X MHA Nova Categoria / Nueva Categoría M AYORA Iglesia de Santa María La Mayor 05/08/1978 X MHA M BENICARLÓ Antic Convent de Sant Francesc 28/07/1982 X MHA M BENICARLÓ Conjunt Hco-Artístic del Carrer de Sant Joaquim, versus: x Casa el Marqués de Benicarló (i entorn, carrer de Sant Joaquim) BENICÀSSIM / BENICASIM Església Parroquial de Sant ‘Tomàs de Villanueva’ 10/10/1980 X MHA M BENIGÁNIM Església Parroquial de Sant Miquel Arcàngel 19/02/1983 X MHA M BIAR Església Parroquial de la Mare de Déu de l’Assumpció 25/03/1982 X MHA M BORRIANA / BURRIANA Conjunt Històric de Borriana 30/03/1978 X CHA CH CARCAIXENT Convent d’Aigües Vives 31/03/1982 X MHA M CARCAIXENT Església Parroquial de Sant Bartomeu 17/06/1981 X MHA M CASTELLFORT Ermita de la Mare de Déu de la Font 16/07/1979 X MHA M CASTELLFORT Ermita de Sant Pere 17/09/1984 X MHA M CASTELLÓ DE LA PLANA / CASTELLÓN DE LA PLANA CASTELLÓ DE LA PLANA / CASTELLÓN DE LA PLANA CASTELLÓ DE LA PLANA / CASTELLÓN DE LA PLANA CASTELLÓ DE LA PLANA / CASTELLÓN DE LA PLANA CERVERA DEL MAESTRE Ajuntament de Castelló de la Plana 17/09/1984 X MHA M La Lllotja del Cànem 17/09/1984 X MHA M X MHA M X MHA M Torre i Molí de l'Oli 14/09/1983 X MHA M COCENTAINA Palau Comtal i Monestir de la Mare de Déu del Miracle 14/05/1981 X MHA M FORCALL Ajuntament 17/10/1981 X MHA M Palau Episcopal Torre Campanar ‘El Fadrí’ 02/09/1981 CHA X 27/07/1978 17/09/1984 M L'OLLERIA Església Parroquial de Santa María Magdalena 09/12/1982 X MHA M LA VALL D'UIXÓ Església Parroquial del Sant Àngel Custodi 06/10/1981 X MHA M LLUTXENT Conjunt Hco-Artístic del Castell de Xío, Església i Convent i Ermita de la Consolació, versus: Castell de Xío (BIC, declaració genèrica) x Ermita de la Consolació x CHA X M X Monestir (Església-Convent) del Corpus Christi M MONÒVER / MONÓVAR Ermita de Santa Bàrbara 22/06/1983 X MHA MUTXAMEL Església Parroquial d’El Salvador 27/08/1981 X MHA M MUTXAMEL Jardí i Palau de ‘Peñacerrada’ 29/07/1983 X CHA JH NULES Temple i replaça dels Carmelites Descalços 11/09/1980 X MHA M SAGUNT / SAGUNTO Església Parroquial d’El Salvador 29/10/1977 X MHA M TORREBLANCA Calvari i primitiva Església 13/11/1982 X MHA M VALENCIA Alquería de Julià 27/06/1978 X MHA M VALENCIA Església del Santíssim Crist del Salvador 13/01/1983 X MHA M VALENCIA Església Parroquial de la Mare de Déu de la Misericòrdia (Barri de Campanar) 02/06/1992 X M M VALENCIA Església de Sant Agustí (Església Parroquial de Santa Caterina i Sant Agustí) 16/04/1980 X MHA M VALENCIA Mercat Central 14/09/1983 X MHA M VALENCIA Palau del Marqués de Campo (o dels Berbedel) 19/02/1982 X MHA M VALENCIA Palau dels Boil d’Arenós (actual Borsa de València) 07/12/1977 X MHA M VALENCIA Palau des Català de Valeriola X MHA M VILLENA Santuari de ‘Nuestra Señora de las Virtudes’ 19/10/1976 X MHA M VISTABELLA DEL MAESTRAT Església Parroquial de l’Assumpció de la Mare de Déu 03/05/1996 X MHA M VISTABELLA DEL MAESTRAT Santuari de Sant Joan Baptista de Penyagolosa i Santa Bàrbara 16/07/1979 X MHA M ZORITA DEL MAESTRAT Santuari de la Mare de Déu de la Balma 13/07/1979 X MHA M 15/05/1992 13/05/1996 M Núm. 5.503 / 02.05.2007 17855 ABREVIATURES EMPRADES EN ELS CUADRES / ABREVIATURAS EMPLEADAS EN LOS CUADROS MHA MONUMENT HISTÒRIC-ARTISTIC M MONUMENT MONUMENTO HISTÓRICO-ARTÍSTICO MONUMENTO CHA CONJUNT HISTORIC-ARTISTIC EE ESPAI ETNOLOGIC CONJUNTO HISTÓRICO-ARTÍSTICO ESPACIO ETNOLÒGICO JH JARDI HISTORIC MIL MONUMENT D’INTERES LOCAL JARDÍN HISTÓRICO MONUMENTO DE INTERÉS LOCAL CH CONJUNT HISTORIC JHIL JARDI HISTORIC D’INTERES LOCAL CONJUNTO HISTÓRICO JARDÍN HISTÓRICO DE INTERÉS LOCAL ANNEX II / ANEXO II Relació d’immobles que van ser objecte de declaració expresses entre els anys 1936 i 1939 i que no han vist convalidada o restablida amb posterioritat. Relación de inmuebles que fueron objeto de declaración expresas entre los años 1936 y 1939 y que no han visto convalidada o restablecida con posterioridad. Municipi / Municipio Denominació / Denominación Declaració / Pub. Gazeta Declaración República BIC Categ. Inicial Nova Categoria / Nueva Categoría TORRES TORRES Baños Árabes 24/01/1938 29/01/1938 X MHA M VALENCIA Real Colegio Seminario del Corpus Christi o del Patriarca (*) 24/01/1938 29/01/1938 X MHA M (*) El Decret d'1/3/1962, publicat en el BOE de 9/3/1962, va declarar bé d'interés cultural la col·lecció museogràfica instal·lada en l'interior del Col·legi i per extensió l'edifici gaudix d'una protecció indirecta des d'eixe moment. El Decreto de 1/3/1962, publicado en el BOE de 9/3/1962, declaró bien de interés cultural la colección museográfica instalada en el interior del Colegio y por extensión el edificio goza de una protección indirecta desde ese momento. ANNEX III / ANEXO III Relació d’immobles declarats Bé d’Interés Cultural amb assignació de noves categories. Relación de inmuebles declarados Bien de Interés Cultural con asignación de nuevas categorías. Municipi / Municipio Denominació /Denominación Pub. BOE BIC Categ. inicial Nova Categoria / Nueva Categoría X MHAL JH MUTXAMEL Jardí de la Finca ‘Casa de Ferraz’ 19/02/1979 NULES Muralles de Mascarell, versus: Conjunt Fortificat de Mascarell 05/05/1949 VALÈNCIA Conjunt Hco-Artístic (Zones de l’Hospital Vell), versus: Recinte de l’Hospital Vell i Ermita de Santa Llúcia Plaça de Manises 18/12/1963 VALÈNCIA MHA X 20/02/1976 CH CHA X (*) M CHA Entorn de BIC (*)Àmbit subsumit en la seua integritat dins del posteriorment declarat Conjunt Històric de València (DOGV 10/05/1993 i BOE 07/09/1993), la qual cosa deixa sense sentit la precedent atribució de conjunt individualitzat. La zona manté la seua consideració patrimonial, si bé com a part d'un Conjunt Històric d'àmbit major del qual resulta indeslligable física, històrica i culturalment i en raó d’això, està subjecta a la tutela que de la seua mateixa condició legal es deriva. D'altra banda, gaudint el Palau de la Generalitat de declaració expressa, BIC Monument (BOE 04/06/1931), així com també el Palau del marqués de la Scala (BOE 03/03/1949), l'àmbit ‘Plaça de Manises' queda també subjecte, en la seua totalitat, a la tutela particularitzada del corresponent entorn monumental que, segons el que disposa l'Aptat. 1 de la Disposició Transitòria Primera de la Llei 5/2007 modificadora de la 4/1998, està reconegut amb caràcter provisional segons la delimitació continguda en l'annex 3 del Catàleg de Béns i Espais Protegits del PGOU de València de 1988, d'acord amb allò que s'ha establit pel “Conveni Marc de Col·laboració entre la Generalitat Valenciana i l'Ajuntament de València per al Desplegament i Execució del Planejament Urbanístic del Conjunt Històric de la Ciutat” subscrit el dia 22 de juny de 1994 i publicat en el DOGV de 04/11/1994. Ámbito subsumido en su integridad dentro del posteriormente declarado Conjunt Històric de València (DOGV 10/05/1993 y BOE 07/09/1993), lo que deja sin sentido la precedente atribución de conjunto individualizado. La zona mantiene su consideración patrimonial, si bien como parte de un Conjunto Histórico de ámbito mayor del cual resulta indesligable física, histórica y culturalmente y en razón de ello, está sujeta a la tutela que de su misma condición legal se deriva. Por otra parte, gozando el Palau de la Generalitat de declaración expresa, BIC Monumento (BOE 04/06/1931), así como también el Palau del Marqués de la Scala (BOE 03/03/1949), el ámbito ‘Plaça de Manises’ queda también sujeto, en su totalidad, a la tutela particularizada del correspondiente entorno monumental que, a tenor de lo dispuesto en el Aptdo. 1 de la Disposición Transitoria Primera de la ley 5/2007 modificadora de la 4/1998, está reconocido con carácter provisional según la delimitación contenida en el Anexo 3 del Catálogo de Bienes y Espacios Protegidos del PGOU de València de 1988, con arreglo a lo establecido por el “Convenio Marco de Colaboración entre la Generalitat Valenciana y el Ayuntamiento de Valencia para el Desarrollo y Ejecución del Planeamiento Urbanístico del Conjunto Histórico de la Ciudad” suscrito el día 22 de junio de 1994 y publicado en el DOGV de 04/11/1994. Núm. 5.503 / 02.05.2007 17856 $11(;,9$1(;2,9 'HVFULSFLyYDORUDWLYDGHOVEpQVDLQVFULXUHRUHDVVLJQDUGHFDWHJRULDHQOD6HFFLy3ULPHUD GHO¶,QYHQWDUL*HQHUDOGHO3DWULPRQL&XOWXUDO9DOHQFLjDPEGHWHUPLQDFLyGHOVVHXVjPELWV G DIHFFLyRHQWRUQVGHSURWHFFLy 'HVFULSFLyQYDORUDWLYDGHORVELHQHVDLQVFULELURUHDVLJQDUGHFDWHJRULDHQOD6HFFLyQ3ULPHUD GHO,QYHQWDULR*HQHUDOGHO3DWULPRQLR&XOWXUDO9DOHQFLDQRFRQGHWHUPLQDFLyQGHVXViPELWRV GHDIHFFLyQRHQWRUQRVGHSURWHFFLyQ $11(;,9$1(;2,9 GH 5HVROXFLyGHG DEULOGHOD'LUHFFLy*HQHUDOGH3DWULPRQL&XOWXUDO9DOHQFLjL0XVHXVGHOD&RQVHOOHULDGH&XOWXUD(GXFDFLyL(VSRUWSHUODTXHV LQFRDH[SHGLHQWSHUDOD SULPHUD IDVH GH O DFWXDOLW]DFLy L DGDSWDFLy SDUFLDO GH OD 6HFFLy 3ULPHUD GH O ,QYHQWDUL *HQHUDO GHO 3DWULPRQL &XOWXUDO 9DOHQFLj HQ PDWqULD GH SDWULPRQL DUTXLWHFWzQLF L PHGLDPELHQWDOLV¶REULSHUtRGHG¶LQIRUPDFLyS~EOLFD 5HVROXFLyQ GH GH DEULO GH OD 'LUHFFLyQ *HQHUDO GH 3DWULPRQLR &XOWXUDO 9DOHQFLDQR \ 0XVHRV GH OD &RQVHOOHULD GH &XOWXUD (GXFDFLyQ \ 'HSRUWH SRU OD TXH VH LQFRD H[SHGLHQWH SDUD OD SULPHUD IDVH GH OD DFWXDOL]DFLyQ \ DGDSWDFLyQ SDUFLDO GH OD 6HFFLyQ 3ULPHUD GHO ,QYHQWDULR *HQHUDO GHO 3DWULPRQLR &XOWXUDO 9DOHQFLDQR HQ PDWHULD GH SDWULPRQLRDUTXLWHFWyQLFR\PHGLRDPELHQWDO\VHDEUHSHULRGRGHLQIRUPDFLyQSXEOLFD Núm. 5.503 / 02.05.2007 17857 $SDUWDWD$SDUWDGRD 'HVFULSFLy GHOV EpQV LQFRDWV DPE DQWHULRULRULWDW D OD /OHL G¶ GH MXQ\ GH /D *HQHUDOLWDWGHO3DWULPRQL&XOWXUDO9DOHQFLjDLQVFULXUHFRPD%pQVG¶,QWHUpV&XOWXUDOHQ OD6HFFLy3ULPHUDGHO¶,QYHQWDUL*HQHUDOGHO3DWULPRQL&XOWXUDO9DOHQFLj 'HVFULSFLyQ GH ORV ELHQHV LQFRDGRV FRQ DQWHULRULGDG D OD /H\ GH GH MXQLR GH /D *HQHUDOLWDWGHO3DWULPRQLR&XOWXUDO9DOHQFLDQR DLQVFULELUFRPR%LHQHVGH,QWHUpV&XOWXUDO HQOD6HFFLyQ3ULPHUDGHO,QYHQWDULR*HQHUDOGHO3DWULPRQLR&XOWXUDO9DOHQFLDQR $11(;,9$1(;2,9 GH 5HVROXFLyGHG DEULOGHOD'LUHFFLy*HQHUDOGH3DWULPRQL&XOWXUDO9DOHQFLjL0XVHXVGHOD&RQVHOOHULDGH&XOWXUD(GXFDFLyL(VSRUWSHUODTXHV LQFRDH[SHGLHQWSHUDOD SULPHUD IDVH GH O DFWXDOLW]DFLy L DGDSWDFLy SDUFLDO GH OD 6HFFLy 3ULPHUD GH O ,QYHQWDUL *HQHUDO GHO 3DWULPRQL &XOWXUDO 9DOHQFLj HQ PDWqULD GH SDWULPRQL DUTXLWHFWzQLF L PHGLDPELHQWDOLV¶REULSHUtRGHG¶LQIRUPDFLyS~EOLFD 5HVROXFLyQ GH GH DEULO GH OD 'LUHFFLyQ *HQHUDO GH 3DWULPRQLR &XOWXUDO 9DOHQFLDQR \ 0XVHRV GH OD &RQVHOOHULD GH &XOWXUD (GXFDFLyQ \ 'HSRUWH SRU OD TXH VH LQFRD H[SHGLHQWH SDUD OD SULPHUD IDVH GH OD DFWXDOL]DFLyQ \ DGDSWDFLyQ SDUFLDO GH OD 6HFFLyQ 3ULPHUD GHO ,QYHQWDULR *HQHUDO GHO 3DWULPRQLR &XOWXUDO 9DOHQFLDQR HQ PDWHULD GH SDWULPRQLRDUTXLWHFWyQLFR\PHGLRDPELHQWDO\VHDEUHSHULRGRGHLQIRUPDFLyQSXEOLFD Núm. 5.503 / 02.05.2007 17858 %e'¶,17(5e6&8/785$/±(6*/e6,$3$55248,$/'(6$17-2$1%$37,67$,7255( &$03$1$5$/&$/¬'(;,9(5702180(17 %,(1'(,17(5e6&8/785$/,*/(6,$3$55248,$/'(6$1-8$1%$87,67$<7255( &$03$1$5,2$/&$/¬'(;,9(5702180(172 'HQRPLQDFLy'HQRPLQDFLyQ 3ULQFLSDO3ULQFLSDO (VJOpVLD3DUURTXLDOGH6DQW-RDQ%DSWLVWDL7RUUH&DPSDQDU ,JOHVLD3DUURTXLDOGH6DQ-XDQ%DXWLVWD\7RUUH&DPSDQDULR /RFDOLW]DFLy/RFDOL]DFLyQ 3URYtQFLD3URYLQFLD&DVWHOOy &RPDUFD&RPDUFD(O%DL[0DHVWUDW 0XQLFLSL0XQLFLSLR$OFDOjGH;LYHUW 8ELFDFLy8ELFDFLyQ3ODoDGHO¶(VJOpVLD 5HIHUqQFLD&DGDVWUDO5HIHUHQFLD&DWDVWUDO ,OOD0DQ]DQD3DUFHOāOD3DUFHOD $QWHFHGHQWV-XUtGLFV$QWHFHGHQWHV-XUtGLFRV ,QFRDFLy,QFRDFLy 3XEOLFDFLyGHODLQFRDFLy3XEOLFDFLyQGHODLQFRDFLyQ 'HVFULSFLy'HVFULSFLyQ 3DUWV,QWHJUDQWV3DUWHV,QWHJUDQWHV − )DoDQDSULQFLSDOLODWHUDOV)DFKDGDSULQFLSDO\ODWHUDOHV − 1DXFHQWUDOLFDSHOOHV1DYHFHQWUDO\FDSLOODV − &UHXHUDPEWDPERU&UXFHURFRQWDPERU − 3UHVELWHUL3UHVELWHULR − &DSHOODGHOD&RPXQLy&DSLOODGHOD&RPXQLyQ − 6DJULVWLD6DFULVWtD − &DPSDQDU&DPSDQDULR 'HVFULSFLy*HQHUDO'HVFULSFLyQ*HQHUDO (QHOQXFOLDQWLFGHODSREODFLyHVWUREDHVWDHVJOpVLDTXHVREUHw[YLVXDOPHQWGHODUHVWDG HGLILFDFLRQV9D VHUHQTXDQHOFRQVHOOGHODYLODYDGHFLGLUUHDOLW]DUXQDQRYDHVJOpVLDGHJUDQVGLPHQVLRQV3HUDL[zVH FHOHEUjXQFRQFXUVGHSURMHFWHVRQHVYDWULDUHOGH-RVHS+HUUHUR /DSULPHUDSHGUDHVYDFROāORFDUHOG DEULOGHSDVVDQWGXUDQWOHVREUHVGLIHUHQWVPHVWUHVFRP$QWRQL *UDQMDYDVHUFRQFORVDSHU-RDQ%DUFHOyHQ(QHVYDQLQLFLDUOHVREUHVGHOFDPSDQDUTXHHVYD DFDEDUHQSHUREUDGH-RDQ%DUFHOyHOTXDOYDSURMHFWDUXQDDOWUDWRUUHHQO DOWUHH[WUHPTXHQRHVYD DUULEDUDUHDOLW]DUSHUODJXHUUDGHOVIUDQFHVRV/ HVJOpVLDHVWDFRQVWUXwGDHQPDoRQHULDLFDUUHXV(VWUDFWD G XQHGLILFLGHWUHVQDXVDPEFUHXHU/DQDXSULQFLSDOHVWjFREHUWDDPEYROWDGHFDQyDPEOOXQHWHVPHQWUH TXHOHVODWHUDOVHVFREUHL[HQDPEF~SXOHVDPEFODUDERLHV(OFUHXHUHVWjFREHUWDPEYROWDGHFDQyLOD]RQD GHOSUHVELWHULDPEF~SXODVREUHSHW[LQHV'HVWDTXHQODGHFRUDFLyGHJXL[HULHVEDUURTXHVLOHVSLQWXUHVGHOD YROWD DPE WHPHV DOāOHJzULFV L ILJXUDWLXV $ O H[WHULRU GHVWDFD OD SRWHQW IDoDQD GH SHUILO PL[WLOLQL UHPDWDGD DPEIORURQV L SLUjPLGHV/DSRUWDGDSULQFLSDO SRVVHw[GRVFRVVRVO LQIHULRUIODQTXHMDW SHU GXHV FROXPQHV D FDGDFRVWDWDPEIRUQtFXOHVDYHQHUDGHVHQWUHHOOHVHOFRVVXSHULRUVHSDUDWSHUXQDPSOHHQWDXODPHQWWpXQD IRUQtFXODFHQWUDO/DUHPDWDGDFRQVWDG¶XQILQHVWUDORYDODPEDEXQGDQWRUQDPHQWDFLy/HVSRUWDGHVODWHUDOV VyQPpVUHGXwGHVLSUHVHQWHQGRVFRVVRVVHSDUDWVSHUXQSRWHQWDUTXLWUDXWRWUHPDWDWDPEXQIURQWyFRUE /DIDoDQDYDVHUUHDOLW]DGDSHU$QWRQL*UDQMDL-RDQ%DUFHOy(QHOFRVWDWGUHWGHODIDoDQDHVWUREDODWRUUH GH JDLUHEp PHWUHV G DOWXUD eV GH SODQWD RFWRJRQDO L SUHVHQWD WUHV FRVVRV VHSDUDWV SHU XQD VHQ]LOOD FRUQLVDPpVHOFRVGHFDPSDQHVLHOWHPSOHWGHUHPDWDGDDPEXQDSURIXVDGHFRUDFLyGHOVHJOH;,;/ DFFpV HV WURED HQ HO FRV LQIHULRU DPE XQD HVFDOLQDWD L SRUWD DOOLQGDGD HPPDUFDGD SHU SLODVWUHV %DVDW HQ HO &DWjOHJGH0RQXPHQWVL&RQMXQWVGHOD&RPXQLWDW9DOHQFLDQD (Q HO FDVFR DQWLJXR GH OD SREODFLyQ VH HQFXHQWUD HVWD LJOHVLD TXH VREUHVDOH YLVXDOPHQWH GHO UHVWR GH HGLILFDFLRQHV )XH HQ FXDQGR HO FRQVHMR GH OD YLOOD GHFLGLy UHDOL]DU XQD QXHYD LJOHVLD GH JUDQGHV GLPHQVLRQHV3DUDHOORVHFHOHEUyXQFRQFXUVRGHSUR\HFWRVGHOTXHVHHOLJLyHOGH-RVp+HUUHUR/DSULPHUD SLHGUDVHFRORFyHOGH$EULOGHSDVDQGRGXUDQWHODVREUDVGLIHUHQWHVPDHVWURVFRPR$QWRQLR*UDQMD $11(;,9$1(;2,9 GH 5HVROXFLyGHG DEULOGHOD'LUHFFLy*HQHUDOGH3DWULPRQL&XOWXUDO9DOHQFLjL0XVHXVGHOD&RQVHOOHULDGH&XOWXUD(GXFDFLyL(VSRUWSHUODTXHV LQFRDH[SHGLHQWSHUDOD SULPHUD IDVH GH O DFWXDOLW]DFLy L DGDSWDFLy SDUFLDO GH OD 6HFFLy 3ULPHUD GH O ,QYHQWDUL *HQHUDO GHO 3DWULPRQL &XOWXUDO 9DOHQFLj HQ PDWqULD GH SDWULPRQL DUTXLWHFWzQLF L PHGLDPELHQWDOLV¶REULSHUtRGHG¶LQIRUPDFLyS~EOLFD 5HVROXFLyQ GH GH DEULO GH OD 'LUHFFLyQ *HQHUDO GH 3DWULPRQLR &XOWXUDO 9DOHQFLDQR \ 0XVHRV GH OD &RQVHOOHULD GH &XOWXUD (GXFDFLyQ \ 'HSRUWH SRU OD TXH VH LQFRD H[SHGLHQWH SDUD OD SULPHUD IDVH GH OD DFWXDOL]DFLyQ \ DGDSWDFLyQ SDUFLDO GH OD 6HFFLyQ 3ULPHUD GHO ,QYHQWDULR *HQHUDO GHO 3DWULPRQLR &XOWXUDO 9DOHQFLDQR HQ PDWHULD GH SDWULPRQLRDUTXLWHFWyQLFR\PHGLRDPELHQWDO\VHDEUHSHULRGRGHLQIRUPDFLyQSXEOLFD Núm. 5.503 / 02.05.2007 17859 FRQFOX\pQGROD-XDQ%DUFHOyHQ(QVHLQLFLDURQODVREUDVGHOFDPSDQDULRWHUPLQiQGRVHHQ SRU-XDQ%DUFHOyTXLHQSUR\HFWyRWUDWRUUHHQHORWURH[WUHPRTXHQRVHOOHJyDUHDOL]DUSRUODJXHUUDGHORV IUDQFHVHV /D LJOHVLD HVWD FRQVWUXLGD HQ PDPSRVWHUtD \ VLOOHUtD 6H WUDWD GH XQ HGLILFLR GH WUHV QDYHV FRQ FUXFHUR /D QDYH SULQFLSDO HVWD FXELHUWD FRQ EyYHGD GH FDxyQ FRQ OXQHWRV PLHQWUDV TXH ODV ODWHUDOHV FRQ F~SXODVFRQOXFHUQDULRV(OFUXFHURFXEUHFRQEyYHGDGHFDxyQ\OD]RQDGHOSUHVELWHULRFRQF~SXODVREUH SHFKLQDV 'HVWDFDQ OD GHFRUDFLyQ D EDVH GH \HVHUtDV EDUURFDV \ ODV SLQWXUDV GH OD EyYHGD FRQ WHPDV DOHJyULFRV\ILJXUDWLYRV$OH[WHULRUGHVWDFDODSRWHQWHIDFKDGDGHSHUILOPL[WLOtQHRUHPDWDGDFRQIORURQHV\ SLUiPLGHV/DSRUWDGDSULQFLSDOSRVHHGRVFXHUSRVHOLQIHULRUIODQTXHDGRSRUGRVFROXPQDVDFDGDODGRFRQ KRUQDFLQDV DYHQHUDGDV HQWUH HOODV HO FXHUSR VXSHULRU VHSDUDGR SRU XQ DQFKR HQWDEODPHQWR WLHQH XQD KRUQDFLQD FHQWUDO (O UHPDWH HV FRQ XQ YHQWDQDO RYDO FRQ XQD RUQDPHQWDFLyQ DEXQGDQWH /DV SRUWDGDV ODWHUDOHV VRQ GH PHQRU WDPDxR SUHVHQWDQGR GRV FXHUSRV VHSDUDGRV SRU XQ SRWHQWH DUTXLWUDEH \ UHPDWDQGR FRQ XQ IURQWyQ FXUYR /D IDFKDGD IXH UHDOL]DGD SRU $QWRQLR *UDQMD \ -XDQ %DUFHOy (Q HO ODGR GHUHFKRGHODIDFKDGDVHHQFXHQWUDODWRUUHGHFDVLPHWURVGHDOWXUD(VGHSODQWDRFWRJRQDO\SUHVHQWD WUHVFXHUSRVVHSDUDGRVSRUXQDVHQFLOODFRUQLVDPiVHOFXHUSRGHFDPSDQDV\HOWHPSOHWHGHUHPDWHFRQXQ SURIXVDGHFRUDFLyQGHOVLJOR;,;(ODFFHVRVHHQFXHQWUDHQHOFXHUSRLQIHULRUFRQXQDHVFDOLQDWD\SXHUWD DGLQWHODGDHQPDUFDGDSRUSLODVWUDV%DVDGRHQHO&DWiORJRGH0RQXPHQWRV\&RQMXQWRVGHOD&RPXQLGDG 9DOHQFLDQD 2EVHUYDFLRQV2EVHUYDFLRQHV (QWRUQ(QWRUQR $QWHFHGHQWVDGPLQLVWUDWLXVGHOLPLWDFLyH[WUHWDGHO H[SHGLHQWGHILQLGDDPEFDUjFWHUSURYLVLRQDO 2ULJHQLQWHUVHFFLyHQWUHHOVHL[RVGHOVFDUUHUV'RFWRU6HJXHUDPE9HUDSXQW$ 6HQWLW+RUDUL /tQLD GHOLPLWDGRUD OD OtQLD LQFRUSRUD OHV SDUFHOāOHV GH O¶LOOD GH FDVHV FUHXD HO FDUUHU 3XUtVVLPDLUHFRUUHODPLWJHUDVXGGHODSDUFHOāODVHJXL[SHUOHVSRVWHULRUVGHOHVSDUFHOāOHV WUDYHVVDODSDUFHOāODSHUODSURORQJDFLyGHODPLWJHUDHQWUHOHVSDUFHOāOHVLGHO¶LOODGHFDVHV &UHXDHOFDUUHUDOFDOGH3XLJLLQFRUSRUDOHVSDUFHOāOHVLGHO¶LOODGHFDVHV7UDYHVVDHOFDUUHUO¶LOOD GHFDVHVLSURVVHJXL[SHUOHVSRVWHULRUVGHOHVSDUFHOāOHVGHO¶LOODGHFDVHVTXHGRQHQDOFDUUHUGH6DQW -RDQ,QFRUSRUDODSDUFHOāODGHO¶LOODGHFDVHVLOHV SDUFHOāOHVLGHO¶LOODGHFDVHV *LUDDOVXGSHUO HL[GHOFDUUHUGHOV$UFVLFUHXDO¶LOODGHFDVHVHQWUHOHVSDUFHOāOHVLL &UHXDHOFDUUHUGH6DQW1LFRODXLUHFRUUHOHVSRVWHULRUVGHOHVSDUFHOāOHVLGHO¶LOODGH FDVHV,QFORXO¶LOODGHFDVHVLV LQWURGXw[HQO¶LOODGHFDVHVHQWUHOHVSDUFHOāOHVLL UHFRUUHOHVSRVWHULRUVGHOHVSDUFHOāOHVLG HVWDLOODGHFDVHVILQVDO HL[GHOFDUUHUGH9HUDLSHU HOOILQVHOSXQWG RULJHQ $QWHFHGHQWHVDGPLQLVWUDWLYRVGHOLPLWDFLyQH[WUDtGDGHOH[SHGLHQWHGHILQLGDFRQFDUiFWHUSURYLVLRQDO 2ULJHQLQWHUVHFFLyQHQWUHORVHMHVGHODVFDOOHV'RFWRU6HJXHUFRQ9HUDSXQWR$ 6HQWLGR+RUDULR /LQHDGHOLPLWDGRUDODOtQHDLQFRUSRUDODVSDUFHODVGHODPDQ]DQDFUX]DODFDOOH3XUtVLPD\ UHFRUUH OD PHGLDQHUD VXU GH OD SDUFHOD VLJXH SRU ODV WUDVHUDV GH ODV SDUFHODV DWUDYLHVD OD SDUFHODSRUODSURORQJDFLyQGHODPHGLDQHUDHQWUHODVSDUFHODV\GHODPDQ]DQD&UX]DOD FDOOH $OFDOGH 3XLJ H LQFRUSRUD ODV SDUFHODV \ GH OD PDQ]DQD $WUDYLHVD OD FDOOH /D 3RPD \ SURVLJXHSRUODVWUDVHUDVGHODVSDUFHODVGHODPDQ]DQDUHFD\HQWHVDODFDOOH6DQ-XDQ,QFRUSRUDOD SDUFHODGHODPDQ]DQD\ODVSDUFHODV\GHODPDQ]DQD*LUDDVXUSRUHO HMHGHODFDOOH$UFRV\FUX]DODPDQ]DQDHQWUHODVSDUFHODV\\&UX]DODFDOOH6DQ1LFROiV\ UHFRUUHODVWUDVHUDVGHODVSDUFHODV\GHODPDQ]DQD,QFOX\HODPDQ]DQD \VHLQWURGXFHHQODPDQ]DQDHQWUHODVSDUFHODV\\UHFRUUHODVWUDVHUDVGHODVSDUFHODV \GHHVWDPDQ]DQDKDVWDHOHMHGHODFDOOH9HUD\SRUpOKDVWDHOSXQWRGHRULJHQ $11(;,9$1(;2,9 GH 5HVROXFLyGHG DEULOGHOD'LUHFFLy*HQHUDOGH3DWULPRQL&XOWXUDO9DOHQFLjL0XVHXVGHOD&RQVHOOHULDGH&XOWXUD(GXFDFLyL(VSRUWSHUODTXHV LQFRDH[SHGLHQWSHUDOD SULPHUD IDVH GH O DFWXDOLW]DFLy L DGDSWDFLy SDUFLDO GH OD 6HFFLy 3ULPHUD GH O ,QYHQWDUL *HQHUDO GHO 3DWULPRQL &XOWXUDO 9DOHQFLj HQ PDWqULD GH SDWULPRQL DUTXLWHFWzQLF L PHGLDPELHQWDOLV¶REULSHUtRGHG¶LQIRUPDFLyS~EOLFD 5HVROXFLyQ GH GH DEULO GH OD 'LUHFFLyQ *HQHUDO GH 3DWULPRQLR &XOWXUDO 9DOHQFLDQR \ 0XVHRV GH OD &RQVHOOHULD GH &XOWXUD (GXFDFLyQ \ 'HSRUWH SRU OD TXH VH LQFRD H[SHGLHQWH SDUD OD SULPHUD IDVH GH OD DFWXDOL]DFLyQ \ DGDSWDFLyQ SDUFLDO GH OD 6HFFLyQ 3ULPHUD GHO ,QYHQWDULR *HQHUDO GHO 3DWULPRQLR &XOWXUDO 9DOHQFLDQR HQ PDWHULD GH SDWULPRQLRDUTXLWHFWyQLFR\PHGLRDPELHQWDO\VHDEUHSHULRGRGHLQIRUPDFLyQSXEOLFD Núm. 5.503 / 02.05.2007 17860 %e'¶,17(5e6&8/785$/±(6*/e6,$3$55248,$/'(6$17-2$1%$37,67$,7255( &$03$1$5$/&$/¬'(;,9(5702180(17 %,(1'(,17(5e6&8/785$/,*/(6,$3$55248,$/'(6$1-8$1%$87,67$<7255( &$03$1$5,2$/&$/¬'(;,9(5702180(172 $11(;,9$1(;2,9 GH 5HVROXFLyGHG DEULOGHOD'LUHFFLy*HQHUDOGH3DWULPRQL&XOWXUDO9DOHQFLjL0XVHXVGHOD&RQVHOOHULDGH&XOWXUD(GXFDFLyL(VSRUWSHUODTXHV LQFRDH[SHGLHQWSHUDOD SULPHUD IDVH GH O DFWXDOLW]DFLy L DGDSWDFLy SDUFLDO GH OD 6HFFLy 3ULPHUD GH O ,QYHQWDUL *HQHUDO GHO 3DWULPRQL &XOWXUDO 9DOHQFLj HQ PDWqULD GH SDWULPRQL DUTXLWHFWzQLF L PHGLDPELHQWDOLV¶REULSHUtRGHG¶LQIRUPDFLyS~EOLFD 5HVROXFLyQ GH GH DEULO GH OD 'LUHFFLyQ *HQHUDO GH 3DWULPRQLR &XOWXUDO 9DOHQFLDQR \ 0XVHRV GH OD &RQVHOOHULD GH &XOWXUD (GXFDFLyQ \ 'HSRUWH SRU OD TXH VH LQFRD H[SHGLHQWH SDUD OD SULPHUD IDVH GH OD DFWXDOL]DFLyQ \ DGDSWDFLyQ SDUFLDO GH OD 6HFFLyQ 3ULPHUD GHO ,QYHQWDULR *HQHUDO GHO 3DWULPRQLR &XOWXUDO 9DOHQFLDQR HQ PDWHULD GH SDWULPRQLRDUTXLWHFWyQLFR\PHGLRDPELHQWDO\VHDEUHSHULRGRGHLQIRUPDFLyQSXEOLFD Núm. 5.503 / 02.05.2007 17861 %e'¶,17(5e6&8/785$/±(6*/e6,$'(6$17$0$5,$/$0$-25$<25$02180(17 %,(1'(,17(5e6&8/785$/,*/(6,$'(6$17$0$5,$/$0$<25$<25$02180(172 'HQRPLQDFLy'HQRPLQDFLyQ 3ULQFLSDO3ULQFLSDO (VJOpVLDGH6DQWD0DULDOD0DMRU ,JOHVLDGH6DQWD0DUtD/D0D\RU $FFHVzULD$FFHVRULD (UPLWDGH6DQW%ODL (UPLWDGH6DQ%ODV /RFDOLW]DFLy/RFDOL]DFLyQ 3URYtQFLD3URYLQFLD9DOqQFLD &RPDUFD&RPDUFD(O9DOOHGH&RIUHQWHV$\RUD 0XQLFLSL0XQLFLSLR$\RUD 8ELFDFLy8ELFDFLyQ3DUWHEDMDGHO&DVWLOOR 5HIHUqQFLD&DGDVWUDO5HIHUHQFLD&DWDVWUDO ,OOD0DQ]DQD3DUFHOāOD3DUFHOD $QWHFHGHQWV-XUtGLFV$QWHFHGHQWHV-XUtGLFRV ,QFRDFLy,QFRDFLyQ 3XEOLFDFLyGHODLQFRDFLy3XEOLFDFLyQGHODLQFRDFLyQ 'HVFULSFLy'HVFULSFLyQ 3DUWV,QWHJUDQWV3DUWHV,QWHJUDQWHV − 1DXDPEFDSHOOHVODWHUDOVHQWUHFRQWUDIRUWV 1DYHFRQFDSLOODVODWHUDOHVHQWUHFRQWUDIXHUWHV − 3UHVELWHUL3UHVELWHULR 'HVFULSFLy*HQHUDO'HVFULSFLyQ*HQHUDO (Q OD SDUW EDL[D GHO FDVWHOO HV WURED HVWD DQWLJD HVJOpVLD SDUURTXLDO GHGLFDGD D 6DQWD 0DULD OD 0DMRU HQ O DFWXDOLWDWpVO HUPLWDGH6DQW%ODL(VWUDFWDG XQDHVJOpVLDTXHVHJXL[ODWLSRORJLD GHOHV GHQRPLQDGHVGH UHFRQTXHVWDG XQDVRODQDXDPEVRVWUDGDGHIXVWDVREUHDUFVGLDIUDJPDLXQDEVLVWUDSH]RwGDO(VWjGLYLGLGD HQTXDWUHWUDPVPpVODFDSoDOHUDSHUDUFVGLDIUDJPDDSXQWDWVVREUHHOVTXDOVHVWUREDODVRVWUDGDGHIXVWD $OHVFDSHOOHVODWHUDOVHQWUHFRQWUDIRUWVV DFFHGL[DWUDYpVG DUFVGHPLJSXQWGRVGHOHVFDSHOOHVGHOFRVWDW GH O HStVWROD HVWDQ FREHUWHV DPE YROWHV GH FUHXHULD L OD UHVWD DPE YROWHV WDSLDGHV / DEVLV HQ OD FODX GH IXVWDGHOTXDOKLKDXQDUHSUHVHQWDFLyGHOD0DUHGH'pXLGRVjQJHOVTXHVXVWHQWHQO HVFXWGHODYLODHVWj FREHUW DPE YROWD GH FUHXHULD $ O H[WHULRU HVWj FREHUWD DPE WHXOD jUDE D GXHV DLJHV HQ OD QDX L D WUHV DLJHVHQODFDSoDOHUD(OVTXDWUHSULPHUVWUDPVVyQGHODPDWHL[DJUDQGjULDODTXDOFRVDLQGLFDTXHSRGULD WUDFWDUVHG XQDSULPHUDFRQVWUXFFLyTXHGHVSUpVHVYDDQDUDPSOLDQWILQVHOVHJOH;9HQTXqV¶DOojO¶~OWLPD FUXJLDLODFDSoDOHUD/DFRQVWUXFFLyGHO (VJOpVLD3DUURTXLDO GHO $VVXPSFLyGHOD0DUH GH'pX HQ HO VHJOH ;9,FRPSRUWjHOWUDVOODWGHOFXOWHDHVWDHQLO¶DEDQGyGHO HVJOpVLDGH6DQWD0DULDOD0DMRUTXHSDVVjD WLQGUHGLYHUVHVDGYRFDFLRQVILQVDO DFWXDOGH6DQW%ODL(QHOVHJOH;9,,,YDWLQGUHXQDLPSRUWDQWUHQRYDFLy PROW SUREDEOHPHQW HV FRQVWUXwUHQ HOV DUFV G DFFpV D OHV FDSHOOHV L V DPSOLDUHQ OHV FDSHOOHV GHO FRVWDW GH O HStVWROD%DVDWHQHO&DWjOHJGH0RQXPHQWVL&RQMXQWVGHOD&RPXQLWDW9DOHQFLDQD (QODSDUWHEDMDGHO&DVWLOORVH HQFXHQWUDHVWDDQWLJXDLJOHVLDSDUURTXLDO GHGLFDGD D6DQWD0DUtDOD0D\RU VLHQGR HQ OD DFWXDOLGDG OD (UPLWD GH 6DQ %ODV 6H WUDWD GH XQD LJOHVLD TXH VLJXH OD WLSRORJtD GH ODV GHQRPLQDGDV GH UHFRQTXLVWD GH XQD VROD QDYH FRQ WHFKXPEUH GH PDGHUD VREUH DUFRV GLDIUDJPD \ XQ iEVLGHWUDSH]RLGDO(VWiGLYLGLGDHQFXDWURWUDPRVPiVODFDEHFHUD SRUDUFRVGLDIUDJPD DSXQWDGRV VREUH ORV TXH VH HQFXHQWUD OD WHFKXPEUH GH PDGHUD $ ODV FDSLOODV ODWHUDOHV HQWUH FRQWUDIXHUWHV VH DFFHGH D WUDYpVGHDUFRVGHPHGLRSXQWRGRVGHODVFDSLOODVGHOODGRGHODHStVWRODHVWiQFXELHUWDVFRQEyYHGDVGH FUXFHUtD\HOUHVWRFRQEyYHGDVWDELFDGDV(OiEVLGHHVWDFXELHUWRFRQEyYHGDGHFUXFHUtDHQFX\DFODYHGH PDGHUDKD\XQDUHSUHVHQWDFLyQGHOD9LUJHQ\GRViQJHOHVTXHVXVWHQWDQHOHVFXGRGHODYLOOD$O H[WHULRU HVWiFXELHUWDFRQWHMDiUDEHDGRVDJXDVHQODQDYH\DWUHVHQODFDEHFHUD/RVFXDWURSULPHURVWUDPRVVRQ GH LJXDO WDPDxR SRU OR TXH SRGUtD WUDWDUVH GH XQD SULPHUD FRQVWUXFFLyQ TXH OXHJR VH LUtD DPSOLDQGR OHYDQWDQGR OD ~OWLPD FUXMtD \ OD FDEHFHUD \D HQ HO VLJOR ;9 /D FRQVWUXFFLyQ GH OD ,JOHVLD 3DUURTXLDO GH OD $VXQFLyQGH1XHVWUD6HxRUDHQHOVLJOR;9,FRQOOHYyHOWUDVODGRGHOFXOWRDpVWDHQDEDQGRQiQGRVHOD LJOHVLDGH6DQWD0DUtDOD0D\RU\SDVDQGRDWHQHUGLYHUVDVDGYRFDFLRQHVKDVWDODDFWXDOGH6DQ%ODV(QHO VLJOR;9,,,WXYRXQDLPSRUWDQWHUHQRYDFLyQPX\SUREDEOHPHQWHVHFRQVWUX\HVHQORVDUFRVGHDFFHVRDODV $11(;,9$1(;2,9 GH 5HVROXFLyGHG DEULOGHOD'LUHFFLy*HQHUDOGH3DWULPRQL&XOWXUDO9DOHQFLjL0XVHXVGHOD&RQVHOOHULDGH&XOWXUD(GXFDFLyL(VSRUWSHUODTXHV LQFRDH[SHGLHQWSHUDOD SULPHUD IDVH GH O DFWXDOLW]DFLy L DGDSWDFLy SDUFLDO GH OD 6HFFLy 3ULPHUD GH O ,QYHQWDUL *HQHUDO GHO 3DWULPRQL &XOWXUDO 9DOHQFLj HQ PDWqULD GH SDWULPRQL DUTXLWHFWzQLF L PHGLDPELHQWDOLV¶REULSHUtRGHG¶LQIRUPDFLyS~EOLFD 5HVROXFLyQ GH GH DEULO GH OD 'LUHFFLyQ *HQHUDO GH 3DWULPRQLR &XOWXUDO 9DOHQFLDQR \ 0XVHRV GH OD &RQVHOOHULD GH &XOWXUD (GXFDFLyQ \ 'HSRUWH SRU OD TXH VH LQFRD H[SHGLHQWH SDUD OD SULPHUD IDVH GH OD DFWXDOL]DFLyQ \ DGDSWDFLyQ SDUFLDO GH OD 6HFFLyQ 3ULPHUD GHO ,QYHQWDULR *HQHUDO GHO 3DWULPRQLR &XOWXUDO 9DOHQFLDQR HQ PDWHULD GH SDWULPRQLRDUTXLWHFWyQLFR\PHGLRDPELHQWDO\VHDEUHSHULRGRGHLQIRUPDFLyQSXEOLFD Núm. 5.503 / 02.05.2007 17862 FDSLOODV \ VH DPSOLDUtDQ ODV FDSLOODV GHO ODGR GH OD HStVWROD %DVDGR HQ HO &DWiORJR GH 0RQXPHQWRV \ &RQMXQWRVGHOD&RPXQLGDG9DOHQFLDQD 2EVHUYDFLRQV2EVHUYDFLRQHV (QWRUQ(QWRUQR $QWHFHGHQWVDGPLQLVWUDWLXVGHOLPLWDFLyH[WUHWDGHO H[SHGLHQWGHILQLGDDPEFDUjFWHUSURYLVLRQDO 2ULJHQLQWHUVHFFLyGHOFDUUHU3HV5HDODPEODGHO5HOORWJHSXQW$ 6HQWLW+RUDUL /tQLDGHOLPLWDGRUDODOtQLDVHJXL[SHUO HL[GHOFDUUHUGHO5HOORWJHLSHOGHOFDUUHU+XPHUDOSHUDJLUDUDQRUGL FRQWLQXDUSHOFDUUHU'(6DQW1LFRODX*LUDD/¶HVWSHOFDUUHU'(6DQW9LFHQWLDVXGSHOFDUUHUGHOD0DUHGH 'pXGHO5RVDUL&UHXDO¶LOODGHFDVHVSHUODPLWJHUDHQWUHOHVSDUFHOāOHVLLLQFRUSRUDHOFDVWHOO &UHXD O¶LOOD GH FDVHV HQWUH OHV SDUFHOāOHV L WRUQD D FUHXDUOD HQWUH OHV SDUFHOāOHV L SURVVHJXL[DQRUGHVWSHUO HL[GHOFDUUHUVHQVHQRPILQVDOSXQWG RULJHQ $QWHFHGHQWHVDGPLQLVWUDWLYRVGHOLPLWDFLyQH[WUDtGDGHOH[SHGLHQWHGHILQLGDFRQFDUiFWHUSURYLVLRQDO 2ULJHQLQWHUVHFFLyQGHODFDOOH3HVR5HDOFRQODGHO5HORMSXQWR$ 6HQWLGR+RUDULR /LQHDGHOLPLWDGRUDODOtQHDVLJXHSRUHOHMHGHODFDOOH5HORM\SRUHOGHODFDOOH+XPHUDOSDUDJLUDUDQRUWH\ FRQWLQXDUSRUODFDOOH6DQ1LFROiV*LUDDHVWHSRUODFDOOH6DQ9LFHQWH\DVXUSRUODFDOOH9LUJHQGHO5RVDULR &UX]D OD PDQ]DQD SRU OD PHGLDQHUD HQWUH ODV SDUFHODV \ H LQFRUSRUD HO FDVWLOOR &UX]D OD PDQ]DQDHQWUHODVSDUFHODV\YXHOYHDFUX]DUODHQWUHODVSDUFHODV\SURVLJXHDQRUGHVWH SRUHOHMHGHODFDOOHVLQQRPEUHKDVWDHOSXQWRGHRULJHQ $11(;,9$1(;2,9 GH 5HVROXFLyGHG DEULOGHOD'LUHFFLy*HQHUDOGH3DWULPRQL&XOWXUDO9DOHQFLjL0XVHXVGHOD&RQVHOOHULDGH&XOWXUD(GXFDFLyL(VSRUWSHUODTXHV LQFRDH[SHGLHQWSHUDOD SULPHUD IDVH GH O DFWXDOLW]DFLy L DGDSWDFLy SDUFLDO GH OD 6HFFLy 3ULPHUD GH O ,QYHQWDUL *HQHUDO GHO 3DWULPRQL &XOWXUDO 9DOHQFLj HQ PDWqULD GH SDWULPRQL DUTXLWHFWzQLF L PHGLDPELHQWDOLV¶REULSHUtRGHG¶LQIRUPDFLyS~EOLFD 5HVROXFLyQ GH GH DEULO GH OD 'LUHFFLyQ *HQHUDO GH 3DWULPRQLR &XOWXUDO 9DOHQFLDQR \ 0XVHRV GH OD &RQVHOOHULD GH &XOWXUD (GXFDFLyQ \ 'HSRUWH SRU OD TXH VH LQFRD H[SHGLHQWH SDUD OD SULPHUD IDVH GH OD DFWXDOL]DFLyQ \ DGDSWDFLyQ SDUFLDO GH OD 6HFFLyQ 3ULPHUD GHO ,QYHQWDULR *HQHUDO GHO 3DWULPRQLR &XOWXUDO 9DOHQFLDQR HQ PDWHULD GH SDWULPRQLRDUTXLWHFWyQLFR\PHGLRDPELHQWDO\VHDEUHSHULRGRGHLQIRUPDFLyQSXEOLFD Núm. 5.503 / 02.05.2007 17863 %e'¶,17(5e6&8/785$/±(6*/e6,$'(6$17$0$5,$/$0$-25$<25$02180(17 %,(1'(,17(5e6&8/785$/,*/(6,$'(6$17$0$5,$/$0$<25$<25$02180(172 $11(;,9$1(;2,9 GH 5HVROXFLyGHG DEULOGHOD'LUHFFLy*HQHUDOGH3DWULPRQL&XOWXUDO9DOHQFLjL0XVHXVGHOD&RQVHOOHULDGH&XOWXUD(GXFDFLyL(VSRUWSHUODTXHV LQFRDH[SHGLHQWSHUDOD SULPHUD IDVH GH O DFWXDOLW]DFLy L DGDSWDFLy SDUFLDO GH OD 6HFFLy 3ULPHUD GH O ,QYHQWDUL *HQHUDO GHO 3DWULPRQL &XOWXUDO 9DOHQFLj HQ PDWqULD GH SDWULPRQL DUTXLWHFWzQLF L PHGLDPELHQWDOLV¶REULSHUtRGHG¶LQIRUPDFLyS~EOLFD 5HVROXFLyQ GH GH DEULO GH OD 'LUHFFLyQ *HQHUDO GH 3DWULPRQLR &XOWXUDO 9DOHQFLDQR \ 0XVHRV GH OD &RQVHOOHULD GH &XOWXUD (GXFDFLyQ \ 'HSRUWH SRU OD TXH VH LQFRD H[SHGLHQWH SDUD OD SULPHUD IDVH GH OD DFWXDOL]DFLyQ \ DGDSWDFLyQ SDUFLDO GH OD 6HFFLyQ 3ULPHUD GHO ,QYHQWDULR *HQHUDO GHO 3DWULPRQLR &XOWXUDO 9DOHQFLDQR HQ PDWHULD GH SDWULPRQLRDUTXLWHFWyQLFR\PHGLRDPELHQWDO\VHDEUHSHULRGRGHLQIRUPDFLyQSXEOLFD Núm. 5.503 / 02.05.2007 17864 %e'¶,17(5e6&8/785$/$17,&&219(17'(6$17)5$1&(6&%(1,&$5/Ï02180(17 %,(1'(,17(5e6&8/785$/$17,*82&219(172'(6$1)5$1&,6&2%(1,&$5/Ï02180(172 'HQRPLQDFLy'HQRPLQDFLyQ 3ULQFLSDO3ULQFLSDO $QWLF&RQYHQWGH6DQW)UDQFHVF $QWLJXR&RQYHQWRGH6DQ)UDQFLVFR /RFDOLW]DFLy/RFDOL]DFLyQ 3URYtQFLD3URYLQFLD&DVWHOOy &RPDUFD&RPDUFD(O%DL[0DHVWUDW 0XQLFLSL0XQLFLSLR%HQLFDUOy 8ELFDFLy8ELFDFLyQ&6DQ)UDQFLVFR 5HIHUqQFLD&DGDVWUDO5HIHUHQFLD&DWDVWUDO ,OOD0DQ]DQD3DUFHOāOD3DUFHOD $QWHFHGHQWV-XUtGLFV$QWHFHGHQWHV-XUtGLFRV ,QFRDFLy,QFRDFLyQ 3XEOLFDFLyGHODLQFRDFLy3XEOLFDFLyQGHODLQFRDFLyQ 'HVFULSFLy'HVFULSFLyQ 3DUWV,QWHJUDQWV3DUWHV,QWHJUDQWHV − (OFRQYHQW(OFRQYHQWR − /¶HVJOqVLD/DLJOHVLD 'HVFULSFLy*HQHUDO'HVFULSFLyQ*HQHUDO 'H O DQWLF FRQYHQW DOoDW HQ HO VHJOH ;9, TXHGHQ PROW SRTXHV UHVWHV $ FDXVD GH OHV VXFFHVVLYHV LQWHUYHQFLRQVO HGLILFLTXHKXLV REVHUYDpVGHOVHJOH;9,,,GDWDLQVFULWDHQODIDoDQD6HPEODTXHHO FRQYHQW DPE OHV VHXHV GHSHQGqQFLHV L O KRUW YD RFXSDU XQD VXSHUItFLH DSUR[LPDGD GH P / RUJDQLW]DFLyGHOFRQYHQWJLUDHQWRUQDXQFODXVWUHGH[LFRWHWHVGLPHQVLRQVHQXQGHOVFRVWDWVGHOTXDOHV WUREDO¶HVJOpVLD/HVGHSHQGqQFLHVFRQYHQWXDOVFRPDUDODFXLQDHOUHIHFWRULOHVFHOāOHVHOVWDOOHUVHWFHV GHVHQYROXSDYHQHQ GXHV HGLILFDFLRQV GHSODQWD UHFWDQJXODULWUHV SLVRVTXHV DUWLFXOHQ SHUSHQGLFXODUPHQW /DIjEULFDGHOFRQMXQWpVGHPDoRQHULDVHQVHFRQFHUWDUSUHVDLUHYRFDGDDPEPRUWHUGHFDOo(OVFDQWRQV HVWDQUHIRUoDWVDPEFDUUHXVGHSHGUDFDOFjULD(OFODXVWUHDH[FHSFLyGHODUHVWDGHOFRQMXQWHVWjUHDOLW]DW HQ UDMROD L HVWj FREHUW SHU YROWD G DUHVWD &DO GHVWDFDU GHO FRQMXQW O HVJOpVLD G XQD VROD QDX GLYLGLGD HQ TXDWUH WUDPV SHU DUFV IDL[RQV L FREHUWD SHU YROWD GH FDQy OD FDSoDOHUD GH O HVJOpVLD pV SHQWDJRQDO D O LQWHULRUPHQWUHTXHDO H[WHULRUpVSODQDLFREHUWDDPEYROWDGHFUHXHULD)ODQTXHMDQWODQDXHVWUREHQOHV FDSHOOHVODWHUDOVFRPXQLFDGHVHQWUHVtHVWDQFREHUWHVSHUYROWDGHFDQyLG DUHVWHVGRVG HOOHVHVFREUL[HQ DPEF~SXOHVVHPLHVIqULTXHV /DIDoDQD GH O HVJOpVLD pV G HVWLO EDUURF PL[WLOtQLD HQ OD VHXD UHPDWDGD DPE XOOVGH ERXL SRUWDDOOLQGDGD(Q HO FHQWUH GH OD UHPDWDGD KL KD XQD HVSDGDQ\D G XQ VRO FRV UHDOLW]DGD HQ FDUUHXVDOVFRVWDWVHVWUREHQSLUjPLGHVLEROHV(QHOVHJOH;;VHOLYDQGRQDUGLIHUHQWVXVRVTXHYDQSRUWDU D UHDOLW]DU GLIHUHQWV UHIRUPHV PRGLILFDQW HO FRQMXQW FRP D FDVD TXDUWHU GH OD *XjUGLD &LYLO R WUDVWHU GH O $MXQWDPHQW(QYDQFRQFORXUHHOVWUHEDOOVGHUHVWDXUDFLyHQHOFRQYHQWSHUDGHVWLQDUOR D DFWLYLWDWV FXOWXUDOV%DVDWHQHO&DWjOHJGH0RQXPHQWVL&RQMXQWVGHOD&RPXQLWDW9DOHQFLDQD 'HO DQWLJXR FRQYHQWR OHYDQWDGR HQ HO VLJOR ;9, TXHGDQ PX\ SRFRV UHVWRV 'HELGR D ODV VXFHVLYDV LQWHUYHQFLRQHVHOHGLILFLRTXHKR\VHREVHUYDHVGHOVLJOR;9,,,IHFKDLQVFULWDHQODIDFKDGD3DUHFH VHUTXHHOFRQYHQWRFRQVXVGHSHQGHQFLDV\HOKXHUWRRFXSyXQDVXSHUILFLHDSUR[LPDGDDORVP/D RUJDQL]DFLyQGHOFRQYHQWRJLUDHQWRUQRDXQFODXVWURGHSHTXHxDVGLPHQVLRQHVHVWDQGRHQXQRGHVXVODGRV ODLJOHVLD/DVGHSHQGHQFLDVFRQYHQWXDOHVFRPRODFRFLQDUHIHFWRULRFHOGDVWDOOHUHVHWFVHGHVDUUROODEDQ HQGRVHGLILFDFLRQHVGHSODQWDUHFWDQJXODU\WUHVSLVRVTXHVHDUWLFXODQSHUSHQGLFXODUPHQWH/DIiEULFDGHO FRQMXQWR HV GH PDPSRVWHUtD VLQ FRQFHUWDU WRPDGD \ UHYRFDGD FRQ PRUWHUR GH FDO /DV HVTXLQDV HVWiQ UHIRU]DGDV FRQ VLOODUHV GH SLHGUD FDOL]D (O FODXVWUR D H[FHSFLyQ GHO UHVWR GHO FRQMXQWR HVWD UHDOL]DGR HQ ODGULOOR\HVWDFXELHUWRSRUEyYHGDGHDULVWD&DEHGHVWDFDUGHOFRQMXQWRODLJOHVLDGHXQDVRODQDYHGLYLGLGD HQFXDWURWUDPRVSRUDUFRVIDMRQHV\FXELHUWDSRUEyYHGDGHFDxyQODFDEHFHUDGHODLJOHVLDHVSHQWDJRQDO DO LQWHULRU PLHQWUDV TXH DO H[WHULRU HV SODQD \ FXEUH FRQ EyYHGD GH FUXFHUtD )ODQTXHDQGR OD QDYH VH HQFXHQWUDQ ODV FDSLOODV ODWHUDOHV FRPXQLFDGDV HQWUH Vt HVWiQ FXELHUWDV SRU EyYHGD GH FDxyQ \ GH DULVWDV GRVGHHOODVFXEUHQFRQF~SXODVVHPLHVIpULFDV/DIDFKDGDGHODLJOHVLDHVGHHVWLOREDUURFR(VPL[WLOtQHDHQ VX UHPDWH FRQ yFXORV \ SXHUWD DGLQWHODGD (Q HO FHQWUR GHO UHPDWH KD\ XQD HVSDGDxD GH XQ VROR FXHUSR UHDOL]DGDHQVLOOHUtDDORVODGRVVHHQFXHQWUDQSLUiPLGHV\ERODV(QHOVLJOR;;VHOHGLHURQGLIHUHQWHVXVRV $11(;,9$1(;2,9 GH 5HVROXFLyGHG DEULOGHOD'LUHFFLy*HQHUDOGH3DWULPRQL&XOWXUDO9DOHQFLjL0XVHXVGHOD&RQVHOOHULDGH&XOWXUD(GXFDFLyL(VSRUWSHUODTXHV LQFRDH[SHGLHQWSHUDOD SULPHUD IDVH GH O DFWXDOLW]DFLy L DGDSWDFLy SDUFLDO GH OD 6HFFLy 3ULPHUD GH O ,QYHQWDUL *HQHUDO GHO 3DWULPRQL &XOWXUDO 9DOHQFLj HQ PDWqULD GH SDWULPRQL DUTXLWHFWzQLF L PHGLDPELHQWDOLV¶REULSHUtRGHG¶LQIRUPDFLyS~EOLFD 5HVROXFLyQ GH GH DEULO GH OD 'LUHFFLyQ *HQHUDO GH 3DWULPRQLR &XOWXUDO 9DOHQFLDQR \ 0XVHRV GH OD &RQVHOOHULD GH &XOWXUD (GXFDFLyQ \ 'HSRUWH SRU OD TXH VH LQFRD H[SHGLHQWH SDUD OD SULPHUD IDVH GH OD DFWXDOL]DFLyQ \ DGDSWDFLyQ SDUFLDO GH OD 6HFFLyQ 3ULPHUD GHO ,QYHQWDULR *HQHUDO GHO 3DWULPRQLR &XOWXUDO 9DOHQFLDQR HQ PDWHULD GH SDWULPRQLRDUTXLWHFWyQLFR\PHGLRDPELHQWDO\VHDEUHSHULRGRGHLQIRUPDFLyQSXEOLFD Núm. 5.503 / 02.05.2007 17865 TXHOOHYDURQDUHDOL]DUGLIHUHQWHVUHIRUPDVPRGLILFDQGRHOFRQMXQWRFRPRFDVDFXDUWHOGHOD*XDUGLD&LYLOR WUDVWHURGHO$\XQWDPLHQWR(QFRQFOX\HURQORVWUDEDMRVGHUHVWDXUDFLyQHQHOFRQYHQWRSDUDGHVWLQDUOR DILQHVFXOWXUDOHV%DVDGRHQHO&DWiORJRGH0RQXPHQWRV\&RQMXQWRVGHOD&RPXQLGDG9DOHQFLDQD 2EVHUYDFLRQV2EVHUYDFLRQHV (QWRUQ(QWRUQR $QWHFHGHQWVDGPLQLVWUDWLXVGHOLPLWDFLyH[WUHWDGHO H[SHGLHQWGHILQLGDDPEFDUjFWHUSURYLVLRQDO 2ULJHQ,QWHUVHFFLyGH O HL[ GHO FDUUHU GH 0DGULG DPE OD SRVWHULRU GH OD SDUFHOāOD Q~P GH O¶LOOD GH FDVHV FDGDVWUDOSXQW$ 6HQWLW$QWLKRUDUL /tQLD GHOLPLWDGRUD 'HV GH O RULJHQ SXQW $ OD OtQLD GLVFRUUH SHU O HL[ GHO FDUUHU GH 0DGULG ILQV D OD VHXD LQWHUVHFFLy DPE OD SURORQJDFLy GH OD PLWJHUD GH OD SDUFHOāOD FDGDVWUDO DPE OD GH O¶LOOD GH FDVHV FDGDVWUDOSHUDHQWUDUSHU OD GLWDPLWJHUDL FRQWLQXDU SHU OHV SRVWHULRUV GH OHV FDVHV DPE IDoDQD DO FDUUHU 5DPyQ L &DMDO L SHUWDQ\HQWV D HL[D PDWHL[D LOOD GH FDVHV ILQV D OD SDUFHOāOD LQFORHQWOD SHU D FRQWLQXDUSHUODPLWJHUDGHSDUFHOāODDPEODFUHXDHOFDUUHUGH6DQW)UDQFHVFLHQWUDSHUODPLWJHUD VXGGHODSDUFHOāODGHO¶LOODGHFDVHVFDGDVWUDOLSURVVHJXL[HQGLUHFFLyQRUGSHUOHVSRVWHULRUVGH OHVFDVHVDPEIDoDQDDOFDUUHU6DQW)UDQFHVFG HVWDPDWHL[DLOODGHFDVHVLGHODILQVDODQ~P G HVWD ~OWLPD 5HFRUUH OD PLWJHUD HQWUH OHV SDUFHOāOHV Q~PHURV L G HVWD ~OWLPD FUHXD HO FDUUHU 6DQW )UDQFHVFLFRQWLQXDSHUODPLWJHUDHQWUHOHVSDUFHOāOHVQ~PHURVLGHO¶LOODGHFDVHVFDGDVWUDOSHU DUHFyUUHUOHVSRVWHULRUVG HVWDLOODGHFDVHVDPEIDoDQDDOFDUUHU$UDJyILQVDOSXQWG RULJHQ $QWHFHGHQWHVDGPLQLVWUDWLYRVGHOLPLWDFLyQH[WUDtGDGHOH[SHGLHQWHGHILQLGDFRQFDUiFWHUSURYLVLRQDO 2ULJHQ ,QWHUVHFFLyQ GHO HMH GH OD FDOOH 0DGULG FRQ OD WUDVHUD GH OD SDUFHOD Q GH OD PDQ]DQD FDWDVWUDO SXQWR$ 6HQWLGR$QWLKRUDULR /tQHD GHOLPLWDGRUD 'HVGH HO RULJHQ SXQWR $ OD OtQHD GLVFXUUH SRU HO HMH GH OD FDOOH 0DGULG KDVWD VX LQWHUVHFFLyQ FRQ OD SURORQJDFLyQ GH OD PHGLDQHUD GH OD SDUFHOD FDWDVWUDO FRQ OD GH OD PDQ]DQD FDWDVWUDOSDUDHQWUDUSRUGLFKDPHGLDQHUD\FRQWLQXDUSRUODVWUDVHUDVGHODVFDVDVFRQIDFKDGDDOD FDOOH 5DPyQ \ &DMDO \ SHUWHQHFLHQWHV D HVD PLVPD PDQ]DQD KDVWD OD SDUFHOD LQFOX\pQGROD SDUD FRQWLQXDUSRUODPHGLDQHUDGHSDUFHODFRQODFUX]DODFDOOH6DQ)UDQFLVFR\HQWUDSRUODPHGLDQHUD VXU GH OD SDUFHOD GH OD PDQ]DQD FDWDVWUDO \ SURVLJXH HQ GLUHFFLyQ QRUWH SRU ODV WUDVHUDV GH ODV FDVDVFRQIDFKDGDDODFDOOH6DQ)UDQFLVFRGHHVWDPLVPDPDQ]DQD\GHODKDVWDODQGHHVWD ~OWLPD5HFRUUHODPHGLDQHUDHQWUHODVSDUFHODVQ~PHURV\GHHVWD~OWLPDFUX]DODFDOOH6DQ)UDQFLVFR \ FRQWLQ~D SRU OD PHGLDQHUD HQWUH ODV SDUFHODV Q~PHURV \ GH OD PDQ]DQD FDWDVWUDO SDUD UHFRUUHUODVWUDVHUDVGHHVWDPDQ]DQDFRQIDFKDGDDODFDOOH$UDJyQKDVWDHOSXQWRGHRULJHQ $11(;,9$1(;2,9 GH 5HVROXFLyGHG DEULOGHOD'LUHFFLy*HQHUDOGH3DWULPRQL&XOWXUDO9DOHQFLjL0XVHXVGHOD&RQVHOOHULDGH&XOWXUD(GXFDFLyL(VSRUWSHUODTXHV LQFRDH[SHGLHQWSHUDOD SULPHUD IDVH GH O DFWXDOLW]DFLy L DGDSWDFLy SDUFLDO GH OD 6HFFLy 3ULPHUD GH O ,QYHQWDUL *HQHUDO GHO 3DWULPRQL &XOWXUDO 9DOHQFLj HQ PDWqULD GH SDWULPRQL DUTXLWHFWzQLF L PHGLDPELHQWDOLV¶REULSHUtRGHG¶LQIRUPDFLyS~EOLFD 5HVROXFLyQ GH GH DEULO GH OD 'LUHFFLyQ *HQHUDO GH 3DWULPRQLR &XOWXUDO 9DOHQFLDQR \ 0XVHRV GH OD &RQVHOOHULD GH &XOWXUD (GXFDFLyQ \ 'HSRUWH SRU OD TXH VH LQFRD H[SHGLHQWH SDUD OD SULPHUD IDVH GH OD DFWXDOL]DFLyQ \ DGDSWDFLyQ SDUFLDO GH OD 6HFFLyQ 3ULPHUD GHO ,QYHQWDULR *HQHUDO GHO 3DWULPRQLR &XOWXUDO 9DOHQFLDQR HQ PDWHULD GH SDWULPRQLRDUTXLWHFWyQLFR\PHGLRDPELHQWDO\VHDEUHSHULRGRGHLQIRUPDFLyQSXEOLFD Núm. 5.503 / 02.05.2007 17866 %e'¶,17(5e6&8/785$/$17,&&219(17'(6$17)5$1&(6&%(1,&$5/Ï02180(17 %,(1'(,17(5e6&8/785$/$17,*82&219(172'(6$1)5$1&,6&2%(1,&$5/Ï02180(172 $11(;,9$1(;2,9 GH 5HVROXFLyGHG DEULOGHOD'LUHFFLy*HQHUDOGH3DWULPRQL&XOWXUDO9DOHQFLjL0XVHXVGHOD&RQVHOOHULDGH&XOWXUD(GXFDFLyL(VSRUWSHUODTXHV LQFRDH[SHGLHQWSHUDOD SULPHUD IDVH GH O DFWXDOLW]DFLy L DGDSWDFLy SDUFLDO GH OD 6HFFLy 3ULPHUD GH O ,QYHQWDUL *HQHUDO GHO 3DWULPRQL &XOWXUDO 9DOHQFLj HQ PDWqULD GH SDWULPRQL DUTXLWHFWzQLF L PHGLDPELHQWDOLV¶REULSHUtRGHG¶LQIRUPDFLyS~EOLFD 5HVROXFLyQ GH GH DEULO GH OD 'LUHFFLyQ *HQHUDO GH 3DWULPRQLR &XOWXUDO 9DOHQFLDQR \ 0XVHRV GH OD &RQVHOOHULD GH &XOWXUD (GXFDFLyQ \ 'HSRUWH SRU OD TXH VH LQFRD H[SHGLHQWH SDUD OD SULPHUD IDVH GH OD DFWXDOL]DFLyQ \ DGDSWDFLyQ SDUFLDO GH OD 6HFFLyQ 3ULPHUD GHO ,QYHQWDULR *HQHUDO GHO 3DWULPRQLR &XOWXUDO 9DOHQFLDQR HQ PDWHULD GH SDWULPRQLRDUTXLWHFWyQLFR\PHGLRDPELHQWDO\VHDEUHSHULRGRGHLQIRUPDFLyQSXEOLFD Núm. 5.503 / 02.05.2007 17867 %e'¶,17(5e6&8/785$/±&$6$'(/0$548e6'(%(1,&$5/Ï%(1,&$5/Ï02180(17 %,(1'(,17(5e6&8/785$/&$6$'(/0$548e6'(%(1,&$5/Ï%(1,&$5/Ï02180(172 'HQRPLQDFLy'HQRPLQDFLyQ 3ULQFLSDO3ULQFLSDO &DVDGHO0DUTXpVGH%HQLFDUOy &DVDGHO0DUTXpVGH%HQLFDUOy /RFDOLW]DFLy/RFDOL]DFLyQ 3URYtQFLD3URYLQFLD&DVWHOOy &RPDUFD&RPDUFD(O%DL[0DHVWUDW 0XQLFLSL0XQLFLSLR%HQLFDUOy 8ELFDFLy8ELFDFLyQ&DUUHUGH6DQW-RDTXLP 5HIHUqQFLD&DGDVWUDO5HIHUHQFLD&DWDVWUDO ,OOD0DQ]DQD3DUFHOāOD3DUFHOD $QWHFHGHQWV-XUtGLFV$QWHFHGHQWHV-XUtGLFRV ,QFRDFLy,QFRDFLyQ 3XEOLFDFLyGHODLQFRDFLy3XEOLFDFLyQGHODLQFRDFLyQ%2( 'HVFULSFLy'HVFULSFLyQ 3DUWV,QWHJUDQWV3DUWHV,QWHJUDQWHV − &DVD&DVD − -DUGt-DUGtQ 'HVFULSFLy*HQHUDO'HVFULSFLyQ*HQHUDO /DFLXWDWGH%HQLFDUOyHVWDVLWXDGDHQXQSODSURSGHOPDU7pHOVHXRULJHQHQXQDDOTXHULDjUDETXHGHSpQ GHO &DVWLOOR GH 3HxtVFROD 'HVSUpV GH OD UHFRQTXHVWD O DQ\ YD VHU DWRUJDGD &DUWD GH 3REODPHQW SHU -DXPH,HVYDDQDUFRQILJXUDQWHOVHXWUDoDWTXDGUDQJXODUGLYLGLWHQTXDWUHSHUGRVFDUUHUVSHUSHQGLFXODUV DODPDQHUDGHOHVIXQGDFLRQVURPDQHVRG DOWUHVSREODFLRQVGHQRYDSODQWDGHVSUpVGHODUHFRQTXHVWD/HV WUDQVIRUPDFLRQV SDWLGHV HQ HOV VHJOHV ;9,, L ;9,,, YDQ IHU GHVDSDUpL[HU ERQD SDUW GH OHV HGLILFDFLRQV GHO QXFOLXUEjO ~QLFFDUUHUTXHFRQVHUYDYDILQVIDSRFXQFHUWFDUjFWHULWLSRORJLHVGHYLYHQGDRULJLQDOVHUDHO FDUUHUGH6DQW-RDTXLPGHWUDoDWLUUHJXODULVLWXDWHQWUHOHVSODFHVGHO*HQHUDO$UDQGDLGH6DQW%DUWRPHX 'LQVGHOFDUUHUGH6DQW-RDTXLPGHVWDFDOD&DVDGHO0DUTXpVDVVHQWDGDHQHOPDMRUVRODUGHODSREODFLyD H[FHSFLyGHO HVJOpVLD9DVHUFRQVWUXwGDHQO ~OWLPTXDUWGHOVHJOH;9,,,SHU-RDTXtQ0LTXHO/OXtVVREUHOHV UXwQHV GHO DQWLJD FDVD GH OD &RPDQGD VHX GHO &RPDQDGRU GH O 2UGH GH 0RQWHVD &RQVWD GH SODQWD EDL[D DPE HQWUHVzO SODQWD QREOH L DQGDQD V RUJDQLW]D D SDUWLU G XQ JUDQ YHVWtEXO DPE GREOH DOWXUD L JDOHULD GH GLVWULEXFLyDODTXDO V DFFHGL[SHUXQDHVFDODLPSHULDOVLWXDGD HQODVHJRQDFUXJLD3HU GDUUHUHGHO HVFDOD V DFFHGL[ D XQ KRUWMDUGt SRVWHULRU eV VLQJXODU OD FXLQD UHYHVWLGD DPE WDXOHOOHWV GH OD IjEULFD GHO &RPWH G $UDQGDGHO $OFRUD%DVDWHQHO&DWjOHJGH0RQXPHQWVL&RQMXQWVGHOD&RPXQLWDW9DOHQFLDQD /D FLXGDG GH %HQLFDUOy HVWD VLWXDGD HQ XQ OODQR FHUFD GHO PDU 7LHQH VX RULJHQ HQ XQD DOTXHUtD iUDEH GHSHQGLHQWH GHO &DVWLOOR GH 3HxtVFROD 7UDV OD UHFRQTXLVWD HQ HO DxR IXH RWRUJDGD &DUWD 3XHEOD SRU -DLPH,VHIXHFRQILJXUDQGRVXWUD]DGRFXDGUDQJXODUGLYLGLGRHQFXDWURSRU GRVFDOOHVSHUSHQGLFXODUHV DO PRGR GH ODV IXQGDFLRQHV URPDQDV R GH RWUDV SREODFLRQHV GH QXHYD SODQWD WUDV OD UHFRQTXLVWD /DV WUDQVIRUPDFLRQHVVXIULGDVHQORVVLJORV;9,,\;9,,,KLFLHURQ GHVDSDUHFHUEXHQDSDUWHGH ODVHGLILFDFLRQHV GHOFDVFRXUEDQROD~QLFDFDOOHTXHFRQVHUYDEDKDVWDKDFHSRFRXQFLHUWRFDUiFWHU\WLSRORJtDVGHYLYLHQGD RULJLQDOHV HUD OD GH 6DQ -RDTXtQ GH WUD]DGR LUUHJXODU \ VLWXDGD HQWUH ODV SOD]DV *HQHUDO $UDQGD \ 6DQ %DUWRORPp'HQWURGHODFDOOHGH6DQ-RDTXtQGHVWDFDOD&DVDGHO0DUTXpVDVHQWDGDHQHOPD\RUVRODUGH OD SREODFLyQ D H[FHSFLyQ GH OD LJOHVLD )XH FRQVWUXLGD HQ HO ~OWLPR FXDUWR GHO VLJOR ;9,,, SRU ' -RDTXtQ 0LTXHO /OXtV VREUHODVUXLQDV GHOD DQWLJXD FDVD GH OD (QFRPLHQGD VHGH GHO &RPHQGDGRU GH OD 2UGHQ GH 0RQWHVD &RQVWD GH SODQWD EDMD FRQ HQWUHVXHOR SODQWD QREOH \ DQGDQD VH RUJDQL]D D SDUWLU GH XQ JUDQ ]DJXiQFRQGREOHDOWXUD\JDOHUtDGHGLVWULEXFLyQDODTXHVHDFFHGHSRUXQDHVFDOHUDLPSHULDOVLWXDGDHQOD VHJXQGD FUXMtD 3RU GHWUiV GH OD HVFDOHUD VH DFFHGH D XQ KXHUWRMDUGtQ SRVWHULRU (V VLQJXODU OD FRFLQD UHYHVWLGDFRQD]XOHMRVGHODIiEULFDGHO&RQGHGH$UDQGDGH$OFRUD%DVDGRHQHO&DWiORJRGH0RQXPHQWRV \&RQMXQWRVGHOD&RPXQLGDG9DOHQFLDQD 2EVHUYDFLRQV2EVHUYDFLRQHV 9DVHULQFRDWFRP&RQMXQW+LVWzULF DQRPHQDW³&DOOHGH6DQ-RDTXtQ´GHVSUpVGHODUHYLVLyWqFQLFD SDVD D VHU0RQXPHQWDPEHQWRUQLQFORHQWKLDTXHOOjPELW $11(;,9$1(;2,9 GH 5HVROXFLyGHG DEULOGHOD'LUHFFLy*HQHUDOGH3DWULPRQL&XOWXUDO9DOHQFLjL0XVHXVGHOD&RQVHOOHULDGH&XOWXUD(GXFDFLyL(VSRUWSHUODTXHV LQFRDH[SHGLHQWSHUDOD SULPHUD IDVH GH O DFWXDOLW]DFLy L DGDSWDFLy SDUFLDO GH OD 6HFFLy 3ULPHUD GH O ,QYHQWDUL *HQHUDO GHO 3DWULPRQL &XOWXUDO 9DOHQFLj HQ PDWqULD GH SDWULPRQL DUTXLWHFWzQLF L PHGLDPELHQWDOLV¶REULSHUtRGHG¶LQIRUPDFLyS~EOLFD 5HVROXFLyQ GH GH DEULO GH OD 'LUHFFLyQ *HQHUDO GH 3DWULPRQLR &XOWXUDO 9DOHQFLDQR \ 0XVHRV GH OD &RQVHOOHULD GH &XOWXUD (GXFDFLyQ \ 'HSRUWH SRU OD TXH VH LQFRD H[SHGLHQWH SDUD OD SULPHUD IDVH GH OD DFWXDOL]DFLyQ \ DGDSWDFLyQ SDUFLDO GH OD 6HFFLyQ 3ULPHUD GHO ,QYHQWDULR *HQHUDO GHO 3DWULPRQLR &XOWXUDO 9DOHQFLDQR HQ PDWHULD GH SDWULPRQLRDUTXLWHFWyQLFR\PHGLRDPELHQWDO\VHDEUHSHULRGRGHLQIRUPDFLyQSXEOLFD Núm. 5.503 / 02.05.2007 17868 )XH LQFRDGR FRPR &RQMXQWR +LVWyULFR GHQRPLQDGR &DOOH GH 6DQ -RDTXtQ WUDV OD UHYLVLyQ WpFQLFD SDVD D 0RQXPHQWRFX\RHQWRUQRLQFOX\HDTXHOiPELWR (QWRUQ(QWRUQR $QWHFHGHQWVDGPLQLVWUDWLXVGHOLPLWDFLyH[WUHWDGHO H[SHGLHQWGHILQLGDDPEFDUjFWHUSURYLVLRQDO 2ULJHQ,QWHUVHFFLyGHO HL[ GHOFDUUHU)HUUHUHVDPE ODSURORQJDFLyGHODIDoDQDQRUGGHODSDUFHOāOD GH O¶LOODGHFDVHVSXQW$ 6HQWLW$QWLKRUDUL /tQLD GHOLPLWDGRUD OD OtQLD VHJXL[ SHU O HL[ GHO FDUUHU )HUUHUHV L SHO GHO FDUUHU 6DQW -DXPH L VHJXL[ SHU OD IDoDQDHVWHLSHUODSRVWHULRUGHODSDUFHOāODGHO¶LOODGHFDVHVLSHUODSURORQJDFLyGHODPLWJHUDVXG GHODSDUFHOāODWUDYHVVDODSDUFHOāODLFRQWLQXDSHUOHVSRVWHULRUVGHOHVSDUFHOāOHVLG HVWDLOODGH FDVHV6 LQWURGXw[HQO¶LOODGHFDVHVLLQFRUSRUDOHVSDUFHOāOHVL&UHXDHOFDUUHU6DQW-DXPHL UHFRUUH OD PLWJHUD HQWUH OHV SDUFHOāOHV L GH O¶LOOD GH FDVHV L UHFRUUH OHV SRVWHULRUV GH OHV SDUFHOāOHVLSHUDFRQWLQXDUSHUODPLWJHUDHQWUHOHVSDUFHOāOHVLG HVWDLOODGHFDVHV6HJXL[SHU O HL[GHOFDUUHU6DQW-RDQHQGLUHFFLyQRUGLUHFRUUHOHVSRVWHULRUVGHOHVSDUFHOāOHVGHO¶LOODGHFDVHV TXHGRQHQDOFDUUHU6DQW-RDTXLPILQVDOSXQWG RULJHQ $QWHFHGHQWHVDGPLQLVWUDWLYRVGHOLPLWDFLyQH[WUDtGDGHOH[SHGLHQWHGHILQLGDFRQFDUiFWHUSURYLVLRQDO 2ULJHQ,QWHUVHFFLyQGHOHMHGHODFDOOH)HUUHUHVFRQODSURORQJDFLyQGHODIDFKDGDQRUWHGHODSDUFHODGH ODPDQ]DQDSXQWR$ 6HQWLGR$QWLKRUDULR /tQHDGHOLPLWDGRUDODOtQHDVLJXHSRUHOHMHGHODFDOOH)HUUHUHV\SRUHOGHODFDOOH6DQW-DXPH\VLJXHSRUOD IDFKDGDHVWH\SRUODWUDVHUDGHODSDUFHODGHODPDQ]DQD\SRUODSURORQJDFLyQGHODPHGLDQHUD VXU GH OD SDUFHOD DWUDYLHVD OD SDUFHOD \ FRQWLQ~D SRU ODV WUDVHUDV GH ODV SDUFHODV \ GH HVWD PDQ]DQD6HLQWURGXFHHQODPDQ]DQDHLQFRUSRUDODVSDUFHODV\&UX]DODFDOOH6DQW-DXPH \UHFRUUHODPHGLDQHUDHQWUHODVSDUFHODV\GHODPDQ]DQD\UHFRUUHODVWUDVHUDVGHODVSDUFHODV \SDUDFRQWLQXDUSRUODPHGLDQHUDHQWUHODVSDUFHODV\GHHVWDPDQ]DQD6LJXHSRUHOHMHGHOD FDOOH6DQW-RDQHQGLUHFFLyQQRUWH\UHFRUUHODVWUDVHUDVGHODVSDUFHODVGHODPDQ]DQDUHFD\HQWHVD ODFDOOH6DQW-RDTXLPKDVWDHOSXQWRGHRULJHQ $11(;,9$1(;2,9 GH 5HVROXFLyGHG DEULOGHOD'LUHFFLy*HQHUDOGH3DWULPRQL&XOWXUDO9DOHQFLjL0XVHXVGHOD&RQVHOOHULDGH&XOWXUD(GXFDFLyL(VSRUWSHUODTXHV LQFRDH[SHGLHQWSHUDOD SULPHUD IDVH GH O DFWXDOLW]DFLy L DGDSWDFLy SDUFLDO GH OD 6HFFLy 3ULPHUD GH O ,QYHQWDUL *HQHUDO GHO 3DWULPRQL &XOWXUDO 9DOHQFLj HQ PDWqULD GH SDWULPRQL DUTXLWHFWzQLF L PHGLDPELHQWDOLV¶REULSHUtRGHG¶LQIRUPDFLyS~EOLFD 5HVROXFLyQ GH GH DEULO GH OD 'LUHFFLyQ *HQHUDO GH 3DWULPRQLR &XOWXUDO 9DOHQFLDQR \ 0XVHRV GH OD &RQVHOOHULD GH &XOWXUD (GXFDFLyQ \ 'HSRUWH SRU OD TXH VH LQFRD H[SHGLHQWH SDUD OD SULPHUD IDVH GH OD DFWXDOL]DFLyQ \ DGDSWDFLyQ SDUFLDO GH OD 6HFFLyQ 3ULPHUD GHO ,QYHQWDULR *HQHUDO GHO 3DWULPRQLR &XOWXUDO 9DOHQFLDQR HQ PDWHULD GH SDWULPRQLRDUTXLWHFWyQLFR\PHGLRDPELHQWDO\VHDEUHSHULRGRGHLQIRUPDFLyQSXEOLFD Núm. 5.503 / 02.05.2007 17869 %e'¶,17(5e6&8/785$/±&$6$'(/0$548e6'(%(1,&$5/Ï%(1,&$5/Ï02180(17 %,(1'(,17(5e6&8/785$/&$6$'(/0$548e6'(%(1,&$5/Ï%(1,&$5/Ï02180(172 $11(;,9$1(;2,9 GH 5HVROXFLyGHG DEULOGHOD'LUHFFLy*HQHUDOGH3DWULPRQL&XOWXUDO9DOHQFLjL0XVHXVGHOD&RQVHOOHULDGH&XOWXUD(GXFDFLyL(VSRUWSHUODTXHV LQFRDH[SHGLHQWSHUDOD SULPHUD IDVH GH O DFWXDOLW]DFLy L DGDSWDFLy SDUFLDO GH OD 6HFFLy 3ULPHUD GH O ,QYHQWDUL *HQHUDO GHO 3DWULPRQL &XOWXUDO 9DOHQFLj HQ PDWqULD GH SDWULPRQL DUTXLWHFWzQLF L PHGLDPELHQWDOLV¶REULSHUtRGHG¶LQIRUPDFLyS~EOLFD 5HVROXFLyQ GH GH DEULO GH OD 'LUHFFLyQ *HQHUDO GH 3DWULPRQLR &XOWXUDO 9DOHQFLDQR \ 0XVHRV GH OD &RQVHOOHULD GH &XOWXUD (GXFDFLyQ \ 'HSRUWH SRU OD TXH VH LQFRD H[SHGLHQWH SDUD OD SULPHUD IDVH GH OD DFWXDOL]DFLyQ \ DGDSWDFLyQ SDUFLDO GH OD 6HFFLyQ 3ULPHUD GHO ,QYHQWDULR *HQHUDO GHO 3DWULPRQLR &XOWXUDO 9DOHQFLDQR HQ PDWHULD GH SDWULPRQLRDUTXLWHFWyQLFR\PHGLRDPELHQWDO\VHDEUHSHULRGRGHLQIRUPDFLyQSXEOLFD Núm. 5.503 / 02.05.2007 17870 %e'¶,17(5e6&8/785$/±(6*/e6,$3$55248,$/'(µ6$172720È6'(9,//$18(9$¶ %(1,&¬66,002180(17 %,(1'(,17(5e6&8/785$/,*/(6,$3$55248,$/'(6$172720È6'(9,//$18(9$ %(1,&$6,002180(172 'HQRPLQDFLy'HQRPLQDFLyQ 3ULQFLSDO3ULQFLSDO (VJOpVLD3DUURTXLDOGH6DQW7RPjVGH9LOODQXHYD ,JOHVLD3DUURTXLDOGH6DQWR7RPiVGH9LOODQXHYD /RFDOLW]DFLy/RFDOL]DFLyQ 3URYtQFLD3URYLQFLD&DVWHOOy &RPDUFD&RPDUFD/D3ODQD$OWD 0XQLFLSLR0XQLFLSLR%HQLFjVVLP%HQLFDVLP 8ELFDFLy8ELFDFLyQ 5HIHUqQFLD&DGDVWUDO5HIHUHQFLD&DWDVWUDO ,OOD0DQ]DQD3DUFHOāOD3DUFHOD $QWHFHGHQWV-XUtGLFV$QWHFHGHQWHV-XUtGLFRV ,QFRDFLy,QFRDFLyQ 3XEOLFDFLyGHODLQFRDFLy3XEOLFDFLyQGHODLQFRDFLyQ%2( 'HVFULSFLy'HVFULSFLyQ 3DUWV,QWHJUDQWV3DUWHV,QWHJUDQWHV − )DoDQDSULQFLSDO)DFKDGDSULQFLSDO\ODWHUDOHV − &DPSDQDU&DPSDQDULR − 1DX SULQFLSDO FUHXHU L SUHVELWHUL VDJULVWLD L OD UHVWD GH OHV GHSHQGqQFLHV 1DYH SULQFLSDO FUXFHUR \ SUHVELWHULRVDFULVWtD\UHVWRGHGHSHQGHQFLDV − &~SXODVREUHWDPERU&~SXODVREUHWDPERU 'HVFULSFLyQ*HQHUDO'HVFULSFLyQ*HQHUDO (VWUDFWDG XQDHVJOpVLDTXHYDVHUHGLILFDGDDFRVWDGHO LOāOXVWUDW(Q)UDQFLVFR3pUH]%D\HUODFRQVWUXFFLy V¶LQLFLD HQ L V¶DFDED HQ /D WUDoD G HVWD HVJOpVLD YD VHU UHDOLW]DGD SHU -RDTXtQ ,EDxH] *DUFtD DUTXLWHFWH DFDGqPLF IRUPDW D ,WjOLD SHU OD TXDO FRVD OD VHXD FRQVWUXFFLy pV XQ GHOV SULPHUV H[HPSOHV D &DVWHOOyG DUTXLWHFWXUDQHRFOjVVLFD(OPHVWUHFRQVWUXFWRUYDVHU-RVp%XHQR/DSODQWDpVUHFWDQJXODUG XQD VRODQDXVHQVHFDSHOOHVODWHUDOVTXHVyQVXEVWLWXwGHVSHUGHSHQGqQFLHVDQQH[HV/DQDXHVGLYLGL[HQWUHV WUDPVDPEFUHXHULSUHVELWHULGHFDSoDOHUDUHFWD$OVSHXVGHO HVJOpVLDHQHOSULPHUWUDPVHVLWXDHOFRUDOW TXHFRPSDUWL[O DFFpVDPEHOFDPSDQDU / DOoDWLQWHULRUV DUWLFXODDPESLODVWUHVDPEXQRUGHTXHFRPELQDHOMzQLFLHOFRULQWLDPEYROXWHVXQLGHVSHU JDUODQGHV /D QDX HVWj FREHUWD DPE YROWD GH PLJ FDQy L HO SUHVELWHUL DPE F~SXOD $ O H[WHULRU GHVWDFD OD IDoDQDGHFRPSRVLFLyUHFWDQJXODUHVWUXFWXUDGDHQGRVFRVVRVHOFRVLQIHULRUpVGHPDMRUDOWXUDLDPEGyVVH VHSDUHQ SHU XQ HQWDXODPHQW 'H ULJRURVD VLPHWULD L SURSRUFLy V RUGHQD DPE SLODVWUHV GzULTXHV HQ DPEGyV FRVVRV O LQIHULRU Wp HQ OD VHXD SDUW FHQWUDO OD SRUWDGD PHQWUH TXH HQ HO VXSHULRU FHQWUD XQD ILQHVWUD DOOLQGDGD /D IDoDQD HVWj UHPDWD SHU XQ IURQWy WULDQJXODU (Q OD SDUW HVTXHUUD GH OD IDoDQD V DOoD HO FDPSDQDU%DVDGDHQHO&DWjOHJGH0RQXPHQWVL&RQMXQWVGHOD&RPXQLWDW9DOHQFLDQD 6HWUDWDGHXQDLJOHVLDTXHIXHHGLILFDGDDH[SHQVDVGHOLOXVWUDGR'RQ)UDQFLVFR3pUH]%D\HULQLFLiQGRVHOD FRQVWUXFFLyQHQ\WHUPLQDGDHQ/DWUD]DGHHVWDLJOHVLDIXHUHDOL]DGDSRU-RDTXtQ,EDxH]*DUFtD DUTXLWHFWR DFDGpPLFR IRUPDGR HQ ,WDOLD SRU OR TXH VX FRQVWUXFFLyQ HV XQR GH ORV SULPHURV HMHPSORV HQ &DVWHOOyQ GH DUTXLWHFWXUD QHRFOiVLFD (O PDHVWUR FRQVWUXFWRU IXH -RVp %XHQR /D SODQWD HV UHFWDQJXODU GH XQDVRODQDYHVLQFDSLOODVODWHUDOHVHVWDVVRQVXVWLWXLGDVSRUGHSHQGHQFLDVDQHMDV/DQDYHVHGLYLGHHQWUHV WUDPRVFRQFUXFHUR\SUHVELWHULRFRQFDEHFHUDUHFWD$ORVSLHVGHODLJOHVLDHQHOSULPHUWUDPRVHVLW~DHO FRURDOWRTXHFRPSDUWHHODFFHVRFRQHOFDPSDQDULR(ODO]DGRLQWHULRUVHDUWLFXODFRQSLODVWUDVFRQXQRUGHQ TXHFRPELQDHOMyQLFR\HOFRULQWLRFRQYROXWDVXQLGDVSRUJXLUQDOGDV/DQDYHHVWDFXELHUWDFRQEyYHGDGH PHGLR FDxyQ \ HO SUHVELWHULR FRQ F~SXOD $O H[WHULRU GHVWDFD OD IDFKDGD GH FRPSRVLFLyQ UHFWDQJXODU HVWUXFWXUDGDHQGRVFXHUSRV(OFXHUSRLQIHULRUHVGHPD\RUDOWXUDVHSDUDGRVDPERVSRUXQHQWDEODPHQWR 'HULJXURVDVLPHWUtD\SURSRUFLyQVHRUGHQDFRQSLODVWUDVGyULFDVHQDPERVFXHUSRVHOLQIHULRUWLHQHHQVX SDUWHFHQWUDOODSRUWDGDPLHQWUDVTXHHQHOVXSHULRUFHQWUDXQDYHQWDQDDGLQWHODGD6HUHPDWDODIDFKDGD SRUXQIURQWyQWULDQJXODU(QODSDUWHL]TXLHUGDGHODIDFKDGDVHDO]DHOFDPSDQDULR%DVDGDHQHO&DWiORJR GH0RQXPHQWRV\&RQMXQWRVGHOD&RPXQLGDG9DOHQFLDQD $11(;,9$1(;2,9 GH 5HVROXFLyGHG DEULOGHOD'LUHFFLy*HQHUDOGH3DWULPRQL&XOWXUDO9DOHQFLjL0XVHXVGHOD&RQVHOOHULDGH&XOWXUD(GXFDFLyL(VSRUWSHUODTXHV LQFRDH[SHGLHQWSHUDOD SULPHUD IDVH GH O DFWXDOLW]DFLy L DGDSWDFLy SDUFLDO GH OD 6HFFLy 3ULPHUD GH O ,QYHQWDUL *HQHUDO GHO 3DWULPRQL &XOWXUDO 9DOHQFLj HQ PDWqULD GH SDWULPRQL DUTXLWHFWzQLF L PHGLDPELHQWDOLV¶REULSHUtRGHG¶LQIRUPDFLyS~EOLFD 5HVROXFLyQ GH GH DEULO GH OD 'LUHFFLyQ *HQHUDO GH 3DWULPRQLR &XOWXUDO 9DOHQFLDQR \ 0XVHRV GH OD &RQVHOOHULD GH &XOWXUD (GXFDFLyQ \ 'HSRUWH SRU OD TXH VH LQFRD H[SHGLHQWH SDUD OD SULPHUD IDVH GH OD DFWXDOL]DFLyQ \ DGDSWDFLyQ SDUFLDO GH OD 6HFFLyQ 3ULPHUD GHO ,QYHQWDULR *HQHUDO GHO 3DWULPRQLR &XOWXUDO 9DOHQFLDQR HQ PDWHULD GH SDWULPRQLRDUTXLWHFWyQLFR\PHGLRDPELHQWDO\VHDEUHSHULRGRGHLQIRUPDFLyQSXEOLFD Núm. 5.503 / 02.05.2007 17871 2EVHUYDFLRQV2EVHUYDFLRQHV (QWRUQ(QWRUQR $QWHFHGHQWVDGPLQLVWUDWLXVGHOLPLWDFLyH[WUHWDGHO H[SHGLHQWGHILQLGDDPEFDUjFWHUSURYLVLRQDO 2ULJHQ,QWHUVHFFLyGHO HL[GHOFDUUHU6DQW7RPjVLODSURORQJDFLyGHODPLWJHUDHQWUHOHVSDUFHOāOHVL GHO¶LOODGHFDVHVSXQW$ 6HQWLW$QWLKRUDUL /tQLDGHOLPLWDGRUD/DOtQLDLQFORXOHVSDUFHOāOHVLGHO¶LOODGHFDVHV,QWURGXw[ODSDUFHOāOD GHO¶LOODGHFDVHV&UHXDHOFDUUHU/HV&UHXVLUHFRUUHOHVSRVWHULRUVGHOHVFDVHV WUDYHVVD OD SDUFHOāOD HQ HVWD GLUHFFLy VHJXL[ SHU OD SRVWHULRU GH OD SDUFHOāOD L LQFORX OD WUDYHVVDGHQRXHOFDUUHU%D\HULJLUDDQRUGRHVWLVHJXL[HQWUHOHVSDUFHOāOHVLLGHO¶LOODGHFDVHV &UHXD HO FDUUHU 6DQW 7RPjV L LQFRUSRUD OHV SDUFHOāOHV L GH O¶LOOD GH FDVHV 7UDYHVVD HO FDUUHU)RQWGHO6HQ\RULLQFRUSRUDGHOHVSDUFHOāOHVLGHO¶LOODGHFDVHV $QWHFHGHQWHVDGPLQLVWUDWLYRVGHOLPLWDFLyQH[WUDtGDGHOH[SHGLHQWHGHILQLGDFRQFDUiFWHUSURYLVLRQDO 2ULJHQ,QWHUVHFFLyQGHOHMHGHODFDOOH6DQWR7RPiV\ODSURORQJDFLyQGHODPHGLDQHUDHQWUHODVSDUFHODV \GHODPDQ]DQDSXQWR$ 6HQWLGR$QWLKRUDULR /tQHDGHOLPLWDGRUD/DOtQHDLQFOX\HODVSDUFHODV\GHODPDQ]DQD,QWURGXFHODSDUFHOD GHODPDQ]DQD&UX]DODFDOOH/HV&UHXV\UHFRUUHODVWUDVHUDVGHODVFDVDV DWUDYLHVDODSDUFHODHQHVWDGLUHFFLyQVLJXHSRUODWUDVHUDGHODSDUFHODHLQFOX\HODDWUDYLHVD GHQXHYRODFDOOH%D\HU\JLUDDQRURHVWH\VLJXHHQWUHODVSDUFHODV\\GHODPDQ]DQD &UX]DODFDOOH6DQWR7RPiVHLQFRUSRUDODVSDUFHODV\GHODPDQ]DQD$WUDYLHVDODFDOOH)RQWGHO 6HxRUHLQFRUSRUDGHODVSDUFHODV\GHODPDQ]DQD $11(;,9$1(;2,9 GH 5HVROXFLyGHG DEULOGHOD'LUHFFLy*HQHUDOGH3DWULPRQL&XOWXUDO9DOHQFLjL0XVHXVGHOD&RQVHOOHULDGH&XOWXUD(GXFDFLyL(VSRUWSHUODTXHV LQFRDH[SHGLHQWSHUDOD SULPHUD IDVH GH O DFWXDOLW]DFLy L DGDSWDFLy SDUFLDO GH OD 6HFFLy 3ULPHUD GH O ,QYHQWDUL *HQHUDO GHO 3DWULPRQL &XOWXUDO 9DOHQFLj HQ PDWqULD GH SDWULPRQL DUTXLWHFWzQLF L PHGLDPELHQWDOLV¶REULSHUtRGHG¶LQIRUPDFLyS~EOLFD 5HVROXFLyQ GH GH DEULO GH OD 'LUHFFLyQ *HQHUDO GH 3DWULPRQLR &XOWXUDO 9DOHQFLDQR \ 0XVHRV GH OD &RQVHOOHULD GH &XOWXUD (GXFDFLyQ \ 'HSRUWH SRU OD TXH VH LQFRD H[SHGLHQWH SDUD OD SULPHUD IDVH GH OD DFWXDOL]DFLyQ \ DGDSWDFLyQ SDUFLDO GH OD 6HFFLyQ 3ULPHUD GHO ,QYHQWDULR *HQHUDO GHO 3DWULPRQLR &XOWXUDO 9DOHQFLDQR HQ PDWHULD GH SDWULPRQLRDUTXLWHFWyQLFR\PHGLRDPELHQWDO\VHDEUHSHULRGRGHLQIRUPDFLyQSXEOLFD Núm. 5.503 / 02.05.2007 17872 %e'¶,17(5e6&8/785$/±(6*/e6,$3$55248,$/'(µ6$172720È6'(9,//$18(9$¶ %(1,&¬66,002180(17 %,(1'(,17(5e6&8/785$/,*/(6,$3$55248,$/'(6$172720È6'(9,//$18(9$ %(1,&$6,002180(172 $11(;,9$1(;2,9 GH 5HVROXFLyGHG DEULOGHOD'LUHFFLy*HQHUDOGH3DWULPRQL&XOWXUDO9DOHQFLjL0XVHXVGHOD&RQVHOOHULDGH&XOWXUD(GXFDFLyL(VSRUWSHUODTXHV LQFRDH[SHGLHQWSHUDOD SULPHUD IDVH GH O DFWXDOLW]DFLy L DGDSWDFLy SDUFLDO GH OD 6HFFLy 3ULPHUD GH O ,QYHQWDUL *HQHUDO GHO 3DWULPRQL &XOWXUDO 9DOHQFLj HQ PDWqULD GH SDWULPRQL DUTXLWHFWzQLF L PHGLDPELHQWDOLV¶REULSHUtRGHG¶LQIRUPDFLyS~EOLFD 5HVROXFLyQ GH GH DEULO GH OD 'LUHFFLyQ *HQHUDO GH 3DWULPRQLR &XOWXUDO 9DOHQFLDQR \ 0XVHRV GH OD &RQVHOOHULD GH &XOWXUD (GXFDFLyQ \ 'HSRUWH SRU OD TXH VH LQFRD H[SHGLHQWH SDUD OD SULPHUD IDVH GH OD DFWXDOL]DFLyQ \ DGDSWDFLyQ SDUFLDO GH OD 6HFFLyQ 3ULPHUD GHO ,QYHQWDULR *HQHUDO GHO 3DWULPRQLR &XOWXUDO 9DOHQFLDQR HQ PDWHULD GH SDWULPRQLRDUTXLWHFWyQLFR\PHGLRDPELHQWDO\VHDEUHSHULRGRGHLQIRUPDFLyQSXEOLFD Núm. 5.503 / 02.05.2007 17873 %e'¶,17(5e6&8/785$/±(6*/e6,$3$55248,$/'(6$170,48(/$5&¬1*(/%(1,*È1,0 02180(17 %,(1'(,17(5e6&8/785$/,*/(6,$3$55248,$/'(6$10,*8(/$5&È1*(/%(1,*È1,0 02180(172 'HQRPLQDFLy'HQRPLQDFLyQ 3ULQFLSDO3ULQFLSDO (VJOpVLD3DUURTXLDOGH6DQW0LTXHO$UFjQJHO ,JOHVLD3DUURTXLDOGH6DQ0LJXHO$UFiQJHO /RFDOLW]DFLy/RFDOL]DFLyQ 3URYtQFLD3URYLQFLD9DOqQFLD &RPDUFD&RPDUFD/D9DOOG¶$OEDLGD 0XQLFLSL0XQLFLSLR%HQLJiQLP 8ELFDFLy8ELFDFLyQ&GHO¶(VJOpVLD 5HIHUqQFLD&DGDVWUDO5HIHUHQFLD&DWDVWUDO ,OOD0DQ]DQD3DUFHOāOD3DUFHOD $QWHFHGHQWV-XUtGLFV$QWHFHGHQWHV-XUtGLFRV ,QFRDFLy,QFRDFLyQ 3XEOLFDFLyGHODLQFRDFLy3XEOLFDFLyQGHODLQFRDFLyQ%2( 'HVFULSFLy'HVFULSFLyQ 3DUWV,QWHJUDQWV3DUWHV,QWHJUDQWHV − /DQDXSULQFLSDOLOHVFDSHOOHVODWHUDOV/DQDYHSULQFLSDO\ODVFDSLOODVODWHUDOHV − /DWRUUHFDPSDQDU/DWRUUHFDPSDQDULR − /DVDJULVWLDLHOVHVSDLVDQQH[RV/DVDFULVWtD\ORVHVSDFLRVDQH[RV − /DFDSHOODGHOD&RPXQLy/DFDSLOODGHOD&RPXQLyQ 'HVFULSFLy*HQHUDO'HVFULSFLyQ*HQHUDO (QHOFHQWUHGHODSREODFLyV DOoDHVWDHVJOpVLDH[HPSOHGHOPDQLHULVPHGHOVHJOH;9,,TXHHQVUHFRUGDD OHVHVJOpVLHVG $\RUD;jWLYDL$OEDLGD/DGLUHFFLyGHO REUDYDVHUGXWDDWHUPHSHU9LFHQWH$EULOILQVD /HV REUHV VHPEOD TXH HV YDQ LQLFLDU HQ MD TXH HV WHQHQ QRWtFLHV G XQ PDQXVFULW GHOV FRPSWHV GH O HVJOpVLDGHVG HL[HPDWHL[DQ\ILQVD(QHVWDSULPHUDIDVHHVYDDOoDUHOFDPSDQDUTXHSRUWDLQVFULWD ODGDWDGH (V WUDFWD G XQ WHPSOH G XQD VROD QDX GLYLGLGD HQ VLV WUDPV DPE FDSHOOHV HQWUH FRQWUDIRUWV FRPXQLFDGHV HQWUH Vt OD VHXD FDSoDOHUD pV SROLJRQDO GH WUHV FRVWDWV / DOoDW HV UHDOLW]D DPE SLODVWUHV GzULTXHV DPE XQ HQWDXODPHQWGHWUtJOLIVLPqWRSHV0DOJUDWO¶XWLOLW]DFLyG¶XQOOHQJXDWJHPDQLHULVWDGHJUDQVHYHULWDWV XWLOLW]HQ OHVWUDGLFLRQVFRQVWUXFWLYHVJzWLTXHVORFDOVHQOHVYROWHVGHFUHXHULDGHODFREHUWD$ILQDOVGHOVHJOH;9,,HV YD UHPRGHODU OD FDSHOOD DPE XQD GHFRUDFLy EDUURFD TXH YD GHVDSDUpL[HU HQ DL[t FRP WDPEp GHVDSDUHJXpHOUHWDXOHPDMRUGHJUDQVGLPHQVLRQV $ O H[WHULRU GHVWDFD OD IDoDQD DPE WUHV FRVVRV GHFUHL[HQWV (Q HO FRV LQIHULRU D PDQHUD G DUF WULRPIDO HV WURED OD SRUWDGD IODQTXHMDGD SHU FROXPQHV DSDULDGHV G RUGH GzULF VLWXDQWVH HQWUH HOV LQWHUFROXPQLV GRV IRUQtFXOHV DYHQHUDGDV (O VHJRQ FRV HV GLVSRVD DPE WUHV IRUQtFXOHV OD FHQWUDO GH PDMRUV GLPHQVLRQV HV UHPDWDDPESLUjPLGHVHVYHOWHV LEROHV (OWHUFHUFRV pVXQYDUHFWDQJXODUHPPDUFDW SHU SLODVWUHV DPE XQ IURQWyWULDQJXODUHQODSDUWVXSHULRUDPEEROHV $O HVTXHUUDGHODIDoDQDSULQFLSDOHVWjHOFDPSDQDURFWRJRQDODPEXQDDOWXUDDSUR[LPDGDGHPHWUHV/D UHPDWDGDRULJLQDOYDVHUGHVWUXwGDHQSHUXQUDLJHQVXEVWLWXFLyHVYDFROāORFDUHOWHPSOHWF~ELFTXHKL KDHQO DFWXDOLWDW(VWDWRUUHFDPSDQDUpVLQGHSHQGHQWGHOWHPSOHHQFDUDTXHHVWDQDGRVVDWV/DFDSHOODGH OD&RPXQLypVG XQDVRODQDXDPEF~SXODKXLWDYDGD9DVHUFRQVWUXwGDHQWUHLLUHQRYDGDHQHO VHJOH;,;/DIjEULFDGHOFRQMXQWpV GHFDUUHXVDPEPDoRQHULD HQFRQWUDIRUWVLPXUV %DVDW HQ HO &DWjOHJGH0RQXPHQWVL&RQMXQWVGHOD&RPXQLWDW9DOHQFLDQD (QHOFHQWURGHODSREODFLyQVHOHYDQWDHVWDLJOHVLDHMHPSORGHOPDQLHULVPRGHOVLJOR;9,,TXHQRVUHFXHUGD DODVLJOHVLDVGH$\RUD;jWLYD\$OEDLGD/DGLUHFFLyQGHODREUDIXHOOHYDGDDFDERSRU9LFHQWH$EULOKDVWD /DVREUDVSDUHFHTXHVHLQLFLDURQHQ\DTXHVHWLHQHQQRWLFLDVGHXQPDQXVFULWRGHODVFXHQWDV GH OD LJOHVLD GHVGH HVH PLVPR DxR KDVWD (Q HVWD SULPHUD IDVH VH OHYDQWy HO FDPSDQDULR TXH OOHYD LQVFULWDODIHFKDGH6HWUDWDGHXQWHPSORGHXQDVRODQDYHGLYLGLGDHQVHLVWUDPRVFRQFDSLOODVHQWUH FRQWUDIXHUWHV FRPXQLFDGDV HQWUH Vt WHQLHQGR FDEHFHUD SROLJRQDO GH WUHV ODGRV (O DO]DGR VH UHDOL]D FRQ SLODVWUDVGyULFDVFRQXQHQWDEODPHQWRGHWULJOLIRV\PHWRSDV$SHVDUGHXWLOL]DUXQOHQJXDMHPDQLHULVWDGH JUDQ VHYHULGDG VH XWLOL]DQ ODV WUDGLFLRQHV FRQVWUXFWLYDV JyWLFDV ORFDOHV HQ ODV EyYHGDV GH FUXFHUtD GH OD FXELHUWD$ILQDOHVGHOVLJOR;9,,VHUHPRGHOyODFDSLOODFRQGHFRUDFLyQEDUURFDGHVDSDUHFLHQGRHQDVt $11(;,9$1(;2,9 GH 5HVROXFLyGHG DEULOGHOD'LUHFFLy*HQHUDOGH3DWULPRQL&XOWXUDO9DOHQFLjL0XVHXVGHOD&RQVHOOHULDGH&XOWXUD(GXFDFLyL(VSRUWSHUODTXHV LQFRDH[SHGLHQWSHUDOD SULPHUD IDVH GH O DFWXDOLW]DFLy L DGDSWDFLy SDUFLDO GH OD 6HFFLy 3ULPHUD GH O ,QYHQWDUL *HQHUDO GHO 3DWULPRQL &XOWXUDO 9DOHQFLj HQ PDWqULD GH SDWULPRQL DUTXLWHFWzQLF L PHGLDPELHQWDOLV¶REULSHUtRGHG¶LQIRUPDFLyS~EOLFD 5HVROXFLyQ GH GH DEULO GH OD 'LUHFFLyQ *HQHUDO GH 3DWULPRQLR &XOWXUDO 9DOHQFLDQR \ 0XVHRV GH OD &RQVHOOHULD GH &XOWXUD (GXFDFLyQ \ 'HSRUWH SRU OD TXH VH LQFRD H[SHGLHQWH SDUD OD SULPHUD IDVH GH OD DFWXDOL]DFLyQ \ DGDSWDFLyQ SDUFLDO GH OD 6HFFLyQ 3ULPHUD GHO ,QYHQWDULR *HQHUDO GHO 3DWULPRQLR &XOWXUDO 9DOHQFLDQR HQ PDWHULD GH SDWULPRQLRDUTXLWHFWyQLFR\PHGLRDPELHQWDO\VHDEUHSHULRGRGHLQIRUPDFLyQSXEOLFD Núm. 5.503 / 02.05.2007 17874 GHFUHFLHQWHV (Q HO FXHUSR LQIHULRU D PRGR GH DUFR WULXQIDO VH HQFXHQWUD OD SRUWDGD IODQTXHDGD SRU FROXPQDV SDUHDGDV GH RUGHQ GyULFR VLWXiQGRVH HQWUH ORV LQWHUFROXPQLRV GRV KRUQDFLQDV DYHQHUDGDV (O VHJXQGR FXHUSR VH GLVSRQH FRQ WUHV KRUQDFLQDV OD FHQWUDO GH PD\RUHV GLPHQVLRQHV VH UHPDWD FRQ SLUiPLGHVHVEHOWDV\ERODV(OWHUFHUFXHUSRHVXQYDQRUHFWDQJXODUHQPDUFDGRSRUSLODVWUDVFRQXQIURQWyQ WULDQJXODUHQODSDUWHVXSHULRUFRQERODV$ODL]TXLHUGDGHODIDFKDGDSULQFLSDOHVWDHOFDPSDQDULRRFWRJRQDO FRQ XQD DOWXUD DSUR[LPDGD GH PHWURV (O UHPDWH RULJLQDO IXH GHVWUXLGR HQ SRU XQ UD\R HQ VXVWLWXFLyQVHFRORFyHOWHPSOHWHF~ELFRTXHKD\HQODDFWXDOLGDG(VWDWRUUHFDPSDQDULRHVLQGHSHQGLHQWH GHOWHPSORDXQTXHHVWiQDGRVDGRV/DFDSLOODGHOD&RPXQLyQHVGHXQDVRODQDYHFRQF~SXODRFKDYDGD )XHFRQVWUXLGDHQWUH\\UHQRYDGDHQHOVLJOR;,;/DIiEULFDGHOFRQMXQWRHVGHVLOODUHV FRQPDPSRVWHUtDGHUHOOHQRHQFRQWUDIXHUWHV\PXURV%DVDGRHQHO&DWiORJRGH0RQXPHQWRV\&RQMXQWRV GHOD&RPXQLGDG9DOHQFLDQD 2EVHUYDFLRQV2EVHUYDFLRQHV (QWRUQ(QWRUQR $QWHFHGHQWVDGPLQLVWUDWLXVGHOLPLWDFLyH[WUHWDGHO H[SHGLHQWGHILQLGDDPEFDUjFWHUSURYLVLRQDO 2ULJHQLQWHUVHFFLyGHO HL[GHOFDUUHU0DUTXpVDPEO HL[GHOFDUUHU'RFWRU5DQWHUSXQW$ 6HQWLW+RUDUL /tQLD GHOLPLWDGRUD OD OtQLD HV GLULJL[ D QRUG LQWURGXLQWVH HQ O¶LOOD GH FDVHV FDGDVWUDO UHFRUUHQW OHV SRVWHULRUV GH OHV SDUFHOāOHV Q~PHURV L &UHXD HO FDUUHU GH 6DQW 5RF L SURVVHJXL[ SHU OHV SRVWHULRUVGHOHVSDUFHOāOHVLGHO¶LOODGHFDVHV7UDYHVVDHOFDUUHUGH0RQWFDGDLV LQWURGXw[ HQO¶LOODGHFDVHVSHOOtPLWVXGGHODSDUFHOāOD5HFRUUHOHVSRVWHULRUVGHOHVSDUFHOāOHVQ~PHURV LG HVWDLOODGHFDVHVILQVDO HL[GHOFDUUHUGHOSUtQFHS)HOLS6HJXL[DOQRUGSHUHVWHHL[ILQVDJLUDUD HVW SHU O HL[ GH O DYLQJXGD 5HDO 7UDYHVVD OD SODoD GH OD %HDWD ,QpV L LQFRUSRUD OHV SDUFHOāOHV GH OHV LOOHV LTXHGRQHQDOVFDUUHUVGHO (VJOpVLDLGHO0DUTXpV*LUDDO¶RHVWSHUO HL[GHOFDUUHUGHO'RFWRU 5DQWHUILQVDOSXQWG RULJHQ $QWHFHGHQWHVDGPLQLVWUDWLYRVGHOLPLWDFLyQH[WUDtGDGHOH[SHGLHQWHGHILQLGDFRQFDUiFWHUSURYLVLRQDO 2ULJHQLQWHUVHFFLyQGHOHMHGHODFDOOH0DUTXpVFRQHOHMHGHODFDOOH'RFWRU5DQWHUSXQWR$ 6HQWLGR+RUDULR /tQHDGHOLPLWDGRUDODOtQHDVHGLULJHDQRUWHLQWURGXFLpQGRVHHQODPDQ]DQDFDWDVWUDOUHFRUULHQGRODV WUDVHUDVGHODVSDUFHODV\&UX]DODFDOOH6DQW5RF\SURVLJXHSRUODVWUDVHUDVGHODVSDUFHODV \GHODPDQ]DQD$WUDYLHVDODFDOOH0RQWFDGD\VHLQWURGXFHHQODPDQ]DQDSRUHO OLQGHVXUGHODSDUFHOD5HFRUUHODVWUDVHUDVGHODVSDUFHODVQ~PHURV\GHHVWDPDQ]DQDKDVWD HOHMHGHODFDOOH3UtQFLSH)HOLSH6LJXHDQRUWHSRUHVWHHMHKDVWDJLUDUDHVWHSRUHOHMHGHODDYHQLGD5HDO $WUDYLHVDODSOD]DGHOD%HDWD,QpVHLQFRUSRUDODVSDUFHODVGHODVPDQ]DQDV\UHFD\HQWHVDODV FDOOHVGHOD,JOHVLD\0DUTXpV*LUDDRHVWHSRUHOHMHGHODFDOOH'RFWRU5DQWHUKDVWDHOSXQWRGHRULJHQ $11(;,9$1(;2,9 GH 5HVROXFLyGHG DEULOGHOD'LUHFFLy*HQHUDOGH3DWULPRQL&XOWXUDO9DOHQFLjL0XVHXVGHOD&RQVHOOHULDGH&XOWXUD(GXFDFLyL(VSRUWSHUODTXHV LQFRDH[SHGLHQWSHUDOD SULPHUD IDVH GH O DFWXDOLW]DFLy L DGDSWDFLy SDUFLDO GH OD 6HFFLy 3ULPHUD GH O ,QYHQWDUL *HQHUDO GHO 3DWULPRQL &XOWXUDO 9DOHQFLj HQ PDWqULD GH SDWULPRQL DUTXLWHFWzQLF L PHGLDPELHQWDOLV¶REULSHUtRGHG¶LQIRUPDFLyS~EOLFD 5HVROXFLyQ GH GH DEULO GH OD 'LUHFFLyQ *HQHUDO GH 3DWULPRQLR &XOWXUDO 9DOHQFLDQR \ 0XVHRV GH OD &RQVHOOHULD GH &XOWXUD (GXFDFLyQ \ 'HSRUWH SRU OD TXH VH LQFRD H[SHGLHQWH SDUD OD SULPHUD IDVH GH OD DFWXDOL]DFLyQ \ DGDSWDFLyQ SDUFLDO GH OD 6HFFLyQ 3ULPHUD GHO ,QYHQWDULR *HQHUDO GHO 3DWULPRQLR &XOWXUDO 9DOHQFLDQR HQ PDWHULD GH SDWULPRQLRDUTXLWHFWyQLFR\PHGLRDPELHQWDO\VHDEUHSHULRGRGHLQIRUPDFLyQSXEOLFD Núm. 5.503 / 02.05.2007 17875 %e'¶,17(5e6&8/785$/±(6*/e6,$3$55248,$/'(6$170,48(/$5&¬1*(/%(1,*È1,0 02180(17 %,(1'(,17(5e6&8/785$/,*/(6,$3$55248,$/'(6$10,*8(/$5&È1*(/%(1,*È1,0 02180(172 $11(;,9$1(;2,9 GH 5HVROXFLyGHG DEULOGHOD'LUHFFLy*HQHUDOGH3DWULPRQL&XOWXUDO9DOHQFLjL0XVHXVGHOD&RQVHOOHULDGH&XOWXUD(GXFDFLyL(VSRUWSHUODTXHV LQFRDH[SHGLHQWSHUDOD SULPHUD IDVH GH O DFWXDOLW]DFLy L DGDSWDFLy SDUFLDO GH OD 6HFFLy 3ULPHUD GH O ,QYHQWDUL *HQHUDO GHO 3DWULPRQL &XOWXUDO 9DOHQFLj HQ PDWqULD GH SDWULPRQL DUTXLWHFWzQLF L PHGLDPELHQWDOLV¶REULSHUtRGHG¶LQIRUPDFLyS~EOLFD 5HVROXFLyQ GH GH DEULO GH OD 'LUHFFLyQ *HQHUDO GH 3DWULPRQLR &XOWXUDO 9DOHQFLDQR \ 0XVHRV GH OD &RQVHOOHULD GH &XOWXUD (GXFDFLyQ \ 'HSRUWH SRU OD TXH VH LQFRD H[SHGLHQWH SDUD OD SULPHUD IDVH GH OD DFWXDOL]DFLyQ \ DGDSWDFLyQ SDUFLDO GH OD 6HFFLyQ 3ULPHUD GHO ,QYHQWDULR *HQHUDO GHO 3DWULPRQLR &XOWXUDO 9DOHQFLDQR HQ PDWHULD GH SDWULPRQLRDUTXLWHFWyQLFR\PHGLRDPELHQWDO\VHDEUHSHULRGRGHLQIRUPDFLyQSXEOLFD Núm. 5.503 / 02.05.2007 17876 %e'¶,17(5e6&8/785$/±(6*/e6,$3$55248,$/'(/$0$5('('e8'(/¶$66803&,Ï%,$5 02180(17 %,(1'(,17(5e6&8/785$/,*/(6,$3$55248,$/'(18(675$6(f25$'(/$$681&,Ï1 %,$502180(172 'HQRPLQDFLy'HQRPLQDFLyQ 3ULQFLSDO3ULQFLSDO (VJOpVLD3DUURTXLDOGHOD0DUHGH'pXGHO¶$VVXPSFLy ,JOHVLD3DUURTXLDOGH1XHVWUD6HxRUDGHOD$VXQFLyQ $FFHVzULD$FFHVRULD ,JOHVLD3DUURTXLDOGHOD9LUJHQGHOD$VXQFLyQ /RFDOL]DFLy/RFDOL]DFLyQ 3URYtQFLD3URYLQFLD$ODFDQW &RPDUFD&RPDUFD/¶$OW9LQDORSy 0XQLFLSL0XQLFLSLR%LDU 8ELFDFLy8ELFDFLyQ3oDGHOD&RQVWLWXFLy3]D&RQVWLWXFLyQ 5HIHUqQFLD&DGDVWUDO5HIHUHQFLD&DWDVWUDO ,OOD0DQ]DQD3DUFHOāOD3DUFHOD $QWHFHGHQWV-XUtGLFV$QWHFHGHQWHV-XUtGLFRV ,QFRDFLy,QFRDFLyQ 3XEOLFDFLyGHODLQFRDFLy3XEOLFDFLyQGHODLQFRDFLyQ%2( 'HVFULSFLy'HVFULSFLyQ 3DUWV,QWHJUDQWV3DUWHV,QWHJUDQWHV − (VJOpVLDDPEQDXFHQWUDOLFDSHOOHVHQWUHFRQWUDIRUWV,JOHVLDFRQQDYHFHQWUDO\FDSLOODVHQWUH FRQWUDIXHUWHV − − − − 7RUUHFDPSDQDU7RUUHFDPSDQDULR 3UHVELWHUL3UHVELWHULR &DSHOODGHOD&RPXQLy&DSLOODGHOD&RPXQLyQ 3RUWDGDSULQFLSDO3RUWDGDSULQFLSDO 'HVFULSFLy*HQHUDO'HVFULSFLyQ*HQHUDO (VJOpVLD JzWLFD G¶RULJHQ PHGLHYDO TXH YD WLQGUH GLYHUVHV LQWHUYHQFLRQV SRVWHULRUV G XQD VROD QDX DPE FDSHOOHVHQWUHFRQWUDIRUWVLFDSoDOHUDSROLJRQDOGHFLQFFRVWDWV/DQDXWpFLQFWUDPVLHVFREUL[DPEYROWDGH FUHXHULDHOSUHVELWHULHVWjFREHUWSHUPLWMjG XQDYROWDGHKXLWQHUYLVTXHV XQL[HQHQXQD~QLFDFODX(VWD HVJOpVLDHVYDFRQFORXUHHQHOVHJOH;9,DPEODSRUWDGDUHQDL[HQWLVWDTXHV KDUHODFLRQDWDPEODSRUWDGHOHV FDGHQHVGHODFDWHGUDOGH0~UFLD /D FDSHOOD GH OD &RPXQLy HV YD UHDOLW]DU D ILQDOV GHO VHJOH ;9,, VHJXLQW HO GLVVHQ\ GH -XDQ %DXWLVWD 3pUH] &DVWLHO OD VHXD SODQWD pV GH FUHX JUHJD GH EUDoRV FXUWV L HVWj FREHUWD SHU XQD F~SXOD VREUH SHW[LQHV 'HFRUDGD DPE XQD ELJDUUDGD GHFRUDFLy GH JXL[RV L IUHVFV 'HVWDFD HQ O HQWRUQ XUEj SHUTXq HV WURED DGRVVDGDDOVSHXVGHO HVJOpVLD (QHOVHJOH;9,,,O HVJOpVLDHVYDUHFREULUG HVWXFVVHJXLQWHOJXVWEDUURF(QO DFWXDOLWDWFRPDUHFRUGG HVWH IHWV KDQGHL[DWDL[tODFDSoDOHUDLOHVFDSHOOHVODWHUDOVPHQWUHTXHODQDXHVYDWRUQDUDOVHXHVWLORULJLQDUL HQ $O H[WHULRUGHVWDFDODIDoDQDRQHVWUREDODSRUWDGDUHQDL[HQWLVWDTXHGHVHQYROXSDHOVPRWLXVGHFRUDWLXVGHO VHX HVWLO FRP VyQ OHV YHQHUHV R SHW[LQHV IRUQtFXOHV SXWWL FDQHOREUHV L EDOXVWUDGD HQWUH G¶DOWUHV /D LFRQRJUDILD TXH GHVHQYROXSD FRQWLQXD OD WUDGLFLy PHGLHYDO pV SHU DL[z TXH YHLHP PDOJUDW OD VHXD HPSUHPWDUHQDL[HQWLVWDFRPHQFDUDSHUGXUHQHOHPHQWVJRWLFLVWHV /D WRUUH FDPSDQDU GH TXDWUH FRVVRV L UHPDWDGD HVWj GHFRUDGD DPE PRWLXV JHRPqWULFV %DVDGD HQ HO &DWjOHJ GH 0RQXPHQWV L &RQMXQWV GH OD &RPXQLWDW 9DOHQFLDQD L OD *XLD G $UTXLWHFWXUD GH OD SURYtQFLD G $ODFDQW 'HRULJHQPHGLHYDOHVHVWDLJOHVLDJyWLFDTXHWXYRGLYHUVDVDFWXDFLRQHVSRVWHULRUHVGHXQDVRODQDYHFRQ FDSLOODVHQWUHFRQWUDIXHUWHV\FDEHFHUDSROLJRQDOGHFLQFRODGRV/DQDYHWLHQHFLQFRWUDPRV\VHFXEUHFRQ EyYHGDGHFUXFHUtDHOSUHVELWHULRHVWiFXELHUWRPHGLDQWHXQDEyYHGDGHRFKRQHUYLRVTXHVHXQHQHQXQD ~QLFDFODYH(VWDLJOHVLDVHFRQFOX\yHQHOVLJOR;9,FRQODSRUWDGDUHQDFHQWLVWDTXHVHKDUHODFLRQDGRFRQOD SXHUWDGHODVFDGHQDVGHOD&DWHGUDOGH0XUFLD /D FDSLOOD GH OD &RPXQLyQ VH UHDOL]y D ILQDOHV GHO VLJOR ;9,, VLJXLHQGR HO GLVHxR GH -XDQ %DXWLVWD 3pUH] &DVWLHO VX SODQWD HV GH FUX] JULHJD GH EUD]RV FRUWRV \ HVWi FXELHUWD SRU XQD F~SXOD VREUH SHFKLQDV $11(;,9$1(;2,9 GH 5HVROXFLyGHG DEULOGHOD'LUHFFLy*HQHUDOGH3DWULPRQL&XOWXUDO9DOHQFLjL0XVHXVGHOD&RQVHOOHULDGH&XOWXUD(GXFDFLyL(VSRUWSHUODTXHV LQFRDH[SHGLHQWSHUDOD SULPHUD IDVH GH O DFWXDOLW]DFLy L DGDSWDFLy SDUFLDO GH OD 6HFFLy 3ULPHUD GH O ,QYHQWDUL *HQHUDO GHO 3DWULPRQL &XOWXUDO 9DOHQFLj HQ PDWqULD GH SDWULPRQL DUTXLWHFWzQLF L PHGLDPELHQWDOLV¶REULSHUtRGHG¶LQIRUPDFLyS~EOLFD 5HVROXFLyQ GH GH DEULO GH OD 'LUHFFLyQ *HQHUDO GH 3DWULPRQLR &XOWXUDO 9DOHQFLDQR \ 0XVHRV GH OD &RQVHOOHULD GH &XOWXUD (GXFDFLyQ \ 'HSRUWH SRU OD TXH VH LQFRD H[SHGLHQWH SDUD OD SULPHUD IDVH GH OD DFWXDOL]DFLyQ \ DGDSWDFLyQ SDUFLDO GH OD 6HFFLyQ 3ULPHUD GHO ,QYHQWDULR *HQHUDO GHO 3DWULPRQLR &XOWXUDO 9DOHQFLDQR HQ PDWHULD GH SDWULPRQLRDUTXLWHFWyQLFR\PHGLRDPELHQWDO\VHDEUHSHULRGRGHLQIRUPDFLyQSXEOLFD Núm. 5.503 / 02.05.2007 17877 'HFRUDGD FRQ XQD DELJDUUDGD GHFRUDFLyQ D EDVH GH \HVR \ IUHVFRV 'HVWDFD HQ HO HQWRUQR XUEDQR HVWD FDSLOOD\DTXHVHHQFXHQWUDDGRVDGDDORVSLHVGHODLJOHVLD (QHOVLJOR;9,,,ODLJOHVLDVHUHFXEULyGHHVWXFRVVLJXLHQGRHOJXVWREDUURFR(QODDFWXDOLGDGFRPRUHFXHUGR GHHVWHKHFKRVHKDQGHMDGRDVtODFDEHFHUD\ODVFDSLOODVODWHUDOHVPLHQWUDVTXHODQDYHVHGHYROYLyDVX HVWLORRULJLQDULRHQ $O H[WHULRU GHVWDFD OD IDFKDGD GRQGH VH HQFXHQWUD OD SRUWDGD UHQDFHQWLVWD TXH GHVDUUROOD ORV PRWLYRV GHFRUDWLYRVGHVXHVWLORFRPRVRQODVYHQHUDVRFRQFKDVKRUQDFLQDVSXWWLFDQGHODEURV\EDODXVWUDGDHQWUH RWURV/DLFRQRJUDItDTXHGHVDUUROODVLJXHODWUDGLFLyQPHGLHYDO3RUHOORYHPRVFRPRDSHVDUGHWHQHUXQD LPSURQWDUHQDFHQWLVWDWRGDYtDSHUGXUDQHOHPHQWRVJRWLFLVWDV /D WRUUH FDPSDQDULR GH FXDWUR FXHUSRV \ UHPDWH HVWi GHFRUDGD FRQ PRWLYRV JHRPpWULFRV %DVDGD HQ HO &DWiORJRGH0RQXPHQWRV\&RQMXQWRVGHOD&RPXQLGDG9DOHQFLD\OD*XtDGH$UTXLWHFWXUDGHOD3URYLQFLDGH $OLFDQWH 2EVHUYDFLRQV2EVHUYDFLRQHV (QWRUQ(QWRUQ $QWHFHGHQWVDGPLQLVWUDWLXVGHOLPLWDFLyH[WUHWDGHO H[SHGLHQWGHILQLGDDPEFDUjFWHUSURYLVLRQDO 2ULJHQ,QWHUVHFFLyGHO HL[GHOFDUUHUGHOD7RUUHWDDPEODSURORQJDFLyGHODPLWJHUDQRUGGHODSDUFHOāOD GHO¶LOODGHFDVHVSXQW$ 6HQWLWKRUDUL /tQLDGHOLPLWDGRUDGHVGHO RULJHQODOtQLDHVGLULJL[DOVXGLLQFRUSRUDOHVSDUFHOāOHVLGHO¶LOODGH FDVHV&UHXDHOFDUUHUGH/XLV&DOSHQDLHPEROLFDODSDUFHOāODGHO¶LOODGHFDVHVLUHFRUUHOHV SRVWHULRUVGHOHVSDUFHOāOHVLGHO¶LOODGHFDVHVVHJXL[SHUODPLWJHUDQRUGGHOD SDUFHOāODG HVWDLOODGHFDVHVLFUHXDHOFDUUHUGH6DQWD0DULD,QFRUSRUDODSDUFHOāODGHO¶LOODGHFDVHV LOHVLGHOD&UHXDHOFDUUHU0DMRULUHFRUUHOHVPLWJHUHVHVWGHOHVSDUFHOāOHVLGH O¶LOODGHFDVHV,QFRUSRUD OHVSDUFHOāOHVLGHO¶LOOD GHFDVHV LVHJXL[SHU O HL[GHO FDUUHUGHO&DSLWjLQFRUSRUDO¶LOODGHFDVHV6HJXL[SHUODPLWJHUDHQWUHOHVSDUFHOāOHVLGHO¶LOODGH FDVHVLSHUOHVSRVWHULRUVGHOHVLOOHVG HVWDLOODGHFDVHV(QYROWDODSDUFHOāODGHO¶LOOD GHFDVHVILQVDOSXQWG RULJHQ$ $QWHFHGHQWHVDGPLQLVWUDWLYRVGHOLPLWDFLyQH[WUDtGDGHOH[SHGLHQWHGHILQLGDFRQFDUiFWHUSURYLVLRQDO 2ULJHQ,QWHUVHFFLyQGHOHMHGHODFDOOH7RUUHWDFRQODSURORQJDFLyQGHODPHGLDQHUDQRUWHGHODSDUFHOD GHODPDQ]DQDSXQWR$ 6HQWLGRKRUDULR /tQHDGHOLPLWDGRUD GHVGH HO RULJHQ OD OtQHD VH GLULJH D VXU H LQFRUSRUD ODV SDUFHODV \ GH OD PDQ]DQD &UX]D OD FDOOH /XLV &DOSHQD \ HQYXHOYH OD SDUFHOD GH OD PDQ]DQD \ UHFRUUH ODV WUDVHUDVGHODVSDUFHODV\GHODPDQ]DQD VLJXHSRUODPHGLDQHUDQRUWHGHOD SDUFHODGHHVWDPDQ]DQD\FUX]DODFDOOH6DQWD0DUtD,QFRUSRUDODSDUFHODGHODPDQ]DQD\ODV \ GH OD &UX]D OD FDOOH 0DMRU \ UHFRUUH ODV PHGLDQHUDV HVWH GH ODV SDUFHODV \ GH OD PDQ]DQD,QFRUSRUDODVSDUFHODV\GHODPDQ]DQD\VLJXHSRUHOHMHGHODFDOOH &DSLWiQ LQFRUSRUD OD PDQ]DQD 6LJXH SRU OD PHGLDQHUD HQWUH ODV SDUFHODV \ GH OD PDQ]DQD \ SRU ODV WUDVHUDV GH ODV PDQ]DQDV GH HVWD PDQ]DQD (QYXHOYH OD SDUFHOD GH OD PDQ]DQDKDVWDHOSXQWRGHRULJHQ$ $11(;,9$1(;2,9 GH 5HVROXFLyGHG DEULOGHOD'LUHFFLy*HQHUDOGH3DWULPRQL&XOWXUDO9DOHQFLjL0XVHXVGHOD&RQVHOOHULDGH&XOWXUD(GXFDFLyL(VSRUWSHUODTXHV LQFRDH[SHGLHQWSHUDOD SULPHUD IDVH GH O DFWXDOLW]DFLy L DGDSWDFLy SDUFLDO GH OD 6HFFLy 3ULPHUD GH O ,QYHQWDUL *HQHUDO GHO 3DWULPRQL &XOWXUDO 9DOHQFLj HQ PDWqULD GH SDWULPRQL DUTXLWHFWzQLF L PHGLDPELHQWDOLV¶REULSHUtRGHG¶LQIRUPDFLyS~EOLFD 5HVROXFLyQ GH GH DEULO GH OD 'LUHFFLyQ *HQHUDO GH 3DWULPRQLR &XOWXUDO 9DOHQFLDQR \ 0XVHRV GH OD &RQVHOOHULD GH &XOWXUD (GXFDFLyQ \ 'HSRUWH SRU OD TXH VH LQFRD H[SHGLHQWH SDUD OD SULPHUD IDVH GH OD DFWXDOL]DFLyQ \ DGDSWDFLyQ SDUFLDO GH OD 6HFFLyQ 3ULPHUD GHO ,QYHQWDULR *HQHUDO GHO 3DWULPRQLR &XOWXUDO 9DOHQFLDQR HQ PDWHULD GH SDWULPRQLRDUTXLWHFWyQLFR\PHGLRDPELHQWDO\VHDEUHSHULRGRGHLQIRUPDFLyQSXEOLFD Núm. 5.503 / 02.05.2007 17878 %e'¶,17(5e6&8/785$/±(6*/e6,$3$55248,$/'(/$0$5('('e8'(/¶$66803&,Ï%,$5 02180(17 %,(1'(,17(5e6&8/785$/,*/(6,$3$55248,$/'(18(675$6(f25$'(/$$681&,Ï1 %,$502180(172 $11(;,9$1(;2,9 GH 5HVROXFLyGHG DEULOGHOD'LUHFFLy*HQHUDOGH3DWULPRQL&XOWXUDO9DOHQFLjL0XVHXVGHOD&RQVHOOHULDGH&XOWXUD(GXFDFLyL(VSRUWSHUODTXHV LQFRDH[SHGLHQWSHUDOD SULPHUD IDVH GH O DFWXDOLW]DFLy L DGDSWDFLy SDUFLDO GH OD 6HFFLy 3ULPHUD GH O ,QYHQWDUL *HQHUDO GHO 3DWULPRQL &XOWXUDO 9DOHQFLj HQ PDWqULD GH SDWULPRQL DUTXLWHFWzQLF L PHGLDPELHQWDOLV¶REULSHUtRGHG¶LQIRUPDFLyS~EOLFD 5HVROXFLyQ GH GH DEULO GH OD 'LUHFFLyQ *HQHUDO GH 3DWULPRQLR &XOWXUDO 9DOHQFLDQR \ 0XVHRV GH OD &RQVHOOHULD GH &XOWXUD (GXFDFLyQ \ 'HSRUWH SRU OD TXH VH LQFRD H[SHGLHQWH SDUD OD SULPHUD IDVH GH OD DFWXDOL]DFLyQ \ DGDSWDFLyQ SDUFLDO GH OD 6HFFLyQ 3ULPHUD GHO ,QYHQWDULR *HQHUDO GHO 3DWULPRQLR &XOWXUDO 9DOHQFLDQR HQ PDWHULD GH SDWULPRQLRDUTXLWHFWyQLFR\PHGLRDPELHQWDO\VHDEUHSHULRGRGHLQIRUPDFLyQSXEOLFD Núm. 5.503 / 02.05.2007 17879 %,(1'(,17(5e6&8/785$/±&21-8172+,67Ï5,&2'(%855,$1$%855,$1$&72+&2 'HQRPLQDFLy'HQRPLQDFLyQ 3ULQFLSDO3ULQFLSDO &RQMXQW+LVWzULFGH%RUULDQD &RQMXQWR+LVWyULFRGH%XUULDQD /RFDOLW]DFLy/RFDOL]DFLyQ 3URYtQFLD3URYLQFLD&DVWHOOy &RPDUFD&RPDUFD/D3ODQD%DL[D 0XQLFLSL0XQLFLSLR%XUULDQD 8ELFDFLy8ELFDFLyQ&DVFDQWLFFDVFRDQWLJXR $QWHFHGHQWV-XUtGLFV$QWHFHGHQWHV-XUtGLFRV ,QFRDFLy,QFRDFLyQ 3XEOLFDFLyGHODLQFRDFLy3XEOLFDFLyQGHODLQFRDFLyQ%2( 'HVFULSFLy'HVFULSFLyQ 'HVFULSFLy*HQHUDO'HVFULSFLyQ*HQHUDO (QODFRPDUFDGHOD3ODQD%DL[DHVWUREDHVWHPXQLFLSLTXHMDGHVGHOVHJOH,;DSDUHL[FRPDQXFOLXUEj(OV RUtJHQV VyQ XQD FLXWDW jUDE HQYROWDGD SHU XQ UHFLQWH PXUDOODW VHPLFLUFXODU UHIRUoDW SHU DOJXQHV WRUUHV TXDGUDGHV7HQLDWUHVHQWUDGHVXQDRULHQWDGDFDSDOULX3RUWDOGH7RUWRVDXQD DOWUDFDSD O RHVW3RUWDO G 2QGDLODWHUFHUDRULHQWDGDFDSDOVXGRHVW3RUWDOGH9DOqQFLD/DFLXWDWFRQTXHULGDO¶DQ\QRYD SDWLUFDQYLVILQVDILQDOVGHO (GDW0LWMDQDHQTXqHVYDQFRQILJXUDQWHOVUDYDOVH[WUDPXUVFRPHO5DYDOGHOD 0DU$ILQDOVGHOVHJOH;9,,O HVWUXFWXUDGHODFLXWDWYDFDQYLDQWHVGHUURTXHQHO3RUWDOGH9DOqQFLDLWRWHO UHFRUUHJXWGHODPXUDOOD(OVUDYDOVSDVVHQDFRQILJXUDUVHFRPHOVPRWRUVGHOGHVHQYROXSDPHQWXUEj(QHO VHJOH;9,,,HQWUHLHVYDQUHDOLW]DUXQDVqULHGHPLOORUHVHQOHVLQIUDHVWUXFWXUHVXUEDQHVFRPOD SDYLPHQWDFLyLO HQOOXPHQDWS~EOLF/DPRUIRORJLDXUEDQDPHGLHYDOQRPpVHVYDFRQVHUYDUHQHOQXFOLGH/D 9LODPHQWUHTXHHOVEDUULVQRXVHVYDQFRQILJXUDQWDPEXQWUDoDWUHJXODUGHEORFVTXDGUDQJXODUVLFDUUHUV UHFWHV &RP D H[HPSOHV WUREHP HO 5DYDO G 2QGD L HO GH 9DOqQFLD (Q KL KD TXDWUH GLVWULFWHV HQ HO PXQLFLSLOD9LODL HOVUDYDOVGH9DOqQFLD G¶2QGDL HO GH OD 0DU $ SULQFLSLV GHO VHJOH ;; HV YDQ HL[DPSODU QRPEURVRV FDUUHUV L HV YDQ FRQILJXUDU DOJXQHV SODFHV L ]RQHV REHUWHV / DUTXLWHFWXUD WUDGLFLRQDO HV FDUDFWHULW]D HQ JHQHUDO SHU HGLILFLV DPE WUHV SODQWHV HQ OD SODQWD EDL[D HV WURED O¶KDELWDFLy OD FXLQD L HO FRUUDO(QODSULPHUDSODQWDHVVLWXDYHQOHVKDELWDFLRQV/DWHUFHUDSODQWDVHUYLDGHPDJDW]HPSHUDFROOLWHV /DFREHUWDDGRVDLJHVDPEWURQFVFDQ\tVLWHXODjUDE%DVDWHQHO&DWjOHJGH0RQXPHQWVL&RQMXQWVGHOD &RPXQLWDW9DOHQFLDQD (QODFRPDUFDGHOD3ODQD%DL[DVHHQFXHQWUDHVWHPXQLFLSLRTXH\DGHVGHHOVLJOR,;DSDUHFHFRPRQ~FOHR XUEDQR/RVRUtJHQHVVRQXQDFLXGDGiUDEHURGHDGDSRUXQUHFLQWRDPXUDOODGRVHPLFLUFXODUUHIRU]DGRSRU DOJXQDVWRUUHVFXDGUDGDV7HQtDWUHVHQWUDGDVXQDRULHQWDGDKDFLDHOUtR3RUWDOGH7RUWRVDRWUDKDFLDHO RHVWH3RUWDOGH2QGD\KDFLDHOVXGRHVWH3RUWDOGH9DOHQFLD/DFLXGDGFRQTXLVWDGDHQQRVXIULy FDPELRVKDVWDILQDOHVGHOD(GDG0HGLDFXDQGRVHYDQFRQILJXUDQGRORVDUUDEDOHVH[WUDPXURVFRPRHOUDYDO GHO0DU$ILQDOHVGHOVLJOR;9,,ODHVWUXFWXUDGHODFLXGDGYDFDPELDQGRVHGHUULEDQHO3RUWDOGH9DOHQFLD\ WRGRHOUHFRUULGRGHODPXUDOOD/RVDUUDEDOHVSDVDQDFRQILJXUDUVHFRPRORVPRWRUHVGHOGHVDUUROORXUEDQR (Q HO VLJOR ;9,,, HQWUH \ VH UHDOL]DURQ XQD VHULH GH PHMRUDV HQ ODV LQIUDHVWUXFWXUDV XUEDQDV FRPRODSDYLPHQWDFLyQ\HODOXPEUDGRS~EOLFR/DPRUIRORJtDXUEDQDPHGLHYDOVRORVHFRQVHUYyHQHOQ~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tDGHDOPDFpQ SDUD FRVHFKDV /D FXELHUWD D GRV DJXDV FRQ UROOL]RV FDxL]R \ WHMD iUDEH %DVDGR HQ HO &DWiORJR GH 0RQXPHQWRV\&RQMXQWRVGHOD&RPXQLGDG9DOHQFLDQD $11(;,9$1(;2,9 GH 5HVROXFLyGHG DEULOGHOD'LUHFFLy*HQHUDOGH3DWULPRQL&XOWXUDO9DOHQFLjL0XVHXVGHOD&RQVHOOHULDGH&XOWXUD(GXFDFLyL(VSRUWSHUODTXHV LQFRDH[SHGLHQWSHUDOD SULPHUD IDVH GH O DFWXDOLW]DFLy L DGDSWDFLy SDUFLDO GH OD 6HFFLy 3ULPHUD GH O ,QYHQWDUL *HQHUDO GHO 3DWULPRQL &XOWXUDO 9DOHQFLj HQ PDWqULD GH SDWULPRQL DUTXLWHFWzQLF L PHGLDPELHQWDOLV¶REULSHUtRGHG¶LQIRUPDFLyS~EOLFD 5HVROXFLyQ GH GH DEULO GH OD 'LUHFFLyQ *HQHUDO GH 3DWULPRQLR &XOWXUDO 9DOHQFLDQR \ 0XVHRV GH OD &RQVHOOHULD GH &XOWXUD (GXFDFLyQ \ 'HSRUWH SRU OD TXH VH LQFRD H[SHGLHQWH SDUD OD SULPHUD IDVH GH OD DFWXDOL]DFLyQ \ DGDSWDFLyQ SDUFLDO GH OD 6HFFLyQ 3ULPHUD GHO ,QYHQWDULR *HQHUDO GHO 3DWULPRQLR &XOWXUDO 9DOHQFLDQR HQ PDWHULD GH SDWULPRQLRDUTXLWHFWyQLFR\PHGLRDPELHQWDO\VHDEUHSHULRGRGHLQIRUPDFLyQSXEOLFD Núm. 5.503 / 02.05.2007 17880 2EVHUYDFLRQV2EVHUYDFLRQHV /DSURWHFFLyLQGLYLGXDOLW]DGDGHOVLPPREOHVTXHIRUPHQSDUWGHOFRQMXQWHVWUDFWDUjDOFRUUHVSRQHQWSODHVSHFLDO /DGHOLPLWDFLyUHFXOOWDPEpDTXHOOHVH[WHQVLRQVGH/D9LODSDWULPRQLDOPHQWPpVFDUDFWHULW]DGHV /D SURWHFFLyQLQGLYLGXDOL]DGD GH ORV LQPXHEOHVTXHIRUPDQ SDUWHGHOFRQMXQWRVHWUDWDUiHQHO FRUUHVSRQGLHQWH SODQ HVSHFLDO /D GHOLPLWDFLyQ LQFOX\H WDPELpQ DTXHOODV H[WHQVLRQHV GH /D 9LOD SDWULPRQLDOPHQWH PiV FDUDFWHUL]DGDV ¬PELWÈPELWR $QWHFHGHQWVDGPLQLVWUDWLXVGHOLPLWDFLyH[WUHWDGHO H[SHGLHQWGHILQLGDDPEFDUjFWHUSURYLVLRQDO 2ULJHQ,QWHUVHFFLyGHO HL[GHOFDUUHU3RHWD&DO]DGDDPEODSURORQJDFLyGHODPLWJHUDQRUGGHODSDUFHOāOD GHO¶LOODGHFDVHVSXQW$ 6HQWLWKRUDUL /tQLDGHOLPLWDGRUDODOtQLDLQFRUSRUDHOVFDUUHUV3RHWD&DOoDGDDYLQJXGD-RDQ%DSWLVWD6DQPDUWtQL&DOYDULL SURVVHJXL[SHUODPLWJHUDHQWUHOHVSDUFHOāOHVLGHO¶LOODGHFDVHV6HJXL[SHUODPLWJHUDHVWGHOD SDUFHOāODLSHUOHVSRVWHULRUVGHOHVSDUFHOāOHVFUHXDODSDUFHOāOD LWRUQDDVHJXLUSHUODSRVWHULRUGHODSDUFHOāODLODPLWJHUDVXGGHOD&UHXD HOFDUUHU6DQW%ODLL UHFRUUHOHVSRVWHULRUVGHOHVSDUFHOāOHVLGHO¶LOODGHFDVHV&UHXDHO FDUUHU GH OD 0DUH GH 'pX GH OD 0LVHULFzUGLD L V LQWURGXw[ HQ O¶LOOD GH FDVHV SHU OD PLWJHUD VXG GH OD SDUFHOāODL SHU OHV SRVWHULRUV GH OHV SDUFHOāOHV L WUDYHVVDODSDUFHOāODLFRQWLQXDSHUOHVSRVWHULRUVGHOHVSDUFHOāOHV L&RQWLQXDSHUO HL[GHOFDUUHUGHOD0DUHGH'pXGH*UjFLDHQGLUHFFLyVXGLWUDYHVVDO¶LOODGHFDVHV SHUODPLWJHUDQRUGGHODSDUFHOāODO¶LOODGHFDVHVSHUOHVPLWJHUHVQRUGGHOHVSDUFHOāOHV LLODSHUOHVPLWJHUHVQRUGGHOHVSDUFHOāOHVLLO¶LOODGHFDVHVSHUODPLWJHUDQRUG GH OD SDUFHOāOD L SHU OHV SRVWHULRUV GH OHV SDUFHOāOHV G HVWD LOOD GH FDVHV TXH GRQHQ DO FDUUHU G¶(O %DUUDQTXHW&UHXDHOFDUUHUGH6DQW6HUDSLLV LQWURGXw[HQO¶LOODGHFDVHVHQWUHOHVSDUFHOāOHVL SURVVHJXL[ SHU OHV SRVWHULRUV GH OHV SDUFHOāOHV L L SHO QRUG GH OD SDUFHOāODG HVWDLOODGHFDVHV&UHXD HOFDUUHU GHO%HDW5DSXOOpV LUHFRUUHOHV SRVWHULRUV GHOHV SDUFHOāOHV LLODPLWJHUDQRUGGHODSDUFHOāODGHO¶LOODGHFDVHV&UHXD O DYLQJXGD G¶$XVLHV0DUFK L LQFRUSRUD OHV SDUFHOāOHV GH O¶LOOD GH FDVHV OHV L GH O¶LOOD GH FDVHVLLGHO¶LOODGHFDVHVLGHO¶LOODGHFDVHV LGHODLOHVSDUFHOāOHVGHO¶LOODGHFDVHV TXHGRQHQ DO DYLQJXGD G¶$XVLHV0DUFK&UHXD HO FDUUHUGHOD0DUHGH'pXGHOV'RORUVLLQWURGXw[OHVSDUFHOāOHVLGHO¶LOODGHFDVHV&UHXDHO FDUUHUG¶$XVLHV0DUFKLWUDYHVVDO¶LOODGHFDVHVSHUODSURORQJDFLyGHODPLWJHUDHQWUHOHVSDUFHOāOHV LGHO¶LOODGHFDVHV5HFRUUHOHVSRVWHULRUVGHOHVSDUFHOāOHVTXHGRQHQDOFDUUHUGH&RORPGHO¶LOODGH FDVHVILQVDODLFRQWLQXDSHUODPLWJHUDVXGGHODSDUFHOāOD&UHXDHOFDUUHUGH6DQW9LFWRULjL LQFRUSRUDODSDUFHOāODGHO¶LOODGHFDVHV7RUQDDFUHXDUHOFDUUHUGH&RORPLUHFRUUHOHVSRVWHULRUV GHOHVSDUFHOāOHVGHO¶LOODGHFDVHVTXHGRQHQDOFDUUHUGH6DQW9LFWRULj&UHXDHOFDUUHUGHOD7DQGDL WUDYHVVDO¶LOODGHFDVHVHQWUHOHVSDUFHOāOHVLLL6HJXL[SHUO HL[GHOFDUUHUGH-RDQ%WD 7HMHGR%HOWUiQILQVDO¶LOODGHFDVHVWUDYHVVDQWODSHUOHVSRVWHULRUVGHOHVSDUFHOāOHVG HVWDTXHGRQHQ DO FDUUHU GH OD &DUUHUD ILQV D OD SDUFHOāOD LQFOXVLYDPHQW &UHXD HO FDUUHU GH OD 7DQGD L LQFRUSRUD OD SDUFHOāODGHO¶LOODGHFDVHV6HJXL[SHUOHVIDoDQHVGHOHVSDUFHOāOHVLGHO¶LOODGHFDVHV HQGLUHFFLyRHVW7UDYHVVDO¶LOODGHFDVHVSHUOHVSRVWHULRUVGHOHVSDUFHOāOHVLLODSHU OHVSRVWHULRUVGH OHV SDUFHOāOHV L 5HFRUUH OHV SRVWHULRUV GH OHV SDUFHOāOHV L GH O¶LOOD GH FDVHV7UDYHVVDHOFDUUHUGH6DQW-DXPHLO¶LOODGHFDVHVSHUOHVSRVWHULRUVGHOHVSDUFHOāOHV L L DUULED ILQV HO FDUUHU GH O(VFRUUHGRU 6HJXL[ SHU O HL[ GHO FDUUHU ILQV D LQWURGXLUVHSHUODPLWJHUDGHOHVSDUFHOāOHVLGHO¶LOODGHFDVHVLFRQWLQXDUSHUOHVSRVWHULRUVGH OHV SDUFHOāOHV L G HVWD LOOD GH FDVHV 7UDYHVVD HO FDUUHU 6DQW 0LTXHO L VHJXL[ SHU OHV SRVWHULRUV GH OHV SDUFHOāOHV L GH O¶LOOD GH FDVHV &UHXD HO FDUUHU GH 6DQW -RVHS L UHFRUUH OHV SRVWHULRUVGHOHVSDUFHOāOHVLGHO¶LOODGHFDVHVLSHUODPLWJHUDRHVWGHODSDUFHOāODG HVWD LOODGHFDVHV6HJXL[SHUODSRVWHULRUGHODSDUFHOāODWUDYHVVDODLSHUOHVSRVWHULRUVGHOHV LLPLWJHUDQRUGGHODSDUFHOāOD6HJXL[SHUO HL[GHOFDUUHUGHO5RVDULRHQGLUHFFLyVXGRHVW ILQV D OD PLWJHUD HQWUH OHV SDUFHOāOHV L GH O¶LOOD GH FDVHV DQWHULRU 6HJXL[ SHU OHV IDoDQHV GH OHV SDUFHOāOHVLGHOFDUUHUGH6DQW-RVHSLWUDYHVVDO¶LOODGHFDVHVSHUODPLWJHUDHQWUHOHVSDUFHOāOHV L7UDYHVVDHOFDUUHUGH6DQW0LTXHOLVHJXL[ SHUODPLWJHUDHQWUHOHVSDUFHOāOHV L L OD PLWJHUD RHVWGHOHVLGHO¶LOODGHFDVHV&UHXDHOFDUUHUGH6DQW-RDQGHOD&UX]LWUDYHVVDO¶LOODGHFDVHV HQWUHOHVSDUFHOāOHVL 7UDYHVVDHOFDUUHUGHOV)UDUHVLLQFRUSRUDOHVSDUFHOāOHVLGHO¶LOOD GH FDVHV 7UDYHVVD HO FDUUHU &DPt G2QGD L WUDYHVVD O¶LOOD GH FDVHV SHU OHV SRVWHULRUV GH OHV SDUFHOāOHVL&UHXDHOFDUUHUGHO%RQ6XFFpVLFRQWLQXDSHUOHVSRVWHULRUVGHOHVSDUFHOāOHV LPLWJHUDQRUGGHODSDUFHOāOD&UHXDHOFDUUHUGHOD7ULQLWDWLVHJXL[ $11(;,9$1(;2,9 GH 5HVROXFLyGHG DEULOGHOD'LUHFFLy*HQHUDOGH3DWULPRQL&XOWXUDO9DOHQFLjL0XVHXVGHOD&RQVHOOHULDGH&XOWXUD(GXFDFLyL(VSRUWSHUODTXHV LQFRDH[SHGLHQWSHUDOD SULPHUD IDVH GH O DFWXDOLW]DFLy L DGDSWDFLy SDUFLDO GH OD 6HFFLy 3ULPHUD GH O ,QYHQWDUL *HQHUDO GHO 3DWULPRQL &XOWXUDO 9DOHQFLj HQ PDWqULD GH SDWULPRQL DUTXLWHFWzQLF L PHGLDPELHQWDOLV¶REULSHUtRGHG¶LQIRUPDFLyS~EOLFD 5HVROXFLyQ GH GH DEULO GH OD 'LUHFFLyQ *HQHUDO GH 3DWULPRQLR &XOWXUDO 9DOHQFLDQR \ 0XVHRV GH OD &RQVHOOHULD GH &XOWXUD (GXFDFLyQ \ 'HSRUWH SRU OD TXH VH LQFRD H[SHGLHQWH SDUD OD SULPHUD IDVH GH OD DFWXDOL]DFLyQ \ DGDSWDFLyQ SDUFLDO GH OD 6HFFLyQ 3ULPHUD GHO ,QYHQWDULR *HQHUDO GHO 3DWULPRQLR &XOWXUDO 9DOHQFLDQR HQ PDWHULD GH SDWULPRQLRDUTXLWHFWyQLFR\PHGLRDPELHQWDO\VHDEUHSHULRGRGHLQIRUPDFLyQSXEOLFD Núm. 5.503 / 02.05.2007 17881 SHU OHV SRVWHULRUV GH OHV SDUFHO OHV L GH O LOOD GH FDVHV &UHXD HO FDUUHU GHO &DUPHQ L UHFRUUHOHVSRVWHULRUVGHOHVSDUFHOāOHVGHODLSHUOHVSRVWHULRUVGHOHVSDUFHOāOHV LGHODILQVDOSXQWG RULJHQ $QWHFHGHQWHVDGPLQLVWUDWLYRVGHOLPLWDFLyQH[WUDtGDGHOH[SHGLHQWHGHILQLGDFRQFDUiFWHUSURYLVLRQDO 2ULJHQ ,QWHUVHFFLyQ GHO HMH GH OD FDOOH 3RHWD &DO]DGD FRQ OD SURORQJDFLyQ GH OD PHGLDQHUD QRUWH GH OD SDUFHODGHODPDQ]DQDSXQWR$ 6HQWLGRKRUDULR /tQHDGHOLPLWDGRUDODOtQHDLQFRUSRUDODVFDOOHV3RHWD&DO]DGDDYHQLGD-XDQ%DXWLVWD6DQPDUWtQ\&DOYDUL\ SURVLJXHSRUODPHGLDQHUDHQWUHODVSDUFHODV\GHODPDQ]DQD6LJXHSRUODPHGLDQHUDHVWHGH ODSDUFHOD\SRUODVWUDVHUDVGHODVSDUFHODVFUX]DODSDUFHOD \ YXHOYH D VHJXLU SRU OD WUDVHUD GH OD SDUFHOD \ OD PHGLDQHUD VXU GH OD &UX]D OD FDOOH 6DQW %ODL \ UHFRUUHODVWUDVHUDVGHODVSDUFHODV\GHODPDQ]DQD&UX]DODFDOOH 9LUJHQGHOD0LVHULFRUGLD\VHLQWURGXFHHQODPDQ]DQDSRUODPHGLDQHUDVXUGHODSDUFHOD\SRU ODVWUDVHUDVGHODVSDUFHODV\DWUDYLHVDODSDUFHOD\ FRQWLQ~DSRUODVWUDVHUDVGHODVSDUFHODV\&RQWLQ~DSRUHOHMH GH ODFDOOH 9LUJHQ GH *UDFLD HQ GLUHFFLyQ VXU \ DWUDYLHVD OD PDQ]DQD SRU OD PHGLDQHUD QRUWH GH OD SDUFHOD OD PDQ]DQD SRU ODV PHGLDQHUDV QRUWH GH ODV SDUFHODV \ \ OD SRU ODV PHGLDQHUDVQRUWHGHODVSDUFHODV\\ODPDQ]DQDSRUODPHGLDQHUDQRUWHGHODSDUFHOD \SRUODVWUDVHUDVGHODVSDUFHODVGHHVWDPDQ]DQDUHFD\HQWHVDODFDOOH(O%DUUDQTXHW&UX]DODFDOOH6DQW 6HUDSL \ VH LQWURGXFH HQ OD PDQ]DQD HQWUH ODV SDUFHODV \ SURVLJXH SRU ODV WUDVHUDV GH ODV SDUFHODV\\SRUHOQRUWHGHODSDUFHODGHHVWDPDQ]DQD&UX]DOD FDOOH%HDWR5DSXOOpV\UHFRUUHODVWUDVHUDVGHODVSDUFHODV\\OD PHGLDQHUD QRUWH GH OD SDUFHOD GH OD PDQ]DQD &UX]D OD DYHQLGD $XVLHV 0DUFK H LQFRUSRUD ODV SDUFHODV GH OD PDQ]DQD ODV \ GH OD PDQ]DQD \ \ GH OD PDQ]DQD\GHODPDQ]DQD \GHOD\ODVSDUFHODVGHOD PDQ]DQDUHFD\HQWHVDODDYHQLGD$XVLHV0DUFK&UX]DODFDOOH9LUJHQGHORV'RORUHVHLQWURGXFHODV SDUFHODV\GHODPDQ]DQD&UX]DODFDOOH$XVLHV0DUFK\DWUDYLHVDODPDQ]DQDSRUOD SURORQJDFLyQGHODPHGLDQHUDHQWUHODVSDUFHODV\GHODPDQ]DQD5HFRUUHODVWUDVHUDVGHODV SDUFHODVUHFD\HQWHVDODFDOOH&ROyQGHODPDQ]DQDKDVWDOD\FRQWLQ~DSRUODPHGLDQHUDVXUGHOD SDUFHOD&UX]DODFDOOH6DQW9LFWRULjHLQFRUSRUDODSDUFHODGHODPDQ]DQD9XHOYHDFUX]DUOD FDOOH&ROyQ\UHFRUUHODVWUDVHUDVGHODVSDUFHODVGHODPDQ]DQDUHFD\HQWHVDODFDOOH6DQW9LFWRULj &UX]DODFDOOH7DQGD\DWUDYLHVDODPDQ]DQDHQWUHODVSDUFHODV\\\6LJXHSRUHOHMHGH ODFDOOH-XDQ%WD7HMHGR%HOWUiQKDVWDODPDQ]DQDDWUDYHViQGRODSRUODVWUDVHUDVGHODVSDUFHODVGH pVWDUHFD\HQWHV DODFDOOH /D&DUUHUDKDVWDODSDUFHODLQFOXVLYH&UX]DODFDOOH /D7DQGD H LQFRUSRUD OD SDUFHODGHODPDQ]DQD6LJXHSRUODVIDFKDGDVGHODVSDUFHODV\GHODPDQ]DQDHQ GLUHFFLy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yQ VXURHVWH KDVWD OD PHGLDQHUD HQWUH ODV SDUFHODV\GHODPDQ]DQDDQWHULRU6LJXHSRUODVIDFKDGDVGHODV SDUFHODV\ GHODFDOOH6DQW -RVHS \ DWUDYLHVD OD PDQ]DQD SRU OD PHGLDQHUD HQWUH ODV SDUFHODV \ $WUDYLHVD OD FDOOH 6DQW 0LTXHO \ VLJXH SRU OD PHGLDQHUD HQWUH ODV SDUFHODV \ \ OD PHGLDQHUD RHVWH GH ODV \ GH OD PDQ]DQD&UX]DODFDOOH6DQW-RDQGHOD&UHX\DWUDYLHVDODPDQ]DQDHQWUHODVSDUFHODV\ $WUDYLHVDODFDOOH'HOV)UDUHVHLQFRUSRUDODVSDUFHODV\GHOD PDQ]DQD $WUDYLHVD OD FDOOH &DPt G2QGD \ DWUDYLHVD OD PDQ]DQD SRU ODV WUDVHUDV GH ODV SDUFHODV\&UX]DODFDOOH%RQ6XFFpV\FRQWLQ~DSRU ODVWUDVHUDVGHODVSDUFHODV \ PHGLDQHUD QRUWH GH OD SDUFHOD &UX]D OD FDOOH 7ULQLWDW \ VLJXH SRU ODV WUDVHUDVGHODVSDUFHODV\GHODPDQ]DQD&UX]DODFDOOH&DUPH\UHFRUUHODVWUDVHUDVGH ODVSDUFHODVGHOD\SRUODVWUDVHUDV GHODVSDUFHODV\GHODKDVWDHO SXQWRGHRULJHQ $11(;,9$1(;2,9 GH 5HVROXFLyGHG DEULOGHOD'LUHFFLy*HQHUDOGH3DWULPRQL&XOWXUDO9DOHQFLjL0XVHXVGHOD&RQVHOOHULDGH&XOWXUD(GXFDFLyL(VSRUWSHUODTXHV LQFRDH[SHGLHQWSHUDOD SULPHUD IDVH GH O DFWXDOLW]DFLy L DGDSWDFLy SDUFLDO GH OD 6HFFLy 3ULPHUD GH O ,QYHQWDUL *HQHUDO GHO 3DWULPRQL &XOWXUDO 9DOHQFLj HQ PDWqULD GH SDWULPRQL DUTXLWHFWzQLF L PHGLDPELHQWDOLV¶REULSHUtRGHG¶LQIRUPDFLyS~EOLFD 5HVROXFLyQ GH GH DEULO GH OD 'LUHFFLyQ *HQHUDO GH 3DWULPRQLR &XOWXUDO 9DOHQFLDQR \ 0XVHRV GH OD &RQVHOOHULD GH &XOWXUD (GXFDFLyQ \ 'HSRUWH SRU OD TXH VH LQFRD H[SHGLHQWH SDUD OD SULPHUD IDVH GH OD DFWXDOL]DFLyQ \ DGDSWDFLyQ SDUFLDO GH OD 6HFFLyQ 3ULPHUD GHO ,QYHQWDULR *HQHUDO GHO 3DWULPRQLR &XOWXUDO 9DOHQFLDQR HQ PDWHULD GH SDWULPRQLRDUTXLWHFWyQLFR\PHGLRDPELHQWDO\VHDEUHSHULRGRGHLQIRUPDFLyQSXEOLFD Núm. 5.503 / 02.05.2007 17882 %e'¶,17(5e6&8/785$/&21-817+,67Ñ5,&'(%255,$1$%255,$1$&21-817+,67Ñ5,& %,(1'(,17(5e6&8/785$/±&21-8172+,67Ï5,&2'(%855,$1$%855,$1$&72+&2 $11(;,9$1(;2,9 GH 5HVROXFLyGHG DEULOGHOD'LUHFFLy*HQHUDOGH3DWULPRQL&XOWXUDO9DOHQFLjL0XVHXVGHOD&RQVHOOHULDGH&XOWXUD(GXFDFLyL(VSRUWSHUODTXHV LQFRDH[SHGLHQWSHUDOD SULPHUD IDVH GH O DFWXDOLW]DFLy L DGDSWDFLy SDUFLDO GH OD 6HFFLy 3ULPHUD GH O ,QYHQWDUL *HQHUDO GHO 3DWULPRQL &XOWXUDO 9DOHQFLj HQ PDWqULD GH SDWULPRQL DUTXLWHFWzQLF L PHGLDPELHQWDOLV¶REULSHUtRGHG¶LQIRUPDFLyS~EOLFD 5HVROXFLyQ GH GH DEULO GH OD 'LUHFFLyQ *HQHUDO GH 3DWULPRQLR &XOWXUDO 9DOHQFLDQR \ 0XVHRV GH OD &RQVHOOHULD GH &XOWXUD (GXFDFLyQ \ 'HSRUWH SRU OD TXH VH LQFRD H[SHGLHQWH SDUD OD SULPHUD IDVH GH OD DFWXDOL]DFLyQ \ DGDSWDFLyQ SDUFLDO GH OD 6HFFLyQ 3ULPHUD GHO ,QYHQWDULR *HQHUDO GHO 3DWULPRQLR &XOWXUDO 9DOHQFLDQR HQ PDWHULD GH SDWULPRQLRDUTXLWHFWyQLFR\PHGLRDPELHQWDO\VHDEUHSHULRGRGHLQIRUPDFLyQSXEOLFD Núm. 5.503 / 02.05.2007 17883 %e'¶,17(5e6&8/785$/±&219(17'¶$,*h(69,9(6&$5&$,;(1702180(17 %,(1'(,17(5e6&8/785$/&219(172'($*8$69,9$6&$5&$,;(1702180(172 'HQRPLQDFLy'HQRPLQDFLyQ 3ULQFLSDO3ULQFLSDO &RQYHQWG¶$LJHV9LYHV &RQYHQWRGH$JXDV9LYDV $FFHVzULD$FFHVRULD 5HLDO0RQHVWLUGH6DQWD0DULDG¶$LJHV9LYHV 5HDO0RQDVWHULRGH6DQWD0DUtDGH$JXDV9LYDV /RFDOLW]DFLy/RFDOL]DFLyQ 3URYtQFLD3URYLQFLD9DOqQFLD &RPDUFD&RPDUFD/D5LEHUD$OWD 0XQLFLSL0XQLFLSLR&DUFDL[HQW 8ELFDFLy8ELFDFLyQ9DOOHGH$JXDV9LYDV&WUD$O]LUD D7DYHUQHV 5HIHUqQFLD&DGDVWUDO5HIHUHQFLD&DWDVWUDO ,OOD0DQ]DQD3DUFHOāOD3DUFHOD± $QWHFHGHQWV-XUtGLFV$QWHFHGHQWHV-XUtGLFRV ,QFRDFLy,QFRDFLyQ,QFRDGR 3XEOLFDFLyGHODLQFRDFLy3XEOLFDFLyQGHODLQFRDFLyQ%2( 'HVFULSFLy'HVFULSFLyQ 3DUWV,QWHJUDQWV3DUWHV,QWHJUDQWHV − (VJOpVLDLFDPSDQDU,JOHVLD\FDPSDQDULR − &RQYHQWLOHVVHXHVGHSHQGqQFLHV&RQYHQWR\VXVGHSHQGHQFLDV − %DVVD%DOVD − &DVDDJUtFROD&DVDGHODERU − &LVWHUQD&LVWHUQD − 6DFULVWLD6DFULVWtD 'HVFULSFLy*HQHUDO'HVFULSFLyQ*HQHUDO $OOODUJGHOVVHJOHV;9,L;9,,HVFRQILJXUDO HVWUXFWXUDDFWXDOGHOFRQYHQW)UDQFLVFR&ROyPDUWtIH[YDOHQFLj YDGLULJLUHQXQDDPSOLDFLyGHOFHQRELSDUWLFXODUPHQWGHOFODXVWUH(QHVGDWHQQRYHVREUHVHQ HV WUDoD L V¶DOoD OD QRYD HVJOpVLD DPE UHUHVDJUDUL VDJULVWLD UHWDXOH PDMRU L WRUUH FDPSDQDU L VyQ GDXUDWVDOJXQVDOWDUV$PHLWDWGHOVHJOH;,;HOFRQYHQWSDVVDDPDQVSULYDGHVLHVGHVWLQDDYLYHQGDUXUDO (QHOPRQHVWLUYDVHUDGTXLULWSHUDGHVWLQDUORDKRWHOUHVLGqQFLD~VTXHFRQWLQXDILQVDO DFWXDOLWDW / HGLILFLV DUWLFXODDOYROWDQWGHOFODXVWUHDOFRVWDWVXGUHFDXO HVJOpVLDHOFRQMXQWGHODJUDQMDDODSDUWQRUGL DOFRVWDWGHO¶HVWUHFDXHOJUDQFRVUHFWDQJXODUGHFLQFSODQWHVTXHGRPLQDHOFRQMXQWLGyQDDODFDUUHWHUD G $O]LUD D 7DYHUQHV $ O RHVW WUREHP OD WRUUH FDPSDQDU O HVJOpVLD OD SRUWDODGD G DFFpV DO FODXVWUH L OHV HGLILFDFLRQVGHODJUDQMD(OFODXVWUHpVGHUHGXwGHVSURSRUFLRQVULFHQWDOODLGHFRUDWDPESLQWXUHVDOIUHVF 'HVWDFD HO JUDQ FRV TXH GRPLQD HVSDFLDOPHQW HO FRQMXQW SUHVHQWD XQD jPSOLD YHUWLFDOLWDW L Wp XQD HVFDOD G DFFpV/ ~OWLPFRVUHPDWDWSHUXQDFRUQLVDDOEHUJDGLYHUVHVSLQWXUHVHQWUHHOOHVXQDUHSUHVHQWDFLyGHOD 0DUH GH 'pX G $LJHV 9LYHV IODQTXHMDGD SHU OD LQVFULSFLy GH O¶DQ\ (QWUH ILQHVWUDOV HV PRVWUHQ HOHPHQWVSLFWzULFVRUQDPHQWDOV/DFREHUWDpVDXQDYHVVDQWLGHWHXODjUDE/ HVJOpVLDpVG XQDQDXDPEXQ O DOWDULVLVFDSHOOHVODWHUDOVWpXQFRUDOWDPEEDUDQDVHPLFLUFXODULFDUUHXVGHGXHVqSRTXHVGHOVHJOH;9 JzWLFDLXQDDOWUDSODWHUHVFD/DYROWDGHOWHPSOHpVGHFDQy/DSRUWDG DFFpVDO HVJOpVLDpVDOOLQGDGDDPE XQSODIyGHFHUjPLFDTXHUHSUHVHQWDOD0DUHGH'pXG $LJHV9LYHV(OFDPSDQDUpVTXDGUDQJXODUUHPDWDW HQWHXODGHOODTXDWUHDLJHV5HVXPEDVDWHQO LQIRUPHGH&3pUH]2ODJH $ORODUJRGHORV VLJORV;9,\;9,, VHFRQILJXUDODHVWUXFWXUD DFWXDOGHOFRQYHQWR)UDQFLVFR &ROyP DUWtILFH YDOHQFLDQRGLULJLyHQXQDDPSOLDFLyQGHOFHQRELRSDUWLFXODUPHQWHGHOFODXVWUR1XHYDVREUDVVHGDWDQ HQVLHQGRHQFXDQGRVHWUD]D\DO]DODQXHYDLJOHVLDFRQWUDVDJUDULRVDFULVWtDUHWDEORPD\RU\ WRUUHFDPSDQDULRGRUiQGRVHDOJXQRVDOWDUHV$PHGLDGRVGHOVLJOR;,;HOFRQYHQWRSDVRDPDQRVSULYDGDV GHVWLQiQGRVHDYLYLHQGDUXUDO(QHOPRQDVWHULRIXHDGTXLULGRSDUD GHVWLQDUORDKRWHOUHVLGHQFLDXVR TXHFRQWLQXDKDVWDODDFWXDOLGDG(OHGLILFLRVHDUWLFXODDOUHGHGRUGHOFODXVWURDOFXDOUHFDHQODLJOHVLDD6XU HO FRQMXQWR GH OD JUDQMD DO 1RUWH \ HO JUDQ FXHUSR UHFWDQJXODU GH FLQFR SODQWDV TXH GRPLQD HO FRQMXQWR UHFD\HQWHDODFDUUHWHUDGH$O]LUDD7DYHUQHVDOHVWH$ORHVWHODWRUUHFDPSDQDULRODLJOHVLDHOSRUWDOyQGH $11(;,9$1(;2,9 GH 5HVROXFLyGHG DEULOGHOD'LUHFFLy*HQHUDOGH3DWULPRQL&XOWXUDO9DOHQFLjL0XVHXVGHOD&RQVHOOHULDGH&XOWXUD(GXFDFLyL(VSRUWSHUODTXHV LQFRDH[SHGLHQWSHUDOD SULPHUD IDVH GH O DFWXDOLW]DFLy L DGDSWDFLy SDUFLDO GH OD 6HFFLy 3ULPHUD GH O ,QYHQWDUL *HQHUDO GHO 3DWULPRQL &XOWXUDO 9DOHQFLj HQ PDWqULD GH SDWULPRQL DUTXLWHFWzQLF L PHGLDPELHQWDOLV¶REULSHUtRGHG¶LQIRUPDFLyS~EOLFD 5HVROXFLyQ GH GH DEULO GH OD 'LUHFFLyQ *HQHUDO GH 3DWULPRQLR &XOWXUDO 9DOHQFLDQR \ 0XVHRV GH OD &RQVHOOHULD GH &XOWXUD (GXFDFLyQ \ 'HSRUWH SRU OD TXH VH LQFRD H[SHGLHQWH SDUD OD SULPHUD IDVH GH OD DFWXDOL]DFLyQ \ DGDSWDFLyQ SDUFLDO GH OD 6HFFLyQ 3ULPHUD GHO ,QYHQWDULR *HQHUDO GHO 3DWULPRQLR &XOWXUDO 9DOHQFLDQR HQ PDWHULD GH SDWULPRQLRDUTXLWHFWyQLFR\PHGLRDPELHQWDO\VHDEUHSHULRGRGHLQIRUPDFLyQSXEOLFD Núm. 5.503 / 02.05.2007 17884 DFFHVRDOFODXVWUR\ODVHGLILFDFLRQHVGHODJUDQMD(OFODXVWURHVGHUHGXFLGDVSURSRUFLRQHVHVULFRHQWDOOD\ GHFRUDGRVFRQSLQWXUDVDOIUHVFR'HVWDFDHOJUDQFXHUSRTXHGRPLQDHVSDFLDOPHQWH HOFRQMXQWRSUHVHQWD XQDDPSOLDYHUWLFDOLGDG\WLHQHXQDHVFDOHUDGHDFFHVR(O~OWLPRFXHUSRUHPDWDGRSRUXQDFRUQLVDFRELMD YDULDV SLQWXUDV HQWUH HOODV IODQTXHDGD SRU OD LQVFULSFLyQ DxR OD 9LUJHQ GH $JXDV 9LYDV (QWUH YHQWDQDOHVVHPXHVWUDQHOHPHQWRVSLFWyULFRVRUQDPHQWDOHV/DFXELHUWDHVDXQDYHUWLHQWH\GHWHMDiUDEH /DLJOHVLDHVGHXQDQDYH\HQHOODKD\DGHPiVGHODOWDUVHLVFDSLOODVODWHUDOHV/DLJOHVLDWLHQHFRURDOWRFRQ EDUDQGLOODVHPLFLUFXODU\VLOOHUtDGHGRVpSRFDVVLJOR;9JyWLFD\RWUDSODWHUHVFD/DEyYHGDGHOWHPSORHV GHFDxyQ/DSXHUWDGHDFFHVRDODLJOHVLDHVDGLQWHODGDFRQXQSDQHOGHFHUiPLFDUHSUHVHQWDQGRD1XHVWUD 6HxRUD GH $JXDV 9LYDV (O FDPSDQDULR HV FXDGUDQJXODU UHPDWDGR HQ WHMDGLOOR D FXDWUR DJXDV 5HVXPHQ EDVDGRHQHOLQIRUPHGH&3pUH]2ODJH 2EVHUYDFLRQV2EVHUYDFLRQHV (QWRUQ(QWRUQR $QWHFHGHQWVDGPLQLVWUDWLXVGHOLPLWDFLyH[WUHWDGHO H[SHGLHQWGHILQLGDDPEFDUjFWHUSURYLVLRQDO 2ULJHQ3XQW$GHFRRUGHQDGHV870 6HQWLW$QWLKRUDUL /tQLD GHOLPLWDGRUD GHV GHO SXQW $ OD OtQLD HPEROLFD O¶LOOD GH FDVHV FDGDVWUDO ILQV DO SXQW % GH FRRUGHQDGHV GHV G HVWH SXQW VHJXL[ ILQV DO SXQW & GH FRRUGHQDGHV VLWXDWHQODIDoDQDHVWGHO¶LOODGHFDVHV6HJXL[SHUODIDoDQDRHVWG HVWDLOODGHFDVHVL SHU OD VHXD SURORQJDFLy ILQV D OD FDUUHWHUD G $O]LUD D 7DYHUQHV GH 9DOOGLJQD VHJXL[ DO QRUG SHO OtPLW GH OD FDUUHWHUDLJLUDDVXGSHUODSURORQJDFLyGHODIDoDQDHVWGHO¶LOODGHFDVHVILQVDOSXQWG LQLFL $QWHFHGHQWHVDGPLQLVWUDWLYRVGHOLPLWDFLyQH[WUDtGDGHOH[SHGLHQWHGHILQLGDFRQFDUiFWHUSURYLVLRQDO 2ULJHQ3XQWR$GHFRRUGHQDGDV870 6HQWLGR$QWLKRUDULR /tQHD GHOLPLWDGRUD GHVGH HO SXQWR $ OD OtQHD HQYXHOYH OD PDQ]DQD FDWDVWUDO KDVWD HO SXQWR % GH FRRUGHQDGDVGHVGHHVWHSXQWRVLJXHKDVWDHOSXQWR&GHFRRUGHQDGDV VLWXDGRHQODIDFKDGDHVWHGHODPDQ]DQD6LJXHSRUODIDFKDGDRHVWHGHHVWDPDQ]DQD \SRUVXSURORQJDFLyQKDVWDODFDUUHWHUDGH$O]LUDD7DYHUQHVGH9DOOGLJQDVLJXHDQRUWHSRUHOOLQGHGHOD FDUUHWHUD\JLUDDVXUSRUODSURORQJDFLyQGHODIDFKDGDHVWHGHODPDQ]DQDKDVWDHOSXQWRGHLQLFLR $11(;,9$1(;2,9 GH 5HVROXFLyGHG DEULOGHOD'LUHFFLy*HQHUDOGH3DWULPRQL&XOWXUDO9DOHQFLjL0XVHXVGHOD&RQVHOOHULDGH&XOWXUD(GXFDFLyL(VSRUWSHUODTXHV LQFRDH[SHGLHQWSHUDOD SULPHUD IDVH GH O DFWXDOLW]DFLy L DGDSWDFLy SDUFLDO GH OD 6HFFLy 3ULPHUD GH O ,QYHQWDUL *HQHUDO GHO 3DWULPRQL &XOWXUDO 9DOHQFLj HQ PDWqULD GH SDWULPRQL DUTXLWHFWzQLF L PHGLDPELHQWDOLV¶REULSHUtRGHG¶LQIRUPDFLyS~EOLFD 5HVROXFLyQ GH GH DEULO GH OD 'LUHFFLyQ *HQHUDO GH 3DWULPRQLR &XOWXUDO 9DOHQFLDQR \ 0XVHRV GH OD &RQVHOOHULD GH &XOWXUD (GXFDFLyQ \ 'HSRUWH SRU OD TXH VH LQFRD H[SHGLHQWH SDUD OD SULPHUD IDVH GH OD DFWXDOL]DFLyQ \ DGDSWDFLyQ SDUFLDO GH OD 6HFFLyQ 3ULPHUD GHO ,QYHQWDULR *HQHUDO GHO 3DWULPRQLR &XOWXUDO 9DOHQFLDQR HQ PDWHULD GH SDWULPRQLRDUTXLWHFWyQLFR\PHGLRDPELHQWDO\VHDEUHSHULRGRGHLQIRUPDFLyQSXEOLFD Núm. 5.503 / 02.05.2007 17885 %e'¶,17(5e6&8/785$/±&219(17'¶$,*h(69,9(6&$5&$,;(1702180(17 %,(1'(,17(5e6&8/785$/&219(172'($*8$69,9$6&$5&$,;(1702180(172 $11(;,9$1(;2,9 GH 5HVROXFLyGHG DEULOGHOD'LUHFFLy*HQHUDOGH3DWULPRQL&XOWXUDO9DOHQFLjL0XVHXVGHOD&RQVHOOHULDGH&XOWXUD(GXFDFLyL(VSRUWSHUODTXHV LQFRDH[SHGLHQWSHUDOD SULPHUD IDVH GH O DFWXDOLW]DFLy L DGDSWDFLy SDUFLDO GH OD 6HFFLy 3ULPHUD GH O ,QYHQWDUL *HQHUDO GHO 3DWULPRQL &XOWXUDO 9DOHQFLj HQ PDWqULD GH SDWULPRQL DUTXLWHFWzQLF L PHGLDPELHQWDOLV¶REULSHUtRGHG¶LQIRUPDFLyS~EOLFD 5HVROXFLyQ GH GH DEULO GH OD 'LUHFFLyQ *HQHUDO GH 3DWULPRQLR &XOWXUDO 9DOHQFLDQR \ 0XVHRV GH OD &RQVHOOHULD GH &XOWXUD (GXFDFLyQ \ 'HSRUWH SRU OD TXH VH LQFRD H[SHGLHQWH SDUD OD SULPHUD IDVH GH OD DFWXDOL]DFLyQ \ DGDSWDFLyQ SDUFLDO GH OD 6HFFLyQ 3ULPHUD GHO ,QYHQWDULR *HQHUDO GHO 3DWULPRQLR &XOWXUDO 9DOHQFLDQR HQ PDWHULD GH SDWULPRQLRDUTXLWHFWyQLFR\PHGLRDPELHQWDO\VHDEUHSHULRGRGHLQIRUPDFLyQSXEOLFD Núm. 5.503 / 02.05.2007 17886 %e'¶,17(5e6&8/785$/(6*/e6,$3$55248,$/'(6$17%$5720(8GH&2*8//$'$ &$5&$,;(1702180(17 %,(1'(,17(5e6&8/785$/,*/(6,$3$55248,$/'(6$1%$572/20eGH&2*8//$'$ &$5&$,;(1702180(172 'HQRPLQDFLy'HQRPLQDFLyQ 3ULQFLSDO3ULQFLSDO (VJOpVLD3DUURTXLDOGH6DQW%DUWRPHX ,JOHVLD3DUURTXLDOGH6DQ%DUWRORPp /RFDOLW]DFLy/RFDOL]DFLyQ 3URYtQFLD3URYLQFLD9DOqQFLD &RPDUFD&RPDUFD/D9DOOG¶$OEDLGD 0XQLFLSL0XQLFLSLR&RJXOODGD&DUFDL[HQW 8ELFDFLy8ELFDFLyQ&WUD$OEHULFD&RJXOODGD 5HIHUqQFLD&DGDVWUDO5HIHUHQFLD&DWDVWUDO ,OOD0DQ]DQD3DUFHOāOD3DUFHOD $QWHFHGHQWV-XUtGLFV$QWHFHGHQWHV-XUtGLFRV ,QFRDFLy,QFRDFLyQ 3XEOLFDFLyGHODLQFRDFLy3XEOLFDFLyQGHODLQFRDFLyQ%2( 'HVFULSFLy'HVFULSFLyQ 3DUWV,QWHJUDQWV3DUWHV,QWHJUDQWHV − (VJOpVLDDPEQDXFHQWUDO,JOHVLDFRQQDYHFHQWUDO − &DSHOOHVODWHUDOV&DSLOODVODWHUDOHV − &DSLOODGHOD0DUHGH'pXGHOD6DOXW&DSLOODGHOD9LUJHQGHOD6DOXG − &DSLOODGHO&ULVWGHOD6DOXW&DSLOODGHO&ULVWRGHOD6DOXG − 3RUWDGDSULQFLSDO3RUWDGDSULQFLSDO − &DPSDQDU&DPSDQDULR 'HVFULSFLy*HQHUDO'HVFULSFLyQ*HQHUDO (QO¶DOGHDGH&RJXOODGDHVWUREDHVWDHVJOpVLDDPEDGYRFDFLyD6DQW%DUWRPHX/DIXQGDFLyGHO HVJOpVLDVH VLWXDULD D ILQDOV GHO VHJOH ;9 L SULQFLSLV GHO VHJOH ;9, 'H OD SULPLWLYD HVWUXFWXUD TXHGHQ SRTXHV UHVWHV QRPpV HQ OD ]RQD GHO SUHVELWHUL L OD VDJULVWLD /D UHVWD GH O HVJOpVLD pV PpV UHFHQW GHO VHJOH ;9,, TXDQ V HIHFWXHQUHIRUPHVV¶DPSOLDODQDXLHVFRQWUXHL[HQOHVFDSHOOHVODWHUDOV(QHOVHJOH;,;HQHV YD FRQVWUXLUODF~SXODGHODFDSHOODGHOD0DUHGH'pXGHOD6DOXW(QHVYDQGXUDWHUPHUHIRUPHVHQOD IDoDQDODFREHUWDLODYROWDDL[tFRPWDPEpHVYDHOHYDUO DOWXUDGHOFDPSDQDU (VWUDFWDG XQDHVJOpVLDGHSODQWDGHFUHXOODWLQDDPEXQDQDXFHQWUDOLFDSHOOHVODWHUDOV/DQDXHVFREUL[ DPE YROWD GH FDQy DPE OOXQHWHV HQ TXq V REULQ ILQHVWUDOV /HV FDSHOOHV HV FREUL[HQ DPE YROWHV YDwGHV D H[FHSFLyGHODFDSHOODGHO&ULVWGHOD6DOXWDPEF~SXODVREUHSHW[LQHV $ O H[WHULRU SUHVHQWD XQD FREHUWD D GXHV DLJHV /D IDoDQD pV GH JUDQV GLPHQVLRQV HQ OD TXH GHVWDFD OD SRUWDGDGHGRVFRVVRVUHDOLW]DGDHQSHGUD/ LQIHULRUpVDOOLQGDWIODQTXHMDWSHUSLODVWUHVGzULTXHVHVWULDGHV (QODSDUWVXSHULRUVHVLWXDXQDIRUQtFXODDPEODLPDWJHGH6DQW%DUWRPHXIODQTXHMDGDSHUYROXWHVFRUEDGHV LSLUjPLGHVHQHOVH[WUHPV/DSRUWDGDHVUHPDWDDPEXQIURQWyWULDQJXODUSDUWLW$ODGUHWDGHODIDoDQDHV WUREDHOFDPSDQDUTXHDFRQVHJXL[O DOWXUDGHPHWUHVLpVGHSODQWDTXDGUDGD(QODSDUWVXSHULRUVREUH HOFRVGHFDPSDQHVVHVLWXDXQEDUDQDUHPDWDGDDPEEROHVHQHOVDQJOHV&RURQDODWRUUHXQWHPSOHWDPE DUFV GH PLJ SXQW HQ FDGD XQ GHOV TXDWUH FRVWDWV FREHUW D TXDWUH DLJHV %DVDW HQ HO &DWjOHJ GH 0RQXPHQWVGHOD&RPXQLWDW9DOHQFLDQD (Q OD DOGHD GH &RJXOODGD VH HQFXHQWUD HVWD LJOHVLD FRQ DGYRFDFLyQ D 6DQ %DUWRORPp /D IXQGDFLyQ GH OD LJOHVLD SHUR VH VLWXDUtD D ILQDOHV GHO VLJOR ;9 \ SULQFLSLRV GHO VLJOR ;9, 'H OD SULPLWLYD HVWUXFWXUD TXHGDQ SRFRVUHVWRVVROR HQOD]RQDGHO SUHVELWHULR \ OD VDFULVWtD (O UHVWR GH OD LJOHVLD HV PiV UHFLHQWH GHO VLJOR ;9,,FXDQGRVHHIHFW~DQUHIRUPDVDPSOLiQGRVHODQDYH\FRQVWUX\pQGRVHODVFDSLOODVODWHUDOHV(QHOVLJOR ;,; HQ VH FRQVWUX\y OD F~SXOD GH OD FDSLOOD GH OD 9LUJHQ GH OD 6DOXG (Q VH OOHYDURQ D FDER UHIRUPDVHQODIDFKDGDFXELHUWD\EyYHGDDVtFRPRWDPELpQVHHOHYyODDOWXUDGHOFDPSDQDULR 6HWUDWDGHXQDLJOHVLDGHSODQWDGHFUX]ODWLQDFRQXQDQDYHFHQWUDO\FDSLOODVODWHUDOHV/DQDYHVHFXEUH FRQ EyYHGD GH FDxyQ FRQ OXQHWRV HQ ORV TXH VH DEUHQ YHQWDQDOHV /DV FDSLOODV VH FXEUHQ FRQ EyYHGDV YDtGDVDH[FHSFLyQGHODFDSLOODGHO&ULVWRGHOD6DOXGFRQF~SXODVREUHSHFKLQDV $11(;,9$1(;2,9 GH 5HVROXFLyGHG DEULOGHOD'LUHFFLy*HQHUDOGH3DWULPRQL&XOWXUDO9DOHQFLjL0XVHXVGHOD&RQVHOOHULDGH&XOWXUD(GXFDFLyL(VSRUWSHUODTXHV LQFRDH[SHGLHQWSHUDOD SULPHUD IDVH GH O DFWXDOLW]DFLy L DGDSWDFLy SDUFLDO GH OD 6HFFLy 3ULPHUD GH O ,QYHQWDUL *HQHUDO GHO 3DWULPRQL &XOWXUDO 9DOHQFLj HQ PDWqULD GH SDWULPRQL DUTXLWHFWzQLF L PHGLDPELHQWDOLV¶REULSHUtRGHG¶LQIRUPDFLyS~EOLFD 5HVROXFLyQ GH GH DEULO GH OD 'LUHFFLyQ *HQHUDO GH 3DWULPRQLR &XOWXUDO 9DOHQFLDQR \ 0XVHRV GH OD &RQVHOOHULD GH &XOWXUD (GXFDFLyQ \ 'HSRUWH SRU OD TXH VH LQFRD H[SHGLHQWH SDUD OD SULPHUD IDVH GH OD DFWXDOL]DFLyQ \ DGDSWDFLyQ SDUFLDO GH OD 6HFFLyQ 3ULPHUD GHO ,QYHQWDULR *HQHUDO GHO 3DWULPRQLR &XOWXUDO 9DOHQFLDQR HQ PDWHULD GH SDWULPRQLRDUTXLWHFWyQLFR\PHGLRDPELHQWDO\VHDEUHSHULRGRGHLQIRUPDFLyQSXEOLFD Núm. 5.503 / 02.05.2007 17887 $OH[WHULRUSUHVHQWDXQDFXELHUWDDGRVDJXDV/DIDFKDGDHVGHJUDQGHVGLPHQVLRQHVHQODTXHGHVWDFDOD SRUWDGD GH GRV FXHUSRV UHDOL]DGD HQ SLHGUD (O LQIHULRU HV DGLQWHODGR IODQTXHDGR SRU SLODVWUDV GyULFDV HVWULDGDV (Q OD SDUWH VXSHULRU VH VLW~D XQD KRUQDFLQD FRQ OD LPDJHQ GH 6DQ %DUWRORPp IODQTXHDGD SRU YROXWDVFXUYDGDV\SLUiPLGHVHQORVH[WUHPRV6HUHPDWDODSRUWDGDFRQXQIURQWyQWULDQJXODUSDUWLGR$OD GHUHFKD GH OD IDFKDGD VH HQFXHQWUD HO FDPSDQDULR TXH DOFDQ]D OD DOWXUD GH PHWURV \ HV GH SODQWD FXDGUDGD(QODSDUWHVXSHULRUVREUHHOFXHUSRGHFDPSDQDVVHVLW~DXQDQWHSHFKRUHPDWDGRFRQERODVHQ ORViQJXORV &RURQDQGR OD WRUUH XQ WHPSOHWH FRQ DUFRV GH PHGLR SXQWR HQ FDGD XQR GH VXV FXDWUR ODGRV FXELHUWRDFXDWURDJXDV%DVDGRHQHO&DWiORJRGH0RQXPHQWRVGHOD&RPXQLGDG9DOHQFLDQD 2EVHUYDFLRQV2EVHUYDFLRQHV (QWRUQ(QWRUQR $QWHFHGHQWVDGPLQLVWUDWLXVGHOLPLWDFLyH[WUHWDGHO H[SHGLHQWGHILQLGDDPEFDUjFWHUSURYLVLRQDO 2ULJHQSXQW$LQWHUVHFFLyGHOFDUUHUGH6DQW%HUWRPHXDPEHOFDUUHUGH6DQW-RVHS 6HQWLWKRUDUL /tQLDGHOLPLWDGRUDODOtQLDVHJXL[SHUO HL[GHOFDUUHUGH6DQW%HUWRPHXILQVDJLUDUSHUODSURORQJDFLyGHOD PLWJHUDGHODSDUFHOāODDPEODGHO¶LOODGHFDVHVVHJXL[SHUODSRVWHULRUG HVWDSDUFHOāODLJLUD SHUDSURVVHJXLUSHUODPLWJHUDGHOHVSDUFHOāOHVLG HVWDLOODGHFDVHV&UHXDHOFDUUHUGHO (VJOpVLDL LQFRUSRUDODSDUFHOāODGHO¶LOODGHFDVHV&UHXDODWUDYHVVLDGHO (VJOpVLDLVHJXL[SHUOHVSRVWHULRUV GH OHV SDUFHOāOHV L GH O¶LOOD GH FDVHV &UHXD HO FDUUHU GH 6DQW -RVHS L LQFRUSRUDOHVSDUFHOāOHVGHO¶LOODGHFDVHVLGHOSROtJRQILQVDOSXQWG RULJHQ $QWHFHGHQWHVDGPLQLVWUDWLYRVGHOLPLWDFLyQH[WUDtGDGHOH[SHGLHQWHGHILQLGDFRQFDUiFWHUSURYLVLRQDO 2ULJHQSXQWR$LQWHUVHFFLyQGHODFDOOH6DQW%HUWRPHXFRQODFDOOH6DQ-RVp 6HQWLGRKRUDULR /tQHDGHOLPLWDGRUDODOtQHDVLJXHSRUHOHMHGHODFDOOH6DQW%HUWRPHXKDVWDJLUDUSRUODSURORQJDFLyQGHOD PHGLDQHUDGHODSDUFHODFRQODGHODPDQ]DQDVLJXHSRUODWUDVHUDGHHVWDSDUFHOD\JLUD SDUD SURVHJXLU SRU OD PHGLDQHUD GH ODV SDUFHODV \ GH HVWD PDQ]DQD &UX]D OD FDOOH GH OD ,JOHVLD H LQFRUSRUDODSDUFHODGHODPDQ]DQD&UX]DODWUDYHVtDGHOD,JOHVLD\VLJXHSRUODVWUDVHUDVGHODV SDUFHODV\GHODPDQ]DQD&UX]DODFDOOH6DQW-RVHSHLQFRUSRUDODVSDUFHODV GHODPDQ]DQD\GHOSROtJRQRKDVWDHOSXQWRGHRULJHQ $11(;,9$1(;2,9 GH 5HVROXFLyGHG DEULOGHOD'LUHFFLy*HQHUDOGH3DWULPRQL&XOWXUDO9DOHQFLjL0XVHXVGHOD&RQVHOOHULDGH&XOWXUD(GXFDFLyL(VSRUWSHUODTXHV LQFRDH[SHGLHQWSHUDOD SULPHUD IDVH GH O DFWXDOLW]DFLy L DGDSWDFLy SDUFLDO GH OD 6HFFLy 3ULPHUD GH O ,QYHQWDUL *HQHUDO GHO 3DWULPRQL &XOWXUDO 9DOHQFLj HQ PDWqULD GH SDWULPRQL DUTXLWHFWzQLF L PHGLDPELHQWDOLV¶REULSHUtRGHG¶LQIRUPDFLyS~EOLFD 5HVROXFLyQ GH GH DEULO GH OD 'LUHFFLyQ *HQHUDO GH 3DWULPRQLR &XOWXUDO 9DOHQFLDQR \ 0XVHRV GH OD &RQVHOOHULD GH &XOWXUD (GXFDFLyQ \ 'HSRUWH SRU OD TXH VH LQFRD H[SHGLHQWH SDUD OD SULPHUD IDVH GH OD DFWXDOL]DFLyQ \ DGDSWDFLyQ SDUFLDO GH OD 6HFFLyQ 3ULPHUD GHO ,QYHQWDULR *HQHUDO GHO 3DWULPRQLR &XOWXUDO 9DOHQFLDQR HQ PDWHULD GH SDWULPRQLRDUTXLWHFWyQLFR\PHGLRDPELHQWDO\VHDEUHSHULRGRGHLQIRUPDFLyQSXEOLFD Núm. 5.503 / 02.05.2007 17888 %e'¶,17(5e6&8/785$/(6*/e6,$3$55248,$/'(6$17%$5720(8GH&2*8//$'$ &$5&$,;(1702180(17 %,(1'(,17(5e6&8/785$/,*/(6,$3$55248,$/'(6$1%$572/20eGH&2*8//$'$ &$5&$,;(1702180(172 $11(;,9$1(;2,9 GH 5HVROXFLyGHG DEULOGHOD'LUHFFLy*HQHUDOGH3DWULPRQL&XOWXUDO9DOHQFLjL0XVHXVGHOD&RQVHOOHULDGH&XOWXUD(GXFDFLyL(VSRUWSHUODTXHV LQFRDH[SHGLHQWSHUDOD SULPHUD IDVH GH O DFWXDOLW]DFLy L DGDSWDFLy SDUFLDO GH OD 6HFFLy 3ULPHUD GH O ,QYHQWDUL *HQHUDO GHO 3DWULPRQL &XOWXUDO 9DOHQFLj HQ PDWqULD GH SDWULPRQL DUTXLWHFWzQLF L PHGLDPELHQWDOLV¶REULSHUtRGHG¶LQIRUPDFLyS~EOLFD 5HVROXFLyQ GH GH DEULO GH OD 'LUHFFLyQ *HQHUDO GH 3DWULPRQLR &XOWXUDO 9DOHQFLDQR \ 0XVHRV GH OD &RQVHOOHULD GH &XOWXUD (GXFDFLyQ \ 'HSRUWH SRU OD TXH VH LQFRD H[SHGLHQWH SDUD OD SULPHUD IDVH GH OD DFWXDOL]DFLyQ \ DGDSWDFLyQ SDUFLDO GH OD 6HFFLyQ 3ULPHUD GHO ,QYHQWDULR *HQHUDO GHO 3DWULPRQLR &XOWXUDO 9DOHQFLDQR HQ PDWHULD GH SDWULPRQLRDUTXLWHFWyQLFR\PHGLRDPELHQWDO\VHDEUHSHULRGRGHLQIRUPDFLyQSXEOLFD Núm. 5.503 / 02.05.2007 17889 %e'¶,17(5e6&8/785$/(50,7$'(/$0$5('('e8'(/$)217&$67(//)257 02180(17 %,(1'(,17(5e6&8/785$/(50,7$'(/$9,5*(1'(/$)8(17(&$67(//)257 02180(172 'HQRPLQDFLy'HQRPLQDFLyQ 3ULQFLSDO3ULQFLSDO (UPLWDGHOD0DUHGH'pXGHOD)RQW (UPLWDGHOD9LUJHQGHOD)XHQWH /RFDOLW]DFLy/RFDOL]DFLyQ 3URYtQFLD3URYLQFLD&DVWHOOy &RPDUFD&RPDUFD(OV3RUWV 0XQLFLSL0XQLFLSLR&DVWHOOIRUW 8ELFDFLy8ELFDFLyQ&WUD&DVWHOOIRUW$UHV 5HIHUqQFLD&DGDVWUDO5HIHUHQFLD&DWDVWUDO 3ROtJRQ3ROtJRQR3DUFHOāOD3DUFHOD\ $QWHFHGHQWV-XUtGLFV$QWHFHGHQWHV-XUtGLFRV ,QFRDFLy,QFRDFLy 3XEOLFDFLyGHODLQFRDFLy3XEOLFDFLyQGHODLQFRDFLyQ%2( 'HVFULSFLyQ'HVFULSFLyQ 3DUWV,QWHJUDQWV3DUWHV,QWHJUDQWHV − &DSHOOD&DSLOOD − (VJOpVLD,JOHVLD − 6DODSLQWDGD6DODSLQWDGD − 'HSHQGqQFLHVGHO¶KRVWDWJHULD'HSHQGHQFLDVGHODKRVSHGHUtD − 3RU[DGDSHUDOHVFDYDOOHULHV3RUFKHSDUDODVFDEDOOHUtDV − 3RUWDOGHOFDPtG¶$UHV3RUWDOGHOFDPLQRGH$UHV − 3RUWDOGHODQWLFFDPtGH&DVWHOOIRUW3RUWDOGHODQWLJXRFDPLQRGH&DVWHOOIRUW − $OMXEFRYD$OMLEH±FXHYD − &UHXGHWHUPH&UX]GHWpUPLQR 'HVFULSFLy*HQHUDO'HVFULSFLyQ*HQHUDO / HUPLWRULGHOD0DUHGH'pXGHOD)RQWVLWXDWDNPGHODSREODFLypVXQGHOVH[HPSOHVPpVVLJQLILFDWLXV GH OD SURYtQFLD (Q HOO HV FRQWLQXHQ UHDOLW]DQW URPHULHV LQLFLDGHV HQ HO VHJOH ;9 DPE PRWLX GH GLIHUHQWV PLUDFOHV (OFRQMXQWGLVSRVDWGHIRUPDWULDQJXODUHVWjIRUPDWSHUO HVJOpVLDO KRVWDWJHULDODFRQIUDULDLXQSRU[H/D FRQVWUXFFLy GHO FRQMXQW FRPSUpQ GHV GHO VHJOH ;9, DO ;9,, L OD WUDoD YD VHU GRQDGD SHU -RDQ 6RO L HOV PHVWUHVG REUHVYDQVHU$QWRQL%UHOOL(VWHYH*DQDXW / HVJOpVLDVHVLWXDMXQWDXQDFRYDHQODTXHKLKDXQEUROODGRUQDWXUDORQVHJRQVODWUDGLFLyHVYDWUREDUOD 0DUHGH'pX/DFDSHOODHQODTXHHVWUREDOD0DUHGH'pXYDVHUFRQVWUXwGDHQLHVWjFREHUWDDPE YROWDGHFUHXHULDHVWUHODGDDPEFODXVGHFRUDGHVDPEPHGDOORQVUHQDL[HQWLVWHV/ HVJOpVLDpVG XQDVRODQDX GLYLGLGD HQ WUHV WUDPV FREHUWV DPE YROWD GH FDQy DPE OOXQHWHV OD FDSHOOD PDMRU HV FREUL[ DPE YROWD GH FUHXHULD L SUHVHQWD DEVLV SROLJRQDO / DFFpV D O HVJOpVLD HVWj HQ HO FRVWDW GH O HStVWROD 6REUH OD SRUWDGD G DFFpVHVFRQVWUXw[HQHOVHJOH;9,,XQFRVUHDOLW]DWHQFDUUHXDWUHPDWDWSHUXQDHVSDGDQ\D / KRVWDWJHULD Wp IRUPD GH ³/´ DPE GRV FRVVRV GHVHQYROXSDWV HQ GRV SODQWHV (O SULPHU FRV DQQH[ D O HVJOpVLD HVWj FRQVWUXwW DPE PXUV GH PDoRQHULD HQJORED OD JUXWD L XQD HGLILFDFLy DPE GXHV VDOHV HQ OD SODQWDEDL[DLKDELWDFLRQVHQODSODQWDVXSHULRU(OVHJRQFRVHVWjFRPSRVW SHUGXHV HGLILFDFLRQVXQDDPE HVWDGHVLHOVHJRQpVO HGLILFLGHOD&RQIUDULDHQTXqHVWUREDOD6DOD3LQWDGD / ~OWLPFRVG HGLILFDFLyDOoDWDPLWMDQVHJOH;,;pVXQSRU[HDOOLQGDWLREHUWDODSODoDSHUDFDYDOOHULVVHVHQ HOVGLHVGHSHOHJULQDWJH%DVDWHQO LQIRUPHWqFQLFUHDOLW]DWSHU3&UX]DQV (O HUPLWRULR GH OD 9LUJHQ GH OD )XHQWH VLWXDGR D NP GH OD SREODFLyQ HV XQR GH ORV HMHPSORV PiV VLJQLILFDWLYRV GH OD SURYLQFLD (Q pO VH VLJXHQ UHDOL]DQGR URPHUtDV LQLFLDGDV HQ HO VLJOR ;9 FRQ PRWLYR GH GLIHUHQWHVPLODJURV (O FRQMXQWR GLVSXHVWR GH IRUPD WULDQJXODU HVWi IRUPDGR SRU OD LJOHVLD OD KRVSHGHUtD OD FRIUDGtD \ XQ SRUFKH/DFRQVWUXFFLyQGHOFRQMXQWRDEDUFDGHVGHHOVLJOR;9,DO;9,,\ODWUD]DIXHGDGDSRU-RDQ6RO\ORV PDHVWURVGHREUDVIXHURQ$QWRQL%UHOO\(VWHYH*DQDXW $11(;,9$1(;2,9 GH 5HVROXFLyGHG DEULOGHOD'LUHFFLy*HQHUDOGH3DWULPRQL&XOWXUDO9DOHQFLjL0XVHXVGHOD&RQVHOOHULDGH&XOWXUD(GXFDFLyL(VSRUWSHUODTXHV LQFRDH[SHGLHQWSHUDOD SULPHUD IDVH GH O DFWXDOLW]DFLy L DGDSWDFLy SDUFLDO GH OD 6HFFLy 3ULPHUD GH O ,QYHQWDUL *HQHUDO GHO 3DWULPRQL &XOWXUDO 9DOHQFLj HQ PDWqULD GH SDWULPRQL DUTXLWHFWzQLF L PHGLDPELHQWDOLV¶REULSHUtRGHG¶LQIRUPDFLyS~EOLFD 5HVROXFLyQ GH GH DEULO GH OD 'LUHFFLyQ *HQHUDO GH 3DWULPRQLR &XOWXUDO 9DOHQFLDQR \ 0XVHRV GH OD &RQVHOOHULD GH &XOWXUD (GXFDFLyQ \ 'HSRUWH SRU OD TXH VH LQFRD H[SHGLHQWH SDUD OD SULPHUD IDVH GH OD DFWXDOL]DFLyQ \ DGDSWDFLyQ SDUFLDO GH OD 6HFFLyQ 3ULPHUD GHO ,QYHQWDULR *HQHUDO GHO 3DWULPRQLR &XOWXUDO 9DOHQFLDQR HQ PDWHULD GH SDWULPRQLRDUTXLWHFWyQLFR\PHGLRDPELHQWDO\VHDEUHSHULRGRGHLQIRUPDFLyQSXEOLFD Núm. 5.503 / 02.05.2007 17890 /D LJOHVLD VH VLW~D MXQWR D XQD FXHYD HQ OD TXH H[LVWH XQ PDQDQWLDO QDWXUDO GRQGH VHJ~Q OD WUDGLFLyQ VH HQFRQWUyOD9LUJHQ/DFDSLOODHQODTXHVHHQFXHQWUDOD9LUJHQIXHFRQVWUXLGDHQ\HVWiFXELHUWDFRQ EyYHGDGHFUXFHUtDHVWUHOODGDFRQFODYHVGHFRUDGDVFRQPHGDOORQHVUHQDFHQWLVWDV/DLJOHVLDHVGHXQDVROD QDYHGLYLGLGDHQWUHVWUDPRVFXELHUWRVFRQEyYHGDGHFDxyQFRQOXQHWRVODFDSLOODPD\RUFXEUHFRQEyYHGD GHFUXFHUtD\SUHVHQWDiEVLGHSROLJRQDO(ODFFHVRDODLJOHVLDHVSRUHOODGRGHODHStVWROD6REUHODSRUWDGD GHDFFHVRVHFRQVWUX\RHQHOVLJOR;9,,XQFXHUSRUHDOL]DGRHQVLOOHUtDUHPDWDGRSRUXQDHVSDGDxD /DKRVSHGHUtDHQIRUPDGH³/´VHFRPSRQHGHGRVFXHUSRVGHVDUUROODGRVHQGRVSODQWDV(OSULPHURDQH[R DODLJOHVLDHQJOREDODJUXWD\XQDHGLILFDFLyQFRQVDODVHQOD SODQWDEDMD\KDELWDFLRQHV HQOD VXSHULRU (VWiFRQVWUXLGRFRQPXURVGHPDPSRVWHUtD(OVHJXQGRFXHUSRHVWiFRPSXHVWRSRUGRVHGLILFDFLRQHVXQD FRQHVWDQFLDV\HOVHJXQGRHVHOHGLILFLRGHOD&RIUDGtDHQHOTXHVHHQFXHQWUDOD6DOD3LQWDGD (O~OWLPRFXHUSRGHHGLILFDFLyQOHYDQWDGRDPHGLDGRVGHOVLJOR;,;HVXQSRUFKHDGLQWHODGR\DELHUWRDOD SOD]D \ DELHUWR D OD SOD]D SDUD FDEDOOHUL]DV HQ ORV GtDV GH SHUHJULQDFLyQ %DVDGR HQ HO LQIRUPH WpFQLFR UHDOL]DGRSRU3&UX]DQV 2EVHUYDFLRQV2EVHUYDFLRQHV (QWRUQ(QWRUQR $QWHFHGHQWHVDGPLQLVWUDWLYRVGHOLPLWDFLyH[WUHWDGHO H[SHGLHQWHGHILQLGDDPEFDUjFWHUSURYLVLRQDO 2ULJHQSXQW$GHFRRUGHQDGHVJHRJUjILTXHV870; < 6HQWLWDQWLKRUDUL /tQLDGHOLPLWDGRUDGHVGHO RULJHQSXQW$ODOtQLD GHGHOLPLWDFLyFUHXDODFDUUHWHUD&9YRUHMDHOOtPLW QRUGGHOHVSDUFHOāOHVLGHOSROtJRQILQVXQDYLDSHFXjULD&UHXDHVWDYLDSHFXjULDLQFORHQWODHQ O HQWRUQGHSURWHFFLyLFRQWLQXDFDSDOVXGILQVDDUULEDUDO %DUUDQFGHOHV/ORPHWHV3URVVHJXL[FDSDOVXG LQFORHQW HO EDUUDQF HQ HO WUDP TXH YRUHMD OD SDUFHOāOD GHO SROtJRQ 'HVSUpV KR FUHXD L YRUHMD O DQWHULRUSDUFHOāODSHOVVHXVOtPLWVVXGLHVWILQVDOSXQWRQV HQFUHXHQHOEDUUDQFGHQRPLQDWHQHVWHWUDP %DUUDQFGHOD)RQWLODFDUUHWHUD&99RUHMDHOEDUUDQFVHJXLQWHOVHXUHFRUUHJXWFDSDO RHVWILQVDUULEDU DODSDUFHOāODGHOSROtJRQ*LUDFDSDOQRUGYRUHMDQWO DQWHULRUSDUFHOāODFUHXDGHQRXODFDUUHWHUD&9 LSURVVHJXL[FDSDOQRUGSHOOtPLWHVWGHOHVSDUFHOāOHVLGHOSROtJRQ'HV G DOOtJLUDFDSDO RHVWYRUHMDQWOHVSDUFHOāOHVLGHVSUpVFRQWLQXDFDSDOQRUGYRUHMDQWHOOtPLW HVWGHOHVSDUFHOāOHVLGHOSROtJRQILQVDDUULEDUDXQDVHQGD&UHXDHVWDVHQGDLQFORHQWOD HQ HQWRUQ GH SURWHFFLy HQ HO WUDP TXH YRUHMD OD SDUFHOāOD 'HVSUpV VHJXL[ FDS DO VXG YRUHMDQW OD SDUFHOāODGHOSROtJRQSHOVHXOtPLWRHVWILQVDDUULEDUDOSXQWG RULJHQ $QWHFHGHQWHVDGPLQLVWUDWLYRVGHOLPLWDFLyQH[WUDtGDGHOH[SHGLHQWHGHILQLGDFRQFDUiFWHUSURYLVLRQDO 2ULJHQSXQWR$GHFRRUGHQDGDVJHRJUiILFDV870; < 6HQWLGRDQWLKRUDULR /tQHDGHOLPLWDGRUDGHVGHHORULJHQSXQWR$ODOtQHD GHGHOLPLWDFLyQFUX]DODFDUUHWHUD&9ERUGHDHO OtPLWH QRUWH GH ODV SDUFHODV \ GHO SROtJRQR KDVWD XQD YtD SHFXDULD &UX]D HVWD YtD SHFXDULD LQFOX\pQGRODHQHOHQWRUQRGHSURWHFFLyQ\FRQWLQ~DKDFLDHO VXUKDVWDOOHJDUDO%DUUDQFGHOHV/ORPHWHV 3URVLJXH KDFLD HO VXU LQFOX\HQGR HO EDUUDQFR HQ HO WUDPR TXH ERUGHD OD SDUFHOD GHO SROtJRQR 'HVSXpV OR FUX]D \ ERUGHD OD DQWHULRU SDUFHOD SRU VXV OtPLWHV VXU \ HVWH KDVWD OOHJDU DO SXQWR GRQGH VH FUX]DQ HO EDUUDQFR GHQRPLQDGR HQ HVWH WUDPR %DUUDQF GH OD )RQW \ OD FDUUHWHUD &9 %RUGHD HO EDUUDQFRVLJXLHQGRVXUHFRUULGRKDFLDHORHVWHKDVWDOOHJDU DOD SDUFHOD GHOSROtJRQR*LUD KDFLD HO QRUWHERUGHDQGRODDQWHULRUSDUFHODFUX]DGHQXHYRODFDUUHWHUD&9\SURVLJXHKDFLDHOQRUWHSRUHO OtPLWH HVWH GH ODV SDUFHODV \ GHO SROtJRQR 'HVGH DOOt JLUD KDFLD HO RHVWH ERUGHDQGR ODV SDUFHODV \ GHVSXpV FRQWLQ~D KDFLD HO QRUWH ERUGHDQGR HO OtPLWH HVWH GH ODV SDUFHODV \ GHO SROtJRQR KDVWD OOHJDU D XQD VHQGD &UX]D HVWD VHQGD LQFOX\pQGROD HQ HQWRUQR GH SURWHFFLyQ HQ HO WUDPR TXH ERUGHD OD SDUFHOD 'HVSXpV VLJXH KDFLD HO VXU ERUGHDQGR OD SDUFHODGHOSROtJRQRSRUVXOtPLWHRHVWHKDVWDOOHJDUDOSXQWRGHRULJHQ $11(;,9$1(;2,9 GH 5HVROXFLyGHG DEULOGHOD'LUHFFLy*HQHUDOGH3DWULPRQL&XOWXUDO9DOHQFLjL0XVHXVGHOD&RQVHOOHULDGH&XOWXUD(GXFDFLyL(VSRUWSHUODTXHV LQFRDH[SHGLHQWSHUDOD SULPHUD IDVH GH O DFWXDOLW]DFLy L DGDSWDFLy SDUFLDO GH OD 6HFFLy 3ULPHUD GH O ,QYHQWDUL *HQHUDO GHO 3DWULPRQL &XOWXUDO 9DOHQFLj HQ PDWqULD GH SDWULPRQL DUTXLWHFWzQLF L PHGLDPELHQWDOLV¶REULSHUtRGHG¶LQIRUPDFLyS~EOLFD 5HVROXFLyQ GH GH DEULO GH OD 'LUHFFLyQ *HQHUDO GH 3DWULPRQLR &XOWXUDO 9DOHQFLDQR \ 0XVHRV GH OD &RQVHOOHULD GH &XOWXUD (GXFDFLyQ \ 'HSRUWH SRU OD TXH VH LQFRD H[SHGLHQWH SDUD OD SULPHUD IDVH GH OD DFWXDOL]DFLyQ \ DGDSWDFLyQ SDUFLDO GH OD 6HFFLyQ 3ULPHUD GHO ,QYHQWDULR *HQHUDO GHO 3DWULPRQLR &XOWXUDO 9DOHQFLDQR HQ PDWHULD GH SDWULPRQLRDUTXLWHFWyQLFR\PHGLRDPELHQWDO\VHDEUHSHULRGRGHLQIRUPDFLyQSXEOLFD Núm. 5.503 / 02.05.2007 17891 %e'¶,17(5e6&8/785$/(50,7$'(/$0$5('('e8'(/$)217&$67(//)257 02180(17 %,(1'(,17(5e6&8/785$/(50,7$'(/$9,5*(1'(/$)8(17(&$67(//)257 02180(172 $11(;,9$1(;2,9 GH 5HVROXFLyGHG DEULOGHOD'LUHFFLy*HQHUDOGH3DWULPRQL&XOWXUDO9DOHQFLjL0XVHXVGHOD&RQVHOOHULDGH&XOWXUD(GXFDFLyL(VSRUWSHUODTXHV LQFRDH[SHGLHQWSHUDOD SULPHUD IDVH GH O DFWXDOLW]DFLy L DGDSWDFLy SDUFLDO GH OD 6HFFLy 3ULPHUD GH O ,QYHQWDUL *HQHUDO GHO 3DWULPRQL &XOWXUDO 9DOHQFLj HQ PDWqULD GH SDWULPRQL DUTXLWHFWzQLF L PHGLDPELHQWDOLV¶REULSHUtRGHG¶LQIRUPDFLyS~EOLFD 5HVROXFLyQGHGHDEULOGHOD'LUHFFLyQ*HQHUDOGH3DWULPRQLR&XOWXUDO9DOHQFLDQR\ 0XVHRV GH OD &RQVHOOHULD GH &XOWXUD (GXFDFLyQ \ 'HSRUWH SRU OD TXH VH LQFRDH[SHGLHQWHSDUDODSULPHUDIDVHGHODDFWXDOL]DFLyQ\DGDSWDFLyQSDUFLDOGHOD6HFFLyQ3ULPHUDGHO,QYHQWDULR*HQHUDOGHO3DWULPRQLR&XOWXUDO9DOHQFLDQRHQPDWHULD GHSDWULPRQLRDUTXLWHFWyQLFR\PHGLRDPELHQWDO\VHDEUHSHULRGRGHLQIRUPDFLyQSXEOLFD Núm. 5.503 / 02.05.2007 17892 %e'¶,17(5e6&8/785$/±(50,7$'(6$173(5(&$67(//)25702180(172 %,(1'(,17(5e6&8/785$/(50,7$'(6$13('52&$67(//)25702180(172 'HQRPLQDFLy'HQRPLQDFLyQ 3ULQFLSDO3ULQFLSDO (UPLWDGH6DQW3HUH (UPLWDGH6DQ3HGUR /RFDOLW]DFLy/RFDOL]DFLyQ 3URYtQFLD3URYLQFLD&DVWHOOy &RPDUFD&RPDUFD(OV3RUWV 0XQLFLSL0XQLFLSLR&DVWHOOIRUW 8ELFDFLy8ELFDFLyQ 5HIHUqQFLD&DGDVWUDO5HIHUHQFLD&DWDVWUDO 3ROtJRQ3ROtJRQR3DUFHOāOD3DUFHOD $QWHFHGHQWV-XUtGLFV$QWHFHGHQWHV-XUtGLFRV ,QFRDFLy,QFRDFLyQ,QFRDW5HVROXFLyGHG¶DJRVWGHGHOD'LUHFFLy*HQHUDOGH3DWULPRQL$UWtVWLF 3XEOLFDFLyGHODLQFRDFLy3XEOLFDFLyQGHODLQFRDFLyQ'2*9 'HFULSFLy'HVFULSFLyQ 3DUWV,QWHJUDQWV3DUWHV,QWHJUDQWHV − (VJOpVLD±HUPLWD,JOHVLDHUPLWD − 0DVLDKRVWDWJHULD0DVtDKRVSHGHUtD − &RUUDOV&RUUDOHV − $OMXE$OMLEH − 3HLUy&UX]GHSLHGUD 'HVFULSFLy*HQHUDO'HVFULSFLyQ*HQHUDO /DFRQVWUXFFLyHVWjIRUPDGDSHUO HVJOpVLD±HUPLWDLXQDPDVLDKRVWDWJHULDDIHJLGDSRVWHULRUPHQWHQHOFRVWDW VXG/ HVJOpVLD GHSODQWDUHFWDQJXODUpV G XQDVRODQDXLHV FRPSRQ GH GXHV SDUWV GLIHUHQFLDGHV SHU OHV VHXHV IjEULTXHV L IRUPD GH FREULPHQW O DEVLV L OD QDX / DEVLV KXLWDYDW DPE FRQWUDIRUWV H[WHULRUV HVWj VHSDUDWGHODQDX SHUXQDUF WULRPIDO DSXQWDWL HVFREUL[ DPEYROWDGHFUHXHULD/DIjEULFDpV GHPXUV GH FDUUHXDW DPE PDUTXHV GH SLFDSHGUHU /D QDX HVWj IRUPDGD SHU FLQF FUXJLHV FREHUWHV DPE DUFV GLDIUDJPD VREUHHOVTXDOVGHVFDQVDODFREHUWDGHIXVWD/ DFFpVHVUHDOLW]DDWUDYpVGHGXHVSRUWHVODSULQFLSDODOVSHXV DPEDUFGHPLJSXQWHQTXqHVOOLJODGDWD/DVHJRQDSRUWDHQODWHUFHUDFUXJLDHVWjIRUPDGDSHUXQ DUF GH PLJ SXQW DGRYHOODW /D OtQLD G LPSRVWD SUHVHQWD XQD GHFRUDFLy DPE WHPHV YHJHWDOV GH WUDGLFLy URPjQLFD OD TXDO FRVD ID SHQVDU TXH SRGULD VHU OD SRUWDGD RULJLQDO /D IjEULFD pV GH PXUV GH PDoRQHULD SUHVDDPEFDOoLDUFVGHFDUUHXDW'HVWDTXHQHOVSDYLPHQWVGHFXGROVTXHIRUPHQGHFRUDFLyYHJHWDO /DPDVLD±KRVWDWJHULDpVXQDFRQVWUXFFLyDIHJLGDLFRQVWDGHGXHVSODQWHV(QODSODQWDLQIHULRUHVGLVSRVHQ HVWDEOHV XQ WUXOO L SDUW GH YLYHQGD GHOV PDVRYHUV OD SRUWD SULQFLSDO SRUWD OD OOHJHQGD PDJDQWRQL EUHO(QODSODQWDVXSHULRUHVGLVWULEXw[HQOHVDOFRYHVLXQD VDODTXHV DGRUQDDPEXQDFDUWHOāODHQTXqHV UHSUHVHQWHQOHVFODXVGH6DQW3HUHLODGDWDHQODILQHVWUDDSDUHL[ODGDWD 'HVSUpVGHO DEVLVHVWUREDO DOMXEFREHUWDPEYROWDGHFDQyFRQVWUXwGDHQSHGUDHQVHF /D FRQVWUXFFLyQ HVWi IRUPDGD SRU OD LJOHVLD±HUPLWD \ XQD PDVtDKRVSHGHUtD DxDGLGD SRVWHULRUPHQWH HQ HO ODGRVXU/DLJOHVLDGHSODQWDUHFWDQJXODUHVGHXQDVRODQDYH\VHFRPSRQHGHGRVSDUWHVGLIHUHQFLDGDV SRUVXVIiEULFDV\IRUPDGHFXEULFLyQHOiEVLGH\ODQDYH(OiEVLGHRFKDYDGRFRQFRQWUDIXHUWHVH[WHULRUHV HVWiVHSDUDGRGHODQDYHSRUXQDUFRWULXQIDODSXQWDGR\VHFXEUHFRQEyYHGDGHFUXFHUtD/DIiEULFDHVGH PXURV GH VLOOHUtD FRQ PDUFDV GH FDQWHUtD /D QDYH HVWi IRUPDGD SRU FLQFR FUXMtDV FXELHUWDV FRQ DUFRV GLDIUDJPDVREUHORVTXH GHVFDQVDODFXELHUWDGHPDGHUD(ODFFHVRVHUHDOL]D DWUDYpV GHGRVSXHUWDVOD SULQFLSDODORVSLHVFRQDUFRGHPHGLRSXQWRHQHOTXHVHOHHODIHFKD/DVHJXQGDSXHUWDHQODWHUFHUD FUXMtDHVWiIRUPDGDSRUXQDUFRGHPHGLRSXQWRGRYHODGR/DOtQHDGHLPSRVWDSUHVHQWDXQDGHFRUDFLyQFRQ WHPDVYHJHWDOHVGHWUDGLFLyQURPiQLFDORTXHKDFHSHQVDUVHDODSRUWDGDRULJLQDO/DIiEULFDHVGHPXURV GH PDPSRVWHUtD WRPDGD FRQ FDO \ DUFRV GH VLOOHUtD 'HVWDFDU ORV SDYLPHQWRV GH JXLMDUURV TXH IRUPDQ GHFRUDFLyQYHJHWDO /DPDVtD±KRVSHGHUtDHVFRQVWUXFFLyQDxDGLGD\FRQVWDGHGRVSODQWDV(QODLQIHULRUVHGLVSRQHQHVWDEORV XQODJDU\SDUWHGHYLYLHQGDGHORVPDVRYHURV/DSXHUWDSULQFLSDOOOHYDODOH\HQGDPDJDQWRQLEUHO $11(;,9$1(;2,9 GH 5HVROXFLyGHG DEULOGHOD'LUHFFLy*HQHUDOGH3DWULPRQL&XOWXUDO9DOHQFLjL0XVHXVGHOD&RQVHOOHULDGH&XOWXUD(GXFDFLyL(VSRUWSHUODTXHV LQFRDH[SHGLHQWSHUDOD SULPHUD IDVH GH O DFWXDOLW]DFLy L DGDSWDFLy SDUFLDO GH OD 6HFFLy 3ULPHUD GH O ,QYHQWDUL *HQHUDO GHO 3DWULPRQL &XOWXUDO 9DOHQFLj HQ PDWqULD GH SDWULPRQL DUTXLWHFWzQLF L PHGLDPELHQWDOLV¶REULSHUtRGHG¶LQIRUPDFLyS~EOLFD 5HVROXFLyQGHGHDEULOGHOD'LUHFFLyQ*HQHUDOGH3DWULPRQLR&XOWXUDO9DOHQFLDQR\ 0XVHRV GH OD &RQVHOOHULD GH &XOWXUD (GXFDFLyQ \ 'HSRUWH SRU OD TXH VH LQFRDH[SHGLHQWHSDUDODSULPHUDIDVHGHODDFWXDOL]DFLyQ\DGDSWDFLyQSDUFLDOGHOD6HFFLyQ3ULPHUDGHO,QYHQWDULR*HQHUDOGHO3DWULPRQLR&XOWXUDO9DOHQFLDQRHQPDWHULD GHSDWULPRQLRDUTXLWHFWyQLFR\PHGLRDPELHQWDO\VHDEUHSHULRGRGHLQIRUPDFLyQSXEOLFD Núm. 5.503 / 02.05.2007 17893 (Q OD SODQWD VXSHULRU VH GLVWULEX\HQ ODV DOFREDV \ XQD VDOD TXH VH DGRUQD FRQ XQD FDUWHOD HQ OD TXH VH UHSUHVHQWDQODVOODYHVGH63HGUR\ODIHFKDHQODYHQWDQDDSDUHFHODIHFKD 7UDVHOiEVLGHVHHQFXHQWUDHODOMLEHFXELHUWRFRQEyYHGDGHFDxyQFRQVWUXLGDHQSLHGUDHQVHFR 2EVHUYDFLRQHV2EVHUYDFLRQHV (QWRUQ(QWRUQR $QWHFHGHQWVDGPLQLVWUDWLXVGHOLPLWDFLyH[WUHWDGHO H[SHGLHQWGHILQLGDDPEFDUjFWHUSURYLVLRQDO 2ULJHQSXQW$GHFRRUGHQDGHVJHRJUjILTXHV870; < 6HQWLWDQWLKRUDUL /tQLD GHOLPLWDGRUD GHV GH O RULJHQ SXQW $ OD OtQLD GH GHOLPLWDFLy VHJXL[ HO &DPt GH &DVWHOOIRUW D 0RUHOOD L O¶LQFORXHQO HQWRUQGHSURWHFFLyHQHOWUDPTXHYRUHMDOHVSDUFHOāOHVLGHOSROtJRQ ILQVDODVHXDWUREDGDDPEHO%DUUDQFGHO0DVGHO5LX&UHXDHOFDPtLFRQWLQXDSHOEDUUDQFFDSDOVXGHQHO WUDPTXHYRUHMDOHVSDUFHOāOHVLGHOSROtJRQ*LUDFDSDOQRUGRHVWLYRUHMD ODSDUFHOāODGHOSROtJRQILQVDODFDUUHWHUD&9&UHXDHVWDLODVHJXL[FDSDOVXGHVWILQVDDUULEDU DODSDUFHOāODGHOSROtJRQ*LUDFDSDOVXGRHVWYRUHMDQWOHVSDUFHOāOHVLGHOSROtJRQILQVD DUULEDUDXQDSLVWDDVIDOWDGD&UHXDODSLVWDLYRUHMDOHVSDUFHOāOHVLILQVDDUULEDUDXQDVHQGD'HV G DFtFRQWLQXDFDSDOVXGSHUODGLWDVHQGDTXHOLPLWDDPEOHVSDUFHOāOHVLGHOSROtJRQ &UHXDODVHQGDLYRUHMDHVWD~OWLPDSDUFHOāODILQVDDUULEDUDODFDUUHWHUD&9&UHXDODFDUUHWHUDLOD VHJXL[FDSDOQRUGILQVDDUULEDUDODSDUFHOāODGHOSROtJRQ*LUDFDSDO HVWVHJXLQWHOOtPLWVXGGHOHV SDUFHOāOHV L GHO SROtJRQ 'HVSUHVD JLUD FDS DO QRUG L FRQWLQXD SHO OtPLW (VWH GH OHV SDUFHOāOHVLGHO SROtJRQ,QFRUSRUDODVHQGDTXHYRUHMD HVWD ~OWLPD SDUFHOāOD SHO VHX OtPLW 1RUG ILQV D DUULEDU D OD SDUFHOāOD GHO SROtJRQ *LUD FDS DO QRUG YRUHMDQWHOOtPLWHVWGHOHVSDUFHOāOHVLGHOSROtJRQILQVDDUULEDUDOSXQWG RULJHQ $QWHFHGHQWHVDGPLQLVWUDWLYRVGHOLPLWDFLyQH[WUDtGDGHOH[SHGLHQWHGHILQLGDFRQFDUiFWHUSURYLVLRQDO 2ULJHQSXQWR$GHFRRUGHQDGDVJHRJUiILFDV870; < 6HQWLGRDQWLKRUDULR /tQHDGHOLPLWDGRUDGHVGHHORULJHQSXQWR$ODOtQHDGHGHOLPLWDFLyQVLJXHHO&DPtGH&DVWHOOIRUWD0RUHOODH LQFOX\H pVWH HQ HO HQWRUQR GH SURWHFFLyQ HQ HO WUDPR TXH ERUGHD ODV SDUFHODV \ GHO SROtJRQR KDVWD VX HQFXHQWUR FRQ HO EDUUDQFR GHO 0DV GHO 5LX &UX]D HO FDPLQR \ FRQWLQ~D SRU HO EDUUDQFRKDFLDHOVXUHQHOWUDPRTXHERUGHDODVSDUFHODV\GHOSROtJRQR *LUDKDFLDHOQRURHVWH\ERUGHDODSDUFHOD GHOSROtJRQR KDVWD OD FDUUHWHUD &9 &UX]D pVWD \ OD VLJXHKDFLDHOVXGHVWHKDVWDOOHJDUDODSDUFHODGHO SROtJRQR*LUDKDFLDHOVXGRHVWH ERUGHDQGR ODV SDUFHODV\GHOSROtJRQRKDVWDOOHJDUDXQDSLVWDDVIDOWDGD&UX]DODSLVWD\ERUGHDODVSDUFHODV \KDVWDOOHJDUDXQDVHQGD'HVGHDKtFRQWLQ~DKDFLDHOVXUSRUGLFKDVHQGDTXHOLPLWDFRQODVSDUFHODV \ GHO SROtJRQR &UX]D OD VHQGD \ ERUGHD HVWD ~OWLPD SDUFHOD KDVWD OOHJDU D OD FDUUHWHUD&9&UX]DODFDUUHWHUD\ODVLJXHKDFLDHOQRUWHKDVWDOOHJDUDODSDUFHODGHOSROtJRQR *LUD KDFLD HO HVWH VLJXLHQGR HO OtPLWH VXU GH ODV SDUFHODV \ GHO SROtJRQR 'HVSXpV JLUD KDFLDHOQRUWH\FRQWLQ~DSRUHOOtPLWHHVWHGHODVSDUFHODV\ GHO SROtJRQR ,QFRUSRUD OD VHQGD TXH ERUGHD HVWD ~OWLPD SDUFHOD SRU VX OtPLWH QRUWH KDVWD OOHJDU D OD SDUFHOD GHO SROtJRQR *LUD KDFLD HO QRUWH ERUGHDQGR HO OtPLWH HVWH GH ODV SDUFHODV \ GHO SROtJRQRKDVWDOOHJDUDOSXQWRGHRULJHQ $11(;,9$1(;2,9 GH 5HVROXFLyGHG DEULOGHOD'LUHFFLy*HQHUDOGH3DWULPRQL&XOWXUDO9DOHQFLjL0XVHXVGHOD&RQVHOOHULDGH&XOWXUD(GXFDFLyL(VSRUWSHUODTXHV LQFRDH[SHGLHQWSHUDOD SULPHUD IDVH GH O DFWXDOLW]DFLy L DGDSWDFLy SDUFLDO GH OD 6HFFLy 3ULPHUD GH O ,QYHQWDUL *HQHUDO GHO 3DWULPRQL &XOWXUDO 9DOHQFLj HQ PDWqULD GH SDWULPRQL DUTXLWHFWzQLF L PHGLDPELHQWDOLV¶REULSHUtRGHG¶LQIRUPDFLyS~EOLFD 5HVROXFLyQGHGHDEULOGHOD'LUHFFLyQ*HQHUDOGH3DWULPRQLR&XOWXUDO9DOHQFLDQR\ 0XVHRV GH OD &RQVHOOHULD GH &XOWXUD (GXFDFLyQ \ 'HSRUWH SRU OD TXH VH LQFRDH[SHGLHQWHSDUDODSULPHUDIDVHGHODDFWXDOL]DFLyQ\DGDSWDFLyQSDUFLDOGHOD6HFFLyQ3ULPHUDGHO,QYHQWDULR*HQHUDOGHO3DWULPRQLR&XOWXUDO9DOHQFLDQRHQPDWHULD GHSDWULPRQLRDUTXLWHFWyQLFR\PHGLRDPELHQWDO\VHDEUHSHULRGRGHLQIRUPDFLyQSXEOLFD Núm. 5.503 / 02.05.2007 17894 (Q OD SODQWD VXSHULRU VH GLVWULEX\HQ ODV DOFREDV \ XQD VDOD TXH VH DGRUQD FRQ XQD FDUWHOD HQ OD TXH VH UHSUHVHQWDQODVOODYHVGH63HGUR\ODIHFKDHQODYHQWDQDDSDUHFHODIHFKD 7UDVHOiEVLGHVHHQFXHQWUDHODOMLEHFXELHUWRFRQEyYHGDGHFDxyQFRQVWUXLGDHQSLHGUDHQVHFR 2EVHUYDFLRQHV2EVHUYDFLRQHV (QWRUQ(QWRUQR $QWHFHGHQWVDGPLQLVWUDWLXVGHOLPLWDFLyH[WUHWDGHO H[SHGLHQWGHILQLGDDPEFDUjFWHUSURYLVLRQDO 2ULJHQSXQW$GHFRRUGHQDGHVJHRJUjILTXHV870; < 6HQWLWDQWLKRUDUL /tQLD GHOLPLWDGRUD GHV GH O RULJHQ SXQW $ OD OtQLD GH GHOLPLWDFLy VHJXL[ HO &DPt GH &DVWHOOIRUW D 0RUHOOD L O¶LQFORXHQO HQWRUQGHSURWHFFLyHQHOWUDPTXHYRUHMDOHVSDUFHOāOHVLGHOSROtJRQ ILQVDODVHXDWUREDGDDPEHO%DUUDQFGHO0DVGHO5LX&UHXDHOFDPtLFRQWLQXDSHOEDUUDQFFDSDOVXGHQHO WUDPTXHYRUHMDOHVSDUFHOāOHVLGHOSROtJRQ*LUDFDSDOQRUGRHVWLYRUHMD ODSDUFHOāODGHOSROtJRQILQVDODFDUUHWHUD&9&UHXDHVWDLODVHJXL[FDSDOVXGHVWILQVDDUULEDU DODSDUFHOāODGHOSROtJRQ*LUDFDSDOVXGRHVWYRUHMDQWOHVSDUFHOāOHVLGHOSROtJRQILQVD DUULEDUDXQDSLVWDDVIDOWDGD&UHXDODSLVWDLYRUHMDOHVSDUFHOāOHVLILQVDDUULEDUDXQDVHQGD'HV G DFtFRQWLQXDFDSDOVXGSHUODGLWDVHQGDTXHOLPLWDDPEOHVSDUFHOāOHVLGHOSROtJRQ &UHXDODVHQGDLYRUHMDHVWD~OWLPDSDUFHOāODILQVDDUULEDUDODFDUUHWHUD&9&UHXDODFDUUHWHUDLOD VHJXL[FDSDOQRUGILQVDDUULEDUDODSDUFHOāODGHOSROtJRQ*LUDFDSDO HVWVHJXLQWHOOtPLWVXGGHOHV SDUFHOāOHV L GHO SROtJRQ 'HVSUHVD JLUD FDS DO QRUG L FRQWLQXD SHO OtPLW (VWH GH OHV SDUFHOāOHVLGHO SROtJRQ,QFRUSRUDODVHQGDTXHYRUHMD HVWD ~OWLPD SDUFHOāOD SHO VHX OtPLW 1RUG ILQV D DUULEDU D OD SDUFHOāOD GHO SROtJRQ *LUD FDS DO QRUG YRUHMDQWHOOtPLWHVWGHOHVSDUFHOāOHVLGHOSROtJRQILQVDDUULEDUDOSXQWG RULJHQ $QWHFHGHQWHVDGPLQLVWUDWLYRVGHOLPLWDFLyQH[WUDtGDGHOH[SHGLHQWHGHILQLGDFRQFDUiFWHUSURYLVLRQDO 2ULJHQSXQWR$GHFRRUGHQDGDVJHRJUiILFDV870; < 6HQWLGRDQWLKRUDULR /tQHDGHOLPLWDGRUDGHVGHHORULJHQSXQWR$ODOtQHDGHGHOLPLWDFLyQVLJXHHO&DPtGH&DVWHOOIRUWD0RUHOODH LQFOX\H pVWH HQ HO HQWRUQR GH SURWHFFLyQ HQ HO WUDPR TXH ERUGHD ODV SDUFHODV \ GHO SROtJRQR KDVWD VX HQFXHQWUR FRQ HO EDUUDQFR GHO 0DV GHO 5LX &UX]D HO FDPLQR \ FRQWLQ~D SRU HO EDUUDQFRKDFLDHOVXUHQHOWUDPRTXHERUGHDODVSDUFHODV\GHOSROtJRQR *LUDKDFLDHOQRURHVWH\ERUGHDODSDUFHOD GHOSROtJRQR KDVWD OD FDUUHWHUD &9 &UX]D pVWD \ OD VLJXHKDFLDHOVXGHVWHKDVWDOOHJDUDODSDUFHODGHO SROtJRQR*LUDKDFLDHOVXGRHVWH ERUGHDQGR ODV SDUFHODV\GHOSROtJRQRKDVWDOOHJDUDXQDSLVWDDVIDOWDGD&UX]DODSLVWD\ERUGHDODVSDUFHODV \KDVWDOOHJDUDXQDVHQGD'HVGHDKtFRQWLQ~DKDFLDHOVXUSRUGLFKDVHQGDTXHOLPLWDFRQODVSDUFHODV \ GHO SROtJRQR &UX]D OD VHQGD \ ERUGHD HVWD ~OWLPD SDUFHOD KDVWD OOHJDU D OD FDUUHWHUD&9&UX]DODFDUUHWHUD\ODVLJXHKDFLDHOQRUWHKDVWDOOHJDUDODSDUFHODGHOSROtJRQR *LUD KDFLD HO HVWH VLJXLHQGR HO OtPLWH VXU GH ODV SDUFHODV \ GHO SROtJRQR 'HVSXpV JLUD KDFLDHOQRUWH\FRQWLQ~DSRUHOOtPLWHHVWHGHODVSDUFHODV\ GHO SROtJRQR ,QFRUSRUD OD VHQGD TXH ERUGHD HVWD ~OWLPD SDUFHOD SRU VX OtPLWH QRUWH KDVWD OOHJDU D OD SDUFHOD GHO SROtJRQR *LUD KDFLD HO QRUWH ERUGHDQGR HO OtPLWH HVWH GH ODV SDUFHODV \ GHO SROtJRQRKDVWDOOHJDUDOSXQWRGHRULJHQ $11(;,9$1(;2,9 GH 5HVROXFLyGHG DEULOGHOD'LUHFFLy*HQHUDOGH3DWULPRQL&XOWXUDO9DOHQFLjL0XVHXVGHOD&RQVHOOHULDGH&XOWXUD(GXFDFLyL(VSRUWSHUODTXHV LQFRDH[SHGLHQWSHUDOD SULPHUD IDVH GH O DFWXDOLW]DFLy L DGDSWDFLy SDUFLDO GH OD 6HFFLy 3ULPHUD GH O ,QYHQWDUL *HQHUDO GHO 3DWULPRQL &XOWXUDO 9DOHQFLj HQ PDWqULD GH SDWULPRQL DUTXLWHFWzQLF L PHGLDPELHQWDOLV¶REULSHUtRGHG¶LQIRUPDFLyS~EOLFD 5HVROXFLyQGHGHDEULOGHOD'LUHFFLyQ*HQHUDOGH3DWULPRQLR&XOWXUDO9DOHQFLDQR\ 0XVHRV GH OD &RQVHOOHULD GH &XOWXUD (GXFDFLyQ \ 'HSRUWH SRU OD TXH VH LQFRDH[SHGLHQWHSDUDODSULPHUDIDVHGHODDFWXDOL]DFLyQ\DGDSWDFLyQSDUFLDOGHOD6HFFLyQ3ULPHUDGHO,QYHQWDULR*HQHUDOGHO3DWULPRQLR&XOWXUDO9DOHQFLDQRHQPDWHULD GHSDWULPRQLRDUTXLWHFWyQLFR\PHGLRDPELHQWDO\VHDEUHSHULRGRGHLQIRUPDFLyQSXEOLFD Núm. 5.503 / 02.05.2007 17895 %e'¶,17(5e6&8/785$/±$-817$0(17'(&$67(//Ï'(/$3/$1$&$67(//Ï'(/$3/$1$ &$67(//Ï1'(/$3/$1$02180(17 %,(1'(,17(5e6&8/785$/$<817$0,(172'(&$67(//Ï1'(/$3/$1$&$67(//Ï'(/$ 3/$1$&$67(//Ï1'(/$3/$1$02180(172 'HQRPLQDFLy'HQRPLQDFLyQ 3ULQFLSDO3ULQFLSDO $MXQWDPHQWGH&DVWHOOyGHOD3ODQD $\XQWDPLHQWRGH&DVWHOOyQGHOD3ODQD $FFHVzULD$FFHVRULD &DVD$MXQWDPHQW &DVD$\XQWDPLHQWR /RFDOL]DFLy/RFDOL]DFLyQ 3URYtQFLD3URYLQFLD&DVWHOOy &RPDUFD&RPDUFD/D3ODQD$OWD 0XQLFLSL0XQLFLSLR&DVWHOOyGHOD3ODQD &DVWHOOyQGHOD3ODQD 8ELFDFLy8ELFDFLyQ3ODoD0DMRU 5HIHUqQFLD&DGDVWUDO5HIHUHQFLD&DWDVWUDO ,OOD0DQ]DQD3DUFHOāOD3DUFHOD $QWHFHGHQWV-XUtGLFV$QWHFHGHQWHV-XUtGLFRV ,QFRDFLy,QFRDFLyQ5HVROXFLyGHG¶DJRVWGHGHOD'LUHFFLy*HQHUDOGH3DWULPRQL$UWtVWLF 3XEOLFDFLyGHODLQFRDFLy3XEOLFDFLyQGHODLQFRDFLyQ'2*9 'HVFULSFLy'HVFULSFLyQ 3DUWV,QWHJUDQWV3DUWHV,QWHJUDQWHV − 3ULPHUDFUXJLDSRU[DGDLOHVVHXHVIDoDQHV3ULPHUDFUXMtDSRUWLFDGD\VXVIDFKDGDV − (PEROFDOOYROXPqWULFGHOFRQMXQWGHO¶LOOD(QYROYHQWHYROXPpWULFDGHVXPDQ]DQD 'HVFULSFLy*HQHUDO'HVFULSFLyQ*HQHUDO / $MXQWDPHQW HV WURED HQ OD 3ODoD 0DMRU (V YD FRPHQoDU D DOoDU D ILQDOV GHO VHJOH ;9,, 9D VXEVWLWXLU O DQWLJD&DVDGHOD9LODTXHV KDYLDTXHGDW[LFRWHWDLHVWUREDYDHQPDOHVWDW(QHVYDQHQFDUUHJDUOHV WUDFHV DO PHVWUH *LO 7RUUDOED GRV DQ\V PpV WDUG FRQWLQXHQ OHV REUHV DPE HO PHVWUH 0HOFKRU 6HUUDQR $OFD]DU &ODUHW L -RVp 6HUUDQR 9D VHU LQDXJXUDW HQ $ O H[WHULRU O DOoDW SULQFLSDO HV FRQILJXUD HQ WUHV FRVVRV VHSDUDWV SHU FRUQLVHV /D SODQWD EDL[D V RUJDQLW]D DPE XQ SzUWLF GH FLQF DUFV GH PLJ SXQW VREUH SLODVWUHVG RUGHWRVFjLDOWUHVGRVSzUWLFVXQHQFDGDODWHUDO/DSODQWDQREOHWpXQDGLYLVLyYHUWLFDOHQFLQF DPESLODVWUHVFRUtQWLHVDPEXQHQWDXODPHQWOOLV7pWUHVEDOFRQVHOFHQWUDOFRUUHJXWDPEFLQFYDQVFRURQDWV SHUIURQWRQVWULDQJXODUVSDUWLWVDPEXQUHPDWDGDSLUDPLGDOTXHV DOWHUQHQDPEIURQWRQVVHPLFLUFXODUVDPE GHFRUDFLyGHYHQHUHV(OWHUFHUFRVpVGHGLPHQVLRQVPpVUHGXwGHVLVHVHSDUDSHUXQDFRUQLVDYRODGD(V GLVWULEXw[DPEFLQFEDOFRQVVHQ]LOOVIODQTXHMDWVSHUSLODVWUHV/ HGLILFLHVUHPDWDDPEXQDEDOXVWUDGD$OOODUJ GHOV VHJOHV ;9,,, L ;,; HV YDQ VXFFHLU DPSOLDFLRQV L UHIRUPHV HQ O HGLILFL $ SULQFLSLV GHO VHJOH ;; HV YD FDQYLDUO DVSHFWHGHODIDoDQDVXEVWLWXLQWODUHL[HULDSHUEDOXVWUDGDLGHVSUpVGHODJXHUUDFLYLOHVYDWRUQDUD ODVHXDLPDWJHRULJLQDO/DSODQWDGHO HGLILFLYDVHUPRGLILFDGDHQODLQWHUYHQFLyGH%DVDWHQOD*XLD G $UTXLWHFWXUDGH&DVWHOOy (O $\XQWDPLHQWR VH HQFXHQWUD HQ OD SOD]D PD\RU 6H FRPHQ]y D OHYDQWDU D ILQDOHV GHO VLJOR ;9,, 9LQR D VXVWLWXLU D OD DQWLJXD &DVD GH OD 9LOD TXH VH KDEtD TXHGDGR SHTXHxD \ VH HQFRQWUDED HQ PDO HVWDGR (Q VH HQFDUJDURQ ODV WUD]DV DO PDHVWUR *LO 7RUUDOED GRV DxRV PiV WDUGH FRQWLQ~DQ ODV REUDV FRQ HO PDHVWUR 0HOFKRU 6HUUDQR $OFD]DU &ODUHW \ -RVp 6HUUDQR )XH LQDXJXUDGR HQ $O H[WHULRU HO DO]DGR SULQFLSDOVHFRQILJXUDHQWUHVFXHUSRVVHSDUDGRVSRUFRUQLVDV/DSODQWDEDMDVHRUJDQL]DFRQXQSyUWLFRGH FLQFRDUFRVGHPHGLR SXQWR VREUH SLODVWUDV GH RUGHQ WRVFDQR \ RWURV GRV XQR HQ FDGD ODWHUDO /D SODQWD QREOH WLHQH XQD GLYLVLyQ YHUWLFDO HQ FLQFR FRQ SLODVWUDV FRULQWLDV FRQ XQ HQWDEODPHQWR OLVR 7LHQH WUHV EDOFRQHVHOFHQWUDOFRUULGRFRQFLQFRYDQRVFRURQDGRVSRUIURQWRQHVWULDQJXODUHV SDUWLGRVFRQXQUHPDWH SLUDPLGDOTXHVHDOWHUQDQFRQIURQWRQHVVHPLFLUFXODUHVFRQGHFRUDFLyQGHYHQHUDV(OWHUFHUFXHUSRHV GH GLPHQVLRQHV PiV UHGXFLGDV VH VHSDUD SRU XQD FRUQLVD YRODGD 6H GLVWULEX\H FRQ FLQFR EDOFRQHV VHQFLOORV IODQTXHDGRV SRU SLODVWUDV (O HGLILFLR UHPDWD FRQ XQD EDODXVWUDGD $ OR ODUJR GH ORV VLJORV ;9,,, \ ;,; VH VXFHGLHURQ DPSOLDFLRQHV \ UHIRUPDV HQ HO HGLILFLR $ SULQFLSLRV GHO VLJOR ;; VH FDPELy HO DVSHFWR GH OD IDFKDGD VXVWLWX\HQGR OD UHMHUtD SRU EDODXVWUDV YROYLpQGRVH D VX LPDJHQ RULJLQDO WUDV OD JXHUUD FLYLO /D $11(;,9$1(;2,9 GH 5HVROXFLyGHG DEULOGHOD'LUHFFLy*HQHUDOGH3DWULPRQL&XOWXUDO9DOHQFLjL0XVHXVGHOD&RQVHOOHULDGH&XOWXUD(GXFDFLyL(VSRUWSHUODTXHV LQFRDH[SHGLHQWSHUDOD SULPHUD IDVH GH O DFWXDOLW]DFLy L DGDSWDFLy SDUFLDO GH OD 6HFFLy 3ULPHUD GH O ,QYHQWDUL *HQHUDO GHO 3DWULPRQL &XOWXUDO 9DOHQFLj HQ PDWqULD GH SDWULPRQL DUTXLWHFWzQLF L PHGLDPELHQWDOLV¶REULSHUtRGHG¶LQIRUPDFLyS~EOLFD 5HVROXFLyQ GH GH DEULO GH OD 'LUHFFLyQ *HQHUDO GH 3DWULPRQLR &XOWXUDO 9DOHQFLDQR \ 0XVHRV GH OD &RQVHOOHULD GH &XOWXUD (GXFDFLyQ \ 'HSRUWH SRU OD TXH VH LQFRD H[SHGLHQWH SDUD OD SULPHUD IDVH GH OD DFWXDOL]DFLyQ \ DGDSWDFLyQ SDUFLDO GH OD 6HFFLyQ 3ULPHUD GHO ,QYHQWDULR *HQHUDO GHO 3DWULPRQLR &XOWXUDO 9DOHQFLDQR HQ PDWHULD GH SDWULPRQLRDUTXLWHFWyQLFR\PHGLRDPELHQWDO\VHDEUHSHULRGRGHLQIRUPDFLyQSXEOLFD Núm. 5.503 / 02.05.2007 17896 SODQWD GHO HGLILFLR IXH PRGLILFDGD HQ OD LQWHUYHQFLyQ GH %DVDGR HQ OD *XtD GH $UTXLWHFWXUD GH &DVWHOOy 2EVHUYDFLRQV2EVHUYDFLRQHV 6ROV V¶KL FRQVHUYD DPE YDORU PRQXPHQWDO OD SULPHUD FUXJLD L OHV FRUUHVSRQHQWV IDoDQHV TXH OD GHILQHL[HQ H[WHULRUPHQW 3UHFLVDPHQW OD OLPLWDFLy GHO VHX YDORU HQ VHQWLW UHSUHVHQWDWLX MXVWLILFD TXH FRPSDUWLVFD HQWRUQ XQLWDULDPEHO)DGUtOD/ORWMDGHO&jQHPLOHVSRUWDGHVGHOD&RQFDWHGUDO 8QLFDPHQWH VH FRQVHUYD FRQ YDORU PRQXPHQWDO OD SULPHUD FUXMtD \ ORV OLHQ]RV GH IDFKDGD FRQ TXH pVWD VH GHILQH H[WHULRUPHQWH 3UHFLVDPHQWH HVH OLPLWDGR YDORU GH UHSUHVHQWDFLyQ HV HO TXH OH KDFH FRPSDUWLU HQWRUQR XQLWDULRFRQDO)DGUtOD/ORWMDGHO&jQHP\ODVSRUWDGDVGHOD&RQFDWHGUDO (QWRUQ(QWRUQ $QWHFHGHQWVDGPLQLVWUDWLXVGHOLPLWDFLyH[WUHWDGHO H[SHGLHQWGHILQLGDDPEFDUjFWHUSURYLVLRQDO 2ULJHQLQWHUVHFFLyGHO HL[GHOFDUUHUGH&RORPLHOFDUUHUGH0HDOOD 6HQWLW+RUDUL /tQLDGHOLPLWDGRUD/DOtQLDUHFRUUHO HL[GHOFDUUHUGH0HDOODHQGLUHFFLyQRUGLJLUDSHOGHOFDUUHU&HUYDQWHVL GHVSUpVSHOGHOFDUUHUG¶$XVLHV0DUFK6 LQWURGXw[HQO¶LOODGHFDVHVHQWUHODPLWJHUDGHOHVSDUFHOāOHV LUHFRUUHOHVSRVWHULRUVGHOHVSDUFHOāOHVLLOD PLWJHUDQRUGGHODSDUFHOāOD$UULEDILQVO HL[ GHOFDUUHU0DMRULFRQWLQXDSHUHVWHILQVDOFDUUHUGHO¶DU[LSUHVWH0RVVpQ%DODJXHU*LUDDRHVWSHUO HL[G HVWH FDUUHU L SHO GH O¶(FFHKRPR ILQV WUDYHVVDU O¶LOOD GH FDVHV HQWUH OHV SDUFHOāOHV L L L SHU D FRQWLQXDUSHUODSRVWHULRUGHODSDUFHOāOD6HJXL[ILQVDO¶LOODLLQFRUSRUDOHVSDUFHOāOHVLG HVWD LOODLODIDoDQDGHODSDUFHOāODTXHGyQDDODSODoDGHOD3HVFDWHULD3URVVHJXL[ILQVD O HL[GHOFDUUHUGH -RVHS*DUFLDVHJXL[SHUO HL[G HVWHFDUUHULSHOGHOFDUUHUG¶(QPLJILQVDOGHOFDUUHUGH&RORPSHOTXDOVHJXL[ ILQVDOSXQWG RULJHQ $QWHFHGHQWHVDGPLQLVWUDWLYRVGHOLPLWDFLyQH[WUDtGDGHOH[SHGLHQWHGHILQLGDFRQFDUiFWHUSURYLVLRQDO 2ULJHQLQWHUVHFFLyQGHOHMHGHODFDOOH&ROyQ\ODFDOOH0HDOOD 6HQWLGR+RUDULR /tQHD GHOLPLWDGRUD /D OtQHD UHFRUUH HO HMH GH OD FDOOH 0HDOOD HQ GLUHFFLyQ QRUWH \ JLUD SRU HO GH OD FDOOH &HUYDQWHV\OXHJRSRUHOGHODFDOOH$XVLDV0DUFK6HLQWURGXFHHQODPDQ]DQDHQWUHODPHGLDQHUDGH ODV SDUFHODV \ UHFRUUH ODV WUDVHUDV GH ODV SDUFHODV \ \ OD PHGLDQHUD QRUWH GH OD SDUFHOD /OHJD KDVWD HO HMH GH OD FDOOH 0DMRU \ FRQWLQ~D SRU pVWH KDVWD OD FDOOH $UFLSUHVWH 0RVpQ %DODJXHU *LUD D RHVWHSRUHOHMHGHHVWDFDOOH\SRUODFDOH(FFH+RPRKDVWDDWUDYHVDUODPDQ]DQDHQWUHODVSDUFHODV \\\SDUDFRQWLQXDUSRUODWUDVHUDGHODSDUFHOD6LJXHKDVWDODPDQ]DQDHLQFRUSRUD ODVSDUFHODV\GHHVWDPDQ]DQD\ODIDFKDGDGHODSDUFHODUHFD\HQWHDODSOD]DGHOD3HVFDGHUtD 3URVLJXHKDVWDHOHMHGHODFDOOH-RVp*DUFtDVLJXHSRUHOHMHGHHVWDFDOOH\SRUHOGHODFDOOH(QPLJKDVWDHO GHODFDOOH&ROyQSRUHOTXHVLJXHKDVWDHOSXQWRGHRULJHQ $11(;,9$1(;2,9 GH 5HVROXFLyGHG DEULOGHOD'LUHFFLy*HQHUDOGH3DWULPRQL&XOWXUDO9DOHQFLjL0XVHXVGHOD&RQVHOOHULDGH&XOWXUD(GXFDFLyL(VSRUWSHUODTXHV LQFRDH[SHGLHQWSHUDOD SULPHUD IDVH GH O DFWXDOLW]DFLy L DGDSWDFLy SDUFLDO GH OD 6HFFLy 3ULPHUD GH O ,QYHQWDUL *HQHUDO GHO 3DWULPRQL &XOWXUDO 9DOHQFLj HQ PDWqULD GH SDWULPRQL DUTXLWHFWzQLF L PHGLDPELHQWDOLV¶REULSHUtRGHG¶LQIRUPDFLyS~EOLFD 5HVROXFLyQ GH GH DEULO GH OD 'LUHFFLyQ *HQHUDO GH 3DWULPRQLR &XOWXUDO 9DOHQFLDQR \ 0XVHRV GH OD &RQVHOOHULD GH &XOWXUD (GXFDFLyQ \ 'HSRUWH SRU OD TXH VH LQFRD H[SHGLHQWH SDUD OD SULPHUD IDVH GH OD DFWXDOL]DFLyQ \ DGDSWDFLyQ SDUFLDO GH OD 6HFFLyQ 3ULPHUD GHO ,QYHQWDULR *HQHUDO GHO 3DWULPRQLR &XOWXUDO 9DOHQFLDQR HQ PDWHULD GH SDWULPRQLRDUTXLWHFWyQLFR\PHGLRDPELHQWDO\VHDEUHSHULRGRGHLQIRUPDFLyQSXEOLFD Núm. 5.503 / 02.05.2007 17897 %e'¶,17(5e6&8/785$/±$-817$0(17'(&$67(//Ï'(/$3/$1$&$67(//Ï'(/$3/$1$ &$67(//Ï1'(/$3/$1$02180(17 %,(1'(,17(5e6&8/785$/$<817$0,(172'(&$67(//Ï1'(/$3/$1$&$67(//Ï'(/$ 3/$1$&$67(//Ï1'(/$3/$1$02180(172 $11(;,9$1(;2,9 GH 5HVROXFLyGHG DEULOGHOD'LUHFFLy*HQHUDOGH3DWULPRQL&XOWXUDO9DOHQFLjL0XVHXVGHOD&RQVHOOHULDGH&XOWXUD(GXFDFLyL(VSRUWSHUODTXHV LQFRDH[SHGLHQWSHUDOD SULPHUD IDVH GH O DFWXDOLW]DFLy L DGDSWDFLy SDUFLDO GH OD 6HFFLy 3ULPHUD GH O ,QYHQWDUL *HQHUDO GHO 3DWULPRQL &XOWXUDO 9DOHQFLj HQ PDWqULD GH SDWULPRQL DUTXLWHFWzQLF L PHGLDPELHQWDOLV¶REULSHUtRGHG¶LQIRUPDFLyS~EOLFD 5HVROXFLyQ GH GH DEULO GH OD 'LUHFFLyQ *HQHUDO GH 3DWULPRQLR &XOWXUDO 9DOHQFLDQR \ 0XVHRV GH OD &RQVHOOHULD GH &XOWXUD (GXFDFLyQ \ 'HSRUWH SRU OD TXH VH LQFRD H[SHGLHQWH SDUD OD SULPHUD IDVH GH OD DFWXDOL]DFLyQ \ DGDSWDFLyQ SDUFLDO GH OD 6HFFLyQ 3ULPHUD GHO ,QYHQWDULR *HQHUDO GHO 3DWULPRQLR &XOWXUDO 9DOHQFLDQR HQ PDWHULD GH SDWULPRQLRDUTXLWHFWyQLFR\PHGLRDPELHQWDO\VHDEUHSHULRGRGHLQIRUPDFLyQSXEOLFD Núm. 5.503 / 02.05.2007 17898 %e'¶,17(5e6&8/785$//$//27-$'(/&¬1(0&$67(//Ï'(/$3/$1$&$67(//Ï1'(/$ 3/$1$02180(17 %,(1'(,17(5e6&8/785$//$/21-$'(/&Èf$02&$67(//Ï'(/$3/$1$&$67(//Ï1'(/$ 3/$1$02180(172 'HQRPLQDFLy'HQRPLQDFLyQ 3ULQFLSDO3ULQFLSDO /D/ORWMDGHO&jQHP /D/RQMDGHO&jQHP&ixDPR /RFDOLW]DFLy/RFDOL]DFLyQ 3URYtQFLD3URYLQFLD&DVWHOOy &RPDUFD&RPDUFD/D3ODQD$OWD 0XQLFLSL0XQLFLSLR&DVWHOOyGHOD3ODQD&DVWHOOyQGHOD 3ODQD 8ELFDFLy8ELFDFLyQ&DUUHUGH&DYDOOHUV 5HIHUqQFLD&DGDVWUDO5HIHUHQFLD&DWDVWUDO ,OOD0DQ]DQD3DUFHOāOD3DUFHOD $QWHFHGHQWV-XUtGLFV$QWHFHGHQWHV-XUtGLFRV ,QFRDFLy,QFRDFLyQ5HVROXFLyGHG¶DJRVWGHGHOD'LUHFFLy*HQHUDOGH3DWULPRQL$UWtVWLF 3XEOLFDFLyGHODLQFRDFLy3XEOLFDFLyQGHODLQFRDFLyQ'2*9 'HVFULSFLy'HVFULSFLyQ 3DUWVLQWHJUDQWV3DUWHV,QWHJUDQWHV − (OFRVGHOD/ORWMDSULPLWLYD(OFXHUSRGHOD/RQMDSULPLWLYD − /¶DPSOLDFLyYXLWFHQWLVWD/DDPSOLDFLyQGHFLPRQyQLFD 'HVFULSFLy*HQHUDO'HVFULSFLyQ*HQHUDO (VWHHGLILFLHVWUREDHQHOFHQWUHGHODFLXWDWSUz[LPDODSODoD0DMRU /D/ORWMDHVYDDOoDUHQHOSULPHUWHUoGHOVHJOH;9,,(O&RQVHOOGHODFLXWDWYDFRPSUDUOD&DVD*XPEDXTXH YD VHU HQGHUURFDGD HQ SHU D FRQVWUXLU HO QRX HGLILFL UHDOLW]DW SHU )UDQFHVF *DOLDQoD (V WUDFWD G XQ HGLILFL GH SODQWD TXDGUDQJXODU REHUW SHOV FRVWDWV H[HPSWV DPE GRV DUFV TXH HV UHFRO]HQ HQ FROXPQHV L VHPLFROXPQHVG RUGHWRVFj/ ~QLFHOHPHQWHVFXOWzULFO HVFXWGHODYLODHVWUREDHQWUHOHVHL[XWHVGHOVDUFV GHOFDUUHUGH&RORP/DIjEULFDGHO HGLILFLpVGHFDUUHXV$SULQFLSLVGHOVHJOH;,;O DMXQWDPHQWYDYHQGUHHO GUHWGHFRQVWUXLUXQSLVVXSHULRU7DPEpHVYDGXUDWHUPHO DPSOLDFLyGHOSLVLQIHULRUSHUDPEGyVFRVWDWV XWLOLW]DQWVHHOPDWHL[PDWHULDOLOOHQJXDWJHDUTXLWHFWzQLF(OSLVVXSHULRUV RUGHQDDPEILQHVWUDOVUHFWDQJXODUV DPEIURQWRQVFRUEVDVVHQWDWVHQPqQVXOHVVREUH HOV TXDOV VH VLWXHQ XQV zFXOV HOāOtSWLFV 'HVWDFD HO EDOFy FRUUHJXW HQ FDQWy GH UHL[HULD (V WHQHQ QRWtFLHV TXH OD IDoDQD G HVWH SLV YD HVWDU SLQWDGD DPE SLQWXUHV DOāOHJzULTXHVG 2OLHW(OFRQMXQWHVFRURQDDPEXQDFRUQLVDFOjVVLFDDPEIUHVFRVLXQDEDUDQDUHPDWDGDSHU JHUURQV/DUHVWDXUDFLyGHO¶HGLILFLYDFRPHQoDUO¶DQ\LFRQWLQXDGXUDQWO¶DQ\VHJRQVSURMHFWHGH 0LJXHOGHO5H\%DVDWHQOD*XLDG $UTXLWHFWXUDGH&DVWHOOyL$QWLJXLWDWVGH&DVWHOOyGHOD3ODQDGH97UDYHU (QHOFHQWURGHODFLXGDG FHUFDQR D OD SOD]D 0D\RU VH HQFXHQWUD HVWH HGLILFLR /D /RQMD VH OHYDQWy HQ HO SULPHUWHUFLRGHOVLJOR;9,,SDUDHOORHO&RQVHOOGHODFLXGDGFRPSUyOD&DVD*XPEDXTXHIXHGHUULEDGDHQ SDUD FRQVWUXLU HO QXHYR HGLILFLR UHDOL]DGR SRU )UDQFHVF *DOLDQoD 6H WUDWD GH XQ HGLILFLR GH SODQWD FXDGUDQJXODU DELHUWR SRU ORV ODGRV H[HQWRV FRQ GRV DUFRV TXH DSR\DQ HQ FROXPQDV \ VHPLFROXPQDV GH RUGHQ WRVFDQR (O ~QLFR HOHPHQWR HVFXOWyULFR HO HVFXGR GH OD YLOOD VH HQFXHQWUD HQWUH ODV HQMXWDV GH ORV DUFRVGHODFDOOH&ROyQ/DIiEULFDGHOHGLILFLRHVGHVLOOHUtD$SULQFLSLRVGHOVLJOR;,;HOD\XQWDPLHQWRYHQGLy HOGHUHFKRGHFRQVWUXLUXQSLVRVXSHULRU7DPELpQVHOOHYyDFDERODDPSOLDFLyQGHOSLVRLQIHULRUSRUDPERV ODGRVXWLOL]iQGRVHHOPLVPRPDWHULDO \ OHQJXDMH DUTXLWHFWyQLFR (O SLVR VXSHULRU VH RUGHQD FRQ YHQWDQDOHV UHFWDQJXODUHV FRQ IURQWRQHV FXUYRV DVHQWDGRV HQ PpQVXODV VREUH ORV TXH VLW~DQ XQRV yFXORV HOtSWLFRV 'HVWDFDHO EDOFyQ FRUULGR HQ HVTXLQD GH UHMHUtD 6H WLHQHQ QRWLFLDV GH TXH OD IDFKDGD GH HVWH SLVR HVWXYR SLQWDGD FRQ SLQWXUDV DOHJyULFDV GH 2OLHW (O FRQMXQWR VH FRURQD FRQ XQD FRUQLVD FOiVLFD FRQ RYDV \ XQ DQWHSHFKR UHPDWDGR SRU MDUURQHV /D UHVWDXUDFLyQ GHO HGLILFLR FRPHQ]y HQ FRQWLQXiQGRVH HQ VHJ~Q SUR\HFWR GH 0LJXHO GHO 5H\ %DVDGR HQ OD *XtD GH $UTXLWHFWXUD GH &DVWHOOyQ \ $QWLJHGDGHV GH &DVWHOOyQGHOD3ODQDGH97UDYHU $11(;,9$1(;2,9 GH 5HVROXFLyGHG DEULOGHOD'LUHFFLy*HQHUDOGH3DWULPRQL&XOWXUDO9DOHQFLjL0XVHXVGHOD&RQVHOOHULDGH&XOWXUD(GXFDFLyL(VSRUWSHUODTXHV LQFRDH[SHGLHQWSHUDOD SULPHUD IDVH GH O DFWXDOLW]DFLy L DGDSWDFLy SDUFLDO GH OD 6HFFLy 3ULPHUD GH O ,QYHQWDUL *HQHUDO GHO 3DWULPRQL &XOWXUDO 9DOHQFLj HQ PDWqULD GH SDWULPRQL DUTXLWHFWzQLF L PHGLDPELHQWDOLV¶REULSHUtRGHG¶LQIRUPDFLyS~EOLFD 5HVROXFLyQ GH GH DEULO GH OD 'LUHFFLyQ *HQHUDO GH 3DWULPRQLR &XOWXUDO 9DOHQFLDQR \ 0XVHRV GH OD &RQVHOOHULD GH &XOWXUD (GXFDFLyQ \ 'HSRUWH SRU OD TXH VH LQFRD H[SHGLHQWH SDUD OD SULPHUD IDVH GH OD DFWXDOL]DFLyQ \ DGDSWDFLyQ SDUFLDO GH OD 6HFFLyQ 3ULPHUD GHO ,QYHQWDULR *HQHUDO GHO 3DWULPRQLR &XOWXUDO 9DOHQFLDQR HQ PDWHULD GH SDWULPRQLRDUTXLWHFWyQLFR\PHGLRDPELHQWDO\VHDEUHSHULRGRGHLQIRUPDFLyQSXEOLFD Núm. 5.503 / 02.05.2007 17899 2EVHUYDFLRQV2EVHUYDFLRQHV (Q SDUWLFLSDU G¶XQ PDWHL[ jPELW PRQXPHQWDO UHSUHVHQWDWLX GH OD FLXWDW FRPSDUWHL[ HQWRUQ XQLWDUL DPE O¶$MXQWDPHQWHO)DGUtLOHVSRUWDGHVGHOD&RQFDWHGUDO $OSDUWLFLSDUGHXQPLVPRiPELWRPRQXPHQWDOUHSUHVHQWDWLYRGH ODFLXGDGFRPSDUWHHQWRUQRXQLWDULRFRQ HO$\XQWDPLHQWRHO)DGUt\ODVSRUWDGDVGHOD&RQFDWHGUDO (QWRUQ(QWRUQR $QWHFHGHQWVDGPLQLVWUDWLXVGHOLPLWDFLyH[WUHWDGHO H[SHGLHQWGHILQLGDDPEFDUjFWHUSURYLVLRQDO 2ULJHQLQWHUVHFFLyGHO HL[GHOFDUUHU&RORPLHOFDUUHU0HDOOD 6HQWLW+RUDUL /tQLD GHOLPLWDGRUD /D OtQLD UHFRUUH O HL[ GHO FDUUHU GH 0HDOOD HQ GLUHFFLy QRUG L JLUD SHO GHO FDUUHU GH &HUYDQWHVLGHVSUpVSHOGHOFDUUHUG¶$XVLHV0DUFK6 LQWURGXw[HQO¶LOODGHFDVHVHQWUHODPLWJHUDGHOHV SDUFHOāOHVLUHFRUUHOHVSRVWHULRUVGHOHVSDUFHOāOHVLLODPLWJHUDQRUGGHODSDUFHOāOD$UULED ILQVO HL[GHOFDUUHU0DMRULFRQWLQXDSHUHVWHILQVDOFDUUHU GHO¶DU[LSUHVWH0RVVpQ%DODJXHU*LUDDRHVWSHU O HL[G HVWHFDUUHULSHOFDUUHUGHO¶(FFHKRPRILQVWUDYHVVDUO¶LOODHQWUHOHVSDUFHOāOHVLLL SHUDFRQWLQXDUSHUODSRVWHULRUGHODSDUFHOāOD6HJXL[ILQVDO¶LOODLLQFRUSRUDOHVSDUFHOāOHVL G HVWDLOODLODIDoDQDGHODSDUFHOāODTXHGyQDDODSODoDGHOD3HVFDWHULD3URVVHJXL[ILQVDO HL[GHOFDUUHU GH-RVHS*DUFLDVHJXL[SHUO HL[ G HVWHFDUUHUL SHOGHOFDUUHUG¶(QPLJILQV DO GHOFDUUHUGH&RORP SHOTXDO VHJXL[ILQVDOSXQWG RULJHQ $QWHFHGHQWHVDGPLQLVWUDWLYRVGHOLPLWDFLyQH[WUDtGDGHOH[SHGLHQWHGHILQLGDFRQFDUiFWHUSURYLVLRQDO 2ULJHQLQWHUVHFFLyQGHOHMHGHODFDOOH&ROyQ\ODFDOOH0HDOOD 6HQWLGR+RUDULR /tQHD GHOLPLWDGRUD /D OtQHD UHFRUUH HO HMH GH OD FDOOH 0HDOOD HQ GLUHFFLyQ QRUWH \ JLUD SRU HO GH OD FDOOH &HUYDQWHV\OXHJRSRUHOGHODFDOOH$XVLHV0DUFK6HLQWURGXFHHQODPDQ]DQDHQWUHODPHGLDQHUDGH ODV SDUFHODV \ UHFRUUH ODV WUDVHUDV GH ODV SDUFHODV \ \ OD PHGLDQHUD QRUWH GH OD SDUFHOD /OHJD KDVWD HO HMH GH OD FDOOH 0DMRU \ FRQWLQ~D SRU pVWH KDVWD OD FDOOH $UFLSUHVWH 0RVpQ %DODJXHU *LUD D RHVWHSRUHOHMHGHHVWDFDOOH\SRUODFDOOH(FFH+RPRKDVWDDWUDYHVDUODPDQ]DQDHQWUHODVSDUFHODV \\\SDUDFRQWLQXDUSRUODWUDVHUDGHODSDUFHOD6LJXHKDVWDODPDQ]DQDHLQFRUSRUD ODVSDUFHODV\GHHVWDPDQ]DQD\ODIDFKDGDGHODSDUFHODUHFD\HQWHDODSOD]DGHOD3HVFDGHUtD 3URVLJXHKDVWDHOHMHGHODFDOOH-RVp*DUFtDVLJXHSRUHOHMHGHHVWDFDOOH\SRUHOGHODFDOOH(QPLJKDVWDHO GHODFDOOH&ROyQSRUHOTXHVLJXHKDVWDHOSXQWRGHRULJHQ $11(;,9$1(;2,9 GH 5HVROXFLyGHG DEULOGHOD'LUHFFLy*HQHUDOGH3DWULPRQL&XOWXUDO9DOHQFLjL0XVHXVGHOD&RQVHOOHULDGH&XOWXUD(GXFDFLyL(VSRUWSHUODTXHV LQFRDH[SHGLHQWSHUDOD SULPHUD IDVH GH O DFWXDOLW]DFLy L DGDSWDFLy SDUFLDO GH OD 6HFFLy 3ULPHUD GH O ,QYHQWDUL *HQHUDO GHO 3DWULPRQL &XOWXUDO 9DOHQFLj HQ PDWqULD GH SDWULPRQL DUTXLWHFWzQLF L PHGLDPELHQWDOLV¶REULSHUtRGHG¶LQIRUPDFLyS~EOLFD 5HVROXFLyQ GH GH DEULO GH OD 'LUHFFLyQ *HQHUDO GH 3DWULPRQLR &XOWXUDO 9DOHQFLDQR \ 0XVHRV GH OD &RQVHOOHULD GH &XOWXUD (GXFDFLyQ \ 'HSRUWH SRU OD TXH VH LQFRD H[SHGLHQWH SDUD OD SULPHUD IDVH GH OD DFWXDOL]DFLyQ \ DGDSWDFLyQ SDUFLDO GH OD 6HFFLyQ 3ULPHUD GHO ,QYHQWDULR *HQHUDO GHO 3DWULPRQLR &XOWXUDO 9DOHQFLDQR HQ PDWHULD GH SDWULPRQLRDUTXLWHFWyQLFR\PHGLRDPELHQWDO\VHDEUHSHULRGRGHLQIRUPDFLyQSXEOLFD Núm. 5.503 / 02.05.2007 17900 %e'¶,17(5e6&8/785$//$//27-$'(/&¬1(0&$67(//Ï'(/$3/$1$&$67(//Ï1'(/$ 3/$1$02180(17 %,(1'(,17(5e6&8/785$//$/21-$'(/&Èf$02&$67(//Ï'(/$3/$1$&$67(//Ï1'(/$ 3/$1$02180(172 $11(;,9$1(;2,9 GH 5HVROXFLyGHG DEULOGHOD'LUHFFLy*HQHUDOGH3DWULPRQL&XOWXUDO9DOHQFLjL0XVHXVGHOD&RQVHOOHULDGH&XOWXUD(GXFDFLyL(VSRUWSHUODTXHV LQFRDH[SHGLHQWSHUDOD SULPHUD IDVH GH O DFWXDOLW]DFLy L DGDSWDFLy SDUFLDO GH OD 6HFFLy 3ULPHUD GH O ,QYHQWDUL *HQHUDO GHO 3DWULPRQL &XOWXUDO 9DOHQFLj HQ PDWqULD GH SDWULPRQL DUTXLWHFWzQLF L PHGLDPELHQWDOLV¶REULSHUtRGHG¶LQIRUPDFLyS~EOLFD 5HVROXFLyQ GH GH DEULO GH OD 'LUHFFLyQ *HQHUDO GH 3DWULPRQLR &XOWXUDO 9DOHQFLDQR \ 0XVHRV GH OD &RQVHOOHULD GH &XOWXUD (GXFDFLyQ \ 'HSRUWH SRU OD TXH VH LQFRD H[SHGLHQWH SDUD OD SULPHUD IDVH GH OD DFWXDOL]DFLyQ \ DGDSWDFLyQ SDUFLDO GH OD 6HFFLyQ 3ULPHUD GHO ,QYHQWDULR *HQHUDO GHO 3DWULPRQLR &XOWXUDO 9DOHQFLDQR HQ PDWHULD GH SDWULPRQLRDUTXLWHFWyQLFR\PHGLRDPELHQWDO\VHDEUHSHULRGRGHLQIRUPDFLyQSXEOLFD Núm. 5.503 / 02.05.2007 17901 %e'¶,17(5e6&8/785$/±3$/$8(3,6&23$/&$67(//Ï'(/$3/$1$&$67(//Ï1'(/$3/$1$ 02180(17 %,(1'(,17(5e6&8/785$/3$/$&,2(3,6&23$/&$67(//Ï'(/$3/$1$&$67(//Ï1'(/$ 3/$1$02180(172 'HQRPLQDFLy'HQRPLQDFLyQ 3ULQFLSDO3ULQFLSDO 3DODX(SLVFRSDO 3DODFLR(SLVFRSDO /RFDOLW]DFLy/RFDOL]DFLyQ 3URYtQFLD3URYLQFLD&DVWHOOy &RPDUFD&RPDUFD/D3ODQD$OWD 0XQLFLSL0XQLFLSLR &DVWHOOyGHOD3ODQD&DVWHOOyQGHOD3ODQD 8ELFDFLy8ELFDFLyQ&DOOH*REHUQDGRU 5HIHUqQFLD&DGDVWUDO5HIHUHQFLD&DWDVWUDO ,OOD0DQ]DQD3DUFHOāOD3DUFHOD $QWHFHGHQWV-XUtGLFV$QWHFHGHQWHV-XUtGLFRV ,QFRDFLy,QFRDFLyQ 3XEOLFDFLyGHODLQFRDFLy3XEOLFDFLyQGHODLQFRDFLyQ%2( 'HVFULSFLy'HVFULSFLyQ 3DUWVLQWHJUDQWV3DUWHV,QWHJUDQWHV − (GLILFLFRPSRVWGHSODQWDEDL[DSODQWDSULPHUDLSRU[H (GLILFLRFRPSXHVWRGHSODQWDEDMDSODQWD SULPHUD\GHVYiQ − − )DoDQDSULQFLSDOLODWHUDOVDPEHVFXWQRELOLDUL )DFKDGDSULQFLSDO\ODWHUDOHVFRQHVFXGRQRELOLDULR (VFDODLPSHULDODPEWDXOHOOHWVLEDUDQD(VFDOHUDLPSHULDOFRQD]XOHMRV\EDUDQGD 'HVFULSFLy*HQHUDO'HVFULSFLyQ*HQHUDO (QHOVDIRUHVGH/D9LODDODYRUDGHOD6pTXLD0DMRUHVYDFRPHQoDUDFRQVWUXLUHVWHHGLILFLHQ(VYD DOoDUDFRVWDGHOELVEHIUD$QWRQLR-RVp6DOLQDVL0RUHQRHQFDUUHJDQWOHVREUHVDO HPLQHQW0LJXHO7LUDW eVXQHGLILFLGHSODQWDUHFWDQJXODUTXHHVGHVHQYROXSDDSDUWLUGHOQXFOLSULQFLSDOFRQILJXUDWSHOFDQFHOOHO YHVWtEXOLO HVFDODDOYROWDQWGHOTXDOV HVWUXFWXUHQHOVGRVFRVVRVGHO HGLILFL(QHOYHVWtEXOG HQWUDGDFREHUW DPE YROWD GH FDQy UHEDL[DGD V REULQ OHV GLIHUHQWV GHSHQGqQFLHV GHO VHPLVRWHUUDQL L GXHV HVFDOHV ODWHUDOV TXH GRQHQ DFFpV D O HQWUHVzO 'HV GHO YHVWtEXO FREHUW DPE YROWD GH FDQy UHEDL[DW V DFFHGL[ D O HVFDOD LPSHULDOFREHUWD DPEYROWDYDwGDTXHFRQGXw[ DO SLVSULQFLSDO /D SODQWDQREOHFRQVHUYDOD VHXD HVWUXFWXUD RULJLQjULDGLYLGLGDHQWUHV]RQHVHQOD]RQDFHQWUDOV XELTXHQHOVDOyODFDSHOODLHOGHVSDW[PHQWUHTXHHQ OHVDOWUHV]RQHVV¶XELTXHQOHVKDELWDFLRQVTXHHVGHVWLQHQD~VSULYDWLGLYHUVRVVHUYLFLV(OSLVVXSHULRUHVWD GHVWLQDWDSRU[H $O H[WHULRUODIDoDQDpVGHFRPSRVLFLyUHFWDQJXODUHVWUXFWXUDGDHQTXDWUHFRVVRV(OQLYHOOLQIHULRUpVXQDOW VzFROGHSHGUDHQTXqV REULQHOVXOOVGHERXGHOVRWHUUDQL/ HQWUHVzOLHOSULPHUSLVV RUGHQHQSHUEDOFRQV G DUFVHJPHQWDW VHSDUDWV SHUFRUQLVD GH SHGUD / HGLILFL HV FRURQD DPE XQ EDUDQD DPE IURQWy L XQ XOO GH ERXHQHOFRVFHQWUDO /DSRUWDGDHVWjUHDOLW]DGDHQSHGUDDPEXQ DUFUHEDL[DW LSLODVWUHV HQFDL[DGHVTXHUHPDWHQDPEWUtJOLIVD PDQHUDGHFDSLWHOO6REUHODSRUWDGDKLKDXQDOjSLGDDPELQVFULSFLyHQTXqHVIDUHIHUqQFLDDODFRQVWUXFFLy GHO HGLILFL6REUHHOEDOFySULQFLSDOHVWUREDO HVFXWGHOELVEHIXQGDGRU /HVIDoDQHVODWHUDOVVHJXL[HQODPDWHL[DRUGHQDFLyTXHODSULQFLSDOSHUzFDQYLHQHOVXOOVGHERXGHOVRWHUUDQL SHUILQHVWUHV/DIjEULFDGHO HGLILFLpVGHFDUUHXVGHSHGUDLPDoRQHULD%DVDWHQHO&DWjOHJGH0RQXPHQWVL &RQMXQWVGHOD&RPXQLWDW9DOHQFLDQD (QODVDIXHUDVGHOD9LODMXQWRDOD6pTXLD0DMRUVHFRPHQ]yDFRQVWUXLUHVWHHGLILFLRHQ6HOHYDQWyD H[SHQVDVGHORELVSRIUD\$QWRQLR-RVp6DOLQDV\0RUHQRHQFDUJDQGRODVREUDVDOSUyFHU0LJXHO7LUDGR (V XQ HGLILFLR GH SODQWD UHFWDQJXODU TXH VH GHVDUUROOD D SDUWLU GHO Q~FOHR SULQFLSDO FRQILJXUDGR SRU HO ]DJXiQHOYHVWtEXOR\ODHVFDOHUDDOUHGHGRUGHOTXHVHHVWUXFWXUDQORVGRVFXHUSRVGHOHGLILFLR(QHO]DJXiQ GHHQWUDGDFXELHUWRFRQEyYHGDGHFDxyQUHEDMDGDVHDEUHQODVGLIHUHQWHVGHSHQGHQFLDVGHOVHPLVyWDQR\ GRV HVFDOHUDV ODWHUDOHV TXH GDQ DFFHVR DO HQWUHVXHOR 'HVGH HO YHVWtEXOR FXELHUWR FRQ EyYHGD GH FDxyQ $11(;,9$1(;2,9 GH 5HVROXFLyGHG DEULOGHOD'LUHFFLy*HQHUDOGH3DWULPRQL&XOWXUDO9DOHQFLjL0XVHXVGHOD&RQVHOOHULDGH&XOWXUD(GXFDFLyL(VSRUWSHUODTXHV LQFRDH[SHGLHQWSHUDOD SULPHUD IDVH GH O DFWXDOLW]DFLy L DGDSWDFLy SDUFLDO GH OD 6HFFLy 3ULPHUD GH O ,QYHQWDUL *HQHUDO GHO 3DWULPRQL &XOWXUDO 9DOHQFLj HQ PDWqULD GH SDWULPRQL DUTXLWHFWzQLF L PHGLDPELHQWDOLV¶REULSHUtRGHG¶LQIRUPDFLyS~EOLFD 5HVROXFLyQ GH GH DEULO GH OD 'LUHFFLyQ *HQHUDO GH 3DWULPRQLR &XOWXUDO 9DOHQFLDQR \ 0XVHRV GH OD &RQVHOOHULD GH &XOWXUD (GXFDFLyQ \ 'HSRUWH SRU OD TXH VH LQFRD H[SHGLHQWH SDUD OD SULPHUD IDVH GH OD DFWXDOL]DFLyQ \ DGDSWDFLyQ SDUFLDO GH OD 6HFFLyQ 3ULPHUD GHO ,QYHQWDULR *HQHUDO GHO 3DWULPRQLR &XOWXUDO 9DOHQFLDQR HQ PDWHULD GH SDWULPRQLRDUTXLWHFWyQLFR\PHGLRDPELHQWDO\VHDEUHSHULRGRGHLQIRUPDFLyQSXEOLFD Núm. 5.503 / 02.05.2007 17902 UHEDMDGR VH DFFHGH D OD HVFDOHUD LPSHULDO FXELHUWD FRQ EyYHGD YDtGD TXH FRQGXFH DO SLVR SULQFLSDO /D SODQWDQREOHFRQVHUYDVXHVWUXFWXUDRULJLQDULDVHGLYLGHHQWUHV]RQDVODFHQWUDOGRQGHVHXELFDQHOVDOyQ FDSLOOD\GHVSDFKRPLHQWUDVTXHHQODVRWUDVODVKDELWDFLRQHVVHGHVWLQDQDXVRSULYDGR\GLYHUVRVVHUYLFLRV (OSLVRVXSHULRUHVWDGHVWLQDGRDGHVYiQ $OH[WHULRUODIDFKDGDHVGHFRPSRVLFLyQUHFWDQJXODUHVWUXFWXUDGDHQFXDWURFXHUSRV(OQLYHOLQIHULRUHVXQ DOWR]yFDORGHSLHGUDHQHOTXHVHDEUHQORVyFXORVGHOVyWDQR(OHQWUHVXHOR\HOSULPHUSLVRVHRUGHQDQSRU EDOFRQHV GH DUFR VHJPHQWDGR VHSDUDGRV SRU FRUQLVD GH SLHGUD (O HGLILFLR UHPDWD FRQ XQ DQWHSHFKR FRQ IURQWyQ\yFXORHQHOFXHUSRFHQWUDO /DSRUWDGDHVWiUHDOL]DGDHQSLHGUDFRQXQDUFRUHEDMDGR\SLODVWUDVHQFDMDGDVTXHUHPDWDQFRQWULJOLIRVD PRGR GH FDSLWHO 6REUH OD SRUWDGD KD\ XQD OiSLGD FRQ LQVFULSFLyQ HQ OD TXH VH KDFH UHIHUHQFLD D OD FRQVWUXFFLyQGHOHGLILFLR6REUHHOEDOFyQSULQFLSDOVHHQFXHQWUDHOHVFXGRGHORELVSRIXQGDGRU /DV IDFKDGDV ODWHUDOHV VLJXHQ OD PLVPD RUGHQDFLyQ TXH OD SULQFLSDO FDPELDQGR ORV yFXORV GHO VyWDQR SRU YHQWDQDV /D IiEULFD GHO HGLILFLR HV GH VLOODUHV GH SLHGUD \ PDPSRVWHUtD %DVDGR HQ HO &DWiORJR GH 0RQXPHQWRV\&RQMXQWRVGHOD&RPXQLGDG9DOHQFLDQD 2EVHUYDFLRQV2EVHUYDFLRQHV (QWRUQ(QWRUQR $QWHFHGHQWVDGPLQLVWUDWLXVGHOLPLWDFLyH[WUHWDGHO H[SHGLHQWGHILQLGDDPEFDUjFWHUSURYLVLRQDO 2ULJHQLQWHUVHFFLyGHO HL[GHOFDUUHUGHO3HVFDGRUDPEODSURORQJDFLyGHODPLWJHUDHQWUHOHVSDUFHOāOHVL GHO¶LOODGHFDVHVSXQW$ 6HQWLW$QWLKRUDUL /tQLDGHOLPLWDGRUD/DOtQLDUHFRUUHODPLWJHUDHQWUHOHVSDUFHOāOHVLLHQWUHOHVLGHODLOODGHFDVHV &UHXDHOFDUUHUGHOJRYHUQDGRU%HUP~GH]GH&DVWURLV LQWURGXw[HQO¶LOODSHUODSRVWHULRUGHOD SDUFHOāODLFRQWLQXDHQHVWDGLUHFFLyWUDYHVVDQWODGLWDLOOD6HJXL[ILQVDOFDUUHU%HOOYHUILQVDODPLWJHUDGH OHVSDUFHOāOHVLGHO¶LOODLUHFRUUHOHVSRVWHULRUVGHOHVSDUFHOāOHVG HVWDLOODTXHGRQHQDOFDUUHU GHO%LVEH6DOLQDV7RUQDDFUHXDUHOFDUUHUGHOJRYHUQDGRU%HUP~GH]LFUHXDO¶LOODHQWUHOHVSDUFHOāOHV LLFRQWLQXDSHOFDUUHU3HVFDGRUILQVDOSXQW$ $QWHFHGHQWHVDGPLQLVWUDWLYRVGHOLPLWDFLyQH[WUDtGDGHOH[SHGLHQWHGHILQLGDFRQFDUiFWHUSURYLVLRQDO 2ULJHQLQWHUVHFFLyQGHOHMHGHODFDOOH3HVFDGRUHVFRQODSURORQJDFLyQGHODPHGLDQHUDHQWUHODVSDUFHODV \GHODPDQ]DQDSXQWR$ 6HQWLGR$QWLKRUDULR /tQHD GHOLPLWDGRUD /D OtQHD UHFRUUH OD PHGLDQHUD HQWUH ODV SDUFHODV \ \ HQWUH ODV \ GH OD PDQ]DQD&UX]DODFDOOH*REHUQDGRU%HUP~GH]GH&DVWUR\VHLQWURGXFHHQODPDQ]DQDSRUOD WUDVHUD GH OD SDUFHOD \ FRQWLQ~D HQ HVWD GLUHFFLyQ DWUDYHVDQGR GLFKD PDQ]DQD 6LJXH KDVWD OD FDOOH %HOOYHU KDVWD OD PHGLDQHUD GH ODV SDUFHODV \ GH OD PDQ]DQD \ UHFRUUH ODV WUDVHUDV GH ODV SDUFHODV GH HVWD PDQ]DQD UHFD\HQWHV D OD FDOOH 2ELVSR 6DOLQDV 9XHOYH D FUX]DU OD FDOOH *REHUQDGRU %HUP~GH]\FUX]DODPDQ]DQDHQWUHODVSDUFHODV\\FRQWLQ~DSRUODFDOOH3HVFDGRUHVKDVWDHO SXQWR$ $11(;,9$1(;2,9 GH 5HVROXFLyGHG DEULOGHOD'LUHFFLy*HQHUDOGH3DWULPRQL&XOWXUDO9DOHQFLjL0XVHXVGHOD&RQVHOOHULDGH&XOWXUD(GXFDFLyL(VSRUWSHUODTXHV LQFRDH[SHGLHQWSHUDOD SULPHUD IDVH GH O DFWXDOLW]DFLy L DGDSWDFLy SDUFLDO GH OD 6HFFLy 3ULPHUD GH O ,QYHQWDUL *HQHUDO GHO 3DWULPRQL &XOWXUDO 9DOHQFLj HQ PDWqULD GH SDWULPRQL DUTXLWHFWzQLF L PHGLDPELHQWDOLV¶REULSHUtRGHG¶LQIRUPDFLyS~EOLFD 5HVROXFLyQ GH GH DEULO GH OD 'LUHFFLyQ *HQHUDO GH 3DWULPRQLR &XOWXUDO 9DOHQFLDQR \ 0XVHRV GH OD &RQVHOOHULD GH &XOWXUD (GXFDFLyQ \ 'HSRUWH SRU OD TXH VH LQFRD H[SHGLHQWH SDUD OD SULPHUD IDVH GH OD DFWXDOL]DFLyQ \ DGDSWDFLyQ SDUFLDO GH OD 6HFFLyQ 3ULPHUD GHO ,QYHQWDULR *HQHUDO GHO 3DWULPRQLR &XOWXUDO 9DOHQFLDQR HQ PDWHULD GH SDWULPRQLRDUTXLWHFWyQLFR\PHGLRDPELHQWDO\VHDEUHSHULRGRGHLQIRUPDFLyQSXEOLFD Núm. 5.503 / 02.05.2007 17903 %e'¶,17(5e6&8/785$/±3$/$8(3,6&23$/&$67(//Ï'(/$3/$1$&$67(//Ï1'(/$3/$1$ 02180(17 %,(1'(,17(5e6&8/785$/3$/$&,2(3,6&23$/&$67(//Ï'(/$3/$1$&$67(//Ï1'(/$ 3/$1$02180(172 $11(;,9$1(;2,9 GH 5HVROXFLyGHG DEULOGHOD'LUHFFLy*HQHUDOGH3DWULPRQL&XOWXUDO9DOHQFLjL0XVHXVGHOD&RQVHOOHULDGH&XOWXUD(GXFDFLyL(VSRUWSHUODTXHV LQFRDH[SHGLHQWSHUDOD SULPHUD IDVH GH O DFWXDOLW]DFLy L DGDSWDFLy SDUFLDO GH OD 6HFFLy 3ULPHUD GH O ,QYHQWDUL *HQHUDO GHO 3DWULPRQL &XOWXUDO 9DOHQFLj HQ PDWqULD GH SDWULPRQL DUTXLWHFWzQLF L PHGLDPELHQWDOLV¶REULSHUtRGHG¶LQIRUPDFLyS~EOLFD 5HVROXFLyQ GH GH DEULO GH OD 'LUHFFLyQ *HQHUDO GH 3DWULPRQLR &XOWXUDO 9DOHQFLDQR \ 0XVHRV GH OD &RQVHOOHULD GH &XOWXUD (GXFDFLyQ \ 'HSRUWH SRU OD TXH VH LQFRD H[SHGLHQWH SDUD OD SULPHUD IDVH GH OD DFWXDOL]DFLyQ \ DGDSWDFLyQ SDUFLDO GH OD 6HFFLyQ 3ULPHUD GHO ,QYHQWDULR *HQHUDO GHO 3DWULPRQLR &XOWXUDO 9DOHQFLDQR HQ PDWHULD GH SDWULPRQLRDUTXLWHFWyQLFR\PHGLRDPELHQWDO\VHDEUHSHULRGRGHLQIRUPDFLyQSXEOLFD Núm. 5.503 / 02.05.2007 17904 %e'¶,17(5e6&8/785$/±7255(&$03$1$5³(/)$'5Ë´&$67(//Ï'(/$3/$1$&$67(//Ï1 '(/$3/$1$02180(17 %,(1'(,17(5e6&8/785$/7255(&$03$1$5,2(/)$'5Ë&$67(//Ï'(/$ 3/$1$&$67(//Ï1'(/$3/$1$02180(172 'HQRPLQDFLy'HQRPLQDFLyQ 3ULQFLSDO3ULQFLSDO 7RUUH&DPSDQDU³(O)DGUt´ 7RUUH&DPSDQDULR(O)DGUt /RFDOLW]DFLy/RFDOL]DFLyQ 3URYtQFLD3URYLQFLD&DVWHOOy &RPDUFD&RPDUFD/D3ODQD$OWD 0XQLFLSL0XQLFLSLR&DVWHOOyGHOD3ODQD&DVWHOOyQGHOD3ODQD 8ELFDFLy8ELFDFLyQ3ODoD0DMRU 5HIHUqQFLD&DGDVWUDO5HIHUHQFLD&DWDVWUDO ,OOD0DQ]DQD3DUFHOāOD3DUFHOD $QWHFHGHQWV-XUtGLFV$QWHFHGHQWHV-XUtGLFRV ,QFRDFLy,QFRDFLyQ5HVROXFLyGHG¶DJRVWGHGHOD 'LUHFFLy*HQHUDOGH3DWULPRQL$UWtVWLF 3XEOLFDFLyGHODLQFRDFLy3XEOLFDFLyQGHODLQFRDFLyQ'2*9 'HVFULSFLy'HVFULSFLyQ 3DUWV,QWHJUDQWV3DUWHV,QWHJUDQWHV − /DWRUUHFDPSDQDU/DWRUUHFDPSDQDULR − /HVFDPSDQHV/DVFDPSDQDV 'HVFULSFLy*HQHUDO'HVFULSFLyQ*HQHUDO 6LWXDWHQ OD SODoD0DMRU HQ HO FHQWUH GH OD FLXWDW MXQW D O HVJOpVLD GH 6DQWD 0DULD OD 0DMRU (O &RQVHOO YD GHFLGLU OD FRQVWUXFFLy G XQ FDPSDQDU HQ SHUz OHV REUHV QR YDQ FRPHQoDU ILQV D (Q YD LQWHUYLQGUH HO PHVWUH dDHUD TXH YD FRQVWUXLU DSUR[LPDGDPHQW HO SULPHU FRV 'HVSUpV G XQD OODUJD SDUDOLW]DFLy L GLYHUVHV SURSRVWHV HQ YDQ LQWHUYLQGUH L YDQ ILQDOLW]DU OD WRUUH )UDQFLVFR *DOLDQoD GH OD /ODQ[D *XLOOHP GHO 5HL 3HUH &URVDOL 0DUF 9ROVDQ\V $QWRQLR L -RDQ 6DXUD VHJRQV OHV WUDFHV TXH KDYLD SUHVHQWDW HO SRUWXJXpV 'DPLj 0pQGH] HQ (V WUDFWD G XQD WRUUH FDPSDQDU H[HPSWD GH SODQWD RFWRJRQDO DPE XQD DOWXUD DSUR[LPDGD GH PHWUHV (VWD GLYLGLGD HQ TXDWUHV FRVVRV TXH D O LQWHULRU HV FRUUHVSRQHQDPEODFDPEUDGHOUHOORWJHODSUHVyGHO HFOHVLjVWLFODYLYHQGDGHOFDPSDQHULODFDPEUDGHOHV FDPSDQHV(VWRVTXDWUHFRVVRVLQWHULRUVQRHVFRUUHVSRQHQDPEOHVOtQLHVGHFRUQLVHV H[WHULRUV(QODSDUW VXSHULRUHVWUREDXQDEDUDQD UHPDUFDGD DPE KXLW JjUJROHV /D WRUUH HV FRURQD DPE XQ FDSLWHOO GH UqSOLFD GH O RULJLQDO GHVWUXwW HQ pV GH SODQWD WULDQJXODU DPE SLODVWUHV G RUGH WRVFj FREHUW DPE WHXOD EODYDLUHPDWDWDPEXQSHQHOOFROāORFDGDHQ$O LQWHULRUXQDHVFDODGHFDUDJRODPELQWUDGyVGLVFRQWLQX SHUPHW DFFHGLU DOV GLVWLQWV SLVRV GH OD WRUUH OHV HVWDGHV GH OD TXDO SRVVHw[HQ FREHUWD YROWDGD HQ SHGUD / DFFpV D OD WRUUH HV UHDOLW]D D WUDYpV G XQ SRUWDGD DOOLQGDGD DPE XQD IRUQtFXOD HQ OD SDUW VXSHULRU IODQTXHMDGDSHUYROXWHVLXQIURQWyWULDQJXODUHQODSDUWVXSHULRU+LKDXQDLQVFULSFLy HQODOOLQGD TXHID UHIHUqQFLDDODFRQVWUXFFLyGHODWRUUHHQWUHL/DWRUUHFDPSDQDUYDVHUUHVWDXUDGDDO¶DQ\ &DO DVVHQ\DODU OD VHPEODQoD G HVWH FDPSDQDU DPE HO GH O (VJOpVLD $U[LSUHVWDO GH 6DQW 0DWHX L O (VJOpVLD 3DUURTXLDOGHO6DOYDGRUGH%RUULDQD%DVDWHQOD*XLDG $UTXLWHFWXUDGH&DVWHOOyL$QWLJXLWDWVGH&DVWHOOyGH OD3ODQDGH97UDYHU 6LWXDGRHQODSODoD0DMRUHQHOFHQWUR GH ODFLXGDG MXQWRDODLJOHVLDGH6DQWD0DULDOD0DMRU(O&RQVHOO GHFLGLy OD FRQVWUXFFLyQ GH XQ FDPSDQDULR HQ SHUR ODV REUDV QR FRPHQ]DURQ KDVWD (Q LQWHUYLQRHOPDHVWURdDHUDFRQVWUX\HQGRDSUR[LPDGDPHQWHHOSULPHUFXHUSR7UDVXQDODUJDSDUDOL]DFLyQ\ YDULDV SURSXHVWDV HQ LQWHUYLQLHURQ \ ILQDOL]DURQ OD WRUUH )UDQFLVFR *DOLDQoD GH OD /DQFKD *XLOOHP GHO 5HL 3HGUR &URVDOL 0DUF 9ROVDQ\V $QWRQLR \ -RDQ 6DXUD VHJ~Q ODV WUD]DV TXH KDEtD SUHVHQWDGR HO SRUWXJXpV'DPLiQ0pQGH]HQ6HWUDWDGHXQDWRUUHFDPSDQDULRH[HQWDGHSODQWDRFWRJRQDOFRQXQD DOWXUD DSUR[LPDGD GH PHWURV (VWi GLYLGLGD HQ FXDWURV FXHUSRV TXH DO LQWHULRU VH FRUUHVSRQGHQ FRQ OD FiPDUDGHOUHORMODSULVLyQGHOHFOHVLiVWLFRODYLYLHQGDGHO FDPSDQHUR\ODFiPDUDGHODVFDPSDQDV(VWRV FXDWURFXHUSRVLQWHULRUHVQRVHFRUUHVSRQGHQFRQODVOtQHDVGH FRUQLVDVH[WHULRUHV(QODSDUWHVXSHULRU VH HQFXHQWUDXQDQWHSHFKRVXEUD\DGRFRQRFKRJiUJRODV/DWRUUHFRURQDFRQ XQD FKDSLWHO GH UHSOLFD $11(;,9$1(;2,9 GH 5HVROXFLyGHG DEULOGHOD'LUHFFLy*HQHUDOGH3DWULPRQL&XOWXUDO9DOHQFLjL0XVHXVGHOD&RQVHOOHULDGH&XOWXUD(GXFDFLyL(VSRUWSHUODTXHV LQFRDH[SHGLHQWSHUDOD SULPHUD IDVH GH O DFWXDOLW]DFLy L DGDSWDFLy SDUFLDO GH OD 6HFFLy 3ULPHUD GH O ,QYHQWDUL *HQHUDO GHO 3DWULPRQL &XOWXUDO 9DOHQFLj HQ PDWqULD GH SDWULPRQL DUTXLWHFWzQLF L PHGLDPELHQWDOLV¶REULSHUtRGHG¶LQIRUPDFLyS~EOLFD 5HVROXFLyQ GH GH DEULO GH OD 'LUHFFLyQ *HQHUDO GH 3DWULPRQLR &XOWXUDO 9DOHQFLDQR \ 0XVHRV GH OD &RQVHOOHULD GH &XOWXUD (GXFDFLyQ \ 'HSRUWH SRU OD TXH VH LQFRD H[SHGLHQWH SDUD OD SULPHUD IDVH GH OD DFWXDOL]DFLyQ \ DGDSWDFLyQ SDUFLDO GH OD 6HFFLyQ 3ULPHUD GHO ,QYHQWDULR *HQHUDO GHO 3DWULPRQLR &XOWXUDO 9DOHQFLDQR HQ PDWHULD GH SDWULPRQLRDUTXLWHFWyQLFR\PHGLRDPELHQWDO\VHDEUHSHULRGRGHLQIRUPDFLyQSXEOLFD Núm. 5.503 / 02.05.2007 17905 GHORULJLQDOGHVWUXLGRHQHVGHSODQWDWULDQJXODUFRQSLODVWUDVGHRUGHQWRVFDQRFXELHUWRFRQWHMDD]XO \UHPDWDGRFRQXQDYHOHWDFRORFDGDHQ$OLQWHULRUXQDHVFDOHUD GH FDUDFRO FRQ LQWUDGyV GLVFRQWLQXR SHUPLWHDFFHGHUDORVGLVWLQWRVSLVRVGHODWRUUHFX\DVHVWDQFLDVSRVHHQFXELHUWD DERYHGDGD HQ SLHGUD(O DFFHVR D OD WRUUH VH UHDOL]D D WUDYpV GH XQ SRUWDGD DGLQWHODGD FRQ XQD KRUQDFLQD HQ OD SDUWH VXSHULRU IODQTXHDGD SRU YROXWDV \ XQ IURQWyQ WULDQJXODU HQ OD SDUWH VXSHULRU +D\ XQD LQVFULSFLyQ HQ HO GLQWHO TXH KDFHUHIHUHQFLDDODFRQVWUXFFLyQGHODWRUUHHQWUH\/DWRUUHFDPSDQDULRIXHUHVWDXUDGD HQ HO DxR&DEHVHxDODUODVHPHMDQ]DGHHVWHFDPSDQDULRFRQHOGHOD,JOHVLD$UFLSUHVWDOGH6DQW0DWHX\OD ,JOHVLD3DUURTXLDOGHO6DOYDGRUGH%XUULDQD%DVDGRHQOD*XtDGH$UTXLWHFWXUDGH&DVWHOOyQ\$QWLJHGDGHV GH&DVWHOOyQGHOD3ODQDGH97UDYHU 2EVHUYDFLRQHV2EVHUYDFLRQHV (Q SDUWLFLSDU G¶XQ PDWHL[ jPELW PRQXPHQWDO UHSUHVHQWDWLX GH OD FLXWDW FRPSDUWHL[ HQWRUQ XQLWDUL DPE O¶$MXQWDPHQWOD/ORWMDGHO&jQHPLOHVSRUWDGHVGHOD&RQFDWHGUDO $OSDUWLFLSDUGHXQPLVPRiPELWRPRQXPHQWDOUHSUHVHQWDWLYRGH ODFLXGDGFRPSDUWHHQWRUQRXQLWDULRFRQ HO$\XQWDPLHQWROD/ORWMDGHO&jQHP\ODVSRUWDGDVGHOD&RQFDWHGUDO (QWRUQ(QWRUQR $QWHFHGHQWVDGPLQLVWUDWLXVGHOLPLWDFLyH[WUHWDGHO H[SHGLHQWGHILQLGDDPEFDUjFWHUSURYLVLRQDO 2ULJHQLQWHUVHFFLyGHO HL[GHOFDUUHU&RORPLHOFDUUHU0HDOOD 6HQWLW+RUDUL /tQLD GHOLPLWDGRUD /D OtQLD UHFRUUH O HL[ GHO FDUUHU GH 0HDOOD HQ GLUHFFLy QRUG L JLUD SHO GHO FDUUHU GH &HUYDQWHVLGHVSUpVSHOGHOFDUUHUG¶$XVLHV0DUFK6 LQWURGXw[HQO¶LOODGHFDVHVHQWUHODPLWJHUDGHOHV SDUFHOāOHVLUHFRUUHOHVSRVWHULRUVGHOHVSDUFHOāOHVLLODPLWJHUDQRUGGHODSDUFHOāOD$UULED ILQVO HL[GHOFDUUHU0DMRULFRQWLQXDSHUHVWHILQVDOFDUUHU GHO¶DU[LSUHVWH0RVVpQ%DODJXHU*LUDDRHVWSHU O HL[G HVWHFDUUHULSHOFDUUHUGHOµ(FFHKRPRILQVDWUDYHVVDUO¶LOODHQWUHOHVSDUFHOāOHVLLL SHUDFRQWLQXDUSHUODSRVWHULRUGHODSDUFHOāOD6HJXL[ILQVDO¶LOODLLQFRUSRUDOHVSDUFHOāOHVL G HVWDLOODLODIDoDQDGHODSDUFHOāODTXHGyQDDODSODoDGHOD3HVFDWHULD3URVVHJXL[ILQVDO HL[GHOFDUUHU GH-RVHS*DUFLDVHJXL[SHUO HL[ G HVWHFDUUHUL SHOGHOFDUUHUG¶(QPLJILQV DO GHOFDUUHUGH&RORP SHOTXDO VHJXL[ILQVDOSXQWG RULJHQ $QWHFHGHQWHVDGPLQLVWUDWLYRVGHOLPLWDFLyQH[WUDtGDGHOH[SHGLHQWHGHILQLGDFRQFDUiFWHUSURYLVLRQDO 2ULJHQLQWHUVHFFLyQGHOHMHGHODFDOOH&ROyQ\ODFDOOH0HDOOD 6HQWLGR+RUDULR /tQHD GHOLPLWDGRUD /D OtQHD UHFRUUH HO HMH GH OD FDOOH 0HDOOD HQ GLUHFFLyQ QRUWH \ JLUD SRU HO GH OD FDOOH &HUYDQWHV\OXHJRSRUHOGHODFDOOH$XVLHV0DUFK6HLQWURGXFHHQODPDQ]DQDHQWUHODPHGLDQHUDGH ODV SDUFHODV \ UHFRUUH ODV WUDVHUDV GH ODV SDUFHODV \ \ OD PHGLDQHUD QRUWH GH OD SDUFHOD /OHJD KDVWD HO HMH GH OD FDOOH 0DMRU \ FRQWLQ~D SRU pVWH KDVWD OD FDOOH $UFLSUHVWH 0RVpQ %DODJXHU *LUD D RHVWHSRUHOHMHGHHVWDFDOOH\SRUODFDOH(FFH+RPRKDVWDDWUDYHVDUODPDQ]DQDHQWUHODVSDUFHODV \\\SDUDFRQWLQXDUSRUODWUDVHUDGHODSDUFHOD6LJXHKDVWDODPDQ]DQDHLQFRUSRUD ODVSDUFHODV\GHHVWDPDQ]DQD\ODIDFKDGDGHODSDUFHODUHFD\HQWHDODSOD]DGHOD3HVFDGHUtD 3URVLJXHKDVWDHOHMHGHODFDOOH-RVp*DUFtDVLJXHSRUHOHMHGHHVWDFDOOH\SRUHOGHODFDOOH(QPLJKDVWDHO GHODFDOOH&ROyQSRUHOTXHVLJXHKDVWDHOSXQWRGHRULJHQ $11(;,9$1(;2,9 GH 5HVROXFLyGHG DEULOGHOD'LUHFFLy*HQHUDOGH3DWULPRQL&XOWXUDO9DOHQFLjL0XVHXVGHOD&RQVHOOHULDGH&XOWXUD(GXFDFLyL(VSRUWSHUODTXHV LQFRDH[SHGLHQWSHUDOD SULPHUD IDVH GH O DFWXDOLW]DFLy L DGDSWDFLy SDUFLDO GH OD 6HFFLy 3ULPHUD GH O ,QYHQWDUL *HQHUDO GHO 3DWULPRQL &XOWXUDO 9DOHQFLj HQ PDWqULD GH SDWULPRQL DUTXLWHFWzQLF L PHGLDPELHQWDOLV¶REULSHUtRGHG¶LQIRUPDFLyS~EOLFD 5HVROXFLyQ GH GH DEULO GH OD 'LUHFFLyQ *HQHUDO GH 3DWULPRQLR &XOWXUDO 9DOHQFLDQR \ 0XVHRV GH OD &RQVHOOHULD GH &XOWXUD (GXFDFLyQ \ 'HSRUWH SRU OD TXH VH LQFRD H[SHGLHQWH SDUD OD SULPHUD IDVH GH OD DFWXDOL]DFLyQ \ DGDSWDFLyQ SDUFLDO GH OD 6HFFLyQ 3ULPHUD GHO ,QYHQWDULR *HQHUDO GHO 3DWULPRQLR &XOWXUDO 9DOHQFLDQR HQ PDWHULD GH SDWULPRQLRDUTXLWHFWyQLFR\PHGLRDPELHQWDO\VHDEUHSHULRGRGHLQIRUPDFLyQSXEOLFD Núm. 5.503 / 02.05.2007 17906 %e'¶,17(5e6&8/785$/±7255(&$03$1$5³(/)$'5Ë´&$67(//Ï'(/$3/$1$&$67(//Ï1 '(/$3/$1$02180(17 %,(1'(,17(5e6&8/785$/7255(&$03$1$5,2(/)$'5Ë&$67(//Ï'(/$ 3/$1$&$67(//Ï1'(/$3/$1$02180(172 $11(;,9$1(;2,9 GH 5HVROXFLyGHG DEULOGHOD'LUHFFLy*HQHUDOGH3DWULPRQL&XOWXUDO9DOHQFLjL0XVHXVGHOD&RQVHOOHULDGH&XOWXUD(GXFDFLyL(VSRUWSHUODTXHV LQFRDH[SHGLHQWSHUDOD SULPHUD IDVH GH O DFWXDOLW]DFLy L DGDSWDFLy SDUFLDO GH OD 6HFFLy 3ULPHUD GH O ,QYHQWDUL *HQHUDO GHO 3DWULPRQL &XOWXUDO 9DOHQFLj HQ PDWqULD GH SDWULPRQL DUTXLWHFWzQLF L PHGLDPELHQWDOLV¶REULSHUtRGHG¶LQIRUPDFLyS~EOLFD 5HVROXFLyQ GH GH DEULO GH OD 'LUHFFLyQ *HQHUDO GH 3DWULPRQLR &XOWXUDO 9DOHQFLDQR \ 0XVHRV GH OD &RQVHOOHULD GH &XOWXUD (GXFDFLyQ \ 'HSRUWH SRU OD TXH VH LQFRD H[SHGLHQWH SDUD OD SULPHUD IDVH GH OD DFWXDOL]DFLyQ \ DGDSWDFLyQ SDUFLDO GH OD 6HFFLyQ 3ULPHUD GHO ,QYHQWDULR *HQHUDO GHO 3DWULPRQLR &XOWXUDO 9DOHQFLDQR HQ PDWHULD GH SDWULPRQLRDUTXLWHFWyQLFR\PHGLRDPELHQWDO\VHDEUHSHULRGRGHLQIRUPDFLyQSXEOLFD Núm. 5.503 / 02.05.2007 17907 %e'¶,17(5e6&8/785$/±7255(,02/Ë'(/¶2/,&(59(5$'(/0$(675(02180(17 %,(1'(,17(5e6&8/785$/±7255(<02/,12'(/$&(,7(&(59(5$'(/0$(675( 02180(172 'HQRPLQDFLy'HQRPLQDFLyQ 3ULQFLSDO3ULQFLSDO 7RUUHL0ROtGHO¶2OL 7RUUH\0ROLQRGHO$FHLWH /RFDOLW]DFLy/RFDOL]DFLyQ 3URYtQFLD3URYLQFLD&DVWHOOy &RPDUFD&RPDUFD(O%DL[0DHVWUDW 0XQLFLSL0XQLFLSLR&HUYHUDGHO0DHVWU 8ELFDFLy8ELFDFLyQ&WUD%HQLFDUOy6DQW0DWHX.0 5HIHUqQFLD&DGDVWUDO5HIHUHQFLD&DWDVWUDO 3ROtJRQ3ROtJRQR3DUFHOāOD3DUFHOD $QUWHFHGHQWV-XUtGLFV$QWHFHGHQWHV-XUtGLFRV ,QFRDFLy,QFRDFLyQ 3XEOLFDFLyGHODLQFRDFLy3XEOLFDFLyQGHODLQFRDFLyQ%2( 'HVFULSFLy'HVFULSFLyQ 3DUWV,QWHJUDQWV3DUWHV,QWHJUDQWHV − &DVD DJUtFROD DPE WLSRORJLD GH WRUUH DPE PDWDFj DOMXEV [LPHQHUHV HVFDOD GH FDUDJRO SDYLPHQWV FHUjPLFVLUHOORWJHGHVRO&DVDDJUtFRODFRQWLSRORJtDGHWRUUHFRQPDWDFiQDOMLEHVFKLPHQHDVHVFDOHUD GHFDUDFROSDYLPHQWRVFHUiPLFRV\UHORMGHVRO − 0ROtDPEQDXGHSUHPVDDPEWRWVHOVVHXVPHFDQLVPHVLLQVFULSFLyGHQDXGHPROLQVFDVHWDGH 9ROWDVDODGHJHUUHVDOWUHVGHSHQGHQFLHVVpQLDSRXLLQVFULSFLyGHHQIDoDQD 0ROLQRFRQQDYH GHSUHQVDFRQWRGRVVXVPHFDQLVPRVHLQVFULSFLyQGHQDYHGHPROLQRVFDVHWDGHYROWDVDODGH WLQDMDVDWUiVGHSHQGHQFLDVQRULD\SR]RHLQVFULSFLyQGHHQIDFKDGD − (VSDLTXHDUWLFXOHQDTXHVWVHOHPHQWV(VSDFLRTXHDUWLFXODQHVWRVHOHPHQWRV 'HVFULSFLy*HQHUDO'HVFULSFLyQ*HQHUDO (O FRQMXQW DUTXLWHFWzQLF GHO 0ROt GH O 2OL HV FRPSRQ GH GRV HGLILFLV XQD WRUUH R FDVD DJULFROD PDUH GHO FRQMXQWLHOPROt SUzSLDPHQW GLW/DWRUUHpV GHSODQWD TXDGUDQJXODU FRQVWD GH WUHV SODQWHV (Q OD SODQWD EDL[DHVGLVSRVHQHOYHVWtEXOO HVFDODLHOVGRVDOMXEVDTXqHVWpDFFpVGHVGHO HQWUHVzO/DSODQWDSULPHUD FRQVWDG XQD VDOD SULQFLSDOL DOWUHV GXHVVDOHV GHPHQRUVGLPHQVLRQV(OSDYLPHQW pVFHUjPLF GH ILQDOV GHO VHJOH ;9, R SULQFLSLV GHO ;9,, /D IDoDQD FRQVWD GH SRUWDGD GH PLJ SXQW DPE GRYHOOHV GH FDUUHXV (Q OD SODQWD SULQFLSDO KL KD GXHV ILQHVWUHV VLPqWULTXHV VREUH OHV TXDOV V DGYHUWL[HQ OHV UHVWHV G XQ PDWDFj /D FREHUWD DFWXDO pV D GXHV DLJHV DPE WHXOD jUDE OHV UHVWHV GH SHUPzGROV UHPHWHQ D XQD FREHUWD DQWHULRU SODQD(QODSDUWVXSHULRUHVFRQVHUYDXQUHOORWJH GHVROLXQD LQVFULSFLy DPE OD GDWD SUREDEOHPHQW G XQDUHIRUPD(OPROtFRQVWDGHGRVHOHPHQWVSULQFLSDOVODVDODGHPROHVTXHFRPSWDYDDPEXQPROtLOD VDODGH SUHPVHVR GH ³JLQ\V´ MXQW D G¶DOWUHV VHFXQGjULHV /D VDOD GH SUHPVHV HQ TXq HV WUREHQ OHV GXHV SUHPVHV pV GH SODQWD UHFWDQJXODU L HVWj GLYLGLGD HQ GRV SHU SLODUV GH PDoRQHULD /D SUHPVD PpV DQWLJD FRQVHUYD OD GDWD GH /D QDX GH PROLQV HVWj GLYLGLGD HQ GXHV SDUWV PLWMDQoDQW GRV DUFV UHEDL[DWV GH FDUUHXV VREUH SLODUV $OWUHV HOHPHQWV TXH FRPSOHWHQ HO PROt VyQ OD VDOD GH OHV JHUUHV O HVWDEOH XQD DOWUD GHSHQGqQFLDXVDGDFRPDYLYHQGDLDOQRUGODVpQLD(OPROtYDVHUUHKDELOLWDWHQWUHHOVDQ\VGHOVHJOH ;;VHJRQVSURMHFWHGH0LJXHOGHO5H\%DVDWHQO LQIRUPHGHO 6HUYHLGH3DWULPRQLLHQHOIXOOHW*XLD%UHX GHO0ROtGHO 2OL (OFRQMXQWRDUTXLWHFWyQLFRGHO0ROtGHO¶2OLVHFRPSRQHGHGRVHGLILFLRVXQDWRUUHRFDVDDJUtFRODLQLFLRGHO FRQMXQWR\HOPROLQRSURSLDPHQWHGLFKR/DWRUUHHVGHSODQWD FXDGUDQJXODUFRQVWDGHWUHVSODQWDV(QOD SODQWD EDMD VH GLVSRQHQ HO ]DJXiQ OD HVFDOHUD \ ORV GRV DOMLEHV D ORV TXH VH WLHQH DFFHVR GHVGH HO HQWUHVXHOR /D SODQWD SULPHUD FRQVWD GH XQD VDOD SULQFLSDO \ RWUDV GRV GH PHQRUHV GLPHQVLRQHV (O SDYLPHQWRHVFHUiPLFRGHILQDOHVGHOVLJOR;9,RSULQFLSLRVGHO;9,,/DIDFKDGDFRQVWDGHSRUWDGDGHPHGLR SXQWRFRQGRYHODVGHVLOOHUtD(QODSODQWDSULQFLSDOKD\GRVYHQWDQDVVLPpWULFDVVREUHODVTXHVHDGYLHUWHQ ORVUHVWRVGHXQPDWDFiQ/DFXELHUWDDFWXDOHVDGRVDJXDVFRQWHMDiUDEHORVUHVWRVGHFDQHFLOORVUHPLWHQ DXQDFXELHUWDDQWHULRUSODQD(QODSDUWHVXSHULRUVHFRQVHUYDXQUHORMGHVRO\XQDLQVFULSFLyQFRQODIHFKD SUREDEOHPHQWHGHXQDUHIRUPD $11(;,9$1(;2,9 GH 5HVROXFLyGHG DEULOGHOD'LUHFFLy*HQHUDOGH3DWULPRQL&XOWXUDO9DOHQFLjL0XVHXVGHOD&RQVHOOHULDGH&XOWXUD(GXFDFLyL(VSRUWSHUODTXHV LQFRDH[SHGLHQWSHUDOD SULPHUD IDVH GH O DFWXDOLW]DFLy L DGDSWDFLy SDUFLDO GH OD 6HFFLy 3ULPHUD GH O ,QYHQWDUL *HQHUDO GHO 3DWULPRQL &XOWXUDO 9DOHQFLj HQ PDWqULD GH SDWULPRQL DUTXLWHFWzQLF L PHGLDPELHQWDOLV¶REULSHUtRGHG¶LQIRUPDFLyS~EOLFD 5HVROXFLyQ GH GH DEULO GH OD 'LUHFFLyQ *HQHUDO GH 3DWULPRQLR &XOWXUDO 9DOHQFLDQR \ 0XVHRV GH OD &RQVHOOHULD GH &XOWXUD (GXFDFLyQ \ 'HSRUWH SRU OD TXH VH LQFRD H[SHGLHQWH SDUD OD SULPHUD IDVH GH OD DFWXDOL]DFLyQ \ DGDSWDFLyQ SDUFLDO GH OD 6HFFLyQ 3ULPHUD GHO ,QYHQWDULR *HQHUDO GHO 3DWULPRQLR &XOWXUDO 9DOHQFLDQR HQ PDWHULD GH SDWULPRQLRDUTXLWHFWyQLFR\PHGLRDPELHQWDO\VHDEUHSHULRGRGHLQIRUPDFLyQSXEOLFD Núm. 5.503 / 02.05.2007 17908 (O PROLQR FRQVWD GH GRV HOHPHQWRV SULQFLSDOHV OD VDOD GH PROHV TXH FRQWDED FRQ XQ PROLQR \ OD VDOD GH SUHQVDVRGH³JLQ\V´MXQWRFRQRWUDVVHFXQGDULDV/DVDODGHSUHQVDVGHSODQWDUHFWDQJXODUGLYLGLGDHQGRV SRUSLODUHVGHPDPSRVWHUtDHQHVWDQDYHVHHQFXHQWUDQODVGRVSUHQVDV/DSUHQVDPiVDQWLJXDFRQVHUYDOD IHFKD GH /D QDYH GH PROLQRV HVWi GLYLGLGD HQ GRV SDUWHV PHGLDQWH GRV DUFRV UHEDMDGRV GH VLOOHUtD VREUH SLODUHV 2WURV HOHPHQWRV TXH FRPSOHWDQ HO PROLQR FRQ OD VDOD GH ODV WLQDMDV HO HVWDEOR RWUD GHSHQGHQFLDXVDGDFRPRYLYLHQGD\DOQRUWHODFHQLD(OPROLQRIXHUHKDELOLWDGRHQWUHORVDxRVGHO VLJOR;;VHJ~QSUR\HFWRGH0LJXHOGHO5H\%DVDGRHQHO,QIRUPHGHO6HUYLFLRGH3DWULPRQLR\HQHOIROOHWR *XLD%UHXGHO0ROtGHO¶2OL 2EVHUYDFLRQV2EVHUYDFLRQHV /D WRUUH R FDVD PDUH TXH IRUPD SDUW GHO FRQMXQW DJUtFROD pV XQ HOHPHQW GHIHQVLX FRQVLGHUDW %p G ,QWHUpV &XOWXUDODO HPSDUDGHOD'LVSRVLFLy$GGLFLRQDO3ULPHUDGHOD/OHLGH3DWULPRQL&XOWXUDO9DOHQFLj'RQDGD DTXHVWD FRQGLFLy OHJDO V¶KD SUHIHULW HVWHQGUH OD &DWHJRULD GH 0RQXPHQW D OD LQWHJULWDW GHOV HGLILFLV L GHSHQGqQFLHV WDPEp SHU WDQW DO PROt SUzSLDPHQW GLW $TXHVWD HGLILFDFLy L SUHPVD FRQVLGHUDGD HQJLQ\ GH PROGUH DYDOXDWV HQ UDy G¶DTXHVWD GHVWLQDFLy WDQ FRQFUHWD SRGULHQ HQTXDGUDUVH SHU PqULWV SURSLV HQ OD &DWHJRULDG¶(VSDL(WQROzJLFTXHDPEHOPDWHL[UDQJGHUHFRQHL[HPHQW%,&KDHVWDWLQVWDXUDGDUHFHQWPHQWHQ ODOHJLVODFLyYDOHQFLDQD /D WRUUH R FDVD LQLFLDO TXH IRUPD SDUWH GHO FRQMXQWR DJUtFROD HV XQ HOHPHQWR GHIHQVLYR FRQVLGHUDGR %LHQ GH ,QWHUpV &XOWXUDO DO DPSDUR GH OD 'LVSRVLFLyQ $GLFLRQDO 3ULPHUD GH OD /H\ GH 3DWULPRQLR &XOWXUDO 9DOHQFLDQR'DGDHVWDFRQGLFLyQOHJDOVHKDSUHIHULGRH[WHQGHUOD&DWHJRUtDGH0RQXPHQWRDODLQWHJULGDGGHORV HGLILFLRV\GHSHQGHQFLDVWDPELpQSRUWDQWRDOPROLQRSURSLDPHQWHGLFKR(VWDHGLILFDFLyQ\SUHQVDFRQVLGHUDGRV HQ UD]yQ GH WDQ FRQFUHWR XVR SRGUtDQ HQFXDGUDUVH HQ OD &DWHJRUtD GH (VSDFLR (WQROyJLFR TXH FRQ HO PLVPR UDQJRGHUHFRQRFLPLHQWR%,&KDVLGRLQVWDXUDGRUHFLHQWHPHQWHHQODOHJLVODFLyQYDOHQFLDQD (QWRUQ(QWRUQR $QWHFHGHQWVDGPLQLVWUDWLXVGHOLPLWDFLyH[WUHWDGHO H[SHGLHQWGHILQLGDDPEFDUjFWHUSURYLVLRQDO 2ULJHQ9qUWH[VXGHVWGHODSDUFHOāODGHOSROtJRQSXQW$ 6HQWLW+RUDUL /tQLD GHOLPLWDGRUD OD OtQLD HV GLULJL[ FDS DO VXG SHU OD PLWJHUD HVWH GH OHV SDUFHOāOHV L L JLUD LQFRUSRUDQWOHVSDUFHOāOHVLODILQVDODFDUUHWHUDD%HQLFDUOy6HJXL[DQRUGSHOOtPLWRHVWG HVWD FDUUHWHUDODFUHXDLLQFRUSRUDOHVSDUFHOāOHVL&UHXDHO FDPt L SURVVHJXL[ SHU XQD OtQLD YLUWXDO D P GH OD FDUUHWHUD ILQV D OD SDUFHOāOD FRQWLQXDQW SHU OD PLWJHUD RHVW GH OD PDWHL[D ILQV D OD FDUUHWHUD &UHXD OD FDUUHWHUD L FRQWLQXD SHO OtPLW HVW GH OD SDUFHOāOD ILQVXQDOtQLDVLWXDGDDPGHODFDUUHWHUDDOVXGG HVWDILQVDOSXQWG RULJHQ $QWHFHGHQWHVDGPLQLVWUDWLYRVGHOLPLWDFLyQH[WUDtGDGHOH[SHGLHQWHGHILQLGDFRQFDUiFWHUSURYLVLRQDO 2ULJHQ9pUWLFHVXGHVWHGHODSDUFHODGHOSROtJRQRSXQWR$ 6HQWLGR+RUDULR /tQHDGHOLPLWDGRUDODOtQHDVHGLULJHKDFLDHOVXUSRUODPHGLDQHUDHVWHGHODVSDUFHODV\\JLUD LQFRUSRUDQGRODVSDUFHODV\ODKDVWDODFDUUHWHUDD%HQLFDUOy6LJXHDQRUWHSRUHOOLQGHRHVWH GH HVWD FDUUHWHUD OD FUX]D H LQFRUSRUD ODV SDUFHODV \ &UX]DHOFDPLQR\SURVLJXHSRUXQDOtQHDYLUWXDODPGHODFDUUHWHUDKDVWDODSDUFHODFRQWLQXDQGR SRUODPHGLDQHUDRHVWHGHODPLVPDKDVWDODFDUUHWHUD&UX]DODFDUUHWHUD\FRQWLQ~DSRUHOOLQGHHVWHGHOD SDUFHODKDVWDXQDOtQHDVLWXDGDDPGHODFDUUHWHUDDOVXUGHpVWDKDVWDHOSXQWRGHRULJHQ $11(;,9$1(;2,9 GH 5HVROXFLyGHG DEULOGHOD'LUHFFLy*HQHUDOGH3DWULPRQL&XOWXUDO9DOHQFLjL0XVHXVGHOD&RQVHOOHULDGH&XOWXUD(GXFDFLyL(VSRUWSHUODTXHV LQFRDH[SHGLHQWSHUDOD SULPHUD IDVH GH O DFWXDOLW]DFLy L DGDSWDFLy SDUFLDO GH OD 6HFFLy 3ULPHUD GH O ,QYHQWDUL *HQHUDO GHO 3DWULPRQL &XOWXUDO 9DOHQFLj HQ PDWqULD GH SDWULPRQL DUTXLWHFWzQLF L PHGLDPELHQWDOLV¶REULSHUtRGHG¶LQIRUPDFLyS~EOLFD 5HVROXFLyQ GH GH DEULO GH OD 'LUHFFLyQ *HQHUDO GH 3DWULPRQLR &XOWXUDO 9DOHQFLDQR \ 0XVHRV GH OD &RQVHOOHULD GH &XOWXUD (GXFDFLyQ \ 'HSRUWH SRU OD TXH VH LQFRD H[SHGLHQWH SDUD OD SULPHUD IDVH GH OD DFWXDOL]DFLyQ \ DGDSWDFLyQ SDUFLDO GH OD 6HFFLyQ 3ULPHUD GHO ,QYHQWDULR *HQHUDO GHO 3DWULPRQLR &XOWXUDO 9DOHQFLDQR HQ PDWHULD GH SDWULPRQLRDUTXLWHFWyQLFR\PHGLRDPELHQWDO\VHDEUHSHULRGRGHLQIRUPDFLyQSXEOLFD Núm. 5.503 / 02.05.2007 17909 %e'¶,17(5e6&8/785$/±7255(,02/Ë'(/¶2/,&(59(5$'(/0$(675(02180(17 %,(1'(,17(5e6&8/785$/±7255(<02/,12'(/$&(,7(&(59(5$'(/0$(675( 02180(172 $11(;,9$1(;2,9 GH 5HVROXFLyGHG DEULOGHOD'LUHFFLy*HQHUDOGH3DWULPRQL&XOWXUDO9DOHQFLjL0XVHXVGHOD&RQVHOOHULDGH&XOWXUD(GXFDFLyL(VSRUWSHUODTXHV LQFRDH[SHGLHQWSHUDOD SULPHUD IDVH GH O DFWXDOLW]DFLy L DGDSWDFLy SDUFLDO GH OD 6HFFLy 3ULPHUD GH O ,QYHQWDUL *HQHUDO GHO 3DWULPRQL &XOWXUDO 9DOHQFLj HQ PDWqULD GH SDWULPRQL DUTXLWHFWzQLF L PHGLDPELHQWDOLV¶REULSHUtRGHG¶LQIRUPDFLyS~EOLFD 5HVROXFLyQ GH GH DEULO GH OD 'LUHFFLyQ *HQHUDO GH 3DWULPRQLR &XOWXUDO 9DOHQFLDQR \ 0XVHRV GH OD &RQVHOOHULD GH &XOWXUD (GXFDFLyQ \ 'HSRUWH SRU OD TXH VH LQFRD H[SHGLHQWH SDUD OD SULPHUD IDVH GH OD DFWXDOL]DFLyQ \ DGDSWDFLyQ SDUFLDO GH OD 6HFFLyQ 3ULPHUD GHO ,QYHQWDULR *HQHUDO GHO 3DWULPRQLR &XOWXUDO 9DOHQFLDQR HQ PDWHULD GH SDWULPRQLRDUTXLWHFWyQLFR\PHGLRDPELHQWDO\VHDEUHSHULRGRGHLQIRUPDFLyQSXEOLFD Núm. 5.503 / 02.05.2007 17910 %e'¶,17(5e6&8/785$/±3$/$8&207$/,021(67,5'(/$0$5('('e8'(/0,5$&/( &2&(17$,1$02180(17 %,(1'(,17(5e6&8/785$/3$/$&,2&21'$/<021$67(5,2'(/$9,5*(1'(/0,/$*52 &2&(17$,1$02180(172 'HQRPLQDFLy'HQRPLQDFLyQ 3ULQFLSDO3ULQFLSDO 3DODX&RPWDOL0RQHVWLUGHOD0DUHGH'pXGHO0LUDFOH 3DODFLR&RQGDO\0RQDVWHULRGHOD9LUJHQGHO0LODJUR $FFHVzULD$FFHVRULD 3DODX)RUWDOHVDGHO&RPWHVGH&RFHQWDLQDL&RQYHQW GHOHV&ODULVHV0RQHVWLUGHOD0DUHGH'pXGHO0LUDFOH 3DODFLR)RUWDOH]DGHORV&RQGHVGH&RFHQWDLQD\ &RQYHQWRGHODV&ODULVDV0RQDVWHULRGHOD9LUJHQGHO 0LODJUR /RFDOLW]DFLy/RFDOL]DFLyQ 3URYtQFLD3URYLQFLD$ODFDQW &RPDUFD&RPDUFD(O&RPWDW 0XQLFLSL0XQLFLSLR&RFHQWDLQD 8ELFDFLy8ELFDFLyQ3ODoDG (O3OD 5HIHUqQFLD&DGDVWUDO5HIHUHQFLD&DWDVWUDO ,OOD0DQ]DQD3DUFHOāOD3DUFHOD\ $QWHFHGHQWV-XUtGLFV$QWHFHGHQWHV-XUtGLFRV ,QFRDFLy,QFRDFLyQ 3XEOLFDFLyGHODLQFRDFLy3XEOLFDFLyQGHODLQFRDFLyQ 'HVFULSFLy'HVFULSFLyQ 3DUWV,QWHJUDQWV3DUWHV,QWHJUDQWHV (OSDODX(OSDODFLR (OFRQYHQW(OFRQYHQWR /¶HVJOqVLDGHO0LUDFOH/DLJOHVLDGHO0LODJUR /¶KRUW(OKXHUWR 'HFULSFLy*HQHUDO'HVFULSFLyQ*HQHUDO /¶HGLILFLGHOV&RPWHVGH&RFHQWDLQDHVWiHPSODoDWHQO DQJOHVXGRHVWIRUPDSDUWGHOUHFLQWHPXUDOODWeVXQ SDODXJzWLFLUHQDL[HQWLVWDGHFDLUHGHIHQVLXSURPRJXWSHUODIDPtOLDGHOV&RUHOODFRPWHVGH&RFHQWDLQDOHV DUPHV GHOV TXDOV HV SRGHQ YHXUH HQ OD IDoDQD L OHV GLIHUHQWV HVWDQFHV /D VHXD SODQWD pV TXDGUDGD DO YROWDQW G XQ SDWL GH ILQDOV GHO VHJOH ;9, HV UHDOLW]D QRPpV OD JDOHULD GHO FRVWDW VXG DPE SLODUV L VHPLFROXPQHVWRVFDQHVDWULEXwWD$ORQVRGH&RYDUUXELDV(OVHXFDLUHGHIHQVLXV DGYHUWL[HQOHVVHXHVWUHV WRUUHVFREHUWHVDTXDWUHDLJHVDPEPDWDFDQVLWURQHUHV/ HQWUDGDpVSHUXQGREOHDUFGHPLJSXQWVLWXDW HQODIDoDQDSULQFLSDO(QODSODQWDEDL[DHVWUREDODFDSHOOD SDODWLQDFREHUWDDPEYROWDGHFUHXHULDHQTXq GHVWDFD HO UHWDXOH GH 1LFRODX %RUUjV (Q OD SODQWD QREOH HV WURED HO 6DOy G $PEDL[DGRUV DPE VRVWUDGHV GHFRUDGHVDPEHVWXFV (QODWRUUHVXGRHVWHVWUREDOD6DOD'DXUDGDDPEYROWDGHFUHXHULDGHFRUDGDDPEIUHVFRVGHO VHJOH;9,, DOāOXVLXVDOVUHLVGH1DYDUUD(OFRQYHQWRFXSDO DODQRUGGHOSDODXLIRUPDXQDXQLWDWDPEHOPDWHL[HQFDUD TXHWpXQDFFpVSURSLSHUXQDGHOHVWRUUHVLSHUO HVJOpVLD(VGHVHQYROXSDDOYROWDQWG XQSDWLLXQKRUWRQ HV GLVSRVHQ OHV GLIHUHQWV GHSHQGqQFLHV / HVJOpVLD GHO FRQYHQW QR GHVWDFD GHV GH O H[WHULRU MD TXH QR Wp SRUWDGD L GHFRUDFLy 1R REVWDQW D O LQWHULRU Wp XQD SURIXVD GHFRUDFLy EDUURFD (V WUDFWD G XQD HVJOpVLD GH SODQWDUHFWDQJXODUG XQDVRODQDXDPEGXHVFDSHOOHVODWHUDOVGLVSRVDGHVHQODPLWDWGHODQDX(VWjFREHUWD DPE YROWD GH FDQy DPE OOXQHWHV &DO GHVWDFDU HO WUDQVSDUHQW D OD FDSoDOHUD TXH LOāOXPLQD HO SUHVELWHUL / HVJOpVLDDOEHUJDXQFRQMXQWGHSLQWXUHVUHDOLW]DWSHOQDSROLWj3DROR0DWWHLVHQDL[tFRPODWDXODGHOD 0DUHGH'pXGHO0LUDFOHG HVWLOJzWLFLQWHUQDFLRQDO%DVDWHQOD*XLDG¶$UTXLWHFWXUDGHODSURYtQFLDG¶$ODFDQW (OHGLILFLRGHORV&RQGHV GH&RFHQWDLQDHVWD HPSOD]DGR HQHOiQJXORVXGRHVWHIRUPDQGRSDUWH GHO UHFLQWR DPXUDOODGR(VXQSDODFLRJyWLFR\UHQDFHQWLVWDGHWLSRGHIHQVLYRSURPRYLGRSRUODIDPLOLDGHORV&RUHOOD &RQGHV GH &RFHQWDLQD FX\DV DUPDV VH SXHGHQ YHU HQ OD IDFKDGD \ ODV GLIHUHQWHV HVWDQFLDV 6X SODQWD HV $11(;,9$1(;2,9 GH 5HVROXFLyGHG DEULOGHOD'LUHFFLy*HQHUDOGH3DWULPRQL&XOWXUDO9DOHQFLjL0XVHXVGHOD&RQVHOOHULDGH&XOWXUD(GXFDFLyL(VSRUWSHUODTXHV LQFRDH[SHGLHQWSHUDOD SULPHUD IDVH GH O DFWXDOLW]DFLy L DGDSWDFLy SDUFLDO GH OD 6HFFLy 3ULPHUD GH O ,QYHQWDUL *HQHUDO GHO 3DWULPRQL &XOWXUDO 9DOHQFLj HQ PDWqULD GH SDWULPRQL DUTXLWHFWzQLF L PHGLDPELHQWDOLV¶REULSHUtRGHG¶LQIRUPDFLyS~EOLFD 5HVROXFLyQ GH GH DEULO GH OD 'LUHFFLyQ *HQHUDO GH 3DWULPRQLR &XOWXUDO 9DOHQFLDQR \ 0XVHRV GH OD &RQVHOOHULD GH &XOWXUD (GXFDFLyQ \ 'HSRUWH SRU OD TXH VH LQFRD H[SHGLHQWH SDUD OD SULPHUD IDVH GH OD DFWXDOL]DFLyQ \ DGDSWDFLyQ SDUFLDO GH OD 6HFFLyQ 3ULPHUD GHO ,QYHQWDULR *HQHUDO GHO 3DWULPRQLR &XOWXUDO 9DOHQFLDQR HQ PDWHULD GH SDWULPRQLRDUTXLWHFWyQLFR\PHGLRDPELHQWDO\VHDEUHSHULRGRGHLQIRUPDFLyQSXEOLFD Núm. 5.503 / 02.05.2007 17911 FXDGUDGDDOUHGHGRUGHXQSDWLR GHILQDOHV GHOVLJOR;9,UHDOL]iQGRVH VRODPHQWHOD JDOHUtDGHOODGR VXUFRQ PDFKRQHV\VHPLFROXPQDVWRVFDQDVDWULEXLGRD$ORQVRGH&RYDUUXELDV(OFDUiFWHUGHIHQVLYRVHDGYLHUWHHQ VXV WUHV WRUUHV FXELHUWDV D FXDWUR DJXDV FRQ PDWDFDQHV \ WURQHUDV /D HQWUDGD HV SRU XQ GREOH DUFR GH PHGLRSXQWRVLWXDGRHQODIDFKDGDSULQFLSDO(QODSODQWDEDMDVHHQFXHQWUDODFDSLOODSDODFLHJDFXELHUWDFRQ EyYHGDGHFUXFHUtDHQODTXHGHVWDFDHOUHWDEORGH1LFRODV%RUUiV(QODSODQWDQREOHVHHQFXHQWUDHO6DOyQ GH (PEDMDGRUHV FRQ WHFKXPEUHV GHFRUDGDV HQ HVWXFR (Q OD WRUUH VXGRHVWH VH HQFXHQWUD OD 6DOD 'RUDGD FRQ EyYHGD GH FUXFHUtD GHFRUDGD FRQ IUHVFRV GHO VLJOR ;9,, DOXVLYRV D ORV UH\HV GH 1DYDUUD (O FRQYHQWR RFXSDHODODQRUWHGHOSDODFLR\IRUPDXQDXQLGDGFRQHOPLVPRDXQTXHWLHQHXQDFFHVRSURSLRSRUXQDGH ODVWRUUHV\SRUODLJOHVLD6HGHVDUUROODDOUHGHGRUGHXQSDWLR\XQKXHUWRGRQGHVHGLVSRQHQODVGLIHUHQWHV GHSHQGHQFLDV /D LJOHVLD GHO FRQYHQWR QR WLHQH UHOHYDQFLD GHVGH HO H[WHULRU \D TXH FDUHFH GH SRUWDGD \ GHFRUDFLyQ6LQHPEDUJRDOLQWHULRUWLHQHXQDSURIXVDGHFRUDFLyQEDUURFD6HWUDWDGHXQDLJOHVLDGHSODQWD UHFWDQJXODUGHXQDVRODQDYHFRQGRVFDSLOODVODWHUDOHVGLVSXHVWDVHQODPLWDGGHODQDYH(VWiFXELHUWDFRQ EyYHGDGHFDxyQFRQOXQHWRV&DEHGHVWDFDUHOWUDQVSDUHQWHGHODFDEHFHUD TXHLOXPLQD HO SUHVELWHULR/D LJOHVLDDOEHUJDXQFRQMXQWRGHSLQWXUDVUHDOL]DGRSRUHOQDSROLWDQR3DROR0DWWHLVHQDVtFRPRODWDEOD GHOD9LUJHQGHO0LODJURGHHVWLORJyWLFRLQWHUQDFLRQDO%DVDGRHQOD*XtDGH$UTXLWHFWXUDGHOD3URYLQFLDGH $OLFDQWH 2EVHUYDFLRQV2EVHUYDFLRQHV (QWRUQ(QWRUQR $QWHFHGHQWVDGPLQLVWUDWLXVGHOLPLWDFLyH[WUHWDGHO H[SHGLHQWGHILQLGDDPEFDUjFWHUSURYLVLRQDO 2ULJHQ9qUWH[GHODPLWJHUDGHOHVSDUFHOāOHVQ~PHURVLGHODLOODGHFDVHVFDGDVWUDOQ~PTXH GyQDDOFDUUHUGHOV'RORUVGHOD0DUHGH'pXSXQW$ 6HQWLW+RUDUL /tQLD GHOLPLWDGRUD 'HV GH O RULJHQ OD OtQLD GHOLPLWDGRUD GHVFHQGL[ D VXGHVW WUDYHVVDQW OD PLWJHUD GH OHV FDVHVQ~PHURVLGHODLOODGHFDVHVQ~PLSHUO HL[GHOFDUUHU3HUH6HTXLQD*LUDDVXGSHUD FRQWLQXDUSHUOHVSRVWHULRUVGHOHVSDUFHOāOHVDPEIDoDQDDOFDUUHUGHOD0DUHGH'pXGHO0LUDFOHGHO¶LOODGH FDVHV FDGDVWUDO Q~P 7UDYHVVD HO FDUUHU GHOV $SzVWROV L FRQWLQXD HQ OD PDWHL[D GLUHFFLy SHU OD PLWJHUDHQWUHOHVFDVHVQ~PHURVLGHO¶LOODQ~PSHUODSRVWHULRUGHODQ~PLSHUODPLWJHUD GHOHVFDVHVQ~PHURVLG HVWDLOOD&UHXDHOFDUUHU6DQWVGHOD3HGUDVHJXL[SHUODPLWJHUDHQWUHOHV FDVHVQ~PHURVLGHO¶LOODQ~PFRQWLQXDSHUOHVSRVWHULRUVGHOVQ~PHURV LG HVWDLOOD&UHXDHOFDUUHUGHO3DUH/OXLV)XOODQDLHQYROWDOHVSDUFHOāOHVQ~PHURVL GHO¶LOODQ~P&UHXDHOFDUUHUGHO5RVDULLLQFORXO¶LOODQ~P&UHXDHOFDUUHUGHO%LVEH(VWDQ\jL UHFRUUHOHVIDoDQHVGHO¶LOODQ~P TXHGRQHQ DOFDUUHU GH6DQW)UDQFHVFILQVDODSDUFHOāODQ~P V LQWURGXw[HQHVWDLOODSHUODPLWJHUDVXGGHGLWDSDUFHOāODLLQFRUSRUDQWODFRQWtQXDSHUOHVSRVWHULRUVGHOHV FDVHVDGHODSODoDGHO9HQHUDEOH(VFXGHULODPLWJHUDVXGGHODSDUFHOāODQ~P&UHXDHOFDUUHUGHOV 6DQWV0HWJHVLVHJXL[DRHVWSHUODPLWJHUDVXGGHODQ~PGHO¶LOODQ~PLSHUODPLWJHUDHQWUHOHV SDUFHOāOHVQ~PHURVL&UHXDHOFDUUHUOD0HOLUHFRUUHOHVPLWJHUHVHQWUHOHVSDUFHOāOHVLLL GHO¶LOODQ~P&RQWLQXDFDSDOQRUGSHUODPLWJHUDGHOHVSDUFHOāOHVLGHO¶LOODQ~PLSHU OHVSRVWHULRUVGHOHVSDUFHOāOHVG HVWDLOODTXHGRQHQDODSODoDGHO9HQHUDEOH(VFXGHUGHVGHODDOD 3URVVHJXL[SHUOHVSRVWHULRUVGHOHVFDVHVQ~PHURVDGHO DQWHULRULOOD&UHXDHOFDUUHUGHOD6DQWtVVLPD 7ULQLWDWLFRQWLQXDSHUODPLWJHUDHQWUHOHVSDUFHOāOHVQ~PHURVLGHO¶LOODQ~PLSHUOHVPLWJHUHV HQWUHOHVSDUFHOāOHVLLLLG HVWDLOOD6HJXL[DQRUGSHOFDUUHUGH6DQW-RVHS&RQWLQXDSHU OHVSRVWHULRUVGHOHVSDUFHOāOHVDPEIDoDQDDOFDUUHUGH6DQW-RVHSLGHOV'RORUVGHOD0DUHGH'pXGHO¶LOOD FDGDVWUDO Q~P FRQWLQXD SHU OD PLWJHUD RHVW GH OD FDVD Q~P G HVWD LOOD L FUHXD HO FDUUHU GH OD 3XMDGDGHOD&RVWD,QFRUSRUDOHVSDUFHOāOHVLGHO¶LOODLFUHXDILQVDOSXQW$WDQFDQW HOSROtJRQ $QWHFHGHQWHVDGPLQLVWUDWLYRVGHOLPLWDFLyQH[WUDtGDGHOH[SHGLHQWHGHILQLGDFRQFDUiFWHUSURYLVLRQDO 2ULJHQ 9pUWLFH GH OD PHGLDQHUD GH ODV SDUFHODV Q~PHURV \ GH OD PDQ]DQD FDWDVWUDO Q UHFD\HQWHDODFDOOH'RORUHVGHOD9LUJHQSXQWR$ 6HQWLGR+RUDULR /tQHDGHOLPLWDGRUD'HVGHHORULJHQODOtQHDGHOLPLWDGRUDGHVFLHQGHDVXGHVWHDWUDYHVDQGRODPHGLDQHUDGH ODVFDVDVQ~PHURV\GHODPDQ]DQDQ\SRUHOHMHGHODFDOOH3HGUR6HTXLQD*LUDDVXUSDUD FRQWLQXDU SRU ODV WUDVHUDV GH ODV SDUFHODV FRQ IDFKDGD D OD FDOOH 0DUH GH 'HX GHO 0LUDFOH GH OD PDQ]DQD FDWDVWUDOQ$WUDYLHVDODFDOOHGHORV$SyVWROHV\FRQWLQ~DHQODPLVPDGLUHFFLyQSRUODPHGLDQHUD HQWUHODVFDVDVQ~PHURV\GHODPDQ]DQDQSRUODWUDVHUDGHODQ\SRUODPHGLDQHUDGH ODV FDVDV Q~PHURV \ GH HVWD PDQ]DQD &UX]D OD FDOOH 6DQWRV GH OD 3LHGUD VLJXH SRU OD PHGLDQHUD HQWUHODVFDVDVQ~PHURV\GHODPDQ]DQDQFRQWLQ~DSRUODVWUDVHUDVGHORVQ~PHURV \GHHVWDPDQ]DQD&UX]DODFDOOH3DGUH/XLV)XOODQD\HQYXHOYHODVSDUFHODVQ~PHURV \GH OD PDQ]DQD Q &UX]D OD FDOOH GHO 5RVDULR H LQFOX\H OD PDQ]DQD Q $11(;,9$1(;2,9 GH 5HVROXFLyGHG DEULOGHOD'LUHFFLy*HQHUDOGH3DWULPRQL&XOWXUDO9DOHQFLjL0XVHXVGHOD&RQVHOOHULDGH&XOWXUD(GXFDFLyL(VSRUWSHUODTXHV LQFRDH[SHGLHQWSHUDOD SULPHUD IDVH GH O DFWXDOLW]DFLy L DGDSWDFLy SDUFLDO GH OD 6HFFLy 3ULPHUD GH O ,QYHQWDUL *HQHUDO GHO 3DWULPRQL &XOWXUDO 9DOHQFLj HQ PDWqULD GH SDWULPRQL DUTXLWHFWzQLF L PHGLDPELHQWDOLV¶REULSHUtRGHG¶LQIRUPDFLyS~EOLFD 5HVROXFLyQ GH GH DEULO GH OD 'LUHFFLyQ *HQHUDO GH 3DWULPRQLR &XOWXUDO 9DOHQFLDQR \ 0XVHRV GH OD &RQVHOOHULD GH &XOWXUD (GXFDFLyQ \ 'HSRUWH SRU OD TXH VH LQFRD H[SHGLHQWH SDUD OD SULPHUD IDVH GH OD DFWXDOL]DFLyQ \ DGDSWDFLyQ SDUFLDO GH OD 6HFFLyQ 3ULPHUD GHO ,QYHQWDULR *HQHUDO GHO 3DWULPRQLR &XOWXUDO 9DOHQFLDQR HQ PDWHULD GH SDWULPRQLRDUTXLWHFWyQLFR\PHGLRDPELHQWDO\VHDEUHSHULRGRGHLQIRUPDFLyQSXEOLFD Núm. 5.503 / 02.05.2007 17912 &UX]D OD FDOOH 2ELVSR (VWDxi \ UHFRUUH ODV IDFKDGDV GH OD PDQ]DQD Q UHFD\HQWHV D OD FDOOH 6DQ )UDQFLVFR KDVWD OD SDUFHOD Q VH LQWURGXFH HQ HVWD PDQ]DQD SRU OD PHGLDQHUD VXU GH HVWD SDUFHOD H LQFRUSRUiQGRODFRQWLQXDSRUODVWUDVHUDVGHODVFDVDVDGHODSOD]D9HQHUDEOH(VFXGHU\ODPHGLDQHUD VXUGHODSDUFHODQ&UX]DODFDOOH6DQWRV0pGLFRV\VLJXHDRHVWHSRUODPHGLDQHUDVXUGHODQGHOD PDQ]DQDQ\SRUODPHGLDQHUDHQWUHODVSDUFHODVQ~PHURV\&UX]DODFDOOHOD0LHO\UHFRUUH ODVPHGLDQHUDVHQWUHODVSDUFHODV\\\GHODPDQ]DQDQ&RQWLQ~DKDFLDHOQRUWHSRUOD PHGLDQHUD GH ODV SDUFHODV \ GH OD PDQ]DQD Q \ SRU ODV WUDVHUDV GH ODV SDUFHODV GH HVWD PDQ]DQD UHFD\HQWHV D OD SOD]D 9HQHUDEOH (VFXGHU GHVGH OD D OD 3URVLJXH SRU ODV WUDVHUDV GH ODV FDVDV Q~PHURV D GH OD DQWHULRU PDQ]DQD &UX]D OD FDOOH 6DQWtVLPD 7ULQLGDG \ FRQWLQ~D SRU OD PHGLDQHUD HQWUH ODV SDUFHODV Q~PHURV \ GH OD PDQ]DQD Q \ SRU ODV PHGLDQHUDV HQWUH ODV SDUFHODV\\\\GHHVWDPDQ]DQD6LJXHDQRUWHSRUODFDOOH6DQ-RVp&RQWLQ~DSRUODV WUDVHUDVGHODVSDUFHODVFRQIDFKDGDDODFDOOH6DQ-RVp\'RORUHVGHOD9LUJHQGHODPDQ]DQDFDWDVWUDOQ FRQWLQ~D SRU OD PHGLDQHUD RHVWH GH OD FDVD Q GH HVWD PDQ]DQD \ FUX]D OD FDOOH 6XELGD GH OD &XHVWD,QFRUSRUDODVSDUFHODV\GHODPDQ]DQD\FUX]DKDVWDHOSXQWR$FHUUDQGR HOSROtJRQR $11(;,9$1(;2,9 GH 5HVROXFLyGHG DEULOGHOD'LUHFFLy*HQHUDOGH3DWULPRQL&XOWXUDO9DOHQFLjL0XVHXVGHOD&RQVHOOHULDGH&XOWXUD(GXFDFLyL(VSRUWSHUODTXHV LQFRDH[SHGLHQWSHUDOD SULPHUD IDVH GH O DFWXDOLW]DFLy L DGDSWDFLy SDUFLDO GH OD 6HFFLy 3ULPHUD GH O ,QYHQWDUL *HQHUDO GHO 3DWULPRQL &XOWXUDO 9DOHQFLj HQ PDWqULD GH SDWULPRQL DUTXLWHFWzQLF L PHGLDPELHQWDOLV¶REULSHUtRGHG¶LQIRUPDFLyS~EOLFD 5HVROXFLyQ GH GH DEULO GH OD 'LUHFFLyQ *HQHUDO GH 3DWULPRQLR &XOWXUDO 9DOHQFLDQR \ 0XVHRV GH OD &RQVHOOHULD GH &XOWXUD (GXFDFLyQ \ 'HSRUWH SRU OD TXH VH LQFRD H[SHGLHQWH SDUD OD SULPHUD IDVH GH OD DFWXDOL]DFLyQ \ DGDSWDFLyQ SDUFLDO GH OD 6HFFLyQ 3ULPHUD GHO ,QYHQWDULR *HQHUDO GHO 3DWULPRQLR &XOWXUDO 9DOHQFLDQR HQ PDWHULD GH SDWULPRQLRDUTXLWHFWyQLFR\PHGLRDPELHQWDO\VHDEUHSHULRGRGHLQIRUPDFLyQSXEOLFD Núm. 5.503 / 02.05.2007 17913 %e'¶,17(5e6&8/785$/±3$/$8&207$/,021(67,5'(/$0$5('('e8'(/0,5$&/( &2&(17$,1$02180(17 %,(1'(,17(5e6&8/785$/3$/$&,2&21'$/<021$67(5,2'(/$9,5*(1'(/0,/$*52 &2&(17$,1$02180(172 $11(;,9$1(;2,9 GH 5HVROXFLyGHG DEULOGHOD'LUHFFLy*HQHUDOGH3DWULPRQL&XOWXUDO9DOHQFLjL0XVHXVGHOD&RQVHOOHULDGH&XOWXUD(GXFDFLyL(VSRUWSHUODTXHV LQFRDH[SHGLHQWSHUDOD SULPHUD IDVH GH O DFWXDOLW]DFLy L DGDSWDFLy SDUFLDO GH OD 6HFFLy 3ULPHUD GH O ,QYHQWDUL *HQHUDO GHO 3DWULPRQL &XOWXUDO 9DOHQFLj HQ PDWqULD GH SDWULPRQL DUTXLWHFWzQLF L PHGLDPELHQWDOLV¶REULSHUtRGHG¶LQIRUPDFLyS~EOLFD 5HVROXFLyQ GH GH DEULO GH OD 'LUHFFLyQ *HQHUDO GH 3DWULPRQLR &XOWXUDO 9DOHQFLDQR \ 0XVHRV GH OD &RQVHOOHULD GH &XOWXUD (GXFDFLyQ \ 'HSRUWH SRU OD TXH VH LQFRD H[SHGLHQWH SDUD OD SULPHUD IDVH GH OD DFWXDOL]DFLyQ \ DGDSWDFLyQ SDUFLDO GH OD 6HFFLyQ 3ULPHUD GHO ,QYHQWDULR *HQHUDO GHO 3DWULPRQLR &XOWXUDO 9DOHQFLDQR HQ PDWHULD GH SDWULPRQLRDUTXLWHFWyQLFR\PHGLRDPELHQWDO\VHDEUHSHULRGRGHLQIRUPDFLyQSXEOLFD Núm. 5.503 / 02.05.2007 17914 %e'¶,17(5e6&8/785$/±$-817$0(17)25&$//02180(17 %,(1'(,17(5e6&8/785$/$<817$0,(172)25&$//02180(172 'HQRPLQDFLy'HQRPLQDFLyQ 3ULQFLSDO3ULQFLSDO $MXQWDPHQW&DVDGHOD9LOD $\XQWDPLHQWR $FFHVVzULD$FFHVRULD &DVDGHOHV(VFDOHWHV &DVDGHODV(VFDOHULWDV /RFDOLW]DFLy/RFDOL]DFLyQ 3URYtQFLD3URYLQFLD&DVWHOOy &RPDUFD&RPDUFD(OV3RUWV 0XQLFLSL0XQLFLSLR)RUFDOO 8ELFDFLy8ELFDFLyQ3ODoD0DMRU 5HIHUqQFLD&DGDVWUDO5HIHUHQFLD&DWDVWUDO ,OOD0DQ]DQD3DUFHOāOD3DUFHOD\ $QWHFHGHQWV-XUtGLFV$QWHFHGHQWHV-XUtGLFRV ,QFRDFLy,QFRVFLyQ 3XEOLFDFLyGHODLQFRDFLy3XEOLFDFLyQGHODLQFRDFLyQ%2( 'HVFULSFLy'HVFULSFLyQ 3DUWV,QWHJUDQWV3DUWHV,QWHJUDQWHV − / DQWLJDFRQIUDULDGH6DQW0LTXHO /DDQWLJXDFRIUDGtDGH6DQ0LJXHO − (GLILFLGHWUHVDOWXUHVQRFRLQFLGHQWVDPEOHVGHODFRQIUDULDHQODSODQWDEDL[DO DQWLFGLSzVLWLSUHVRQV GDOWXQHVTXDQWHVGHSHQGqQFLHVLSHUXOWLPXQjWLF (GLILFLRGHWUHVDOWXUDVQRFRLQFLGHQWHVFRQODVGHOD − − − − − − − − − FRIUDGtDHQOD SODQWDEDMDHODQWLJXRGHSyVLWR\FiUFHOHVHQFLPDYDULDVGHSHQGHQFLDV\SRUXOWLPRXQ iWLFR /D/ORWMDKXL+RVWDO/D/RQMDKR\0HVyQ / $MXQWDPHQW(O$\XQWDPLHQWR )DoDQDVLVFHQWLVWD)DFKDGDVHLVFHQWLVWD (VFDODG DFFpVG DQDGDLWRUQDGD(VFDOHUDGHDFFHVRGHLGD\YXHOWD /D7RUUDVVDGHSHGUDWDOODGD(O7RUUHyQGHFDQWHUtD / HVSDGDQ\D/DHVSDGDxD (OPXUDOGHODIDoDQDUHVWDXUDWHQO LQWHULRU(OPXUDOGHODIDFKDGDUHVWDXUDGRHQHOLQWHULRU / HVFXWKHUjOGLFTXHGDWDGH(OHVFXGRKHUiOGLFRTXHGDWDGH )RUQtFXODGHSULPHUDPLWDWGHOVHJOH;;+RUQDFLQDGHSULPHUDPLWDGGHOVLJOR;; 'HVFULSFLy*HQHUDO'HVFULSFLyQ*HQHUDO / $MXQWDPHQWHVFRPSRQGHGRVHGLILFLV HO SULPLWLX$MXQWDPHQW TXHGLVSRVDYD G XQDOORWMDHQSODQD EDL[D TXHGyQDDODSODoD0DMRULOD&RQIUDULDGH6DQW0LTXHOTXHGyQDDODSODoDGHOPDWHL[QRPLDOFDUUHUGHOD 3LORWDRFDUUHU)RUW (OSULPLWLX$MXQWDPHQWpVODSDUWPpVDQWLJDGLVSRVDG XQUHFLQWHG DUFXDFLRQVHQSODQWDEDL[DDFWXDOPHQW RFXSDGHVSHUO +RVWDO6REUHODGLWDOORWMDKLKDGXHVDOWXUHV PpVXQDpVODSODQWDQREOHDTXqV DFFHGL[D WUDYpV GH O HVFDOD G DQDGD L WRUQDGD VLVFHQWLVWD L OD VXSHULRU XWLOLW]DGD FRP D PDJDW]HP / DVSHFWH TXH SUHVHQWDULD O DQWLF DMXQWDPHQW DEDQV GH OD UHIRUPD GHO VHJOH ;9,, HVWDULD HVWUHWDPHQW UHODFLRQDW DPE HOV DMXQWDPHQWVGH&DWt0RUHOOD9LODIUDQFDL(O7RUREDVVDWVHQODGLVSRVLFLyG¶XQDOORWMDEDL[LVDOHVFRPXQDOV HQ OD SODQWD VXSHULRU (O UHFLQWH GH O DQWLJD &RQIUDULD GH 6DQW 0LTXHO TXH MD H[LVWLD D ILQDOV GHO VHJOH ;9 VHJRQVFRQVWDGRFXPHQWDOPHQWpVXQDVDODFRPSRVWDSHUWUHVFUXJLHVDPEGRVDUFVLSLODUHQHOFHQWUHGH FDGDXQDG HOOHV6REUHODVDODGHOHVDFWXDFLRQVHVWjODVDOD PpVLPSRUWDQWDPEXQWHL[LQDWTXHVXVWHQWHQ GRV SLODUV GH VHFFLy RFWRJRQDO 6HPEOD TXH HVWD VDOD YD VHU XWLOLW]DGD FRP D OORF GH UHXQLRQV GHO &RQVHOO V¶XQHL[DODSODQWDQREOHGHO $MXQWDPHQWDWUDYpVG XQDHVFDOD/DIDoDQDUHFDXDODSODoDGHOD&RQIUDULD HQHOOD GHVWDFDO DUFGHPLJ SXQW VREUHHOTXDOV XELFD XQD IRUQtFXOD (O FDUUHX V XWLOLW]D HQ O DFFpV L HQ HOV FDQWRQVODUHVWDpVGHPDoRQHULD(OUjIHFG LQIOXqQFLDDUDJRQHVDpVGHOVHJOH;9,, / DQWLF$MXQWDPHQWYDSDWLUXQDUHIRUPDDSULQFLSLVGHOVHJOH;9,,(QHVGXDWHUPHO REUDQRYDGHOD IDoDQD TXH GyQD D OD SODoD 0DMRU /D QRYD IDoDQD FRQVLVWL[ HQ XQ FRV FHQWUDO TXH V DOoD D PDQHUD GH WRUUDVVDUHPDWDGDDPEXQDHVSDGDQ\D(VWDGHSHGUDWDOODGDHVPRVWUDKXLFRPSOHWDGDSHUXQDDOWUDGH $11(;,9$1(;2,9 GH 5HVROXFLyGHG DEULOGHOD'LUHFFLy*HQHUDOGH3DWULPRQL&XOWXUDO9DOHQFLjL0XVHXVGHOD&RQVHOOHULDGH&XOWXUD(GXFDFLyL(VSRUWSHUODTXHV LQFRDH[SHGLHQWSHUDOD SULPHUD IDVH GH O DFWXDOLW]DFLy L DGDSWDFLy SDUFLDO GH OD 6HFFLy 3ULPHUD GH O ,QYHQWDUL *HQHUDO GHO 3DWULPRQL &XOWXUDO 9DOHQFLj HQ PDWqULD GH SDWULPRQL DUTXLWHFWzQLF L PHGLDPELHQWDOLV¶REULSHUtRGHG¶LQIRUPDFLyS~EOLFD 5HVROXFLyQ GH GH DEULO GH OD 'LUHFFLyQ *HQHUDO GH 3DWULPRQLR &XOWXUDO 9DOHQFLDQR \ 0XVHRV GH OD &RQVHOOHULD GH &XOWXUD (GXFDFLyQ \ 'HSRUWH SRU OD TXH VH LQFRD H[SHGLHQWH SDUD OD SULPHUD IDVH GH OD DFWXDOL]DFLyQ \ DGDSWDFLyQ SDUFLDO GH OD 6HFFLyQ 3ULPHUD GHO ,QYHQWDULR *HQHUDO GHO 3DWULPRQLR &XOWXUDO 9DOHQFLDQR HQ PDWHULD GH SDWULPRQLRDUTXLWHFWyQLFR\PHGLRDPELHQWDO\VHDEUHSHULRGRGHLQIRUPDFLyQSXEOLFD Núm. 5.503 / 02.05.2007 17915 IHUURLQVWDOāODGDHQ/ DFFpVDODSODQWDQREOHWpOORFD WUDYpVG XQDHVFDODG DQDGDLWRUQDGDDPEGRV WLUVFRQWUDSRVDWVTXHFRQIOXw[HQHQODSRUWDSULQFLSDOG DUFDGRYHOODWDPEO HVFXWGHOD9LOD(OEXLWGHO HVFDOD pVXQDUFG DFFpVDODOORWMDTXHV XWLOLW]DYDFRPDOPRGt(VWjUHIRUPDWDPEpDIHFWDDOHVFREHUWHVWUDFWDQW GHGRQDUPDMRUXQLWDWDOVGRVHGLILFLV6yQG HVWDPDWHL[DqSRFDHOUjIHFLODIXVWHULDGHOHVSRUWHVLILQHVWUHV GHVWDFDQW VREUHWRW OD SRUWD SULQFLSDO %DVDW HQ O (VWXGL 3UHYL SDUWLFXODULW]DW GH O $QWLF $MXQWDPHQW DXWRUV &XOOD'XDOGHL*LODUTXLWHFWHV (O$\XQWDPLHQWRVHFRPSRQHGHGRVHGLILFLRVHOSULPLWLYR$\XQWDPLHQWRTXHGLVSRQtDGHXQDORQMDHQSODQD EDMDUHFD\HQWHDODSOD]D0DMRU\OD&RQIUDULDGH6DQW0LTXHOUHFD\HQWHDODSOD]DGHOPLVPRQRPEUH\DOD FDOOHGHOD3LORWDRFDOOH)RUW (O SULPLWLYR $\XQWDPLHQWR HV OD SDUWH PiV DQWLJXD GLVSRQH GH XQ UHFLQWR GH DUTXHUtDV HQ SODQWD EDMD DFWXDOPHQWHRFXSDGDVSRUHO0HVyQ6REUHGLFKDORQMDKD\GRVDOWXUDVPiVXQDHVODSODQWDQREOHDODTXH VH DFFHGH D WUDYpV GH OD HVFDOHUD GH LGD \ YXHOWD VHLVFHQWLVWD \ OD VXSHULRU XWLOL]DGD FRPR DOPDFpQ (O DVSHFWRTXHSUHVHQWDUtDHODQWLJXRD\XQWDPLHQWRDQWHVGHODUHIRUPD GHOVLJOR;9,, HVWDUtD HVWUHFKDPHQWH UHODFLRQDGRFRQORVD\XQWDPLHQWRVGH&DWt0RUHOOD9LODIUDQFD\(O7RURHQEDVHDGLVSRQHUXQDORQMDDEDMR \VDODVFRPXQDOHVHQODSODQWDVXSHULRU (O UHFLQWR GH OD DQWLJXD &RQIUDULD GH 6DQW 0LTXHO TXH \D H[LVWtD D ILQDOHV GHO VLJOR ;9 VHJ~Q FRQVWD GRFXPHQWDOPHQWHHVXQDVDODFRPSXHVWDSRUWUHVFUXMtDVFRQGRVDUFRV\SLODUHQHOFHQWURGHFDGDXQDGH HOODV 6REUH OD VDOD GH ODV DUTXHUtDV HVWi OD VDOD PiV LPSRUWDQWH FRQ XQ DUWHVRQDGR TXH VXVWHQWDQ GRV SLODUHV GH VHFFLyQ RFWRJRQDO 3DUHFH TXH HVWD VDOD IXH XWLOL]DGD FRPR OXJDU GH UHXQLRQHV GHO &RQVHOO XQLpQGRVHDOD SODQWDQREOH GHOD\XQWDPLHQWR DWUDYpV GHXQD HVFDOHUD /DIDFKDGDUHFDHDODSOD]DGHOD &RQIUDULDHQHOODGHVWDFDHODUFRGHPHGLRSXQWRVREUHHOTXH VHXELFDXQDKRUQDFLQD/DVLOOHUtDVHXWLOL]D HQHODFFHVR\HQODVHVTXLQDVVLHQGRHOUHVWRGHPDPSRVWHUtD(ODOHURGHLQIOXHQFLDDUDJRQHVDHVGHOVLJOR ;9,, (O DQWLJXR $\XQWDPLHQWR VXIULy XQD UHIRUPD D SULQFLSLRV GHO VLJOR ;9,, (Q VH OOHYR D FDER OD REUD QXHYDGHODIDFKDGDUHFD\HQWHDODSOD]D0DMRU/DQXHYDIDFKDGDFRQVLVWtDHQXQFXHUSRFHQWUDOTXHVHDO]D DPRGRGHWRUUHyQUHPDWDGRFRQXQDHVSDGDxD(VWDGHFDQWHUtDVHPXHVWUDKR\FRPSOHWDGDSRURWUDGH KLHUURLQVWDODGDHQ(ODFFHVRDDOSODQWDQREOHWLHQHOXJDUDWUDYpVGHXQDHVFDOHUDGHLGD\YXHOWDFRQ GRVWLURVFRQWUDSXHVWRVTXHFRQIOX\HQHQODSXHUWDSULQFLSDOGHDUFRGRYHODGRFRQHOHVFXGRGHOD9LOOD(O KXHFRGHODHVFDOHUDHVXQDUFRGHDFFHVRDODORQMDTXHVHXWLOL]DEDFRPRDOPXGtQ(VWiUHIRUPDWDPELpQ DIHFWRDODVFXELHUWDVWUDWDQGRGHGDUPD\RUXQLGDGDORVGRVHGLILFLRV6RQGHHVWDPLVPDpSRFDHODOHUR\ OD FDUSLQWHUtD GH ODV SXHUWDV \ YHQWDQDV GHVWDFDQGR VREUHWRGR OD SXHUWD SULQFLSDO %DVDGR HQ HO (VWXGLR 3UHYLRSDUWLFXODUL]DGRGHO$QWLJXR$\XQWDPLHQWRDXWRUHV&XOOD'XDOGH\*LODUTXLWHFWRV 2EVHUYDFLRQV2EVHUYDFLRQHV (QWRUQ(QWRUQR $QWHFHGHQWVDGPLQLVWUDWLXVGHOLPLWDFLyH[WUHWDGHO H[SHGLHQWGHILQLGDDPEFDUjFWHUSURYLVLRQDO 2ULJHQ,QWHUVHFFLyGHOHVSDUFHOāOHVLHQOHVVHXHVIDoDQHVQRUGTXHGRQHQDOFDUUHU&RUPXOOGHO¶LOOD GHFDVHVQ~PSXQW$ 6HQWLW+RUDUL /tQLDGHOLPLWDGRUDODOtQLDGHOLPLWDGRUDFRQWLQXDLQFRUSRUDQWOHVSDUFHOāOHVGHO¶LOODGHFDVHVQ~P &RQWtQXDSHUODIDoDQDQRUGGHODSDUFHOāODQ~PSHUWDQ\HQWDO¶LOODLQFORXOHV SDUFHOāOHV LGHODPDWHL[DLOODSURVVHJXLQWSHUODPLWJHUDG HVWD~OWLPDSDUFHOāODILQVDFUHXDUHOFDUUHUGHO &DUPH6 LQWURGXw[HQO¶LOODSHUODPLWJHUDGHOHVSDUFHOāOHVLLVHJXL[SHUOHVSRVWHULRUVGHOHV SDUFHOāOHVLLSHUODPLWJHUDHQWUHOHVL&UHXDHOFDUUHU)RUQLSURVVHJXL[SHUO¶LOODHQWUH OHVSDUFHOāOHVLSHUOHVSRVWHULRUVGHOHVSDUFHOāOHVLODPLWJHUDRHVWGHODSDUFHOāODILQV DO FDUUHU GHOV 'HVHPSDUDWV &UHXD HVWD L FRQWLQXD WUDYHVVDQW O¶LOOD HQWUH OHV SDUFHOāOHV L OHV SRVWHULRUVGHOHVSDUFHOāOHVL&UHXDHOFDUUHUGHOV'RORUVFRQWLQXDQWDWUDYpVGHO¶LOODHQWUH OHVSDUFHOāOHVLLL&UHXDHOFDUUHU&RQVRODFLyFRQWLQXDQWSHUO¶LOODHQWUHODPLWJHUDGHOHV SDUFHOāOHV L L FRQWLQXDQW FDS D O RHVW SHU OD SRVWHULRU GH OD SDUFHOāOD ILQV DO FDUUHU GH 7RPHX 6DOYDGRU7UDYHVVDO¶LOODSHUOHVSRVWHULRUVGHOHVSDUFHOāOHVLFUHXDQWOD3ODoD0DMRULVHJXLQWD WUDYpVGHO¶LOODLQFRUSRUDOHVSDUFHOāOHVL&UHXDHOFDUUHUGH6DQW9LFHQW VHJXLQW FDS DO QRUG SHU OD PLWJHUD GH OHV SDUFHOāOHV L GH O¶LOOD YRUHMDQW HVWD ~OWLPD L GHVHPERFDQW HQ HO FDUUHU GH 6DQW $QWRQL VHJXLQW HO VHX HL[ FDS DO QRUG ILQV D UHSUHQGUH O¶LOOD FDGDVWUDO HQODSDUHWPLWJHUDGHOHVSDUFHOāOHVDPEOHVLHVWDDPEOHVSDUFHOāOHVL&UHXDHO FDUUHUGH6DQW9LFWRUV HQGLQVDHQO¶LOODHQWUHOHVSDUFHOāOHVLVHQWLWQRUGILQVDFRQFORXUHHQ HOSXQWG RULJHQ$ $QWHFHGHQWHVDGPLQLVWUDWLYRVGHOLPLWDFLyQH[WUDtGDGHOH[SHGLHQWHGHILQLGDFRQFDUiFWHUSURYLVLRQDO 2ULJHQ ,QWHUVHFFLyQ GH ODV SDUFHODV \ HQ VXV IDFKDGDV QRUWH UHFD\HQWHV D OD FDOOH &RUPXOO GH OD $11(;,9$1(;2,9 GH 5HVROXFLyGHG DEULOGHOD'LUHFFLy*HQHUDOGH3DWULPRQL&XOWXUDO9DOHQFLjL0XVHXVGHOD&RQVHOOHULDGH&XOWXUD(GXFDFLyL(VSRUWSHUODTXHV LQFRDH[SHGLHQWSHUDOD SULPHUD IDVH GH O DFWXDOLW]DFLy L DGDSWDFLy SDUFLDO GH OD 6HFFLy 3ULPHUD GH O ,QYHQWDUL *HQHUDO GHO 3DWULPRQL &XOWXUDO 9DOHQFLj HQ PDWqULD GH SDWULPRQL DUTXLWHFWzQLF L PHGLDPELHQWDOLV¶REULSHUtRGHG¶LQIRUPDFLyS~EOLFD 5HVROXFLyQ GH GH DEULO GH OD 'LUHFFLyQ *HQHUDO GH 3DWULPRQLR &XOWXUDO 9DOHQFLDQR \ 0XVHRV GH OD &RQVHOOHULD GH &XOWXUD (GXFDFLyQ \ 'HSRUWH SRU OD TXH VH LQFRD H[SHGLHQWH SDUD OD SULPHUD IDVH GH OD DFWXDOL]DFLyQ \ DGDSWDFLyQ SDUFLDO GH OD 6HFFLyQ 3ULPHUD GHO ,QYHQWDULR *HQHUDO GHO 3DWULPRQLR &XOWXUDO 9DOHQFLDQR HQ PDWHULD GH SDWULPRQLRDUTXLWHFWyQLFR\PHGLRDPELHQWDO\VHDEUHSHULRGRGHLQIRUPDFLyQSXEOLFD Núm. 5.503 / 02.05.2007 17916 PDQ]DQDQSXQWR$ 6HQWLGR+RUDULR /tQHDGHOLPLWDGRUD/DOtQHDGHOLPLWDGRUDVLJXHLQFRUSRUDQGRODVSDUFHODVGHODPDQ]DQD &RQWLQXDSRUODIDFKDGDQRUWHGHODSDUFHODSHUWHQHFLHQWHDODPDQ]DQDLQFOX\HODVSDUFHODV \ GH OD PLVPD PDQ]DQD SURVLJXLHQGR SRU OD PHGLDQHUD GH HVWD ~OWLPD SDUFHOD KDVWD FUX]DU OD FDOOHGHO&DUPHQ6HLQWURGXFHHQODPDQ]DQDSRUODPHGLDQHUDGHODVSDUFHODV\\VLJXHSRU ODVWUDVHUDVGHODVSDUFHODV\\SRUODPHGLDQHUDHQWUHODV\&UX]DODFDOOH)RUQ\SURVLJXHSRU ODPDQ]DQDHQWUHODVSDUFHODV\SRUODVWUDVHUDV GHODVSDUFHODV\ODPHGLDQHUD RHVWHGHODSDUFHODKDVWDODFDOOH'HVHPSDUDWV&UX]DpVWD \ FRQWLQ~D DWUDYHVDQGR OD PDQ]DQD HQWUH ODV SDUFHODV \ ODV WUDVHUDV GH ODV SDUFHODV \ &UX]D OD FDOOH 'RORUV FRQWLQXDQGR D WUDYpVGHODPDQ]DQDHQWUHODVSDUFHODV\\\&UX]DODFDOOH&RQVRODFLyFRQWLQXDQGRSRU ODPDQ]DQDHQWUHODPHGLDQHUDGHODVSDUFHODV\\FRQWLQXDQGRKDFLDHORHVWHSRUODWUDVHUDGH ODSDUFHODKDVWDODFDOOH7RPiV6DOYDGRU$WUDYLHVDODPDQ]DQDSRUODVWUDVHUDVGHODVSDUFHODV \FUX]DQGROD3ODoD0DMRU\VLJXLHQGRDWUDYpVGHODPDQ]DQDLQFRUSRUDODVSDUFHODV \&UX]DODFDOOH6DQW9LFHQWVLJXLHQGRKDFLDHOQRUWHSRUODPHGLDQHUDGHODVSDUFHODV \GHODPDQ]DQDQERUGHDQGRHVWD~OWLPD\GHVHPERFDQGRHQODFDOOH6DQW$QWRQLVLJXLHQGRVX HMHKDFLDHOQRUWHKDVWDUHWRPDUODPDQ]DQDHQODPHGLDQHUtDGHODVSDUFHODVFRQODV\ pVWD FRQ ODV SDUFHODV \ &UX]D OD FDOOH 6DQW 9LFWRU VH DGHQWUD HQ OD PDQ]DQD Q HQWUH ODV SDUFHODV\VHQWLGRQRUWHKDVWDFRQFOXLUHQHOSXQWRGHRULJHQ$ $11(;,9$1(;2,9 GH 5HVROXFLyGHG DEULOGHOD'LUHFFLy*HQHUDOGH3DWULPRQL&XOWXUDO9DOHQFLjL0XVHXVGHOD&RQVHOOHULDGH&XOWXUD(GXFDFLyL(VSRUWSHUODTXHV LQFRDH[SHGLHQWSHUDOD SULPHUD IDVH GH O DFWXDOLW]DFLy L DGDSWDFLy SDUFLDO GH OD 6HFFLy 3ULPHUD GH O ,QYHQWDUL *HQHUDO GHO 3DWULPRQL &XOWXUDO 9DOHQFLj HQ PDWqULD GH SDWULPRQL DUTXLWHFWzQLF L PHGLDPELHQWDOLV¶REULSHUtRGHG¶LQIRUPDFLyS~EOLFD 5HVROXFLyQ GH GH DEULO GH OD 'LUHFFLyQ *HQHUDO GH 3DWULPRQLR &XOWXUDO 9DOHQFLDQR \ 0XVHRV GH OD &RQVHOOHULD GH &XOWXUD (GXFDFLyQ \ 'HSRUWH SRU OD TXH VH LQFRD H[SHGLHQWH SDUD OD SULPHUD IDVH GH OD DFWXDOL]DFLyQ \ DGDSWDFLyQ SDUFLDO GH OD 6HFFLyQ 3ULPHUD GHO ,QYHQWDULR *HQHUDO GHO 3DWULPRQLR &XOWXUDO 9DOHQFLDQR HQ PDWHULD GH SDWULPRQLRDUTXLWHFWyQLFR\PHGLRDPELHQWDO\VHDEUHSHULRGRGHLQIRUPDFLyQSXEOLFD Núm. 5.503 / 02.05.2007 17917 %e'¶,17(5e6&8/785$/±$-817$0(17)25&$//02180(17 %,(1'(,17(5e6&8/785$/$<817$0,(172)25&$//02180(172 $11(;,9$1(;2,9 GH 5HVROXFLyGHG DEULOGHOD'LUHFFLy*HQHUDOGH3DWULPRQL&XOWXUDO9DOHQFLjL0XVHXVGHOD&RQVHOOHULDGH&XOWXUD(GXFDFLyL(VSRUWSHUODTXHV LQFRDH[SHGLHQWSHUDOD SULPHUD IDVH GH O DFWXDOLW]DFLy L DGDSWDFLy SDUFLDO GH OD 6HFFLy 3ULPHUD GH O ,QYHQWDUL *HQHUDO GHO 3DWULPRQL &XOWXUDO 9DOHQFLj HQ PDWqULD GH SDWULPRQL DUTXLWHFWzQLF L PHGLDPELHQWDOLV¶REULSHUtRGHG¶LQIRUPDFLyS~EOLFD 5HVROXFLyQ GH GH DEULO GH OD 'LUHFFLyQ *HQHUDO GH 3DWULPRQLR &XOWXUDO 9DOHQFLDQR \ 0XVHRV GH OD &RQVHOOHULD GH &XOWXUD (GXFDFLyQ \ 'HSRUWH SRU OD TXH VH LQFRD H[SHGLHQWH SDUD OD SULPHUD IDVH GH OD DFWXDOL]DFLyQ \ DGDSWDFLyQ SDUFLDO GH OD 6HFFLyQ 3ULPHUD GHO ,QYHQWDULR *HQHUDO GHO 3DWULPRQLR &XOWXUDO 9DOHQFLDQR HQ PDWHULD GH SDWULPRQLRDUTXLWHFWyQLFR\PHGLRDPELHQWDO\VHDEUHSHULRGRGHLQIRUPDFLyQSXEOLFD Núm. 5.503 / 02.05.2007 17918 /¶2//(5,$02180(17 %,(1'(,17(5e6&8/785$/±,*/(6,$3$55248,$/'(6$17$0$5Ë$0$*'$/(1$ /¶2//(5,$02180(172 'HQRPLQDFLy'HQRPLQDFLyQ 3ULQFLSDO3ULQFLSDO (VJOpVLD3DUURTXLDOGH6DQWD0DULD0DJGDOHQD ,JOHVLD3DUURTXLDOGH6DQWD0DUtD0DJGDOHQD /RFDOLW]DFLy/RFDOL]DFLyQ 3URYtQFLD3URYLQFLD9DOqQFLD &RPDUFD&RPDUFD/D9DOOG¶$OEDLGD 0XQLFLSL0XQLFLSLR/¶2OOHULD 8ELFDFLy8ELFDFLyQ&DUUHUGHO¶(VJOpVLD 5HIHUqQFLD&DGDVWUDO5HIHUHQFLD&DWDVWUDO ,OOD0DQ]DQD3DUFHOāOD3DUFHOD $QWHFHGHQWV-XUtGLFV$QWHFHGHQWHV-XUtGLFRV ,QFRDFLy,QFRDFLyQ 3XEOLFDFLyGHODLQFRDFLy3XEOLFDFLyQGHODLQFRDFLyQ%2( 'HVFULSFLy'HVFULSFLyQ 3DUWV,QWHJUDQWV3DUWHV,QWHJUDQWHV − 1DXFHQWUDOGHTXDWUHWUDPV1DYHFHQWUDOGHFXDWURWUDPRV − $EVLVSROLJRQDOÈEVLGHSROLJRQDO − &DSHOOHVHQWUHFRQWUDIRUWV&DSLOODVHQWUHFRQWUDIXHUWHV − 7RUUHFDPSDQDU7RUUHFDPSDQDULR − (VFDOLQDWDFHQWUDO(VFDOLQDWDFHQWUDO − &ULSWD&ULSWD 'HVFULSFLy*HQHUDO'HVFULSFLyQ*HQHUDO (VWUREDVLWXDGDDO HVWGHOQXFOLDQWLF(VGHVFRQHL[ODGDWDGHODVHXDFRQVWUXFFLySUREDEOHPHQWGHVSUpVGH OD*XHUUD GHOHV*HUPDQLHVLDEDQVGHMDTXHHQHL[H DQ\ DSDUHL[DQRPHQDGDHQOHV YLVLWHV SDVWRUDOV(VWUDFWDG XQDHVJOpVLDG XQDVRODQDXGLYLGLGDHQTXDWUHWUDPVFREHUWVDPEYROWDGHFUHXHULD DPEFDSHOOHVHQWUHFRQWUDIRUWVLFDSoDOHUDSROLJRQDOFREHUWDDPEYROWDHVWUHODGD/DFDSHOODGHOD&RPXQLy HQHOFRVWDWGHO HStVWRODSUHVHQWDXQDF~SXOD7DQWHVWDFDSHOODFRPODVDJULVWLDLHOUHUHVDJUDULVyQG XQD qSRFDSRVWHULRUUHDOLW]DWVHQWUHHOVVHJOHV;9,,L;9,,,MDTXHSUHVHQWHQXQDIjEULFDGLIHUHQW3UREDEOHPHQW HOWHUUDWUpPROGHYDDIHFWDUODYROWDGHO HVJOpVLDLYDVHUDOHVKRUHVTXDQHVYDQUHDOLW]DUUHIRUPHVDO JXVWGHO qSRFD3HUDL[zSUHVHQWDXQDVqULHG HVWXFVLSLQWXUHVEDUURTXHV$O H[WHULRUGHVWDFDODIDoDQDLOD WRUUH VLWXDGD D OD GUHWD DPEGXHV UHPDWDGHV SHU XQ HPPHUOHWDW GHFRUDWLX /D SRUWDGD D PDQHUD G DUF WULRPIDOGREOHSUHVHQWD HQHOVIODQFV VHPLFROXPQHVHQWUHOHVTXHHV GLVSRVHQ YHQHUHV (V FRPELQHQ HQ OD SRUWDGDHOVWUHVRUGHQVDUTXLWHFWzQLFVWRVFjMzQLFLFRULQWLDL[tFRPXQULFWUDFWDPHQWGHFRUDWLXDEDVHGH PDVFDURQVSXWWLLKDUSLHV$ODSDUWVXSHULRUVHVLWXDHOUHOOHXGH6DQWD0DJGDOHQDUHFOLQDGD+LKDXQDDOWUD SRUWDGDODWHUDODQRPHQDGD(OV*ULVRQVPpV[LFRWHWDDODTXHV DFFHGL[SHUXQDHVFDOLQDWD/DIjEULFDGHO FRQMXQW pV GH PDoRQHULD SUHVD DPE DUJDPDVVD GH FDOo L FDUUHXV GH SHGUD FDOFjULD HQ HOV FDQWRQV L HOV FRQWUDIRUWV%DVDWHQHO&DWjOHJGH0RQXPHQWVL&RQMXQWVGHOD&RPXQLWDW9DOHQFLDQD 6HHQFXHQWUDVLWXDGDDOHVWHGHOFDVFRDQWLJXR6HGHVFRQRFHODIHFKDGHVXFRQVWUXFFLyQSUREDEOHPHQWH WUDVODJXHUUDGHODV*HUPDQtDV\DQWHVGH\DTXHHQHVHDxRDSDUHFHQRPEUDGDHQODVYLVLWDV SDVWRUDOHV 6H WUDWD GH XQD LJOHVLD GH XQD VROD QDYH GLYLGLGD HQ FXDWUR WUDPRV FXELHUWRV FRQ EyYHGD GH FUXFHUtDFRQFDSLOODVHQWUHFRQWUDIXHUWHV\FDEHFHUDSROLJRQDOFXELHUWDFRQEyYHGDHVWUHOODGD/DFDSLOODGH OD &RPXQLyQ HQ HO ODGR GH OD HStVWROD SUHVHQWD XQD F~SXOD 7DQWR HVWD FDSLOOD FRPR OD VDFULVWtD \ HO WUDVDJUDULR VRQ GH XQD pSRFD SRVWHULRU UHDOL]DGRV HQWUH ORV VLJORV ;9,, \ ;9,,, \D TXH SUHVHQWDQ XQD IiEULFD GLIHUHQWH 3UREDEOHPHQWH HO WHUUHPRWR GH DIHFWy D OD EyYHGD GH OD LJOHVLD \ IXH HQWRQFHV FXDQGR VH UHDOL]DURQ UHIRUPDV DO JXVWR GH OD pSRFD 3RU HOOR SUHVHQWD XQD VHULH GH HVWXFRV \ SLQWXUDV EDUURFDV$OH[WHULRUGHVWDFDODIDFKDGD\ODWRUUHVLWXDGDD ODGHUHFKDDPEDVUHPDWDVSRUXQDOPHQDGR GHFRUDWLYR/DSRUWDGDDPRGRGHDUFRWULXQIDOGREOHSUHVHQWDHQORVIODQFRVVHPLFROXPQDVHQWUHODVTXHVH GLVSRQHQYHQHUDV6HFRPELQDQHQODSRUWDGDORVWUHVRUGHQHVDUTXLWHFWyQLFRVWRVFDQRMyQLFR\FRULQWLRDVt FRPRXQULFRWUDWDPLHQWRGHFRUDWLYRDEDVHGHPDVFDURQHVSXWWL\DUStDV(QODSDUWHVXSHULRUVHVLW~DHO UHOLHYHGH6DQWD0DJGDOHQDUHFRVWDGD+D\RWUDSRUWDGDODWHUDOOODPDGD(OV*ULVRQVGHPHQRUWDPDxRD $11(;,9$1(;2,9 GH 5HVROXFLyGHG DEULOGHOD'LUHFFLy*HQHUDOGH3DWULPRQL&XOWXUDO9DOHQFLjL0XVHXVGHOD&RQVHOOHULDGH&XOWXUD(GXFDFLyL(VSRUWSHUODTXHV LQFRDH[SHGLHQWSHUDOD SULPHUD IDVH GH O DFWXDOLW]DFLy L DGDSWDFLy SDUFLDO GH OD 6HFFLy 3ULPHUD GH O ,QYHQWDUL *HQHUDO GHO 3DWULPRQL &XOWXUDO 9DOHQFLj HQ PDWqULD GH SDWULPRQL DUTXLWHFWzQLF L PHGLDPELHQWDOLV¶REULSHUtRGHG¶LQIRUPDFLyS~EOLFD 5HVROXFLyQ GH GH DEULO GH OD 'LUHFFLyQ *HQHUDO GH 3DWULPRQLR &XOWXUDO 9DOHQFLDQR \ 0XVHRV GH OD &RQVHOOHULD GH &XOWXUD (GXFDFLyQ \ 'HSRUWH SRU OD TXH VH LQFRD H[SHGLHQWH SDUD OD SULPHUD IDVH GH OD DFWXDOL]DFLyQ \ DGDSWDFLyQ SDUFLDO GH OD 6HFFLyQ 3ULPHUD GHO ,QYHQWDULR *HQHUDO GHO 3DWULPRQLR &XOWXUDO 9DOHQFLDQR HQ PDWHULD GH SDWULPRQLRDUTXLWHFWyQLFR\PHGLRDPELHQWDO\VHDEUHSHULRGRGHLQIRUPDFLyQSXEOLFD Núm. 5.503 / 02.05.2007 17919 ODTXHVHDFFHGHSRUXQDHVFDOLQDWD/DIiEULFDGHOFRQMXQWRHVGHPDPSRVWHUtDWRPDGDFRQDUJDPDVDGH FDO\VLOOHUtDGHSLHGUDFDOL]DHQODVHVTXLQDV\ORVFRQWUDIXHUWHV%DVDGRHQHO&DWiORJRGH0RQXPHQWRV\ &RQMXQWRVGHOD&RPXQLGDG9DOHQFLDQD 2EVHUYDFLRQV2EVHUYDFLRQHV (QWRUQ(QWRUQR $QWHFHGHQWVDGPLQLVWUDWLXVGHOLPLWDFLyH[WUHWDGHO H[SHGLHQWGHILQLGDDPEFDUjFWHUSURYLVLRQDO 2ULJHQ3XQW$YqUWH[VXGGHODSDUFHOāODFDGDVWUDOGHO¶LOODGHFDVHV 6HQWLWKRUDUL /tQLD GHOLPLWDGRUD /D OtQLD UHFRUUH OHV SRVWHULRUV GH OHV SDUFHOāOHV GH O¶LOOD GH FDVHV TXH GRQHQ DO FDUUHUGHO (VJOpVLDLDOD5DYDOHW&UHXDHOFDUUHUGHOD0DUHGH'pXGHO&DUPHLVHJXL[OHVSRVWHULRUVGHOHV SDUFHOāOHVLGHO¶LOOD&UHXDHOFDUUHUGHO (VJOpVLDLVHJXL[SHUODPLWJHUDQRUGGHOD SDUFHOāODGHO¶LOOD&UHXDHOFDUUHUG¶(O6DOYDGRULLQFRUSRUDODSDUFHOāODGHO¶LOOD6HJXL[SHU ODPLWJHUDQRUGGHODSDUFHOāODGHO¶LOODGHFDVHVLSHUOHVSRVWHULRUVGHOHVSDUFHOāOHVL GHODPDWHL[D5HFRUUHODPLWJHUDQRUGGHODSDUFHOāODGHO¶LOODDQWHULRUFUHXDHOFDUUHUGH6DQW7RPHXL LQFRUSRUDOHVSDUFHOāOHVGHVGHODDODLQFOXVLYDPHQWGHO¶LOOD&UHXDHOFDUUHUGHO5DYDOHWILQVDO SXQWG RULJHQ $QWHFHGHQWHVDGPLQLVWUDWLYRVGHOLPLWDFLyQH[WUDtGDGHOH[SHGLHQWHGHILQLGDFRQFDUiFWHUSURYLVLRQDO 2ULJHQ3XQWR$YpUWLFHVXUGHODSDUFHODFDWDVWUDOGHODPDQ]DQD 6HQWLGRKRUDULR /tQHDGHOLPLWDGRUDODOtQHDUHFRUUHODVWUDVHUDVGHODVSDUFHODVGHODPDQ]DQDUHFD\HQWHVDODFDOOH GHOD,JOHVLD\DODGHO5DYDOHW&UX]DODFDOOH9LUJHQGHO&DUPHQ\VLJXHODVWUDVHUDVGHODVSDUFHODV \GHODPDQ]DQD&UX]DODFDOOHGHOD,JOHVLD\VLJXHSRUODPHGLDQHUDQRUWHGHODSDUFHOD GHODPDQ]DQD&UX]DODFDOOH(O6DOYDGRUHLQFRUSRUD ODSDUFHODGHODPDQ]DQD6LJXH SRUODPHGLDQHUDQRUWHGHODSDUFHODGHODPDQ]DQD\SRUODVWUDVHUDVGHODVSDUFHODV\ GHODPLVPD5HFRUUHODPHGLDQHUDQRUWHGHODSDUFHODGH ODPDQ]DQDDQWHULRUFUX]DODFDOOH6DQWR 7RPiVHLQFRUSRUDODVSDUFHODVGHVGHODDODLQFOXVLYH GHODPDQ]DQD&UX]DODFDOOH5DYDOHW KDVWDHOSXQWRGHRULJHQ $11(;,9$1(;2,9 GH 5HVROXFLyGHG DEULOGHOD'LUHFFLy*HQHUDOGH3DWULPRQL&XOWXUDO9DOHQFLjL0XVHXVGHOD&RQVHOOHULDGH&XOWXUD(GXFDFLyL(VSRUWSHUODTXHV LQFRDH[SHGLHQWSHUDOD SULPHUD IDVH GH O DFWXDOLW]DFLy L DGDSWDFLy SDUFLDO GH OD 6HFFLy 3ULPHUD GH O ,QYHQWDUL *HQHUDO GHO 3DWULPRQL &XOWXUDO 9DOHQFLj HQ PDWqULD GH SDWULPRQL DUTXLWHFWzQLF L PHGLDPELHQWDOLV¶REULSHUtRGHG¶LQIRUPDFLyS~EOLFD 5HVROXFLyQ GH GH DEULO GH OD 'LUHFFLyQ *HQHUDO GH 3DWULPRQLR &XOWXUDO 9DOHQFLDQR \ 0XVHRV GH OD &RQVHOOHULD GH &XOWXUD (GXFDFLyQ \ 'HSRUWH SRU OD TXH VH LQFRD H[SHGLHQWH SDUD OD SULPHUD IDVH GH OD DFWXDOL]DFLyQ \ DGDSWDFLyQ SDUFLDO GH OD 6HFFLyQ 3ULPHUD GHO ,QYHQWDULR *HQHUDO GHO 3DWULPRQLR &XOWXUDO 9DOHQFLDQR HQ PDWHULD GH SDWULPRQLRDUTXLWHFWyQLFR\PHGLRDPELHQWDO\VHDEUHSHULRGRGHLQIRUPDFLyQSXEOLFD Núm. 5.503 / 02.05.2007 17920 %e'¶,17(5e6&8/785$/±(6*/e6,$3$55248,$/'(6$17$0$5,$0$*'$/(1$ /¶2//(5,$02180(17 %,(1'(,17(5e6&8/785$/±,*/(6,$3$55248,$/'(6$17$0$5Ë$0$*'$/(1$ /¶2//(5,$02180(172 $11(;,9$1(;2,9 GH 5HVROXFLyGHG DEULOGHOD'LUHFFLy*HQHUDOGH3DWULPRQL&XOWXUDO9DOHQFLjL0XVHXVGHOD&RQVHOOHULDGH&XOWXUD(GXFDFLyL(VSRUWSHUODTXHV LQFRDH[SHGLHQWSHUDOD SULPHUD IDVH GH O DFWXDOLW]DFLy L DGDSWDFLy SDUFLDO GH OD 6HFFLy 3ULPHUD GH O ,QYHQWDUL *HQHUDO GHO 3DWULPRQL &XOWXUDO 9DOHQFLj HQ PDWqULD GH SDWULPRQL DUTXLWHFWzQLF L PHGLDPELHQWDOLV¶REULSHUtRGHG¶LQIRUPDFLyS~EOLFD 5HVROXFLyQ GH GH DEULO GH OD 'LUHFFLyQ *HQHUDO GH 3DWULPRQLR &XOWXUDO 9DOHQFLDQR \ 0XVHRV GH OD &RQVHOOHULD GH &XOWXUD (GXFDFLyQ \ 'HSRUWH SRU OD TXH VH LQFRD H[SHGLHQWH SDUD OD SULPHUD IDVH GH OD DFWXDOL]DFLyQ \ DGDSWDFLyQ SDUFLDO GH OD 6HFFLyQ 3ULPHUD GHO ,QYHQWDULR *HQHUDO GHO 3DWULPRQLR &XOWXUDO 9DOHQFLDQR HQ PDWHULD GH SDWULPRQLRDUTXLWHFWyQLFR\PHGLRDPELHQWDO\VHDEUHSHULRGRGHLQIRUPDFLyQSXEOLFD Núm. 5.503 / 02.05.2007 17921 %e'¶,17(5e6&8/785$/±(6*/e6,$3$55248,$/'(/6$17¬1*(/&8672',/$9$//'¶8,;Ï 02180(17 %,(1'(,17(5e6&8/785$/,*/(6,$3$55248,$/'(/6$172È1*(/&8672',2/$9$// '¶8,;Ï02180(172 'HQRPLQDFLy'HQRPLQDFLyQ 3ULQFLSDO3ULQFLSDO (VJOpVLD3DUURTXLDOGHO6DQW¬QJHO&XVWRGL ,JOHVLD3DUURTXLDOGHO6DQWRÈQJHO&XVWRGLR /RFDOLW]DFLy/RFDOL]DFLyQ 3URYtQFLD3URYLQFLD&DVWHOOy &RPDUFD&RPDUFD/D3ODQD%DL[D 0XQLFLSL0XQLFLSLR/D9DOOG¶8L[y 8ELFDFLy8ELFDFLyQ3OD]DGHO6DQWRÈQJHO 5HIHUqQFLD&DGDVWUDO5HIHUHQFLD&DWDVWUDO ,OOD0DQ]DQD3DUFHOāOD3DUFHOD $QWHFHGHQWV-XUtGLFV$QWHFHGHQWV-XUtGLFRV ,QFRDFLy,QFRDFLyQ,QFRDGR 3XEOLFDFLyGHODLQFRDFLy3XEOLFDFLyQGHODLQFRDFLyQ%2( 'HVFULSFLy'HVFULSFLyQ 3DUWV,QWHJUDQWV3DUWHV,QWHJUDQWHV − /DQDXFHQWUDOLOHVODWHUDOVDPEHOVDOWDUV/DQDYHFHQWUDO\ODVODWHUDOHVFRQVXVDOWDUHV − /DFDSHOODGHO6DJUDUL/DFDSLOODGHO6DJUDULR − /HVFDSHOOHVGHO&DUQDGDULGHOD0DUHGH'pXGHOV'RORUVLGHO'DUUHUHDOWDU /DVFDSLOODVGHO&DUQDGDUL GHOD9LUJHQGHORV'RORUHV\GHO7UDVDOWDU − /DWRUUHFDPSDQDU/DWRUUHFDPSDQDULR − /DVDJULVWLD/DVDFULVWtD − /HVIDoDQHV/DVIDFKDGDV − (OVIUHVFRV/RVIUHVFRV 'HVFULSFLy*HQHUDO'HVFULSFLyQ*HQHUDO / HVJOpVLD YD VHU LQLFLDGD HQ VHJRQV OHV WUDFHV GH 7RPHX /OHRQDUW L 7RPHX 3DQV V HQFDUUHJj OD FRQVWUXFFLyD-RDQGHO5LXL-RDQG ,JXDOSHGUDSLTXHUVGHOOORFGH3LQD3RVVLEOHPHQWHVWHHGLILFLFRQFOzVHQ IyUD UHQDL[HQWLVWD DPE IDoDQD DPE IURQWy WULDQJXODU GREOH WRUUH FDPSDQDU G XQD VROD QDX L DEVLV FLUFXODU(QHOVHJOH;9,,,HQV¶LQLFLDUHQOHVREUHVG¶DPSOLDFLyHVYDQDPSOLDUOHVFDSHOOHVODWHUDOVILQV DFRQYHUWLUOHVHQQDXVHVYDDOoDUHOFUHXHUHOSUHVELWHULOHVVDJULVWLHVLODFDSHOODGHO6DJUDUL / HGLILFLDFWXDOpVGHSODQWDGHFUHXOODWLQDDPEQDXFHQWUDOLGXHVQDXVODWHUDOVWp[LFRWHWVHVSDLVHQWUHHOV FRQWUDIRUWVGHVWLQDWVDDOWDUVODWHUDOV$O HVTXHUUDHQHOFRVWDWQRUGRHVWHVWUREDODFDSHOODGHO&DUQDGDUL TXHRFXSDHOSHUtPHWUHGHOTXHGHJXpVHUODSULPLWLYDHVJOpVLD (QODFDSoDOHUDHVWUREHQODVDJULVWLDLODFDSHOODGHO6DJUDULHVWD~OWLPDDPESODQWDGHFUHXLQYHUWLGDDPE XQD[LFRWHWDF~SXODLOODQWHUQD(OUHUHVDJUDULpVUHFWDQJXODUDPEXQDYROWDFHQWUDOHOāOtSWLFD /DQDXFHQWUDOHVWDFREHUWDDPEYROWDGHFDQyDPEOOXQHWHVGLYLGLGDHQTXDWUHWUDPVSHUDUFVIDL[RQV&DGD XQGHOVHVSDLVGHOHVQDXVODWHUDOVHVWDFREHUWDPEXQDF~SXOD (OFUHXHUGHVWDFDHQSODQWDHQHOFHQWUHLVREUHXQWDPERURFWRJRQDOV HOHYDODF~SXODFREHUWDDO H[WHULRU DPEWHXODEODYDYLGULDGD(OSUHVELWHULpVUHFWDQJXODUFREHUWDPEYROWDGHFDQy /HVF~SXOHVLOHVSHW[LQHVHVWDQGHFRUDGHVDOIUHVFDL[tFRPODYROWDGHOSUHVELWHULLHOUHUHVDJUDUL /DIjEULFDH[WHULRUGHO HGLILFLpVGHSHGUHVGH[LFRWHWDLLUUHJXODUJUDQGjULDXQLGHVDPEDUJDPDVVDGHFDOoL DUHQDDPEFDUUHXVHQHOVFDQWRQVLSRUWDGHV(QODIDoDQDSULQFLSDOVLWXDGDDOVSHXVGHO HGLILFLGHVWDFDOD SRUWDGDDPEXQFRVLQIHULRUDOOLQGDWDPEHQFRL[LQDWHQHOVFDQWRQV$ODGUHWDHVWUREDODWRUUHFDPSDQDU GHSODQWDTXDGUDGDUHDOLW]DGDHQFDUUHXVHQHOFRVGHFDPSDQHV /D LJOHVLD IXH LQLFLDGD HQ VHJ~Q ODV WUD]DV GH 7RPiV /OHRQDUW \ 7RPiV 3DQHV \ VH HQFDUJy OD FRQVWUXFFLyQD-RDQGHO5tR\-RDQGH,JXDOFDQWHURVGHOOXJDUGH3LQD3RVLEOHPHQWHHVWHHGLILFLRFRQFOXLGR HQIXHVHUHQDFHQWLVWDFRQIDFKDGDFRQIURQWyQWULDQJXODUGREOHWRUUHFDPSDQDULRGHXQDVRODQDYH\ iEVLGHFLUFXODU(QHOVLJOR;9,,,HOWHPSORVHDPSOLyLQLFLiQGRVHODVREUDVHQVHDPSOLDURQODVFDSLOODV $11(;,9$1(;2,9 GH 5HVROXFLyGHG DEULOGHOD'LUHFFLy*HQHUDOGH3DWULPRQL&XOWXUDO9DOHQFLjL0XVHXVGHOD&RQVHOOHULDGH&XOWXUD(GXFDFLyL(VSRUWSHUODTXHV LQFRDH[SHGLHQWSHUDOD SULPHUD IDVH GH O DFWXDOLW]DFLy L DGDSWDFLy SDUFLDO GH OD 6HFFLy 3ULPHUD GH O ,QYHQWDUL *HQHUDO GHO 3DWULPRQL &XOWXUDO 9DOHQFLj HQ PDWqULD GH SDWULPRQL DUTXLWHFWzQLF L PHGLDPELHQWDOLV¶REULSHUtRGHG¶LQIRUPDFLyS~EOLFD 5HVROXFLyQ GH GH DEULO GH OD 'LUHFFLyQ *HQHUDO GH 3DWULPRQLR &XOWXUDO 9DOHQFLDQR \ 0XVHRV GH OD &RQVHOOHULD GH &XOWXUD (GXFDFLyQ \ 'HSRUWH SRU OD TXH VH LQFRD H[SHGLHQWH SDUD OD SULPHUD IDVH GH OD DFWXDOL]DFLyQ \ DGDSWDFLyQ SDUFLDO GH OD 6HFFLyQ 3ULPHUD GHO ,QYHQWDULR *HQHUDO GHO 3DWULPRQLR &XOWXUDO 9DOHQFLDQR HQ PDWHULD GH SDWULPRQLRDUTXLWHFWyQLFR\PHGLRDPELHQWDO\VHDEUHSHULRGRGHLQIRUPDFLyQSXEOLFD Núm. 5.503 / 02.05.2007 17922 ODWHUDOHV KDVWD FRQYHUWLUODV HQ QDYHV VH OHYDQWy HO FUXFHUR HO SUHVELWHULR ODV VDFULVWtDV \ FDSLOOD GHO 6DJUDULR (O HGLILFLR DFWXDO HV GH SODQWD GH FUX] ODWLQD FRQ QDYH FHQWUDO \ GRV QDYHV ODWHUDOHV TXH WLHQH SHTXHxRV HVSDFLRV HQWUH ORV FRQWUDIXHUWHV GHVWLQDGRV D DOWDUHV ODWHUDOHV $ OD L]TXLHUGD HQ HO ODGR QRURHVWH VH HQFXHQWUDODFDSLOODGHO&DUQDGDULTXHRFXSDHOSHUtPHWURGHORTXHSXGRVHUODSULPLWLYDLJOHVLD (QODFDEHFHUD VHHQFXHQWUDQOD VDFULVWtD \ODFDSLOODGHO VDJUDULR HVWDXOWLPDFRQSODQWD GHFUX]LQYHUWLGD FRQXQDSHTXHxDF~SXOD\OLQWHUQD(OWUDVDJUDULRHVUHFWDQJXODUFRQXQDEyYHGDFHQWUDOHOtSWLFD /DQDYHFHQWUDOHVWDFXELHUWDFRQEyYHGDGHFDxyQFRQOXQHWRVGLYLGLGDHQFXDWURWUDPRVSRUDUFRVIDMRQHV &DGDXQRGHORVHVSDFLRVGHODVQDYHVODWHUDOHVHVWDFXELHUWRFRQXQDF~SXOD (O FUXFHUR GHVWDFD HQ SODQWD HQ HO FHQWUR \ VREUH XQ WDPERU RFWRJRQDO VH HOHYD OD F~SXOD FXELHUWD DO H[WHULRUFRQWHMDD]XOYLGULDGD(OSUHVELWHULRHVUHFWDQJXODUFXELHUWRFRQEyYHGDGHFDxyQ /DVF~SXODV\ODVSHFKLQDVHVWiQGHFRUDGDVDOIUHVFRDVtFRPRODEyYHGDGHOSUHVELWHULR\HOWUDVDJUDULR /DIiEULFDH[WHULRUGHOHGLILFLRHVGHSLHGUDVGHSHTXHxRHLUUHJXODUWDPDxRXQLGDVFRQDUJDPDVDGHFDO\ DUHQDFRQVLOODUHVHQODVHVTXLQDV\SRUWDGDV(QODIDFKDGDSULQFLSDOVLWXDGDDORVSLHVGHOHGLILFLRGHVWDFD ODSRUWDGDFRQXQFXHUSRLQIHULRUDGLQWHODGRFRQDOPRKDGLOODGRHQODVHVTXLQDV$ODGHUHFKDVHHQFXHQWUD ODWRUUHFDPSDQDULRGHSODQWDFXDGUDGDUHDOL]DGDHQVLOOHUtDHQHOFXHUSRGHFDPSDQDV 2EVHUYDFLRQV2EVHUYDFLRQHV (QWRUQ(QWRUQR $QWHFHGHQWVDGPLQLVWUDWLXVGHOLPLWDFLyH[WUHWDGHO H[SHGLHQWGHILQLGDDPEFDUjFWHUSURYLVLRQDO 2ULJHQ7UREDGDGHODSURORQJDFLyGHOFDUUHUGH%HQLJDIXOODPEO DOLQHDFLyQRUGGHOHVFDVHVGHO¶LOOD FDGDVWUDOQ~P3XQW$ 6HQWLW+RUDUL (VERVVD GHOLPLWDGRUD 'HV GH O RULJHQ OD OtQLD VHJXL[ SHU OHV DOLQHDFLRQV HVWH L VXG GH O¶LOOD GH FDVHV Q~P TXHGRQHQDOVFDUUHUVGHO3RUFDULGHOD&RYD6DQWDILQVDODIDoDQDVXGGHODFDVDQ~PGHO¶LOOD FDGDVWUDOQ~PUHFRUUHQWODSHUDFRQWLQXDUSHUO DOLQHDFLyRHVWGHODSDUFHOāODQ~PWUHQFDQWVHHQ ODSODoDGH6DQWLDJR2EyQLGLULJLQWVHDODPLWJHUDRHVWGHODFDVDQ~PGHO¶LOODFDGDVWUDOQ~P 6HJXLQWHVWDPLWJHUDLFRQWLQXDQWSHUOHVSRVWHULRUVGHOHVFDVHVG HVWDLOODTXHGRQHQDODSODoDGH6LOYHVWUH 6HJDUUDJLUDDO HVWSHUODIDoDQDGHODFDVDQ~PILQVDHQIURQWDUDPEODPLWJHUDRHVWGHODFDVDQ~P GH O¶LOODQ~PWUDYHVVDQWHOFDUUHUGH OD 0DUH GH 'pX GHOV 'RORUV &RQWLQXD SHU HVWD PLWJHUD GH OD FDVDQ~PGHO¶LOODQ~PLDUULEDDOFDUUHUGHO6DJUDULGHO6DQW¬QJHOFRQWLQXDSHUOHVIDoDQHVGH OHVFDVHVQ~PLQ~PFUHXDHOFDUUHUHQYROWDQWODFDVDQ~PGHO¶LOODQ~P'HVG DFtFUHXDHO FDUUHUGHO&DOYDULLVHJXL[SHUOHVSDUWVGHOGDUUHUHGHOHVFDVHVTXHGRQHQDODSODoDGHOD0HUFpLIDoDQDGH ODFDVDQ~PTXHGyQDDOFDUUHUGHOD5HGRQDGHO¶LOODQ~PILQVDOSXQWGHWUREDGDDPEO DOLQHDFLy QRUGGHODFDVDQ~PGHO¶LOODFDGDVWUDOQ~PVHJXL[ SHUpVWDLFRQWLQXDSHUOHVSDUWVGHOGDUUHUH GHOHVFDVHVQ~PHURVLGHODPDWHL[DLOODLSRVWHULRUPHQWHQJOREDOHVFDVHVQ~PHURVL GHO¶LOODQ~PSHUDILQDOLW]DUHQHOSXQWG RULJHQ$ $QWHFHGHQWHVDGPLQLVWUDWLYRVGHOLPLWDFLyQH[WUDtGDGHOH[SHGLHQWHGHILQLGDFRQFDUiFWHUSURYLVLRQDO 2ULJHQ (QFXHQWUR GH OD SURORQJDFLyQ GH OD FDOOH %HQLJDIXOO FRQ OD DOLQHDFLyQ QRUWH GH ODV FDVDV GH OD PDQ]DQDFDWDVWUDOQ3XQWR$ 6HQWLGR+RUDULR /LQHDGHOLPLWDGRUD'HVGHHORULJHQODOtQHDVLJXHSRUODVDOLQHDFLRQHVHVWH\VXUGHODPDQ]DQDQ UHFD\HQWHV D ODV FDOOHV 3RUFDU \ GH OD &RYD 6DQWD KDVWD OD IDFKDGD VXU GH OD FDVD Q GH OD PDQ]DQD FDWDVWUDOQUHFRUULpQGRODSDUDFRQWLQXDUSRUODDOLQHDFLyQRHVWHGHODSDUFHODQTXHEUiQGRVHHQ ODSOD]DGH6DQWLDJR2EyQ\GLULJLpQGRVHDODPHGLDQHUDRHVWHGHODFDVDQGHODPDQ]DQDFDWDVWUDOQ 6LJXLHQGRHVWDPHGLDQHUD\FRQWLQXDQGRSRUODVWUDVHUDVGHODVFDVDVGHHVWDPDQ]DQDUHFD\HQWHVD ODSOD]DGH6LOYHVWUH6HJDUUDJLUDDOHVWHSRUODIDFKDGDGHODFDVDQKDVWDHQIUHQWDUFRQODPHGLDQHUD RHVWH GH OD FDVD Q GH OD PDQ]DQD Q DWUDYHVDQGR OD FDOOH GH 1XHVWUD 6HxRUD GH ORV 'RORUHV &RQWLQXDSRUHVWDPHGLDQHUDGHODFDVDQGHODPDQ]DQDQ\OOHJDDODFDOOH6DJUDULRGHO6DQWR $QJHOFRQWLQ~DSRUODVIDFKDGDV GH ODV FDVDV Q \ Q FUX]D OD FDOOH HQYROYLpQGR OD FDVD Q GH OD PDQ]DQDQ'HVGHDTXtFUX]DODFDOOH&DOYDULR\VLJXHSRUODVWUDVHUDVGHODVFDVDVUHFD\HQWHVDOD SOD]DGHOD0HUFHG\IDFKDGDGHODFDVDQUHFD\HQWHDODFDOOH5HGRQGDGHODPDQ]DQDQKDVWD HOSXQWRGHHQFXHQWURFRQODDOLQHDFLyQQRUWHGHODFDVDQGHODPDQ]DQDFDWDVWUDOQVLJXHSRU pVWD\FRQWLQ~DSRUODVWUDVHUDVGHODVFDVDVQ~PHURV\GHODPLVPDPDQ]DQD\SRVWHULRUPHQWH HQJOREDODVFDVDVQ~PHURV\GHODPDQ]DQDQSDUDILQDOL]DUHQHOSXQWRGHRULJHQ$ $11(;,9$1(;2,9 GH 5HVROXFLyGHG DEULOGHOD'LUHFFLy*HQHUDOGH3DWULPRQL&XOWXUDO9DOHQFLjL0XVHXVGHOD&RQVHOOHULDGH&XOWXUD(GXFDFLyL(VSRUWSHUODTXHV LQFRDH[SHGLHQWSHUDOD SULPHUD IDVH GH O DFWXDOLW]DFLy L DGDSWDFLy SDUFLDO GH OD 6HFFLy 3ULPHUD GH O ,QYHQWDUL *HQHUDO GHO 3DWULPRQL &XOWXUDO 9DOHQFLj HQ PDWqULD GH SDWULPRQL DUTXLWHFWzQLF L PHGLDPELHQWDOLV¶REULSHUtRGHG¶LQIRUPDFLyS~EOLFD 5HVROXFLyQ GH GH DEULO GH OD 'LUHFFLyQ *HQHUDO GH 3DWULPRQLR &XOWXUDO 9DOHQFLDQR \ 0XVHRV GH OD &RQVHOOHULD GH &XOWXUD (GXFDFLyQ \ 'HSRUWH SRU OD TXH VH LQFRD H[SHGLHQWH SDUD OD SULPHUD IDVH GH OD DFWXDOL]DFLyQ \ DGDSWDFLyQ SDUFLDO GH OD 6HFFLyQ 3ULPHUD GHO ,QYHQWDULR *HQHUDO GHO 3DWULPRQLR &XOWXUDO 9DOHQFLDQR HQ PDWHULD GH SDWULPRQLRDUTXLWHFWyQLFR\PHGLRDPELHQWDO\VHDEUHSHULRGRGHLQIRUPDFLyQSXEOLFD Núm. 5.503 / 02.05.2007 17923 %e'¶,17(5e6&8/785$/±(6*/e6,$3$55248,$/'(/6$17¬1*(/&8672',/$9$//'¶8,;Ï 02180(17 %,(1'(,17(5e6&8/785$/,*/(6,$3$55248,$/'(/6$172È1*(/&8672',2/$9$// '¶8,;Ï02180(172 $11(;,9$1(;2,9 GH 5HVROXFLyGHG DEULOGHOD'LUHFFLy*HQHUDOGH3DWULPRQL&XOWXUDO9DOHQFLjL0XVHXVGHOD&RQVHOOHULDGH&XOWXUD(GXFDFLyL(VSRUWSHUODTXHV LQFRDH[SHGLHQWSHUDOD SULPHUD IDVH GH O DFWXDOLW]DFLy L DGDSWDFLy SDUFLDO GH OD 6HFFLy 3ULPHUD GH O ,QYHQWDUL *HQHUDO GHO 3DWULPRQL &XOWXUDO 9DOHQFLj HQ PDWqULD GH SDWULPRQL DUTXLWHFWzQLF L PHGLDPELHQWDOLV¶REULSHUtRGHG¶LQIRUPDFLyS~EOLFD 5HVROXFLyQ GH GH DEULO GH OD 'LUHFFLyQ *HQHUDO GH 3DWULPRQLR &XOWXUDO 9DOHQFLDQR \ 0XVHRV GH OD &RQVHOOHULD GH &XOWXUD (GXFDFLyQ \ 'HSRUWH SRU OD TXH VH LQFRD H[SHGLHQWH SDUD OD SULPHUD IDVH GH OD DFWXDOL]DFLyQ \ DGDSWDFLyQ SDUFLDO GH OD 6HFFLyQ 3ULPHUD GHO ,QYHQWDULR *HQHUDO GHO 3DWULPRQLR &XOWXUDO 9DOHQFLDQR HQ PDWHULD GH SDWULPRQLRDUTXLWHFWyQLFR\PHGLRDPELHQWDO\VHDEUHSHULRGRGHLQIRUPDFLyQSXEOLFD Núm. 5.503 / 02.05.2007 17924 %e'¶,17(5e6&8/785$/±(50,7$'(/$&2162/$&,Ï//87;(1702180(17 %,(1'(,17(5e6&8/785$/±(50,7$'(/$&2162/$&,Ï1//87;(1702180(172 'HQRPLQDFLy'HQRPLQDFLyQ 3ULQFLSDO3ULQFLSDO (UPLWDGHOD&RQVRODFLy (UPLWDGHOD&RQVRODFLyQ /RFDOL]DFLy/RFDOL]DFLyQ 3URYtQFLD3URYLQFLD9DOqQFLD &RPDUFD&RPDUFD/D9DOOG¶$OEDLGD 0XQLFLSL0XQLFLSLR/OXW[HQW 8ELFDFLy8ELFDFLyQ&DPtGHOD&RVWD 5HIHUHQFLD&DGDVWUDO5HIHUHQFLD&DWDVWUDO 3ROtJRQ3ROtJRQR3DUFHOāOD3DUFHOD $QWHFHGHQWV-XUtGLFV$QWHFHGHQWHV-XUtGLFRV ,QFRDFLy,QFRDFLyQ 3XEOLFDFLyGHODLQFRDFLy3XEOLFDFLyQGHODLQFRDFLyQ%2( 'HVFULSFLy'HVFULSFLyQ 3DUWV,QWHJUDQWV3DUWHV,QWHJUDQWHV − &DSHOODDPEYROWHVFLPERULLF~SXOD&DSLOODFRQEyYHGDVFLPERUULR\F~SXOD − &DPEULO&DPDUtQ − (VFDODLPSHULDO(VFDOHUDLPSHULDO − 6DJULVWLD6DFULVWtD − &LQFDOMXEVVXEWHUUDQLV&LQFRDOMLEHVVXEWHUUiQHRV − (VSDGDQ\D(VSDGDxD − &RVVRV DIHJLWV D OD FDSHOOD DPE OHV GHSHQGqQFLHV GH O DFWXDO YLYHQGD L OHV YLQFXODGHV DPE OHV IDHQHV DJUtFROHV&XHUSRVDxDGLGRVDODFDSLOODFRQODVGHSHQGHQFLDVGHODDFWXDOYLYLHQGD\ODVYLQFXODGDVFRQ ODVIDHQDVDJUtFRODV − − 3DWLRFRUUDO3DWLRRFRUUDO 3DUDPHQWVH[WHULRUVDPEHQUHL[DWVPLUDGRUVILQHVWUHVLSRUWDJUDQG DFFpV3DUDPHQWRVH[WHULRUHVFRQ HQUHMDGRVPLUDGRUHVYHQWDQDV\SRUWyQGHDFFHVR 'HVFULSFLy*HQHUDO'HVFULSFLyQ*HQHUDO / HUPLWDGHOD&RQVRODFLyYDVHUIXQGDGDHQSHUXQVSHOHJULQVFDWDODQVTXHIUHTHQWDYHQHOPRQHVWLU HQHOSDUDWJHRQMDKDYLDH[LVWLWXQDHUPLWDGHGLFDGDDO DGYRFDFLyGH6DQW&RVPHL6DQW'DPLjLHQHOOORF HQTXqHOµ&DPtGH&RVWD IDXQUHSHWMy GDYDQW G XQ GHOV HQFUHXDPHQWV YRWLXV GHO 6 ;,9 L D PLWMDQ FDPt HQWUHODSREODFLyLHOFRQYHQW$OVLPEROLVPHGHOOORFVHVXPDODFRQFHSFLyGHWHPSOHRUDWRULHQFUHXJUHJDL F~SXOD LQWHULRU GH PLWMD WDURQMD DPE WRWV HOV DWULEXWV L ULTXHVHV RUQDPHQWDOV HQ FODX SRSXODU GH OD VHXD DGVFULSFLy EDUURFD LQVHULW HQ XQD DXVWHUD HGLILFDFLy R HPEROFDOO G RUGH F~ELF TXH HV UHODFLRQD DPE O¶DUTXLWHFWXUDUXUDOGHODVHXDqSRFDPpVIXQFLRQDOLHOVHXSDWLDVVRFLDW'LQVG¶DTXHVWYROXPHVUHVRODPE O¶HGLILFLy D FREHUW OD WRWDOLWDW GHO SURJUDPD FRPSOHPHQWDUL G XQ HUPLWRUL DWUL YLYHQGD FDSHOOD FDPEULO VDJULVWLD GHSHQGqQFLHV G DFROOLGD GH SHOHJULQV &DO DIHJLU FRP D HOHPHQWV G¶LQWHUpV OD LPDWJHULD OHV IXVWHULHVHOVWDXOHOOHWVGH0DQLVHVIUHVFRVLYLGULHUHVDWULEXWVHQSDUWG HQFHUWDGDIDFWXUDPRGHUQDGHOV DQ\V GHO 6;; %DVDW HQ HO &DWjOHJ GH 0RQXPHQWV L &RQMXQWV GH OD &RPXQLWDW 9DOqQFLD L *XLD GH OD SURYtQFLDGH9DOqQFLD /D (UPLWD GH OD &RQVRODFLyQ IXH IXQGDGD HQ SRU XQRV SHUHJULQRV FDWDODQHV TXH IUHFXHQWDEDQ HO 0RQDVWHULRHQHOSDUDMHGRQGH\DKDEtDH[LVWLGRXQD(UPLWDEDMRODDGYRFDFLyQGH6DQ&RVPHL6DQ'DPLiQ \HQHOOXJDUHQTXHHOµ&DPtGH&RVWD¶KDFHXQUHSHFKRDQWHXQDGHODVFUXFHVYRWLYDVGHO6;,9\DPHGLR FDPLQRHQWUHODSREODFLyQ\HOFRQYHQWR$OVLPEROLVPRGHOOXJDUVHVXPDODFRQFHSFLyQGHWHPSORRUDWRULR HQFUX]JULHJD\F~SXODLQWHULRUGHPHGLDQDUDQMDFRQWRGRVORVDWULEXWRV\ULTXH]DVRUQDPHQWDOHVHQFODYH SRSXODU GH VX DGVFULSFLyQ EDUURFD LQVHUWR HQ XQD DXVWHUD HGLILFDFLyQ HQYROYHQWH GH RUGHQ F~ELFR UHODFLRQDEOHFRQODPiVIXQFLRQDODUTXLWHFWXUDUXUDOGHVXpSRFD\VXSDWLRDVRFLDGR&RQODHQYROYHQWHVH VROYHQWD D FXELHUWR OD WRWDOLGDG GHO SURJUDPD FRPSOHPHQWDULR GH XQ HUPLWRULR DWULR YLYLHQGD FDSLOOD FDPDUtQVDFULVWtDGHSHQGHQFLDVGHDFRJLGDGHSHUHJULQRV6HKDGHDxDGLUFRPRHOHPHQWRVGHLQWHUpVOD LPDJLQHUtD FDUSLQWHUtDV D]XOHMRV GH 0DQLVHV IUHVFRV \ YLGULHUDV DWULEXWRV HQ SDUWH GH DFHUWDGD IDFWXUD $11(;,9$1(;2,9 GH 5HVROXFLyGHG DEULOGHOD'LUHFFLy*HQHUDOGH3DWULPRQL&XOWXUDO9DOHQFLjL0XVHXVGHOD&RQVHOOHULDGH&XOWXUD(GXFDFLyL(VSRUWSHUODTXHV LQFRDH[SHGLHQWSHUDOD SULPHUD IDVH GH O DFWXDOLW]DFLy L DGDSWDFLy SDUFLDO GH OD 6HFFLy 3ULPHUD GH O ,QYHQWDUL *HQHUDO GHO 3DWULPRQL &XOWXUDO 9DOHQFLj HQ PDWqULD GH SDWULPRQL DUTXLWHFWzQLF L PHGLDPELHQWDOLV¶REULSHUtRGHG¶LQIRUPDFLyS~EOLFD 5HVROXFLyQ GH GH DEULO GH OD 'LUHFFLyQ *HQHUDO GH 3DWULPRQLR &XOWXUDO 9DOHQFLDQR \ 0XVHRV GH OD &RQVHOOHULD GH &XOWXUD (GXFDFLyQ \ 'HSRUWH SRU OD TXH VH LQFRD H[SHGLHQWH SDUD OD SULPHUD IDVH GH OD DFWXDOL]DFLyQ \ DGDSWDFLyQ SDUFLDO GH OD 6HFFLyQ 3ULPHUD GHO ,QYHQWDULR *HQHUDO GHO 3DWULPRQLR &XOWXUDO 9DOHQFLDQR HQ PDWHULD GH SDWULPRQLRDUTXLWHFWyQLFR\PHGLRDPELHQWDO\VHDEUHSHULRGRGHLQIRUPDFLyQSXEOLFD Núm. 5.503 / 02.05.2007 17925 PRGHUQDGHORVDxRVGHO6;;%DVDGRHQHO&DWiORJRGH0RQXPHQWRV\&RQMXQWRVGHOD&RPXQLGDG 9DOHQFLD\*XtDGHOD3URYLQFLDGH9DOHQFLD 2EVHUYDFLRQV2EVHUYDFLRQHV (QWRUQ(QWRUQ $QWHFHGHQWVDGPLQLVWUDWLXVGHOLPLWDFLyH[WUHWDGHO H[SHGLHQWGHILQLGDDPEFDUjFWHUSURYLVLRQDO 2ULJHQ7UREDGDGHO HL[GHO&DPtGHO&DOYDULDPEODSURORQJDFLyGHODPLWJHUDQRUGGHOD SDUFHOāODGHO SROtJRQFDGDVWUDOSXQW$ 6HQWLW+RUDUL /tQLDGHOLPLWDGRUDGHVGHO RULJHQODOtQLDHVGLULJL[DHVWHYRUHMDQWHOFDPtSHOOtPLWQRUGGHODSDUFHOāOD GHOSROtJRQILQVDODWUREDGD DPE OD SDUFHOāOD6HJXL[SHOOtPLWVXGGHOD SDUFHOāODILQVDO FDPt H[LVWHQW*LUDDQRUGSHUO HVWGHODSDUFHOāODWUDYHVVDHOFDPtLVHJXL[ILQVDOYqUWH[VXGGHODSDUFHOāOD YRUHMDHVWDSDUFHOāODLQFRUSRUDQWODLGHVGHOVHXH[WUHPRHVWHVGLULJL[DQRUGHVWILQVDOYqUWH[RHVWGH ODSDUFHOāODGHOSROtJRQ9RUHMDWRWLQFORHQWOHVOHVSDUFHOāOHVLGHVGHO YqUWH[QRUGG HVWDHVGLULJL[DHVWHILQV DODLQFORHQWOD'HVGHOYqUWH[ HVWHG HVWD HVGLULJL[ DO YqUWH[ VXGGHODSDUFHOāODSHUDFRQWLQXDUYRUHMDQWHOOtPLWRHVWGHOHVSDUFHOāOHVL'HVG HVWHFUHXDHO FDPtLHVGLULJL[DOYqUWH[HVWHGHODSDUFHOāODGHOSROtJRQ VHJXL[DVXGLQFRUSRUDQW HOFDPtDIURQWDQW DPEOHVSDUFHOāOHVLJLUDDRHVWSHOOtPLWQRUGGHOHVSDUFHOāOHVLILQVDOSXQWG RULJHQ $QWHFHGHQWHVDGPLQLVWUDWLYRVGHOLPLWDFLyQH[WUDtGDGHOH[SHGLHQWHGHILQLGDFRQFDUiFWHUSURYLVLRQDO 2ULJHQ(QFXHQWURGHOHMHGHO&DPLQRGHO&DOYDULRFRQODSURORQJDFLyQGHODPHGLDQHUDQRUWHGHODSDUFHOD GHOSROtJRQRFDWDVWUDOSXQWR$ 6HQWLGR+RUDULR /LQHD GHOLPLWDGRUD GHVGH HO RULJHQ OD OtQHD VH GLULJH D HVWH ERUGHDQGR HO FDPLQR SRU HO OLQGH QRUWH GH OD SDUFHODGHOSROtJRQRKDVWDHOHQFXHQWURFRQODSDUFHOD6LJXHSRUHOOLQGHVXUGHODSDUFHOD KDVWDHOFDPLQRH[LVWHQWH*LUDDQRUWHSRUHOHVWHGHODSDUFHODDWUDYLHVDHOFDPLQR\ VLJXHKDVWDHO YpUWLFH VXU GH OD SDUFHOD ERUGHD HVWD SDUFHOD LQFRUSRUiQGROD \ GHVGH VX H[WUHPR RHVWH VH GLULJH D QRUHVWH KDVWD HO YpUWLFH RHVWH GH OD SDUFHOD GHO SROtJRQR %RUGHD LQFOX\pQGRODV ODV SDUFHODV \GHVGHHOYpUWLFHQRUWHGHpVWDVHGLULJHDHVWHKDVWDODLQFOX\pQGROD'HVGHHO YpUWLFHHVWHGHpVWDVH GLULJH DO YpUWLFH VXU GH OD SDUFHOD SDUD VHJXLU ERUGHDQGR HO OLQGH RHVWH GH ODV SDUFHODV\'HVGHHVWHFUX]DHOFDPLQR\VHGLULJHDOYpUWLFHHVWHGHODSDUFHODGHOSROtJRQR VLJXHDVXULQFRUSRUDQGRHOFDPLQROLQGDQGRFRQODVSDUFHODV\JLUDDRHVWHSRUHOOLQGHQRUWHGHODV SDUFHODV\KDVWDHOSXQWRGHRULJHQ $11(;,9$1(;2,9 GH 5HVROXFLyGHG DEULOGHOD'LUHFFLy*HQHUDOGH3DWULPRQL&XOWXUDO9DOHQFLjL0XVHXVGHOD&RQVHOOHULDGH&XOWXUD(GXFDFLyL(VSRUWSHUODTXHV LQFRDH[SHGLHQWSHUDOD SULPHUD IDVH GH O DFWXDOLW]DFLy L DGDSWDFLy SDUFLDO GH OD 6HFFLy 3ULPHUD GH O ,QYHQWDUL *HQHUDO GHO 3DWULPRQL &XOWXUDO 9DOHQFLj HQ PDWqULD GH SDWULPRQL DUTXLWHFWzQLF L PHGLDPELHQWDOLV¶REULSHUtRGHG¶LQIRUPDFLyS~EOLFD 5HVROXFLyQ GH GH DEULO GH OD 'LUHFFLyQ *HQHUDO GH 3DWULPRQLR &XOWXUDO 9DOHQFLDQR \ 0XVHRV GH OD &RQVHOOHULD GH &XOWXUD (GXFDFLyQ \ 'HSRUWH SRU OD TXH VH LQFRD H[SHGLHQWH SDUD OD SULPHUD IDVH GH OD DFWXDOL]DFLyQ \ DGDSWDFLyQ SDUFLDO GH OD 6HFFLyQ 3ULPHUD GHO ,QYHQWDULR *HQHUDO GHO 3DWULPRQLR &XOWXUDO 9DOHQFLDQR HQ PDWHULD GH SDWULPRQLRDUTXLWHFWyQLFR\PHGLRDPELHQWDO\VHDEUHSHULRGRGHLQIRUPDFLyQSXEOLFD Núm. 5.503 / 02.05.2007 17926 %e'¶,17(5e6&8/785$/±(50,7$'(/$&2162/$&,Ï//87;(1702180(17 %,(1'(,17(5e6&8/785$/±(50,7$'(/$&2162/$&,Ï1//87;(1702180(172 $11(;,9$1(;2,9 GH 5HVROXFLyGHG DEULOGHOD'LUHFFLy*HQHUDOGH3DWULPRQL&XOWXUDO9DOHQFLjL0XVHXVGHOD&RQVHOOHULDGH&XOWXUD(GXFDFLyL(VSRUWSHUODTXHV LQFRDH[SHGLHQWSHUDOD SULPHUD IDVH GH O DFWXDOLW]DFLy L DGDSWDFLy SDUFLDO GH OD 6HFFLy 3ULPHUD GH O ,QYHQWDUL *HQHUDO GHO 3DWULPRQL &XOWXUDO 9DOHQFLj HQ PDWqULD GH SDWULPRQL DUTXLWHFWzQLF L PHGLDPELHQWDOLV¶REULSHUtRGHG¶LQIRUPDFLyS~EOLFD 5HVROXFLyQ GH GH DEULO GH OD 'LUHFFLyQ *HQHUDO GH 3DWULPRQLR &XOWXUDO 9DOHQFLDQR \ 0XVHRV GH OD &RQVHOOHULD GH &XOWXUD (GXFDFLyQ \ 'HSRUWH SRU OD TXH VH LQFRD H[SHGLHQWH SDUD OD SULPHUD IDVH GH OD DFWXDOL]DFLyQ \ DGDSWDFLyQ SDUFLDO GH OD 6HFFLyQ 3ULPHUD GHO ,QYHQWDULR *HQHUDO GHO 3DWULPRQLR &XOWXUDO 9DOHQFLDQR HQ PDWHULD GH SDWULPRQLRDUTXLWHFWyQLFR\PHGLRDPELHQWDO\VHDEUHSHULRGRGHLQIRUPDFLyQSXEOLFD Núm. 5.503 / 02.05.2007 17927 %e'¶,17(5e6&8/785$/±021(67,5(6*/e6,$&219(17'(/&25386&+5,67,//87;(17 02180(17 %,(1'(,17(5e6&8/785$/021$67(5,2,*/(6,$&219(172'(/&25386&+5,67,//87;(17 02180(172 'HQRPLQDFLy'HQRPLQDFLyQ 3ULQFLSDO3ULQFLSDO 0RQHVWLUGHO&RUSXV&KULVWL 0RQDVWHULRGHO&RUSXV&KULVWL $FFHVzULD$FFHVRULD (VJOpVLDL&RQYHQWGHO&RUSXV&KULVWL ,JOHVLD\&RQYHQWRGHO&RUSXV&KULVWL /RFDOL]DFLy/RFDOL]DFLyQ 3URYLQFLD3URYLQFLD9DOqQFLD &RPDUFD&RPDUFD/D9DOOG¶$OEDLGD 0XQLFLSL0XQLFLSLR/OXW[HQW 8ELFDFLy8ELFDFLyQ&DPtGH&RVWD 5HIHUHQFLD&DGDVWUDO5HIHUHQFLD&DWDVWUDO 3ROtJRQ3ROtJRQR3DUFHOāOD3DUFHOD \ $QWHFHGHQWV-XUtGLFV$QWHFHGHQWHV-XUtGLFRV ,QFRDFLy,QFRDFLyQ 3XEOLFDFLyGHODLQFRDFLy3XEOLFDFLyQGHODLQFRDFLyQ%2( 'HVFULSFLy'HVFULSFLyQ 3DUWV,QWHJUDQWV3DUWHV,QWHJUDQWHV − (VJOpVLDFDSHOODGHOD&RPXQLyFDSHOODGHOD6DQWD)DoVDJULVWLDFODXVWUHDXODWRUUHUHIHFWRULFXLQD HVFDODHVSDGDQ\DSODQWHVVXSHULRUVDPEFHOāOHVGLSzVLWVSDWLGHVHUYHLVGHSHQGqQFLHVFRUUDOVDOMXEV HUPLWHVSUz[LPHV,JOHVLDFDSLOODGHOD&RPXQLyQFDSLOODGHOD6DQWD)D]VDFULVWtDFODXVWURDXODWRUUH − UHIHFWRULRFRFLQDHVFDOHUDHVSDGDxDSODQWDVVXSHULRUHVFRQFHOGDVGHSyVLWRVSDWLRGHVHUYLFLR GHSHQGHQFLDVFRUUDOHVDOMLEHVHUPLWDVSUy[LPDV $YDQWSODoDGHSHQGqQFLHVLG¶DOWUHVHVSDLVLHOHPHQWVYLQFXODWV$QWHSOD]DGHSHQGHQFLDV\RWURV HVSDFLRV\HOHPQWRVYLQFXODGRV 'HVFULSFLy*HQHUDO'HVFULSFLyQ*HQHUDO (O0RQHVWLUGHO&RUSXV&KULVWLSUHVHQWDHGLILFDFLRQVGHGLIHUHQWVqSRTXHVFRPHQojDDOoDUVHDOVHJOH;,9 /DFRQVWUXFFLyG HVWHPRQHVWLUHVWjYLQFXODGDDO³0LUDFOHGHOV&RUSRUDOV´TXHVHJRQVODWUDGLFLyRFRUUHJXp HQHVWHOORFHQHOVHJOH;,,,(OFRQMXQWV RUGHQDDWUDYpVG XQFODXVWUHHQHOFRVWDWVXGGHOTXDOHVWUREHQ O DXODOHVFHOāOHVLHOUHIHFWRUL(OFODXVWUHpVGHSODQWDTXDGUDGDLFRQVWDGHGRVFRVVRVHOFRVLQIHULRUDPE DUFVVREUHSLODVWUHV HOVFDSLWHOOV GHOHV TXDOVHVWDQGHFRUDWV DPEPRWLXV HXFDUtVWLFV/ (VJOpVLDGHO&RUSXV &KULVWL VHVLWXDHQHO FRVWDW QRUG GHO FODXVWUH GHO PRQHVWLU GHO PDWHL[ QRP (V WUDFWD G XQD HVJOpVLD G XQD VRODQDXGLYLGLGDHQTXDWUHWUDPVDPEFRUDOWDOVSHXV(VWjFREHUWDDPEYROWDGHFUHXHULDLYROWDHVWUHODGD HQ HO FRU DOW (Q HO FRVWDW GH O HStVWROD SUHVHQWD GXHV FDSHOOHV DQQH[HV UHDOLW]DGHV HQ HO VHJOH ;9,,, OD FDSHOODGHOD6DQWD)DoLODFDSHOOD GHOD&RPXQLyHVWD~OWLPD GH SODQWDGHFUHXJUHJDDPEF~SXODVREUH SHW[LQHV/DIjEULFDGHO HVJOpVLDHVWjUHDOLW]DGDDPEPDoRQHULDHQHOVPXUVLFDUUHXVHQHOVFRQWUDIRUWVLHQ HOVFDQWRQV&DSDO HVWGHOFRQMXQWHVWUREDHOSDWLGHVHUYHLVDOYROWDQWGHOTXDOHVGLVWULEXw[HQOHVGLIHUHQWV GHSHQGqQFLHV SHU DO IXQFLRQDPHQW GHO PRQHVWLU %DVDW HQ HO &DWjOHJ GH 0RQXPHQWV L &RQMXQWV GH OD &RPXQLWDW9DOHQFLDQDLOD*XLDG $UTXLWHFWXUDGHODSURYtQFLDGH9DOqQFLD (O 0RQDVWHULR GHO &RUSXV &KULVWL SUHVHQWD HGLILFDFLRQHV GH GLIHUHQWHV pSRFDV FRPHQ]iQGRVH D OHYDQWDU GHVGH HO VLJOR ;,9 /D FRQVWUXFFLyQ GH HVWH PRQDVWHULR HVWD YLQFXODGD DO ³0LODJUR GH ORV &RUSRUDOHV´ TXH VHJ~QODWUDGLFLyQRFXUULyHQHVWHOXJDUHQHOVLJOR;,,,(O FRQMXQWRVHRUGHQDDWUDYpVGHXQFODXVWURHQ FX\RODGRVXUVHHQFXHQWUDQHODXODODVFHOGDV\HOUHIHFWRULR(OFODXVWURGHSODQWDFXDGUDGDFRQVWDGHGRV FXHUSRVHOLQIHULRUFRQDUFRVVREUHSLODVWUDVFRQFDSLWHOHVGHFRUDGRVFRQPRWLYRVHXFDUtVWLFRV/D,JOHVLDGHO &RUSXV &KULVWL VH VLW~D HQ HO ODGR QRUWH GHO FODXVWUR GHO PRQDVWHULR GHO PLVPR QRPEUH 6H WUDWD GH XQD LJOHVLD GH XQD VROD QDYH GLYLGLGD HQ FXDWUR WUDPRV FRQ FRUR DOWR D ORV SLHV (VWi FXELHUWD FRQ EyYHGD GH FUXFHUtD\EyYHGDHVWUHOODGDHQHOFRURDOWR(QHOODGRGHOD(StVWRODSUHVHQWDGRVFDSLOODVDQH[DVUHDOL]DGDV HQHOVLJOR;9,,,ODFDSLOODGHOD6DQWD)D]\ODFDSLOODGHOD&RPXQLyQHVWDXOWLPDGHSODQWDGHFUX]JULHJD $11(;,9$1(;2,9 GH 5HVROXFLyGHG DEULOGHOD'LUHFFLy*HQHUDOGH3DWULPRQL&XOWXUDO9DOHQFLjL0XVHXVGHOD&RQVHOOHULDGH&XOWXUD(GXFDFLyL(VSRUWSHUODTXHV LQFRDH[SHGLHQWSHUDOD SULPHUD IDVH GH O DFWXDOLW]DFLy L DGDSWDFLy SDUFLDO GH OD 6HFFLy 3ULPHUD GH O ,QYHQWDUL *HQHUDO GHO 3DWULPRQL &XOWXUDO 9DOHQFLj HQ PDWqULD GH SDWULPRQL DUTXLWHFWzQLF L PHGLDPELHQWDOLV¶REULSHUtRGHG¶LQIRUPDFLyS~EOLFD 5HVROXFLyQ GH GH DEULO GH OD 'LUHFFLyQ *HQHUDO GH 3DWULPRQLR &XOWXUDO 9DOHQFLDQR \ 0XVHRV GH OD &RQVHOOHULD GH &XOWXUD (GXFDFLyQ \ 'HSRUWH SRU OD TXH VH LQFRD H[SHGLHQWH SDUD OD SULPHUD IDVH GH OD DFWXDOL]DFLyQ \ DGDSWDFLyQ SDUFLDO GH OD 6HFFLyQ 3ULPHUD GHO ,QYHQWDULR *HQHUDO GHO 3DWULPRQLR &XOWXUDO 9DOHQFLDQR HQ PDWHULD GH SDWULPRQLRDUTXLWHFWyQLFR\PHGLRDPELHQWDO\VHDEUHSHULRGRGHLQIRUPDFLyQSXEOLFD Núm. 5.503 / 02.05.2007 17928 FRQF~SXODVREUHSHFKLQDV/DIiEULFDGHODLJOHVLDHVWiUHDOL]DGDFRQPDPSRVWHUtDHQORVPXURV\VLOOHUtDHQ ORVFRQWUDIXHUWHV\HQODVHVTXLQDV+DFLDHOHVWHGHOFRQMXQWRVHHQFXHQWUDHOSDWLRGHVHUYLFLRVDOUHGHGRU GHO FXDO VH GLVWULEX\HQ ODV GLIHUHQWHV GHSHQGHQFLDV SDUD HO IXQFLRQDPLHQWR GHO PRQDVWHULR %DVDGR HQ HO &DWiORJRGH0RQXPHQWRV\&RQMXQWRVGHOD&RPXQLGDG9DOHQFLDQD\OD*XtDGH$UTXLWHFWXUDGHOD3URYLQFLD GH9DOHQFLD 2EVHUYDFLRQV2EVHUYDFLRQHV / HVJOpVLDFRQYHQWXDOMDFRPSWDDPEGHFODUDFLyLQGLYLGXDOLW]DGDSHU5HLDO'HFUHWGHGHPDUo SXEOLFDWHQHO%2(GHGHPDLJGH$OVHUSDUWLQWHJUDQWGHOPRQHVWLUODSURWHFFLyMXUtGLFDV DPSOLDUj DODWRWDOLWDWGHO LPPREOH /DLJOHVLDFRQYHQWXDO\DFXHQWDFRQGHFODUDFLyQLQGLYLGXDOL]DGDSRU5HDO'HFUHWRGHGHPDU]R SXEOLFDGRHQHO%2(GHGHPD\RGH$OVHUSDUWHLQWHJUDQWHGHOPRQDVWHULRODSURWHFFLyQMXUtGLFDVH DPSOLDUiDODWRWDOLGDGGHOLQPXHEOH (QWRUQ(QWRUQ $QWHFHGHQWVDGPLQLVWUDWLXVGHOLPLWDFLyH[WUHWDGHO H[SHGLHQWGHILQLGDDPEFDUjFWHUSURYLVLRQDO 2ULJHQ7UREDGDGHO HL[GHO&DPtGHO&DOYDULDPEODSURORQJDFLyGHODPLWJHUDQRUGGHOD SDUFHOāODGHO SROtJRQFDGDVWUDOSXQW$ 6HQWLW+RUDUL /tQLDGHOLPLWDGRUDGHVGHO RULJHQODOtQLDHVGLULJL[DO¶HVWYRUHMDQWHOFDPtSHOOtPLWQRUGGHODSDUFHOāOD GHOSROtJRQILQVDODWUREDGD DPE OD SDUFHOāOD6HJXL[SHOOtPLWVXGGHOD SDUFHOāODILQVDO FDPt H[LVWHQW*LUDDQRUGSHUO HVWGHODSDUFHOāODWUDYHVVDHOFDPtLVHJXL[ILQVDOYqUWH[VXGGHODSDUFHOāOD YRUHMDHVWDSDUFHOāODLQFRUSRUDQWODLGHVGHOVHXH[WUHPRHVWHVGLULJL[DQRUGHVWILQVDOYqUWH[RHVWGH OD SDUFHOāOD GHO SROtJRQ 9RUHMD LQFORHQWOHV OHV SDUFHOāOHV L GHV GHO YqUWH[QRUGG HVWDHVGLULJL[DHVWHILQVDODLQFORHQWOD'HVGHOYqUWH[HVG HVWDHVGLULJL[DOYqUWH[VXG GHODSDUFHOāODSHUDFRQWLQXDUYRUHMDQWHOOtPLWRHVWGHOHVSDUFHOāOHVL'HVG HVWHFUHXDHOFDPt LHVGLULJL[DOYqUWH[HVWHGHODSDUFHOāODGHOSROtJRQVHJXL[DOVXGLQFRUSRUDQWHOFDPtOLPLWDQWDPEOHV SDUFHOāOHVLJLUDDO¶RHVWSHOOtPLWQRUGGHOHVSDUFHOāOHVLILQVDOSXQWG RULJHQ $QWHFHGHQWHVDGPLQLVWUDWLYRVGHOLPLWDFLyQH[WUDtGDGHOH[SHGLHQWHGHILQLGDFRQFDUiFWHUSURYLVLRQDO 2ULJHQ(QFXHQWURGHOHMHGHO&DPLQRGHO&DOYDULRFRQODSURORQJDFLyQGHODPHGLDQHUDQRUWHGHODSDUFHOD GHOSROtJRQRFDWDVWUDOSXQWR$ 6HQWLGR+RUDULR /LQHD GHOLPLWDGRUD GHVGH HO RULJHQ OD OtQHD VH GLULJH D HVWH ERUGHDQGR HO FDPLQR SRU HO OLQGH QRUWH GH OD SDUFHODGHOSROtJRQRKDVWDHOHQFXHQWURFRQODSDUFHOD6LJXHSRUHOOLQGHVXUGHODSDUFHOD KDVWDHOFDPLQRH[LVWHQWH*LUDDQRUWHSRUHOHVWHGHODSDUFHODDWUDYLHVDHOFDPLQR\ VLJXHKDVWDHO YpUWLFH VXU GH OD SDUFHOD ERUGHD HVWD SDUFHOD LQFRUSRUiQGROD \ GHVGH VX H[WUHPR RHVWH VH GLULJH D QRUHVWH KDVWD HO YpUWLFH RHVWH GH OD SDUFHOD GHO SROtJRQR %RUGHD LQFOX\pQGRODV ODV SDUFHODV \GHVGHHOYpUWLFHQRUWHGHpVWDVHGLULJHDHVWHKDVWDODLQFOX\pQGROD'HVGHHO YpUWLFHHVWHGHpVWDVH GLULJH DO YpUWLFH VXU GH OD SDUFHOD SDUD VHJXLU ERUGHDQGR HO OLQGH RHVWH GH ODV SDUFHODV\'HVGHpVWHFUX]DHOFDPLQR\VHGLULJHDOYpUWLFHHVWHGHODSDUFHODGHOSROtJRQR VLJXHDOVXULQFRUSRUDQGRHOFDPLQROLQGDQGRFRQODVSDUFHODV\JLUDDRHVWHSRUHOOLQGHQRUWHGHODV SDUFHODV\KDVWDHOSXQWRGHRULJHQ $11(;,9$1(;2,9 GH 5HVROXFLyGHG DEULOGHOD'LUHFFLy*HQHUDOGH3DWULPRQL&XOWXUDO9DOHQFLjL0XVHXVGHOD&RQVHOOHULDGH&XOWXUD(GXFDFLyL(VSRUWSHUODTXHV LQFRDH[SHGLHQWSHUDOD SULPHUD IDVH GH O DFWXDOLW]DFLy L DGDSWDFLy SDUFLDO GH OD 6HFFLy 3ULPHUD GH O ,QYHQWDUL *HQHUDO GHO 3DWULPRQL &XOWXUDO 9DOHQFLj HQ PDWqULD GH SDWULPRQL DUTXLWHFWzQLF L PHGLDPELHQWDOLV¶REULSHUtRGHG¶LQIRUPDFLyS~EOLFD 5HVROXFLyQ GH GH DEULO GH OD 'LUHFFLyQ *HQHUDO GH 3DWULPRQLR &XOWXUDO 9DOHQFLDQR \ 0XVHRV GH OD &RQVHOOHULD GH &XOWXUD (GXFDFLyQ \ 'HSRUWH SRU OD TXH VH LQFRD H[SHGLHQWH SDUD OD SULPHUD IDVH GH OD DFWXDOL]DFLyQ \ DGDSWDFLyQ SDUFLDO GH OD 6HFFLyQ 3ULPHUD GHO ,QYHQWDULR *HQHUDO GHO 3DWULPRQLR &XOWXUDO 9DOHQFLDQR HQ PDWHULD GH SDWULPRQLRDUTXLWHFWyQLFR\PHGLRDPELHQWDO\VHDEUHSHULRGRGHLQIRUPDFLyQSXEOLFD Núm. 5.503 / 02.05.2007 17929 %e'¶,17(5e6&8/785$/±021(67,5(6*/e6,$&219(17'(/&25386&+5,67,//87;(17 02180(17 %,(1'(,17(5e6&8/785$/021$67(5,2,*/(6,$&219(172'(/&25386&+5,67,//87;(17 02180(172 $11(;,9$1(;2,9 GH 5HVROXFLyGHG DEULOGHOD'LUHFFLy*HQHUDOGH3DWULPRQL&XOWXUDO9DOHQFLjL0XVHXVGHOD&RQVHOOHULDGH&XOWXUD(GXFDFLyL(VSRUWSHUODTXHV LQFRDH[SHGLHQWSHUDOD SULPHUD IDVH GH O DFWXDOLW]DFLy L DGDSWDFLy SDUFLDO GH OD 6HFFLy 3ULPHUD GH O ,QYHQWDUL *HQHUDO GHO 3DWULPRQL &XOWXUDO 9DOHQFLj HQ PDWqULD GH SDWULPRQL DUTXLWHFWzQLF L PHGLDPELHQWDOLV¶REULSHUtRGHG¶LQIRUPDFLyS~EOLFD 5HVROXFLyQ GH GH DEULO GH OD 'LUHFFLyQ *HQHUDO GH 3DWULPRQLR &XOWXUDO 9DOHQFLDQR \ 0XVHRV GH OD &RQVHOOHULD GH &XOWXUD (GXFDFLyQ \ 'HSRUWH SRU OD TXH VH LQFRD H[SHGLHQWH SDUD OD SULPHUD IDVH GH OD DFWXDOL]DFLyQ \ DGDSWDFLyQ SDUFLDO GH OD 6HFFLyQ 3ULPHUD GHO ,QYHQWDULR *HQHUDO GHO 3DWULPRQLR &XOWXUDO 9DOHQFLDQR HQ PDWHULD GH SDWULPRQLRDUTXLWHFWyQLFR\PHGLRDPELHQWDO\VHDEUHSHULRGRGHLQIRUPDFLyQSXEOLFD Núm. 5.503 / 02.05.2007 17930 %e'¶,17(5e6&8/785$/±(50,7$'(6$17$%¬5%$5$021Ñ9(502180(17 %,(1'(,17(5e6&8/785$/(50,7$'(6$17$%È5%$5$021Ï9$502180(172 'HQRPLQDFLy'HQRPLQDFLyQ 3ULQFLSDO3ULQFLSDO (UPLWDGH6DQWD%jUEDUD (UPLWDGH6DQWD%iUEDUD /RFDOLW]DFLy/RFDOL]DFLyQ 3URYtQFLD3URYLQFLD$ODFDQW &RPDUFD&RPDUFD(O9LQDORSy0LWMj 0XQLFLSL0XQLFLSLR0RQzYHU0RQyYDU 8ELFDFLy8ELFDFLyQ&DUUHUGHO6DJULVWj 5HIHUqQFLD&DGDVWUDO5HIHUHQFLD&DWDVWUDO ,OOD0DQ]DQD3DUFHOāOD3DUFHOD $QWHFHGHQWV-XUtGLFV$QWHFHGHQWHV-XUtGLFRV ,QFRDFLy,QFRDFLyQ 3XEOLFDFLyGHODLQFRDFLy3XEOLFDFLyQGHODLQFRDFLyQ%2( 'HVFULSFLy'HVFULSFLyQ 3DUWV,QWHJUDQWV3DUWHV,QWHJUDQWHV /¶(GLILFL(O(GLILFLR 'HVFULSFLy*HQHUDO'HVFULSFLyQ*HQHUDO (V WUDFWD G XQ HGLILFL DwOODW GH SODQWD UHFWDQJXODU GLYLGLW HQ WUHV HVSDLV GLIHUHQFLDWV $O VXG XQ DWUL SRUWLFDW DPE WUHV DUFV VREUH FROXPQHV GH SHGUD HQ OD ]RQD LQWHUPqGLD OD FDSHOOD GH SODQWD HOāOtSWLFD L DO QRUG OD VDJULVWLD R FDVD GH O¶HUPLWDQD 8QD F~SXOD GH PLWMD WDURQMD HV UHFRO]D VREUH OD FRUQLVD F~SXOD TXH HQ O H[WUDGyV D O H[WHULRU V REVHUYD HQ GREOH FXUYDWXUD DFDEDGD HQ WHXOD YLGULDGD HQ FRORU EODX $ O LQWHULRU GHVWDFDHOVzOGHJUDQVOORVHVGHSHGUDLODGHFRUDFLyHQIRUPDGHJDUODQGHVVDQHIHVIORURQVHQUHOOHXLOD XWLOLW]DFLyGHFDSLWHOOVFRULQWLV9DVHUFRQVWUXwWHQHOVHJOH;9,,, 5HVXPGHODGHVFULSFLyGH69DUHOD 6HWUDWDGHXQHGLILFLRDLVODGRGHSODQWDUHFWDQJXODUGLYLGLGRHQWUHVHVSDFLRVGLIHUHQFLDGRV$OVXUXQDWULR SRUWLFDGRFRQWUHVDUFRVVREUHFROXPQDVGHSLHGUDHQOD]RQDLQWHUPHGLDODFDSLOODGHSODQWDHOtSWLFD\DO QRUWHODVDFULVWtDRFDVDGHODVDQWHUD8QDF~SXODGHPHGLDQDUDQMDVHDSR\DVREUHODFRUQLVDF~SXODTXH HQ HO WUDVGyV DO H[WHULRU VH REVHUYD HQ GREOH FXUYDWXUD WHUPLQDGD HQ WHMD YLGULDGD HQ FRORU D]XO $O LQWHULRU GHVWDFD HO VXHOR GH JUDQGHV ORVDV GH SLHGUD \ OD GHFRUDFLyQ D EDVH GH JXLUQDOGDV FHQHIDV IORURQHVHQUHOLHYH\ODXWLOL]DFLyQGHFDSLWHOHVFRULQWLRV)XHFRQVWUXLGRHQHOVLJOR;9,,,5HVXPHQGHOD GHVFULSFLyQGH69DUHOD 2EVHUYDFLRQV2EVHUYDFLRQHV (O FDUjFWHU DGGLWLX GH OD SRU[DGD FRQGLFLRQD OD URWXQGLWDW EDUURFD GH OD IDoDQD L F~SXOD TXH GH PDQHUD XQLWjULDFDUDFWHULW]HQODLPDWJHDUTXLWHFWzQLFDGHO¶LPPREOH (O FDUiFWHU DGLWLYR GHO SyUWLFR FRQGLFLRQD OD URWXQGLGDG EDUURFD GH OD IDFKDGD \ F~SXOD TXH GH PDQHUD XQLWDULDFDUDFWHUL]DQHOLPDJHQDUTXLWHFWyQLFDGHOLQPXHEOH $11(;,9$1(;2,9 GH 5HVROXFLyGHG DEULOGHOD'LUHFFLy*HQHUDOGH3DWULPRQL&XOWXUDO9DOHQFLjL0XVHXVGHOD&RQVHOOHULDGH&XOWXUD(GXFDFLyL(VSRUWSHUODTXHV LQFRDH[SHGLHQWSHUDOD SULPHUD IDVH GH O DFWXDOLW]DFLy L DGDSWDFLy SDUFLDO GH OD 6HFFLy 3ULPHUD GH O ,QYHQWDUL *HQHUDO GHO 3DWULPRQL &XOWXUDO 9DOHQFLj HQ PDWqULD GH SDWULPRQL DUTXLWHFWzQLF L PHGLDPELHQWDOLV¶REULSHUtRGHG¶LQIRUPDFLyS~EOLFD 5HVROXFLyQ GH GH DEULO GH OD 'LUHFFLyQ *HQHUDO GH 3DWULPRQLR &XOWXUDO 9DOHQFLDQR \ 0XVHRV GH OD &RQVHOOHULD GH &XOWXUD (GXFDFLyQ \ 'HSRUWH SRU OD TXH VH LQFRD H[SHGLHQWH SDUD OD SULPHUD IDVH GH OD DFWXDOL]DFLyQ \ DGDSWDFLyQ SDUFLDO GH OD 6HFFLyQ 3ULPHUD GHO ,QYHQWDULR *HQHUDO GHO 3DWULPRQLR &XOWXUDO 9DOHQFLDQR HQ PDWHULD GH SDWULPRQLRDUTXLWHFWyQLFR\PHGLRDPELHQWDO\VHDEUHSHULRGRGHLQIRUPDFLyQSXEOLFD Núm. 5.503 / 02.05.2007 17931 (QWRUQR(QWRUQR $QWHFHGHQWVDGPLQLVWUDWLXVGHOLPLWDFLyH[WUHWDGHO H[SHGLHQWGHILQLGDDPEFDUjFWHUSURYLVLRQDO 2ULJHQ7UREDGDGHO HL[GHOFDUUHUGH6DQWD%jUEDUDDPESURORQJDFLyGHOFDUUHUGH0DVLDQHWSXQW$ 6HQWLW+RUDUL /tQLD GHOLPLWDGRUD 'HV GH O RULJHQ $ SHU O HL[ GHO FDPt FXUYLOLQL SURORQJDFLy GHO FDUUHU GH 0DVLDQHW TXH GLVFRUUHSHOVzOQRXUEDQLW]DEOHILQVDODVHXDWUREDGDDPEO¶DQRPHQDW&DPtGHOV&ORWVDFtJLUDDVXGHVW VHJXL[ SHU O HL[ GH O HVPHQWDW FDPt ILQV D OD VHXD WUREDGD DPE OD LOOD GH FDVHV FDGDVWUDO OD YRUHMD H[FORHQWOD L HV GLULJL[ D O HL[ GHO FDUUHU GH %HUWROLFR SHO TXH SURVVHJXL[ *LUD SHO FDUUHU GHO 0DQ\R ILQV DO FDUUHU GH /D 3DX LQFORHQWOR ILQV D O HL[ GHO FDUUHU GH 6DQWD %jUEDUD L SHU O HL[ G HVWH FDUUHU ILQV DO SXQW G RULJHQ$ $QWHFHGHQWHVDGPLQLVWUDWLYRVGHOLPLWDFLyQH[WUDtGDGHOH[SHGLHQWHGHILQLGDFRQFDUiFWHUSURYLVLRQDO 2ULJHQ(QFXHQWURGHOHMHGHODFDOOH6DQWD%iUEDUDFRQSURORQJDFLyQGHODFDOOH0DVLDQHWSXQWR$ 6HQWLGR+RUDULR /LQHDGHOLPLWDGRUD'HVGHHORULJHQ$SRUHOHMHGHOFDPLQRFXUYLOtQHRSURORQJDFLyQGHODFDOOH0DVLDQHWTXH GLVFXUUHSRUHOVXHORQRXUEDQL]DEOHKDVWDVXHQFXHQWURFRQHOOODPDGR&DPtGHOV&ORWVDTXtJLUDDVXUHVWH VLJXH SRU HO HMH GHO FLWDGR FDPLQR KDVWD VX HQFXHQWUR FRQ OD PDQ]DQD FDWDVWUDO OD ERUGHD H[FOX\pQGROD\VHGLULJHDOHMHGHODFDOOH%HUWROLFRSRUHOTXHSURVLJXH*LUDSRUODFDOOH0DQ\RKDVWDODFDOOH GH/D3DXLQFOX\pQGRODKDVWDHOHMHGHODFDOOH6DQWD%iUEDUD \SRUHOHMHGHHVWDFDOOHKDVWDHOSXQWRGH RULJHQ$ $11(;,9$1(;2,9 GH 5HVROXFLyGHG DEULOGHOD'LUHFFLy*HQHUDOGH3DWULPRQL&XOWXUDO9DOHQFLjL0XVHXVGHOD&RQVHOOHULDGH&XOWXUD(GXFDFLyL(VSRUWSHUODTXHV LQFRDH[SHGLHQWSHUDOD SULPHUD IDVH GH O DFWXDOLW]DFLy L DGDSWDFLy SDUFLDO GH OD 6HFFLy 3ULPHUD GH O ,QYHQWDUL *HQHUDO GHO 3DWULPRQL &XOWXUDO 9DOHQFLj HQ PDWqULD GH SDWULPRQL DUTXLWHFWzQLF L PHGLDPELHQWDOLV¶REULSHUtRGHG¶LQIRUPDFLyS~EOLFD 5HVROXFLyQ GH GH DEULO GH OD 'LUHFFLyQ *HQHUDO GH 3DWULPRQLR &XOWXUDO 9DOHQFLDQR \ 0XVHRV GH OD &RQVHOOHULD GH &XOWXUD (GXFDFLyQ \ 'HSRUWH SRU OD TXH VH LQFRD H[SHGLHQWH SDUD OD SULPHUD IDVH GH OD DFWXDOL]DFLyQ \ DGDSWDFLyQ SDUFLDO GH OD 6HFFLyQ 3ULPHUD GHO ,QYHQWDULR *HQHUDO GHO 3DWULPRQLR &XOWXUDO 9DOHQFLDQR HQ PDWHULD GH SDWULPRQLRDUTXLWHFWyQLFR\PHGLRDPELHQWDO\VHDEUHSHULRGRGHLQIRUPDFLyQSXEOLFD Núm. 5.503 / 02.05.2007 17932 %e'¶,17(5e6&8/785$/±(50,7$'(6$17$%¬5%$5$021Ñ9(502180(17 %,(1'(,17(5e6&8/785$/(50,7$'(6$17$%È5%$5$021Ï9$502180(172 $11(;,9$1(;2,9 GH 5HVROXFLyGHG DEULOGHOD'LUHFFLy*HQHUDOGH3DWULPRQL&XOWXUDO9DOHQFLjL0XVHXVGHOD&RQVHOOHULDGH&XOWXUD(GXFDFLyL(VSRUWSHUODTXHV LQFRDH[SHGLHQWSHUDOD SULPHUD IDVH GH O DFWXDOLW]DFLy L DGDSWDFLy SDUFLDO GH OD 6HFFLy 3ULPHUD GH O ,QYHQWDUL *HQHUDO GHO 3DWULPRQL &XOWXUDO 9DOHQFLj HQ PDWqULD GH SDWULPRQL DUTXLWHFWzQLF L PHGLDPELHQWDOLV¶REULSHUtRGHG¶LQIRUPDFLyS~EOLFD 5HVROXFLyQ GH GH DEULO GH OD 'LUHFFLyQ *HQHUDO GH 3DWULPRQLR &XOWXUDO 9DOHQFLDQR \ 0XVHRV GH OD &RQVHOOHULD GH &XOWXUD (GXFDFLyQ \ 'HSRUWH SRU OD TXH VH LQFRD H[SHGLHQWH SDUD OD SULPHUD IDVH GH OD DFWXDOL]DFLyQ \ DGDSWDFLyQ SDUFLDO GH OD 6HFFLyQ 3ULPHUD GHO ,QYHQWDULR *HQHUDO GHO 3DWULPRQLR &XOWXUDO 9DOHQFLDQR HQ PDWHULD GH SDWULPRQLRDUTXLWHFWyQLFR\PHGLRDPELHQWDO\VHDEUHSHULRGRGHLQIRUPDFLyQSXEOLFD Núm. 5.503 / 02.05.2007 17933 %e'¶,17(5e6&8/785$/±(6*/e6,$3$55248,$/'(/6$/9$'25087;$0(/02180(17 %,(1'(,17(5e6&8/785$/,*/(6,$3$55248,$/'((/6$/9$'25087;$0(/02180(172 'HQRPLQDFLy'HQRPLQDFLyQ 3ULQFLSDO3ULQFLSDO (VJOpVLD3DUURTXLDOGHO6DOYDGRU ,JOHVLD3DUURTXLDOGHO6DOYDGRU /RFDOL]DFLy/RFDOL]DFLyQ 3URYtQFLD3URYLQFLD$ODFDQW &RPDUFD&RPDUFD/¶$ODFDQWt 0XQLFLSL0XQLFLSLR0XW[DPHO 8ELFDFLy8ELFDFLyQ&GHO0HVWUH6DOD0DUFR 5HIHUqQFLD&DGDVWUDO5HIHUHQFLD&DWDVWUDO ,OOD0DQ]DQD3DUFHOāOD3DUFHOD $QWHFHGHQWV-XUtGLFV$QWHFHGHQWHV-XUtGLFRV ,QFRDFLy,QFRDFLyQ 3XEOLFDFLy GH OD LQFRDFLy 3XEOLFDFLyQ GH OD LQFRDFLyQ%2( 'HVFULSFLy'HVFULSFLyQ 3DUWV,QWHJUDQWV3DUWHV,QWHJUDQWHV − 7RUUHFDPSDQDU7RUUHFDPSDQDULR − (VJOpVLDDPEQDXSULQFLSDO,JOHVLDFRQQDYHSULQFLSDO − &DSHOOHVODWHUDOV&DSLOODVODWHUDOHV − &RU&RUR − 3RUWDGDSULQFLSDOLODWHUDOV3RUWDGDSULQFLSDO\ODWHUDOHV − 6DJULVWLD6DFULVWtD − &DSHOOD0DUHGH'pXGH/RUHWR&DSLOOD9LUJHQGH/RUHWR 'HVFULSFLy*HQHUDO'HVFULSFLyQ*HQHUDO / (VJOpVLD3DUURTXLDOGHO6DOYDGRUHVWUREDHQHOFHQWUHGHOD9LODGH0XW[DPHOpVO HGLILFLPpVGHVWDFDEOHGH OD FLXWDW (O WHPSOH DFWXDO HVWj DGRVVDW D OD SULPLWLYD WRUUH GHIHQVLYD GHO VHJOH ;9, TXH DFWXDOPHQW pV HO FDPSDQDU TXH GDWD GHO VHJOH ;9,,, (V WUDFWD G XQD HVJOpVLD GH SODQWD GH FUHX OODWLQD G XQD VROD QDX L FDSHOOHV HQWUH FRQWUDIRUWV SHUIRUDWV TXH SHUPHWHQ OD FRPXQLFDFLy HQWUH OHV HVPHQWDGHV FDSHOOHV 3UHVHQWD XQFUHXHUDOVFRVWDWVGHOTXDOVHVLWXHQODVDJULVWLDLODFDSHOODGHOD0DUHGH'pX/DFREHUWDGHODQDXpVGH YROWDGHFDQyDPEOOXQHWHVPHQWUHVTXHHOSUHVELWHULFREUL[DPEXQDF~SXOD/ LQWHULRUV DUWLFXODSHUPLWMj GH FROXPQHV MzQLTXHV DPE XQD JDOHULD FRUUHJXGD VREUH O HQWDXODPHQW VROXFLy PROW XWLOLW]DGD HQ HO VHJOH ;9,,,/DGHFRUDFLyHVWjIRUPDGDSHUPHGDOORQVLPRWOXUHVG HVFDLROD/ HVJOpVLDFRQVWDGHWUHVDFFHVVRVGRV G HOOVHQHOVEUDoRVGHOFUHXHULHOSULQFLSDODOVSHXVGHO HVJOpVLDODIDoDQDKDTXHGDWLQFRQFOXVD/DSRUWDGD HVGLYLGL[HQGRVFRVVRVO LQIHULRUDOOLQGDWLHOVXSHULRUDPEXQDIRUQtFXODTXHDOEHUJDHOVDQW/DFDSHOODGH OD0DUHGH'pXDQRPHQDGDDQWHULRUPHQWpVGHSODQWDTXDGUDGDDPEXQDF~SXODTXHWpXQFXSXOtSHUDOD LOāOXPLQDFLyLQWHULRU%DVDWHQHO&DWjOHJGH0RQXPHQWVL&RQMXQWVGHOD&RPXQLWDW9DOHQFLDQD /D,JOHVLD3DUURTXLDOGHO6DOYDGRUVHHQFXHQWUDHQHOFHQWURGHOD9LODGH0XW[DPHOVLHQGRHOHGLILFLRPiV GHVWDFDEOHGHODFLXGDG(OWHPSORDFWXDOTXHGDDGRVDGRDODSULPLWLYDWRUUHGHIHQVLYDGHOVLJOR;9,DFWXDO FDPSDQDULRTXHGDWDGHODFHQWXULDGHO;9,,,6HWUDWDGHXQDLJOHVLDGHSODQWDGHFUX]ODWLQDGHXQDVROD QDYH\FDSLOODVHQWUHFRQWUDIXHUWHVHVWDQGRpVWRVKRUDGDGRVSHUPLWLHQGRODFRPXQLFDFLyQHQWUHODVFDSLOODV 3UHVHQWDXQFUXFHURDFX\RVODGRVVHVLW~DQODVDFULVWtD\ODFDSLOODGHOD9LUJHQ/DFXELHUWDGHODQDYHHVWi UHDOL]DGDPHGLDQWH EyYHGDGHFDxyQFRQOXQHWRVPLHQWUDVTXHHOSUHVELWHULR VH FXEUH FRQ XQD F~SXOD (O LQWHULRUVHDUWLFXODSRUPHGLRGHFROXPQDVMyQLFDVFRQXQDJDOHUtDFRUULGDVREUHHOHQWDEODPHQWRVROXFLyQ PX\XWLOL]DGDHQHOVLJOR;9,,,/DGHFRUDFLyQHVDEDVHGHPHGDOORQHV\PROGXUDVGHHVFD\ROD/DLJOHVLD FRQVWDGHWUHVDFFHVRVGRVGHHOORVHQORVEUD]RVGHOFUXFHUR\HOSULQFLSDODORVSLHVGHODLJOHVLDKDELHQGR TXHGDGRODIDFKDGDLQFRQFOXVD/DSRUWDGDVHGLYLGHHQGRVFXHUSRVHOLQIHULRUDGLQWHODGR\HOVXSHULRUFRQ XQD KRUQDFLQD TXH DOEHUJD DO VDQWR /D FDSLOOD GH OD 9LUJHQ PHQFLRQDGD DQWHULRUPHQWH HV GH SODQWD FXDGUDGD FRQ XQD F~SXOD TXH WLHQH XQ FXSXOtQ SDUD OD LOXPLQDFLyQ LQWHULRU %DVDGR HQ HO &DWiORJR GH 0RQXPHQWRV\&RQMXQWRVGHOD&RPXQLGDG9DOHQFLDQD $11(;,9$1(;2,9 GH 5HVROXFLyGHG DEULOGHOD'LUHFFLy*HQHUDOGH3DWULPRQL&XOWXUDO9DOHQFLjL0XVHXVGHOD&RQVHOOHULDGH&XOWXUD(GXFDFLyL(VSRUWSHUODTXHV LQFRDH[SHGLHQWSHUDOD SULPHUD IDVH GH O DFWXDOLW]DFLy L DGDSWDFLy SDUFLDO GH OD 6HFFLy 3ULPHUD GH O ,QYHQWDUL *HQHUDO GHO 3DWULPRQL &XOWXUDO 9DOHQFLj HQ PDWqULD GH SDWULPRQL DUTXLWHFWzQLF L PHGLDPELHQWDOLV¶REULSHUtRGHG¶LQIRUPDFLyS~EOLFD 5HVROXFLyQ GH GH DEULO GH OD 'LUHFFLyQ *HQHUDO GH 3DWULPRQLR &XOWXUDO 9DOHQFLDQR \ 0XVHRV GH OD &RQVHOOHULD GH &XOWXUD (GXFDFLyQ \ 'HSRUWH SRU OD TXH VH LQFRD H[SHGLHQWH SDUD OD SULPHUD IDVH GH OD DFWXDOL]DFLyQ \ DGDSWDFLyQ SDUFLDO GH OD 6HFFLyQ 3ULPHUD GHO ,QYHQWDULR *HQHUDO GHO 3DWULPRQLR &XOWXUDO 9DOHQFLDQR HQ PDWHULD GH SDWULPRQLRDUTXLWHFWyQLFR\PHGLRDPELHQWDO\VHDEUHSHULRGRGHLQIRUPDFLyQSXEOLFD Núm. 5.503 / 02.05.2007 17934 2EVHUYDFLRQV2EVHUYDFLRQHV /DWRUUHGHIHQVLYDVREUHODTXDOHVFRQVWUXHL[O¶DFWXDOWRUUHFDPSDQDUMDJDXGHL[HQUDyGHODVHXDQDWXUDOHVD LFRQIRUPHDOD/OHLGHODFRQVLGHUDFLyGH%,&0RQXPHQW /DWRUUHGHIHQVLYDEDVHGHODFWXDOFDPSDQDULR\DGLVIUXWDHQUD]yQGHVXQDWXUDOH]D\GHDFXHUGRDODOH\GH ODFRQVLGHUDFLyQGH%,&0RQXPHQWR (QWRUQ(QWRUQ $QWHFHGHQWVDGPLQLVWUDWLXVGHOLPLWDFLyH[WUHWDGHO H[SHGLHQWGHILQLGDDPEFDUjFWHUSURYLVLRQDO 2ULJHQLQWHUVHFFLyGHOFDUUHUGH5RGULJXH]$OEHUWDPEODSURORQJDFLyGHODPLWJHUDQRUGHVWGHODSDUFHOāOD GHO¶LOODGHFDVHVSXQW$ 6HQWLWKRUDUL /tQLDGHOLPLWDGRUDODOtQLDUHFRUUHODPLWJHUDHQWUHOHVSDUFHOāOHVLGHO¶LOODGHFDVHVLVHJXL[SHU OHVSRVWHULRUVGHOHVSDUFHOāOHVLGHODPDWHL[D6HJXL[SHUODPLWJHUDQRUGGHODSDUFHOāOD G HVWDLOODGHFDVHV&UHXDHOFDUUHUGHO0HVWUH6DOD0DUFR LFRQWLQXDSHUOHVSRVWHULRUVGHOHVSDUFHOāOHV GHO¶LOODGHFDVHVTXHGRQHQDOFDUUHUGHO&DUPHQLOHVGHO¶LOODGHFDVHVTXHGRQHQDOFDUUHUGH OD 0DULVWHOD 6HJXL[ SHU OHV SRVWHULRUV GH OHV SDUFHOāOHV GH O¶LOOD GH FDVHV TXH GRQHQ DOV FDUUHUV GHO 6DJUDW &RU L SODoD 1RYD VHJXL[ SHU OD PLWJHUD HQWUH OHV SDUFHOāOHV L G HVWD LOOD GH FDVHV L FUHXD HO FDUUHUGHO0DU,QFRUSRUDODSDUFHOāODGHO¶LOODGHFDVHVLOHVLGHOD&UHXDHOFDUUHUGH 6DQW$QWRQLLV LQWURGXw[HQO¶LOODGHFDVHVHQWUHOHVSDUFHOāOHVL6HJXL[HQGLUHFFLyQRUGSHUOHV SRVWHULRUV GH OHV SDUFHOāOHV G HVWD LOOD GH FDVHV TXH GRQHQ D OD SODoD 1RYD JLUD SHU O HL[ GHO FDUUHU GH 5RGUtJXH]$OEHUWILQVDOSXQWG RULJHQ $QWHFHGHQWHVDGPLQLVWUDWLYRVGHOLPLWDFLyQH[WUDtGDGHOH[SHGLHQWHGHILQLGDFRQFDUiFWHUSURYLVLRQDO 2ULJHQLQWHUVHFFLyQGHODFDOOH5RGULJXH]$OEHUWFRQODSURORQJDFLyQGHODPHGLDQHUDQRUGHVWHGHODSDUFHOD GHODPDQ]DQDSXQWR$ 6HQWLGRKRUDULR /tQHDGHOLPLWDGRUDODOtQHDUHFRUUHODPHGLDQHUDHQWUHODV SDUFHODV\ GHODPDQ]DQD \ VLJXH SRUODVWUDVHUDVGHODVSDUFHODV\GHODPLVPD6LJXHSRUODPHGLDQHUDQRUWHGHODSDUFHOD GH HVWD PDQ]DQD &UX]D OD FDOOH 0DHVWUR 6DOD 0DUFR \ FRQWLQ~D SRU ODV WUDVHUDV GH ODV SDUFHODV GH OD PDQ]DQD UHFD\HQWHV D OD FDOOH &DUPHQ \ ODV GH OD PDQ]DQD UHFD\HQWHV D OD FDOOH 0DULVWHOD 6LJXHSRUODVWUDVHUDVGHODVSDUFHODVGHODPDQ]DQDUHFD\HQWHVDODVFDOOHV6DJUDGR&RUD]yQ\SOD]D 1XHYD VLJXH SRU OD PHGLDQHUD HQWUH ODV SDUFHODV \ GH HVWD PDQ]DQD \ FUX]D OD FDOOH 'HO 0DU ,QFRUSRUDOD SDUFHOD GH OD PDQ]DQD \ ODV \ GH OD &UX]D OD FDOOH 6DQ $QWRQLR \ VH LQWURGXFHHQODPDQ]DQDHQWUHODVSDUFHODV\6LJXHHQGLUHFFLyQQRUWHSRUODVWUDVHUDVGHODV SDUFHODVGHHVWDPDQ]DQDUHFD\HQWHVDODSOD]D1XHYDJLUDSRUHOHMHGHODFDOOH5RGUtJXH]$OEHUWKDVWDHO SXQWRGHRULJHQ $11(;,9$1(;2,9 GH 5HVROXFLyGHG DEULOGHOD'LUHFFLy*HQHUDOGH3DWULPRQL&XOWXUDO9DOHQFLjL0XVHXVGHOD&RQVHOOHULDGH&XOWXUD(GXFDFLyL(VSRUWSHUODTXHV LQFRDH[SHGLHQWSHUDOD SULPHUD IDVH GH O DFWXDOLW]DFLy L DGDSWDFLy SDUFLDO GH OD 6HFFLy 3ULPHUD GH O ,QYHQWDUL *HQHUDO GHO 3DWULPRQL &XOWXUDO 9DOHQFLj HQ PDWqULD GH SDWULPRQL DUTXLWHFWzQLF L PHGLDPELHQWDOLV¶REULSHUtRGHG¶LQIRUPDFLyS~EOLFD 5HVROXFLyQ GH GH DEULO GH OD 'LUHFFLyQ *HQHUDO GH 3DWULPRQLR &XOWXUDO 9DOHQFLDQR \ 0XVHRV GH OD &RQVHOOHULD GH &XOWXUD (GXFDFLyQ \ 'HSRUWH SRU OD TXH VH LQFRD H[SHGLHQWH SDUD OD SULPHUD IDVH GH OD DFWXDOL]DFLyQ \ DGDSWDFLyQ SDUFLDO GH OD 6HFFLyQ 3ULPHUD GHO ,QYHQWDULR *HQHUDO GHO 3DWULPRQLR &XOWXUDO 9DOHQFLDQR HQ PDWHULD GH SDWULPRQLRDUTXLWHFWyQLFR\PHGLRDPELHQWDO\VHDEUHSHULRGRGHLQIRUPDFLyQSXEOLFD Núm. 5.503 / 02.05.2007 17935 %e'¶,17(5e6&8/785$/±(6*/e6,$3$55248,$/'(/6$/9$'25087;$0(/02180(17 %,(1'(,17(5e6&8/785$/,*/(6,$3$55248,$/'((/6$/9$'25087;$0(/02180(172 $11(;,9$1(;2,9 GH 5HVROXFLyGHG DEULOGHOD'LUHFFLy*HQHUDOGH3DWULPRQL&XOWXUDO9DOHQFLjL0XVHXVGHOD&RQVHOOHULDGH&XOWXUD(GXFDFLyL(VSRUWSHUODTXHV LQFRDH[SHGLHQWSHUDOD SULPHUD IDVH GH O DFWXDOLW]DFLy L DGDSWDFLy SDUFLDO GH OD 6HFFLy 3ULPHUD GH O ,QYHQWDUL *HQHUDO GHO 3DWULPRQL &XOWXUDO 9DOHQFLj HQ PDWqULD GH SDWULPRQL DUTXLWHFWzQLF L PHGLDPELHQWDOLV¶REULSHUtRGHG¶LQIRUPDFLyS~EOLFD 5HVROXFLyQ GH GH DEULO GH OD 'LUHFFLyQ *HQHUDO GH 3DWULPRQLR &XOWXUDO 9DOHQFLDQR \ 0XVHRV GH OD &RQVHOOHULD GH &XOWXUD (GXFDFLyQ \ 'HSRUWH SRU OD TXH VH LQFRD H[SHGLHQWH SDUD OD SULPHUD IDVH GH OD DFWXDOL]DFLyQ \ DGDSWDFLyQ SDUFLDO GH OD 6HFFLyQ 3ULPHUD GHO ,QYHQWDULR *HQHUDO GHO 3DWULPRQLR &XOWXUDO 9DOHQFLDQR HQ PDWHULD GH SDWULPRQLRDUTXLWHFWyQLFR\PHGLRDPELHQWDO\VHDEUHSHULRGRGHLQIRUPDFLyQSXEOLFD Núm. 5.503 / 02.05.2007 17936 %e'¶,17(5e6&8/785$/±-$5'Ë,3$/$8'(3(f$&(55$'$087;$0(/-$5'Ë+,67Ñ5,& %,(1'(,17(5e6&8/785$/±-$5'Ë1<3$/$&,2'(3(f$&(55$'$087;$0(/-$5'Ë1+,67Ñ5,&2 'HQRPLQDFLy'HQRPLQDFLyQ 3ULQFLSDO3ULQFLSDO -DUGtL3DODXGH3HxDFHUUDGD -DUGtQ\3DODFLRGH3HxDFHUUDGD /RFDOL]DFLy/RFDOL]DFLyQ 3URYtQFLD3URYLQFLD$ODFDQW &RPDUFD&RPDUFD/¶$ODFDQWt 0XQLFLSL0XQLFLSLR0XW[DPHO 8ELFDFLy8ELFDFLyQ3OD]DGHO3REOH1RX 5HIHUqQFLD&DGDVWUDO5HIHUHQFLD&DWDVWUDO ,OOD0DQ]DQD 3DUFHOāOD3DUFHOD\ 3ROtJRQ3ROtJRQR $QWHFHGHQWV-XUtGLFV$QWHFHGHQWHV-XUtGLFRV ,QFRDFLy,QFRDFLyQ 3XEOLFDFLyGHODLQFRDFLy3XEOLFDFLyQGHODLQFRDFLyQ%2( 'HVFULSFLy'HVFULSFLyQ 3DUWV,QWHJUDQWV3DUWHV,QWHJUDQWHV − 3DODXDPEHVFDODH[WHULRU3DODFLRFRQHVFDOHUDH[WHULRU − -DUGtLKRUW-DUGtQ\KXHUWR − 6DIDUHLJ$OEHUFD − )RQWV)XHQWHV − 6HQGDDPEHVWjWXHV6HQGHURFRQHVWDWXDV − 3ODoD3OD]D 'HVFULSFLy*HQHUDO'HVFULSFLyQ*HQHUDO 3HxDFHUUDGDpVXQOORFDVVRFLDWDOFDVFXUEjGH0XW[DPHOLHVWjFRQVWLWXwWSHUXQQXFOLXUEjXQSDODXLMDUGt DUWLFXODWVPLWMDQoDQWXQDSODoDTXDGUDGD(QDOJXQPRPHQW3HxDFHUUDGDYDFRQVWLWXLUXQDHQWLWDWPXQLFLSDO SUzSLD TXHGj DVVLPLODGD SHU 0XW[DPHO HQ OHV UHIRUPHV DGPLQLVWUDWLYHV GHO VHJOH ;,; (QFDUD TXH QR HV FRQVHUYD GRFXPHQWDFLy O RULJHQ GH OD FDVD SRW VLWXDUVH DO FRPHQoDPHQW GH O qSRFD PRGHUQD (O VHX DVSHFWHDFWXDOGDWDGHUHIRUPHVLDPSOLDFLRQVHIHFWXDGHVDILQDOVGHOVHWFHQWV/DYLYHQGDDGTXLUL[FDUjFWHU SDODWt 6 LQWURGXw[HQ QRXV DVSHFWHV XUEDQV HQ OD UHDOLW]DFLy G XQD SODoD TXDGUDGD DPE HOV FDUUHUV G DFFpV VLWXDWVHQOHVPHGLDWULXVGHWUHVGHOVFRVWDWVHQHOTXDUWFDQWyVHVLWXDHOSDODXTXHGHVSUpVGHODUHIRUPDL DPSOLDFLy V DGHTXD D OHV QRYHV FRUUHQWV DUTXLWHFWzQLTXHV GHO EDUURF WDUGj /D ILOHUD G KDELWDFLRQV DPE OD VHXDGLVSRVLFLyFRQVHFXWLYDVXSRVDODUHQRYDFLyPpVVLJQLILFDWLYD$DL[zFDODIHJLUHOFDQYLGHUHODFLyVRFLDO OD FDVD GHL[D GH VHU H[FOXVLYDPHQW XQD SHoD GHVWLQDGD D GRQDU FDEXGD D OHV FROOLWHV GHO FDPS L HV WUDQVIRUPD HQ XQ HOHPHQW SHU DO JDXGL L FRPRGLWDW GHOV SURSLHWDULV &RP D UHVXOWDW OHV SHFHV HV GLPHQVLRQHQHQIXQFLyGHOHVQHFHVVLWDWVGHUHODFLyIDPLOLDURFLRDFWLYLWDWVVRFLDOVODGHFRUDFLyDFRQVHJXL[ XQ JUDX HORTHQW GH UHILQDPHQW /D SODQWD GHO SDODX HV GHVHQYROXSD HQ IRUPD G¶/ 7DQW OD IDoDQD SULQFLSDO TXH UHFDX HQ OD SODoD TXDGUDGD FRP OD IDoDQD QREOH TXH GyQD DO MDUGt V RUGHQHQ SHU PLWMj GH EXLWVVLPqWULFVDPEGXHVIDoDQHVVyQSODQHV/DPDMRUQRYHWDWLTXHFRQVWLWXHL[HOWUHWPpVFDUDFWHUtVWLFGHO SUHVHQWEpHVWjGHWHUPLQDGDSHOMDUGtUHVXOWDWGHOHVLPSRUWDQWVUHIRUPHVGXWHVDWHUPHDOFRPHQoDPHQW GHOVHJOH;,;HQHOO HVGLVWLQJL[HQOHVWUHVWLSRORJLHVPpV GLIRVHV GHOV MDUGLQV HXURSHXV pV D GLU IUDQFpV DQJOpV L LWDOLj TXH TXHGHQ SHUIHFWDPHQW GLIHUHQFLDWV HQWUH VL (V WUREHQ HVSqFLHV DUEzULHV YDULDGHV HVWjWXHVEDOXVWUDGHVLIRQWV69DUHOD 3HxDFHUUDGD HV XQ OXJDU DVRFLDGR DO FDVFR XUEDQR GH 0XW[DPHO \ FRQVWLWXLGR SRU XQ Q~FOHR XUEDQR XQ SDODFLR \ MDUGtQ DUWLFXODGRV PHGLDQWH XQD SOD]D FXDGUDGD (Q DOJ~Q PRPHQWR 3HxDFHUUDGD FRQVWLWX\y HQWLGDGPXQLFLSDO SURSLDTXHGDQGRDVLPLODGD SRU0XW[DPHOHQODVUHIRUPDVDGPLQLVWUDWLYDV GHO VLJOR ;,; $XQTXHVHFDUHFHGHGRFXPHQWDFLyQHORULJHQGHODFDVDSXHGHVLWXDUVHDFRPLHQ]RVGHODpSRFDPRGHUQD 6X DVSHFWR DFWXDO GDWD GH UHIRUPDV \ DPSOLDFLRQHV HIHFWXDGDV D ILQDOHV GHO VHWHFLHQWRV /D YLYLHQGD DGTXLHUH FDUiFWHU SDODFLHJR 6H LQWURGXFHQ QXHYRV DVSHFWRV XUEDQRV HQ OD UHDOL]DFLyQ GH XQD SOD]D FXDGUDGDFRQODVFDOOHVGHDFFHVRVLWXDGDVHQODVPHGLDWULFHVGHWUHVGHORVODGRV(QHOFXDUWRVHVLW~DHO $11(;,9$1(;2,9 GH 5HVROXFLyGHG DEULOGHOD'LUHFFLy*HQHUDOGH3DWULPRQL&XOWXUDO9DOHQFLjL0XVHXVGHOD&RQVHOOHULDGH&XOWXUD(GXFDFLyL(VSRUWSHUODTXHV LQFRDH[SHGLHQWSHUDOD SULPHUD IDVH GH O DFWXDOLW]DFLy L DGDSWDFLy SDUFLDO GH OD 6HFFLy 3ULPHUD GH O ,QYHQWDUL *HQHUDO GHO 3DWULPRQL &XOWXUDO 9DOHQFLj HQ PDWqULD GH SDWULPRQL DUTXLWHFWzQLF L PHGLDPELHQWDOLV¶REULSHUtRGHG¶LQIRUPDFLyS~EOLFD 5HVROXFLyQ GH GH DEULO GH OD 'LUHFFLyQ *HQHUDO GH 3DWULPRQLR &XOWXUDO 9DOHQFLDQR \ 0XVHRV GH OD &RQVHOOHULD GH &XOWXUD (GXFDFLyQ \ 'HSRUWH SRU OD TXH VH LQFRD H[SHGLHQWH SDUD OD SULPHUD IDVH GH OD DFWXDOL]DFLyQ \ DGDSWDFLyQ SDUFLDO GH OD 6HFFLyQ 3ULPHUD GHO ,QYHQWDULR *HQHUDO GHO 3DWULPRQLR &XOWXUDO 9DOHQFLDQR HQ PDWHULD GH SDWULPRQLRDUTXLWHFWyQLFR\PHGLRDPELHQWDO\VHDEUHSHULRGRGHLQIRUPDFLyQSXEOLFD Núm. 5.503 / 02.05.2007 17937 SDODFLR TXH WUDV OD UHIRUPD \ DPSOLDFLyQ VH DGHFXD D ODV QXHYDV FRUULHQWHV DUTXLWHFWyQLFDV GHO EDUURFR WDUGtR /D HQILODGD GH KDELWDFLRQHV GLVSXHVWDV HQ VXFHVLyQ VXSRQH OD UHQRYDFLyQ PiV VLJQLILFDWLYD $ HOOR KD\TXHDxDGLUHOFDPELRGHUHODFLyQVRFLDOODFDVDGHMDGHVHUH[FOXVLYDPHQWHXQDSLH]DGHVWLQDGDDGDU FDELGD D ODV FRVHFKDV GHO FDPSR \ VH WUDQVIRUPD HQ XQ HOHPHQWR SDUD HO GLVIUXWH \ FRPRGLGDG GH ORV SURSLHWDULRVXVXDULRV&RPRUHVXOWDGRODVSLH]DVVHGLPHQVLRQDQHQIXQFLyQGHODVQHFHVLGDGHVGHUHODFLyQ IDPLOLDURFLRRDFWLYLGDGHVVRFLDOHVODGHFRUDFLyQDOFDQ]DXQJUDGRHORFXHQWHGHUHILQDPLHQWR/DSODQWDGHO SDODFLR VH GHVDUUROOD HQ / 7DQWR OD IDFKDGD SULQFLSDO TXH UHFDH HQ OD SOD]D FXDGUDGD FRPR OD IDFKDGD QREOH TXH GD DO MDUGtQ VH RUGHQDQ PHGLDQWH KXHFRV VLPpWULFRV VLHQGR ODV IDFKDGDV SODQDV /D PD\RU QRYHGDGVLQJXODUPHQWHFDUDFWHUL]DGRUDGHOSUHVHQWHELHQYLHQHGHWHUPLQDGDSRUHOMDUGtQUHVXOWDGRGHODV LPSRUWDQWHVUHIRUPDVOOHYDGDVDFDERDFRPLHQ]RVGHOVLJOR;,;(QpOVHGLVWLQJXHQODVWUHVWLSRORJtDVPiV GLIXQGLGDVGHORVMDUGLQHVHXURSHRV&DGDXQRGHORVWLSRVIUDQFpVLQJOpVLWDOLDQRTXHGDQSHUIHFWDPHQWH GLIHUHQFLDGRV HQWUH Vt 6H HQFXHQWUDQ HVSHFLHV DUEyUHDV YDULDGDV HVWDWXDV EDODXVWUDGDV \ IXHQWHV 69DUHOD 2EVHUYDFLRQV2EVHUYDFLRQHV (QWRUQ(QWRUQ $QWHFHGHQWVDGPLQLVWUDWLXVGHOLPLWDFLyH[WUHWDGHO H[SHGLHQWGHILQLGDDPEFDUjFWHUSURYLVLRQDO 2ULJHQLQWHUVHFFLyGHOVHL[RVGHOVFDUUHUVGH9LOOHQDLGH%HQHL[DPDSXQW$ 6HQWLWDQWLKRUDUL /tQLDGHOLPLWDGRUDODOtQLDVHJXL[SHUO HL[GHOFDUUHU9LOOHQDLQWURGXLQWVH HQ O LOODFDGDVWUDO HQWUH OHV SDUFHOāOHV L FRQWLQXD SHO OtPLW HVW GH OHV SDUFHOāOHV L ILQV DO FDPt H[LVWHQW 9RUHMD HO FDPt HQ GLUHFFLyQRUGLFRQWLQXDSHOVOtPLWVHVWGHOHVSDUFHOāOHVLLVHJXL[DQRUGLQFORHQWHOFDPtLODSDUFHOāOD FUHXDODILQVDLQFORXUHODTXHYRUHMDILQVDOFDPtGH3HxDJRORVDLQFRUSRUDQWKRILQVDOFDUUHU %HQHL[DPDLSHUO HL[G HVWHFDUUHUILQVDOSXQWG RULJHQ $QWHFHGHQWHVDGPLQLVWUDWLYRVGHOLPLWDFLyQH[WUDtGDGHOH[SHGLHQWHGHILQLGDFRQFDUiFWHUSURYLVLRQDO 2ULJHQLQWHUVHFFLyQGHORVHMHVGHODVFDOOHV9LOOHQD\%HQHMDPDSXQWR$ 6HQWLGRDQWLKRUDULR /tQHD GHOLPLWDGRUD /tQHD GHOLPLWDGRUD OD OtQHD VLJXH SRU HO HMH GH OD FDOOH 9LOOHQD LQWURGXFLpQGRVH HQ OD PDQ]DQD HQWUH ODV SDUFHODV \ FRQWLQ~D SRU HO OLQGH HVWH GH ODV SDUFHODV \ KDVWD HO FDPLQRH[LVWHQWH%RUGHDHOFDPLQRHQGLUHFFLyQQRUWH\FRQWLQ~DSRUORVOLQGHVHVWHGHODVSDUFHODV\ \VLJXHDQRUWHLQFOX\HQGRHOFDPLQR\ODSDUFHODFUX]DODKDVWDLQFOXLUODTXHERUGHDKDVWDHO FDPLQRGH3HxDJRORVDLQFRUSRUiQGRORKDVWDODFDOOH%HQHMDPD\SRUHOHMHGHHVWDFDOOHKDVWDHOSXQWRGH RULJHQ $11(;,9$1(;2,9 GH 5HVROXFLyGHG DEULOGHOD'LUHFFLy*HQHUDOGH3DWULPRQL&XOWXUDO9DOHQFLjL0XVHXVGHOD&RQVHOOHULDGH&XOWXUD(GXFDFLyL(VSRUWSHUODTXHV LQFRDH[SHGLHQWSHUDOD SULPHUD IDVH GH O DFWXDOLW]DFLy L DGDSWDFLy SDUFLDO GH OD 6HFFLy 3ULPHUD GH O ,QYHQWDUL *HQHUDO GHO 3DWULPRQL &XOWXUDO 9DOHQFLj HQ PDWqULD GH SDWULPRQL DUTXLWHFWzQLF L PHGLDPELHQWDOLV¶REULSHUtRGHG¶LQIRUPDFLyS~EOLFD 5HVROXFLyQ GH GH DEULO GH OD 'LUHFFLyQ *HQHUDO GH 3DWULPRQLR &XOWXUDO 9DOHQFLDQR \ 0XVHRV GH OD &RQVHOOHULD GH &XOWXUD (GXFDFLyQ \ 'HSRUWH SRU OD TXH VH LQFRD H[SHGLHQWH SDUD OD SULPHUD IDVH GH OD DFWXDOL]DFLyQ \ DGDSWDFLyQ SDUFLDO GH OD 6HFFLyQ 3ULPHUD GHO ,QYHQWDULR *HQHUDO GHO 3DWULPRQLR &XOWXUDO 9DOHQFLDQR HQ PDWHULD GH SDWULPRQLRDUTXLWHFWyQLFR\PHGLRDPELHQWDO\VHDEUHSHULRGRGHLQIRUPDFLyQSXEOLFD Núm. 5.503 / 02.05.2007 17938 %e'¶,17(5e6&8/785$/±-$5'Ë,3$/$8'(3(f$&(55$'$087;$0(/-$5'Ë+,67Ñ5,& %,(1'(,17(5e6&8/785$/±-$5'Ë1<3$/$&,2'(3(f$&(55$'$087;$0(/-$5'Ë1+,67Ñ5,&2 $11(;,9$1(;2,9 GH 5HVROXFLyGHG DEULOGHOD'LUHFFLy*HQHUDOGH3DWULPRQL&XOWXUDO9DOHQFLjL0XVHXVGHOD&RQVHOOHULDGH&XOWXUD(GXFDFLyL(VSRUWSHUODTXHV LQFRDH[SHGLHQWSHUDOD SULPHUD IDVH GH O DFWXDOLW]DFLy L DGDSWDFLy SDUFLDO GH OD 6HFFLy 3ULPHUD GH O ,QYHQWDUL *HQHUDO GHO 3DWULPRQL &XOWXUDO 9DOHQFLj HQ PDWqULD GH SDWULPRQL DUTXLWHFWzQLF L PHGLDPELHQWDOLV¶REULSHUtRGHG¶LQIRUPDFLyS~EOLFD 5HVROXFLyQ GH GH DEULO GH OD 'LUHFFLyQ *HQHUDO GH 3DWULPRQLR &XOWXUDO 9DOHQFLDQR \ 0XVHRV GH OD &RQVHOOHULD GH &XOWXUD (GXFDFLyQ \ 'HSRUWH SRU OD TXH VH LQFRD H[SHGLHQWH SDUD OD SULPHUD IDVH GH OD DFWXDOL]DFLyQ \ DGDSWDFLyQ SDUFLDO GH OD 6HFFLyQ 3ULPHUD GHO ,QYHQWDULR *HQHUDO GHO 3DWULPRQLR &XOWXUDO 9DOHQFLDQR HQ PDWHULD GH SDWULPRQLRDUTXLWHFWyQLFR\PHGLRDPELHQWDO\VHDEUHSHULRGRGHLQIRUPDFLyQSXEOLFD Núm. 5.503 / 02.05.2007 17939 %e'¶,17(5e6&8/785$/±7(03/(,3/$&(7$'(/6&$50(/,7(6'(6&$/d2618/(602180(17 %,(1'(,17(5e6&8/785$/±7(03/2<3/$=2/(7$'(/26&$50(5/,7$6'(6&$/=2618/(6 02180(172 'HQRPLQDFLy'HQRPLQDFLyQ 3ULQFLSDO3ULQFLSDO 7HPSOHL3ODFHWDGHOV&DUPHOLWHV'HVFDOoRV 7HPSOR\3OD]ROHWDGHORV&DUPHOLWDV'HVFDO]RV $FFHVzULD$FFHVRULD (VJOpVLDGHOD6DJUDGD)DPtOLD ,JOHVLDGHOD6DJUDGD)DPLOLD /RFDOL]DFLy/RFDOL]DFLyQ 3URYtQFLD3URYLQFLD&DVWHOOy &RPDUFD&RPDUFD/D3ODQD%DL[D 0XQLFLSL0XQLFLSLR1XOHV 8ELFDFLy8ELFDFLyQ3ODoDGHOV&DUPHOLWHV'HVFDOoRV 5HIHUqQFLD&DGDVWUDO5HIHUHQFLD&DWDVWUDO ,OOD0DQ]DQD3DUFHOāOD3DUFHOD $QWHFHGHQWV-XUtGLFV$QWHFHGHQWHV-XUtGLFRV ,QFRDFLy,QFRDFLyQ 3XEOLFDFLyGHODLQFRDFLy3XEOLFDFLyQGHODLQFRDFLyQ%2( 'HVFULSFLy'HVFULSFLyQ 3DUWV,QWHJUDQWV3DUWHV,QWHJUDQWHV − /DQDXSULQFLSDOLOHVFDSHOOHVODWHUDOV/DQDYHSULQFLSDO\ODVFDSLOODVODWHUDOHV − /DVDJULVWLDLHOVHVSDLVDQQH[RV/DVDFULVWtD\ORVHVSDFLRVDQH[RV − (OFRU(OFRUR − /DSODFHWD/DSOD]D − +DELWDWJHGHOUHFWRU9LYLHQGDGHOSiUURFR 'HVFULSFLy*HQHUDO'HVFULSFLyQ*HQHUDO (OFRQYHQWHVYDFRQVWUXLUVHJRQVOHVWUDFHVGHIUD-RVHSGHOD&RQFHSFLy/HVREUHVHVYDQLQLFLDUHQL V¶DOODUJDUHQILQVDO¶DQ\DQ\HQTXqHVYDUHDOLW]DUODIDoDQDGHO HVJOpVLD(QHOFRQYHQWYDVHU VDTXHMDWLDEDQGRQDW(QO HVJOpVLDpVUHVWDXUDGD8QVDQ\VPpVWDUGHQpVGHVWUXwWHOFRQYHQWL HVFRQVHUYD~QLFDPHQWO HVJOpVLD / HVJOpVLDpVXQWHPSOHGHSODQWDGHFUHXOODWLQDDPEXQDQDX DPEFDSHOOHV HQWUHFRQWUDIRUWVFRPXQLFDWV HQWUHHOOV7pXQDPSOLFUHXHUTXHGHVWDFDHQSODQWDHQODLQWHUVHFFLyGHOTXDODPEODQDXFHQWUDOV DOoDXQD F~SXOD/DVHSDUDFLyGHODQDXDPEOHVFDSHOOHVODWHUDOVHVUHDOLW]DSHUPLWMjGHSLODVWUHVLDUFVGHPLJSXQW /DQDXHVWjGLYLGLGDHQFLQFWUDPV$OVSHXVGHO HVJOpVLDVH VLWXD HOFRUDOW/DFREHUWDLQWHULRUHVIDDPE YROWDGHFDQyDPEOOXQHWHVHQODQDXLF~SXODDPESHW[LQHVHQOHVFDSHOOHVODWHUDOV/DFDSoDOHUDpVSODQDL HVWjPROWWUDQVIRUPDGD /D FDSHOOD GHO 6DJUDUL VLWXDGD D O HVTXHUUD Wp DFFpV SHU XQ DUF HVELDL[DW L HVWj FREHUWD DPE XQD F~SXOD HOāOtSWLFD / LQWHULRU Wp SRFD GHFRUDFLy MD TXH HQ OD UHVWDXUDFLy GHOV DQ\V OD GHFRUDFLy EDUURFD YD VHU VXEVWLWXwGDSHUXQDDOWUDFODVVLFLVWDPpVFRLQFLGHQWDPEODIDoDQDGHL[DQWPpVYLVLEOHVOHVOtQLHVHVWUXFWXUDOV 8QVzFROFHUjPLFGHOVHJOH;9,,,UHFRUUHODQDXHOFRULOHVFDSHOOHVODWHUDOV /D IDoDQD pV OD SDUW PpV LPSRUWDQW GHO FRQMXQW HV FRPSRQ G XQ UHFWDQJOH HPPDUFDW SHU GXHV SLODVWUHV L GLYLGLW HQ GXHV ]RQHV KRULW]RQWDOV HQ OD ]RQD LQIHULRU Wp XQ SzUWLF WULSDUWLW L HQ OD ]RQD VXSHULRU XQD IRUQtFXODHVFXWGHO RUGHLILQHVWUHVUHFWDQJXODUV5HPDWDODIDoDQDXQIURQWyUHFWDQJXODUDPEXQXOOGHERX FLUFXODUDOFHQWUH (QIURQW GH OD IDoDQD KL KD XQD SODFHWD DPE XQ PXU TXH OD WDQFD HQ OD TXH O $MXQWDPHQW HQ YD FROāORFDU HO EURFDO GHO SRX GHO FRQYHQW %DVDW HQ HO &DWjOHJ GH 0RQXPHQWV L &RQMXQWV GH OD &RPXQLWDW 9DOHQFLDQD (O FRQYHQWR VH FRQVWUX\y VHJ~Q ODV WUD]DV GH IUD\ -RVp GH OD &RQFHSFLyQ /DV REUDV VH LQLFLDURQ HQ DODUJiQGRVHKDVWDDxRHQTXHVHUHDOL]yODIDFKDGDGHODLJOHVLD(QHOFRQYHQWRIXHVDTXHDGR\ DEDQGRQDGR (1 OD LJOHVLD HV UHVWDXUDGD 8QRV DxRV PiV WDUGH HQ HV GHVWUXLGR HO FRQYHQWR FRQVHUYiQGRVH~QLFDPHQWHODLJOHVLD $11(;,9$1(;2,9 GH 5HVROXFLyGHG DEULOGHOD'LUHFFLy*HQHUDOGH3DWULPRQL&XOWXUDO9DOHQFLjL0XVHXVGHOD&RQVHOOHULDGH&XOWXUD(GXFDFLyL(VSRUWSHUODTXHV LQFRDH[SHGLHQWSHUDOD SULPHUD IDVH GH O DFWXDOLW]DFLy L DGDSWDFLy SDUFLDO GH OD 6HFFLy 3ULPHUD GH O ,QYHQWDUL *HQHUDO GHO 3DWULPRQL &XOWXUDO 9DOHQFLj HQ PDWqULD GH SDWULPRQL DUTXLWHFWzQLF L PHGLDPELHQWDOLV¶REULSHUtRGHG¶LQIRUPDFLyS~EOLFD 5HVROXFLyQ GH GH DEULO GH OD 'LUHFFLyQ *HQHUDO GH 3DWULPRQLR &XOWXUDO 9DOHQFLDQR \ 0XVHRV GH OD &RQVHOOHULD GH &XOWXUD (GXFDFLyQ \ 'HSRUWH SRU OD TXH VH LQFRD H[SHGLHQWH SDUD OD SULPHUD IDVH GH OD DFWXDOL]DFLyQ \ DGDSWDFLyQ SDUFLDO GH OD 6HFFLyQ 3ULPHUD GHO ,QYHQWDULR *HQHUDO GHO 3DWULPRQLR &XOWXUDO 9DOHQFLDQR HQ PDWHULD GH SDWULPRQLRDUTXLWHFWyQLFR\PHGLRDPELHQWDO\VHDEUHSHULRGRGHLQIRUPDFLyQSXEOLFD Núm. 5.503 / 02.05.2007 17940 /DLJOHVLDHVXQWHPSORGHSODQWDGHFUX]ODWLQDFRQXQDQDYHFRQFDSLOODVHQWUHFRQWUDIXHUWHVFRPXQLFDGRV HQWUHVt7LHQHXQDPSOLRFUXFHURTXHGHVWDFDHQSODQWDHQFX\DLQWHUVHFFLyQFRQODQDYHFHQWUDOVHOHYDQWD XQDF~SXOD/DVHSDUDFLyQGHODQDYHFRQODVFDSLOODVODWHUDOHVVHUHDOL]DPHGLDQWHSLODVWUDV\DUFRVGHPHGLR SXQWR/DQDYHHVWiGLYLGLGDHQFLQFRWUDPRV$ORVSLHVGHODLJOHVLDVHVLW~DHOFRURDOWR/DFXELHUWDLQWHULRU HVFRQEyYHGDGHFDxyQFRQOXQHWRVHQODQDYH\EyYHGDVYDtGDVHQODVFDSLOODVODWHUDOHV/DFDEHFHUDHV SODQD\HVWDPX\WUDQVIRUPDGD /DFDSLOODGHO6DJUDULRVLWXDGDDODL]TXLHUGDWLHQHDFFHVRSRUXQDUFRHQHVYLDMH\HVWDFXELHUWDFRQXQD F~SXOD HOtSWLFD (O LQWHULRU WLHQH SRFD GHFRUDFLyQ \D TXH HQ OD UHVWDXUDFLyQ GH ORV DxRV OD GHFRUDFLyQ EDUURFD IXH VXVWLWXtGD SRU RWUD FODVLFLVWD PiV DFRUGH FRQ OD IDFKDGD GHMDQGR PiV YLVLEOHV ODV OtQHDV HVWUXFWXUDOHV8Q]yFDORFHUiPLFRGHOVLJOR;9,,,UHFRUUHODQDYHHOFRUR\ODVFDSLOODVODWHUDOHV /DIDFKDGDHVORPiVLPSRUWDQWHGHOFRQMXQWR6HFRPSRQHGHXQ UHFWiQJXORHQPDUFDGRSRUGRVSLODVWUDV GLYLGLGRHQGRV]RQDVKRUL]RQWDOHVHQODLQIHULRUXQSyUWLFRWULSDUWLWR\HQODVXSHULRUXQDKRUQDFLQDHVFXGR GHODRUGHQ\YHQWDQDVUHFWDQJXODUHV5HPDWDODIDFKDGDFRQXQIURQWyQUHFWDQJXODUFRQXQyFXORFLUFXODU HQHOFHQWUR )UHQWHDODIDFKDGDKD\XQDSOD]ROHWDFRQXQPXURTXHODFLHUUDHQODTXHHO$\XQWDPLHQWRHQFRORFy HO EURFDO GHO SR]R GHO FRQYHQWR %DVDGR HQ HO &DWiORJR GH 0RQXPHQWRV \ &RQMXQWRV GH OD &RPXQLGDG 9DOHQFLDQD 2EVHUYDFLRQV2EVHUYDFLRQHV (QWRUQ(QWRUQ $QWHFHGHQWVDGPLQLVWUDWLXVGHOLPLWDFLyH[WUHWDGHO H[SHGLHQWGHILQLGDDPEFDUjFWHUSURYLVLRQDO 2ULJHQSXQW$VLWXDWHQODPLWJHUDGHOHVSDUFHOāOHVLGHO¶LOODGHFDVHVHQHOFDUUHU6DQW7HUHVD GH-HV~V 6HQWLWDQWLKRUDUL /tQLD GHOLPLWDGRUD OD OtQLD HV GLULJL[ DO VXGRHVW LQWURGXLQWVH HQ O¶LOOD GH FDVHV FDGDVWUDO SHU OD PLWJHUD QRUG GH OD SDUFHOāOD UHFRUUHQW OHV SRVWHULRUV GH OHV SDUFHOāOHV L &UHXD HO FDUUHU 0DMRU L SURVVHJXL[ SHU OD PLWJHUD VXG GH OD SDUFHOāOD GH O¶LOOD GH FDVHV FDGDVWUDO VHJXL[ SHU OHV SRVWHULRUV GH OHV SDUFHOāOHV WUDYHVVD HQ HVWD GLUHFFLy OD L VHJXL[ SHU OHV SRVWHULRUV GH OHV SDUFHOāOHV L (V GLULJL[ D VXG L HPEROLFD O¶LOOD GH FDVHV L FRQWLQXD SHU O HL[ GHO FDUUHU GH OD 6DJUDGD)DPtOLDLFRQWLQXDSHUODPLWJHUDQRUGGHODSDUFHOāODLOHVSRVWHULRUVGHOHVLGH O¶LOOD GH FDVHV 6HJXL[ SHU OD PLWJHUD QRUG GH OD SDUFHOāOD G HVWD LOOD GH FDVHV L FUHXD HO FDUUHU 0DMRU,QFRUSRUDOHVSDUFHOāOHV L GHO¶LOODGHFDVHVLUHFRUUHOHV SRVWHULRUV GHOHVSDUFHOāOHVGH O¶LOODGHFDVHVTXHGRQHQDOFDUUHU0DMRU&UHXDHOFDUUHUGH6DQWD7HUHVDILQVDOSXQWG RULJHQ $QWHFHGHQWHVDGPLQLVWUDWLYRVGHOLPLWDFLyQH[WUDtGDGHOH[SHGLHQWHGHILQLGDFRQFDUiFWHUSURYLVLRQDO 2ULJHQSXQWR$ VLWXDGRHQODPHGLDQHUD GHODVSDUFHODV\GHODPDQ]DQDHQODFDOOH 6DQWD 7HUHVDGH-HV~V 6HQWLGRDQWLKRUDULR /tQHD GHOLPLWDGRUD OD OtQHD VH GLULJH DO VXGRHVWH LQWURGXFLpQGRVH HQ OD PDQ]DQD FDWDVWUDO SRU OD PHGLDQHUD QRUWH GH OD SDUFHOD UHFRUULHQGR ODV WUDVHUDV GH ODV SDUFHODV \ &UX]D OD FDOOH 0D\RU \ SURVLJXH SRU OD PHGLDQHUD VXU GH OD SDUFHOD GH OD PDQ]DQD FDWDVWUDO VLJXH SRU ODV WUDVHUDVGHODVSDUFHODVDWUDYLHVDHQHVWDGLUHFFLyQOD\VLJXHSRUODVWUDVHUDVGHODVSDUFHODV \6HGLULJHDVXU\ HQYXHOYHODPDQ]DQD \FRQWLQ~D SRUHOHMH GHODFDOOH6DJUDGD)DPLOLD\ FRQWLQ~DSRUODPHGLDQHUDQRUWHGHODSDUFHOD\ODVWUDVHUDVGHODV \GH ODPDQ]DQD 6LJXHSRUODPHGLDQHUDQRUWHGHODSDUFHODGHHVWDPDQ]DQD\FUX]DODFDOOH0D\RU,QFRUSRUDODV SDUFHODV \ GH OD PDQ]DQD \ UHFRUUH ODV WUDVHUDV GH ODV SDUFHODV GH OD PDQ]DQD UHFD\HQWHVDODFDOOH0D\RU&UX]DODFDOOH6DQWD7HUHVDKDVWDHOSXQWRGHRULJHQ $11(;,9$1(;2,9 GH 5HVROXFLyGHG DEULOGHOD'LUHFFLy*HQHUDOGH3DWULPRQL&XOWXUDO9DOHQFLjL0XVHXVGHOD&RQVHOOHULDGH&XOWXUD(GXFDFLyL(VSRUWSHUODTXHV LQFRDH[SHGLHQWSHUDOD SULPHUD IDVH GH O DFWXDOLW]DFLy L DGDSWDFLy SDUFLDO GH OD 6HFFLy 3ULPHUD GH O ,QYHQWDUL *HQHUDO GHO 3DWULPRQL &XOWXUDO 9DOHQFLj HQ PDWqULD GH SDWULPRQL DUTXLWHFWzQLF L PHGLDPELHQWDOLV¶REULSHUtRGHG¶LQIRUPDFLyS~EOLFD 5HVROXFLyQ GH GH DEULO GH OD 'LUHFFLyQ *HQHUDO GH 3DWULPRQLR &XOWXUDO 9DOHQFLDQR \ 0XVHRV GH OD &RQVHOOHULD GH &XOWXUD (GXFDFLyQ \ 'HSRUWH SRU OD TXH VH LQFRD H[SHGLHQWH SDUD OD SULPHUD IDVH GH OD DFWXDOL]DFLyQ \ DGDSWDFLyQ SDUFLDO GH OD 6HFFLyQ 3ULPHUD GHO ,QYHQWDULR *HQHUDO GHO 3DWULPRQLR &XOWXUDO 9DOHQFLDQR HQ PDWHULD GH SDWULPRQLRDUTXLWHFWyQLFR\PHGLRDPELHQWDO\VHDEUHSHULRGRGHLQIRUPDFLyQSXEOLFD Núm. 5.503 / 02.05.2007 17941 %e'¶,17(5e6&8/785$/±7(03/(,3/$&(7$'(/6&$50(/,7(6'(6&$/d2618/(602180(17 %,(1'(,17(5e6&8/785$/±7(03/2<3/$=2/(7$'(/26&$50(5/,7$6'(6&$/=2618/(6 02180(172 $11(;,9$1(;2,9 GH 5HVROXFLyGHG DEULOGHOD'LUHFFLy*HQHUDOGH3DWULPRQL&XOWXUDO9DOHQFLjL0XVHXVGHOD&RQVHOOHULDGH&XOWXUD(GXFDFLyL(VSRUWSHUODTXHV LQFRDH[SHGLHQWSHUDOD SULPHUD IDVH GH O DFWXDOLW]DFLy L DGDSWDFLy SDUFLDO GH OD 6HFFLy 3ULPHUD GH O ,QYHQWDUL *HQHUDO GHO 3DWULPRQL &XOWXUDO 9DOHQFLj HQ PDWqULD GH SDWULPRQL DUTXLWHFWzQLF L PHGLDPELHQWDOLV¶REULSHUtRGHG¶LQIRUPDFLyS~EOLFD 5HVROXFLyQ GH GH DEULO GH OD 'LUHFFLyQ *HQHUDO GH 3DWULPRQLR &XOWXUDO 9DOHQFLDQR \ 0XVHRV GH OD &RQVHOOHULD GH &XOWXUD (GXFDFLyQ \ 'HSRUWH SRU OD TXH VH LQFRD H[SHGLHQWH SDUD OD SULPHUD IDVH GH OD DFWXDOL]DFLyQ \ DGDSWDFLyQ SDUFLDO GH OD 6HFFLyQ 3ULPHUD GHO ,QYHQWDULR *HQHUDO GHO 3DWULPRQLR &XOWXUDO 9DOHQFLDQR HQ PDWHULD GH SDWULPRQLRDUTXLWHFWyQLFR\PHGLRDPELHQWDO\VHDEUHSHULRGRGHLQIRUPDFLyQSXEOLFD Núm. 5.503 / 02.05.2007 17942 %e'¶,17(5e6&8/785$/±(6*/e6,$3$55248,$/'(/6$/9$'256$*81702180(17 %,(1'(,17(5e6&8/785$/±,*/(6,$3$55248,$/'(/6$/9$'256$*817202180(172 'HQRPLQDFLy'HQRPLQDFLyQ 3ULQFLSDO3ULQFLSDO (VJOpVLD3DUURTXLDOGHO6DOYDGRU ,JOHVLD3DUURTXLDOGHO6DOYDGRU /RFDOL]DFLy/RFDOL]DFLyQ 3URYtQFLD3URYLQFLD9DOqQFLD &RPDUFD&RPDUFD(O&DPSGH0RUYHGUH 0XQLFLSL0XQLFLSLR6DJXQW6DJXQWR 8ELFDFLy8ELFDFLyQ&9DOqQFLD 5HIHUqQFLD&DGDVWUDO5HIHUHQFLD&DWDVWUDO ,OOD0DQ]DQD3DUFHOāOD3DUFHOD $QWHFHGHQWV-XUtGLFV$QWHFHGHQWHV-XUtGLFRV ,QFRDFLy,QFRDFLyQ 3XEOLFDFLyGHODLQFRDFLy3XEOLFDFLyQGHODLQFRDFLyQ%2( 'HVFULSFLy'HVFULSFLyQ 3DUWV,QWHJUDQWV3DUWHV,QWHJUDQWHV − 1DXSULQFLSDO1DYHSULQFLSDO − $EVLVSROLJRQDOÈEVLGHSROLJRQDO − 6DJULVWLD6DFULVWtD − &DSHOOHV&DSLOODV − 7RUUH7RUUH 'HVFULSFLy*HQHUDO'HVFULSFLyQ*HQHUDO (VWUDFWDG XQDHVJOpVLDG XQDVRODQDXDPEXQDEVLVSROLJRQDOLFRQWUDIRUWVH[WHULRUVUHDOLW]DGDDILQDOVGHO VHJOH;,,,/DQDXHVWjGLYLGLGDHQWUHVWUDPVSHUPLWMjG DUFVGLDIUDJPDVREUHHOVTXDOVEDL[DODVRVWUDGDGH IXVWD VHJXHL[ OD WLSRORJLD GH OHV DQRPHQDGHV HVJOpVLHV GH UHFRQTXHVWD / DEVLV SUHVHQWD FLQF FRVWDWV L HVWj FREHUW DPE YROWD GH FUHXHULD DPE SOHPHQWHULD GH UDMROD FRQQHFWD DPE OD QDX SHU PLWMj G XQ DUF GH WULRPIRJLYDOUHEDL[DW(QHOFRVWDWGHO HStVWRODHVWUREHQHQHOSULPHUWUDPDOVSHXVO DFFpVDODWRUUHLOD FDSHOODEDSWLVPDO(QHVWHPDWHL[FRVWDWHQHOWUDPSUHYLDODFDSoDOHUDHVWUREDODFDSHOODGHOD&RPXQLy (V WUDFWD G XQ HVSDL DPE SODQWD GH FUHX JUHJD FREHUW DPE XQD YROWD GH PLWMD WDURQMD / DOoDW LQWHULRU HV UHDOLW]D SHU PLWMj GH SLODVWUHV G RUGUH FRPSRVW /D IDoDQD GH O HVJOpVLD SUHVHQWD XQD SRUWDGD G DUF GH PLJ SXQWDPEXQDPDUFDGDOtQLDG LPSRVWD(QODSDUWVXSHULRUV REULXQYDOOHXJHUDPHQWDSXQWDW$GRVVDGDDOD IDoDQDGHO HVJOpVLDHVWUREDODWRUUHFDPSDQDU'HSODQWDUHFWDQJXODUHVWjGLYLGLGDHQGRVFRVVRVSHUPLWMj G XQD OtQLD G LPSRVWD (O FRV VXSHULRU DOEHUJD OHV FDPSDQHV $ HOOD V DFFHGL[ GHV GH GLQV GH O HVJOpVLD $ O LQWHULRUSUHVHQWDXQDHVFDODGHFDUDJROGHSLOyFHQWUDOUHDOLW]DGDDPEFDUUHXV/ HVJOpVLDYDVHUUHVWDXUDGD HQWUHHOVDQ\VL(Q ODUHVWDXUDFLyHV YDSURFHGLUD O HOLPLQDFLyGHOHVFDVHV DQQH[HV SHOFRVWDW QRUGJHQHUDQWXQDSODoD/DVDJULVWLDYDVHUFRQVWUXwGDHQODQRYDSODoD$PEDozOHVIDoDQHVGHO HVJOpVLD YDQTXHGDUOOLXUHVG HGLILFDFLRQVLYDQVHUHPEODQTXLQDGHV(VYDQUHDOLW]DUH[FDYDFLRQVDUTXHROzJLTXHVHQ TXqYDQDSDUpL[HUXQDSHGUDVHSXOFUDOHOVIRQDPHQWVGHODSULPLWLYDHVJOpVLDWDXOHOOHWVLSHFHVFHUjPLTXHV G qSRFDURPDQD%DVDWHQHO&DWjOHJGH0RQXPHQWVL&RQMXQWVGHOD&RPXQLWDW9DOHQFLDQD 6H WUDWD GH XQD LJOHVLD GH XQD VROD QDYH FRQ XQ iEVLGH SROLJRQDO \ FRQWUDIXHUWHV H[WHULRUHV UHDOL]DGD D ILQDOHVGHOVLJOR;,,,/DQDYHHVWDGLYLGLGDHQWUHVWUDPRVPHGLDQWHDUFRVGLDIUDJPDVREUHORVTXHDSHDOD WHFKXPEUH GH PDGHUD VLJXLHQGR OD WLSRORJtD GH ODV OODPDGDV LJOHVLDV GH UHFRQTXLVWD (O iEVLGH SUHVHQWD FLQFR ODGRV \ HVWD FXELHUWR FRQ EyYHGD GH FUXFHUtD FRQ SOHPHQWHUtD GH ODGULOOR FRQHFWD FRQ OD QDYH PHGLDQWHXQDUFRGHWULXQIRRMLYDOUHEDMDGR(QHOODGRGHODHStVWRODVHHQFXHQWUDQHQHOSULPHUWUDPRDORV SLHV HO DFFHVR D OD WRUUH \ OD FDSLOOD EDXWLVPDO (Q HVWH PLVPR ODGR HQ HO WUDPR SUHYLR D OD FDEHFHUD VH HQFXHQWUD OD FDSLOOD GH OD &RPXQLyQ 6H WUDWD GH XQ HVSDFLR FRQ SODQWD GH FUX] JULHJD FXELHUWR FRQ XQD EyYHGDGHPHGLDQDUDQMD(ODO]DGRLQWHULRUVHUHDOL]DPHGLDQWHSLODVWUDVGHRUGHQFRPSXHVWR/DIDFKDGD GH OD LJOHVLD SUHVHQWD XQD SRUWDGD GH DUFR GH PHGLR SXQWR FRQ PDUFDGD OtQHD GH LPSRVWD (Q OD SDUWH VXSHULRU VH DEUH XQ YDQR OLJHUDPHQWH DSXQWDGR $GRVDGD D OD IDFKDGD GH OD LJOHVLD VH HQFXHQWUD OD WRUUH FDPSDQDULR'HSODQWDUHFWDQJXODUHVWiGLYLGLGDHQGRVFXHUSRV PHGLDQWHXQDOtQHDGH LPSRVWD(OFXHUSR $11(;,9$1(;2,9 GH 5HVROXFLyGHG DEULOGHOD'LUHFFLy*HQHUDOGH3DWULPRQL&XOWXUDO9DOHQFLjL0XVHXVGHOD&RQVHOOHULDGH&XOWXUD(GXFDFLyL(VSRUWSHUODTXHV LQFRDH[SHGLHQWSHUDOD SULPHUD IDVH GH O DFWXDOLW]DFLy L DGDSWDFLy SDUFLDO GH OD 6HFFLy 3ULPHUD GH O ,QYHQWDUL *HQHUDO GHO 3DWULPRQL &XOWXUDO 9DOHQFLj HQ PDWqULD GH SDWULPRQL DUTXLWHFWzQLF L PHGLDPELHQWDOLV¶REULSHUtRGHG¶LQIRUPDFLyS~EOLFD 5HVROXFLyQ GH GH DEULO GH OD 'LUHFFLyQ *HQHUDO GH 3DWULPRQLR &XOWXUDO 9DOHQFLDQR \ 0XVHRV GH OD &RQVHOOHULD GH &XOWXUD (GXFDFLyQ \ 'HSRUWH SRU OD TXH VH LQFRD H[SHGLHQWH SDUD OD SULPHUD IDVH GH OD DFWXDOL]DFLyQ \ DGDSWDFLyQ SDUFLDO GH OD 6HFFLyQ 3ULPHUD GHO ,QYHQWDULR *HQHUDO GHO 3DWULPRQLR &XOWXUDO 9DOHQFLDQR HQ PDWHULD GH SDWULPRQLRDUTXLWHFWyQLFR\PHGLRDPELHQWDO\VHDEUHSHULRGRGHLQIRUPDFLyQSXEOLFD Núm. 5.503 / 02.05.2007 17943 VXSHULRU DOEHUJD ODV FDPSDQDV $ HOOD VH DFFHGH GHVGH HO LQWHULRU GH OD LJOHVLD $O LQWHULRU SUHVHQWD XQD HVFDOHUD GH FDUDFRO GH SLOyQ FHQWUDO UHDOL]DGD HQ VLOOHUtD /D LJOHVLD IXH UHVWDXUDGD HQWUH ORV DxRV \ (QODUHVWDXUDFLyQVHSURFHGLyDODHOLPLQDFLyQGHODVFDVDVDQHMDVSRUHOODGRQRUWHJHQHUDQGRXQD SOD]D/DVDFULVWtDIXHFRQVWUXLGDHQODQXHYDSOD]D&RQHVWR ODVIDFKDGDVGHODLJOHVLDTXHGDURQOLEUHVGH HGLILFDFLRQHV \ IXHURQ HQFDODGDV 6H UHDOL]DURQ H[FDYDFLRQHV DUTXHROyJLFDV HQ ODV TXH DSDUHFLHURQ XQD SLHGUDVHSXOFUDOORVFLPLHQWRVGHODSULPLWLYDLJOHVLDD]XOHMRV\SLH]DVFHUiPLFDVGHpSRFDURPDQD%DVDGD HQHO&DWiORJRGH0RQXPHQWRV\&RQMXQWRVGHOD&RPXQLGDG9DOHQFLDQD 2EVHUYDFLRQV2EVHUYDFLRQHV (QWRUQ(QWRUQ $QWHFHGHQWVDGPLQLVWUDWLXVGHOLPLWDFLyH[WUHWDGHO H[SHGLHQWGHILQLGDDPEFDUjFWHUSURYLVLRQDO 2ULJHQ3XQW$LQWHUVHFFLyGHOHVPLWJHUHVQRUGGHOHVSDUFHOāOHVQ~PGHODLOODGHFDVHVLQ~P GHO¶LOODGHFDVHV 6HQWLWKRUDUL /tQLDGHOLPLWDGRUDGHVGHO RULJHQODOtQLDUHFRUUHODPLWJHUDQRUGGHODSDUFHOāODQ~PGHODLOODGHFDVHV LOHVSRVWHULRUV GHOVQ~PHURV GHODPDWHL[DLOOD GHFDVHV&RQWLQXDQW HOWUDoDW GHODOtQLD HQWUHOHVPLWJHUHVGHOHVSDUFHOāOHVLGHO¶LOODHQYROWDHVWDLOODLVHJXL[DVXGSHUO HL[GHO DYLQJXGD GHO 3DtV 9DOHQFLj 6 LQWURGXw[ HQ O¶LOOD HQWUH OHV SDUFHOāOHV L L FRQWLQXD SHU OHV SRVWHULRUV GH OHV SDUFHOāOHVLOHVPLWJHUHVVXGGHOHVL&UHXDHOFDUUHUGH9DOqQFLDLUHFRUUHOHVIDoDQHVGHOHV SDUFHOāOHVLGHO¶LOOD5HFRUUHOHVSRVWHULRUVGHOHVSDUFHOāOHV GHODPDWHL[DLOOD&UHXDHOFDUUHUGH'DURTXLLVHJXL[OHVSRVWHULRUVGHOHVSDUFHOāOHV LGHO¶LOODILQVDOSXQWG RULJHQ $QWHFHGHQWHVDGPLQLVWUDWLYRVGHOLPLWDFLyQH[WUDtGDGHOH[SHGLHQWHGHILQLGDFRQFDUiFWHUSURYLVLRQDO 2ULJHQ3XQWR$LQWHUVHFFLyQGHODVPHGLDQHUDVQRUWHGHODVSDUFHODVQGHODPDQ]DQD\Q GHODPDQ]DQD 6HQWLGRKRUDULR /tQHDGHOLPLWDGRUDGHVGHHORULJHQODOtQHDUHFRUUHODPHGLDQHUDQRUWHGHODSDUFHODQGHODPDQ]DQD \ODVWUDVHUDVGHORVQ~PHURV GHODPLVPDPDQ]DQD&RQWLQXDQGRHOWUD]DGRGHODOtQHD HQWUHODVPHGLDQHUDVGHODVSDUFHODV\GHODPDQ]DQDHQYXHOYHHVWDPDQ]DQD\VLJXHDVXUSRU HOHMHGHODDYHQLGD3DtV9DOHQFLj6HLQWURGXFHHQODPDQ]DQDHQWUHODVSDUFHODV\\FRQWLQ~DSRU ODVWUDVHUDVGHODVSDUFHODV\ODVPHGLDQHUDVVXUGHODV\&UX]DODFDOOH9DOHQFLD\UHFRUUH ODV IDFKDGDV GH ODV SDUFHODV \ GH OD PDQ]DQD 5HFRUUH ODV WUDVHUDV GH ODV SDUFHODV GH OD PLVPD PDQ]DQD &UX]D OD FDOOH 'DURTXL \ VLJXH ODV WUDVHUDVGHODVSDUFHODV\GHODPDQ]DQDKDVWDHOSXQWRGHRULJHQ $11(;,9$1(;2,9 GH 5HVROXFLyGHG DEULOGHOD'LUHFFLy*HQHUDOGH3DWULPRQL&XOWXUDO9DOHQFLjL0XVHXVGHOD&RQVHOOHULDGH&XOWXUD(GXFDFLyL(VSRUWSHUODTXHV LQFRDH[SHGLHQWSHUDOD SULPHUD IDVH GH O DFWXDOLW]DFLy L DGDSWDFLy SDUFLDO GH OD 6HFFLy 3ULPHUD GH O ,QYHQWDUL *HQHUDO GHO 3DWULPRQL &XOWXUDO 9DOHQFLj HQ PDWqULD GH SDWULPRQL DUTXLWHFWzQLF L PHGLDPELHQWDOLV¶REULSHUtRGHG¶LQIRUPDFLyS~EOLFD 5HVROXFLyQ GH GH DEULO GH OD 'LUHFFLyQ *HQHUDO GH 3DWULPRQLR &XOWXUDO 9DOHQFLDQR \ 0XVHRV GH OD &RQVHOOHULD GH &XOWXUD (GXFDFLyQ \ 'HSRUWH SRU OD TXH VH LQFRD H[SHGLHQWH SDUD OD SULPHUD IDVH GH OD DFWXDOL]DFLyQ \ DGDSWDFLyQ SDUFLDO GH OD 6HFFLyQ 3ULPHUD GHO ,QYHQWDULR *HQHUDO GHO 3DWULPRQLR &XOWXUDO 9DOHQFLDQR HQ PDWHULD GH SDWULPRQLRDUTXLWHFWyQLFR\PHGLRDPELHQWDO\VHDEUHSHULRGRGHLQIRUPDFLyQSXEOLFD Núm. 5.503 / 02.05.2007 17944 %e'¶,17(5e6&8/785$/±(6*/e6,$3$55248,$/'(/6$/9$'256$*81702180(17 %,(1'(,17(5e6&8/785$/±,*/(6,$3$55248,$/'(/6$/9$'256$*817202180(172 $11(;,9$1(;2,9 GH 5HVROXFLyGHG DEULOGHOD'LUHFFLy*HQHUDOGH3DWULPRQL&XOWXUDO9DOHQFLjL0XVHXVGHOD&RQVHOOHULDGH&XOWXUD(GXFDFLyL(VSRUWSHUODTXHV LQFRDH[SHGLHQWSHUDOD SULPHUD IDVH GH O DFWXDOLW]DFLy L DGDSWDFLy SDUFLDO GH OD 6HFFLy 3ULPHUD GH O ,QYHQWDUL *HQHUDO GHO 3DWULPRQL &XOWXUDO 9DOHQFLj HQ PDWqULD GH SDWULPRQL DUTXLWHFWzQLF L PHGLDPELHQWDOLV¶REULSHUtRGHG¶LQIRUPDFLyS~EOLFD 5HVROXFLyQ GH GH DEULO GH OD 'LUHFFLyQ *HQHUDO GH 3DWULPRQLR &XOWXUDO 9DOHQFLDQR \ 0XVHRV GH OD &RQVHOOHULD GH &XOWXUD (GXFDFLyQ \ 'HSRUWH SRU OD TXH VH LQFRD H[SHGLHQWH SDUD OD SULPHUD IDVH GH OD DFWXDOL]DFLyQ \ DGDSWDFLyQ SDUFLDO GH OD 6HFFLyQ 3ULPHUD GHO ,QYHQWDULR *HQHUDO GHO 3DWULPRQLR &XOWXUDO 9DOHQFLDQR HQ PDWHULD GH SDWULPRQLRDUTXLWHFWyQLFR\PHGLRDPELHQWDO\VHDEUHSHULRGRGHLQIRUPDFLyQSXEOLFD Núm. 5.503 / 02.05.2007 17945 %e'¶,17(5e6&8/785$/±&$/9$5,,35,0,7,9$(6*/e6,$7255(%/$1&$02180(17 %,(1'(,17(5e6&8/785$/±&$/9$5,2<35,0,7,9$,*/(6,$7255(%/$1&$02180(172 'HQRPLQDFLy'HQRPLQDFLyQ 3ULQFLSDO3ULQFLSDO &DOYDULLSULPLWLYD(VJOpVLD &DOYDULR\SULPLWLYD,JOHVLD $FFHVzULD$FFHVRULD &DOYDULL(VJOpVLDGH6DQW)UDQFHVF &DOYDULRH,JOHVLDGH6DQW)UDQFHVF /RFDOL]DFLy/RFDOL]DFLyQ 3URYtQFLD3URYLQFLD&DVWHOOy &RPDUFD&RPDUFD/D3ODQD%DL[D 0XQLFLSL0XQLFLSLR7RUUHEODQFD 8ELFDFLy8ELFDFLyQ$ORHVWHGHO&DVFR8UEDQR 5HIHUqQFLD&DGDVWUDO5HIHUHQFLD&DWDVWUDO ,OOD0DQ]DQD3DUFHOāOD3DUFHOD $QWHFHGHQWV-XUtGLFV$QWHFHGHQWHV-XUtGLFRV ,QFRDFLy,QFRDFLyQ 3XEOLFDFLyGHODLQFRDFLy3XEOLFDFLyQGHODLQFRDFLyQ%2( 'HVFULSFLy'HVFULSFLyQ 3DUWV,QWHJUDQWV3DUWHV,QWHJUDQWHV − &DOYDUL&DOYDULR − (VJOpVLDGH6DQW)UDQFHVF,JOHVLDGH6DQ)UDQFLVFR − &DSHOODGHO6DQWtVVLP&ULVWGHO&DOYDUL&DSLOODGHO6DQWtVLPR&ULVWRGHO&DOYDULR − (VWDFLRQVGHO&DOYDUL(VWDFLRQHVGHO&DOYDULR − 0XUDGDLWDQFDPHQW0XUDOOD\FHUUDPLHQWR 'HVFULSFLy*HQHUDO'HVFULSFLyQ*HQHUDO 8ELFDWDO RHVWGHODSREODFLyHVWUREDHVWH&DOYDULTXHLQFORXHQHOVHXUHFLQWHODSULPLWLYDHVJOpVLDGH6DQW )UDQFHVFGHOLPLWDGDSDUFLDOPHQWSHUXQWUDPGHPXUDOODOD&DSLOODGHO6DQWtVVLP&ULVWGHO&DOYDULDL[tFRP HO FDPt HQ ]LJD]DJD TXH DVFHQGL[ ILQV D DTXHOOD $O OODUJ GHO FDOYDUL HV GHVHQYROXSHQ OHV HVWDFLRQV /D FDSHOODpVGHSODQWDTXDGUDQJXODUDPEIjEULFDGHPDoRQHULDLUHIRUoRVGHFDUUHXVHQHOVDQJOHV/DIDoDQD pV UHFWDQJXODU DPE XQD SRUWDGD DOOLQGDGD UHDOLW]DGD HQ SHGUD HQ OD SDUW VXSHULRU KL KD XQD ILQHVWUD TXDGUDGDLHQODUHPDWDGDXQDHVSDGDQ\DDIHJLGD7pXQDF~SXODFHJDTXHDO H[WHULRUHVFREUL[DPEWHXOD EODYD/DLPDWJHGHO&ULVWHVWjUHDOLW]DGDSHU&DUPHOR9LFHQW MDTXHODLPDWJHRULJLQDOYDVHUGHVWUXwGDHQ $OUHFLQWHHVWUREDO (VJOpVLDGH6DQW)UDQFHVFFRQVWUXwGDHQHOVHJOH;,9IRUPDYDSDUWGHOUHFLQWHIRUWLILFDW (V WUDFWD G XQD HVJOpVLD GH SODQWD UHFWDQJXODU DPE XQD VROD QDX GLYLGLGD HQ TXDWUH WUDPV FREHUWD DPE YROWHVGHFUHXHULDDPEWHUFHOHWV3UHVHQWDXQDLOāOXPLQDFLyHVFDVVDDPEXQDWURQHUDHQHOSUHVELWHULLXQD HVSLWOOHUDDOVSHXVGHO HUPLWDVREUHODSRUWDDFWXDOUHDOLW]DGDHQ/DSRUWDG DFFpVpVDOOLQGDGDVHQVH JHQV GH GHFRUDFLy UHOOHYDQW 7p WUHV PXUV UHDOLW]DWV HQ PDoRQHULD TXH VHPEOHQ DIHJLWV SHU WDO GH IHU GH FRQWUDIRUWV HQ IDOODU HOV H[LVWHQWV SHU OD FROāORFDFLy GH OHV YROWHV TXH VXEVWLWXLUHQ O¶DQWLJD VRVWUDGD SUREDEOHPHQWGHIXVWD3UHVHQWDQRPEURVHVHVSLWOOHUHVLXQDEDUEDFDQDODWHUDOVREUHO DQWLJDSRUWDG DFFpV OD TXDO FRVD OL GyQD HO FDUjFWHU IRUWLILFDW %DVDW HQ HO &DWjOHJ GH 0RQXPHQWV L &RQMXQWV GH OD &RPXQLWDW 9DOHQFLDQD 8ELFDGRDORHVWHGHODSREODFLyQVHHQFXHQWUDHVWHFDOYDULRTXHLQFOX\HHQVXUHFLQWRODSULPLWLYDLJOHVLDGH 6DQ)UDQFLVFRGHOLPLWDGDSDUFLDOPHQWHSRUXQWUDPRGHPXUDOODOD&DSLOODGHO6DQWtVLPR&ULVWRGHO&DOYDULR DVt FRPR HO FDPLQR HQ ]LJ]DJ TXH DVFLHQGH KDVWD OD PLVPD $ OR ODUJR GHO FDOYDULR GH GHVDUUROODQ ODV HVWDFLRQHV/DFDSLOODHVGH SODQWDFXDGUDQJXODUFRQIiEULFDGHPDPSRVWHUtD\UHIXHU]RVGHVLOOHUtDHQORV iQJXORV/DIDFKDGDHVUHFWDQJXODUFRQXQDSRUWDGDDGLQWHODGDUHDOL]DGDHQSLHGUDHQODSDUWHVXSHULRUKD\ XQDYHQWDQDFXDGUDGD\HQHOUHPDWHXQDHVSDGDxDDxDGLGD7LHQHXQDF~SXODFLHJDTXHDOH[WHULRUFXEUH FRQ WHMD D]XO /D LPDJHQ GHO &ULVWR HVWD UHDOL]DGD SRU &DUPHOR 9LFHQW \D TXH OD RULJLQDO IXH GHVWUXLGD HQ (QHOUHFLQWRVHHQFXHQWUDOD,JOHVLDGH6DQ)UDQFLVFRFRQVWUXLGDHQHOVLJOR;,9IRUPDEDSDUWHGHOUHFLQWR IRUWLILFDGR 6H WUDWD GH XQD LJOHVLD GH SODQWD UHFWDQJXODU FRQ XQD VROD QDYH GLYLGLGD HQ FXDWUR WUDPRV $11(;,9$1(;2,9 GH 5HVROXFLyGHG DEULOGHOD'LUHFFLy*HQHUDOGH3DWULPRQL&XOWXUDO9DOHQFLjL0XVHXVGHOD&RQVHOOHULDGH&XOWXUD(GXFDFLyL(VSRUWSHUODTXHV LQFRDH[SHGLHQWSHUDOD SULPHUD IDVH GH O DFWXDOLW]DFLy L DGDSWDFLy SDUFLDO GH OD 6HFFLy 3ULPHUD GH O ,QYHQWDUL *HQHUDO GHO 3DWULPRQL &XOWXUDO 9DOHQFLj HQ PDWqULD GH SDWULPRQL DUTXLWHFWzQLF L PHGLDPELHQWDOLV¶REULSHUtRGHG¶LQIRUPDFLyS~EOLFD 5HVROXFLyQ GH GH DEULO GH OD 'LUHFFLyQ *HQHUDO GH 3DWULPRQLR &XOWXUDO 9DOHQFLDQR \ 0XVHRV GH OD &RQVHOOHULD GH &XOWXUD (GXFDFLyQ \ 'HSRUWH SRU OD TXH VH LQFRD H[SHGLHQWH SDUD OD SULPHUD IDVH GH OD DFWXDOL]DFLyQ \ DGDSWDFLyQ SDUFLDO GH OD 6HFFLyQ 3ULPHUD GHO ,QYHQWDULR *HQHUDO GHO 3DWULPRQLR &XOWXUDO 9DOHQFLDQR HQ PDWHULD GH SDWULPRQLRDUTXLWHFWyQLFR\PHGLRDPELHQWDO\VHDEUHSHULRGRGHLQIRUPDFLyQSXEOLFD Núm. 5.503 / 02.05.2007 17946 FXELHUWD FRQ EyYHGDV GH FUXFHUtD FRQ WHUFHOHWHV 3UHVHQWD XQD LOXPLQDFLyQ HVFDVD FRQ XQD WURQHUD HQ HO SUHVELWHULR \ XQD VDHWHUD D ORV SLHV GH OD HUPLWD VREUH OD SXHUWD DFWXDO UHDOL]DGD HQ /D SXHUWD GH DFFHVR HV DGLQWHODGD VLQ GHFRUDFLyQ UHOHYDQWH 7LHQH WUHV PXURV FRQWUDIXHUWHV VHJ~Q SDUHFH DxDGLGRV DO IDOODU ORV PXURV SRU OD FRORFDFLyQ GH ODV EyYHGDV TXH YLQLHURQ D VXVWLWXLU D XQD DQWLJXD WHFKXPEUH PX\ SUREDEOHPHQWH GH PDGHUD /RV PXURV HVWiQ UHDOL]DGRV HQ PDPSRVWHUtD 3UHVHQWD QXPHURVDV VDHWHUDV \ XQDEDUEDFDQDODWHUDOVREUHODDQWLJXDSXHUWDGHDFFHVRORTXHOHGDHOFDUiFWHUIRUWLILFDGR%DVDGRHQHO &DWiORJRGH0RQXPHQWRV\&RQMXQWRVGHOD&RPXQLGDG9DOHQFLDQD 2EVHUYDFLRQV2EVHUYDFLRQHV /¶(VJOpVLDHQUHODFLyDPEHOVHXVFRPSRQHQWVGHIHQVLXVJDXGHL[MDHQUDyGHODVHXDQDWXUDOHVDLFRQIRUPHD OD/OHLGHODFRQGLFLyGH%,&0RQXPHQW(QHOUHFLQWHKLKDFRQVWUXFFLRQVPRGHUQHVLQLFLDOPHQWYLQFXODGHVD DFWLYLWDWVUHOLJLRVHVIRUD G¶HVFDODLFRQWH[WO¶LPSDFWH GH OHV TXDOV V¶KD SURFXUDW PLQLPLW]DU L DFODULU PLWMDQoDQW XQD LQWHUYHQFLy G¶HQGHUURF SDUFLDO L UHDGHTXDFLy TXH VHJRQV SURMHFWH GH O¶DUTXLWHFWH )UDQFHVF 7DEHUQHU IRX H[HFXWDGDHQODSULPHUDPHLWDWGHOVDQ\VGHO6;; /D,JOHVLDHQUHODFLyQFRQVXVFRPSRQHQWHVGHIHQVLYRVGLVIUXWD\DHQUD]yQGHVXQDWXUDOH]D\GHDFXHUGRD OD /H\ GH OD FRQGLFLyQ GH %,& 0RQXPHQWR (Q HO UHFLQWR H[LVWHQ FRQVWUXFFLRQHV PRGHUQDV LQLFLDOPHQWH YLQFXODGDV D XVRV UHOLJLRVRV IXHUD GH HVFDOD \ FRQWH[WR FX\R LPSDFWR VH KD SURFXUDGR PLQLPL]DU L FODULILFDU PHGLDQWH XQD LQWHUYHQFLyQ GH GHUULER SDUFLDO \ UHDGHFXDFLyQ TXH VHJ~Q SUR\HFWR GHO DUTXLWHFWR )UDQFLVFR 7DEHUQHUIXHHMHFXWDGDHQODSULPHUDPLWDGGHORVDxRVGHO6;; (QWRUQ(QWRUQ $QWHFHGHQWVDGPLQLVWUDWLXVGHOLPLWDFLyH[WUHWDGHO H[SHGLHQWGHILQLGDDPEFDUjFWHUSURYLVLRQDO 2ULJHQLQWHUVHFFLyHQWUHO HL[GHOFDUUHUGH6DQW&ULVWzIRODPEODSURORQJDFLyGHODPLWJHUDQRUGGHOD SDUFHOāODGHO¶LOODGHFDVHV 6HQWLW$QWLKRUDUL /tQLD GHOLPLWDGRUD /D OtQLD UHFRUUH O HL[ GHO FDUUHU GH %RQDLUH L JLUD D QRUG HQWUH OD PLWJHUD HQWUH OHV SDUFHOāOHVLLHQWUHOHVLGHO¶LOODFDGDVWUDO6HJXL[DHVWHSHUO HL[GHOFDUUHUG¶$ODULWRUQDD JLUDUDQRUGSHUO HL[G HVWHFDUUHUILQVDO DYLQJXGDGH%DUFHORQD9RUHMDODGLWDDYLQJXGDILQVDJLUDUSHUOD SURORQJDFLyGHODIDoDQDQRUGGHO¶LOODYRUHMDODGLWDLOODLFRQWLQXDSHUODPLWJHUDHQWUHOHVSDUFHOāOHV LLL&UHXDHOFDUUHUGHO&DOYDULLHQYROWDODSDUFHOāODGHO¶LOODLOHVLGHOD $QWHFHGHQWHVDGPLQLVWUDWLYRVGHOLPLWDFLyQH[WUDtGDGHOH[SHGLHQWHGHILQLGDFRQFDUiFWHUSURYLVLRQDO 2ULJHQLQWHUVHFFLyQHQWUHHOHMHGHODFDOOH6DQ&ULVWyEDOFRQOD SURORQJDFLyQGHODPHGLDQHUDQRUWH GH OD SDUFHODGHODPDQ]DQD 6HQWLGR$QWLKRUDULR /tQHD GHOLPLWDGRUD /D OtQHD UHFRUUH HO HMH GH OD FDOOH %RQDLUH \ JLUD D QRUWH HQWUH OD PHGLDQHUD HQWUH ODV SDUFHODV\\HQWUHODV\GHODPDQ]DQDFDWDVWUDO6LJXHDHVWHSRUHOHMHGHODFDOOH$ODU\ YXHOYHDJLUDU DQRUWHSRU HO HMHGH HVWDFDOOH KDVWD OD DYHQLGD GH %DUFHORQD %RUGHD GLFKD DYHQLGD KDVWD JLUDUSRUODSURORQJDFLyQGHODIDFKDGDQRUWHGHODPDQ]DQDERUGHDGLFKDPDQ]DQD\FRQWLQ~DSRUOD PHGLDQHUD HQWUH ODV SDUFHODV \ \ \ &UX]D OD FDOOH &DOYDULR \ HQYXHOYH OD SDUFHOD GH OD PDQ]DQD\ODV\GHOD $11(;,9$1(;2,9 GH 5HVROXFLyGHG DEULOGHOD'LUHFFLy*HQHUDOGH3DWULPRQL&XOWXUDO9DOHQFLjL0XVHXVGHOD&RQVHOOHULDGH&XOWXUD(GXFDFLyL(VSRUWSHUODTXHV LQFRDH[SHGLHQWSHUDOD SULPHUD IDVH GH O DFWXDOLW]DFLy L DGDSWDFLy SDUFLDO GH OD 6HFFLy 3ULPHUD GH O ,QYHQWDUL *HQHUDO GHO 3DWULPRQL &XOWXUDO 9DOHQFLj HQ PDWqULD GH SDWULPRQL DUTXLWHFWzQLF L PHGLDPELHQWDOLV¶REULSHUtRGHG¶LQIRUPDFLyS~EOLFD 5HVROXFLyQ GH GH DEULO GH OD 'LUHFFLyQ *HQHUDO GH 3DWULPRQLR &XOWXUDO 9DOHQFLDQR \ 0XVHRV GH OD &RQVHOOHULD GH &XOWXUD (GXFDFLyQ \ 'HSRUWH SRU OD TXH VH LQFRD H[SHGLHQWH SDUD OD SULPHUD IDVH GH OD DFWXDOL]DFLyQ \ DGDSWDFLyQ SDUFLDO GH OD 6HFFLyQ 3ULPHUD GHO ,QYHQWDULR *HQHUDO GHO 3DWULPRQLR &XOWXUDO 9DOHQFLDQR HQ PDWHULD GH SDWULPRQLRDUTXLWHFWyQLFR\PHGLRDPELHQWDO\VHDEUHSHULRGRGHLQIRUPDFLyQSXEOLFD Núm. 5.503 / 02.05.2007 17947 %e'¶,17(5e6&8/785$/±&$/9$5,,35,0,7,9$(6*/e6,$7255(%/$1&$02180(17 %,(1'(,17(5e6&8/785$/±&$/9$5,2<35,0,7,9$,*/(6,$7255(%/$1&$02180(172 $11(;,9$1(;2,9 GH 5HVROXFLyGHG DEULOGHOD'LUHFFLy*HQHUDOGH3DWULPRQL&XOWXUDO9DOHQFLjL0XVHXVGHOD&RQVHOOHULDGH&XOWXUD(GXFDFLyL(VSRUWSHUODTXHV LQFRDH[SHGLHQWSHUDOD SULPHUD IDVH GH O DFWXDOLW]DFLy L DGDSWDFLy SDUFLDO GH OD 6HFFLy 3ULPHUD GH O ,QYHQWDUL *HQHUDO GHO 3DWULPRQL &XOWXUDO 9DOHQFLj HQ PDWqULD GH SDWULPRQL DUTXLWHFWzQLF L PHGLDPELHQWDOLV¶REULSHUtRGHG¶LQIRUPDFLyS~EOLFD 5HVROXFLyQ GH GH DEULO GH OD 'LUHFFLyQ *HQHUDO GH 3DWULPRQLR &XOWXUDO 9DOHQFLDQR \ 0XVHRV GH OD &RQVHOOHULD GH &XOWXUD (GXFDFLyQ \ 'HSRUWH SRU OD TXH VH LQFRD H[SHGLHQWH SDUD OD SULPHUD IDVH GH OD DFWXDOL]DFLyQ \ DGDSWDFLyQ SDUFLDO GH OD 6HFFLyQ 3ULPHUD GHO ,QYHQWDULR *HQHUDO GHO 3DWULPRQLR &XOWXUDO 9DOHQFLDQR HQ PDWHULD GH SDWULPRQLRDUTXLWHFWyQLFR\PHGLRDPELHQWDO\VHDEUHSHULRGRGHLQIRUPDFLyQSXEOLFD Núm. 5.503 / 02.05.2007 17948 %e'¶,17(5e6&8/785$/±$/48(5,$'(-8/,¬9$/Ê1&,$02180(17 %,(1'(,17(5e6&8/785$/±$/48(5Ë$'(-8/,¬9$/(1&,$02180(172 'HQRPLQDFLy'HQRPLQDFLyQ 3ULQFLSDO3ULQFLSDO $OTXHULDGH-XOLj $OTXHUtDGH-XOLj /RFDOL]DFLy/RFDOL]DFLyQ 3URYtQFLD3URYLQFLD9DOqQFLD &RPDUFD&RPDUFD9DOqQFLD 0XQLFLSL0XQLFLSLR9DOqQFLD 8ELFDFLy8ELFDFLyQ&&DVWDQ7REHxDV9HOi]TXH]\3DVVHLJGHOD 3HW[LQD 5HIHUqQFLD&DGDVWUDO5HIHUHQFLD&DWDVWUDO ,OOD0DQ]DQD3DUFHOāOD3DUFHOD $QWHFHGHQWV-XUtGLFV$QWHFHGHQWHV-XUtGLFRV ,QFRDFLy,QFRDFLyQ 3XEOLFDFLyGHODLQFRDFLy3XEOLFDFLyQGHODLQFRDFLyQ%2( 'HVFULSFLy'HVFULSFLyQ 3DUWV,QWHJUDQWV3DUWHV,QWHJUDQWHV − (GLILFLGHO¶$OTXHULDLWRWHVOHVVHXHVHVWDQFHV(GLILFLRGHODDOTXHUtDFRQWRGDVVXVGHSHQGHQFLDV − -DUGt-DUGtQ − 7jSLD7DSLD 'HVFULSFLy*HQHUDO'HVFULSFLyQ*HQHUDO / $OTXHULDGH-XOLjVHVLWXDYDHQO KRUWDDODULEHUDGHO7~ULDLHQO DFWXDOLWDWHVWUREDHQODUHWtFXODXUEDQDGH ODFLXWDW(OFRQMXQWGHOTXDOHVFRQVHUYD~QLFDPHQWO DOTXHULDFRQVWDYDGHO HGLILFLO KRUWLXQMDUGtLPPHGLDW D OD YLYHQGD / HGLILFL pV XQ GHOV HVFDVVRV H[HPSODUV FRQVHUYDWV G DOTXHULD YDOHQFLDQD GHO VHJOH ;9,, DPE WUDFWDPHQWFXOWHLGHFRUDFLyQREOH/DSRUWDSULQFLSDOWpXQDVHQ]LOODHPERFDGXUDGHSHGUDLVREUHHOODHVWj O ~QLF EDOFy GH O H[WHULRU MD TXH OD UHVWD GHOV EXLWV VyQ ILQHVWUHV (Q HO EDOFy O¶REHUWXUD HV GHVHQYROXSD D PDQHUDGHSRUWDGDDPESLODVWUHVHVWULDGHVHQHOVFRVWDWVVREUHOHVTXDOVVHVLWXHQPqQVXOHVTXHVXVWHQWHQ XQ HQWDXODPHQW HQ OD SDUW VXSHULRU GHO TXDO VH VLWXD HQ IURQWy SDUWLW TXH DOEHUJD XQD YHQHUD (Q HVWH PDWHL[ HL[ VH VLWXD XQD WRUUH GH GRV DOWXUHV (Q OD IDoDQD TXH GyQD DO MDUGt V REUL XQD SRUWDGD FROXPQHV MzQLTXHV VREUH OHV TXDOV VH VLWXD XQ HQWDXODPHQW PROW UHVVDOWDW DPE XQ IURQWy FRUE HQ OD SDUW VXSHULRU / HGLILFLHVWDFRURQDWDPESLUjPLGHVLEROHV$O LQWHULRUHVGLVSRVDXQYHVWtEXODPEDUFUHEDL[DWHQHOFHQWUH /HVKDELWDFLRQVGHSODQWDEDL[DHVWDQFREHUWHVDPEELJXHVGHIXVWD(QHVWDSODQWDHVGHVHQYROXSDXQVzFRO GHWDXOHOOHWVGHILQDOVGHOVHJOH;9,,&DOGHVWDFDUODGHFRUDFLyGHOVVRVWUHVGHOHVGLIHUHQWVHVWDQFHVHQOD SODQWDLQIHULRUDPEPRWOXUHVJHRPqWULTXHVLSHW[LQHVHQHOVFDQWRQVHQODSODQWDVXSHULRUO HVWDQoDDPEXQ HVJUDILDWDPEPRWLXVYHJHWDOVLIDQWjVWLFVXQGHOVSRFVH[HPSOHVGHILQDOVGHOVHJOH;9,,TXHHVFRQVHUYHQ HQLQWHULRUVGHYLYHQGHV%DVDWHQHO&DWjOHJGH0RQXPHQWVL&RQMXQWVGHOD&RPXQLWDW9DOHQFLDQD /D $OTXHUtD GH -XOLj VH VLWXDED HQ OD KXHUWD HQFRQWUiQGRVH HQ OD DFWXDOLGDG HQ OD UHWtFXOD XUEDQD GH OD FLXGDG (O FRQMXQWR FRQVWDED GHO HGLILFLR HO KXHUWR \ XQ MDUGtQ LQPHGLDWR D OD YLYLHQGD FRQVHUYiQGRVH ~QLFDPHQWHODDOTXHUtD(OHGLILFLRHVXQRGHORVHVFDVRVHMHPSODUHVFRQVHUYDGRVGHDOTXHUtDYDOHQFLDQDGHO VLJOR;9,,&RQWUDWDPLHQWRFXOWR\GHFRUDFLyQQREOH/DSXHUWDSULQFLSDOWLHQHXQDVHQFLOODHPERFDGXUDGH SLHGUD\VREUHHOODHVWiHO~QLFREDOFyQGHOH[WHULRU\DTXHHOUHVWRGHORVYDQRVVRQYHQWDQDV(QHOEDOFyQ HO YDQR VH GHVDUUROOD D PRGR GH SRUWDGD FRQ SLODVWUDV HVWULDGDV HQ ORV ODGRV VREUH ODV TXH VH VLW~DQ PpQVXODVTXH VXVWHQWDQXQ HQWDEODPHQWR HQFX\DSDUWH VXSHULRU VH VLW~DHQ IURQWyQ SDUWLGR TXH DOEHUJD XQDYHQHUD(QHVWHPLVPRHMHVHVLW~DXQDWRUUHGHGRVDOWXUDV(QODIDFKDGDUHFD\HQWHDOMDUGtQVHDEUH XQDSRUWDGDFROXPQDVMyQLFDVVREUHODVTXHVHVLW~DXQHQWDEODPHQWRPX\UHVDOWDGRFRQXQIURQWyQFXUYR HQODSDUWHVXSHULRU(OHGLILFLRHVWDUHPDWDGRFRQSLUiPLGHV\ERODV$OLQWHULRUVHGLVSRQHXQ]DJXiQFRQ DUFRUHEDMDGRHQHOFHQWUR/DVKDELWDFLRQHVGH SODQWDEDMDHVWiQFXELHUWDVFRQYLJDV GHPDGHUD(QHVWD SODQWD VH GHVDUUROOD XQ ]yFDOR GH D]XOHMRV GH ILQDOHV GHO VLJOR ;9,, &DEH GHVWDFDU OD GHFRUDFLyQ GH ORV WHFKRVGHODVGLIHUHQWHVHVWDQFLDVHQODSODQWDLQIHULRUFRQPROGXUDVJHRPpWULFDV\FRQFKDVHQODVHVTXLQDV HQODSODQWD VXSHULRU OD HVWDQFLD FRQ XQ HVJUDILDGR FRQ PRWLYRV YHJHWDOHV \ IDQWiVWLFRV XQR GH ORV SRFRV HMHPSORV GHILQDOHV GHOVLJOR;9,,TXHVHFRQVHUYDQHQLQWHULRUHVGHYLYLHQGDV%DVDGRHQHO&DWiORJR GH 0RQXPHQWRV\&RQMXQWRVGHOD&RPXQLGDG9DOHQFLDQD $11(;,9$1(;2,9 GH 5HVROXFLyGHG DEULOGHOD'LUHFFLy*HQHUDOGH3DWULPRQL&XOWXUDO9DOHQFLjL0XVHXVGHOD&RQVHOOHULDGH&XOWXUD(GXFDFLyL(VSRUWSHUODTXHV LQFRDH[SHGLHQWSHUDOD SULPHUD IDVH GH O DFWXDOLW]DFLy L DGDSWDFLy SDUFLDO GH OD 6HFFLy 3ULPHUD GH O ,QYHQWDUL *HQHUDO GHO 3DWULPRQL &XOWXUDO 9DOHQFLj HQ PDWqULD GH SDWULPRQL DUTXLWHFWzQLF L PHGLDPELHQWDOLV¶REULSHUtRGHG¶LQIRUPDFLyS~EOLFD 5HVROXFLyQ GH GH DEULO GH OD 'LUHFFLyQ *HQHUDO GH 3DWULPRQLR &XOWXUDO 9DOHQFLDQR \ 0XVHRV GH OD &RQVHOOHULD GH &XOWXUD (GXFDFLyQ \ 'HSRUWH SRU OD TXH VH LQFRD H[SHGLHQWH SDUD OD SULPHUD IDVH GH OD DFWXDOL]DFLyQ \ DGDSWDFLyQ SDUFLDO GH OD 6HFFLyQ 3ULPHUD GHO ,QYHQWDULR *HQHUDO GHO 3DWULPRQLR &XOWXUDO 9DOHQFLDQR HQ PDWHULD GH SDWULPRQLRDUTXLWHFWyQLFR\PHGLRDPELHQWDO\VHDEUHSHULRGRGHLQIRUPDFLyQSXEOLFD Núm. 5.503 / 02.05.2007 17949 2EVHUYDFLRQV2EVHUYDFLRQHV (QWRUQ(QWRUQ $QWHFHGHQWV DGPLQLVWUDWLXV /D GHOLPLWDFLy GH O HQWRUQ GH SURWHFFLy V DFXOO DO TXH GLVSRVD O $SWDW GH OD 'LVSRVLFLy 7UDQVLWzULD 3ULPHUD GH OD OOHL PRGLILFDGRUD GH OD (VWD GHOLPLWDFLy TXHGD UHFRQHJXGD DPE FDUjFWHU SURYLVLRQDO VHJRQV OD GHOLPLWDFLy FRQWLQJXGD HQ OD UHVROXFLy GH GH MXQ\ GH SXEOLFDGDHQHO'2*9GHGDWD 2ULJHQFDQWyRULHQWDOGHO HQFUHXDPHQWHQWUHHOVFDUUHUVGH9HOi]TXH]L%UDVLO 6HQWLW$QWLKRUDUL /tQLDGHOLPLWDGRUD/DOtQLDUHFRUUHOHVIDoDQHVGHOFDUUHUGH%UDVLOILQVDODPLWDWGHODSDUFHOāODGHO¶LOOD GHFDVHV&UHXDHOFDUUHUGH%UDVLOLHVSURORQJDSHOIURQWGHO[DPIUjHQWUHHOVFDUUHUVGH%UDVLOLGH &DVWiQ7REHxDVTXHFRPHQoDDUHFyUUHUILQVTXHJLUDLSDVVDD O DOWUHFRVWDWDO DOWXUDGHODPLWJHUDHQWUH OHVSDUFHOāOHVFDGDVWUDOVLGHO¶LOODGHFDVHVTXHWUDYHVVDHL[LQWHQWUHOHVSDUFHOāOHVLGHOD PDWHL[DLOOD(VSURORQJDILQVDO DPSLWGHOULXTXHUHFRUUHDOOODUJGHOSDVVHLJGHOD3HW[LQDILQVTXHWRUQDD JLUDU SHU D LQWURGXLUVH HQWUH OHV SDUFHOāOHV L GH O¶LOOD GH FDVHV 5HFRUUH OHV SRVWHULRUV GH OHV SDUFHOāOHVL HL[LQWSHOFDUUHUGH&DVWiQ7REHxDVLUHFRUUHQWOHVIDoDQHV G HVWDILQVD FUHXDUHOFDUUHUGH9HOi]TXH]LWRUQDUDOSXQWG RULJHQ $QWHFHGHQWHV DGPLQLVWUDWLYRV /D GHOLPLWDFLyQ GHO HQWRUQR GH SURWHFFLyQ VH DFRJH D OR GLVSXHVWR HQ HO $SWGRGHOD'LVSRVLFLyQ7UDQVLWRULD3ULPHUDGHODOH\PRGLILFDGRUDGHOD(VWDGHOLPLWDFLyQ TXHGDUHFRQRFLGDFRQFDUiFWHUSURYLVLRQDOVHJ~QODGHOLPLWDFLyQFRQWHQLGDHQODUHVROXFLyQGHGHMXQLR GHSXEOLFDGDHQHO'2*9GHIHFKD 2ULJHQHVTXLQDRULHQWDOGHOFUXFHHQWUHODVFDOOHV9HOi]TXH]\%UDVLO 6HQWLGR$QWLKRUDULR /tQHD GHOLPLWDGRUD /D OtQHD UHFRUUH ODV IDFKDGDV GH OD FDOOH %UDVLO KDVWD OD PLWDG GH OD SDUFHOD GH OD PDQ]DQD&UX]DODFDOOH%UDVLO\VHSURORQJDSRUHOIUHQWHGHOFKDIOiQHQWUHODVFDOOHV%UDVLO\&DVWiQ 7REHxDVTXHFRPLHQ]DDUHFRUUHUKDVWDTXHJLUD\SDVDDORWUR ODGRDODDOWXUDGHODPHGLDQHUDHQWUHODV SDUFHODVFDWDVWUDOHV\GHODPDQ]DQDTXHDWUDYLHVDVDOLHQGRHQWUHODVSDUFHODV\GHOD PLVPDPDQ]DQD6HSURORQJDKDVWDHOSUHWLOGHOUtRTXHUHFRUUHDORODUJRGHO3DVHRGHOD3HFKLQDKDVWDTXH YXHOYHDJLUDUSDUDLQWURGXFLUVHHQWUHODVSDUFHODV\GHODPDQ]DQD5HFRUUHODVWUDVHUDVGHODV SDUFHODV\VDOLHQGRSRU ODFDOOH&DVWiQ 7REHxDV\UHFRUULHQGR ODVIDFKDGDVGH pVWD KDVWDFUX]DUODFDOOH9HOi]TXH]\YROYHUDOSXQWRGHRULJHQ $11(;,9$1(;2,9 GH 5HVROXFLyGHG DEULOGHOD'LUHFFLy*HQHUDOGH3DWULPRQL&XOWXUDO9DOHQFLjL0XVHXVGHOD&RQVHOOHULDGH&XOWXUD(GXFDFLyL(VSRUWSHUODTXHV LQFRDH[SHGLHQWSHUDOD SULPHUD IDVH GH O DFWXDOLW]DFLy L DGDSWDFLy SDUFLDO GH OD 6HFFLy 3ULPHUD GH O ,QYHQWDUL *HQHUDO GHO 3DWULPRQL &XOWXUDO 9DOHQFLj HQ PDWqULD GH SDWULPRQL DUTXLWHFWzQLF L PHGLDPELHQWDOLV¶REULSHUtRGHG¶LQIRUPDFLyS~EOLFD 5HVROXFLyQ GH GH DEULO GH OD 'LUHFFLyQ *HQHUDO GH 3DWULPRQLR &XOWXUDO 9DOHQFLDQR \ 0XVHRV GH OD &RQVHOOHULD GH &XOWXUD (GXFDFLyQ \ 'HSRUWH SRU OD TXH VH LQFRD H[SHGLHQWH SDUD OD SULPHUD IDVH GH OD DFWXDOL]DFLyQ \ DGDSWDFLyQ SDUFLDO GH OD 6HFFLyQ 3ULPHUD GHO ,QYHQWDULR *HQHUDO GHO 3DWULPRQLR &XOWXUDO 9DOHQFLDQR HQ PDWHULD GH SDWULPRQLRDUTXLWHFWyQLFR\PHGLRDPELHQWDO\VHDEUHSHULRGRGHLQIRUPDFLyQSXEOLFD Núm. 5.503 / 02.05.2007 17950 %e'¶,17(5e6&8/785$/±$/48(5,$'(-8/,¬9$/Ê1&,$02180(17 %,(1'(,17(5e6&8/785$/±$/48(5Ë$'(-8/,¬9$/(1&,$02180(172 $11(;,9$1(;2,9 5HVROXFLyGHG DEULOGHOD'LUHFFLy*HQHUDOGH3DWULPRQL&XOWXUDO9DOHQFLjL0XVHXVGHOD&RQVHOOHULDGH&XOWXUD(GXFDFLyL(VSRUWSHUODTXHV LQFRD H[SHGLHQWSHUDODSULPHUDIDVHGHO DFWXDOLW]DFLyLDGDSWDFLy SDUFLDOGHOD6HFFLy3ULPHUDGHO ,QYHQWDUL*HQHUDOGHO3DWULPRQL&XOWXUDO9DOHQFLjHQPDWqULDGH SDWULPRQLDUTXLWHFWzQLFLPHGLDPELHQWDOLV¶REULSHUtRGHG¶LQIRUPDFLyS~EOLFD 5HVROXFLyQGHGHDEULOGHOD'LUHFFLyQ*HQHUDOGH3DWULPRQLR&XOWXUDO9DOHQFLDQR\0XVHRVGHOD&RQVHOOHULDGH&XOWXUD(GXFDFLyQ\'HSRUWHSRUOD TXH VH LQFRD H[SHGLHQWH SDUD OD SULPHUD IDVH GH OD DFWXDOL]DFLyQ \ DGDSWDFLyQ SDUFLDO GH OD 6HFFLyQ 3ULPHUD GHO ,QYHQWDULR *HQHUDO GHO 3DWULPRQLR &XOWXUDO 9DOHQFLDQRHQPDWHULDGHSDWULPRQLRDUTXLWHFWyQLFR\PHGLRDPELHQWDO\VHDEUHSHULRGRGHLQIRUPDFLyQSXEOLFD GH Núm. 5.503 / 02.05.2007 17951 %e'¶,17(5e6&8/785$/±(6*/e6,$3$55248,$/'(/$0$5('('e8'(/$0,6(5,&Ñ5',$ '(&$03$1$59$/Ê1&,$02180(17 %,(1'(,17(5e6&8/785$/±,*/(6,$3$55248,$/'(18(675$6(f25$'(/$0,6(5,&25',$ '(&$03$1$59$/(1&,$02180(172 'HQRPLQDFLy'HQRPLQDFLyQ 3ULQFLSDO3ULQFLSDO (VJOqVLD3DUURTXLDOGHOD0DUHGH'pXGHOD 0LVHULFzUGLDGH&DPSDQDU ,JOHVLD3DUURTXLDOGH1XHVWUD6HxRUDGHOD 0LVHULFRUGLDGH&DPSDQDU /RFDOL]DFLy/RFDOL]DFLyQ 3URYtQFLD3URYLQFLD9DOqQFLD &RPDUFD&RPDUFDO¶+RUWD 0XQLFLSL0XQLFLSLR9DOqQFLD 8ELFDFLy8ELFDFLyQ3ODoDGHO¶(VJOpVLD%DUULGH &DPSDQDU 5HIHUHQFLD&DGDVWUDO5HIHUHQFLD&DWDVWUDO ,OOD0DQ]DQD3DUFHOāOD3DUFHOD $QWHFHGHQWV-XUtGLFV$QWHFHGHQWHV-XUtGLFRV ,QFRDFLy,QFRDFLyQ 3XEOLFDFLyGHODLQFRDFLy3XEOLFDFLyQGHODLQFRDFLyQ'2*9%2( 'HVFULSFLy'HVFULSFLyQ 3DUWV,QWHJUDQWV3DUWHV,QWHJUDQWHV − 1DXSULQFLSDO1DYHSULQFLSDO − &DSHOOHVODWHUDOV&DSLOODVODWHUDOHV − 5HUHVDJUDUL7UDVDJUDULR − &DSHOODGHOD&RPXQLy&DSLOODGHOD&RPXQLyQ − &DPSDQDU&DPSDQDULR − )DoDQDSULQFLSDODPESRUWDGDLODWHUDOV)DFKDGDSULQFLSDOFRQSRUWDGD\ODWHUDOHV 'HVFULSFLy*HQHUDO'HVFULSFLyQ*HQHUDO (Q HO %DUUL GH &DPSDQDU DQWLF PXQLFLSL LQWHJUDW D OD FLXWDW GH 9DOqQFLD HQ HV WURED HVWD HVJOpVLD /D SDUUzTXLD YD VHU LQVWDXUDGD HQ VREUH XQD DQWLJD HUPLWD (Q HV YD LQDXJXUDU XQD [LFRWHWD FDSHOOD FRQVWUXwGDDPEPRWLXGHODWUREDOODGHOD0DUHGH'pXGH&DPSDQDUHQeVDILQDOVGHOVHJOH;9,,LVHJXLQW HOVSRVWXODWVGHOEDUURFTXDQV LQLFLDO DPSOLDFLyGHOSUHVELWHULODFRQVWUXFFLyGHOUHUHVDJUDULLODQRYDSODQWDGH ODFDSHOODGHODFRPXQLy$HVWDHWDSDGHUHQRYDFLyFRUUHVSRQWDPEp O LQLFLGHODFRQVWUXFFLyGHOFDPSDQDU(O UHUHVDJUDULWpSODQWDUHFWDQJXODUDPEDFFpVGLUHFWHSHUGXHVSRUWHVODWHUDOVMXQWDO DOWDUPDMRU(OWHPSOHHVWj FREHUWSHUXQDYROWDGHFDQyGLYLGLGDHQWUHVVHFFLRQVSHUTXDWUHDUFVIDL[RQVTXHGRQHQOORFHQHOVHXFHQWUHD XQD VLQJXODU YROWD YDwGD (OV VHXV SDUDPHQWV HVWDQ GHFRUDWV DPE PDJQtILTXHV SLQWXUHV DO IUHVF DWULEXwGHV D 'LRQLVLR9LGDO )LQDOPHQW HQ L FRQWUDFWDGHV DPE HO PHVWUH G REUHV -RVp 0tQJXH] V LQLFLHQ OHV REUHV GH FRQFOXVLy GHO FDPSDQDUODIjEULFDGHOTXDOGHFRQVLGHUDEOHVSURSRUFLRQVHVWUXFWXUDOVH[HPSOLILFDXQDQRYDWLSRORJLDGHWRUUHV FDPSDQDUV FDUDFWHULW]DWV SHO GHVHQYROXSDPHQW G XQD SRWHQW FRURQDFLy HVJUDRQDGD GH GRV FRVVRV DPE DOHWHV G HQOODoLFREHUWSHUXQFDVLOLFLGHWHXOHVYLGULDGHVeVHQHL[HPRPHQWTXDQYDKDYHUVHGHUHIRUPDUODIDoDQD UHPDWDGDSHUXQSRWHQWSHUILOPL[WLOLQLG HYLGHQWWUDGLFLyVHWFHQWLVWDHQFRQQH[LyDPEFHUWVHOHPHQWVGHFRUDWLXV GH OD FDSHOOD GH OD 0DUH GH 'pX 3RVWHULRUPHQW O HVJOpVLD KD VLJXW UHSULVWLQDGD DPE HVWXFV L GDXUDWV TXH OL FRQIHUL[HQ XQ FHUW FDUjFWHU KXLWFHQWLVWD (O FDPSDQDU YD HVWDU UHVWDXUDW DPE UHFXSHUDFLy GHO VHX RULJLQDO FURPDWLVPHDILQDOVGHOVDQ\VGHO6;;%DVDWHQO LQIRUPHGHO6HUYLFLGH3DWULPRQL$UWtVWLF,PPREOH (QHOEDUULRGH&DPSDQDUDQWLJXRPXQLFLSLRLQWHJUDGRDODFLXGDGHQVHHQFXHQWUDHVWiLJOHVLD /D SDUURTXLD IXH LQVWDXUDGD HQ VREUH XQD DQWLJXD HUPLWD (Q VH LQDXJXUy XQD SHTXHxD FDSLOOD FRQVWUXLGD FRQ PRWLYR GHO KDOOD]JR GH OD 9LUJHQ GH &DPSDQDU HQ (V D ILQDOHV GHO VLJOR ;9,, FXDQGR VH LQLFLDODDPSOLDFLyQGHOSUHVELWHULRODFRQVWUXFFLyQGHOWUDVDJUDULR\ODQXHYDSODQWDGHODFDSLOODGHODFRPXQLyQ VLJXLHQGR ORV SRVWXODGRV GHO EDUURFR $ HVWD UHQRYDFLyQ FRUUHVSRQGH WDPELpQ HO LQLFLR GH OD FRQVWUXFFLyQ GHO FDPSDQDULR (O WUDVDJUDULR GH SODQWD UHFWDQJXODU FRQ DFFHVR GLUHFWR SRU GRV SXHUWDV ODWHUDOHV MXQWR DO DOWDU PD\RU(OWHPSORHVWiFXELHUWR SRUXQD EyYHGDGHFDxyQGLYLGLGD HQ WUHV VHFFLRQHV SRU FXDWUR DUFRV IDMRQHV $11(;,9$1(;2,9 GH 5HVROXFLyGHG DEULOGHOD'LUHFFLy*HQHUDOGH3DWULPRQL&XOWXUDO9DOHQFLjL0XVHXVGHOD&RQVHOOHULDGH&XOWXUD(GXFDFLyL(VSRUWSHUODTXHV LQFRDH[SHGLHQWSHUDOD SULPHUD IDVH GH O DFWXDOLW]DFLy L DGDSWDFLy SDUFLDO GH OD 6HFFLy 3ULPHUD GH O ,QYHQWDUL *HQHUDO GHO 3DWULPRQL &XOWXUDO 9DOHQFLj HQ PDWqULD GH SDWULPRQL DUTXLWHFWzQLF L PHGLDPELHQWDOLV¶REULSHUtRGHG¶LQIRUPDFLyS~EOLFD 5HVROXFLyQ GH GH DEULO GH OD 'LUHFFLyQ *HQHUDO GH 3DWULPRQLR &XOWXUDO 9DOHQFLDQR \ 0XVHRV GH OD &RQVHOOHULD GH &XOWXUD (GXFDFLyQ \ 'HSRUWH SRU OD TXH VH LQFRD H[SHGLHQWH SDUD OD SULPHUD IDVH GH OD DFWXDOL]DFLyQ \ DGDSWDFLyQ SDUFLDO GH OD 6HFFLyQ 3ULPHUD GHO ,QYHQWDULR *HQHUDO GHO 3DWULPRQLR &XOWXUDO 9DOHQFLDQR HQ PDWHULD GH SDWULPRQLRDUTXLWHFWyQLFR\PHGLRDPELHQWDO\VHDEUHSHULRGRGHLQIRUPDFLyQSXEOLFD Núm. 5.503 / 02.05.2007 17952 TXH GDQ OXJDU HQ VX FHQWUR D XQD VLQJXODU EyYHGD YDtGD 6XV SDUDPHQWRV HVWiQ GHFRUDGRV FRQ PDJQtILFDV SLQWXUDVDOIUHVFRDWULEXLGDVD'LRQLVLR9LGDO )LQDOPHQWHHQVHLQLFLDQODVREUDVGHFRQFOXVLyQGHOFDPSDQDULRFRQWUDWDGDVFRQHOPDHVWURGHREUDV-RVp 0tQJXH] FX\D IiEULFD GH FRQVLGHUDEOHV SURSRUFLRQHV HVWUXFWXUDOHV HMHPSOLILFD XQD QXHYD WLSRORJtD GH WRUUHV FDPSDQDULRV FDUDFWHUL]DGRV SRU HO GHVDUUROOR GH XQ SRWHQWH UHPDWH HVFDORQDGR GH GRV FXHUSRV FRQ DOHWDV GH HQODFH\FRURQDGRSRUXQFKDSLWHOGHWHMDVYLGULDGDV(VHQHVHPRPHQWRFXDQGRGHELyUHIRUPDUVHODIDFKDGD UHPDWDGDSRUXQSRWHQWHSHUILOPL[WLOtQHRGHHYLGHQWHWUDGLFLyQVHWHFHQWLVWDHQFRQH[LyQFRQFLHUWRVHOHPHQWRV GHFRUDWLYRVGHODFDSLOODGHOD9LUJHQ3RVWHULRUPHQWHODLJOHVLDKDVLGRUHSULVWLQDGDFRQHVWXFRV\GRUDGRVTXHOH FRQILHUHQ XQ FLHUWR FDUiFWHU GHFLPRQyQLFR (O FDPSDQDULR IXH UHVWDXUDGR FRQ UHFXSHUDFLyQ GH VX FURPDWLVPR RULJLQDODILQDOHVGHORVDxRVGHO6;;%DVDGRHQHOLQIRUPHGHO6HUYLFLRGH3DWULPRQLR$UWtVWLFR,QPXHEOH 2EVHUYDFLRQV2EVHUYDFLRQHV (QWRUQ(QWRUQ $QWHFHGHQWV DGPLQLVWUDWLXV OD GHOLPLWDFLy GH O HQWRUQ GH SURWHFFLy V DFXOO DO TXH GLVSRVD O $SWDW GH OD 'LVSRVLFLy 7UDQVLWzULD 3ULPHUD GH OD OOHL PRGLILFDGRUD GH OD (VWD GHOLPLWDFLy TXHGD UHFRQHJXGDDPEFDUjFWHUSURYLVLRQDOVHJRQVODGHOLPLWDFLyFRQWLQJXGDHQODUHVROXFLyGHG DEULOGH SXEOLFDGDHQHO'2*9GHGDWD 2ULJHQYqUWH[QRUGHVWGHODSDUFHOāODGHO¶LOODGHFDVHVFDGDVWUDOSXQW$ 6HQWLW+RUDUL /tQLDGHOLPLWDGRUDODOtQLDFUHXDHOFDUUHU%HQLGRUPLHQJOREDOHVSDUFHOāOHVLGHO¶LOODGH FDVHV7RUQDDFUHXDUHOFDUUHU%HQLGRUPLLQFRUSRUDOHVSDUFHOāOHVGHO¶LOODGHFDVHV OHVLGHODLOHVLGHOD&UHXDHOFDUUHU3HVFDPLQHVLLQFRUSRUDOHVSDUFHOāOHV LGHO¶LOODGHFDVHV&UHXD HOFDUUHU EDUy GH%DU[HWDLFRQWLQXD DRHVWLQFRUSRUDQW O¶LOODGHFDVHVFDGDVWUDOILQVDOSXQWG RULJHQ $QWHFHGHQWHVDGPLQLVWUDWLYRVODGHOLPLWDFLyQGHOHQWRUQRGHSURWHFFLyQVHDFRJHDORGLVSXHVWRHQHO$SWGR GHOD'LVSRVLFLyQ7UDQVLWRULD3ULPHUDGHODOH\PRGLILFDGRUDGHOD(VWDGHOLPLWDFLyQTXHGD UHFRQRFLGDFRQFDUiFWHUSURYLVLRQDOVHJ~QODGHOLPLWDFLyQFRQWHQLGDHQODUHVROXFLyQGHGHDEULOGH SXEOLFDGDHQHO'2*9GHIHFKD 2ULJHQYpUWLFHQRUGHVWHGHODSDUFHODGHODPDQ]DQDFDWDVWUDOSXQWR$ 6HQWLGR+RUDULR /tQHD GHOLPLWDGRUD OD OtQHD FUX]D OD FDOOH %HQLGRUP \ HQJORED ODV SDUFHODV \ GH OD PDQ]DQD9XHOYHDFUX]DUODFDOOH%HQLGRUPHLQFRUSRUDODVSDUFHODVGHODPDQ]DQD ODV\GHOD\ODV\GHOD&UX]DODFDOOH'UDJDPLQDVHLQFRUSRUDODVSDUFHODV \GHODPDQ]DQD&UX]DODFDOOH%DUyQGH%DUFKHWD\FRQWLQ~DDRHVWHLQFRUSRUDQGROD PDQ]DQDFDWDVWUDOKDVWDHOSXQWRGHRULJHQ $11(;,9$1(;2,9 GH 5HVROXFLyGHG DEULOGHOD'LUHFFLy*HQHUDOGH3DWULPRQL&XOWXUDO9DOHQFLjL0XVHXVGHOD&RQVHOOHULDGH&XOWXUD(GXFDFLyL(VSRUWSHUODTXHV LQFRDH[SHGLHQWSHUDOD SULPHUD IDVH GH O DFWXDOLW]DFLy L DGDSWDFLy SDUFLDO GH OD 6HFFLy 3ULPHUD GH O ,QYHQWDUL *HQHUDO GHO 3DWULPRQL &XOWXUDO 9DOHQFLj HQ PDWqULD GH SDWULPRQL DUTXLWHFWzQLF L PHGLDPELHQWDOLV¶REULSHUtRGHG¶LQIRUPDFLyS~EOLFD 5HVROXFLyQ GH GH DEULO GH OD 'LUHFFLyQ *HQHUDO GH 3DWULPRQLR &XOWXUDO 9DOHQFLDQR \ 0XVHRV GH OD &RQVHOOHULD GH &XOWXUD (GXFDFLyQ \ 'HSRUWH SRU OD TXH VH LQFRD H[SHGLHQWH SDUD OD SULPHUD IDVH GH OD DFWXDOL]DFLyQ \ DGDSWDFLyQ SDUFLDO GH OD 6HFFLyQ 3ULPHUD GHO ,QYHQWDULR *HQHUDO GHO 3DWULPRQLR &XOWXUDO 9DOHQFLDQR HQ PDWHULD GH SDWULPRQLRDUTXLWHFWyQLFR\PHGLRDPELHQWDO\VHDEUHSHULRGRGHLQIRUPDFLyQSXEOLFD Núm. 5.503 / 02.05.2007 17953 %e'¶,17(5e6&8/785$/±(6*/e6,$3$55248,$/'(/$0$5('('e8'(/$0,6(5,&Ñ5',$ '(&$03$1$59$/Ê1&,$02180(17 %,(1'(,17(5e6&8/785$/±,*/(6,$3$55248,$/'(18(675$6(f25$'(/$0,6(5,&25',$ '(&$03$1$59$/(1&,$02180(172 $11(;,9$1(;2,9 5HVROXFLyGHG DEULOGHOD'LUHFFLy*HQHUDOGH3DWULPRQL&XOWXUDO9DOHQFLjL0XVHXVGHOD&RQVHOOHULDGH&XOWXUD(GXFDFLyL(VSRUWSHUODTXHV LQFRD H[SHGLHQWSHUDODSULPHUDIDVHGHO DFWXDOLW]DFLyLDGDSWDFLy SDUFLDOGHOD6HFFLy3ULPHUDGHO ,QYHQWDUL*HQHUDOGHO3DWULPRQL&XOWXUDO9DOHQFLjHQPDWqULDGH SDWULPRQLDUTXLWHFWzQLFLPHGLDPELHQWDOLV¶REULSHUtRGHG¶LQIRUPDFLyS~EOLFD 5HVROXFLyQGHGHDEULOGHOD'LUHFFLyQ*HQHUDOGH3DWULPRQLR&XOWXUDO9DOHQFLDQR\0XVHRVGHOD&RQVHOOHULDGH&XOWXUD(GXFDFLyQ\'HSRUWHSRUOD TXH VH LQFRD H[SHGLHQWH SDUD OD SULPHUD IDVH GH OD DFWXDOL]DFLyQ \ DGDSWDFLyQ SDUFLDO GH OD 6HFFLyQ 3ULPHUD GHO ,QYHQWDULR *HQHUDO GHO 3DWULPRQLR &XOWXUDO 9DOHQFLDQRHQPDWHULDGHSDWULPRQLRDUTXLWHFWyQLFR\PHGLRDPELHQWDO\VHDEUHSHULRGRGHLQIRUPDFLyQSXEOLFD GH Núm. 5.503 / 02.05.2007 17954 %e'¶,17(5e6&8/785$/±(6*/e6,$'(/6$17Ë66,0&5,67'(/6$/9$'259$/Ê1&,$02180(17 %,(1'(,17(5e6&8/785$/±,*/(6,$'(/6$17Ë6,02&5,672'(/6$/9$'259$/(1&,$02180(172 'HQRPLQDFLy'HQRPLQDFLyQ 3ULQFLSDO3ULQFLSDO (VJOpVLDGHO6DQWtVVLP&ULVWGHO6DOYDGRU ,JOHVLDGHO6DQWtVLPR&ULVWRGHO6DOYDGRU $FFHVzULD$FFHVRULD 5HLDO(VJOpVLDGHO6DOYDGRU 5HDO,JOHVLDGHO6DOYDGRU /RFDOL]DFLy/RFDOL]DFLyQ 3URYtQFLD3URYLQFLD9DOqQFLD &RPDUFD&RPDUFDO¶+RUWD 0XQLFLSL0XQLFLSLR9DOqQFLD 8ELFDFLy8ELFDFLyQ&7ULQLWDULV 5HIHUqQFLD&DGDVWUDO5HIHUHQFLD&DWDVWUDO ,OOD0DQ]DQD3DUFHOāOD3DUFHOD $QWHFHGHQWV-XUtGLFV$QWHFHGHQWHV-XUtGLFRV ,QFRDFLy,QFRDFLyQ 3XEOLFDFLyGHODLQFRDFLy3XEOLFDFLyQGHODLQFRDFLyQ%2( 'HVFULSFLy'HVFULSFLyQ 3DUWV,QWHJUDQWV3DUWHV,QWHJUDQWHV − /DQDX/DQDYH − /DFDSHOODPDMRU/DFDSLOODPD\RU − /HVFDSHOOHVODWHUDOV/DVFDSLOODVODWHUDOHV − (OFRUHOHYDW(OFRURHOHYDGR − /DFDSHOODGHOD&RPXQLy/DFDSLOODGHOD&RPXQLyQ − 6DJULVWLD6DFULVWtD − $U[LX$UFKLYR − 7RUUH&DPSDQDU7RUUH&DPSDQDULR − 3RUWDGHV3RUWDGDV 'HVFULSFLy*HQHUDO'HVFULSFLyQ*HQHUDO (VWUDFWDG XQDGHOHVHVJOpVLHVDOoDGHVGHVSUpVGHODUHFRQTXHVWDHQHOVHJOH;,,,LUHQRYDGDXQVHJOHPpV WDUGHVFRQVHUYDHOFDPSDQDUG¶XQJzWLFWDQVHQ]LOOTXHPDVVD YHJDGHVKDHVWDWTXDOLILFDWHUUzQLDPHQWGH URPjQLF(QHOVHJOH;9,HVYDUHHGLILFDUJUDQSDUWGHO HVJOpVLD(QHOVHJOH;9,,HQWUHLHVYD PRGHUQLW]DU O HVJOpVLD DPE XQD GHFRUDFLy LQWHULRU EDUURFD /D GHFRUDFLy DFWXDO GHO WHPSOH pV G HVWLO QHRFOjVVLF D FDXVD GH O ~OWLPD LQWHUYHQFLy GXWD D WHUPH HQWUH L D FjUUHF GH 0DQXHO )RUQpV L *XUUHD DUTXLWHFWH DFDGqPLF TXH YDULj QRYDPHQW HO SUHVELWHUL (V WUDFWD G XQD HVJOpVLD GH SODQWD UHFWDQJXODU G XQD VROD QDX DPE [LFRWHWHV FDSHOOHV ODWHUDOV HQWUH FRQWUDIRUWV (VWj GLYLGLGD HQ VLV WUDPV L SUHVHQWDFDSoDOHUDSROLJRQDOHQFDUDTXHYLVXDOPHQWDO LQWHULRUVHPEODUHFWD/DQDXHVWjFREHUWDDPEYROWD GHFDQyDPEOOXQHWHVGHSHUILOFRUE/ HVJOpVLDHVWjULFDPHQWGHFRUDGD/DFDSHOODGHOD&RPXQLyUHDOLW]DGD HQHOVHJOH;9,,LUHIRUPDGDXQVHJOHPpVWDUGpVGHSODQWDUHFWDQJXODUGLYLGLGDHQGRVHVSDLVSHUXQDUF IDL[y (VWj FREHUWD DPE XQD YROWD UHEDL[DGD GHFRUDGD DPE SLQWXUHV DO IUHVF SHU 9LFHQWH /ySH] /D WRUUH FDPSDQDU DOoDGD HQ HO VHJOH ;,9 pV GH SODQWD TXDGUDGD L UHDOLW]DGD HQ FDUUHXV KD HVWDW UHFHQWPHQW UHVWDXUDGDFRPSOHWDQWHOVYROXPVTXHOLIDOWDYHQ (Q HO VHJOH ;9, YD VHU TXDQ HV YD UHDOLW]DU OD QRYD IjEULFD GHO WHPSOH DPSOLDQWOR SHU OD FDSoDOHUD OD FRQVWUXFFLyGHOFRUO DOWDUPDMRU OD VDJULVWLD L O DU[LX /D SRUWDGD GHO FDUUHU GHO 6DOYDGRU pV DOOLQGDGD DPE XQD FRUQLVD DPE SLQDFOHV EXOERVRV TXH IODQTXHJHQ XQD IRUQtFXOD DPE OD LPDWJH GHO &ULVW &UXFLILFDW /D SRUWDGDODWHUDOTXHGyQDDOFDUUHUGHOV7ULQLWDULV pVWDPEpPROW VHQ]LOODDOOLQGDGDDPEXQDIRUQtFXODHQOD SDUWVXSHULRU (QYDSHUGUHODFDWHJRULDGHSDUUzTXLDTXHSDVVjD6DQWD0zQLFDTXHGDQWGDYDOOODVHXDWXWHODLGDYDOO OD GHO VHPLQDUL FRQWLJX %DVDW HQ HO &DWjOHJ GH 0RQXPHQWV L &RQMXQWV GH OD &RPXQLWDW 9DOHQFLDQD L 9DOqQFLD$UTXLWHFWXUDUHOLJLRVD $11(;,9$1(;2,9 GH 5HVROXFLyGHG DEULOGHOD'LUHFFLy*HQHUDOGH3DWULPRQL&XOWXUDO9DOHQFLjL0XVHXVGHOD&RQVHOOHULDGH&XOWXUD(GXFDFLyL(VSRUWSHUODTXHV LQFRDH[SHGLHQWSHUDOD SULPHUD IDVH GH O DFWXDOLW]DFLy L DGDSWDFLy SDUFLDO GH OD 6HFFLy 3ULPHUD GH O ,QYHQWDUL *HQHUDO GHO 3DWULPRQL &XOWXUDO 9DOHQFLj HQ PDWqULD GH SDWULPRQL DUTXLWHFWzQLF L PHGLDPELHQWDOLV¶REULSHUtRGHG¶LQIRUPDFLyS~EOLFD 5HVROXFLyQ GH GH DEULO GH OD 'LUHFFLyQ *HQHUDO GH 3DWULPRQLR &XOWXUDO 9DOHQFLDQR \ 0XVHRV GH OD &RQVHOOHULD GH &XOWXUD (GXFDFLyQ \ 'HSRUWH SRU OD TXH VH LQFRD H[SHGLHQWH SDUD OD SULPHUD IDVH GH OD DFWXDOL]DFLyQ \ DGDSWDFLyQ SDUFLDO GH OD 6HFFLyQ 3ULPHUD GHO ,QYHQWDULR *HQHUDO GHO 3DWULPRQLR &XOWXUDO 9DOHQFLDQR HQ PDWHULD GH SDWULPRQLRDUTXLWHFWyQLFR\PHGLRDPELHQWDO\VHDEUHSHULRGRGHLQIRUPDFLyQSXEOLFD Núm. 5.503 / 02.05.2007 17955 6HWUDWDGHXQDGHODVLJOHVLDVOHYDQWDGDVWUDVODUHFRQTXLVWDHQHOVLJOR;,,,\UHQRYDGDXQVLJORPDVWDUGH FRQVHUYiQGRVH HO FDPSDQDULR GH XQ JyWLFR WDQ HVFXHWR TXH GHPDVLDGDV YHFHV VH OH KD FDOLILFDGR HUUyQHDPHQWHGHURPiQLFR(QHOVLJOR;9,VHUHHGLILFyJUDQSDUWHGHODLJOHVLD(QHOVLJOR;9,,HQWUH \VHUHQRYyODLJOHVLDFRQXQDGHFRUDFLyQLQWHULRUEDUURFD/DGHFRUDFLyQDFWXDOGHOWHPSORHVGHHVWLOR QHRFOiVLFR GHELGR D OD ~OWLPD LQWHUYHQFLyQ OOHYDGD D FDER HQWUH \ D FDUJR GH 0DQXHO )RUQpV \ *XUUHD DUTXLWHFWR DFDGpPLFR UHDOL]DQGR QXHYDPHQWH HO SUHVELWHULR 6H WUDWD GH XQD LJOHVLD GH SODQWD UHFWDQJXODU GH XQD VROD QDYH FRQ SHTXHxDV FDSLOODV ODWHUDOHV HQWUH FRQWUDIXHUWHV (VWi GLYLGLGD HQ VHLV WUDPRV \ SUHVHQWD FDEHFHUD SROLJRQDO DXQTXH YLVXDOPHQWH DO LQWHULRU SDUHFH UHFWD /D QDYH HVWi FXELHUWD FRQ EyYHGD GH FDxyQ FRQ OXQHWRV GH SHUILO FXUYR /D LJOHVLD HVWi ULFDPHQWH GHFRUDGD /D FDSLOOD GH OD &RPXQLyQ HV GH SODQWD UHFWDQJXODU GLYLGLGD HQ GRV HVSDFLRV SRU XQ DUFR IDMyQ )XH UHDOL]DGD HQ HO VLJOR ;9,, UHDOL]iQGRVH UHIRUPDV XQ VLJOR PiV WDUGH (VWi FXELHUWD FRQ XQD EyYHGD UHEDMDGD GHFRUDGD FRQ SLQWXUDVDOIUHVFRSRU9LFHQWH/ySH]/DWRUUHFDPSDQDULROHYDQWDGDHQHOVLJOR;,9HVGHSODQWDFXDGUDGD\ UHDOL]DGDHQVLOOHUtDKDVLGRUHVWDXUDGDUHFLHQWHPHQWH\FRPSOHWDGRHOYROXPHQTXHOHIDOWDED (Q HO VLJOR ;9, IXH FXDQGR VH UHDOL]y OD QXHYD IiEULFD GHO WHPSOR DPSOLiQGROR SRU OD FDEHFHUD OD FRQVWUXFFLyQGHOFRURHODOWDUPD\RUODVDFULVWtD\HODUFKLYR/DSRUWDGDGHODFDOOH6DOYDGRUHVDGLQWHODGD FRQXQDFRUQLVDFRQSLQiFXORVEXOERVRVTXHIODQTXHDQXQDKRUQDFLQDFRQODLPDJHQGHO&ULVWR&UXFLILFDGR /DSRUWDGDODWHUDOUHFD\HQWHDODFDOOH7ULQLWDULRVHVWDPELpQPX\VHQFLOODDGLQWHODGDFRQXQDKRUQDFLQDHQ OD SDUWH VXSHULRU (Q SHUGLy VX FDWHJRULD GH SDUURTXLD TXH SDVy D 6DQWD 0yQLFD TXHGDQGR EDMR VX WXWHOD \ EDMR OD GHO VHPLQDULR FRQWLJXR %DVDGR HQ HO &DWiORJR GH 0RQXPHQWRV \ &RQMXQWRV GH OD &RPXQLGDG9DOHQFLDQD\9DOHQFLD$UTXLWHFWXUDUHOLJLRVD 2EVHUYDFLRQV2EVHUYDFLRQHV (QWRUQ(QWRUQ $QWHFHGHQWV DGPLQLVWUDWLXV OD GHOLPLWDFLy GH O HQWRUQ GH SURWHFFLy V DFXOO DO TXH GLVSRVD O $SWDW GH OD 'LVSRVLFLy 7UDQVLWzULD 3ULPHUD GH OD OOHL PRGLILFDGRUD GH OD (VWD GHOLPLWDFLy TXHGD UHFRQHJXGD DPE FDUjFWHU SURYLVLRQDO VHJRQV OD GHOLPLWDFLy FRQWLQJXGD HQ OD UHVROXFLy GH G RFWXEUH GH SXEOLFDGDHQHO'2*9GHGDWD 2ULJHQ LQWHUVHFFLy HQWUH O DOLQHDFLy RHVW GHO FDUUHU GHO 6DOYDGRU L O DOLQHDFLy VXG GHO FDUUHU GH OD /OLEHUWDW SXQW$ 6HQWLW+RUDUL /tQLDGHOLPLWDGRUDODOtQLDHVGLULJL[DO HVWFUHXDHOFDUUHUGHO6DOYDGRULYRUHMDHOOtPLWQRUGGHO¶LOODGHFDVHV FDGDVWUDOQ~PLQFORHQWODFUHXDHOFDUUHUGHO6DJUDULR GHO6DOYDGRUDODWUREDGDDPEO¶LOODGHFDVHV FDGDVWUDOQ~PUHFRUUHOHVIDoDQHVG HVWDLOODGHFDVHVTXHGRQHQDOFDUUHU9LFLDQDSODoDGHO&RPWH GH &DUOHW L FDUUHU GHO EDUy G +HUYpV &RQWLQXD D O¶RHVW SHU O DOLQHDFLy QRUG GHO FDUUHU GHOV 7ULQLWDULV FUHXD HVWHFDUUHULLQFRUSRUDOHVSDUFHOāOHVFDGDVWUDOVL GHO¶LOODGHFDVHVOD3ODoDGHOFRPWH GHO5HDOLOHVSDUFHOāOHVLGHO¶LOODGHFDVHV&UHXDHOFDUUHUGHO6DOYDGRULQFORHQWHQO HQWRUQO¶LOOD GHFDVHVFDGDVWUDOLODSDUFHOāODGHO LOOD&UHXDHOFDUUHUGHOD8QLyLVHJXL[SHUOHVIDoDQHV VXGLHVWHGHO¶LOODGHFDVHVILQVDOSXQW$ $QWHFHGHQWHVDGPLQLVWUDWLYRVODGHOLPLWDFLyQGHOHQWRUQRGHSURWHFFLyQVHDFRJHDORGLVSXHVWRHQHO$SWGR GHOD'LVSRVLFLyQ7UDQVLWRULD3ULPHUDGHODOH\PRGLILFDGRUDGHOD(VWDGHOLPLWDFLyQTXHGD UHFRQRFLGD FRQ FDUiFWHU SURYLVLRQDO VHJ~Q OD GHOLPLWDFLyQ FRQWHQLGD HQ OD UHVROXFLyQ GH GH RFWXEUH GH SXEOLFDGDHQHO'2*9GHIHFKD 6HQWLGR+RUDULR /tQHDGHOLPLWDGRUDODOtQHDVHGLULJHDOHVWHFUX]DODFDOOH6DOYDGRU\ERUGHDHOOLPLWHQRUWHGHODPDQ]DQD FDWDVWUDOQLQFOX\pQGRODFUX]DODFDOOH6DJUDULRGHO6DOYDGRUDOHQFXHQWURFRQODPDQ]DQDFDWDVWUDO QUHFRUUHODVIDFKDGDVGHHVWDPDQ]DQDUHFD\HQWHVDODFDOOH9LFLDQDSOD]D&RQGHGH&DUOHW\FDOOH %DURQGH+HUYpV&RQWLQXDDRHVWHSRUODDOLQHDFLyQQRUWHGHODFDOOH7ULQLWDULRVFUX]DHVWDFDOOHHLQFRUSRUD ODVSDUFHODVFDWDVWUDOHV\GHODPDQ]DQDOD3OD]D&RQGHGHO5HDO\ODVSDUFHODV\ GHODPDQ]DQD&UX]DODFDOOHGHO6DOYDGRULQFOX\HQGRHQHOHQWRUQRODPDQ]DQDFDWDVWUDO\OD SDUFHOD GH OD PDQ]DQD &UX]D OD FDOOH GH OD 8QLyQ \ VLJXH SRU ODV IDFKDGDV VXU \ HVWH GH OD PDQ]DQDKDVWDHOSXQWR$ $11(;,9$1(;2,9 GH 5HVROXFLyGHG DEULOGHOD'LUHFFLy*HQHUDOGH3DWULPRQL&XOWXUDO9DOHQFLjL0XVHXVGHOD&RQVHOOHULDGH&XOWXUD(GXFDFLyL(VSRUWSHUODTXHV LQFRDH[SHGLHQWSHUDOD SULPHUD IDVH GH O DFWXDOLW]DFLy L DGDSWDFLy SDUFLDO GH OD 6HFFLy 3ULPHUD GH O ,QYHQWDUL *HQHUDO GHO 3DWULPRQL &XOWXUDO 9DOHQFLj HQ PDWqULD GH SDWULPRQL DUTXLWHFWzQLF L PHGLDPELHQWDOLV¶REULSHUtRGHG¶LQIRUPDFLyS~EOLFD 5HVROXFLyQ GH GH DEULO GH OD 'LUHFFLyQ *HQHUDO GH 3DWULPRQLR &XOWXUDO 9DOHQFLDQR \ 0XVHRV GH OD &RQVHOOHULD GH &XOWXUD (GXFDFLyQ \ 'HSRUWH SRU OD TXH VH LQFRD H[SHGLHQWH SDUD OD SULPHUD IDVH GH OD DFWXDOL]DFLyQ \ DGDSWDFLyQ SDUFLDO GH OD 6HFFLyQ 3ULPHUD GHO ,QYHQWDULR *HQHUDO GHO 3DWULPRQLR &XOWXUDO 9DOHQFLDQR HQ PDWHULD GH SDWULPRQLRDUTXLWHFWyQLFR\PHGLRDPELHQWDO\VHDEUHSHULRGRGHLQIRUPDFLyQSXEOLFD Núm. 5.503 / 02.05.2007 17956 %e'¶,17(5e6&8/785$/±(6*/e6,$'(/6$17Ë66,0&5,67'(/6$/9$'259$/Ê1&,$02180(17 %,(1'(,17(5e6&8/785$/±,*/(6,$'(/6$17Ë6,02&5,672'(/6$/9$'259$/(1&,$02180(172 $11(;,9$1(;2,9 5HVROXFLyGHG DEULOGHOD'LUHFFLy*HQHUDOGH3DWULPRQL&XOWXUDO9DOHQFLjL0XVHXVGHOD&RQVHOOHULDGH&XOWXUD(GXFDFLyL(VSRUWSHUODTXHV LQFRD H[SHGLHQWSHUDODSULPHUDIDVHGHO DFWXDOLW]DFLyLDGDSWDFLy SDUFLDOGHOD6HFFLy3ULPHUDGHO ,QYHQWDUL*HQHUDOGHO3DWULPRQL&XOWXUDO9DOHQFLjHQPDWqULDGH SDWULPRQLDUTXLWHFWzQLFLPHGLDPELHQWDOLV¶REULSHUtRGHG¶LQIRUPDFLyS~EOLFD 5HVROXFLyQGHGHDEULOGHOD'LUHFFLyQ*HQHUDOGH3DWULPRQLR&XOWXUDO9DOHQFLDQR\0XVHRVGHOD&RQVHOOHULDGH&XOWXUD(GXFDFLyQ\'HSRUWHSRUOD TXH VH LQFRD H[SHGLHQWH SDUD OD SULPHUD IDVH GH OD DFWXDOL]DFLyQ \ DGDSWDFLyQ SDUFLDO GH OD 6HFFLyQ 3ULPHUD GHO ,QYHQWDULR *HQHUDO GHO 3DWULPRQLR &XOWXUDO 9DOHQFLDQRHQPDWHULDGHSDWULPRQLRDUTXLWHFWyQLFR\PHGLRDPELHQWDO\VHDEUHSHULRGRGHLQIRUPDFLyQSXEOLFD GH Núm. 5.503 / 02.05.2007 17957 %e'¶,17(5e6&8/785$/±(6*/e6,$'(6$17$*867Ë(6*/e6,$3$55248,$/'(6$17$ &$7(5,1$,6$17$*867Ë9$/Ê1&,$02180(17 %,(1'(,17(5e6&8/785$/±,*/(6,$'(6$1$*867Ë1,*/(6,$3$55248,$/'(6$17$&$7$/,1$ <6$1$*867Ë19$/(1&,$02180(172 'HQRPLQDFLy'HQRPLQDFLyQ 3ULQFLSDO3ULQFLSDO (VJOpVLD3DUURTXLDOGH6DQWD&DWHULQDL6DQWD$JXVWt ,JOHVLD3DUURTXLDOGH6DQWD&DWDOLQD\6DQ$JXVWtQ $FFHVzULD$FFHVRULD (VJOpVLDGH6DQW$JXVWt$QWLFFRQYHQWG¶DJXVWLQV ,JOHVLDGH6DQ$JXVWtQ$QWLJXRFRQYHQWRGHDJXVWLQRV /RFDOL]DFLy/RFDOL]DFLyQ 3URYtFLD3URYLQFLD9DOqQFLD &RPDUFD&RPDUFDO¶+RUWD 0XQLFLSL0XQLFLSLR9DOqQFLD 8ELFDFLy8ELFDFLyQ&0DUHGH'pXGH*UjFLD 5HIHUqQFLD&DGDVWUDO5HIHUHQFLD&DWDVWUDO ,OOD0DQ]DQD3DUFHOāOD3DUFHOD $QWHFHGHQWV-XUtGLFV$QWHFHGHQWHV-XUtGLFRV ,QFRDFLy,QFRDFLyQ 3XEOLFDFLyGHODLQFRDFLy3XEOLFDFLyQGHODLQFRDFLyQ%2( 'HVFULSFLy'HVFULSFLyQ 3DUWV,QWHJUDQWV3DUWHV,QWHJUDQWHV − $EVLVÈEVLGH − 1DXSULQFLSDOLFDSHOOHVODWHUDOV1DYHSULQFLSDO\FDSLOODVODWHUDOHV − &RUHOHYDW&RURHOHYDGR − 5HVWHV FRQVWUXFWLYHV L DUTXHROzJLTXHV SHUWDQ\HQWV DO FODXVWUH GHO &RQYHQW GH )UDUHV (UPLWDQV GH 6DQW $JXVWt VLWXDWV HQ HO PXU ODWHUDO RHVW GH O HVJOpVLD L HQ O HVSDL HQMDUGLQDW 5HVWRV FRQVWUXFWLYRV \ DUTXHROyJLFRVSHUWHQHFLHQWHVDOFODXVWURGHOFRQYHQWRGHIUDLOHVHUPLWDxRVGH6DQ$JXVWtQVLWXDGRVHQHO PXURODWHUDORHVWHGHODLJOHVLD\HQHOHVSDFLRDMDUGLQDGR − 3RUWDGDODWHUDOHVWTXHGyQDDODSODoDGH6DQW$JXVWt3RUWDGDODWHUDOHVWHUHFD\HQWHDODSOD]DGH6DQ $JXVWtQ 'HVFULSFLy*HQHUDO'HVFULSFLyQ*HQHUDO / (VJOpVLD3DUURTXLDOGH6DQWD&DWHULQDL6DQW$JXVWtpVO HVJOpVLDGHO DQWLF&RQYHQWGH)UDUHV(UPLWDQVGH 6DQW$JXVWtDVVHQWDWVD9DOqQFLDHQHOVHJOH;,,,(OFRQYHQWFRPSWDYDDPEXQFODXVWUHMXQWDO HVJOpVLDDPE VHW]H DUFDGHV SHU SDQGD TXH RFXSDYD O¶DFWXDO MDUGt DGMDFHQW (Q HO VHJOH ;9,, HV YD FRQVWUXLU XQ DOWUH FODXVWUH FDS DO FRVWDW QRUG L O DQWHULRU HV YD HOHYDU HQ XQD SODQWD 'XUDQW OD *XHUUD G ,QGHSHQGqQFLD YD VHUYLU FRP D TXDUWHU D OHV WURSHV IUDQFHVHV HQ (O WHPSOH YD VHU UHQRYDW HQ 'HVSUpV GH OD GHVDPRUWLW]DFLy GH OHV GHSHQGqQFLHV FRQYHQWXDOV YDQ VHU XWLOLW]DGHV FRP D SUHVLGL ILQV DO VHX HQGHUURFDPHQW HQ TXHGDQW ~QLFDPHQW O HVJOpVLD REHUWD DO FXOWH / HVJOpVLD G XQD VROD QDX DPE FDSHOOHV HQWUH FRQWUDIRUWV Wp XQ DEVLV SROLJRQDO GH FLQF FRVWDWV FREHUW DPE YROWD GH FUHXHULD HVWUHODGD PHQWUHTXHHOVVLVWUDPVGHODQDXKRIDQDPEYROWHVGHFUHXHULDVLPSOHHOWUDPPpVSUz[LPDOSUHVELWHULpV GHPDMRUDPSOjULD LHVFRUUHVSRQ DPE GRVFDSHOOHV3UHVHQWDFRU DOW DOVSHXV HQTXq HVWUREDO ~QLFDFODX RULJLQDO (Q HV YD DIHJLU XQ UHYHVWLPHQW EDUURF TXH YD VHU UHSULVWLQDW D SDUWLU GH ' HVSHFLDO UHOOHYjQFLDpVO¶LFRQDPHGLHYDOGHOD0DUHGH'pXGH*UjFLDTXHDOEHUJDHVWDHVJOpVLD /DSRUWDGDODWHUDOYDKDYHUGHUHDOLW]DUVHGXUDQWHOSULPHUWHUoGHOVHJOH;9,,(VWjIODQTXHMDGDSHUSDUHOOV GHFROXPQHVGzULTXHVVREUHSHGHVWDOVEDVHG¶XQIURQWyFRUESDUWLWHQODSDUWVXSHULRUXQDIRUQtFXODHQWUH YROXWHV DPE OD LPDWJH GHO VDQW WLWXODU FRURQDGD SHU XQ IURQWy WULDQJXODU LJXDOPHQW SDUWLW (Q HV YD UHDOLW]DUXQQRXFDPSDQDUDFjUUHFGHO¶DUTXLWHFWH/OXtV)HUUHUHVHQUDMRODTXHVHULDHPEROFDOODWDPEXQD PRUIRORJLDJRWLFLVWDHQODLQWHUYHQFLyGHSRVWJXHUUD 'HVSUpVGHOD*XHUUD&LYLOYDTXHGDUPROWDIHFWDGDSHOTXHHVYDSHQVDUHQHO VHXHQGHUURFDPHQW;DYLHU *RHUOLFKYDUHDOLW]DUXQDLQWHUYHQFLyHQTXHOLYDGRQDUHOVHXDVSHFWHDFWXDOGHGXEWyVKLVWRULFLVPH DPE DSODFDWV GH SHGUD YHOOD HQ HO SDUDPHQW RULHQWDO IRUPDFLy G¶HVWDQFHV EDL[HV DOV SHXV GH O¶DEVLV L FRQIHFFLyGHQRYDPRUIRORJLDQHRJzWLFDSHUDODIDoDQDPHULGLRQDOLHOFDPSDQDU(OVGHWDOOVGHFRUDWLXVLHOV UHWDXOHVQHRJzWLFVYDQVHUUHDOLW]DWVSHU-RVHS-XVWR9LOODOED(VWDLQWHUYHQFLyV DFXVDHQODIDoDQDDOVSHXVL $11(;,9$1(;2,9 GH 5HVROXFLyGHG DEULOGHOD'LUHFFLy*HQHUDOGH3DWULPRQL&XOWXUDO9DOHQFLjL0XVHXVGHOD&RQVHOOHULDGH&XOWXUD(GXFDFLyL(VSRUWSHUODTXHV LQFRDH[SHGLHQWSHUDOD SULPHUD IDVH GH O DFWXDOLW]DFLy L DGDSWDFLy SDUFLDO GH OD 6HFFLy 3ULPHUD GH O ,QYHQWDUL *HQHUDO GHO 3DWULPRQL &XOWXUDO 9DOHQFLj HQ PDWqULD GH SDWULPRQL DUTXLWHFWzQLF L PHGLDPELHQWDOLV¶REULSHUtRGHG¶LQIRUPDFLyS~EOLFD 5HVROXFLyQ GH GH DEULO GH OD 'LUHFFLyQ *HQHUDO GH 3DWULPRQLR &XOWXUDO 9DOHQFLDQR \ 0XVHRV GH OD &RQVHOOHULD GH &XOWXUD (GXFDFLyQ \ 'HSRUWH SRU OD TXH VH LQFRD H[SHGLHQWH SDUD OD SULPHUD IDVH GH OD DFWXDOL]DFLyQ \ DGDSWDFLyQ SDUFLDO GH OD 6HFFLyQ 3ULPHUD GHO ,QYHQWDULR *HQHUDO GHO 3DWULPRQLR &XOWXUDO 9DOHQFLDQR HQ PDWHULD GH SDWULPRQLRDUTXLWHFWyQLFR\PHGLRDPELHQWDO\VHDEUHSHULRGRGHLQIRUPDFLyQSXEOLFD Núm. 5.503 / 02.05.2007 17958 HQ HO FDPSDQDU L SURGXw[HQ XQD OHFWXUD FRQIXVD VREUH O HVWUXFWXUD DUTXLWHFWzQLFD GH O HGLILFL %DVDW HQ HO &DWjOHJGH0RQXPHQWVL&RQMXQWVGHOD&RPXQLWDW9DOHQFLDQDL9DOqQFLD$UTXLWHFWXUDUHOLJLRVD /D,JOHVLD3DUURTXLDOGH6DQWD&DWDOLQD\6DQ$JXVWtQHVODLJOHVLDGHODQWLJXRFRQYHQWRGHIUDLOHVHUPLWDxRV GH6DQ$JXVWtQDVHQWDGRVHQ9DOHQFLDHQHOVLJOR;,,,(OFRQYHQWRFRQWDEDFRQXQFODXVWURMXQWRDODLJOHVLD RFXSDQGR HO MDUGtQ DFWXDO DG\DFHQWH FRQ GLHFLVpLV DUFDGDV SRU SDQGD (Q HO VLJOR ;9,, VH FRQVWUX\y RWUR FODXVWURKDFLDHOODGRQRUWH\HODQWHULRUVHHOHYyHQXQDSODQWD'XUDQWHOD*XHUUDGH,QGHSHQGHQFLDVLUYLy FRPRFXDUWHODODVWURSDVIUDQFHVDVHQ(OWHPSORIXHUHQRYDGRHQ7UDVODGHVDPRUWL]DFLyQGH ODV GHSHQGHQFLDV FRQYHQWXDOHV IXHURQ XWLOL]DGDV FRPR SUHVLGLR KDVWD VX GHUULER HQ TXHGDQGR ~QLFDPHQWHODLJOHVLDDELHUWDDOFXOWR/DLJOHVLDGHXQDVRODQDYHFRQFDSLOODVHQWUHFRQWUDIXHUWHVWLHQHXQ iEVLGHSROLJRQDOGHFLQFRODGRVFXELHUWRFRQEyYHGDGHFUXFHUtDHVWUHOODGDPLHQWUDVTXHORVVHLVWUDPRVGH ODQDYHORKDFHQFRQEyYHGDVGHFUXFHUtDVLPSOHHOWUDPRPiVFHUFDQRDOSUHVELWHULRHVGHPD\RUDQFKXUD\ VHFRUUHVSRQGHFRQGRVFDSLOODV3UHVHQWDFRURDOWRDORVSLHVHQHOTXHVHHQFXHQWUDOD~QLFDFODYHRULJLQDO (QVHDxDGLyXQUHYHVWLPLHQWREDUURFRTXHIXHUHSULVWLQDGRDSDUWLUGH'HHVSHFLDOUHOHYDQFLD HVHOLFRQRPHGLHYDOGHOD9LUJHQGH*UDFLDTXHDOEHUJDHVWDLJOHVLD /D SRUWDGD ODWHUDO GHELy UHDOL]DUVH GXUDQWH HO SULPHU WHUFLR GHO VLJOR ;9,, (VWi IODQTXHDGD SRU SDUHV GH FROXPQDV GyULFDV VREUH SHGHVWDOHV UHPDWDGD FRQ XQ IURQWyQ FXUYR SDUWLGR HQ OD SDUWH VXSHULRU XQD KRUQDFLQDHQWUHYROXWDVFRQODLPDJHQGHOVDQWRWLWXODUUHPDWDGDSRUXQIURQWyQWULDQJXODUSDUWLGR(Q VH HGLILFy XQ QXHYR FDPSDQDULR D FDUJR GHO DUTXLWHFWR /XLV )HUUHUHV HQ ODGULOOR TXH VHULD UHFXELHUWR FRQ XQDPRUIRORJtDJRWLFLVWDHQODLQWHUYHQFLyQGHSRVJXHUUD 7UDV OD *XHUUD &LYLO TXHGy PX\ DIHFWDGD SRU OR TXH VH SHQVy HQ VX GHUULER -DYLHU *RHUOLFK UHDOL]y XQD LQWHUYHQFLyQHQTXHOHGLRVXDVSHFWRDFWXDOGHGXGRVRKLVWRULFLVPRFRQDSODFDGRVGHSLHGUDYLHMD HQ HO SDUDPHQWR RULHQWDO IRUPDFLyQ GH GHSHQGHQFLDV EDMDV D ORV SLHV GHO iEVLGH L SURYLVLyQ GH QXHYD PRUIRORJtD JRWL]DQWH SDUD OD IDFKDGD PHULGLRQDO \ HO FDPSDQDULR /RV GHWDOOHV GHFRUDWLYRV \ ORV UHWDEORV QHRJyWLFRVIXHURQUHDOL]DGRVSRU-RVp-XVWR9LOODOED(VWDLQWHUYHQFLyQVHDFXVDHQODIDFKDGDDORVSLHV\HQ HOFDPSDQDULR\SURGXFHQXQDOHFWXUDFRQIXVDVREUHODHVWUXFWXUDDUTXLWHFWyQLFDGHOHGLILFLR%DVDGRHQHO &DWiORJRGH0RQXPHQWRV\&RQMXQWRVGHOD&RPXQLGDG9DOHQFLDQD\9DOHQFLD$UTXLWHFWXUDUHOLJLRVD 2EVHUYDFLRQV2EVHUYDFLRQHV 'HVSUpVGHWRWHVOHVDFWXDFLRQVUHDOLW]DGHV DOOODUJGHOD VHXDKLVWzULDGHVWDTXHQSHO VHXYDORUSDWULPRQLDO HOV HOHPHQWV UHODFLRQDWV DPE O HVWUXFWXUD RULJLQjULD PHGLHYDO GH O HGLILFL FRP VyQ OD JUDQ QDX DPE FLQF FDSHOOHV TXDGUDGHV HQWUH FRQWUDIRUWV L O DEVLV SROLJRQDO GH FLQF FRVWDWV 3HU WDQW QR pV GHVFDUWDEOH XQD UHVWDXUDFLyFUtWLFDGHOPRQXPHQWTXHSRVHHQFULVLHQWRWRHQSDUWOHVUHIRUPHVGHO6;; 7UDV WRGDV ODV DFWXDFLRQHV UHDOL]DGDV D OR ODUJR GH VX KLVWRULD GHVWDFDQ SRU VX YDORU SDWULPRQLDO ORV HOHPHQWRVUHODFLRQDGRVFRQODHVWUXFWXUDRULJLQDULDPHGLHYDOGHOHGLILFLRFRPRVRQODJUDQQDYHFRQFLQFR FDSLOODVFXDGUDGDVHQWUHFRQWUDIXHUWHV\HOiEVLGHSROLJRQDOGHFLQFRODGRV3RUWDQWRQRHVGHVFDUWDEOHXQD UHVWDXUDFLyQFUtWLFDGHOPRQXPHQWRTXHSRQJDHQFULVLVHQWRGRRHQSDUWHODVUHIRUPHVGHO6;; (QWRUQ(QWRUQ $QWHFHGHQWV DGPLQLVWUDWLXV OD GHOLPLWDFLy GH O HQWRUQ GH SURWHFFLy V DFXOO DO TXH GLVSRVD O $SWDW GH OD 'LVSRVLFLy 7UDQVLWzULD 3ULPHUD GH OD OOHL PRGLILFDGRUD GH OD (VWD GHOLPLWDFLy TXHGD UHFRQHJXGD DPE FDUjFWHU SURYLVLRQDO VHJRQV OD GHOLPLWDFLy FRQWLQJXGD HQ O DQQH[ GHO &DWjOHJ GH %pQV L (VSDLV 3URWHJLWV GHO 3*28 GH 9DOqQFLD GH G DFRUG DPE DOOz TXH V KD HVWDEOLW SHO ³&RQYHQL 0DUF GH &ROāODERUDFLyHQWUHOD*HQHUDOLWDW9DOHQFLDQDLO $MXQWDPHQWGH9DOqQFLDSHUDO'HVSOHJDPHQWL([HFXFLyGHO 3ODQHMDPHQW8UEDQtVWLFGHO&RQMXQW+LVWzULFGHOD&LXWDW´VXEVFULWHOGLDGHMXQ\GHLSXEOLFDWHQHO '2*9GH 2ULJHQLQWHUVHFFLyHQWUHDOLQHDFLyGUHWD&4XHYHGRLDOLQHDFLyVXGGH&2VFDSXQW$ 6HQWLW+RUDUL /tQLDGHOLPLWDGRUD/DOtQLDHVGLULJL[DO HVWUHFRUUHQWO DOLQHDFLyVXGGHOFDUUHU2VFDLQFRUSRUDODSDUFHOāOD GHO¶LOODFDGDVWUDOFUHXDHOFDUUHU1WUD6HQ\RUDGH*UjFLDILQVDODWUREDGDDPEO¶LOODFDGDVWUDOQ~P GHODTXHLQFRUSRUDODSDUFHOāOD&UHXDO DYLQJXGDEDUyGH&jUFHULHOFDUUHU6DQW9LFHQWLFRQWtQXD FDSDOVXGILQVDO DOLQHDFLyQRUGGHOFDUUHU&REHUWGH6DQW3DXFUHXDHOFDUUHULFRQWLQXDSHUODIDW[DGDGH ODSDUFHOāODGHO¶LOODFDGDVWUDOQ~PTXHGyQDDODSODoDGH6DQW$JXVWt(VGLULJL[DO DOLQHDFLyVXG GHOFDUUHU*XLOOHPGH&DVWURSHUODTXHFRQWLQXDFDSDO RHVWWUDYHVVDQWHOFDUUHU6DQW9LFHQW0jUWLU&UHXD HOFDUUHU&HUYDQWHVLUHFRUUHO DOLQHDFLyQRUGGHO¶LOODGHFDVHV*LUDDQRUGLFUHXDHOFDUUHU*XLOOHPGH &DVWUR L HV GLULJL[ FDS D O RULJHQ SHU O DOLQHDFLy HVWH GHO FDUUHU 4XHYHGR LQFRUSRUDQW G HL[D IRUPD O¶LOOD FDGDVWUDOQ~P $QWHFHGHQWHVDGPLQLVWUDWLYRVODGHOLPLWDFLyQGHOHQWRUQRGHSURWHFFLyQVHDFRJHDORGLVSXHVWRHQHO$SWGR GHOD'LVSRVLFLyQ7UDQVLWRULD3ULPHUDGHODOH\PRGLILFDGRUDGHOD(VWDGHOLPLWDFLyQTXHGD $11(;,9$1(;2,9 GH 5HVROXFLyGHG DEULOGHOD'LUHFFLy*HQHUDOGH3DWULPRQL&XOWXUDO9DOHQFLjL0XVHXVGHOD&RQVHOOHULDGH&XOWXUD(GXFDFLyL(VSRUWSHUODTXHV LQFRDH[SHGLHQWSHUDOD SULPHUD IDVH GH O DFWXDOLW]DFLy L DGDSWDFLy SDUFLDO GH OD 6HFFLy 3ULPHUD GH O ,QYHQWDUL *HQHUDO GHO 3DWULPRQL &XOWXUDO 9DOHQFLj HQ PDWqULD GH SDWULPRQL DUTXLWHFWzQLF L PHGLDPELHQWDOLV¶REULSHUtRGHG¶LQIRUPDFLyS~EOLFD 5HVROXFLyQ GH GH DEULO GH OD 'LUHFFLyQ *HQHUDO GH 3DWULPRQLR &XOWXUDO 9DOHQFLDQR \ 0XVHRV GH OD &RQVHOOHULD GH &XOWXUD (GXFDFLyQ \ 'HSRUWH SRU OD TXH VH LQFRD H[SHGLHQWH SDUD OD SULPHUD IDVH GH OD DFWXDOL]DFLyQ \ DGDSWDFLyQ SDUFLDO GH OD 6HFFLyQ 3ULPHUD GHO ,QYHQWDULR *HQHUDO GHO 3DWULPRQLR &XOWXUDO 9DOHQFLDQR HQ PDWHULD GH SDWULPRQLRDUTXLWHFWyQLFR\PHGLRDPELHQWDO\VHDEUHSHULRGRGHLQIRUPDFLyQSXEOLFD Núm. 5.503 / 02.05.2007 17959 UHFRQRFLGDFRQFDUiFWHUSURYLVLRQDOVHJ~QODGHOLPLWDFLyQFRQWHQLGDHQHO$QH[RGHO&DWiORJRGH%LHQHV\ (VSDFLRV3URWHJLGRVGHO3*28GH9DOqQFLDGHFRQDUUHJORDORHVWDEOHFLGRSRUHO³&RQYHQLR0DUFRGH &RODERUDFLyQHQWUHOD*HQHUDOLWDW9DOHQFLDQD\HO$\XQWDPLHQWR GH 9DOHQFLD SDUD HO 'HVDUUROOR \ (MHFXFLyQ GHO 3ODQHDPLHQWR 8UEDQtVWLFR GHO &RQMXQWR +LVWyULFR GH OD &LXGDG´ VXVFULWR HO GtD GH MXQLR GH \ SXEOLFDGRHQHO'2*9GH 2ULJHQLQWHUVHFFLyQHQWUHDOLQHDFLyQGHUHFKD&4XHYHGR\DOLQHDFLyQVXUGHODFDOOH+XHVFDSXQWR³$´ 6HQWLGR+RUDULR /tQHD GHOLPLWDGRUD OD OtQHD VH GLULJH DO HVWH UHFRUULHQGR OD DOLQHDFLyQ VXU GH OD FDOOH +XHVFD LQFRUSRUD OD SDUFHODGHODPDQ]DQDFDWDVWUDOFUX]DODFDOOH1XHVWUD6HxRUDGH*UDFLDKDVWDHOHQFXHQWURFRQOD PDQ]DQDFDWDVWUDOGHODTXHLQFRUSRUDODSDUFHOD&UX]DODDYHQLGD%DUyQGH&DUFHU\ODFDOOH6DQ 9LFHQWH\FRQWLQXDKDFLDHOVXUKDVWDODDOLQHDFLyQQRUWHGHODFDOOH&REHUWL]RGH6DQ3DEORFUX]DODFDOOH\ FRQWLQ~D SRU OD IDFKDGD GH OD SDUFHOD GH OD PDQ]DQD FDWDVWUDO Q UHFD\HQWH D OD SOD]D GH 6DQ $JXVWtQ 6H GLULJH D OD DOLQHDFLyQ VXU GH OD FDOOH *XLOOHP GH &DVWUR SRU OD TXH FRQWLQ~D KDFLD HO RHVWH DWUDYHVDQGRODFDOOH6DQ9LFHQWH0iUWLU&UX]DODFDOOH&HUYDQWHV\UHFRUUHODDOLQHDFLyQQRUWHGHODPDQ]DQD *LUDDQRUWH\FUX]DODFDOOH*XLOOHPGH&DVWUR\VHGLULJHKDFLDHORULJHQSRUODDOLQHDFLyQHVWHGHOD FDOOH4XHYHGRLQFRUSRUDQGRGHHVDIRUPDODPDQ]DQDFDWDVWUDOQ $11(;,9$1(;2,9 GH 5HVROXFLyGHG DEULOGHOD'LUHFFLy*HQHUDOGH3DWULPRQL&XOWXUDO9DOHQFLjL0XVHXVGHOD&RQVHOOHULDGH&XOWXUD(GXFDFLyL(VSRUWSHUODTXHV LQFRDH[SHGLHQWSHUDOD SULPHUD IDVH GH O DFWXDOLW]DFLy L DGDSWDFLy SDUFLDO GH OD 6HFFLy 3ULPHUD GH O ,QYHQWDUL *HQHUDO GHO 3DWULPRQL &XOWXUDO 9DOHQFLj HQ PDWqULD GH SDWULPRQL DUTXLWHFWzQLF L PHGLDPELHQWDOLV¶REULSHUtRGHG¶LQIRUPDFLyS~EOLFD 5HVROXFLyQ GH GH DEULO GH OD 'LUHFFLyQ *HQHUDO GH 3DWULPRQLR &XOWXUDO 9DOHQFLDQR \ 0XVHRV GH OD &RQVHOOHULD GH &XOWXUD (GXFDFLyQ \ 'HSRUWH SRU OD TXH VH LQFRD H[SHGLHQWH SDUD OD SULPHUD IDVH GH OD DFWXDOL]DFLyQ \ DGDSWDFLyQ SDUFLDO GH OD 6HFFLyQ 3ULPHUD GHO ,QYHQWDULR *HQHUDO GHO 3DWULPRQLR &XOWXUDO 9DOHQFLDQR HQ PDWHULD GH SDWULPRQLRDUTXLWHFWyQLFR\PHGLRDPELHQWDO\VHDEUHSHULRGRGHLQIRUPDFLyQSXEOLFD Núm. 5.503 / 02.05.2007 17960 %e'¶,17(5e6&8/785$/±(6*/e6,$'(6$17$*867Ë(6*/e6,$3$55248,$/'(6$17$ &$7(5,1$,6$17$*867Ë9$/Ê1&,$02180(17 %,(1'(,17(5e6&8/785$/±,*/(6,$'(6$1$*867Ë1,*/(6,$3$55248,$/'(6$17$&$7$/,1$ <6$1$*867Ë19$/(1&,$02180(172 $11(;,9$1(;2,9 5HVROXFLyGHG DEULOGHOD'LUHFFLy*HQHUDOGH3DWULPRQL&XOWXUDO9DOHQFLjL0XVHXVGHOD&RQVHOOHULDGH&XOWXUD(GXFDFLyL(VSRUWSHUODTXHV LQFRD H[SHGLHQWSHUDODSULPHUDIDVHGHO DFWXDOLW]DFLyLDGDSWDFLy SDUFLDOGHOD6HFFLy3ULPHUDGHO ,QYHQWDUL*HQHUDOGHO3DWULPRQL&XOWXUDO9DOHQFLjHQPDWqULDGH SDWULPRQLDUTXLWHFWzQLFLPHGLDPELHQWDOLV¶REULSHUtRGHG¶LQIRUPDFLyS~EOLFD 5HVROXFLyQGHGHDEULOGHOD'LUHFFLyQ*HQHUDOGH3DWULPRQLR&XOWXUDO9DOHQFLDQR\0XVHRVGHOD&RQVHOOHULDGH&XOWXUD(GXFDFLyQ\'HSRUWHSRUOD TXH VH LQFRD H[SHGLHQWH SDUD OD SULPHUD IDVH GH OD DFWXDOL]DFLyQ \ DGDSWDFLyQ SDUFLDO GH OD 6HFFLyQ 3ULPHUD GHO ,QYHQWDULR *HQHUDO GHO 3DWULPRQLR &XOWXUDO 9DOHQFLDQRHQPDWHULDGHSDWULPRQLRDUTXLWHFWyQLFR\PHGLRDPELHQWDO\VHDEUHSHULRGRGHLQIRUPDFLyQSXEOLFD GH Núm. 5.503 / 02.05.2007 17961 %e'¶,17(5e6&8/785$/±0(5&$7&(175$/9$/Ê1&,$02180(17 %,(1'(,17(5e6&8/785$/±0(5&$'2&(175$/9$/(1&,$02180(172 'HQRPLQDFLy'HQRPLQDFLyQ 3ULQFLSDO3ULQFLSDO 0HUFDW&HQWUDO 0HUFDGR&HQWUDO /RFDOL]DFLy/RFDOL]DFLyQ 3URYtQFLD3URYLQFLD9DOqQFLD &RPDUFD&RPDUFDO¶+RUWD 0XQLFLSL0XQLFLSLR9DOqQFLD 8ELFDFLy8ELFDFLyQ3ODoDGHO0HUFDW 5HIHUqFLD&DGDVWUDO5HIHUHQFLD&DWDVWUDO ,OOD0DQ]DQD3DUFHOāOD3DUFHOD \ $QWHFHGHQWV-XUtGLFV$QWHFHGHQWHV-XUtGLFRV ,QFRDFLy,QFRDFLyQ 3XEOLFDFLyGHODLQFRDFLy3XEOLFDFLyQGHODLQFRDFLyQ%2( 'HVFULSFLy'HVFULSFLyQ 3DUWV,QWHJUDQWV3DUWHV,QWHJUDQWHV − (O 0HUFDW SUzSLDPHQW GLW FRQVWLWXwW SHO UHFLQWH FHQWUDO L OD SHVFDWHULD DPE FDGD XQD GH OHV VHXHV GHSHQGqQFLHV (O 0HUFDGR SURSLDPHQWH GLFKR FRQVWLWXLGR SRU HO UHFLQWR FHQWUDO \ OD SHVFDGHUtD FRQ − − FDGDXQDGHVXVGHSHQGHQFLDV / HGLILFLGHOD7LQqQFLDG $OFDOGLD(OHGLILFLRGHOD7HQHQFLDGH$OFDOGtD (OV GRV SDYHOORQV TXH IODQTXHJHQ O DFFpV SULQFLSDO HQ OD 3ODoD GHO 0HUFDW /RV GRV SDEHOORQHV TXH − 5HL[HULD H[WHULRU L EDUDQHV TXH GHOLPLWHQ HO UHFLQWH 5HMHUtD H[WHULRU \ DQWHSHFKRV TXH GHOLPLWDQ HO IODQTXHDQHODFFHVRSULQFLSDOHQOD3OD]DGHO0HUFDGR UHFLQWR 'HVFULSFLy*HQHUDO'HVFULSFLyQ*HQHUDO (OSURMHFWHGDWDWHQYDVHUDWRUJDWD)UDQFLVFR*XjUGLD9LDOL$OHMDQGUR6ROHUL0DFK$SDUWLUGH ODGLUHFFLyGHOHVREUHVYDSDVVDUD(QULTXH9LHGPDHVYDLQDXJXUDUO¶DQ\ 6¶DOoDHQXQDVXSHUItFLHGHPHWUHVTXDGUDWV3UHVHQWDXQDSODQWDLUUHJXODUGLYLGLGDHQGRVHVSDLVSHU XQ FRVWDW HO PHUFDW JHQHUDO L SHU XQ DOWUH OD SHVFDWHULD /D SHVFDWHULD HQ OD ]RQD RHVW pV GH SODQWD RFWRJRQDODPEXQD F~SXOD HOāOtSWLFD /D ]RQD JHQHUDO GHO PHUFDW DGRSWD XQD VROXFLy EDVLOLFDO HQ IRUPD GH FUHXOODWLQDTXHHVFRPSOHWDDPEDOWUHVQDXVVHFXQGjULHVSDUDOāOHOHVDODGHPDMRUORQJLWXGDGDSWDQWVHD OD IRUPD LUUHJXODU GHO VRODU HQ OD LQWHUVHFFLy GH OD TXDO V DOoD XQD F~SXOD / HVWUXFWXUD HVWj UHDOLW]DGD HQ IHUUR(OVWDQFDPHQWVHVGHVHQYROXSHQVREUHXQDEDVHGHSHGUDDPEXQVzFROUHYHVWLWGHWDXOHOOHWVGHOTXDO DUUDQTXHQ OHV IXVWHULHV PHWjOāOLTXHV DPE XQ SHUILO GH SHGUD OD XQLy GHO TXDO HV UHDOLW]D DPE IjEULFD GH UDMRODDPEUHYHVWLPHQWGHWDXOHOOHWVGHFRUDWVDPEUHIOH[RVPHWjOāOLFV (QODSODoDGHO0HUFDWHVWUREHQGRVSDYHOORQVGHSODQWDUHFWDQJXODUUHDOLW]DWVHQUDMRODDPEDSOLFDFLRQVGH SHGUDLFHUjPLFDGHFRUDGD(OSDYHOOyGHOD7LQqQFLDG $OFDOGLDHQODIDoDQDSRVWHULRUHVWjGLYLGLWHQSODQWD EDL[D L SLV VXSHULRU L HVWj UHDOLW]DW HQ SHGUD (O PHUFDW pV G HVWLO PRGHUQLVWD HQFDUD TXH LQFORX HOHPHQWV KLVWRULFLVWHV HQ HOV SDYHOORQV TXH IODQTXHJHQ OD IDoDQD SULQFLSDO PHQWUH TXH HO SDYHOOy GH OD 7LQqQFLD G $OFDOGLDVHJXLULDPpVHOFRUUHQWQRXFHQWLVWD(QO¶DFWXDOLWDWHVWjHQSOHSURFpVGHUHKDELOLWDFLyLQWHJUDOTXH FRPSOHWDUjODGHVHQYROXSDGDDUDIDXQDGqFDGDHQO¶LQWHULRUGHOD3HVFDWHULD'HVFULSFLyHODERUDGDDSDUWLU EjVLFDPHQW GH µ(O 0HUFDW &HQWUDO GH 9DOqQFLD )RUPDFLy L HYROXFLy GH O HQWRUQ KLVWzULF GHO 0HUFDW GH - (VWHEDQ &KDSDSUtD L / 3DODLD 3pUH] (O 0HUFDW GH 9DOqQFLD PLO DQ\V G KLVWzULD GH - / &RUEtQ )HUUHU L / $UTXLWHFWXUDGHO (FOHFWLFLVPHD9DOqQFLDGH'%HQLWR*RHUOLFK (O SUR\HFWR IHFKDGR HQ IXH RWRUJDGR D )UDQFLVFR *XDUGLD 9LDO \ $OHMDQGUR 6ROHU \ 0DFK $ SDUWLU GH ODGLUHFFLyQGHODVREUDVSDVyD(QULTXH9LHGPDLQDXJXUiQGRVHHQ (Q XQD VXSHUILFLH GH PHWURV FXDGUDGRV VH OHYDQWD HVWH PHUFDGR 3UHVHQWD XQD SODQWD LUUHJXODU GLYLGLGDHQGRVHVSDFLRVSRUXQODGRHOPHUFDGRJHQHUDO\SRURWURODSHVFDGHUtD/DSHVFDGHUtDHQOD]RQD RHVWH HV GH SODQWD RFWRJRQDO FRQ XQD F~SXOD HOtSWLFD /D ]RQD JHQHUDO GHO PHUFDGR DGRSWD XQD VROXFLyQ $11(;,9$1(;2,9 GH 5HVROXFLyGHG DEULOGHOD'LUHFFLy*HQHUDOGH3DWULPRQL&XOWXUDO9DOHQFLjL0XVHXVGHOD&RQVHOOHULDGH&XOWXUD(GXFDFLyL(VSRUWSHUODTXHV LQFRDH[SHGLHQWSHUDOD SULPHUD IDVH GH O DFWXDOLW]DFLy L DGDSWDFLy SDUFLDO GH OD 6HFFLy 3ULPHUD GH O ,QYHQWDUL *HQHUDO GHO 3DWULPRQL &XOWXUDO 9DOHQFLj HQ PDWqULD GH SDWULPRQL DUTXLWHFWzQLF L PHGLDPELHQWDOLV¶REULSHUtRGHG¶LQIRUPDFLyS~EOLFD 5HVROXFLyQ GH GH DEULO GH OD 'LUHFFLyQ *HQHUDO GH 3DWULPRQLR &XOWXUDO 9DOHQFLDQR \ 0XVHRV GH OD &RQVHOOHULD GH &XOWXUD (GXFDFLyQ \ 'HSRUWH SRU OD TXH VH LQFRD H[SHGLHQWH SDUD OD SULPHUD IDVH GH OD DFWXDOL]DFLyQ \ DGDSWDFLyQ SDUFLDO GH OD 6HFFLyQ 3ULPHUD GHO ,QYHQWDULR *HQHUDO GHO 3DWULPRQLR &XOWXUDO 9DOHQFLDQR HQ PDWHULD GH SDWULPRQLRDUTXLWHFWyQLFR\PHGLRDPELHQWDO\VHDEUHSHULRGRGHLQIRUPDFLyQSXEOLFD Núm. 5.503 / 02.05.2007 17962 EDVLOLFDO HQ IRUPD GH FUX] ODWLQD TXH VH FRPSOHWD FRQ RWUDV QDYHV VHFXQGDULDV SDUDOHODV D OD GH PD\RU ORQJLWXG DGDSWiQGRVH D OD IRUPD LUUHJXODU GHO VRODU HQ FX\D LQWHUVHFFLyQ VH OHYDQWD XQD F~SXOD /D HVWUXFWXUDHVWiUHDOL]DGDHQKLHUUR/RVFHUUDPLHQWRVVHGHVDUUROODQVREUHXQDEDVHGHSLHGUDFRQXQ]yFDOR UHYHVWLGR GH D]XOHMRV GHO TXH DUUDQFDQ ODV FDUSLQWHUtDV PHWiOLFDV FRQ XQ SHUILO GH SLHGUD FX\D XQLyQ VH UHDOL]DFRQIiEULFDGHODGULOORFRQUHYHVWLPLHQWRGHD]XOHMRVGHFRUDGRVFRQUHIOHMRVPHWiOLFRV (Q OD SOD]D GHO 0HUFDGR VH HQFXHQWUDQ GRV SDEHOORQHV GH SODQWD UHFWDQJXODU UHDOL]DGRV HQ ODGULOOR FRQ DSOLFDFLRQHVGHSLHGUD\FHUiPLFDGHFRUDGD(OSDEHOOyQGHOD7HQHQFLDGH$OFDOGtDHQ ODIDFKDGDWUDVHUD HVWiGLYLGLGRHQSODQWDEDMD\SLVRVXSHULRU\HVWiUHDOL]DGR HQSLHGUD(OPHUFDGRHVGHHVWLORPRGHUQLVWD DXQTXHLQFOX\HHOHPHQWRVKLVWRULFLVWDVHQORVSDEHOORQHVTXHIODQTXHDQODIDFKDGDSULQFLSDOPLHQWUDVTXHHO SDEHOOyQ GH OD WHQHQFLD GH DOFDOGtD VHJXLUtD PiV OD FRUULHQWH QRXFHQWLVWD (Q OD DFWXDOLGDG HVWi HQ SOHQR SURFHVR GH UHKDELOLWDFLyQ LQWHJUDO TXH FRPSOHWDUi OD GHVDUUROODGD KDUi XQD GpFDGD HQ HO LQWHULRU GH OD 3HVFDGHUtD 'HVFULSFLyQ HODERUDGD D SDUWLU EiVLFDPHQWH GH (O 0HUFDGR &HQWUDO GH 9DOHQFLD )RUPDFLyQ \ HYROXFLyQ GHO HQWRUQR KLVWyULFR GHO 0HUFDGR GH - (VWHEDQ &KDSDSUtD \ / 3DODLD 3pUH] (O 0HUFDGR GH 9DOHQFLDPLODxRVGHKLVWRULDGH-/&RUEtQ)HUUHU\/D$UTXLWHFWXUDGHO(FOHFWLFLVPRHQ9DOHQFLDGH' %HQLWR*RHUOLFK 2EVHUYDFLRQV2EVHUYDFLRQHV (QWRUQ(QWRUQ $QWHFHGHQWV DGPLQLVWUDWLXV OD GHOLPLWDFLy GH O HQWRUQ GH SURWHFFLy V DFXOO DO TXH GLVSRVD O $SWDW GH OD 'LVSRVLFLy 7UDQVLWzULD 3ULPHUD GH OD OOHL PRGLILFDGRUD GH OD (VWD GHOLPLWDFLy TXHGD UHFRQHJXGD DPE FDUjFWHU SURYLVLRQDO VHJRQV OD GHOLPLWDFLy FRQWLQJXGD HQ OD UHVROXFLy GH G RFWXEUH GH SXEOLFDGDHQHO'2*9GHGDWD 2ULJHQ&DQWyGHO¶LOODGHFDVHVFDGDVWUDOTXHGyQDDOD3ODoDGHO0HUFDWLDOFDUUHUGHOV9DOHULROD 6HQWLW$QWLKRUDUL /tQLD GHOLPLWDGRUD /D OtQLD V HVWpQ SHO FDUUHU GHOV 9DOHULROD ILQV DO FDUUHU GH OHV %RWHOOHV FUHXDQWOD L LQFRUSRUDQWOHVSDUFHOāOHVLGHO¶LOODGHFDVHVLOHVLGHOD7UDYHVVDHOFDUUHU GH%HOOXJDLLQFRUSRUDO¶LOODGHFDVHVLHVSURORQJDILQVDODVHXDLQWHUVHFFLyDPEHOFDUUHUGHGRQ-XDQ GH 9LODUUDVD *LUD SHU HVWD ILQV DO FDUUHU GH OHV 5HL[HV TXH UHFRUUH HQ OD VHXD WRWDOLWDW 7UDYHVVD O¶LOOD GH FDVHV SHU GDUUHUH GH OHV SDUFHOāOHV L $ O HL[LGD UHFRUUH SDUW GHO FDUUHU GH 6DQW $QWRQL L V LQWURGXw[SHUO¶LOODGHFDVHVLQFORHQWODSDUFHOāODHL[LQWDO DYLQJXGDGHOEDUyGH&jUFHU&UHXDOD UHIHULGDDYLQJXGDLSHQHWUDHQO¶LOODGHFDVHVSHUODPLWJHUDHQWUHOHVSDUFHOāOHVLLHL[LQWHQWUH ODSDUFHOāODL5HFRUUHHOFDUUHUGHO3RHWD/ORPEDUWILQVDOVHXHQFUHXDPHQWDPE0DOORUTXLQVLFRQWLQXD SHUHVWD~OWLPDILQVDODVHXDFRQIOXqQFLDDPEHOFDUUHUGHO3RSXOTXHVHJXL[DOVHXWRUQILQVDOD3ODoDGHOD 0HUFp 7UDYHVVD OD 3ODoD GH OD 0HUFp LQFORHQW tQWHJUD O¶LOOD GH FDVHV ILQV DO FDUUHU )ODVVDGHUV WUDYHVVDGHVSUpVO DYLQJXGDGH0DUtD&ULVWLQDLFUHXDO¶LOODGHFDVHVSHUGDUUHUHGHOHVSDUFHOāOHVL 7UDYHVVDDOFDUUHU6DQW)HUUDQILQV DODIDoDQDGHOD SDUFHOāODL GLVFRUUHQW SHU OHV SRVWHULRUV GH OHV SDUFHOāOHVLHL[LQWSHOFDUUHUGHOV0DQ\DQVLJLUDQWFDSDOFDUUHU7UHQFKTXHUHFRUUH ILQVDOVHXHQFUHXDPHQWDPEHOFDUUHUGHOV'UHWV3XMDSHOFDUUHUGHOV'UHWVOD3ODoDGHO'RFWRU&ROODGRHO FDUUHU GH OD /ORWMD OD 3ODoD GH OD &RPSDQ\LD L HO FDUUHU GH OHV 'DQVHV *LUD SHO FDUUHU GHOV &DL[HUV LQFRUSRUDQWWRWDO¶LOODGHFDVHVLGLVFRUUHSHUODIDoDQDGHODSDUFHOāODILQVDOD3ODoDGHO0HUFDWTXH WUDYHVVDILQVHOSXQWG RULJHQ $QWHFHGHQWHVDGPLQLVWUDWLYRVODGHOLPLWDFLyQGHOHQWRUQRGHSURWHFFLyQVHDFRJHDORGLVSXHVWRHQHO$SWGR GHOD'LVSRVLFLyQ7UDQVLWRULD3ULPHUDGHODOH\PRGLILFDGRUDGHOD(VWDGHOLPLWDFLyQTXHGD UHFRQRFLGD FRQ FDUiFWHU SURYLVLRQDO VHJ~Q OD GHOLPLWDFLyQ FRQWHQLGD HQ OD UHVROXFLyQ GH GH RFWXEUH GH SXEOLFDGDHQHO'2*9GHIHFKD 2ULJHQ(VTXLQDGHODPDQ]DQDFDWDVWUDOUHFD\HQWHDOD3OD]DGHO0HUFDGR\DODFDOOH9DOHULROD 6HQWLGR$QWLKRUDULR /tQHD GHOLPLWDGRUD /D OtQHD VH H[WLHQGH SRU OD FDOOH 9DOHULROD KDVWD OD FDOOH %RWHOODV FUX]iQGROD H LQFRUSRUDQGRODVSDUFHODV\GHODPDQ]DQD\ODV\GHOD$WUDYLHVDODFDOOH %HOOXJD H LQFRUSRUD OD PDQ]DQD \ VH SURORQJD KDVWD VX LQWHUVHFFLyQ FRQ OD FDOOH 'RQ -XDQ GH 9LODUUDVD*LUDSRUpVWDKDVWDODFDOOH5HMDV TXH UHFRUUH HQ VX WRWDOLGDG $WUDYLHVD OD PDQ]DQD SRU GHWUiV GH ODV SDUFHODV \ $ OD VDOLGD UHFRUUH SDUWH GH OD FDOOH 6DQ $QWRQLR \ VH LQWURGXFH SRU OD PDQ]DQDLQFOX\HQGRODSDUFHODVDOLHQGRDOD$YHQLGD%DUyQGH&iUFHU&UX]DODUHIHULGD$YHQLGD\ SHQHWUDHQODPDQ]DQDSRUODPHGLDQHUDHQWUHODVSDUFHODV\\VDOLHQGRHQWUHODSDUFHOD\ 5HFRUUH OD FDOOH 3RHWD /ORPEDUW KDVWD VX FUXFH FRQ 0DOORUTXLQV \ FRQWLQ~D SRU pVWD ~OWLPD KDVWD VX FRQIOXHQFLD FRQ OD FDOOH 3RSXO TXH VLJXH D VX YH] KDVWD OD 3OD]D GH OD 0HUFHG $WUDYLHVD OD 3OD]D GH OD 0HUFHG LQFOX\HQGR tQWHJUD OD PDQ]DQD KDVWD OD FDOOH )ODVDGHUV DWUDYLHVD GHVSXpV OD $YHQLGD GH 0DUtD &ULVWLQD \ FUX]D OD PDQ]DQD SRU GHWUiV GH ODV SDUFHODV \ $WUDYLHVD D OD FDOOH 6DQ )HUQDQGRKDVWDODIDFKDGDGHODSDUFHOD\GLVFXUULHQGRSRUODVWUDVHUDVGHODVSDUFHODV $11(;,9$1(;2,9 GH 5HVROXFLyGHG DEULOGHOD'LUHFFLy*HQHUDOGH3DWULPRQL&XOWXUDO9DOHQFLjL0XVHXVGHOD&RQVHOOHULDGH&XOWXUD(GXFDFLyL(VSRUWSHUODTXHV LQFRDH[SHGLHQWSHUDOD SULPHUD IDVH GH O DFWXDOLW]DFLy L DGDSWDFLy SDUFLDO GH OD 6HFFLy 3ULPHUD GH O ,QYHQWDUL *HQHUDO GHO 3DWULPRQL &XOWXUDO 9DOHQFLj HQ PDWqULD GH SDWULPRQL DUTXLWHFWzQLF L PHGLDPELHQWDOLV¶REULSHUtRGHG¶LQIRUPDFLyS~EOLFD 5HVROXFLyQ GH GH DEULO GH OD 'LUHFFLyQ *HQHUDO GH 3DWULPRQLR &XOWXUDO 9DOHQFLDQR \ 0XVHRV GH OD &RQVHOOHULD GH &XOWXUD (GXFDFLyQ \ 'HSRUWH SRU OD TXH VH LQFRD H[SHGLHQWH SDUD OD SULPHUD IDVH GH OD DFWXDOL]DFLyQ \ DGDSWDFLyQ SDUFLDO GH OD 6HFFLyQ 3ULPHUD GHO ,QYHQWDULR *HQHUDO GHO 3DWULPRQLR &XOWXUDO 9DOHQFLDQR HQ PDWHULD GH SDWULPRQLRDUTXLWHFWyQLFR\PHGLRDPELHQWDO\VHDEUHSHULRGRGHLQIRUPDFLyQSXEOLFD Núm. 5.503 / 02.05.2007 17963 \VDOLHQGRSRUODFDOOH&HUUDMHURV\JLUDQGRKDFLDODFDOOH7UHQFKTXHUHFRUUHKDVWDVXFUXFHFRQODGH ORV'HUHFKRV6XEHSRUODFDOOHGHORV'HUHFKRVOD3OD]DGHO'RFWRU&ROODGRODFDOOHGHOD/RQMDOD3OD]DGH OD &RPSDxtD \ OD FDOOH GH ODV 'DQ]DV *LUD SRU OD FDOOH &DMHURV LQFRUSRUDQGR WRGD OD PDQ]DQD \ GLVFXUUHSRUODIDFKDGDGHODSDUFHODKDVWDOD3OD]DGHO0HUFDGRTXHDWUDYLHVDKDVWDDOSXQWRGHRULJHQ $11(;,9$1(;2,9 GH 5HVROXFLyGHG DEULOGHOD'LUHFFLy*HQHUDOGH3DWULPRQL&XOWXUDO9DOHQFLjL0XVHXVGHOD&RQVHOOHULDGH&XOWXUD(GXFDFLyL(VSRUWSHUODTXHV LQFRDH[SHGLHQWSHUDOD SULPHUD IDVH GH O DFWXDOLW]DFLy L DGDSWDFLy SDUFLDO GH OD 6HFFLy 3ULPHUD GH O ,QYHQWDUL *HQHUDO GHO 3DWULPRQL &XOWXUDO 9DOHQFLj HQ PDWqULD GH SDWULPRQL DUTXLWHFWzQLF L PHGLDPELHQWDOLV¶REULSHUtRGHG¶LQIRUPDFLyS~EOLFD 5HVROXFLyQ GH GH DEULO GH OD 'LUHFFLyQ *HQHUDO GH 3DWULPRQLR &XOWXUDO 9DOHQFLDQR \ 0XVHRV GH OD &RQVHOOHULD GH &XOWXUD (GXFDFLyQ \ 'HSRUWH SRU OD TXH VH LQFRD H[SHGLHQWH SDUD OD SULPHUD IDVH GH OD DFWXDOL]DFLyQ \ DGDSWDFLyQ SDUFLDO GH OD 6HFFLyQ 3ULPHUD GHO ,QYHQWDULR *HQHUDO GHO 3DWULPRQLR &XOWXUDO 9DOHQFLDQR HQ PDWHULD GH SDWULPRQLRDUTXLWHFWyQLFR\PHGLRDPELHQWDO\VHDEUHSHULRGRGHLQIRUPDFLyQSXEOLFD Núm. 5.503 / 02.05.2007 17964 %e'¶,17(5e6&8/785$/±0(5&$7&(175$/9$/Ê1&,$02180(17 %,(1'(,17(5e6&8/785$/±0(5&$'2&(175$/9$/(1&,$02180(172 $11(;,9$1(;2,9 GH 5HVROXFLy GH G DEULO GH OD 'LUHFFLy *HQHUDO GH 3DWULPRQL &XOWXUDO 9DOHQFLj L 0XVHXV GH OD &RQVHOOHULD GH &XOWXUD (GXFDFLy L (VSRUW SHU OD TXH V LQFRDH[SHGLHQWSHUDODSULPHUDIDVHGHO DFWXDOLW]DFLyLDGDSWDFLySDUFLDOGHOD6HFFLy3ULPHUDGHO ,QYHQWDUL*HQHUDOGHO3DWULPRQL&XOWXUDO9DOHQFLjHQ PDWqULDGHSDWULPRQLDUTXLWHFWzQLFLPHGLDPELHQWDOLV¶REULSHUtRGHG¶LQIRUPDFLyS~EOLFD 5HVROXFLyQGHGHDEULOGHOD'LUHFFLyQ*HQHUDOGH3DWULPRQLR&XOWXUDO9DOHQFLDQR\0XVHRVGHOD&RQVHOOHULDGH&XOWXUD(GXFDFLyQ\'HSRUWHSRUODTXHVH LQFRDH[SHGLHQWHSDUDODSULPHUDIDVHGHODDFWXDOL]DFLyQ\DGDSWDFLyQSDUFLDOGHOD6HFFLyQ3ULPHUDGHO,QYHQWDULR*HQHUDOGHO3DWULPRQLR&XOWXUDO9DOHQFLDQRHQPDWHULD GHSDWULPRQLRDUTXLWHFWyQLFR\PHGLRDPELHQWDO\VHDEUHSHULRGRGHLQIRUPDFLyQSXEOLFD Núm. 5.503 / 02.05.2007 17965 %e'¶,17(5e6&8/785$/±3$/$8'(/0$548e6'(&$0322'(/6&207(6'(%(5%('(/ 9$/Ê1&,$02180(17 %,(1'(,17(5e6&8/785$/±3$/$&,2'(/0$548e6'(&$0322'(/26&21'(6'(%(5%('(/ 9$/(1&,$02180(172 'HQRPLQDFLy'HQRPLQDFLyQ 3ULQFLSDO3ULQFLSDO 3DODXGHO0DUTXpVGH&DPSRRGHOV%HUEHGHO 3DODFLRGHO0DUTXpVGH&DPSRRGHORV%HUEHGHO $FFHVzULD$FFHVRULD 0XVHXGHOD&LXWDW 0XVHRGHOD&LXGDG /RFDOL]DFLy/RFDOL]DFLyQ 3URYtQFLD3URYLQFLD9DOqQFLD &RPDUFD&RPDUFDO¶+RUWD 0XQLFLSL0XQLFLSLR9DOqQFLD 8ELFDFLy8ELFDFLyQ3ODoDGHO¶$UTXHELVEH 5HIHUHQFLD&DGDVWUDO5HIHUHQFLD&DWDVWUDO ,OOD0DQ]DQD3DUFHOāOD3DUFHOD $QWHFHGHQWV-XUtGLFV$QWHFHGHQWHV-XUtGLFRV ,QFRDFLy,QFRDFLyQ 3XEOLFDFLyGHODLQFRDFLy3XEOLFDFLyQGHODLQFRDFLyQ%2( 'HVFULSFLy'HVFULSFLyQ 3DUWV,QWHJUDQWV3DUWHV,QWHJUDQWHV − (GLILFL SULQFLSDO FRPSRVW GH VHPLVRWHUUDQL HQWUHVzO SODQWD QREOH L GXHV SODQWHV VXSHULRUV (GLILFLR SULQFLSDOFRPSXHVWRGHVHPLVyWDQRHQWUHVXHORSODQWDQREOH\GRVSODQWDVVXSHULRUHV − − − − − − − − − 3DWL3DWLR (VFDODDPEF~SXODVREUHSHW[LQHV(VFDOHUDFRQF~SXODVREUHSHFKLQDV (VFXWVQRELOLDULV(VFXGRVQRELOLDULRV 6DORQV6DORQHV (O³IXPRLU´(O³IXPRLU´ /¶2UDWRUL2UDWRULR /D³6HUUp´/D³6HUUp´ &DSHOOD&DSLOOD )DoDQHVDPESRUWDODGHVLUHL[HULHV)DFKDGDVFRQSRUWDORQHV\UHMHUtDV 'HVFULSFLy*HQHUDO'HVFULSFLyQ*HQHUDO / DQWLFFDVDORWGHOVFRPWHVG 2ORFDXYDVHUFRPSUDWHQSHO0DUTXpVGH&DPSRTXLYDUHIHUODIDoDQDL OL YD FRQIHULU O DVSHFWH DFWXDO HO YD DPSOLDU DPE YLYHQGHV LPPHGLDWHV JHQHUDQW XQD XQLWDW DUTXLWHFWzQLFD EHQGHILQLGDLDUWLFXODGDDOYROWDQWGHOSDWLWRWLTXHDPEH[WHQVLRQVSXQWXDOVFRPSHOD&DSHOODR2UDWRUL HQ HGLILFDFLRQV YHwQHV YLQFXODGHV D OD PDWHL[D SURSLHWDW /HV REUHV YDQ VHU SRUWDGHV D WHUPH SHU 0DQXHO )HUUDQGR HQ3RVWHULRUPHQW YD VHU DGTXLULW SHOV FRPWHV GH %HUEHGHO DOV TXDOV V¶KL GHX OD GHFRUDFLy UHVWDXUDFLy L FRQGLFLRQDPHQW GH OHV VDOHV LQWHULRUV (Q O DFWXDOLWDW O¶HGLILFL GHO PXVHX RFXSD O¶LOOD GH FDVHV FRPSOHWDGHVSUpVG¶XQDDPSOLDFLyVREUHOHVHGLILFDFLRQVTXHUHFDXHQDOFDUUHUGHOV9HQHUDEOHVOHVTXDOVWRW LHVWDUUHODFLRQDGHVQRFRPSDUWHL[HQODFRQGLFLyPRQXPHQWDOGHO¶LPPREOHPDWULX /DIDoDQD GHO SDODX DFWXDO HQWUDGD DO PXVHX HV FRPSRQ G XQ FRV FHQWUDO IODQTXHMDW SHU GRV ODWHUDOV TXH V HOHYHQDPEXQDDOWXUDPpVDPDQHUDGHWRUUDVVHV(OFRVFHQWUDOHVFRQILJXUDDPEGRVREHUWXUHVHQFDGD SODQWDLHVWjUHPDWDWSHUXQIURQWyLEDOXVWUDGD$FRQWLQXDFLyGHOSDODXHVGLVSRVDODIDoDQDGHOVHGLILFLV DGMDFHQWVVHSDUDGDSHUXQDYLWULQDTXHDO LQWHULRUFRUUHVSRQDPEO HVSDLGHQRPLQDW´OD6HUUp´ 'HVSUpVGHO LQJUpVV DFFHGL[DXQYHVWtEXOTXHGyQDSDVDOSDWLFHQWUDOGHOSDODX(OSDWLpVUHFWDQJXODUDPE DUFDGHVHQODSDUWLQIHULRU(QHOSULPHUSLVHQHOFRVWDWSDUDOāOHODODIDoDQDKLKDXQPLUDGRU(QHOVDOWUHV WUHVFRVWDWV HV GHVHQYROXSD XQ EDOFy FRUUHJXW $ OD GUHWD GHO SDWL HV WURED O HVFDOD OD FDL[D GH OD TXDO HV WDQFDDPEXQDF~SXODLGyQDSDVDODSODQWDVXSHULRU/ HVFDOD GHVHPERFDHQXQUHSODQHOOTXHGyQDSDVD OHVGLIHUHQWVVDOHV GHOSDODXFRPHO VDOy GH EDOO R HO VDOy ,PSHUL TXH HQ O DFWXDOLWDW VyQ VDOHV H[SRVLWLYHV FRQVHUYDQWPROWHVG HOOHVODGHFRUDFLyEjVLFDRULJLQDO$WUDYpVGHOHVHVWDGHVXELFDGHVHQHVWHSULPHUHGLILFL HVGyQDSDVDOHVVDOHVTXHHVWUREHQHQOHVHGLILFDFLRQVDQQH[HV(QHVWHVVDOHVHVWUREHQKXLH[SRVLFLRQV WHPjWLTXHVGHOHVFROāOHFFLRQVPXQLFLSDOV(OSDODXSUzSLDPHQW GLWpVDGLUILQVDOOtPLWGHO HVSDLHQYLGUDW YD VHUUHVWDXUDWHQVRWDODGLUHFFLy SULQFLSDO GH O¶DUTXLWHFWH 0DQXHO 3RUWDFHOL 5RLJ SHU D DOEHUJDU HO $11(;,9$1(;2,9 GH 5HVROXFLyGHG DEULOGHOD'LUHFFLy*HQHUDOGH3DWULPRQL&XOWXUDO9DOHQFLjL0XVHXVGHOD&RQVHOOHULDGH&XOWXUD(GXFDFLyL(VSRUWSHUODTXHV LQFRDH[SHGLHQWSHUDOD SULPHUD IDVH GH O DFWXDOLW]DFLy L DGDSWDFLy SDUFLDO GH OD 6HFFLy 3ULPHUD GH O ,QYHQWDUL *HQHUDO GHO 3DWULPRQL &XOWXUDO 9DOHQFLj HQ PDWqULD GH SDWULPRQL DUTXLWHFWzQLF L PHGLDPELHQWDOLV¶REULSHUtRGHG¶LQIRUPDFLyS~EOLFD 5HVROXFLyQ GH GH DEULO GH OD 'LUHFFLyQ *HQHUDO GH 3DWULPRQLR &XOWXUDO 9DOHQFLDQR \ 0XVHRV GH OD &RQVHOOHULD GH &XOWXUD (GXFDFLyQ \ 'HSRUWH SRU OD TXH VH LQFRD H[SHGLHQWH SDUD OD SULPHUD IDVH GH OD DFWXDOL]DFLyQ \ DGDSWDFLyQ SDUFLDO GH OD 6HFFLyQ 3ULPHUD GHO ,QYHQWDULR *HQHUDO GHO 3DWULPRQLR &XOWXUDO 9DOHQFLDQR HQ PDWHULD GH SDWULPRQLRDUTXLWHFWyQLFR\PHGLRDPELHQWDO\VHDEUHSHULRGRGHLQIRUPDFLyQSXEOLFD Núm. 5.503 / 02.05.2007 17966 0XVHXGHOD&LXWDW(QXQDVHJRQDLQWHUYHQFLyHQHOVDQ\VGHOPDWHL[VHJOHHVYDQLQFRUSRUDUHOVHGLILFLV YHwQV PDQWHQLQW OD IDoDQD L EXLGDQW O¶LQWHULRU SHU D FRPSOHPHQWDFLy IXQFLRQDO GHO SURJUDPD H[SRVLWLX L PXVHtVWLF GH O¶LPPREOH (VWH PXVHX KD VHJXW SDUFLDOPHQW UHIXQGDW FRP µ0XVHX G +LVWzULD GH 9DOqQFLD HQ O DPRUWLW]DWµ'LSzVLWG $LJHV LPPREOHWDPEpGHPLWMDQVGHO;,;XELFDWDO LQLFLGHO3DVVHLJGHOD3HW[LQDMD HQWHUPHGH0LVODWD%DVDWHQHO&DWjOHJGH0RQXPHQWVL&RQMXQWVGHOD&RPXQLWDW9DOHQFLDQD (ODQWLJXRFDVHUyQGHORVFRQGHVGH2ORFDXIXHFRPSUDGRHQSRUHO0DUTXpVGH&DPSRTXLpQUHKL]R OD IDFKDGD FRQILULpQGROH HO DVSHFWR DFWXDO \ OR DPSOLy FRQ YLYLHQGDV FROLQGDQWHV JHQHUDQGR XQD XQLGDG DUTXLWHFWyQLFDELHQGHILQLGD\DUWLFXODGDHQWRUQRDOSDWLRVLELHQTXHFRQH[WHQVLRQHVSXQWXDOHVFRPRSH OD &DSLOOD X 2UDWRULR HQ HGLILFDFLRQHV YHFLQD YLQFXODGDV D OD PLVPD SURSLHGDG /HV XWLOL]DQGR XQ SDUWH GH HVWRV SDUD OD FDSLOOD GHO SDODFLR /DV REUDV IXHURQ OOHYDGDV D DFDER SRU 0DQXHO )HUUDQGR HQ 3RVWHULRUPHQWH IXH DGTXLULGR SRU ORV &RQGHV GH %HUEHGHO D TXLHQHV GHEH OD GHFRUDFLyQ UHVWDXUDFLyQ \ DFRQGLFLRQDPLHQWRGHODVVDODVLQWHULRUHV(QODDFWXDOLGDGHOHGLILFLRGHOPXVHRRFXSDODPDQ]DQDFRPSOHWD GHVSXpV GH XQD DPSOLDFLyQ VREUH ODV HGLILFDFLRQHV TXH UHFDHQ D OD FDOOH GH /RV 9HQHUDEOHV ODV FXDOHV D SHVDUGHHVWDUUHODFLRQDGDVQRFRPSDUWHQODFRQGLFLyQPRQXPHQWDOGH£OLQPXHEOHPDWUL] /D IDFKDGD GHO SDODFLR DFWXDO HQWUDGD DO PXVHR VH FRPSRQH GH XQ FXHUSR FHQWUDO IODQTXHDGR SRU GRV ODWHUDOHV TXH VH HOHYDQ FRQ XQD DOWXUD PiV D PRGR GH WRUUHRQHV (O FXHUSR FHQWUDO VH FRQILJXUD FRQ GRV YDQRVHQFDGDSODQWD\HVWiUHPDWDGRSRUXQIURQWyQ\EDODXVWUDGD$FRQWLQXDFLyQGHOSDODFLRVHGLVSRQH OD IDFKDGD GH ORV HGLILFLRV FROLQGDQWHV VHSDUDGDV SRU XQD FULVWDOHUD TXH DO LQWHULRU FRUUHVSRQGH FRQ HO HVSDFLRGHQRPLQDGR´OD6HUUp´ 7UDVHOLQJUHVRVHDFFHGHDXQ]DJXiQTXHGDSDVRDOSDWLRFHQWUDOGHOSDODFLR(OSDWLRHVUHFWDQJXODUFRQ DUFDGDVHQODSDUWHLQIHULRU(QHOSULPHUSLVRHQHOODGRSDUDOHORDODIDFKDGDKD\XQPLUDGRU(QORVRWURV WUHVODGRVVHGHVDUUROODXQEDOFyQFRUULGR$ODGHUHFKDGHOSDWLRVHHQFXHQWUDODHVFDOHUDFX\DFDMDVHFLHUUD FRQ XQD F~SXOD \ GD SDVR D OD SODQWD VXSHULRU /D HVFDOHUD GHVHPERFD HQ XQ UHOODQR TXH GD SDVR D ODV GLIHUHQWHV VDODV GHO SDODFLR FRPR HO VDOyQ GH EDLOH R HO VDOyQ ,PSHULR TXH HQ OD DFWXDOLGDG VRQ VDODV H[SRVLWLYDVFRQVHUYDQGRPXFKDVGHHOODVODGHFRUDFLyQRULJLQDO$WUDYpVGHODVHVWDQFLDVXELFDGDVHQHVWH SULPHU HGLILFLR VH GD SDVR D ODV VDODV TXH VH HQFXHQWUDQ HQ ODV HGLILFDFLRQHV DQH[DV (Q HVWDV VDODV VH HQFXHQWUDQ KR\ H[SRVLFLRQHV WHPiWLFDV GH ODV FROHFFLRQHV PXQLFLSDOHV (O SDODFLR SURSLDPHQWH GLFKR HV GHFLU KDVWD HO OtPLWH GHO HVSDFLR DFULVWDODGR IXH UHVWDXUDGR HQ EDMR OD GLUHFFLyQ SULQFLSDO GHO DUTXLWHFWR 0DQXHO 3RUWDFHOL 5RLJ FRQ OD ILQDOLGDG GH GDU DOEHUJXH DO 0XVHX GH OD &LXWDW (Q XQD VHJXQGD LQWHUYHQFLyQ HQ ORV DxRV GHO PLVPR VLJOR VH LQFRUSRUDURQ ORV HGLILFLRV FROLQGDQWHV FRQVHUYDQGR OD IDFKDGD\YDFLDQGRVXLQWHULRUSDUD HOFRPSOHPHQWDGRIXQFLRQDO GHOSURJUDPD H[SRVLWLYR\PXVHtVWLFRGHO LQPXHEOH(VWHPXVHRKDVLGRSDUFLDOPHQWHUHIXQGDGRFRPRµ0XVHXG¶+LVWzULDGH9DOqQFLD¶HQHODPRUWL]DGR µ'LSzVLWG¶$LJHV¶LPPXHEOHWDPELpQGHPHGLDGRVGHO;,;XELFDGRHQHOLQLFLRGHO3DVVHLJGHOH3HW[LQD\D WpUPLQRGH0LVODWD%DVDGRHQHO&DWiORJRGH0RQXPHQWRV\&RQMXQWRVGHOD&RPXQLGDG9DOHQFLDQD 2EVHUYDFLRQV2EVHUYDFLRQHV /¶KDELOLWDFLy HIHFWXDGD FRP D VHX GHO 0XVHX GH OD &LXWDW V¶HQWpQ YLQFXODGD D OD GHFODUDFLy PRQXPHQWDO HQ OD PLGDTXHPDQWpUHDOoDRDFUHL[HOVYDORUVGHO¶LPPREOHSRGHQWpVVHUVRWPHVDDUHYLVLyFUtWLFDSHULQWHUYHQFLRQV XOWHULRUV TXH VLJXHQ SODQWHMDGHV GHV GH OD SHUVSHFWLYD JOREDO L XQLWjULD DPE TXH DTXHL[D IRX H[HFXWDGD FRQFyUUHJXHQDPELJXDORVXSHULRUVROYqQFLDDODYDORULW]DFLyLJDXGLSDWULPRQLDO GHO¶LPPREOHLFRPSWHQDWDO HIHFWHDPEO¶DXWRULW]DFLyH[SUHVVDGHO¶DGPLQLVWUDFLyWXWHODUHQODPDWqULD (Q O DFWXDOLWDW O¶HGLILFL GHO PXVHX RFXSD O¶LOOD GH FDVHV FRPSOHWD GHVSUpV G¶XQD DPSOLDFLy VREUH OHV HGLILFDFLRQV TXH UHFDXHQ DO FDUUHU GHOV 9HQHUDEOHV L OHV TXDOV WRW L HVWDU UHODFLRQDGHV QR FRPSDUWHL[HQ OD FRQGLFLy PRQXPHQWDOGHO¶LPPREOHPDWULX /DKDELOLWDFLyQHIHFWXDGDFRPRVHGHGHO0XVHXGHOD&LXWDWVHHQWLHQGHYLQFXODGDDODGHFODUDFLyQPRQXPHQWDO HQ WDQWR HQ FXDQWR PDQWLHQH UHDO]D R DFUHFLHQWD ORV YDORUHV GHO LQPXHEOH SXGLHQGR VHU VRPHWLGD D UHYLVLyQ FUtWLFDSRULQWHUYHQFLRQHVXOWHULRUHVTXHVHDQSODQWHDGDVGHVGHODSHUVSHFWLYDJOREDO\XQLWDULDFRQTXHDTXHOOD IXH HMHFXWDGD FRQFXUUDQ FRQ LJXDO R PD\RU VROYHQFLD D OD YDORUL]DFLyQ \ GLVIUXWH SDWULPRQLDO GHO LQPXHEOH \ FXHQWHQDWDOHIHFWRFRQODDXWRUL]DFLyQDGPLQLVWUDWLYDGHODDGPLQLVWUDFLyQWXWHODUHQODPDWHULD (Q OD DFWXDOLGDG HO HGLILFLR GHO PXVHR RFXSD OD PDQ]DQD FRPSOHWD GHVSXpV GH XQD DPSOLDFLyQ VREUH ODV HGLILFDFLRQHVTXHUHFDHQDODFDOOHGH/RV9HQHUDEOHVODVFXDOHVDSHVDUGHHVWDUUHODFLRQDGDVQRFRPSDUWHQOD FRQGLFLyQPRQXPHQWDOGH£OLQPXHEOHPDWUL] (QWRUQ(QWRUQ $QWHFHGHQWVDGPLQLVWUDWLXVLGHVFULSFLy/ HQWRUQGHSURWHFFLyGHO3DODXGHO0DUTXpVGH&DPSRRGH %HUEHGHOHVWUREDLQFOzVHQXQjPELWPDMRUTXHHQJOREDHOVHQWRUQVG¶DOWUHVEpQVMDGHFODUDWV%,&TXHHO FLUFXPGHQLTXHKDQHVWDWREMHFWHGHUHFRQHL[HPHQWHVSHFtILFPLWMDQoDQWODFRUUHVSRQHQWUHVROXFLyGHOD 'LUHFFLy*HQHUDOGH3DWULPRQL$UWtVWLFGHOD&RQVHOOHULDGH&XOWXUD(GXFDFLyL&LqQFLDFRQYDOLGDGDDPE FDUjFWHUSURYLVLRQDOSHUOD'LVSRVLFLy7UDQVLWzULD3ULPHUDDSDUWDW3ULPHUGHODUHFHQW/OHLGHGH $11(;,9$1(;2,9 GH 5HVROXFLyGHG DEULOGHOD'LUHFFLy*HQHUDOGH3DWULPRQL&XOWXUDO9DOHQFLjL0XVHXVGHOD&RQVHOOHULDGH&XOWXUD(GXFDFLyL(VSRUWSHUODTXHV LQFRDH[SHGLHQWSHUDOD SULPHUD IDVH GH O DFWXDOLW]DFLy L DGDSWDFLy SDUFLDO GH OD 6HFFLy 3ULPHUD GH O ,QYHQWDUL *HQHUDO GHO 3DWULPRQL &XOWXUDO 9DOHQFLj HQ PDWqULD GH SDWULPRQL DUTXLWHFWzQLF L PHGLDPELHQWDOLV¶REULSHUtRGHG¶LQIRUPDFLyS~EOLFD 5HVROXFLyQ GH GH DEULO GH OD 'LUHFFLyQ *HQHUDO GH 3DWULPRQLR &XOWXUDO 9DOHQFLDQR \ 0XVHRV GH OD &RQVHOOHULD GH &XOWXUD (GXFDFLyQ \ 'HSRUWH SRU OD TXH VH LQFRD H[SHGLHQWH SDUD OD SULPHUD IDVH GH OD DFWXDOL]DFLyQ \ DGDSWDFLyQ SDUFLDO GH OD 6HFFLyQ 3ULPHUD GHO ,QYHQWDULR *HQHUDO GHO 3DWULPRQLR &XOWXUDO 9DOHQFLDQR HQ PDWHULD GH SDWULPRQLRDUTXLWHFWyQLFR\PHGLRDPELHQWDO\VHDEUHSHULRGRGHLQIRUPDFLyQSXEOLFD Núm. 5.503 / 02.05.2007 − − − − − − − − − − 17967 IHEUHUGH/D*HQHUDOLWDWGH0RGLILFDFLyGHOD/OHLG¶GHMXQ\GHO3DWULPRQL&XOWXUDO9DOHQFLj VHJRQVDTXHVWHVGDGHVUHVSHFWLYHV 3DODXFDVDGHOV(VFULYj5HVROXFLyGHGHPDLJGH'2*9Q~P (VJOpVLD&DWHGUDO0HWURSROLWDQDGH6DQWD0DULD5HVROXFLyGHGHPDLJGH'2*9Q~P 5HLDO%DVtOLFDGH OD0DUH GH'pXGHOV'HVHPSDUDWV5HVROXFLyGH GHPDLJGH '2*9 Q~P (GLILFL$QWLF$OPRGt5HVROXFLyGHPDLJGH'2*9Q~P (VJOpVLD3DUURTXLDOGH6DQW(VWHYH3URWRPjUWLU5HVROXFLyGHGHPDLJGH'2*9Q~P $QWHFHGHQWHVDGPLQLVWUDWLYRV\GHVFULSFLyQ(O HQWRUQRGHSURWHFFLyQGHO 3DODFLRGHO0DUTXpVGH&DPSRR GH %HUEHGHO VH HQFXHQWUD LQFOXLGR HQ XQ iPELWR PD\RU TXH HQJORED ORV HQWRUQRV GH RWURV ELHQHV \D GHFODUDGRV %,& TXH OR FLUFXQGDQ \ TXH KDQ VLGR REMHWR GH UHFRQRFLPLHQWR HVSHFtILFR PHGLDQWH OD FRUUHVSRQGLHQWH 5HVROXFLyQ GH OD 'LUHFFLyQ *HQHUDO GH 3DWULPRQLR $UWtVWLFR GH OD &RQVHOOHULD GH &XOWXUD (GXFDFLyQ \ &LHQFLD FRQYDOLGDGD FRQ FDUiFWHU SURYLVLRQDO SRU OD 'LVSRVLFLyQ 7UDQVLWRULD 3ULPHUD DSDUWDGR 3ULPHUR GH OD UHFLHQWH /H\ GH GH IHEUHUR GH /D *HQHUDOLWDW GH 0RGLILFDFLyQ GH OD /H\ G¶GHMXQLRGHO3DWULPRQLR&XOWXUDO9DOHQFLDQRVHJ~QORVGDWRVTXHVHFLWDQ 3DODFLRFDVDGHORV(VFULYi5HVROXFLyQGHGHPD\RGH'2*9Q ,JOHVLD &DWHGUDO 0HWURSROLWDQD GH 6DQWD 0DUtD 5HVROXFLyQ GH GH PD\R GH '2*9 Q 5HDO%DVtOLFDGHOD9LUJHQGHORV'HVDPSDUDGRV5HVROXFLyQGHGHPD\RGH'2*9Q (GLILFLR$QWLJXR$OPXGtQ5HVROXFLyQGHPD\RGH'2*9Q ,JOHVLD 3DUURTXLDO GH 6DQ (VWHEDQ 3URWRPiUWLU 5HVROXFLyQ GH GH PD\R GH '2*9 Q $11(;,9$1(;2,9 GH 5HVROXFLyGHG DEULOGHOD'LUHFFLy*HQHUDOGH3DWULPRQL&XOWXUDO9DOHQFLjL0XVHXVGHOD&RQVHOOHULDGH&XOWXUD(GXFDFLyL(VSRUWSHUODTXHV LQFRDH[SHGLHQWSHUDOD SULPHUD IDVH GH O DFWXDOLW]DFLy L DGDSWDFLy SDUFLDO GH OD 6HFFLy 3ULPHUD GH O ,QYHQWDUL *HQHUDO GHO 3DWULPRQL &XOWXUDO 9DOHQFLj HQ PDWqULD GH SDWULPRQL DUTXLWHFWzQLF L PHGLDPELHQWDOLV¶REULSHUtRGHG¶LQIRUPDFLyS~EOLFD 5HVROXFLyQ GH GH DEULO GH OD 'LUHFFLyQ *HQHUDO GH 3DWULPRQLR &XOWXUDO 9DOHQFLDQR \ 0XVHRV GH OD &RQVHOOHULD GH &XOWXUD (GXFDFLyQ \ 'HSRUWH SRU OD TXH VH LQFRD H[SHGLHQWH SDUD OD SULPHUD IDVH GH OD DFWXDOL]DFLyQ \ DGDSWDFLyQ SDUFLDO GH OD 6HFFLyQ 3ULPHUD GHO ,QYHQWDULR *HQHUDO GHO 3DWULPRQLR &XOWXUDO 9DOHQFLDQR HQ PDWHULD GH SDWULPRQLRDUTXLWHFWyQLFR\PHGLRDPELHQWDO\VHDEUHSHULRGRGHLQIRUPDFLyQSXEOLFD Núm. 5.503 / 02.05.2007 17968 %e'¶,17(5e6&8/785$/±3$/$8'(/0$548e6'(&$0322'(/6&207(6'(%(5%('(/ 9$/Ê1&,$02180(17 %,(1'(,17(5e6&8/785$/±3$/$&,2'(/0$548e6'(&$0322'(/26&21'(6'(%(5%('(/ 9$/(1&,$02180(172 $11(;,9$1(;2,9 GH 5HVROXFLyGHG DEULOGHOD'LUHFFLy*HQHUDOGH3DWULPRQL&XOWXUDO9DOHQFLjL0XVHXVGHOD&RQVHOOHULDGH&XOWXUD(GXFDFLyL(VSRUWSHUODTXHV LQFRDH[SHGLHQWSHUDOD SULPHUD IDVH GH O DFWXDOLW]DFLy L DGDSWDFLy SDUFLDO GH OD 6HFFLy 3ULPHUD GH O ,QYHQWDUL *HQHUDO GHO 3DWULPRQL &XOWXUDO 9DOHQFLj HQ PDWqULD GH SDWULPRQL DUTXLWHFWzQLF L PHGLDPELHQWDOLV¶REULSHUtRGHG¶LQIRUPDFLyS~EOLFD 5HVROXFLyQ GH GH DEULO GH OD 'LUHFFLyQ *HQHUDO GH 3DWULPRQLR &XOWXUDO 9DOHQFLDQR \ 0XVHRV GH OD &RQVHOOHULD GH &XOWXUD (GXFDFLyQ \ 'HSRUWH SRU OD TXH VH LQFRD H[SHGLHQWH SDUD OD SULPHUD IDVH GH OD DFWXDOL]DFLyQ \ DGDSWDFLyQ SDUFLDO GH OD 6HFFLyQ 3ULPHUD GHO ,QYHQWDULR *HQHUDO GHO 3DWULPRQLR &XOWXUDO 9DOHQFLDQR HQ PDWHULD GH SDWULPRQLRDUTXLWHFWyQLFR\PHGLRDPELHQWDO\VHDEUHSHULRGRGHLQIRUPDFLyQSXEOLFD Núm. 5.503 / 02.05.2007 17969 %e'¶,17(5e6&8/785$/±3$/$8'(/6%2,/'¶$5(1Ï6$&78$/%256$'(9$/Ê1&,$ 9$/Ê1&,$02180(17 %,(1'(,17(5e6&8/785$/3$/$&,2'(/26%2,/'($5(1Ï6$&78$/%2/6$'(9$/(1&,$ 9$/(1&,$02180(172 'HQRPLQDFLy'HQRPLQDFLyQ 3ULQFLSDO3ULQFLSDO 3DODXGHOV%RLOG¶$UHQyV 3DODFLRGHORV%RLOGH$UHQyV $FFHVzULD$FFHVRULD %RUVDGH9DOqQFLD %ROVDGH9DOHQFLD /RFDOL]DFLy/RFDOL]DFLyQ 3URYtQFLD3URYLQFLD9DOqQFLD &RPDUFD&RPDUFDO¶+RUWD 0XQLFLSL0XQLFLSLR9DOqQFLD 8ELFDFLy8ELFDFLyQ&/OLEUHUVL 5HIHUHQFLD&DGDVWUDO5HIHUHQFLD&DWDVWUDO ,OOD0DQ]DQD3DUFHOāOD3DUFHOD\ $QWHFHGHQWV-XUtGLFV$QWHFHGHQWHV-XUtGLFRV ,QFRDFLy,QFRDFLyQ 3XEOLFDFLyGHODLQFRDFLy3XEOLFDFLyQGHODLQFRDFLyQ%2( 'HVFULSFLy'HVFULSFLyQ 3DUWV,QWHJUDQWV3DUWHV,QWHJUDQWHV − (GLILFLFRPSRVWGHVHPLVRWHUUDQLHQWUHVzOSODQWDQREOHLSLVDOW(GLILFLRFRPSXHVWRGHVHPLVyWDQR HQWUHVXHORSODQWDQREOH\SLVRDOWR − − − − − 1DXVXSHULRUGHOGDUUHUH1DYHVXSHULRUWUDVHUD 7RUUHPLUDPDU7RUUHPLUDPDU )DoDQHV)DFKDGDV 3RUWDGDDPEHVFXWQRELOLDUL3RUWDGDFRQHVFXGRQRELOLDULR 3DWLGHFHOREHUW3DWLRGHVFXELHUWR 'HVFULSFLy*HQHUDO'HVFULSFLyQ*HQHUDO (VWUDFWDG XQSDODXTXHVHJXHL[ODWUDGLFLyPHGLHYDOSHUzGHSXUDGDLUHYLVDGDSHOVFRVWXPVLJXVWRVGHOHV qSRTXHVSRVWHULRUVDOoDWVREUHXQVRODUHQFDQWyTXHSHUWDQ\DODIDPtOLDGHOV%RLO/ HGLILFLTXHHVFRQVHUYD HQO DFWXDOLWDWHVGHXDXQDFRQILJXUDFLySODQWHMDGDHQHOVHJOH;9,,, /DIDoDQDPRVWUDOD GLYLVLyIXQFLRQDOLMHUjUTXLFD GHO¶LPPREOHDPEVLJQLILFDFLyGHOVHPLVRWHUUDQLHQWUHVzO SODQWDQREOHLSLVDOW9HUWLFDOPHQWWpVLVEXLWVSHUFDGDXQDGHOHVSODQWHV/DIDoDQDWpXQVzFROGHFDUUHXV PHQWUHTXHODUHVWDGHODPDWHL[DHVWjHVWXFDW'HVWDTXHQOHVEDOFRQDGHVGHIHUURIRUMDW /DSRUWDGDSULQFLSDOHVWjUHDOLW]DGDHQSHGUDSUHVHQWDHQODSDUWVXSHULRUO HVFXWGHODIDPtOLD%RLOLDWUDYpV G HOODV DFFHGL[DOSDWLUHFWDQJXODUDPETXDWUHDUFVHVFDUVHUV$O HVTXHUUDHVWUREDO HVFDODTXHGyQDSDVD ODSODQWDSULQFLSDOPHQWUHTXHHQHOFRVWDWFRQWUDULHVWUREDO HVFDODTXHFRPXQLFDDPEWRWHVOHVSODQWHV$O IRQVGHOSDWLSDUDOāOHODODIDoDQDKLKDXQDVDODUHFWDQJXODUDODTXDOV DFFHGL[SHUGRVDUFVGHPLJSXQW UHDOLW]DWVHQSHGUDVLWXDWVHQOHVJDOHULHVTXHIRUPDHOSDWL'HVSUpVG HVWDVDODYDKDYHUKLXQSDWLTXHHQ HOVDQ\V GHOVHJOH;; YD VHU RFXSDW SHU XQD PRGHUQD HGLILFDFLy DPE GLYHUVHV DOWXUHV (Q OD SDUW GH OD IDoDQDPpVSUz[LPDDO DFWXDOFDUUHU3RHWD4XHUROV REULXQDDOWUDSRUWDGDPpV[LFRWHWDTXHFRUUHVSRQMDD XQSODQWHMDPHQWHGLILFDWRULSOXULUHVLGHQFLDO/DIjEULFDGHO HGLILFLFRPELQDGLYHUVRVPDWHULDOVFRPODWjSLDOD UDMRODLODPDoRQHULD(OVIRUMDWVHVWDQUHDOLW]DWVDPEELJXHVGHIXVWDDPEYROWHVGHUDMROD 'HVSUpV GH JUHXV DPHQDFHV G¶HQUUXQDPHQW ILQDOPHQW O¶HGLILF IRX DGTXLULW SHU OD *HQHUDOLWDW L UHVWDXUDW HQ VHJRQV FRQFXUV UHVWULQJLW JXDQ\DW SHU O¶DUTXLWHFWH &DUORV &DPSRV *RQ]iOH] DPE OD ILQDOLWDW GH GHVWLQDUORFRP DVHX GHOD%RUVD GH9DOqQFLDIXQFLyTXHFRQVHUYDHQO¶DFWXDOLWDW%DVDWHQHO &DWjOHJ GH 0RQXPHQWVL&RQMXQWVGHOD&RPXQLWDW9DOHQFLDQD 6H WUDWD GH XQ SDODFLR TXH VLJXH OD WUDGLFLyQ PHGLHYDO SHUR GHSXUDGD \ UHYLVDGD SRU ODV FRVWXPEUHV \ JXVWRVSRVWHULRUHVOHYDQWDGRVREUHXQVRODUHQHVTXLQDSHUWHQHFLHQWHDODIDPLOLDGHORV%RLO(OHGLILFLRTXH VHFRQVHUYDHQODDFWXDOLGDGVHGHEHDXQDFRQILJXUDFLyQSODQWHDGDHQHOVLJOR;9,,, $11(;,9$1(;2,9 GH 5HVROXFLyGHG DEULOGHOD'LUHFFLy*HQHUDOGH3DWULPRQL&XOWXUDO9DOHQFLjL0XVHXVGHOD&RQVHOOHULDGH&XOWXUD(GXFDFLyL(VSRUWSHUODTXHV LQFRDH[SHGLHQWSHUDOD SULPHUD IDVH GH O DFWXDOLW]DFLy L DGDSWDFLy SDUFLDO GH OD 6HFFLy 3ULPHUD GH O ,QYHQWDUL *HQHUDO GHO 3DWULPRQL &XOWXUDO 9DOHQFLj HQ PDWqULD GH SDWULPRQL DUTXLWHFWzQLF L PHGLDPELHQWDOLV¶REULSHUtRGHG¶LQIRUPDFLyS~EOLFD 5HVROXFLyQ GH GH DEULO GH OD 'LUHFFLyQ *HQHUDO GH 3DWULPRQLR &XOWXUDO 9DOHQFLDQR \ 0XVHRV GH OD &RQVHOOHULD GH &XOWXUD (GXFDFLyQ \ 'HSRUWH SRU OD TXH VH LQFRD H[SHGLHQWH SDUD OD SULPHUD IDVH GH OD DFWXDOL]DFLyQ \ DGDSWDFLyQ SDUFLDO GH OD 6HFFLyQ 3ULPHUD GHO ,QYHQWDULR *HQHUDO GHO 3DWULPRQLR &XOWXUDO 9DOHQFLDQR HQ PDWHULD GH SDWULPRQLRDUTXLWHFWyQLFR\PHGLRDPELHQWDO\VHDEUHSHULRGRGHLQIRUPDFLyQSXEOLFD Núm. 5.503 / 02.05.2007 17970 /D IDFKDGD PXHVWUD OD GLYLVLyQ IXQFLRQDO \ MHUDUTXLFD GHO LQPXHEOH DO VLJQLILFDU HO VHPLVyWDQR HQWUHVXHOR SODQWDQREOH\SLVRDOWR9HUWLFDOPHQWHWLHQHVHLVKXHFRVSRUFDGDXQDGHODVSODQWDV/DIDFKDGDWLHQHXQ ]yFDOR GH VLOOHUtD PLHQWUDV TXH HO UHVWR GH OD PLVPD HVWi HVWXFDGR 'HVWDFDQ ODV EDOFRQDGDV GH KLHUUR IRUMDGR /D SRUWDGD SULQFLSDOHVWiUHDOL]DGDHQ SLHGUD SUHVHQWD HQODSDUWH VXSHULRU HO HVFXGR GH OD IDPLOLD %RLO D WUDYpV GH HOOD VH DFFHGH DO SDWLR UHFWDQJXODU FRQ FXDWUR DUFRV HVFDU]DQRV $ OD L]TXLHUGD VH HQFXHQWUD OD HVFDOHUDTXHGDSDVRDODSODQWDSULQFLSDOPLHQWUDVTXH HQHO ODGRFRQWUDULR VH HQFXHQWUD ODHVFDOHUDTXH FRPXQLFDFRQWRGDVODVSODQWDV$OIRQGRGHOSDWLRSDUDOHORDODIDFKDGDKD\XQDVDODUHFWDQJXODUDODTXH VHDFFHGHSRUGRVDUFRVGHPHGLRSXQWRUHDOL]DGRVHQSLHGUDVLWXDGRVHQODVJDOHUtDVTXHIRUPDHOSDWLR 7UDVHVWDVDODKXERXQSDWLRTXHHQORVDxRVGHOVLJOR;;IXHRFXSDGRSRUXQDPRGHUQDHGLILFDFLyQFRQ YDULDVDOWXUDV(QODSDUWHGHODIDFKDGDPiVFHUFDQDDODDFWXDOFDOOH3RHWD4XHUROVHDEUHRWUDSRUWDGDGH PHQRU WDPDxR TXH FRUUHVSRQGH \D D XQ SODQWHDPLHQWR HGLILFDWRULR SOXULUHVLGHQFLDO /D IiEULFD GHO HGLILFLR FRPELQDGLIHUHQWHVPDWHULDOHVFRPRHOWDSLDOHOODGULOOR\ODPDPSRVWHUtD/RVIRUMDGRVHVWiQUHDOL]DGRVFRQ YLJDVGHPDGHUDFRQEyYHGDVGHODGULOOR 7UDVJUDYHVDPHQD]DVGHDUUXLQDPLHQWRILQDOPHQWHHOHGLILFLRIXHDGTXLULGRSRU/D*HQHUDOLWDW\UHVWDXUDGR HQVHJ~QFRQFXUVRGHSUR\HFWRVJDQDGRSRUHODUTXLWHFWR&DUORV&DPSRV*RQ]iOH]FRQODILQDOLGDGGH GHVWLQDUORDVHGHGHOD%ROVDGH9DOHQFLDIXQFLyQTXHFRQVHUYDHQODDFWXDOLGDG%DVDGRHQHO&DWiORJRGH 0RQXPHQWRV\&RQMXQWRVGHOD&RPXQLGDG9DOHQFLDQD 2EVHUYDFLRQV2EVHUYDFLRQHV /¶KDELOLWDFLyHIHFWXDGDFRPD VHX GHOD%RUVDGH9DOqQFLDV¶HQWpQYLQFXODGD DOD GHFODUDFLy PRQXPHQWDO HQ OD PLGDTXHPDQWpUHDOoDRDFUHL[HOVYDORUVGHO¶LPPREOHSRGHQWpVVHUVRWPHVDDUHYLVLyFUtWLFDSHULQWHUYHQFLRQV XOWHULRUV TXH VLJXHQ SODQWHMDGHV GHV GH OD SHUVSHFWLYD JOREDO L XQLWjULD DPE TXH DTXHL[D IRX H[HFXWDGD FRQFRUUHQ DPE LJXDO R VXSHULRU VROYqQFLD D OD YDORULW]DFLy L JDXGL SDWULPRQLDO GH O¶LPPREOH L FRPSWHQ D WDO HIHFWHDPEO¶DXWRULW]DFLyH[SUHVVDGHO¶DGPLQLVWUDFLyWXWHODUHQODPDWqULD /DKDELOLWDFLyQHIHFWXDGDFRPRVHGHGHOD%ROVDGH9DOHQFLDVHHQWLHQGHYLQFXODGDDODGHFODUDFLyQPRQXPHQWDO HQ WDQWR HQ FXDQWR PDQWLHQH UHDO]D R DFUHFLHQWD ORV YDORUHV GHO LQPXHEOH SXGLHQGR VHU VRPHWLGD D UHYLVLyQ FUtWLFDSRULQWHUYHQFLRQHVXOWHULRUHVTXHVHDQSODQWHDGDVGHVGHODSHUVSHFWLYDJOREDO\XQLWDULDFRQTXHDTXHOOD IXH HMHFXWDGD FRQFXUUDQ FRQ LJXDO R PD\RU VROYHQFLD D OD YDORUL]DFLyQ \ GLVIUXWH SDWULPRQLDO GHO LQPXHEOH \ FXHQWHQDWDOHIHFWRFRQODDXWRUL]DFLyQDGPLQLVWUDWLYDGHODDGPLQLVWUDFLyQWXWHODUHQODPDWHULD (QWRUQ(QWRUQ $QWHFHGHQWV DGPLQLVWUDWLXV L GHVFULSFLy / HQWRUQ GH SURWHFFLy GHO 3DODX GHOV %RLO HV WURED PDMRULWjULDPHQW LQFOzV HQ XQ jPELW VXSHULRU TXH HQJORED HOV HQWRUQV G¶DOWUHV EpQV %,& TXH HO FLUFXPGHQ L TXH KDQ HVWDW REMHFWHGHUHFRQHL[HPHQWHVSHFtILFPLWMDQoDQWODFRUUHVSRQHQWUHVROXFLyGHOD'LUHFFLy*HQHUDOGH3DWULPRQL $UWtVWLF GH OD &RQVHOOHULD GH &XOWXUD (GXFDFLy L &LqQFLD FRQYDOLGDGD DPE FDUjFWHU SURYLVLRQDO SHU OD 'LVSRVLFLy7UDQVLWzULD3ULPHUDDSDUWDW3ULPHUGHODUHFHQW/OHLGHGHIHEUHUGH/D*HQHUDOLWDWGH 0RGLILFDFLy GH OD /OHL G¶ GH MXQ\ GHO 3DWULPRQL &XOWXUDO 9DOHQFLj VHJRQV DTXHVWHV GDGHV UHVSHFWLYHV − 5HLDO&ROāOHJL GHO&RUSXV&KULVWL R GHO3DWULDUFD5HVROXFLyGH GH MXOLRO GH '2*9 Q~P − 3DODX GHO PDUTXpV GH 'RV $LJHV 5HVROXFLy GH GH VHWHPEUH GH GH GDWD '2*9 Q~P − 8QLYHUVLWDWGH9DOqQFLD5HVROXFLyGHGHMXOLROGH'2*9Q~P − (VJOpVLDGH6DQW-RDQGHOD&UHX5HVROXFLyGHG DJRVWGH'2*9Q~P 3HUDOWUDEDQGDODGHOLPLWDFLyV¶HVWpQDOHVSDUFHOāOHVLGHO¶LOODFDGDVWUDODFROOLQWVH DDOOzGLVSRVDWSHUO $SWDWGHOD'LVSRVLFLy7UDQVLWzULD3ULPHUDGHOD/OHLPRGLILFDGRUDGHOD FRPDGHOLPLWDFLyUHFRQHJXGDDPEFDUjFWHUSURYLVLRQDOVHJRQVODJUDILDGHO DQQH[GHO&DWjOHJGH%pQVL (VSDLV 3URWHJLWV GHO 3*28 GH 9DOqQFLD GH G DFRUG DPE DOOz TXH V KD HVWDEOLW SHO ³&RQYHQL 0DUF GH &ROāODERUDFLyHQWUHOD*HQHUDOLWDW9DOHQFLDQDLO $MXQWDPHQWGH9DOqQFLDSHUDO'HVSOHJDPHQWL([HFXFLyGHO 3ODQHMDPHQW8UEDQtVWLFGHO&RQMXQW+LVWzULFGHOD&LXWDW´VXEVFULWHOGLDGHMXQ\GHLSXEOLFDWHQHO '2*9GH $QWHFHGHQWHV DGPLQLVWUDWLYRV \ GHVFULSFLyQ HO HQWRUQR GH SURWHFFLyQ GHO 3DODFLR GH %RLO GH $UHQyV VH HQFXHQWUDPD\RULWDULDPHQWHLQFOXLGRHQXQiPELWRVXSHULRUHQJOREDORVHQWRUQRVGHRWURVELHQHV%,&TXHOR FLUFXQGDQ\TXHKDQVLGRREMHWRGHUHFRQRFLPLHQWRHVSHFtILFRPHGLDQWHODFRUUHVSRQGLHQWH5HVROXFLyQGHOD 'LUHFFLyQ*HQHUDOGH3DWULPRQLR$UWtVWLFRGHOD&RQVHOOHULDGH&XOWXUD(GXFDFLyQ\&LHQFLDFRQYDOLGDGDFRQ FDUiFWHUSURYLVLRQDOSRUOD'LVSRVLFLyQ7UDQVLWRULD3ULPHUDDSDUWDGR3ULPHURGHODUHFLHQWH/H\GH $11(;,9$1(;2,9 GH 5HVROXFLyGHG DEULOGHOD'LUHFFLy*HQHUDOGH3DWULPRQL&XOWXUDO9DOHQFLjL0XVHXVGHOD&RQVHOOHULDGH&XOWXUD(GXFDFLyL(VSRUWSHUODTXHV LQFRDH[SHGLHQWSHUDOD SULPHUD IDVH GH O DFWXDOLW]DFLy L DGDSWDFLy SDUFLDO GH OD 6HFFLy 3ULPHUD GH O ,QYHQWDUL *HQHUDO GHO 3DWULPRQL &XOWXUDO 9DOHQFLj HQ PDWqULD GH SDWULPRQL DUTXLWHFWzQLF L PHGLDPELHQWDOLV¶REULSHUtRGHG¶LQIRUPDFLyS~EOLFD 5HVROXFLyQ GH GH DEULO GH OD 'LUHFFLyQ *HQHUDO GH 3DWULPRQLR &XOWXUDO 9DOHQFLDQR \ 0XVHRV GH OD &RQVHOOHULD GH &XOWXUD (GXFDFLyQ \ 'HSRUWH SRU OD TXH VH LQFRD H[SHGLHQWH SDUD OD SULPHUD IDVH GH OD DFWXDOL]DFLyQ \ DGDSWDFLyQ SDUFLDO GH OD 6HFFLyQ 3ULPHUD GHO ,QYHQWDULR *HQHUDO GHO 3DWULPRQLR &XOWXUDO 9DOHQFLDQR HQ PDWHULD GH SDWULPRQLRDUTXLWHFWyQLFR\PHGLRDPELHQWDO\VHDEUHSHULRGRGHLQIRUPDFLyQSXEOLFD Núm. 5.503 / 02.05.2007 17971 GH IHEUHUR GH /D *HQHUDOLWDW GH 0RGLILFDFLyQ GH OD /H\ G¶ GH MXQLR GHO 3DWULPRQLR &XOWXUDO 9DOHQFLDQRVHJ~QORVGDWRVTXHVHFLWDQ − 5HDO&ROHJLRGHO&RUSXV&KULVWLRGHO3DWULDUFD5HVROXFLyQGHGHMXOLRGH'2*9Q − 3DODFLR GHO 0DUTXpV GH 'RV $JXDV 5HVROXFLyQ GH GH VHSWLHPEUH GH '2*9 Q − 8QLYHUVLWDWGH9DOqQFLD5HVROXFLyQGHGHMXOLRGH'2*9Q − ,JOHVLDGH6DQ-XDQGHOD&UX]5HVROXFLyQGHGHDJRVWRGH'2*9Q 3RURWUDSDUWHODGHOLPLWDFLyQVHH[WLHQGHDODVSDUFHODV\GHODPDQ]DQDFDWDVWUDO DFRJLpQGRVH D OR GLVSXHVWR HQ HO $SWGR GH OD 'LVSRVLFLyQ 7UDQVLWRULD 3ULPHUD GH OD OH\ PRGLILFDGRUDGHODFRPRGHOLPLWDFLyQUHFRQRFLGDFRQFDUiFWHUSURYLVLRQDOVHJ~QODJUDItDGHO$QH[R GHO&DWiORJRGH%LHQHV\(VSDFLRV3URWHJLGRVGHO3*28GH9DOqQFLDGHFRQDUUHJORDORHVWDEOHFLGR SRUHO³&RQYHQLR0DUFRGH&RODERUDFLyQHQWUHOD*HQHUDOLWDW9DOHQFLDQD\HO$\XQWDPLHQWRGH9DOHQFLDSDUD HO'HVDUUROOR\(MHFXFLyQGHO3ODQHDPLHQWR8UEDQtVWLFRGHO&RQMXQWR+LVWyULFRGHOD&LXGDG´VXVFULWRHOGtD GHMXQLRGH\SXEOLFDGRHQHO'2*9GH $11(;,9$1(;2,9 GH 5HVROXFLyGHG DEULOGHOD'LUHFFLy*HQHUDOGH3DWULPRQL&XOWXUDO9DOHQFLjL0XVHXVGHOD&RQVHOOHULDGH&XOWXUD(GXFDFLyL(VSRUWSHUODTXHV LQFRDH[SHGLHQWSHUDOD SULPHUD IDVH GH O DFWXDOLW]DFLy L DGDSWDFLy SDUFLDO GH OD 6HFFLy 3ULPHUD GH O ,QYHQWDUL *HQHUDO GHO 3DWULPRQL &XOWXUDO 9DOHQFLj HQ PDWqULD GH SDWULPRQL DUTXLWHFWzQLF L PHGLDPELHQWDOLV¶REULSHUtRGHG¶LQIRUPDFLyS~EOLFD 5HVROXFLyQ GH GH DEULO GH OD 'LUHFFLyQ *HQHUDO GH 3DWULPRQLR &XOWXUDO 9DOHQFLDQR \ 0XVHRV GH OD &RQVHOOHULD GH &XOWXUD (GXFDFLyQ \ 'HSRUWH SRU OD TXH VH LQFRD H[SHGLHQWH SDUD OD SULPHUD IDVH GH OD DFWXDOL]DFLyQ \ DGDSWDFLyQ SDUFLDO GH OD 6HFFLyQ 3ULPHUD GHO ,QYHQWDULR *HQHUDO GHO 3DWULPRQLR &XOWXUDO 9DOHQFLDQR HQ PDWHULD GH SDWULPRQLRDUTXLWHFWyQLFR\PHGLRDPELHQWDO\VHDEUHSHULRGRGHLQIRUPDFLyQSXEOLFD Núm. 5.503 / 02.05.2007 17972 %e'¶,17(5e6&8/785$/±3$/$8'(/6%2,/'¶$5(1Ï6$&78$/%256$'(9$/Ê1&,$ 9$/Ê1&,$02180(17 %,(1'(,17(5e6&8/785$/3$/$&,2'(/26%2,/'($5(1Ï6$&78$/%2/6$'(9$/(1&,$ 9$/(1&,$02180(172 $11(;,9$1(;2,9 GH 5HVROXFLyGHG DEULOGHOD'LUHFFLy*HQHUDOGH3DWULPRQL&XOWXUDO9DOHQFLjL0XVHXVGHOD&RQVHOOHULDGH&XOWXUD(GXFDFLyL(VSRUWSHUODTXHV LQFRDH[SHGLHQWSHUDOD SULPHUD IDVH GH O DFWXDOLW]DFLy L DGDSWDFLy SDUFLDO GH OD 6HFFLy 3ULPHUD GH O ,QYHQWDUL *HQHUDO GHO 3DWULPRQL &XOWXUDO 9DOHQFLj HQ PDWqULD GH SDWULPRQL DUTXLWHFWzQLF L PHGLDPELHQWDOLV¶REULSHUtRGHG¶LQIRUPDFLyS~EOLFD 5HVROXFLyQ GH GH DEULO GH OD 'LUHFFLyQ *HQHUDO GH 3DWULPRQLR &XOWXUDO 9DOHQFLDQR \ 0XVHRV GH OD &RQVHOOHULD GH &XOWXUD (GXFDFLyQ \ 'HSRUWH SRU OD TXH VH LQFRD H[SHGLHQWH SDUD OD SULPHUD IDVH GH OD DFWXDOL]DFLyQ \ DGDSWDFLyQ SDUFLDO GH OD 6HFFLyQ 3ULPHUD GHO ,QYHQWDULR *HQHUDO GHO 3DWULPRQLR &XOWXUDO 9DOHQFLDQR HQ PDWHULD GH SDWULPRQLRDUTXLWHFWyQLFR\PHGLRDPELHQWDO\VHDEUHSHULRGRGHLQIRUPDFLyQSXEOLFD Núm. 5.503 / 02.05.2007 17973 %e'¶,17(5e6&8/785$/±3$/$8'(/6&$7$/¬'(9$/(5,2/$9$/Ê1&,$02180(17 %,(1'(,17(5e6&8/785$/±3$/$&,2'(/26&$7$/¬'(9$/(5,2/$9$/(1&,$02180(172 'HQRPLQDFLy'HQRPLQDFLyQ 3ULQFLSDO3ULQFLSDO 3DODXGHOV&DWDOjGH9DOHULROD 3DODFLRGHORV&DWDOjGH9DOHULROD /RFDOL]DFLy/RFDOL]DFLyQ 3URYtFLD3URYLQFLD9DOqQFLD &RPDUFD&RPDUFDO¶+RUWD 0XQLFLSL0XQLFLSLR9DOqQFLD 8ELFDFLy8ELFDFLyQ3ODoDGH1XOHV 5HIHUHQFLD&DGDVWUDO5HIHUHQFLD&DWDVWUDO ,OOD0DQ]DQD3DUFHOāOD3DUFHOD $QWHFHGHQWV-XUtGLFV$QWHFHGHQWHV-XUtGLFRV ,QFRDFLy,QFRDFLyQ 3XEOLFDFLyGHODLQFRDFLy3XEOLFDFLyQGHODLQFRDFLyQ1R3XEOLFDGR 'HVFULSFLy'HVFULSFLyQ 3DUWV,QWHJUDQWV3DUWHV,QWHJUDQWHV − (GLILFLFRPSRVWGHVHPLVRWHUUDQLSODQWDEDL[DSODQWDSULQFLSDOLVHJRQD(GLILFLRFRPSXHVWRGH VHPLVyWDQRSODQWDEDMDSODQWDSULQFLSDO\VHJXQGD − − )DoDQDSULQFLSDODPEHVFXWQRELOLDULLODWHUDOV)DFKDGDSULQFLSDOFRQHVFXGRQRELOLDULR\ODWHUDOHV 3DWLFHQWUDOLHVFDOHV3DWLRFHQWUDO\HVFDOHUDV 'HVFULSFLy*HQHUDO'HVFULSFLyQ*HQHUDO (O3DODXGHOV&DWDOjGH9DOHULRODLJXDOTXHPROWHVDOWUHVFDVHVSDLUDOVYDOHQFLDQHVpVHOUHVXOWDWGHP~OWLSOHV LQWHUYHQFLRQV L UHIRUPHV TXH V¶KL KDQ UHDOLW]DW GHV GHO VHJOH ;9 ILQV D O DQ\ DQ\ GH O¶~OWLPD UHKDELOLWDFLyLQWHJUDO/ HGLILFLVHJXHL[OHVSDXWHVGHOJzWLFFLYLOV RUJDQLW]DHQWRUQG XQSDWLFHQWUDODPEXQD HVFDODHQDQJOHTXHFRQGXw[DODSODQWDQREOHGHFRUDGDDPEXQDPRWOXUDHQ]LJD]DJD'HODIjEULFDJzWLFD WDQVROVKLUHVWHQDOJXQVHOHPHQWVHVWUXFWXUDOVFRPDUDODUHIHULGDHVFDODHOVDUFVHVFDUVHUVTXHGHOLPLWHQ HOSDWLLODOOLQGDG XQGHOVILQHVWUDOVJHPLQDWV/DJUDQUHIRUPDGHO LPPREOHHQODVHXDFRQILJXUDFLyDFWXDO QRWLQGUjOORFILQVDTXDQHVFRPSUDODFDVDFRQWLJXDLV¶RFXSDJDLUHEpODWRWDOLWDWGHO¶LOODHVUHDOLW]DOD QRYD IDoDQD SULQFLSDO TXH UHFDX D OD SODoD GH 1XOHV L DL[t FDQYLD O RULHQWDFLy GH O HGLILFL $ O H[WHULRU HV UHIOHFWL[HQHOVTXDWUHQLYHOOVWUDGLFLRQDOVHQTXqHVGLYLGL[HQHOVSDODXVYDOHQFLDQVpVDGLUHOVHPLVRWHUUDQL GHGLFDW D PDJDW]HP O HQWUHVzO XWLOLW]DW FRP D SODQWD GH VHUYHLV OD SODQWD QREOH RQ HV WURED OD UHVLGqQFLD VHQ\RULDOLHOSLVDOWRQVHVLWXHQOHVKDELWDFLRQVGHOVFULDWVLHOVSRU[HV7RWHOFRVGHODIDoDQDHVWjFRQVWUXwW HQ IjEULFD GH UDMROD DVVHQWDGD VREUH XQ EDVDPHQW GH FDUUHXV D PDQHUD GH VzFRO GHVWDFDQW HOV JUDQV EDOFRQVGHODSODQWDQREOHUHFRO]DWVVREUHWRUQDSXQWHV /DSRUWDSULQFLSDODPEOOLQGDGHSHGUDSLFDGDGyQDSDVDXQDPSOLYHVWtEXOGLYLGLWHQGRVFUXJLHVSHUXQDUF FDUSDQHOO DO YROWDQW GH O¶HVPHQWDW YHVWtEXO V REULQ GLYHUVHV GHSHQGqQFLHV L OHV GXHV HVFDOHV ODWHUDOV TXH GRQHQSDVDO HQWUHVzOLDODSODQWDSULQFLSDO(QHOVHJOH;,;FDQYLDODSURSLHWDWGHOSDODXSHUODTXDOFRVD O HVFXWSHUWDQ\DODIDPtOLD(VFRIHW$PE ODLQWHUYHQFLyQHRJzWLFDHQ HO SDWL HV YDQ REULU JUDQV EDOFRQDGHV VREUHHOVDUFVHVFDUVHUVLHVYDUHIRUPDUODSRUWDG DFFpVDOSLVSULQFLSDO(QWUHHOLHOHVSRUWDD WHUPHODUHKDELOLWDFLyLQWHJUDOGHO HGLILFLTXHKDDSRUWDWHOGHVFREULPHQWGHWHJLQDWVODUHFRQVWLWXFLyHVSDFLDO G¶HVWDQFHV L OD UHSULVWLQDFLy GHFRUDWLYD L FURPjWLFD GHOV SDUDPHQWV 3RVWHULRUPHQW KD HVWDW DGTXLULW SHU OD *HQHUDOLWDW SHU D ~V DGPLQLVWUDWLX 5HVXP GH O LQIRUPH GHO 6HUYHL GH 3DWULPRQL $UTXLWHFWzQLF L 0HGLDPELHQWDO (OSDODFLRGHORV&DWDOiGH9DOHULRODDOLJXDOTXHRWUDVPXFKDVFDVDVVRODULHJDVYDOHQFLDQDVHVHOIUXWRGH P~OWLSOHV LQWHUYHQFLRQHV \ UHIRUPDV DVt HQ HVWH SDODFLR VH KDQ UHDOL]DGR GHVGH HO VLJOR ;9 KDVWD HO DxR DxRGHODXOWLPDUHKDELOLWDFLyQLQWHJUDO(OHGLILFLRVLJXLHQGRODVSDXWDVGHOJyWLFRFLYLOVHRUJDQL]DHQ WRUQR D XQ SDWLR FHQWUDO FRQ XQD HVFDOHUD HQ iQJXOR TXH FRQGXFH D OD SODQWD QREOH GHFRUDGD FRQ XQD PROGXUDHQ]LJ]DJ'HODIiEULFDJyWLFDWDQVRORQRVUHVWDQDOJXQRVHOHPHQWRVHVWUXFWXUDOHVWDOHVFRPROD UHIHULGD HVFDOHUD ORV DUFRV HVFDU]DQRV TXH GHOLPLWDQ HO SDWLR \ HO GLQWHO GH XQR GH ORV YHQWDQDOHV $11(;,9$1(;2,9 GH 5HVROXFLyGHG DEULOGHOD'LUHFFLy*HQHUDOGH3DWULPRQL&XOWXUDO9DOHQFLjL0XVHXVGHOD&RQVHOOHULDGH&XOWXUD(GXFDFLyL(VSRUWSHUODTXHV LQFRDH[SHGLHQWSHUDOD SULPHUD IDVH GH O DFWXDOLW]DFLy L DGDSWDFLy SDUFLDO GH OD 6HFFLy 3ULPHUD GH O ,QYHQWDUL *HQHUDO GHO 3DWULPRQL &XOWXUDO 9DOHQFLj HQ PDWqULD GH SDWULPRQL DUTXLWHFWzQLF L PHGLDPELHQWDOLV¶REULSHUtRGHG¶LQIRUPDFLyS~EOLFD 5HVROXFLyQ GH GH DEULO GH OD 'LUHFFLyQ *HQHUDO GH 3DWULPRQLR &XOWXUDO 9DOHQFLDQR \ 0XVHRV GH OD &RQVHOOHULD GH &XOWXUD (GXFDFLyQ \ 'HSRUWH SRU OD TXH VH LQFRD H[SHGLHQWH SDUD OD SULPHUD IDVH GH OD DFWXDOL]DFLyQ \ DGDSWDFLyQ SDUFLDO GH OD 6HFFLyQ 3ULPHUD GHO ,QYHQWDULR *HQHUDO GHO 3DWULPRQLR &XOWXUDO 9DOHQFLDQR HQ PDWHULD GH SDWULPRQLRDUTXLWHFWyQLFR\PHGLRDPELHQWDO\VHDEUHSHULRGRGHLQIRUPDFLyQSXEOLFD Núm. 5.503 / 02.05.2007 17974 JHPLQDGRV/DJUDQUHIRUPDGHOLQPXHEOHHQVXFRQILJXUDFLyQDFWXDOQRWHQGUiOXJDUKDVWDFXDQGR VH FRPSUD OD FDVD FRQWLJXD RFXSiQGRVH FDVL OD WRWDOLGDG GH OD PDQ]DQD \ UHDOL]iQGRVH OD QXHYD IDFKDGD SULQFLSDO D OD SOD]D GH 1XOHV FDPELiQGRVH DVt OD RULHQWDFLyQ GHO HGLILFLR 6H UHIOHMDQ DO H[WHULRU ORV FXDWUR QLYHOHVWUDGLFLRQDOHVHQTXHVHGLYLGHQORVSDODFLRVYDOHQFLDQRVFRQHOVHPLVyWDQRGHGLFDGRDDOPDFpQHO HQWUHVXHORXWLOL]DGRFRPRSODQWDGHVHUYLFLRVODSODQWDQREOHGRQGHVHHQFXHQWUDODUHVLGHQFLDVHxRULDO\HO SLVRDOWRHQGRQGHVHVLW~DQODVKDELWDFLRQHVGHORVFULDGRV\ORVGHVYDQHV 7RGR HO FXHUSR GH OD IDFKDGD HVWD FRQVWUXLGR HQ IiEULFD GH ODGULOOR DVHQWDGD VREUH XQ EDVDPHQWR GH VLOODUHVDPRGRGH]yFDORGHVWDFDQGRORVJUDQGHVEDOFRQHVGHODSODQWDQREOHDSR\DGRVVREUHWRUQDSXQWDV /DSXHUWDSULQFLSDOFRQGLQWHOGHFDQWHUtDGDSDVRDXQDPSOLR]DJXiQGLYLGLGRHQGRVFUXMtDVSRUXQDUFR FDUSDQHO DOUHGHGRUGHOFXDOVH DEUHQGLYHUVDVGHSHQGHQFLDV\ODVGRVHVFDOHUDVODWHUDOHVTXHGDQ SDVR DO HQWUHVXHOR \ OD SODQWD SULQFLSDO (Q HO VLJOR ;,; SRU FDPELR GH SURSLHGDG HO HVFXGR SHUWHQHFH D OD IDPLOLD (VFRIHW /D LQWHUYHQFLyQ QHRJyWLFD HQ HO SDWLR HQ HO FXDO VH DEULHURQ JUDQGHV EDOFRQDGDV VREUH ORV DUFRV HVFDU]DQRV \ VH UHIRUPy OD SXHUWD GH DFFHVR DO SLVR SULQFLSDO (QWUH \ VH OOHYD D FDER OD UHKDELOLWDFLyQ LQWHJUDO GHO HGLILFLR DFWXDFLyQ TXH KD DSRUWDGR HO GHVFXEULPLHQWR GH DUWHVRQDGRV OD UHFRQVWLWXFLyQ HVSDFLDO GH GHSHQGHQFLDV \ OD UHSULVWLQDFLyQ GHFRUDWLYD \ FURPiWLFD GH ORV SDUDPHQWRV 3RVWHULRUPHQWH KD VLGR DGTXLULGR SRU OD *HQHUDOLWDW 9DOHQFLDQD SDUD XVR DGPLQLVWUDWLYR 5HVXPHQ GHO LQIRUPHGHO6HUYLFLRGH3DWULPRQLR$UTXLWHFWyQLFR\0HGLRDPELHQWDO 2EVHUYDFLRQV2EVHUYDFLRQHV (QWRUQ(QWRUQ $QWHFHGHQWV DGPLQLVWUDWLXV OD GHOLPLWDFLy GH O HQWRUQ GH SURWHFFLy V DFXOO DO TXH GLVSRVD O $SWDW GH OD 'LVSRVLFLy 7UDQVLWzULD 3ULPHUD GH OD OOHL PRGLILFDGRUD GH OD (VWD GHOLPLWDFLy TXHGD UHFRQHJXGD DPE FDUjFWHU SURYLVLRQDO VHJRQV OD GHOLPLWDFLy FRQWLQJXGD HQ O DQQH[ GHO &DWjOHJ GH %pQV L (VSDLV 3URWHJLWV GHO 3*28 GH 9DOqQFLD GH G DFRUG DPE DOOz TXH V KD HVWDEOLW SHO ³&RQYHQL 0DUF GH &ROāODERUDFLyHQWUHOD*HQHUDOLWDW9DOHQFLDQDLO $MXQWDPHQWGH9DOqQFLDSHUDO'HVSOHJDPHQWL([HFXFLyGHO 3ODQHMDPHQW8UEDQtVWLFGHO&RQMXQW+LVWzULFGHOD&LXWDW´VXEVFULWHOGLDGHMXQ\GHLSXEOLFDWHQHO '2*9GH 2ULJHQ9qUWH[HVWHGHODSDUFHOāODFDGDVWUDOGHO¶LOODGHFDVHVSXQW$ 6HQWLWKRUDUL /tQLD GHOLPLWDGRUD 'HV GH O RULJHQ OD OtQLD HV GLULJL[ DO VXG SHU OD IDoDQD HVW GH O¶LOOD GH FDVHV FDGDVWUDO FUHXDHOFDUUHUGHOV)UDQFLVFDQVLVHJXL[SHUODIDoDQDHVWGHO¶LOODGHFDVHV&UHXDHOFDUUHUGH 6DPDQLHJRLLQFRUSRUDOHVSDUFHOāOHVLGHO¶LOODGHFDVHVODGHODLODGHOD *LUD D RHVW SHU O HL[ GHO FDUUHU GHOV )UDQFLVFDQV L SHU OD IDoDQD RHVW GH OD SDUFHOāOD GH O¶LOOD GH FDVHV 6 LQWURGXw[HQODPDWHL[DSHUODPLWJHUDQRUGGHODSDUFHOāODLFRQWLQXDSHUODGHODILQVHOSXQW G RULJHQ $QWHFHGHQWHVDGPLQLVWUDWLYRVODGHOLPLWDFLyQGHOHQWRUQRGHSURWHFFLyQVHDFRJHDORGLVSXHVWRHQHO$SWGR GHOD'LVSRVLFLyQ7UDQVLWRULD3ULPHUDGHODOH\PRGLILFDGRUDGHOD(VWDGHOLPLWDFLyQTXHGD UHFRQRFLGDFRQFDUiFWHUSURYLVLRQDOVHJ~QODGHOLPLWDFLyQFRQWHQLGDHQHO$QH[RGHO&DWiORJRGH%LHQHV\ (VSDFLRV3URWHJLGRVGHO3*28GH9DOqQFLDGHFRQDUUHJORDORHVWDEOHFLGRSRUHO³&RQYHQLR0DUFRGH &RODERUDFLyQHQWUHOD*HQHUDOLWDW9DOHQFLDQD \HO$\XQWDPLHQWR GH 9DOHQFLD SDUD HO 'HVDUUROOR \ (MHFXFLyQ GHO 3ODQHDPLHQWR 8UEDQtVWLFR GHO &RQMXQWR +LVWyULFR GH OD &LXGDG´ VXVFULWR HO GtD GH MXQLR GH \ SXEOLFDGRHQHO'2*9GH 2ULJHQ9pUWLFHHVWHGHODSDUFHODFDWDVWUDOGHODPDQ]DQDSXQWR$ 6HQWLGRKRUDULR /tQHD GHOLPLWDGRUD 'HVGH HO RULJHQ OD OtQHD VH GLULJH D VXU SRU OD IDFKDGD HVWH GH OD PDQ]DQD FDWDVWUDO FUX]D OD FDOOH )UDQFLVFDQRV \ VLJXH SRU OD IDFKDGD HVWH GH OD PDQ]DQD &UX]D OD FDOOH 6DPDQLHJRHLQFRUSRUDODVSDUFHODV\GHODPDQ]DQDODGHOD\ODGHODSDUFHOD *LUD D RHVWH SRU HO HMH GH OD FDOOH )UDQFLVFDQRV \ SRU OD IDFKDGD RHVWH GH OD SDUFHOD GH OD PDQ]DQD6HLQWURGXFHHQODPLVPDSRUODPHGLDQHUDQRUWH GHODSDUFHOD\FRQWLQXDSRUODGHOD KDVWDHOSXQWRGHRULJHQ $11(;,9$1(;2,9 GH 5HVROXFLyGHG DEULOGHOD'LUHFFLy*HQHUDOGH3DWULPRQL&XOWXUDO9DOHQFLjL0XVHXVGHOD&RQVHOOHULDGH&XOWXUD(GXFDFLyL(VSRUWSHUODTXHV LQFRDH[SHGLHQWSHUDOD SULPHUD IDVH GH O DFWXDOLW]DFLy L DGDSWDFLy SDUFLDO GH OD 6HFFLy 3ULPHUD GH O ,QYHQWDUL *HQHUDO GHO 3DWULPRQL &XOWXUDO 9DOHQFLj HQ PDWqULD GH SDWULPRQL DUTXLWHFWzQLF L PHGLDPELHQWDOLV¶REULSHUtRGHG¶LQIRUPDFLyS~EOLFD 5HVROXFLyQ GH GH DEULO GH OD 'LUHFFLyQ *HQHUDO GH 3DWULPRQLR &XOWXUDO 9DOHQFLDQR \ 0XVHRV GH OD &RQVHOOHULD GH &XOWXUD (GXFDFLyQ \ 'HSRUWH SRU OD TXH VH LQFRD H[SHGLHQWH SDUD OD SULPHUD IDVH GH OD DFWXDOL]DFLyQ \ DGDSWDFLyQ SDUFLDO GH OD 6HFFLyQ 3ULPHUD GHO ,QYHQWDULR *HQHUDO GHO 3DWULPRQLR &XOWXUDO 9DOHQFLDQR HQ PDWHULD GH SDWULPRQLRDUTXLWHFWyQLFR\PHGLRDPELHQWDO\VHDEUHSHULRGRGHLQIRUPDFLyQSXEOLFD Núm. 5.503 / 02.05.2007 17975 %e'¶,17(5e6&8/785$/±3$/$8'(/6&$7$/¬'(9$/(5,2/$9$/Ê1&,$02180(17 %,(1'(,17(5e6&8/785$/±3$/$&,2'(/26&$7$/¬'(9$/(5,2/$9$/(1&,$02180(172 $11(;,9$1(;2,9 GH 5HVROXFLyGHG DEULOGHOD'LUHFFLy*HQHUDOGH3DWULPRQL&XOWXUDO9DOHQFLjL0XVHXVGHOD&RQVHOOHULDGH&XOWXUD(GXFDFLyL(VSRUWSHUODTXHV LQFRDH[SHGLHQWSHUDOD SULPHUD IDVH GH O DFWXDOLW]DFLy L DGDSWDFLy SDUFLDO GH OD 6HFFLy 3ULPHUD GH O ,QYHQWDUL *HQHUDO GHO 3DWULPRQL &XOWXUDO 9DOHQFLj HQ PDWqULD GH SDWULPRQL DUTXLWHFWzQLF L PHGLDPELHQWDOLV¶REULSHUtRGHG¶LQIRUPDFLyS~EOLFD 5HVROXFLyQ GH GH DEULO GH OD 'LUHFFLyQ *HQHUDO GH 3DWULPRQLR &XOWXUDO 9DOHQFLDQR \ 0XVHRV GH OD &RQVHOOHULD GH &XOWXUD (GXFDFLyQ \ 'HSRUWH SRU OD TXH VH LQFRD H[SHGLHQWH SDUD OD SULPHUD IDVH GH OD DFWXDOL]DFLyQ \ DGDSWDFLyQ SDUFLDO GH OD 6HFFLyQ 3ULPHUD GHO ,QYHQWDULR *HQHUDO GHO 3DWULPRQLR &XOWXUDO 9DOHQFLDQR HQ PDWHULD GH SDWULPRQLRDUTXLWHFWyQLFR\PHGLRDPELHQWDO\VHDEUHSHULRGRGHLQIRUPDFLyQSXEOLFD Núm. 5.503 / 02.05.2007 %e'¶,17(5e6&8/785$/±6$178$5,'(/$0$5('('e8'(/(69,578769,//(1$02180(17 %,(1'(,17(5e6&8/785$/±6$178$5,2'(18(675$6(f25$'(/$69,578'(69,//(1$02180(172 'HQRPLQDFLy'HQRPLQDFLyQ 3ULQFLSDO3ULQFLSDO 6DQWXDULGHµ1XHVWUD6HxRUDGHODV9LUWXGHV¶OD 0DUHGH'pXGHOHV9LUWXWV 6DQWXDULRGH1XHVWUD6HxRUDGHODV9LUWXGHV $FFHVzULD$FFHVRULD 0RQHVWLUGHµODV9LUWXGHV¶OHV9LUWXWV 0RQDVWHULRGHODV9LUWXGHV /RFDOL]DFLy/RFDOL]DFLyQ 3URYtQFLD3URYLQFLD$ODFDQW &RPDUFD&RPDUFD/¶$OW9LQDORSy 0XQLFLSL0XQLFLSLR9LOOHQD 8ELFDFLy8ELFDFLyQ&WUD$3$YG 6DQWXDULR 5HIHUqQFLD&DGDVWUDO5HIHUHQFLD&DWDVWUDO <+13ROtJRQ3ROtJRQR $QWHFHGHQWV-XUtGLFV$QWHFHGHQWHV-XUtGLFRV ,QFRDFLy,QFRDFLyQ 3XEOLFDFLyGHODLQFRDFLy3XEOLFDFLyQGHODLQFRDFLyQ%2( 'HVFULSFLy'HVFULSFLyQ 3DUWV,QWHJUDQWV3DUWHV,QWHJUDQWHV − (VJOpVLD,JOHVLD − &ODXVWUH&ODXVWUR − 'HSHQGHQFLHVPRQDFDOV'HSHQGHQFLDVPRQDFDOHV 'HVFULSFLy*HQHUDO'HVFULSFLyQ*HQHUDO (VWHVDQWXDUL HVWUREDHQXQ SDUDWJHMXQW DXQD OODFXQD DFWXDOPHQW GHVVHFDGD D XQV TXLOzPHWUHV GH OD FLXWDWSUz[LPDODµ)XHQWHGHO&KRSR¶6HPEODTXHHOVHXRULJHQYDVHUXQDHUPLWDGHILQDOVGHOVHJOH;,9 GHODTXDOKLURPDQHQUHVWHVHQODFULSWD3RVWHULRUPHQWYDVHURFXSDWSHOVPRQMRVDJXVWLQV/DLPDWJHTXH RIHUL[KXLHOVDQWXDULGDWDGHOVHJOH;9,GHO¶DQ\VHJRQVODGDWDLQVFULWDHQXQDFODXGHO HVJOpVLD 6 DFFHGL[DOFRQMXQWGHVGHOFRVWDWHVWRQHVWUREDODSRUWDGDUHQDL[HQWLVWDTXHHVGLYLGL[HQGRVFRVVRVHO FRV LQIHULRU DPE XQ DUF GH PLJ SXQW HQWUH FROXPQHV FRPSRVWHV VREUH XQ EDVDPHQW 8Q IULV GHFRUDW DPE HOHPHQWV ILJXUDWLXV L DQWURSRPRUIV GyQD SDV DO FRV VXSHULRU TXH Wp HQ OD SDUW FHQWUDO XQD IRUQtFXOD DYHQHUDGDRQHVWUREDODLPDWJHGHOD0DUHGH'pXGHOHV9LUWXWV(VWjUHDOLW]DGDHQSHGUDDPEGHFRUDFLy HQEDL[RVUHOOHXVGHJDUODQGHVLPHGDOORQVDPEILJXUHVFDUDFWHUtVWLFGHO HVWLOUHQDL[HQWLVWD / DFFpV FRQGXw[ DO SDWL UHFWDQJXODU GH GRV SLVRV /D SDUW EDL[D V RUGHQD DPE DUFV FDUSDQHOOV UHDOLW]DWV HQ UDMROD (O SLV VXSHULRU SUHVHQWD ILQHVWUHV EDOFRQHUHV /HV JDOHULHV GHO FODXVWUH HV FREUL[HQ DPE UHYROWRQV L ELJDPGHIXVWDFDUDYLVWD / HVJOpVLD FRQVWD G XQD QDX SULQFLSDO L GRV ODWHUDOV PpV [LFRWHWHV (VWj GLYLGLGD HQ WUHV WUDPV DPE XQ FDPEULO D OD GUHWD GH O DOWDU L FRU DOW DOV SHXV / DFFpV HV UHDOLW]D SHO FODXVWUH DO VHJRQ WUDP GHO FRVWDW GH O HStVWRODHOGHODGUHWD$UFVDSXQWDWVVHSDUHQHOVWUDPVFREHUWVDPEYROWHVGHFUHXHULDTXHUHFRO]HQHQ PqQVXOHV TXH GRQHQ HQ SLODUV TXDGUDQJXODUV $O FRVWDW GH O DOWDU HV WURED HO FDPEULO GH OD 0DUH GH 'pX G HVWLO EDUURF UHDOLW]DW HQ HO VHJOH ;9,, L GH SODQWD TXDGUDGD HVWj GHFRUDW D EDVH G HVWXFV L SLQWXUHV TXH FREUL[HQWRWO HVSDL/HVSLQWXUHVVyQGHOVHJOH;9,,, $O H[WHULRUV DGYHUWL[HQHOVFRQWUDIRUWVGHO HVJOpVLDHOFDPSDQDUGHUHGXwGHVGLPHQVLRQVLOD[LFRWHWDF~SXOD GHOFDPEULO%DVDWHQHO&DWjOHJGH0RQXPHQWVL&RQMXQWVGHOD&RPXQLWDW9DOHQFLDQD (Q XQ SDUDMH MXQWR D XQD ODJXQD DFWXDOPHQWH GHVHFDGD D XQRV NLOyPHWURV GH OD FLXGDG FHUFDQR D OD )XHQWH GHO &KRSR VH HQFXHQWUD HVWH VDQWXDULR 3DUHFH VHU TXH HO RULJHQ IXH XQD HUPLWD GH ILQHV GHO VLJOR ;,9GHODKR\TXHGDQUHVWRVHQODFULSWD3RVWHULRUPHQWHIXHRFXSDGRSRUORVPRQMHVDJXVWLQRV/DLPDJHQ TXHRIUHFHKR\HOVDQWXDULRGDWDGHOVLJOR;9,VHJ~QODIHFKDLQVFULWDHQXQDFODYHGHODLJOHVLD 6HDFFHGHDOFRQMXQWRGHVGHHOODGRHVWHGRQGHVHHQFXHQWUDODSRUWDGDUHQDFHQWLVWDeVWDVHGLYLGHHQGRV FXHUSRVHOLQIHULRUFRQXQDUFRGHPHGLRSXQWRHQWUHFROXPQDVFRPSXHVWDVVREUHXQEDVDPHQWR8QIULVR GHFRUDGR FRQ HOHPHQWRV ILJXUDWLYRV \ DQWURSRPRUIRV GD SDVR DO FXHUSR VXSHULRU TXH WLHQH HQ OD SDUWH $11(;,9$1(;2,9 GH 5HVROXFLyGHG DEULOGHOD'LUHFFLy*HQHUDOGH3DWULPRQL&XOWXUDO9DOHQFLjL0XVHXVGHOD&RQVHOOHULDGH&XOWXUD(GXFDFLyL(VSRUWSHUODTXHV LQFRDH[SHGLHQWSHUDOD SULPHUD IDVH GH O DFWXDOLW]DFLy L DGDSWDFLy SDUFLDO GH OD 6HFFLy 3ULPHUD GH O ,QYHQWDUL *HQHUDO GHO 3DWULPRQL &XOWXUDO 9DOHQFLj HQ PDWqULD GH SDWULPRQL DUTXLWHFWzQLF L PHGLDPELHQWDOLV¶REULSHUtRGHG¶LQIRUPDFLyS~EOLFD 5HVROXFLyQ GH GH DEULO GH OD 'LUHFFLyQ *HQHUDO GH 3DWULPRQLR &XOWXUDO 9DOHQFLDQR \ 0XVHRV GH OD &RQVHOOHULD GH &XOWXUD (GXFDFLyQ \ 'HSRUWH SRU OD TXH VH LQFRD H[SHGLHQWH SDUD OD SULPHUD IDVH GH OD DFWXDOL]DFLyQ \ DGDSWDFLyQ SDUFLDO GH OD 6HFFLyQ 3ULPHUD GHO ,QYHQWDULR *HQHUDO GHO 3DWULPRQLR &XOWXUDO 9DOHQFLDQR HQ PDWHULD GH SDWULPRQLRDUTXLWHFWyQLFR\PHGLRDPELHQWDO\VHDEUHSHULRGRGHLQIRUPDFLyQSXEOLFD 17976 Núm. 5.503 / 02.05.2007 FHQWUDOXQDKRUQDFLQDDYHQHUDGDGRQGHVHHQFXHQWUDODLPDJHQGHODYLUJHQGHODV9LUWXGHV(VWiUHDOL]DGD HQSLHGUDFRQ GHFRUDFLyQ HQ EDMRUUHOLHYHV GH JXLUQDOGDV \ PHGDOORQHV FRQ ILJXUDV FDUDFWHUtVWLFR GHO HVWLOR UHQDFHQWLVWD (O DFFHVR FRQGXFH DO SDWLR UHFWDQJXODU GH GRV SLVRV /D SDUWH EDMD VH RUGHQD PHGLDQWH DUFRV FDUSDQHOHV UHDOL]DGRVHQODGULOOR(OSLVRVXSHULRUSUHVHQWDYHQWDQDVEDOFRQHUDV/DVJDOHUtDVGHOFODXVWURVHFXEUHQFRQ UHYROWRQHV\YLJDVGHPDGHUDFDUDYLVWD /DLJOHVLDFRQVWDGHXQDQDYHSULQFLSDO\GRVODWHUDOHVGHPHQRUWDPDxR(VWiGLYLGLGDHQWUHVWUDPRVFRQ XQFDPDUtQDODGHUHFKDGHODOWDU\FRURDOWRDORVSLHV(ODFFHVRVHUHDOL]DSRUHOFODXVWURDOVHJXQGRWUDPR GHO ODGR GH OD (StVWROD HO GH OD GHUHFKD $UFRV DSXQWDGRV VHSDUDQ ORV WUDPRV FXELHUWRV FRQ EyYHGDV GH FUXFHUtD TXH DSR\DQ HQ PpQVXODV UHFD\HQWHV HQ SLODUHV FXDGUDQJXODUHV $O ODGR GHO DOWDU VH HQFXHQWUD HO FDPDUtQ GH OD 9LUJHQ GH HVWLOR EDUURFR UHDOL]DGR HQ HO VLJOR ;9,, \ GH SODQWD FXDGUDGD HVWi GHFRUDGR D EDVHGHHVWXFRV\SLQWXUDVTXHFXEUHQWRGRHOHVSDFLR/DVSLQWXUDVVRQGHOVLJOR;9,,, $OH[WHULRUVHDGYLHUWHQORVFRQWUDIXHUWHVGHODLJOHVLDHOFDPSDQDULRGHUHGXFLGDVGLPHQVLRQHV\ODSHTXHxD F~SXODGHOFDPDUtQ%DVDGRHQHO&DWiORJRGH0RQXPHQWRV\&RQMXQWRVGHOD&RPXQLGDG9DOHQFLDQD 2EVHUYDFLRQV2EVHUYDFLRQHV (QWRUQ(QWRUQ $QWHFHGHQWVDGPLQLVWUDWLXVGHOLPLWDFLyH[WUHWDGHO H[SHGLHQWGHILQLGDDPEFDUjFWHUSURYLVLRQDO 2ULJHQLQWHUVHFFLyGHO DYLQJXGDGHOVDQWXDULDPEHOGHOFDPtGH&DXGHWHD6DOLQDVSXQW$ 6HQWLWKRUDUL /tQLDGHOLPLWDGRUDODOtQLDVHJXL[SHUO HL[GHO DYLQJXGDGHOµ6DQWXDULR¶LJLUDUHFRUUHQWOHVIDoDQHVVXGRHVW GHOHVSDUFHOāODLGHO¶LOODFDGDVWUDO&UHXDHVWDLOODSHUOHVSDUWVGHOGDUUHUHGHOHVSDUFHOāOHVL JLUDDOVXGRHVWSHUO HL[GHOFDUUHUILQVDOFDPtGH&DXGHWHD6DOLQDVSHOTXDOVHJXL[DOVXGHVWILQVDOD VHXDLQWHUVHFFLyDPEXQDFLUFXPIHUqQFLDYLUWXDOGHUDGLPDPEFHQWUHHQHOFDQWyVXGGHO HGLILFLGHO 6DQWXDULLSHUDTXHVWDILQVDODVHXDWUREDGDDPEXQDDOWUDFLUFXPIHUqQFLDYLUWXDOGHUDGLPDPEFHQWUH HQHOYqUWH[RHVWGHOGLW6DQWXDUL*LUDSHUDTXHVWDVHJRQDFLUFXPIHUqQFLDILQVDO HL[GHOFDPtGH&DXGHWHD 6DOLQDVLFRQWLQXDSHUHOOILQVDOSXQWG RULJHQ $QWHFHGHQWHVDGPLQLVWUDWLYRVGHOLPLWDFLyQH[WUDtGDGHOH[SHGLHQWHGHILQLGDFRQFDUiFWHUSURYLVLRQDO 2ULJHQLQWHUVHFFLyQGHODDYHQLGDGHO6DQWXDULRFRQHOGHOFDPLQRGH&DXGHWHD6DOLQDVSXQWR$ 6HQWLGRKRUDULR /tQHD GHOLPLWDGRUD OD OtQHD VLJXH SRU HO HMH GH OD DYHQLGD GHO 6DQWXDULR \ JLUD UHFRUULHQGR ODV IDFKDGDV VXGRHVWHGHODVSDUFHOD\GHODPDQ]DQDFDWDVWUDO&UX]DHVWDPDQ]DQDSRUODVWUDVHUDVGHODV SDUFHODV \ JLUD D VXURHVWH SRU HO HMH GH OD FDOOH KDVWD HO FDPLQR GH &DXGHWH D 6DOLQDV SRU HO TXH VLJXH D VXGHVWH KDVWD VX LQWHUVHFFLyQ FRQ XQD FLUFXQIHUHQFLD YLUWXDO GH UDGLR P FRQ FHQWUR HQ OD HVTXLQDVXUGHOHGLILFLRGHO6DQWXDULR\SRUpVWDKDVWDVXHQFXHQWURFRQRWUDFLUFXQIHUHQFLDYLUWXDOGHUDGLR PFRQFHQWURHQHOYpUWLFHRHVWHGHGLFKR6DQWXDULR*LUDSRUHVWDVHJXQGDFLUFXQIHUHQFLDKDVWDHOHMH GHOFDPLQRGH&DXGHWHD6DOLQDV\VLJXHSRUpOKDVWDHOSXQWRGHRULJHQ $11(;,9$1(;2,9 GH 5HVROXFLyGHG DEULOGHOD'LUHFFLy*HQHUDOGH3DWULPRQL&XOWXUDO9DOHQFLjL0XVHXVGHOD&RQVHOOHULDGH&XOWXUD(GXFDFLyL(VSRUWSHUODTXHV LQFRDH[SHGLHQWSHUDOD SULPHUD IDVH GH O DFWXDOLW]DFLy L DGDSWDFLy SDUFLDO GH OD 6HFFLy 3ULPHUD GH O ,QYHQWDUL *HQHUDO GHO 3DWULPRQL &XOWXUDO 9DOHQFLj HQ PDWqULD GH SDWULPRQL DUTXLWHFWzQLF L PHGLDPELHQWDOLV¶REULSHUtRGHG¶LQIRUPDFLyS~EOLFD 5HVROXFLyQ GH GH DEULO GH OD 'LUHFFLyQ *HQHUDO GH 3DWULPRQLR &XOWXUDO 9DOHQFLDQR \ 0XVHRV GH OD &RQVHOOHULD GH &XOWXUD (GXFDFLyQ \ 'HSRUWH SRU OD TXH VH LQFRD H[SHGLHQWH SDUD OD SULPHUD IDVH GH OD DFWXDOL]DFLyQ \ DGDSWDFLyQ SDUFLDO GH OD 6HFFLyQ 3ULPHUD GHO ,QYHQWDULR *HQHUDO GHO 3DWULPRQLR &XOWXUDO 9DOHQFLDQR HQ PDWHULD GH SDWULPRQLRDUTXLWHFWyQLFR\PHGLRDPELHQWDO\VHDEUHSHULRGRGHLQIRUPDFLyQSXEOLFD 17977 Núm. 5.503 / 02.05.2007 %e'¶,17(5e6&8/785$/±6$178$5,'(/$0$5('('e8'(/(69,578769,//(1$02180(17 %,(1'(,17(5e6&8/785$/±6$178$5,2'(18(675$6(f25$'(/$69,578'(69,//(1$02180(172 $11(;,9$1(;2,9 GH 5HVROXFLyGHG DEULOGHOD'LUHFFLy*HQHUDOGH3DWULPRQL&XOWXUDO9DOHQFLjL0XVHXVGHOD&RQVHOOHULDGH&XOWXUD(GXFDFLyL(VSRUWSHUODTXHV LQFRDH[SHGLHQWSHUDOD SULPHUD IDVH GH O DFWXDOLW]DFLy L DGDSWDFLy SDUFLDO GH OD 6HFFLy 3ULPHUD GH O ,QYHQWDUL *HQHUDO GHO 3DWULPRQL &XOWXUDO 9DOHQFLj HQ PDWqULD GH SDWULPRQL DUTXLWHFWzQLF L PHGLDPELHQWDOLV¶REULSHUtRGHG¶LQIRUPDFLyS~EOLFD 5HVROXFLyQ GH GH DEULO GH OD 'LUHFFLyQ *HQHUDO GH 3DWULPRQLR &XOWXUDO 9DOHQFLDQR \ 0XVHRV GH OD &RQVHOOHULD GH &XOWXUD (GXFDFLyQ \ 'HSRUWH SRU OD TXH VH LQFRD H[SHGLHQWH SDUD OD SULPHUD IDVH GH OD DFWXDOL]DFLyQ \ DGDSWDFLyQ SDUFLDO GH OD 6HFFLyQ 3ULPHUD GHO ,QYHQWDULR *HQHUDO GHO 3DWULPRQLR &XOWXUDO 9DOHQFLDQR HQ PDWHULD GH SDWULPRQLRDUTXLWHFWyQLFR\PHGLRDPELHQWDO\VHDEUHSHULRGRGHLQIRUPDFLyQSXEOLFD 17978 Núm. 5.503 / 02.05.2007 %e'¶,17(5e6&8/785$/±(6*/e6,$3$55248,$/'(/¶$66803&,Ï'(/$0$5('('e8 9,67$%(//$'(/0$(675$702180(17 %,(1'(,17(5e6&8/785$/±,*/(6,$3$55248,$/'(/$$681&,Ï1'(18(675$6(f25$ 9,67$%(//$'(/0$(675$=*202180(172 'HQRPLQDFLy'HQRPLQDFLyQ 3ULQFLSDO3ULQFLSDO (VJOpVLD3DUURTXLDOGHO¶$VVXPSFLyGHOD0DUHGH 'pX ,JOHVLD3DUURTXLDOGHOD$VXQFLyQGH1XHVWUD6HxRUD /RFDOL]DFLy/RFDOL]DFLyQ 3URYtQFLD3URYLQFLD&DVWHOOy &RPDUFD&RPDUFD/ $OFDODWpQ 0XQLFLSL0XQLFLSLR9LVWDEHOODGHO0DHVWUD]JR 8ELFDFLy8ELFDFLyQ3ODoDGHO¶(VJOpVLD 5HIHUqQFLD&DGDVWUDO5HIHUHQFLD&DWDVWUDO ,OOD0DQ]DQD3DUFHOāOD3DUFHOD $QWHFHGHQWV-XUtGLFV$QWHFHGHQWHV-XUtGLFRV ,QFRDFLy,QFRDFLyQ 3XEOLFDFLyGHODLQFRDFLy3XEOLFDFLyQGHODLQFRDFLyQ'2*9%2( 'HVFULSFLy'HVFULSFLyQ 3DUWV,QWHJUDQWV3DUWHV,QWHJUDQWHV − 3RUWDGHV3RUWDGDV − 7RUUHFDPSDQDU7RUUHFDPSDQDULR − 1DXV1DYHV 'HVFULSFLy*HQHUDO'HVFULSFLyQ*HQHUDO $O ILQDO GHO FDUUHU 0DMRU V REUL OD SODoD GH O (VJOpVLD HQ TXq HV WURED HVWH PRQXPHQWDO HGLILFL eV XQ GHOV PLOORUVWHPSOHVG XQOODUJHSLVRGLDUTXLWHFWzQLFTXHHVGHVHQYROXSDHQO DUTXLWHFWXUDYDOHQFLDQDGHVGHILQDOV GHO VHJOH ;9, ILQV PLWMDQ GHO VHJOH ;9,, L TXH VyQ ERQ H[HPSOH OHV HVJOpVLHV SDUURTXLDOV GH 9LODIUDQFD 7UDLJXHUD/D-DQD;HUWL&DQHWOR5RLJHQWUHG¶DOWUHV(QWRWHVHOOHVHOOOHQJXDWJHLO RUGUHUHQDL[HQWLVWDHV FRPELQDDPEVROXFLRQVFRQVWUXFWLYHVGHWUDGLFLyJzWLFDFRPODYROWDGHFUHXHULD / HVJOpVLD pV GH WUHV QDXV DPE SUHVELWHUL KXLWDYDW L GHDPEXODWRUL TXHGDQW OD VHXD SODQWD LQVFULWD HQ XQ UHFWDQJOH3RVVHw[XQDQDXFHQWUDOLGXHVODWHUDOVGHFLQFWUDPVLO ~OWLPGHODFHQWUDOHVWDQFDIRUPDQWDEVLV SROLJRQDO 'DUUHUH XQ GHDPEXODWRUL FREHUW DPE YROWD GH FDQy (V FREUL[ DPE YROWHV GH FUHXHULD TXH VyQ VLPSOHV HQ OHV QDXV ODWHUDOV L DPE WHUFHOHWV HQ OD FHQWUDO L FDSHOOHV GH OD FDSoDOHUD L DPE WHUFHOHWV OOLJDGXUHV L FDGHQHV HQ O DEVLV (O GHDPEXODWRUL TXHGD FREHUW HQ HOV VHXV WUHV WUDPV SHU GXHV YROWHV GH FUHXHULD GLIHUHQWV XQD G HOOHV WUHQFDGD SHU OD FODUDERLD EDUURFD D PDQHUD GH WUDQVSDUHQW L XQD YROWD GH FDVVHWRQV7pODWRUUHVLWXDGDDOVSHXVLGXHVFDSHOOHVLVDJULVWLHVHQODFDSoDOHUD /DSRUWDGDSULQFLSDOHVGLVSRVDDPDQHUDGHIDoDQDUHWDXOHGHWUHVSLVRVLV DOEHUJDGDYDOOXQQtQ[ROTXHHV WDQFDSHUXQDUFDSXQWDW/DVLWXDGDDOVSHXVLGDYDOOODWRUUHTXHGDSURWHJLGDDL[tPDWHL[SHUXQQtQ[ROTXH HVWDQFDSHUXQDUFGHPLJSXQW /D WRUUHFDPSDQDU V DOoD VREUH O DQJOH VXGRHVW GHO FRV SULQFLSDO eV GH SODQWD UHFWDQJXODU (OV VHXV SDUDPHQWV G DQJOH VyQ SURORQJDFLy GHOV PXUV ODWHUDO L WHVWHUD GH O HGLILFL 3UHVHQWD XQ FRV VXSHULRU GH FDPSDQHVUHPDWDWSHUjWLFSHULPHWUDWDPEEDUDQDDSLODVWUDGD/DIjEULFDpVGHFDUUHXVDPEO¶H[FHSFLyGHO PXUGHO HYDQJHOL6HUYLFLGH3DWULPRQL$UTXLWHFWzQLFL0HGLDPELHQWDO $OILQDOGHODFDOOH0D\RUVHDEUHODSOD]DGHOD,JOHVLDHQODTXHVHHQFXHQWUDHVWHPRQXPHQWDOHGLILFLR(V XQR GH ORV PHMRUHV WHPSORV GH XQ ODUJR HSLVRGLR DUTXLWHFWyQLFR TXH VH GHVDUUROOD HQ OD DUTXLWHFWXUD YDOHQFLDQD GHVGH ILQDOHV GHO VLJOR ;9, KDVWD PHGLDGRV GHO VLJOR ;9,, \ GH TXH VRQ EXHQ HMHPSOR ODV SDUURTXLDOHVGH9LODIUDQFD7UDLJXHUD/D-DQD;HUW&DQHWOR5RLJHQWUHRWUDV(QWRGDVHOODVHOOHQJXDMH\ HO RUGHQ UHQDFHQWLVWD VH FRPELQD FRQ VROXFLRQHV FRQVWUXFWLYDV GH WUDGLFLyQ JyWLFD FRPR OD EyYHGD GH FUXFHUtD /D LJOHVLD HV GH WUHV QDYHV FRQ SUHVELWHULR RFKDYDGR \ GHDPEXODWRULR TXHGDQGR VX SODQWD LQVFULWD HQ XQ UHFWiQJXOR 3RVHH XQD QDYH FHQWUDO \ GRV ODWHUDOHV GH FLQFR WUDPRV \ HO ~OWLPR GH OD FHQWUDO VH FLHUUD IRUPDQGRiEVLGHSROLJRQDO'HWUiVXQGHDPEXODWRULRFXELHUWRFRQEyYHGDGHFDxyQ6HFXEUHFRQEyYHGDV GHFUXFHUtDTXHVRQVLPSOHVHQODVQDYHVODWHUDOHV\FRQWHUFHOHWHVHQODFHQWUDO\FDSLOODVGHODFDEHFHUD\ $11(;,9$1(;2,9 GH 5HVROXFLyGHG DEULOGHOD'LUHFFLy*HQHUDOGH3DWULPRQL&XOWXUDO9DOHQFLjL0XVHXVGHOD&RQVHOOHULDGH&XOWXUD(GXFDFLyL(VSRUWSHUODTXHV LQFRDH[SHGLHQWSHUDOD SULPHUD IDVH GH O DFWXDOLW]DFLy L DGDSWDFLy SDUFLDO GH OD 6HFFLy 3ULPHUD GH O ,QYHQWDUL *HQHUDO GHO 3DWULPRQL &XOWXUDO 9DOHQFLj HQ PDWqULD GH SDWULPRQL DUTXLWHFWzQLF L PHGLDPELHQWDOLV¶REULSHUtRGHG¶LQIRUPDFLyS~EOLFD 5HVROXFLyQ GH GH DEULO GH OD 'LUHFFLyQ *HQHUDO GH 3DWULPRQLR &XOWXUDO 9DOHQFLDQR \ 0XVHRV GH OD &RQVHOOHULD GH &XOWXUD (GXFDFLyQ \ 'HSRUWH SRU OD TXH VH LQFRD H[SHGLHQWH SDUD OD SULPHUD IDVH GH OD DFWXDOL]DFLyQ \ DGDSWDFLyQ SDUFLDO GH OD 6HFFLyQ 3ULPHUD GHO ,QYHQWDULR *HQHUDO GHO 3DWULPRQLR &XOWXUDO 9DOHQFLDQR HQ PDWHULD GH SDWULPRQLRDUTXLWHFWyQLFR\PHGLRDPELHQWDO\VHDEUHSHULRGRGHLQIRUPDFLyQSXEOLFD 17979 Núm. 5.503 / 02.05.2007 FRQ WHUFHOHWHV OLJDGXUDV \ FDGHQDV HQ HO iEVLGH (O GHDPEXODWRULR TXHGD FXELHUWR HQ VXV WUHV WUDPRV SRU GRVEyYHGDVGHFUXFHUtDGLIHUHQWHVXQDGHHOODVURWDSRUHOOXFHUQDULREDUURFRDPRGRGHWUDQVSDUHQWH\ XQD EyYHGD GH FDVHWRQHV 7LHQH OD WRUUH VLWXDGD D ORV SLHV \ GRV FDSLOODV \ VDFULVWtDV HQ OD FDEHFHUD /D SRUWDGD SULQFLSDO VH GLVSRQH D PRGR GH IDFKDGD UHWDEOR GH WUHV SLVRV \ VH DOEHUJD EDMR XQ QLFKR TXH VH FLHUUD SRUXQDUFRDSXQWDGR /D VLWXDGDD ORV SLHV \EDMRODWRUUHTXHGD SURWHJLGD DVLPLVPR SRU XQ QLFKR TXH VH FLHUUD SRU XQ DUFR GH PHGLR SXQWR /D WRUUHFDPSDQDULR VH OHYDQWD VREUH HO iQJXOR VXGRHVWH GHO FXHUSRSULQFLSDO(VGHSODQWDUHFWDQJXODU6XVSDUDPHQWRVGHiQJXORVRQSURORQJDFLyQGHORVPXURVODWHUDO \ WHVWHUR GHO HGLILFLR 3UHVHQWD XQ FXHUSR VXSHULRU GH FDPSDQDV UHPDWDGR SRU iWLFR SHULPHWUDGR FRQ DQWHSHFKRDSLODVWUDGR/DIiEULFDHVGHVLOOHUtDDH[FHSFLyQGHOPXURGHOHYDQJHOLR6HUYLFLRGH3DWULPRQLR $UTXLWHFWyQLFR\0HGLRDPELHQWDO 2EVHUYDFLRQV2EVHUYDFLRQHV (QWRUQ(QWRUQ $QWHFHGHQWV DGPLQLVWUDWLXV OD GHOLPLWDFLy GH O HQWRUQ GH SURWHFFLy V DFXOO DO TXH GLVSRVD O $SWDW GH OD 'LVSRVLFLy 7UDQVLWzULD 3ULPHUD GH OD OOHL PRGLILFDGRUD GH OD (VWD GHOLPLWDFLy TXHGD UHFRQHJXGDDPEFDUjFWHUSURYLVLRQDOVHJRQV OD GHOLPLWDFLy FRQWLQJXGD HQ OD UHVROXFLy GH GH IHEUHU GH SXEOLFDGDHQHO'2*9GHGDWD 2ULJHQLQWHUVHFFLyHQWUHXQDOtQLDYLUWXDOSDUDOāOHODDODFDUUHWHUD GH0RVTXHUXHODD/D)RLDDPGHOD PDWHL[DDPEODSURORQJDFLyGHODPLWJHUDQRUGGHODSDUFHOāODGHO¶LOODGHFDVHVFDGDVWUDOSXQW$ 6HQWLWDQWLKRUDUL /tQLDGHOLPLWDGRUDGHVGHO RULJHQODOtQLDVHJXL[DO¶RHVWSHUODSURORQJDFLyGHODPLWJHUDQRUGGHODSDUFHOāOD GH O¶LOOD GH FDVHV ILQV D FRQWLQXDU SHU OD SRVWHULRU G HVWD SDUFHOāOD L SHU OD PLWJHUD HQWUH OHV SDUFHOāOHVLG HVWDLOOD$UULEDILQVO HL[GHOFDUUHUGHO*HQHUDO0RODLSHUHOOHVGLULJL[DOVXGLQWURGXLQW VHHQO¶LOODGHFDVHVSHUODPLWJHUDHQWUHOHVSDUFHOāOHVLHQJOREDQWOHVL&UHXDHO FDUUHU0DMRULLQFRUSRUDOHVSDUFHOāOHVLGHO¶LOODGHFDVHVLOHVLGH O¶LOOD7UDYHVVDO¶LOODHQWUHOHVSDUFHOāOHVLLODLOD9RUHMDOHVIDoDQHV QRUG GHOHV SDUFHOāOHVLLHVGLULJL[DQRUGILQVDO HL[GHOFDUUHUG¶(UHV7URLDSHOTXHVHJXL[ILQVDLQFRUSRUDU ODSDUFHOāODGHO¶LOODFRQWLQXDDQRUGSHUODSURORQJDFLyGHODPLWJHUDHQWUHOHVSDUFHOāOHVL G HVWDLOODILQVDODWUREDGDG XQDOtQLDYLUWXDODPGHODFDUUHWHUDGH0RVTXHUXHODD/D)RLDSHUODTXH SURVVHJXL[ILQVHOSXQWG RULJHQ $QWHFHGHQWHVDGPLQLVWUDWLYRVODGHOLPLWDFLyQGHOHQWRUQRGHSURWHFFLyQVHDFRJHDORGLVSXHVWRHQHO$SWGR GHOD'LVSRVLFLyQ7UDQVLWRULD3ULPHUDGHODOH\PRGLILFDGRUDGHOD(VWDGHOLPLWDFLyQTXHGD UHFRQRFLGD FRQ FDUiFWHU SURYLVLRQDO VHJ~Q OD GHOLPLWDFLyQ FRQWHQLGD HQ OD UHVROXFLyQ GH GH IHEUHUR GH SXEOLFDGDHQHO'2*9GHIHFKD 2ULJHQLQWHUVHFFLyQHQWUHXQDOtQHDYLUWXDOSDUDOHODDODFDUUHWHUDGH0RVTXHUXHODD/D)R\DDPGHOD PLVPDFRQODSURORQJDFLyQGHODPHGLDQHUDQRUWHGHODSDUFHODGHODPDQ]DQDFDWDVWUDOSXQWR$ 6HQWLGRDQWLKRUDULR /tQHDGHOLPLWDGRUDGHVGHHORULJHQODOtQHDVLJXHDRHVWH SRUODSURORQJDFLyQ GHODPHGLDQHUDQRUWH GHOD SDUFHODGHODPDQ]DQDKDVWDFRQWLQXDUSRUODWUDVHUDGHHVWDSDUFHOD\SRUODPHGLDQHUDHQWUHODV SDUFHODV \ GH HVWD PDQ]DQD /OHJD KDVWD HO HMH GH OD FDOOH *HQHUDO 0ROD \ SRU HO VH GLULJH D VXU LQWURGXFLpQGRVHHQODPDQ]DQDSRUODPHGLDQHUDHQWUHODV SDUFHODV\HQJOREDQGRODV \&UX]DODFDOOH0DMRUHLQFRUSRUDODVSDUFHODV\GHODPDQ]DQD\ODV \GHODPDQ]DQD$WUDYLHVDODPDQ]DQDHQWUHODVSDUFHODV\\OD\OD %RUGHDODVIDFKDGDVQRUWHGHODV SDUFHODV\\VHGLULJH D QRUWH KDVWD HO HMH GH OD FDOOH (UDV 7UR\D SRU HO TXH VLJXH KDVWD LQFRUSRUDU OD SDUFHOD GH OD PDQ]DQD FRQWLQ~D D QRUWH SRU OD SURORQJDFLyQGHODPHGLDQHUDHQWUHODVSDUFHODV\GHHVWDPDQ]DQDKDVWDHOHQFXHQWURGHXQDOtQHD YLUWXDODPGHODFDUUHWHUDGH0RVTXHUXHODD/D)RLDSRUODTXHSURVLJXHKDVWDHOSXQWRGHRULJHQ $11(;,9$1(;2,9 GH 5HVROXFLyGHG DEULOGHOD'LUHFFLy*HQHUDOGH3DWULPRQL&XOWXUDO9DOHQFLjL0XVHXVGHOD&RQVHOOHULDGH&XOWXUD(GXFDFLyL(VSRUWSHUODTXHV LQFRDH[SHGLHQWSHUDOD SULPHUD IDVH GH O DFWXDOLW]DFLy L DGDSWDFLy SDUFLDO GH OD 6HFFLy 3ULPHUD GH O ,QYHQWDUL *HQHUDO GHO 3DWULPRQL &XOWXUDO 9DOHQFLj HQ PDWqULD GH SDWULPRQL DUTXLWHFWzQLF L PHGLDPELHQWDOLV¶REULSHUtRGHG¶LQIRUPDFLyS~EOLFD 5HVROXFLyQ GH GH DEULO GH OD 'LUHFFLyQ *HQHUDO GH 3DWULPRQLR &XOWXUDO 9DOHQFLDQR \ 0XVHRV GH OD &RQVHOOHULD GH &XOWXUD (GXFDFLyQ \ 'HSRUWH SRU OD TXH VH LQFRD H[SHGLHQWH SDUD OD SULPHUD IDVH GH OD DFWXDOL]DFLyQ \ DGDSWDFLyQ SDUFLDO GH OD 6HFFLyQ 3ULPHUD GHO ,QYHQWDULR *HQHUDO GHO 3DWULPRQLR &XOWXUDO 9DOHQFLDQR HQ PDWHULD GH SDWULPRQLRDUTXLWHFWyQLFR\PHGLRDPELHQWDO\VHDEUHSHULRGRGHLQIRUPDFLyQSXEOLFD 17980 Núm. 5.503 / 02.05.2007 %e'¶,17(5e6&8/785$/±(6*/e6,$3$55248,$/'(/¶$66803&,Ï'(/$0$5('('e8 9,67$%(//$'(/0$(675$702180(17 %,(1'(,17(5e6&8/785$/±,*/(6,$3$55248,$/'(/$$681&,Ï1'(18(675$6(f25$ 9,67$%(//$'(/0$(675$=*202180(172 $11(;,9$1(;2,9 GH 5HVROXFLyGHG DEULOGHOD'LUHFFLy*HQHUDOGH3DWULPRQL&XOWXUDO9DOHQFLjL0XVHXVGHOD&RQVHOOHULDGH&XOWXUD(GXFDFLyL(VSRUWSHUODTXHV LQFRDH[SHGLHQWSHUDOD SULPHUD IDVH GH O DFWXDOLW]DFLy L DGDSWDFLy SDUFLDO GH OD 6HFFLy 3ULPHUD GH O ,QYHQWDUL *HQHUDO GHO 3DWULPRQL &XOWXUDO 9DOHQFLj HQ PDWqULD GH SDWULPRQL DUTXLWHFWzQLF L PHGLDPELHQWDOLV¶REULSHUtRGHG¶LQIRUPDFLyS~EOLFD 5HVROXFLyQ GH GH DEULO GH OD 'LUHFFLyQ *HQHUDO GH 3DWULPRQLR &XOWXUDO 9DOHQFLDQR \ 0XVHRV GH OD &RQVHOOHULD GH &XOWXUD (GXFDFLyQ \ 'HSRUWH SRU OD TXH VH LQFRD H[SHGLHQWH SDUD OD SULPHUD IDVH GH OD DFWXDOL]DFLyQ \ DGDSWDFLyQ SDUFLDO GH OD 6HFFLyQ 3ULPHUD GHO ,QYHQWDULR *HQHUDO GHO 3DWULPRQLR &XOWXUDO 9DOHQFLDQR HQ PDWHULD GH SDWULPRQLRDUTXLWHFWyQLFR\PHGLRDPELHQWDO\VHDEUHSHULRGRGHLQIRUPDFLyQSXEOLFD 17981 Núm. 5.503 / 02.05.2007 %e'¶,17(5e6&8/785$/±6$178$5,'(6$17-2$1%$37,67$'(3(1<$*2/26$,6$17$ %¬5%$5$9,67$%(//$'(/0$(675$702180(17 %,(1'(,17(5e6&8/785$/±6$178$5,2'(6$1-8$1%$87,67$'(3(1<$*2/26$<6$17$%È5%$5$ 9,67$%(//$'(/0$(675$=*202180(172 'HQRPLQDFLy'HQRPLQDFLyQ 3ULQFLSDO3ULQFLSDO 6DQWXDULGH6DQW-RDQ%DSWLVWDGH3HQ\DJRORVDL 6DQWD%jUEDUD 6DQWXDULRGH6DQ-XDQ%DXWLVWDGH3HQ\DJRORVD\ 6DQWD%iUEDUD $FFHVzULD$FFHVRULD 6DQWXDULGH6DQW-RDQGH3HQ\DJRORVD 6DQWXDULRGH6DQ-XDQGH3HQ\DJRORVD /RFDOL]DFLy/RFDOL]DFLyQ 3URYtQFLD3URYLQFLD&DVWHOOy &RPDUFD&RPDUFD/ $OFDODWpQ 0XQLFLSL0XQLFLSLR9LVWDEHOODGHO0DHVWUD]JR 8ELFDFLy8ELFDFLyQ3ODoDGHO¶(VJOpVLD 5HIHUqQFLD&DGDVWUDO5HIHUHQFLD&DWDVWUDO 3ROtJRQ3ROtJRQR3DUFHOāOD3DUFHOD 3ROtJRQ3ROtJRQR3DUFHOāOD3DUFHOD $QWHFHGHQWV-XUtGLFV$QWHFHGHQWHV-XUtGLFRV ,QFRDFLy,QFRDFLyQ 3XEOLFDFLyGHODLQFRDFLy3XEOLFDFLyQGHODLQFRDFLyQ%2( 'HVFULSFLy'HVFULSFLyQ 3DUWV,QWHJUDQWV3DUWHV,QWHJUDQWHV − (VJOpVLDDPEQDXSULQFLSDOLYROWHVDPEOOXQHWVFDSHOODODWHUDOFRUFDPEULOLSRUWDGD ,JOHVLDFRQQDYH SULQFLSDOFRQEyYHGDVGHOXQHWRVFDSLOODODWHUDOFRURFDPDUtQ\SRUWDGD − − − − 3DWLLQWHULRULHVWDQFHVDQQH[HV3DWLRLQWHULRU\GHSHQGHQFLDVDQHMDV &RVVRVDGGLFLRQDOVLDUTXHULHV&XHUSRVDGLFLRQDOHV\DUTXHUtDV 7RUUH7RUUH )RQW)XHQWH 'HVFULSFLy*HQHUDO'HVFULSFLyQ*HQHUDO (OVDQWXDULHVWDIRUPDWSHUXQFRQMXQWG HGLILFDFLRQVHQWRUQG XQDSODoDJHQHUDOLXQ[LFRWHWSDWLLQWHULRUDO YROWDQWGHOTXDOV DUWLFXOHQOHVGLIHUHQWVGHSHQGqQFLHVTXHVyQOHVPpVDQWLJXHV 6 DFFHGL[ DO VDQWXDUL D WUDYpV G XQD SRUWDGD G DUF GH PLJ SXQW TXH FRQGXw[ DO SDWL $ OD GUHWD HV WURED OD WRUUHFDPSDQDUGHO HVJOpVLDTXHSUHVHQWDHVFDVVRVEXLWVLHVWjUHPDWDGDDPESLQDFOHVLEROHV (O SDWL FHQWUDO SUHVHQWD HQ WUHV GHOV VHXV FRVWDWV SzUWLF FRUUHJXW G DUFV HVFDUVHUV $O YROWDQW GHO SDWL V DUWLFXOHQOHVGLIHUHQWVGHSHQGqQFLHVHQWUHOHVTXDOVFDODVVHQ\DODUHOUHVWDXUDQWODFXLQDPDJDW]HPVLXQD HVWDGD[LPHQHUD 8QD DOWUD SDUW GHO UHFLQWH OD IRUPD O HGLILFL DOODUJDW TXH DOEHUJD OHV GHX KDELWDFLRQV GHOV SHOHJULQVLHQODSODQWDEDL[DWpXQSzUWLFDPDQHUDGHFRUUHGRUH[WHULRU(VFRPSOHWDHOFRQMXQWDPEDOWUHV GXHVHGLILFDFLRQVH[HPSWHV / HVJOpVLD VLWXDGD DO VXG pV G XQD VROD QDX L TXDWUH WUDPV GH GHVLJXDO ORQJLWXG FREHUWV DPE YROWHV DPE OOXQHWHVHOVWUHVSULPHUVLDPEF~SXODVREUHSHW[LQHVO ~OWLPFRUUHVSRQHQWDOSUHVELWHUL/DSRUWDGDSULQFLSDO DOVSHXVHVWjOODXUDGDHQSHGUDLFRQVWDODGDWDGHTXHLQGLFDO DQ\GHODVHXDILQDOLW]DFLy/ HQWUDGD ODWHUDOTXHGyQDDOSDWLFHQWUDOSRVVHw[XQDSRUWDGDDPEXQVHQ]LOODUF GHPLJSXQWUHFRO]DWHQ SLODVWUHV DPEPRWOXUHVFOjVVLTXHVLFDSLWHOOVLXQDFODXOOHXJHUDPHQWUHPDUFDGD(QHVWHPDWHL[IURQWHVFRQVHUYHQ SLQWXUHV PXUDOV TXH VHJRQV VHPEOD GDWHQ GH O qSRFD GH FRQVWUXFFLy GHO WHPSOH 7DPEp KL KD UHVWHV GH SLQWXUHVDOIUHVFHQ OD SODQWDEDL[DGHFDPSDQDU (QIURQWGHO HQWUDGDODWHUDOHQO LQWHULRU GHO HVJOpVLDHV WUREDO ~QLFDFDSHOODTXHSRVVHw[HOWHPSOHGHSODQWDTXDGUDGDLJUDQGLPHQVLy%DVDWHQO (VWXGL3UHYLGHO 6DQWXDUL6DQW-RDQGH3HQ\DJRORVD (O 6DQWXDULR HVWi IRUPDGR SRU XQ FRQMXQWR GH HGLILFDFLRQHV HQ WRUQR D XQD SOD]D JHQHUDO \ XQ SHTXHxR SDWLRLQWHULRUDOUHGHGRUGHOFXDOVHDUWLFXODQODVGLIHUHQWHVGHSHQGHQFLDVTXHVRQODVPiVDQWLJXDV $11(;,9$1(;2,9 GH 5HVROXFLyGHG DEULOGHOD'LUHFFLy*HQHUDOGH3DWULPRQL&XOWXUDO9DOHQFLjL0XVHXVGHOD&RQVHOOHULDGH&XOWXUD(GXFDFLyL(VSRUWSHUODTXHV LQFRDH[SHGLHQWSHUDOD SULPHUD IDVH GH O DFWXDOLW]DFLy L DGDSWDFLy SDUFLDO GH OD 6HFFLy 3ULPHUD GH O ,QYHQWDUL *HQHUDO GHO 3DWULPRQL &XOWXUDO 9DOHQFLj HQ PDWqULD GH SDWULPRQL DUTXLWHFWzQLF L PHGLDPELHQWDOLV¶REULSHUtRGHG¶LQIRUPDFLyS~EOLFD 5HVROXFLyQ GH GH DEULO GH OD 'LUHFFLyQ *HQHUDO GH 3DWULPRQLR &XOWXUDO 9DOHQFLDQR \ 0XVHRV GH OD &RQVHOOHULD GH &XOWXUD (GXFDFLyQ \ 'HSRUWH SRU OD TXH VH LQFRD H[SHGLHQWH SDUD OD SULPHUD IDVH GH OD DFWXDOL]DFLyQ \ DGDSWDFLyQ SDUFLDO GH OD 6HFFLyQ 3ULPHUD GHO ,QYHQWDULR *HQHUDO GHO 3DWULPRQLR &XOWXUDO 9DOHQFLDQR HQ PDWHULD GH SDWULPRQLRDUTXLWHFWyQLFR\PHGLRDPELHQWDO\VHDEUHSHULRGRGHLQIRUPDFLyQSXEOLFD 17982 Núm. 5.503 / 02.05.2007 6HDFFHGHDOVDQWXDULRDWUDYpVGHXQDSRUWDGDGHDUFRGHPHGLRSXQWRTXHFRQGXFHDOSDWLR$ODGHUHFKD VHHQFXHQWUDODWRUUHFDPSDQDULRGHODLJOHVLDTXHSUHVHQWDHVFDVRVYDQRV\HVWiUHPDWDGDFRQSLQiFXORV\ ERODV (O SDWLR FHQWUDO SUHVHQWD HQ WUHV GH VXV ODGRV SyUWLFR FRUULGR GH DUFRV HVFDU]DQRV $OUHGHGRU GHO SDWLR VH DUWLFXODQODVGLIHUHQWHVGHSHQGHQFLDVHQWUHODVTXHFDEHVHxDODUHOUHVWDXUDQWHODFRFLQDDOPDFHQHV\XQD HVWDQFLDFKLPHQHD2WUDSDUWHGHOUHFLQWRODIRUPDHOHGLILFLRDODUJDGRTXHDOEHUJDODVGLH]KDELWDFLRQHVGH ORVSHUHJULQRV\HQSODQWDEDMDWLHQHXQSyUWLFRDPRGRGHFRUUHGRUH[WHULRU6HFRPSOHWDHOFRQMXQWRFRQ RWUDVGRVHGLILFDFLRQHVH[HQWDV /DLJOHVLDVLWXDGDDO6XUHVGHXQDVRODQDYH\FXDWURWUDPRVGHGHVLJXDOORQJLWXGFXELHUWRVFRQEyYHGDV FRQ OXQHWRV ORV WUHV SULPHURV \ FRQ F~SXOD VREUH SHFKLQDV HO ~OWLPR FRUUHVSRQGLHQWH DO SUHVELWHULR /D SRUWDGD SULQFLSDO D ORV SLHV HVWi ODEUDGD HQ SLHGUD \ FRQVWD OD IHFKD GH TXH LQGLFD HO DxR GH VX ILQDOL]DFLyQ /D HQWUDGD ODWHUDO TXH GD DO SDWLR FHQWUDO SRVHH XQD SRUWDGD FRQ XQ VHQFLOOR DUFR GH PHGLR SXQWRDSR\DGRHQSLODVWUDVFRQPROGXUDVFOiVLFDV\FDSLWHOHV\XQDFODYHOLJHUDPHQWHUHPDUFDGD(QHVWD PLVPRIUHQWHVHFRQVHUYDQSLQWXUDVPXUDOHVTXHDOSDUHFHUGDWDQGHODpSRFDGHFRQVWUXFFLyQGHOWHPSOR 7DPELpQKD\UHVWRVGHSLQWXUDVDOIUHVFRHQODSODQWDEDMDGHFDPSDQDULR)UHQWHDODHQWUDGDODWHUDOHQHO LQWHULRU GH OD LJOHVLD VH HQFXHQWUD OD ~QLFD FDSLOOD TXH SRVHH HO WHPSOR GH SODQWD FXDGUDGD \ JUDQ GLPHQVLyQ%DVDGRHQHO(VWXGLR3UHYLRGHO6DQWXDULR6DQ-XDQGH3HQ\DJRORVD 2EVHUYDFLRQV2EVHUYDFLRQHV (QWRUQ(QWRUQ $QWHFHGHQWVDGPLQLVWUDWLXVGHOLPLWDFLyH[WUHWDGHO H[SHGLHQWGHILQLGDDPEFDUjFWHUSURYLVLRQDO /tQLDGHOLPLWDGRUDIRUPDGDSHUODLQWHUVHFFLyGHTXDWUHFLUFXPIHUqQFLHVYLUWXDOVGHUDGLPDPEFHQWUHV HQHOYqUWH[QRUGHQODSDUFHOāODHQHOVYqUWH[VRHVWLVXGGHODGHOSROtJRQFDGDVWUDOLHQ O HVWGHODGHOSROtJRQFDGDVWUDO $QWHFHGHQWHVDGPLQLVWUDWLYRVGHOLPLWDFLyQH[WUDtGDGHOH[SHGLHQWHGHILQLGDFRQFDUiFWHUSURYLVLRQDO /tQHD GHOLPLWDGRUD IRUPDGD SRU OD LQWHUVHFFLyQ GH FXDWUR FLUFXQIHUHQFLDV YLUWXDOHV GH UDGLR P FRQ FHQWURV HQ HO YpUWLFH QRUWH HQ OD SDUFHOD HQ ORV YpUWLFHV RHVWH \ VXU GH OD GHO SROtJRQR FDWDVWUDO\HQHOHVWHGHODGHOSROtJRQRFDWDVWUDO $11(;,9$1(;2,9 GH 5HVROXFLyGHG DEULOGHOD'LUHFFLy*HQHUDOGH3DWULPRQL&XOWXUDO9DOHQFLjL0XVHXVGHOD&RQVHOOHULDGH&XOWXUD(GXFDFLyL(VSRUWSHUODTXHV LQFRDH[SHGLHQWSHUDOD SULPHUD IDVH GH O DFWXDOLW]DFLy L DGDSWDFLy SDUFLDO GH OD 6HFFLy 3ULPHUD GH O ,QYHQWDUL *HQHUDO GHO 3DWULPRQL &XOWXUDO 9DOHQFLj HQ PDWqULD GH SDWULPRQL DUTXLWHFWzQLF L PHGLDPELHQWDOLV¶REULSHUtRGHG¶LQIRUPDFLyS~EOLFD 5HVROXFLyQ GH GH DEULO GH OD 'LUHFFLyQ *HQHUDO GH 3DWULPRQLR &XOWXUDO 9DOHQFLDQR \ 0XVHRV GH OD &RQVHOOHULD GH &XOWXUD (GXFDFLyQ \ 'HSRUWH SRU OD TXH VH LQFRD H[SHGLHQWH SDUD OD SULPHUD IDVH GH OD DFWXDOL]DFLyQ \ DGDSWDFLyQ SDUFLDO GH OD 6HFFLyQ 3ULPHUD GHO ,QYHQWDULR *HQHUDO GHO 3DWULPRQLR &XOWXUDO 9DOHQFLDQR HQ PDWHULD GH SDWULPRQLRDUTXLWHFWyQLFR\PHGLRDPELHQWDO\VHDEUHSHULRGRGHLQIRUPDFLyQSXEOLFD 17983 Núm. 5.503 / 02.05.2007 %e'¶,17(5e6&8/785$/±6$178$5,'(6$17-2$1%$37,67$'(3(1<$*2/26$,6$17$ %¬5%$5$9,67$%(//$'(/0$(675$702180(17 %,(1'(,17(5e6&8/785$/±6$178$5,2'(6$1-8$1%$87,67$'(3(1<$*2/26$<6$17$%È5%$5$ 9,67$%(//$'(/0$(675$=*202180(172 $11(;,9$1(;2,9 GH 5HVROXFLyGHG DEULOGHOD'LUHFFLy*HQHUDOGH3DWULPRQL&XOWXUDO9DOHQFLjL0XVHXVGHOD&RQVHOOHULDGH&XOWXUD(GXFDFLyL(VSRUWSHUODTXHV LQFRDH[SHGLHQWSHUDOD SULPHUD IDVH GH O DFWXDOLW]DFLy L DGDSWDFLy SDUFLDO GH OD 6HFFLy 3ULPHUD GH O ,QYHQWDUL *HQHUDO GHO 3DWULPRQL &XOWXUDO 9DOHQFLj HQ PDWqULD GH SDWULPRQL DUTXLWHFWzQLF L PHGLDPELHQWDOLV¶REULSHUtRGHG¶LQIRUPDFLyS~EOLFD 5HVROXFLyQ GH GH DEULO GH OD 'LUHFFLyQ *HQHUDO GH 3DWULPRQLR &XOWXUDO 9DOHQFLDQR \ 0XVHRV GH OD &RQVHOOHULD GH &XOWXUD (GXFDFLyQ \ 'HSRUWH SRU OD TXH VH LQFRD H[SHGLHQWH SDUD OD SULPHUD IDVH GH OD DFWXDOL]DFLyQ \ DGDSWDFLyQ SDUFLDO GH OD 6HFFLyQ 3ULPHUD GHO ,QYHQWDULR *HQHUDO GHO 3DWULPRQLR &XOWXUDO 9DOHQFLDQR HQ PDWHULD GH SDWULPRQLRDUTXLWHFWyQLFR\PHGLRDPELHQWDO\VHDEUHSHULRGRGHLQIRUPDFLyQSXEOLFD 17984 Núm. 5.503 / 02.05.2007 %e'¶,17(5e6&8/785$/±6$178$5,'(/$0$5('('e8'(/$%$/0$=25,7$'(/ 0$(675$702180(17 %,(1'(,17(5e6&8/785$/±6$178$5,2'(/$9,5*(1'(/$%$/0$=25,7$'(/0$(675$=*2 02180(172 'HQRPLQDFLy'HQRPLQDFLyQ 3ULQFLSDO3ULQFLSDO 6DQWXDULGHOD0DUHGH'pXGHOD%DOPD 6DQWXDULRGHOD9LUJHQGHOD%DOPD /RFDOL]DFLy/RFDOL]DFLyQ 3URYtQFLD3URYLQFLD&DVWHOOy &RPDUFD&RPDUFD(OV3RUWV 0XQLFLSL0XQLFLSLR=RULWDGHO0DHVWUD]JR 8ELFDFLy8ELFDFLyQ&WUD$LJXDYLYD 5HIHUHQFLD&DGDVWUDO5HIHUHQFLD&DWDVWUDO 3ROtJRQ3ROtJRQR3DUFHOāOD3DUFHOD $QWHFHGHQWV-XUtGLFV$QWHFHGHQWHV-XUtGLFRV ,QFRDFLy,QFRDFLyQ 3XEOLFDFLyGHODLQFRDFLy3XEOLFDFLyQGHODLQFRDFLyQ%2( 'HVFULSFLy'HVFULSFLyQ 3DUWV,QWHJUDQWV3DUWHV,QWHJUDQWHV − /¶HVJOpVLDDPEHOFDPSDQDU/DLJOHVLDFRQVXFDPSDQDULR − (OFRUUHGRUHQWUHO HVJOpVLDLODUHVWDG HGLILFDFLRQV(OFRUUHGRUHQWUHODLJOHVLD\HOUHVWRGHHGLILFDFLRQHV − &RYD L HGLILFL RQ V¶XELFD HO UHVWDXUDQW L HO FHOOHU &XHYD \ HGLILFLR GRQGH VH XELFD HO UHVWDXUDQWH \ OD ERGHJD − − − − $QWLJDFDVDGHO¶HUPLWjLFXLQD$QWLJXDFDVDGHOHUPLWDxR\FRFLQD /HVWUHVKRVWDWJHULHV/DVWUHVKRVSHGHUtDV /DIRQWLHOSRU[RTXHODFXEUL[/DIXHQWH\HOSRUFKHTXHODFXEUH /D&UHX&REHUWD/D&UX]&XELHUWD 'HVFULSFLy*HQHUDO'HVFULSFLyQ*HQHUDO /HV SULPHUHV QRWtFLHV HV UHPXQWHQ DO VHJOH ;,9 O DIOXqQFLD GH SHOHJULQV YD FRPSRUWDU TXH HV UHDOLW]DUHQ REUHVHQHQ O HVJOpVLD L O KRVWDWJHULD WRUQDQWVH D DPSOLDU O¶~OWLPD HQWUH L $ PLWMDQ VHJOH ;9,, HV YD DPSOLDU O HVJOpVLD L HV FRQVWUXw[ HO FDPSDQDU L OD SRUWDGD -D HQ HO VHJOH ;9,,, V DPSOLD O KRVWDWJHULD (O VDQWXDUL HV FRPSRQ G XQ FRQMXQW G HGLILFLV L FRQVWUXFFLRQV HQWUH HOV TXDOV GHVWDTXHQ O HVJOpVLD L HOV WUHV KRVWDWJHULHV 'H OHV WUHV KRVWDWJHULHV OD SULPHUD HV WURED VREUH OD SRU[DGD G DFFpV GDWDEOH D ILQDOV GHO VHJOH ;9,,, R FRPHQoDPHQWV GHO ;,; /D VHJRQD DQRPHQDGD ³OD VDOD ERQD´ pV XQD FRQVWUXFFLyPpVVzOLGDGHODPDWHL[DqSRFD/DWHUFHUDOD³VDODGHOEDOO´GHOVHJOH;9,,(VWHVGXHV~OWLPHV DPEjPSOLHVDUFDGHVGHSHGUDGHPLJSXQW / HVJOpVLDHVWUREDHQXQDEULFQDWXUDOHQODURFD3UHVHQWDIDoDQDDOULXDPEEDOFRQVEDOXVWUHVLPXUVGH SHGUD L FDOo 6 HQWUD HQ HOOD D WUDYpV G XQD SRUWDGD TXH GyQD DO FRUUHGRU VLWXDGD HQ OD SDUW LQIHULRU GHO FDPSDQDU /D SRUWDGD VLVFHQWLVWD pV XQ GHOV HOHPHQWV LQWHUHVVDQWV SDUWLFXODUPHQW SHU OD LQFOLQDFLy REOLTXD GHOVVHXVHOHPHQWV /D IDoDQD HQ FDUUHXV HV SURORQJD FDS D O DOW IRUPDQW HO FDPSDQDU GH GRV FRVVRV TXH FXOPLQD DPE UHPDWDGHVSLUDPLGDOV (QO LQWHULRUOD&RYDRQV XELFDHOFXOWHpVGHIRUPDLUUHJXODU &RPSOHWDHOFRQMXQWGHOVDQWXDULODFUHXFREHUWDGRFXPHQWDGDMDGHVGHLUHQRYDGDHQL DGTXLUL[IRUPDGHWHPSOHWSLUDPLGDOHVWDQWFRQVWUXwGDHQPDoRQHULDLFREHUWDDPEWHXOHVEODYHV(VWjHQ SURFqVGHUHVWDXUDFLy%DVDWHQHO&DWjOHJGH0RQXPHQWVL&RQMXQWVGHOD&RPXQLWDW9DOHQFLDQD /DVSULPHUDVQRWLFLDVVHUHPRQWDQDOVLJOR;,9ODDIOXHQFLDGHSHUHJULQRVFRPSRUWyTXHVHUHDOL]DVHQREUDV HQHQODLJOHVLD \ODKRVSHGHUtDYROYLpQGRVHD DPSOLDU OD XOWLPD HQWUH \ $ PHGLDGRV GHO VLJOR;9,,VHDPSOLyODLJOHVLD\VHFRQVWUX\HHOFDPSDQDULR\ODSRUWDGDV<DHQHOVLJOR;9,,,VHDPSOLDOD KRVSHGHUtD(OVDQWXDULRVHFRPSRQHGHXQFRQMXQWRGHHGLILFLRV\FRQVWUXFFLRQHVHQWUHORVTXHGHVWDFDQOD LJOHVLD \ ODV WUHV KRVSHGHUtDV 'H ODV WUHV KRVSHGHUtD OD SULPHUD VH HQFXHQWUD VREUH HO SRUFKH GH DFFHVR GDWDEOH D ILQDOHV GHO VLJOR ;9,,, R FRPLHQ]RV GHO ;,; /D VHJXQGD OODPDGD GH ³OD VDOD ERQD´ HV XQD $11(;,9$1(;2,9 GH 5HVROXFLyGHG DEULOGHOD'LUHFFLy*HQHUDOGH3DWULPRQL&XOWXUDO9DOHQFLjL0XVHXVGHOD&RQVHOOHULDGH&XOWXUD(GXFDFLyL(VSRUWSHUODTXHV LQFRDH[SHGLHQWSHUDOD SULPHUD IDVH GH O DFWXDOLW]DFLy L DGDSWDFLy SDUFLDO GH OD 6HFFLy 3ULPHUD GH O ,QYHQWDUL *HQHUDO GHO 3DWULPRQL &XOWXUDO 9DOHQFLj HQ PDWqULD GH SDWULPRQL DUTXLWHFWzQLF L PHGLDPELHQWDOLV¶REULSHUtRGHG¶LQIRUPDFLyS~EOLFD 5HVROXFLyQ GH GH DEULO GH OD 'LUHFFLyQ *HQHUDO GH 3DWULPRQLR &XOWXUDO 9DOHQFLDQR \ 0XVHRV GH OD &RQVHOOHULD GH &XOWXUD (GXFDFLyQ \ 'HSRUWH SRU OD TXH VH LQFRD H[SHGLHQWH SDUD OD SULPHUD IDVH GH OD DFWXDOL]DFLyQ \ DGDSWDFLyQ SDUFLDO GH OD 6HFFLyQ 3ULPHUD GHO ,QYHQWDULR *HQHUDO GHO 3DWULPRQLR &XOWXUDO 9DOHQFLDQR HQ PDWHULD GH SDWULPRQLRDUTXLWHFWyQLFR\PHGLRDPELHQWDO\VHDEUHSHULRGRGHLQIRUPDFLyQSXEOLFD 17985 Núm. 5.503 / 02.05.2007 FRQVWUXFFLyQPiV VyOLGDGHODPLVPDpSRFD /D WHUFHUD OD ³VDOD GHO EDOO´ GHO VLJOR ;9,, (VWDV GRV XOWLPDV FRQDPSOLDVDUFDGDVGHSLHGUDGHPHGLRSXQWR /DLJOHVLDVHHQFXHQWUDHQXQDEULJRQDWXUDOHQODURFD3UHVHQWDIDFKDGDDOUtRFRQEDOFRQHVEDODXVWUHV\ PXURVGHSLHGUD\FDO6HHQWUDHQHOODDWUDYpVGHXQDSRUWDGDUHFD\HQWHDOFRUUHGRUVLWXDGDHQODSDUWH LQIHULRUGHOFDPSDQDULR/DSRUWDGDVHLVFHQWLVWDHVXQRGHORVHOHPHQWRVLQWHUHVDQWHVSDUWLFXODUPHQWHSRUOD LQFOLQDFLyQREOLFXDGHVXVPLHPEURV /DIDFKDGDHQVLOOHUtDVHSURORQJDKDFLDORDOWRIRUPDQGRHOFDPSDQDULRGHGRVFXHUSRVTXHFXOPLQDFRQ UHPDWHVSLUDPLGDOHV (QHOLQWHULRUODFXHYDGRQGHVHXELFDHOFXOWRHVGHIRUPDLUUHJXODU&RPSOHWDHOFRQMXQWRGHOVDQWXDULRGH OD FUX] FXELHUWD 'RFXPHQWDGD \D GHVGH \ UHQRYDGD HQ \ DGTXLHUH IRUPD GH WHPSOHWH SLUDPLGDOHVWDQGRFRQVWUXLGDHQPDPSRVWHUtD\FXELHUWDFRQWHMDVD]XOHV(VWiHQSURFHVRGHUHVWDXUDFLyQ %DVDGRHQHO&DWiORJRGH0RQXPHQWRV\&RQMXQWRVGHOD&RPXQLGDG9DOHQFLDQD 2EVHUYDFLRQV2EVHUYDFLRQHV (QWRUQ(QWRUQ $QWHFHGHQWVDGPLQLVWUDWLXVGHOLPLWDFLyH[WUHWDGHO H[SHGLHQWGHILQLGDDPEFDUjFWHUSURYLVLRQDO 2ULJHQYqUWH[QRUGGHODPLWJHUDHQWUHOHVSDUFHOāOHVLGHOSROtJRQFDGDVWUDOQ~P3XQW$ 6HQWLW+RUDUL /tQLDGHOLPLWDGRUD'HVGHO RULJHQODOtQLDGHOLPLWDGRUDUHFRUUHOHVPLWJHUHVHQWUHOHVSDUFHOāOHVLL LGHOSROtJRQFDGDVWUDOQ~P&UHXDHOULX%HUJDQWVLQFRUSRUDQWORHQGLUHFFLyQRUGRHVW&RQWLQXDSHU ODPLWJHUDHQWUHOHVSDUFHOāOHVLGHOSROtJRQFDGDVWUDOQ~P3URVVHJXL[SHUODGLWDPLWJHUDFUHXDOD FDUUHWHUD&6LUHFRUUHHOOtPLWVXGGHODSDUFHOāODQ~P5HFRUUHHOOtPLWVXGGHODµ&RODGDGH7DOD\ROD¶ LJLUDDQRUGHQWUHOHVSDUFHOāOHVLLUHFRUUHOHVPLWJHUHVHQWUHOHVSDUFHOāOHVLLLLL SHUODSURORQJDFLyG HVWDILQVDODFDUUHWHUD&6LQFRUSRUDQWODLJLUDQWDVXGILQVDOSXQWG RULJHQ $QWHFHGHQWHVDGPLQLVWUDWLYRVGHOLPLWDFLyQH[WUDtGDGHOH[SHGLHQWHGHILQLGDFRQFDUiFWHUSURYLVLRQDO 2ULJHQYpUWLFHQRUWHGHODPHGLDQHUDHQWUHODVSDUFHODV\GHOSROtJRQRFDWDVWUDOQ3XQWR$ 6HQWLGR+RUDULR /tQHDGHOLPLWDGRUD'HVGHHORULJHQODOtQHDGHOLPLWDGRUDUHFRUUHODVPHGLDQHUDVHQWUHODVSDUFHODV\\ \ GHO SROtJRQR FDWDVWUDO Q &UX]D HO UtR %HUJDQWHV LQFRUSRUiQGROR HQ GLUHFFLyQ QRURHVWH &RQWLQXD SRU OD PHGLDQHUD HQWUH ODV SDUFHODV \ GHO SROtJRQR FDWDVWUDO Q 3URVLJXH SRU GLFKD PHGLDQHUDFUX]DODFDUUHWHUD&6\UHFRUUHHOOLQGH VXU GH OD SDUFHODQ5HFRUUHHOOLQGH VXU GHOD &RODGDGH7DOD\ROD\JLUDDQRUWHHQWUHODVSDUFHODV\\UHFRUUHODVPHGLDQHUDVHQWUHODVSDUFHODV\ \\\\SRUODSURORQJDFLyQGHpVWDKDVWDODFDUUHWHUD&6LQFRUSRUiQGROD\JLUDQGRD VXUKDVWDHOSXQWRGHRULJHQ $11(;,9$1(;2,9 GH 5HVROXFLyGHG DEULOGHOD'LUHFFLy*HQHUDOGH3DWULPRQL&XOWXUDO9DOHQFLjL0XVHXVGHOD&RQVHOOHULDGH&XOWXUD(GXFDFLyL(VSRUWSHUODTXHV LQFRDH[SHGLHQWSHUDOD SULPHUD IDVH GH O DFWXDOLW]DFLy L DGDSWDFLy SDUFLDO GH OD 6HFFLy 3ULPHUD GH O ,QYHQWDUL *HQHUDO GHO 3DWULPRQL &XOWXUDO 9DOHQFLj HQ PDWqULD GH SDWULPRQL DUTXLWHFWzQLF L PHGLDPELHQWDOLV¶REULSHUtRGHG¶LQIRUPDFLyS~EOLFD 5HVROXFLyQ GH GH DEULO GH OD 'LUHFFLyQ *HQHUDO GH 3DWULPRQLR &XOWXUDO 9DOHQFLDQR \ 0XVHRV GH OD &RQVHOOHULD GH &XOWXUD (GXFDFLyQ \ 'HSRUWH SRU OD TXH VH LQFRD H[SHGLHQWH SDUD OD SULPHUD IDVH GH OD DFWXDOL]DFLyQ \ DGDSWDFLyQ SDUFLDO GH OD 6HFFLyQ 3ULPHUD GHO ,QYHQWDULR *HQHUDO GHO 3DWULPRQLR &XOWXUDO 9DOHQFLDQR HQ PDWHULD GH SDWULPRQLRDUTXLWHFWyQLFR\PHGLRDPELHQWDO\VHDEUHSHULRGRGHLQIRUPDFLyQSXEOLFD 17986 Núm. 5.503 / 02.05.2007 %e'¶,17(5e6&8/785$/±6$178$5,'(/$0$5('('e8'(/$%$/0$=25,7$'(/ 0$(675$702180(17 %,(1'(,17(5e6&8/785$/±6$178$5,2'(/$9,5*(1'(/$%$/0$=25,7$'(/0$(675$=*2 02180(172 $11(;,9$1(;2,9 GH 5HVROXFLyGHG DEULOGHOD'LUHFFLy*HQHUDOGH3DWULPRQL&XOWXUDO9DOHQFLjL0XVHXVGHOD&RQVHOOHULDGH&XOWXUD(GXFDFLyL(VSRUWSHUODTXHV LQFRDH[SHGLHQWSHUDOD SULPHUD IDVH GH O DFWXDOLW]DFLy L DGDSWDFLy SDUFLDO GH OD 6HFFLy 3ULPHUD GH O ,QYHQWDUL *HQHUDO GHO 3DWULPRQL &XOWXUDO 9DOHQFLj HQ PDWqULD GH SDWULPRQL DUTXLWHFWzQLF L PHGLDPELHQWDOLV¶REULSHUtRGHG¶LQIRUPDFLyS~EOLFD 5HVROXFLyQ GH GH DEULO GH OD 'LUHFFLyQ *HQHUDO GH 3DWULPRQLR &XOWXUDO 9DOHQFLDQR \ 0XVHRV GH OD &RQVHOOHULD GH &XOWXUD (GXFDFLyQ \ 'HSRUWH SRU OD TXH VH LQFRD H[SHGLHQWH SDUD OD SULPHUD IDVH GH OD DFWXDOL]DFLyQ \ DGDSWDFLyQ SDUFLDO GH OD 6HFFLyQ 3ULPHUD GHO ,QYHQWDULR *HQHUDO GHO 3DWULPRQLR &XOWXUDO 9DOHQFLDQR HQ PDWHULD GH SDWULPRQLRDUTXLWHFWyQLFR\PHGLRDPELHQWDO\VHDEUHSHULRGRGHLQIRUPDFLyQSXEOLFD 17987 Núm. 5.503 / 02.05.2007 17988 $SDUWDWE$SDUWDGRE 'HVFULSFLy GHOV EpQV FRUUHVSRQHQWV D OHV GHFODUDFLRQV FXOWXUDOV HIHFWXDGHV HQWUH HOV DQ\V LLQRFRQYDOLGDGHVRUHVWDEOLGHVSRVWHULRUPHQWDLQVFULXUHFRPD%pQVG¶,QWHUpV &XOWXUDOHQOD6HFFLy3ULPHUDGHO¶,QYHQWDUL*HQHUDOGHO3DWULPRQL&XOWXUDO9DOHQFLj 'HVFULSFLyQGHORVELHQHVFRUUHVSRQGLHQWHVDODVGHFODUDFLRQHVFXOWXUDOHVHIHFWXDGDVHQWUHORV DxRV\\QRFRQYDOLGDGDVRUHVWDEOHFLGDVSRVWHULRUPHQWHDLQVFULELUFRPR%LHQHVGH ,QWHUpV &XOWXUDO HQ OD 6HFFLyQ 3ULPHUD GHO ,QYHQWDULR *HQHUDO GHO 3DWULPRQLR &XOWXUDO 9DOHQFLDQR $11(;,9$1(;2,9 GH 5HVROXFLyGHG DEULOGHOD'LUHFFLy*HQHUDOGH3DWULPRQL&XOWXUDO9DOHQFLjL0XVHXVGHOD&RQVHOOHULDGH&XOWXUD(GXFDFLyL(VSRUWSHUODTXHV LQFRDH[SHGLHQWSHUDOD SULPHUD IDVH GH O DFWXDOLW]DFLy L DGDSWDFLy SDUFLDO GH OD 6HFFLy 3ULPHUD GH O ,QYHQWDUL *HQHUDO GHO 3DWULPRQL &XOWXUDO 9DOHQFLj HQ PDWqULD GH SDWULPRQL DUTXLWHFWzQLF L PHGLDPELHQWDOLV¶REULSHUtRGHG¶LQIRUPDFLyS~EOLFD 5HVROXFLyQ GH GH DEULO GH OD 'LUHFFLyQ *HQHUDO GH 3DWULPRQLR &XOWXUDO 9DOHQFLDQR \ 0XVHRV GH OD &RQVHOOHULD GH &XOWXUD (GXFDFLyQ \ 'HSRUWH SRU OD TXH VH LQFRD H[SHGLHQWH SDUD OD SULPHUD IDVH GH OD DFWXDOL]DFLyQ \ DGDSWDFLyQ SDUFLDO GH OD 6HFFLyQ 3ULPHUD GHO ,QYHQWDULR *HQHUDO GHO 3DWULPRQLR &XOWXUDO 9DOHQFLDQR HQ PDWHULD GH SDWULPRQLRDUTXLWHFWyQLFR\PHGLRDPELHQWDO\VHDEUHSHULRGRGHLQIRUPDFLyQSXEOLFD Núm. 5.503 / 02.05.2007 17989 %e'¶,17(5e6&8/785$/±%$1<6¬5$%67255(67255(602180(17 %,(1'(,17(5e6&8/785$/±%$f26È5$%(67255(67255(602180(172 'HQRPLQDFLy'HQRPLQDFLyQ 3ULQFLSDO3ULQFLSDO %DQ\V¬UDEV %DxRVÈUDEHV /RFDOL]DFLy/RFDOL]DFLyQ 3URYtQFLD3URYLQFLD9DOqQFLD &RPDUFD&RPDUFD(O&DPSGH0RUYHGUH 0XQLFLSL0XQLFLSLR7RUUHV7RUUHV 8ELFDFLy8ELFDFLyQ3ODoDGHO¶(VJOpVLDQ' 5HIHUqQFLD&DGDVWUDO5HIHUHQFLD&DWDVWUDO ,OOD0DQ]DQD3DUFHOāOD3DUFHOD $QWHFHGHQWV-XUtGLFV$QWHFHGHQWHV-XUtGLFRV 'HFODUDFLySUHFHGHQW'HFODUDFLyQSUHFHGHQWH 3XEOLFDFLyGHODGHFODUDFLySUHFHGHQW3XEOLFDFLyQGHODGHFODUDFLyQSUHFHGHQWH*DFHWDGHOD5HS~EOLFD 'HVFULSFLy'HVFULSFLyQ 3DUWV,QWHJUDQWV3DUWHV,QWHJUDQWHV − (OUHFLQWHFREHUWGHOVEDQ\V(OUHFLQWRFXELHUWRGHORVEDxRV − (OMDFLPHQWDUTXHROzJLFGHOYHVWtEXOGHOVEDQ\V(O\DFLPLHQWRDUTXHROyJLFRGHOYHVWtEXORGHORVEDxRV − (OWUDPGHOD6pTXLD0DMRUGH6DJXQW(OWUDPRGHODµ6pTXLD0DMRUGH6DJXQW¶ 'HVFULSFLy*HQHUDO'HVFULSFLyQ*HQHUDO (OV %DQ\V ¬UDEV GH 7RUUHV7RUUHV V¶XELTXHQ D WRFDU GH OD SREODFLy DVVRFLDGDPHQW D OD 6pTXLD 0DMRU GH 6DJXQWTXHYRUHMDO¶DQWLFQXFOLXUEj (O UHFLQWH FREHUW GHOV %DQ\V pV XQD SODQWD GH IRUPD UHFWDQJXODU TXH FRQWp WUHV VDOHV WDPEp UHFWDQJXODUV FREHUWHV DPE YROWHV GLVSRVDGHV HQ SDUDOāOHO L HQ RULHQWDFLy QRUGVXG FRQHJXGHV DPE HOV QRPV GH IUHGD WqELDLFDOHQWD/ HQWUDGDDOV%DQ\VHVORFDOLW]DYDDODIURQWHUDQRUG'HVGHOYHVWtEXOV¶DFFHGLDSHUXQDSRUWD GH PLJ SXQW D OD VDOD IUHGD /D VDOD IUHGD pV OD PpV DXVWHUD GH OHV WUHV /D VDOD WqELD pV OD GH PDMRU VXSHUItFLH L DPSOjULD (VWj GLYLGLGD HQ WUHV SDUWV SHU PLWMj GH GRV DUFV GH PLJ SXQW IHWV DPE UDMROHV TXH FRQIRUPHQGXHVDOFRYHVODWHUDOVDOoDGHVXQHVFDOyUHVSHFWHDO HVSDLFHQWUDO/DWHUFHUDVDODpVODFDOHQWDL Wp XQD VXSHUItFLH G XQV [ P L V HVFDOID SHU XQD FDPEUD VXEWHUUjQLD RQ V LQMHFWD DLUH FDOHQW (O SDYLPHQW GHOV %DQ\V pV GH UDMROHV FXLWHV GLVSRVDGHV HQ HVSLQD GH SHL[ /D LOāOXPLQDFLy GH O LQWHULRU V DFRQVHJXHL[SHUOHVOOXHUQHV6yQGHVHFFLyHVWUHOODGDLWURQFSLUDPLGDOVGHEDVHHQO LQWUDGyVGHODYROWD /¶H[FDYDFLy DUTXHROzJLFD GHO D EDQGD G¶RIHULU XQD GDWDFLy PpV SUHFLVD HQ HO 6 ;,9 MD HQ pSRFD FULVWLDQD KD SHUPpV GRFXPHQWDU OHV HVWUXFWXUHV FRUUHVSRQHQWV DO 9HVWtEXO R VDOD GH GHVFDQV GHOV EDQ\V /¶HVWDQoDpVGHSODQWDTXDGUDGDDPEPXUVSHULPHWUDOVFRQVWUXwWVGHWjSLDGHWHUUDDPEFURVWDGHPRUWHU 7LSROzJLFDPHQWHOV%DQ\VGH7RUUHV7RUUHVUHVSRQHQDOPRGHOTXHHVUHSHWHL[DOOODUJGHWRWDODJHRJUDILD KLVWzULFDjUDEWUHVVDOHVDPEXQDFHQWUDOPpVDPSOD/HVOOXHUQHVGHVHFFLyHVWUHOODGDLIRUPDHQWURQFGH SLUjPLGHVyQHVWLOtVWLFDPHQWUHSUHVHQWDWLYHVGHO DUTXLWHFWXUDjUDE(OVLVWHPDKLGUjXOLFEDVDWHVSHFLDOPHQW DPE O¶DEDVWLPHQW GH OD 6pTXLD 0DMRU GH 6DJXQW SRGLD YHXUH¶V FRPSOHPHQWDW SHU XQ DOMXE YHt GHO TXDO GHULYDULDSHUDO ~VJHQHUDOGHODSREODFLyHOTXHHQFDUDVXEVLVWL[ 'H SURSLHWDW PXQLFLSDO HO SURFpV GH UHKDELOLWDFLy LQWHJUDO SODQWHMDW GqFDGHV HQUHUH D FjUUHF GH /D *HQHUDOLWDW KD FRPHQoDW D SUHQGUH FRV HQ O¶DQ\ L HVWj SUHYLVW FRQFORXUH¶O HQ HO 5HVXP GH O¶HVERUUDQ\WqFQLFGHODSURSRVWDGHO¶$MXQWDPHQWGH7RUUHV7RUUHVSHUDODGHFODUDFLy%,& /RV %DxRV ÈUDEHV GH 7RUUHV7RUUHV VH VLWXDQ MXQWR D OD SREODFLyQ DVRFLDGDPHQWH D OD 6pTXLD 0DMRU GH 6DJXQWTXHERUGHDHODQWLJXRQXFOHRXUEDQR (O UHFLQWR FXELHUWR GH ORV %DxRV HV XQD SODQWD GH IRUPD UHFWDQJXODU TXH FRQWLHQH WUHV VDODV WDPELpQ UHFWDQJXODUHVFXELHUWDVFRQEyYHGDVGLVSXHVWDVHQSDUDOHOR\ HQRULHQWDFLyQQRUWHVXUFRQRFLGDVFRQORV QRPEUHV GHIUtDWLELD\FDOLHQWH /D HQWUDGD HQ ORV %DxRV VH ORFDOL]DED HQ HO QRUWH 'HVGH HO YHVWtEXOR VH DFFHGtDSRUXQDSXHUWDGHPHGLRSXQWRDODVDODIUtD/DVDODIUtDHVODPiVDXVWHUDGHODVWUHV/DVDODWLELD HV OD GHPD\RUVXSHUILFLH\ DQFKXUD(VWiGLYLGLGDHQWUHV SDUWHV SRUPHGLR GHGRV DUFRV GH PHGLR SXQWR KHFKRV FRQ ODGULOORV TXH FRQIRUPDQ GRV DOFREDV ODWHUDOHV OHYDQWDGDV XQ HVFDOyQ FRQ UHVSHFWR DO HVSDFLR FHQWUDO/DWHUFHUD VDOD HVODFDOLHQWH\WLHQHXQDVXSHUILFLH GHXQRV [ P \ VH FDOLHQWD SRU XQD $11(;,9$1(;2,9 GH 5HVROXFLyGHG DEULOGHOD'LUHFFLy*HQHUDOGH3DWULPRQL&XOWXUDO9DOHQFLjL0XVHXVGHOD&RQVHOOHULDGH&XOWXUD(GXFDFLyL(VSRUWSHUODTXHV LQFRDH[SHGLHQWSHUDOD SULPHUD IDVH GH O DFWXDOLW]DFLy L DGDSWDFLy SDUFLDO GH OD 6HFFLy 3ULPHUD GH O ,QYHQWDUL *HQHUDO GHO 3DWULPRQL &XOWXUDO 9DOHQFLj HQ PDWqULD GH SDWULPRQL DUTXLWHFWzQLF L PHGLDPELHQWDOLV¶REULSHUtRGHG¶LQIRUPDFLyS~EOLFD 5HVROXFLyQ GH GH DEULO GH OD 'LUHFFLyQ *HQHUDO GH 3DWULPRQLR &XOWXUDO 9DOHQFLDQR \ 0XVHRV GH OD &RQVHOOHULD GH &XOWXUD (GXFDFLyQ \ 'HSRUWH SRU OD TXH VH LQFRD H[SHGLHQWH SDUD OD SULPHUD IDVH GH OD DFWXDOL]DFLyQ \ DGDSWDFLyQ SDUFLDO GH OD 6HFFLyQ 3ULPHUD GHO ,QYHQWDULR *HQHUDO GHO 3DWULPRQLR &XOWXUDO 9DOHQFLDQR HQ PDWHULD GH SDWULPRQLRDUTXLWHFWyQLFR\PHGLRDPELHQWDO\VHDEUHSHULRGRGHLQIRUPDFLyQSXEOLFD Núm. 5.503 / 02.05.2007 17990 FiPDUD VXEWHUUiQHD GRQGH VH LQ\HFWD DLUH FDOLHQWH (O SDYLPHQWR GH ORV %DxRV HV GH ODGULOORV FRFLGRV GLVSXHVWRV HQ HVSLQD GH SH] /D LOXPLQDFLyQ GHO LQWHULRU VH FRQVLJXH SRU ODV OXFHUQDV 6RQ GH VHFFLyQ HVWUHOODGD\WURQFRSLUDPLGDOHVGHEDVHHQHOLQWUDGyVGHODEyYHGD /DH[FDYDFLyQDUTXHROyJLFDGHKDSHUPLWLGRDGHPiVGHRIUHFHUXQDGDWDFLyQPiVSUHFLVD6;,9\D HQ pSRFD FULVWLDQD GRFXPHQWDU ODV HVWUXFWXUDV FRUUHVSRQGLHQWHV DO 9HVWtEXOR R VDOD GH GHVFDQVR GH ORV EDxRV /D HVWDQFLD HV GH SODQWD FXDGUDGD FRQ PXURV SHULPHWUDOHV FRQVWUXLGRV GH WDSLD FRQ FRVWUD GH PRUWHUR 7LSROyJLFDPHQWH ORV %DxRV GH 7RUUHV 7RUUHV UHVSRQGHQ DO PRGHOR TXH VH UHSLWH D OR ODUJR GH WRGD OD JHRJUDItDKLVWyULFDiUDEHWUHVVDODVFRQXQDFHQWUDOPHVDQFKD/DVOXFHUQDVGHVHFFLyQHVWUHOODGD\IRUPD HQWURQFRGHSLUiPLGHVRQ HVWLOtVWLFDPHQWHUHSUHVHQWDWLYDVGHODDUTXLWHFWXUDiUDEH(OVLVWHPDKLGUiXOLFR EDVDGRSDUWLFXODUPHQWHHQHODEDVWHFLPLHQWRGHOD6pTXLD0DMRUGH6DJXQWSRGtDYHUVHFRPSOHPHQWDGRSHU XQDOMLEHYHFLQRGHOFXDOGHULYDUtDHOTXHFRQFHELGRSDUDVHUYLFLRGHODSREODFLyQD~QVXEVLVWH 'H SURSLHGDG PXQLFLSDO HO SURFHVR GH UHKDELOLWDFLyQ LQWHJUDO SODQWHDGR GpFDGDV DWUiV D FDUJR GH /D *HQHUDOLWDW FRPHQ]y D WRPDU FXHUSR HQ HO DxR \ HVWi SUHYLVWR FRQFOXLU HQ HO 5HVXPHQ GHO ERUUDGRUWpFQLFRGHODSURSXHVWDGHO$\XQWDPLHQWRGH7RUUHV7RUUHVSDUDODGHFODUDFLyQ%,& 2EVHUYDFLRQV2EVHUYDFLRQHV (QWRUQ(QWRUQ $QWHFHGHQWVDGPLQLVWUDWLXVGHOLPLWDFLyGHO H[SHGLHQWDPEFDUjFWHUSURYLVLRQDO 2ULJHQLQWHUVHFFLyGH O HL[GHO&DPtG ,HORVDPEODSURORQJDFLyGHODPLWJHUDQRUG GHODSDUFHOāOD GHO SROtJRQSXQW$ 6HQWLWKRUDUL /tQLDGHOLPLWDGRUD'HVGHO RULJHQODOtQLDGLVFRUUHSHUODPLWJHUDQRUGGHODSDUFHOāODGHOSROtJRQSHU DVHJXLUSHUODPLWJHUDQRUGGHODSDUFHOāODJLUDQWLFRQWLQXDQWSHUODPLWJHUDHVWGHOHVSDUFHOāOHV L&UHXDHOFDL[HUGHOD6pTXLD0DMRUGH6DJXQWILQVDUULEDUDOFRVWDWQRUGGHO DQWLJDFDUUHWHUD G $UDJyVHJXLQWSHUDTXHL[FRVWDWPHWUHV&UHXDODGLWDFDUUHWHUDLDPGHODPDWHL[DJLUDDSRQHQWL VHJXL[ HQ SDUDOāOHO D OD FDUUHWHUD ILQV DUULEDU D O (VJOpVLD 3DUURTXLDO OD TXDO LQFRUSRUD &UHXD HO FDUUHU GH O HVJOpVLDLSXMDDOQRUGSHUODIDoDQDGHODSDUFHOāODQ~PG DTXHVWFDUUHULLQFRUSRUDOHVSDUFHOāOHVL GHODPDWHL[D/DOtQLDFRQWLQXDFDSDOQRUGHQODGLUHFFLyGH ODSDUWGHOGDUUHUHGHODSDUFHOāODLFUHXDHO FDL[HU GHOD6pTXLD0DMRUILQVDO YqUWH[ VXG GHODPLWJHUDGHOHVSDUFHOāOHVLGHO SROtJRQ L GHV G DFtLQFRUSRUDOHVSDUFHOāOHVLG HVWHSROtJRQILQVWDQFDUDPEO¶RULJHQ $QWHFHGHQWHVDGPLQLVWUDWLYRVGHOLPLWDFLyQGHOH[SHGLHQWHFRQFDUiFWHUSURYLVLRQDO 2ULJHQLQWHUVHFFLyQGHOHMHGHOFDPLQRGH,HORVFRQODSURORQJDFLyQGHODPHGLDQHUDQRUWHGHODSDUFHOD GHOSROtJRQRSXQWR$ 6HQWLGRKRUDULR /tQHDGHOLPLWDGRUD'HVGHHORULJHQODOtQHDGLVFXUUHSRUODPHGLDQHUDQRUWHGHODSDUFHODGHOSROtJRQR SDUDVHJXLUSRUODPHGLDQHUDQRUWHGHODSDUFHODJLUDQGR\FRQWLQXDQGRSRUODPHGLDQHUD HVWH GH ODVSDUFHODV\&UX]DHOFDMHURGHODDFHTXLD0D\RUGH6DJXQWRKDVWDOOHJDUDOODGRQRUWH GHODDQWLJXDFDUUHWHUDGH$UDJyQVLJXLHQGRSRUHVWHODGRPHWURV&UX]DGLFKDFDUUHWHUD\DPGHOD PLVPDJLUDDSRQLHQWH\VLJXHHQSDUDOHORDODFDUUHWHUDKDVWDOOHJDUDOD,JOHVLD3DUURTXLDOODFXDOLQFRUSRUD &UX]D OD FDOOH GH OD ,JOHVLD \ VXEH D QRUWH SRU OD IDFKDGD Q GH SROLFtD GH HVWD FDOOH H LQFRUSRUD ODV SDUFHODV\GHODPLVPD/DOtQHDFRQWLQ~DKDFLDHOQRUWHHQODGLUHFFLyQGHODWUDVHUDGHODSDUFHOD\ FUX]D HO FDMHUR GH OD DFHTXLD 0D\RU KDVWD HO YpUWLFH VXU GH OD PHGLDQHUD GH ODV SDUFHODV \ GHO SROtJRQR\GHVGHDTXtLQFRUSRUDODVSDUFHODV\GHHVWHSROtJRQRKDVWDFHUUDUFRQ HORULJHQ $11(;,9$1(;2,9 GH 5HVROXFLyGHG DEULOGHOD'LUHFFLy*HQHUDOGH3DWULPRQL&XOWXUDO9DOHQFLjL0XVHXVGHOD&RQVHOOHULDGH&XOWXUD(GXFDFLyL(VSRUWSHUODTXHV LQFRDH[SHGLHQWSHUDOD SULPHUD IDVH GH O DFWXDOLW]DFLy L DGDSWDFLy SDUFLDO GH OD 6HFFLy 3ULPHUD GH O ,QYHQWDUL *HQHUDO GHO 3DWULPRQL &XOWXUDO 9DOHQFLj HQ PDWqULD GH SDWULPRQL DUTXLWHFWzQLF L PHGLDPELHQWDOLV¶REULSHUtRGHG¶LQIRUPDFLyS~EOLFD 5HVROXFLyQ GH GH DEULO GH OD 'LUHFFLyQ *HQHUDO GH 3DWULPRQLR &XOWXUDO 9DOHQFLDQR \ 0XVHRV GH OD &RQVHOOHULD GH &XOWXUD (GXFDFLyQ \ 'HSRUWH SRU OD TXH VH LQFRD H[SHGLHQWH SDUD OD SULPHUD IDVH GH OD DFWXDOL]DFLyQ \ DGDSWDFLyQ SDUFLDO GH OD 6HFFLyQ 3ULPHUD GHO ,QYHQWDULR *HQHUDO GHO 3DWULPRQLR &XOWXUDO 9DOHQFLDQR HQ PDWHULD GH SDWULPRQLRDUTXLWHFWyQLFR\PHGLRDPELHQWDO\VHDEUHSHULRGRGHLQIRUPDFLyQSXEOLFD Núm. 5.503 / 02.05.2007 17991 %,(1'(,17(5e6&8/785$/ %$f26È5$%(67255(67255(602180(172 $11(;,9$1(;2,9 GH 5HVROXFLyGHG DEULOGHOD'LUHFFLy*HQHUDOGH3DWULPRQL&XOWXUDO9DOHQFLjL0XVHXVGHOD&RQVHOOHULDGH&XOWXUD(GXFDFLyL(VSRUWSHUODTXHV LQFRDH[SHGLHQWSHUDOD SULPHUD IDVH GH O DFWXDOLW]DFLy L DGDSWDFLy SDUFLDO GH OD 6HFFLy 3ULPHUD GH O ,QYHQWDUL *HQHUDO GHO 3DWULPRQL &XOWXUDO 9DOHQFLj HQ PDWqULD GH SDWULPRQL DUTXLWHFWzQLF L PHGLDPELHQWDOLV¶REULSHUtRGHG¶LQIRUPDFLyS~EOLFD 5HVROXFLyQ GH GH DEULO GH OD 'LUHFFLyQ *HQHUDO GH 3DWULPRQLR &XOWXUDO 9DOHQFLDQR \ 0XVHRV GH OD &RQVHOOHULD GH &XOWXUD (GXFDFLyQ \ 'HSRUWH SRU OD TXH VH LQFRD H[SHGLHQWH SDUD OD SULPHUD IDVH GH OD DFWXDOL]DFLyQ \ DGDSWDFLyQ SDUFLDO GH OD 6HFFLyQ 3ULPHUD GHO ,QYHQWDULR *HQHUDO GHO 3DWULPRQLR &XOWXUDO 9DOHQFLDQR HQ PDWHULD GH SDWULPRQLRDUTXLWHFWyQLFR\PHGLRDPELHQWDO\VHDEUHSHULRGRGHLQIRUPDFLyQSXEOLFD Núm. 5.503 / 02.05.2007 17992 %e'¶,17(5e6&8/785$/±5(,$/&2/ā/(*,6(0,1$5,'(/&25386&+5,67,2'(/3$75,$5&$9$/(1&,$ 02180(17 %,(1'(,17(5e6&8/785$/±5($/&2/(*,26(0,1$5,2'(/&25386&+5,67,2'(/3$75,$5&$ 02180(172 'HQRPLQDFLy'HQRPLQDFLyQ 3ULQFLSDO3ULQFLSDO 5HLDO&ROāOHJL6HPLQDULGHO&RUSXV&KULVWLRGHO 3DWULDUFD 5HDO&ROHJLR6HPLQDULRGHO&RUSXV&KULVWLRGHO 3DWULDUFD /RFDOL]DFLy/RFDOL]DFLyQ 3URYtQFLD3URYLQFLD9DOqQFLD O&RPDUFD&RPDUFDO¶+RUWD 0XQLFLSL0XQLFLSLR9DOqQFLD 8ELFDFLy8ELFDFLyQ&GHOD1DX 5HIHUqQFLD&DGDVWUDO5HIHUHQFLD&DWDVWUDO ,OOD0DQ]DQD3DUFHOāOD3DUFHOD $QWHFHGHQWV-XUtGLFV$QWHFHGHQWHV-XUtGLFRV 'HFODUDFLySUHFHGHQW'HFODUDFLyQSUHFHGHQWH 3XEOLFDFLyGHODGHFODUDFLySUHFHGHQW3XEOLFDFLyQGHODGHFODUDFLyQSUHFHGHQWH*DFHWDGHOD5HS~EOLFD 'HFODUDFLyQ DVVRFLDGD D OD IXQFLy PXVHtVWLFD L DU[LYtVWLFD 'HFODUDFLyQ DVRFLDGD D OD IXQFLyQ PXVHtVWLFD \ DUFKLYtVWLFD%2( 'HVFULSFLy'HVFULSFLyQ 3DUWV,QWHJUDQWV3DUWHV,QWHJUDQWHV − $WUL FDSHOOD WRUUH FDPSDQDU HVJOpVLD FODXVWUH SDWL HVFDOHV GHSHQGqQFLHV GHO FROāOHJL VDOD G HVWXGL DU[LX DGPLQLVWUDFLy KDELWDFLRQV UHFWRUDOV VDOD GH UHJLGRUV FHOāOHV L ELEOLRWHFD VDOD GH PDSHV DXOHV UHIHFWRUL VDJULVWLD UHOLTXLDUL JXDUGDURED ELEOLRWHFD GHO 3DWULDUFD $WULR FDSLOOD WRUUH FDPSDQDULR LJOHVLD FODXVWUR SDWLR HVFDOHUDV GHSHQGHQFLDV GHO FROHJLR VDOD GH HVWXGLR DUFKLYR DGPLQLVWUDFLyQ KDELWDFLRQHV UHFWRUDOHV VDOD GH FRQFHMDOHV FHOGDV \ ELEOLRWHFD VDOD GH PDSDV DXODV UHIHFWRULR VDFULVWtDUHOLFDULRJXDUGDUURSDELEOLRWHFDGHO3DWULDUFD 'HVFULSFLy*HQHUDO'HVFULSFLyQ*HQHUDO (QHOFHQWUHGHODFLXWDWHQIURQWGHO DQWLJD8QLYHUVLWDW/LWHUjULDHVWUREDHO5HLDO&ROāOHJL6HPLQDULGHO&RUSXV &KULVWLWDPEpFRQHJXWFRP³(O3DWULDUFD´SHUTXqYDVHUDOoDWDLQVWjQFLHVGHOSDWULDUFD6DQW-RDQGH5LEHUD /D VHXD FRQVWUXFFLy YD FRPHQoDU HQ L HV YD DFDEDU HQ 9DQ LQWHUYLQGUH PHVWUHV SHGUDSLTXHUV FRP *DVSDU *UHJRUL *XLOOHP GHO 5HL L %DUWRPHX $EULO HQWUH G¶DOWUHV (V WUDFWD G XQ FRPSDFWH HGLILFL TXH RFXSDXQDLOOD FRPSOHWD 6 RUGHQD D WUDYpV G XQ FODXVWUH UHFWDQJXODU DO YROWDQW GHO TXDO HV GLVWULEXw[HQ OHV GHSHQGqQFLHV FROāOHJLDOV L HQ HO FRVWDW RHVW HV WURED O HVJOpVLD (O FODXVWUH pV XQ GHOV PLOORUV H[HPSOHV G DUTXLWHFWXUD UHQDL[HQWLVWD UHDOLW]DW DPE FROXPQHV GH PDUEUH JHQRYpV / HVJOpVLD pV GH SODQWD GH FUHX OODWLQDDPEXQDVRODQDXDPEFDSHOOHVODWHUDOVLFDSoDOHUDUHFWDDPEF~SXODHQHOFUHXHU(VWjGLYLGLGDHQ GRVWUDPVLSUHVHQWDXQWHUFHUWUDPDOVSHXVVREUHHOTXDO HVGLVSRVDHOFRUDOW/ LQWHULRUHVWjWRWDOPHQW GHFRUDWSHUSLQWXUHVDOIUHVF/DFDSHOODpVGHSODQWDUHFWDQJXODUDPEFDSoDOHUDSROLJRQDOGHFRUDGDDOIUHVF SHU7RPiV+HUQiQGH](QO DQJOHQRUGHVWGHOFODXVWUHV DOoDO HVFDODGHYROWHVUHDOLW]DGDDPEFDUUHXVTXHpV XQ H[HPSOH SHU D DOWUHV UHDOLW]DGHV SRVWHULRUPHQW HQ GLYHUVRV HGLILFLV (Q OD IDoDQD GHVWDFD OD JDOHULD VXSHULRUG DUTXHWVLODWRUUHFDPSDQDU GHOFDQWy/D SRUWDGDUHDOLW]DGDHQPDUEUHSUHVHQWDXQ DUF DOOLQGDW IODQTXHMDW SHU FROXPQHV DSDULDGHV VREUH SHGHVWDOV 'HVSUpV GHO FODXVWUH L O HVJOpVLD HV GHVHQYROXSHQ OHV GHSHQGqQFLHVGHVHUYHL HQWRUQDXQSDWLPHQRU(QOD SDUW SRVWHULRU GH O HGLILFL V REUL XQD SRUWD GDYDQW OD TXDOV DOojXQDUHL[DHQHOVHJOH;,;DPEDOWVDPSLWVLUHPDWDGHVHQIRUPDGHSLUjPLGH%DVDWHQHO&DWjOHJ GH0RQXPHQWVL&RQMXQWVGHOD&RPXQLWDW9DOHQFLDQDL9DOqQFLD$UTXLWHFWXUDUHOLJLRVD (QHOFHQWURGHODFLXGDGIUHQWHDODDQWLJXD8QLYHUVLGDG/LWHUDULDVHHQFXHQWUDHO5HDO&ROHJLR6HPLQDULRGHO &RUSXV&KULVWLWDPELpQFRQRFLGRFRPR(O3DWULDUFD )XH OHYDQWDGR D LQVWDQFLDV GHO SDWULDUFD 6DQ -XDQ GH 5LEHUD 6X FRQVWUXFFLyQ VH FRPHQ]y HQ WHUPLQiQGRVH HQ ,QWHUYLQLHURQ PDHVWURV FDQWHURV FRPR *DVSDU *UHJRUt *XLOOHP GHO 5H\ %DUWRORPp $11(;,9$1(;2,9 GH 5HVROXFLyGHG DEULOGHOD'LUHFFLy*HQHUDOGH3DWULPRQL&XOWXUDO9DOHQFLjL0XVHXVGHOD&RQVHOOHULDGH&XOWXUD(GXFDFLyL(VSRUWSHUODTXHV LQFRDH[SHGLHQWSHUDOD SULPHUD IDVH GH O DFWXDOLW]DFLy L DGDSWDFLy SDUFLDO GH OD 6HFFLy 3ULPHUD GH O ,QYHQWDUL *HQHUDO GHO 3DWULPRQL &XOWXUDO 9DOHQFLj HQ PDWqULD GH SDWULPRQL DUTXLWHFWzQLF L PHGLDPELHQWDOLV¶REULSHUtRGHG¶LQIRUPDFLyS~EOLFD 5HVROXFLyQ GH GH DEULO GH OD 'LUHFFLyQ *HQHUDO GH 3DWULPRQLR &XOWXUDO 9DOHQFLDQR \ 0XVHRV GH OD &RQVHOOHULD GH &XOWXUD (GXFDFLyQ \ 'HSRUWH SRU OD TXH VH LQFRD H[SHGLHQWH SDUD OD SULPHUD IDVH GH OD DFWXDOL]DFLyQ \ DGDSWDFLyQ SDUFLDO GH OD 6HFFLyQ 3ULPHUD GHO ,QYHQWDULR *HQHUDO GHO 3DWULPRQLR &XOWXUDO 9DOHQFLDQR HQ PDWHULD GH SDWULPRQLRDUTXLWHFWyQLFR\PHGLRDPELHQWDO\VHDEUHSHULRGRGHLQIRUPDFLyQSXEOLFD Núm. 5.503 / 02.05.2007 17993 $EULOHQWUHRWURV6HWUDWDGHXQFRPSDFWRHGLILFLRTXHRFXSDXQDPDQ]DQDFRPSOHWD6HRUGHQDDWUDYpVGH XQ FODXVWUR UHFWDQJXODU DOUHGHGRU GHO FXDO VH GLVWULEX\HQ ODV GHSHQGHQFLDV FROHJLDOHV \ HQ HO ODGR RHVWH VH HQFXHQWUDODLJOHVLD (O FODXVWUR HV XQR GH ORV PHMRUHV HMHPSORV GH DUTXLWHFWXUD UHQDFHQWLVWD UHDOL]DGR FRQ FROXPQDVGHPiUPROJHQRYpV/DLJOHVLDHVGHSODQWDGHFUX]ODWLQDFRQXQDVRODQDYHFRQFDSLOODVODWHUDOHV\ FDEHFHUD UHFWD FRQ F~SXOD HQ HO FUXFHUR (VWi GLYLGLGD HQ GRV WUDPRV SUHVHQWDQGR XQ WHUFHUR D ORV SLHV VREUHHOTXHVHGLVSRQHHOFRURDOWR(OLQWHULRUHVWDWRWDOPHQWHGHFRUDGRSRUSLQWXUDVDOIUHVFR/DFDSLOODHV GHSODQWDUHFWDQJXODUFRQFDEHFHUDSROLJRQDOGHFRUDGDDOIUHVFRSRU7RPiV+HUQiQGH](QHOiQJXORQRUHVWH GHO FODXVWUR VH DO]D OD HVFDOHUD GH YROWHV UHDOL]DGD HQ FDQWHUtD TXH VHUtD HMHPSOR SDUD RWUDV UHDOL]DGDV SRVWHULRUPHQWHHQRWURVHGLILFLRV(QODIDFKDGDGHVWDFDODJDOHUtDVXSHULRUGHDUTXLOORV\ODWRUUHFDPSDQDULR GH OD HVTXLQD /D SRUWDGD UHDOL]DGD HQ PiUPRO SUHVHQWD XQ DUFR DGLQWHODGR IODQTXHDGR SRU FROXPQDV SDUHDGDVVREUHSHGHVWDOHV7UDVHOFODXVWUR\ODLJOHVLDVHGHVDUUROODQODVGHSHQGHQFLDVGHVHUYLFLRHQWRUQRD XQSDWLRPHQRU(QODSDUWHWUDVHUDGHO HGLILFLR VH DEUH XQD SXHUWD DQWH OD TXH VH OHYDQWR XQD YHUMD HQ HO VLJOR ;,; FRQ DOWRV SUHWLOHV \ UHPDWHV HQ IRUPD GH SLUiPLGH %DVDGR HQ HO &DWiORJR GH 0RQXPHQWRV \ &RQMXQWRVGHOD&RPXQLGDG9DOHQFLDQD\9DOHQFLD$UTXLWHFWXUDUHOLJLRVD 2EVHUYDFLRQV2EVHUYDFLRQHV (QWRUQ(QWRUQ $QWHFHGHQWV DGPLQLVWUDWLXV /D GHOLPLWDFLy GH O HQWRUQ GH SURWHFFLy V DFXOO DO TXH GLVSRVD O $SWDW GH OD 'LVSRVLFLy 7UDQVLWzULD 3ULPHUD GH OD OOHL PRGLILFDGRUD GH OD (VWD GHOLPLWDFLy TXHGD UHFRQHJXGD DPE FDUjFWHU SURYLVLRQDO VHJRQV OD GHOLPLWDFLy FRQWLQJXGD HQ OD UHVROXFLy GH GH MXOLRO GH SXEOLFDGDHQHO'2*9GHGDWD 2ULJHQ9qUWH[QRUGHVWGHODSDUFHOāODFDGDVWUDOGHO LOODGHFDVHVSXQW$ 6HQWLWDQWLKRUDUL /tQLDGHOLPLWDGRUDGHVGHO RULJHQODOtQLDHVGLULJL[DQRUG SHOOtPLWRHVWGHOFDUUHUGHOHV&RPqGLHVILQVDO FDUUHU GH OD 3DX 6HJXL[ SHO OtPLW VXG G HVWH FDUUHU ILQV DO FDUUHU G¶(Q 6DOD SHU OD TXDO SURVVHJXL[ ILQV DO FDUUHUGHOV/OLEUHUVSHUODTXDOVHJXL[DRHVWSHUDHQJOREDUO LOODFDGDVWUDO&UHXDHOFDUUHUGH6DOYjL LQFRUSRUDOD SDUFHOāOD GHO LOOD FUHXD HOFDUUHU GHOD6ROHWDW L UHFRUUH OHV SDUWV GHO GDUUHUH GH OHV SDUFHOāOHVLGHO LOODGHFDVHVFUHXDHOFDUUHUGH0LQ\DQDILQVDOSXQWG RULJHQ $QWHFHGHQWHV DGPLQLVWUDWLYRV /D GHOLPLWDFLyQ GHO HQWRUQR GH SURWHFFLyQ VH DFRJH D OR GLVSXHVWR HQ HO $SWGRGHOD'LVSRVLFLyQ7UDQVLWRULD3ULPHUDGHODOH\PRGLILFDGRUDGHOD(VWDGHOLPLWDFLyQ TXHGDUHFRQRFLGDFRQFDUiFWHU SURYLVLRQDOVHJ~QOD GHOLPLWDFLyQFRQWHQLGDHQODUHVROXFLyQGH GHMXOLR GHSXEOLFDGDHQHO'2*9GHIHFKD 2ULJHQ9pUWLFHQRUGHVWHGHODSDUFHODFDWDVWUDOGHODPDQ]DQDSXQWR$ 6HQWLGRDQWLKRUDULR /tQHDGHOLPLWDGRUDGHVGHHORULJHQODOtQHDVHGLULJHDQRUWHSRUHOOLQGHRHVWHGHODFDOOH&RPHGLDVKDVWDOD FDOOHGHOD3D]6LJXHSRUHOOLQGHVXUGHHVWDFDOOHKDVWDOD FDOOH(Q6DODSRUODTXHSURVLJXHKDVWDODFDOOH /LEUHURV SRU OD TXH VLJXH D RHVWH SDUD HQJOREDU OD PDQ]DQD &UX]D OD FDOOH 6DOYi H LQFRUSRUD OD SDUFHODGHODPDQ]DQDFUX]DODFDOOH6ROHGDG\UHFRUUHODVWUDVHUDVGHODVSDUFHODV\ GHODPDQ]DQDFUX]DODFDOOH0LxDQDKDVWDHOSXQWRGHRULJHQ $11(;,9$1(;2,9 GH 5HVROXFLyGHG DEULOGHOD'LUHFFLy*HQHUDOGH3DWULPRQL&XOWXUDO9DOHQFLjL0XVHXVGHOD&RQVHOOHULDGH&XOWXUD(GXFDFLyL(VSRUWSHUODTXHV LQFRDH[SHGLHQWSHUDOD SULPHUD IDVH GH O DFWXDOLW]DFLy L DGDSWDFLy SDUFLDO GH OD 6HFFLy 3ULPHUD GH O ,QYHQWDUL *HQHUDO GHO 3DWULPRQL &XOWXUDO 9DOHQFLj HQ PDWqULD GH SDWULPRQL DUTXLWHFWzQLF L PHGLDPELHQWDOLV¶REULSHUtRGHG¶LQIRUPDFLyS~EOLFD 5HVROXFLyQ GH GH DEULO GH OD 'LUHFFLyQ *HQHUDO GH 3DWULPRQLR &XOWXUDO 9DOHQFLDQR \ 0XVHRV GH OD &RQVHOOHULD GH &XOWXUD (GXFDFLyQ \ 'HSRUWH SRU OD TXH VH LQFRD H[SHGLHQWH SDUD OD SULPHUD IDVH GH OD DFWXDOL]DFLyQ \ DGDSWDFLyQ SDUFLDO GH OD 6HFFLyQ 3ULPHUD GHO ,QYHQWDULR *HQHUDO GHO 3DWULPRQLR &XOWXUDO 9DOHQFLDQR HQ PDWHULD GH SDWULPRQLRDUTXLWHFWyQLFR\PHGLRDPELHQWDO\VHDEUHSHULRGRGHLQIRUPDFLyQSXEOLFD Núm. 5.503 / 02.05.2007 17994 %e'¶,17(5e6&8/785$/±5(,$/&2/ā/(*,6(0,1$5,'(/&25386&+5,67,2'(/3$75,$5&$9$/(1&,$ 02180(17 %,(1'(,17(5e6&8/785$/±5($/&2/(*,26(0,1$5,2'(/&25386&+5,67,2'(/3$75,$5&$02180(172 $11(;,9$1(;2,9 GH 5HVROXFLyGHG DEULOGHOD'LUHFFLy*HQHUDOGH3DWULPRQL&XOWXUDO9DOHQFLjL0XVHXVGHOD&RQVHOOHULDGH&XOWXUD(GXFDFLyL(VSRUWSHUODTXHV LQFRDH[SHGLHQWSHUDOD SULPHUD IDVH GH O DFWXDOLW]DFLy L DGDSWDFLy SDUFLDO GH OD 6HFFLy 3ULPHUD GH O ,QYHQWDUL *HQHUDO GHO 3DWULPRQL &XOWXUDO 9DOHQFLj HQ PDWqULD GH SDWULPRQL DUTXLWHFWzQLF L PHGLDPELHQWDOLV¶REULSHUtRGHG¶LQIRUPDFLyS~EOLFD 5HVROXFLyQ GH GH DEULO GH OD 'LUHFFLyQ *HQHUDO GH 3DWULPRQLR &XOWXUDO 9DOHQFLDQR \ 0XVHRV GH OD &RQVHOOHULD GH &XOWXUD (GXFDFLyQ \ 'HSRUWH SRU OD TXH VH LQFRD H[SHGLHQWH SDUD OD SULPHUD IDVH GH OD DFWXDOL]DFLyQ \ DGDSWDFLyQ SDUFLDO GH OD 6HFFLyQ 3ULPHUD GHO ,QYHQWDULR *HQHUDO GHO 3DWULPRQLR &XOWXUDO 9DOHQFLDQR HQ PDWHULD GH SDWULPRQLRDUTXLWHFWyQLFR\PHGLRDPELHQWDO\VHDEUHSHULRGRGHLQIRUPDFLyQSXEOLFD Núm. 5.503 / 02.05.2007 17995 $SDUWDWF$SDUWDGRF 'HVFULSFLy GHOV %pQV G¶,QWHUpV &XOWXUDO TXH GHFODUDWV DPE DQWHULRULWDW D OD /OHL G¶GHMXQ\GH/D*HQHUDOLWDWGHO3DWULPRQL&XOWXUDO9DOHQFLjLSUHFLVDWVGHUHDGVFULSFLy D GLIHUHQW &DWHJRULD HQ OD 6HFFLy 3ULPHUD GH O¶,QYHQWDUL *HQHUDO GHO 3DWULPRQL YHXUDQ YDULDWHOVHXUqJLPWXWHODU 'HVFULSFLyQ GH ORV %LHQHV GH ,QWHUpV &XOWXUDO TXH GHFODUDGRV FRQ DQWHULRULGDG D OD /H\ GHGHMXQLRGH/D*HQHUDOLWDWGHO3DWULPRQLR&XOWXUDO9DOHQFLDQR\SUHFLVDGRVGH UHDGVFULSFLyQ D GLIHUHQWH &DWHJRUtD HQ OD 6HFFLyQ 3ULPHUD GHO ,QYHQWDULR *HQHUDO GHO 3DWULPRQLR&XOWXUDO9DOHQFLDQRYHUiQYDULDGRVXUpJLPHQWXWHODU $11(;,9$1(;2,9 GH 5HVROXFLyGHG DEULOGHOD'LUHFFLy*HQHUDOGH3DWULPRQL&XOWXUDO9DOHQFLjL0XVHXVGHOD&RQVHOOHULDGH&XOWXUD(GXFDFLyL(VSRUWSHUODTXHV LQFRDH[SHGLHQWSHUDOD SULPHUD IDVH GH O DFWXDOLW]DFLy L DGDSWDFLy SDUFLDO GH OD 6HFFLy 3ULPHUD GH O ,QYHQWDUL *HQHUDO GHO 3DWULPRQL &XOWXUDO 9DOHQFLj HQ PDWqULD GH SDWULPRQL DUTXLWHFWzQLF L PHGLDPELHQWDOLV¶REULSHUtRGHG¶LQIRUPDFLyS~EOLFD 5HVROXFLyQ GH GH DEULO GH OD 'LUHFFLyQ *HQHUDO GH 3DWULPRQLR &XOWXUDO 9DOHQFLDQR \ 0XVHRV GH OD &RQVHOOHULD GH &XOWXUD (GXFDFLyQ \ 'HSRUWH SRU OD TXH VH LQFRD H[SHGLHQWH SDUD OD SULPHUD IDVH GH OD DFWXDOL]DFLyQ \ DGDSWDFLyQ SDUFLDO GH OD 6HFFLyQ 3ULPHUD GHO ,QYHQWDULR *HQHUDO GHO 3DWULPRQLR &XOWXUDO 9DOHQFLDQR HQ PDWHULD GH SDWULPRQLRDUTXLWHFWyQLFR\PHGLRDPELHQWDO\VHDEUHSHULRGRGHLQIRUPDFLyQSXEOLFD Núm. 5.503 / 02.05.2007 17996 %e'¶,17(5e6&8/785$/±&21-817)257,),&$7'(0$6&$5(//18/(6 &21-817+,67Ñ5,& %,(1'(,17(5e6&8/785$/&21-8172)257,),&$'2'(0$6&$5(//18/(6&21-8172+,67Ï5,&2 'HQRPLQDFLy'HQRPLQDFLyQ 3ULQFLSDO3ULQFLSDO &RQMXQW)RUWLILFDWGH0DVFDUHOO &RQMXQWR)RUWLILFDGRGH0DVFDUHOO $FFHVzULD$FFHVRULD 3REODWL0XUDGHVGH0DVFDUHOO 3REODGR\0XUDOODVGH0DVFDUHOO /RFDOL]DFLy/RFDOL]DFLyQ 3URYtQFLD3URYLQFLD&DVWHOOy &RPDUFD&RPDUFD/D3ODQD%DL[D 0XQLFLSL0XQLFLSLR1XOHV 8ELFDFLy8ELFDFLyQ-XQWR& $QWHFHGHQWV-XUtGLFV$QWHFHGHQWHV-XUtGLFRV 'HFODUDFLy'HFODUDFLyQ 3XEOLFDFLy GH OD GHFODUDFLy 3XEOLFDFLyQ GH OD GHFODUDFLyQ%2( &DWHJRULD&DWHJRUtD0RQXPHQW0RQXPHQWR 1RYD$GVFULSFLy1XHYD$GVFULSFLyQ&RQMXQW+LVWzULF&RQMXQWR+LVWyULFR 'HVFULSFLy'HVFULSFLyQ 3DUWV,QWHJUDQWV3DUWHV,QWHJUDQWHV − (OQXFOLXUEjSURSLDPHQWGLW(OQ~FOHRXUEDQRSURSLDPHQWHGLFKR − /HVPXUDOOHVLODVHXDYLFXODFLyWHUULWRULDO/DVPXUDOODV\VXYLQFXODFLyQWHUULWRULDO 'HVFULSFLy*HQHUDO'HVFULSFLyQ*HQHUDO $OQRUGHVWGH1XOHVHVWUREDHVWDYLODGH[LFRWHWHVGLPHQVLRQVTXHYDGHL[DUGHVHUPXQLFLSLDPHLWDWGHO VHJOH;,;SHUDDQQH[DUVHD1XOHV6HPEODTXHO RULJHQGDWDGHOVHJOH;,,,TXDQHVYDQUHDOLW]DUSREODFLRQV GHQRYDSODQWDGHVSUpVGHODUHFRQTXHVWD9DHVWDUSREODWSHUPRULVFRVILQVDOVHJOH;9,,TXDQYDQ VHUH[SXOVDWV' HVWDPDQHUDSUjFWLFDPHQWTXHGDGHVSREODGDDL[tHQQRPpVKLKDYLHQWHUUDWLQHQWV /HVPXUDOOHVYDQVHUUHDOLW]DGHVHQHOVHJOH;,,,DPEIjEULFD GHWjSLDHQFDUDTXHGHVSUpVYDQVHUUHIHWHV HQHOVVHJOHVVHJHQWV(VWUDFWDG XQUHFLQWHPXUDOODWGHSODQWDUHFWDQJXODUDPEXQDDOWXUDSUz[LPDDOV PHWUHV (V FRQILJXUD SHU PLWMj GH FDUUHUV UHFWHV TXH V HQFUHXHQ SHUSHQGLFXODUPHQW FDUDFWHUtVWLF GH SREODFLRQVGHUHFRQTXHVWD(QHOFHQWUHHVWjODSODoDRQHVWUREHQO HVJOpVLDUHDOLW]DGDHQHOVHJOH;9,,L O DMXQWDPHQW UHDOLW]DW HQ HO VHJOH ;9,,, VHJRQV XQD LQVFULSFLy HQ OD SRUWDGD /HV FDVHV RFXSHQ SDUFHOāOHVUHFWDQJXODUVTXHHVGLYLGL[HQHQOD]RQDKDELWDGDLHOSDWL(VFRQILJXUHQVHJRQVOHVWLSRORJLHVGH FDVHVGHOODXUDGRUVGHOD]RQDGHJUDQVHQ]LOOHVDLQRVREUHSDVVDQWO DOWXUDGHODPXUDOODQLOHVWRUUHV(Q FDGDXQGHOVFRVWDWVGHODPXUDOODHQHOFHQWUHVHVLWXDXQD WRUUHGHSODQWDUHFWDQJXODU/HVGHOVFRVWDWV HVWHO3RUWDOGHO +RUWDLO¶RHVWHO3RUWDOGH9DOqQFLDVyQG XQDPHQRUDOWXUDLHQHOOHVHVWUREHQOHVSRUWHV R SDVVRV G DFFpV $PEGyV VyQ G DUF GH PLJ SXQW DGRYHOODWV $ ILQDOV GHO VHJOH ;,; OHV PXUDOOHV YDQ VHU UHVWDXUDGHV$ILQDOVGHOVHJOH;;HVYDQUHDOLW]DUGLIHUHQWVLQWHUYHQFLRQVSHUDODUHKDELOLWDFLyLFRQVHUYDFLy GHOUHFLQWH%DVDWDO&DWjOHJGH0RQXPHQWVL&RQMXQWVGHOD&RPXQLWDW9DOHQFLDQD $OQRUGHVWHGH1XOHVVHHQFXHQWUDHVWDYLOODGHSHTXHxDVGLPHQVLRQHVTXHGHMyGHVHUPXQLFLSLRDPHGLGRV GHO VLJOR ;,; SDUD DQH[LRQDUVH D 1XOHV 3DUHFH VHU TXH HO RULJHQ GDWD GHO VLJOR ;,,, FXDQGR VH UHDOL]DURQ SREODFLRQHV GH QXHYD SODQWD WUDV OD UHFRQTXLVWD (VWXYR SREODGR SRU PRULVFRV KDVWD HO VLJOR ;9,, FXDQGR IXHURQ H[SXOVDGRV 'H HVWH PRGR SUiFWLFDPHQWH TXHGR GHVSREODGD DVt HQ VyOR KDEtD WHUUDWHQLHQWHV /DV PXUDOODV IXHURQ UHDOL]DGDV HQ HO VLJOR ;,,, FRQ IiEULFD GH WDSLDO DXQTXH OXHJR IXHURQ UHKHFKDV HQ ORV VLJORV VLJXLHQWHV 6H WUDWD GH XQ UHFLQWR DPXUDOODGR GH SODQWD UHFWDQJXODU FRQ XQD DOWXUD SUy[LPD D ORV PHWURV 6H FRQILJXUD PHGLDQWH FDOOHV UHFWDV TXH VH FUX]DQ SHUSHQGLFXODUPHQWH FDUDFWHUtVWLFR GH SREODFLRQHV GH UHFRQTXLVWD (Q HO FHQWUR HVWi OD SOD]D GRQGH VH HQFXHQWUDQ OD ,JOHVLD UHDOL]DGDHQHOVLJOR;9,,\HO$\XQWDPLHQWRUHDOL]DGRHQHOVLJOR;9,,,VHJ~QXQDLQVFULSFLyQHQOD SRUWDGD /DV FDVDV RFXSDQ SDUFHODV UHFWDQJXODUHV TXH VH GLYLGHQ HQ OD ]RQD KDELWDGD \ HO SDWLR 6H FRQILJXUDQVHJ~QODVWLSRORJtDVGHFDVDVGHODEUDGRUHVGHOD]RQDGHJUDQVHQFLOOH]\QRVREUHSDVDQGROD DOWXUDGHODPXUDOODQLODVWRUUHV(QFDGDXQRGHORVODGRVGHODPXUDOODHQHOFHQWURVHVLW~DXQDWRUUHGH $11(;,9$1(;2,9 GH 5HVROXFLy GH G DEULO GH OD 'LUHFFLy *HQHUDO GH 3DWULPRQL &XOWXUDO 9DOHQFLj L 0XVHXV GH OD &RQVHOOHULD GH &XOWXUD (GXFDFLy L (VSRUW SHU OD TXH V LQFRDH[SHGLHQWSHUDODSULPHUDIDVHGHO DFWXDOLW]DFLyLDGDSWDFLySDUFLDOGHOD6HFFLy3ULPHUDGHO ,QYHQWDUL*HQHUDOGHO3DWULPRQL&XOWXUDO9DOHQFLjHQ PDWqULDGHSDWULPRQLDUTXLWHFWzQLFLPHGLDPELHQWDOLV¶REULSHUtRGHG¶LQIRUPDFLyS~EOLFD 5HVROXFLyQ GH GH DEULO GH OD 'LUHFFLyQ *HQHUDO GH 3DWULPRQLR &XOWXUDO 9DOHQFLDQR \ 0XVHRV GH OD &RQVHOOHULD GH &XOWXUD (GXFDFLyQ \ 'HSRUWH SRU OD TXH VH LQFRD H[SHGLHQWH SDUD OD SULPHUD IDVH GH OD DFWXDOL]DFLyQ \ DGDSWDFLyQ SDUFLDO GH OD 6HFFLyQ 3ULPHUD GHO ,QYHQWDULR *HQHUDO GHO 3DWULPRQLR &XOWXUDO 9DOHQFLDQR HQ PDWHULD GH SDWULPRQLRDUTXLWHFWyQLFR\PHGLRDPELHQWDO\VHDEUHSHULRGRGHLQIRUPDFLyQSXEOLFD Núm. 5.503 / 02.05.2007 17997 SODQWDUHFWDQJXODU/DVGHORVODGRVHVWHHO3RUWDOGH/ +RUWD\DORHVWHHO3RUWDOGH9DOHQFLDVRQGHXQD PHQRUDOWXUD\HQHOODVVHHQFXHQWUDQODVSXHVWDVRSDVRVGHDFFHVR$PERVVRQGHDUFRGHPHGLRSXQWR DGRYHODGRV $ ILQDOHV GHO VLJOR ;,; ODV PXUDOODV IXHURQ UHVWDXUDGDV $ ILQDOHV GHO VLJOR ;; VH UHDOL]DURQ GLIHUHQWHV LQWHUYHQFLRQHV SDUD OD UHKDELOLWDFLyQ \ FRQVHUYDFLyQ GHO UHFLQWR %DVDGR HQ HO &DWiORJR GH 0RQXPHQWRV\&RQMXQWRVGHOD&RPXQLGDG9DOHQFLDQD 2EVHUYDFLRQV2EVHUYDFLRQHV ¬PELWÈPELWR $QWHFHGHQWV DGPLQLVWUDWLXV OD GHOLPLWDFLy GH O jPELW GH SURWHFFLy V DFXOO DO TXH GLVSRVD O $SWDW GH OD 'LVSRVLFLy 7UDQVLWzULD 3ULPHUD GH OD OOHL PRGLILFDGRUD GH OD (VWD GHOLPLWDFLy TXHGD UHFRQHJXGDVHJRQVODGHOLPLWDFLyFRQWLQJXGDHQ HOGHFUHWGHG DEULOGHSXEOLFDGD HQHO '2*9GHGDWD 2ULJHQ LQWHUVHFFLy GH OD FDUUHWHUD & DPE O DQWLF WUDoDW GHO IHUURFDUULO GH YLD HVWUHWD FDS D %XUULDQD SXQW$ 6HQWLWKRUDUL /tQLD GHOLPLWDGRUD GHV GH O RULJHQ L HQ VHQWLW KRUDUL OD OtQLD GLVFRUUH DO OODUJ GHO PDUJH HVTXHUUH GH OD FDUUHWHUDFRPDUFDO&WUDYHVVDQWHOSDVHOHYDWTXHVDOYDHOIHUURFDUULOILQVDXQFDPtSDUWLFXODUDQWHULRUDO FDPt³/D5DWOOD´UHFRUUHQWKRSHOVHXPDUJHHVTXHUUHILQVDWUREDUVHDPEODVHQGD0LWMDQD(QHVWHSXQWOD OtQLDGLVFRUUHSHOPDUJHHVTXHUUHILQVDOFDPtO $OF~GLDIHQWXQ[LFRWHWHVTXLYDPHQWILQVDWUREDUO DQWLFWUDoDW GHOIHUURFDUULOGHYLDHVWUHWDUHFRUUHQWKRVHPSUHSHOPDUJHHVTXHUUHILQVDOSXQWG RULJHQ $QWHFHGHQWHVDGPLQLVWUDWLYRVODGHOLPLWDFLyQGHOiPELWRGHSURWHFFLyQVHDFRJHDORGLVSXHVWRHQHO$SWGR GHOD'LVSRVLFLyQ7UDQVLWRULD3ULPHUDGHODOH\PRGLILFDGRUDGHOD(VWDGHOLPLWDFLyQTXHGD UHFRQRFLGD VHJ~Q OD GHOLPLWDFLyQ FRQWHQLGD HQ HO GHFUHWR GH G DEULO GH SXEOLFDGD HQ HO '2*9GHIHFKD 2ULJHQ HQFXHQWUR GHO WUD]DGR GH OD FDUUHWHUD FRPDUFDO FRQ HO DQWLJXR WUD]DGR GHO IHUURFDUULO GH YtD HVWUHFKDKDFLD%XUULDQDSXQWR$ 6HQWLGRKRUDULR /tQHDGHOLPLWDGRUDGHVGHHORULJHQ\HQVHQWLGRKRUDULRODOtQHDGLVFXUUHDORODUJRGHOPDUJHQL]TXLHUGRGH ODFDUUHWHUDFRPDUFDO&DWUDYHVDQGRHOSDVRHOHYDGRTXHVDOYDHOIHUURFDUULOKDVWDXQFDPLQRSDUWLFXODU DQWHULRUDOFDPLQR³/D5DOOD´UHFRUULpQGRORSRUVXPDUJHQL]TXLHUGRKDVWDHQFRQWUDUVHFRQODVHQGD0LWMDQD (Q HVWH SXQWR OD OtQHD GLVFXUUH SRU HO PDUJHQ L]TXLHUGR KDVWD HO FDPLQR $OFXGLD KDFLHQGR XQ SHTXHxR TXLHEUR KDVWD HQFRQWUDU HO DQWLJXR WUD]DGR GHO IHUURFDUULO GH YtD HVWUHFKD UHFRUULpQGROR VLHPSUH SRU HO PDUJHQL]TXLHUGRKDVWDHOSXQWRGHRULJHQ $11(;,9$1(;2,9 GH 5HVROXFLy GH G DEULO GH OD 'LUHFFLy *HQHUDO GH 3DWULPRQL &XOWXUDO 9DOHQFLj L 0XVHXV GH OD &RQVHOOHULD GH &XOWXUD (GXFDFLy L (VSRUW SHU OD TXH V LQFRDH[SHGLHQWSHUDODSULPHUDIDVHGHO DFWXDOLW]DFLyLDGDSWDFLySDUFLDOGHOD6HFFLy3ULPHUDGHO ,QYHQWDUL*HQHUDOGHO3DWULPRQL&XOWXUDO9DOHQFLjHQ PDWqULDGHSDWULPRQLDUTXLWHFWzQLFLPHGLDPELHQWDOLV¶REULSHUtRGHG¶LQIRUPDFLyS~EOLFD 5HVROXFLyQ GH GH DEULO GH OD 'LUHFFLyQ *HQHUDO GH 3DWULPRQLR &XOWXUDO 9DOHQFLDQR \ 0XVHRV GH OD &RQVHOOHULD GH &XOWXUD (GXFDFLyQ \ 'HSRUWH SRU OD TXH VH LQFRD H[SHGLHQWH SDUD OD SULPHUD IDVH GH OD DFWXDOL]DFLyQ \ DGDSWDFLyQ SDUFLDO GH OD 6HFFLyQ 3ULPHUD GHO ,QYHQWDULR *HQHUDO GHO 3DWULPRQLR &XOWXUDO 9DOHQFLDQR HQ PDWHULD GH SDWULPRQLRDUTXLWHFWyQLFR\PHGLRDPELHQWDO\VHDEUHSHULRGRGHLQIRUPDFLyQSXEOLFD Núm. 5.503 / 02.05.2007 17998 %e'¶,17(5e6&8/785$/±&21-817)257,),&$7'(0$6&$5(//18/(6 &21-817+,67Ñ5,& %,(1'(,17(5e6&8/785$/&21-8172)257,),&$'2'(0$6&$5(//18/(6&21-8172+,67Ï5,&2 $11(;,9$1(;2,9 GH 5HVROXFLy GH G DEULO GH OD 'LUHFFLy *HQHUDO GH 3DWULPRQL &XOWXUDO 9DOHQFLj L 0XVHXV GH OD &RQVHOOHULD GH &XOWXUD (GXFDFLy L (VSRUW SHU OD TXH V LQFRDH[SHGLHQWSHUDODSULPHUDIDVHGHO DFWXDOLW]DFLyLDGDSWDFLySDUFLDOGHOD6HFFLy3ULPHUDGHO ,QYHQWDUL*HQHUDOGHO3DWULPRQL&XOWXUDO9DOHQFLjHQ PDWqULDGHSDWULPRQLDUTXLWHFWzQLFLPHGLDPELHQWDOLV¶REULSHUtRGHG¶LQIRUPDFLyS~EOLFD 5HVROXFLyQ GH GH DEULO GH OD 'LUHFFLyQ *HQHUDO GH 3DWULPRQLR &XOWXUDO 9DOHQFLDQR \ 0XVHRV GH OD &RQVHOOHULD GH &XOWXUD (GXFDFLyQ \ 'HSRUWH SRU OD TXH VH LQFRD H[SHGLHQWH SDUD OD SULPHUD IDVH GH OD DFWXDOL]DFLyQ \ DGDSWDFLyQ SDUFLDO GH OD 6HFFLyQ 3ULPHUD GHO ,QYHQWDULR *HQHUDO GHO 3DWULPRQLR &XOWXUDO 9DOHQFLDQR HQ PDWHULD GH SDWULPRQLRDUTXLWHFWyQLFR\PHGLRDPELHQWDO\VHDEUHSHULRGRGHLQIRUPDFLyQSXEOLFD Núm. 5.503 / 02.05.2007 17999 %e'¶,17(5e6&8/785$/±5(&,17('(/¶+263,7$/9(//,(50,7$'(6$17$//Ò&,$9$/Ê1&,$ 02180(17 %,(1'(,17(5e6&8/785$/±5(&,172'(/+263,7$/9,(-$<(50,7$'(6$17$/8&Ë$9$/(1&,$ 02180(172 'HQRPLQDFLy'HQRPLQDFLyQ 3ULQFLSDO3ULQFLSDO 5HFLQWHGHO¶+RVSLWDO9HOOL(UPLWDGH6DQWD/O~FLD 5HFLQWRGHO+RVSLWDO9LHMR\(UPLWDGH6DQWD/XFtD /RFDOL]DFLy/RFDOL]DFLyQ 3URYtQFLD3URYLQFLD9DOqQFLD &RPDUFD&RPDUFDO¶+RUWD 0XQLFLSL0XQLFLSLR9DOqQFLD 8ELFDFLy8ELFDFLyQHQWUHHOVFDUUHUVGHO¶+RVSLWDO L*XLOOHPGH&DVWUR 5HIHUHQFLD&DGDVWUDO5HIHUHQFLD&DWDVWUDO ,OOD0DQ]DQD3DUFHOāOD3DUFHOD \ $QWHFHGHQWV-XUtGLFV$QWHFHGHQWHV-XUtGLFRV 'HFODUDFLy'HFODUDFLyQ 3XEOLFDFLyGHODGHFODUDFLy3XEOLFDFLyQGHODGHFODUDFLyQ%2( &DWHJRULD&DWHJRUtD&RQMXQW+LVWzULF&RQMXQWR+LVWyULFR 1RYD$GVFULSFLy1XHYD$GVFULSFLyQ0RQXPHQW0RQXPHQWR 'HVFULSFLy'HVFULSFLyQ 3DUWV,QWHJUDQWV3DUWHV,QWHJUDQWHV − $QWLJDLQIHUPHULD$QWLJXDHQIHUPHUtD − 5HVWHVGHO¶2EUD1RYD5HVWRVGHODµ2EUD1RYD¶ − (OFDSLWXOHW(OFDSLWXOHW − 5HVWHV DUTXHROzJLFRDUTXLWHFWzQLFV LQFORHQWKL O¶HVJOpVLD HO WUDP GH PXUDGD FULVWLDQD L OHV VRFRODGHV L SRUWDGHVUHOOHXVLHVFXOWXUHVGHOHVHGLILFDFLRQVYXLWFHQWLVWHVGHO¶DQWLF+RVSLWDO*HQHUDOL GHO¶DQWLJDD )DFXOWDWGH0HGHFLQD5HVWRVDUTXHROyJLFRDUTXLWHFWyQLFRVLQFOX\HQGRODLJOHVLD HOWUDPRGHPXUDOOD − − FULVWLDQD L ORV ]yFDORV SRUWDGDV UHOLHYHV \ HVFXOWXUDV GH ODV HGLILFDFLRQHV GHFLPRQyQLFDV GHO DQWLJXR +RVSLWDO*HQHUDO\GHO¶DQWLJXDIDFXOWDGGH0HGLFLQD /D SRUWDGD JzWLFD GH OD SULPLWLYD FRQVWUXFFLy GH O¶KRVSLWDO /D SRUWDGD JyWLFD GH OD SULPLWLYD FRQVWUXFFLyQGHOKRVSLWDO (UPLWDGH6DQWD/O~FLD(UPLWDGH6DQWD/XFtD 'HVFULSFLy*HQHUDO'HVFULSFLyQ*HQHUDO eVDSULQFLSLVGHOVHJOH;9FDSDTXDQHVSODQWHMDODFRQVWUXFFLyG XQKRVSLWDOTXHDFROOLUDHOVERMRVL HOVGHPHQWV(QHVYDLQLFLDUODFRQVWUXFFLyGHODLQIHUPHULDDPESODQWDGHFUHXJUHJD3RVWHULRUPHQW DPLWMDQVHJOH;9,,HVYD DOoDUXQDDOWUDLQIHUPHULD HQIRUPD GH 7/DLQIHUPHULDYHOODUHDOLW]DGDHQ HO VHJOH;9,pVG HVWLOUHQDL[HQWLVWDDPESODQWDGHFUHX(OVEUDoRVHVWDQGLYLGLWVHQGXHVSODQWHVFDGDXQDGH OHVTXDOVHVWjGLYLGLGDHQWUHVQDXVSHUFROXPQHVDPEEDVHVLFDSLWHOOVGHFRUDWVLXQPDUFDWqQWDVL6REUH OHVFROXPQHVHVGHVHQYROXSHQYROWHV(QODLQWHUVHFFLyGHOVEUDoRVHVGHVHQYROXSDXQHVSDLRFWRJRQDOVREUH HOTXDOV HOHYDXQDF~SXODVREUHXQDOWWDPERUHVSDLHQTXqVHVLWXDYDXQDOWDU(QODVHJRQDPHLWDWGHOV DQ\VV¶KLYDKDELOLWDUFRPD%LEOLRWHFD3~EOLFD (QIURQWGHO HQWUDGDHVWUREDODSRUWDGDJzWLFDUHVWDGHOSULPLWLXKRVSLWDO(VWUDFWDG XQDSRUWDGDDOOLQGDGD DPEDUFDSXQWDWDPEDUTXLYROWHVLXQDUFFRQRSLDOIRUPDWSHUXQGREOHDUUDEjLWLPSjEXLWDPEXQDLPDWJH GHODPDUHGHGpXGHPRGHUQDUHDOLW]DFLy (OFDSLWXOHWYDVHUFRQVWUXwWHQHOVHJOH;9,,,HQSHUOD&RQIUDULDGHOD0DUHGH'pXGHOV,QQRFHQWV 0jUWLUVL'HVHPSDUDWVeVXQ[LFRWHWHGLILFLTXHVHUYLDWDQWG¶RUDWRULFRPGHVDODGHUHXQLRQVGHO&DStWROGH OD FRQIUDULD 7p SODQWD UHFWDQJXODU L XQD IDoDQD DPE UHPDWDGD PL[WLOtQLD L XQD HVSDGDQ\D GH GLPHQVLy UHGXwGDHQHOFHQWUH / HUPLWD GH 6DQWD /O~FLD VH VLWXD HQ O H[WUHP PpV SUz[LP DO FDUUHU GH *XLOOHP GH &DVWUR eV OD VHX GH OD &RQIUDULDGH6DQWD/O~FLDTXHYDVHUFUHDGDDILQDOVGHOVHJOH;,9/DVHXDFRQVWUXFFLypVLQFHUWDHQFDUDTXH HVFRQVHUYHQUHVWHVPHGLHYDOVHQODFDSHOODPDMRUFRPVyQHOVQHUYLVG XQDYROWD/ HGLILFLTXHHVFRQVHUYD $11(;,9$1(;2,9 GH 5HVROXFLy GH G DEULO GH OD 'LUHFFLy *HQHUDO GH 3DWULPRQL &XOWXUDO 9DOHQFLj L 0XVHXV GH OD &RQVHOOHULD GH &XOWXUD (GXFDFLy L (VSRUW SHU OD TXH V LQFRDH[SHGLHQWSHUDODSULPHUDIDVHGHO DFWXDOLW]DFLyLDGDSWDFLySDUFLDOGHOD6HFFLy3ULPHUDGHO ,QYHQWDUL*HQHUDOGHO3DWULPRQL&XOWXUDO9DOHQFLjHQ PDWqULDGHSDWULPRQLDUTXLWHFWzQLFLPHGLDPELHQWDOLV¶REULSHUtRGHG¶LQIRUPDFLyS~EOLFD 5HVROXFLyQ GH GH DEULO GH OD 'LUHFFLyQ *HQHUDO GH 3DWULPRQLR &XOWXUDO 9DOHQFLDQR \ 0XVHRV GH OD &RQVHOOHULD GH &XOWXUD (GXFDFLyQ \ 'HSRUWH SRU OD TXH VH LQFRD H[SHGLHQWH SDUD OD SULPHUD IDVH GH OD DFWXDOL]DFLyQ \ DGDSWDFLyQ SDUFLDO GH OD 6HFFLyQ 3ULPHUD GHO ,QYHQWDULR *HQHUDO GHO 3DWULPRQLR &XOWXUDO 9DOHQFLDQR HQ PDWHULD GH SDWULPRQLRDUTXLWHFWyQLFR\PHGLRDPELHQWDO\VHDEUHSHULRGRGHLQIRUPDFLyQSXEOLFD Núm. 5.503 / 02.05.2007 18000 pVG HVWLOEDUURF' XQDVRODQDXUHFWDQJXODUDPEFDSHOOHVODWHUDOVFLQFDFDGDFRVWDW/DQDXHVWjFREHUWD DPEYROWDUHEDL[DGDDPEOOXQHWHVHQTXqV REULQILQHVWUHV(QODSODQWDVXSHULRUGHO HUPLWDKLKDODVDODGH MXQWHVTXHHQO DFWXDOLWDWpVPXVHX/DIDoDQDpVPROWVHQ]LOODDPEXQDIRUQtFXODDPEHOEXVWGHODVDQWD WLWXODULXQDHVSDGDQ\DHQODSDUWVXSHULRU (QHOVMDUGLQVKDELOLWDWVFRPHQWRUQGHOD%LEOLRWHFD3~EOLFD HVFRQVHUYHQGHVFRQWH[WXDOL]DGHVQRPEURVHV SHFHVDUTXLWHFWzQLTXHVGHSHGUDSLFDGDEDVHVFROXPQHVLFDSLWHOOVHQSDUWLFXODUTXHSHUWDQ\HQWVDO¶2EUD 1RYD IRUPHQ IDOVRV SDWLV R FRPSRQHQ GH PDQHUD GLVSHUVD GHWDOOV SVHXGRDUTXHROzJLFV HQ FDPLQV L SDUWHUUHV7DPEpVXEVLVWHL[HQHOWUDoDWLG¶DOWUHVUHVWHVHQHOVXEVzODSDUWGHOHVUHFHQWPHQWH[KXPDGHV (QHOVHJOH;,;VH OYDDMXQWDUDO KRVSLWDOOD)DFXOWDWGH0HGLFLQDVHJRQVSURMHFWHGH6HEDVWLiQ0RQOHyQGH L UHDOLW]DGD SHU $QWRQLR 0DUWRUHOO HQ %DVDW HQ HO &DWjOHJ GH 0RQXPHQWV L &RQMXQWV GH OD &RPXQLWDW9DOHQFLDQD (VDSULQFLSLRVGHOVLJOR;9KDFLDFXDQGRVHSODQWHDODFRQVWUXFFLyQGHXQKRVSLWDOTXHDFRJLHVHDORV ORFRV \ D ORV GHPHQWHV (Q VH LQLFLy OD FRQVWUXFFLyQ GH OD HQIHUPHUtD FRQ SODQWD GH FUX] JULHJD 3RVWHULRUPHQWH D PHGLDGRV GHO VLJOR ;9,, VH OHYDQWy RWUD HQIHUPHUtD HQ IRUPD GH 7 /D HQIHUPHUtD UHDOL]DGDHQHOVLJOR;9,GHHVWLORUHQDFHQWLVWDFRQSODQWDGHFUX]/RVEUD]RVHVWiQGLYLGLGRVHQGRVSODQWDV FDGD XQD GH HOODV GLYLGLGD HQ WUHV QDYHV SRU FROXPQDV FRQ EDVDV \ FDSLWHOHV GHFRUDGRV \ XQ PDUFDGR pQWDVLV6REUHODVFROXPQDVVHGHVDUUROODQEyYHGDV(QODLQWHUVHFFLyQGHORVEUD]RVVHGHVDUUROODXQHVSDFLR RFWRJRQDOVREUHHOTXHVHHOHYDXQDF~SXODVREUHXQDOWRWDPERUHQTXHVHVLWXDEDXQDOWDU )UHQWH D OD HQWUDGD VH HQFXHQWUD OD SRUWDGD JyWLFD UHVWR GHO SULPLWLYR KRVSLWDO 6H WUDWD GH XQD SRUWDGD DGLQWHODGDFRQDUFRDSXQWDGRFRQDUTXLYROWDV\XQDUFRFRQRSLDOIRUPDGRSRUXQGREOHDOIL]\WtPSDQRYDFtR FRQXQDLPDJHQGHODYLUJHQGHPRGHUQDUHDOL]DFLyQ (QODVHJRQDPLWDGGHORVDxRVVHUDKDELOLWyFRPR %LEOLRWHFD3~EOLFD (OFDSLWXOHWIXHFRQVWUXLGR HQHO VLJOR;9,,, HQ SRU OD &RIUDGtD GH 1XHVWUD 6HxRUD GH ORV ,QRFHQWHV 0iUWLUHV \ 'HVDPSDUDGRV (V XQ SHTXHxR HGLILFLR TXH VHUYtD WDQWR FRPR RUDWRULR FRPR VDOD GH UHXQLRQHV GHO &DSLWXOR GH OD FRIUDGtD 7LHQH SODQWD UHFWDQJXODU \ FRQ XQD IDFKDGD FRQ UHPDWH PL[WLOtQHR \ XQD HVSDGDxDGHSHTXHxRWDPDxRHQHOFHQWUR /D(UPLWDGH6DQWD/XFtDVHVLW~DHQHOH[WUHPRPiVFHUFDQRDODFDOOH*XLOOHPGH&DVWUR(VODVHGHGHOD &RIUDGtD GH 6DQWD /XFtD TXH IXH FUHDGD D ILQDOHV GHO VLJOR ;,9 6X FRQVWUXFFLyQ HV LQFLHUWD DXQTXH VH FRQVHUYDQ UHVWRV PHGLHYDOHV HQ OD FDSLOOD PD\RU FRPR VRQ ORV QHUYLRV GH XQD EyYHGD (O HGLILFLR TXH VH FRQVHUYD HV GH HVWLOR EDUURFR 'H XQD VROD QDYH UHFWDQJXODU FRQ FDSLOODV ODWHUDOHV FLQFR D FDGD ODGR /D QDYHHVWiFXELHUWDFRQEyYHGDUHEDMDGDFRQOXQHWRVHQORVTXHVHDEUHQYHQWDQDV(QODSODQWDVXSHULRUGH ODHUPLWDVHHQFXHQWUDODVDODGHMXQWDVTXHHQODDFWXDOLGDGHVPXVHR/DIDFKDGDHVPX\VHQFLOODFRQXQD KRUQDFLQDFRQHOEXVWRGHODVDQWDWLWXODU\XQDHVSDGDxDHQODSDUWHVXSHULRU (Q ORV MDUGLQHV KDELOLWDGRV FRPR HQYROYHQWH GH OD %LEOLRWHFD 3~EOLFD VH FRQVHUYDQ GHVFRQWH[WXDOL]DGDV QXPHURVDV SLH]DV DUTXLWHFWyQLFDV GH FDQWHUtD EDVDV FROXPQDV \ FDSLWHOHV HQ SDUWLFXODU TXH SHUWHQHFLHQWHVDODHQIHUPHUtDQXHYDO¶2EUD1RYDIRUPDQIDOVRVSDWLRVRFRQVWLWX\HQGHPDQHUDGLVSHUVD GHWDOOHV DUTXHRORJL]DQWHV HQ FDPLQRV \ SDUWHUUHV 7DPELpQ VXEVLVWHQ VXV WUD]DV \ RWURV UHVWRV HQ HO VXEVXHORDGHPiVGHORVUHFLHQWHPHQWHH[KXPDGRV (QHOVLJOR;,;VHLQVWDORMXQWyDOKRVSLWDOOD)DFXOWDGGH0HGLFLQDVHJ~QSUR\HFWRGH6HEDVWLiQ0RQOHyQGH \UHDOL]DGDSRU$QWRQLR0DUWRUHOOHQ%DVDGRHQHO&DWiORJRGH0RQXPHQWRV\&RQMXQWRVGHOD &RPXQLGDG9DOHQFLDQD 2EVHUYDFLRQV2EVHUYDFLRQHV /¶HQMDUGLQDPHQW L WUDFWDPHQW JHQHUDO GHO FRQMXQW PHUHL[ XQD UHYLVLy FUtWLFD TXH KDUPRQLW]H PRGHUQLWDW L IXQFLRQDOLWDWDPEULJRUDUTXHROzJLFOHJLELOLWDWDUTXLWHFWzQLFDLFRQVHTHQWSRVDGDHQYjOXDGHOFRQMXQW (O DMDUGLQDPLHQWR \ WUDWDPLHQWR JHQHUDO GHO UHFLQWR PHUHFH XQD UHYLVLyQ FUtWLFD TXH DUPRQLFH PRGHUQLGDG \ IXQFLRQDOLGDGFRQULJRUDUTXHROyJLFROHJLELOLGDGDUTXLWHFWyQLFD\FRQVHFXHQWHSXHVWDHQYDORUGHOFRQMXQWR (QWRUQ(QWRUQ $QWHFHGHQWV DGPLQLVWUDWLXV OD GHOLPLWDFLy GH O HQWRUQ GH SURWHFFLy V DFXOO DO TXH GLVSRVD O $SWDW GH OD 'LVSRVLFLy 7UDQVLWzULD 3ULPHUD GH OD OOHL PRGLILFDGRUD GH OD (VWD GHOLPLWDFLy TXHGD UHFRQHJXGD DPE FDUjFWHU SURYLVLRQDO VHJRQV OD GHOLPLWDFLy FRQWLQJXGD HQ O DQQH[ GHO &DWjOHJ GH %pQV L (VSDLV 3URWHJLWV GHO 3*28 GH 9DOqQFLD GH G DFRUG DPE DOOz TXH V KD HVWDEOLW SHO ³&RQYHQL 0DUF GH &ROāODERUDFLyHQWUHOD*HQHUDOLWDW9DOHQFLDQDLO $MXQWDPHQWGH9DOqQFLDSHUDO'HVSOHJDPHQWL([HFXFLyGHO 3ODQHMDPHQW8UEDQtVWLFGHO&RQMXQW+LVWzULFGHOD&LXWDW´VXEVFULWHOGLDGHMXQ\GHLSXEOLFDWHQHO '2*9GH 2ULJHQLQWHUVHFFLyGHO HL[GHOFDUUHUGH*XLOOHPGH&DVWURDPEHOGHOFDUUHUGH4XHYHGRSXQW$ 6HQWLWDQWLKRUDUL $11(;,9$1(;2,9 GH 5HVROXFLy GH G DEULO GH OD 'LUHFFLy *HQHUDO GH 3DWULPRQL &XOWXUDO 9DOHQFLj L 0XVHXV GH OD &RQVHOOHULD GH &XOWXUD (GXFDFLy L (VSRUW SHU OD TXH V LQFRDH[SHGLHQWSHUDODSULPHUDIDVHGHO DFWXDOLW]DFLyLDGDSWDFLySDUFLDOGHOD6HFFLy3ULPHUDGHO ,QYHQWDUL*HQHUDOGHO3DWULPRQL&XOWXUDO9DOHQFLjHQ PDWqULDGHSDWULPRQLDUTXLWHFWzQLFLPHGLDPELHQWDOLV¶REULSHUtRGHG¶LQIRUPDFLyS~EOLFD 5HVROXFLyQ GH GH DEULO GH OD 'LUHFFLyQ *HQHUDO GH 3DWULPRQLR &XOWXUDO 9DOHQFLDQR \ 0XVHRV GH OD &RQVHOOHULD GH &XOWXUD (GXFDFLyQ \ 'HSRUWH SRU OD TXH VH LQFRD H[SHGLHQWH SDUD OD SULPHUD IDVH GH OD DFWXDOL]DFLyQ \ DGDSWDFLyQ SDUFLDO GH OD 6HFFLyQ 3ULPHUD GHO ,QYHQWDULR *HQHUDO GHO 3DWULPRQLR &XOWXUDO 9DOHQFLDQR HQ PDWHULD GH SDWULPRQLRDUTXLWHFWyQLFR\PHGLRDPELHQWDO\VHDEUHSHULRGRGHLQIRUPDFLyQSXEOLFD Núm. 5.503 / 02.05.2007 18001 /tQLDGHOLPLWDGRUDGHVGHO RULJHQODOtQLDVHJXL[SHUO HL[GHOFDUUHUGH4XHYHGRILQVDFRQWLQXDUSHUO¶HL[GHO FDUUHU GH %DUy GH &jUFHU L HO GHO FDUUHU GH O +RVSLWDO GHO TXDO LQFRSRUD WRW O¶HVSDL S~EOLF VHJXLQW SHU OHV IDoDQHVGHOHVHGLILFDFLRQVSHULPHWUDOVTXHGRQHQDOUHIHULWFDUUHUGHO¶+RVSLWDOILQVLQWHUVHFWDUDPEO¶HL[GHO FDUUHUGH*XLOOHPGH&DVWURTXHVHJXHL[ILQVDOSXQWG RULJHQ $QWHFHGHQWHVDGPLQLVWUDWLYRVODGHOLPLWDFLyQGHOHQWRUQRGHSURWHFFLyQVHDFRJHDORGLVSXHVWRHQHO$SWGR GHOD'LVSRVLFLyQ7UDQVLWRULD3ULPHUDGHODOH\PRGLILFDGRUDGHOD(VWDGHOLPLWDFLyQTXHGD UHFRQRFLGDFRQFDUiFWHUSURYLVLRQDOVHJ~QODGHOLPLWDFLyQFRQWHQLGDHQHO$QH[RGHO&DWiORJRGH%LHQHV\ (VSDFLRV3URWHJLGRVGHO3*28GH9DOqQFLDGHFRQDUUHJORDORHVWDEOHFLGRSRUHO³&RQYHQLR0DUFRGH &RODERUDFLyQHQWUHOD*HQHUDOLWDW9DOHQFLDQD \HO$\XQWDPLHQWR GH 9DOHQFLD SDUD HO 'HVDUUROOR \ (MHFXFLyQ GHO 3ODQHDPLHQWR 8UEDQtVWLFR GHO &RQMXQWR +LVWyULFR GH OD &LXGDG´ VXVFULWR HO GtD GH MXQLR GH \ SXEOLFDGRHQHO'2*9GH 2ULJHQLQWHUVHFFLyQGHOHMHGHODFDOOH*XLOOHPGH&DVWURFRQHOGHODFDOOH4XHYHGRSXQWR$ 6HQWLGRDQWLKRUDULR /tQHDGHOLPLWDGRUDGHVGHHORULJHQODOtQHDVLJXHSRUHOHMHGHODFDOOH4XHYHGRKDVWDFRQWLQXDUSRUHOGHOD FDOOH%DUyQGH&DUFHU\HOGHODFDOOH'HO+RVSLWDO'HOFXODLQFRUSRUDWRGRVXHVSDFLRS~EOLFRVLJXLHQGRSRU ODVIDFKDGDVGHODVHGLILFDFLRQHVSHULPHWUDOHVTXHUHDFHQVREUHHVDFDOOHKDVWDLQWHUVHFWDUFRQHOHMHGHOD FDOOH*XLOOHPGH&DVWURTXHVLJXHKDVWDHOSXQWRGHRULJHQ $11(;,9$1(;2,9 GH 5HVROXFLy GH G DEULO GH OD 'LUHFFLy *HQHUDO GH 3DWULPRQL &XOWXUDO 9DOHQFLj L 0XVHXV GH OD &RQVHOOHULD GH &XOWXUD (GXFDFLy L (VSRUW SHU OD TXH V LQFRDH[SHGLHQWSHUDODSULPHUDIDVHGHO DFWXDOLW]DFLyLDGDSWDFLySDUFLDOGHOD6HFFLy3ULPHUDGHO ,QYHQWDUL*HQHUDOGHO3DWULPRQL&XOWXUDO9DOHQFLjHQ PDWqULDGHSDWULPRQLDUTXLWHFWzQLFLPHGLDPELHQWDOLV¶REULSHUtRGHG¶LQIRUPDFLyS~EOLFD 5HVROXFLyQ GH GH DEULO GH OD 'LUHFFLyQ *HQHUDO GH 3DWULPRQLR &XOWXUDO 9DOHQFLDQR \ 0XVHRV GH OD &RQVHOOHULD GH &XOWXUD (GXFDFLyQ \ 'HSRUWH SRU OD TXH VH LQFRD H[SHGLHQWH SDUD OD SULPHUD IDVH GH OD DFWXDOL]DFLyQ \ DGDSWDFLyQ SDUFLDO GH OD 6HFFLyQ 3ULPHUD GHO ,QYHQWDULR *HQHUDO GHO 3DWULPRQLR &XOWXUDO 9DOHQFLDQR HQ PDWHULD GH SDWULPRQLRDUTXLWHFWyQLFR\PHGLRDPELHQWDO\VHDEUHSHULRGRGHLQIRUPDFLyQSXEOLFD Núm. 5.503 / 02.05.2007 18002 %e'¶,17(5e6&8/785$/±5(&,17('(/¶+263,7$/9(//,(50,7$'(6$17$//Ò&,$9$/Ê1&,$ 02180(17 %,(1'(,17(5e6&8/785$/±5(&,172'(/+263,7$/9,(-$<(50,7$'(6$17$/8&Ë$9$/(1&,$ 02180(172 $11(;,9$1(;2,9 GH 5HVROXFLy GH G DEULO GH OD 'LUHFFLy *HQHUDO GH 3DWULPRQL &XOWXUDO 9DOHQFLj L 0XVHXV GH OD &RQVHOOHULD GH &XOWXUD (GXFDFLy L (VSRUW SHU OD TXH V LQFRDH[SHGLHQWSHUDODSULPHUDIDVHGHO DFWXDOLW]DFLyLDGDSWDFLySDUFLDOGHOD6HFFLy3ULPHUDGHO ,QYHQWDUL*HQHUDOGHO3DWULPRQL&XOWXUDO9DOHQFLjHQ PDWqULDGHSDWULPRQLDUTXLWHFWzQLFLPHGLDPELHQWDOLV¶REULSHUtRGHG¶LQIRUPDFLyS~EOLFD 5HVROXFLyQ GH GH DEULO GH OD 'LUHFFLyQ *HQHUDO GH 3DWULPRQLR &XOWXUDO 9DOHQFLDQR \ 0XVHRV GH OD &RQVHOOHULD GH &XOWXUD (GXFDFLyQ \ 'HSRUWH SRU OD TXH VH LQFRD H[SHGLHQWH SDUD OD SULPHUD IDVH GH OD DFWXDOL]DFLyQ \ DGDSWDFLyQ SDUFLDO GH OD 6HFFLyQ 3ULPHUD GHO ,QYHQWDULR *HQHUDO GHO 3DWULPRQLR &XOWXUDO 9DOHQFLDQR HQ PDWHULD GH SDWULPRQLRDUTXLWHFWyQLFR\PHGLRDPELHQWDO\VHDEUHSHULRGRGHLQIRUPDFLyQSXEOLFD