Universidad Centroamericana José Simeón Cañas Reglamento Interno de Trabajo Febrero de 2010 2 *65;,50+6 7mNPUH *(7Ð;<360! +PZWVZPJPVULZ7YLSPTPUHYLZ *(7Ð;<3600! 9LX\PZP[VZKL0UNYLZV *(7Ð;<36000! +xHZ`/VYHZKL;YHIHQV *(7Ð;<360=! /VYHZKLZ[PUHKHZHSHZ*VTPKHZ *(7Ð;<36=! :HSHYPVZ *(7Ð;<36=0! +LZJHUZV:LTHUHS *(7Ð;<36=00! (Z\L[VZ *(7Ð;<36=000! =HJHJPVULZ *(7Ð;<360?! (N\PUHSKVZ *(7Ð;<36?! +LYLJOVZ6ISPNHJPVULZ`7YVOPIPJPVULZ KLSVZ;YHIHQHKVYLZ *(7Ð;<36?0! 6ISPNHJPVULZ`7YVOPIPJPVULZ KLSH<UP]LYZPKHK *(7Ð;<36?00! 3PJLUJPHZ`(\ZLUJPHZ *(7Ð;<36?000! 3HIVYLZ0UKLIPKHZWHYH4\QLYLZ` 4LUVYLZKL,KHK 3 *(7Ð;<36?0=! ,_mTLULZ4tKPJVZ`4LKPKHZ 7YVÄSmJ[PJHZ *(7Ð;<36?=! :LN\YPKHKL/PNPLULLULS;YHIHQV *(7Ð;<36?=0! )V[PX\xU *(7Ð;<36?=00! 7L[PJPVULZ9LJSHTVZ`4VKVKL 9LZVS]LYSVZ *(7Ð;<36?=000!+PZWVZPJPVULZ+PZJPWSPUHYPHZ`4VKVKL (WSPJHYSHZ *(7Ð;<36?0?! +PZWVZPJPVULZ-PUHSLZ7\ISPJPKHK` =PNLUJPH 4 *(7Ð;<360 +0:76:0*065,:79,30405(9,: (Y[,SWYLZLU[L9LNSHTLU[V0U[LYUVKL;YHIHQV[PLULWVY VIQL[VLZ[HISLJLYSHZYLNSHZVISPNH[VYPHZKLJHYmJ[LY[tJUPJVHK TPUPZ[YH[P]VULJLZHYPHZ`[PSLZWHYHSHI\LUHTHYJOHKLSH<UP ]LYZPKHK*LU[YVHTLYPJHUHKL,S:HS]HKVY¸1VZt:PTL}U*H|HZ¹ HSHZJ\HSLZKLILZ\QL[HYZL[VKVLSWLYZVUHSLUSHLQLJ\JP}U` KLZHYYVSSVKLS[YHIHQV (Y[3H<UP]LYZPKHK*LU[YVHTLYPJHUHKL,S:HS]HKVY¸1VZt :PTL}U*H|HZ¹LZ\UHJVYWVYHJP}UKL\[PSPKHKWISPJHZPUÄULZ KLS\JYVX\L[PLULSHÄUHSPKHKKLIYPUKHYSVZZLY]PJPVZKLLK\JH JP}UZ\WLYPVYPU]LZ[PNHJP}U`WYV`LJJP}UZVJPHSWHYHKLZHYYVSSHY `TLQVYHYSHLK\JHJP}U`SHZVJPLKHKLUNLULYHSKLSH9LWISPJH KL,S:HS]HKVY (Y[7HYHSVZLMLJ[VZKLSWYLZLU[L9LNSHTLU[VSHKLUV TPUHJP}UKL<UP]LYZPKHK*LU[YVHTLYPJHUHKL,S:HS]HKVY¸1VZt :PTL}U*H|HZ¹WVKYmZ\Z[P[\PYZLPUKPZ[PU[HTLU[LWVYSHZKL¸<UP ]LYZPKHK¹V¸<*(¹:L\[PSPaHYmUSVZ[tYTPUVZKL¸LTWSLHKVZ¹V ¸[YHIHQHKVYLZ¹WHYHKLZPNUHYHSZLJ[VYSHIVYHS (Y[ ;VKVZ SVZ [YHIHQHKVYLZ ZVU YLZWVUZHISLZ HU[L SH <UP]LYZPKHKWVYLSLZ[YPJ[VJ\TWSPTPLU[VKLZ\ZKLILYLZ`VISP NHJPVULZWHYHSVJ\HSSVZQLMLZKLKLWHY[HTLU[VV\UPKHKLZ[mU LUSHVISPNHJP}UKLL_PNPYSLZKPJOVJ\TWSPTPLU[V (Y[3H<*(WHYHSVZLMLJ[VZKLSWYLZLU[L9LNSHTLU[V LZ[mLZ[Y\J[\YHKHWVYSVZZPN\PLU[LZVYNHUPZTVZ`\UPKHKLZ!1\U[H KL +PYLJ[VYLZ" 9LJ[VYxH"=PJLYLJ[VYxH(JHKtTPJH"=PJLYLJ[VYxH 5 -PUHUJPLYH"=PJLYLJ[VYxHKL7YV`LJJP}U:VJPHS":LJYL[HYxH.LUL YHS"+PYLJJP}U(KTPUPZ[YH[P]H"-HJ\S[HKLZ"+LWHY[HTLU[VZ(JHKt TPJVZ"<UPKHKLZKL7YV`LJJP}U:VJPHS"`<UPKHKLZ(KTPUPZ[YH [P]HZJ\`VZQLMLZZVUJVUZPKLYHKVZLTWSLHKVZKLJVUÄHUaH (Y[,SWLYZVUHSKLSH<UP]LYZPKHKLZ[mPU[LNYHKVLUJVU KPJP}U`UTLYVX\LM\LYLUULJLZHYPVZWHYHLSTLQVYKLZLU]VS ]PTPLU[V`KLZHYYVSSVKLSHZVWLYHJPVULZKLSHTPZTH *(7Ð;<3600 9,8<0:0;6:+,05.9,:6 (Y[ 7HYH ZLY LTWSLHKV KL SH <*( ZVU ULJLZHYPVZ SVZ YLX\PZP[VZZPN\PLU[LZ! 6 H :LYTH`VYKLH|VZKLLKHK" I 7YLZLU[HYKVJ\TLU[VUPJVKLPKLU[PKHK+<0JHYUtKL YLZPKLU[L\V[YVKVJ\TLU[VKLPKLU[PÄJHJP}U" J 9L\UPYSHZJVUKPJPVULZMxZPJHZ`KLZHS\KULJLZHYPHZWHYH LSJHYNVHKLZLTWL|HY" K 7VZLLYSHWYLWHYHJP}UHJHKtTPJHHKTPUPZ[YH[P]H[tJUPJH VSHL_WLYPLUJPHULJLZHYPHWHYHLSJHYNVHKLZLTWL|HY"` L 7YLZLU[HYHUL_VHSHYLZWLJ[P]HZVSPJP[\KSHKVJ\TLU[HJP}U ZPN\PLU[L!MV[VJVWPHKLZ\KVJ\TLU[VUPJVKLPKLU[PKHK JHYUt KL YLZPKLU[L \ V[YV KVJ\TLU[V KL PKLU[PÄJHJP}U" JVUZ[HUJPHKLZ\UP]LSLK\JH[P]V"MV[VJVWPHKLZ\[HYQL[H KL HÄSPHJP}U HS 0UZ[P[\[V :HS]HKVYL|V KLS :LN\YV :VJPHS 0:::"MV[VJVWPHKL[HYQL[HKLSUTLYVUPJVWYL]PZPVUHS 5<7"`MV[VJVWPHKLSH[HYQL[HKLSUTLYVKLPKLU[PÄJH JP}U[YPI\[HYPH50; (Y[ :P SH <UP]LYZPKHK HWY\LIH SH ZVSPJP[\K KL PUNYLZV JLSLIYHYmUHTIHZWHY[LZ\UJVU[YH[VPUKP]PK\HSKL[YHIHQVLZJYP[V KLJVUMVYTPKHKHSHSL` (Y[ ;VKVLTWSLHKVHSPUNYLZHYWVYWYPTLYH]LaHSH<UP ]LYZPKHKZLJVUZPKLYHYmLUJHSPKHKKLWY\LIHWVY\UWLYxVKVKL [YLPU[HKxHZ[YHUZJ\YYPKVKPJOVWLYxVKVZLZ\ZJYPIPYmLSYLZWLJ[P ]VJVU[YH[VKL[YHIHQV+LU[YVKLSWLYxVKVHU[LZTLUJPVUHKV J\HSX\PLYH KL SHZ WHY[LZ WVKYm KHY WVY [LYTPUHKV LS JVU[YH[V PUKP]PK\HS ZPU L_WYLZP}U KL JH\ZH ` ZPU YLZWVUZHIPSPKHK WHYH UPUN\UV KL SVZ JVU[YH[HU[LZ 7LYV OHIPLUKV JVUJS\PKV KPJOV [tYTPUVZPUX\LUPUN\UHKLSHZWHY[LZTHUPMLZ[HYLZ\]VS\U[HKKL KHYWVY[LYTPUHKVLSJVU[YH[VKLWY\LIHSHWYLZ[HJP}UKLSZLY]P JPVJVU[PU\HYmWVY[PLTWVPUKLÄUPKVVWVYLS[PLTWVJVU]LUPKV LULSJVU[YH[V :P \U [YHIHQHKVY `H OH WYLZ[HKV ZLY]PJPVZ LU SH <*( WLYV PUNYLZHKLU\L]VH[YHIHQHYLUSHIVYLZKPZ[PU[HZHSHZX\LOH`H KLZLTWL|HKVHU[LYPVYTLU[LZ\ZWYPTLYVZ[YLPU[HKxHZZLLU[LU KLYmUKLWY\LIH (Y[(SVZ[YHIHQHKVYLZJ\`HYLSHJP}ULTHULKL\UJVU [YH[VWHYHSHWYLZ[HJP}UKLZLY]PJPVZWYVMLZPVUHSLZV[tJUPJVZUV ZLSLZHWSPJHYmLZ[L9LNSHTLU[VUPLS*}KPNVKL;YHIHQV *(7Ð;<36000 +Ð(:@/69(:+,;9()(16 (Y[3HZOVYHZKL[YHIHQVZVUKP\YUHZ`UVJ[\YUHZ3HZ KP\YUHZLZ[mUJVTWYLUKPKHZLU[YLSHZZLPZOVYHZ`SHZKPLJPU\L]L OVYHZ KL \U TPZTV KxH" ` SHZ UVJ[\YUHZ LU[YL SHZ KPLJPU\L]L OVYHZKL\UKxH`SHZZLPZOVYHZKLSKxHZPN\PLU[L3HQVYUHKHVY 7 KPUHYPHKL[YHIHQVLMLJ[P]VKP\YUVZHS]VSHZL_JLWJPVULZSLNHSLZ UVL_JLKLYmKLVJOVOVYHZKPHYPHZUPSHUVJ[\YUHKLZPL[L"SHQVY UHKHKL[YHIHQVX\LJVTWYLUKHTmZKLJ\H[YVOVYHZUVJ[\YUHZ ZLYm JVUZPKLYHKH UVJ[\YUH WHYH LS LMLJ[V KL Z\ K\YHJP}U 3H ZLTHUHSHIVYHSKP\YUHUVL_JLKLYmKLJ\HYLU[H`J\H[YVOVYHZ UPSHUVJ[\YUHKL[YLPU[H`U\L]L (Y[ 3HZ QVYUHKHZ VYKPUHYPHZ KL [YHIHQV ZL LZ[HISLJLU WHYHSHZVÄJPUHZHKTPUPZ[YH[P]HZKLSHTHULYHZPN\PLU[L!KL! HTH!T`KL!WTH!WTKLS\ULZH]PLYULZ" KL!HTH!HTWHYHLSKxHZmIHKV3HZQVYUHKHZKL SHIVYLZ HJHKtTPJHZ LZ[HYmU HKLJ\HKHZ H SHZ ULJLZPKHKLZ KL H[LUJP}UKLLZ[\KPHU[LZ (Y[3H<UP]LYZPKHKZLYLZLY]HLSKLYLJOVKLLZ[PW\SHY OVYHYPVZ LZWLJPHSLZ LU LS YLZWLJ[P]V JVU[YH[V KL [YHIHQV WHYH HX\LSSVZ LTWSLHKVZ J\`HZ SHIVYLZ HZx SV YLX\PLYHU 3HZ TVKP ÄJHJPVULZ H SVZ OVYHYPVZ LZ[HISLJPKVZ ZL YLHSPaHYmU KL JVTU HJ\LYKV JVU SVZ [YHIHQHKVYLZ HMLJ[HKVZ" LU JHZV KL KPZJVYKPH PU[LU]LUKYmLS+PYLJ[VY.LULYHSKL;YHIHQVKLJVUMVYTPKHKHS (Y[KLS*}KPNVKL;YHIHQV (Y[ 5PUNU LTWSLHKV WVKYm [YHIHQHY OVYHZ L_[YHVY KPUHYPHZZPUVLZJVUSHH\[VYPaHJP}UWYL]PHKLSYLZWLJ[P]VQLML PUTLKP[H[V ,S[YHIHQVYLHSPaHKVLUOVYHZL_[YHVYKPUHYPHZZ}SVWVKYmH\ [VYPaHYZLLUMVYTHVJHZPVUHSJ\HUKVJPYJ\UZ[HUJPHZPTWYL]PZ[HZ LZWLJPHSLZ V ULJLZHYPHZ WHYH SH WYLZ[HJP}U KLS ZLY]PJPV HZx SV L_PQHU ,S[YHIHQVYLHSPaHKVLUOVYHZL_[YHVYKPUHYPHZZLYLT\ULYHYm JVU\UYLJHYNVKLSKLSZHSHYPVImZPJVWVYOVYH,U[YLSH [LYTPUHJP}UKL\UHQVYUHKH`HZLHVYKPUHYPHVJVUHKPJP}UKL [PLTWVL_[YHVYKPUHYPV`LSPUPJPVKLSHZPN\PLU[LKLILYmTLKPHY \USHWZVUVTLUVYKLVJOVOVYHZ 8 (Y[ 3HZ SHIVYLZ X\L ZL LQLJ\[LU LU OVYHZ UVJ[\YUHZ KLILYmUWHNHYZLJVU\UKLYLJHYNVZVIYLLSZHSHYPVLZ[HISL JPKVWVYPN\HS[YHIHQVLUOVYHZKP\YUHZ:PULTIHYNVHX\LSSHZ SHIVYLZX\LZLYLHSPJLULUOVYHZUVJ[\YUHZWHYHYLWVULYOVYHZ UVJ\TWSPKHZKLQVYUHKHVYKPUHYPHKP\YUHZLYmUWHNHKHZJVULS ZHSHYPVVYKPUHYPVX\LJVYYLZWVUKHZPUYLJHYNVHSN\UV (Y[;VKV[YHIHQHKVY[PLULSHVISPNHJP}UKLWYLZLU[HYZLH Z\W\LZ[VKL[YHIHQVHSHOVYHL_HJ[HLUX\LZLPUPJPLZ\QVYUHKH (ZxTPZTVSVZ[YHIHQHKVYLZUVWVKYmUZ\ZWLUKLYUPHIHUKV UHYZ\ZSHIVYLZHU[LZX\LSHQVYUHKHKL[YHIHQVOH`H[LYTPUHKV *(7Ð;<360= /69(:+,:;05(+(:(3(:*640+(: (Y[3HQVYUHKHKL[YHIHQVLZ[mKP]PKPKHLUKVZWLYxVKVZ KLQHUKV KL PU[LYTLKPV \U SHWZV KLZKL SHZ T OHZ[H SHZ !WT,Z[L[PLTWVUVMVYTHWHY[LKLSHQVYUHKHKL[YHIHQV UV LZ[HUKV LS LTWSLHKV HS ZLY]PJPV KLS WH[YVUV ` ZL KH WHYH WLYTP[PYX\LSVZ[YHIHQHKVYLZW\LKHUKLZJHUZHY`[VTHYZ\ZHSP TLU[VZLULSS\NHYX\LLZ[PTLUJVU]LUPLU[L *(7Ð;<36= :(3(906: (Y[ 3VZ ZHSHYPVZ ZLYmU JHUJLSHKVZ LU SHZ VÄJPUHZ KL SH <UP]LYZPKHK WVY SH WLYZVUH LUJHYNHKH ` H\[VYPaHKH WHYH [HS LMLJ[V;HTIPtUZLWVKYmUJHUJLSHYLUV[YHMVYTHJVU]LUPLU[L HSLTWSLHKVZPLTWYLKLJVTUHJ\LYKVJVUSH<UP]LYZPKHK 9 (Y[ ,S ZHSHYPV KLIL KL WHNHYZL LU TVULKH KL J\YZV SLNHS (Y[ 3H MLJOH KL WHNV ZLYm LS S[PTV ]PLYULZ KL JHKH TLZ LMLJ[\mUKVZL LU SHZ VÄJPUHZ KL ! HT LU HKLSHU[L KPZWVZPJP}UHWSPJHISLH[VKVLSWLYZVUHSKLSH<UP]LYZPKHK (Y[;VKVLSWLYZVUHSLZ[mVISPNHKVHÄYTHYKLYLJPIPKV ` JVUMVYTL LU SH WSHUPSSH KL WHNV \UH ]La ]LYPÄJHKV X\L SH JHU[PKHKLZ[PW\SHKHLUSHWSHUPSSHZLHPN\HSHSHYLJPIPKH (Y[ ,S ZHSHYPV ZL WHNHYm HS WYVWPV [YHIHQHKVY" WLYV ZP tZ[LUVW\KPLYLJVUJ\YYPYHJVIYHYSVLSWHNVZLOHYmHZ\J}U `\NLVJVTWH|LYVHKL]PKHVHSHWLYZVUHX\LWYL]PHTLU[L KLZPNUL`H\[VYPJLWVYLZJYP[VX\PLUWYLZLU[HYmHKLTmZSHJt K\SHKLPKLU[PKHKKLSLTWSLHKV (Y[;VKVYLJSHTVYLSHJPVUHKVJVUZHSHYPVZ`V[YHZWYLZ [HJPVULZKLILYmKPYPNPYZLHSQLMLKLZ\YLZWLJ[P]VKLWHY[HTLU[VV \UPKHK *(7Ð;<36=0 +,:*(5:6:,4(5(3 (Y[;VKV[YHIHQHKVYKLSH<UP]LYZPKHK[PLULKLYLJOVH NVaHYKL\UKxHKLKLZJHUZVYLT\ULYHKVJVU\UZHSHYPVVYKPUH YPVWVYJHKHZLTHUHSHIVYHSJVTWSL[H (Y[7LYKLYmU[V[HSTLU[LLSKLYLJOVHSHYLT\ULYHJP}U KLSKxHKLKLZJHUZVSVZ[YHIHQHKVYLZX\LMHS[HYLUPUQ\Z[PÄJHKH TLU[L HS [YHIHQV X\L HIHUKVULU SHZ SHIVYLZ V X\L WVY J\HS X\PLYJH\ZHUVQ\Z[PÄJHKHUVJVTWSL[LUZ\ZLTHUHSHIVYHS 10 (X\tSSVZX\LHJ\T\SHYLUTLKPHOVYHLUSSLNHKHZ[HYKLZL SLZ KLZJVU[HYm LS LX\P]HSLU[L H \UH OVYH KL [YHIHQV ZP UV ZVU Q\Z[PÄJHKHZ (Y[,UJHZVKLX\L\U[YHIHQHKVYKLJVTUHJ\LYKV JVUSH<UP]LYZPKHKSHIVYLLSKxHX\LSLNHS`JVU[YHJ[\HSTLU[LSL JVYYLZWVUKLJVTVKLZJHUZVZLTHUHS[LUKYmKLYLJOVHSZHSHYPV ImZPJV JVYYLZWVUKPLU[L H LZL KxH TmZ \UH YLT\ULYHJP}U KLS JPUJ\LU[HWVYJPLU[VJVTVTxUPTVWVYSHZOVYHZX\L[YHIHQLU` H\UKxHKLKLZJHUZVJVTWLUZH[VYPVYLT\ULYHKV :P[YHIHQHULUOVYHZL_[YHVYKPUHYPHZLSJmSJ\SVWHYHLSWHNV KLSVZYLJ HYNVZYLZWLJ[P]VZZLOHYm[VTHUKVJVTVIHZLLSZHSH YPVL_[YHVYKPUHYPVX\LSLJVYYLZWVUKLWVYSHQVYUHKHKLLZLKxH ZLNUSVKPZW\LZ[VLULSPUJPZVPU[LYPVY *(7Ð;<36=00 (:<,;6: (Y[:LLZ[HISLJLUJVTVKxHZKLHZ\L[VYLT\ULYHKVZSVZ ZPN\PLU[LZ! H7YPTLYVKLLULYV" I1\L]LZ]PLYULZ`ZmIHKVKL:LTHUH:HU[H" J7YPTLYVKLTH`V" K=LPU[PK}ZKLQ\UPV" L;YLZJPUJV`ZLPZKLHNVZ[V" M8\PUJLKLZLW[PLTIYL" N+VZKLUV]PLTIYL"` O=LPU[PJPUJVKLKPJPLTIYL 11 (Y[,SKxHKLHZ\L[VZLYLT\ULYHYmJVULSZHSHYPVImZPJV :PLSZHSHYPVZLO\IPLZLLZ[PW\SHKVWVYZLTHUHX\PUJLUHTLZ\ V[YVWLYxVKVTH`VYZLWYLZ\WVULX\LLUZ\TVU[VLZ[mPUJS\PKV SHYLT\ULYHJP}UKLSKxHKLHZ\L[V (Y[ 3VZ [YHIHQHKVYLZ X\L KL JVTU HJ\LYKV JVU SH <UP]LYZPKHK [YHIHQLU LS KxH KL HZ\L[V KL]LUNHYmU \U ZHSHYPV L_[YHVYKPUHYPVPU[LNYHKVWVYLSZHSHYPVImZPJVTmZ\UYLJHYNVKLS JPLUWVYJPLU[VKLtZ[L :P [YHIHQHYLU OVYHZ L_[YHZ LS JmSJ\SV WHYH LS WHNV KL SVZ YLJHYNVZ YLZWLJ[P]VZ ZL OHYm LU IHZL HS ZHSHYPV L_[YHVYKPUHYPV LZ[HISLJPKVLULSPUJPZVHU[LYPVY (Y[:PJVPUJPKPLYL\UKxHKLHZ\L[VJVULSKxHKLKLZ JHUZV ZLTHUHS LS [YHIHQHKVY [LUKYm KLYLJOV UPJHTLU[L H Z\ ZHSHYPVImZPJV"WLYVZP[YHIHQHYLLUKPJOVKxH[LUKYmKLYLJOVH SH YLT\ULYHJP}U LZWLJPHS X\L LZ[HISLJL LS HY[xJ\SV KL LZ[L YLNSHTLU[V`HSJVYYLZWVUKPLU[LKLZJHUZVJVTWLUZH[VYPVYLT\ ULYHKV (Y[ 3VZ WYVMLZVYLZ NVaHU LU WHY[L KL SPILY[HK WHYH WYVNYHTHYZ\ZHJ[P]PKHKLZ"WVYSVX\LZPLSPNPLYLU]VS\U[HYPHTLU [LKxHZKLHZ\L[VWHYHJ\TWSPYJVUZ\ZSHIVYLZLZ[mUL_JS\PKVZ KLSVKPZW\LZ[VLUSVZHY[xJ\SVZ `KLLZ[L*HWx[\SV*\HU KVZLVW[HYLWVYYLHSPaHYHJ[P]PKHKLZLUKxHZKLHZ\L[VZLKLILYm WYL]PHTLU[LKHYH]PZVHSHZH\[VYPKHKLZHJHKtTPJHZ 3VZ WYVMLZVYLZ WVKYmU [HTIPtU YLWVULY LU KxHZ KL HZ\L[V JVULSJVUZLU[PTPLU[VKLSHZH\[VYPKHKLZHJHKtTPJHZSHZOVYHZV SVZKxHZX\LUVO\IPLYLUHZPZ[PKVHZ\[YHIHQV"WVYSVX\LLULZ[L JHZVLZ[mUL_JS\xKVZKLSVKPZW\LZ[VLUSVZHY[xJ\SVZ ` 12 *(7Ð;<36=000 =(*(*065,: (Y[ 3H <UP]LYZPKHK YLJVUVJL H Z\Z [YHIHQHKVYLZ WVY JHKH H|V KL ZLY]PJPV X\PUJL KxHZ JHSLUKHYPV KL ]HJHJPVULZ YLT\ULYHKVZJVU\UHWYLZ[HJP}ULX\P]HSLU[LHSZHSHYPVVYKPUH YPVJVYYLZWVUKPLU[LHKPJOVSHWZVTmZ\U[YLPU[HWVYJPLU[VKL YLJHYNVZVIYLLSTPZTV (Y[ ;VKV [YHIHQHKVY WHYH [LULY KLYLJOV H ]HJHJPVULZ KLILYm HJYLKP[HY \U H|V KL [YHIHQV JVU[PU\V \U TxUPTV KL KVZJPLU[VZ KxHZ [YHIHQHKVZ LMLJ[P]HTLU[L ` UV [LULY MHS[HZ KL HZPZ[LUJPHPUQ\Z[PÄJHKHZ (Y[3H<UP]LYZPKHKWVKYmMYHJJPVUHYSHZ]HJHJPVULZLU [YLZWLYxVKVZKLU[YVKLSH|VKL[YHIHQVK\YHUKVJHKHWLYxVKV ZPL[LKxHZJVTVTxUPTV *(7Ð;<360? (.<05(3+6: (Y[ 3VZ [YHIHQHKVYLZ X\L HS KxH KVJL KL KPJPLTIYL UV [\]PLYLU \U H|V KL WYLZ[HY Z\Z ZLY]PJPVZ H SH <*( [LUKYmU KLYLJOVHX\LZLSLZWHN\LLUJVUJLW[VKLHN\PUHSKVSHWHY[L WYVWVYJPVUHSHS[PLTWVSHIVYHKVKLSHJHU[PKHKX\LSLZOHIYxH JVYYLZWVUKPKVZPO\IPLYLUJVTWSL[HKV\UH|VKLZLY]PJPVHSH MLJOHPUKPJHKH (Y[ 4PLU[YHZ UV LZ[t SLNPZSHKV LS KLJPTV[LYJLY TLZ KLWHNVZHSHYPHSSVZ[YHIHQHKVYLZX\LHSKxHKVJLKLKPJPLTIYL 13 [\]PLYLU\UH|VVTmZKL\UH|VKLWYLZ[HYZ\ZZLY]PJPVZ[LU KYmUKLYLJOVHX\LZLSLZWHN\LLUJVUJLW[VKLHN\PUHSKVSH JHU[PKHKTxUPTHZPN\PLU[L! H 7HYHX\PLU[\]PLYL\UH|VVTmZ`TLUVZKL[YLZH|VZKL ZLY]PJPVSHWYLZ[HJP}ULX\P]HSLU[LHSZHSHYPVKLKPLaKxHZ" I 7HYHX\PLU[\]PLYL[YLZH|VZVTmZ`TLUVZKLKPLaH|VZ KLZLY]PJPVSHWYLZ[HJP}ULX\P]HSLU[LHX\PUJLKxHZ` J 7HYHX\PLU[\]PLYLKPLaVTmZH|VZKLZLY]PJPVSHWYLZ[H JP}ULX\P]HSLU[LHKPLJPVJOVKxHZ (Y[7LYKLYmU[V[HSTLU[LLSKLYLJOVHHN\PUHSKVSVZ[YH IHQHKVYLZX\LLUKVZTLZLZZLHUVUVJVUZLJ\[P]VZKLSWLYxVKV JVTWYLUKPKVLU[YLLSKVJLKLKPJPLTIYLHU[LYPVY`LSVUJLKL KPJPLTIYLLUX\LOHIYxHKLWHNHYZLSHWYPTHOH`HU[LUPKVLU JHKH \UV KL KPJOVZ TLZLZ TmZ KL KVZ MHS[HZ PUQ\Z[PÄJHKHZ KL H\ZLUJPHHS[YHIHQVH\UX\LtZ[HZM\LYLUKLZ}SVTLKPVKxH *(7Ð;<36? +,9,*/6:6)30.(*065,: @796/0)0*065,:+,36:;9()(1(+69,: (Y[3VZ[YHIHQHKVYLZKLSH<*(NVaHYmUKL[VKVZSVZ KLYLJOVZX\LSHSL`SLZJVUJLKL (Y[ 3VZ[YHIHQHKVYLZVIZLY]HYmU`J\TWSPYmUSHZVISPNH JPVULZX\LKLHJ\LYKVJVUSHUH[\YHSLaHKLSVZW\LZ[VZVJHYNVZ ZLHUULJLZHYPHZWHYHSHI\LUHTHYJOHKLSH<UP]LYZPKHKLU[YL SHZJ\HSLZZLW\LKLUTLUJPVUHY! 14 H 7YLZLU[HYZL`YL[PYHYZLKLSH<UP]LYZPKHKHSHZOVYHZZL|H SHKHZLUZ\YLZWLJ[P]VOVYHYPVKL[YHIHQV" I (ZPZ[PYJVUW\U[\HSPKHK`WLYTHULJLYLUZ\[YHIHQVK\YHU [LSHZOVYHZZL|HSHKHZWHYHLSKLZLTWL|VKLZ\ZSHIVYLZ" J :VTL[LYZL H SVZ L_mTLULZ TtKPJVZ WLYP}KPJVZ WVY SV TLUVZ \UH ]La HS H|V" LU LS [PLTWV X\L KL[LYTPUL SH <UP]LYZPKHK V J\HUKV tZ[H UV[HYH X\L LS [YHIHQHKVY ZL LUJ\LU[YH THUPÄLZ[HTLU[L LUMLYTV" WHYH LZ[L LMLJ[V ZLYmU ]HSPKVZ SVZ L_mTLULZ WYHJ[PJHKVZ WVY LS 0UZ[P[\[V :HS]HKVYL|VKLS:LN\YV:VJPHS0:::WVYSHZ\UPKHKLZ KLZHS\KVWVYTtKPJVZNYHK\HKVZ,ULZ[LS[PTVJHZV SVZJVZ[VZZLYmUWVYJ\LU[HKLSH<UP]LYZPKHK" K .\HYKHY SH JVYYLJJP}U ` JVTWVZ[\YH KLIPKH K\YHU[L LS KLZLTWL|V KL SHZ SHIVYLZ LZWLJPHSTLU[L LU SHZ YLSH JPVULZ JVU LS LZ[\KPHU[L L]P[HUKV X\L UV ZL VJHZPVULU X\LQHZ Q\Z[PÄJHKHZ WVY LS THS ZLY]PJPV V KLZH[LUJP}U" V WVYLSTHS[YH[V`MHS[HZKLYLZWL[V" L 5VLQLJ\[HYHJ[VZX\LWLY[\YILUSHKPZJPWSPUHVHS[LYLULS UVYTHSKLZHYYVSSVKLSHZSHIVYLZ" M 4HU[LULYSPTWPV`J\PKHKVLSLX\PWV`mYLHKL[YHIHQV" N 7YLZLU[HYSH[HYQL[HKLJVU[YVSKLJP[HZKLS0:::JVUSH THYJHJP}UKLLU[YHKH`ZHSPKHKLJVUZ\S[HHZ\QLMLPUTL KPH[V"ZPLTWYLX\LtZ[LSVZVSPJP[L" O 6ILKLJLYSHZPUZ[Y\JJPVULZ`}YKLULZX\LLUTH[LYPHKL [YHIHQVYLJPIHKLZ\QLMLPUTLKPH[VVZ\WLYPVY`KLZLTWL |HYSHZJVTPZPVULZLZWLJPHSLZX\LZLHULUJVTLUKHKHZ" 15 P .\HYKHYYPN\YVZHYLZLY]HKLSVZZLJYL[VZKLSH<UP]LYZPKHK KLSVZJ\HSLZ[\]PLYLUJVUVJPTPLU[VWVYYHa}UKLZ\JHY NV`ZVIYLSVZHZ\U[VZHKTPUPZ[YH[P]VZJ\`HKP]\SNHJP}U W\LKHJH\ZHYWLYQ\PJPVZHSH<UP]LYZPKHK" Q 9LZWL[HYHZ\ZQLMLZJVTWH|LYVZKL[YHIHQVLZ[\KPHU[LZ HZxJVTVHSWISPJVLUNLULYHS" R 6IZLY]HYI\LUHJVUK\J[HLULSS\NHYKL[YHIHQVVLULS KLZLTWL|VKLZ\ZSHIVYLZ" S 7YLZ[HYH\_PSPVLUJ\HSX\PLY[PLTWVX\LZLULJLZP[LJ\HU KVWVYZPUPLZ[YVVYPLZNVPUTPULU[LWLSPNYLUSHZWLYZVUHZ SVZPU[LYLZLZKLSH<*(Z\ZJVTWH|LYVZKL[YHIHQVVKL SVZLZ[\KPHU[LZLUNLULYHS" T<ZHY YVWH SPTWPH ` HKLJ\HKH WHYH LMLJ[VZ KL OPNPLUL ` WYLZLU[HJP}U" U 7HNHYSVZKH|VZ`WLYQ\PJPVZX\LJH\ZLUWVYZ\J\SWHLU SVZVIQL[VZX\LLZ[tUHZ\J\PKHKVKLHJ\LYKVJVUSHSL`" V 9LWVY[HY PUTLKPH[HTLU[L H Z\ QLML PUTLKPH[V J\HSX\PLY HUVTHSxHX\LUV[HYLLULSWYVJLZVKL[YHIHQVHZxJVTV SHZKLÄJPLUJPHZKLSVZKLTmZ[YHIHQHKVYLZLULSKLZLTWL |VKLZ\ZSHIVYLZ"` W *\TWSPYSVLZ[HISLJPKVLULSJVU[YH[VPUKP]PK\HSKL[YHIH QVJVULSWYLZLU[L9LNSHTLU[V0U[LYUVKL;YHIHQV`JVU [VKHZSHZKPZWVZPJPVULZX\LSLPTWVUNHLS*}KPNVKL;YH IHQV`KLTmZM\LU[LZKLVISPNHJPVULZSHIVYHSLZHZxJVTV KLPUZ[Y\J[P]VZSHIVYHSLZKLSHZH\[VYPKHKLZZ\WLYPVYLZKL SH<*( 16 (Y[ 3HZ M\UJPVULZ ` H[YPI\JPVULZ KL JHKH W\LZ[V KL [YHIHQVLZ[HYmUJVU[LTWSHKHZLULS4HU\HSKL+LZJYPWJP}UKL 7\LZ[VZ3H<UP]LYZPKHKWYVWVYJPVUHYmHJHKH[YHIHQHKVYSHKLZ JYPWJP}UKLSW\LZ[VJVYYLZWVUKPLU[L (Y[3LZLZ[mWYVOPIPKVHSVZ[YHIHQHKVYLZ! H +LKPJHYZL LU SHZ OVYHZ KL [YHIHQV H HZ\U[VZ HQLUVZ H Z\ [YHIHQVVPU[LYY\TWPYSHZSHIVYLZKLZ\ZJVTWH|LYVZ" I 7LYTHULJLYLUS\NHYLZKPZ[PU[VZKLHX\LSVHX\LSSVZX\L ZLSLZOH`HHZPNUHKVWHYHSHLQLJ\JP}UKLZ\ZSHIVYLZ" J 0U[YVK\JPYWLYZVUHSUVH\[VYPaHKVLULSS\NHYKL[YHIHQV" K 9LHSPaHYHJ[P]PKHKLZKPZ[PU[HZHSHZX\LJVYYLZWVUKLUZPU WYL]PVJVUVJPTPLU[VKLZ\QLMLPUTLKPH[V" L 0UNLYPYILIPKHZLTIYPHNHU[LZVOHJLY\ZVKLUHYJ}[PJVZV KYVNHZLULY]HU[LZKLU[YVKLSHZPUZ[HSHJPVULZKLSH<UP ]LYZPKHKLUOVYHZKL[YHIHQV" M 7YLZLU[HYZL H Z\Z SHIVYLZ H KLZLTWL|HY SHZ TPZTHZ LU LZ[HKVKLLTIYPHN\LaVIHQVSHPUÅ\LUJPHKL\UUHYJ}[PJV VKYVNHLULY]HU[L" N ,QLJ\[HYHJ[VZX\LW\LKHUWVULYLUWLSPNYVSHWYVWPHZL N\YPKHKKLS[YHIHQHKVYSHKLZ\ZJVTWH|LYVZQLMLZ\V[YHZ WLYZVUHZ"HZxJVTV[HTIPtUSHKLSVZLKPÄJPVZSVJHSLZ` KLSLX\PWV`TH[LYPHSKLSH<UP]LYZPKHK" O *VTL[LYHJ[VZPUTVYHSLZ\ZHYWHSHIYHZZVLJLZVKPYPNPYZL H Z\Z JVTWH|LYVZ LU MVYTH PUKLJVYVZH PYYLZWL[\VZH V PUZ\S[HU[L" 17 P /HJLYKPI\QVZWPU[\YHZVPUZJYPWJPVULZKLU[YVKLSHZPUZ [HSHJPVULZKLSH<UP]LYZPKHKJVSVJHYY}[\SVZVH]PZVZLU J\HSX\PLYWHY[LKLSHTPZTHZPUWYL]PVJVUZLU[PTPLU[VKL SHZH\[VYPKHKLZYLZWLJ[P]HZ" Q +PZTPU\PY PU[LUJPVUHSTLU[L LS YP[TV KL LQLJ\JP}U KLS [YHIHQVZ\ZWLUKLYSHIVYLZWYVTV]LYZ\ZWLUZPVULZPU[LT WLZ[P]HTLU[LKLSHZTPZTHZVL_JP[HYHZ\KLJSHYHJP}U PUPJPHJP}U V THU[LUPTPLU[V ZLH X\L WHY[PJPWL V UV LU LSSHZ" R :\TPUPZ[YHYH[LYJLYVZVL_[YH|VZZPUWYL]PHH\[VYPaHJP}U KLSH<UP]LYZPKHKKH[VZYLSHJPVUHKVZJVUSHVYNHUPaHJP}U VJVUJ\HSX\PLYHKLSVZZPZ[LTHZ`WYVJLKPTPLU[VZ`WV Sx[PJHZKLSHTPZTH" S ,QLJ\[HYKLMLJ[\VZHTLU[LLS[YHIHQVVLUMVYTHULNSPNLU [L" T*H\ZHYPU[LYY\WJPVULZJVULSLTWSLVKLTLKPVZKLJ\HS X\PLYUH[\YHSLaHJVULSVIQL[VKLX\LLS[YHIHQVWYVWPVV LSKL[LYJLYVZUVZHSNHLUSHJHU[PKHKJHSPKHK`[PLTWV ÄQHKVWVYSH<UP]LYZPKHK" U *VUÄHY H V[YV [YHIHQHKVY ZPU SH H\[VYPaHJP}U JVYYLZ WVUKPLU[L SH LQLJ\JP}U KLS [YHIHQV WYVWPV HZP JVTV LS THULQVKLPUZ[Y\TLU[VZ`TH[LYPHSLZKLSH<UP]LYZPKHK" 18 V /HILY WYLZLU[HKV WHYH SH HKTPZP}U KL SH <UP]LYZPKHK V WYLZLU[HY KLZW\tZ WHYH J\HSX\PLY LMLJ[V KVJ\TLU[VZ V JVTWYVIHU[LZMHSZVZPUJVTWSL[VZVHS[LYHKVZ" W +PZ[YPI\PYLUOVYHZKL[YHIHQVLUSVZYLJPU[VZKLSH<UP ]LYZPKHKOVQHZ]VSHU[LZJPYJ\SHYLZ\V[YHZZLTLQHU[LZUV VYKLUHKHZVH\[VYPaHKHZWVYSHTPZTH" X +H|HYKLZ[Y\PYVJHTIPHYKLS\NHYH]PZVZVHK]LY[LUJPHZ ZVIYLJVUKPJPVULZPUZHS\IYLZKLZLN\YPKHKLOPNPLUL"` Y 0TWLKPYX\LZLJ\TWSHUSHZTLKPKHZKLZLN\YPKHKLUSHZ VWLYHJPVULZ`WYVJLZVZKL[YHIHQV *(7Ð;<36?0 6)30.(*065,:@796/0)0*065,: +,3(<50=,9:0+(+ (Y[:VUVISPNHJPVULZKLSH<UP]LYZPKHK! H 7HNHYHS[YHIHQHKVYZ\ZHSHYPVLUMVYTHJ\HU[xHMLJOH` S\NHYLZ[HISLJPKVZLULZ[L9LNSHTLU[V" I .\HYKHYSHKLIPKHJVUZPKLYHJP}U`YLZWL[VHSVZ[YHIHQH KVYLZHIZ[LUPtUKVZLKLTHS[YH[HYSVZKLVIYHVKLWHSHIYH" J 6MYLJLYSHZJVUKPJPVULZHKLJ\HKHZKL[YHIHQVHJHKH\UV KLZ\ZLTWSLHKVZ" K *VUJLKLYHSVZ[YHIHQHKVYLZSHZSPJLUJPHZLZ[HISLJPKHZWVY SHSL`" L *\TWSPYJVULZ[L9LNSHTLU[V0U[LYUVKL;YHIHQV`JVU[V KHZSHZSL`LZX\LPTWVUNHULS*}KPNVKL;YHIHQV`KLTmZ M\LU[LZKLVISPNHJPVULZSHIVYHSLZ" 19 (Y[:VUWYVOPIPJPVULZKLSH<UP]LYZPKHK! H ,_PNPYVHJLW[HYKLSVZ[YHIHQHKVYLZNYH[PÄJHJPVULZWHYH X\LZLSLZHKTP[HLULS[YHIHQVVWHYHVI[LULYHSNUWYP ]PSLNPV" I ;YH[HYKLPUÅ\PYLUZ\Z[YHIHQHKVYLZLUJ\HU[VHSLQLYJPJPV KLZ\ZKLYLJOVZWVSx[PJVZVYLSPNPVZVZ" J 9L[LULY SHZ OLYYHTPLU[HZ \ VIQL[VZ X\L WLY[LULaJHU H Z\Z [YHIHQHKVYLZ WHYH NHYHU[PaHY LS J\TWSPTPLU[V KL SHZ VISPNHJPVULZKLtZ[VZ" K 9LK\JPYKPYLJ[HVPUKPYLJ[HTLU[LSVZZHSHYPVZ`WYLZ[HJPV ULZ ZVJPHSLZ YLJVUVJPKHZ SLNHSTLU[L H SVZ [YHIHQHKVYLZ ZHS]VX\LL_PZ[HJH\ZHSLNHS"` L ,QLJ\[HY J\HSX\PLY HJ[V X\L KPYLJ[H V PUKPYLJ[HTLU[L [PLUKH H YLZ[YPUNPY SVZ KLYLJOVZ X\L LZ[L 9LNSHTLU[V LS *}KPNVKL;YHIHQV`KLTmZM\LU[LZKLVISPNHJPVULZSHIV YHSLZJVUÄLYLUHSVZ[YHIHQHKVYLZ *(7Ð;<36?00 30*,5*0(:@(<:,5*0(: (Y[ 3H <UP]LYZPKHK JVUJLKLYm SPJLUJPH JVU NVJL KL Z\LSKVHZ\Z[YHIHQHKVYLZLUSHZJPYJ\UZ[HUJPHZZPN\PLU[LZ! 20 H 7HYHJ\TWSPYSHZVISPNHJPVULZKLJHYmJ[LYWISPJVLZ[HISL JPKHZ WVY SH SL` \ VYKLUHKHZ WVY H\[VYPKHK JVTWL[LU[L ,ULZ[VZJHZVZSH<UP]LYZPKHKKLILYmWHNHYHS[YHIHQHKVY \UHWYLZ[HJP}ULX\P]HSLU[LHSZHSHYPVVYKPUHYPVX\LOHIYxH KL]LUNHKVLULS[PLTWVX\LYLX\PLYHLSJ\TWSPTPLU[VKL SHZVISPNHJPVULZKPJOHZ" I 7HYHJ\TWSPYSHZVISPNHJPVULZMHTPSPHYLZX\LYHJPVUHSTLU[L YLJSHTLUZ\WYLZLUJPHJVTVJ\HUKVLS[YHIHQHKVYJVU [YHLTH[YPTVUPVVLUSVZJHZVZKLT\LY[LVLUMLYTLKHK NYH]LKLZ\J}U`\NLKLZ\ZHZJLUKPLU[LZ`KLZJLUKPLU[LZ" SVTPZTVX\LJ\HUKVZL[YH[LKLWLYZVUHZX\LKLWLUKHU LJVU}TPJHTLU[L KL tS ` X\L HWHYLaJHU UVTPUHKHZ LU LS YLZWLJ[P]V JVU[YH[V KL [YHIHQV V LU Z\ KLMLJ[V LU J\HSX\PLY YLNPZ[YV KL SH PUZ[P[\JP}U ,Z[H SPJLUJPH K\YHYm LS [PLTWV ULJLZHYPV" WLYV SH <UP]LYZPKHK ZVSHTLU[L LZ [HYmVISPNHKHHYLJVUVJLYWVYLZ[HJH\ZH\UHWYLZ[HJP}U LX\P]HSLU[LHSZHSHYPVVYKPUHYPVKLKVZKxHZLUJHKHTLZ JHSLUKHYPV`LUUPUNUJHZVTmZKLX\PUJLKxHZLU\U TPZTVH|VJHSLUKHYPV"` J 7HYHHZPZ[PYHHJ[P]PKHKLZKPYLJ[HTLU[LYLSHJPVUHKHZJVUSH <UP]LYZPKHKLUJVTLUKHKHZWVYtZ[HVLUYLWYLZLU[HJP}U KLSHTPZTH:LL_JLW[HUKLLZ[VZJHZVZHX\LSSVZYLSH[P ]VZHILJHZKLLZ[\KPVZJ\`HYLN\SHJP}ULZ[mJVU[LTWSH KHLULSZPZ[LTHKLILJHZKLSH<UP]LYZPKHK (Y[ 3H <UP]LYZPKHK JVUJLKLYm SPJLUJPH ZPU NVJL KL Z\LSKV H Z\Z [YHIHQHKVYLZ WHYH H[LUKLY HZ\U[VZ LZ[YPJ[HTLU[L WLYZVUHSLZ UV JVU[LTWSHKVZ LU LS HY[xJ\SV HU[LYPVY J\`H Q\Z [PÄJHJP}U KLIL ZLY KL[LYTPUHKH WVY SH H\[VYPKHK VYNHUPaH[P]H JVYYLZWVUKPLU[L (Y[:LLZ[HISLJLUSVZZPN\PLU[LZUP]LSLZKLH\[VYPaHJP}U WHYHJVUJLKLYSPJLUJPHZ! 21 H 1LML PUTLKPH[V KLS [YHIHQHKVY! JVUJLKLYm SPJLUJPH OHZ[H WVYZPL[LKxHZ`HZLHJVUNVJLVZPUNVJLKLZ\LSKV" I ,S 9LJ[VY =PJLYLJ[VY :LJYL[HYPV .LULYHS V LS +PYLJ[VY (KTPUPZ[YH[P]V! JVUJLKLYmU SPJLUJPHZ WVY TmZ KL ZPL[L KxHZOHZ[H[YLPU[H`HZLHJVUNVJLVZPUNVJLKLZ\LSKV" J 1\U[HKL+PYLJ[VYLZ!JVUJLKLYmSPJLUJPHZWVYTmZKL[YLPU [HKxHZ`HZLHJVUNVJLVZPUNVJLKLZ\LSKV (Y[*\HUKV\U[YHIHQHKVYULJLZP[LH\ZLU[HYZLKLS[YHIH QVKLILYmZVSPJP[HYWLYTPZVWVYLZJYP[VHZ\QLMLPUTLKPH[VZ\WL YPVYLZWLJPÄJHUKVSHMLJOHK\YHJP}UHWYV_PTHKH`LSTV[P]VKLS WLYTPZV,SQLMLPUTLKPH[VKLS[YHIHQHKVYKLJPKPYmSHWYVJLKLUJPH VUVKLSWLYTPZVZVSPJP[HKV:PLS[YHIHQHKVYZLLUJVU[YHYLPT WVZPIPSP[HKVKLTHULYHPTWYL]PZ[HWHYHWYLZLU[HYZLHZ\[YHIHQV KLILYmKHYH]PZVWVYLZJYP[VHZ\QLMLPUTLKPH[VLULSJ\YZVKLS WYPTLYKxHKLH\ZLUJPHPUKPJHUKVLSS\NHY`SHKPYLJJP}ULUX\L ZLLUJ\LU[YH`LSTV[P]VX\LSLPTWPKLWYLZLU[HYZLHZ\ZSHIVYLZ ,ULZ[LS[PTVJHZVLS[YHIHQHKVYKLILYmQ\Z[PÄJHYZ\H\ZLUJPH JVUSVZTLKPVZKLWY\LIHX\LSH<UP]LYZPKHKKL[LYTPUL,SQLML PUTLKPH[V KLZW\tZ KL LU[LYHYZL KL SH ZP[\HJP}U KLS LTWSLHKV H\ZLU[LKLILYmUV[PÄJHYSVHSH6ÄJPUHKL7LYZVUHSLULSMVYT\ SHYPVJVYYLZWVUKPLU[L *\HUKV\U[YHIHQHKVYZLLUJ\LU[YLPUJHWHJP[HKVWVYLUMLY TLKHK`HJJPKLU[LJVT\ULZVWVYTH[LYUPKHKSH<UP]LYZPKHK SLWHNHYmLSKLZ\ZHSHYPVK\YHU[LSVZ[YLZWYPTLYVZKxHZKL PUJHWHJPKHKZPLTWYL`J\HUKVZLJVTWY\LIL[HSJVUKPJP}UJVU SHJLY[PÄJHJP}UTtKPJHL_[LUKPKHWVYLS0UZ[P[\[V:HS]HKVYL|VKLS :LN\YV:VJPHSVWVYLSTtKPJVX\LSLH[PLUKLWHY[PJ\SHYTLU[L,U HTIVZJHZVZLSKVJ\TLU[VKLILYmJVU[LULYLSUVTIYLÄYTH ZLSSV`UTLYVKLSYLNPZ[YVKLSTtKPJVLUSHQ\U[HKL]PNPSHUJPH 22 *(7Ð;<36?000 3()69,:05+,)0+(:7(9(4<1,9,: @4,569,:+,,+(+ (Y[,USH<UP]LYZPKHKUVSHIVYHYmUTLUVYLZKLKPLJPV JOVH|VZKLLKHK"WLYVZPLULSM\[\YVZLJVU[YH[HYLUZLHWSPJHYm SVWYLZJYP[VWVYLS*}KPNVKL;YHIHQV`KLTmZUVYTHZHWSPJHISLZ SLNHSLZ (Y[ 3HT\QLYLTIHYHaHKHUVWVKYmKLZ[PUHYZLH[YHIH QVZX\LYLX\PLYHULZM\LYaVZMxZPJVZPUJVTWH[PISLZJVUZ\LZ[HKV WYLZ\TPtUKVZLX\LJ\HSX\PLY[YHIHQVX\LYLX\PLYH\ULZM\LYaV MxZPJV JVUZPKLYHISL LZ PUJVTWH[PISL JVU LS LZ[HKV KL NYH]PKLa KLZW\tZKLSJ\HY[VTLZKLLTIHYHaV ,U SV KLTmZ ZL HWSPJHYm SV X\L H LMLJ[V KPZWVUNH SH SL` ` KLTmZM\LU[LZKLVISPNHJPVULZSHIVYHSLZ *(7Ð;<36?0= ,?Í4,5,:4i+0*6:@4,+0+(:796-03Í*;0*(: (Y[ 3H <UP]LYZPKHK L_PNPYm H Z\Z [YHIHQHKVYLZ L_m TLULZ TtKPJVZ NLULYHSLZ \UH ]La HS H|V V J\HUKV SV LZ[PTL JVU]LUPLU[L +PJOVZ L_mTLULZ WVKYmU ]LYPÄJHYZL LU WLYxVKVZ TLUVYLZZPHZxSVL_PNPLYLUSHZH\[VYPKHKLZJVTWL[LU[LZJVULS VIQL[VKLWYV[LNLYSHZHS\KKLSVZ[YHIHQHKVYLZ,ZLU[LUKPKVX\L SVZL_mTLULZHX\LZLYLÄLYLLSPUJPZVHU[LYPVYZLYmU]LYPÄJHKVZ WHYHZ\]HSPKLaLULS0:::VLU\USHIVYH[VYPVVWVYTtKPJVZ PUKPJHKVZWVYSH<UP]LYZPKHKLUJ\`VJHZVZLYmtZ[HSHX\LWH N\LSVZNHZ[VZX\LVJHZPVULUSVZL_mTLULZTLUJPVUHKVZ 23 (Y[ ;VKV [YHIHQHKVY X\L HKX\PLYH \UH LUMLYTLKHK PUMLJ[VJVU[HNPVZH V X\L ZL LUJ\LU[YL PTWVZPIPSP[HKV WHYH LS KLZLTWL|VKLZ\ZSHIVYLZKLILYmJVT\UPJHYSVHSHTH`VYIYL ]LKHKWVZPISLHSH<UP]LYZPKHKX\PLUWVKYmKLZPNUHY\UTtKPJV WHY[PJ\SHYWHYHJVTWYVIHYSVX\LZLLZ[PTLJVU]LUPLU[L *(7Ð;<36?= :,.<90+(+,/0.0,5,,5,3;9()(16 (Y[3H<UP]LYZPKHKTHU[LUKYmLUJVTWSL[VLZ[HKVKL ZHS\IYPKHKSPTWPLaHLOPNPLUL[VKHZZ\ZKLWLUKLUJPHZ*\TWSPYm HZxTPZTVJVUSHZKPZWVZPJPVULZX\LZVIYLOPNPLUL`WYL]PZP}U ZVJPHSVYKLUHYLUSHZH\[VYPKHKLZKLSHTH[LYPH ,U ]PY[\K KL LZ[HY Z\QL[H HS YtNPTLU KLS 0UZ[P[\[V :HS]HKV YL|V KLS :LN\YV :VJPHS SH <UP]LYZPKHK X\LKHYm L_LU[H KL SHZ WYLZ[HJPVULZX\LSLPTWVULLS*}KPNVKL;YHIHQV`V[YHZSL`LZ WYVT\SNHKHZLUMH]VYKLSVZ[YHIHQHKVYLZLUSHTLKPKHX\LZLHU J\IPLY[HZWVYLS0::::PULTIHYNVZPWVYKPZWVZPJPVULZSLNHSLZ KL JVU[YH[V KL [YHIHQV V KL LZ[L 9LNSHTLU[V SH <UP]LYZPKHK LZ[\]PLYLVISPNHKHHKHYWYLZ[HJPVULZZ\WLYPVYLZHSHZJVUJLKPKHZ WVYLS0:::SVZ[YHIHQHKVYLZWVKYmUYLJSHTHYSLSHWHY[LX\LUV YLJPIPLYLUKLSTLUJPVUHKV0UZ[P[\[V (Y[*VULSVIQL[VKLWYV[LNLYSH]PKHSHZHS\KVSHPU[L NYPKHKJVYWVYHSKLZ\Z[YHIHQHKVYLZSH<UP]LYZPKHKJ\TWSPYmJVU SHZVISPNHJPVULZWLY[PULU[LZKLSYLNSHTLU[VNLULYHSZVIYLZLN\YP KHKLOPNPLULLUSVZJLU[YVZKL[YHIHQVLUSVYLSH[P]VHZLY]PJPV KLHN\HZLY]PJPVZZHUP[HYPVZVYKLU`HZLVKLSVZSVJHSLZL[J JVTVLUSVYLMLYLU[LHSHZJVUKPJPVULZTxUPTHZKLWYL]PZP}ULU TH[LYPHKLZLN\YPKHK 24 (Y[3VZ[YHIHQHKVYLZKLSH<UP]LYZPKHKJ\TWSPYmUJVU SHZTLKPKHZYLSH[P]HZKLOPNPLUL`ZLN\YPKHKX\LZLKPJ[HYLU (Y[,S[YHIHQHKVYZLYmKPYLJ[HTLU[LYLZWVUZHISLKLSVZ KH|VZTH[LYPHSLZVYPNPUHKVZWVYLSX\LIYHU[HTPLU[VKLSHZTLKP KHZKLZLN\YPKHK`LS\ZVPUHKLJ\HKVKLSLX\PWVKLWYV[LJJP}U X\LZLOH`HWYVWVYJPVUHKV (Y[ *HKH LTWSLHKV ` JHKH WLYZVUH LUJHYNHKH LZ[mU VISPNHKVZHVIZLY]HY`VILKLJLYSHZPUZ[Y\JJPVULZKLZLN\YPKHK KLSHZWLYZVUHZ`KLSVZVIQL[VZLUSVZSVJHSLZKLSH<UP]LYZPKHK ,Z WYVOPIPKV X\P[HY HU\SHY VIZ[HJ\SPaHY V LU NLULYHS WYV ]VJHY SH PULÄJPLUJPH KL SVZ KPZWVZP[P]VZ WHYH SH WYL]LUJP}U KL HJJPKLU[LZ,ZVISPNH[VYPVWHYHJHKHLTWSLHKV\ZHYSVZTLKPVZ KLWYV[LJJP}UX\LZLOHUZ\TPUPZ[YHKVWHYHLSKLZLTWL|VKLZ\ [YHIHQVJVTVWVYLQLTWSV!TmZJHYHZN\HU[LZ\UPMVYTLZNVYYVZ L[J *HKH LTWSLHKV [PLUL SH VISPNHJP}U KL H]PZHY H Z\ QLML PU TLKPH[HTLU[L ZVIYL J\HSX\PLY HUVYTHSPKHK HJJPKLU[L WLY[\Y IHJP}UL[J`ZPM\LYLULJLZHYPVZVSPJP[HYPUZ[Y\JJPVULZ"LUJHZV KLKLÄJPLUJPHVKH|VZLUTmX\PUHZHWHYH[VZL[JLSLTWSLHKV KLILJVT\UPJHYSVPUTLKPH[HTLU[LHZ\QLML *(7Ð;<36?=0 )6;08<Ð5 (Y[ 3H <UP]LYZPKHK THU[LUKYm LU \U S\NHY HJJLZPISL ` WHYH \ZV NYH[\P[V KL [VKVZ SVZ [YHIHQHKVYLZ H Z\ ZLY]PJPV \U IV[PX\xULX\PWHKVJVUSVZTLKPJHTLU[VZLUSHMVYTHX\LKL [LYTPULSH+PYLJJP}U.LULYHSKL7YL]PZP}U:VJPHS 25 *(7Ð;<36?=00 7,;0*065,:9,*3(46:@46+6 +,9,:63=,936: (Y[3HZWL[PJPVULZVYLJSHTVZKLJ\HSX\PLYUH[\YHSLaH X\L M\LYLU ZL OHYmU ]LYIHSTLU[L V WVY LZJYP[V WYPTLYV HU[L LS QLML PUTLKPH[V ` KLZW\tZ LU SH 6ÄJPUH KL 7LYZVUHS 7VZ [LYPVYTLU[L WVKYmU OHJLYSHZ HU[L LS +PYLJ[VY (KTPUPZ[YH[P]V :LJYL[HYPV .LULYHS =PJL9LJ[VY V 9LJ[VY ZLNU JVYYLZWVUKH 3VZYLJSHTVZZLYmUYLZ\LS[VZLU\USHWZVUVTH`VYKLJPUJVKxHZ SHIVYHSLZ *(7Ð;<36?=000 +0:76:0*065,:+0:*07305(90(:@46+6+, (730*(93(: (Y[ ,S PUJ\TWSPTPLU[V KL SHZ VISPNHJPVULZ ` SH PUMYHJ JP}UKLSHZKPZWVZPJPVULZJVU[LUPKHZLULZ[L9LNSHTLU[V0U[LYUV ZLYmUZHUJPVUHKHZKLJVUMVYTPKHKHSHNYH]LKHKKLSHMHS[H (Y[3H<UP]LYZPKHKJHSPÄJHSHZMHS[HZLUSL]LZTLUVZ NYH]LZNYH]LZ`T\`NYH]LZJVUMVYTLHSHZKLÄUPJPVULZZPN\PLU [LZ! 26 H -HS[HZ SL]LZ! ZVU LS PUJ\TWSPTPLU[V KL SHZ VISPNHJPVULZ JVU[LTWSHKHZLULSHY[xJ\SV KLLZ[L9LNSHTLU[V`SH ]PVSHJP}UKLSHZWYVOPIPJPVULZLZ[PW\SHKHZLUSVZSP[LYHSLZ HIJ`KKLSHY[xJ\SVKLSTPZTV I -HS[HZTLUVZNYH]LZ!JVUZPZ[LULUSHJ\HY[HYLP[LYHJP}UKL MHS[HZSL]LZ J -HS[HZNYH]LZ!JVUZPZ[LULUSHZL_[HYLP[LYHJP}UKLSHZMHS[HZ SL]LZVSH]PVSHJP}UKL\UHKLSHZWYVOPIPJPVULZPUKPJH KHZLUSVZSP[LYHSLZKLZKLLSLOHZ[HLSYKLSHY[xJ\SV KLSWYLZLU[L9LNSHTLU[V K -HS[HZ T\` NYH]LZ! JVUZPZ[LU LU SH YLP[LYHJP}U KL MHS[HZ NYH]LZ (Y[3HZMHS[HZZLYmUZHUJPVUHKHZLUSHMVYTHZPN\PLU[L! H (TVULZ[HJP}U]LYIHS!ZLHWSPJHYmLULSJHZVKLSHZMHS[HZ SL]LZ3HHTVULZ[HJP}UKLILYmOHJLYZLLUWYP]HKVWVYLS QLMLPUTLKPH[VYLZWLJ[P]V I (TVULZ[HJP}ULZJYP[H!WYVJLKLYmLULSJHZVKLSHZMHS[HZ TLUVZNYH]LZZPLUKVYLZWVUZHIPSPKHKKLSQLMLPUTLKPH [V LS HWSPJHYSH KLIPLUKV LU]PHY JVWPH KL SH TPZTH H SH 6ÄJPUH KL 7LYZVUHS ,Z[H JVWPH KLILYm ZLY ÄYTHKH WVY LS LTWSLHKV HTVULZ[HKV J\HUKV ZL SL LU[YLNH SH UV[H VYPNPUHSKLHTVULZ[HJP}U J :\ZWLUZP}UWVY\UKxH!ZLYmWYVJLKLU[LJ\HUKVLS[YHIH QHKVYOH`HPUJ\YYPKVLUMHS[HZNYH]LZ K ,UJHZVKLMHS[HZT\`NYH]LZZ\ZWLUZP}UWVYTmZKL\U KxHOHZ[H[YLPU[HKxHZJVUH\[VYPaHJP}UKLS+PYLJ[VY.LUL YHSKL0UZWLJJP}UKL;YHIHQV L 3H <*( ZL YLZLY]H Z\ KLYLJOV KL KHY WVY [LYTPUHKV LS JVU[YH[VPUKP]PK\HSKL[YHIHQVWVYPUJ\YYPYLS[YHIHQHKVYLU 27 SHZ JVUK\J[HZ ZL|HSHKHZ LU LS *}KPNV KL;YHIHQV JVTV JH\ZHSLZKLKLZWPKV (Y[ 3H <UP]LYZPKHK [HTIPtU KHYm WVY [LYTPUHKV LS JVU[YH[VKL[YHIHQVJVUZ\Z[YHIHQHKVYLZZPUPUJ\YYPYLUYLZWVU ZHIPSPKHKKLZ\WHY[LLUSVZZPN\PLU[LZJHZVZ! H 7VY OHILY LUNH|HKV LS [YHIHQHKVY H SH <UP]LYZPKHK HS JLSLIYHY LS JVU[YH[V WYLZLU[HUKV KVJ\TLU[HJP}U MHSZH ZVIYLZ\HW[P[\K"LZ[HJH\ZHUVWVKYmHSLNHYZLKLZW\tZKL [YLPU[HKxHZKLPUPJPHKHZSHZSHIVYLZ I 7VYULNSPNLUJPHYLP[LYHKHKLS[YHIHQHKVY J 7VYHJ[VZNYH]LZJVU[YHSHTVYHSJVTL[PKVZWVYLS[YHIHQH KVYKLU[YVKLSHZPUZ[HSHJPVULZKLSH<UP]LYZPKHKVM\LYH KL tZ[H J\HUKV ZL LUJVU[YHYL LU LS KLZLTWL|V KL Z\Z SHIVYLZ K 7VYJVTL[LYLS[YHIHQHKVYLUJ\HSX\PLYJPYJ\UZ[HUJPHHJ[VZ KLPYYLZWL[VLUJVU[YHKLZ\ZYLWYLZLU[HU[LZVQLMLZVKL Z\ZJVTWH|LYVZKL[YHIHQV"ZPUX\LO\IPLYLWYLJLKPKVWYV ]VJHJP}UPUTLKPH[HKLWHY[LKLSHZWLYZVUHZUVTPUHKHZ L 7VYYL]LSHYLS[YHIHQHKVYZLJYL[VZKLSH<UP]LYZPKHKVWVY HWYV]LJOHYZLKLLSSVZ M 7VY MHS[HY LS [YHIHQHKVY H Z\Z SHIVYLZ ZPU WLYTPZV V ZPU JH\ZHQ\Z[PÄJHKHK\YHU[LKVZKxHZSHIVYHSLZJVTWSL[VZ` JVUZLJ\[P]VZ"VK\YHU[L[YLZKxHZUVJVUZLJ\[P]VZLU\U TPZTV TLZ JHSLUKHYPV" LU[LUKPtUKVZL WVY [HSLZ LU LZ[L S[PTV JHZV UV Z}SV KxHZ JVTWSL[VZ ZPUV [HTIPtU SVZ TLKPVZKxHZ 28 N 7VY HWYVWPHYZL PUKLIPKHTLU[L KL OLYYHTPLU[HZ TLYJH KLYxH \ V[YV VIQL[V WYVWPLKHK KL SH <UP]LYZPKHK ZPU LS WLYTPZV]LYIHSVLZJYP[VKLSHWLYZVUHH\[VYPaHKH O 7VYJVTL[LYLS[YHIHQHKVYHJ[VZX\LWLY[\YILUNYH]LTLU[L LSVYKLULUSH<UP]LYZPKHKHS[LYHUKVLSUVYTHSKLZHYYVSSV KLSHZSHIVYLZ *(7Ð;<36?0? +0:76:0*065,:-05(3,: 7<)30*0+(+@=0.,5*0( (Y[ 3V YLN\SHKV LU LZ[L 9LNSHTLU[V 0U[LYUV ZL LU [LUKLYm ZPU WLYQ\PJPV KL TLQVYLZ KLYLJOVZ X\L LU MH]VY KL SVZ [YHIHQHKVYLZLZ[HISLaJHUSHZSL`LZSHIVYHSLZSVZJVU[YH[VZ`SVZ YLJVUVJPKVZWVYSHJVZ[\TIYLKLSH<UP]LYZPKHK 3VUVWYL]PZ[VZLYLZVS]LYmJVUHYYLNSVHSHZUVYTHZNLUL YHSLZKLSHSLNPZSHJP}USHIVYHS (Y[+LU[YVKLSVZZLPZKxHZZPN\PLU[LZHHX\LSLUX\L M\LYLHWYVIHKVWVYLS+PYLJ[VY.LULYHSKLS;YHIHQVLSWYLZLU[L 9LNSHTLU[V 0U[LYUV ZL KHYm H JVUVJLY H SVZ [YHIHQHKVYLZ WVY TLKPVKLLQLTWSHYLZLZJYP[VZJVUJHYHJ[LYLZSLNPISLZX\LZLJV SVJHYmULUS\NHYLZKLMmJPS]PZPIPSPKHKKLU[YVKLSH<UP]LYZPKHK ,S9LNSHTLU[VLU[YHYmLU]PNLUJPHX\PUJLKxHZKLZW\tZKL SHMLJOHLUX\LZLOH`HKHKVHJVUVJLYHSVZ[YHIHQHKVYLZ (Y[;VKHYLMVYTHVTVKPÄJHJP}UHLZ[L9LNSHTLU[VUV [LUKYm]HSPKLaZPUVZLVIZLY]HULS[YmTP[L`WSHaVZLZ[HISLJPKVZ LULSHY[xJ\SVHU[LYPVY 29 (Y[4PLU[YHZLSWYLZLU[L9LNSHTLU[V0U[LYUVKL;YHIHQV Z\ZYLMVYTHZ`TVKPÄJHJPVULZLZ[tULU]PNLUJPHUVZLYmULJL ZHYPVLSWSHaVKLX\PUJLKxHZWHYHX\LZ\ZKPZWVZPJPVULZZLHUKL VISPNH[VYPHVIZLY]HUJPHYLZWLJ[VKLSHZU\L]HZH\[VYPKHKLZVZ\Z YLWYLZLU[HU[LZ`SVZ[YHIHQHKVYLZKLU\L]VPUNYLZV 56;(:! ,SWYLZLU[L9LNSHTLU[VM\LHWYVIHKVWVYLS+PYLJ[VY.LUL YHSKL;YHIHQVKLS4PUPZ[LYPVKL;YHIHQV`7YL]PZP}U:VJPHS LSKLQ\SPVKL ,SWYLZLU[L9LNSHTLU[VZLKP}HJVUVJLYHSVZ[YHIHQHKVYLZ LSKLQ\SPVKL WVYSVX\LZ\]PNLUJPHLZLMLJ[P]HH WHY[PYKLSKLQ\SPVKL ,S+PYLJ[VY.LULYHSKL;YHIHQVHWYVI}SHTVKPÄJHJP}UKLS (Y[KLSWYLZLU[L9LNSHTLU[VLS KLQ\UPVKL 30