Actas del I Congreso Internacional de la Asociación Ibérica de Estudios de Traducción e Interpretación Traducir Lingüística. Words and Rules de Steven Pinker, un caso práctico Javier ORTIZ GARCÍA Universidad Autónoma de Madrid Como citar este artículo: ORTIZ GARCÍA, Javier (2003) «Traducir lingüística. Words and Rules de Steven Pinker, un caso práctico», en MUÑOZ MARTÍN, Ricardo [ed.] I AIETI. Actas del I Congreso Internacional de la Asociación Ibérica de Estudios de Traducción e Interpretación. Granada 12-14 de Febrero de 2003. Granada: AIETI. Vol. n.º 1, pp. 125-206. ISBN 84-933360-0-9. Versión electrónica disponible en la web de la AIETI: <http://www.aieti.eu/pubs/actas/I/AIETI_1_JOG_Traducir.pdf>. 7UDGXFLU/LQJtVWLFD :RUGVDQG5XOHVGH6WHYHQ3LQNHU XQFDVRSUiFWLFR -DYLHU257,=*$5&Ì$ 8QLYHUVLGDG$XWyQRPDGH0DGULG 5HVXPHQ MDYLHURUWL]#XDPHV (VWHDUWtFXORSURSRQHEDViQGRVHHQWUDGXFFLRQHV\DSXEOLFDGDVWUHVPDQHUDVGH WUDGXFLU WH[WRV GH OLQJtVWLFD R UHODFLRQDGRV FRQ OD OLQJtVWLFD 3DUD HOOR QRV VHUYLPRVGHFXDWURWUDGXFFLRQHVGHFXDWUROLEURVHVFULWRVRULJLQDOPHQWHHQLQJOpV D VDEHU:RUGVDQG5XOHV3DODEUDV\UHJODVGH6WHYHQ3LQNHU/LQJXLVWLFV$Q ,QWURGXFWLRQ ,QWURGXFFLyQ D OD OLQJtVWLFD GH $QGUHZ 5DGIRUG HW DO 0HWDSKRUV :H /LYH %\ 0HWiIRUDV GH OD YLGD FRWLGLDQD GH *HRUJH /DNRII \ 0DUN -RKQVRQ \ 7KH /DQJXDJH ,QVWLQFW (O ,QVWLQWR GHO OHQJXDMH GH 6WHYHQ 3LQNHU6HJ~QODVHVWUDWHJLDVJHQHUDOHVOOHYDGDVDFDERSRUORVWUDGXFWRUHVHQODV GLVWLQWDVWUDGXFFLRQHVVHDQDOL]DQORVUHVXOWDGRVGHODVPLVPDV\VHSURSRQHXQD WHUPLQRORJtD SDUD UHFRQRFHU HVDV HVWUDWHJLDV OODPDPRV HVWUDWHJLD ©DJOXWL QDQWHªODOOHYDGDDFDERSRUHOWUDGXFWRUGH3DODEUDV\5HJODVHQFXDQWRTXHOR TXH SUHWHQGH IXQGDPHQWDOPHQWH HV PRVWUDU XQD LQYLVLELOLGDG FDVL FRPSOHWD FXDQGR WUDGXFH ORV HMHPSORV HPSOHDGRV HQ OD REUD D OODPDPRV HVWUDWHJLD ©SVHXGRDLVODQWHª OD HQFRQWUDGD HQ OD WUDGXFFLyQ GH /LQJXLVWLFV $Q ,QWURGXF WLRQSRUTXHHOWUDGXFWRUVHYDDOHMDQGRGHODLQYLVLELOLGDGFODUDPHQWHFRGLILFDGD HQODFDWHJRUtDDQWHULRUEHV ODHVWUDWHJLD©DLVODQWHªGHODWUDGXFFLyQ 0HWi IRUDVGHODYLGDFRWLGLDQDGRQGHHOWUDGXFWRUVHKDFHPiVYLVLEOHTXHHQODVHVWUD WHJLDVDQWHULRUHVGHVGHWRGRVORVSXQWRVGHYLVWDDXQTXHHVSHFLDOPHQWHDODKRUD GHODWUDGXFFLyQGHORVHMHPSORVHPSOHDGRVSRU/DNRII\-RKQVRQFSRU~OWLPR ORTXHKHPRVGDGRHQOODPDUHVWUDWHJLD©VXSHUDLVODQWHªVHFRORFDHQHOH[WUHPR RSXHVWRGH3DODEUDV\5HJODVWRGRVORVHMHPSORVDXQTXHQRVyORHVRVHWUDGX FHQ©DGDSWDGRVªDODOHQJXDHVSDxRODGHPDQHUDTXHHOWH[WRHVSDxRO\HOLQJOpV DSHQDV VL HQFXHQWUDQ SXQWRV FRQYHUJHQWHV GHVGH HO SXQWR GH YLVWD WUDGXFWROy JLFR /DV FXDWUR HVWUDWHJLDV GHVDUUROODGDV SRU ORV WUDGXFWRUHV GH ODV REUDV DQDOL]DGDVTXHGDQDPSOLDPHQWHLOXVWUDGDVFRQH[WUDFWRVGHORVWH[WRVHQFXHVWLyQ ,QWURGXFFLyQ (OSUHVHQWHHVWXGLRSUHWHQGHKDFHUXQDSHTXHxDDSRUWDFLyQDOFDPSRGHODSUiFWLFD GH OD WUDGXFFLyQ \ SDUD HOOR QRV VHUYLUHPRV GH YDULDV WUDGXFFLRQHV GH WH[WRV GH OLQJtVWLFDRUHODFLRQDGRVFRQODOLQJtVWLFD/DVHOHFFLyQGHHVWRVWH[WRVYLHQHGHOD (Q5LFDUGR0XxR]0DUWtQHG,$,(7,$FWDVGHO,&RQJUHVR,QWHUQDFLRQDOGHOD$VRFLDFLyQ,EpULFDGH(VWXGLRVGH7UDGXF FLyQH,QWHUSUHWDFLyQ*UDQDGDGHIHEUHURGH*UDQDGD$,(7,9RO,SS,6%1$,(7, -D Y LH U2 UW L ] *DU Ft D H[SHULHQFLDSURSLD GH WUDGXFLUXQWH[WRGH HVWHWLSR\GHODVLPXOWiQHDGRFXPHQ WDFLyQOOHYDGDDFDERTXHFDGDWUDGXFFLyQUHTXLHUH(OWH[WRSULQFLSDODOTXHKDUH PRVUHIHUHQFLDHV:RUGVDQG5XOHV7KH,QJUHGLHQWVRI/DQJXDJHGH6WHYHQ3LQNHUORV WH[WRVTXHQRVKDQVHUYLGRGHXQPRGRXRWURGHUHIHUHQFLD\DVHYHUiPiVDGH ODQWHFyPR\TXHVRQORVTXHVHYDQDXWLOL]DUHQHVWHHVWXGLRVRQFRQVXVUHVSHF WLYDV WUDGXFFLRQHV DO HVSDxRO 0HWDSKRUV :H /LYH %\ GH *HRUJH /DNRII \ 0DUN -RKQVRQ/LQJXLVWLFV$Q,QWURGXFWLRQGH$QGUHZ5DGIRUG0DUWLQ$WNLQVRQ'DYLG %ULWDLQ+DUDOG&ODKVHQ\$QGUHZ6SHQFHU\7KH/DQJXDJH,QVWLQFWGHO \DPHQFLR QDGR6WHYHQ3LQNHU (OHVStULWXGHHVWHDQiOLVLVHVPHUDPHQWHREVHUYDGRUFRPSDUDWLYR\SUHWHQGLGD PHQWHFRQVWUXFWLYRHQQLQJ~QFDVRVHWUDWDGHFULWLFDUJUDWXLWDPHQWHODVWUDGXFFLR QHVTXHVHHVWXGLDQQLGHRIUHFHUYHUVLRQHVDOWHUQDWLYDVGHORTXHVHKDWUDGXFLGRHQ ODVYHUVLRQHVDQDOL]DGDV(VSRUHOORTXHHODQiOLVLVHVWiHQIRFDGRIXQGDPHQWDOPHQWH D ODVHVWUDWHJLDVJHQHUDOHVTXHHOWUDGXFWRUDGRSWyHQVXPRPHQWRDOHQIUHQWDUVHDO WH[WR WHQLHQGR HQ FXHQWD FODUR HVWi HO WLSR WH[WXDO TXH WHQtD HQWUH ODV PDQRV /DV DOXVLRQHVDHMHPSORVFRQFUHWRVGHFDGDXQDGHODVWUDGXFFLRQHVGHORVFXDWURWH[WRV HVWXGLDGRV VH DQWRMD LQHYLWDEOH SHUR VLHPSUH HVWDUiQ HQIRFDGDV KDFLD ORV DVSHFWRV HVWUDWpJLFRV JHQHUDOHV GHO WUDEDMR GHO WUDGXFWRU 7DPSRFR VH SUHWHQGH KDFHU XQ HVWXGLR LQWURVSHFWLYRGH ODVGLIHUHQWHV FRUULHQWHVRDSUR[LPDFLRQHVDO HVWXGLRGHOD OLQJtVWLFDSHUVH DXQTXHHVRVtODVHOHFFLyQGHWH[WRVKDTXHULGRWDPELpQFXEULUXQ HVSHFWUR TXH DXQTXH UHGXFLGtVLPR FRPSDUDGR FRQ OD DPSOLD JDPD GH GLVFLSOLQDV UHODFLRQDGDV FRQ OD OLQJtVWLFD H[LVWHQWHV KR\ GtD VHD PtQLPDPHQWH UHSUHVHQWDWLYR GHORTXHVHSXHGHHQFRQWUDUHOOHFWRUQRDYH]DGRHQODPDWHULD\SRUH[WHQVLyQOR TXH HO OHFWRU HVSDxRO WLHQH D VX GLVSRVLFLyQ HQ VX OHQJXD $Vt HQFRQWUDPRV TXH HO WH[WRGH5DGIRUGHWDO UHSUHVHQWDXQDDPHQD\HORFXHQWHLQWURGXFFLyQDODOLQJtVWLFD HVFULWDGHVGHXQSXQWRGHYLVWDHPLQHQWHPHQWHWHyULFRODVGRVREUDVGH3LQNHUQRV PXHVWUDQHQWUHRWUDVFRVDVHOHVWDGRGHODFXHVWLyQGHORVHVWXGLRVGHSVLFROLQJtV WLFD HQ JHQHUDO \ PiV FRQFUHWDPHQWH GH ODV QXHYDV WHFQRORJtDV QHXURFLHQWtILFDV DSOLFDGDV DO HVWXGLR OHQJXDMH SRU ~OWLPR HO PiV FOiVLFR OLEUR GH /DNRII \ -RKQVRQ WUDWD HO WHPD GHO HPSOHR GHO VLJQLILFDGR UHODFLRQDGR FRQ RWURV DVSHFWRV GH OD YLGD FRWLGLDQDFRPRODSROtWLFDHOWUDEDMRRHODPRU 6LKD\DOJRHQFRP~QHQORVFXDWUROLEURV\VXVWUDGXFFLRQHVTXHVHYDQDHV WXGLDUHVHOSUROtILFRXVRGHHMHPSORVTXHLOXVWUDQWRGRORH[SXHVWRHQORVPLVPRV OyJLFRHQHVFULWRVGHHVWDQDWXUDOH]DDXQTXHFXULRVDPHQWHpVWHHVHODVSHFWRGRQ GH PiV GLILHUHQ ODV FXDWUR YHUVLRQHV HQ HVSDxRO /RV FXDWUR WUDGXFWRUHV PDQHMDQ HVRV HMHPSORV HQ HVSDxRO TXH QR ORV REMHWLYRV RULJLQDOHV GH HVRV HMHPSORV GH PRGRV \ PDQHUDV ELHQ GLIHUHQWHV 9HDPRV HQ 0HWiIRUDV GH OD YLGD FRWLGLDQD 0HWi IRUDV D SDUWLU GH DKRUD \ (O LQVWLQWR GHO OHQJXDMH ,QVWLQWR FDVL WRGRV ORV HMHPSORV DSDUHFHQ HQ HVSDxRO HQ XQRV FDVRV WUDGXFLGRV \ HQ RWURV DGDSWDGRV \D YHUHPRV PiVDGHODQWHTXpHQWHQGHPRVDTXtSRU©WUDGXFLGRª\©DGDSWDGRªHQ,QWURGXFFLyQ D OD/LQJtVWLFD,QWURGXFFLyQ \3DODEUDV\UHJODV3DODEUDVODHVWUDWHJLDGHORVWUDGXF WRUHVKDUHVSHWDGRFDVLVLHPSUHODLQFOXVLyQGHORVHMHPSORVHQODOHQJXDH[WUDQMHUD TXHDSDUHFH HQ HO RULJLQDOLQJOpV HQ ODPD\RUtDGHORV FDVRVDXQTXH QR HQWRGRV 196 7UDGXFLU/LQJtVWLFD:RUGVDQG5XOHVGH6WHYHQ3LQNHUXQFDVRSUiFWLFR HOORVFRQ H[SOLFDFLRQHVDGDSWDFLRQHV RWUDGXFFLRQHVVHJ~QODVQHFHVLGDGHVGHOD WUDGXFFLyQ\GHOOHFWRUDOTXHYDGLULJLGD HVDWUDGXFFLyQ3RUVXSXHVWRTXH HQORV GRV JUXSRV HQ ORV TXH \D KHPRV GLYLGLGR ORV FXDWURV WH[WRV DSDUHFHQ YDULDEOHV HVWUDWpJLFDVGHWUDGXFFLyQGHPD\RURPHQRUHQMXQGLDTXHLUHPRVDQDOL]DQGRDOR ODUJRGHOHVWXGLR3RUHMHPSORHQ0HWiIRUDVVHLQFOX\HQDOJXQDVQRWDVGHODWUDGXF WRUD D SLH GH SiJLQD TXH H[SOLFDQ MXVWLILFDQ \ DSR\DQ ODV GHFLVLRQHV WRPDGDV HQ ,QVWLQWR ODVHVFDVDVQRWDVGHOWUDGXFWRUHQQLQJ~QFDVRVHKDQLQFOXLGRFRQHVWHILQ (Q,QWURGXFFLyQ ODWUDGXFWRUDVHYLRREOLJDGDDWUDGXFLUDO HVSDxRODOJXQRVGHORV HMHPSORVGHVHFFLRQHVFRPSOHWDVVLQLQFOXLUHORULJLQDOFRPRDTXpOODVHQODVTXHORV DXWRUHV GHO RULJLQDO SURSRQHQ DO OHFWRU XQRV HMHUFLFLRV VREUH OR H[SXHVWR HQ HVH FDStWXOR SRU ~OWLPR HO WUDGXFWRU GH 3DODEUDV QR VH HQFRQWUy FRQ HVWH SUREOHPD SHURVtDOJ~QRWURSDUHFLGRFRPRHQHOFDVRGHODQRWUDGXFFLyQGHODVWLUDVFyPL FDVTXHHODXWRUHVSDUFHSRUWRGRHOOLEUR (VWUDWHJLDDJOXWLQDQWH3DODEUDV\UHJODV 3DODEUDV\UHJODV ODWUDGXFFLyQVREUHODTXHEDVDPRVHVWHHQVD\RHVXQHVWXGLRGH XQIHQyPHQROLQJtVWLFRUHODWLYDPHQWHFRQRFLGRORVYHUERVUHJXODUHVHLUUHJXODUHV GHOLQJOpVYLVWRGHVGHP~OWLSOHVSXQWRVGHYLVWDFX\DILQDOLGDG~OWLPDHVPRVWUDU FyPR HO OHQJXDMH \ SRU H[WHQVLyQ OD PHQWH KXPDQD WLHQH GRV IXQFLRQDPLHQWRV SHUIHFWDPHQWHGHOLPLWDGRV\VHSDUDGRVDVDEHUODVSDODEUDVYHUERVLUUHJXODUHV\ ODVUHJODVUHJXODUHV (QODHGLFLyQHVSDxROD\DPRGRGH H[SOLFDFLyQ VHLQFOX\H XQD QRWD TXH SUHWHQGH D\XGDU \ DFODUDU DO OHFWRU HO SURFHGLPLHQWR WUDGXFWROyJLFR OOHYDGR D FDER \ TXH TXL]i VHD OR TXH GLVWLQJXH HVWD WUDGXFFLyQ GH ODV RWUDV WUHV DUULEDPHQFLRQDGDV3LQNHU 1RWDDODHGLFLyQHVSDxROD $QWH OD GLILFXOWDG TXH VXSRQH YHUWHU DO HVSDxRO XQD REUD GH OLQJtVWLFD LQJOHVDFRQHMHPSORVFDVLH[FOXVLYDPHQWHHQLQJOpVVHUiFRQYHQLHQWHDFODUDU XQD VHULH GH SXQWRV VREUH HO PRGHOR GH WUDEDMR HPSOHDGR HQ OD SUHVHQWH WUDGXFFLyQ 6HKDRSWDGRSRUPLQLPL]DUHOQ~PHURGHQRWDVGHOWUDGXFWRUDSLHGH SiJLQD FRQ REMHWR GH HYLWDUOH DO OHFWRU XQD FRQWLQXD LQWHUUXSFLyQ GHO KLOR GHO WH[WR JHQHUDO (Q VX PD\RUtD ORV HMHPSORV GH 6WHYHQ 3LQNHU HVWiQ FRQYHQLHQWHPHQWH FRQWH[WXDOL]DGRV \ XQD H[SOLFDFLyQ GH ORV PLVPRV QR KDUtDVLQRUHVWDUIOXLGH]DODOHFWXUD1RREVWDQWHHQDOJXQRVSRFRVFDVRV VH KD DxDGLGR XQD QRWD DFODUDWRULD FRQ XQ HMHPSOR VLPLODU GH OD OHQJXD HVSDxROD &RPR QRUPD JHQHUDO WRGRV ORV HMHPSORV GHO OLEUR VH PDQWLHQHQ HQ OD OHQJXD HQ TXH DSDUHFHQ HQ HO WH[WR RULJLQDO FRQ OD WUDGXFFLyQ HQWUH SDUpQWHVLV\HQWUHFRPLOODGRVLPSOHDSHVDUGHTXHHQDOJXQRVGHORVFDVRV HODVSHFWRVHPiQWLFRGHORVPLVPRVQRVHDUHOHYDQWH 197 -D Y LH U2 UW L ] *DU Ft D /D PD\RUtD GH ODV FLWDV DSDUHFH ~QLFDPHQWH HQ VX YHUVLyQ WUDGXFLGD H[FHSWRHQDTXHOORVFDVRVHQORVTXHHORULJLQDODSRUWDDVSHFWRVUHOHYDQWHV\ GH GLItFLO FRPSUHQVLyQ HQ HVD OHQJXD HQ FX\R FDVR VH LQFOX\HQ ODV GRV YHUVLRQHV3RU~OWLPRDOJXQDVFLWDV\HMHPSORVDSDUHFHQVyORHQLQJOpVFRQ EUHYHVH[SOLFDFLRQHVDFHUFDGHODVSHFWRVXEUD\DGRSRUHODXWRUHQHOXVRGH ORVPLVPRV 3DUD QXHVWUR DQiOLVLV OR TXH GH YHUGDG QRV LQWHUHVD HV TXp KDFHU FRQ ORV YHUERV UHJXODUHVHLUUHJXODUHVLQJOHVHVHQODYHUVLyQHVSDxROD<DXQTXHSDUH]FDSDUDGy MLFR GH ODV FXDWUR WUDGXFFLRQHV PHQFLRQDGDV pVWD VHJXUDPHQWH VHD OD TXH PHQRV SUREOHPDV FUHD DO WUDGXFWRU SRUTXH QR SDUHFH KDEHU RWUD DOWHUQDWLYD TXH QR VHD LQFOXLU WRGDV \ FDGD XQD GH ODV IRUPDV YHUEDOHV TXH 3LQNHU HPSOHD SDUD DOFDQ]DU VXV FRQFOXVLRQHV 3RU HMHPSOR \D HQ HO SUHIDFLR GHO OLEUR HO DXWRU KDEOD GH ORV HUURUHVWtSLFRVTXHORVQLxRVFRPHWHQFXDQGRHPSLH]DQDIRUPDURUDFLRQHVGHPiV GHWUHVSDODEUDVKROGHG\ EUHDNHGHQOXJDUGHORVFRUUHFWRVKHOG\ EURNH %LHQSRGUtD HO WUDGXFWRU HQFRQWUDU HMHPSORV SDUHFLGRV HQ HVSDxRO URPSLGR \ KDFLGR SRU HMHPSOR SHUR FODUR OD LUUHJXODULGDG YHUEDO HQ LQJOpV WLHQH XQRV FRQGLFLRQDQWHV KLVWyULFRV IRQROyJLFRV \ VLQWiFWLFRV TXH QR WLHQHQ FDVL QDGD TXH YHU FRQ OD GH ORV YHUERVHQHVSDxROTXL]iPiVLPSRUWDQWHTXHHVWDVGLIHUHQFLDVHYLGHQWHVHVTXHOD KLSyWHVLV GHO OLEUR YHUVD VREUH HVD LUUHJXODULGDG \ VXV SHFXOLDULGDGHV HQ LQJOpV \ HQ FRQVHFXHQFLD SDUHFH TXH DO WUDGXFWRU QR OH TXHGD RWUD RSFLyQ TXH LQFOXLU ORV YHUERVHQLQJOpVFRQODWUDGXFFLyQDOHVSDxROGHORVPLVPRVSDUDIDFLOLWDUDOOHFWRU VXFRPSUHQVLyQ9HDPRVXQHMHPSORVHQFLOOR3LQNHU PHHWPHW ULQJUDQJ EHDUERUH VWHDOVWROH EUHDNEURNH /DWUDGXFFLyQGLFH YHUVXV YHUVXV YHUVXV YHUVXV YHUVXV PHWHPHWHG ZULQJZUXQJ EDUHEDUHG VWHHOVWHHOHG EUDNHEUDNHG PHHWPHW¶HQFRQWUDU· IUHQWHD PHWHPHWHG¶UHSDUWLU· ULQJUDQJ¶OODPDU· IUHQWHD ZULQJZUXQJ¶UHWRUFHU· EHDUERUH¶OOHYDU· IUHQWHD EDUHEDUHG¶UHYHODU· VWHDOVWROH¶UREDU· IUHQWHD VWHHOVWHHOHG¶DFHUDU· EUHDNEURNH¶URPSHU·IUHQWHD EUDNHEUDNHG¶IUHQDU· (O OHFWRU SRGUtD SUHJXQWDUVH TXp DSRUWD HO VLJQLILFDGR GH FDGD XQR GH ORV YHUERV LQJOHVHV HQ HVSDxRO \ OD UHVSXHVWD SRGUtD LU HQ FXDOTXLHUD GH ODV GRV GLUHFFLRQHV SRVLEOHVORTXHVtHVWiFODURHVTXHHOWUDGXFWRUKDGHUHVROYHUDVXQWRVEDVWDQWHPiV FRPSOLFDGRVTXHpVWHLQWHQWDQGRVHJXLUODPLVPDHVWUDWHJLDTXHHQHOHMHPSORDQWH ULRUHVGHFLULQFOX\HQGRODWUDGXFFLyQRODHODERUDFLyQGHXQDH[SOLFDFLyQTXHHQ HOFDVRGHORVYHUERVUHJXODUHVHLUUHJXODUHVLQJOHVHVQRKDOXJDU&RQWRGDVHJXUL GDGDOWUDGXFWRUGHHVWHWH[WRQROHUHVXOWDQDGDVHQFLOORHQFRQWUDUODFRKHUHQFLDGH 198 7UDGXFLU/LQJtVWLFD:RUGVDQG5XOHVGH6WHYHQ3LQNHUXQFDVRSUiFWLFR ODHVWUDWHJLDGHODWUDGXFFLyQ SRUTXHDOJXQRGHORV HMHPSORV UD\DQOD©LQWUDGXFL ELOLGDGªGHODTXHWDQWRVHKDHVFULWRHQORV~OWLPRVDxRV(OVLJXLHQWHHMHPSOR\VX QRWUDGXFFLyQLOXVWUDQDODSHUIHFFFLyQHOWHQXHFDPELRGHHVWUDWHJLDGHOWUDGXFWRU TXH PiV DGHODQWH FRPHQWDUHPRV GLFH HO WH[WR HQ LQJOpV DO KLOR GHO XVR GH OD SDODEUDJURZ\VXIRUPDGHSDVDGR3LQNHU 7236< ´,QWKHDEVHQFHRIVXFKUHRUJDQL]DWLRQWKHFLW\VFRXUWVWUXFWXUHDVDZKROHKDVMXVW ¶JURZHG· OLNH 7RSV\µ ´/LNH 7RSV\ WKDW *RYHUQPHQWKHOG VXUSOXV RI IDUP FRPPRGLWLHV ¶MXVW NHHSV JURZLQJ·µ 2QFH DQG IRU DOO 7RSV\V H[DFW ZRUGV SXQFWXDWHG YDULRXVO\ LQ GLIIHUHQW HGLWLRQV DQG LQ GLIIHUHQW ERRNV RI TXRWDWLRQV ZHUH´,VSHFW,JURZGµ1R´MXVWµQR´MHV·µQR´JURZLQ·µQRQXIILQ·$Q\ZD\ 7RSV\4XHHQRIWKH&OLFKpVVKRXOGGURSGHDG6HH&OLFKpV (Q OD YHUVLyQ HVSDxROD pVWH HMHPSOR QR DSDUHFH WUDGXFLGR \ Vt EUHYHPHQWH LQWURGXFLGRDQWHVGHVXDSDULFLyQ (QWUHVXVHMHPSORVVHHQFXHQWUDQEORZHGNQRZHGWKURZHG¶ODQ]y·GUDZHG\ JURZHG FDVR pVWH TXH VH KL]R IDPRVR SRU HO SHUVRQDMH +DUULHW %HHFKHU 6WRZH GHO OLEUR 8QFOH 7RPV &DELQ 7KHRGRUH %HUQVWHLQ HQ 7KH &DUHIXO :ULWHU FRPHQWD VREUHODVSDODEUDVGH+DUULHWWDQDPHQXGRFLWDGDV 7236< ´,QWKHDEVHQFHRIVXFKUHRUJDQL]DWLRQ>@µ $QWHODFDVLLPSRVLELOLGDGGHWUDVODGDUORTXHHODXWRUTXLHUHPRVWUDUDVXVOHFWRUHV SRUTXHHOHVSDxROQRSRVHHHVRVUDVJRVYHUEDOHVGLIHUHQFLDGRUHVHQSDUWLFXODUHO WUDGXFWRU RSWD SRU OD LQWURGXFFLyQ GHO HMHPSOR VXSRQLHQGR XQRV FRQRFLPLHQWRV EiVLFRVGHLQJOpVSRUSDUWHGHOOHFWRU6LQHPEDUJRQRVLHPSUHVXFHGHDVtSRUTXH HQDOJXQRVRWURVFDVRVHQORVTXHODWUDGXFFLyQWDPELpQRIUHFtDGLILFXOWDGHVSDUHFL GDV HO WUDGXFWRU Vt TXH KD SRGLGR FRQFLOLDU ODV GLIHUHQFLDV LQFOX\HQGR HO WH[WR HQ HVSDxRO3LQNHU ´,WRXJKWGHSHVWWLPH¶ELWH·VKRXOGEH²¶ERWH·µ 0LVV0LWQLFNJDYHDOLWWOHJDVS ´%RWH·"µ0U3DUNKLOODVNHGLQDPD]HPHQW´·%RWH·"µ ´%RWH·µVDLG0U.DSODQ 0U3DUNKLOOVKRRNKLVKHDG´,GRQWVHH\RXUSRLQWµ ´9HOOµVLJKHG0U.DSODQZLWKDPRGHVWVKUXJ´LILWLV¶ZULWHZURWHZULWWHQ·VR Y\LVQW¶ELWHERWHELWWHQ"µ 3V\FKLFF\PEDOVFUDVKHGLQ0U3DUNLOOVHDUV ´7KHUH LV QR VXFK D ZRUG ERWHµ SURWHVWHG 0LVV 0LWQLFN ZKR WRRN WKLV DOO DV D SHUVRQDODIIURQW+HUYRLFHZDVVPDOOEXWGHVSHUDWH ´1RWVXFKDYRLGµ 0U .DSODQ UHSHDWHG LURQLFDOO\ ´0LQH GHDU 0LWQLFN GRQW , NQRZLVQRWVRFKD YRLG"'LG,VD\LVVRFK DYRLG"$OO,PHVNLQNLVLVQWORJLFDO VKRXOGEHVRFKDYRLG"µ 199 -D Y LH U2 UW L ] *DU Ft D ¶³&UHtDTXHHOSDVDGRGHELWHGHEHUtDVHUERWH /DVHxRULWD0LWQLFNGLRXQSHTXHxRVXVSLUR ³¢%RWH" ³SUHJXQWyVRUSUHQGLGRHOVHxRU3DUNKLOO ³6tERWH³ FRQWHVWy.DSODQ ³1RHQWLHQGRORTXHGLFHV³GLMR3DUNKLOOPRYLHQGRODFDEH]D ³%XHQR³ VXVSLUy .DSODQ FRQ XQ OHYH PRYLPLHQWR GH KRPEURV³ VL HV ZULWHZURWHZULWWHQ ¢SRUTXpQRELWHERWHELWWHQ" &tPEDORVSVtTXLFRVLUUXPSLHURQHQORVRtGRVGH3DUNKLOO ³1RH[LVWHODSDODEUDERWH³ SURWHVWy0LWQLFNTXHVHORKDEtDWRPDGRFRPR XQDDIUHQWDSHUVRQDO6XYR]VRQDEDGpELO\GHVHVSHUDGD ³£4Xp QR H[LVWH OD SDODEUD ERWH³ UHSLWLy LUyQLFDPHQWH .DSODQ³ 0L TXHULGD 0LWQLFN ¢VH FUHH TXH QR Vp TXH HVD SDODEUD QR H[LVWH" ¢+H GLFKR TXHH[LVWDHVDSDODEUD"/RTXHGLJRHVTXH¢QRVHUtDOyJLFRTXHH[LVWLHUDHVD SDODEUD"· &ODURHVWiTXHVHSLHUGHJUDQSDUWHGHOVDERUGHORULJLQDOSRUHMHPSORODLPLWDFLyQ GHODFHQWRGHPXFKRVKDEODQWHVGHKHEUHRTXHDSUHQGHQLQJOpVSHURHOOHFWRUHVSD xRO VXSXHVWDPHQWH FDSWD SHUIHFWDPHQWH OR TXH HO RULJLQDO SUHWHQGH ORJUDU FRQ OD LOXVWUDFLyQ \D TXH DQWHV GH LQWURGXFLU HO HMHPSOR FRQ VX FRUUHVSRQGLHQWH WUDGXF FLyQVHOHDGYLHUWHGHTXHVHWUDWDGH©XQHPLJUDQWHMXGtRTXHDSUHQGHLQJOpVGHV SXpVGHOWUDEDMRTXHKDEODFRQVXWtSLFRDFHQWRª /OHJDGRVDHVWHSXQWRFRPSUREDPRVTXHORH[SOLFDGRHQODQRWDDFODUDWRULDGH OD WUDGXFFLyQ GH :RUGV DQG 5XOHV VH WUDVODGD D ORV HMHPSORV SUHVHQWDGRV \ TXH VH UHVXPHQHQWUHVFDVRVGLIHUHQWHV D $TXpOORV HQ ORV TXH DSDUHFH HO WH[WR LQJOpV R GH FXDOTXLHU RWUD OHQJXD FRQ VX FRUUHVSRQGLHQWH WUDGXFFLyQ DO HVSDxRO (VWH SULPHU DSDUWDGR OR FRPSRQHQ IXQGDPHQWDOPHQWH ORV YHUERV UHJXODUHV H LUUHJXODUHV LQJOH VHVTXHDSDUHFHQHQODREUD E $TXpOORV HQ ORV TXH HO DXWRU GHO WH[WR IXHQWH HPSOHD HMHPSORV GH FDVL LPSRVLEOHFRPSUHQVLyQSDUDHOOHFWRUHVSDxROVLQXQDH[SOLFDFLyQIXHUDGH ODWUDGXFFLyQ(QHVWRVFDVRVODWUDGXFFLyQGHMDHOHMHPSORHQLQJOpVRHQ RWUD OHQJXD VLQ WUDGXFFLyQ DOJXQD OD H[SOLFDFLyQ D OD TXH DQWHV OODPi EDPRV©DGDSWDFLyQªGHVHPSHxDHOSDSHODFODUDWRULRHQODWUDGXFFLyQ F 3RU ~OWLPR DTXHOORV FDVRV HQ ORV TXH HO WH[WR GH OOHJDGD SHUPLWH OD LQFOXVLyQGHOWH[WR IXHQWH HQLQJOpV R HQ RWUDOHQJXDFRQODWUDGXFFLyQ FRUUHVSRQGLHQWH/DGLIHUHQFLD HQWUHORV HMHPSORVGHHVWH DSDUWDGR \ORV GHDUDGLFDHQTXHHQDTXpOODVLOXVWUDFLRQHVGHOWH[WRIXHQWHQRYDQPiV DOOiGHXQYHUERVUHJXODUHVRLUUHJXODUHV\HQpVWHQRVHQIUHQWDPRVD XQWH[WRPiVRPHQRVODUJR 200 7UDGXFLU/LQJtVWLFD:RUGVDQG5XOHVGH6WHYHQ3LQNHUXQFDVRSUiFWLFR (VWUDWHJLDVDLVODQWHV,QWURGXFFLyQDODOLQJtVWLFD0HWiIRUDVGHOD YLGDFRWLGLDQDH ,QVWLQWRGHOOHQJXDMH (VWUDWHJLDSVHXGRDLVODQWH 9HDPRV D FRQWLQXDFLyQ \ D PRGR FRPSDUDWLYR TXp VXFHGH HQ FDVRV SDUHFLGRV HQFRQWUDGRVHQODVRWUDVWUHVWUDGXFFLRQHVPHQFLRQDGDVDQWHV4XL]iODWUDGXFFLyQ TXHPiVVHDFHUFDDODGH3DODEUDVGHVGHHOSXQWRGHYLVWDHVWUDWpJLFRVHD,QWURGXF FLyQ HQ FXDQWR TXH HQ DOJXQRV GH ORV FDVRV VH LQWHQWD DJOXWLQDU ODV VROXFLRQHV H[SOLFLWDGDV HQ OD VHFFLyQDQWHULRUDXQTXH HQ OD PD\RUtDGH HOORVODWUDGXFWRUDVH GHFDQWDSRUOR TXHDOOtWLSLILFDPRVFRPRD HVGHFLUODLQFOXVLyQHQODWUDGXFFLyQ GHO HMHPSOR GHO WH[WR IXHQWH FRQ VX FRUUHVSRQGLHQWH WUDGXFFLyQ VLQ PHGLDFLyQ GH QLQJXQD©DGDSDWDFLyQªDGLFLRQDO4XL]iSRUHOORWDPELpQSRGUtDPRVGHQRPLQDUOD FRPRODPHQRVSXUDGHODVHVWUDWHJLDVDLVODQWHVGHODVTXHKDEODPRVHQHVWDVHFFLyQ ©SVHXGRDLVODQWHª/RVGRVVLJXLHQWHVHMHPSORVPXHVWUDQHVWDSHTXHxDYDULDQWHD ODKRUDGHUHVROYHUORVSUREOHPDVTXHSODQWHDHOWH[WRIXHQWH $OKDEODUGHODVSURSLHGDGHVPRUIROyJLFDVGHORVYHUERVLQJOHVHVHOWH[WR LQJOpVGDFRPRHMHPSORVWUHVYHUERVHQVXIRUPDVLPSOHUHDGZULWH\IRUPDW TXH VH FRQYLHUWHQ HQ OD WUDGXFFLyQ HQ ©UHDG ¶OHHU· ZULWH ¶HVFULELU· \ IRUPDW ¶IRUPDWHDU·ª 5DGIRUG HV GHFLU OD PLVPD VROXFLyQ GH IRUPD\FRQWHQLGR\DSUHYLVWDHQHODSDUWDGRDGH3DODEUDV 6LQHPEDUJRXQSRFRDQWHVGHOHMHPSORDQWHULRU HQFRQWUDPRVHVWHRWURHQ HO TXH OODPD D SULPHUD YLVWD OD GLIHUHQWH VROXFLyQ GH OD WUDGXFWRUD HQ HO RULJLQDO KDEODQGR GH ODV FRQMXQFLRQHV FRRUGLQDQWHV DSDUHFHQ HVWRV VHQFL OORV HMHPSORV HQ LQJOpV ©QDXJKW\ EXW IXQQ\ª \ ©(XJHQH LV (QJOLVK EXW VSHDNV 6SDQLVKªTXHVHOHHQHQODWUDGXFFLyQVLPSOHPHQWHFRPR©WUDYLHVRSHURJUD FLRVRª \ ©(XJHQH HV LQJOpV SHUR KDEOD FDVWHOODQRª 5DWIRUG HV GHFLU OR TXH HQ ODWLSRJUDItDGH VROXFLRQHV HVWDEOHFLGD HQODWUDGXFFLyQGH 3DODEUDVVHUtDXQDSDUWDGRQXHYRHOG\DTXHDOOtQRDSDUHFtDHVDVROXFLyQ ¢4XpHVORTXHSXGROOHYDUDODWUDGXFWRUDGH,QWURGXFFLyQHQXQHVSDFLRWDQFRUWR UHFRUGHPRV TXH ORV HMHPSORV DSDUHFHQ FDVL MXQWRV \ OR TXH HV PiV LPSRUWDQWH WUDWiQGRVHGHFDVRVWDQSDUHFLGRVGHVGHHOSXQWRGHYLVWDGHODWUDGXFFLyQFDPELDU GH HVWUDWHJLD GH PDQHUD WDQ UDGLFDO" 'HVGH OXHJR TXH QR DSDUHQWD KDEHU VLGR OD QHJOLJHQFLD\VtODFRQVLGHUDFLyQGHTXHHQHOVHJXQGRGHORVHMHPSORVVHKDHQWHQ GLGRTXHODVGRVFRUWDVRUDFLRQHVHQLQJOpVQRVRQQHFHVDULDVSDUDODFRPSUHQVLyQ JHQHUDOGHOWH[WR\HQHOSULPHURVt\DTXHVHHVWiKDFLHQGRUHIHUHQFLDDODIRUPD FLyQPRUIROyJLFDGHORVYHUERVLQJOHVHVTXHQRHVLJXDOTXHODGHORVHVSDxROHV$ SHVDUGHTXHODPD\RUtDGHORVHMHPSORVHQFRQWUDGRVHQHVWDWUDGXFFLyQVHVROXFLR QD LQFOX\HQGR ORV HMHPSORV HQ LQJOpV FRQ VX WUDGXFFLyQ FRUUHVSRQGLHQWH HQ HVSDxROSRUORTXHpVWHTXHDTXtSUHVHQWDPRVHVXQDH[FHSFLyQRSUHFLVDPHQWH SRUHVRVXUJHODGXGD\ODGLIHUHQFLDFRQODWUDGXFFLyQGH3DODEUDV GHSRUTXpQR 201 -D Y LH U2 UW L ] *DU Ft D VH GHFLGLy LQFOXLU HQ HVWH FDVR WDPELpQ OD WUDGXFFLyQ $XQTXH \D VH KD GLFKR TXH ORV HMHPSORV TXH QR DSDUHFHQ HQ ODV GRV OHQJXDV VRQ ORV PHQRV HO OHFWRU SRGUtD SUHJXQWDUVHQRVLQUD]yQSRUTXpXQDVYHFHVVt\RWUDVQRWDQWR9HDPRVVLQRXQ ~OWLPRHMHPSORGHHVWDWUDGXFFLyQHQODTXHDOKDEODUGHDOJXQRVWUDVWRUQRVOp[LFRV DSDUHFLGRV HQ DGXOWRV FRQ 5HWUDVR HVSHFtILFR GHO OHQJXDMH VH GDQ ORV VLJXLHQWHV FDVRVFRQVXVWUDGXFFLRQHV D \RXJRWD WDSHUHFRUGHUV¶W~WLHQHVXQPDJQHWyIRQRV E WKHIRXUEXVJRLQ%RXFKHUYLOOH¶ORVFXDWURDXWRE~VYDQD%RXFKHUYLOOH· F WKHDPEXODQFHDUULYH¶ODDPEXODQFLDOOHJDU· 5DWIRUG ¢3RUTXpQRPDQWHQHUVyORHOHMHPSORHQHVSDxROVL\DVHKDKHFKRHQFDVRVDQWHULR UHVVXSXHVWDPHQWHFRQVLGHUDQGRTXHDOOHFWRUHVSDxROQROHDSRUWDQDGDODRUDFLyQ HQLQJOpV" (VWUDWHJLDDLVODQWH /D WUDGXFFLyQ GH 0HWiIRUDV WLHQH XQD HVWUDWHJLD GH WUDGXFFLyQ ELHQ GHILQLGD GHQWUR GHOPDUFRGHQRPLQDGR©DLVODQWHªWRGRVORVHMHPSORVHPSOHDGRVSRU/DNRII\-RKQ VRQHQVXVPHWiIRUDVGHODYLGDFRWLGLDQDKDQHQFRQWUDGRVXWUDGXFFLyQHQHVSDxRO SRUORTXHHOWH[WRHQLQJOpVQRDSDUHFHHQQLQJXQRGHORVFDVRVHVRVtHQDOJXQDV RFDVLRQHVWDOFRPRH[SOLFDQORVDXWRUHVGHOD©,QWURGXFFLyQªDODYHUVLyQHVSDxROD DOJXQRVGHORVHMHPSORVVXHQDQIRU]DGRVHQHVSDxRO\RWURVQRPXFKRVVRQSUiFWL FDPHQWHLQFRPSUHQVLEOHVSRUORTXHVHH[SOLFDODPHWiIRUDHQQRWDDSLHGHSiJLQD 'HO SULPHU WLSR GH PHWiIRUD OD TXH QR RIUHFH QLQJ~Q SUREOHPD DO OHFWRU HQFRQWUDPRV QXPHURVRV HMHPSORV FRPR FDVL WRGRV DTXpOORV UHODFLRQDGRV FRQ HO FDPSRVHPiQWLFRGHODPRU/DNRII\/DNRII /29(,6$3$7,(17 7KLV LV D VLFN UHODWLRQVKLS 7KH\ KDYH D VWURQJ KHDOWK\ PDUULDJH 7KH PDUULDJH LV GHDG LW FDQW EH UHYLYHG 7KHLU PDUULDJH LV RQ WKH PHQG 7KHLU UHODWLRQVKLSLVLQUHDOO\JRRGVKDSH (/$025(6813$&,(17( (V XQD UHODFLyQ HQIHUPD (O VX\R HV XQ PDWULPRQLR IXHUWH \ VDQR (O PDWULPRQLR HVWi PXHUWR QR VH OH SXHGH KDFHU UHYLYLU 6X PDWULPRQLR HVWi PHMRUDQGR 6XUHODFLyQHVWiUHDOPHQWHHQEXHQDIRUPD $TXHOODV WUDGXFFLRQHV TXH SXHGHQ SUHVHQWDU SUREOHPDV GH FRPSUHQVLyQ DO OHFWRU HVSDxRO\TXHHQODLQWURGXFFLyQGHQRPLQDEDQ©WUDGXFFLRQHVIRU]DGDVªVRQSRFR IUHFXHQWHVYHDPRVDOJXQDVGHHOODV (Q HO FDStWXOR GH VX OLEUR /DNRII \ -RKQVRQ KDFHQ UHIHUHQFLD H[SUHVD D OD JUDQ FDQWLGDG GH PHWiIRUDV TXH VH SXHGH HQFRQWUDU TXH UHODFLRQDQ ODV LGHDV FRQ RWURVFDPSRVVHPiQWLFRVPiVFRQFUHWRVSRUHMHPSORHPSDUHQWDQODVLGHDVFRQOD 202 7UDGXFLU/LQJtVWLFD:RUGVDQG5XOHVGH6WHYHQ3LQNHUXQFDVRSUiFWLFR FRPLGD GRQGH HQFRQWUDPRV XQ HMHPSOR TXH VREUHVDOH GHO UHVWR DQWH HO TXH OD WUDGXFWRUDGHFLGLyGDUXQDVROXFLyQLQWHUPHGLD'LFHHOWH[WRLQJOpV©:HGRQWQHHG WRVSRRQIHHGRXUVWXGHQWVª/DNRIITXHDSDUHFHWUDGXFLGRFRPR©1RWHQH PRVTXHGDUGHFRPHUWUDWDUFRPRQLxRVDQXHVWURVHVWXGLDQWHVª/DNRII (QRWURFDVRGHSDUHFLGDVROXFLyQVHHPSDUHQWDHODPRUFRQODJXHUUD©+HZRQKHU KDQGLQPDUULDJHª/DNRIISDVDD©&RQVLJXLyVXPDQRJDQyª/DNRII ,QGHSHQGLHQWHPHQWH GH TXH VHKXELHVH SRGLGREXVFDU DOJXQD DOWHUQDWLYD TXH QRV SHUPLWLHVH SDVDU HVWRV FDVRV DO JUXSR OD HVWUDWHJLD FRKHUHQWH GH OD WUDGXFWRUD QR DIHFWD HQ DEVROXWR OD FRPSUHQVLyQ GHO WH[WR \ PXFKR PHQRV LQWHUILHUHHQODIOXLGH]GHODOHFWXUD 4XL]iQR VHSXHGDGHFLUORPLVPRGHO~OWLPRWLSRGH VROXFLyQ HQFRQWUDGR HQ0HWiIRUDV HVWRTXLHUHGHFLUTXHHQORVHMHPSORVTXHVLJXHQODOHFWXUDVHYHLQWH UUXPSLGDSRUODLQVHUFLyQGHQRWDVH[SOLFDWLYDVDSLHGHSiJLQDTXHHOOHFWRURELHQ REYLDIUHFXHQWHDXQTXHSRFRHGLILFDQWHROHOOHYDDSDUDUVXOHFWXUDSDUDDFXGLUD ODOODPDGDGHODWUDGXFWRUD1RREVWDQWH\FRPRSUXHEDQORVHMHPSORVDFRQWLQXD FLyQ GHVWDFDGRV HVWD VROXFLyQ VH DQWRMD FRPR OD ~QLFD SRVLEOH +DEODQGR GHO WLHPSRFRPRFRQFHSWR/DNRII\-RKQVRQUHVDOWDQODHVWUXFWXUDFLyQGHOWLHPSRHQOD OHQJXDHQWpUPLQRVPHWDIyULFRVHQPRYLPLHQWR\SRUHVRGDQHVWHHMHPSOR©,ORRN IRUZDUGWRWKHDUULYDORI&KULVWPDVª/DNRIIDQWHHOTXHODWUDGXFWRUDQRWXYR RWUDRSFLyQTXHWUDGXFLUORFRPR©$QVtRODOOHJDGDGHOD1DYLGDGª/DNRII FRQODLQVHUFLyQGHXQDQRWDDSLHGHSiJLQDTXHOHHORVLJXLHQWH©/LWHUDOPHQWH©, ORRN IRUZDUG WR WKH DUULYDO RI &KULVWPDVª /D SUHSRVLFLyQ IRUZDUG VLJQLILFD ¶KDFLD GHODQWH·/DNRII$SHVDUGHTXHHOHVSDxROHVULFRHQPHWiIRUDVHQODVTXH HOGLQHURWLHQHVXFXRWDLPDJLQDULDODRUDFLyQ©/HWPHSXWLQP\WZRFHQWVZRUWKª /DNRIIQRHQFXHQWUDVXVLJQLILFDGRUHDOHQODWUDGXFFLyQ©3HUPtWDPHTXH DSRUWHPLVGRV FHQWDYRVª /DNRIISRUORTXHODQRWDH[SOLFDWLYD©HQHVSD xROVHGLUtDPiVSURSLDPHQWH´PLJUDQLWRGHDUHQDµªIXHUDGHOWH[WRVHKDFHDTXt LQFOXVRPiVQHFHVDULD (VWUDWHJLDVXSHUDLVODQWH (O~OWLPRFDVRTXHYDPRVDDQDOL]DUHVHOGHODWUDGXFFLyQGH7KH/DQJXDJH,QVWLQFW GH 6WHYHQ3LQNHU HOPLVPRDXWRUGH:RUGVDQG5XOHV OLEURFRQ HO TXH HPSH]iED PRVHVWHHVWXGLR'HVGHHOSXQWRGHYLVWDGHOSURFHVRGHODWUDGXFFLyQTXHDTXtQRV LQWHUHVDORVGRVOLEURVRIUHFHQFDUDFWHUtVWLFDVPX\VLPLODUHVDXQTXHTXL]iVRUSUHQ GHQWHPHQWH ODV VROXFLRQHV TXH ODV WUDGXFFLRQHV RIUHFHQ VRQ ELHQ GLIHUHQWHV (Q ,QVWLQWR HO WUDGXFWRU QR VH VLUYH GH QLQJXQD QRWD DFODUDWRULD DO FRPLHQ]R GH OD WUDGXFFLyQDXQTXHVtDSDUHFHQHVSDUFLGDVDOJXQDVQRWDVDSLHGHSiJLQD0HQFLR QDPRVODDXVHQFLDGHH[SOLFDFLRQHVGLULJLGDVDOOHFWRUSRUTXHODLQPHQVDPD\RUtD GH ORV HMHPSORV GHO WH[WR RULJHQ DSDUHFHQ QR WDQWR WUDGXFLGRV FRPR DGDSWDGRV DO HVSDxROELHQGHFLPRVDGDSWDGRVFRPRPXHVWUDHVWHFDVRHQHOTXH3LQNHUVHVLUYH GHODMHUJDGHOEpLVERO\PiVFRQFUHWDPHQWHGHODGH'L]]\'HDQIDPRVRFRPHQ WDULVWD GH OD FDGHQD &%6 DQWLJXR MXJDGRU GH EpLVERO \ HQ OD DFWXDOLGDG FRQRFLGR SRU VXV D YHFHV LQWHQFLRQDGDV ©LQH[DFWLWXGHVª OLQJtVWLFDV ,QFOXLPRV OD LQWURGXF 203 -D Y LH U2 UW L ] *DU Ft D FLyQFRQOD TXH3LQNHUDGRUQDODFLWDGH 'L]]L\'HDQ 3LQNHU\ODWUDGXF FLyQHVSDxROD3LQNHU 'L]]\'HDQWKH6W/RXLV&DUGLQDO·VSLWFKHUDQG&%6DQQRXQFHUZDVQRWRULRXVIRU VD\LQJ ´+H VORRG LQWR VHFRQG EDVHµ FRPPRQ LQ KLV QDWLYH $UNDQVDV )RU IRXU GHFDGHV(QJOLVKWHDFKHUVDFURVVWKHQDWLRQHQJDJHGLQDOHWWHUZULWLQJFDPSDLJQWR &%6GHPDQGLQJWKDWKHEHUHPRYHGPXFKWRKLVGHOLJKW>@2QFHKHEDLWHGWKHP ZLWKWKHIROORZLQJSOD\E\SOD\ ´7KH SLWFKHU ZRXQG XS DQG IODQJ WKH EDOO DW WKH EDWWHU 7KH EDWWHU VZDQJ DQG PLVVHG7KHSLWFKHUIODQJWKHEDOODJDLQDQGWKLVWLPHWKHEDWWHUFRQQHFWHG+HKLWD KLJKIO\ULJKWWRWKHFHQWHUILHOGHU7KHFHQWHUILHOGHUZDVDOOVHWWRFDWFKWKHEDOOEXW DWWKHODVWPLQXWHKLVH\HVZHUHEORXQGE\WKHVXQDQGKHGURSSHGLWµ 1RKDFHPXFKRRtGHFLUDXQIXWEROLVWDHQXQDVGHFODUDFLRQHVSRUWHOHYLVLyQ ©1RHVTXH\RFRQWUDGL]FDDOiUELWURª0XFKRVDFDGpPLFRVHLQWHOHFWXDOHVVH DIDQDQHQFULWLFDU S~EOLFDPHQWHHVWRV DEXVRVOLQJtVWLFRV LURQL]iQGRORVHQ IRUPDGHViWLUDVFRPRODVLJXLHQWH ©(O H[WUHPR DYDQ]XYR SRU OD EDQGD GHUHFKD FXDQGR HO GHIHQVD OH VDOLy DO SDVR(OGHODQWHURDQGyPX\OLVWRSDUDHYLWDUOD]DQFDGLOOD\DYDQ]XYRKDVWD OD OtQHD GH IRQGR (QWRQFHV FHQWUy KDFLD HO iUHD SHTXHxD GRQGH VH HQFRQWUDED HO GHODQWHUR FHQWUR eVWH GHWHQLy HO EDOyQ FRQ HO SHFKR \ VH GLVSXVLyDUHPDWDU6LQHPEDUJRHOSRUWHURDGYLUWRVXLQWHQFLyQ\VHHFKXYRD VXVSLHVIUXVWUDQGRODRFDVLyQGHJRO 6REUDQWRGRVORVFRPHQWDULRVH[FHSWRGRVGHUHODWLYDUHOHYDQFLDSDUDODWUDGXFFLyQ FRPR EXHQ SVLFROLQJLVWD 3LQNHU VH MDFWD GH OOHYDU VLHPSUH HQ HO EROVLOOR XQ OiSL] SDUD DSXQWDU WRGR DTXHOOR TXH FXDOTXLHU KDEODQWH SXHGD HQXQFLDU HQ FXDO TXLHUPRPHQWRHVGHFLUWRGRVVXVHMHPSORV\pVWHQRHVXQDH[FHSFLyQVRQUHDOHV HQ UHDOLGDG PXFKRV DILFLRQDGRV DO EpLVERO HVWDGRXQLGHQVHV FRQMXJDQ HO YHUER WR IOLQJ©HTXLYRFDGDPHQWHªIODQJHQOXJDUGHIOXQJHQVXIRUPDGHSDVDGRORTXH 3LQNHUTXLHUHLQGLFDUFRQVXHMHPSORHVSUHFLVDPHQWHTXHHVHXVRSUHWHQGLGDPHQWH HTXLYRFDGRQRORHVHQHOFRQWH[WRHQHOTXHVHSURGXFH1LQJXQDGHHVWDVGRVSUH PLVDVVHFXPSOHQHQHOFDVRGHODDGDSWDFLyQHVSDxRODSULPHURSRUTXHHOHMHPSOR QR DSDUHQWD VHU UHDO HQ HO VHQWLGR TXH OR HV HO LQJOpV \ HQ VHJXQGR OXJDU SRUTXH QDGLHQLVLTXLHUDORVIXWEROLVWDVVRQFDSDFHVGHHPSOHDUDYDQ]XYRRHFKXYR /DVLJXLHQWHLOXVWUDFLyQGHODWUDGXFFLyQGH,QVWLQWRWDPELpQKDEODSRUVtVROD HQ HO FDStWXOR HQ HO TXH 3LQNHU H[SOLFD HO IXQFLRQDPLHQWR GHO OHQJXDMH FLWD XQRV HMHPSORV VDFDGRV GHO &ROXPELD -RXUQDOLVP 5HYLHZ TXH OH VLUYHQ SDUD KDEODU GH OD HFRQRPtD \ OD DPELJHGDG OLQJtVWLFDV WDQ FRPXQHV HQ HO OHQJXDMH SHULRGtVWLFR 3LQNHU 1HZ+RXVLQJIRU(OGHUO\1RW<HW'HDG 1HZ0LVVRXUL8&KDQFHOORU([SHFWV/LWWOH6H[ RQ7KHLU:D\WR&UXLVH$PRQJ'HDGLQ3ODQH&UDVK 1--XGJHWR5XOHRQ1XGH%HDFK &KRX5HPDLQV&UHPDWHG 204 7UDGXFLU/LQJtVWLFD:RUGVDQG5XOHVGH6WHYHQ3LQNHUXQFDVRSUiFWLFR &KLQHVH$SHPDQ'DWHG +HUVKH\%DUV3URWHVW 5HDJDQ:LQVRQ%XGJHW%XW0RUH/LHV$KHDG 'HHU.LOOHG &RPSODLQWV$ERXW1%$5HIHUHHV*URZLQJ8JO\ /DWUDGXFFLyQHVSDxRODQRLQFOX\HWRGRVORVHMHPSORV\DTXHOORVTXHDSDUHFHQGL FHQORVLJXLHQWH3LQNHU 3UR\HFWRGHYLYLHQGDVSDUDDQFLDQRVD~QHQDFWLYR -XHFHVSURJUHVLVWDVVHPDQLILHVWDQDIDYRUGHOQXGLVPRSRUORV SDVLOORVGHOD$XGLHQFLD1DFLRQDO 'RFHSHUVRQDVFDPLQRGHXQFUXFHURHQWUHODVYtFWLPDVGHODFFLGHQWH GHDYLDFLyQ $QWURSRLGHGHVFXELHUWRHQ&KLQDFLWDGRHQHOFRQJUHVRGH DQWURSRORJtD /DPDQLIHVWDFLyQGH$XWRPyYLOHV5HQDXOWFRQJUHJDD 6DLQ]DKRJDHOFDUEXUDGRUHQORV0LO/DJRV\VHUHWLUDGHO0XQGLDO /RVGRFHHMHPSORVVHFRQYLHUWHQHQVHLVHQODYHUVLyQHVSDxROD\SRUVXSXHVWRQR LOXVWUDQQLGHOHMRVHODSDUDWRWHyULFRDOTXHDFRPSDxDQHQODYHUVLyQLQJOHVD¢1R VHSRGUtDKDEHUDFRPSDxDGRDODYHUVLyQHVSDxRODORVHMHPSORVHQLQJOpVFRQXQD EUHYHSHURDFODUDGRUDQRWDGHOWUDGXFWRUGHQWURRIXHUDGHOWH[WR" 3RU~OWLPRFDEHGHVWDFDUTXHXQDUHYLVLyQGHODELEOLRJUDItDHQODVGRVHGLFLR QHVGHOOLEURHQFXHVWLyQRULJLQDO\WUDGXFFLyQTXL]iQRVD\XGHWDQWRRPiVTXH ORVHMHPSORVDUULEDFRPHQWDGRVSDUDVDEHUGHTXpWLSRGHWUDGXFFLyQHVWDPRVKD EODQGRHQODYHUVLyQHVSDxRODDSDUHFHXQDREUDTXHHORULJLQDOGH3LQNHUQRFLWD VLQPHQRVFDERGHORTXHHVDHQWUDGDELEOLRJUiILFDSXHGDDSRUWDUDOOHFWRUHVSDxRO HOKHFKRHQVtPLVPRUDWLILFDTXHQRVHQFRQWUDPRVDQWHXQHMHPSORGHWUDGXFFLyQ TXHKDHPSOHDGRORTXHKHPRVGDGRHQOODPDU©HVWUDWHJLDVXSHUDLVODQWHª &RQFOXVLyQ /RV FXDWUR FDVRV GH WUDGXFFLyQ GH REUDV GH OLQJtVWLFD DQDOL]DGRV \ ODV GLIHUHQWHV HVWUDWHJLDVOOHYDGDVD FDERSRUORVWUDGXFWRUHVUHVSHFWLYRVSRQHQ GH PDQLILHVWROD FRPSOLFDGDODERUGHOWUDGXFWRUGHHVWHWLSRGH WH[WRV/DYLVLELOLGDGLQYLVLELOLGDG GHO WUDGXFWRU 9HQXWL VH PDQLILHVWD HQ ODV FXDWUR REUDV WUDGXFLGDV GH XQ PRGRSURJUHVLYRJUDGDFLyQTXHSRGUtDPRVHTXLSDUDGHODVLJXLHQWHPDQHUDVHJ~Q ODV FDWHJRUtDV DJOXWLQDQWHV R DLVODQWHV SURSXHVWDV /D FDWHJRUtD DJOXWLQDQWH GH OD WUDGXFFLyQGH3DODEUDVFRUUHVSRQGHUtDDODPD\RULQYLVLELOLGDGGHOWUDGXFWRUHQ FXDQWR TXH QR SUHWHQGH VLQR PDQWHQHU HO WH[WR IXHQWH OR PiV LQWDFWR SRVLEOH ODV FDWHJRUtDV DLVODQWHV VH YDQ DOHMDQGR GH OD LQYLVLELOLGDG GH PDQHUD SDXODWLQD \ SURJUHVLYD FRUUHVSRQGLHQGR OD PiV FHUFDQD D OD YLVLELOLGDG D OD GHQRPLQDGD 205 -D Y LH U2 UW L ] *DU Ft D SVHXGRDLVODQWHGH,QWURGXFFLyQTXHVHSRVLFLRQDHQXQDORFDOL]DFLyQFDVLHTXLGLV WDQWHGHODYLVLELOLGDG\ODLQYLVLELOLGDGODWUDGXFFLyQDLVODQWHGH0HWiIRUDVGDXQ SDVRKDFLDODYLVLELOLGDG\ODWDQJHQFLDOLGDGGHOWUDGXFWRUTXHFXOPLQDHQOD~OWLPD GHODVFDWHJRUtDVSURSXHVWDVSODVPDGDHQODWUDGXFFLyQGH7KH /DQJXDJH,QVWLQFW\ TXHKHPRVGHQRPLQDGRHVWUDWHJLDVXSHUDLVODQWH 5HIHUHQFLDV /$.2)) *HRUJH\0DUN-2+16210HWDSKRUV:H/LYH%\ &KLFDJR7KH8QLYHUVLW\RI &KLFDJR3UHVV ³0HWiIRUDVGHODYLGDFRWLGLDQD7UDG&DUPHQ*21=É/(=0$5Ì1 0DGULG&iWHGUD 3,1.(5 6WHYHQ 7KH /DQJXDJH,QVWLQFW+RZWKH 0LQG&UHDWHV /DQJXDJH 1XHYD<RUN 3HUHQQLDO&ODVVLFV ³\(OLQVWLQWRGHOOHQJXDMH&yPRFUHDHOOHQJXDMHODPHQWH7UDGGH-RVp0DQXHO ,*2$*21=É/(= 0DGULG$OLDQ]D(GLWRULDO ³:RUGVDQG5XOHV7KH,QJUHGLHQWVRI/DQJXDJH 1XHYD<RUN%DVLF%RRNV ³ 3DODEUDV \ UHJODV /RV LQJUHGLHQWHV GHO OHQJXDMH 7UDG GH -DYLHU 257,= *$5&Ì$ 0DGULG'HEDWH 5$')25' $QGUHZ 0DUWLQ $7.,1621 'DYLG %5,7$,1 +DUDOG &/$+6(1 \ $QGUHZ 63(1&(5 /LQJXLVWLFV$Q,QWURGXFWLRQ &DPEULGJH&DPEULGJH8QLYHUVLW\3UHVV ³ ,QWURGXFFLyQ D OD OLQJtVWLFD 7UDG GH 1XULD %(/ 5$)(&$6 0DGULG &DPEULGJH 8QLYHUVLW\3UHVV(VSDxD 9(187, /DZUHQFH 7KH 7UDQVODWRUV ,QYLVLELOLW\ $ +LVWRU\ RI 7UDQVODWLRQ /RQGUHV 5RXWOHGJH 206