+GFLA>A;A90FAN=JKA<9<9L]DA;9<=19DH9J9YKG "9;MDL9<<=%F?=FA=JY9 !K;M=D9<=%F?=FA=JY9<=/J9FKHGJL= +)*.,- !,-#4(*++),(++#)6#!!#(, +JGQ=;LGHJ=K=FL9<G;GEGJ=IMAKALGH9J;A9DH9J9D9G:L=F;A]F<=D/YLMDG<= %F?=FA=JG<=/J9FKHGJL= DMEFG!AD==F'9::X*F=LLG +JG>=KGJ#MY9D=B9F<J919D=F;A9 1WKIM=R 19DH9J9YKG BMFAG Índice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Índice de figuras Figura 1.1: Calle las Torres......................................................................................................... 3 Figura 1.2: Enrique Cood con Calle San Jorge........................................................................... 4 Figura 2.1: Paradero simple ...................................................................................................... 14 Figura 2.2: Paradero dividido ................................................................................................... 15 Figura 2.3: Diseño de parada y bahía ....................................................................................... 20 Figura 4.1: Ubicación de paraderos según Google Maps ......................................................... 34 Figura 4.2: Layout del tramo de estudio ................................................................................... 35 Figura 4.3: Recorrido línea 702 Top Tur .................................................................................. 38 Figura 4.4: Primer paradero informal e inicio de recorrido en calle las Torres........................ 40 Figura 4.5: Último paradero informar y fin del tramo en estudio............................................. 41 Figura 4.6: Perfil de carga medición de subida. ....................................................................... 42 Figura 4.7: Tasa de ocupación de microbuses .......................................................................... 43 Figura 4.8: Pasajeros en espera de microbús ............................................................................ 43 Figura 4.9: Herramientas Vissim 7.00 ...................................................................................... 45 Figura 4.10: Configuración línea de transporte público. .......................................................... 46 Figura 4.11: Configuración de paraderos. ................................................................................ 46 Figura 4.12: Paradero en PTV Vissim. ..................................................................................... 47 Figura 5.1: Layout situación actual con solución. .................................................................... 54 Figura 5.2: Paradero fijo en red de estudio. .............................................................................. 55 Figura 5.3: Paradero con señalización. ..................................................................................... 56 Figura 5.4: Pasajeros abordan los microbuses situación calibrada. .......................................... 58 Figura 5.5: Gráfico comparativo de microbuses en circulación. .............................................. 59 Figura 5.6: Gráfico diferencia de tiempo de viaje. ................................................................... 60 Figura 5.7: Gráfico diferencia detenciones............................................................................... 61 Figura A2.1:Segundo paradero informal. ................................................................................. 72 Figura A2.2: Tercer paradero informal..................................................................................... 73 Figura A2.3: Cuarto paradero informal. ................................................................................... 73 Figura A2.4: Quinto paradero informal. ................................................................................... 74 Figura A2.5: Sexto paradero informal. ..................................................................................... 74 Figura A2.6: Séptimo paradero informal. ................................................................................. 75 Figura A2.7: Octavo paradero informal.................................................................................... 75 Figura A2.8: Noveno paradero informal................................................................................... 76 Figura A2.9: Décimo paradero informal................................................................................... 76 Figura A2.10: Undécimo paradero informal............................................................................. 77 Figura A2.11: Duodécimo paradero informal........................................................................... 77 AAA Índice de tablas Tabla 2.1: Valores de Za para distintas probabilidades............................................................. 11 Tabla 2.2: Eficiencia de sitios linealmente dispuestos en paraderos ........................................ 11 Tabla 2.3: Ventajas y desventajas de ubicación de paraderos .................................................. 18 Tabla 2.4:Valores para determinación del tipo de prioridad .................................................... 23 Tabla 4.1: Características del sector ......................................................................................... 36 Tabla 4.2: Características del sector. ........................................................................................ 36 Tabla 4.3: Velocidad de microbuses......................................................................................... 37 Tabla 4.4: Resumen de datos empresa Top Tur........................................................................ 39 Tabla 4.5: Conteo estación de transferencia ............................................................................. 40 Tabla 4.6: Datos ingresados PTV VISSIM............................................................................... 44 Tabla 4.7: Indicadores de rendimiento arrojado en PTV VISSIM. .......................................... 49 Tabla 4.8: Situación actual calibrada de pasajeros comparada con datos tomados en terreno. 50 Tabla 4.9: Situación actual calibrada de transporte público comparada con datos tomados en terreno. ...................................................................................................................................... 51 Tabla 4.10: Situación actual calibrada de detenciones comparada con lo observado en terreno. .................................................................................................................................................. 51 Tabla 5.1: Identificación de tipo de diseño de paraderos. ........................................................ 54 Tabla 5.2: Distancia entre paraderos......................................................................................... 55 Tabla 5.3: Pasajeros que abordan el transporte público............................................................ 57 Tabla 5.4:Comparación de circulación de buses de transporte público.................................... 58 Tabla 5.5: Comparación de tiempos de viajes .......................................................................... 59 Tabla 5.6: Indicador de rendimiento de propuesta de solución ................................................ 60 Tabla A1.1: Conteo primera estación de transferencia............................................................. 67 Tabla A1.2: Conteo segunda estación de transferencia. ........................................................... 67 Tabla A1.3: Conteo tercera estación de transferencia. ............................................................. 67 Tabla A1.4: Conteo cuarta estación de transferencia................................................................ 68 Tabla A1.5: Conteo quinta estación de transferencia. .............................................................. 68 Tabla A1.6: Conteo sexta estación de transferencia. ................................................................ 69 Tabla A1.7: Conteo séptima estación de transferencia. ............................................................ 70 Tabla A1.8: Conteo octava estación de transferencia. .............................................................. 70 Tabla A1.9: Conteo novena estación de transferencia.............................................................. 71 Tabla A1.10: Conteo décima estación de transferencia............................................................ 71 Tabla A1.11: Conteo último paradero en estudio ..................................................................... 72 AN Glosario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esumen !FEM;@GK<=DGK;=JJGK<=19DH9J9YKGK=@9AF;J=E=FL9<GD9HG:D9;A]F;GF=DLJ9FK;MJKG<= DGK 9[GK Q ;GF =KLG K= @9F ?=F=J9<G FM=N9K NY9K <= ;GF=PA]F Q HMFLGK <= H9J9<9 H9J9 =D LJ9FKHGJL=H^:DA;G .AF=E:9J?G D99MK=F;A9<=MF:M=F<AK=[GNA9D=KMF9HJG:D=EWLA;9H9J9 D9E9QGJY9<=DGK;=JJGK Q9IM==FEM;@GK;9KGKFGK==F;M=FLJ9F 9;LM9DAR9<GK GFG;M=FL9F ;GFDGK<AK=[GKF=;=K9JAGKH9J9IM=DGK J=KA<=FL=KHM=<9F;AJ;MD9J Q =KH=J9J=DLJ9FKHGJL=<= E9F=J9=PH=<AL9 0FG<=DGK;=JJGKIM= K==F>J=FL99 =KLG =K-G;M9FL M:A;9<G=F9JJAG*b$A??AFK !FD9K @GJ9K HMFL9 E9[9F9 L9FLG DGK EA;JG:MK=K ;GEG DGK MKM9JAGK FG DG?J9F =D ;MEHDAEA=FLG <= ALAF=J9JAGK Q LA=EHGK <= NA9B= <=K=9<GK <=:A<G9D9K;GFKL9FL=K<=L=F;AGF=KIM= J=9DAR9F DGK :MK=K H9J9 LGE9J H9K9B=JGK Q D99MK=F;A9<=H9J9<=JGK >GJE9D=K =F=DK=;LGJ +GJ DG L9FLG =D G:B=LANG HJAF;AH9D <= =KL= HJGQ=;LG =K <AKEAFMAJ D9K <=L=F;AGF=K <=EGJ9K Q LA=EHGK <= NA9B= <= DGK :MK=K IM= ;AJ;MD9F =F =D K=;LGJ <= =KLM<AG 9 LJ9NXK <= E=<A<9K <= EALA?9;A]FIM=AF;DMQ9F ;9E:AGK =F=D<AK=[GNA9D =KH=;Y>A;9E=FL= =FD9 AEHD=E=FL9;A]F<= H9J9<=JGK>GJE9D=K +9J9 ;MEHDAJ ;GF =D G:B=LANG K= J=9DAR9 MF9 KAEMD9;A]F <= D9 KALM9;A]F 9;LM9D <=D ;GEHGJL9EA=FLG <=D LJ9FKHGJL= H^:DA;G Q<=DGKH9K9B=JGK =F =DK=;LGJ<==KLM<AG H9J9DM=?G HJGHGF=J QKAEMD9J MF9 KGDM;A]F 9D9K>9D=F;A9K<=L=;L9<9K +9J9 =DDG K=MLADAR9JW =D 0,$14/# de microsimulación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ntroducción 19DH9J9YKGK=;GEHGF= <=;=JJGK ;9<9MFG<==DDGK;GF;9J9;L=JYKLA;9K ^FA;9K=F;M9FLG9 NANA=F<9K ;9DD=K LGHG?J9>Y9 =FLJ=GLJGK ;LM9DE=FL= =D;J=;AEA=FLG<=HG:D9;A]F@9A<G=F 9ME=FLG Q<=:A<G9D9 ?J9F=PH9FKA]F QD9K<A>A;MDL9<=K<=9;;=KG =PAKL=F K=;LGJ=K<==KLGK ;=JJGK IM= K= =F;M=FLJ9F KAF MF <AK=[G =KL9:D=;A<G H9J9 =D LJ9FKHGJL= H^:DA;G Q MKM9JAGK DG ;M9D K= 9?J9N9 9 E=<A<9 IM= K= 9K;A=F<= 9 DGK K=;LGJ=K EWK 9DLG <= DGK :9JJAGK 0F ;D9JG =B=EHDG <=DG9FL=JAGJ =K ;=JJG-G;M9FLM:A;9<G=F:9JJAG*b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ntecedentes !D =JJG-G;M9FL K==F;M=FLJ9 M:A;9<G=F =D 9JJAG*b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ituación problema =JJG-G;M9FLM:A;9<G=F9JJAG*b$A??AFK@9;J=;A<G<=E9F=J9 KA?FA>A;9LAN9 <=HG:D9;A]F J9YR <=D ;J=;AEA=FLG ;GFKA<=J9:D= <= HG:D9;A]F Q HGJ KG:J= LG<G =F DM?9J=K EWK 9DLG <=D :9JJAG=D<AK=[GNA9DF=;=K9JAGFGK==F;M=FLJ99;LM9DAR9<G <=:A<G9D9=K;9K9AFN=JKA]F<=D9 (MFA;AH9DA<9<<=19DH9J9YKG=F;=JJG-G;M9FL 'GE=F;AGF9<G9>=;L9 >MF<9E=FL9DE=FL=9D9 ;9DD=HJAF;AH9D <GF<=;AJ;MD9 =DLJ9FKHGJL=H^:DA;G IM=;GEHJ=F<=MFLJ9EGIM=9:9J;9<=K<= ;9DD= D9K/GJJ=K@9KL9!FJAIM= GG< ;GF ;9DD=.9F&GJ?= ;GFMFLGL9D<= CAD]E=LJGK 9:= <=KL9;9JIM==KL=K=;LGJHGK==;GF=PA]F<AJ=;L9;GF=D;=FLJG<=D9;AM<9<Q;M=FL9;GFKGDG MF9DYF=9<=EA;JG:MK=K .=G:K=JN9 IM==F=DLJ9EGE=F;AGF9<G9FL=JAGJE=FL= FG;M=FL9;GF <=E9J;9;A]F H9J9<=JGK <=>AFA<GKQ;9FLA<9<<=EA;JG:MK=K=D;M9DJ=IMA=J=;=JJG-G;M9FL 9<G9DG9FL=JAGJ KMJ?=D9 KA?MA=FL= HJG:D=EWLA;9 =D LJ9FKHGJL= H^:DA;G 9D FG ;GFL9J ;GF H9J9<=JGK <=>AFA<GK K= <=:= <=L=F=J=FDGKDM?9J=KIM=DGKH9K9B=JGKA<=FLA>A;9F;GEGH9J9<9K DGIM=?=F=J9MFJ=LJ9KG=F =DALAF=J9JAG<9<GHGJD9 DYF=9<=LJ9FKHGJL=H^:DA;G ;GEG H9J9DGK MKM9JAGKIM=MLADAR9F=KL= E=<AG<=LJ9FKHGJL= +GJ GLJGD9<G K=G:K=JN9IM=D9<=E9F<9FGK=9BMKL99D9;9H9;A<9<<= DGKH9J9<=JGKFA9D9>J=;M=F;A9 Q;9FLA<9< <= EA;JG:MK=K .=?^F /(1 D9 >J=;M=F;A9 IM= <=:= ;MEHDAJ D9 DYF=9 =K <= EAFMLGK ;GF EA;JG:MK=K =F ;AJ;MD9;A]F KAF =E:9J?G DG E=F;AGF9<G FG K= 9BMKL9 ;GF DG G:K=JN9<G =F L=JJ=FG ;LM9DE=FL= ;AJ;MD9FK=AKEA;JG:MK=K=F=DK=;LGJ =D;M9D LA=F=MF9>J=;M=F;A9<= EAFMLGK =FLJ==DD9K <=K<=;9DD= D9K/GJJ=K@9KL9;9DD= !FJAIM=G<G;GF .9F&GJ?= L9J<9F<G =FLJ=9EAFMLGK9HJGPAE9<9E=FL==FJ=9DAR9J=DJ=;GJJA<G .=A<=FLA>A;9 IM==F=DLJ9EG <= =KLM<AG =PAKL=F H9J9<9K AF>GJE9D=K +JG<M;LG <= DG 9FL=JAGJ =D LJ9FKHGJL= FG <9 ;MEHDAEA=FLG 9D ALAF=J9JAG Q >DGL9 <= EA;JG:MK=K =KL9:D=;A<9K HGJ D9 =EHJ=K9 /GH /MJ Q =D /J9FKHGJL= (=LJGHGDAL9FG <= 19DH9J9YKG /(1 +GJ GLJ9 H9JL= D9 9MK=F;A9 <= <=E9J;9;A]F Q<AK=[GNA9D =FD9NY9?=F=J9MFH=DA?JGH9J9=DLJ9FKHGJL==F?=F=J9D Q9IM=FG K= =F;M=FLJ9 =D K=FLA<G <= D9K HAKL9K FA K=[9D=K <= HJAGJA<9< DG IM= HM=<= ?=F=J9J >MLMJGK 9;;A<=FL=K =F =D K=;LGJ KY L9E:AXF HG<=EGK K=[9D9J IM= =KL9 KALM9;A]F K= HJ=K=FL9 ?=F=J9DE=FL==F@GJ9HMFL9 =K<=;AJ <MJ9FL=D9E9[9F9 D9;M9D;GEHJ=F<=MF@GJ9JAGIM=N9 <=K<=D9K 9E@9KL9D9K 9E ;GFLAFM9;A]F K=HJ=K=FL9D9"A?MJ9 Q"A?MJ9 D9HJAE=J9<==DD9K;GJJ=KHGF<= 9 ;9DD= D9K/GJJ=K <GF<= K= AFA;A9=DJ=;GJJA<G <=DLJ9FKHGJL=H^:DA;G =F=DD9 K=G:K=JN9D99MK=F;A9<= H9NAE=FL9;A]F K=[9DAR9;A]F Q H9J9<=JGK >ABGK !F D9 K=?MF<9 ADMKLJ9;A]F D9 ;M9D =K ;9DD= !FJAIM= GG< ;GF .9F &GJ?= ;GJJ=KHGF<= 9D >AF9D <=D LJ9EG =KLM<A9<G =F 9IM=D K=;LGJ K= G:K=JN9 D9 9MK=F;A9 <= <AK=[G Q <= H9J9<=JGK >ABGK ;9:= <=KL9;9J IM= =D LJ9FKHGJL= H^:DA;G LJ9FKAL9HGJ=KL=DM?9JQJ=9DAR9D9^DLAE9LGE9<=H9K9B=JGK H9J99KY;GFLAFM9J=DJ=;GJJA<G=F <AJ=;;A]F9D;=FLJG<=19DH9J9YKG Figura 1.1: Calle las Torres. Fuente: Recuperado de google maps (mayo,2019) Figura 1.2: Enrique Cood con Calle San Jorge. Fuente: Recuperado de Google Maps (mayo, 2019). 1.3 Justificación del problema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bjetivos 1.4.1 Objetivo general -=9DAR9J?=KLA]F<=H9J9<=JGK=F9JJAG*b$A??AFK =FMFLJ9EGIM=;GEHJ=F<=<=K<= ;9DD= D9K /GJJ=K @9KL9!FJAIM=GG<;GF ;9DD= .9F &GJ?= ;GF=DHJGH]KALG<=E=BGJ9J DGK AF<A;9<GJ=K <= J=F<AEA=FLG<= <=EGJ9 <=L=F;AGF=K Q LA=EHG <= NA9B= 9 LJ9NXK <=KAEMD9;A]F<= 9DL=JF9LAN9K 1.4.2 Objetivos específicos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etodología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lcances y límites 'GK DYEAL=K <=D HJGQ=;LG K= =F>G;9F HJAF;AH9DE=FL= =F =D ;GEA=FRG <=D J=;GJJA<G <= DGK EA;JG:MK=K =D;M9D;GEHJ=F<=MFLJ9EG<=K<=;9DD=D9K/GJJ=K@9KL9!FJAIM=GG<;GF;9DD= .9F&GJ?= K==KLM<A9 =DLJ9Q=;LG<=:9B9<99D;=FLJG<=D9;AM<9< Q9IM= K=HJ=K=FL9D9E9QGJ ;9FLA<9< <= ;GF>DA;LGK 9KG;A9<GK 9 <AK=[G NA9D =KH=;Y>A;9E=FL= =F D9 9MK=F;A9 <= H9J9<=JGK +GJDGL9FLG D9LGE9<=<9LGKK=J=9DAR9=F@GJ9HMFL9E9[9F9<=K<=D9K 9 IM==K <GF<=K=HJ=K=FL9D9HJG:D=EWLA;9E=F;AGF9<99FL=JAGJE=FL= !F DG IM= 9 LGE9 <= <=;AKAGF=K J=KH=;L9 K= <=:= J=9DAR9J :9BG FGJE9LAN9K Q E9FM9D=K 9;LM9DAR9<GK ;GEG-! !10 (!.+%10 Q"=JFWF<=R H9J99KY?=F=J9J D9KKGDM;AGF=KJ=;GE=F<9<9K D9K;M9D=K<=:=F=KL9JJ=D9;AGF9<9K;GF=D<AK=[GNA9D<=DK=;LGJ =KH=;Y>A;9E=FL==FD9AEHD=E=FL9;A]F<=H9J9<=JGK =FLJG <= DGK 9D;9F;=K IM= HGK== =D HJGQ=;LG K= =F;M=FLJ9 =D 9;LM9DAR9J =D <AK=[G NA9D ;GFK=JN9F<G DGK 9KH=;LGK >YKA;GK EWK J=D=N9FL=K = AEHD=E=FL9F<G MF <AK=[G 9;GJ<= 9 D9K F=;=KA<9<=KIM=HJ=K=FL9FDGKMKM9JAGKJ=KA<=FL=K<=DK=;LGJ -=D9;AGF9<G;GFDG9FL=JAGJ K= =F;M=FLJ9FDGKE9FM9D=K<=<AK=[GNA9D HJAF;AH9DE=FL=-! !10 (!.+%10 Q "=JFWF<=R =F <GF<= =K HGKA:D= NAKM9DAR9J D9K J=;GE=F<9;AGF=K <= <AK=[G NA9D !K AEHGJL9FL=E=F;AGF9J IM=H9J9D9AEHD=E=FL9;A]F<=H9J9<=JGK=F=DLJ9EG<=K;JALGK=<=:=F ;GFKA<=J9JFGJE9LAN9K9;LM9D=K<=DEA;JGKAEMD9<GJ1%..%( 1.8 Estructura del proyecto !D=KLM<AG;M=FL9 ;GF;M9LJGH9JL=KHJAF;AH9D=K ;GE=FR9F<G;GFD9<=>AFA;A]F<=DHJG:D=E9Q D9E9F=J9=FIM=K=IMA=J=9:GJ<9J=DHJGQ=;LG !DK=?MF<G;9HYLMDG<=DHJGQ=;LGK==F>G;99D9 L=GJY9 <=D HJGQ=;LG <GF<= K= =F;M=FLJ9F ;GF;=HLGK Q <=>AFA;AGF=K IM= H=JEAL9F ;GEHJ=F<=J <=E=BGJE9F=J9=DL=E9=F=KLM<AG9;=J;9<=D<AK=[GNA9D !F=DL=J;=J;9HYLMDGK==>=;L^9MF9 J=NAKA]F <= D9 DAL=J9LMJ9 9KG;A9<9 ;GF =D L=E9 <=D HJGQ=;LG =F =D ;M9D K= LJ9:9B9 DG IM= K= <=FGEAF9 =KL9<G <=D 9JL= !D G:B=LANG <= DG 9FL=JAGJE=FL= E=F;AGF9<G =K 9F9DAR9J D9K AFN=KLA?9;AGF=KJ=9DAR9<9KQ<=DEAKEGEG<G<9J;GFG;AEA=FLG<=D9KALM9;A]FHJG:D=E9 '9;M9JL9H9JL=<=DHJGQ=;LG;GJJ=KHGF<=9D;9HYLMDG<=D9KALM9;A]F 9;LM9D<=DWJ=9<==KLM<AG =F =DD9 K= <=L9DD9 DG G:L=FA<GK <= DGK ;GFL=GK <= =KL9;A]F <= LJ9FK>=J=F;A9 Q <= DGK <9LGK J=;GHAD9<GKDGK;M9D=KKAJN=FH9J9=KL9:D=;=JMF <A9?F]KLA;G <=D9KALM9;A]F9;LM9D "AF9DE=FL= =FDGK;9HYLMDGIMAFLGQK=PLG;GJJ=KHGF<=F9D<=K9JJGDDGQ9FWDAKAK<=D9KALM9;A]F ;GFHJGQ=;LGHD9FL=9<GK >J=FL= 9D<A9?F]KLA;G=D;M9D>M=9HDA;9<G9D9KALM9;A]F9;LM9D<=DWJ=9 <==KLM<AGQ=F=D^DLAEG;9HYLMDGK==FLJ=?9FD9K;GF;DMKAGF=K?=F=J9<9K<=DHJGQ=;LG;GFD9K J=KH=;LAN9KHJGQ=;;AGF=K 2 Marco teórico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apacidad de estaciones de transferencia .=?^F"=JFWF<=R D9;9H9;A<9<<=MF9=KL9;A]F<=LJ9FK>=J=F;A9HM=<=E=<AJK=<=K<= <GK H=JKH=;LAN9K '9 HJAE=J9 ;GFKA<=J9 D9 EWPAE9 ;9FLA<9< <= G:B=LGK IM= HM=<=F K=J LJ9FK>=JA<GK=FD9=KL9;A]FHGJMF9MFA<9<<=LA=EHG '9K=?MF<9;GJJ=KHGF<=9 D9H=JKH=;LAN9 <= D9 ;AJ;MD9;A]F <= N=@Y;MDGK <GF<= D9 ;9H9;A<9< =K D9 EWPAE9 ;9FLA<9< <= N=@Y;MDGK IM= HM=<=FK=J9L=F<A<GHGJMFA<9<<=LA=EHG !FKYFL=KAK K=HM=<=<=>AFAJ;9H9;A<9<<=LJW>A;G<= MF9 =KL9;A]F <= LJ9FK>=J=F;A9 ;GEG D9 EWPAE9 ;9FLA<9< <= N=@Y;MDGK IM= HM=<= =FLJ9J 9 D9 =KL9;A]F HGJ MFA<9< <= LA=EHG 9:= <=KL9;9J IM= =PAKL=F EG<=DGK H9J9 =D ;WD;MDG <= ;9H9;A<9< <= MF9 =KL9;A]F <= LJ9FK>=J=F;A9 =D ;M9D ;GEA=FR9 ;GF MF EG<=DG #=FXJA;G ;GFLAFM9=D;GFEG<=DG$( '%&46-!'16+2) D9;M9D=KMF9HM:DA;9;A]F<= /- Q>AF9DE=FL=;GF=DEG<=DG%-!)! #A:KGF =L9D DGK;M9D=KK=JWF<=>AFA<GK 9;GFLAFM9;A]F 2.1.1 Modelo genérico '9 ;9H9;A<9<<=MF9=KL9;A]F<=LJ9FK>=J=F;A9<=H=F<= <= <AN=JK9K N9JA9:D=K Q9K=9 =D DM?9J<= ;9J?9 Q <=K;9J?9 =D LA=EHG <= G;MH9;A]F =F D9 =KL9;A]F Q >AF9DE=FL= =D LA=EHG =F IM= DGK KALAGKK==F;M=FLJ9F;GF<AKHGFA:ADA<9< ;GFLAFM9;A]F K=HJ=K=FL9D9>GJEMD9<=DEG<=DG GF<= ;9H9;A<9<<=LJW>A;GHGJ=KL9;A]F6N=@ @7 )F^E=JG<=DM?9J=K<=;9J?9Q<=K;9J?9GKALAGK L LA=EHGHJGE=<AGIM=D9=KL9;A]F=KLWG;MH9F<GGLA=EHG<=G;MH9;A]F6K7 HJGHGJ;A]F<=DLA=EHGIM=DGKKALAGK=KLWF<AKHGFA:D=K 2.1.2 HCM (Highway Capacity Manual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abla 2.1: Valores de Za para distintas probabilidades 59 Fuente: Elementos de la teoría del tráfico vehicular, Fernández 2008 +9J9D9G:L=F;A]F<=DF^E=JG=>=;LANG<=KALAGK=FD9 /9:D9 =FLJ=?9N9DGJ=K<==>A;A=F;A9<= DGK KALAGKDAF=9DE=FL=<AKHM=KLGK=FH9J9<=JGK =D;M9D=PHDA;9=F=DD9IM=KAHGK==MFKALAG=K ;GEHD=L9E=FL= =>A;A=FL= Q9 IM= =KLW G;MH9<G 9 MF <=D LA=EHG 9D 9?J=?9J MF K=?MF<G KALAG =KL=9HGJL9MF9D9;9H9;A<9<<=9L=F;A]F<=N=@Y;MDGK KAK=9?J=?9MFL=J;=JKALAG 9HGJL9J9MF <==>A;A=F;A9 .AF=E:9J?G 9D9?J=?9JMF;M9JLGQIMAFLGKALAGKGDGK=9?J=?9 MF QMF<=;9H9;A<9<<=9L=F;A]F"=JFWF<=R Tabla 2.2: Eficiencia de sitios linealmente dispuestos en paraderos Sin adelantar en paradero Nº de sitios 1 2 3 4 5 Adelantamiento en paradero Eficiencia % Neb Eficiencia % 100 1,00 100 85 1,85 85 60 2,45 75 20 2,65 65 5 2,7 50 Fuente: Elementos de la teoría del tráfico vehicular, Fernández 2008 Neb 1,00 1,85 2,6 3,25 3,75 +9J9D9G:L=F;A]F<=DH9JWE=LJGL< K=<=:=;GFKA<=J9J=DLA=EHG<=LJ9FK>=J=F;A9<=H9K9B=JGK =D;M9D=K=DLA=EHG<MJ9FL==D;M9D=D:MKH=JE9F=;=<=L=FA<GH9J9D9KM:A<9Q:9B9<9<=DGK MKM9JAGK .=<=:=;GFKA<=J9JD9KA?MA=FL=>GJEMD9 GF<= +9F^E=JG<=H9K9B=JGKIM=:9B9HGJ:MKHGJD9HM=JL9EWKMK9<9=FDGKEAFHMFL9 L9LA=EHG<=:9B9<9<=MFH9K9B=JG6K H9P7 +: F^E=JG <= H9K9B=JGK IM= KM:=F HGJ :MK HGJ D9 HM=JL9 EWK MK9<9 =F DGK EAF HMFL9 L:LA=EHG<=KM:A<9<=MFH9K9B=JG6K H9P7 LG;LA=EHG<=9H=JLMJ9<=;A=JJ=<=HM=JL9K6K7 2.1.3 IRENE !KL=EG<=DG<=KAEMD9;A]F;9D;MD9;9H9;A<9< <=EGJ9KQ;GD9K=FH9J9<=JGK !KMFHJG?J9E9 <= EG<=D9;A]F E=KGK;]HA;G <= H9J9<=JGK <= E^DLAHD=K KALAGK =D ;M9D H=JEAL= 9H9J=FL9J =D J=F<AEA=FLG<=MFH9J9<=JG :9BG<AKLAFLGKFAN=D=K<=<=E9F<9 #A:KGF =L9D +9J9 ;9D;MD9J D9 ;9H9;A<9< <= MF H9J9<=JG <= ) KALAGK =F 6:MK @7 9 LJ9NXK <= D9 KA?MA=FL= >GJEMD9 GF<= F=K=DF^E=JGE=<AG<=N=@Y;MDGKIM=HM=<==FLJ9J9DH9J9<=JG L =K=DLA=EHG<=G;MH9;A]F<=DH9J9<=JG 2.2 Estaciones de transferencia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igura 2.1: Paradero simple Fuente: Elementos de la teoría del tráfico vehicular, Fernández, 2008. ++)#/##) <AKHGKALANGNA9D=D;M9D<=H=F<=<=D>DMBGQ<=D9<=E9F<9KGFE9QGJ=K !F =D ;9KG <= DG E=F;AGF9<G 9FL=JAGJE=FL= K= J=IMA=J= MF WJ=9 <= H9J9<9 <ANA<A=F<G MF H9J9<=JG=FN9JAGKH9J9<=JGKKAEHD=KEWKH=IM=[GK =D;M9DK=<=FGEAF9KM:H9J9<=JG !FD9 "A?MJ9 K=G:K=JN9H9J9<=JG<ANA<A<G=D;M9D=PHDA;9DGE=F;AGF9<G9FL=JAGJE=FL= Figura 2.2: Paradero dividido Fuente: Elementos de la teoría del tráfico vehicular, Fernández, 2008. 2.3 Recomendaciones para la implementación de paraderos '9 >MF;A]F <= MF H9J9<=JG ;GJJ=KHGF<= =F HJGL=?=J =D H=9L]F <=D >DMBG N=@A;MD9J <= D9K ;GF<A;AGF=K ;DAEWLA;9K Q >AF9DE=FL= >9;ADAL9 9 DGK MKM9JAGK MF DM?9J <= <=K;9FKG EA=FLJ9K =KH=J9D9DD=?9<9<=D:MK=F=DH9J9<=JG "=JFWF<=R19D=FRM=D9 +9J9D9HD9FA>A;9;A]F<=D9K<=L=F;AGF=KIM=J=9DAR9=DLJ9FKHGJL=H^:DA;GK=<=:=;GFKA<=J9JD9 JML9IM==KL=J=9DAR9 =KHGJ=KLG IM=K=<=:=;GFKA<=J9JLJ=K9KH=;LGKAEHGJL9FL=KDGK;M9D=K KGF=KH9;A9EA=FLG DG;9DAR9;A]FQ<AK=[G<=DGKH9J9<=JGK "=JFWF<=R19D=FRM=D9 2.3.1 Espaciamiento entre paraderos !D MKG <= =KH9;A9EA=FLGK =FLJ= H9J9<=JGK <=E9KA9<GK ;GJLGK <=?J9<9 D9 ;9DA<9< <=D K=JNA;AG HJ=KL9<G =FLXJEAFGK<=N=DG;A<9<<=GH=J9;A]F IM=HGK== =DLJ9FKHGJL= H^:DA;G KYEAKEG D9K ;GFKL9FL=K <=L=F;AGF=K ?=F=J9F ?9KLGK =D=N9<GK H9J9 HJGN==J >9;ADA<9<=K <= AEHD=E=FL9;A]F <= J=>M?AGK :9FIMADDGK Q H9F=D=K <= AF>GJE9;A]F +GJ GLJG D9<G KA DGK =KH9;A9EA=FLGK KGF <=E9KA9<G D9J?GK 9ME=FL9 D9 <AKL9F;A9 <= ;9EAF9L9 <=K<= =D HMFLG <= GJA?=F@9KL9=DH9J9<=JG =F ;GFK=;M=F;A9 <=DG 9FL=JAGJ D9K ;GF<A;AGF=K<=9;;=KA:ADA<9<9D KAKL=E9 <= LJ9FKHGJL= H^:DA;G =EH=GJ9F +GJ DG IM= =K F=;=K9JAG MF ;GEHJGEAKG =FLJ= MF ;GJLG9;;=KGG;=J;9FY99DGKH9J9<=JGKQMF9=D=N9<9N=DG;A<9<<=GH=J9;A]F<=DK=JNA;AG;GF H9J9<9K<AK?J=?9<9K "=JFWF<=R19D=FRM=D9 +GJ DG L9FLG H9J9 MF9 =>A;A=FL= AEHD=E=FL9;A]F <= =KH9;A9EA=FLGK =FLJ= H9J9<=JGK K= <=:= J=D9;AGF9J D9;9FLA<9<<=NA9B=K?=F=J9<GK Q 9LJ9Y<GK BMFLG 9D NGDME=F<=H9K9B=JGKIM=;AJ;MD9 9LJ9NXK<=DWJ=99F9DAR9<9 !D =KH9;A9EA=FLG<=:=K=J L9D IM= =FHJGE=<AGFGKMH=J=DGK E 9 EFAK=9AF>=JAGJ9DGK E9 E !PAKL=F;9KGK=P;=H;AGF9D=K =D;M9D=KHGKA:D= ;GFKA<=J9J DGK =KH9;A9EA=FLGK AF>=JAGJ=K 9 DG E=F;AGF9<G 9FL=JAGJE=FL= =KL= ;9KG KGDG K= H=JEAL= ;M9F<G DGK H9J9<=JGK KGF <ANA<A<GK HJG<M;LG <= =D=N9<9K <=E9F<9K HGJ KM:A<9K :9B9<9K "=JFWF<=R19D=FRM=D9 0FEG<=DG<=K9JJGDD9<G=F@AD=HGJ9<= %<=H= <=L=JEAF9 =D=KH9;A9EA=FLG]HLAEG =FLJ=H9J9<=JGK ?=F=J9F<G AEH9;LGK HGKALANGKL9FLG H9J9=DGH=J9<GJ;GEGH9J9DGK MKM9JAGKQ9 IM= <AKEAFMQ==DLA=EHG <= ;9EAF9L9Q<=EGJ9 =FDGK H9J9<=JGK +GJGLJGD9<G =DLJ9FKHGJL= H^:DA;G9DJ=9DAR9JD9GH=J9;A]F<AKEAFMQ= ;GKLGK <=GH=J9;A]FHGJ <=L=F;A]F +9J9 G:L=F=J D9 <AKL9F;A9 ]HLAE9 <= <AK=[G <= H9J9<=JGK K= HM=<= ;9D;MD9J ;GF D9 KA?MA=FL= >GJEMD9 9<= %<=H= GF<= < <AKL9F;A9]HLAE9=FLJ=H9J9<=JGK=FE=LJGK HJGHGJ;A]F<=:MK=KIM=K=<=LA=F=F=FH9J9<=JGK ,: >DMBG<=:MK=KIM=H9K9HGJ=DH9J9<=JG:MK @ +;HJ=;AGKG;A9D<=D;GE:MKLA:D= <;GFKMEGMFAL9JAGHGJ<=L=F;A]F<=D:MK <H<=EGJ9E=<A9=FH9J9<=JGKK NH N=DG;A<9<<=;9EAF9L9 J;GFKMEGMFAL9JAG9DJ=D9FLY /*:L9K9<=G;MH9;A]F<=DGK:MK=K=F=DLJ9EGQH=JYG<G 1/N9DGJKM:B=LANG<=DLA=EHG +<<=FKA<9<<=<=E9F<9<=H9K9B=JGK=F=DLJ9EG KM:A<9Q:9B9<9H9P CE @ EH9JWE=LJG<AKL9F;A9E=<A9;9EAF9<9 HGF<=J9<GJ<=DLA=EHG<=9;;=KG )H F^E=JG<=H9J9<=JGK +KL9K9<=H9K9B=JGKIM=KM:=FH9P :MK +:L9K9<=H9K9B=JGKIM=:9B9FH9P :MK +9J9 A<=FLA>A;9J =D F^E=JG <= KALAGK IM= K= J=IMA=J=F K= <=:= L=F=J =F ;M=FL9 D9 KA?MA=FL= >]JEMD9 GF<= 'LD9J?G<=LJ9FKHGJL=H^:DA;G=F6E7 <<AKL9F;A9]HLAE9=FLJ=H9J9<=JGK=F 6E7 0F >9;LGJ AEHGJL9FL= Q ;GEHD=E=FLG <= D9K >]JEMD9K E=F;AGF9<9K 9FL=JAGJE=FL= KGF DGK H9K9B=JGKIM=KM:=FQ:9B9F<=DGKEA;JG:MK=K H9J9=D ;WD;MDG E=F;AGF9<G9FL=JAGJE=FL=K= <=>AF=F D9KKA?MA=FL=K>]JEMD9K +9K9B=JGKIM=KM:=F +9K9B=JGKIM=:9B9F 2.4.2 Localización de paraderos !PAKL=FLJ=KLAHGK<=M:A;9;AGF=K<=H9J9<=JG9DGD9J?G<=D9;9DD=GNY9 =DHJAE=JG =K 9FL=K <= D9 AFL=JK=;;A]F =D K=?MF<G H9K9<9 <= D9 AFL=JK=;;A]F Q >AF9DE=FL= 9 EAL9< <= ;M9<J9 29J< .=?^F IM= HJ=K=FL9F D9K M:A;9;AGF=K E=F;AGF9<9K 9FL=JAGJE=FL= K= HJ=K=FL9F =F D9 /9:D9 9;GFLAFM9;A]F ##4( Tabla 2.3: Ventajas y desventajas de ubicación de paraderos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uente: Ward, (2019). 2.4.3 Diseño de paraderos .=?^F =D=KLM<AG<="=JFWF<=R19D=FRM=D9 MF<AK=[GKAEHD=<=H9J9<=JG=K9IMXD=F <GF<=DGK:MK=KK=<=LA=F=F9D:GJ<=<=D99;=J9 QKG:J=D9NY9 .AF=E:9J?G 9H=K9J<=IM==D <AK=[G=K;GFN=FA=FL=H9J9DGKH9K9B=JGKQJ=IMA=J=EYFAE9KE9FAG:J9K ?=F=J9MF:DGIM=G<=D J=KLG<=DLJW>A;G<MJ9FL=D9<=L=F;A]F c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igura 2.3: Diseño de parada y bahía Fuente: Diagnóstico y diseño de facilidades al transporte público, Fernández y Valenzuela (2002) 2.5 Velocidad comercial '9N=DG;A<9<;GE=J;A9D 1; =KD9N=DG;A<9<HJGE=<AG =EHD=9<9<=N=@Y;MDGK<=DLJ9FKHGJL= H^:DA;GH9J9J=9DAR9JMFNA9B=;GEHD=LG<=J=;GJJA<G D9;M9DAF;DMQ=<=EGJ9K<=;M9DIMA=JLAHG '9N=DG;A<9<;GE=J;A9D<=MF:MK=F MFLJ9EG;GJJ=KHGF<=9D9N=DG;A<9<E=<A9<=NA9B==FLJ= MF H9J9<=JG GJA?=F Q GLJG <=KLAFG AF;DMQ=F<G LG<9K D9K <=L=F;AGF=K AFL=JE=<A9K .= HM=<= ;9D;MD9J;GFD9KA?MA=FL=>]JEMD9 GF<= 'DGF?ALM<<=DLJ9EG6CE7 /NA9B= LA=EHGLGL9D<=NA9B==F=DLJ9EG =F6K7 =FLJG<==KL9K=HM=<=G:L=F=JAF<A;9<GJ=K<=FAN=D=K<=K=JNA;AGH9J9MKM9JAGK AF<A;9<GJ=K <=D;GKLG<=GH=J9;A]FQ>AF9DE=FL==D LA=EHGLGL9D<=DNA9B==F=DN=@Y;MDG =DGE=F;AGF9<G 9FL=JAGJE=FL=K=<=KHJ=F<=D9KA?MA=FL=>]JEMD9 GF<= LE LA=EHG ;GFKMEA<G=FEGNAEA=FLG 6K7 LALA=EHG;GFKMEA<G=FAFL=JK=;;A]F 6K7 LHLA=EHG;GFKMEA<G =FH9J9<=JGK 6K7 'GK LA=EHG <= NA9B= =F EGNAEA=FLG L E DGK LA=EHGK <= NA9B= =F H9J9<=JGK Q ;GFKMEA<GK =F AFL=JK=;;AGF=KLA =KLWF<9<GK=?^FD9KKA?MA=FL=K=PHJ=KAGF=K GF<= 1J N=DG;A<9<<=J=;GJJA<G<=:MK=K =P;DMA<9D9K<=L=F;AGF=K )AF^E=JG<=AFL=JK=;;AGF=K=F=DLJ9EG <A<=EGJ9E=<A9<=:MKHGJAFL=JK=;;AGF=K=F6K7 )HF^E=JG<=H9J9<=JGK=F=DLJ9EG H<=EGJ9E=<A9HGJ:MK=FH9J9<=JGK=F6K7 !KL9^DLAE9K=G:LA=F=<=D9KA?MA=FL=E9F=J9 GF<= <G <=EGJ9E=<A9HGJ:MK<=:A<G9D9LJ9FK>=J=F;A9<=H9K9B=JGK=F6K7 <;<=EGJ9E=<A9HGJ:MK<=:A<G9;GF?=KLA]F<=H9J9<=JGK=F6K7 9:=<=KL9;9JIM=K=<=:=;GFKA<=J9J=DLA=EHGIM=L9J<9FDGKEA;JG:MK=K=FJ=;GJJ=J=DLJ9EG HGJDGIM=K=<=KHJ=F<=D9KA?MA=FL=>]JEMD9 GF<= /LLA=EHGLGL9D<=NA9B==FMFLJ9EGGJML9 'DGF?ALM<<=DLJ9EG=F 6CE7 1;N=DG;A<9<;GE=J;A9D=F 6CE @7 +9J9=KL9:D=;=J E=<A<9K <=HJAGJA<9<9:MK=K=FAFL=JK=;;A]F H9J9<=JGK Q LJ9EGK<=NY9K K= <=:=;GFKA<=J9JD9KN9JA9:D=K<=LA=EHGK;GEG<=EGJ9K <=L=F;AGF=KQ;GD9K !FD9/9:D9 D9 ;M9D >M= =KL9:D=;A<9 HGJ "=JFWF<=R E=F;AGF9F IM= KA D9 N=DG;A<9< <= J=;GJJA<G =K E=FGJ<=6CE @7K=J=IMA=J=AEHD=E=FL9JE=<A<9K<=HJAGJA<9<=FLJ9EGK<=NY9K +GJGLJG D9<G KA D9 N=DG;A<9< ;GE=J;A9D =F AFL=JK=;;AGF=K LJ9EGK <= NY9 G H9J9<=JGK =K E=FGJ <= 6CE @7 K=KGDA;AL9=KL9:D=;=JE=<A<9K<=HJAGJA<9<9:MK=K=FLG<G=D=B= "=JFWF<=R +#&, Tabla 2.4:Valores para determinación del tipo de prioridad +'), (-+,#)(, ++), &)#)'+#&%'" &)#+)++#)%'" -(#)(,-/" )&,/" ')+,/",, Fuente: Elementos de la teoría del tráfico vehicular, Fernández, 1999. 2.6 Demoras en estaciones de transferencia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etenciones .=?^F "=JFWF<=R =D F^E=JG <= <=L=F;AGF=K =F AFL=JK=;;AGF=K FG K=E9>GJAR9<9K <=H=F<=<=DLAHG<=K=[9D<=HJAGJA<9<IM= =PAKL9 .A=PAKL=D9K=[9Dc+9J=dLG<GN=@Y;MDGK= <=LA=F= 9D E=FGK MF9 N=R .A =PAKL= K=[9D c=<9 =D +9KGd K]DG @9Q <=L=F;A]F KA =D AFL=JN9DG =FLJ= N=@Y;MDGK =F =D >DMBG HJAF;AH9D =K E=FGJ IM= D9 :J=;@9 ;JYLA;9 '9 HJG:9:ADA<9< <= G;MJJ=F;A9<==KLG=K GF<= .A GL9AF>=JAGJ<= <=L=F;A]F =K<=;AJH=DGL]F=KA?M9D9?J9<G<=K9LMJ9;A]F K=LA=F= GF<= @+JGE=<AG<=<=L=F;AGF=KHGJN=@Y;MDG6<=L N=@7 PH#J9<G<=K9LMJ9;A]F<=D9NY9HJAGJAL9JA9 IH"DMBG<=D9NY9HJAGJAL9JA96N=@ @7 +JGHGJ;A]F<=N=@Y;MDGKIM=DD=?9F=FH=DGL]FHGJD9NY9HJAGJAL9JA9 J=;@9EYFAE96K=?7 %FL=JN9DGEYFAEG 2.8 Vissim ,$14/# 1AKKAE c#02+&#//*'#+1"#0'*2)!'?+*'!/,0!?-'!"#) 1/8$'!,#02+*,"#), .2#-#/*'1#/#-/#0#+1/1,",0),0202/',0"#)3;-@ )'!6#012"'/020'+1#/0#!!',+#0 21,0 1/+0-,/1# "# !/% 6 !2).2'#/ 1'-, "# 1/+0-,/1# "# !/% 6 !2).2'#/ 1'-, "# 1/+0-,/1# -@ )'!, 6 0# $#//,3'/', , !,+3#+!',+)bb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ransporte público en Vissim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emoras en Vissim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iempo de viaje en Vissim !F +/1 1%..%( (9FM9D =D LA=EHG <= NA9B= MLADAR9 <GK EXLG<GK AL=J9LANGK ;M9F<G K= HJ=K=FL9 9KA?F9;A]F <AFWEA;9 9<9 EXLG<G =K =D=?A<G <= 9;M=J<G ;GF D9 AEHGJL9F;A9IM=K=D=<X9DLA=EHG<=NA9B==FD9K ;GJJA<9K !KLGKEXLG<GKKGFDGKKA?MA=FL=K 2-)) -)+0*)((#&,./#1) =KMLADAR9<G;M9F<G=DLA=EHGLA=F=E=FGJ H=KG 2-))*+)'#),,.,#/), =KMLADAR9<G;M9F<G=DLA=EHGLA=F=E9QGJH=KG 2.8.4 Aplicaciones del software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stado del arte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c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iagnóstico de la situación actual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atastro físico-operativo +9J9;9J9;L=JAR9J=DWJ=9=F=KLM<AG<=;=JJG-G;M9FLK= J=9DAR9 MF9<=K;JAH;A]F>YKA;9<=D;=JJG Q ;GEG K= =F;M=FLJ9 9;LM9DE=FL= =D >MF;AGF9EA=FLG <= <AK=[G NA9D =KH=;Y>A;9E=FL= <= DGK H9J9<=JGKIM=K==F;M=FLJ9F=F=DK=;LGJ =K<=;AJ ;9L9KLJGGH=J9LANG 4.1.1 Aspectos físicos del sector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igura 4.1: Ubicación de paraderos según Google Maps Fuente: Recuperado de Google Maps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igura 4.2: Layout del tramo de estudio Fuente: Elaboración propia con datos tomados en terreno, 2019 ;GFLAFM9;A]F =FD9/9:D9 K=HJ=K=FL9D9FME=J9;A]F<=DGKH9J9<=JGK=F=DK=;LGJ <GF<= K=A<=FLA>A;9KAHGK==<=E9J;9;A]FGK=[9DXLA;9 IM=A<=FLA>AIM=D9=PAKL=F;A9 <=MFH9J9<=JG=F =K= DM?9J 9D A?M9D K= HM=<= G:K=JN9J KA =PAKL= G FG 9;=J9K =F =D ;=JJG =F =D ;9KG <= IM= KA =PAKL9F9;=J9KK=K=[9D9DGKE=LJGKIM=EA<= XKL9 =F=D;9KG;GFLJ9JAG K= =F;M=FLJ9 ;GFMFcFG HGK==d !K AEHGJL9FL= K=[9D9J IM= DGK LJ=K HJAE=JGK H9J9<=JGK ;M=FL9F ;GF 9;=J9K <= LA=JJ9 ;J=9<9KHGJ=D>J=;M=FL=MKG<=DGKMKM9JAGKIM=J=KA<=F=F=K=K=;LGJ 9:=<=KL9;9JIM= =FD9 "A?MJ9 K=A<=FLA>A;9FD9FME=J9;A]F QM:A;9;A]F<=DGKH9J9<=JGKK=[9D9<GK=F<A;@9L9:D9 Tabla 4.1: Características del sector Número de paraderos Paraderos Ancho de acera informales demarcados 1 No No posee 2 No No posee 3 No No posee 4 No 2 mts 5 No 2 mts 6 No 2 mts 7 No 2 mts 8 No 2 mts 9 No 2 mts 10 No 2 mts 11 No 2 mts 12 No 2 mts 13 No 2 mts Fuente: Elaboración propia con datos obtenidos en terreno !FD9/9:D9 K=G:K=JN9;GEG =KLW ;GEHM=KL9D9NY9 <=;9DD=D9K/GJJ=K@9KL9!FJAIM=G<G ;GF.9F&GJ?= =L9DD9 =D9F;@G<=D9;9DR9<9 =D F^E=JG <=HAKL9K =DK=FLA<G <=D9KNY9K =D LAHG<=H9NAE=FLG Q>AF9DE=FL= =FIM==KL9<GK==F;M=FLJ9D9NY9 '9NY9=FLG<G=DLJ9EG<= =KLM<AGK==F;M=FLJ9=FE9D=KL9<G @9;A=F<GIM=D9;AJ;MD9;A]F<=DLJ9FKHGJL=QDGKN=@Y;MDGK H9JLA;MD9J=KK=N=99>=;L9<G Nombre de vía calle las Torres - Enrique Tabla 4.2: Características del sector. Ancho calzada Pistas Sentido 4 mts 2 Bidirecional Material Estado de vías asfalto mal estado Cood con San Jorge Fuente: Elaboración propia con datos obtenidos en terreno, 2019. 4.1.2 Aspectos operativos del sector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abla 4.3: Velocidad de microbuses. Tipo de vehículo Datos tomados en el sector Microbuses Velocidad comercial 4.8 km/h Velocidad recorrido 35 km/h Fuente: Elaboración propia con datos tomado en terreno, 2019. 4.2 Transporte público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igura 4.3: Recorrido línea 702 Top Tur Fuente: Recuperado de Google Earth Valparaíso, 2019. !F D9 /9:D9 K= HJ=K=FL9 D9K ;9J9;L=JYKLA;9K EA;JG:MK=K <GF<= =F =DD9 K= =F;M=FLJ9 ;9H9;A<9< LA=EHG <= J=;GJJA<G N=DG;A<9< ;GE=J;A9D >J=;M=F;A9 <= K9DA<9 Q F^E=JG <= EA;JG:MK=KIM=HGK==D9DYF=9 Tabla 4.4: Resumen de datos empresa Top Tur Empresa: Top Tur S.A Línea:702 Parámetro Unidad Tipo de vehículo Capacidad del microbus Valores Microbus Pax/bus 30 Distancia de recorrido tramo en Km estudio Tiempo de recorrido tramo en estudio Minutos 1.2 Frecuencia de salida Minutos 12 Velocidad recorrido Km/h 35 15 Velocidad comercial Km/h 4.8 Microbuses 9 Fuente: Datos Recuperados de empresa Top Tur, 2019. 4.3 Medición subida y bajada de pasajeros .= J=9DAR9 ;GFL=G <= H9K9B=JGK =F =KL9;AGF=K <= LJ9FK>=J=F;A9 M:A;9<9K =F ;=JJG -G;M9FL !D ;GFL=G =K J=9DAR9<G E9JL=K <= E9QG =F ;GF<A;AGF=K <= MF <Y9 D9:GJ9D FGJE9D =F @GJ9JAG HMFL9E9[9F9 =FAFL=JN9DGK<=EAFMLGK =FLJ= a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abla 4.5: Conteo estación de transferencia Subida pasajeros Pasajeros (pax/15 min bus) Promedio tiempo (s) Pasajeros (pax) Promedio Total 7:00 - 7:15 2 100 ---- ---- Tiempo de apertura y cierre de puertas (s) 4 7:15 - 7:30 2 100 ---- ---- 4 2 ---- 7:30 - 7:45 2 51 ---- ---- 4 1 ---- 7:45 - 8:00 2 50 ---- ---- 4 1 ---- Período Promedio tiempo (s) Bajada de pasajeros Buses que se detienen Buses que no se detienen 2 ---- Fuente: Elaboración propia con datos tomados en terreno. ;GFLAFM9;A]F =FD9"A?MJ9 K= EM=KLJ9 D9K;GF<A;AGF=K <= D9HJAE=J9H9J9<9 <=DLJ9FKHGJL= H^:DA;GD9;M9DJ=HJ=K=FL9=DHJAE=JHMFLG<=;GFL=G !FL9FLG =FD9"A?MJ9 K=A<=FLA>A;9=D ^DLAEG H9J9<=JG !DJ=KLG<= D9K>A?MJ9K J=HJ=K=FL9FL=K<=DGKH9J9<=JGK<=DK=;LGJ=F=KLM<AG K==F;M=FLJ9F =F=DF=PG Figura 4.4: Primer paradero informal e inicio de recorrido en calle las Torres. Fuente: Recuperado de Google Maps (mayo, 2019) Figura 4.5: Último paradero informar y fin del tramo en estudio. Fuente: Recuperado de Google Maps (mayo, 2019). /G<GDG<=L9DD9<G9FL=JAGJE=FL= =K F=;=K9JAGH9J9DD=N9J9;9:GD9KAEMD9;A]F<=D9KALM9;A]F 9;LM9D =F =D EA;JGKAEMD9<GJ 1AKKAE 9<9 MFG <= DGK ;GFL=GK 9F;@GK <= HAKL9K N=DG;A<9< ;GE=J;A9DQ>J=;M=F;A9<=DGKEA;JG:MK=KKGFMF>9;LGJAEHGJL9FL=9D9@GJ9<=KAEMD9J 4.4 Perfil de carga paraderos cerro Rocuant !D H=J>AD <= ;9J?9 <=D K=;LGJ =F =KLM<AG H=JEAL= <AKHGF=J E=<A<GJ=K 9 :GJ<G Q >M=J9 <= DGK EA;JG:MK=K <=EG<G IM=J=?AKLJ= D9;9FLA<9<<=H=JKGF9KIM=KM:=FQ:9B9F=F;9<9MFG<= DGK H9J9<=JGK (!.+%10 !F =KL= ;9KG K= J=9DAR9 H=J>AD <= ;9J?9 <= KM:A<9K <= H9K9B=JGK<=:A<G9IM==F@GJ9HMFL9E9[9F9=K <GF<= K= HJ=K=FL9 D9 E9QGJ <=E9F<9 =KL9K= G:LA=F= 9 LJ9NXK <=D HJGE=<AG <= H9K9B=JGK IM= 9:GJ<9F DGK EA;JG:MK=K =F ;9<9 MFG <= DGK H9J9<=JGK A<=FLA>A;9<GK =F =D LJ9EG <= =KLM<AG =F H=JYG<G <= MF9 @GJ9 EMDLAHDA;9<G HGJ D9 ;9FLA<9<<=EA;JG:MK=KIM=HGK==D9DYF=9 K=G:K=JN9DGE=F;AGF9<G=FD9"A?MJ9 Figura 4.6: Perfil de carga medición de subida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igura 4.7: Tasa de ocupación de microbuses Fuente: Elaboración propia con datos obtenidos en terreno. !F J=D9;A]F 9 DG 9FL=JAGJ K= G:LA=F= D9 ;9FLA<9< <= H9K9B=JGK IM= FG 9:GJ<9F =D EA;JG:^K Q IM=<9F=FD9=KH=J9<=DKA?MA=FL= DGE=F;AGF9<GK==PHGF=9;GFLAFM9;A]F=FD9"A?MJ9 Figura 4.8: Pasajeros en espera de microbús Fuente: Elaboración propia con datos obtenidos en terreno. "AF9DE=FL= H9J9J=9DAR9JMF9KAEMD9;A]FQ<A9?F]KLA;G<=D9KALM9;A]F9;LM9DK=<=:==D9:GJ9J '9QGML=F=DEA;JGKAEMD9<GJ1%..%( H9J9=DDG LG<GDG =PHM=KLG9FL=JAGJE=FL= KGF^LAD=KH9J9 =DKA?MA=FL=H9KG=D;M9DK=HJG;=<=9KAEMD9J=F=DEA;JGKAEMD9<GJ+/11%..%( 4.5 Simulación de la red con Vissim +9J9 ;GE=FR9J 9 EG<=D9J D9 KALM9;A]F 9;LM9D <=D LJ9EG <= =KLM<AG K= <=:= ;J=9J D9 AF>J9=KLJM;LMJ9J=KH=;LG9 D9?=GE=LJY9Q>MF;AGF9EA=FLGIM==PAKL==FD99;LM9DA<9< H9J9=DDG K= MLADAR9F D9KE=<A<9KIM=K=HJ=K=FL9F=FD9K=;;A]F9FL=JAGJ=FD9/9:D9 @9KL9/9:D9 ;9<9 MFG <= =KLGK <9LGK KGF >MF<9E=FL9D=K 9D EGE=FLG <= J=9DAR9J D9 EG<=D9;A]F =F =D HJG?J9E9 +/1 1%..%( ;GFLAFM9;A]F =F D9 /9:D9 K= HJ=K=FL9 J=KME=F <= DGK <9LGK MLADAR9<GK=F =DEA;JGKAEMD9<GJ Tabla 4.6: Datos ingresados PTV VISSIM. Parámetro Detalle Ancho por pista 4 metros Número de pistas 2 Sentido Bidireccional Largo de tramo 1.2 km Velocidad recorrido 35 km/h Velocidad comercial 4.8 km/h Flujo de buses (bus/h) 6 Frecuencia de transporte público 12 minutos Flujo de vehiculos ( veh/h) 25 Capacidad del bus ( pax/bus) 50 Tasa de ocupación del bus inico recorrido 20 Tiempo de despeje (s/parada) 95 Tiempo de subida(s/pax) 2 Pasajeros que abordan (pax/bus) Tabla 4.5 Probabilidad de bajada (pax) 4% Fuente: Elaboración propia con datos tomados en terreno. La modelación del software permite que el Layout del cerro, sea creada con datos específicos tomados en terreno, de tal manera de crear un diseño manual. Para ello se debe obtener imagen del sector en estudio, para así dimensionarla en el microsimulador en escala basada en la realidad para su correcta aplicación. Luego se crea la calzada y composición estructural con las respectivas intersecciones y aceras, a través de la herramienta Links (1), donde se debe identificar el número y ancho de pistas, se identifican los conflictos que existen entre intersecciones, a través de la herramienta Conflict Areas, donde se debe especificar quien tiene prioridad en cada una de las intersecciones. Finalmente se identifica si existe en el sector señal de prioridad a través de la herramienta Priority Rules. Cabe destacar que en el sector de estudio solo se encuentra demarcada una señal de prioridad. Seguido de lo anterior, se identifican las herramientas utilizadas en PTV VISSIM en la Figura 4.9. Figura 4.9: Herramientas Vissim 7.0 Fuente: Recuperado de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igura 4.10: Configuración línea de transporte público. Fuente: PTV VISSIM 7.0, 2019. +9J9 D9 ;J=9;A]F <= D9K H9J9<9K <= LJ9FKHGJL= H^:DA;G NAKL9K =F L=JJ=FG D9K ;M9D=K KGF LJ=;= H9J9<9K K=G;MH9<9D9@=JJ9EA=FL9 2 )'!/+0-,/11,- ;GEGK=NAKM9DAR9=FD9"A?MJ9 9:=<=KL9;9JIM= =F;9<9MF9<==DD9KK=<=:=AF?J=K9J=FHJAE=JDM?9JD9DGF?ALM<IM= LA=F= =D LJ9FKHGJL= H^:DA;G IM= ;AJ;MD9 =F =D K=;LGJ <= =KLM<AG DM=?G K= ;GFLAF^9 ;GF =D NGDME=F#),)<=H9K9B=JGKIM=DD=?9F9;9<9H9J9<9=FAFL=JN9DGK<=LA=EHG=FK=?MF<GK '*#$/,*'*#, .=A<=FLA>A;9<G=FJGBGDGE=F;AGF9<G=FD9"A?MJ9 Figura 4.11: Configuración de paraderos. Fuente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igura 4.12: Paradero en PTV Vissim. Fuente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igura 4.13: Layout situación actual. Fuente: Recuperado de PTV VISSIM 7.0, 2019. Tabla 4.7: Indicadores de rendimiento arrojado en PTV VISSIM. Pasajeros (pax/15min) Resultados Total pasajeros ingresados 7:00- 7:15 147 Total pasajeros ingresados 7:15- 7:30 120 Total pasajeros ingresados 7:30- 7:45 150 Total pasajeros ingresados 7:45- 8:00 40 Flujo transporte público (bus/15min) Promedio circulación de buses de 7:00- 7:15 3 Promedio circulación de buses de 7:15- 7:30 2 Promedio circulación de buses de7:30- 7:45 1 Promedio circulación de buses de 7:45- 8:00 1 Tiempo de viaje (s) Tiempo de viaje (s) de 7:00- 7:15 540 Tiempo de viaje en (s) de 7:15- 7:30 300 Tiempo de viaje en (s) de 7:30- 7:45 420 Tiempo de viaje en (s) de 7:45- 8:00 600 Detenciones bus (det/bus) Detenciones 7:00- 7:15 12 Detenciones 7:15- 7:30 12 Detenciones 7:30- 7:45 12 Detenciones 7:45- 8:00 12 Fuente: Recuperado de PTV VISSIM, 2019. 4.6 Calibración de la situación actual por PTV VISSIM 'GK <9LGK IM= K= MLADAR9F H9J9 D9 ;9DA:J9;A]F <= D9 KALM9;A]F 9;LM9D ;GJJ=KHGF<=F HJAF;AH9DE=FL= 9D NGDME=F<=H=9LGF=KIM==KH=J9F=FDGKH9J9<=JGK Q KM:=F9DGKEA;JG:MK=K .= ;GFKA<=J9 D9 ;9FLA<9< <= EA;JG:MK=K IM= J=;GJJ= D9 J=< 9D A?M9D IM= D9 N=DG;A<9< <= J=;GJJA<G IM==PAKL= >AF9DE=FL==DLA=EHGIM=L9J<9=FJ=;GJJ=<D9J=< !F =D ;9KG <=D NGDME=F <= H=9LGF=K IM= =KH=J9F =F DGK H9J9<=JGK DGK <9LGK IM= >M=JGF MLADAR9<GK<=J=>=J=F;A9H9J9;9DA:J9JD9KALM9;A]F9;LM9D K= =F;M=FLJ9F=FD9/9:D9 =F=DD9 K= J=9DAR9;GEH9J9;A]F<=<9LGKKAF;9DA:J9J DGNAKLG=FL=JJ=FGQ=DHGJ;=FL9B=<=<A>=J=F;A9 IM=K=G:LMNG9D;9DA:J9JDGK<9LGK Tabla 4.8: Situación actual calibrada de pasajeros comparada con datos tomados en terreno. Pasajeros (pax/15min) #%$#"# #"& ) $"" " Total pasajeros ingresados 7:00- 7:15 106 100 6% Total pasajeros ingresados 7:15- 7:30 100 100 0% Total pasajeros ingresados 7:30- 7:45 50 50 0% Total pasajeros ingresados 7:45- 8:00 46 50 9% Fuente: Elaboración propia a través de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abla 4.9: Situación actual calibrada de transporte público comparada con datos tomados en terreno. Transporte público (bus/15min) Resultados Observado Índice de calibrados en terreno mejora Promedio circulación de buses 7:00 - 7:15 2 2 0% Promedio circulación de buses 7:15 - 7:30 2 2 0% Promedio circulación de buses 7:30 - 7:45 1 1 0% Promedio circulación de buses 7:45 - 8:00 1 1 0% Tiempo de viaje 7:00 - 7:15 750,8 720 4% Tiempo de viaje 7:15 - 7:30 720 720 0% Tiempo de viaje 7:30 - 7:45 725 720 1% Tiempo de viaje 7:45 - 8:00 720 720 0% Tiempo de viaje (s) Fuente: Elaboración propia a través de PTV VISSIM 7.00, 2019. .=?^F DG NAKLG =F D9 /9:D9 D9 <A>=J=F;A9 IM= =PAKL= =FLJ= D9 EG<=D9;A]F Q DGK <9LGK G:L=FA<GK=FL=JJ=FG<= LA=EHG<=NA9B=Q;AJ;MD9;A]F<=DLJ9FKHGJL=H^:DA;G=KJ=HJ=K=FL9LANG Q9IM=DGKHGJ;=FL9B=K<=<A>=J=F;A9FGKMH=J9F=D -=KH=;LG9D9K<=L=F;AGF=KJ=9DAR9<9KHGJDGKEA;JG:MK=K=F@GJ9HMFL9E9[9F9=KL9K>M=JGF 9BMKL9<9KK=?^FDGNAKLG=FL=JJ=FG 9:=<=KL9;9JIM=D9K<=L=F;AGF=K;GFL9:ADAR9<9KK=JWFD9K N=;=KIM=DGKEA;JG:MK=KK=<=LA=F=F=FDGKH9J9<=JGKAF>GJE9D=K <=:A<G9IM=D9;AJ;MD9;A]F <= DGK EA;JG:MK=K =F =D LJ9EG <= =KLM<AG =K ;GFLAF^9 <=:A<G 9 IM= =K MF9 NY9 HJAF;AH9D 'G E=F;AGF9<G9FL=JAGJE=FL=K=HM=<=G:K=JN9J=FD9/9:D9 Tabla 4.10: Situación actual calibrada de detenciones comparada con lo observado en terreno. Detenciones Resultados calibrados Observado Índice de en terreno mejora Detenciones 7:00 – 7:15 11 11 0% Detenciones 7:15 - 7:30 11 11 0% Detenciones 7:30 - 7:45 11 11 0% Detenciones 7:45 - 8:00 11 11 0% Fuente: Elaboración propia a través de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ropuesta de solución !KL= ;9HYLMDG LA=F= ;GEG G:B=LANG HJ=K=FL9J MF9 9DL=JF9LAN9 <= KGDM;A]F H9J9 =D HJGQ=;LG D9 ;M9DK=;GEHGF=<=E=BGJ9K<=<AK=[GNA9D D9;M9D;GFKAKL==FD9J=<M;;A]F=AEHD=E=FL9;A]F <=H9J9<=JGK>ABGK 9ME=FL9JD9>J=;M=F;A9 Q;9FLA<9<<= EA;JG:MK=K H9J9MF9E=BGJGH=J9;A]F <=D LJ9FKHGJL= H^:DA;G =F =D 9JJAG *b$A??AFK ;=JJG -G;M9FL !KL9 9DL=JF9LAN9 =K KAEMD9<9 E=<A9FL= =D EA;JGKAEMD9<GJ 1%..%( H9J9 G:L=F=J AF<A;9<GJ=K <= J=F<AEA=FLG IM= H=JEAL=F <=L=JEAF9J J=;GE=F<9;AGF=KH9J9D9GH=J9;A]F<=DGKH9J9<=JGK9DGD9J?G<=DWJ=9<==KLM<AG +GKL=JAGJE=FL= =KLGK<9LGKKGF;GEH9J9<GK;GFD9;9DA:J9;A]F=PHM=KL9=F=D;9HYLMDG9FL=JAGJ H9J9=KL9:D=;=JKA=KL99DL=JF9LAN9J=HJ=K=FL9MF9KGDM;A]FGK=<=:=K=?MAJLJ9:9B9F<G=FMF9 HJGHM=KL9IM=J=9DA;=E=BGJ9K=FD9KALM9;A]F9;LM9D<=DHJGQ=;LG 5.1 Propuesta de implementación de paradero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igura 5.1: Layout situación actual con solución. Fuente: Recuperado de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abla 5.1: Identificación de tipo de diseño de paraderos. Paraderos 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 Refugio peatonal √ √ x x x √ x √ Señalización √ √ √ √ √ √ √ √ Fuente: Elaboración propia con datos obtenidos en terreno. Tabla 5.2: Distancia entre paraderos Paraderos Distancia (m) 1a2 2a3 3a4 4a5 5a6 6a7 7a8 225 214 145 100 220 225 285 Fuente: Elaboración propia con datos obtenidos en terreno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igura 5.2: Paradero fijo en red de estudio. Fuente: Recuperado de PTV VISSIM 7.0, 2019. '9"A?MJ9 EM=KLJ9=D<AK=[G<=MFH9J9<=JGIM=IM=<9J=?MD9<G;GFK=[9DAR9;A]F<=:A<G9 IM= =D =KH9;AG >YKA;G FG H=JEAL= D9 AEHD=E=FL9;A]F <= J=>M?AG !KL= LAHG <= J=?MD9;A]F E=<A9FL= MF9 K=[9DAR9;A]F <= H9J9<9 ;MQ9 K=[9DAR9;A]F <=:= =KL9J 9<Q9;=FL=K 9 D9 ;9DR9<9 =FLJ=9HJGPAE9<9E=FL=9 E=LJGK !KHGJ=KLG HGJDGIM= =K 9HDA;9<G9DGKH9J9<=JGK Q <=D=B=IM=K==KLM<A9=F=DHJGQ=;LG Figura 5.3: Paradero con señalización. Fuente: Recuperado de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abla 5.3: Pasajeros que abordan el transporte público. Situación con proyecto Situación actual calibrada % de ocupación Total pasajeros ingresados 7:00- 7:15 104 106 44% Total pasajeros ingresados 7:15- 7:30 98 100 53% Total pasajeros ingresados 7:30- 7:45 92 50 63% Total pasajeros ingresados 7:45- 8:00 96 46 56% Pasajeros (pax/15min) Fuente: Recuperado de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igura 5.4: Pasajeros abordan los microbuses situación calibrada. Fuente: Elaboración propia con datos obtenidos de PTV VISSIM 7.0, 2019. -=KH=;LG 9 DGK EA;JG:MK=K IM= ;AJ;MD9F =F @GJ9 HMFL9 E9[9F9 K= G:LA=F= MF =F =D YF<A;=<=E=BGJ9 <=:A<G9IM=;MEHD=;GFDG=PHM=KLGHGJ/(1 <=<G;=EA;JG:MK=K =F;AJ;MD9;A]F ;GFMF9>J=;M=F;A9<=;M9LJGEAFMLGK=FLJ==DD9K DGE=F;AGF9<G9FL=JAGJE=FL= K=NAKM9DAR9=FD9/9:D9 Tabla 5.4:Comparación de circulación de buses de transporte público. Transporte público (bus/15min) Situación Situación Índice de mejora actual con calibrada proyecto Promedio circulación de buses 7:00- 7:15 3 2 33% Promedio circulación de buses 7:15- 7:30 4 2 50% Promedio circulación de buses 7:30 - 7:45 3 1 67% Promedio circulación de buses 7:45- 8:00 2 1 50% Fuente: Recuperado de PTV VISSIM 7.0, 2019. ;GFLAFM9;A]F =F D9 "A?MJ9 K= J=9DAR9 ;GEH9J9;A]F ?JW>A;9 =FLJ= D9 ;AJ;MD9;A]F <=D LJ9FKHGJL=H^:DA;GIM=HJ=K=FL9D9KALM9;A]F9;LM9D;9DA:J9<9QD9HJGHM=KL9<=KGDM;A]F Figura 5.5: Gráfico comparativo de microbuses en circulación. Fuente: Elaboración propia a través de datos obtenidos desde VISSIM 7.0, 2019. +GKL=JAGJE=FL= =DLA=EHG<=NA9B=<=DGKEA;JG:MK=K QDGKH9K9B=JGK =FJ=;GJJ=J=DLJ9EG=F =KLM<AG<AKEAFMQ= <=<G;=EAFMLGK9KA=L=EAFMLGK DGIM==IMAN9D=9MF =F=DYF<A;=<= E=BGJ9;GEGK=EM=KLJ9=FD9/9:D9 Tabla 5.5: Comparación de tiempos de viajes Situación Situación con proyecto actual Tiempo de viaje (s) (s) calibrada en (s) Índice de mejora 7:00- 7:15 463,08 720 55% 7:15- 7:30 465,16 720 55% 7:30- 7:45 462,99 720 54% 7:45- 8:00 463,63 720 55% Fuente: Recuperado de PTV VISSIM 7.0, 2019. !F D9 "A?MJ9 K= HJ=K=FL9 ?JW>A;G <= ;GEH9J9;A]F <= J=KMDL9<GK =FLJ= D9 KALM9;A]F 9;LM9D ;9DA:J9<9QKALM9;A]FHJGHM=KL9 Figura 5.6: Gráfico diferencia de tiempo de viaje. Fuente: Elaboración propia con datos obtenidos desde VISSIM 7.0, 2019. -=KH=;LG9D9K<=L=F;AGF=K<=DGKEA;JG:MK=KIM=;AJ;MD9F=F;=JJG-G;M9FL <AKEAFMQ=<=:A<G 9D9AEHD=E=FL9;A]F<=H9J9<=JGK>ABGK Q<=N9DD9KH=9LGF9D=K =K AEHGJL9FL= ;GFKA<=J9JIM=D9K <=L=F;AGF=KKGF;GFL9:ADAR9<9K=FD9KN=;=KIM==DLJ9FKHGJL=H^:DA;GK=<=LA=F=H9J9D9LGE9 <=H9K9B=JGK 'GE=F;AGF9<G9FL=JAGJ G:DA?99DGKH=9LGF=KJ=KA<=FL=K<=DK=;LGJ=KH=J9J=FDGK DM?9J=K<==KH=J9 GEGJ=KMDL9<GK=G:LA=F=MFYF<A;=<=E=BGJ9<=MF 'G=PHM=KLGK= G:K=JN9=FD9/9:D9 Tabla 5.6: Indicador de rendimiento de propuesta de solución Situación Situación Detenciones (det/bus) con proyecto actual (det/veh) calibrada Índice de mejora Detenciones 7:00- 7:15 8 11 37% Detenciones 7:15- 7:30 8 11 37% Detenciones 7:30- 7:45 8 11 37% Detenciones 7:45- 8:00 8 11 37% Fuente: Recuperado de PTV VISSIM 7.0, 2019 !F D9 "A?MJ9 K= HJ=K=FL9 ?JW>A;G <= ;GEH9J9;A]F <= J=KMDL9<GK =FLJ= D9 KALM9;A]F 9;LM9D ;9DA:J9<9QKALM9;A]FHJGHM=KL9 Figura 5.7: Gráfico diferencia detenciones Fuente: Elaboración propia con datos obtenidos desde VISSIM 7.0, 2019. +GJ GLJG D9<G ;GFKA<=J9F<G D9 DGF?ALM< <=D LJ9EG =F =KLM<AG K= HM=<= <=L=JEAF9J IM= D9 N=DG;A<9< ;GE=J;A9D 9ME=FL99 6CE @7 QN=DG;A<9<<=J=;GJJA<G K=E9FLA=F==F 6CE @7 <=:A<G9D9K;9J9;L=JYKLA;9K>YKA;9KIM= HGK===DK=;LGJ Q;GFKA<=J9F<GIM==D=KLM<AG=K=F=D LJ9EG <= :9B9<9 !K AEHGJL9FL= L=F=J =F ;M=FL9 IM= DGK ;=JJGK <= 19DH9J9YKG K= ;9J9;L=JAR9F HGJ KMK HJGFMF;A9<9K H=F<A=FL=K =:A<G 9 DG 9FL=JAGJ =D J=KMDL9<G G:L=FA<G KA?M= KA=F<G J=HJ=K=FL9LANG9DGNAKLG=FL=JJ=FG "AF9DE=FL= D9 KALM9;A]F HJGQ=;L9<9 9JJGB9 MF9 <AKEAFM;A]F =F DGK LA=EHGK <= NA9B=K MF 9ME=FLG=FD9;AJ;MD9;A]F=FDGKEA;JG:MK=K Q<AKEAFM;A]F<=D9K<=L=F;AGF=KIM=J=9DAR9:9=D LJ9FKHGJL= DG IM= ?=F=J9 MF9 E=BGJ9 =F D9K ;GF<A;AGF=K 9;LM9D=K L9FLG H9J9 =D LJ9FKHGJL= H^:DA;G;GEGH9J9DGKMKM9JAGKJ=KA<=FL=K<=DK=;LGJ =:A<G9D9AEHD=E=FL9;A]F<=H9J9<=JGK >ABGK 9ME=FLG=FD9;AJ;MD9;A]F<=EA;JG:MK=K Q>J=;M=F;A9<= =KLGK 9JJGB9IM==DYF<A;=<= E=BGJ9=K<=MF Conclusión y futuros trabajos !D HJ=K=FL= HJGQ=;LG K= <=K9JJGDD9 H9J9 <AKEAFMAJ LA=EHGK <= NA9B= Q <=L=F;AGF=K <=D ;=JJG -G;M9FL =D G:B=LANG =K AEHD=E=FL9J H9J9<=JGK Q 9ME=FL9J D9 ;9FLA<9< <= EA;JG:MK=K IM= ;AJ;MD9F=F=DK=;LGJ <=:A<G9IM==D;=JJGFG;M=FL9;GF=DK=JNA;AG<=LJ9FKHGJL=9<=;M9<GQ ;GFMF<AK=[GNA9D9;LM9DAR9<G DGD9J?G<=D<=K9JJGDDG<=DHJGQ=;LGIM=<9J=>D=B9<GIM=FG KGDGK==F;M=FLJ9F<=K9;LM9DAR9<GK=FKM<AK=[G KAFGIM=K==F;M=FLJ9F;GF MF:9BGF^E=JG <=EA;JG:MK=KIM=J=9DAR9F=DJ=;GJJA<G=F;=JJG-G;M9FL =F;GFLJWF<GK=9;LM9DE=FL=;GFKGDG K=AK EA;JG:MK=K ;GF MF9 >J=;M=F;A9 <= EAFMLGK !F ;GFK=;M=F;A9 DGK MKM9JAGK L9J<9F =F DD=?9J9 KMK <=KLAFGK <=:A<G9D9K D9J?9K=KH=J9K<= D9KDD=?9<9K<=EA;JG:MK=K H9J9=DAFA;AG<=D J=;GJJA<G ;GEGL9E:AXF <=D9K>J=;M=FL=KH9J9<9KIM=J=9DAR9=DLJ9FKHGJL= H9J9D9LGE9<= H9K9B=JGK 'M=?G <= <=K9JJGDD9J D9 KALM9;A]F ;GF HJGQ=;LG =F =D EA;JGAEMD9<GJ +/1 1%..%( K= G:LMNG IM=D9KGDM;A]FHJGHM=KL9 D9;M9D;GFKAKL==FD9AEHD=E=FL9;A]F<=H9J9<=JGK >GJE9D=K >ABGK 9ME=FL9J9<G;= EA;JG:MK=K=F;AJ;MD9;A]FJ=KMDL9=>A;A=FL=<=:A<G9IM=<AKEAFMQ] DGK LA=EHGK<=NA9B= <=EAFMLGK9EAFMLGK=FJ=;GJJ=JD9J=< 9D<AKEAFMAJD9>J=;M=F;A9<= DGKEA;JG:MK=K9EAFMLGK=FLJ==DDGK <AKEAFMQ=L9E:AXF D9K=KH=J9K<=DGKH9K9B=JGK =FDGK H9J9<=JGKQ>AF9DE=FL= <AKEAFMQ=F D9K;GFKL9FL=K<=L=F;AGF=KIM=<=:Y9J=9DAR9J=DLJ9FKHGJL= H^:DA;G9DFG;GFL9J;GFH9J9<=JGK<=>AFA<GK 'G9FL=JAGJ?=F=J9MFAEH9;LGHGKALANGH9J9DGK J=KA<=FL=K <= ;=JJG -G;M9FL Q9 IM= <AKEAFMQ= <= E9F=J9 ;GFKA<=J9:D= DGK AF<A;9<GJ=K <= J=F<AEA=FLG ;GF MF =F D9K <=L=F;AGF=K =F LA=EHG <= NA9B= Q =F MF =F D9 >J=;M=F;A9<=DGKEA;JG:MK=K J=KH=;LG9D9KALM9;A]F9;LM9D .A:A=FDGE=F;AGF9<G9FL=JAGJE=FL= =KMF>9;LGJAEHGJL9FL=H9J9=D;=JJG=F=KLM<AG K=<=:= K=?MAJLJ9:9B9F<G=F=D<AK=[GNA9D<=LG<G;=JJG-G;M9FL<=:A<G9 IM=FGK==F;M=FLJ9;GFD9K ;GF<A;AGF=K 9<=;M9<9KH9J9D9 ;AJ;MD9;A]F<=N=@Y;MDGK Q LJ9FKHGJL= !KHGJ=KLG HGJDGIM= ;GEG LJ9:9BG >MLMJG K= KM?A=J= =D J=<AK=[G NA9D <= LG<G ;=JJG -G;M9FL <GF<= =PAKL9 D9 AEHD=E=FL9;A]F <= E=<A<9K <= EALA?9;A]F H9NAE=FL9;A]F <= NY9K Q 9;=J9K =PAKL=FL=K =F =D K=;LGJ<==KLM<AG !F D9 9;LM9DA<9< <=:A<G 9 MF9 ;9LWKLJG>= G;MJJA<9 =D <A;A=E:J= <=D =F =D ;=JJG <= =KLM<AG K=<99;GFG;=JIM=D9KNY9KIM=;GEHGF=F-G;M9FLFG=KLWFAFK;JAL9KQJ=?MD9JAR9<9K =F=D(MFA;AHAG<=19DH9J9YKG =DK=;LGJ>A?MJ9;GEGWJ=9N=J<= 'G9FL=JAGJ BMKLA>A;9IM=@GQ =F<Y9;=JJG-G;M9FLFG;M=FL=;GFD9KE=<A<9K<=EALA?9;A]F Q <AK=[GNA9DJ=IM=JA<G "AF9DE=FL= ;GEGLJ9:9BG>MLMJGK=<=:=AEHD=E=FL9JMF9KMH=JNAKA]F=AFKH=;;A]F;GFKL9FL= 9D =KL9<G <= DGK EA;JG:MK=K H=JL=F=;A=FL=K 9 D9 DYF=9 IM= ;AJ;MD9 =F ;=JJG -G;M9FL <=:A<G 9 IM=D9=EHJ=K9KA;M=FL9;GFD9KE9IMAF9JA9K F=;=K9JA9K H9J9K9LAK>9;=JD9<=E9F<9IM==PAKL= @GQ=F=DK=;LGJ<==KLM<AG KAF=E:9J?G FGJ=9DAR9F D9K E9FL=F;AGF=K9<=;M9<9KH9J9=D:M=F >MF;AGF9EA=FLG<= XKL9K Referencias LAK:9 =KHG:D9EA=FLG <= 19DH9J9YKG -=;MH=J9<G 9:JAD <= <= @LLH OOO 9LAK:9 ;D OH ;GFL=FL MHDG9<K -=HGJL= LAK:9 (GFALGJ =FKG 19DH9J9 KG DGO H<> GJHGJ9;A]F +9J9<=JGK Q J=>M?AGK H=9LGF9D=K ;D9N=K =F D9 ;9<=F9 <=D LJ9FKHGJL= H^:DA;G9;;=KA:D= ,/-,/!'?+!'2""!!#0' )# CADE – IDEPE (1988). Investigación de análisis y seguimiento de transporte público. Informe final, Intendencia del a Región Metropolitana, Santiago. J9A? + <=BMFAG<= 'YF=9<=LJ9FKHGJL= ! '9::X !FLJ=NAKL9<GJ EBTU (1982). Tratamento preferencial ao transporte coletivo por ônibus. Empresa Brasileira dos Transportes Urbanos, Ministerio dos Transportes, Brasilia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nexos Anexo 1 " Tabla A1.1: Conteo primera estación de transferencia. " % #"# #"# $ $ $ %##!% %##!% "( " #"# " #"# # # "" $ # '%# $ # ' $ $ %"$## Fuente: Elaboración propia con datos tomado en terreno, 2019. " Tabla A1.2: Conteo segunda estación de transferencia. " % #"# #"# $ $ $ %##!% %##!% "" ( " #"# " #"# # # "" $ # ' $ # ' $ $ %"$## Fuente: Elaboración propia con datos tomado en terreno, 2019. Tabla A1.3: Conteo tercera estación de transferencia. % #"# " " $ $ $ %##!% %##!% "" ( # # "" $ $ %"$## " $ # #"# ' " $ # #"# ' #"# Fuente: Elaboración propia con datos tomado en terreno, 2019. " Tabla A1.4: Conteo cuarta estación de transferencia. " % #"# #"# $ $ $ %##!% %##!% "" ( " #"# " #"# # # "" $ # ' $ # ' $ $ %"$## Fuente: Elaboración propia con datos tomados en terreno, 2019. Tabla A1.5: Conteo quinta estación de transferencia. % #"# " #"# " $ $ $ %##!% %##!% "" ( # # "" $ $ %"$## " $ # #"# ' " $ # #"# ' Fuente: Elaboración propia con datos tomados en terreno, 2019. " Tabla A1.6: Conteo sexta estación de transferencia. " % #"# #"# $ $ $ %##!% %##!% "( " #"# " #"# # # "" $ # ' $ # ' $ $ %"$## Fuente: Elaboración propia con datos tomado en terreno, 2019. " Tabla A1.7: Conteo séptima estación de transferencia. " % #"# #"# $ $ $ %##!% %##!% "( " #"# " #"# # # "" $ # ' $ # ' $ $ %"$## Fuente: Elaboración propia con datos tomado en terreno, 2019. " Tabla A1.8: Conteo octava estación de transferencia. " % #"# #"# $ $ $ %##!% %##!% "( " #"# " #"# # # "" $ # ' $ # ' $ $ %"$## Fuente: Elaboración propia con datos tomados en terreno, 2019. " Tabla A1.9: Conteo novena estación de transferencia. " % #"# #"# $ $ $ %##!% %##!% "( " #"# " #"# # # "" $ # ' $ # ' $ $ %"$## Fuente: Elaboración propia con datos tomados en terreno, 2019. " Tabla A1.10: Conteo décima estación de transferencia. " % #"# #"# $ $ $ %##!% %##!% "( " #"# " #"# # # "" $ # ' $ # ' $ $ %"$## Fuente: Elaboración de transferencia con datos tomados en terreno, 2019. " Tabla A1.11: Conteo último paradero en estudio " % #"# #"# $ $ $ %## %## "( " #"# " #"# !%# !%# "" $ # ' $ # ' $ $ %"$## Fuente: Elaboración propia con datos obtenidos en terreno, 2019. Anexo 2 Figura A2.1:Segundo paradero informal. Fuente: Recuperado de Google Maps, 2019. Figura A2.2: Tercer paradero informal. Fuente: Recuperado de Google Maps, 2019. Figura A2.3: Cuarto paradero informal. Fuente: Recuperado de Google Maps, 2019. Figura A2.4: Quinto paradero informal. Fuente: Recuperado de Google Maps, 2019. Figura A2.5: Sexto paradero informal. Fuente: Recuperado de Google Maps, 2019. Figura A2.6: Séptimo paradero informal. Fuente: Recuperado de Google Maps, 2019. Figura A2.7: Octavo paradero informal. Fuente: Recuperado de Google Maps, 2019. Figura A2.8: Noveno paradero informal. Fuente: Recuperado de Google Maps, 2019. Figura A2.9: Décimo paradero informal. Fuente: Recuperado de Google Maps, 2019. Figura A2.10: Undécimo paradero informal. Fuente: Recuperado de Google Maps,2019. Figura A2.11: Duodécimo paradero informal. Fuente: Recuperado de Google Maps,2019.