Criterio jurídico garantista 8 issn: 2145-3381 - Año 3 - No. 4 - Enero-Junio de 2011 Razón, sentimientos y derechos humanos* -25*(6,(55$ Fundación Universidad Autónoma de Colombia (FUAC) 5(680(1 (OREMHWLYRGHHVWHHVFULWRHVH[SRQHU\HYDOXDUORVDUJXPHQWRVTXH(UQVW7XJHQGKDWSUHVHQWDDIDYRUGHGRVWHVLV/D SULPHUDWHVLVDILUPDTXHHOLPSHUDWLYRFDWHJyULFRNDQWLDQRHVHO~QLFRSULQFLSLRSODXVLEOHHQWUHWRGRVORVSULQFLSLRVPR UDOHVQRWUDVFHQGHQWHVTXHH[LVWHQ/DVHJXQGDWHVLVDILUPDTXHFRQEDVHHQWDOSULQFLSLRHVSRVLEOHGDUXQIXQGDPHQWR VyOLGRSDUDORVGHUHFKRVKXPDQRV$UJXPHQWDUHPRVTXHODVFUtWLFDVGH7XJHQGKDWDOXWLOLWDULVPRTXHFRQVLGHUDFRPRVX DGYHUVDULRPiVIXHUWHHQVXE~VTXHGDGHXQSULQFLSLRpWLFRSODXVLEOHQRVRQWDQFRQWXQGHQWHVFRPRpOVXSRQH\TXHOD QRFLyQUHYLVDGDGHLPSHUDWLYRFDWHJyULFRTXHSURSRQHHVHQHOIRQGRHTXLYDOHQWHDXQSULQFLSLRXWLOLWDULVWDPiVH[DFWD PHQWHDOSULQFLSLRGHLJXDOFRQVLGHUDFLyQGHLQWHUHVHVIRUPXODGRHQSRU3HWHU6LQJHU3HURVLELHQORTXHWHUPLQD SRUDGPLWLU7XJHQGKDWHVHQUHDOLGDGXQSULQFLSLRXWLOLWDULVWDVHQLHJDDUHFRQRFHUORVDOFDQFHVTXHWLHQHWDOSULQFLSLRHQ UHODFLyQFRQODGHIHQVDGHORVGHUHFKRVGHORVDQLPDOHVHODERUWR\ODREOLJDFLyQGHD\XGDU)LQDOPHQWHH[DPLQDUHPRVHO WUDWDPLHQWRTXH7XJHQGKDWKDFHGHOWHPDGHORVGHUHFKRVKXPDQRVDODOX]GHOSHQVDPLHQWRGH5RUW\SDUDPRVWUDUTXHOD DSHODFLyQDORVVHQWLPLHQWRVPRUDOHVDQXODODQHFHVLGDGGHEXVFDUXQIXQGDPHQWRSDUDWDOHVGHUHFKRV(VWHKHFKRWDPELpQ FRQWULEX\HDPRVWUDUTXHODSURSXHVWDpWLFDPiVSODXVLEOHHVHOXWLOLWDULVPRHOFXDOHVDItQFRQHOSHQVDPLHQWRURUWLDQR 3$/$%5$6&/$9(MXVWLILFDFLyQPRUDOVHQWLPLHQWRVPRUDOHVGHUHFKRVKXPDQRVDQWLUUHDOLVPRDQWLIXQGDFLRQDOLVPR VROLGDULGDGXWLOLWDULVPRLPSHUDWLYRFDWHJyULFRIDOLELOLVPRSUDJPDWLVPR )HFKDGHUHFHSFLyQ )HFKDGHDFHSWDFLyQ (ODUWtFXORHVUHVXOWDGRGHOLQWHUpVGHODXWRUHQODILORVRItDGH5RUW\7LHQHTXHYHUFRQVXSUHSDUDFLyQSDUDHOSUR\HFWRGHLQYHVWL JDFLyQHQHOTXHDERUGDODUHODFLyQHQWUHpWLFD\OLWHUDWXUDHQ5RUW\UHFLHQWHPHQWHDYDODGRSRU&ROFLHQFLDVHLQVFULWRHQHOJUXSR GHLQYHVWLJDFLyQ*UDItD 'RFHQWHLQYHVWLJDGRUGHWLHPSRFRPSOHWRGHOD8QLYHUVLGDG$XWyQRPDGH&RORPELD)LOyVRIRGHOD8QLYHUVLGDG1DFLRQDO\0DJtVWHU HQILORVRItDGHOD8QLYHUVLGDGGHORV$QGHV$FWXDOPHQWHUHDOL]DHVWXGLRVGH'RFWRUDGRHQILORVRItDHQOD8QLYHUVLGDG1DFLRQDO MRUJHPLOO#KRWPDLOFRP Razón, sentimientos y derechos humanos Páginas 8 a 33 9 3HURDXQTXHODUD]yQFXDQGRVHYHFXPSOLGDPHQWHDVLVWLGD\PHMRUDGDVHDVXILFLHQWHSDUDLQVWUXLU QRVDFHUFDGHVLODVWHQGHQFLDVGHODVFXDOLGDGHV\GHODVDFFLRQHVVRQSHUQLFLRVDVRVRQ~WLOHVQR HVSRUVtVRODVXILFLHQWHSDUDSURGXFLUQLQJXQDFHQVXUDRDSUREDFLyQPRUDO/DXWLOLGDGHVVyOROD WHQGHQFLDKDFLDXQFLHUWRILQ\VLHOILQQRVUHVXOWDUDWRWDOPHQWHLQGLIHUHQWHKDEUtDPRVGHVHQWLUOD PLVPDLQGLIHUHQFLDKDFLDORVPHGLRV6HUHTXLHUHSXHVTXHXQVHQWLPLHQWRVHPDQLILHVWHDILQGHGDU SUHIHUHQFLDDODVWHQGHQFLDV~WLOHVVREUHODVSHUQLFLRVDV(VWHVHQWLPLHQWRQRSXHGHVHURWURTXHXQ VHQWLPLHQWRDIDYRUGHODIHOLFLGDGGHOJpQHURKXPDQR\XQUHVHQWLPLHQWRSRUVXGHVGLFKDSXHVVRQ HVWRVORVGRVGLIHUHQWHVILQHVTXHODYLUWXG\HOYLFLRWLHQGHQDSURPRYHU$TXtSRUWDQWRODUD]yQ QRVLQVWUX\HDFHUFDGHODVYDULDVWHQGHQFLDVGHODVDFFLRQHV\HOVHQWLPLHQWRKXPDQLWDULRKDFHXQD GLVWLQFLyQDIDYRUGHDTXHOODVTXHVRQ~WLOHV\EHQHILFLRVDV Introducción (OREMHWLYRGHHVWHHVFULWRHVH[SRQHU\HYDOXDUORV DUJXPHQWRVTXH7XJHQGKDWSUHVHQWDDIDYRUGH GRVWHVLVIXQGDPHQWDOHV/DSULPHUDWHVLVDILUPD TXHHOLPSHUDWLYRFDWHJyULFRNDQWLDQR´HVHOPiV DFRQVHMDEOH HO ~QLFR SODXVLEOH HQWUH WRGRV ORV SULQFLSLRVPRUDOHVQRWUDVFHQGHQWHVTXHH[LVWHQµ /DVHJXQGDWHVLVDILUPDTXHFRQEDVHHQWDOSULQ FLSLRHVSRVLEOHGDUXQIXQGDPHQWRVyOLGRSDUDORV GHUHFKRVKXPDQRV $UJXPHQWDUHPRVTXHODVFUtWLFDVGH7XJHQGKDW DOXWLOLWDULVPRTXHFRQVLGHUDFRPRVXDGYHUVDULR PiVIXHUWHHQVXE~VTXHGDGHXQSULQFLSLRpWLFR SODXVLEOHQRVRQWDQFRQWXQGHQWHVFRPRpOVXSRQH \TXHODQRFLyQUHYLVDGDGHLPSHUDWLYRFDWHJyULFR TXHSURSRQHHVHQHOIRQGRHTXLYDOHQWHDXQSULQ FLSLR XWLOLWDULVWD PiV H[DFWDPHQWH DO SULQFLSLR GHLJXDOFRQVLGHUDFLyQGHLQWHUHVHVIRUPXODGRHQ SRU3HWHU6LQJHU3HURVLELHQORTXHWHUPLQD SRUDGPLWLU7XJHQGKDWHVHQUHDOLGDGXQSULQFL +80( SLRXWLOLWDULVWDVHQLHJDDUHFRQRFHUORVDOFDQFHV TXHWLHQHWDOSULQFLSLRHQUHODFLyQFRQODGHIHQVD GH ORV GHUHFKRV GH ORV DQLPDOHV HO DERUWR \ OD REOLJDFLyQGHD\XGDU)LQDOPHQWHH[DPLQDUHPRV HOWUDWDPLHQWRTXH7XJHQGKDWKDFHGHOWHPDGH ORVGHUHFKRVKXPDQRVDODOX]GHOSHQVDPLHQWR GH 5RUW\ SDUD PRVWUDU TXH OD DSHODFLyQ D ORV VHQWLPLHQWRVPRUDOHVDQXODODQHFHVLGDGGHEXVFDU XQIXQGDPHQWRSDUDWDOHVGHUHFKRV(VWHKHFKR WDPELpQFRQWULEX\HDPRVWUDUTXHODPRUDOPiV SODXVLEOHHVHOXWLOLWDULVPRHOFXDOHVDItQFRQHO SHQVDPLHQWRURUWLDQR De los motivos a las razones 8QDGHODVFXHVWLRQHVIXQGDPHQWDOHVGHODpWLFD WLHQHTXHYHUFRQHOSUREOHPDGHODPRWLYDFLyQ PRUDOHVWRHVFRQHODVXQWRGHTXHHQpWLFDQR EDVWDFRQGHILQLUTXpHVORFRUUHFWRROREXHQR VLQRTXHHVSUHFLVRH[SOLFDUWDPELpQTXpPRWLYD DODVSHUVRQDVDKDFHUHOELHQ(QHOFDVRGH7X 78*(1'+$7(Lecciones de ética%DUFHORQD*HGLVDSiJ 9HU6,1*(53Ética práctica/RQGUHV&DPEULGJH8QLYHUVLW\3UHVVFDStWXORVD Criterio jurídico garantista 10 issn: 2145-3381 - Año 3 - No. 4 - Enero-Junio de 2011 JHQGKDWHVWHSUREOHPDHVWiHQFRQH[LyQHVWUHFKD FRQHOSUREOHPDGHODVUD]RQHVSDUDDFWXDU&RPR YHUHPRV 7XJHQGKDW GLIHUHQFLDUi HQWUH UD]RQHV \PRWLYRVQRVLHQGRMDPiVORVPRWLYRVUD]RQHV SDUDDFWXDU8QDWHRUtDFRUUHFWDGHODPRWLYDFLyQ PRUDO GHEH GHMDU HVSDFLR SDUD ODV UD]RQHV TXH VRQODVTXHHQGHILQLWLYDSHUPLWLUiQKDEODUGHXQ SULQFLSLRGHHQMXLFLDPLHQWRPRUDO&RPHQ]DUpSRU DQDOL]DUHVWHSXQWR VHUDSUREDGRSRUDTXHODFX\RDPRUQROHRWRUJDV YDORUµFRPRPHGLRSDUDVXSHUDUODVOLPLWDFLRQHV GHOPRGHORRULJLQDOH[SOLFDWLYRGHODPRWLYDFLyQ TXHVyORVHDWHQtDDODVUHODFLRQHVSUy[LPDV3HUR OR GHFLVLYR GHO WUDWDPLHQWR GH OD PRWLYDFLyQ GH 6PLWKWLHQHTXHYHUFRQODSRVLELOLGDGGHVHSDUDUHO FRQFHSWRGHVHUGLJQRGHDSUREDFLyQGHOFRQFHSWR GHVHUDSUREDGRFRPRFRQVWLWXWLYRGHODQRFLyQGH FRQFLHQFLDPRUDO(VSRUTXHWHQHPRVODFDSDFLGDG GH VHU FRQVFLHQWHV GH KDEHUQRV FRPSRUWDGR GH 7XJHQGKDWFRPLHQ]DH[DPLQDQGRODWHRUtDGHOD PDQHUD GLJQD DXQ FXDQGR VH QRV UHSUXHEH SRU PRWLYDFLyQGH$GDP6PLWKTXLHQHVWDEOHFLyTXH HOORORTXHQRVSHUPLWHQRVHQWLUQRVFXOSDEOHV ODPRWLYDFLyQPRUDOWLHQHTXHYHUFRQHOVHUDSUR 'H PDQHUD FRUUHVSRQGLHQWH VDEHU TXH DOJXLHQ EDGRMXVWLILFDGRGHVGHHOSXQWRGHYLVWDGHORE QRVRGLD\VHLQGLJQDFRQQRVRWURV\QRREVWDQWH VHUYDGRULPSDUFLDO'HKHFKRORVVHUHVKXPDQRV VRPRVHORJLDGRVHVFDXVDGHSHUYHUVLyQPRUDO SRUQDWXUDOH]DTXHUHPRVVHUDPDGRV\DJUDGDU SHURWDPELpQTXHUHPRVVHUDSUREDGRVHQQXHVWUDV /DFRQFLHQFLDPRUDOSRUORWDQWRHVWiYLQFXODGD DFFLRQHV\PRGRGHVHU7XJHQGKDWOHFRQFHGHD FRQHOSULQFLSLRGHTXH´(OWHPRUDVHUGLJQRVGH 6PLWKTXHQRHVQHFHVDULRXQIXQGDPHQWRPiVDOOi UHSUREDFLyQHVPD\RUTXHHOWHPRUDVHUUHSUR GHODVLPSDWtD\GHODQHFHVLGDGGHVLPSDWtDQDWX EDGRVµ(OHOHPHQWRGHFLVLYRUHVLGHHQWRQFHVHQ UDOSDUDH[SOLFDUODPRWLYDFLyQPRUDOHLQFOXVR HO SRGHU GLIHUHQFLDU HO VHU DSUHFLDGR R HORJLDGR SDUDFRQVLGHUDUODFRPR´HOPRWLYRPiVLQHTXtYRFR FRUUHFWDPHQWH GHO VHU HORJLDGR IiFWLFR R LQFR SDUD TXHUHU FRQVLGHUDUVH FRPR PLHPEUR GH OD UUHFWR(OVHUGLJQRGHDSUHFLRQRVHGHULYDGHO FRPXQLGDG PRUDO \ WDPELpQ SDUD TXHUHU REUDU VHUDSUHFLDGR6LHOVHUGLJQRGHDSUHFLRDVSLUDD PRUDOPHQWHµ3HVHDHOOR7XJHQGKDWQRTXLHUH REMHWLYLGDGHOODVyORVHSXHGHGHULYDUGHOREVHUYD FRPSURPHWHUVHFRQXQ´GRJPDWLVPRDQWURSROy GRULPSDUFLDO6HUGLJQRGHDSUHFLRVyORVHSXHGH JLFRµSRUORFXDOVXJLHUHILMDUVHPiVELHQHQODV HVWDEOHFHUREMHWLYDPHQWHGHVGHXQSXQWRGHYLVWD FRQH[LRQHVFRQFHSWXDOHVLPSOLFDGDVHQHODVXQWR LPSDUFLDO'HKHFKR´(OHVSHFWDGRULPSDUFLDOHV TXHHQGHIHQGHUTXHVHHVWiKDFLHQGRXQDFRUUHFWD ODLGHDUHJXODWLYDGHODSUREDUPLVPR\HVWDLGHD GHVFULSFLyQGHODQDWXUDOH]DKXPDQD3RUHMHPSOR UHJXODWLYD SHUWHQHFH DO DSUREDU « GHVGH HO VL DOJXLHQ TXLHUH VHU DPDGR HQWRQFHV WDPELpQ SULQFLSLRSRUTXHWDOSUHWHQVLyQREMHWLYDHVDOJR TXLHUHVHUDSUREDGR,QFOXVRHVSRVLEOHSODQWHDU LQKHUHQWHDOVHQWLGRGHDSUREDUµ(QFRQVHFXHQ TXH ´WH UHVXOWD DVLPLVPR LPSRUWDQWH DJUDGDU \ FLDHVLPSRVLEOHDSUREDUDDOJXLHQVLQMX]JDUOR 60,7+$La teoría de los sentimientos morales0DGULG$OLDQ]D 78*(1'+$7(Lecciones de ética%DUFHORQD*HGLVDSiJ ,EtG ,EtGSiJ Razón, sentimientos y derechos humanos Páginas 8 a 33 11 /DVYLUWXGHVTXHVRQ~WLOHV HQODVUHODFLRQHV FRQORVGHPiVSUHVXSRQHQ TXHXQRVHLQWHUHVD SRUHOELHQHVWDUGHORVGHPiV \HOORGHVFDQVDVREUH HOVHQWLPLHQWRGH EHQHYROHQFLDRGHVLPSDWtD FRPR EXHQR 7XJHQKDW FRQVLGHUD TXH OD WHRUtD DVSHFWRVQRUPDWLYRVTXHGHEHQVHUDERUGDGRV GHODPRWLYDFLyQGH6PLWKHVVyOLGDDOSHUPLWLU GHVGHHOSXQWRGHYLVWDGHOREVHUYDGRULPSDU VHSDUDU HO DSUREDU GH OR GLJQR GH DSUREDFLyQ FLDO HVWRHVYHUFRQFODULGDGTXHODDSUREDFLyQKDOOD /DHTXLYRFDFLyQVHUHODFLRQDFRQODGLILFXOWDGGH VXOHJLWLPLGDGHQUD]RQHV\HQFRQVHFXHQFLDHQ GHWHUPLQDUTXLpQHVFRQVWLWX\HQODFRPXQLGDG XQSULQFLSLRGHHQMXLFLDPLHQWRPRUDO¢3HURFXiO PRUDO 1R VH VDEH VL HO HVSHFWDGRU LPSDUFLDO HVHVHSULQFLSLR\FyPRVHGHWHUPLQD" SXHGHVHUFXDOTXLHUVHUKXPDQRRHOPLHPEUR GH XQD FRPXQLGDG PRUDO GHWHUPLQDGD 3DUD 6PLWK HO HVSHFWDGRU LPSDUFLDO HV FXDOTXLHU El imperativo categórico como único principio VHUKXPDQRDXQTXHHVWRQRORH[FOX\HVHJ~Q moral plausible 7XJHQGKDW GH FDHU HQ HO HWQRFHQWULVPR /D ~QLFDIRUPDGHQRFDHUHQpOVHUtDHVWDEOHFLHQGR /DREMHWLYLGDGGHODPRUDOSDUHFHSUHVXSRQHUOD XQDQRFLyQGHEXHQRDWUDYpVGHXQDVQRUPDV SRVLELOLGDGGHHVWDEOHFHUFXiQGRXQMXLFLRPRUDO WUDQVFXOWXUDOHVYiOLGDV HVWi HTXLYRFDGR\ FXiQGRHV FRUUHFWR'HVGH HO 3RGHPRVFXHVWLRQDUORDFHUWDGRGHXQDQRUPD SXQWRGHYLVWDREMHWLYLVWDGHOREVHUYDGRULPSDU GHVGH HO SXQWR GH YLVWD GH VX OHJLWLPLGDG R FLDOH[LVWHQYDULRVQLYHOHVHQORVTXHVHSXHGHGDU MXVWLILFDFLyQ3HURVLQRH[LVWHXQDMXVWLILFDFLyQ XQIDOORHQORVMXLFLRVPRUDOHVDVDEHU DEVROXWDSDUDORVSULQFLSLRVPRUDOHVHQWRQFHV /DHTXLYRFDFLyQVHSUHVHQWDHQTXLHQMX]JDSRU ¢TXpDOWHUQDWLYDQRVTXHGD" IDOWDGHLQIRUPDFLyQ$TXtHOHUURUHVHPStULFR \QRQRUPDWLYR $TXtODVDOLGDGH7XJHQGKDWHVLQJHQLRVDVLELHQ /DHTXLYRFDFLyQUHVLGHHQTXHODVLWXDFLyQHV QRSRGHPRVMXVWLILFDUUDFLRQDOPHQWHHOSULQFLSLR HPStULFDPHQWH FRPSOHMD \ H[LVWHQ P~OWLSOHV GHODPRUDOVtTXHSRGHPRVFRPSDUDUGLYHUVRV Criterio jurídico garantista 12 issn: 2145-3381 - Año 3 - No. 4 - Enero-Junio de 2011 SULQFLSLRVSDUDHOHJLUHOPiVUDFLRQDORSODXVLEOH $XQTXHWDOFRPSDUDFLyQQRVHUtDQHFHVDULDVLVH DFHSWDUDTXHHOSULQFLSLRGHOHVSHFWDGRULPSDUFLDO HVVXILFLHQWHSDUDFRQVWUXLUXQDpWLFDXQLYHUVDO 3HURVHJ~Q7XJHQGKDWHOSULQFLSLRWLHQHVHULDV OLPLWDFLRQHV LGLRVLQFUiWLFDV SXHV HO REVHUYDGRU LPSDUFLDOREVHUYDGHVGHXQSXQWRGHYLVWDGHWHU PLQDGRVLQHOFXDOQRSRGUtDMX]JDU'HKHFKRHO SULQFLSLRSUHVXSRQHHOSXQWRGHYLVWDGHODVLP SDWtDDFHUFDGHOFXDOSRGHPRVSUHJXQWDUWRGDYtD SRUTXpHVHVHHOIXQGDPHQWR\QRRWUR$GHPiV HO SULQFLSLR EULQGD HVFDVD MXVWLILFDFLyQ SDUD ODV YLUWXGHVGHODMXVWLFLD\ODEHQHILFHQFLD3RUHOOR HVQHFHVDULRFRPSOHPHQWDUHOSULQFLSLRGH6PLWK FRQHOLPSHUDWLYRFDWHJyULFRNDQWLDQRVLVHMX]JD VHGHEHMX]JDUGHVGHHOSXQWRGHYLVWDGHO´UHVSHWR LPSDUFLDOGHORVLQWHUHVHVGHORVSDUWLFLSDQWHVµ 3DUD7XJHQGKDWGLFKDIRUPXODFLyQGHOSULQFLSLR GH MXVWLILFDFLyQ GH ORV MXLFLRV PRUDOHV VXSRQH GLIHUHQFLDU GRV FXHVWLRQHV D VDEHU ´¢4Xp HV OR TXH SDUHFH FRPR PRUDOPHQWH EXHQR GHVGH OD SHUVSHFWLYDGHFXDOTXLHUDHVWRHVGHOTXHMX]JD LPSDUFLDOPHQWH"µ\´¢&yPRGHVHDFXDOTXLHUDTXH WRGRVORWUDWHQRTXHVHFRPSRUWHQFRQUHVSHFWR DpO"µ /D SODXVLELOLGDG GHO SULQFLSLR PRUDO GHVFDQ VD VREUH OD HVWUDWHJLD NDQWLDQD GH FRQVWUXLU OD SULPHUD FXHVWLyQ VREUH OD VHJXQGD 3HUR ¢TXp VLJQLILFDHVWR"6LJQLILFDTXHOREXHQRVyORSXHGH HVWDUGHILQLGRGHPDQHUDXQLYHUVDODSDUWLUGHOD FRQVLGHUDFLyQ LPSDUFLDO GH ORV LQWHUHVHV GH ORV SDUWLFLSDQWHV7RGRVGHVHDPRVTXHVHQRVMX]JXH GHPDQHUDLPSDUFLDO(OSUREOHPDFRQODPRUDO ,EtGSiJ ,EtG WUDGLFLRQDOUHOLJLRVDHVTXHKDEODGHXQD´XQLYHU VDOLGDGµGHVGHXQSXQWRGHYLVWDGHWHUPLQDGRTXH QRHVGHVSXpVGHWRGRXQLYHUVDOL]DEOH 3DVHPRVDKRUDDPLUDUORVDUJXPHQWRVTXH7X JHQGKDW RIUHFH HQ DSR\R GH VX WHVLV GH TXH ´HO SULQFLSLRGHODFRQVLGHUDFLyQLJXDOGHORVGHUHFKRV HLQWHUHVHVGHWRGRVµHVHO~QLFRSULQFLSLRPRUDO SODXVLEOH7XJHQGKDWGLYLGHVXDUJXPHQWDFLyQHQ GRVSDVRVDORVTXHOODPDHOFRPSRQHQWHSRVLWLYR \HOFRPSRQHQWHQHJDWLYR(OSDVRSRVLWLYRFRQ VLVWHHQPRVWUDUTXHHOSULQFLSLRHVUHFRPHQGDEOH PLHQWUDVTXHHOSDVRQHJDWLYRFRQVLVWHHQPRVWUDU TXHRWURVFDQGLGDWRVDILJXUDUFRPRHOSULQFLSLR SODXVLEOHQRVRQUHFRPHQGDEOHVUDFLRQDOHVGH ELGRDFLHUWDVIDOODVFRQFHSWXDOHV (O SDVR SRVLWLYR VH DSR\D HQ HO DUJXPHQWR GHO SDUiVLWRPRUDOR)UHH5LGHUHLQWHQWDPRVWUDUOD UDFLRQDOLGDGGHOSURFHGLPLHQWRSDUDGHWHUPLQDU TXpQRUPDVPRUDOHVXQRGHVHDUtDTXHORVRWURV DGRSWDUDQ(QWDQWRTXHPLHPEURGHODFRPXQLGDG PRUDOHQODTXHYLYHQXHVWURSDUiVLWRPRUDOGHEH SUHVXSRQHUXQDFRQFLHQFLDPRUDOHQORVGHPiVH LQFOXVRSXHGHOOHJDUDSURPRYHUOD&RQHOORJR]D GHORVEHQHILFLRVGHYLYLUHQXQDFRPXQLGDGPRUDO SHURVLQWHQHUREOLJDFLRQHVKDFLDORVGHPiV6LOR TXHXQRDQKHODHVTXHVXVGHVHRVVHDQUHVSHWDGRV UDFLRQDOPHQWHODPHMRUHOHFFLyQVHUtDRSWDUSRU YLYLUHQXQDFRPXQLGDGTXHSURPXHYDHOUHVSH WR SRU ORV LQWHUHVHV GH WRGRV (Q FRQVHFXHQFLD OD PHMRU PRUDO OD PiV UHFRPHQGDEOH GHVGH OD SHUVSHFWLYDGHVXVXVXDULRVVHUtDODPRUDONDQ WLDQD7XJHQGKDWVHSUHJXQWDVLVXDUJXPHQWRHV FLUFXODUSXHVODHVWUDWHJLDGHSUHJXQWDUDTXLpQ Razón, sentimientos y derechos humanos Páginas 8 a 33 EHQHILFLDODPRUDOSDUHFHSUHVXSRQHUMXVWDPHQWH ORTXHKD\TXHGHPRVWUDU3HURQRKD\WDOFtUFXOR HQODDUJXPHQWDFLyQ\DTXHSUHFLVDPHQWHHOVHU PRUDO VXSRQH VXSHUDU HO HJRtVPR pWLFR OR FXDO QRVLJQLILFDTXHORVLQWHUHVHVGHODVSHUVRQDVQR GHEDQVHUWRPDGRVHQFXHQWD8QDPRUDOVLQOD SUHRFXSDFLyQSRUORVLQWHUHVHVGHODVSHUVRQDVQR SDUHFHVHUFRKHUHQWHPHQWHFRQFHELEOH (O SDVR QHJDWLYR FRQVLVWH HQ GHPRVWUDU OD QR SODXVLELOLGDG GH RWURV HQIRTXHV HQ PDWHULD GH MXVWLILFDFLyQPRUDO6HJ~Q7XJHQGKDWVRQWUHV /DpWLFDGHODFRPSDVLyQFX\RSULQFLSLRFRQVLV WHHQQRLQIULQJLUGRORUHLPSHGLUOR7XJHQGKDW ODGHVFDUWDFRPRSODXVLEOHSXHVFRQEDVHHQWDO ´SULQFLSLRµQRHVSRVLEOHFRQVWUXLUXQVLVWHPD GHQRUPDV /DpWLFDFRPXQLWDULDFX\RSULQFLSLRVHGHILQH SRUHOLGHDOGHODFRQVHUYDFLyQGHO(VWDGR7X JHQGKDWQRODFRQVLGHUDFRPRSODXVLEOHGHELGR DTXHHOYDORUGHODOHDOWDGDO(VWDGRSRUHQFLPD GHORVELHQHVSHUVRQDOHVWHUPLQDSRUFDHUHQ MXVWLILFDFLRQHVWUDVFHQGHQWHV /DpWLFDXWLOLWDULVWDODFXDOHVXQDPRUDOGHOD FRPSDVLyQHQVHQWLGRSRVLWLYR (O ~QLFR FRPSHWLGRU VHULR HQ OD SXJQD SRU OD SODXVLELOLGDG HV HO XWLOLWDULVPR 6HJ~Q 7XJHQ GKDW HO XWLOLWDULVPR HV XQD pWLFD TXH FRPSDUWH FRQODpWLFDGH.DQWHOpQIDVLVVREUHODQRFLyQGH SHUVRQD\HQHOKHFKRGHTXHQRDFXGHDHQWLGDGHV WUDVFHQGHQWHVHQODIXQGDPHQWDFLyQGHODPRUDO 3HUR7XJHQGKDWFRQVLGHUDTXHHVSRVLEOHHQVX GLVFXVLyQFRQORVXWLOLWDULVWDVGHMDUSRUIXHUDHO WHPDGHORVDQLPDOHVFXHVWLyQPX\SUREOHPiWLFD SXHVHVLPSRVLEOHKDEODUGHXWLOLWDULVPRFOiVLFRR GHSUHIHUHQFLDVLQHQWHQGHUTXHHVSUHFLVDPHQWH ODDPSOLDFLyQGHOFtUFXORGHORPRUDO\HOFRPHQ]DU DWRPDUVHHQVHULRORVGHUHFKRVGHORVDQLPDOHV XQRGHORVHOHPHQWRVPiVLQQRYDGRUHVGHODSUR SXHVWDpWLFDGHORVXWLOLWDULVWDV 7XJHQGKDW UHFRQRFH TXH HO SULQFLSLR GH MXVWLIL FDFLyQPRUDOGHOXWLOLWDULVPR´FRQWLHQHDOJRDVX IDYRUTXHKDVLGRGHVFXLGDGRSRUHONDQWLVPRµ DOJR TXH VyOR SXHGH VDOLU D OD OX] VL VH DGRSWD OD HVWUDWHJLD GH UHQXQFLDU D OD IXQGDPHQWDFLyQ WUDVFHQGHQWHGHODPRUDODXQTXHVLQFDHUHQORV EUD]RVGHXQFRQWUDFWXDOLVPRLQVXILFLHQWH3DUD DSUHFLDUFRQPiVFODULGDGHOHOHPHQWRYDOLRVRTXH \DFHWUDVHOXWLOLWDULVPR7XJHQGKDWUHDOL]DXQD SHTXHxDUHFRQVWUXFFLyQKLVWyULFDGHOGHVDUUROOR\ HYROXFLyQGHOXWLOLWDULVPR(OSULQFLSLRXWLOLWDULVWD DSDUHFHSRUSULPHUDYH]HQ+XWFKHVRQ(Q+XPH VHGDXQDQRFLyQVLPLODUSXHVHOILOyVRIRHVFRFpV GHILHQGHODWHVLVGHTXHORTXHOHGDHOYDORUPRUDO DODVYLUWXGHVHVVXXWLOLGDGHQODVUHODFLRQHVFRQ ORVGHPiV\FRQXQRPLVPR/DVYLUWXGHVTXHVRQ ~WLOHVHQODVUHODFLRQHVFRQORVGHPiVSUHVXSRQHQ TXHXQRVHLQWHUHVDSRUHOELHQHVWDUGHORVRWURV\ HOORGHVFDQVDVREUHHOVHQWLPLHQWRGHEHQHYROHQFLD RGHVLPSDWtD(OUHFRQRFLPLHQWRGHTXHORTXH GRWDGHYDORUDFLHUWDVYLUWXGHVHVVXXWLOLGDGSDUD ORVGHPiVVHDSR\DHQODSUXHEDTXH+XPHGDSDUD UHFKD]DUODVYLUWXGHVPRQDFDOHV(ODUJXPHQWRHV HOVLJXLHQWH <FRPRVHDGPLWHTXHWRGDFXDOLGDG~WLORDJUD GDEOHSDUDQRVRWURVRSDUDORVGHPiVHVSDUWHGHO 9HU6,1*(53Ética práctica/RQGUHV&DPEULGJH8QLYHUVLW\3UHVV ,EtGSiJ 13 Criterio jurídico garantista 14 issn: 2145-3381 - Año 3 - No. 4 - Enero-Junio de 2011 PpULWRSHUVRQDOQRVHUHFLELUiQLQJXQDRWUDDOOt GRQGHORVKRPEUHVMX]JXHQFRQVXUD]yQQDWXUDO H[HQWD GH SUHMXLFLRV \ VLQ ODV DSDULHQFLDV HQJD xRVDVGHODVXSHUVWLFLyQ\GHODIDOVDUHOLJLyQ(O FHOLEDWRD\XQRSHQLWHQFLDPRUWLILFDFLyQQHJDFLyQ GH Vt PLVPR KXPLOGDG VLOHQFLR VROHGDG \ WRGR HOFRQMXQWRGHYLUWXGHVPRQDFDOHV¢SRUTXpVRQ UHFKD]DGDVHQWRGDVSDUWHVSRUORVKRPEUHVVHQ VDWRVVLQRSRUTXHQRVLUYHQGHQDGDQLIDYRUHFHQ ODIRUWXQDGHOKRPEUHHQHOPXQGRQROHKDFHQ PiVYDOLRVRFRPRPLHPEURGHODVRFLHGDGQLOH FDOLILFDQ SDUD HO UHFUHR \ HQWUHWHQLPLHQWR GH OD FRPSDxtDQLLQFUHPHQWDQVXFDSDFLGDGGHJR]DU" 3RUHOFRQWUDULRREVHUYDPRVTXHWRGDVHOODVREV WDFXOL]DQHVWRVILQHVGHVHDEOHVWRUQDQHVW~SLGRDO HQWHQGLPLHQWR\HQGXUHFHQHOFRUD]yQRVFXUHFHQ ODIDQWDVtD\DJULDQHOFDUiFWHU3RUORWDQWR\FRQ UD]yQ ODV SDVDPRV D OD FROXPQD RSXHVWD \ ODV FRORFDPRVHQHOFDWiORJRGHORVYLFLRV\QRKD\ VXSHUVWLFLyQTXHWHQJDHQWUHORVKRPEUHVIXHU]D VXILFLHQWHSDUDSHUYHUWLUSRUHQWHURODIXHU]DGH HVWRVVHQWLPLHQWRVQDWXUDOHV8QIDQiWLFRVRPEUtR \REVWLQDGRSXHGHWHQHUWUDVVXPXHUWHXQOXJDU HQHOFDOHQGDULRSHURGLItFLOPHQWHVHUiDGPLWLGRHQ YLGDHQLQWLPLGDG\VRFLHGDGDQRVHUSRUTXLHQHV VHDQWDQGHOLUDQWHV\OyEUHJRVFRPRpO (OSULQFLSLRGHOUHVSHWRXQLYHUVDO QRVLJQLILFDTXHHQWRGDV ODVFLUFXQVWDQFLDVODVSHUVRQDV GHEDQWUDWDUVHGHODPLVPDPDQHUD +D\FDVRVGRQGHHOUHVSHWR H[LJHWUDWDUDORVGHPiVGHPRGR GLIHUHQWHSHURHVWDGLIHUHQFLDFLyQ SXHGHFRQVWUXLUVHGHVGH ODLPSDUFLDOLGDG 6HJ~Q7XJHQGKDWODWHVLVGHODXWLOLGDGGHODVYLU WXGHVHQ+XPHHVFRUUHVSRQGLHQWHFRQVXSURSLD WHVLVGHTXHODPRUDOWLHQHTXHYHUDQWHWRGRFRQ ORVGHVHRV\ORVLQWHUHVHVGHORVGHPiV(VPiV WDQWRHONDQWLVPRFRPRHOXWLOLWDULVPRFRLQFLGHQ HQTXHDOUHFKD]DUODPRUDOWHROyJLFDOR~QLFR TXHSXHGHVHUYLUGHEDVHSDUDODFRQVWUXFFLyQGH ODPRUDOLGDGHVHOUHVSHWRSRUORVLQWHUHVHVGHORV GHPiVDOJRTXHORVXWLOLWDULVWDVDVRFLDQFRQQRFLyQ GHEHQHYROHQFLD3HURHOSDUDOHORFRQ+XPHWLHQH VXVOLPLWDFLRQHVSXHVVXFRQFHSFLyQGHXWLOLGDG RIHOLFLGDGHVUHODWLYDDODVRFLHGDG\QRDOLQGLYL +80('Investigación sobre los principios de la moral%XHQRV$LUHV$JXLODUSS Razón, sentimientos y derechos humanos Páginas 8 a 33 15 GXR(VWRVXSRQHXQDOLPLWDFLyQWDPELpQSDUDVX HOUHVSHWRH[LJHWUDWDUDORVGHPiVGHPRGRGLIH QRFLyQGHMXVWLFLDTXHQRLQFRUSRUDXQDQRFLyQGH UHQWHSHURHVWDGLIHUHQFLDFLyQSXHGHFRQVWUXLUVH FRQVLGHUDFLyQ´SRUFDGDXQR\WRGRVORVRWURVµ GHVGHODLPSDUFLDOLGDG3RUHMHPSORVHWUDWDDORV GLVFDSDFLWDGRVGHPDQHUDGLIHUHQWHSHURLPSDU ´/D PHMRU DFFLyQ HV DTXHOOD TXH SURSRUFLRQD OD FLDO3HUR¢TXpVXFHGHDTXtFRQHOSULQFLSLRGHOD PD\RUIHOLFLGDGSDUDHOPD\RUQ~PHURµWDOHVOD PD\RUIHOLFLGDG"¢3URGXFHORVPLVPRVUHVXOWDGRV IyUPXODHQODTXH+XWFKHVRQUHVXPLyHOSULQFLSLR TXHHOSULQFLSLRGHOUHVSHWRXQLYHUVDO"(VHQHVWH XWLOLWDULVWD3HURORYHUGDGHUDPHQWHLPSRUWDQWH SXQWRHQHOTXH7XJHQGKDWGHVDUUROODODVFUtWLFDV HQ+XWFKHVRQHVVXDSRUWHHQPRVWUDUODVOLPLWD DOSULQFLSLRGHXWLOLGDG\DOXWLOLWDULVPRDWUDYpV FLRQHVGHOGHRQWRORJLVPRNDQWLDQRDOVXJHULUXQD GHOHVWXGLRGHWUHVFDVRV/DHVWUDWHJLDFRQVLVWH SUHJXQWDTXHFRPRHOPLVPR7XJHQGKDWDGPLWH HQPRVWUDUTXHHOSULQFLSLRGHODPD\RUIHOLFLGDG HONDQWLVPRQRKDWHQLGRHQFXHQWD´¢&yPRQRV FRQGXFLUtDDDFWRVPRUDOPHQWHUHSUREDEOHVSRUOR FRPSRUWDPRVPRUDOPHQWHPHMRUIUHQWHDYDULDV TXHPiVELHQGHEHUtDVHUDGRSWDGRHOSULQFLSLRGHO DOWHUQDWLYDV GH DFFLyQ TXH FRQFLHUQHQ SRVLWLYD UHVSHFWRXQLYHUVDOFRPRHO~QLFRSULQFLSLRPRUDO PHQWHRQHJDWLYDPHQWHDYDULDVSHUVRQDV"µ SODXVLEOH5HFRUGHPRVTXH7XJHQGKDWWLHQHTXH PRVWUDUTXHHOXWLOLWDULVPRQRHVUDFLRQDOPHQWH 5HVSRQGHUDFHUWDGDPHQWHDHVWDSUHJXQWDLPSOLFD DFHSWDEOH\TXHSRUHOORQRSXHGHVHUSODXVLEOH IRUPXODUHOSULQFLSLRJHQHUDOSODXVLEOHGHODPRUDO ´«ORVLQWHUHVHVGHWRGRVGHEHQUHVSHWDUVHGHLJXDO 3ULPHU FDVR OD UHJOD GH OD PD\RU IHOLFLGDG PRGRHOORVWLHQHQGHUHFKRDHVRµ3HUR¢FyPRVH H[LJHVXSULPLUGHUHFKRVHVSHFLDOHVFRPRORV UHODFLRQDHOSULQFLSLRGHXWLOLGDGFRQHVWHQXHYR VXUJLGRVGHODSURPHVDRGHXQFRQWUDWR8Q SULQFLSLR"$SULPHUDYLVWDHOSULQFLSLRGHODPD\RU XWLOLWDULVWDGHEHDFHSWDUVLHVFRQVLVWHQWHFRQ IHOLFLGDGQRHVHTXLYDOHQWHDOSULQFLSLRGHOUHVSHWR VXSRVWXUDTXHHVSUHFLVRURPSHUVLHPSUHFRQ LPSDUFLDOGHORVLQWHUHVHVGHWRGRVGHELGRDGRV ODVSURPHVDVVLFRQHOORVHSXHGHREWHQHUXQD UD]RQHV(QSULPHUOXJDUHOSULQFLSLRGHUHVSHWR PD\RUIHOLFLGDG LQFRUSRUDODQRFLyQGHMXVWLFLDDOKDEODUGHLJXDOHV GHUHFKRV PLHQWUDV TXH HO SULQFLSLR GH XWLOLGDG 6HJXQGRFDVRODUHJODGHODPD\RUIHOLFLGDG QRODLQFRUSRUDSXHVHQHOFiOFXORXWLOLWDULVWDVH VXSRQH QR UHFRQRFHU REOLJDFLRQHV HVSHFLD WUDWDGHHVWDEOHFHUODPD\RUIHOLFLGDGRLQIHOLFLGDG OHV TXH VXUJHQ GH ODV UHODFLRQHV SHUVRQDOHV VLHQGRLQGLIHUHQWHHOSUREOHPDGHODMXVWLFLDGLVWUL SDGUHKLMR(VWDPRVREOLJDGRVDDOLPHQWDUD EXWLYDKD\GHUHFKRVTXHQRVHSXHGHQJDUDQWL]DU QXHVWURKLMRSHURQRDOKLMRGHFXDOTXLHUSHU R GLVWULEXLU VHJ~Q PpULWRV VLQR TXH YDOHQ SDUD VRQD8QXWLOLWDULVWDFRKHUHQWHGHEHDGPLWLU WRGRVGHPDQHUDLUUHVWULFWD(QVHJXQGROXJDUHO TXHVLVHORJUDODPD\RUIHOLFLGDGDFRVWDGH SULQFLSLRGHOUHVSHFWRXQLYHUVDOQRVLJQLILFDTXH VDFULILFDUGLFKDVREOLJDFLRQHVHVSHFLDOHVKD\ HQ WRGDV ODV FLUFXQVWDQFLDV ODV SHUVRQDV GHEDQ TXHKDFHUOR WUDWDUVH GH OD PLVPD PDQHUD +D\ FDVRV GRQGH 78*(1'+$7(Lecciones de ética%DUFHORQD*HGLVDSiJ ,EtGSiJ Criterio jurídico garantista 16 issn: 2145-3381 - Año 3 - No. 4 - Enero-Junio de 2011 7HUFHUFDVRODUHJODGHODPD\RUIHOLFLGDGSHU PLWHTXHXQRSXHGDWHQHUGHUHFKRDVDFULILFDU XQDYLGD\SXHGDGLVSRQHUGHORVyUJDQRVGH XQSDFLHQWHVLFRQHOORVHVDOYDQVHLVYLGDVSXHV FODUDPHQWHHOUHVXOWDGRHVPHMRUDOPD[LPL]DU ODIHOLFLGDGSDUDODPD\RUtD 8QD SRVLEOH VDOLGD D WDOHV FUtWLFDV FRQVLVWH HQ DILUPDUTXHHOSXQWRGHYLVWDXWLOLWDULVWDVHVDO YDVLVHWLHQHQHQFXHQWD´FRQH[LRQHVHPStULFDV DGLFLRQDOHVµ3RUHMHPSORVHSXHGHUHVSRQGHUDO VHJXQGR FDVR GLFLHQGR TXH ´$TXHOORV FX\RV GH UHFKRVHVSHFLDOHVVRQSHUMXGLFDGRVVXIULUiQPiV WDPELpQ FXDQGR VHDQ YXOQHUDGRV ORV GHUHFKRV GH VXV IDPLOLDUHVµ 3HUR OR GHFLVLYR DTXt SDUD 7XJHQGKDWFRQVLVWHHQYHUTXHODGHELOLGDGGHO SULQFLSLRGHXWLOLGDGVHKDOODHQVXFRUUHFFLyQHP StULFDDOPRVWUDUVHFRPRXQSULQFLSLRLQVXILFLHQWH DGLIHUHQFLDGHOSULQFLSLRGHUHVSHWRXQLYHUVDOTXH VtSHUPLWHXQDVROXFLyQUD]RQDEOHDORVWUHVFDVRV SUREOHPiWLFRVVLHQGRSRUHOORFRPSDUDWLYDPHQWH PiVSODXVLEOH HO SULQFLSLR GH UHVSHWR XQLYHUVDO XQ SULQFLSLR NDQWLDQRRHVXQSULQFLSLRXWLOLWDULVWDVLQPiV" (Q SULPHU OXJDU OD QRFLyQ GH XWLOLWDULVPR TXH HPSOHD7XJHQGKDWVLELHQWUDWDGHVHUH[KDXVWLYD GHMDSRUIXHUDDQDGDPiV\QDGDPHQRVTXHD0LOO XQRGHORVFUtWLFRVPiVLPSRUWDQWHVGH%HQWKDP 0LOOIXHXQFRQWLQXDGRUGHODILORVRItDXWLOLWDULVWD GH%HQWKDP(QHVWHVHQWLGRHVWXYRFRQYHQFLGRGH ODLPSRUWDQFLDGHEXVFDUXQDIXQGDPHQWDFLyQGH ODPRUDOTXHQRDFXGLHUDDSULQFLSLRVPHWDItVLFRV VLQRDKHFKRVREVHUYDEOHV0LOOUHDOL]yXQSHUIHF FLRQDPLHQWRGHOSULQFLSLRGHXWLOLGDGGH%HQWKDP 3DUDDPERVODQRFLyQGHXWLOLGDGVHUHODFLRQDEDHQ WDQWRIXQGDPHQWRGHODPRUDOFRQODREOLJDFLyQGH SURPRYHUDFFLRQHVTXHJDUDQWL]DUDQODIHOLFLGDG SDUDHOPD\RUQ~PHURGHSHUVRQDV$TXtIHOLFLGDG RULJLQDOPHQWHVLJQLILFDEDSODFHU\DXVHQFLDGHGR ORU1RREVWDQWH0LOODPSOLyODQRFLyQGHXWLOLGDG IXQGDGDDKRUDHQORVLQWHUHVHVSHUPDQHQWHVGHO KRPEUHTXHDVSLUDDXQSURJUHVRPRUDO &RPRPHGLRSDUDDOFDQ]DUPiVDSUR[LPDGDPHQ WHHVWHLGHDOODXWLOLGDGUHFRPHQGDUiHQSULPHU WpUPLQR TXH ODV OH\HV \ RUJDQL]DFLRQHV VRFLDOHV DUPRQLFHQ HQ OR SRVLEOHV OD IHOLFLGDG R FRPR HQ WpUPLQRV SUiFWLFRV SRGUtD GHQRPLQDUVH ORV LQWHUHVHVGHFDGDLQGLYLGXRFRQORVLQWHUHVHVGHO FRQMXQWR $ 7XJHQGKDW OH SDUHFH FKRFDQWH HO FDUiFWHU UHGXFFLRQLVWD GHO XWLOLWDULVPR VREUH WRGR HO GH %HQWKDPTXHYHODVUHODFLRQHVFRQORVGHPiVHQ WpUPLQRVGHVXPDV\UHVWDV$XQTXHUHFRQRFHTXH HOSULQFLSLR´7RGRVKDQGHFRQWDUVHFRPRXQR\ QLQJXQRFRPRPiVGHXQRµHVGHXQYDORUDOWRHQ HOSURJUHVRPRUDOGHODKXPDQLGDGWLHQHXQUDQJR (QHOXWLOLWDULVPRGH0LOOWDPELpQKD\XQDQRFLyQ GHDSOLFDFLyQUHVWULQJLGRDODVUHJODVGHMXHJRGHO FODUDGHLPSDUFLDOLGDGTXHORDFHUFDPXFKRD.DQW FiOFXORXWLOLWDULVWD\QRSXHGHLQWHUSUHWDUVHFRPR 'HERUHSHWLUTXHORVGHWUDFWRUHVGHOXWLOLWDULVPR XQ SULQFLSLR UHODWLYR D OD LJXDOGDG GH GHUHFKRV UDUDV YHFHV OH KDFHQ MXVWLFLD \ UHFRQRFHQ TXH OD IHOLFLGDG TXH FRQVWLWX\H HO FULWHULR XWLOLWDULVWD 3HUR¢VRQYiOLGDVODVFUtWLFDVDOXWLOLWDULVPR"¢(V ,EtGSiJ 0,//-6Utilitarismo%DUFHORQD$OWD\DSiJ(OpQIDVLVHVPtR Razón, sentimientos y derechos humanos Páginas 8 a 33 GH OR TXH HV FRUUHFWR HQ XQD FRQGXFWD QR HV OD SURSLD IHOLFLGDG GHO DJHQWH VLQR OD GH WRGRV ORV DIHFWDGRV(QWUHODIHOLFLGDGSHUVRQDOGHODJHQWH\ ODGHORVGHPiVHOXWLOLWDULVWDREOLJDDDTXpODVHU WDQHVWULFWDPHQWHLPSDUFLDOFRPRXQHVSHFWDGRU GHVLQWHUHVDGR\EHQHYROHQWH 0LOO FRQVLGHUy TXH HO XWLOLWDULVPR DQWHULRU FDtD HQXQDHVSHFLHGHLQGLYLGXDOLVPRHVWiWLFR\SUR EOHPiWLFRTXHVHFHQWUDEDHQODVDWLVIDFFLyQGHO SODFHUSRUSDUWHGHOVXMHWR3DUDpOORVLQGLYLGXRV VRQHQWLGDGHVGLQiPLFDVTXHHVWiQHQSURFHVRGH SHUIHFFLRQDPLHQWR \ FRPR WDOHV HVWiQ RULHQWD GRV DO GHVDUUROOR GH WRGDV VXV SRWHQFLDOLGDGHV 0LOOWDPELpQFRQGHQyHOLQGLYLGXDOLVPRTXHVyOR DWLHQGHDORVLQWHUHVHVSULYDGRV\VHGHVSUHRFXSD GHORVLQWHUHVHVS~EOLFRVRGHOELHQFRP~Q$GLIH UHQFLDGH%HQWKDPFRQVLGHUyTXHORVVHQWLPLHQWRV PRUDOHVHUDQIXQGDPHQWDOHVDODKRUDGHKDEODU GHpWLFD/RVVHQWLPLHQWRVPRUDOHVDQWHFHGHQDO LQWHUpVSDUWLFXODU(VWHHQIRTXHOHSHUPLWLyHQWHQ GHUTXHORTXHXQHDORVLQGLYLGXRVQRHVHOSODFHU VLQRHOSURJUHVRGHOHVStULWXKXPDQRHVGHFLUTXH XQDFRVDHUDHOLQWHUpVRVDWLVIDFFLyQSURSLD\RWUD FRVDPX\GLVWLQWDHUDODIHOLFLGDG 17 FUHDFLyQGHXQDQXHYDUHOLJLyQODUHOLJLyQGHOD KXPDQLGDG8QDUHOLJLy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iWLFR &RQUHVSHFWRDOVDFULILFLRGHSHUVRQDVHQHOFDVR GH0LOOHVFODURTXHQRHVSRVLEOHTXHSRUPRWLYRV XWLOLWDULVWDVODVSHUVRQDVDFHSWHQFLHUWRVEHQHIL FLRVDFRVWDGHOVDFULILFLRGHORVGHPiV/DLGHDGH LPSDUFLDOLGDG\ODLGHDGHTXHKD\TXHWHQHUHQ FXHQWDORVLQWHUHVHVGHORVGHPiVKDFHQTXHWDOHV DFWRVQRVHSXHGDQOOHYDUDFDERVLQYLRODUWDOHV LGHDOHV<WDOHVLGHDOHVFRQVWLWX\HQHOELHQHVWDUGH ODFRPXQLGDGVLQODFXDOQRVHSXHGHGLVIUXWDUGH ORVELHQHV\GHODOLEHUWDG¢4XLpQGHVHDUtDYLYLU HQXQDVRFLHGDGHQODTXHQRVHWLHQHXQPtQLPR GHVHJXULGDGSDUDYLYLU\QRVHSXHGHREWHQHUDOJR \GLVIUXWDUORVLQHOVDFULILFLRGHDOJXLHQ" 8QRGHORVDSRUWHVIXQGDPHQWDOHVGHOSHQVDPLHQ WRGH0LOOVHGLRHQHOWHUUHQRGHODVUHODFLRQHV HQWUH UHOLJLyQ \ PRUDO \ HQ VX UHFKD]R GH XQD IXQGDPHQWDFLyQ WUDVFHQGHQWH GH OD PRUDO 0LOO VHSUHJXQWyVLODFUHHQFLDUHOLJLRVDHVUHDOPHQWH LQGLVSHQVDEOHSDUDHOELHQHVWDUGHODKXPDQLGDG RVLSRUHOFRQWUDULRORVEHQHILFLRVTXHODFUHHQFLD UHOLJLRVD SURGXFH SRGtDQ VHU REWHQLGRV GH RWUD PDQHUD VLQ WHQHU TXH FDUJDU FRQ ORV PDOHV TXH YDQXQLGRVDGLFKRVEHQHILFLRVFXDQGRVHREWLHQHQ (QORTXHVLJXHLQWHQWDUpPRVWUDUTXHHOVXSXHVWR GHODUHOLJLyQ'HDKtTXH0LOOKD\DSURSXHVWROD SULQFLSLRNDQWLDQRGH7XJHQGKDWHVHQUHDOLGDG ,EtG Criterio jurídico garantista 18 issn: 2145-3381 - Año 3 - No. 4 - Enero-Junio de 2011 /RVLQGLYLGXRV VRQHQWLGDGHVGLQiPLFDV TXHHVWiQHQSURFHVR GHSHUIHFFLRQDPLHQWR \FRPRWDOHVHVWiQ RULHQWDGRVDOGHVDUUROOR GHWRGDVVXV SRWHQFLDOLGDGHV XQ SULQFLSLR XWLOLWDULVWD FRQ OR FXDO OD PRUDO SODXVLEOHVHUtDSUHFLVDPHQWHpVWD\QRODNDQWLDQD 6HJ~Q7XJHQGKDWHOSULQFLSLRTXHpOGHILHQGHHV ´«HO SULQFLSLR GH OD FRQVLGHUDFLyQ LJXDO GH ORV GHUHFKRVHLQWHUHVHVGHWRGRVµ3HURHVWHSULQFL SLR DGPLWH XQD LQWHUSUHWDFLyQ XWLOLWDULVWD SXHV VLPSOHPHQWHEDVWDFRQTXHQRVSUHJXQWHPRVTXp FRQVHFXHQFLDVVHVHJXLUtDQGHDGRSWDUGLFKRSULQ FLSLR(VWHSULQFLSLRHVVLPLODUDOVXJHULGRSRU3H WHU6LQJHUHQVXOLEUReWLFDSUiFWLFDSXEOLFDGRHQ 3DUD6LQJHUVXpWLFDXWLOLWDULVWDHVWiEDVDGD HQHOSULQFLSLRGHLJXDOFRQVLGHUDFLyQGHLQWHUHVHV /DVPHMRUHVFRQVHFXHQFLDVVHGHILQHQHQWpUPLQRV GHGLFKRSULQFLSLR(OSULQFLSLRHVWDEOHFHTXHDOD KRUDGHDFWXDUGHERWHQHUHQFXHQWDORVLQWHUHVHV GHWRGDVODVSHUVRQDVDIHFWDGDVSRUPLDFFLyQ8QD DFFLyQHVEXHQDVLPD[LPL]DORVLQWHUHVHVGHORV DIHFWDGRV(OSULQFLSLRGHLJXDOFRQVLGHUDFLyQGH LQWHUHVHVHVXQSULQFLSLRGHLJXDOGDG\GHLPSDU FLDOLGDG(QSDODEUDVGH6LQJHU /D HVHQFLD GHO SULQFLSLR GH LJXDO FRQVLGHUDFLyQ GH LQWHUHVHV HV TXH HQ QXHVWUDV GHOLEHUDFLRQHV PRUDOHV GDPRV OD PLVPD LPSRUWDQFLD D ORV LQ WHUHVHV SDUHFLGRV GH WRGRV DTXHOORV D TXLHQHV DIHFWDQQXHVWUDVDFFLRQHV(VWRTXLHUHGHFLUTXH VLVyOR$\%VHYLHUDQDIHFWDGRVSRUXQDDFFLyQ GHWHUPLQDGDHQODTXH$SDUHFHSHUGHUPiVGHOR TXH%JDQDHVSUHIHULEOHQRHMHFXWDUGLFKDDFFLyQ 6LDFHSWDPRVHOSULQFLSLRGHLJXDOFRQVLGHUDFLyQ GHLQWHUHVHVQRSRGHPRVDILUPDUTXHUHDOL]DUOD DFFLyQGHWHUPLQDGDHVPHMRUDSHVDUGHORVKHFKRV GHVFULWRVGHELGRDTXHQRVSUHRFXSDPiV%TXH $/RTXHUHDOPHQWHVHGHVSUHQGHGHOSULQFLSLR HVORVLJXLHQWHXQLQWHUpVHVXQLQWHUpVVHDGH TXLHQVHD (VWHSULQFLSLRHVXWLOLWDULVWD'HKHFKRFRQEDVHHQ pOSRGHPRVUHVSRQGHUDODVFUtWLFDVGH7XJHQGKDW 6,1*(53Ética práctica/RQGUHV&DPEULGJH8QLYHUVLW\3UHVVSS Razón, sentimientos y derechos humanos Páginas 8 a 33 19 \YHUHOXWLOLWDULVPRFOiVLFRHQFRQWLQXLGDGFRQHO REOLJDFLRQHV"¢(QTXpFRQVLVWHWHQHUXQGH XWLOLWDULVPRGHSUHIHUHQFLDGH6LQJHU UHFKR" 5HVSRQGHU D DPEDV SUHJXQWDV VXSRQH GHWHUPLQDU VL HVWDPRV R QR MXVWLILFDGRV SDUD /DPDQHUDGHSHQVDUTXHKHHVER]DGRHVXQDIRU PDGHXWLOLWDULVPR6HGLIHUHQFLDGHOXWLOLWDULVPR KDEODUGHGHUHFKRVPRUDOHVDSDUWLUGHODQRFLyQ FOiVLFRHQTXHVHHQWLHQGHSRUODVPHMRUHVFRQVH GHREOLJDFLyQPRUDOORFXDOQRVFRQGXFLUiGHOD FXHQFLDVORTXHHQJHQHUDOIDYRUHFHORVLQWHUHVHV HVIHUD SULYDGD D OD HVIHUD S~EOLFD GH OD PRUDO GH ORV DIHFWDGRV \ QR PHUDPHQWH FRPR OR TXH HVGHFLUDODVXQWRGHODPRUDOSROtWLFDGRQGHVH DXPHQWDHOSODFHU\UHGXFHHOGRORU6LQHPEDUJR WUDWDGHGHWHUPLQDUODERQGDGRPDOGDGGHFLHUWDV VHKDVXJHULGRTXHORVXWLOLWDULVWDVFOiVLFRVFRPR DFFLRQHVGHO(VWDGR %HQWKDP-RKQ6WXDUW\0LOOXVDEDQ´SODFHUµ\´GR ORUµHQXQVHQWLGRDPSOLRTXHOHVSHUPLWtDLQFOXLU FRPR´SODFHUµHOFRQVHJXLUORTXHXQRGHVHDED\ ORFRQWUDULRFRPR´GRORUµ6LHVWDLQWHUSUHWDFLyQ HVFRUUHFWDGHVDSDUHFHODGLIHUHQFLDHQWUHHOXWL OLWDULVPR FOiVLFR \ HO XWLOLWDULVPR EDVDGR HQ ORV LQWHUHVHV (VFODURDSDUWLUGHORGLFKRTXHHOSULQFLSLRGH LJXDOFRQVLGHUDFLyQGHLQWHUHVHVHVDODYH]XQ SULQFLSLRGHHQMXLFLDPLHQWR\XQSURFHGLPLHQWR GHGHFLVLyQORFXDOSHUPLWHVXSHUDUODVOLPLWDFLR QHVGHOSULQFLSLRNDQWLDQRTXHVyORSXHGHVHUXQ SULQFLSLRGHHQMXLFLDPLHQWR Los derechos humanos y el principio de respeto universal 6HJ~Q7XJHQGKDWHOSULQFLSLRGHOUHVSHWRXQL YHUVDOLPSOLFDHOUHFRQRFLPLHQWRGHLJXDOGDGGH GHUHFKRV SDUD WRGRV 6L QXHVWUD REOLJDFLyQ HV UHVSHWDUORVLQWHUHVHVGHORVGHPiVHOORVXSRQH UHFRQRFHU TXH ORV GHPiV JR]DQ GH XQRV GHUH FKRV3HURWDOWHVLVQHFHVLWDMXVWLILFDFLyQORFXDO VXSRQGUi UHVSRQGHU D GRV SUHJXQWDV ¢4Xp MXVWLILFDFLyQWHQHPRVSDUDUHFRQRFHUTXHDTXHOODV SHUVRQDVIUHQWHDODVTXHWHQHPRVREOLJDFLRQHV SRVHHQ GHUHFKRV HQ FRUUHVSRQGHQFLD FRQ WDOHV ,EtGSiJ(OpQIDVLVHVPtR /DMXVWLILFDFLyQGH7XJHQGKDWFRPLHQ]DSRUGH WHUPLQDUFRPRSXQWRGHSDUWLGDHQTXpFRQVLVWH OD MXVWLILFDFLyQ GH ORV GHUHFKRV VXEMHWLYRV ¢(V SRVLEOH FRPR VXJLHUH 0DFNLH GHULYDU OD PRUDO D SDUWLU GHO FRQFHSWR GH GHUHFKR VXEMHWLYR VLQ QHFHVLGDGGHDSHODUQLDOSULQFLSLRNDQWLDQRQLDO XWLOLWDULVWD"6HJ~Q7XJHQGKDWXQDPRUDOFHQWUD GDHQODQRFLyQGHGHUHFKRVXEMHWLYRVHRSRQHPiV TXHQDGDDOXWLOLWDULVPRHOFXDODOVHUXQDPRUDO WHOHROyJLFDQRDFHSWDODSULPDFtDGHORVGHUHFKRV GHWRGRVFRPRDOJRLQDOLHQDEOHTXHHVWpSRUIXHUD GHODQRFLyQGHXWLOLGDG(QHOFDVRGH.DQWOD FRQWUDSRVLFLyQ FRQ OD SURSXHVWD GH 0DFNLH HV PHQRV HYLGHQWH SXHV HQ .DQW FODUDPHQWH KD\ XQDRULHQWDFLyQpWLFDTXHIDYRUHFHXQDMXVWLILFD FLyQGHORVGHUHFKRVKXPDQRVGHVGHODQRFLyQGH REOLJDFLyQLPSOtFLWDHQODVHJXQGDIRUPXODFLyQ GHOLPSHUDWLYRFDWHJyULFRODFXDOSHUPLWHKDEODU GHOUHVSHWRDORVGHUHFKRVGHORVGHPiV3HUROD SURSXHVWDGH0DFNLHIUDFDVDSRUTXHHQGHILQLWLYD HOFRQFHSWRGHREOLJDFLyQQRHVUHHPSOD]DEOHSRU HOFRQFHSWRGHGHUHFKRSXHVODQRFLyQGHREOLJD FLyQSUHVXSRQHODQRFLyQGHVDQFLyQSRUORFXDO ORV GHUHFKRV SHUGHUtDQ SHVR VLQ XQD QRFLyQ GH REOLJDFLyQDVtHQWHQGLGD1RHVSRVLEOHKDEODUGH GHUHFKRVVLQVDQFLRQHV Criterio jurídico garantista 20 issn: 2145-3381 - Año 3 - No. 4 - Enero-Junio de 2011 (VSUHFLVRHQWRQFHVDFODUDUODQRFLyQGHGHUHFKR VXEMHWLYR3DUDHOORHV~WLOFRPHQ]DUSRUGHUHFKRV TXHD~QQRVHDQQLOHJDOHVQLPRUDOHVRTXHQR UHTXLHUHQ VHUOR FRPR HVWUDWHJLD SDUD HQWHQGHU GLFKDQRFLyQ(VWRVGHUHFKRVSHUVRQDOHVVXUJHQ SRUHMHPSORHQHOFDVRGHODSURPHVD&XDQGRVH SURPHWHDOJRVHJHQHUDXQGHUHFKRFRUUHVSRQGLHQ WHDXQDREOLJDFLyQ(VWR\REOLJDGRDFXPSOLUOD SURPHVD\ODVSHUVRQDVWLHQHQGHUHFKRDH[LJLUVX FXPSOLPLHQWR3HURORVGHUHFKRVVRQFRVDVTXHVH H[LJHQSHURWDPELpQDOJRDORTXHVHSXHGHUHQXQ FLDU$GHPiVHVSRVLEOHDSUHQGHUORTXHVLJQLILFD WHQHUXQGHUHFKRFRQDQWHULRULGDGDODFDSDFLGDG SDUD HYDOXDU PRUDOPHQWH (Q FRQVHFXHQFLD DO DILUPDU TXH URPSHU XQD SURPHVD HV PDOR VyOR TXHUHPRVGHFLU´TXHH[LVWHXQDREOLJDFLyQPRUDO QRUHODWLYDGHPDQWHQHUODREOLJDFLyQUHODWLYDTXH WHQHPRVIUHQWHDTXLHQKHPRVKHFKRODSURPHVDµ 3RUORWDQWRVLHVWRHVDVtWRGDYtDQRVHSRVHHXQD H[SOLFDFLyQGHORTXHVLJQLILFDXQGHUHFKRPRUDO /RTXHWHQHPRVHVXQDVXSHUSRVLFLyQGHORVQL YHOHVPRUDO\OHJDO/DUXSWXUDGHXQDSURPHVD PHSXHGHHQYLDUDODFiUFHO/DVQRUPDVPRUDOHV SXHGHQGDUOXJDUDQRUPDVSHQDOHV\HOGHUHFKR SXHGHVHUHQMXLFLDGRPRUDOPHQWH 3HUR´¢(VUD]RQDEOHQRVyORFLPHQWDUORVGHUHFKRV HVSHFLDOHVPHGLDQWHORVJHQHUDOHVFRUUHVSRQGLHQ WHV PRUDOHV \R OHJDOHV VLQR WDPELpQ UHIHULU D ORVGHUHFKRVSDUWHVGHODVRWUDVQRUPDVPRUDOHV \OHJDOHV"µ/RTXHHVWiHQMXHJRDTXtHVWUDWDU GH MXVWLILFDU OD DPSOLDFLyQ GH ODV H[LJHQFLDV R UHFODPRVKDFLDDOJXLHQSURSLDVGHORVGHUHFKRV HVSHFLDOHV KDFLD XQD LQVWDQFLD GH UHFODPR PiV JHQHUDO HVWR HV HQ HO FDVR GHO GHUHFKR OHJDO KDFLDXQDLQVWDQFLDMXGLFLDO3HURHQHOFDVRGHO GHUHFKR PRUDO QR HV REYLR TXH FRQWDUtD DTXt FRPRXQDLQVWDQFLDGHUHFODPRPiVJHQHUDO$QWH HVWDGLILFXOWDGODSUHJXQWDREOLJDGDTXHVHKDFH 7XJHQGKDWHV´¢4XpVHQWLGRWLHQHHQJHQHUDO KDEODUGHXQGHUHFKRVREUHDOJR"µ7HQHUGHUHFKR VREUHXQDFRVDVLJQLILFDHQODLQWHUSUHWDFLyQGH $OH[\DQiORJDPHQWHFRPRHQHOFDVRGHORVGH UHFKRVHVSHFLDOHVTXHDOJXLHQGHEHUHVSRQGHUHQ HVWHFDVRHO(VWDGR3HURWDPELpQODH[LJHQFLDGH FXPSOLPLHQWRGHXQGHUHFKRSXHGHHVWDUGLULJLGD DWRGDVODVSHUVRQDV /DFXHVWLyQFODYHTXHKD\TXHUHVROYHUHV´¢TXp SXHGHTXHUHUGHFLUHQWRQFHVTXHORVVHUHVKXPD QRV´WLHQHQµFLHUWRVGHUHFKRVVLPSOHPHQWHSRUTXH VRQVHUHVKXPDQRV"µ$SULPHUDYLVWDQRSDUHFH VHUFODURTXHSXHGDQH[LVWLUGHUHFKRVTXHQRKDQ VLGR RWRUJDGRV SRU QDGLH FRPR VXFHGHUtD HQ HO FDVRGHORVGHUHFKRVKXPDQRVTXHVLPSOHPHQWHVH WLHQHQSRUHOKHFKRGHVHUVHUHVKXPDQRV¢3HURHV HVWRFRUUHFWR"6HJ~Q7XJHQGKDWQR/RVGHUHFKRV KXPDQRV VRQ RWRUJDGRV SRU QRVRWURV PLVPRV DWRGRVORVVHUHVKXPDQRVHQODPHGLGDHQTXH DFHSWDPRV\DGRSWDPRVODPRUDOGHOUHVSHWRXQL YHUVDO(QHVWHVHQWLGRORVGHUHFKRVPRUDOHVVRQ GHUHFKRVTXHVRQFRQIHULGRVSRUQRVRWURVPLVPRV VLDFHSWDPRVWUDWDUDORVGHPiVEDMRHOSULQFLSLR ´ORVLQWHUHVHVGHWRGRVGHEHQUHVSHWDUVHGHLJXDO PRGRHOORVWLHQHVGHUHFKRDHVRµ$FRQWLQXDFLyQ 7XJHQGKDWVHSUHJXQWDVLH[LVWHQWDOHVGHUHFKRV 78*(1'+$7(Lecciones de ética%DUFHORQD*HGLVDSiJ ,EtGSiJ ,EtG ,EtGSiJ Razón, sentimientos y derechos humanos Páginas 8 a 33 SXHVVLQRHVDVtVXDUJXPHQWRDIDYRUGHODIXQ GDPHQWDFLyQ GH ORV GHUHFKRV KXPDQRV VREUH HO SULQFLSLRGHOUHVSHWRXQLYHUVDOQRSDUHFHIXQFLR QDU/RTXHVHKDGHPRVWUDGRHVTXHVLH[LVWHQ HVRVGHUHFKRVXQDPDQHUDUD]RQDEOHGHH[SOLFDU VXRULJHQHVTXHKDQVLGRRWRUJDGRVDSHODQGRD ODPRUDOGHOUHVSHWRXQLYHUVDO3HURODFXHVWLyQ DKRUDHVVDEHUVLH[LVWHQ¢&yPRGHWHUPLQDPRV ODH[LVWHQFLDGHWDOHVGHUHFKRV"/DSUHJXQWDVyOR SXHGH VHU UHVSRQGLGD D SDUWLU GHO SULQFLSLR GHO HQMXLFLDPLHQWR PRUDO HVWR HV ´GHVGH HO OXJDU GRQGH«KD\TXHUHVSRQGHUDWRGDVODVFXHVWLR QHVPRUDOHV¢FyPRTXHUHPRVGHVGHXQSXQWRGH YLVWDLPSDUFLDOTXHWRGRVVHFRPSRUWHQ"µ3HUR ¢FyPRVHHVWDEOHFHODH[LVWHQFLDGHORVGHUHFKRV KXPDQRVDSDUWLUGHWDOSULQFLSLR"/DH[SOLFDFLyQ GH7XJHQGKDWHVODVLJXLHQWH 6LUHFRQRFHPRVDORWURFRPRVXMHWRGHGHUHFKRV ORFRQFHELPRVFRPRVRVWHQLHQGRHQVXPDQRXQD FDQWLGDG LQGHWHUPLQDGD GH ULHQGDV LQYLVLEOHV D ODVTXHHVWDPRVOLJDGRVHQFXDQWRPLHPEURV GH ODFRPXQLGDGPRUDO\TXHpOSXHGHUHFRUGDUQRV GDGRHOFDVR 7DOYH]HVWRQRVHDPXFKRSHURHVDOJRHORWUR HVFRQVLGHUDGRDKRUDFRPRVXMHWRVXMHWRGHGHUH FKRV\QRFRPRPHURREMHWRGHQXHVWUDVREOLJD FLRQHVHVGHFLUTXHHQWHQGHPRVQXHVWUDREOLJDFLyQ FRPRUHIOHMRGHVXGHUHFKR<VLQRVSUHJXQWDPRV VLHVGHVHDEOHHVWHUHIXHU]RGHODPRUDOGHVGHOD SHUVSHFWLYD LPSDUFLDO GHO DIHFWDGR OD UHVSXHVWD VyORSXHGHVHUSRVLWLYD\SRUFRQVLJXLHQWHH[LVWHQ GLFKRVGHUHFKRVWDQUiSLGDPHQWHVHSXHGHDTXt GHULYDUODH[LVWHQFLD\HVWiMXVWLILFDGRTXH\RKD\D FRPSUHQGLGRDVtGHVGHHOFRPLHQ]RODPRUDOGHO 21 LPSHUDWLYR FDWHJyULFR 4XHGD DTXt WDPELpQ PiV IXHUWHPHQWHVXEUD\DGRORTXHFLHUWDPHQWHHVWDED FRQWHQLGR HQ HO LPSHUDWLYR FDWHJyULFR HV GHFLU TXHDKRUDWRGRVHMX]JDGHVGHODSHUVSHFWLYDGH TXLHQHVSRVHHQORVGHUHFKRV$XQTXHHOFRQFHSWR GH GHUHFKR GHVFDQVD VREUH HO GH REOLJDFLyQ VX FRQWHQLGRHVWDOTXHODVREOLJDFLRQHVUHVXOWDQGH ORVLQWHUHVHV\QHFHVLGDGHV\GHORVGHUHFKRVTXH VHVLJXHQGHHOORVORVGHUHFKRVVHVLJXHQGHODV QHFHVLGDGHVVLHOORDSDUHFHFRPRGHVHDEOHGHVGH HOHQMXLFLDPLHQWRLPSDUFLDO /DDQWHULRUDUJXPHQWDFLyQGH7XJHQGKDWLPSOL FD FLHUWDV WHVLV SUREOHPiWLFDV /D SULPHUD WHVLV HVWDEOHFHTXHHOIXQGDPHQWRPiVSODXVLEOHVREUH HOFXDOVHHULJHQORVGHUHFKRVKXPDQRVHVHOSULQ FLSLR GHO UHVSHWR XQLYHUVDO (VWR HV DVt SXHV VH VXSRQHTXHGLFKRSULQFLSLRHVHOSULQFLSLRPRUDO PiVSODXVLEOH/DVHJXQGDWHVLVHVTXHKD\XQD FRUUHODFLyQPX\IXHUWHHQWUHLQWHUHVHVQHFHVLGD GHV\GHUHFKRVGHWDOIRUPDTXHVyORKD\GHUH FKRVVLVHWLHQHQORVFRUUHVSRQGLHQWHVLQWHUHVHV\ VHUHFRQRFHQGHVGHXQSXQWRGHYLVWDLPSDUFLDO (VWD ~OWLPD WHVLV SDUHFHUtD HQWUDU HQ FRQIOLFWR FRQODDILUPDFLyQGH7XJHQGKDWGHTXHORVQLxRV SHTXHxRVWLHQHQGHUHFKRVSHURQRREOLJDFLRQHV SXHVFDEUtDSUHJXQWDUVHVLWLHQHVHQWLGRDWULEXLU LQWHUHVHV\QHFHVLGDGHVDXQQLxR$SULPHUDYLV WDSDUHFHTXHQRWLHQHVHQWLGR\HQFRQVHFXHQFLD ORVQLxRVQRWHQGUtDQFLHUWRVGHUHFKRV7XJHQGKDW SRGUtDUHSOLFDUTXHSXHGHHVWDUGHQWURGHQXHVWURV LQWHUHVHVODREOLJDFLyQGHUHFRQRFHUOHVXQGHWHU PLQDGRGHUHFKRDORVQLxRVSHURHVWRQRLPSOLFD ,EtGSiJ ,EtGSiJ9DOHODSHQDVHxDODUODVLPLOLWXGGHSODQWHDPLHQWRVHQWUH7XJHQGKDW\$ODQ*HZLUWKHQHOWHPDGHODIXQGDPHQWD FLyQGHORVGHUHFKRVKXPDQRV6HJ~Q*HZLUWKORVGHUHFKRVKXPDQRV´UHTXLHUHQTXHWRGRDJHQWHWRPHHQFXHQWDIDYRUDEOHPHQWH ORVPiVLPSRUWDQWHVLQWHUHVHVGHORVGHPiVDJHQWHVIXWXURVµ*HZLUWK$´/DEDVH\HOFRQWHQLGRGHORVGHUHFKRVKXPDQRVµHQ %HWHJyQ-HGDerecho y moral%DUFHORQD$ULHOSiJ 9HU78*(1'+$7(Lecciones de ética%DUFHORQD*HGLVDSiJ\VLJXLHQWHV Criterio jurídico garantista 22 issn: 2145-3381 - Año 3 - No. 4 - Enero-Junio de 2011 TXHHOORVWHQJDQHQVtPLVPRVHVRVGHUHFKRV6L ODDWULEXFLyQGHGHUHFKRVGHSHQGHGHSRGHUWHQHU LQWHUHVHVHQWRQFHV7XJHQGKDWVHUtDQXHYDPHQWH XQXWLOLWDULVWDSXHVSDUD6LQJHUSRUHMHPSORWH QHUGHUHFKRDODYLGDVHUHODFLRQDFRQHOLQWHUpV SRUHVWDUYLYR\SRUORWDQWRFRQODFDSDFLGDGGH WHQHULQWHUHVHVTXHVyORHVDWULEXLEOHDORVVHUHV KXPDQRVTXHVRQSHUVRQDVHVGHFLUVHUHVDXWR FRQVFLHQWHV\UDFLRQDOHVFDSDFLGDGTXHQRSRVHHQ ORVQLxRV FLyQPRUDOGHUHVSHWRDORVVHUHVKXPDQRV1LORV LVUDHOtHV TXH PDWDQ PXVXOPDQHV QL ORV PXVXO PDQHVTXHPDWDQLVUDHOtHVHVWiQGHVGHVXSXQWR GHYLVWDYLRODQGRHOGHUHFKRDODYLGDGHQDGLH $PERVDGXFHQTXHHVWiQPDWDQGRDQLPDOHVQR SUHFLVDPHQWH VHUHV KXPDQRV /D UHVSXHVWD GHO IXQGDFLRQDOLVPR PRUDO WUDGLFLRQDO D HVWH FRQ WUDVHQWLGRVHJ~Q5RUW\KDVLGRODGHEXVFDUXQ FULWHULRSDUDHVWDEOHFHU´TXpWLHQHQGHHVSHFLDOORV EtSHGRVLPSOXPHVH[SOLFDQGRTXpHVORHVHQFLDOD ORVVHUHVKXPDQRVµ Derechos humanos sin fundamentos: la propuesta de Rorty /DSRVHVLyQGHUDFLRQDOLGDGKDSHUPLWLGRKLVWy ULFDPHQWHVHSDUDUDORVDQLPDOHVGHORVKRPEUHV FRQVWLWX\pQGRVH DGHPiV HQ HO IXQGDPHQWR GH OD PRUDOLGDG7DOHQIRTXHVHJ~Q5RUW\GHEHSRVWXODU XQDUHDOLGDGWUDQVFXOWXUDOTXHSHUPLWDTXHGLFKD UDFLRQDOLGDGVHSXHGDSUHGLFDUGHPDQHUDXQLYHUVDO GHORVVHUHVKXPDQRV3HUR¢HVFRUUHFWRKDEODUGH XQD UDFLRQDOLGDG XQLYHUVDO" ¢(V HO SULQFLSLR GHO UHVSHWRXQLYHUVDOWUDQVFXOWXUDOHOIXQGDPHQWRGH ORVGHUHFKRVKXPDQRVFRPRVRVWLHQH7XJHQGKDW" 3DUD5RUW\QRKD\SRVLELOLGDGGHKDOODUXQIXQ GDPHQWR DOOHQGH OD FXOWXUD SDUD WDOHV GHUHFKRV 3RUHOFRQWUDULRSDUD5RUW\KD\TXH´GHIHQGHUOD WHVLVGHTXHQDGDTXHVHDUHOHYDQWHSDUDODGHFLVLyQ PRUDOVHSDUDDORVVHUHVKXPDQRVGHORVDQLPDOHV H[FHSWRFLHUWRVKHFKRVGHOPXQGRKLVWyULFDPHQWH FRQWLQJHQWHVKHFKRVFXOWXUDOHVµ 6HJ~Q 5RUW\ HV SRVLEOH KDEODU GH XQD pWLFD VLQ IXQGDPHQWRVXQLYHUVDOHVVLQTXHSRUHOORDQXOH (QDUDVGHODGLVFXVLyQVXSRQJDPRVTXHORGLFKR KDVWDDTXtHQFRQWUDGH7XJHQGKDWQRHVYiOLGR\ TXHVXSURSXHVWDPRUDOVHDODPiVSODXVLEOH\VLUYD SDUDIXQGDPHQWDUORVGHUHFKRVKXPDQRV3HURVL HVSRVLEOHGHPRVWUDUTXHORVGHUHFKRVKXPDQRV QRUHTXLHUHQGHIXQGDPHQWDFLyQHQWRQFHV¢TXp VHQWLGR WLHQH KDEODU GH XQD PRUDO SODXVLEOH" $ FRQWLQXDFLyQH[SRQGUp\DQDOL]DUpORVDUJXPHQWRV GH5RUW\DIDYRUGHODWHVLVGHTXHORVGHUHFKRVKX PDQRVQLQHFHVLWDQQLSXHGHQVHUIXQGDPHQWDGRVD SDUWLUGHXQSULQFLSLRUDFLRQDOFRPRFODUDPHQWH VRVWLHQH7XJHQGKDW 6LTXLHQHVYLRODQORVGHUHFKRVKXPDQRVQRFUHHQ HVWDUYLROiQGRORVHQWRQFHVODH[SOLFDFLyQGHHVWD SDUDGRMDVHGHEHDTXHTXLHQHVPDWDQ\YLRODQD RWURVQRORVLQFOX\HQHQHOFtUFXORGHFRQVLGHUD 6,1*(53Ética práctica/RQGUHV&DPEULGJH8QLYHUVLW\3UHVVSiJ 5RUW\MXQWRFRQ0LFKDHO,JQDWLHIIHVXQRGHORVUHSUHVHQWDQWHVPiVGHVWDFDGRVGHOHQIRTXHDQWLIXQGDFLRQDOLVWDGHORVGHUHFKRV KXPDQRV9HU,JQDWLHII0´+XPDQ5LJKWVDV,GRODWU\µHQ*XWPDQ$Human Rights as Politics an Idolatry.3ULQFHWRQ3ULQFHWRQ 8QLYHUVLW\3UHVV 5257<5Verdad y progreso%DUFHORQD3DLGyVSiJ ,EtGSiJ Razón, sentimientos y derechos humanos Páginas 8 a 33 23 4XLHQDILUPHTXHHOUHVSHWR DORVGHUHFKRVKXPDQRV GHSHQGHGHOFRQRFLPLHQWR GHODQDWXUDOH]DKXPDQD HVWiFRPSURPHWLGRFRQ HOFRQRFLPLHQWRGHKHFKRV TXHVRQLQGHSHQGLHQWHV GHODFXOWXUD\ODKLVWRULD PRVODSRVLELOLGDGGHIRPHQWDUHOUHVSHWRDORV GHUHFKRVKXPDQRV6LQRHVSRVLEOHKDEODUGHXQD QDWXUDOH]DKXPDQDXQLYHUVDOHQWRQFHVHOUHVSHWR DODYLGDKXPDQDQRVXSRQHKDOODUODHVHQFLDGH ORKXPDQR0iVELHQHOUHVSHWRDODYLGDKXPD QD VH DSR\D HQ KHFKRV KLVWyULFRV \ FXOWXUDOHV QR HQ DOJR TXH HVWp PiV DOOi GH WDOHV KHFKRV FRQWLQJHQWHV4XLHQDILUPHTXHHOUHVSHWRDORV GHUHFKRVKXPDQRVGHSHQGHGHOFRQRFLPLHQWRGH ODQDWXUDOH]DKXPDQDHVWiFRPSURPHWLGRFRQHO FRQRFLPLHQWRGHKHFKRVTXHVRQLQGHSHQGLHQWHV GHODFXOWXUD\ODKLVWRULD3HURSDUD5RUW\QR HVSRVLEOHHVFDSDUGHQXHVWURVFRQGLFLRQDPLHQ WRVKLVWyULFRV\FXOWXUDOHV\HQWUDUHQFRQWDFWR UDFLRQDOFRQHODWULEXWRGLVWLQWLYR\HVHQFLDOGH ORKXPDQR(OVXSXHVWRGHTXHH[LVWHXQFRQR FLPLHQWRGHODQDWXUDOH]DKXPDQDGHVFDQVDDVX YH]VREUHHOVXSXHVWRGHTXHKD\XQDHVHQFLDGH ORKXPDQR\XQDFDSDFLGDGUDVWUHDGRUDGHGLFKD ,EtGSiJ HVHQFLD3HURWDOHVVXSXHVWRVVRQLQGHIHQGLEOHV VLVHDGRSWDXQHQIRTXHQDWXUDOLVWDLQVSLUDGRHQ 'DUZLQTXLHQ KDVDFDGRDODPD\RUtDGHORVLQWHOHFWXDOHVGHODLGHD GHTXHORVVHUHVKXPDQRVWLHQHQXQLQJUHGLHQWH HVSHFLDODxDGLGR1RVKDFRQYHQFLGRDFDVLWRGRVGH TXHVRPRVDQLPDOHVFRQXQWDOHQWRH[FHSFLRQDOOR VXILFLHQWHPHQWHLQWHOLJHQWHVSDUDKDFHUQRVFDUJR GHQXHVWUDSURSLDHYROXFLyQ (OJUDQOHJDGRGH'DUZLQHVKDEHUPRVWUDGRTXH QRSXHGHKDEHUXQDHVHQFLDGHORKXPDQR\TXH ODFRQGLFLyQKXPDQDHVHVWDUVRPHWLGDDOFDPELR ORVKXPDQRVVRQPiVPRGLILFDEOHV\PiVVXMHWRVD UHFUHDUVHXQD\RWUDYH]TXHORTXHHOHVHQFLDOLVPR SODWyQLFRSHQVy3RUHOORODFUHFLHQWHFRQFLHQFLD KLVWyULFD GH HVWD FRQGLFLyQ FRQWLQJHQWH GH OR KXPDQRKDFHTXHFDUH]FDQGHVHQWLGRWRGRVORV SURJUDPDVGHLQYHVWLJDFLyQILORVyILFRVTXHHVSH UDQHQFRQWUDUQXHVWUDYHUGDGHUDQDWXUDOH]DFRPR Criterio jurídico garantista 24 issn: 2145-3381 - Año 3 - No. 4 - Enero-Junio de 2011 FRQGLFLyQ SDUD KDEODU GH XQ IXQGDPHQWR ILUPH SDUDODPRUDO'HKHFKR'DUZLQQRSURSRQHRWUD WHRUtDVREUHODYHUGDGHUDQDWXUDOH]DKXPDQDVLQR TXH´QRVGDUD]RQHVSDUDQRWHQHUTXHSUHJXQWDU TXpVRPRVHQUHDOLGDGµ3RUORWDQWRVLORVGH UHFKRVKXPDQRVGHEHQHVWDUIXQGDPHQWDGRVHQ KHFKRVWUDQVFXOWXUDOHVPRUDOPHQWHVLJQLILFDWLYRV HQWRQFHVWDOHVKHFKRVGHEHQH[LVWLULQGHSHQGLHQ WHPHQWHGHFXDOTXLHUFXOWXUD3HURVLVHORJUDQ KDOODUEXHQDVUD]RQHVSDUDFUHHUTXHWDOHVKHFKRV QR H[LVWHQ HVWR VXSRQGUtD QHJDU OD SRVLELOLGDG GHHQWUDUHQFRQWDFWRFRQODYHUGDGHUDQDWXUDOH ]DKXPDQD/DHVHQFLDGHODQDWXUDOH]DKXPDQD UHVXOWDUtDVHUXQPLWRSODWyQLFRFX\DUHDOLGDGQR TXHGD GHPRVWUDGD SRU OD XUJHQWH QHFHVLGDG GH HVFDSDUXQD\RWUDYH]GHODFRQWLQJHQFLDGHWRGR ORKXPDQR3DUD5RUW\HVSRVLEOHGHVDUUROODUXQ DUJXPHQWRSUDJPDWLVWDTXHGHPXHVWUHODIXWLOLGDG PRUDOGHOSODWRQLVPRDVDEHU (VWH DUJXPHQWR SUDJPDWLVWD HQ FRQWUD GH ORV SODWy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tWRGRDKLVWR ULDVWULVWHV\VHQWLPHQWDOHVTXHQRVKDQUHODWDGR KDVWDODFRQFOXVLyQGHTXHSUREDEOHPHQWHQRKD\D ,EtGSiJ ,EtGSiJ XQFRQRFLPLHQWRGHOWLSRTXH3ODWyQLPDJLQy< DxDGLPRV TXH QR SDUHFLHQGR TXH OD LQVLVWHQFLD HQXQDSUHWHQGLGDQDWXUDOH]DKXPDQDDKLVWyULFD VHHVWpWUDGXFLHQGRHQQDGD~WLOSUREDEOHPHQWH QRH[LVWDXQDWDOQDWXUDOH]DRFXDQGRPHQRVQR KD\QDGDHQHOODTXHVHDUHOHYDQWHSDUDQXHVWUDV GHFLVLRQHVPRUDOHV (OGHQRPLQDGRDUJXPHQWRSUDJPiWLFRGHODHIL FDFLDFDXVDOSURSXHVWRSRU5RUW\VHDSR\DHQOD HQVHxDQ]DGH-DPHVGHVRPHWHUODVLGHDVILORVyILFDV DODFULEDGHVXVUHVXOWDGRVSUiFWLFRV(VSUHFLVR DQDOL]DUVL\FyPRORVSUREOHPDV\DUJXPHQWRV ILORVyILFRVLQFLGHQHQORVDVXQWRVKXPDQRV3DUD DPERV SUDJPDWLVWDV DILUPDU TXH XQD FUHHQFLD HV YHUGDGHUD HV OR PLVPR TXH VRVWHQHU TXH WDO FUHHQFLDGHWHUPLQDXQDGLIHUHQFLDLPSRUWDQWHHQ ODSUiFWLFD(QHVWHVHQWLGRUHFXUULUDXQFRQRFL PLHQWRPRUDOWUDQVFXOWXUDOQRVLUYHSDUDH[SOLFDU FyPR VH GD HO UHVSHWR D ORV GHUHFKRV KXPDQRV SXHV WDO UHFXUVR FDUHFH GH HILFDFLD FDXVDO 6LQ WDOHILFDFLDQRKD\FyPRDVHJXUDUODUHDOLGDGGH XQRVKHFKRVPRUDOHVWUDQVFXOWXUDOHVFX\RFRQR FLPLHQWREULQGHXQRVIXQGDPHQWRVVyOLGRVSDUD HO HVWDEOHFLPLHQWR \ HO UHVSHWR GH ORV GHUHFKRV KXPDQRV3DUD5RUW\QRHVODSUHJXQWDSODWyQLFD ´¢TXpVRPRV"µVLQRPiVELHQODSUHJXQWD´¢TXp TXHUHPRV KDFHU GH QRVRWURV"µ OD TXH GHEH VHU UHVSRQGLGD+D\TXHH[DPLQDUODVFRQVHFXHQFLDV SUiFWLFDVGHDGRSWDUFLHUWDVFUHHQFLDVPRUDOHVHQ YH]GHEXVFDUODHVHQFLDGHODERQGDG /RVSUDJPDWLVWDVQRFUHHQTXHODLQGDJDFLyQSXHGH SRQHUQRVHQFRQWDFWRFRQXQDUHDOLGDGQRKXPD QDPiVGHORTXHKD\DPRVSRGLGRHVWDUQXQFD\ SRU FRQVLJXLHQWH VHJ~Q HOORV OD ~QLFD FXHVWLyQ Razón, sentimientos y derechos humanos Páginas 8 a 33 LPSRUWDQWHHV¢VHUiPHMRUODYLGDKXPDQDHQHO IXWXURVLDGRSWDPRVHVWDFUHHQFLDHVWDSUiFWLFD HVWDLQVWLWXFLyQ" /D SURPRFLyQ GH ORV GHUHFKRV KXPDQRV QR GHSHQGHGHDUJXPHQWRVTXHUHFXUUDQDXQDUD FLRQDOLGDG WUDQVFXOWXUDO $KRUD ELHQ ¢DSHODU D ORVVHQWLPLHQWRVPRUDOHVWLHQHODHILFDFLDFDXVDO QHFHVDULD SDUD H[SOLFDU HO IORUHFLPLHQWR GH XQD FXOWXUDGHOUHVSHWRDORVGHUHFKRVKXPDQRV"3DUD 5RUW\pVWHHVHOFDVRORFXDOVLJQLILFDTXHUHDOL]DU ODXWRStDGHOD,OXVWUDFLyQHVWRHVODXWRStDOLEHUDO GHOUHVSHWRDFLHUWRVGHUHFKRVLQDOLHQDEOHVVyORVH SXHGHKDFHUUHDOLGDG´DEDVHGHPDQLSXODUQXHV WURV VHQWLPLHQWRV \ QR LQFUHPHQWDQGR QXHVWUR FRQRFLPLHQWR«µ )UHQWH D SHQVDGRUHV FRPR 7XJHQGKDW 5RUW\ LQWHQWDPRVWUDUODSODXVLELOLGDGGHXQDpWLFDGHO UHVSHWRDORVGHUHFKRVKXPDQRVVLQQHFHVLGDGGH SRVWXODUIXQGDPHQWRVUDFLRQDOHVXQLYHUVDOHV(V SUHFLVRDFXGLUDORVVHQWLPLHQWRVPRUDOHV\VXSHUDU HOGXDOLVPRWUDGLFLRQDOHQWUHUD]yQ\VHQWLPLHQWR GHOFXDOHVWRGDYtDSUHVDHOILOyVRIRDOHPiQ+D\ TXHDEDQGRQDUODWUDGLFLyQSODWyQLFDUHVSRQVDEOH GH HVWH GXDOLVPR H LQVSLUDUVH HQ ILOyVRIRV FRPR +XPHTXLHQFXHVWLRQyODVXSXHVWDRSRVLFLyQHQ WUHUD]yQ\VHQWLPLHQWR+XPHKDPRVWUDGRFRQ FUHFHVTXHXQDDGHFXDGDFRPSUHQVLyQGHODPRUDO 25 QRSXHGHVHUDMHQDDOSDSHOGHWHUPLQDQWHGHORV VHQWLPLHQWRVPRUDOHV $ SDUWLU GH HVWD LGHD GH +XPH 5RUW\ DGHODQWD XQDFUtWLFDHQFRQWUDGHODWUDGLFLyQUDFLRQDOLVWD\ IXQGDFLRQDOLVWDHQILORVRItDPRUDO7DOWUDGLFLyQKD GDGRSRUVXSXHVWRTXHOD~QLFDIRUPDGHFRQFHELU \H[SOLFDUHOSURJUHVRPRUDOHVLQWHUSUHWiQGROR ~QLFDPHQWHFRPRXQSURJUHVRUHODWLYRDOFRQR FLPLHQWRPRUDO$GHPiVGHVGHHVWDySWLFDUDFLR QDOLVWD ORV VHQWLPLHQWRV QR SXHGHQ GDU FXHQWD GHOFRQFHSWRGHREOLJDFLyQPRUDOQHFHVDULRSDUD KDEODU GH GHUHFKRV KXPDQRV FRPR OR VRVWLHQH FODUDPHQWH7XJHQGKDW 3HURVHJ~Q5RUW\ODQRFLyQGHREOLJDFLyQPRUDO QRUHTXLHUHGHXQDWHRUtDILORVyILFDTXHODH[SOLTXH FRPR7XJHQGKDWDILUPDSXHVHQUHDOLGDGQRKD\ QDGDTXpH[SOLFDU1RHVYHUGDGTXHODVSHUVRQDV VHPXHVWUHQPiVUHVSHWXRVDVGHORVGHUHFKRVKX PDQRVSRUTXHVHSDQPiVDFHUFDGHODQDWXUDOH]D GHOELHQHQVtRGHODQDWXUDOH]DXQLYHUVDOGHOD UDFLRQDOLGDGSUiFWLFD/RTXHVHSXHGH\VHGHEH FRPSUHQGHUGHODREOLJDFLyQPRUDOQRVHREWLHQH GHXQDIXHQWHGLVWLQWDDORTXHODWUDGLFLyQOLEHUDO KDORJUDGRHQORVGLIHUHQWHVSURFHVRVGHDFXOWXUD FLyQ\GHJHQHUDFLyQGHQXHYRVKiELWRVGHUHVSHWR DORVGHUHFKRVKXPDQRV 5257<5El pragmatismo, una versión%DUFHORQD$ULHOSiJ'HKHFKRSDUD5RUW\ODVpWLFDVWUDGLFLRQDOHVTXHDSHODQ DUHDOLGDGHVSODWyQLFDVRFXDVLSODWyQLFDVSDUDIXQGDPHQWDUODPRUDOGHOUHVSHWRDORVGHUHFKRVKXPDQRVSXHGHQVHUDFXVDGDVGH pWLFDVDXWRULWDULDV(VWRLQFOX\HD3ODWyQ.DQW\7XJHQGKDW3RUHVRSDUD5RUW\VXHQIRTXHSUDJPiWLFR\DQWLIXQGDFLRQDOLVWDGH ORVGHUHFKRVKXPDQRVGHEHGHIHQGHUODSRVLELOLGDGGHXQSXQWRGHYLVWDDQWLDXWRULWDULR´&RQDQWLDXWRULWDULVPRHQpWLFDPHUHILHUR DOGHVDUUROORTXHDFDERGHGHVFULELUODDFWLWXGTXHHQWLHQGHORTXHFDOLILFDPRVGHDERPLQDFLyQGHPRUDOQRFRPRXQDLQWXLFLyQ SURGXFLGDSRUXQDSDUWHGHQRVRWURVTXHHVWiHQFRQH[LyQFRQDOJRQRKXPDQR\EXHQRVLQRVLPSOHPHQWHFRPRXQOHJDGRFXOWXUDO UHYLVDEOHµ,EtGSiJ/DPRUDOSODXVLEOHGH7XJHQGKDWQRSDUHFHVHUXQ´OHJDGRFXOWXUDOUHYLVDEOHµ 5257<5Verdad y progreso%DUFHORQD3DLGyVSiJ +80('Investigación sobre los principios de la moral.%XHQRV$LUHV$JXLODU Criterio jurídico garantista 26 issn: 2145-3381 - Año 3 - No. 4 - Enero-Junio de 2011 (OHUURUIXQGDFLRQDOGHODILORVRItDPRUDOWUDGLFLR QDOHQHOFXDOFDHWDPELpQ7XJHQGKDWFRQVLVWHHQ IDEULFDUXQDLPDJHQPtWLFDGHXQ\RQRUHODFLRQDO HJRtVWDTXHVyORVLJXHVXVLQFOLQDFLRQHVVLQWHQHU HQFXHQWDORVLQWHUHVHVGHORVGHPiV7DOHVWUD WHJLD EDVDGD HQ OD FUHDFLyQ GH HVWH PtWLFR \R SHUPLWHDVHJXUDUTXHORVVHQWLPLHQWRVQRVRQOR VXILFLHQWHPHQWHVyOLGRVSDUDHQIUHQWDUORVUHWRV GHODPRUDOLGDG\TXHHVVyORODUD]yQODTXHSXH GHVDOYDUDORVVHUHVKXPDQRV\FRQYHUWLUORVHQ PHMRUHVSHUVRQDV(QSDODEUDVGH5RUW\ XQ\RTXHSXHGHH[LVWLUVLQSUHRFXSDUVHSRUORV GHPiV XQ \R YLVWR FRPR XQ IUtR SVLFySDWD TXH HVSUHFLVRUHSULPLUSDUDWHQHUHQFXHQWDODVQH FHVLGDGHV GH OD GHPiV JHQWH (VWD HV OD LPDJHQ GHO \R TXH ILOyVRIRV FRPR 3ODWyQ LQWHUSUHWDURQ HQWpUPLQRVGHODGLYLVLyQUD]yQSDVLRQHV'HVGH 3ODWyQ2FFLGHQWHKDFRQVLGHUDGRTXHODGLVWLQFLyQ UD]yQSDVLyQ HV SDUDOHOD D OD GLVWLQFLyQ HQWUH OR XQLYHUVDO\ORLQGLYLGXDO\DODGLVWLQFLyQHQWUH DFWRV GHVLQWHUHVDGRV \ DFWRV HJRtVWDV 'H HVWD VXHUWHODVWUDGLFLRQHVUHOLJLRVDSODWyQLFD\NDQ WLDQDQRVKDQFDUJDGRFRQODGLVWLQFLyQHQWUHXQ \RYHUGDGHUR\XQIDOVR\RHQWUHXQ\RDWHQWRDOR TXHOHGLFHODFRQFLHQFLD\XQRTXHHVWiSUHRFXSDGR SRUVXYHUGDGHURLQWHUpV(VWH~OWLPR\RQROOHJD DVHUPRUDOHVVyORSUXGHQFLDO 6RQ SUHFLVDPHQWH HVWH WLSR H[SOLFDFLRQHV UDFLR QDOLVWDVGHODPRUDOODVTXHKD\TXHDEDQGRQDU FRPR FRQGLFLyQ SDUD FRPHQ]DU D UHFRQRFHU HO YDORUGHORVVHQWLPLHQWRVPRUDOHV5RUW\FUHHTXH KD\XQDDOWHUQDWLYDUHDODODVH[SOLFDFLRQHV\IXQ GDPHQWDFLRQHVUDFLRQDOLVWDVGHODPRUDO6LQRVH DFHSWDTXHORVVHUHVKXPDQRVWLHQHQODFDSDFLGDG GHVHQWLUVLPSDWtDSRUORVGHPiVHOSUREOHPDTXH SODQWHD HO DPRUDOLVPR GH SRU TXp GHEHPRV VHU PRUDOHVVHUtDLQVROXEOHVLWRGRVORVVHUHVKXPDQRV IXHUDQSDUiVLWRVPRUDOHV(QHVWHRUGHQGHLGHDV HOSURJUHVRPRUDOQRWHQGUtDQDGDTXHYHUFRQXQ VXSXHVWRDXPHQWRGHODUDFLRQDOLGDGSUiFWLFDGH ORVDJHQWHVPRUDOHV3RUHOFRQWUDULRSURJUHVDU VLJQLILFDVHJ~Q5RUW\HQWHQGHUTXHXQDFXOWXUD HV PHMRU TXH RWUD SRUTXH UHVSHWD ORV GHUHFKRV KXPDQRV$KRUDELHQWDOUHVSHWRVyORVHHQWLHQGH VLWLHQHHQFXHQWDTXHWDOHVVHUHVKXPDQRVKDQ ORJUDGRXQDVHQVLELOLGDGFDGDYH]PD\RUKDFLDVXV VHPHMDQWHVHVGHFLUVRQPiVVROLGDULRVVLHQWHQHO GRORUDMHQRFRPRDOJRSURSLR7DOVHQVLELOLGDGDO GRORUDMHQRHVORTXHSHUPLWHOXFKDUSRUHOUHFR QRFLPLHQWRGHORVGHUHFKRVKXPDQRVGHDTXHOORV TXHWUDGLFLRQDOPHQWHQRVRQFRQVLGHUDGRVLJXDOHV HQGHUHFKRVORVKRPRVH[XDOHVODVPLQRUtDVpWQL FDVHWF6LQXQDHGXFDFLyQVHQWLPHQWDOVLQVHQ WLPLHQWRVPRUDOHVGHVDUUROODGRVHOVXHxRGHXQD VRFLHGDGLQFOX\HQWHQRGHMDGHVHUXQDTXLPHUD (O PHMRU DUJXPHQWR \ SUREDEOHPHQWH HO ~QLFR SDUDGHMDUDWUiV HO IXQGDFLRQDOLVPR HV HO TXH \D KHVXJHULGRKDFHUORVHUtDPiVHILFD]SRUTXHQRV SHUPLWLUtD FRQFHQWUDU QXHVWUDV HQHUJtDV HQ OD PDQLSXODFLyQGHORVVHQWLPLHQWRVHQODHGXFDFLyQ VHQWLPHQWDO(VWDFODVHGHHGXFDFLyQIDPLOLDUL]DOR VXILFLHQWHHQWUHVtDODVSHUVRQDVGHtQGROHGLYHUVD FRPRSDUDTXHHVWpQPHQRVWHQWDGRVGHPLUDUD ORVTXHVRQGLIHUHQWHVDHOORVFRPRVLVyORIXHUDQ FXDVLKXPDQRV/DPHWDGHHVWDIRUPDGHPDQLSX ODFLyQGHORVVHQWLPLHQWRVHVH[SDQGLUODUHIHUHQFLD GHODVH[SUHVLRQHVSHUVRQDVGHQXHVWURWLSR\JHQWH FRPRQRVRWURV 5257<5El pragmatismo, una versión%DUFHORQD$ULHOSS 5257<5Verdad y progreso%DUFHORQD3DLGyVSiJ3DUD7XJHQGKDWODMXVWLILFDFLyQGHODPRUDOQRSXHGHGHSHQGHUGH ODVPRWLYDFLRQHVHVGHFLUGHORVVHQWLPLHQWRVVLQRGHXQFRQMXQWRVXVWDQWLYRGHUD]RQHV$GHPiVORVVHQWLPLHQWRVVyORWLHQHQXQ SDSHOHQODpWLFDVLVHSUHVXSRQHDQWHVHOUHVSHWRHVGHFLUTXHHOSULQFLSLRGHODPRUDOLGDGHVDQWHULRUDOVHQWLPLHQWR\QRDOFRQ Razón, sentimientos y derechos humanos Páginas 8 a 33 27 Conclusión ¢(V FRKHUHQWHODSRVWXUDGH5RUW\DOKDEODUGH XQDpWLFDVLQIXQGDPHQWRV\GHIHQGHUQRREVWDQWH ORV GHUHFKRV KXPDQRV" ¢1R UHTXLHUHQ GHVSXpV GHWRGRORVGHUHFKRVKXPDQRVGHXQIXQGDPHQWR XQLYHUVDO"$PDQHUDGHFRQFOXVLyQPHJXVWDUtD DQDOL]DU\HYDOXDUDOJXQRVDUJXPHQWRVHQFRQWUD GHODQWLIXQGDFLRQDOLVPRGH5RUW\ 3DUDDOJXQRVWHyULFRVFRPR6FKDHIHUODSRVWXUD GH5RUW\HVLQFRQVLVWHQWHSRUORFXDOQRHVSRVLEOH VHUDQWLIXQGDFLRQDOLVWDHQpWLFD\HVWDUDIDYRUGH ORVGHUHFKRVKXPDQRV(VSUHFLVRVHUXQIXQGDFLR QDOLVWDVLVHTXLHUHGHIHQGHUWDOHVGHUHFKRVSXHV VXH[SOLFDFLyQ>ODGH5RUW\@GHSRUTXpHOSUR\HFWR GH ORV GHUHFKRV KXPDQRV HV UHOHYDQWH WDPELpQ LPSOLFDODDILUPDFLyQGHXQVXSXHVWRFUXFLDOTXH VyORSXHGHVHUMXVWLILFDGRDSHODQGRDDOJ~QIXQ GDPHQWR 6yORQXHVWUDIDOLEOHFDSDFLGDG GHVHQWLUVROLGDULGDGSXHGHDFHUFDUQRV DOLGHDOOLEHUDOGHFRQVLGHUDU TXHODFUXHOGDGHVXQDRSFLyQ TXHSRGHPRV\GHEHPRVDEDQGRQDU 3RUVXSXHVWRKD\TXHDGPLWLU TXHSRGHPRVIUDFDVDUXQD\RWUDYH] DQWHVGHORJUDUORVLHVTXH ORORJUDPRV7RGDHVSHUDQ]DHV GHVSXpVGHWRGRIDOLEOH 6LORVGHUHFKRVKXPDQRVQRSUHFLVDQGHXQIXQGD PHQWRTXHGHVFDQVHVREUHREOLJDFLRQHVPRUDOHV XQLYHUVDOHVVLQRTXHVyOREDVWDDSHODUDVHQWLPLHQ WRVPRUDOHVFRPRSURSRQH5RUW\HQWRQFHV¢FyPR H[SOLFDUHOSURJUHVRPRUDOFRQEDVHHQHOGHVD UUROORHLQFUHPHQWRGHXQVHQWLPLHQWRGHVLPSDWtD FDGDYH]PiVJHQHUDOL]DGRVLQSUHVXSRQHUDOJ~Q WLSRGHIXQGDPHQWRTXHH[SOLTXHODDPSOLDFLyQGH GLFKR VHQWLPLHQWR" (O SURJUHVR PRUDO UHTXLHUH SRVWXODUVHQWLPLHQWRVPRUDOHVTXHVHDQUHFRQR FLGRV FRPR YDOLRVRV WUDQVFXOWXUDOPHQWH 5RUW\ FXDOYXHOYHLQFRQVLVWHQWHVXSRVWXUDDIDYRUGHORV WLHQHTXHVHUXQHVHQFLDOLVWDGHVSXpVGHWRGROR GHUHFKRVKXPDQRVDOWHQHUTXHSUHVXSRQHUSDUD WUDULRFRPRVXJLHUH5RUW\,QFOXVRVLVHDGPLWLHVHTXHORVVHQWLPLHQWRVIXHUDQGHWHUPLQDQWHVHQODpWLFDVyORORVHUtDQGHPDQHUD FRQWLQJHQWHDOJRTXHVHUtDVXPDPDPHQWHSUREOHPiWLFRGHVGHHOSODQWHDPLHQWRGH7XJHQGKDW0iVDGHODQWHQRVRFXSDUHPRVGH XQDSRVLEOHUHVSXHVWDGH5RUW\DHVWDREMHFLyQ 6&+$()(5%´+XPDQ5LJKWVSUREOHPVZLWKWKH)RXQGDWLRQOHVV$SURDFKµHQSocial Theory and Practice9ROHQHUR SiJ Criterio jurídico garantista 28 issn: 2145-3381 - Año 3 - No. 4 - Enero-Junio de 2011 VXGHIHQVDVHQWLPHQWDOGHWDOHVGHUHFKRVDTXHOOR DGHPiVHOVHUHQHOTXHHVWDVHVWDEDQGHVWLQDGDV TXHSUHFLVDPHQWHQLHJD DFXOPLQDU$QiORJDPHQWHPLHQWUDVTXHQRSR GHPRVWHQHUSRUREMHWRODSHUIHFFLyQVtSRGHPRV 5RUW\SDUHFHFUHHUTXHSXHGHGHMDUGHKDEODUGH IXQGDPHQWRV DO DSHODU D VHQWLPLHQWRV HQ YH] GH DVSLUDUDWRPDUHQFRQVLGHUDFLyQPiVQHFHVLGDGHV KHFKRV3HURHVWRQRSDUHFHSODXVLEOH6LHVYHUGDG GHODJHQWHTXHDQWHV TXHDOJXQRVVHQWLPLHQWRVVRQWUDQVFXOWXUDOPHQWH PiV YDOLRVRV TXH RWURV HV VHJXUDPHQWH YHUGDG HQ YLUWXG GH DOJXQRV KHFKRV WUDQVFXOWXUDOHV R FRQMXQWRVGHKHFKRV(VGLItFLOYHUFyPRVHSRGUtD MXVWLILFDUXQSURJUHVRGHVHQWLPLHQWRVPRUDOHVVLQ DSHODUDKHFKRVDFHUFDGHORVVHUHVKXPDQRVKH FKRVTXHDSHODUtDQDOYHUGDGHURWLSRGHQDWXUDOH]D KXPDQDFX\DH[LVWHQFLD5RUW\QLHJD 3HUR SDUD 5RUW\ QR HV SUHFLVR VHU HVHQFLDOLVWD DFHUFDGHODQDWXUDOH]DKXPDQDFRPRFRQGLFLyQ SDUDGHIHQGHUHOUHVSHWRDORVGHUHFKRVKXPDQRV /DFRQWLQJHQFLDGHORKXPDQRHVXQDFRQGLFLyQ TXH QR HV SRVLEOH UHKXLU FRPR SUHWHQGHQ ORV IXQGDFLRQDOLVWDV FRPR 6FKDHIHU TXH VXSRQHQ HUUyQHDPHQWH TXH HV SRVLEOH DVXPLU TXH VH KD OOHJDGR DO ILQDO GH OD LQYHVWLJDFLyQ FLHQWtILFD \ pWLFDDFHUFDGHORVVHUHVKXPDQRV$ILUPDUTXH H[LVWHXQIXQGDPHQWRWUDQVFXOWXUDOSDUDKDEODU GHUHVSHWRHVORPLVPRTXHQHJDUODQDWXUDOH]D FDPELDQWHGHORVKXPDQRV/DREFHFDGDE~VTXHGD GHODYHUGDG~OWLPDDFHUFDGHODKXPDQLGDG\GHO PXQGRGHEHFHGHUVXSXHVWRDODPiVPRGHVWD SURSXHVWDGHLQFOXVLyQGHXQQ~PHURFDGDYH] PD\RU GH SHUVRQDV WUDGLFLRQDOPHQWH H[FOXLGDV GHO UHFRQRFLPLHQWR GH VXV QHFHVLGDGHV HQ WpU PLQRVGHGHUHFKRV 6HJ~Q:LOOLDP7DOERWW5RUW\HVXQDQWLUUHDOLVWD \FRPRWDOQRSXHGHGHIHQGHUHOSURJUHVRPRUDO TXH VXSRQH OD GHIHQVD PLVPD GH ORV GHUHFKRV KXPDQRV SXHV FODUDPHQWH VRQ XQ SURJUHVR HQ PDWHULDPRUDO6LSRUUHDOLVPRPRUDOVHHQWLHQGH ODFUHHQFLDHQODH[LVWHQFLDGHYHUGDGHVPRUDOHV REMHWLYDV HQWRQFHV 5RUW\ HV XQ DQWLUUHDOLVWD DO QHJDUSUHFLVDPHQWHODH[LVWHQFLDGHWDOHVYHUGD GHV$KRUDELHQQRHVSRVLEOHKDEODUGHSURJUHVR VLQRFRPRODQDUUDFLyQGHXQUHDOLVWDGHOUHODWR GHOKDOOD]JRGHYHUGDGHVPRUDOHVQXHYDVTXHVX SHUDQODSDUFLDOLGDGGHORVHQIRTXHVDQWHULRUHV\ DPSOtDQODXQLYHUVDOLGDGGHORVSULQFLSLRVPRUDOHV (QSDODEUDVGH7DOERWW «KHGLVFXWLGRFyPRODUHJODGHRUR\HOSULQFL SLRXWLOLWDULVWDLOXVWUDQHOGHVDUUROORGHSULQFLSLRV PRUDOHVTXHWUDVFLHQGHQODVGLYLVLRQHVSDUURTXLD OHVGHIDPLOLDWULEXQDFLyQHLQFOXVRHVSHFLH/R PLVPRHVYHUGDGGHORVGHUHFKRVKXPDQRVEiVL FRV«6LORVGHUHFKRVKXPDQRVVHDSOLFDQDVHUHV FDSDFHVGHDXWRQRPtDHQWRQFHVWDOHVGHUHFKRVQRV SURSRUFLRQDQRWURHMHPSORGHSULQFLSLRVPRUDOHV TXHWUDVFLHQGHQODVGLYLVLRQHVSDUURTXLDOHV\OR JUDQYHUGDGHUDXQLYHUVDOLGDG 6HJ~Q7DOERWWVL5RUW\GHILHQGHHOSURJUHVRPRUDO (VRVHUtDFRPRSUHWHQGHUKDEHUOOHJDGRDOILQDOGH FRPR XQ SURJUHVR HQ ORV VHQWLPLHQWRV PRUDOHV ODHYROXFLyQELROyJLFDFRPRSUHWHQGHUQRVyORVHU HQWRQFHVWDOQRFLyQGHSURJUHVRGHEHVHUDMHQDDOD HO~OWLPRKHUHGHURGHWRGDVODVHUDVDQWHULRUHVVLQR YHUGDG\HQFRQVHFXHQFLDDOFRQRFLPLHQWR$GHPiV ,EtGSS ,E^LGSiJ 7$/%277:Which Rights Sould Be Universal1HZ<RUN2[IRUG8QLYHUVLW\3UHVVSiJ Razón, sentimientos y derechos humanos Páginas 8 a 33 29 KDEODUGHSURJUHVRSUHVXSRQHTXHWDOSURFHVRKLV WyULFRQRVXFHGHGHPDQHUDFLHJDSRUTXHODQRFLyQ GHSURJUHVRHVWHOHROyJLFD\FRPRWDOLPSOLFDXQ ILQREMHWLYRKDFLDHOFXDOVHGLULJH 0iVDGHODQWHDILUPDTXHODQRFLyQGHSURJUHVR PRUDO VH GHEH HQWHQGHU \ UHLQWHUSUHWDU FRPR OD E~VTXHGD GH XQD ´PHMRU YHUVLyQ GH QRVRWURV PLVPRVµ &UHRTXH5RUW\XVDHOWpUPLQRSURJUHVRVLPSOH PHQWHSDUDH[SUHVDUVXDSUREDFLyQGHOSURFHVR SRUPHGLRGHOFXDOORVGHUHFKRVKDQVLGRH[WHQ GLGRVPiVDOOiGHORVOtPLWHVGHODUD]DODUHOLJLyQ \HOJpQHUR3HUR¢SRUTXpFRQVLGHUDHVWRFRPR SURJUHVRVLQRKD\QDGDREMHWLYRKDFLDORFXDOGL FKRGHVDUUROORHVWpGLULJLGR"&UHRTXHODUHVSXHVWD GH 5RUW\ SRGUtD VHU TXH QXHVWURV VHQWLPLHQWRV PLVPRVGHWHUPLQDQORVHVWiQGDUHVGHSURJUHVRGH PRGRTXHQRREVWDQWHVXGHVDUUROORFXHQWDFRPR SURJUHVR(VWRPHSDUHFHXQDIRUPDLQGLUHFWDGH GHFLUTXHQRKD\UHDOPHQWHSURJUHVR 7DQSURQWRFRPRVHDEDQGRQDODLGHDGHTXHQRV KDFHPRV PHQRV FUXHOHV \ WUDWDPRV PHMRU D ORV GHPiVSRUKDEHUFRPSUHQGLGRPHMRUODQDWXUDOH]D GHOVHUKXPDQRGHORVGHUHFKRVKXPDQRV«SDUHFH VXILFLHQWHGHILQLUHOSURJUHVRPRUDOFRPRXQFRQ YHUWLUQRVHQODPHMRUYHUVLyQGHQRVRWURVPLVPRV HQSHUVRQDVTXHQRVRQUDFLVWDVQLDJUHVLYDVQL LQWROHUDQWHHWF 3HUR HVWD REMHFLyQ GH 7DOERWW QR HV WDQ IXHUWH FRPRSDUHFH6HJ~Q5RUW\HOSURJUHVRQRVHSXHGH HQWHQGHUGHPDQHUDWHOHROyJLFDGHWDOPRGRTXH HVWp GLULJLGR KDFLD XQD PHWD REMHWLYD /D ~QLFD GHVFULSFLyQTXHVHSXHGHGDUGHOSURJUHVRPRUDO VyORVHSXHGHKDFHUVLWLHQHHQFXHQWDORVLQWHUH VHV\ILQHVGDGRVFXOWXUDOHKLVWyULFDPHQWHSXHV QXQFDVHSXHGHKDEODUGHSURJUHVRPRUDOVLQRGH PDQHUDHWQRFpQWULFD &LHUWDPHQWH KHPRV SURJUHVDGR VHJ~Q QXHVWUD SURSLDDSUHFLDFLyQ(VGHFLUHVWDPRVHQXQDGLV SRVLFLyQPXFKRPHMRUGHVHUYLUDORVSURSyVLWRV TXHGHVHDPRVVHUYLU\GHVROYHQWDUODVVLWXDFLRQHV DODVTXHFUHHPRVTXHQRVHQIUHQWDPRVGHORTXH ORHVWXYLHURQQXHVWURVDQWHSDVDGRV ,EtGSiJ 5257<5Verdad y progreso%DUFHORQD3DLGyVSiJ ,EtGSiJ 3HURSDUD7DOERWWKD\XQDIDOHQFLDPiVSUHRFX SDQWH HQ HO DQWLIXQGDFLRQOLVPR pWLFR GH 5RUW\ (O SURJUHVR PRUDO LPSOLFDUtD FLHUWR JUDGR GH DUELWUDULHGDG GHO FXDO 5RUW\ QR SXHGH HVFDSDU +D\TXHKDFHUH[WHQVLYRVORVGHUHFKRVKXPDQRV DWRGDODKXPDQLGDG3HUR¢FyPRHVSRVLEOHGLFKD H[WHQVLyQ"6HJ~Q5RUW\ODFODYHHVHOLQFUHPHQWR GHVLPSDWtDKDFLDORVGHPiV3HUR¢VHQWLUVLPSDWtD KDFLDDOJXLHQQRHVGHVSXpVGHWRGRDUELWUDULR" (VFODURTXHODVLPSDWtDHVGHSHQGLHQWHGHOFRQ WH[WR \ SRU HOOR QR SRGUtD VHU XQLYHUVDOPHQWH DSOLFDEOH&RPRVXFHGHHQODSHOtFXOD'LVWULWR HVIDFWLEOHVHJ~Q7DOERWWTXHVHGpXQHQFXHQ WUR FRQ H[WUDWHUUHVWUHV TXH WHQJDQ ODV PLVPDV FDSDFLGDGHV FRJQLWLYDV \ HPRFLRQDOHV TXH ORV VHUHVKXPDQRVSHURTXHWHQJDQODDWHUUDGRUD\ GHVDJUDGDEOHDSDULHQFLDGHJUDQGHVLQVHFWRV/D SUHJXQWDREYLDVHUtD¢GHVSHUWDUtDQVLPSDWtDHQ ORVVHUHVKXPDQRV\OHVFRQFHGHUtDQFRQEDVHHQ HOOD LJXDOGDG GH GHUHFKRV" ¢4Xp QRV JDUDQWL]D Criterio jurídico garantista 30 issn: 2145-3381 - Año 3 - No. 4 - Enero-Junio de 2011 TXHQRVXFHGHUtDORFRQWUDULR"¢1RORVHOLPLQD UtDQORVKXPDQRVPRWLYDGRVSRUHOVHQWLPLHQWR GHUHSXOVLyQTXHSURGXFHQHQHOORV"¢4XLpQGLFH TXHODKXPDQLGDGQRSXHGDYHUHQWDOPDVDFUHGH H[WUDWHUUHVWUHVXQVLJQRGHSURJUHVRPRUDO"6L HOVHQWLPLHQWRGHVLPSDWtDHVWDEOHFHODDWULEXFLyQ GHGHUHFKRV\GHILQHTXLpQWLHQHGHUHFKRV\TXLpQ QRORVWLHQHHQWRQFHVVHUtDFODUDPHQWHLQMXVWRQR UHFRQRFHUOHGHUHFKRVDFLHUWRVVHUHVTXHVyORQRV SURGXFHQDVFR(QFRQFOXVLyQHOUHFRQRFLPLHQWR GHGHUHFKRVDORVRWURVQRGHEHVHUXQDVXQWRTXH GHEDKDFHUVHVREUHODVLPSDWtD 5RUW\SRGUtDGHIHQGHUVHGHODDQWHULRUREMHFLyQ DILUPDQGRTXHORVVHQWLPLHQWRVGHODVSHUVRQDV VRQPRGLILFDEOHV\PROGHDEOHVDWUDYpVGHFLHUWD HGXFDFLyQ VHQWLPHQWDO FRQ EDVH HQ GLIHUHQWHV QDUUDWLYDV8Q VHQWLPLHQWR FRPRODVLPSDWtDVH SXHGH PROGHDU \ FDPELDU D WUDYpV GH UHODWRV \ GRFXPHQWDOHVTXHSHUVXDGDQDORVKXPDQRVGHTXH ORVH[WUDWHUUHVWUHVSRVHHQVHQWLPLHQWRVFRPRORV KXPDQRV\WLHQHQSRUHOORODFDSDFLGDGGHVHQWLU GRORU\SODFHU6REUHHVWDEDVHHVSRVLEOHLQFUH PHQWDUODSUHRFXSDFLyQSRUWDOHVVHUHVDSDUWLUGH VHQWLUVROLGDULGDGSRUHOORVSXHVVXVXIULPLHQWRQR UHVXOWDUtDDFHSWDEOHFRPRFRQVHFXHQFLDGHQHJDU OHVFLHUWRVGHUHFKRV3DUD5RUW\QRVHUtDSRVLEOH GHVGHODUD]yQWUDWDUORVFRQUHVSHWRSXHVVHJ~Q HVWDEOHFLy+XPH 1RHVFRQWUDULRDODUD]yQHOSUHIHULUODGHVWUXF FLyQGHOPXQGRHQWHURDWHQHUXQUDVJXxRHQPL GHGR1RHVFRQWUDULRDODUD]yQTXH\RSUHILHUD PLUXLQDFRQWDOGHHYLWDUHOPHQRUVXIULPLHQWR DXQLQGLRRDFXDOTXLHUSHUVRQDWRWDOPHQWHGHV FRQRFLGD (OUD]RQDPLHQWRSUiFWLFRRPRUDOQRGHEHGHMDU SRU IXHUD ORV ILQHV H LQWHUHVHV GH ODV SHUVRQDV ORVFXDOHVVHGHILQHQWHQLHQGRHQFXHQWDVXVQH FHVLGDGHV \ GHVHRV 3HUR GHVGH OD VROD UD]yQ HV LQGLIHUHQWHFyPRVHGHEHWUDWDUDORVGHPiV6yOR D SDUWLU GH VHQWLU HO GRORU DMHQR FRPR SURSLR HVTXHORVGHPiVVHUHVKXPDQRVOOHJDQDKDFHU SDUWHGHQXHVWUDFRPXQLGDGPRUDO/DMXVWLFLDHV OHDOWDGDPSOLDGDDXQFtUFXORFDGDYH]PiVDPSOLR GHSHUVRQDV )LQDOPHQWH 7XJHQGKDW SRGUtD FRQWUDDWDFDU D 5RUW\6HJ~QYLPRVSDUD7XJHQGKDWHOUHVSHWR HVDQWHULRUDORVVHQWLPLHQWRV\HQFRQVHFXHQFLD QRVHSRGUtDUHVSHWDUODGLJQLGDGGHORVGHPiV\ UHFRQRFHUOHVLJXDOHVGHUHFKRVVLQRGHVGHHOSULQ FLSLRGHOUHVSHWRXQLYHUVDO3HURSDUD5RUW\HVWR QRVHUtDXQSUREOHPD6yORKD\TXHFRPSUHQGHU FyPRODQRFLyQGHXQLYHUVDOLGDGVHUHLQWHUSUHWD GHVGHVXSRVWXUDSUDJPiWLFD/DXQLYHUVDOLGDGQR HVXQDFRQGLFLyQSUHYLDTXHGHWHUPLQHPLUHODFLyQ FRQORVGHPiV(VPiVELHQDSDUWLUGHXQDUD]yQ GLDOyJLFDHLPDJLQDWLYDGRQGHHVSRVLEOHSHQVDU TXHVHGpXQLQFHQWLYRDODFXULRVLGDGSDUDHQWDEODU XQGLiORJRFRQSHUVRQDVQRUPDOPHQWHH[FOXLGDV GHODFRQYHUVDFLyQFRPRORVPLHPEURVGHODFR PXQLGDG/*7%\FLHUWDVPLQRUtDVpWQLFDV7DOHV LQWHUORFXWRUHVVRQLPSRUWDQWHVSRUTXHSHUPLWHQ HQULTXHFHU\DPSOLDUQXHVWUDYLVLyQGHORKXPDQR DOPRVWUDUQRVRWUDVFUHHQFLDVQRIRUPXODGDVHQ QXHVWUDWUDGLFLyQ/DXQLYHUVDOLGDGVHUtDXQUHVXO WDGRGHODFRQYHUVDFLyQQRXQDFRQGLFLyQSUHYLD\ DSULRULSDUDTXHpVWDVHUHDOLFH<ORVVHQWLPLHQWRV VRQXQDFRQGLFLyQSUHYLDSDUDUHFRQRFHUODVQHFH VLGDGHV\ORVLQWHUHVHVGHORVGHPiVHQYLUWXGGH ORVFXDOHVOHVUHFRQRFHPRVGHUHFKRV $FDVR HO LQFUHPHQWR GH FRPXQLFDFLyQ HQWUH FR PXQLGDGHVDQWHULRUPHQWHH[FOXVLYLVWDVTXHHVWRV SURFHVRVFRQWLQJHQWHVSURGXFHQSXHGDJUDGXDO +80('Tratado de la naturaleza humana0DGULG(GLWRUD1DFLRQDOSiJ Razón, sentimientos y derechos humanos Páginas 8 a 33 PHQWHOOHJDUDFUHDUXQLYHUVDOLGDG3HURQRYHR HQTXpVHQWLGRSRGUtDHVWHLQFUHPHQWRHTXLYDOHUDO UHFRQRFLPLHQWRGHXQDXQLYHUVDOLGDGSUHYLDPHQWH H[LVWHQWH 31 TXHSRGHPRV\GHEHPRVDEDQGRQDU3RUVXSXHVWR KD\TXHDGPLWLUTXHSRGHPRVIUDFDVDUXQD\RWUD YH]DQWHVGHORJUDUORVLHVTXHORORJUDPRV7RGD HVSHUDQ]DHVGHVSXpVGHWRGRIDOLEOH (QFRQFOXVLyQSDUHFHTXHVLORVGHUHFKRVKXPDQRV QRQHFHVLWDQGHXQIXQGDPHQWRUDFLRQDO\XQLYHU VDOHQWRQFHVODSURSXHVWDGH7XJHQGKDWQRSXHGH %,%/,2*5$)Ì$ DSDUHFHUFRPRODPiVSODXVLEOHDOQRUHFRQRFHUOD FRQWLQJHQFLDGHWRGRORKXPDQR\DOVXSRQHUTXH *870$1$Human Rights as Politics an Idolatry. 3ULQ FHWRQ3ULQFHWRQ8QLYHUVLW\3UHVV HVSRVLEOHHVFDSDUGHODKLVWRULDFRPRFRQGLFLyQ *(:,57+$´/DEDVH\HOFRQWHQLGRGHORVGHUHFKRV SDUDKDEODUGHODPRUDOLGDG &XDQGR GLJR TXH PL LQWHUSUHWDFLyQ HV WDPELpQ KLVWyULFDHOODQRORHVGHVGHOXHJRGHXQPRGRWDQ IXQGDPHQWDOFRPRHOFDVRGH0DF,QW\UH3DUDPt FRPRSDUDFXDOTXLHUpWLFDLOXVWUDGDORHVSHFtILFR GH QXHVWUD VLWXDFLyQ KLVWyULFD HV TXH SHUPLWH \ H[LJHSODQWHDUHOSUREOHPDGHODPRUDOGHPRGR DKLVWyULFRXQDFRQFHSFLyQTXHGHEHSDUHFHUDE VXUGDSDUD0DF,QW\UHVLWRGDPRUDOHVWiUHIHULGD DODVWUDGLFLRQHV +DEUtD TXH DJUHJDU TXH OD FRQFHSFLyQ GH 7X JHQGKDW WDPELpQ VHUtD DEVXUGD GHVGH OD PLUDGD SUDJPiWLFD \ DQWLIXQGDFLRQDOLVWD GH 5RUW\ 6L 7XJHQGKDWUHFRQRFHTXHQRHVSRVLEOHGDUXQIXQ GDPHQWRGHODPRUDOHQWpUPLQRVDEVROXWRVHOOR QRLPSOLFDTXHUHFRQR]FDTXHFRPRGLMLPRVDQWHV ORV GHUHFKRV KXPDQRV VHDQ XQ OHJDGR FXOWXUDO UHYLVDEOH6LQHVWHUHFRQRFLPLHQWRVXSURSXHVWD PRUDO VLPSOHPHQWH HV DXWRULWDULD HQ WpUPLQRV URUWLDQRV \ SRU OR WDQWR DEVROXWLVWD HQ DOJXQD PHGLGD3RUHOORHOVXSXHVWRFRQRFLPLHQWRGHXQ UHLQRGHYHUGDGHVPRUDOHVXQLYHUVDOHVQRSXHGH VHUXQDFRQGLFLyQSDUDHOIRPHQWRGHOUHVSHWRDORV GHUHFKRVKXPDQRV6yORQXHVWUDIDOLEOHFDSDFLGDG GH VHQWLU VROLGDULGDG SXHGH DFHUFDUQRV DO LGHDO OLEHUDOGHFRQVLGHUDUTXHODFUXHOGDGHVXQDRSFLyQ KXPDQRVµHQ%HWHJyQ-HGDerecho y moral %DUFHORQD$ULHO +80('Investigación sobre los principios de la moral %XHQRV$LUHV$JXLODU +80( ' Tratado de la naturaleza humana 0DGULG (GLWRUD1DFLRQDO 0,//-6Utilitarismo%DUFHORQD$OWD\D 5257< 5 El pragmatismo, una versión %DUFHORQD $ULHO 5257<5Verdad y progreso%DUFHORQD3DLGyV 6,1*(53Ética práctica/RQGUHV&DPEULGJH8QLYHU VLW\3UHVV 6&+$()(5%´+XPDQ5LJKWVSUREOHPVZLWKWKH)RXQ GDWLRQOHVV$SURDFKµLQSocial Theory and Practice 9ROHQHUR 6+8(6DQG+85/(<6HGDe los derechos humanos 0DGULG7URWWD 60,7+$La teoría de los sentimientos morales0DGULG $OLDQ]D 7$/%277 : Which Rights Sould Be Universal 1HZ <RUN2[IRUG8QLYHUVLW\3UHVV 78*(1'+$7(Lecciones de ética%DUFHORQD*HGLVD 5257<5El pragmatismo, una versión%DUFHORQD$ULHOSiJ 78*(1'+$7(Lecciones de ética%DUFHORQD*HGLVDSiJ