(175(9,67$$-26()$2/,9(5$IHWDSHU5LFDUGR&DVWURL$OEHUW0DUWtQ L&LQWLD0DUWtQIHWDHOGHJHQHUGH UEORF$EDQVGHPDU[DU ¢(QTXpSXHEORQDFLy" %LHQYHQLGD%DGDMR] ¢6XIDPLOLD\DKDEtDYLYLGRRWHQLDUDtFHVIDPLOLDUHV\DHQHO SXHEOR" 1R\DQRVYLQLPRVWRGRVSDUDDFiVHYLQRSULPHURPLSDGUH\\D QRVLpUDPRVGRVPLKHUPDQR\PLPDGUH\\RQDGDPiVORVGHPiV QDFLHURQHQ7RFLQD6HYLOOD0LVKHUPDQRV ¢(QTXHDxRQDFLyXVWHG" (QHO ¢1DFLyHQFDVD" 3XHVVLPHSDUHFHTXHVLSRUTXHDQWHVVHWHQtDQHQODVFDVDV ¢&XDQWRVKHUPDQRVHUDQ" \\R ¢$TXpVHGHGLFDEDQVXVSDGUHV" 0LVSDGUHVDOFDPSR ¢&yPRHUDVXYLGDGHQLxD"MXHJRV 7UDEDMDQGRHQODFDVDSRUTXHPLVSDGUHVWHQtDQXQWUDEDMRKDFtDQ FDUEyQ\SLFRVHQWRQFHV\RWUDEDMDEDD\XGiQGROHVHQODFDVD ¢4XpWLSRGHUHODFLyQWHQtDFRQVXVSDGUHV"(UDQPX\VHYHURVR PiVELHQFDULxRVRV" 1RQRPX\ELHQ ¢&yPRHUDVXFDVD" 0LFDVDPX\JUDQGHWHQLDWUHVKDELWDFLRQHVVXFRPHGRUDOXHJRWHQLD ODFRFLQDHOSDWLRHOFRUUDO(UDJUDQGHWHQtDPRVDQLPDOHVWHQtDPRV YDFDVWHQtDPRVDQLPDOHV ¢/DGH%DGDMR]RODGH6HYLOOD" 1RODGH6HYLOOD ¢(UDSURSLHGDGGHVXVSDGUHV" 6L ¢4XpSHUVRQDVYLYtDQHQVXFDVD" 3XHVYLYtDPRVWRGRVORVKHUPDQRV\ORVSDGUHV\PLDEXHODWDPELpQ HVWXYRYLYLHQGR ¢3RGUtDH[SOLFDUDOJXQDGHVXVFRVWXPEUHVIDPLOLDUHV"TXH FRPtDQILHVWDV (VTXHDQWHVQRVHFHOHEUDEDQDGDQRHVFRPRDKRUDQRVHFHOHEUDED QDGD\QRVpTXpFRPtDPRVSHURDQWHVQRVHFHOHEUDEDXQ FXPSOHDxRVQRVHFHOHEUDEDXQVDQWRHVTXHHQWRQFHVQRVHSRGtD HVWiEDPRVELHQSHURQRVHSRGtD1RUHFXHUGR\RQDGDGHHVR ¢&yPRHUDVXVLWXDFLyQHFRQyPLFD" 3XHVHVWDEDELHQQRHVTXHWXYLpUDPRVPXFKRSHURHVWiEDPRVELHQ (OFROHJLR ,EDDOFROHJLRSHURDORPHMRULEDXQPHV\GHVSXpVPHOOHYDEDDOR PHMRUFDVLWRGRHOFXUVRTXH\DQRLEDSRUTXHKDFtDIDOWDHQODFDVD\ QRSRGtDLUDOFROHJLR ¢7HQtDPXFKRVDPLJRVHQHOSXHEOR" 6tVtTXHWHQLDDPLJDVHQWRQFHVQRVHOOHYDEDQDPLJRVVHOOHYDEDQ DPLJDVPiVTXHQDGD ¢$TXpHGDGRKDVWDTXpHGDGIXHDOFROHJLR" 1RIXLPXFKRSRUTXHQRSRGtD(QHOFROHJLR"%LHQSHTXHxLWDWHQGUtD XQRVDxRVRDVtSRUTXHDORPHMRULEDXQPHV\PHTXLWDEDQSRUTXH KDFLDIDOWDHQODFDVDSHURQRPHDFXHUGRDTXpHGDGGHMHGHHVWXGLDU $KRUDHVFXDQGR\RHVWR\DSUHQGLHQGR ¢&yPRHUDODHVFXHOD" (UDXQDHVFXHODJUDQGH\TXHTXLHUHVTXHWHGLJD\VLKDFtDV FXDOTXLHUFRVDSRQtDVODPDQR\WHGDEDQFRQODSDOPHWD<VLQR KDFtDVFXDOTXLHUFRVDPHMRUDPtQRSHURWHFDVWLJDEDQ<RIXLSRFR \HQWRQFHVQR ¢(UDQPX\VHYHURV" 6LHQWRQFHVHUDQPX\VHYHURVHK ¢&yPRHVWDEDRUJDQL]DGDFKLFRV\FKLFDVMXQWRV" 1RQDGDPiVHUDDYHUVtHUDXQFROHJLRGHQLxDV\VLKDEtDXQ FROHJLRHUDGHQLxRVQRHVFRPRDKRUDXVWHGHVFRPRDKRUDQR7RGR HUDORTXHHUDHOFROHJLRHUDGHQLxDV\HOFROHJLRTXHHUDGHQLxRV SXHVGHQLxRVQRKDEtDQLxDQLQJXQD ¢(UDORPLVPRSDUDORVFKLFRVTXHODVFKLFDV"¢/HVHQVHxDEDQOR PLVPR" +RPEUH\RFUHRTXHVLSHUR\RWHQJRDPLVKHUPDQRVHVTXHWDPSRFR IXHURQDOFROHJLRPLVKHUPDQRVVDEHQSRUTXHPLSDGUHOHVHQVHxy SRUTXHFRPRWHQtDQTXHLUDODPLOLSXHVHQWRQFHVPLSDGUHVDELD\OHV HQVHxDEDDHOORVDOHHU\HVFULELUSDUDFXDQGRIXHUDQDODPLOLVLQ HPEDUJRDQRVRWUDVDPLKHUPDQD\DPtQRSRUTXHQRWHQtDPRVTXH LUDODPLOL ¢&yPROHVWUDWDEDQORVSURIHVRUHV" +RPEUH\DWHKHGLFKRGHHVWRQRHVTXHPHDFXHUGHPXFKRSHUR\R PHDFXHUGRGHTXHFRPRQRKLFLHUDVXQDFRVDELHQSRQtDVODPDQR\ FRPRKLFLHUDVDVtFHUUDQGRHOSXxRWHODFRJtDQ\WHGDEDQPiVIXHUWH ¢/OHYDEDQXQLIRUPH" 1RQRKDEtDQDGDGHHVR ¢7LHQHDOJ~QUHFXHUGRHVSHFLDO"¢<DOJXQDDQpFGRWD" 0PQR'HPLLQIDQFLDQRVpTXHWUDEDMDEDPXFKRSHURDO FROHJLR\DWHGLJRTXHQRLEDPXFKRSRUTXHFODURPHTXLWDEDQSRUTXH \RHUDSHTXHxDSHURHUDODPD\RUFLOODGHODVKHPEUDV\WHQLDWUDEDMR HQODFDVD /HHQVHxDURQORPiVEiVLFRDTXtQR" /DPLJXLWDTXH\RVDELDOHHUDOOtQRVSXVLHURQWDPELpQDODVSHUVRQDV PD\RUHVPiVGH\HQWRQFHV\RDSUHQGtXQSRTXLWRGHHVFULELU SRUTXHVHPHROYLGyORSRTXLWRTXHVDEtD\DKRUDDTXt\DVpPiV<R QRIXLDSHQDVDOFROHJLR 2WURVDVSHFWRV ¢4XpUHFXHUGDGHODJXHUUD" 1R\RQDFtHQWRQFHVHQHOIXHFXDQGRODJXHUUD\QR<RPH DFXHUGRTXHOHGHFtDDPLPDGUHHQODSXHUWDGHPLFDVDGHOSXHEOR\ \ROHGHFtDTXHKDEtDXQSDORGHODOX]\PLPDGUHPHGHFtDFRPRPH SRGtDDFRUGDUGHDTXHOORSXHVVtTXHPHDFRUGDEDFODURFRQORV FXDWURDxLWRVSXHVVtTXHPHDFRUGDEDGHHOORQRGHODJXHUUDQRQR PHDFXHUGRGHQDGD ¢0XULyDOJ~QIDPLOLDU" $OOtHQHOSXHEOR"3XHVVLPXULyPLDEXHOD\PLDEXHORPLVDEXHORV PXULHURQDOOt ¢$FDXVDGHODJXHUUD" 1R\RFUHRTXHQRHKWHQJRXQWtRTXHVHPXULyFXDQGRODJXHUUDHO KHUPDQRGHPLPDGUHPXULyFXDQGRODJXHUUDHVHVtTXHOHPDWDURQ FXDQGRODJXHUUD ¢7LHQHDOJ~QRWURUHFXHUGRGHVXSXHEORRGHXVWHGTXHTXLHUD H[SOLFDU" 'HPLSXHEORQRSRUTXHFODURDOVDOLUSHTXHxLWDQRPHDFXHUGR Q%ORF(OYLDWJHLHOSURFpV ¢4XLHQGHFLGLyLUVHGHOSXHEOR" 0LVSDGUHV ¢3RUTXpPRWLYRGHFLGLHURQHPLJUDU" 1RWHSXHGRGHFLUSRUTXHVHYLYtDPHMRUDKtHQODSDUWHGH6HYLOOD TXHDOOtHQ%DGDMR]\IXHFXDQGRWHUPLQyODJXHUUDFXDQGRQRVRWURV QRVYLQLPRVSRUHVRWHGLJRTXHDOWHUPLQDUODJXHUUDIXHFXDQGRQRV YLQLPRVQRVRWURVWUHVD6HYLOOD ¢4XLpQIXHHOSULPHURHQPDUFKDUVH"¢2VHIXHWRGDODIDPLOLD" 1RPHSDUHFHTXHPLSDGUHVHYLQRDQWHV\GHVSXpV\DQRVYLQLPRV QRVRWURVFUHRTXHIXHDVt ¢(UDQORV~QLFRVTXHVHPDUFKDEDQGHOSXHEOR" <RPHSDUHFHTXHQRWDPSRFRPHDFXHUGR\DWHGLJRTXHHUD SHTXHxDDPLPHSDUHFHTXHQRTXHORPLVPRTXHQRVRWURVWDPELpQ VHLUtDQPiV ¢&yPRVHVLQWLyFXDQGRGHMyVXSXHEOR" (UDSHTXHxD ¢<HOGH6HYLOOD" $YHUHOGH6HYLOODVt&XDQGRPHYLQHDTXtFODURTXH\RPHDFXHUGR\ PHDFXHUGRPXFKRGHDOOtSRUTXHDOOtHVGyQGHPHKHFULDGRDOOtPH FULDURQ ¢4XpUHFXHUGDGHOYLDMH")XHPX\GXURTXHUHFRUULGRKLFLVWHLV FXDQWRGXUyHOYLDMHFRQTXpPHGLRGHWUDQVSRUWHORKLFLVWHLV 1RGXURQRGXURQRIXHHQORVWUHQHVDTXHOORVTXHKDEtDDQWHV\ YHQtDPRVORVVHLVHQHOWUHQFRPRpUDPRVVHLVFRJtDPRVODVGRV SDUWHV%LHQ ¢&XiQWRGXUyHOYLDMH"¢6HDFXHUGDGHOWLHPSRTXHGXUy" 3XHVVDOLPRVSRUODWDUGH\DORVWUHVGtDVDTXt(VTXHDQWHVVH HFKDEDQPXFKDVKRUDVSDUDLUGHVGH6HYLOODDOD%DUFHORQD ¢/OHYDEDQPXFKRHTXLSDMH" 1RQROOHYiEDPRVPXFKRODURSD\FUHRTXHWDPELpQWUDMHXQD ODYDGRUD\RWUDVFRVDVSHURYDPRVHVR\DYLQR ¢6HDFXHUGDGHTXpUHFRUULGRKLFLVWHLV" ¢(OUHFRUULGR"<RPHSDUHFHTXHSDVDPRVSRU0DGULGSHUR\RQRWH SXHGR1RKLFLPRVHOFDPLQRGH6HYLOODD%DUFHORQDVHJXLGRQR KLFLPRVWUDVERUGRQLQDGD ¢6HDFXHUGDGHFXiQWRGLQHURFRVWy" 1RSHURQRVFRVWySRTXLWRPHSDUHFHTXHQRFRVWDEDPXFKRHQWRQFHV ¢3RUTXpGHFLGLHURQYHQLUD&DWDOXxD" 3RUTXHWHQtDDDTXtPLVSDGUHVDTXtQR\RORVWHQtDHQ0DQUHVD WDPELpQWHQtDPLIDPLOLDOD~QLFDTXHTXHGDEDHQHOSXHEORHUD\R\ PLVXHJUD\PLFXxDGDHVWDEDQDTXtHQ*UDQROOHUVTXHSRUHVRWXYHTXH YHQLUPHSDUDDTXt ¢<VXVKLMRVWDPELpQHVWDEDQFRQXVWHGHQHOSXHEOR" 6tFODUR UEORF/¶DUULEDGDLHOVSULPHUVWHPSV ¢$TXpOXJDUOOHJy\FRPRVHVLQWLy"TXpIXHORSULPHURTXHSHQVyDO OOHJDU $OOOHJDUDTXt"%XHQRPX\ELHQSRUTXH\RWHQtDWRGDPLIDPLOLDSRU DTXt\DOOtHVWDEDVRODHQHOSXHEOR\RELHQ ¢<HQHOSXHEORGH6HYLOODVHDFXHUGD" ¢&XiQGR\ROOHJXpD6HYLOOD"¢&XiQGRHUDSHTXHxLWD"1RQRFXDQGR \ROOHJXpD6HYLOODQR ¢'yQGHRVDORMDVWHLV"FRPRHUDODFDVD /DFDVDHUDXQSLVRTXHYLYtDQPLVXHJUD\PLFXxDGR (Q0DQUHVDQR" $TXtHQ*UDQROOHUVHUDXQSLVRTXHHUDGHHOORVEXHQRGHHOORVQRHUD DOTXLODGR\HQWRQFHVYLYLHURQHQXQDKDELWDFLyQ\HQXQDKDELWDFLyQ HVWiEDPRVORVVHLV\GHVSXpV\DOHFRPSUpDPLKLMRXQVRIiSDUDHO FRPHGRUGHHVWRVTXHVHDEUHQ\HVFDPD\HQWRQFHVGRUPtDPLKLMR SRUTXH\DWHQtDDxRV\HQWRQFHVGRUPtDPLKLMRHQHOFRPHGRU (QWRQFHVWHQtDDTXtDOJ~QFRQRFLGRQR" 7HQtDDPLVXHJUD\DPLFXxDGR ¢&XDOHVIXHURQODVSULPHUDVGLILFXOWDGHVDOSULQFLSLR" $TXt"%XHQRSXHV\RQRWHQtDWUDEDMR0LPDULGRQRWHQtDWUDEDMR FXDQGRYLQLPRVDTXt\\RWDPSRFRWHQtD\pOHVWDEDHQ0DQUHVDHQXQ SXHEOHFLWR\EXHQRHQVHJXLGDHQFRQWUyWUDEDMR\VHSXVRDWUDEDMDU\R WDPELpQPHSXVHDKDFHUIDHQDV\EXHQRWDPSRFRORSDVDPRVPX\PDO QR"(QVHJXLGDHPSHFpDWUDEDMDUDPiVFRPRHVWDEDDTXtPLVXHJUD\ PLIDPLOLDWDPSRFRORSDVDPRVPDODPHQWH ¢7HQtDLVSUREOHPDVHFRQyPLFRV" %XHQRQRPXFKRVSHURWDPSRFRQRQRHVTXHHVWiEDPRVFRPR DKRUDSHUREXHQRPLPDULGRpOWUDEDMDED\\RWDPELpQKDFLHQGR IDHQDVQRHVTXHWXYLpUDPRVSDUDWHQHUXQFRFKHSHURWHQtDPRVSDUD DFODUDUWHQtDPRVSDUDLUVLJXLHQGR ¢)XHGLItFLOLQWHJUDUVHDODYLGDGHDTXt" 1RWHQtDPLIDPLOLDDTXtDPLPDULGRVLTXHQROHDJUDGDEDHVWR SRUTXHOHJXVWDEDPiVDTXHOORSHURFRPR\DQRVYLQLPRVWRGRVQR WXERPiVUHPHGLRTXHTXHGDUVH ¢7HQtDWUDEDMR" 1RQL\RQLpOQRVSXVLPRVDWUDEDMDUFODURHUDQGtDVWHQtDDTXtD PLVXHJUD\HQVHJXLGDpOHPSH]yDWUDEDMDU\\RWDPELpQHPSHFpD WUDEDMDUKDFLHQGRIDHQDV ¢<VXPDULGRGHTXpWUDEDMDED" 0LPDULGRWUDEDMDEDGHSDOHWD <XVWHG" <R\DORVDEHPRVHQODFDVD ¢&yPRRVRUJDQL]DEDLVFRPRORVKLMRV" &RQORVKLMRV"%LHQ ¢&XDQWRVKLMRVWHQtD" 7HQtD ¢(VWDEDQVHSDUDGRVRHUDQPX\SHTXHxRV" 1RHVTXHHUDQPX\SHTXHxRVODPiVFKLFDWHQtDFXDQGR\RYLQH DTXtOHSDVyFRPRDPLFRQDxRV\LEDDOFROHJLRGyQGHXVWHGHV YDLVDKRUD ¢&yPRFUHHTXHFDPELyVXYLGD" +RPEUHPLYLGDGHDOOtDDTXtKDFDPELDGRPXFKRSDUDPHMRUORTXH SDVDTXHDTXtWHQtD\RPLIDPLOLD\DOOtHVWDEDVROD ¢/HVRUSUHQGLyTXHDTXtKXELHUDRWURLGLRPD" 1RORTXHSDVDTXHD~QQRORVpPHJXVWDUtD ¢/HFRVWyHQWHQGHUORRKDEODUOR" (VTXHQRORVpWDPSRFRKDEODUORKDEODUORQRHQWLHQGRDOJXQDV FRVLWDVSHURQRVpKDEODUPLVKLMRVVtTXHORVDEHQVHKDQFULDGRDTXt \ORVDEHQ ¢&yPRHUDODYLGDDOSULQFLSLRHQ&DQ%DVVD" ¢$TXt"$TXtPX\ELHQSHURELHQSRUTXHHOSLVRHUDPtRDOOtHUD DOTXLODGRSRUTXHGHVSXpVGHYLYLUFRQPLVXHJUDPHWXYHTXHLUSDUD DTXtDUULEDSHURHVWHHVPtR <VXVKLMRVFUHtDTXHHVWDEDQPHMRUDTXt" 1R\RFUHRTXHYLYtDQDTXtPHMRUSRUTXHWDPSRFRHUDQWDQJUDQGHV\ VHKLFLHURQODYLGDDTXt(VWiQWUDEDMDQGR\HVWiQFDVDGRV\WRGR(OORV QRVDEHQQLTXHHVDTXHOOR U%ORF/DYLGDDOFDSGHOWHPSV ¢$OFDERGHXQRVDxRVVXYLGDKDEtDPHMRUDGR" 6t ¢&yPRPHMRUyHOEDUULRDOFDERGHXQRVDxRV" 1RVHHVTXHFXDQGRQRVRWURVOOHJDPRVDTXtHOEDUULRQRHVWDEDQLOD SOD]DQRHVWDEDHVWRKHFKRHUDXQKXHUWRDTXtKDEtDXQDFDVD$KRUD KDFDPELDGRHVWRPXFKRWHQHPRVXQDSOD]DGRQGHYLYR\RDOOtGRQGH XVWHGHVYDLVSXHVDKtHQIUHQWHYLYR\R ¢$QWHVGHOOHJDUWHQtDLVDOJXQDVWLHUUDV" 1RWLHUUDV"GHQRVRWURV"1RQRWHQtDPRVDQGDYLYLPRVFRQPLVXHJUD DOPLVPRSLVRTXHHOODXQRVSRFRVGHDxRVKDVWDTXHHQFRQWUDPRVXQR ¢&yPRHUDODUHODFLyQHQWUHORVYHFLQRV" 'HDTXt"0X\ELHQPX\ELHQ\RFRQWRGRVPHOOHYRPX\ELHQ\DOOt HQ*UDQROOHUVORPLVPRPX\ELHQ ¢0HMRUyVXVLWXDFLyQHFRQyPLFD" 6t ¢6XVKLMRVVHDGDSWDURQIiFLOPHQWH" 1R\RQRPHHQFRQWUpH[WUDxDDTXtSRUTXHHVWDEDPX\VRODHQHO SXHEOR\HQWRQFHVDTXtDXQTXHPLJHQWHQRHVWDDTXtSHURHVWDEDHQ 0DQUHVD\RFRJtDHOWUHQ\\DHVWiHQFDPELRDOOtHVWDEDVROD0LQLxD SHTXHxDQDFLyDOOtPLVSDGUHVQRHVWDEDQQRWHQLDFRQTXLHQDOOtQL QDGLH1DPiVTXHDODVYHFLQDV ¢3LHQVDTXHVXVKLMRVKDQWHQLGRPiVRSRUWXQLGDGHV"¢&XiOHV" 0LVKLMRVVtEXHQRHVWXGLRVHVWXGLRVQRSRUTXHHOPD\RU\DWHQLD DxRVFXDQGRYLQRSHUREXHQRHVFDUSLQWHUR6tFDUSLQWHUR\EXHQROD SHTXHxDHVWXYRDTXtHVWXGLDQGRSHURORGHMy\EXHQRDKRUDHVWiHQ XQDIiEULFD ¢+DEpLVLGRIUHFXHQWHPHQWHDOSXHEOR" 1LXQDYH]TXHOiVWLPDFRQORTXHPHJXVWDDPL ¢7HQpLVIDPLOLDDOOt"¢2VYLHQHQDYLVLWDU" 3ULPDVKDFHSRFRYLQRXQDSULPDSHURWDPSRFRWDPSRFRYLHQHQ YLQLHURQSRUTXHWLHQHDTXtXQKLMR\YLQRDYHUPH ¢/DVSHUVRQDVTXHVHTXHGDURQDOOtTXHSLHQVDQGHHVWDPDUFKD" &RPRTXHWHQtDDTXtWDPELpQXQKLMRHOORVKDEtDQHVWDGRDTXt YLYLHQGRWDPELpQOXHJRHOORVVHIXHURQGHMDURQXQKLMRDTXt\YLQLHURQ HODxRSDVDGRDYHUOR\YLQLHURQDYHUPH ¢&yPRRVVHQWtVDFWXDOPHQWH"¢9ROYHUtDDOSXHEOR" 1R3RUTXH\RDOOt\DQRFRQR]FRDQDGLHODVSHUVRQDVGHPLHGDG\D PXFKDVQRHVWiQRODPD\RUtDVHKDQYHQLGRPHJXVWDUtDLUDYHU DTXHOORHQ6HPDQD6DQWDHQODVIHULDVHQ6HSWLHPEUHPHJXVWDUtDLUD YHUFRPRHVWiSDUDYHUORSDUDYLYLUQRQR ¢/DFDVDD~QODWHQHLV" /DFDVDODYHQGLHURQDOFDERGHPXFKRVDxRV ¢4XpEDODQFHKDFHGHVXHPLJUDFLyQ"$VSHFWRVSRVLWLYRV\ QHJDWLYRV <RODHQFXHQWURELHQPX\ELHQWRGR