Le Journal Spirite nº 68 - CENTRO GIENNENSE DE ESTUDIOS

Anuncio
&
680$5,2
1n$%5,/
(',725,$/
-RXUQDO 6SLULWH
/H
1n$%5,/0$<2-81,2E
/$5(9…67$'(/&…5&8/2(63…5,7$
$//$1.$5'(&'(1$1&<)5$1&,$
,OSESCRITORES
INSPIRADOSPORELMÉSALLÉ
'266,(5
/RVHVFULWRUHVLQVSLUDGRVSRUHOP–VDOO–
7UDGXFFL§Q
5XWK1HXPDQQ
/(-2851$/63,5,7(
'LUHFWRUGHSXEOLFDFL§Q
-DFTXHV3HFFDWWH
6XVFULSFLRQHV
-HDQ&ODXGH7KLULRQ
ERXOHYDUG&KDUOHPDJQH
1DQF\
MFODXGHWKLULRQ#ZDQDGRRIU
7žO
6HGHVRFLDO
&HUFOH6SLULWH$OODQ.DUGHF
UXH-XOHV)HUU\
'RPPDUWLQVRXV$PDQFH
7žO
HPDLOMSHFFDWWH#IUHHIU
,PSUHVRHQ&((
&RPLFL§QSDULWDULD1o
1o,661
)2726(,//8675$&,21(6
$UFKLYRV&6$.
/(-2851$/63,5,7(1o$%5,/
(OHYROXFLRQLVPRFXHVWLRQDGR
/DJžQHVLVGHOKRPEUHHQWUHHVS¢ULWX\PDWHULD
'266,(5
$FHUDGH7KžRSKLOH*DXWLHU
/DQRYHODDFWXDO
/DVLGHDVHVS¢ULWDVGH*HRUJH6DQG
(VS¢ULWD\$YDWDUQRYHODVGH7KžRSKLOH*DXWLHU
%DO]DF8QDFRPHGLDKXPDQDPX\HVS¢ULWD
*RHWKHXQSHQVDPLHQWRHVS¢ULWDDQWLFLSDGR
/DYLOODGHOVLOHQFLRGRFXPHQWRVS§VWXPRVº
$OH[DQGUH'XPDV3DGUH
&KDUOHV'LFNHQV\HOPLVWHULRGH(GZLQ'URRG
,,QVSLUDFL§Q\PHGLXPQLGDGGHODLGHDVXJHULGDº
(175(9,67$
&RQ-HDQ-DFTXHV&KDUERQLHUPHGLFRDQHVWHVLVWD
126$'5(66(6
$1&,(161n'8-2851$/63,5,7(
686&5,3&,Š1$8-2851$/63,5,7(
'
(',725,$/
SRU
-$&48(63(&&$77(
(/(92/8&,21,602&8(67,21$'2
x4XLžQVHDFXHUGDWRGDY¢DKR\TXH7KžRSKLOH*DXWLHU+RQRUžGH%DO]DF$OH[DQGUH'XPDV
*HRUJH6DQG$OIUHGGH0XVVHWHWFVDOSLFDURQVXVREUDVGHUHIHUHQFLDVHVS¢ULWDVRHVSLULWXDOLVWDV
HQVLWXDFLRQHVTXHVXSHUDQODIDQWDV¢Dº
(OP•VDOO•HQODOLWHUDWXUD
AVh ^YZVh gZ[ZgZciZh Va b{h Vaa{ h^ZbegZ ]Vc ^che^gVYd V
adhXgZVYdgZhnVadhVgi^hiVh#H^?Zg‹c^bd7dhX]nL^aa^Vb
7aV`ZegdYj_ZgdcgZegZhZciVX^dcZhe^Xi‹g^XVhfjZZkdXVc
aVbjZgiZnZaig{ch^idVab{hVaa{!XdcjcV^cij^X^‹cfjZ
cdZhi{aZ_dhYZ]VXZgeZchVgZcaVhC9:bdYZgcVh!digdh
b{h ^c\ZcjVbZciZ ]Vc e^ciVYd X^Zadh aaZcdh YZ {c\ZaZh
dYZbdc^dh!gZ[aZ_VcYdaVeZgeZijV^ciZggd\VciZ]jbVcV
hdWgZaVbjZgiZnZaYZhi^cd#
=dn Zc Y†V! Zh Xdc [gZXjZcX^V Za X^cZ Za fjZ d[gZXZ
dWgVh [Vci{hi^XVh fjZ ]VXZc gZ[ZgZcX^V V adh [Zc‹bZcdh
eVgVcdgbVaZh!VaVedh^WaZXdbjc^XVX^‹cXdcadhZhe†g^ijh!
V aV gZZcXVgcVX^‹c! ZiX# N ajZ\d! aV a^iZgVijgV i^ZcZ hj
adiZ YZ cdkZaVh [Vci{hi^XVh! b{h d bZcdh ^che^gVYVh Zc
[Zc‹bZcdh gZVaZh# :h eVgi^XjaVgbZciZ Zc Za h^\ad M>M
YdcYZ hZ ZcXjZcigVc ZkdXVX^dcZh cdkZaZhXVh ^che^gVYVh
edgaV^ckZhi^\VX^‹cbZiV[†h^XVn]VhiVedgaVhZmeZg^ZcX^Vh
Zhe†g^iVhYZVfjZai^Zbed#ªFj^‚chZVXjZgYVidYVk†V]dn
fjZI]‚de]^aZ<Vji^Zg!=dcdg‚YZ7VaoVX!6aZmVcYgZ9jbVh!
<Zdg\ZHVcY!6a[gZYYZBjhhZi!ZiX#!hVae^XVgdchjhdWgVh
YZgZ[ZgZcX^VhZhe†g^iVhdZhe^g^ijVa^hiVh!Zch^ijVX^dcZhfjZ
hjeZgVcaV[VciVh†VnfjZ!Vab^hbdi^Zbed!hdcXaVgVbZciZ
^che^gVYVh edg ad fjZ nV hZ hVW†V hdWgZ Za b{h Vaa{ n aVh
Xdbjc^XVX^dcZhXdcZadigdbjcYd48^ZgiVbZciZZa\gVc
=j\d]VW†VbVgXVYdZaidcd!Xdchjh8dciZbeaVX^dcZhn
digVhdWgVh!ZcaVhfjZcdhZejZYZZk^iVgkZgaV^c[ajZcX^V
YZhjhZmeZg^ZcX^VhYZ?ZghZn#NVciZhYZ‚a!cdhZejZYZ
YZhXj^YVgiVbedXdVhj¹bVZhigdº8]ViZVjWg^VcYfjZcd
hZfjZYVVig{hXdchjhBZbdg^VhYZjaigVijbWV#
:cZhiZcbZgdYZAZ?djgcVaHe^g^iZ!d[gZXZbdhjcYdhh^Zg
hdWgZZhidhY^[ZgZciZhVjidgZhfjZiVcW^ZchZ]VcgZ[Zg^Yd
Va iZbV YZ aV bjZgiZ! V igVk‚h YZ hjh ZheZgVcoVh! hjh
XgZZcX^VhdhjhXZgiZoVh#
(QWUHYLVWD1'(
IVbW^‚c jc Z_ZXjidg b{h bdYZgcd hZ ]V YZY^XVYd V
aV ZhXg^ijgV YZ cdkZaVh [Vci{hi^XVh! hZ igViV YZ cjZhigd
^ck^iVYd YZ ZhiZ cbZgd YZ AZ ?djgcVa He^g^iZ! Za YdXidg
?ZVc"?VXfjZh8]VgWdc^Zg!b‚Y^XdVcZhiZh^hiVYZIdjadjhZ!
XdcdX^YdV]dgVedgZa^ciZg‚hfjZegZhiVVadh[Zc‹bZcdh
YZ C9:! d :B>! :meZg^ZcX^Vh YZ BjZgiZ >cb^cZciZ#Hjh
igZh cdkZaVh! egZhZciVYdh edg ‚a b^hbd Xdbd ¹cdkZaVh
b‚Y^XVhº! hdc kZgYVYZgdh i]g^aaZgh YZ hjheZchd! Zc adh
fjZhZWdgYZVadcdgbVanadeVgVcdgbVa#KZgaVe{\^cV
¹AZXijgVhgZXdbZcYVYVhºYZZhiVgZk^hiV#
6aiZcZgXdcdX^b^ZcidYZa^ciZg‚hYZaYdXidg8]VgWdcc^Zg
edgaVhC9:!ajZ\dYZaXdc\gZhdYZBVgi^\jZhZa&,YZ
_jc^dYZ'%%+!aZegdejh^bdhjcVZcigZk^hiVfjZVeVgZXZ
ZcidcXZhZcZhiVgZk^hiV#6XZei‹!VYZb{h!jcV^ck^iVX^‹c
YZ cjZhigd 8†gXjad! eVgV kZc^g V EVg†h Za h{WVYd * YZ
bVnd V YVg jcV Xdc[ZgZcX^V Xjnd iZbV Zh/¹:m^hiZ Za
YZhej‚hYZaVk^YVº#
(OUHWRUQRGHOFUHDFLRQLVPR
:aXdb^ZcodYZah^\adMM>cdhigVZhjadiZYZXdcXZeX^dcZh
Vci^\jVhfjZkjZakZcVaVbdYV!VigVk‚hYZadgZa^\^dhd!ad
b†hi^Xdn]VhiVYZa[jcYVbZciVa^hbd#9Zhej‚hYZjch^\ad
MMX^Zci†[^XdngVX^dcVafjZegVXi^XVWVaVbVndg†VYZaVh
kZXZh Za bViZg^Va^hbd [^adh‹[^Xd! aV kjZaiV YZ ad gZa^\^dhd
cdhgZ\gZhVVXdcXZeidhfjZhZXgZ†VcYZh\VhiVYdhnfjZ
YZhe^ZgiVcZcjcV^cZheZgVYVgZcdkVX^‹c!jc¹gZk^kVaºYZad
^ggVX^dcVaWV_didYVhhjh[dgbVh!nVhZigViZYZadhb†hi^Xdh
YZaVCZl6\ZdYZagZidgcdVaVhiZdg†Vhb{hh^bea^hiVh
hdWgZaVXgZVX^‹cYZabjcYd#
AV 7^Wa^V _Vb{h ]VW†V XdchZ\j^Yd iVcidh VYZeidh! YZhYZ
fjZhZ[dg_VgdcaVhcjZkVhZhe^g^ijVa^YVYZhYZ^che^gVX^dcZh
Y^kZghVhfjZbZoXaVcVaZ\gZbZciZZaZhdiZg^hbd!adb†hi^Xd
nadgZa^\^dhd!XdcjcV^begdciVCZl6\ZfjZhZVWgZVidYVh
aVhiZdg†Vhedh^WaZhZ^bV\^cVWaZh!ZchVW^VhXdbW^cVX^dcZh
fjZ gZXjggZc iVcid V aV Vhigdad\†V aVh ZcZg\†Vh X‹hb^XVh
XdbdVadhVci^\jdhiZmidhhV\gVYdh#HZ]VXZZk^YZciZfjZ
idYVeZghdcVfjZVhe^gZVjccjZkdYZhXjWg^b^ZcidYZad
Zhe^g^ijVadYZadgZa^\^dhd!iZgb^cZedgeZgYZgaVWg_jaVn
cdhVWZgnVdg^ZciVghZZchjWhfjZYVbZiV[†h^XV#
:cigZidYVhaVh\gVcYZhegZ\jciVhfjZhZeaVciZVc![^\jgV
Za ^cZajY^WaZ egdWaZbV YZ adh dg†\ZcZh YZa bjcYd n YZ
/(-2851$/63,5,7(1o$%5,/
(
aV ]jbVc^YVY# 8dc adh VkVcXZh YZiZgb^cVciZh egdejZhidh edg 8]VgaZh
9Vgl^cn6a[gZYGjhhZaLVaaVXZ!ZcZah^\adM>M!hZXgZ†V]VWZggZhjZaidaVh
XjZhi^dcZh b{h Zhe^cdhVh YZ jc ZkdajX^dc^hbd bjai^"b^aZcVg^d! YZcigd
YZ jcV XdcXZeX^‹c bViZg^Va^hiV eVgV Za eg^bZgd n Zhe^g^ijVa^hiV eVgV Za
hZ\jcYd# FjZYVWV idYVk†V edg Xdch^YZgVg Za egdWaZbV YZ adh ZhaVWdcZh
[VaiVciZh!eVgVZaXjVaaVeVaZdcidad\†Vcd]VVedgiVYdidYVhaVhgZhejZhiVh#
EZgd ]Z Vfj† fjZ ]dn Zc Y†V! idYd Zhd Zh kjZaid V XjZhi^dcVg edg jcV
cjZkVdaZVYVW†Wa^XV!\ZcZgVYViVcidedgadhgZa^\^dhdhZmigZb^hiVhXdbd
edg Zhe^g^ijVa^hiVh YZ idYV aVnV! egZhidh V WVggZg Zc jc hVci^Vb‚c idYdh
adh YZhXjWg^b^Zcidh fjZ! YZhYZ AVbVgX` nIZ^a]VgY YZ 8]VgY^c! eVhVcYd
edg 9Vgl^c n GjhhZa LVaaVXZ! YVWVc iZhi^bdc^d YZ jc ZkdajX^dc^hbd
igVch[dgb^hiVegd\gZh^kd!YZhYZaVVeVg^X^‹cYZadheg^bZgdhZaZbZcidhYZ
k^YVkZ\ZiVanVc^bVa]VhiVaV]jbVc^oVX^‹c#HZgZ\gZhVZcidcXZhVaVhiZh^h
b{hh^bea^hiVhYZaXgZVX^dc^hbd!YZaVhfjZ<Zdg\Zh8jk^Zg&,+."&-('
[jZZaai^bdYZadheVaZdci‹ad\dhZcgZ[Zg^ghZidYVk†V#
AV7^Wa^VZhi{ejZhgZVabZciZYZkjZaiV!cdnVZchjkZgh^‹ch^bW‹a^XV!
h^cdZchjaZXijgVa^iZgVa!eVaVWgVedgeVaVWgV#HZgZ\gZhVV6Y{cn:kV!Za
VgXVYZCd‚nVcdZhjcVh^beaZ^bV\Zc!aVXgZVX^‹cY^k^cVZhZab^aV\gd
YZjcVk^YVVeVgZX^YV]VXZedXd!niVaXdbdhZegZhZciV]dnVcjZhigdh
d_dh#HZ]VXZXdbdh^adheVaZdci‹ad\dhXdchjYViVX^‹cedgZaXVgWdcd
&) cjcXV ]jW^ZgVc YZhXjW^Zgid cVYV# :a e^iZX{cigded d Za ]dbWgZ YZ
8gd"BV\cdc!nVcdiZcYg†VccVYVfjZkZgZcZhiV]^hidg^VYZa]dbWgZ#
8dbegZcYVcfj^‚cejZYZ°
:m^hiZ h^c ZbWVg\d digV kZgh^‹c jc edXd b{h hZg^V YZa XgZVX^dc^hbd
¹bdYZgcdº fjZ hZ ZcXjZcigV WV_d aV eajbV YZ G‚bn 8]Vjk^c d YZ ?ZVc
H^YZg#Jcd!eVgVeh^X‹ad\dnZadigd!j[‹ad\d!eaVciZVcaV]^e‹iZh^hYZ¹hVaidhº
ZcaVZkdajX^‹c!YZW^Ydh!cdhZhVWZYZbVh^VYdW^ZcVfj‚#6Yb^i^ZcYdZc
idYdaVhZYVYZhnaVh‚edXVhXdbcbZciZYZ[^c^YVhedgaVX^ZcX^V!Zaadh
hZ]VcVednVYdhdWgZadh[VbdhdhZhaVWdcZh[VaiVciZh!eVgVYZYjX^gfjZ
]VW†V X^Zgid cbZgd YZ ^bedh^W^a^YVYZh \Zc‚i^XVh YZ igVch[dgbVX^dcZh
egd\gZh^kVh Zc aV ZkdajX^‹c YZ aVh ZheZX^Zh# 6ejciVc ]VX^V bjiVX^dcZh
WgjhXVh!Xjnddg^\Zc^cYZ[^c^YdedYg†VhZgk^cXjaVYdVjcV[jZgoVZhe^g^ijVa
Y^k^cV!fj^o{h!dV\‚gbZcZhegdXZYZciZhYZajc^kZghd!^cXajhd!edgfj‚
cd! V k^YVh ZmigViZggZhigZh kZc^YVh V hZbWgVg cjZhigd eaVcZiV#6h† ejZh!
Za igVch[dgb^hbd YVgl^c^Vcd idbV eadbd Zc Za VaV! b^ZcigVh fjZ jcV
cjZkVkZgh^‹cYZaXgZVX^dc^hbdhZ^bedcZZcVa\jcdhbZY^dhX^Zci†[^Xdh
b^cdg^iVg^dh#H^W^ZcZhiVcjZkV^YZV!cdZhg^Y†XjaVZch†b^hbV!Xdci^ZcZ
^\jVabZciZhjhegde^dh¹ZhaVWdcZh[VaiVciZhº!ZhYZX^gaVhZmea^XVX^dcZhYZ
ZhiVhWgjhXVhbjiVX^dcZh#HZYZbjZhigVhdWgZidYdfjZX^ZgiVhZkdajX^dcZh
\Zc‚i^XVh hZg†Vc ^bedh^WaZh Xdbd! edg Z_Zbead! aVh eg^bZgVh eaVciVh
Xjai^kVYVh edg adh hjbZg^dh fjZ cd i^ZcZc c^c\c eVgZciZhXd \Zc‚i^Xd
XdcaVheaVciVhhVakV_ZhfjZedYg†VchZgXdch^YZgVYVhXdbdYZaVb^hbV
[Vb^a^V#AVVeVg^X^‹cYZadheg^bZgdhXZgZVaZhXjai^kVYdhcdhZYZWZg†VV
jcV bjiVX^‹c YZ eaVciVh hVakV_Zh# H^c YZX^gcdh egZX^hVbZciZ YZ YdcYZ
egdXZYZg†VcZhiVhkVg^ZYVYZhcjZkVh!fjZVjcaV\Zc‚i^XVbdYZgcVhZg†V
VaeVgZXZg^cXVeVoYZXadcVgVeVgi^gYZeaVciVhhVakV_Zh!adhhjhiZciVYdgZh
YZ ZhiV iZdg†V cd VYZaVciVc ]^e‹iZh^h! cd ]VXZc b{h fjZ hjWgVnVg aV
^bedh^W^a^YVYYZX^ZgiVhbjiVX^dcZh!^ck^VWaZh\Zc‚i^XVbZciZ!hZ\cZaadh#
GZheZXid V aV ZkdajX^‹c Vc^bVa n ]jbVcV! ]VXZc Za b^hbd i^ed YZ
XjZhi^dcVb^Zcid!eaVciZVcYd^cXajhdVa\jcVhXdcigVY^XX^dcZhZcZaeaVcd
\Zc‚i^Xd#CdiZcZbdhadhXdcdX^b^Zcidhhj[^X^ZciZheVgVZcigVgYZaaZcd
ZcZhiZYZWViZ!ZcZafjZc^adhX^Zci†[^XdhZhi{cYZVXjZgYdZcigZZaadh!
eZgdfj^o{hedYZbdhd[gZXZgVa\jcVh^YZVh°
/DHYROXFL¦QVHJ­QHOHVSLULWLVPR
9ZhYZ hjh dg†\ZcZh! Za Zhe^g^i^hbd Za^\^‹ Zc hj [^adhd[†V Za XVbed YZa
igVch[dgb^hbd! Zc aV ‚edXV Zc fjZ 6aaVc @VgYZX! XdciZbedg{cZd YZ
9Vgl^c!VWjcYVWVZcZahZci^YdYZaVXdcXZeX^‹cZkdajX^dc^hiV#6ŠVYVbdh
fjZ6a[gZYGjhhZaLVaaVXZfj^Zc!Vab^hbdi^ZbedfjZ9Vgl^c!ZaVWdg‹jcV
/(-2851$/63,5,7(1o$%5,/
*HRUJHV&XYLHU
5žP\&KDXYLQ
)
/
+RPPHGH&UR0DJQRQ
$GDPHW(YH
)UDQœRLV5HQžGH&KDWHDXEULDQG
&KDUOHV'DUZLQ
iZdg†VhZbZ_VciZ!hZkdak^‹ajZ\dZhe†g^iV!adXjVacdejhdZcZcigZY^X]dhj
iZdg†V!eZg[ZXiVbZciZVYVeiVWaZVjcVk^h^‹cZhe^g^ijVa^hiVYZaVZkdajX^‹c#
NZhiVbW^‚cWV_djcV‹ei^XVZhe†g^iVfjZhZXdbegZcYZcbZ_dgVcaVh
bjiVX^dcZh hjXZh^kVh YZ aV k^YV! hVW^ZcYd fjZ idYV k^YV XdbedgiV jc
eg^cX^e^dZhe^g^ijVahjhXZei^WaZYZ]VXZgaVZkdajX^dcVg!h^ZcYdZaeg^cX^e^d
k^iVaZabdidgYZaVhegd\gZh^kVhigVch[dgbVX^dcZh\Zc‚i^XVh#:hVh†Xdbd
adheg^bZgdhZhe†g^ijh]jbVcd^YZhZcXVgcVYdhZcadhXjZgedhYZ\gVcYZh
bdcdhadhVciZeVhVYdhXdbjcZhVadh]jbVcdhnVadhbdcdhYZ]dn!
]^X^ZgdcZkdajX^dcVg!XdchjegZhZcX^Vk^iVaY^[ZgZciZVaVYZaVc^bVa!jcV
gVbVXdckZgi^YVZcaVZheZX^Z]jbVcV#8jVcYdGjhhZaLVaaVXZhZkdak^‹
Zhe†g^iV!cdijkdc^c\cegdWaZbVZcVYVeiVghjiZdg†VYZaVZkdajX^‹cV
adhXdcXZeidhZhe†g^iVh!ZcXdcigVcYdfjZidYdXdcXdgYVWVeZg[ZXiVbZciZ#
N [jZ ^\jVa eVgV6aaVc @VgYZX! YZ VXjZgYd V hj iZdg†V egZhZciVYV Zc AV
<‚cZh^hhZ\cZa:he^g^i^hbd#
B{h Vaa{ YZ Zhidh eg^cX^e^dh! hdWgZ adh XjVaZh cdh VednVbdh idYVk†V
]dn! ªYZWZ idbVghZ Zc XjZciV Za cjZkd XjZhi^dcVb^Zcid YZ i^ed
¹XgZVX^dc^hiVº hZ\c adh Vg\jbZcidh eaVciZVYdh! ZheZX^VabZciZ edg
G‚bn8]Vjk^cn?ZVcH^YZg4
HVWZbdhfjZadhZmigViZggZhigZhhZ]VcbVc^[ZhiVYdYZhYZh^ZbegZ!hVWZbdh
^\jVabZciZfjZZcdigdhi^Zbedhijk^ZgdcXdciVXidXdcadh]jbVcdhYZ
X^k^a^oVX^dcZhVci^\jVh!adXjVaZgVbjX]db{h[{X^afjZ]dn!VjcXjVcYd
Xdc[gZXjZcX^V[jZgdcXdch^YZgVYdhXdbdY^dhZhkZc^YdhYZaX^Zad#
EVgi^ZcYdYZZhiVgZVa^YVYh^ZbegZdW_ZiVYVedgcjbZgdhdh^ggZYjXi^WaZh!
ªcdejZYZ^bV\^cVghZfjZhZgZhkZc^YdhYZdigVeVgiZ]VnVcigVchedgiVYd
Xdc Zaadh! kdajciVg^VbZciZ d cd! \‚gbZcZh YZ k^YV egdXZYZciZh YZ hjh
egde^dhbjcYdhnYZhXdcdX^YdhZcaVI^ZggV4EjZYZhZgYZadgYZcYZjc
dg\Vc^hbdXZajaVg†c[^bd!XdbdedYg†VhZg!nYZbVcZgVkdajciVg^V!ZaVedgiZ
YZ hZb^aaVh ^cZm^hiZciZh Zc aVI^ZggV! eZgd VYVeiVWaZh# HVakd Zggdg YZ b^
eVgiZ!VccdhZhVWZX‹bdVeVgZX^‹ZabV†oXjai^kVYdZc6b‚g^XV8ZcigVa!
k^hid fjZ cd ]Vn eaVciVh hVakV_Zh YZa b^hbd i^ed hjhXZei^WaZh YZ ]VWZg
bjiVYd#NZcZhiVgZ\^‹c!cjbZgdhdhgZhidhVgfjZda‹\^XdheVgZXZc^cY^XVg
ZaeVhdcdidg^dYZhZgZhkZc^YdhYZdigVeVgiZ°KVnVbdhb{haZ_dhidYVk†V/
adhXdciVXidhXdcadh¹Y^dhZhkZc^YdhYZaX^Zadº!ªcd]jW^ZgVcedY^YdYVg
aj\VgVkZXZhVVXdeaVb^ZcidhZcigZ]jbVcdhnZmigViZggZhigZh!h^ZhfjZ
[jZgVcXdbeVi^WaZh!VaejcidYZYVgcVX^b^ZcidVc^Šdh¹\Zc‚i^XVbZciZ
bdY^[^XVYdhº4 =Z Vfj† h^beaZbZciZ Va\jcVh ]^e‹iZh^h fjZ YZhYZ jc
ejcidYZk^hiVZhe†g^iVh^\jZch^ZcYdeaVjh^WaZh!eVgVVejciVaVgZhiViZh^h
YZa XgZVX^dc^hbd bdYZgcd fjZ! edg digV eVgiZ! YZ kZo Zc XjVcYd ZkdXV
ZhiVh[VbdhVh^ciZgkZcX^dcZhZmigViZggZhigZh#H^!ZcXVbW^d!ZhiV]^e‹iZh^h
YZ aVh bjiVX^dcZh WgjiVaZh Zc aV ZkdajX^‹c YZ aVh ZheZX^Zh hZ VednV Zc
^ciZgkZcX^dcZh Y^k^cVh fjZ! Zc Y^kZghVh ‚edXVh! ]VWg†Vc bdY^[^XVYd Za
Xjghd cdgbVa YZ aV cVijgVaZoV eVgV ]VXZgaV YVg \gVcYZh hVaidh VYZaVciZ!
kZgYVYZgVbZciZcdedYgZbdhhZ\j^g!ejZhhZiZgb^cVg†VXVh^edgZcXdcigVg
aVhXdcXZeX^dcZhW†Wa^XVhYZaVXgZVX^‹c#
HZ edYg†V ZcidcXZh! V eVgi^g YZ Zhidh XjVcidh ZaZbZcidh iZ‹g^Xdh! igViVg
YZZhiVWaZXZgjcVeg^bZgVh†ciZh^hegdk^h^dcVaXdbdh^\jZ/eZgbVcZXZbdh
idiVabZciZ [^ZaZh V aV iZdg†V YZ aV ZkdajX^‹c igVch[dgb^hiV iVa n Xdbd
[jZ YZ[^c^YV n YZ Y^kZghVh bVcZgVh edg AVbVgX`! 9Vgl^c! GjhhZa
LVaaVXZ n b{h gZX^ZciZbZciZ IZ^a]VgY YZ 8]VgY^c# EZgd hZ edYg†V! edg
fj‚ cd! VŠVY^gaZ jc idfjZ YZ¹XgZVX^dc^hbdº V eVgi^g YZ ^ciZgkZcX^dcZh
ZmigViZggZhigZh!hjhXZei^WaZhYZ]VWZgbdY^[^XVYdX^ZgidhYVidh\Zc‚i^Xdh
dYZ]VWZghZbWgVYd!kdajciVg^VbZciZdcd!\‚gbZcZhegdXZYZciZhYZhjh
egde^dheaVcZiVhnfjZ]VWg†VcbdY^[^XVYdh^\c^[^XVi^kVbZciZadhVheZXidh
\Zc‚i^XdhejgVbZciZiZggZcVaZh#
HdWgZZhiZiZbV!egdedcZbdhZcZhiVgZk^hiVjcVgi†XjadhdWgZaVhY^[ZgZciZh
iZdg†VhYZaVZkdajX^‹cZcaV]^hidg^V!i^ijaVYd¹:a\‚cZh^hYZa]dbWgZ/ZcigZ
Zhe†g^ijnbViZg^Vº![^gbVYdedgB‚aVc^ZAVWW‚#
/(-2851$/63,5,7(1o$%5,/
*
(92/8&,Š1
SRU
0‚/$1,(/$%%‚
/$*1(6,6'(/+20%5(
(175((63…5,78<0$7(5,$
xF§PRLPDJLQDUTXHVHSXHGDGHVDSDUHFHUHQXQLQVWDQWHFRPRVLQRKXELžUDPRVH[LVWLGR
QXQFD SDUD TXH WRGRV QXHVWURV UHFXHUGRV VH UH®QDQ HQ OD QDGD \ QXHVWURV VXIULPLHQWRV
KD\DQVLGRYDQRV"
9
ZhYZh^ZbegZ!ZcidYVheVgiZh!ZahZg]jbVcdh^ZbegZhZ
]VegZ\jciVYdYZYdcYZkZc†V!nfj‚ZgV‚agZVabZciZ/
ªJcXjZged4ªJcZhe†g^ij4ªJcedXdYZadhYdh4AV
\‚cZh^hYZa]dbWgZZhejZhjcejcid[jcYVbZciVa!eZgdfjZ
^\jVabZciZ egdkdXV cjbZgdhVh eda‚b^XVh ejZh XVYV jcd
YZhZVgZhejZhiVhXaVgVhna‹\^XVhhdWgZaVZhZcX^Vb^hbVYZ
hj hZg# B^ZcigVh fjZ Va\jcdh ]Vc gZ[aZm^dcVYd hdWgZ ZhiVh
egZ\jciVhVigVk‚hYZaV[^adhd[†V!digdhhZ]VcVnjYVYdXdc
aVgZa^\^‹cedghjhgZhejZhiVhegZXdcXZW^YVh0ZcXjVcidVaV
X^ZcX^V!VafjZgZgXdcigVggZhiVgaVh^YZVhgZa^\^dhVh!egdedgX^dc‹
ZaZbZcidhXgjX^VaZheVgVaVXdbegZch^‹cYZaVZkdajX^‹cYZaV
bViZg^VeZgdcd]VedY^YdVedgiVg^cY^XVX^‹cVa\jcVgZheZXid
V cjZhigd nd egd[jcYd# EVgV bjX]dh X^Zci†[^Xdh! cjZhigd
eZchVb^ZcidcdhZg†Vh^cdZahjWhigVidYZcjZhigdXZgZWgd!n!V
aVbjZgiZYZhVeVgZXZg†VbdhXdc‚a#EZgd!ªX‹bd^bV\^cVgfjZ
hZejZYVYZhVeVgZXZgZcjc^chiVciZ!Xdbdh^cd]jW^‚gVbdh
Zm^hi^YdcjcXV!eVgVfjZidYdhcjZhigdhgZXjZgYdhhZgZcVc
Zc aV cVYV n cjZhigdh hj[g^b^Zcidh ]VnVc h^Yd kVcdh4 6a
eg^cX^e^dYZah^\adMM!cjbZgdhdhZhe†g^iVh!iVaZhXdbd;hd[ij
8eppWded=WXh_[b:[bWdd[!ji^a^oVgdcZhdhb^hbdhb‚idYdh
X^Zci†[^XdheVgVYZbdhigVgfjZZaZhe†g^ijZm^hiZb{hVaa{YZaV
bViZg^V!nfjZZaXZgZWgdZhh‹adjcV]ZggVb^ZciVYZaVabV#
6h†ejY^ZgdcbdhigVgVaVajoYZaY†V!bZY^VciZcjbZgdhdh
iZhi^bdc^dh![Zc‹bZcdhXdbdaViZaZeVi†V!aViZaZ`^cZh^V!aV
XaVg^k^YZcX^Vn]VhiVaV[did\gV[†VZhe†g^iVeVgVYZbdhigVgaV
^cYZeZcYZcX^VYZaZhe†g^ij[gZciZVaXjZged#
YZjcVciZeVhVYdXdbceg^bdgY^Va!WV_daV^c[ajZcX^VYZ
[VXidgZhVbW^ZciVaZh0
(#AV ^cigdYjXX^‹c YZa Zhe†g^ij/ :a XjZged nV cd Zh h^cd jcV
]ZggVb^ZciV ^cY^heZchVWaZ eVgV eZgb^i^g aV ZkdajX^‹c YZa
Zhe†g^ij#
AVhiZdg†VhYZaVZkdajX^‹cXdbedgiVc
igZh\gVcYZhXdgg^ZciZh/
&#:a;^_^hbdfjZeaVciZVfjZ9^dh]VWg†VXgZVYdXVYVZheZX^Z
Vc^bVa d kZ\ZiVa ZmVXiVbZciZ Xdbd aV XdcdXZbdh ]dn!
YZZhVbVcZgVc^c\jcVYZZaaVhiZcYg†VaVedh^W^a^YVYYZ
ZkdajX^dcVgVigVk‚hYZai^Zbed0
'#:aIgVch[dgb^hbdfjZ!edgZaXdcigVg^d!YZhVggdaaVaViZdg†V
YZ igVch[dgbVX^dcZh egd\gZh^kVh YZ aVh ZheZX^Zh! V eVgi^g
IZcZbdh ZcidcXZh Ydh iZdg†Vh fjZ hZ XdcigVedcZc# AV
eg^bZgVZhaVYZjcVXgZVX^‹cVaZVidg^VYZaVk^YV!YZW^YVVa
VoVg! n h^c c^c\jcV [jZgoV Y^gZXig^o# ;cfƒZeYb[i ).*")(*!
hZ\j^Yd edg ;f_Ykhe ()&"',% n edg BkYh[Y_e .*"*(!
eaVciZ‹ aV ]^e‹iZh^h YZ fjZ Zc Za eg^cX^e^d igdodh YZ XjZged
hjg\^Zgdc Zhedci{cZVbZciZ YZa hjZad n hZ gZjc^Zgdc Va VoVg
YZ hjh ZcXjZcigdh# HZ ]VWg†Vc XgZVYd ZcidcXZh idYVh aVh
XdbW^cVX^dcZhdg\{c^XVhedh^WaZhWjZnXdcXVWZoVYZ]dbWgZ!
/(-2851$/63,5,7(1o$%5,/
&8$1'235('20,1$(/),-,602
/RVILO¦VRIRVJULHJRV
AV<gZX^VVci^\jV[jZXjcVYZjcVZ[ZgkZhXZcX^V^ciZaZXijVa
fjZaaZk‹VZhijY^dhiVcidVc^kZaeda†i^XdXdbdVgi†hi^Xdn
[^adh‹[^XdfjZ!edgdigVeVgiZ]Vc^c[ajZcX^VYdegd[jcYVbZciZ
cjZhigVXjaijgVdXX^YZciVa#6ciZhYZZhiV‚edXV!aVigVchb^h^‹c
YZaV^c[dgbVX^‹chZ]VX†VhdWgZidYddgVabZciZ0ZhVZhaV
gVo‹cedgaVXjVaXVh^cdfjZYVc^c\cgVhigd#
:aeg^bZgcdbWgZfjZ]VaaZ\VYdVcdhdigdhZh7dWn_cWdZhe
Z[ C_b[je +&%"*),# Hjh gZ[aZm^dcZh hZ ^chXg^WZc Zc aV
YZeZcYZcX^VYZac^Šd[gZciZVhjheVYgZh#:cZ[ZXid!Za]ZX]d
YZ fjZ cZXZh^iVgV kVg^dh VŠdh eVgV edYZg ViZcYZg hdad V
hjh cZXZh^YVYZh aZ ^cig^\‹ bjX]d! ejZh Zc aV cVijgVaZoV
adh Vc^bVaZh YZWZc hVWZg YZ[ZcYZghZ hdadh XdcigV adh
YZegZYVYdgZh YZhYZ hj cVX^b^Zcid! h^ cd cd hdWgZk^kZc#
;dgbja‹ZcidcXZhaV]^e‹iZh^hYZfjZadheg^bZgdh]dbWgZh
]VWg†VccVX^YdYZ\gVcYZheZXZh!ZcZa^ciZg^dgYZadhXjVaZh
]VWg†Vc ZcXdcigVYd VWg^\d! hZ\jg^YVY n Va^bZcid0 eVgV hVa^g
h^ZcYdVji‹cdbdh#
+
]dbWgZh^cWdXV!eZoXdcWgVodh!ZiX##9ZcigdYZZhiVVcVgfj†VYZadh
hZgZhk^k^ZciZh!hdaVbZciZ]VWg†VchdWgZk^k^Yd!ajX]VcYdXdciZcVX^YVY!
adhb{hk^VWaZhnb{hVYVeiVYdh#:cXjVcidV9Zb‹Xg^id)+%"(,%!
‚aZhZa[jcYVYdgYZaViZdg†VVidb^hiVhZ\caVXjVaaVcVijgVaZoVhZ
]VWg†VXgZVYdedgZabdk^b^Zcid[dgij^idYZadh{idbdhZcZakVX†d#:a
]dbWgZ]VWg†VhVa^Yd!ejZh!Zhedci{cZVbZciZYZahjZad!VaVoVgYZaVh
XdbW^cVX^dcZhVi‹b^XVh#:a]dbWgZcdhZg†VZcidcXZhb{hfjZjc[Za^o
VXX^YZciZYZaVcVijgVaZoVnh^ZbegZ]VWg†ViZc^YdaVVeVg^ZcX^VVXijVa#
(SLFXUR
AVhZ\jcYViZdg†VZc_jZ\dZhdejZhiVVaVYZaVoVg/ZhaVYZaV[^cVa^YVY
dg\{c^XV!YZX^Y^YVedgjcV[jZgoV^ciZa^\ZciZY^gZXig^o#7dWn|]ehWiZ[
9bWpec[d[*%%")'-n7h_ijŒj[b[i(-)"(''hdchjhegZXjghdgZh#
:hiZai^bdc^Z\VaV\‚cZh^h[dgij^iVYZaVk^YV0b{hW^ZcaV9^k^c^YVY
igViVg†V YZ VaXVcoVg jc \gVYd YZ eZg[ZXX^‹c Zc hj XgZVX^‹c0 Vh†!
kZ\ZiVaZhnVc^bVaZhcdhZg†Vch^cdZhWdodhXjndgZhjaiVYd!¹ZahZg
eZg[ZXidº!hZg†VZa]dbWgZ#6g^hi‹iZaZhZhejZhZaeg^bZgdZcY^hXZgc^g
jcV _ZgVgfj†V YZ ad k^k^ZciZ Xdc jcV Xdci^cj^YVY ZcigZ adh hZgZh
^cVc^bVYdheaVciVhnadhhZgZhVc^bVYdh#
:caVVci^\“ZYVY!]VnejZhigZhXdcXZeX^dcZh^bedgiVciZh/jcV_ZgVgfj†V
YZadhhZgZhk^k^ZciZhXdcjcVegd\gZh^‹ccVijgVa!jcVegdYjXX^‹cYZ
aVVgbdc†Vdg\{c^XVedgVoVgnfjZcdZkdajX^dcV!n[^cVabZciZjcV
ajX]VedgaVhjeZgk^kZcX^V#EdgdigVeVgiZ!ZaZhe†g^ijcdi^ZcZc^c\c
aj\VgZcaVhiZdg†VhYZaV‚edXV!YdcYZidYdhZYZhVggdaaVXdbdh^h‹ad
ZaXjZgedhZbdY^[^XVgVb^ZcigVhfjZZaVabVeZgbVcZX†VZhi{i^XV#
/DLQIOXHQFLDGHODUHOLJL¦Q
$QD[LPDQGURGH0LOHWR
$QD[–JRUDVGH&OD]RPHQH
AjZ\d YZ aVh Y^kZghVh ^ckVh^dcZh Xdadc^VaZh n aV ^chiVjgVX^‹c YZa
[ZjYVa^hbd!ZaZhijY^dYZaVcVijgVaZoVhZWdggVYZig{hYZaVgZa^\^‹c
Xg^hi^VcVnhZ[dgbVedXdVedXdjccjZkdbdk^b^Zcid/ZaXgZVX^dc^hbd#
:hiVZhjcVXgZZcX^VhZ\caVXjVaZajc^kZghdnadh^cY^k^Yjdh]Vc
h^YdXgZVYdhZhedci{cZVbZciZedg9^dh#:hiViZh^h[jZVXZeiVYVedg
aVbVndg†VYZadh^cY^k^YjdhejZhaVegZdXjeVX^‹cXZcigVa!ZcVfjZa
eZg†dYdYZXVgZcX^Vhn\jZggVh!ZgVaVhjeZgk^kZcX^VY^Vg^V#AVgZ[aZm^‹c
hdWgZaVk^YVdXjeVWVh‹adVadhcdWaZhnaVbVndg†VYZaVedWaVX^‹c
hZ XdciZciVWV Xdc XgZZg ad fjZ Za XaZgd! idYdedYZgdhd! V[^gbVWV#
GZXdgYZbdhfjZhZ\cZhidheg^cX^e^dh!9^dh]VWg†VXgZVYdadhX^Zadh
naVi^ZggVZchZ^hY†Vh!Vh†Xdbdjc]dbWgZnjcVbj_Zg!6Y{cn:kV#
whidh]VWg†Vck^k^YdZcZa_VgY†cYZa:Y‚ceZgd!]VW^ZcYdXdbZi^Yd
Za eZXVYd dg^\^cVa! 9^dh adh Zck^‹ V aVI^ZggV eVgV XVhi^\Vgadh#IdYdh
egdkZcYg†VbdhYZZhiVeVgZ_Vc^XV#:cgZhjbZc!adhiZmidhW†Wa^Xdh
ZgVcVh^b^aVYdhVjcVkZgYVYhV\gVYVZ^cXdciZhiVWaZgZheZXidVaV
\‚cZh^h^cbZY^ViVYZabjcYdnYZadhhZgZhk^k^ZciZh#
EVgV adh XgZVX^dc^hiVh! aV cdX^‹c YZ Zhe†g^ij eZgbVcZXZ jc^YV V aV
Y^k^c^YVY#=VWg†Vh^YdXgZVYdZhedci{cZVbZciZ!_jcidXdcZaXjZged
n!YZhej‚hYZaVk^YViZggZcVa!^g†VVaeVgV†hd!Vaejg\Vidg^ddVa^c[^Zgcd
edgidYVaVZiZgc^YVY#AVgZhjggZXX^‹cZhi{egdbZi^YVYZcigdYZjc
i^Zbed ^cYZiZgb^cVYd n hZ gZ[^ZgZ h‹ad Za XjZged# =VWg†V ejZh jcV
XdcZm^‹cdg\{c^XVnZhe^g^ijVaYZa]dbWgZYZhYZhjXgZVX^‹c#
DWhZgkVbdhfjZaVh^YZVhXgZVX^dc^hiVhhdch^ZbegZYZVXijVa^YVY!
ZheZX^VabZciZZcadh:hiVYdhJc^Ydh#HZZcXjZcigVcZcZadg^\Zc
YZcjbZgdhdhegdXZhdh!Zab{h[VbdhdYZadhXjVaZh!aaVbVYdZa
egdXZhdYZabdcd!hZYZhVggdaa‹Zc&.'*ZcIZccZhhZZ#Jc_dkZc
egd[Zhdg! I]dbVh HXdeZh! [jZ VXjhVYd edg ]VWZg ZchZŠVYd aVh
aZnZhYZaVZkdajX^‹c!XdcigVk^c^ZcYdjcVaZnYZZhZZhiVYdfjZaV
egd]^W†V#:cZhV‚edXV!aVde^c^‹ceWa^XVZhiVWVbVndg^iVg^VbZciZ
YZhjaVYdn!YZZhVbVcZgV!VjcfjZgZX^W^‹jcVeZfjZŠVbjaiV!ZhiZ
egdXZhd[jZXdch^YZgVYdXdbdjcVk^Xidg^VYZadhZkdajX^dc^hiVh!
VahZgaVde^c^‹ceWa^XV[VkdgVWaZVaegd[Zhdg#
/(-2851$/63,5,7(1o$%5,/
,
(/(67$%/(&,0,(172'(/75$16)250,602
(ODSRUWHGHORVJUDQGHVGHVFXEULPLHQWRV
K^c^ZgdcajZ\dadh\gVcYZhYZhXjWg^b^Zcidh!Zceg^bZgaj\VgXdc
adh k^V_Zh YZ BVgXd Edad &'*)"&(') Va :migZbd Dg^ZciZ! n YZ
8g^hi‹WVa8da‹c&)*&"&*%+V6b‚g^XV#;jZjceZg†dYdV\^iVYdYZ
XjZhi^dcVb^ZcidhnZhijY^dhhdWgZadhhZgZhk^k^ZciZh#:cZ[ZXid!hZ
YZhXjWg^ZgdccjZkVhZheZX^ZhkZ\ZiVaZhnVc^bVaZh!YZhXdcdX^YVh
[jZgVYZcjZhigdXdci^cZciZ!nfjZZhiVWVcVYVeiVYVhVhjZcidgcd#
:hdegdkdX‹^ciZggd\VciZhgZa^\^dhVhejZh!ªX‹bd]VWg†VcedY^Yd
ZbWVgXVgiVciVhXg^VijgVhY^[ZgZciZhZcZaVgXVYZCd‚VabdbZcid
YZaY^ajk^d46YZb{h!ZhiVWVciVcW^ZcVYVeiVYVhVhjbZY^dfjZ
XdhiVWV igVWV_d XdbegZcYZg X‹bd ]VWg†V edY^Yd ZcXdcigVghZ
edgZ_Zbead«jcdhdedaVgZcZaBdciZ6gVgViEdgdigVeVgiZ!aV
^ckZcX^‹cYZab^XgdhXde^d!V[^cVaZhYZah^\adMK>edgZa]daVcY‚h
OVX]Vg^Vh?VchhZc!VWg^‹ZaXVb^cd]VX^VjcbjcYd^c[^c^iZh^bVa
cdYZhXg^idedgaV7^Wa^V#
IdYdZhidXgZ‹jcVkZgYVYZgV[^hjgVZcaVXgZZcX^VZcadhiZmidh
hV\gVYdh# ;jZ jc \gVc eVhd Zc Za egd\gZhd YZ aVh ^YZVh/ 9^dh nV
cdZhiVWVegZhZciZZcXVYV^chiVciZ!cd]^odh^cdYVgZa^bejahd
^c^X^VaYZaVk^YV#AVX^ZcX^VhZXdadX‹ZcidcXZhedgZcX^bVYZadh
iZmidhW†Wa^Xdh#
=DFKDULDV-HQVVHQ
/DVLQYHVWLJDFLRQHVHQHO-DUG¡QGHO5H\
=VhiV ZhiV ‚edXV! aV ^YZV YZ ZheZX^Z hZ\j†V h^ZcYd kV\V/ adh hZgZh
k^k^ZciZh YVc cVX^b^Zcid V hZbZ_VciZh eZgd iVbW^‚c hZ XgZ†Vc
edh^WaZh aVh VaiZgVX^dcZh YZ ZheZX^Zh! Xdbd aV igVch[dgbVX^‹c YZa
ig^\dZcig‚Wda#6h†!cdgZej\cVWVeZchVgfjZ«jcVkZejY^ZgVcVXZg
YZjc{gWdaEZgd!idYd^WVVXVbW^VgXdcCWhY^Wdj&+*%"&,(-#:c
&+,-!VagZaZkVgVhjeVYgZZcZaejZhidYZedgiZgdYZa?VgY†cYZaGZn
XdckZgi^Ydb{hiVgYZZcBjhZdYZ=^hidg^VCVijgVaaaZ\‹Vaeg^bZg
eaVcdedgZaZhijY^dYZZheZX^bZcZhegdXZYZciZhYZaZmigVc_Zgd#;jZ
ZaYZhXjWg^b^ZcidYZjcV]^ZgWVYZhXdcdX^YVZcZa_VgY†cfjZY^ddigV
ZheZX^ZYZ]^ZgWV!adfjZadaaZk‹VigVWV_VghdWgZaVigVchbjiVX^‹cYZ
aVh[dgbVhk^k^ZciZh#HZ\c‚a!ZaXgZVYdg]VWg†VejZhidZcX^gXjaVX^‹c
jc bdYZad c^Xd YZ XVYV \‚cZgd YZ hZgZh k^k^ZciZh fjZ hZ ]VWg†V
Y^kZgh^[^XVYdVigVk‚haVhZYVYZh#
6jcfjZ YZ VXjZgYd Xdc ZhiVh XdcXZeX^dcZh! 8k\\ed &,%,"&,--
Vedn‹ eg^bZgd aVh iZdg†Vh [^_^hiVh! Zh YZX^g aV ^cbjiVW^a^YVY YZ aVh
ZheZX^ZhVigVk‚hYZai^Zbed#:cZ[ZXid!adhiZ‹ad\dhjc^kZgh^iVg^dhYZ
aVHdgWdcVYZah^\adMK>>>iZc†VcjcVXdch^YZgVWaZ^c[ajZcX^VhdWgZaVh
^YZVhnegZY^XVWVcZa[^_^hbd#;jZedgZhdfjZV7j[[dcaZXdhi‹igVWV_d
V[^gbVghjhiZdg†VhZkdaji^kVh#EZgd!idbVcYdXdc[^VcoVZch†b^hbd
\gVX^VhVhjXgZX^ZciZedejaVg^YVYX^Zci†[^XV!YZhV[^‹VadhgZa^\^dhdh
n YZhVggdaa‹ jc igVch[dgb^hbd bdYZgVYd/ aV cVijgVaZoV egdXZYZg†V
edgY^hZŠdhhjXZh^kdhXdcb^gVhVbZ_dgVghjhegdYjXX^dcZh\gVX^Vh
V aV ^c[ajZcX^V YZa bZY^d! igVchb^i^‚cYdhZ aVh bdY^[^XVX^dcZh YZ
\ZcZgVX^‹cZc\ZcZgVX^‹c#6YZb{h!h^iVZa[^cYZaVZkdajX^‹cb{h
Vaa{YZcjZhigVXdbegZch^‹c!YZW^ZcYdZhVhbdY^[^XVX^dcZhhZgk^gV
9^dhYZcigdYZjci^Zbed^cYZiZgb^cVYd#
B_dd[e&,%,"&,,-gZXd\^‹ajZ\dZhiViZdg†V#;jZZaeg^bZgcVijgVa^hiV
Zc V\gjeVg V adh hZgZh k^k^ZciZh adh kZ\ZiVaZh Zc ZhiZ XVhd hZ\c
jcVZhigjXijgVVgWdgZhXZciZ!Xdcjcdg\Vc^hbdc^XdZchjdg^\Zc!n
egZhZciVcYdVaZmigZbdYZhjhgVbVh[Vb^a^VhYZZheZX^ZhY^[ZgZciZh!
eZgdYZXdbeaZ_^YVYZfj^kVaZciZ#AVhbdY^[^XVX^dcZhhZg†VcYZW^YVh
VadhXVbW^dhYZaZcidgcd#GZX]VoVWVejZhaVhiZdg†VhYZ6g^hi‹iZaZh
hZ\caVhXjVaZh]VWg†VjcbdYd_Zg{gfj^Xda^cZVa!YZaZaZbZcidb{h
^beZg[ZXidVaZaZbZcideZg[ZXid!ZhYZX^gZa]dbWgZ#
/(-2851$/63,5,7(1o$%5,/
/HFOHUFFRPWHGH%XIIRQ
&DUO9RQ/LQQHR
-
6aV^ckZghV!YZcjcX^VcYdaViZdg†VYZjcV^c[^c^YVYYZdg\Vc^hbdh
cVX^Ydh YZ jc hdad hZg n egZXdc^oVcYd aV \ZcZgVX^‹c Zhedci{cZV!
:_Z[hej &,&("&,-)! ;hWice :Whm_d &,(&"&-%'! VWjZad YZ
8]VgaZh 9Vgl^c n BWcWhYa &,))"&-'.! egdiZ\^Yd YZ 7j[[dc!
Y^Zgdc Va bZY^d VbW^ZciZ jc eVeZa [jcYVbZciVa bjX]d b{h fjZ
A^ccZd/ZaYZbdY^[^XVg^cY^gZXiVbZciZadh‹g\Vcdh#EdgZ_Zbead!h^
adh{gWdaZhhZ]VXZcb{hVaidh!VaVh_^gV[VhaZhXdhiVg{b{haaZ\VgVaVh
]d_VhniZcYg{cfjZZhi^gVgZaXjZaadXdcb{h[gZXjZcX^V0ZhidiZcYg†V
XdbdXdchZXjZcX^VXgZVg_^gV[VhYZXjZaadb{haVg\dZcaVhh^\j^ZciZh
\ZcZgVX^dcZh#6cjZkVhXdcY^X^dcZhZmiZg^dgZhhZVa^Vg†VcejZhcjZkdh
bdYdhYZk^k^gnjcVZkdajX^‹c[†h^XVeVgVjcVbZ_dgVYVeiVX^‹cVa
bZY^d#CdiZbdhfjZAVbVgX`[jZZaeg^bZgX^Zci†[^XdZcZhiVWaZXZgZa
k†cXjadZcigZdg\Vc^hbdnZcidgcdnZcZc[gZciVgaV>\aZh^VZmedc^ZcYd
VW^ZgiVbZciZaVigVch[dgbVX^‹cYZaVhZheZX^ZhdZheZX^VX^‹c#
'HQLV'LGHURW
=[e\\heoIW_dj#>_bW_h[ &,,'"&-)) Xdch^YZgVWV! Zc XVbW^d! fjZ
ZaZ[ZXidYZabZY^dVbW^ZciZZhY^gZXid/aVhigVch[dgbVX^dcZhcdhZ
]Vg†VcnVYZ\ZcZgVX^‹cZc\ZcZgVX^‹ch^cdYZjcVkZo!ZcZhiVYd
ZbWg^dcVg^d# N! hZ\c ‚a! cd hZg†Vc VYVeiVYdgVh Va Zcidgcd h^cd
VaZVidg^Vh#;jZhZ\j^YdZchjhiZdg†Vhedgdigdh^ckZhi^\VYdgZhiVaZh
Xdbd Bo[bb &,.,"&-,*! IY^ef[d^Wk[h &,--"&-+% n ]VhiV hj
]^_d?i_Zeh[=[e\\heoIW_dj#>_bW_h[&-%*"&-+&#
/DVHOHFFL¦QQDWXUDO
-HDQ%DSWLVWHGH0RQHWFKHYDOLHUGH/DPDUFN
&KDUOHV/\HO
:c Za h^\ad M>M ]Vn jcV kZgYVYZgV gZkdajX^‹c Xdc 8]VgaZh 9Vgl^c
&-%."&--' n 6a[gZY GjhhZa LVaaVXZ &-'("&.&(# 6bWdh
egdejh^Zgdc aV b^hbV iZdg†V eZgd [jZ 9Vgl^c fj^Zc XdhZX]‹ adh
]dcdgZh#EdgZcXdcigVghZZcZaZmigVc_Zgd!LVaaVXZcdejYdegZhZciVg
‚ab^hbdhjhZhijY^dhVabjcYdX^Zci†[^Xd#6YZb{h!:adg^\ZcYZaVh
ZheZX^Zh!fjZijkdjc\gVc‚m^id!^bejah‹V9Vgl^c#:cZhiV‚edXV!
adh eVgi^YVg^dh YZa [^_^hbd n YZa igVch[dgb^hbd hZ Zc[gZciVWVc Zc
YZWViZhh^c[^c#Adh[^_^hiVhZgVcb{hcjbZgdhdh!eZgd9Vgl^c^ckZgi^g†V
aViZcYZcX^VZ^bedcYg†VaViZdg†VigVch[dgb^hiV\gVX^VhVZhijY^dh
YdXjbZciVYdh n jc Xdch^YZgVWaZ cbZgd YZ ]ZX]dh idbVYdh Zc
idYdhadhXVbedhVcVidb†VXdbeVgVYV!eVaZdcidad\†V!ZiX##
:a YVgl^c^hbd YZhXVchV Zc aV cdX^‹c YZ hZaZXX^‹ccVijgVa# HZ\c
9Vgl^cnLVaaVXZ!adhhZgZhk^k^ZciZhhZgZegdYjXZcVjcVkZadX^YVY
[ZcdbZcVanaVcVijgVaZoV]VWg†VZhiVWaZX^YdjcZfj^a^Wg^d\gVX^VhV
aVYZegZYVX^‹ceVgVcdhZghjeZgedWaVYV#:cZhiZXVhd!hdaVbZciZadh
b{hVeidheVgVYZ[ZcYZghZd]j^ghdWgZk^k^g†VcnedYg†VcgZegdYjX^ghZ#
IVbW^‚c!VZ_ZbeadYZaVh]^e‹iZh^hYZA^ccZd!ZabZY^dVbW^ZciZ
iZcYg†VjceVeZacdYZhYZŠVWaZhdWgZaVZkdajX^‹cYZadh^cY^k^Yjdh#
H^cZbWVg\d!XdcigVg^VbZciZVaViZh^hYZAVbVgX`!aVhkVg^VX^dcZhfjZ
YZZaadYZg^kVg†VccdiZcYg†Vcc^c\jcVa‹\^XVc^WjhXVg†VcegdXjgVg
Va ^cY^k^Yjd b{h kZciV_Vh eVgV hdWgZk^k^g# GZhjb^ZcYd! Za Zcidgcd
]Vg†V ZkdajX^dcVg adh dg\Vc^hbdh Zc idYdh adh hZci^Ydh! eZgd h‹ad
hdWgZk^k^g†VcVfjZaadhfjZ!\gVX^VhV‚a!]jW^ZgVcVYfj^g^YdkVg^VX^dcZh
fjZaZhY^ZgVcb{hkZciV_VhedgZ_Zbead!adhfjZ]jW^ZgVcVYfj^g^Yd
bhXjadhb{hi‹c^XdheVgVXdggZgg{e^YdiZcYg†Vcb{hedh^W^a^YVYZh
YZhdWgZk^k^gfjZadhdigdh!fjZYZhVeVgZXZg†Vc#:cXVYV\ZcZgVX^‹c
hZ deZgVg†V! jcV hZkZgV hZaZXX^‹c n hdaVbZciZ adh b{h Z[^X^ZciZh
hjWh^hi^g†VceVgVigVchb^i^ghjhXVgVXiZg†hi^XVhVaVYZhXZcYZcX^V#
AVh gZVXX^dcZh [gZciZ Va YVgl^c^hbd [jZgdc k^gjaZciVh iVcid Zc Za
eaVcd gZa^\^dhd Xdbd Zc Za eaVcd X^Zci†[^Xd# HZ gZegdX]Vgdc Ydh
ejcidhVZhiViZdg†V/Zceg^bZgaj\Vg!9Vgl^c^cXajnZVa]dbWgZZc
aVXVYZcVYZaVZkdajX^‹c#:a]ZX]dYZYVgaZjcVciZeVhVYdXdbc
XdcadhdigdhVc^bVaZh!X]dX‹V\gVceVgiZYZaVedWaVX^‹c!hdWgZ
idYdVadhXgZVX^dc^hiVh!fjZXdch^YZgVWVcVa]dbWgZXdbdaV¹dWgV
bVZhigVº YZ aV cVijgVaZoV# :hd kdak†V V edcZg Zc iZaV YZ _j^X^d hj
/(-2851$/63,5,7(1o$%5,/
.
dg^\ZcY^k^cdhZ\cadhiZmidhW†Wa^Xdh#:chZ\jcYdaj\Vg!cdedY†V
VYb^i^ghZ aV ajX]V edg aV hjeZgk^kZcX^V! Zh YZX^g Za ]ZX]d YZ fjZ
jcdhbjZgVcZcZaigVchXjghdYZ^cXZhVciZhajX]Vh#6bjX]dhaZh
gZej\cVWV aV ^YZV YZ fjZ Za ]dbWgZ! XgZVYd V ^bV\Zc YZ 9^dh!
ejY^ZgViZcZgXdbedgiVb^ZcidhiVcV\gZh^kdh]VX^VZaeg‹_^bd#
9Za aVYd X^Zci†[^Xd! ]jWd eVgi^YVg^dh n YZigVXidgZh! YZ adh XjVaZh
Va\jcdhigViVgdcYZ]VXZgXZchjgVgadhiZmidh#JcX^Zci†[^Xd!DlZc!
]VhiVXVa^[^X‹VhjiZdg†VYZ¹^c_jg^VVaVX^ZcX^Vº#EZgd!Vh†nidYd
9Vgl^cegdh^\j^‹hjh^ckZhi^\VX^dcZh!ejZhfjZg†VZmea^XVgidiVabZciZ
adh [Zc‹bZcdh YZ aV kVg^VW^a^YVY YZ aVh ZheZX^Zh n YZ aV ]ZgZcX^V#
9ZhY^X]VYVbZciZ!cdkZg†VZagZhjaiVYdYZhjh^ckZhi^\VX^dcZh#
(OGHVFXEULPLHQWRGHODJHQWLFD
H^ W^Zc 9Vgl^c cd ejYd gZhedcYZg V hjh ]^e‹iZh^h! hj iZdg†V cd
[jZ VWVcYdcVYV! h^c ZbWVg\d# =hƒ]eho C[dZ[b &-''"&--)!
bdc_Z n Wdi{c^Xd Vjhig^VXd! ^WV V XaVg^[^XVg Za bZXVc^hbd YZ aV
Y^kZgh^YVY \gVX^Vh V hj ZhijY^d hdWgZ Za \j^hVciZ E^hjb hVi^kjb#
:a dW_Zi^kd eg^bZgd YZ hj igVWV_d ZgV [ZXjcYVg Vgi^[^X^VabZciZ aVh
eaVciVheVgVdWiZcZgcjZkdhXdadgZh#:hdaZY^daV^YZVYZdWhZgkVg
aVh XVgVXiZg†hi^XVh YZ adh ]†Wg^Ydh V igVk‚h YZ hj YZhXZcYZcX^V#
:hijY^‹ejZhaVigVchb^h^‹cYZaVhY^[ZgZciZhXVgVXiZg†hi^XVhnYZZaad
YZhVggdaa‹aVhaZnZh#<gVX^VhVhjh^ckZhi^\VX^dcZh!BZcYZaeaVci‹adh
[jcYVbZcidh YZ aV \Zc‚i^XV n VWg^‹ jc cjZkd XVb^cd Va ZhijY^d
YZa]dbWgZ#:cZ[ZXid!ZcadhjXZh^kdaVZkdajX^‹ciVbW^‚cfjZY‹
^chiVaVYVZcZa^ciZg^dgYZcjZhigVhX‚ajaVh#
6eZhVgYZjcVY^[jh^‹cYZhjhigVWV_dhZcZabZY^dX^Zci†[^Xd!‚hidh
cd ijk^Zgdc c^c\c ZXd n edg Va\c i^Zbed hjh iZdg†Vh XVnZgdc
ZcZadak^Yd#AjZ\d!aViZdg†VbZcYZa^VcVYZaVigVchb^h^‹cYZadh
XVgVXiZgZh hZg†V Vea^XVYV V adh Vc^bVaZh n V adh ]dbWgZh# EZgd aV
\Zc‚i^XV!WjhXVcYdaVk^YVZcaV^ci^b^YVYYZcjZhigVhX‚ajaVh!YZ_V
h^cZbWVg\dYZaVYdadZhZcX^VaYZcdhdigdhb^hbdh/ZaZhe†g^ij#
,VLGRUH*HRIIUR\6DLQW+LODLUH
(OQHRGDUZLQLVPR
AViZdg†VYZaVhZaZXX^‹ccVijgVakdak^‹VaVhjeZg[^X^ZZc&-)-Xdc
jcXdaZXX^dc^hiV^c\a‚hfjZYZhXjWg^‹Zaeg^bZgZhe‚X^bZcYZ7^hidc
WZijaVg^VYZVaVhcZ\gVh#:hjcVbVg^edhVfjZ]VW^ijVabZciZi^ZcZ
aVhVaVhXaVgVh0eZgd!Zc)-VŠdhidYVhaVhbVg^edhVhYZZhiVZheZX^Z
hZ ]VW†Vc XdckZgi^Yd Zc cZ\gVh# Edg Zaad! hjg\^Zgdc cjbZgdhVh
^ciZggd\VciZh eVgV ZcXdcigVg jcV Zmea^XVX^‹c V ZhiZ [Zc‹bZcd#
>WbZWd[nA[jjb[m[bbZb^i^ZgdcZcidcXZhaV]^e‹iZh^hYVgl^c^VcV
YZ aV VYVeiVX^‹c Va bZY^d# :c Z[ZXid! Zc jc eZg†dYd ^ciZch^kd YZ
^cYjhig^Va^oVX^‹cadh{gWdaZh]VW†VcidbVYdjcXdadgdhXjgdVXVjhV
YZa]jbdYZaVh[{Wg^XVh#6]dgVW^Zc!jcVbVg^edhVXaVgVhdWgZjc
igdcXddhXjgdZhb{hk^h^WaZeVgVaVhVkZhnedgiVcidb{hkjacZgVWaZ#
:hiVh ZheZX^Zh hZ ]VWg†Vc VYVeiVYd ZcidcXZh Va eV^hV_Z VbW^ZciZ!
XVbW^VcYdYZXdadg!eVgVZajY^gVadhYZegZYVYdgZh#
:hZcZhiZeZg†dYdfjZcVXZZacZd"YVgl^c^hbd!jcVYdXig^cVfjZ
bZoXaV\Zc‚i^XVnVbW^ZciZ/Zadg\Vc^hbdhZVYVeiVg†VVadhXVbW^dh
YZabZY^deVgVeZgb^i^gaVXdci^cj^YVYYZaVZheZX^Z#
6afjZgZgZmea^XVgaVhXdhVhb{hZcYZiVaaZ!adhX^Zci†[^XdhXgZVgdcajZ\d
aVW^dad\†VbdaZXjaVg#H^cZbWVg\d!VXijVabZciZbjX]dh[Zc‹bZcdh
cd h^ZbegZ ZcXjZcigVc Zmea^XVX^‹c# :c Z[ZXid! adh ^ckZhi^\VYdgZh
igViVcYZZcXdcigVgZaXVb^cdVigVk‚hYZa[jcX^dcVb^ZcidXZajaVg#
EZgd! Zc jc ZcXVgc^oVYd Zh[jZgod edg dedcZghZ Va XgZVX^dc^hbd!
]VcgZX]VoVYdaVcdX^‹cb^hbVYZZhe^g^ijVa^YVY!fjZh^cZbWVg\d
i^ZcZ hj aj\Vg Zc Za egde^d hZcd YZ cjZhigVh X‚ajaVh# B^ZcigVh aV
X^ZcX^VhZa^b^iZVXdch^YZgVgh‹adaVbViZg^V!h^cVŠVY^gaZjcV[jZgoV
^ciZa^\ZciZ!igdeZoVg{Xdcejcidh^chdajWaZh#
/(-2851$/63,5,7(1o$%5,/
-RKQ+DOGDQH
+HQUL%HUQDUG.HWWOHZHOO
&%
/$,1752'8&&,Š1'(/(63…5,78
/DHVSLULWXDOL]DFL¦QGHODPDWHULD
9Zhej‚hYZZhiZ[gZcZh†X^Zci†[^XdYZah^\adM>M!hZYZhiVXV
jc ^ckZhi^\VYdg eVaZdci‹ad\d n hVXZgYdiZ _Zhj^iV! F_[hh[
J[_b^WhZZ[9^WhZ_d&--&"&.**cVX^Yd_jhidZcbZY^d
YZ idYdh Zhidh XjZhi^dcVb^Zcidh# 9ZhYZ hj c^ŠZo! hZ
VeVh^dc‹ edg aVh X^ZcX^Vh cVijgVaZh! ZheZX^VabZciZ edg
aV \Zdad\†V n aV eVaZdcidad\†V# Hj Xdbegdb^hd _Zhj^iV
VjcVYd V aVh ZmXVkVX^dcZh fjZ ZbegZcY^‹ Zc :migZbd
Dg^ZciZ! ad XdcYj_Zgdc V jcV XdcXZeX^‹c YZ cjZhigV
\‚cZh^h fjZ XdbW^cV X^ZcX^V n [Z Xg^hi^VcV# HZ\c ‚a!
]VWg†VbjX]VhZiVeVhfjZhZhjXZYZcZcaVZkdajX^‹c!YZ
aVhfjZ9^dhhZg†VZabdidg#:ceg^bZgaj\Vg]VWg†V]VW^Yd
aV Xdhbd\‚cZh^h cVX^b^Zcid n YZhVggdaad YZa jc^kZghd!
ajZ\d aV W^d\‚cZh^h! cVX^b^Zcid n YZhVggdaad YZ aV k^YV
n!adfjZk^k^bdhVXijVabZciZ!aVcdd\‚cZh^hcVX^b^Zcid
n YZhVggdaad YZa Zhe†g^ij# HZ\c ZhiV ‹ei^XV! ]VWg†V jcV
egd\gZh^kV Zhe^g^ijVa^oVX^‹c YZ aV bViZg^V! Xjnd [^c Zh
VXZgXVghZ V 9^dh# :a eVhd YZ aV W^dh[ZgV k^YV iZggZcVa! V
aV cddh[ZgV k^YV YZa Zhe†g^ij! hZ ]Vg†V edg jc YZhVggdaad
YZaVhXdcX^ZcX^Vh]jbVcVh!fjZiZgb^cVg†Vcedgjc^ghZn
XgZVgjcV¹hjeZgXdcX^ZcX^Vº#
8dcigVg^VbZciZ V adh YZb{h X^Zci†[^Xdh! IZ^a]VgY YZ
8]VgY^c^cXajnZZcidcXZhaVcdX^‹cYZZhe†g^ijZchjiZdg†V/
Za]dbWgZnVcdZhh‹adjcbdci‹cYZX‚ajaVhV\gjeVYVh#
CddWhiVciZ!hjiZdg†VeZgbVcZXZViVYVVaV^YZVYZfjZ
Za]dbWgZhZg†Vjc¹hZghjeZg^dgºYZcigdYZaVZkdajX^‹c!aV
ai^bVZiVeVVciZhYZaVYkZc^b^ZcidYZ9^dh#
(OHVS¡ULWXDPRGHODPDWHULD
ZmegZh^‹c b^cZgVa! Zc ZhiV Vgbdc†V ^cY^heZchVWaZ YZ adh
gZ^cdhº#6h†!ZaZhe^g^i^hbd^ciZ\gVaViZdg†VYZaVZkdajX^‹c
egd\gZh^kV/ YZhej‚h YZ hj [dgbVX^‹c! cjZhigd eaVcZiV hZ
Zc[g^‹ [dgbVcYd aVh gdXVh# K^cd ajZ\d aV Vib‹h[ZgV! Za
V\jVnjcZcidgcdegde^X^dVaVVeVg^X^‹cYZadhkZ\ZiVaZh#
9Zhej‚hYZjci^Zbed^cYZ[^c^WaZ!VeVgZX^ZgdcadhVc^bVaZh
nhZVYVeiVgdcZcidcXZhVadhY^[ZgZciZhZhiVYdhXa^b{i^Xdh
YZaVI^ZggV!ZkdajX^dcVcYd[†h^XVbZciZeVgVhdWgZk^k^g#;jZ
XjVcYdZabZY^diZggZcVaejYdgZjc^gidYdhadhZaZbZcidh
^cY^heZchVWaZheVgVZaXdb^ZcodYZhjgZXdgg^YdZkdaji^kd
fjZZa]dbWgZZcXVgc‹#
:caVb^hbVdWgV!edYZbdhaZZg/¹;jZedgZaVXdeaVb^Zcid
YZadh\gVcYZhbdcdhfjZ[jZgdc[ZXjcYVYdhadheg^bZgdh
]dbWgZh#9Zae^iZXVcigdejhVa]dbdhVe^Zch!Vh^hi^bdhVaV
aZciVZkdajX^‹cYZaVbViZg^VeZg^Zhe^g^ijVaedgZa^bejahd
YZaZhe†g^ij#AVVgbdc†Vea{hi^XVYZadhXjZgedhhZV[^cVZc
b^aadcZhYZVŠdhº#8dbegZcYZgZbdhVfj†fjZZa]dbWgZ]V
ZcXVgcVYdZcaVYZhXZcYZcX^VYZadh\gVcYZhbdcdhYZaV
EgZ]^hidg^V#CdZhejZhjchZgVeVgiZZcaVZkdajX^‹c#I^ZcZ
hj aj\Vg hdWgZ aVI^ZggV Xdbd aVh eaVciVh n adh Vc^bVaZh#
EdgdigVeVgiZ!adfjZadY^[ZgZcX^VYZaVc^bVa!Zhh‹adhj
XVeVX^YVYYZgZ[aZm^dcVgnhjaZc\jV_Z#
:hiZ ZmigVXid cdh bjZhigV ^\jVabZciZ fjZ Za Zhe†g^ij n
Za XjZged Zhi{c †ci^bVbZciZ a^\VYdh# GZXdgYZbdh fjZ
Za hZg ]jbVcd hZ XdbedcZ YZ igZh eVgiZh/ jcV eVgiZ
bViZg^Va/ZaXjZged!jcVeVgiZhZb^"bViZg^Va/ZaeZg^Zhe†g^ij
n jcV eVgiZ ^cbViZg^Va/ Za Zhe†g^ij# H^ZcYd Za eZg^Zhe†g^ij
Za ]^ad XdcYjXidg ZcigZ Za Zhe†g^ij n Za XjZged! b^ZcigVh
Za Zhe†g^ij ZkdajX^dcV! V igVk‚h YZ b^aZh YZ VŠdh! ad XjVa
^bea^XVbdY^[^XVX^dcZhXdgedgVaZh#IdYdadfjZidXVVjcd
gZeZgXjiZhdWgZZadigd#
Edg aV b^hbV ‚edXV! aZ_dh YZ aV gZa^\^‹c n YZ aV X^ZcX^V!
k^cd V ^chiVjgVghZ digV XdcXZeX^‹c YZa dg^\Zc YZa
]dbWgZ/ Za Zhe^g^i^hbd# AVh eg^bZgVh ^ciZggd\VciZh hdWgZ
Za Zhe†g^ij cVX^Zgdc Zc 6b‚g^XV Xdc aVh ]ZgbVcVh ;dm
edg bVc^[ZhiVX^dcZh YZ [VaaZX^Ydh# ;jZ ZcidcXZh XjVcYd
Za iZbV ^ciZgZh‹ V adh \gVcYZh X^Zci†[^Xdh iVaZh Xdbd
;hd[ij8eppWde!9^Whb[iH_Y^[j!M_bb_Wc9heea[id]VhiV
=kijWl[=[b[o#
HZYZbdhig‹fjZVa\dYZcdhdigdhejZYZhjWh^hi^gYZhej‚h
YZaVbjZgiZnbVc^[ZhiVghZb{hVaa{YZaXjZged#ª:hdcd
h^\c^[^XVg†V fjZ YjgVciZ cjZhigV k^YV iZggZcVa Zm^hiZ Zc
cdhdigdhZhVb^hbV[jZgoV^ciZa^\ZciZ4;jZVeVgi^gYZZhZ
XjZhi^dcVb^ZcidfjZhZZhijY^VgdcndWhZgkVgdc!\gVX^VhV
g^\jgdhdhb‚idYdhX^Zci†[^Xdh!aVh\gVcYZhbVc^[ZhiVX^dcZh
YZaZhe†g^ij]jbVcdXdbdaVW^adXVX^‹c!aVXaVg^k^YZcX^Vn
]VhiVaViZaZ`^cZh^V#
H^c ZbWVg\d! b{h Vaa{ YZ aV X^ZcX^V! Za Zhe^g^i^hbd
eZgb^iZgZhedcYZgVjcVegZ\jciV[jcYVbZciVa/ªEdgfj‚
ZhiVbdhZcaVI^ZggV4JcYZhZcXVgcVYdcdh]VigV†YdZhiV
gZhejZhiV/¹KjZhigdh Zhe†g^ijh cd Zhi{c ad hj[^X^ZciZbZciZ
ZkdajX^dcVYdheVgVedYZgk^k^gZchZgZc^YVY!ZcVbdgnZc
Vgbdc†V!ZcZabjcYd^ck^h^WaZ#8dbegZcYZgZaVbdgnk^k^g
aVVgbdc†V!Zm^\ZbViZg^Va^YVY#K^k†hhdWgZaVI^ZggVjcdhXdc
digdh!Vab^hbdi^ZbedhVW‚^hiVbW^‚cY^hi^c\j^gVjcdhYZ
digdh#6egZcY‚^hVXdbegZcYZgdh!VVbVgdh#:hZZhidYdZa
hZci^YdYZaVZcXVgcVX^‹cYZhZVYVedg9^dhº#9ZVXjZgYdV
ZhiVheVaVWgVh!edYZbdhXdbegZcYZgfjZaVk^YVZcZhiZ
bjcYdcdZhb{hfjZjceVhdeVgVVYfj^g^gXdcdX^b^Zcidh!
VWg^gaVXdcX^ZcX^VVaeg‹_^bdnVegZcYZgVVbVg/ZaXjZged
ZcidcXZh cd Zh b{h fjZ jc igV_Z ^cY^heZchVWaZ eVgV
bdkZghZZcZaZcidgcdiZggZcVa!eZgdcdjcV[^cVa^YVY#
B{h gZX^ZciZbZciZ! adh YZhZcXVgcVYdh ]Vc kZc^Yd eVgV
YVgcdh ^c[dgbVX^dcZh gZheZXid V cjZhigV \‚cZh^h# HZ\c
Za CjZkd A^Wgd YZ adh :he†g^ijh/¹AVX^gXjchiVcX^V]jbVcV
Zh jcV cZXZh^YVY Zkdaji^kV# :aaV ]V hVW^Yd idbVg [dgbV V
eVgi^gYZadhbViZg^VaZhY^hedc^WaZhhdWgZZa\adWdiZggZhigZ#
AV X^gXjchiVcX^V ]jbVcV hZ ]V VYVeiVYd ejZh Va Zcidgcd
YZabZY^degZZm^hiZciZ!cVX^YdYZaVXVgcZVc^bVa#;jZ]VXZ
h^ZiZ b^aadcZh YZ VŠdh! YZhej‚h YZ aVh eg^bZgVh [dgbVh!
YZhej‚hYZaVheg^bZgVhWgjiVa^YVYZhYZaVZmegZh^‹cVc^bVa!
YZhej‚hYZaVhWgjiVa^YVYZhYZaVZmegZh^‹ckZ\ZiVanYZaV
EVgVgZhedcYZgVcjZhigVegdWaZb{i^XV!hdbdhZhe†g^ijh
ZcXVgcVYdhZcaVbViZg^V#JcdcdejZYZgZYjX^ghZVaV
ZckdaijgVXVgcVa0cjZhigVkZgYVYZgVk^YVZhi{b{hVaa{#
H^c ZbWVg\d! cjZhigd XjZged Zh ^cY^heZchVWaZ eVgV
eZgb^i^gcdh aaZkVg V W^Zc cjZhigd VegZcY^oV_Z YZ aV
k^YV#:hegZX^hdejZhiZcZgXj^YVYd#6a^cXaj^gaVcdX^‹c
YZ jc XgZVYdg! aV XjZhi^‹c YZ aV k^YV Zh YZa^XVYV#
EZgd!XdbdadYZX†V7j[[dc!cdedYZbdhXdcXZW^gadh
YZh^\c^dh YZ aV cVijgVaZoV0 VXZeiZbdh ZcidcXZh aVh
odcVhYZhdbWgVnhZVbdh]jb^aYZh/aVXgZVX^‹ci^ZcZ
hjhgVodcZhfjZaVgVo‹cYZhXdcdXZ#
/(-2851$/63,5,7(1o$%5,/
&&
'266,(5
,OSESCRITORES
INSPIRADOSPORELMÉSALLÉ
/(-2851$/63,5,7(1o$%5,/
&'
'266,(5
/26(6&5,725(6,163,5$'26325(/0z6$//z
SRU
)$%,(11(728=(7
$&(5&$'(7+23+,/(*$87,(5
< VLQ HPEDUJR HQWUH FHQWHQDUHV GH FDUWDV GHO DXWRU GH 6SLULWH UHDJUXSDGDV SRU 6SRHOEHUFK GH
/RYHQMRXO XQDGPLUDGRUGH*DXWLHU \TXHUHSUHVHQWDQGRFHYRO®PHQHV QRHQFRQWUžP–VTXHXQD
VRODFDUWDGH'HOSKLQHGH*LUDUGLQGRQGHOHSLGHD7KžRTXHSDUWLFLSHHQXQDVHVL§QGHPDJQHWLVPR
68&8/785$
;jZXdceaVXZgnVYb^gVX^‹cfjZYZhXjWg†aVk^YVnaVdWgV
YZI]‚de]^aZ<Vji^Zg!ajZ\dYZhjbVc^[ZhiVX^‹cZchZh^‹c
Zhe†g^iV Zc VWg^a YZ '%%(# Hj cdkZaV He^g^iZ :he^g^i^hiV
[dgbVWV eVgiZ YZ b^ XjaijgV Zhe†g^iV eZgd \gVcYZ [jZ b^
hdgegZhVVaXdbegdWVgfjZbjX]VhYZhjhcdkZaVh[Vci{hi^XVh
XdbdAZe^ZYYZbdb^Z¼¼!:ae^ZYZaVbdb^V!AVXV[Zi^ƒgZ
AVXV[ZiZgV!6kViVgd]VhiVAVbdgiZVbdjgZjhZAVbjZgiZ
VbdgdhV!ZcXZggVWVc\gVcYZhXdcdX^b^ZcidhZcbViZg^VYZ
Xdbjc^XVX^‹cXdcZadigdbjcYd#
HZigViVWVYZjc]dbWgZYZ\gVcZgjY^X^‹c#9ZhYZaVZYVY
YZ * VŠdh XjVcYd YZ \daeZ VegZcY^‹ V aZZg! edg X‹aZgV n
edg YZheZX]d hZ kdak^‹ Wja†b^Xd YZ XdcdX^b^Zcidh# Hjh
Y†Vh! XjVcYd cd hVa†V! eVhVWVc Zc aZXijgVh! ^cXajnZcYd
jcV WjZcV eVgiZ YZ hjh cdX]Zh# :c hjh ZcigZi^Zch!
hdjkZc^ghZiXdggZhedcYVcXZhXdckZghVX^dcZh! gZXjZgYdhn
XdggZhedcYZcX^Vh! hj nZgcd! :b^aZ 7Zg\ZgVi! cdh ]VWaV YZ
hjXjaijgVZcX^Xade‚Y^XV0hj\jhidedgaVaZc\jV[gVcXZhVad
Zbej_Vg{iVbW^‚cVVegZcYZghZYZbZbdg^VZaY^XX^dcVg^d
V[^cYZedYZgji^a^oVgidYVhaVheVaVWgVheVgVZcg^fjZXZghj
kdXVWjaVg^d#
¹AVh X^ZcX^Vh n aVh VgiZh cd [jZgdc ^cYV\VYVh edg ‚a! Xdbd
jcd hZ ^bV\^cV! h‹ad ]VhiV aV i‚Xc^XV! h^cd b{h W^Zc ]VhiV
aVhegd[jcY^YVYZhXVh^b^hiZg^dhVhYZhjhYZhXjWg^b^Zcidhn
hjhgZaVX^dcZh#CdZhXdbdZ_Zbead!c^h^fj^ZgVZchjdWgV!
h^cdZcaVXdckZghVX^‹cYZI]‚de]^aZ<Vji^Zg!fjZc^Zab{h
ZheZX^Va^hiV YZ adh ZgjY^idh _Vb{h ad eZhX‹ Zc [VaiV c^ ad
Xdc[jcY^ܼ!cdhZmea^XVVYZb{h#
Edg VŠVY^YjgV bjn hjeZghi^X^dhd!I]‚de]^aZ <Vji^Zg ]VW†V
igV†YdYZjcdYZhjhk^V_ZhV:heVŠV!jcVXVWZoVYZidgd!
ejZhhZXdch^YZgVWVfjZadhXjZgcdhYZaVWZhi^VXdc_jgVWVc
aV bVaV hjZgiZ# ;jZ bVgXVYd ^\jVabZciZ edg jc ]dbWgZ!
Za ^c\Zc^Zgd HlZYWZg\! cVX^Yd jc h^\ad VciZh! fj^Zc eVgV
YZhXVchVg YZ hjh igVWV_dh X^Zci†[^Xdh hZ ZcigZ\VWV V aV
a^iZgVijgV n Xdbedc†V XdbdI]‚d! kZghdh Zc aVi†c#6 ZhiZ
HlZYWZg\!adXdcdXZbdh]dnWV_dZacdbWgZYZ:bbVcjZa
HlZYZcWdg\fjZXdchV\g‹kZ^ci^h^ZiZVŠdhYZhjk^YVVaV
ZmeadgVX^‹c YZa bjcYd ^ck^h^WaZ! YZhej‚h YZ hjh [VbdhVh
k^h^dcZh#
EVgV \VcVghZ aV k^YV! Za WjZc I]‚d! Xdbd hZ aZ aaVbVWV!
ZhXg^W†V Zc Za eZg^‹Y^Xd AV EgZhhZ! fjZ ]^od YZ ‚a! YjgVciZ
b{h YZ igZ^ciV VŠdh! Za Xg†i^Xd YgVb{i^Xd n Vgi†hi^Xd b{h
XdgiZ_VYdniZb^YdYZEVg†h#
686$0,*26(63…5,7$6
6ZhdhZhjbVWVjcVgZYYZ^c[ajZcX^Vh!ejZhhjhVb^\dh
ZgVc ^ccjbZgVWaZh! XdbZcoVcYd edgK^Xidg =j\d V fj^Zc
YZ[ZcYZg†VidYVhjk^YVVjcVg^Zh\dYZeZgYZghjejZhid
Zc Za eZg^‹Y^Xd XjVcYd Za Zm^a^d YZa BVZhigd! n V fj^Zc aZ
Y^g†V/¹IZgZhb^eVYgZ!b^bVYgZ!b^eVig^Vnb^[Vb^a^Vº#
:cXdcigVgZbdhajZ\daVegZhZcX^VYZjcVbj_Zg^bedgiVciZ
Zchjk^YVVfj^Zc‚aegdiZ\Zg†VXdc[gZXjZcX^VYZaV^gVYZ
hjeVig‹cZcAVEgZhhZ!:b^aZYZ<^gVgY^c!nfjZcdZhdigV
fjZaVfjZ^cigdYj_dVK^Xidg=j\dXdcaVhbZhVh\^gVidg^Vh!
aVhZŠdgV9Zae]^cZYZ<^gVgY^c#
JhiZYZh]VWg{cXdbegZcY^Yd!b^hXVgdhaZXidgZh!fjZh^aZh
]VWad YZ Zhidh eZghdcV_Zh! Zh edgfjZ Zh ^cXdcXZW^WaZ fjZ
I]‚de]^aZ <Vji^Zg! Xdc iVaZh Vb^hiVYZh YZ aVh fjZ cd hZ
hZeVg‹cjcXVVadaVg\dYZhjk^YV!cd]VnVeVgi^X^eVYdZc
hZh^dcZhZhe†g^iVh#
6b‚a^Z7djYZi!ZhedhVYZ6aaVc@VgYZXcdhadXdc[^gbVg†V
Zc jcd YZ hjh bZchV_Zh! ejZh ajZ\d YZ aV bjZgiZ YZ hj
Zhedhd! ZaaV Xdci^cj‹ aVh hZh^dcZh Xdc Za edZiV n digdh
Vb^\dh ZcigZ ZaadhK^Xidg^Zc HVgYdj!6aZmVcYgZ 9ZaVccZ d
E^ZggZ<V…iVcAZnbVg^Z#Nh^cZbWVg\d!ZcigZXZciZcVgZhYZ
XVgiVhYZaVjidgYZHe^g^iZ!gZV\gjeVYVhedgHedZaWZgX]YZ
AdkZc_dja!jcVYb^gVYdgYZ<Vji^Zg!nfjZgZegZhZciVcYdXZ
kdabZcZh!cdZcXdcig‚b{hfjZjcVhdaVXVgiVYZ9Zae]^cZ
YZ<^gVgY^cYdcYZaZe^YZVI]‚dfjZeVgi^X^eZZcjcVhZh^‹c
YZbV\cZi^hbd/¹BVŠVcV_jZkZhedgaViVgYZ!aZZhXg^WZZaaV!
iZcYg{aj\VgZaegdY^\^dYZaaZkVciVb^ZcidbV\c‚i^Xd!]VWg{
iVbW^‚cjchZŠdgfjZkZZaedgkZc^gZcaViVeVYZjcWdiZ
/(-2851$/63,5,7(1o$%5,/
&(
YZedbVYV!eZgdZhiZegdY^\^dcdXjZciV!ZhedgVŠVY^YjgV#BVŠVcV
ejZhº#:hh^cZbWVg\daVbdYVYZVfjZaaV‚edXVYdcYZ]VW†VbjX]d
^ciZg‚hedgZabV\cZi^hbdnZahdcVbWja^hbd#
68)$0,/,$
AV egde^V ]^_V YZ I]‚de]^aZ <Vji^Zg! ?jY^i]! cdkZa^hiV! fj^Zc hZ
XdckZgi^g†V Zc aV eg^bZgV bj_Zg Zc hZg VXd\^YV edg aV VXVYZb^V
<dcXdjgi! cdh gZaViV Zc hjh bZbdg^Vh! aV bVcZgV Zc fjZ igVW‹
XdcdX^b^Zcid Xdc aVh bZhVh \^gVciZh/¹bZ dXjgg†V V kZXZh! edg aV
cdX]Z! fjZ bZ aZkVciVWV Xdc jc a^\Zgd VXXZhd YZ hdcVbWja^hbd#
6Wg†V aV kZciVcV n aVh eZgh^VcVh! ad XjVa ZgV WVhiVciZ \gVkZ Zc Za
fj^cid0ajZ\dkV\VWVedgZaVeVgiVbZcid!Xdcb^Vabd]VYVWV_dZa
WgVod!nXdc[gZXjZcX^V^WVVVggd_VgaVhdWgZaVXVbVYZaV^chi^ijig^o!
fjZhZYZheZgiVWVbjnVhjhiVYV#EZgdXjVcYdXdbegZcY^‹fjZnd
Ydgb†V!nfjZfj^o{hZgVjchj_ZidaX^Yd!hZ^ciZgZh‹k^kVbZciZn
bZ ^ciZggd\‹ bZi‹Y^XVbZciZ hdWgZ adh b^hiZg^dh YZa edgkZc^g°
;jZZcidcXZhaVHZŠdg^iVfj^ZccdhYZhXjWg^‹idYVjcVeVgiZYZhj
VabVfjZ\jVgYVWVZchZXgZid#:aaVhZdXjeVWVYZZhe^g^i^hbd!YZ
bZhVh\^gVciZh!YZdXjai^hbdnYZbV\cZi^hbd°CdhaaZk‹ZcidcXZh
VahVa‹cYZa8dcYZYZDjgX]!jcdYZadhbVZhigdhb{h[Vbdhdh#:a
XdcYZcdh]VX†VhZciVgYZaVciZYZaVbZhV!gZXdbZcY{cYdcdhedcZg
ZcX^bV cjZhigVh bVcdh ZmiZcY^YVh! cd bdkZgcdh n XVaaVgcdh°
8jVcYdhZegZhZciVWVZaZhe†g^ij!Za8dcYZad^ciZggd\VWV!gZX^iVcYd
^cXVchVWaZbZciZZaVa[VWZidº#
:a bVg^Yd YZ ?jY^i]! 8VijaaZ BZcY‚h! YZ fj^Zc hZ Y^kdgX^‹ n
fj^Zc ijkd ^\jVabZciZ jc bZgZX^Yd aj\Vg Zc aV ]^hidg^V YZ aV
a^iZgVijgV! ijkd jc hjZŠd egZbdc^idg^d! Za YZ hj bjZgiZ/¹:hiV
cdX]Z]ZhdŠVYdjcVXdhVVWdb^cVWaZ!aZY^_dVjcVb^\d#8V†Yd
YZ jc igZc! V\dc^oVWV aZciVbZciZ! ^ciZgb^cVWaZbZciZ! aZ_dh YZ
idYd Vjm^a^d ]jbVcd# «:h Vigdo 6h† Bdg^g‚º# :[ZXi^kVbZciZ [jZ
ZcXdcigVYdVaVhhZ^hYZaVbVŠVcV!WV_djcicZa!XdcZagdhigd
gZXdcdX^WaZ!eZgdaVeVgiZigVhZgVYZaXg{cZd]jcY^YV!Zae^ZnZa
WgVodYZgZX]dh]VW†Vch^Ydig^ijgVYdh#?ZVc8dXiZVj]VWaVg{YZ
ZaadZchjhEdgigV^ih"HdjkZc^gh#
'HOSKLQHGH*LUDUGLQ
+2125'(%$/=$&
7VaoVX!&'VŠdhbVndg!hZ^ciZgZh‹iVbW^‚cedgZabV\cZi^hbdn
aV]^ecdh^h#AZWg^cYVg{VadaVg\dYZhjk^YVjcVh^cXZgVVb^hiVY#
<Vji^Zg ad ]VW†V hZYjX^Yd \gVX^Vh V hj cdkZaV! BVYZbd^hZaaZ YZ
BVje^c!YZaVXjVaaZZcXVciVWVZa^beZgi^cZciZegZ[VX^dnX^Zgidh
eZghdcV_ZhYZbj_ZgZh]{W^abZciZegZhZciVYdh#
6aVbjZgiZYZ7VaoVX!<Vji^ZgaZg^cY^‹jc]dbZcV_ZejcoVciZZc
jcVdWgVfjZaZhZg†VYZY^XVYV0eZgdYZ_ZbdhVI]‚dfjZ]VWaZYZhj
Vb^\d/¹7VaoVX!XdbdK^h]c!ZaY^dh^cY^d!edhZ†VZaYdcYZaVkViVg!
ZhYZX^gZaYZZcXVgcVgZcXjZgedhY^[ZgZciZhnk^k^gZai^ZbedfjZ
fjZg†V#6jcfjZeVgZX^ZgVh^c\jaVgYZX^gadZceaZcdh^\adM>M!7VaoVX
[jZjck^YZciZ#Hjb‚g^idYZdWhZgkVYdg!hjeZghe^XVX^VYZ[^h^‹ad\d!
hj\Zc^dYZZhXg^idgcdWVhiVceVgVZmea^XVgaV^c[^c^iVkVg^ZYVYYZ
adhYdhdigZhb^ai^edhfjZ_jZ\VcjceVeZab{hdbZcdh^bedgiVciZ
ZcaV8dbZY^V]jbVcV#wacdadhXde^VWV!adhk^k†V^YZVabZciZ°:c
aj\VgYZaVi^ciVfjZ^c[jcYZcVhjhXgZVX^dcZhadhVjidgZhdgY^cVg^dh
jcVkZgYVYZgVhVc\gZgd_VX^gXjaVedghjhkZcVhº#
Cdh XjZciV VYZb{h fjZ Zc VfjZa i^Zbed ¹7VaoVX ZhiVWV bjn
egZdXjeVYdedgaVhX^ZcX^VhdXjaiVh!aVfj^gdbVcX^V!aVXVgidbVcX^V!
hZ aZ ]VW†V ]VWaVYd YZ jcV h^W^aV b{h VhdbWgdhV fjZ aV hZŠdg^iV
AZcdgbVcY!ncdhYZiZgb^c‹!Vh†XdbdVaVhZŠdgVYZ<^gVgY^c!fjZ
[j‚gVbdhVXdchjaiVgXdcZaaVº#
/(-2851$/63,5,7(1o$%5,/
-XGLWK*DXWLHU
&DWXOOH0HQGžV
&)
9Zh\gVX^VYVbZciZ! iZcZbdh aV XdhijbWgZ YZ XdbegdWVg fjZ Zh
gVgdZcXdcigVgZcaVhW^d\gV[†VhYZ]dbWgZhX‚aZWgZh!hjeZgiZcZcX^V
dh^beVi†VedgaVXVjhVZhe†g^iV#
$/)5(''(0866(7
+RQRUž'H%DO]DF
:c Za XVhd YZ I]‚de]^aZ <Vji^Zg! Zh V 6a[gZY YZ BjhhZi! edZiV
YZhVeVgZX^Yd edXd YZhej‚h fjZ aV hZŠdgV YZ <^gVgY^c V fj^Zc
YZWZbdh jc Xdb^Zcod YZ gZhejZhiV# Eg{Xi^XVbZciZ YZ aV b^hbV
ZYVY!VbWdhVjidgZhejWa^XVgdchjheg^bZgdhkZghdhXdchZ^hbZhZh
YZ^ciZgkVadnI]‚dY^h[gjiVWVYZXaVbVcYdadhkZghdhYZhjXdaZ\V
XjnVhZch^W^a^YVYZgVXZgXVcVVaVhjnV#
:hiVbdh Zc &-++! VXVWV YZ VeVgZXZg aV cdkZaV He^g^iZ nI]‚de]^aZ
<Vji^Zg gZX^WZ cjbZgdhdh XdggZdh! ZheZX^VabZciZ kZghdh! gZX^W^Ydh
ZchZh^‹cZhe†g^iV!eZgdYZ_Zbdhb{hW^ZcZmegZhVghZVaedZiV!Zcjc
XdggZd Y^g^\^Yd V aV X‚aZWgZ WV^aVg^cV 8VgadiiV <g^h^! ]ZgbVcV YZ hj
XdbeVŠZgV!eVgVfj^ZcXdbedcZZaWVaaZiYZ<^hZaaZnVfj^Zcegd[ZhV
jcVkZgYVYZgVeVh^‹c!VYZb{haVcdkZaV[jZZhXg^iVZcXVhVYZZaaV/
¹NdiZY^g†VfjZHe^g^iZ!b{hVaa{YZhjZ[ZXida^iZgVg^d!]VegdYjX^Ydjc
Z[ZXidb{\^XdYZadb{hZmigVŠd!idYdZabjcYdYZaVhbZhVh\^gVciZh
nYZadhZhe†g^ijh\daeZVYdgZh]Vh^Ydegd[jcYVbZciZXdcbdk^Yd#HZ
^bV\^cVcfjZhdnjc^c^X^VYdnfjZXdcdoXdZa\gVchZXgZid#:cZhiZ
hZci^Yd]ZgZX^W^YdaVhXVgiVhb{hZmigVŠVbZciZadXVh°=ZgZX^W^Yd
iVbW^‚c YZa digd bjcYd kZghdh YZ6a[gZY YZ BjhhZi hdWgZ He^g^iZ
[ZX]VYdhZa'YZY^X^ZbWgZ#HdcZcXVciVYdgZhniVcW^ZcZcZaZhi^ad
YZaedZiVfjZXdcdX†bjX]d!fjZcdYjYVg†VZcXgZZgadhYZ‚a!h^hZ
ejY^ZgVVYb^i^gfjZjcbjZgid]V\VkZghdhnejZYVigVchb^i^gadhV
jck^kd#BZ[jZgdcZck^VYdhedgjcVbj_Zgb‚Y^jb#=ZadhVfj†/
=ZbZVfj†YZkjZaiV!VjcfjZ]VW†V!hZŠdgV!
?jgVYdVb^h\gVcYZhY^dhZhcjcXVb{hg^bVg#
:hjcig^hiZd[^X^d]VXZg^beg^b^g
AVhdWgVhYZjcVjidggZYjX^YdVaZhiVYdYZVabV#
«=VW†V]j^YdaZ_dhYZkdhdigdhEZgdjcZhe†g^ijZcXVciVYdg
6gg^Zh\VVa]VWaVgYZcdhdigdhZmX^iVgaVhdcg^hV#
E^ZchdfjZhVWZb{hYZadfjZfj^ZgZYZX^g
NfjZZcVa\jcVeVgiZ]VZcXdcigVYdhjZheZXigd#
$OIUHG'H0XVVHW
«JcZheZXigd8^ZgiVbZciZaVVkZcijgVZhZmigVŠV
Ndb^hbdbZgZ†YZZhdXjVcYdZhiVWVZcZhiZbjcYd#
EZgdXjVcYdV[^gbVWVfjZcdXgZ†V
=VW†V!XdbdjchVakVYdg!VXd\^YdVb^WjZc{c\Za#
FjZad]VWg†VVbVYd!XjVcYd!aV[gZciZVbVg^aaZciV!
6ednVYVhdWgZb^bVcd!ZcaVcdX]ZZcaVkZciVcV!
B^Zhe†g^ij!aadgVcYd!WjhXVWVVa\gVcfj^o{h
«NgZXdgg†VVadaZ_dhadhXVbedhYZa^c[^c^id
6b^\dh!ªfj‚ZheZg{^hYZjch^\adh^cXgZZcX^Vh4
8jVcYd]Vn{^hidbVYdkjZhigd[gjidb{h]Zgbdhd!
:a]dbWgZh^ZbegZigdeZoVg{XdcjcVijbWV
H^nVcdi^ZcZZheZgVcoVeVgVhdhiZcZgad#
EZgdZhidhkZghdh!iZY^g{c!«cdhdcYZ‚a
FjZbZ^bedgiVYZhej‚hYZidYd!aVXZchjgVYZakja\d
8jVcYdZhiVWVk^kd!nVcdbZ^bedgiVWV!
8dcb{hgVo‹c!gZ^g‚YZZhd]dnZcY†V#
&DUORWWD*ULVL
:cgZVa^YVY!XjVcYd\VggVeViZVWVb^heZfjZŠdh\VgVWVidh!YZhej‚h
YZ]VWZghdŠVYdfjZbVgX]VWVWV_dadhXVhiVŠdhdbZhZciVWVVa
WdgYZYZaViZggVoV!nVcdbZ^bV\^cVWVadfjZ]VX†V°ªIZVXjZgYVh
/(-2851$/63,5,7(1o$%5,/
&*
YZadhXgj_^Ydh!hjhe^gdh!gj^YdhYZeVhdhngjbdgZhZmigVŠdh
fjZbZdWhZh^dcVgdcZcb^XjVgidYjgVciZaVheg^bZgVh
hZbVcVh YZ b^ ZhiVcX^V Zc Hi# ?ZVc4 :gV fj^o{h fjZ Za
bjcYd^ck^h^WaZfjZg†VZcigVgZcXdbjc^XVX^‹cXdcb^\dn
hZZcXjZcigVZcb^dWgVjcVeVgiZ^ckdajciVg^V°º
wa _Vb{h Xdc[ZhVg†V hj eZgiZcZcX^V V aV XVjhV Zhe†g^iV
n Zh h^c YjYV edg Zaad fjZ BjhhZi ZheZX^[^XV W^Zc fjZ
hVWZbjX]db{hfjZcdfj^ZgZYZX^g#6eVgZXZVfj†bjn
XaVgVbZciZfjZhjk^Z_dVb^\dadXdcdXZW^Zc#
(&26
/26(6&5,725(6,163,5$'26325(/0z6$//z
8108(57248(122/9,'$
686(67$'26'($/0$
:c Z[ZXid XjVcYd :gcZhi ;ZnYZVj cdh ad YZhXg^WZ Zc
hjh hdjkZc^gh ^ci^bZh ‚a [jZ fj^Zc aZ VnjY‹ V ZhXg^W^g
hj cdkZaV hdWgZ aV bdb^V \gVX^Vh V hjh XdcdX^b^Zcid
]^hi‹g^Xdh hdWgZ :\^eid hZ ZcXjZcigV Zc aVh eVaVWgVh
YZI]‚dhj[VaiVYZZheZgVcoVeZgdiVbW^‚chjig^hiZoV
VciZaVbjZgiZ!VhjcidfjZVWdgYVXdc[gZXjZcX^V!cdh
XjZciV:gcZhi;ZnYZVjnXjVcYd‚hiZaZYZXaVgViZcZgaV
ZheZgVcoVYZgZk^k^g!I]‚daZ^ciZggjbeZVh†/
¹«8‹bd ªI Vc cd i^ZcZh hj[^X^ZciZ4 ª9ZhYZ ]VXZ
XVh^ X^cXjZciV VŠdh fjZ Zhi{h Zc Za bjcYd n cd Zhi{h
XVchVYd YZ Vh^hi^g eZgeZijVbZciZ Va ZheZXi{Xjad YZ aV
^bWZX^a^YVYig^jc[VciZ!YZaZiZgcd‚m^idYZadhbZY^dXgZh
n YZ adh bVadh! YZ aV ^bedh^W^a^YVY Zc fjZ ZhiVbdh YZ
]VXZgZaW^Zc4«GZk^k^gdigVeVgiZ:cjcbjcYdY^[ZgZciZ!
ZcdigdeaVcZiV!fj^o{h!eZgdZcZhiVi^ZggV^c[VbZYdcYZ
idYdadfjZZh]ZgbdhdZhVWjX]ZVYd!YdcYZadhWjZcdh
hdcidgijgVYdh°º
H†!hjh^YZVhZgVcZhe†g^iVh#CdYjYVWVYZaV^cbdgiVa^YVY
YZa VabV n hZ ad YZX†V XaVgVbZciZ! eZgd cjcXV YZ_Vg†V
aj\VgZchjha^WgdheVgVhjhhZci^b^Zcidh!‚aZgVeVgi^YVg^d
YZa VgiZ edg Za VgiZ n YZhZVWV Zk^iVg adh egdWaZbVh! Zh
edg Zhd fjZ hZ XdciZciVWV Xdc YVg \gVc ^bedgiVcX^V
V aVh YZhXg^eX^dcZh# 9Z ‚a hZ Y^g†V fjZ eZ^cVWV Xdc aVh
eVaVWgVh#
¹IZc\d b^h ^YZVh egde^Vh! Y^XZ! hdWgZ idYVh aVh XdhVh!
hdWgZ Za VgiZ! aV eda†i^XV! aV [^adhd[†V! aVh gZa^\^dcZh! aV
bdgVa!aVX^ZcX^V!aVX^k^a^oVX^‹c!ZaVh†aaVbVYdegd\gZhd!
^cXajhdhdWgZaV^cYjhig^V°6]dgVW^Zc!ZcXjZcigd^ci^a
]VXZgjcVXde^VfjZcdhZ^beg^bZnZhidnhZ\jgdYZcd
X]dXVgXdccVY^Zº#
ª6 XVjhV YZ hj cdidg^ZYVY ]VWg{ fjZg^Yd \jVgYVg jc
g^cX‹chZXgZid49Vg†VbjZhigVhYZjcZhe†g^ijk^h^dcVg^d
XjVcYdZc&-,%YZXaVg‹/
¹«8‹bdhdcWZhi^Vhadh]dbWgZh«CdhZ]VWg†VedY^Yd
eVhVg h^c ZhiV \jZggV «8j{ciV \ZciZ! fjZ hZ ]VWg†V
YVYd edg [Za^o YZ hZ\j^g k^k^ZcYd! kV V hZg bjZgiV
8j{ciVhXdhVh]ZgbdhVhedYg†Vc]VXZghZXdcZaY^cZgd
fjZhZkVV\VhiVg#CjcXVhZ]VXZgZigdXZYZgXVb^cdV
hj h^\ad ^bejcZbZciZ# :h X^Zgid fjZ b^ZcigVh hdbdh!
h‹adeZY^bdhigVWV_Vgnk^k^gZceVojcdhXdcdigdh°AV
\jZggVnVcdZhi{ZccjZhigVhXdhijbWgZh#:abdk^b^Zcid
jc^kZghVa YZ adh Zhe†g^ijh YZWZ hZg Y^g^\^Yd Zc ZhijY^dh
hZg^dh/ aV X^ZcX^V! Za VgiZ! aV ^cYjhig^V# =Z Vfj† fjZ
YZ egdcid! hZ cdh gZX]VoV Zc eaZcd ]VX^V aVh k^Z_Vh
XdhijbWgZhYZaVWVgWVg^Z#K^k†VbdhZcZah^\adM>MnhZ
cdhkjZakZVaaZkVgV<Zc\^h"@Vcº#
«:hiZZhidYVk†V!Vn!jcaVbZcidYZVXijVa^YVY
/(-2851$/63,5,7(1o$%5,/
G
dWZgi9VaZDlZc!ZgjY^idnZhXg^idgYZgZcdbWgZ!
]V ejWa^XVYd dWgVh eVgV VejciVaVg aV [^adhd[†V
Zhe†g^iV Xdbd ;ddi ;Vaah dc i]Z 7djcYVgn d[ Vcdi]Zg
LdgaY:ae^ZhdWgZZaa†b^iZYZadigdbjcYd#IZhi^\d
YZjcVbVc^[ZhiVX^‹cYZjcVb^\d[VaaZX^Yd!Za9dXidg
@cdm!gZaViV/
¹:a9dXidg@cdmZgVjceZchVYdgegd[jcYdneVgi^YVg^d
gZhjZaidYZaVhiZdg†VhbViZg^Va^hiVh#:hiVWVV[ZXiVYdYZ
jcV cZjbdc†V egd\gZh^kV n! h^ci^ZcYd VXZgXVghZ hj [^c!
]VWaVWV V bZcjYd YZa hjZŠd ZiZgcd fjZ aZ ZheZgVWV
n Xdc ‚a Za dak^Yd ZiZgcd# Cd iZb†V V aV bjZgiZ#Nd aZ
Y^_ZjcY†V/»=V\VbdhjceVXid!YdXidg/h^Vaa{Vgg^WVhZ
h^ZciZjhiZYk^k^g!^ciZciZadedh^WaZeVgVXdbjc^XVgbZ
ZhiVheVaVWgVh/»K^kdidYVk†V¼0¼n‚abZ]^odaVegdbZhV
hdaZbcZbZciZ° 9Zhej‚h YZ hj bjZgiZ! nd ZheZgVWV
^beVX^ZciZ fjZ bZ Y^ZgV cdi^X^Vh hjnVh# :hZ YZhZd hZ
VXZcij‹b{hVaVaaZ\VYVVcjZhigVX^jYVYYZjcb‚Y^jb
YZbViZg^Va^oVX^dcZhfjZkZc†VYZaZhiZYZ6b‚g^XV!nZc
XjndXVg{XiZghZg^dndiZc†VjcVXdc[^VcoVVWhdajiVº#
HZ ^ciZci‹ Za ZmeZg^bZcid YZ Xdbjc^XVX^‹c Xdc VfjZa
Zhe†g^ijedgbZY^dYZaVZhXg^ijgVY^gZXiVhdWgZjcVe^oVggV#
¹A^be^‚ jcV e^oVggV! aZ ejhZ jc e^oVgg†c n Xdadfj‚ aV
e^oVggVXdcigVaVhjeZg[^X^Z^ciZg^dgYZaVbZhV#:ab‚Y^jb
ejhdjcVYZhjhbVcdhhdWgZaVb†V!YZWV_dYZaVbZhV
naVdigVZcX^bV°:hXjX]VbdhZagj^YdYZae^oVgg†cfjZ
gVhXVWV hdWgZ aV e^oVggV! n Va aZkVciVgaV! ZcXdcigVbdh
aVhh^\j^ZciZha†cZVh/»6b^\dDlZc!adh[Zc‹bZcdhfjZ
cdhd[gZXZaVcVijgVaZoVhdc^ggZh^hi^WaZh!nZaVh†aaVbVYd
[^a‹hd[d! fjZ V bZcjYd ajX]V XdcigV jc ]ZX]d fjZ
XdcigVhiVhjhiZdg†Vh[Vkdg^iVh!VXVWVedghZgaVcoVYdV
jc dX‚Vcd YZ YjYVh
Z^cXZgi^YjbWgZ#:hiZ
cd Zh egZX^hVbZciZ
b^ XVhd! VjcfjZ b^h
Vci^\jVh ^YZVh hdWgZ
aV k^YV [jijgV Zhi‚c
V]dgV igVhidgcVYVh
YZ Vgg^WV VWV_d/ eZgd
aZ Xdc[^Zhd fjZ b^
YZh^ajh^‹c ]V h^Yd
V\gVYVWaZ! n hdn [Za^o
Vb^\d b†d YZ edYZg
YZX^gaZ/»k^kdidYVk†V¼#
HjVb^\dh^ZbegZ#
L^aa^Vb@cdmº
&+
'266,(5
/26(6&5,725(6,163,5$'26325(/0z6$//z
SRU
-2&(/<1(&+$5/(6
/$129(/$$&78$/
$FWXDOPHQWH OR SDUDQRUPDO HV H[SORWDGR HQ ODV QRYHODV SXHV HV XQ WHPD TXH VHGXFH HO
S®EOLFR/RVDXWRUHVUHODWDQKLVWRULDVGHUHHQFDUQDFLRQHVIDQWDVPDVGHVFULSFLRQHVGHOP–V
DOO–HKLVWRULDVGHODYLGDGHVSXžVGHODYLGDP–VRPHQRVIDQWDVLRVDV
A
Va^iZgVijgV[Vci{hi^XVZhi{eaV\VYVYZgZaVidhdXjaidh!
XjZcidh n aZnZcYVh! YdcYZ hZ XgjoVc aV Wgj_Zg†V! aV
bV\^V!adZmigVŠdnad^ggVX^dcVa#:ahjZŠdnaVgZVa^YVY!
adhdWgZcVijgVanadcVijgVahZbZoXaVcnhZZcigZbZoXaVc#
6XijVabZciZ! ad eVgVcdgbVa Zh ZmeadiVYd Zc aVh cdkZaVh
ejZhZhjciZbVfjZhZYjXZZaeWa^Xd#AdhVjidgZhgZaViVc
]^hidg^Vh YZ gZZcXVgcVX^dcZh! [VciVhbVh! YZhXg^eX^dcZh
YZa b{h Vaa{ Z ]^hidg^Vh YZ aV k^YV YZhej‚h YZ aV k^YV!
b{h d bZcdh [VciVh^dhVh eVgV cdhdigdh adh Zhe†g^iVh! fjZ
XdcdXZbdh aV VjiZci^X^YVY YZ Zhidh [Zc‹bZcdh# 8jVcYd
aVh cdkZaVh YZhXg^WZc ]ZX]dh Zhe†g^iVh! Vjc XjVcYd cd hZ
gZ[^ZgVcVaZhe^g^i^hbd!hjhX^iVcZbdX^dcZh!^ciZggd\VciZhn
Y^hXjh^dcZhnZhdZhjceg^bZgeVhd!h^ZhiVhdWgVhYZhe^ZgiVc
aVh XdcX^ZcX^Vh# 8dc \gVc [gZXjZcX^V adh iZbVh ji^a^oVYdh
hdc dXVh^dcZh eVgV ZhXg^W^g jcV ]^hidg^V [Vci{hi^XV# Digdh
ZhXg^idgZhXdcdXZcjcedXdb{hZaiZbVn]VXZc gZhVaiVg
^YZVhfjZVkZXZhhdcXZgXVcVhYZaVh^YZVhZhe†g^iVh#
+HDTX¡UHV­PHQHVGHDOJXQDVQRYHODVGH
0DUF/Y\!ZhXg^idg[gVcX‚hcVX^YdZa&+YZdXijWgZYZ
&.+&Zc7djad\cZ7^aaVcXdjgi#
;ji_Y½ƒjW_jlhW_#Lekih[le_h
Nh^[jZgVX^Zgid"kdakZgVkZgiZ
AVjgZc!b‚Y^Xd^ciZgcdYZaHVc;gVcX^hXdBZbdg^Va=dhe^iVa!
ZhjcV_dkZcVXi^kV!bjnV\jhid!VeVh^dcVYVedghjd[^X^d#
JcVbVŠVcV!YZX^YZYVgjceVhZdaZ_dhYZaVX^jYVY!ndXjggZ
Za VXX^YZciZ! hj kZ]†Xjad YV kVg^Vh kjZaiVh YZ XVbeVcV# HZ
XdbegjZWVaVbjZgiZXZgZWgVanZaaVXVZZcjcXdbVegd[jcYd#
6gi]jg!ZcaVigZ^ciZcVnh^ZbegZhdaiZgdZhVgfj^iZXid!igVWV_V
XdchjVhdX^VYdnVb^\d!EVja#HjXVb^cdXgjoVg{ZaYZAVjgZc
YZjcVbVcZgVXjg^dhV#CdZcZa]dhe^iVa!h^cdZcZaVgbVg^d
YZaXjVgidYZWVŠdYZhjVeVgiVbZcid#6gi]jg!fjZVXVWVYZ
^chiVaVghZ Vaa†! aV YZhXjWgZ jcV iVgYZ idbVcYd jc WVŠd# Hj
XjZgedZhi{ZcXdbVZcZa]dhe^iVanhjYdWaZZchjVci^\jd
VeVgiVbZcid# Edg hjejZhid! cVXZ jcV ]ZgbdhV ]^hidg^V YZ
VbdgZcigZAVjgZcnZa_dkZcVgfj^iZXidVfj^ZchjhVb^\dh
Zbe^ZoVcVXdch^YZgVgXdbdjcigVhidgcVYd#;dgodhVbZciZ!
]VWaV hdad# :h Za c^Xd fjZ kZ Za XjZged YZ AVjgZc! aV dnZ
n aV idXV# EZgd! Zc Za ]dhe^iVa! adh b‚Y^Xdh Xdch^YZgVc aV
ZjiVcVh^V#8db^ZcoVjcVXVggZgVXdcigVZagZad_!VeZhVgYZ
aVY^[^XjaiVYYZaViVgZV#:aVjidgZmeadgVV[dcYdZhVodcVYZ
hdbWgV X^Zci†[^XV fjZ Zh Za XdbV egd[jcYd#6a\jcdh cd hZ
hVakVcb^ZcigVhfjZdigdhhZYZhe^ZgiVc!VkZXZhYZhej‚hYZ
bjX]†h^bdhVŠdh#ªFj‚ejZYZhjXZYZgYjgVciZZhZeZg†dYd
YZ¹igVch^X^‹cº YdcYZ cd hZ Zhi{ c^ bjZgid c^ k^kd4Kdjh
gZkd^gZhaVXdci^cjVX^‹cYZ:ih^X¼‚iV^ikgV^hZZcXjZcigVc
adheZghdcV_ZhYZaVcdkZaVVciZg^dg#H^aVk^YVaZd[gZX^ZgVV
6gi]jgnVAVjgZcjcVhZ\jcYVdedgijc^YVYYZkdakZgVkZghZ!
ªhVWg†VcidbVgidYdhadhg^Zh\dheVgVVegdkZX]VgaV4
BWfheY^W_d[\e_iAVeg‹m^bVkZo
?dcVi]Vc<VgYcZgZhZmeZgidZce^cijgVYZah^\adM>Mnbjn
eVgi^XjaVgbZciZZcjce^cidggjhd!KaVY^b^gGVYh`^c#Egdcid
hZ XVhVg{ Xdc hj egdbZi^YV6ccV0 hj bZ_dg Vb^\d! EZiZg
<lZa![jcX^dcVg^diVhVYdg!i^ZcZ\gVcYZhegZdXjeVX^dcZhZc
ZaeaVcdegd[Zh^dcVanXjZciVXdcaVkZciVYZX^cXdXjVYgdh
YZa e^cidg egZ[Zg^Yd YZ hj Vb^\d eVgV gZaVcoVg hj XVggZgV#
:cidcXZhVbWdhkVcVAdcYgZhYdcYZhZg{cZmejZhiVhaVh
iZaVh#:hVaa†YdcYZ?dcVi]VcXdcdXZV8aVgV!fjZXdbd‚aZh
jcVVeVh^dcVYVYZaVhdWgVhYZGVYh`^c#JcdYZadhXjVYgdh
Zc XjZhi^‹c YZWZg†V hZg aV dWgV bVZhigV YZ aV XdaZXX^‹c/
AV_dkZcXdcZakZhi^Ydgd_d#:hiZXjVYgdZhjcVkZgYVYZgV
aZnZcYV ejZh! ]Vn fjZ hVWZg fjZKaVY^b^g GVYh`^c nV cd
e^ciVWVZagdhigdYZaVhbj_ZgZhncdji^a^oVWVZagd_dZchjh
XjVYgdh!b^ZcigVhfjZZhiZVciZg^dgbZciZX^iVYdXdciZc†V
jci^ciZYZjcgd_degd[jcYdYZhXdcdX^Yd#?dcVi]Vcn8aVgV
Zhi{c XdckZcX^Ydh YZ ]VWZghZ XdcdX^Yd nV# EZgd! ªY‹cYZ
n Xj{cYd4 JW^XVYV Zc Za XVbed YZ aV e^cijgV n YZ ad
/(-2851$/63,5,7(1o$%5,/
&,
eVgVcdgbVa!ZhiV]^hidg^V]VWaVYZjcVbdgfjZ]VeVhVYdVigVk‚h
YZ aV bjZgiZ n aVh gZZcXVgcVX^dcZh#IdYdh Zhidh eZghdcV_Zh nV hZ
]Vc XdcdX^Yd Zc k^YVh VciZg^dgZh# JcV eVgZ_V YZ ZcVbdgVYdh hZ
ZcXjZcigV h^\ad igVh h^\ad# EZgd! Zc Za eVhVYd! hj Vbdg hZ \gVc_Z‹
ZcZb^\dh#JcVeZghdcV^ciZciVkZc\VghZ!nZcXVYV‚edXV!]VhVW^Yd
ZcXdcigVgadhnXdcigVg^VghjhYZhi^cdh#
6HSWMRXUVSRXUXQHWHUQLW
H^ZiZY†VheVgVjcVZiZgc^YVY
wai^ZcZZaZcXVcidYZaY^VWad#:aaVi^ZcZaV[jZgoVYZadh{c\ZaZh#EVgV
edcZgi‚gb^cdVhjZiZgcVg^kVa^YVY!9^dhnAjX^[ZghZ]VcaVcoVYdjc
ai^bdYZhV[†d#:ck†VcZcb^h^‹cVhjhYdhbZ_dgZhV\ZciZh#AjXVhn
Od[^ViZcYg{cZcidcXZhh^ZiZY†VhhdWgZaVi^ZggVeVgV]VXZgig^jc[Vg
hjWVcYdnYZX^Y^gfj^Zc!h^Za7^ZcdZaBVa!Y^g^\^g{Vadh]dbWgZh#
6adg\Vc^oVgZhiVVejZhiVVWhjgYV!9^dhnAjX^[Zgad]VW†VcegZk^hid
idYdZmXZeidjcVXdhV#FjZZa{c\ZanZaYZbdc^dhZXdcdX^ZgVc#
:cigZOd[^V!aVb{h]ZgbdhVYZadh{c\ZaZhnAjXVh!Zab{hiZgg^WaZ!hZ
_jZ\VZaedgkZc^gYZabjcYdZcjcYjZadVeVh^dcVYdnVeVh^dcVciZ
YZh^ZiZY†Vhnh^ZiZcdX]Zh#
+HDTX¡UHV­PHQHVGHDOJXQDVQRYHODVGH
%HUQDUG:HEHU!ZhXg^idg!cVX^YdVIdjadjhZZa&-YZ
hZei^ZbWgZYZ&.+&#
B[iJ^WdWjedWkj[i
:hiZ a^Wgd! fjZ ejZYZ XVa^[^XVghZ YZ cdkZaV X^Zci†[^Xd"[^adh‹[^XV!
Xdc jc \gVcd YZ [VciVh†V! cdh aaZkV Va YZhXjWg^b^Zcid YZa ai^bd
Xdci^cZciZ^cZmeadgVYd!aVbjZgiZ#
IVcVidcVjiV! eVaVWgV YZg^kVYV YZ ¹iVcVidad\†Vº! k^ZcZ YZa \g^Z\d
I]VcVidhY^dhYZaVbjZgiZncVji^hcVkZ\VciZnh^\c^[^XVejZh
cVkZ\VciZdZmeadgVYdgYZaVbjZgiZ#:a]dbWgZad]VZmeadgVYdidYd/
ZabjcYdYZaZheVX^d!ZabjcYdhjWbVg^cd!ZabjcYdhjWiZgg{cZd0h^c
ZbWVg\daZ[VaiVZaXdcdX^b^ZcidYZjcbjcYd/ZaXdci^cZciZYZadh
bjZgidh#=ZVfj†aVeg‹m^bV[gdciZgV#:hiVcdkZaVXjZciVaV]^hidg^V
YZjc^ckZhi^\VYdg!B^X]VZaE^chdc!nYZhjVb^\dGVdjaGVodgWV`fjZ
ZmeadgVg{cZa×ai^bd8dci^cZciZ!ji^a^oVcYdi‚Xc^XVhYZaVbZY^X^cV
n YZ aV Vhigdc{ji^XV# :hiV VkZcijgV aZh XdcYjX^g{ V igVk‚h YZ aVh
gZ\^dcZhYZaXdci^cZciZYZadhbjZgidh]VX^VaVX‚aZWgZajo#<gVX^Vh
Vhjh¹ZmeadgVYdgZhº!adhIVcVidcVjiVhkdajciVg^dhfjZVgg^Zh\Vchjh
k^YVh!cjZhigdhYdh]‚gdZhkVcV]VXZggZigdXZYZgegd\gZh^kVbZciZ
aVheVaVWgVhIZggV^cXd\c^iVeVgVYZhXjWg^gadhb^hiZg^dhYZaVbjZgiZ#
:adW_Zi^kdXdch^hiZZc^bV\^cVgjcVk^h^‹caV^XVYZaVbjZgiZnadh
ZkZcijVaZh Z[ZXidh YZ aV gZkZaVX^‹c YZ hj b^hiZg^d hdWgZ cjZhigVh
hdX^ZYVYZh VXijVaZh# :a a^Wgd Zhi{ hVae^XVYd YZ cjbZgdhdh iZmidh
hV\gVYdh ZmigV†Ydh YZ aVh b^idad\†Vh! gZa^\^dcZh n Xdhbd\dc†Vh YZa
bjcYdZciZgd!ZaA^Wgdi^WZiVcdYZadhBjZgidh!ZaA^WgdZ\^eX^dYZ
adhBjZgidh°!eZgdiVbW^‚cYZaVhb^idad\†VhniZmidhhV\gVYdhYZ
XVh^idYVhaVhgZa^\^dcZhfjZYZhYZh^ZbegZ^ciZciVcYVggZhejZhiVh
hdWgZ Za ai^bd k^V_Z n Za ¹kZgYVYZgdº EVgV†hd# EdXd V edXd! adh
iVcVidcVjiVhigVoVcaVXVgiV\Zd\g{[^XVYZZhZbjcYdYZhXdcdX^Yd
n YZhXjWgZc eV^hV_Zh ^cbZchdh n bVgVk^aadhdh# :a i‚gb^cd ¹iZggV
^cXd\c^iVºgZigdXZYZb^ZcigVhegd\gZhVZaXdcdX^b^ZcidYZadfjZcdh
k^ZcZYZhej‚hYZ]VWZgZm]VaVYdcjZhigdai^bdhjhe^gd#
DejWZ[bWkjeh"8[hdWhZM[X[h0
¹9dh VŠdh n bZY^d YZ ^ckZhi^\VX^‹c hdWgZ aV bjZgiZ! hdWgZ adh
b†hi^Xdh!hdWgZaVhgZa^\^dcZh#AZhI]VcVidcVjiZh!ZhiVbW^‚cb^a^Wgd
b{hghi^Xd#8^ZgidheVhV_Zh[jZgdcZhXg^idhZcZhXg^ijgVVjidb{i^XV#
:h YZX^g fjZ cd ]VW†V ^ciZcX^‹c YZ ^ciZ\gVg Za gZaVid V jcV ^cig^\V!
/(-2851$/63,5,7(1o$%5,/
0DUF/HY\
&-
b^h YZYdh Xdgg†Vc hdadh hdWgZ Za iZXaVYd n nd gZaZ†V YZhej‚h eVgV
YZhXjWg^gadfjZ]VW†VZhXg^id#=ZXVbW^VYdbjnedXdaVZhigjXijgV
YZaVeg^bZgVbda^ZcYV#HZcX^aaVbZciZ!edgfjZcdXdbegZcY†VW^Zc
edgfj‚]VW†VZhXg^idZhdVh†nVfjZaadbZ^cig^\VWV#6jcV]dgV!ZhiZ
a^Wgd Z_ZgXZ hdWgZ b† jcV ZmigVŠV [VhX^cVX^‹c# Edg digV eVgiZ! b{h
iVgYZ!XdbegZcY†edgfj‚]VW†VgZYVXiVYdVh†X^ZgidheVhV_Zh#9ZkZo
Zc XjVcYd! ZcXjZcigd aZXidgZh fjZ bZ ]VWaVc YZ adhI]VcVh n fjZ
eVgZXZc]VWZgXdbegZcY^Ydb{hXdhVhfjZndYZZhiZa^Wgd!adXjVa
bZY^k^ZgiZbjX]d#:hZZhiVbW^‚cZaeaVXZgYZaVZhXg^ijgV#
AdhI]VcVh!YZW^YdVhjgZaVi^kd[gVXVhdXdbZgX^VahZ]VXdckZgi^YdZc
b^eZfjZŠda^WgdXd_d#Nh^cZbWVg\dZhedgZafjZeVgVY‹_^XVbZciZ
h^Zcidb{hXVg^Šdº#
:aa^Wgd[dgbVeVgiZYZaVIg^ad\†VYZadhIVcVidcVjiVhYZaVfjZZh
Zaeg^bZgkdajbZc#A¼:be^gZYZh6c\Zh:a^beZg^dYZadhÍc\ZaZhn
CdjhaZh9^ZjmCdhdigdhadh9^dhZhXdbeaZiVcZaX^Xad#
%HUQDUG:HEHU
B½;cf_h[Z[i7d][i:a^beZg^dYZadhÍc\ZaZh
ªFjZe^ZchVcadh{c\ZaZhYZcdhdigdh4ª8j{aZhhjk^h^‹cYZcjZhigV
ZheZX^ZhdWgZaVi^ZggV4B^X]VZaE^chdc!Zm"iVcVidcVjiV!]Vad\gVYd
eVhVg YZa digd aVYd# 9Z ]jbVcd gZZcXVgcVYd! hZ ]V XdckZgi^Yd Zc
{c\ZanZhZZhjckZgYVYZgdigVWV_dVi^ZbedXdbeaZid#:aaj\VgYZ
Z_ZgX^X^dZhZaEVgV†hd#EVhVYdZaeg^bZg^beVXid!B^X]VZahZYVXjZciV
YZfjZhZgjc{c\ZacdZhjc_jZ\dYZeaVXZg#6YZb{hfjZi^ZcZVhj
XVg\dVigZhbdgiVaZhbjniZgXdh#KZcjh!jcVVXig^ocdgiZVbZg^XVcV
k†Xi^bVYZb^\gVŠVh!>\dg!jchdaYVYdgjhdgZnYZaed`Zgn?VXfjZh!jc
Vc\jhi^VYdXg‹c^Xd#EdgVŠVY^YjgV!hjbZcidg:YbdcYLZaahaZ]V
ZheZX^[^XVYdW^ZcfjZhjYZWZgYZ{c\ZaZgVXjbea^gidYdhhjhkdidh!
«edg VWZggVciZh fjZ [jZgVc EZgd B^X]VZa! ^chVX^VWaZ ZmeadgVYdg!
XdchZgkVYZhjk^YVVciZg^dgjc\jhidedgaVVkZcijgV#Íc\ZagZWZaYZ!
hZ]V[^_VYddigVbZiV/YZhXjWg^gZab{hVaa{nZab{hVaa{YZab{hVaa{#
Nfj^o{heZcZigVgZabjcYdVcb{hVgg^WV!ZaYZadhY^dhZh#
Dekib[i:_[knCdhdhigdhadh9^dhZh
:a]‚gdZYZaV]^hidg^VZhh^ZbegZB^X]VZaE^chdcfj^Zc!YZhej‚hYZ
]VWZgh^Ydjc]jbVcdAdhIVcVidcVjiVhnjc{c\Za!:a>beZg^dYZ
adhÍc\ZaZh!hZ]VXdckZgi^Yd[^cVabZciZZcjc¹VajbcdY^dhº#:hi{
V]dgVZcVa\caj\VgYZajc^kZghd!ZcaV^haVYZ6ZYZc#8VYVY†V!jcY^dh
Y^[ZgZciZZchZŠVVZhidhcjZkdhVajbcdhX‹bd[dgbVgjcbjcYd
eVgVVa\cY†VXdckZgi^ghZVhjkZoZcjcY^dh#AVXdbeZiZcX^VZhYjgV
ZcZhZbjcYd#6h†!XVYVY†V!adhai^bdhYZaVXaVhZhdcZa^b^cVYdh!
aaZkVYdhedgadhXZciVjgdh#6YZb{hYZZhd!jcb^hiZg^dhd¹9Z^X^YVº
VhZh^cd YZ Y^dhZh ]VXZ ZhigV\dh ZcigZ adh &)) Vajbcdh YZ ZhiV
cjZkVegdbdX^‹cYZVegZcY^XZhYZY^dhZh#
5HVXPHQGHODQRYHODGH'LGLHU+DUQHUR
&DXZHODHUW/D9LHLQWHUGLWHAVK^YVegd]^W^YV#
'LGLHU9DQ&DXZHODHUW
9^Y^Zg=VgcZgd8VjlZaVZgiZhjcZhXg^idgcVX^YdZcC^oVZc&.+%#
?VXfjZh AdgbZVj hZ YZhe^ZgiV jcV bVŠVcV! bjZgid Zc hj XVbV#
DWhZgkV hj XjZged YZhYZ ad Vaid YZa kZci^aVYdg YZ hj gZbdafjZ#
6hjaVYd!hjVbVciZYjZgbZea{X^YVbZciZ#:aaZXidgZkdajX^dcV
VigVk‚hYZaVb^gVYVYZabjZgidfjZhZfjZYVZc\VcX]VYdVaV
k^YVYZadhk^kdhnnVcdejZYZeVgi^gYZZhiZbjcYd#?VXfjZhkV
V YZVbWjaVg YZ jc aj\Vg V digd gZhedcY^ZcYd V aVh aaVbVYVh YZ
adhk^kdh#9ZhXjWg^g{fjZaVheZghdcVhVaVhfjZVbVWV!aZVbVWVc
iVbW^‚c YZ hj bVcZgV VjcfjZ ‚a cd hZ Y^ZgV XjZciV#6a\d bjn
[jZgiZhZZhiVWaZXZZcidcXZhZcigZ?VXfjZhnhjheVg^ZciZhXjVcYd
idbVXdcX^ZcX^VYZhjk^YVeVhVYV#
/(-2851$/63,5,7(1o$%5,/
&.
(&26
/26(6&5,725(6,163,5$'26325(/0z6$//z
SRU
-2&(/<1(&+$5/(6
/$129(/$
:
migVXid YZ jc
bZchV_ZYZ8]VgaZh
9^X`ZchZc&.-./
¹:h egZX^hd VbVg V
aV cdkZaV! Zh egZX^hd
hVWdgZVgaVcdkZaV#:c
gZVa^YVY! aV [‹gbjaV
cdkZaZhXVZmegZhVadh
Y^[ZgZciZh ZhiVYdh
V[ZXi^kdhYZaVcVij"
gVaZoV ]jbVcV! Y^[Z"
gZciZh ‚edXVh! Y^[ZgZciZh aj\VgZh! Y^[ZgZciZh h^ijV"
X^dcZh#AVcdkZaVZmegZhVaVkZgYVYYZaVcVijgVaZoVYZ
adh]dbWgZh#:megZhVaVkZgYVYYZaXVg{XiZgYZa^cY^"
k^Yjd!jW^XVYdedgZaVjidgZcjcXdciZmidYZ[^c^Yd#Cd
ZhjcVbZci^gV!aVcdkZaVcdZhjcVhjedh^X^‹c!ZhjcV
ZmegZh^‹cZhZcX^VaYZkjZhigVhcVijgVaZoVhegd[jcYVh!
ZhYZX^gYZkjZhigVhcVijgVaZoVhZhe^g^ijVaZh#:hegZX^hd
hdŠVgfjZaVcdkZaVhZViVbW^‚cjcbdYdYZYZhXj"
Wg^gVa]dbWgZ!YZYZhXjWg^ghjVabV!YZYZhXjWg^gad
fjZhZ]VXdckZc^YdZcaaVbVgZckjZhigVaZc\jViVc
]ZgbdhV/adhZhiVYdhYZVabV#:hedgZhdfjZdh^ck^id
VaZZg#:hedgZhdfjZdh^ck^id![gVcXZhZh!VaZZgiVcid
b{hedgXjVcidcdXVgZX‚^hYZVjidgZhncdkZa^hiVh
bjnX‚aZWgZhnYZ\gVciVaZcidº#
/$,163,5$&,Š1
ªFjZ Zh aV ^che^gVX^‹c YZhYZ Za ejcid YZ k^hiV
Zhe†g^iV4:hiVegZ\jciVhZaZ]^odV<VWg^Za9ZaVccZ
fj^ZcgZhedcY^‹Vh†/¹:hbjnX^ZgidfjZ]VnVgi^hiVh
YZ \gVc iVaZcid fjZ h‹ad i^ZcZc fjZ gZXjgg^g V aV
[jZgoVYZa^bV\^cVg^d!VaV[jZgoVYZaVgZ[aZm^‹ceVgV
aVXdchigjXX^‹c^ciZa^\ZciZnVbdgdhVYZhjhdWgVh
fjZXdbeVgiZcXdcZaeWa^Xd#EZgd!Zm^hiZciVbW^‚c
Vgi^hiVhfjZ!ZcZhiZXVbed!ZcXjZcigVc^che^gVX^‹c
YjgVciZaVXdi^Y^VcVYZh^cXdgedgVX^‹ccdXijgcVncd
YZ_Vc ZcidcXZh YZ igVhaVYVgaV Y^gZXiVbZciZ V hjh
gZVa^oVX^dcZh#:m^hiZciVbW^‚cadhVgi^hiVhfjZZcigVc
Zc Xdbjc^XVX^‹c Xdc Za b{h Vaa{ n fjZ WjhXVc
ZmegZhVg Xdc idYV cVijgVa^YVY ZhV Xdbjc^XVX^‹c
YZcigdYZhjegd[Zh^‹cº#
/(-2851$/63,5,7(1o$%5,/
µ6(/(9$17$%$35(6$
'(81$),(%5('(,163,5$&,Š1¹¶
A
V cdkZaV A¼6kZc^g :a edgkZc^g YZ :j\ƒcZ 7dccZbƒgZ
&-&("&-.( Zh jcV dWgV YZhi^cVYV V kja\Vg^oVg adh
eg^cX^e^dh YZ aV [^adhd[†V Zhe†g^iV n [jZ ZhXg^iV YZhej‚h jc
ZcXjZcigdgZVaXdcjc_dkZcb‚Y^jbWgZi‹c#
¹EjYZ kZgad! VŠVYZ Va Vjidg! n b^ WjZcV ZhigZaaV fj^hd
fjZ aZ [jZgV h^be{i^Xd# :gV jc _dkZc YZ kZ^ci^X^cXd VŠdh
Va XjVa hj eVYgZ! g^Xd XVbeZh^cd YZa XVci‹c! ]VW†V ]ZX]d
YVg X^ZgiV ZYjXVX^‹c! hZ\c bZ ]VW†V Y^X]d b^ Vc[^ig^‹c0
h^beaZ! bZaVcX‹a^Xd n hdŠVYdg! ^bejahVcYd aV WdcYVY
]VhiVaVZmXZaZcX^V!nYdiVYdYZjciZbeZgVbZcidZcfjZ
Zah^hiZbVcZgk^dhdYdb^cVWVh^cXdcigVeZhd#HZaZkVciVWV
Va VaWV! egZhV YZ jcV [^ZWgZ YZ ^che^gVX^‹c fjZ cd edY†V
Ydb^cVg!nYZggVbVWVVbVgZhhdWgZZaeVeZaZmigVŠVh^YZVh
fjZWgdiVWVcYZh†b^hbVhZchjXZgZWgd!VZheVaYVhYZ‚a
nVbZcjYdVhjeZhVg#Adk^igVWV_VcYd#:cZaZheVX^dYZ
jcV]dgV!XjWg†V^ckVg^VWaZbZciZhjXjVYZgcdYZfj^cXZd
Y^ZX^h‚^he{\^cVhYZZhXg^ijgV!h^ckVX^aVX^‹c!h^ciVX]VYjgVh!
h^cYZiZcZghZjchZ\jcYdVWjhXVgjcV^YZV!jcV[gVhZ!jcV
eVaVWgV#:gVjc\g^[dVW^Zgid!YZYdcYZWgdiVWVaV^che^gVX^‹c
ZcX]dggdh^ZbegZ^\jVa°ºAdhiZmidhhZVbdcidcVWVcZcjc
VgbVg^dfjZ‚aaZbdhig‹VaVjidg¹8dchiVWVYZjcVhY^ZX^h^ZiZ
b^ae{\^cVh!ZhXg^iVhZcXjVigdVŠdh#=VW†VVaa†jcXZciZcVg
YZXjZcidhncdkZaVh!igViVYdhhdWgZY^kZghdhiZbVh!gZXZiVh
b‚Y^XVhndigVhb{m^bVh°º:cjcVXVgiVY^g^\^YVVaVGZkjZ
He^g^iZ!:j\ƒcZ7dccZbƒgZXdc[^gbVfjZcdZgVZhe†g^iVn
fjZZa]^hidg^VYdg!ajZ\dYZZhZeVgi^XjaVgZcXjZcigd!ejYd
dWhZgkVgnhVXVgVaVajoadhZhXg^idhbZY^bc^XdhYZa_dkZc#
6ŠVYZ/ ¹>bedgiV bjX]d fjZ Zhidh hZXgZidh YZ adh XjVaZh
Za VoVg bZ ]V ]ZX]d YZedh^iVg^d! cd bjZgVc Xdcb^\d! h^
Xdci^ZcZcVa\dhZg^ZYVY!nfjZhZhZeVh^Zm^hiZcgZaVX^dcZh
edh^WaZhZcigZaVh^ciZa^\ZcX^VhhjeZg^dgZhYZadigdaVYdYZaV
k^YVnaVh^ciZa^\ZcX^VhY‹X^aZhYZ‚hiZ0nXgZdfjZhZg†Vbjn
^bedgiVciZeVgVcdhdigdhZciVWaVggZaVX^dcZhXVYVkZob{h
hZ\j^YVhXdcZhidhbjZgidhYZWjZcVkdajciVYfjZeVgZXZc
Y^hejZhidhVegZhiVgcdhhZbZ_VciZhhZgk^X^dhº#
'(3$8/%2',(5(63…5,7$
9
ZWZbdhVEVja7dY^ZgaVX‚aZWgZK^aaVYjH^aZcXZfjZZh
dW_ZidYZjcVgi†XjadZcZhiVgZk^hiV#EZgdZhiVcdZhaV
c^XVdWgVfjZZhiZVjidgZhXg^W^‹#HZaZYZWZ^\jVabZciZaV
BVcd^gYZhDbWgZhBVch^‹cYZaVhHdbWgVhZcaVfjZaVh
[VXjaiVYZhbZY^bc^XVhYZjcVc^ŠVYZdX]dVŠdheZgb^iZc
gZhdakZgjcb^hiZg^dhdZc^\bVnXdbegZcYZgadfjZhjXZY^‹
*%VŠdhVciZhVadhgZX^‚cXVhVYdhfjZYZhVeVgZX^ZgdcaV
iVgYZ YZ hj WdYV h^c c^c\jcV gVo‹c n h^c fjZ cjcXV hZ
ZcXdcigVgVchjhXjZgedh#
'%
'266,(5
/26(6&5,725(6,163,5$'26325(/0z6$//z
SRU
-2&(/<1(&+$5/(6
/$6,'($6(63…5,7$6
'(*(25*(6$1'
8Q WLHPSR HQ TXH HVWDQGR FXPSOLGD OD QHFHVDULD REUD GH GHVWUXFFL§Q VH EXVFDU–
FXLGDGRVDPHQWHHQWUHORVWUR]RVGHOSDVDGRXQDYHUGDGTXHQRSXHGHSHUGHUVH
:
a&YZ_ja^dYZ&-%)cVX†VZcEVg†h6jgdgV9je^c!b{h
XdcdX^YVWV_dZacdbWgZYZ<Zdg\ZHVcY#IgZhbZhZh
b{hiVgYZ!Za(YZdXijWgZ!ZcAndc!aVhZŠdgV?ZVccZ
G^kV^a YVWV V ajo Va eZfjZŠd 9Zc^oVgY =^eedaniZ A‚dc
G^kV^a! h^c hdheZX]Vg Zc ad b{h b†c^bd fjZ ZhiZ ai^bd
hZ XdckZgi^g†V Zc Za X‚aZWgZ 6aaVc @VgYZX# 6YZb{h YZ hj
VŠdYZcVX^b^Zcid!ZhidhYdheZghdcV_Zhi^ZcZcZcXdbc
hjh^YZVhgZheZXidVaV^cbdgiVa^YVY!aVeZg[ZXi^W^a^YVYYZa
VabVnaVgZZcXVgcVX^‹c!^YZVhVeVgi^gYZaVhXjVaZh6aaVc
@VgYZX [jcYVg†V! Xdbd hVWZbdh! aV [^adhd[†V Zhe†g^iV! ^YZVh
fjZ <Zdg\Z HVcY YZhZ‹ XdbeVgi^g Xdc hjh aZXidgZh Zc
cjbZgdhVhdWgVh#
/RVRU¡JHQHV\ODWUD\HFWRULDHVSLULWXDO
GH*HRUJH6DQG
¹IVakZob^k^YVZciZgVhZXdchjbVWjhXVcYdaVkZgYVY!h^c
fjZaaZ\jZVVXaVgVgjchdadVheZXidºZhXg^WZ<Zdg\ZHVcY
fj^Zc!ZcZ[ZXid!cdYZ_Vg{YZVeVh^dcVghZedgaVajX]VYZaVh
^YZVh!ZaVXde^dYZZhe^g^ijVa^YVYnaVWhfjZYV^cXVchVWaZ
YZ9^dh#:hZVXde^dijkdhjdg^\ZcbjniZbegVcd#
:ceg^bZgaj\Vg!aV^c[VcX^VYZVfjZaaVfjZidYVk†VaaZkVZa
YjaXZcdbWgZYZ6jgdgV!kVVhZgbVgXVYVXdc[gZXjZcX^V
YZbVcZgVig{\^XVedgaVhX^gXjchiVcX^VhhdX^VaZhneda†i^XVh
YZa eZg†dYd cVedaZ‹c^Xd n edg aV YZhVeVg^X^‹c YZ hZgZh
fjZg^Ydh#
EdgdigVeVgiZ!Xg^VYVZcZaXVbedZcCd]Vci!ZcaVegde^ZYVY
WZgg^X]dcV YZ hj VWjZaV!6jgdgV kV V hZg egd[jcYVbZciZ
^begZ\cVYV edg aVh igVY^X^dcZh n aZnZcYVh YZa 7Zggn!
Vh† Xdbd edg adh gZaVidh YZ adh XVbeZh^cdh YZ hj VaYZV
gZ[ZgZciZhVaVhbVc^[ZhiVX^dcZhhdWgZcVijgVaZhYZaVhfjZ
hdciZhi^\dh!Zc[dgbVYZVeVg^X^dcZh[VciVhbVaZh¹k^h^dcZhº
XdbdaVhaaVbVg{#H^ZbegZiZcYg{jcVedh^X^‹cbjnXaVgV
Xdc gZaVX^‹c V ZhiVh bVc^[ZhiVX^dcZh eVgVcdgbVaZh XjnV
edh^W^a^YVYVXZeiVXdbd[Zc‹bZcdhcVijgVaZhXjnVh[jZciZh
hdc idYVk†V YZhXdcdX^YVh eVgV aV X^ZcX^V ]jbVcV# :aaV hZ
Zmea^XVg{Zchja^WgdK^h^dchYZaVcj^iYVchcdhXVbeV\cZh
K^h^dcZhYZaVcdX]ZZccjZhigdhXVbedhY^X^ZcYd/¹Cdhdn
YZadhfjZY^XZc!VciZaVhhjeZghi^X^dcZhghi^XVh/bZci^gV!
^bWZX^a^YVY!k^h^‹cYZab^ZYd0ndY^\d[Zc‹bZcdYZk^h^‹c!
d[Zc‹bZcdZmiZgcd^ch‹a^idZ^cXdbegZcY^Yd#CdedgZhd
XgZd c^ Zc Wgj_dh c^ Zc b^aV\gdh# EZgd Za ]ZX]d Zm^hiZ! Za
]ZX]d hZ XjbeaZ0 fjZ hZV jc [VciVhbV Zc Za V^gZ d h‹ad
ZcZad_dYZafjZadb^gV!ZhiVbW^‚ckZgYVYZgVbZciZjc
dW_ZidgZVana‹\^XVbZciZegdYjX^YdXdbdZagZ[aZ_dYZjcV
[^\jgVZcjcZheZ_dº#HZ\cZaaV!Zhidh[Zc‹bZcdhYZWZchZg
ZhijY^VYdhedgaVX^ZcX^V/
¹AVdWgVYZaVX^ZcX^V!ZcZhidhi^Zbedh!ZhgZX]VoVgidYd
ad fjZ eVgZoXV hdWgZcVijgVa! edgfjZ aV ^\cdgVcX^V n aV
^bedhijgV ]Vc VWjhVYd YZbVh^VYd i^Zbed#6h† Xdbd adh
eda†i^Xdhhdc[dgoVYdhVgZhdakZgXdc]^ZggdaVhXjZhi^dcZh
hdX^VaZh!eVgVVWg^gVaVc{a^h^hjccjZkdXVbed!adh]dbWgZh
YZ ZhijY^d hdc dWa^\VYdh V ZX]Vg Xdc[jhVbZciZ Va [jZ\d
Za \Va^bVi†Vh YZ adh Wgj_dh n adh b^aV\gdh YZ aV [Z#KZcYg{
jci^ZbedZcfjZZhiVcYdXjbea^YVaVcZXZhVg^VdWgVYZ
YZhigjXX^‹c! hZ WjhXVg{ Xj^YVYdhVbZciZ! ZcigZ adh igdodh
YZaeVhVYd!jcVkZgYVYfjZcdejZYZeZgYZghZº#
Hj egde^d ]ZgbVcd! =^eedaniZ ZhiVWV ^\jVabZciZ hj_Zid
V ZhiZ \‚cZgd YZ k^h^dcZh# :aaV cdh XjZciV Zc hj a^Wgd
VjidW^d\g{[^Xd=^hidg^VYZb^k^YVX‹bdZhiZai^bdZhijkd
Zc[ZgbdYZb^ZYd!YZhej‚hYZ]VWZgk^hidZa[VciVhbVYZhj
eVYgZ[VaaZX^YdVa\jcdhY†VhVciZh#>\jVabZciZ!Y^g†VbjX]d
b{hiVgYZYZ6a[gZYYZBjhhZifjZkZ†VVeVg^X^dcZhnd†V
kdXZhnfjZZaedZiVXV†VZcigVcXZXdc\gVc[VX^a^YVY#
;^cVabZciZ!ZYjXVYVgZa^\^dhVbZciZedghjVWjZaV!6jgdgV
[jZ jW^XVYV Zc jc XdckZcid Zc EVg†h! ZcigZ adh XVidgXZ n
adh Y^ZX^h‚^h VŠdh! ad XjVa ^\jVabZciZ YZ_Vg†V hjh ]jZaaVh#
6aa† VigVk^ZhV jcV Xg^h^h YZ b^hi^X^hbd Va ejcid YZ fjZgZg
ZcigVgZcaVgZa^\^‹ceZgdg{e^YVbZciZhZYVXjZciVYZfjZ
¹aV ZYjXVX^‹c gZa^\^dhV iVa n Xdbd Zh ZchZŠVYV Xdc[dgbV
jcZhigZX]ZoYZaZhe†g^ijZcaj\VgYZjcVVeZgijgVhdWgZZa
bjcYdºngZX]VoVjcVgZa^\^‹cfjZXdcYZcVVa^c[^ZgcdZiZgcd#
B{hiVgYZ!gdbeZg{XdcaV>\aZh^VXVi‹a^XVeZgdXdchZgkVg{
/(-2851$/63,5,7(1o$%5,/
h^ZbegZaV[ZZc¹jc9^dhYZb^hZg^XdgY^Vºnjc^ccVidgZheZidedg
aVhXdhVhY^k^cVh#:cCjZkVh8VgiVhYZjck^V_ZgdZhXg^W^g{/
¹CZXZh^idVjc9^dh!cdeVgVhVi^h[VXZgb^Z\d†hbddXdchdaVgb^
YZW^a^YVY! h^cd edg XgZZg V aV ]jbVc^YVY YZedh^iVg^V YZ jc [jZ\d
hV\gVYdb{hejgdfjZZhiZXdcZaXjVahZXVa^ZciV#CjcXVhZbZ]Vg{
XdbegZcYZgfjZadXgjZa!ad^c_jhidnad[ZgdohdcaZnZhh^cXVjhV!h^c
dW_Zi^kdnh^cXdggZXi^kdZcZajc^kZghdº#
NV VYjaiV! 6jgdgV XdckZgi^YV Zc <Zdg\Z HVcY h^\j^‹ WjhXVcYd
dg^ZciVX^‹c eda†i^XV n Zhe^g^ijVa! fjZ Za ZcXjZcigd Xdc X^Zgidh
[^a‹hd[dhiVaZhXdbdAVbZccV^hnE^ZggZAZgdjmaaZcVg†V#:aeg^bZgd
egZY^XVZaVbdgYZa]dbWgZ!aVa^WZgiVYnaV_jhi^X^V!jcXgZYdZcZa
fjZ<Zdg\ZHVcYhZgZXdcdXZ#:ahZ\jcYd!E^ZggZAZgdjm!egZXdc^oV
jcVYdXig^cVhdX^Vaneda†i^XV!^begZ\cVYVYZZhe^g^ijVa^YVYnWVhVYV
ZcaV[gViZgc^YVYVh†XdbdjcgZidgcdVaVh[jZciZhYZaXg^hi^Vc^hbd#
9Z gZejWa^XVcV hZ kdakZg{ hdX^Va^hiV! eVaVWgV fjZ hZ YZWZ V E^ZggZ
AZgdjm Xdc fj^Zc <Zdg\Z HVcY Zhijkd Zc h^cidc†V YjgVciZ kVg^dh
VŠdh#HVWZbdhfjZE^ZggZAZgdjmeVgi^X^e‹ZchZh^dcZhYZZhe^g^i^hbd
nfjZXdcdX^‹V6aaVc@VgYZXXjVcYdZhiZai^bd]VW^iVWVidYVk†V
ZcZaeVhV_ZHV^ciZ6ccZYZEVg†hnhj^c[ajZcX^VhdWgZ<Zdg\ZHVcY
ZcZhiZXVbedZhZk^YZciZ#
*HRUJH6DQG
/DLQPRUWDOLGDGGHODOPD
AV[ZZcjcVk^YVZiZgcV_Vb{hVWVcYdc‹V<Zdg\ZHVcY#whiV[jZ
iVbW^‚c!ZcbZY^dYZadhh^chVWdgZhYZhjk^YVeg^kVYVnYZadhb{h
XgjZaZhYjZadh[Vb^a^VgZh!hjkZgYVYZgdnc^XdgZ[j\^d#:cXdcigVbdh
cjbZgdhdhZ_ZbeadhYZZhiVXgZZcX^VZc8dggZhedcYZcX^V#6h†!VciZ
aVe‚gY^YVYZhjc^ZiVegZ[Zg^YV!ZhXg^WZVjcVVb^\V/¹:hidnhZ\jgVYZ
ZcXdcigVgVb^c^ŠVZcZadigdbjcYd#EZgX^WdfjZhdbdhcdhdigdh
adhfjZeZgYZbdhnZaadhPadhY^[jcidhRadhfjZ\VcVcº#
>\jVabZciZ!XjVcYdZc_jc^dYZ&-)-gZX^WZjcVXVgiVYZhZheZgVYV
YZhjVb^\VaVXdbZY^VciZBVg^Z9dghVa!Xdbjc^X{cYdaZaVbjZgiZ
YZ hj c^Zid! <Zdg\Z HVcY aZ gZhedcYZ Za &+ YZ _jc^d YZ &-)-/
¹Ij XVgiV bZ gdbeZ Za XdgVo‹c n aadgd Xdci^\d V ZhiZ [Za^o c^Šd
WZcYZX^Ydedg9^dh!ejZh]VkjZaidV‚aVciZhYZXdcdXZgcjZhigV
ig^hiZn]dgg^WaZk^YV#«waZhbjn[Za^o=Vk^k^Ydh‹adYZXj^YVYdh!YZ
Vbdg!YZXVg^X^VhnYZVaZ\g†V#CdZhZcZhiVeZfjZŠVijbWVYdcYZ
aadgVg{h#:hZcZahZcdYZ9^dh°:hi{igVcfj^aVedgij]^_d!ZcZhiZ
bdbZcid‚aZhfjZg^YdZcdigVeVgiZnZaVbdgfjZh^ZbegZaZYVh!
VeZhVgYZaVbjZgiZ!aZVXdbeVŠVnaZegdiZ\ZZcdigVZh[ZgVYZ
Zm^hiZcX^VYdcYZiZkZniZhdcg†Zh^cXZhVg°9^dhZh_jhid!cdZh
^beaVXVWaZnkZc\Vi^kdXdbdadh]dbWgZh#CdZhadXjgV!c^idciZg†V
XgZZgZcjcVk^YVbZ_dgYdcYZkVcVfjZaadhfjZcdhYZ_VcnYdcYZ
adhZcXdcigVgZbdh#:cXjVcidVb†!bZhZg†V^bedh^WaZcdXgZZg!n
VfjZaadhVadhfjZ]ZeZgY^YdnfjZg^Ydh^ZbegZbZeVgZXZck^kdh#
H^aVbjZgiZ[jZgVVa\dVWhdajid!aVk^YVcdZm^hi^g†Vº#
$XURUHHWVRQIUUH+LSSRO\WH
/DUHHQFDUQDFL¦Q
Bjn^c[ajZcX^VYVedgaVYdXig^cVYZAZgdjm!aVXgZZcX^VYZ<Zdg\Z
HVcY Zc jcV eVa^c\ZcZh^V cd i^ZcZ c^c\jcV YjYV n VeVgZXZ Zc
bjX]VhYZhjhdWgVh#6h†!ZhXg^WZZc=^hid^gZYZbVk^Z/
¹AdhhVcidhYZidYVhaVhgZa^\^dcZhfjZcdh\g^iVcYZhYZZa[dcYd
YZ aV Vci^\“ZYVY fjZ cdh a^WZgZbdh YZ aV bViZg^V eVgV ZaZkVgcdh
Zc aV _ZgVgfj†V XZaZhi^Va YZ adh Zhe†g^ijh cd cdh ]Vc Zc\VŠVYd Zc
XjVcidVaVXgZZcX^VVYb^h^WaZedgaVgVo‹cbdYZgcV#=dneZchVbdh
fjZ!h^hdbdh^cbdgiVaZh!ZhXdcaVXdcY^X^‹cYZgZkZhi^gh^cXZhVg
‹g\Vcdh cjZkdh eVgV XdbeaZiVg cjZhigd hZg fjZ egdWVWaZbZciZ
cdi^ZcZZaYZgZX]dVXdckZgi^ghZZcZhe†g^ijejgd0eZgdedYZbdh
b^gVgZhiVi^ZggVXdbdjcaj\VgYZeVhdnXdciVgXdcjcYZheZgiVg
b{h YjaXZ Zc aV XjcV fjZ cdh ZheZgV Zc digd aj\Vg# 9Z bjcYdh
/(-2851$/63,5,7(1o$%5,/
3LHUUH/HURX[
''
Zc bjcYdh! YZhed_{cYdcdh YZ aV Vc^bVa^YVY fjZ Zc ZhiZ
bjcYdXdbWViZcjZhigVZhe^g^ijVa^YVY!edYZbdh]VXZgcdh
VeidheVgVgZkZhi^gjcXjZgedb{hejgd!b{hVegde^VYdVaVh
cZXZh^YVYZhYZaVabV!bZcdhXdbWVi^YVnbZcdhigVWVYV
edgadhVX]VfjZhYZaVk^YV]jbVcViVanXdbdaVhj[g^bdh
ZcZhiZbjcYdº#
>\jVabZciZ!Zchja^Wgd8dggZhedcYVcXZ!<Zdg\ZHVcYZkdXV
gZeZi^YVhkZXZhhj[ZZcaVgZZcXVgcVX^‹c/
¹:hidnhZ\jgVYZfjZadhbjZgidhZhi{cW^Zc!fjZYZhXVchVc
fj^o{hVciZhYZgZk^k^g!nfjZZcidYdXVhd!gZXVZcZcZaXg^hda
eVgVhVa^gYZ‚aXdcadfjZZcb{h]VciZc^YdYZWjZcdh!n
YZegd\gZhdºXdggZhedcYZcX^VXdc<jhiVkZ;aVjWZgi
¹HdWgZ aV bjZgiZ iZc\d XgZZcX^Vh bjn YjaXZh n bjn
g^hjZŠVh!nbZ^bV\^cd]VWZgbZgZX^Ydh‹adjcVhjZgiZbjn
VbVWaZ Zc aV digV k^YV# Cd e^Yd ZhiVg Zc Za h‚ei^bd X^Zad
XdcadhhZgV[^cZhc^XdciZbeaVgidYdZai^ZbedZagdhigdYZa
6ai†h^bd# Edg digV eVgiZ! cd XgZd fjZ ‚a iZc\V c^ gdhigd c^
eZg[^a!nVYZb{hh^W^ZcZhjc\gVc\dodZhiVgZcadheg^bZgdh
aj\VgZh!ZhdcdZhjcVcZXZh^YVYeVgVb†#«=VniVcidhWdc^idh
bjcYdheZfjZŠdhedg]VW^iVg«=VhiVdigdg^cX‹cYZZhiZ!
WV_d digV [dgbV «8j{ciVh [Za^X^YVYZh dXjaiVh ejZYZ ]VWZg
ZcadYZhXdcdX^YdYZaVhdigVhZm^hiZcX^VhªNfj^‚ccdhY^XZ
fjZaVcjZhigVhZVaVbZ_dg4ºV6aZmVcYgZ9jbVh]^_d#
He^g^Y^dc Zh jcV YZ aVh cdkZaVh YZ HVcY fjZ b{h aZ YZWZ
V AZgdjm! V fj^Zc! VYZb{h Zhi{ YZY^XVYV# :c ZhiV dWgV!
aVh Xdbjc^XVX^dcZh ZcigZ adh bjZgidh n adh k^kdh edg aV
k^hiV! aV VjY^X^‹c n aV ^che^gVX^‹c Vh† Xdbd Za iZbV YZ aV
gZZcXVgcVX^‹ci^ZcZcjcaj\VgegZedcYZgVciZ#=ZVfj†jc
g{e^YdgZhjbZc/
9Zig{hYZadhk^Z_dhbjgdhYZjcXdckZcid!jcVijbWVegdiZ"
\^YVedgiZggdg†[^XdhhjWiZgg{cZdh!Xdci^ZcZjcbVcjhXg^id
egZX^dhd! dWgV YZa VWViZ HVbjZa =‚Wgdc^jh! fj^Zc idbV
ZcgZa^\^‹cZacdbWgZYZHe^g^Y^dc!jck^h^dcVg^dZcWjhXV
YZjcV[ZcjZkVXjnd[VciVhbVeVgZXZgdcYVgaVVWVY†Vn
k^h^iVgVhjhegdiZ\^Ydh#JcegdXZhdYZhjXZh^‹c!YZbVZhigd
VY^hX†ejad!eZgb^i^g{fjZcdhZe^ZgYVZahZXgZidYZaVdWgV
ZciZggVYVZcZhVijbWV#;ja\ZcXZhjXZYZVHe^g^Y^dc!ajZ\d
Za^\ZV6aZm^hfj^Zc!VhjkZo!ZaZ\^g{V6c\ZaeVgVfjZhZVZa
(OHVS¢ULWXTXHHVW–HQHOKRPEUHHVGLYLQR
SHURQRHV'LRV(VW–DFRWDGR\
OLPLWDGRHQYRVRWURVHVXQDOX]TXH
PDUFKD\YLDMD/LEUHVHHTXLYRFDGHUXWD
\DYHFHVSLHUGHVXOX]FRQVXPLžQGRVH
GHPDVLDGRHQODYLGDRUJ–QLFDR
DLVO–QGRVHGHPDVLDGRGHHVWDYLGD
YZedh^iVg^dYZahZXgZid!hZXgZidfjZhZg{Y^kja\VYdVa[^cVa
YZaVcdkZaV!]VX^‚cYdcdhXdbegZcYZgfjZ<Zdg\ZHVcY!
k†VHe^g^Y^dc!VeZaVVa_dVfj^c^hbd!XgZZcX^V[dgbjaVYVedg
?dVX]^b YZ ;^dgZ n hj Y^hX†ejad ?ZVc YZ EVgbV hZ\c aV
XjVa!YZhej‚hYZaVgZa^\^‹cYZaeVYgZZa_jYV†hbd!ajZ\daV
gZa^\^‹cYZa]^_dZaXg^hi^Vc^hbd!YZWZg†VkZc^gjcViZgXZgV
gZa^\^‹c!aVYZaZhe†g^ij#
:cZaZmigVXidh^\j^ZciZ!jcdYZadheZghdcV_Zheg^cX^eVaZh!
6aZm^h!hZegZ\jciVh^‚acdZhaVgZZcXVgcVX^‹cYZ=ZWgdc^jh
He^g^Y^dc/
¹8gZd Zc jc Zc\ZcYgVb^Zcid eZgeZijd YZ aVh VabVh! fjZ
cddWZYZXZVaZnZhb^hiZg^dhVhc^VaVodh^ck^h^WaZh#6kZXZh
bZ ]Z egZ\jciVYd! h^ nd cd hZg‚ Za b^hbd =‚Wgdc^jh!
bdY^[^XVYdZcjcVZm^hiZcX^VcjZkVedgaVhY^[ZgZcX^VhYZ
jch^\adedhiZg^dgVahjnd#EZgd!XdbdZhiZeZchVb^ZcidZgV
YZbVh^VYdegZhjcijdhdeVgVhZgXdbeaZiVbZciZX^Zgid!bZ
Y^_ZfjZ‚aedY†VhZgndh^c]VWZgYZ_VYdYZhZg‚a!Vh†Xdbd!
ZcZadgYZc[†h^Xd!jc]dbWgZ!VagZegdYjX^gaVZhiVijgV!adh
gVh\dhnaVh^cXa^cVX^dcZhYZhjhVciZeVhVYdh!adh]VXZgZk^k^g
ZchjeZghdcV!VjcfjZiZc^ZcYdjcVZm^hiZcX^Vegde^VfjZ
bdY^[^XVaVZm^hiZcX^VigVchb^i^YVedgZaadhº#
:cZhiZdigdZmigVXid!jcb‚Y^XdZhaaVbVYdVaVXVWZXZgV
YZaeVYgZ6aZm^h!Zc[ZgbdYZV\diVb^Zcid^ciZaZXijVa#H^\jZ
ZhiZY^{ad\dZc[dgbVYZjcVbjn]ZgbdhVbZi{[dgVhdWgZ
aVhjeZgk^kZcX^VYZaZhe†g^ijnaVgZZcXVgcVX^‹c/
¹¸EVYgZb†d!aV]d_V]VYZh\VhiVYdaV[jcYV#
¸ªFj‚ Zh jcV b^hZgVWaZ [jcYV YZ b{h d YZ bZcdh4
¸GZhedcY^‹ b^ bVZhigd hdcg^ZcYd¸0 ªaV ]d_V cd Zh
^cYZhigjXi^WaZ4
¸H†!¸XdciZhi‹ZaYdXidg¸0eZgdejZYZdm^YVghZXjVcYd
aV[jcYVjhVYVnVcdaVegdiZ\Z#
¸ªFj‚ ^bedgiV fjZ jcV ]d_V bZaaVYV hZ dm^YZ4 ¸
Egdh^\j^‹ZaeVYgZ6aZm^h¸0ZaaVZhi{nV[jZgVYZhZgk^X^d#:h
egZX^hdfjZZabZiVahZVkjZaidVedcZgZcaV]d\jZgVeVgV
hZgigVWV_VYdnji^a^oVYdYZcjZkdº#
:c8dchjZadnAV8dbiZhhZYZGjYdahiVYi!ZhiVhYdhcdkZaVh
fjZZcgZVa^YVYcdhdcb{hfjZjcV!ZcXdcigVbdh^\jVabZciZ
cjbZgdhdheVhV_ZhfjZigViVcYZaVgZZcXVgcVX^‹cnYZaVh
k^YVhhjXZh^kVh#=ZVfj†^\jVabZciZjcWgZkZgZhjbZc/
8dchjZad! bVgVk^aadhV XVciVciZ ^iVa^VcV YZWZ ]j^g V
KZcZX^V YdcYZ hj[gZ adh VhZY^dh YZ jc \Zci^a]dbWgZ# :aaV
Zhi{XdcigViVYVXdbdegd[ZhdgVYZXVcidedgZa8dcYZYZ
GjYdahiVYi! jc ]dbWgZ ZmigVŠd! gdYZVYd YZ jc egd[jcYd
b^hiZg^d# wa Zh egZhV YZ k^daZcidh YZa^g^dh n YZ ZchjZŠdh
YZgZZcXVgcVX^‹cYdcYZgZk^kZaVVidgbZciVYV]^hidg^VYZ
hjh VciZeVhVYdh ]jh^iVh# HZ ZcVbdgV VeVh^dcVYVbZciZ
YZ 8dchjZad n aV e^YZ Zc bVig^bdc^d# AV _dkZc XVciVciZ!
iZbZgdhV YZ ZhiZ eZghdcV_Z h^c\jaVg! ]jnZ YZ cjZkd n hZ
Xdck^ZgiZ Zc XVciVciZ YZ aV ‹eZgV YZK^ZcV# EZgd gZ\gZhV
_jcid Va 8dcYZ fjZ V\dc^oV n hZ XVhV Xdc ‚a _jhid VciZh
YZhjbjZgiZ#8dchjZadZcidcXZhegdh^\jZhjXVb^cdhdaV#
:begZcYZjcgZXdgg^Yd^c^X^{i^XdZcZaXVbedYZadXjai^hbd#
:heZghZ\j^YVedgk^h^dcZhYZhjbVg^Yd#ª:hi{‚agZVabZciZ
bjZgid4
:cZhiVcdkZaV!<Zdg\ZHVcYegZhiVVa8dcYZYZGjYdahiVYi
eVaVWgVh fjZ igVYjXZc hjh †ci^bVh Xdck^XX^dcZh! Xdbd
edYZbdhXdbegdWVgZcadhZ_ZbeadhfjZh^\jZc/
¹° edg b{h fjZ hZ ]VnVc fjZbVYd adh VgX]^kdh YZ aVh
[Vb^a^VhnadhYdXjbZcidhYZaV]^hidg^V!hZŠdgXVeZaa{c0edg
b{hfjZhZ]VnVZYjXVYdVadhc^ŠdhZcaV^\cdgVcX^VYZaV
k^YVVciZg^dg0edgb{hfjZhZ]VnV^bejZhidh^aZcX^dVadh
h^beaZhedgZahd[^hbV!nVadhY‚W^aZhedgaVVbZcVoV/c^Za
b^ZYdVaYZhedi^hbd!c^Va^c[^Zgcd!ejZYZcV]d\VgaVhb^a
kdXZhYZaeVhVYdfjZhZZaZkVcedgidYVheVgiZh#«Cd!cd!
]VWaVcYZbVh^VYdVaid!ZhiVhkdXZhiZgg^WaZh!eVgVfjZaVYZ
/(-2851$/63,5,7(1o$%5,/
'(
jchVXZgYdiZaZh^bedc\Vh^aZcX^d=VWaVcVcjZhigVhVabVhZcZa
hjZŠd!edgWdXVYZadhZheZXigdhfjZhZaZkVciVceVgVVYkZgi^gcdh0
]VWaVcVcjZhigdhd†YdheVgVXdciVgcdhadhXg†bZcZh!aVhYZhY^X]Vhn
aVh]VoVŠVhYZcjZhigdheVYgZhº#
¹° Za gZXjZgYd YZ ad fjZ ]VW†V h^Yd n YZ ad fjZ ]VW†V k^hid Zc
h^\adheVhVYdhidb‹jcVVeVg^ZcX^VYZViZggVYdgVgZVa^YVY!XjVcYd
6aWZgik^cdVbVc^[ZhiVgjcV[VXjaiVYeVgi^XjaVgnkZgYVYZgVbZciZ
^cVjY^iV°:hiV[VXjaiVYhZaaVbV!Y^XZcZcdigdheV†hZh!aVhZ\jcYd
k^hiVº#¹6aWZgikZndnZadfjZc^c\cdigdejZYZkZgc^d†gº#
<Zdg\ZHVcYeZgbVcZXZ]jb^aYZZchj[ZngZXdcdXZfjZcdi^ZcZ
gZhejZhiVVidYd/
¹Cd ZheZgVg‚^h YZ b†! ^bV\^cd! fjZ dh Y^\V YZ fj‚ bVcZgV ‚a PZa
Zhe†g^ijRhZegZcYZVaa†eVgVgZkZhi^ghZYZjcVcjZkVk^YVdg\{c^XV#:hid
ZhZab^aV\gdYZaVXgZVX^‹cjc^kZghVa!fjZcdcdh]Vh^YdgZkZaVYdn
fjZfj^o{hZaZhe†g^ijhZeVXjVcYdhZVejgVbZciZZhe†g^ij#6a\jcdh
XgZZcfjZ‚ai^ZcZ‹g\VcdhZheZX†[^Xdh^cYZeZcY^ZciZhYZaVbViZg^V#
:hidZh^gb{haZ_dhYZadfjZndejZYd^gº#
/DSHUIHFWLELOLGDG
:c hj a^Wgd HdjkZc^gh Zi ^Y‚Zh GZXjZgYdh Z ^YZVh! <Zdg\Z HVcY
ZhXg^WZjcXVe†ijadi^ijaVYd/¹GZaVX^‹cYZjcVXgZZcX^VZhe^g^ijVa^hiVº!
ZcZaXjVacdhY^XZfjZc^XVbZciZaV^cbdgiVa^YVYYZaVabVeZgb^iZ
Zaegd\gZhd/
¹AVeZgeZij^YVYYZandZm^hiZejZhcVYVhZYZhigjnZ#AVcdX^‹cYZ
ZhiVeZgeZij^YVYZhjcVhjcidYZegd\gZhd#Adh]dbWgZhh^ZbegZ
]VcXgZ†YdnidYdhXaVbVcedgZaaV#:hejZhjcYZgZX]dfjZZaadh
V[^gbVcnjcVXdcfj^hiVVhZ\jgVYVVaedgkZc^gYZaZhe†g^ijº#:cZhZ
b^hbda^Wgd!ZaaVcdhY^XZ^\jVabZciZ/
¹° Za egd\gZhd jc^kZghVa Zh aV aZn Y^k^cV edg ZmXZaZcX^V n aV k^YV
dg\{c^XV Zh Za XVbed ZmeZg^bZciVa YdcYZ Za Zhe†g^ij hZ VXaVgV
n [dgodhVbZciZ hZ gZ]VW^a^iV# 6h† Xdbd Zc aV k^YV YZa ]dbWgZ
^ciZa^\ZciZaVh[VaiVhhZgZeVgVcdcdhedcZcZc\jVgY^VXdcigVaV
gZeZi^X^‹cYZaVhXV†YVh!^\jVabZciZZcaVk^YVZiZgcVYZaZhe†g^ij!
XVYVhZg^ZYZZm^hiZcX^VhZhjcVaZXX^‹cfjZhZejZYZVegdkZX]Vg°
AV bjZgiZ cd Zm^hiZ# EjZh Za Zggdg ZiZgcd n Za XVhi^\d ZiZgcd YZa
Zhe†g^ijcdejZYZcZm^hi^gº#
:hiV XdcXZeX^‹c aZ eZgb^iZ Zmea^XVg aV egZhZcX^V YZa bVa hdWgZ aV
i^ZggVZa^b^cVcYdaVXgZZcX^VZcZaY^VWad/
¹°:hfjZZabVa!edgbdchigjdhdfjZcdheVgZoXV!cdZhb{hfjZ
aV ^\cdgVcX^V YZa W^Zc# :h jcV XZ\jZgV YZa Zhe†g^ij! fjZ cd XgZ‚^h
YZ[^c^i^kVejZh!YZhYZZhiVk^YV!aVXdbWVi†hZcadhdigdhnZckdhdigdh
b^hbdh#:aZhe†g^ijfjZZhi{ZcZa]dbWgZZhY^k^cd!eZgdcdZh9^dh#
:hi{VXdiVYdna^b^iVYdZckdhdigdh0ZhjcVajofjZbVgX]Vnk^V_V#
A^WgZ!hZZfj^kdXVYZgjiVnVkZXZhe^ZgYZhjajo!Xdchjb^‚cYdhZ
YZbVh^VYd Zc aV k^YV dg\{c^XV d V^ha{cYdhZ YZbVh^VYd YZ ZhiV
k^YVº#
:cZabdbZcidYZaVe‚gY^YVYZjchZgfjZg^Yd!<Zdg\ZHVcY^ch^hiZ
Xdc[gZXjZcX^VZcZhiZ^cZk^iVWaZegd\gZhd#EdgZ_Zbead!YZhej‚hYZ
aVYZhVeVg^X^‹cegZbVijgVYZhjeZfjZŠd]^_d!XdciZhiVVh†!Za&'YZ
V\dhidYZ&-+)VaVhXdcYdaZcX^VhYZK^Xidg=j\d/
¹>\jVafjZjhiZY!Zhi^bdfjZaVbjZgiZZhjcW^ZcejZhZhaVgZcdkVX^‹c!
edgXdch^\j^ZciZaVbZ_dgVYZjcVZm^hiZcX^Vº8dggZhedcYVcXZ#
:c digV XVgiV V =^eedaniZ IV^cZ! [ZX]VYV Za * YZ VWg^a YZ &-,'!
VcdiV/
¹8dbd ad ]V YZbdhigVYd Fj^cZi! aVh gVoVh n aVh ZheZX^Zh! fjZ hZ
hjXZYZcdfjZegdk^ZcZcjcVhYZdigVh!i^ZcYZch^ZbegZ!hVakdaVh
aV\jcVh! aVh YZhk^VX^dcZh n adh ]jcY^b^Zcidh! V Xdchi^ij^g jc i^ed
b{heZg[ZXidfjZZhXdbdZahjZŠdZiZgcd!Za^YZVa^chVi^h[ZX]dYZ
/(-2851$/63,5,7(1o$%5,/
$OH[DQGUH'XPDVILOV
*XVWDYH)ODXEHUW
')
aVcVijgVaZoV#:h^\jVaXdcZaZhe†g^ij]jbVcd!fj^ZgZ
ZaZkVghZ!XdbeaZiVghZ!gZ[^cVghZ#:hV]Vh^Ydh^ZbegZ
b^Xdck^XX^‹c!b^]^adXdcYjXidg!ndfjZ]ZfjZg^Yd
kZg Va ]dbWgZ V igVk‚h YZa eg^hbV YZ aV cVijgVaZoVº
8dggZhedcYVcXZ#
;^cVabZciZ! <Zdg\Z HVcY e^ZchV fjZ Za Vbdg Zh
^cY^heZchVWaZeVgVZaegd\gZhdiVanXdbdcdhadhj\^ZgZ
Zc hj a^Wgd >begZhh^dch Zi hdjkZc^gh>begZh^dcZh n
gZXjZgYdh/
¹:a edgkZc^g Zhi{ WVhVYd Zc Za Vbdg! n idbVY cd
^bedgiVfj‚digVeVaVWgVeVgVZmegZhVgaVcZXZh^YVY
YZ aV VhdX^VX^‹c! n h^ZbegZ iZcYg‚^h fjZ gZ\gZhVg V
ZhiVXZgiZoVYZfjZZadY^dbViVVaVgVoV]jbVcV!
fjZZaZ\d†hbdaVeVgVa^oV!fjZh‹adZaVbdgaVgZedcZ
ZcaVk†VfjZ9^dh!nh^fjZg‚^hY^g‚»aVcVijgVaZoV¼!aZ
]VigVoVYdº#
9Zhej‚hYZZhiVWgZkZd_ZVYVVaVh^YZVhZhe†g^iVhYZ
<Zdg\Z HVcY! ]Z Vfj† eVgV XdcXaj^g ZhiZ Vgi†Xjad! aV
XVgiVfjZ6aaVc@VgYZXY^g^\^‹VaVZhXg^idgVZa'%YZ
bVnd YZ &-*,! _jhid YZhej‚h YZ aV VeVg^X^‹c YZ :a
A^WgdYZadh:he†g^ijh/
HZŠdgV!
IZc\dZa]dcdgYZZck^VgdhjcZ_ZbeaVgYZ:aA^WgdYZ
adh:he†g^ijhXjnddWhZfj^ddhgjZ\dVXZeiVg#
H^ _jo\d edg X^ZgiVh ^YZVh ZmejZhiVh Zc kVg^dh YZ
kjZhigdh iZmidh! aV XjZhi^‹c YZ aVh gZaVX^dcZh YZa
]dbWgZ Xdc adh hZgZh ^cXdge‹gZdh cd dh Zh ZmigVŠV/
h^c egZ_jo\Vg hdWgZ kjZhigV de^c^‹c gZheZXid V jc
iZbVh^b^aVg!hjedc\dfjZjcZhe†g^ijYZZa^iZXdbd
ZakjZhigd!hZŠdgV!cdhZg{Ydb^cVYdedgadhegZ_j^X^dh
nYZWZYZhZVgZaZmVbZc#
H^kjZhigVhdXjeVX^dcZhdheZgb^iZcYZY^XVgVa\jcdh
^chiVciZhVZhiVaZXijgV!fj^o{hkZg‚^h!edgaVZmedh^X^‹c
YZZhiVYdXig^cV!fjZZaZhe^g^i^hbdhVaZYZaZhigZX]d
X†gXjadYZaVhbVc^[ZhiVX^dcZhbViZg^VaZheVgVVWgVoVg
idYVh aVh aZnZh fjZ g^\Zc V aV ]jbVc^YVY# Edg digV
eVgiZ! hZŠdgV! adh :he†g^ijh bZ ]Vc ]VWaVYd YZ kdh
kVg^VhkZXZhn!VaYZY^XVgdhZhiVdWgV!fjZZhbjX]d
b{hYZZaadhfjZb†V!cd]V\dh^cdXjbea^gZaYZhZd
fjZbZ]Vc^che^gVYd#
GZX^W^Y!dhgjZ\d!hZŠdgV!XdcZaig^WjidYZaVVYb^gVX^‹c
fjZXdbeVgidXdciVcidhdigdh!Za]dbZcV_ZYZb^h
hZci^b^Zcidhb{hY^hi^c\j^Ydh#
6aaVc@VgYZX
<Zdg\ZHVcYcdY^dc^c\jcVXdci^cjVX^‹cVZhiVXVgiV#
ªAZn‹:aA^WgdYZadh:he†g^ijh4:hY^[†X^aYZhVWZg#:aXVhd
ZhfjZ!VjcfjZZhiVYVbVYZjcV^cbZchVVbea^ijY
YZk^h^‹c!cdhZVY]^g^‹XdbeaZiVbZciZVaV[^adhd[†V
Zhe†g^iV!ZhiVWVh^cZbWVg\dYZVXjZgYdXdc‚hiVZc
cjbZgdhdh ejcidh0 eVgV egjZWV ZhiV ai^bV X^iV YZ
<Zdg\ZHVcYfjZY^XZVa]VWaVgYZhj[Z¹YZWZeVgZXZg
^chj[^X^ZciZVjcdh!ZmXZh^kVVdigdh/aVYdXig^cVZiZgcV
YZadhXgZnZciZh!Za9^dhWjZcd!ZaVabV^cbdgiVanaVh
ZheZgVcoVhYZaVdigVk^YV!]ZVfj†adfjZ!Zcb†!]V
gZh^hi^YdVidYdZmVbZc!VidYVY^hXjh^‹cn]VhiVVadh
^ciZgkVadhYZYjYVYZhZheZgVYVº#
(&26
/26(6&5,725(6,163,5$'26325(/0z6$//z
µ(1(/3$…6'(/26(168(ˆ26¹¶
:
Y\VgEdZ!ZhXg^idgcdgiZV"
bZg^XVcd!
XdbeVgiZ
Xdc BZak^aaZ jcV hdbWg†V
k^h^‹cbZiV[†h^XV!bZoXaVYZ
ZaZbZcidh YZ gZVa^hbd! YZ
eVgdY^VnYZWjgaZhXd#9^dV
aVcdkZaVhjXVgiVYZcdWaZoV
n[jZZa^ckZcidgYZaVcdkZaV
eda^X†VXV#CjbZgdhdhgZaVidh
hjndhegZ[^\jgVcadh\‚cZgdh
YZaVX^ZcX^V[^XX^‹cnYZad
[Vci{hi^Xd# wa YZhXg^W†V Vh† hj ZhiVYd bZciVa/¹AVh gZVa^"
YVYZhYZabjcYdbZV[ZXiVcXdbdk^h^dcZhnhdaVbZciZ
Vh†!b^ZcigVhfjZaVhadXVh^YZVhYZaeV†hYZadhZchjZŠdhhZ
Xdck^ZgiZcZcXVbW^d!cdh‹adZcZaVa^bZcidYZb^Zm^h"
iZcX^VXdi^Y^VcV!h^cdedh^i^kVbZciZZcZhiVc^XVnZciZgV
Zm^hiZcX^Vº#
µ(67(,038/626(&5(72¹¶
G
dW^chdc 8gjhdZ! cdkZaV
ZhXg^iVedg9Vc^Za9Z[dZ
Zhi{ ^begZ\cVYV YZ jcV
VaiV[^adhd[†VbdgVanYZadh
eg^cX^e^dhYZaZhe^g^i^hbd#
¹BZ ^bejhZ! ejZh! Xdbd
dWa^\VX^‹c cd gZh^hi^g _Vb{h
V ZhVh kdXZh b^hiZg^dhVh
fjZ cdh ^ck^iVc V idbVg iVa
eVgi^Yd!V]VXZgdVcd]VXZg
iVa XdhV! VjcfjZ c^c\jcV
gVo‹c VednZ ZhZ ^bejahd hZXgZid° EZgd cjcXV Zh YZbV"
h^VYdiVgYZeVgVhZghVW^d!nVXdchZ_dVidYdhadh]dbWgZh
gZ[aZm^kdh XjnV Zm^hiZcX^V ZhiVg†V hdbZi^YV! ^\jVa fjZ aV
b†V!VVXX^YZciZhZmigVdgY^cVg^dh!Vh†XdbdVaVhk^X^h^ijYZh
b{hXdbjcZh!fjZcjcXVYZhXj^YZcZhdhVk^hdh†ci^bdhYZ
aV Egdk^YZcX^V! XjVafj^ZgV fjZ hZV aV ^ciZa^\ZcX^V ^ck^h^WaZ
fjZcdhadhigVchb^iZº#
8jVcYdk^dZchjZŠdhfjZigZhbVg^cZgdhe^gViVh^ciZc"
iVWVcVhZh^cVgVadhZheVŠdaZh!fjZY‹XdckZcX^YdYZZhiV
gZVa^YVYZ]^od_jhi^X^V#¹ª8‹bdbZ[jZgdcgZkZaVYdhZhidh
]ZX]dh4 ªEdg fj‚ hZXgZiV Xdbjc^XVX^‹c YZ adh Zhe†g^ijh
^ck^h^WaZhbZZgVcVedgiVYdh4°CVYVYZbjZhigVb{hXaVgV"
bZciZaVgZVa^YVYYZjcVk^YV[jijgVnYZjcbjcYd^ck^h^WaZ
fjZaVXd^cX^YZcX^VYZaVhXVjhVhhZ\jcYVhXdcX^ZgiVh^YZVh
fjZcdh]Zbdh[dgbVYd^ciZg^dgbZciZ!h^c]VWZggZX^W^Ydc^
YVYdVhjVhjcidc^c\jcVXdbjc^XVX^‹c]jbVcVº#
/(-2851$/63,5,7(1o$%5,/
'*
'266,(5
/26(6&5,725(6,163,5$'26325(/0z6$//z
SRU
-2&(/<1(&+$5/(6
(63…5,7$<$9$7$5
129(/$6'(7+23+,/(*$87,(5
0XFKDVREUDVWUDGXFHQVXGLVJXVWRSRUQRSRGHUHVFDSDUDORVO¢PLWHVGHODFRQGLFL§QKXPDQD
DV¢FRPRVXQHFHVLGDGGHHYDVL§QLPDJLQDULDP–VDOO–GHOWLHPSR\GHODPXHUWH
(OHPHQWRVELRJU•ILFRV
I]‚de]^aZ <Vji^Zg! cVX^Yd ZcIVgWZh Zc &-&&! egdkZc†V YZ
jcV[Vb^a^VWjg\jZhV!^chiVaVYVajZ\dZcEVg†h#HZYZY^X‹V
jcV XVggZgV YZ e^cidg! eZgd hj ZcXjZcigd XdcK^Xidg =j\d
Zc_jc^dYZ&.'.aZYZheZgi‹Za\jhidedgaVa^iZgVijgVnaZ
^cX^i‹VbdY^[^XVghjkdXVX^‹c#Hjeg^bZgVXdaZXX^‹c!EdZh†Vh
VeVgZX^‹ Zc _ja^d YZ &-(%# :a VŠd h^\j^ZciZ hZ ZY^i‹ AV
8V[ZiZgV!eg^bZgXjZcid[Vci{hi^Xd#I]‚de]^aZ<Vji^Zg!edZiV!
cdkZa^hiV! e^cidg! Xg†i^Xd YZ VgiZ n eZg^dY^hiV ZhXg^W^‹ XZgXV
YZ b^a YdhX^Zcidh Vgi†Xjadh fjZ Xdchi^ijnZgdc hj bZY^d
YZ hjWh^hiZcX^V# :cigZ hjh \gVcYZh dWgVh ejZYZc X^iVghZ
BVYZbd^hZaaZ9ZBVje^c!;dgijc^d!AVId^hdcY¼dg!JcZcj^i
YZ8a‚de}igZ!AZ8Ve^iV^cZ;gVXVhhZ!AV8db‚Y^ZYZaVBdgi#
:hXg^WZeVgVZaiZVigdngZYVXiVa^WgZidhYZWVaaZihYZadhXjVaZh
Za b{h X‚aZWgZ Zh <^hZaaZ! egZhZciVYd Zc aV ‹eZgV Zc _jc^d
YZ&-)&#EjWa^XV:bVjmZiXVb‚Zh:hbVaiZhnXVbV[Zdh!
XdaZXX^‹cYZedZbVh#I]‚de]^aZ<Vji^ZgZhjcdYZadhb{h
Wg^aaVciZh gZegZhZciVciZh YZa bdk^b^Zcid gdb{ci^Xd#6jidg
YZcdkZaVh[Vci{hi^XVh!6gg^VBVgXZaaV!AVBdgiZVbdjgZjhZ!
AZGdbVcYZaVbdb^Z d He^g^iZ! k^V_V edg :heVŠV!6g\Za^V!
Gjh^VDg^ZciZnÍ[g^XV#6h^hiZVcjbZgdhVhbVc^[ZhiVX^dcZh
Zhe†g^iVh!ZcidcXZhbjnYZbdYVZcadhX†gXjadhbjcYVcdh
fjZ[gZXjZciV#8^ZgidhXjZcidhbjZhigVcidYdZa^ciZg‚hfjZ
egZhiVVZhidh[Zc‹bZcdh!edgdigVeVgiZgZX^W^‹jcZ_ZbeaVg
YZ:aA^WgdYZadh:he†g^ijhZck^VYdedgZaegde^d6aaVc@VgYZX#
:cZ[ZXid!bjX]VhdWgVhigVYjXZchjY^h\jhidedgcdedYZg
ZhXVeVgVadha†b^iZhYZaVXdcY^X^‹c]jbVcVVh†Xdbdhj
cZXZh^YVYYZZkVh^‹c^bV\^cVg^Vb{hVaa{YZai^ZbednYZaV
bjZgiZ#I]‚de]^aZ<Vji^Zgbjg^‹Zc&-,'ZcCZj^aan#
(VS¡ULWD
:hiVcdkZaV[Vci{hi^XV[jZejWa^XVYVZccdk^ZbWgZYZ&-+*!
edgZa¹Bdc^idgjc^kZghVaº#:aegdiV\dc^hiVYZaVcdkZaV!fjZ
hZ aaVbV <jn 9Z BVa^kZgi! ZcigV Zc Xdbjc^XVX^‹c Xdc Za
Zhe†g^ijYZjcV_dkZcfjZcdaZ]VW†VXdc[ZhVYdhjVbdg
/(-2851$/63,5,7(1o$%5,/
XjVcYd k^k†V# JcV kZo bjZgiV! hj Zhe†g^ij bVc^[^ZhiV hjh
hZci^b^Zcidh#:aa^Wgd:he†g^iVd[gZXZjcVk^h^‹cigVcfj^a^oVYdgV
nhZgZcVYZabjcYdZhe^g^ijVa!YZaVhgZaVX^dcZhYZVbdgn
YZadh^ciZgXVbW^dhhZci^bZciVaZhfjZejZYZcZm^hi^gZcigZ
ZcXVgcVYdhnYZhZcXVgcVYdh!b{hVaa{YZaVbjZgiZ#:caV
a^iZgVijgVcdkZaZhXV!aVbjZgiZZhgZegZhZciVYVXdbdjcV
igV\ZY^VfjZedcZ[^cVaVbdg#6]dgVW^Zc!Zc:he†g^iV!ZaaVcd
Zhjc[gZcdVadhhZci^b^ZcidhVbdgdhdh![VkdgZX^ZcYdedg
ZaXdcigVg^djcVeVh^‹cVWhdajiVnidiVaedgfjZZhk^k^YVZc
ZaeaVcdZhe^g^ijVa#
5HVXPHQGHODREUD
AV ]^hidg^V i^ZcZ aj\Vg Zc EVg†h# <jn YZ BVa^kZgi! _dkZc
bjcYVcd WVhiVciZ Z\d†hiV! [gZXjZciV V jcV _dkZc k^jYV!
aV hZŠdgV YZNbWZgXdjgi! h^c ZmeZg^bZciVg! h^c ZbWVg\d!
jc hZci^b^Zcid bjn egd[jcYd ]VX^V ZaaV# JcV bVŠVcV!
hj bVcd Zh egZhV YZ ]dgb^\jZdh n ZhXg^WZ! Xdbd V hj
eZhVg! jcV XVgiV YZ gjeijgV# :hijeZ[VXid! YZX^YZ ^g V XVhV
YZ hj Vb^\V0 n! Va bdbZcid YZ hVa^g XgZZ ZhXjX]Vg jc
hjhe^gd#6a\jcVh]dgVhb{hiVgYZ!ZaWVg‹cYZ;‚gd‚!aZYV
jcZmigVŠdXdchZ_d/¹FjZYZjhiZYa^WgZeVgVZaVbdgfjZ!
fj^o{h!aZk^h^iVg{#AdhZhe†g^ijhi^ZcZcZad_dhdWgZjhiZYº#
9Z]ZX]d!aVhhZŠVaZhYZab{hVaa{hZbjai^ea^XVc#9ZhYZZa
Y†Vh^\j^ZciZ!VabdbZcidYZZcigVgVaVXVhVYZaVhZŠdgV
YZNbWZgXdjgi!dnZbjgbjgVgZchjd†Yd/¹CdZcigZhº#:c
hjXVhV!ZcjcZheZ_dkZcZX^Vcd!kZ[dgbVghZadhgVh\dhYZa
gdhigdYZjcV_dkZcVaVfjZWVji^oV¹:he†g^iVº#:cZaaV\dYZa
7dhfjZkjZakZVZcXdcigVgVfjZaaVVeVg^X^‹cZcjcig^cZd!n
hZaVcoVh^c‚m^idZchjeZghZXjX^‹c#CddWhiVciZ!:he†g^iV
hZaZgZkZaVYZcjZkdZc[dgbVYZjcVbVcdY^{[VcVfjZ
hj\^ZgZZa\ZhidYZZhXg^W^g#<jnXdbegZcYZfjZYZWZhZgk^g
YZ^ciZgbZY^Vg^d!YZb‚Y^jb!nZhXg^WZjcVXdcbdkZYdgV
Xdc[Zh^‹c/ aV k^g\^cVa VeVg^X^‹c Zh jc VabV fjZ ZheZgV hj
_j^X^d0Zchjk^YViZggZcVa!Vb‹adXVbZciZV<jnnbjg^‹Zc
ZaXdckZcidVaVZYVYYZY^ZX^dX]dVŠdh#
'+
$OJXQRVH[WUDFWRV
7KžRSKLOH*DXWLHU
¹8jVcYd Zhijkd Zc aV XVaaZ! eZch‹! cd h^c X^Zgid iZbdg! Zc aV
VYkZgiZcX^VhdWgZcVijgVafjZ]VW†VgZX^W^YdVciZhYZZcigVgZcaV
XVhVYZaVhZŠdgVYZNbWZgXdjginZcaVk^h^iVYZaWVg‹cYZ;‚gd‚!
fjZXd^cX^Y^‹YZbVcZgViVch^c\jaVgXdchjYZhdWZY^ZcX^VVVfjZa
b^hiZg^dhdVk^hd#AZeVgZX†VfjZZaWVg‹c]VW†Vh^YdZck^VYdXdbd
VedndedgadhedYZgZhdXjaidhXjnVegZhZcX^VhZci†VkV\VbZciZV
hjVagZYZYdg#<jnYZBVa^kZgi!h^chZgh^hiZb{i^XVbZciZ^cXg‚Yjadc^
ZhX‚ei^Xd!cdiZc†Vh^cZbWVg\daV[Z[{X^a!n_Vb{hhZaZ]VW†Vk^hid
XdciV\^VYdedgadhZchjZŠdhYZadhbV\cZi^oVYdgZh!YZaVhbZhVh
\^gVciZh n YZ adh Zhe†g^ijh \daeZVYdgZh# =VhiV hZci†V jcV hjZgiZ
YZ gZejah^‹c ]VX^V ZhVh ZmeZg^ZcX^Vh YdcYZ hZ fj^ZgZ ZmeadiVg ad
bVgVk^aadhd!nhZ]VW†VcZ\VYdVkZgVaX‚aZWgZ=dbZYZfj^ZcZc
hjbdbZcidhZdXje‹idYdEVg†h#IdYVk†VaVk†heZgV!hZYZheaVoVWV
XdbdjcbjX]VX]dYZhegZdXjeVYd!YZWjZc]jbdg!WVhiVciZ[Za^o!
ZchjbV!YZZhiVgZcZabjcYd!YdcYZcd]VX†VYZbVh^VYdbVaV
[^\jgV!ZcXZggVYdZcZaX†gXjadYZaVhXdhVhk^h^WaZhnh^c^cfj^ZiVghZ
edgfjZ Za eaVcZiV VggVhigVgV Xdc ‚a Zc hj gdcYV VagZYZYdg YZa hda
jcVVib‹h[ZgVVc^bVYVdcdedgjcVedWaVX^‹cYZhZgZh^ck^h^WaZh
Z^ciVc\^WaZh#H^cZbWVg\d!cdedY†VYZ_VgYZXdckZc^gZcfjZaVh
XdcY^X^dcZhYZhjk^YV]VW†VcXVbW^VYd0jcZaZbZcidcjZkdigViVWV
YZ^cigdYjX^ghZ!h^cfjZad]jW^ZgVaaVbVYd!ZchjZm^hiZcX^V]VhiV
ZcidcXZh iVc VeVX^WaZ n YZ aV fjZ ]VW†V YZhiZggVYd Xdc Xj^YVYd
idYVhaVhegdWVWaZhXVjhVhYZYZhdgYZc#:gVedXVXdhVidYVk†V/jc
hjhe^gd Y‚W^a Xdbd jc \Zb^Yd YZ VgeV Z‹a^XV! jcV hjhi^ijX^‹c YZ
eZchVb^Zcid Zc jcV XVgiV ZhXg^iV bVfj^cVabZciZ! igZh eVaVWgVh
hdeaVYVh Va d†Yd! Za ZcXjZcigd YZ jc WVg‹c YZ V^gZ hdaZbcZ n
[Vi†Y^Xd!eZgdZgVZk^YZciZfjZZaZhe†g^ij\^gVWVVhjVagZYZYdg#:a
WVg‹cYZ;‚gd‚aZZmea^X‹VBVa^kZgiaVk^YVYZadhZhe†g^ijhYZhej‚h
YZhjbjZgiZnX‹bdejZYZcZaadhbVc^[ZhiVghZ/»jhiZY]VhZgk^Yd
YZb‚Y^jb!edgfjZaVhgZaVX^dcZhcdZhi{cbjnZhiVWaZX^YVhZcigZ
jhiZYnZaZhe†g^ijfjZaZk^h^iV¼!Y^_dZaWVg‹cYZ;‚gd‚0»eZgdegdcid
cd cZXZh^iVg{ b{h YZ Zhidh bZY^dh YZ Xdbjc^XVX^‹c aZcidh n
ghi^Xdh#HjhVabVhhZXdbeZcZigVg{cedgZaeZchVb^ZcidnZaYZhZd!
h^cc^c\ch^\cdZmiZg^dg/ªEVgZXZjhiZYegZdXjeVYd4¼
»H†! ad Xdc[^Zhd¼! gZhedcY^‹ BVa^kZgi! »Zhidn Zc jcV hjZgiZ YZ
ZbWg^V\jZo!nVXVYV^chiVciZbZegZ\jcidh^cdhdnegZhVYZVa\jcV
VajX^cVX^‹c¼#
»6]jnZciZ iVaZh ^YZVh fjZ ]Vg†Vc ]j^g Za Zhe†g^ij eVgV h^ZbegZ!
cd igViZ jhiZY YZ Zmea^XVg ad ^cZmea^XVWaZ! n VWVcY‹cZhZ Xdc jcV
[ZnjcVhjb^h^‹cVWhdajiVhVaV^c[ajZcX^VfjZaZ\j†V#AVbZcdg
YjYV igVZg†V jcV gjeijgV n aZ XVjhVg†V ZiZgcVh aVbZciVX^dcZh# Jc
eZgb^hdgVgVbZciZVXdgYVYdgZcZZcZaX^ZadVaVhVabVhfjZcd
hZ]VcZcXdcigVYdZcaVk^YV0Vegdk‚X]Zad!nbj‚higZhZY^\cdYZiVa
[Za^X^YVY¼#
»HZg‚Y^\cdYZZaaV!Xg‚VbZ!ncd]Vg‚hj[g^gdigVkZoV®:he†g^iV¯
adhYdadgZhfjZaZ]Z^c[a^\^Ydh^cfjZgZgb^ZcigVhidYVk†V]VW^iVWV
ZhiZbjcYd#EZgd!e^ZchdV]dgV!ZcZagZaVidfjZbZY^Xi‹ZhiZVabV
VYdgVWaZ!cdbZY^_dZacdbWgZfjZiZc†VZcaVi^ZggV¼#
»ªFj^ZgZhVWZgad4KVnVVaEƒgZ"AVX]V^hZ!hjWVaVXda^cVn!XZgXVYZaV
XVe^aaV!kZg{jhiZYjcVijbWVYZb{gbdaWaVcXdhdWgZaVXjVaZhi{
ZhXjae^YVjcVXgjoXV†YVnVYdgcVYVZchjigVkZhVŠdedgjcVXdgdcV
YZgdhVhYZYZa^XVYVh]d_VhYZb{gbda!dWgVbVZhigVYZjcX‚aZWgZ
X^cXZa#:cZabZYVaa‹c[dgbVYdedgaVXdgdcV!jcVWgZkZ^chXg^eX^‹c
aZ bdhigVg{ ad fjZ cd ]Z h^Yd Vjidg^oVYd [dgbVabZciZ V YZX^gaZ#
AVijbWV!ZchjbjYdaZc\jV_Z!]VWaVg{Zcb^aj\VgVjcfjZ!eVgV
b†!ZhVZhjcVXjg^dh^YVYkVcV#FjZ^bedgiVjccdbWgZiZggZcVa!
XjVcYd hZ igViV YZ jc ZiZgcd Vbdg# EZgd jhiZY idYVk†V cd Zhi{
/(-2851$/63,5,7(1o$%5,/
',
XdbeaZiVbZciZYZhed_VYdYZaVh^YZVh]jbVcVh!nZhdhZ
XdcX^WZ#Cd]VXZbjX]di^ZbedfjZjhiZY]VejZhidZae^Z
[jZgVYZaX†gXjadfjZZcX^ZggVaVk^YVdgY^cVg^V¼#
<jnhZY^g^\ZVaVijbWVYZaV_dkZcnXgZZkZgVaZ_VghZjcV
[dgbV ZhWZaiV n WaVcXV# 9ZhYZ ZcidcXZh! hj Zm^hiZcX^V hZ
Y^k^YZ Zc Ydh eVgiZh Y^hi^ciVh! jcV gZVa! aV digV [Vci{hi^XV#
:a Vbdg YZ :he†g^iV aZ ^che^gV! aZ ZmVaiV n ]VhiV aZ YV! edg
jcbdbZcid!aV^YZVYZfjZYZ_VhjZckdaijgViZggZcVa#HZ
YZhe^YZ[^cVabZciZYZaVhZŠdgVYZNbWZgXdjgineVgiZZc
jc XgjXZgd ]VX^V <gZX^V0 :he†g^iV k^V_V V hj aVYd# 9jgVciZ
jcVZmXjgh^‹cYZbdciVŠVedgadhVagZYZYdgZhYZ6iZcVh!
YZhVeVgZXZ# :a \j†V XjZciV fjZ jcdh WVcYdaZgdh ViVXVgdc
Za\gjednbViVgdcVa_dkZcYZjcWVaVod!eZgdfjZZcZhZ
bdbZcidjcV[^\jgVYZgZheaVcYZX^ZciZVaWdgnbVgVk^aadhV
]ZgbdhjgVWV_‹YZaX^ZadeVgVidbVgZaVabVYZabjZgidn
kdaVgXdcZaaV#6]dgVW^Zc!Vab^hbdi^Zbed!Zchj]VW^iVX^‹c
YZEVg†h!ZaWVg‹cYZ;‚gd‚h^ci^‹jcVk^hdb^hiZg^dhd0n!Va
aZkVciVgaVXVWZoV!ejYdkZgZaZkVghZZcZaX^ZadYdhejcidh
Wg^aaVciZh/»EgdcidhZVXZgXVgdcXVYVkZob{hn!XdbdYdh
\diVhYZgdX†dfjZgjZYVchdWgZaVb^hbV]d_VYZVojXZcV!
iZgb^cVgdc edg [jcY^ghZ Zc jcV eZgaV c^XV¼# »=Zadh Vaa†
[Za^XZheVgVh^ZbegZ0hjhVabVhgZjc^YVh[dgbVcjc{c\ZaYZ
Vbdg¼0Y^XZXdcjchjhe^gdbZaVcX‹a^XdZaWVg‹cYZ;‚gd‚#»N
nd!ªXj{cidi^ZbediZcYg‚fjZZheZgVgidYVk†V4¼º
$YDWDU
6kViVgZh^\jVabZciZjcVcdkZaVZhe†g^iVYZI]‚de]^aZ<Vji^Zg#
:c^cY^d¹6kViVgºh^\c^[^XVZcXVgcVX^‹c!igVch[dgbVX^‹c#
5HVXPHQGH$YDWDU
6kViVg Zh aV ]^hidg^V YZ jc ]dbWgZ aaVbVYd DXiVkZ YZ
HVk^aaZ# :c[Zgbd YZ Vbdg! YZX^YZ ZcidcXZh V ^chiVcX^Vh
YZ hj bVYgZ ]VXZghZ ViZcYZg edg Za YdXidg 7VaiVhVg
8]ZgWZccZVj!fjZ]VW†VZhiVYdZcaV>cY^V#DXiVkZZmea^XV
VaYdXidgfjZYjgVciZjck^V_ZV;adgZcX^V!hZZcVbdg‹YZ
aVXdcYZhVEgVhXdk^ZA^W^ch`V#:hiZVbdgcdi^ZcZZheZgVcoV
YZgZX^egdX^YVY!ejZhaVXdcYZhVVbVVhjbVg^YdZaXdcYZ
DaV[A^W^ch`V#:aYdXidg8]ZgWZccZVjeZgbjiVZcidcXZhaVh
VabVhYZadhYdhg^kVaZhk^kdhfjZidbVcVh†aVVeVg^ZcX^V
jcdYZadigd#:agZhjaiVYdcdZhZaZheZgVYdedgDXiVkZYZ
HVk^aaZ!EgVhXdk^ZadgZX]VoV!ejZhcdgZXdcdXZZaVabVYZ
hjZhedhd#:cidcXZhXVYVjcdgZXjeZgVhjXjZged#:aYdXidg
VegdkZX]VaVdXVh^‹ceVgVVegde^VghZZaXjZgedYZDXiVkZ
YZ HVk^aaZ eVgV ]ZgZYVg hj egde^V X^ZcX^V n egdhZ\j^g hjh
ZhijY^dhXdcjcXjZgedb{h_dkZc#
$OJXQRVH[WUDFWRV
¹¼KVbdh¼!Y^XZ7VaiVhVg8]ZgWdccZVj!»Xdc[†ZZcb†!hdnZa
b‚Y^XdYZaVhVabVh¼#
¸»N W^Zc! YdXidg! bZ bjZgd YZ Vbdg# BZ ZcXdcigVWV Zc
;adgZcX^V° AaZ\‹ jcV XVaZhV n k^ gZheaVcYZXZg V jcV
bj_ZgYZjcVWZaaZoV^cXdbeVgVWaZ#NdZhiVWVVXVWVaad
n ejYZ VXZgXVgbZ ad WVhiVciZ eVgV cd eZgYZg c^c\c
YZiVaaZ YZ ZhiV dWgV YZ VgiZ ]jbVcV#6ciZ aV VeVg^X^‹c
YZ ZhiV WZaaZoV hjegZbV! dak^Y‚ b^h VbdgZh YZ VciVŠd#
AVh e{\^cVh YZ b^ XdgVo‹c kdak^Zgdc V ZhiVg Zc WaVcXd/
idYd cdbWgZ n idYd gZXjZgYd! YZhVeVgZX^Zgdc# 6fjZa
[ViVaZcXjZcigd[ZX]‹eVgVb†jcVk^YVcjZkV#JcY†V!cd
ejY^ZcYdXdciZcZgb{hb^^beZg^dhdYZhZdYZkZgVaV
/(-2851$/63,5,7(1o$%5,/
XdcYZhV!VYZaVci‚aV]dgVYZb^VXdhijbWgVYVk^h^iV#BZ
hZci‚[gZciZVZaaVhdWgZaVh^aaVfjZbZVh^\c‹¼#
¸»Cd Y^\V jcV eVaVWgV! DXiVkZ0 jhiZY bZ VbV! ad h‚! ad
h^Zcid!adXgZd0cdaZgZegdX]dZcVWhdajid!ejZhZaVbdg
Zh^ckdajciVg^d#AZXdbeVYZoXd!ejZhcdejZYdfjZgZgaZ!
nZhjcVeZcVeVgVb†hZghjYZhY^X]V#AVbZcidfjZbZ
]VnV ZcXdcigVYd# Eg^bZgd ZheZg‚ fjZ b^ eZgh^hiZciZ
[g^VaYVY aZ XVchVg†V n hZ VaZ_VgV# FjZ b^ WZc^\c^YVY cd
]V\VcVXZgZcjhiZYc^c\jcV^ajh^‹c!c^c\chjZŠd!ncd
idbZb^a{hi^bVedgjcVa^Zcid#Jc{c\ZaXdcZhXjYdYZ
Y^VbVciZ n ZheVYV gZheaVcYZX^ZciZ! bZ egdiZ\Z XdcigV
idYVhZYjXX^‹c!bZ_dgfjZaVgZa^\^‹c!bZ_dgfjZZaYZWZg!
bZ_dg fjZ aV k^gijY0 n ZhZ {c\Za Zh b^ Vbdg/ VYdgd Va
XdcYZAVW^ch`^#IZc\daV[Za^X^YVYYZ]VWZgZcXdcigVYdaV
eVh^‹cZcZabVig^bdc^d¼#
JcV daZVYV YZ a{\g^bVh Wgdi‹ YZ b^h e{geVYdh VciZ ZhiV
Xdc[Zh^‹ciVc[gVcXV!iVcaZVaniVccdWaZbZciZeY^XV!n
hZci†Zcb†gdbeZghZZagZhdgiZYZb^k^YV#6aY†Vh^\j^ZciZ
VWVcYdc‚ ;adgZcX^V#»ª=V kjZaid jhiZY V kZg V aV XdcYZhV
EgVhXdk^ZAVW^ch`^4¼Y^_dZaYdXidg!Xjndhd_dhVojaZhWg^aaVWVc
ZmigVŠVbZciZ# »Cd¼! gZhedcY^‹ DXiVkZ! »eZgd ZaaV Zhi{ Zc
EVg†h¼#6aa†k^k†VYZhYZ]VX†VVa\ci^ZbedaVXdcYZhVEgVhXdk^Z
AVW^ch`^XdchjbVg^YdZaXdcYZDaV[AVW^ch`^!YZhej‚hfjZ
‚hiZgZ\gZh‹YZaV\jZggVYZa8{jXVhd#8dcfj‚ZbWg^V\jZo
hZ]VW†VcZcXdcigVYdVfjZaadhYdhZhedhdh#ª8‹bde^ciVg
ZhVh Ydh VabVh [jcY^YVh Zc jcV hdaV n hZbZ_VciZh V Ydh
a{\g^bVhYZgdX†dfjZ!YZha^o{cYdhZhdWgZjce‚iVadYZa^g^d!
hZZcXjZcigVc!hZbZoXaVc!hZVWhdgWZcjcVVaVdigVncd
[dgbVcnVh^cdjcVeZgaVc^XV4DaV[nEgVhXdk^ZhZ]VW†Vc
VbVYd YZhYZ c^Šdh0 cjcXV hjh XdgVodcZh ]VW†Vc aVi^Yd
b{h fjZ edg jc hdad cdbWgZ0 hVW†Vc XVh^ YZhYZ aV XjcV
fjZhZeZgiZcZXZg†Vc0[dgbVWVcZhVYjVa^YVYZcaVjc^YVY!
fjZ Zh aV Vgbdc†V XdbeaZiV n! _jcidh! bVgX]VWVc! d b{h
W^Zc kdaVWVc! edg aV k^YV Zc jc kjZad ^Y‚ci^Xd! hdhiZc^Yd!
YZha^o{cYdhZXdbdYdheVadbVhVaVhfjZZab^hbdYZhZd
aaVbV! eVgV hZgk^gcdh YZ aV ]ZgbdhV ZmegZh^‹c YZ 9VciZ#
JhiZYZhXdbegZcYZg{cfjZXdchZbZ_VciZg^kVa!DXiVkZYZ
HVk^aaZiZc†VedXVdedgijc^YVYnfjZ]VX†VW^ZcZcYZ_VghZ
bdg^gigVcfj^aVbZciZhdWgZadhXd_^cZhYZhjY^k{c!VeZhVg
YZaVZheZgVcoVfjZ^ciZciVWVkdakZgV^chj[aVgZchjXdgVo‹c
Za[Vci{hi^XdYdXidg7VaiVhVg8]ZgWdccZVj#»HjgZaVid!fjZ
]Z ZhXjX]VYd ViZciVbZciZ¼! Y^XZ Za YdXidg V DXiVkZ!»bZ
YZbjZhigVfjZidYVZheZgVcoVYZhjeVgiZhZg†Vfj^b‚g^XV#
AV XdcYZhV _Vb{h XdbeVgi^g{ hj Vbdg# =Z Y^X]d fjZ cd
]VW†V ZheZgVcoV Xdc adh bZY^dh dgY^cVg^dh¼! egdh^\j^‹ Va
YdXidg0»eZgdZm^hiZcedYZgZhdXjaidhfjZaVX^ZcX^VbdYZgcV
YZhXdcdXZnfjZaVigVY^X^‹c]VXdchZgkVYdZcZhdheV†hZh
ZmigVŠdh YZcdb^cVYdh W{gWVgdh edg jcV X^k^a^oVX^‹c
^\cdgVciZ#Fj^ZgdYZX^g¼!gZhedcY^‹igVcfj^aVbZciZ7VaiVhVg
8]ZgWdccZVj!»fjZcd]Zdak^YVYdaV[‹gbjaVb{\^XVYZb^
Vb^\d7gV]bV"Ad\jb!XdcdX^YdZcaVh>cY^Vh!naVXdcYZhV
EgVhXdk^ZhZg†Vbjn[^cVh^gZXdcdX^ZgVZaVabVYZDXiVkZYZ
HVk^aaZZcZaXjZgedYZDaV[AVW^ch`^¼#
:a XdcYZ DaV[ AVW^ch`^ ]VW†V d†Yd ]VWaVg YZ adh b^aV\gdh
gZVa^oVYdh edg Za YdXidg n hj Xjg^dh^YVY bZY^d Xg‚YjaV hZ
]VW†VZcXZcY^Yd#K^h^i‹ejZhVaiVjbVijg\d#9jgVciZhjk^h^iV!
Zab‚Y^XdaZ]^odidXVgjcbZiVaXVg\VYdYZjcbV\cZi^hbd
[ja\jgVciZnXVn‹Xdbd[jab^cVYd#:aYdXidg]VXZWjhXVg
'-
DXiVkZ YZ HVk^aaZ# DXiVkZ hZ egZhZciV VciZ Za YdXidg0 dXjggZc
ZcidcXZhXdhVhbjnZmigVŠVhn!Xdcjc\ZhidXaVgdYZaYdXidg!Za
VabVYZDXiVkZdXjeVZaXjZgedYZaXdcYZAVW^ch`^nZaVabVYZa
XdcYZ Za YZ DXiVkZ0 Za VkViVg ZhiVWV Xjbea^Yd#»9ZheZgiZbdh V
cjZhigdh Yjgb^ZciZh¼! Y^XZ 8]ZgWdccZVj#»N W^Zc¼! Y^XZ Za YdXidg
XjVcYd ]jWd Y^h[gjiVYd ad hj[^X^ZciZ YZ aV hdgegZhV YZ DXiVkZ"
AVW^ch`^!»ªfj‚aZeVgZXZhjcjZkVk^k^ZcYV4ªHZZcXjZcigVhjVabV
W^Zc^chiVaVYVZcZaXjZgedYZZhiZZcXVciVYdg_^cZiZ!bVg^YdYZ
aVbj_Zgb{h]ZgbdhVYZabjcYd4¼6]dgV!idYVhaVhejZgiVhYZaV
bVch^‹cAVW^ch`^aZZhi{cVW^ZgiVhYZeVgZceVg#DXiVkZ"AVW^ch`^
kjZakZVhjXVhVnkVVkZgVaVXdcYZhV#6jcfjZc^c\jcVeZghe^XVX^V
]jbVcV]jW^ZgVedY^YdVY^k^cVgZab^hiZg^dhdYZheaVoVb^ZcidYZ
VabVhdeZgVYdedgZaYdXidg8]ZgWdccZVjedgbZY^dYZaV[‹gbjaV
YZa hVccn}h^ 7gV]bV"Ad\jb! EgVhXdk^Z cd gZXdcdX†V! Zc adh d_dh
YZ DXiVkZ"AVW^ch`^! aV ZmegZh^‹c dgY^cVg^V YZ adh d_dh YZDaV[!aV
YZ jc Vbdg ejgd! hZgZcd! XdchiVciZ! ZiZgcd0 jcV eVh^‹c iZggZcVa
^cXZcY^VWVVfjZaaVb^gVYVfjZaVYZhXdcXZgiVWV#:aaVcdhZYVWV
XjZciVYZadfjZ]VW†VeVhVYd!eZgdVa\d]VW†VeVhVYd#ª:aVXjZgYd
hjWa^bZYZhjhVabVh]VW†Vh^YdgdidedgVa\jcVY^hdcVcX^VfjZZaaV
YZhXdcdX†V4G{e^YVbZciZhZeaVciZ‹ZhVhegZ\jciVhh^cedYZgaVh
gZhedcYZgYZbVcZgVhVi^h[VXidg^VnhZY^_dfjZZhiVWVadXV/eZgd!Zc
Za[dcYd!hZci†VfjZiZc†VgVo‹c#JciZggdghZXgZidaV^ckVY†VXdbd
h^ ]jW^ZgV ZhiVYd Zc egZhZcX^V YZ jc eZa^\gd YZhXdcdX^Yd! eZgd
egZhZci^YdedgZhVhZ\jcYVk^hiVYZaVabV!VaVfjZjcdh^ZbegZhZ
Zfj^kdXVh^cddWZYZXZ#HZaZkVci‹V\^iVYVncZgk^dhVnhZY^g^\^‹
]VX^V aV ejZgiV YZ hj Ydgb^idg^d# :a [Vahd XdcYZ aV VXdbeVŠ‹!
gdYZVcYdhjX^cijgVXdcjcWgVod!eZgdXjVcYdaaZ\‹VajbWgVa!ZaaV
hZkdak^‹!hZYZijkdjc^chiVciZ!WaVcXVn[g†VXdbdjcVZhiVijV!Y^d
jck^hiVodYZVhdbWgdVa_dkZc!Zcig‹!XZgg‹aVejZgiVg{e^YVbZciZ
nZX]‹ZaXZggd_d»«AVb^gVYVYZDXiVkZ¼:mXaVb‹XVnZcYdhZb^
YZhkVcZX^YVhdWgZjcY^k{c#8jVcYdejYdgZXjeZgVghjhhZci^Ydh!
hZY^_d/»ªEZgdX‹bdZhfjZZhVb^gVYV!XjnVZmegZh^‹ccjcXV]Z
dak^YVYd!Wg^aaVZhiVcdX]ZZcadhd_dhYZDaV[4ª8‹bd]Zk^hidZhV
aaVbVhdbWg†VnYZhZheZgVYVVajbWgVgVigVk‚haVheje^aVhYZb^
bVg^Yd4«DaV[«DaV[H^bZ]ZZfj^kdXVYd!h^]ZXZY^YdadXVbZciZ
V kVcdh iZggdgZh! bZ eZgYdcVg{h0 eZgd fjZ h^ iZ ]jW^ZgV VXd\^Yd
ZhiVcdX]Z!]jW^ZgVXgZ†YdZcigZ\VgbZVdigd¼#
Cdhdigdh cd igViVgZbdh YZ YZhXg^W^g aV XdcigVg^ZYVY YZ DXiVkZ
XjVcYdhZZcXdcig‹VciZjcVejZgiVXZggVYVndn‹ZaX]^gg^Yd^ciZg^dg
YZaXZggd_d#HjhjegZbVZheZgVcoVhZYZggjbWVWV#«Nfj‚wa]VW†V
gZXjgg^YdVbZY^dhiZgg^WaZh!ZmigVŠdh!Vgg^Zh\VcYdhjk^YVZcZhiZ
bjcYdnhjVabVZcZadigdeVgVXdcfj^hiVgVjcVbj_ZgfjZhZaZ
ZhXVeVWV!VjcfjZa^WgVYd^cYZ[ZchdVh†b^hbdedgaVhWgj_Zg†VhYZ
aV>cY^V#GZX]VoVYdXdbdVbVciZ!adZgViVbW^‚cXdbdbVg^Yd#6a
Y†V h^\j^ZciZ! YjgVciZ Za YZhVnjcd! EgVhXdk^Z aZ ]VWa‹ Zc edaVXd!
aZc\jVYZhXdcdX^YVedgDXiVkZ"AVW^ch`^#:aYZhXdcX^ZgidYZaedWgZ
VbVciZZgV]dgg^WaZ0cd]VW†V^bV\^cVYdZhiVhXdbea^XVX^dcZhVa
Zc[jcYVghZ Zc aV e^Za YZa XdcYZ DaV[ AVW^ch`^ n XdbegZcY^‹ fjZ
gdWVcYd aV [dgbV YZ digd! jcd hZ Zmedc†V V Yjgdh YZhZc\VŠdh#
6a idbVg Za XjZged YZa XdcYZ DaV[ AVW^ch`^! ]jW^ZgV cZXZh^iVYd
gdWVgaZ iVbW^‚c hjh cdX^dcZh VciZg^dgZh! aVh aZc\jVh fjZ edhZ†V!
hjhgZXjZgYdhYZc^ŠZo!adhb^aYZiVaaZh†ci^bdhfjZXdbedcZcZa
nd YZ jc ]dbWgZ! aVh gZaVX^dcZh fjZ k^cXjaVc hj Zm^hiZcX^VVaVh
digVhZm^hiZcX^Vh/neVgVZhdcd]jW^ZgVWVhiVYdidYdZahVWZgYZa
YdXidg7VaiVhVg8]ZgWdccZVj#«Fj‚gVW^V=VW^iVgWV_dZab^hbd
iZ_VYdfjZEgVhXdk^Z!kZgaV!]VWaVgaZ!WZhVghj]ZgbdhVbVcdXdcadh
b^hbdhaVW^dhYZhjbVg^YdncdedYZgZc\VŠVghjejYdgXZaZhiZ!
«nigV^X^dcVghZVXVYV^chiVciZedgVa\jcV^cZmea^XVWaZZhije^YZo
/(-2851$/63,5,7(1o$%5,/
'.
»«:hiVWV ZhXg^id Vaa{ Vgg^WV fjZ EgVhXdk^Z cd bZ VbVg†V cjcXV
H^c ZbWVg\d! ]Z ]ZX]d Za bVndg hVXg^[^X^d Va ejZYV YZhXZcYZg
Zadg\jaad]jbVcd/]ZgZcjcX^VYdVb^nd¼#JcXg^VYd!VaVWg^gaV
ejZgiV!VcjcX^‹Vjck^h^iVciZ#»Hg#DXiVkZYZHVk^aaZ¼#:aXdcYZDaV[!
gZkZhi^YdYZaVVeVg^ZcX^VYZDXiVkZ!hZVYZaVci‹]VX^VaVXdcYZhV
VaVfjZhVajY‹egd[jcYVbZciZ#8dbegZcY^‹adfjZ]VW†VeVhVYd
njcVgVW^VhW^iVhZVedYZg‹YZ‚ak^ZcYdVhjZheZXigdVc^bVYd
edg digV VabV ^chiVaVYV Zc hj egde^V XVhV! n hZ VWVaVco‹ V aV
\Vg\VciVYZa[VahdXdcYZ#»«AVYg‹c!WVcYdaZgd!bVakVYd!YZkj‚akVbZ
b^e^Za¼B{hiVgYZ!DXiVkZ"AVW^ch`^gZX^W^‹jcVXVgiVXdca†cZVh!
igVoVYVh edg jcV bVcd [dgoVYV n Xdc jcV ZhXg^ijgV fjZ eVgZX†V
XdcigV]ZX]V!ejZhDaV[cdiZc†VaVXdhijbWgZYZZhXg^W^gXdcadh
YZYdhYZDXiVkZ#DaV[YZHVk^aaZgZiVWVVDXiVkZ"AVW^ch`^VYjZad#
6fj†! aVh XdcY^X^dcZh YZa YjZad! Zc VeVg^ZcX^V dgY^cVg^Vh eVgV adh
ZheZXiVYdgZh! ZgVc ZmigVŠVh eVgV adh XdbWVi^ZciZh# :c Z[ZXid!
XVYVjcdiZc†VYZaVciZVhjegde^dXjZgednYZW†VXaVkVgZaVXZgd
Zc jcV XVgcZ fjZ ]VhiV aV k†heZgV aZ ]VW†V eZgiZcZX^Yd# DXiVkZ"
AVW^ch`^iZc†VaVkZciV_V!eZgdaaVb‹VDaV[YZHVk^aaZeVgV]VWaVgaZ/
»Hj [Za^X^YVY Zhi{ Zc b^h bVcdh# EjZYd XdchZgkVg eVgV h^ZbegZ
ZhiZ XjZged YdcYZ bZ Vad_d ]dn n fjZ aZ eZgiZcZXZ V jhiZY Zc
aZ\†i^bVegde^ZYVY#EVgVaaZ\VgVEgVhXdk^Z!]ZZbeaZVYdjcbZY^d
]dgg^WaZ!]dggdgdhdnfjZh‹adjcVeVh^‹cYZa^gVciZedY†VegdkdXVg0
ZaYdXidg8]ZgWdccZVj]V^ciZciVYdXdcb^\djcigVWV_dfjZYZ_V
Vig{hVadhiVjbVijg\dhYZidYdhadheV†hZhnYZidYdhadhi^Zbedh#
9Zhej‚hYZ]VWZgcdhhjbZg\^YdVVbWdhZcZahjZŠd!]^odXVbW^Vg
bV\c‚i^XVbZciZ YZ Zckdaidg^d cjZhigVh VabVh# «B^aV\gd ^ci^a
KdnVYZkdakZgaZhjXjZged/«EgVhXdk^ZcdbZfj^ZgZ:caV[dgbV
YZa Zhedhd ]V gZXdcdX^Yd Za VabV YZa VbVciZ0 hj b^gVYV hZ ]V
Xdc\ZaVYdhdWgZZajbWgVaYZaVVaXdWVXdcnj\Va¼#DXiVkZYZHVk^aaZ
aZY^XZVaYdXidg8]ZgWdccZVj/
»B^XVgdYdXidg!edcYg‚VegjZWVhjX^ZcX^VjcVkZob{h/:hegZX^hd
gZ^ciZ\gVg cjZhigVh VabVh XVYV jcV V hj Ydb^X^a^d ]VW^ijVa¼# :a
edWgZ DXiVkZ hdŠVWV Xdc hj ZheZgVcoV YZhkVcZX^YV# :a YdXidg
8]ZgWdccZVj VXij‹# :a VabV YZ DXiVkZ hZ VaZ_‹ aZciVbZciZ YZa
XjZged YZ DaV[! n Zc aj\Vg YZ kdakZg Va hjnd! hZ ZaZk‹! hZ ZaZk‹
Xdbd XjVafj^ZgV [Za^o YZ hZg a^WgZ! n cd eVgZX†V egZdXjeVghZ edg
kdakZg V ZcigVg Zc hj eg^h^‹c# :a YdXidg ^ciZggjbe^‹ adh Zh[jZgodh
fjZ hVW†V hjeZg[ajdh n YZheZgi‹ Va XdcYZ fj^Zc! Va kZghZ Zc jc
ZheZ_dXdchjhgVh\dh]VW^ijVaZh!aVco‹jc\g^idYZVaZ\g†V#:aYdXidg
7VaiVhVg 8]ZgWdccZVj fjZY‹ hdad [gZciZ V [gZciZ Xdc Za XVY{kZg
YZDXiVkZYZHVk^aaZ#:aYdXidgidX‹ZaXjZged!b^g‹ZcZaZheZ_d
hjgdhigdVggj\VYd!Xjgi^Ydngj\dhdXdbdjcVe^ZaYZoVeV!Xdc
V^gZ h^c\jaVgbZciZ YZhYZŠdhd! n ]VX^ZcYd hdWgZ ‚a Za \Zhid Xdc
ZafjZhZYZhXVgiVjck^Z_digV_ZXjVcYdZahVhigZigVZjcdcjZkd!
bjgbjg‹ aV [‹gbjaV YZa hVccn}h^ 7gV]bV"Ad\jb# :chZ\j^YV! Za
XjZged YZa YdXidg 7VaiVhVg 8]ZgWdccZVj gdY‹ Xdbd [jab^cVYd
hdWgZaVVa[dbWgVnZaYZDXiVkZYZHVk^aaZhZ^g\j^‹[jZgiZ!VaZgiV
nk^kVo#»«6Y^‹h!edWgZ_^g‹c]jbVcd!b^hZgVWaZ]VgVedVW^ZgidZcZa
XdYd!gV†YdedgidYVhaVhXdhijgVh!fjZ]ZVggVhigVYdhZiZciVVŠdh
edgaVhX^cXdeVgiZhYZabjcYdBZ]VhegZhiVYdbjnWjZchZgk^X^d!
ncdiZYZ_dh^cVa\ceZhVg#«JcdhZVXdhijbWgVVadigdedgk^k^g
iVcidi^Zbed_jcidhEZgdXdcZhiZZckdaidg^d_dkZc!fjZb^X^ZcX^V
egdcid]VWg{kjZaidgdWjhid!edYg‚ZhijY^Vg!igVWV_VgnaZZgidYVk†V
Va\jcVh eVaVWgVh YZa \gVc a^Wgd! h^c fjZ aV bjZgiZ ad X^ZggZ Zc Za
e{ggV[db{h^ciZgZhVciZY^X^ZcYd/®«:hhj[^X^ZciZ¯¼AjZ\dYZZhV
dgVX^‹c[cZWgZY^g^\^YVVh†b^hbd!DXiVkZ"8]ZgWdccZVjhVa^‹Xdc
eVhdigVcfj^adeVgV^gVidbVgedhZh^‹cYZhjcjZkVZm^hiZcX^Vº#
/(-2851$/63,5,7(1o$%5,/
(&26
/26(6&5,725(6
,163,5$'26325(/0z6$//z
SRU
-2&(/<1(&+$5/(6
129(/$6)$17y67,&$6
'(7+23+,/(*$87,(5
°ZkdXVcZaVbdgYZ]dbWgZh_‹kZcZhedg
WZaaVh bjZgiVh/ 6gg^V BVgXZaaV! gZXjZgYd
YZ EdbeZnV/ :c Za h^\ad M>M! YjgVciZ jc
k^V_Z V C{edaZh! jcdh Vb^\dh k^h^iVgdc jc
bjhZd#AVXZc^oVbdaYZVYVYZjcV]ZgbdhV
^iVa^VcV ^c[aVbV Za XdgVo‹c YZ DXiVk^Zc#
:hiZ ZhijY^VciZ! hdŠVYdg! Zh dWhZh^dcVYd
ZcidcXZhedg6gg^V!]ZgbdhVedbeZnVcVYZa
eg^bZgh^\adYZhej‚hYZ8g^hid#
Dbe]VaZ/ZhiZXjZcidgZaViVaV[VhX^cVX^‹c
YZ jc ZhijY^VciZ YZ Y^ZX^h^ZiZ VŠdh edg
Dbe]VaZ!eZghdcV_Zb^ida‹\^XdfjZVeVgZXZ
ZcZaZbeVeZaVYdfjZYZXdgVaVheVgZYZhYZ
hj]VW^iVX^‹cnVafjZXgZZkZgVc^bVghZ#
AV bjZgiV ZcVbdgVYV/ :h aV ]^hidg^V YZ
jc _dkZc hVXZgYdiZ fjZ hZ ZcVbdgV
eZgY^YVbZciZYZaVXdgiZhVcV8aVg^bdcYZ#
EZgd!ZaaVbjZgZegdcidnYZhYZZcidcXZhhZ
aZVeVgZXZZchjZŠdh#
(%
'266,(5
/26(6&5,725(6,163,5$'26325(/0z6$//z
SRU
-($1/28,63(7,7
%$/=$&
81$&20(',$+80$1$08<(63…5,7$
+DEU¢D GH SDJDU FDUR HVDV KRUDV GH JORULD TXH FRQRFHU¢D HQ VX YLGD D FRVWD GH LQILQLWRV
VXIULPLHQWRV QL¥R VLQ DPRU MRYHQ FROHJLDO VROLWDULR \ DQJXVWLDGR YLGD TXH DOWHUQD V§UGLGDV
FRPLGDV\HOFRQWLQXRDFRVRGHORVDFUHHGRUHV
=
dcdg‚YZ7VaoVXgZegZhZciVVa¹\Zc^d[gVcX‚hºZcidYd
ZabjcYd0AV8dbZY^V]jbVcVZhi{igVYjX^YVVXVh^
ZcidYdhadh^Y^dbVhnhjVjidgZhjcdYZadh\gVcYZh
YZaVa^iZgVijgVbjcY^Va#ªHZg{edgfjZZhXg^W^‹bjX]†h^bd4
EdghjejZhidfjZcd!Za\Zc^da^iZgVg^dcdhZb^YZedgeZhd
c^edgbZigda^cZVaZcaVhWjZcVhW^Wa^diZXVh#
8dc [gZXjZcX^V cd hZ gZXjZgYV fjZ Za ZhijY^d YZ aVh
XdhijbWgZhZcAV8dbZY^V]jbVcV!fjZ[jZZai†ijadZaZ\^Yd
edgZaegde^d7VaoVXeVgVZhiZ^bedcZciZigdodYZk^YV!YViV
YZaVGZhiVjgVX^‹c#EgZ[^\jgV!YZ]ZX]d!jcViZdg†V[^adh‹[^XV
YZa ]dbWgZ n YZ hj YZhi^cd bjX]d bZcdh XdcdX^Yd fjZ
ZaZhijY^dYZXVgVXiZgZhYZaXjVacdXdchi^ijnZb{hfjZaV
WVhZ!b{hkdajb^cdhVedghjejZhid!Zao‹XVadYZjch^hiZbV
XdbeaZidYZeZchVb^Zcidhbjn^begZ\cVYdhYZZhe^g^i^hbd!
i‚gb^cdidYVk†Vcdji^a^oVYdedghjhXdciZbedg{cZdh#
(ODUWHGHOUHWUDWR
6jidg [adg^Yd! 7VaoVX cd ZhXdcYZ c^c\jcd YZ adh k^X^dh n
adh VeZi^idh YZ aV VkZcijgV ]jbVcV# 8dc jc gVgd iVaZcid
cVggVi^kd!edcZZcZhXZcVZcZhiV[VbdhV8dbZY^V]jbVcV
b{h YZ Ydh b^a eZghdcV_Zh Y^[ZgZciZh! fjZ hZ XgjoVc n hZ
ZcXjZcigVc Zc cdkZciV n jcV cdkZaVh! XjZcidh n ZhijY^dh
[^adh‹[^Xdh# Adh YZhi^cdh YZ adh GVhi^\cVX! 8‚hVg 7^gdiiZVj!
eVe{<dg^di!JghjaZB^gdjZi!niVcidhdigdh!hZegZX^hVch^c
aVbZcdgXdcigVY^XX^‹cYZjckdajbZcVdigdeVgViZ_ZgaV
igVbVYZjcV]jbVc^YVYfjZaVbVndg†VYZaVhkZXZhXdggZ
YZig{hYZhjhk^X^dhnhjh[VciVhbVh!VbZgXZYYZbZofj^cdh
egdnZXidh YZ k^YV! V bZcjYd \j^VYdh edg aV gVeVX^YVY! Za
\jhidedgZaY^cZgd!aVhbj_ZgZhnZaedYZg#AdhY‚W^aZhhdc
ig^ijgVYdhedgadhb{h[jZgiZh!fjZVhjkZohjXjbWZcVhjh
kVcdhegdnZXidh#
:hXdc[gZXjZcX^VjcVk^h^‹cX†c^XVnYZhZc\VŠVYVaVfjZhZ
i^ZcZYZjcVjidgXdch^YZgVYd]^eZg"gZVa^hiV#:cZ[ZXid!fj‚
iVaZcidXdbdZaYZ7VaoVXeVgVigVoVgZcVa\jcVh[gVhZhjc
gZigVidb{hkZgYVYZgdfjZcVijgVanfjZhZXdck^ZgiZZcZa
VgfjZi^edYZjcVkVgd!YZjcVbW^X^dhd!YZjc_jZg\j^hiV!ZiX#
?o\jZhZb{hW^Zc/=ZVfj†VajhjgZgd<dWhZX`!ZcHXƒcZhYZ
aVk^Zeg^k‚Z:hXZcVhYZaVk^YVeg^kVYV/
¹ª8VeiVg{jhiZYW^ZcZhV[^\jgVe{a^YVnbVX^aZciV!VaVXjVa
nd fj^h^ZgV fjZ aV VXVYZb^V bZ eZgb^i^ZgV YVg Za cdbWgZ
YZ XVgV YZ ajo4 HZ eVgZX†V V aV eaViV YZhYdgVYV# :a XVWZaad
YZb^jhjgZgdZgVa^hd!Xj^YVYdhVbZciZeZ^cVYdnYZjc\g^h
XZc^X^Zcid#AdhgVh\dhYZhjgdhigd!^beVh^WaZhXdbdadhYZa
hZŠdgYZIVaaZngVcY!eVgZX†Vc]VWZgh^YdkVX^VYdhZcWgdcXZ#
Hjh eZfjZŠdh d_dh VbVg^aadh Xdbd adh YZ jc ]jg‹c!XVh^cd
iZc†VceZhiVŠVhniZb†VcVaVajo!eZgdadhegdiZ\†VaVk^hZgV
YZjcVk^Z_V\dggV#HjcVg^oejci^V\jYVZhiVWViVce^XVYVZc
aVejciVfjZaV]jW^ZgV^hXdbeVgVYdVjcVWVggZcV#IZc†Vadh
aVW^dh YZa\VYdh YZ Zhdh Vafj^b^hiVh n k^Z_^idh e^ciVYdh edg
GZbWgVcYidedgBZioj#6fjZa]dbWgZ]VWaVWVWV_d!Zcidcd
hjVkZ!ncdhZZc[VYVWVcjcXV#HjZYVYZgVjcegdWaZbV/cd
hZedY†VhVWZgh^]VW†VZckZ_ZX^YdVciZhYZi^Zbeddh^]VW†V
ZXdcdb^oVYdhj_jkZcijYeVgVfjZaZh^gk^ZgVh^ZbegZ°ªIZc†V
eVg^ZciZh!Vb^\dh4:gVg^XddedWgZ!cVY^ZedY†VXdciZhiVgV
ZhVhegZ\jciVh#CjcXVhZkZ†VY^cZgdZchjXVhV°º
:cgZVa^YVY!aVXdbZY^VYZaVheVh^dcZh]jbVcVhidXVXdc
bVndg[gZXjZcX^VaVigV\ZY^V#CdhZgZi^ZcZejZhYZ7VaoVX
h^cdaVdhXjg^YVYYZaigVod!h^cedcZgXj^YVYdVaYZhVggdaadYZ
aVZedeZnVfjZYZYZhVhigZhZc[gVXVhdhYZ_VZcigZkZgVa\jcdh
[ja\dgZhYZgZYZcX^‹cnYZYZhi^cdh]Zgd^Xdh!V]d\VYdhZcZa
XjVYgdYZaVheVh^dcZhnZ\d†hbdhb{hXdbjcZh#
H^GVhi^\cVXXdggZYZhV[^VciZYZig{hYZa‚m^idWV_didYVhhjh
[dgbVh/¹EVg†heVgVadhYdhº!ZcXjVcidVeVe{<dg^di!‚aaaZkV
jcVk^YVYZeg^kVX^dcZheVgVegdXjgVgjcWjZcbVig^bdc^dV
hjhYdh]^_Vhg^XVbZciZYdiVYVh#Bdg^g{hdadZchjWj]VgY^aaV!
VWVcYdcVYdedgZaaVh!ejZhhZVkZg\dcoVg{cedghjdg^\Zc
naZdak^YVg{c#AdhhZgZh]jbVcdhhZZc\jaaZc!hZYZh\VggVc
ZcigZh†dhZYZhed_Vc![dgc^XVcnhZYZhV[†Vc!k^kZceVgVhjh
^chi^cidhnedgZhd[gVXVhVcVciZaV^cY^[ZgZcX^V\ZcZgVa#
EZgd!YZdWgVZcdWgV!VeVgZXZciVbW^‚cVa\jcVh[^\jgVhYZ
ZmXZeX^‹cfjZXdcigVhiVcXdcaVWja^b^V\ZcZgVa#
/(-2851$/63,5,7(1o$%5,/
(&
:c AZ Anh YVch aV KVaa‚Z! Zh aV hZŠdgV YZ BdgihVj[ fjZ hjed
gZh^hi^gVjcVbdgXdbeVgi^YdeVgVbVciZcZghj]dcdgYZbj_Zg
XVhVYV!VjcfjZhjbVg^YdaVigV^X^dcVWVXdcjcV^cY^[ZgZcX^VYZ
egde^ZiVg^d]Vhi^VYd#
:a 8dgdcZa 8]VWZgi! ]‚gdZ kVaZgdhd YZ aVh ZedeZnVh cVedaZ‹c^XVh
ZhYZXaVgVYdbjZgidZcZaXVbedYZWViVaaV#HZYZhe^ZgiVWV_djcV
e^aVYZkZgYVYZgdhbjZgidhnVXdhiVYZb^aeZg^eZX^VhgZ\gZhVVŠdh
b{h iVgYZ eVgV gZ^k^cY^XVg hj [dgijcV n hj bj_Zg! kjZaiV V XVhVg
YZhYZ ZcidcXZh# GZcjcX^V Va egdXZhd n XdbegZcY^ZcYd fjZ nV cd
Zh W^ZckZc^Yd! iZgb^cV YZhXdcdX^Yd n b^hZgVWaZ eZgd a^WgZ Zc jc
Vc‹c^bdVh^adYZVcX^Vcdh#
8QDYLGDDWRUPHQWDGD
7VaoVXXdcdX^‹W^ZcZhiZbjcYdnhjhhZŠjZadh#
6ciZhYZXdckZgi^ghZZcjceg^h^dcZgdYZaVZhXg^ijgV!VgVo‹cYZYdXZ
V XVidgXZ ]dgVh YZ igVWV_d YZhe^VYVYd! ^ciZci‹ bdciVg cZ\dX^dh!
fjZ iZgb^cVgdc idYdh Vggj^cVYdh# CZXZh^iVWV ZcidcXZh XgZVg eVgV
kZcYZg!kZcYZgadb{hedh^WaZjcVa^iZgVijgVXgZVYVV[jZgoVYZXV[‚
ncdX]Zhh^cYdgb^g#8^Zgidha^Wgdhhjg\^ZgdcYZjcVdkVg^VhcdX]Zh
VigdXZh! igZh eVgV Za EVe{<dg^di! digdh hZ YZXVciVgdc edg Va\jcdh
VŠdh#Fj‚^bedgiV!Zaegda^_dcVggVYdgaaZkVVYZaVciZkVg^dhigVWV_dh
nXgZV^cXVchVWaZbZciZ#9Zi^ZbedZci^ZbedZbZg\ZeVgVgZXd\Zg
jcVWdXVcVYVYZk^YVeVg^h^ZchZ!fjZbVhXVXdcWjZcY^ZciZ![Zhi^cZh
n [gVcXVX]ZaVh! VbVciZh _‹kZcZh n VaWdgdiVYdgVh! XVggdoV eZghdcVa
XjVcYdVa[^cY^hedcZYZX^ZgiV]da\jgV!]jcY^‚cYdhZg{e^YVbZciZ
edg adh ZmXZhdh YZ idYd \‚cZgd n adh VXgZZYdgZh XVYV kZo b{h
cjbZgdhdh#
:c ‚a! aV hjWa^bZ kZX^cV h^ZbegZ Xdc VeZi^idh XVgcVaZh# 8jVcYd
Zc &-(*ZhXg^WZ AZ Anh YVch aV KVaa‚Z! fjZ ZmVaiV aV k^gijY! Y^g^\Z
\gVcYZhhZgbdcZhYZ[^YZa^YVYnYZVbdgVaVhZŠdgV=Vch`V!fjZhZ
XdckZgi^g{ZcaVhZŠdgVYZ7VaoVXV[^cVaZhYZhjk^YV!eZgdVcjYVjc
[d\dhdk†cXjadXdcjcV_dkZc^c\aZhV!aVXdcYZhV<j^YdWdc^"K^hXdci^!
V aV fjZ gZX^WZ Zc hj cjZkd e^hd YZ hdaiZgd! VbjZWaVYd Xdc aj_d
YZhZc[gZcVYdnVafj^aVYdWV_djccdbWgZ[VahdeVgVZhXVeVgYZadh
VXgZZYdgZh#:hVaa†YdcYZZbegZcYZg{^\jVabZciZH‚gVe]^iV!hjdWgV
b{h^YZVa^oVYV«naVb{hZhe†g^iV
waZheVgi^XjaVgbZciZaX^YdnhZkZgdeVgVadhhZŠjZadhYZZhiZbjcYd!
eZgd VYdgV adh hVadcZh n aVh bjcYVcVa^YVYZh# Adh ]VW†V XdcdX^Yd
bjn _dkZc! \gVX^Vh Va eg^bZg Vbdg YZ hj k^YV! aV hZŠdgV AVjgZ YZ
7ZgcnbjX]dbVndgfjZ‚a!«kZ^ci^Y‹hVŠdhb{hnfj^Zc\doVWVYZ
jcVgZ\jaVg[dgijcV!fjZaZeZgb^i†V[gZXjZciVgZa<gVcBjcYd#
=VWg†VYZeV\VgXVgd!ZhVh]dgVhYZ\adg^VfjZXdcdXZg†VZchjk^YV!V
XdhiVYZ^c[^c^idhhj[g^b^Zcidh0c^Šdh^cVbdg!_dkZcXdaZ\^Vahda^iVg^d
nVc\jhi^VYd!k^YVfjZVaiZgcVh‹gY^YVhXdb^YVhnZaXdci^cjdVXdhd
YZadhVXgZZYdgZh#
:a ¹_dkZc bjn hjX^dº fjZ YZhXg^WZ K^\cn hZ YZ_V \j^Vg Z ^c^X^Vg
eg^bZgdedghjg^XVk^jYV!Vfj^ZcYZ_Vg{XVh^ZcaVb^hZg^Ve^Y^‚cYdaZ
egZhiVYd bjX]d Y^cZgd eVgV XdadXVX^dcZh YjYdhVh n XgZVX^‹c YZ
cZ\dX^dh edg Z_Zbead eZg^‹Y^Xdh Z ^begZciV fjZ g{e^YVbZciZ
XVZg†VcZcfj^ZWgV#
AVjgZYZ7ZgcnaZXdchjZaV!Va^ZciV!gZXdc[dgiVnXj^YVbViZgcVabZciZ#
¹:aaV ]V h^Yd jcV bVYgZ! jcV Vb^\V! jcV [Vb^a^V! jc Vb^\d! jc
XdchZ_Zgd° H^c ZaaV! X^ZgiVbZciZ! nd ZhiVg†V bjZgidº! gZXdcdXZ
=dcdg‚#CddWhiVciZaV]^odhj[g^gbjX]dVjcfjZaZegd[ZhVWVjcV
egd[jcYViZgcjgV#=VWg†VfjZZheZgVg!h^cZbWVg\d!]VhiV&-'.!Xdc
AZh8]djVch eVgV fjZ Za ‚m^id a^iZgVg^d eZgb^i^ZgV edg [^c Va Vjidg
k^k^gYZhjhXgZVX^dcZh#
CddWhiVciZ!edghjeVhVYdYZVkZcijgZgdYZhV[dgijcVYdfjZYVg{
eZghdcVabZciZgZhedchVWaZYZeVh^kdhXdadhVaZhfjZadigVch[dgbVg{c
/(-2851$/63,5,7(1o$%5,/
+RQRUž'H%DO]DF
6H¥RUDGH0RUVDXI
HO3DS–*RULRW
('
(O&RURQHO&KDEHUW
[^cVabZciZZcXVji^kda^iZgVg^dYZ\Zc^d#AZ]Vg†Vc[VaiVigZ^ciVVŠdh
YZegZeVgVX^‹cnZchVndhY^kZghdheVgVZcXdcigVghjXVb^cd!fjZad
aaZkVg†VVY^ZX^dX]dVŠdhYZ^ciZchVXgZVX^‹c!hdhiZc^YViVcidedgjcV
^bV\^cVX^‹cYZhWdgYVciZXdbdedghjhZci^YdYZaVdWhZgkVX^‹c#
AVYZhbZhjgVYZhjdWgVZhaV^bV\ZcYZZhVk^YVYZeg^h^dcZgdYZa
ZhXg^idg^d!k^h^WaZbZciZbjn^che^gVYdnYZggdX]VcYdjcVZcZg\†V
XdadhVaZcjcVk^YVVc{ad\VVjcVYZhjhdWgVh#AVE^ZaYZoVeV!dWgV
VaZ\‹g^XV!^c^X^‹YZ]ZX]djcX^XadYZdWgVhb{hegd[jcYVhnbjn
b†hi^XVh#Jc_dkZc!h^cjcX‚ci^bd!hZYZY^XVVjcVXVggZgVa^iZgVg^V
dX^Zci†[^XVfjZcdaZhjhiZciV#9ZhZheZgVYd!Xdch^YZgVZahj^X^Y^d
eZgdZcXjZcigVjciVa^hb{cb{\^XdZcXVhVYZjcVci^XjVg^d!fjZhZ
adYVYZhej‚hYZ]VWZgaZegZkZc^YdYZaeZa^\gdYZaVha^WZgVa^YVYZh
YZ ZhiV¹E^Za YZ oVeV#º HZ igViV YZ jcV hjZgiZ YZ ea^Z\d YZ XjZgd
[^cd fjZ XjbeaZ idYdh adh YZhZdh YZ hj egde^ZiVg^d bZY^VciZ jc
ZcXd\^b^Zcid YZ aV e^Za! fjZ XdggZhedcYZ V jcV gZYjXX^‹c YZa
i^ZbedYZk^YVegdedgX^dcVaVaiVbVŠdYZaYZhZdnVhjY^[^XjaiVY#
AV e^Za Zh ejZh ^Y‚ci^XV V aV ZheZgVcoV YZ k^YV YZ hj [Za^o i^ijaVg!
fj^Zc^ciZciVg{ZckVcdVaZ_VgaVbVaY^X^‹c!eZgdbdg^g{bjn_dkZc
nbjng^XdZcigZadhWgVodhYZaVbj_ZgfjZVbV#
HZg{iVbW^‚cZaXVhdYZ=dcdg‚YZ7VaoVX!fjZ[^cVabZciZZcXdcigVg{
Vhj]ZgbdhVXdcYZhVedaVXV!aVhZŠdgV=Vch`V![VWjadhVbZciZg^XV!
k^jYVgZX^ZciZYZa8dcYZ=Vch`^#HZXVhVg{XdcZaaVZc&-*%!Zc@^Zk!
n bdg^g{ Zc EVg†h Va\jcdh bZhZh b{h iVgYZ! g^Xd! VbVYd! VYjaVYd
edg Za \gVc bjcYd eZgd Vggj^cVYd edg aV YZhbZhjgV YZ jcV k^YV!
Xdchjb^YVZcjcVkZgYVYZgV¹E^ZaYZoVeVº#
/DSURJUHVL¦QGHXQSHQVDPLHQWRILORV¦ILFR
/DXUH'H%HUQ\
6H¥RUD+DQVND
K^Xidg=j\d!hjVb^\d!adkZg{bdg^gXVh^ZchjhWgVodhnegdcjcX^Vg{
hj Zad\^d [cZWgZ Zc Za EƒgZ AVX]V^hZ! Vaa† b^hbd YdcYZ GVhi^\cVX
VgZc\VWVVEVg†h/¹EVg†heVgVadhYdhº#:hiV^beZijdhVZcZg\†Vk^iVacd
hZXdciZciVWVXdcfjZbVgaVkZaVedgaVhYdhejciVh#HZ^ciZggd\VWV
^\jVabZciZhdWgZZahZci^YdYZaVk^YVn]VW†VXdbegZcY^YdaV[jZgoV
YZa eZchVb^Zcid Vh† Xdbd aV [^cVa^YVY YZ aV ajX]V ]jbVcV# Edg
hjejZhid!aVVegZX^VX^‹cYZaVhXdhVhfjZYVVbea^VbZciZYZ[gVjYVYV/
¸¹AVbVndgeVgiZYZaV]jbVc^YVYk^h^WaZ!aVeVgiZb{hY‚W^a!]VW^iV
aV Zh[ZgV YZa >chi^cid# Adh ^chi^ci^kdh cVXZc! igVWV_Vc n bjZgZc h^c
ZaZkVghZVahZ\jcYd\gVYdYZaV^ciZa^\ZcX^V]jbVcVºH‚gVe]^iV#
¸¹6fj†!ZaejcidYZeVgi^YVeVgVidYdZhZaY^cZgd#=VXZ[VaiVZa
Y^cZgd!]VhiVeVgVegZhX^cY^gYZaY^cZgdºH‚gVe]^iV#
¸ ¹C^c\jcV iZdg†V eda†i^XV ]V k^k^Yd# Adh \dW^Zgcdh eVhVc Xdbd
adh ]dbWgZh! h^c igVchb^i^ghZ c^c\jcV ZchZŠVcoV n c^c\c h^hiZbV
Zc\ZcYgVjch^hiZbVb{heZg[ZXidfjZZaVciZg^dgº#
7VaoVX cd XgZZ Zc aV VXX^‹c XdaZXi^kV0 Za eVhd Va hZ\jcYd ZhiVY^d
YZ XdcX^ZcX^V cd ejZYZ hZg b{h fjZ ^cY^k^YjVa# HZ VbdaYV ejZh
eZghdcVabZciZVaVBdcVgfj†VYZ_ja^dnVYb^iZh^ceZhiVŠZVgaVh
\jZggVhYZXdadc^oVX^‹cYZBVggjZXdhnYZ6g\Za^V!fjZeZgb^i^g{V
Va\jcdhYZhjh]‚gdZhXjWg^ghZYZ\adg^VdhVa^gV[adiZ#
:m^hiZ h^c ZbWVg\d jcV egd\gZh^‹c YZ hj eZchVb^Zcid fjZ Zc
µjkgZhe]^adhde]^fjZhigVoVZakZgYVYZgdhZci^YdYZaVgZYZcX^‹c
]jbVcV!Xdc[gZXjZcX^VidiVabZciZ^\cdgVYdeZgdbjngZVaYZaV
8dbZY^V]jbVcV#
¹:cZaZheZXi{XjadYZZhiVhdX^ZYVYVidgbZciVYVh^cXZhVgiVcidZc
hjhWVhZhXdbdZchjhZ[ZXidh!ZchjhXVjhVhXdbdZchjhVXX^dcZh!
Zc aV fjZ aV [^aVcigde†V Zh jc bV\c†[^Xd Zggdg j Za egd\gZhd jc
Y^heVgViZ°]Zad\gVYdaVXdc[^gbVX^‹cYZZhiVkZgYVY!fjZaVk^YV
Zhi{ZccdhdigdhncdV[jZgV#8dchX^ZciZYZadhk^X^dhYZabjcYdYZ
adh^chi^cidhnYZadhVeZi^idh!Za]dbWgZejZYZVegZcYZgnZaZkVghZº
Adj^hAVbWZgi#
:a XdcdX^b^Zcid n Za \jhid edg VegZcYZg Xdchi^ijnZc aV eg^bZgV
/(-2851$/63,5,7(1o$%5,/
((
ZiVeVYZa^i^cZgVg^d#7VaoVXi^ZcZjcViZgcjgVeVgi^XjaVg]VX^V
ZahVW^d!fjZYZY^XVZkZcijVabZciZhjk^YVVaVegZcY^oV_Z
YZahVWZgfjZ¹aaZkVegd\gZh^kVbZciZVaXdcdX^b^ZcidYZaVh
gZ\aVhYZ[jcX^dcVb^ZcidYZZhiZbjcYdnYZaVhaZnZhYZ
9^dheVgVZajc^kZghdZciZgdºAdj^hAVbWZgi#
:cAVgZX]ZgX]ZYZa¼6WhdajAVWhfjZYVYZa6Whdajid!Za
hVW^d8aVZh\VhiVg{idYVhj[dgijcV!Vh†XdbdaVYZhj[Vb^a^V!
Zcjcg^\jgdhdigVWV_dYZfj†b^XdWjhXVcYdY†VigVhY†VZa
eg^cX^e^d YZ WVhZ Xdbc V idYV aV bViZg^V!¹Za VWhdajidº!
fjZaZeZgb^i^g{ajZ\dedgaVYZhXdbedh^X^‹cYZac^ig‹\Zcd!
eVhVgVdeZgVX^dcZhYZXgZVX^‹cYZhjhiVcX^VhiVaZhXdbdZa
Y^VbVciZ#9Z]ZX]d!ZhZaYZhZdYZXdbegZcYZg!b{hfjZZa
hZŠjZadYZaV\VcVcX^VadfjZadbjZkZ!]VhiVjcVbjZgiZ
XVh^hZgZcVYVedgaV^ajb^cVX^‹cYZaXdcdX^b^Zcid[^cVa#:a
gZXdgg^YdX^Zci†[^XddWgVhdWgZaVeVX^ZcX^VnYZhZbWdXVZc
¹ZabjcYdbdgVa#º
AV cdkZaV Adj^h AVbWZgi ZcigZ\V aV hZ\jcYV ZiVeV YZa
^i^cZgVg^d!aV¹YZjc]dbWgZfjZigVhaVYVidYVhjVXX^‹cVa
eZchVb^Zcid!XdbddigdhedcZchjk^YVZcaVVXX^‹cº#?dkZc
\Zc^dhjeZgYdiVYdfjZhj[gZZabVgi^g^dZcZaXdaZ\^dYZadh
DgVidg^Vcdh!Adj^hZhXVaVidYdhadh\gVYdhYZaXdcdX^b^Zcid
]jbVcdnhZXdck^ZgiZegd\gZh^kVbZciZZcjc{c\Za#IdbVYd
edgadXdVa[^cVaYZhjk^YV!hZg{XdbegZcY^Ydh‹adedghj
bj_Zg!fjZaZVnjYVVgZVa^oVgjcVk^YVXVh^XdciZbeaVi^kV
YdcYZ cd i^ZcZ eg{Xi^XVbZciZ b{h c^c\c XdciVXid Xdc
aV]jbVc^YVY#¹:hZZhijY^d!ZhZ\jhidZaZkVgdchjXdgVo‹c!
ad ejg^[^XVgdc! ad ZccdWaZX^Zgdc! aZ Y^Zgdc VeZi^id edg aV
cVijgVaZoV Y^k^cVº# :c ZhiZ a^Wgd! 7VaoVX [^cVabZciZ ]VXZ
YZhXjWg^gVAdj^hadha^WgdhYZjcegZXjghdgYZaZhe^g^i^hbd/
¹HZ\cHlZYZcWdg\!Za{c\ZahZg†VZa^cY^k^YjdZcfjZZahZg
^ciZg^dgad\gVig^jc[VghdWgZZahZgZmiZg^dgº#
µ/DH[LVWHQFLDGHXQPXQGRHVSLULWXDO¹
HOSRGHUGH'LRV¶
Digdha^Wgdhk^ZcZcVegZX^hVgZaegde‹h^idbjnZhe^g^ijVa^hiV
YZ7VaoVX#:cJghjaZB^gdjZi!ZaVjidgYZhVggdaaVhjXgZZcX^V
ZcdigdhedYZgZhYZaeZchVb^Zcid]jbVcd!n]VXZZaZad\^d
YZ jc b‚Y^Xd bdYZgcd fjZ hZ VWgZ Va bV\cZi^hbd/¹6h†!
aV[jZgoVZciZgVYZjc]dbWgZYZWZiZcZgaVegde^ZYVYYZ
gZVXX^dcVg hdWgZ adh digdh n eZcZigVgadh YZ jcV ZhZcX^V
ZmigVŠV V aV hjnVº# H^\jZc ZcidcXZh aVg\dh YZhVggdaadh
Zcijh^VhiVh hdWgZ aV ]^hidg^V YZa BZhbZg^hbd n hj
gZXjeZgVX^‹c edg jcV bZY^X^cV bdYZgcV! YZhZbWVgVoVYV
YZidYdhhjhegZ_j^X^dh#
8dckZgi^YdV9^dhedghjV]^_VYV!aVVYdgVWaZJghjaZB^gdjZi!
ZhiZ b‚Y^Xd aV hVakVg{ YZ aV gVeVX^YVY YZ hjh ]ZgZYZgdh
n gZ\gZhVg{ Xdbd ZheZXigd eVgV ^c[dgbVg V JghjaZ YZa
Xdbeadi[dbZciVYdeVgVYZhed_VgaV#;^cVabZciZaVkZc\Vg{
YZhjZcidgcd#:haVdXVh^‹ceVgVfjZ7VaoVXhZZcigZ\jZV
jccjZkdZad\^dYZaVhiZh^hYZHlZYZcWdg\nVbVc^[ZhiVg
hjhegde^VhXgZZcX^Vh/¹KjZhigdeVYg^cd!]^_Vb†VaZY^XZZa
ZaXjgV8]VeZgdcVJghjaZ]VW†VgZXdcdX^YdaVedh^W^a^YVY
YZ aV Zm^hiZcX^V YZ jc bjcYd Zhe^g^ijVaº# wa cd h‹ad! XgZZ
Zc ZhiVh VeVg^X^dcZh h^cd fjZ VnjYV V aV X]^XV V kZg jc
gZhjaiVYdYZ¹ZaedYZgYZ9^dhº#
H‚gVe]^iV! bjX]d i^Zbed dak^YVYd edg aV Xg†i^XV XdgdcV
Za eZchVb^Zcid [^adh‹[^Xd YZ 7VaoVX# Adj^h AVbWZgi!
aVWdg^dhVbZciZ ]ZX]d n gZ]ZX]d «XjVigd kZgh^dcZh
/(-2851$/63,5,7(1o$%5,/
hjXZh^kVhgZegZhZciVVa{c\ZaZc[dgbVX^‹c0H‚gVe]^ijh#
H‚gVe]^iVYZhXg^WZVa{c\ZaiZgb^cVYdfjZhZjcZVaEVYgZ!
9^dh!YZhej‚hYZ]VWZgXdcXaj^Ydk^Xidg^dhVbZciZhjX^Xad
YZk^YVhhjXZh^kVhnXdbeaZbZciVg^Vh/¹9^dhcd]VXgZVYd
{c\ZaZh ZheZX^VabZciZ0 cd Zm^hiZ fj^Zc cd ]VnV h^Yd
]dbWgZhdWgZaVi^ZggV#9ZZhVbVcZgVaVI^ZggVZaVab{X^\d
YZaX^Zadº#
¸ ¹AVh ^YZVh VYfj^g^YVh edg Za Z_ZgX^X^d YZ ZhiVh k^gijYZh
6bdg!eVgVXdbZcoVghZigVchb^iZcVaVcjZkVZckdaijgV
]jbVcV WV_d aV fjZ hZ ZhXdcYZc aVh bZiVbdg[dh^h YZahZg
^ciZg^dgº# wa XgZZ ejZh [^gbZbZciZ Zc aV eVa^c\ZcZh^V n
ZhWdoVZcjcXVe†ijadbjnaVg\daVh^YZVhYZhjbVZhigdYZ
eZchVb^Zcid!HlZYZcWdg\!Xjnd\Zc^dgZXdcdXZ#AVheVaVWgVh
YZaeVhidg7ZX`ZgVXZgXVYZHlZYZcWdg\!gZXdcdX^ZcYdcd
]VWZgXdbegZcY^YdidYdYZZcigVYV!c^XgZ†YdidYdYZhej‚h!
hdch^cc^c\jcVYjYVaVhYZaegde^d7VaoVX#
HZhVWZ!edghjhXVgiVhVaVhZŠdgV=Vch`V!fjZ‚aZgVbjn
XgZnZciZ n VeVh^dcVYd YZ HlZYZcWdg\! fjZ [^\jgVWV Zc
WjZc aj\Vg Zc hj W^Wa^diZXV# Digdh ZmigVXidh gZhjbZc hj
eZchVb^Zcid/ ¹Edg Za b^hiZg^d YZ jcV eVa^c\ZcZh^V bjn
hZbZ_VciZ Va edYZg fjZ iZcYg†V jc ]dbWgZ YZ gZXdcdXZg!
edg adh a^cZVbZcidh! iZ\jbZcidh n gjY^bZcidh YZ jcV
hZb^aaV! hjh [adgVX^dcZh VciZg^dgZh Zc aVh ^ccjbZgVWaZh
bdY^[^XVX^dcZhYZhjhbVi^XZh!hjheZg[jbZhnhjh[dgbVhº#
Adj^hAVbWZgi#
¸¹:a]dbWgZcdejZYZhZggZ\ZcZgVYdh^cdhjXZh^kVbZciZº!
H‚gVe]^iVZcjcaVg\dVegZcY^oV_ZfjZeVhVedgcjbZgdhdh
¹:m^hi^gZhº!Y^g†Vbdh¹Zm^hiZcX^Vh#º:aVbdgYZh†b^hbdeVhV
edgZaYZhVggdaadYZa\Zc^d!fjZhZVWgZVadhYZb{hedgZa
6bdg!ajZ\dedgaVHVW^Yjg†V#whiVadaaZkVVaVXdbegZch^‹c
YZidYVhaVhXdhVh!^cXaj^YVhaVhXdhVhdXjaiVh!fjZaZVWgZc
V aV ^ajb^cVX^‹c n V aV XdbegZch^‹c YZ aVh XdhVh Y^k^cVh#
9Zhej‚h YZ ]VWZg ¹Xg^WVYd bjX]d i^Zbed hj nd ^ciZg^dg
fjZ nV cd ejZYZ hZg XdciVb^cVYd edg c^c\jcd YZ adh
V[ZXidh iZggZcVaZhº! Za Zhe†g^ij Vc\Za^XVa Zhi{ [^cVabZciZ
a^hid eVgV jc^ghZ V 9^dh#IVa Zh Za XVhd YZ ZhiV b^hiZg^dhV
Xg^VijgV! H‚gVe]^iV# :c jcV eZfjZŠV VaYZV V^haVYV YZ
CdgjZ\V!ZhH‚gVe]^ijheVgVB^ccV!aV]^_VYZaeVhidgfjZ
XVZeZgY^YVbZciZZcVbdgVYV#:hH‚gVe]^iVeVgVL^a[g^Y!fjZ
kVX^aVZcigZZaaVnB^ccV!^begZh^dcVYdedgaVbjn[jZgiZ
eZghdcVa^YVYYZZhiZZmigVŠdhZg#AVbjZgiZYZhZbeViVg{V
adhXVcY^YVidhVaaaVbVg9^dhVH‚gVe]^ijh"H‚gVe]^iV!fjZZc
ZhiZZhiVY^dnVcdXdcdXZaVY^[ZgZcX^VX^‹chZmjVa#B^ccV
nL^a[g^Y! ^chigj^Ydh YZ aVh XdhVh Y^k^cVh edg Za egd[ZiV Va
fjZ]VcVbVYdhZjc^g{ceVgVVnjYVghZbjijVbZciZZchj
X^XadYZk^YV!XjnVhgZ\aVhnVXdcdXZc#
«9ZX^Y^YVbZciZ! ]Zcdh Vfj† W^Zc aZ_dh YZa ZhX‚ei^Xd
YZhZc\VŠVYd Z ]^eZg"gZVa^hiV YZ cjZhigVh ZcX^XadeZY^Vh
9Z_Zbdh V]dgV V ZhiZ \gVc egZXjghdg YZa Zhe^g^i^hbd Xdc
Va\jcVh YZ aVh _dnVh fjZ ejZYZ d[gZXZgcdh eVgV bVYjgVg
cjZhigVgZ[aZm^‹c!VXZgXVYZcjZhigdXVb^cdeZghdcVa/
¹=ZbdhcVX^YdeVgViZcYZg]VX^VZaX^Zad#AVEVig^V!XdbdZa
gdhigdYZjcVbVYgZ!_Vb{hVhjhiVVjcc^ŠdºH‚gVe]^iV#
¹H^ fjZg‚^h VXdhijbWgVg V kjZhigdh e^Zh V bVgX]Vg edg Za
XVb^cdfjZXdcYjXZVa8^Zad!hVWZYW^ZcfjZadhXdb^Zcodh
hdc Yjgdh° 9^dh fj^ZgZ hZg WjhXVYd edg h† b^hbd° Dh
fj^ZgZZciZgdh0eZgdXjVcYddh]VW‚^hZcigZ\VYdV‚a!cjcXV
dhVWVcYdcVºH‚gVe]^iV#
()
'266,(5
/26(6&5,725(6,163,5$'26325(/0z6$//z
SRU
(7,(11(%(57+$87
*2(7+(
813(16$0,(172(63…5,7$$17,&,3$'2
0–VDOO–GHVXJHQLRDUW¢VWLFR\OLWHUDULRYDPRVDGHVFXEULUDXQ*RHWKHEDMRP®OWLSOHVIDFHWDV
SUHVHQWDQGRHOHVS¢ULWXGHXQJUDQILO§VRIRTXHHQVXHQIRTXHGHODYLGD\VXFRQFHSFL§QGHO
PXQGRUHXQL§LGHDVFHUFDQDVDODVGHODILORVRI¢DHVS¢ULWD
6
jidg egda†[^Xd! cdkZa^hiV
egd[jcYdndg^\^cVa!edZiV
nYgVbVijg\d!<dZi]ZYZ_‹
Zc]ZgZcX^VdWgVhiVaZhXdbdAVh
ig^WjaVX^dcZh YZa _dkZc LZgi]Zg
n;Vjhid!aVhb{hXdcdX^YVh!fjZ
^c[ajZcX^Vgdc cdiVWaZbZciZ aV
XjaijgVVaZbVcVnVjcZjgdeZVYZ
hj‚edXV#Hj^bedgiVcX^VeVgVaV
^YZci^YVYXjaijgVaVaZbVcVejZYZ
XdbeVgVghZ V aV YZ H]V`ZheZVgZ
eVgVaV^YZci^YVYXjaijgVa^c\aZhV#
:aZ\^YdZc'%%*Zc*§aj\VgZcigZ
aVh eZghdcVa^YVYZh egZ[Zg^YVh
YZ adh VaZbVcZh! <dZi]Z h^\jZ
h^ZcYd idYVk†V ]dn aV gZ[ZgZcX^V
a^iZgVg^V \Zgb{c^XV eVgV cjbZ"
gdhVh\ZcZgVX^dcZh#B{hVaa{YZhj
\Zc^dVgi†hi^Xdna^iZgVg^d!kVbdhV
YZhXjWg^gVjc<dZi]ZWV_dbai^eaZh[VXZiVh!egZhZciVcYd
ZaZhe†g^ijYZjc\gVc[^a‹hd[dfjZ!ZchjZc[dfjZYZaVk^YV
nhjXdcXZeX^‹cYZabjcYd!gZjc^‹^YZVhXZgXVcVhVaVhYZ
aV[^adhd[†VZhe†g^iV#KZgZbdhedgZ_ZbeadfjZ;Vjhid!aV\gVc
dWgVYZhjk^YV!egZhZciVX^ZgiVhVajh^dcZhncdX^dcZhZhe†"
g^iVhfjZZh^ciZgZhVciZYZhiVXVgnVcVa^oVg#
8QJUDQHVS¡ULWXGHREVHUYDFL¦Q
?d]VccLda[\Vc\kdc<dZi]ZcVX^‹Zc;gVc`[jgiV[^cVaZh
YZV\dhidYZ&,).nbjg^‹ZcbVgodYZ&-('ZcLZ^bVg!
VaVZYVYYZ-'VŠdh#:YjXVYda^WZgVabZciZZcjcbZY^d
egdiZhiVciZ VXdbdYVYd n Xjaid! gZX^W^‹ jcV ZYjXVX^‹c
]jbVc^hiVg^\jgdhVnegd[jcYV!ndWijkdhjYdXidgVYdZc
YZgZX]dZc&,,'#>chiVaVYdZcLZ^bVg!YdcYZiZgb^cVg†Vhj
k^YVWV_dZahZjY‹c^bdYZHVW^dYZLZ^bVg!hZXdck^gi^‹Zc
bV\^higVYd! XdchZ_Zgd! b^c^higd
YZa YjfjZ YZ HV_dc^V"LZ^bVg n
Vhjb^‹ ZcidcXZh ^ccjbZgVWaZh
iVgZVh VYb^c^higVi^kVh! eda†i^XVh
n [^cVcX^ZgVh YZ aV XdgiZ#6hZ\j"
gVcYd b{h iVgYZ Za XVg\d YZ
Y^gZXidg YZa iZVigd YjXVa! [jZ jc
Vh^Yjdk^h^iVciZYZhVadcZha^iZgV"
g^dhYdcYZXdcdX^‹VcjbZgdhdh
Vgi^hiVh n [^a‹hd[dh! iVaZh Xdbd
HX]^aaZg d HX]deZc]VjZg# Hj
k^YV Zhi{ _VadcVYV YZ bai^eaZh
ZcXjZcigdh[ZbZc^cdhfjZ[jZgdc
V bZcjYd [jZciZ YZ XgZVX^dcZh
ed‚i^XVh#HjdWgVa^iZgVg^VZmegZhV
jc Zhe†g^ij YZ jcV \gVc XjaijgV!
^begZ\cVYV iVcid YZ Xa{h^Xdh
Vci^\jdh n bdYZgcdh Xdbd YZ
aV 7^Wa^V! aV b^idad\†V Vci^\jV d
aZnZcYVhedejaVgZhVaZbVcVh#
6jcfjZ!b{hXdcdX^YdXdbdeZghdcVa^YVYa^iZgVg^V!<dZi]Z!
YdiVYd YZ jc cdiVWaZ Zhe†g^ij YZ dWhZgkVX^‹c! Xjg^dhd
n VW^Zgid! hZ ^ciZgZh‹ ^\jVabZciZ edg aVh X^ZcX^Vh YZ aV
cVijgVaZoV! Xdbd aV Wdi{c^XV! aV VcVidb†V! aV [†h^XV d aV
\Zdad\†V eVgV ad XjVa XdaZXX^dcVWV e^ZYgVh! VWVcYdcVYd
edXdVedXdhjh[jcX^dcZhVYb^c^higVi^kVhniZVigVaZh#Edg
Z_Zbead!Zc&,.%ejWa^X‹jcZchVndhdWgZaVbZiVbdg[dh^h
YZ aVh eaVciVh Zc Za fjZ ^ciZciVWV ZhiVWaZXZg jcV iZdg†V
\ZcZgVa hdWgZ aV bdg[dad\†V YZ adh kZ\ZiVaZh# 8dc bjX]V
Vci^X^eVX^‹cgZheZXidVaVh^YZVh\ZcZgVabZciZhdhiZc^YVh
Zchj‚edXVhdWgZaVheaVciVh!ZhWdo‹^\jVabZciZjcViZdg†V
YZaVZkdajX^‹cZcadhkZ\ZiVaZh!Xdck^gi^‚cYdhZVh†ZcjcdYZ
adheg^bZgdh¸nfj^o{hZaeg^bZgd¸ZcZbeaZVgZai‚gb^cd
bZiVbdg[dh^h Zc Wdi{c^XV! eg^cX^e^d gZXdcdX^Yd ]dn Zc
/(-2851$/63,5,7(1o$%5,/
(*
Y†V#Hj^ciZg‚hedgaVhX^ZcX^VhcVijgVaZhaZaaZk‹iVbW^‚c]VX^VaV
dhiZdad\†V!«aVXjVaaZYZWZZaYZhXjWg^b^ZcidYZa]jZhd^ciZgbVm^aVg
ZcZa]dbWgZH^ZbegZWVhVYVhZcaVdWhZgkVX^‹cnZaVc{a^h^hYZ
adh]ZX]dh!hdc^\jVabZciZbjnVXijVaZhidYVk†VhjhiZdg†VhhdWgZ
aV‹ei^XV!aVeZgheZXi^kVdaVeZgXZeX^‹cYZadhXdadgZhhdWgZaVXjVa
ZhXg^W^‹ hjIgViVYd YZ adh 8dadgZh Zc &-&%! bjX]d VciZh YZ adh
igVWV_dhYZX‚aZWgZhX^Zci†[^XdhYZah^\adMK>>>!Xdbd:#8]ZkgZja#
;jZVh†Xdbd!\gVX^VhVhjegd[jcYdiVaZcidYZdWhZgkVYdgnVhj
[jZgoVYZ^cij^X^‹c!nedgZaViZcidZmVbZcYZbjai^ijYYZYZiVaaZh
ZcadhdW_ZidhfjZhZegZhZciVWVcVhjXjg^dh^YVY¸YZiVaaZhfjZ
]VWg†Vc ZhXVeVYd V jc Zhe†g^ij bZcdh ^ckZhi^\VYdg¸ <dZi]Z
Xdch^\j^‹ [dgbjaVg ^YZVh \ZcZgVaZh fjZ ]Vc VYfj^g^Yd YZgZX]d
YZ X^jYVYVc†V Zc aV X^ZcX^V n ijk^Zgdc cd edXV ^c[ajZcX^V Zc hj
YZhVggdaad#EdgZhiVbZidYdad\†VZcaVdWhZgkVX^‹cejgVnh^hiZb{i^XV
YZaVhXdhVh!aaZ\‹VaZc[dfjZejZhidZceg{Xi^XVbZY^dh^\adb{h
iVgYZedg6aaVc@VgYZXZcZaZh[jZgodYZ^ckZhi^\VX^‹cedh^i^kVnYZ
ZmeZg^bZciVX^‹cfjZXVgVXiZg^oVVa[jcYVYdgYZaZhe^g^i^hbd#
)DXVWRUHIHUHQFLDVHVS¡ULWDV¹
:aYgVbVYZ;Vjhid[jZeVgV<dZi]ZjcVdWgVYZaVg\dVa^ZcidedgfjZ
[jZZhXg^iVZckVg^dhYZXZc^dh#AVheg^bZgVhZhXZcVhYViVcYZ&,,)
njcVeg^bZgVeVgiZ[jZejWa^XVYVZc&-%-Zc[dgbVYZigV\ZY^V#:c
XjVcidVahZ\jcYd;Vjhid!h‹ad[jZiZgb^cVYdZc&-'.!edXdi^Zbed
VciZh YZ hj bjZgiZ# 7jhXVcYd ]VXZg jcV h†ciZh^h YZ hjh ^YZVh Zc
[^adhd[†VnZc]^hidg^VcVijgVa!;Vjhid[jZjcedXdZaXdbeVŠZgd^YZVa
YZhjk^YV!XdbdjcYdWaZ^ciZaZXijVa!hdWgZfjZgZ\gZh‹h^cXZhVg!
ZcXVgcVcYd Zc ‚a idYVh hjh ^YZVh! eZghdc^[^XVcYd Zc ‚a idYVh hjh
bZiVbdg[dh^hnhjhgZ[aZm^dcZh#DWgV[^adh‹[^XVngZa^\^dhV!ZmegZh‹
Vaa†hjhhZci^b^Zcidh!hjhajX]Vh^ciZgcVhnhjhbZY^iVX^dcZh#;Vjhid!
idbVYdZchjXdc_jcid!Xdci^ZcZejZhidYdhadhZhi^adhYZ<dZi]Z#
H^hjhedZh†VhcdZgVc!Xdbd‚aY^XZ!b{hfjZ[gV\bZcidhYZjcV
\gVcXdc[Zh^‹c!;Vjhid[jZhjXdc[Zh^‹c\ZcZgVa#
;Vjhid Zh jcV bVgVk^aadhV VYVeiVX^‹c YZ jcV k^Z_V aZnZcYV Zc Za
Zhe†g^ijYZah^\adMK>>>ZchjZmegZh^‹cb{hVbea^Vn\ZcZgdhV#AZ_dh
YZjceZghdcV_ZYZ[^XX^‹c!Za;VjhidYZ<dZi]ZaaZkVZch†aVgZVa^YVY
YZaVk^YV!iZc^ZcYdfj^o{hXdbddg^\ZcVjcX‚aZWgZiVjbVijg\d
YZ [^cZh YZa h^\ad MK! jc X^Zgid ?ZVc ;Vjhi! bV\d n c^\gdbVciZ!
XdckZgi^Yd aZ\ZcYVg^VbZciZ Zc ]‚gdZ YZ bVgVk^aadhVh VkZcijgVh#
8dbdhZYZhXjWg^g{!Za]‚gdZWjhXVZcaVVXX^‹cZahZci^YdYZidYV
k^YV!igVhYZjcVWhdajideZgXZei^WaZZc[gV\bZcidhedgbZY^dYZ
hjXZh^kVhZmeZg^ZcX^VhfjZVXVWVcedgYZhZbWdXVg!VeZhVgYZidYd!
ZcaVk^Xidg^VYZaW^ZchdWgZZabVa#<dZi]Z]VXZYZhjeZghdcV_ZaV
YdWaZZcXVgcVX^‹cYZak^Z_dhVW^dZcWjhXVYZaVkZgYVYVWhdajiV!
fjZh^ZbegZeVgZXZZhXVeVgYZ‚a!]VX^ZcYd^ci^aZhhjhZh[jZgodh!
nYZa]dbWgZ{k^Yd!VjcZchjkZ_Zo!YZidYVhaVhkdajeijdh^YVYZh
]jbVcVh# :c ;Vjhid! hZ ZcXjZcigV ZhiV ajX]V ^cXZhVciZ ZcigZ jc
ZhXZei^X^hbd Yd\b{i^Xd n aVh V[^gbVX^dcZh YZ aV XdcX^ZcX^V! eVgV
XZYZg [^cVabZciZ V aVh hZYjXX^dcZh n kZcYZg hj VabV Va ^c[ZgcVa
iZciVYdgfjZgZ^cVXdbdVbdnhZŠdg/BZ[^hi‹[ZaZh#
EZgd!ªfjZcdhXjZciV;Vjhid4;VjhidZhjc^c[dgijcVYdk^Z_d!fjZ
[^gbVXdchjhVc\gZjceVXidXdcBZ[^hi‹[ZaZh#6XVbW^dYZhjk^YV!
BZ[^hidYZWZigVZgaZ[Za^X^YVY#AZd[gZXZZcidcXZhV;Vjhidg^fjZoV!
_jkZcijYnVbdgWV_dadhgVh\dhYZBVg\jZg^iZ#EZgd‚aVWVcYdcVV
aVWZaaVfjZ!ZcjcVXXZhdYZadXjgV!V]d\VVhj]^_d#9^dhaVeZgYdcV!
n Zh edg hj bjZgiZ fjZ ;Vjhid ZhXVeV V aV XV†YV egdbZi^YV! Va
XdbegZcYZgaVhk^gijYZhYZaVVXX^‹c#6WdgYZbdhVa\jcdheVhV_Zh
XVgVXiZg†hi^XdhYZaVdWgV/
¸AV¹9ZY^XVidg^VºZhjcV]ZgbdhVngVY^VciZZaZkVX^‹ced‚i^XVZc
aVfjZ<dZi]ZbVc^[^ZhiVnVhjhXdck^XX^dcZhZhe^g^ijVa^hiVh/
/(-2851$/63,5,7(1o$%5,/
0LFKHO(XJQH&KHYUHXO
*RHWKHHW6FKLOOHU
)DXVWGDQVVRQFDELQHW
(+
¹DhVXZgX{^hYZcjZkd![dgbVh[adiVciZh!
FjZVeVgZX^hiZ^hVciZhVb^VabVijgWVYVº#
°
¹NgZidbVcYdjcYZhZdbjX]di^ZbedVeV\VYd!hdnVggVhigVYd
=VX^VZhZh^aZcX^dhdn\gVkZgZ^cdYZadhZhe†g^ijhº#
¸:caVeg^bZgVeVgiZYZaVigV\ZY^V!¹AVCdX]Zº!<dZi]ZcdhbjZhigV
V;VjhidZcigZ\VYdVjcbdc‹ad\dXdbd]VXZcVkZXZhadh[^a‹hd[dh
XjVcYdaaZ\VaVZYVYYZaVhYZh^ajh^dcZh#:hegZX^hd^bV\^cVgadZc
jcZhigZX]dXjVgid\‹i^XdYZVaiVhW‹kZYVh!ZcbZY^dYZaVcdX]Z
egd[jcYV! ZhXVcY^ZcYd kZghdh Zc adh fjZ eVgZXZ gZh^\cVghZ V jcV
[dgbV YZ Vc^fj^aVX^‹c YZ aV k^YV! aVbZciVcYd cd edYZg edhZZg aV
kZgYVY#:hVZhaVgVo‹cedgaVfjZaaZ\VVXdc[ZhVghjhiZcYZcX^Vh
]VX^VaVhX^ZcX^VhdXjaiVh/
2VDFHUF–LVGHQXHYRIRUPDVIORWDQWHV»
¹BZ]ZZcigZ\VYdejZhVaVbV\^V
EVgVkZgh^!edgaV[jZgoVnaVkdoYZaZhe†g^ij!
BjX]dhb^hiZg^dhbZhZg†VcgZkZaVYdhº#
AjZ\d!kdak^ZcYdhjhd_dhVaX^Zad![^_VcYdaVajcV^cb‹k^ahdWgZhjh
a^WgdhnhjheVeZaZh!kjZakZVgZeZi^gcdh^cX^Zgida^g^hbd/
¹H^ejY^ZhZ!hdWgZaVXjbWgZYZadhbdciZh!
EVhVgZcijXVgVajo!
EaVcZVgXdcadh:he†g^ijhZcadhVcigdhYZaVbdciVŠV!
:cijXgZehXjadZggVghdWgZaVhegVYZgVh
H^ejY^ZhZ!a^WZgVYdYZaZheZhd]jbdYZaVX^ZcX^V!
«HjbZg\^gbZZceaZcVhVajYZcijgdX†dº
:cidcXZh! i^gdcZVYd ZcigZ hjh Vhe^gVX^dcZh ]VX^V ad ^YZVa n idYd
ad fjZ aZ gdYZV ¸a^Wgdh! eVeZaZh V]jbVYdh! ZhfjZaZidh! iVggdh!
VeVgVidhVafj†b^Xdh°!igViVYZ]j^gYZZhZXjVgidVafjZXdch^YZgV
jcXVaVWdodnXdb^ZcoVVXdbegZcYZgX‹bdjcZhe†g^ijaZ]VWaVV
digdZhe†g^ij#NhZZmegZhVVh†/
0HKHHQWUHJDGRSXHVDODPDJLD»
¹6b^aVYddhV\^i{^h!:he†g^ijh!«gZhedcYZYbZh^bZZhXjX]{^h
°
¹HdaVbZciZ]dnXdbegZcYdaVeVaVWgVYZaHVW^d/
:abjcYdYZadh:he†g^ijhcdZhi{XZggVYd#º
¸:cjcXjVYgdedhiZg^dg!¹6ciZaVejZgiVYZaVX^jYVYº!kZbdhV
;Vjhidb‚Y^Xd!ZcbZY^dYZaejZWad!fjZVXaVbVZc‚aVaVX^ZcX^V
fjZ]VhVakVYdViVcidhedWgZhZc[ZgbdhYZjcViZgg^WaZZe^YZb^V#
EZgd ‚a gZX]VoV idYVh aVh egjZWVh YZ gZXdcdX^b^Zcid fjZ hZ aZ
d[gZXZc! edgfjZ YjYV YZ hj X^ZcX^V n cd ejZYZ VeVgiVghZ YZ hj
ZhXZei^X^hbd#;VjhidVhe^gVVaVk^YV[jijgVfjZk^hajbWgVeaZcVYZ
\gVcYZoVhed‚i^XVh#Adh\dXZhYZaZhijY^d!ZcZah^aZcX^dYZa\VW^cZiZ!
nVcdaZY^XZccVYV!h‹adaZegZdXjeVaVk^YVZhe^g^ijVa/
0žSKLVWRV
DGUHVVDQW•)DXVW
¹9dhVabVh]VW^iVcZcb^hZcd!
:h[dgo{cYdhZjcVndigVedghZeVgVghZ!
JcV!Zcjc{k^YdVbdgedgaVk^YV!hZV[ZggV
6abjcYd!edghjh‹g\Vcdhhj_ZiVYV!
AVdigVhZZaZkV^beZg^dhVYZaedakd
=VX^VadhXVbedhYZcjZhigdhZaZkVYdhVcXZhigdh#
«D]H^]VnZcZaV^gZ:he†g^ijh
FjZ!ZcigZX^Zadni^ZggV!hZbjZkZchdWZgVcdh!
7V_VYYZkjZhigVhcjWZhYZdgd!
NaaZkVYbZVjcVk^YVcjZkV#º
/(-2851$/63,5,7(1o$%5,/
(,
Hj XgZZcX^V Zc Za bjcYd YZa b{h Vaa{ Zh XdbeaZiV n iVc
VWhdajiVfjZiZgb^cVV[^gbVcYdfjZcdXVbW^Vg†V!edgjcV
XVeVYZgZn!ZaVWg^\db{\^XdfjZadigVchedgiVg†VVabjcYd
YZadhZhe†g^ijh#
¸:cadhXVe†ijadhfjZh^\jZc!hZVh^hiZVjcVZhXZcVYZ
]ZX]^XZg†V bZY^ZkVa Zc aV fjZ BZ[^hi‹[ZaZh [dgbjaV hjh
egdedh^X^dcZhZcZhidhi‚gb^cdh/
¹BZYZY^XVg‚VijhZgk^X^d!
6jcVhZŠVaijnVVXijVg‚h^cigZ\jVc^YZhXVchd#
8jVcYdcdhZcXdcigZbdhZcZaB{hVaa{!
I]Vg{hdigdiVcid#º
EZgdZcZhZbdbZcid!;VjhidcdhZegZdXjeVedgZab{h
Vaa{# Hj Xdck^XX^‹c Zhi{ ]ZX]V# 9Z_V d†g hjh bVaY^X^dcZh
edg adh eaVXZgZh iZggZcVaZh! edg aVh hVi^h[VXX^dcZh YZ adh
hZci^Ydh!edgZaVbdg!ZaedYZg!aV[dgijcV!aVZheZgVcoVnaV
[Z#NaVbjZgiZhdaVi^ZcZ!eVgV‚a!jcVigVXi^kdXdchdaVYdg#
AVhZYjXX^‹cVXVWVh^cZbWVg\dedgaVXdcXajh^‹cYZaeVXid
^c[ZgcVa# ;Vjhid! XjgVYd YZ aV hZY YZa hVWZg! hZ ZcigZ\V Va
YZa^g^dYZadhhZci^Ydh!VaVheVh^dcZhVgY^ZciZhnVidYVhaVh
kdajeijdh^YVYZh!h^ejZYZZcXdcigVgjcVcjZkV_jkZcijY#
¹<XQDLQYLWDFL¦QDODDFFL¦Q
6aZhXg^W^g;VjhidYjgVciZXVh^idYVhjk^YV!<dZi]Zfj^hd
YZhXg^W^g!VigVk‚hYZaV]^hidg^Vh^c\jaVgYZjc^cY^k^YjdVaV
kZoZmXZeX^dcVaZ^gg^hdg^d!ZaYZhi^cdYZaV]jbVc^YVYZciZgV
Xdc[gdciVYVVaVh[jZgoVhX‹hb^XVhXdcaVhXjVaZhZhi{Zc
gZaVX^‹c YZ Xdc[a^Xidh n XVbW^dh# AV [dgbV YZ aV dWgV! Zc
YdheVgiZhfjZhZgZhedcYZcnhZdedcZc!ZmegZhVnVZhV
dedh^X^‹c/ Za eg^bZg ;Vjhid Zh XVh^ idiVabZciZ hjW_Zi^kd!
idYd Vaa† YZhXg^WZ V jc ^cY^k^Yjd b{h ^bejah^kd n b{h
VeVh^dcVYd!b^ZcigVhfjZZcXVbW^d!ZcZahZ\jcYd;Vjhid
cd]VnXVh^cVYVYZhjW_Zi^kd#6fj†VeVgZXZjcbjcYdb{h
ZaZkVYd!b{hVbea^d!b{hXaVgd!b{ha^WZgVYdYZaVheVh^dcZh
]jbVcVh!iZcY^ZciZ]VX^Vjc^YZVa#
:a]‚gdZYZ;VjhidhZYZ[^cZedgaVkdajciVYYZYVgedg[^cV
hjk^YV¸nVab^hbdi^ZbedVahZg]jbVcd¸jckZgYVYZgd
Xdb^Zcod!cdYjYVcYdeVgVZaadZcZc[gZciVgaVh[jZgoVhYZa
bVa# AV igV\ZY^V YZ ;Vjhid gZhjaiV hZg jcV igV\ZY^V YZ aV
Xdc[gdciVX^‹c!XVgVXiZg†hi^XVYZjcVajX]Vh^ZbegZ^cX^ZgiV!
YZ jc eZa^\gd eZgeZijd! h^c‹c^bd YZa XdbWViZ ZcigZ
[jZgoVhYZaW^Zcn[jZgoVhYZabVa#EdgdigVeVgiZ;Vjhidn
BZ[^hi‹[ZaZhgZegZhZciVcZhiVVbW^kVaZcX^V!XdchjhVai^WV_dh!
hjheVgV†hdhnhjh^c[^Zgcdh!hjhVaiZgcVcX^VheZgbVcZciZh
ZcigZZmVaiVX^dcZhnYZegZh^dcZh#GZegZhZciVcaVdedh^X^‹c
ZcigZ Ydh ^YZVh! ZcigZ Ydh i^edh! ZcigZ Ydh bVcZgVh YZ
XdbegZcYZgaVk^YV0ZcigZZaZhe†g^ijYZcZ\VX^‹cnYZ^gdc†V
gZegZhZciVYVedgBZ[^hidnaV^cXZhVciZVhe^gVX^‹cVa^YZVa
eZghdc^[^XVYVedg;Vjhid#
CVijgVabZciZ!ZhZeZgeZijdWVaVcXZdnZhVajX]V^cXZhVciZ
Zc\ZcYgVc aV VXX^‹c n ZhZ eg^cX^e^d YZ VXX^‹c VeVgZXZ
ZcidcXZh Xdbd aV e^ZYgV Vc\jaVg YZ aV dWgV YZ <dZi]Z#
¹;jZgVYZaVXVg^YVY!cd]VnhVakVX^‹cºY^g†Vb{hiVgYZ6aaVc
@VgYZX!¹;jZgVYZaVVXX^‹c!cd]VnhVakVX^‹cº]jW^ZgVedY^Yd
YZXaVgVg<dZi]Z#AVVXX^‹chZXdck^ZgiZZcZac^XdgZbZY^d
V ad ig{\^Xd YZ aV Zm^hiZcX^V! h‹ad ZaaV ejZYZ gZhi^ij^g Va
]dbWgZhj^ciZ\g^YVYZcaVY^c{b^XVfjZ‚aejZYZeaVc^[^XVg
eVgV]VXZgZkdajX^dcVghjZm^hiZcX^V#NZcZ[ZXid!]VhiVhj
ai^bdhjhe^gd!;Vjhidh^\jZh^ZcYdZa]dbWgZ^chVi^h[ZX]d
/(-2851$/63,5,7(1o$%5,/
fjZXdchZgkVjcV[Z^ciVXiVZcaVhk^gijYZhYZaVVXX^‹c!ejZh
]VXdbegZcY^YdfjZ!VeZhVgYZjcVajX]VfjZhZkZh^c[^c!
^cVXVWVYVnh^ZbegZgZXdbZcoVYV!aVVXX^‹cZh[jZciZYZ
gZ\ZcZgVX^‹cneZgb^iZh^ZbegZjccjZkd^c^X^d#:hedgZhd
fjZ!VeZhVgYZhjeVXidXdcBZ[^hidfjZadYZWZg†V]VWZg
XdcYZcVYd eVgV h^ZbegZ! Va gZYZhXjWg^g aVh k^gijYZh YZa
igVWV_dnYZaVVXX^‹cVahZgk^X^dYZaVXdaZXi^k^YVY!;Vjhid
XdcdXZ [^cVabZciZ aV gZYZcX^‹c [^cVa! egdbZi^YV Zc Zhidh
i‚gb^cdh/
¹HZ]VhVakVYdZacdWaZb^ZbWgdYZabjcYdYZadh:he†g^ijh!
hZ]VhVakVYdYZaBVa#
6fjZa XjnV k^YV ]V eVhVYd edg eZcdhdh Zh[jZgodh! V ZhZ
edYZbdha^WZgVgad#º
:aeZghdcV_ZYZ;Vjhid!Xdbd^bV\ZcYZidYVaV]jbVc^YVY!
d[gZXZ ejZh aV edh^W^a^YVY YZ aV gZcdkVX^‹c/ Zh h‹ad edg aV
ZcZg\†V YZ hj kdajciVY n edg hj ^cXVchVWaZ eZgh^hiZcX^V
ZcZaZh[jZgodfjZZa]dbWgZejZYZbZgZXZgaVXaZbZcX^V
YZ 9^dh V aV ]dgV hjegZbV# ;Vjhid Zh VWhjZaid n hVakVYd
h^cedgZaadiZcZgfjZeVhVgedgaVheZcVhYZaVZme^VX^‹c
n YZ Va\jcV [dgbV YZ `VgbV ejc^i^kd! h‹ad edgfjZ ‚a
h^beaZbZciZ ]V VXijVYd Zc XdcdX^b^Zcid YZ XVjhV!
gZWVhVcYdhjh[gjhigVX^dcZh!Xjg^dhdedgidYd!nh^ZbegZXdc
aV^cX^iVX^‹cVhZ\j^gVXijVcYd#:hiZbZchV_ZZhZcX^VaZhi{
ZceZg[ZXiVVgbdc†VXdcadheg^cX^e^dh[jcYVbZciVaZhYZaV
[^adhd[†VZhe†g^iVfjZ!ZchjVea^XVX^‹c!aaZkVVahZg]jbVcd
V^ciZggd\VghZhdWgZaVhjZgiZYZhjZm^hiZcX^V!Y{cYdaZadh
bZY^dheVgVhjZkdajX^‹cnhjegde^dVkVcXZ#HZZcXjZcigV
aVcdX^‹cZhZcX^VaYZaa^WgZVaWZYg†dnYZaVgZhedchVW^a^YVY
VaVkZo^cY^k^YjVanXdaZXi^kV!iVcidZcZabVaXdbdZcZa
W^Zc!nZcaVidbVYZXdcX^ZcX^VfjZYZWZZhiVgVhdX^VYV#
:c Z[ZXid! Za Zhe^g^i^hbd ^ck^iV V aV VXX^‹c n V aV ajX]V!
ajX]VZcZahZci^YdVbea^dncdWaZ!ajX]VXdcigVidYVhaVh
YZh^\jVaYVYZh!aVh^c_jhi^X^Vh!aVhb^hZg^Vh!aVhdegZh^dcZh!adh
dhXjgVci^hbdh°!XdbdXdc[gZXjZcX^VcdhZcXVciVgZeZi^g#
NV^bV\ZcYZaVVaZ\dg†VYZaVgZYZcX^‹c[^cVaYZ;Vjhid!
Zhi{cZhdh¹eZcdhdhZh[jZgodhºfjZ]Vg{cZkdajX^dcVgVaV
]jbVc^YVYeVgVVaXVcoVgcjZhigVeViZgc^YVYY^k^cVfjZcdh
]VXgZVYdh^beaZhZ^\cdgVciZh!eZgdhdbZi^Ydh!iVcidVaVh
WV_ZoVh YZ aVh [jZgoVh YZa bVa Xdbd V aVh k^gijYZh YZ aVh
[jZgoVhYZaW^Zc#
*RHWKHXQSHQVDPLHQWRHVS¡ULWDDQWLFLSDGR
:c hj dWgV [^adh‹[^XV! <dZi]Z hjed bVc^[ZhiVg hjh
hZci^b^ZcidheZghdcVaZh!hjhYZh^ajh^dcZh!hjhVhe^gVX^dcZh
n hjh Xdck^XX^dcZh# 6a YgVbVi^oVg aV aZnZcYV YZ ;Vjhid!
hjed^beg^b^gaZjcVZm^hiZcX^Vegde^VedgaVheZgXZeX^dcZh
egd[jcYVh hdWgZ Za hVWZg ]jbVcd! aaZ\VcYd! ad ]Zbdh
YZhiVXVYd!]VhiVaV^cij^X^‹cYZadh[Zc‹bZcdheh†fj^Xdh!
^che^gVYdfj^o{hedgZaXdcdX^b^ZcidVedgiVYdedgX^Zgidh
egZXjghdgZh YZ hj ‚edXV! iVaZh Xdbd :# HlZYZcWdg\#
EdYZbdhYZX^gfjZ!ZcidYdhadhXVhdh!‚a[jZiVbW^‚cjc
egZXjghdg#6i†ijadYZVc‚XYdiV!<dZi]Z!ZcidcXZhYZjcdh
kZ^ciZ VŠdh [jZ XjgVYd! Y^XZ! edg jc b‚Y^Xd Vafj^b^hiV!
ajZ\d YZ jc VXX^YZciZ YZ XdX]Z fjZ aZ ]VW†V YZ_VYd jc
k^kdYdadgZcZaeZX]d#9jgVciZhjXdckVaZXZcX^V!WV_daV
^c[ajZcX^VYZaVhZŠdg^iVYZ@aZiiZcWZg\!jcVVb^\VYZhj
bVYgZfjZXgZ†VZcaVe^ZYgV[^adhd[Va!XdbZco‹VYZY^XVghZ
VaVheg{Xi^XVhYZjcb^hi^X^hbd!jc^YVhVaVhYZaVhX^ZcX^Vh
(-
[†h^XVhncVijgVaZh!eg{Xi^XVhfjZhZZcXjZcigVcZcXVYV
e{\^cVYZ;Vjhid#:cZaXdc_jcidYZhjdWgVhZbjZhigV
ejZh[gVcXVbZciZZhe^g^ijVa^hiV!XdbdZc\ZcZgVaidYdh
adhedZiVhnadhVgi^hiVhZcVbdgVYdhYZa^YZVa!XdcaV
^cij^X^‹c YZa b{h Vaa{# 8dbd kZgYVYZgd bZiV[†h^Xd!
fj^ZgZ ZhijY^Vg aVh XjZhi^dcZh [jcYVbZciVaZh YZa
]dbWgZiVaZhXdbdaVhgZ[ZgZciZhVaV^cbdgiVa^YVYYZa
VabV!aVZm^hiZcX^VYZ9^dh!aVhgVodcZhYZaVZm^hiZcX^V
YZabVadZahZci^YdYZaVk^YV#6aaZZgViZciVbZciZhj
YgVbVYZ;Vjhid!hZkZejZhfjZ!nVV[^cZhYZah^\ad
MK>>>! hZ iZc†V aV ^cij^X^‹c YZ aVh ^YZVh Zhe^g^ijVa^hiVh
bdYZgcVh! VjcfjZ edg hjejZhid! h^c XdcdXZg adh
[Zc‹bZcdhYZaZhe^g^i^hbdZmeZg^bZciVa#
AdhiZmidhYZ<dZi]ZbjZhigVcaVegd[jcYVVgbdc†V
fjZZm^hiZZcigZaVcVijgVaZoVnaVXgZVX^‹cVgi†hi^XV!Vh†
XdbdaVegZhZcX^VYZ9^dhZcaVZkdajX^‹cYZajc^kZghd#
AV^c[ajZcX^VYZ?#?#GdjhhZVjZh^\jVabZciZbVc^[^ZhiV
Zc bjX]Vh YZ hjh edZh†Vh# DWhZgkVYdg ViZcid YZ hj
i^Zbed[jZ^c[ajZcX^VYdedgaVGZkdajX^‹c;gVcXZhV!
Va\jcVhYZhjhdWgVhYVciZhi^bdc^dYZaVZkdajX^‹c
YZ hjh XdcXZeidh bdgVaZh n eda†i^Xdh# 9Z jc ^YZVa
gZejWa^XVcd! Xdch^YZgV! edg Z_Zbead! fjZ Zh V aV
Za^iZ V aV fjZ Xdck^ZcZ XdcYjX^g V aV XdaZXi^k^YVY V
jcV igVch[dgbVX^‹c hdX^Va fjZ! hZ\c ‚a! XdcX^a^Vg†V
bdcVgfj†V n gZeWa^XV# 6aa† idYVk†V hZ gZXdcdXZ Za
eg^cX^e^d YZ aV VXX^‹c Zc [Vkdg YZ jcV ZkdajX^‹c
^cY^k^YjVanXdaZXi^kV#;jZ^\jVabZciZjcdYZadhai^bdh
]dbWgZhjc^kZghVaZhZcaVigVY^X^‹cYZaGZcVX^b^Zcid
nYZaVhAjXZh!VZ_ZbeadYZcjZhigdh9^YZgdi!KdaiV^gZ!
BdciZhfj^ZjnY¼6aZbWZgi#<dZi]Z[dgbVeVgiZejZh
YZZhidh]dbWgZhYZX^ZcX^Vh!XjaijgV!na^iZgVijgVYZ
adhh^\adhMK>>nMK>>>fjZijk^ZgdcZhVXdch^YZgVX^‹c
jc^kZghVa^hiV YZ aVh XdhVh! bZoXaVcYd Y^hX^ea^cVh
Y^kZghVh n kVg^VYVh! iVcid X^Zci†[^XVh Xdbd a^iZgVg^Vh!
iVcidZhe^g^ijVaZhXdbdbViZg^VaZh!YZhZVcYdVedgiVg
Va\Zc^d]jbVcdjcVk^h^‹chjegV"cdgbVafjZkjZakZ
VXdadXVgVa]dbWgZZcZaXZcigdYZaV8gZVX^‹cnYZ
aVVgbdc†VYZajc^kZghd#:cjcV[dgbVYZeVciZ†hbd!
hZVXZgXVb{hdbZcdhVHe^cdoV!YZaXjVahZVaZ_V!cd
dWhiVciZ! edg hjh ^YZVh hdWgZ aV k^YV n aV cVijgVaZoV#
8ZgXVYZadh[^a‹hd[dhYZaVcVijgVaZoV!gZcZaVh^YZVh
YZadh\gVcYZheZchVYdgZhVaZbVcZhYZaV‚edXViVaZh
XdbdHX]Zaa^c\!=Z\Zad]VhiV=ZgYZgfjZad^c[ajZcX^‹
cdiVWaZbZciZ#Edghjh^YZVhYZY^cVb^hbdjc^kZghVa!
YZ Xdci^cj^YVY Zc adh [Zc‹bZcdh cVijgVaZh! \gVX^Vh
V jcV h^cZg\^V b{h Zhi‚i^XV n ed‚i^XV! VeVgZXZg{
[^cVabZciZ Xdbd jcd YZ adh gZegZhZciVciZh YZa
^YZVa^hbdVaVVaZbVcVZcZaVXidYZaVZYVYYZdgd
YZagdbVci^X^hbd#
32(0$
UHFLELGRSRU
0,&+(/3$17,1
/,%(5$&,Š1
:ajc^kZghd]VYVYdhjhZXgZidZcaVcdX]Z
8jVcYdaVajcVWg^aaVWV!naVhZhigZaaVhgZheaVcYZX†Vc
:akZadYZaVhfj^bZgVhhZgVh\‹YZegdcid
EVgVYZ_Vgaj\VgVaEVYgZnXdbZcoVgbVŠVcV
AVbjZgiZhjXjbW^‹ZcaVajoYZaViVgYZ
NZaZhe†g^ij]VWa‹!YVcYdZheZgVcoV
KZgYVYYZb^VabVeVgVh^ZbegZgZkZaVYV
K^ZcZXdcb^\dVa]dbWgZVYZX^ghjkZgYVY
AVhbZci^gVh]Vck^k^Yd!Zab^ZYdnVcdi^ZcZaj\Vg
AVhYZXdgVX^dcZhYZVnZghZZhigZaaVcZcaVhdbWgV
AVhZhidaVhbdgVYVhhZ\jVgYVcZcXV_dcZh
9^dh!fjZaVi^ZggV\^gZVa[^cnfjZadh]dbWgZhXVbW^Zc
AVZiZgc^YVYVkVcoVnfjZbVadhYZXgZidh
9ZaV8^ZcX^Vh^ck^YVeVgVfj^ZccVYVZhhZXgZid
AdhbVZhigdhegZiZcY^ZciZhYZhVWZgnYZi^Zbed
9Z_Vg{caVajoeZcZigVgaVeg^bVkZgV
AVZhiVX^‹ckZgYZnVbVg^aaVYZadhaaVcidhYZgZcdkVX^‹c
:haVijbWVh^cbjZgidhnZa]dbWgZh^cijbWV
=dbWgZhYZaeaVcZiV!]^_dhYZa9^dhk^kd
NVkZdig^jc[VciZaVVjgdgVYZa[jijgd
6aVbZhVYZbVYZgVgZYdcYVXdbdjchda
AVhkdXZhYZad^ck^h^WaZVcjcX^VWVcaVcdi^X^V
9ZaedgkZc^gYZadh]dbWgZhh^cb^ZYdhnh^cigVWVh
BVgX]VgZg\j^Ydhna^WgZhZcaV\gVkZ]jb^aYVY
9ZVfjZaadhfjZ]VcXdbegZcY^YdfjZZaVbdgZcaVXVWZoV
:hXVeVYZaVYZcigd!eVgV]VXZgYZaZhe†g^ijhjXdgVo‹cnhjXdcfj^hiV
9LFWRU+XJR
>YZVaZheda†i^Xdh!Vgbdc†VYZajc^kZghd!XVg{XiZgY^k^cdYZ
aV8gZVX^‹c!k^h^‹cjc^kZghVaYZaeZchVb^Zcid]jbVcd!
Y^kZgh^YVY n h†ciZh^h YZ adh XdcdX^b^Zcidh ZcigZ
bViZg^Va^YVYnZhe^g^ijVa^YVY!k^gijYZhYZaVVXX^‹c/ZhiV
XdbegZch^‹c\ZcZgVaYZaVhXdhVhnYZaVk^YVYZcdiV!
V cd YjYVg! X^ZgiVh XdcXZeX^dcZh [^adh‹[^XVh Zhe†g^iVh
iVanXdbdaVhZcXdcigVbdhZcZaZhe^g^i^hbdfjZhZg†V
YZ[^c^YdVa\jcdhYZXZc^dhb{hiVgYZedg6aaVc@VgYZX#
/(-2851$/63,5,7(1o$%5,/
(.
'266,(5
/26(6&5,725(6,163,5$'26325(/0z6$//z
SRU
0$5,(12„//(&2857,2/
/$9,//$'(/6,/(1&,2
'2&80(17263Š678026'(81'2&725(10(',&,1$
5(63(&72$81&$62'(5((1&$51$&,Š1
(VWDDSDULFL§QH[LVWL§UHDOPHQWH\QRIXHXQDDOXFLQDFL§QSXUD\VLPSOHVLQRXQIHQ§PHQRGH
WUDQVILJXUDFL§QGHODTXHHOGRFWRU*LOOHV%RGLQIXHWHVWLJRSULYLOHJLDGR
A
WL_bbWZ[bI_b[dY_e! ^cXgZ†WaZ cdkZaV YZ EVja 7dY^Zg
&-,*"&.)+Y^hX†ejadYZ6aaVc@VgYZX![jZejWa^XVYV
Zc &.'&# :hiV ]^hidg^V kZgYVYZgV cdh XjZciV aV
ZmigVdgY^cVg^VVkZcijgVXjndeg^cX^eVaiZhi^\dZhjc_dkZc
b‚Y^Xd#6cX^Vcdneg‹m^bdVaVbjZgiZ!hjYZhZdZhaZ\Vghj
]^hidg^V!nZhVEVja7dY^ZgVfj^Zc]VXZaaVbVgVhjXVWZXZgV
eVgV ZcigZ\VgaZ hj bVcjhXg^id# 7dY^Zg idbV Za a^Wgd n Zh
Vh†XdbdcVXZZhiV[Vci{hi^XVcdkZaV/AVK^aaVYZah^aZcX^d#
6a [^c YZa gZaVid! EVja 7dY^Zg gZegdYjXZ Va\jcVh cdiVh
XdbeaZbZciVg^VhfjZZaYdXidg]VVŠVY^YdVabVcjhXg^id#
:hiVh dWhZgkVX^dcZh eZghdcVaZh YZbjZhigVc X‹bd hj
VkZcijgVdg^Zci‹hjhiZdg†Vh]VX^VaVYdXig^cVZhe†g^iV#
Edg digV eVgiZ! Za YdXidg <^aaZh 7dY^c YZhXg^WZ bjn
ZmVXiVbZciZ ad fjZ Zh Za Zhe^g^i^hbd bdYZgcd# :a
:he^g^i^hbd!Y^XZ!Zhjch^hiZbV[^adh‹[^XdbjnYZ[^c^Yd0Za
]dbWgZ!hjeVhVYd!hjgVo‹cYZhZg!hjedgkZc^g!iVaZhhdc
adhiZbVheg^cX^eVaZhfjZVWdgYVZhiV[^adhd[†VZhe†g^iV#:a
]dbWgZZhi{XdbejZhidedgigZheg^cX^e^dhbjnY^hi^cidh/
&•:aXjZgedbViZg^Va!hdedgiZnbZY^dYZVXX^‹cYZdigdh
Ydh eg^cX^e^dh0 '• :a Zhe†g^ij! XVjhV YZ aV XdcX^ZcX^V! aV
^ciZa^\ZcX^V n aV kdajciVY0 (• :cigZ Zhidh Ydh eg^cX^e^dh
dejZhidh! Za eZg^Zhe†g^ij d ViVYjgV [aj†Y^XV fjZ ZcaVoV Za
Zhe†g^ijVaXjZgednfjZVXdbeVŠVVaZhe†g^ijYZhej‚hYZ
aVbjZgiZiZggZcVanaZh^gkZYZcjZkdXjZged#:aXjZged!Za
eZg^Zhe†g^ijnZaZhe†g^ij!hdcadhigZheg^cX^e^dhfjZ[dgbVc
Va]dbWgZZcXVgcVYd#
:hiZ]dbWgZZc[gZci‹aVbViZg^Va^oVX^‹cXdbeaZiVYZjchZg
eZg[ZXiVbZciZdg\Vc^oVYd#:hiVVeVg^X^‹cZm^hi^‹gZVabZciZ
ncd[jZjcVVajX^cVX^‹cejgVnh^beaZ!h^cdjc[Zc‹bZcd
YZ igVch[^\jgVX^‹c YZ aV fjZ Za YdXidg <^aaZh 7dY^c [jZ
iZhi^\d eg^k^aZ\^VYd# :hiV bVc^[ZhiVX^‹c! WVhiVciZ gVgV!
eZgdfjZh^cZbWVg\dcdZhZmXZeX^dcVa!ejZYZiZcZgaj\Vg
YZ bVcZgV bViZg^Va! Zh YZX^g fjZ jc VeVgVid [did\g{[^Xd
]jW^ZgVedY^YdgZegdYjX^ghjh^b{\ZcZh#
/(-2851$/63,5,7(1o$%5,/
5HVXPHQGHODKLVWRULD
:hiVbdh Zc &-**# :c aVh kjZaiVh YZ jc eVhZd V XVWVaad!
Za_dkZcYdXidg<^aaZh7dY^chZYZi^ZcZVciZjcVk^aaVfjZ
eVgZXZYZhdXjeVYV#>bejahVYdedgjcVZmigVŠVXjg^dh^YVY!
eZcZigVZcaVXVhVnhZZcXjZcigVg{e^YVbZciZZcegZhZcX^V
YZjcXjg^dhdeZghdcV_Zfj^ZcaZY^XZ]VWZgcVX^YdZc&,(%#
8db^ZcoVZcidcXZhjcY^{ad\dZcigZadhYdhegdiV\dc^hiVh
fjZ egdhZ\j^g{ Zc Y^kZghdh ZcXjZcigdh# :a VcX^Vcd aZ
XjZciVhj]^hidg^V!aZcVggVaVigV\ZY^VfjZgdYZVhjbjZgiZ
naZgZkZaVfjZeg‹m^bVbZciZkVVgZZcXVgcVgXjVcYddigV
eZghdcV]VnVk^k^Yd^\jVabZciZZab^hbdYgVbV#:aXjg^dhd
eZghdcV_ZX^iVZcidcXZhVa_dkZcnaZegdedcZZcXdcigVghZ
Xdc‚a(*VŠdhb{hiVgYZ#9jgVciZidYdZhZi^Zbed!Za_dkZc
YdXidgYZWZg{\jVgYVgZahZXgZidnhZgZac^XdYZedh^iVg^d
YZaVhgZkZaVX^dcZhYZaVcX^Vcd#AZ]VXZegdbZiZg\jVgYVg
h^aZcX^dncdgZkZaVgcjcXVVaVcjZkVeZghdcVfjZ‚ahZg{
adfjZVciZg^dgbZciZaZ]VW†VXdc[^VYd#
EVhVc igZ^ciV n X^cXd VŠdh n Za YdXidg hZ ZcXjZcigV
Z[ZXi^kVbZciZ Zc egZhZcX^V YZa cjZkd ZcXVgcVYd# AVh
egZY^XX^dcZh hZ XjbeaZc n Za YdXidg! bjYd iZhi^\d YZ
ad fjZ aZ [jZ VcjcX^VYd! Vh^hi^g{ ^bediZciZ V aV cjZkV
Zm^hiZcX^V egd\gVbVYV YZ ZhiZ ]dbWgZ# AjZ\d! XjVcYd
idYVhaVhegZY^XX^dcZhhZ]VnVcXjbea^Yd!YVg{iZhi^bdc^d
YZhjhdWhZgkVX^dcZhnXdciVg{hj^cXgZ†WaZ]^hidg^V!Xdbd
hZad]VW†VeZY^YdZa[VciVhbV#
AVdWgVijkdjcZcdgbZ‚m^idZchjVeVg^X^‹c!nZc&.''
<VWg^Za9ZaVccZaZ]^odZaeg‹ad\dfjZaZhWg^cYVbdhVfj†/
µ)HOL]DTXHOTXHKDSRGLGRSHQHWUDU
ODVFDXVDVVHFUHWDVGHODVFRVDV¶
9ZhYZfjZZa:he^g^i^hbd]^odhjgZVeVg^X^‹cZcZabjcYd!
V bZY^VYdh YZa h^\ad eVhVYd! hZ ejZYZ V[^gbVg fjZ ]V
gZX^W^YdaVXdchV\gVX^‹cYZaV8^ZcX^V!ejZhZcidYdhadh
eV†hZh!edgkdoYZadhhVW^dhb{hVjidg^oVYdh!aVgZVa^YVY
)%
+DELWYHUV
(PPDQXHO6ZHGHQERUJ
5XG\DU.LSOLQJ
YZ hjh [Zc‹bZcdh ]V h^Yd V[^gbVYV Xdc iVciV [gZXjZcX^V! fjZ
Za aZXidg fjZ fj^h^ZgV XdckZcXZghZ YZ Zaad hZ kZg†V dWa^\VYd V
Xdchi^ij^ghZZcjcVkZgYVYZgVW^Wa^diZXV#
:aZmVbZcViZcidYZidYVhhjhbVc^[ZhiVX^dcZh]VYVYdaj\VgV
jcVbV\c†[^XVh†ciZh^hZmea^XVi^kVfjZgZhedcYZXdbeaZiVbZciZ
V ZhiVh ZaZkVYVh n bZaVcX‹a^XVh egZ\jciVh fjZ idYd ]dbWgZ
fjZe^ZchVhZ]V]ZX]dVa\cY†V/ªFj^‚cZhhdbdh4ª9ZY‹cYZ
kZc^bdh4ª6Y‹cYZkVbdh4
:h ^cY^hXji^WaZbZciZ cdiVWaZ fjZ ZhiV cjZkV [^adhd[†V hZ
ZcXjZcigZ ^\jVabZciZ VaZ_VYV YZ aVh iZdg†Vh bViZg^Va^hiVh n YZ
aVhZchZŠVcoVhYd\b{i^XVhYZaVhgZa^\^dcZh!VjcfjZidbZYZaV
X^ZcX^V hjh b‚idYdh egZX^hdh n hZ ZcXjZcigZ Xdc aVh b{h VaiVh
ZheZXjaVX^dcZhYZaZhdiZg^hbdYZidYVhaVhgZa^\^dcZh#:hejZhYZa
bVndg^ciZg‚hYVgVXdcdXZgVa\gVceWa^Xdadh[Zc‹bZcdhnaVh
iZdg†VhYZaZhe^g^i^hbdnZab‚idYdVYdeiVYdedgZaVjidgYZZhiV
ZcXVciVYdgVdWgVZhZb^cZciZbZciZVegde^VYdeVgVY^[jcY^gadh
ZcigZ aVh bVhVh! YZhed_VcYd hj ZhijY^d YZ idYV Vg^YZo n YZ aVh
Y^hXjh^dcZhejgVbZciZX^Zci†[^XVh#
AVK^aaVYZaH^aZcX^dZhjcgZaVidVeVh^dcVciZfjZZmedcZ!Zchjh
gVh\dheg^cX^eVaZhaVeVgiZ[Zcdb‚c^XVYZaZhe^g^i^hbdn!h^W^Zc
aVigVbVeZgiZcZXZZcegde^ZYVYVaVjidg!adhZe^hdY^dhhdch^c
ZbWVg\dYZjcVg^\jgdhVZmVXi^ijY!ejZhhdcXVaXVYdh!YZVa\jcV
bVcZgV! YZ adh ZmeZg^bZcidh b{h hZkZgVbZciZ XdcigdaVYdh#
Edg digV eVgiZ! ZhiV cd Zh aV eg^bZgV kZo fjZ ad fjZ hZ aaVbV
ZggVYVbZciZ¹ad bVgVk^aadhdº Zh ji^a^oVYd Zc aV a^iZgVijgV# :c Za
ai^bdh^\ad!adhZhXg^idgZhb{h^ajhigZh!cd]VcYZhYZŠVYdgZXjgg^g
VZaad#:a\gVc7VaoVXZcAdj^hAVbWZginH‚gVe]^ijhnH‚gVe]^iV
cdh]VcYVYdVXdcdXZgaVhiZdg†VhhlZYZcWdg\^VcVh#
:c JghjaZ B^gdjZ! ‚a cd iZbZ ]VXZg VeVgZXZg aV hdbWgV YZa
k^Z_d YdXidg fjZ k^ZcZ V XdchdaVg V hj eje^aV! ZmejZhid V aVh
bVfj^cVX^dcZh YZ jcV [Vb^a^V Zck^Y^dhV# :a egdY^\^dhd \Zc^d
YgVb{i^Xd YZ6aZmVcYgZ 9jbVh eVYgZ! Zc ?dhZe] 7VahVbd! cdh
]VXZVh^hi^gVaVhb{hY^kZghVhZhXZcVhYZbV\cZi^hbd!Vh†Xdbd
Zc AV 8dcYZhV YZ 8]Vgcn V aV fjZ ]dn Zc Y†V hZ aaVbVg†V jcV
VeVg^X^‹ciZaZe{i^XV!XjVcYdZa]^_dYZ6cYg‚YZIVkZgcnkZ!ZcZa
WdhfjZYZK^aaZgh"8diiZg„ih!Za[VciVhbVYZhjbVYgZ#
;^cVabZciZ! Zc :a K^oXdcYZ YZ 7gV\ZadccZ! 6i]dh! bdg^WjcYd!
eZgX^WZZaVabVYZhj]^_d!]Zg^YdbdgiVabZciZZcaVXdhiVV[g^XVcV
n Za YZhegZcY^b^Zcid YZ hj XjZged ZaZk{cYdhZ Va ZheVX^d#IdYdh
Zhidh [Zc‹bZcdh i^ZcZc jcV gZVa^YVY iVc ^cY^hXji^WaZbZciZ
ZhiVWaZX^YV]dn!fjZadhZhXg^idgZhXdbdaVhZŠdgVYZEVja<gZcYZa!
ZaYdXidgLnabnGjYnVgY@^ea^c\adh]Vcji^a^oVYdZcejWa^XVX^dcZh
gZX^ZciZhfjZ]Vcad\gVYdjckZgYVYZgd‚m^id#:hidnVWhdajiVbZciZ
eZghjVY^Yd YZ fjZ AVK^aaV YZa H^aZcX^d ]ZX]^oVg{ V adh aZXidgZh!
ejZh!Va^ciZg‚hVeVh^dcVciZYZagZaVid!VaV\gVYVX^‹chVW^VbZciZ
bZY^YV YZ adh Ze^hdY^dh hZ V\gZ\Vc Y^hXjh^dcZh W^Zc XdcYjX^YVh
fjZedcZcYZgZa^ZkZaV^bedgiVcX^V[^adh‹[^XVYZXVYVjcdYZZhidh
VXdciZX^b^Zcidh n YZ Zaad gZhjaiV jcV k^h^‹c YZ Xdc_jcid YZ aV
YdXig^cVZhe†g^iV!bjneVgi^XjaVgbZciZYZaVZchZŠVcoVYZaVhk^YVh
hjXZh^kVh!fjZhZ\gVWVg{ZcaVbZbdg^VYZidYdhadhaZXidgZh#:a
Zhi^adZhVeVh^dcVciZ!ed‚i^Xd!h^ZbegZVaZciVYdgncdhZh^ZciZZa
igVWV_dYZaVjidgfjZ!cddWhiVciZ!]VYZW^YdhZgXdch^YZgVWaZ!eVgV
XdchZ\j^gYVgVhjdWgViVaXVg{XiZgYZgZVa^YVY#
6\gVYZoXVbdhejZhVEVja7dY^ZgaVcdWaZiVgZVfjZ]VZbegZcY^Yd
nYZhZVbdhfjZZa\gVceWa^XdY^h[gjiZYZaZcXVcidYZZhiVdWgV!
]VX^ZcYdYZZaaVidYdZa‚m^idfjZiVcidbZgZXZ!ejZhZhiZa^Wgd
ZhVaVkZojcV]ZgbdhVdWgVnjcVWjZcVVXX^‹c#
<VWg^Za9ZaVccZ!EgZh^YZciZYZaV¹Jc^‹c:he†g^iVºYZ;gVcX^V#
/(-2851$/63,5,7(1o$%5,/
)&
8dbdhZ]VWg{cYVYdXjZciV!ZhiZgZaVidZhjcV]^hidg^V
kZgYVYZgV!neVgVYVgaZhjcVci^X^edn!edgfj‚cd!ZaYZhZd
YZ aZZgaV! aZh egZhZciVbdh Vfj† Za Xdb^Zcod! XjVcYd Za
Vjidg ZcXjZcigV edg eg^bZgV kZo aV bViZg^Va^oVX^‹c YZa
[VciVhbV#
¹:a - YZ bVnd YZ &.&%! gZX^W† jc WgZkZ iZaZ\gVbV
gZYVXiVYdVh†/»9dXidg<^aaZh7dY^c!bdg^WjcYd!aZgZXaVbV
^cbZY^ViVbZciZ¼#BZhdgegZcY†jcedXdVagZX^W^gVfjZa
iZaZ\gVbV! ejZh c^c\c aVod YZ eVgZciZhXd bZ jc†V V
aV eZghdcV fjZ hZ bZ YZX†V bdg^WjcYV# :a YdXidg <^aaZh
7dY^cZgVjck^Z_dVb^\dYZb^[Vb^a^Vn!]VhiVZhZY†V!nd
cd]VW†ViZc^Ydb{hfjZgZaVX^dcZhhjeZg[^X^VaZhXdc‚a/
jcViVg_ZiVZck^VYVXVYVVŠdeVgVZaY†VYZ6ŠdCjZkd!
n jcV XdgiV k^h^iV fjZ ]VX†V XjVcYd edg XVhjVa^YVY ^WV
VIdjgh! b^ X^jYVY cViVa! YdcYZ k^k†V Za YdXidg n YdcYZ
]VW†VZ_ZgX^YdaVbZY^X^cVedgXVh^X^cXjZciVVŠdh#=VX†V
nVVa\ci^ZbedfjZZaYdXidg<^aaZh7dY^c!bjnVcX^Vcd!
iZc†VdX]ZciVVŠdh!cdZ_ZgX†VnVedgVh†YZX^ghjVgiZ!n
hZ]VW†VgZi^gVYdVjcVXVh^iVbjnXZgXVYZaVZhiVX^‹c
YZ Idjgh# Adh aVodh YZ Vb^hiVY fjZ bZ jc†Vc V ‚a! cd
_jhi^[^XVWVc!Vb^hd_dh!ZaZck†dYZahjhdY^X]diZaZ\gVbV!
h^cZbWVg\dedgYZ[ZgZcX^V]VX^VZaY^\cdVcX^Vcd!XgZ†b^
YZWZggZhedcYZgVaaaVbVYdfjZhZbZ]VW†V]ZX]d#H^c
Y^aVX^‹cidb‚ZaigZcb{hg{e^Yd!nbZcdhYZX^cXd]dgVh
YZhej‚hYZb^hVa^YVYZEVg†h!]VW†VaaZ\VYdVaYdb^X^a^d
YZaVcX^VcdYdXidg#;j^^cigdYjX^YdZchZ\j^YVVaVVaXdWV
YZa bdg^WjcYd! XjnVh [jZgoVh Z ^ciZa^\ZcX^V eVgZX^Zgdc
gZVc^bVghZhW^iVbZciZVakZgbZ#
6jcVhZŠVahjnV!aVZc[ZgbZgVfjZhZZcXdcigVWVXZgXV
YZ aV XVbV hZ gZi^g‹! n fjZY‚ hdad XdckZghVcYd Xdc Za
Zc[Zgbd# JcV kZo aaZ\VYd V hj aVYd! ]Z Vfj† ad fjZ Za
bdg^WjcYdbZgZkZa‹/
»=^_dfjZg^Yd!bZY^_dZckdoWV_V!Vc]ZaVciZ!Zhidnbjn
hVi^h[ZX]dYZfjZ]VnVhgZhedcY^YdXdciVciVhda^X^ijYV
b^aaVbVYd#CdbZfjZYVcb{hfjZVa\jcVh]dgVhYZk^YV
niZb†VcdedYZgYVgiZYZk^kVkdoVa\jcVhZmea^XVX^dcZh
gZheZXid V jc dW_Zid fjZ fj^Zgd YVgiZ# H^ fj^ZgZh VWg^g
aVW^Wa^diZXVfjZZhi{XZgXVYZi^0hdWgZaVeg^bZgViVWaV
Vgg^WV]VnjceZfjZŠdeVfjZiZ!i‹bVad!ZheVgVi^¼#
>cbZY^ViVbZciZ dWZYZX† Va VcX^Vcd! h^c gZhedcYZg! VWg†
Za bjZWaZ n Zc Z[ZXid! ZcXdcig‚ Za eZfjZŠd eVfjZiZ
^cY^XVYd#
»6]dgV!Xdci^cj‹Zabdg^WjcYd!«kZcVhZciVgiZXZgXVYZ
b†nZhXjX]V
Ad fjZ iZ ZcigZ\d ]dn! Zh jc bVcjhXg^id idiVabZciZ
ZhXg^id edg b^ bVcd0 Za gZaVid fjZ Xdci^ZcZ gZ[^ZgZ aV
b{h h^c\jaVg n b{h ZmigVdgY^cVg^V VkZcijgV fjZ jc hZg
]jbVcd ejZYV XdcXZW^g# =Vg{h Xdc ZhiZ gZaVid ad fjZ
_jo\jZhWjZcd0iZYZ_dZaXj^YVYdYZedcZgZcdgYZcaVh
cdiVhVŠVY^YVhVfj†nVaa{!iVbW^‚cYZgZXi^[^XVgX^ZgiVh
[gVhZhh^iZYZX^YZhVejWa^XVgadVa\cY†V!nXgZdfjZiZ
YZX^Y^g{hV]VXZgad!cdedgfjZZhiZigVWV_dhZVjcVdWgV
a^iZgVg^V^beZXVWaZ!h^cdedgfjZhZ]Vg{cZXZhVg^d#
IZ]ZaZ\VYdedgiZhiVbZcidjceZfjZŠddWhZfj^deVgV
^cYZbc^oVgiZedgaVbdaZhi^VfjZiZZhidnXVjhVcYdV]dgV0
cdiZc\dh^cdjcVbjnbdYZhiV[dgijcVfjZYZ_dVb^h
/(-2851$/63,5,7(1o$%5,/
]ZgZYZgdh Y^gZXidh! eZgd V i^ iZ ]Z gZhZgkVYd Za Ydc YZ
ZhiZbVcjhXg^id!bjX]db{hegZX^dhdfjZidYdZaY^cZgd
fjZejY^ZgVd[gZXZgiZ!ejZhZgZhZac^XdXVeVoiVcidYZ
XdbegZcYZgadXdbdYZji^a^oVgad¼#:cZhZbdbZcid!jcV
Xg^h^h k^daZciV hd[dX‹ Va bdg^WjcYd! n YZW† aaVbVg V aV
Zc[ZgbZgV#
6 eZhVg YZ adh Xj^YVYdh fjZ ZaaV n nd egdY^\Vbdh Va
YdXidg <^aaZh 7dY^c! ‚hiZ cd gZXdWg‹ Za XdcdX^b^Zcid!
n jcV ]dgV YZhej‚h Zme^gVWV Zc cjZhigdh WgVodh#
GZheZijdhd YZ aV ai^bV kdajciVY YZ b^ k^Z_d Vb^\d!
ZcigZ\d]dnZhiZbVcjhXg^idVaeWa^Xd!fjZVhjkZoYZWZ
idbVgXdcdX^b^ZcidYZaVVhdbWgdhV]^hidg^V!n_jo\Vg{
Xdc idYV ^cYZeZcYZcX^V YZhej‚h YZ ]VWZgad aZ†Yd! ejZh
Za gZaVid fjZ h^\jZ Zh jc [gV\bZcid YZa ZiZgcd edZbV
YZaVCVijgVaZoVigVYjX^YdZcjcaZc\jV_Z]jbVcd!fjZ
VcjcX^VaVk^Xidg^VYZaVajo!ZaXVadgnaV]ZgbdhjgVhdWgZ
idYdadfjZZh[Zd!hdbWg†dn]ZaVYdº#
EVja7dY^Zg#
(OFRPLHQ]RGHOUHODWR
¹H^]VnjceZfjZŠdg^cX‹cYZ;gVcX^VYdcYZhZgZhe^gVjc
V^gZ ejgd Zc aVh aaVcjgVh kZgYdhVh gZ\VYVh edg jc Wdc^id
g†d! ‚hiZ Zh h^c Y^hXjh^‹c Za XdfjZid kVaaZ YZa Ad^g! n Za
k^V_Zgd fjZ YjgVciZ adh bZhZh YZ kZgVcd! h^\jZ Za Xjghd
YZa VeVX^WaZ g†d! aVbZciV cd edYZg YZiZgb^cVg! ZcigZ aVh
Ydh dg^aaVh! Zc Xj{a aZ \jhiVg†V [^_Vg hj gZh^YZcX^V# :h Zc
aVh egdm^b^YVYZh YZ ZhiZ VbVWaZ kVaaZ! jc edXd hdWgZ
aV eZfjZŠV X^jYVY YZ 8]}iZVj"Yj"Ad^g! fjZ nd iZc†V aV
XdhijbWgZYZ^gXVYVVŠd!VXVhVYZb^hVWjZadhVeVhVgZa
i^ZbedYZb^hkVXVX^dcZhYZZhijY^VciZVaWdgdiVYdgnV
kZXZhedXdhZg^d#6]dgVW^Zc!VfjZaVŠdYZ&-**!ndiZc†V
kZ^ci^X^cXd VŠdh/ VXVWVWV YZ gZX^W^gbZ Xdbd YdXidg Zc
bZY^X^cVYZaV;VXjaiVYYZEVg†h!nZhiVWVjcedXddg\jaadhd
YZb^Y^eadbV!XVg\VYdYZ^b{\ZcZhYdcYZZaedgkZc^gn
adhegdnZXidh!cdhdcb{hfjZeVaVWgVhkV\VhfjZbVahZ
hVWZc YZ[^c^g n fjZ h^ZbegZ hdc Ydb^cVYVh edg hjZŠdh
^begZX^hdh!eZgdedYZgdhVbZciZYdgVYdhedgaVk^kVX^YVY
YZcjZhigV^bV\^cVX^‹c!hjZŠdhfjZXdc[gZXjZcX^VcdhZ
gZVa^oVccjcXV!nXjndgZXjZgYda^\ZgdhZe^ZgYZVa\db{h
$SHVDUGHORVFXLGDGRVTXHHOOD\\R
SURGLJDPRVDOGRFWRU*LOOHV%RGLQ
žVWHQRUHFREU§HOFRQRFLPLHQWR\XQD
KRUDGHVSXžVH[SLUDEDHQQXHVWURV
EUD]RV5HVSHWXRVRGHOD®OWLPD
YROXQWDGGHPLYLHMRDPLJRHQWUHJRKR\
HVWHPDQXVFULWRDOS®EOLFR
iVgYZXdbdjc]jbd[j\^i^kdZcZaVojaYZaX^Zad#
6]dgVW^Zc!jcVbVŠVcVfjZ]VW†VeVgi^YdVh†VaVVkZcijgV!
Y^g^\†Vb^XVWVaadedgjceZfjZŠdhZcYZgdeg^kVYdfjZ
iZgb^cVWV Zc aV gZ_V YZ jcV egde^ZYVY fjZ hZ eZgX^W†V
kV\VbZciZVaWdgYZYZaVXVggZiZgV#Cdh‚fj‚Xjg^dh^YVY
bZ^bejah‹VfjZaaVbVŠVcV]VX^VZhZh^aZcX^dhdXVhZg‹c!
)'
(&26
/26(6&5,725(6
,163,5$'26325(/0z6$//z
º>;I?:EKD79J?LE
Cx:?KC;I9H?8?;DJ;±»
EVja6YVb!ZhXg^idg[gVcX‚h&-+'"&.'%
iZc†V XdcX^ZcX^V YZ hj XVeVX^YVY eVgV
gZX^W^gVadhZhe†g^ijh/¹=Zh^YdjcVXi^kd
b‚Y^jb ZhXg^W^ZciZ# AV [jZgoV fjZ bZ
^che^gVWV iZc†V iVa [jZgoV [†h^XV! fjZ
dWa^\VWVVaa{e^oa^WgZVgZbdciVgaVXjZhiV
YZaeVeZa^cXa^cVYdedgb^bVcd!VeZhVg
YZaVhaZnZhYZaVeZhVYZo#:hiV[jZgoVkZ†V
cd h‹ad Za eVhVYd fjZ nd YZhXdcdX†V!
h^cdfjZiZc†VaVegZhX^ZcX^VYZaedgkZc^g#
HjhegZY^XX^dcZhZgVcVhdbWgdhVhedghj
gZVa^oVX^‹c!k^hidfjZcVYV!cVYV!bZad
edY†V]VXZgegZkZgº#
eZgdbZeVgZX†VfjZjcV[jZgoVYZhXdcdX^YV!^cYZeZcY^ZciZYZb^
kdajciVY!bZ^cX^iVWVVWjhXVgVa\d!Va\c^cY^X^deVgVVnjYVgbZ
VeZcZigVgZab^hiZg^dYZVfjZaVWVcYdcd#6aaaZ\VgVaVgZ_VhVai‚
YZaXVWVaadnVi‚VaVc^bVaVjcdYZadhWVggdiZh!ajZ\dh^ceZchVg!
n Xdbd h^ Va\j^Zc YZW^ZgV kZc^g VWg^gbZ! idb‚ jc VaVbWgZ fjZ
XdggZhedcY†VVjcVXVbeVcVfjZeZgX^W†YZig{hYZaVgZ_V!Vgg^WV
YZaidYd#I^g‚a^\ZgVbZciZeg^bZgd!ajZ\db{h[jZgiZ!najZ\dbjn
k^daZciVbZciZ VciZh YZ edYZg ]VXZg k^WgVg aV XVbeVcV fjZ jc
WZ_jXdYZigZeVYdgVbVciZc†Veg^h^dcZgV#
6 b^ ai^bd Zh[jZgod! Za WVYV_d hVX‹ Va WgdcXZ jc hdc^Yd
egd[jcYd! hdgYd! XVh^ h^c^Zhigd! fjZ gZeZgXji^‹ Xdbd jc ZXd
Zc aVh egd[jcY^YVYZh YZa _VgY†c# Jc ZhXVad[g†d gZXdgg^‹ idYd
b^ hZg! bZ eVgZX^‹ ]VWZg YZheZgiVYd idgeZ Z ^ci^abZciZ jcV
Vci^\“ZYVY Ydgb^YV! n bZ hZci† ^cX‹bdYd# HdWgZ b^ XVWZoV
jc b^gad Wjga‹c! ZhXdcY^Yd ZcigZ Za ZheZhd [daaV_Z YZ jc \gVc
{gWda!gZhedcY^‹!h^aWVcYd^g‹c^XVbZciZ!Vahdc^YdYZaVXVbeVcV
XjnVai^bVk^WgVX^‹cVXVWVWVYZVeV\VghZ#EdghjejZhid!cVY^Z
VXjY^‹Vb^aaVbVYd!nhdcgZ†VciZadfjZiZgb^c‚edgXdch^YZgVg
jcVX]^fj^aaVYVYZb^eVgiZ#CddWhiVciZb^Xjg^dh^YVYVccd
ZhiVWVhVi^h[ZX]V!nYZ_VcYdVb^XVWVaadViVYdVaVgZ_V!WdgYZ‚
aVbjgVaaVfjZgdYZVWVZa_VgY†c#BZY^XjZciVZcidcXZhYZfjZ
aV egde^ZYVY YZW†V iZcZg jcV \gVc ZmiZch^‹c! adh bjgdh fjZ aV
gdYZVWVch^ZbegZhZegdadc\VWVc0ZaiZggZcdfjZhZZcXdcigVWV
YZig{hYZaVk^k^ZcYVYZW†VhZgjceVgfjZXdch^YZgVWaZ!db{hW^Zc
jcV hjZgiZ YZ WdhfjZ! YZa XjVa VeZcVh ZcigZkZ†V aV XdeV YZ adh
{gWdaZh!VegZiVYdhnZcigZbZoXaVYdh!eZgdYZadhfjZVY^k^cVWV
aVhWVhZheZgY^YVhZcigZadhgZkdai^_dh^cZmig^XVWaZhYZkZgYdg#
B^ Xjg^dh^YVY hZ V\jY^oVWV! Za bjgd fjZ ZhiVWV WdgYZVcYd cd
bZ eVgZX†V bjn Vaid! n jc adXd YZhZd bZ k^cd Va Zhe†g^ij! Za
YZ eZcZigVg Zc VfjZaaV egde^ZYVY eVgV gZXdggZgaV Zc idYdh adh
hZci^Ydh#:chjbV!ndcdVgg^Zh\VWVcVYV!nbZZmXjhVWVVciZb^h
egde^dhd_dhedgb^Xjg^dh^YVY#H^ceZchVgadb{h!igZe‚hdWgZjc
hVa^ZciZVednVYdVabjgd!nYZjc{\^ahVaidZhijkZhdWgZaVXgZhiV#
IjkZidYVk†VjcV^cYZX^h^‹cfjZYjg‹h‹adjchZ\jcYd!nYVcYdaV
ZheVaYVVaeZchVb^ZcidYZfjZ]VX†VbVa!bZYZ_‚XVZghdWgZaV
ZheZhV]^ZgWVYZaeVgfjZ#H^ZbegZh^ceZchVg!bZVYZaVci‚]VhiV
aVejZgiVYZaVXVhV!nXdcjc\ZhidbjncVijgVaigVi‚YZVWg^gaV!
ZheZgVcYd YZ hdWgV ZcXdcigVgaV XZggVYV# EVgV b^ \gVc hdgegZhV!
hZVWg^‹!nYVcYdjceVhdVYZaVciZ!bZZcXdcig‚ZcjcVVbea^V
]VW^iVX^‹cfjZbZeVgZX^‹WVhiVciZgZXVg\VYV#
+R\HQG¢D\DQRVHHGLWDHVWDQRYHODSHURWDOYH]
SXHGDQ HQFRQWUDUOD HQ ,QWHUQHW HVSHFLDOPHQWH
FRQVXOWDQGRHOVLWHZZZOLYUHUDUHERRNFRP
b&RQXQSRFRGHVXHUWHTXL]–VKD\DWRGDY¢DDOJXQRV
HMHPSODUHV
H^ZbegZ ^bejahVYd edg jcV [jZgoV ^cXdchX^ZciZ n Xdbd h^ YZ
kZgVh]jW^ZgVh^YdZcXVg\VYdYZ^ckZciVg^VgidYdadfjZ]VW†VV
b^VagZYZYdg!VWg†aVW^Wa^diZXV!nidb‚jca^WgdVaVoVgYZjcdYZ
adhVcVfjZaZh!eZgdZcZabdbZcidZcfjZbZY^hedc†VVaZZg!
d† YZig{h YZ b† jcV g^h^iV hZbZ_VciZ Va gj^Yd YZ jcV bVigVXV!
nbZkdak†iVcWgjhXVbZciZfjZYZ_‚XVZgZaa^WgdfjZiZc†VZc
aVbVcd!adXjVaegdYj_djcVcjWZYZedakdbjnYZhV\gVYVWaZ
YjgVciZkVg^dhhZ\jcYdh#EZgdZhdbZ^bedgi‹edXdZcidcXZh!
ejZheVgVb^\gVcZhijeZ[VXX^‹ck^YZaVciZYZb†Vjck^Z_^id
YZ jcdh hZhZciV VŠdh fjZ bZ b^gVWV ]VX^ZcYd d†g h^ZbegZ
VfjZaaVZmigVŠVg^hVfjZbZ]VW†V]ZX]dkdakZgiVck^kVbZciZ#
:chZ\j^YV hZ bZ ]^od Zk^YZciZ aV g^Y^XjaZo YZ b^ h^ijVX^‹c n!
gd_dYZhdgegZhV!ZmXaVb‚/
¸Fj^h^ZgVjhiZY!hZŠdg!ZmXjhVgaVcZXZYVYYZjc]dbWgZfjZhZ
]V^cigdYjX^YdZchjbdgVYV#HdnZaYdXidg<^aaZh7dY^c!nejZYZ
ZhiVghZ\jgdYZfjZcdiZc\dc^c\jcVbVaV^ciZcX^‹c#HdaVbZciZ
/(-2851$/63,5,7(1o$%5,/
)(
jcV ^cZmea^XVWaZ Xjg^dh^YVY bZ ]V ^bejahVYd V kZc^g V
Zhidhaj\VgZh!XgZnZcYd!aZXdc[^Zhd!cdZcXdcigVgVcVY^Z!
ejZheZchVWVfjZaVXVhVZhiVWVYZh]VW^iVYV#
¸:cZ[ZXidadZhi{!cdhZZfj^kdXVjhiZY!bZgZhedcY^‹
Zak^Z_^id!XdcjcVkdoV\g^VXdbdhjg^hV#
¸H†! eZgd Zc idYd XVhd! ^\cdgVWV fjZ Za egde^ZiVg^d
k^c^ZgVVkZXZh!niZc\dfjZZmegZhVgaZb^bVndgeZhVg
edg ]VWZgbZ XdcYjX^Yd iVc cZX^VbZciZ Xdc ‚a# B^
^ciZgadXjidg ]^od d†g YZ cjZkd hj g^hV ZhWdoVcYd jc
\Zhid^g‹c^Xd#
¸«7V]:abVacdZh\gVcYZ!Zhi{jhiZYY^hXjaeVYd!n
h^ZcYd Vh†! iZc\V ejZh aV WdcYVY YZ hZciVghZ! n h^ ad
YZhZVkVbdhVX]VgaVgjcedXd#Nbjnk^kd!Zak^Z_^id
hVXjY^‹ZaedakdYZjcVYZaVhh^aaVh!ajZ\dXdc\gVX^V
aV VXZgX‹ V b†! b^ZcigVh ‚a b^hbd idbVWV Vh^Zcid
Zc aV WjiVXV YZaVciZ YZa ZhXg^idg^d# 9ZhXdcXZgiVYd
n Xdc[jhd! dWZYZX† n bZ YZ_‚ XVZg b{h W^Zc fjZ
hZciVgbZhdWgZaVh^aaVfjZVh†bZZgVd[gZX^YV#H‹adZc
ZhZbdbZcid!dWhZgk‚ZaZmigVŠdViVk†dYZaeZghdcV_Z#
whiZ! Zc Z[ZXid! ZhiVWV kZhi^Yd Xdbd ad ]VX†Vc adh
hZŠdgZh YZ bZY^VYdh YZa h^\ad MK>>>/ XVao‹c Xdgid!
bZY^VhYZhZYVnXVhVXVYZVXjZgYdXdcZaXVao‹c!Zc
jcVeVaVWgViZc†VVciZb^hd_dhVjc]dbWgZfjZbZ
eVgZX†V]VWZghdWgZk^k^YdVhj‚edXV!nijkZjc\Zhid
fjZ igV^X^dc‹ b^ hdgegZhV# 9Z cjZkd Za k^Z_^id YZ_‹
ZhXjX]Vghjg^hVV\jYVnV\g^VfjZ!cdh‚edgfj‚bZ
^begZh^dcVWVYZhV\gVYVWaZbZciZ!ajZ\dbZY^_d/
¸JhiZYdWhZgkVb^ViVk†dfjZnVcdZhi{YZbdYV!«Z]°
B^igV_Znb^XVao‹cXdgidaZVhdbWgVc#Fj‚fj^ZgZjhiZY
YZb^i^Zbed!jcdhZkZhi†VY^[ZgZciZfjZV]dgV!ZhdZh
idYd#AZkVci‚adhd_dh!gZeZci^cVbZciZZhijeZ[VXid#
¸ª9Zhji^Zbed47VaWjXZ‚#
¸«EjZhh†8VgdhZŠdg!YZb^i^Zbed!ZhYZX^gXjVcYdZgV
_dkZc!XjVcYdiZc†VhjZYVY!kZ^ci^X^cXdVŠdh!Zc&,**!
]VXZ ZmVXiVbZciZ X^Zc VŠdh! ejZh! h^ cd bZ Zfj^kdXd!
V]dgVZhiVbdhZc&-**#BZejhZYZe^ZYZjchVaidn!
bZaZkVci‚iVcWgjhXVbZciZfjZkdafj‚aVh^aaVhdWgZaV
fjZZhiVWVhZciVYd#
¸KZVbdh! kZVbdh! Xdci^cj‹ Za h^c\jaVg eZghdcV_Z!
h^ZbegZ bjn XVabVYd! aZ gjZ\d! Y‚_ZbZ hZ\j^g! iZcYg{
bdi^kdheVgVVhdbWgVghZb{hXjVcYdhZeV°
¸8jVcYd hZeV° gZeZi† Xdbd jc ZXd! XVYV kZo b{h
VijgY^Yd#
¸KVnV! cd ZhiVWV jhiZY Xjg^dhd! bZ ad ]V Xdc[ZhVYd
]VXZ edXd! «n W^Zc AZ VhZ\jgd fjZ hj Xjg^dh^YVY hZg{
hVi^h[ZX]V0 kVbdh! aZkVciZ hj h^aaV! h^‚ciZhZ n h†\VbZ
ZhXjX]VcYd#6ciZZhiVheVaVWgVh!hZci†bdciVgZcb†jcV
X‹aZgVhdgYV!nZmXaVb‚XdckZ]ZbZcX^V/
¸HZ WjgaV jhiZY! hZŠdg# Fj^o{h fj^ZgV XVhi^\VgbZ edg
]VWZgdhVYdeZcZigVgVfj†!ni^ZcZ\jhidZcbd[VghZYZ
b†#6igZk^‚cYdhZ V egZiZcYZg fjZ ZhiVWV k^kd! ]VXZ jc
h^\ad!Zc&,**#
¸8dbdiZc\dZa]dcdgYZYZX^gaZ!ZhiVZh!hZad_jgd!aV
ZmVXiVkZgYVY!naZgZe^idfjZZcZhV‚edXVndiZc†Vhj
ZYVY!kZ^ci^X^cXdVŠdh!]VW^ZcYdcVX^YdZa&YZbVndYZ
&,(%#9ZcjZkdY^jcgZhe^c\d#
/(-2851$/63,5,7(1o$%5,/
¸AZgjZ\d!hZŠdg!fjZhjheZcYVZhiVWgdbVeZhVYV!cd
hdn jc c^Šd! n Zh ^ci^a aaZkVg aV [VghV b{h aZ_dh0 jhiZY
cdi^ZcZ!cdejZYZiZcZg&'*VŠdh!nVYZb{h!h^]jW^ZgV
aaZ\VYd V ZhV ZmigVdgY^cVg^V ZYVY! ZhiVg†V jhiZY b{h
ZcXdgkVYdnb{hVX]VXdhdYZadfjZeVgZXZ#
¸«9^dhb†d8VgdhZŠdg!cdfj^ZgdY^hejiVg!c^Y^hXji^g
Xdc jhiZY ]dn! bZ gZhZgkd XdckZcXZgaZ jc edXd b{h
iVgYZ! ejZh cdh kdakZgZbdh V kZg# BVŠVcV! ]{\VbZ Za
]dcdgYZkdakZgVfj†VaVb^hbV]dgV!ndiVbW^‚ckZcYg‚
n X]VgaVgZbdh b{h aVg\VbZciZ# AV bVcZgV Zc fjZ kdn
V YZheZY^gbZ YZ hj dWhi^cVYV eZghdcV! X^ZgiVbZciZ aZ
hdgegZcYZg{! iVcid d b{h fjZ idYd ad fjZ aZ VXVWdYZ
YZX^g!nhZg{eVgVjhiZYbViZg^VYZgZ[aZm^‹c#AVcdX]ZaZ
VXdchZ_Vg{!eZgdVciZhYZhZeVgVgcdh!aZ]Vg‚jceZfjZŠd
[Vkdg#JhiZY]VZhXVaVYdZabjgdeVgVkZc^g]VhiVVfj†
n]VYZh\VggVYdhjigV_Z!VaV^ofj^ZgYVXZgXVYZaXdYd0
Zh ^ci^a fjZ kjZakV V ]VXZg iVa \^bcVh^V0 i^ZcZ V W^Zc
hZg {\^a! eZgd Zh bZ_dg fjZ idbZ jc XVb^cd bZcdh
eZa^\gdhd! hVa\V ejZh hZcX^aaVbZciZ edg aV gZ_V YZaVciZ
YZaVXVhV!h‹adiZcYg{fjZi^gVgYZaXZggd_dfjZaVX^ZggV
edgYZcigd#IVakZoiZc\VVa\jcVY^[^XjaiVYeVgV]VXZgad
[jcX^dcVg! ejZh aVh ^c_jg^Vh YZa i^Zbed ad ]Vc dm^YVYd
[jZgiZbZciZ!eZgde^ZchdfjZadXdchZ\j^g{!nbVŠVcV!
XjVcYd kjZakV! h^beaZbZciZ VednZ Za YZYd hdWgZ jcV
hjZgiZYZWdi‹c\gVcYZ!h^ijVYdVaVYZgZX]V!XZgXVYZa
e^XVedgiZ YZ ]^Zggd! aV gZ_V hZ VWg^g{! Vh† Xdbd idYd Za
XZggd_d hZ gZedcYg{ Va bdbZcid Zc fjZ X^ZggZ jhiZY
aVejZgiV#:hjcbZXVc^hbdhZXgZid!jcWdc^idigVWV_d!
hZŠdg! ]ZX]d edg jc dWgZgd YZa h^\ad eVhVYd# «KVbdh
7jZcVhiVgYZhnbVŠVcVh^c[VaiV#
>WV V gZhedcYZgaZ Va h^c\jaVg eZghdcV_Z! XjVcYd eVgV
b^ \gVc ZhijeZ[VXX^‹c bZ Y^ XjZciV YZ fjZ nV cd
ZhiVWV YZaVciZ YZ b^h d_dh# =VW†V YZhVeVgZX^Yd
^chiVci{cZVbZciZ#B^g‚Vb^VagZYZYdg!bZZcXdcigVWV
XdbeaZiVbZciZhdadZcaV]VW^iVX^‹c#EdgjcdhhZ\jcYdh
XgZ† fjZ b^ XZgZWgd ZhiVaaVg†V! iVc VijgY^Yd ZhiVWV!
ajZ\d gZXdWg{cYdbZ jc edXd! bZ VWVaVcX‚ ]VX^V aV
ejZgiV n ZhXjYg^Š‚ adh VagZYZYdgZh! hZ\jgd YZ fjZ b^
^ciZgadXjidgcd]VW†VedY^Yd]j^giVcg{e^YVbZciZ#6aa†!
Xdbd Zc aV ]VW^iVX^‹c! cd k^ cVYV! n Xdc[jcY^Yd! h^c
hVWZgfj‚eZchVgbZY^g^\†bVfj^cVabZciZ]VX^VaVgZ_V
eVgV]j^gadb{hg{e^YVbZciZedh^WaZ#6aaaZ\VgXZgXVYZ
aVgZ_VgZXdgY‚aVh^chigjXX^dcZhfjZhZbZ]VW†VcYVYd!
Z[ZXi^kVbZciZ!ZaXZggd_dZm^hi†V!nad]^XZ[jcX^dcVgh^c
Zh[jZgod#AVejZgiVhZVWg^‹nbZZcXdcig‚XVh^ZchZ\j^YV
VadigdaVYdYZaVgZ_VfjZVigV_Zk^daZciVbZciZ]VX^V
b†# D† jc eZfjZŠd gj^Yd hZXd fjZ bZ ^cY^X‹ fjZ Za
XZggd_dkdak†VVhjaj\Vg#H^ZbegZXjg^dhd!h^cZbWVg\d!
bZ VigZk† V VednVg Za YZYd Zc Za aj\Vg ^cY^XVYd! Va
eg^bZgk^hiVod]VW†VeZgX^W^YdZaWdi‹c#7V_daVegZh^‹c!
ZhXjX]‚YZcjZkdjcgj^YdhZXd!naVgZ_Vkdak^‹VVWg^g#
AVXZgg‚ZchZ\j^YVn!YZhViVcYdVaXVWVaadfjZe^V[VWV!
hVai‚VaVh^aaV#:aVc^bVa!e^XVYdedgb^hZhejZaVh!eVgi^‹
Va\VadeZ#Jcb^cjidYZhej‚h]VW†V\VcVYdaVXVggZiZgV
nYZ_‚XdggZgVaVWZhi^V!fjZVjc\VadeZadXdbZkdak^‹
VaaZkVg]VhiVaVXVhVYZb^hVWjZadhº#
))
'266,(5
/26(6&5,725(6,163,5$'26325(/0z6$//z
SRU
(00$18(//(3ƒ&+(85
$/(;$1'5('80$63$'5(
+RPEUH GH WHDWUR HQ VX FRUD]§Q 'XPDV PDQWHQGU– HQ VXV QRYHODV HO VHQWLGR GH OD
HVFHQRJUDI¢D\HOJXVWRSRUODV¶VRUSUHVDV·&RODERUDFRQYDULRVDXWRUHVHVSHFLDOPHQWHFRQ
$XJXVWH0DTXHWDTXLHQFRQRFL§HQ
:
cigZ aV bjai^ijY YZ dWgVh
ZhXg^iVh edg 6aZmVcYgZ
9jbVh! aVh gZ[ZgZcX^Vh V aV
[^adhd[†V Zhe†g^iV igVhajXZc Zc hj
ZhXg^ijgVncdheZgb^iZcXVa^[^XVgad
YZ h^beVi^oVciZ Zhe†g^iV Xdbd
ad [jZ hj XdciZbedg{cZd K^Xidg
=j\d! V fj^Zc! edg digV eVgiZ!
XdcdX^‹bjnW^Zc#
9Zhej‚h YZ jcV WgZkZ W^d\gV[†V
YZ 6aZmVcYgZ 9jbVh! X^iVgZbdh
Va\jcdh ZmigVXidh YZ hj dWgV!
^cbZchV Zc gZhjbZc! fjZ
gZkZaVc hj ^ciZg‚h edg idYd ad
fjZ hZ gZ[^ZgV V aV k^YV YZhej‚h
YZ aV bjZgiZ! Za bV\cZi^hbd! aV
XaVg^k^YZcX^V!ZiX#
(OHPHQWRVELRJU•ILFRV
6aZmVcYgZ 9jbVh! hj kZgYVYZgd
cdbWgZZgV6aZmVcYgZ9VknYZaV
EV^aaZiZg^Z cVX^‹ ZcK^aaZgh"8diiZg„ih# DWa^\VYd V igVWV_Vg
YZhYZhjeg^bZgV_jkZcijY!XdbZco‹XdbdZhXg^W^ZciZYZ
cdiVg^d#6adhkZ^ciZVŠdh!¹hjWZVEVg†hºeVgVegdWVghjZgiZ#
Hj¹WZaaVeajbVºaZkVaZhZgXdcigViVYdZcadhYZheVX]dhYZa
9jfjZYZDgaZ{ch#8db^ZcoVejWa^XVcYdVa\jcVhXg‹c^XVh
ZcaVegZchVnhZZ_ZgX^iVZcedZbVhfjZaaZ\VV]VXZgZY^iVg0
XdcdXZ XdbZY^VciZh! ZcigZ Zaadh Za ig{\^XdIVabV! fjZ aZ
Va^ZciV# 9ZhXjWgZ iVbW^‚c Za iZVigd YZ H]V`ZheZVgZ Xdc
bdi^kd YZ jcV \^gV YZ XdbZY^VciZh ^c\aZhZh edg ;gVcX^V#
;gZXjZciVZcidcXZhjc\gjed_‹kZcZhZhXg^idgZhVednVYdh
edg8]VgaZhCdY^Zg#:c&-'.!6#9jbVhXdcdXZjc^cbZchd
‚m^idXdc=Zcg^>>>ZihVXdjg=Zcg^>>>nhjXdgiZ!jcYgVbV
]^hi‹g^Xd! XgZVYd Zc aV 8db‚Y^Z";gVcV^hZ# AV e^ZoV aZ
kVaZ XdckZgi^ghZ Zc jcd YZ adh bVhXVgdcZh YZ egdV YZa
iZVigdgdb{ci^Xd0aZeZgb^iZ^\jVabZciZVYfj^g^gY^cZgdn
cdidg^ZYVY#
AjZ\d!b^ZcigVhh^\jZegdYjX^ZcYddWgVhiZVigVaZh!hZYZY^XV
V gZYVXiVg Xg‹c^XVh ]^hi‹g^XVh!
gZXjZgYdh YZ k^V_Z n cdkZaVh#
=dbWgZ YZ iZVigd Zc hj XdgVo‹c!
9jbVhbVciZcYg{ZchjhcdkZaVh
Za hZci^Yd YZ aV ZhXZcd\gV[†V n Za
\jhidedgaVh¹hdgegZhVhº#8daVWdgV
Xdc kVg^dh VjidgZh! ZheZX^VabZciZ
Xdc 6j\jhiZ BVfjZi! V fj^Zc
XdcdX^‹ Zc &-(-0 ZhiZ _dkZc
egd[Zhdg YZ ]^hidg^V aZ VnjYVg{ V
ZhXg^W^g hjh eg^bZgVh cdkZaVh# 6
eVgi^gYZjcZhWdodZaVWdgVYdedg
6j\jhiZ BVfjZi d gZVa^oVYd Zc
Xdbc! 9jbVh VedgiV hj iVaZcid
cdkZaZhXd n YZhVggdaaV Za gZaVid
VŠVY^ZcYdeZghdcV_ZhhZXjcYVg^dh
n Y^{ad\dh# :h Vh† Xdbd! V eVgi^g
YZ &-)%! XgZV b{h YZ dX]ZciV
cdkZaVhZcigZZaaVhaVig^ad\†VYZadh
BdhfjZiZgdh/AdhIgZhbdhfjZiZgdh
&-))!KZ^ciZVŠdhYZhej‚h&-)*!
:aK^oXdcYZYZ7gV\ZadccZ&-)-!:aX^XadYZaVGZ^cVBVg\di
&-),n:a8dcYZYZBdciZXg^hid&-)*#
Bjn ^ckdajXgVYd Zc hj h^\ad! 9jbVh Zh ^\jVabZciZ jc
\gVck^V_Zgd!hZZ_ZgX^iVZcaVeda†i^XV!XgZVjciZVigd!ZY^iV
eZg^‹Y^Xdh! ]VXZ Xdchigj^g jc XVhi^aad° 9Zh\gVX^VYVbZciZ
hj YZa^g^d YZ \gVcYZoV n hj egdY^\Va^YVY aZ ]VXZc XdcdXZg
hdcVYVh fj^ZWgVh n aZ dWa^\Vc V eZghZ\j^g ZhZ Y^cZgd fjZ
\VhiViVcegdcidad\VcV/¹6kZcijgVhVbdgdhVh!egdXZhdhn
k^V_ZhVa^bZciVcaVejWa^XVX^‹cYZhjhe^cidgZhXVhBZbdg^Vh
nYZhjh>begZh^dcZhYZk^V_Zº#
Bjg^‹ZcXVhVYZhj]^_d!6aZmVcYgZ9jbVh]^_d!VjidgYZAV
9VbVYZaVh8VbZa^Vh#
8QSHQVDPLHQWRHVSLULWXDOLVWD
:ceg^bZgaj\Vg!]ZbdhZmigV†YdYZhjhbZbdg^VhZaZbZcidh
gZaVi^kdhVhjhXdck^XX^dcZhZhe^g^ijVaZh0‚aVaa†YZiVaaVXdc
\gVcegZX^h^‹c!hjk^YV!hjhZcXjZcigdh!hjhgZ[aZm^dcZhZiX#
/(-2851$/63,5,7(1o$%5,/
)*
:cZaZmigVXidfjZh^\jZ!YViZhi^bdc^dYZaVbVc^[ZhiVX^‹cedhi"
bdgiZbYZhjeVYgZVaXjVaZhiVWVbjnVeZ\VYd/
¹°ZhidfjZhjXZYZZcaVcdX]ZnfjZkdnVgZaViVg!hZVdcdZ[ZXid
YZb^_dkZc^bV\^cVX^‹c!bZ]Vg†VXgZZgfjZhZ]VW†Vdak^YVYdZhiV
ViZcX^‹ce^VYdhV#EdgdigVeVgiZ!ndcdiZc†VdigV^YZVYZaVbjZgiZ
YZ aV fjZ nV ]Z gZ[Zg^Yd V egde‹h^id YZa \gVc eZggd cZ\gd n YZa
WVŠ^hiVYZhkVcZX^Yd0VYZb{h!bZ]jW^ZgVh^YdbjnY^[†X^aegZkZgaV
YZb^eVYgZ!Vfj^Zc]VW†Vk^hidbdciVgVXVWVaadigZhY†VhVciZh°
HZ bZ ]VW†V ^chiVaVYd ZcidcXZh Zc aV XVhV YZa eVYgZ YZ b^h Ydh
eg^bdh°6ZhdYZaVhdX]d!b^eg^bVBVg^VccZ[jZVWjhXVgbZ!bZ
VXdhi‹ZcaVeZfjZŠVXVbV[gZciZVaV\gVcYZ!nbZYdgb†XdcZhZ
WjZchjZŠdfjZ9^dhYVVadhc^Šdh!XdbdZagdX†dYZeg^bVkZgV#6
bZY^VcdX]Z![j^YZheZgiVYd!dbZ_dgY^X]d![j^bdhYZheZgiVYdh!b^
eg^bVnnd!edgjc\gVc\daeZYVYdhdWgZaVejZgiV#JcVaVbeVg^aaV
VgY†VhdWgZjcVbZh^iVYZcdX]Z0VagZheaVcYdgYZZhiVaVbeVg^aaV!
k^Vb^eg^bVaZkVciVghZYZhjXVbV!bjnVhjhiVYV!eZgdh^cYZX^g
cVYV#CVY^ZedY†VaaVbVgVZhiVejZgiV^ciZg^dg!ejZhaVhdigVhYdh
ejZgiVhZhiVWVcXZggVYVh#EZgd!edgZaXdcigVg^d!nd!fjZ]dnXVh^bZ
ZhigZbZoXdVaZhXg^W^gZhiVha†cZVhcdZmeZg^bZciVWVc^c\ciZbdg/
WV_‚YZb^XVbVnVkVcX‚]VX^VaVejZgiV#
¸ª6Y‹cYZkVh!6aZmVcYgZ4BZ\g^i‹b^eg^bV0ªVY‹cYZkVh4
¸AdkZhW^Zc!gZhedcY†igVcfj^aVbZciZ!kdnVVWg^gaZ V eVe{! fjZ
k^ZcZYZX^gcdhVY^‹h#
AV edWgZ X]^XV hVai‹ ZcidcXZh YZ hj XVbV bjn hdgegZcY^YV! bZ
hj_Zi‹XjVcYdedc†VaVbVcdZcaVXZggVYjgV!nbZVXdhi‹VaV[jZgoV
Zcb^XVbV#NdbZYZWVi†VZcigZhjhWgVodh!\g^iVcYdXdcidYVhb^h
[jZgoVh/
¸«6Y^‹h!eVe{«6Y^‹h!eVe{
6a\d eVgZX^Yd V jc ]{a^id bdgiZX^cd eVh‹ hdWgZ b^ gdhigd n bZ
XVab‹#
CddWhiVciZbZkdak†VYdgb^gXdcadhd_dhaaZcdhYZa{\g^bVhnaV
\Vg\VciVaaZcVYZhdaadodh#CdhYZheZgiVbdhVaY†Vh^\j^ZciZ#
«B^eVYgZ]VW†VbjZgid_jhidZcZabdbZcidZcfjZZhiZ\gVc\daeZ
fjZVXVWdYZbZcX^dcVg[jZYVYdZchjejZgiV:cidcXZhZhXjX]‚
ZhiVheVaVWgVh!h^chVWZgZmVXiVbZciZadfjZh^\c^[^XVWVc/
¸«B^edWgZc^Šd!ijeVe{!fjZiVcidiZfjZg†V!Zhi{bjZgid
ªFj‚ WdXV egdcjcX^‹ hdWgZ b† VfjZaaVh eVaVWgVh fjZ bZ ]VX†Vc
]j‚g[VcdVadhigZhVŠdhnbZY^d4BZhZg†V^bedh^WaZYZX^gad#ªEdg
fj^‚cbZ[jZVcjcX^VYVaVbVndgYZhY^X]VYZb^k^YV4Ad^\cdgd#
¸B^eVe{Zhi{bjZgid!gZea^fj‚#ªFj‚fj^ZgZYZX^gZhd4
¸:hdfj^ZgZYZX^gfjZcdadkZg{hb{h#
¸8‹bd!ªcdkZg‚Vb{heVe{4
¸Cd#
¸ªNedgfj‚cdadkZg‚b{h4
¸EdgfjZZaWjZc9^dhad]VgZXd\^Yd#
¸ªEVgVh^ZbegZ4
¸EVgVh^ZbegZ#
¸ªNY^XZhfjZcdadkZg‚b{h4
¸B{hcjcXV#
¸ªB{hcjcXV!cjcXV4
¸«B{hcjcXV
¸ªNY‹cYZk^kZZaWjZc9^dh4
¸:cZaX^Zad°º
DigdZcjcX^VYdYZ6aZmVcYgZ9jbVhcdh^c[dgbV^\jVabZciZhdWgZ
hj[^adhd[†VYZk^YV/
¹°6idYVhZhiVh!nd]ZiZc^Ydjc\gVcgZheZidedgidYVhaVhXdhVh
hVciVh!jcV\gVc[ZZcaVEgdk^YZcX^V!jc\gVcVbdgV9^dh#CjcXV
]Z iZc^Yd! Zc Za igVchXjghd YZ jcV k^YV nV WVhiVciZ aVg\V! Zc aVh
/(-2851$/63,5,7(1o$%5,/
$XJXVWH0DTXHW
&KDUOHV1RGLHU
9LFWRU+XJR
)+
]dgVh b{h YdadgdhVh YZ ZhiV k^YV! c^ jc bdbZcid YZ YjYV!
c^jc^chiVciZYZYZhZheZgVX^‹c0cdbZVigZkZg†VVYZX^gfjZ
ZhidnhZ\jgdYZaV^cbdgiVa^YVYYZb^VabV!eZgdY^g‚fjZaV
ZheZgd#HdaVbZciZXgZdfjZaVbjZgiZZhZadak^YdYZaeVhVYd
h^chZgaVgZcjcX^VVaedgkZc^g#H^hZad\gVgVYVgbZbdg^VVaVh
VabVh!hZ]VWg†VgZhjZaidZa\gVcb^hiZg^dXjnVeVaVWgV\jVgYV
9^dh/ZcidcXZhaVhVabVhgZXdgYVg†Vc!naV^cbdgiVa^YVYhZg†V
gZkZaVYV°º
DigVgZ[aZm^‹cYZ9jbVhhdWgZZaiZbV/
¹°:hiV^ciZgkZcX^‹cYZhZgZh^cbViZg^VaZhnhjeZg^dgZhZcZa
YZhi^cd]jbVcdiZc†VjcaVYd[Vci{hi^XdfjZV\gVYVWVVb^
^bV\^cVX^‹c!n[jZfj^o{hZhiVYZZhiVcdX]ZaVfjZhZbWg‹Zc
b^Zhe†g^ijZa\ZgbZcYZ9dc?jVcYZBVgVcV!fjZZXadh^dc‹
h‹addcXZVŠdhYZhej‚h°º
:cdigdeVhV_Z!YVXjZciVYZjc^ciZgXVbW^dYZ^YZVhXdcjc
ZheZXiVYdg! Vh^hiZciZ Xdbd ‚a V jcV dWgV iZVigVa! BVak^cV0
hj ^ciZgadXjidg aZ XVjh‹ jcV [jZgiZ ^begZh^‹c Zc XjVcid
V hj XdcXZeX^‹c YZ ad¹hdWgZcVijgVaº ]Z Vfj† aVh eVaVWgVh
^ciZgXVbW^VYVhZcigZ9jbVhnVfjZaZheZXiVYdg#H^cZbWVg\d!
Vfj† 9jbVh hZ bjZhigV YjW^iVi^kd VciZ aVh XZgiZoVh YZ hj
^ciZgadXjidg/
¹9jbVh/ ª8ZchjgV jhiZY ZcidcXZh aV ^ciZgkZcX^‹c YZ hZgZh
hdWgZcVijgVaZhZcZaYgVbV4
¸Cd!edgZaXdcigVg^d!bZZcXVciV#IdYdhadh\gVcYZhbVZhigdh
]VcZmigV†YdYZZaad^ciZchdhZ[ZXidh/H]V`ZheZVgZ!Zc=VbaZi!
ZcBVXWZi]!nZc?ja^d8‚hVg0Bda^ƒgZ!Zc:a;Zhi†cYZE^ZggZ!
fjZ]jW^ZgVYZW^YdaaVbVghZ:a8dck^YVYdYZE^ZYgV!eVgVfjZ
hji†ijadijk^ZgVh^\c^[^XVYd0KdaiV^gZ!ZcH‚b^gVb^h!0<dZi]Z!
Zc;Vjhi#Cd!edgZaXdcigVg^d!bZZcXVciVadhdWgZcVijgVa!nV
fjZadXgZd#
¸«8‹bdª8gZZjhiZYZcadhdWgZcVijgVa4
¸H^cYjYV#
¸ª:caVk^YVXdbc4
¸EdghjejZhid#:cidYdbdbZcidcdhXdYZVbdhXdchZgZh
fjZcdhhdcYZhXdcdX^YdhedgfjZcdhhdc^ck^h^WaZh/ZaV^gZ!
Za[jZ\dnaVi^ZggVZhi{c]VW^iVYdh#H^a[dh!\cdbdh!dcY^cVh!
YjZcYZh! YjZcYZX^aadh! {c\ZaZh n YZbdc^dh! [adiVc! igZeVc!
\^gVcnhVaiVcVagZYZYdgYZcdhdigdh#ªFj‚hdcZhVhZhigZaaVh
[j\VXZhZcaVcdX]Z¸bZiZdgdhfjZadhVhig‹cdbdhigViVc
ZckVcdYZZmea^XVgcdh!nYZadhfjZcdejZYZcYZhXjWg^gc^
aVXVjhVc^Za[^c¸h^cd{c\ZaZhfjZkVcYZjcbjcYdVdigd
aaZkVcYdaVh‹gYZcZhYZ9^dh4JcY†V!kZgZbdhidYdZhd#
¸ªKZgZbdh!Y^XZjhiZY4
¸8aVgdfjZh†!kZgZbdh#«EjZhXaVgdªEdgfj‚fj^ZgZjhiZY
fjZcdkZVbdhZhVhbVgVk^aaVh4
¸9^XZjhiZY¹cdhº!ªZhfjZaVhkZgZbdheZghdcVabZciZ4
¸«D]CdY^\dZhdegZX^hVbZciZ°CdndfjZnVhdnk^Z_d0iVa
kZojhiZYfjZidYVk†VZh_dkZc0eZgd!XdchZ\jg^YVY!cjZhigdh
YZhXZcY^ZciZh#
¸ªN X‹bd Y^VWadh kZg{c cjZhigdh YZhXZcY^ZciZh Va\d fjZ
cdhdigdhcdkZbdh4
¸EjZhXdbdcdhdigdhkZbdhXdhVhfjZcjZhigdhVciZeVhVYdh
cd]Vck^hid#
¸ªFj‚kZbdhcdhdigdhfjZZaadhcd]Vck^hid4
¸«KVnV «:a kVedg! adh [jh^aZh V e^hi‹c! Za VZgdhiVid! aV
ZaZXig^X^YVY!aV^begZciV!aVe‹akdgVYZXVŠ‹cª8gZZjhiZYfjZ
hZVeVgVYZiZcZghZVb^iVYXVb^cdfjZZabjcYdbVgX]V4
ª8gZZjhiZYfjZYZhej‚hYZ]VWZgXdcfj^hiVYdhjXZh^kVbZciZ
aVi^ZggV!ZaV\jVnZa[jZ\d!Za]dbWgZcdhZ]Vg{YjZŠdYZa
V^gZ!edgZ_Zbead4HZg†VVWhjgYdcdiZcZgZhiVXdck^XX^‹c#ª:h
fjZjhiZYedgXVhjVa^YVYadYjYV!_dkZc4«IVcideZdg!iVcid
eZdg!iVcideZdg
9jbVhXdcXajnZ/
¸B^[Z!hZŠdg!Xdc[^ZhdjcVXdhV!ZhfjZndcdYjYdc^XgZd#
CjcXVb^Zhe†g^ijhZ]VYZiZc^YdZcZhiVXaVhZYZiZbVh!n
ZhiVWV Zfj^kdXVYd! ad kZd! edgfjZ ejZYZc iZcZg Za ^ciZg‚h
fjZ bZ h^Zcid a^hid V idbVg! h^ ijk^ZgV aV Y^X]V YZ X]VgaVg
bjX]di^ZbedXdcjhiZY#ª9ZbdYdfjZjhiZYXgZZ!hZŠdg!
fjZedXdVedXdad\gVgZbdhXdcdXZgidYdhadhhZXgZidhYZ
aVcVijgVaZoV4
¸:hidnXdckZcX^YdYZZaad#º
HZejZYZZkdXVg^\jVabZciZidYVaV^c[ajZcX^VYZK^Xidg=j\d
Vfj^Zc6aZmVcYgZ9jbVhXdcdX^‹bjnW^ZcnXdcfj^Zc!Xdc
idYVhZ\jg^YVY!^ciZgXVbW^‹cjbZgdhVh^YZVhhdWgZaV[^adhd[†V
Zhe†g^iV#:cZ[ZXid!YjgVciZhjZm^a^dZc?ZghZn!K^Xidg=j\d!hZ
^ciZgZh‹edgadh[Zc‹bZcdhZhe†g^iVhZheZX^VabZciZadhfjZ
h^\j^ZgdcVaVbjZgiZVXX^YZciVaYZhj]^_VA‚dedaY^cZ#Hj]^_d
8]VgaZh=j\dgZhjai‹hZgZab‚Y^jb^ciZgbZY^Vg^d!gZX^W^ZcYd
cjbZgdhVhXdbjc^XVX^dcZhh^\c^[^XVi^kVh#
:c ?dhZe] 7VahVbd! b‚bd^gZh Y¼jc b‚YZX^c ?dhZe]
7VahVbd!bZbdg^VhYZjcb‚Y^Xd!6aZmVcYgZ9jbVhZkdXV
ZabV\cZi^hbd]VX^ZcYdgZ[ZgZcX^VVBZhbZg&,()"&-&*!
b‚Y^Xdk^Zc‚h!VjidgYZjcViZh^hfjZZmea^XVfjZidYdXjZged
b^cZgVa!kZ\ZiVadVc^bVYdZhi{WVŠVYdedgjc¹[aj^Ydºn
fjZaVgZeVgi^X^‹cVgbdc^dhVYZZhZ[aj^YdZh\VgVciZYZaV
hVajY[†h^XVnbZciVa#BZhbZgbV\cZi^oVWVVhjhVb^\dh!hjh
Ydb‚hi^XdhnhjhXVbeZh^cdhZchjegde^ZYVYYZ7joVcXn#Jc
Y†VbV\cZi^o‹VjcdYZhjheVhidgZh!K^XidgGVXZ!fjZXVn‹Zc
ZhiVYdYZhjZŠdegd[jcYdeZgdeZgbVcZX^‹XVeVoYZ]VWaVg
aX^YVbZciZ#9ZhXg^W^‹Za^ciZg^dgYZhjXjZged!Y^V\cdhi^X‹
hj Zc[ZgbZYVY n egZhXg^W^‹ hjh bZY^XVbZcidh# :a BVgfj‚h
VcjcX^‹hjYZhXjWg^b^ZcidZcbVndYZ&,-)WV_dZacdbWgZ
YZ¹HjZŠdbV\c‚i^XddegdkdXVYdº#KZghja^WgdBZbdg^Vh
eVgVhZgk^gVaV]^hidg^VnVaZhiVWaZX^b^ZcidYZabV\cZi^hbd
Vc^bVa·&,-)#
:c aV cdkZaV YZ 9jbVh! ?dhZe] 7VahVbd! ZhiZ b‚Y^Xd
ZmeZg^bZciV hjh [VXjaiVYZh _jcid V jcV k^YZciZ!6cYgZV! V
fj^Zc aZ VYb^c^higV eVhZh bV\c‚i^Xdh# 7V_d aV XdcYjXX^‹c
YZ 7VahVbd! ZhiV _dkZc hZ ZcXjZcigV ^cbZghV Zc jc hjZŠd
bV\c‚i^XdnYZhXg^WZadhaj\VgZhneZghdcV_ZhfjZ‚aigViVYZ
]VXZgaZ¹kZgº#:migVXidYZaXVe†ijad>M¹AVk^YZciZº/
¹7VahVbdhZY^g^\ZV6cYgZVaVk^YZciZ/
¸IZ]ZbVcYVYdVYdgb^g!Y^XZ0ªYjZgbZh4
6cYgZVaVco‹jchjhe^gd!eZgdcdgZhedcY^‹#7VahVbdhZVXZgX‹
VaVX]^XVnaVXVg\‹YZjcVbVndgXVci^YVYYZ[aj^Yd#
¸Fj^ZgdfjZ]VWaZh!Y^XZ#
AVX]^XVhZZhigZbZXZº#
:c digV cdkZaV! AV 8dbiZhhZ YZ 8]Vgcn! XVe†ijad AMMM>/
¹9dWaZk^hiVº!9jbVhZkdXVVaXaVg^k^YZciZ8V\a^dhigdXjnVh
egZY^XX^dcZhgZhjaiVcZmVXiVh#AV]^hidg^VhZh^iVZcaV‚edXV
/(-2851$/63,5,7(1o$%5,/
),
YZaVgZkdajX^‹c#AVgZ^cVBVg^Z"6cid^cZiiZ[^\jgV^\jVabZciZZc
digdhXVe†ijadhn8V\a^dhigdZhegZhZciVYdXdbdhjVY^k^cd#
HZZmegZhVZcZhidhi‚gb^cdh/
¹¸ªN Y‹cYZ bZ ]Z Zfj^kdXVYd ]VhiV V]dgV! <^aWZgi4 Y^XZ
8V\a^dhigd#ª;jZXjVcYdaZegZY^_ZaVbjZgiZYZ;VkgVh!fjZh^c
ZbWVg\d!VabdbZcidYZX^h^kd!]^XZidYdadfjZejYZeVgV
^beZY^g4 ª;jZ XjVcYd aZ Vk^h‚ fjZ Za gZn b^hbd ^cig^\VWV
XdcigVB^gVWZVj!nfjZB^gVWZVjcdhZg†VcdbWgVYdb^c^higd4
ª;jZXjVcYdaZY^_ZfjZGdWZhe^ZggZaZkVciVg†VZaXVYVahdYZ
8]VgaZh>!n7dcVeVgiZZaigdcdYZ8VgadbV\cd4:cXjVcidV
Zhd! cd ejZYZ VXjhVgbZ YZ Zggdg! ejZh adh i^Zbedh idYVk†V
cdhdcXjbea^Ydhn!YZZhiVhXdhVh!jcVheZgiZcZXZcV[^cVaZh
YZZhiZh^\ad!naVhdigVhVXdb^ZcodhYZah^\adeg‹m^bd#6]dgV
W^Zc!]dn!b^XVgd<^aWZgi!jhiZYhVWZbZ_dgfjZcVY^ZfjZY^\d
aVkZgYVYY^X^‚cYdaZfjZZagZnYZWZ]j^gYjgVciZaVcdX]ZYZ
bVŠVcV!ejZhjhiZYZhjcdYZadhV\ZciZhYZZhiV[j\V°º
:cAZK^XdbiZYZ7gV\ZadccZ!Vh^hi^bdh^\jVabZciZVagZaVid
YZjceVYgZ!6i]dh!fjZi^ZcZjcVk^h^‹cYZhj]^_dGVdja!fjZ
eVgi^‹eVgVajX]VgZcÍ[g^XVnbjg^‹ZcXdbWViZ#waadWjhXV
ZcigZadhbjZgidhZcZaXVbedYZWViVaaVnVh^hiZVhjhVa^YV
]VX^VZab{hVaa{/
¹°=VW†VaaZ\VYdViVaejcidYZ^ajh^‹c!fjZVfjZaaVk^h^‹cZgV
eVgV‚ajck^V_ZgZVa]ZX]dedgZaeVYgZVÍ[g^XVeVgVdWiZcZg
ZchZŠVcoVhb{hZmVXiVhhdWgZZa]^_d#º
¹° :cidcXZh! b^ZcigVh hj b^gVYV ZggVWV edg aV aaVcjgV!
kdak^‚cYdhZ]VX^VidYdhaVYdh!k^dVeVgZXZgjcV[dgbVWaVcXV
YZig{h YZ adh b^gidh gZh^cdhdh#6fjZaaV [^\jgV ZhiVWV kZhi^YV
XdcjcigV_ZYZd[^X^Va/iZc†VZcaVbVcdjcVZheVYVfjZWgVYV0
VkVco‹aZciVbZciZ]VX^V6i]dhfj^Zc!aZkVci{cYdhZYZ\daeZn
[^_VcYdhjb^gVYVhdWgZZaaV!cd]VWaVWV!cdhZbdk†V!nfjZg†V
VWg^g hjh WgVodh! edgfjZ Zc ZhiZ d[^X^Va h^aZcX^dhd n e{a^Yd!
VXVWVWVYZgZXdcdXZgVGVdja#
:aXdcYZ^ciZci‹jc\g^id!fjZfjZY‹V]d\VYdZchj\Vg\VciV#
GVdja! Xdc jc \Zhid! aZ ^cY^XVWV XVaaVg XdadXVcYd jc YZYd
hdWgZhjWdXVngZigdXZY^ZcYdedXdVedXd!h^cfjZ6i]dhaZ
k^ZgVbdkZghjhe^ZgcVh#:aXdcYZ!b{he{a^YdfjZGVdja!b{h
iZbWadgdhd!h^\j^‹Vhj]^_dVigVkZhVcYdeZcdhVbZciZWgZoVaZh
nbVidggVaZh!e^ZYgVhn[dhdh#GVdjacdeVgZX†VidXVgaVi^ZggV!
nc^c\cdWhi{XjadigVWVWVaVa^\ZgZoVYZhjbVgX]V#:aXdcYZ!
Vfj^Zc[Vi^\VWVcadhVXX^YZciZhYZaiZggZcd!egdcidhZYZijkd
V\diVYd# GVdja h^ZbegZ aZ ]VX†V hZŠVh YZ fjZ aZ h^\j^ZgV# :a
i^ZgcdeVYgZ!Vfj^ZcZaVbdgYZkdak†VaVh[jZgoVh!ZchVn‹jc
ai^bdbdk^b^ZcidnZhXVa‹aVbdciVŠVYZig{hYZa_dkZc!fjZ
aZVigV†VXdchj\Zhidnhjhdcg^hV#
Edg [^c! idX‹ aV XgZhiV YZ aV Xda^cV! n k^d Y^Wj_VghZ Zc cZ\gd!
hdWgZZa]dg^odciZWaVcfjZVYdedgaVajcV!aVh[dgbVhV‚gZVhn
ed‚i^XVhYZGVdja#6i]dhZmiZcY^‹aVbVcdeVgVVXZgXVghZVhj
]^_dVbVYd!hdWgZaVbZhZiV!n‚hiZiVbW^‚caZiZcY^‹aVhjnV0
eZgdhW^iVbZciZ!Xdbdh^Za_dkZc]jW^ZgVh^YdVggVhigVYdVhj
eZhVg!gZigdXZY^ZcYdh^ZbegZ!YZ_‹aVi^ZggV!n6i]dhk^dWg^aaVg
ZaX^ZadZcigZadhe^ZhYZhj]^_dnZahjZadYZaVXda^cV#GVdja
hZ ZaZkVWV ^chZch^WaZbZciZ Zc Za kVX†d! h^ZbegZ hdcg^ZciZ!
h^ZbegZaaVbVcYdXdcZa\Zhid0hZVaZ_VWV]VX^VZaX^Zad#6i]dh
hdai‹jc\g^idYZViZbdg^oVYViZgcjgV0b^g‹]VX^VVWV_d#HZkZ†V
jcXVbedYZhigj^Ydn!Xdbd{idbdh^cb‹k^aZh!idYdhVfjZaadh
WaVcXdhXVY{kZgZhYZaZ_‚gX^idgZVa#NajZ\d!aZkVciVcYdaVXVWZoV!
k^dh^ZbegZ!h^ZbegZ!Vhj]^_dfjZaZ^ck^iVWVVhjW^gXdc‚aº#
/(-2851$/63,5,7(1o$%5,/
(&26
/26(6&5,725(6,163,5$'26325(/0z6$//z
SRU
(00$18(//(3ƒ&+(85
$'80$67(67,021,2
AVHZŠdgVE#iZc†VjcV
]^_V#:hiV]^_V!aaZ\VYVYZ
egdk^cX^VeVgVXj^YVgV
hj bVYgZ! ]VW†V h^Yd
ejZhiV Zc ZhiVYd
YZ
hdcVbWja^hbd
edg Za YdXidg 8# n
gZXdcdX^YV edg ‚a
XdbdYZjcVeZg[ZXiV
ajX^YZo# ;jZ Ydgb^YV
Xdc hjZŠd bV\c‚i^Xd
nXdchjaiVYVhdWgZZaZhiVYdYZhjbVYgZ#6aeg^bZg
Zh[jZgodfjZ]^odeVgVkZg!hj[^\jgVhZYZhXdbejhd!
naVha{\g^bVhaZk^c^ZgdcVadhd_dh#6cjcX^‹fjZjcV
bjZgiZ VeVX^WaZ! eZgd ^cZk^iVWaZ! aaZ\Vg†V V hj bVYgZ
Za Y†V h^\j^ZciZ edg aV bVŠVcV# >ciZggd\VYV hdWgZ Za
VheZXidfjZegZhZciVWVZa^ciZg^dgYZaeZX]d!YZXaVg‹
fjZZaejab‹cYZaVeVgiZYZgZX]VnVcdk^k†V!fjZZhiVWV
kVX†dnZchjejgVX^‹c]VX^VaVeVgiZYdghVa^c[Zg^dg!n
hjbZg\^YdZcjcYZggVbZhZgdhd0fjZZaejab‹cYZa
XdhiVYd ^ofj^ZgYd ZhiVWV hVcd n! hdad! Va^bZciVWV aV
k^YV#:cXjVcidVaVhk†hXZgVhVWYdb^cVaZh!Za]†\VYd!
hZ\c ZaaV! ZhiVWV WaVcXjoXd n Vggj\VYd0 eZgd adh
^ciZhi^cdhZhiVWVchVcdh#
:hiVh YZXaVgVX^dcZh [jZgdc ]ZX]Vh Zc egZhZcX^V YZ
iZhi^\dh#6aY†Vh^\j^ZciZ!VaV]dgVY^X]V!aVhZŠdgVE#!
bjg^‹#HZ]^odaVVjideh^VZcegZhZcX^VYZXdb^hVg^dh
YZaV6XVYZb^V!nZaZhiVYdYZaXVY{kZghZZcXdcig‹
ZmVXiVbZciZ Xdc[dgbZ V aV YZhXg^eX^‹c ]ZX]V edg
aV hdc{bWjaV# :h ad fjZ gZedgiVgdc adh eZg^‹Y^Xdh!
Zh ad fjZ Xdch^\c‹ Za egdXZhd kZgWVa! Zh ad fjZ bZ
Xdci‹ n Xdc[^gb‹ Za egde^d ?jaZh 8adfjZi! jc Y†V
fjZ XdckZgh{WVbdh ¸VciZh YZ fjZ hZ ^ckZciVgV
Za Xadgd[dgbd¸ hdWgZ Zhdh \gVcYZh b^hiZg^dh YZ aV
cVijgVaZoVYdcYZhZe^ZgYZZaZhe†g^ij]jbVcd#
B{h iVgYZ! XjVcYd egZeVgVWV b^ a^Wgd YZ ?dhZe]
7VahVbd! edg iZcZg ^ciZg‚h Zc egd[jcY^oVg ZhiV
XjZhi^‹cYZWVi^YVYZhYZ]VXZiVcidi^ZbedhdWgZZa
edYZgdaV^bediZcX^VYZabV\cZi^hbd!gZhdak†]VXZg
Va\jcdh ZmeZg^bZcidh eZghdcVaZh! edg cd [^VgbZ YZ
adh fjZ ejY^ZgVc ]VXZg YZaVciZ YZ b† ZmigVŠdh fjZ
i^ZcZc ^ciZg‚h Zc VXgZY^iVg Za bV\cZi^hbd# BZ ]^XZ
ejZh bV\cZi^oVYdg# =Z Vfj† ad fjZ dWhZgk‚/ ZhiVWV
YdiVYdYZjc\gVcedYZgbV\c‚i^Xdn\ZcZgVabZciZ
ZhZedYZg]VW†V]ZX]degZhVhdWgZadhYdhiZgX^dhYZ
aVheZghdcVhVaVhfjZndhdbZi†V#
)'266,(5
/26(6&5,725(6,163,5$'26325(/0z6$//z
SRU
-($13,(55(/$77$1=,2
&+$5/(6',&.(16
<(/0,67(5,2'((':,1'522'
7UHVD¥RVGHVSXžVGHVXOOHJDGDDOP–VDOO–&KDUOHV'LFNHQVWHUPLQ§VXREUDPDQLIHVW–QGRVH
D WUDYžV GH XQ PžGLXP HQ VHVLRQHV PHGL®PQLFDV 0X\ SURQWR OD SUHQVD GLIXQGLU¢D HVH
PLVWHULRVR
E
gdkZc^ZciZ YZ jcV [Vb^a^V
bdYZhiV! 8]VgaZh 9^X`Zch
hj[g^‹ bjX]d edg hj h^ijV"
X^‹c hdX^Va hjh eVYgZh ZhiVWVc
XjW^ZgidhYZYZjYVh#6aVhVa^YVYZ
aVZhXjZaV!Zcig‹ZcjcYZheVX]d
_jg†Y^XdZ!^bejahVYdedgjcV\gVc
Xjg^dh^YVY ^ciZaZXijVa! [gZXjZc"
iVWV Xdc Vh^Yj^YVY aVh hVaVh YZ
aZXijgV# :beaZVYd Xdbd ZhiZ"
c‹\gV[d Zc jcV gZk^hiV! g{e^YV"
bZciZhZ]^odcdiVg#:c&-(,!Xdc
Adh eVeZaZh e‹hijbdh YZa 8ajW
E^X`l^X`!dWgVbVZhigVYZa]jbdg
Wg^i{c^Xd! Za ‚m^id [jZ ^cbZY^Vid#
9ZhYZ ZcidcXZh! XdbeVgi^‹ hj
k^YV ZcigZ aV a^iZgVijgV n adh
k^V_Zh#Bjg^‹!g^XdnX‚aZWgZ!Vadh
X^cXjZciV n dX]d VŠdh# :hXg^idg
XdbegdbZi^Yd! 9^X`Zch hjed
YZcjcX^Vg n XdcYZcVg Zc hjh
iZmidh!XdcbjX]d]jbdg^hbdn
jc^ccZ\VWaZiVaZcidYZcVggVYdg!
aVb^hZg^VnaVZmeadiVX^‹c^cYjhig^Va#HjheZghdcV_ZhXVgVX"
iZg†hi^Xdh Z ^cdak^YVWaZh ]Vc ]ZX]d YZ ‚a jc ZhXg^idg bjn
edejaVg!jcV[^\jgVXZcigVaYZaVa^iZgVijgVYZah^\adM>M#
8jVcYd 8]VgaZh 9^X`Zch bjg^‹ hW^iVbZciZ! Zc _jc^d YZ
&-,%!]VW†VZhXg^idhZ^hYZaVhYdXZZcigZ\VhbZchjVaZhZc
aVhfjZiZc†V^ciZcX^‹cYZejWa^XVgZc[daaZi†c:ab^hiZg^dYZ
:Yl^c 9gddY# :a bjcYd a^iZgVg^d XaVh^[^X‹ ZhiV dWgV Xdbd
^cXdcXajhV#
H^c ZbWVg\d! Zc &-,(! Zc adh :hiVYdh Jc^Ydh! hZ ]VWa‹
cjZkVbZciZ YZ ‚a \gVX^Vh V jc _dkZc fjZ V[^gbVWV hZg
hj ^ciZgbZY^Vg^d bZY^bc^Xd# IgZh VŠdh YZhej‚h YZ hj
aaZ\VYVVab{hVaa{!8]VgaZh9^X`Zch
iZgb^c‹hjdWgVbVc^[Zhi{cYdhZ!V
igVk‚h YZ jc b‚Y^jb Zc hZh^dcZh
bZY^bc^XVh# Bjn egdcid aV
egZchV Y^[jcY^g†V ZhZ b^hiZg^dhd
XVhdYZhZcXVYZcVcYdZaZhijedgZc
ZabjcYda^iZgVg^dnX^Zci†[^Xd#
8QD¤RDQWHV
AV ]^hidg^V Xdb^ZcoV Zc 7gViiaZ"
Wdgdj\]! Zc KZgbdci! Zc dXijWgZ
YZ &-,'! Vaa† YdcYZ k^kZ jc _dkZc!
?VbZh!cVX^YdZc7dhidc#I^ZcZ&)
VŠdh!nYZhYZadhigZXZ!Zhi{Xdbd
VegZcY^o Xdc jc bZX{c^Xd YdcYZ
aVWdgVY^Zo]dgVhedgY†V#JcViVgYZ
YZdidŠd!adhVb^\dhad^ck^iVcVjcV
hZh^‹c YZ Zhe^g^i^hbd# FjZY‹ bjn
^begZh^dcVYd edg VfjZaaV eg^bZgV
ZmeZg^ZcX^V0 Zc Z[ZXid! hZ YZ_Vgdc
d†g\daeZh!hZZaZk‹jcVbZhVnhZ
kdaX‹ eVgV YZiZcZghZ [^cVabZciZ
hdWgZ hjh gdY^aaVh# H^c ZbWVg\d! ‚a
cdVXZeiVZadg^\ZcYZadh[Zc‹bZcdh#9jgVciZaVhZ\jcYV
hZh^‹c! hZ VXZaZgVg{ Za g^ibd YZ adh ZkZcidh# HW^iVbZciZ!
?VbZhXVZZcigVcXZ!hZVedYZgVYZjca{e^onXdb^ZcoVV
ZhXg^W^g#:abZchV_ZZh[^gbVYdXdcZacdbWgZYZjc]^_dYZ
jcdYZadheVgi^X^eVciZh!XjnVZm^hiZcX^V?VbZhc^h^fj^ZgV
hdheZX]VWV#AVhhZh^dcZhkVcVbjai^ea^XVghZVadaVg\dYZa
bZhYZdXijWgZ!njcViVgYZ!Zh8]VgaZh9^X`Zchfj^ZchZ
bVc^[^ZhiV# whiZ e^YZ dg\Vc^oVg jcV hZh^‹c eVgV Za &* YZ
cdk^ZbWgZ#AaZ\VYdZaY†V!Za_dkZchZV†haVZchjXjVgidZc
idiVa dhXjg^YVY# 9Zhej‚h YZ Va\jcdh ^chiVciZh YZ gZXd\^"
b^Zcid! idbV jc a{e^o n Xdb^ZcoV V ZhXg^W^g Zc jcV ]d_V
WaVcXV#IZgb^cVYVaVhZh^‹c!?VbZhaZZZabZchV_ZgZX^W^Yd
/(-2851$/63,5,7(1o$%5,/
).
n XdbegjZWV fjZ Zhi{ [^gbVYd edg 8]VgaZh 9^X`Zch# whiZ
YZhZV iZgb^cVg hj dWgV ^cXdcXajhV edg hj ^ciZgbZY^VX^‹c
bZY^bc^XV#E^YZ^\jVabZciZVa_dkZcfjZ]V\VaVeg^bZgV
hZh^‹cZcaVCdX]ZWjZcV!jcY†VeVgi^XjaVgbZciZVegZX^VYd
edg Za X‚aZWgZ cdkZa^hiV# AZ gjZ\V fjZ aZ YZY^fjZ idYd hj
i^Zbeda^WgZejZhadcZXZh^iV#
9Zhej‚h YZ bjX]Vh gZ[aZm^dcZh! n XdckZcX^Yd YZ aV
Zm^hiZcX^VYZadhZhe†g^ijh!?VbZhVXZeiV#6h†!ZcigZZa')YZ
Y^X^ZbWgZYZ&-,'n_ja^dYZ&-,(!gZX^W^g{b^aYdhX^ZciVh
]d_VhbVcjhXg^iVhedgZhXg^ijgVVjidb{i^XV#H^cZbWVg\d!Zc
hjWgZkZZhXdaVg^YVY!‚acd]VW†VbdhigVYdc^c\ciVaZcid
eVgi^XjaVgedgaVa^iZgVijgV#6aXdb^Zcod!cdgZX^W†VVaZhe†g^ij
8]VgaZh9^X`Zchb{hfjZigZhkZXZhedghZbVcVnXdchZ\j†V
igZhdXjVigde{\^cVhb{m^bd#AjZ\d!g{e^YVbZciZ!Zag^ibd
hZVXZaZg‹naVhhZh^dcZhhZYZhVggdaaVWVcYdhkZXZhVaY†V#
8VYV kZo! aV dWgV hZ Zcg^fjZX†V Xdc Y^Zo! YdXZ n V kZXZh
]VhiVkZ^ciZe{\^cVh#
AVhhZh^dcZhhZYZhVggdaaVWVch^ZbegZZcaVb^hbV[dgbV#6a
_dkZcaZXdhiVWVigVWV_dgZaV_VghZ!egZhVYZjchZci^b^Zcid
YZiZbdgVciZaV^YZVYZZcigVgZcXdciVXidXdcZabjcYd
YZadhbjZgidh#:cidcXZhZa_dkZcZheZgVWVVa\jcdhb^cjidh!
ajZ\d eZgY†V Za XdcdX^b^Zcid! n ZgV Vh† Xdbd gZX^W†V aVh
eVaVWgVhYZ8]VgaZh9^X`Zch#AVhhZh^dcZhYjgVWVcYZigZ^ciV
VcdkZciVb^cjidhn!VaYZheZgiVg!‚ah‹adiZc†VjcgZXjZgYd/
aV^bV\ZcYZaVjidgYZDa^kZgIl^hi!hZciVYdVhjaVYd!Xdc
aVXVWZoVZcigZhjhbVcdhnZceaZcVgZ[aZm^‹c#8VYVkZo!aV
hZh^‹ciZgb^cVWVXjVcYd?VbZhhZci†VjcVbVcdeZhVYVn
[g†VedhVghZhdWgZhj]dbWgd#AVhdgegZhVnZab^ZYdad]VX†Vc
hVa^gYZhjVijgY^b^Zcid#:cZ[ZXid!8]VgaZh9^X`Zchcd]VX†V
h^cdZck^VgedgiZaZeVi†Vhj^bV\ZceVgVegdYjX^gZhZ\Zhid#
EVgVXdcXaj^gZhiZWgZkZgZXjZgYd]^hi‹g^Xd!VŠVY^gZbdhfjZ
Za YZhVggdaad bZY^bc^Xd ZmeZg^bZciVYd edg Za _dkZc aZ
eZgb^i^‹VYfj^g^gjcVhZgZc^YVYVciZh^cZm^hiZciZ#
9ZiZc\{bdcdhV]dgVZcaVgZVXX^‹cYZabjcYda^iZgVg^d#
/DRSLQL¦QGHORVHVSHFLDOLVWDV
6abdbZcidYZadh]ZX]dh!jceZg^‹Y^Xd!I]ZHeg^c\[^ZaY9V^an
Jc^dc!Zck^‹VjcdYZhjheZg^dY^hiVhV7gViiaZWdgdj\]eVgV
]VXZgVaa†jcVXdbegdWVX^‹c#IZgb^cVYVaV^ckZhi^\VX^‹c!Za
eZg^‹Y^Xd ejWa^X‹ V dX]d XdajbcVh adh gZhjaiVYdh YZ hjh
^ckZhi^\VX^dcZh#8^iVgZbdhh‹adVa\jcdh#
:a gZaVid Xdb^ZcoV Zc Za b^hbd h^i^d YdcYZ hZ ]VW†V
^ciZggjbe^YdVaVbjZgiZYZaVjidgnZcjcZhi^ada^iZgVg^d
^Y‚ci^Xd#6eVgZXZc Va\jcdh eZghdcV_Zh cjZkdh! Xdbd hda†V
]VXZg8]VgaZh9^X`ZchXjVcYdZhXg^W†VjcVcdkZaVh^ZbegZ
^cigdYjX†V cjZkdh eZghdcV_Zh Va [^cVa YZ hjh XgZVX^dcZh#
6YZb{h! ZheZX^Va^hiVh Zc a^iZgVijgV XdbegdWVgdc ]ZX]dh
hdgegZcYZciZh#:cZ[ZXid!aVheVaVWgVhZhi{cZhXg^iVhZchj
dgid\gV[†V Xdbd Zc >c\aViZggV n cd Xdbd Zc adh :hiVYdh
Jc^Ydh#EdgZ_Zbead!aVeVaVWgVXdVahXVgW‹cZhi{ZhXg^iV
Xdbd hZ VXdhijbWgV Zc <gVc 7gZiVŠV! n cd Xdbd Zc adh
JH6# Adh ZheZX^Va^hiVh YZhXjWg^Zgdc ^\jVabZciZ \^gdh YZ
[gVhZhji^a^oVYdhZcZaeV†hYZaVgdhVncdZcadh:hiVYdh
Jc^Ydh#Adhaj\VgZhnaVhXVaaZhhdcYZhXg^idhYZbVcZgV^YZVa
n bjZhigVc jc eZg[ZXid XdcdX^b^Zcid YZ aV \Zd\gV[†V YZ
AdcYgZh#;^cVabZciZ!aVZhXg^ijgVVXde^VYVcdXdggZhedcYZV
aVYZ?VbZhh^cdVaVYZacdkZa^hiV^c\a‚h#
ª8‹bdedY†VXdcdXZgidYdhZhidhYZiVaaZhjcVYdaZhXZciZ
YZXVidgXZVŠdh!XdcjcV^chigjXX^‹cZhXdaVgbjnZcYZWaZn
/(-2851$/63,5,7(1o$%5,/
h^c]VWZgVWVcYdcVYdcjcXVhjKZgbdcicViVa4
6aXdb^Zcod!ZaeZg^dY^hiV]VW†V^YdVkZgVab‚Y^jbeVgV
YZhXjWg^gaVhjeZgX]Zg†V!eZgdYZhej‚hYZjcV^ckZhi^\VX^‹c
hZg^VnXdcaVVnjYVYZZheZX^Va^hiVh!h‹adejYdXdcXaj^gVh†/
¹:c XdchZXjZcX^V bZ kZd XdadXVYd Zc ZhiV VaiZgcVi^kV/ d
jc ]dbWgZ YZ \Zc^d XjVafj^ZgV ]V ji^a^oVYd Va Hg# ?VbZh
Xdbd ^chigjbZcid eVgV egZhZciVg Va eWa^Xd jcV dWgV
ZmigVdgY^cVg^V!YZjcVbVcZgVZmigVdgY^cVg^V!dW^ZcZhiZa^Wgd!
XdbdegZiZcYZhj^ck^h^WaZVjidg![jZZhXg^idZ[ZXi^kVbZciZ
WV_dZaY^XiVYdYZaegde^d9^X`Zch#AVhZ\jcYVhjedh^X^‹c
cdZhZcVWhdajidb{hbVgVk^aadhVfjZaVeg^bZgV#H^Zm^hiZ
ZcKZgbdcijc]dbWgZ!YZhXdcdX^Yd]VhiVV]dgV!XVeVoYZ
ZhXg^W^gXdbd9^X`Zch!X^ZgiVbZciZcdi^ZcZc^c\cbdi^kd
eVgV ]VWZg gZXjgg^Yd V hZbZ_VciZ hjWiZg[j\^d# H^! edg digV
eVgiZ!ZhZaegde^d9^X`Zchfj^Zc]VWaV!VjcfjZZhi‚bjZgid!
ªeVgVfj‚hdgegZhVhcdYZWZbdhegZeVgVgcdh4
9dn iZhi^bdc^d! Xdc idYV ]dcZhi^YVY! YZ fjZ ]VW^ZcYd
iZc^Yd idiVa a^WZgiVY eVgV ZmVb^cVg a^WgZbZciZ idYVh
aVh XdhVh! cd ]Z edY^Yd ZcXdcigVg Za b†c^bd gVhigd YZ
Zc\VŠdº#
8VYVhZghdWgZZhiZeaVcZiVi^ZcZhjegde^dZhi^ad!hjegde^d
bdYd YZ ZhXg^W^g n YZ ]VWaVg# N Xdbd ad ViZhi^\jV ZhiZ
eZg^dY^hiV!aVhZ\jcYVb^iVYYZaVdWgVh^\jZZhiVcYdZcZa
Zhi^ad!Za\^gdnaVZmegZh^‹cYZ8]VgaZh9^X`Zch#IdYVhZhiVh
egjZWVhXViVad\VYVhcdejZYZch^cdXdc[^gbVgaVV[^gbVX^‹c
YZ VfjZa _dkZc YZ XVidgXZ VŠdh#6YZb{h! ZhiZ XVhd cd Zh
c^Xd#AV]^hidg^VYZaV[^adhd[†VZhe†g^iVcdh]VbdhigVYdjc
\gVccbZgdYZ]ZX]dhh^b^aVgZh/adhZhe†g^ijh]VckZc^Yd
YZhej‚hYZhjbjZgiZeVgViZgb^cVghjhdWgVh#Edgh^beaZ
Vbdg!e^cidgZh!ZhXg^idgZh!bh^XdhnbjX]dhdigdhVgi^hiVh
h^\jZcXgZVcYdYZhYZhjb{hVaa{#
*%
'266,(5
/26(6&5,725(6,163,5$'26325(/0z6$//z
SRU
3$75,&,$6$/,%$
,163,5$&,Š1<0(',801,'$'
'(/$,'($68*(5,'$$/$2%5$0(',01,&$
(Q ORV LQLFLDGRV GHO PXQGR DQWLJXR GHVGH ORV SURIHWDV KDVWD ORV SRHWDV \ HVFULWRUHV OD
LQVSLUDFL§QSURYRFDHOž[WDVLVLQWHOHFWXDOTXHSHUPLWHODFRPXQLFDFL§QFRQHOP–VDOO–‚VWD
VHPDQLILHVWDGHPDQHUDGLIHUHQWHVHJ®QODQDWXUDOH]DGHORVKRPEUHVTXHODUHFLEHQ
N
V hZVc [^a‹hd[dh! ZhXg^"
idgZh d edZiVh! adh
]dbWgZh YZ \Zc^d ]Vc
YZ_VYd dWgVh bV\c†[^XVh fjZ
ZmegZhVcaVg^fjZoVYZhj^ciZ"
a^\ZcX^V!YZhjhhZci^b^Zcidhd
YZhjXdbegdb^hdeda†i^Xdedg
jcV hdX^ZYVY Y^[ZgZciZ# ª9Z
Y‹cYZaZhkZc†VZhV^che^gVX^‹c4
ªBjhV!Zcijh^Vhbd!adXjgV4
:hidh ]dbWgZh YZ \Zc^d hdc
V kZXZh b‚Y^jbh Zc Y^kZghdh
\gVYdh! Zc ‹gYZcZh Y^[ZgZciZh!
ngZaVX^dcVYdhXdcZab{hVaa{
kdajciVg^VbZciZdcd#6a\jcdh
YZ Zaadh ]Vc h^Yd ^che^gVYdh
h‹ad jcV hdaV kZo Zc hj k^YV!
YZ_VcYdjcVegjZWV^cbdgiVaVigVk‚hYZadhh^\adh#:aZhijY^d
YZaVbZY^jbc^YVY^cij^i^kVeZgb^iZXdbegZcYZgX‹bdZa
eZchVb^ZcidYZaZhe†g^ijZhigVchb^i^YdVaZhXg^idgdedZiV!
fjZcdhadgZhi^ijnZ!hj[g^ZcYdbdY^[^XVX^dcZhYZVXjZgYdV
hj\gVYdYZYZhVggdaad^ciZaZXijVa!VhjbVcZgVYZhZci^gdV
hj]VW^a^YVYeVgVZmegZhVgXdceVaVWgVhhjhZhiVYdhYZVabV#
:aVgi^hiVhZXdck^ZgiZZcidcXZhZcZa^chigjbZcidYZjcV
XdcX^ZcX^VfjZ!VkZXZh!adhjeZgV#6aVkZo\j†Vnk^h^dcVg^d!
ZaZhXg^idg!ZaedZiVYViZhi^bdc^deVgVYZheZgiVgaVhXdcX^Zc"
X^Vh#¹AV^che^gVX^‹cZhjcVhj\Zhi^‹cYZadhZhe†g^ijhfjZcdh
gZkZaVZaedgkZc^gnaVhXdhVhdXjaiVhºYZX†VE^i{\dgVh#
AdfjZhZeVgVZaiVaZcidYZa\Zc^d!ZhaVedWgZoVdg^fjZoVYZ
aV^che^gVX^‹c!aVXjVaVajYZVjcZcijh^VhbdfjZZhegZX^hd
hVWZgXdbegZcYZg/¹=Vg‚^hkjZhigVigV\ZY^VXjVcYdkjZhigd
Zcijh^Vhbddh\dW^ZgcZ0ejZhhVW‚^hfjZ]VXZ[VaiVgZX^W^g
aV^che^gVX^‹cncjcXVWjhXVgaVº#KdaiV^gZ!XVgiV8]VWVcdc!
&,++#
EVgVA^iig‚!ZcZah^\adM>M!aV^che^gVX^‹cZhYZdg^\ZcY^k^cd#
¹9Zh^\cV bdk^b^Zcidh YZa VabV! eZchVb^Zcidh! VXX^dcZh
fjZ hdc YZW^YVh V jcV ^chj"
[aVX^‹c Y^k^cV! XdbeVgVYVh V
aV^chj[aVX^‹cfjZ^cigdYjXZZa
V^gZZcadhejabdcZhº#
=dn Zc Y†V! aV eVaVWgV ¹^che^"
gVX^‹cº YZh^\cV aV bVndg†V YZ
aVhkZXZhjchdead^ciZg^dgfjZ
hZ ZbeVg^ZciV Xdc Za hdead
Y^k^cd YZ aV igVY^X^‹c! edgfjZ
Zh gZX^W^Yd! Zhedci{cZVbZciZ!
eZgdfjZhZY^hi^c\jZYZ‚aedg
hZg cVijgVa# H^c ZbWVg\d! edg
cVijgVa fjZ cdh eVgZoXV ZhZ
ZhiVYd! iZcZbdh aV hZchVX^‹c
YZ hZg ]VW^iVYdh n hdXdgg^Ydh
edgVa\db{h\gVcYZfjZcdhd"
igdhfjZcdh]VXZVXijVgbZ_dg
YZadfjZ]jW^‚gVbdhedY^Yd]VXZgadhdadh#8dbegZcYZbdh
fjZ H‹XgViZh ]VnV edY^Yd iZcZg aV Xdck^XX^‹c YZ fjZ jc
Y^dh hZ ZmegZhVWV V igVk‚h ‚a! XdbeVgVcYd aV ^che^gVX^‹c
ed‚i^XVXdcaVe^ZYgVYZ=ZgVXaZV!jcVe^ZYgVfjZedhZZZa
edYZgYZbV\cZi^oVgadhdW_ZidhbZi{a^Xdh#¹EjZhidYdhadh
edZiVh ‚e^Xdh gZX^iVc idYdh hjh ]Zgbdhdh edZbVh cd Zc
k^gijY YZ jc VgiZ! h^cd edgfjZ hdc ^che^gVYdh n edhZ†Ydh!
nhjXZYZ^\jVaXdcadhWjZcdhedZiVha†g^Xdh°adhedZbVh
]Zgbdhdhcdi^ZcZcXVg{XiZg]jbVcdncdhdcdWgVYZadh
]dbWgZh!h^cdfjZi^ZcZcjcXVg{XiZgY^k^cdnhdcdWgVYZ
adhY^dhZhnadhedZiVhcdhdcb{hfjZadh^ci‚gegZiZhYZadh
Y^dhZhXjVcYdhdcedhZ†Ydh!XjVafj^ZgVfjZhZVaVY^k^c^YVY
fjZedhZVVXVYVjcdYZZaadhº#>dc
EVgVEaVi‹c/¹:aedZiVnZaegd[ZiV!eVgVgZX^W^gaV^che^gVX^‹c
YZWZc ZcigVg Zc jc ZhiVYd hjeZg^dg! YdcYZ hj ]dg^odciZ
^ciZaZXijVa Zh ZchVcX]VYd Z ^ajb^cVYd edg jcV ajo b{h
VaiV#Cdhdcadhk^YZciZh!adhegd[ZiVhdadhedZiVhfj^ZcZh
]VWaVc!h^cdZh9^dhfj^Zc]VWaVZcZaadhº#
:cadh^c^X^VYdhYZabjcYdVci^\jd!YZhYZadhegd[ZiVh]VhiV
/(-2851$/63,5,7(1o$%5,/
*&
adhedZiVhnZhXg^idgZh!aV^che^gVX^‹cegdkdXVZa‚miVh^h^ciZaZXijVa
fjZeZgb^iZaVXdbjc^XVX^‹cXdcZab{hVaa{#whiVhZbVc^[^ZhiVYZ
bVcZgVY^[ZgZciZhZ\caVcVijgVaZoVYZadh]dbWgZhfjZaVgZX^WZc!
jcVcVijgVaZoVfjZgZhjaiVYZaVhk^YVhVciZg^dgZhYdcYZZaYZhVggdaad
YZaV^ciZa^\ZcX^VnYZaVegd[jcYVhZch^W^a^YVY]VXZY^[†X^aY^hi^c\j^g
ZaeZchVb^Zcidegde^dYZaVjidgYZaV^YZVhj\Zg^YVedgZa^che^gVYdg
dXjaid#:hiV^che^gVX^‹cejZYZaaZ\VgWgjiVabZciZXdc[jZgoV]VhiV
hdgegZcYZgadhhZci^Ydh[†h^Xdh#
/DLQVSLUDFL¦QHQORVµPRGHUQRV¶
@$<$LedIY^_bb[hYgVbVijg\dVaZb{c!Vb^\dYZ<dZi]ZZcVbdgVYd
YZa^YZVanYZaVa^WZgiVYYZXaVg‹fjZhjhb{h]ZgbdhdheZchVb^Zcidh
cdZgVcYZhjegde^VXgZVX^‹c!aZaaZ\VWVciVcg{e^YVbZciZnXdciVa
[jZgoV! fjZ iZc†V Y^[^XjaiVY eVgV VigVeVgadh Xdc hj[^X^ZciZ gVe^YZo
eVgV igVchXg^W^gadh# BVYVbZ YZ HiV…a Y^g†V YZ ‚a/ ¹HX]^aaZg ZgV jc
]dbWgZYZgVgd\Zc^dnYZjcVeZg[ZXiVWjZcV[Z!YdhXVa^YVYZhfjZ
YZWZg†VchZg^chZeVgVWaZh!VabZcdhZcjc]dbWgZYZaZigVh°:hVa\d
]ZgbdhdaV^cdXZcX^VZcZa\Zc^dnZaXVcYdgZcaV[jZgoVº#
AVdWgVnaVeZghdcVa^YVYYZ>[_dh_Y^>[_d[!X‚aZWgZZhXg^idgVaZb{c!
edZiVVYb^gVYd!eZg^dY^hiV!]^hidg^VYdgYZaVh^YZVh!]VchjhX^iVYd
Y^hXjh^dcZhVeVh^dcVYVhedgaVg\di^Zbed#9ZhiZggVYdZcEVg†hZc
&-(&!=Z^cg^X]=Z^cZZchjegZ[VX^dYZL^aa^VbGVYXa^[[YZX†VZhid/
¹:hXg^W†L^aa^VbGVYXa^[[Zc7Zga†c!YjgVciZadhai^bdhY†VhYZ&-'&!
eZchVcYdfjZZahda^ajb^cVWVXdchjhgVndh!b{hW^ZcYZhVeVX^WaZh!
adhiZ_VYdhXjW^ZgidhYZc^ZkZnadh{gWdaZhYZhed_VYdhYZhjh]d_Vh#
:hXg^W† h^c ^ciZggjeX^‹c n h^c ]VXZg jcV Zcb^ZcYV# 6a ZhXg^W^g! bZ
eVgZX†VfjZd†VhdWgZb^XVWZoVXdbdjcWVi^gYZVaVh#8jVcYdaZ
Xdci‚ZhiZ]ZX]dVb^hVb^\dh!_‹kZcZhedZiVhWZga^cZhZh!hZb^gVgdc
YZbVcZgVh^c\jaVgnbZYZXaVgVgdcjc{c^bZbZciZfjZcjcXV]VW†Vc
hZci^YdcVYVhZbZ_VciZVaZhXg^W^gº#HjigV\ZY^VZhZhe†g^iV#6XX^‹cn
YZhZcaVXZhj[gZcaV^c[ajZcX^VgZX†egdXVYZabjcYdYZadhk^kdhn
adhbjZgidh#AV^gdc†VYZaedZiVcjcXVViVXVWVVa^YZVa#6ejciVWV
Va eVgi^XjaVg^hbd fjZ Vc hjWh^hi†V Zc adh ]ZX]dh YZ aV k^YV gZVa!
aV^cidaZgVcX^VgZa^\^dhVnhdWgZidYdadhVe‹hidaZhYZZhiVai^bV!
fjZ ^ciZciVWVc igVWVg aV bVgX]V YZa egd\gZhd#6eVh^dcVYVbZciZ
ZcVbdgVYdYZaVkZgYVYnYZaVa^WZgiVY![aV\ZaVWVXdchjhhVgXVhbdh
adhYZ[ZXidhYZhj‚edXV#IdYdadfjZaVhdX^ZYVYZcXZggVWVZchj
hZcd YZ XdcigVhiZh ejcoVciZh! YZ adXjgVh n YZ ^YZVh a^b^iVYVh hZ
ZcXjZcigVZchjhdWgVh^ajb^cVYVhedgjcVajoXgjYVZ^beaVXVWaZ#
6eZhVgYZadhiZgg^WaZhhj[g^b^ZcidhfjZaZXVjhVWVhjZc[ZgbZYVY
^cXjgVWaZYZaVb‚YjaVZhe^cVahZ\j†VaZnZcYd!gZX^W^ZcYdnY^XiVcYd
hjheZchVb^Zcidh#I]‚de]^aZ<Vji^ZgZcZaegZ[VX^dYZadhXjVYgdh
YZk^V_ZhYZhXg^WZVZhiZ\Zc^d/¹9jgVciZZhiVaVg\VV\dc†V!d[gZX^‹
Za[Zc‹bZcdYZaVabVh^cXjZged!YZaZhe†g^ijfjZegZhX^cYZYZaV
bViZg^V°:a\Zc^dgZhjX^iVWVZhiZgdhigdbjZgid#=Z^cZZhZabVndg
a†g^XdYZ6aZbVc^VnhZXdadXVcVijgVabZciZVaaVYdYZ<dZi]ZnYZ
HX]^aaZgº#9ZjcV^ciZa^\ZcX^VYZaVhb{hhji^aZh!YZ_‹VaVedhiZg^YVY
jcVdWgVcdiVWaZ#Bjg^‹Za&,YZ[ZWgZgdYZ&-*)#6aZmVcYgZ9jbVh
n I]‚de]^aZ <Vji^Zg aZ VXdbeVŠVgdc Va XZbZciZg^d BdcibVgigZ#
¹BjZgd XgZnZcYd Zc jc 9^dh c^Xd n ZiZgcd XgZVYdg YZa bjcYd n
XjnVb^hZg^XdgY^V^beadgdeVgVb^VabV^cbdgiVaº#
7b\h[Z Z[ Ckii[j! ¹a¼Zc[Vci iZgg^WaZº! YZa gdbVci^X^hbd ZhiVWV
hdbZi^YdVaVhb{hY^kZghVh^c[ajZcX^VhfjZ‚ab^hbddWhZgkVWV/¹H†!
YZX†V!ndhj[gdYZa[Zc‹bZcdfjZadhiVjbVijg\dhaaVbVcedhZh^‹c#
9dhZhe†g^ijhhZ]VcVYjZŠVYdYZb†º#<#HVcY!ZaaVn‚a#
:a edZiV ZcigVWV Zc igVcXZ! [jZ V aV kZo jc edZiV ^che^gVYd n jc
b‚Y^jbk^YZciZnVjY^i^kd/¹=VXZbjX]dhVŠdhfjZiZc\dk^h^dcZh
nd^\dkdXZh#8‹bdYjYVg†VndXjVcYdidYdhb^hhZci^YdhbZad
/(-2851$/63,5,7(1o$%5,/
)ULHGULFK9RQ6FKLOOHU
+HQUL+HLQH
3HUF\%\VVKH6KHOOH\
)XHQWHV
/žRQ'HQLV'DQVOµLQYLVLEOH
*DEULHO 'HODQQH 5HFKHUFKHV VXU OD PžGLXPQLWž
%UDXVVFKYL1RWUHOLWWžUDWXUHžWXGLžHGDQVOHVWH[WHV
/DUHYXHVSLULWHGH
*'
V[^gbVc°8j{ciVhkZXZh!VaXVZgaVcdX]Z!]Zk^hidnd†YdVa
_dkZceg†cX^eZfjZbZ[jZfjZg^YdnVdigdYZb^hVb^\dh
igVWVYdhZcYjZadYZaVciZYZb†#:caVh]dgVhZcfjZZhiV
Xdbjc^‹chZdeZgV!bZeVgZXZfjZb^Zhe†g^ijhZYZheZ\V
YZb^XjZgedeVgVgZhedcYZgVaVkdoYZadhZhe†g^ijhfjZbZ
]VWaVcº#6a[gZYYZBjhhZiVafjZXVgVXiZg^oVcaV[VciVh†V!aV
_jkZcijYnZaVbdg!Y^Vad\VXdcaVbjhV!YZhkVg†V!bVcZ_V
Za^ggZheZidnaVYZhZckdaijgV!ZhjcVci^Xdc[dgb^hiVYZaVh
^YZVhnYZadhhjZŠdh#
F[hYo8oii^[I^[bb[o!jcdYZadhbVndgZhedZiVha†g^XdhYZa
digdaVYdYZaXVcVaYZaVBVcX]V!fjZbjg^‹ig{\^XVbZciZ
VaVZYVYYZ(%VŠdh!eZgiZcZXZVaVhZ\jcYV\ZcZgVX^‹cYZ
edZiVh ^c\aZhZh# >YZVa^hiV n gZWZaYZ! cd XZh‹ YZ YZcjcX^Vg
aVhdegZh^dcZhYZidYV†cYdaZ#HjXgZVX^‹ced‚i^XVZhjcV
idbV YZ XdcX^ZcX^V eda†i^XV# Hj gZkdajX^‹c Zh h^c‹c^bd
YZa^WZgiVYnYZVbdg#:caVdWgVYZH]ZaaZnZhi{cjc^YVh
edZh†VbZiV[†h^XVneda†i^XV#:hiZk^gijdhdYZadhg^ibdhnYZ
aVheVaVWgVhcdhd[gZXZjca^g^hbdZhedci{cZdYZjcVgVgV
ejgZoVegd[‚i^XV#
HjGZWZa^‹cYZa>haVb!Zh!hZ\c‚a!jcaVg\dedZbVcVggVi^kd!
jcVhjXZh^‹cYZ^b{\ZcZhYZhi^cVYVhV^ajhigVgeZg[ZXiVbZciZ
Za XgZX^b^Zcid n aV ZkdajX^‹c YZa Zhe†g^ij ^cY^k^YjVa Zc hj
Vhe^gVX^‹cnhjVeZ\dVaVbdgYZaV]jbVc^YVY#:aEgdbZiZd
a^WZgVYdZhaVdWgVbVZhigVYZH]ZaaZnfjZd[gZXZaVh†ciZh^h
YZ aVh Ydh ^che^gVX^dcZh/ aV gZkdajX^‹c n ad ^ck^h^WaZ! n jc
bZchV_ZYZZheZgVcoV#:c6YdcV^h!H]ZaaZnZmegZhVhj[ZZc
ZadigdbjcYd#
=ZVfj†adfjZY^_dBZYl^c!]^hidg^VYdgYZH]ZaaZn/¹hdŠVWV
bjn YZhe^Zgid! Zc jcV hjZgiZ YZ VWhigVXX^‹c aZi{g\^XV
fjZ aZ ZgV ]VW^ijVa! n! YZhej‚h YZ XVYV VXXZhd! hjh d_dh
XZciZaaZVWVc!hjhaVW^dhiZbWaVWVcnhjkdohZkdak†Vig‚bjaV
edgaVZbdX^‹c#:cigVWVZcjcVZheZX^ZYZhdcVbWja^hbd
YjgVciZZaXjVahjaZc\jV_ZZgVb{hW^ZcYZjcZhe†g^ijdYZ
jc{c\ZafjZYZjc]dbWgZº;‚a^mGVWZk^YVYZH]ZaaZn#
¹HjhaZXijgVhXdci^cjVh!Y^XZI]‚de]^aZ<Vji]^Zg]VWaVcYd
\RDYHFHVFRUU¢DDPLHVFULWRULRGLFH
*RHWKHVLQPROHVWDUPHHQHQGHUH]DU
XQDKRMDGHSDSHOTXHHVWDEDGH
WUDYžV\HVFULE¢DPLREUDHQYHUVR
GHVGHHOFRPLHQ]RKDVWDHOILQDODO
VHVJRVLQPRYHUPH
YZ 7VaoVX! cd [jZgdc ^ciZggjbe^YVh edg Za XdaZ\^d n Xdc
ZaaVhhZYZhVggdaa‹aVbZY^iVX^‹cZmi{i^XVYZaeZchVb^Zcid!
gZhjaiVcYd YZ Zaad eVgV 7VaoVX jcV gVgV Zc[ZgbZYVY! jcV
[^ZWgZcZgk^dhV!jcVhjZgiZYZXdbV0e{a^Yd!Zc[aVfjZX^Yd!
WV_daV^begZh^‹cYZjcVXdc\Zhi^‹cYZ^YZVh!eVgZX†V^bW‚X^a#
HjVXi^ijYZhaVYZjcZmi{i^Xd!YZjchdc{bWjadfjZYjZgbZ
Xdcadhd_dhVW^Zgidh!eZgY^YdZcjcVegd[jcYVZchdŠVX^‹c!
cdd†VadfjZhZaZYZX†V!dhjZhe†g^ijgZ\gZhVYdYZhYZaZ_dh
aaZ\VWVYZbVh^VYdiVgYZeVgVaVgZhejZhiV#7VaoVXYZX†VYZ
h†b^hbd/DnZcYdVaVh\ZciZhZcaVXVaaZ!edY†VVY]Zg^gbZ
Vhjhk^YVh!hZci†Vhjh]VgVedhhdWgZaVZheVaYV!bVgX]VWV
Xdc adh e^Zh Zc hjh oVeVidh eZg[dgVYdh0 hjh YZhZdh! hjh
cZXZh^YVYZh!idYdeVhVWVVb^VabV!nb^VabVeVhVWVVaV
YZZaadh!ZgVZahjZŠdYZjc]dbWgZYZhe^Zgidº#
/DREUDPHGL­PQLFD
AV 9^k^cV 8dbZY^V YZ :Wdj[7b_]^_[h_ Zh jc eZgZ\g^cV_Z
V igVk‚h YZ adh bjcYdh ^ck^h^WaZh! h^\j^ZcYd adh \gVcYZh
a^cZVb^ZcidhYZaV^c^X^VX^‹cZcadhb^hiZg^dhVci^\jdhfjZ
i^ZcZcXdbdeg^cX^e^daVXdbjc^‹cXdcaddXjaid#:aiZbVZh
Zajc^kZghdZciZgd!cVijgVanhdWgZcVijgVa#
:aIVhhd Xdbejhd V adh &- VŠdh! hj edZbV XVWVaaZgZhXd!
WV_daV^che^gVX^‹cYZ6g^dhidnb{hiVgYZ!Zc&*,*!hjdWgV
XVe^iVa!hj?ZgjhVa‚ca^WZgVYV#:hiZgZaVidaZ\ZcYVg^dZckZ^ciZ
XVcidh!fjZbZoXaVaVZkdXVX^‹c]^hi‹g^XVYZaVXdcfj^hiVYZ
adhhVcidhaj\VgZhedgadheg^bZgdhXgjoVYdhXdcaVe^cijgV
YZaVheVh^dcZhVbdgdhVh!Zhi{ZhXg^idXdcjca^g^hbdfjZhZ
YZhZc[gZcVhdWgZidYdZcadhZe^hdY^dhegd[Vcdh#B{hVaa{
YZ adh Zc[gZciVb^Zcidh ZcigZ Xg^hi^Vcdh n hVggVXZcdh! ZaaV
Zh Za aj\Vg eg^k^aZ\^VYd YZ jc XdbWViZ X‹hb^Xd ZcigZ aVh
[jZgoVhY^k^cVhZ^c[ZgcVaZh#
<dZi]Z!AVbVgi^cZn7VjYZaV^gZk^ZgdcZc‚ajcVegZ[^\jgV"
X^‹cYZaVhdWhZh^dcZhZ^cij^X^dcZhYZcjZhigVhZch^W^a^YVY
bdYZgcV#
:a ;Vjhid YZ =e[j^[ Zh bV\^higVa/¹ndVkZXZhXdgg†VVb^
ZhXg^idg^d! Y^XZ <dZi]Z! h^c bdaZhiVgbZ Zc ZcYZgZoVg jcV
]d_V YZ eVeZa fjZ ZhiVWV YZ igVk‚h! n ZhXg^W†V b^ dWgV Zc
kZghdYZhYZZaXdb^Zcod]VhiVZa[^cVaVahZh\d!h^cbdkZgbZ#
6ZhiZZ[ZXid!idbVWVYZegZ[ZgZcX^Vjca{e^o!fjZhZegZhiV
bZ_dgVigVoVgadhXVgVXiZgZh!ejZhVkZXZhedYg†V]VWZgbZ
YZheZgiVYdYZb^edZh†VYZhdc{bWjad!dY^higV†YdedgZa
X]^aa^YddZagdXZYZb^eajbV!nV]d\VgZchjcVX^b^Zcid
jcVeZfjZŠVegdYjXX^‹cº#
@eWY^_cZ[<_ehW n @[WdZ[FWhcW [jZgdc ^chigj^Ydh edg
k^h^dcZh n ZhXg^W^Zgdc :a ZkVc\Za^d :iZgcd edg Y^XiVYd YZ
jcZhe†g^ij#Idb{hYZ6fj^cdXdckZghVWVXdcjceZghdcV_Z
^ck^h^WaZ#9ZcdX]Z!hjXZaYVhZaaZcVWVYZjcVajoZmigVŠV#
HjhZe†hidaVhaZ[jZgdcY^XiVYVhnZhV[VXjaiVYYZhVeVgZX^‹
hW^iVbZciZ#
H]V`ZheZVgZ!B^aidc!AVbVgi^cZnK^Xidg=j\d[jZgdcZhXg^"
idgZh ^che^gVYdh n VgY^ZciZh YZ[ZchdgZh! Xdbd =j\d! YZ
aV Xdbjc^XVX^‹c edh^WaZ ZcigZ adh k^kdh n adh bjZgidh# :a
b{h Vaa{ [ZXjcYVWV hj \Zc^d# AVbVgi^cZ hZ _jhi^[^XVWV YZ
aVhXg†i^XVhYZ:c[Vci^cXdcZhiVheVaVWgVh/¹IZc\db^dW_Z"
i^kd!‚acdadhdheZX]V/cVY^ZhVWZXj{aZh!ZmXZeidnd#Kdn
VaeVhdfjZZai^ZbedY^hedcZncdb{hg{e^Yd#:hiZ[^cZh
^beZghdcVa n c^XVbZciZ Y^k^cd# HZ YZhXjWg^g{ b{h iVgYZ#
B^ZcigVhiVcid!X‹bdfj^ZgZ‚afjZ]VWaZVadh]dbWgZhYZ
XVgcZn]jZhdZcZaejgdaZc\jV_ZYZadh:he†g^ijhº#
:aZhXg^idg!ZaedZiV!ZhjcV\j†V!jck^YZciZ!jchZghZch^WaZ
fjZVY^k^cVaVhVegZch^dcZhYZaV]jbVc^YVY!nVkZXZhaZ
bjZhigVZaXVb^cd#9VVaVheVaVWgVhhjkZgYVYZgdhZci^Yd
eVgVjcVZmegZh^‹chjegZbVYZaeZchVb^Zcid#9Z_ZbdhaV
XdcXajh^‹cYZZhiZk^V_ZVigVk‚hYZaVa^iZgVijgV^che^gVYVV
6cYg‚7gZidc!kZc^YdVcjZhigd8†gXjadZchZh^‹cZhe†g^iV/
¹Cd bdaZhi‚^h V adh edZiVh! cd gdW‚^h hj XdcX^ZcX^V! cd
YZh\Vgg‚^hZakZadYZhjZheZgVcoV!kdaVYXdcZaadh]VX^VaVh
XjbWgZhb{hVaiVh!b{hWZaaVh!b{h\gVcYZh!XVYVkZob{h
kZgYVYZgVhº#
/(-2851$/63,5,7(1o$%5,/
*(
(&26
/26(6&5,725(6,163,5$'26325(/0z6$//z
SRU
3$75,&,$6$/,%$
:caVhB‚Y^iVi^dched‚i^fjZhYZAVbVgi^cZ!
AVBjZgiZYZH‹XgViZhZhjcVdYVVaZhe†g^ij^che^gVYdg/
6h†XjVcYdiZaVcXZhhdWgZb^VabV!
:cijh^Vhbd!{\j^aVkZcXZYdgV!
6agj^YdYZijhVaVhYZ[jZ\d
I^ZbWadYZhVcid]dggdg0
BZYZWVidWV_dijedYZg!
=jnd!iZbdfjZijegZhZcX^V
CdVc^fj^aZjcXdgVo‹cbdgiVa!
8dbdjc[jZ\dfjZZagVndZcX^ZcYZ!
FjZcdhZVeV\Vb{h!nXdchjbZ
AV]d\jZgV!ZaiZbeadnZaVaiVg#
AdhVW‚^h!Vb^\dh0VbZcjYd!YZhYZb^_jkZcijY!
Jc\Zc^dYZhXdcdX^YdbZ^che^g‹aVhVW^Yjg†V!
NYZabjcYd[jijgdbZYZhXjWg^‹aVhaZnZh#
ª:gVVa\c9^dhZhXdcY^YdZcjcVkdo4
ªJcVhdbWgVVWgVo{cYdbZXdchZXgZiVVb^hiVY4
ª:aZXdYZaedgkZc^g4ªAVbjhVYZaedZiV4
Cdh‚0eZgdZaZhe†g^ijfjZbZ]VWaVWVbjnfjZYd!
9ZhYZfjZVb^[^cbZVXZgXdV\gVcYZheVhdh!
:chdc^Ydhb{hVaidhbZ]VWaVnbZXdchjZaV#
GZXdcdoXdb{hegdcidhjY^k^cVeVaVWgV!
NVhZVfjZjcXdgVo‹cgdYZVYdYZaijbjaidYZadhhZci^Ydh
8dcb{hh^aZcX^dZhXjX]VhjhVXZcidh0
NVhZVfjZ!XdbdZaVkZ!Za^ck^h^WaZ\Zc^d
GZYdWaVedgaViVgYZhjXdcbdkZYdgVVgbdc†V0
Db{hW^ZcfjZdak^YVcYdZaY†VfjZkVViZgb^cVg!
B^VabV!hjheZcY^YVVadhWdgYZhYZaedgkZc^g!
9^hi^c\jZbZ_dgZahdc^YdfjZeVgiZYZdigdbjcYd!
8dbdZacVkZ\VciZ!aViVgYZ!ZggVcYdhdWgZaVdaV!
6bZY^YVfjZWd\VnhZVXZgXVVaWdgYZ!
9^hi^c\jZbZ_dgaVkdofjZhZZaZkVYZaejZgid#
:hZ^ck^h^WaZVb^\d_Vb{hbZVWVcYdcV!
H^ZbegZhjVXZcidZcb^d†YdgZhjZcV!
NhjkdoZcb^kdo]VWaVhdaV]dn0
6b^\dh!«ZhXjX]VYejZhNVcdhdnnd!«Zh‚a
$OSKRQVH'H/DPDUWLQH
EZgdVakjZadYZaeZchVb^Zcid
:a^chi^cidYZadhhZci^YdhhZdedcZZckVcd0
7V_dZaY^dh!b^VabVdeg^b^YV
HVaiV!VWVa{coViZ!n\daeZVb^hZcd#
:agVndX^gXjaVZcb^hkZcVh
6hdbWgVYdYZa[jZ\dfjZbZfjZbV#
Ad^gg^idXdbWVi^‚cYdad!
NaVaVkVYZb^\Zc^d
HZYZhWdgYVZcidggZciZhYZVgbdc†V!
NbZXdchjbZZhXVeVcYd#
/(-2851$/63,5,7(1o$%5,/
/D0XHUWHGH6§FUDWHV
AVbVgi^cZ!\gVcYedƒiZang^fjZVY‚Xg^iXZi‚iVi
eVgi^Xja^ZgfjZYdccZa¼^che^gVi^dcZcXZhkZgh/
*)
( 1 7 5 ( 9 , 6 7$
SDODEUDVUHFRJLGDVSRU
-$&48(63(&&$77(
-($1-$&48(6&+$5%21,(5
0',&2$1(67(6,67$
$OSULQFLSLRPHGHGLTXžDXQDFDUUHUDGHPžGLFRUXUDO\IXHDOIUHFXHQWDUORV6$086HUYLFLR
GH$\XGD0žGLFDGH(PHUJHQFLDSDUDSHUIHFFLRQDUPHHQHOFDPSRGHODHPHUJHQFLDTXH
GHFLG¢QRFRQWHQWDUPHFRQPLGLSORPDGHPžGLFRGHPHGLFLQDJHQHUDO
«Gk_ƒd[ikij[Z5
<ehcWY_Œd"fhe\[i_Œd"c[Z_e
ieY_Wb$«Fk[Z[kij[Zfh[i[djWhi[
[dkdWiYkWdjWib‡d[Wi5
Hdnb‚Y^XdVcZhiZh^hiV"gZVc^bVYdg#
IZc\d X^cXjZciV VŠdh! hdn XVhVYd!
iZc\d Ydh ]^_dh! \ZbZadh! fjZ ]dn
i^ZcZc kZ^ciZ VŠdh! n Z_Zgod ZhiZ
VeVh^dcVciZ d[^X^d YZhYZ ]VXZ b{h
YZ kZ^ciZ VŠdh# EgdkZc\d YZ jc
bZY^d hdX^Va bdYZhid0 b^ bVYgZ!
^\jVafjZb^VWjZaV!ZgV^chi^ijig^on
b^eVYgZZgV_Z[ZYZdWgVh#
K^k† jcV ^c[VcX^V [Za^o n Xdc b^
]ZgbVcd!X^cXdVŠdhbZcdgfjZnd!
gZX^W^bdhjcVZYjXVX^‹cigVY^X^dcVa0
aV^XV eVgV aV ZchZŠVcoV n XVi‹a^XV
eVgVaVgZa^\^‹c#
6a eg^cX^e^d bZ YZY^fj‚ V jcV XVggZgV YZ b‚Y^Xd gjgVa n
[jZ Va [gZXjZciVg adh H6BJ HZgk^X^d YZ 6njYV B‚Y^XV
YZ :bZg\ZcX^V eVgV eZg[ZXX^dcVgbZ Zc Za XVbed YZ aV
ZbZg\ZcX^VfjZYZX^Y†cdXdciZciVgbZXdcb^Y^eadbVYZ
b‚Y^Xd YZ bZY^X^cV \ZcZgVa! h^cd egdadc\Vg b^h ZhijY^dh
YZigZhVŠdheVgVZheZX^Va^oVgbZZcVcZhiZh^V"gZVc^bVX^‹c#
DWijkZhdWgZhVa^ZciZZcb^iZh^hYZYdXidgVYdZcbZY^X^cV
n\Vc‚b^XdcXjghdeVg^h^ZchZYZZheZX^Va^hiVZcVcZhiZh^V"
gZVc^bVX^‹c Zc &.-+# AjZ\d! YZhej‚h YZ jc eZg†dYd YZ
hjeaZcX^Vh Zc adh fj^g‹[Vcdh n jc^YVYZh YZ gZVc^bVX^‹c
YZ Y^[ZgZciZh dg\Vc^oVX^dcZh! bZ ^chiVa‚ Zc jcV eZfjZŠV
Xa†c^XVYZaYZeVgiVbZcidYZa6g^ƒ\ZeVgV^ciZ\gVgbZajZ\d
VjcVYZaVhbVndgZhXa†c^XVhidadhVcVhZcaVfjZigVWV_d
]dn#HdnZab‚Y^XdgZ[ZgZciZYZaVjc^YVYYZgZVc^bVX^‹c
YZZhiZZhiVWaZX^b^Zcid#9jgVciZY^ZX^dX]dVŠdhXjbea†aVh
[jcX^dcZhYZEgZh^YZciZYZ8dc[ZgZcX^VYZa:hiVWaZX^b^Zcid#
:hiZ eVeZa YZ bZY^VYdg! ZaZ\^Yd edg adh b‚Y^Xdh YZ jc
ZhiVWaZX^b^Zcid eVgV gZegZhZciVgadh! bZ kZc†V W^Zc! eZgd
b^h dXjeVX^dcZh Xdbd Vjidg YZ cdkZaVh n Xdc[ZgZcX^hiV!
fjZZm^\†VcXVYVkZob{hi^Zbed!bZdWa^\VgdcVgZcjcX^Vg
VZhiV[jcX^‹cYZEgZh^YZciZYZ8B:0
jcVZaZXX^‹cfjZcdaVbZcid#
«J[d‡Wkij[ZkdWYh[[dY_W
fWhj_YkbWhWdj[iZ[_dj[h[iWhi[
fehbWiD:;5O"«gk[f_[diW
kij[ZZ[bWih[b_]_ed[i5
6ciZh YZ ^ciZgZhVgbZ edg adh C9:!
ijkZjcVZmeZg^ZcX^Vbjn[jZgiZfjZ
bZ ]^od XdbegZcYZg fjZ cjZhigd
XjZged ZgV h‹ad jc Zckdaidg^d! jcV
hjZgiZ YZ kZ]†Xjad iZggZcVa fjZ
YZ_VbdhZcZabdbZcidYZcjZhigV
bjZgiZ#
AZ XjZcid# ;jZ YjgVciZ jcV YZ b^h
eg^bZgVh \jVgY^Vh Xdbd b‚Y^Xd Zc
ZaH6BJYZIdjadjhhZ#;j^aaZkVYdV
jc VXX^YZciZ YZ XVggZiZgV fjZ VXVWVWV YZ egdYjX^ghZ n V
eg^bZgVk^hiVbZY^XjZciVYZfjZZgV\gVkZ#6iZcY†Vjc
_dkZcVigVeVYdZcigZadhgZhidhYZhjVjid#K†Xi^bVYZb^
ZbdX^‹cnYZb^^cZmeZg^ZcX^V!jcVkZoZcZa^ciZg^dgYZa
kZ]†Xjad!cdaaZ\j‚V]VXZgigVch[jh^‹cVa]Zg^YdfjZbjg^‹
VciZ b^h d_dh! YZhej‚h YZ ]VWZg ^ciZgXVbW^VYd Xdcb^\d
VeZcVhVa\jcVh[gVhZhVjY^WaZh#:cZabdbZcidYZbdg^g!hj
eje^aVhZY^aVi‹!jcVX]^heVhZVeV\‹Zchjb^gVYVnhdWgZ
idYd!h†!hdWgZidYd!eZgX^W†bjnXaVgVbZciZjcV¹egZhZcX^Vº
fjZVWVcYdcVWVhjXjZgededgaVX^bVYZhjXg{cZd0ZgV
Xdbdjchdead^cYZhXg^ei^WaZnZhV¹Zci^YVYºgdo‹aVeVgiZ
YZgZX]VYZb^gdhigdeVgVZaZkVghZajZ\dbjng{e^Ydedg
ZcX^bVYZb†#;jZVeVgi^gYZVfjZaY†VfjZijkZaVVWhdajiV
XZgiZoVYZfjZZm^hi†VZaYZhej‚hYZaVk^YV#
:cadfjZVb†XdcX^ZgcZ!bZVigVZb{hadZhe^g^ijVafjZ
ad gZa^\^dhd# AVh edh^X^dcZh g†\^YVh n Yd\b{i^XVh YZ aVh
gZa^\^dcZh ]Vc bViVYd YZbVh^VYV \ZciZ eVgV fjZ hZ aVh
ejZYVidbVgZchZg^d#IdYdhadhiZmidhhV\gVYdhXdci^ZcZc
aVhkZgYVYZhZhZcX^VaZhfjZg^\ZcZhiZbjcYd!nVhZigViZ
YZaVIdg{!YZa8dg{cdYZaCjZkdIZhiVbZcid!eZgdX^ZgiVh
/(-2851$/63,5,7(1o$%5,/
**
aZXijgVhhZXiVg^VhZ^ciZ\g^hiVhYZZhidhiZmidhgZegZhZciVc
eZa^\gdh eVgV Za Xdc_jcid YZ aV ]jbVc^YVY# H^c ZbWVg\d!
]VW^ZcYd gZX^W^Yd jcV ZYjXVX^‹c XVi‹a^XV! bZ dXjggZ V
bZcjYd!ZcX^ZgiVhX^gXjchiVcX^Vh!fjZgZodVBVg†V!Vb^
bdYd#AZ]VWadXdbdVjcVXdc[^YZciZdVjcVVb^\V#Cd
dak^YdfjZZcb^c^ŠZo[j^XjgVYdb^aV\gdhVbZciZYZjc
]dbWgd eVgVa^oVYd fjZ hZ gZhiVWaZX^‹ h^c hZXjZaVh! Va Y†V
h^\j^ZciZ YZ jc k^V_Z V AdjgYZh! eVgV aV \gVc hdgegZhV YZa
X^gj_VcdfjZbZViZcY†V#
:c Z[ZXid! idYd hjXZYZ Xdbd h^ cjZhigV XdcX^ZcX^V [jZgV
XVeVoYZVXijVgXdbdjcZb^hdg"gZXZeidg!gZheZXidVjcV
hjegVXdcX^ZcX^VXdcZXiVYVZcZb^h^‹cedgaVdgVX^‹cdZc
gZXZeX^‹cedgaVbZY^jbc^YVY#
;dikb_XheB½Wfh„il_[[n_ij[;n_ij[[bZ[ifkƒi
Z[bWl_ZW"kij[Zh[Yk[hZWkd^[Y^eZ[ikd_‹[p
gk[i[h[bWY_edWYedkdYec_[dpeZ[D:;$
«Deibefk[Z[Z[iYh_X_h5
BjniZbegVcdk^k†jcVYZh^cXdgedgVX^‹c#;jZYjgVciZb^
eg^bZgV ^c[VcX^V! nd YVWV kjZaiVh VagZYZYdg YZ aV bZhV
YZaXdbZYdgZcb^eZfjZŠdig^X^Xadgd_dnidYVk†ViZc\d
aVk^h^‹cegZX^hVYZaVZhXZcV!Xdbdh^bZ]jW^ZgVedY^Yd
XdadXVgedgZcX^bVYZYZb†b^ZcigVhgdYVWV!Vc^kZaYZa
iZX]dYZaV]VW^iVX^‹cnVaaVYdYZaVa{beVgV!eVgVhZgb{h
ZmVXid#Nd ZhXjX]VWV W^Zc V b^h eVYgZh n b^ VWjZad bZ
e^Y^‹ fjZ YZijk^ZgV b^h kjZaiVh! eZgd hZ\j† eZYVaZVcYd V
eZhVg YZ hjh Xdcb^cVX^dcZh! ]VhiV fjZ jcV Wd[ZiVYV bZ
YZkdak^‹Vb^XjZged#6h†ZhfjZ!«ZagZ\gZhdVaVZckdaijgV
iZggZcVacdh^ZbegZhZ]VXZXdchjVk^YVY
9eceWd[ij[i_ijW"«j_[d[kij[ZkdeeZeiYWieiZ[
fWY_[dj[igk[^WoWdl_l_ZekdWD:;5«<k[WfWhj_hZ[
[iegk[_d_Y_ŒkdWh[\b[n_ŒdieXh[[bWikdje5
:aXVhdb{hdg^\^cVaYZC9:YZafjZ]Zh^YdiZhi^\dZcZa
bVgXdYZb^d[^X^dYZVcZhiZh^hiVZhh^cYjYVVa\jcVZaYZ
jcV_dkZcVaVfjZ]VW†VYdgb^YdeVgVjcVX^gj\†VWZc^\cV
n fjZ! Va YZheZgiVg! bZ ejYd YZhXg^W^g! cd h‹ad hj egde^V
deZgVX^‹c! h^cd iVbW^‚c ad fjZ dXjgg†V Va b^hbd i^Zbed
ZcZafj^g‹[VcdkZX^cd#:cZhiZXVhd!hZkZfjZZai‚gb^cd
¹ZmeZg^ZcX^V XZgXVcV V aV bjZgiZº C9: e^ZgYZ idYd hj
hZci^Yd!ejZhZhiVeVX^ZciZVaVfjZk^\^a‚YjgVciZidYVhj
^ciZgkZcX^‹ccdbZeaVciZ‹c^c\cegdWaZbVk^iVaeVgi^XjaVg
nhZejZYZXdcXaj^gZcidcXZhfjZcdZhcZXZhVg^dZhiVgVaVh
ejZgiVhYZaVbjZgiZeVgVhVa^gYZaXjZged#
:hX^ZgidfjZXjVcYdhZZhiZhi^\dYZiVaZmeZg^ZcX^V!jcdcd
ejZYZh^cd^ciZgZhVghZZcadh[Zc‹bZcdhYZaVhC9:eVgV
^ciZciVgXdbegZcYZgadfjZhjXZYZ#
7b]kdWifWbWXhWiieXh[ikj‡e=Wijedgk[i_]d_\_YŒ
ckY^efWhWkij[Z±
:h X^Zgid fjZ b^ i†d <Vhidc h^\c^[^X‹ bjX]d Zc b^
^c[VcX^V#6aXdcigVg^dYZb^eVYgZd^cXajhdYZb^VWjZad!
‚a iZc†V bjX]d i^Zbed eVgV YZY^XVgbZ n Xdc [gZXjZcX^V
]VX†VbdhWVaaVYZhZc[dg„i!ZcZaigVchXjghdYZadhXjVaZh
gZhedcY†V V b^h bai^eaZh egZ\jciVh hdWgZ Za YZhej‚h YZ
aVk^YVXdci{cYdbZ[Vci{hi^XVh]^hidg^VhYZ[VciVhbVh!YZ
gZZcXVgcVX^‹cn]VhiVYZbZiZbeh^Xdh^h#BZ]VW†VY^X]d
fjZVhjbjZgiZ!gZZcXVgcVg†VZcjc{\j^aVnfjZ]Vg†VdX]dh
ZcZaX^ZadeVgVYVgbZVZciZcYZgfjZad]VW†Vad\gVYd#Ad
/(-2851$/63,5,7(1o$%5,/
b{h^cXgZ†WaZZhfjZZaY†VYZhjZci^Zggd]VW†VZcZ[ZXid!
bjnVaidZcZaX^Zad!jcVkZfjZ]VX†VdX]dh#H^cYjYV!ZhiV
ZgVjcVhZŠVaYZb^i†dfjZbZ]VX†VXdbegZcYZgfjZaV
bjZgiZcdZgVjc[^cVWhdajid#
B^ i†d iZc†V VYdgVX^‹c edg adh \Vidh n hj XVhV ZhiVWV
aaZcV YZ Zaadh# AZh Vig^Wj†V edYZgZh hdWgZcVijgVaZh Xdbd
YdcZh YZ XjgVX^‹c d YZ egZbdc^X^‹c# :h hdgegZcYZciZ
XdbegdWVgfjZX^ZgiVhX^k^a^oVX^dcZhgZbdiVhVig^WjnZcV
ZhidhVc^bVaZhZhVh[VXjaiVYZhfjZ‚a]VW†VYZhXjW^ZgidYZ
bVcZgV^cij^i^kV#
9kƒdj[deibW^_ijeh_WZ[@[\\
AV]^hidg^VhZYZhVggdaaVZcjceZfjZŠd]dhe^iVaeZg^[‚g^Xd
YdcYZndZ_ZgX†VaVh[jcX^dcZhYZ^ciZgcd#?Z[[!ZaZc[ZgbZgd
YZZbZg\ZcX^VhbZ]VW†VYZheZgiVYdeVgVZmVb^cVgVjc
bdidg^hiV]Zg^YdfjZ]VW†VYZggVeVYdhdWgZjcVeaVXVYZ
]^Zad#:heZg{WVbdhaVaaZ\VYVYZaX^gj_VcdYZ\jVgY^Vn?Z[[
bZXdci‹VXZgXVYZjcVC9:fjZ‚a]VW†Vk^k^YdajZ\dYZ
jcVXX^YZciZYZbdid#:heZgVWVfjZZahZb{[dgdXVbW^VgV
Va kZgYZ XjVcYd [jZ \daeZVYd edg YZig{h edg jc kZ]†Xjad
^bedh^WaZ YZ ^YZci^[^XVg Zc Za bdbZcid YZa ^beVXid# Hj
XjZged[jZaVcoVYdedgadhV^gZhncdXVn‹hdWgZaVXVaoVYV0
Va bZcdh Vh† Zh Xdbd ‚a eZgX^W^‹ aVh XdhVh Zc jc eg^bZg
bdbZcid# FjZY‹ YZiZc^Yd! Xdbd hjheZcY^Yd Zc Za V^gZ!
b^ZcigVhhjXjZged^cZgiZgZedhVWVZcaVXVggZiZgV#9ZhYZaV
edh^X^‹cZcfjZhZZcXdcigVWV!ejYd^YZci^[^XVgZakZ]†Xjad
fjZad]VW†VX]dXVYdk^daZciVbZciZ!kZgVabVaXdcYjXidg
WV_VgYZa;dgY;^ZhiVgd_d!iZbZgdhdYZfjZad]jW^ZgVbViVYd!
ejZh?Z[[iVbW^‚cZgVXVeVoYZVY^k^cVghjheZchVb^Zcidh!
nVh^hi^‹^bediZciZVaV[j\VYZZhiZkZgYVYZgd]db^X^YV#:a
]dbWgZ!eZchVcYdh‹adZch†b^hbd!]VW†VVWVcYdcVYdVhj
k†Xi^bVh^cegZhiVgaZZab†c^bdhdXdggd#EZgd!YZhej‚hYZYdh
bZhZhYZXdbV!ZabVaX]d[Zg[jZZcXdcigVYdnXdcYZcVYd
edgcdVh^hiZcX^V!\daeZhn]Zg^YVh^ckdajciVg^VhXdcYZa^id
YZ [j\V! ejZh ?Z[[ ]VW†V edY^Yd hZŠVaVg adh cbZgdh YZ
bVig†XjaVYZa;dgY#=ZVfj†jcVegjZWVhjeaZbZciVg^VfjZ
bjZhigV W^Zc fjZ aVh ZmeZg^ZcX^Vh YZ hVa^YV YZa XjZged
k^k^YVhYjgVciZaVhC9:cdhdcVajX^cVX^dcZh#
«9Œceh[WYY_edWhWdj[beiYWieiZ[YecW5
HdWgZidYdZhegZX^hdYZX^gVadheVg^ZciZhYZadhXdbVidhdh!
fjZZaadhcdhj[gZcnfjZ!VjcZcadhZhiVY^dhb{hVkVcoVYdh
YZ hj XdbV! ejZYZc eZgX^W^g! d†g n kZg hj Zcidgcd0 Zc
XdchZXjZcX^V!XjVafj^ZgVfjZhZVaV\gVkZYVYYZaXdbVcd
]VnejZhfjZVWVcYdcVgadhigVi{cYdadhXdbd¹]dgiVa^oVhº
XdbdYZh\gVX^VYVbZciZidYVk†V]VXZcYZbVh^VYdhYZb^h
XdaZ\Vh# Edg Za XdcigVg^d! ]VXZ [VaiV VWgVoVgadh! ]VWaVgaZh!
idXVgadh! ]VXZgaZh ZhXjX]Vg aVh bh^XVh fjZ aZh \jhiVWVc!
[^_Vg [didh hdWgZ aVh eVgZYZh YZ hj ]VW^iVX^‹c! bdhigVgaZh
fjZ hZ aZh fj^ZgZ Y{cYdaZh Vbdg# :beZgd! VbVgadh cd Zh
gZiZcZgadhZcaVi^ZggVVXjVafj^ZgegZX^d!nYZab^hbdbdYd
fjZadhb‚Y^XdhcdYZWZcXdbZiZgZmXZhdhiZgVe‚ji^Xdh!adh
eVg^ZciZhYZadhXdbVidhdhfjZZhi{cZcjcZhiVYdXa†c^Xd
YZhZheZgVYdYZWZcYZ_VgadheVgi^gZceVoh^cgZiZcZgadhXdc
aaVcidh d ZmegZhVcYd jcV eZcV Z\d†hiV0 Zh egZX^hd hVWZg
YZ_VgadheVgi^gZceVoXdgiVcYdZaXdgY‹cYZeaViVfjZaZh
gZi^ZcZidYVk†VZchjXjZgediZggZcVa#
:c Za .% YZ adh XVhdh! adh XdbVidhdh cd gZXjZgYVc
cVYV YZ hj ZmeZg^ZcX^V! eZgd Za &% YZ Zaadh ]V k^k^Yd
*+
Zc Za bdbZcid YZa XdbV jc bdbZcid bVgVk^aadhd! Xdc
eZgXZeX^dcZh bjn V\gVYVWaZh! h‹ad Za gZ\gZhd Zh Ydadgdhd
XjVcYdZaXjZgediZggZcVaZheZgX^W^YdcjZkVbZciZXdchjh
]Zg^YVhnhjhaZh^dcZh#
6a\jcdh XdbVidhdh ]Vc h^Yd XVeVXZh YZ k^hjVa^oVg! Xdc
jcV ZmigVdgY^cVg^V V\jYZoV! ZkZcidh gZVaZh fjZ hjXZY†Vc
Zc hj ]VW^iVX^‹c d iVbW^‚c V Y^hiVcX^V! n idYd Zhid Xdc
jcVVXi^k^YVYXZgZWgVaXVh^cjaV#:hidfj^ZgZYZX^gfjZaVh
[VXjaiVYZhXd\cdhX^i^kVhnhZchdg^VaZhhdcedh^WaZh[jZgVYZ
idYd [jcX^dcVb^Zcid XZgZWgVa cdgbVa n edg iVcid fjZ aV
XdcX^ZcX^VcdZh¹hZXgZiVYVºedgZaXZgZWgdXdbdaVW^a^hZh
hZXgZiVYVedgZa]†\VYd#
H^ aV XaVg^k^YZcX^V! aV egZXd\c^X^‹c n aV iZaZeVi†V hdc
[Zc‹bZcdh gZXjggZciZh Zc aVh C9:! n h^ adh XdbVidhdh d
adhZmeZg^ZcXZghi^ZcZcVkZXZhaV[VXjaiVYYZVY^k^cVg
adh eZchVb^Zcidh YZa gZVc^bVYdg fjZ Z[ZXiV hj bVhV_Z
XVgY^VXddYZaX^gj_VcdfjZadhdeZgV!Zh^\jVabZciZedh^WaZ
fjZadh[Zc‹bZcdhiZaZe{i^XdhhdWgZkZc\Vccdh‹adZcZa
hZci^YdhVcVYdg"eVX^ZciZ!h^cdiVbW^‚cVagZk‚h!ZhYZX^gYZa
eVX^ZciZ]VX^VZahVcVYdg#6h†!]ZiZc^YdeZghdcVabZciZ!n
gZeZi^YVhkZXZh!eZchVb^Zcidh^cYjX^YdhedgadhXdbVidhdh
fjZbZaaZkVcV]VXZgaVhXdhVhXdc[dgbZVhjh¹YZhZdhºZc
b^ai^bda^WgdYdnYdhZ_ZbeadhXVgVXiZg†hi^XdhYZZaad#
«Gkƒ[njhW[kij[ZZ[bYed]h[ieZ[CWhj_]k[i[d`kd_e
Z[(&&,5«L[kij[ZWbb‡kdWlWdY[i_]d_\_YWj_le[d[b
h[YedeY_c_[djeZ[bei^[Y^eifeh[bc[Z_eY_[dj‡\_Ye5
:a &, YZ _jc^d YZ '%%+! jcV _dkZc YZ '. VŠdh! Hdc^V
7Vg`VaaV]!ad\g‹jcVegdZoV[ZcdbZcVa/gZjc^gZcBVgi^\jZh
Vadhb{h\gVcYZhX^Zci†[^XdhbjcY^VaZhfjZ]VcigVWV_VYd
YZhYZ ]VXZ igZ^ciV VŠdh Zc aVh C9:! Xdc aV ZmXZeX^dcVa
eVgi^X^eVX^‹c YZ GVnbdcY BddYn! Za egZXjghdg YZ ZhiZ
ZmigVdgY^cVg^d[Zc‹bZcd#6ZhiZXdadfj^dVh^hi^Zgdc'#+%%
eZghdcVh!b^ZcigVhfjZZcdXijWgZeVhVYd!Zc=djhidcZc
::JJ!h‹adZhiVWVcegZhZciZh)%%eZghdcVheVgVVh^hi^gVjc
ZkZcidXdbeVgVWaZ#
6a [^cVa YZ ZhiZ Xdc\gZhd! ]jWd jc VhdbWgdhd XdchZchd
hdWgZigZhejcidh[jcYVbZciVaZh/
&:h edh^WaZ jc ZhiVYd YZ XdcX^ZcX^V XjVcYd Za XZgZWgd
YZ_VYZ[jcX^dcVgXdcegjZWVZaZXigdZcXZ[Vad\g{[^XVYZ
Vednd#
'=VhiV ]dn cd Zm^hiZ c^c\jcV Zmea^XVX^‹c X^Zci†[^XV
VXZeiVWaZ eVgV adh [Zc‹bZcdh YZ YZh^cXdgedgVX^‹c
k^k^YdhYjgVciZaVhZmeZg^ZcX^VhYZbjZgiZ^cb^cZciZ#
(AVhZmeZg^ZcX^VhYZYZh^cXdgedgVX^‹chdcedh^WaZh![jZgV
YZadhZhiVYdhYZbjZgiZ^cb^cZciZ#
:aeg^bZgejcidYZZhiZXdchZchdigVhidgcVYZiVabVcZgV
adh eVgVY^\bVh X^Zci†[^Xdh! fjZ aV ^c[dgbVX^‹c! fjZ h^c
ZbWVg\d]Vh^YdejWa^XVYVZcgZk^hiVhYZXdb^i‚YZaZXijgV
XdbdI]ZAVcXZidCVijgZ!ZcXjZcigVbjX]VhY^[^XjaiVYZh
eVgVedYZghZgY^[jcY^YV#
;dCWhj_]k[i"kij[ZYedeY_ŒWHWocedZCeeZo"gk_[d
Z_Y[j[d[hkdb_Xhe[dfh[fWhWY_ŒdZedZ[ZWh|[b\edZe
Z[ikf[diWc_[dje[dYedYbki_ed[iYbWhWiofh[Y_iWi$
«IWX[Wb]ec|iZ[[ije5Obk[]e"«Yk|b[iikef_d_Œd
ieXh[[ij[]hWdfh[Ykhieh5
IjkZZaeg^k^aZ\^dYZiZcZgjcVaVg\VY^hXjh^‹cXdcGVnbdcY
BddYn#HjZmeZg^ZcX^VaZ^cX^iVVhZgbjnegjYZciZZcaVh
XdcXajh^dcZhfjZY^[jcYZejZheVgZXZ]VWZghj[g^YdbjX]d
edg aVh WgdbVh hjhX^iVYVh edg hj ZmXZhd YZ Zcijh^Vhbd
XjVcYdaVejWa^XVX^‹cYZhja^WgdAVk^YVYZhej‚hYZaVk^YV!
]VXZ(%VŠdh#FjZY‹bjn^begZh^dcVYdedgaVVbea^ijYYZ
aVbVc^[ZhiVX^‹cYZa&,YZ_jc^dnedgZaadZmegZhVfjZYVg{
Zc;gVcX^VaVeg^b^X^VYZhjeg‹m^bVdWgV#
H^c YjYV Va\jcV! GVnbdcY BddYn hZ\j^g{ h^ZcYd aV
eZghdcVa^YVYfjZb{h]VbVgXVYdaV]^hidg^VYZaVhC9:!
]VWaVcYdnZhijY^VcYdYZeg^bZgdZhiVhZmeZg^ZcX^VhZcZa
jbWgVaYZaVbjZgiZ!eZgd!Xdbdad]VXZcdiVg!XdcbjX]V
_jhi^X^V! b^ XdaZ\V cdgiZVbZg^XVcd! Za YdXidg BVjg^XZ
Gdla^c\!XVgY^‹ad\dYZhjZhiVYd!GVnbdcYBddYnZhVciZ
idYdjc[^a‹hd[dfjZajZ\d]VaaZ\VYdVhZgb‚Y^Xdeh^fj^VigV!
eZgdZhiZ^ckZhi^\VYdgcjcXV]ViZc^YdaVdedgijc^YVYYZ
gZVc^bVgVVa\j^Zc#HZcX^aaVbZciZ]VgZXd\^YdVY^hiVcX^V
adhiZhi^bdc^dhYZadhZkZcidhk^k^YdhedgadhZmeZg^ZcXZgh
n cjcXV ]V iZc^Yd dXVh^‹c YZ dWhZgkVg edg h† b^hbd
adh [Zc‹bZcdh fjZ hZ YZhVggdaaVc Zc Za bdbZcid YZ aVh
gZVc^bVX^dcZhnfjZYZhXg^WdZcb^a^WgdXdbdedgZ_Zbead!
aVZmi^cX^‹cYZaV^cYZhXg^ei^WaZajoZcaVb^gVYVYZVfjZaadh
fjZ[VaaZXZcXjVcYdaVgZVc^bVX^‹c[VaaV#
«J_[d[kij[ZYedjWYjeYed?WdZi<hWdY_WeYed?WdZi
?dj[hdWj_edWb 5«;ij|kij[Z[d[ijWŒfj_YWZ[
_dl[ij_]WY_Œdej_[d[kdWjhWo[Yjeh_Wc|if[hiedWb5
AjZ\d YZ b^ WgZkZ ^ciZgkZcX^‹c Zc BVgi^\jZh gZaVi^kV V
aVhedh^W^a^YVYZhiZaZe{i^XVhZcadhXdbVidhdh!]ZgZX^W^Yd
bjX]dXdggZdYZZc[ZgbZgdhn]VhiVYZb‚Y^Xdh!fjZ]VW†Vc
iZc^YdZmeZg^ZcX^VhVc{ad\VhVaVb†V#IZc\deZchVYd]VXZg
jcZhijY^d[jijgdhdWgZZhiZ[Zc‹bZcd_jcidVb^hXdaZ\Vh
VcZhiZh^hiVh"gZVc^bVYdgZhWV_daV[dgbVYZjcXjZhi^dcVg^d
h^beaZfjZaZhhZg{egdejZhidYZab^hbdbdYdfjZad]^od
<gZnhdc ]VXZ jcdh VŠdh! eVgV ZkVajVg Za [Zc‹bZcd C9:#
Hda^X^i‚^ciZ\gVgZaZfj^edYZ>6C9H;gVcX^VeVgVaaZkVgV
W^Zc ZhiZ ZhijY^d! eZgd gZX]VoVgdc b^ XVcY^YVijgV ejZh!
hZ\c hjh eVaVWgVh! ZcXdcigVWVc b^ ^bV\Zc¹YZbVh^VYd
Zhdi‚g^XVºeVgVhZgVYb^i^YdZcigZZaadh#BZkdak†ZcidcXZh
]VX^V >6C9H Fj‚WZX! fjZ eVgZXZ b{h VW^Zgid! ejZh bZ
^ck^iVgdc V YVg jcV Xdc[ZgZcX^V Zc BdcigZVa Zc dXijWgZ
eg‹m^bd#9ZhZVc^\jVabZciZVnjYVgbZZcb^egdnZXidYZ
^ckZhi^\VX^‹cZcadhXdbVidhdh#
;djh[beif_ed[heide[hj[Wc[h_YWdeiCeeZo"C[bl_d
Cehi["A[dd[j^H_d]±"«^WoWb]‘df[hiedW`[
gk[^WoWWjhW‡Zec|iikWj[dY_Œdfeh
iki_dl[ij_]WY_ed[ioj[eh‡Wi5
9Z ]ZX]d! idYdh adh \gVcYZh e^dcZgdh cdgiZVbZg^XVcdh
fjZ hZ ]Vc ^ciZgZhVYd Zc aVh C9: bZgZXZc Za bVndg
gZheZid! ejZh ]Vc Zc[gZciVYd YZ [dgbV bjn kVa^ZciZ jc
iZbV XdbeaZiVbZciZ YZhVXgZY^iVYd edg aV Xdbjc^YVY
X^Zci†[^XV k†Xi^bV YZ Y^hdcVcX^V Xd\c^i^kV# AV Y^hdcVcX^V
Xd\c^i^kVZhjcYZhdgYZcYZa_j^X^dXdch^hiZciZZccZ\VgaV
Zm^hiZcX^VYZjc]ZX]ddYZjc[Zc‹bZcdfjZXdcigVY^XZ
aVh ^c[dgbVX^dcZh VXZeiVYVh# 6h†! eVgV aV bVndg†V YZ adh
X^Zci†[^Xdh!aVhZmeZg^ZcX^VhYZhVa^YVYZaXjZgeddYZbjZgiZ
^cb^cZciZ cd Zm^hiZc! VjcfjZ hdWgZ ZhiZ eaVcZiV ]VnV
bjX]VhYZXZcVhYZb^aadcZhYZZmeZg^ZcXZgh!ejZh]VhiV
Za bdbZcid cd Zm^hiZ c^c\jcV Zmea^XVX^‹c X^Zci†[^XV fjZ
d[gZXZg#EZgdcdhdchdaVbZciZadhX^Zci†[^XdhadhfjZhj[gZc
/(-2851$/63,5,7(1o$%5,/
*,
YZZhiVY^h[jcX^‹cYZagVodcVb^Zcid#9Zh\gVX^VYVbZciZ]Z
edY^YdXdbegdWVgfjZX^ZgidheZg^dY^hiVhYVWVcbjZhigVh
YZ Y^hdcVcX^V! Va c^kZa YZ hj hVWZg! XjVcYd hZ igViVWV YZ
]VWaVg YZa YZhej‚h YZ aV k^YV# EjYZ [dgbVg eVgiZ YZ aVh
XdcXajh^dcZhYZBVgi^\jZhZc\gVcYZhbZY^dhXdbd:jgdeV
&!;G(!GB8!ICInaVegZchV^ciZgcVX^dcVaeg^k^aZ\^‹WVhiVciZ
W^ZcaV^c[dgbVX^‹c!ZcXVbW^d;gVcX^V'egZ[^g^‹hjeg^b^g
b^ ZcigZk^hiV! fjZ YZW†V eVhVg Xdc aVh ^c[dgbVX^dcZh YZ
aVh'%/%%]dgVhegZiZmiVcYdjcVVkZg†VYZhdc^YdYjgVciZ
b^gZ\^higdneVhVcYdZcb^aj\VgVdigdb‚Y^Xd!fjZcd
Y^_dcVYVgZheZXidVZhZXdchZchd^cX‹bdYd!nXdcgVo‹c!
ejZh Za b‚Y^Xd Zc XjZhi^‹c «cd Zhijkd Zc BVgi^\jZh n
Zk^YZciZbZciZcdXdcdX†VZa[Zc‹bZcdC9:
7bb[[hb[i[eXi[hlWgk[kij[Z[ij|WX_[hjeWjeZWibWi
Z_iY_fb_dWiZ[befWhWdehcWb"j[b[fWj‡W"YbWh_l_Z[dY_W"
fh[ced_Y_ed[i±_dYbkie^WijWbWYeckd_YWY_Œd[if‡h_jW$
«F_[diWkij[Zgk[beij[ij_ced_eiZ[D:;WfehjWdkdW
Yed\_hcWY_ŒdWjeZeibeiZ[c|i\[dŒc[deifi‡gk_Yei5
;dejhWifWbWXhWi"«f_[diWgk[^WokdWi‡dj[i_iW
i[h[ijWXb[Y_ZW[djh[bWiZ_\[h[dj[i_dl[ij_]WY_ed[i
l_dYkbWZWiWbefWhWdehcWb5
8dbdhZejZYZaZZgZcb^a^Wgd!]ZiZc^Yddedgijc^YVYYZ
edYZgXdbjc^XVgbZXdcadhXdbVidhdheZgdiVbW^‚cXdc
[VaaZX^YdhXdbd8Vi]Zg^cZAVc\aVYZ!aVZhedhVYZhVeVgZX^YV
YZE]^a^eeZGV\jZcZVjnaVhZmeZg^ZcX^VhbZY^bc^XVhfjZ
]Z iZc^Yd cd ]Vc ]ZX]d h^cd Xdc[^gbVg b^ XZgiZoV YZ aV
Zm^hiZcX^VYZjcVk^YVYZhej‚hYZaVbjZgiZ#E^ZchdfjZad
eVgVcdgbVaYZ]dnhZg{adcdgbVaYZbVŠVcV!YZab^hbd
bdYd fjZ ad cdgbVa YZ ]dn [jZ ad eVgVcdgbVa YZ VnZg#
«=VXZbZcdhYZjch^\adfjZadhiZa‚[dcdhedgi{i^aZhdadh
WgVodh gdWdi^oVYdh XdbVcYVYdh edg Za XZgZWgd ZgVc YZa
Ydb^c^dYZadeVgVcdgbVaIdYdZhY^[ZgZciZ]dnZcY†V#Jc
Y†VaaZ\Vg{ZcfjZaVhXdbjc^XVX^dcZhXdcZab{hVaa{hZg{c
XdbjcZh! eZgd fjZYV idYVk†V bjX]d igVWV_d fjZ ]VXZg
VciZhYZaaZ\VgVZhd#
«;ikij[ZfWhj_ZWh_eZ[bWj[i_iZ[bWh[[dYWhdWY_Œd5O
ieXh[[ij[fkdje"«gkƒf_[diWZ[bjhWXW`e
Z[?WdIj[l[diedieXh[beid_‹eigk[h[Yk[hZWd
ik‘bj_cWl_ZW5
B^cdkZaV/9Zgg^ƒgZaVajb^ƒgZ9Zig{hYZaVajoYZbjZhigV
W^Zc fjZ hdn eVgi^YVg^d YZ aV iZh^h YZ aV gZZcXVgcVX^‹c#
6jcfjZ ZhiV ]^e‹iZh^h cd Zhi‚ YZbdhigVYV YZ bVcZgV
[dgbVa! eVgV b† Zh Zk^YZciZ ^cij^i^kVbZciZ n! Zc Z[ZXid!
adh igVWV_dh YZ >Vc HiZkZchdc Vg\jbZciVc ZhiV iZdg†V
YZ bVcZgV ^begZh^dcVciZ# :c digd XVbed! Za eh^fj^VigV
cdgiZVbZg^XVcd!ZaYdXidg7g^VcLZ^hhhZh^gkZYZaVhiZdg†Vh
YZ aV gZZcXVgcVX^‹c eVgV igViVg V hjh eVX^ZciZh# 8jgV aVh
[dW^Vh n adh igVhidgcdh YZ XdbedgiVb^Zcid WjhXVcYd Za
igVjbVi^hbd ^c^X^Va! cd Zc aV eg^bZgV ^c[VcX^V Xdbd ad
]VXZZaeh^XdVc{a^h^h[gZjY^Vcd!h^cdZcaVhk^YVhVciZg^dgZh
]VX^ZcYdgZ\gZhVgVhjheVX^ZciZhWV_d]^ecdh^h!nXdch^\jZ
ZmXZaZciZhgZhjaiVYdh#
:cadfjZVb†XdcX^ZgcZ!XgZd]VWZgk^k^YdnVjcVk^YVZc
i^ZbedhYZadhX{iVgdhejZhYZhYZaVZYVYYZ+VŠdh!eZY†V
b^heVYgZhfjZbZaaZkVgVcVBdcih‚\jg!aj\Vgeg^k^aZ\^VYd
YZaXViVg^hbd!h^cfjZVaeVgZXZgcjcXV]jW^ZgVZhXjX]VYd
/(-2851$/63,5,7(1o$%5,/
egdcjcX^VgZhZcdbWgZ!Z^ch^hi†iVcidfjZbZaaZkVgdcVaa{
VjcfjZZaaj\VgZhijk^ZgVh^ijVYdVb{hYZjcY†VZcVjidYZ
aVXVhV[Vb^a^Vg#=dn!k^kd[gZciZVaXVhi^aadYZBdcih‚\jgn
ZmeZg^bZcidjc[dgb^YVWaZW^ZcZhiVgZcXjVcidaaZ\dXZgXV
YZ ZhZ h^i^d bjn XVg\VYd YZ ZcZg\†V k^WgVidg^V# Hdn bjn
hZch^WaZVX^ZgidhZaZbZcidh¸XdbdadhWdhfjZh!aVhe^ZYgVh!
adh bZc]^gZh! adh Y‹abZcZh d X^ZgiVh gj^cVh bZY^ZkVaZh¸
fjZbZeZgb^iZcgZ\ZcZgVgbZg{e^YVbZciZVhjXdciVXid
ne^ZchdfjZadfjZh^ZcidZhi‚ZcZhigZX]VgZaVX^‹cXdcjc
aZ_VcdeVhVYd!ZciZggVYdZcZa[dcYdYZb^bZbdg^V#
«;dikef_d_Œd"bWY_[dY_W[ij|[dfheY[ieZ[[lebkY_Œd
e"Z_Y^eZ[ejhWcWd[hW"Z[fbWdj[Whi[\_dWbc[dj[bWi
]hWdZ[ifh[]kdjWic[jW\‡i_YWi5Begk[gk_p|ioWfk[Z[
kij[Zc[Z_h[dikfhef_ec[Z_e"[bZ[bWc[Z_Y_dW±
AVhX^ZcX^Vh!aVbZY^X^cV!aVhgZa^\^dcZhi^ZcZcaVZc[VYdhV
iZcYZcX^VYZfjZgZgZkdajX^dcVgV^haVYVbZciZ!aZkVciVcYd
WVgg^XVYVh Zc aVh XZgiZoVh YZ hjh Yd\bVh# N Zhid Zh
eVgi^XjaVgbZciZ X^Zgid eVgV aV bZY^X^cV igVY^X^dcVa fjZ
Zh jcV bZY^X^cV h^cidb{i^XV! fjZ VXiV XjVcYd Zh XVh^
YZbVh^VYd iVgYZ! Zh YZX^g! XjVcYd aV Zc[ZgbZYVY nV
Zhi{ ^chiVaVYV n fjZ! edg [VaiV YZ ]jb^aYVY! YZhegZX^V
egd[jcYVbZciZaVhbZY^X^cVhaaVbVYVh¹eVgVaZaVhºfjZh^c
ZbWVg\dhVWZciZcZgjcVk^h^‹cb{h]da†hi^XVYZa^cY^k^Yjd!
VXijVcYdhdWgZaVZc[ZgbZYVY!VciZhYZfjZhZ^chiVaZcadh
YZh‹gYZcZh#H^jhiZYaZegZ\jciVVjcb‚Y^Xdfj‚e^ZchV
YZaVk^YVnYZaVbjZgiZ!ZhjcedXdXdbdh^aZegZ\jciVgV
V jc gZad_Zgd ad fjZ e^ZchV hdWgZ Za i^Zbed# :a ¹i‚Xc^Xd
YZa i^Zbedº aZ gZhedcYZg{ fjZ ‚hiZ hZ YZhXdbedcZ Zc
]dgVh!b^cjidhnhZ\jcYdh!fjZhZb^YZXdcaVheZfjZŠVh
gjZYVhYZciVYVhdXdcaVhk^WgVX^dcZhYZaXjVgod!eZgdcd
^g{bjX]db{haZ_dh#9ZaVb^hbVbVcZgV!Zab‚Y^XdfjZ
Xdc YZbVh^VYV [gZXjZcX^V hZ XdbedgiV Xdbd jc h^beaZ
¹i‚Xc^XdYZaVk^YVº!aZY^g{fjZaVbjZgiZZhaVYZiZcX^‹c
W^da‹\^XV YZa [jcX^dcVb^Zcid XZajaVg n fjZ hj eVeZa hZ
a^b^iV V gZigVhVg ad b{h edh^WaZ ZhZ [Vi†Y^Xd kZcX^b^Zcid#
H^VXVhd!ZagZhid!idYdZagZhid!cdaZXdcX^ZgcZ#«Fj‚Zggdg
:hidcdZhbjn^ciZa^\ZciZ#
«O:_ei[djeZe[ije5;bWceh"[beZ_e"bWcWhY^WZ[b
ckdZe±«9k|b[iiki[dj_c_[dje5
6XijVabZciZeVgZXZcZm^hi^gYdhZkdajX^dcZhdejZhiVhnXVh^
XdcigVY^Xidg^VhfjZ\j†VcZaedgkZc^gYZidYVaV]jbVc^YVY#
EdgjcaVYd!Zc[dgbVZk^YZciZ!ZaZXdh^hiZbVYZcjZhigd
eaVcZiV Zhi{ Zc eZa^\gd ^cb^cZciZ Xdc jc g^Zh\d k^iVa
XdbegdbZi^YdVbjnXdgideaVod#NedgZadigd!eVgZXZg†V
fjZ aVh Xdgg^ZciZh YZ eZchVb^Zcid gZa^\^dhVh! X^Zci†[^XVh
n [^adh‹[^XVh [^cVabZciZ hZ gZcZc! YZhej‚h YZ ]VWZghZ
XdbWVi^Yd V bjZgiZ YjgVciZ b^aZc^dh eVgV hj\Zg^g Zc jc
^bejahdXdbcaVZm^hiZcX^VYZjcVZiZgcVhjeZgk^kZcX^V#
Fj^ZgV 9^dh! fjZ aV hVW^Yjg†V YZ adh ]dbWgZh egZkVaZoXV
hdWgZhjhadXjgVhYZhigjXidgVheVgVZk^iVgadeZdgnadh\j†Z
VidYdh_jcidhedgZaXVb^cdYZaVbdg#
:meZg^ZcXZg/EZghdcVfjZ]Vk^k^YdjcVC9:
>VcYh/ 6hdX^VX^‹c >ciZgcVX^dcVa eVgV Za ZhijY^d YZ adh
ZhiVYdhXZgXVcdhVaVbjZgiZ#
*-
)2580685/(1(7
/(&(5&/('³26/21259€*(
AZ h^iZ Yj XZgXaZ6aaVc @VgYZX lll#he^g^i^hbZ#Xdb
egdedhZ Y^[[‚gZciZh gjWg^fjZh Y¼^c[dgbVi^dc Zi YZ
kZciZZca^\cZYZhdjkgV\ZhZigZkjZhYZa¼VhhdX^V"
i^dc#JcZcdjkZaaZgjWg^fjZ®;dgjb¯V‚i‚^chiVa"
a‚ZhjgaZh^iZV[^cY¼‚iVWa^gjcZheVXZYZY^Vad\jZ
hjeea‚bZciV^gZ# 8Z [dgjb YZ Y^hXjhh^dc ^ci^ija‚
®6j"YZa|YZhbdih¯!eZgbZiVjm^ciZgcVjiZhYZ
edhZgidjiZhaZjghfjZhi^dch0aZhg‚edchZhhdci
‚aVWdg‚ZhZib^hZhZceaVXZYVchjcY‚aV^Y¼Zc"
k^gdcjcZhZbV^cZ#
Cdh Vb^h he^g^iZh Da^k^Zg ZiKVa‚g^Z ;VjkZa hZ hdci
^chiVaa‚h | Dhad d‘ ^ah ZmZgXZci Zc fjVa^i‚ YZ
egd[ZhhZjgh YZ [gVcV^h# >ah VhhjgZci aV Xg‚Vi^dc Yj
XZgXaZ6aaVc@VgYZXYZCdgkƒ\Z
|=Z\\Za^WV``Zc*$%(,*DHAD
I‚a/%%),'').'&+&
Z"bV^a/[Vda^5dca^cZ#cd
/(&(5&/('(728/286(
AV gZeg‚hZciVi^dc idjadjhV^cZ Yj 8ZgXaZ 6aaVc
@VgYZXhZY‚kZadeeZhdjhaVgZhedchVW^a^i‚Y:i^ZccZ
7Zgi]Vji Zi YZK‚gdc^fjZ E^aVid# 9Vch XZiiZ XVe^"
iVaZ g‚\^dcVaZ Yj HjY YZ aV ;gVcXZ! aZ he^g^i^hbZ V
Y‚hdgbV^hjcZkgV^ZgZeg‚hZciVi^dcfj^eZgbZiVjm
eZghdccZh ^ci‚gZhh‚Zh YVhh^hiZg Vjm Xdc[‚gZcXZh
ig^bZhig^ZaaZh dg\Vc^h‚Zh |IdjadjhZ Zi YZ egZcYgZ
XdciVXiVkZXaZhgZhedchVWaZh#
EdjgidjigZchZ^\cZbZci/
:i^ZccZ7Zgi]VjiZiK‚gdc^fjZE^aVid
7}i^bZci;Vci^cAVidjg"6eeVgiZbZcic•&)
&&&!gjZYZhIgdƒcZh
(&'%%IDJADJH:
I‚a/%*())'%-%'
Z"bV^a/
Zi^ZccZ#WZgi]Vji5aVedhiZ#cZi
lll#he^g^i^hbZ"idjadjhZ#Xdb
3(50$1(1&('8&(5&/('(1$1&<
6[^c YZ g‚edcYgZ Vjm c‚XZhh^i‚h Y¼jcZ WdccZ
^c[dgbVi^dc! aZ XZgXaZ YZ CVcXn i^Zci jcZ
eZgbVcZcXZ|hdcadXVaYZHV^ci"BVmaZhhVbZY^h
YZ&)]%%|&-]%%#
H^kdjhhdj]V^iZoegZcYgZXdciVXiZigZcXdcigZgjc
gZhedchVWaZhVchgZcYZo"kdjh!h^kdjhkdjaZokdjh
egdXjgZga^kgZhZigZkjZh!h^kdjhVkZoh^beaZbZci
WZhd^cY¼jcgZchZ^\cZbZcieVgi‚a‚e]dcZ!egd[^iZo
YZ cdigZ eZgbVcZcXZ Yj hVbZY^ Vegƒh"b^Y^! YZ
&)]%%|&-]%%/
,.!gjZ<VbWZiiV"G‚h^YZcXZAZh8]VjbZiiZh
7adX8!Zcig‚Z'
*)&(%H6>CI"B6M
AVhdccZiiZZhiVjcdbYZE^ZghVci^
I‚a/%(-('&'-)*
Jekj[ib[ifWhkj_ediZk9[hYb[
iedjZ_ifed_Xb[i
WkbeYWbZ[f[hcWd[dY[$
&(//8/('
,17(59(17,21'(63+120€1(63$5$1250$8;
Febj[h][_ij"^Wdj_i[i"f^ƒdec„d[iifedjWdƒi_d[nfb_gkƒi$Leki…j[ijƒce_dZ[f^ƒdec„d[i
_d[nfb_YWXb[igk_f[hjkhX[djlejh[[n_ij[dY[$Lekif[di[pgk_biW]_jZ[^Wdj_i[ifhel[dWdjZ[
bWkjh[cedZ[$Kd]hekf[Z[if_h_j[ii[fhefei[ZƒjkZ_[hlejh[jƒce_]dW][$<W_j[ikdhƒY_j
YbW_h[jfhƒY_i$:WdibWc[ikh[Z[i[iYeddW_iiWdY[i[jZ[i[ifeii_X_b_jƒi"b[]hekf[ZƒjkZ[
lekiWffehj[hWZ[i[nfb_YWj_edi[jbW_Z[dƒY[iiW_h[}bWiebkj_edZkfheXb„c[$
;dleo[plejh[jƒce_]dW][}CWh_[#De†bb[9ekhj_eb
."hk[Zk=hWdZFWhY#+*+(&B7NEK$
Jƒb0&).)/,,('+
BkdZ_"cWhZ_"`[kZ_"l[dZh[Z_0Wfh„i'.^c[hYh[Z_[jm[[a#[dZ0jekj[bW`ekhdƒ[$
;dYWiZ½WXi[dY[bW_ii[hkdc[iiW][ikhhƒfedZ[kh_dZ_gkWdjleiYeehZeddƒ[i$
;#cW_b0Dede'()X_i6ehWd][$\h
1289($8
$GHVWLQDWLRQGHVDYHXJOHVHWPDOYR\DQWV
/³DVVRFLDWLRQ9DOHQWLQ+D¯\$9+SURSRVHHQYHUVLRQDXGLR/HOLYUHGHVHVSULWV
G³$OODQ.DUGHFGLWHQFDVVHWWHVGHPLQXWHV
5HQVHLJQHPHQWV$9+UXH'XURF3DULVFHGH[
7O)D[
KWWSZZZDYKDVVRIUHPDLODYK#DYKDVVRIU
/(-2851$/63,5,7(1o$%5,/
/(-2851$/63,5,7(
:WdY_[dd[ih[lk[iiedj[dYeh[Z_ifed_Xb[i"Zedjle_Y_b[ifh_dY_fWknj^„c[iWXehZƒi$B[idkcƒheicWhgkƒi
ZkdWijƒh_igk[ \edjbeX`[jZkd[fhecej_ed$7dY_[didkcƒheiƒfk_iƒi0d–'}d–'*[jd–'&*AZXideaVhb^Z"AZhbV^hdch]Vci‚Zh"AVb‚Y^jbc^i‚Vgi^hi^fjZ
":migV^ihYZY^Vad\jZhVkZXYZhZheg^ih
&+AVeajgVa^i‚YZhbdcYZh]VW^i‚h"AZhZc[VcihegdY^\Zh"9dhh^Zg/
A¼‚iViYZa¼Zheg^iVj"YZa|YZaVbdgi"6eedgih!bVi‚g^Va^hVi^dch
&- AZh b^gVXaZh YZ AdjgYZh " A¼]^hid^gZ Yj 8ZgXaZ ' " 9dhh^Zg/
HdbbZh"cdjhaZXZcigZYZa¼jc^kZgh4"A‚\ZcYZhZibnhiƒgZhY‚kd^"
a‚h"6j\jhi^cAZhV\Z#
&. B‚Y^jbc^i‚/ aZ Y‚kZadeeZbZci b‚Y^jbc^fjZ " A¼]^hid^gZ Yj
8ZgXaZ6aaVc@VgYZX("6jm\gVcYh]dbbZh!aZhe^g^i^hbZgZXdccV^h"
hVci"AZ\j^YZ/bni]Zdjg‚Va^i‚
'%;VcibZhY¼:XdhhZ"AVe]did\gVe]^ZigVchXZcYZciVaZ"A¼]^hid^gZ
Yj8ZgXaZ6aaVc@VgYZX)":a‚e]VciBVc":Y\Vg8VnXZ"GdhZbVgn
7gdlc
'&AZhhiVghZceVgaZci"AVfjVig^ƒbZY^bZch^dc
A¼]^hid^gZYj8ZgXaZ6aaVc@VgYZX"*":jhVe^VEVaVY^cdEVYgZE^d/jc
b‚Y^jbVjX¶jgYZa¼‚\a^hZ
''He^g^i^hbZZieda^i^fjZ"AVM‚cd\adhh^Z
A¼]^hid^gZ Yj 8ZgXaZ6aaVc @VgYZX + " H^hh^ he^g^iZ " EVYgZ E^d/ jc
b‚Y^jbVjX¶jgYZa¼‚\a^hZ'ZeVgi^Z
'(B‚Y^Vh0_¼nXgd^h!_¼nXgd^heVh"A¼]^hid^gZYj8ZgXaZ,"EdgigV^i/
:a‚dcdgZ E^eZg " I‚bd^\cV\Zh eVhh‚h/ aZ [VcibZ YZh k^kVcih "
8dggZhedcYVcXZhXgd^h‚Zh
') BVm :gchi Zi a¼‚c^\bZ YZ a¼6g^odcV " A¼]^hid^gZ Yj 8ZgXaZ6aaVc
@VgYZX-"Adj^h>>YZ7Vk^ƒgZ‚iV^i"^ab‚Y^jb4";dgjbh|CVcXn
Zi7ZhVcdc"AVXdbWjhi^dchedciVc‚Z
'*:cigZi^ZcVkZXaZegd[ZhhZjg?ZVc9^Zg`Zch
A¼]^hid^gZ Yj 8ZgXaZ6aaVc @VgYZX". " AV k^Z Zi a¼¶jkgZ YZ <VWg^Za
9ZaVccZ"AZN‚i^!bni]Zdjg‚Va^i‚
'+K^Xidg =j\d he^g^iZ " AV g‚^cXVgcVi^dc " AZ bVˆigZ E]^a^eeZ YZ
Andc"9Vc^Za9jc\aVh=dbZ!jcb‚Y^jbZmigVdgY^cV^gZ"AZYdXiZjg
<jhiVkZ<ZaZn
', :cigZi^Zc VkZX ?ZVc"E^ZggZ <^gVgY " AV XViVhigde]Z Yj G&%& "
L^aa^Vb8gdd`Zh"AZYdXiZjgEVejh"AVk^ZYZhZheg^ihYVcha¼Vj"YZa|
"BVii]ZlBVcc^c\!hdc]^hid^gZ
'- AZ hdbcVbWja^hbZ cVijgZa " :cigZi^Zc VkZX <Vhidc 9ZWZkZg
"AZhe^g^i^hbZ[VXZ|aVhX^ZcXZHe^g^i^hbZZigZa^\^dc"AVbjh^fjZYZ
a¼^ck^h^WaZ8]VgaZhG^X]Zi
'.AZbV\c‚i^hbZ!jcZ‚cZg\^ZY¼VkZc^g
:cigZi^Zc VkZX BVg^Z"8VeYZXdbbZ " AZh e]^adhde]Zh " FjVcY aZh
h^gƒcZh[dcihjg[VXZ"GZcXdcigZhe^g^iZ!|egdedhYj7g‚h^a
(%8Zai^hbZZiYgj^Y^hbZ"A¼]dbbZZiaVW„iZ
AZcZl"V\ZdjaZWg^X"|"WgVXhe^g^ijZa"A¼VgX]^iZXijgZZiaZhdcYZhYZ
[dgbZh"?ZVc"BVg^ZK^VccZn!Xjg‚Y¼6gh!b‚Y^jb#
(& 9dhh^Zg/ AZ g„kZ " AZ h^m^ƒbZ hZch " 8¼Zhi fjd^ aZ he^g^i^hbZ4
" =^hid^gZ Yj bV\c‚i^hbZ Zi YZ hZh eg‚XjghZjgh " H^g6gi]jg 8dcVc
9dnaZ
('AZha‚\ZcYZhhdci"ZaaZhjcZg‚Va^i‚"/aZhZheg^ihg‚edcYZci"6egd"
edhYZaVbdcY^Va^hVi^dc"AVgV^Z\‚VciZ"K^ZZia‚\ZcYZYZ7djYY]V
"6aX]^b^Z!aZ\gVcYhZXgZi
(( BV^hdch ]Vci‚Zh Zi [VcibZh " A¼ZmegZhh^dc Vgi^hi^fjZ YZ a¼Vj"
YZa|"?jhi^XZZieZ^cZYZbdgiA¼‚aZXigdc!jcZeVgi^XjaZY^k^h^WaZZi
^ciZaa^\ZciZAVg‚^cXVgcVi^dc
()E]‚cdbƒcZhDKC>H"AZhZXgZiYZ;Vi^bVAZh[dgXZhYZaVeZc"
h‚Z"AVk^ZYZCdhigVYVbjh"AZEƒgZAVX]V^hZ"AVehnX]db‚ig^Z
(* A¼^cfj^h^i^dc Y¼]^Zg Zi Y¼Vj_djgY¼]j^ GZcXdcigZh he^g^iZh Vj
K‚c‚oj‚aV " A¼VidbZ he^g^ijZa " ?ZVc BZnZg! aZ W^Zc[V^iZjg Yj he^g^"
i^hbZ
(+AZhVgi^hiZhYZaVj"YZa|"?ZVccZ96gXV"i"ZaaZ‚i‚Wg’a‚Z4"AZh
bVaVY^ZhbZciVaZh|igVkZgha]^hid^gZ"AVXdbWjhi^dchedciVc‚Z"AV
ehnX]db‚ig^Z
(,A¼>B>!>chi^ijiB‚iVehnX]^fjZ>ciZgcVi^dcVaEg‚bdc^i^dchZiegZh"
hZci^bZcih"AZ[VcibZYZhk^kVcihY‚bdcigZa¼Zm^hiZcXZYZa¼}bZ
A¼ZXideaVhb^Z
(-AZ7g‚h^a!jcZiZggZYZhe^g^ijVa^i‚"CVeda‚dcV"i"^a‚i‚Zbed^"
hdcc‚4"KdnV\ZZcGdjbVc^Z=^hid^gZYZXdbƒiZh"Ed‚h^Zhe^g^iZ
(.8]g^hi^Vc^hbZZihe^g^i^hbZ":cigZi^Zc|egdedhYZaVXaV^gkdnVcXZ
/(-2851$/63,5,7(1o$%5,/
"AZkdnV\ZVhigVa"AV[V^bYVchaZbdcYZ"Ed‚h^Zhe^g^iZ
)% AZh \gVcYZh ‚c^\bZh Yj bdcYZ " AV b‚Y^jbc^i‚ deeg^b‚Z "
:cigZi^ZcVkZX@Vg^cZ8]ViZ^\cZgAVb‚i]dYZ8dj‚dja¼^bV\^cVi^dc
Vjedjkd^g
)& BV\c‚i^hZjgh Zi <j‚g^hZjgh "6 egdedh YZh \gZ[[Zh " :cigZi^Zc
VkZX6Yg^ZcE^ZghVci^a¼=necdhZEd‚h^Zhhe^g^iZh
)'9dhh^Zg/ aV g‚^cXVgcVi^dc " :cigZi^Zc VkZXK^g\^a! bV\c‚i^hZjg Zi
]necdi^hZjg he^g^iZ :me‚g^ZcXZh YZ ehnX]db‚ig^Z " AV hXa‚gdhZ Zc
eaVfjZ
)(9dhh^Zg/aVXaV^gkdnVcXZ"EZji"dceg‚Y^gZa¼VkZc^g4"B‚Y^VhZi
eVgVcdgbVa"I‚a‚eVi]^ZEhnX]db‚ig^Z"CVeda‚dc>>>ZiaZhe^g^i^hbZ
EZ^cZYZbdgi#
)) 9dhh^Zg/ aV b‚Y^jbc^i‚ " GVhedji^cZ! aZ bd^cZ VkZcijg^Zg "
:cigZi^ZcVkZX7ZgcVYZiiZ8]ZkVaaZn/aZbV\c‚i^hbZhjgaZhVc^bVjm
"A¼:\neiZ#
)*9dhh^Zg/aZe]‚cdbƒcZDKC>"AZhbVaVY^ZhdjWa^‚Zh":cigZi^Zc
VkZXBVg^Z"Cd…aaZ8djgi^da"AVe]nidi]‚gVe^Zhe^g^iZ"EdgigV^i/BƒgZ
I‚g‚hV
)+9dhh^Zg/AZh[VcibZh"AZb‚Y^jb?ZVc<jh^`"EhnX]db‚ig^Z
"H^\bjcY;gZjY"AVg‚^cXVgcVi^dcCdc|aVeZ^cZYZbdgi"AVigd^"
h^ƒbZg‚k‚aVi^dc#
),9dhh^Zg/aZh[dgXZhYZaVeZch‚Z"8aV^gkdnVcXZhjgk^ZhVci‚g^ZjgZh
"AVk^ZYZ<VWg^Za9ZaVccZ&ƒgZeVgi^Z"G‚[aZm^dchjgaZhg„kZh#
)- 9dhh^Zg/ aZh eg‚XjghZjgh Yj he^g^i^hbZ " >ciZgk^Zl YZ GdhZbVgn
7gdlc"Hd^chbV\c‚i^fjZh/i‚bd^\cV\Zh"K^daZcXZZig‚egZhh^dc
). 9dhh^Zg/ C9:! :me‚g^ZcXZ YZ bdgi ^bb^cZciZ " AZ k^hV\Z Yj
bdcYZ":heg^ihZihZci^bZcih"Gj[^cVCdZ\\ZgVi]"AZhegdeg^‚i‚h
Yje‚g^heg^i
*%9dhh^Zg/:igZhe^g^iZVj_djgY¼]j^"8]^XdMVk^Zg!b‚Y^jb"8gd^hZi!
XaV^gkdnVci"BVc^ejaVi^dch\‚c‚i^fjZh/AZXadcV\Z#
*&9dhh^Zg/AZhXdchigjXi^dch‚cn\bVi^fjZh":cigZi^ZcVkZX@Vg^cZ
hjg¹AZCdjkZVjA^kgZYZh:heg^ihº"A¼VgiY¼]^ZgZiY¼Vj_djgY¼]j^"AZh
eaj^ZhY¼Vc^bVjm":cfj„iZhjgaZbdcYZ^ck^h^WaZ
*'9dhh^Zg/EVgVcdgbVaZiX^c‚bV"6egdedhYjhZci^bZcigZa^\^Zjm
"I‚a‚eVi]^Z/aZehnX]^hbZk‚\‚iVa"AZhbdchigZhbVg^ch"AZhhe]ƒgZh
Yj8dhiVG^XV":cfj„iZYZadc\‚k^i‚
*( 9dhh^Zg/6aaVc @VgYZX! aZ [dcYViZjg Yj he^g^i^hbZ " HX^ZcXZ/ AZh
bVaVY^ZhYZa¼Vci‚g^dg^i‚"=^hid^gZ/AZbjh‚ZYjhe^g^i^hbZ":igVc\Z/
AZ XdcXZgi YZ ?ZVc Gdb^Zg " AZXijgZh XdchZ^aa‚Zh/ AZh XZgXaZh YVch
aZhWa‚h
*) 9dhh^Zg/ AZ he^g^i^hbZ Zi aV hX^ZcXZ " AV _ZjcZ [^aaZ ‚aZXig^fjZ
" :cigZi^Zc"VkZX ?d…a ;gVcX]ZiZVj hjg aV ehnX]d`^c‚h^Z " :g^X GVjaZi!
X]ZgX]Zjg[gVcV^h"FjVcYaZhe^g^i^hbZYdccZjcYgd^iYZg‚edchZ
"=^hid^gZhbV\^fjZhYZa¼]^hid^gZYZ;gVcXZ"#
** 9dhh^Zg/ He^g^i^hbZ Zi b‚YZX^cZ " 9^heVg^i^dc eVgi^ZaaZ Y¼jc
b‚Y^jb"OddbhjgaVbV_dg^i‚h^aZcX^ZjhZ"AVk^ZYZCdhigVYVbjh
"AZYgj^Y^hbZ"EVYg‚E^d!jcb‚Y^jbYZkZcjhV^ci":cfj„iZhjgaZ
bdcYZ^ck^h^WaZ
*+ 9dhh^Zg/ AV fjVig^ƒbZ Y^bZch^dc " :cigZi^Zc hjg aV ed‚h^Z VkZX
>\dgBVcdjX]^Vc"A‚dcVgYYZK^cX^!a¼‚i^cXZaaZYj\‚c^Z"Oddbhjg
aVbV_dg^i‚h^aZcX^ZjhZ/AZh[ZbbZheg^mCdWZa"AVhVci‚]da^hi^fjZ
":medh^i^dcYZhXjaeijgZhb‚Y^jbc^fjZhZc6c\aZiZggZ#
*,9dhh^Zg/AVb‚Y^jbc^i‚Vj[‚b^c^c"HXjaeijgZhb‚Y^jbc^fjZh
|B^X]Za]VbEg^dgn"OddbhjgaVbV_dg^i‚h^aZcX^ZjhZ/AZh[ZbbZh
eg^mCdWZa'"AZhe^g^i^hbZZiaVaV‰X^i‚
*- 9dhh^Zg/ 7^XZciZcV^gZ YZ aV CV^hhVcXZ Y¼6aaVc @VgYZX " AV m‚cd"
\adhh^Z " <Zdg\Z HVcY " AV XdchX^ZcXZ " :cigZi^Zc/ AZ XZgXaZ6aaVc
@VgYZXV(%Vch"JcZbV^hdc]Vci‚ZZcAdggV^cZ"8gdeX^gXaZhZc
>iVa^Z
*.9dhh^Zg/6kdch"cdjheajh^Zjghk^Zh4/aVg‚^cXVgcVi^dc"E]‚cdbƒcZh
^cZmea^fj‚hZcH^X^aZ":me‚g^ZcXZYZehnX]db‚ig^Z";dgjb|Dhad
He^g^i^hbZZihdX^‚i‚
+%9dhh^Zg/AVk^ZYZhZheg^ihYVcha¼Vj"YZa|#":a^hVWZi]@jWaZg"Gdhh!
djaZhYZgc^Zgh^chiVcihYZaVk^Z"EVhXVa;dgijcnZiaVXaV^gkdnVcXZ
"AVgV^hdcYZaVY‚gV^hdc
+&9dhh^Zg/AZhVgi^hiZhb‚Y^jbh"8ZciZcV^gZYZaVbdgiYZAdj^hZ
*.
+% B^X]Za"²Y‚Xdjkg^g/Ajc^kZghY:Y\Vg8VnXZh
++9dhh^Zg/AVehnX]db‚ig^Z"AZhdbcVbWja^hbZcVijgZaZibV\c‚"
i^fjZ":B>"C9:!jcZcdjkZaaZdg^ZciVi^dc";dj^aaZhVgX]‚dad\^fjZ
Y^g^\‚ZhYZej^haVj"YZa|"AZWdc]ZjgZhi"^ajide^fjZ4";Vji"^aidj"
_djghXgd^gZZcJg^<ZaaZg4
+, 9dhh^Zg/ AZ \j^YZ " =dbbV\Z he^g^iZ/ 6j gZkd^g H‚\daƒcZ "
A^cXgdnVWaZXaV^gkdnVciZiehnX]dbƒigZEZiZg=jg`dh"AZhIZbea^Zgh
| aV ajb^ƒgZ Yj he^g^i^hbZ " :hXaVkV\Z! Xdadc^Va^hbZ! aZ eVhh‚ cZhi
YdcX_VbV^hbdgi4"Ed‚h^Zhhe^g^iZh#
+' 9dhh^Zg/ FjZhi"XZ fjjc b‚Y^jb4 " 8aV^gkdnVcih X‚aƒWgZh/
<‚gVgY8gd^hZiZiBVYVbZ;gVnV"²Y‚Xdjkg^g/HZXgZihZia‚\ZcYZh
YZaV;gVcXZbnhi‚g^ZjhZ"I‚bd^\cV\Zhe^g^iZ
+(9dhh^Zg/He^g^i^hbZZihdX^‚i‚":cigZi^ZcVkZX@Vg^cZ8]ViZ^\cZg
"6ciZccZhe^g^iZYZCdgkƒ\Z/;dgjbVaiZgcVi^[Dhad'%%*"Ed‚h^Zh
he^g^iZh
+)9dhh^Zg/AVXaV^gkdnVcXZ"AZhg„kZhX‚aƒWgZhYZa¼]^hid^gZ">a‚iV^i
jcZ[d^h°!jcZ]^hid^gZkgV^Z"AZg„kZ"AZhegZjkZhYZaVhjgk^Z#
+* 9dhh^Zg/ BVi‚g^Va^hVi^dc Zi ZXideaVhb^Z " Dg^\^c6gi/ :medh^i^dc
Vgi^hi^fjZYj8ZgXaZ6aaVc@VgYZX"Ed‚h^Zhhe^g^iZh
7JJ;DJ?ED
EdjgkdhXdbbVcYZhYVcX^Zchcjb‚gdh!kdjhW‚c‚[^X^ZoYjcZgZb^hZZcX]d^h^hhVcijcdjeajh^Zjghadih
YZ*gZkjZhbVgfj‚ZhYjcZVhi‚g^hfjZkd^ga^hiZX^"YZhhdjh/aZadihYZ*gZkjZhYZ&*|))!hVj[&,‚ej^h‚
ZhikZcYj'+[khei[gV^hYZedgiXdbeg^h
3KRWRFRSLH]RXGžFRXSH]VXLYDQWOHSRLQWLOOž
686&5,3&,Š1$8-2851$/63,5,7(
/(-2851$/63,5,7(1n$%5,/
0(6&225'211(6
0OOH0PH01RP3UQRP
&RFKH]693
$GUHVVH
&RGHSRVWDO 9LOOH
7OSKRQH
HPDLO
#
3D\V
/
DERQQHPHQWDQQXHOHVWGHSRUWFRPSULV
'RP7RPHW(WUDQJHUSRUWFRPSULV(WUDQJHUUJOHPHQWSDUPDQGDWSRVWH
3DLHPHQWSDUFDUWHEDQFDLUHVXUOHVLWH,QWHUQHWVSLULWLVPHFRPSDLHPHQWVžFXULVž
3DLHPHQWSDUFKœTXHEDQFDLUHRXSRVWDO”O
RUGUHGX&HUFOH$OODQ.DUGHF
-HUHWRXQHOHFRXSRQ”O
DGUHVVHVXLYDQWH
-HDQ&ODXGH7+,5,21%RXOHYDUG&KDUOHPDJQH1$1&<
VLJQDWXUH
3RXUWRXVUHQVHLJQHPHQWVFRQFHUQDQWOHVFRPPDQGHVWžO
RXHPDLOMFODXGHWKLULRQ#ZDQDGRRIU
-(&+2,6,602102'('(5€*/(0(17
FKœTXHEDQFDLUH RX
&RFKH]693
-(&2&+(/$/(6&$6(6'(618052648,0
,175(66((17
FKœTXHSRVWDO
0$&200$1'(
28,MHVRXVFULVXQDERQQHPHQWDQQXHODX-RXUQDO6SLULWH
&RFKH]693
28,MHGVLUHUHFHYRLUOHVQXPURVFRFKVFLGHVVXV
&RFKH]693
QRPEUHGHORWVGHUHYXHV[HXURVSRUWFRPSULVSDUORWVRLWXQWRWDOGH
28,MHGVLUHUHFHYRLUOHVUHYXHV”O
XQLW
&RFKH]693
QXPURV[HXURVSRUWFRPSULVSDUUHYXHVRLWXQWRWDOGH
727$/'(0$&200$1'(
/(-2851$/63,5,7(1o$%5,/
Descargar