$UWtFXORGH5HÁH[LyQ Dolor y sufrimiento no son sinónimos pero son intrínsecos a la naturaleza humana DOLOR Y SUFRIMIENTO NO SON SINÓNIMOS PERO SON INTRÍNSECOS A LA NATURALEZA HUMANA: UNA VISIÓN DEL DOLOR Y EL SUFRIMIENTO HUMANO PAIN AND SUFFERING ARE NOT SYNONYMOUS BUT ARE INTRINSIC TO HUMAN NATURE: A VISION OF PAIN AND HUMAN SUFFERING Rubén Darío Camargo* RESUMEN (OGRORU\HOVXIULPLHQWRQRWLHQHQXQUHIHUHQWH KLVWyULFRHQHOKRPEUH6RORGHVGHTXHHOKRPEUH HV FRQVFLHQWH GH VX KXPDQLGDG VH SUHVHQWD HO GRORU\HOVXIULPLHQWR(OKRPEUH\HOGRORUVLHPSUH KDQH[LVWLGRVHVXIUHFXDQGRVHQDFH\VHVLHQWH GRORUSURFHVRTXHVHUHSLWHHQFDGDUHVSLUDFLyQ FHOXODUHQFDGDUHDFFLyQGHR[LUHGXFFLyQ%LROy JLFDPHQWHHQ/DWtQ3$7,25 68)5,53$'(&(5 HVHOHVIXHU]RHQHUJpWLFRGHWRGRVHUYLYRSDUDVX LQWHJUDFLyQIDFWRULDOFHOXODU (Q OD PHGLFLQD HO GRORU WLHQH VX H[SOLFDFLyQ DQDWyPLFD\¿VLROyJLFDHOGRORUKDFHUHIHUHQFLDD ORVRPiWLFR\DOR¿VLROyJLFR(O'RORUDJXGRHVOD FRQVHFXHQFLDLQPHGLDWDGHODDFWLYDFLyQGHOVLVWH PDQRFLFHSWLYRJHQHUDOPHQWHSRUXQGDxRWLVXODU VRPiWLFRRYLVFHUDOGHVDSDUHFLHQGRKDELWXDOPHQWH FRQ OD OHVLyQ TXH OR RULJLQy (O 'RORU FUyQLFR HV DTXHOTXHSHUVLVWHHQDXVHQFLDGHODOHVLyQSHULIp ULFDLQLFLDO(QODHVHQFLDGHOD¿ORVRItDHOGRORUHV LPSHQVDEOHHLQWHOLJLEOHVHVLHQWHVHPDQHMDVH WROHUDSHURQRVHSLHQVDHQGRORU 'RORU\VXIULPLHQWRQRVRQVLQyQLPRVSHURVRQ LQWUtQVHFRV D OD QDWXUDOH]D KXPDQD (O KRPEUH FXDQGRH[SHULPHQWDHOGRORUVHHQFXHQWUDFRQVX SURSLROtPLWHFRQVXSURSLDLPSRWHQFLDGHQRSRGHU FDPELDUXQKHFKRUHDO(OVXIULPLHQWRKXPDQRHQOD DWHQFLyQGLDULDGHOSDFLHQWHHQIHUPRQRORPDQHMD PRVSRUVHUHVWHDOJRLQWDQJLEOHQRPRQLWRUL]DEOH \PXFKRPHQRVPHGLEOH\FXDQWL¿FDEOH (OGRORUGHOHQIHUPRQRHVOLEUHQLYROXQWDULRHV SURGXFWRGHODIUDJLOLGDGGHVXPDWHULDHOGRORUGHO TXHVXIUHGHVSLHUWDHQVXVIDPLOLDUHVODVROLGDULGDG \7ROHUDQFLD Palabra clave: 'RORUVXIULPLHQWRSDFLHQWH 0'0LHPEURGHOD$FDGHPLD1DFLRQDOGH0HGLFLQD3UHVLGHQWHGHO&DStWXORGHO$WOiQWLFR0HGLFLQD,QWHUQD&XLGDGRV,QWHQVLYRV )LORVRItD8QLYHUVLGDGGH1DYDUUD(VSDxD'LUHFWRU&LHQWt¿FR&XLGDGRLQWHQVLYR&OtQLFD*HQHUDOGHO1RUWH%DUUDQTXLOOD&RORPELD ,6610(',&,1$%RJRWi9RO1R3iJV0DU]R 25 Rubén Dario Camargo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¿DEOH7KHSDWLHQW VSDLQLVQRWIUHHRUYR OXQWDU\LWLVWKHUHVXOWRIPDWWHUIUDJLOLW\$VXIIHULQJ SDWLHQWDULVHVVROLGDULW\DQGWROHUDQFHLQKLVUHODWLYHV KHUUDPLHQWDVGHPHGLFDPHQWRVTXHQRVGDUiQDOLYLR DOGRORUItVLFRGHOSDFLHQWHSHURQRFRPSOHWDPHQWH FXDQGRHVHVHUKXPDQRFRPSRQHQWHLQWHJUDOSVL FRVRPiWLFRVXIUH (OVXIULPLHQWRKXPDQRHQODDWHQFLyQGLDULDGHO SDFLHQWHQRORPDQHMDPRVSRUVHUHVWHDOJRLQWDQJLEOH QRPRQLWRUL]DEOH\PXFKRPHQRVPHGLEOH\FXDQWL ¿FDEOH3RUHVWDUD]yQQRVHHQFXHQWUDGHQWURGH QXHVWURSODQGHPDQHMRSXHVWRTXHFRQVLGHUDPRV TXHXQDEXHQDVHGDFLyQ\XQDEXHQDDQDOJHVLD FRQWURODQ HO GRORU ItVLFR JHQHUDQGR D WUDYpV GH VLQDSVLV \ TXLPLR UHFHSWRUHV SDUD OD HVWDELOLGDG SVtTXLFDGHOVXIULPLHQWR (QHOSUHIDFLRGHODREUDThe nature of suffering and the goals of medicine (ULF-&DVVHOOHVFULELy ³/DSUXHEDTXHXQ VLVWHPDVDQLWDULRGHEHUtDVXSHUDU HVVXLGRQHLGDG SDUDHQIUHQWDUVHDOVXIULPLHQWR´(VWH OLEURSDUWHGHODSUHPLVDGHTXHODPHGLFLQD PRGHUQD QRVXSHUDHVWDSUXHED'HKHFKR ODVEDVHVFHQ WUDOHVHQTXHHVWiEDVDGDOD PHGLFLQDGHOVLJOR;; QRSURSRUFLRQDQHOHPHQWRDOJXQRSDUDFRPSUHQGHU HOVXIULPLHQWR3DUDHOPDQHMRGHOGRORUODGLVQHDX RWURVSUREOHPDVItVLFRVDJXGRVRFUyQLFRVVHKD UHDOL]DGRGHIRUPDPDJQt¿FDSDUDHOVXIULPLHQWRQR INTRODUCCIÓN (OVXIULPLHQWRGHEH DIHFWDULQHYLWDEOHPHQWHDO LQGLYLGXRORVFXHUSRVQRVXIUHQODVSHUVRQDVVXIUHQ /DVIUDVHVGH&DVVHOOGHMDQPHULGLDQDPHQWHFODUR TXHHOVXIULPLHQWRYDPiVDOOiGHODSXUDDIHFFLyQ ItVLFD\TXHQRGHEHKDFHUVHVLQyQLPRGHGRORUVH SXHGHWHQHUGRORUVLQVXIULPLHQWR\VHSXHGHVXIULU VLQGRORU7RGRHOORVXJLHUHTXHHOVXIULPLHQWRHV XQDYLYHQFLDSVLFROyJLFDGLItFLOGHFRUUHODFLRQDUFRQ OHVLyQItVLFDDOJXQD6LORVLQGLYLGXRVVXIUHQVyOR ODFRPXQLFDFLyQGHFDGDXQRSXHGHFRQYHQFHUQRV GHVXH[LVWHQFLD (OGRORUItVLFRGHOSDFLHQWHVHFRPSUHQGHGHV GHHOFRQRFLPLHQWRGHODDQDWRPtD\OD¿VLRORJtD SRGHPRV LQWHUSUHWDUOR \ PDQHMDUOR 7HQHPRV ODV (O FDUiFWHU VXEMHWLYR GHO VXIULPLHQWR VXSRQH XQJUDYHLQFRQYHQLHQWHSDUDVXYDORUDFLyQ$SHVDU GHTXHVHKDQGLVHxDGRLQVWUXPHQWRVGHREVHUYD Keywords: 3DLQVXIIHULQJSDWLHQW 26 ,6610(',&,1$%RJRWi9RO1R3iJV0DU]R Dolor y sufrimiento no son sinónimos pero son intrínsecos a la naturaleza humana FLyQ FRQGXFWXDO \ ¿VLROyJLFD H[LVWH XQDQLPLGDG HQ FRQVLGHUDU OD GHFODUDFLyQ GHO SURSLR SDFLHQWH DXWRYDORUDFLyQFRPRODIXHQWHPiVYiOLGD\¿DEOH GHWDOLQIRUPDFLyQORTXHQRKDFHPiVTXHUHFR QRFHUHOSUREOHPDGHODVXEMHWLYLGDGLQWUtQVHFDGH ODHYDOXDFLyQGHOVXIULPLHQWR (VWDVUHDOLGDGHVFRPRODVHQIHUPHGDGHVHQ RFDVLRQHV WHUULEOHPHQWH ODUJDV \ GRORURVDV GH PXHVWUDQODLQVX¿FLHQFLDGHODPDWHULDHQFXDQWR VHU 3HUR OR FLHUWR HV TXH FUHDQ SDUD HO KRPEUH VLWXDFLRQHVUHDOPHQWHGUDPiWLFDVHLQWHUURJDQWHV DQJXVWLRVRV FXDQGR HO GRORU \ HO VXIULPLHQWR VH YLYHQDOODGRGHOHQIHUPR DOLOR Y SUFRIMIENTO 6XIULPRV HQ WRGR PRPHQWR \ D~Q FRQ PiV UD]yQFXDQGRQRVHVWDPRVDGDSWDQGRDOPHGLRTXH QRVURGHDPpGLFRSDFLHQWHIDPLOLDU'DGRTXHHO PHGLRHVGLQiPLFRHOVXIULPLHQWRHVPiVLQWHQVR FXDQWRPiVGLQiPLFRVHDHVWHHVGHFLUHOPHGLR(O VXIULPLHQWRHVPHQRVLQWHQVRHQVLWXDFLRQHVTXH\D WHQHPRVFRQWURODGDV&XDQGRVHQRVFDPELDXQD UXWLQDVHJHQHUDQGLYHUVDVVHQVDFLRQHV$QVLHGDG HVWUpVGHVHR (OGRORU\HOVXIULPLHQWRKXPDQRKDQH[LVWLGR GHVGHODSHUFHSFLyQGHOLQGLYLGXRFRPRKXPDQR FRQYLYLHQGR FRQ VX PHGLR DPELHQWH 'HVGH XQ SXQWRGHYLVWDUHOLJLRVR¿ORVy¿FRFLHQWt¿FRWHR OyJLFRPpGLFRVLHPSUHVHKDSUHRFXSDGRSRUGDU UHVSXHVWDDOGRORU\VXFRQVDELGRVXIULPLHQWR 7RGDVODVSHUVRQDVDORODUJRGHVXYLGDH[ SHULPHQWDQ HO GRORU \ HO VXIULPLHQWR HQ GLYHUVDV RFDVLRQHV 7RGRV KHPRV VHQWLGR DOJXQD YH] OD HQIHUPHGDG OD VROHGDG HO IUDFDVR HWF 1DGLH HVWi D VDOYR GHO VXIULPLHQWR QL VLTXLHUD DTXHOODV SHUVRQDVTXHVHVLHQWHQIHOLFHV\DIRUWXQDGDV\D TXHHVWHIRUPDSDUWHGHQXHVWUDYLGDHVLQKHUHQWH DOVHUKXPDQR /RVGRORUHVItVLFRVGHOSDFLHQWHSRUORJHQH UDOQRGHSHQGHQGHVXOLEHUWDGQLGHVXYROXQWDG 6REUHYLHQHQFRPRFRQVHFXHQFLDGHODIUDJLOLGDG GHOVHUPDWHULDOSRUODHQIHUPHGDGRWUDXPDTXH SDGH]FDRULJLQDGRXQDVYHFHVHQIRUPDGHFDWiV WURIHVRWUDVSRUHQIHUPHGDGHVDJXGDVRFUyQLFDV /DHGXFDFLyQHVODIRUPDTXHWLHQHHOKRPEUH GHDGDSWDUVHDOVXIULPLHQWR'DLJXDOODIRUPDHQOD FXDOVHQRVKD\DHGXFDGRSXHVQRHVWDPRVH[HQWRV GHHQFRQWUDUQRVFRQVLWXDFLRQHVTXHQRVOOHYHQD QXHVWURV OtPLWHV OR YHUGDGHUDPHQWH LPSRUWDQWH HVTXHODSDUWHUDFLRQDOQRVFDSDFLWDPHMRURSHRU SDUDDIURQWDUHVRVFDPELRV ANTROPOLOGÍA DEL DOLOR Y EL SUFRIMIENTO 1R H[LVWH XQ RULJHQ KLVWyULFR GHO GRORU XQ PRPHQWRWHPSRUDOGHWHUPLQDGRHQTXHSXHGDFR ,6610(',&,1$%RJRWi9RO1R3iJV0DU]R 27 Rubén Dario Camargo ORFDUVHVXDSDULFLyQHQHOPXQGR$PHGLGDTXHOD FLHQFLDKLVWyULFDHQVDQFKDHOKRUL]RQWHGHOSDVDGR KXPDQRVHGHVFXEUHODSUHVHQFLDFRQWLQXDGHOGRORU \QXQFDXQSHULRGRIHOL]\PHQRVXQDHGDGGHRUR FDUDFWHUL]DGDSRUVXDXVHQFLD/RTXHFRPLHQ]D \FHVDVRQIRUPDVFRQFUHWDVGHOGRORUQXQFDWRGR HOVXIULPLHQWR <HVRKDVWDHOSXQWRGHTXHODLGHDGHDXVHQFLD WRWDOGHGRORU\VXIULPLHQWRHVSDUWHLQWHJUDOGHOD QRFLyQWHROyJLFDGHSDUDtVR (O VXIULPLHQWR IUHQWH DO GRORU HV XQ YRFDEOR DEVWUDFWRHQFLHUWRPRGRLQFRQPHQVXUDEOHGHELGRD TXHQRWLHQHTXHYHUFRQHOFXHUSRHQWUDHOGRPLQLR GHORHVSLULWXDO(OGRORU\HOVXIULPLHQWRHVWiQSUHVHQ WHVHQODGLPHQVLyQHVSLULWXDO\FRUSRUDOGHOKRPEUH HVGHFLUVRQLQWUtQVHFRVDVXQDWXUDOH]DKXPDQD (OGRORUHVGH¿QLGRFRPRXQDVHQVDFLyQGHVD JUDGDEOH SURGXFLGD SRU XQ HVWLPXOR GH FDUiFWHU SHUMXGLFLDO+DFHUHIHUHQFLDDORVRPiWLFR(OVX IULPLHQWRPRUDOHVGRORUGHODOPDHVHQHIHFWRGH WLSRHVSLULWXDO\QRODGLPHQVLyQSVtTXLFDGHOGRORU TXHDFRPSDxDDOVXIULPLHQWRPRUDO (OKRPEUHFXDQGRH[SHULPHQWDHOVXIULPLHQWR OROOHYDDODGHVRULHQWDFLyQ\DSHUGHUODFODULGDGGHO SHQVDPLHQWR6HHQFXHQWUDFRQVXSURSLROtPLWH FRQVXSURSLDLPSRWHQFLDGHQRSRGHUFDPELDUXQ KHFKRUHDO (O KRPEUH HQ VX VXIULPLHQWR HV XQ PLVWHULR LQWDQJLEOH TXL]i QLQJXQD RWUD FRVD H[LJH HQ VX UHDOLGDG REMHWLYD VHU WUDWDGR HQ OD IRUPD GH XQ H[SOtFLWRSUREOHPD FILOSOFÍA DEL DOLOR Y EL SUFRIMIENTO (O GRORU HV LQWHOLJLEOH LPSHQVDEOH HO GRORU QRHVVXVWDQFLDQRHVDFFLGHQWH\DTXHQRWLHQH 28 HVHQFLDHV$QXODFLyQGHDFWLWXG(681*5,(7$ (1 /$ 3(5621$ 3HUR HV SUHFLVR SURIXQGL]DU PiV¢HOGRORUHVDOJRVXVWDQFLDORDOJRDFFLGHQWDO HQHOKRPEUH"(OGRORUQRHVVXVWDQFLDQLHVDFFL GHQWH3DUHFHHQWRQFHVTXHODSUHJXQWDSODQWHDGD QRWLHQHFRQWHVWDFLyQ\HVLQ~WLOIRUPXODUOD3HUR ¢QRSXHGHDFDVRSUHJXQWDUVHOHJtWLPDPHQWHTXp HVHOGRORU" (OGRORUHVUHIUDFWDULRDHVWDSUHJXQWDSXHVWR TXHHOGRORUQRHVLQWHOLJLEOHSHURQRVRORGHKHFKR VLQRHQDEVROXWRDOPHQRVHQHOSODQRKXPDQR &RQRWUDVSDODEUDVHOGRORUQRHVWiIXHUDGHOSHQ VDPLHQWRFRPRXQDHVSHFLHGHFRVDHQVtDODTXH HOSHQVDPLHQWRQROOHJD(OGRORUQRHVLQWHOLJLEOH \ DO SUHVHQWDUVH D OD FRQFLHQFLD FRPR VLQ GXGD DFRQWHFHVHHQFXHQWUDHQHOODFRPRLPSHQVDEOH (OGRORUHVDQWHWRGRXQDVLWXDFLyQSHUVRQDO (OKRPEUHHVWiDWHQD]DGRHQWXPHFLGRHQHOGRORU DOJR GH VX DFWLYLGDG H[LVWHQFLDO HVWi TXHEUDGR \ SDUDOHODPHQWHLQpGLWR(OGRORUFRPROtPLWHLQIUDQ TXHDEOH HV DQXODFLyQ GH DFWLWXG HQ WDQWR GXHOH SUHFLVDPHQWHPLVHUQRVHGHVSOLHJDQRVH\HUJXH VREUHVt(OGRORUHVJULHWDGHODSHUVRQD (Q OD GLPHQVLyQ KXPDQD FRUSRUDO WHQHPRV GRORUORVHQWLPRVVXIULPRVRDJXDQWDPRVORTXH QRFDEHHVSHVDUOR(OOXJDUGHDVHQWDPLHQWRSUL PDULRGHOGRORUHQQRVRWURVQRHVHOSHQVDPLHQWR SHURORGHFLVLYRHVTXHQRSRGHPRVHQWHQGHUORDO WUDVODGDUORDpO 'RORU\VXIULPLHQWRQRVRQVLQyQLPRV$XQTXH VHXVDQFRPRVLQyQLPRVHOVXIULPLHQWRItVLFRLQ GLFDFXDOTXLHU©GRORUGHOFXHUSRª\HOVXIULPLHQWR PRUDOHO©GRORUGHODOPDªHVHVWH~OWLPRXQGRORU GHWLSRHVSLULWXDO\QRVyORODGLPHQVLyQ©SVtTXLFDª GHOGRORUTXHDFRPSDxDWDQWRHOVXIULPLHQWRPRUDO FRPRHOItVLFRGLVWLQFLyQHQWUHVXIULPLHQWRItVLFR\ VXIULPLHQWRPRUDO ,6610(',&,1$%RJRWi9RO1R3iJV0DU]R Dolor y sufrimiento no son sinónimos pero son intrínsecos a la naturaleza humana /DFDXVDPiVIUHFXHQWHGHVXIULPLHQWRHVHO GRORUItVLFRSHURGRORU\VXIULPLHQWRQRVRQVLQy QLPRV(OGRORUHVXQDVHQVDFLyQ¿MD\WtSLFDGHOR GHVDJUDGDEOHGHGLIHUHQWHJUDGRGHLQWHQVLGDG(O GRORUKDFHUHIHUHQFLDDORUGHQGHORVRPiWLFRGH OR¿VLROyJLFR\VHSXHGHGH¿QLUFRPRODVHQVDFLyQ GHVDJUDGDEOHSURGXFLGDSRUODDFFLyQGHHVWtPXORV GHFDUiFWHUSHUMXGLFLDO(OVXIULPLHQWRHQFDPELRHV XQDPDQLIHVWDFLyQGHODHVSLULWXDOLGDGGHODSHUVRQD GHVXDQKHORGHIHOLFLGDG(QFRQVHFXHQFLDHVWD GLVWLQFLyQWLHQHFRPRIXQGDPHQWRODGREOHGLPHQ VLyQGHOVHUKXPDQRHLQGLFDHOHOHPHQWRFRUSRUDO \HVSLULWXDOFRPRORVVXMHWRVLQPHGLDWRVRGLUHFWRV GHOGRORU\GHOVXIULPLHQWRUHVSHFWLYDPHQWH(OGRORU WLHQHXQVHQWLGRItVLFR\HOVXIULPLHQWRXQVHQWLGR PHWDItVLFR(OSULPHURQRVLQYLWDDUHÀH[LRQDUVREUH HOFXHUSRHOVHJXQGRVXVFLWDSUHJXQWDVPiVSUR IXQGDV\H[LVWHQFLDOHVVRORHOVXIULPLHQWRQRVDEUH ODVSXHUWDVGHOFRQRFLPLHQWRSURIXQGRGHODYLGD BIOLOGÍA DEL DOLOR /RVUHFHSWRUHVSDUDHOGRORUVHHQFXHQWUDQHQ ODSLHOHQODVHVWUXFWXUDVP~VFXORHVTXHOpWLFDV\HQ ODVYtVFHUDV/RVUHFHSWRUHVFXWiQHRVWHUPLQDFLRQHV QHUYLRVDV OLEUHV WUDGXFHQ HVWtPXORV PHFiQLFRV WpUPLFRV R TXtPLFRV HQ XQ WUHQ GH SRWHQFLDOHV HOpFWULFRVTXHVHWUDQVPLWHQSRUVXVD[RQHVKDFLD ODPpGXODHVSLQDO /RV FXHUSRV FHOXODUHV GH ORV QRFLFHSWRUHV SHULIpULFRV VH HQFXHQWUDQ HQ ORV JDQJOLRV GH OD UDt]GRUVDO\ODSULPHUDVLQDSVLVVHUHDOL]DDQLYHO GHODVWDGRUVDOGHODPpGXODHVSLQDOWDQWRFRQODV LQWHUQHXURQDVORFDOHVFRPRFRQODVQHXURQDVGH SUR\HFFLyQ TXH OOHYDQ OD LQIRUPDFLyQ QRFLFHSWLYD KDFLD FHQWURV VXSHULRUHV HQ HO WURQFR FHUHEUDO \ HQHOWiODPR(QWRQFHVVHSXHGHGHFLUTXHHOGRORU KDFHUHIHUHQFLDDORVRPiWLFR\DOR¿VLROyJLFR ,6610(',&,1$%RJRWi9RO1R3iJV0DU]R 29 Rubén Dario Camargo (Q OD ,QWHUQDWLRQDO$VVRFLDWLRQ IRU WKH 6WXG\RI3DLQ,$63GH¿QHHOGRORUFRPR"Una experiencia sensorial y emocional desagradable asociada con una lesión hística real o potencial, o que se describe como ocasionada por dicha lesión" GRORUVLQRTXHIUHFXHQWHPHQWHRWURVWLSRVGHVX IULPLHQWRVRQGHVFULWRVHQWpUPLQRVGHWDOGRORUOR FXDOSXHGHFRPSOLFDUHODQiOLVLVGHXQSDFLHQWHDO LQYROXFUDUQRVHQVXGLPHQVLyQSVLFROyJLFDVRPiWLFD GHOFXHUSRRVRPiWLFDGHODOPD (VWD GH¿QLFLyQ VXSXVR HQ VX PRPHQWR KLV WyULFRXQFDPELRFRQUHVSHFWRDODVDQWHULRUHVDO LQWURGXFLU GRV QXHYRV FRQFHSWRV HO GRORU QR HV XQDH[SHULHQFLDSXUDPHQWHQRFLFHSWLYDVLQRTXH HVWi LQWHJUDGD SRU FRPSRQHQWHV HPRFLRQDOHV \ VXEMHWLYRVHQVHJXQGROXJDUSXHGHSURGXFLUVHVLQ FDXVDVRPiWLFDTXHODMXVWL¿TXH (OHVWtPXORGRORURVRSURGXFHXQDUHVSXHVWD JOREDOGHOLQGLYLGXRGHVFULWDFRPRFRQGXFWDGRORURVD FRQMXQWRGHDFWLYLGDGHVTXHUHDOL]DXQSDFLHQWH FRPR UHVSXHVWD D OD SUHVHQFLD GH GRORU OR FXDO OOHYDDFXDOTXLHUREVHUYDGRUDODFRQFOXVLyQGHTXH HOLQGLYLGXRHVWiH[SHULPHQWiQGROR\UHSUHVHQWDHQ UHDOLGDGHO~QLFRtQGLFHFOtQLFRREVHUYDEOHGHGRORU \VXIULPLHQWR (OGRORUDJXGRHVODFRQVHFXHQFLDLQPHGLDWDGH ODDFWLYDFLyQGHOVLVWHPDQRFLFHSWLYRJHQHUDOPHQWH SRUXQGDxRWLVXODUVRPiWLFRRYLVFHUDOGHVDSDUH FLHQGRKDELWXDOPHQWHFRQODOHVLyQTXHORRULJLQy (OGRORUFUyQLFRHVDTXHOTXHSHUVLVWHHQDXVHQFLD GHODOHVLyQSHULIpULFDLQLFLDO +R\SRUKR\HVFODURTXHHOGRORU\HOVXIUL PLHQWRQRSXHGHQVHUDQDOL]DGRVFRPRODH[FOXVLYD H[SUHVLyQ GH XQD HVWLPXODFLyQ QRFLFHSWLYD \ UH TXLHUHQHQSURSRUFLyQDVXFRPSOHMLGDGXQDQiOLVLV GHODVGLPHQVLRQHVKXPDQDV\D~QVRFLDOHVTXH FRQGLFLRQDQVXSHUVLVWHQFLDGHQWURGHXQPRGHOR TXHFRQWHPSODDVSHFWRVELROyJLFRVSVLFROyJLFRV VRFLDOHVSHUVSHFWLYDELRSVLFRVRFLDO\KXPDQRV 7RGRHVWHSURFHVRGHVFULWRHQODSHUFHSFLyQGHO GRORU\HQODFRQGXFWDGRORURVDSXHGHVHUPRGL¿FDGR SRUGRVGLPHQVLRQHVODVHQVRULRGLVFULPLQDWLYDHQ ODFXDOSUHGRPLQDQORVHYHQWRVVRPiWLFRV\QHXUR ¿VLROyJLFRVWDQWRQRUPDOHVFRPRDQRUPDOHV\OD GLPHQVLyQDIHFWLYRHPRFLRQDOGRQGHSUHGRPLQDOD DFWLYDFLyQGHIHQyPHQRVDIHFWLYRV\FRJQRVFLWLYRV TXHFRQWURODQODFRQGXFWDREVHUYDEOHGHOLQGLYLGXR VHGHEHH[DPLQDUWDQWRHOPHFDQLVPRRUJiQLFRGH OD SURGXFFLyQ GHO GRORU FRPR DTXHOORV DVSHFWRV FRQFHSWXDOHVGHH[SHULHQFLDVSUHYLDVPRWLYDFLR QDOHV\DIHFWLYDVDOUHGHGRUGHODVLWXDFLyQGRORURVD HQ WRGR HQIHUPR FXDQGR VH DQDOL]D HO DVSHFWR SVLFROyJLFRGHOGRORU PSICOLOGÍA DEL DOLOR Y EL SUFRIMIENTO SUFRIMIENTO EN LA FAMILIA DEL ENFERMO (O GRORU HQ OD SHUVRQD DO SHUFLELUOR VHQWLUOR \ PDQLIHVWDUOR JHQHUD XQD UHVSXHVWD DIHFWLYD HPRFLRQDOGHFDUiFWHUQHJDWLYRDODFXDOOODPDPRV VXIULPLHQWR &RQMXQWR GH UHDFFLRQHV DIHFWLYDV \ RUJiQLFDV QHJDWLYDV TXH VH SURGXFHQ FRPR UHV SXHVWDDODSUHVHQFLDGHXQHVWLPXORQRFLFHSWLYR (OVXIULPLHQWRHQODSHUVRQDQROHHVH[FOXVLYRDO (O VXIULPLHQWR GH ORV IDPLOLDUHV GHO HQIHUPR SRVLELOLWDHQHOORVHOHMHUFLFLRGHODFRPSUHQVLyQ GHODWROHUDQFLDGHODD\XGDGHOVDFUL¿FLRGHOD JUDWXLGDG\VREUHWRGRGHODPRUTXHHVHOIDFWRU PiV SHUVRQDOL]DQWH (VWH HV HO VHQWLPLHQWR TXH GHVSLHUWDDVXVIDPLOLDUHVHOGRORU\VXIULPLHQWRGH TXLHQHVWiVXIULHQGR 30 ,6610(',&,1$%RJRWi9RO1R3iJV0DU]R Dolor y sufrimiento no son sinónimos pero son intrínsecos a la naturaleza humana /DVDFWLWXGHVGHOIDPLOLDUGHOSDFLHQWHIUHQWH DOGRORU\VXIULPLHQWRSXHGHQVHU $FHSWDFLyQ1RUPDOPHQWHDQWHXQDPDODQR WLFLDRXQDFRQWUDULHGDGTXHVXSRQJDGRORUGHVX IDPLOLDUQHFHVLWDQWLHPSRSDUDDVLPLODUOR\DFHSWDUOR FRQVHUHQLGDG\FRQDSORPR 5HFKD]R 7UDWDQ GH HYLWDU \ GHVFRQRFHU HO GRORU\VXIULPLHQWRTXHRFDVLRQDXQDPDODQRWLFLDR FRQWUDULHGDGTXHVXSRQHQVXIULPLHQWRHQVXIDPLOLDU TXHHVWiVXIULHQGRQRGHEHPRVGXGDUHQD\XGDUOH 1XHVWUDVRODSUHVHQFLDFRQHODPRUTXHOHSRGHPRV GDUSXHGHKDFHUOHHVWHWUDQFHPiVOOHYDGHUR (OVXIULPLHQWRFRQGXFHDXQDPDGXUDFLyQGH ODSHUVRQDOLGDG(QODVGLIHUHQWHVIRUPDVHQTXHVH SXHGHSUHVHQWDUQRVSURGXFHXQSHVDU\XQGRORU TXHQRVKDFHUHÀH[LRQDUVREUHQRVRWURVPLVPRV \VREUHQXHVWUDSURSLDYLGD\DFXHVWLRQDUQRVHO SRUTXpGHWRGRORTXHQRVDFRQWHFH REFERENCIAS 'HVHVSHUDFLyQ(VQRUPDOTXHFXDQGRXQD SHUVRQDHVWiVXIULHQGRSRUSUREOHPDVGHHQIHUPHGDG GHVXIDPLOLDUVHVLHQWHFRQXQDSURIXQGDWULVWH]D (VQRUPDOSRUWDQWRTXHSURWHVWHOORUHJULWHRVH HQIDGH6LQHPEDUJRORTXHQRSXHGHRFXUULUHV TXHHOVXIULPLHQWRVHDFRQVWDQWH 3DUDD\XGDUHVPHMRUWUDWDUGHHVFXFKDUDHVD SHUVRQDSRQHUQRVHQVXOXJDUSDUDFRPSUHQGHUOD VHQWLU VX VXIULPLHQWR VX WHPRU \ VX UDELD SHUR VREUHWRGRHVWDUFRQHVWDSHUVRQDFRPSDUWLHQGR ORVPRPHQWRVGRORURVRVSRUORVTXHHVWiSDVDQGR FXLGiQGROD \ WUDWDQGR GH DOLYLDUOH OD SHQD HQ HO PRPHQWRGHODHQWUHYLVWD\HQFXHQWURVVXFHVLYRV (OVXIULPLHQWRVDFDORPHMRUGHQRVRWURVPLVPRV 3RUHVRFXDQGRYHPRVDXQDPLJRRXQIDPLOLDU 'H(PSDLUH<DQHV*'LOHPDVHQODWRPDGHGHFLVLRQHV HQHOSDFLHQWHFULWLFR&XDGHUQRVGH3URJUDPD Re JLRQDOGH%LRpWLFD206 &DVVHOO (- The nature of suffering and the goals of medicine. 2[IRUG2[IRUG8QLYHUVLW\3UHVV ,$636XEFRPPLWWHHRQ7D[RQRP\3DLQWHUPVDOLVWZLWK GH¿QLWLRQVDQGQRWHVRQXVDJHPain )XQGDPHQWRVGHFXLGDGRFULWLFRHQVRSRUWHLQLFLDO6R FLHGDGGH0HGLFLQD&UtWLFD$XWRUHV9DULRV3ULPHUD HGLFLyQHQHVSDxRO$UJHQWLQD(GLWRULDO&RODERUDGRUHV S - )LQOD\ +XPDQLGDGHV 0pGLFDV 9RO 1R 0D\R $JRVWR 7XUQHU/%LRHWKLFVLQSOXUDOLVWLFVRFLHWLHV0HG+HDOWK &DUH3KLORV 3HGUR)%HMDUDQR&RQFHSWRVVREUHHOGRORUGHOVtQWRPD DODHVSHFLDOLGDGPpGLFD -RVp ÈQJHO *DUFtD &XDGUDGR$QWURSRORJtD )LORVy¿FD (816$ 7RPDV0HOHQGR,QWURGXFFLyQDOD)LORVR¿D(816$ Fecha de recibido: Noviembre 17 de 2011 Fecha de aprobado: Diciembre 15 de 2011 ,6610(',&,1$%RJRWi9RO1R3iJV0DU]R 31