(OODERUDWRULR d CfTR GH GHSURYLVL¡Q 1DQDOL]DQGR ODYLGDGH FULVWR2 $GROHVFHQWHV /LEURGHODOXPQR RU`]VdTV_eVd DGROHVFHQWHV 8QLGDG /HFFLyQ 1eV_T`^aRdZ_2 ³(QHIHFWRWRGDODOH\VHUHVXPHHQXQ VRORPDQGDPLHQWR$PDDWXSUyMLPR FRPRDWLPLVPR´*iODWDV %XUEXMDV 3DUiERODGHO%XHQ6DPDULWDQR /HHU/XFDV ¥ 4XpVLJQL¿FDYLYLUODYLGDFULVWLDQD"$YHFHVHVGLItFLOHQWHQGHUOR\QHFHVLWDPRV SUHJXQWDUDVtFRPRORVGLVFtSXORVOHSUHJXQWDURQD-HV~VFXDQGRHVWXYRDTXt HQODWLHUUD¢4XpOH\HVQHFHVLWDPRVVHJXLU"¢(VPiVLPSRUWDQWHDVHJXUDUVH GHLUDODLJOHVLDWRGRHOWLHPSRRHVPiVLPSRUWDQWHDOHMDUVHGHOWDEDFR\HODOFRKRO"¢(VPiV LPSRUWDQWHDEVWHQHUQRVGHDGRUDUDtGRORVRJXDUGDUQXHVWURFRUD]yQGHODOXMXULDRODDYDULFLD" -HV~VFRQ¿UPyORTXHORVGLVFtSXORVSHQVDEDQTXHHUDPiVLPSRUWDQWHFRQODSDUiERODGHO %XHQ6DPDULWDQR³$PDDO6HxRUWX'LRVFRQWRGRWXFRUD]yQ\FRQWRGDWXDOPD\FRQWRGDVWXV IXHU]DV\FRQWRGDWXPHQWH\DPDDWXSUyMLPRFRPRDWLPLVPR´(VWDSDUiERODWUDWDODVHJXQGD SDUWHGHHVWHPDQGDPLHQWRDPDUDRWURVFRPRDQRVRWURVPLVPRV3HUR¢FyPRVDEHPRVTXH DPDPRVDORVGHPiV"-HV~VQRVGDXQHMHPSOR(QODSDUiERODGHO%XHQ6DPDULWDQRYHPRVD XQKRPEUHTXHHVGHMDGRMXQWRDOFDPLQRPHGLRPXHUWR\WUHVKRPEUHVTXHSDVDQORHQFXHQWUDQ DKt(VFXULRVR\DTXHHOSULPHUKRPEUHHVXQVDFHGRWHSHURQRKL]RQDGDSDUDD\XGDUOR (VWHHVFRPRXQSDVWRUGHXQDLJOHVLDKR\HQGtDHVDOJXLHQTXHHVEXHQR\TXHWRGRVOR UHFRQRFHQFRPRDOJXLHQTXHKDFHODVFRVDVFRUUHFWDVWRGRHOWLHPSR<FRPRDOJXLHQTXHJXtD DRWURVHQODUHOLJLyQ3HURHQHVWDSDUiERODHOQRKDFHORFRUUHFWR(OGHFLGHQRLQYROXFUDUVH /DVHJXQGDSHUVRQDTXHSDVySRUDKtIXHXQ/HYLWDWDPELpQHVXQDSHUVRQDUHOLJLRVDSHURFRQ XQDFUHHQFLDGLIHUHQWH3RGUtDVHUFRPRDOJXLHQGHXQDGHQRPLQDFLyQGLIHUHQWHDODWX\DHOORV WDPELpQVRQFULVWLDQRVSHURFUHHQXQSRTXLWRGLIHUHQWHDWL1RWD&RPRPDHVWURSRGUtDVWHQHU PD\RULPSDFWRDTXtPHQFLRQDGRDOJXQDRWUDGHQRPLQDFLRQGLIHUHQWHDODWX\DFRPRHMHPSOR(O WHUFHUKRPEUHTXHSDVyQRHUDGHOWRGRUHOLJLRVRSHURVHGHWXYRSDUD\XGDUDOKRPEUHKHULGR FXLGyGHpO\SDJRVXKRVSHGDMHHQHOKRWHO(VWHWHUFHUKRPEUHQRVPXHVWUDDTXpVHSDUHFH ODFRPSDVLyQ3ULPHURGHWHQHUQRV\VHQWLUODFRPSDVLyQVHJXQGRWRPDUDFFLyQ\D\XGDUDOD SHUVRQD\WHUFHUR£HVWDUDOSHQGLHQWHKDVWDTXHWRGRHVWpUHVXHOWR(QHVWDSDUiEROD-HV~V HVSHFt¿FDPHQWHQRVPXHVWUDDGRVKRPEUHVFULVWLDQRVTXHVHDVHJXUDEDQGHKDFHUWRGDVODV FRVDVUHOLJLRVDV3HURFXDQGRVHYLHURQIUHQWHDDOJXLHQTXHWHQtDQHFHVLGDGQRORD\XGDURQ1R KD\QDGDGHPDORFRQVHJXLUODVHQVHxDQ]DV\UHJODVGHQXHVWUDLJOHVLDSHURVLKD\DOJRGHPDOR FXDQGR62/2KDFHPRVHVWDVFRVDV6LHVWDPRVVLJXLHQGRD'LRVGHEHPRVHVFXFKDUD-HV~V FRQHVWDSDUiEROD'HEHPRVWUDWDUDORVGHPiVFRPRTXHUHPRVTXHQRVWUDWHQDQRVRWURV GHEHPRVWHQHUFRPSDVLyQSRUODJHQWHFXDQGRHVWpQHQQHFHVLGDG\£+$&(5$/*2DOUHVSHFWR 1RGHEHPRVHQYROYHUQRVGHPDVLDGRHQODVUHJODVUHOLJLRVDV\GHMDUDXQODGRODVSULQFLSDOHV HQVHxDQ]DVGH-HV~V'HEHPRVDPDUPiVD'LRV\SRQHUDRWURVSULPHUR£'HEHPRVPDQWHQHU QXHVWURVRMRVDELHUWRVDOPXQGRTXHQRVURGHD\7(1&203$6,Ï1 ¢4XpFRVDVSUiFWLFDVSRGHPRVKDFHUSDUDWUDWDUDRWURVFRPRTXHUHPRVTXHQRVWUDWHQ" ¢&XiOHVVRQDOJXQDVFRVDVTXHGHPXHVWUDQDPLVWDG" 7DUHD/XFDV 3iJLQDV\ ¢4XpHVVHUXQKRPEUHYHUGDGHUR" R^`dRTRdR g +R\GHEHVHVFRJHUXQDDFWLYLGDGTXHKDFHUGXUDQWHOD VHPDQDSDUDDOJXLHQ<DTXHGHFLGDVFXDOHVFUtEHODSDUD TXHQRVHWHROYLGH FULVWRHV &RPSDVLYR 6DOPR /HFFLyQ ³$VtTXH\ROHVGLJR3LGDQ\VHOHVGDUiEXVTXHQ\HQFRQWUDUiQ OODPHQ\VHOHVDEULUiODSXHUWD3RUTXHWRGRHOTXHSLGHUHFLEHHOTXH EXVFDHQFXHQWUD\DOTXHOODPDVHOHDEUH´/XFDV 1YRS]R]V2 /D2UDFLyQ /HHU/XFDV QODOHFFLyQGHKR\QRVHQIRFDUHPRVHQXQDSDUWHLPSRUWDQWHGHQXHVWUDYLGDFULVWLDQD £/$25$&,Ï10LUDUHPRVSXQWRVGHODRUDFLyQ6yORKDFHUODFyPRKDFHUOD\£6(5 3(56,67(17(HQHOOD (OSULPHUSXQWRHVREYLR\HVTXHODRUDFLyQHVLPSRUWDQWH-HV~VVHWRPyWLHPSRSDUDRUDU QRVRORHQRFDFLRQHVHVSHFLDOHVVLQRTXHWDPELpQODSUDFWLFDEDUHJXODUPHQWH&RPRFULVWLDQRV GHEHPRVVHJXLUVXHMHPSOR\WRPDUWLHPSRSDUDRUDU/DVHJXQGDSDUWHGHHVWDOHFFLyQVHHQIRFD HQ&Ï02RUDU/DRUDFLyQEiVLFDPHQWHHQXQDSOiWLFDFRQ'LRVSHURµ(O3DGUH1XHVWUR¶HO FXDOHQFRQWUDPRVHQ0DWHR\/XFDVQRVGDXQEXHQHMHPSORGHFyPRKDFHUOR³3DGUHQXHVWUR TXHHVWiVHQHOFLHORVDQWL¿FDGRVHDWXQRPEUHYHQJDWXUHLQRKiJDVHWXYROXQWDGHQODWLHUUD FRPRHQHOFLHOR'DQRVKR\QXHVWURSDQFRWLGLDQR3HUGyQDQRVQXHVWUDVGHXGDVFRPRWDPELpQ QRVRWURVKHPRVSHUGRQDGRDQXHVWURVGHXGRUHV<QRQRVGHMHVFDHUHQWHQWDFLyQVLQROtEUDQRV GHOPDOLJQR´0DWHR/DSULPHUDSDUWHHVWiEiVLFDPHQWHDODEDQGRD'LRVSLGLHQGRTXH 6XVDQWLGDGVHPXHVWUHPiV\SLGLHQGRTXHHOSODQGH'LRVSUHYDOH]FDHQODWLHUUD'HVSXpV ODRUDFLyQHQWUDHQODVSHWLFLRQHVSHUVRQDOHVSLGLHQGRTXH'LRVQRVD\XGHFRQQXHVWUDV QHFHVLGDGHVEiVLFDVFRPRHODOLPHQWRGLDULR\TXHSRGDPRVUHFLELUSHUGyQSRUQXHVWURV SHFDGRVSHUGRQDQGRDRWURV\TXH'LRVQRVSURWHMDGHODVWHQWDFLRQHV\GHOGLDEOR(VWRQRVGD XQPRGHOREiVLFRGHFyPRRUDU/DWHUFHUDSDUWHGHODOHFFLyQGHKR\VHHQIRFDHQODLPSRUWDQFLD GHSHUVHYHUDUHQODRUDFLyQ-HV~VOHVFRQWyDVXVGLVFtSXORVXQDKLVWRULDDFHUFDGHXQYHFLQR PROHVWR(VWHKRPEUHQHFHVLWDEDFRPLGDSDUDVXYLVLWD\WRGDVODVWLHQGDVHVWiQFHUUDGDVDVt TXHOHSLGHDVXYHFLQRTXHVHOHYDQWHHQODQRFKH\DWDUGHSDUDTXHORD\XGH(OKRPEUHQR ORTXLHUHKDFHUSHURSRUFDXVDGHOD3(56,67(1&,$GHVXDPLJRVHULQGH\OHGDWRGRORTXH QHFHVLWD%iVLFDPHQWH-HV~VHVWiGLFLHQGRTXHVHDPRV3(56,67(17(6DOSHGLUOHDeODVt FRPRHVWHKRPEUHHQODKLVWRULD\£eOQRVYDDGDUWRGRORTXHQHFHVLWDPRV-HV~VORGHMDDXQ PiVFODURFRQHVWRVYHUVRVFODYHV ³$VtTXH\ROHVGLJR3LGDQ\VHOHVGDUiEXVTXHQ\HQFRQWUDUiQOODPHQ\VHOHVDEULUiOD SXHUWD3RUTXHWRGRHOTXHSLGHUHFLEHHOTXHEXVFDHQFXHQWUD\DOTXHOODPDVHOHDEUH´ /XFDV(QWRQFHVHVWHGtDKHPRVYLVWRSXQWRVLPSRUWDQWHV £/DRUDFLyQ(VLPSRUWDQWHKDFHUOD £6HJXLUHOHMHPSOR-HV~VQRVPXHVWUDFyPRKDFHUORFRQDODEDQ]D\SHWLFLRQHV £(ODVXQWRGHODSHUVLVWHQFLD(PSXMD\SLGHSRUTXHHVRKDUiODGLIHUHQFLD (VLPSRUWDQWHRUDUD'LRVHQWRQFHVWyPDWHHOWLHPSR\£+È%/$/( < ¢&yPRSXHGRHVFXFKDUD'LRVFXDQGRPHKDEOD" ¢&yPRSXHGRHVWDUVHJXURGHTXHHVODYR]GH'LRV" 7DUHD/XFDV 3iJLQDV\ ¢$TXpVHSDUHFHODSHUVLVWHQFLDHQODRUDFLyQ" FULVWRHV defUZ`ViecR/HH/XFDVSDUDHQFRQWUDURWUD OHFFLyQLPSRUWDQWHDFHUFDGHODSHUVLVWHQFLDHQODRUDFLyQ < R^`dRTRdR g (VFRJHXQDRUDFLyQHVSHFt¿FDKDUiVHVDRUDFLyQ 6XPR6DFHUGRWH WRGRVORVGtDVGHODVHPDQD<DTXHHVFRMDVWX +HEUHRV RUDFLyQHVFUtEHODHQWXOLEURSDUDTXHQRVHWHROYLGH 'HV¿OHGH 3LPLHQWDV *ORERHQ OD%RWHOOD /HFFLyQ 1RccVaZ_eVeV2 ³3RUWDQWRSDUDTXHVHDQERUUDGRVVXVSHFDGRV DUUHSLpQWDQVH\YXpOYDQVHD'LRVD¿QGHTXHYHQJDQ WLHPSRVGHGHVFDQVRGHSDUWHGHO6HxRU´ +HFKRV 3DUiERODGHO+LMR3UyGLJR /HHU/XFDV ODUUHSHQWLPLHQWRHVXQSXQWRSULQFLSDODORODUJRGHWRGDOD(VFULWXUD\QLQJ~QHVWXGLRGHOD %LEOLDHVWDUtDFRPSOHWRVLQHO6LHVWiVYLYLHQGRODYLGDFULVWLDQDW~GHEHVH[SHULPHQWDUHO DUUHSHQWLPLHQWR\QRVRORHOGtDTXHOHGLVWHWXYLGDD-HV~VVLQRGHXQDIRUPDFRQWLQXD £'LRVDPDHODUUHSHQWLPLHQWR+HFKRV³3RUWDQWRSDUDTXHVHDQERUUDGRVVXVSHFDGRV DUUHSLpQWDQVH\YXpOYDQVHD'LRVD¿QGHTXHYHQJDQWLHPSRVGHGHVFDQVRGHSDUWHGHO6HxRU´ 'LRVQRVPDQGDDUUHSHQWLUQRVGHQXHVWUDPDOGDG-REeOSURPHWHUHVWDXUDUQRVFXDQGR QRVDUUHSHQWLPRV-HUeOQRVHQVHxDTXHVLQRVDUUHSHQWLPRVSRGHPRV9,9,5(] eOQRVSLGHTXHQRVDUUHSLQWDPRV\QRVYROYDPRVDQXHVWUDYLGDFULVWLDQDFRPRDOSULQFLSLR$S \-HV~VQRVGLMRTXHVLQRQRVDUUHSHQWLPRV£SHUHFHUHPRV/F1RVRWURVGHEHPRV SURGXFLUIUXWRVHQQXHVWUDYLGDTXHPXHVWUHQXQDUUHSHQWLPLHQWRFRQWLQXR0WWHQHPRV TXHGHPRVWUDUQXHVWURDUUHSHQWLPLHQWRFRQKHFKRV+FKKD\UHJRFLMRHQHOFLHORFXDQGR QRVDUUHSHQWLPRV/F\GHEHPRVDUUHSHQWLUQRVXQRVDRWURV/F'HWRGRVHVWRV YHUVRV\PXFKRVPiVDGHPiVGHYDULDVKLVWRULDVTXHVHHQFXHQWUDQDORODUJRGHWRGDOD (VFULWXUDSRGHPRVYHUTXHHODUUHSHQWLPLHQWRHVXQDSDUWHSULQFLSDOGHODYLGDFULVWLDQD£1DGLH HVSHUIHFWR\WRGRVGHEHPRVUHFRQRFHUQXHVWUDVIDOODVDUUHSHQWLUQRV\GHMDUODVDWUiV(VWD VHPDQDHVWDUHPRVPLUDQGRODSDUiERODGHO+LMR3UyGLJR(VXQHMHPSORPX\ERQLWRGHORTXH HVDUUHSHQWLPLHQWR\ODUHVSXHVWDGH'LRVSDUDHO(VWHKLMRSHFDWRPDHOGLQHURGHVXSDSi\ ORVJDVWDUiSLGDPHQWHHQFRVDVPDODV(QWRQFHVpOVHHQFXHQWUDHQXQDVLWXDFLyQGRQGHHVWi SDVDQGRKDPEUHV\QHFHVLGDGHV\GHFLGHDUUHSHQWLUVH\UHJUHVDUFRQVXSDGUH(OSULPHUSXQWR TXHSRGHPRVYHUHVTXHQHFHVLWDPRVGDUQRVODYXHOWDFRPSOHWDPHQWHGHMDUORTXHHVWHPRV KDFLHQGR\UHJUHVDUQRV1HFHVLWDPRVGHMDUHOSHFDGR\GDUOHFRPSOHWDPHQWHODHVSDOGD1R KXELHUDVHUYLGRTXHHOKLMRSUyGLJROODPDUDSRUWHOpIRQRDVXSDSiSDUDDUUHSHQWLUVH\TXHGDUVH GRQGHHVWDEDeOWXYRTXHGHMDUVXSHFDGR\UHJUHVDUDODFDVDGHVXSDGUH(OVHJXQGRSXQWR TXHSRGHPRVYHUHQODHQVHxDQ]DGHOKLMRSUyGLJRHVTXHOOHJyFRQKXPLOGDGDGPLWLHQGRTXH KDEtDKHFKRDOJRPDOR(VWRHVXQDSDUWHLPSRUWDQWHGHODUUHSHQWLPLHQWRDGPLWLUQXHVWUDVIDOWDV 0XFKDVYHFHVTXHUHPRVUHJUHVDUD'LRVSHURFXDQGRVRPRVFXHVWLRQDGRVQRSRGHPRVDGPLWLU TXHHQYHUGDGKHPRVKHFKRDOJRPDOR£(VWRQRVLUYHDVt1RSXHGHVDUUHSHQWLUWH\KXPLOODUWH VLQDGPLWLUTXHKDVKHFKRDOJRPDOR£+D\TXHUHFRQRFHUTXHKHPRVSHFDGR/DWHUFHUDFRVD PDUDYLOORVDTXHSRGHPRVYHUHQHVWDSDUiERODHVFyPR'LRVUHVSRQGHDVXKLMReOOHPXHVWUD PXFKRDPRU\DFHSWDFLyQ\£FHOHEUDVXDUUHSHQWLPLHQWRFRQXQD¿HVWDHVSHFLDO'LRVVLHQWH ORPLVPRSRUWL\SRUPtFXDQGRQRVDUUHSHQWLPRV£eOQRVUHFLEHFRQORVEUD]RVDELHUWRV £(QWRQFHVQRVRORPHPRULFHVORVGHWDOOHVGHHVWDSDUiERODVLQRDSOtFDODHQWXYLGD'LRVDPD HODUUHSHQWLPLHQWR\QRVRORGHORVQXHYRVFULVWLDQRV(VWDOHFFLyQHVSDUDWL\SDUDPtSDUD UHFRUGDUTXHFXDQGRQRVHQFRQWUDPRVFRPLHQGRFRPLGDGHFHUGRVSRGDPRVGDUQRVFXHQWDGH TXHKHPRVVLGRDWUDSDGRVSRUHOSHFDGR£\TXHVtKD\PDQHUDGHVDOLUQRVGHDKt'HMDGHKDFHU ORTXHHVWiVKDFLHQGRGDWHODYXHOWD\£UHJUpVDWHD'LRV/OHJDFRQKXPLOGDGDGPLWLHQGRTXH KDVSHFDGR\HQFRQWUDUiVTXH£eOWHHVWiHVSHUDQGRFRQORVEUD]RVDELHUWRVSDUDUHFLELUWH\ WUDWDUWHFRPRXQKLMRRKLMDDPDGR < XPDHVWURWHJXLDUiHQOD VLJXLHQWHDFWLYLGDG K 7DUHD/XFDV 3iJLQDV\ R^`dRTRdR g $FRQWLQXDFLyQHQFRQWUDUiVXQDOLVWDGHSHFDGRVGH XQRVVHDUUHSHQWLUiQHQFODVH\RWURVHQVXFDVD FULVWRHV 3DGUH(WHUQR ,VDtDV aVTRU`daRcRRccVaV_eZcdV /D%LEOLDQRVKDEODGHQXHVWUDUHODFLyQFRQ'LRVXVDQGRLPiJHQHVGHODDJULFXOWXUD ³$EUDQVXUFRVHQWHUUHQRVQRODEUDGRV\QRVLHPEUHQHQWUHHVSLQRV«PDUTXHQVXFRUD]yQFRQODVHxDOGHO SDFWR&LUFXQFtGHQVHSDUDKRQUDUDO6HxRUQRVHDTXHSRUODPDOGDGGHVXVREUDVPLIXURUVHHQFLHQGDFRPR HOIXHJR\DUGDVLQTXHQDGLHSXHGDDSDJDUOR´-HUHPtDV 1XHVWUDYLGDHVFRPRXQWHUUHQRTXHQRKDVLGRWUDEDMDGRHVWiWDQGXURTXHQRSXHGHVVHPEUDUODVHPLOOD \VLODVLHPEUDVQRGXUDPXFKRVLQRTXHPXHUH\DTXHQRWLHQHSURIXQGLGDG+D\TXHQRWDUWDPELpQTXHORV DJULFXOWRUHVFRQWLQXDPHQWHHVWiQEDUEHFKDQGRHOWHUUHQRPHWLHQGRHODUDGRFDGDYH]HQORPiVSURIXQGR SDUDYROWHDUODWLHUUD\TXHVHDPiVSURGXFWLYD\HOWHUUHQRQRVHHQGXUH]FDSRUHQFLPD(VWRSDVDWDPELpQHQ QXHVWURVFRUD]RQHVFDGDYH]TXHQRVDUUHSHQWLPRV\OORUDPRVHQHODOWDU3HURFXDQGRHODUUHSHQWLPLHQWRQR HVDOJRSURIXQGR\JHQXLQRKDFHPRVTXHQXHVWURFRUD]yQVHHQGXUH]FD\QRVYROYHPRVVXSHU¿FLDOHV 3DUDURPSHUFRQHVWDGXUH]DGHQXHVWURFRUD]yQQHFHVLWDPRVFDYDUSURIXQGRGHQWURGHQRVRWURVWDOFRPR HODJULFXOWRUORKDFHFRQODWLHUUD ¢4XpVHUiORTXHQHFHVLWDPRVKDFHU"&DUORV)LQQH\XQIDPRVRSUHGLFDGRUGH,QJODWHUUDKDEOyGHHVWH WHPDGXUDQWHORVDxRV)LQQH\GLMRTXHKDEtDSHUVRQDVTXHLQWHQWDEDQ³6(17,56(0$/´SRUVXV SHFDGRV1DGLHSXHGHLQWHQWDUVHQWLUVHPDOSRUVXVSURSLDVIXHU]DV6LORWUDWDPRVWRPDPRVHOULHVJRGH HQGXUHFHUQXHVWURFRUD]yQDXQPiVFDGDYH]3HURVtKD\DOJRTXHSRGHPRVKDFHU3RGHPRVSRQHUQXHVWUD DWHQFLyQHQDOJRKDVWDTXHOOHJXHQORVVHQWLPLHQWRV/RTXHQHFHVLWDPRVKDFHUSDUDURPSHUHVHFRUD]yQ GXUR\TXHVHKDJDEODQGRDQWH'LRVHVPLUDU\H[DPLQDUQXHVWURFRUD]yQ«VLQDSXUDUQRV«GHEHPRVYHU KDFLDQXHVWURLQWHULRU'HEHPRVH[DPLQDUVLUHDOPHQWHHVWDPRVFDPLQDQGRFRQ'LRVFDGDGtDRHVWDPRV FDPLQDQGRFRQHOGLDEOR6LHVWDPRVVLUYLHQGRD'LRVRDOGLDEOR\VLHVWDPRVEDMRHOFRQWUROGH'LRVRQR (VWDHVXQDFODVHPX\HVSHFLDOTXHYDDFDPELDUWXYLGDVLSXHGHVUHFLELUODYLVLyQ\SXHGHVWHQHUXQ DUUHSHQWLPLHQWRJHQXLQR 0LHQWUDVYDQOH\HQGRODOLVWDGHSHFDGRVStGHOHD'LRVTXHDEODQGHWXFRUD]yQ3tGHOHTXHWHGHXQ YHUGDGHURDUUHSHQWLPLHQWRGHWDOPDQHUDTXHORSXHGDVVHQWLU @_TcVUf]ZURU 5HFXHUGDORVPRPHQWRVHQORVFXDOHVKDVDFXVDGR D'LRVGHPHQWLUSRUODPDQHUDHQTXHQRFUHHV 6XVSURPHVDV\GHFODUDFLRQHV'LRVKDSURPHWLGR GDUHO(VStULWX6DQWRDORVTXHVHORSLGHQ /XFDV$KRUD¢ORKDVFUHtGR"¢7LHQHV ODH[SHFWDWLYDGHTXHeOWHYDDUHVSRQGHU" ¢9HUGDGTXHFXDQGRRUDVWHSRUHO(VStULWX6DQWR SUiFWLFDPHQWHGLMLVWHHQWXFRUD]yQ<RQRFUHR TXHORYD\DDUHFLELU´"6LQRFUHHVQLWLHQHVOD H[SHFWDWLYDGHUHFLELUODVEHQGLFLRQHVTXH'LRVKD SURPHWLGRORDFXVDVDeOGHPHQWLURVR =R]eRUVR^`ca`c`ec`d 0LUDDOUHGHGRUDWXVDPLJRV\IDPLOLDUHV\ UHFXHUGDTXpWDQSRFDFRPSDVLyQKDVVHQWLGRSRU HOORVKDVHVWDGRDKtSDUDGRVRODPHQWHYLpQGROHV LUGLUHFWRDOLQ¿HUQR\SDUHFHTXHQRWHLPSRUWD ¢&XiQWRVGtDVKDQSDVDGRHQORVFXDOHVQLKDV RUDGRSRUVXFRQGLFLyQQLWLHQHVXQGHVHRSRU VXVDOYDFLyQ"¢<TXpSDVDFRQORVSHUGLGRV" 4XL]iVQLVLTXLHUDWHLQWHUHVDDSUHQGHUGHVX FRQGLFLyQ0LUDHVWR\YHTXpWDQWRWHLQWHUHVDV SRUORVSHUGLGRV\KRQHVWDPHQWHFXiOHVVRQWXV VHQWLPLHQWRVKDFLDHOORV\VLGHVHDVVXVDOYDFLyQ 0LGHWXGHVLQWHUpVSRUVXVDOYDFLyQDOQHJDUWHD SUDFWLFDUHOGDUSDUDTXHOHVOOHJXHHO(YDQJHOLR ¢7HKDVQHJDGRDXQDODVFRVDVEiVLFDVGHODYLGD FRPRXQFDIpRXQUHIUHVFR"¢7HKDVOLPLWDGRHQ WXYLGD\YLYLGRLQFRQYHQLHQWHVSDUDTXHHOORVVHDQ VDOYRV"¢2UDVDGLDULRSRUHOORV"¢'DVGHWXGLQHUR SDUDHO6HxRUFXDQGRYDVDRUDU"6LW~QRHVWiV KDFLHQGRHVWDVFRVDV\QRKD\HQWLXQDDJRQtDSRU ORVSHUGLGRV¢SRUTXpHUHVWDQKLSyFULWD\SUHWHQGHV VHUXQFULVWLDQR"7XSURIHVLyQGHIHHVXQLQVXOWRD -HVXFULVWR =R]eRUVacV`TfaRcdVa`c]R WR^Z]ZR 3LHQVDHQODPDQHUDHQTXHKDVYLYLGRGHODQWHGHWX IDPLOLDFyPRKDVRUDGR\TXpHMHPSOROHVKDVGDGR ¢4XpKDFHVUHJXODUPHQWHSDUDPHMRUDUVXQLYHO HVSLULWXDO"¢4XpGHEHUKDVGHVFXLGDGR" =R]eRUVTfZURU`a`cdfac`aZR gZUR ¢(QFXiQWRVFDVRVKDVHVWDGRWDQDSXUDGRHQWXV DVXQWRVSHUVRQDOHVTXHQRWHKDVGDGRDODWDUHD GHDUUHJODUWXVFXHQWDVFRQ'LRVFXiQWDVYHFHVKDV GHVFXLGDGRFRPSOHWDPHQWHHOYHUWXFRQGXFWD HQWRQFHVEDMDVWXJXDUGLD\SHFDVDQWHHOPXQGR DQWHODLJOHVLD\DQWH'LRV" =R]eRUV_VXRcdVRd^Zd^` +D\PXFKDVSHUVRQDVTXHHVWiQGLVSXHVWRVSDUD KDFHUFXDOTXLHUFRVDHQHOFULVWLDQLVPRTXHQR UHTXLHUDQHJDUVHDVtPLVPRV3HURFXDQGRVH UHTXLHUHTXHKDJDQDOJRGHQHJDUVHDVtPLVPRV GLFHQµ£RKHVGHPDVLDGR¶(OORVSLHQVDQTXHHVWiQ KDFLHQGRDOJRPX\JUDQGHSDUD'LRV\KDFHQ PXFKDVFRVDVSHURQRHVWiQGLVSXHVWRVDGHMDU DOJXQDFRPRGLGDGRELHQHVWDUSDUDVHUYLUDO6HxRU 1RHVWiQGLVSXHVWRVDVXIULUYHUJHQ]DVSRUHO QRPEUHGH&ULVWR7DPSRFRHVWiQGLVSXHVWRVD QHJDUVHDORVOXMRVGHODYLGDSDUDVDOYDUDOPXQGR GHOLQ¿HUQR7DQOHMRVHVWiQHOORVGHUHFRUGDU TXHHOQHJDUVHDVtPLVPRVHVXQDFRQGLFLyQGHO GLVFLSXODGRTXHQRFRQRFHQORTXHHVQHJDUVHD VtPLVPR5HDOPHQWHQXQFDVHKDQQHJDGRDVt PLVPRVHQDOJRSRU&ULVWR\HO(YDQJHOLR£2KTXH SURQWRHVDVSHUVRQDVHVWDUiQHQHOLQ¿HUQR JZV_U``SdeTf]`aRcRbfV`ec`d ecRSR[V_ 4XL]iVKDVGHELOLWDGRVXLQÀXHQFLDSRU LQVLQXDFLRQHVFRQWUDHOORV1RVRORKDVSULYDGRD 'LRVGHWXVWDOHQWRVSHURWDPELpQKDVDWDGRODV PDQRVGHDOJXLHQPiV£4XHVLHUYRWDQPDOYDGR HVHOTXHQRVRORQRKDFHQDGDSHURWDPELpQ REVWDFXOL]DDORVGHPiV(VWRDOJXQDVYHFHVVH KDFHWRPDQGRWLHPSRLQQHFHVDULRRWUDVYHFHV GHVWUX\HQGRODFRQ¿DQ]DGHRWURVFULVWLDQRV$Vt TXHW~KDVFDtGRHQHOMXHJRGH6DWDQiVQRVROR VLHQGRXQRFLRVRSHURVLQGHMDUDRWURVWUDEDMDU DV_eV^f_UR_R ¢&XiOKDVLGRHOHVWDGRGHVXFRUD]yQFRQ UHVSHFWRDVXVSRVHVLRQHVPXQGDQDV"¢/DVKD PLUDGRFRPRUHDOPHQWHVX\DV±FRPRVLWXYLHUD XQGHUHFKRSDUDGLVSRQHUGHHOODVGHDFXHUGR DVXSURSLDYROXQWDG"6LORKDKHFKRHVFUtEDOR 6LKDDPDGRHVDSRVHVLyQ\ODKDEXVFDGRSDUD VXSURSLRELHQRSDUDVDWLVIDFHUODOXMXULDROD DPELFLyQRXQHVStULWXPXQGDQRRJXDUGDUORSDUD VXVIDPLOLDVXVWHGKDSHFDGR\GHEHDUUHSHQWLUVH FcXf]]` +D]XQDFROHFFLyQGHWRGRVORVPRPHQWRVTXH SXHGDVGRQGHW~PLVPRGHWHFWHVTXHXVDVWHHO RUJXOOR/DYDQLGDGHVXQDPDQHUDSDUWLFXODUGHO RUJXOOR¢&XiQWDVYHFHVWHKDVGDGRFXHQWDGH TXHHVWiVVLHQGRYDQLGRVRDHQWXDSDULHQFLD\ YHVWLGR"¢&XiQWDVYHFHVKDVWRPDGRPiVWLHPSR HQDUUHJODUWXFXHUSRSDUDDVLVWLUDODLJOHVLDTXH HQSUHSDUDUWXPHQWHSDUDDODEDUDO6HxRU"7HKDV FXLGDGRPiVHQWXDSDULHQFLDH[WHUQDSDUDTXHOD YHDHOKRPEUHPRUWDOTXHHQODDSDULHQFLDGHWX DOPDSDUDTXHODYHDHO'LRVTXHEXVFDFRUD]RQHV 'HKHFKRWHKDVSXHVWRDWLPLVPRSDUDTXHRWURV WHDODEHQHQYH]GHSUHSDUDUWHSDUDDODEDUD'LRV +DVEXVFDGRGLYLGLUODDODEDQ]DGHODFDVDGH'LRV TXLWDQGRODDWHQFLyQGHODJHQWHHQ'LRVSDUDTXH YHDQWXERQLWDDSDULHQFLD(VHQYDQRSUHWHQGHU DKRUDTXHQRWHLQWHUHVDORTXHODJHQWHSLHQVD GHWL6HDKRQHVWRDFRQHVWR¢6HWRPDUtDXVWHG WRGDVHVDVPROHVWLDVVLODVSHUVRQDVHVWXYLHUDQ FLHJDV" <_XR` (VFULEHWRGRVORVFDVRVHQORVTXHKDVHVWDGRFRQ XQDSHUVRQD\OHKDVKHFKRDOJRTXHQRTXLVLHUDV TXHDOJXLHQWHKLFLHUDDWL'LRVQRVKDGDGRXQD UHJODHQHVWHFDVR³7RGDVODVFRVDVTXHTXLHUHV TXHORVKRPEUHVWHKDJDQKiFHODVW~DHOORV´ (VWDHVODUHJOD<VLQRORVKDVKHFKRHUHVXQ HQJDxDGRU5HFXHUGDODUHJODQRHVTXHVROR KDJDVORTXHVDEHVTXHHOORVSRGUtDQSRUWL\D TXHHVWRHVORPLVPRTXHKDFHQORVSHFDGRUHV/D UHJODHV³+D]OHVORVTXLHUHVTXHHOORVWHKDJDQ´ ?Za`TcVdR 3RUHMHPSORHQVXVRUDFLRQHV\FRQIHVLRQHVD 'LRV(VFULEHORVFDVRVHQORVFXDOHVRUDVWHSRU FRVDVTXHUHDOPHQWHQRTXHUtDV<ODHYLGHQFLD HVTXHFXDQGRWHUPLQDVGHRUDUVHWHROYLGy SRUORTXHHVWDEDVRUDQGR¢&XiQWDVYHFHV KDVFRQIHVDGRSHFDGRVTXHQLVLTXLHUDTXHUtDV GHMDUGHKDFHUQRWHQtDVHOSURSyVLWRGHGHMDUGH UHSHWLUORV"6LKDVFRQIHVDGRSHFDGRVDXQFXDQGR VDEtDVTXHLEDVDUHJUHVDU\YROYHUORVDKDFHU I`SRcR;Z`d 3LHQVDHQORVPRPHQWRVHQORVFXDOHVKDV PDOJDVWDGRWXWLHPSRJDVWDQGRODVKRUDVTXH 'LRVWHKDGDGRSDUDVHUYLUOH\JDQDUDOPDVHQ HQWUHWHQLPLHQWRVYDQRVRFRQYHUVDFLRQHVQHFLDV OH\HQGRQRYHODVRKDFLHQGRQDGDFDVRVHQORV TXHKDVDSOLFDGRPDOWXVWDOHQWRVGRQGHKDV JDVWDGRGLQHURHQWXVSURSLRVOXMRVRJDVWDGRHQ FRVDVTXHQRQHFHVLWDEDVTXHQRFRQWULEXtDQDWX VDOXGFRQIRUWRXWLOLGDG /HFFLyQ &HULOORV GHDOWD 9HORFLGDG 1dVRXcRUVTZU`2 ³'HQJUDFLDVDO6(f25SRUTXHpOHV EXHQRVXJUDQDPRUSHUGXUDSDUD VLHPSUH´6DOPR -HV~VVDQDDGLH]/HSURVRV /HHU/XFDV JUDGHFLPLHQWRHVDOJRTXH'LRVDPD\EXVFDHQODJHQWH$JUDGHFLPLHQWRVLJQL¿FDTXH DGPLWLPRVDOJRTXHQRKXELpUDPRVSRGLGRKDFHUSRUQRVRWURVPLVPRV\UHFRQRFHPRVOD D\XGDTXHYLQRGHRWURV(QHVWHFDVR-HV~VIXHHOTXHVDQyDORVOHSURVRVSRUPHGLR GHOSRGHUGH'LRV-HV~VQRIXHHQYLDGRDVDQDUORVSHURWXYRFRPSDVLyQGHHVWRVFXDQGR HOORVFODPDURQDeO\eOORVVDQy 'HORVKRPEUHVTXHIXHURQVDQDGRVVRODPHQWHXQRUHJUHVyDGDUOHODVJUDFLDVD-HV~V¢4Xp SDVyFRQORVRWURVQXHYH"(VIiFLOSDUDQRVRWURVMX]JDUDHVRVSRUVXIDOWDGHDJUDGHFLPLHQWR SHURQRVRWURVORKDFHPRVWRGRHOWLHPSR'LRVFRQVWDQWHPHQWHQRVHVWiD\XGDQGRPLQLVWUDQGR\ VXSOLHQGRQXHVWUDVQHFHVLGDGHV\QRVRWURVQRVJR]DPRVGHTXHQXHVWUDVQHFHVLGDGHVKDVVLGR VXSOLGDVSHURVHJXLPRVFRQQXHVWURGtDVLQXQVLPSOH³JUDFLDV´-HV~VVHxDODHQHVWDSDUiEROD TXHHOKRPEUHDJUDGHFLGRHUDXQVDPDULWDQRRVHDXQH[WUDQMHUR 0XFKDVYHFHVODJHQWHTXHQRHVFULVWLDQDHVPiVDJUDGHFLGDFRQ'LRVTXHORVFULVWLDQRV(OORV VHVLHQWHQDJUDGHFLGRVFXDQGR'LRVOHVKDFHDOJRHVSHFLDO\QRVRWURVFRPRFULVWLDQRVFRPR TXHQRVDFRVWXPEUDPRVDTXH'LRVVHPXHYD\WUDEDMHHQQXHVWUDVYLGDV\QRVROYLGDPRVGH VLPSOHPHQWHGHFLUOHJUDFLDV ¢4XpKL]R'LRVHQWXYLGDODVHPDQDSDVDGD"£'DOHJUDFLDVDeOSRUHOOR(VWDHVXQDOHFFLyQ VHQFLOODSHURHVPX\LPSRUWDQWH£6($*5$'(&,'2 8 ¢(QTXpFRVDVQRUPDOPHQWHVRPRVDJUDGHFLGRV" ¢4XpVHUtDDOJRFRPSOHWDPHQWHGLIHUHQWHPX\VLPSOHRH[WUDxRSRUOR TXHSRGHPRVHVWDUDJUDGHFLGRV" defUZ`ViecR (QFXHQWUDYHUVRVHQORV6DOPRVTXHPHQFLRQHQHOGDUJUDFLDV < FULVWRHV 7DUHD/XFDV 3iJLQDV (O0DHVWUR -XDQ R^`dRTRdR g /DWDUHDGHHVWDVHPDQDVHUiGHFLU³JUDFLDV´HQGLIHUHQWHVRFDVLRQHVGXUDQWH ODVHPDQD /HFFLyQ ³«&ULVWR-HV~VYLQRDOPXQGRDVDOYDUDORV SHFDGRUHVGHORVFXDOHV\RVR\HOSULPHUR´ 7LPRWHRE 1RdT`^`VcVd2 =DTXHRHOUHFDXGDGRUGH,PSXHVWRV /HHU/XFDV XFKRVGHQRVRWURVFRQRFHPRVODKLVWRULDGH=DTXHRHOKRPEUHTXHVHVXELyDXQiUERO SDUDYHUD-HV~V¢3HURFXiQWRVGHXVWHGHVVDEHQTXHHVWHKRPEUHHUDPX\ULFR" £7DPELpQHUDXQSHFDGRUeOQRLEDDODLJOHVLDQRD\XGDEDHQQDGDDORVFULVWLDQRV¢6H SXHGHQLPDJLQDUDO3UHVLGHQWH0XQLFLSDOELHQYHVWLGRFRQVXWUDMHVXELpQGRVHDXQiUERO"$KRUD LPDJtQDWHTXHHVWHKRPEUHULFRVHVXEHDXQiUEROSDUDYHUDXQKHUPDQRTXHOOHJDDODFLXGDG SDUDWHQHUXQDFDPSDxDHYDQJHOtVWLFD¢1RHVHVWRUDUR" =DTXHRHUDFKDSDUULWR\FRQPXFKRGLQHUR7DPELpQpOHUDSHFDGRU1RDVLVWtDDODLJOHVLD UHJXODUPHQWH1RHUDDOJXLHQTXH-HV~VHVFRJHUtDSDUDDQGDUFRQpO1RHUDDOJXLHQTXHODJHQWH SHQVDUDTXHPHUHFtDODDWHQFLyQGHXQSURIHWDIDPRVR/D(VFULWXUDGLFHTXH-HV~VYLQRDEXVFDU \DVDOYDUORTXHVHKDEtDSHUGLGR=DTXHRHVWDEDSHUGLGRSHURWHQtDPXFKRLQWHUpVHQODVFRVDV GH'LRVHVWRORGHPXHVWUDHOKHFKRGHTXHDXQTXHHUDULFRVHVXELyDXQiUEROSDUDYHUPHMRUD -HV~VPLHQWUDVSDVDED -HV~VTXLHUHOOHJDUDWLKR\DVtFRPRHUHV1RWLHQHVTXHFDPELDUXQPRQWyQGHFRVDVDQWHVGH TXHeOWHHQFXHQWUHeOHVQXHVWUR6DOYDGRU\QRHVWiHVSHUDQGRTXHVHDVSHUIHFWRDQWHVGHTXH WHDFHUTXHVDeOeOGHVHDUHXQLUVHFRQWLJRDVtFRPRHUHVSRUTXHeOWHDPD\WHFRQRFH\KD YHQLGRSDUDVDOYDUWHeOTXLHUHHVWDUFRQWLJRFRPRORKL]RFRQ=DTXHR -HV~VIXHDVXFDVDFHQyFRQpO\OD%LEOLDQRGLFHTXH-HV~VORKD\DSUHVLRQDGRROHKD\D KDEODGRGHDOJR=DTXHRVRORVHVLQWLyPRYLGRSDUDGDU\GHFODUDTXHYDDGDUODPLWDGGHWRGR ORTXHWLHQHDODJHQWHSREUH¢5HFXHUGDQTXHpOHUDPX\ULFR"£4XHGHFLVLyQWDQHQRUPHKDFHpO DTXt -HV~VTXLHUHOOHJDUFRQWLJR\FRQPLJRDVtFRPRVRPRVeOTXLHUHµMXQWDUVHFRQWLJRSDUDFHQDU\ TXHGDUVHHQWXFDVD¶eOHVWiEXVFDQGRODVFRVDVQRUPDOHV\QRWLHQHVTXHFDPELDUORTXHHUHV SDUDTXH-HV~VTXLHUDOOHJDUFRQWLJReOWHFRQRFHDVtFRPRHUHV\WRGDYtDTXLHUHSDVDUWLHPSR FRQWLJR ¢4XpGLFHVW~"¢$EULUiVODSXHUWDGHWXYLGDD-HV~VKR\" 0DHVWURV3RUIDYRUGLULMDQHQVXFODVHXQDRUDFLyQSDUDTXHDEUDQVXYLGDD-HV~VKR\ D ¢&XiOHVVRQDOJXQDVH[SHFWDWLYDVGHOPXQGRSDUDQXHVWURDVSHFWRH[WHUQR" 7DUHD/XFDV ¢'HHVDVH[SHFWDWLYDVFXiOHVVRQWDPELpQGH'LRVHQOD%LEOLD" 3iJLQDV\ +D]XQDOLVWDGHFRVDVGHWXSHUVRQDTXH'LRVWHKDGDGR\QRSXHGHVFDPELDU defUZ`ViecR/HH6D\FRPHQWHQFyPRHVWDKLVWRULDGHOD%LEOLDVH UHODFLRQDFRQHVWDOHFFLyQ < FULVWRHV $PRU -XDQ R^`dRTRdR g (VWDVHPDQDGHEHUiVSURQXQFLDUXQDIUDVH UHSHWLWLYDFDGDQRFKHDQWHVGHGRUPLU«³'LRVPH DPDDVtFRPRVR\´ +XHYR )ORWDQGR /HFFLyQ 3DVD %DLODGRUD ³/RVTXHYLYHQHQUHPRWRVOXJDUHVVHDVRPEUDQ DQWHWXVSURGLJLRVGHORULHQWHDORFFLGHQWHW~ LQVSLUDVFDQFLRQHVGHDOHJUtD´6DOPR 18]SR]V2 /DHQWUDGD7ULXQIDO /HHU/XFDV XDQGRQRVRWURVGHFLGLPRVDODEDUD'LRVQRUPDOPHQWHFDQWDPRVXQFDQWR JULWDPRVXQDDODEDQ]DDeOOHYDQWDPRVODVPDQRVRQRVDUURGLOODPRV $ODEDPRVD'LRVSRUTXHeOHVQXHVWUR5H\eOHVPiVJUDQGHTXHQRVRWURV \eOKDKHFKRFRVDVPDUDYLOORVDVSDUDQRVRWURV/RDODEDPRVDeOSRU6XVPLODJURVSRU6X SDODEUDSDUDQRVRWURV\SRUTXHeOHVGLJQRGHQXHVWUDDODEDQ]D¢$TXpVHSDUHFHODDODEDQ]D\ ODDGRUDFLyQ"¢4XpHVORTXHKDFHQHQVXLJOHVLD" (OGtDGHODHQWUDGDWULXQIDOGH-HV~VD-HUXVDOpQIXHXQSRTXLWRGLIHUHQWHSRUTXHWRGRVHVWDEDQ HQODFDOOH(VWDEDQHQS~EOLFR\KDEtDXQDPXOWLWXGGHJHQWHUHXQLGD-HV~VHQWUyD-HUXVDOpQ PRQWDGRHQXQEXUURSDUDFXPSOLUODSURIHFtDGHVXHQWUDGDFRPRUH\\PLHQWUDVTXHHQWUDED DODFLXGDGODJHQWHFRPHQ]yDDODEDUOH/DJHQWHXVyVXVPDQRVSDUDDGRUDUOHSXVRVXV FKDPDUUDVHQHOVXHOR\KRMDVGHiUEROFRPRVLHVWXYLHUDQSRQLHQGRXQDµDOIRPEUDURMD¶SDUD TXHeOSXGLHUDSDVDUSRUDKt/DJHQWHWDPELpQXVyVXVYRFHVSDUDJULWDUDODEDQ]DVD-HV~V GHFODUiQGRORFRPRUH\\GiQGROHODJORULDDeO(UDLPSRUWDQWHTXHHOORVDODEDUDQD-HV~V SRUTXH³VLHOORVQRORKDFtDQODVSLHGUDVLEDQDJULWDU´7RGRHO8QLYHUVRREVHUYDEDPLHQWUDVHO 5H\HQWUDEDDODFLXGDG\IXHQDWXUDOODDODEDQ]D/DDODEDQ]DHVQDWXUDOSDUDWL\SDUDPtKR\ DVtFRPRORIXHSDUDPXFKRVHQDTXHOGtD-HV~VKDOOHJDGR\DHQWUDGRHQQXHVWUDYLGDVKD KHFKRPLODJURVSDUDTXHQRVRWURVORVYHDPRV\KDFDPELDGRDOPXQGR$OJRGHQWURGHQRVRWURV VDEHTXHGHEHPRVJULWDUDODEDQ]DDO5H\GHUH\HV7DPELpQGHEHPRVGHMDUFRVDVDVXVSLHV XVDQGRQXHVWUDVPDQRV\YR]SDUDEULQGDUOHDODEDQ]DDeO6LQRVRWURVQRORDODEDPRVDOJXLHQ RDOJRORKDUiQ£3HUR'LRVVHUiDODEDGR1RUPDOPHQWHSHQVDPRVTXHODDODEDQ]DD'LRVVRQ FDQWRVTXHOHFDQWDPRVDeOSHURWDPELpQSXHGHVHUPXFKRPiVTXHHVR/DDODEDQ]DLQFOX\H FDQWRVJULWRVYLYLUFRUUHFWDPHQWHVDFUL¿FLRV\RIUHQGD6XYLGDGHVDFUL¿FLRHVXQDIRUPDGH DGRUDU3HURDXQFXDQGRQRVRWURVDODEDPRVD'LRVFRQQXHVWUDVDFFLRQHVKD\WLHPSRVFXDQGR GHEHPRV*5,7$5DODEDQ]DVDeO-HV~VHVGLJQRGHQXHVWUDDODEDQ]DeOHVQXHVWUR6HxRUeO HVQXHVWUR5H\HQWRQFHV£$/È%$/( 0DHVWURV7RPDXQRVPLQXWRVSDUDJULWDUD-HV~VDKtHQVXFODVH3XHGHVJULWDUORPLVPRTXH HOORVJULWDURQHQHVWDKLVWRULD³£%HQGLWRHOTXHYLHQHHQHOQRPEUHGHO6HxRU£+RVDQQDHQODV DOWXUDV£3D]HQHOFLHOR\JORULDHQODVDOWXUDV´'H0DWHR\/XFDV : GDVHQXQEXHQWLHPSRHQDGRUDFLyQHQODFODVH 7DUHD/XFDV 3iJLQDV\ FULVWRHV 5H\(WHUQR -HUHPtDV R^`dRTRdR g 7XWDUHDHVTXHDODEHVD'LRVHQODVHPDQD3XHGHVJULWDU ³$OHOX\D´FDGDGtDSXHGHVFDQWDUXQFDQWRHQODFDVDR SXHGHVRUDUD'LRVGLFLpQGROHTXHWDQPDUDYLOORHV(VFRJHTXpHVOR TXHYDVDKDFHU /HFFLyQ 1DR_eV_eV]Z^aZ`2 ³&UHDHQPtRK'LRVXQFRUD]yQOLPSLR\ UHQXHYDOD¿UPH]DGHPLHVStULWX´6DOPR -HV~VHQHO7HPSOR /HHU/XFDV DKLVWRULDGHKR\HVGHFyPR-HV~VHQFRQWUyDODJHQWHKDFLHQGRGLQHUR\UREDQGRDRWURV $'(1752GHOWHPSORODIRUPDHQTXHVHHQRMyVLQSHFDU\ORVVDFyDWRGRV(VWDVHULH GH³(O/DERUDWRULRGH/XFDV´WLHQHXQHQIRTXHHVSHFt¿FRHQODDSOLFDFLyQGHYHUGDGHV DQXHVWUDYLGD1RVRORHVWDUHPRVHVWXGLDQGRORTXH-HV~VKL]RHQHOWHPSORDTXHOGtDVLQR YLHQGRODPDQHUDHQFyPRDSOLFDUORDQXHVWUDVYLGDV¢7~SXHGHVYHUXQDPDQHUDGHDSOLFDU HVWDOHFFLyQ"8QDDSOLFDFLyQREYLDHVTXHGHEHPRVGHWUDWDUDQXHVWUDVLJOHVLDVFRQUHVSHWR HOODVVRQOODPDGDV³&DVDVGH2UDFLyQ´(OHGL¿FLRGRQGHYDPRVDDODEDUD'LRVGHEHVHUWUDWDGR ELHQHVWDUOLPSLR\TXHQRHVWHPRVUREDQGRRKDFLHQGRWUDPSDDGHQWUR(VWHGtDYDPRVDYHU XQDDSOLFDFLyQTXHTXL]iVQRHVWDQREYLD(QFRQWUDPRVHQHO1XHYR7HVWDPHQWRTXHQXHVWURV FXHUSRVVRQWHPSORGHO6HxRU&R'LRVQRHVWiEXVFDQGRHGL¿FLRVGRQGHYLYLUVLQRTXH VHUHJRFLMDHQQRVRWURV6XVKLMRVeOTXLHUHHQWUDUDQXHVWURVFRUD]RQHV'HKHFKRHOFRUD]yQHV ODSDUWHPiVLPSRUWDQWHGHWRGRHOFXHUSR³3RUVREUHWRGDVODVFRVDVFXLGDWXFRUD]yQSRUTXH GHpOPDQDODYLGD´3U'RQGHTXLHUDTXHYDPRVODJHQWHHVWiSUHRFXSDGDHQFyPRQRV YHPRVQXHVWUDURSDHOFRORUGHQXHVWUDSLHO\QXHVWURFRPSRUWDPLHQWRH[WHUQR3HURHVWRQR HVORTXHOHLQWHUHVDD'LRVTXLHQHVODSHUVRQDSULQFLSDODODTXHGHEHPRVTXHUHULPSUHVLRQDU \DJUDGDU³/DJHQWHVH¿MDHQODVDSDULHQFLDVSHUR\RPH¿MRHQHOFRUD]yQ´6E+D\ PXFKDVKLVWRULDVSRUWRGDOD%LEOLDTXHFRQ¿UPDQHVWHYHUVR\HVWHFRQFHSWR'LRVHVWiLQWHUHVDGR HQQXHVWURVFRUD]RQHV/DYHUGDGHVTXHQXHVWURVFRUD]RQHVVHSXHGHQHQVXFLDU\RFXSDU FRPRHVWDEDQORVYHQGHGRUHV\ODGURQHVHQHOWHPSORHOGtDTXH-HV~VORVVDFy3RGHPRVHVWDU GHPDVLDGRHQIRFDGRVHQHOGLQHUR«PLQWLpQGRQRVDQRVRWURVPLVPRV«HQJDxDQGRGHXQD PDQHUDHQTXHSHQVDPRVTXHQDGLHQRVYDDGHVFXEULU«\ODOLVWDFRQWLQ~D&RPR'LRVHVWi PiVSUHRFXSDGRSRUQXHVWURVFRUD]RQHVTXHSRUFXDOTXLHURWUDFRVD\SRUTXHOD%LEOLDGLFHTXH DKRUDVRPRVHOWHPSORGHO6HxRUODPHMRUPDQHUDGHDSOLFDUHVWDOHFFLyQDQXHVWUDVYLGDVKR\HV £/,03,$1'218(67526&25$=21(6 (QyMDWHFRQWXSHFDGRHQyMDWHFRQODIRUPDHQTXHHVFRQGHVFRVDVGH'LRV\VDFDHVWRGHWL 3tGHOHD'LRVTXHWHGHXQFRUD]yQOLPSLRFRPRGLFHQXHVWURYHUVRSDUDPHPRUL]DU³&UHDHQ PtRK'LRVXQFRUD]yQOLPSLR«´6DOPR1RGHMHVTXHODDPDUJXUDRHOHQRMRSURGX]FDQ HVSDFLRVIHRVHQWXFRUD]yQ-HVXFULVWRTXLHUHKDELWDUWH\TXLHUHTXHWH£0$17(1*$6/,03,2 C 8QDGHODVFRVDVTXHSXHGHQUiSLGDPHQWHHQVXFLDUQXHVWURFRUD]yQHVHOFKLVPH ¢4XpHVHOFKLVPH" ¢4XpVXFHGHFXDQGRW~FRPLHQ]DVXQUXPRUVREUHDOJXLHQ\QRHVYHUGDGHUR" 7DUHD/XFDV 3iJLQDV\ ¢&yPRWHVLHQWHVFXDQGRHQFXHQWUDVDRWURVFKLVPHDQGRVREUHWL" defUZ`ViecR /HH1PSDUDYHUXQHMHPSORGHFKLVPH\HOFDVWLJRGH'LRV < FULVWRHV 3LHGUD 3ULQFLSDO 3HGUR R^`dRTRdR g 7XWDUHDHVRUDUSRUXQFRUD]yQOLPSLRPLHQWUDV OLPSLDVDOJRHQWXUHFiPDUD3RUHMHPSORSXHGHV DUUHJODUWXFDPDPLHQWUDVTXHRUDVSRUODOLPSLH]DGHWX FRUD]yQ /RGR 3HJDMRVR /HFFLyQ ³$ODYHUGDGQRPHDYHUJHQ]RGHO HYDQJHOLRSXHVHVSRGHUGH'LRVSDUD ODVDOYDFLyQGHWRGRVORVTXHFUHHQ´ 5RPDQRVD 3DODEUDV 2FXOWDV 1_`eV RgVcX¢V_TVd2 3HGURQLHJDD-HV~V /HHU/XFDV DPHV5HQZLFNIXHDFXVDGR\DUUHVWDGRSRUQHJDUVHDREHGHFHUODDXWRULGDG GHOUH\\DTXHFRQWLQXySUHGLFDQGRHOHYDQJHOLRFXDQGROHRUGHQDURQTXHQR ORKLFLHUDeOIXHVHQWHQFLDGRDPXHUWHSHUROHGLHURQXQDVHPDQDSDUDTXH ORSHQVDUD(OUH\OHRIUHFLyGHMDUORYLYLUVLOHGDEDVXOHDOWDGDpOHQOXJDUGHD-HVXFULVWR6H KDEtDUHXQLGRXQDPXOWLWXGGHSHUVRQDVSDUDYHUORTXHLEDDKDFHUHOGH)HEUHURGHHQ (GLQEHUJK(VFRFLDeOOH\y$SRFDOLSVLV\FDQWyHO6DOPRRUyD'LRVHQIUHQWHGHWRGRV\ GHFLGLyQRQHJDUD-HVXFULVWReOVRORWHQtDDxRVFXDQGRORFROJDURQHQS~EOLFR8QPiUWLUHV DOJXLHQTXHPXHUHSRUVXIHHQ'LRV\ORVHVWXGLRVPXHVWUDQTXHKDQVLGRPiVGHDOD IHFKDSRUWRGRHOPXQGR(OSDUDUVHIUHQWHDRWURVFRQUHVSHFWRDVXFUHHQFLDHQ'LRVQRHVDOJR IiFLOGHKDFHUSHURPXFKRVORKDQKHFKRDXQFXDQGRSLHUGDQVXVWUDEDMRVVHEXUOHQGHHOORVHQ ODHVFXHODVHDQDPHQD]DGRVRPXHUDQ 1XHVWUDIHHQ-HVXFULVWRFRPRQXHVWUR6DOYDGRUQHFHVLWDVHUDVtGHIXHUWH3HGURSHQVyTXHpO WHQtDXQDIHIXHUWHWDPELpQpOSHQVyTXHpOPRULUtDSRU-HVXFULVWRVLOHGDEDQODRSRUWXQLGDG SHURFXQDGROOHJyHOWLHPSR£pOQHJyD&ULVWR(VWDVOiJULPDVWLHQHQTXHKDEHUVDOLGRGHVGHVX FRUD]yQ\FRQPXFKRGRORU£4XHWUHPHQGRHVVDEHUTXHKDVQHJDGRDO~QLFR'LRVYHUGDGHUR 3HUR-HVXFULVWRQRVDPDWDQWRTXHQRVSHUGRQDDXQGHHVWR-HV~VVDEtDTXH3HGURLEDDIDOODU \WRGDYtDORDPy\ORHQWUHQy'HVSXpV'LRVXVyD3HGURSDUDKDFHUWRGRWLSRGHPLQLVWHULRSDUD 6XUHLQR ¢3RUTXpWHQHPRVTXHSRQHUQRV¿UPHVHQQXHVWUDIH\QRDYHUJRQ]DUQRVGHHOOD"¢3RUTXpQR SXGR-DPHV5HQZLFNVRORGHFLUOHDOUH\TXHORSRQtDDpOSRUHQFLPDGH'LRVUHJUHVDUDVXFDVD \FRQWLQXDUSUHGLFDQGR"¢3RUTXpWXYRTXHPRULUSRUVXIH" 6DWDQiVHVWiDTXtHQODWLHUUD\WLHQHXQDFRVDLPSRUWDQWHSRUKDFHUPDWDUUREDU\GHVWUXLUQRV eOTXLHUHVHSDUDUQRVGH'LRVSHUPDQHQWHPHQWH 8QDGHVXVWpFQLFDVIDYRULWDVHVTXHQRVDYHUJRQFHPRVGHQXHVWUR6DOYDGRUGHWDOPDQHUDTXH QRGHMHPRVTXHRWURVVHSDQTXHVRPRVFULVWLDQRV\HQWRQFHVQRVHPSXMDDXQSXQWRGRQGHQRV YHPRVIRU]DGRVDQHJDURUHFRQRFHUS~EOLFDPHQWHD&ULVWR 1RVLHQWDVYHUJHQ]DVLQRSiUDWHFRPRORVPLOHVGHPiUWLUHVDWUDYpVGHODKLVWRULDTXLHQHV PDQWXYLHURQVXIH6LIDOODPRVFRPR3HGURQRVDUUHSHQWLPRV\YROYHPRVD-HV~VTXLHQQRV SHUGRQD\QRVJXtD1RVRWURVWDPELpQSRGHPRVWHQHUODIXHU]DSDUDSDUDUQRVHQIUHQWHGHPXFKD JHQWH\SURFODPDUQXHVWUDIHDVtFRPR3HGURORKL]RPiVWDUGHHQVXYLGD A ¢4XpHVWHQHUYHUJHQ]D" 0HQFLRQDDOJXQDVRFDVLRQHVHQODVTXHKD]WHQLGRYHUJHQ]DGHKDFHUDOJR 7DUHD/XFDV 3iJLQDV\ ¢&yPRKD]YHQFLGRODYHUJHQ]DHQWXYLGD" defUZ`ViecR /HHODKLVWRULDGH0RLVpV\VXOODPDGR YLHQGRe[RGR R^`dRTRdR < g 7XWDUHDHVWDVHPDQDHVOOHYDUXQD%LEOLDDODHVFXHODXQ GtD\OHHUODSRUXQRVPLQXWRV FULVWRHV &RUGHUR GH'LRV -XDQ /HFFLyQ 1;VfURaRXRUR2 ³£$TXtWLHQHQDO&RUGHURGH'LRVTXHTXLWDHO SHFDGRGHOPXQGR´-XDQE /D&UXFL¿[LyQ /HHU/XFDV HVGHHOSULQFLSLRGHORVWLHPSRV'LRVFUHyDOKRPEUHFRQHOSURSyVLWRGHYLYLU\WHQHU FRPXQLyQFRQpO6HVXSRQtDTXHODYLGDLEDDVHUVLQSHFDGR1RKDEUtDKDELGRWUDPSDV URERVPHQWLUDVDSURYHFKDGRV«QLSROtWLFDQLPXHUWH 3HUROOHJyHOGtDIDWDOHQHO-DUGtQGHO(GpQHOKRPEUH\ODPXMHUFRPLHURQGHOiUEROSURKLELGR VLHQGRWHQWDGRVSRUODVHUSLHQWHTXHHUDHOGLDEOR$TXHOGtDTXHHOKRPEUHSHFyHOSHFDGR\ ODPXHUWHHQWUDURQDOPXQGR/RVKXPDQRV\DQRSXGLHURQWHQHUFRPXQLyQFRQ'LRVFRPReO ORKDEtDSODQHDGRRULJLQDOPHQWH/DUHODFLyQVHURPSLy&RPRXQDUUHJORWHPSRUDOODJHQWH GHO$QWLJXR7HVWDPHQWRSRGtDVDFUL¿FDUHQRIUHQGDXQDRYHMDOLPSLDD'LRVFRPRSDJRSRUVXV SHFDGRVSHURVROROHVVHUYtDSRUSRFRWLHPSRGHVSXpVWHQtDQTXHKDFHURWUDRIUHQGD/RV VDFHUGRWHVVRORVHSRGtDQFRPXQLFDUFRQ'LRVXQDYH]DODxRFXDQGRHQWUDEDQHQHOOXJDU 6DQWtVLPR'LRVWXYRXQSODQPDUDYLOORVRTXHFDPELDUtDWRGRHVR(OSODQGH'LRVIXHHQYLDUD VX+LMR-HV~VDOPXQGRFRPRXQKXPDQRSDUDYLYLUXQDYLGDSHUIHFWD\OXHJRVDFUL¿FDUVHDVt PLVPRFRPRHO&RGHURSHUIHFWRSRUQXHVWURVSHFDGRV8QDYH]TXH-HV~VKLFLHUDHVWHVDFUL¿FLR £TXHGDUtDPRVOLEUHVGHSHFDGR<DQRWHQGUtDPRVTXHVDFUL¿FDUFRUGHURVWRGRHOWLHPSR\ £SRGUtDPRVFRPXQLFDUQRVGLUHFWDPHQWHFRQ'LRVFDGDKRPEUHSRUVtPLVPR ¢3HURTXpWXYRTXHKDFHU-HV~V"eOVHGHMyDUUHVWDU\VHUHQMXLFLDGRDXQFXDQGRQRKDEtD KHFKRQDGDPDOR/RFROJDURQHQXQDFUX]FRPRFDVWLJR\PXULy(QHOPRPHQWRHQTXHPXULy -HV~VSDJySRUQXHVWURVSHFDGRV/D%LEOLDQRVHQVHxDTXHHOSDJRSRUHOSHFDGRHVODPXHUWH 7RGRVQRVRWURVKHPRVSHFDGR\DVHDPLQWLHQGRHQJDxDGRUREDQGRPDWDQGRWHQLHQGRFHORV DPDUJXUD\PXFKRVRWURVSHFDGRV\PHUHFHPRVHOFDVWLJRSRUORTXHKHPRVKHFKR£(OFDVWLJR SRUQXHVWURSHFDGRHVODPXHUWH £3HURJUDFLDVD'LRVeOWXYRXQSODQGLIHUHQWH-HVXFULVWRVHRIUHFLyDSDJDUHOFDVWLJRSRU QRVRWURV'LRVQRVRIUHFHHOUHJDORGHVDOYDFLyQDWUDYpVGHVX+LMR-HV~V£6LQRVRWURVOR DFHSWDPRVSRGHPRVVHUOLEUHVGHQXHVWURSHFDGR (VWRQRTXLHUHGHFLUTXHQXQFDYDPRVDSHFDUVRORVLJQL¿FDTXHDFWXDOPHQWHHVWDPRVOLEUHVGHO FDVWLJRSRUQXHVWURVSHFDGRV£(VWRHVWDQDVRPEURVR1RKD\QDGDPiVTXHSRGDPRVKDFHU SDUDJDQDUQXHVWUDVDOYDFLyQ-HV~V\DSDJyHOSUHFLRFRQ6XYLGD3RUTXHKHPRVSHFDGRW~ \\RWHQHPRVXQDJUDQGHXGDTXHSDJDU1XHVWURFDVWLJRHVODPXHUWHHWHUQD-HVXFULVWRYLQR DODWLHUUDVRORSDUDYLYLUXQDYLGDSHUIHFWDWRPDUQXHVWUROXJDU\SDJDUHOSUHFLRSRUQXHVWURV SHFDGRV6XPXHUWH3$*Ï/$'(8'$£\DKRUDVRPRVOLEUHV£*ORULDD'LRV ; ¢&yPRWHVHQWLUtDVVLWXVSDSiVWHGLMHUDQTXHHVWDVHPDQDW~YDVDVXIULUHO FDVWLJRSRUORTXHKLFLHURQWXVKHUPDQRV" 7DUHD/XFDV ¢(QTXpRFDVLRQHVDOJXLHQKDSDJDGRXQDGHXGDSRUWL" 3iJLQDV\ ¢4XpHVODVDOYDFLyQ" defUZ`ViecR /HH,VDtDV\FRPHQWHQGHORTXH-HV~VKL]RSRUFDGDXQRGHXVWHGHV < FULVWRHV (O5HGHQWRU 6DOPR R^`dRTRdR g £&RPRUHFXHUGRGHODGHXGDSDJDGDGHQXHVWURV SHFDGRVEXVFDODGHXGDGHRWUR\SiJDOD4XL]iV GXOFHV¿DGRVRDOJR &DSDV 6HSDUDGDV /HFFLyQ 3RGHU ([SORVLYR 1:V]ScR]` ³(VWXYHPXHUWRSHURDKRUDYLYRSRUORVVLJORVGHORV VLJORV\WHQJRODVOODYHVGHODPXHUWH\GHOLQ¿HUQR´ $SRFDOLSVLVD /D5HVXUUHFFLyQ /HHU/XFDV QDJUDQPXOWLWXGHVWDEDOOHJDQGRDOÈQJHOGHOD,QGHSHQGHQFLDPLHQWUDV GDEDQJULWRVGHM~ELORTXHVHHVFXFKDEDQSRUWRGDVSDUWHV/DJHQWHHVWDED FHOHEUDQGR«FRPLHQGRGXOFHV\JRORVLQDVVDOXGDQGRDSHUVRQDVTXHQL VLTXLHUDFRQRFtDQEULQFDQGR\JULWDQGRFRQJR]R£0p[LFRDFDEDGHJDQDUOD&RSD0XQGLDO6XE /D¿HVWDFRQWLQXDUtDWRGDODQRFKHPLHQWUDVWRGRVMXQWRVJULWDEDQ£6tVH3XGR /DFHOHEUDFLyQTXHWRGRVORVPH[LFDQRVKLFLHURQHVHGtDHVXQJUDQHMHPSORSDUDQRVRWURV GHOJR]RGHO'RPLQJRGHUHVXUUHFFLyQ/DUHVXUUHFFLyQGHQXHVWUR6HxRUHVXQRGHORVSXQWRV SULQFLSDOHVTXHQRVVHSDUDQGHRWUDVUHOLJLRQHV1XHVWUR6DOYDGRUQRHVWiPXHUWRFRPRRWURV £VLQRTXHUHVXFLWyGHODPXHUWH\HVWiYLYRKR\+D\PXFKDVUHOLJLRQHVFRQSURIHWDVRVDQWRV SHURWRGRVHVWiQPXHUWRV(QOD%LEOLDWDPELpQKD\PXFKDVUHOLJLRQHVSHURHOORVDGRUDEDQD tGRORVGHRURTXHUHSUHVHQWDEDQDOtGHUHVPXHUWRVXREMHWRVPXHUWRV(OORVLQYHQWDEDQUHOLJLRQHV GHOVRORGHRWUDVFRVDV£SHURQRKD\QDGDFRPRQXHVWUDUHOLJLyQHQWRGRHOPXQGR£/RV FULVWLDQRVDODEDPRVDXQ'LRVTXHHVWiYLYR-HV~VYLQRDODWLHUUDFRPRXQKRPEUHVDFUL¿FyVX YLGDSRUQXHVWURVSHFDGRVPXULHQGRHQODFUX]£\DOWHUFHUGtDeOUHVXFLWyGHODPXHUWH 'HKHFKRFRPRQXHVWURYHUVRGHPHPRULDGLFH£-HV~VDKRUDWLHQHODVOODYHVGHODPXHUWH\ GHOLQ¿HUQR1LQJ~QKXPDQRSXHGHHQJDxDUDODPXHUWH(VXQSRGHUPiVIXHUWHTXHQRVRWURV (QFXDOTXLHUPRPHQWRSRGHPRVHQFRQWUDUQRVHQXQDVLWXDFLyQSHOLJURVD\PRULU-HVXFULVWRVLQ HPEDUJRHVVXSHULRUDODPXHUWHSRUTXHeOPXULy\UHVXFLWyeOQXQFDYROYHUiDPRULU £(VWHHVXQFRQFHSWRWDQPDUDYLOORVRTXHYDOHODSHQDFHOHEUDUOR£(VWRHVDOJRPiVJUDQGHTXH JDQDUOD&RSD0XQGLDOSRUTXHWRGDODUD]DKXPDQDDKRUDSXHGHWHQHUYLGDHWHUQD(VWRHVOD FRVDPiVJUDQGHGHWRGRHOSODQHWD\DOJRTXHODJHQWHGHWRGDVODVQDFLRQHVSXHGHQFHOHEUDU MXQWRV£3HURSDUHFHTXHQRVRWURVVDEHPRVFHOHEUDUPHMRUHOI~WERO£1RHVTXHWHQJDPRVTXH FHOHEUDUPHQRVHOI~WEROSHURFHOHEUHPRVPiVODUHVXUUHFFLyQ£,QYRO~FUHQVHJULWHQEULQTXHQ TXpGHQVHGHVSLHUWRVWRGDODQRFKHFRPDQPXFKDVJRORVLQDVYLVLWDPXFKRVIDPLOLDUHV\DPLJRV JXDUGDPXFKRGLQHUR\JiVWDORGHXQDPDQHUDGLYHUWLGD£1XHVWUR6DOYDGRU-HVXFULVWRHVWiYLYR SDJySRUQXHVWURVSHFDGRV\YDOHODSHQD&(/e%5$/2 L ¢&XiOHVODIHFKDTXHPiVFHOHEUDV\FyPRODFHOHEUDV" ¢&yPRFHOHEUDUtDVODUHVXUUHFFLyQGH-HV~V" ¢&XDOHVODGLIHUHQFLDHQWUH-HVXFULVWR0DKRPD\%XGD" defUZ`ViecR /HHe[RGR±SDUDYHUODFHOHEUDFLyQFRQ0RLVpV < R^`dRTRdR g /DWDUHDSDUDFDGDDOXPQRHVSODQHDUXQD¿HVWDSDUD FHOHEUDUODUHVXUUHFFLyQHQVXFDVDFRPXQLGDGRFODVH\ £ORJUDUOR 7DUHD/XFDV 3iJLQDV\ FULVWRHV /D 5HVXUUHFFLyQ -XDQ 1_`UfUVd2 /HFFLyQ ³3RUTXHPHKDVYLVWRKDVFUHtGR²OHGLMR-HV~V² GLFKRVRVORVTXHQRKDQYLVWR\VLQHPEDUJRFUHHQ´ -XDQ -HV~VVHDSDUHFHDORV'LVFtSXORV /HHU/XFDV X\DGHQWURGHQRVRWURVTXHUHPRVFRPSODFHUDQXHVWURVSDSiV1RVVRxDPRVWUDEDMDQGR HQXQSUR\HFWRFRQQXHVWURSDSiGRQGHpOQRVGLJDTXpWDQRUJXOORVRVHVLHQWHSRU QXHVWURWUDEDMR7DPELpQTXHUHPRVTXHQXHVWURVPDHVWURVVHVLHQWDQRUJXOORVRV GHQRVRWURV\QRVGHQFDOL¿FDFLRQHVPX\EXHQDV4XHUHPRVp[LWREXHQDVFDOL¿FDFLRQHV\ SRSXODULGDG4XHUHPRVKDFHUGLQHURFXDQGRFUH]FDPRV7RGRVORVKXPDQRVWHQHPRVXQGHVHR HQQXHVWURLQWHULRUGHWHQHUp[LWR$OJXQDVYHFHVSDVDQFRVDVGLItFLOHVTXHQRVKDFHQUHQXQFLDUR SHUGHUODHVSHUDQ]DSHURHOVXHxRHVHOp[LWR ¢&XiQWRVGHQRVRWURVVDEHPRVORTXHVHVLHQWHREWHQHUXQDJUDQFDOL¿FDFLyQHQDOJRLPSRUWDQWH HQODHVFXHOD"¢&yPRUHSUHVHQWDUELHQXQDGDQ]DRVNHWFKHQODHVFXHOD"£(VPDUDYLOORVR £1XHVWUDIHWDPELpQSXHGHUHFLELUFDOL¿FDFLRQHV3XHGHVHUXQDLGHDUDUDSDUDWLSRUTXHQDGLH SXHGHYHUWXIH\QDGLHVDEHTXpFDOL¿FDFLyQWHWRFDSRUWXIH«£SHUR'LRVVLVDEH/DIHHVFUHHU DXQFXDQGRQRSRGHPRVYHU'LRVTXLHUHTXHQRVRWURVFUHDPRVHQeODXQFXDQGRQRSRGDPRV YHUOR'LRVTXLHUHTXHFUHDPRVHQVXVPDQGDPLHQWRV\ORVREHGH]FDPRVDXQFXDQGRQR YHDPRVORVUHVXOWDGRV /DKLVWRULDGHKR\HVDFHUFDGH7RPiVTXLHQEDWDOOySDUDFUHHUeOSLGLyTXH-HVXFULVWROHPRVWUDU XQDSUXHED¢&XiQWRVGHXVWHGHVKDQHVFXFKDGRGHRWURVTXHTXLHUHQXQDSUXHEDGH'LRV" /RDVRPEURVRGHHVWRHVTXH'LRVQRVHHQRMyFRQ7RPiV\OHPXHVWUDODSUXHEDTXHpO TXLHUH+D\RWUDVKLVWRULDVHQOD%LEOLDTXHQRVPXHVWUDQTXH'LRVWXYRPLVHULFRUGLDFRQDOJ~Q KXPDQRTXHTXLVRXQDSUXHED\eOVHODGLR*HGHyQ3HURWDPELpQKD\PXFKDVKLVWRULDVHQOD %LEOLDTXHPXHVWUDQORFRQWHQWRTXHVHSRQH'LRVFXDQGROHFUHHPRVVLQSHGLUQLQJXQDSUXHED $EUDKDP 6LW~TXLHUHVVDFDUEXHQDVFDOL¿FDFLRQHVHQWXIHWHQHUp[LWRGHOFXDO'LRVYDDHVWDURUJXOORVR« HQWRQFHVQXHVWURWUDEDMRHVFUHHUHQ'LRVDXQFXDQGRQRSRGHPRVYHUOH3HURVLGXGDPRVFRPR 7RPiVSRGHPRVSHGLUOHD'LRV\DYHFHVeOQRVPRVWUDUiODSUXHEDTXHQHFHVLWDPRV£6HDPRV FULVWLDQRVIXHUWHVTXHFUHHQHQ'LRV\VXVSULQFLSLRVVLQGXGDU D ¢4XpFULWHULRVXVDUtDVSDUDFDOL¿FDUWXIH" ¢3RUTXpHVWDQGLItFLOVHUKRQHVWRFRQVLJRPLVPRDFHUFDGHFDOL¿FDUODIH" 7DUHD/XFDV 3iJLQDV\ ¢4XHFDOL¿FDFLyQOHGDVD7RPiVHQVXIH\SRUTXp" defUZ`ViecR /HH5H\HVSDUDYHUODKLVWRULDGH1DDPiQ'HVSXpVFDOL¿FDVXIH < FULVWRHV 'LRVGH OD9LGD 6DOPR R^`dRTRdR g /DWDUHDHVWUDWDUGHFDOL¿FDUKRQHVWDPHQWHWXIH 3ULPHURORSXHGHVKDFHUHQODFODVH£'HVSXpV WXWDUHDHVSHGLUOHVDWXVSDSiVOHWHGHQXQDFDOL¿FDFLyQ SRUWXIH *ORER 0iJLFR /HFFLyQ 1XEHHQOD %RWHOOD ³4XHULGRVKHUPDQRVOHVUXHJRFRPRDH[WUDQMHURV \SHUHJULQRVHQHVWHPXQGRTXHVHDSDUWHQGHORV GHVHRVSHFDPLQRVRVTXHFRPEDWHQFRQWUDODYLGD´ 3HGUR 1VdaVcRV] cVXcVd`2 /D$VFHQVLyQ /HHU/XFDV QGtDGRVPLVLRQHURVHVWDEDQUHJUHVDQGRDVXFDVDHQORV(VWDGRV8QLGRVGHVSXpVGH KDEHUVHUYLGRD'LRV\DVXLJOHVLDHQÈIULFDSRUPiVGHDxRV(OORVHVSHUDEDQTXH ODJHQWHHVWXYLHUDHVSHUiQGRORVSDUDDQLPDUORV\UHFLELUORVHQFDVDGHVSXpVGHOFDPSR PLVLRQHUR$OPLVPRWLHPSRKDEtDDOJXQRVVROGDGRVTXHHVWDEDQUHJUHVDQGRDFDVDGHVSXpVGH VXVHUYLFLRHQHOPDUSRUVRORDxRV+DEtDXQDPXOWLWXGHVSHUDQGRHOEDUFR\ORVPLVLRQHURV HVWDEDQDQLPDGRVSRUYHUDVXVDPLJRV\DVXVIDPLOLDUHV3HURFXDQGRFDGDXQRIXHEDMDQGR VHKL]RREYLRTXHWRGRVHVWDEDQDOOtSDUDUHFLELUDORVVROGDGRV\QRDORVPLVLRQHURV(OKRPEUH OHPHQFLRQyDVXHVSRVDVXWULVWH]DGHQRWHQHUDQDGLHTXHORVUHFLELHUDDOUHJUHVDUDFDVDHOOD OHGLMR³$PRUHVWRVVROGDGRVWLHQHQHVWDUHFHSFLyQSRUTXHHOORVHVWiQOOHJDQGRDFDVD3HUR QRVRWURVWRGDYtDQROOHJDPRV(OFLHORHVQXHVWUDFDVD´ -HV~VHVHO+LMRGH'LRVTXLHQYLQRDODWLHUUDDYLYLUFRQQRVRWURV'LRVFRPRKXPDQReOYLYLy WRGDVODVFRVDVTXHQRVRWURVKDFHPRVWRGDVODVWHQWDFLRQHVSDUDSHFDUSHURQRSHFy'HVSXpV GHTXHPXULy\UHVXFLWy'LRVOROOHYyDFDVDDOFLHOR/D%LEOLDGLFHTXH-HVXFULVWRHVWiDKRUD PLVPRHQHOFLHORVHQWDGRDODGHUHFKDGH'LRV\UHLQDQGR/D%LEOLDWDPELpQGLFHTXHXQGtD -HVXFULVWRYDDUHJUHVDUSRUVX1RYLD(VWDHVODDQDORJtDGHQRVRWURVOD,JOHVLD-HVXFULVWRYDD UHJUHVDUDODWLHUUDSDUDUHFRJHUQRVXQGtD\QRVOOHYDUiDFDVD (VWRQRVD\XGDDPDQWHQHUQRVHQIRFDGRVDVtFRPRHVWDSDUHMDGHPLVLRQHURV«TXHHVWH PXQGRQRHVQXHVWUDFDVD1RVRWURVKHPRVQDFLGRGHQXHYR\VRPRVQXHYDVFULDWXUDV/DV FRVDVGHHVWHPXQGRQRWLHQHQQXHVWUDDWHQFLyQ\QRQRVSXHGHQGDUHOYHUGDGHURJR]R6RPRV H[WUDQMHURVDTXtHQODWLHUUD£(QOXJDUGHSRQHUQRVFyPRGRVDTXtHQODWLHUUDPDQWHQJDPRV QXHVWUDPHQWH\FRUD]yQHQIRFDGRVHQ-HVXFULVWRHVSHUDQGRVX5(*5(62 L ¢3RUTXpXQ'LRVGHDPRUPDQGDSHUVRQDVDOLQ¿HUQR" ¢&XiQGRFUHHVTXHUHJUHVDUi-HV~V" defUZ`ViecR /HH7HVDORQLFHQVHVSDUDYHUFyPRHVSHUDUHOUHJUHVR < 7DUHD/XFDV\ +HFKRV 3iJLQDV\ FULVWRHV 5H\GH*ORULD 6DOPR R^`dRTRdR g (VWDVHPDQDGHEHVGHSODQHDUXQGtDSDUDFRPHUDOJRGHRWURSDtVHVWRWHD\XGDUi DUHFRUGDUTXHHUHVH[WUDQMHURDTXtHQODWLHUUD/RFRPLGDPiVH[WUDxDPHMRU £3L]]D\DQRFXHQWD /HFFLyQ 1]eVRjfUR2 ³$VtPLVPRHQQXHVWUDGHELOLGDGHO(VStULWXDFXGHD D\XGDUQRV´5RPDQRV (O3HQWHFRVWpV /HHU+HFKRV PDJLQDTXHWXSDSiWHGDXQUHJDORHVSHFLDOHQWXFXPSOHDxRV£SHURWHQLHJDVDDEULUOR6HUtD IHRKDFHUOHHVWRDpO¢YHUGDG"eOKL]RWRGRHOWUDEDMRSDUDUHJDOiUWHORSHURW~ORUHFKD]DVDXQ FXDQGRQRVDEHVORTXHHV(VWRVXHQDVRUSUHQGHQWHSHURHVODPDQHUDHQTXHPXFKRVGH QRVRWURVWUDWDPRVDO(VStULWX6DQWR /D%LEOLDGLFHFODUDPHQWHTXHHO(VStULWX6DQWRHVXQUHJDORSDUDQRVRWURVHVDOJXLHQTXHIXH HQYLDGRDODWLHUUDSDUDD\XGDUQRVDYLYLUXQDYLGDSLDGRVD&XDQGRQRVDEHPRVFyPRRUDUeO QRVGDODSDODEUDRXQSODQ&XDQGRQRVDEHPRVFyPRD\XGDUDRWUDSHUVRQDSRGHPRVFRQ¿DU HQeOSRUTXHeOVDEHH[DFWDPHQWHTXpKDFHU+D\PXFKDVVLWXDFLRQHVGRQGHQHFHVLWDPRV DO(VStULWX6DQWRDXQHQQXHVWUDYLGDGLDULD$KRUDLPDJtQDWHTXHGHFLGHVLJQRUDUDWXPDPi FRPSOHWDPHQWH3ODWLFDVFRQWXSDSiFRQWXVKHUPDQRVSHURFXDQGRWXPDPiHQWUDDOOXJDU GRQGHHVWiVW~QLVLTXLHUDOHGLFHVµKROD¶<FXDQGRHOODWHKDEODODLJQRUDV\QRODHVFXFKDV $GHPiVFXDQGRQHFHVLWDVD\XGDFRQWXVWDUHDVEXVFDVDOUHGHGRUDOJXLHQTXHWHD\XGH«DXQ FXDQGRHOODHVWiGHSLHMXQWRDWL(VWRVHUtDPX\IHRKDFpUVHORDWXPDPi£3HURHVWRHVORTXH HVWDPRVKDFLHQGRWRGRHOWLHPSRFRQHO(VStULWX6DQWR eOVRORHVXQUHJDORGH'LRV£VLQRTXHHVWiYLYReOHVWiLJXDOGHYLYRTXHW~PDPi«VRORTXH QRSRGHPRVYHUOReOHVWiFRQQRVRWURVWRGRVORVGtDVDXQFXDQGRORLJQRUDPRV\eODQKHOD D\XGDUQRVHQWRGRWLSRGHVLWXDFLRQHV/DKLVWRULDEtEOLFDGHKR\QRVKDEODDFHUFDGHOSULPHUGtD HQTXHHO(VStULWX6DQWRYLQRDODWLHUUD£/DJHQWHHVWDEDPX\DQLPDGD(OORVFDQWDEDQDODEDEDQ \KDEODEDQHQOHQJXDV(OORVWHQtDQPiVSRGHU\PiVIXHU]DHVSLULWXDO(OORVQRWHQtDQPLHGRGH FRPSDUWLUHOHYDQJHOLRRKDEODUHQS~EOLFR(OORVWHQtDQPiVDPRUORVXQRVDORVRWURV(OSODQGH 'LRVQRVRORIXHHQYLDUDO(VStULWX6DQWRDTXHOGtD£(OJUDQSODQLQFOXtDHQYLDUDO(VStULWX6DQWR DODWLHUUDSDUDVHUHOD\XGDGRUGHFDGDXQRGHQRVRWURV¢&yPRKDFHeOSDUDHVWDUFRQFDGD SHUVRQDDOUHGHGRUGHODWLHUUD"(VWRVHUtDLPSRVLEOHSDUDWL\SDUDPtSHURQDGDHVLPSRVLEOH SDUD'LRVeOFRQRFHFXiQWRVFDEHOORVWHQHPRVHQQXHVWUDFDEH]DeOFRQRFHWXVSHQVDPLHQWRV DQWHVGHTXHORVKDEOHV£(O(VStULWX6DQWRHVWiDTXtSDUDD\XGDUWHDVtTXHQRORLJQRUHV @ ¢4XpSXHGHVKDFHUHVWDVHPDQDSDUDUHFRQRFHUDO(VStULWX6DQWRHQYH]GH LJQRUDUOR" ¢(QTXpRFDVLRQHVWHKDVVHQWLGRJXLDGRSRUHO(VStULWX6DQWR" ¢4XpGRQHVYHVTXHVHPDQL¿HVWDQHQWXLJOHVLD" FULVWRHV (PDQXHO 0DWHR defUZ`ViecR /HHDFHUFDGHORVGRQHVHVSLULWXDOHVHQ&RU\ < R^`dRTRdR g /DWDUHDGHHVWDVHPDQDHVWDUiPX\GLItFLOSHURWDPELpQVHUiGHPXFKD D\XGDSDUDWRGRV£&RPRHOHMHPSORHQODOHFFLyQORVQLxRVQHFHVLWDQ WUDWDUGHLJQRUDUDVXPDPiSRUXQGtDFRPSOHWR2EYLDPHQWHQHFHVLWDQDYLVDU DODVPDPiVGHDQWHPDQRSDUDTXHD\XGHQFRQVXSDUWLFLSDFLyQ(VWROHVGDUiD ORVQLxRV\DODVPDPiVXQHMHPSORPX\FODURGHODPDQHUDHQTXHLJQRUDPRVDO (VStULWX6DQWRGLDULDPHQWH (OHFWULFLGDG (VWiWLFD 3RScZV_U`]RSZS]ZR V_TRdR4 ]fTRd dVXf_URaRceV CVTTZ_ 'tD ]fTRd /XFDV 'HVSXpVGHHVWRHO6HxRUHVFRJLyDRWURVVHWHQWD\GRVSDUD HQYLDUORVGHGRVHQGRVGHODQWHGHpODWRGRSXHEOR\OXJDU DGRQGHpOSHQVDEDLU©(VDEXQGDQWHODFRVHFKD²OHVGLMR² SHURVRQSRFRVORVREUHURV3tGDQOHSRUWDQWRDO6HxRUGH ODFRVHFKDTXHPDQGHREUHURVDVXFDPSR£9D\DQXVWHGHV 0LUHQTXHORVHQYtRFRPRFRUGHURVHQPHGLRGHORERV1R OOHYHQPRQHGHURQLEROVDQLVDQGDOLDVQLVHGHWHQJDQD VDOXGDUDQDGLHSRUHOFDPLQRª&XDQGRHQWUHQHQXQDFDVD GLJDQSULPHUR³3D]DHVWDFDVD´6LKD\DOOtDOJXLHQGLJQR GHSD]JR]DUiGHHOOD\VLQRODEHQGLFLyQQRVHFXPSOLUi 4XpGHQVHHQHVDFDVD\FRPDQ\EHEDQGHORTXHHOORV WHQJDQSRUTXHHOWUDEDMDGRUWLHQHGHUHFKRDVXVXHOGR1R DQGHQGHFDVDHQFDVDª&XDQGRHQWUHQHQXQSXHEOR\ORV UHFLEDQFRPDQORTXHOHVVLUYDQ6DQHQDORVHQIHUPRVTXH HQFXHQWUHQDOOt\GtJDQOHV³(OUHLQRGH'LRV\DHVWiFHUFD GHXVWHGHV´3HURFXDQGRHQWUHQHQXQSXHEORGRQGHQRORV UHFLEDQVDOJDQDODVSOD]DV\GLJDQ³$XQHOSROYRGHHVWH SXHEORTXHVHQRVKDSHJDGRDORVSLHVQRVORVDFXGLPRV HQSURWHVWDFRQWUDXVWHGHV3HURWHQJDQSRUVHJXURTXH\D HVWiFHUFDHOUHLQRGH'LRV´/HVGLJRTXHHQDTXHOGtDVHUi PiVWROHUDEOHHOFDVWLJRSDUD6RGRPDTXHSDUDHVHSXHEOR 4XpKDFHIDOWDSDUDOHYDQWDUODFRVHFKD"BBBBBBBBBBBBBBB BBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBB 'tD /XFDV ª£$\GHWL&RUD]tQ£$\GHWL%HWVDLGD6LVHKXELHUDQKHFKR HQ7LUR\HQ6LGyQORVPLODJURVTXHVHKLFLHURQHQPHGLR GHXVWHGHV\DKDFHWLHPSRTXHVHKDEUtDQDUUHSHQWLGR FRQJUDQGHVODPHQWRV3HURHQHOMXLFLRVHUiPiVWROHUDEOH HOFDVWLJRSDUD7LUR\6LGyQTXHSDUDXVWHGHV<W~ &DSHUQD~P¢DFDVRVHUiVOHYDQWDGDKDVWDHOFLHOR"1R VLQRTXHGHVFHQGHUiVKDVWDHODELVPRª(OTXHORVHVFXFKD DXVWHGHVPHHVFXFKDDPtHOTXHORVUHFKD]DDXVWHGHV PHUHFKD]DDPt\HOTXHPHUHFKD]DDPtUHFKD]DDOTXH PHHQYLyª&XDQGRORVVHWHQWD\GRVUHJUHVDURQGLMHURQ FRQWHQWRV²6HxRUKDVWDORVGHPRQLRVVHQRVVRPHWHQHQ WXQRPEUH²<RYHtDD6DWDQiVFDHUGHOFLHORFRPRXQUD\R ²UHVSRQGLypO²6tOHVKHGDGRDXWRULGDGDXVWHGHVSDUD SLVRWHDUVHUSLHQWHV\HVFRUSLRQHV\YHQFHUWRGRHOSRGHU GHOHQHPLJRQDGDOHVSRGUiKDFHUGDxR6LQHPEDUJRQR VHDOHJUHQGHTXHSXHGDQVRPHWHUDORVHVStULWXVVLQR DOpJUHQVHGHTXHVXVQRPEUHVHVWiQHVFULWRVHQHOFLHOR (QDTXHOPRPHQWR-HV~VOOHQRGHDOHJUtDSRUHO(VStULWX 6DQWRGLMR©7HDODER3DGUH6HxRUGHOFLHOR\GHODWLHUUD SRUTXHKDELHQGRHVFRQGLGRHVWDVFRVDVGHORVVDELRVH LQVWUXLGRVVHODVKDVUHYHODGRDORVTXHVRQFRPRQLxRV 6t3DGUHSRUTXHHVDIXHWXEXHQDYROXQWDGª0L3DGUHPH KDHQWUHJDGRWRGDVODVFRVDV1DGLHVDEHTXLpQHVHO+LMR VLQRHO3DGUH\QDGLHVDEHTXLpQHVHO3DGUHVLQRHO+LMR \DTXHODTXLHQHO+LMRTXLHUDUHYHOiUVHORª9ROYLpQGRVHD VXVGLVFtSXORVOHVGLMRDSDUWH©'LFKRVRVORVRMRVTXHYHQ ORTXHXVWHGHVYHQ/HVGLJRTXHPXFKRVSURIHWDV\UH\HV TXLVLHURQYHUORTXHXVWHGHVYHQSHURQRORYLHURQ\RtUOR TXHXVWHGHVR\HQSHURQRORR\HURQª ¢4XpOHVGLR-HV~VDORVGLVFtSXORVSDUDTXHQDGDOHV KLFLHUDGDxR"BBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBB 'tD /XFDV (QHVWRVHSUHVHQWyXQH[SHUWRHQODOH\\SDUDSRQHUD SUXHEDD-HV~VOHKL]RHVWDSUHJXQWD²0DHVWUR¢TXp WHQJRTXHKDFHUSDUDKHUHGDUODYLGDHWHUQD"-HV~VUHSOLFy ²¢4XpHVWiHVFULWRHQODOH\"¢&yPRODLQWHUSUHWDVW~" &RPRUHVSXHVWDHOKRPEUHFLWy²´$PDDO6HxRUWX 'LRVFRQWRGRWXFRUD]yQFRQWRGRWXVHUFRQWRGDVWXV IXHU]DV\FRQWRGDWXPHQWH´\³$PDDWXSUyMLPRFRPR DWLPLVPR´²%LHQFRQWHVWDGR²OHGLMR-HV~V²+D]HVR \YLYLUiV3HURpOTXHUtDMXVWL¿FDUVHDVtTXHOHSUHJXQWyD -HV~V²¢<TXLpQHVPLSUyMLPR"-HV~VUHVSRQGLy² %DMDEDXQKRPEUHGH-HUXVDOpQD-HULFy\FD\yHQPDQRV GHXQRVODGURQHV/HTXLWDURQODURSDORJROSHDURQ\VH IXHURQGHMiQGRORPHGLRPXHUWR5HVXOWDTXHYLDMDEDSRU HOPLVPRFDPLQRXQVDFHUGRWHTXLHQDOYHUORVHGHVYLy\ VLJXLyGHODUJR$VtWDPELpQOOHJyDDTXHOOXJDUXQOHYLWD \DOYHUORVHGHVYLy\VLJXLyGHODUJR3HURXQVDPDULWDQR TXHLEDGHYLDMHOOHJyDGRQGHHVWDEDHOKRPEUH\YLpQGROR VHFRPSDGHFLyGHpO6HDFHUFyOHFXUyODVKHULGDVFRQ YLQR\DFHLWH\VHODVYHQGy/XHJRORPRQWyVREUHVX SURSLDFDEDOJDGXUDOROOHYyDXQDORMDPLHQWR\ORFXLGy $OGtDVLJXLHQWHVDFyGRVPRQHGDVGHSODWD\VHODVGLR DOGXHxRGHODORMDPLHQWR³&XtGHPHOR²OHGLMR²\ORTXH JDVWHXVWHGGHPiVVHORSDJDUpFXDQGR\RYXHOYD´¢&XiO GHHVWRVWUHVSLHQVDVTXHGHPRVWUyVHUHOSUyMLPRGHOTXH FD\yHQPDQRVGHORVODGURQHV"²(OTXHVHFRPSDGHFLy GHpO²FRQWHVWyHOH[SHUWRHQODOH\²$QGDHQWRQFHV\ KD]W~ORPLVPR²FRQFOX\y-HV~V(QFDVDGH0DUWD\ 0DUtD ¢4XpOHGLMR-HV~VTXHKLFLHUDDOH[SHUWRGHODOH\"BBBBBB BBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBB 'tD /XFDV 0LHQWUDVLEDGHFDPLQRFRQVXVGLVFtSXORV-HV~VHQWUyHQ XQDDOGHD\XQDPXMHUOODPDGD0DUWDORUHFLELyHQVXFDVD 7HQtDHOODXQDKHUPDQDOODPDGD0DUtDTXHVHQWDGDDORV SLHVGHO6HxRUHVFXFKDEDORTXHpOGHFtD0DUWDSRUVX SDUWHVHVHQWtDDEUXPDGDSRUTXHWHQtDPXFKRTXHKDFHU $VtTXHVHDFHUFyDpO\OHGLMR²6HxRU¢QRWHLPSRUWDTXH PLKHUPDQDPHKD\DGHMDGRVLUYLHQGRVROD"£'LOHTXHPH D\XGH²0DUWD0DUWD²OHFRQWHVWy-HV~V²HVWiVLQTXLHWD \SUHRFXSDGDSRUPXFKDVFRVDVSHURVyORXQDHVQHFHVDULD 0DUtDKDHVFRJLGRODPHMRU\QDGLHVHODTXLWDUi CfTRd 8QGtDHVWDED-HV~VRUDQGRHQFLHUWROXJDU&XDQGRWHUPLQy OHGLMRXQRGHVXVGLVFtSXORV²6HxRUHQVpxDQRVDRUDU DVtFRPR-XDQHQVHxyDVXVGLVFtSXORV eOOHVGLMR²&XDQGRRUHQGLJDQª´3DGUHVDQWL¿FDGRVHD WXQRPEUH9HQJDWXUHLQR'DQRVFDGDGtDQXHVWURSDQ FRWLGLDQR 3HUGyQDQRVQXHVWURVSHFDGRVSRUTXHWDPELpQQRVRWURV SHUGRQDPRVDWRGRVORVTXHQRVRIHQGHQ<QRQRVPHWDVHQ WHQWDFLyQ´ ª6XSRQJDPRV²FRQWLQXy²TXHXQRGHXVWHGHVWLHQHXQ DPLJR\DPHGLDQRFKHYD\OHGLFH³$PLJRSUpVWDPH WUHVSDQHVSXHVVHPHKDSUHVHQWDGRXQDPLJRUHFLpQ OOHJDGRGHYLDMH\QRWHQJRQDGDTXHRIUHFHUOH´<HOTXH HVWiDGHQWUROHFRQWHVWD³1RPHPROHVWHV<DHVWiFHUUDGD ODSXHUWD\PLVKLMRV\\RHVWDPRVDFRVWDGRV1RSXHGR OHYDQWDUPHDGDUWHQDGD´ 6HJ~Q-HV~V¢&XiOGHODVGRVKHUPDQDVKDEtDHVFRJLGROR PHMRU"BBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBB 'tD /XFDV /HVGLJRTXHDXQTXHQRVHOHYDQWHDGDUOHSDQSRUVHU DPLJRVX\RVtVHOHYDQWDUiSRUVXLPSHUWLQHQFLD\OHGDUi FXDQWRQHFHVLWHª$VtTXH\ROHVGLJR3LGDQ\VHOHVGDUi EXVTXHQ\HQFRQWUDUiQOODPHQ\VHOHVDEULUiODSXHUWD 3RUTXHWRGRHOTXHSLGHUHFLEHHOTXHEXVFDHQFXHQWUD\DO TXHOODPDVHOHDEUH ª¢4XLpQGHXVWHGHVTXHVHDSDGUHVLVXKLMROHSLGHXQ SHVFDGROHGDUiHQFDPELRXQDVHUSLHQWH"¢2VLOHSLGHXQ KXHYROHGDUiXQHVFRUSLyQ"3XHVVLXVWHGHVDXQVLHQGR PDORVVDEHQGDUFRVDVEXHQDVDVXVKLMRV£FXiQWRPiVHO 3DGUHFHOHVWLDOGDUiHO(VStULWX6DQWRDTXLHQHVVHORSLGDQ ¢$TXLpQOHGDUiHO3DGUHHO(VStULWX6DQWR"BBBBBBBBBBBBBB BBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBB CVTTZ_ 'tD /XFDV (QRWUDRFDVLyQ-HV~VH[SXOVDEDGHXQKRPEUHDXQ GHPRQLRTXHORKDEtDGHMDGRPXGR&XDQGRVDOLyHO GHPRQLRHOPXGRKDEOy\ODJHQWHVHTXHGyDVRPEUDGD 3HURDOJXQRVGLMHURQ©eVWHH[SXOVDDORVGHPRQLRVSRU PHGLRGH%HHO]HE~SUtQFLSHGHORVGHPRQLRVª2WURVSDUD SRQHUORDSUXHEDOHSHGtDQXQDVHxDOGHOFLHOR&RPRpO FRQRFtDVXVSHQVDPLHQWRVOHVGLMR©7RGRUHLQRGLYLGLGR FRQWUDVtPLVPRTXHGDUiDVRODGR\XQDFDVDGLYLGLGDFRQWUD VtPLVPDVHGHUUXPEDUi3RUWDQWRVL6DWDQiVHVWiGLYLGLGR FRQWUDVtPLVPR¢FyPRSXHGHPDQWHQHUVHHQSLHVXUHLQR" /RSUHJXQWRSRUTXHXVWHGHVGLFHQTXH\RH[SXOVRDORV GHPRQLRVSRUPHGLRGH%HHO]HE~$KRUDELHQVL\RH[SXOVR DORVGHPRQLRVSRUPHGLRGH%HHO]HE~¢ORVVHJXLGRUHV GHXVWHGHVSRUPHGLRGHTXLpQORVH[SXOVDQ"3RUHVR HOORVPLVPRVORVMX]JDUiQDXVWHGHV3HURVLH[SXOVRDORV GHPRQLRVFRQHOSRGHUGH'LRVHVRVLJQL¿FDTXHKDOOHJDGR DXVWHGHVHOUHLQRGH'LRVª&XDQGRXQKRPEUHIXHUWH\ELHQ DUPDGRFXLGDVXKDFLHQGDVXVELHQHVHVWiQVHJXURV3HUR VLORDWDFDRWURPiVIXHUWHTXHpO\ORYHQFHOHTXLWDODV DUPDVHQTXHFRQ¿DED\UHSDUWHHOERWtQª(OTXHQRHVWi GHPLSDUWHHVWiFRQWUDPt\HOTXHFRQPLJRQRUHFRJH HVSDUFH ¢4XpVLJQL¿FDEDTXH-HV~VHVWXYLHUDH[SXOVDQGRGHPRQLRV FRQHOSRGHUGH'LRV"BBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBB BBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBB 'tD /XFDV ª&XDQGRXQHVStULWXPDOLJQRVDOHGHXQDSHUVRQDYDSRU OXJDUHViULGRVEXVFDQGRXQGHVFDQVR<DOQRHQFRQWUDUOR GLFH³9ROYHUpDPLFDVDGHGRQGHVDOt´&XDQGROOHJDOD HQFXHQWUDEDUULGD\DUUHJODGD/XHJRYD\WUDHRWURVVLHWH HVStULWXVPiVPDOYDGRVTXHpO\HQWUDQDYLYLUDOOt$Vt TXHHOHVWDGR¿QDOGHDTXHOODSHUVRQDUHVXOWDSHRUTXH HOLQLFLDOª0LHQWUDV-HV~VGHFtDHVWDVFRVDVXQDPXMHU GHHQWUHODPXOWLWXGH[FODPy²£'LFKRVDODPXMHUTXHWH GLRDOX]\WHDPDPDQWy²'LFKRVRVPiVELHQ²FRQWHVWy -HV~V²ORVTXHR\HQODSDODEUDGH'LRV\ODREHGHFHQ &RPRFUHFtDODPXOWLWXG-HV~VVHSXVRDGHFLUOHV©eVWD HVXQDJHQHUDFLyQPDOYDGD3LGHXQDVHxDOPLODJURVD SHURQRVHOHGDUiPiVVHxDOTXHODGH-RQiV$VtFRPR -RQiVIXHXQDVHxDOSDUDORVKDELWDQWHVGH1tQLYHWDPELpQ ORVHUiHO+LMRGHOKRPEUHSDUDHVWDJHQHUDFLyQ/DUHLQD GHO6XUVHOHYDQWDUiHQHOGtDGHOMXLFLR\FRQGHQDUiDHVWD JHQWHSRUTXHHOODYLQRGHVGHORVFRQ¿QHVGHODWLHUUDSDUD HVFXFKDUODVDELGXUtDGH6DORPyQ\DTXtWLHQHQXVWHGHVD XQRPiVJUDQGHTXH6DORPyQ/RVQLQLYLWDVVHOHYDQWDUiQ HQHOGtDGHOMXLFLR\FRQGHQDUiQDHVWDJHQHUDFLyQSRUTXH HOORVVHDUUHSLQWLHURQDOHVFXFKDUODSUHGLFDFLyQGH-RQiV \DTXtWLHQHQXVWHGHVDXQRPiVJUDQGHTXH-RQiVª1DGLH HQFLHQGHXQDOiPSDUDSDUDOXHJRSRQHUODHQXQOXJDU HVFRQGLGRRFXEULUODFRQXQFDMyQVLQRSDUDSRQHUODHQXQD UHSLVDD¿QGHTXHORVTXHHQWUHQWHQJDQOX]7XVRMRVVRQ ODOiPSDUDGHWXFXHUSR6LWXYLVLyQHVFODUDWRGRWXVHU GLVIUXWDUiGHODOX]SHURVLHVWiQXEODGDWRGRWXVHUHVWDUi HQODRVFXULGDG$VHJ~UDWHGHTXHODOX]TXHFUHHVWHQHU QRVHDRVFXULGDG3RUWDQWRVLWRGRWXVHUGLVIUXWDGHOD OX]VLQTXHQLQJXQDSDUWHTXHGHHQODRVFXULGDGHVWDUiV FRPSOHWDPHQWHLOXPLQDGRFRPRFXDQGRXQDOiPSDUDWH DOXPEUDFRQVXOX]ª 6HJ~Q-HV~V¢4XLpQHVVRQPiVGLFKRVRV"BBBBBBBBBBBB BBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBB 'tD /XFDV &XDQGR-HV~VWHUPLQyGHKDEODUXQIDULVHRORLQYLWyD FRPHUFRQpODVtTXHHQWUyHQODFDVD\VHVHQWyDODPHVD 3HURHOIDULVHRVHVRUSUHQGLyDOYHUTXH-HV~VQRKDEtD FXPSOLGRFRQHOULWRGHODYDUVHDQWHVGHFRPHU²5HVXOWD TXHXVWHGHVORVIDULVHRV²OHVGLMRHO6HxRU²OLPSLDQHO YDVR\HOSODWRSRUIXHUDSHURSRUGHQWURHVWiQXVWHGHV OOHQRVGHFRGLFLD\GHPDOGDG£1HFLRV¢$FDVRHOTXHKL]R ORGHDIXHUDQRKL]RWDPELpQORGHDGHQWUR"'HQPiVELHQD ORVSREUHVGHORTXHHVWiGHQWUR\DVtWRGRTXHGDUiOLPSLR SDUDXVWHGHVª£$\GHXVWHGHVIDULVHRVTXHGDQODGpFLPD SDUWHGHODPHQWDGHODUXGD\GHWRGDFODVHGHOHJXPEUHV SHURGHVFXLGDQODMXVWLFLD\HODPRUGH'LRV'HEtDQKDEHU SUDFWLFDGRHVWRVLQGHMDUGHKDFHUDTXHOORª£$\GHXVWHGHV IDULVHRVTXHVHPXHUHQSRUORVSULPHURVSXHVWRVHQODV VLQDJRJDV\ORVVDOXGRVHQODVSOD]DVª£$\GHXVWHGHVTXH VRQFRPRWXPEDVVLQOiSLGDVREUHODVTXHDQGDODJHQWH VLQGDUVHFXHQWD8QRGHORVH[SHUWRVHQODOH\OHUHVSRQGLy ²0DHVWURDOKDEODUDVtQRVLQVXOWDVWDPELpQDQRVRWURV &RQWHVWy-HV~V²£$\GHXVWHGHVWDPELpQH[SHUWRVHQOD OH\$EUXPDQDORVGHPiVFRQFDUJDVTXHDSHQDVVHSXHGHQ VRSRUWDUSHURXVWHGHVPLVPRVQROHYDQWDQQLXQGHGRSDUD D\XGDUORVª£$\GHXVWHGHVTXHFRQVWUX\HQPRQXPHQWRV SDUDORVSURIHWDVDTXLHQHVORVDQWHSDVDGRVGHXVWHGHV PDWDURQ HO+LMRGHOKRPEUHORUHFRQRFHUiGHODQWHGHORViQJHOHVGH 'LRV3HURDOTXHPHGHVFRQR]FDGHODQWHGHODJHQWHVHOH GHVFRQRFHUiGHODQWHGHORViQJHOHVGH'LRV<WRGRHOTXH SURQXQFLHDOJXQDSDODEUDFRQWUDHO+LMRGHOKRPEUHVHUi SHUGRQDGRSHURHOTXHEODVIHPHFRQWUDHO(VStULWX6DQWR QRWHQGUiSHUGyQª&XDQGRORVKDJDQFRPSDUHFHUDQWH ODVVLQDJRJDVORVJREHUQDQWHV\ODVDXWRULGDGHVQRVH SUHRFXSHQGHFyPRYDQDGHIHQGHUVHRGHTXpYDQDGHFLU SRUTXHHQHVHPRPHQWRHO(VStULWX6DQWROHVHQVHxDUiOR TXHGHEHQUHVSRQGHUª8QRGHHQWUHODPXOWLWXGOHSLGLy 0DHVWURGLOHDPLKHUPDQRTXHFRPSDUWDODKHUHQFLD FRQPLJR²+RPEUH²UHSOLFy-HV~V²¢TXLpQPHQRPEUy DPtMXH]RiUELWURHQWUHXVWHGHV" ¢4XpHUDORTXHORVIDULVHRVHVWDEDQGHVFXLGDQGR"BBBBBBB BBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBB ¢4XpVXFHGHUiFRQORVTXHUHFRQR]FDQD-HV~VGHODQWHGH ODJHQWH"BBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBB BBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBB 'tD /XFDV (QUHDOLGDGDSUXHEDQORTXHKLFLHURQVXVDQWHSDVDGRV HOORVPDWDURQDORVSURIHWDV\XVWHGHVOHVFRQVWUX\HQORV VHSXOFURV3RUHVRGLMR'LRVHQVXVDELGXUtD³/HVHQYLDUp SURIHWDV\DSyVWROHVGHORVFXDOHVPDWDUiQDXQRV\ SHUVHJXLUiQDRWURV´3RUORWDQWRDHVWDJHQHUDFLyQVH OHSHGLUiQFXHQWDVGHODVDQJUHGHWRGRVORVSURIHWDV GHUUDPDGDGHVGHHOSULQFLSLRGHOPXQGRGHVGHODVDQJUHGH $EHOKDVWDODVDQJUHGH=DFDUtDVHOTXHPXULyHQWUHHODOWDU \HOVDQWXDULR6tOHVDVHJXURTXHGHWRGRHVWRVHOHSHGLUiQ FXHQWDVDHVWDJHQHUDFLyQª£$\GHXVWHGHVH[SHUWRVHQOD OH\SRUTXHVHKDQDGXHxDGRGHODOODYHGHOFRQRFLPLHQWR 8VWHGHVPLVPRVQRKDQHQWUDGR\DORVTXHTXHUtDQHQWUDU OHVKDQFHUUDGRHOSDVR&XDQGR-HV~VVDOLyGHDOOtORV PDHVWURVGHODOH\\ORVIDULVHRVUHVHQWLGRVVHSXVLHURQD DFRVDUORDSUHJXQWDV(VWDEDQWHQGLpQGROHWUDPSDVSDUDYHU VLIDOODEDHQDOJR CfTRd 0LHQWUDVWDQWRVHKDEtDQUHXQLGRPLOODUHVGHSHUVRQDV WDQWDVTXHVHDWURSHOODEDQXQDVDRWUDV-HV~VFRPHQ]yD KDEODUGLULJLpQGRVHSULPHURDVXVGLVFtSXORV©&XtGHQVHGH ODOHYDGXUDGHORVIDULVHRVRVHDGHODKLSRFUHVtD1RKD\ QDGDHQFXELHUWRTXHQROOHJXHDUHYHODUVHQLQDGDHVFRQGLGR TXHQROOHJXHDFRQRFHUVH$VtTXHWRGRORTXHXVWHGHVKDQ GLFKRHQODRVFXULGDGVHGDUiDFRQRFHUDSOHQDOX]\ORTXH KDQVXVXUUDGRDSXHUWDFHUUDGDVHSURFODPDUiGHVGHODV D]RWHDV ¢'HTXHVHWHQtDQTXHFXLGDUORVGLVFtSXORV"BBBBBBBBBBBB BBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBB 'tD /XFDV ª$XVWHGHVPLVDPLJRVOHVGLJRTXHQRWHPDQDORVTXH PDWDQHOFXHUSRSHURGHVSXpVQRSXHGHQKDFHUPiV/HV YR\DHQVHxDUPiVELHQDTXLpQGHEHQWHPHUWHPDQDOTXH GHVSXpVGHGDUPXHUWHWLHQHSRGHUSDUDHFKDUORVDOLQ¿HUQR 6tOHVDVHJXURTXHDpOGHEHQWHPHUOH¢1RVHYHQGHQFLQFR JRUULRQHVSRUGRVPRQHGLWDV"6LQHPEDUJR'LRVQRVHROYLGD GHQLQJXQRGHHOORV$VtPLVPRVXFHGHFRQXVWHGHVDXQORV FDEHOORVGHVXFDEH]DHVWiQFRQWDGRV1RWHQJDQPLHGR XVWHGHVYDOHQPiVTXHPXFKRVJRUULRQHVª/HVDVHJXURTXH DFXDOTXLHUDTXHPHUHFRQR]FDGHODQWHGHODJHQWHWDPELpQ CVTTZ_ 'tD /XFDV ª£7HQJDQFXLGDGR²DGYLUWLyDODJHQWH²$EVWpQJDQVH GHWRGDDYDULFLDODYLGDGHXQDSHUVRQDQRGHSHQGHGH ODDEXQGDQFLDGHVXVELHQHV(QWRQFHVOHVFRQWyHVWD SDUiEROD²(OWHUUHQRGHXQKRPEUHULFROHSURGXMRXQD EXHQDFRVHFKD$VtTXHVHSXVRDSHQVDU³¢4XpYR\D KDFHU"1RWHQJRGyQGHDOPDFHQDUPLFRVHFKD´3RU¿Q GLMR³<DVpORTXHYR\DKDFHUGHUULEDUpPLVJUDQHURV\ FRQVWUXLUpRWURVPiVJUDQGHVGRQGHSXHGDDOPDFHQDU WRGRPLJUDQR\PLVELHQHV<GLUp$OPDPtD\DWLHQHV EDVWDQWHVFRVDVEXHQDVJXDUGDGDVSDUDPXFKRVDxRV 'HVFDQVDFRPHEHEH\JR]DGHODYLGD´3HUR'LRVOH GLMR³£1HFLR(VWDPLVPDQRFKHWHYDQDUHFODPDUODYLGD ¢<TXLpQVHTXHGDUiFRQORTXHKDVDFXPXODGR"´ª$VtOH VXFHGHDOTXHDFXPXODULTXH]DVSDUDVtPLVPRHQYH]GH VHUULFRGHODQWHGH'LRV/XHJRGLMR-HV~VDVXVGLVFtSXORV ²3RUHVROHVGLJR1RVHSUHRFXSHQSRUVXYLGDTXp FRPHUiQQLSRUVXFXHUSRFRQTXpVHYHVWLUiQ/DYLGD WLHQHPiVYDORUTXHODFRPLGD\HOFXHUSRPiVTXHOD URSD)tMHQVHHQORVFXHUYRVQRVLHPEUDQQLFRVHFKDQQL WLHQHQDOPDFpQQLJUDQHURVLQHPEDUJR'LRVORVDOLPHQWD £&XiQWRPiVYDOHQXVWHGHVTXHODVDYHV¢4XLpQGH XVWHGHVSRUPXFKRTXHVHSUHRFXSHSXHGHDxDGLUXQD VRODKRUDDOFXUVRGHVXYLGD"<DTXHQRSXHGHQKDFHUDOJR WDQLQVLJQL¿FDQWH¢SRUTXpVHSUHRFXSDQSRUORGHPiV" 6HJ~Q-HV~V¢'HTXpGHEHPRVDEVWHQHUQRV"BBBBBBBBBB BBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBB 'tD /XFDV ª)tMHQVHFyPRFUHFHQORVOLULRV1RWUDEDMDQQLKLODQVLQ HPEDUJROHVGLJRTXHQLVLTXLHUD6DORPyQFRQWRGRVX HVSOHQGRUVHYHVWtDFRPRXQRGHHOORV6LDVtYLVWH'LRVD ODKLHUEDTXHKR\HVWiHQHOFDPSR\PDxDQDHVDUURMDGD DOKRUQR£FXiQWRPiVKDUiSRUXVWHGHVJHQWHGHSRFDIH $VtTXHQRVHDIDQHQSRUORTXHKDQGHFRPHUREHEHU GHMHQGHDWRUPHQWDUVH(OPXQGRSDJDQRDQGDWUDVWRGDV HVWDVFRVDVSHURHO3DGUHVDEHTXHXVWHGHVODVQHFHVLWDQ 8VWHGHVSRUHOFRQWUDULREXVTXHQHOUHLQRGH'LRV\HVWDV FRVDVOHVVHUiQDxDGLGDVª1RWHQJDQPLHGRPLUHEDxR SHTXHxRSRUTXHHVODEXHQDYROXQWDGGHO3DGUHGDUOHVHO UHLQR9HQGDQVXVELHQHV\GHQDORVSREUHV3URYpDQVHGH EROVDVTXHQRVHGHVJDVWHQDFXPXOHQXQWHVRURLQDJRWDEOH HQHOFLHORGRQGHQRKD\ODGUyQTXHDFHFKHQLSROLOODTXH GHVWUX\D3XHVGRQGHWHQJDQXVWHGHVVXWHVRURDOOtHVWDUi WDPELpQVXFRUD]yQª0DQWpQJDQVHOLVWRVFRQODURSD ELHQDMXVWDGD\ODOX]HQFHQGLGD3yUWHQVHFRPRVLHUYRV TXHHVSHUDQDTXHUHJUHVHVXVHxRUGHXQEDQTXHWHGH ERGDVSDUDDEULUOHODSXHUWDWDQSURQWRFRPRpOOOHJXH\ WRTXH'LFKRVRVORVVLHUYRVDTXLHQHVVXVHxRUHQFXHQWUH SHQGLHQWHVGHVXOOHJDGD&UpDQPHTXHVHDMXVWDUiODURSD KDUiTXHORVVLHUYRVVHVLHQWHQDODPHVD\pOPLVPRVH SRQGUiDVHUYLUOHV6tGLFKRVRVDTXHOORVVLHUYRVDTXLHQHVVX VHxRUHQFXHQWUHSUHSDUDGRVDXQTXHOOHJXHDODPHGLDQRFKH RGHPDGUXJDGD ¢4XpGHEHPRVKDFHUSDUDTXHVHQRVVHDQVXSOLGDVODV FRVDVTXHQHFHVLWDPRV"BBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBB BBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBB -HV~VGLULJLpQGRVHDODPXOWLWXG²&XDQGRXVWHGHVYHQ TXHVHOHYDQWDXQDQXEHHQHORFFLGHQWHHQVHJXLGDGLFHQ ³9DDOORYHU´\DVtVXFHGH<FXDQGRVRSODHOYLHQWRGHO VXUGLFHQ³9DDKDFHUFDORU´\DVtVXFHGH£+LSyFULWDV 8VWHGHVVDEHQLQWHUSUHWDUODDSDULHQFLDGHODWLHUUD\GHO FLHOR¢&yPRHVTXHQRVDEHQLQWHUSUHWDUHOWLHPSRDFWXDO" ª¢3RUTXpQRMX]JDQSRUXVWHGHVPLVPRVORTXHHVMXVWR" 6LWLHQHVTXHLUFRQXQDGYHUVDULRDOPDJLVWUDGRSURFXUD UHFRQFLOLDUWHFRQpOHQHOFDPLQRQRVHDTXHWHOOHYHSRU ODIXHU]DDQWHHOMXH]\HOMXH]WHHQWUHJXHDODOJXDFLO\HO DOJXDFLOWHPHWDHQODFiUFHO7HGLJRTXHQRVDOGUiVGHDOOt KDVWDTXHSDJXHVHO~OWLPRFHQWDYR ¢4XpQRVSLGH-HV~VHQHOYHUVR"BBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBB BBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBB BBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBB 'tD ]fTRd /XFDV 'tD (QDTXHOODRFDVLyQDOJXQRVTXHKDEtDQOOHJDGROHFRQWDURQ /XFDV D-HV~VFyPR3LODWRKDEtDGDGRPXHUWHDXQRVJDOLOHRV 3HURHQWLHQGDQHVWR6LXQGXHxRGHFDVDVXSLHUDDTXpKRUD FXDQGRHOORVRIUHFtDQVXVVDFUL¿FLRV-HV~VOHVUHVSRQGLy YDDOOHJDUHOODGUyQHVWDUtDSHQGLHQWHSDUDQRGHMDUORIRU]DU ©¢3LHQVDQXVWHGHVTXHHVRVJDOLOHRVSRUKDEHUVXIULGR ODHQWUDGD$VtPLVPRGHEHQXVWHGHVHVWDUSUHSDUDGRV DVtHUDQPiVSHFDGRUHVTXHWRGRVORVGHPiV"£/HVGLJR SRUTXHHO+LMRGHOKRPEUHYHQGUiFXDQGRPHQRVORHVSHUHQ TXHQR'HODPLVPDPDQHUDWRGRVXVWHGHVSHUHFHUiQ ²6HxRU²OHSUHJXQWy3HGUR²¢FXHQWDVHVWDSDUiERODSDUD DPHQRVTXHVHDUUHSLHQWDQ¢2SLHQVDQTXHDTXHOORV QRVRWURVRSDUDWRGRV"5HVSRQGLyHO6HxRU²¢'yQGHVH GLHFLRFKRTXHIXHURQDSODVWDGRVSRUODWRUUHGH6LORp KDOODXQPD\RUGRPR¿HO\SUXGHQWHDTXLHQVXVHxRUGHMD HUDQPiVFXOSDEOHVTXHWRGRVORVGHPiVKDELWDQWHV HQFDUJDGRGHORVVLHUYRVSDUDUHSDUWLUOHVODFRPLGDDVX GH-HUXVDOpQ"£/HVGLJRTXHQR'HODPLVPDPDQHUD GHELGRWLHPSR"'LFKRVRHOVLHUYRFX\RVHxRUDOUHJUHVDU WRGRVXVWHGHVSHUHFHUiQDPHQRVTXHVHDUUHSLHQWDQª ORHQFXHQWUDFXPSOLHQGRFRQVXGHEHU/HVDVHJXURTXHOR (QWRQFHVOHVFRQWyHVWDSDUiEROD©8QKRPEUHWHQtDXQD SRQGUiDFDUJRGHWRGRVVXVELHQHV3HUR£TXpWDOVLHVH KLJXHUDSODQWDGDHQVXYLxHGRSHURFXDQGRIXHDEXVFDU VLHUYRVHSRQHDSHQVDU³0LVHxRUWDUGDHQYROYHU´\OXHJR IUXWRHQHOODQRHQFRQWUyQDGD$VtTXHOHGLMRDOYLxDGRU FRPLHQ]DDJROSHDUDORVFULDGRV\DODVFULDGDV\DFRPHU ³0LUD\DKDFHWUHVDxRVTXHYHQJRDEXVFDUIUXWRHQHVWD \EHEHU\HPERUUDFKDUVH(OVHxRUGHHVHVLHUYRYROYHUi KLJXHUD\QRKHHQFRQWUDGRQDGD£&yUWDOD¢3DUDTXp HOGtDHQTXHHOVLHUYRPHQRVORHVSHUH\DODKRUDPHQRV KDGHRFXSDUWHUUHQR"´³6HxRU²OHFRQWHVWyHOYLxDGRU² SHQVDGD(QWRQFHVORFDVWLJDUiVHYHUDPHQWH\OHLPSRQGUiOD GpMHODWRGDYtDSRUXQDxRPiVSDUDTXH\RSXHGDFDYDU FRQGHQDTXHUHFLEHQORVLQFUpGXORVª(OVLHUYRTXHFRQRFHOD DVXDOUHGHGRU\HFKDUOHDERQR$VtWDOYH]HQDGHODQWHGp YROXQWDGGHVXVHxRU\QRVHSUHSDUDSDUDFXPSOLUODUHFLELUi IUXWRVLQRFyUWHOD´ª8QViEDGR-HV~VHVWDEDHQVHxDQGR PXFKRVJROSHV(QFDPELRHOTXHQRODFRQRFH\KDFHDOJR HQXQDGHODVVLQDJRJDV\HVWDEDDOOtXQDPXMHUTXHSRU TXHPHUH]FDFDVWLJRUHFLELUiSRFRVJROSHV$WRGRHOTXH FDXVDGHXQGHPRQLROOHYDEDGLHFLRFKRDxRVHQIHUPD VHOHKDGDGRPXFKRVHOHH[LJLUiPXFKR\DOTXHVHOHKD $QGDEDHQFRUYDGD\GHQLQJ~QPRGRSRGtDHQGHUH]DUVH FRQ¿DGRPXFKRVHOHSHGLUiDXQPiV &XDQGR-HV~VODYLRODOODPy\OHGLMR²0XMHUTXHGDV OLEUHGHWXHQIHUPHGDG ¢3RUTXpWHQHPRVTXHHVWDUSUHSDUDGRV" $OPLVPRWLHPSRSXVRODVPDQRVVREUHHOOD\DOLQVWDQWHOD BBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBB PXMHUVHHQGHUH]y\HPSH]yDDODEDUD'LRV BBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBB 'tD /XFDV ª+HYHQLGRDWUDHUIXHJRDODWLHUUD\£FyPRTXLVLHUDTXH\D HVWXYLHUDDUGLHQGR3HURWHQJRTXHSDVDUSRUODSUXHEDGH XQEDXWLVPR\£FXiQWDDQJXVWLDVLHQWRKDVWDTXHVHFXPSOD ¢&UHHQXVWHGHVTXHYLQHDWUDHUSD]DODWLHUUD"£/HVGLJR TXHQRVLQRGLYLVLyQ'HDKRUDHQDGHODQWHHVWDUiQGLYLGLGRV FLQFRHQXQDIDPLOLDWUHVFRQWUDGRV\GRVFRQWUDWUHV6H HQIUHQWDUiQHOSDGUHFRQWUDVXKLMR\HOKLMRFRQWUDVXSDGUH ODPDGUHFRQWUDVXKLMD\ODKLMDFRQWUDVXPDGUHODVXHJUD FRQWUDVXQXHUD\ODQXHUDFRQWUDVXVXHJUD/XHJRDxDGLy 6HJ~Q-HV~V¢4XpGHEHPRVKDFHUSDUDQRSHUHFHU"BBBBB BBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBB CVTTZ_ 'tD /XFDV ,QGLJQDGRSRUTXH-HV~VKDEtDVDQDGRHQViEDGRHOMHIH GHODVLQDJRJDLQWHUYLQRGLULJLpQGRVHDODJHQWH²+D\ VHLVGtDVHQTXHVHSXHGHWUDEDMDUDVtTXHYHQJDQHVRV GtDVSDUDVHUVDQDGRV\QRHOViEDGR²£+LSyFULWDV ²OHFRQWHVWyHO6HxRU²¢$FDVRQRGHVDWDFDGDXQRGH XVWHGHVVXEXH\RVXEXUURHQViEDGR\ORVDFDGHOHVWDEOR SDUDOOHYDUORDWRPDUDJXD"6LQHPEDUJRDHVWDPXMHUTXH HVKLMDGH$EUDKDP\DTXLHQ6DWDQiVWHQtDDWDGDGXUDQWH GLHFLRFKRODUJRVDxRV¢QRVHOHGHEtDTXLWDUHVWDFDGHQD HQViEDGR"&XDQGRUD]RQyDVtTXHGDURQKXPLOODGRVWRGRV VXVDGYHUVDULRVSHURODJHQWHHVWDEDHQFDQWDGDGHWDQWDV PDUDYLOODVTXHpOKDFtD²¢$TXpVHSDUHFHHOUHLQRGH 'LRV"²FRQWLQXy-HV~V²¢&RQTXpYR\DFRPSDUDUOR"6H SDUHFHDXQJUDQRGHPRVWD]DTXHXQKRPEUHVHPEUyHQ VXKXHUWR&UHFLyKDVWDFRQYHUWLUVHHQXQiUERO\ODVDYHV DQLGDURQHQVXVUDPDV 9ROYLyDGHFLU²¢&RQTXpYR\DFRPSDUDUHOUHLQRGH'LRV" (VFRPRODOHYDGXUDTXHXQDPXMHUWRPy\PH]FOyFRQXQD JUDQFDQWLGDGGHKDULQDKDVWDTXHIHUPHQWyWRGDODPDVD ¢&RQTXpFRPSDUy-HV~VHOUHLQRGH'LRV"BBBBBBBBBBBBBB BBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBB 'tD /XFDV &RQWLQXDQGRVXYLDMHD-HUXVDOpQ-HV~VHQVHxDEDHQORV SXHEORV\DOGHDVSRUGRQGHSDVDED²6HxRU¢VRQSRFRV ORVTXHYDQDVDOYDUVH"²OHSUHJXQWyXQR²(VIXpUFHQVH SRUHQWUDUSRUODSXHUWDHVWUHFKD²FRQWHVWy²SRUTXH OHVGLJRTXHPXFKRVWUDWDUiQGHHQWUDU\QRSRGUiQ7DQ SURQWRFRPRHOGXHxRGHODFDVDVHKD\DOHYDQWDGRDFHUUDU ODSXHUWDXVWHGHVGHVGHDIXHUDVHSRQGUiQDJROSHDUOD SXHUWDGLFLHQGR³6HxRUiEUHQRV´3HURpOOHVFRQWHVWDUi ³1RVpTXLpQHVVRQXVWHGHV´(QWRQFHVGLUiQ³&RPLPRV\ EHELPRVFRQWLJR\W~HQVHxDVWHHQQXHVWUDVSOD]DV´3HUR pOOHVFRQWHVWDUi³/HVUHSLWRTXHQRVpTXLpQHVVRQXVWHGHV £$SiUWHQVHGHPtWRGRVXVWHGHVKDFHGRUHVGHLQMXVWLFLD´ ª$OOtKDEUiOODQWR\UHFKLQDUGHGLHQWHVFXDQGRYHDQHQ HOUHLQRGH'LRVD$EUDKDP,VDDF-DFRE\DWRGRVORV SURIHWDVPLHQWUDVDXVWHGHVORVHFKDQIXHUD+DEUiTXLHQHV OOHJXHQGHORULHQWH\GHORFFLGHQWHGHOQRUWH\GHOVXUSDUD VHQWDUVHDOEDQTXHWHHQHOUHLQRGH'LRV(QHIHFWRKD\ ~OWLPRVTXHVHUiQSULPHURV\SULPHURVTXHVHUiQ~OWLPRV (QHVHPRPHQWRVHDFHUFDURQD-HV~VXQRVIDULVHRV\OH GLMHURQ²6DOGHDTXt\YHWHDRWUROXJDUSRUTXH+HURGHV TXLHUHPDWDUWHeOOHVFRQWHVWy²9D\DQ\GtJDQOHDHVH ]RUUR³0LUDKR\\PDxDQDVHJXLUpH[SXOVDQGRGHPRQLRV \VDQDQGRDODJHQWH\DOWHUFHUGtDWHUPLQDUpORTXHGHER KDFHU´7HQJRTXHVHJXLUDGHODQWHKR\PDxDQD\SDVDGR PDxDQDSRUTXHQRSXHGHVHUTXHPXHUDXQSURIHWDIXHUDGH -HUXVDOpQª£-HUXVDOpQ-HUXVDOpQTXHPDWDVDORVSURIHWDV \DSHGUHDVDORVTXHVHWHHQYtDQ£&XiQWDVYHFHVTXLVH UHXQLUDWXVKLMRVFRPRUH~QHODJDOOLQDDVXVSROOLWRVGHEDMR GHVXVDODVSHURQRTXLVLVWH3XHVELHQODFDVDGHXVWHGHV YDDTXHGDUDEDQGRQDGD<OHVDGYLHUWRTXH\DQRYROYHUiQ DYHUPHKDVWDHOGtDTXHGLJDQ³£%HQGLWRHOTXHYLHQHHQHO QRPEUHGHO6HxRU´ ¢$TXpGLFH-HV~VTXHQRVHVIRUFHPRV"BBBBBBBBBBBBBBB BBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBB 'tD ]fTRd /XFDV 8QGtD-HV~VIXHDFRPHUDFDVDGHXQQRWDEOHGHORV IDULVHRV(UDViEDGRDVtTXHpVWRVHVWDEDQDFHFKDQGRD -HV~V$OOtGHODQWHGHpOHVWDEDXQKRPEUHHQIHUPRGH KLGURSHVtD-HV~VOHVSUHJXQWyDORVH[SHUWRVHQODOH\\D ORVIDULVHRV²¢(VWiSHUPLWLGRRQRVDQDUHQViEDGR" 3HURHOORVVHTXHGDURQFDOODGRV(QWRQFHVWRPyDOKRPEUH ORVDQy\ORGHVSLGLy7DPELpQOHVGLMR ²6LXQRGHXVWHGHVWLHQHXQKLMRRXQEXH\TXHVHOHFDH HQXQSR]R¢QRORVDFDHQVHJXLGDDXQTXHVHDViEDGR" <QRSXGLHURQFRQWHVWDUOHQDGD$OQRWDUFyPRORVLQYLWDGRV HVFRJtDQORVOXJDUHVGHKRQRUHQODPHVDOHVFRQWyHVWD SDUiEROD ²&XDQGRDOJXLHQWHLQYLWHDXQD¿HVWDGHERGDVQR WHVLHQWHVHQHOOXJDUGHKRQRUQRVHDTXHKD\DDOJ~Q LQYLWDGRPiVGLVWLQJXLGRTXHW~6LHVDVtHOTXHORVLQYLWyD ORVGRVYHQGUi\WHGLUi³&pGHOHWXDVLHQWRDHVWHKRPEUH´ (QWRQFHVDYHUJRQ]DGRWHQGUiVTXHRFXSDUHO~OWLPR DVLHQWR0iVELHQFXDQGRWHLQYLWHQVLpQWDWHHQHO~OWLPR OXJDUSDUDTXHFXDQGRYHQJDHOTXHWHLQYLWyWHGLJD ³$PLJRSDVDPiVDGHODQWHDXQOXJDUPHMRU´$VtUHFLELUiV KRQRUHQSUHVHQFLDGHWRGRVORVGHPiVLQYLWDGRV7RGR HOTXHDVtPLVPRVHHQDOWHFHVHUiKXPLOODGR\HOTXHVH KXPLOODVHUiHQDOWHFLGR7DPELpQGLMR-HV~VDOTXHORKDEtD LQYLWDGR²&XDQGRGHVXQDFRPLGDRXQDFHQDQRLQYLWHV DWXVDPLJRVQLDWXVKHUPDQRVQLDWXVSDULHQWHVQLDWXV YHFLQRVULFRVQRVHDTXHHOORVDVXYH]WHLQYLWHQ\DVt VHDVUHFRPSHQVDGR0iVELHQFXDQGRGHVXQEDQTXHWH LQYLWDDORVSREUHVDORVLQYiOLGRVDORVFRMRV\DORV FLHJRV(QWRQFHVVHUiVGLFKRVRSXHVDXQTXHHOORVQR WLHQHQFRQTXpUHFRPSHQVDUWHVHUiVUHFRPSHQVDGRHQOD UHVXUUHFFLyQGHORVMXVWRV ¢4XpVXFHGHFRQORVTXHVHKXPLOODQ"BBBBBBBBBBBBBBBB BBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBB 'tD /XFDV $ORtUHVWRXQRGHORVTXHHVWDEDQVHQWDGRVDODPHVD FRQ-HV~VOHGLMR²£'LFKRVRHOTXHFRPDHQHOEDQTXHWH GHOUHLQRGH'LRV-HV~VOHFRQWHVWy²&LHUWRKRPEUH SUHSDUyXQJUDQEDQTXHWHHLQYLWyDPXFKDVSHUVRQDV$ ODKRUDGHOEDQTXHWHPDQGyDVXVLHUYRDGHFLUOHVDORV LQYLWDGRV³9HQJDQSRUTXH\DWRGRHVWiOLVWR´3HURWRGRV VLQH[FHSFLyQFRPHQ]DURQDGLVFXOSDUVH(OSULPHUROHGLMR ³$FDERGHFRPSUDUXQWHUUHQR\WHQJRTXHLUDYHUOR7H UXHJRTXHPHGLVFXOSHV´2WURDGXMR³$FDERGHFRPSUDU FLQFR\XQWDVGHEXH\HV\YR\DSUREDUODV7HUXHJRTXH PHGLVFXOSHV´2WURDOHJy³$FDERGHFDVDUPH\SRUHVR QRSXHGRLU´(OVLHUYRUHJUHVy\OHLQIRUPyGHHVWRDVX VHxRU(QWRQFHVHOGXHxRGHODFDVDVHHQRMy\OHPDQGy DVXVLHUYR³6DOGHSULVDSRUODVSOD]DV\ORVFDOOHMRQHVGHO SXHEOR\WUDHDFiDORVSREUHVDORVLQYiOLGRVDORVFRMRV \DORVFLHJRV´³6HxRU²OHGLMROXHJRHOVLHUYR²\DKLFH ORTXHXVWHGPHPDQGySHURWRGDYtDKD\OXJDU´(QWRQFHV HOVHxRUOHUHVSRQGLy³9HSRUORVFDPLQRV\ODVYHUHGDV\ REOtJDORVDHQWUDUSDUDTXHVHOOHQHPLFDVD/HVGLJRTXH QLQJXQRGHDTXHOORVLQYLWDGRVGLVIUXWDUiGHPLEDQTXHWH´ *UDQGHVPXOWLWXGHVVHJXtDQD-HV~V\pOVHYROYLy\OHV GLMR ¢4XLpQHVVHUiQGLFKRVRV"BBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBB BBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBB 'tD /XFDV ©6LDOJXQRYLHQHDPt\QRVDFUL¿FDHODPRUDVXSDGUH\ DVXPDGUHDVXHVSRVD\DVXVKLMRVDVXVKHUPDQRV\ DVXVKHUPDQDV\DXQDVXSURSLDYLGDQRSXHGHVHUPL GLVFtSXOR<HOTXHQRFDUJDVXFUX]\PHVLJXHQRSXHGHVHU PLGLVFtSXORª6XSRQJDPRVTXHDOJXQRGHXVWHGHVTXLHUH FRQVWUXLUXQDWRUUH¢$FDVRQRVHVLHQWDSULPHURDFDOFXODU HOFRVWRSDUDYHUVLWLHQHVX¿FLHQWHGLQHURSDUDWHUPLQDUOD" 6LHFKDORVFLPLHQWRV\QRSXHGHWHUPLQDUODWRGRVORVTXH ODYHDQFRPHQ]DUiQDEXUODUVHGHpO\GLUiQ³(VWHKRPEUH \DQRSXGRWHUPLQDUORTXHFRPHQ]yDFRQVWUXLU´ª2 VXSRQJDPRVTXHXQUH\HVWiDSXQWRGHLUDODJXHUUDFRQWUD RWURUH\¢$FDVRQRVHVLHQWDSULPHURDFDOFXODUVLFRQGLH] PLOKRPEUHVSXHGHHQIUHQWDUVHDOTXHYLHQHFRQWUDpOFRQ YHLQWHPLO"6LQRSXHGHHQYLDUiXQDGHOHJDFLyQPLHQWUDVHO RWURHVWiWRGDYtDOHMRVSDUDSHGLUFRQGLFLRQHVGHSD]'H ODPLVPDPDQHUDFXDOTXLHUDGHXVWHGHVTXHQRUHQXQFLH DWRGRVVXVELHQHVQRSXHGHVHUPLGLVFtSXORª/DVDOHV EXHQDSHURVLVHYXHOYHLQVtSLGD¢FyPRUHFXSHUDUiHO VDERU"1RVLUYHQLSDUDODWLHUUDQLSDUDHODERQRKD\TXH WLUDUODIXHUDª(OTXHWHQJDRtGRVSDUDRtUTXHRLJDª ¢4XpVHQHFHVLWDSDUDVHUGLVFtSXORGH-HV~V"BBBBBBBBBB BBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBB BBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBB CVTTZ_ 'tD ]fTRd /XFDV 0XFKRVUHFDXGDGRUHVGHLPSXHVWRV\SHFDGRUHVVH DFHUFDEDQD-HV~VSDUDRtUORGHPRGRTXHORVIDULVHRV\ORV PDHVWURVGHODOH\VHSXVLHURQDPXUPXUDU©(VWHKRPEUH UHFLEHDORVSHFDGRUHV\FRPHFRQHOORVªeOHQWRQFHVOHV FRQWyHVWDSDUiEROD©6XSRQJDPRVTXHXQRGHXVWHGHV WLHQHFLHQRYHMDV\SLHUGHXQDGHHOODV¢1RGHMDODVQRYHQWD \QXHYHHQHOFDPSR\YDHQEXVFDGHODRYHMDSHUGLGD KDVWDHQFRQWUDUOD"<FXDQGRODHQFXHQWUDOOHQRGHDOHJUtD ODFDUJDHQORVKRPEURV\YXHOYHDODFDVD$OOOHJDUUH~QH DVXVDPLJRV\YHFLQRV\OHVGLFH³$OpJUHQVHFRQPLJR \DHQFRQWUpODRYHMDTXHVHPHKDEtDSHUGLGR´/HVGLJR TXHDVtHVWDPELpQHQHOFLHORKDEUiPiVDOHJUtDSRUXQ VRORSHFDGRUTXHVHDUUHSLHQWDTXHSRUQRYHQWD\QXHYH MXVWRVTXHQRQHFHVLWDQDUUHSHQWLUVHª2VXSRQJDPRV TXHXQDPXMHUWLHQHGLH]PRQHGDVGHSODWD\SLHUGHXQD ¢1RHQFLHQGHXQDOiPSDUDEDUUHODFDVD\EXVFDFRQ FXLGDGRKDVWDHQFRQWUDUOD"<FXDQGRODHQFXHQWUDUH~QH DVXVDPLJDV\YHFLQDV\OHVGLFH³$OpJUHQVHFRQPLJR\D HQFRQWUpODPRQHGDTXHVHPHKDEtDSHUGLGR´/HVGLJRTXH DVtPLVPRVHDOHJUD'LRVFRQVXViQJHOHVSRUXQSHFDGRU TXHVHDUUHSLHQWH ¢&yPRUHDFFLRQD'LRVFXDQGRXQSHFDGRUVHDUUHSLHQWH"BB BBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBB 'tD /XFDV 8QKRPEUHWHQtDGRVKLMRV²FRQWLQXy-HV~V²(OPHQRUGH HOORVOHGLMRDVXSDGUH³3DSiGDPHORTXHPHWRFDGHOD KHUHQFLD´$VtTXHHOSDGUHUHSDUWLyVXVELHQHVHQWUHORV GRV3RFRGHVSXpVHOKLMRPHQRUMXQWyWRGRORTXHWHQtD \VHIXHDXQSDtVOHMDQRDOOtYLYLyGHVHQIUHQDGDPHQWH\ GHUURFKyVXKHUHQFLDª&XDQGR\DORKDEtDJDVWDGRWRGR VREUHYLQRXQDJUDQHVFDVH]HQODUHJLyQ\pOFRPHQ]yD SDVDUQHFHVLGDG$VtTXHIXH\FRQVLJXLyHPSOHRFRQXQ FLXGDGDQRGHDTXHOSDtVTXLHQORPDQGyDVXVFDPSRV DFXLGDUFHUGRV7DQWDKDPEUHWHQtDTXHKXELHUDTXHULGR OOHQDUVHHOHVWyPDJRFRQODFRPLGDTXHGDEDQDORVFHUGRV SHURDXQDVtQDGLHOHGDEDQDGD3RU¿QUHFDSDFLWy\VH GLMR³£&XiQWRVMRUQDOHURVGHPLSDGUHWLHQHQFRPLGDGH VREUD\\RDTXtPHPXHURGHKDPEUH7HQJRTXHYROYHUD PLSDGUH\GHFLUOH3DSiKHSHFDGRFRQWUDHOFLHOR\FRQWUD WL<DQRPHUH]FRTXHVHPHOODPHWXKLMRWUiWDPHFRPRVL IXHUDXQRGHWXVMRUQDOHURV´$VtTXHHPSUHQGLyHOYLDMH\VH IXHDVXSDGUHª7RGDYtDHVWDEDOHMRVFXDQGRVXSDGUHOR YLR\VHFRPSDGHFLyGHpOVDOLyFRUULHQGRDVXHQFXHQWUR ORDEUD]y\OREHVy(OMRYHQOHGLMR³3DSiKHSHFDGR FRQWUDHOFLHOR\FRQWUDWL<DQRPHUH]FRTXHVHPHOODPH WXKLMR´ ¢&RQWUDTXLpQVHGLRFXHQWDTXHKDEtDSHFDGRHOKLMR" BBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBB BBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBB 'tD /XFDV 3HURHOSDGUHRUGHQyDVXVVLHUYRV³£3URQWR7UDLJDQOD PHMRUURSDSDUDYHVWLUOR3yQJDQOHWDPELpQXQDQLOORHQHO GHGR\VDQGDOLDVHQORVSLHV7UDLJDQHOWHUQHURPiVJRUGR \PiWHQORSDUDFHOHEUDUXQEDQTXHWH3RUTXHHVWHKLMRPtR HVWDEDPXHUWRSHURDKRUDKDYXHOWRDODYLGDVHKDEtD SHUGLGRSHUR\DORKHPRVHQFRQWUDGR´$VtTXHHPSH]DURQ DKDFHU¿HVWDª0LHQWUDVWDQWRHOKLMRPD\RUHVWDEDHQHO FDPSR$OYROYHUFXDQGRVHDFHUFyDODFDVDR\yODP~VLFD GHOEDLOH(QWRQFHVOODPyDXQRGHORVVLHUYRV\OHSUHJXQWy TXpSDVDED³+DOOHJDGRWXKHUPDQR²OHUHVSRQGLy²\WX SDSiKDPDWDGRHOWHUQHURPiVJRUGRSRUTXHKDUHFREUDGR DVXKLMRVDQR\VDOYR´,QGLJQDGRHOKHUPDQRPD\RUVH QHJyDHQWUDU$VtTXHVXSDGUHVDOLyDVXSOLFDUOHTXHOR KLFLHUD3HURpOOHFRQWHVWy³£)tMDWHFXiQWRVDxRVWHKH VHUYLGRVLQGHVREHGHFHUMDPiVWXVyUGHQHV\QLXQFDEULWR PHKDVGDGRSDUDFHOHEUDUXQD¿HVWDFRQPLVDPLJRV £3HURDKRUDOOHJDHVHKLMRWX\RTXHKDGHVSLOIDUUDGRWX IRUWXQDFRQSURVWLWXWDV\W~PDQGDVPDWDUHQVXKRQRU HOWHUQHURPiVJRUGR´ª³+LMRPtR²OHGLMRVXSDGUH² W~VLHPSUHHVWiVFRQPLJR\WRGRORTXHWHQJRHVWX\R 3HURWHQtDPRVTXHKDFHU¿HVWD\DOHJUDUQRVSRUTXHHVWH KHUPDQRWX\RHVWDEDPXHUWRSHURDKRUDKDYXHOWRDOD YLGDVHKDEtDSHUGLGRSHUR\DORKHPRVHQFRQWUDGR´ª ¢4XpKL]RHOSDGUHFXDQGROOHJyVXKLMR"BBBBBBBBBBBBBBB BBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBB 'tD ]fTRd /XFDV -HV~VFRQWyRWUDSDUiERODDVXVGLVFtSXORV©8Q KRPEUHULFRWHQtDXQDGPLQLVWUDGRUDTXLHQDFXVDURQGH GHUURFKDUVXVELHQHV$VtTXHORPDQGyDOODPDU\OHGLMR ³¢4XpHVHVWRTXHPHGLFHQGHWL"5LQGHFXHQWDVGHWX DGPLQLVWUDFLyQSRUTXH\DQRSXHGHVVHJXLUHQWXSXHVWR´ (ODGPLQLVWUDGRUUHÀH[LRQy³¢4XpYR\DKDFHUDKRUDTXH PLSDWUyQHVWiSRUTXLWDUPHHOSXHVWR"1RWHQJRIXHU]DV SDUDFDYDU\PHGDYHUJHQ]DSHGLUOLPRVQD7HQJRTXH DVHJXUDUPHGHTXHFXDQGRPHHFKHQGHODDGPLQLVWUDFLyQ KD\DJHQWHTXHPHUHFLEDHQVXFDVD£<DVpORTXHYR\D KDFHU´ª/ODPyHQWRQFHVDFDGDXQRGHORVTXHOHGHEtDQ DOJRDVXSDWUyQ$OSULPHUROHSUHJXQWy³¢&XiQWROH GHEHVDPLSDWUyQ"´³&LHQEDUULOHVGHDFHLWH´OHFRQWHVWy pO(ODGPLQLVWUDGRUOHGLMR³7RPDWXIDFWXUDVLpQWDWHHQ VHJXLGD\HVFULEHFLQFXHQWD´/XHJRSUHJXQWyDOVHJXQGR ³<W~¢FXiQWRGHEHV"´³&LHQEXOWRVGHWULJR´FRQWHVWy(O DGPLQLVWUDGRUOHGLMR³7RPDWXIDFWXUD\HVFULEHRFKHQWD´ ª3XHVELHQHOSDWUyQHORJLyDODGPLQLVWUDGRUGHULTXH]DV PXQGDQDV>SRUKDEHUDFWXDGRFRQDVWXFLD(VTXHORVGH HVWHPXQGRHQVXWUDWRFRQORVTXHVRQFRPRHOORVVRQPiV DVWXWRVTXHORVTXHKDQUHFLELGRODOX]3RUHVROHVGLJRTXH VHYDOJDQGHODVULTXH]DVPXQGDQDVSDUDJDQDUDPLJRVD ¿QGHTXHFXDQGRpVWDVVHDFDEHQKD\DTXLHQHVORVUHFLEDQ DXVWHGHVHQODVYLYLHQGDVHWHUQDVª(OTXHHVKRQUDGRHQ ORSRFRWDPELpQORVHUiHQORPXFKR\HOTXHQRHVtQWHJUR HQORSRFRWDPSRFRORVHUiHQORPXFKR3RUHVRVLXVWHGHV QRKDQVLGRKRQUDGRVHQHOXVRGHODVULTXH]DVPXQGDQDV ¢TXLpQOHVFRQ¿DUiODVYHUGDGHUDV"<VLFRQORDMHQRQR KDQVLGRKRQUDGRV¢TXLpQOHVGDUiDXVWHGHVORTXHOHV SHUWHQHFH" ¢4XpSDVDUiVLQRVRPRVKRQUDGRV"BBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBB BBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBB 'tD /XFDV ª1LQJ~QVLUYLHQWHSXHGHVHUYLUDGRVSDWURQHV 0HQRVSUHFLDUiDXQR\DPDUiDORWURRTXHUUiPXFKRD XQR\GHVSUHFLDUiDORWUR8VWHGHVQRSXHGHQVHUYLUDOD YH]D'LRV\DODVULTXH]DVª2tDQWRGRHVWRORVIDULVHRVD TXLHQHVOHVHQFDQWDEDHOGLQHUR\VHEXUODEDQGH-HV~VeO OHVGLMR©8VWHGHVVHKDFHQORVEXHQRVDQWHODJHQWHSHUR 'LRVFRQRFHVXVFRUD]RQHV'HQVHFXHQWDGHTXHDTXHOOR TXHODJHQWHWLHQHHQJUDQHVWLPDHVGHWHVWDEOHGHODQWH GH'LRVª/DOH\\ORVSURIHWDVVHSURFODPDURQKDVWD-XDQ 'HVGHHQWRQFHVVHDQXQFLDQODVEXHQDVQXHYDVGHOUHLQRGH 'LRV\WRGRVVHHVIXHU]DQSRUHQWUDUHQpO(VPiVIiFLOTXH GHVDSDUH]FDQHOFLHOR\ODWLHUUDTXHFDLJDXQDVRODWLOGHGH ODOH\ª7RGRHOTXHVHGLYRUFLDGHVXHVSRVD\VHFDVDFRQ RWUDFRPHWHDGXOWHULR\HOTXHVHFDVDFRQODGLYRUFLDGD FRPHWHDGXOWHULRª+DEtDXQKRPEUHULFRTXHVHYHVWtD OXMRVDPHQW@\GDEDHVSOpQGLGRVEDQTXHWHVWRGRVORVGtDV$ ODSXHUWDGHVXFDVDVHWHQGtDXQPHQGLJROODPDGR/i]DUR TXHHVWDEDFXELHUWRGHOODJDV\TXHKXELHUDTXHULGROOHQDUVH HOHVWyPDJRFRQORTXHFDtDGHODPHVDGHOULFR+DVWDORV SHUURVVHDFHUFDEDQ\OHODPtDQODVOODJDVª5HVXOWDTXH PXULyHOPHQGLJR\ORViQJHOHVVHOROOHYDURQSDUDTXH HVWXYLHUDDOODGRGH$EUDKDP7DPELpQPXULyHOULFR\OR VHSXOWDURQ(QHOLQ¿HUQRHQPHGLRGHVXVWRUPHQWRVHOULFR OHYDQWyORVRMRV\YLRGHOHMRVD$EUDKDP\D/i]DURMXQWRD pO ¢4XpSDVDUiVLQRVRWURVVHUYLPRVDGRVSDWURQHV"BBBBBBB BBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBB BBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBB CVTTZ_ 'tD /XFDV $VtTXHDO]yODYR]\OROODPy³3DGUH$EUDKDPWHQ FRPSDVLyQGHPt\PDQGDD/i]DURTXHPRMHODSXQWD GHOGHGRHQDJXD\PHUHIUHVTXHODOHQJXDSRUTXH HVWR\VXIULHQGRPXFKRHQHVWHIXHJR´3HUR$EUDKDPOH FRQWHVWy³+LMRUHFXHUGDTXHGXUDQWHWXYLGDWHIXHPX\ ELHQPLHQWUDVTXHD/i]DUROHIXHPX\PDOSHURDKRUDD pOOHWRFDUHFLELUFRQVXHORDTXt\DWLVXIULUWHUULEOHPHQWH $GHPiVGHHVRKD\XQJUDQDELVPRHQWUHQRVRWURV\ XVWHGHVGHPRGRTXHORVTXHTXLHUHQSDVDUGHDTXtSDUD DOOiQRSXHGHQQLWDPSRFRSXHGHQORVGHDOOiSDUDDFi´ ªeOUHVSRQGLy³(QWRQFHVWHUXHJRSDGUHTXHPDQGHV D/i]DURDODFDVDGHPLSDGUHSDUDTXHDGYLHUWDDPLV FLQFRKHUPDQRV\QRYHQJDQHOORVWDPELpQDHVWHOXJDUGH WRUPHQWR´3HUR$EUDKDPOHFRQWHVWy³<DWLHQHQD0RLVpV \DORVSURIHWDV£TXHOHVKDJDQFDVRDHOORV´³1ROHVKDUiQ FDVRSDGUH$EUDKDP²UHSOLFyHOULFR²HQFDPELRVLVH OHVSUHVHQWDUDXQRGHHQWUHORVPXHUWRVHQWRQFHVVtVH DUUHSHQWLUtDQ´$EUDKDPOHGLMR³6LQROHVKDFHQFDVRD 0RLVpV\DORVSURIHWDVWDPSRFRVHFRQYHQFHUiQDXQTXH DOJXLHQVHOHYDQWHGHHQWUHORVPXHUWRV´ª CfTRd /XHJRGLMR-HV~VDVXVGLVFtSXORV²/RVWURSLH]RVVRQ LQHYLWDEOHVSHUR£D\GHDTXHOTXHORVRFDVLRQD0iV OHYDOGUtDVHUDUURMDGRDOPDUFRQXQDSLHGUDGHPROLQR DWDGDDOFXHOORTXHVHUYLUGHWURSLH]RDXQRVRORGHHVWRV SHTXHxRV$VtTXH£FXtGHQVHª6LWXKHUPDQRSHFD UHSUpQGHOR\VLVHDUUHSLHQWHSHUGyQDOR$XQVLSHFD FRQWUDWLVLHWHYHFHVHQXQGtD\VLHWHYHFHVUHJUHVDD GHFLUWH³0HDUUHSLHQWR´SHUGyQDOR ¢&XiQWDVYHFHVGLFH-HV~VTXHGHEHPRVSHUGRQDUDOTXH SHFDFRQWUDQRVRWURV"BBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBB BBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBB 'tD /XFDV (QWRQFHVORVDSyVWROHVOHGLMHURQDO6HxRU²£$XPHQWD QXHVWUDIH²6LXVWHGHVWXYLHUDQXQDIHWDQSHTXHxDFRPR XQJUDQRGHPRVWD]D²OHVUHVSRQGLyHO6HxRU²SRGUtDQ GHFLUOHDHVWHiUERO³'HVDUUiLJDWH\SOiQWDWHHQHOPDU´\ OHVREHGHFHUtDª6XSRQJDPRVTXHXQRGHXVWHGHVWLHQH XQVLHUYRTXHKDHVWDGRDUDQGRHOFDPSRRFXLGDQGRODV RYHMDV&XDQGRHOVLHUYRUHJUHVDGHOFDPSR¢DFDVRVH OHGLFH³9HQHQVHJXLGDDVHQWDUWHDODPHVD´"¢1RVH OHGLUtDPiVELHQ³3UHSiUDPHODFRPLGD\FiPELDWHGH URSDSDUDDWHQGHUPHPLHQWUDV\RFHQRGHVSXpVW~SRGUiV FHQDU´"¢$FDVRVHOHGDUtDQODVJUDFLDVDOVLHUYRSRUKDEHU KHFKRORTXHVHOHPDQGy"$VtWDPELpQXVWHGHVFXDQGR KD\DQKHFKRWRGRORTXHVHOHVKDPDQGDGRGHEHQGHFLU ³6RPRVVLHUYRVLQ~WLOHVQRKHPRVKHFKRPiVTXHFXPSOLU FRQQXHVWURGHEHU´8QGtDVLJXLHQGRVXYLDMHD-HUXVDOpQ -HV~VSDVDEDSRU6DPDULD\*DOLOHD&XDQGRHVWDEDSRU HQWUDUHQXQSXHEORVDOLHURQDVXHQFXHQWURGLH]KRPEUHV HQIHUPRVGHOHSUD&RPRVHKDEtDQTXHGDGRDFLHUWD GLVWDQFLDJULWDURQ²£-HV~V0DHVWURWHQFRPSDVLyQGH QRVRWURV$OYHUORVOHVGLMR²9D\DQDSUHVHQWDUVHDORV VDFHUGRWHV5HVXOWyTXHPLHQWUDVLEDQGHFDPLQRTXHGDURQ OLPSLRV8QRGHHOORVDOYHUVH\DVDQRUHJUHVyDODEDQGR D'LRVDJUDQGHVYRFHV&D\yURVWURHQWLHUUDDORVSLHVGH -HV~V\OHGLRODVJUDFLDVQRREVWDQWHTXHHUDVDPDULWDQR GH'LRVQLFRQVLGHUDFLyQGHQDGLH(QHOPLVPRSXHEOR KDEtDXQDYLXGDTXHLQVLVWtDHQSHGLUOH³+iJDPHXVWHG MXVWLFLDFRQWUDPLDGYHUVDULR´'XUDQWHDOJ~QWLHPSRpOVH QHJySHURSRU¿QFRQFOX\y³$XQTXHQRWHPRD'LRVQL WHQJRFRQVLGHUDFLyQGHQDGLHFRPRHVWDYLXGDQRGHMD ¢&XiQWRVGHORVOHSURVRVUHJUHVDURQDGDUJUDFLDVSRUVX GHPROHVWDUPHYR\DWHQHUTXHKDFHUOHMXVWLFLDQRVHD VDQLGDG"BBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBB TXHFRQVXVYLVLWDVPHKDJDODYLGDLPSRVLEOH´ª&RQWLQXy HO6HxRU©7HQJDQHQFXHQWDORTXHGLMRHOMXH]LQMXVWR 'tD ¢$FDVR'LRVQRKDUiMXVWLFLDDVXVHVFRJLGRVTXHFODPDQ /XFDV DpOGtD\QRFKH"¢6HWDUGDUiPXFKRHQUHVSRQGHUOHV"/HV ²¢$FDVRQRTXHGDURQOLPSLRVORVGLH]"²SUHJXQWy-HV~V² GLJRTXHVtOHVKDUiMXVWLFLD\VLQGHPRUD1RREVWDQWH ¢'yQGHHVWiQORVRWURVQXHYH"¢1RKXERQLQJXQRTXH FXDQGRYHQJDHO+LMRGHOKRPEUH¢HQFRQWUDUiIHHQOD UHJUHVDUDDGDUJORULDD'LRVH[FHSWRHVWHH[WUDQMHUR" WLHUUD"ª$DOJXQRVTXHFRQ¿DQGRHQVtPLVPRVVHFUHtDQ /HYiQWDWH\YHWH²OHGLMRDOKRPEUH²WXIHWHKDVDQDGR MXVWRV\TXHGHVSUHFLDEDQDORVGHPiV-HV~VOHVFRQWy /RVIDULVHRVOHSUHJXQWDURQD-HV~VFXiQGRLEDDYHQLU HVWDSDUiEROD©'RVKRPEUHVVXELHURQDOWHPSORDRUDU HOUHLQRGH'LRV\pOOHVUHVSRQGLy²/DYHQLGDGHOUHLQR XQRHUDIDULVHR\HORWURUHFDXGDGRUGHLPSXHVWRV(O GH'LRVQRVHSXHGHVRPHWHUDFiOFXORV1RYDQDGHFLU IDULVHRVHSXVRDRUDUFRQVLJRPLVPR³2K'LRVWHGR\ ³£0tUHQORDFi£0tUHQORDOOi´'HQVHFXHQWDGHTXHHOUHLQRGH JUDFLDVSRUTXHQRVR\FRPRRWURVKRPEUHV²ODGURQHV 'LRVHVWiHQWUHXVWHGHV$VXVGLVFtSXORVOHVGLMR²/OHJDUi PDOKHFKRUHVDG~OWHURV²QLPXFKRPHQRVFRPRHVH HOWLHPSRHQTXHXVWHGHVDQKHODUiQYLYLUVLTXLHUDXQRGH UHFDXGDGRUGHLPSXHVWRV$\XQRGRVYHFHVDODVHPDQD\ ORVGtDVGHO+LMRGHOKRPEUHSHURQRSRGUiQ/HVGLUiQ GR\ODGpFLPDSDUWHGHWRGRORTXHUHFLER´(QFDPELRHO ³£0tUHQORDOOi£0tUHQORDFi´1RYD\DQQRORVVLJDQ3RUTXH UHFDXGDGRUGHLPSXHVWRVTXHVHKDEtDTXHGDGRDFLHUWD HQVXGtDHO+LMRGHOKRPEUHVHUiFRPRHOUHOiPSDJRTXH GLVWDQFLDQLVLTXLHUDVHDWUHYtDDDO]DUODYLVWDDOFLHOR IXOJXUDHLOXPLQDHOFLHORGHXQRDRWURH[WUHPR3HURDQWHV VLQRTXHVHJROSHDEDHOSHFKR\GHFtD³£2K'LRVWHQ pOWLHQHTXHVXIULUPXFKDVFRVDV\VHUUHFKD]DGRSRUHVWD FRPSDVLyQGHPtTXHVR\SHFDGRU´ª/HVGLJRTXHpVWH\ JHQHUDFLyQª7DOFRPRVXFHGLyHQWLHPSRVGH1RpDVt QRDTXpOYROYLyDVXFDVDMXVWL¿FDGRDQWH'LRV3XHVWRGR WDPELpQVHUiFXDQGRYHQJDHO+LMRGHOKRPEUH&RPtDQ HOTXHDVtPLVPRVHHQDOWHFHVHUiKXPLOODGR\HOTXHVH EHEtDQ\VHFDVDEDQ\GDEDQHQFDVDPLHQWRKDVWDHOGtD KXPLOODVHUiHQDOWHFLGRª HQTXH1RpHQWUyHQHODUFDHQWRQFHVOOHJyHOGLOXYLR\ORV GHVWUX\yDWRGRV ¢4XpGLFH-HV~VTXHKDUi'LRVDORVTXHFODPDQDeOGtD\ QRFKH"BBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBB ¢6HJ~Q-HV~VFRPRVHUiQORVWLHPSRVFXDQGRYHQJDHO+LMR BBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBB GHO+RPEUH"BBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBB BBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBB CVTTZ_ 'tD /XFDV ª/RPLVPRVXFHGLyHQWLHPSRVGH/RWFRPtDQ\EHEtDQ FRPSUDEDQ\YHQGtDQVHPEUDEDQ\HGL¿FDEDQ3HURHOGtD HQTXH/RWVDOLyGH6RGRPDOORYLyGHOFLHORIXHJR\D]XIUH\ DFDEyFRQWRGRV ª$VtVHUiHOGtDHQTXHVHPDQL¿HVWHHO+LMRGHOKRPEUH(Q DTXHOGtDHOTXHHVWpHQODD]RWHD\WHQJDVXVFRVDVGHQWUR GHODFDVDTXHQREDMHDEXVFDUODV$VtPLVPRHOTXHHVWp HQHOFDPSRTXHQRUHJUHVHSRUORTXHKD\DGHMDGRDWUiV £$FXpUGHQVHGHODHVSRVDGH/RW(OTXHSURFXUHFRQVHUYDU VXYLGDODSHUGHUi\HOTXHODSLHUGDODFRQVHUYDUi/HVGLJR TXHHQDTXHOODQRFKHHVWDUiQGRVSHUVRQDVHQXQDPLVPD FDPDXQDVHUiOOHYDGD\ODRWUDVHUiGHMDGD'RVPXMHUHV HVWDUiQPROLHQGRMXQWDVXQDVHUiOOHYDGD\ODRWUDVHUi GHMDGD²¢'yQGH6HxRU"²SUHJXQWDURQ ¢4XpSDVDFRQHOTXHSURFXUDFRQVHUYDUVXYLGD"BBBBBBBB BBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBB 'tD ]fTRd /XFDV -HV~VOHVFRQWyDVXVGLVFtSXORVXQDSDUiERODSDUD PRVWUDUOHVTXHGHEtDQRUDUVLHPSUHVLQGHVDQLPDUVH/HV GLMR©+DEtDHQFLHUWRSXHEORXQMXH]TXHQRWHQtDWHPRU 'tD /XFDV 7DPELpQOHOOHYDEDQQLxRVSHTXHxRVD-HV~VSDUDTXHORV WRFDUD$OYHUHVWRORVGLVFtSXORVUHSUHQGtDQDTXLHQHVORV OOHYDEDQ3HUR-HV~VOODPyDORVQLxRV\GLMR©'HMHQTXH ORVQLxRVYHQJDQDPt\QRVHORLPSLGDQSRUTXHHOUHLQR GH'LRVHVGHTXLHQHVVRQFRPRHOORV/HVDVHJXURTXHHO TXHQRUHFLEDHOUHLQRGH'LRVFRPRXQQLxRGHQLQJXQD PDQHUDHQWUDUiHQpOª&LHUWRGLULJHQWHOHSUHJXQWy ²0DHVWUREXHQR¢TXpWHQJRTXHKDFHUSDUDKHUHGDUOD YLGDHWHUQD"²¢3RUTXpPHOODPDVEXHQR"²UHVSRQGLy -HV~V²1DGLHHVEXHQRVLQRVROR'LRV<DVDEHVORV PDQGDPLHQWRV³1RFRPHWDVDGXOWHULRQRPDWHVQRUREHV QRSUHVHQWHVIDOVRWHVWLPRQLRKRQUDDWXSDGUH\DWX PDGUH´²7RGRHVRORKHFXPSOLGRGHVGHTXHHUDMRYHQ ²GLMRHOKRPEUH$ORtUHVWR-HV~VDxDGLy²7RGDYtD WHIDOWDXQDFRVDYHQGHWRGRORTXHWLHQHV\UHSiUWHOR HQWUHORVSREUHV\WHQGUiVWHVRURHQHOFLHOR/XHJRYHQ \VtJXHPH&XDQGRHOKRPEUHR\yHVWRVHHQWULVWHFLy PXFKRSXHVHUDPX\ULFR$OYHUORWDQDÀLJLGR-HV~V FRPHQWy²£4XpGLItFLOHVSDUDORVULFRVHQWUDUHQHOUHLQR GH'LRV(QUHDOLGDGOHUHVXOWDPiVIiFLODXQFDPHOORSDVDU SRUHORMRGHXQDDJXMDTXHDXQULFRHQWUDUHQHOUHLQRGH 'LRV/RVTXHORR\HURQSUHJXQWDURQ²(QWRQFHV¢TXLpQ SRGUiVDOYDUVH"²/RTXHHVLPSRVLEOHSDUDORVKRPEUHV HVSRVLEOHSDUD'LRV²DFODUy-HV~V²0LUD²OHGLMR 3HGUR²QRVRWURVKHPRVGHMDGRWRGRORTXHWHQtDPRVSDUD VHJXLUWH²/HVDVHJXUR²UHVSRQGLy-HV~V²TXHWRGRHO TXHSRUFDXVDGHOUHLQRGH'LRVKD\DGHMDGRFDVDHVSRVD KHUPDQRVSDGUHVRKLMRVUHFLELUiPXFKRPiVHQHVWH WLHPSR\HQODHGDGYHQLGHUDODYLGDHWHUQD ¢'HTXLpQHVHOUHLQRGH'LRV"BBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBB BBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBB 'tD /XFDV (QWRQFHV-HV~VWRPyDSDUWHDORVGRFH\OHVGLMR©$KRUD YDPRVUXPERD-HUXVDOpQGRQGHVHFXPSOLUiWRGRORTXH HVFULELHURQORVSURIHWDVDFHUFDGHO+LMRGHOKRPEUH(Q HIHFWRVHUiHQWUHJDGRDORVJHQWLOHV6HEXUODUiQGHpOOR LQVXOWDUiQOHHVFXSLUiQ\GHVSXpVGHD]RWDUORORPDWDUiQ 3HURDOWHUFHUGtDUHVXFLWDUiª /RVGLVFtSXORVQRHQWHQGLHURQQDGDGHHVWR/HVHUD LQFRPSUHQVLEOHSXHVQRFDSWDEDQHOVHQWLGRGHORTXHOHV KDEODED6XFHGLyTXHDODFHUFDUVH-HV~VD-HULFyHVWDEDXQ FLHJRVHQWDGRMXQWRDOFDPLQRSLGLHQGROLPRVQD&XDQGRR\y DODPXOWLWXGTXHSDVDEDSUHJXQWyTXpDFRQWHFtD²-HV~V GH1D]DUHWHVWiSDVDQGRSRUDTXt²OHUHVSRQGLHURQ ²£-HV~V+LMRGH'DYLGWHQFRPSDVLyQGHPt²JULWyHO FLHJR/RVTXHLEDQGHODQWHORUHSUHQGtDQSDUDTXHVH FDOODUDSHURpOVHSXVRDJULWDUD~QPiVIXHUWH²£+LMR GH'DYLGWHQFRPSDVLyQGHPt-HV~VVHGHWXYR\PDQGy TXHVHORWUDMHUDQ&XDQGRHOFLHJRVHDFHUFyOHSUHJXQWy -HV~V²¢4XpTXLHUHVTXHKDJDSRUWL"²6HxRUTXLHUR YHU²£5HFLEHODYLVWD²OHGLMR-HV~V²7XIHWHKDVDQDGR $OLQVWDQWHUHFREUyODYLVWD(QWRQFHVJORUL¿FDQGRD'LRV FRPHQ]yDVHJXLUD-HV~V\WRGRVORVTXHORYLHURQGDEDQ DODEDQ]DD'LRV ¢4XpSDVDEDFRQORVGLVFtSXORVFXDQGR-HV~VOHVKDEODED GHWRGRORTXHLEDDSDGHFHU"BBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBB BBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBB 'tD ]fTRd /XFDV -HV~VOOHJyD-HULFy\FRPHQ]yDFUX]DUODFLXGDG5HVXOWD TXHKDEtDDOOtXQKRPEUHOODPDGR=DTXHRMHIHGHORV UHFDXGDGRUHVGHLPSXHVWRVTXHHUDPX\ULFR(VWDED WUDWDQGRGHYHUTXLpQHUD-HV~VSHURODPXOWLWXGVHOR LPSHGtDSXHVHUDGHEDMDHVWDWXUD3RUHVRVHDGHODQWy FRUULHQGR\VHVXELyDXQiUEROSDUDSRGHUYHUOR\DTXH -HV~VLEDDSDVDUSRUDOOt /OHJDQGRDOOXJDU-HV~VPLUyKDFLDDUULED\OHGLMR² =DTXHREDMDHQVHJXLGD7HQJRTXHTXHGDUPHKR\HQWX FDVD$VtTXHVHDSUHVXUyDEDMDU\PX\FRQWHQWRUHFLELyD -HV~VHQVXFDVD$OYHUHVWRWRGRVHPSH]DURQDPXUPXUDU ©+DLGRDKRVSHGDUVHFRQXQSHFDGRUª3HUR=DTXHRGLMR UHVXHOWDPHQWH²0LUD6HxRU$KRUDPLVPRYR\DGDUDORV SREUHVODPLWDGGHPLVELHQHV\VLHQDOJRKHGHIUDXGDGR DDOJXLHQOHGHYROYHUpFXDWURYHFHVODFDQWLGDGTXHVHD ²+R\KDOOHJDGRODVDOYDFLyQDHVWDFDVD²OHGLMR-HV~V² \DTXHpVWHWDPELpQHVKLMRGH$EUDKDP3RUTXHHO+LMRGHO KRPEUHYLQRDEXVFDU\DVDOYDUORTXHVHKDEtDSHUGLGR ¢&XiOIXHODUHFRPSHQVDSDUD=DTXHRSRUKDEHUVH HVIRU]DGRSDUDHQFRQWUDUVHFRQ-HV~V"BBBBBBBBBBBBBBBB BBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBB 'tD /XFDV &RPRODJHQWHORHVFXFKDEDSDVyDFRQWDUOHVXQD SDUiERODSRUTXHHVWDEDFHUFDGH-HUXVDOpQ\ODJHQWH SHQVDEDTXHHOUHLQRGH'LRVLEDDPDQLIHVWDUVHHQ FXDOTXLHUPRPHQWR$VtTXHOHVGLMRhQKRPEUHGHOD QREOH]DVHIXHDXQSDtVOHMDQRSDUDVHUFRURQDGRUH\\ OXHJRUHJUHVDU/ODPyDGLH]GHVXVVLHUYRV\HQWUHJyD FDGDFXDOXQDEXHQDFDQWLGDGGHGLQHUR/HVLQVWUX\y ³+DJDQQHJRFLRFRQHVWHGLQHURKDVWDTXH\RYXHOYD´3HUR VXVV~EGLWRVORRGLDEDQ\PDQGDURQWUDVpOXQDGHOHJDFLyQ DGHFLU³1RTXHUHPRVDpVWHSRUUH\´ª$SHVDUGHWRGR IXHQRPEUDGRUH\&XDQGRUHJUHVyDVXSDtVPDQGyOODPDU DORVVLHUYRVDTXLHQHVKDEtDHQWUHJDGRHOGLQHURSDUD HQWHUDUVHGHORTXHKDEtDQJDQDGR6HSUHVHQWyHOSULPHUR \GLMR³6HxRUVXGLQHURKDSURGXFLGRGLH]YHFHVPiV´ ³£+LFLVWHELHQVLHUYREXHQR²OHUHVSRQGLyHOUH\²3XHVWR TXHKDVVLGR¿HOHQWDQSRFDFRVDWHGR\HOJRELHUQRGH GLH]FLXGDGHV´6HSUHVHQWyHOVHJXQGR\GLMR³6HxRUVX GLQHURKDSURGXFLGRFLQFRYHFHVPiV´(OUH\OHUHVSRQGLy ³$WLWHSRQJRVREUHFLQFRFLXGDGHV´ ¢4XpKL]RHOUH\FRQDTXHOORVTXHKLFLHURQSURGXFLUVX GLQHUR"BBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBB BBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBB 'tD /XFDV ª/OHJyRWURVLHUYR\GLMR³6HxRUDTXtWLHQHVXGLQHURORKH WHQLGRJXDUGDGRHQYXHOWRHQXQSDxXHOR(VTXHOHWHQtD PLHGRDXVWHGTXHHVXQKRPEUHPX\H[LJHQWHWRPDOR TXHQRGHSRVLWy\FRVHFKDORTXHQRVHPEUy´(OUH\OH FRQWHVWy³6LHUYRPDORFRQWXVSURSLDVSDODEUDVWHYR\D MX]JDU¢$VtTXHVDEtDVTXHVR\PX\H[LJHQWHTXHWRPROR TXHQRGHSRVLWp\FRVHFKRORTXHQRVHPEUp"(QWRQFHV ¢SRUTXpQRSXVLVWHPLGLQHURHQHOEDQFRSDUDTXHDO UHJUHVDUSXGLHUDUHFODPDUORVLQWHUHVHV"´/XHJRGLMRDORV SUHVHQWHV³4XtWHQOHHOGLQHUR\GpQVHORDOTXHUHFLELyGLH] YHFHVPiV´³6HxRU²SURWHVWDURQ²£pO\DWLHQHGLH]YHFHV PiV´(OUH\FRQWHVWy³/HVDVHJXURTXHDWRGRHOTXHWLHQH VHOHGDUiPiVSHURDOTXHQRWLHQHVHOHTXLWDUiKDVWDOR TXHWLHQH3HURHQFXDQWRDHVRVHQHPLJRVPtRVTXHQR PHTXHUtDQSRUUH\WUiLJDQORVDFi\PiWHQORVGHODQWHGH Pt´ª'LFKRHVWR-HV~VVLJXLyDGHODQWHVXELHQGRKDFLD -HUXVDOpQ&XDQGRVHDFHUFyD%HWIDJXp\D%HWDQLD MXQWRDOPRQWHOODPDGRGHORV2OLYRVHQYLyDGRVGHVXV GLVFtSXORVFRQHVWHHQFDUJR©9D\DQDODDOGHDTXHHVWi HQIUHQWH\DOHQWUDUHQHOODHQFRQWUDUiQDWDGRDXQEXUULWR HQHOTXHQDGLHVHKDPRQWDGR'HViWHQOR\WUiLJDQORDFi <VLDOJXLHQOHVSUHJXQWD³¢3RUTXpORGHVDWDQ"´GtJDQOH ³(O6HxRUORQHFHVLWD´ª)XHURQ\ORHQFRQWUDURQWDOFRPR pOOHVKDEtDGLFKR ¢4XpSDVyFRQHOVLHUYRTXHQRKL]RSURGXFLUHOGLQHURGHO UH\"BBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBB BBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBB CVTTZ_ 'tD /XFDV &XDQGRHVWDEDQGHVDWDQGRHOEXUULWRORVGXHxRVOHV SUHJXQWDURQ²¢3RUTXpGHVDWDQHOEXUULWR"²(O6HxRU ORQHFHVLWD²FRQWHVWDURQ6HOROOHYDURQSXHVD-HV~V /XHJRSXVLHURQVXVPDQWRVHQFLPDGHOEXUULWR\D\XGDURQD -HV~VDPRQWDUVH$PHGLGDTXHDYDQ]DEDODJHQWHWHQGtD VXVPDQWRVVREUHHOFDPLQR$ODFHUFDUVHpODODEDMDGDGHO PRQWHGHORV2OLYRVWRGRVORVGLVFtSXORVVHHQWXVLDVPDURQ\ FRPHQ]DURQDDODEDUD'LRVSRUWDQWRVPLODJURVTXHKDEtDQ YLVWR*ULWDEDQ²£%HQGLWRHO5H\TXHYLHQHHQHOQRPEUH GHO6HxRU£3D]HQHOFLHOR\JORULDHQODVDOWXUDV$OJXQRV GHORVIDULVHRVTXHHVWDEDQHQWUHODJHQWHOHUHFODPDURQ D-HV~V²£0DHVWURUHSUHQGHDWXVGLVFtSXORV3HURpO UHVSRQGLy/HVDVHJXURTXHVLHOORVVHFDOODQJULWDUiQ ODVSLHGUDV&XDQGRVHDFHUFDEDD-HUXVDOpQ-HV~VYLR ODFLXGDG\OORUySRUHOOD'LMR²£&yPRTXLVLHUDTXHKR\ VXSLHUDVORTXHWHSXHGHWUDHUSD]3HURHVRDKRUDHVWi RFXOWRDWXVRMRV7HVREUHYHQGUiQGtDVHQTXHWXVHQHPLJRV OHYDQWDUiQXQPXUR\WHURGHDUiQ\WHHQFHUUDUiQSRUWRGRV ODGRV7HGHUULEDUiQDWL\DWXVKLMRVGHQWURGHWXVPXUDOODV 1RGHMDUiQQLXQDSLHGUDVREUHRWUDSRUTXHQRUHFRQRFLVWHHO WLHPSRHQTXH'LRVYLQRDVDOYDUWH ¢4XpLEDDSDVDUFRQ-HUXVDOpQSRUQRKDEHUFRQRFLGRHO WLHPSRHQTXH'LRVKDEtDYHQLGR"BBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBB BBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBB 'tD /XFDV /XHJRHQWUyHQHOWHPSOR\FRPHQ]yDHFKDUGHDOOtDORV TXHHVWDEDQYHQGLHQGR©(VFULWRHVWi²OHVGLMR²³0LFDVD VHUiFDVDGHRUDFLyQ´SHURXVWHGHVODKDQFRQYHUWLGRHQ ³FXHYDGHODGURQHV´ª7RGRVORVGtDVHQVHxDEDHQHOWHPSOR \ORVMHIHVGHORVVDFHUGRWHVORVPDHVWURVGHODOH\\ORV GLULJHQWHVGHOSXHEORSURFXUDEDQPDWDUOR6LQHPEDUJRQR HQFRQWUDEDQODPDQHUDGHKDFHUORSRUTXHWRGRHOSXHEOROR HVFXFKDEDFRQJUDQLQWHUpV ]fTRd 8QGtDPLHQWUDV-HV~VHQVHxDEDDOSXHEORHQHOWHPSOR\ OHVSUHGLFDEDHOHYDQJHOLRVHOHDFHUFDURQORVMHIHVGHORV VDFHUGRWHV\ORVPDHVWURVGHODOH\MXQWRFRQORVDQFLDQRV ²'LQRVFRQTXpDXWRULGDGKDFHVHVWR²ORLQWHUURJDURQ² ¢4XLpQWHGLRHVDDXWRULGDG"²<RWDPELpQYR\DKDFHUOHV XQDSUHJXQWDDXVWHGHV²UHSOLFypO²'tJDQPH(OEDXWLVPR GH-XDQ¢SURFHGtDGHOFLHORRGHODWLHUUD"(OORVSXHVOR GLVFXWLHURQHQWUHVt©6LUHVSRQGHPRV³'HOFLHOR´QRVGLUi ³¢3RUTXpQROHFUH\HURQ"´3HURVLGHFLPRV³'HODWLHUUD´ WRGRHOSXHEORQRVDSHGUHDUiSRUTXHHVWiQFRQYHQFLGRVGH TXH-XDQHUDXQSURIHWDª$VtTXHOHUHVSRQGLHURQ²1R VDEHPRVGHGyQGHHUD²3XHV\RWDPSRFROHVYR\DGHFLU FRQTXpDXWRULGDGKDJRHVWR3DUiERODGHORVODEUDGRUHV PDOYDGRV ¢(QTXpKDEtDFRQYHUWLGRODJHQWHHOWHPSOR"BBBBBBBBBBB BBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBB 'tD /XFDV 3DVyOXHJRDFRQWDUOHDODJHQWHHVWDSDUiEROD²8Q KRPEUHSODQWyXQYLxHGRVHORDUUHQGyDXQRVODEUDGRUHV \VHIXHGHYLDMHSRUODUJRWLHPSR/OHJDGDODFRVHFKD PDQGyXQVLHUYRDORVODEUDGRUHVSDUDTXHOHGLHUDQ SDUWHGHODFRVHFKD3HURORVODEUDGRUHVORJROSHDURQ \ORGHVSLGLHURQFRQODVPDQRVYDFtDV/HVHQYLyRWUR VLHUYRSHURWDPELpQDpVWHORJROSHDURQORKXPLOODURQ\ ORGHVSLGLHURQFRQODVPDQRVYDFtDV(QWRQFHVHQYLyXQ WHUFHURSHURDXQDpVWHORKLULHURQ\ORH[SXOVDURQ ª(QWRQFHVSHQVyHOGXHxRGHOYLxHGR³¢4XpYR\DKDFHU" (QYLDUpDPLKLMRDPDGRVHJXURTXHDpOVtORUHVSHWDUiQ´ 3HURFXDQGRORYLHURQORVODEUDGRUHVWUDWDURQHODVXQWR ³eVWHHVHOKHUHGHUR²GLMHURQ²0DWpPRVOR\ODKHUHQFLD VHUiQXHVWUD´$VtTXHORDUURMDURQIXHUDGHOYLxHGR\OR PDWDURQª¢4XpOHVKDUiHOGXHxR"9ROYHUiDFDEDUiFRQ HVRVODEUDGRUHV\GDUiHOYLxHGRDRWURV$ORtUHVWROD JHQWHH[FODPy²£'LRVQRORTXLHUD0LUiQGRORV¿MDPHQWH -HV~VOHVGLMR²(QWRQFHV¢TXpVLJQL¿FDHVWRTXHHVWi HVFULWRª´/DSLHGUDTXHGHVHFKDURQORVFRQVWUXFWRUHVKD OOHJDGRDVHUODSLHGUDDQJXODU´" 7RGRHOTXHFDLJDVREUHHVDSLHGUDTXHGDUi GHVSHGD]DGR\VLHOODFDHVREUHDOJXLHQORKDUiSROYR ¢4XpKLFLHURQORVODEUDGRUHVFRQHOKLMRGHOGXHxRGHOD YLxD"BBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBB BBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBB 'tD /XFDV /RVPDHVWURVGHODOH\\ORVMHIHVGHORVVDFHUGRWHV FD\HQGRHQFXHQWDTXHODSDUiERODLEDGLULJLGDFRQWUDHOORV EXVFDURQODPDQHUDGHHFKDUOHPDQRHQDTXHOPLVPR PRPHQWR3HURWHPtDQDOSXHEOR(QWRQFHVSDUDDFHFKDUOR HQYLDURQHVStDVTXH¿QJtDQVHUJHQWHKRQRUDEOH3HQVDEDQ DWUDSDUD-HV~VHQDOJRTXHpOGLMHUD\DVtSRGHUHQWUHJDUOR DODMXULVGLFFLyQGHOJREHUQDGRU²0DHVWUR²GLMHURQORV HVStDV²VDEHPRVTXHORTXHGLFHV\HQVHxDVHVFRUUHFWR 1RMX]JDVSRUODVDSDULHQFLDVVLQRTXHGHYHUGDGHQVHxDV HOFDPLQRGH'LRV¢1RVHVWiSHUPLWLGRSDJDULPSXHVWRV DOFpVDURQR"3HUR-HV~VGiQGRVHFXHQWDGHVXVPDODV LQWHQFLRQHVUHSOLFy²0XpVWUHQPHXQDPRQHGDURPDQD ¢'HTXLpQVRQHVWDLPDJHQ\HVWDLQVFULSFLyQ"²'HOFpVDU ²FRQWHVWDURQ²(QWRQFHVGHQOHDOFpVDUORTXHHVGHO FpVDU\D'LRVORTXHHVGH'LRV1RSXGLHURQDWUDSDUOR HQORTXHGHFtDHQS~EOLFR$VtTXHDGPLUDGRVGHVX UHVSXHVWDVHFDOODURQ/XHJRDOJXQRVGHORVVDGXFHRV TXHGHFtDQTXHQRKD\UHVXUUHFFLyQVHDFHUFDURQD -HV~V\OHSODQWHDURQXQSUREOHPD²0DHVWUR0RLVpV QRVHQVHxyHQVXVHVFULWRVTXHVLXQKRPEUHPXHUH\ GHMDDODYLXGDVLQKLMRVHOKHUPDQRGHHVHKRPEUHWLHQH TXHFDVDUVHFRQODYLXGDSDUDTXHVXKHUPDQRWHQJD GHVFHQGHQFLD3XHVELHQKDEtDVLHWHKHUPDQRV(OSULPHUR VHFDVy\PXULyVLQGHMDUKLMRV(QWRQFHVHOVHJXQGR\HO WHUFHURVHFDVDURQFRQHOOD\DVtVXFHVLYDPHQWHPXULHURQ ORVVLHWHVLQGHMDUKLMRV3RU~OWLPRPXULyWDPELpQODPXMHU ¢&yPRVHTXHGDEDQORVVDFHUGRWHVTXHYHQtDQDWHQWDUD -HV~VFXDQGReVWHOHVUHVSRQGtD"BBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBB BBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBB 'tD /XFDV $KRUDELHQHQODUHVXUUHFFLyQ¢GHFXiOVHUiHVSRVDHVWD PXMHU\DTXHORVVLHWHHVWXYLHURQFDVDGRVFRQHOOD" ²/DJHQWHGHHVWHPXQGRVHFDVD\VHGDHQFDVDPLHQWR² OHVFRQWHVWy-HV~V²3HURHQFXDQWRDORVTXHVHDQGLJQRV GHWRPDUSDUWHHQHOPXQGRYHQLGHURSRUODUHVXUUHFFLyQ pVRVQRVHFDVDUiQQLVHUiQGDGRVHQFDVDPLHQWRQL WDPSRFRSRGUiQPRULUSXHVVHUiQFRPRORViQJHOHV6RQ KLMRVGH'LRVSRUTXHWRPDQSDUWHHQODUHVXUUHFFLyQ3HUR TXHORVPXHUWRVUHVXFLWDQORGLRDHQWHQGHU0RLVpVPLVPR HQHOSDVDMHVREUHOD]DU]DSXHVOODPDDO6HxRU³HO'LRVGH $EUDKDPGH,VDDF\GH-DFRE´eOQRHV'LRVGHPXHUWRV VLQRGHYLYRVHQHIHFWRSDUDpOWRGRVHOORVYLYHQ$OJXQRV GHORVPDHVWURVGHODOH\OHUHVSRQGLHURQ²£%LHQGLFKR 0DHVWUR<\DQRVHDWUHYLHURQDKDFHUOHPiVSUHJXQWDV 3HUR-HV~VOHVSUHJXQWy²¢&yPRHVTXHGLFHQTXHHO &ULVWRHVKLMRGH'DYLG"'DYLGPLVPRGHFODUDHQHOOLEURGH ORV6DOPRVª´'LMRHO6HxRUDPL6HxRU µ6LpQWDWHDPLGHUHFKDKDVWDTXHSRQJDDWXVHQHPLJRV SRUHVWUDGRGHWXVSLHV¶³'DYLGOROODPD³6HxRU´¢&yPR SXHGHHQWRQFHVVHUVXKLMR" DVXVWHQ(VQHFHVDULRTXHHVRVXFHGDSULPHURSHURHO ¿QQRYHQGUiHQVHJXLGDª6HOHYDQWDUiQDFLyQFRQWUD QDFLyQ\UHLQRFRQWUDUHLQR²FRQWLQXy²+DEUiJUDQGHV WHUUHPRWRVKDPEUH\HSLGHPLDVSRUWRGDVSDUWHVFRVDV HVSDQWRVDV\JUDQGHVVHxDOHVGHOFLHORª3HURDQWHVGH WRGRHVWRHFKDUiQPDQRGHXVWHGHV\ORVSHUVHJXLUiQ/RV HQWUHJDUiQDODVVLQDJRJDV\DODVFiUFHOHV\SRUFDXVD GHPLQRPEUHORVOOHYDUiQDQWHUH\HV\JREHUQDGRUHV $VtWHQGUiQXVWHGHVODRSRUWXQLGDGGHGDUWHVWLPRQLR DQWHHOORV3HURWHQJDQHQFXHQWDTXHQRKD\SRUTXp SUHSDUDUXQDGHIHQVDGHDQWHPDQRSXHV\RPLVPROHV GDUpWDOHORFXHQFLD\VDELGXUtDSDUDUHVSRQGHUTXHQLQJ~Q DGYHUVDULRSRGUiUHVLVWLUOHVQLFRQWUDGHFLUOHV8VWHGHVVHUiQ WUDLFLRQDGRVDXQSRUVXVSDGUHVKHUPDQRVSDULHQWHV\ DPLJRV\DDOJXQRVGHXVWHGHVVHOHVGDUiPXHUWH7RGR HOPXQGRORVRGLDUiSRUFDXVDGHPLQRPEUH3HURQRVH SHUGHUiQLXQVRORFDEHOORGHVXFDEH]D6LVHPDQWLHQHQ ¿UPHVVHVDOYDUiQ ¢4XLpQHVVRQORVTXHVHVDOYDUiQ"BBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBB BBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBB 6HJ~Q-HV~VQXHVWUR'LRVHV'LRVGH«BBBBBBBBBBBBBBBB BBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBB 'tD /XFDV ª$KRUDELHQFXDQGRYHDQD-HUXVDOpQURGHDGDGH HMpUFLWRVVHSDQTXHVXGHVRODFLyQ\DHVWiFHUFD(QWRQFHV ORVTXHHVWpQHQ-XGHDKX\DQDODVPRQWDxDVORVTXH 'tD HVWpQHQODFLXGDGVDOJDQGHHOOD\ORVTXHHVWpQHQHO /XFDV FDPSRQRHQWUHQHQODFLXGDGeVHVHUiHOWLHPSRGHOMXLFLR 0LHQWUDVWRGRHOSXHEORORHVFXFKDED-HV~VOHVGLMRDVXV FXDQGRVHFXPSOLUiWRGRORTXHHVWiHVFULWR£$\GHODV GLVFtSXORV²&XtGHQVHGHORVPDHVWURVGHODOH\/HVJXVWD TXHHVWpQHPEDUD]DGDVRDPDPDQWDQGRHQDTXHOORVGtDV SDVHDUVHFRQURSDVRVWHQWRVDV\OHVHQFDQWDTXHORVVDOXGHQ 3RUTXHKDEUiJUDQDÀLFFLyQHQODWLHUUD\FDVWLJRFRQWUD HQODVSOD]DV\RFXSDUHOSULPHUSXHVWRHQODVVLQDJRJDV HVWHSXHEOR&DHUiQD¿ORGHHVSDGD\ORVOOHYDUiQFDXWLYRV \ORVOXJDUHVGHKRQRUHQORVEDQTXHWHV'HYRUDQORV DWRGDVODVQDFLRQHV/RVJHQWLOHVSLVRWHDUiQD-HUXVDOpQ ELHQHVGHODVYLXGDV\DODYH]KDFHQODUJDVSOHJDULDVSDUD KDVWDTXHVHFXPSODQORVWLHPSRVVHxDODGRVSDUDHOORV LPSUHVLRQDUDORVGHPiVeVWRVUHFLELUiQSHRUFDVWLJR ª+DEUiVHxDOHVHQHOVROODOXQD\ODVHVWUHOODV(QOD ]fTRd WLHUUDODVQDFLRQHVHVWDUiQDQJXVWLDGDV\SHUSOHMDVSRUHO -HV~VVHGHWXYRDREVHUYDU\YLRDORVULFRVTXHHFKDEDQ EUDPLGR\ODDJLWDFLyQGHOPDU6HGHVPD\DUiQGHWHUURUORV VXVRIUHQGDVHQODVDOFDQFtDVGHOWHPSOR7DPELpQYLRD KRPEUHVWHPHURVRVSRUORTXHYDDVXFHGHUOHDOPXQGR XQDYLXGDSREUHTXHHFKDEDGRVPRQHGLWDVGHFREUH²/HV SRUTXHORVFXHUSRVFHOHVWHVVHUiQVDFXGLGRV(QWRQFHV DVHJXUR²GLMR²TXHHVWDYLXGDSREUHKDHFKDGRPiVTXH YHUiQDO+LMRGHOKRPEUHYHQLUHQXQDQXEHFRQSRGHU\ WRGRVORVGHPiV7RGRVHOORVGLHURQVXVRIUHQGDVGHORTXH JUDQJORULD&XDQGRFRPLHQFHQDVXFHGHUHVWDVFRVDV OHVVREUDEDSHURHOODGHVXSREUH]DHFKyWRGRORTXHWHQtD FREUHQiQLPR\OHYDQWHQODFDEH]DSRUTXHVHDFHUFDVX SDUDVXVXVWHQWR$OJXQRVGHVXVGLVFtSXORVFRPHQWDEDQ UHGHQFLyQ DFHUFDGHOWHPSORGHFyPRHVWDEDDGRUQDGRFRQKHUPRVDV SLHGUDV\FRQRIUHQGDVGHGLFDGDVD'LRV3HUR-HV~VGLMR ¢3RUTXpGHEHPRVOHYDQWDUQXHVWUDVFDEH]DV\FREUDU ²(QFXDQWRDWRGRHVWRTXHYHQXVWHGHVOOHJDUiHOGtDHQ iQLPR"BBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBB TXHQRTXHGDUiSLHGUDVREUHSLHGUDWRGRVHUiGHUULEDGR BBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBB ²0DHVWUR²OHSUHJXQWDURQ²¢FXiQGRVXFHGHUiHVR\FXiO VHUiODVHxDOGHTXHHVWiDSXQWRGHVXFHGHU"²7HQJDQ 'tD FXLGDGRQRVHGHMHQHQJDxDU²OHVDGYLUWLy-HV~V² /XFDV 9HQGUiQPXFKRVTXHXVDQGRPLQRPEUHGLUiQ³<RVR\´\ -HV~VWDPELpQOHVSURSXVRHVWDFRPSDUDFLyQ²)tMHQVH ³(OWLHPSRHVWiFHUFD´1RORVVLJDQXVWHGHV HQODKLJXHUD\HQORVGHPiViUEROHV&XDQGREURWDQODV CVTTZ_ ¢$TXLpQGLMR-HV~VTXHQRVLJXLpUDPRV"BBBBBBBBBBBBBBB BBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBB BBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBB 'tD /XFDV &XDQGRVHSDQGHJXHUUDV\GHUHYROXFLRQHVQRVH KRMDVXVWHGHVSXHGHQYHUSRUVtPLVPRV\VDEHUTXHHO YHUDQRHVWiFHUFD,JXDOPHQWHFXDQGRYHDQTXHVXFHGHQ HVWDVFRVDVVHSDQTXHHOUHLQRGH'LRVHVWiFHUFDª/HV DVHJXURTXHQRSDVDUiHVWDJHQHUDFLyQKDVWDTXHWRGDV HVWDVFRVDVVXFHGDQ(OFLHOR\ODWLHUUDSDVDUiQSHURPLV SDODEUDVMDPiVSDVDUiQª7HQJDQFXLGDGRQRVHDTXHVH OHVHQGXUH]FDHOFRUD]yQSRUHOYLFLRODHPEULDJXH]\ODV SUHRFXSDFLRQHVGHHVWDYLGD'HRWUDPDQHUDDTXHOGtD FDHUiGHLPSURYLVRVREUHXVWHGHVSXHVYHQGUiFRPRXQD WUDPSDVREUHWRGRVORVKDELWDQWHVGHODWLHUUD(VWpQVLHPSUH YLJLODQWHV\RUHQSDUDTXHSXHGDQHVFDSDUGHWRGRORTXH HVWiSRUVXFHGHU\SUHVHQWDUVHGHODQWHGHO+LMRGHOKRPEUH 'HGtD-HV~VHQVHxDEDHQHOWHPSORSHURVDOtDDSDVDUOD QRFKHHQHOPRQWHOODPDGRGHORV2OLYRV\WRGDODJHQWH PDGUXJDEDSDUDLUDOWHPSORDRtUOR ¢3RUTXpQHFHVLWDPRVHVWDUYLJLODQGR\RUDQGR"BBBBBBBBBB BBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBB 'tD ]fTRd /XFDV 6HDSUR[LPDEDOD¿HVWDGHORV3DQHVVLQOHYDGXUDOODPDGD OD3DVFXD/RVMHIHVGHORVVDFHUGRWHV\ORVPDHVWURVGH ODOH\EXVFDEDQDOJ~QPRGRGHDFDEDUFRQ-HV~VSRUTXH WHPtDQDOSXHEOR(QWRQFHVHQWUy6DWDQiVHQ-XGDVXQR GHORVGRFHDOTXHOODPDEDQ,VFDULRWHeVWHIXHDORVMHIHV GHORVVDFHUGRWHV\DORVFDSLWDQHVGHOWHPSORSDUDWUDWDU FRQHOORVFyPROHVHQWUHJDUtDD-HV~V(OORVVHDOHJUDURQ\ DFRUGDURQGDUOHGLQHUReODFHSWy\FRPHQ]yDEXVFDUXQD RSRUWXQLGDGSDUDHQWUHJDUOHVD-HV~VFXDQGRQRKXELHUD JHQWH&XDQGROOHJyHOGtDGHOD¿HVWDGHORV3DQHVVLQ OHYDGXUDHQTXHGHEtDVDFUL¿FDUVHHOFRUGHURGHOD3DVFXD -HV~VHQYLyD3HGUR\D-XDQGLFLpQGROHV²9D\DQDKDFHU ORVSUHSDUDWLYRVSDUDTXHFRPDPRVOD3DVFXD²¢'yQGH TXLHUHVTXHODSUHSDUHPRV"²OHSUHJXQWDURQ²0LUHQ ²FRQWHVWypO²DOHQWUDUXVWHGHVHQODFLXGDGOHVVDOGUiDO HQFXHQWURXQKRPEUHTXHOOHYDXQFiQWDURGHDJXD6tJDQOR KDVWDODFDVDHQTXHHQWUH\GtJDQOHDOGXHxRGHODFDVD ³(O0DHVWURSUHJXQWD¢'yQGHHVWiODVDODHQODTXHYR\D FRPHUOD3DVFXDFRQPLVGLVFtSXORV"´eOOHVPRVWUDUiHQOD SODQWDDOWDXQDVDODDPSOLD\DPXHEODGD3UHSDUHQDOOtOD FHQD(OORVVHIXHURQ\HQFRQWUDURQWRGRWDOFRPROHVKDEtD GLFKR-HV~V$VtTXHSUHSDUDURQOD3DVFXD XQRVDRWURVTXLpQGHHOORVKDUtDHVWR7XYLHURQDGHPiV XQDOWHUFDGRVREUHFXiOGHHOORVVHUtDHOPiVLPSRUWDQWH -HV~VOHVGLMR²/RVUH\HVGHODVQDFLRQHVRSULPHQDVXV V~EGLWRV\ORVTXHHMHUFHQDXWRULGDGVREUHHOORVVHOODPDQ DVtPLVPRVEHQHIDFWRUHV1RVHDDVtHQWUHXVWHGHV$O FRQWUDULRHOPD\RUGHEHFRPSRUWDUVHFRPRHOPHQRU\ HOTXHPDQGDFRPRHOTXHVLUYH3RUTXH¢TXLpQHVPiV LPSRUWDQWHHOTXHHVWiDODPHVDRHOTXHVLUYH"¢1RORHV HOTXHHVWiVHQWDGRDODPHVD"6LQHPEDUJR\RHVWR\HQWUH XVWHGHVFRPRXQRTXHVLUYH ¢&XiOHUDOD¿HVWDTXHHVWDEDSRUFHOHEUDUVH"BBBBBBBBBBB BBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBB BBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBB &yPRGHEHPRVFRPSRUWDUQRVVHJ~Q-HV~V"BBBBBBBBBB BBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBB BBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBB BBBBBB 'tD /XFDV $KRUDELHQXVWHGHVVRQORVTXHKDQHVWDGRVLHPSUHD PLODGRHQPLVSUXHEDV3RUHVR\RPLVPROHVFRQFHGR XQUHLQRDVtFRPRPL3DGUHPHORFRQFHGLyDPtSDUD TXHFRPDQ\EHEDQDPLPHVDHQPLUHLQR\VHVLHQWHQ HQWURQRVSDUDMX]JDUDODVGRFHWULEXVGH,VUDHOª6LPyQ 6LPyQPLUDTXH6DWDQiVKDSHGLGR]DUDQGHDUORVDXVWHGHV FRPRVLIXHUDQWULJR3HUR\RKHRUDGRSRUWLSDUDTXHQR IDOOHWXIH<W~FXDQGRWHKD\DVYXHOWRDPtIRUWDOHFHDWXV KHUPDQRV²6HxRU²UHVSRQGLy3HGUR²HVWR\GLVSXHVWRD LUFRQWLJRWDQWRDODFiUFHOFRPRDODPXHUWH ²3HGURWHGLJRTXHKR\PLVPRDQWHVGHTXHFDQWH HOJDOORWUHVYHFHVQHJDUiVTXHPHFRQRFHV/XHJR -HV~VGLMRDWRGRV²&XDQGRORVHQYLpDXVWHGHVVLQ PRQHGHURQLEROVDQLVDQGDOLDV¢DFDVROHVIDOWyDOJR" ²1DGD²UHVSRQGLHURQ²$KRUDHQFDPELRHOTXH WHQJDXQPRQHGHURTXHOROOHYHDVtPLVPRHOTXHWHQJD XQDEROVD<HOTXHQDGDWHQJDTXHYHQGDVXPDQWR \FRPSUHXQDHVSDGD3RUTXHOHVGLJRTXHWLHQHTXH FXPSOLUVHHQPtDTXHOORTXHHVWiHVFULWR³<IXHFRQWDGR HQWUHORVWUDQVJUHVRUHV´(QHIHFWRORTXHVHKDHVFULWR GHPtVHHVWiFXPSOLHQGR²0LUD6HxRU²OHVHxDODURQ ORVGLVFtSXORV²DTXtKD\GRVHVSDGDV²£%DVWD²OHV FRQWHVWy-HV~VRUDHQHOPRQWHGHORV2OLYRV CVTTZ_ ¢3RUTXpLEDDFDQWDUHOJDOORYHFHV"BBBBBBBBBBBBBBBB BBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBB 'tD /XFDV &XDQGROOHJyODKRUD-HV~V\VXVDSyVWROHVVHVHQWDURQD ODPHVD(QWRQFHVOHVGLMR²+HWHQLGRPXFKtVLPRVGHVHRV GHFRPHUHVWD3DVFXDFRQXVWHGHVDQWHVGHSDGHFHUSXHV OHVGLJRTXHQRYROYHUpDFRPHUODKDVWDTXHWHQJDVXSOHQR FXPSOLPLHQWRHQHOUHLQRGH'LRV/XHJRWRPyODFRSDGLR JUDFLDV\GLMR²7RPHQHVWR\UHSiUWDQORHQWUHXVWHGHV/HV GLJRTXHQRYROYHUpDEHEHUGHOIUXWRGHODYLGKDVWDTXH YHQJDHOUHLQRGH'LRV7DPELpQWRPySDQ\GHVSXpVGHGDU JUDFLDVORSDUWLyVHORGLRDHOORV\GLMR²(VWHSDQHVPL FXHUSRHQWUHJDGRSRUXVWHGHVKDJDQHVWRHQPHPRULDGH Pt'HODPLVPDPDQHUDWRPyODFRSDGHVSXpVGHODFHQD \GLMR²(VWDFRSDHVHOQXHYRSDFWRHQPLVDQJUHTXHHV GHUUDPDGDSRUXVWHGHV3HURVHSDQTXHODPDQRGHOTXHYD DWUDLFLRQDUPHHVWiFRQODPtDVREUHODPHVD$ODYHUGDG HO+LMRGHOKRPEUHVHLUiVHJ~QHVWiGHFUHWDGRSHUR£D\GH DTXHOTXHORWUDLFLRQD(QWRQFHVFRPHQ]DURQDSUHJXQWDUVH 'tD /XFDV -HV~VVDOLyGHODFLXGDG\FRPRGHFRVWXPEUHVHGLULJLy DOPRQWHGHORV2OLYRV\VXVGLVFtSXORVORVLJXLHURQ &XDQGROOHJDURQDOOXJDUOHVGLMR©2UHQSDUDTXHQR FDLJDQHQWHQWDFLyQª(QWRQFHVVHVHSDUyGHHOORVDXQD EXHQDGLVWDQFLDVHDUURGLOOy\HPSH]yDRUDU©3DGUHVL TXLHUHVQRPHKDJDVEHEHUHVWHWUDJRDPDUJRSHURQRVH FXPSODPLYROXQWDGVLQRODWX\Dª(QWRQFHVVHOHDSDUHFLy XQiQJHOGHOFLHORSDUDIRUWDOHFHUOR3HURFRPRHVWDED DQJXVWLDGRVHSXVRDRUDUFRQPiVIHUYRU\VXVXGRUHUD FRPRJRWDVGHVDQJUHTXHFDtDQDWLHUUD&XDQGRWHUPLQy GHRUDU\YROYLyDORVGLVFtSXORVORVHQFRQWUyGRUPLGRV DJRWDGRVSRUODWULVWH]D©¢3RUTXpHVWiQGXUPLHQGR" ²OHVH[KRUWy²/HYiQWHQVH\RUHQSDUDTXHQRFDLJDQ HQWHQWDFLyQª7RGDYtDHVWDEDKDEODQGR-HV~VFXDQGRVH DSDUHFLyXQDWXUED\DOIUHQWHLEDXQRGHORVGRFHHOTXH VHOODPDED-XGDVeVWHVHDFHUFyD-HV~VSDUDEHVDUOR SHUR-HV~VOHSUHJXQWy²-XGDV¢FRQXQEHVRWUDLFLRQDVDO +LMRGHOKRPEUH"/RVGLVFtSXORVTXHORURGHDEDQDOGDUVH FXHQWDGHORTXHSDVDEDGLMHURQ²6HxRU¢DWDFDPRVFRQ ODHVSDGD"<XQRGHHOORVKLULyDOVLHUYRGHOVXPRVDFHUGRWH FRUWiQGROHODRUHMDGHUHFKD²£'pMHQORV²RUGHQy-HV~V (QWRQFHVOHWRFyODRUHMDDOKRPEUH\ORVDQy/XHJRGLMRD ORVMHIHVGHORVVDFHUGRWHVDORVFDSLWDQHVGHOWHPSOR\DORV DQFLDQRVTXHKDEtDQYHQLGRDSUHQGHUOR²¢$FDVRVR\XQ EDQGLGRSDUDTXHYHQJDQFRQWUDPtFRQHVSDGDV\SDORV" 7RGRVORVGtDVHVWDEDFRQXVWHGHVHQHOWHPSOR\QRVH DWUHYLHURQDSRQHUPHODVPDQRVHQFLPD3HUR\DKDOOHJDGR ODKRUDGHXVWHGHVFXDQGRUHLQDQODVWLQLHEODV ¢3DUDTXpOHVGLMR-HV~VDVXVGLVFtSXORVTXHRUDUDQ"BBBBB BBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBB 'tD /XFDV 3UHQGLHURQHQWRQFHVD-HV~V\OROOHYDURQDODFDVDGHOVXPR VDFHUGRWH3HGURORVVHJXtDGHOHMRV3HUROXHJRFXDQGR HQFHQGLHURQXQDIRJDWDHQPHGLRGHOSDWLR\VHVHQWDURQ DOUHGHGRU3HGURVHOHVXQLy8QDFULDGDORYLRDOOtVHQWDGRD ODOXPEUHORPLUyGHWHQLGDPHQWH\GLMR²eVWHHVWDEDFRQpO 3HURpOORQHJy0XFKDFKD\RQRORFRQR]FR3RFRGHVSXpV ORYLRRWUR\D¿UPy²7~WDPELpQHUHVXQRGHHOORV£1R KRPEUHQRORVR\²FRQWHVWy3HGUR&RPRXQDKRUDPiV WDUGHRWURORDFXVy²6HJXURTXHpVWHHVWDEDFRQpOPLUHQ TXHHVJDOLOHR ²£+RPEUHQRVpGHTXpHVWiVKDEODQGR²UHSOLFy3HGUR (QHOPLVPRPRPHQWRHQTXHGLMRHVRFDQWyHOJDOOR(O 6HxRUVHYROYLy\PLUyGLUHFWDPHQWHD3HGUR(QWRQFHV 3HGURVHDFRUGyGHORTXHHO6HxRUOHKDEtDGLFKR©+R\ PLVPRDQWHVGHTXHHOJDOORFDQWHPHQHJDUiVWUHVYHFHV ª<VDOLHQGRGHDOOtOORUyDPDUJDPHQWH/RVKRPEUHVTXH YLJLODEDQD-HV~VFRPHQ]DURQDEXUODUVHGHpO\DJROSHDUOR /HYHQGDURQORVRMRV\OHLQFUHSDEDQ²£$GLYLQDTXLpQWH SHJy<OHODQ]DEDQPXFKRVRWURVLQVXOWRV ¢&XiOIXHODUHDFFLyQGH3HGURDOGDUVHFXHQWDGHTXHKDEtD QHJDGRD-HV~V"BBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBB BBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBB 'tD /XFDV $ODPDQHFHUVHUHXQLHURQORVDQFLDQRVGHOSXHEORWDQWR ORVMHIHVGHORVVDFHUGRWHVFRPRORVPDHVWURVGHODOH\H KLFLHURQFRPSDUHFHUD-HV~VDQWHHO&RQVHMR²6LHUHVHO &ULVWRGtQRVOR²OHH[LJLHURQ-HV~VOHVFRQWHVWy²6LVHOR GLMHUDDXVWHGHVQRPHORFUHHUtDQ\VLOHVKLFLHUDSUHJXQWDV QRPHFRQWHVWDUtDQ3HURGHDKRUDHQDGHODQWHHO+LMRGHO KRPEUHHVWDUiVHQWDGRDODGHUHFKDGHO'LRV7RGRSRGHURVR ²¢(UHVW~HQWRQFHVHO+LMRGH'LRV"²OHSUHJXQWDURQD XQDYR]²8VWHGHVPLVPRVORGLFHQ ²¢3DUDTXpQHFHVLWDPRVPiVWHVWLPRQLRV"²UHVROYLHURQ² $FDEDPRVGHRtUORGHVXVSURSLRVODELRV CfTRd $VtTXHODDVDPEOHDHQSOHQRVHOHYDQWy\OROOHYDURQD 3LODWR<FRPHQ]DURQODDFXVDFLyQFRQHVWDVSDODEUDV ²+HPRVGHVFXELHUWRDHVWHKRPEUHDJLWDQGRDQXHVWUD QDFLyQ6HRSRQHDOSDJRGHLPSXHVWRVDOHPSHUDGRU\ D¿UPDTXHpOHVHO&ULVWRXQUH\$VtTXH3LODWROHSUHJXQWy D-HV~V²¢(UHVW~HOUH\GHORVMXGtRV"²7~PLVPROR GLFHV²UHVSRQGLy(QWRQFHV3LODWRGHFODUyDORVMHIHVGH ORVVDFHUGRWHV\DODPXOWLWXG²1RHQFXHQWURTXHHVWH KRPEUHVHDFXOSDEOHGHQDGD3HURHOORVLQVLVWtDQ²&RQ VXVHQVHxDQ]DVDJLWDDOSXHEORSRUWRGD-XGHD&RPHQ]y HQ*DOLOHD\KDOOHJDGRKDVWDDTXt ¢4XpIXHORTXHGLMR3LODWRGHVSXpVGHKDEODUFRQ-HV~V" BBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBB BBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBB CVTTZ_ 'tD /XFDV $ORtUHVWR3LODWRSUHJXQWyVLHOKRPEUHHUDJDOLOHR &XDQGRVHHQWHUyGHTXHSHUWHQHFtDDODMXULVGLFFLyQ GH+HURGHVVHORPDQGyDpO\DTXHHQDTXHOORVGtDV WDPELpQ+HURGHVHVWDEDHQ-HUXVDOpQ$OYHUD-HV~V +HURGHVVHSXVRPX\FRQWHQWRKDFtDWLHPSRTXHTXHUtD YHUORSRUORTXHRtDDFHUFDGHpO\HVSHUDEDSUHVHQFLDU DOJ~QPLODJURTXHKLFLHUD-HV~V/RDFRVyFRQPXFKDV SUHJXQWDVSHUR-HV~VQROHFRQWHVWDEDQDGD$OOtHVWDEDQ WDPELpQORVMHIHVGHORVVDFHUGRWHV\ORVPDHVWURVGHOD OH\DFXViQGRORFRQYHKHPHQFLD(QWRQFHV+HURGHV\VXV VROGDGRVFRQGHVSUHFLR\EXUODVOHSXVLHURQXQPDQWR OXMRVR\ORPDQGDURQGHYXHOWDD3LODWR$QWHULRUPHQWH +HURGHV\3LODWRQRVHOOHYDEDQELHQSHURHVHPLVPRGtD VHKLFLHURQDPLJRV3LODWRHQWRQFHVUHXQLyDORVMHIHVGH ORVVDFHUGRWHVDORVJREHUQDQWHV\DOSXHEOR\OHVGLMR² 8VWHGHVPHWUDMHURQDHVWHKRPEUHDFXVDGRGHIRPHQWDUOD UHEHOLyQHQWUHHOSXHEORSHURUHVXOWDTXHORKHLQWHUURJDGR GHODQWHGHXVWHGHVVLQHQFRQWUDUTXHVHDFXOSDEOHGHOR TXHXVWHGHVORDFXVDQ<HVFODURTXHWDPSRFR+HURGHV ORKDMX]JDGRFXOSDEOHSXHVWRTXHQRVORGHYROYLy&RPR SXHGHQYHUQRKDFRPHWLGRQLQJ~QGHOLWRTXHPHUH]FDOD PXHUWHDVtTXHOHGDUpXQDSDOL]D\GHVSXpVORVROWDUp 3HURWRGRVJULWDURQDXQDYR]²£/OpYDWHDpVH£6XpOWDQRV D%DUUDEiV$%DUUDEiVORKDEtDQPHWLGRHQODFiUFHOSRU XQDLQVXUUHFFLyQHQODFLXGDG\SRUKRPLFLGLR ¢$TXLpQSLGLyODJHQWHTXHVROWDUDQHQOXJDUGH-HV~V" BBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBB 'tD /XFDV 3LODWRFRPRTXHUtDVROWDUD-HV~VDSHOyDOSXHEORRWUDYH] SHURHOORVVHSXVLHURQDJULWDU²£&UXFLItFDOR£&UXFLItFDOR 3RUWHUFHUDYH]OHVKDEOy²3HUR¢TXpFULPHQKD FRPHWLGRHVWHKRPEUH"1RHQFXHQWURTXHpOVHDFXOSDEOH GHQDGDTXHPHUH]FDODSHQDGHPXHUWHDVtTXHOHGDUp XQDSDOL]D\GHVSXpVORVROWDUp3HURDYR]HQFXHOOR HOORVVLJXLHURQLQVLVWLHQGRHQTXHORFUXFL¿FDUD\FRQVXV JULWRVVHLPSXVLHURQ3RU¿Q3LODWRGHFLGLyFRQFHGHUOHV VXGHPDQGDVROWyDOKRPEUHTXHOHSHGtDQHOTXHSRU LQVXUUHFFLyQ\KRPLFLGLRKDEtDVLGRHFKDGRHQODFiUFHO\ GHMyTXHKLFLHUDQFRQ-HV~VORTXHTXLVLHUDQ&XDQGRVH OROOHYDEDQHFKDURQPDQRGHXQWDO6LPyQGH&LUHQHTXH YROYtDGHOFDPSR\OHFDUJDURQODFUX]SDUDTXHODOOHYDUD GHWUiVGH-HV~V/RVHJXtDPXFKDJHQWHGHOSXHEORLQFOXVR PXMHUHVTXHVHJROSHDEDQHOSHFKRODPHQWiQGRVHSRUpO -HV~VVHYROYLyKDFLDHOODV\OHVGLMR²+LMDVGH-HUXVDOpQ QROORUHQSRUPtOORUHQPiVELHQSRUXVWHGHV\SRUVXVKLMRV 0LUHQYDDOOHJDUHOWLHPSRHQTXHVHGLUi³£'LFKRVDVODV HVWpULOHVTXHQXQFDGLHURQDOX]QLDPDPDQWDURQ´ ¢4XpOHVGLMR-HV~VDODVPXMHUHVTXHLEDQODPHQWiQGRVH GHWUiVGHeO"BBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBB BBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBB 'tD /XFDV ª(QWRQFHV³GLUiQDODVPRQWDxDVµ£&DLJDQVREUHQRVRWURV¶ \DODVFROLQDVµ£&~EUDQQRV¶³3RUTXHVLHVWRVHKDFHFXDQGR HOiUEROHVWiYHUGH¢TXpQRVXFHGHUiFXDQGRHVWpVHFR" 7DPELpQOOHYDEDQFRQpODRWURVGRVDPERVFULPLQDOHV SDUDVHUHMHFXWDGRV&XDQGROOHJDURQDOOXJDUOODPDGROD &DODYHUDORFUXFL¿FDURQDOOtMXQWRFRQORVFULPLQDOHVXQRD VXGHUHFKD\RWURDVXL]TXLHUGD²3DGUH²GLMR-HV~V² SHUGyQDORVSRUTXHQRVDEHQORTXHKDFHQ0LHQWUDVWDQWR HFKDEDQVXHUWHVSDUDUHSDUWLUVHHQWUHVtODURSDGH-HV~V /DJHQWHSRUVXSDUWHVHTXHGyDOOtREVHUYDQGR\DXQORV JREHUQDQWHVHVWDEDQEXUOiQGRVHGHpO²6DOYyDRWURV² GHFtDQ²TXHVHVDOYHDVtPLVPRVLHVHO&ULVWRGH'LRVHO (VFRJLGR7DPELpQORVVROGDGRVVHDFHUFDURQSDUDEXUODUVH GHpO/HRIUHFLHURQYLQDJUH\OHGLMHURQ²6LHUHVHOUH\GH ORVMXGtRVViOYDWHDWLPLVPR5HVXOWDTXHKDEtDVREUHpOXQ OHWUHURTXHGHFtD©³eVWHHVHO5H\GHORVMXGtRV´ª ¢4XpGHFtDHOOHWUHURTXHSXVLHURQVREUH-HV~V" BBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBB 'tD /XFDV 8QRGHORVFULPLQDOHVDOOtFROJDGRVHPSH]yDLQVXOWDUOR ²¢1RHUHVW~HO&ULVWR"£6iOYDWHDWLPLVPR\DQRVRWURV 3HURHORWURFULPLQDOORUHSUHQGLy²¢1LVLTXLHUDWHPRUGH 'LRVWLHQHVDXQTXHVXIUHVODPLVPDFRQGHQD"(QQXHVWUR FDVRHOFDVWLJRHVMXVWRSXHVVXIULPRVORTXHPHUHFHQ QXHVWURVGHOLWRVpVWHHQFDPELRQRKDKHFKRQDGDPDOR /XHJRGLMR ²-HV~VDFXpUGDWHGHPtFXDQGRYHQJDVHQWXUHLQR ²7HDVHJXURTXHKR\HVWDUiVFRQPLJRHQHOSDUDtVR²OH FRQWHVWy-HV~V'HVGHHOPHGLRGtD\KDVWDODPHGLDWDUGH@ WRGDODWLHUUDTXHGyVXPLGDHQODRVFXULGDGSXHVHOVROVH RFXOWy<ODFRUWLQDGHOVDQWXDULRGHOWHPSORVHUDVJyHQ GRV(QWRQFHV-HV~VH[FODPyFRQIXHU]D²£3DGUHHQWXV PDQRVHQFRPLHQGRPLHVStULWX<DOGHFLUHVWRH[SLUy(O FHQWXULyQDOYHUORTXHKDEtDVXFHGLGRDODEyD'LRV\GLMR ²9HUGDGHUDPHQWHHVWHKRPEUHHUDMXVWR(QWRQFHVORVTXH VHKDEtDQUHXQLGRSDUDSUHVHQFLDUDTXHOHVSHFWiFXORDOYHU ORRFXUULGRVHIXHURQGHDOOtJROSHiQGRVHHOSHFKR3HUR WRGRVORVFRQRFLGRVGH-HV~VLQFOXVRODVPXMHUHVTXHOR KDEtDQVHJXLGRGHVGH*DOLOHDVHTXHGDURQPLUDQGRGHVGH OHMRV ¢4XpKL]RHOFHQWXULyQDOYHUWRGRORTXHKDEtDVXFHGLGR" BBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBB 'tD /XFDV +DEtDXQKRPEUHEXHQR\MXVWROODPDGR-RVpPLHPEURGHO &RQVHMRTXHQRKDEtDHVWDGRGHDFXHUGRFRQODGHFLVLyQQL FRQODFRQGXFWDGHHOORV(UDQDWXUDOGHXQSXHEORGH-XGHD OODPDGR$ULPDWHD\HVSHUDEDHOUHLQRGH'LRVeVWHVH SUHVHQWyDQWH3LODWR\OHSLGLyHOFXHUSRGH-HV~V'HVSXpV GHEDMDUORORHQYROYLyHQXQDViEDQDGHOLQR\ORSXVRHQ XQVHSXOFURFDYDGRHQODURFDHQHOTXHWRGDYtDQRVH KDEtDVHSXOWDGRDQDGLH(UDHOGtDGHSUHSDUDFLyQSDUD HOViEDGRTXHHVWDEDDSXQWRGHFRPHQ]DU/DVPXMHUHV TXHKDEtDQDFRPSDxDGRD-HV~VGHVGH*DOLOHDVLJXLHURQ D-RVpSDUDYHUHOVHSXOFUR\FyPRFRORFDEDQHOFXHUSR /XHJRYROYLHURQDFDVD\SUHSDUDURQHVSHFLDVDURPiWLFDV \SHUIXPHV(QWRQFHVGHVFDQVDURQHOViEDGRFRQIRUPHDO PDQGDPLHQWR CfTRd (OSULPHUGtDGHODVHPDQDPX\GHPDxDQDODVPXMHUHV IXHURQDOVHSXOFUROOHYDQGRODVHVSHFLDVDURPiWLFDVTXH KDEtDQSUHSDUDGR(QFRQWUDURQTXHKDEtDVLGRTXLWDGDOD SLHGUDTXHFXEUtDHOVHSXOFUR\DOHQWUDUQRKDOODURQHO FXHUSRGHO6HxRU-HV~V ¢4XpSUHSDUDURQODVPXMHUHVSDUDXQJLUHOFXHUSRGH -HV~V"BBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBB BBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBB CVTTZ_ 'tD /XFDV 0LHQWUDVVHSUHJXQWDEDQTXpKDEUtDSDVDGRVHOH SUHVHQWDURQGRVKRPEUHVFRQURSDVUHVSODQGHFLHQWHV $VXVWDGDVVHSRVWUDURQVREUHVXURVWURSHURHOORVOHV GLMHURQ²¢3RUTXpEXVFDQXVWHGHVHQWUHORVPXHUWRVDO TXHYLYH"1RHVWiDTXt£KDUHVXFLWDGR5HFXHUGHQORTXH OHVGLMRFXDQGRWRGDYtDHVWDEDFRQXVWHGHVHQ*DOLOHD ³(O+LMRGHOKRPEUHWLHQHTXHVHUHQWUHJDGRHQPDQRVGH KRPEUHVSHFDGRUHV\VHUFUXFL¿FDGRSHURDOWHUFHUGtD UHVXFLWDUi´(QWRQFHVHOODVVHDFRUGDURQGHODVSDODEUDVGH -HV~V$OUHJUHVDUGHOVHSXOFUROHVFRQWDURQWRGDVHVWDV FRVDVDORVRQFH\DWRGRVORVGHPiV/DVPXMHUHVHUDQ 0DUtD0DJGDOHQD-XDQD0DUtDODPDGUHGH-DFRER\ ODVGHPiVTXHODVDFRPSDxDEDQ3HURDORVGLVFtSXORVHO UHODWROHVSDUHFLyXQDWRQWHUtDDVtTXHQROHVFUH\HURQ 3HGURVLQHPEDUJRVDOLyFRUULHQGRDOVHSXOFUR6HDVRPy \YLRVyORODVYHQGDVGHOLQR/XHJRYROYLyDVXFDVD H[WUDxDGRGHORTXHKDEtDVXFHGLGR$TXHOPLVPRGtDGRV GHHOORVVHGLULJtDQDXQSXHEOROODPDGR(PD~VDXQRV RQFHNLOyPHWURVGH-HUXVDOpQ,EDQFRQYHUVDQGRVREUHWRGR ORTXHKDEtDDFRQWHFLGR6XFHGLyTXHPLHQWUDVKDEODEDQ \GLVFXWtDQ-HV~VPLVPRVHDFHUFy\FRPHQ]yDFDPLQDU FRQHOORVSHURQRORUHFRQRFLHURQSXHVVXVRMRVHVWDEDQ YHODGRV ¢4XpSUHJXQWDOHVKLFLHURQORViQJHOHVDODVPXMHUHV"BBBB BBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBB BBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBB 'tD /XFDV ²¢4XpYLHQHQGLVFXWLHQGRSRUHOFDPLQR"²OHVSUHJXQWy 6HGHWXYLHURQFDEL]EDMRV\XQRGHHOORVOODPDGR&OHRIDV OHGLMR²¢(UHVW~HO~QLFRSHUHJULQRHQ-HUXVDOpQTXHQR VHKDHQWHUDGRGHWRGRORTXHKDSDVDGRUHFLHQWHPHQWH" ²¢4XpHVORTXHKDSDVDGR"²OHVSUHJXQWy²/RGH -HV~VGH1D]DUHW(UDXQSURIHWDSRGHURVRHQREUDV\HQ SDODEUDVGHODQWHGH'LRV\GHWRGRHOSXHEOR/RVMHIHVGH ORVVDFHUGRWHV\QXHVWURVJREHUQDQWHVORHQWUHJDURQSDUD VHUFRQGHQDGRDPXHUWH\ORFUXFL¿FDURQSHURQRVRWURV DEULJiEDPRVODHVSHUDQ]DGHTXHHUDpOTXLHQUHGLPLUtDD ,VUDHO(VPiV\DKDFHWUHVGtDVTXHVXFHGLyWRGRHVWR 7DPELpQDOJXQDVPXMHUHVGHQXHVWURJUXSRQRVGHMDURQ DVRPEUDGRV(VWDPDxDQDPX\WHPSUDQRIXHURQDO VHSXOFURSHURQRKDOODURQVXFXHUSR&XDQGRYROYLHURQQRV FRQWDURQTXHVHOHVKDEtDQDSDUHFLGRXQRViQJHOHVTXLHQHV OHVGLMHURQTXHpOHVWiYLYR$OJXQRVGHQXHVWURVFRPSDxHURV IXHURQGHVSXpVDOVHSXOFUR\ORHQFRQWUDURQWDOFRPRKDEtDQ GLFKRODVPXMHUHVSHURDpOQRORYLHURQ²£4XpWRUSHVVRQ XVWHGHV²OHVGLMR²\TXpWDUGRVGHFRUD]yQSDUDFUHHUWRGR ORTXHKDQGLFKRORVSURIHWDV¢$FDVRQRWHQtDTXHVXIULUHO &ULVWRHVWDVFRVDVDQWHVGHHQWUDUHQVXJORULD"(QWRQFHV FRPHQ]DQGRSRU0RLVpV\SRUWRGRVORVSURIHWDVOHVH[SOLFy ORTXHVHUHIHUtDDpOHQWRGDVODV(VFULWXUDV$ODFHUFDUVH DOSXHEORDGRQGHVHGLULJtDQ-HV~VKL]RFRPRTXHLEDPiV OHMRV3HURHOORVLQVLVWLHURQ²4XpGDWHFRQQRVRWURVTXH HVWiDWDUGHFLHQGR\DHVFDVLGHQRFKH$VtTXHHQWUySDUD TXHGDUVHFRQHOORV ¢3RUTXpOHVH[SOLFy-HV~VWRGRORVTXHORVSURIHWDVGHFtDQ GHeOHQODV(VFULWXUDV"BBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBB BBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBB 'tD /XFDV /XHJRHVWDQGRFRQHOORVDODPHVDWRPyHOSDQOREHQGLMR ORSDUWLy\VHORGLR(QWRQFHVVHOHVDEULHURQORVRMRV\OR UHFRQRFLHURQSHURpOGHVDSDUHFLy6HGHFtDQHOXQRDORWUR ²¢1RDUGtDQXHVWURFRUD]yQPLHQWUDVFRQYHUVDEDFRQ QRVRWURVHQHOFDPLQR\QRVH[SOLFDEDODV(VFULWXUDV"$O LQVWDQWHVHSXVLHURQHQFDPLQR\UHJUHVDURQD-HUXVDOpQ $OOtHQFRQWUDURQDORVRQFH\DORVTXHHVWDEDQUHXQLGRVFRQ HOORV©£(VFLHUWR²GHFtDQ²(O6HxRUKDUHVXFLWDGR\VH OHKDDSDUHFLGRD6LPyQª/RVGRVSRUVXSDUWHFRQWDURQ ORTXHOHVKDEtDVXFHGLGRHQHOFDPLQR\FyPRKDEtDQ UHFRQRFLGRD-HV~VFXDQGRSDUWLyHOSDQ-HV~VVHDSDUHFH DORVGLVFtSXORV7RGDYtDHVWDEDQHOORVKDEODQGRDFHUFDGH HVWRFXDQGR-HV~VPLVPRVHSXVRHQPHGLRGHHOORV\OHV GLMR²3D]DXVWHGHV$WHUURUL]DGRVFUH\HURQTXHYHtDQD XQHVStULWX²¢3RUTXpVHDVXVWDQWDQWR"²OHVSUHJXQWy² ¢3RUTXpOHVYLHQHQGXGDV"0LUHQPLVPDQRV\PLVSLHV £6R\\RPLVPR7yTXHQPH\YHDQXQHVStULWXQRWLHQHFDUQH QLKXHVRVFRPRYHQTXHORVWHQJR\R 'LFKRHVWROHVPRVWUyODVPDQRV\ORVSLHV&RPRHOORVQR DFDEDEDQGHFUHHUORDFDXVDGHODDOHJUtD\GHODVRPEUROHV SUHJXQWy²¢7LHQHQDTXtDOJRGHFRPHU" \VHORFRPLyGHODQWHGHHOORV/XHJROHVGLMR²&XDQGR WRGDYtDHVWDED\RFRQXVWHGHVOHVGHFtDTXHWHQtDTXH FXPSOLUVHWRGRORTXHHVWiHVFULWRDFHUFDGHPtHQODOH\ GH0RLVpVHQORVSURIHWDV\HQORVVDOPRV(QWRQFHV OHVDEULyHOHQWHQGLPLHQWRSDUDTXHFRPSUHQGLHUDQODV (VFULWXUDV²(VWRHVORTXHHVWiHVFULWR²OHVH[SOLFy² TXHHO&ULVWRSDGHFHUi\UHVXFLWDUiDOWHUFHUGtD\HQVX QRPEUHVHSUHGLFDUiQHODUUHSHQWLPLHQWR\HOSHUGyQGH SHFDGRVDWRGDVODVQDFLRQHVFRPHQ]DQGRSRU-HUXVDOpQ 8VWHGHVVRQWHVWLJRVGHHVWDVFRVDV$KRUDYR\DHQYLDUOHV ORTXHKDSURPHWLGRPL3DGUHSHURXVWHGHVTXpGHQVHHQ ODFLXGDGKDVWDTXHVHDQUHYHVWLGRVGHOSRGHUGHORDOWR 'HVSXpVORVOOHYy-HV~VKDVWD%HWDQLDDOOtDO]yODVPDQRV \ORVEHQGLMR6XFHGLyTXHPLHQWUDVORVEHQGHFtDVHDOHMy GHHOORV\IXHOOHYDGRDOFLHOR(OORVHQWRQFHVORDGRUDURQ \OXHJRUHJUHVDURQD-HUXVDOpQFRQJUDQDOHJUtD<HVWDEDQ FRQWLQXDPHQWHHQHOWHPSORDODEDQGRD'LRV ¢4XpHVORTXHGHEHPRVSUHGLFDUHQHOQRPEUHGH-HV~V" BBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBB BBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBB 'LD YVTY`d +HFKRV &XDQGROOHJyHOGtDGH3HQWHFRVWpVHVWDEDQWRGRVMXQWRV HQHOPLVPROXJDU'HUHSHQWHYLQRGHOFLHORXQUXLGRFRPR HOGHXQDYLROHQWDUiIDJDGHYLHQWR\OOHQyWRGDODFDVD GRQGHHVWDEDQUHXQLGRV6HOHVDSDUHFLHURQHQWRQFHVXQDV OHQJXDVFRPRGHIXHJRTXHVHUHSDUWLHURQ\VHSRVDURQ VREUHFDGDXQRGHHOORV7RGRVIXHURQOOHQRVGHO(VStULWX 6DQWR\FRPHQ]DURQDKDEODUHQGLIHUHQWHVOHQJXDVVHJ~Q HO(VStULWXOHVFRQFHGtDH[SUHVDUVH (VWDEDQGHYLVLWDHQ-HUXVDOpQMXGtRVSLDGRVRV SURFHGHQWHVGHWRGDVODVQDFLRQHVGHODWLHUUD$ORtUDTXHO EXOOLFLRVHDJROSDURQ\TXHGDURQWRGRVSDVPDGRVSRUTXH FDGDXQRORVHVFXFKDEDKDEODUHQVXSURSLRLGLRPD 'HVFRQFHUWDGRV\PDUDYLOODGRVGHFtDQ¢1RVRQJDOLOHRV WRGRVHVWRVTXHHVWiQKDEODQGR"¢&yPRHVTXHFDGDXQR GHQRVRWURVORVR\HKDEODUHQVXOHQJXDPDWHUQD"3DUWRV PHGRV\HODPLWDVKDELWDQWHVGH0HVRSRWDPLDGH-XGHD\ GH&DSDGRFLDGHO3RQWR\GH$VLDGH)ULJLD\GH3DQ¿OLD GH(JLSWR\GHODVUHJLRQHVGH/LELDFHUFDQDVD&LUHQH YLVLWDQWHVOOHJDGRVGH5RPDMXGtRV\SURVpOLWRVFUHWHQVHV \iUDEHV£WRGRVSRULJXDOORVRtPRVSURFODPDUHQQXHVWUD SURSLDOHQJXDODVPDUDYLOODVGH'LRV 'HVFRQFHUWDGRV\SHUSOHMRVVHSUHJXQWDEDQ¢4XpTXLHUH GHFLUHVWR"2WURVVHEXUODEDQ\GHFtDQ/RTXHSDVDHVTXH HVWiQERUUDFKRV ¢'HTXpIXHURQOOHQRVORVGLVFtSXORVHQGtDGH 3HQWHFRVWpV"BBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBB BBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBB ¢4XpFUH\HURQORVGLVFtSXORVTXHYHtDQFXDQGRVHOHV DSDUHFLy-HV~V"BBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBB BBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBB 'tD /XFDV /HGLHURQXQSHGD]RGHSHVFDGRDVDGRDVtTXHORWRPy 5BCMBQFSJEJDBEFMB$MBTF "TJTUFODJB -FDUVSBEF-VDBT 7FSTPTEFNFNPSJB 5SBFS"NJHPTBMBDMBTF $VNQMJS©7BNPTB$BTBª .JOJTUFSJP1SP7JTJO (ODERUDGRSRU0LQLVWHULR3UR9LVLyQUHVHUYDPRVORVGHUHFKRV /HVGDPRVSHUPLVRGHKDFHUFRSLDVGHOPDWHULDOSDUDVXV QHFHVLGDGHVRSDUDEHQGLFLUDRWURVPLQLVWHULRVQRSDUDYHQGHU 7RGDOD(VFULWXUDWRPDGRGHOD1XHYD9HUVLyQ,QWHUQDFLRQDO 8VDGRFRQ3HUPLVR ,PSUHVRHQ+XDWDEDPSRHQODVRÀFLQDVGH0LQLVWHULR3UR9LVLyQ £*UDFLDVDOHTXLSRFUHDWLYRGHOPDWHULDO 'ZLJKW\.ULVWLQD.UDXVV*HUPiQ$OFiQWDU 5XEpQ&DQW~D\7DQL(GG\ 3DUDPiVLQIRUPDFLyQFRQWiFWDQRVD NULVWL#SURYLVPH[FRP ROOiPDQRVD 0LQLVWHULR3URYLVLyQ +XDWDEDPSR6RQRUD0p[LFR