Semillero de Derecho Procesal - Universidad Libre, Sede Bogotá tutela judicial efectiva no dineraria en el proceso monitorio colombiano* Semillero de Derecho Procesal - Universidad Libre, Sede Bogotá José Joaquín Rodríguez ArévaloI Kelly Johana Merchán BejaranoII Sebastián Gómez Alarcón (Ponente) III Coordinador del semillero: Armando Augusto Quintero González*7 Resumen 4JOMVHBSBEVEBTFMQSPDFTPNPOJUPSJPGVFJODPSQPSBEPBCVFOBIPSB EFOUSPEFOVFTUSPPSEFOBNJFOUPKVSÓEJDPQSPDFTBMQPSUBOUPCFOFmDJBSÈ B MPT NJFNCSPT EF MB QPCMBDJØO NFOPT GBWPSFDJEB DPO VO FTDFOBSJP EFMJUJHJPTVNBSJPnFYJCMFZCSFWF&TUPFWJUBSÈKVJDJPTJOUFSNJOBCMFT Z FOHPSSPTPT FO BRVFMMPT FWFOUPT FO MPT RVF MPT DJVEBEBOPT IBZBO DPOmHVSBEP DPO TVT EFVEPSFT PCMJHBDJPOFT FO EJOFSP EFUFSNJOBEBT 3FDJCJEPTFQUJFNCSFEF"QSPCBEPGFCSFSPEF I "SUJDVMP*OÏEJUP 1BSB DJUBS FM BSUÓDVMP (».&; 4FCBTUJÈO 30%3¶(6&; +PTÏ +PBRVÓO .&3$)«/ ,FMMZ+PIBOBi5VUFMBKVEJDJBMFGFDUJWBOPEJOFSBSJBFOFMQSPDFTPNPOJUPSJPDPMPNCJBOPw Revista del Instituto Colombiano de Derecho Procesal /P FOFSP o KVOJP #PHPUÈ*OTUJUVUP$PMPNCJBOPEF%FSFDIP1SPDFTBMQQ *OWFTUJHBDJØOQSFTFOUBEBFOFM97*$PODVSTP*OUFSOBDJPOBMEF4FNJMMFSPTEF%FSFDIP 1SPDFTBMRVFTFMMFWØBDBCPFOFMNBSDPEFM9997*$POHSFTP$PMPNCJBOPEF%FSFDIP 1SPDFTBMFOMBDJVEBEEF1FSFJSBFOFMNFTEF4FQUJFNCSFEFMZDPOFMDVBMTFPCUVWP FMTFHVOEPMVHBSFOEJDIPDFSUBNFO-BQPOFODJBGVFFTDPHJEBFOUSFMPTNFKPSFTNFNPSJBMFTFTDSJUPT &TUVEJBOUF EF DVBSUP B×P EF %FSFDIP EF MB 6OJWFSTJEBE -JCSF #PHPUÈ .JFNCSP EFM TFNJMMFSP EF JOWFTUJHBDJØO i1SPDFTPT $POTUJUVDJPOBMFT Z "DUJWJTNP KVEJDJBMw EFM $FOUSP EF*OWFTUJHBDJPOFT(BOBEPSEFM$PODVSTP6OJWFSTJUBSJPEF%FSFDIP)VNBOPTEFMB %FGFOTPSÓBEFM1VFCMP3FQSFTFOUBOUFEFMB6OJWFSTJEBE-JCSFFOMBTU"OOVBM*OUFS "NFSJDBO )VNBO 3JHIUT .PPU $PVSU $PNQFUJUJPO &NBJM KPBRVJOSPESJHVF[BSFWBMP! HNBJMDPN. issn - tQQt&OFSP+VOJPEFt#PHPUÈ%$$PMPNCJB 43 Tutela judicial efectiva no dineraria en el proceso monitorio colombiano Z FYJHJCMFT RVF FNBOFO EF VOB SFMBDJØO KVSÓEJDP OFHPDJBM Z RVF OP TVQFSFOMBNÓOJNBDVBOUÓB $POMBTBOUFSJPSFTDBSBDUFSÓTUJDBTGVFDSFBEPFMQSPDFTPNPOJUPSJPFO $PMPNCJB QPS MP RVF TF BEWJFSUFO WBSJPT QVOUPT EF JOUFSÏT QBSB MPT FTUVEJPTPT EFM %FSFDIP QSPDFTBM DPNP MB WJBCJMJEBE EFM NFODJPOBEP QSPDFTP KVEJDJBM QBSB PCMJHBDJPOFT FYUSBDPOUSBDUVBMFT MB FWFOUVBM UJNJEF[ EFM MFHJTMBEPS BM DPOmHVSBS FTUF QSPDFTP EFDMBSBUJWP QBSB BTVOUPTRVFOPTVQFSFOMBNÓOJNBDVBOUÓBZBTVOUPTQSPDFEJNFOUBMFT DPNPMBQSPIJCJDJØOEFMBOPUJmDBDJØOQPSFNQMB[BNJFOUPFOUSFPUSPT &M QSFTFOUF USBCBKP EF JOWFTUJHBDJØO CVTDB SFTQPOEFS MBT TJHVJFOUFT QSFHVOUBT{se necesita en Colombia un proceso monitorio para crear títulos ejecutivos de obligaciones de hacer y dar-entregar BEFNÈT EF TFS QPTJUJWB MB SFTQVFTUB B MB QSFHVOUB BOUFSJPS {sufriría alguna modificación el procedimiento establecido por el artículo 421 del C.G.P. en los casos en que se demande la constitución de títulos ejecutivos por obligaciones de hacer o dar-entregar?; mOBMNFOUF{con el actual proceso monitorio regulado por el C.G.P., es posible constituir títulos ejecutivos dinerarios por obligaciones de dar-entregar y/o hacer por medio de subrogados pecuniarios Palabras clave: PCMJHBDJPOFTEFEBSZIBDFSTVCSPHBEPTQFDVOJBSJPT BDSFFEPSFTQSPDFTPNPOJUPSJP Abstract ͳF NPOJUPSZ QSPDFTT XBT XJUIPVU BOZ EPVCU JOUFHSBUFE KVTU JO UJNF JO PVS MFHBM TZTUFN TJODF JU XJMM CFOFmU UIF QPPS QPQVMBUJPO XJUI TVNNBSZ nFYJCMF BOE CSJFG MJUJHBUJPO XIJDI XJMM BWPJE FOEMFTT BOE DVNCFSTPNF USJBMT JO UIPTF FWFOUT XIFSF BSF DJUJ[FOT UIBU IBWF II III *7 44 &TUVEJBOUF EF DVBSUP B×P EF %FSFDIP EF MB 6OJWFSTJEBE -JCSF #PHPUÈ .JFNCSP EFM4FNJMMFSPSFQSFTFOUBOUFEFMB6OJWFSTJEBE-JCSFBOUFFMDPODVSTPEFTFNJMMFSPEFM *OTUJUVUP$PMPNCJBOPEF%FSFDIP1SPDFTBM&NBJMLFMMZCFKBSBOP!HNBJMDPN &TUVEJBOUFEFDVBSUPB×PEF%FSFDIPEFMB6OJWFSTJEBE-JCSF#PHPUÈ1POFOUFFOMBT 97**+PSOBEBTEF%FSFDIP1SPDFTBM"EPMGP.JOB#BMBOUB1POFOUFBOUFFM97*$PODVSTP *OUFSOBDJPOBM EF &TUVEJBOUFT EF %FSFDIP i4FNJMMFSPT EF %FSFDIP 1SPDFTBMw &NBJM HPNF[BMBSDPOT!HNBJMDPN "CPHBEP 6OJWFSTJEBE -JCSF &TQFDJBMJTUB FO %FSFDIP 1SPDFTBM $JWJM EF MB 6OJWFSTJEBE &YUFSOBEPEF$PMPNCJB$BOEJEBUPB.BHJTUFSEFMB.BFTUSÓBFO%FSFDIPDPO²OGBTJT FO 3FTQPOTBCJMJEBE $POUSBDUVBM &YUSBDPOUSBDUVBM $JWJM Z EFM &TUBEP EF MB NJTNB 6OJWFSTJEBE%PDFOUF6OJWFSTJEBE-JCSF4FDDJPOBM#PHPUÈ.JFNCSPEFM0CTFSWBUPSJP EF *OUFSWFODJØO $JVEBEBOB $POTUJUVDJPOBM EF MB 6OJWFSTJEBE -JCSF &NBJM RVJOUFSPHPO[BMF[!HNBJMDPN. Revista del Instituto Colombiano de Derecho Procesal t/P Semillero de Derecho Procesal - Universidad Libre, Sede Bogotá DPOmHVSBUFEmOBODJBMEFUFSNJOBUFBOEFOGPSDFBCMFPCMJHBUJPOTXJUI BMFHBMOFHPUJBUFETPVSDFVOEFSUIFTNBMMBNPVOUSBHF 8IJUUIFDIBSBDUFSJTUJDTBOECFOFmUTHJWFOBCPWFUIFNPOJUPSZQSPDFTT XBT DSFBUFE JO $PMPNCJB CVU UIFZ SBJTF BT XFMM JOUFSFTUJOH UPQJDT XPSUI TUVEZJOH MJLF JUT BQQMJDBUJPO UP OPOOFHPUJBUFE PCMJHBUJPOT UIFFWFOUVBMMFHJTMBUPSTIZOFTTXIFOTFUJUUPUIFTNBMMBNPVOUSBOHF BMTPQSPDFEVSBMJTTVFTMJLFQSPIJCJUJOHUIFFNQMBDFNFOUOPUJmDBUJPO BNPOHPUIFST ͳF QSFTFOU JOWFTUJHBUJPO QSPKFDU QSFUFOET XJUI UP BOTXFS UIF OFYU RVFTUJPOTJTOFFEFEJO$PMPNCJBBNPOJUPSZQSPDFTTUPDSFBUFFYFDVUJWF UJUMFT PG EPJOH PS HJWJOHEFMJWFSJOH PCMJHBUJPOT BMTP *G UIF BOTXFS JT BĊSNBUJWF XPVME JU DIBOHF UIF QSPDFTT FTUBCMJTIFE CZ UIF BSUJDMF PGUIFi$(1wJOUIFDBTFUIBUJUTEFNBOEFEUIFFYFDVUJWFUJUMFT DPOTUJUVUJPOGPSEPJOHPSHJWJOHEFMJWFSJOHPCMJHBUJPOT 'JOBMMZXJUI UIFBDUVBMNPOJUPSZQSPDFTTSFHVMBUFECZUIF$(1JUJTQPTTJCMFUP CVJMEFYFDVUJWFNPOFZUJUMFTGPSEPJOHPSHJWJOHEFMJWFSJOHPCMJHBUJPOT BOEPSEPUISPVHIQFDVOJBSZTVSSPHBUFT Key words: HJWJOHEFMJWFSJOH PCMJHBUJPOT QFDVOJBSZ TVSSPHBUFT EFCUPSTNPOJUPSZQSPDFTT 1. Introducción. &M ÏYJUP RVF IB MPHSBEP FM QSPDFTP NPOJUPSJP FO EJWFSTPT QBÓTFT UBOUP FVSPQFPTDPNPJCFSPBNFSJDBOPTMPIBDFVOPEFMPTQSPDFTPTNÈTVUJMJ[BEPTFO FMÈNCJUPDJWJMZEBMVHBSBTVJODMVTJØOFOFMPSEFOBNJFOUPKVSÓEJDPDPMPNCJBOP &TUB DPOTBHSBDJØO TF NBUFSJBMJ[Ø DPO MB FYQFEJDJØO EFM $ØEJHP (FOFSBM EFM 1SPDFTP -FZ EF DPO FM PCKFUJWP EF CSJOEBS B MPT DJVEBEBOPT VOB IFSSBNJFOUB NÈT FYQFEJUB Z FmDB[ RVF MPT BDUVBMFT QSPDFTPT KVEJDJBMFT "TÓ MP &O &TQB×B EF MPT QSPDFTPT NPOJUPSJPT FO TF QBTØ B FO FT EFDJS FO DVBUSP B×PT TF IBO EVQMJDBEP FM OÞNFSP EF QSPDFTPT NPOJUPSJPT %BUPT FYUSBÓEPTEFMB.FNPSJBEFM$POTFKP(FOFSBMEFM1PEFS+VEJDJBM BQSPCBEBQPSFM1MFOPFM EFNBZPEFIUUQXXXQPEFSKVEJDJBMFTDHQKFT1PEFS@KVEJDJBM<DPOTVMUBEP FM EF NBZP EF > 1PS TV MBEP FO FO *UBMJB TF IBO USBNJUBEP DFSDB EF VO NJMMØOEFQSPDFTPTNPOJUPSJPTFO'SBODJBTFIBTVQFSBEPFMNJMMØOEPTDJFOUPTNJMZFO "MFNBOJBTFIBMMFHBEPBMBDJGSBEFPDIPNJMMPOFT%BUPTUPNBEPTEF1*$»*+6/0: +PBO&MQSPDFTPNPOJUPSJPVOBWJTJØOFTQB×PMBZFVSPQFBQFOTBEBFO$PMPNCJB BFE &O999***$POHSFTP$PMPNCJBOPEF%FSFDIP1SPDFTBM#PHPUÈ%$6OJWFSTJEBE-JCSF EF$PMPNCJBTFQUJFNCSFQ i-BJOUSPEVDDJØOEFMQSPDFTPNPOJUPSJPFOQBÓTFTMBUJOPBNFSJDBOPTZBFTVOBSFBMJEBE NVZDPOTPMJEBEBFOFMUJFNQPDBTPEF6SVHVBZP#SBTJMw*CÓE issn - tQQt&OFSP+VOJPEFt#PHPUÈ%$$PMPNCJB 45 Tutela judicial efectiva no dineraria en el proceso monitorio colombiano EFKB WFS FM QSPGFTPS 6MJTFT $BOPTB DVBOEP JOEJDØ RVF i<F>TUF OVFWP QSPDFTP <FO $PMPNCJB> QBSB PCMJHBDJPOFT FO EJOFSP EF OBUVSBMF[B DPOUSBDUVBM EFUFSNJOBEBZFYJHJCMFRVFTFBOEFNÓOJNBDVBOUÓBFTVOBNFEJEBEFBDDFTP BMBKVTUJDJBQBSBBDSFFEPSFTEFQFRVF×BTZNFEJBOBTDVBOUÓBTRVFOPQVFEFO P BDPTUVNCSBO QPS EJWFSTBT SB[POFT EPDVNFOUBS TVT DSÏEJUPT FO UÓUVMPT FKFDVUJWPTZRVFDPOMBTBMUFSOBUJWBTQSPDFTBMFTBDUVBMFTEJGÓDJMFTEFNPSBEBT ZDPTUPTBTQSFmFSFOEBSMPUPEPQPSQFSEJEPw3&TFTUBMBSB[ØOQPSMBRVFFM QSPQØTJUPEFMQSPDFTPNPOJUPSJPFTTFSWJSQBSBMBDSFBDJØOSÈQJEBEFVOUÓUVMP FKFDVUJWPSFTQFDUPEFBRVFMMBTQFSTPOBTRVFTPOBDSFFEPSBTEFVOBPCMJHBDJØO DSFEJUJDJBOPDPOUFOJEBFOVOEPDVNFOUPRVFMBIBHBKVEJDJBMNFOUFFYJHJCMF PRVFBMFYJTUJSFMEPDVNFOUPFTUFMFTSFTVMUFQSFDBSJPQBSBTVDPCSPQPSMB WÓB FKFDVUJWB %JDIP EF PUSB NBOFSB FM QSPDFTP NPOJUPSJP QPESÈ FWJUBS FM EFTBSSPMMPEFVOQSPDFTPEFDPOPDJNJFOUPNÈTMBSHPZEJTQFOEJPTP 1PS MP BOUFSJPS FM QSPDFTP NPOJUPSJP EB NVFTUSB EF TFS VO NFDBOJTNP KVEJDJBM QBSB MB UVUFMB EFM DSÏEJUP4 P EF NFKPS NBOFSB TF FODVBESB DPNP NFEJEB QBSB MB UVUFMB QSJWJMFHJBEB EFM NJTNP FO SB[ØO B RVF TV FTUSVDUVSB QSPDFEJNFOUBMQSPNFUFVOBQSPUFDDJØOÈHJMZSÈQJEBEFMEFSFDIPEFMBDSFFEPS RVFBNQBSBEFGPSNBFmDB[MBPCMJHBDJØODSFEJUJDJB &MQSPDFTPNPOJUPSJPBTVWF[QVFEFTFSFOUFOEJEPDPNPFMEFTBSSPMMPEF MBUVUFMBKVEJDJBMFGFDUJWBFODBCF[BEFM&TUBEPZTVTPSEFOBNJFOUPTKVSÓEJDPT QSPDFTBMFTBTÓDPNPMBNBUFSJBMJ[BDJØOEFMEFCFSEFHBSBOUJ[BSMPTEFSFDIPTZ MJCFSUBEFTDPOTBHSBEPTFOMB$POWFODJØO"NFSJDBOBTPCSF%FSFDIPT)VNBOPT FOQBSUJDVMBSFMEFSFDIPBMBQSPUFDDJØOKVEJDJBMZFMEFSFDIPBMQBUSJNPOJP&O FTUFTFOUJEPMBBENJOJTUSBDJØOEFKVTUJDJBEFCFQSPQFOEFSQPSMBTBUJTGBDDJØO SFBMZFGFDUJWBEFMPTEFSFDIPTSFDPOPDJEPTFOFMEFSFDIPTVTUBODJBMNFEJBOUF MBVUJMJ[BDJØOEFQSPDFTPTRVFGBDJMJUFOMBNBUFSJBMJ[BDJØOEFMPTEFSFDIPTEF MPTDJVEBEBOPT&MQSPDFTPNPOJUPSJPFTVONFDBOJTNPRVFCVTDBDVNQMJSDPO FTUPTQSPQØTJUPT. 3 $"/04"46«3&;6MJTFT&MQSPDFTPNPOJUPSJP&O$ØEJHP(FOFSBMEFM1SPDFTP-FZ EFKVMJP %FDSFUPEFZOPUBTEFDPOTUJUVDJPOBMJEBEDPNFOUBEP DPOBSUÓDVMPTFYQMJDBUJWPTEFNJFNCSPTEFM*$%1#PHPUÈ%$*OTUJUVUP$PMPNCJBOPEF %FSFDIP1SPDFTBMQ 4 1*$»*+6/0:+PBO &MQSPDFTPNPOJUPSJPVOBWJTJØOFTQB×PMBZFVSPQFBEFMBUVUFMB SÈQJEBEFMDSÏEJUPFEO¡ &O3FWJTUBEFM*OTUJUVUP$PMPNCJBOPEF%FSFDIP1SPDFTBM #PHPUÈ%$*OTUJUVUP$PMPNCJBOPEF%FSFDIP1SPDFTBMKVOJPEFQ $"/04"46«3&;0QDJUQ *CÓE 46 Revista del Instituto Colombiano de Derecho Procesal t/P Semillero de Derecho Procesal - Universidad Libre, Sede Bogotá $PO FM NFODJPOBEP NFDBOJTNP MPT BDSFFEPSFT EF PCMJHBDJPOFT EF UJQP EJOFSBSJPRVFOPDVFOUBODPOVOUÓUVMPFKFDVUJWPWFOVOQSPDFTPRVFFOBSNPOÓB DPO MB UVUFMB KVEJDJBM FGFDUJWB QSPUFHF KVEJDJBMNFOUF TV DSÏEJUP %F MP RVF TF EFTQSFOEF RVF MPT BDSFFEPSFT EF PCMJHBDJPOFT OP EJOFSBSJBT FO QBSUJDVMBS QPSTFSPCKFUPEFOVFTUSPUSBCBKPEFQSFTUBDJPOFTEFIBDFSZEBSFOUSFHBS OP FODVFOUSBO SFnFKBEP FO FM QSPDFTP NPOJUPSJP DPMPNCJBOP VO NFDBOJTNP RVF QSPUFKB TV DSÏEJUP QVFT DPO FM $ØEJHP (FOFSBM EFM 1SPDFTP MBT PCMJHBDJPOFT EJOFSBSJBTTFSÈOMBTÞOJDBTDPOMBTRVFQPESÈODPOTUJUVJSTFMPTUÓUVMPTFKFDVUJWPT DPOBZVEBEFFTUFQSPDFTPKVEJDJBM. 4FCVTDBFOUPODFTRVFFTUFQSPDFTPÈHJMZEFGÈDJMBDDFTPTFBNQMÓFBFTUPT BDSFFEPSFTEFPCMJHBDJPOFTEFIBDFSDPOFMmOEFNBYJNJ[BSMBUVUFMBKVEJDJBM FGFDUJWBFOSB[ØOBRVFFTUBQPTJCJMJEBEGBDJMJUBSÓBFMBDDFTPEFMBTQFSTPOBTBMB KVTUJDJBZFMSFDPOPDJNJFOUPFGFDUJWPEFTVTEFSFDIPTEFGPSNBNÈTGÈDJMRVFTJTF IJDJFSBQPSFMQSPDFTPEFDMBSBUJWPDMÈTJDPFOUPEPDBTPNÈTMBSHPGPSNBMZQPDP BDDFTJCMFQBSBRVJFOOPDVFOUBDPOMPTNFEJPTFDPOØNJDPTQBSBFNQSFOEFSVO QSPDFTPPSEJOBSJP &OUFOEFNPTRVFFMPCKFUJWPQMBOUFBEPSFGFSFOUFBMBBNQMJBDJØOEFMQSPDFTP NPOJUPSJP B UPEP UJQP EF PCMJHBDJPOFT DSFEJUJDJBT FT VO QSPDFTP RVF TF EFCF TVSUJSQPSNFEJPEFVOBSFGPSNBEFUJQPMFHBMFOFM$POHSFTPEFMB3FQÞCMJDBEF $PMPNCJBZDJFSUPFTRVFEJDIBSFGPSNBQVFEFEFNPSBSTFFOMMFHBSBMBFTQFSB UBMWF[EFVOQPTJDJPOBNJFOUPZGPSUBMFDJNJFOUPEFEJDIPQSPDFTPRVFQFSNJUJSÈ EFUFSNJOBSMBFGFDUJWJEBEPQPTJCMFTGBMMBTEFMQSPDFTPNPOJUPSJP &OUPEPDBTPOPTQSPQPOFNPTFTUBCMFDFSTJFM&TUBEPDPMPNCJBOPSFRVJFSF RVFFMQSPDFTPNPOJUPSJPQFSNJUBMBDSFBDJØOEFUÓUVMPTFKFDVUJWPTDPOUFOUJWPTEF PCMJHBDJPOFTEFIBDFS-VFHPEFTFSBTFSUJWBMBSFTQVFTUBBMBOUFSJPSJOUFSSPHBOUF DPOUJOVBSFNPTDPOFMFTUVEJPEFMQSPDFEJNJFOUPFTUBCMFDJEPQPSFMMFHJTMBEPSBM QSPDFTPNPOJUPSJPDPMPNCJBOPDPOFMQSPQØTJUPEFJEFOUJmDBSDVÈMFTTFSÓBOMBT WBSJBDJPOFTRVFEJDIPQSPDFTPEFCFUFOFSQBSBQPEFSmOBMJ[BSDPOVOUÓUVMPRVF QSFTUFNÏSJUPFKFDVUJWPQPSVOBPCMJHBDJØOEFIBDFS 1PS ÞMUJNP TF FYQPOESÈO VOBT QFRVF×BT SFnFYJPOFT mOBMFT UFOEJFOUFT B HFOFSBS BMUFSOBUJWBT QBSB PCUFOFS UÓUVMPT FKFDVUJWPT RVF TF PSJHJOFO FO PCMJHBDJPOFTEFEBSFOUSFHBSZPIBDFSEFJNQPTJCMFDVNQMJNJFOUPNJFOUSBTTFTVSUFO MPTDBNCJPTMFHJTMBUJWPTDPSSFTQPOEJFOUFT &M BSUÓDVMP EFM $ØEJHP (FOFSBM EFM 1SPDFTP DPOTBHSB EF NBOFSB FYQSFTB RVF TFSÈ QSPDFEFOUFFMQSPDFTPNPOJUPSJPSFTQFDUPEFi2VJFOQSFUFOEBFMQBHPEFVOBPCMJHBDJØO FOEJOFSPEFOBUVSBMF[BDPOUSBDUVBMEFUFSNJOBEBZFYJHJCMFRVFTFBEFNÓOJNBDVBOUÓB QPESÈQSPNPWFSQSPDFTPNPOJUPSJPDPOTVKFDJØOBMBTEJTQPTJDJPOFTEFFTUF$BQÓUVMPw TVCSBZBEPFTOVFTUSP issn - tQQt&OFSP+VOJPEFt#PHPUÈ%$$PMPNCJB 47 Tutela judicial efectiva no dineraria en el proceso monitorio colombiano 2. Aspectos metodológicos de la investigación. 2.1 Las preguntas de investigación. &OFMUSBCBKPRVFFMMFDUPSUJFOFFOTVTNBOPTMBJOWFTUJHBDJØOCVTDBSFTQPOEFS MBTTJHVJFOUFTQSFHVOUBT {4FOFDFTJUBFO$PMPNCJBVOQSPDFTPNPOJUPSJPQBSBDSFBSUÓUVMPTFKFDVUJWPT DPOPCMJHBDJPOFTEFIBDFSZEBSFOUSFHBS %FTFSQPTJUJWBMBSFTQVFTUBBMBQSFHVOUBBOUFSJPS{TVGSJSÓBBMHVOBNPEJmDBDJØOFMQSPDFEJNJFOUPFTUBCMFDJEPQPSFMBSUÓDVMPEFM$ØEJHP(FOFSBMEFM 1SPDFTPFOMPTDBTPTFORVFTFEFNBOEFMBDPOTUJUVDJØOEFUÓUVMPTFKFDVUJWPTQPS PCMJHBDJPOFTEFIBDFSZEBSFOUSFHBS "EFNÈT{DPOFMBDUVBMQSPDFTPNPOJUPSJPSFHVMBEPQPSFM$ØEJHP(FOFSBM EFM1SPDFTPFTQPTJCMFDPOTUJUVJSUÓUVMPTFKFDVUJWPTEJOFSBSJPTQPSPCMJHBDJPOFT EFEBSFOUSFHBSZPIBDFSQPSNFEJPEFTVCSPHBEPTQFDVOJBSJPT 2.2 La estrategia metodológica. " MB QSFTFOUF JOWFTUJHBDJØO TF MF BQMJDBSÈ VO FOGPRVF UBOUP CÈTJDP KVSÓEJDP PEPDVNFOUBMBTÓDPNPTPDJPKVSÓEJDP&MQSJNFSFOGPRVFTF×BMBEPTFVUJMJ[BSÈ DPNPTPQPSUFQBSBEFTBSSPMMBSMPTBTQFDUPTDPODFQUVBMFTZUFØSJDPTEFMQSPDFTP NPOJUPSJP DPMPNCJBOP Z FM QSPDFTP NPOJUPSJP DPNQBSBEP EF JHVBM GPSNB TFSÈ UPNBEP QBSB BOBMJ[BS DJFSUPT BTQFDUPT EF MB UFPSÓB EF MBT PCMJHBDJPOFT Z TV JNQMJDBDJØO FO FM QSPDFTP NPOJUPSJP MP DVBM MF EBSÈ BM USBCBKP VO FOGPRVF JOUFSEJTDJQMJOBSJPFOUSFFM%FSFDIPQSPDFTBMZFM%FSFDIPDJWJM 3. Breve historia del proceso monitorio. -BFUJNPMPHÓBEFMBQBMBCSBiNPOJUPSJPwQSPWJFOFEFMBSBÓ[MBUJOBmonitorius RVF TJHOJmDB BEWFSUFODJB RVF TJSWF QBSB BWJTBS P BNPOFTUBS 4V PSJHFO DPNP mHVSBKVSÓEJDBTFSFNPOUBBMB&EBE.FEJBFOMB1FOÓOTVMB*UÈMJDBIBDJBFMTJHMP 9*** DPO FM preceptum o mandatum de solvendo cum clausula iustificativa, DVBOEP MPT KVSJTUBT JUBMJBOPT EFM NFODJPOBEP TJHMP TF QSFHVOUBSPO QPS MB TJUVBDJØOEFBRVFMMPTBDSFFEPSFTRVFOPDVFOUBODPOVOEPDVNFOUPRVFSFÞOB MBTDPOEJDJPOFTEFVOUÓUVMPFKFDVUJWPFTUPFTRVFTFBDMBSPFYQSFTPFYJHJCMFZ 48 %JDDJPOBSJP EF MB MFOHVB FTQB×PMB NPOJUPSJP IUQEMFSBFFTJE QFGLBT <$POTVMUBEPFMNJÏSDPMFTEFNBS[PEF> Revista del Instituto Colombiano de Derecho Procesal t/P Semillero de Derecho Procesal - Universidad Libre, Sede Bogotá RVFEFQSVFCBEFMBFYJTUFODJBEFVOBPCMJHBDJØODPOUSBFMEFVEPS1BSBFTUPT BDSFFEPSFTTFDSFØFMQSPDFTPNPOJUPSJPRVFTFEFTQMFHØQPSUPEB&VSPQBZRVF IBFNQF[BEPBMMFHBSBMPTQBÓTFTJCFSPBNFSJDBOPTEFTEFMBTFHVOEBNJUBEEFM TJHMP99-BSB[ØOEFFTUBUFOEFODJBEFJNQMFNFOUBDJØOEFMQSPDFTPNPOJUPSJP SBEJDBBMJHVBMRVFFOFMTJHMP97***oÏQPDBQPTUFSJPSBMB3FWPMVDJØO'SBODFTBEF oFOMBOFDFTJEBEEFQSPDFTPTKVEJDJBMFTiRVFWFSEBEFSBNFOUFHBSBOUJDFO MB FGFDUJWJEBE EF MPT EFSFDIPT TVTUBODJBMFT DPO BDDFTP SBQJEF[ Z FmDBDJB EFTUFSSBOEP PCTUÈDVMPT FYDFTJWPT P JSSB[POBCMFT TJO EFTNFESP EFM EFSFDIP BM EFCJEP QSPDFTPw &O ÞMUJNBT MP RVF TF RVJTP DPO FTUF QSPDFTP EFDMBSBUJWP GVF FWJUBS VO KVJDJP QMFOBSJP QBSB UFOFS MB QPTJCJMJEBE EF DPOTUJUVJS VO UÓUVMP FKFDVUJWP SÈQJEP Z FmDB[ FT EFDJS FM QSPDFTP NPOJUPSJP FT DPOTJEFSBEP DPNP VOBBMUFSOBUJWBBMQSPDFTPPSEJOBSJPEFCJEPBRVFFTUFFTGPSNBMJTUBZFYUFOTP 4. ¿Qué es el proceso monitorio? &MQSPDFTPNPOJUPSJPTFIBDMBTJmDBEPFO$PMPNCJBEFOUSPEFMPTQSPDFTPT EFDMBSBUJWPTFTQFDJBMFTQPSRVFTVmOBMJEBEFTMBDSFBDJØOEFVOUÓUVMPFKFDVUJWP TFFODVFOUSBFOUPODFTEFOUSPEFMBTNFEJEBTEFUVUFMBQSJWJMFHJBEBEFMDSÏEJUP EFM$ØEJHP(FOFSBMEFM1SPDFTP&OPUSBTQBMBCSBTTVmOBMJEBEFTHBSBOUJ[BSMB UVUFMBKVEJDJBMFGFDUJWBTJOMBOFDFTJEBEEFBHPUBSPSFBMJ[BSUPEBTMBTFUBQBTEFM QSPDFTPPSEJOBSJPPEFDMBSBUJWPQBSBPCUFOFSTFOUFODJBRVFEFDMBSFFMEFSFDIP FODPOUSPWFSTJB. &TUF UBNCJÏO IB TJEP DBUBMPHBEP FO PUSBT MBUJUVEFT EFM NVOEP DPNP VO QSPDFTP QMFOBSJP EBEP RVF MB TPMVDJØO RVF TF EÏ BM DPOnJDUP EFOUSP EF FTUF QSPDFTP UFOESÈ FGFDUPT EF DPTB KV[HBEB FO DBTP EF JODPNQBSFDFODJB EFM EFVEPS "TÓ MP IB EFUFSNJOBEP FM QSPGFTPS $PSSFB %FMDBTTP DVBOEP EFmOF $)*07&/%" (JVTFQQF *OTUJUVDJPOFT EFM EFSFDIP QSPDFTBM DJWJM 4FSJF DMÈTJDPT EFM %FSFDIP 1SPDFTBM $JWJM 7PMVNFO .ÏYJDP &EJUPSJBM +VSÓEJDB 6OJWFSTJUBSJB Q 1*$» * +6/0: &M QSPDFTP NPOJUPSJP VOB WJTJØO FTQB×PMB Z FVSPQFB QFOTBOEP FO $PMPNCJB0QDJUQ 26*/5&30 1²3&; .BHEB *TBCFM Z #0/&55 035*;# 4BNJS "MCFSUP &M QSPDFTP .POJUPSJP 5FOEFODJB EFM EFSFDIP QSPDFTBM JCFSPBNFSJDBOP &O 99*7 +PSOBEBT *CFSPBNFSJDBOBT %F %FSFDIP 1SPDFTBM 1BOBNÈ *OTUJUVUP $PMPNCP 1BOBNF×P EF %FSFDIP1SPDFTBMF*OTUJUVUP*CFSPBNFSJDBOPEF%FSFDIP1SPDFTBMQ 1*$» * +6/0: &M QSPDFTP NPOJUPSJP VOB WJTJØO FTQB×PMB Z FVSPQFB QFOTBOEP FO $PMPNCJB0QDJUQ $0-.&/"3&4 63*#& $BSMPT &M 1SPDFTP EF MB &TUSVDUVSB .POJUPSJB $ÞDVUB -JUPHSBG ÓB/VFWB(SBOBEBQQ issn - tQQt&OFSP+VOJPEFt#PHPUÈ%$$PMPNCJB 49 Tutela judicial efectiva no dineraria en el proceso monitorio colombiano FMQSPDFTPNPOJUPSJPDPNPVOiQSPDFTPFTQFDJBMQMFOBSJPSÈQJEPRVFUJFOEF NFEJBOUFMBJOWFSTJØOEFMBJOJDJBUJWBEFMDPOUSBEJDUPSJPBMBSÈQJEBDSFBDJØOEF VOUÓUVMPFKFDVUJWPDPOFGFDUPTEFDPTBKV[HBEBFOBRVFMMPTDBTPTRVFEFUFSNJOF MBMFZ. 4FHÞO1JFSP$BMBNFOESFJFMQSPDFTPNPOJUPSJPFTBRVFMQPSNFEJPEFMDVBM DPOMBTJNQMFQFUJDJØOFTDSJUBEFMBDSFFEPSFMKVF[DPNQFUFOUFMJCSBTJOPÓSBM EFVEPSVOBPSEFODPOEJDJPOBEBEFQBHPDPOBEWFSUFODJBEFRVFFMEFVEPSQVFEF IBDFSPQPTJDJØOEFOUSPEFMUÏSNJOPFTUBCMFDJEP-BPSEFOEFQBHPEFCFSÓBDPOTJEFSBSTFDPNPVOJOJDJPEFFKFDVDJØOZBRVFFMKVF[OPCVTDBDPOFTUBEFDMBSBSFM EFSFDIPTJOPRVFQBSUFEFFOUFOEFSTVFYJTUFODJBZPSEFOBTVFKFDVDJØO. %JDIP MP BOUFSJPS TF QVFEF EFEVDJS RVF FM QSPDFTP NPOJUPSJP UJFOF WBSJBT mOBMJEBEFTFOUSFMBTDVBMFTFODPOUSBNPT 1PUFODJBSMBUVUFMBKVEJDJBMFGFDUJWB $SFBSEFNBOFSBSÈQJEBVOUÓUVMPFKFDVUJWP 3. 3FEVDJS MB DBOUJEBE EF QSPDFTPT EFDMBSBUJWPT QBSB DPOUSJCVJS EF GPSNB JOEJSFDUBBNFKPSBSMBSBQJEF[DPORVFTFSFTVFMWFOFTUPTQSPDFTPT %FPUSPMBEPDPNPDBSBDUFSÓTUJDBFTFODJBMEFMQSPDFTPNPOJUPSJPTFPCTFSWB MBJOWFSTJØOEFMBJOJDJBUJWBEFMDPOUSBEJDUPSJPQPSNFEJPEFMBDVBMQSFTFOUBEB MBTPMJDJUVEQBSBRVFTFSFRVJFSBBMEFVEPSRVFIBHBFGFDUJWBVOBPCMJHBDJØOBM EFNBOEBEPTFMFDPOEFOBQSPWJTJPOBMNFOUFTJOTFSPÓEP4JOFNCBSHPBRVFM CJFOQVFEFIBDFSPQPTJDJØOBFTUFMMBNBEPDPNPBTVWF[QVFEFOPPQPOFSTFZ HVBSEBSTJMFODJPDBTPFOFMDVBMTFFNJUJSÈVOBEFDJTJØOTFOUFODJB DPOMPDVBM TFEPDVNFOUBMBPCMJHBDJØOBMVEJEBQPSFMBDSFFEPSZFODPOUSBEFMEFVEPS1PS MPUBOUPFTMBQBSUFQBTJWBMBRVFoBMBUFOEFSBMBSFBMJEBEEFDJEFTJFTOFDFTBSJP BCSJS FM DPOUSBEJDUPSJP GSFOUF B MB TPMJDJUVE EFM EFNBOEBOUF FO DBTP EF OP IBDFSMPTFJUFSBTFQSPDFEFSÈDPNPBDBCBEFFYQMJDBSTF -B MFHJTMBDJØO EF MPT EJGFSFOUFT QBÓTFT RVF VUJMJ[BO FM QSPDFTP NPOJUPSJP QSFTFOUB BMHVOBT EJGFSFODJBT FO DVBOUP B TV FTUSVDUVSB Z DBSBDUFSÓTUJDBT QVFT TJCJFOFMQSPDFTPNPOJUPSJPUVWPTVPSJHFOFO*UBMJBZEFBMMÓTFFYQBOEJØQPS *CÓE $"-"."/%3&* 1JFSP &M 1SPDFEJNJFOUP .POJUPSJP. 5SBEVDDJØO EF 4BOUJBHP 4FOUJT .FMFEP#VFOPT"JSFT&EJDJPOFT+VSÓEJDBT&VSPQB"NÏSJDBQZ 1*$»*+6/0:&MQSPDFTPNPOJUPSJPVOBWJTJØOFTQB×PMBZFVSPQFBEFMBUVUFMBSÈQJEB EFMDSÏEJUP.0QDJUQ "-7"3"%0 7&--040 "EPMGP " -FDDJPOFT EF EFSFDIP QSPDFTBM BEBQUBEBT B MB MFHJTMBDJØOQSPDFTBMDJWJMZQFOBMEFMB1SPWJODJBEF#VFOPT"JSFT&EJUPSJBM"TUSFB Q 50 Revista del Instituto Colombiano de Derecho Procesal t/P Semillero de Derecho Procesal - Universidad Libre, Sede Bogotá &VSPQB OP UPEPT MPT QBÓTFT SFHVMBO EF MB NJTNB NBOFSB FTUF QSPDFTP -BT QSJODJQBMFT EJGFSFODJBT RVF DPOTBHSBO MBT MFHJTMBDJPOFT SBEJDBO FO RVF FM QSPDFTPNPOJUPSJPQVFEFTFSQVSPEPDVNFOUBSJPMJNJUBEPPJMJNJUBEP 1. Puro FO FTUF DBTP OP FT PCMJHBUPSJP QBSB FM BDSFFEPS BQPSUBS KVOUP B MB EFNBOEBQSVFCBTEPDVNFOUBMFTZBRVFFTTVmDJFOUFMBTJNQMFBmSNBDJØO EFMBFYJTUFODJBEFMBEFVEBQBSBRVFTFQSPEV[DBVOSFRVFSJNJFOUPEFQBHP 2. Documental TF DBSBDUFSJ[B QPS MB PCMJHBDJØO EF BQPSUBS VO UÓUVMP EPDVNFOUBMEFMDVBMQVFEBJOGFSJSTFMBFYJTUFODJBEFVOBPCMJHBDJØOFYQSFTB DMBSBZFYJHJCMF. 3. Limitado TF EB DVBOEP MBT QSFUFOTJPOFT RVF TF MMFWBO B DPOPDJNJFOUP EF MB KVSJTEJDDJØO QBSB RVF TFBO USBNJUBEBT NFEJBOUF QSPDFTP NPOJUPSJP OP QVFEFO FYDFEFS EFUFSNJOBEB DBOUJEBE EJOFSBSJB 4VFMF TFS FM UJQP EF QSPDFTPNPOJUPSJPSFDPNFOEBEPQBSBBRVFMMPT&TUBEPTRVFWBOBSFHVMBSMP QPSQSJNFSBWF[DPNPFM&TUBEPDPMPNCJBOP 4. IlimitadoFOFTUFDBTPQPSNFEJPEFMQSPDFTPNPOJUPSJPTFQPESÈUVUFMBS DVBMRVJFSUJQPEFSFDMBNBDJØOEJOFSBSJBTJOMÓNJUFFDPOØNJDPBMHVOP&TUP PDVSSF FO QBÓTFT DPNP &TQB×B RVF JOJDJBSPO DPO VO QSPDFTP NPOJUPSJP MJNJUBEPZDPOFMUJFNQPTFGVFFYQBOEJFOEPIBTUBTFSJMJNJUBEP. &ODPODMVTJØOFMQSPDFTPNPOJUPSJPQSPDVSBMBDSFBDJØOSÈQJEBEFVOUÓUVMP FKFDVUJWPQBSBBRVFMMPTDBTPTFORVFFMBDSFFEPSOPEJTQPOHBEFVOJOTUSVNFOUP FKFDVUJWP P UÓUVMP FKFDVUJWP QBSB GVOEBNFOUBS TVT EFSFDIPT &O FM NJTNP TFOUJEP MP FYQMJDB FM QSPGFTPS 5PNÈT Z 7BMJFOUF BM BmSNBS RVF iFM BDSFFEPS JOTBUJTGFDIPRVFOPQPTFZFTFVOUÓUVMPFKFDVUJWPZOPTFSFTJHOBCBBBDVEJSBM QSPDFTPPSEJOBSJPTFQSFTFOUBCBBOUFFMKVF[ZTPMJDJUBCBEFÏMMBFNJTJØOEFM mandatum de solvendo cum clausula iustificativa4JFMKVF[BDDFEÓBMBQFUJDJØO EFMBDSFFEPSZQBSBFMMPOJTJRVJFSBOFDFTJUBCBBQPSUBSVOBQSVFCBEPDVNFOUBM EFM DSÏEJUP FNJUÓB FM mandatum PSEFO EF QBHP EJSJHJEB DPOUSB FM EFVEPS y w. 1*$»*+6/0:&MQSPDFTPNPOJUPSJPVOBWJTJØOFTQB×PMBZFVSPQFBEFMBUVUFMBSÈQJEB EFMDSÏEJUP. 0QDJUQ $"-"."/%3&*0QDJUQ *CÓE $033&"%&-$"440+VBO1BCMP&MQSPDFTPNPOJUPSJP+.#04$)&EJUPS#BSDFMPOB Q (».&; 0304$0 +PTÏ "MFKBOESP *OUSPEVDDJØO BM 1SPDFTP .POJUPSJP $POTUJUVDJPOBMJ[BDJØOZ0SBMJEBEEFM%FSFDIP$JWJM.FEFMMÓO-JCSFSÓB+VSÓEJDB4ÈODIF[3-5%" Q issn - tQQt&OFSP+VOJPEFt#PHPUÈ%$$PMPNCJB 51 Tutela judicial efectiva no dineraria en el proceso monitorio colombiano 5. El proceso monitorio en Colombia. "MJHVBMRVFTFFYQVTPBOUFSJPSNFOUFFMQSPDFTPNPOJUPSJPFO$PMPNCJB IB TJEP DPOTBHSBEP DPNP VO QSPDFEJNJFOUP TFODJMMP QPS NFEJP EFM DVBM TF EPDVNFOUBVOBPCMJHBDJØODMBSBFYQSFTBZFYJHJCMFTJOMBQFOVSJBEFFNQSFOEFS VO QSPDFTP KVEJDJBM EF DPOPDJNJFOUP TJFNQSF RVF FM EFVEPS OP QMBOUFF PQPTJDJØO&TQSPDFEFOUFFOMBBDUVBMJEBEQBSBRVJFOQSFUFOEBFMQBHPEFVOB PCMJHBDJØOFOEJOFSPEFOBUVSBMF[BDPOUSBDUVBMEFUFSNJOBEBZFYJHJCMF &TUF QSPDFTP FO $PMPNCJB GVF JODPSQPSBEP BM PSEFOBNJFOUP KVSÓEJDP DPO MBFYQFEJDJØOEFM$ØEJHP(FOFSBMEFM1SPDFTPFOBEFMBOUF$(1 -FZ EFFOTV$BQÓUVMP*7ZBSUÓDVMPTZ&TVOQSPDFTPQVSPZ MJNJUBEPEBEPRVFFMBSUÓDVMPEFM$(1FTUBCMFDFRVFTPMPQPESÈIBDFS VTPEFMQSPDFTPNPOJUPSJPRVJFOQSFUFOEBFMQBHPEFVOBPCMJHBDJØORVFTFB EF NÓOJNB DVBOUÓB %F JHVBM GPSNB QBSB BDDFEFS B FTUF OP FT PCMJHBUPSJP QSFTFOUBSQSVFCBEPDVNFOUBMTFHÞOMPEJTQVFTUPFOFMOVNFSBMJODJTP EFMBSUÓDVMPEFM$(1 &O MP RVF SFTQFDUB B TV USÈNJUF TJ QSFTFOUBEB MB TPMJDJUVE QPS QBSUF EFM EFNBOEBOUFTFMMFHBSFBFKFSDFSPQPTJDJØOQPSQBSUFEFMEFNBOEBEPMBTPMVDJØO BMDPOnJDUPTFTVSUJSÈQPSNFEJPEFVOQSPDFTPWFSCBMTVNBSJPEFOUSPEFMNJTNP FYQFEJFOUF FO PUSPT UÏSNJOPT OP IBCSÈ OFDFTJEBE EF JOUFSQPOFS VOB OVFWB EFNBOEBEFDMBSBUJWBEBEPRVFDVBOEPTVSHFPQPTJDJØOQPSQBSUFEFMEFVEPS TFBCSFQBTPBMBGBTFDPHOPDJUJWB&MEFNBOEBEPGVFSBEFPQPOFSTFUBNCJÏO UJFOFMBPQDJØOEFQBHBSFTUPFTIPOSBSMBPCMJHBDJØOFODVZPDBTPTFUFSNJOBSÈ FMQSPDFTP5BNCJÏOQPESÈOPPQPOFSTFBMHVBSEBSTJMFODJP-PEFDMBSBEPQPS FMEFNBOEBOUFEBSÈQSVFCBEFMBFYJTUFODJBZNPOUPEFMBPCMJHBDJØODVBOEP OPIBZBPCKFDJØOEFMEFNBOEBEPEFJHVBMGPSNBBMTJMFODJPEFMEFNBOEBEP TFMFEBSÈMBDPOOPUBDJØOEFBDFQUBDJØOEFFTUBNBOFSBRVFEBSÈFTUBCMFDJEBMB PCMJHBDJØOZQPSMPUBOUPTFUPSOBSÈOTVQFSnVBTPUSBTQSVFCBT. "EFNÈT FO FM QSPDFTP NPOJUPSJP TPMP TF SFDPOPDFSÈO PCMJHBDJPOFT EJOFSBSJBTZBTFBFONPOFEBOBDJPOBMPFYUSBOKFSBQPSMPDVBMTFFYDMVZFOEF FTUFQFEJNFOUPPCMJHBDJPOFTEFEBSPFOUSFHBSFTQFDJFTNVFCMFTPCJFOFTEF HÏOFSPEJTUJOUPTEFEJOFSPEFIBDFSPEFOPIBDFSOJQSFUFOTJPOFTDPNQMFKBT RVFBDVNVMFOMBTBTQJSBDJPOFTEFEJOFSPDPOBMHVOBEFFTUBTPUSBT. -FZ EF +VMJP i1PS NFEJP EF MB DVBM TF FYQJEF FM $ØEJHP (FOFSBM EFM 1SPDFTPZTFEJDUBOPUSBTEJTQPTJDJPOFTw1VCMJDBEBFOFM%JBSJP0mDJBM/PEF EFKVMJPEF $POTBHSBEBFOFMBSUÓDVMPEFM$(1DVBOUÓBRVFOPQVFEFTVQFSBSMPT4.-.7 FTEFÞOJDBJOTUBODJBZOPTFSÈOFDFTBSJPBCPHBEP $"/04"46«3&;0QDJUQ *CÓE 52 Revista del Instituto Colombiano de Derecho Procesal t/P Semillero de Derecho Procesal - Universidad Libre, Sede Bogotá -BPCMJHBDJØORVFDPNPZBTFEJKPEFCFTFSFOEJOFSPUFOESÈRVFTFSEFUFSNJOBEBQPSVOBTJNQMFPQFSBDJØONBUFNÈUJDBKVOUPDPOMPTSFTQFDUJWPTJOUFSFTFT EFNPSBPQMB[P"EFNÈTEFCFTFSFYJHJCMFMPRVFTJHOJmDBRVFMBPCMJHBDJØO QVFEFIBDFSTFFGFDUJWBDVBOEPFMQMB[PTFIBZBWFODJEPPTFIBZBDVNQMJEPMB DPOEJDJØOQBDUBEB &MQSPDFTPNPOJUPSJPOPQPESÈVUJMJ[BSTFQBSBDPCSBSQFSKVJDJPTEFOBUVSBMF[B FYUSBDPOUSBDUVBM RVF TFBO DVBOUJmDBEPT VOJMBUFSBMNFOUF EBEP RVF MPT DPOnJDUPTEFFTUBOBUVSBMF[BEFCFSÈOTVSUJSTFQPSNFEJPEFQSPDFTPEFDMBSBUJWP 'JOBMNFOUFFMQSPDFTPNPOJUPSJPFO$PMPNCJBSFRVJFSFEFOPUJmDBDJØOQFSTPOBM BM EFNBOEBEP Z OP BENJUF FM FNQMB[BNJFOUP EF FTUF OJ FM OPNCSBNJFOUP EF DVSBEPS ad litem, QPS PCWJBT SB[POFT %F JHVBM NBOFSB UBNQPDP QFSNJUF MB JOUFSWFODJØOEFUFSDFSPTMBVUJMJ[BDJØOEFFYDFQDJPOFTQSFWJBTPMBEFNBOEBEF SFDPOWFODJØOQPSFMEFNBOEBEPMPQSJNFSPDPOFMQSPQØTJUPEFHBSBOUJ[BSFM EFCJEPQSPDFTPEFMMMBNBEPBKVJDJPZMPÞMUJNPFONJSBTBFWJUBSRVFTFEFTRVJDJF TVmOBMJEBEDFMFSJEBEZFmDBDJB. 6. Estudio del proceso monitorio en el Derecho comparado. 4J CJFO FT DJFSUP RVF FM QSPDFTP NPOJUPSJP TJSWF FO QSJNFSB NFEJEB QBSB DPOTUJUVJS VO UÓUVMP FKFDVUJWP EF VOB QSFTUBDJØO DJFSUB Z FYJHJCMF EF EBS DBOUJEBEFTEFEJOFSPFTUPOPJNQMJDBRVFOPQVFEBTFSVTBEPQBSBMBFKFDVDJØO EFPCMJHBDJPOFTEFEBSVOCJFOJONVFCMFPNVFCMFEFIBDFSPOPIBDFSDPNPMP WFSFNPTTFHVJEBNFOUF 6.1 Italia. &O *UBMJB EFTEF FM B×P TF FTUBCMFDJØ FO FM BSUÓDVMP EFM $ØEJHP EF 1SPDFEJNJFOUP $JWJM MB “ingiunzione”, RVF DPOTJTUF FO VO QSPDFEJNJFOUP NPOJUPSJP EPDVNFOUBM -B QFUJDJØO SFBMJ[BEB EFCF TPQPSUBSTF DPO QSVFCBT 4J TFUSBUBEFEPDVNFOUPTFTQFDJBMFTDPNPMFUSBTEFDBNCJPPQBHBSÏTTFQVFEF TPMJDJUBS MB FKFDVDJØO QSPWJTJPOBM EF MB PCMJHBDJØO 1PS FTUP OP FT TVmDJFOUF MB PQPTJDJØOTJNQMFZMMBOB contrariu sensu EFMNPOJUPSJPQVSPBTÓEFCFNFEJBS QSVFCB EPDVNFOUBM RVF MB EFCFSÈ TVTUFOUBS FO MB BVEJFODJB EF DPOPDJNJFOUP FODBSHBEBEFSFTPMWFSMBQSPDFEFODJBEFMBPQPTJDJØOQPSMPRVFTFFOUJFOEFRVF MBDBSHBEFMBQSVFCBRVFEBFODBCF[BEFMEFVEPS4JOPTFQSFTFOUBPQPTJDJØO $"/04"46«3&;0QDJUQ 3&/%&5*&%FSFDIPQSPDFTBMDJWJMU**OÞN#VFOPT"JSFTQ issn - tQQt&OFSP+VOJPEFt#PHPUÈ%$$PMPNCJB 53 Tutela judicial efectiva no dineraria en el proceso monitorio colombiano EFOUSPEFMPTEÓBTTJHVJFOUFTBMBOPUJmDBDJØOFMSFRVFSJNJFOUPEFQBHPTFSÈ EFmOJUJWPZFMEFVEPSQPESÈTFSFKFDVUBEP &TUF QSPDFTP UBNCJÏO EFOPNJOBEP EF JOZVODJØO TJSWF QBSB FM DPCSP EF TVNBTEFEJOFSPDPTBTGVOHJCMFTPFOUSFHBEFDPTBTNVFCMFTEFUFSNJOBEBT -BTFTUBEÓTUJDBTTPODMBSBTBMBIPSBEFNPTUSBSOPTFMJODSFNFOUPFOMBVUJMJ[BDJØOEFFTUFQSPDFTPQVFTFOMPTKV[HBEPTZUSJCVOBMFTDJWJMFTJUBMJBOPT FYQJEJFSPO NBOEBUPT EF QBHP DJGSB RVF FO FM B×P BVNFOUØ B NBOEBUPT EF QBHP .ÈT SFDJFOUFNFOUF IBTUB FM B×P TF IBO USBNJUBEPDFSDBEFVONJMMØOEFQSPDFTPTNPOJUPSJPT. 6.2 Uruguay. -PT BOUFDFEFOUFT EFM QSPDFTP NPOJUPSJP FO 6SVHVBZ EBUBO EFM $ØEJHP EF 1SPDFEJNJFOUP $JWJM EF BIPSB EFSPHBEP RVF DPOUFOÓB SFTQFDUP B MPT KVJDJPT TVNBSJPT FTQFDJBMFT MB iFOUSFHB EF MB DPTBw Z MB iFOUSFHB FGFDUJWB EF MB IFSFODJBwQSPDFTPTRVFQPTFÓBOVOBFTUSVDUVSBNPOJUPSJBZRVFDPOUFNQMBCBO MBJOWFSTJØOEFMDPOUSBEJDUPSJP &TBTÓRVFFM$ØEJHP(FOFSBMEFM1SPDFTPWJHFOUF- FOTVMJCSP**Z FTQFDÓmDBNFOUFDBQÓUVMP*7SFHMBNFOUBMPTiQSPDFTPTEFFTUSVDUVSBNPOJUPSJBw RVFBTVWF[JODMVZFOFMiQSPDFTPFKFDVUJWPwGSFOUFBMDPCSPEFTVNBTEFEJOFSP Z RVF FTUBCMFDFO VO iQSPDFEJNJFOUP NPOJUPSJPw 1BSB JOJDJBS VO QSPDFTP NPOJUPSJPTFSFRVFSJSÈEPDVNFOUPBVUÏOUJDPPBVUFOUJDBEPOPUBSJBMNFOUFFOMB FUBQBQSFMJNJOBSSFTQFDUJWBFYDFQUPDVBOEPTFUSBUFEFVODPOUSBUPRVFQVFEB TFSQSPCBEPQPSNFEJPEFUFTUJHPT 6.2.1 Ejecución del proceso monitorio en Uruguay. $VBOEPTFQJEBMBFKFDVDJØOFMKVF[EFDSFUBSÈFNCBSHPIBTUBIBDFSTFFGFDUJWB MBDBOUJEBESFDMBNBEBMPTJOUFSFTFTZDPTUBTEFMQSPDFTP"QBSUJSEFMBVUPRVF EFDSFUBFMFNCBSHPFMFKFDVUBEPUFOESÈVOQMB[PEFEÓBTQBSBPQPOFSTFDPO MPTNFEJPTEFQSVFCBOFDFTBSJPTQBSBEFTWJSUVBSMBQSFUFOTJØOEFMBDDJPOBOUF%F %&-$"440 $033&" +VBO 1BCMP &M QSPDFTP NPOJUPSJP FO MB OVFWB MFZ EF FOKVJDJBNJFOUPDJWJM&O3FWJTUB9VSJEJDB(BMFHBIUUQSFYVSHBOFUQEG$0-QEG <$POTVMUBEPFOTFQUJFNCSFEF> 1*$»*+6/0:&M1SPDFTP.POJUPSJPVOBWJTJØOFTQB×PMBZFVSPQFBEFMBUVUFMBSÈQJEB EFMDSÏEJUP0Q$JUQ /*$"4530 4&0"/& (VTUBWP -PT PUSPT QSPDFTPT NPOJUPSJPT FO FM DØEJHP HFOFSBM EFM QSPDFTP VSVHVBZP. &O .FNPSJBT EFM 9997 $POHSFTP $PMPNCJBOP EF %FSFDIP 1SPDFTBM6OJWFSTJEBE-JCSF#PHPUÈ%$$PMPNCJBQQZTT 54 Revista del Instituto Colombiano de Derecho Procesal t/P Semillero de Derecho Procesal - Universidad Libre, Sede Bogotá JHVBMNBOFSBTJOPTFQSFTFOUBMBPQPTJDJØOTFQBTBSÈBMBWÓBEFBQSFNJPRVF DPOTJTUFFOFMQSPDFTPKVEJDJBMFODBNJOBEPBTBUJTGBDFSMBPCMJHBDJØO %FMNJTNPNPEPMBMFZVSVHVBZBWJHFOUFDPOUFNQMBPUSPTUJQPTEFQSPDFTPT NPOJUPSJPTSFTQFDUPBEJGFSFOUFTPCMJHBDJPOFTBTBCFS 1. Entrega de la cosa. )BDF SFGFSFODJB B DPTBT iRVF OP TFBO EJOFSP Z RVF TF EFCBOQPSWJSUVEEFMBMFZFMUFTUBNFOUPFMDPOUSBUPFMBDUPBENJOJTUSBUJWPP MBEFDMBSBDJØOVOJMBUFSBMEFMBWPMVOUBEwDPOUFOJEPFOFMBSUÓDVMPJODJTP EFM$ØEJHP(FOFSBMEFMQSPDFTPEF6SVHVBZGSFOUFBFTUP-BHBSNJMMBTF×BMB RVF TJ FTUF JOTUJUVUP OP FYJTUJFSB FO OVFTUSB MFZ SFTVMUBSÓBO QPDP NFOPT RVF CVSMBEPTMPTEFSFDIPTEFBRVFMRVFUVWJFSBVODPOUSBUPQPSFMDVBMFMEFVEPS EFCÓB FOUSFHBSMF VOB DPTB DJFSUB Z EFUFSNJOBEB QPS DVBOUP OP FTUBOEP TFNFKBOUFEPDVNFOUPHBSBOUJ[BEPQPSMBWÓBFKFDVUJWBFMBDSFFEPSUFOESÓB RVF SFDVSSJS GPS[PTBNFOUF B MB WÓB PSEJOBSJB QBSB FYJHJS FM DVNQMJNJFOUP EF MB PCMJHBDJØO EF MB PUSB QBSUF DPOUSBUBOUF DPO HSBWF QFSKVJDJP QBSB TV EFSFDIP QVFT FTUBSÓB PCMJHBEP B TPQPSUBS MPT EJTQFOEJPT Z MB MFOUJUVE EFM KVJDJPEFDMBSBUJWP&SBQPSPUSBQBSUFVOBDPOTFDVFODJBKVSÓEJDBEBSWJSUVE FKFDVUJWB B VO EPDVNFOUP DVZP PCKFUP GVFSB DBOUJEBE EF EJOFSP MÓRVJEB Z FYJHJCMFZOPIBDFSFYUFOTJWBMBNJTNBQPSMPNFOPTBMPTEPDVNFOUPTRVF UVWJFSBOQPSPCKFUPDPTBTDJFSUBTZEFUFSNJOBEBT. 2. Entrega efectiva de la herencia. 4F QSFTFOUB DVBOEP VO UFSDFSP JNQJEF RVFFMIFSFEFSPFKFS[BMBQPTFTJØOEFCJFOFTIFSFEJUBSJPTTJOJOWPDBSOJOHÞO EFSFDIP TPCSF FMMPT BTÓ MP TF×BMB FM BSUÓDVMP EFM $ØEJHP FO DPNFOUP %FMNJTNPNPEPMBKVSJTQSVEFODJBVSVHVBZBIBEFTBSSPMMBEPMPTSFRVJTJUPT FTFODJBMFTQBSBTVQSPDFEFODJBFTUPTTPO33 B 2VFFYJTUBVOTVDFTPSTJORVFTFBOFDFTBSJPMBEFDMBSBUPSJBEFIFSFEFSPT C 2VFBMUFSDFSPRVFTFSFTJTUFBMBFOUSFHBEFMPTCJFOFTOPMFDPOTUFRVFFM BDUPSSFWJTUFMBDBMJEBEEFIFSFEFSP D 2VFFMUFSDFSPOPBDDJPOFOJOHÞOEFSFDIPTPCSFMPTCJFOFTIFSFEJUBSJPT %F MP BOUFSJPS TF EFTQSFOEF RVF TPMP QPESÈ BDVEJSTF B FTUF QSPDFEJNJFOUP DVBOEPFMUFSDFSPOPJOWPRVFOJOHÞOEFSFDIPTPCSFMPTCJFOFTIFSFEJUBSJPT $JUBEPQPS&-*;"-%&+PSHF-VJT3FHJNFO1SPDFTBMEFMKVJDJPTVNBSJPEFFOUSFHBEFMB DPTB&O3FWJTUBEF5ÏDOJDB'PSFOTF/P*OTUJUVUPEF5ÏDOJDB'PSFOTF'VOEBDJØOEF $VMUVSB6OJWFSTJUBSJB.POUFWJEFPQ 33 4FOUFODJB/PEFEFM5SJCVOBMEF"QFMBDJPOFTEF'BNJMJBEFFS5VSOPQVCMJDBEB FO3FWJTUB6SVHVBZBEF%FSFDIPEF'BNJMJB/P'VOEBDJØOEF$VMUVSB6OJWFSTJUBSJB .POUFWJEFPQQZ issn - tQQt&OFSP+VOJPEFt#PHPUÈ%$$PMPNCJB 55 Tutela judicial efectiva no dineraria en el proceso monitorio colombiano 3. Pacto comisorio.4JUVBDJØOTFHÞOFMBSUÓDVMPEFM$ØEJHP(FOFSBMEFM QSPDFTPVSVHVBZPFOMBRVFiTFEFNBOEBMBSFTPMVDJØOEFVODPOUSBUPFO DVNQMJNJFOUPEFMQBDUPDPNJTPSJPDPOWFOJEP&OMBQSPWJEFODJBJOJDJBMTF EJTQPOESÈTJTFKVTUJmDBQPSFMBDUPSMBDBÓEBFONPSBEFMEFNBOEBEPMB SFTPMVDJØOEFMDPOUSBUP%JDIBSFTPMVDJØORVFEBSÈTJOFGFDUPTJFMQBHPEFM QSFDJP TF SFBMJ[B FM EÓB IÈCJM TJHVJFOUF B MB OPUJmDBDJØO BM EFNBOEBEP EF BRVFMMBSFTPMVDJØOw %F VOB NFKPS NBOFSB #BSSJPT EF «OHFMJT FYQMJDB TPCSF FM USÈNJUF EFM QBDUP DPNJTPSJP CBKP MB mHVSB QSPDFTBM EFM NPOJUPSJP RVF TJ MB EFDJTJØO SFTVMUBGBWPSBCMFBMBDDJPOBOUFMBSFTPMVDJØOEFMDPOUSBUPTFWFSJmDBDPOMB TFOUFODJBZBOUFTEFMBOPUJmDBDJØOEFMEFNBOEBEP&OFTUBBEFNÈTEFRVF FMEFVEPSTFFOUFSFEFMBEFNBOEBFOTVDPOUSBUBNCJÏOTFOPUJmDBEFMB TFOUFODJBRVFEJTQVTPMBSFTPMVDJØOTBMWPRVFFMEFVEPSQBHVFEFOUSPEF MBTIPSBTTJHVJFOUFTBTVOPUJmDBDJØOMPRVFEFKBTJOFGFDUPMBTFOUFODJB DPOTUJUVUJWBEJDUBEB34. 4. Escritura forzada. &O FTUF QSPDFTP TF CVTDB FM DVNQMJNJFOUP EF MB PCMJHBDJØO EF FTDSJUVSBS FTUBCMFDJEB FO MBT QSPNFTBT EF FOBKFOBDJØO EF JONVFCMFT B QMB[PT P FRVJWBMFOUFT P EF DBTBT EF DPNFSDJP DPOGPSNF MP FOTF×BFMBSUÓDVMPEFMBMFZQSPDFTBMVSVHVBZB "EFNÈT EF MP BOUFSJPS TF QPTJCJMJUØ RVF QPS NFEJP EFM NPOJUPSJP TF DBODFMBSBDVBMRVJFSDPOUSBUPEFIJQPUFDBMPDVBMFTVOMPHSPRVFEFBDVFSEP B5BSJHPFTVOBWÓBRVFQSFTFSWBMBTHBSBOUÓBTEFMEFCJEPQSPDFTPZBMBWF[ FTUBCMFDFVOQSPDFEJNJFOUPSÈQJEPZFmDB[QBSBPCUFOFSMBDBODFMBDJØOEF MBIJQPUFDBRVFNVDIBTWFDFTOPFTMPHSBEBQPSWÓBTFYUSBKVEJDJBMFT. 5. Resolución de contrato de promesa. 1PS FTUF NFEJP iTF EFNBOEB MB SFTPMVDJØO QPS GBMUB EF QBHP EF QSPNFTBT EF FOBKFOBDJØO EF JONVFCMFT B QMB[PT P DBTBT EF DPNFSDJP JOTDSJUBT FO MPT SFHJTUSPT SFTQFDUJWPTw 4F EJTQPOESÈEFMBSFTPMVDJØOQSFWJBDPOTUJUVDJØOFONPSBEFMEFNBOEBEPZ QSFWJBJOUJNBDJØOEFQBHPBSU 1BSBRVFQSPDFEBEJDIPQSPDFTPTFSFRVJFSF 34 i3FVOJØO DJFOUÓmDB TPCSF QBDUP DPNJTPSJP DPO MB QBSUJDJQBDJØO EF JOUFHSBOUFT EF MPT *OTUJUVUPT EF %FSFDIP 1SPDFTBM Z %FSFDIP $JWJMw 7FSTJØO DPSSFHJEB EF MBT EJTFSUBDJPOFT SFBMJ[BEBT FO FM #BODP )JQPUFDBSJP EFM 6SVHVBZ FM EF BCSJM EF &O 3FWJTUB6SVHVBZBEF%FSFDIP1SPDFTBM/P'VOEBDJØOEF$VMUVSB6OJWFSTJUBSJB .POUFWJEFPQ 5"3*(0&OSJRVF$POWFOJFODJBEFJOTUJUVJSPUSPNPOJUPSJPFMEFDBODFMBDJØOKVEJDJBM EF MB IJQPUFDB &O 3FWJTUB 6SVHVBZB EF %FSFDIP 1SPDFTBM /P 'VOEBDJØO EF $VMUVSB6OJWFSTJUBSJB.POUFWJEFPQQB 56 Revista del Instituto Colombiano de Derecho Procesal t/P Semillero de Derecho Procesal - Universidad Libre, Sede Bogotá B 1SFWJBDPOTUJUVDJØOFONPSBEFMQSPNJUFOUFDPNQSBEPSZ C -BJOUJNBDJØOEFQBHPQSFWJB 6. Separación de cuerpos y divorcio. 1SPDFEFSÈDVBOEPFMBDUPSKVTUJmRVFMBT FYJHFODJBT Z SFRVJTJUPT EFM $ØEJHP $JWJM VSVHVBZP Z DPODVSSB VOB EF MBT DBVTBMFTQSFWJTUBT. 7. Cesación de condominio de origen contractual. 4F SFBMJ[B QPS QSPDFTP NPOJUPSJPDVBOEPDVBMRVJFSBEFMPTDPQSPQJFUBSJPTBMBDSFEJUBSFMEPNJOJPZ BmSNBSMBJNQPTJCJMJEBEEFEJWJTJØOFYJHFMBWFOUBZSFQBSUPEFMQSFDJPRVFTF PCUFOHBDPOUFOJEPFOFMBSUÓDVMPEFM$ØEJHP(FOFSBMEFM1SPDFTP -PTSFRVJTJUPTQBSBRVFQSPDFEBTPO B &MDPOEPNJOJPEFCFTFSEFPSJHFODPOUSBDUVBM C &MBDDJPOBOUFEFCFBDSFEJUBSRVFFTVOPEFMPTDPQSPQJFUBSJPTZBQPSUBSMB FTDSJUVSBQÞCMJDBEFCJEBNFOUFJOTDSJUBFOFMSFHJTUSPSFTQFDUJWP D &MBDUPSEFCFJOWPDBS JNQPTJCJMJEBEEFEJWJEJSFMCJFOPMPTCJFOFTFO DPOEPNJOJP OFDFTJEBE EF QSPDFEFS B TV WFOUB QBSB QPTUFSJPSNFOUF EJWJEJS FM DBQJUBM MÓRVJEP FOUSF FM WBMPS EF MBT DVPUBT QBSUF EF MPT DPNVOFSPT. 8. Procesos de desalojo en general.1SPDFEFGSFOUFBJONVFCMFTUBOUPVSCBOPT DPNP SVSBMFT 4PO BQMJDBCMFT MPT BSUÓDVMPT B EFM $ØEJHP 1SPDFTBM VSVHVBZP &TUPQFSNJUFWJTMVNCSBSMBQSFQPOEFSBODJBZDPOmBO[BRVFTFMFIBPUPSHBEP BMNPOJUPSJPDPNPVOBGPSNBEFIBDFSNÈTFYQFEJUPTMPTQSPDFTPTEFEJWFSTB OBUVSBMF[BQFSGFDUBNFOUFWJBCMFQBSBPCMJHBDJPOFTEFDVBMRVJFSUJQP " NBOFSB EF DPODMVTJØO OPT VOJNPT B MP EJDIP QPS FM USBUBEJTUB /JDBTUSP 4FPBOFBMTF×BMBSDPNPVOÏYJUPMBJNQMFNFOUBDJØOEFMQSPDFEJNJFOUPNPOJUPSJP FOFTQFDJBMFOQSPDFTPTEFEFTBMPKPFKFDVUJWPTZFOUSFHBEFMBDPTBUBOUPBTÓRVF BQSPYJNBEBNFOUFFOFMEFMPTQSPDFTPTDPOQSPDFEJNJFOUPTNPOJUPSJPT OPTFQSFTFOUBOFYDFQDJPOFTMPDVBMEFSJWBFORVFiFMQSPDFTPTFJOJDJBDPOVO $ØEJHP(FOFSBMEFM1SPDFTPEF6SVHVBZ-FZ1SPNVMHBEBFMEFPDUVCSFEF "354Z *CÓE"SUÓDVMP/VNFSBMFTZ 5"3*(0&OSJRVF-FDDJPOFTEF%FSFDIP1SPDFTBM$JWJM5PNP*7BFEJDJØO'VOEBDJØO EF$VMUVSB6OJWFSTJUBSJB.POUFWJEFPQQZ 7&4$07* &OSJRVF -BT NPEFSOBT UFOEFODJBT EFM QSPDFTP DJWJM DPOUFNQPSÈOFP 3FWJTUB6SVHVBZBEF%FSFDIP1SPDFTBM/P'VOEBDJØOEFDVMUVSB6OJWFSTJUBSJB .POUFWJEFPQQZTT issn - tQQt&OFSP+VOJPEFt#PHPUÈ%$$PMPNCJB 57 Tutela judicial efectiva no dineraria en el proceso monitorio colombiano FTDSJUPZQVFEFUFSNJOBSDPOFMQSPWFJNJFOUPJOJDJBMw%FFTUBNBOFSBTFMPHSBO MPTQPTUVMBEPTEFHBSBOUJTNPZKVTUJDJBDPOFmDJFODJBZDFMFSJEBE. 6.3 Código Procesal Civil modelo para Iberoamérica. &OFMB×PEFDPOMBTQSJNFSBT+PSOBEBT-BUJOPBNFSJDBOBTEF%FSFDIP 1SPDFTBMEF.POUFWJEFPTFDSFBFM*OTUJUVUP*CFSPBNFSJDBOPEF%FSFDIP1SPDFTBM ZFTFOMBTDVBSUBTKPSOBEBTFO7FOF[VFMBEFNBS[PEFEPOEFTFQMBOUFØ MBQSPQVFTUBEFDSFBSVOBOPSNBUJWJEBEQSPDFTBMVOJmDBEBQBSB*CFSPBNÏSJDB 1PTUFSJPSNFOUFFOMBT7*+PSOBEBTEF%FSFDIPQSPDFTBMFO(VBUFNBMBEF ZMBT7**+PSOBEBTFO&DVBEPSGVFBOBMJ[BEPFMBOUFQSPZFDUPEF$ØEJHP.PEFMP 1SPDFTBM$JWJM&OFMNFODJPOBEPBOUFQSPZFDUPKVOUPDPOTVTBOUFDFEFOUFT ZFYQPTJDJØOEFNPUJWPTTFQVCMJDØFO.POUFWJEFPZTVUFYUPGVFOVFWBNFOUF DPOTJEFSBEPFMNJTNPB×PFOMBT9*+PSOBEBTDFMFCSBEBTFO3ÓPEF+BOFJSP. 6.3.1 Proceso de estructura monitoria en el Código Procesal Civil Modelo Para Iberoamérica. &OFTUFDØEJHPTFDPOTBHSØMBFTUSVDUVSBNPOJUPSJBOPTPMPQBSBMBFKFDVDJØO EFUÓUVMPTFYUSBKVEJDJBMFTDPNPMPTUÓUVMPTFKFDVUJWPTTJOPQBSBMPTKVEJDJBMFTRVF TFDPOTUJUVZFOQPSNFEJPEFTFOUFODJBFOQSPDFTPEFDPOPDJNJFOUP*HVBMNFOUF IBTJEPDPOUFNQMBEPQBSBQSPDFTPTEFEFTBMPKPPEFTBIVDJPFOUSFHBEFMBDPTB FOUSFHBEFMBIFSFODJBSFTPMVDJØOQPSGBMUBEFQBHPZFTDSJUVSBDJØOKVEJDJBMEF QSPNFTBTJOTDSJUBTFOFMSFTQFDUJWPSFHJTUSP43. &YJTUF VOB DBUFHPSÓB EFM QSPDFTP NPOJUPSJP EFOPNJOBEB DPNP QSPDFTP NPOJUPSJPDPOFUBQBQSFQBSBUPSJBFOMBRVFQBSBRVFFMKVF[EJDUFTFOUFODJBZ PSEFOFFMDVNQMJNJFOUPEFMBQSFTUBDJØOTFEFCFSÈTVSUJSVOBFUBQBQSFMJNJOBS QBSB BDSFEJUBS TV FYJTUFODJB "TÓ FM $ØEJHP 1SPDFTBM $JWJM .PEFMP QBSB *CFSPBNÏSJDBDPNPFYDFQDJØOBMQSFTVQVFTUPEPDVNFOUBMJODMVZFFMiDBTPEF FOUSFHBEFMBDPTBEFSJWBEBEFDPOUSBUPEFMRVFSFTVMUFMBPCMJHBDJØOEFEBSTJ -"/%0/*«OHFM&M$ØEJHP(FOFSBMEFM1SPDFTPBEJFDJTÏJTB×PTEFTVWJHFODJB&O 3FWJTUB +VEJDBUVSB /P 1VCMJDBDJØO 0mDJBM EF MB "TPDJBDJØO EF .BHJTUSBEPT EFM 6SVHVBZ.POUFWJEFP.BZPEFQ /*$"45304&0"/&0QDJUQ ."35¶/&;»TDBS+PTÏ&MQSPDFEJNJFOUPNPOJUPSJPFOFM$ØEJHP1SPDFTBM$JWJM.PEFMP QBSB*CFSPBNÏSJDBIUUQCJCMJPKVSJEJDBTVOBNNYMJCSPTQEG<$POTVMUBEP FONBZPEF>QQ 43 $0-.&/"3&4 63*#& $BSMPT "MCFSUP &TUSVDUVSB .POJUPSJB Z MB )JQPUFDB &O .FNPSJBT 999* $POHSFTP $PMPNCJBOP EF %FSFDIP 1SPDFTBM $BSUBHFOB EF *OEJBT Q 58 Revista del Instituto Colombiano de Derecho Procesal t/P Semillero de Derecho Procesal - Universidad Libre, Sede Bogotá TFUSBUBEFDPOUSBUPRVFOPSFRVJFSFEPDVNFOUBDJØOZFOFUBQBQSFMJNJOBSRVF TFTFHVJSÈQPSMBWÓBJODJEFOUBMQPESÈFTUBCMFDFSTFMBQSVFCBEFMBFYJTUFODJBEFM DPOUSBUPZTVDVNQMJNJFOUPQPSQBSUFEFMBDUPSw &M BSUÓDVMP EFM $ØEJHP 1SPDFTBM $JWJM QBSB *CFSPBNÏSJDB FTUBCMFDF RVF iSFRVFSJSÈ EPDVNFOUP BVUÏOUJDP P BVUFOUJDBEP KVEJDJBMNFOUF FO MB FUBQB QSFMJNJOBSSFTQFDUJWBwZEFKBDMBSPRVFFTVOQSPDFTPNPOJUPSJPEPDVNFOUBM44 BTÓEFMNJTNPNPEPMBPQPTJDJØOEFMEFVEPSEFCFFTUBSGVOEBEBFOMPTIFDIPTZ FMEFSFDIPZEFCFCVTDBSBCSJSVOQSPDFTPEFDPOPDJNJFOUPQBSBEFUFSNJOBSTJMB PQPTJDJØOBMFHBEBQPSFMEFVEPSEFNVFTUSBMBGBMUBEFGVOEBNFOUPEFMNBOEBUP PTJQPSFMDPOUSBSJPFTUFEFCFTFSNBOUFOJEPZIFDIPFKFDVUPSJP. 3FTQFDUP EF TV USÈNJUF Z DBSBDUFSÓTUJDBT FTUF QSPDFTP FT TJNJMBS BM DPOUFNQMBEPQPSMBMFHJTMBDJØOVSVHVBZBZBRVFFTVONPOJUPSJPEPDVNFOUBM FOFMRVFFTSFRVJTJUPJOEJTQFOTBCMFBOFYBSBMBEFNBOEBFTDSJUPRVFBDSFEJUFMB FYJTUFODJBEFMBPCMJHBDJØOBMNPNFOUPEFFYQPOFSMBEFNBOEBFOFTUFQSPDFTP "RVÓFMKVF[EJDUBTFOUFODJBZBDFQUBMBTQSFUFOTJPOFTEFMBDDJPOBOUFZBTVWF[ FMEFVEPSQPESÈPQPOFSTFFOFMQMB[PEFEÓBTBQPSUBSMBTQSVFCBTZBCSJSFM DPOUSBEJDUPSJPDPOMBTGPSNBMJEBEFTEFVOKVJDJPEFDMBSBUJWPPSEJOBSJP&MEFVEPS UBNCJÏOQPESÈHVBSEBSTJMFODJPMPRVFEBSÓBDPNPSFTVMUBEPMBDPOTUJUVDJØOEF UÓUVMPFKFDVUJWPZQBTBSÓBBMBWÓBEFBQSFNJPPQPESÓBTBUJTGBDFSMBPCMJHBDJØOZ HFOFSBSMBUFSNJOBDJØOEFMQSPDFTP. 6.4 El Salvador. &TUF UJQP EF QSPDFTP TF FODVFOUSB DPOTBHSBEP B QBSUJS EFM BSUÓDVMP EFM $ØEJHPEF1SPDFEJNJFOUP$JWJMEFM4BMWBEPSZTFJOJDJBDPOMBQSFTFOUBDJØOEF MBTPMJDJUVENPOJUPSJBQPSQBSUFEFRVJFOQSFUFOEBFMQBHPEFEFVEBFOEJOFSP MÓRVJEBWFODJEBZFYJHJCMF 4F EFCFSÈ BMMFHBS DVBMRVJFS TPQPSUF RVF KVTUJmRVF VO QSJODJQJP EF QSVFCB TVmDJFOUF ZB TFB EF DSFBDJØO VOJMBUFSBM QFSP RVF DPOUFOHB TFMMP P mSNB EFM EFVEPS &T SFRVJTJUP JOEJTQFOTBCMF MB JEFOUJmDBDJØO EFM EFVEPS KVOUP DPO FM EPNJDJMJPQBSBMBEFCJEBOPUJmDBDJØOQFSTPOBMEFJHVBMGPSNBTFEFCFNFODJPOBS 44 26*/5&30 1²3&; .BHEB *TBCFM Z #0/&55 035*; 4BNJS "MCFSUP &M QSPDFTP NPOJUPSJP 5FOEFODJB EFM EFSFDIP QSPDFTBM JCFSPBNFSJDBOP. &O 3FWJTUB EFM *OTUJUVUP $PMPNCJBOPEF%FSFDIP1SPDFTBM/PQ 10/;.BOVFM"MCFSUP&MQSPDFTPNPOJUPSJP&O3FWJTUBEFM$PMFHJPEF"CPHBEPTEF MB1MBUBQQZ $0-.&/"3&4 63*#& $BSMPT "MCFSUP &M 1SPDFEJNJFOUP .POJUPSJP FO "NÏSJDB -BUJOB1BTBEPQSFTFOUFZGVUVSP#PHPUÈ%$&EJUPSJBM5FNJT4"QQ issn - tQQt&OFSP+VOJPEFt#PHPUÈ%$$PMPNCJB 59 Tutela judicial efectiva no dineraria en el proceso monitorio colombiano FMPSJHFOZDVBOUÓBEFMBEFVEB&OFMDBTPEFOPJODMVJSTFMPTBOUFSJPSFTSFRVJTJUPT MBEFNBOEBTFSÈSFDIB[BEBTJOMVHBSBBQFMBDJØO 4J MB EFNBOEB DVNQMF MPT SFRVJTJUPT BOUFSJPSNFOUF NFODJPOBEPT TFSÈ BDFQUBEB MB TPMJDJUVE Z TF EBSÈ USBTMBEP BM EFVEPS QPS WFJOUF EÓBT QBSB RVF TF PQPOHB P TBUJTGBHB MB PCMJHBDJØO EF FTUB NBOFSB TF EBSÈ QPS UFSNJOBEP FM QSPDFTP. 4FQVFEFJOJDJBSQSPDFTPNPOJUPSJPQBSBTBUJTGBDFSPCMJHBDJPOFTEFIBDFSEF OPIBDFSZEFEBSDPTBFTQFDÓmDB-BPCMJHBDJØOEFCFDPOTUBSFOEPDVNFOUPZTF QPESÈQSFUFOEFSFYDMVTJWBNFOUFFMDVNQMJNJFOUPEFMBTBOUFSJPSFTPCMJHBDJPOFT TJORVFTFQVFEBTVTUJUVJSMBQFUJDJØOQPSTVFRVJWBMFOUFFOEJOFSPFYDFQUPDVBOEP IBZB NBOJGFTUBDJØO FYQSFTB EFM TPMJDJUBOUF P FYJTUB BCTPMVUB JNQPTJCJMJEBE EFM DVNQMJNJFOUPFTQFDÓmDP-PBOUFSJPSMFEBMBQPTJCJMJEBEBMTPMJDJUBOUFEFFYJHJS FOUSFFMFRVJWBMFOUFFOEJOFSPPMBFOUSFHBEFVOCJFOTFSWJDJPPQSPEVDUPEF DBSBDUFSÓTUJDBTZQSFTUBDJPOFTTFNFKBOUFTBMBTEFMPSJHJOBM 6.5 Venezuela. %FTEF TF JNQMFNFOUØ FM QSPDFTP QPS JOUJNBDJØO DPNP DBUFHPSÓB FTQFDJBMEFMQSPDFTPFKFDVUJWPFOFMBSUÓDVMPEFM$ØEJHPEF1SPDFEJNJFOUP $JWJMWFOF[PMBOPGVFDPOTBHSBEBMBQPTJCJMJEBEEFQFSTFHVJSFMQBHPEFVOBTVNB MÓRVJEBEFEJOFSPPMBFOUSFHBEFDJFSUBDBOUJEBEEFDPTBTGVOHJCMFTPEFVOBDPTB NVFCMFEFUFSNJOBEBDBTPFOFMDVBMFMEFVEPSUJFOFEÓBTQBSBRVFQBHVFP FOUSFHVFMBDPTB. &OFTUFTFOUJEPMB4BMBEF$BTBDJØO$JWJMEFM5SJCVOBM4VQSFNPEF+VTUJDJB BmSNØ RVF i &M QSPDFEJNJFOUP QPS JOUJNBDJØO TF BENJUF TJFNQSF RVF FM EFNBOEBEPQFSTJHBFMQBHPEFVOBTVNBMÓRVJEBZFYJHJCMFEFEJOFSPPMBFOUSFHB EFDBOUJEBEDJFSUBEFDPTBTGVOHJCMFTPEFVOBDPTBNVFCMFEFUFSNJOBEBMPRVF TJHOJmDBRVFTPMPQSPDFEFDVBOEPTFUSBUFEFBDDJPOFTEFDPOEFOBRVFQFSTJHBO FMDVNQMJNJFOUPEFPCMJHBDJPOFTEFEBSRVFDPOTUFFOQSVFCBEPDVNFOUBM w. #"3")0/"."("º"4POJB&MJ[BCFUI&MQSPDFTP.POJUPSJPFOFM$ØEJHP1SPDFTBM $JWJMZ.FSDBOUJM5FTJTEFQSFHSBEP6OJWFSTJEBEEFM4BMWBEPS&M4BMWBEPSQQ ZTT $ØEJHP1SPDFTBM$JWJMZ.FSDBOUJMEF&M4BMWBEPS%FDSFUP/P1SPNVMHBEBFMEF TFQUJFNCSFEF"SUÓDVMP $ØEJHPEF1SPDFEJNJFOUP$JWJMEFMB3FQÞCMJDBEF7FOF[VFMB(BDFUB0GJDJBM/¡ &YUSBPSEJOBSJBEFEFTFQUJFNCSFEF 4BMBEF$BTBDJØO$JWJMEFM5SJCVOBM4VQSFNPEF+VTUJDJBFO4FOUFODJB/¡3$EF GFDIB DBTP .VMUJTFSWJDJPT -FTMVJT $" DPOUSB "OUPOJP +VHVFSB 3PNÈO &91DPOQPOFODJBEFM%S5VMJP«MWBSF[ 60 Revista del Instituto Colombiano de Derecho Procesal t/P Semillero de Derecho Procesal - Universidad Libre, Sede Bogotá 6.6 Conclusiones del estudio legal comparado. 4FQVFEFFWJEFODJBSFOFMBOUFSJPSBOÈMJTJTEFEFSFDIPDPNQBSBEPEFMQSPDFTP NPOJUPSJPRVFMBTPCMJHBDJPOFTEFDSÏEJUPEFDVBMRVJFSOBUVSBMF[BEBSIBDFS OP IBDFS ZB TF USBNJUBO QPS FTUF QSPDFTP FO QSPDVSB EF TBUJTGBDFS FM DVNQMJNJFOUP EF PCMJHBDJPOFT EF EJWFSTB ÓOEPMF MP DVBM SFEVOEB FO CFOFmDJP EF MP FOTF×BEP QPS FM QSPGFTPS 'FSOBOEP )JOFTUSPTB iFM EFSFDIP TF QSFPDVQB QPS MBUVUFMBBEFDVBEBEFMDSÏEJUPZy FTUÈBUFOUPBQSPQPSDJPOBSBMBDSFFEPSMPT JOTUSVNFOUPT ØQUJNPT QBSB TV TBUJTGBDDJØO DBCBMw &TUP OPT MMFWB B BmBO[BS MB UFTJT QSPQVFTUB QPS MB JOWFTUJHBDJØO EJSJHJEB B RVF DVBMRVJFS BDSFFEPS EF PCMJHBDJPOFT EF DSÏEJUP TJO JNQPSUBS TV OBUVSBMF[B QVFEB BDDFEFS BM QSPDFTP NPOJUPSJPDPMPNCJBOPDVBOEPBTÓMPSFRVJFSBMPDVBMUJFOFDPNPEFSSPUFSPVOB KVTUJDJBÈHJMDPOBDDFTPQBSBUPEPTZDPOVOBTPMVDJØOBMDPOnJDUPFOVOUÏSNJOP SB[POBCMF5PEPIBCJEBDVFOUBEFRVFSFTVMUBEFJOFYPSBCMFJNQPSUBODJBDPOUBS DPOQSPDFTPTFYQFEJUPTZNPEFSOPTRVFSFTVFMWBOQSPOUBNFOUFMBDPOUSPWFSTJB ZQPSTVQVFTUPTJOEFTNFESPEFMBTHBSBOUÓBTQSPDFTBMFT 7. Breves consideraciones a la Sentencia C-726 de 2014. &TSFMFWBOUFFTUVEJBSMPTQMBOUFBNJFOUPTRVFEFMQSPDFTPNPOJUPSJPSFBMJ[ØMB $PSUF$POTUJUVDJPOBMNFEJBOUF4FOUFODJB$EFFOMBRVFBDUVØDPNP NBHJTUSBEBTVTUBODJBEPSB.BSUIB7JDUPSJB4ÈDIJDB.ÏOEF[MBDVBMTFJOWJUBB DPOTVMUBS4JCJFOMB$PSUF$POTUJUVDJPOBMFOEJDIBQSPWJEFODJBIBDFNFODJØO B PCMJHBDJPOFT EJGFSFOUFT B MBT EJOFSBSJBT DVBOEP TF QSPQVTP DPODFQUVBMJ[BS ÞOJDBNFOUFFTUBTFOUFOEFNPTRVFTVPCKFUJWPOPGVFFMEFWJTVBMJ[BSFMQSPDFTP NPOJUPSJP DPNP VO JOTUSVNFOUP RVF QFSNJUJFSB FM DPCSP EF QSFTUBDJPOFT EF EBSFOUSFHBSZPIBDFS-PBOUFSJPSEBEPRVFBMFTUVEJBSMBQSPDFEFODJBEFEJDIP QSPDFTPDPOUFOJEBFOFMBSUÓDVMPEFM$(1FOSFMBDJØOBRVFMBPCMJHBDJØO UJFOFRVFTFSFTUSJDUBNFOUFEJOFSBSJBMB$PSUFEFmOJØFTUBDPNPVOBDBOUJEBE EFEJOFSPFONPOFEBEFDVSTPMFHBMZQBTPTJHVJFOUFQFOTBOEPFOEFTBSSPMMBSTV BmSNBDJØOMBFKFNQMJmDØDPNPMBFOUSFHBNBUFSJBMEFVOCJFOPVOBPCMJHBDJØO EFIBDFSPOPIBDFS&OPUSBTQBMBCSBTFMEFTFNCSPMMPOPDPSSFTQPOEFPHVBSEB DPODPSEBODJBDPOMBEFmOJDJØOJOJDJBMEBEBEFEJOFSPFONPOFEBEFDVSTPMFHBM 'VFSB EF MP BOUFSJPS MB NFODJØO B FTUF UJQP EF PCMJHBDJPOFT OP EJOFSBSJBT TF FODVFOUSB FONBSDBEB EFOUSP EFM obiter dicta EF MB TFOUFODJB QVFT FTUF )*/&45304" 'FSOBOEP 5SBUBEP EF MBT PCMJHBDJPOFT $PODFQUP FTUSVDUVSB Z 7JDJTJUVEFT5FSDFSBFEJDJØO5PNP*#PHPUÈ$PMPNCJB&EJUPSJBM6OJWFSTJEBE&YUFSOBEPEF $PMPNCJBQ issn - tQQt&OFSP+VOJPEFt#PHPUÈ%$$PMPNCJB 61 Tutela judicial efectiva no dineraria en el proceso monitorio colombiano JOWPMVOUBSJPEFTDVJEPFOMBBDMBSBDJØOEFMBFYQSFTJØOEJOFSBSJBUVWPQPSPCKFUJWP DPOUFYUVBMJ[BSBDFSDBEFMBOBUVSBMF[BKVSÓEJDBEFMQSPDFTPNPOJUPSJPMPRVFOP HFOFSBVOBFTUSFDIBSFMBDJØOFOUSFUBMNFODJØOZFMQMBOUFBNJFOUPEFMQSPCMFNB SFMBUJWPBEFUFSNJOBSTJTFWVMOFSBFMEFCJEPQSPDFTPZFMEFSFDIPBMBEFGFOTBEFM EFVEPS $POTJEFSBNPT BTÓ RVF FM QMBOUFBNJFOUP EF MB $PSUF $POTUJUVDJPOBM OP EB TPMVDJØOBOVFTUSBQSFHVOUBQSPCMFNBOJMBSFTVFMWFOFHBUJWBNFOUFQFSPCJFO QVFEFTFSFOUFOEJEPDPNPMBQVFSUBEFFOUSBEBBMEFCBUFBDFSDBEFTJFMQSPDFTP NPOJUPSJPFTQSPDFEFOUFQBSBPCMJHBDJPOFTOPEJOFSBSJBT 8. Sesiones de debate del Código General del Proceso en el Congreso de la República y tutela judicial efectiva. &M QSPZFDUP EF MFZ EFM $ØEJHP (FOFSBM EFM 1SPDFTP DPO QVCMJDBDJØO FO FM $POHSFTPEFMB3FQÞCMJDBFONBS[PEFNFEJBOUFHBDFUB$ÈNBSB JODMVÓB FO FM BSUÓDVMP SFMBUJWP B MB QSPDFEFODJB EFM QSPDFTP NPOJUPSJP RVFFTUFTPMPQPEÓBDPOPDFSEFPCMJHBDJPOFTEFUJQPEJOFSBSJPEFUFSNJOBEBTZ FYJHJCMFTRVFGVFSBOEFNÓOJNBPNFOPSDVBOUÓB%JDIBFTUJQVMBDJØOOPSNBUJWB TFNBOUVWPBMPMBSHPEFMQSJNFSZTFHVOEPEFCBUFHBDFUBTZ 4PMP GVF IBTUB FM UFSDFS EFCBUF HBDFUB QSJNFSB QPOFODJB TFOBEP RVF FM QSPDFTP NPOJUPSJP GVF SFGPSNBEP QBSB MJNJUBSTF B PCMJHBDJPOFT FO EJOFSP EFOBUVSBMF[BDPOUSBDUVBMZÞOJDBNFOUFEFNÓOJNBDVBOUÓB%JDIBSFGPSNBTF GVOEBNFOUBFORVFFMQSPDFTPNPOJUPSJPFTUÈEJTF×BEPQBSBiFMDJVEBEBOPEF B QJFw QBSB BTFHVSBS TV BDDFTP B MB BENJOJTUSBDJØO EF KVTUJDJB MP DVBM BUJFOEF BOUF UPEP B MB SFBMJEBE DPMPNCJBOB 1FSP GVF FO FTBT NJTNBT TFTJPOFT EF EFCBUFQBSBMBFYQFEJDJØOEFM$(1FOFM$POHSFTPEFMB3FQÞCMJDBEPOEFTF EFTBUJFOEFRVFMBSFBMJEBEDPMPNCJBOBOPFTUÈEFMJNJUBEBÞOJDBNFOUFBTFDUPSFT DPNFSDJBMFT RVF NBOFKFO DBOUJEBEFT MÓRVJEBT EF EJOFSP 1PS FM DPOUSBSJP FO MBSFBMJEBEDPMPNCJBOBFYJTUFOPUSPTTFDUPSFTQPCMBDJPOBMFTDVZPTDPOnJDUPT QVFEFO OP TFS FYDMVTJWBNFOUF EJOFSBSJPT DPNP CJFO TF EFCJØ BEWFSUJS FO VO DØEJHPEFQSPDFEJNJFOUPDJWJMIFDIPDPOMBQBSUJDJQBDJØOEFNPDSÈUJDBEFUPEPT MPTTFDUPSFTEFMQBÓT %JDIP MP BOUFSJPS MB FYDMVTJØO EF PCMJHBDJPOFT OP EJOFSBSJBT EFM QSPDFTP NPOJUPSJP QPS QBSUF EFM $POHSFTP EF MB 3FQÞCMJDB OP DVFOUB P OP QPTFF VOB (BDFUBQSJNFSBQPOFODJB4FOBEPEFNBS[PEFM $PMPNCJBDVFOUBDPOVOBQPCMBDJØOUPUBMOBDJPOBMEFEFMBDVBMMBQPCMBDJØO SVSBMFTEFMTFHÞOFTUBEÓTUJDBTEFM%"/&BKVOJPEF 62 Revista del Instituto Colombiano de Derecho Procesal t/P Semillero de Derecho Procesal - Universidad Libre, Sede Bogotá BEFDVBEBNPUJWBDJØOZBRVFFMPCKFUJWPEFMQSPDFTPNPOJUPSJPTFWFBGFDUBEP DVBOEP TF FYDMVZFO EF TV DPNQFUFODJB PCMJHBDJPOFT EF EBSFOUSFHBS P IBDFS TJORVFNFEJFVOJOUFSÏTEFQSFDBVDJØOQSVEFODJBPEJTDSFDJØODPNPTÓTVDFEF DPOMBFYDMVTJØOQSPWJTJPOBMEFPCMJHBDJPOFTEFNFOPSPNBZPSDVBOUÓBZRVF QSPWFOHBOEFSFMBDJPOFTFYUSBDPOUSBDUVBMFT-PBOUFSJPSEBEPRVFMBTQSFUFOTJPOFTEFTBUJTGBDDJØOEFPCMJHBDJPOFTEJOFSBSJBTTFQSFTFOUBOFONBZPSNFEJEB SFTQFDUPEFMBTPCMJHBDJPOFTOPEJOFSBSJBTQPSMPRVFOPTFOFDFTJUBQSVEFODJB PEJTDSFDJØOQBSBVOQSPDFTPRVFZBDPOPDFEFMBNBZPSÓBEFPCMJHBDJPOFTUPEB WF[RVFBRVFMRVFQVFEFMPNÈTUBNCJÏOQVFEFMPNFOPT 1FSPFMIFDIPEFRVFMBTPCMJHBDJPOFTOPEJOFSBSJBTTFBONFOPTFODPNQBSBDJØODPOMBTPCMJHBDJPOFTEJOFSBSJBTOPTJHOJmDBRVFMBTQSJNFSBTOPTFBOVOB DBOUJEBE SFQSFTFOUBUJWB Z QPS FMMP EFCBO TFS FYDMVJEBT EFM QSPDFTP NPOJUPSJP EBEP RVF BRVFMMPT BDSFFEPSFT EF PCMJHBDJPOFT EF EBSFOUSFHBS P IBDFS UJFOF UBNCJÏOEFSFDIPBMBUVUFMBKVEJDJBMFGFDUJWBEFTVTDSÏEJUPTMPRVFJNQMJDBQBSB FMJOEJWJEVPDJFSUBTHBSBOUÓBTDPOTJTUFOUFTFO B &YJHJS BOUF MPT KVFDFT FM BNQBSP P FM SFTUBCMFDJNJFOUP EF TVT EFSFDIPT F JOUFSFTFTMFHÓUJNPT C 3FDJCJSEFMPTKVFDFTMBBUFODJØOPQPSUVOBEFTVTQSFUFOTJPOFTFODPOEJDJPOFT EFJHVBMEBE D (P[BSFODPOEJDJPOFTEFJHVBMEBEEFMUSBUBNJFOUPQSPDFTBMBEFDVBEPDPO TVKFDJØOBMPTSJUPTQSFFTUBCMFDJEPTZDPOQMFOBPCTFSWBODJBEFMBTHBSBOUÓBT QSPDFTBMFTQSFWJTUBTFOMBDPOTUJUVDJØOZMBTMFZFT E 0CUFOFSFOUJFNQPSB[POBCMFVOQSPOVODJBNJFOUPKVEJDJBMRVFSFTVFMWBTV SFDMBNBDJØO F "MDBO[BS FO DVBOUP TFB QPTJCMF FM DVNQMJNJFOUP FGFDUJWP EF MB EFDJTJØO KVEJDJBM. 1PTJDJØO TFNFKBOUF QPTFF MB $PSUF $POTUJUVDJPOBM DVBOEP FOUJFOEF RVF FM EFSFDIPBMBDDFTPBMBBENJOJTUSBDJØOEFKVTUJDJBIBDFSFGFSFODJBBMBQPTJCJMJEBE RVFUJFOFUPEPTVKFUPEFTFSQBSUFEFVOQSPDFTPQBSBRVFTFSFTVFMWBOEFGPOEP TVTQSFUFOTJPOFTNFEJBOUFQSPDFEJNJFOUPTBEFDVBEPTJEØOFPTZFGFDUJWPTRVF TFEFTBSSPMMFOFOVOUJFNQPSB[POBCMFDPOMBTHBSBOUÓBTQSPQJBTEFVOEFCJEP QSPDFTPBTÓDPNPFMEFSFDIPBRVFTVCTJTUBFOFMPSEFOKVSÓEJDPVOBHBNBBNQMJB Z TVmDJFOUF EF NFDBOJTNPT KVEJDJBMFT BDDJPOFT Z SFDVSTPT QBSB MB FGFDUJWB SFTPMVDJØOEFMPTDPOnJDUPT. *CÓE $PSUF$POTUJUVDJPOBM4FOUFODJB$EFEFNBZPEF.13PESJHP&TDPCBS(JM issn - tQQt&OFSP+VOJPEFt#PHPUÈ%$$PMPNCJB 63 Tutela judicial efectiva no dineraria en el proceso monitorio colombiano " QBSUJS EF MBT BOUFSJPSFT QSFDJTJPOFT Z BM UFOFS FO DVFOUB RVF FM TJTUFNB KVEJDJBM DPMPNCJBOP BUSBWJFTB QPS VOB TJUVBDJØO DPNQMFKB FO FM FOUFOEJEP EF RVFMPTQSPDFTPTKVEJDJBMFTBDUVBMFTOPTPOQSPDFTPTRVFTFUFSNJOFOEFOUSPEF VOQMB[PSB[POBCMFTFDPMJHFDØNPFM$POHSFTPEFMB3FQÞCMJDBEFKØEFTQSPUFHJEPTEFVONFDBOJTNPÈHJMBMPTDJVEBEBOPTEFPCMJHBDJPOFTOPEJOFSBSJBT&T EFDJSFTUFQFSNJUJØRVFRVJFOGVFSBUJUVMBSEFVOBPCMJHBDJØOEFEBSFOUSFHBSP IBDFSRVFTFBEFNÓOJNBDVBOUÓBZRVFOPDVFOUFDPOVOUÓUVMPFKFDVUJWPQVFEB WFS BGFDUBEP TV EFSFDIP B MB UVUFMB KVEJDJBM FGFDUJWB UPEB WF[ RVF FM QSPDFTP BM RVFQVFEFOBDDFEFSDVBMFTVOQSPDFTPDPHOPTDJUJWPSFTVMUBFOMBNBZPSÓBEF PDBTJPOFTNÈTPOFSPTPRVFFMEFSFDIPNJTNPFOEJTDVTJØORVFTFQSFUFOEFIBDFS WBMFS%FFTUBNBOFSBBMOPFODPOUSBSMPTNFEJPTKVEJDJBMFTBEFDVBEPTFTQPTJCMF RVFTFQSFmFSBSFOVODJBSBFYJHJSFMDVNQMJNJFOUPEFVOBPCMJHBDJØOOPEJOFSBSJB &T QPS FTUP RVF MB FYDMVTJØO EF PCMJHBDJPOFT OP EJOFSBSJBT EFM QSPDFTP NPOJUPSJPEFTBUJFOEFBMBPCTFSWBODJBZDVNQMJNJFOUPEFMPTQSJODJQJPTZWBMPSFT EFGFOEJEPTQPSMB$POTUJUVDJØO1PMÓUJDBMPTDVBMFTOPQVFEFOTFSEFTDPOPDJEPT QPSFMMFHJTMBEPSFOUBOUPMBMJCFSUBEEFDPOmHVSBDJØOMFHJTMBUJWBQPTFFMÓNJUFTP SFTUSJDDJPOFTDPNPMBEJHOJEBEIVNBOBMBKVTUJDJBMBJHVBMEBEZFMPSEFOKVTUPT FOUSFPUSPT 9. Necesidad de un proceso monitorio en Colombia para crear títulos por obligaciones de dar-entregar y hacer. $PNPTFQVFEFJOGFSJSEFMPEJDIPIBTUBBRVÓSFTQFDUPEFMBQSJNFSBQSFHVOUB QSPCMFNBGPSNVMBEBFTUPFTTJFTOFDFTBSJPVOQSPDFTPNPOJUPSJPQBSBPCMJHBDJPOFT EF IBDFS Z EBSFOUSFHBS FO $PMPNCJB IFNPT MMFHBEP B VOB SFTQVFTUB BmSNBUJWB ZB RVF TF QVFEF FWJEFODJBS EFM BOÈMJTJT EFM EFSFDIP DPNQBSBEP QSPQVFTUPDPOSFMBDJØOBMQSPDFTPNPOJUPSJPRVFMBTPCMJHBDJPOFTEFDSÏEJUPEF OBUVSBMF[BEFEBSFOUSFHBSZIBDFSTPOHBSBOUJ[BEBTDPOFMNPOJUPSJPFOEJWFSTPT QBÓTFTEFMNVOEPBMQBSFDFSQPSRVFFOUJFOEFORVFJHVBMQSPUFDDJØOEFMDSÏEJUP SFRVJFSFOMPTBDSFFEPSFTEFPCMJHBDJPOFTEJOFSBSJBTDPNPMPTEFPUSBOBUVSBMF[B 4FHVSBNFOUFMBUJNJEF[RVFTFPCTFSWØQPSQBSUFEFMMFHJTMBEPSDPMPNCJBOP TPCSF FTUF UØQJDP PCFEFDJØ B MP OPWJDJP EF UBM JOTUJUVDJØO QSPDFTBM FO OVFTUSP PSEFOBNJFOUPKVSÓEJDP&TUPEFNVFTUSBRVFFMQSPDFTPNPOJUPSJPQVFEFZEFCF TFSFYUFOEJEPUBOUPQBSBMBDPOTUJUVDJØOEFUÓUVMPTFKFDVUJWPTQPSPCMJHBDJPOFT EFIBDFSPEBSFOUSFHBSBTÓDPNPQBSBFMQBHPEFMBTNJTNBT"EFNÈTQPSOP FYJTUJSSB[POFTDPOTUJUVDJPOBMFTRVFJNQJEBOJNQMFNFOUBSMBQSPQVFTUBRVFFO 64 (BDFUBEFM$POHSFTP1SJNFSEFCBUFDÈNBSBEFMEFNBZPEF Revista del Instituto Colombiano de Derecho Procesal t/P Semillero de Derecho Procesal - Universidad Libre, Sede Bogotá FTUBPDBTJØOGPSNVMBNPTDPNPMPFTRVFOPIBZBDPTBKV[HBEBDPOTUJUVDJPOBM SFTQFDUP EFM DBOPO RVF EJTQPOF MB QSPDFEFODJB EFM QSPDFEJNJFOUP NPOJUPSJP DPMPNCJBOPBVORVFTFIBZBSFWJTBEPFO4FOUFODJB$EFFOSB[ØOB RVFOPGVFPCKFUPEFFTUVEJPMPBRVÓFYQVFTUPFOUFOEFNPTJHVBMNFOUFOFDFTBSJP RVFTFEFBQFSUVSBBMBMJNJUBEBQSPDFEFODJBEFMQSPDFTPNPOJUPSJPFOMPUPDBOUF BMBTPCMJHBDJPOFTPCKFUPEFEPDVNFOUBDJØO 7BMHB TF×BMBS RVF TF SFBMJ[Ø VOB CÞTRVFEB EF EBUPT FTUBEÓTUJDPT DPODSFUPT FOMPTRVFTFQVEJFSBDPOTUBUBSMBEFNBOEBEFMBTPDJFEBEDPMPNCJBOBSFTQFDUP EF QSPDFTPT EFDMBSBUJWPT EF NÓOJNB DVBOUÓB DPO FM QSPQØTJUP EF EPDVNFOUBS PCMJHBDJPOFT OP EJOFSBSJBT FNQFSP MPT ÞOJDPT DPNQFOEJPT EF TFOUFODJBT RVF TFIBMMBSPOGVFSPOFODPOUSBEPTFOMBTSFMBUPSÓBTEFMB$PSUF4VQSFNBEF+VTUJDJB ZMPT5SJCVOBMFT4VQFSJPSFTEF%JTUSJUP+VEJDJBMMPTDVBMFTTPMBNFOUFDPOPDFO EF SFDVSTPT EF DBTBDJØO Z BQFMBDJØO EF BTVOUPT OFDFTBSJBNFOUF EF NBZPS DVBOUÓB"EFNÈTMPTKV[HBEPTNVOJDJQBMFTMPTDVBMFTDPOPDFOEFMPTQSPDFTPT EFNÓOJNBDVBOUÓBEFNBOFSBFYDMVTJWBJNQPSUBOUFTQBSBOVFTUSPUSBCBKP OP DMBTJmDBOFOTVTFTUBEÓTUJDBTFTUBDMBTFEFBTVOUPTEFNBOFSBJOEFQFOEJFOUFTJOP RVFMPTBHMPNFSBOQPSUJQPMPHÓBTHFOÏSJDBTMPRVFIJ[PJNQPTJCMFEFNPTUSBSEF NBOFSBGBDUVBMMBOFDFTJEBETPDJBMEFOVFTUSBQSPQVFTUB4JOFNCBSHPQBSUJNPT EF FOUFOEFS WÈMJEB Z SFBM MB BmSNBDJØO TJO NVFTUSBT DPODSFUBT EF FTUVEJPT FTUBEÓTUJDPT IFDIBQPSFM$POHSFTPEFMB3FQÞCMJDBBMFYQPOFSMPTNPUJWPTEFM QSPZFDUPEFMFZRVFmOBMNFOUFUFSNJOØFOMPRVFIPZTFDPOPDFDPNPFM$ØEJHP (FOFSBMEFM1SPDFTPFOFMFOUFOEJEPEFRVFFMDJVEBEBOPDPNÞOSFRVFSÓBEFVO QSPDFTPNPOJUPSJPQBSBEPDVNFOUBSTVTSÏEJUPTEJOFSBSJPTEFNÓOJNBDVBOUÓB IBTUB4.-.7 QBSBFYUFOEFSMBDPOBQPZPEFMBTSFHMBTEFMBFYQFSJFODJB DPNPUFTJTWÈMJEBFOFMDBNQPEFMBTPCMJHBDJPOFTOPEJOFSBSJBT &OTVNBBÞODPOFMJNQBTFZBJOEJDBEPDPOTJEFSBNPTDPOBQPZPFOMBJOWFTUJHBDJØOEPDVNFOUBMSFBMJ[BEBRVFDVBMRVJFSQFSTPOBBDSFFEPSBEFPCMJHBDJPOFT EFDSÏEJUPEJOFSBSJBTPEFEBSFOUSFHBSPIBDFSTJOUÓUVMPFKFDVUJWPEFCFUFOFS MB QPTJCJMJEBE EF BDDFEFS BM QSPDFTP NPOJUPSJP DVBOEP QSFUFOEB EPDVNFOUBS QSFTUBDJPOFTEJTUJOUBTBMBTPUPSHBEBTFOTVNBTEJOFSBSJBTZUFOFSDPNPEFSSPUFSP VOBKVTUJDJBFYQFEJUBDPOBDDFTPQBSBUPEPTZDPOVOBTPMVDJØOBMDPOnJDUPFO VO QMB[P SB[POBCMF -P BOUFSJPS QPSRVF TJO RVFSFS SFEVOEBS TPCSF FM BTVOUP SFTVMUBEFJOFYPSBCMFJNQPSUBODJBDPOUBSDPOQSPDFTPTÈHJMFTZNPEFSOPTRVF SFTVFMWBOQSPOUBNFOUFMBTDPOUSPWFSTJBTRVFTFTVTDJUBOFOUSFMPTDJVEBEBOPT QPSTVQVFTUPTJOEFTNFESPEFMBTHBSBOUÓBTQSPDFTBMFTEFMPTMMBNBEPTBKVJDJPT -PT KV[HBEPT DPOTVMUBEPT SFMBDJPOBO EF NBOFSB HFOFSBM MPT QSPDFTPT PSEJOBSJPT FKFDVUJWPTBHSBSJPTBCSFWJBEPTWFSCBMFTFOUSFPUSPTRVFUJFOFOCBKPTVDPOPDJNJFOUP 4FQVFEFODPOTVMUBSMBTFTUBEÓTUJDBTSFQPSUBEBTQPSDBEBEFTQBDIPKVEJDJBMFO$PMPNCJB FO FM TJHVJFOUF MJOL IUUQTXXXSBNBKVEJDJBMHPWDPQPSUBMTPCSFMBSBNBFTUBEJTUJDBTKVEJDJBMFT issn - tQQt&OFSP+VOJPEFt#PHPUÈ%$$PMPNCJB 65 Tutela judicial efectiva no dineraria en el proceso monitorio colombiano 10. Modificación del proceso monitorio para la procedencia de obligaciones de dar-entregar y hacer. $PO FM PCKFUJWP EF EBS SFTQVFTUB BM JOUFSSPHBOUF QMBOUFBEP SFGFSFOUF B EFUFSNJOBSTJMBFTUSVDUVSBEFMBDUVBMQSPDFTPNPOJUPSJPTVGSJSÓBBMHVOBNPEJmDBDJØOBMJOUFHSBSMBTPCMJHBDJPOFTEFEBSDPTBTNVFCMFTVPCMJHBDJPOFTEFIBDFS BM SFnFYJPOBS TPCSF FM BTVOUP IFNPT DPODMVJEP RVF TPO EPT MPT FWFOUVBMFT DBNCJPTRVFEFCFSÓBTVGSJSFMQSPDFEJNJFOUPEFMQSPDFTPNPOJUPSJPDPMPNCJBOP FMQSJNFSPSBEJDBFOFMUJFNQPUÏSNJOPKVEJDJBM RVFMFEFCFSÈPUPSHBSFMKVF[BM EFVEPSQBSBRVFFTUFQBHVFPDVNQMBMBPCMJHBDJØOFMTFHVOEPPCFEFDFBQFSNJUJS RVFFOMBFKFDVDJØOEFMBTFOUFODJBBDPOUJOVBDJØOEFMEFDMBSBUJWPFTQFDJBMZB USBWÏTEFMQSPDFEJNJFOUPFTUBCMFDJEPFOFMBSUÓDVMPEFM$ØEJHP(FOFSBMEFM 1SPDFTP $ ( 1 Z FO QBSUJDVMBS FO FM NPNFOUP EF GPSNVMBS FM EFNBOEBOUF MBTPMJDJUVEEFRVFIBCMBMBOPSNBUJWBFODPNFOUPFMBDSFFEPSQVFEBBDVNVMBS QSFUFOTJPOFTDPOFMQSPQØTJUPEFRVFJOJDJBEBMBFKFDVDJØOEFMBTFOUFODJBQPS MB PCMJHBDJØO in natura Z FTUB OP TFB IPOSBEB QPS FM EFVEPS FM QSPDFTP OP TF UFSNJOFTJOPRVFTFDPCSFOBIPSBMPTQFSKVJDJPTDPNQFOTBUPSJPT -BSB[ØOEFMBQSJNFSBNPEJmDBDJØOQSPQVFTUBQBSUFEFMBOBUVSBMF[BEFMBT PCMJHBDJPOFTEFEBSDPTBTEJTUJOUBTBEJOFSPZIBDFSQVFTTVDFEFRVFFOPDBTJPOFT MBQSFTUBDJØOQVFEFUPNBSNÈTUJFNQPRVFFMFTUJQVMBEPFOFMQSPDFTPNPOJUPSJP FOSB[ØOEFMBTDBMJEBEFTRVFEFCFDPOUFOFSMBPCMJHBDJØO"TÓMPIBFOUFOEJEPFM $(1BMFTUJQVMBSRVFFMQBHPEFPCMJHBDJPOFTFOFMQSPDFTPFKFDVUJWP EFEBS VPCMJHBDJPOFTEFIBDFSTFIBSÈFOFMQMB[PQSVEFODJBMPSB[POBCMFRVFFMKVF[ EFUFSNJOF. %FMPBOUFSJPSTFEFTQSFOEFRVFFOFMQSPDFTPNPOJUPSJPFMQMB[PQBSBRVFFM EFVEPSQBHVFRVFEBBEJTDSFDJPOBMJEBEEFMKVF[DPOCBTFFOTVCVFOTBCFSZDPO BUFODJØOBMQSJODJQJPEFQSPQPSDJPOBMJEBEZSB[POBCJMJEBE &TJNQPSUBOUFBDMBSBSRVFFMQMB[PRVFPUPSHVFFMKVF[EJGFSFOUFBMPTEÓBT FTUJQVMBEPT BDUVBMNFOUF TPMP EFCFSÈ PQFSBS DVBOEP FM EFVEPS WBZB B DVNQMJS DPOMBPCMJHBDJØOFTEFDJSDVBOEPWBZBBIPOSBSMBQSFTUBDJØOQVFTQBSBRVFTF FOUJFOEBRVFFMEFNBOEBEPHVBSEØTJMFODJPPQBSBRVFFTUFTFQVFEBPQPOFSTF TFHVJSÈODPOUBOEPMPTEÓBTFTUJQVMBEPTQPSMFZ 1BSBNBZPSDMBSJEBEBDFSDBEFMPTNPNFOUPTQSPDFTBMFTFORVFTFEFCFTVSUJS EJDIB NPEJmDBDJØO IFNPT HSBmDBEP FM QSPDFTP NPOJUPSJP NFEJBOUF VO NBQB DPODFQUVBMZTF×BMBEPFOÏMMBÞOJDBSFGPSNBOFDFTBSJB 66 -FZ EF +VMJP i1PS NFEJP EF MB DVBM TF FYQJEF FM $ØEJHP (FOFSBM EFM 1SPDFTPZTFEJDUBOPUSBTEJTQPTJDJPOFTw1VCMJDBEBFOFM%JBSJP0mDJBM/PEF EFKVMJPEFBSUÓDVMPTZ Revista del Instituto Colombiano de Derecho Procesal t/P 1SPDFTP .POJUPSJPFO $PMPNCJB $POMPTSFRVJTJUPTRVF EJTQPOFFMBSUÓDVMP EFM$(1 1SFTFOUBDJØOEF MBEFNBOEB EÓBT /PUJmDBDJØO QFSTPOBM 1BHPEF PCMJHBDJØO 0QPOFSTF (VBSEBS TJMFODJP &TFUÏSNJOPRVFEBBEJTDSFDJPOBMJEBE EFMKVF[EFQFOEJFOEPEFMBDMBTFEF PCMJHBDJØO4PMPFOMPTFWFOUPTFORVF TFRVJFSBDVNQMJS &OPCMJHBDJPOFTEFEBSDPTBTEJGFSFOUFT EFEJOFSPZIBDFSFMUÏSNJOPQBSB DVNQMJSMBPCMJHBDJØODBNCJB 3FRVFSJNJFOUP EFQBHP "ENJUJS*OBENJUJS 4VCTBOBS 1BSDJBM 1SPDFTP WFSCBMTVNBSJP QPSMBQBSUF PCKFUBEB 4FOUFODJB QPSMBQBSUF OPPCKFUBEB 1SPDFTP WFSCBM TVNBSJP "VEJFODJB EFM $(1 1BSBPQPOFSTFPRVFTFEÏQPSEBEP FMTJMFODJPEFMEFNBOEBEPTFDPOUBSBO JHVBMNFOUFMPTEÓBT 5FSNJOBFM QSPDFTPQPS QBHP 5PUBM EÓBT QBSBQFEJS QSVFCBT 4FOUFODJB DPOTUJUVUJWB EFUÓUVMP FKFDVUJWP Semillero de Derecho Procesal - Universidad Libre, Sede Bogotá issn - tQQt&OFSP+VOJPEFt#PHPUÈ%$$PMPNCJB 67 Tutela judicial efectiva no dineraria en el proceso monitorio colombiano %FPUSPMBEPSFTQFDUPEFMBTFHVOEBQSPQVFTUBEFNPEJmDBDJØOQBSUJNPTEF BEWFSUJSRVFFOFMFWFOUPFORVFTFDPOTUJUVZBOUÓUVMPTFKFDVUJWPTQPSPCMJHBDJPOFT EFEBSFOUSFHBSZPIBDFSDPOMBVUJMJ[BDJØOEFMQSPDFTPNPOJUPSJPZFMBDSFFEPS BM IBDFS VTP EFM BSUÓDVMP EFM $ØEJHP (FOFSBM EFM 1SPDFTP OP QVFEB TJOP iTPMJDJUBSMBFKFDVDJØODPOCBTFFOMBTFOUFODJBwFOUBOUPGPSNVMBEBMBTPMJDJUVE iFMKVF[MJCSBSÈNBOEBNJFOUPFKFDVUJWPEFBDVFSEPDPOMPTF×BMBEPFOMBQBSUF SFTPMVUJWB EF MB TFOUFODJBw 4VSHF FOUPODFT FM QSPCMFNB QBSB FM BDSFFEPS FO DVBOUPBMBBQMJDBDJØOEFMBTNJTNBTOPSNBTEFMQSPDFTPFKFDVUJWPJOJDJBEPQPS TFNFKBOUFTPCMJHBDJPOFTMPRVFOFDFTBSJBNFOUFBMQSFTFOUBSTFMBJNQPTJCJMJEBE EFDVNQMJNJFOUPEFMBQSFTUBDJØOHFOFSBSÓBMBUFSNJOBDJØOEFMQSPDFEJNJFOUP EFFKFDVDJØOEFMBTFOUFODJBBMOPQPEFSBDVNVMBSTFQSFUFOTJPOFTTVCTJEJBSJBT EJSJHJEBTBMQBHPEFMBQSFTUBDJØOEFIBDFSZEBSFOUSFHBSFOTVFRVJWBMFOUFFO EJOFSPTVCSPHBEPQFDVOJBSJP &OFTFPSEFOEFJEFBTTFSÈOFDFTBSJPRVFFMMFHJTMBEPSJODMVZBFOFMJODJTP UFSDFSP EFM BSUÓDVMP EFM $ØEJHP (FOFSBM EFM 1SPDFTP MB QPTJCJMJEBE QBSB FM BDSFFEPS EF JOJDJBS MB FKFDVDJØO EF MB TFOUFODJB EFM QSPDFTP NPOJUPSJP EF DPOGPSNJEBEDPOMPSFHMBEPFOFMBSUÓDVMPEFMBNJTNBDPEJmDBDJØOQFSPFTUB EFCFQFSNJUJSMFJODMVJSFOMBTPMJDJUVEQSFUFOTJPOFTEJSJHJEBTBTFSTVCTJEJBSJBT QBSBRVFFOFMFWFOUPFORVFFMEFVEPSOPIPOSFMBPCMJHBDJØOQSJNJHFOJBFM QSPDFTP OP TF UFSNJOF DPNP MP JOEJDB FM BSUÓDVMP EFM $ØEJHP (FOFSBM EFM 1SPDFTPTJOPRVFDPOUJOÞFDPOMBFKFDVDJØOQPSQFSKVJDJPT &OTÓOUFTJTTPOEPTMPTDBNCJPTRVFTFHVSBNFOUFTVGSJSÈFMQSPDFTPNPOJUPSJP VOB WF[ OVFTUSB MFHJTMBDJØO JODMVZB MB DPOTUJUVDJØO EF UÓUVMPT FKFDVUJWPT QPS PCMJHBDJPOFTOPEJOFSBSJBTFMQSJNFSPTFSFmFSFBMUÏSNJOPKVEJDJBMQBSBRVFFM EFVEPSQVFEBIPOSBSTVPCMJHBDJØOin naturaUJFNQPRVFEFCFSÈTFSFTUBCMFDJEP QPSFMKVF[ZRVFOPNPEJmDBFMUÏSNJOPMFHBMEFMPTEÓBTFOMPTEFNÈTFWFOUPT RVFTFQVFEFOQSFTFOUBSFOFTUFQSPDFTPDPNPMPTPOFMUÏSNJOPQBSBBTJHOBS MBT DPOTFDVFODJBT KVSÓEJDBT QPS IBCFS HVBSEBEP TJMFODJP FM EFNBOEBEP P FM QFSUJOFOUFQBSBQSPQPOFSFYDFQDJPOFTEFNÏSJUPPMPRVFFTMPNJTNPFKFSDFS TVEFSFDIPEFEFGFOTB 'JOBMNFOUFFMTFHVOEPQVOUPQSPDFEJNFOUBMFOFMRVFEFCFSÈNPEJmDBSTF FM QSPDFTP NPOJUPSJP FT FM DPOUFOJEP Z QSPDFEFODJB EF MB TPMJDJUVE RVF EFCF QSFTFOUBSTFQBSBJOJDJBSFMQSPDFTPFKFDVUJWPBDPOUJOVBDJØOEFMEFDMBSBUJWPFO FM FOUFOEJEP FO RVF EJDIB TPMJDJUVE QFSNJUB JODMVJS QSFUFOTJPOFT TVCTJEJBSJBT SFTQFDUPEFMBPCMJHBDJØOEFEBSFOUSFHBSZIBDFSSFDPOPDJEBFOMBTFOUFODJBZ FOQBSUJDVMBSFOTVFRVJWBMFOUFFOEJOFSPDPOFMQSPQØTJUPEFRVFBEFMBOUBEP FM QSPDFTP EF FKFDVDJØO FTUF OP TF WFB GSVTUSBEP BM NPNFOUP EF FYJHJSTF FM DVNQMJNJFOUPEFMBQSFTUBDJØOBMEFVEPSZVOBWF[OPIBZBTJEPIPOSBEBFMKVF[ OPUFOHBPUSBPQDJØOTJOPMBEFUFSNJOBSFMQSPDFTP$POUPEPMPBOUFSJPSOPT QSPQPOFNPTEPUBSBMBDSFFEPSEFIFSSBNJFOUBTQBSBRVFBMJOJDJBSMBFKFDVDJØO 68 Revista del Instituto Colombiano de Derecho Procesal t/P Semillero de Derecho Procesal - Universidad Libre, Sede Bogotá EFTVUÓUVMPFKFDVUJWPTFOUFODJBQVFEBBDVNVMBSQSFUFOTJPOFTFOMBTPMJDJUVEDPO FMQSPQØTJUPEFJOJDJBSMBFKFDVDJØOEFQFSKVJDJPTEFNBOFSBTVCTJEJBSJBVOBWF[ TFIBHBJNQPTJCMFMBFKFDVDJØOQSJODJQBM 11. Aplicación del proceso monitorio regulado por el Código General del Proceso con ocasión de obligaciones de dar-entregar y hacer a través de subrogados pecuniarios. 4JCJFOFTDJFSUPRVFFMQSPDFTPNPOJUPSJPFO$PMPNCJBJODPSQPSBEPQPSFM $ØEJHP(FOFSBMEFM1SPDFTPOPDPOUFNQMBMBQPTJCJMJEBEEFDPOTUJUVJSUÓUVMPT FKFDVUJWPTQSPWFOJFOUFTEFPCMJHBDJPOFTEFEBSFOUSFHBSZIBDFSDPOTJEFSBNPT RVF FT WJBCMF TV VUJMJ[BDJØO QBSB MB DSFBDJØO EF FTUPT FO MPT FWFOUPT FO RVF EJDIBTPCMJHBDJPOFTTFBOGÓTJDBPNPSBMNFOUFJNQPTJCMFT$$BSU -P BOUFSJPSTJTFUJFOFFODVFOUBFMUSBUBNJFOUPRVFFMMFHJTMBEPSMFEBBMJOUFSJPS EFM QSPDFTP FKFDVUJWP B MBT PCMJHBDJPOFT EJTUJOUBT EF MBT EJOFSBSJBT $PNP TF WFSÈUBNCJÏOFTQPTJCMFSFQMJDBSEJDIPUSBUBNJFOUPFOMPTQSPDFTPTEFDPOPDJNJFOUP -BFTFODJBEFMOFHPDJPKVSÓEJDPFTMBSFMBDJØOEPOEFFMEFVEPSFTUÈPCMJHBEP BEFUFSNJOBEPDPNQPSUBNJFOUPIBDFSOPIBDFSEBS ZFMBDSFFEPSFTCFOFmDJBSJP EF FTUF BRVÓ MB MFZ FT FM NFEJP DPBDUJWP RVF FO DBTP EF SFRVFSJSTF TFSWJSÈQBSBTBUJTGBDFSMBQSFTUBDJØOin natura,EFTFSQPTJCMFTVDVNQMJNJFOUP PFOEJOFSPDPOBZVEBEFMTVCSPHBEPQFDVOJBSJPEFMBQSFTUBDJØOQFSKVJDJPT DPNQFOTBUPSJPT "TÓ MBT DPTBT FO FM NPNFOUP FO RVF FM EFVEPS OP DVNQMB MB QSFTUBDJØO QBDUBEB TF WF TPNFUJEP B TFS FKFDVUBEP GPS[PTBNFOUF QBSB FM DVNQMJNJFOUP EF MB NJTNB QPS QBSUF EFM BDSFFEPS &TUP QPSRVF MB PCMJHBDJØO KVSÓEJDB USBF JOTFSUP FM DPNQPOFOUF EF DPBDDJØO RVF EF OP FYJTUJS EFKBSÓB TPMBNFOUF B MB CVFOBWPMVOUBEEFMEFVEPSFMDVNQMJNJFOUPEFMBPCMJHBDJØOZFTUBSÓBNPTFO FM DBNQP EF MBT PCMJHBDJPOFT OBUVSBMFT TPMP TVTDFQUJCMFT EF DVNQMJNJFOUP WPMVOUBSJP SB[ØO QPS MB RVF FM &TUBEP MF PUPSHB BM BDSFFEPS MB GBDVMUBE EF WBMFSTFEFNFEJPTQBSBDPNQFMFSPGPS[BSBMEFVEPSSFOVFOUFBQBHBSZDPOFMMP FWJUBSFMJODVNQMJNJFOUPQFSFOOFEFMEFVEPS $PNQBSUJNPT BTÓ MBT BmSNBDJPOFT IFDIBT QPS FM QSPGFTPS 6MJTFT $BOPTB DVBOEP FOTF×B RVF iMB QPTJCJMJEBE EF FYJHJS FM DVNQMJNJFOUP P FKFDVDJØO FT VOBDBSBDUFSÓTUJDBGVOEBNFOUBMEFMBPCMJHBDJØORVFMFEBDBUFHPSÓBUBOUPFOFM DBNQPNPSBMDPNPFOFMKVSÓEJDP1BSBFMFGFDUPMPTPSEFOBNJFOUPTQSPDFTBMFT EFCFOHBSBOUJ[BSVOBUVUFMBKVEJDJBMFGFDUJWBBMBDSFFEPSQPSRVFTJFMEFVEPS issn - tQQt&OFSP+VOJPEFt#PHPUÈ%$$PMPNCJB 69 Tutela judicial efectiva no dineraria en el proceso monitorio colombiano BTVBOUPKPQVFEFEFKBSEFDVNQMJSOPFYJTUFVOWÓODVMPPCMJHBUPSJPTJOPVOB TJNQMFMJCFSBMJEBEVOBDPOUJOHFODJBEFCVFOBWPMVOUBEPHFOFSPTJEBEw. 1PSDPOTJHVJFOUFMPTFMFNFOUPTFTFODJBMFTEFMBPCMJHBDJØOFTUPFTFMEÏCJUP Z MB SFTQPOTBCJMJEBE HFOFSBO FO FM EFVEPS FM UFNPS EF WFSTF FYQVFTUP B MBT BDDJPOFTKVEJDJBMFTQPSQBSUFEFMBDSFFEPS%FJHVBMGPSNBPUPSHBOBFTUFÞMUJNP MBUSBORVJMJEBEEFFODPOUSBSVOBNQBSPBTVTJOUFSFTFTin naturaPNFEJBOUF FMTVCSPHBEPQFDVOJBSJPZEFQPEFSDPCSBSMPTQFSKVJDJPTEFSJWBEPTEFMJODVNQMJNJFOUP #SJO[ GVF FM QSJNFSP FO QMBOUFBS MB UFPSÓB EFM EÏCJUP Z MB SFTQPOTBCJMJEBE DPNP FMFNFOUPT GVODJPOBMFT EF MB PCMJHBDJØO MB SFTQPOTBCJMJEBE QBUSJNPOJBM EFM EFVEPS FT MP GVOEBNFOUBM FO MB SFMBDJØO DSFEJUJDJB Z EB FM EFSFDIP BM BDSFFEPS EF QFSTFHVJS FTF QBUSJNPOJP FO DBTP EF JODVNQMJNJFOUP %FTEF FM %FSFDIP +VTUJOJBOP TF BCSJØ MB QPTJCJMJEBE QBSB FM BDSFFEPS EF EFNBOEBS MB FKFDVDJØOFTQFDÓmDBZFOOVFTUSP%FSFDIPBDUVBMFTUBQPTJCJMJEBETFFODVFOUSB BDPNQB×BEBEFMBGBDVMUBEEFRVFTFDVNQMBMBPCMJHBDJØOEFEJGFSFOUFTGPSNBT. 'SFOUF BM JODVNQMJNJFOUP EFM EFVEPS EF PCMJHBDJPOFT OP EJOFSBSJBT OP TPMBNFOUF TVCTJTUF MB PCMJHBDJØO DPO MB NJTNB QSFTUBDJØO EF TFS BÞO GBDUJCMF TVFKFDVDJØOTJOPRVFUBNCJÏOQFSEVSBMBPCMJHBDJØODPOWFSUJEBFOEJOFSPFO PUSBTQBMBCSBTFMBDSFFEPSUJFOFMBQPTJCJMJEBEEFQSFUFOEFSEFTEFVOQSJODJQJP FMFRVJWBMFOUFQFDVOJBSJPBOUFFMGSBDBTPPMBEJmDVMUBEEFMBFKFDVDJØOin natura. &OMPTPSEFOBNJFOUPTEFUSBEJDJØOSPNBOJTUBMBFKFDVDJØOFTQFDÓmDBDPOTUJUVZF VOBQSJNFSBPQDJØOOBUVSBMNFOUFEFTEFRVFTFBGBDUJCMFZQFSTJTUBFMJOUFSÏT EFMBDSFFEPSFOFMEÏCJUPQSJNBSJP. 1PSMPBOUFSJPSFTOBUVSBMRVFFM%FSFDIPTFQSFPDVQFQPSMBUVUFMBBEFDVBEB EF MPT EFSFDIPT EF DSÏEJUP Z RVF FTUÏ BUFOUP B QSPQPSDJPOBS BM BDSFFEPS MPT JOTUSVNFOUPTØQUJNPTQBSBTVTBUJTGBDDJØODBCBM&OFTUFTFOUJEPOPUJFOFQPS RVÏFYUSB×BSMBUFOEFODJBBDPOTJEFSBSEFBOUFNBOPMBQPTJCJMJEBEEFFKFDVDJØO DPBDUJWBFTQFDÓmDBEFQSFTUBDJØOiFMQSPDFTPEFCFEBSBRVJFOUJFOFVOEFSFDIP UPEPBRVFMMPZQSFDJTBNFOUFBRVFMMPRVFUJFOFEFSFDIPBPCUFOFSFODVBOUPFMMP TFBQSÈDUJDBNFOUFQPTJCMFw"TÓDPNPFTFTUBMBNBOFSBOBUVSBMEFTBUJTGBDFSFM JOUFSÏTEFMBDSFFEPSUBNCJÏOTFQVFEFTBUJTGBDFSMBPCMJHBDJØOQPSFMFRVJWBMFOUF QFDVOJBSJPEFMBDPTBPEFMTFSWJDJPFORVÏDPOTJTUFFMPCKFUPEFMBSFMBDJØO $"/04"46«3&;0QDJUQ #"3"44*-6%07*$05FPSJBHFOFSBMFEFMMFPCCMJHB[JPOJ*DJUQZT )*/&45304"0QDJUQ 1SJODJQJPTTPCSFMPTDPOUSBUPTDPNFSDJBMFTJOUFSOBDJPOBMFTEF6OJESPJU3PNBQ ZTTZZTT*%#PHPUÈ *CÓE 70 Revista del Instituto Colombiano de Derecho Procesal t/P Semillero de Derecho Procesal - Universidad Libre, Sede Bogotá -BSB[ØORVFOPTMMFWBBSFBMJ[BSVOFTUVEJPUBOUPEFMBTPCMJHBDJPOFTZDPO FTUPEFMPTEFCFSFTZEFSFDIPTEFRVJFOFTGPSNBOQBSUFEFVOBSFMBDJØOKVSÓEJDB BTÓDPNPEFMPTNFEJPTQPSMPTDVBMFTTFQVFEFOIBDFSFYJHJCMFTMBTQSFTUBDJPOFT DPOUFOJEBTFOMBPCMJHBDJØOPCFEFDFBMJOUFSÏTEFRVFFTUBTPCMJHBDJPOFTDSFEJUJDJBTOPTFDPOWJFSUBOFOPCMJHBDJPOFTNFSBNFOUFOBUVSBMFTPRVFÞOJDBNFOUF QVFEBOTFSSFDPOPDJEBTFOFMFTDFOBSJPEFMQSPDFTPEFDMBSBUJWP $MBSB FT OVFTUSB JOUFODJØO EF FWJUBS RVF MBT PCMJHBDJPOFT RVF TVSHFO FOUSF MPTQBSUJDVMBSFTDPOQSFTUBDJPOFTEFEBSFOUSFHBSZIBDFSEFTQSPWJTUBTEFUÓUVMP FKFDVUJWPTFDPOWJFSUBOFOPCMJHBDJPOFTEFDPNQMFKBDPOTUJUVDJØORVFMFTJNQJEB BDVEJS BOUF FM QSPDFTP FKFDVUJWP QBSB RVF TF MFT TBUJTGBHB TV EFSFDIP Z RVF MB ÞOJDB PQDJØO DPOTFDVFOUF TFB MB EF BDVEJS B VO QSPDFTP EFDMBSBUJWP B UPEBT MVDFTNÈTFYUFOTPPOFSPTPZEFTHBTUBOUFQBSBRVJFOOPDVFOUBDPOMPTNFEJPT FDPOØNJDPTZEFUJFNQPOFDFTBSJPTFOFTUFUJQPEFQSPDFTP1PSMPBOUFSJPSFT RVFFONVDIPTEFFTUPTDBTPTTFQSFmFSFBCBOEPOBSFMEFSFDIPEFBDDJØOZEFKBS RVFMBPCMJHBDJØORVFEFBMBMJCFSBMJEBEEFMEFVEPS 1BSBMPTDJVEBEBOPTRVFTFFODVFOUSBOFOFTUBTJUVBDJØOGVFQFOTBEPFMQSPDFTP NPOJUPSJP RVF MMFHB DPNP VO QSPDFTP RVF HBSBOUJ[B FM DSÏEJUP Z NBYJNJ[B MB UVUFMBKVEJDJBMFGFDUJWBBMFOUFOEFSRVFFMDVNQMJNJFOUPEFMBTPCMJHBDJPOFTUJFOF HSBOSFMFWBODJBTPDJBMZFDPOØNJDB&OQBMBCSBTEF(BMHBOPiDVBOEPNBZPSTFB FMQPSDFOUBKFEFMBTPCMJHBDJPOFTDVNQMJEBTUBOUPNBZPSTFSÈFMCFOFmDJPQBSB UPEPFMTJTUFNBFDPOØNJDPZBRVFDVNQMJSMBTPCMJHBDJPOFTTJHOJmDBJODSFNFOUBS MB DJSDVMBDJØO EF MB SJRVF[B BVNFOUBS MB QSPEVDDJØO EF CJFOFT Z TFSWJDJPT FO VOBQBMBCSBDPOUSJCVJSBMEFTBSSPMMPFDPOØNJDPw&OÞMUJNBTQPSRVFi<M>BQB[ TPDJBM Z MB DPOWJWFODJB DJVEBEBOB QBDÓmDB UBNCJÏO UJFOFO DPNP QSFTVQVFTUP OFDFTBSJPMBFYJTUFODJBEFVOBNQBSPEFKVTUJDJBRVFHBSBOUJDFVONFDBOJTNP FmDJFOUFZFGFDUJWPFOMBTPMVDJØOEFMBTDPOUSPWFSTJBTw. 1FSPFMBNQBSPEFMQSPDFTPNPOJUPSJPFO$PMPNCJBTFDPODSFUBIBTUBBIPSB BMBTPCMJHBDJPOFTEJOFSBSJBTZFWJUBBTÓRVFRVJFOFTGVFSBOUJUVMBSFTEFDSÏEJUPT DPO QSFTUBDJPOFT EF EBS Z IBDFS QVEJFSBO IBDFS FGFDUJWPT TVT EFSFDIPT FO FM QSPDFTPNPOJUPSJPFTEFDJSHFOFSBRVFBMHVOBTEFFTUBTEFVEBTOPDPOUFOJEBT FOVOUÓUVMPFKFDVUJWPTFWVFMWBOFWFOUVBMNFOUFPCMJHBDJPOFTOBUVSBMFTUPEBWF[ RVFBDVEJSBMQSPDFTPEFDMBSBUJWPQVFEFSFTVMUBSMFTNÈTPOFSPTPRVFFMEFSFDIP FOEJTDVTJØO 1PSMPBOUFSJPSTFQSFUFOEFRVFFMQSPDFTPNPOJUPSJPTFBNQMÓFBMBTPCMJHBDJPOFT DSFEJUJDJBT EF EBSFOUSFHBS Z IBDFS Z QSPUFKB FM EFSFDIP RVF UJFOF UPEP BDSFFEPS EF RVF MF TFB TBUJTGFDIP TV EFSFDIP 4JO FNCBSHP NJFOUSBT TF EF MB )*/&45304"0QDJUQ (BDFUBEFoBDUBEFDPNJTJØO4FOBEPBCSJMEF issn - tQQt&OFSP+VOJPEFt#PHPUÈ%$$PMPNCJB 71 Tutela judicial efectiva no dineraria en el proceso monitorio colombiano SFGPSNBMFHJTMBUJWBRVFTFEFNBOEBTFMFEFCFSÈQFSNJUJSBMBDSFFEPSQSFUFOEFS FM DVNQMJNJFOUP EF MB PCMJHBDJØO OP EJOFSBSJB QPS NFEJP EF TVCSPHBEPT QFDVOJBSJPTDVBOEPMBPCMJHBDJØOJOJDJBMFTUÏFOJNQPTJCJMJEBEEFDVNQMJSTFBTÓ TFBDUÞBEFBDVFSEPDPOMPFTUJQVMBEPFOFM$ØEJHP(FOFSBMEFM1SPDFTPFOMP SFGFSFOUFBMBOBUVSBMF[BEJOFSBSJBEFEJDIPQSPDFTP &M GVOEBNFOUP EF OVFTUSB QSPQVFTUB MP FODPOUSBNPT FO MP FYQVFTUP QPS 'FSOBOEP)JOFTUSPTBDVBOEPBmSNBRVF FT DPNQSFOTJCMF RVF FO EFUFSNJOBEBT DJSDVOTUBODJBT QBSUJDVMBSFT P FO VO BNCJFOUFZFOVOBEFUFSNJOBEBUSBEJDJØOEFEFSFDIPTFBQSFGFSJCMFJOEJWJEVBMNFOUFPQPSFMTJTUFNBBDPOWFSTJØOEFMBQSFTUBDJØOin naturaBVOBTVNB EFEJOFSPZBTÓFMNFDBOJTNPQSPDFTBMIBMMFHBEPBTFSTFODJMMPZÈHJMQBSBRVF MBTBUJTGBDDJØOEFMEFVEPSTFMPHSFFOEJOFSPEÏCJUPTFDVOEBSJPTVCSPHBEP QFDVOJBSJP <y>FMIFDIPEFRVFFMEJOFSPTFBFMDPNÞOEFOPNJOBEPSEFUPEPT MPTWBMPSFTQBUSJNPOJBMFTZEFRVFTFBDØNPEPSFNJUJSTFBÏMQBSBEFUFSNJOBS FMNPOUPEFQSFTUBDJØOOPJNQMJDBRVFBMMÈIBZBEFMMFHBSTFOFDFTBSJBNFOUF FOMBIJQØUFTJTEFJODVNQMJNJFOUPBOUFTEFBEPQUBSFTUBQPTUVSBTFSÓBJOEJTQFOTBCMFDPOTJEFSBSMBQPTJCJMJEBEEFMBFKFDVDJØOFTQFDÓmDBFMFRVJMJCSJPEF MBTQBSUFTFMJOUFSÏTEFMBDSFFEPSFMJOUFSÏTQÞCMJDP&OÞMUJNBTMBFKFDVDJØO FTQFDÓmDB OP IB EF FTUBS FYDMVJEB TJOP DVBOEP NFEJB VOB JNQPTJCJMJEBE NBUFSJBMNPSBMPKVSÓEJDBTFBBDBVTBEFMBOBUVSBMF[BEFMBPCMJHBDJØOTFB BDBVTBEFHSBOEFTEJmDVMUBEFTNBUFSJBMFTTFBBDBVTBEFVOBJNQPTJCJMJEBE KVSÓEJDBEFFKFDVUBSMB. &O$PMPNCJBOPFTFYUSB×PFMUFNBEFMTVCSPHBEPQFDVOJBSJPFOUBOUPRVF TFBQMJDBFOMPTQSPDFTPTFKFDVUJWPTQPSPCMJHBDJPOFTEFEBSCJFOFTEJTUJOUPTB EJOFSP BTÓ DPNP QPS QSFTUBDJPOFT EF IBDFS 5BM JOTUJUVDJØO FT WJTJCMF FO MPT BSUÓDVMPTBZBEFM$ØEJHPEF1SPDFEJNJFOUP$JWJMPMPTBSUÓDVMPT BZBEFM$ØEJHP(FOFSBMEFM1SPDFTPMPTDVBMFTDPOUFNQMBOMB QPTJCJMJEBEQBSBFMBDSFFEPSEFFWJUBSMBUFSNJOBDJØOEFMQSPDFTPEFFKFDVDJØOFO FMFWFOUPFORVFTFMJCSFNBOEBNJFOUPFKFDVUJWPQPSMBTQSFTUBDJPOFTSFGFSJEBTZ BMEFNBOEBEPFKFDVUBEPMFTFBJNQPTJCMFDVNQMJSMBT&OPUSPTUÏSNJOPTFYJTUF MBUVUFMBQPSFMFRVJWBMFOUFQFDVOJBSJPZBRVFFM&TUBEPOPQVFEFEFKBSEFEBS QSPUFDDJØOBRVJFOUJFOFVOEFSFDIPEFDSÏEJUPJODVNQMJEPMPRVFHFOFSBRVF TVEFCFSEFQSPUFDDJØOFTUÏEJSJHJEPBMBUVUFMBEFMPTEFSFDIPTRVFQPEÓBOTFS USBOTGPSNBEPTFOEJOFSP. )*/&45304"0QDJUQ 0#"/%0#-"/$07ÓDUPS&MEFSFDIPBMBUVUFMBKVSJTEJDDJPOBMFGFDUJWBFOMBKVSJTQSVEFODJB-JNB1BMFTUSB&EJUPSFT 72 Revista del Instituto Colombiano de Derecho Procesal t/P Semillero de Derecho Procesal - Universidad Libre, Sede Bogotá "TÓMPIBEFKBEPWFSMBKVEJDBUVSBDVBOEPBMJOUFSQSFUBSFMNBSDPOPSNBUJWP FODPNFOUPIBTF×BMBEPRVF UBNCJÏOBQBSFDFSFHMBEBMBQPTJCJMJEBEBGBWPSEFMBDSFFEPSBMNPNFOUPEF WPMWFSTFJNQPTJCMFMBPCMJHBDJØOJOTBUJTGFDIBPQFSEFSQBSBÏMUPEPJOUFSÏTEF PQUBSQPSTVTUJUVJSMBQSFTUBDJØOEFCJEBPTFBFTUFÞMUJNPQVFEFEFKBSEFMBEP MBBDSFFODJBPSJHJOBMZQSPDVSBSFOMVHBSEFFMMBMBJNQPTJDJØOEFQFSKVJDJPT DPNPBTÓTFFTUJQVMBFOFMBSUÓDVMPEFM$ØEJHP$JWJMBMNBOJGFTUBSRVF i4J MB PCMJHBDJØO FT EF IBDFS Z EFVEPS TF DPOTUJUVZF FO NPSB QPESÈ QFEJS FM BDSFFEPS 2VF FM EFVEPS MF JOEFNOJDF MPT QFSKVJDJPT SFTVMUBOUFT EF MB JOGSBDDJØO EFM DPOUSBUPw 3FHMB KVSÓEJDB RVF FODVFOUSB FDP FO FM BSUÓDVMP EF MB MFZ EF QSPDFEJNJFOUPT %FTEF MVFHP BOUF FTUB ÞMUJNB IJQØUFTJT IBCSÈEFBDSFEJUBSTFUBOUPMBPCMJHBDJØOPSJHJOBMDPNPMBTDPOEJDJPOFTRVFMF IBCJMJUFOFTDPHFSMBWÓBTVTUJUVUJWBZFTFMBDDJPOBOUFRVJFOTPQPSUBMBDBSHBEF BEPTBSBMBEFNBOEBBRVFMMPTNÓOJNPTSFRVJTJUPTZEPDVNFOUPTRVFBUFTUBO FM DPNQSPNJTP B DBSHP EF MB QFSTPOB DPOWPDBEB B QSPDFTP FO FM FYUSFNP QBTJWP. &NQFSPMBQSFHVOUBRVFTJHVFFOUPODFTTFDFOUSBFOSFTQPOEFSTJOVFTUSP PSEFOBNJFOUP KVSÓEJDP QFSNJUF BQMJDBS FM TVCSPHBEP QFDVOJBSJP FO QSPDFTPT EFDMBSBUJWPT FO UBOUP RVF FM NPOJUPSJP FT DPOTJEFSBEP VOP EF FMMPT $PO FTF QSPQØTJUPUSBFNPTBDPMBDJØOMBTFOUFODJBQSPGFSJEBQPSMB4BMBEF$BTBDJØO$JWJM EFMB$PSUF4VQSFNBEF+VTUJDJBEF$PMPNCJBBEJBEBFMEFOPWJFNCSFEF FOMBRVFFTB$PSQPSBDJØOTFQSPQVTPEFUFSNJOBSTJMBQPTJCJMJEBEEFQSFUFOEFS FM QBHP EF QFSKVJDJPT DPNQFOTBUPSJPT TVCSPHBEP QFDVOJBSJP FO MPT QSPDFTPT PSEJOBSJPT FSB WJBCMF FO $PMPNCJB -VFHP EF BOBMJ[BS EF NBOFSB QBOPSÈNJDB MBT EJTQPTJDJPOFT DPOTBHSBEBT FO MPT BSUÓDVMPT EFM$ØEJHP$JWJMBTÓDPNPFMBSUÓDVMPEFMBT-FZEFBOUJHVP $ØEJHP +VEJDJBM Z FM BSUÓDVMP EFM $ØEJHP EF 1SPDFEJNJFOUP $JWJM OPSNB TJNJMBSBMBSUÓDVMPEFM$ØEJHP(FOFSBMEFM1SPDFTP FTUBDPODMVZØRVFi<M> BTEJTQPTJDJPOFTUSBOTDSJUBTTFSFmFSFOQPSJHVBMBUPEBTDMBTFTEFPCMJHBDJPOFT TFBOEFEBSIBDFSPOPIBDFSHFOÏSJDBTPFTQFDÓmDBTEFNFEJPPEFSFTVMUBEP: TJTPOBQMJDBCMFTBMQSPDFTPEFFKFDVDJØODPOUBOUPNBZPSGVOEBNFOUPMPTPOBM PSEJOBSJPDPODVZBTFOUFODJBTFQFSTJHVFDPOTUJUVJSVOUÓUVMPFKFDVUJWPw. 1PSFTFTFOEFSPTJFMGVOEBNFOUPEFMMFHJTMBEPSQBSBQFSNJUJSMBTVCSPHBDJØO QFDVOJBSJB FO FM QSPDFTP FKFDVUJWP PCFEFDF B MB JNQPTJCJMJEBE EF QBHBS MB PCMJHBDJØOin naturaOPEJOFSBSJBZEFJHVBMGPSNBFM&TUBEPEFCFQFSNJUJSMB 5SJCVOBM4VQFSJPSEFM%JTUSJUP+VEJDJBMEF#PHPUÈ4BMB$JWJM4FOUFODJBEFEFGFCSFSP EF&YQ.1&MVJO(VJMMFSNP"CSFP5SJWJ×P $GS1*/&%"30%3¶(6&;"MGPOTPZPUSP&MUÓUVMP&KFDVUJWPZMPT1SPDFTPT&KFDVUJWPT 0DUBWB&EJDJØO#PHPUÈ-FZFSQQQJFEFQÈHJOB issn - tQQt&OFSP+VOJPEFt#PHPUÈ%$$PMPNCJB 73 Tutela judicial efectiva no dineraria en el proceso monitorio colombiano TBUJTGBDDJØOEFMEFSFDIPGVOEBNFOUBMBMBDDFTPBMBBENJOJTUSBDJØOEFKVTUJDJB OP FYJTUF EFOUSP EF OVFTUSP PSEFOBNJFOUP KVSÓEJDP OJOHVOB SB[ØO DPOTUJUVDJPOBMOJMFHBMRVFJNQJEBMBTVCSPHBDJØOQFDVOJBSJBEJSFDUBNFOUFEFOUSPEF QSPDFTPTEFDMBSBUJWPTDPNPZBTFWJPQPSMPRVFOPIBZQSPIJCJDJØOUBNQPDP SFTQFDUPEFIBDFSMPFOFMQSPDFTPNPOJUPSJPDPOUFNQMBEPFOFM$ØEJHP(FOFSBM EFM1SPDFTP "TÓMBTDPTBTTJFMBSUÓDVMPEFM$ØEJHP(FOFSBMEFM1SPDFTPTF×BMBRVF QSPDFEFSÈFMQSPDFTPNPOJUPSJPQBSBiRVJFOQSFUFOEBFMQBHPEFVOBPCMJHBDJØO FO EJOFSP EF OBUVSBMF[B DPOUSBDUVBM EFUFSNJOBEB Z FYJHJCMF RVF TFB EF NÓOJNB DVBOUÓBw QVFEF BmSNBSTF RVF DVBMRVJFS DJVEBEBOP QPESÈ CVTDBS MB DPOTUJUVDJØOEFVOUÓUVMPFKFDVUJWPBUSBWÏTEFFTUFQSPDFTPKVEJDJBMBVODVBOEP MB PCMJHBDJØO QSJNJHFOJB TFB EF BRVFMMBT EJTUJOUBT B MBT EJOFSBSJBT TJFNQSF Z DVBOEPTFCVTRVFTVCSPHBSMBQPSVOBEJOFSBSJB 4FTPTUJFOFMPBOUFSJPSFOUBOUPFMMFHJTMBEPSFTDMBSPFOFTUBCMFDFSRVFiRVJFO QSFUFOEBFMQBHPEFVOBPCMJHBDJØOFOEJOFSPwQPESÈBDVEJSBMNPOJUPSJPQPSMP RVFFMKVF[OPQPESÈSFDIB[BSMBEFNBOEBDVBOEPMBQSFUFOTJØOTFBFMQBHPEF MBPCMJHBDJØOEJOFSBSJBBVODVBOEPFMGVOEBNFOUPGÈDUJDPEFKFWFSMBFWFOUVBM FYJTUFODJBEFVOBPCMJHBDJØOEJTUJOUBBMBEJOFSBSJBQFSPFMEFNBOEBOUFIBHB VTPEFMTVCSPHBEPQFDVOJBSJPQPSJNQPTJCJMJEBEEFTVDVNQMJNJFOUP /BUVSBMNFOUFMBPCMJHBDJØOBTVCSPHBSEFCFQSPWFOJSEFVOOFHPDJPKVSÓEJDP DFMFCSBEP FOUSF MBT QBSUFT FO MJUJHJP EFCF TFS EF NÓOJNB DVBOUÓB FYJHJCMF Z EFJNQPTJCMFDVNQMJNJFOUP1FSPVOBWF[TVQFSBEPTEJDIPTQSFTVQVFTUPTFT QSPDFEFOUFFMQSPDFTPNPOJUPSJP -BPCMJHBDJØOBVORVFTFBQSFTFOUBEBDPNPTVCSPHBEPQFDVOJBSJPQVFEF TFSEFUFSNJOBEBFOUBOUPFMKVSBNFOUPFTUJNBUPSJPDPOUFNQMBEPFOFMBSUÓDVMP EFM$ØEJHP(FOFSBMEFM1SPDFTPQFSNJUJSÈRVFFMEFNBOEBOUFFTUJNFFO EJOFSPFMQBHPEFMBPCMJHBDJØORVFFOQSJODJQJPFSBEJTUJOUBBEJOFSP%FTFS PCKFUBEP TFSÈ FOUPODFT FM EJDUBNFO QFSJDJBM FM FODBSHBEP EF FTUBCMFDFS MB DVBOUÓBEFMBQSFTUBDJØO &OFTFPSEFOEFJEFBTFMQSPDFEJNJFOUPFTUBCMFDJEPFOFMBSUÓDVMPEFM $ØEJHP(FOFSBMEFM1SPDFTPFTUPUBMNFOUFBQMJDBCMFFOFTUFDBTPZBRVFEFOP FYJTUJSPQPTJDJØOFMKVF[UFOESÈRVFEFDMBSBSMBDPOTUJUVDJØOEFMUÓUVMPFKFDVUJWP QPSEJDIBPCMJHBDJØOEJOFSBSJBTPMJDJUBEBFOMBEFNBOEB"IPSBEFHFOFSBSTF PQPTJDJØOFOUSFPUSPTBTQFDUPTQPESÈEFCBUJSTFMBJNQPTJCJMJEBEEFDVNQMJNJFOUPGÓTJDBPNPSBMEFMBQSFTUBDJØOQSJNJHFOJBEFTVFSUFRVFEFBDSFEJUBSTF UBM DPOEJDJØO QPS FM FYUSFNP BDUJWP EF MB SFMBDJØO QSPDFTBM UBNCJÏO UFOESÈ RVFUFSNJOBSFMQSPDFTPDPOTFOUFODJBRVFDPOTUJUVZBFMUÓUVMPFKFDVUJWPQFSP EFTBMJSBWBOUFMBPQPTJDJØOTFUFSNJOBSÈFMQSPDFTPQBSBRVFTFBFOUPODFTFM QSPDFTPEFDMBSBUJWPMBÞOJDBWÓB 74 Revista del Instituto Colombiano de Derecho Procesal t/P Semillero de Derecho Procesal - Universidad Libre, Sede Bogotá "VORVF QBSF[DB VO EPCMF SFDPSSJEP FM RVF FWFOUVBMNFOUF FM EFNBOEBOUF EFCBBEFMBOUBSQSPDFTPNPOJUPSJPZQSPDFTPEFDMBSBUJWP MPDJFSUPFTRVFOVFTUSB QSPQVFTUBTFSÈVOBTPMVDJØOFONVDIPTDBTPTFOUBOUPRVFBMQBSUJSEFMBCVFOB GFZMFBMUBEEFMBTQBSUFTTFQPESÈODPOTUJUVJSUÓUVMPTFKFDVUJWPTDPOGPSNFBMP TF×BMBEPIBTUBBRVÓFOUPEPTBRVFMMPTDBTPTEFNÓOJNBDVBOUÓBFOMPTRVFOPTFB QPTJCMFIPOSBSMBTPCMJHBDJPOFTEJTUJOUBTBMBTEJOFSBSJBT 12. Conclusiones. &MQSPDFTPNPOJUPSJPDPNPVOBJOTUJUVDJØOJOOPWBEPSBGVFJODPSQPSBEPFO MBMFHJTMBDJØOKVSÓEJDPQSPDFTBMDPMPNCJBOBDPOFM$ØEJHP(FOFSBMEFM1SPDFTP -FZEFHSBDJBTBMCVFOEFTBSSPMMPZBQMJDBDJØORVFFTUFIBUFOJEPFO EJTUJOUPT QBÓTFT EFM NVOEP &T QPS FTP RVF FM MFHJTMBEPS MP JOTUJUVZØ QBSB RVF GVFTFVOBIFSSBNJFOUBNÈTFGFDUJWBZFmDB[QBSBMBTBUJTGBDDJØOZQSPUFDDJØOEF MPTEFSFDIPTEFMPTBDSFFEPSFTEFPCMJHBDJPOFTEJOFSBSJBTEFBRVÓRVFEFUFSNJOØ TVMÓNJUFEFBQMJDBDJØOBPCMJHBDJPOFTDPOUSBDUVBMFTZRVFOPTVQFSFOMBNÓOJNB DVBOUÓB -BFTUSVDUVSBEFMQSPDFTPNPOJUPSJPMPDBSBDUFSJ[BDPNPVOQSPDFTPDÏMFSF RVFCSJOEBMBQPTJCJMJEBEEFDPOTUJUVJSUÓUVMPTFKFDVUJWPTBRVJFOFTOPMPQPTFFO BUSBWÏTEFVOQSPDFTPTJNQMFZFDPOØNJDP&TBRVÓEPOEFWFNPTMPTCFOFmDJPT RVFFTUFQSPDFTPPGSFDFQBSBFGFDUPTEFNBUFSJBMJ[BDJØOEFEFSFDIPTBMBTPDJFEBE DPMPNCJBOBEFUBMTVFSUFRVFOPTDVFTUJPOBNPTTPCSFMBEFTQSPUFDDJØOFWJEFOUF EFBRVFMMPTBDSFFEPSFTEFPCMJHBDJPOFTEFUJQPOPEJOFSBSJBTRVFOPTFFODVFOUSBO BNQBSBEPTQPSFMÈNCJUPEFDPOPDJNJFOUPEFMQSPDFTPNPOJUPSJP &T EF MP BOUFSJPS RVF TVSHF MB QSJNFSB QSFHVOUB EF OVFTUSB JOWFTUJHBDJØO SFBMJ[BEB MB DVBM CVTDB EFUFSNJOBS TJ FO $PMPNCJB TF OFDFTJUB VO QSPDFTP NPOJUPSJPRVFDPOTUJUVZBUÓUVMPTFKFDVUJWPTQPSPCMJHBDJPOFTEFEBSFOUSFHBSZ IBDFSBMPRVFSFTQPOEFNPTBmSNBUJWBNFOUFZTPQPSUBNPTOVFTUSBSFTQVFTUB FO &M BOÈMJTJT EFM %FSFDIP DPNQBSBEP FO EPOEF FODPOUSBNPT RVF FO QBÓTFT DPNP"MFNBOJB"VTUSJBF*UBMJBFMQSPDFTPNPOJUPSJPOPTPMPFTFNQMFBEP QBSBSFDMBNBSFMQBHPEFPCMJHBDJPOFTEJOFSBSJBTTJOPUBNCJÏOQBSBFOUSFHB EFDPTBNVFCMFEFUFSNJOBEBZFOUSFHBEFDPTBGVOHJCMF:BFO-BUJOPBNÏSJDB FODPOUSBNPTRVFFO7FOF[VFMB6SVHVBZZFM4BMWBEPSBQMJDBOVOQSPDFTP NPOJUPSJPBCJFSUPBPUSPUJQPEFPCMJHBDJPOFTOPEJOFSBSJBTEBSIBDFSPOP IBDFS EFFTBNBOFSBQSPUFHFOBUPEPTMPTBDSFFEPSFTFOJHVBMFTDPOEJDJPOFT &OFMFTUVEJPSFBMJ[BEPBMB4FOUFODJB$EFMB×PFOMBRVFMB$PSUF $POTUJUVDJPOBMTPTUVWPRVFiFMQSPDFTPNPOJUPSJPTPMPDPOPDFEFPCMJHBDJPOFT EJOFSBSJBTFTEFDJSPCMJHBDJPOFTEFIBDFSPEFEBSFOUSFHBSw%FFTUFFTUVEJP issn - tQQt&OFSP+VOJPEFt#PHPUÈ%$$PMPNCJB 75 Tutela judicial efectiva no dineraria en el proceso monitorio colombiano mOBMNFOUFBEWFSUJNPTBEFNÈTEFMBJODPOHSVFODJBFOMPTQMBOUFBNJFOUPT RVFFTUPTTFFODVFOUSBOFOFMobiter dicta EFMBTFOUFODJBEFFTUBNBOFSB RVFEBOTJOVOBSFTQVFTUBEFmOJUPSJBOVFTUSPTDVFTUJPOBNJFOUPT 3. &OFMFTUVEJPEFMBTHBDFUBTEFM$POHSFTPFOMBRVFTFEFTBSSPMMBSPOMPTEFCBUFT BDFSDBEFMBFYQFEJDJØOEFM$ØEJHP(FOFSBMEFM1SPDFTPEFMBDVBMBEWFSUJNPT RVFOPTFNPUJWØMBJODMVTJØOPOPEFPCMJHBDJPOFTEFEBSFOUSFHBSPEFIBDFS EFOUSPEFMÈNCJUPEFBQMJDBDJØOEFMQSPDFTPNPOJUPSJP 4. &OFMEFSFDIPBMBUVUFMBKVEJDJBMFGFDUJWBFOUBOUPFTVOBCBTFFOMBDVBMTF FEJmDB FM &TUBEP 4PDJBM Z %FNPDSÈUJDP EF %FSFDIP FM DVBM SFDPOPDF B MPT DJVEBEBOPTMBGBDVMUBEEFBDDFEFSBMBKVTUJDJBDPOHBSBOUÓBTEFJHVBMEBEQBSB FMSFDPOPDJNJFOUPQSPUFDDJØOZSFTUBCMFDJNJFOUPEFTVTEFSFDIPTUPEPFO PCTFSWBODJBEFMEFCJEPQSPDFTP &OFMEFSFDIPBMBUVUFMBKVEJDJBMEFMDSÏEJUPFOUBOUPFMDVNQMJNJFOUPEFMBT PCMJHBDJPOFTEFDVBMRVJFSOBUVSBMF[BFTVOEFSFDIPRVFQPTFFUPEBQFSTPOB ZEFCFQSPQFOEFSQPSTVNBUFSJBMJ[BDJØOBUSBWÏTEFBDDJPOFTMFHBMFTJEØOFBT QBSBBTFHVSBSMBFGFDUJWJEBEEFMDSÏEJUP 1VFTCJFOUSBTIBCFSPCUFOJEPVOBSFTQVFTUBBmSNBUJWBBMBQSJNFSBQSFHVOUB OPT QSFHVOUBNPT TJ MB JODMVTJØO EF PCMJHBDJPOFT OP EJOFSBSJBT FO FM QSPDFTP NPOJUPSJPJNQMJDBSÓBVOBSFGPSNBPNPEJmDBDJØOFOEJDIPQSPDFTPDVBOEPTF QSFUFOEBMBDPOTUJUVDJØOEFUÓUVMPTFKFDVUJWPTQPSPCMJHBDJPOFTEFEBSFOUSFHBS PIBDFS%BEPFMFTUVEJPSFBMJ[BEPBEWFSUJNPTRVFFOFGFDUPTPOOFDFTBSJBTEPT SFGPSNBTBMQSPDFEJNJFOUPFOMPTTJHVJFOUFTUÏSNJOPT &TUB SFGPSNB IBDF SFGFSFODJB BM UÏSNJOP KVEJDJBM BEPQUBEP QBSB RVF FM EFVEPSQBHVFMBPCMJHBDJØOUPEBWF[RVFFM$(1FTUBCMFDFEÓBTQBSB FGFDUVBS FM DVNQMJNJFOUP EF MB PCMJHBDJØO &WJEFODJBNPT FOUPODFT RVF QVEJFSB MMFHBS B SFTVMUBS JOTVmDJFOUF FTUF UÏSNJOP EBEB MB OBUVSBMF[B NJTNB EF MBT PCMJHBDJPOFT EF UJQP OP EJOFSBSJBT QPS MP DVBM BDVEJNPT B MB EJTDSFDJPOBMJEBE KVEJDJBM FO PCTFSWBODJB EF MPT QSJODJQJPT EF SB[POBCJMJEBEZQSPQPSDJPOBMJEBEQBSBMBmKBDJØOEFMQMB[PRVFFMKVF[DPOTJEFSF QSVEFOUFOFDFTBSJPZTVmDJFOUFQBSBMBSFBMJ[BDJØOEFMQBHPEFMBPCMJHBDJØO EFEBSFOUSFHBSPIBDFS &T OFDFTBSJB VOB NPEJmDBDJØO FO DVBOUP BM DPOUFOJEP Z MB QSPDFEFODJB EF MBTPMJDJUVERVFTFEFCFQSFTFOUBSQBSBJOJDJBSFMQSPDFTPFKFDVUJWPBDPOUJOVBDJØO EFM QSPDFTP NPOJUPSJP FO MB NFEJEB FO RVF FTB TPMJDJUVE QVFEB BENJUJSQSFUFOTJPOFTTVCTJEJBSJBTQPSFMFRVJWBMFOUFFOEJOFSPEFMBPCMJHBDJØO EFEBSFOUSFHBSZIBDFSEFUBMGPSNBRVFQVFEBTFSBDFQUBEBFOMBTFOUFODJB 5PEPDPOFMPCKFUPEFRVFMBTFOUFODJBQFSNJUBJODMVJSQSFUFOTJPOFTTVCTJEJBSJBTQBSBFGFDUJWJ[BSBÞONÈTFMQBHPEFMUÓUVMPFKFDVUJWPPCUFOJEPBOUFMB JNQPTJCJMJEBEEFMEFVEPSEFDVNQMJSMBPCMJHBDJØOQSJODJQBM 76 Revista del Instituto Colombiano de Derecho Procesal t/P Semillero de Derecho Procesal - Universidad Libre, Sede Bogotá 1PSÞMUJNPOVFTUSBJOWFTUJHBDJØOTFQSPQVTPSFTQPOEFSTJFOFGFDUPBUSBWÏT EFMQSPDFTPNPOJUPSJPBDUVBMTFQVFEFODPOTUJUVJSUÓUVMPTFKFDVUJWPTEJOFSBSJPT EFSJWBEPTEFTVCSPHBEPTQFDVOJBSJPTEFPCMJHBDJPOFTEFEBSFOUSFHBSPIBDFS"M PCUFOFSVOSFTVMUBEPQPTJUJWPQVFTPCTFSWBNPTRVFFTQPTJCMFZRVFTFSFBMJ[BSÓB FODBCBMDVNQMJNJFOUPEFMBEJTQPTJDJØOOPSNBUJWBEFMBSUÓDVMPEF$(1 UPEB WF[ RVF EJDIP BSUÓDVMP FYJHF RVF B USBWÏT EFM QSPDFTP NPOJUPSJP TF EFCF QSFUFOEFSFMQBHPEFVOBPCMJHBDJØOEJOFSBSJB&OFTUFFOUFOEJEPFMBDSFFEPSEF PCMJHBDJPOFTOPEJOFSBSJBTQPESÈBDDFEFSBMQSPDFTPNPOJUPSJPBDUVBMQBSBRVF MFTFBDPOTUJUVJEPVOUÓUVMPFKFDVUJWPEJOFSBSJPQPSFMFRVJWBMFOUFFOEJOFSPEFTV PCMJHBDJØOPSJHJOBMEFEBSFOUSFHBSPIBDFS *EFBNPTFTUPDPOFMQSPQØTJUPEFPUPSHBSIFSSBNJFOUBTEFBQMJDBDJØOEJSFDUB Z DPODSFUB QVFT DPNQSFOEFNPT RVF QBSB MB BNQMJBDJØO P JNQMFNFOUBDJØO EF MB QSPQVFTUB IFDIB FO FTUB JOWFTUJHBDJØO TF SFRVJFSF BEFNÈT EF UJFNQP VO QPTJDJPOBNJFOUP EFM QSPDFTP NPOJUPSJP FO $PMPNCJB %F FTUB GPSNB OP FTQFSBNPT RVF MPT EFSFDIPT EF DSÏEJUP EF MPT BDSFFEPSFT EF PCMJHBDJPOFT OP EJOFSBSJBT RVFEFO TJO QSPUFDDJØO, contrario sensu, B USBWÏT EF FTUB BMUFSOBUJWB EFMTVCSPHBEPQFDVOJBSJPEFMBPCMJHBDJØOEFEBSFOUSFHBSPIBDFSQSFUFOEFNPT RVFUPEPBDSFFEPSEFPCMJHBDJPOFTEFDVBMRVJFSOBUVSBMF[BBDDFEBBMBBENJOJTUSBDJØOEFKVTUJDJBQBSBRVFTVTEFSFDIPTTFBOEFDMBSBEPTZEFUBMGPSNBFYJHJCMFT $BEB QSPQVFTUB QMBOUFBEB QPS FTUB JOWFTUJHBDJØO GVF TPNFUJEB QPS NFEJP EF VOB FODVFTUB SFBMJ[BEB B PQFSBEPSFT KVEJDJBMFT EPDFOUFT VOJWFSTJUBSJPT Z BCPHBEPTMJUJHBOUFTFTQFDJBMJ[BEPTFOFMÈSFBEFEFSFDIPQSPDFTBMBVOBEFUBMMBEB WBMPSBDJØODPOMBJOUFODJØOEFFWJEFODJBSTVBDPHJEBZGBDUJCJMJEBEEFBQMJDBDJØO &TUBEJPDPNPSFTVMUBEPMPTTJHVJFOUFTQPSDFOUBKFTTPCSFDBEBVOPEFMPTJOUFSSPHBOUFTQSPQVFTUPT t %F MB QSJNFSB QSFHVOUB QMBOUFBEB SFTQFDUP B MB OFDFTJEBE EF BNQMJBS FM QSPDFTPNPOJUPSJPQBSBBDSFFEPSFTEFPCMJHBDJPOFTEFEBSFOUSFHBSPIBDFS PCUVWJNPTVOBSFTQVFTUBBmSNBUJWBEFMFOFMNVFTUSFPHFOFSBM t 3FTQFDUPEFMBTFHVOEBQSFHVOUBOPTFODPOUSBNPTDPOVOEFBDFQUBDJØO RVF EFNVFTUSB MB BRVJFTDFODJB QPS QBSUF EF MBT QFSTPOBT FODVFTUBEBT FO SFMBDJØOBMBSFGPSNBQMBOUFBEBBMUÏSNJOPKVEJDJBMFTUBCMFDJEPQBSBFMDVNQMJNJFOUPEFMBPCMJHBDJØO1PSPUSPMBEPUFOFNPTVOEFQFSTPOBTBGBWPS EFMBSFGPSNBEFMBQPTJCJMJEBEEFVOBQSFUFOTJØOTVCTJEJBSJBEFTVCSPHBEP QFDVOJBSJP QBSB MB FKFDVDJØO EF TFOUFODJBT KVEJDJBMFT TPCSF PCMJHBDJPOFT EF EBSFOUSFHBSPIBDFS t &ODVBOUPBMBUFSDFSBQSFHVOUBFWJEFODJBNPTVOEFBQSPCBDJØOTPCSF MB BMUFSOBUJWB QBSB MPT BDSFFEPSFT EF PCMJHBDJPOFT OP EJOFSBSJBT EF RVF IBHBODVNQMJSTVBDSFFODJBDPOFMQSPDFTPNPOJUPSJPBDUVBMBUSBWÏTEFVO TVCSPHBEPQFDVOJBSJP issn - tQQt&OFSP+VOJPEFt#PHPUÈ%$$PMPNCJB 77 Tutela judicial efectiva no dineraria en el proceso monitorio colombiano 'JOBMNFOUFQPSNFEJPEFFTUPTQMBOUFBNJFOUPTDFMFCSBNPTMBDPOTBHSBDJØO EFMQSPDFTPNPOJUPSJPFOFM$ØEJHP(FOFSBMEFM1SPDFTPZBRVFDPNPTFNJMMFSPT EFJOWFTUJHBDJØOOVFTUSBUBSFBFTHFOFSBSDPOPDJNJFOUPBQMJDBCMFBMBTQSPCMFNÈUJDBT TPDJBMFT FO MBT DVBMFT FM %FSFDIP FT VO JOTUSVNFOUP EF TPMVDJØO FO UÏSNJOPTEFKVTUJDJBQPSMPDVBMMBNPUJWBDJØORVFJODFOUJWBOVFTUSBTQSPQVFTUBT OPFTPUSBRVFBQPSUBSBMDSFDJNJFOUPEFVOBJOTUJUVDJØOJOOPWBEPSBRVFCSJOEB VOTJOOÞNFSPEFCFOFmDJPTBMPTDJVEBEBOPT Bibliografía Doctrina "-4*/")VHP5SBUBEPUFØSJDPQSÈDUJDPEFEFSFDIPQSPDFTBMDJWJMZDPNFSDJBMU7 #T"T&EJBS "-7"3"%0 7&--040 "EPMGP " -FDDJPOFT EF EFSFDIP QSPDFTBM BEBQUBEBT B MB MFHJTMBDJØOQSPDFTBMDJWJMZQFOBMEFMB1SPWJODJBEF#VFOPT"JSFT&EJUPSJBM"TUSFB $0-.&/"3&4 63*#& $BSMPT &M 1SPDFTP EF MB &TUSVDUVSB .POJUPSJB $ÞDVUB -JUPHSBGÓB/VFWB(SBOBEB $"-"."/%3&* 1JFSP &M 1SPDFEJNJFOUP .POJUPSJP 5SBEVDDJØO QPS 4BOUJBHP 4FOUJT.FMFEP#VFOPT"JSFT&EJDJPOFT+VSÓEJDBT&VSPQB"NÏSJDB &M QSPDFEJNJFOUP NPOJUPSJP FO "NÏSJDB -BUJOB QBTBEP QSFTFOUF Z GVUVSP #PHPUÈ%$&EJUPSJBM5FNJT4" $)*07&/%"(JVTFQQF*OTUJUVDJPOFTEFMEFSFDIPQSPDFTBMDJWJM4FSJFDMÈTJDPTEFM %FSFDIP1SPDFTBM$JWJM7PMVNFO&EJUPSJBM+VSÓEJDB6OJWFSTJUBSJB.ÏYJDP (».&; 030;$0 +PTÏ "MFKBOESP *OUSPEVDDJØO BM 1SPDFTP .POJUPSJP $POTUJUVDJPOBMJ[BDJØOZ0SBMJEBEEFM%FSFDIP$JWJM.FEFMMÓO-JCSFSÓB+VSÓEJDB4ÈODIF[ 3-5%" )*/&45304" 'FSOBOEP 5SBUBEP EF MBT PCMJHBDJPOFT $PODFQUP FTUSVDUVSB Z 7JDJTJUVEFT5PNP*5FSDFSBFEJDJØO#PHPUÈ$PMPNCJB&EJUPSJBM6OJWFSTJEBE&YUFSOBEP EF$PMPNCJB ."35¶/&; 0TDBS +PTÏ &M QSPDFEJNJFOUP NPOJUPSJP FO FM $ØEJHP 1SPDFTBM $JWJM .PEFMP QBSB *CFSPBNÏSJDB IUUQCJCMJPKVSJEJDBTVOBNNYMJCSPTQFEG <$POTVMUBEPFONBZPEF> 0#"/%0#-"/$07ÓDUPS&MEFSFDIPBMBUVUFMBKVSJTEJDDJPOBMFGFDUJWBFOMBKVSJTQSVEFODJB-JNB1BMFTUSB&EJUPSFT 1SJODJQJPTTPCSFMPTDPOUSBUPTDPNFSDJBMFTJOUFSOBDJPOBMFTEF6OJESPJU3PNB QQZTTZZTT*%#PHPUÈ 3&/%&5*&%FSFDIPQSPDFTBMDJWJM5PNP**OVN#VFOPT"JSFT 5"3*(0 &OSJRVF -FDDJPOFT EF %FSFDIP 1SPDFTBM $JWJM 5PNP *7 B FEJDJØO 'VOEBDJØOEF$VMUVSB6OJWFSTJUBSJB.POUFWJEFP Artículos de revista y memorias $"/04"46«3&;6MJTFT&MQSPDFTPNPOJUPSJP&O$ØEJHP(FOFSBMEFM1SPDFTPMFZ EFKVMJP %FDSFUPEFZOPUBTEFDPOTUJUVDJPOBMJEBEDPNFOUBEP 78 Revista del Instituto Colombiano de Derecho Procesal t/P Semillero de Derecho Procesal - Universidad Libre, Sede Bogotá DPOBSUÓDVMPTFYQMJDBUJWPTEFNJFNCSPTEFM*$%1#PHPUÈ%$*OTUJUVUP$PMPNCJBOPEF %FSFDIP1SPDFTBM $0-.&/"3&463*#&$BSMPT"MCFSUP&MQSPDFTP.POJUPSJPFOFM$ØEJHP(FOFSBM EFM 1SPDFTP FO $PMPNCJB -FZ EF &O 999*7 $POHSFTP $PMPNCJBOP EF %FSFDIP1SPDFTBM#PHPUÈ%$6OJWFSTJEBE-JCSFEF$PMPNCJBTFQUJFNCSF &TUSVDUVSB NPOJUPSJB Z MB IJQPUFDB &O 999* $POHSFTP $PMPNCJBOP EF %FSFDIP1SPDFTBM#PHPUÈ%$6OJWFSTJEBE-JCSFEF$PMPNCJBTFQUJFNCSF #6+04"7"%&---PSFO[P.-PTQSJODJQJPTEFM$ØEJHP(FOFSBMEFM1SPDFTP-FZ EF &O 999*7 $POHSFTP $PMPNCJBOP EF %FSFDIP 1SPDFTBM #PHPUÈ %$ 6OJWFSTJEBE-JCSFEF$PMPNCJBTFQUJFNCSF %&-$"440 $033&" +VBO 1BCMP &M QSPDFTP NPOJUPSJP FO MB OVFWB MFZ EF FOKVJDJBNJFOUP DJWJM &O 3FWJTUB 9VSJEJDB (BMFHB 3FDVQFSBEP EF IUUQSFYVSHBOFUQEG $0-QEG <$POTVMUBEPFOTFQUJFNCSFEF> &-*;"%&+PSHF-VJT3ÏHJNFOQSPDFTBMEFMKVJDJPTVNBSJPEFFOUSFHBEFMBDPTB&O 3FWJTUBEF5ÏDOJDB'PSFOTF/P*OTUJUVUPEF5ÏDOJDB'PSFOTF'VOEBDJØOEF$VMUVSB 6OJWFSTJUBSJB.POUFWJEFP -"/%0/* «OHFM &M $ØEJHP (FOFSBM EFM 1SPDFTP B EJFDJTÏJT B×PT EF TV WJHFODJB &O3FWJTUB+VEJDBUVSB/P1VCMJDBDJØO0mDJBMEFMB"TPDJBDJØOEF.BHJTUSBEPTEFM 6SVHVBZ.POUFWJEFPNBZPEF /*$"45304&0"/&(VTUBWP-PTPUSPTQSPDFTPTNPOJUPSJPTFOFMDØEJHPHFOFSBM EFMQSPDFTPVSVHVBZP&O9997$POHSFTP$PMPNCJBOPEF%FSFDIP1SPDFTBM#PHPUÈ %$6OJWFSTJEBE-JCSFEF$PMPNCJB 1*$» * +6/0: +PBO &M 1SPDFTP .POJUPSJP VOB WJTJØO FTQB×PMB Z FVSPQFB EF MB UVUFMB SÈQJEB EFM DSÏEJUP FE O &O 3FWJTUB EFM *OTUJUVUP $PMPNCJBOP EF %FSFDIP 1SPDFTBM#PHPUÈ%$*OTUJUVUP$PMPNCJBOPEF%FSFDIP1SPDFTBMKVOJPEF &M1SPDFTP.POJUPSJPVOBWJTJØOFTQB×PMBZFVSPQFBQFOTBOEPFO$PMPNCJB &O999***$POHSFTP$PMPNCJBOPEF%FSFDIP1SPDFTBM#PHPUÈ%$6OJWFSTJEBE-JCSF EF$PMPNCJBTFQUJFNCSF 10/;.BOVFM"MCFSUP&MQSPDFTPNPOJUPSJP&O3FWJTUBEFM$PMFHJPEF"CPHBEPT EFMB1MBUB 26*/5&30 1²3&; .BHEB *TBCFM Z #0/&55 035*; 4BNJS "MCFSUP &M QSPDFTP .POJUPSJP 5FOEFODJB EFM EFSFDIP QSPDFTBM JCFSPBNFSJDBOP &O 99*7 +PSOBEBT *CFSPBNFSJDBOBT EF %FSFDIP 1SPDFTBM 1BOBNÈ *OTUJUVUP $PMPNCP 1BOBNF×P EF %FSFDIP1SPDFTBMF*OTUJUVUP*CFSPBNFSJDBOPEF%FSFDIP1SPDFTBM 3FVOJØO$JFOUÓmDBTPCSFQBDUPDPNJTPSJPDPOMBQBSUJDJQBDJØOEFJOUFHSBOUFTEFMPT JOTUJUVUPTEF%FSFDIP1SPDFTBMZ%FSFDIP$JWJM7FSTJØODPSSFHJEBEFMBTEJTFSUBDJPOFT SFBMJ[BEBTFOFM#BODP)JQPUFDBSJPEFM6SVHVBZEF%FSFDIP1SPDFTBM'VOEBDJØO EF$VMUVSB6OJWFSTJUBSJB.POUFWJEFP 4FOUFODJB/PEFEFM5SJCVOBMEF"QFMBDJPOFTEF'BNJMJBEFFSUVSOP&O 3FWJTUB 6SVHVBZB EF %FSFDIP EF 'BNJMJB /P 'VOEBDJØO EF $VMUVSB 6OJWFSTJUBSJB .POUFWJEFP 4*-7" 30.&30 .BSDFMB 1SPDFTPT EF ÞOJDB JOTUBODJB &O 9997 $POHSFTP $PMPNCJBOP EF %FSFDIP 1SPDFTBM #PHPUÈ %$ 6OJWFSTJEBE -JCSF EF $PMPNCJB TFQUJFNCSF issn - tQQt&OFSP+VOJPEFt#PHPUÈ%$$PMPNCJB 79 Tutela judicial efectiva no dineraria en el proceso monitorio colombiano 5"3*(0 &OSJRVF $POWFOJFODJB EF JOTUJUVJS PUSP NPOJUPSJP FM EF DBODFMBDJØO KVEJDJBMEFMBIJQPUFDB&O3FWJTUB6SVHVBZBEF%FSFDIP1SPDFTBM/P'VOEBDJØO 6OJWFSTJUBSJB.POUFWJEFP 7"3("4 4*-7" -VJT &SOFTUP -B GVODJØO DPOTUJUVDJPOBM EF MPT QSJODJQJPT EFM $ØEJHP (FOFSBM EFM QSPDFTP &O 999*7 $POHSFTP $PMPNCJBOP EF %FSFDIP 1SPDFTBM #PHPUÈ%$6OJWFSTJEBE-JCSFEF$PMPNCJBTFQUJFNCSF 7&4$07*&OSJRVF-BTNPEFSOBTUFOEFODJBTEFMQSPDFTPDJWJMDPOUFNQPSÈOFP&O 3FWJTUBVSVHVBZBEF%FSFDIP1SPDFTBM/P'VOEBDJØOEF$VMUVSB6OJWFSTJUBSJB .POUFWJEFP Legislación nacional -FZEF+VMJP i1PSNFEJPEFMBDVBMTFFYQJEFFM$ØEJHP(FOFSBMEFM 1SPDFTPZTFEJDUBOPUSBTEJTQPTJDJPOFTw1VCMJDBEBFOFM%JBSJP0mDJBM/PEF EFKVMJPEF $0-0.#*"-FZEF.BZP $ØEJHP$JWJM Legislación internacional $»%*(0(&/&3"-%&-130$&40%&636(6":-FZ1SPNVMHBEBFM EFPDUVCSFEF $»%*(0 130$&4"- $*7*- : .&3$"/5*- %& &- 4"-7"%03 %FDSFUP /P 1SPNVMHBEBFMEFTFQUJFNCSFEF -FZEF&OKVJDJBNJFOUP$JWJMEF&TQB×B-&$ -FZ1SPNVMHBEBFMEFFOFSPEF 3FGPSNBBMB-FZEF&OKVJDJBNJFOUP$JWJMNFEJBOUF-FZEFEFPDUVCSF Tesis #"3")0/"."("º"4POJB&MJ[BCFUI&MQSPDFTP.POJUPSJPFOFM$ØEJHP1SPDFTBM $JWJMZ.FSDBOUJM5FTJTEFQSFHSBEP6OJWFSTJEBEEFM4BMWBEPS&M4BMWBEPS Jurisprudencia nacional $035& $0/45*56$*0/"- 4FOUFODJB $ EFM WFJOUJDVBUSP EF TFQUJFNCSFEFEPTNJMDBUPSDF.1.BSUIB7JDUPSJB4ÈDIJDB.ÏOEF[ $035&$0/45*56$*0/"-4FOUFODJB$EFMQSJNFSP EFNBS[PEFM EPTNJMPODF.1-VJT&SOFTUP7BSHBT4JMWB $035&$0/45*56$*0/"-4FOUFODJB$EFMUSFJOUB EFNBS[PEFEPT NJMOVFWF.1-VJT&SOFTUP7BSHBT4JMWB 53*#6/"- 461&3*03 %&- %*453*50 +6%*$*"- %& #0(05« 4BMB $JWJM 4FOUFODJBEFEFGFCSFSPEF&YQ.1&MVJO(VJMMFSNP"CSFP5SJWJ×P Documentos oficiales (BDFUBEFBDUBEFQMFOBSJB4FOBEPNBZPEF (BDFUBEFBDUBEFDPNJTJØO$ÈNBSBNBZPEF (BDFUBEFo"DUBEFDPODJMJBDJØO4FOBEPKVOJPEF (BDFUBEFoBDUBEFQMFOBSJB$ÈNBSBPDUVCSFEF (BDFUBEFoBDUBEFDPODJMJBDJØO$ÈNBSBKVOJPEF (BDFUBEFoBDUBEFDPNJTJØO4FOBEPBCSJMEF 80 Revista del Instituto Colombiano de Derecho Procesal t/P