"OB1BHBOP*OHSJE4WFSEMJDLZ1BVMB$PTUBT 1BSUJDJQBDJwOFJODJEFODJB EFMBTPDJFEBEDJWJM FOMBTQPMrUJDBTFEVDBUJWBT FMDBTPBSHFOUJOP "OB1BHBOP *OHSJE4WFSEMJDL 1BVMB$PTUBT $PMFDDJwOMJCSPT'-"1& 1BSUJDJQBDJwOFJODJEFODJB EFMBTPDJFEBEDJWJM FOMBTQPMrUJDBTFEVDBUJWBT FMDBTPBSHFOUJOP "OB1BHBOP *OHSJE4WFSEMJDL 1BVMB$PTUBT 'PSP-BUJOPBNFSJDBOPEF1PMrUJDBT&EVDBUJWBT°'-"1& XXXGPSPMBUJOPPSH $PPSEJOBDJwOHFOFSBM 1BCMP7FOFHBT1SPHSBNB*OUFSEJTDJQMJOBSJP EF*OWFTUJHBDJPOFT&EVDBUJWBT1**&$IJMF $PPSEJOBDJPOFTOBDJPOBMFT 'BOOZ.VvP[1FS| *OHSJE4WFSEMJDL"SHFOUJOB 3BGBFM-VDJP(JM/JDBSBHVB .JHVFMÇOHFM3PESrHVF[.nYJDP 1BCMP(FOUJMJ#SBTJM 1BCMP7FOFHBT$IJMF 0SMBOEP1VMJEP$PMPNCJB '-"1& FT VOB JOJDJBUJWB JOUFSJOTUJUVDJPOBM EFTUJOBEB B HFOFSBS Z BNQMJBSFTQBDJPTEFFODVFOUSPZBSUJDVMBDJwOEFPSHBOJ[BDJPOFTEF MBTPDJFEBEDJWJMRVFQSPNVFWFOMBEFGFOTBEFMBFEVDBDJwOQ|CMJDB '-"1&QSFUFOEFJOWPMVDSBSTFZDPNQSPNFUFSTFDPOFMEFTBSSPMMPEF QSPDFTPTEFNPDSgUJDPTEFDBNCJPFEVDBUJWPZDPOMBQSPNPDJwOEF FTUSBUFHJBT EF NPWJMJ[BDJwO TPDJBM DFOUSBEPT FO FM SFDPOPDJNJFOUP EFMEFSFDIPJOBMJFOBCMFBVOBFEVDBDJwOEFDBMJEBEQBSBUPEPTMPT MBUJOPBNFSJDBOPTZMBUJOPBNFSJDBOBT *OTUJUVDJPOFTNJFNCSPTEF'-"1& oro 'PSP&EVDBUJWP'&1FS|XXXGPSPFEVDBUJWPPSHQF ducativo L P P LABORATORIO DE -BCPSBUPSJPEF1PMrUJDBT1|CMJDBT-11"SHFOUJOB XXXMQQCVFOPTBJSFTOFU Políticas Públicas OCIPE - IDEUCA 0CTFSWBUPSJP$FOUSPBNFSJDBOPQBSBMB*ODJEFODJBFO MBT1PMrUJDBT&EVDBUJWBT°0$*1&*%&6$"/JDBSBHVB XXXVDBFEVOJJOTUJUVUPTJEFVDB bservatorio O educación C I U D A D A N O D E LA 0CTFSWBUPSJP$JVEBEBOPEFMB&EVDBDJwO0$&.nYJDP XXXPCTFSWBUPSJPPSH 0CTFSWBUPSJP-BUJOPBNFSJDBOPEF1PMrUJDBT&EVDBUJWBT 0-1&%#SBTJMXXXPMQFEOFU piie 1SPHSBNB*OUFSEJTDJQMJOBSJPEF*OWFTUJHBDJPOFTFO &EVDBDJwO1**&$IJMFXXXQJJFDM 6OJWFSTJEBE1FEBHwHJDB/BDJPOBM61/$PMPNCJBXXX QFEBHPHJDBFEVDP 1BHBOP"OB 1BSUJDJQBDJwOFJODJEFODJBEFMBTPDJFEBEDJWJMFOMBTQPMrUJDBTFEVDBUJWBT FMDBTPBSHFOUJOP"OB1BHBOP1BVMB$PTUBT*OHSJE4WFSEMJDLBFE #VFOPT"JSFT'VOE-BCPSBUPSJPEF1PMrUJDBT1|CMJDBT &#PPL-JCSPT'MBQF *4#/ 1PMrUJDBT&EVDBUJWBT*$PTUBT1BVMB**4WFSEMJDL*OHSJE***5rUVMP $%% 'FDIBEFDBUBMPHBDJwO '-"1&DVFOUBDPOFMBQPZPEFMB'VOEBDJwO'PSE $PMFDDJwO-JCSPT'-"1& $PPSEJOBDJwOFEJUPSJBM*OHSJE4WFSEMJDL "TJTUFOUFFEJUPSJBM1BVMB$PTUBT $PSSFDDJwOFEJUPSJBM5FSFTB$JMMP %JTFvPHSg¾DPZBSNBEP#FBUSJ[#VSFDPWJDTZ-FUJDJB4UJWFM 1SJNFSBFEJDJwONBS[PEF 4FQFSNJUFMBSFQSPEVDDJwOUPUBMPQBSDJBMEFMPTDPOUFOJEPTEFFTUFMJCSP DJUBOEPMBGVFOUFZFOWJBOEPDPQJBEFMBQVCMJDBDJwOBM'PSP-BUJOPBNFSJDBOP EF1PMrUJDBT&EVDBUJWBT -BCPSBUPSJPEF1PMrUJDBT1|CMJDBT#VFOPT"JSFT-11 5VDVNgO&#VFOPT"JSFT 4FDSFUBSrB(FOFSBMEF'-"1&1SPHSBNB*OUFSEJTDJQMJOBSJP EF*OWFTUJHBDJPOFTFO&EVDBDJwO1**& %BMNBDJB1SPWJEFODJB4BOUJBHP -BSFTQPOTBCJMJEBEQPSMBTPQJOJPOFTFYQSFTBEBTFOFMQSFTFOUFMJCSP JODVNCFOFYDMVTJWBNFOUFBMPTBVUPSFT¾SNBOUFTZTVQVCMJDBDJwOOP OFDFTBSJBNFOUFSF¿FKBMPTQVOUPTEFWJTUBEF'-"1& Ê/%*$& *OUSPEVDDJwO "QSPYJNBDJwODPODFQUVBMZBOUFDFEFOUFT .BSDPDPODFQUVBM 6OCSFWFSFQBTPQPSMBQPMrUJDBBSHFOUJOBEFMPT |MUJNPTBvPT $BSBDUFSJ[BDJwOHFOFSBMEFMFTDFOBSJP QPMrUJDPFEVDBUJWP "OUFDFEFOUFT -BOVFWBHFTUJwOEFHPCJFSOPZTVTMrOFBTEF QPMrUJDBFEVDBUJWB $BSBDUFSJ[BDJwOEJBHOwTUJDBEFMBTJUVBDJwO EFMBQBSUJDJQBDJwOFJODJEFODJBEFMBTPDJFEBE DJWJMFOMBQPMrUJDBFEVDBUJWB &TUSVDUVSBEFQBSUJDJQBDJwOFTUBCMFDJEBQPSFM HPCJFSOPBDUVBM 1SPDFTPTEFQBSUJDJQBDJwOFGFDUJWBNFOUFEFTBSSPMMBEPT .PWJNJFOUPTZDBNQBvBTQPSGVFSBEFMBTFTUSVDUVSBT EFQBSUJDJQBDJwOQSPQVFTUBTQPSFMHPCJFSOP $BTPFNCMFNgUJDPEFQBSUJDJQBDJwOFJODJEFODJB 5FOEFODJBTHFOFSBMFT"HFOEBTZUFNBTQSJPSJUBSJPT 4rOUFTJTJOUFSQSFUBUJWBEFMFTUVEJP "OFYP #JCMJPHSBGrB 1BSUJDJQBDJwOFJODJEFODJBEFMBTPDJFEBEDJWJMFMDBTPBSHFOUJOP "OB1BHBOP*OHSJE4WFSEMJDLZ1BVMB$PTUBT */530%6$$*Î/ &MQSFTFOUFEPDVNFOUPTFQSPQPOFDPOUSJCVJSDPOMBQSPEVDDJwO EFQFOTBNJFOUPDSrUJDPTPCSFFEVDBDJwO$PNPFTTBCJEPEFTEFMB QFSTQFDUJWBDSrUJDBFMDPOPDJNJFOUPOPQVFEFTFSEJTPDJBEPEFVOB UPNBEFQPTJDJwOQPMrUJDBRVFFOFTUFDBTPDPODSFUPTFIBMMBFODPO TPOBODJBDPOMPTQSPQwTJUPTHFOFSBMFTFOVODJBEPTQPS'-"1&ZTVT QSPHSBNBTEFUSBCBKP&OUSFUBMFTPCKFUJWPTTFDVFOUBOFMGPSUBMFDJ NJFOUPEFNFDBOJTNPTEFNPDSgUJDPTMBQSPEVDDJwOEFJOTVNPTMB QBSUJDJQBDJwO FO QSPOVODJBNJFOUPT Z NPWJMJ[BDJPOFT RVF FO FTUSF DIPWrODVMPDPOMBTSFTUBOUFTPSHBOJ[BDJPOFTTPDJBMFTEFMDBNQPQP QVMBSQFSNJUBOCSFHBSQPSFMDVNQMJNJFOUPEFVOPEFMPTEFSFDIPT TPDJBMFTNgTJNQPSUBOUFTFMEFSFDIPBMBFEVDBDJwO &OFMNBSDPEFEJDIPTPCKFUJWPTDPOTJEFSBNPTRVFMBQBSUJDJQB DJwOFJODJEFODJBEFMB²TPDJFEBEDJWJM³FOMBTQPMrUJDBTFEVDBDJPOBMFT DPOTUJUVZFVOBDPOEJDJwOTJOFRVBOPOQBSBRVFEJDIBTQPMrUJDBTUFO HBOVODBSgDUFSEFNPDSgUJDPFJHVBMJUBSJP &TUFQPTJDJPOBNJFOUPJOJDJBMSFRVJFSFBMHVOBTQSFDJTJPOFTBMPT¾ OFTEFFWJUBSDBFSFODPODFQUPTQBSBHVBTP²MVHBSFTDPNVOFT³RVF MJD|BO MPT EFUFSNJOBOUFT IJTUwSJDPQPMrUJDPT EF MPT QSPDFTPT TPDJB MFT%FBRVrRVFFOFMDBTPEFMB3FQ|CMJDB"SHFOUJOBBMPTFGFDUPT EFEJTDVUJSZBOBMJ[BSMBQBSUJDJQBDJwOTPDJBMFOQPMrUJDBTFEVDBUJWBT OPTJOUFSFTBSgQSPCMFNBUJ[BSUBOUPFMQSPUBHPOJTNPZMBDBMJEBEEF MBQBSUJDJQBDJwO°FTUVEJBOEPMBTFTUSVDUVSBTZNFDBOJTNPTRVFJO UFOUBOQSPNPWFSMBQBSUJDJQBDJwOTVHSBEPEFJODJEFODJBTVPSJHFO MBSFMBDJwOFOUSFEFNBOEBTPMVDIBTTPDJBMFTZBDDJwOFTUBUBMFUD° DVBOUPMBTDPOEJDJPOFTFTUSVDUVSBMFTZEFQPTJCJMJEBEEFMBNJTNB 1BSUJDJQBDJwOFJODJEFODJBEFMBTPDJFEBEDJWJMFMDBTPBSHFOUJOP 1BSBUBMQSPQwTJUPFYBNJOBSFNPTBMHVOPTQSPDFTPTRVFFOMPT |MUJNPTBvPTEFSJWBSPOFOMBTBODJwOEFMFZFTFEVDBUJWBTBTBCJFO EBTEFRVFFTTwMPVOBWrBEFFOUSBEBQBSBBOBMJ[BSFMMVHBSRVFUJFOF MBQBSUJDJQBDJwOTPDJBMFOMBTQPMrUJDBTQ|CMJDBTFOFMgSFBFEVDBUJWB "EFNgTEFFGFDUVBSVOBOgMJTJTHMPCBMEFMUFNBFODVFTUJwOOPT BCPDBSFNPT BM FTUVEJP EF VO ²DBTP FNCMFNgUJDP³ FM QSPDFTP RVF EFSJWwFOMB-FZEF'JOBODJBNJFOUP&EVDBUJWP°-FZ/°TBO DJPOBEBFMEFEJDJFNCSFEF RVFTFBOBMJ[BSgDPOQBSUJDVMBS EFUBMMF-BFMFDDJwOEFEJDIBMFZDPNPDBTPEPOEFDFOUSBSMBNJSBEB PCFEFDFBMBTTJHVJFOUFTSB[POFT -PTQSPCMFNBTSFMBUJWPTBM¾OBODJBNJFOUPEFMBFEVDBDJwOGVFSPO NPUJWP EF MVDIBT EFNBOEBT Z DVFTUJPOBNJFOUPT EFTEF MB TBODJwO EFMB-FZEF5SBOTGFSFODJBRVF°WBMHBMBSFEVOEBODJB°USBOT¾SJwMPT TFSWJDJPTFEVDBUJWPTEFMBFOTFvBO[BNFEJBZTVQFSJPSOPVOJWFSTJ UBSJBBMBTQSPWJODJBT &MIFDIPEFRVFTFUSBUFEFVOQSPDFTPDPODMVJEPQFSNJUFBOBMJ[BS MBTEJGFSFOUFTGBTFTIBTUBMBFGFDUJWBTBODJwOEFMBMFZFJODMVTPFO TVBQMJDBDJwOQPTUFSJPS -BQBSUJDVMBSJEBEEFDFOUSBSOPTFOMPTQSPDFTPTRVFEFSJWBSPOFO MBDPODSFDJwOEFJOTUSVNFOUPTOPSNBUJWPTMFZFT OPTMMFWBBQMBO UFBS VOB EJTDVTJwO TPCSF EJWFSTBT SFMBDJPOFT FOUSF MPT TJHVJFOUFT BTQFDUPT -BQBSUJDJQBDJwOEFMPTEJGFSFOUFTDPMFDUJWPTNPWJNJFOUPTTPDJB MFTZTJOEJDBMFTQPSFKFNQMP -PTFTQBDJPTEFQBSUJDJQBDJwOQSPQVFTUPTQPSFM1PEFS&KFDVUJWP -BSF¿FYJwOTPCSFFMFTQBDJPQSPQJPEFMBEJTDVTJwOMFHJTMBUJWBFM QBSMBNFOUPRVFIPZTFFODVFOUSBNVZEFWBMVBEP "OBMJ[BSFNPTFMQSPDFTPRVFEFSJWwFOMBTBODJwOEFMB-FZEF&EVDBDJwO5nDOJDP 1SPGFTJPOBMMB-FZEF'JOBODJBNJFOUP&EVDBUJWPZFMEFCBUFQBSBMBTBODJwOEFVOBOVFWB-FZ EF&EVDBDJwO/BDJPOBMRVFTVTUJUVZBMBBNQMJBNFOUFDVFTUJPOBEBZB|OWJHFOUF -FZ'FEFSBM EF&EVDBDJwO "OB1BHBOP*OHSJE4WFSEMJDLZ1BVMB$PTUBT "1309*."$*Î/$0/$&156"-:"/5&$&%&/5&4 ."3$0$0/$&156"1BSBEJTDVUJSZBOBMJ[BSMBQBSUJDJQBDJwOFJODJEFODJBEFMBTPDJF EBEDJWJMFOQPMrUJDBTFEVDBUJWBTOPTQBSFDFOFDFTBSJPJOUSPEVDJSFM DPOUFYUP EPOEF DSFFNPT EFCF EBSTF FTUF EFCBUF %FTEF OVFTUSB QFSTQFDUJWBMPTDPODFQUPTEF²QBSUJDJQBDJwO³Z²TPDJFEBEDJWJM³OP OFDFTJUFO QSFDJTBSTF FO UBOUP DPODFQUPT BCTUSBDUPT QMBVTJCMFT EF EF¾OJDJPOFTEFTDPOUFYUVBMJ[BEBTTJOPFOUBOUPDPOTUSVDDJPOFTIJT UwSJDBTZFTQBDJPTEFMVDIBEFQPEFS1PSFMMPDPOTJEFSBNPTJOTPTMB ZBCMFMBMFDUVSBIJTUwSJDPQPMrUJDBEFMPTQSPDFTPTRVFDPO¾HVSBOMBT DPOEJDJPOFTFTUSVDUVSBMFTZEFQPTJCJMJEBEEFMBQBSUJDJQBDJwOEFMB TPDJFEBEDJWJMFOMBTQPMrUJDBTFEVDBUJWBT &O FTUF TFOUJEP VOB QSJNFSB DVFTUJwO B DPOTJEFSBS FO MPT EF CBUFTTPCSF²MBQBSUJDJQBDJwO³FTTVSFMBDJwODPOMBEFNPDSBDJB&T NFOFTUFSEJTDVUJSDwNPFMEJTDVSTPEFMBQBSUJDJQBDJwOTFIBWVFMUP IFHFNwOJDPWJODVMBEPBM²FNQPEFSBNJFOUP³ZBMBSFTQPOTBCJMJEBE JOEJWJEVBMQSPQJBEFMPTBDUVBMFTTJTUFNBTEFEFNPDSBDJBGPSNBM&M ²FNQPEFSBNJFOUP³DPNP²EBSWP[³BMPTRVFOPUJFOFOPBRVJFOFT MBUJFOFONgTBDBMMBEBFTVODPODFQUPRVFDPNJFO[BBUFOFSVOMV HBSDFOUSBMFOMPTEJTDVSTPTTPCSFMBQBSUJDJQBDJwO&OUBOUPEJTDVSTP BVODVBOEPTFFODVFOUSBFOEJTQVUBEFTEFMwHJDBTQPMrUJDBTBOUJUnUJ DBTRVFMVDIBOQPSTVTJHOJ¾DBDJwOIBUPNBEPQBSBNVDIPTMBGVFS [BEFMTFOUJEPDPN|OJODMVTPQBSBKVTUJ¾DBSMPTQSPDFTPTEFSFGPSNB RVFTFIBCJMJUBOCBKPTVFOVODJBDJwO$PNPTFvBMB(BSZ"OEFSTPO ²<©> &M UnSNJOP QBSUJDJQBDJwO FT MP RVF MPT QPTUFTUSVDUVSBMJTUBT MMB NBSrBOVOTJHOJ¾DBOUF¿PUBOUFFMDVBMQVFEFGgDJMNFOUFTFSVTBEP 1BSUJDJQBDJwOFJODJEFODJBEFMBTPDJFEBEDJWJMFMDBTPBSHFOUJOP UBOUPQBSBJOEJDBSQSgDUJDBTQBSUJDJQBUJWBTDPNPQBSBTFvBMBSPUSBT RVF TPO MB BOUrUFTJT EF MB QBSUJDJQBDJwO -BDMBV Z .PVGGF ³ "OEFSTPO &TQFDr¾DBNFOUFFOFMUFSSFOPFEVDBUJWPFMMFOHVBKFEFMBQBSUJ DJQBDJwOJOHSFTwDPOMPTQSPDFTPTEFSFGPSNBFEVDBUJWBEFMPTBvPT OPWFOUBWJODVMBEPDPOEJGFSFOUFTOJWFMFTEFJOUFSWFODJwOBENJOJT USBDJwO FTDPMBS BVUwOPNB Z QBSUJDJQBUJWB JOWFTUJHBDJwO QBSUJDJQBUJ WB QBSUJDJQBDJwO EF MPT QBESFT Z MB DPNVOJEBE FO MB WJEB FTDPMBS QBSUJDJQBDJwOEFMPTEPDFOUFTFOMBTEFDJTJPOFTFUDZDPOEJWFSTBT JOJDJBUJWBTEFSFFTUSVDUVSBDJwORVFJODMVZFSPOMBMJCSFFMFDDJwOEFFT DVFMBDPOTVTQSPQVFTUBTFTQFDr¾DBTDPNPMBTFTDVFMBTDIBSUFSP MPTCPOPTDIFRVFTFTDPMBSFT MBEFTDFOUSBMJ[BDJwOMBQBSUJDJQBDJwO EFMPTQBESFTZMPTDPOTFKPTEFFTDVFMBEPOEFTFDPNQBSUFFMHPCJFS OPFUDnUFSB "IPSBCJFOMPRVFTFFTUgTFvBMBOEPFOFMUFSSFOPFEVDBUJWPQVF EFPCTFSWBSTFBMFKBOEPVOQPDPMBMFOUFZNJSBOEPDwNP²NVDIBT EFMBTQSPQVFTUBTFEVDBUJWBTEFNBZPSQBSUJDJQBDJwORVFTVSHFOEF VOBQSFPDVQBDJwOQPSMBEFNPDSBDJBQBSUFOEFVODPODFQUPEFEF NPDSBDJBMJCFSBMPSFQSFTFOUBUJWBPDPOGVOEFOEFNPDSBDJBDPOFMFD DJwOEFOUSPEFMDBQJUBMJTNPEFMJCSFNFSDBEP³"OEFSTPO 1PS FMMPFOUFOEFNPTRVFMBDVFTUJwOEFMBTGPSNBTZEFMPTDPOUFOJEPT RVFBERVJFSFOMPTTJTUFNBTEFNPDSgUJDPTFO"NnSJDB-BUJOBUBNCJnO EFCFTFSNPUJWPEFDPOTJEFSBDJwO (VJMMFSNP 0µ%POOFMM FO TV BOgMJTJT TPCSF MBT SFMBDJPOFT FOUSF &TUBEPEFNPDSBUJ[BDJwOZDJVEBEBOrBBDVvBFMUnSNJOP²EFNPDSBDJB EFMFHBUJWB³QBSBDPOUSBTUBSMBTDPOMBTJOTUJUVDJPOBMJ[BEBTDPOTPMJEB EBTFTUBCMFDJEBTPSFQSFTFOUBUJWBT 0µ%POOFMMQMBOUFBRVFDPO²FM UnSNJOP ´EFMFHBUJWBµ TF TFvBMB VOB DPODFQDJwO Z QSgDUJDB EFM QPEFS FKFDVUJWPRVFQSFTVQPOFRVFFTUFUJFOFFMEFSFDIPEFMFHBEPQPSFM FMFDUPSBEPEFIBDFSMPRVFMFQBSF[DBBEFDVBEPQBSBFMQBrT5BNCJnO B¾SNBRVFMBTEFNPDSBDJBTEFMFHBUJWBTTPOJOIFSFOUFNFOUFIPTUJMFT BMPTQBUSPOFTEFSFQSFTFOUBDJwOOPSNBMFTFOMBTEFNPDSBDJBTFTUB CMFDJEBTBMBDSFBDJwOZGPSUBMFDJNJFOUPEFJOTUJUVDJPOFTQPMrUJDBTZ "OB1BHBOP*OHSJE4WFSEMJDLZ1BVMB$PTUBT FTQFDJBMNFOUFBMPRVFEFOPNJOB´SFTQPOTBCJMJEBEIPSJ[POUBMµ<©> "EFNgTDPNPWFSFNPTFMDPNQPOFOUFMJCFSBMEFFTUBTEFNPDSBDJBT FTNVZEnCJM"MHVOPTBVUPSFTUJFOEFOBDPOGVOEJSMBEFNPDSBDJBEF MFHBUJWBDPOFMQPQVMJTNP1PSTVQVFTUPRVFBNCPTDPNQBSUFOWB SJBTDBSBDUFSrTUJDBTJNQPSUBOUFTQFSPBMNFOPTFO"NnSJDB-BUJOB FMQPQVMJTNPJNQMJDwVOBBNQMJBDJwOBVODVBOEPTFMPDPOUSPMFWFS UJDBMNFOUF EFMBQBSUJDJQBDJwOZEFMBPSHBOJ[BDJwOQPMrUJDBQPQVMBS ZDPFYJTUJwDPOQFSrPEPTEFFYQBOTJwOEJOgNJDBEFMBFDPOPNrBEP NnTUJDB &O DBNCJP MB EFNPDSBDJB EFMFHBUJWB UJFOEF UrQJDBNFOUF B EFTQPMJUJ[BSBMBQPCMBDJwO°FYDFQUPEVSBOUFCSFWFTNPNFOUPTFOMPT DVBMFTEFNBOEBTVBQPZPQMFTCJDJUBSJP°ZBDUVBMNFOUFDPFYJTUFDPO QFSrPEPTEFTFWFSBDSJTJTFDPOwNJDB³0µ%POOFMM %FTEFOVFTUSBQFSTQFDUJWBMPTTJTUFNBTEFNPDSgUJDPTQSJODJQBM NFOUFFOMPTQBrTFTQFSJGnSJDPTTFWJFSPOTFWFSBNFOUFBGFDUBEPTB QBSUJS EF MB DPOTPMJEBDJwO EF MB IFHFNPOrB OFPMJCFSBM /P TwMP MPT 0SHBOJTNPT*OUFSOBDJPOBMFTZMPT&TUBEPTNJFNCSPTEFM(SVQPEFMPT DPOEJDJPOBSPOMBTQPMrUJDBTZBDUVBSPODPNPFMFNFOUPSFTUSJDUJWP -BHSBOBTJNFUSrBTPDJBMSFTVMUBOUFEFFTUFQSPDFTPEFEPNJOBDJwO GVFFSPTJPOBOEPFMQPEFSEFMBTDMBTFTQPQVMBSFTZQPSDPOTJHVJFO UFMBJODJEFODJBEFFTUPTTFDUPSFTFOMBGPSNVMBDJwOEFQPMrUJDBTQ| CMJDBTEFDMJOw%FFTUFNPEPMPTQSPDFTPTEFQBSUJDJQBDJwOQPMrUJDB TF EFCJMJUBSPO Z DPOTFDVFOUFNFOUF UBNCJnO EFDSFDJFSPO MBT QPTJ CJMJEBEFTEFMPTTFDUPSFTQPQVMBSFTEFEJTQVUBSNBZPSFTHSBEPTEF JOUFSWFODJwOFOFMSVNCPQPMrUJDPEFMQBrTBQBSUJSEFQSPZFDUPTEF EFTBSSPMMPBMUFSOBUJWPRVFSFQSFTFOUBSBOTVTJOUFSFTFT 3FDPSEFNPT RVF FO "NnSJDB -BUJOB IBTUB MPT BvPT ²<©> FM UFNBEFMBEFNPDSBDJBZMBQBSUJDJQBDJwOFTUBCBDFOUSBEPFOFMTJT UFNB QPMrUJDP QBSUJEPT QPMrUJDPT Z FMFDDJPOFT QBSB MB USBOTGPSNB DJwOTPDJBMEFNPDSgUJDBHVFSSBTEFMJCFSBDJwOQBSBMBTTJUVBDJPOFT SFWPMVDJPOBSJBT&M&TUBEPOBDJwOFTUBCBFOFMDFOUSPZMPTBDUPSFT PSJFOUBCBOTVTFTUSBUFHJBTFOFTFOJWFM*ODMVTJWFBDUPSFTDPSQPSB 0µ%POOFMMMBNBBFTUBSFTQPOTBCJMJEBE²DPOUSPMDPUJEJBOPEFMBWBMJEF[ZMBMFHBMJEBE EFMBTBDDJPOFTEFM&KFDVUJWPQPSQBSUFEFPUSPTPSHBOJTNPTQ|CMJDPTRVFTPOSB[POBCMFNFOUF BVUwOPNPTEFMNJTNP³ 1BSUJDJQBDJwOFJODJEFODJBEFMBTPDJFEBEDJWJMFMDBTPBSHFOUJOP UJWPTUSBEJDJPOBMFT°MBCVSHVFTrBFMNPWJNJFOUPPCSFSPMPTNJMJUB SFT°FSBONJSBEPTGVOEBNFOUBMNFOUFFODVBOUPBTVDBQBDJEBEEF JOUFSWFOJSFOFMFTQBDJPQPMrUJDPEFMQPEFSEFM&TUBEP4JCJFOIBCrB USBTOBDJPOBMJTNPTEJWFSTPTMBTBMJBO[BTZSFGVFS[PTJOUFSOBDJPOBMFT EFFTPTZPUSPTBDUPSFTFTUBCBOPSJFOUBEPTBBVNFOUBSMPTSFDVSTPT ZMBDBQBDJEBEEFBDDJwOZEFQSFTJwOFOFMQMBOPOBDJPOBM0USPTBD UPSFTTPDJBMFTFSBOEnCJMFTMPRVFIBCrBFSBOQSPUFTUBTEFNBOEBT GSFOUFBM&TUBEPPFTQBDJPTEFTPDJBCJMJEBEZEFSFGVFS[PDVMUVSBMMP DBM-PTJOUFSFTFTEFSFHJPOFTJOUFSOBTPEFHSVQPTTPDJBMFTFTQFDr¾ DPTUFOrBODPNPSFGFSFOUFCgTJDPBM&TUBEPOBDJPOBM³+FMrO "Tr FO OVFTUSP QBrT IBTUB MB EnDBEB EFM FM HSVFTP EF MPT QSPDFTPTQBSUJDJQBUJWPTFSBMMFWBEPBEFMBOUFBUSBWnTEFEJGFSFOUFT MVDIBTFODBSBEBTQPSDPMFDUJWPTEFUSBCBKBEPSFT(SBOQBSUFEFFT UBTMVDIBTTFBTFOUBCBOFOVOBUSBEJDJwOQPQVMJTUBDVZBTDBSBDUF SrTUJDBTQPTFFO²<©>USFTQSJODJQJPTPB¾SNBDJPOFTNBZPSFTVOPFM QSJODJQJPEFMBDPOEVDDJwOBUSBWnTEFMMrEFSVOMJEFSB[HPQFSTPOB MJTUBDPOGVFSUFSFUwSJDBOBDJPOBMJTUB EPTFMQSJODJQJPEFMBTCBTFT TPDJBMFTPSHBOJ[BEBTMB¾HVSBEFM1VFCMP/BDJwO USFTMBDPOTUJUV DJwOEFVOBDPBMJDJwOJOUFSDMBTFTDPOEJDJwOQBSBVOBEJTUSJCVDJwOEF MBSJRVF[BNgTFRVJUBUJWBFMNPEFMPTPDJPFDPOwNJDPJOUFHSBEPS ³ 4WBNQB.BSJTUFMMB "TrGVFSPOMBT²DMBTFTQPQVMBSFT³RVF BCBSDBCBOVOBQMVSBMJEBEEFTVKFUPTVODPOHMPNFSBEPIFUFSPHnOFP EF DPMFDUJWPT GPSNBEP GVOEBNFOUBMNFOUF QPS USBCBKBEPSFT VSCB OPT PFMQVFCMPTVKFUPIPNPHnOFPRVFVOJ¾DBCBMBNVMUJQMJDJEBE EFSFBMJEBEFTQPMrUJDBTQSFTFOUFTFOOVFTUSPQBrT MPTQSPUBHPOJTUBT EFMPTQSJODJQBMFTFTDFOBSJPTEPOEFTFKVHBCBVOBQBSUJDJQBDJwOQP MrUJDBBGPOEP 2Vn JNQMJDBCBO FTUBT MVDIBT ²&O UnSNJOPT QPMrUJDPT FTUP JN QMJDw VO EFTBSSPMMP EF MB QBSUJDJQBDJwO CBKP MB GPSNB EF MVDIB EF MPT EFSFDIPT EF MPT USBCBKBEPSFT NgT RVF QPS MPT EFSFDIPT EF MB DJVEBEBOrB °SFQSFTFOUBDJwO rOUJNBNFOUF MJHBEB BM QFSPOJTNP° 6O DPOKVOUP EF DJSDVOTUBODJBT UFSNJOBSPO QPS EFTQMB[BS BM USBCBKBEPS EFMDFOUSPEFMBDVMUVSBQPQVMBSMBNPEJ¾DBDJwOEFMDPOUSBUPEFUSB CBKP FM BVNFOUP EF MB TVCPDVQBDJwO MB EFTPDVQBDJwO Z MB FDPOP NrBJOGPSNBMMBDSJTJT¾OBODJFSBEFM&TUBEPRVFTPDBWwMBTQPMrUJDBT TPDJBMFT MB BQBSJDJwO EFM TFOUJNJFOUP EF GSBHNFOUBDJwO TPDJBM EF "OB1BHBOP*OHSJE4WFSEMJDLZ1BVMB$PTUBT QBSDPOMBQnSEJEBEFMTFOUJNJFOUPEFQBSUJDJQBDJwOFOMBTPDJFEBE UPUBM°FMUSBCBKBEPSTFTJFOUFQBSUrDJQFFOMBDSFBDJwOEFMBSJRVF[B OBDJPOBM TFOUJNJFOUP DPNQMFUBNFOUF EJGFSFOUF EFM FYQFSJNFOUBEP QPSFMTVQFSOVNFSBSJPQBSBRVJFOOPIBZVOBQMB[BTFHVSBOJSFTQF UBCMF°ZMBBQBSJDJwOEFVOBPQJOJwOQ|CMJDBGVFSUFNFOUFMJHBEBBMB ¾HVSBEFMDJVEBEBOP³.FSLMFO 1PSMPWJTUPEFTEFNFEJBEPT EFMBEnDBEBEFMZIBTUBMBBDUVBMJEBEMBTMVDIBTFODBSBEBTQPS DPMFDUJWPTEFUSBCBKBEPSFTTVGSJSgOHSBOEFTUSBOTGPSNBDJPOFT"Tr MB BDDJwO DPMFDUJWB BTVNJSg OVFWBT GPSNBT EF QBSUJDJQBDJwO FO MBT RVFTPCSFTBMFOUBOUPMPTOVFWPTNPWJNJFOUPTTPDJBMFTDPNPMPTEJT UJOUPTNPEPTRVFDBSBDUFSJ[BSPOBMBQSPUFTUBTPDJBMDPOTVTGPSNBT BMUFSOBUJWBTEFSFTJTUFODJBZEFMVDIB &OFTUFNBSDPFMDPODFQUPEFQBSUJDJQBDJwOBEPQUwEJGFSFOUFTEJ SFDDJPOFT1PSVOMBEPFOFMDPOUFYUPEFBQMJDBDJwOEFMBTQPMrUJDBT OFPMJCFSBMFTZEFMBTEFNPDSBDJBTSFTUSJOHJEBT²<©>FMSPMEFMPTDJV EBEBOPTOPFTEFDJEJSQPMrUJDBTZMVFHPFMFHJSSFQSFTFOUBOUFTRVFMBT QPOHBOFOQSgDUJDBTJOPTwMPFMFHJSBMPTIPNCSFTRVFBEPQUBSgOMBT EFDJTJPOFT&OUPODFTMBQBSUJDJQBDJwOFTDBUBMPHBEBDPNPCBKBQPS RVFMBTEFDJTJPOFTRVFEBOSFTFSWBEBTBMBTFMJUFTEJSJHFOUFT&TUFFT QSFDJTBNFOUF FM NFDBOJTNP DMBVTVSBEP QPS MB USBTOBDJPOBMJ[BDJwO TVCPSEJOBEBIPZEPNJOBOUF-BTQPMrUJDBTGVOEBNFOUBMFTBUJOFOUFT BMPTNPEFMPTEPNnTUJDPTEFTPDJFEBEOPTPOEFDJEJEBTOJQPSMPT DJVEBEBOPTOJQPSMPTQBSUJEPTOJQPSMPTHPCJFSOPTMBUJOPBNFSJDB OPT&OTVNBMBFTUSVDUVSBZGVODJPOBNJFOUPEFMQPEFSJOUFSOBDJP OBMSFTUSJOHFOFMFTQFDUSPEFEFDJTJPOFTBMBMDBODFEFMPTTJTUFNBT QPMrUJDPT MPDBMFT Z DPO FMMP MB TPCFSBOrB OBDJPOBM Z DJVEBEBOB -B EFNPDSBDJB°UBOFYBMUBEBQPSFMOFPDPOTFSWBEVSJTNPMJCFSBM°RVFEB FOFOUSFEJDIP³&[DVSSB &O FTUF FTDFOBSJP MB ²TPDJFEBE DJWJM³ GVF DPCSBOEP SFMFWBODJB DPNP VO BDUPS DFOUSBM EF MP RVF FTUF OVFWP SnHJNFO MMBNw QBSUJ DJQBDJwO DJVEBEBOB BDUPS DBQB[ QBSB EJDIBT QPMrUJDBT EF DPOT USVJS VO FTDFOBSJP QSJWJMFHJBEP QBSB FM EFTBSSPMMP EF FYQFSJFODJBT ²EFNPDSgUJDBT³ 3FTVMUBFWJEFOUFRVFFTUBTSFGFSFODJBTQPMrUJDBTZDPODFQUVBMFT JOTUBMBEBT QPS MB IFHFNPOrB OFPMJCFSBM OP DPOUFNQMBO MBT EFT 1BSUJDJQBDJwOFJODJEFODJBEFMBTPDJFEBEDJWJMFMDBTPBSHFOUJOP JHVBMEBEFT JOIFSFOUFT BM DBQJUBMJTNP /BODZ 'SBTFS 'SBTFS BOBMJ[BMPTMrNJUFTEFMBEFNPDSBDJBFOMBTTPDJFEBEFTEFMDBQJUBMJTNP UBSErPZFODVFOUSBFOFMDPODFQUPEF²FTGFSBQ|CMJDB³EF)BCFSNBT VOBGVFOUFJOEJTQFOTBCMFQBSBEJDIPBOgMJTJT4FQSFHVOUBQPSFMMJ CSFBDDFTPQPSMBTQPTJCJMJEBEFTEFTVTQFOEFSMBTEFTJHVBMEBEFTFO FMNPNFOUPEFMBEFMJCFSBDJwODPNPTJnTUBTOPFYJTUJFSBO'SBTFS %FFTUFNPEP/BODZ'SBTFSOPTSFDVFSEBRVF²<©>FOTPDJFEB EFTFTUSBUJ¾DBEBTMPTHSVQPTTPDJBMFTRVFUJFOFOEJGFSFOUFTDVPUBT EFQPEFSUJFOEFOBEFTBSSPMMBSFTUJMPTDVMUVSBMFTEFTJHVBMNFOUFWBMP SBEPT&MSFTVMUBEPFTFMEFTBSSPMMPEFQPEFSPTBTQSFTJPOFTJOGPSNB MFTRVFNBSHJOBOMBTDPOUSJCVDJPOFTEFMPTNJFNCSPTEFMPTHSVQPT TVCPSEJOBEPTUBOUPFOMPTDPOUFYUPTEFMBWJEBDPUJEJBOBDPNPFO MBTFTGFSBTQ|CMJDBTP¾DJBMFT-BFDPOPNrBQPMrUJDBQBSUJDVMBSEFMB FTGFSBQ|CMJDBCVSHVFTBQPSMPEFNgTBNQMrBFOMVHBSEFNJUJHBS UBMFTQSFTJPOFT&OFTUBFTGFSBQ|CMJDBMPTNFEJPTRVFDPOTUJUVZFO FM TPQPSUF NBUFSJBM QBSB MB DJSDVMBDJwO EF MBT JEFBT TPO QSPQJFEBE QSJWBEBZPQFSBODPOgOJNPEFMVDSP1PSDPOTJHVJFOUFMPTHSVQPT TPDJBMNFOUFTVCPSEJOBEPTDBSFDFOQPSMPHFOFSBMEFVOBDDFTPJHVBM BMPTNFEJPTNBUFSJBMFTRVFQFSNJUFOMBJHVBMQBSUJDJQBDJwO%FFTUB 6OFKFNQMPEFMB EFTJHVBMEBE FTUSVDUVSBMFOVOFTQBDJP EF EJTDVTJwOZEFDJTJwO EPOEFQBSUJDJQBCBMBTPDJFEBEDJWJMTFSF¿FKBFOMPPDVSSJEPFOFMNFTEFKVMJPFOMBTSFVOJPOFT EFM$POTFKPEFM4BMBSJPZMBTQBSJUBSJBTQBSB¾KBSFMNPOUPEFVOOVFWPTBMBSJPNrOJNP+VOUP BSFQSFTFOUBOUFTEFM.JOJTUFSJPEF5SBCBKP&NQMFPZ4FHVSJEBEEFMB/BDJwOTFDPOHSFHBSPO EJGFSFOUFTBDUPSFTEFMBTPDJFEBEDJWJMSFQSFTFOUBOUFTEFMB6OJwOEF*OEVTUSJBMFT"SHFOUJOPT 6*" EFMB$POGFEFSBDJwO(FOFSBMEFM5SBCBKP$(5 EFMB$FOUSBMEF5SBCBKBEPSFT"SHFOUJOPT $5" EFMB'FEFSBDJwO"HSBSJB&OSFMBDJwODPOMPTSFTVMUBEPTEFFTUBTSFVOJPOFTFMQFSJPEJTUB 3B|M%FMMBUPSSFSF¿FYJPOB²-BTFvBMQSJODJQBMIBTJEPMBNPEFSBDJwODPNPDPOMBTKVCJMBDJP OFTTFTVCJwFMQJTPQBSBRVFOPRVFEBSBUBOMFKPTEFMBSFBMJEBEQFSPOPNgTRVFFTP-B SFMBDJwOFOUSFHBOBODJBTFNQSFTBSJBTZTBMBSJPTTJHVFTJFOEPVOBDVFTUJwOBKFOBBMBTNFTBT EFEJTDVTJwO0USBWF[MBDMBTFFNQSFTBSJBHBOwMBCBUBMMBDVMUVSBMFMTBMBSJPOPFTVOBNFEJ EBEFKVTUJDJBTPDJBMTJOPVO´DPTUPµRVFDVBOUPNgTTVCFNFOPT´WJBCMFµIBDFFMDSFDJNJFOUP FDPOwNJDP ´TBOPµ <©> -B SFDVQFSBDJwO EFM TBMBSJP NrOJNP MVFHP EFM DPOHFMBNJFOUP TVGSJEP EVSBOUFMPTZFMSFUSBTPBMRVFTFMPTPNFUJwFOMBEnDBEBZNFEJBQSFWJBBM FTVO EBUPWBMJPTP1FSPFM$POTFKPEFM4BMBSJPEJTUBEFTFSVOFTQBDJPEFNPDSgUJDPQBSBFMEFTBSSP MMPEFQPMrUJDBTSFEJTUSJCVUJWBT6OBWF[NgTMPTHSVQPTDPODFOUSBEPTEFMTFDUPSFNQSFTBSJP NPTUSBSPOTVQPEFSRVFFOQBSUFTFSF¿FKBFOMPTWBMPSFTEFMTBMBSJPNrOJNPQFSPNVDIPNgT DVBOEPTFNJSBOMPTDSJUFSJPTRVFTJHVFOQSFWBMFDJFOEP³3B|M%FMMBUPSSF²%JTDVTJwOTBMBSJBM BSDIJWBEBZEFSFEJTUSJCVJSJOHSFTPTOJIBCMBS³FO1gHJOBEFKVMJPEF "OB1BHBOP*OHSJE4WFSEMJDLZ1BVMB$PTUBT NBOFSBMBFDPOPNrBQPMrUJDBSFGVFS[BFTUSVDUVSBMNFOUFMPRVFMBDVM UVSBMPHSBJOGPSNBMNFOUF³'SBTFS -BIFHFNPOrBOFPMJCFSBMQSPNPWJwBMBTPDJFEBEDJWJMDPNPBDUPS EFDJTJWPEFMBFTDFOBEFNPDSgUJDBZBMBWF[MBEFTQPKwEFTVDBSgD UFSQPMrUJDPEFMBTEJWFSTBTZEFTJHVBMFTQPTJDJPOFTRVFEFUFOUBOFT UPTBDUPSFTFOMBFTUSVDUVSBTPDJBM"MUJFNQPUBNCJnOSFBMJ[wPUSBT PQFSBDJPOFTEJTDVSTJWBTFJEFPMwHJDBT%JWJEJwTPDJFEBEDJWJMFTUBEP ZNFSDBEPZNBSDwEJGFSFODJBTBGBWPSEFMBTPDJFEBEDJWJMFOEFUSJ NFOUPEFMFTUBEP%FTEFFTUBQFSTQFDUJWB&NJS4BEFSOPTBEWJFSUF RVFVOB²<©>WJTJwOMJCFSBMRVFDFOUSFMBBDVNVMBDJwOEFGVFS[BTFO MBPQPTJDJwOTPDJFEBEDJWJM&TUBEPFTUBSgEFTUJOBEBOPTPMBNFOUFBM GSBDBTPTJOPBQSPWPDBSNgTDPOGVTJwORVFDMBSJEBEZBWBODFT$PNP FGFDUPEFMBTSFDJFOUFTEJDUBEVSBTFOMPTQBrTFTEFMDPOPTVSIBIB CJEPVOBUFOEFODJBBSFDIB[BSMBBDDJwOFTUBUBMDPOTJEFSgOEPMBQPS EF¾OJDJwONBMnWPMBZDPOUSBQVFTUBBVOBUBNCJnOTJFNQSFCFOn¾ DB´TPDJFEBEDJWJMµ.JFOUSBTMPFTUBUBMTFJEFOUJ¾DBCBDPOMBSFQSF TJwODPOFMNBMVTPEFMPTSFDVSTPTQ|CMJDPTDPOMBCVSPDSBDJBFM FTQBDJPQSJWBEPMB´TPDJFEBEDJWJMµUFOEJwBJEFOUJ¾DBSTFDPOMPRVF TFPQPOrBBM&TUBEPJODMVTJWFQPSUnSNJOP´DJWJMµPQVFTUPBNJMJUBS³ 4BEFS 3FTBMUB FM BVUPS RVF FTF ²<©> NBOJRVFrTNP UFOEJw B HFOFSBSEPTUJQPTEFQSPCMFNBTQPSVOMBEPEFTDBSUwMBQPTJCJMJEBE EFEFNPDSBUJ[BDJwOSBEJDBMEFM&TUBEPQPSPUSPMBEPQVTPFOMBNJT NBCPMTBEFHBUPTUPEPMPRVFOPFT&TUBEPJODMVZFOEPMBTHSBOEFT FNQSFTBTQSJWBEBT<©>³4BEFS &OFTUFNBSDP4BEFSOPTSFDVFSEBRVFFO²<©>MBTUFTJTEF.BSY B QBSUJS EF MPT ´.BOVTDSJUPT FDPOwNJDPT¾MPTw¾DPTµ Z FO MBT EF (SBNTDJMBTPDJFEBEDJWJMFTVOFTQBDJPEFEJTQVUBQPSMBIFHFNPOrB FOUSFMBTDMBTFTGVOEBNFOUBMFT1PSMPUBOUPFTVOFTQBDJPRVFFOH MPCBMPNFKPSZMPQFPSRVFFMMJCFSBMJTNPJOUFOUBEJTGSB[BSBUSBWnTEF MBPQPTJDJwOFTUBUBMQSJWBEPJNQSJNJnOEPMFDPOOPUBDJPOFTQPTJUJWBT RVFJODMVZFOFM´NFSDBEPµ1BSB(SBNTDJMBTPDJFEBEDJWJMFTVOFTQB DJPQSJWJMFHJBEPEFMVDIBEFDMBTFTBUSBWFTBEPQPSMBTDPOUSBEJDDJP OFTGVOEBNFOUBMFTEFMBTPDJFEBEDBQJUBMJTUBZQPSFTUBSB[wOOPTF PQPOFBM&TUBEPQPSRVFMBDMBTFEPNJOBOUF°MBCVSHVFTrB°TFBQSPQJB EFnMZMPIBDFGVODJPOBSBGBWPSEFTVTJOUFSFTFT³4BEFS 1BSUJDJQBDJwOFJODJEFODJBEFMBTPDJFEBEDJWJMFMDBTPBSHFOUJOP "IPSB CJFO FTUBT USBOTGPSNBDJPOFT QPMrUJDBT PQFSBEBT QPS FM OFPMJCFSBMJTNPOPTwMPJODJEJFSPOFOMBTGPSNBTFTUBCMFDJEBTIFHF NwOJDBNFOUF QBSB QSPNPWFS MB QBSUJDJQBDJwO TPDJBM -PT DBNCJPT PDVSSJEPTFOFMNVOEPEFMUSBCBKPBTPDJBEPTDPOFMNPEFMPEFBDV NVMBDJwO RVFJNQPOFFTUBGBTFEFMDBQJUBMJTNP JNQMJDBSPO RVF MPT TVKFUPTBUSBWnTEFEJWFSTBTWrBTMJHBEBTDPOFNQSFOEJNJFOUPTJOEJ WJEVBMFTPHSVQBMFTTFWJFSBO²PCMJHBEPT³BQBSUJDJQBSQBSBBTFHVSBS MBSFQSPEVDDJwOEFTVTWJEBT "MSFTQFDUP.BSJTUFMMB4WBNQBOPTTF vBMBRVF²<>FMEFTNBOUFMBNJFOUPEFMNPEFMPEFSFHVMBDJwOBTPDJB EPBMSnHJNFOGPSEJTUBUSBKPDPNPDPOTFDVFODJBVOBSFGPSNVMBDJwO EFMSPMEFJOEJWJEVPFOMBTPDJFEBE1BSUFEFMBUFPSrBTPDJBMIBWFOJEP BOBMJ[BOEPEJDIPTQSPDFTPTFOUnSNJOPTEFVOBOVFWBEJOgNJDBEF JOEJWJEVBMJ[BDJwODPOTJEFSBEBDPNPMBPUSBDBSBEFMQSPDFTPEFHMP CBMJ[BDJwO(JEEFOT#FDLFOUSFPUSPT %FTEFFTUBQFSTQFDUJWBMB TPDJFEBE DPOUFNQPSgOFB FYJHF RVF MPT JOEJWJEVPT TF IBHBO DBSHP EFTrNJTNPTZRVFJOEFQFOEJFOUFNFOUFEFTVTSFDVSTPTNBUFSJBMFT Z TJNCwMJDPT EFTBSSPMMFO MPT TPQPSUFT Z MBT DPNQFUFODJBT OFDFTB SJBTQBSBHBSBOUJ[BSTVBDDFTPBMPTCJFOFTTPDJBMFT%FNBOFSBNgT HFOFSBMFMQVOUPEFQBSUJEBEFMQSPDFTPEFJOEJWJEVBMJ[BDJwOFTMB FTUSFDIBBTPDJBDJwOFOUSFFMOVFWPNPEFMPEFBDVNVMBDJwOZFMQSP DFTPEFEFTSFHVMBDJwO$JFSUBNFOUFMBEFTSFHVMBDJwODPOMMFWBVOB EFNBOEBEFBVUPSSFHVMBDJwOZMBBVUPSSFHVMBDJwOFYJHFBVUPOPNrB MBRVFFOEJGFSFOUFTHSBEPTZNFEJEBTBUSBWJFTBUBOUPMBTTPDJFEB EFTDFOUSBMFTDPNPMBTQFSJGnSJDBT³4WBNQB.BSJTUFMMB &OFTUFNBSDP;ZHNVOU#BVNBOQMBOUFBRVFMBJOEJWJEVBMJ[BDJwO DPOTJTUFFOUSBOTGPSNBSMBJEFOUJEBEIVNBOBEFBMHPEBEPFOVOBUB ;ZHNVOU#BVNBOSF¿FYJPOBTPCSFMPTOVFWPTQSPDFTPTEFJOEJWJEVBMJ[BDJwOZTFvB MBRVF²<©>MBDFSUJEVNCSFEFBZFSEJPQBTPBMBJODFSUJEVNCSFEFIPZUBOUPFOFMUSBCBKPDPNP FOMBMwHJDBEFQSPHSFTP4FUSBUBEFVOQBTBKFEFMBJODFSUJEVNCSFSFTQFDUPEFMPTNFEJPT DPODFSUF[BTPCSFMPT¾OFT BVOBJODFSUJEVNCSFSFTQFDUPEFMPT¾OFT&OFTUBFUBQBTwMPMF DPSSFTQPOEFDPNQFUFBMJOEJWJEVPEFTDVCSJSRVFFTDBQB[EFIBDFSBNQMJBSTVDBQBDJEBE FMFHJSMPT¾OFT<>WJWJSFOUSFPQDJPOFTBQBSFOUFNFOUFJO¾OJUBTPBMNFOPTFONFEJPEFNgT PQDJPOFTEFMBTRVFVOPQPESrBFMFHJS QFSNJUFMBHSBUBTFOTBDJwOEF´TFSMJCSFEFDPOWFSUJSTF FOBMHVJFOµ³4FSNPEFSOPTJHOJ¾DBRVFMBDPNQMFUVETJFNQSFFTGVUVSBC|TRVFEBJODFTBOUF EFMBHSBUJ¾DBDJwO JNQMJDBRVFSFSFTUBSVOQBTPQPSEFMBOUFEFVOPNJTNP5FOFSVOBJEFOUJ EBETwMPFYJTUFFOUBOUPQSPZFDUPJOBDBCBEP "OB1BHBOP*OHSJE4WFSEMJDLZ1BVMB$PTUBT SFBZTFUSBUBEFVOBUBSFBRVFFTSFTQPOTBCJMJEBEEFMJOEJWJEVPUBOUP DPNPTVTDPOTFDVFODJBT-BJOEJWJEVBMJ[BDJwOJNQMJDBUSBOTGPSNBSTF FOMPRVFVOP²FT³ZBRVFOPTFOBDF²TJFOEP³-BPUSBDBSBEFMBJO EJWJEVBMJ[BDJwOFTUgFOMBEFTJOUFHSBDJwOEFMDPODFQUPEFDJVEBEBOrB VODJVEBEBOPRVFQSPDVSBTVCJFOFTUBSBUSBWnTEFMCJFOFTUBSEFMB DJVEBE°MPDPN|OFTFMFTQBDJPQ|CMJDP° &OFGFDUPFOMBQFSTQFD UJWB EF MB JOEJWJEVBMJ[BDJwO FM FTQBDJP Q|CMJDP SFTVMUB QSJWBUJ[BEP ²<> &M JOUFSnT Q|CMJDP TFMJNJUB B MBDVSJPTJEBE QPS MB WJEB QSJWBEB EFMBT¾HVSBTQ|CMJDBTZFMBSUFEFMBWJEBQ|CMJDBRVFEBSFEVDJEPB MBFYIJCJDJwOQ|CMJDBEFBTVOUPTQSJWBEPTZBDPOGFTJPOFTQ|CMJDBT EFTFOUJNJFOUPTQSJWBEPT<>³#BVNBO -PDJFSUPFTRVFB QFTBSEFMBWBODFEFMBFTGFSBQSJWBEBTPCSFMBQ|CMJDBMPTQSPCMFNBT QSJWBEPTOPTFDPOTUJUVZFOFOMPQ|CMJDPOJBVOQVFTUPTFOFTFFTDF OBSJP$POUJO|BOTJFOEPBTVOUPTQSJWBEPT-PRVFFOFGFDUPBDPOUFDF FT VO EFTQMB[BNJFOUP EF MB BHFOEB VOB FYQVMTJwO EF MPT BTVOUPT Q|CMJDPTEFMBBHFOEBQPMrUJDB -BOPDJwOEFFNQPEFSBNJFOUPWJOPBSFGPS[BSFTUBTJUVBDJwO&M ²FNQPEFSBNJFOUP³ JNQMJDw VOB GPSNB EF QPUFODJBS EFDJTJPOFT Z BDDJPOFTEFMPTJOEJWJEVPTBUSBWnTEFQSPDFTPTEFBVUPEFUFSNJOB DJwO4FUSBUBEFQSgDUJDBTRVFJNQVMTBSPOMB²QBSUJDJQBDJwO³EFTVT NJFNCSPTMMBNBEPT²CFOF¾DJBSJPT³FOFMEJTDVSTPEFMBTQPMrUJDBT TPDJBMFTIFHFNwOJDBT QBSBBDDFEFSBSFDVSTPTQ|CMJDPTRVFQPSMP HFOFSBMSFEVOEwFOMBDPOTUSVDDJwOEFOVFWPTIgCJUPTTPDJBMFTFO USFMPTQPCSFT &TUBJEFBEFQBSUJDJQBDJwOZEFQSPUBHPOJTNPEFMBTPDJFEBEDJ WJM UBNCJnO FTUVWP QSFTFOUF FO MBT SFGPSNVMBDJPOFT MJHBEBT BM QB QFMEFM&TUBEPTPCSFUPEPFOFMgSFBEFMBTQPMrUJDBTTPDJBMFT&OMB "SHFOUJOBQSJODJQBMNFOUFEVSBOUFMBEnDBEBQBTBEBEJDIBTQPMrUJ DBTPUPSHBSPOVOQBQFMDFOUSBMBMB²TPDJFEBEDJWJM³OPNJOBEBDPNP ²UFSDFSTFDUPS³ "RVnTFMMBNw²UFSDFSTFDUPS³ ²$PNPDPSSFMBUPMw HJDPEFMQSFEPNJOJPEFMBTJEFPMPHrBTDMgTJDBTFOMBSFQSFTFOUBDJwO EFMBWJEBTPDJBMZMBDPOTFDVFOUFEFMJNJUBDJwOEFgNCJUPTEJGFSFO DJBEPT FM NFSDBEP MB TPDJFEBE DJWJM Z FM &TUBEP DPNP gSCJUSPT EF JOUFSFTFTQSJWBEPT TFEFTBSSPMMwVOBJOUFOTBBDDJwOZVOBWBTUBQSP EVDDJwO RVF EJP MVHBS BM DPSQVT UFwSJDPNFUPEPMwHJDP DPOTUJUVUJWP EFMBSFEJOTUJUVDJPOBMOPFTUBUBMEFBDDJwOBTJTUFODJBMZEFTFSWJDJPT 1BSUJDJQBDJwOFJODJEFODJBEFMBTPDJFEBEDJWJMFMDBTPBSHFOUJOP TPDJBMFTEFOPNJOBEB5FSDFS4FDUPSP4FDUPS4PDJBMRVFQPSFOUPODFT QPErBEFTDSJCJSTFDPNPVODBNQPFOGPSNBDJwO%FMNJTNPGPSNBCB QBSUFMBOVFWB¾MBOUSPQrBFOUFOEJEBDPNPMBNPEBMJEBEEFBQPZPZ ¾OBODJBNJFOUP EF MBT BDDJPOFT Z TFSWJDJPT TPDJBMFT Z BTJTUFODJBMFT QSFTUBEPT QPS MBT JOTUJUVDJPOFT RVF DPOGPSNBO UBM DBNQP FO BQF MBDJwO B MB CVFOB WPMVOUBE MPT TFOUJNJFOUPT ZP MPT JOUFSFTFT QBS UJDVMBSFTFOHFOFSBMSJDPTGBNPTPTZOPGBNPTPTFNQSFTBSJPTZP FNQSFTBT ³(SBTTJ %FTEFFTUBQFSTQFDUJWB&TUFMB(SBTTJQMBOUFBRVFFM²<©>5FSDFS 4FDUPSDPOTUJUVZFVOgNCJUPEFDPOWFSHFODJB&OTVGPSNBDJwODPO ¿VZFSPOEFTEFMBWJFKBUSBEJDJwO¾MBOUSwQJDBZMBCFOF¾DFODJBQSJWBEB EFMBRVFFTUSJCVUBSJBMBOVFWB¾MBOUSPQrB IBTUBMBUSBEJDJwOGVOEBEB QPSMBTQSJNJHFOJBTPSHBOJ[BDJPOFTOPHVCFSOBNFOUBMFTRVFPQFSB CBOGVOEBNFOUBMNFOUFFOFMDBNQPEFMB&EVDBDJwOZMB1SPNPDJwO 1PQVMBSZTFQSPQPOrBODPNP²FTQBDJPTEFNJMJUBODJB³$BSEBSFMMJZ 3PTFOGFME ZDPNPVOBJOTUJUVDJPOBMJEBEQPQVMBSFOGSFOUBEB BM&TUBEPDMBTJTUB³(SBTTJ -BBVUPSBBWBO[BFOTVDBSBDUF SJ[BDJwOZOPTTFvBMBRVFB²HSBOEFTSBTHPTFMUFSDFSTFDUPSRVFEw DPOTUJUVJEPQPSMBT0/(QPQVMBSFTZMBTPSHBOJ[BDJPOFTEFCBTFQPS MBTUSBEJDJPOBMFTPSHBOJ[BDJPOFTZGVOEBDJPOFTEFCFOF¾DFODJBIFSF EFSBTEFMBTWJFKBT´EBNBTµQPSMBTUBNCJnODMgTJDBTPSHBOJ[BDJPOFT EFDBSJEBEQSJODJQBMNFOUFEFMB*HMFTJB$BUwMJDBQPSJOUFSNFEJPEF $gSJUBTZFM&KnSDJUPEF4BMWBDJwOFOUSFPUSBTFOUJEBEFTZQPSOVF WBTPSHBOJ[BDJPOFTNgTPNFOPTBVUPHFTUJPOBEBTPJNQVMTBEBTQPS MPTQMBOFTZQSPHSBNBTFTUBUBMFTPDPO¾OBODJBNJFOUPFYUFSOPRVF SFRVFSrBO MB ´DPOUSBQBSUF EF MB DPNVOJEBEµ QPS PSHBOJ[BDJPOFT EF EFGFOTBEFEFSFDIPTDrWJDPTEFHSVQPTEJTDSJNJOBEPTBTrDPNPQPS MBT'VOEBDJPOFTFNQSFTBSJBTPEFEJTUJOUPPSJHFO DPOEJWFSTPTPC KFUJWPT³(SBTTJ $wNPTFBSUJDVMBSPOFTUBTPSHBOJ[BDJPOFTDPOFM&TUBEP ²&OUSF PUSBT DVFTUJPOFT FTUP EJP MVHBS B MB SFEF¾OJDJwO EF MBT SFMBDJPOFT EF MBT PSHBOJ[BDJPOFT OP HVCFSOBNFOUBMFT DPO FM &TUBEP OBDJPOBM $BSEBSFMMJZ3PTFOGFME FMDVBM°BMBWF[°UFSDFSJ[wCVFOBQBS UFEFTVTQSPQJBTJOUFSWFODJPOFTQPSFTUBWrBBVORVFQBSUJDJQBOEP EFM¾OBODJBNJFOUPEFBMHVOBTJOTUJUVDJPOFTPEFBMHVOPTQSPHSBNBT EFMBTNJTNBTPDBOBMJ[BOEPMPTQSPHSBNBTQSPQJPTQPSWrBEFMBT "OB1BHBOP*OHSJE4WFSEMJDLZ1BVMB$PTUBT PSHBOJ[BDJPOFT EF MB DPNVOJEBE DPNP DPOUSBQBSUF MPDBM QPS DVZB DVFOUB DPSSJw HFOFSBMNFOUF FM USBCBKP WPMVOUBSJP -B QBSUJDJQB DJwOEFM&TUBEPDPNPFOUJEBERVFDBOBMJ[BCBGPOEPTDPNQMFKJ[wMB SFMBDJwO EF FTUF Z MBT PSHBOJ[BDJPOFT Z EJP MVHBS B MB BQBSJDJwO EF 0/( ´QSPNPWJEBTµ QPS MBT QSPQJBT P¾DJOBT P QSPHSBNBT HVCFSOB NFOUBMFTUPEBWF[RVFMPTQSnTUBNPTQBSBBTJTUFODJBZQSPNPDJwO GVFSBODPOEJDJPOBEPTBMB´QBSUJDJQBDJwOEFPSHBOJ[BDJPOFTMPDBMFTµ 'JOBMNFOUF B MPT GPOEPT Q|CMJDPT TF BHSFHw MB ¾MBOUSPQrB MPDBM EF FNQSFTBTZGVOEBDJPOFTFOFM¾OBODJBNJFOUPEFMBTPSHBOJ[BDJPOFT EFMTFDUPS³(SBTTJ -BBVUPSBBHSFHBRVF²<©>OPTwMPMBSFMB DJwO¾OBODJFSBDPOFM&TUBEPEFWJOPQSPCMFNgUJDBQBSBMBBVUPOPNrB EFMBTPSHBOJ[BDJPOFTUBNCJnOMBTFOUJEBEFT¾OBODJFSBTGVOEBDJP OFT¾MBOUSwQJDBTBHFODJBTZPSHBOJTNPTEFDPPQFSBDJwOJOUFSOBDJP OBMFTPOBDJPOBMFT ¾KBOTVTQPMrUJDBTEFBTJHOBDJwOEFSFDVSTPTMP RVFIBDPOTUSFvJEPBMBT0/(BBEFDVBSMBTTVZBTPCKFUJWPTZUJQP EFTFSWJDJPT¾OFTZNPEBMJEBEFTEFUSBCBKP BMBPGFSUBEF¾OBODJB NJFOUP³(SBTTJ 2Vn DPOTFDVFODJBT USBKP FTUF NPEFMP FO MBT SFMBDJPOFT FOUSF PSHBOJ[BDJPOFTTPDJBMFTZ&TUBEP ²&MDBSgDUFSFYQMrDJUBNFOUFQPMr UJDPEFMBTJOUFSWFODJPOFTTPDJBMFTTVJNQPTJDJwO FTMPRVFSFTVMUB DVFTUJPOBEPDPOMBUFSDFSJ[BDJwOZMBTVCTJEJBSJEBEEFM&TUBEPFO NBUFSJBEFJOUFSWFODJPOFTTPDJBMFTBMSFTPMWFSTFEFFTUFNPEPMBT DPOEJDJPOFTEFVTPEFMPTSFDVSTPTQ|CMJDPTZFMUJQPEFMB[PTRVF DBSBDUFSJ[BOMPTDPNQPSUBNJFOUPTQPMrUJDPTBOBMJ[BEPTFOFMQVOUP BOUFSJPS 1PS FTP MB DPOTUJUVDJwO EFM TFDUPS TPDJBM EF JOUFSWFODJP OFTTPDJBMFTDPNPQPMrUJDBEF&TUBEPEFCFFOUFOEFSTFFOFMNBSDP EFMQSPZFDUPQPMrUJDPJOTQJSBEPQPSMBJEFPMPHrBEFMOFPMJCFSBMJTNP³ (SBTTJ 2Vn JNQBDUPT UVWJFSPO FTUBT QPMrUJDBT FO FM FTQBDJP MPDBM DP NVOJUBSJPCBSSJBMEFMBTDMBTFTQPQVMBSFT -PDJFSUPFTRVFMFKPTEF BVTFOUBSTFFM&TUBEPFOFTUPTUFSSJUPSJPTnTUFTFIJ[PQSFTFOUFFOEJ DIBTQSgDUJDBTBUSBWnTEFMBBQMJDBDJwOEFQPMrUJDBTGPDBMJ[BEBT%F 7BMF MB QFOB EFTUBDBS RVF FTUPT FTQBDJPT DPNVOBMFT FTUVWJFSPO TJHOBEPT QPS QSgDUJDBTDMJFOUFMBSFT6OBNJSBEBTPCSFFTUFUJQPEFJOUFSBDDJPOFTQVFEFDPMPDBSFMGPDPFO VOB QFSTQFDUJWB RVF BOBMJDF MBT SFMBDJPOFT EF EPNJOBDJwO RVF TF UFKFO FOUSF NFEJBEPSFT Z 1BSUJDJQBDJwOFJODJEFODJBEFMBTPDJFEBEDJWJMFMDBTPBSHFOUJOP FTUFNPEPMBQPUFODJBMJEBEZFMTFOUJEPEFFTUBTBDDJPOFTFODBSBEBT QPSPSHBOJ[BDJPOFTDPNVOJUBSJBTZEFMBTPDJFEBEDJWJMOPBQVOUBSPO BSFWFSUJSMPTQBSgNFUSPTFTUSVDUVSBMFTEFEFTJHVBMEBETPDJBMZFDP OwNJDBOJBJOUFSQFMBSBM&TUBEPQBSBRVFnTUFDPOTUSVZFSBJOTUBO DJBTJOTUJUVDJPOBMFTRVFBTFHVSBSBOMBEJTUSJCVDJwOBRVFMMPTCJFOFTZ TFSWJDJPTDBQBDFTEFHBSBOUJ[BSMBDJVEBEBOrBEFUPEPTMPTTFDUPSFT &OUPODFTEFTEFOVFTUSBQFSTQFDUJWBMBQBSUJDJQBDJwOQMBOUFBEB OP DPOTUJUVZw QBSB MPT TFDUPSFT QPQVMBSFT VOB FYQSFTJwO B USBWnT EFMBDVBMTFFOTBODIBSPOTVTQPTJCJMJEBEFTEFDJVEBEBOrBEFEF NPDSBDJBEFQPEFS.gTCJFOTFWJFSPO²PCMJHBEPT³BQBSUJDJQBSB QBSUJSEFSFEFTEFTPCSFWJWFODJBEFDBSgDUFSUFSSJUPSJBMQPSMPSFHVMBS GVODJPOBMFT B MBT OVFWBT GPSNBT EF DPOUSPM Z EPNJOBDJwO QPMrUJDB 2VnMMFWBBFTUPTTFDUPSFTBNPWFSTFFOEJGFSFOUFTFTQBDJPTQ|CMJ DPT ²5SFTQSJNFSPTGBDUPSFTFNQVKBOBTrBMBNPWJMJ[BDJwODPMFDUJWB TPCSFMBBSFOBQ|CMJDB&OQSJNFSMVHBSMBJOTV¾DJFODJBEFJOHSFTPT MPDVBMMPTWVFMWFEFQFOEJFOUFTEFMPTSFDVSTPTDVZPBDDFTPSFRVJFSF EFVOQBTPPCMJHBUPSJPQPSFMTJTUFNBQPMrUJDPEPOEFTPODPOUSPMB EBTMBTJOTUJUVDJPOFTRVFNPOPQPMJ[BOFTPTSFDVSTPT %FTQVnTVOB EJTUSJCVDJwOEFQSPEVDUPTZVOBCBTUFDJNJFOUPEFTFSWJDJPTFGFDUVB EPTJFNQSFQPSEFCBKPEFMBTOFDFTJEBEFTMPRVFPCMJHBBFTUBSQFS QFUVBNFOUFFOCVTDBEFBMHVOBDPTB'JOBMNFOUFMBEJ¾DVMUBE°NgT B|OMBJNQPTJCJMJEBE°EFJOTDSJCJSMBTGPSNBTEFBDDFTPBM%FSFDIP DMJFOUFTFMJOUFSDBNCJPEFGBWPSFTRVFSFBMJ[BOMPTNJTNPTMBHBNBEFDPOEJDJPOBNJFOUPT QSFTFOUFT FO MBT QFSDFQDJPOFT Z BDUJUVEFT RVF DSV[BO FM KVFHP EF SFHMBT ²QFSTPOBMFT³ B MB IPSBEFQMBOFBSZFKFDVUBSMBTGPSNBTEFEJTUSJCVDJwOEFMPTSFDVSTPT4FUSBUBEFVOEJTQPTJ UJWPDFOUSBMEFMBHFTUJwOEFMBTQPMrUJDBTTPDJBMFTEFVOBEFMBTNPEBMJEBEFTEFJOUFSWFODJwO QSJWJMFHJBEB RVF DBSBDUFSJ[w B MB JNQMFNFOUBDJwO EF QSPHSBNBT TPDJBMFT EVSBOUF MB EnDBEB EFMOPWFOUBZRVFDPOTUJUVZwVOSFUSPDFTPFOBRVFMMPTBTQFDUPTSFGFSJEPTBMFKFSDJDJPEFMPT EFSFDIPTTPDJBMFT-BTMwHJDBTQSFTFOUFTFOFTUBTQSgDUJDBTTVTDPOTFDVFODJBTFOFMFKFSDJDJP EFMBWJEBDJVEBEBOBFOMBEFHSBEBDJwOEFMBTDPOEJDJPOFTEFWJEBEFMPTTFDUPSFTQPQVMBSFT OPUJFOFOBOVFTUSPKVJDJPDPNPSFTQPOTBCMFQSJODJQBMBMBUSBNBRVFTFUFKFFOUSF²NFEJBEP SFT³Z²DMJFOUFT³"MSFTQFDUP.BHEBMFOB$IJBSB TFQSFHVOUBTPCSFMBTSFMBDJPOFTFOUSF FTUPTQSPDFTPTZMBTSFGPSNBTEFM&TUBEPFOHFOFSBMZQMBOUFB² &ORVnNFEJEBFTUBTQSgDUJDBT ´NJDSPµFTUgOFYQSFTBOEPEFGPSNBQBSUJDVMBSMPTQSPDFTPTEFQSJWBUJ[BDJwO ³<©>ZBTJNJTNP DPOTJEFSBTJFTUBQSFPDVQBDJwOOPQFSNJUF²DVFTUJPOBSMPTQSPDFTPT´NBDSPµRVFFTUgOEBOEP TFOUJEPBFTUBTGPSNBTRVFQBSFDFOTFSQSFWJBTBVORVFFONFOPSFTDBMB BMPTQSPDFTPTEF BKVTUFSFGPSNBDPOMPTRVFOPTFOGSFOUBNPT³ "OB1BHBOP*OHSJE4WFSEMJDLZ1BVMB$PTUBT MPRVFMBTPCMJHBBVOBOFHPDJBDJwODPOTUBOUFDPOMBTBENJOJTUSBDJP OFTZMBTBVUPSJEBEFT³.FSLMFO &O FTUF NBSDP %FOJT .FSLMFS UBNCJnO BQVOUB RVF FO ²<©> MBT HSBOEFTDJVEBEFTEF"NnSJDB-BUJOBFTUBEFQFOEFODJBQPMrUJDBTFIB BDFOUVBEPDPOFMEFUFSJPSPEFMBTDPOEJDJPOFTEFWJEBZMBEFTBSUJ DVMBDJwOEFMPTTJTUFNBTEFQSPUFDDJwOTPDJBMTPCSFUPEPFTUBUBMFT BVORVFUBNCJnOEFMPTTJOEJDBUPTRVFTPOEFHSBOJNQPSUBODJBFO DJFSUPTQBrTFTDPNP"SHFOUJOBP6SVHVBZ 1FSPMBEFQFOEFODJBSFT QFDUP EF MPT TJTUFNBT QPMrUJDPT MPDBMFT TF SFGPS[w EF JHVBM NBOFSB USBTMBSFPSJFOUBDJwOEFMBTQPMrUJDBTQ|CMJDBT-BEFTDFOUSBMJ[BDJwO ZFMFOGPRVFEFMBTQPMrUJDBTTPDJBMFTDPOUSJCVZFSPOBUFSSJUPSBMJ[BS FMBDDFTPBMBBZVEBTPDJBM%VSBOUFMPTBvPTZTPCSFUPEPEVSBO UFMPTMPTHPCJFSOPTPSJFOUBSPOTVBDDJwOTPDJBMFOVOBMwHJDBEF ´QSPZFDUPTµDPOMBJOUFODJwOEFMVDIBSDPOUSBMBQPCSF[BFOGVODJwO EFOFDFTJEBEFTZEFPCKFUJWPTRVFEFCrBOTFSEF¾OJEPTMPDBMNFOUF "TrWJTUPEFTEFBCBKPMBQVFTUBFONBSDIBEFFTUBOVFWBPSJFOUB DJwOUVWPFGFDUPTCJFOQSFDJTPTUSBTMBJOWJUBDJwOBMB´QBSUJDJQBDJwO BDUJWBµMPTIBCJUBOUFTEFMPTCBSSJPTEFCJFSPOPSHBOJ[BSTFB¾OEF FTUBSQSFTFOUFTBMMrEPOEFTFEJTQPOrBEFSFDVSTPTBUBMQVOUPRVF TFFTQFDJBMJ[BSPOZFOEPJODMVTPIBTUBVOBDJFSUB´QSPGFTJPOBMJ[BDJwOµ FOMBQSFTFOUBDJwOEFQSPZFDUPTQBSBMBNVKFSDVBOEPMB¾OBODJB DJwOTFPSJFOUBCBFOSFMBDJwOBMHnOFSPQBSBMBJOGBODJBDVBOEPFTB MPTDIJDPTRVFTFMFTEBQBSBMPTBMJNFOUPTDVBOEPMPRVFTFSFQBSUF FTEFPSEFOBMJNFOUBSJPDPOUSBFM4JEBMBWJWJFOEBPFMFOUPSOPVSCB OPFODBOUJEBEEFQSPZFDUPTEFEFTBSSPMMPCBSSJBM &TTPSQSFOEFOUF WFSMBWFSTBUJMJEBEMB´¿FYJCJMJEBEµZMBDBQBDJEBEEFFNQSFOEJNJFO UP EF MPT EJSJHFOUFT CBSSJBMFT QVFT EFCFO EJSJHJSTF B MB JOTUJUVDJwO BMBRVF´QSFDJTBNFOUFIPZµTFMFQVFEFTBDBSBMHPMBJOUFOEFODJB FOJOWJFSOPVOB0/(FYUSBOKFSBFTUFBvPVOBJHMFTJBFOPUPvPFM QBSUJEP#MBODPQBSBMPTQSPZFDUPTEFWJWJFOEBPFM$PMPSBEPQBSBMPT SFMBDJPOBEPTDPOMBBMJNFOUBDJwOZFM'SFOUF"NQMJPQBSBUPEPMPRVF DPODJFSOFBMNVOJDJQJP³.FSLMFO &MBVUPSBWBO[BFOTVTSF¿FYJPOFTZBHSFHBRVFEF²FTUBNBOF SB TF PCMJHB B MPT IBCJUBOUFT B NPWFSTF FO VOB MwHJDB EF ´DB[BEP SFTµ BDFDIBOEP QFSNBOFOUFNFOUF MB QSFTB QBSB MMFWBSMB BM CBSSJP 4FFODVFOUSBOFOVONFEJPSJDPFOQPTJCJMJEBEFTZPDBTJPOFTEBEBT 1BSUJDJQBDJwOFJODJEFODJBEFMBTPDJFEBEDJWJMFMDBTPBSHFOUJOP QPSMBDPNQMFKJEBEEFMTJTUFNBJOTUJUVDJPOBMZQPSMBOBUVSBMF[BEFM KVFHP QPMrUJDP 4JO FNCBSHP OP QVFEFO JOTDSJCJSTF FO TJTUFNBT EF SFHVMBDJwOFTUBCJMJ[BEBTQPSFMEFSFDIPZMBJOTDSJQDJwOJOTUJUVDJPOBM³ .FSLMFO %FFTUFNPEPMPT²<©>IBCJUBOUFTZTVTPSHBOJ[B DJPOFTMPDBMFTTPOPCMJHBEPTBVOBNVMUJQMJDJEBEEFMwHJDBTEFBDDJwO RVFEPNJOBONgTPNFOPT ZBNVMUJQMJDBSJHVBMNFOUFTVTB¾MJBDJP OFTJOTUJUVDJPOBMFT³.FSLMFO "IPSBCJFODVBOUPNBZPSFTMB QSFDBSJFEBEJOTUJUVDJPOBMNBZPSFTFMBVNFOUPEFMBTEJWFSTBT¾MJB DJPOFTRVFQPTFFOMPTIBCJUBOUFTEFVOCBSSJP"TrDVBOUP²<©>NgT NBTJWBFTMBQSFDBSJFEBEZNgTGBMMBOMBTJOTUJUVDJPOFTNgTNVMUJ QMJDBOMPTIBCJUBOUFTTVTQFSUFOFODJBT&OFGFDUPFMUFSSJUPSJPEFMPT CBSSJPTTFDPOTUJUVZFBQBSUJSEFMBTVQFSQPTJDJwOEFDrSDVMPTEFQFS UFOFODJBJHMFTJBTCBOEBTEFKwWFOFTSFEFTEFUSg¾DPTEJWFSTPTFM HSVQPEFMBPMMBQPQVMBSZFMEFMBHVBSEFSrBFUD³.FSLMFO 1PDPUJFOFORVFWFSFTUBTBDDJPOFTDPOQSPDFTPTEFQBSUJDJQBDJwO FOMPTDVBMFTFMEFSFDIPMBDPOTUSVDDJwOEFPUSPNPEFMPTPDJFUBMZ MBEJTUSJCVDJwOEFMQPEFSTFIBMMFOFOFMIPSJ[POUF³:TJMBMJNJUBDJwO BMPMPDBMFTBNFOVEPMBBNFOB[BRVFQFTBTPCSFFTUBTQPCMBDJP OFT FM EFSFDIP BQBSFDF DPNP MrNJUF TVQFSJPS EF MB SFMBDJwO DPO MP QPMrUJDPUBMDPNPFTUFFWPMVDJPOBBQBSUJSEFVOBCBTFUFSSJUPSJBM&O FGFDUPDPNPIBCJUBOUFTEFMCBSSJPMPT´DJVEBEBOPTµQVFEFOJOUFOUBS NPWJMJ[BSFMEFSFDIPBTVGBWPS²UFOFNPTEFSFDIPBMBWJWJFOEB³ QFSP EJGrDJMNFOUF FTUBSgO FO DPOEJDJPOFT EF NPEJ¾DBS MB MFZ P EF UFOFS JO¿VFODJB TPCSF FM PSEFO JOTUJUVDJPOBM 1PS FMMP TF BGBOBO FO VOB JOUFSNJOBCMF C|TRVFEB EF SFDVSTPT DVZB EJTUSJCVDJwO OP FTUg HBSBOUJ[BEB QPS OJOH|O EFSFDIP P MP RVF OP FT QPTJCMF BDDFEFS B DBVTBEFMBTEJTGVODJPOFTZEFMBTJOTV¾DJFODJBTJOTUJUVDJPOBMFT&O FTUFDPOUFYUPTFJOTDSJCFVOBCVFOBQBSUFEFMBTJOJDJBUJWBTEF´MVDIB DPOUSBMBQPCSF[BµMMFWBEBTBDBCPQPSBMHVOBTPSHBOJ[BDJPOFTJOUFS OBDJPOBMFT Z QPS VOB CVFOB DBOUJEBE EF 0/( &T QPS FMMP UBNCJnO RVF FO MVHBS EF NPEJ¾DBS MB TJUVBDJwO DPOUSB MB DVBM MVDIBO FTUBT FTUSBUFHJBTUFSNJOBOQPSSFGPS[BSFTBTMwHJDBTEFGVODJPOBNJFOUPZB EFNBTJBEPCJFOFTUBCMFDJEBFOMPTCBSSJPTQPCSFT³%FFTUFNPEP DSFFNPTRVFMB²<©>NPWJMJ[BDJwOQPMrUJDBOPTPTUJFOFMBTPMBDPOT USVDDJwOEFVOBOBDJwOPMBEFGFOTBEFVOPTEFSFDIPTQBSBUPEPT TJOPMBPCUFODJwOEFSFTVMUBEPTJONFEJBUPT³<©>²$POGSPOUBEPTBMB "OB1BHBOP*OHSJE4WFSEMJDLZ1BVMB$PTUBT QSFDBSJFEBEBMPJODJFSUPZBMBNPWJMJ[BDJwOEFMPTJOEJWJEVPTMBT DMBTFTQPQVMBSFTDPNQPOFOGPSNBTNgTPNFOPTCBTUBSEBTEFDJV EBEBOrBRVFMFTQFSNJUFIBDFSGSFOUFBWFDFTBFTBTEJ¾DVMUBEFT³ .FSLMFO :BNFODJPOBNPTRVFFONBSDPEFMOFPMJCFSBMJTNPFMDPODFQUPEF QBSUJDJQBDJwOBTVNJwEJGFSFOUFTEJSFDDJPOFT1PSFTPQPEFNPTTFvB MBSRVFOPUPEBPSHBOJ[BDJwOTPDJBMRVFEwDPO¾OBEBBFTUFNBQBQP MrUJDPUBOSFTUSJDUJWPZGVODJPOBMBMOFPMJCFSBMJTNP&OFTUFDPOUFYUP ²<©>TFIBDFOFDFTBSJPEJGFSFODJBSFOFMDBNQPEFOUSPEFMRVFRVF EBSPO JOUFHSBEBT B MBT PSHBOJ[BDJPOFT TPDJBMFT DPOTUJUVJEBT DPNP BDUPSFTDPMFDUJWPTRVFTFNPWJMJ[BOQPSJOTUJUVJSSFBMJ[BSPMPHSBSFM SFDPOPDJNJFOUPEFMPTJOUFSFTFTZOFDFTJEBEFTEFVODPMFDUJWPEFUFS NJOBEPFTEFDJSTVSFDPOPDJNJFOUPDPNPTVKFUPEFEFSFDIPTDrWJDPT ZTPDJBMFTMBTNVKFSFTMPTOJvPTMPTEFTPDVQBEPTVOBNJOPSrBRVF TVGSF EJTDSJNJOBDJwO QPCMBDJwO FYDMVJEB EFM BDDFTP B MB UJFSSB Z MB WJWJFOEBMBTPSHBOJ[BDJPOFTEFEFSFDIPTIVNBOPT RVFJNQVMTBOMB GPSNBDJwOEFVOFTQBDJPQ|CMJDPQPMJUJ[BEPZEFTBUBOQSPDFTPTQPMr UJDPDVMUVSBMFTRVFQVFEFOQMBTNBSFONBSDPTOPSNBUJWPTFJOTUJUV DJPOBMFTDPODBQBDJEBEEFJNQPOFSFMEFCFSDrWJDPEFTVTFHVSJEBE TPDJBMZQPMrUJDB EFBRVFMMBTEFTUJOBEBTBBQMJDBSMPTSFDVSTPTEFMB ¾MBOUSPQrBRVFBCBSDBEBTQPSVONPWJNJFOUPQPMrUJDPRVFEFTQPMJUJ [BFMFTQBDJPQ|CMJDPTPOEFTCPSEBEBTFOTVTJHOJ¾DBDJwOFOUBOUP SFUSPUSBFOBMPTUnSNJOPTEFMB´CVFOBWPMVOUBEµPMB´QJFEBEµMBPCMJ HBDJwOTPDJBMEFBUFOEFSOFDFTJEBEFTEFEJGFSFOUFrOEPMF FNBOBEB EFMQSJODJQJPMJCFSBMNPEFSOPEFMBJHVBMEBE³(SBTTJ :FTEFTEFFTUBQFSTQFDUJWBRVFFTOFDFTBSJPSFTDBUBSBMBTPDJF EBEDJWJM²<©>FOVOTFOUJEPIJTUwSJDPEFBSFOBFOMBRVFTFEJSJNF MBQPMrUJDBPNgTBEFDVBEBNFOUFMBIFHFNPOrB OPTFSFEVDFBM UFSDFSTFDUPSPTFDUPSTPDJBM"MBWF[MPTNFEJPTZSFDVSTPTEFQPEFS ZEFIFHFNPOrBOPTPOZBPNFOPTRVFOVODB FMTwMPJOUFSDBNCJPZ MBJOUFSBDDJwOEJSFDUBOJTwMPMPTQBSUJEPTQPMrUJDPTPMPTNFEJPTEF DPNVOJDBDJwOPMBTJOTUJUVDJPOFTZQPMrUJDBTEF&TUBEP5PEPTFMMPT TPOTJNVMUgOFBNFOUFFTQBDJPTEFDPORVJTUBSFDVSTPTEFQPEFSZ BVOBDUPSFTFOMBMVDIBQPSMBIFHFNPOrB³(SBTTJ &OFTUFNBSDPBEJGFSFODJBEFEnDBEBTBOUFSJPSFTEPOEFMPTQSP UBHPOJTUBTQPMrUJDPTFSBOPFM²QVFCMP³PMPTUSBCBKBEPSFTMPTQSP 1BSUJDJQBDJwOFJODJEFODJBEFMBTPDJFEBEDJWJMFMDBTPBSHFOUJOP DFTPTEFEFTDPMFDUJWJ[BDJwOMJHBEPTDPOMBEFTJOEVTUSJBM[BDJwORVF BUSBWFTw B OVFTUSP QBrT EFTFNCPDBSPO FO MB BQBSJDJwO EF OVFWPT TVKFUPT TPDJBMFT DVZBT QSgDUJDBT MF JNQSJNJFSPO OVFWPT TFOUJEPT B MPTQSPDFTPTEFDJVEBEBOJ[BDJwOBMB¾HVSBEFMBMVDIBTQPSMPTEF SFDIPTDJVEBEBOPT²&TVOEFOPNJOBEPSDPN|OBMBDPO¾HVSBDJwOEF EJTUJOUBTJEFOUJEBEFTTPDJBMFTFO"SHFOUJOBEVSBOUFFM|MUJNPEFDF OJPFMMMBNBEPBMBJOTUJUVDJwOEFNFEJBDJPOFTDJVEBEBOBT&TUPFT MBBQFMBDJwOBDPOTUJUVJSWrODVMPTCBKPMBGPSNBEFEFSFDIPTDPOUSB QSgDUJDBTRVFTVQVTJFSPOTVEFTUJUVDJwOEFGPSNBDJwOPSFFNQMB[P EFTEFEJTUJOUPTNPWJNJFOUPTZGPSNBTPSHBOJ[BUJWBTRVFGVFSPOBS UJDVMBOEPQPTJUJWBNFOUFFTUBTSFTJTUFODJBTBVOBSFEF¾OJDJwOEFMPT BTVOUPTQ|CMJDPTZEFMBTGPSNBTEFQBSUJDJQBDJwO³<©>²"EJGFSFODJB EFNPWJNJFOUPTIJTUwSJDPTRVFBCSFWBSPOTVQPUFODJBDJVEBEBOJ[BO UF EFM EFSFDIP DPMFDUJWP EFM ´QVFCMPµ P MB OBDJwO B SF GPSNVMBS MB DPNVOJEBEQPMrUJDBEFTEFVOBTJUVBDJwOEFBTVNJEBQPTUFSHBDJwOZ NFEJBOUFMBBDDJwOSFQBSBUPSJBFTUBUBMMPTNPWJNJFOUPTDPOUFNQP SgOFPTTFDPOTUJUVZFOQPSGVFSBEFM&TUBEPZSFQSFTFOUBO´DBTPTEF VOJWFSTBMJTNPJOUFOTJWPµ°BRVFMRVFFYJHFMBOPEJTDSJNJOBDJwOEFMPT JOEJWJEVPT°QPSTPCSFDVBMRVJFSGPSNVMBEF´VOJWFSTBMJTNPFYUFOTJWPµ °FMRVFCVTDBTVVOJGPSNJEBE°#BMJCBS &TDPOUSBVODPOTFOTP WJTVBMJ[BEP FO UPSOP BM PSEFO FTUBUBM DPNP |OJDP SFHVMBEPS EF MBT SFMBDJPOFTTPDJBMFTZBMNFSDBEPDPNPEJTQPTJUJWPPCMJHBEPEFJOUF HSBDJwORVFTFNVMUJQMJDBOMPTDPO¿JDUPTRVFFTUgOFOMBCBTFEFMBT DJVEBEBOrBTFNFSHFOUFT³%FMBNBUB %FTEFFTUBQFSTQFDUJWB QPEFNPTBEWFSUJSRVF²<©>MBTOVFWBTWJODVMBDJPOFTFOUSFTPDJFEBE ZFTUBEPDPO¾HVSBEBTEFTEFFMJOUFSJPSEFMBTOVFWBTJEFOUJEBEFT IBZBOFNFSHJEPFOMPTUFSSJUPSJPTTPDJBMFTZQPMrUJDPTGSBHNFOUBEPT DPNQPSUBOEP WFSEBEFSPT NPWJNJFOUPT EF SFUFSSJUPSJBMJ[BDJwO EF QPMJUJ[BDJwOEFMPTUFSSJUPSJPTIBCJUBEPTZEFTVTFOMBDFTZSFMBDJPOFT DPOFMFTQBDJPOBDJPOBMNgTBNQMJP³%FMBNBUB &OOVFTUSPQBrTMBTOVFWBTQSgDUJDBTDJVEBEBOBTUBNCJnOSFDVQF SBSPOMPTSFDPSSJEPTZUSBZFDUPTEFMPTDPMFDUJWPTTPDJBMFTIJTUwSJDPT MB NFNPSJB EF MBT EJWFSTBT MVDIBT FOUBCMBEBT QBSB FOTBODIBS MBT CBTFTEFMPTEFSFDIPTEFMBTNBZPSrBT%FBMMrFNFSHJFSPOOVFWBT FYQFSJFODJBTZIPSJ[POUFTQPMrUJDPT:BOPTFSgOFMQVFCMPMPTUSBCB KBEPSFTPMPTTJOEJDBUPTMPTBDUPSFTGVOEBNFOUBMFTEFMPTQSPDFTPT "OB1BHBOP*OHSJE4WFSEMJDLZ1BVMB$PTUBT EF QBSUJDJQBDJwO "QBSFDFO OVFWBT PSHBOJ[BDJPOFT DPO EJGFSFOUFT USBEJDJPOFTZNBUSJDFTQPMrUJDBTRVFEFTEFFMDBNQPEFMB²TPDJFEBE DJWJM³FOUFOEJEBFTUBDPNPBSFOBEPOEFTFEJSJNFMBQPMrUJDB FODB SBSPOBUSBWnTEFOVFWBTQFSTQFDUJWBTBDDJPOFTDPMFDUJWBTEFSFTJT UFODJBZEFMVDIB&OFTUFNBSDPFODPOUSBNPTNPWJNJFOUPTEFNBUSJ[ TJOEJDBMDPNPFTFMDBTPEFMB$FOUSBMEF5SBCBKBEPSFT"SHFOUJOPT EFSBr[UFSSJUPSJBMDPNPMPTNPWJNJFOUPTEFEFTPDVQBEPTPBRVFMMPT MJHBEPT DPO MB UJFSSB Z MB WJWJFOEB EFM NVOEP SVSBM DPNP MPT NP WJNJFOUPT EF DBNQFTJOPT P EF NVKFSFT BHSPQFDVBSJBT "TJNJTNP UBNCJnO TF EFTUBDBSPO MPT NPWJNJFOUPT EF NVKFSFT EF KVCJMBEPT EF MVDIB DPOUSB MB WJPMFODJB QPMJDJBM FOUSF PUSPT 1BSUJDVMBSNFOUF FODBTPEFMDBNQPFEVDBUJWPGVFSPOMPTTJOEJDBUPTEPDFOUFTTPCSF UPEPBRVFMMPTBHSVQBEPTFO$FOUSBMEF5SBCBKBEPSFTEFMB&EVDBDJwO EFMB3FQ|CMJDB"SHFOUJOB$5&3" MPTRVFFOGSFOUBSPOMPTFNCBUFT EFMBTQPMrUJDBTOFPMJCFSBMFTFOFEVDBDJwO"Tr²<©>VOBCVFOBQBS UFEFMBTBDDJPOFTDPMFDUJWBTFNQSFOEJEBTQPSMPTNPWJNJFOUPTTP DJBMFT FYQSFTBO VOB MVDIB QPS BNQMJBS Z SFGPSNVMBS MB DPNVOJEBE FOMPTEPTTFOUJEPTSFGFSJEPTQPS'SBTFS BTBCFSUBOUPFOFM QMBOPFDPOwNJDPQPMrUJDPDPNPFOFMDVMUVSBMTJNCwMJDP"UrUVMPEF FKFNQMP MBT EFNBOEBT EF MBT PSHBOJ[BDJPOFT QJRVFUFSBT TVSHJEBT FOMB|MUJNBEnDBEBFOMB"SHFOUJOBQVFEFOTFSDPNQSFOEJEBTDPNP FMFODBCBMHBNJFOUPZMBZVYUBQPTJDJwOEFBNCBTEJNFOTJPOFTQPS VOMBEPDPNPVOBMVDIBPSJFOUBEBBPCUFOFSFMSFDPOPDJNJFOUPRVF BMVEFUBOUPBMBJOWJTJCJMJEBEJOJDJBMEFMPTEFTPDVQBEPTDPNP°NgT SFDJFOUFNFOUF° B MB FTUJHNBUJ[BDJwO TPDJBM RVF QBEFDFO QPS PUSP MBEPDPNPVOBMVDIBRVFBQVOUBBEFOVODJBSMBFTUSVDUVSBEFEFT JHVBMEBE Z EF QSJWBDJwO EFOUSP EFM BDUVBM NPEFMP EF BDVNVMBDJwO DPOMPDVBMEFTMJ[BFOUPODFTMBDVFTUJwOEFMBSF EJTUSJCVDJwOEFMPT CJFOFTTPDJBMFT"VORVFDPONVDIBNFOPTWJTJCJMJEBEFOFTUBEJSFD DJwO QVFEFO JODMVJSTF UBNCJnO MBT EFNBOEBT B GBWPS EFM SFDPOPDJ NJFOUPEFMPTEFSFDIPTUFSSJUPSJBMFTZBNCJFOUBMFTQSPUBHPOJ[BEBT QPS MPT NPWJNJFOUPT DBNQFTJOPT WFDJOBMFT F JOErHFOBT BTr DPNP BRVFMMPTSFDMBNPTRVFBQVOUBOBMBBDFQUBDJwOFJODMVTJwOEFMBEJ WFSTJEBETFYVBM³4WBNQB 1PSPUSPMBEPDPNPZBEFTDSJCJNPTVOQVOUPDSVDJBMEFMPTQSPDF TPTEFEPNJOBDJwOQPMrUJDBTFQMBTNwFOMBSFMBDJwOFOUSFFM&TUBEP 1BSUJDJQBDJwOFJODJEFODJBEFMBTPDJFEBEDJWJMFMDBTPBSHFOUJOP ZMBTPSHBOJ[BDJPOFTTPDJBMFTSFMBDJwOTJHOBEBQPSWrODVMPTEFTVC PSEJOBDJwO FO NVDIPT DBTPT MJHBEBT B QSgDUJDBT DMJFOUFMBSFT 4JO FNCBSHPZBMNJTNPUJFNQPUBNCJnOTFQVTJFSPOFOQSgDUJDBPUSBT NPEBMJEBEFTEFSFMBDJwOFOUSFBNCPTBDUPSFTFOEPOEFMBTPSHBOJ [BDJPOFTTPDJBMFTQSPDVSBSPOBCSJSVOBFYQFSJFODJBEJTUJOUBSFTQFDUP EFMBTQPMrUJDBTQ|CMJDBT²<©>TFUSBUBEFEFVOB´GPSNBEFFOUFOEFS MBQPMrUJDBµRVFSFDMBNBMBJNQMFNFOUBDJwOEFEFSFDIPTBTVNJFOEP MBQBSUJDJQBDJwOEFMPTNPWJNJFOUPTZPSHBOJ[BDJPOFTTPDJBMFTFOMB EF¾OJDJwOEFMPTTFOUJEPTZDPOUFOJEPTEFMPQ|CMJDPFTUBUBM:FTUF SFDMBNPEFDPOUBSFOFM&TUBEPTFWJFOFFONBSDBOEPBUSBWnTEFJOT UBODJBTQBSUJDJQBUJWBTZNPEBMJEBEFTEFSFMBDJwOZOFHPDJBDJwODPO MBJOTUBODJBFTUBUBMRVFBOUFTVBVTFODJBPGBMMBQVHOBOQPSTVSDBS MBT³%FMBNBUB "IPSBCJFOPUSPQVOUPEFUFOTJwOFTFMRVFTFFYQSFTBFOFMEFT FODVFOUSPDPODFQUVBMZQPMrUJDPFOUSFMBTOVFWBTJEFOUJEBEFTTPDJB MFTFOUSFMPTNPWJNJFOUPTTPDJBMFTZQPMrUJDPTZMBDPOTUSVDDJwOEF DJVEBEBOrB:BNFODJPOBNPTRVFMBBQBSJDJwOEFOVFWPTTVKFUPTTP DJBMFTEFTFNCPDwFOBMHVOPTDBTPTFOOVFWBT¾HVSBTEFDJVEBEB OrB:UBNCJnOQPEFNPTBvBEJSRVFMPTUSBZFDUPTMBTEFNBOEBTMBT QSFTJPOFTOFHPDJBDJPOFTMVDIBTDPO¿JDUPT RVF FODBSBO EJGFSFOUFT DPMFDUJWPTTPDJBMFTUBNCJnOQVFEFOJOTDSJCJSTFFOVOBC|TRVFEBEF NBZPSDJVEBEBOJ[BDJwO -BTDPODFQUVBMJ[BDJPOFTDSrUJDBTBDFSDBEFMBDJVEBEBOrBEJTDVUFO MBSFTUSJDDJwOEFMDPODFQUPBVOFTUBUVTMFHBMEFEFSFDIPTZSFTQPO TBCJMJEBEFTEF¾OJFOEPBMBDJVEBEBOrBDPNPVOBJEFOUJEBEQPMrUJDB RVFTFDPOTUSVZFZFTDPOUJOHFOUF.PVGGF -BDJVEBEBOrBTF JOUFSQSFUBDPNPVOBBDDJwOOPDPNPBMHPRVFTFQPTFFTJOPRVFTF FKFSDFDPNPQSgDUJDBBUSBWFTBEBQPSEFUFSNJOBDJPOFTDPODSFUBTEF EJTUJOUP UJQP HnOFSP FUOJB DMBTF Z HSVQP TPDJBM BDUJWJEBE MBCPSBM FOUSF PUSBT $PNP TFvBMB (FSNgO $BOUFSP ²<> %FTEF FM QVOUP EF WJTUB FQJTUFNPMwHJDP DJVEBEBOrB FT VOB DBUFHPSrB DPNQMFKB "MVEF TJNVMUgOFBNFOUFBTVKFUPTQPMrUJDPTRVFEFCJFSBOTFSBMBWF[B QPS UBEPSFTEFEFSFDIPTDJWJMFTQPMrUJDPTZTPDJBMFT C NJFNCSPTEFVOB DPNVOJEBEQPMrUJDBZD QBSUrDJQFTEFMBDPOTUSVDDJwOEFMPSEFOEFNP DSgUJDP$PNPQPSUBEPSFTGPSNBMNFOUFVOJWFSTBMFTEFEFSFDIPTFT UPTTVKFUPTFOGSFOUBOMBTDPOUSBEJDDJPOFTEFVOTJTUFNBRVFBNQMrBZ "OB1BHBOP*OHSJE4WFSEMJDLZ1BVMB$PTUBT SFUSBFFMBDDFTPZHPDFFGFDUJWPBFTPTEFSFDIPTTFH|OMPTDPOUFYUPT ZNPNFOUPTIJTUwSJDPT)PZFTUBNPTDPNPZBEJKJNPTFOVOQFSrPEP EFSFUSBDDJwO$PNPNJFNCSPTKVSrEJDBNFOUFJHVBMFTEFVOBDPNV OJEBEQPMrUJDBTFVCJDBOFOMBTUFOTJPOFTEFJODMVTJwOFYDMVTJwO&O FTUFNPNFOUPEFTVIJTUPSJBFMDBQJUBMJTNPIBDFEFMBFYDMVTJwOVOB EFMBTDPOEJDJPOFTEFTVQSPQJBFYQBOTJwO$PNPQPUFODJBMFTQBSUr DJQFTEFMBDPOTUSVDDJwOEFVOPSEFOEFNPDSgUJDPMPTTVKFUPTEFCFO BQSFOEFSBPSEFOBSZTFSPSEFOBEPTEFOUSPEFVOTJTUFNBQPMrUJDPRVF OPQVFEFFMVEJSMBDPOUSBEJDDJwOEFMFHJUJNBSVONPEPEFBDVNVMB DJwOZRVFIPZSFRVJFSFQBSBFMMPEFVOBOVFWBJEFOUJEBEDJVEBEBOB &O FTUF TFOUJEP MBT VUPQrBT DJVEBEBOBT EF USBEJDJwO SFQVCMJDBOB F JODMVTPMJCFSBMFTUgOFODSJTJT<>³$BOUFSP -BQSgDUJDBQPMrUJDBFOVOTFOUJEPNgTBNQMJPBCBSDBMPQ|CMJDP DPNPFTQBDJPEFMJUJHJPBSFOBEFOFHPDJBDJwOTPCSFMPRVFFTDPN|O Z DPOTJEFSB MB IFUFSPHFOFJEBE EF GPSNBT PSHBOJ[BUJWBT EF EFCBUF QSPUFTUBZSFDMBNP$PNPTFvBMB4JMWJB4FSSBBOBMJ[BOEPB3BODJnSF ²<> MP Q|CMJDP TF NVFTUSB BRVr OP TFvBMBOEP MP DPN|O MP EBEPQPSTVQVFTUPVOFTUBEPQSFWJPEFSFHMBTTFBOBSHVNFOUBUJ WBTMFHJTMBUJWBTEFGBDUPVOFTQBDJPQSFFTUBCMFDJEPEFFODVFOUSP TJOPMPQ|CMJDPDPNPFMOPNCSFEFMMJUJHJPDPNPFMFTQBDJPRVFSF DPOPDF MBT EJGFSFODJBT MBT EJTQVUBT JSSFEVDUJCMFT FM DPO¿JDUP : MB DJVEBEBOrB TF SFDPO¾HVSB DPO BRVnM OP QSFTFOUgOEPTF DPNP VOB DPOEJDJwORVFTFPCUJFOFPHBOBQPSEFSFDIPTJOPRVFTFQPOFFO KVFHPDBEBWF[RVFFMJOEJWJEVPTFUPNBQBSUFEFFOFTFFTQBDJPEF MVDIB<>³4FSSB &O CVFOB NFEJEB DSFFNPT RVF DPNP PSHBOJ[BDJPOFT EF MB TP DJFEBEDJWJMMBMVDIBQPSMBJHVBMEBETPDJBMQPSMBEJTUSJCVDJwOEFMPT SFDVSTPT EFCF FTUBS FO MB NnEVMB EF MB DPOTUSVDDJwO EF VO QPEFS QPMrUJDPBMUFSOBUJWPRVFUFOHBDPNPIPSJ[POUFMBC|TRVFEBEFNBZPS EFNPDSBDJB4FUSBUBEFSFDVQFSBSGPSUBMFDFSFMQBQFMFOFTUPTQSP DFTPTEFDPORVJTUB EFQSgDUJDBTFNBODJQBUPSJBTEFUPEBGPSNBEF EPNJOBDJwOBUSBWnTEFVOBDDFTPDPMFDUJWPZVOJWFSTBMBMBQPMrUJDB #BMJWBS 4JOEVEBFTUFBDDFTPSFRVJFSFUBNCJnOEFOVFWBT SFMBDJPOFT EF GVFS[B RVF DPMPRVFO FO FM DFOUSP MB DPOTUSVDDJwO EF QPEFS 1BSUJDJQBDJwOFJODJEFODJBEFMBTPDJFEBEDJWJMFMDBTPBSHFOUJOP &OFTUFTFOUJEPEVSBOUFMBT|MUJNBTEnDBEBTTFIBOEFTBSSPMMBEP EJGFSFOUFT FYQFSJFODJBT RVF NVFTUSBO MBT QPTJCJMJEBEFT Z MrNJUFT EF FTUBTGPSNBTEFDPOTUSVDDJwODPMFDUJWBEFTBSSPMMBEBQPSGVFSBEFMPT DBOBMFTUSBEJDJPOBMFTEFQBSUJDJQBDJwOTJOEJDBUPTQBSUJEPTQPMrUJDPT 4FH|O /BODZ 'SBTFS FO FM NBSDP EF VOB TPDJFEBE FTUSBUJ¾DBEB BM HVOPTHSVQPTQSPNVFWFOVOBDPOGSPOUBDJwOEJTDVSTJWBFTEFDJS²<©> NJFNCSPTEFMPTHSVQPTTPDJBMFTTVCPSEJOBEPT°NVKFSFTUSBCBKBEP SFTQFSTPOBTEFDPMPSHBZTZMFTCJBOBT°IBODPNQSPCBEPSFQFUJEB NFOUFRVFSFTVMUBWFOUBKPTPDPOTUJUVJSQ|CMJDPTBMUFSOBUJWPT1SPQPOHP MMBNBSBFTUPTQ|CMJDPTDPOUSBQ|CMJDPTTVCBMUFSOPTQBSBJOEJDBSRVF TFUSBUBEFFTQBDJPTEJTDVSTJWPTQBSBMFMPTEPOEFMPTNJFNCSPTEFMPT HSVQPTTPDJBMFTTVCPSEJOBEPTJOWFOUBOZIBDFODJSDVMBSDPOUSBEJTDVS TPMPRVFBTVWF[QFSNJUFGPSNVMBSJOUFSQSFUBDJPOFTPQVFTUBTEFTVT JEFOUJEBEFTJOUFSFTFTZOFDFTJEBEFT³'SBTFS "MNJTNPUJFNQPEFTEFMBTPDJFEBEDJWJMTFIBOHFOFSBEPPUSBT QSgDUJDBTQPMrUJDBTDPOJNQPSUBOUFTJNQBDUPTBOJWFMNVOEJBM&OBM HVOBNFEJEBIBOMPHSBEPEFTQMB[BSMBDFOUSBMJEBEEFM&TUBEPFOMBT $VNCSFT $POWFODJPOFT "DVFSEPT Z $POGFSFODJBT TPCSF UFNgUJDBT MJHBEBTBNVKFSNFEJPBNCJFOUFJOGBODJBIgCJUBUFUD%FTEFMBEn DBEBEFMFTUPTFTQBDJPT²QBSBMFMPT³QFSNJUJFSPORVFEJGFSFOUFT PSHBOJ[BDJPOFTTPDJBMFTUVWJFSBOVOBDBCJEBZVOBJODJEFODJBOPDP OPDJEBTIBTUBFMNPNFOUPFOgNCJUPTNBDSPTPDJBMFT &TUBTFYQFSJFODJBTKVOUPBPUSPTNPWJNJFOUPTEFEJGFSFOUFUJQPZ UFOPS[BQBUJTNP4JO5JFSSBBOUJHMPCBMJ[BDJwOFUD RVFTFEFTBSSP MMBSPOFOMBEnDBEBEFMDPO¿VZFSPOFOMBPSHBOJ[BDJwOEFMQSJNFS 'PSP4PDJBM.VOEJBMSFBMJ[BEPFO1PSUP"MFHSFFOFOFSPEF"MMr TFDPNQBSUJFSPOFYQFSJFODJBTEFMVDIBQSPHSBNBTZEFCBUFTNPEB MJEBEFTEFQSPUFTUBQPTJDJPOFTGSFOUFBMBHMPCBMJ[BDJwOOFPMJCFSBM 4FPBOFZ5BEEFJ %FTEFFMIBTUBMBBDUVBMJEBEFTUFFT QBDJPEFEJTDVTJwODPOWFSHFODJBZQSPQVFTUBTFIBNBOUFOJEPDPO VOD|NVMPEFPSHBOJ[BDJPOFTEFMBTPDJFEBEDJWJMRVFQFSTJTUFOFO QMBOUFBSRVF²PUSPNVOEPFTQPTJCMF³ 'JOBMNFOUFDSFFNPTRVFMBTPDJFEBEDJWJMQVFEFZEFCF EFTB SSPMMBSQSgDUJDBTQPMrUJDBTRVFDPOUSJCVZBOBNPEJ¾DBSFMSVNCPRVF MFJNQSJNFBOVFTUSBTTPDJFEBEFTMBIFHFNPOrBEFMDBQJUBMJTNPUBS ErP&OQBMBCSBTEF&NJS4BEFS "OB1BHBOP*OHSJE4WFSEMJDLZ1BVMB$PTUBT 4FUSBUBBTrEFDPOTUSVJSVOBWJTJwOZVOOVFWPFTQBDJPQBSBMB QPMrUJDB/PMBWJTJwOUSBEJDJPOBMEFMBQPMrUJDBRVFMBSFTUSJOHFBMPT FTQBDJPTJOTUJUVDJPOBMFTZBMPTDBMFOEBSJPTFMFDUPSBMFTFORVFUPEB MB FOFSHrB EF MB MVDIB EF MBT QFSTPOBT Z EF MBT PSHBOJ[BDJPOFT TF DBOBMJ[BIBDJBMBDPORVJTUBEFHPCJFSOPTZEFEJQVUBEPT5BNQPDPMP RVFCVTDBBDVNVMBSGVFS[BTQBSBBTBMUBSBMBQBSBUPEF&TUBEPDPNP TJFMQPEFSGVFSBVOBDPTBZFMBQBSBUPEFM&TUBEPDPODFOUSBUPEPFM QPEFSEFMBTPDJFEBE6OBWJTJwORVFQJFOTFMBMVDIBTPDJBMQPMrUJDBF JEFPMwHJDBFOMBQFSTQFDUJWBEFVOQSPZFDUPEFVOBIFHFNPOrBBMUFS OBUJWBBOUJDBQJUBMJTUBEFDPOTUSVDDJwOEFVOBOVFWBTPDJFEBETFB FOTVTCBTFTFDPOwNJDBTTPDJBMFTQPMrUJDBTPDVMUVSBMFT &O FTB QFSTQFDUJWB TFQBSBS MB MVDIB TPDJBM EF MB QPMrUJDB °MB ²TPDJFEBE DJWJM³ EFM &TUBEP° SFQSFTFOUBSrB HJSBS FO WBDrP BDVNV MBOEP GVFS[B TPDJBM TJO IBDFSMB EFTFNCPDBS FO GVFS[B QPMrUJDB P QFPSUPEBWrBIBDJFOEPRVFFTBGVFS[BTFBDBOBMJ[BEBQBSBQSPZFD UPTEFSFOPWBDJwOEFMBTGVFS[BTTJTUnNJDBTZOPEFTVDBSgDUFSEF USBOTGPSNBDJwO <©>-BBMUFSOBUJWBOPFTFOUPODFTFOUSFTPDJFEBEDJWJMP&TUBEP PFOUSFGVFS[BTTPDJBMFTPQPMrUJDBTZBRVFMBMVDIBTPDJBMOPTFTVT UFOUBFOFMWBDrPQPMrUJDP4JOPMMFOBNPTFTFFTQBDJPDPOVOQSPZFDUP EFHPCJFSOPEFTPDJFEBEFTUBSFNPTQFSNJUJFOEPRVFPUSPTDPPQUFO FTBGVFS[BTPDJBM -BWJTJwOMJCFSBMCVTDBCMPRVFBSUPEBBMUFSOBUJWBFOMBQPMBSJ[B DJwOFTUBUBMQSJWBEPDPOMBEFTDBMJ¾DBDJwOEFMQSJNFSPZMBBVUPNg UJDB SFWBMPSJ[BDJwO EFM TFHVOEP EPOEF TF FTDPOEFO MBT SFMBDJPOFT EF NFSDBEP 1BSB OPTPUSPT TF USBUB EF EFTQMB[BS FTB QPMBSJ[BDJwO JOUSPEVDJFOEPFMFMFNFOUPDMBWFEFMPQ|CMJDPFMRVFSFQSFTFOUBMB EFNPDSBUJ[BDJwOSBEJDBMEFM&TUBEPZFMRVFTPOCVFOPTFKFNQMPTMBT QPMrUJDBTEFQSFTVQVFTUPQBSUJDJQBUJWPZMBDPOTUSVDDJwOEFMPTBTFO UBNJFOUPTQSPNPWJEBQPSFM.PWJNJFOUPEF5SBCBKBEPSFT3VSBMFT4JO 5JFSSBFO#SBTJM 4FUSBUBQPSMPUBOUPEFSFEF¾OJSMBOPDJwOEFQPMrUJDBJNQSJNJnO EPMFVODBSgDUFSQ|CMJDPUPSOgOEPMBVOFTQBDJPEFBDVNVMBDJwOEF GVFS[BTTPDJBMFTDVMUVSBMFTZEJSFDUBNFOUFQPMrUJDBTRVFCSBOEPMB EVBMJEBE &TUBEPTPDJFEBE DJWJM RVF QFSUFOFDF BM VOJWFSTP MJCFSBM Z 1BSUJDJQBDJwOFJODJEFODJBEFMBTPDJFEBEDJWJMFMDBTPBSHFOUJOP DIPDB EJSFDUBNFOUF DPO MB TPDJBMJ[BDJwO EF MB QPMrUJDB Z EFM QPEFS PCKFUJWPTGVOEBNFOUBMFTEFMBMVDIBQPSMBFNBODJQBDJwOEFMPTIPN CSFT4BEFS 6/#3&7&3&1"40103-"10-Ê5*$""3(&/5*/" %&-04Ò-5*.04$*/$0"d04 -BTGPSNBTEFQBSUJDJQBDJwOEFMPTEJWFSTPTBDUPSFTEFMBTPDJF EBEDJWJMFOMB"SHFOUJOBBDUVBMTFUPSOBOQBSUJDVMBSFTZDPOTUJUVZFO VO JNQPSUBOUF FKF EF EFCBUF Z BOgMJTJT FO OVFTUSPT ErBT -BT NP EJ¾DBDJPOFT FO FM DPOUFYUP QPMrUJDP EF MB "SHFOUJOB JODJEFO FO TVT DBSBDUFSrTUJDBT -BBQFSUVSBEFNPDSgUJDBEFQFSNJUJwMBWVFMUBBMBQBSUJDJQB DJwOEFEJWFSTPTZNVDIPTTFDUPSFTEFMBTPDJFEBEDJWJMTJMFODJBEPT IBTUBFTFNPNFOUPQPSMBEJDUBEVSBNJMJUBS-PTDPO¿JDUPTZQSPUFT UBTSFUPNBSPOTVTGPSNBTUSBEJDJPOBMFTEFMVDIBIVFMHBTZNPWJMJ[B DJPOFT4VgSF[ %VSBOUFMPTBvPTOPWFOUBZFOFMNBSDPEFMBJNQMFNFOUBDJwOEF QPMrUJDBT OFPMJCFSBMFT MB DPO¿JDUJWJEBE QBSFDJw EJTNJOVJS FO MB QSJ NFSBNJUBEEFMBEnDBEB-BQSPGVOEJ[BDJwOEFUBMFTQPMrUJDBTQSP WPDw VO QSPDFTP EF ²SFUSPDFTP DPPQUBDJwO Z GSBHNFOUBDJwO TPDJBM FOMBTPSHBOJ[BDJPOFTTJOEJDBMFTZNPWJNJFOUPTQPQVMBSFT³4FPBOF &TUPTVQVTPMBDPOTPMJEBDJwOEFVOBEJSJHFODJBTJOEJDBMBGrOBM HPCJFSOP$(5 ZFMOBDJNJFOUPEFOVFWBTFYQFSJFODJBTEFPSHBOJ[B DJwOTJOEJDBMEFPQPTJDJwODPNPMB$5")BDJBMBTFHVOEBNJUBEEF MBEnDBEBDVBOEPMPTFGFDUPTOFHBUJWPTEFMBTQPMrUJDBTOFPMJCFSB -B$POGFEFSBDJwO(FOFSBMEFM5SBCBKPTVSHFFODPNPGVTJwOEFMTJOEJDBMJTNPBS HFOUJOP&OMBnQPDBEFMHPCJFSOPEF+%1FSwODPCSBVOQSPUBHPOJTNPDFOUSBMBUBMQVOUPRVF RVFEwJEFOUJ¾DBEBDPOFM1BSUJEP+VTUJDJBMJTUBQFSPOJTUB %VSBOUFFMHPCJFSOPEF$.FOFN ²QBSUJDJQB³EFMPTCFOF¾DJPTEFMQPEFSFWPMVDJPOBOEPIBDJBVOTJOEJDBMJTNPFNQSFTBSJBM -B$FOUSBMEF5SBCBKBEPSFT"SHFOUJOPTTFPSJHJOBFOMPTJOJDJPTEFMPTBvPTOPWFOUBZ BNFEJBEPTEFEJDIBEnDBEBTFDPOTUJUVZFFOMBDFOUSBMTJOEJDBMBMUFSOBUJWBBMB$POGFEFSBDJwO (FOFSBMEFM5SBCBKP$(5 ZFODBCF[BMBPQPTJDJwOTJOEJDBMBMHPCJFSOPNFOFNJTUB "OB1BHBOP*OHSJE4WFSEMJDLZ1BVMB$PTUBT MFTTFIJDJFSPONVZWJTJCMFTMBTQSPUFTUBTDPNFO[BSPOBDPCSBSPUSP DBSgDUFS4FQSPEVDFVO²BVUnOUJDPDBNCJPDVBMJUBUJWPZEF²FTUJMP³ FOFMEFTBSSPMMPZNBOFKPEFMBDPO¿JDUJWJEBETPDJBM³4VgSF[ DPNJFO[BOBJOTUBMBSTFOVFWBTGPSNBTNgTWJTJCMFTZNgTNFEJgUJ DBTDPNPMPTDPSUFTEFSVUBMPTFTDSBDIFTMBTNBSDIBTEFTJMFODJP DBSBWBOBTDBNQBNFOUPTFUDnUFSB &O FM DBNQP FEVDBUJWP DPNP QBSUF EF FTUF QSPDFTP TF JOTUBMw VOB OVFWB GPSNB EF QSPUFTUB B USBWnT EF MP RVF TF MMBNw MB $BSQB #MBODB -B$5&3"$POGFEFSBDJwOEF5SBCBKBEPSFTEFMB&EVDBDJwOEFMB 3FQ|CMJDB "SHFOUJOB GVF MB QSJODJQBM QSPUBHPOJTUB EF FTUB BDDJwO RVJFOBUSBWnTEFFTUBGPSNB²MPHSwFTUSVDUVSBSTVTMVDIBTZOFHP DJBDJPOFTFOUPSOPBGPSNBTEFQSPUFTUBTPDJBMZTJOEJDBMRVFJODPS QPSBSPOOVFWBTNPEBMJEBEFTEFHFTUJwOFYQSFTJwOZEJGVTJwOEFMPT DPO¿JDUPTSFTJHOJ¾DBOEPMBTGPSNBTDPOWFODJPOBMFTPUSBEJDJPOBMFT EFFYQSFTBSFJOTUBMBSFOMBBHFOEBQ|CMJDBMBTEFNBOEBTZSFJWJOEJ DBDJPOFTTFDUPSJBMFT³4VgSF[ &TUBTOVFWBTGPSNBTRVFJSSVNQJFSPOFOMBFTDFOBQ|CMJDBUVWJF SPO EPT DPOTFDVFODJBT GVOEBNFOUBMFT FO QSJNFS MVHBS ²UPSOBSPO NgTQPMrUJDPTZHFOFSBMFT°ZNFOPTTFDUPSJBMFTZSFJWJOEJDBUJWPT°MPT SFDMBNPTEFMPTEPDFOUFTTJOEJDBMJ[BEPT³4VgSF[ ZFOTF HVOEPMVHBSQFSNJUJFSPOMBOBDJPOBMJ[BDJwOEFMBQSPUFTUBDPOEFO TBOEP FO VO TPMP TrNCPMP UPEPT MPT DPO¿JDUPT QSPWJODJBMFT RVF TF WFOrBOEFTBSSPMMBOEP6OUFSDFSBTQFDUPRVFMBDBSBDUFSJ[wGVFRVF TVFTQBDJPSFTVMUwQSPQJDJPQBSBMBSFVOJwOEFN|MUJQMFTZEJWFSTBT CBUBMMBTDPOUSBFMNPEFMPRVFFYDFErBOMPTSFDMBNPTFEVDBUJWPT4JO EVEBFTUPSFGPS[wMBUFOEFODJBBRVFMPTSFDMBNPTTFUPSOBTFONgT QPMrUJDPTZHFOFSBMFTMPHSBOEPFOUPODFTEJTQVUBSMBTQPMrUJDBTOFP MJCFSBMFTTPCSFMBCBTFEFVOBNQMJPDPOTFOTPEFEJTUJOUPTTFDUPSFT EFMBTPDJFEBEDJWJM&OQBMBCSBTEF/PSNB(JBSSBDB(JBSSBDBZDPM ²-BQSPUFTUBBSHFOUJOBFOMBEnDBEBEFMPTBvPTOPWFOUBTFIB &O TF JOTUBMB VOB DBSQB GSFOUF BM $POHSFTP /BDJPOBM FO MB RVF BDBNQBSPO NBFTUSPT RVF BZVOBCBO Z SFDMBNBCBO VOB MFZ EF ¾OBODJBNJFOUP FEVDBUJWP -VFHP EF USFT BvPTTFPCUVWPVOBMFZEFJODFOUJWPEPDFOUFBQBSUJSEFMBDVBMFM&TUBEP/BDJPOBMBQPSUB NJMMPOFTEFQFTPTBOVBMFTEFTUJOBEPTFYDMVTJWBNFOUFBBVNFOUPTTBMBSJBMFT 1BSUJDJQBDJwOFJODJEFODJBEFMBTPDJFEBEDJWJMFMDBTPBSHFOUJOP DBSBDUFSJ[BEPQPSFMTVSHJNJFOUPEFGPSNBTOPWFEPTBTFJOnEJUBTEF BDDJwODVZBFYQSFTJwONgYJNBQPSMBSFQFSDVTJwOZDPOUJOVJEBEIB TJEPMBJNQMFNFOUBDJwOEFMB´$BSQB#MBODBµEFMPTEPDFOUFTRVFGVF MVFHPVUJMJ[BEBQPSPUSPTBDUPSFTTPDJBMFTFOEJGFSFOUFTNPNFOUPTZ MVHBSFT³ "M ¾OBMJ[BS MB EnDBEB EFM OPWFOUB MBT DPOTFDVFODJBT TPDJBMFT EF MBT QPMrUJDBT OFPMJCFSBMFT TF IJDJFSPO UFSSJCMFNFOUF FWJEFOUFT DBrEB TJTUFNgUJDB EF MPT TBMBSJPT QSFDBSJ[BDJwO EF MBT DPOEJDJPOFT EF USBCBKP BMUrTJNPT rOEJDFT EF EFTFNQMFP QBVQFSJ[BDJwO RVF OP IBDrB NgT RVF EBS DVFOUB EFM BDFMFSBEP QSPDFTP EF DPODFOUSBDJwO EFMJOHSFTPZMBSJRVF[BRVFTVQVTPMBBQMJDBDJwOEFEJDIBTQPMrUJDBT &OQBSBMFMPMBDPSSVQDJwOEFGVODJPOBSJPTZQPMrUJDPTDBEBWF[NgT WJTJCMFBUSBWnTEFMPTNFEJPTEFDPNVOJDBDJwODVFTUJPOwBMBTJOTUJ UVDJPOFTZBMPTQBSUJEPTQPMrUJDPT -BBTVODJwOEFMHPCJFSOPEFMB"MJBO[BDPO'FSOBOEPEFMB3|B DPNPQSFTJEFOUFSFQSFTFOUwVOUSJVOGPEFMBPQPTJDJwOBVOBEnDB EB EF BQMJDBDJwO EF QPMrUJDBT OFPMJCFSBMFT 4JO FNCBSHP QSPOUP TF FWJEFODJwVOBDPOUJOVJEBEFOFTUFTFOUJEPSFQSFTFOUBEBQPSBKVTUFT ¾TDBMFTZQFSNBOFOUFTSFDPSUFTFOFMHBTUPQ|CMJDPIFDIPRVFFOFM DBNQPFEVDBUJWPTFNBOJ¾FTUwBUSBWnTEFMSFDPSUFEFMQSFTVQVFTUP VOJWFSTJUBSJPZFMSFUSBTPFOFMQBHPEFM*ODFOUJWP%PDFOUF'0/*% 'SFOUFBFTUBTQPMrUJDBTVOBNQMJPBSDPEFNPWJNJFOUPTZPSHBOJ [BDJPOFTTPDJBMFTUSBCBKBEPSFTEFTPDVQBEPTFNQMFBEPTEFMTFDUPS Q|CMJDPNBFTUSPTEPDFOUFTVOJWFSTJUBSJPTFTUVEJBOUFTFUD QSPUB HPOJ[BSPO VO JOUFOTP Z QSPMPOHBEP QFSrPEP EF QSPUFTUBT FO GPSNB EFNPWJMJ[BDJPOFTIVFMHBTDPSUFTEFSVUBFUDRVFIBDJB¾OFTEF BCSJFSPOQBTPBMBT²KPSOBEBTEFEJDJFNCSF³MBDSJTJTZMBDBr EBEFMHPCJFSOPEF'FSOBOEPEFMB3|B "MJBO[BQPMrUJDBDPOGPSNBEBQPSMB6OJwO$rWJDB3BEJDBM6$3 ZFM'SFOUFEFM1BrT 4PMJEBSJP'3&1"40 &MZEFEJDJFNCSFEFMDPODFOUSBFMQSPDFTPEFQSPUFTUBRVFTFWFOrBEF TBSSPMMBEPFOFMQBrT4FQSPEVDFOSFCFMJPOFTQPQVMBSFTVSCBOBTTPCSFUPEPFOMBDJVEBEEF #VFOPT"JSFTFOEPOEFMPT²DBDFSPMB[PT³GVFSPOVOTrNCPMP$POGVFSUFSFQSFTJwOQPSQBSUF EFM HPCJFSOP IVCP HSBO DBOUJEBE EF IFSJEPT Z NVFSUPT .JFOUSBT UBOUP FO FM DPOVSCB "OB1BHBOP*OHSJE4WFSEMJDLZ1BVMB$PTUBT &TUB DSJTJT NBSDB EPT DPOTFDVFODJBT JNQPSUBOUFT FO QSJNFS MV HBS²TFvBMBFMRVJFCSFEFMEJTDJQMJOBNJFOUPTPDJBMDPOTPMJEBEPCBKP FMFKFSDJDJPZMBBNFOB[BEFMUFSSPSSFQSFTJWPEFMBQBTBEBEJDUBEVSB ZSFDVQFSBEBCBKPMBGPSNBEF²UFSSPSFDPOwNJDP³<>EFMBEnDBEB EFM OPWFOUB³ 4FPBOF " QBSUJS EF FMMP TF JODPSQPSBSPO B|O NgTGPSNBTZTFDUPSFTBMBQBSUJDJQBDJwOZQSPUFTUB4FNVMUJQMJDBSPO MBTPSHBOJ[BDJPOFTTFBCSJFSPOOVFWPTFTQBDJPTEFQBSUJDJQBDJwOTF ²FOTBODIwFMFTQBDJPQ|CMJDP³1PSPUSBQBSUFZFOTFHVOEPMVHBSMB DSJTJTBCSJwQBTPBVODVFTUJPOBNJFOUPEFMDPOKVOUPEFMPTQPEFSFTEFM &TUBEP1PEFS&KFDVUJWP1PEFSMFHJTMBUJWP°FM1BSMBNFOUP°Z1PEFS +VEJDJBM°DPODSrUJDBTDFOUSBEBTFOMB$PSUF4VQSFNBEF+VTUJDJB° Z QPSMPUBOUPBVOBDSJTJTEFMFHJUJNJEBEEFMTJTUFNBQPMrUJDP $POSFGFSFODJBBFTUP$-P[BOPBWBO[BVOQPDPNgTEJDJFOEP ²"QBSUJSIBZVOQVOUPEFJO¿FYJwOFOMBWJEBQPMrUJDBBSHFOUJOB -BTPDJFEBEGVFDBQB[EFDVFTUJPOBSMBFYQFSJFODJBQPMrUJDBEFMOFP MJCFSBMJTNPQFSPUVWPDPNPMrNJUFOPIBCFSTJEPDBQB[EFDPOTUSVJS VOBGVFS[BQPMrUJDBRVFQFSNJUBTPTUFOFSVOQSPDFTPEFUSBOTGPSNB DJwO&TBFUBQBQPMrUJDBFYJTUFZTFFYQSFTBFOBMHVOBTDPTBTIPZ QPSFKFNQMPFMEJTDVSTPMFHrUJNPQBSBFTUBTPDJFEBEUJFOFRVFDPO GSPOUBSDPOMPRVFQBTwFOMPT³ -B TVDFTJwO EF DJODP QSFTJEFOUFT FO NFOPT EF RVJODF ErBT SF ¿FKwMBDSJTJTQPMrUJDBEFMNPNFOUP&OFOFSPEFMB"TBNCMFB -FHJTMBUJWB OPNCSw QSFTJEFOUF B &EVBSEP %VIBMEF DBOEJEBUP EFM 1BSUJEP+VTUJDJBMJTUB4VHFTUJwOEJPDPOUJOVJEBEBMBTQPMrUJDBTOFP MJCFSBMFT SFJUFSBOEP FM FTRVFNB EF USBOTGFSFODJB EF JOHSFTPT Z SJ RVF[BTRVFDBSBDUFSJ[wBMBEnDBEBEFMOPWFOUBBUSBWnTEFWBSJBEBT QPMrUJDBTEFBKVTUFZSFEVDDJwOEFMHBTUPQ|CMJDP OP CPOBFSFOTF Z PUSBT DJVEBEFT EFM JOUFSJPS EFM QBrT TF QSPEVDrBO TBRVFPT Z SFDMBNPT EF DPNJEB &YQSFTJwOEF+)BCFSNBT &MDBOUPSFJUFSBEP²2VFTFWBZBOUPEPT³FTVOTrNCPMPEFMBTSFCFMJPOFTEFEJDJFN CSFEFZMPTNFTFTTVCTJHVJFOUFTZSFQSFTFOUwFMDSFDJFOUFEFTDSnEJUPTPCSFFMTJTUFNB QPMrUJDPBSHFOUJOP 3FGFSFOUFEFMB$FOUSBMEF5SBCBKBEPSFT"SHFOUJOPT$5" ZBDUVBM%JQVUBEP/BDJPOBM &OUSFWJTUBB$MBVEJP-P[BOP 1BSUJDJQBDJwOFJODJEFODJBEFMBTPDJFEBEDJWJMFMDBTPBSHFOUJOP &OFTUFNBSDPTFQSPEVKFSPOMBTFMFDDJPOFTEFNBZPEFMZMB BTVODJwOEFMBDUVBMQSFTJEFOUF/nTUPS,JSDIOFS°UBNCJnODBOEJEBUP EFM1BSUJEP+VTUJDJBMJTUB°BQBSUJSEFMPDVBMTFJOTUBMwDPNPEJTDVS TP²P¾DJBMEFHPCJFSOP³MBDSrUJDBBM²NPEFMPEFMPTOPWFOUB³&TUB OVFWBHFTUJwOJOUSPEVDFFOTVEJTDVSTPMBTJOUFODJPOFTEFBDVFSEPZ OFHPDJBDJwODPOEJGFSFOUFTTFDUPSFTEBOEPJOJDJPBVOQSPDFTPEFSF QPTJDJPOBNJFOUPQPMrUJDPRVFDPOUJO|BFOMBBDUVBMJEBE-PTEJTUJOUPT BDUPSFT EF MB TPDJFEBE DJWJM °HSFNJPT PSHBOJ[BDJPOFT OP HVCFSOB NFOUBMFTNPWJNJFOUPTTPDJBMFTQBSUJEPTQPMrUJDPTPSHBOJ[BDJPOFT FTUVEJBOUJMFTFUD°TFSFVCJDBOFOGVODJwOEFMBQPZPVPQPTJDJwOBMB HFTUJwO&TUPIBDFEFMFTDFOBSJPQPMrUJDPZEFMBQBSUJDJQBDJwOFOHF OFSBMVOBUSBNBDPNQMFKBDPOOVFWPTFMFNFOUPTZOVFWPTEFCBUFT "OB1BHBOP*OHSJE4WFSEMJDLZ1BVMB$PTUBT $"3"$5&3*;"$*Î/(&/&3"- %&-&4$&/"3*010-Ê5*$0&%6$"5*70 "/5&$&%&/5&4 &OMBEnDBEBEFMFOMB"SHFOUJOBTFQSPGVOEJ[wVOQSPDFTPJOJ DJBEPFOMB|MUJNBEJDUBEVSBNJMJUBS5BMDPNPTFWJFOFNFODJPOBOEP MBT QPMrUJDBT EF DPSUF OFPMJCFSBM JNQVTJFSPO VO OVFWP SnHJNFO TP DJPFDPOwNJDPDBSBDUFSJ[BEPQPSVOQBUSwOSFHSFTJWPEFEJTUSJCVDJwO EFMJOHSFTPZMBSJRVF[BRVFTJHOJ¾DwVOGVSJPTPQSPDFTPEFDPODFO USBDJwOEFMDBQJUBMZFYQSPQJBDJwOEFCJFOFTJOHSFTPTZEFSFDIPTEF BNQMJBTGSBOKBTTPDJBMFT &TUF OVFWP SnHJNFO TF DPOTUJUVZw FOUSF PUSBT DPTBT TPCSF MB JEFB HFOFSBMJ[BEB EF VO ²&TUBEP EFVEPS JOF¾DB[ CVSPDSBUJ[BEP MFOUP JODBQB[ EF HFSFODJBS TVT ´OFHPDJPTµ DPOKVOUBNFOUF DPO VO GVFSUF DVFTUJPOBNJFOUP B MB HPCFSOBCJMJEBE FO FM OVFWP FTDFOBSJP NVOEJBM´HMPCBMJ[BEPµ'SFOUFBFTBJEFBTFJNQMFNFOUwVOQSPDFTP EF3FGPSNBTEFM&TUBEPDPOMB¾OBMJEBEEF´EFTSFHVMBSµBDUJWJEBEFT FMJNJOBSTVQFSQPTJDJPOFTCVSPDSgUJDBTSFEVDJSDPTUPTBMJHFSBSQSP DFEJNJFOUPT USBOTGFSJS SFTQPOTBCJMJEBEFT DPOTJEFSBEBT TVQFS¿VBT ZTVCTBOBSMPTFYDFTPTEFQFSTPOBM³1nSF[Z#Sg 4WFSEMJDL RVFTFFGFDUJWJ[wDPOQPMrUJDBTEFBKVTUF°QBSBIBDFSGSFOUF²BM EFTQJMGBSSPEFM&TUBEP³°EFTDFOUSBMJ[BDJwO°QBSBEFTCVSPDSBUJ[BSMP ZBDFSDBSMBTEFDJTJPOFTBMB²HFOUF³°ZEFTSFHVMBDJPOFT°QBSBQFS NJUJSVOBNBZPSJOJDJBUJWBQSJWBEB° 4F QSPEVKP VOB USBOTGFSFODJB EFM QPEFS EFM &TUBEP IBDJB NB OPT EF MPT HSBOEFT HSVQPT FDPOwNJDPT QSJWBEPT QSPWPDBOEP VOB QSFFNJOFODJB EFM QPEFS FDPOwNJDP QPS TPCSF FM QPEFS QPMrUJDP -B BDFOUVBDJwOEFMBBQFSUVSBDPNFSDJBMJOJDJBEBDPOMBEJDUBEVSBNJMJ UBSZMBNBTJWBQSJWBUJ[BDJwOEFMBTFNQSFTBTEFTFSWJDJPTQ|CMJDPT BCSJwFMKVFHPBVOOVFWPDJDMPEFFOEFVEBNJFOUPFYUFSOPZUFSNJ 1BSUJDJQBDJwOFJODJEFODJBEFMBTPDJFEBEDJWJMFMDBTPBSHFOUJOP OwQPSDPOTVNBSFMQSPDFTPEFEFTJOEVTUSJBMJ[BDJwOZFYQBOTJwOEFM EFTFNQMFP &TUPJNQMJDwVOEFCJMJUBNJFOUPEFM&TUBEPZVODBNCJPFOMBDPO DFQDJwOEF²MPQ|CMJDP³TFQBTwEFDPODFCJSBM&TUBEPDPNPFTQBDJP EFOFHPDJBDJwOEFMVDIBQPMrUJDBEPOEFMBTEJTUJOUBTGVFS[BTTPDJB MFT QPErBO QBSUJDJQBS EFM KVFHP EFNPDSgUJDP RVF FMMP JNQMJDBCB VO &TUBEPHBSBOUFEFMEFSFDIPDJVEBEBOPEFQBSUJDJQBSEFHPCFSOBSEF QSPUFTUBSBVOBDPODFQDJwOEF&TUBEPJOF¾DJFOUFFJOF¾DB[RVFEFCrB DFEFSFM´NPOPQPMJPµEFMPT´TFSWJDJPTµZBOPEFSFDIPTDJVEBEBOPT B PUSBTFOUJEBEFTRVFMPSFTPMWFSrBODPOF¾DBDJB³4WFSEMJDL &O FTUF DPOUFYUP FM QFOTBNJFOUP IFHFNwOJDP Z MBT QSPQVFTUBT SFGPSNJTUBTFOMBFEVDBDJwOFTUVWJFSPOFOMrOFBDPOFTBTQSFNJTBT CgTJDBT &OUSF PUSPT BTQFDUPT MB JEFB EF RVF MB ²DSJTJT EF MB FEV DBDJwO³FSBMBDPOTFDVFODJBEFVOJOF¾DB[NBOFKPQPSQBSUFEFMBT BENJOJTUSBDJPOFTFTUBUBMFTTFGVFJOTUBMBOEPEFMBNBOPEFMPTFOGP RVFTEFMNBOBHNFOUFOFEVDBDJwOZEFMBDBMJEBEFOUFOEJEBDPNP FMSFTVMUBEPEFVOBSFMBDJwOFDPOwNJDBFOUSFJOTVNPTZQSPEVDUPT $PO JEnOUJDB PSJFOUBDJwO FM EJBHOwTUJDP RVF TFvBMBCB °ZB DPO GVFS[BEFTEFMPTBvPT°MBFYJTUFODJBEFVOTJTUFNBFEVDBUJWPDFO USBMJ[BEPCVSPDSBUJ[BEPZIPNPHFOFJ[BOUFGVFVOBCBTFBSHVNFOUBM JOEJTDVUJCMF QBSB JNQMFNFOUBS MPT QSPDFTPT EF SFGPSNB OFPMJCFSBM 'SFOUFBFTFEJBHOwTUJDPUBOUPMBEFSFDIBDPNPMBJ[RVJFSEBQBSF DrBODPOGVOEJSTFFOFMEJTDVSTPTPCSFMB²MJCFSUBE³FM²SFTQFUPQPS MB EJWFSTJEBE Z MBT QBSUJDVMBSJEBEFT SFHJPOBMFT³ Z MB ²BVUPOPNrB³ &TUBBQBSFOUFDPJODJEFODJBTJSWJwEFQBSBHVBTQBSBJNQVMTBSMBTSF GPSNBTFOFMDBNQPFEVDBUJWPEVSBOUFMPTBvPTBVODVBOEPSgQJ EBNFOUFTFSFDPOPDJFSBMBEJSFDDJwORVFJCBUPNBOEPFMQSPDFTPEF USBOTGPSNBDJwO "MQPDPUJFNQPRVFEwDMBSPRVFFTPTDPODFQUPTFOMBTSFGPSNBT OFPMJCFSBMFT TF FODPOUSBCBO TVCTVNJEPT B PUSBT JEFBT DFOUSBMFT WJODVMBEBTDPOFMFTQrSJUVQSJWBUJ[BEPSZEFNFSDBEP%FVOBGPSNB DPIFSFOUFDPOMPRVFTVDFErBDPOMBTFNQSFTBTEFTFSWJDJPTQ|CMJDPT ZQPSMPUBOUPDPOMBTMrOFBTEFQPMrUJDBBOJWFMOBDJPOBMFMFKFDFOUSBM TFUSBTMBEwBMBQSFPDVQBDJwOQPSMBF¾DJFODJBEFMBTBENJOJTUSBDJP OFT-BJEFBEFRVFMBF¾DJFODJBEFMBTPSHBOJ[BDJPOFTFSBMPRVFIB "OB1BHBOP*OHSJE4WFSEMJDLZ1BVMB$PTUBT CrBRVFSFTPMWFSCVTDwTVBODMBKFFOVOJNBHJOBSJPRVFDPNFO[BCBB FYQBOEJSTFZRVFQMBOUFBCBVOBBOUJOPNJB²FNQSFTBTQSJWBEBTF¾ DJFOUFTWTFNQSFTBTEFTFSWJDJPTQ|CMJDPTJOF¾DJFOUFTCVSPDSgUJDBT ZMFOUBT³MPDVBMDFSSBCBCJFOFMKVTUJ¾DBUJWPEF²RVJUBSMF³BM&TUBEP MBSFTQPOTBCJMJEBEQPS²MPQ|CMJDP³ZBWBO[BSTPCSFVOBQSJWBUJ[BDJwO BWFDFTFYQMrDJUBZPUSBTWFDFTFODVCJFSUB%FFTFNPEPMBEJWFSTJ EBE Z MB BVUPOPNrB QBTBSPO B GPSNBS QBSUF EF MB QSPCMFNgUJDB EF MB²HFTUJwOFTDPMBS³FOUFOEJEBDPNPHFSFODJBNJFOUPNBOBHNFOU DPOVOBDMBSBPSJFOUBDJwOBMNFSDBEP &OFTUFDPOUFYUPFMBQFMBUJWPBMBQBSUJDJQBDJwOCVTDBCBGPNFO UBSMBJEFBEFRVFVOGVFSUFZDPNQSPNFUJEPUSBCBKP²QBSUJDJQBUJWP³ FSBJOEJTQFOTBCMFQBSBFMMPHSPEFMPTPCKFUJWPTZSFTVMUBEPTFEVDBUJ WPTQSFEF¾OJEPT"TrFOVODJBEBMBQBSUJDJQBDJwOHBOBCBFMTFOUJEP DPN|O F JODMVTP TVHFSrB VO FTQBDJP EF SFTQPOTBCJMJEBE JOEJWJEVBM WPMVOUBSJB FOMBQPTJCJMJEBEEFVOBDPOTUSVDDJwOEFNPDSgUJDB4JO FNCBSHPMPRVFGVFRVFEBOEPBMEFTDVCJFSUPGVFRVFMB²DPOWPDB UPSJBBQBSUJDJQBS³MFKPTEFDPOTUJUVJSTFFOVOBQBSUJDJQBDJwOBVUnO UJDBFOMPTUnSNJOPTEF(BSZ"OEFSTPO SFTVMUwVOBFTUSBUFHJBEF MFHJUJNBDJwOEFMBTEFDJTJPOFTZVOBUFDOPMPHrBEFDPOUSPMTP¾TUJDB EBFOSFMBDJwODPOMPTEPDFOUFTZIBDJBMBTGBNJMJBTMBQBSUJDJQBDJwO EFMPTQBESFT VOBGPSNBEFBSHVNFOUBSTPCSFMBTCPOEBEFTEFVO NFSDBEPFEVDBUJWPTPCSFMBCBTFEFMBMJCFSUBEEFFMFDDJwOEFFTDVF MBT &O EF¾OJUJWB VOB QBSUJDJQBDJwO ²JOBVUnOUJDB³ SFQSPEVDUPSB EF MPTQPEFSFTIFHFNwOJDPT -BSFGPSNBFEVDBUJWBEFMPTTFDPOTPMJEwDPOMBTBODJwOEF VODVFSQPEFMFZFTBDUVBMNFOUFDPOTUJUVZFOUBOUPQPSTVBTQFDUP OPSNBUJWPDPNPGVOEBNFOUBMNFOUFQPSMBTDPOTFDVFODJBTRVFQSP (BSZ"OEFSTPOTFvBMBRVF²<©>MBQBSUJDJQBDJwOFTBVUnOUJDBTJJODMVZFSFQSFTFO UBOUFTEFHSVQPTEFJOUFSnTSFMFWBOUFTZDSFBFTQBDJPTSFMBUJWBNFOUFTFHVSPTZFTUSVDUVSBEPT QBSBRVFMBTEJGFSFOUFTWPDFTTFBOFTDVDIBEBT<©><ZRVF>MPT¾OFT|MUJNPTEFMBQBSUJDJQBDJwO EFCFOTFSMBDPOTUJUVDJwOEFVOBDJVEBEBOrBEFNPDSgUJDBZVOBNBZPSKVTUJDJBSFEJTUSJCVUJWB QBSBMPTHSVQPTEFTGBWPSFDJEPTPFOUnSNJOPTFEVDBDJPOBMFTOJWFMFTEFMPHSPNgTJHVBMJUB SJPTZSFTVMUBEPTTPDJBMFTZBDBEnNJDPTNgTBMUPTQBSBUPEPTMPTFTUVEJBOUFT©³QgH 1BSUJDJQBDJwOFJODJEFODJBEFMBTPDJFEBEDJWJMFMDBTPBSHFOUJOP EVKFSPOFMQVOUPEFQBSUJEBTPCSFFMDVBMTFEFTBSSPMMBOMBTQPMrUJDBT FEVDBUJWBTBDUVBMFT &ONBUFSJBFEVDBUJWBMBTPSJFOUBDJPOFTQSJODJQBMFTFOMrOFBDPO ²BDIJDBS FM &TUBEP³ IJDJFSPO GPDP FO MB EFTDFOUSBMJ[BDJwO Z USBOT GFSFODJB EF TFSWJDJPT FEVDBUJWPT FO MB NPEJ¾DBDJwO EF MB FTUSVD UVSB EFM TJTUFNB FO FM BWBODF TPCSF MB BVUPOPNrB VOJWFSTJUBSJB Z FO VOB SFDPODFQUVBMJ[BDJwO EF MB FEVDBDJwO Q|CMJDB RVF QBTBSrB B DPNQSFOEFS B MB HFTUJwO FTUBUBM Z B MB HFTUJwO QSJWBEB CBKP FTB EFOPNJOBDJwO -BEFTDFOUSBMJ[BDJwOTFQMBTNwFOMB-FZEF5SBOTGFSFODJBEFMPT TFSWJDJPT FEVDBUJWPT -FZ / 4F USBUw EF MB USBOTGF SFODJBEFMBTFTDVFMBTEFTEFMBOBDJwOBMPTHPCJFSOPTQSPWJODJBMFT CBKPMBJEFBEFRVFMBTKVSJTEJDDJPOFTBTVDBSHPSFTQPOEFSrBO°KVOUP DPOMPTSFDVSTPTOFDFTBSJPTEFNBOFSBEJSFDUBBMBTOFDFTJEBEFTZ QSPCMFNgUJDBTMPDBMFTQSJODJQJPEFMBEJWFSTJEBESFHJPOBM -BBVUP OPNrBEFEFDJTJwONFKPSBSrBMBF¾DJFODJBFTDPMBSZMBUSBOTGFSFODJB EFFTUBCMFDJNJFOUPTGVFQSFTFOUBEBDPNPMB|OJDBBMUFSOBUJWBGSFOUF BMBDSJTJT&TUBTBODJwOMMFWwBDPNQMFUBSVOQSPDFTPEFUSBOTGFSFO DJBRVFZBTFIBCrBJOJDJBEPFOPUSBTFUBQBTPSEFOBOEPFMUSBTQBTP EFMPTFTUBCMFDJNJFOUPTEFM/JWFM.FEJPZ4VQFSJPSOPVOJWFSTJUBSJP CBKPVOEJTDVSTPEF¾OJEPFOUnSNJOPTEFMBSFEJTUSJCVDJwOEFMQPEFS "RVrDBCFBDMBSBSRVFMB$POTUJUVDJwO/BDJPOBMEFMB3FQ|CMJDB"SHFOUJOBFTMFZGVO EBNFOUBMRVFEBFMNBSDPKVSrEJDPQBSBFMQBrTFTUBCMFDFFMGFEFSBMJTNPDPNPPSHBOJ[BDJwO QPMrUJDBZVOUJQPEFHPCJFSOPSFQSFTFOUBUJWPSFQVCMJDBOPZGFEFSBM&MQBrTTFDPNQPOFEF WFJOUJDVBUSPQSPWJODJBTZMB$JVEBE"VUwOPNBEF#VFOPT"JSFTDBEBVOBDPOTVTQSPQJPTQP EFSFTFKFDVUJWPMFHJTMBUJWPZKVEJDJBMFOGPSNBBOgMPHBBMHPCJFSOPOBDJPOBM$BEBKVSJTEJDDJwO EJDUB TV QSPQJB DPOTUJUVDJwO EF BDVFSEP DPO MPT QSJODJQJPT FTUBCMFDJEPT FO MB $POTUJUVDJwO /BDJPOBMZTVTQSPQJBTMFZFT4FH|OEJDUBMBOPSNBMPTPSHBOJTNPTRVFSJHFOMBFEVDBDJwO OBDJPOBMTPOFM.JOJTUFSJPEF&EVDBDJwO$JFODJBZ5FDOPMPHrBEFMB/BDJwO°FOFMNBSDPEFM 1PEFS &KFDVUJWP /BDJPOBM °DPNP FM NgT BMUP OJWFM EF DPOEVDDJwO EF MB FEVDBDJwO BSHFOUJOB °DPOSFTQPOTBCJMJEBEDPODVSSFOUFZDPODFSUBEBDPOFM(PCJFSOPEFMB$JVEBE"VUwOPNBEF #VFOPT"JSFTZMBTQSPWJODJBTZMBTBVUPSJEBEFTEFFTUBT|MUJNBTRVFUJFOFOBTVDBSHP°TJUVB DJwORVFTFDPNQMFUBDPOMBSFGPSNBEFMPTBvPTOPWFOUB°MBBENJOJTUSBDJwOZTVQFSWJTJwOEFMB NBZPSQBSUFEFMPTTFSWJDJPTFEVDBUJWPTFYDFQUVBEPFMTVCTJTUFNBVOJWFSTJUBSJP-BTQPMrUJDBT FEVDBUJWBT OBDJPOBMFT TPO DPODFSUBEBT FO VO wSHBOP EF DPODFSUBDJwO FM $POTFKP 'FEFSBM DPOTUJUVJEPQPSMBTBVUPSJEBEFTEFDBEBBENJOJTUSBDJwOFEVDBUJWBKVSJTEJDDJPOBM -BFYQSFTJwO²BDIJDBSFM&TUBEPFTBHSBOEBSMB/BDJwO³GVFVUJMJ[BEBFOMBnQPDBEF MBEJDUBEVSBQBSBHFOFSBSVOBPQJOJwOQ|CMJDBGBWPSBCMFBMQSPDFTPEFQSJWBUJ[BDJwO "OB1BHBOP*OHSJE4WFSEMJDLZ1BVMB$PTUBT TPDJBMZQPMrUJDPFONBSDBEPFOFMQBSBEJHNBEFMBEFNPDSBDJB4JO FNCBSHP²MBQPMrUJDBEFUSBOTGFSFODJBEFMBTFTDVFMBTDPOTUJUVrBVO SFRVJTJUPQBSBMBSFOFHPDJBDJwOEFMBEFVEBFYUFSOBDPOUSBrEBQPSFM QBrT ZB DPOUFNQMBEP FO BDVFSEPT ¾SNBEPT DPO FM #BODP .VOEJBM ZFM'POEP.POFUBSJP*OUFSOBDJPOBM³'JOOFHBO'MPSFODJBZ1BHBOP "OB -B -FZ 'FEFSBM EF &EVDBDJwO -FZ / EF¾OJw VOB OVFWBFTUSVDUVSBQBSBFMTJTUFNBFEVDBUJWP&EVDBDJwOJOJDJBMQBSB OJvPT EF B BvPT TJFOEP PCMJHBUPSJP FM |MUJNP BvP &EVDBDJwO (FOFSBM#gTJDB&(# EFBvPTEFEVSBDJwOBQBSUJSEFMPTBvPT EFFEBEZPSHBOJ[BEBFODJDMPT&(#Z &EVDBDJwO1PMJNPEBM BDPOUJOVBDJwOEFMB&(#ZDPOBvPTEFEVSBDJwOZQPS|MUJNPMB &EVDBDJwO4VQFSJPSQSPGFTJPOBMZBDBEnNJDBEFHSBEPZEFQPTUSB EP&TUBFTUSVDUVSBTFJNQMFNFOUBSrBEFGPSNBHSBEVBMZQSPHSFTJWB FODBEBKVSJTEJDDJwO3FTQFDUPEFMBPCMJHBUPSJFEBEMB-'&FYUFOEJw B BvPT MB FEVDBDJwO PCMJHBUPSJB EF B BvPT 5BNCJnO FO FM QSPDFTP EF FMBCPSBDJwO EF MB MFZ FM NJOJTUFSJP QSPNPWJw BDVFSEPT GFEFSBMFTTPCSFFMDPOKVOUPEFTBCFSFTSFMFWBOUFTQBSBFMDPOKVOUP EFM UFSSJUPSJP OBDJPOBM 4F EF¾OJFSPO FO FTF NBSDP MPT $POUFOJEPT #gTJDPT $PNVOFT $#$ QBSB TFS BQMJDBEPT B OJWFM OBDJPOBM $BEB QSPWJODJBUFOESrBFTBCBTFQBSBMBDPOTUSVDDJwOEFEJTFvPTDVSSJDV MBSFTKVSJTEJDDJPOBMFT0USPEJTQPTJUJWPRVFGPSNwQBSUFEFMFOUSBNB EP SFGPSNJTUB GVF FM 4JTUFNB /BDJPOBM EF &WBMVBDJwO EF MB $BMJEBE 4*/&$ MVFHP EFWFOJEP 0QFSBUJWP /BDJPOBM EF &WBMVBDJwO 0/& DPOBTJFOUPFOMB%JSFDDJwO/BDJPOBMEF*OWFTUJHBDJwOZ&WBMVBDJwO &EVDBUJWB%*/*&$& RVFUFOrBDPNPPCKFUJWPMBHFOFSBDJwOEFJOGPS NBDJwOBDFSDBEFMPTEFTFNQFvPTZSFTVMUBEPTEFMTJTUFNBFEVDBUJ WP²QBSBMBNFKPSBEFMBDBMJEBEEFMBFEVDBDJwO³ -PTDBNCJPTDVSSJDVMBSFTZEFFTUSVDUVSBJNQMJDBSPODBNCJPTFO MB GPSNBDJwO Z DBQBDJUBDJwO EPDFOUF 1PS VOB QBSUF TF DSFw MB 3FE 'FEFSBMEF'PSNBDJwO%PDFOUF$POUJOVBDPOMBJEFBEFRVFVOPEFMPT QSPCMFNBTDFOUSBMFTFSBMBBDUVBMJ[BDJwOEFMPTEPDFOUFTZBEFNgT TFEFTBSSPMMBSPOQSPDFTPTPSJFOUBEPTBMBSFDPOWFSTJwOEFMPTEPDFO UFTQBSBTV²SFVCJDBDJwO³FOMPTOVFWPTDJDMPTOJWFMFTZNPEBMJEBEFT EFFOTFvBO[B&TUBTFTUSBUFHJBTGPSNBUJWBTGVFSPOFYQFSJNFOUBEBT QPSMPTEPDFOUFTDPNPVOBGPSNBEFJNQPOFSFMNPEFMPQPSMBWrBEF 1BSUJDJQBDJwOFJODJEFODJBEFMBTPDJFEBEDJWJMFMDBTPBSHFOUJOP HFOFSBS USBOTNJTPSFT EF MB QBMBCSB P¾DJBM &OUSF PUSBT SB[POFT MB EFTJHVBMBQMJDBDJwOEFMBOPSNBQBSBFMDPOKVOUPEFMQBrTQSPGVOEJ [wMBTEFTJHVBMFTDPOEJDJPOFTMBCPSBMFTQBSBMPTUSBCBKBEPSFTEFMB FEVDBDJwOZMBDPOWJWFODJBEFDVMUVSBTQSPGFTJPOBMFTEJTUJOUBTFOVO NJTNPgNCJUPDPOEJGFSFOUFSFNVOFSBDJwOQPSJHVBMUBSFB -BEFTDFOUSBMJ[BDJwOBENJOJTUSBUJWBKVOUPDPOVOBGVFSUFDPODFO USBDJwOEFMBTEFDJTJPOFTUnDOJDPQPMrUJDBTFOFM.JOJTUFSJP/BDJPOBM MBUSBOTGFSFODJBJOTV¾DJFOUFEFGPOEPTEFTUJOBEPTNBZPSNFOUFQBSB ¾OFT FTQFDr¾DPT QPS MB WrB EF ²GPOEPT DPODVSTBCMFT³ B MP RVF TF TVNBSPOMPTQBSUJDVMBSFTDPO¿JDUPTEFDBEBQSPWJODJBZTVTJTUFNB FEVDBUJWP EFSJWw FO VOB BQMJDBDJwO NVZ EFTJHVBM EF MB SFGPSNB Z BHVEJ[wMBTUFOEFODJBTBMBTFHNFOUBDJwOEFMTJTUFNBFEVDBUJWP &O MP DPODSFUP ²MB EFTDFOUSBMJ[BDJwO OP GVF FO SFBMJEBE OJOH|O QSPDFTP EF EFNPDSBUJ[BDJwO EFM QPEFS °BSHVNFOUPT VUJMJ[BEPT FO TV NPNFOUP°TJOPVOJOTUSVNFOUPEFBKVTUF¾OBODJFSPRVFJNQMJDwVOB USBOTGFSFODJBEFSFTQPOTBCJMJEBEFTTJOGPOEPTZTJNVMUgOFBNFOUFMBSF DFOUSBMJ[BDJwOEFMDPOUSPMFONBOPTEFVO&TUBEP°WBDrPEFFTDVFMBT°³ $5&3"*OTUJUVUPEF*OWFTUJHBDJPOFT1FEBHwHJDBT.BSJOB7JMUF ²1PSTVQBSUFFMSFFNQMB[PEFMBWJFKBFTUSVDUVSBEFMTJTUFNBQPS FMBDUVBMZTVJNQMFNFOUBDJwOEFTBSUJDVMBEBFOOPNCSFEFMSFTQFUP BMGFEFSBMJTNP°PUSPEFMPTBSHVNFOUPTEFMNPNFOUP°GVFFMWFIrDV MPNgTQPEFSPTPQBSBBHVEJ[BSMBGSBHNFOUBDJwO³$5&3"*OTUJUVUP EF*OWFTUJHBDJPOFT1FEBHwHJDBT.BSJOB7JMUF &OFMNJTNPDPOUFYUPEFBQMJDBDJwOEFMBTQPMrUJDBTOFPMJCFSBMFT MB-FZEF&EVDBDJwO4VQFSJPS-&4 GVFMBUFSDFSBIF SSBNJFOUBMFHBMRVFEJPTVTUFOUPBMBUSBOTGPSNBDJwOFEVDBUJWB )BTUBFMNPNFOUPMBFEVDBDJwOTVQFSJPSOPDPOUBCBDPOVONBS DPRVFSFHVMBSBFMDPOKVOUPEFMBFEVDBDJwOTVQFSJPSVOJWFSTJUBSJB ZOPVOJWFSTJUBSJBQ|CMJDBZQSJWBEB-BTVOJWFSTJEBEFTIBCrBODPO RVJTUBEPTVBVUPOPNrBZBVUBSRVrBEFTEFIBDrBNVDIPUJFNQPBUSgT DPOMBSFGPSNBVOJWFSTJUBSJBEFZMBFEVDBDJwOTVQFSJPSOPVOJ WFSTJUBSJBMMBNBEBUFSDJBSJBOPGPSNBCBQBSUFEFFTFVOJWFSTP $POVOFTUJMPEFGVFSUFDPOGSPOUBDJwODPOUSBFMQPEFSJOTUJUVJEPFO FMTJTUFNBVOJWFSTJUBSJPMB-&4MFKPTEFSFTVMUBSEFVOEJBHOwTUJDP EFMBTQSPCMFNgUJDBTEFMOJWFMZPCKFUPEFDPOTVMUBTDPOMPTBDUPSFT "OB1BHBOP*OHSJE4WFSEMJDLZ1BVMB$PTUBT JOWPMVDSBEPTSFTQPOEJwBMBOFDFTJEBEQPMrUJDBEF²TVKFUBS³FTFOJ WFMEFMTJTUFNBZFODVBESBSMPFOMPTNBSDPTHFOFSBMFTEFMBSFGPSNB 0CWJBNFOUFFTUBTJUVBDJwOHFOFSwVOBGVFSUFSFTJTUFODJBEFMTFDUPS GVOEBEBFOFMDBSgDUFSNFSDBOUJMJTUBEFMBOPSNBRVFFGFDUJWBNFOUF FTUBCBTJFOEPBDPSEBEBDPOFM#BODP.VOEJBMFOFMNBSDPEFM¾OBO DJBNJFOUPPUPSHBEPQBSBFTUPT¾OFTZRVFQSFWFrBMBBNQMJBDJwOIB DJBFMTFDUPSQSJWBEPEFM²OFHPDJPVOJWFSTJUBSJP³QPSVOBQBSUFZQPS MBPUSBFOUBOUPRVFFMOVFWPJOTUSVNFOUPKVSrEJDPDSFBCBEPTJOTUBO DJBTHVCFSOBNFOUBMFTDPOMBTDVBMFTMBTVOJWFSTJEBEFTIBCSrBOEFOF HPDJBS4FDSFwMB4FDSFUBSrBEF1PMrUJDBT6OJWFSTJUBSJBTEFM.JOJTUFSJP EF&EVDBDJwOFM$POTFKPEF6OJWFSTJEBEFTZMB$PNJTJwO/BDJPOBMEF &WBMVBDJwOZ"DSFEJUBDJwO6OJWFSTJUBSJB$0/&"6 BDBSHPEFMBFWB MVBDJwOZBDSFEJUBDJwOEFMBTPGFSUBTZEFMBTJOTUJUVDJPOFT 6OBQBSUJDVMBSJEBEEFMB-&4FTRVFBCBSDwBMDPOKVOUPEFMBFEV DBDJwO TVQFSJPS QPS MP RVF TV TBODJwO TJHOJ¾Dw MB JODMVTJwO EF MBT JOTUJUVDJPOFTUFSDJBSJBTEFGPSNBDJwOEPDFOUFZEFGPSNBDJwOUnDOJDP QSPGFTJPOBM FO VOB NJTNB OPSNB MFHBM &TUB TJUVBDJwO HFOFSw BTJ NJTNPVOBTFSJFEFOPWFEBEFTQBSBMBTJOTUJUVDJPOFTTVQFSJPSFTOP VOJWFSTJUBSJBTFOUSFMBTDVBMFTDBCFNFODJPOBSMBBSUJDVMBDJwODPO MBTVOJWFSTJEBEFTMBBDSFEJUBDJwOZFWBMVBDJwOEFTVTJOTUJUVDJPOFTZ UJUVMBDJPOFTMBEJTDVTJwOTPCSFFMWBMPSEFMPTUrUVMPTBMBIPSBEFMPT QPTHSBEPTFUDnUFSB &OUSFPUSBTDPTBTFOFMOJWFMVOJWFSTJUBSJPMBOPSNBQPTJCJMJUwF JODMVTPFTUJNVMwFMJODSFNFOUPEFPGFSUBTEFMTFDUPSQSJWBEPDPOFM NJTNPSFDPOPDJNJFOUPKVSrEJDPRVFMBTEFMTFDUPSQ|CMJDPEJPMVHBS BMBNFSDBOUJMJ[BDJwOEFMPTNFDBOJTNPTEFMQSPQJP&TUBEPBCSJFO EPFYQMrDJUBNFOUFMBQPTJCJMJEBEEFBSBODFMBSMPTFTUVEJPTEFHSBEP ZEFSFTUSJOHJSMBVOJWFSTBMJEBEEFMJOHSFTPQPTJCJMJUwMBSFPSHBOJ[B DJwOEFMBTDBSSFSBTEFKBOEPMBPQDJwOEFSFDPSUBSUSBNPTEFHSBEP QBSBFYUFOEFSQPTHSBEPTBSBODFMBEPTQPTJCJMJUwVOBPGFSUBEFHSBEP BSBODFMBEBPSJFOUBEBBMBBSUJDVMBDJwODPOMBTJOTUJUVDJPOFTUFSDJBSJBT MJDFODJBUVSBT QBSB FHSFTBEPT EF UFSDJBSJPT DBSSFSBT EF BSUJDVMB DJwO TPTUVWPMPTSFHrNFOFTEFQBTBOUrBTDPNPDPOEJDJPOFTQBSBFM FHSFTPSFQSPEVDJFOEPMPTTJTUFNBTEFUSBCBKPHSBUVJUPZ²BTPDJBO EP³°FODPIFSFODJBDPOMBTQPMrUJDBTOFPMJCFSBMFT°MBVOJWFSTJEBEB MBFNQSFTBZDFOUSBMJ[wMBTBUSJCVDJPOFTEFFWBMVBDJwOZBDSFEJUBDJwO 1BSUJDJQBDJwOFJODJEFODJBEFMBTPDJFEBEDJWJMFMDBTPBSHFOUJOP FONBOPTEFVOBBHFODJBFTUBUBMDPOVOGVFSUFDPNQPOFOUFQPMrUJDP ZOPBDBEnNJDP FOTVDPOTUJUVDJwO 5BMDPNPTFNFODJPOwNgTBSSJCBUBOUPFMQSPDFEJNJFOUPQBSBTV DPODFQDJwOZBQSPCBDJwODPNPTVDPOUFOJEPFTQFDr¾DPQSPEVKPVO HSBOSFDIB[PRVFB|OTFTPTUJFOFZPCMJHBBMBOVFWBHFTUJwOQPMrUJDB BQPOFSFOBHFOEBMBEJTDVTJwOEFVOBOVFWBMFZRVFMBSFFNQMBDF 5SFDFBvPTNgTUBSEFTFQVFEFPCTFSWBSRVFMBTDPOTFDVFODJBT EFMQSPHSBNBEFSFGPSNBEFMBTQPMrUJDBTOFPMJCFSBMFTFOFEVDBDJwO IBOTJEPOFGBTUBT/PTwMPOPTFQSPEVKPFMEFDMBNBEPQSPDFTPEF NPDSBUJ[BEPSTJOPRVFBMDPOUSBSJPTFQSPGVOEJ[BSPOMBTEFTJHVBM EBEFTBMUPTrOEJDFTEFFYDMVTJwOZGSBDBTPFTDPMBSQBSBMPTQPCSFT ZMBGSBHNFOUBDJwOEFMTJTUFNBDSJTUBMJ[BEPFOVOTJTUFNBFOFMRVF DPOWJWFONVDIBTFTUSVDUVSBT &OUnSNJOPTHFOFSBMFTTFQVFEFB¾SNBSRVF²MBSFGPSNBFEVDB UJWBEFKwVOTJTUFNBGSBDUVSBEPZGSBHNFOUBEP%FKwVOTBMEPFDP OwNJDPOFHBUJWPEFEFVEBFYUFSOB QBSBVOBSFGPSNBNVZDPTUPTB RVFEFTBUFOEJwMPTQSPCMFNBTNgTBDVDJBOUFTZIPZBHSBWBEPTEF MBFEVDBDJwOEFOVFTUSPQBrTBOBMGBCFUJTNPMBTPCSFFEBEMBSFQJ UFODJBFMBCBOEPOPFUD &OMBBDUVBMJEBEFYJTUFOFOMB"SHFOUJOB NgTEFUSFTEJGFSFOUFTFTUSVDUVSBTEFTJTUFNBFEVDBUJWPZTFH|O VOBOPUBQVCMJDBEBQPSVOEJBSJPOBDJPOBMFMEPNJOHPEFNBZPEF BDUVBMNFOUF IBZNgTEFBMVNOPTGVFSBEFMTJT UFNBFTDPMBSQPSNPUJWPTRVFTFJEFOUJ¾DBODPOMBDSJTJTTPDJBM EFMPT|MUJNPTBvPTFOUBOUPRVFVOPTNBZPSFTEF BvPT OP TBCFO MFFS OJ FTDSJCJS &M EJBHOwTUJDP SFWFMB UBNCJnO RVFFTUPTHVBSJTNPTMFKPTEFEJTUSJCVJSTFFOGPSNBIPNPHn OFBTFvBMBOVOBTJUVBDJwOEFEFTJHVBMEBEQSPGVOEBFOUSFMBT EJWFSTBTKVSJTEJDDJPOFTEFMQBrT³4WFSEMJDL -B NBZPS QBSUF EF MBT QSPWJODJBT BSHFOUJOBT BTVNJw MB OVFWB FTUSVDUVSB FTDPMBS EF VOB &EVDBDJwO (FOFSBM #gTJDB PCMJHBUPSJB &(# EF BvPT Z MB FEVDBDJwO QPMJNPEBM OP PCMJHBUPSJBBMHVOBTKVSJTEJDDJPOFTDPNPMB$JVEBEEF#VFOPT"JSFTNBOUVWJFSPOMBFTUSVD UVSBBOUFSJPSBvPTEFQSJNBSJBZEFTFDVOEBSJBBNCBTPCMJHBUPSJBT ZPUSBTKVSJTEJDDJPOFT BEBQUBSPOMBQSPQVFTUBSFGPSNJTUBBMTJTUFNBBOUFSJPSDPOBvPTEF&(# .JFOUSBTRVFFOMBDJVEBEEF#VFOPT"JSFTWBBDMBTFFMEFMPTBMVNOPTFO DPOEJDJPOFTEFDVSTBSMPTQSJNFSPTEPTBvPTEFMBFTDVFMBNFEJB°EFDBSgDUFSPCMJHBUPSJP° FO.JTJPOFTTwMPFMBDDFEFBFTBQPTJCJMJEBEFO4BOUJBHPEFM&TUFSPMPIBDFFM "OB1BHBOP*OHSJE4WFSEMJDLZ1BVMB$PTUBT -"/6&7"(&45*Î/%&(0#*&3/0 :464-Ê/&"4%&10-Ê5*$"&%6$"5*7" %VSBOUFFTUPT|MUJNPTBvPTOVFTUSPQBrTBTJTUJwBDBNCJPTJOT UJUVDJPOBMFTDSVDJBMFTDVZPQVOUPEFJO¿FYJwOTFVCJDBFOMBTKPSOB EBTEFMZEFEJDJFNCSFEF-VFHPEFM¾OBMBCSVQUPEFM (PCJFSOPEFMB"MJBO[BDPBMJDJwOFOUSFMB6OJwO$rWJDB3BEJDBMZFM 'SFQBTP ZEFTQVnTEFMBBTVODJwOEFVOBHFTUJwOEFTJHOBEBQPSFM 1BSMBNFOUPEFTEFFMBvPBMBTVNJSFMOVFWPHPCJFSOPFMFHJ EPQPSMBDJVEBEBOrBTFFTUBCJMJ[BSPOMPTNBSDPTJOTUJUVDJPOBMFTEF MBTQSJODJQBMFTgSFBTEFHPCJFSOPBOJWFMOBDJPOBM1PSFTPDSFFNPT RVFQBSBEFTBSSPMMBSVONBQBEJBHOwTUJDPTPCSFMBJODJEFODJBEFMB TPDJFEBEDJWJMFOMBTQPMrUJDBTFEVDBUJWBTSFTVMUBDPOWFOJFOUFUFOFS FO DVFOUB FTUF |MUJNP QFSrPEP HVCFSOBNFOUBM EBEP RVF EF FTUF NPEPTFQVFEFSFBMJ[BSVOSFDPSSJEPNgTBDBCBEPTPCSFMPTQSPDF TPTQBSUJDJQBUJWPTQVFTUPTFONBSDIBFOFTUFDBNQPEFMBTQPMrUJDBT Q|CMJDBT &OVODPOUFYUPEFBNQMJPDPOTFOTPQPSFMSFDIB[PBMBSFGPSNBEF MPTZTVTFGFDUPTSFQSFTFOUBEPFOMBTWPDFTEFMPTEJTUJOUPTDP MFDUJWPTEFMBTPDJFEBEDJWJMWJODVMBEBTBMDBNQPFEVDBUJWPBTrDPNP FOMBTEFMPTEJWFSTPTBDUPSFTHVCFSOBNFOUBMFTMBBDUVBMHFTUJwOEF HPCJFSOPTPTUJFOFVOEJTDVSTPFOFMRVFTFQMBOUFBBWBO[BSFODBN CJPTTVTUBOUJWPTSFTQFDUPEFMPFYJTUFOUF1SPQPOFVO1MBOEF"DDJwO DPO FKFT QSJODJQBMFT FO MPT DVBMFT TF JOTDSJCFO MPT QSPHSBNBT QSPZFDUPT F JOUFSWFODJPOFT DPOT|MUFTF "OFYP 4JO MB QSFUFOTJwO ZFO$PSSJFOUFTFMQPSDJFOUP&MQSPCMFNBEFMBOBMGBCFUJTNPUBNCJnOTFFYUJFOEFFOGPS NBEFTJHVBMFO5JFSSBEFM'VFHPBGFDUBBMEFMBQPCMBDJwOQFSPFOFM$IBDPBMDBO[B FMZFO$PSSJFOUFTFMFOUSFPUSPTFYUSFNPT-PTEBUPTGPSNBOQBSUFEFMQSJNFS JOGPSNFEFMNPOJUPSFPEFMBMFZEF¾OBODJBNJFOUPFEVDBUJWPRVFQVTPFONBSDIBFM$FOUSPEF *NQMFNFOUBDJwOEF1PMrUJDBT1|CMJDBTQBSBMB&RVJEBEZFM$SFDJNJFOUP$JQQFD -B/BDJwO EFNBZPEF &MZEFEJDJFNCSFEFUVWPMVHBSFOMB"SHFOUJOBVOBTJHOJ¾DBUJWBQSPUFTUB TPDJBMTFHVJEBEFVOBDSJTJTJOTUJUVDJPOBMRVFUVWPDPNPDPOTFDVFODJBMBSFOVODJBEFMQSFTJ EFOUFDPOTUJUVDJPOBMZMBDPOGPSNBDJwOEFVOHPCJFSOPQSPWJTJPOBMFMFHJEPQPSFM1BSMBNFOUP 1BSUJDJQBDJwOFJODJEFODJBEFMBTPDJFEBEDJWJMFMDBTPBSHFOUJOP EFTFSFYIBVTUJWPTBRVrBCPSEBSFNPTBMHVOBTEFMBTMrOFBTRVFB OVFTUSPKVJDJPMPSFQSFTFOUBO &O FTUF NBSDP FO MPT TJHVJFOUFT BQBSUBEPT FYBNJOBSFNPT MPT QSPDFTPTEFSJWBEPTEFMBTBODJwOEFMFZFTFEVDBUJWBTFOMPT|MUJNPT BvPT-FZEF&EVDBDJwO5nDOJDP1SPGFTJPOBMMB-FZEF'JOBODJBNJFOUP &EVDBUJWPZMBFMBCPSBDJwOEFVOBOVFWB-FZEF&EVDBDJwO/BDJPOBM RVFTVTUJUVZBMB-FZ'FEFSBMEF&EVDBDJwO-BFMFDDJwOEFFTUPTDBTPT TFWJODVMBDPOMBNBHOJUVERVFQPTFFOFOWJSUVEEFMBTQPTJCJMJEBEFT RVFFODJFSSBOFTUBTOVFWBTOPSNBUJWBTBOJWFMOBDJPOBM&OFMMPTQVF EFOEJWJTBSTFJOTUBODJBTEFJOUFSDBNCJPEFCBUFOFHPDJBDJPOFTRVF FOBMHVOPTNPNFOUPTIBOMMFHBEPBMBDPOTUSVDDJwOEFBDVFSEPTZ DPOTFOTPT WJODVMBEPT BM EJTFvP EF MBT QPMrUJDBT FEVDBUJWBT &O BM HVOBNFEJEBFOFMDBTPEFMPTQSPHSBNBTZQSPZFDUPTFM1SPHSBNB /BDJPOBM EF "MGBCFUJ[BDJwO EF "EVMUPT FM 1SPHSBNB /BDJPOBM EF &EVDBDJwO 4PMJEBSJB FM 1SPHSBNB /BDJPOBM EF *ODMVTJwO &EVDBUJWB ²5PEPTB&TUVEJBS³FM1SPHSBNBEF7PMVOUBSJBEP6OJWFSTJUBSJPFOUSF PUSPT UBNCJnOEFTEFMBQPMrUJDBHVCFSOBNFOUBMTFJOWJUBBQBSUJDJ QBSBEJWFSTBTPSHBOJ[BDJPOFTEFMBTPDJFEBEDJWJM4JOFNCBSHPEFTEF OVFTUSBQFSTQFDUJWBTFUSBUBNgTCJFOEFJOTUBODJBTFOMBTRVFMBT PSHBOJ[BDJPOFTTPOQBSUFEFMBFKFDVDJwOEFQPMrUJDBTQSFWJBNFOUFEF ¾OJEBT&TUPDVFTUJPOBMBJOUFODJwO²BVUnOUJDB³EFBCSJSFTQBDJPTEF QBSUJDJQBDJwOZBTVWF[MMFWBBQSFHVOUBSTFTJ°FOSFBMJEBE°OPTFUSB UBEFQSPDFTPTRVFDPOMMFWBOFMPCKFUJWPEFMFHJUJNBSMBTQPMrUJDBTHV CFSOBNFOUBMFTZEJTNJOVJSMBTTJUVBDJPOFTEFDPO¿JDUP&OMPTQgSSBGPT RVFTJHVFODPNFOUBNPTMBTQSJODJQBMFTMrOFBTEFMBBDUVBMHFTUJwO $POFMJOJDJPEFFTUBHFTUJwOEFHPCJFSOPFM&TUBEP/BDJPOBMTF IJ[PDBSHPEFSFTPMWFSGVFSUFTDPO¿JDUPTQSPWJODJBMFTDPONPUJWPEF MBJOUFSSVQDJwOFOFMQBHPEFTBMBSJPTZMBDPOTFDVFOUFTVTQFOTJwO EFMBTDMBTFT-VFHPFTUBCMFDJw°FOOFHPDJBDJwODPOMBTQSJODJQBMFT FOUJEBEFTHSFNJBMFT°VOQJTPTBMBSJBMQBSBFMDPOKVOUPEFMPTEPDFO UFTEFMQBrT1PS|MUJNPTFSFHVMBSJ[wFMQBHPEFM'0/*%RVFTFQSP SSPHwDPOMBTBODJwOEFMB-FZEF'JOBODJBNJFOUP&EVDBUJWPFOMBRVF TFFTUBCMFDFDPNPQSJODJQBMPCKFUJWPMBFRVJQBSBDJwOTBMBSJBMEFMPT EPDFOUFTEFUPEPFMQBrT&TUFQVOUPTFSgBNQMJBEPNgTBEFMBOUF &O SFMBDJwO DPO MB GPSNBDJwO JOJDJBM Z DBQBDJUBDJwO EPDFOUF FM EJBHOwTUJDPDPOFMRVFDVFOUBFMHPCJFSOPTFvBMBVOBBMUBGSBHNFO "OB1BHBOP*OHSJE4WFSEMJDLZ1BVMB$PTUBT UBDJwOEFTBSUJDVMBDJwOZIFUFSPHFOFJEBEFOMBFEVDBDJwOEFFTUFOJ WFM)FUFSPHFOFJEBERVFTFDBSBDUFSJ[BQPSMBEJWFSTJEBEEFPGFSUBT RVFBCBSDBOMPT*OTUJUVUPTEF'PSNBDJwO%PDFOUFFTUBUBMFTDPOEJGF SFODJBTJNQPSUBOUFTFOTVTUSBZFDUPSJBTTFH|OEFQFOEBOIJTUwSJDB NFOUFEFMBTQSPWJODJBTPIBZBOTJEPUSBOTGFSJEPT MPTQSPGFTPSBEPT EFMBTVOJWFSTJEBEFTZMBTPGFSUBTEFMTFDUPSQSJWBEP"TJNJTNPFM TJTUFNB EF FWBMVBDJwO Z BDSFEJUBDJwO JOTUJUVDJPOBM BCBSDB TwMP VO DPOKVOUPEFJOTUJUVDJPOFTZEFTEFFMQVOUPEFWJTUBOPSNBUJWPIBZ TVQFSQPTJDJPOFT gSFBT EF WBDBODJB Z EFTDPOPDJNJFOUP KVSrEJDP -B GPSNBDJwO QSPGFTJPOBM P DBQBDJUBDJwO EPDFOUF TF BKVTUB B DBEB KV SJTEJDDJwOTFH|OMBTEJGFSFOUFTBEBQUBDJPOFTOPSNBUJWBTQMBOFTEF FTUVEJPZSFDVSTPT%FTEFMBBENJOJTUSBDJwODFOUSBMTFFWJEFODJBMB QSFPDVQBDJwOQPSBSSJCBSBVOTJTUFNBEFGPSNBDJwOJOUFHSBEPZNgT IPNPHnOFPRVFUSBCBKFTPCSFMBUFOTJwOFOUSFMBTEJWFSTJEBEFTKVSJT EJDDJPOBMFTZMBOPSNBUJWBOBDJPOBM 1PSPUSBQBSUFMBTUSBOTGPSNBDJPOFTTPDJBMFTQPMrUJDBTZFDPOw NJDBTZMBTDSJTJTSFDVSSFOUFTHFOFSBEPSBTEFQPCSF[BZFYDMVTJwO QMBOUFBOOVFWPTEFTBGrPTQBSBMBGPSNBDJwOZDBQBDJUBDJwOEPDFOUF -BBDUVBMHFTUJwOEFHPCJFSOPQBSFDFSFDPOPDFSFTUFEJBHOwTUJDPZFO TVEJTDVSTPJOUFOUBJODMVJSOVFWPTDPOUFOJEPTZEJTQPTJUJWPTGPSNBUJ WPT FTDVFMBT JUJOFSBOUFT EF EPDFOUFT DBQBDJUBDJPOFT NVMUJNFEJB MFTDBQBDJUBDJPOFTBEJTUBODJBDJDMPTEFDJOFZGPSNBDJwOBUFOFPT QFEBHwHJDPTUBMMFSFTTFNJOBSJPTFUDnUFSB -BQPMrUJDBEF#FDBTRVFJNQVMTBMBBENJOJTUSBDJwODFOUSBMUJFOF QBSUJDVMBSJNQPSUBODJBFOSFMBDJwODPOMPTSFDVSTPTRVFEJTUSJCVZF 4FUSBUBEFCFDBTFTUVEJBOUJMFTVOJWFSTJUBSJBTEFHSBEPEFQPTHSB EPZFOFMFYUFSJPS&OFTFPSEFOTFFGFDUJWJ[BOBUSBWnTEFEJWFSTPT QSPHSBNBTFM1SPHSBNB/BDJPOBMEF#FDBT&TUVEJBOUJMFTEFTUJOBEBT BKwWFOFTFOTJUVBDJwOEF²SJFTHPFEVDBUJWP³EFM&(#Z1PMJNPEBM P/JWFM.FEJPFM1SPHSBNB/BDJPOBMEF*ODMVTJwO&EVDBUJWB²5PEPT B&TUVEJBS³PUPSHBCFDBTBKwWFOFTRVFTFSFJODPSQPSFOBMTJTUFNB FEVDBUJWP CFDBT FM 1SPHSBNB ²&MFHJS MB EPDFODJB³ BCSF DPODVSTPT EF CFDBT QBSB KwWFOFT RVF FMJKBO MB DBSSFSB EPDFOUF FM 1SPHSBNB /BDJPOBM EF #FDBT 6OJWFSTJUBSJBT PUPSHB CFDBT PSJFOUB EBTBMBDDFTPPQFSNBOFODJBEFBMVNOPTEFMOJWFMVOJWFSTJUBSJPDPO FTDBTPT SFDVSTPT FDPOwNJDPT Z CVFO EFTFNQFvP BDBEnNJDP FM 1BSUJDJQBDJwOFJODJEFODJBEFMBTPDJFEBEDJWJMFMDBTPBSHFOUJOP 1SPHSBNBEF'PSNBDJwOZ$BQBDJUBDJwOQBSBFM4FDUPS&EVDBUJWPFO DPOWFOJPDPO6OJWFSTJEBEFTVPUSPT0SHBOJTNPTPUPSHBCFDBTFTUV EJPTEFQPTHSBEPFM1SPHSBNBEFGPSNBDJwODBQBDJUBDJwOZCFDBT JOUFSOBDJPOBMFT QBSUJDJQB FO QSPHSBNBT EF CFDBT EF JOUFSDBNCJP Z DPPQFSBDJwODPOPUSPTQBrTFT -B QPMrUJDB EF JOGSBFTUSVDUVSB DPO FM 1MBO /BDJPOBM FTDVFMBT QSFWnMBTVTUJUVDJwOEFFEJ¾DJPTFTDPMBSFTFYJTUFOUFT°ZFONBMBTDPO EJDJPOFT°PMBDPOTUSVDDJwOEFFEJ¾DJPTFTDPMBSFTOVFWPT°EFFTDVFMBT RVFEFCFOFTUBSBUFOEJFOEPBQPCMBDJPOFTDPOOFDFTJEBEFTCgTJDBT JOTBUJTGFDIBT°&MEFMQSFTVQVFTUPFTUgEFTUJOBEPBMOJWFM.FEJP P1PMJNPEBM.gTBMMgEFFTUFQMBOTFFODVFOUSBOFOUSFMBTMrOFBTEFM HPCJFSOPMBBNQMJBDJwOEFBVMBTFMNFKPSBNJFOUPEFMBJOGSBFTUSVDUVSB FTDPMBSZMBDPOTUSVDDJwOEF*OTUJUVUPTEF'PSNBDJwO%PDFOUF $PO MB -'& FO MPT TF DPOTJEFSw B MB FEVDBDJwO EF BEVMUPT ²DPNPVOSnHJNFOFTQFDJBMDPOMBDPOTJHVJFOUFEFTKFSBSRVJ[BDJwOEF MBNPEBMJEBEDVFTUJwORVFTFBHSFHwBMEFUFSJPSPZBQSPEVDJEPQPS MBUSBOTGFSFODJBFEVDBUJWB$PNPUBMEFKwEFUFOFSFOMBNBZPSrBEF MBTQSPWJODJBTDPOEVDDJwOZTVQFSWJTJwOFTQFDr¾DBTFOFMNBSDPEFVO QSPDFTPEFDJFSSFEFTFSWJDJPTFEVDBUJWPTGVTJwOEFBMHVOPTEFFMMPT DPOPUSBTPGFSUBTZEFTJOWFSTJwO&MIFDIPEFTFSMBFEVDBDJwOEFBEVM UPTVOBNPEBMJEBERVFBUJFOEFBTFDUPSFTTPDJBMFTFOTJUVBDJwOEFQP CSF[BZQPSFOEFDPOFTDBTPQPEFSSFMBUJWPQBSBEFNBOEBSBM&TUBEP TJHOJ¾Dw RVF FM FGFDUP EFTUSVDUJWP EF MB 5SBOTGPSNBDJwO &EVDBUJWB IBZBTJEPQBSUJDVMBSNFOUFOPUBCMFFOFTUFDBNQPDPOMBDPOTJHVJFOUF WVMOFSBDJwOEFMEFSFDIPBMBFEVDBDJwOEFFTUPTTFDUPSFT³'JOOFHBO Z 1BHBOP -B BDUVBM HFTUJwO EF HPCJFSOP QPOF FO NBSDIB FM 1SPHSBNB/BDJPOBMEF"MGBCFUJ[BDJwOZ&EVDBDJwO#gTJDBQBSB+wWFOFT Z"EVMUPTRVFFODPOWFOJPDPOPSHBOJ[BDJPOFTEFMBTPDJFEBEDJWJMZ BUSBWnTEFWPMVOUBSJPTRVFQFSUFOFDFOBFMMBTMMFWBOBDBCPVOQSP DFTPEFBMGBCFUJ[BDJwOJOJDJBMEFNFTFTQBSBMVFHPBSUJDVMBSDPOFM 4JTUFNBEF&EVDBDJwOEF+wWFOFTZ"EVMUPTEFDBEB+VSJTEJDDJwODPO FMPCKFUPEFDPNQMFUBSMBFTDPMBSJEBEQSJNBSJBCgTJDB1VFEFEFDJSTF FTUBQPMrUJDBRVFTFSFUPNBEFTEFFMOJWFMDFOUSBMDPOBMHVOPTBWBO DFTFODVBOUPBMBBMGBCFUJ[BDJwOEFQPCMBDJPOFTFYDMVJEBTQFSPRVF TVEJNFOTJwOOPJNQMJDBB¾SNBSRVFTFUSBUFEFVOBSVQUVSBSFTQFDUP EFMPT$BCSrBQSFHVOUBSTFTJJNQMJDBBMNFOPTVODBNCJPTJHOJ¾DB UJWPFOFTUFTFOUJEP4FH|OEBUPTP¾DJBMFT.JOJTUFSJPEF&EVDBDJwO "OB1BHBOP*OHSJE4WFSEMJDLZ1BVMB$PTUBT $JFODJBZ5FDOPMPHrB FOMPRVFWBEFMBvPQBSUJDJQBSPO PSHBOJ[BDJPOFT°VOJWFSTJEBEFTHSFNJPTFOUJEBEFTEFMBTPDJFEBEDJ WJMNPWJNJFOUPTQPQVMBSFTZPSHBOJTNPTEFFTUBEPTNVOJDJQBMFTQSP WJODJBMFTZOBDJPOBMFT°TFQVTJFSPOFONBSDIBOVFWPTDFOUSPT EFBMGBCFUJ[BDJwOZTFBMGBCFUJ[BSPOQFSTPOBT &O SFMBDJwO DPO MB QPMrUJDB EF EFSFDIPT IVNBOPT Z FO MP FTQF Dr¾DBNFOUFWJODVMBEPDPOMB|MUJNBEJDUBEVSBNJMJUBSMBHFTUJwOBD UVBM EF HPCJFSOP NBOUJFOF VO EJTDVSTP FYQMrDJUP RVF DPOEFOB MPT EFSFDIPTWVMOFSBEPTQPSFMUFSSPSJTNPEF&TUBEPEVSBOUFFMQFSrPEP EJDUBUPSJBM&M$POHSFTP/BDJPOBMBOVMwMBTMFZFTEFJNQVOJEBEBMB WF[RVFMB$PSUF4VQSFNBEF+VTUJDJBMBTEFDMBSwJODPOTUJUVDJPOBMFT "DUVBMNFOUFTFFTUgOMMFWBOEPBDBCPKVJDJPTQFOBMFTQPSDSrNFOFT EFMFTBIVNBOJEBE&OTFEFDMBSwBMB&TDVFMBEF.FDgOJDBEFMB "SNBEB&4." DPNPVO²&TQBDJPQBSBMB.FNPSJBMB1SPNPDJwOZ %FGFOTBEFMPT%FSFDIPT)VNBOPT³&TUBTBDDJPOFTNBSDBOVODBN CJPSFTQFDUPEFMBTQPMrUJDBTEF&TUBEPRVFTFMMFWBSPOBDBCPEVSBO UFMBEnDBEBEFMZRVFTFNBOUVWJFSPOJOUBDUBTFOMBTHFTUJPOFT EFHPCJFSOPQPTUFSJPSFT &OQMBOPEFMBTQPMrUJDBTFEVDBUJWBTVOBEFMBTJOJDJBUJWBTWJODV MBEBTDPOFTUBQPMrUJDBHFOFSBMFTFMQSPZFDUP²"BvPT³EFMHPMQF EF &TUBEP EF RVF DFOUSB TV QSPQVFTUB EF SF¿FYJwO FO JOT UBODJBT EF GPSNBDJwO Z DBQBDJUBDJwO EPDFOUF BSUJDVMBEBT DPO PUSPT 1SPHSBNBTEFM.JOJTUFSJP/BDJPOBM&OUSFTVTPCKFUJWPTTFQSPQPOFO USBCBKBS TPCSF MB SF¿FYJwO EF MB IJTUPSJB SFDJFOUF FM UFSSPSJTNP EF &TUBEPZMBWVMOFSBDJwOEFMPTEFSFDIPTIVNBOPT"MHVOBTPUSBTBD DJPOFTFOFTUFTFOUJEPFODPMBCPSBDJwODPOMBT"CVFMBTEF1MB[BEF .BZPTPOQSPEVDDJwOZEJTUSJCVDJwOFOMBTFTDVFMBTEFNBUFSJBMFT EJEgDUJDPTQBSBFMOJWFMNFEJPTPCSFFMEFSFDIPBMBJEFOUJEBEFTQB %VSBOUF MB USBOTJDJwO EFNPDSgUJDB TF TBODJPOBSPO MBT MFZFT EF ²1VOUP ¾OBM³ Z ²0CFEJFODJBEFCJEB³RVFDFSSBSPOFMDBNJOPBMFOKVJDJBNJFOUPBSFTQPOTBCMFTEFMUFSSPSJTNP EF&TUBEP%VSBOUFFMHPCJFSOPEF$.FOFNTFTVNBSPOMPTJOEVMUPTQSFTJEFODJBMFTBMPTB|O DPOEFOBEPTZQSPDFTBEPTQPSMBKVTUJDJBGFEFSBM &OMB&TDVFMBEF.FDgOJDBEFMB"SNBEB&4." GVODJPOwEVSBOUFMB|MUJNBEJDUBEV SBNJMJUBSVOPEFMPTNgTHSBOEFTDFOUSPTDMBOEFTUJOPTEFEFUFODJwOZFYUFSNJOJP 1BSUJDJQBDJwOFJODJEFODJBEFMBTPDJFEBEDJWJMFMDBTPBSHFOUJOP DJPTUFMFWJTJWPTFOFMDBOBMFTUBUBMQBSBFMUSBUBNJFOUPEFMBJEFOUJEBE FOMBTFTDVFMBT²&TDVFMBTQPSMBJEFOUJEBE³ FOUSFPUSBTDPTBT &M².JOJTUFSJPTJOFTDVFMBT³QFSPDPOMBDPODFOUSBDJwOZDFOUSB MJ[BDJwOEFMBTEFDJTJPOFTUnDOJDPQPMrUJDBTEFMBEnDBEBEFMPT DPOUJO|BQSFTFOUFFOMBHFTUJwOBDUVBM-BEJTUSJCVDJwOEFGPOEPTTJ HVFBDPOUFDJFOEPFOQBSUFBUSBWnTEFMNFDBOJTNPEF²GPOEPTDPO DVSTBCMFT³BTJHOBEPTBUFNBTZB¾OFTFTQFDr¾DPTRVFTFBEKVEJDBO TFH|O QSFTFOUBDJwO EF QSPZFDUPT QPS QBSUF EF MBT KVSJTEJDDJPOFT FOSFTQVFTUBBDPOWPDBUPSJBTEFTEFMBBENJOJTUSBDJwODFOUSBM4PO FKFNQMPT EF FMMP &M 1SPHSBNB .FKPSBNJFOUP EF MB &TDVFMB .FEJB FM1SPHSBNB*OUFHSBMQBSBMB*HVBMEBE&EVDBUJWB1**& FM1SPHSBNB ÇSFBT EF 7BDBODJB MB $POWPDBUPSJB B QSPZFDUPT QBSB MB NPEFSOJ [BDJwO EF MBCPSBUPSJPT DJFOUr¾DPT FM ¾OBODJBNJFOUP EF QSPZFDUPT QSFTFOUBEPTQPSVOJWFSTJEBEFTFOFMNBSDPEFMBBSUJDVMBDJwOEFMB FEVDBDJwOTVQFSJPSDPOMBFOTFvBO[B.FEJB1PMJNPEBMFM1SPHSBNB EF7PMVOUBSJBEP6OJWFSTJUBSJPFOUSFPUSBT &TUBQPMrUJDBSFQSPEVDFQPSVOMBEPNFDBOJTNPTEFDPNQFUFODJB FOUSFBRVFMMPTRVFTFFODVFOUSBO²BQUPT³QBSBQBSUJDJQBS0/(FT DVFMBTJOTUJUVUPTEFGPSNBDJwOEPDFOUFFUD ZQPSFMPUSPQSPNVF WFMBEFMFHBDJwOZUFSDFSJ[BDJwOEFMBFKFDVDJwOEFMBTMrOFBTQPMrUJDBT DFOUSBMFT"TVWF[FTUBTGPSNBTTFSFQJUFOFOPUSBTgSFBTZTFDUPSFT EFHPCJFSOPEPOEFMBTDPOWPDBUPSJBTBDPODVSTPDPOTUJUVZFOVOPEF MPTNFDBOJTNPTIBCJUVBMFTEFEJTUSJCVDJwOEFMPTSFDVSTPT 1PS|MUJNPFOFMHPCJFSOPOBDJPOBMTBMEwVOBQBSUFEFTVEFV EBDPOFM'POEP.POFUBSJP*OUFSOBDJPOBM'.* &OFMgSFBEFFEVDBDJwO EFTEFFMBvPTFGPNFOUBMBSFBMJ[BDJwOEFBDVFSEPTRVFQFSNJUBO DBOKFBSTFSWJDJPTEFMBEFVEBFYUFSOBQPSJOWFSTJwOFOFEVDBDJwO&TUF EJTDVSTPFTSBUJ¾DBEPFOFMBvPFOMB$VNCSFEFMBT"NnSJDBT "DUVBMNFOUF FM .JOJTUFSJP EF &EVDBDJwO DPOUJO|B SFDJCJFOEP GPOEPT FYUFSOPT RVF EFTUJOB B EJWFSTBT BDDJPOFT JOGSBFTUSVDUVSB FRVJQBNJFOUPCFDBT¾OBODJBNJFOUPBFTDVFMBTFODPOUFYUPTEFTGB -B3FTPMVDJwO/EFM$POTFKP'FEFSBMEF$VMUVSBZ&EVDBDJwOSFDPNJFOEBMB SFBMJ[BDJwOEFFTUVEJPTZMBFKFDVDJwOEFMrOFBTQPMrUJDBTFOFTUFTFOUJEP&ODPPQFSBDJwODPO MB0&*TFSFBMJ[BOFTUVEJPTTPCSFTVWJBCJMJEBE "OB1BHBOP*OHSJE4WFSEMJDLZ1BVMB$PTUBT WPSBCMFTFUD BMHVOPTBUSBWnTEFEJWFSTPT1SPHSBNBTZ1SPZFDUPT 1**&130.4&FOUSFPUSPT ZFOPUSPTDBTPTFO²DPPQFSBDJwO³DPO MB0&*MB0&"PMB6/&4$0 -PTQSPDFTPTEFTBODJwOEFMBTUSFTMFZFTRVFFOVODJBNPTDPNP DPODSFDJPOFT OPSNBUJWBT EF FTUB BENJOJTUSBDJwO QBSFDFO SFDPHFS °FOBMHVOPTDBTPT°SFDMBNPTZSFJWJOEJDBDJPOFTIJTUwSJDBTEFEJWFS TPTTFDUPSFTEFMDBNQPFEVDBUJWPQPSMPDVBMMBTJOTUBODJBTEFEJg MPHPZEJTDVTJwOQPTFFOVOQFTPUBMRVFBVNFOUBMBSFMFWBODJBEFM BOgMJTJT EF MB QBSUJDJQBDJwO F JODJEFODJB EF MB TPDJFEBE DJWJM FO MBT QPMrUJDBTFEVDBUJWBT $BCF EFTUBDBS UBM DPNP TF NFODJPOw NgT BSSJCB RVF MB BDUVBM HFTUJwO QMBOUFB B USBWnT EF TVT EFDMBSBDJPOFT Q|CMJDBT Z EF TVT PCKFUJWPT QPMrUJDPT MB OFDFTJEBE EF DPOTUSVJS FTQBDJPT EF BDVFSEP DPOEJWFSTPTBDUPSFT&OUSFTVTPCKFUJWPTTFJODMVZFOMBTTJHVJFOUFT NFODJPOFTFOSFGFSFODJBBMBBQFSUVSBEFDBOBMFTEFQBSUJDJQBDJwO » (FOFSBSMBTJOTUBODJBTEFQBSUJDJQBDJwOBDUJWBEFMDPOKVOUPEFMPT BDUPSFTEFMTJTUFNBFEVDBUJWPFOFMEFCBUFFJNQMFNFOUBDJwOEF MBTQPMrUJDBTFEVDBUJWBTFOQBSUJDVMBSEFMPTTJOEJDBUPTEPDFOUFT ZOPEPDFOUFTZEFMBTPSHBOJ[BDJPOFTEFQBESFTZFTUVEJBOUFTZ » $POWPDBSBUPEPTMPTBDUPSFTOBDJPOBMFTGVFS[BTQPMrUJDBTTPDJB MFTSFMJHJPTBTZQSPEVDUJWBTFOUSFPUSBTBMBFMBCPSBDJwOEFVO 1SPZFDUP&EVDBUJWP/BDJPOBMRVFTFDPOTUJUVZBFOO|DMFPDFOUSBM EFMBQPMrUJDBEF&TUBEPBNFEJBOPZMBSHPQMB[PQBSBFMEFTBSSPMMP FDPOwNJDPTPDJBMZDVMUVSBM³.JOJTUFSJPEF&EVDBDJwO$JFODJBZ 5FDOPMPHrB "IPSB CJFO FT FO FM QMBOP OPSNBUJWP EPOEF TF QVFEF SFHJTUSBS MBFYJTUFODJBEFDBOBMFTEFQBSUJDJQBDJwORVFTFEJSJHFOBJODPSQPSBS MPT QVOUPT EF WJTUB EF MB TPDJFEBE DJWJM QBSB MB FMBCPSBDJwO EF MBT -FZFTGVOEBNFOUBMFTEFFTUFDBNQP&OFTUFTFOUJEPQBSBMBTBO DJwOEFMBT-FZFT5nDOJDP1SPGFTJPOBMEF'JOBODJBNJFOUPZ(FOFSBM EF &EVDBDJwO TF FMBCPSBSPO SFTPMVDJPOFT EFM $POTFKP 'FEFSBM EF $VMUVSBZ&EVDBDJwOQBSBDSFBSDPNJTJPOFTEFUSBCBKPDVZBUBSFBDPO TJTUrBFOFTUBCMFDFSFTQBDJPTEFEJgMPHPDPOMBTPSHBOJ[BDJPOFTQBSB FMEJTFvPEFMBQPMrUJDBFEVDBUJWBPCJFOQBSBTVBQMJDBDJwO 1BSUJDJQBDJwOFJODJEFODJBEFMBTPDJFEBEDJWJMFMDBTPBSHFOUJOP &OFMDBTPEFMB-FZ5nDOJDP1SPGFTJPOBMFOFMUSBOTDVSTPEFMUSB CBKPTPCSFFM"OUFQSPZFDUPEF-FZEVSBOUFFM°MBMFZTFTBODJP OB FO FM ° FM $POTFKP 'FEFSBM EF &EVDBDJwO SFTVFMWF $POTFKP 'FEFSBM EF $VMUVSB Z &EVDBDJwO .JOJTUFSJP EF &EVDBDJwO $JFODJB Z 5FDOPMPHrB ²"DPSEBSRVFFM.JOJTUFSJPEF&EVDBDJwO$JFODJB Z5FDOPMPHrBEFMB/BDJwOIBSgFYUFOTJWBMBQBSUJDJQBDJwODPOTVMUBO EPBMPTHSFNJPTEPDFOUFTPUSPTBDUPSFTEFMTJTUFNBFEVDBUJWPVOJ WFSTJEBEFTJOTUJUVDJPOFTBDBEnNJDBTZPSHBOJ[BDJPOFTTPDJBMFT³ &O FM DBTP EF MB -FZ EF 'JOBODJBNJFOUP &EVDBUJWP °RVF TF TBO DJPOw B ¾OFT EFM Z FOUSw FO WJHFODJB FO ° MB SFTPMVDJwO RVFFTUBCMFDFDSFBSVOBDPNJTJwOEFUSBCBKPQBSBMBFMBCPSBDJwOEFM BOUFQSPZFDUPEFMFZNBOJ¾FTUBRVFUBMQSPDFTP²EFCFSgEFTBSSPMMBS TFOFDFTBSJBNFOUFDPOFMQSPUBHPOJTNPEFMBTBVUPSJEBEFTFEVDB UJWBT OBDJPOBMFT Z KVSJTEJDDJPOBMFT Z MB QBSUJDJQBDJwO EF UPEPT MPT BDUPSFTEFMTJTUFNBFEVDBUJWPBNQMJBOEPMBDPOWPDBUPSJBBEJWFSTBT PSHBOJ[BDJPOFT TPDJBMFT³ $POTFKP 'FEFSBM EF $VMUVSB Z &EVDBDJwO .JOJTUFSJPEF&EVDBDJwO$JFODJBZ5FDOPMPHrB &OFMNJTNPTFOUJEPZSFTQFDUPEFMSFDJFOUFEFCBUFQBSBMBTBO DJwOEFVOB-FZEF&EVDBDJwO/BDJPOBMRVFTVTUJUVZBMB-FZ'FEFSBM EF &EVDBDJwO FM $POTFKP 'FEFSBM EF &EVDBDJwO SFTVFMWF DSFBS VOB DPNJTJwOEFUSBCBKP²RVFFMBCPSFVOEPDVNFOUPCBTFRVFDPOUFOHB MPTFKFTOFDFTBSJPTQBSBFMBOgMJTJTZEJTDVTJwOEFVOBOVFWBMFZEF FEVDBDJwODPOMPTEJWFSTPTBDUPSFTEFMTJTUFNBFEVDBUJWPOBDJPOBM³ -BNJTNBOPSNBNFODJPOB³RVFMBTBDDJPOFTDPODVSSFOUFTQBSBMB SFDVQFSBDJwOEFMBFEVDBDJwOEFCFSgOEFTBSSPMMBSTFOFDFTBSJBNFOUF DPOFMQSPUBHPOJTNPEFMBTBVUPSJEBEFTFEVDBUJWBTOBDJPOBMFTZKV SJTEJDDJPOBMFTEFMPTEPDFOUFTEFMBTGBNJMJBT<>ZMBQBSUJDJQBDJwO EFUPEPTMPTBDUPSFTEFMTJTUFNBFEVDBUJWPBNQMJBOEPMBDPOWPDBUP SJBBEJWFSTBTPSHBOJ[BDJPOFTTPDJBMFT³$POTFKP'FEFSBMEF$VMUVSBZ &EVDBDJwO.JOJTUFSJPEF&EVDBDJwO$JFODJBZ5FDOPMPHrB "OB1BHBOP*OHSJE4WFSEMJDLZ1BVMB$PTUBT $"3"$5&3*;"$*Î/%*"(/Î45*$"%&-"4*56"$*Î/ %&-"1"35*$*1"$*Î/&*/$*%&/$*" %&-"40$*&%"%$*7*-&/-"10-Ê5*$"&%6$"5*7" &4536$563"%&1"35*$*1"$*Î/ &45"#-&$*%"103&-(0#*&3/0"$56"&TQPTJCMFJEFOUJ¾DBSBMHVOPTNFDBOJTNPTFJOTUSVNFOUPTJOTUJ UVDJPOBMFTBCJFSUPTQPSFMHPCJFSOPDPOFM¾OEFIBCJMJUBSZDBOBMJ[BS MBQBSUJDJQBDJwOEFMPTEJGFSFOUFTBDUPSFTEFMBTPDJFEBEDJWJMFOSFMB DJwODPOFMEFCBUFEJTFvPEFTBSSPMMPHFTUJwOTFHVJNJFOUPDPOUSPM ZFWBMVBDJwOEFMBTQPMrUJDBTFEVDBUJWBT &OUnSNJOPTHFOFSBMFTFTUPTNFDBOJTNPTPFTUSBUFHJBTJOTUJUV DJPOBMFTTFUSBEVDFOFOFTQBDJPTEFDPODFSUBDJwOZBSUJDVMBDJwODPO EJWFSTPTTFDUPSFTEFMBTPDJFEBEDJWJMSFBMJ[BDJwOEFTFNJOBSJPTFO DVFOUSPTZKPSOBEBTDPOWPDBUPSJBTBDPODVSTPT²JOWJUBDJPOFT³BTFS QBSUFEFMBJNQMFNFOUBDJwOEFBDDJPOFTEJWFSTBTZPUPSHBNJFOUPEF SFDVSTPTNBUFSJBMFT &OFTUFDPOKVOUPDBCFEJTUJOHVJSBRVFMMPTNFDBOJTNPTRVFTPO QSPQJPT EF MB FTUSVDUVSB EFM .JOJTUFSJP EF &EVDBDJwO EF BRVFMMPT RVFDPOGPSNBOMBFTUSBUFHJBQPMrUJDBEFMHPCJFSOPBDUVBM &ODVBOUPBMPTQSJNFSPTDBCFIBDFSVOBNFODJwOBMB¾HVSBEFM $POTFKP'FEFSBMEF$VMUVSBZ&EVDBDJwO&TUFDPOGPSNBMBFTUSVDUVSB EFM .JOJTUFSJP EF &EVDBDJwO Z FTUg DPNQVFTUP QPS MBT BVUPSJEBEFT FEVDBUJWBTEFDBEBKVSJTEJDDJwOZQSFTJEJEBQPSFM.JOJTUSPOBDJPOBM %FTEFTVTJOJDJPTGVFQMBOUFBEPDPNPVOFTQBDJPEFDPOTUSVDDJwOEF BDVFSEPTZDPODFSUBDJwOEFQPMrUJDBFEVDBUJWB&TJOUFSnTNBOJ¾FTUP 1BSUJDJQBDJwOFJODJEFODJBEFMBTPDJFEBEDJWJMFMDBTPBSHFOUJOP EFFTUBHFTUJwOFM²KFSBSRVJ[BSTVSPM³DPNPPSHBOJTNPEFDPODFS UBDJwO F JEFOUJ¾DBSMP DPNP VO FTQBDJP EF QBSUJDJQBDJwO GFEFSBM FO SFMBDJwODPOFMEJTFvPZEFCBUFEFMBTQPMrUJDBTQ|CMJDBT&M$POTFKP FOTVDPOKVOUPTFSF|OFQPSOPSNBUJWBEPTWFDFTBMBvPFOBTBNCMFB PSEJOBSJBFYDFQUPRVFFMQSFTJEFOUFPFM$PNJUn&KFDVUJWPDPOWPRVFO BBTBNCMFBFYUSBPSEJOBSJB&M$PNJUn&KFDVUJWPZMBTDPNJTJPOFTEF USBCBKPDPO¾OFTFTQFDr¾DPTMPIBDFOEFNBOFSBSFHVMBS &OSFMBDJwODPOMBBQFSUVSBEFNFDBOJTNPTEFQBSUJDJQBDJwORVF DPOGPSNBO VOB FTUSBUFHJB QPMrUJDB DBCF NFODJPOBS UBM DPNP TF NFODJPOwMBTJOTUBODJBTEFEJgMPHPQSPQVFTUBTQPSFMHPCJFSOPDPO NPUJWPEFMBTBODJwOEFMBTMFZFTEF&EVDBDJwO5nDOJDP1SPGFTJPOBM EF 'JOBODJBNJFOUP &EVDBUJWP Z EF MB SFDJFOUF -FZ /BDJPOBM EF &EVDBDJwO "DPOUJOVBDJwOTFEFTDSJCFDwNPTFFGFDUJWJ[BSPOUBMFTEFDMBSB DJPOFTZSFTPMVDJPOFTSFTQFDUPEFMBBQFSUVSBEFDBOBMFTEFQBSUJDJ QBDJwOZDVgMGVFFM²VTP³EFFTPTDBOBMFTQPSQBSUFEFMPTEJWFSTPT BDUPSFTDPOWPDBEPT 130$&404%&1"35*$*1"$*Î/&'&$5*7".&/5&%&4"330--"%04 -FZ5nDOJDP1SPGFTJPOBM $POMB3FGPSNB&EVDBUJWBEFMPTBvPTMBFEVDBDJwOUnDOJDBFO MB "SHFOUJOB TVGSJw HSBWFT DPOTFDVFODJBT -B USBOTGFSFODJB EF MPT FTUBCMFDJNJFOUPTBMBTQSPWJODJBTTJOMBFGFDUJWJ[BDJwOEFMPTSFDVS TPTKVOUPDPOMBSFFTUSVDUVSBDJwODVSSJDVMBSBUFOUwDPOUSBFMGVODJP OBNJFOUPZPSHBOJ[BDJwOUSBEJDJPOBMEFMBFEVDBDJwOUnDOJDB%FTEF FOUPODFTMBTKVSJTEJDDJPOFTUJFOFOEJTUJOUPTQMBOFTEFFTUVEJPZEF EVSBDJwOEFMBTDBSSFSBT(SBODBOUJEBEEFFTDVFMBTUnDOJDBTTFDPO WJSUJFSPOFOQPMJNPEBMFTDPOEJTUJOUBTPSJFOUBDJPOFTQFSEJFOEPBTr JNQPSUBOUFTDBSHBTIPSBSJBTEFGPSNBDJwOQSPGFTJPOBMZEFNBUFSJBT FMFNFOUBMFT -BBQMJDBDJwOEFMBTQPMrUJDBTOFPMJCFSBMFTFOPUSBTFTGFSBTPQVFT UBTBMEFTBSSPMMPEFMBJOEVTUSJBOBDJPOBMZRVFSFTVMUBSPOFOMBEFT USVDDJwOEFMBQSPEVDDJwOMPDBMGVFSPOPUSPGBDUPSEFUFSNJOBOUFFO "OB1BHBOP*OHSJE4WFSEMJDLZ1BVMB$PTUBT FTUFQSPDFTPUFOJFOEPFODVFOUBMBDFOUSBMJEBERVFBERVJFSFMBSFMB DJwOEFMBFEVDBDJwOUnDOJDPQSPGFTJPOBMDPOFMNVOEPQSPEVDUJWP -BTEJ¾DVMUBEFTFOFMDBNQPEFMBQSPEVDDJwOKVOUPDPOMBTBD UVBMFT GBMFODJBT FO MB FEVDBDJwO UnDOJDB USBFO BQBSFKBEPT QSPCMF NBTQBSBMBJOTFSDJwOMBCPSBM%FTEFFMHPCJFSOPTFQMBOUFBRVFOPT IBMMBNPT GSFOUF B VO QSPDFTP EF SFDVQFSBDJwO JOEVTUSJBM Z RVF FO FTUFNBSDPOPIBZQFSTPOBTDPODBQBDJEBEZDPOPDJNJFOUPTUnDOJ DPTQBSBMBTgSFBTEFMBQSPEVDDJwORVFMPSFRVJFSFO %FTEF IBDF WBSJPT BvPT EJWFSTPT TFDUPSFT HSFNJBMFT USBCBKB EPSFT EPDFOUFT Z OP EPDFOUF QMBOUFBO MB OFDFTJEBE EF VOB OVFWB -FZ-BBDUVBMHFTUJwOEFHPCJFSOPDPOTJEFSBFTUFUFNBDPNPVOPEF MPTQSJPSJUBSJPTBUSBUBSFOMBDBSUFSBFEVDBUJWB&TBTrRVFFM1PEFS &KFDVUJWP FMBCPSw VO BOUFQSPZFDUP EF MFZ RVF BCSJw VO QSPDFTP EF EFCBUFZBDVFSEPTFOUPSOPBFTUBQSPCMFNgUJDB &OQSJNFSBJOTUBODJBEJDIPBOUFQSPZFDUPTFEFCBUJwDPOMPTNJOJT USPTEFMBTEJWFSTBTKVSJTEJDDJPOFTFOFMNBSDPEFM$POTFKP'FEFSBMEFM $VMUVSBZ&EVDBDJwO-VFHPGVFEJTDVUJEPDPOFNQSFTBSJPTZHSFNJPT FOFMgNCJUPEFM$POTFKP/BDJPOBMEF&EVDBDJwOZ5SBCBKP$0/&5 0USB JOTUBODJB FO MB RVF TF USBCBKw TPCSF FM QSPZFDUP EF MFZ GVF FM 99***&ODVFOUSP'FEFSBMEF&EVDBDJwOZ5SBCBKPMMFWBEPBDBCPQPS FM*OTUJUVUP/BDJPOBMEF&EVDBDJwO5FDOPMwHJDB*/&5 EFM.JOJTUFSJP EF&EVDBDJwO$JFODJBZ5FDOPMPHrB"MMrQBSUJDJQBSPOSFQSFTFOUBOUFT EF HSFNJPT EPDFOUFT EF BMDBODF OBDJPOBM $5&3" 4"%01 6%" Z ".&5 EFMB6OJwO*OEVTUSJBM"SHFOUJOB6*" ZEFMB$POGFEFSBDJwO "SHFOUJOBEFMB.FEJBOB&NQSFTB$".& &M QSPZFDUP FMBCPSBEP QPS FM 1PEFS &KFDVUJWP JOHSFTw FO FM $POHSFTP/BDJPOBMFOOPWJFNCSFEF4FMPWPUwFOMBDgNBSB EFEJQVUBEPTFMEFBHPTUPEFMBvPTJHVJFOUFZTFTBODJPOwQPT UFSJPSNFOUF°DPOMBBQSPCBDJwOEFMBDgNBSBEFTFOBEPSFT°VOPT ErBTEFTQVnT &OFMgNCJUPQBSMBNFOUBSJPTFMMFWBSPOBDBCPPUSBTJOTUBODJBTEF DPOTVMUB-BTDPNJTJPOFTEFFEVDBDJwOEFBNCBTDgNBSBT°EJQVUB EPTZTFOBEPSFT°DVSTBSPO²JOWJUBDJPOFT³BPQJOBSTPCSFMPTQSPZFD UPTEFMFZBEJWFSTPTTFDUPSFTEFMBTPDJFEBEDJWJMQSJODJQBMNFOUFB DgNBSBTFNQSFTBSJBMFTZHSFNJPTEPDFOUFT 1BSUJDJQBDJwOFJODJEFODJBEFMBTPDJFEBEDJWJMFMDBTPBSHFOUJOP 1VFEFEFDJSTFRVFFMQSPZFDUPRVFJOJDJBMNFOUFQSFTFOUwFM1PEFS &KFDVUJWPQBSBFMEFCBUFFOFM$POHSFTP/BDJPOBMUVWPNPEJ¾DBDJP OFTRVFMVFHPEFTBSSPMMBSFNPTZGVFSPOQSPEVDUPEFMBTJOTUBODJBT NFODJPOBEBT4JOFNCBSHPZBQFTBSEFFMMPTVBQSPCBDJwOOPGVF QPSBNQMJBNBZPSrBTJFOEPMPTWPUPTBGBWPSZFODPOUSB -B-FZTBODJPOBEBFTUBCMFDFVONBSDPSFHVMBUPSJPHFOFSBMQBSBMB FEVDBDJwOUnDOJDBZGPSNBDJwOQSPGFTJPOBMBDPSEFDPOFMEJBHOwTUJDP NFODJPOBEP&TUBCMFDFMBEVSBDJwOEFTFJTBvPTQBSBMBFEVDBDJwO NFEJBUnDOJDBFMSFDPOPDJNJFOUPOBDJPOBMEFMPTFTUVEJPTBUSBWnTEF DFSUJ¾DBDJPOFTZUrUVMPTRVFEFCFSgOTFSIPNPMPHBEPTQPSFM$POTFKP 'FEFSBMEF$VMUVSBZ&EVDBDJwOVO¾OBODJBNJFOUPFTQFDr¾DPQBSBFM TFDUPSRVFEFUFSNJOBVONPOUPBOVBMEFMQSFTVQVFTUPOBDJPOBMRVF EFCFSgTFSEFTUJOBEPBFTUFTFDUPSEFMQSFTVQVFTUPBOVBMQSF WJTUP QBSB FM TFDUPS Q|CMJDP OBDJPOBM QBSB JOWFSUJS FO FRVJQBNJFO UPTJOTVNPZDBQBDJUBDJwO1FSNJUFBMBWF[RVFMPTBMVNOPTEFMBT FTDVFMBTUnDOJDBTSFBMJDFOQBTBOUrBTFOFNQSFTBTQSJWBEBTQSFWJB ¾SNBEFDPOWFOJPTEFDPMBCPSBDJwODPOMBTBVUPSJEBEFTFEVDBUJWBT &MEJTDVSTPP¾DJBMTPTUJFOFRVF²FTUBMFZFTFMJOTUSVNFOUPOFDF TBSJPQBSBVOB"SHFOUJOBJOEVTUSJBMZQSPEVDUJWBEPOEFMPTKwWFOFTZ MPTUSBCBKBEPSFTUFOHBOMBQPTJCJMJEBEEFFTUVEJBSZBDDFEFSBMUSBCB KPDPOMBDBMJEBERVFNFSFDFO<>/PTwMPFTUBNPTEJTDVUJFOEPVOB OVFWBMFZEFFEVDBDJwOUnDOJDBQBSBFMQBrTTJOPRVFUBNCJnOFTUB NPTEF¾OJFOEPRVnQFS¾MEF"SHFOUJOBRVFSFNPT³1PSPUSBQBSUF SFTBMUBOFMUSBUBNJFOUPEFMUFNBDPNPVOBJOJDJBUJWBEFFTUBHFTUJwO ZTPTUJFOFORVFTVEJTFvPTFEJPFOFMNBSDPEFVOQPTJUJWPQSPDFTP EFQBSUJDJQBDJwOEFMBDPNVOJEBEFEVDBUJWB "IPSB CJFO MBT QPTJDJPOFT Z PQJOJPOFT EVSBOUF FTUF QSPDFTP GVFSPO EJWFSTBT -PT HSFNJPT EF BMDBODF OBDJPOBM DPNP $5&3" Z ".&5 FOUSF PUSPT TPTUJFOFO RVF TF USBUw EF VO QSPDFTP QPTJUJWP ZDPOTJEFSBSPOBFTUBMFZ²DPNPVOQSJNFSQBTPFOFMBWBODFIBDJB VOBOVFWBMFZEFFEVDBDJwORVFQFSNJUBTVQFSBSMBGSBHNFOUBDJwO %FDMBSBDJPOFTEFM.JOJTUSPEF&EVDBDJwO%BOJFM'JMNVTFO.JOJTUFSJPEF&EVDBDJwO $JFODJBZ5FDOPMPHrB1PSUBM&EVDBUJWPEFM.JOJTUFSJPEF&EVDBDJwO%JQVUBEPTEJPNFEJBTBO DJwOBMQSPZFDUPEFMFZEFFEVDBDJwOUnDOJDBEFBHPTUPEF "OB1BHBOP*OHSJE4WFSEMJDLZ1BVMB$PTUBT RVFTJHOJ¾DwMBJNQMFNFOUBDJwOEFMB-FZ'FEFSBMZMBUSBOTGFSFODJB EFFTDVFMBT³465&#" 7BMPSBOQSJODJQBMNFOUFRVFTFIBZB TBODJPOBEPVOBMFZ²QPSGVFSB³EFMBSFHMBNFOUBDJwOFYJTUFOUFRVF OPIJDJFSBSFGFSFODJBTZFONJFOEBTBMB-FZ'FEFSBMEF&EVDBDJwOZ MB-FZEF&EVDBDJwO4VQFSJPSDPNP¾HVSBCBFOFMQSPZFDUPJOJDJBM &OFTUFTFOUJEPDPOTJEFSBORVFTVTBQPSUFTGVFSPODPOUFNQMBEPT "TJNJTNP BMHVOPT TFDUPSFT EF MB FEVDBDJwO UnDOJDB FTQFDr¾DB NFOUF EJSFDUPSFT EF FTDVFMB TPTUJFOFO RVF FTUB MFZ FT VO BWBODF JNQPSUBOUFEFTEFFMHPCJFSOPQVFTDPOFMMB²FTUgOEJDJFOEPRVFMB FEVDBDJwOUnDOJDBOPQVFEFEFTBQBSFDFS³ 4JOFNCBSHPPUSPTTFDUPSFTEFMBTPDJFEBEDJWJMNBZPSNFOUFMJ HBEPT B DFOUSPT EF FTUVEJBOUFT TF PQPOFO EF NBOFSB NgT EFUFS NJOBOUFBFTUB-FZ&OCVFOBNFEJEBMBTDSrUJDBTTFDFOUSBOFOMB BNCJHFEBESFTQFDUPEFMBEVSBDJwOEFMBFEVDBDJwOUnDOJDBNFEJB -B OVFWB -FZ FTUBCMFDF RVF MPT QMBOFT EF FTUVEJP EFM OJWFM NFEJP UnDOJDPEFCFOUFOFSVOBEVSBDJwOEFTFJTBvPT-BBNCJHFEBESF TVMUBEFMBGBMUBEFQSFDJTJwOSFTQFDUPEFMQVOUPEFQBSUJEBEFFTPT TFJTBvPT-BIFUFSPHFOFJEBEEFMTJTUFNBFOFMQBrTIBSgRVFDBEB KVSJTEJDDJwOBKVTUFMBOPSNBBTVDPOWFOJFODJBQVEJFOEPPQUBSQPS DPOUFNQMBSEFTEFFMPDUBWPBvPEFMB&(#ZVODJDMP1PMJNPEBMEF DVBUSP BvPT P EFTEF FM TnQUJNP EF MB &(# DPNQMFUBOEP DPO MPT USFTBvPTEF1PMJNPEBM 3FTQFDUPEFMBTQBTBOUrBTUBNCJnOTFBCSFPUSBEJTDVTJwO-B-FZ FTUBCMFDF DPNP TF NFODJPOBCB NgT BSSJCB RVF MPT BMVNOPT QVF EBO SFBMJ[BS QBTBOUrBT FO FNQSFTBT QSJWBEBT QSFWJP DPOWFOJP EF FTUBT DPO MBT BVUPSJEBEFT FEVDBUJWBT -PT TFDUPSFT FNQSFTBSJBMFT DPOTVMUBEPTFOTVNPNFOUPBDPSEBSPODPOMBTBODJwOEFMB-FZ4JO FNCBSHPHSVQPTEFFTUVEJBOUFTEFFTDVFMBTUnDOJDBTOPNBOUVWJF SPOMBNJTNBQPTUVSB%VSBOUFFMQSPDFTPEFTBODJwOFOFM$POHSFTP /BDJPOBMSFBMJ[BSPONBOJGFTUBDJPOFT°KVOUPDPOEPDFOUFTEFMBTFT DVFMBT°FOMBTRVFFTHSJNrBORVFMBOPSNBOPIBDrBPUSBDPTBRVF QFSNJUJSMBFOUSBEBEFMTFDUPSQSJWBEPBUSBWnTEFMBTFNQSFTBTFOFM %FDMBSBDJPOFTEF1FESP#JOJSFDUPSEFMB&TDVFMB5nDOJDB/²0UUP,SBVTF³FMDP MFHJPJOEVTUSJBMNgTBOUJHVPEFMQBrTGVOEBEPIBDFBvPT ²&EVDBDJwO5nDOJDBBQSVFCBO VOBMFZRVFCVTDBNFKPSBSMBDBQBDJUBDJwO³FO$MBSrO#VFOPT"JSFTEFBHPTUPEF 1BSUJDJQBDJwOFJODJEFODJBEFMBTPDJFEBEDJWJMFMDBTPBSHFOUJOP FTQBDJPQ|CMJDPEFMBFEVDBDJwOBMBWF[RVFBUSBWnTEFMNFDBOJT NPEFQBTBOUrBTSFQSPEVDrBMBVUJMJ[BDJwOEFNBOPEFPCSBCBSBUB QPSQBSUFEFFTUBT1PSPUSPMBEPDPOTJEFSBSPORVFMBTBODJwOJNQMJ DBCBVOBEFWBMVBDJwOEFMUrUVMPDPOWJSUJFOEPBMBFTDVFMBUnDOJDBFO VOCBDIJMMFSDPOPSJFOUBDJwOFTQFDJBM(VUJnSSF[ -BTQSJODJQBMFTDSrUJDBTRVFBDBCBNPTEFNFODJPOBSMBTSFBMJ[BO MPT TFDUPSFT FTUVEJBOUJMFT MJHBEPT B MBT FTDVFMBT UnDOJDBT BMHVOPT TFDUPSFT EPDFOUFT Z UBNCJnO MPT QBSUJEPT QPMrUJDPT EF J[RVJFSEB &TUBT QPTJDJPOFT TPTUJFOFO RVF OP IVCP EFCBUF TV¾DJFOUF QPS VO MBEP MPT FTUVEJBOUFT DPOTJEFSBSPO RVF MPT MFHJTMBEPSFT MPT EFKB SPO GVFSB EFM EFCBUF Z QPS FM PUSP QPS FKFNQMP NJFNCSPT EF MB 'VOEBDJwO 0UUP ,SBVTF FHSFTBEPT EF EJDIB FTDVFMB UnDOJDB TPT UJFOFO RVF IVCP EJTDSJNJOBDJwO FO MB DPOWPDBUPSJB B DPOTVMUB EF EJWFSTPT TFDUPSFT ²RVJFOFT OP FTUBCBO EF BDVFSEP DPO MB MFZ RVF TFSrBWPUBEBZTBODJPOBEBOPGVFSPODPOWPDBEPT³3FWJTUB.VOEP %PDFOUF -FZEF'JOBODJBNJFOUP&EVDBUJWP &MQSPDFTPRVFJNQMJDwMBTBODJwOEFFTUBMFZEPOEFTFUSBCBKB TPCSFSFJWJOEJDBDJPOFTIJTUwSJDBTEFMTJOEJDBMJTNPEPDFOUFMMFWwBMB EFDJTJwOEFUPNBSMBDPNPDBTPEFFTUVEJPFOSFMBDJwODPOMBQBSUJDJ QBDJwOZTVJODJEFODJBFOMBTQPMrUJDBTFEVDBUJWBT.gTBEFMBOUFTF EFTBSSPMMBUBMBOgMJTJT %FCBUFQBSBVOBOVFWB-FZEF&EVDBDJwO/BDJPOBM $POTJEFSBOEPRVFMBTDPOTFDVFODJBTOFHBUJWBTEFMBTSFGPSNBT EFMPTBvPTJNQPOrBOMBOFDFTJEBEEFVODBNCJPZBQPZgOEPTF FOMBTSFJWJOEJDBDJPOFTEFEJWFSTPTTFDUPSFTEFMBTPDJFEBEDJWJMMB BDUVBMHFTUJwOEFHPCJFSOPUPNBMBJOJDJBUJWBEFDPNFO[BSVOQSPDF TPEFFMBCPSBDJwOZQPTUFSJPSTBODJwOEFVOBOVFWB-FZ/BDJPOBMEF &EVDBDJwO "HFODJB 5nMBN ²&M TFOBEP DPOWJSUJw FO MFZ VO QSPZFDUP RVF SFHVMB MB FEVDBDJwO UnDOJDB³#VFOPT"JSFTEFTFQUJFNCSFEFM "OB1BHBOP*OHSJE4WFSEMJDLZ1BVMB$PTUBT &O FM EJTDVSTP P¾DJBM TF QMBOUFB MB OFDFTJEBE EF VOB OVFWB -FZ /BDJPOBMEF&EVDBDJwODPOMB¾OBMJEBEEF²RVFFTUBTNFEJEBTBQVO UFO B SFWFSUJSMBGSBHNFOUBDJwOEFMTJTUFNB FEVDBUJWP³ <©> "Tr TF vBMBO²RVFSFNPTRVFUPEPTMPTDIJDPTFTUVEJFOZUFOHBOBDDFTPB MBNJTNBDBMJEBEEFFEVDBDJwO³.JOJTUFSJPEF&EVDBDJwO$JFODJBZ 5FDOPMPHrB &OSFMBDJwODPOMBQBSUJDJQBDJwOFM.JOJTUSPEF&EVDBDJwONBOJ GFTUw²RVFSFNPTRVFMBQBSUJDJQBDJwOEFMPTEPDFOUFTTFBFMSBTHP EJTUJOUJWPEFMBEJTDVTJwORVFJOJDJBNPTZRVFMBMFZFOUSFFOMBTFT DVFMBTEFMBNBOPEFMPTNBFTUSPT³$MBSrO "TVWF[FMQSFTJ EFOUF,JSDIOFSEFDMBSw²-BBSHFOUJOBOFDFTJUBVOQSPGVOEPEFCBUF RVFOPTQFSNJUBFMBCPSBSVOQSPZFDUPEFMFZEFFEVDBDJwOOBDJPOBM BNQMJBNFOUF MFHJUJNBEP QPS MB PQJOJwO Z MB QBSUJDJQBDJwO EFM DPO KVOUP EF MB DJVEBEBOrB <> 4PNPT DPOTDJFOUFT EF RVF BM DPOWPDBS BM EFCBUF TPCSF FM GVUVSP EF MB FEVDBDJwO BSHFOUJOB UBNCJnO FTUB NPTQPOJFOEPFOEJTDVTJwOFMNPEFMPEFQBrTRVFRVFSFNPTQBSBMBT QSwYJNBTEnDBEBT³.PSFOP &ONBZPEFFTUFBvPFMHPCJFSOPFMBCPSwVOEPDVNFOUPQBSBFM EFCBUFEFVOBOVFWB-FZEF&EVDBDJwO/BDJPOBMRVFSFFNQMBDFBMB -FZ'FEFSBMEF&EVDBDJwO&OFTUFNBSDPMMFWwBDBCPWBSJBTBDDJPOFT WJODVMBEBTBMBBQFSUVSBEFFTQBDJPTEFQBSUJDJQBDJwOBEJWFSTPTTFD UPSFTEFMBTPDJFEBEDJWJM&MEPDVNFOUPNFODJPOBEPGVFEJTUSJCVJEP FOMPTFTUBCMFDJNJFOUPTFEVDBUJWPTEFMQBrTDPOMBJOUFODJwOEFTFSWJS EFBQPZPBMBEJTDVTJwORVFQSPNPWJwMBSFBMJ[BDJwOEFVOB+PSOBEB /BDJPOBMEFSF¿FYJwOZEJTDVTJwOFOMBTFTDVFMBTRVFTFJNQMFNFOUw .JOJTUFSJPEF&EVDBDJwO$JFODJBZ5FDOPMPHrB%PDVNFOUPQBSBFMEFCBUF²-FZEF &EVDBDJwO/BDJPOBM)BDJBVOBFEVDBDJwOEFDBMJEBEQBSBVOBTPDJFEBENgTKVTUB³NBZPEFM &TUFEPDVNFOUPQPTUVMBFKFTEFEJTDVTJwO(BSBOUJ[BSRVFUPEPTUFOHBOBDDFTPZ QFSNBOF[DBOFOFMTJTUFNBFEVDBUJWP-BCVFOBDBMJEBEEFMBFEVDBDJwOFTVOEFSFDIPEF UPEPT(BSBOUJ[BSFMEFSFDIPBTFSSFDPOPDJEPZSFTQFUBEPFOTVMFOHVBZFOTVDVMUVSB (BSBOUJ[BSFMEFSFDIPEFVOBFEVDBDJwOBMPMBSHPEFUPEBMBWJEB(BSBOUJ[BSFMEFSFDIPEF MBTGBNJMJBTBQBSUJDJQBSFOMBFEVDBDJwOEFTVTIJKPT&MEPDFOUFDPNPTVKFUPEFEFSFDIPHB SBOUJ[BSMBTDPOEJDJPOFTEJHOBTEFUSBCBKPEFGPSNBDJwOZEFDBSSFSB(BSBOUJ[BSFMEFSFDIP EFMPTBMVNOPTZBMVNOBTBUFOFSFTDVFMBTFODPOEJDJPOFTNBUFSJBMFTEJHOBT(BSBOUJ[BSFM EFSFDIPEFUPEPTZUPEBTBQBSUJDJQBSEFMEFTBGrPFEVDBUJWP(BSBOUJ[BSFMEFSFDIPEFUPEPT ZUPEBTBDPOPDFSZEPNJOBSMBTOVFWBTUFDOPMPHrBTEFMBJOGPSNBDJwO1POFSFMHPCJFSOPEF MBFEVDBDJwOBMTFSWJDJPEFMPTPCKFUJWPTEFMBDBMJEBEQBSBUPEPTZUPEBT 1BSUJDJQBDJwOFJODJEFODJBEFMBTPDJFEBEDJWJMFMDBTPBSHFOUJOP EVSBOUFFMNFTEFKVMJPEFFTUFBvP -BTQSPQVFTUBTFMBCPSBEBTQPS EPDFOUFT FTUVEJBOUFT Z QBESFT TF FOUSFHBSPO B MB BENJOJTUSBDJwO DFOUSBMBUSBWnTEFTJTUFNBUJ[BDJPOFTKVSJTEJDDJPOBMFT 1PSPUSBQBSUFTFSFBMJ[wVOBFODVFTUBEFPQJOJwORVFTFQVCMJDw FOUSFTJNQPSUBOUFTEJBSJPTOBDJPOBMFT$MBSrO-B/BDJwOZ1gHJOB ZFOFMQPSUBMFEVDBUJWPFOEFMTJUJPXFCEFM.JOJTUFSJPEF&EVDBDJwO "TJNJTNP EVSBOUF BMHVOBT KPSOBEBT MBT NJTNBT TF BQMJDBSPO FO QVFTUPTDBMMFKFSPTVCJDBEPTFOMPTQSJODJQBMFTDFOUSPTVSCBOPT EFM QBrT-BJOUFODJwOGVFSFDBCBSMBTPQJOJPOFTEFBRVFMMPT²QBSUJDVMB SFT³RVFRVJTJFSBOQBSUJDJQBSEFFTUBJOTUBODJBEFEFCBUF&OFMNJT NP TJUJP XFC TF HFOFSw VO FTQBDJP EPOEF TF QVCMJDBSPO EJTUJOUPT QSPOVODJBNJFOUPTEFFYQFSUPTJOTUJUVDJPOFTZEJWFSTBTPSHBOJ[BDJP OFTEFMBTPDJFEBEDJWJM 4FMMFWBSPOBDBCP²SPOEBT³EFDPOTVMUBZEJTDVTJwOBUSBWnTEF MBTDVBMFTFM.JOJTUFSJPEF&EVDBDJwODPOWPDwBEJWFSTPTTFDUPSFTEF MBTPDJFEBEDJWJMPSHBOJ[BDJPOFTHSFNJBMFTEPDFOUFTZOPEPDFOUFT VOJWFSTJEBEFTPSHBOJ[BDJPOFTEFEFSFDIPTIVNBOPTJHMFTJBTNPWJ NJFOUPTTPDJBMFTBDUPSFTTPDJBMFTWJODVMBEPTBMNVOEPEFMUSBCBKPZ MBQSPEVDDJwONFEJPTEFDPNVOJDBDJwO0/(SFQSFTFOUBOUFTEFMPT QVFCMPTPSJHJOBSJPTFUDFOMBTRVFFTUPTQSFTFOUBSPOTVTQSPQVFT UBTFOSFMBDJwODPOFMEPDVNFOUPJOJDJBMFMBCPSBEPQPSFMHPCJFSOP &OSFMBDJwODPOFMEFCBUFRVFDVMNJOwIBDFQPDPUJFNQPIVCP ZIBZEJWFSTBTPQJOJPOFTZQPTJDJPOBNJFOUPTQPMrUJDPT1PSVOBQBS UF MPT QSJODJQBMFT HSFNJPT EPDFOUFT EF BMDBODF OBDJPOBM $5&3" 4"%01".&5Z6%"BQPZBSPOMBJOJDJBUJWBFJODMVTPTPTUJFOFORVF UBMQSPDFTPGVFFOQBSUFSFTVMUBEPEFTVTMVDIBTZSFJWJOEJDBDJPOFT -PWFODPNPMBDPOUJOVJEBEEFMQSPDFTPJOJDJBEPDPOMBTBODJwOEFMB MFZEF'JOBODJBNJFOUP&EVDBUJWP"MHVOPTNPWJNJFOUPTTPDJBMFTBTr DPNPTFDUPSFTFNQSFTBSJBMFTZBVUPSJEBEFTVOJWFSTJUBSJBTUBNCJnO BQPZBSPOMBJOJDJBUJWB -BT DSrUJDBT FO WPDFT EF EPDFOUFT F JOWFTUJHBEPSFT EFM gNCJUP VOJWFSTJUBSJPPSHBOJ[BDJPOFTFTUVEJBOUJMFTZNPWJNJFOUPTTPDJBMFT TFDPODFOUSBSPOFOEJWFSTPTUFNBT1PSVOMBEPTFQMBOUFwRVFMB FODVFTUB DPOUVWP rUFN NVZ HFOFSBMFT F JOEVKP B SFTQVFTUBT PC WJBT1PSPUSPRVFFMEPDVNFOUPFMBCPSBEPQBSBFMEFCBUFUVWPVO DPOUFOJEPEFDBSgDUFSNVZHFOFSBMZOPFTQFDJ¾DwDVgMFTTFSrBOMPT "OB1BHBOP*OHSJE4WFSEMJDLZ1BVMB$PTUBT NFDBOJTNPT QBSB JNQMFNFOUBS MBT MrOFBT QPMrUJDBT WBMF EFDJS RVF DBSFDrBEFQSPQVFTUBTDPODSFUBTBDFSDBEFBRVFMMBTQPMrUJDBTOFDF TBSJBTQBSBDVNQMJSDPOFMEFSFDIPBMBFEVDBDJwO0USBEFMBTDSrUJDBT TFDFOUSwFOMBTGPSNBTZMPTUJFNQPTFTUBCMFDJEPTQBSBFMEFCBUF "RVrMPTQSJODJQBMFTBSHVNFOUPTBEVKFSPORVFMPTFTDBTPTUJFNQPT OPQFSNJUJFSPOVOEFCBUFWFSEBEFSBNFOUFEFNPDSgUJDPFOFMRVFMPT EJWFSTPTTFDUPSFTEFMBTPDJFEBEDJWJMQVEJFSBOFYQPOFSFJOUFSDBN CJBSBDFSDBEFMPTDPOUFOJEPTEFMBMFZ&ODVBOUPBMBTGPSNBTTF QMBOUFw RVF OP TF EJTUSJCVZFSPO MBT IFSSBNJFOUBT OFDFTBSJBT QBSB RVF MPT TFDUPSFT TPDJBMFT WJODVMBEPT B MB FEVDBDJwO Z MB TPDJFEBE FOTVDPOKVOUPQVEJFSBOIBDFSVOQSPDFTPEFEFCBUFBVUnOUJDP&O SFTVNFORVFOPIVCPFMFNFOUPTTPDJBMJ[BEPTQBSBVOEJBHOwTUJDP RVFTJSWJFSBEFJOTVNPFOFTUFTFOUJEP " NFEJBEPT EF TFQUJFNCSF FM 1PEFS &KFDVUJWP QSFTFOUw FM BOUF QSPZFDUPEF-FZEF&EVDBDJwO/BDJPOBMQBSBRVFTFBUSBUBEPQPSFM $POHSFTP/BDJPOBM&OUSFMPTQVOUPTNgTJNQPSUBOUFTTFEFTUBDBMB JOUFODJwOEFBWBO[BSTPCSFVONPEFMPFEVDBUJWPVOJ¾DBEPWPMWJFO EPBMBFTUSVDUVSBEFQSJNBSJBZTFDVOEBSJB ZFYUFOEFSMBPCMJHBUP SJFEBEBBvPT -BJOTUBODJBQBSMBNFOUBSJBBDBCBEFDVMNJOBSDPOMBSFDJFOUFBQSP CBDJwOEFMBMFZFOMB$gNBSBEF%JQVUBEPTMVFHPEFRVFTFBQSPCB SBFOMBEF4FOBEPSFTVOBTFNBOBBOUFT&OFMEFCBUFQBSMBNFOUBSJP TFEJTDVUJFSPOBMHVOPTEFMPTQVOUPTEFMBMFZQFSPFOUnSNJOPTHF OFSBMFTQVFEFEFDJSTFRVFTFBQSPCwMBFTUSVDUVSBQSFTFOUBEBQPSFM 1PEFS&KFDVUJWPFOFMNFTEFTFQUJFNCSF-B-FZFOUSBSgFOWJHFODJB FOFMBvP .07*.*&/504:$".1"d"4103'6&3"%&-"4&4536$563"4 %&1"35*$*1"$*Î/13016&45"4103&-(0#*&3/0 $PNPZBBEFMBOUBNPTMPTDBNCJPTJOTUJUVDJPOBMFTEFDJTJWPTRVF TJHOBSPO B OVFTUSP QBrT EVSBOUF MPT |MUJNPT BvPT GVFSPO BDPNQB vBEPTQPSEJGFSFOUFTVSHFODJBTTPDJBMFTMBQPCSF[BFMEFTFNQMFP MBBMJNFOUBDJwOMBWJWJFOEB&OFTUFNBSDPTFJOTDSJCFOMPTHSBWFT QSPCMFNBTQPSMPTRVFBUSBWFTBCBFMTJTUFNBFEVDBUJWP%FBIrRVF HSBOQBSUFEFMPTNPWJNJFOUPTTPDJBMFTEFOVFTUSPQBrTTFBCPDBSBO 1BSUJDJQBDJwOFJODJEFODJBEFMBTPDJFEBEDJWJMFMDBTPBSHFOUJOP BEFNBOEBSZEFTBSSPMMBSQSPQVFTUBTQBSBDPOUFOFSZSFTPMWFSFTUBT TJUVBDJPOFTBHVEBTRVFBDBCBNPTEFNFODJPOBS 4FH|OMPTEBUPTSFMFWBEPTQPSFM0CTFSWBUPSJP-BUJOPBNFSJDBOP EF1PMrUJDBT&EVDBUJWBT0-1&E TPCSFMB$PO¿JDUJWJEBE%PDFOUFFO "NnSJDB-BUJOBFOUSFMPTBvPTZTFPCTFSWBVODSFDJ NJFOUPEFMBDPO¿JDUJWJEBEEFMTFDUPSDPO¿JDUPTFOFO ZFO &TUPTTFEFTBSSPMMBOQSJODJQBMNFOUFFOGPSNBT EFIVFMHBTBDUPTZNPWJMJ[BDJPOFT°FOFTFPSEFO°ZFOTVNBZPSrB TPO MMFWBEPT B DBCP QPS EPDFOUFT EFM OJWFM CgTJDP &TUPT SFHJTUSPT NVFTUSBORVFMBTQSJODJQBMFTEFNBOEBTTFWJODVMBOBSFDMBNPTMB CPSBMFTEFSFDPNQPTJDJwOTBMBSJBMFTQFDr¾DBNFOUF-PDVBMSFTVMUB MwHJDPFOFMNBSDPEFMBDSJTJTEFZMBQPTUFSJPSEFWBMVBDJwOFJO ¿BDJwOFOFMBvP"VORVFFONFOPSHSBEPTFSFHJTUSBOBMHVOPT DBTPTFOMPTRVFMBTIVFMHBTZNPWJMJ[BDJPOFTDPOUJFOFOEFNBOEBT NgT HMPCBMFT WJODVMBEBT B SFJWJOEJDBDJPOFT EF QPMrUJDB FEVDBUJWB QSFTVQVFTUPT EFTDFOUSBMJ[BDJwO EFM TJTUFNB TJTUFNBT EF FWBMVB DJwOEPDFOUFFUD PTJTUnNJDBQPMrUJDBEFNBOEBTBSUJDVMBEBTKVOUP B PUSBT PSHBOJ[BDJPOFT TJOEJDBMFT P TPDJBMFT RVF JNQVHOBO MJOFB NJFOUPTHFOFSBMFTEFMBTQPMrUJDBTHVCFSOBNFOUBMFT -BNBZPSrBEFMPTDPO¿JDUPTTFEJFSPOFOKVSJTEJDDJPOFTQSPWJODJB MFTZFODPOUSBEFMPTHPCJFSOPTMPDBMFT²-BSFMBDJwOSFMBUJWBNFOUF CVFOBEFMHPCJFSOPDPOMB$5&3"ZMBCBMDBOJ[BDJwOEFMBDPO¿JDUJWJ EBEEPDFOUFWrBMBEFTDFOUSBMJ[BDJwOIJDJFSPOEFMCJFOJP FMQSJNFSPFONVDIPUJFNQPTJOIVFMHBTEPDFOUFTOBDJPOBMFT³&O MB$5&3"MMFWwBDBCPVOQBSPOBDJPOBMRVFFOFMSFDMBNPEFMB TBODJwOEFVOB-FZEF'JOBODJBNJFOUP&EVDBUJWPDPOUFNQMwMPTSF DMBNPTMBCPSBMFTQSPWJODJBMFTBMBWF[RVFOPEFKwQPSFMMPEFNBO UFOFSFMDBOBMEFEJgMPHPDPOFMHPCJFSOPRVFMMFWBSBBMBBQSPCBDJwO EFMQSPZFDUPEFMFZFOMBTFHVOEBNJUBEEFEJDIPBvP "TrFOVODPOUFYUPDPNQMFKPZDSrUJDPQPEFNPTJEFOUJ¾DBSBMHV OBTJOJDJBUJWBTMMFWBEBTBDBCPQPSEJGFSFOUFTBDUPSFTEFMBTPDJFEBE 1SPHSBNB EJTDJQMJOBS EF JOWFTUJHBDJwO BOgMJTJT GPSNBDJwO EJGVTJwO Z EPDVNFOUB DJwOTPCSFMBTQPMrUJDBTFEVDBUJWBTFO"NnSJDB-BUJOBDPHFTUJPOBEPQPSFM-11#VFOPT"JSFTZ FM-116&3+XXXPMQFEOFUDPO¿JDUPT 0MQFE "OB1BHBOP*OHSJE4WFSEMJDLZ1BVMB$PTUBT DJWJMWJODVMBEPTBMgNCJUPFEVDBUJWPZQPSGVFSBEFMBTFTUSVDUVSBTEF QBSUJDJQBDJwOQSPQVFTUBTQPSFMHPCJFSOP $POGFEFSBDJwOEFUSBCBKBEPSFTEFMB&EVDBDJwO EFMB3FQ|CMJDB"SHFOUJOB$5&3" -B$5&3"OBDFFOZDPOHSFHBBTJOEJDBUPTEPDFOUFTEFUPEBT MBTKVSJTEJDDJPOFTEFMQBrT4FJODPSQPSBBMB$FOUSBMEF5SBCBKBEPSFT "SHFOUJOPT$5" DVBOEPFTUBTFGVOEBFODPNP$POHSFTPEF MPT5SBCBKBEPSFT"SHFOUJOPTMVFHPTFDPOWFSUJSgFO$FOUSBMFOFMBvP &OUSF MPT IJUPT EF TVT MVDIBT TF FODVFOUSB MB SFBMJ[BDJwO FO EFMB.BSDIB#MBODBNBSDIBEFEPDFOUFTBMB$BQJUBMEFTQVnT EFErBTEFIVFMHB ZMBJOTUBMBDJwOEFMB$BSQB#MBODBEFMBZVOP EPDFOUFGSFOUFBM$POHSFTP/BDJPOBMFOBCSJMEF -B $BSQB #MBODB GVF MFWBOUBEB FO EJDJFNCSF EF EFTQVnT EFErBTEFBZVOPMVFHPEFIBCFSDPOTFHVJEPMBDPOGPSNBDJwO EFVOGPOEPEPDFOUFRVFJNQMJDBCBVOBVNFOUPTBMBSJBMEFQPS NFT4JOFNCBSHPBQFTBSEFFTFUSJVOGPMPTTVDFTJWPTHPCJFSOPT QPTUFSJPSFTBMEF$BSMPT.FOFNOPNFKPSBSPOMBTJUVBDJwOFEVDBUJWB "Tr²<©>MBTJUVBDJwOFTUSJDUBNFOUFFEVDBUJWBGVFDBEBWF[NgTDSr UJDBFOFMQFSrPEP/PTwMPMBSFGPSNBFEVDBUJWBMB²5SBOTGPSNBDJwO &EVDBUJWB³ ZBNPTUSBCBTFvBMFTDMBSBTEFBHPUBNJFOUP¾OBODJFSPZ DPNFO[BCBBFWJEFODJBSFMJODVNQMJNJFOUPEFTVTNFUBTZPCKFUJWPT TJOPRVFFMDPOKVOUPEFMBTDPOEJDJPOFTNrOJNBTRVFHBSBOUJ[BOMB SFQSPEVDDJwONJTNBEFMBFTDPMBSJEBEFTUBCBOFOQFMJHSP-BNVMUJ QMJDBDJwOZQSPGVOEJ[BDJwOEFMPTDPO¿JDUPTEPDFOUFTFODBTJUPEBT MBTQSPWJODJBTEFMQBrTIBDJBQSJODJQJPTEFQPOrBFOSJFTHPFM DPNJFO[PEFMDJDMPMFDUJWPFONVDIBTKVSJTEJDDJPOFTFEVDBUJWBTEFM QBrTZMBDBOUJEBEEFErBTEFDMBTFQFSEJEPTQPSIVFMHBTEPDFOUFT IBDrBQPOFSFOEVEBTMBDPOUJOVJEBEEFMBFTDPMBSJ[BDJwOFOVOHSVQP TJHOJ¾DBUJWPEFQSPWJODJBT-BTTJUVBDJPOFTEFDFTBDJwOEFQBHPTB MPTEPDFOUFTFOMBTQSPWJODJBTEF3rP/FHSP&OUSF3rPT4BO+VBOZ 5VDVNgO EVSBOUF MPT BvPT Z GVFSPO QBSBEJHNgUJDBT FO FTFTFOUJEP<©>³4VgSF[ 3FTVMUBFWJEFOUFRVFTFUSBUwEFVOQFSrPEPNVZDSrUJDPFOMBDP NVOJEBEFEVDBUJWBFOVODPOUFYUPNBSDBEPQPSDPOTUBOUFTNPWJMJ 1BSUJDJQBDJwOFJODJEFODJBEFMBTPDJFEBEDJWJMFMDBTPBSHFOUJOP [BDJPOFTTPDJBMFTQSPUBHPOJ[BEBTQPSEJGFSFOUFTBDUPSFTEFUPEPFM QBrT²%FFTUBGPSNBFOUSFFMZFMBEFNgTEFNVMUJQMJ DBSTFMBTIVFMHBTZMBTNPWJMJ[BDJPOFTEPDFOUFTFOUPEPFMQBrTZEF WFSTF BNFOB[BEP FM DPNJFO[P Z MB DPOUJOVJEBE EFM DJDMP MFDUJWP FO NVDIBTQSPWJODJBTFOWBSJBTPDBTJPOFT » TFJOTUBMBSPODBSQBTCMBODBTZDBNQBNFOUPTFOBMHVOBTQMB[BT DnOUSJDBTEFMBTDBQJUBMFTEFQSPWJODJBDPNPFOMBTEF$PSSJFOUFT +VKVZ4BOUB$SV[5VDVNgO#VFOPT"JSFTFOUSFPUSBT » TFSFBMJ[BSPODBSBWBOBTFEVDBUJWBTRVFSFDPSSrBOMPDBMJEBEFTEFM JOUFSJPSEFMBTQSPWJODJBTDPOFM¾OEFEJGVOEJSMPTSFDMBNPTZTV NBSBEIFTJPOFTQPSFKFNQMPFOMBQSPWJODJBEF#VFOPT"JSFT » TF MMFWBSPO BEFMBOUF QJRVFUFT Z DPSUFT EF SVUB KVOUP DPO PUSPT USBCBKBEPSFTZHSVQPTEFEFTPDVQBEPTFOFTQFDJBMFO/FVRVnO QFSPUBNCJnOFO+VKVZ$PSSJFOUFT3rP/FHSP » TF EFTBSSPMMBSPO KPSOBEBT EF SF¿FYJwO EPDFOUF DPNP VOB NP EBMJEBEEFMVDIBTJOEJDBMRVFTFFOUSPODBCBDPOVOBWJFKBSFJWJO EJDBDJwO EFM TFDUPS EPDFOUF TJO TVTQFOTJwO EF DMBTFT Z DPO MB QSFTFODJBEFBMVNOPTZQBESFTZFOMBTRVFTFEFCBUrBOUFNBT FTUSJDUBNFOUFWJODVMBEPTDPOMBNFEJEBEFGVFS[BQFSPUBNCJnO BTQFDUPTQPMrUJDPTSFMBDJPOBEPTDPOMBDSJTJTHFOFSBMEFMBFEVDB DJwOFOFMQBrT#VFOPT"JSFT&OUSF3rPT » TFMMFWBSPOBEFMBOUFDPOHSFTPTFEVDBUJWPTUBNCJnODPNPFTUSB UFHJBEFMVDIBHSFNJBMDPNPFM$POHSFTPEFM'SFOUF(SFNJBMEF %PDFOUFT#POBFSFOTFTEFFOFMRVFNJMJUBOUFTEFMB'&#Z FM465&#"QFSPUBNCJnOEPDFOUFTOPTJOEJDBMJ[BEPTEFCBUJFSPO TPCSFMPTSFTVMUBEPTEFMBTKPSOBEBTEFSF¿FYJwOSFBMJ[BEBTDPO BOUFSJPSJEBE³4VgSF[ "QBSUJSEFMBvPTFJOTUBMBMFOUBNFOUFVOFTDFOBSJPEFNBZPS FTUBCJMJEBEJOTUJUVDJPOBMZBMBWF[FMSFQVOUFEFBMHVOPTJOEJDBEP SFTTPDJBMFTZFDPOwNJDPTHFOFSBDPOEJDJPOFTQBSBQSPNPWFSOVF %FIFDIPFONVDIBTQSPWJODJBTEFMQBrTTFWJPBNFOB[BEPFMNJTNPBvPMFDUJWP QPSMBDBOUJEBEEFErBTEFDMBTFQFSEJEPTQPSIVFMHBTEPDFOUFTFOSFDMBNPEFTBMBSJPTFJO DFOUJWPT BEFVEBEPT -PT DBTPT EF 4BO +VBO &OUSF 3rPT Z 3rP /FHSP TPO QBSBEJHNgUJDPT FO FTFTFOUJEP "OB1BHBOP*OHSJE4WFSEMJDLZ1BVMB$PTUBT WPTPCKFUJWPTFOMBTMVDIBTTPDJBMFT&TFOFTUFNBSDPRVFMB$5&3" WJFOFSFDMBNBOEPQPSVOBOVFWB-FZ/BDJPOBMEF&EVDBDJwORVFSF FNQMBDFBMB-FZ'FEFSBMEF&EVDBDJwOTBODJPOBEBFO%VSBOUF FMBvPTFSFBMJ[BSPO$POHSFTPT&EVDBUJWPT1SPWJODJBMFTEPOEF MBTFOUJEBEFTEFCBTFEF$5&3"FMBCPSBSPOQSPQVFTUBTFOFTUFTFO UJEP -BT NJTNBT GVFSPO EJTDVUJEBT FO FM FS $POHSFTP &EVDBUJWP EFEPOEFEFSJWBSPOVOBTFSJFEFQSPQVFTUBTQBSBMBFMBCPSBDJwOEF QPMrUJDBTRVFHBSBOUJDFOFMEFSFDIPTPDJBMBMBFEVDBDJwO&OUSFFMMBT TFJODMVZFMBTBODJwOEFVOBOVFWB-FZ/BDJPOBMEF&EVDBDJwOVOB MB-FZEF'JOBODJBNJFOUPRVFHBSBOUJDFMPTSFDVSTPTOFDFTBSJPTQBSB FMDVNQMJNJFOUPEFMEFSFDIPTPDJBMBMBFEVDBDJwOMBSFEF¾OJDJwOEF MBGPSNBDJwOEPDFOUFDPOMBTBODJwOEFVOBOVFWB-FZEF&EVDBDJwO 4VQFSJPSMBEFNPDSBUJ[BDJwOEFMHPCJFSOPEFMBFEVDBDJwOMBSFEJT DVTJwOEFMSnHJNFOMBCPSBMEPDFOUFFOQPTEFMDVNQMJNJFOUPEFMPT EFSFDIPTEFMPTUSBCBKBEPSFTEFMBFEVDBDJwO $BNQBvB"SHFOUJOBQPSFM%FSFDIPBMB&EVDBDJwO -B$BNQBvB"SHFOUJOBQPSFM%FSFDIPBMB&EVDBDJwOTFFONBS DBFOVOBQSPQVFTUBEFOJWFMNVOEJBMRVFQSPNVFWFBMBFEVDBDJwO DPNPVOEFSFDIPIVNBOPCgTJDP"TrQSPDVSBNPWJMJ[BSMBQSFTJwO Q|CMJDB TPCSF MPT HPCJFSOPT QBSB RVF FTUPT DVNQMBO TVT DPNQSP NJTPTEFQSPWFFSFEVDBDJwOCgTJDBMJCSFPCMJHBUPSJBZQ|CMJDBQBSB UPEPTFOQBSUJDVMBSBOJvPTNVKFSFTZTFDUPSFTQSJWBEPTZFOEFT WFOUBKBEFMBTPDJFEBE $BEBBvPMBDBNQBvBJNQVMTBFOFMNFTEFBCSJMMB²TFNBOBEF BDDJwOHMPCBMQPSMBFEVDBDJwO³%FFTUFNPEPCVTDBNPWJMJ[BSBUP EPTMPTTFDUPSFTEFMBTPDJFEBEBMSFEFEPSEFBMH|OUFNBQBSUJDVMBS WJODVMBEPBMEFSFDIPBMBFEVDBDJwOQBSBUPEPT &OMB"SHFOUJOBMBDBNQBvBFTMMFWBEBBDBCPQPSVODPOKVOUPEF PSHBOJ[BDJPOFT EF MB TPDJFEBE DJWJM °0/( EF USBCBKP TPDJPDPNVOJ UBSJPDBQBDJUBDJwOJOWFTUJHBDJwOTJOEJDBUPTFUD °RVFDPOTJEFSBO 4F USBUB EF $*11&$ 'F Z "MFHSrB 'VOEBDJwO 4&4 '-"$40 'VOEBDJwO FTDPMBSFT -BCPSBUPSJP EF 1PMrUJDBT &EVDBUJWBT 4BWF EF $IJMESFO $5&3" $5" MBT PSHBOJ[BDJPOFT RVF FOUSFPUSBTGPSNBOQBSUFEFFTUBDBNQBvB 1BSUJDJQBDJwOFJODJEFODJBEFMBTPDJFEBEDJWJMFMDBTPBSHFOUJOP GVOEBNFOUBMMBQPTJCJMJEBEEFEFTBSSPMMBSFTUSBUFHJBTSFHJPOBMFTRVF JODJEBOQPTJUJWBNFOUFFOMBTQPMrUJDBTQ|CMJDBT &OFMDPNQSPNJTPQFSNBOFOUFQPSNFKPSBSMPTOJWFMFTEFFRVJEBE Z DBMJEBE EF MPT TJTUFNBT FEVDBUJWPT MB $BNQBvB MMBNB B SFBMJ[BS EFCBUFT QBSB MB TBODJwO EF VOB OVFWB -FZ OBDJPOBM EF &EVDBDJwO FSSBEJDBSFMIBNCSFEFUPEBMBQPCMBDJwOBMDBO[BSMPTUSFDFBvPTEF FEVDBDJwOQBSBUPEPTMPTOJvPTOJvBTZKwWFOFTFGFDUJWJ[BSFMDVN QMJNJFOUP EF MB -FZ EF 'JOBODJBNJFOUP &EVDBUJWP USBTQBSFOUBS MB BTJHOBDJwOQSFTVQVFTUBSJBOBDJPOBMZQSPWJODJBMHBSBOUJ[BSMBNFKP SBEFMBTDPOEJDJPOFTMBCPSBMFTEPDFOUFTFSSBEJDBSFMBOBMGBCFUJTNP ZFMUSBCBKPJOGBOUJMQPTJCJMJUBSMBQBSUJDJQBDJwOFGFDUJWBEFMPTEJTUJO UPTBDUPSFTTPDJBMFTDPNQSPNFUJEPTDPOMBFEVDBDJwOFJNQVMTBSMBT BDDJPOFTOFDFTBSJBTQBSBRVFMBTQPMrUJDBTFEVDBUJWBTBUJFOEBOBMPT TFDUPSFTIJTUwSJDBNFOUFQPTUFSHBEPT &OFTUFNBSDPEVSBOUFMBTFNBOBEFMBMEFBCSJMEF TFMMFWBSPOBDBCPEJWFSTBTBDUJWJEBEFTFOEJGFSFOUFTQVOUPTEFMQBrT TF QSPEVKFSPO NBUFSJBMFT JOGPSNBUJWPT TPCSF MB DBNQBvB B¾DIFT USrQUJDPTTFvBMBEPUFTFUD RVFGVFSPOEJGVOEJEPTFOUSFMBTPSHBOJ [BDJPOFTZHSFNJPTRVFBQPZBOZQBSUJDJQBOEFFTUBBDDJwO"TVWF[ FTUPTEJGVOEJFSPOFMNBUFSJBMFOBRVFMMPTFTUBCMFDJNJFOUPTFEVDBUJ WPTFOMPTRVFTFMMFWBSPOBDBCPBMHVOBTPUSBTBDUJWJEBEFTSBEJPT BCJFSUBTUBMMFSFTQBSBMBDPNVOJEBETPCSFFMEFSFDIPBMBFEVDBDJwO UBMMFSFTEFDBQBDJUBDJwOEPDFOUFWJODVMBEPTBMUFNBUBMMFSFTEFEJCV KPZQJOUBEBEFNVSBMFTSFMFWBNJFOUPTPCSF²FYDMVTJwOFEVDBUJWB³ FOWBSJBTQSPWJODJBTMMFWBEPBDBCPQPSEPDFOUFTZBMVNOPT°EBUPT RVFGVFSPOJODMVJEPTFOMPTB¾DIFTRVFTFEJFSPOBDPOPDFS°FUD 1PS PUSB QBSUF TF SFBMJ[w VO BDUPIPNFOBKF BM .BFTUSP *TBVSP "SBODJCJB EJSJHFOUF EF $5&3" Z EFNgT EPDFOUFT EFTBQBSFDJEPT Z BTFTJOBEPTQPSMB|MUJNBEJDUBEVSBNJMJUBS4FSFBMJ[wFMEFBCSJMFO VOBTBMBFTQFDJBMEFMB'FSJB*OUFSOBDJPOBMEFM-JCSPEF#VFOPT"JSFT "EFNgT MB $BNQBvB BSHFOUJOB QPS FM EFSFDIP B MB FEVDBDJwO QBSUJDJQwEFMBSPOEBEFDPOTVMUBTRVFMMFWwBDBCPFMHPCJFSOPDPO $5&3"FOTJUJPXFCIUUQXXXDUFSBPSHBSDBNQBvB "OB1BHBOP*OHSJE4WFSEMJDLZ1BVMB$PTUBT NPUJWPEFMBFMBCPSBDJwOEFMQSPZFDUPEFMBOVFWB-FZEF&EVDBDJwO /BDJPOBMZFMBCPSwVOEPDVNFOUPRVFTFQSFTFOUwBMBTBVUPSJEBEFT ZTFEJGVOEJwBOUFMBPQJOJwOQ|CMJDB .PWJNJFOUPQPSVOB&EVDBDJwO1|CMJDB1PQVMBS $PO NPUJWP EF MB BQFSUVSB BM EFCBUF TPCSF VOB OVFWB -FZ EF &EVDBDJwO /BDJPOBM TF HFOFSBSPO NgT FTQBDJPT EF EJTDVTJwO BM UFSOBUJWPT B MPT QSPQVFTUPT QPS FM HPCJFSOP &O FTUF NBSDP WBSJBT PSHBOJ[BDJPOFTTPDJBMFTZNPWJNJFOUPTQPMrUJDPTFOTJOUPOrBDPOMB JOJDJBUJWBEFMHPCJFSOPQSPNVFWFOQSPDFTPTEFEJTDVTJwOZQBSUJDJ QBDJwOBMUFSOBUJWPT°KPSOBEBTUBMMFSFTFUD°BMBWF[RVFSFTBMUBOEP MBJNQPSUBODJBEFMBQBSUJDJQBDJwOEFMPTTFDUPSFTQPQVMBSFTJNQVM TBO MB DPOGPSNBDJwO EF VO .PWJNJFOUP QPS VOB &EVDBDJwO 1|CMJDB 1PQVMBS"MHVOPTEFFMMPTTPO.PWJNJFOUP#BSSJPTEF1JFEJWFSTPT SFQSFTFOUBOUFT EF "5& 65& $5&3" 465&#" .PWJNJFOUP -JCSFT EFM 4VS "HSVQBDJwO .BSUrO 'JFSSP 'SFOUF #BSSJBM EF EJDJFNCSF FOUSF PUSPT -PT QSJODJQBMFT UFNBT FO MPT RVF TF QSPQPOFO DFOUSBS MB EJTDVTJwO TPO MB EFSPHBDJwO EF MB -FZ 'FEFSBM EF &EVDBDJwO MB VOJ¾DBDJwOEFMTJTUFNBFEVDBUJWPOBDJPOBMUBOUPFOMPSFGFSJEPBMB GPSNBDJwOEPDFOUFDPNPBMPTDPOUFOJEPTEFFOTFvBO[BJHVBMEBEFO MBTDPOEJDJPOFTEFBDDFTPZQFSNBOFODJBEFUPEPTMPTOJvPTOJvBT BEPMFTDFOUFTKwWFOFTZBEVMUPTFYUFOTJwOEFMPTBvPTEFPCMJHBUP SJFEBEBMPTOJWFMFTJOJDJBMQSJNBSJPZTFDVOEBSJPFOUPEPFMUFSSJUPSJP OBDJPOBMBSUJDVMBDJwOEFMBFEVDBDJwOPCMJHBUPSJBDPOMBVOJWFSTJEBE FOUSFPUSBTDPTBT 4FUSBUBEFVOBJOJDJBUJWBRVFDPOWPDBBMBEJTDVTJwOZFMEFCBUF QPSFMDVNQMJNJFOUPEFMEFSFDIPBMBFEVDBDJwOQBSBUPEPT &MEPDVNFOUPEFMB$BNQBvBQVFEFDPOTVMUBSTFFOMBTQgHJOBTXFCEFMBTJOTUJUV DJPOFTRVFMBDPOGPSNBO 1BSUJDJQBDJwOFJODJEFODJBEFMBTPDJFEBEDJWJMFMDBTPBSHFOUJOP 1SPQVFTUBTQBSBMB&EVDBDJwO4VQFSJPS %VSBOUF FM QSJNFS HPCJFSOP NFOFNJTUB MB DSFBDJwO EFMB4FDSFUBSrBEF1PMrUJDBT6OJWFSTJUBSJBTFOFMNBSDPEFM.JOJTUFSJP EF &EVDBDJwO TF JOJDJw ¾KBOEP QPMrUJDBT SFMBDJPOBEBT DPO MB NPEJ¾DBDJwOEFSFHJNFOFTMBCPSBMFTDSFBDJwOEFHSBODBOUJEBEEF VOJWFSTJEBEFTQSJWBEBTFUDnUFSB &OFMBvPMVFHPEFMBTMFZFTEF5SBOTGFSFODJBZ-FZ'FEFSBM EF&EVDBDJwOTFTBODJPOBMB-FZEF&EVDBDJwO4VQFSJPS-&4 EPOEF TFNFODJPOBRVFMFDPSSFTQPOEFBM&TUBEPMBSFTQPOTBCJMJEBEJOEFMF HBCMFFOMBQSFTUBDJwOEFMTFSWJDJPEFFEVDBDJwOTVQFSJPSEFDBSgDUFS Q|CMJDP 1FSP BM NJTNP UJFNQP TV MFUSB EB MVHBS B BNCJHFEBEFT WJODVMBEBTBMBSBODFMBNJFOUPZQPSMPUBOUPMJNJUBDJPOFTFOFMJOHSF TPQPTHSBEPTQBHPTZQBTBOUrBTDPOHSBOEFTFNQSFTBT %FTEFFOUPODFTMPTBTQFDUPTQSFTVQVFTUBSJPTZQPMrUJDPJOTUJUV DJPOBMFTTFSgONPUJWPEFMVDIBQPSQBSUFEFMBTPSHBOJ[BDJPOFTWJO DVMBEBTBMBFEVDBDJwOTVQFSJPSZBMBVOJWFSTJUBSJBFOQBSUJDVMBS %VSBOUFMPTBvPTZMBTQPMrUJDBTEFBKVTUFGPDBMJ[BSPOMB SFEVDDJwO QSFTVQVFTUBSJBEFFEVDBDJwOFOMBSFCBKBEFMPTTBMBSJPT &OFMBvPTFJOUFOUwIBDFSVOSFDPSUFEFMFOMBFEVDBDJwOZ FMJNJOBSFM'POEPEF*ODFOUJWP%PDFOUF'0/*% MPRVFQSPNPWJwQB SPTZNPWJMJ[BDJPOFTEFUPEPTMPTEPDFOUFTJODMVJEPTMPTEFFEVDBDJwO TVQFSJPS²&OFMgNCJUPVOJWFSTJUBSJPGVFSPOUPNBEBTMBTQSJODJQBMFT VOJWFSTJEBEFTEFMQBrTZFONVDIBTEFFMMBTTFEJDUBSPODMBTFTQ|CMJ DBTSFDIB[BOEPMBSFEVDDJwOEFMQSFTVQVFTUP³Giarraca, 2001) %VSBOUFFMBvPTFFGFDUVwVOSFDPSUFTBMBSJBMEFMBFN QMFBEPTFTUBUBMFTZKVCJMBEPTZTFQSPEVKFSPOSFUSBTPTFOFMQBHPEFM '0/*%&TUPQSPEVKPOVFWBNFOUFQBSPTBDUJWPTUPNBEFGBDVMUBEFT ZDMBTFTQ|CMJDBT &OFTUFNBSDPEVSBOUFFMBvPTFTVDFEJFSPOWBSJBTNPWJMJ[B DJPOFTZBDDJPOFTEFQSPUFTUB-PTNPUJWPTQSJODJQBMFTTFDFOUSBCBO FOFMBVNFOUPTBMBSJBMEPDFOUFCMBORVFPEFBEJDJPOBMFTFOOFHSPZ SFOUBQBSBMPTEPDFOUFTBEIPOPSFTFOUSFPUSBTDPTBT ZNBZPSQSF TVQVFTUPQBSBFMTFDUPSFEVDBUJWPVOJWFSTJUBSJP"FTUPTFTVNBSgO MPTSFDMBNPTQPSMBEFSPHBDJwOEFMB-&4BTrDPNPUBNCJnOMBEFMB -FZ'FEFSBMEF&EVDBDJwO "OB1BHBOP*OHSJE4WFSEMJDLZ1BVMB$PTUBT %VSBOUFMPTNFTFTEFBHPTUPTFQUJFNCSFZPDUVCSFEFTF EFTBSSPMMwVOJNQPSUBOUFDPO¿JDUPFOFMgNCJUPVOJWFSTJUBSJP4FMMF WBSPOBDBCPVOBTFSJFEFNFEJEBTEFGVFS[BJNQVMTBEBTQPSMBTEPT DFOUSBMFTEPDFOUFTNgTOVNFSPTBTEFMQBrTMB$0/"%6IJTUwSJDBZ MB$0/"%6&TUBTNFEJEBTTFDPODSFUBSPOFOKPSOBEBTEFQBSPZ NPWJMJ[BDJwOZDPOUBSPODPOVOGVFSUFBQPZPEFPSHBOJ[BDJPOFTFTUV EJBOUJMFT&MDPO¿JDUPTFNBOJGFTUwFOVOJWFSTJEBEFTQ|CMJDBTEFM QBrT5PSPODIJL 0USBEFMBTBDDJPOFTMMFWBEBTBDBCPEVSBOUFFTFQFSrPEPGVFFM ²***&ODVFOUSP/BDJPOBMDPOUSBMB-&4³FOEPOEFQBSUJDJQBSPOEJWFS TBTPSHBOJ[BDJPOFTEFMNPWJNJFOUPFTUVEJBOUJMFOUSFMBTRVFTFFO DPOUSBCBO MB '6#" MB '6-1 -B 1MBUB MB '61 1BUBHPOJB MB '6$ $PNBIVF Z HSBO DBOUJEBE EF DFOUSPT EF FTUVEJBOUFT EF UPEP FM QBrT&OFTUFNBSDPUBNCJnOTFMMFWBSPOBDBCPNBSDIBTZUPNBT EFMBTVOJWFSTJEBEFT -B NFTB EF OFHPDJBDJPOFT FO MB RVF QBSUJDJQBSPO FM TFDSFUBSJP EF QPMrUJDBT VOJWFSTJUBSJBT MPT SFDUPSFT EF MBT VOJWFSTJEBEFT Z MPT HSFNJPT EPDFOUFT OP DPOEVKP B TPMVDJPOFT TBUJTGBDUPSJBT QPS VO UJFNQP 'JOBMNFOUF MPT HSFNJPT EPDFOUFT OFHPDJBSPO VO BVNFOUP TBMBSJBMEFMRVFQBSFDFOPIBCFSUFOJEPFMBDVFSEPEFMBTCBTFT 1POT %VSBOUFFMBvPKVOUPBMPTSFDMBNPTQFSNBOFOUFTQPSNF KPSBTTBMBSJBMFTZBVNFOUPEFMQSFTVQVFTUPFEVDBUJWPTFTVNBPUSP NPUJWPEFDPO¿JDUP&OFMUSBOTDVSTPEFMBQSJNFSBNJUBEEFBvPFO FMTFOPEFMgNCJUPVOJWFSTJUBSJPEFMB$JVEBEEF#VFOPT"JSFTTFQSP EVKFSPO VOB TFSJF DPOGSPOUBDJPOFT DPO NPUJWP EF MB SFOPWBDJwO EF BVUPSJEBEFT EF MB 6OJWFSTJEBE EF #VFOPT "JSFT &M SFDMBNP DFOUSBM EFMBTPSHBOJ[BDJPOFTFTUVEJBOUJMFTFTUgWJODVMBEPBMBSFGPSNBEFM FTUBUVUPEPDFOUFZBMBEFNPDSBUJ[BDJwOEFMPTwSHBOPTEFHPCJFSOP UFNBTRVFDPONPUJWPEFMBDPOWPDBUPSJBBFMFDDJPOFTSFUPNwQSPUB HPOJTNP1PSPUSBQBSUFTFBHSFHwBMSFDMBNPFTUVEJBOUJMMBPQPTJ 'FEFSBDJwOEF%PDFOUFT*OWFTUJHBEPSFTZ$SFBEPSFT6OJWFSTJUBSJPT$0/"%6IJTUw SJDB Z'FEFSBDJwO/BDJPOBMEF%PDFOUFT6OJWFSTJUBSJPT$0/"%6 SFTQFDUJWBNFOUF 1SFOTBEFMMB6OJwOEF+VWFOUVEFTQPSFM4PDJBMJTNP1BSUJEP0CSFSP²***&ODVFOUSP /BDJPOBMDPOUSBMB-&4³FOXXXVKTPSHBSEFTFQUJFNCSFEF 1BSUJDJQBDJwOFJODJEFODJBEFMBTPDJFEBEDJWJMFMDBTPBSHFOUJOP DJwOBMBDBOEJEBUVSBEFVOPEFMPTEFDBOPTRVFGVFGVODJPOBSJPEFM HPCJFSOPEFMB$JVEBEEF#VFOPT"JSFTEVSBOUFMB|MUJNBEJDUBEVSB NJMJUBS .BOJGFTUBDJPOFTUPNBTZBTBNCMFBTGVFSPOBMHVOBTEFMBTBDDJP OFTMMFWBEBTBDBCPQPSMB'FEFSBDJwO6OJWFSTJUBSJBEF#VFOPT"JSFT '6#" &TUPTDPO¿JDUPTQSPEVKFSPOMBTVTQFOTJwOEFWBSJBTBTBN CMFBTVOJWFSTJUBSJBTMBSFOVODJBEFMBTQJSBOUFNFODJPOBEPBTVDBO EJEBUVSBZDBNCJPTFOMB4FDSFUBSrBEF1PMrUJDBT6OJWFSTJUBSJBT1PS BIPSB²MPTSFDMBNPTEFEFNPDSBUJ[BDJwOTPTUFOJEPTQPSMBJ[RVJFSEB FTUVEJBOUJMNBOUJFOFOBMBTJOTUJUVDJPOFTTJOSFDUPSFMFDUP³1gHJOB &OQBSBMFMPUBNCJnOEVSBOUFFTUFBvPTFWJFOFEFTBSSPMMBOEPVO DPO¿JDUPTJNJMBSFOMB6OJWFSTJEBEEF$PNBIVFEPOEFEFTEFFMNFT EFNBZPIBZWBSJBTVOJEBEFTBDBEnNJDBTUPNBEBT &OFMNBSDPEFFTUPTDPO¿JDUPTFMHPCJFSOPBQSVFCBVOBVNFOUP EFNJMMPOFTEFQFTPTQBSBFMTJTUFNBVOJWFSTJUBSJPNPOUPDPOTJ EFSBCMFNFOUFNFOPSBMRVFSFDMBNBCBOMPTSFDUPSFTNJMMPOFT 'JOBMNFOUFQVFEFEFDJSTFRVFFOFTUBTFHVOEBNJUBEEFBvPTF TVNBOBMPTSFDMBNPTZBIBCJUVBMFTBVNFOUPEFQSFTVQVFTUPZEF TBMBSJPT FM SFDIB[P B MB MFZ FEVDBUJWB RVF QSPNVFWF FM HPCJFSOP $POMBDPOTJHOB²1PSVOBFEVDBDJwOQ|CMJDBFTUBUBM|OJDBHSBUVJUB ZMBJDB³TFMMFWwBDBCPMB².BSDIB/BDJPOBM&EVDBUJWB³FOMBRVFTF NPWJMJ[BSPOHSFNJPTEPDFOUFTEFMOJWFM$0/"%6IJTUwSJDB ZGFEFSB DJPOFTFTUVEJBOUJMFTDPNP'6#"'6-1'6$'63FOVOBNBSDIBFM QBTBEPEFTFQUJFNCSF1gHJOB .PWJNJFOUPTZDBNQBvBTFOFMNBSDPEFEJGFSFOUFTMVDIBTTPDJBMFT &OFMNBSDPEFEJWFSTBTQSPUFTUBTTPDJBMFTFTOFDFTBSJPUFOFSFO DVFOUBRVFFYJTUFONPWJMJ[BDJPOFTDPMFDUJWBTDBNQBvBTNPWJNJFO UPTQPQVMBSFTRVFTJOJOTDSJCJSTFFOFMDBNQPFEVDBUJWPFOUSFMBT EJGFSFOUFTEFNBOEBTRVFQMBOUFBODPMPDBOUBNCJnOBMEFSFDIPBMB FEVDBDJwODPNPVOFMFNFOUPQSJWJMFHJBEPEFTVTMVDIBT4FUSBUBEF BDDJPOFTDPMFDUJWBTRVFJOTUBMBOFOFMDFOUSPEFTVTSFDMBNPTFMDVN QMJNJFOUPEFMPTEFSFDIPTDJWJMFTTPDJBMFTFDPOwNJDPTZDVMUVSBMFT RVFTFIBMMBOBNFOB[BEPT "OB1BHBOP*OHSJE4WFSEMJDLZ1BVMB$PTUBT "Tr QPS VO MBEP FM 'SFOBQP 'SFOUF /BDJPOBM DPOUSB MB 1PCSF[B ²QSPNPWJEPQPSMB$5"BDPNJFO[PTEFMBvPDPNCJOBCBMBEF OVODJBEFMBJOFRVJUBUJWBEJTUSJCVDJwOEFMJOHSFTPDPOVOBQSPQVFTUBEF ´TIPDLEJTUSJCVUJWPµRVFFYQMrDJUBNFOUFJOWFSUrBMBFOUPODFTDPOTJHOB EFMHPCJFSOPEFJNQVMTBSVO´TIPDLEFDPO¾BO[BµEJSJHJEPBMNFSDBEP ZBMPTPSHBOJTNPTEFDSnEJUPJOUFSOBDJPOBMFTBQBSUJSEFQPMrUJDBTEF BKVTUF¾TDBM"DPSEFDPOFTUPFMQMBOEFBDDJwODPNQSFOErBBSUJDVMBS MBQBSUJDJQBDJwOEF´EJGFSFOUFTBDUPSFTTPDJBMFTZQPMrUJDPTµZMBQVFTUB FONBSDIBEFVONPWJNJFOUPQBSBSFBMJ[BSVOBDPOTVMUBQPQVMBSRVF MFHJUJNBSBBUSBWnTEFFTFNFDBOJTNPEFEFNPDSBDJBEJSFDUBMBJN QMFNFOUBDJwOEFVOTFHVSPEFFNQMFPZGPSNBDJwOQBSBKFGFTZKFGBT EFGBNJMJBZVOBBTJHOBDJwOVOJWFSTBMQPSIJKP³(VSSFSB -B DPOTVMUB TF SFBMJ[w FO EJDJFNCSF EF Z MPHSw KVOUBS ¾SNBT ²%JDIB QSPQVFTUB TPTUFOrB VOB FTUSBUFHJB EF SFEJTUSJCVDJwO EF MPT JOHSFTPT TPCSF MB CBTF EF USFT JOTUSVNFOUPT VO4FHVSPEF&NQMFPZ'PSNBDJwOQBSBUPEPKFGFEFIPHBSEFTPDV QBEPVOB"TJHOBDJwO6OJWFSTBMQBSBUPEPTMPTNFOPSFTEFBvPT ZMB"TJHOBDJwOEFM)BCFS.rOJNPQBSBMPTNBZPSFTEFBvPTTJO DPCFSUVSB QSFWJTJPOBM &M BDDJPOBS DPOKVOUP EF FTUBT USFT NFEJEBT QFSNJUJSrB VCJDBS B UPEPT MPT IPHBSFT QPS FODJNB EF MB -rOFB EF MB 1PCSF[BBMUJFNQPRVFBMEFTDPNQSJNJSMBQSFTJwOTPCSFFMNFSDBEP MBCPSBMB¾SNBSrBDPOEJDJPOFTNBUFSJBMFTNgTGBWPSBCMFTQBSBFMDPO KVOUPEFMPTPDVQBEPT-BQSPQVFTUBTFFONBSDBCBFOVOBFTUSBUFHJB EF6/*7&34"-*;"$*Î/%&%&3&$)04BMBTBMVEBMBFEVDBDJwOBM FNQMFPZBMBQSFWJTJwO RVFSFTUJUVZFSBBMBQPCMBDJwOTVDBSgDUFSEF DJVEBEBOPT BM UJFNQP RVF QPUFODJBOEP FM DPOTVNP QPQVMBS DPNP FKFEFMNFSDBEPJOUFSOPTFJOTDSJCrBDPNPVOBWBODFFOMBEJSFDDJwO EFHFTUBSPUSPQBUSwOQSPEVDUJWPBDPSEFBMOVFWPQBSBEJHNBUFDOPMw HJDPWJHFOUFFOMBFDPOPNrBNVOEJBM³-P[BOP "DUVBMNFOUF FM'SFOBQPQSJPSJ[BMBJONFEJBUBVOJWFSTBMJ[BDJwOEFMSnHJNFOBDUVBM EFBTJHOBDJPOFTGBNJMJBSFTTBMBSJPGBNJMJBSQPSIJKP BMUJFNQPRVFIB BDUVBMJ[BEPMBWJBCJMJEBEFDPOwNJDBEFMBQSPQVFTUBQMFCJTDJUBEBFO FMBvP-P[BOP &O TJOUPOrB DPO FTUF SFDMBNP FM .PWJNJFOUP /BDJPOBM EF MPT $IJDPTEFM1VFCMPRVFDPNPZBNFODJPOBNPTEFTEFFMBvPTF NPWJMJ[BSFDMBNBOEPUSBOTGPSNBDJPOFTTVTUBOUJWBTQBSBNPEJ¾DBSMB 1BSUJDJQBDJwOFJODJEFODJBEFMBTPDJFEBEDJWJMFMDBTPBSHFOUJOP TJUVBDJwOEFFYUSFNBQPCSF[BRVFQBEFDFHSBOQBSUFEFMBJOGBODJBZ MBBEPMFTDFODJBUBNCJnOTPMJDJUBVOBBTJHOBDJwOVOJWFSTBMQPSIJKPZ VOTFHVSPEFFNQMFPZGPSNBDJwOQBSBMPTQBESFT "TJNJTNPMBTPSHBOJ[BDJPOFTEFEFTPDVQBEPTUBNCJnOJODPSQP SBSPOFOTVTSFDMBNPTFMEFSFDIPBMBFEVDBDJwODPNPVOBTQFDUP QSJPSJUBSJP 5FDIP USBCBKP KVTUJDJB TBMVE FEVDBDJwO TPO BMHVOBT EFMBTEFNBOEBTNgTFYJHJEBTQPSFTUPTNPWJNJFOUPT"MHVOPTEF FMMPTUVWJFSPOVOEFTBSSPMMPQBSUJDVMBSNFOUFTJHOJ¾DBUJWPFOFMDBN QPFEVDBUJWPBMDSFBSgSFBTEFUSBCBKPFTQFDr¾DBTFTDVFMBTFTQB DJPT EF GPSNBDJwO UBMMFSFT MBCPSBMFT FUD 4wMP B UrUVMP EF FKFNQMP QPEFNPTOPNCSBSBM.PWJNJFOUP#BSSJPTEF1JFBMEF5SBCBKBEPSFT %FTPDVQBEPTEFMB.BUBO[BFM.PWJNJFOUP5FSSJUPSJBMEF-JCFSBDJwO FOUSFPUSPT DPNPQSPNPUPSFTEFMEFSFDIPBMBFEVDBDJwOFOUSFTVT SFDMBNPT Z QSPQVFTUBT &O FTUB MrOFB FM .PWJNJFOUP /BDJPOBM EF &NQSFTBT3FDVQFSBEBT./&3 UBNCJnOJNQVMTBFOTVTFNQSFOEJ NJFOUPTQSPEVDUJWPTMBDSFBDJwOEFFTDVFMBTZQSPHSBNBTEFBMGBCF UJ[BDJwOBSUJDVMBEPTDPODFOUSPTDVMUVSBMFTCJCMJPUFDBTFUDnUFSB "OB1BHBOP*OHSJE4WFSEMJDLZ1BVMB$PTUBT $"40&.#-&.Ç5*$0%&1"35*$*1"$*Î/&*/$*%&/$*" &M¾OBODJBNJFOUPFEVDBUJWPFOMB"SHFOUJOBFTNPUJWPEFSFDMBNP EFMPTQSJODJQBMFTTFDUPSFTEFMDBNQPFEVDBUJWPEFTEFIBDFZBWB SJPTBvPT6OQSPDFTPRVFGVFNBSDBEPQPSEJGFSFOUFTNPNFOUPTEF QSPUFTUBZOFHPDJBDJwOZRVFDVMNJOBFOMBSFDJFOUFTBODJwOEFMB-FZ EF'JOBODJBNJFOUP&EVDBUJWP1PSFTPBNFSJUBTFSUPNBEPDPNPVO DBTPFOFMRVFMBQBSUJDJQBDJwOEFTFDUPSFTEFMBTPDJFEBEDJWJMQPTFF VODPOTJEFSBCMFJNQBDUPFJODJEFODJBFOMPTQSPDFTPTEFEJTFvPEF MBTQPMrUJDBTQ|CMJDBT -BTQPMrUJDBTEFDPSUFOFPMJCFSBMBQMJDBEBTEVSBOUFMBEnDBEBEF MPTBvPTNBSDBOVOQVOUPEFJO¿FYJwOFOSFMBDJwODPOMBTGPSNBT EFQBSUJDJQBDJwOZQSPUFTUBEFMPTEJWFSTPTTFDUPSFTEFMBTPDJFEBE DJWJM$PNPTFNFODJPOwEJDIBTQPMrUJDBTQSPEVKFSPOQSPDFTPTEFFY DMVTJwORVFSFTVMUBSPOFODPOTJEFSBCMFTCBKBTZEJTNJOVDJPOFTFOMBT NBOJGFTUBDJPOFTZQSPUFTUBTEVSBOUFMBQSJNFSBNJUBEEFMBEnDBEB 1FSPFOMBTFHVOEBNJUBEDPNJFO[BOBSFHJTUSBSTFDBNCJPTDVBMJ UBUJWPTUBOUPFOSFMBDJwODPOTVTGPSNBTDPNPDPOTVTDPOUFOJEPT -BT NBOJGFTUBDJPOFT DPCSBO NBZPS WJTJCJMJEBE B USBWnT EF OVFWBT FYQSFTJPOFTDPNPMPTDPSUFTEFSVUBMPTQJRVFUFTMBTNBSDIBTEFM TJMFODJPMPTFTDSBDIFTZMPTDBNQBNFOUPTQSPMPOHBEPTTJORVFQPS FMMPTFEFKFEFMBEPBRVFMMPTFTUJMPTNgTUSBEJDJPOBMFTWJODVMBEPTB IVFMHBTNPWJMJ[BDJPOFTFUD4VgSF[ 1BSUJDJQBDJwOFJODJEFODJBEFMBTPDJFEBEDJWJMFMDBTPBSHFOUJOP &OFMDBNQPFEVDBUJWPZFOFMNBSDPEFMBSFGPSNBEFMPTBvPT °DPOHSBWFTDPOTFDVFODJBTQBSBFMTJTUFNBFEVDBUJWPBSHFOUJOP°MB $BSQB #MBODB BM[BEB FO FM BvP QPS MPT HSFNJPT EPDFOUFT FT VOBEFMBTGPSNBTNgTWJTJCMFTEFMNPNFOUP&TUBBDDJwONBSDBVO IJUPFOSFMBDJwODPOMBTGPSNBTEFQSPUFTUBMPTSFDMBNPTFOFMDBNQP FEVDBUJWPZTVWJODVMBDJwODPOMBTQPMrUJDBTQ|CMJDBT4VgSF[ &O FM NBSDP EF MBT QPMrUJDBT OFPMJCFSBMFT Z MBT SFGPSNBT FEVDB UJWBTMB$5&3"DPNFO[wVOQSPDFTPEFSFTJTUFODJBBUSBWnTEFVOB TFSJFEFBDUPTZNPWJMJ[BDJPOFT%VSBOUFMBQSJNFSBNJUBEEFMBEn DBEBMPTDPO¿JDUPTHSFNJBMFTTFNVMUJQMJDBSPOFOMBTQSPWJODJBTQFSP FM JNQBDUP EF MBT NPWJMJ[BDJPOFT OP GVF TV¾DJFOUF QBSB EFUFOFS FM QSPDFTPZBJOJDJBEPQPSMBSFGPSNB -BOFDFTJEBEEFVOJSFTUPTDPO¿JDUPTFOVOBTPMBMVDIBZEFJN QMFNFOUBS VOB NPEBMJEBE EF QSPUFTUB DBQB[ EF FWJUBS MBT IVFMHBT SFJUFSBEBTZMBQnSEJEBEFErBTEFDMBTF°RVFSFTVMUBCBOGVODJPOB MFT BM EJTDVSTP SFGPSNJTUB° Q MMFHw B VO QVOUP EF JO¿FYJwO FO BQBSUJSEFMBJOTUBMBDJwOEFMB$BSQB#MBODB&TUBJOJDJBUJWBUVWP DPNPFKFDFOUSBMFMSFDMBNPEFVOBMFZEF¾OBODJBNJFOUPFEVDBUJ WP-BBDDJwOMPHSBSgMBVOJ¾DBDJwOZMBOBDJPOBMJ[BDJwOEFMDPO¿JDUP FEVDBUJWP 5BMDPNPTFNFODJPOBCBNgTBSSJCBDPOTUJUVZFVOIJUPFOSFMB DJwODPOMBTGPSNBTEFQSPUFTUBEFMB"SHFOUJOBFOFTFNPNFOUP4V WJTJCJMJEBEZDPOTUBODJBEVSwErBTGSFOUFBM$POHSFTP/BDJPOBM FOMB$JVEBEEF#VFOPT"JSFT IJDJFSPORVFUSBTDFOEJFSBOEFNBOFSB OPUBCMFMPTSFDMBNPTTFDUPSJBMFTRVFMMFHBSPOBTFSUPNBEPTQPSFM DPOKVOUPEFMBTPDJFEBE&ODVBOUPBMDPOUFOJEPEFFTUPTSFDMBNPT UBNCJnOIVCPVODBNCJPDVBMJUBUJWP&MJNQBDUPEFMBSFGPSNBMMFWwB VOSFQMBOUFPFOFMDBSgDUFSEFMBTSFJWJOEJDBDJPOFTNBSDPFOFMDVBM MBOFDFTJEBEEFM¾OBODJBNJFOUPFEVDBUJWPDPNJFO[BBTFSQMBOUFBEB OPTwMPMJHBEBBMSFDMBNPTBMBSJBMTJOPUBNCJnOBMDVNQMJNJFOUPEFM EFSFDIPTPDJBMBMB&EVDBDJwOZBMBFYJHFODJBEFVO&TUBEPRVFMP HBSBOUJDF²%FTEFMB$BSQBTFBCSJwFMEFCBUFTPCSFFMEFTUJOPEFMB FTDVFMB Q|CMJDB TF QVTP FO DVFTUJPOBNJFOUP QPQVMBS MB FKFDVDJwO EFMBSFGPSNBTFMBBTJNJMwBMBKVTUFTFFWJEFODJwRVFOPIBZUSBOT GPSNBDJwODPOOJvPTIBNCSJFOUPT<>4FFNQJF[BBFOUFOEFSRVFMB SFGPSNBDBFTJTFEFSSPUBMBQPMrUJDBFEVDBUJWBZTPDJBMEFMBDVBMMB "OB1BHBOP*OHSJE4WFSEMJDLZ1BVMB$PTUBT -FZ'FEFSBMEF&EVDBDJwOFTTPMPVODBQrUVMP³$5&3"$/5&$PMFHJP EFQSPGFTPSFT"'656'&/"1&4-11 -B GPSNB EF SFDMBNP DPOTJTUJw FO BZVOBS IBTUB RVF GVFSB BUFO EJEPFMQFEJEPEFVOBMFZEF¾OBODJBNJFOUP&TUPGVFBDPNQBvBEP EF HSBO DBOUJEBE EF QBSPT OBDJPOBMFT NBSDIBT BZVOPT FO MBT FT DVFMBTSFDJUBMFTEFN|TJDBFUDZEFMB¾SNBEFQFUJUPSJPBCJFSUPBM DPOKVOUPEFMBTPDJFEBE %VSBOUFMBEJTDVTJwODPOFMHPCJFSOPTPCSFMBDSFBDJwOEF VO 'POEP EF 'JOBODJBNJFOUP &EVDBUJWP TF JOUFOTJ¾Dw MPHSBOEP VO QJTPEFBDVFSEPRVFQFSNJUJwMBBQSPCBDJwOEFMB-FZ/$PO FTUBMFZTFDSFBFM²'POEP/BDJPOBMEF*ODFOUJWP%PDFOUF³'0/*% QPSFMUnSNJOPEFBvPT&MNJTNPUJFOFDPNPPCKFUJWPFMNFKPSB NJFOUPEFMPTTBMBSJPTEPDFOUFTEFUPEBTMBTFTDVFMBTQSPWJODJBMFTZ EFMB$JVEBE"VUwOPNBEF#VFOPT"JSFTTFBOFTUBTEFHFTUJwOFTUB UBMPQSJWBEBTTVCWFODJPOBEBT4FUSBUBEFVOBBTJHOBDJwOFTQFDJBM °SFNVOFSBUJWBOPCPOJ¾DBCMF°QPSDBSHPEPDFOUF 1FSPFM1PEFS&KFDVUJWPWFUBVOBDMgVTVMBRVFHBSBOUJ[BCBFMTPT UFOJNJFOUPEFM'POEPMBBQMJDBDJwOEFJNQVFTUPTBMTFDUPSBVUPNP UPS -B BVTFODJB EF FTUB DMgVTVMB JNQFErB RVF FM HPCJFSOP QVEJFSB BTFHVSBSMBSFDBVEBDJwOQBSBFTUPT¾OFT'SFOUFBFTUPFM$POHSFTP EF$5&3"SFTVFMWFMBDPOUJOVJEBEEFMQMBOEFMVDIBZFMTPTUFOJNJFO UPEFMB$BSQB#MBODB$5&3"$/5&$PMFHJPEFQSPGFTPSFT"'656 '&/"1&4-11 &OOPWJFNCSFEFMVFHPEFVOOVFWPQBSPOBDJPOBMEPDFOUFZ FOFMNBSDPEFOFHPDJBDJPOFTTPTUFOJEBTDPOFMSFDJFOUFNFOUFFMFD UPQSFTJEFOUF'FSOBOEP%F-B3|BFM$POHSFTPEFMB$5&3"EFDJEF MFWBOUBSMB$BSQB&OFMNFTTJHVJFOUFTFBQSVFCBVOBNPEJ¾DBDJwO BMB-FZEF*ODFOUJWP%PDFOUFQPSMBDVBMTFDSFBVOGPOEPBOVBMEF NJMMPOFTEFQFTPTFTUBWF[FYUSBrEPTEFSFOUBTHFOFSBMFTZTJO MBJODFSUJEVNCSFEFMJNQVFTUPBVUPNPUPS %VSBOUFFMHPCJFSOPEF%VIBMEFFOGFCSFSPEFMMB$5&3" BNFOB[B DPO SFJOTUBMBS MB $BSQB B SBr[ EF BUSBTPT FO FM DPCSP EFM *ODFOUJWP%PDFOUFMPTTBMBSJPTFUD&MHPCJFSOPEF%VIBMEFWBMMBMB QMB[BEFMPT%PT$POHSFTPT 1BSUJDJQBDJwOFJODJEFODJBEFMBTPDJFEBEDJWJMFMDBTPBSHFOUJOP -BBDUVBMHFTUJwOEFHPCJFSOPRVFBTVNFFONBZPEFSFHV MBSJ[BFMQBHPZBVNFOUBMBDVPUBEFM*ODFOUJWP%PDFOUF&OFOFSPEFM MB$5&3"SFBMJ[BVO$POHSFTP&YUSBPSEJOBSJPFOFMRVFSFTVFM WFVO1MBOEF"DDJwOQBSBFYJHJSFMBVNFOUPEFMBDVPUBEFM*ODFOUJWP ZVOB-FZRVFMFEJFSBDPOUJOVJEBEFMQMB[PEFQBHPFTUBCMFDJEPFOMB -FZ/WFODrBFOFM &OBHPTUPEFFTFBvPTFTBODJPOB MB-FZ/RVFFTUBCMFDFTVDPOUJOVJEBEQPSBvPTPIBTUBMB BQSPCBDJwOEFVOBMFZEF'JOBODJBNJFOUP&EVDBUJWPJOUFHSBM&OMPT NFTFTTVDFTJWPTTFBVNFOUBOVFWBNFOUFMBDVPUB -B$5&3"FWBM|BEFNBOFSBNVZQPTJUJWBFTUFQSPDFTPDPOTJEF SBOEP RVF ²-B DSFBDJwO Z MB DPOUJOVJEBE EFM '0/*% DPOTUJUVZF VO MPHSPRVFFYDFEFMPTBMBSJBMZBRVFJNQMJDBRVFFMHPCJFSOPOBDJPOBM WVFMWBBIBDFSTFDBSHPEFM'JOBODJBNJFOUPEFMBFEVDBDJwOMVFHPRVF MBT QPMrUJDBTNFOFNJTUBTIBCrBOEFTSFTQPOTBCJMJ[BEPBM&TUBEPEF TVDPNQSPNJTPJOEFMFHBCMFGSFOUFBMB&EVDBDJwO1|CMJDB³$5&3" &M4FDSFUBSJP(FOFSBMEFMB$FOUSBMBOBMJ[BFTUFQSPDFTPEJDJFO EP²1VEJNPTFODPOUSBSMBGPSNBEFDPOWFSUJSVOBEFNBOEBOVFTUSB FOVOBCBOEFSBEFMBDJVEBEBOrB:QVEJNPTIBDFSRVFFTUBCBOEFSB EFMBDJVEBEBOrBTFDPOWJSUJFSBBMBGVFS[BEFMBMVDIBRVFEFTBSSPMMB NPTFOVOBQPMrUJDBQ|CMJDB-PHSBNPTBUSBWnTEFVOBMFZMBDPOT UJUVDJwOEFVOGPOEPEF¾OBODJBNJFOUPFEVDBUJWP³465&#" &M'0/*%BCSJwFMDBNJOPQBSBMBQSPGVOEJ[BDJwOEFMSFDMBNPRVF QVTPTVTPCKFUJWPTFOMBTBODJwOEFVOBMFZEF¾OBODJBNJFOUPFEV DBUJWPRVFJODMVZB » BVNFOUPEFMBJOWFSTJwOFEVDBUJWBEFMBMEFM1#* » FOVOBHSBEVBMJEBEEFOPNgTEFBvPT » RVF SFTUJUVZB MB QSPQPSDJwO EF JOWFSTJwO FOUSF /BDJwO Z QSPWJO DJBTQSFWJBBMBUSBOTGFSFODJBEFFTDVFMBT » DPO MB QBSUJDJQBDJwO EF $5&3" FO FM DPOUSPM EF MB FKFDVDJwO QSFTVQVFTUBSJB » RVFHBSBOUJDFVOQJTPTBMBSJBMVOJ¾DBEP » ZVOBJOWFSTJwOQPSBMVNOPRVFQFSNJUBTVQFSBSMBFYDMVTJwOFEV DBUJWB465&#" "OB1BHBOP*OHSJE4WFSEMJDLZ1BVMB$PTUBT 3FTVMUB DFOUSBM FO FTUF SFDMBNP MB DPSSFTQPOTBCJMJEBE FOUSF MB OBDJwOZMBTQSPWJODJBT-BTQSPWJODJBTOPDVFOUBODPOSFDVSTPTTV ¾DJFOUFTQBSBIBDFSGSFOUFBMQBHPEFTBMBSJPTZDPOUSJCVJSBMBWF[ DPOMBVOJ¾DBDJwOEFFTUPTFOUPEPFMQBrT&TQPSFTUPRVFTFIBDF nOGBTJTFORVFMPTGPOEPTFTUnOHBSBOUJ[BEPTQPSBNCPTZTFBTVNB MBSFTQPOTBCJMJEBEEFJOWFSUJSMPTFOUBMTFOUJEP "TVWF[FTJNQPSUBOUFSFTBMUBSRVFUFOJFOEPFODVFOUBMPTJOUFO UPTIJTUwSJDPT°MB-FZ'FEFSBMEF&EVDBDJwOFTUBCMFDJwMMFHBSBVO EFM1#*RVFOVODBTFDPOTJHVJw°FTUBEFNBOEBIBDFIJODBQJnFOEPT QVOUPTDFOUSBMFTQPSVOMBEPFOFMJODSFNFOUPEFMPTSFDVSTPTQBSB FMTFDUPSZQPSFMPUSPFOMPTNFDBOJTNPTQBSBBTFHVSBSFMEFTUJOP EFMPTNJNPT 5BNCJnOSFTVMUBSFMFWBOUFUFOFSFODVFOUBRVF²<>MBFYQFSJFO DJBJOUFSOBDJPOBMJOEJDBRVFFTBUSBWnTEFSFOUBTHFOFSBMFTRVFTF ¾OBODJB MB FEVDBDJwO NJFOUSBT RVF MBT MFZFT FTQFDr¾DBT TF PSJFO UBO B GPOEPT DPNQFOTBUPSJPT <> /P IBZ BOUFDFEFOUFT EF VOB MFZ EF¾OBODJBNJFOUPFTQFDr¾DPQBSBMBFEVDBDJwO-BJOWFSTJwOFOMPT QBrTFTDFOUSBMFTFTUgHBSBOUJ[BEBQPSVOBEFDJTJwOQPMrUJDBCBTBEB FOVOBQPMrUJDBUSJCVUBSJBTFSJBTPTUFOJEBFOFMUJFNQPFOEPOEFMB FWBTJwOFTMBFYDFQDJwO³**1&#VFOPT"JSFT &TUPFTMP RVF TFJOUFOUwFOPUSBTPQPSUVOJEBEFTFOMB"SHFOUJOBZOPTFDPOTJHVJw MP DVBM IBDF EF FTUB EFNBOEB BMHP OPWFEPTP BM IBDFS IJODBQJn FO RVFMPTGPOEPTQ|CMJDPTFTUnOTVKFUPTBMDVNQMJNJFOUPEFVOBOPSNB FTQFDr¾DB %VSBOUFBCSJMEFMMB$5&3"SFBMJ[BVOBNPWJMJ[BDJwOQPSUPEP FMQBrTDPOMB²$BSBWBOB/BDJPOBMQPSMB&TDVFMB1|CMJDB³DPOFMPCKF UJWPEFFGFDUJWJ[BSMBTBODJwOEFVOB-FZEF'JOBODJBNJFOUP&EVDBUJWP RVFFTUBCMF[DB²VOQJTP³EFQVOUPTEFM1#*QBSBMBFEVDBDJwO&M BSHVNFOUPQSJODJQBMTFDFOUSwFORVFFM&TUBEPEFKFEFEFTUJOBSMB NBZPSrBEFMPTSFDVSTPTBTBMEBSMBEFVEBFYUFSOBZBTVNBFOQSJ NFSMVHBSFMDPNQSPNJTPDPOMBEFVEBJOUFSOB&OQBMBCSBTEF)VHP :BTLZ°4FDSFUBSJP(FOFSBMEF$5&3"°²RVFMBEFNBOEBB|OJOTBUJT GFDIBTFDPOWJFSUBFOQPMrUJDBQ|CMJDB³465&#" -B $BSBWBOBEVSwVONFTZNFEJPZ¾OBMJ[wDPOVOQBSPOBDJP OBMZVOBNBSDIBEVSBOUFFMNFTEFNBZPEFM-VFHPEFFTUP 1BSUJDJQBDJwOFJODJEFODJBEFMBTPDJFEBEDJWJMFMDBTPBSHFOUJOP EVSBOUF FM NFT EF TFQUJFNCSF MB $5&3" JNQVMTw VOB $BNQBvB EF .PWJMJ[BDJwOFOUPEPFMQBrTRVFUVWPDPNPFKFDFOUSBMMB¾SNBEF VO 1FUJUPSJP EJSJHJEP OP TwMP B MPT EPDFOUFT TJOP BM DPOKVOUP EF MB TPDJFEBE 1BSB FTUB nQPDB FM HPCJFSOP DPOWPDB B USBWnT EF MP RVF MMBNB ²SPOEBEFDPOTVMUBT³BEJTUJOUPTTFDUPSFTSFQSFTFOUBUJWPTEFMBTP DJFEBEDJWJMHSFNJPTEPDFOUFTFNQSFTBSJPTSFQSFTFOUBOUFTEFPS HBOJ[BDJPOFTTPDJBMFTBDBEnNJDPTFUD BEJTDVUJSFMQSPZFDUPEFMFZ RVFTFSgFOWJBEPBM$POHSFTP &O MB DPOWPDBUPSJB BM TFDUPS FNQSFTBSJBM QBSUJDJQBSPO SFQSFTFO UBOUFTEFMB"TPDJBDJwO&NQSFTBSJB"SHFOUJOB"&" "TPDJBDJwOEF &OUJEBEFT &EVDBUJWBT 1SJWBEBT "SHFOUJOBT "%&&13" "TPDJBDJwO EF3FDVSTPT)VNBOPTEFMB"SHFOUJOB"%3)" +VOUB$PPSEJOBEPSB EF &OTFvBO[B 1SJWBEB $003%*&1 *OTUJUVUP QBSB FM %FTBSSPMMP &NQSFTBSJBM EF MB "SHFOUJOB *%&" 6OJwO *OEVTUSJBM "SHFOUJOB 6*" $gNBSB "SHFOUJOB EF MB $POTUSVDDJwO $gNBSB "SHFOUJOB EF *OEVNFOUBSJB $gNBSB "SHFOUJOB EFM -JCSP $gNBSB "SHFOUJOB EF 1VCMJDBDJPOFT$gNBSBEF$POWFSUJEPSFTEF1BQFMZ'BCSJDBOUFTEF "SUrDVMPTEF-JCSFSrB$gNBSBEF$POWFSUJEPSFTEF1BQFM#BODP3rP EFMB1MBUB4"#BODP3rP$MBSrO*#.*/5&--B/BDJwO.JMMJDPN "SHFOUJOB 4*%64 4PDJFEBE $PNFSDJBM EFM 1MBUB 4" 5FDIJOU Z 5FMFDPN"MMrNBOJGFTUBSPOTVBQPZPBMQSPZFDUPQSFTFOUBEPQPSFM 1PEFS &KFDVUJWP IBDJFOEP IJODBQJn FO MB JNQPSUBODJB EF MB FEVDB DJwOQBSBFMGVUVSPQSPEVDUJWPEFMQBrTZFOMBOFDFTJEBEEFFTUBCMF DFSVOOVFWP¾OBODJBNJFOUPQBSBFMTFDUPS &O VOB TFHVOEB JOTUBODJB TF DPOWPDBSPO B BDBEnNJDPT Z SF QSFTFOUBOUFT EF BMHVOBT PSHBOJ[BDJPOFT TPDJBMFT 'VOEBDJwO 4VTUFOUBCJMJEBE &EVDBDJwO 4PMJEBSJEBE 4&4 "TPDJBDJwO EF 1BESJOPT EF "MVNOPT Z &TDVFMBT 3VSBMFT "1"&3 'VOEBDJwO $JNJFOUPT 'VOEBDJwO &TDPMBSFT 'VOEBDJwO 'F Z "MFHSrB $BSJUBT 'VOEBDJwO"3$03"TPDJBDJwO$SJTUJBOBEF%JSJHFOUFTEF&NQSFTBT "$%&'VOEBDJwO$PNQSPNJTP"TPDJBDJwO$PODJFODJBFUD RVF UBNCJnONBOJGFTUBSPOTVBQPZP 1SFWJBZQBSBMFMBNFOUFBFTUBT²SPOEBTEFDPOTVMUBT³TFMMFWBSPO B DBCP SFVOJPOFT EF USBCBKP DPO MPT QSJODJQBMFT HSFNJPT EPDFOUFT "OB1BHBOP*OHSJE4WFSEMJDLZ1BVMB$PTUBT EFBMDBODFOBDJPOBMJOTUBODJBTBUSBWnTEFMBTDVBMFTTFDFOUSBOMPT QSJODJQBMFT QSPDFTPT EF OFHPDJBDJwO -B $5&3" GVF VO JOUFSMPDVUPS DFOUSBMFOFTUFQSPDFTP-VFHPEFMBTNFEJEBTEFGVFS[BZBNFODJP OBEBT DPNFO[BSPO MBT ²DPOWFSTBDJPOFT³ F JOTUBODJBT EF OFHPDJB DJwODPOFMHPCJFSOP &OFMNFTEFEJDJFNCSFEFMTFBQSPCwMBMFZEF'JOBODJBNJFOUP &EVDBUJWP/ QPSWPUPTBGBWPSDPOUSBFODPOUSBFO MB$gNBSBEF%JQVUBEPTEFM$POHSFTP/BDJPOBM ZFOUSwFOWJHFODJBFM EFFOFSPEFM'JOBMNFOUFFTUBJODMVZwVOBVNFOUPEFMQSF TVQVFTUPBMEFM1#*QFSPFOFMQMB[PEFBvPTZOPBvPTDPNP QMBOUFBCBMB$5&3" VOBEJTUSJCVDJwOEFMNJTNPFOQSPQPSDJPOFTJO WFSTBTBMPQMBOUFBEPFTEFDJSFMBDBSHPEFMBTQSPWJODJBTZFM BDBSHPEFOBDJwO"TVWF[FOUSFMPTQSJODJQBMFTPCKFUJWPTEFMB MFZ²TFFODVFOUSBOFMEFHBSBOUJ[BSMBJHVBMEBEEFPQPSUVOJEBEFTEF BQSFOEJ[BKFBQPZBSMBTQPMrUJDBTEFNFKPSBFOMBDBMJEBEEFMBFOTF vBO[BZGPSUBMFDFSMBJOWFTUJHBDJwODJFOUr¾DPUFDOPMwHJDB.JOJTUFSJP EF&EVDBDJwO$JFODJBZ5FDOPMPHrB -BQSPDFEFODJBEFMPTGPOEPTEFTUJOBEPTBMBVNFOUPQSFTVQVFT UBSJPNBSDBOMBEJGFSFODJBDPOSFTQFDUPBMB-FZ'FEFSBMEF&EVDBDJwO TBODJPOBEBFOMPTBvPT&MBVNFOUPBQSPCBEPFOFTFFOUPODFTOP FSBDMBSPSFTQFDUPEFMPSJHFOEFMPTGPOEPTOJEFMBTDPOEJDJPOFTQBSB TV BQMJDBDJwO -BT QSPWJODJBT EFTWJBCBO MPT GPOEPT TFH|O EJGFSFO UFTDSJUFSJPT&OFTUFDBTPMPTSFDVSTPTQSPWFOESgOEFMBVNFOUPEF MPTGPOEPTDPQBSUJDJQBCMFTRVFTFSgOEJTUSJCVJEPTFOMBTQSPWJODJBT QFSP B DPOEJDJwO EF TFS JOWFSUJEPT FO EFUFSNJOBEPT QVOUPT PCSBT EFJOGSBFTUSVDUVSBMJCSPTDPNQVUBEPSBTNBUFSJBMEJEgDUJDPZDBQB DJUBDJwO-BTQSPWJODJBTQPSTVQBSUFEFCFSgONFKPSBSMPTTBMBSJPT EPDFOUFTZMBBQFSUVSBEFOVFWPTDBSHPT &OFMNFTEFBCSJMEFMDPSSJFOUFBvPQPS3FTPMVDJwOEFM$POTFKP 'FEFSBMEF$VMUVSBZ&EVDBDJwO.JOJTUFSJPEF&EVDBDJwO$JFODJBZ 5FDOPMPHrB TF DSFB VOB DPNJTJwO FO MB RVF FM .JOJTUFSJP FM $POTFKP'FEFSBMZMPTHSFNJPTEPDFOUFTBDPSEBSgOVODPOWFOJPNBS DPTPCSFMBTDPOEJDJPOFTMBCPSBMFTDBMFOEBSJPFEVDBUJWPTBMBSJPNr OJNPEPDFOUFZDBSSFSBEPDFOUFTFH|OMPRVFFTUBCMFDFFM"SUEF MB-FZEF'JOBODJBNJFOUP&EVDBUJWP 1BSUJDJQBDJwOFJODJEFODJBEFMBTPDJFEBEDJWJMFMDBTPBSHFOUJOP 4JOFNCBSHPEPDFOUFTZFTUVEJBOUFTVOJWFSTJUBSJPT°FOUSFPUSPT TFDUPSFT° QMBOUFBO PCKFDJPOFT SFTQFDUP EF MPT BDVFSEPT EFTBSSP MMBEPTDPOFMTFDUPSFNQSFTBSJBM&TUPTBDVFSEPTTPOJOUFSQSFUBEPT DPNPVOBQSJWBUJ[BDJwOEFMBFEVDBDJwOZVODBSgDUFSNFSDBOUJMJTUB EFMBOPSNB5BNCJnOTFDVFTUJPOBMBEFQFOEFODJBEFMPTBVNFOUPT EFM 1#* EBEP RVF FTUP QPOF FO QFMJHSP TV FGFDUJWJ[BDJwO &O PUSPT DBTPTTFDPOTJEFSBRVFBVORVFFMBVNFOUPFTNVZWBMPSBCMFFTUF OPWJFOFBSFTPMWFSMPTQSPCMFNBTEFMBEJTUSJCVDJwOEFMJOHSFTPRVF EFCFOTFSUSBUBEPTFOTJNVMUBOFJEBEQBSBRVFFTUBMFZPCUFOHBCVF OPTSFTVMUBEPT -B $5&3" DPOTJEFSB RVF FO BMHVOB NFEJEB FTUF SFTVMUBEP °B QFTBSEFRVFTFNPEJ¾DBSPOTVTQMBOUFPTJOJDJBMFT°FTGSVUPEFTVT SFJWJOEJDBDJPOFTIJTUwSJDBTZRVFMBFYJTUFODJBEFJOTUBODJBTEFEJg MPHPFTUgOQFSNJUJFOEPFOTBODIBSMPTNgSHFOFTEFJODJEFODJBFOMB EF¾OJDJwOEFMBQPMrUJDBTFEVDBUJWBT 1FSPZBTVWF[MB²BQFSUVSBBMEJgMPHP³QPSQBSUFEFMHPCJFSOP MMFWwBVOSFQPTJDJPOBNJFOUPQPMrUJDPQBSBMB$FOUSBMMPDVBMJNQMJ DwFJNQMJDBWBSJBTDVFTUJPOFT1PSVOMBEPRVFMBUSBEJDJPOBMGPSNB EFQBSUJDJQBDJwOMJHBEBBMBQSPUFTUBZMBSFTJTUFODJB°QSPGVOEJ[BEB EVSBOUFFMHPCJFSOPEF.FOFNZTPTUFOJEBFOMPTQPTUFSJPSFT°FT SFWJTBEB GSFOUF B FTUB ²JOWJUBDJwO³ 4F QSPEVDF BTr ²VO HJSP³ IBDJB OVFWBTGPSNBTFTUBWF[EFEJgMPHPZOFHPDJBDJwO-PDVBMDPOMMFWB BTVWF[MBOFDFTJEBEQPMrUJDBEFDPOUBSDPOIFSSBNJFOUBTEFBOgMJTJT RVFQFSNJUBOEJTDVUJSZQSPQPOFSFOUBMFTJOTUBODJBTEFQBSUJDJQBDJwO TPCSFFMEJTFvPZMBJNQMFNFOUBDJwOEFMBTQPMrUJDBTFEVDBUJWBT-B $5&3"IJ[PVOQSPDFTPFOFTUFTFOUJEPUBMDPNPTFNFODJPOwNgT BSSJCBJOUSPEVDJFOEPBQBSUJSEFMB$BSQB#MBODBSFJWJOEJDBDJPOFTZB OPUBOTFDUPSJBMFTTJOPNgTHMPCBMFTZWJODVMBEBTBMEFSFDIPTPDJBM BMBFEVDBDJwO&OFTUFDPOUFYUPMBDPOTUSVDDJwODPMFDUJWBEFFTUPT QPTJDJPOBNJFOUPTFTVOPEFMPTBDUVBMFTEFTBGrPTEFMBTPSHBOJ[B DJPOFTEFMBTPDJFEBEDJWJMQPOJnOEPTFFOKVFHPMPTQSPDFTPTEFNP DSgUJDPTOPTwMPFOSFMBDJwODPOFM&TUBEPZTV²BQFSUVSB³BMEJgMPHP 0QJOJPOFTEFEPDFOUFTSFVOJEPTFOMB"TPDJBDJwO(SFNJBM%PDFOUFZEFFTUVEJBOUFT VOJWFSTJUBSJPTEFMB'6#"FO1gHJOB²&TQFSBO[BTZUFNPSFTBDBEnNJDPTGSFOUFBMB-FZEF 'JOBODJBNJFOUP³#VFOPT"JSFTEFPDUVCSFEF "OB1BHBOP*OHSJE4WFSEMJDLZ1BVMB$PTUBT TJOPUBNCJnOFOFMJOUFSJPSEFMBTPSHBOJ[BDJPOFTTPDJBMFTRVFDPOT USVZFOQPTJDJPOBNJFOUPTZQVHOBOQPSJODJEJSFOMBTQPMrUJDBTQ|CMJ DBT5BMDPNPTFNFODJPOwBMQSJODJQJPEFFTUFUSBCBKPMBTQPMrUJDBT OFPMJCFSBMFTIBOEFKBEPTVTIVFMMBTFOMBTGPSNBTEFQBSUJDJQBDJwO Z FO MPT TVKFUPT NJTNPT -B DPOTUSVDDJwO DPMFDUJWB Z EFNPDSgUJDB FOVONBSDPEFOFHPDJBDJwODPOMBJOTUBODJBFTUBUBMDPOTUJUVZFVO SFUPQBSBMBTPSHBOJ[BDJPOFTTPDJBMFTBDPTUVNCSBEBTBQSgDUJDBTZ FTUSVDUVSBTEFQBSUJDJQBDJwOMJHBEBTBMBSFTJTUFODJB&TUPOPJNQMJDB BCBOEPOBSMBTQPSDPNQMFUPTJOPJODPSQPSBSPUSBTOVFWBT $POTJEFSBNPTRVFFMQSPDFTPRVFTFEFTDSJCJwFOUPSOPBMSFDMBNP QPSFM¾OBODJBNJFOUPFEVDBUJWPFOMB"SHFOUJOBFTFKFNQMPEFFTUBT DVFTUJPOFT-BTGPSNBTEFQSPUFTUBUSBEJDJPOBMFT°IVFMHBTZNPWJMJ [BDJPOFT°ZMBQPTUFSJPSJOUSPEVDDJwOEFOVFWBTGPSNBTDPOMB$BSQB #MBODBIJDJFSPOEFFTUFVOUFNBDFOUSBM&OSFTQVFTUBMPTDBOBMFT EFOFHPDJBDJwOBCJFSUPTQPSFMHPCJFSOPQBSFDFODPO¾HVSBSVOOVFWP FTQBDJPEFQBSUJDJQBDJwOBDUVBMNFOUFFODPOTUSVDDJwO&TQBDJPRVF IBTUBFMNPNFOUPDVFOUBDPOEFUFSNJOBEBTDBSBDUFSrTUJDBT$5&3" FTVOBEFMBTPSHBOJ[BDJPOFTRVFNgT²IBDFVTP³EFEJDIPT²DBOB MFT³QFSPZBMNJTNPUJFNQPNVDIBTPUSBTPSHBOJ[BDJPOFTTPDJBMFT OPTPO²JOWJUBEBT³PSFDIB[BOEFMMFOPFTUPTFTQBDJPTNBOUFOJnO EPTF FO QPTJDJPOFT EF SFTJTUFODJB Z PQPTJDJwO 3FTVMUB JNQPSUBOUF EFTUBDBSMPQBSBOPSFTUSJOHJSMBWJTJwOBVOBTPMBGPSNBEFQBSUJDJQB DJwOZQPEFSTFvBMBSRVFBDUVBMNFOUFDPOWJWFOWBSJBTEFFMMBTFOVO NJTNPFTDFOBSJP &OEF¾OJUJWBMB-FZEF'JOBODJBNJFOUP°BVORVFDPODBNCJPTJN QPSUBOUFT°DPOUFNQMBVOSFDMBNPQPSFMRVFMPTHSFNJPTEPDFOUFT °ZQSJODJQBMNFOUF$5&3"°WJFOFOMVDIBOEPIBDFNVDIPTBvPT-BT QSPUFTUBT NPWJMJ[BDJPOFT Z OFHPDJBDJPOFT DVMNJOBO FO FM EJTFvP Z QPTUFSJPSTBODJwOEFMBMFZZBTVWF[BCSFOPUSPQSPDFTP°RVFFTUg DPNFO[BOEP°WJODVMBEPBMBBQMJDBDJwOZEFTBSSPMMPEFFTUBQPMrUJDB Q|CMJDB &OSFMBDJwODPOFTUFQSPDFTPRVF²TFBCSF³NFODJPOgCBNPTFOFMQVOUP***²FOBCSJM EFMDPSSJFOUFBvPQPS3FTPMVDJwOEFM$POTFKP'FEFSBMEF$VMUVSBTFSFTPMWJwMBDSFBDJwOEF VOBDPNJTJwOFOMBRVFFM.JOJTUFSJPFM$POTFKP'FEFSBMZMPTHSFNJPTEPDFOUFTBDPSEBSgOVO DPOWFOJPNBSDPTPCSFMBTDPOEJDJPOFTMBCPSBMFTDBMFOEBSJPFEVDBUJWPTBMBSJPNrOJNPEPDFOUF 1BSUJDJQBDJwOFJODJEFODJBEFMBTPDJFEBEDJWJMFMDBTPBSHFOUJOP 4VEFTBSSPMMPFOUSFPUSBTDPTBTQFSNJUJSgFWBMVBSTJMBBQFSUVSB FTUBUBMFOFTUBTZPUSBTJOTUBODJBTQSPEVDFVODBNCJP°PBMNFOPT VOBHSJFUB°PTJUBOTwMPTFUSBUBEFNFDBOJTNPTMJHBEPTBMBMFHJUJ NBDJwOEFMBTQPMrUJDBTHVCFSOBNFOUBMFT -BMFZEF¾OBODJBNJFOUPJODMVZFQVOUPTTJHOJ¾DBUJWPTQBSBFMTFD UPSFEVDBUJWPQFSPFODVFOUSBTVTMJNJUBDJPOFTTJOPFTEFTBSSPMMBEB FOFMNBSDPEFQPMrUJDBTQ|CMJDBTRVFSFEJTUSJCVZBOFMJOHSFTP ZDBSSFSBEPDFOUFTFH|OMPRVFFTUBCMFDFFM"SUEFMB-FZEF'JOBODJBNJFOUP&EVDBUJWP³ 3FTPMVDJwO / $POTFKP 'FEFSBM EF $VMUVSB Z &EVDBDJwO .JOJTUFSJP EF &EVDBDJwO $JFODJBZ5FDOPMPHrB "OB1BHBOP*OHSJE4WFSEMJDLZ1BVMB$PTUBT 5&/%&/$*"4(&/&3"-&4 "(&/%"4:5&."413*03*5"3*04 &MFTDFOBSJPEFNBZPSFTUBCJMJEBEJOTUJUVDJPOBMZFMSFQVOUFEFBM HVOPTJOEJDBEPSFTTPDJBMFTZFDPOwNJDPTHFOFSBODPOEJDJPOFTQBSB QSPNPWFSOVFWPTPCKFUJWPTFOMBTMVDIBTTPDJBMFTZQBSBEJTQPOFSEF PUSPNPEPEFMPTDBOBMFTEFQBSUJDJQBDJwORVFPGSFDFOMBTQPMrUJDBT Q|CMJDBTBDUVBMFT &OFTUFNBSDPQPEFNPTEFDJSRVFFMFTDFOBSJPEFQBSUJDJQBDJwO BDUVBMSFTVMUBDPNQMFKPZDPOEJWFSTBTDBSBDUFSrTUJDBT » 1PSVOMBEPTFSFHJTUSBVOBEJTNJOVDJwOEFMBDPO¿JDUJWJEBEEP DFOUF SFTQFDUP EF MB QMBOUFBEB EVSBOUF MB EnDBEB EFM Z FO MPTQSJNFSPTBvPTEFMBBDUVBMFOEPOEFMBDSJTJTEFMBCSrB OVFWPTFTQBDJPTEFQBSUJDJQBDJwOFOGPSNBEFQSPUFTUBT » 4JOFNCBSHPMPTSFHJTUSPTEFM0-1&EEFNVFTUSBORVFMPTDPO¿JD UPTEPDFOUFTBOJWFMQSPWJODJBMDSFDJFSPOFOUSFFMZFM BVORVFDPOJNQPSUBOUFBVTFODJBEFSFDMBNPTOBDJPOBMFT » "TVWF[TFSFHJTUSBMBUFOEFODJBEFBMHVOPTBDUPSFTBQBSUJDJQBS EFMPTDBOBMFTEFEJgMPHPQSPQVFTUPTQPSMBTQPMrUJDBTQ|CMJDBT P¾DJBMFT&MEJgMPHPMBDPOTVMUBMPTEFCBUFTMBTFODVFTUBTTPO BMHVOPTEFMPTNFDBOJTNPTVUJMJ[BEPTQPSMBTQPMrUJDBTQ|CMJDBT HVCFSOBNFOUBMFTQBSBMPHSBSMBFYQSFTJwOEFEJGFSFOUFTPSHBOJ [BDJPOFT SFTQFDUP EF UFNBT FTQFDr¾DPT Z BNQMJBS MBT CBTFT EF MFHJUJNJEBE EF TVT QSPQVFTUBT -PT TJOEJDBUPT EPDFOUFT TPCSF UPEPMPTBHSVQBEPTFOMB$5&3"BEWJFSUFOFOMBTBODJwOEFMBT 1BSUJDJQBDJwOFJODJEFODJBEFMBTPDJFEBEDJWJMFMDBTPBSHFOUJOP -FZFTRVFEFTDSJCJNPTMBDPODSFDJwOEFQBSUFEFTVTSFDMBNPT EFMPT|MUJNPTBvPTZBMBWF[QPTFFOFYQFDUBUJWBTSFTQFDUPEF TVT FGFDUPT 5BNCJnO KVOUP DPO BMHVOBT PSHBOJ[BDJPOFT EF MB TPDJFEBEDJWJMZBMHVOPTNPWJNJFOUPTTPDJBMFTIBDFOVTPEFMPT DBOBMFTEFQBSUJDJQBDJwOQSPQVFTUPTQPSFMHPCJFSOPZFOFTUBT MFZFTTBODJPOBEBT » %FTEFPUSBTQFSTQFDUJWBTFTUVEJBOUFTPSHBOJ[BDJPOFTTPDJBMFT EPDFOUFTVOJWFSTJUBSJPTDSJUJDBOMBTMJNJUBDJPOFTEFMBQBSUJDJQB DJwOEJTFvBEBQPSFMHPCJFSOPMBTCBTFTTPDJBMFTEFMPTDPOTFOTPT BMDBO[BEPTMBBNCJHFEBEEFMBTQSPQVFTUBTZMBTPSJFOUBDJPOFT HFOFSBMFTEFMBTQPMrUJDBTQSPQVFTUBTZEFTBSSPMMBEBT 1PEFNPTEFDJSFOUPODFTRVFFOMBBDUVBMJEBETFQSFTFOUBVOB TFSJFEJWFSTBEFGPSNBTEFQBSUJDJQBDJwORVFDPOWJWFOFOFMNJTNP FTDFOBSJPZBOPTwMPTJHOBEBTQPSQSPUFTUBTZNPWJMJ[BDJPOFTTJOP UBNCJnOQPSFTQBDJPTEFOFHPDJBDJwOZEJgMPHPDPOFM&TUBEP 4J SFUPNBNPT OVFTUSB JEFB EF SFWJTBS MPT DPODFQUPT EF QBSUJDJ QBDJwOZEFTPDJFEBEDJWJMTFUSBUBEFTEFOVFTUSBQFSTQFDUJWBEF NFKPSBSZSFQMBOUFBSMPTSFDPSSJEPTRVFGVJNPTNFODJPOBOEP-BWJUB MJEBEZFMEJOBNJTNPRVFFYIJCFOMBTQSPUFTUBTTPDJBMFTBMBIPSBEF QMBOUFBSSFDMBNPTIBDJBFM&TUBEPZMBTSFTQVFTUBTRVFTFTVDFEFOB FTUBTEFNBOEBTOPQPTFFOVODPSSFMBUPDPOMBQBSUJDJQBDJwOEFTQMF HBEBBUSBWnTEFMPTNFDBOJTNPTGPSNBMFTRVFQPTFFOMBTQPMrUJDBT Q|CMJDBTQBSBSFDPHFSFJODPSQPSBSMPTBQPSUFTEFMBTPSHBOJ[BDJPOFT EFMBTPDJFEBEDJWJM-BBVTFODJBEFUSBEJDJwOZEFFYQFSJFODJBFOFM VTPEFFTUPTNFDBOJTNPTEFNPDSgUJDPTZVOUJQPEFEFNPDSBDJBRVF TVFMFDPODFOUSBSTVTEFDJTJPOFTFOFM1PEFS&KFDVUJWPMFSFTUBOQP UFODJBBUBMFTQSPDFTPT&OUPODFTFTOFDFTBSJPBDPNQBvBSMBBDDJwO DPMFDUJWBDPOMBSFDSFBDJwOEFFTUPTFTQBDJPTGPSNBMFT5FOTBSQBSB RVFOVNFSPTPTHSVQPTZPSHBOJ[BDJPOFT°UBOUPMPTJOWPMVDSBEPTFO ²DBNQBvBT³P²NPWJNJFOUPT³BEIPDDPNPBRVFMMPTRVFOPMPFTUgO° TFJOWPMVDSFOFOVOUJQPEFQBSUJDJQBDJwOEFNBZPSJOUFOTJEBEBCSBO ZPSFDSFFOFTUPTgNCJUPTEFEJTQVUBQBSBSFQFOTBSMBTBHFOEBTHV CFSOBNFOUBMFTZQSPCMFNBUJ[BSBMHVOPTEFMPTTVQVFTUPTBUSBWnTEF MPTDVBMFTTFJNQVMTBOMPTBDUVBMFTDBNCJPTFOFEVDBDJwO "OB1BHBOP*OHSJE4WFSEMJDLZ1BVMB$PTUBT -PTDBOBMFTEFEJgMPHPBCJFSUPTQPSFMHPCJFSOP°BVORVFJOTV¾ DJFOUFT°IBOHFOFSBEPVOQSPDFTPEFSFQPTJDJPOBNJFOUPQPMrUJDPFO FMDBNQPEFMBTPSHBOJ[BDJPOFTTPDJBMFT4FIBOEFTBSSPMMBEPBRVrMPT QSPDFTPTFOMPTRVFQBSUJDJQBSPOMPTTJOEJDBUPTEPDFOUFTDPONPUJWP EFMBTBODJwOEFMBTMFZFTUSBUBEBT1FSPUBNCJnODBCFNFODJPOBSFM DBTP EF BRVFMMPT NPWJNJFOUPT TPDJBMFT RVF TPO ²JOWJUBEPT³ QPS FM HPCJFSOPBMBJNQMFNFOUBDJwOEFEFUFSNJOBEPTQSPHSBNBTZQSPZFD UPT-PRVFSFTVMUBOPWFEPTPFJOUFSFTBOUFBUFOFSFODVFOUBFTRVF FOHFOFSBMMPTNPWJNJFOUPTTPDJBMFTTPOSFDPOPDJEPTZSFDPSEBEPT QPSTVTGPSNBTEFBDDJwOWJODVMBEBTBMBQSPUFTUBKVTUBNFOUFQPSOP QPTFFSPUSPTDBOBMFTEFBDDJwORVFMFTQFSNJUBOBDDFEFSBRVJFOFT QSPEVDFOMBTEFDJTJPOFT&OFTUFDBTPMPTDBOBMFTVUJMJ[BEPTFTUgO TJFOEPTJTFRVJFSF²BUrQJDPT³QBSBFTUFUJQPEFDPMFDUJWPTPDJBMMP DVBMMMFWBBVOQSPDFTPJOUFSOPEFSFEF¾OJDJwOQPMrUJDB 3FTVMUB VO EFTBGrP °TPCSF UPEP QBSB BRVFMMBT PSHBOJ[BDJPOFT RVF DPOTJEFSBOBFTUFNPNFOUPVOBPQPSUVOJEBEEFJODJEJSEFPUSBNBOFSB FOMBTQPMrUJDBTQ|CMJDBT°BUSBWFTBSFMQSPDFTPRVFJNQMJDBTBMJSEFVOB QPTUVSBEFSFTJTUFODJBZQPTJDJPOBSTFFOVOMVHBSEFQSPQPTJDJwOJOUFO UBOEPBMBWF[TPTUFOFSVOQSPDFTPEFNPDSgUJDPBMJOUFSJPSEFTVTPSHB OJ[BDJPOFT1SPDFTPFOFMRVFTFQVFEBDPOTUSVJSBOBMJ[BSZQSPZFDUBS TPCSFMBQPMrUJDBOBDJPOBMEFNBOFSBDPMFDUJWBZBMBWF[FODPOUSBSMBT FTUSBUFHJBTQPMrUJDBTRVFQFSNJUBOOFHPDJBSDPOFM&TUBEP : OP UBOTwMPFOFMQMBOPEFMBFEVDBDJwO -B FGFDUJWJ[BDJwO EFM EFSFDIPBMBFEVDBDJwOSFRVJFSFHBSBOUJ[BSPUSPTFMFNFOUPTEFMPT EFSFDIPT TPDJBMFT TBMVE BMJNFOUBDJwO WJWJFOEB &O FTUF TFOUJEP QSPCBCMFNFOUFTFBOFDFTBSJPQSFTUBSNBZPSBUFODJwOBBRVFMMBTNP WJMJ[BDJPOFTTPDJBMFTRVFJOUSPEVDFOFMEFSFDIPBMBFEVDBDJwOFOVO NBSDPEFMVDIBTNgTJOUFHSBMFT4FUSBUBDPNPZBNFODJPOBNPTEF JOUSPEVDJS²FMFMFNFOUPDMBWFEFMPQ|CMJDPFMRVFSFQSFTFOUBMBEF NPDSBUJ[BDJwOSBEJDBMEFM&TUBEP<©>EFSFEF¾OJSMBOPDJwOEFQPMrUJDB JNQSJNJnOEPMFVODBSgDUFSQ|CMJDPUPSOgOEPMBVOFTQBDJPEFBDVNV MBDJwOEFGVFS[BTTPDJBMFTDVMUVSBMFTZEJSFDUBNFOUFQPMrUJDBTRVF CSBOEPMBEVBMJEBE&TUBEPTPDJFEBEDJWJMRVFQFSUFOFDFBMVOJWFSTP MJCFSBMZDIPDBEJSFDUBNFOUFDPOMBTPDJBMJ[BDJwOEFMBQPMrUJDBZEFM QPEFSPCKFUJWPTGVOEBNFOUBMFTEFMBMVDIBQPSMBFNBODJQBDJwOEF MPTIPNCSFT³4BEFS 1BSUJDJQBDJwOFJODJEFODJBEFMBTPDJFEBEDJWJMFMDBTPBSHFOUJOP "OB1BHBOP*OHSJE4WFSEMJDLZ1BVMB$PTUBT 4Ê/5&4*4*/5&313&5"5*7"%&-&456%*0 -PTQSPDFTPTFTUVEJBEPTBOBMJ[BOMPTSFDPSSJEPTDPMFDUJWPTEFTB SSPMMBEPTQPSMBTPDJFEBEDJWJMQBSBJODJEJSFOFMDBNQPEFMBTQPMrUJDBT Q|CMJDBTFOFEVDBDJwOFOFMNBSDPEFSFHrNFOFTEFNPDSgUJDPTEF BMDBODFSFTUSJOHJEP3FTVMUBFWJEFOUFRVFBMHVOPTEFMPTMPHSPTFO NBUFSJBEFQPMrUJDBFEVDBUJWBRVFFYIJCFMBBDUVBMHFTUJwONBOUJFOFO VOWrODVMPFTUSFDIPDPOMBBMUBDPO¿JDUJWJEBETPDJBMDPOMPTQSPDFTPT EFMVDIBEFMBDPNVOJEBEFEVDBUJWBQPSQSPCMFNBTEF¾OBODJBNJFO UPZQPSUPSDFSMBTEJSFDDJPOFTQPMrUJDBTEFMDBNQPFEVDBUJWP "TVWF[MPTQSPDFTPTFTUVEJBEPTQFSNJUFOPCTFSWBSRVFMBTEJ WFSTBTGPSNBTEFQBSUJDJQBDJwORVFDPNQPOFOFMFTDFOBSJPBDUVBM QPOFO FO FM DFOUSP EFM BOgMJTJT EPT QSPCMFNgUJDBT QPS VO MBEP MB QSFPDVQBDJwO QPS FM QBQFM RVF PDVQBO MBT PSHBOJ[BDJPOFT FO SFMB DJwO DPO FM &TUBEP Z PUSPT BDUPSFT TPDJBMFT QPOJnOEPTF FO KVFHP DVFTUJPOFTWJODVMBEBTBMBBVUPOPNrBMBDPPQUBDJwOMBQPTJCJMJEBE EF DPOTUSVJS DPOUSBIFHFNPOrB FUD 1PS PUSP MBEP MB QSFPDVQBDJwO BMJOUFSJPSEFMBTPSHBOJ[BDJPOFTEFMBTPDJFEBEDJWJMFOSFMBDJwODPO MBDBMJEBEEFMBQBSUJDJQBDJwOTJFOEPMBTOFHPDJBDJPOFTJOUFSWFODJP OFTNBOJGFTUBDJPOFTZQPTJDJPOBNJFOUPTDPOTUJUVZFOUFTZIBDFEP SFTEFMBNJTNBFOVODPOUFYUPRVFQPOFFOEJTDVTJwOFMCJOPNJP ²SFTJTUFODJBPQPTJDJwO³WT²QSPQPTJDJwOOFHPDJBDJwO³ &OFTUFNBSDPMPTDBOBMFTBCJFSUPTFOMBBDUVBMJEBEQPSMBTQPMrUJ DBTFEVDBUJWBTP¾DJBMFTQBSBFMEJgMPHPZMBDPOTVMUBDPOMBTPDJFEBE 1BSUJDJQBDJwOFJODJEFODJBEFMBTPDJFEBEDJWJMFMDBTPBSHFOUJOP SFTVMUBOQPTJUJWPTBMBIPSBEFBOBMJ[BSMPTQSPDFTPTEFQBSUJDJQBDJwO EFMBTPSHBOJ[BDJPOFTEFMBTPDJFEBEDJWJM&OFTUFTFOUJEPDSFFNPT RVFFTOFDFTBSJPBNQMJBSEJDIBQBSUJDJQBDJwO4FUSBUBEFJODPSQPSBS BPUSPTBDUPSFTTPDJBMFTRVFKVOUPDPOMPTRVFZBWJFOFOQBSUJDJQBO EPQVFEBOEFTBSSPMMBSQSPEVDDJPOFTQPMrUJDBTZDPODFQUVBMFTDPMFD UJWBTRVFBNQMrFOMBTCBTFTEFMPTDPOTFOTPTBMDBO[BEPTUSBEV[DBO FOBSSFHMPTJOTUJUVDJPOBMFTTVTEFNBOEBTZQSPQPOHBOZSFDSFFOMBT BHFOEBTTPCSFMPTQSJODJQBMFTQSPCMFNBTEFMTJTUFNBFEVDBUJWP 4JOFNCBSHPDPNPZBNFODJPOBNPTMBWJUBMJEBEZFMEJOBNJTNP EFMBTPSHBOJ[BDJPOFTTPDJBMFTTFNBOJ¾FTUBQSJODJQBMNFOUFFOEJ GFSFOUFTUJQPTEFQSPUFTUBTPDJBMRVFQPSMPSFHVMBSFYQSFTBOVOB WPMVOUBEEFJODJEJSFOMPTSVNCPTEFMBTQPMrUJDBTQ|CMJDBT4JDPNQB SBNPTQPEFNPTPCTFSWBSRVFFTUBTQSgDUJDBTQPMrUJDBTOPQPTFFO VODPSSFMBUPFODVBOUPBTVOJWFMFJOUFOTJEBESFTQFDUPEFMUJQPQBS UJDJQBDJwO FO MPT NFDBOJTNPT GPSNBMFT RVF EFUFOUBO MBT QPMrUJDBT Q|CMJDBT QBSB SFDPHFS F JODPSQPSBS MPT BQPSUFT EF MBT PSHBOJ[BDJP OFT EF MB TPDJFEBE DJWJM :B EJKJNPT RVF MB BVTFODJB EF USBEJDJwO Z EFFYQFSJFODJBFOFMVTPEFFTUPTNFDBOJTNPTRVFQPTFFOOVFTUSBT EFNPDSBDJBTTVNBEPBVOUJQPEFSnHJNFOJOTUJUVDJPOBMRVFTVFMF DPODFOUSBSTVTEFDJTJPOFTFOFM1PEFS&KFDVUJWPMFSFTUBOQPUFODJBB FTUPTQSPDFTPT&OUPODFTFTOFDFTBSJPBDPNQBvBSBMBBDDJwODPMFD UJWBDPOMBSFDSFBDJwOEFFTUPTFTQBDJPTGPSNBMFT "MIBCFSIFDIPFKFFOMPTQSPDFTPTEFTBODJwOEFMBTUSFTMFZFT NFODJPOBEBTDBCFVOBSF¿FYJwOSFTQFDUPEFMBQBSUJDJQBDJwOWJODV MBEBBM1PEFS-FHJTMBUJWPJOTUBODJBRVFDPNPwSHBOPHVCFSOBNFO UBMDPOTUJUVZFFOTrNJTNBVOFTQBDJPEFQBSUJDJQBDJwOZFKFSDJDJPEF MBEFNPDSBDJB -B EFNPDSBDJB SFQVCMJDBOB TVQPOF MB EJWJTJwO EF QPEFSFT &KFDVUJWP-FHJTMBUJWPZ+VEJDJBM RVFDPNPMPTwSHBOPTQSJODJQBMFT EFHPCJFSOPFRVJMJCSBOMBCBMBO[BFOMPTQSPDFTPTQPMrUJDPTZFOMB UPNBEFEFDJTJPOFT&OMB"SHFOUJOBEFMPT|MUJNPTBvPTZTPCSFUPEP MVFHPEFMBDSJTJTEFMBTJOTUJUVDJPOFTQPMrUJDBTIBOQFSEJEPDSF EJCJMJEBE EF NBOFSB DSFDJFOUF &O QBSUJDVMBS FM 1PEFS -FHJTMBUJWP SFQSFTFOUBEPFOFM$POHSFTP/BDJPOBMTFFODVFOUSBCBTUBOUFEFWB MVBEPDPNPJOTUBODJBEFEFMJCFSBDJwOZSFQSFTFOUBDJwOEFMPTJOUFSF TFTEFMQVFCMPZMBTQSPWJODJBT "OB1BHBOP*OHSJE4WFSEMJDLZ1BVMB$PTUBT &TUPTFEFCFFOQBSUFBVOFKFSDJDJPEFMBEFNPDSBDJBSFQSFTFOUB UJWBRVFFOFMNBSDPEFMBTTPDJFEBEFTDBQJUBMJTUBTUSBTMBEBMBDPN QFUFODJBEFNFSDBEPBMgNCJUPEFMPQPMrUJDPTJFOEPMBPCUFODJwOEF WPUPTFM¾OEFM²WrODVMP³DPOMBDJVEBEBOrBZFMJOJDJPEFVOQSPDFTPFO FMRVFMBTEFDJTJPOFTQPMrUJDBTSFTVMUBOBKFOBTBMPTJOUFSFTFTEFM²QVF CMP³RVJUBOEPDSFEJCJMJEBEBMBTJOTUJUVDJPOFTQPMrUJDBTEFM&TUBEP 1PSPUSBQBSUFZFOTFHVOEPMVHBSSFTVMUBOPUBCMFRVFFOFMDBTP EFMBBDUVBMHFTUJwOEFHPCJFSOPMBT²JOWJUBDJPOFT³BBMHVOPTTFDUP SFTEFMBTPDJFEBEDJWJMBQBSUJDJQBSEFDJFSUBTJOTUBODJBTEFOFHPDJB DJwOTFBODVSTBEBTEFTEFFM1PEFS&KFDVUJWPZOPEFTEFFM-FHJTMBUJWP )FNPTSFHJTUSBEPZNFODJPOBEPBMHVOPTJOUFSDBNCJPTZSFVOJPOFTFO MBTRVFFTUF|MUJNPFOFMNBSDPEFDPNJTJPOFTQBSMBNFOUBSJBTPCMP RVFTQBSUJEBSJPTIBMMFWBEPBDBCPJOUFSDBNCJPTDPOEJWFSTPTTFDUPSFT EFMBTPDJFEBEDJWJM4JOFNCBSHPFTUPOPQBSFDFIBCFSUFOJEPNBZPS SFMFWBODJBFOSFMBDJwODPOMBNPEJ¾DBDJwOEFMPTQSPZFDUPTEFMFZ %FBMHVOBNBOFSBEJGFSFOUFTTFDUPSFTTPDJBMFTWJFOFOSFDMBNBO EPFOMPT|MUJNPTBvPTVOBSFGPSNBQPMrUJDBQSPGVOEBZMBFMBCPSB DJwOEFVOBBHFOEBQPTOFPMJCFSBM&OCVFOBNFEJEBMPTFTQBDJPTEF EJTDVTJwOEFDPOTVMUBZEFQSPQPTJDJwOTPCSFUFNBTSFMFWBOUFTEFM TJTUFNBFEVDBUJWPDPOTUJUVZFOVOBJOTUBODJBQSJWJMFHJBEBQBSBRVF FMTFOUJEPEFMBQSgDUJDBQPMrUJDBTFUSBEV[DBFOMBC|TRVFEBDPMFDUJ WBEFIFSSBNJFOUBTEFUSBOTGPSNBDJwOTPDJBM1SPCBCMFNFOUFFTUPT FTQBDJPTQVFEBOBCSJSIVFMMBTQBSBTFOUBSMBTCBTFTEFOVFWPTTJTUF NBTEFNPDSgUJDPTRVFBNQMrFOMBTPCFSBOrBDJVEBEBOBMPTQSPDFTPT EFEJTQVUBEFMDBQJUBMDVMUVSBMFJNQVMTFOMBQPMJUJ[BDJwOZTPDJBMJ[B DJwOEFMFTQBDJPQ|CMJDP &O FTUB MrOFB FM BOgMJTJT EF MPT QSPDFTPT EF QBSUJDJQBDJwO EF MB TPDJFEBEDJWJMDPOTUJUVZFVOBPDBTJwOQSPQJDJBQBSBSFWJTBSZQSPQP OFSOVFWBTGPSNBTEFSFQSFTFOUBDJwOQPMrUJDBRVFBSUJDVMFOMBEFNP DSBDJBEJSFDUBZQBSUJDJQBUJWBFOTBZBEBQPSBMHVOPTNPWJNJFOUPTZ PSHBOJ[BDJPOFT TPDJBMFT DPO MB EFNPDSBDJB SFQSFTFOUBUJWB WJHFOUF FO MPT NBSDPT QPMrUJDPJOTUJUVDJPOBMFT EF OVFTUSP QBrT 4F USBUB EF BOFYBSBMPTNPEPTEFSFQSFTFOUBDJwOZBFYJTUFOUFTOVFWBTGPSNBT ZDPOUFOJEPTTPCSFFMQSPCMFNBEFMBQBSUJDJQBDJwORVFP¾DJFODPNP DPOUSBQFTPEFMPTTVDFTJWPTWBDJBNJFOUPTRVFUVWJFSPOMBTEFNPDSB DJBTFOFMNBSDPEFMBIFHFNPOrBOFPMJCFSBM 1BSUJDJQBDJwOFJODJEFODJBEFMBTPDJFEBEDJWJMFMDBTPBSHFOUJOP "TJNJTNPQBSBFOTBODIBSMPTQSPDFTPTEFNPDSgUJDPTFTOFDFTB SJPQSPNPWFSFMGVODJPOBNJFOUPEFDPOUSPMFTDJVEBEBOPTEJSJHJEPTB FTUSFDIBSBRVFMMPTNgSHFOFTRVFIBCJMJUBOMBDPODFOUSBDJwOEFQP EFSEFMBTFMJUFTQPMrUJDBTZUBNCJnOBNPEJ¾DBSFMQFTPJOTUJUVDJPOBM ZDVMUVSBMEFMPTFTUJMPTEFHPCJFSOPRVFDFOUSBMJ[BOMBTEFDJTJPOFTFO NBOPTEFVOMrEFSZPVOHSVQPSFEVDJEPEFEJSJHFOUFT "IPSBCJFOFTUPTSFDPSSJEPTQBSUJDJQBUJWPTTFEFTBSSPMMBOFOVO NBSDP EPOEF MPT QSPDFTPT EF EFTJHVBMEBE JNQBDUBSPO FO FM QPEFS QPMrUJDPZTPDJBMEFEJGFSFOUFTTFDUPSFTTPDJBMFT&OTJOUPOrBDPOFTUB TJUVBDJwO OPT IBMMBNPT GSFOUF PSHBOJ[BDJPOFT TPDJBMFT RVF QPTFFO SFDVSTPTNVZEFTJHVBMFTZDVZPTBDUPSFTTFIBMMBOBUSBWFTBEPTQPS OJWFMFTEFGSBHNFOUBDJwOZEFJOFTUBCJMJEBETJHOJ¾DBUJWBT1PSFTP DSFFNPTRVFQBSBRVFFTUBEFTJHVBMEBEFTUSVDUVSBMOPP¾DJFDPNP VOFMFNFOUPEFUFSNJOBOUFEFMPTQSPDFTPTQBSUJDJQBUJWPTFTOFDFTB SJPGPSUBMFDFSBMPTBDUPSFTQFSUFOFDJFOUFTBMPTTFDUPSFTQPQVMBSFT ZBTVTPSHBOJ[BDJPOFT"TrTFUSBUBEFDPOUSJCVJSBVOBEJTUSJCVDJwO EJGFSFOUFEFMBTDVPUBTEFMQPEFSFOMBTPDJFEBEDPOMB¾OBMJEBEEF BDIJDBSMBCSFDIBFOUSFMBTEFTJHVBMFTQPTJDJPOFTRVFEFUFOUBOMPT EJGFSFOUFT TFDUPSFT TPDJBMFT Z QSPNPWFS VOB QVKB NFOPT BTJNnUSJ DBFOUSFMBTFMJUFTMPTHSVQPTDPODFOUSBEPTEFQPEFSZMPTTFDUPSFT TVCBMUFSOPT 3FTVMUBFWJEFOUFRVFFMEFTQMJFHVFEFFTUBTQSgDUJDBTTPDJPQPMr UJDBTEFCFUFOFSFODVFOUBRVFFTOFDFTBSJPQVKBSQPSMBSFDPOTUSVD DJwOEFM&TUBEPFOMBMrOFBEFSFWJTBSZSFQMBOUFBSMPTJOUFSFTFTBMPT RVFSFTQPOEFZMBTPSJFOUBDJPOFTQPMrUJDBTRVFQSJWJMFHJB 1PS |MUJNP FT OFDFTBSJP EFTUBDBS RVF MB BHVEB TJUVBDJwO TP DJPFDPOwNJDBEFWBTUPTTFDUPSFTTPDJBMFTSFRVJFSFEFUSBUBNJFOUPT JOUFHSBMFTRVFQFSNJUBOOPTwMPBUFOEFSMBFGFDUJWJ[BDJwOEFMEFSFDIP BMBFEVDBDJwOTJOPUBNCJnOEFBRVFMMPTPUSPTEFSFDIPTBMBBMJNFO UBDJwOBMBTBMVEBMBWJWJFOEB4FUSBUBEFHBSBOUJ[BSMBTDPOEJDJP OFTJOEJTQFOTBCMFTQBSBRVFUPEBMBOJvF[ZMBBEPMFTDFODJBQVFEBO BDDFEFSBMBFEVDBDJwOZMBDVMUVSB&OFTUFTFOUJEPDBNQBvBTDPNP MBTEFM'SFOBQPMBEF$IJDPTEFM1VFCMPPMBTEFNBOEBTEFBMHVOPT NPWJNJFOUPTEFUSBCBKBEPSFTEFTPDVQBEPTTPOFKFNQMPTEFBDDJP OFTDPMFDUJWBTRVFSFDMBNBOQPSMBBQMJDBDJwOEFEJGFSFOUFTEFSFDIPT RVFQFSNJUBOHBSBOUJ[BSVOBWJEBEJHOBQBSBUPEPTZUPEBT "OB1BHBOP*OHSJE4WFSEMJDLZ1BVMB$PTUBT "/&90 1SPHSBNBTQSPZFDUPTBDDJPOFTFJOUFSWFODJPOFT EFMBBDUVBMHFTUJwOEFHPCJFSOP .gTFEVDBDJwOQBSBUPEPT » 1SPHSBNB/BDJPOBMEF#FDBTFTUVEJBOUJMFTCFDBTEFT UJOBEBTBKwWFOFTEFBBvPTRVFFTUnODVSTBOEPFMOJWFMF NFEJPZTFFODVFOUSFOFOSJFTHPEFBCBOEPOBSTVTFTUVEJPT » $JDMPMFDUJWPEFErBTEFDMBTF » -JCSFUBFTDPMBSTFHVJNJFOUPEFMBUSBZFDUPSJBFTDPMBSZEFTBMVE EFMPTBMVNOPTFODPOKVOUPDPOFMNJOJTUFSJPEFTBMVE » 1SPHSBNBUPEPTBFTUVEJBS BQBSBSFJOTFSUBSKwWFOFTFOFMOJWFMNFEJP C$BQBDJUBDJwOZTVCTJEJPTQBSBQSPGFTPSFTZSFGFSFOUFTDPNVOJ UBSJPTEFQSPZFDUPTMPDBMFTEFJODMVTJwOFTDPMBS » 1SPHSBNBBQSFOEFSFOTFvBOEPFTUVEJBOUFTEFMPT|MUJNPTBvPT EFM .FEJP Z EF JOTUJUVUPT EF GPSNBDJwO EPDFOUF BDPNQBvBO B BMVNOPT EF DJDMPT BOUFSJPSFT B BQSFOEFS Z QFSNBOFDFS FO MB FTDVFMB » $FOUSPTEFBDUJWJEBEFTKVWFOJMFT$"+ DFOUSPTDPOBDUJWJEB EFTEFQPSUJWBTDVMUVSBMFTZSFDSFBUJWBTQBSBKwWFOFT » $POTUBODJBEFFTDPMBSJEBEQBSBMPTIJKPTEF²+FGBTZ+FGFTEFIP HBS³PCMJHBUPSJBQBSBSFOPWBSMPTQMBOFTEFTVTQBESFT » 1SPHSBNBEFFEVDBDJwOFOFTUBCMFDJNJFOUPTQFOJUFODJBSJPTDBQB DJUBDJwOEPDFOUFZQSPWJTJwOEFNBUFSJBMFT &TUB JOGPSNBDJwO GVF FYUSBrEB EF .JOJTUFSJP EF &EVDBDJwO $JFODJB Z 5FDOPMPHrB 6OQSPZFDUPFEVDBUJWPQBSBMBJOUFHSBDJwOMBJHVBMEBEZFMEFTBSSPMMP0CKFUJWPTEFMB HFTUJwOFEVDBUJWB1MBOEF"DDJwO 1BSUJDJQBDJwOFJODJEFODJBEFMBTPDJFEBEDJWJMFMDBTPBSHFOUJOP .FKPSDBMJEBEFEVDBUJWB » $PODFSUBDJwO OBDJPOBM BDFSDB EF OJWFMFT EF BQSFOEJ[BKF QSJPSJUBSJPT » .FKPSBNJFOUPEFMBDBMJEBEQFEBHwHJDBFOMBFTDVFMBNFEJB B 'JOBODJBDJwO EF QSPZFDUPT EF NFKPSBNJFOUP EF MB FTDVFMB NFEJB C"SUJDVMBDJwOFOUSFMBFTDVFMBNFEJBZMBVOJWFSTJEBE D/|DMFPTEFBQSFOEJ[BKFQSJPSJUBSJPTFOFM1PMJNPEBM E5VUPSFTQFEBHwHJDPT F$POTUSVDDJwOEFFTDVFMBTEFOJWFMNFEJPZQPMJNPEBM » 1SPHSBNB 1FEBHwHJDP /BDJPOBM QBSB MB 'PSNBDJwO %PDFOUF .FKPSB EF DPOEJDJPOFT EF *'% QPTHSBEPT Z TFNJOBSJPT QBTBO UrBTZFYQFSJFODJBTEFJOUFSDBNCJPTVCTJEJPTQBSBQSPZFDUPTEF JOWFTUJHBDJwO » 1SPHSBNB&MFHJSMB%PDFODJBCFDBTQBSBKwWFOFTRVFFN QSFOEBOMBUBSFBEFFOTFvBS » &EVDBDJwO FO WBMPSFT EFNPDSgUJDPT GPSUBMFDJNJFOUP EF QSPHSB NBTEFFEVDBDJwOTPMJEBSJBDPOWJWFODJBFUD » -JCSPT QBSB UPEPT %JTUSJCVDJwO EF MJCSPT EF UFYUP FO &(# Z 1PMJNPEBM EJTUSJCVDJwO EF MJCSPT EF DVFOUPT FO FTQBDJPT OP USBEJDJPOBMFT » 1MBO EF BMGBCFUJ[BDJwO DJFOUr¾DB *OUFHSBDJwO DJFODJB Z FTDVFMB B USBWnT EF MB QSPNPDJwO EF BDUJWJEBEFT DJFOUr¾DBT MB FMBCP SBDJwO Z EJTUSJCVDJwO EF NBUFSJBMFT Z EFTBSSPMMP EF BDUJWJEBEFT JUJOFSBOUFT » 1MBO/BDJPOBMEF-FDUVSBFTUBCMFDJNJFOUPEFCJCMJPUFDBTFO&(# ZEJTUSJCVDJwOEFMJCSPTQBSBKwWFOFTZBEVMUPTQSPNPDJwOEF MBMFDUVSBFOMPTEPDFOUFT » 1SPHSBNB EF &EVDBDJwO 3VSBM "QPZP FTQFDr¾DP QBSB FTDVFMBT SVSBMFTOJWFMJOJDJBMBM|MUJNPMB&(# » &WBMVBDJwOEFMBDBMJEBEFEVDBUJWBSFBMJ[BDJwOEFPQFSBUJWPTOB DJPOBMFTEFFWBMVBDJwODBEBEPTBvPT » $FOTPOBDJPOBMEPDFOUFSFBMJ[BEPFOFM "OB1BHBOP*OHSJE4WFSEMJDLZ1BVMB$PTUBT )BDJBMBJHVBMEBEFEVDBUJWB » 1SPHSBNB*OUFHSBMQBSBMB*HVBMEBE&EVDBUJWB"QPZPBFTDVFMBT DPONBZPSWVMOFSBCJMJEBETPDJBMFO¾OBODJBNJFOUPEFQSPZFDUPT QFEBHwHJDPTQSPWJTJwOEFDPNQVUBEPSBTFJNQSFTPSBTEJTUSJCV DJwOEFMJCSPTDBQBDJUBDJwOQBSBEPDFOUFTZEJSFDUJWPTBQPSUFT FOCJCMJPUFDBTZFOJOGSBFTUSVDUVSBFTDPMBS » 1MBO/BDJPOBMEF"MGBCFUJ[BDJwOGPSNBDJwOZDBQBDJUBDJwOEFEP DFOUFT QBSB FTUB UBSFB QSPEVDDJwO TFMFDDJwO Z EJTUSJCVDJwO EF NBUFSJBMFT » 1SPHSBNBEF&EVDBDJwODPOUJOVBEF"EVMUPTCFOF¾DJB SJPTEFQMBOFTKFGFTZKFGBTEFIPHBSDPNQMFUBSgOMB&(#Z FMOJWFMNFEJP » 1SPHSBNB/BDJPOBMEFFEVDBDJwO*OUFSDVMUVSBMZ#JMJOHF#FDBTB FTUVEJBOUFTBCPSrHFOFTQVCMJDBDJwOEFMJCSPTQBSBMBEJGVTJwOEF MBJEFOUJEBEEFMBTEJTUJOUBTDPNVOJEBEFTGPSUBMFDJNJFOUPEFMB GPSNBDJwOEFSFDVSTPTIVNBOPT 'PSUBMFDJNJFOUPEFMWrODVMPFOUSFFEVDBDJwOZUSBCBKP » $PODFSUBDJwOQBSBMBTBODJwOEFVOBOVFWBMFZEFFEVDBDJwOUnD OJDPQSPGFTJPOBMRVFTFJNQMFNFOUBEVSBOUFFM-BMFZTF TBODJPOBFOFM » *OTUJUVUP/BDJPOBMEF&EVDBDJwOUFDOPMwHJDB*/&5 1SPHSBNB/BDJPOBMGPSNBSTFQBSBUSBCBKBSDSFBDJwOEFJOT UJUVDJPOFTEFGPSNBDJwOQSPGFTJPOBMWJODVMBEBBTFDUPSFTQSJPSJUBSJPT EFMBFDPOPNrB 1SPHSBNB 'PSNBDJwO QBSB FM USBCBKP Z MB JOUFHSBDJwO TPDJBM GPSNBDJwO QSPGFTJPOBM MBCPSBM Z PDVQBDJPOBM QBSB KwWFOFT Z BEVM UPT EFTPDVQBEPT DPO DBQBDJEBEFT EJGFSFOUFT P EF JOTUJUVUPT QFOJUFODJBSJPT $POTFKP/BDJPOBMEF&EVDBDJwO°5SBCBKP$0/&5 DSFBDJwOEF GPSPTTFDUPSJBMFT 1SPHSBNB'PSNBDJwO5nDOJDB.FEJBZ4VQFSJPSOP6OJWFSTJUBSJB QSPZFDUPTFOFTDVFMBTTPCSFQSgDUJDBTQSPEVDUJWBT 1BSUJDJQBDJwOFJODJEFODJBEFMBTPDJFEBEDJWJMFMDBTPBSHFOUJOP 3FBDUJWBDJwO Z FRVJQBNJFOUP EF FTDVFMBT UnDOJDBT JOWFSTJwO FO FTUBCMFDJNJFOUPT UnDOJDPT EFM QBrT QBSB MB DBQBDJUBDJwO Z FM FRVJQBNJFOUP "NQMJBDJwOZNFKPSBEFMBJOGSBFTUSVDUVSBFTDPMBS » 1MBO/BDJPOBMFTDVFMBTDPOTUSVDDJwOEFFTDVFMBTOVF WBTFOUPEPFMQBrT .FKPSBNJFOUPEFMBTDPOEJDJPOFTEFMUSBCBKPEPDFOUF » 'POEP/BDJPOBMEF*ODFOUJWP%PDFOUF'0/*% SFHVMBSJ[BDJwOEF QBHPTZBVNFOUPEFM » %FTBSSPMMPQSPGFTJPOBMEPDFOUF &TDVFMBJUJOFSBOUFQBSBEPDFOUFT $BQBDJUBDJwOEPDFOUFNVMUJNFEJBM $BQBDJUBDJwOBEJTUBODJB "UFOFPTQFEBHwHJDPT $JDMPTEFDJOFZGPSNBDJwO 5BMMFSFTDPODJFOUr¾DPTBSUJTUBTZQFOTBEPSFT "VNFOUPQSPHSFTJWPEFMQSFTVQVFTUPFEVDBUJWP » BVNFOUPEFMEFMQSFTVQVFTUPQBSBMBFEVDBDJwOSFT QFDUPEFMBvP » TF TBODJPOB MB -FZ EF 'JOBODJBNJFOUP FEVDBUJWP RVF FT UBCMFDF RVF FM QSFTVQVFTUP FEVDBUJWP MMFHBSg BM EFM 1#* EF NBOFSBQSPHSFTJWBFOUSFFMBvPZFM *OOPWBDJwOUFDOPMwHJDBZNFEJPTEFDPNVOJDBDJwOBMTFSWJDJP EFMBFEVDBDJwO » $PNQVUBEPSBTQBSBFTDVFMBT » &EVDBS QPSUBM FEVDBUJWP RVF QSPNPDJPOB MBT OVFWBT UFDOPMP HrBTEFMBJOGPSNBDJwOZMBDPNVOJDBDJwO "OB1BHBOP*OHSJE4WFSEMJDLZ1BVMB$PTUBT » 1SPHSBNBFTDVFMBZNFEJPT$PODVSTPTZQSPZFDUPT » 1VFOUFTBS FTUBCMFDJNJFOUP EF TFSWJDJP EF JOUFSOFU FO MBT FTDVFMBT » 1SPHSBNBT WJSUVBMFT 4FS %PDFOUF )PZ Z "VMBT )FSNBOBT JOUFS DBNCJPFOUSFFTDVFMBTBSHFOUJOBTZDIJMFOBT +FSBSRVJ[BDJwOZGPSUBMFDJNJFOUPEFMBBDUJWJEBEDJFOUr¾DB ZUFDOPMwHJDB » 1SPHSBNB EF KFSBSRVJ[BDJwO EF MB BDUJWJEBE DJFOUr¾DB Z UFDOP MwHJDB BVNFOUP EFM QSFTVQVFTUP JODPSQPSBDJwO EF NgT CFDB SJPTEF$0/*$&5BVNFOUPEFMBTSFNVOFSBDJPOFTEFCFDBSJPTF JOWFTUJHBEPSFT » 1SPHSBNB 3BrDFT 1VFTUB FO NBSDIB EF MB 3FE EF "SHFOUJOPT *OWFTUJHBEPSFTZ$JFOUr¾DPTFOFM&YUFSJPS » 'PSUBMFDJNJFOUPEFMBTDBQBDJEBEFTQSPWJODJBMFTFODJFODJBZUFD OPMPHrB"QPSUFTBMBTQSPWJODJBTQBSBMBJOOPWBDJwOQSPEVDUJWB » 1SPHSBNBÇSFBTEF7BDBODJBDPODVSTPTOBDJPOBMFTQBSBJNQVM TBSgSFBTEFEFTBSSPMMPJOTV¾DJFOUF » $POWPDBUPSJBEFQSPZFDUPTEFNPEFSOJ[BDJwOEFMBCPSBUPSJPTEF JOWFTUJHBDJwO¾OBODJBNJFOUPQBSBMBBERVJTJDJwOEFFRVJQBNJFO UPOVFWP » 1BUFOUFT EF JOWFODJwO ¾OBODJBNJFOUP QBSB MB QSFTFOUBDJwO EF TPMJDJUVEFTEFQBUFOUFT )BDJBMBJOUFHSBDJwODBMJEBEZQFSUJOFODJBFOQPMrUJDBVOJWFSTJUBSJB » #FDBT VOJWFSTJUBSJBT CFDBT B FTUVEJBOUFT EF DBSSFSBT DPOTJEF SBEBTQSJPSJUBSJBTQBSBFMEFTBSSPMMPOBDJPOBMFODPOKVOUPDPOFM NJOJTUFSJPEFFDPOPNrB » 1SPHSBNB EF KFSBSRVJ[BDJwO EF MB BDUJWJEBE VOJWFSTJUBSJB BV NFOUPT TBMBSJBMFT B QSPGFTPSFT DPO EFEJDBDJwO FYDMVTJWB Z TFNJFYDMVTJWB » *ODSFNFOUPEFM1SFTVQVFTUPVOJWFSTJUBSJP 1BSUJDJQBDJwOFJODJEFODJBEFMBTPDJFEBEDJWJMFMDBTPBSHFOUJOP » .FKPSBTBDBEnNJDBTDBSSFSBTEFJOHFOJFSrBZEFgSFBTQSJPSJUB SJBTTFH|ONJOJTUFSJPEFFDPOPNrB » 1PTHSBEPTQSPHSBNBTBTPDJBEPTDPO#SBTJMZ$IJMF » "SUJDVMBDJwOFJOUFHSBDJwOFOUSFVOJWFSTJEBEFT » "SUJDVMBDJwO EF MB FEVDBDJwO TVQFSJPS DPO MB FOTFvBO[B .FEJB 1PMJNPEBM ¾OBODJBNJFOUP EF QSPZFDUPT QSFTFOUBEPT QPS VOJWFSTJEBEFT » 1SPNPDJwO EF DBMJEBE JODPSQPSBDJwO B MPT QSPDFTPT EF FWBMVB DJwOEFDBMJEBEBDBSSFSBT » $JDMPDPNVOFTEFDPOUFOJEPTCgTJDPT¾OBODJBNJFOUPQBSBFMEF TBSSPMMPEFDJDMPTDPNVOFT » 'JOBODJBNJFOUP EF QSPZFDUPT EF FYUFOTJwO Z WJODVMBDJwO QFEBHwHJDB » %PDFOUFTJOWFTUJHBEPSFTQSPHSBNBEFJODFOUJWPT » 'JOBODJBNJFOUP QBSB MB 3FGPSNB Z SFFTUSVDUVSBDJwO MBCPSBM EFM QFSTPOBMEPDFOUFZOPEPDFOUF » &EJ¾DP|OJDPQBSBMBGBDVMUBEEFDJFODJBTTPDJBMFT¾OBODJBNJFOUP EFMQSJNFSUSBNP 0USPT1SPHSBNBTZ1SPZFDUPT » 1SPHSBNB/BDJPOBMEF1SFWFODJwOEFM7*)TJEBFOMB&TDVFMB » 1SPHSBNB/BDJPOBMEF$POWJWFODJBFTDPMBS » 1SPHSBNB/BDJPOBM&EVDBDJwOTPMJEBSJB » &MPCTFSWBUPSJP"SHFOUJOPEF7JPMFODJBFOMBT&TDVFMBT » 1SPHSBNBEF3FGPSNB"ENJOJTUSBUJWBEFMPT4JTUFNBT&EVDBUJWPT 1SPWJODJBMFT1SFHBTF » 130.4&1SPHSBNBEFNFKPSBNJFOUPEFMTJTUFNBFEVDBUJWP » "BvPTEFMHPMQF "OB1BHBOP*OHSJE4WFSEMJDLZ1BVMB$PTUBT #*#-*0(3"'Ê" "HFODJB5nMBN²&MTFOBEPDPOWJSUJwFOMFZVOQSPZFDUPRVFSFHV MBMBFEVDBDJwOUnDOJDB³#VFOPT"JSFTEFTFQUJFNCSFEFM "OEFSTPO(BSZ ²)BDJBVOBQBSUJDJQBDJwOBVUnOUJDBEF DPOTUSVZFOEP MPT EJTDVSTPT EF MBT SFGPSNBT QBSUJDJQBUJWBT FO FEV DBDJwO³ FO . /BSPEPXTLJ Z PUSPT FET /VFWBT UFOEFODJBT FO QPMrUJDBT FEVDBUJWBT #VFOPT "JSFT 5FNBT'VOEBDJwO (PCJFSOP Z 4PDJFEBE #BMJWBS &UJFOOF ²4VCKFUJWJEBE Z TVCKFUJWBDJwO³ FO #FOKBNrO"SEJUFFE &MSFWFSTPEFMBEJGFSFODJB*EFOUJEBEZQPMrUJ DB/VFWB4PDJFEBE$PMFDDJwO/VCFTZ5JFSSB #BVNBO;ZHNVOU -BNPEFSOJEBEMrRVJEB#VFOPT"JSFT 'POEPEF$VMUVSB&DPOwNJDB #JOJ1FESP %FDMBSBDJPOFTEFMSFDUPSEFMB&TDVFMB5nDOJDB /²0UUP,SBVTF³DPMFHJPJOEVTUSJBMNgTBOUJHVPEFMQBrTGVOEBEP IBDFBvPT ²&EVDBDJwO5nDOJDBBQSVFCBOVOBMFZRVFCVTDBNF KPSBSMBDBQBDJUBDJwO³FO$MBSrO#VFOPT"JSFTEFBHPTUPEF $BOUFSP (FSNgO &M EFSFDIP B MB QPMrUJDB DPNJFO[B FO PUSBFTDVFMBJOUFSWFODJwOFOFMQBOFM²%FNPDSBDJBFEVDBDJwOQ|CMJ DBFJEFOUJEBE³*$POHSFTP/BDJPOBMEF1SPEVDDJwOZ3F¿FYJwOTPCSF &EVDBDJwO6OJWFSTJEBE/BDJPOBMEF3rP$VBSUPPDUVCSFEF $IJBSB .BHEBMFOB ²-VDFTZTPNCSBTTPCSFFMDMJFOUFMJT NP/PUBTTPCSFMPTUFYUPTZBMHVOBTQSFHVOUBTFOUPSOPBMBJNQMF NFOUBDJwOEFMBTQPMrUJDBTTPDJBMFT³"QVOUFTEF*OWFTUJHBDJwO #VFOPT"JSFT $MBSrO²+PSOBEBEFEFCBUFQPSMB-FZEF&EVDBDJwO³#VFOPT"JSFT EFNBZPEF $5&3" "SU²6O1PDPEF)JTUPSJB³FOXXXDUFSBPSHBS $5&3" $/5& $PMFHJP EF QSPGFTPSFT "'656'&/"1&4 -11 -BT SFGPSNBT FEVDBUJWBT FO MPT QBrTFT EFM DPOP TVS 6O CBMBODF DSrUJDP #VFOPT "JSFT $-"$40 'SBHNFOUP UPNBEP EF MB 1BSUJDJQBDJwOFJODJEFODJBEFMBTPDJFEBEDJWJMFMDBTPBSHFOUJOP .FNPSJB EF $5&3" DPSSFTQPOEJFOUF BM QFSrPEP EF KVMJP EF EFKVOJPEF $5&3"*OTUJUVUP EF *OWFTUJHBDJPOFT 1FEBHwHJDBT .BSJOB 7JMUF ²$POTFDVFODJBTEFMBJNQMFNFOUBDJwOEFMBFTUSVDUVSB²EF¾ OJEB³QPSMBMFZGFEFSBMEFFEVDBDJwO³ %FMBNBUB(BCSJFMB ²*OUSPEVDDJwO³FO(BCSJFMB%FMBNBUB DPNQ $JVEBEBOrBZ5FSSJUPSJP-BTSFMBDJPOFTQPMrUJDBTEFMBTOVF WBTJEFOUJEBEFTTPDJBMFT#VFOPT"JSFT&TQBDJP&EJUPSJBM &OUSFWJTUBBMQSFTJEFOUFZTFDSFUBSJPHFOFSBMEFMB'VOEBDJwO0UUP ,SBVTF²-BWFMPDJEBEFOMBTBODJwOEFMBMFZUJFOFVOUSBTGPOEPFDP OwNJDP³FO3FWJTUB.VOEP%PDFOUF0CSBTPDJBM041-"% &[DVSSB"OB.BSrB ²(MPCBMJ[BDJwOOFPMJCFSBMJTNPZTPDJF EBEDJWJM"MHVOPT%FTBGrPTQBSBMPT.PWJNJFOUPT4PDJBMFTZ1PQVMBSFT -BUJOPBNFSJDBOPT³ FO $POUFYUP Z &EVDBmkP 3FWJTUB EF &EVDBDJwO FO "NnSJDB -BUJOB Z FM $BSJCF BvP / BCSJMKVOJP EF 6OJWFSTJEBE 3FHJPOBM EP /PSPFTUF EP &TUBEP EP 3rP (SBOEF EP 4VM &EJUPSB*/*+6Ê 'JMNVT%BOJFM %FDMBSBDJPOFTEFM.JOJTUSPEF&EVDBDJwO FO.JOJTUFSJPEF&EVDBDJwO$JFODJBZ5FDOPMPHrB1PSUBM&EVDBUJWP EFM.JOJTUFSJPEF&EVDBDJwO%JQVUBEPTEJPNFEJBTBODJwOBMQSPZFD UPEFMFZEFFEVDBDJwOUnDOJDBEFBHPTUPEF 'JOOFHBO 'MPSFODJB Z "OB 1BHBOP ²&M EFSFDIP B MB &EVDBDJwO FO MB "SHFOUJOB³ *OGPSNF /BDJPOBM #VFOPT "JSFT '-"1&-11 'SBTFS /BODZ ²1FOTBOEP EF OVFWP MB FTGFSB Q|CMJDB³ FO/BODZ'SBTFS*VTUJUJB*OUFSSVQUB3F¿FYJPOFTDSrUJDBTEFTEFMBQP TJDJwO ´QPTUTPDJBMJTUBµ #PHPUg 6OJWFSTJEBE EF MPT "OEFT4JHMP EFM )PNCSF&EJUPSFT (JBSSBDB/PSNBDPPSE B 7FKBDJPOFT9"SUFZ1SPUFTUB 4PDJBMFO#VFOPT"JSFT#VFOPT"JSFT*OTUJUVUPEF*OWFTUJHBDJPOFT (JOP(FSNBOJ'BDVMUBEEF$JFODJBT4PDJBMFT6OJWFSTJEBEEF#VFOPT "JSFT*OGPSNFTEF$PZVOUVSB/ (JBSSBDB /PSNBZDPMT C -BQSPUFTUBTPDJBMFOMBBSHFO UJOB5SBOTGPSNBDJPOFTFDPOwNJDBTZDSJTJTTPDJBMFOFMJOUFSJPSEFM QBrT#VFOPT"JSFT"MJBO[BFEJUPSJBM "OB1BHBOP*OHSJE4WFSEMJDLZ1BVMB$PTUBT (SBTTJ &TUFMB ²1PMrUJDBT EF BTJTUFODJB GPDBMJ[BEBT FO FMEFTFNQMFPZMBQPCSF[B³FO1PMrUJDBTZQSPCMFNBTTPDJBMFTFOMB TPDJFEBEOFPMJCFSBM-BPUSBEnDBEBJOGBNF#VFOPT"JSFT&TQBDJP &EJUPSJBM (VSSFSB .BSrB 4JMWBOB ²-B SFEF¾OJDJwO EFM DPO¿JDUP TPDJBM -B DPOGPSNBDJwO EF MB $FOUSBM EF 5SBCBKBEPSFT "SHFOUJOPT $5" ³ FO (BCSJFMB %FMBNBUB DPNQ $JVEBEBOrB Z 5FSSJUPSJP -BT SFMBDJPOFT QPMrUJDBT EF MBT OVFWBT JEFOUJEBEFT TPDJBMFT #VFOPT "JSFT&TQBDJP&EJUPSJBM (VUJnSSF[ "MGSFEP ²&EVDBDJwO 5nDOJDB BQSVFCBO VOB MFZ RVF CVTDB NFKPSBS MB DBQBDJUBDJwO³ FO $MBSrO #VFOPT "JSFT EFBHPTUPEFZ"HFODJB5nMBN²&MTFOBEPDPOWJSUJwFOMFZVO QSPZFDUPRVFSFHVMBMBFEVDBDJwOUnDOJDB³#VFOPT"JSFTEFTFQ UJFNCSFEF **1&#VFOPT "JSFT ²&M ¾OBODJBNJFOUP FEVDBUJWP NJUPT Z SFBMJEBEFT³FO*OGPSNFTQFSJPErTUJDPT/#VFOPT"JSFT +FMrO&MJ[BCFUI ²-BFTDBMBEFMBBDDJwOFOMPTNPWJNJFO UPTTPDJBMFT³FO&MJ[BCFUI+FMrODPNQ .gTBMMgEFMBOBDJwOMBT FTDBMBTN|MUJQMFTEFMPTNPWJNJFOUPTTPDJBMFT-JCSPTEFM;PS[BM -P[BOP$MBVEJPDPPSE -BVOJWFSTBMJ[BDJwOEFMBTBTJH OBDJPOFTGBNJMJBSFTZMBBDUVBMJ[BDJwOEFMBQSPQVFTUBEFM'SFOBQP %JTUJOUBTPQDJPOFT*OTUJUVUPEF&TUVEJPTZ'PSNBDJwOEFMB$5" .FSLMFO%FOJT ²7JWJSFOMPTNgSHFOFT/PUBTTPCSFTP DJBCJMJEBEZDVMUVSBFOMPTBTFOUBNJFOUPTEFM(SBO#VFOPT"JSFT³FO .BSJTUFMMB4WBNQBFE %FTEF"CBKP-BTUSBOTGPSNBDJPOFTEFMBT JEFOUJEBEFTTPDJBMFT#VFOPT"JSFT#JCMPT .FSLMFO%FOJTB ²$POMPTQJFTFOMBUJFSSB-BJOTDSJQDJwO UFSSJUPSJBMEFMBTDMBTFTQPQVMBSFT°FO"SHFOUJOBZFOPUSPTMVHBSFT° ²FO1PCSFTDJVEBEBOPT-BTDMBTFTQPQVMBSFTFOMBFSBEFNPDSgUJDB "SHFOUJOB #VFOPT"JSFT(PSMB .FSLMFO%FOJTC ²*OEJWJEVPTZDJVEBEBOPT/PUBTQBSB VOFOGPRVFPCKFUJWJTUBEFMBTVCKFUJWJEBEQPQVMBS .JOJTUFSJPEF&EVDBDJwO$JFODJBZ5FDOPMPHrB1PSUBM&EVDBUJWP EFM.JOJTUFSJPEF&EVDBDJwO FOXXXNFHPWBS 1BSUJDJQBDJwOFJODJEFODJBEFMBTPDJFEBEDJWJMFMDBTPBSHFOUJOP .JOJTUFSJPEF&EVDBDJwO$JFODJBZ5FDOPMPHrB1PSUBM&EVDBUJWP EFM .JOJTUFSJP EF &EVDBDJwO EFDMBSBDJPOFT EFM .JOJTUSP EF &EVDBDJwO%BOJFM'JMNVTFO²'JMNVTQSFTFOUwFMBOUFQSPZFDUPEFMB OVFWB-FZEF&EVDBDJwO/BDJPOBMTFQUJFNCSFEFM .JOJTUFSJPEF&EVDBDJwO$JFODJBZ5FDOPMPHrB 6OQSPZFDUP FEVDBUJWPQBSBMBJOUFHSBDJwOMBJHVBMEBEZFMEFTBSSPMMP0CKFUJWPT EFMBHFTUJwOFEVDBUJWB1MBOEF"DDJwO .JOJTUFSJPEF&EVDBDJwO$JFODJBZ5FDOPMPHrB%PDVNFOUPQBSBFM EFCBUF²-FZEF&EVDBDJwO/BDJPOBM)BDJBVOBFEVDBDJwOEFDBMJEBE QBSBVOBTPDJFEBENgTKVTUB³NBZPEFM .PSFOP -JMJBOB ²"SSBODw FM EFCBUF QPS MB -FZ EF &EVDBDJwO³FO$MBSrO#VFOPT"JSFTEFNBZPEF .PVGGF $IBOUBMM &M SFUPSOP EF MP QPMrUJDP #BSDFMPOB 1BJEPT ,ZNMJDLB 8 Z 8 /PSNBO ²&M SFUPSOP EFM DJVEBEBOP 6OBSFWJTJwOEFMBQSPEVDDJwOSFDJFOUFFOUFPSrBEFMBDJVEBEBOrB³FO ÇHPSB$VBEFSOPEF&TUVEJPT1PMrUJDPT#VFOPT"JSFT/ 0µ%POOFMM(VJMMFSNP ²&TUBEPEFNPDSBUJ[BDJwOZDJVEB EBOrB³FO/VFWB4PDJFEBE 1gHJOB 0QJOJPOFT EF EPDFOUFT SFVOJEPT FO MB "TPDJBDJwO (SFNJBM %PDFOUF Z EF FTUVEJBOUFT VOJWFSTJUBSJPT EF MB '6#"FO%JBSJP²&TQFSBO[BTZUFNPSFTBDBEnNJDPTGSFOUFBMB-FZ EF'JOBODJBNJFOUP³#VFOPT"JSFTEFPDUVCSFEF 1gHJOB ²&OCVTDBEFVOTFDSFUBSJP*ODFSUJEVNCSFFO FM gSFB EF QPMrUJDBT VOJWFSTJUBSJBT³ #VFOPT "JSFT EF BHPTUP EF 1gHJOB ².BSDIB³#VFOPT"JSFTEFTFQUJFNCSFEFM 1POT4FSHJP ²&MDPO¿JDUPVOJWFSTJUBSJP&MFTUVEJBOUBEP TFQPOFEFQJF³FO3FWJTUB4PDJBMJTNPP#BSCBSJFEFTFQUJFNCSF EF 1PSUBM&EVDBUJWPEFM.JOJTUFSJPEF&EVDBDJwO$JFODJBZ5FDOPMPHrB ²4F BQSPCw MB MFZ EF ¾OBODJBNJFOUP FEVDBUJWP QPS BNQMJB NBZPSrB³EFEJDJFNCSFEF "OB1BHBOP*OHSJE4WFSEMJDLZ1BVMB$PTUBT 4FPBOF +PTn ²$SJTJT EF SnHJNFO Z QSPUFTUB TPDJBM FO MB "SHFOUJOB³#VFOPT"JSFT%PDVNFOUPT04"-$-"$40 4FPBOF+PTnZ&NJMJP5BEEFJ ²%F4FBUUMFB1PSUP"MFHSF 1BTBEP QSFTFOUF Z GVUVSP EFM NPWJNJFOUP BOUJNVOEJBMJ[BDJwO OFPMJCFSBM³ FO +PTF 4FPBOF Z &NJMJP 5BEEFJ DPNQT 3FTJTUFODJBT .VOEJBMFT%F4FBUUMFB1PSUP"MFHSF$-"$40 4FSSB 4 ²"DFSDBEFMBDJVEBEBOrB³NJNFP 4VgSF[ %BOJFM $PO¿JDUP 4PDJBM Z QSPUFTUB EPDFOUF FO "NnSJDB-BUJOB&TUVEJPEFDBTPFMDPO¿JDUPEPDFOUFFO"SHFOUJOB 4FSJF&OTBZPTF*OWFTUJHBDJPOFT-110-1&%6/&4$0 4VgSF[ %BOJFM ²$PO¿JDUP TPDJBM Z QSPUFTUB EPDFOUF FO "NnSJDB-BUJOB&TUVEJPEFDBTPFMDPO¿JDUPEPDFOUFFO"SHFOUJOB -BCPSBUPSJPEF1PMrUJDBT1|CMJDBT4FSJFEF&OTBZPTF *OWFTUJHBDJPOFT/#VFOPT"JSFT 465&#" B ²" PDIP BvPT EF MB DBSQB CMBODB 6OB IJTUP SJB DPO ¾OBM BCJFSUP³ FO -B FEVDBDJwO FO OVFTUSBT NBOPT / %JTDVSTPEFM4FDSFUBSJP(FOFSBMEF$5&3"°)VHP:BTLZ°FOFMBDUP QPSMPTPDIPBvPTEFMB$BSQB#MBODB1MB[BEFM$POHSFTPEFBCSJM EFM 465&#"C ²&OUSFWJTUBB)VHP:BTLZ³°4FDSFUBSJP(FOFSBM EFMB$5&3"°QVCMJDBEBFOXXXTVUFCBPSHBS 465&#" D ²1PTJDJPOBNJFOUP EF $5&3"465&#" TPCSF MB SFHMBNFOUBDJwO EF MB -FZ 5nDOJDP 1SPGFTJPOBM³ FO 3FWJTUB -B &EVDBDJwOFOOVFTUSBTNBOPT#VFOPT"JSFT/ 4WBNQB .BSJTUFMMB B ²-B EJNFOTJPOFT EF MB FYQFSJFODJB QJRVFUFSB³FO-BTPDJFEBEFYDMVZFOUF#VFOPT"JSFT5BVSVT 4WBNQB.BSJTUFMMBC ².VUBDJPOFTEFMBDJVEBEBOrB³FO-B TPDJFEBEFYDMVZFOUF#VFOPT"JSFT5BVSVT 4WFSEMJDL*OHSJE ²"QVOUFTQBSBEFCBUJSTPCSFMBHFTUJwO FTDPMBSFODMBWFQPMrUJDB6OBNJSBEBQPSMBTJUVBDJwOFO"SHFOUJOB³ FO 3FWJTUB &MFDUSwOJDB *CFSPBNFSJDBOB TPCSF $BMJEBE &¾DBDJB Z $BNCJP FO &EVDBDJwO F QQ FO IUUQXXXSJOBDFOFU BSUTWPMOVNFBSUQEG 1BSUJDJQBDJwOFJODJEFODJBEFMBTPDJFEBEDJWJMFMDBTPBSHFOUJOP 5PSPODIJL "MFKBOESB ².PWJMJ[BDJPOFT FO SFDMBNPT EF NgT GPOEPT QBSB VOJWFSTJEBEFT³ FO $MBSrO #VFOPT "JSFT EF BHPTUPEF 3FTPMVDJwO / "SU / $POTFKP 'FEFSBM EF $VMUVSB Z &EVDBDJwO.JOJTUFSJPEF&EVDBDJwO$JFODJBZ5FDOPMPHrB 3FTPMVDJwO / $POTFKP 'FEFSBM EF $VMUVSB Z &EVDBDJwO .JOJTUFSJPEF&EVDBDJwO$JFODJBZ5FDOPMPHrB 3FTPMVDJwO / $POTFKP 'FEFSBM EF $VMUVSB Z &EVDBDJwO .JOJTUFSJPEF&EVDBDJwO$JFODJBZ5FDOPMPHrB 3FTPMVDJwO / $POTFKP 'FEFSBM EF $VMUVSB Z &EVDBDJwO .JOJTUFSJPEF&EVDBDJwO$JFODJBZ5FDOPMPHrB $0-&$$*Î/-*#304'-"1& 1BSUJDJQBDJwOFJODJEFODJBEFMBTPDJFEBEDJWJMFOMBTQPMrUJDBTFEVDBUJWBT FMDBTPBSHFOUJOP "OB1BHBOP*OHSJE4WFSEMJDLZ1BVMB$PTUBT &MEFSFDIPBMBFEVDBDJwOFO"SHFOUJOB 'MPSFODJB'JOOFHBOZ"OB1BHBOP 1BSUJDJQBDJwOFJODJEFODJBEFMBTPDJFEBEDJWJMFOMBTQPMrUJDBTFEVDBUJWBT FMDBTPCSBTJMFvP 'MPSFODJB4UVCSJO$PPSEJOBEPSB &MEFSFDIPBMBFEVDBDJwOFO#SBTJM &TUFMB4DIFJOWBS 1BSUJDJQBDJwOFJODJEFODJBEFMBTPDJFEBEDJWJMFOMBTQPMrUJDBTFEVDBUJWBT FMDBTPDPMPNCJBOP /PIFNB)FSOgOEF[(VFWBSB &MEFSFDIPBMBFEVDBDJwOFO$PMPNCJB $BSMPT"MCFSUP-FSNB$BSSFvP 1BSUJDJQBDJwOFJODJEFODJBEFMBTPDJFEBEDJWJMFOMBTQPMrUJDBTFEVDBUJWBT FMDBTPDIJMFOP 3PESJHP$PSOFKP+VBO(PO[gMF[Z+VBO1BCMP$BMEJDIPVSZ &MEFSFDIPBMBFEVDBDJwOFO$IJMF +FT|T3FEPOEP$PPSEJOBEPS 1BSUJDJQBDJwOFJODJEFODJBEFMBTPDJFEBEDJWJMFOMBTQPMrUJDBTFEVDBUJWBT FMDBTPNFYJDBOP #FSUIB4BMJOBT"NFTDVBZ4JMWJB&MFOB"NBEPS1nSF[ -BFEVDBDJwOCgTJDBDPNPEFSFDIPTPDJBMGVOEBNFOUBMFTUVEJBOUFT SFDVSTPTZFTDVFMBTJOErHFOBT &MEFSFDIPBMBFEVDBDJwOFO.nYJDP .JHVFMÇOHFM3PESrHVF[ 1BSUJDJQBDJwOFJODJEFODJBEFMBTPDJFEBEDJWJMFOMBTQPMrUJDBTFEVDBUJWBT FMDBTPOJDBSBHFOTF 3BGBFM-VDJP(JM &MEFSFDIPBMBFEVDBDJwOFO/JDBSBHVB .JHVFMEF$BTUJMMB6SCJOB 1BSUJDJQBDJwOFJODJEFODJBEFMBTPDJFEBEDJWJMFOMBTQPMrUJDBTFEVDBUJWBT FMDBTPQFSVBOP 1BUSJDJB"OESBEFZ.JHVFM.BSUrOF[ &MEFSFDIPBMBFEVDBDJwOFO1FS| (MBEZT7JHP(VUJnSSF[Z5FSFTB/BLBOP0TPSFT &MEFSFDIPBMBFEVDBDJwOVOCBMBODFEFMBTJUVBDJwOFO"NnSJDB-BUJOB 1BCMP(FOUJMJ 1BSUJDJQBDJwOFJODJEFODJBEFMBTPDJFEBEDJWJMFOMBTQPMrUJDBTFEVDBUJWBT FO"NnSJDB-BUJOB *OHSJE4WFSEMJDL