/$0È69(5'$'(5$+,6725,$48(-$0È6 )8(5$&217$'$'(/0È69$/(5262< 9(5'$'(52&$%$//(52 520$1&('(/ 520$1&('(/ &$%$//(52)5,6$5'2 &$%$//(52)5,6$5'2 ([WUDFWRURPDQFHDGRGHO4XLMRWH 3ULPHUDSDUWH 3250$18(/*21=$/(=&$%5(5$%5(0$1/(=$0%5$ GHPDU]R 7tWXOR5RPDQFHGHO&DEDOOHUR)ULVDUGR $XWRU0DQXHO*RQ]iOH]&DEUHUD ,6%1ííí; 'HSyVLWROHJDO$í767-2005 (GLWD(GLWRULDO&OXE8QLYHUVLWDULR7HOI &&RWWROHQJRí6DQ9LFHQWH$OLFDQWH ZZZHFXIP 3ULQWHGLQ6SDLQ ,PSULPH,PSUHQWD*DPPD7HOI &&RWWROHQJRí6DQ9LFHQWH$OLFDQWH ZZZJDPPDIP JDPPD#JDPPDIP 5HVHUYDGRV WRGRV ORV GHUHFKRV 1L OD WRWDOLGDG QL SDUWH GH HVWH OLEUR SXHGH UHSURGXFLUVH R WUDQVPLWLUVHSRUQLQJ~QSURFHGLPLHQWRHOHFWUyQLFRRPHFiQLFRLQFOX\HQGRIRWRFRSLDJUDEDFLyQPDJQpWLFD RFXDOTXLHUDOPDFHQDPLHQWRGHLQIRUPDFLyQRVLVWHPDGHUHSURGXFFLyQVLQSHUPLVRSUHYLR\SRUHVFULWR GHORVWLWXODUHVGHO&RS\ULJKW 352/2*2 'HOSRUTXpGHODVORFXUDV WHQJRKDOODGDODUHVSXHVWD TXHORVOLEURVGHDYHQWXUDV KDFHQSHUGHUODFKDYHWD GLpUDOHDTXHOSRUDTXHOODV \GLpUDPHDPtSRUpVWD (Q HVWH ³520$1&( '(/ &$%$//(52 )5,6$5'2´ TXHGDUHVXPLGR(O4XLMRWHXQOLEURFRQWH[WRPX\GHQVRPX\ DPSOLR GH ODUJR \ SURIXQGR FRQWHQLGR SHUR TXH UHVXOWD SRFR GLJHULEOH DOJR HPSDODJRVR TXH QR HQWUD ELHQ VH SHJD \ OOHJD DSURGXFLUFDQVDQFLRSRUORTXHKD\TXHEHEHUDJXDGHVFDQVDU \ UHWRPDU GH QXHYR HO DOLHQWR \ OD OHFWXUD FRQ EDVWDQWH GH SDFLHQFLD 3RU HVWR VRQ OHJLRQHV ORV OHFWRUHV TXH KDQ FRPHQ]DGR DOHHU(O4XLMRWHPXFKRVORVTXHFRQRFHQELHQKDVWDHO TXLQWR FDStWXOR SRFRV ORV TXH KDQ OOHJDGR DO YHLQWH \ VRQ VyOR XQRV FXDQWRVORVTXH~QLFDPHQWHFRQRFHQHOWtWXORGHODVKD]DxDVSHUR QRVHKDQDWUHYLGRDHQWUDUVHHQVXPDUDxDDOJXQRVSRUTXHOHV KDOOHJDGRHOWLHPSRGHMXELODUVH\GHVFDQVDUDQWHVGHWHUPLQDU FRQWDPDxDHPSUHVDTXHOHVOOHYDUtDPiVGHPHGLDYLGDRPiV GH XQD YLGD HQWHUD VL SUHWHQGLHUDQ H[WUDHU WRGR HO QpFWDU TXH UH]XPD 3UHWHQGLHQGR KDFHU PiV OOHYDGHUD OD WDUHD GH OHHU (O 4XLMRWH KH GLOXLGR XQ WDQWR HO WH[WR SDUD KDFHUOR PiV ÀXLGR PiV WUDJDEOH PiV GLJHULEOH VLQ H[FHGHUPH D ¿Q GH FRQVHUYDU VXHVHQFLDOXHJROHKHDxDGLGRXQSRFRGHVDODOJRGHSLPLHQWD \XQWRTXHGHD]DIUiQSDUDTXHPDQWHQJDHOVDERU\HOFRORUSRU ~OWLPROHKHGDGRODIRUPDGH5RPDQFHTXHDXQTXHPRQyWRQR HVXQSODWRPHQRVFRUULHQWH\UHVXOWDSRUOREUHYH\RWURVVDERUHV PHQRVFDQVLQR 6L YROYLHUD D HVFULELU RWUD YH] HO 520$1&( '(/ &$%$//(52)5,6$5'2FRQWRGDVHJXULGDGORKDUtDGLIHUHQWH 0DQXHO*RQ]iOH]&DEUHUD SXHV HO FDPSR D UHFRUUHU WLHQH WDQWRV YHULFXHWRV WURFKDV \ YHUHGDV TXH UHVXOWD LPSRVLEOH SDVDU GRV YHFHV SRU HO PLVPR FDPLQR TXH DQWHV VH DQGXYR SXHV WRGRV SDUHFHQ EXHQRV \ DFHUWDGRVRTXL]iQRORHVQLQJXQR (VWR\VHJXURTXHORPLVPROHVXFHGHUtDDFXDOTXLHUDTXH OR KD\D LQWHQWDGR DQWHV R TXH VH DWUHYD FRQ OD HPSUHVD HQ OR YHQLGHUR 6L 'RQ 4XLMRWH VH PHWLy HQ DYHQWXUDV GH GHVIDFHU HQWXHUWRVUHSDUDULQMXVWLFLDV\VRFRUUHUDGDPDVHVSRUTXHKDEtD SHUGLGRHOMXLFLRDFDXVDGHWDQWRVOLEURVGHFDEDOOHUtDFRPRKDEtD OHtGR SHUR HQ PL FDVR QR UHFXHUGR WHQHU PRWLYRV SDUD KDEHU SHUGLGRODFRUGXUDOREDVWDQWHFRPRSDUDPHWHUPHHQFDPLVDGH RQFHYDUDVFRPRPHSDUHFHTXHDFDERGHKDFHU(Q¿QVHDORTXH IXHUHDTXtHVWiHO520$1&('(/&$%$//(52)5,6$5'2 0L SURSyVLWR DO KDFHU HVWH WUDEDMR HV FRQVHJXLU TXH VH LQFUHPHQWH VL HVWR IXHUD SRVLEOH HO Q~PHUR GH SHUVRQDV TXH OHHQHVDSUHFLRVD\XQLYHUVDOREUDOLWHUDULDTXHHV(O4XLMRWHWDQ DPSOLDPHQWHFRQRFLGD\DGPLUDGD &RQVLGHURTXHHVWHSURSyVLWRHVXQREMHWLYRDOFDQ]DEOH ORVHUiSRUPHGLRGHDOJXQRVPHFDQLVPRVTXHSXHGHQSRQHUVH HQ PDUFKD XQD YH] WHUPLQDGR \ GDGR D FRQRFHU PL WUDEDMR ³520$1&('(/&$%$//(52)5,6$5'2´FRPRXQH[WUDFWR GHO 4XLMRWH SHUR HVFULWR HQ IRUPD TXH VH DOHMD GH OD SURVD EDUURFD 4XLHQ \D KD\D OHtGR (O 4XLMRWH \ OHD GHVSXpV HVWH 520$1&( YROYHUi D VHQWLU HO GHVHR GH UHWRPDU OD OHFWXUD GH DTXHOODREUDDXQTXHVyORVHDSRUFRPSDUDUORVGLVWLQWRVVDERUHV TXHRIUHFHXQPLVPRSURGXFWRHOXQRHVFULWRHQSURVD\HORWURHQ YHUVRD~QVLQiQLPRGHFRPSHWHQFLD\VLQGLVWRUVLRQHVDUUHJORV RFRPSRQHQGDVDGXOWHUDQWHV 4XLHQ QR KXELHUD WHUPLQDGR GH OHHU (O 4XLMRWH DKRUD WHUPLQDUi GH KDFHUOR GHVSXpV GH OHtGR HVWH 520$1&( TXL]i SRUHOGHVHRGHUHFRUGDU\GHDJRWDUDTXHOODFRSDGHWDQVDEURVR OLFRU &RPRQDGDHVWiH[HQWRGHULHVJRWHPRTXHVHDPD\RUHO Q~PHURGHTXLHQHVKDELHQGROHtGRDTXHOODREUDOHDQDKRUDHVWH 5RPDQFHGHO&DEDOOHUR)ULVDUGR H[WUDFWRSHURQRFRQiQLPRGHVDERUHDUGLVWLQWRVSODFHUHVVLQR SDUD EXVFDU PLV GHIHFWRV HUURUHV RPLVLRQHV R FXDOTXLHU RWUD IDOWD UHDO R LPDJLQDULD \ GDUVH FRQ HVWR HO KXPDQR SODFHU GH HFKDUPHHQFLPDXQGHPROHGRUFKDSDUUyQGHFUtWLFDGHVWUXFWLYDV \GHVDOHQWDGRUDV 3HUR PL EXHQD IH TXHGD SDJDGD HQ OD FUHHQFLD GH TXH SXHGRHVWDUHTXLYRFDGRHQORUHIHUHQWHDODFRQGLFLyQKXPDQD HQVXPD\RUtD\HQTXHQRORHVWR\HQFXDQWRDPLWUDEDMR 4XLHQHVQRKXELHUDQOHtGR(O4XLMRWH\OHDQHO520$1&( '(/ &$%$//(52 )5,6$5'2 VH TXHGDUiQ FRPR HVSHUR TXH FRQHVDHVSHUDQ]DORKDJRFRQODERFDHQGXO]DGD\FRQGHVHRVGH PiVDEXQGDQFLDGHORPLVPREXVFDUiQFRQJUDQLQWHUpVHOULFR PDQDQWLDOGHGRQGHEURWDQ\SURFHGHQWDOHVUHWD]RVGHEHOOH]D\ GXO]XUDQDFLHQGRHQHOORVHOGHVHRGHOHHU\EHEHUGHODIXHQWHGH WDOHVVDERUHV (Q HVWH JUXSR HVWDUiQ ORV GH DOPD QREOH \ VHQVLEOH D OR VXEOLPH TXH DXQ QR KDELHQGR DOFDQ]DGR HQ PL WUDEDMR QL GH OHMRV WDO JUDGR GH SHUIHFFLyQ VL SRQH HQ HO FDPLQR GH KDFHUVH XQDLGHDGHFXiOVHUiHVHHVWDGRGHODOPD(VWiHQPLGHVHRTXH HVWHVHDHOJUXSRPiVQXPHURVRGHFXDQWRVOHDQPLWUDEDMR\D FRQVHFXHQFLDGHHOOROHDQOXHJR(O4XLMRWH /D JHQWH RSLQD TXH (O 4XLMRWH UHVXOWD OHQWR SHVDGR FDQVDGR \ DJRWDGRU SRU OR UHSHWLGR GHO WHQRU GH ODV DYHQWXUDV TXHHQpOVHUHODWDQSHURHVWRVXFHGHSRUTXHUHUKDFHUHOFDPLQR WRGRHQODPLVPDMRUQDGD/RPLVPRTXHQRIXHHVFULWRHQGLH] QL HQ YHLQWH GtDV DVt GHEHUi VHU OHtGR GH IRUPD HVSDFLDGD XQD DYHQWXUDFDGDVHPDQDFXDQGRODRFDVLyQVHWHUFLH &RQHOGHVHRGHDSXUDUVXVDERUKDVWDHOIRQGRVLQWHPRU DO H[FHVR OpDVH HO 520$1&( '(/ &$%$//(52 )5,6$5'2 DODOX]GHORVFDQGLOHV\DOFDORUGHXQDJUDQIRJDWDFXDQGRHO DEXHORIXPDHQVXSLSDVHQWDGRHQXQULQFyQFHUFDGHOFDORUGH OD OXPEUH FXDQGR RWURV KDFHQ SOHLWD SDUD VHURQHV RWURV FRVHQ HVSDUWHxDV ODV PXMHUHV FRVHQ ERWRQHV ODV PR]DV KDEODQ GH DPRUHVHLOXVLRQHVORVSDVWRUHVSUHSDUDQVXV]XUURQHVODDEXHOD KDFH JDQFKLOOR OD PR]D FDVDGHUD ERUGD ViEDQDV SDUD HO DMXDU RWURDWL]DODOXPEUHGRQGHHOSHUURVHPROHVWDSRUTXHORTXLWDQ 0DQXHO*RQ]iOH]&DEUHUD GHO ODGR GHO IXHJR GRQGH HO JDWR URQURQHD HQ ODV SLHUQDV GHO DEXHORGRQGHORVSHTXHxRVJULWDQ\MXHJDQD]X]DQGRHOSHUURDO JDWRGRQGHODVQRFKHVVRQODUJDV\OOXYLRVDVGHOLQYLHUQR %pEDVHSXHVWUDJRDWUDJRSDUDPHMRUVDERUHDUORTXHPL WUDEDMRQRHVYLQRSDUDGHXQWUDJRDSXUDUOR (QFXDQWRDOWUDWRTXHOHKHGDGRHQPLWUDEDMRDOWH[WRGHO 4XLMRWHFRPRSXHGHFRPSUREDUVHKHVHJXLGRORPiV¿HOPHQWH SRVLEOHODOLWHUDOLGDGGHOPLVPRHQQDGDKHDOWHUDGRVXVHQWLGR \VXFRQWH[WR(QODVDSRUWDFLRQHVTXHKHWHQLGRTXHKDFHUSRU PRWLYRV GH OD ULPD KH XWLOL]DGR VLHPSUH SDODEUDV GHO SURSLR WH[WRVLJXLHQGRODOtQHDGHODSHUVRQDOLGDGGHFDGDSURWDJRQLVWD /RV SRHPDV RULJLQDOHV ORV KH SXHVWRV HQ YHURV GH RFKR VtODEDV SRU DFRPRGDUORV DO UHVWR GHO URPDQFH SHUR VLQ LQWHQFLyQ GH HQPHQGDUQLPHMRUDUFRVDDOJXQDQLPXFKRPHQRVDIHDUDOJRR GHFLUDOJRHQPHQRVFDERRGHVGRURGHODLQWHJULGDGGHORULJLQDO GHO TXH \R KH PDQHMDGR $Vt SXHV DXQ QR VLHQGR XQD FRSLD OLWHUDOHVXQ¿HOUHÀHMRGHOFRQWHQLGRSULPDULR 4XLHQ OHD HVWH ³520$1&( '(/ &$%$//(52 )5,6$5'2´ SXHGH HVWDU VHJXUR GH TXH KD OHtGR (O 4XLMRWH HQ VXLQWHJULGDGHQVXSDUWHPiVVXVWDQFLRVD\GLYHUWLGD\TXHKD VLGRGLVSHQVDGRGHODOHFWXUDGHSDUWHVPHQRVDIRUWXQDGDV\GH UHOOHQR (QUHVXPHQ &XDQGRVHDYLHQWDXQDSDUYD HQXQPRQWyQTXHGDHOWULJR HQRWURTXHGDODSDMD HOSULPHURHVUHGXFLGR HORWURHVODDEXQGDQFLD OXHJRHOEXHQDYHQWDGRU XVDQGRGHVXYHQWDMD VHTXHGDFRQORPHMRU GHMDQGRDXQODGRODSDMD (ODXWRU R C$3,78/2, A48Ë&20,(1=$/$+,6725,$ '(/&$%$//(52)5,6$5'2 &210È6),(5$6$9(1785$6 48(-$0È6+È<$16('$'2 '21'(6(&8(17$689,'$ 48,(1(5$&202(67$%$ </$/2&85$68)5,'$ EQXQOXJDUGHOD0DQFKD TXH\DQDGLHUHFRUGDED FLHUWRKLGDOJRFDEDOOHUR ODUJRWLHPSRKDTXHPRUDED XQDODQ]DHQDVWLOOHUR \DGDUJDDQWLJXDSRUWDED URFtQÀDFR\FRUUHGRU HOFDEDOOHURPRQWDED GHPiVYDFDTXHFDUQHUR HUDODROODTXHFHQDED VDOSLFyQODVPXFKDVQRFKHV ORVViEDGRVHPSHRUDED OHQWHMDVWRGRVORVYLHUQHV DOFRPHU\DODFHQDGD SDORPLQRORVGRPLQJRV HQTXHVXKDFLHQGDJDVWDED YHVWtDVD\RGHYHODUWH \GHYHOOXGRFDO]DED FRQXQYHOORUtPX\¿QR HQWUHVHPDQDVHKRQUDED $QGDEDQSRUORVFLQFXHQWD ORVDxRVTXH\DFRQWDED HQMXWRGHFDUQH\URVWUR GH¿JXUDGHVJDUEDGD UHFLRHUD\HVSLJDGR FXDOFHQWHQRHQWUHFHEDGD GHODUJRDQGDU\HVWLUDGR SHUGLGD\ODUJDPLUDGD ODFDUDFRPR]DSDWR ODUJDVHFD\DUUXJDGD QDUL]ODUJD\DJXLOHxD TXHDODERFDOHOOHJDED RMRVDOIRQGRHVFRQGLGRV TXHSRUGRVFXHYDVPLUDED ODUJDEDUED\GHVFRPSXHVWD TXHSRFDVYHFHVFRUWDED 8QDDPDHQFDVDWHQtD TXHGHFXDUHQWDSDVDED VREULQDWHQtDFRQHOORV 0DQXHO*RQ]iOH]&DEUHUD TXHDORVYHLQWHQROOHJDED \XQPR]RGHFDPSR\SOD]D TXHDVXURFtQOHHQVLOODED HUDJUDQPDGUXJDGRU FRPRDFD]DGRUFXDGUDED 'HVXKLVWRULD\DEROHQJR PHPRULDDOJXQDTXHGDED GHQRPEUHGHVFRQRFLGR GHVREUHQRPEUH)ULVDUGD 0X\GDGRIXHDODOHFWXUD TXHGHDYHQWXUDVWUDWDED OLEURVGHFDEDOOHUtD FXDQWRVWXYRGHYRUDED YHQGLyFDVDYHQGLyKDFLHQGD \PiVOLEURVVHFRPSUDED FXDQWRVPiVOLEURVOHtD HOVHVRPiVOHIDOWDED GHWDQWROHHUOH\HQGR HOMXLFLRVHOHYROFDED 'H)HOLFLDQRGH6LOYD HUDQORVTXHPiVJXVWDED SRUVXFODULGDGGHSURVD \UD]RQHVLQWULQFDGDV JXVWiEDQOHORVUHTXLHEURV TXHHQPXFKDVSDUWHVKDOODED \PiVUD]RQDQGRDTXHVWH TXHDVtVXUD]yQFRQWDED ³/DUD]yQGHVLQUD]yQ TXHDPLUD]yQDOFDQ]DED WDQPLUD]yQHQÀDTXHFH TXHFRQUD]yQPHTXHMDED´ &RQHVWD\RWUDVUD]RQHV HOMXLFLRVHOHYROFDED SRUHQFRQWUDUOHVVHQWLGR VHVXIUtD\GHVYHODED 1RJXVWDEDODVKHULGDV TXHDGRQ%HOLDQtVFDXVDEDQ SRUODPXFKDVFLFDWULFHV TXHSRUHOFXHUSRGHMDEDQ &RQHOFXUDGHOOXJDU PXFKDVYHFHVVHHQIUDVFDED VREUHHOPD\RUFDEDOOHUR GHTXHHQORVOLEURVVHKDEODED 6L3DOPHUtQGH,QJODWHUUD DOGH*DXODVXSHUDED PDV1LFROiVHOEDUEHUR HUDD)HERDTXLHQDO]DED 'HFtDTXH&LG5X\'tD] HOGHODHQRUPH³&RODGD´ QRIXHPHMRUFDEDOOHUR TXHDTXHOGHOD$UGLHQWH(VSDGD &RQ'RQ%HUQDUGRGHO &DUSLR HQPHMRUiQLPRHVWDED TXHD5ROGiQHOHQFDQWDGR HQ5RQFHVYDOOHVPDWDED GHDTXHOJLJDQWH0RUJDQWH PXFKR\JUDQELHQVHFRQWDED SRUTXHFRQVHUJLJDQWHVFR PX\DIDEOHVHPRVWUDED 5H\QDOGRVGH0RQWDOEiQ HUDHOTXHPiVOHOOHQDED TXHHOtGRORGH0DKRPD WRGRHQRURORUREDED 5HPDWDGR\DVXMXLFLR HQVXORFXUDSHQVDED HOVHUFDEDOOHURDQGDQWH FRPRHQORVOLEURVFRQWDEDQ \EXVFDUODVDYHQWXUDV TXHDFDEDOOHURVFXDGUDED GHVIDFLHQGRORVDJUDYLRV GRQGHIDPDVHJDQDED 5RPDQFHGHO&DEDOOHUR)ULVDUGR LPDJLQiEDVHHOSREUH ODFDEH]DFRURQDGD SRUODIXHU]DGHVXEUD]R HQ7UDSLVRQGDSUREDGD 3XOLyDUPDV\DUPDGXUDV TXHOXHQJRVVLJORVJXDUGDED IXHURQGHVXELVDEXHOR HQXQULQFyQROYLGDGDV )XHOXHJRDYHUVXURFtQ TXHPiVWDFKDVSUHVHQWDED TXHHOFDEDOORGH*RQHOD TXHSLHO\KXHVRVPRVWUDED %XFpIDORGH$OHMDQGUR QL%DELHFDOHLJXDODEDQ FXDWURGtDVOHSDVDURQ SRUYHUTXpQRPEUHOHGDED GHVSXpVGHSRQHUPLOQRPEUHV ³5RFLQDQWH´OHOODPDED XQQRPEUHDOWR\VRQRUR TXHPXFKRVLJQL¿FDED URFtQÀDFR\HQPRVFDGR GHPX\SHUH]RVDDQGDGD WDQYLHMR\GHVWDUWDODGR TXHORVKXHVRVELHQPRVWUDED WDQGHVSURYLVWRGHFDUQHV FRPRORPRGHXQDHVSDGD FRQUDVSDTXHSDUHFLHUD GHVHUUDUVLHUUDPHOODGD 3XHVWRQRPEUHDVXFDEDOOR DVtWDPELpQORWRPDED GHVSXpVGHORVRFKRGtDV ³'RQ)ULVDUGR´VHOODPDED $FRUGyVHTXH$PDGtV HOGHVXUHLQRDJUHJDED VHOODPy$PDGtVGH*DXOD SRUTXHDOOiHQ*DXODUHLQDED DLPLWDFLyQ'RQ)ULVDUGR HOGHVXSDWULDDJUHJDED ³'RQ)ULVDUGRGHOD0DQFKD´ SRUWRGRQRPEUHOOHYDED /LPSLDVDUPDV\DUPDGXUDV KHFKRVPRUULyQ\FHODGD SXHVWRQRPEUHDVXURFtQ VyORGDPDOHIDOWDED SRUVLSRUDOJXQDVXHUWH DOJ~QJLJDQWHHQFRQWUDED VHUiEXHQRTXHDVXGDPD UHQGLGRVHSUHVHQWDUD 'HURGLOODVDQWHHOOD GLJDFRQYR]KXPLOODGD ³\RVR\&DUDFXOLDQGUR GH0DOLQGUDQLDLQVXODGD DTXLHQYHQFLy'RQ)ULVDUGR TXHHOGHOD0DQFKDOODPDEDQ PDQGyTXHDYXHVWUDPHUFHG \YROXQWDGPHTXHGDUD´ £&yPRGDQGRHVWHGLVFXUVR HOFDEDOOHURVHKROJDED \PiVFXDQGRKDOOyDTXLHQGDU HOQRPEUHSDUDVXDPDGD 8QDPR]DODEUDGRUD DOOtGHFHUFDKDELWDED HUDHOOD$OGRQ]D/RUHQ]R TXHGHSLODVHOODPDED ³'XOFLQHDGHO7RERVR´ FRQHVWHQRPEUHTXHGDED QRPEUHSHUHJULQR\GXOFH FRPRWRGRVORVTXHGDED 3XOLyDUPDV\DUPDGXUD TXHDOOiHQXQULQFyQJXDUGDED EUXxyODQ]DOLMyHVSDGD OLPSLyFDVFR\VXFHODGD O C$3,78/2,, A48Ë6(',&(<6(&8(17$ '(6835,0(5$6$/,'$</$ //(*$'$$/$9(17$ H HFKDVSXHVODV SUHYHQFLRQHV DVXLQWHQFLyQVHDSUHVWDED SDUDRIUHFHUORVUHPHGLRV TXHHOPXQGRQHFHVLWDED VLQGDUSDUWHDOJXQDDQDGLH VLQHVSHUDUODDOERUDGD XQDPDxDQDGHMXOLR VXVDUPDPHQWRVWRPDED VXELyVREUH5RFLQDQWH FRPS~VRVHODFHODGD SRUODSXHUWDGHOFRUUDO VDOLyDGDUJDHPEUD]DGD 0DVDSHQDVHQHOFDPSR XQGHEHUOHSUHRFXSDED GHEtDDUPDUVHFDEDOOHUR TXHGHVHKRQRUQRJR]DED HVWHSHQVDPLHQWROHKL]R TXHHQXQSXQWRWLWXEHDUD PDVSXGRPiVVXORFXUD \VXHPSUHVDFRQWLQXDED 4XtVRVHDUPDUFDEDOOHUR FRPRORVOLEURVFRQWDEDQ SRUFXDOTXLHUDTXHWRSDVH TXHHVHH[WUHPRQRLPSRUWDED 5RFtQÀDFR\FRUUHGRU HOFDEDOOHURPRQWDED YLHMDODQ]DHQDVWLOOHUR \DQWLJXDDGDUJDOHDUPDED <HQGRSXHV\DFDPLQDQGR FRQVLJRVHSODWLFDED ³¢TXLpQGXGDTXHDOOiHQORV WLHPSRVODKLVWRULDDVtVH FRQWDUD" $SHQDVWHQGLHUD$SROR VXFDEHOOHUDGRUDGD GHMDQGRVXEODQGDFDPD DPRUWDOHVVHPRVWUDED´ 'RQ)ULVDUGRGHOD0DQFKD D5RFLQDQWHPRQWDED SRUORVFDPSRVGH0RQWLHO VXDQGDGXUDFRPHQ]DED 0DQXHO*RQ]iOH]&DEUHUD <HUDYHUGDGTXHSRUpO 'RQ)ULVDUGRFDPLQDED GDQGRFDPSRDOGHVYDUtR GLVSDUDWHVHQVDUWDED KDEODEDFRQVLJRPLVPR \DVtVyORVHHVFXFKDED EDMRDTXHODUGLHQWHVRO TXHHOVHVROHDFKLFKDUUDED pODQGDEDWDQGHVSDFLR \HOVROWDQGHSULVDHQWUDED TXHGHUUHWtDOHORVVHVRV VLHVTXHDOJXQROHTXHGDED $ODQRFKHFHUHOGtD PXHUWRGHKDPEUHVH HQFRQWUDED SRUGHVFXEULUXQFDVWLOOR DWRGDVSDUWHVPLUDED 3RU¿QOOHJyFRPRSXGR DXQDYHQWDGHVWHFKDGD KDOOyDODSXHUWDGRVPR]DV TXHDOOtHVWDEDQGHSDUDGD PXMHUHVVRQGHOSDUWLGR FRPRDVtVHOHVOODPDED FDPLQRYDQGH6HYLOOD GLMHURQDODOOHJDGD 1XHVWUREXHQDYHQWXUHUR WRGRVHORLPDJLQDED FRPRKDEtDOHtGRHQORVOLEURV SRUFDVWLOORODWRPDED )XHVHOOHJDQGRDODYHQWD TXHSRUFDVWLOORWRPDED \DSRFRWUHFKRGHpOOD D5RFLQDQWHSDUDED HVSHUDEDTXHXQHQDQR DODVDOPHQDVOOHJDUD DQXQFLDQGRFRQWURPSHWDV TXHXQFDEDOOHUROOHJDED /OHJyDSXHUWDVGHODYHQWD GRQGHODVPR]DVHVWDEDQ SRUGRVKHUPRVDVGRQFHOODV 'RQ)ULVDUGRODVWRPDED (QHVWRTXHXQEXHQSRUTXHUR XQODUJRFXHUQRVRQDED SRUUHFRJHUDORVSXHUFRV TXHWHQtDHQODPDQDGD /HSDUHFLyD'RQ)ULVDUGR HVFXFKDUORTXHGHVHDED ODVVHxDOHVGHXQHQDQR DQXQFLDQGRVXOOHJDGD $TXHOHVSHUSHQWRGHKRPEUH YLpURQOHTXHVHDFHUFDED VREUHXQMDPHOJRPRQWDGR SRUWDQGRODQ]D\DGDUJD KDFLDODYHQWDFRUULHQGR HPSUHQGLHURQUHWLUDGD 'RQ)ULVDUGRTXHODVYLHUD OHVGLMRHQYR]VRVHJDGD ³1RQIX\DQYXHVWUDV PHUFHGHV QLWRPHQWHPRUGHQDGD FDQRQFDEHDFDEDOOHUR IDFHUOHVGHVDJXLVDGD´ 0LUiEDQOHDOOtODVPR]DV \VXURVWUROHEXVFDEDQ SRUTXHODPDODYLVHUD ORFXEUtD\ORWDSDED PDVSRUOODPDUOHVGRQFHOODV ODULVDVHOHVVROWDED 'RQ)ULVDUGRPX\FRUULGR GHVWHPRGROHVKDEODED ³%LHQSDUHFHODPHVXUD HQODVIHUPRVDVJXDUGDGD 5RPDQFHGHO&DEDOOHUR)ULVDUGR \HVPXFKDVDQGH]ODULVD TXHHQOHYHFDXVDHVIXQGDGD´ (QHVWHSXQWRHOYHQWHUR D'RQ)ULVDUGROHKDEODED FXDQWREXVTXHHOFDEDOOHUR ORKDOODUiHQHVWDSRVDGD DOYHQWHUR'RQ)ULVDUGR SRUDOFDLGHORWRPDED YLpQGROHWDQWDKXPLOGDG GHVWHPRGRFRQWHVWDED ³3DUDPtEXHQFDVWHOODQR FXDOTXLHUDFRVDEDVWDED PLVDUUHRVVRQODVDUPDV PLGHVFDQVRHVODEDWDOOD´ (OOODPDUOHFDVWHOODQR DOYHQWHURFRQWHQWDED VLHQGRPiVODGUyQTXH&DFR TXHDOOiHQ6DQO~FDUVHFULDED ³6HJ~QHVRYXHVWUDVDUPDV HOYHQWHURFRQWLQXDED VLHPSUHVHUiQGXUDVSHxDV YXHVWURGRUPLUODYHODGD´ /HSLGLyOXHJRDOYHQWHUR TXHHOFDEDOOROHFXLGDUD SRUTXHHUDODPHMRUSLH]D TXHFRQSDQGHVD\XQDED GRQFHOODVD'RQ)ULVDUGR GHVXVDUPDVGHVSRMDEDQ SRUQRFRUWDUOHODVFLQWDV ODFHODGDOHGHMDEDQ SRUSULQFLSDOHVVHxRUDV 'RQ)ULVDUGRODVWRPDED OXHJRFRQPXFKRGRQDLUH GHVWHPRGROHVKDEODED ³1XQFDIXHUDFDEDOOHUR GHGDPDVWDQELHQVHUYLGR FRPRORIXH'RQ)ULVDUGR TXHHVWDEDUHFLpQYHQLGR GRQFHOODVFXUDEDQGpO SULQFHVDVGHVXURFLQR´ &RQMHUJDGHFDEDOOHURV KL]RDOOtVXSUHVHQWDGD HPSOHDQGRPLOMHULJRQ]DV TXHQDGLHOHGHVFLIUDED 'RQ)ULVDUGRGHOD0DQFKD TXHDVtGLMRVHOODPDED 5RFLQDQWHVXFDEDOOR HOSHQFRTXHOHDJXDQWDED /DVPR]DVOHSUHJXQWDURQ TXpTXHUtDGH\DQWDGD FXDOTXLHUFRVD\DQWDUtD 'RQ)ULVDUGRFRQWHVWDED $ODSXHUWDGHODYHQWD SRUTXHDOOtVHUHVIUHVFDUD WUDMpURQOHGHFHQDU JUDQFD]XHODGH³WUXFKDGD´ GLyOHVFRQWHQWRDODVWULSDV TXHYDFDQWHVODVOOHYDED 5LVDHUDYHUOHFRPHU SRUFXOSDGHODFHODGD QDGDOOHJDEDDODERFD VLGHDOJXLHQQRVHD\XGDED 8QFDVWUDGRUDODYHQWD HQHVWHSXQWROOHJDED KL]RVRQDUVXVLOEDWR DQXQFLDQGRVXOOHJDGD 'RQ)ULVDUGRDOHVFXFKDUOH P~VLFDVVHLPDJLQDED GHDOJ~QIDPRVRFDVWLOOR GRQGHGDPDVOHURGHDEDQ 0DQXHO*RQ]iOH]&DEUHUD 1RHUDHOKDPEUHQLHO GHVFDQVRORTXHPiVOHIDWLJDED VHUDUPDGRFDEDOOHUR HUDHODIiQTXHOOHYDED 3HUODV ³(ODQGDEDWDQGHVSDFLR HOVROWDQGHSULVDHQWUDED TXHGHUUHWtDOHORVVHVRV VLHVTXHDOJXQROHTXHGDED´ ³1RQIX\DQYXHVWUDV PHUFHGHV QLWRPHQWHPRUGHQDGD FDQRQFDEHDFDEDOOHURV IDFHUOHVGHVDJXLVDGD´ ³1XQFDIXHUDFDEDOOHUR GHGDPDVWDQELHQVHUYLGR FRPRORIXH'RQ)ULVDUGR TXHHVWDEDUHFLpQYHQLGR GRQFHOODVFXUDEDQGpO SULQFHVDVGHVXURFLQR´ M C$3,78/2,,, D21'(6(&8(17$/$)250$ (148(6($50Ï&$%$//(52325 819(17(52&216251$ PURVLJXLyVXORFRHPSHxR YHQWHULOFHQDDFDEDGD VHHQFHUUyFRQHOYHQWHUR \RWURVPXORVHQODFXDGUD KLQFDGRDQWHpOGHURGLOODV XQJUDQGRQOHVXSOLFDED TXHOHDUPDVHFDEDOOHUR RMDPiVVHOHYDQWDUD FRQVLQWLyHQHOORHOYHQWHUR TXHVRFDUUyQOHHVFXFKDED TXHDQGDEDIDOWRGHMXLFLR HOYHQWHUREDUUXQWDED OHGLMRTXHHUDDFHUWDGR DTXHOORTXHGHPDQGDED FRPRFDEHDXQFDEDOOHUR GHSUHVHQFLDWDQJDOODUGD 3RUVHJXLUOHODFRUULHQWH VXVKD]DxDVUHODWDED QXQFDIXHURQVXFHGLGDV TXHDOOtVHODVLQYHQWDED FDEDOOHURHQWLHPSRVPR]RV SRUWRGRHOPXQGRURQGDED 'H0iODJDORV3HUFKHOHV MDPiVORVDEDQGRQDED QLODVLVODVGH5LDUiQ &RPSiVGH6HYLOODDQGDED $]RJXHMRGH6HJRYLD 2OLYHUDYDOHQFLDQD QLODSOD\DGH6DQO~FDU QL5RQGLOODGH*UDQDGD WDPSRFRHO3RWURGH&yUGRED HQVXVYLDMHVROYLGDED \9HQWLOODVHQ7ROHGR \PXFKDVSDUWHVFRQWDED PXFKDVYLXGDV\GRQFHOODV FRQRFtD\HQJDxDED DXGLHQFLDV\WULEXQDOHV HQWRGRVWXYRSDUDGD UHFRJLGRHQVXFDVWLOOR DWRGRVGDEDSRVDGD 'tMROHTXHDTXHOFDVWLOOR FRQFDSLOODQRFRQWDED 0DQXHO*RQ]iOH]&DEUHUD TXHIXHUDOXJDUGHVHDGR GRQGHODVDUPDVYHODUD TXHHQXQSDWLRGHOFDVWLOOR HVDQRFKHVODVYHODUD TXHDODPDxDQDVLJXLHQWH FRQFHUHPRQLDOHDUPDUD 3UHJXQWyOHD'RQ)ULVDUGR VLDOJ~QGLQHUROOHYDED QLEODQFDGLMROOHYDU TXHQRORQHFHVLWDED TXHFDEDOOHURVDQGDQWHV QLQJXQRDOIRUMDVOOHYDED DORTXHGLMRHOYHQWHUR TXHDHVWHSXQWRVHHQJDxDED ODKLVWRULDQRORHVFULEtD SRUVHUFRVD\DDFODUDGD 3RUVDOLUGHDWROODGHUR PHWLGRHQHOTXHVHKDOODED UHFRPHQGyOHHOYHQWHUR TXHHQHOIXWXUROOHYDUD DOIRUMDV\DOJ~QGLQHUR \XQDFDPLVDODYDGD 3URPHWLyOH'RQ)ULVDUGR HOKDFHUORTXHPDQGDED FRQODPiVSXQWXDOLGDG TXHVXGHEHUOHGHMDUD 3RUTXHYHODVHODVDUPDV TXHHQHVDFRQWLHQGDHVWDED GHVLJQyOHXQJUDQFRUUDO TXHMXQWRDODYHQWDHVWDED S~VRODVVREUHXQDSLOD GRQGHHOJDQDGRDEUHYDED \FRQJHQWLOFRQWLQHQWH 'RQ)ULVDUGRODVYHODED &RQWyHOYHQWHURDODVJHQWHV TXHHQDTXHOODYHQWDHVWDEDQ ODORFXUDGHVXKXpVSHG HOTXHODVDUPDVYHODED $GPLUyOHVODORFXUD pOVRVHJDGRPLUDED QLXQPRPHQWRGHODVDUPDV VXVRMRVORVVHSDUDED &HUUDGDTXHGyODQRFKH SHURODOXQDDOXPEUDED PD\RUWXYRFODULGDG TXHDTXHOGHTXLHQODWRPDED $QWRMyVHOHDXQDUULHUR GHORVTXHHQODYHQWDHVWDEDQ SRUGDUOHDJXDDVXUHFXD ODSLODQHFHVLWDED ODVDUPDVGH'RQ)ULVDUGR GHODSLODODVTXLWDED HOFXDOTXHOHYLROOHJDU FRQYR]DOWDOHJULWDED £2KW~TXLHQTXLHUDTXHVHDV TXHHVDVDUPDVVRQYHODGDV GHOPiVIXHUWHFDEDOOHUR TXHMDPiVVHFLxyHVSDGD 0tUDWHELHQORTXHKDJDV 'RQ)ULVDUGRDPHQD]DED QRODVWRTXHVVLQRTXLHUHV TXHODYLGDWHFRVWDUD HODUULHURDHVWDVUD]RQHV DWHQFLyQQROHVSUHVWDED \IXHUDPHMRUWHQHUOD SRUTXHHQVDOXGVHFXUDUD WUDEyODVGHODVFRUUHDV \OHMRVODVDUURMDED HVWRTXHYLR'RQ)ULVDUGR D'XOFLQHDFODPDED ³£6RFRUUHGPHPLVHxRUD GHVWDSULPHUDDIUHQWDGD 5RPDQFHGHO&DEDOOHUR)ULVDUGR QRPHQHJXpLVDKRUD IDYRUTXHQHFHVLWDED´ <GLFLHQGRHVWRDODUULHUR WDQJUDQJROSHOHDVHVWDED FRQVXODQ]DHQODFDEH]D TXHDOVXHORORGHUULEDED YLQRGHVSXpVRWURDUULHUR KL]RWDPELpQODMXJDGD UHSLWLyOH'RQ)ULVDUGR RWUDFDEH]DUDMDGD $OUXLGRDFXGLyODJHQWH SDUDYHUORTXHSDVDED 'RQ)ULVDUGRHPEUD]yDGDUJD \SXVRPDQRDODHVSDGD YLDQGDQWHV\RWURVDUULHURV HQYLHQGRODDQLPDODGD DSHGUDGDVODHPSUHQGLHURQ TXHFRQODDGDUJDHVTXLYDED (OYHQWHURGDEDYRFHV GLFLpQGROHVFRPRHVWDED TXHSRUORFRVHOLEUDVH DXQTXHDWRGRVORVPDWDUD 'RQ)ULVDUGRSRUVXSDUWH PD\RUHVYRFHVOHVGDED OODPiEDOHVDOHYRVRV \WUDLGRUHVOHVOODPDED DOVHxRUGHDTXHOFDVWLOOR PDOQDFLGROROODPDED VLpO\DIXHVHFDEDOOHUR VXDOHYRVtDSDJDUD DORVRWURVGHVRHFHV \FDQDOODORVWUDWDED TXHVLDOJXQROHRIHQGLHVH VXGHPDVtDSDJDUD 7DQIXULEXQGRVHSXVR \WDOHVUHWRVODQ]DED TXHODJHQWHGHODYHQWD PLHGR\WHPRUOHFREUDED 3DUDHYLWDUPiVGHVJUDFLDV HOYHQWHURVHDEUHYLDED OOHJiQGRVHD'RQ)ULVDUGR DQWHpOVHGLVFXOSDED GtMROHTXHDTXHOFDVWLOOR FRQFDSLOODQRFRQWDED SDUDDUPDUOHFDEDOOHUR WDPSRFRODSUHFLVDED 'DUOHJUDQHVSDOGDUD]R GHVSXpVGHJUDQSHVFR]DGD SDUDDUPDUOHFDEDOOHUR SRUFHUHPRQLDEDVWDED &UH\yORDVt'RQ)ULVDUGR \GtMROHTXHDEUHYLDUD SRUTXHVL\DIXHVHDUPDGR WRGRVDOOtORVPDWDED $GYHUWLGR\WHPHURVR HOFDVWHOODQRTXHGDED WUDMRXQOLEURHQTXHODSDMD \ODFHEDGDDVHQWDED OOHJyVHFRQODVGRQFHOODV GRQGH'RQ)ULVDUGRHVWDED DOFXDOPDQGyTXHDQWHpO GHURGLOODVVHOHKLQFDUD PXUPXUDQGRXQDRUDFLyQ XQJUDQSHVFR]yQOHGDED \XQHVSDOGDUD]ROXHJR FRPRKDFLHQGRTXHUH]DED PDQGyOXHJRXQDGRQFHOOD TXHOHFLxHVHODHVSDGD GLMRODEXHQDVHxRUD PLHQWUDVFHxtDODHVSDGD 'LRVGpDYXHVWUDPHUFHG OLGHVELHQDYHQWXUDGDV 0DQXHO*RQ]iOH]&DEUHUD $ODGDPD'RQ)ULVDUGR SRUVXQRPEUHSUHJXQWDED VHJ~QHOODUHVSRQGLy OD7RORVDVHOODPDED ODRWUDGHODVGRVGDPDV ODVHVSXHODVOHFDO]DED WDPELpQDOOt'RQ)ULVDUGR SRUVXQRPEUHSUHJXQWDED PHOODPDQOD0ROLQHUD ODGRQFHOODFRQWHVWDED KLMDVR\GHXQPROLQHUR TXHHQ$QWHTXHUDKDELWDED +HFKDVSXHVODVFHUHPRQLDV 'RQ)ULVDUGRFDEDOJDED HOYHQWHURSRUQRYHUOH ODVFRVWDVOHSHUGRQDED 3HUODV 3URVLJXLyVXORFRHPSHxR YHQWHULOFHQDDFDEDGD VHHQFHUUyFRQHOYHQWHUR \RWURVPXORVHQODFXDGUD &HUUDGDTXHGyODQRFKH SHURODOXQDDOXPEUDED PD\RUWXYRFODULGDG TXHDTXHOGHTXLHQODWRPDED A C$3,78/2,9 E175(275$6&26$66( &8(17$/$3$/,=$48(/(',(521 $'260,//$6'(/$9(17$ AUPDGR\DFDEDOOHUR VDOLyGHODYHQWDDODOED WDQFRQWHQWR\WDQJDOODUGR TXHODFLQFKDUHYHQWDED GHDTXHOSHQFRUHYLHMDGR TXHSRUFDEDOORPRQWDED PDVYtQROHDODPHPRULD ORTXHHOYHQWHURFRQWDED VREUHHOGLQHUR\FDPLVD TXHGHQLQJXQROOHYDED (PSUHQGLyOXHJRHOFDPLQR TXHDVXDOGHDOHOOHYDED SRUSURFXUDUVHHVFXGHUR HQXQYHFLQRSHQVDED $SRFRVSDVRVDQGDGRV KDFLDVXYLHMDPRUDGD YRFHVOOHJDURQGHXQERVTXH TXHDGLHVWUDPDQRTXHGDED DSHQDVTXHODVR\HUD 'RQ)ULVDUGRVHDOHJUDED \GDEDJUDFLDVDO&LHOR TXHODRFDVLyQOHEULQGDED HQFDPLQyD5RFLQDQWH GRQGHODVYRFHVVHGDEDQ DSHQDVHQWUyHQHOERVTXH HQFRQWUyXQDOOHJXDDWDGD KDOOyWDPELpQXQPXFKDFKR TXHDSHQDVTXLQFHFRQWDED DWDGRHVWDDXQDHQFLQD HUDTXLHQODVYRFHVGDED GHPHGLRDUULEDGHVQXGR XQODEUDGRUOHD]RWDED FRQXQDJUXHVDSUHWLQD IXHUWHVFRUUHD]RVOHGDED SRUSHUGHUOHXQDVRYHMDV GHXQDKDWDMRTXHJXDUGDED (VWRTXHYLR'RQ)ULVDUGR WURQyOHFRQYR]DLUDGD GHVFRUWpVUXtQFDEDOOHUR SDJDUKDEUpLVODD]RWDGD $QWHDTXHOODODQ]DHQULVWUH GHDTXHOOD¿JXUDDUPDGD HOODEUDGRUSRUVXYLGD 0DQXHO*RQ]iOH]&DEUHUD QLFXDWURUHDOHVSDJDUD ODEUDGRUD'RQ)ULVDUGR ODVPLOUD]RQHVOHGDED GHODVFDXVDV\HOPRWLYR GHDTXHOODJUDQGHD]RWDGD ³¢0LHQWHGHODQWHGHPt" 'RQ)ULVDUGRSUHJXQWDED SRUHOVROTXHQRVDOXPEUD FRQPLODQ]DRVWUDVSDVDUD 3DJDGOHVLQRWUDUpSOLFD \VLQRTXH'LRVRVYDOJD SRUTXHDTXtHQHVWHSXQWR SRU'LRVTXHRVDQLTXLODUD´ (OODEUDGRUKXPLOODGR DVXFULDGRGHVDWDED FXiQWROHGHEtDHODPR 'RQ)ULVDUGRSUHJXQWDED (OGLMRTXHQXHYHPHVHV DVLHWHUHDOHVPHVDGD VHVHQWD\WUHVVRQORVUHDOHV TXH'RQ)ULVDUGRVDFDED 'LMROXHJRDOODEUDGRU TXHDOOtORVGHVHPEROVDUD VLQRTXHUtDPRULU SRUQRSDJDUODVROGDGD 5HVSRQGLyOHHOODEUDGRU TXHWDQWRQROHDGHXGDED TXHWUHVSDUHVGH]DSDWRV GHODFXHQWDGHVFRQWDUD %LHQVHTXHGHWRGRHVR 'RQ)ULVDUGRUHSOLFDED PDVTXpGHQVHORV]DSDWRV SRUYXHVWUDIXHUWHD]RWDGD (OPDOHVWiFDEDOOHUR HOODEUDGRUDSHODED TXHWHQJRHOGLQHURHQFDVD YHQJDTXHDOOtOHSDJDUD ,UPHFRQpOQLSRUSLHQVR HOPR]ROHUHSOLFDED SRUTXHHQKDOOiQGRPHVyOR DJROSHVPHGHVROODUD 1RKDUiWDOHOFDEDOOHUR 'RQ)ULVDUGRUHSOLFDED EDVWDTXH\RVHORPDQGH SRUTXHSDJXHODVROGDGD MXURTXHVtODSDJR HOODEUDGRUFRQWHVWDED \DXQVHORVGDUpVDKXPDGRV ORVUHDOHVGHODVROGDGD 'HOVDKXPHULRRVKDJRJUDFLD 'RQ)ULVDUGRFRQWHVWDED VHORGDUHLVWRGRHQUHDOHV TXHFRQHVRPHEDVWDED 'LFLHQGRHVWRD5RFLQDQWH SLFyHVSXHODV\YRODED HOODEUDGRUDVXFULDGR GHVWDPDQHUDOHKDEODED ³£9HQLGDFiKLMRPtR SRUTXHRVSDJXHODVROGDGD´ HVRMXURGLMRÈQGUpV TXHDVtHOPR]RVHOODPDED ³(VRWDPELpQMXUR\R HOODEUDGRUUHSOLFDED TXLHURDFUHFHQWDUODGHXGD SRUDFUHFHQWDUODSDJD´ $VLpQGROHSRUXQEUD]R FRQWUDODHQFLQDORDWDED GLyOHWDQWRVODWLJD]RV TXHSRUPXHUWRORGHMDED 3RU¿QDOFDERGHXQUDWR HODPRORGHVDWDED $QGUpVVHTXHGyOORUDQGR 5RPDQFHGHO&DEDOOHUR)ULVDUGR HODPRULHQGRTXHGDED 'RQ)ULVDUGRVDWLVIHFKR DVXDOGHDFDPLQDED GHDTXHOODFXHUGDDYHQWXUD RIUHFLyHOWULXQIRDVXDPDGD D\HUVHDUPyFDEDOOHUR KR\HQWXHUWRVDOODQDED OLEUyGHOOiWLJRDXQFULDGR DTXLHQVXDPRD]RWDED 0HWLGRHQFDYLODFLRQHV DOFDQ]yODHQFUXFLMDGD HUDQFXDWURORVFDPLQRV SDUWLHQGRGHOTXHOOHYDED SHQVDQGRHVWXYRJUDQWLHPSR SRUFXDOGHWRGRVWRPDED VROWyULHQGDD5RFLQDQWH TXHSXVRUXPERDODFXDGUD 1RDQGDGDVHUDQGRVPLOODV XQJUDQWURSHOVHDFHUFDED PHUFDGHUHVWROHGDQRV TXHD0XUFLDVHHQFDPLQDED QXHYDRFDVLyQGHDYHQWXUD 'RQ)ULVDUGRDGLYLQDED $¿UPDGRHQORVHVWULERV DGDUJD\ODQ]DHPSXxDED DQWHDTXHOORVFDEDOOHURV HVWDVGLDWULEDVODQ]DED ³WRGRHOPXQGRVHGHWHQJD VLDOSXQWRQRFRQIHVDUD VHUODKHUPRVD'XOFLQHD EHOOH]DQXQFDLJXDODGD´ R\HQGRDTXHVWDVUD]RQHV GHTXLHQWDOSRUWHPRVWUDED FDWDURQORVPHUFDGHUHV TXHGHXQORFRVHWUDWDED HOPHUFDGHUSLGHSUXHEDV GHDTXHOORTXHSUHJRQDED QHJyVHODV'RQ)ULVDUGR TXHFRQSUXHEDVQRFRQWDED XQRTXHVLHUDWXHUWD RTXL]iTXHFRUFRYDGD RWURTXHVLPiVGHUHFKD TXHKXVRVGH*XDGDUUDPD QDGLHDORWURFRQYHQFtD TXHDORVGRVUD]yQVREUDED 1RYHQFLHQGRFRQUD]RQHV DODVDUPDVDSHODED DUUHPHWLyFRQVXODQ]D EDMDFRQWUDTXLHQKDEODED DODPLWDGGHOFDPLQR 5RFLQDQWHWURSH]DED ODQ]yDODPRSRUORVVXHORV TXHXQODUJRWUHFKRURGDED 0XFKRTXLVROHYDQWDUVH FRVDTXHQXQFDORJUDED FHODGDODQ]D\HVSXHODV \DGDUJDVHORHVWRUEDEDQ <HQWDQWRTXHHQOHYDQWDUVH FRQJUDQHVIXHU]RSXMDED HQYLHQGRTXHQRSRGtD DORVDUULHURVJULWDED ³1RQIX\iLVJHQWHFREDUGH JHQWHFDXWLYD\PDOYDGD ODFXOSDIXHGHOFDEDOOR TXHDOWURSH]DUPHWLUDED´ 8QRGHDTXHOORVPXOHURV TXHPDODLQWHQFLyQOOHYDED UHVSXHVWDDWDQWDDUURJDQFLD HQODVFRVWLOODVOHGDED (VWRDSURYHFKyXQPXOHUR YLHQGRTXHQROHYDQWDED URPSLHQGRHQWUR]RVODODQ]D 0DQXHO*RQ]iOH]&DEUHUD JUDQ³DPDVLMR´OHGDED ³PROOyOHFRPRDFLEHUD´ DOOtPiVSDORVOHGDED TXHMDPiVVHGLRDXQDHVWHUD \SRUPXHUWRORGHMDED 'iEDQOHYRFHVVXVDPRV SRUTXHPiVQROHDSDOHDUD SHURHOPR]R\DSLFDGR ³WRGRHOUHVWROHHQYLGDED´ ORVGHPiVWUR]RVGHODQ]D WDPELpQVHORVDVWLOODED $SHVDUGHWDOSDOL]D VXERFDQXQFDFHUUDED FRQDPHQD]DVDO&LHOR \DOD7LHUUDHQTXHVHKDOODED 3DUWLHURQORVPHUFDGHUHV pOHQHOVXHORTXHGDED LQWHQWDUDOHYDQWDUVH FRVDTXHQXQFDORJUDED FD\pUDVHWDQWDVYHFHV FXDQWDVRWUDVORLQWHQWDED 7HQtDVHSRUGLFKRVR GHODGHVJUDFLDSDVDGD SDUHFLpQGROHVHUSURSLD GHFDEDOOHUHVFDDQGDGD N C$3,78/29 TXHQRWHGXHOHPLPDO" 2QRORVDEHVVHxRUD RHUHVIDOVD\GHVOHDO´ S(&8(17$$48Ë48(81 <SURVLJXLHQGRHOURPDQFH 9(&,12$3$/($'2/2(1&2175$%$ GHVWHPRGRFRQWLQXDED <0217È1'2/2(168%8552$/ £2KQREOHPDUTXpVGH 38(%/2/25(*5(6$%$ 0DQWXD PLVHxRU\WtRFDUQDO´ VLHQGRSXHVTXHHQHIHFWR (QHVWHSXQWRXQYHFLQR DPHQHDUVHQRDOFDQ]DED TXHGHOPROLQRWRUQDED UHFRUGDQGRD9DOGRYLQRV SUHJXQWyOH¢TXpVHQWtD" \DOGH0DQWXDUHFRUGDED TXHWDQWULVWHVHTXHMDED TXH&DUORWRHQODPRQWDxD 'RQ)ULVDUGRDOODEUDGRU PDOKHULGRORGHMDED SRUHOGH0DQWXDWRPDED KLVWRULDELHQFRQRFLGD \SURVLJXLHQGRHOURPDQFH \SRUWRGRVFHOHEUDGD VXVGHVJUDFLDVOHFRQWDED FRQWRGRQRPiVFUHtEOH (OODEUDGRUGHHVFXFKDUOH TXHORVPLODJURVTXHREUDED DVRPEUDGRVHTXHGDED 0DKRPDDOOiHQODVDUHQDV R\HQGRORVGLVSDUDWHV GHDTXHOOD$UDELDGRUDGD TXHGHVGHHOVXHORFRQWDED 3DUHFLyHVWDGHPROGH TXLWiQGROHODYLVHUD SDUDHOSDVRHQTXHVHKDOODED TXHWHQtDGHVWUR]DGD FRPRLPLWDQGRDOGHOERVTXH OHOLPSLyHOURVWURGHOSROYR GHFtDPLHQWUDVURGDED TXHODFDUDOHWDSDED ³¢'yQGHHVWiVVHxRUDPtD UHFRQRFLyOH\OHGLMR 0DQXHO*RQ]iOH]&DEUHUD £YiOJDPHVHxRU)ULVDUGD TXHDVtGHEtDOODPDUVH FXDQGRHOMXLFLROHDEXQGDED (QYLpQGROHKHFKRSHGD]RV SRUORVKHFKRVSUHJXQWDED DTXHOVLJXLyVXURPDQFH \DQDGDOHFRQWHVWDED OHGLRHOODEUDGRUSRUORFR YLHQGRODVSUXHEDVTXHGDED OHDFRPRGyFRPRSXGR VREUHHOEXUURTXHOOHYDED 5HFRJLyOXHJRODVDUPDV WRGDVURWDV\DVWLOODGDV OLyODVVREUH5RFLQDQWH \DOSXHEORVHHQFDPLQDED 7DQTXHEUDQWDGR\PROLGR 'RQ)ULVDUGRVHHQFRQWUDED TXHDO&LHORJUDQGHVVXVSLURV GHYH]HQFXDQGRODQ]DED GHQXHYRDTXHOODEUDGRU SRUVXVPDOHVSUHJXQWDED WDOSDUHFtDTXHHOGLDEOR ORVFXHQWRVOHUHFRUGDED 2OYLGDQGRD9DOGRYLQRV $ELQGDUUiH]UHFRUGDED FXDQGR5RGULJR1DUYiH] GH$QWHTXHUDORDSUHVDED VLHPSUHDODVPLVPDV SUHJXQWDV ODVPLVPDVUHVSXHVWDVGDED FRPRDTXHO0RQWHPD\RU HQ/D'LDQDHQDPRUDGD 'XUDQWHHOODUJRFDPLQR ODVPLOOH\HQGDVFRQWDED DOODEUDGRUGHHVFXFKDUOH HOGLDEORVHOROOHYDED &RQRFLyTXHVXYHFLQR ORFRGHUHPDWHDQGDED GLyVHSULVDSRUOOHJDU GHWDQWRTXHOHHQIDGDED $O¿QGHVXODUJDDUHQJD DVtGRQ)ULVDUGRKDEODED D5RGULJRGH1DUYiH] FRPRDOODEUDGRUOODPDED ³6HSDODYXHVWUDPHUFHG TXHHVWD-DULIDQRPEUDGD HV'XOFLQHDGHO7RERVR SRUTXLHQPLVIHFKRV\RKDJD´ ³0tUHPHYXHVWUDPHUFHG HOODEUDGRUUHSOLFDED VXPHUFHGQRHV9DOGRYLQRV VLQRHOKRQUDGR)ULVDUGD QL\R5RGULJR1DUYiH] QLHOGH0DQWXDPHOODPDED VLQRTXHVR\3HGUR$ORQVR YHFLQRGRQGHKDELWDED´ (QHVWDSOiWLFDV\RWUDV DODQRFKHFHUOOHJDEDQ QRTXLVRTXHD'RQ)ULVDUGR OHYLHVHQORPDOTXHHVWDED (QWUDGDHVWDEDODQRFKH FXDQGRDVXFDVDOOHJDED FRQHOEDUEHUR\HOFXUD UHYXHOWD\DOERURWDGD DOOtHODPDD3HGUR3pUH] DYRFHVOHFRPHQWDED WUHVGtDVOOHYDSHUGLGR VLQVDEHUSRUGyQGHDQGDED DOOtPDOGLMRORVOLEURV DTXLHQODFXOSDOHHFKDED DEXQGDQGRVXVREULQD D1LFROiVOHFRQWDED 5RPDQFHGHO&DEDOOHUR)ULVDUGR TXHVXWtRFRQORVOLEURV ODUJRVGtDVVHSDVDED OXHJRDOFDERGHORVFXDOHV SRQtDPDQRDODHVSDGD FRQPXHEOHV\FRQSDUHGHV DFXFKLOODGDVDQGDED TXHPDWyDFXDWURJLJDQWHV \DPX\FDQVDGRFRQWDED TXHVDQJUHGHODVKHULGDV HUDHOVXGRUTXHVXGDED EHEtDXQMDUURGHDJXDIUtD FRQHVRVHVRVHJDED HUDEHELGDTXH(VTXLIH VXJUDQDPLJROHHQYLDED 0DV\RPHWHQJRODFXOSD SRUTXHHQWLHPSRVQRDYLVDUD SDUDTXHWRGRVORVOLEURV SRUKHUHMHVVHTXHPDUDQ (QHVWRFRLQFLGHHOFXUD TXHDOIXHJRORVFRQGHQDED HVWRR\HUDHOODEUDGRU TXHWUDVODSXHUWDHVSHUDED GLVLSyWRGDVRVSHFKD VREUHHOPDOTXHOHDTXHMDED ³$EUDQPHYXHVWUDVPHUFHGHV´ DORVGHGHQWURJULWDED ³DEUDQD'RQ9DOGRYLQRV \DOGH0DQWXD´TXHOOHJDED DORVJULWRVDFXGLHURQ SDUDYHUTXLHQWDOHVGDED SDUDDEUD]DUDOKLGDOJR ODJHQWHVHDEDODQ]DED ³7pQJDQVHYXHVWUDVPHUFHGHV TXHYHQJRKHULGRJULWDED ODFXOSDWXYRHOFDEDOOR OODPHQDODVDELD8UJDQGD ³0LUDW~VLHQKRUDPDOD GHFtDDOSXQWRODFULDGD PHGHFtDHOFRUD]yQ GHODSDWDTXHFRMHDED £PDOGLWRVVHDQORVOLEURV GHFDEDOOHUtDDUPDGD TXHWDODYXHVWUDPHUFHG GHMDUDQWDQPDOSDUDGD´ %XVFiURQOHODVKHULGDV SHURQLQJXQDOOHYDED WRGRHUDPROLPLHQWR TXHHOFDEDOORWURSH]DED FRPEDWLHQGRDGRVMD\DQHV GHIRUPDGHVDIRUDGD £7DWDGLMRDOSXQWRHOFXUD ¢MD\DQHVKD\HQGDQ]DGD" DQWHVTXHOOHJXHODQRFKH TXHPDUpDPLVDQWLJXDGD +LFLpURQOHPLOSUHJXQWDV SHURDWRGDVFRQWHVWDED TXHHUDFRPHU\GRUPLU ORTXHPiVQHFHVLWDED (OFXUDGHOODEUDGRU DPSOLDPHQWHVHLQIRUPDED GHORKHFKR\GHORGLFKR PLOGLVSDUDWHVFRQWDED GHFLGLyVHHOOLFHQFLDGR SRUKDFHUORTXHGHVHDED HQFDVDGH'RQ)ULVDUGR DOOtDOEDUEHURFLWDED C C$3,78/29, HUDHOTXHDOOtVHIRUPDED SRUHOWHPDRHODXWRU FDGDHMHPSODUVHMX]JDED S(&8(17$$48Ë&202(/ DOOtVHMX]JyDORVOLEURV &85$&21(/%$5%(52</$6 TXH'RQ)ULVDUGRJXDUGDED '$0$6&21'(1$521$/$6//$0$6 SRUUHVSRQVDEOHVGLUHFWRV $/26/,%526'($9(1785$ GHDTXHOPDOTXHOHDTXHMDED GHVSXpVTXHIXHUDMX]JDGRV MLHQWUDV)ULVDUGRGRUPtD DOFRUUDOVHOHVHFKDED DFWXDEDGHSUHVLGHQWH SRUORPROLGRTXHHVWDED 3HGUR3pUH]OLFHQFLDGR HQWUiURQVHDODSRVHQWR TXHDVtHOFXUDVHOODPDED GRQGHORVOLEURVJXDUGDED GRQ1LFROiVHOEDUEHUR HODPDHQWUDEDFRQHOORV FRPR¿VFDOVHSRUWDED PiVGHFLHQOLEURVKDOODEDQ FRQODVREULQD\HODPD JUDQGHVELHQHQFXDGHUQDGRV ODFRUWHVHFRPSOHWDED PiVRWURVTXHQRORHVWDEDQ -X]JDURQFDVRSRUFDVR OOHYyHODPDDJXDEHQGLWD SDUDYHUFXiOVHTXHPDED SRUTXHHOFXUDORVURFLDUD PXFKRVIXHURQFRQGHQDGRV \DOGHPRQLRGHORVOLEURV DOJ~QWDOFXDOVHVDOYDED DOLQ¿HUQRORVHFKDUD SRUHVWHLQWHUFHGHHOFXUD 5HXQLGRVFXUD\EDUEHUR DTXHOORFRQGHQDHODPD FRQODVREULQD\ODFULDGD TXLHQQRWLHQHYDOHGRU DO]yVHJUDQWULEXQDO HVDUURMDGRDODOODPD PLHQWUDVDTXHOGHVFDQVDED $ODV³6HUJDVGH(VSODQGLiQ´ WULEXQDOFRQWUDODVOHWUDV 0DQXHO*RQ]iOH]&DEUHUD DOIXHJRVHFRQGHQDED OXHJRIXH³$PDGtVGH*UHFLD´ HOTXHDOIXHJRVHDUURMDED YD\DQWRGRVDOFRUUDO DOOtHOFXUDVHQWHQFLDED DXQTXHOD³3LQWLTXLQHVWUD´ \³'DULQHO´VHTXHPDUD \¢TXLpQHVHVHWRQHO" HOFXUDOHVSUHJXQWDED ³'RQ2OLYDQWHGH/DXUD´ HOEDUEHURFRQWHVWDED ³'RQ)ORULVPDUWHGH +LUFDQLD´ GHVHJXQGRVHMX]JDED SXHVYD\DSUHVWRDOFRUUDO HOEXHQFXUDVHQWHQFLDED ³(O&DEDOOHUR3ODWLU´ HOEDUEHURSUHVHQWDED DFRPSDxHDORVGHPiV TXHQRKD\YHQLDTXHOHYDOJD ³&DEDOOHURGHOD&UX]´ SRUVLJXLHQWHVHMX]JDED ³WUDVGHODFUX]HVWiHOGLDEOR´ \DOIXHJRVHFRQGHQDED ³(VSHMRFDEDOOHUHVFR´ HUDHORWURTXHOOHJDED GH5HLQDOGRV0RQWDOEiQ TXHHQSR]RVHFRVHHFKDED /OHJy³3DOPHUtQGH2OLYD´ \MXQWRFRQpOOOHJDED HO³3DOPHUtQGH,QJODWHUUD´ \DVtHOFXUDVHQWHQFLDED KiJDVHUDMDVODROLYD \YD\DDOIXHJRDUURMDGD HVDSDOPDGH,QJODWHUUD SRU~QLFDVHDJXDUGDGD 6HVDOYy³$PDGtVGH*DXOD´ TXHFXDWUROLEURVIRUPDED SRUVHUSULPHURHQ(VSDxD TXHHQLPSUHQWDVHHGLWDED <³3DOPHUtQGH,QJODWHUUD´ TXHXQVDELRUH\OR¿UPDED SRUGRVYDOLRVDVYLUWXGHV FRQODVTXHHOOLEURFRQWDED XQDSRUTXHIXHUDUH\ GH3RUWXJDOTXLHQ¿UPDED RWUDSRUTXHIXHUDEXHQR FXDQWRHQHOOLEURFRQWDED +HFKDVODVGRVH[FHSFLRQHV HOVHYHURMXH]PDQGDED £YD\DQWRGRVDODKRJXHUD \PiVGHXQFLHQWRTXHPDED ³£7pQJDVHHQHVRFRPSDGUH HOEDUEHUROHHVSHWDED WHQJRDTXt³'RQ%HOLDQtV´ TXHQRVHTXHPDSRUQDGD´ ³SXHVWHQHGORYRVFRPSDGUH HOFXUDOHUHSOLFDED DQDGLHGHVSRUOHFWXUD TXpGHVHSRUUHVHUYDGD \GHVHDODXWRUUXLEDUER HOFXUDOHUHFHWDED SRUTXHSXUJXHFRQVXLUD ODLPSHUWLQHQFLDPRVWUDGD´ \ORVGHPiVDOFRUUDO \DOIXHJRORVFRQGHQDED TXHHODPDFRQJUDQFRQWHQWR SRUODYHQWDQDDUURMDED &D\yVHOHGHOPRQWyQ XQRTXHVHWLWXODED ³+LVWRULDGHOFDEDOOHUR 7LUDQWHHO%ODQFR´UH]DED 5RPDQFHGHO&DEDOOHUR)ULVDUGR ³£YiOJDPH'LRVGLMRHOFXUD FXDQGRWDOQRPEUHHVFXFKDED GHVSXpVGHPLODODEDQ]DV SDUDVtVHORTXHGDED ³4XLULHOHLVyQ0RQWDOEiQ´ DFRQWLQXDFLyQOOHJDED \HOFDEDOOHUR³)RQVHFD´ TXHFRQ7LUDQWHOXFKDED GRQGH³3ODFHUGHPLYLGD´ VXVDJXGH]DVFRQWDED FRQORVHPEXVWHV\DPRUHV GHODYLXGD³5HSRVDGD´ ODVHxRUD(PSHUDWUL] GH+LSyOLWRHQDPRUDGD \RWUDVFRVDVTXHRWURVOLEURV FDUHFHQ\DTXtVHKDOODEDQ OOHYDGOHDFDVD\OHHGOH HOFXUDUHFRPHQGDED DVtVHUiVHxRUFXUD HOEDUEHURFRQWHVWDED ¢4XpKDUHPRVFRQORV SHTXHxRV" HOEDUEHURLQWHUURJDED HVRVWUDWDQGHSRHVtD HVORTXHHOFXUDDFODUDED ³QRPHUHFHQVHUTXHPDGRV´ QRVRQFXOSDEOHVGHQDGD FRQWUDULDIXHODVREULQD TXHGHRWURPRGRRSLQDED SRUWHPRUGHTXHVXWtR QXHYDORFXUDWRPDUD HQOLEUDQGRODSUHVHQWH VLHVTXHDOLEDUODOOHJDED %LHQKDGLFKRHVWDGRQFHOOD HOFXUDOHUHSOLFDED \ELHQVHUiTXHHOWURSLH]R GHGHODQWHVHTXLWDUD &RPHQ]DPRVSRU³/D'LDQD´ TXHQRGHEHVHUTXHPDGD TXLWDQGRYHUVRVPD\RUHV TXHODSURVDVHTXHGDUD ³/D'LDQDGH6DOPDQWLQR´ DOIXHJRVHFRQGHQDED \³/D'LDQDGH*LO3ROR´ HUDGHOIXHJRLQGXOWDGD 'HORVOLEURVGHSRHVtD ³/DGH%UHPDQ´VHOLEUDED FRQWUDORVPLOGHWUDFWRUHV FRQTXHVLQGXGDFRQWDED WDPELpQGH0RQWHPD\RU HUD³/D'LDQD´LQGXOWDGD \³/D)RUWXQDGHDPRU´ PX\ODUJDPHQWHHORJLDGD ORVGLH]OLEURVTXHODIRUPDQ VRQGHXQDJUDFLDH[WUHPDGD GRQGHVHGDQORVVXFHVRV GHIRUPDGLVSDUDWDGD (VWHHV³(O3DVWRUGH,EHULD´ HOEDUEHURSUHVHQWDED HVWH³1LQIDVGHO+HQDUHV´ TXHFRPRDORWURTXHPDED (VWH³(O3DVWRUGH)LOLGD´ DOTXHWDPELpQVHJXDUGDED ³7HVRURGHODVSRHVtDV´ HOEDUEHURWUDVKRMDED OtPSLHVHGHVXVEDMH]DV \TXHOXHJRVHJXDUGDUD (O³&DQFLRQHURGH/ySH]´ HOEDUEHUROHDQXQFLDED JXiUGHVHMXQWRDORVRWURV TXHVXVYHUVRVDGPLUDEDQ 2WUDVPXFKDVVHVDOYDURQ 0DQXHO*RQ]iOH]&DEUHUD DTXLHQHOFXUDLQGXOWDED SRUDPLJR\FRQRFLGR GHODXWRUTXHODV¿UPDED 7DPELpQIXH³/D*DODWHD´ REUDTXHHOFXUDLQGXOWDED GHXQWDO0LJXHOGH&HUYDQWHV SRUODDPLVWDGTXHJXDUGDED PiVYHUVDGRIXHHQGHVGLFKDV TXHHQORVYHUVRVTXHFDQWDED \ORPLVPR³/D$UDXFDQD´ \(O0RQVHUUDWH´\³/D $XVWULDGD´ \³/DV/iJULPDVGH$QJpOLFD´ PXQGLDOPHQWHFHOHEUDGD &DQVDGRGHYHUPiVOLEURV DVtDFDUJDFHUUDGD TXHORVGHPiVVHTXHPDVHQ IXHODVHQWHQFLDGLFWDGD ³/DVOiJULPDVGH$QJpOLFD´ SRU~OWLPRSUHVHQWDGD HVWDVOORUiUDODV\R VLDOIXHJRODVFRQGHQDUD E C$3,78/29,, R(38(672<$'(/$&$,'$ 6(*8,'2'(68(6&8'(52 (035(1',Ï18(9$6$/,'$ MLHQWUDVMX]JDEDQORVOLEURV 'RQ)ULVDUGRGHVSHUWDED ORVXSLHURQSRUORVJULWRV \JUDQGHVYRFHVTXHGDED SRUDFXGLUDOHVWUXHQGR ODYLVWDQRFRQWLQXDED \VLQVHUYLVWRQLOHtGR WRGROLEURVHTXHPDED /OHJDURQD'RQ)ULVDUGR TXH\DOHYDQWDGRHVWDED \UHSDUWLHQGRDGRVPDQRV UHYpVFRQWUDFXFKLOODGD DODIXHU]DORYROYLHURQ DODFDPDGRQGHHVWDED VHUHQR\D\VRVHJDGR FRQHOFXUDFRQYHUVDED 3RUDU]RELVSR7XUStQ 'RQ)ULVDUGRORQRPEUDED GHLUSHUGLHQGRHQHOWRUQHR WULVWHPHQWHVHTXHMDED ³&DOOHVXPHUFHGFRPSDGUH HOFXUDOHFRQVRODED TXHELHQVHUi'LRVVHUYLGR \TXHODVXHUWHPXGDUD ODTXHKR\VHSHUGLHUD VHUiPDxDQDJDQDGD GHVFDQVHYXHVWUDPHUFHG GHWDQWDKHULGDFDXVDGD´ ³+HULGR\RQRPHHQFXHQWUR 'RQ)ULVDUGRUHSOLFDED PDVTXHEUDQWDGR\PROLGR QLQJXQDGXGDTXHGDED HOEDVWDUGR'RQ5ROGiQ TXHPLYDORUHQYLGLDED FRQHOWURQFRGHXQDHQFLQD DSDORVPHGHVORPDED PDVQRIXHUD\R5HLQDOGRV VLHVWDQRPHODSDJDUD WUiLJDQPHDKRUDGH\DQWDU TXH\DKDUp\RODYHQJDGD´ $TXHOODQRFKHDEUDVy WRGRVORVOLEURVHODPD FXDQWRVKXER\HQFRQWUy 0DQXHO*RQ]iOH]&DEUHUD IXHURQSDFWRGHODOODPD 3RUHOEDUEHUR\HOFXUD HVWDVROXFLyQIXHGDGD TXHVHWDSLDVHDSRVHQWR GRQGHORVOLEURVJXDUGDED $OFDERGHSRFRVGtDV TXH\DPHMRUVHHQFRQWUDED SRUHOFXDUWR\SRUORVOLEURV 'RQ)ULVDUGRSUHJXQWDED ³¢4XpEXVFDYXHVWUDPHUFHG QLTXpOLEURVQLTXpQDGD" QRKD\OLEURVHQHVWDFDVD HODPDOHFRQWHVWDED´ ³ORVOOHYyXQHQFDQWDGRU ODVREULQDOHDSR\DED TXHGHVFHQGLyGHXQDVLHUSH \DODSRVHQWRVHHQWUDED QRGHMyOLEURQLQJXQR QLHODSRVHQWRGHMDED DOSDUWLUVHOXHJRGLMR TXH0XxDWyQVHOODPDED´ 0HMRUGLMHUDV)UHVWyQ 'RQ)ULVDUGROHHQPHQGDED VyORVpTXHDFDEDHQ³WRQ´ HODPDOHFRQWHVWDED ³(VXQVDELRHQFDQWDGRU 'RQ)ULVDUGRFRQWLQXDED SURWHFWRUGHPLHQHPLJR TXHPHODWLHQHMXUDGD´ ³¢4XLpQSXHGHGXGDUHQHVR" ODVREULQDFRQWHVWDED SXHGHTXHYXHVWUDPHUFHG YXHOYDXQGtDWUDVTXLODGD´ ³&XiQPDOHVWiVHQODFXHQWD 'RQ)ULVDUGRUHSOLFDED SULPHURTXHPHWUDVTXLOHQ EDUEDVWUHQGUpOHVSHODGDV´ 'HSDUWLHQGRFRQHOFXUD FRQODVREULQD\HODPD WUDQVFXUULHURQTXLQFHGtDV HQWUHHOVRVLHJR\ODFDOPD (QDTXHOWLHPSRDXQYHFLQR TXHFRUWRHQPROOHUDDQGDED FRQYHQFLyFRQPLOSURPHVDV \HVFXGHURORQRPEUDED $TXLHQWRPyGHHVFXGHUR 3DQFKRGHQRPEUHOOHYDED DQFKRGHSDQ]D³3DQ]DQFKR´ \FRQ3DQFKRVHTXHGDED FXHUSRUHFKRQFKR\PRUHQR GHODUJDSLHUQD\GHOJDGD ODFDEH]DQRHUDJUDQGH pUDOHELHQUHGRQGHDGD HUDGHKXPDQRVSHQVDUHV GHDQGDGXUDVRVHJDGD FRQPiVSDFLHQFLDTXH-RE FRPRDHVFXGHURFXDGUDED 6L³HQTXtWDPHDOOiHVDVSDMDV´ XQDtQVXODJDQDUD 'RQ)ULVDUGRVXVHxRU JREHUQDGRUORQRPEUDUD WDQWRRIUHFLy\SURPHWLy \WDQWDHVSHUDQ]DGDED TXH3DQFKR*UDQ]DDFHSWy HOFDUJRTXHOHEULQGDED /OHYiQGRVHGHOFRQVHMR TXHDTXHOYHQWHUROHGDED SRUSURFXUDUVHXQGLQHUR VXSDWULPRQLRHPSHxDED TXHOOHYDVHXQDVDOIRUMDV DVXHVFXGHURRUGHQDED 5RPDQFHGHO&DEDOOHUR)ULVDUGR SRUVXSDUWHXQDVFDPLVDV SRUFRQVHMRVHOOHYDED /HGLMR3DQFKRTXHVXDVQR HQOOHYiUVHORSHQVDED SRUTXHpODQGDQGRGHSLH PXFKRWLHPSRQRDJXDQWDED (QHODVXQWRGHODVQR 'RQ)ULVDUGRUHSDUDED SRUTXHXQHVFXGHURDVQDGR GHQDGLHVHOHDFRUGDED 3UHSDUDGRVORVSHUWUHFKRV TXHFDGDFXDOSUHFLVDED SDUWLpURQVH\DGHQRFKH FXDQGRQDGLHORHVSHUDED 3DQFKRVREUHVXMXPHQWR FRPRXQSDWULDUFDVHKDOODED FRQODERWD\ODVDOIRUMDV HQVXtQVXODVRxDED 3RUORVFDPSRVGH0RQWLHO 'RQ)ULVDUGRFDEDOJDED VHJXLGRSRU3DQFKR*UDQ]D TXHDVXMXPHQWRPRQWDED 3DQFKR*UDQ]DVXHVFXGHUR ODVSURPHVDVUHIUHVFDED ³QRROYLGHYXHVWUDPHUFHG ODtQVXODVHxDODGD´ ³+DVGHVDEHU6DQFKRDPLJR 'RQ)ULVDUGROHLQIRUPDED TXHQRPEUDUJREHUQDGRUHV IXHFRVWXPEUHPX\OOHYDGD HOEXHQFDEDOOHURDQGDQWH TXHDOJ~QUHLQRFRQTXLVWDED SRUGHXGDVFRQVXHVFXGHUR JREHUQDGRUORQRPEUDED \\RWHSURPHWRPiV 'RQ)ULVDUGRFRQWLQXDED TXHVL\RJDQDVHUHLQRV UH\GHDOJXQRWHQRPEUDED´ ³'HHVWDPDQHUDVHxRU 3DQFKR*UDQ]DOHDFODUDED -XDQD*XWLpUUH]PLHVSRVD HQUHLQDVHWUDQVIRUPDED´ ³¢4XLpQORGXGDPLEXHQ 3DQFKR" 'RQ)ULVDUGRSUHJXQWDED´ ³HQHVRSRQJR\RGXGDV VXFULDGROHFRQWHVWDED SRUTXHWHQJRSDUDPt TXHDXQTXHUHLQRVGLOXYLDUD 0DU*XWLpUUH]HQWRGRV OHFDEH]DOHEDLODUD TXHQLDGRVPDUDYHGtV SDUDVHUUHLQDOOHJDUD FRQGHVDVHUiPHMRU HVWRVL'LRVODD\XGDED´ ³(QFRPLpQGDORW~D'LRV 'RQ)ULVDUGROHLQGLFDED PDVW~QRWHDSRTXHVWDQWR TXHFRQPHQRVWHEDVWDUD´ (VFXGHURDFDEDOOHUR DOWRTXHUHVSXHVWDGDED DOOtHOXQRSRQHVXHxRV GRQGHHORWURGHOLUDED D C$3,78/29,,, E63$17$%/(<181&$9,67$ 1,-$0È6,0$*,1$'$ %$7$//$48('21)5,6$5'2 &2175$02/,126/,%5$%$ <2752668&(62648(621 '()(/,=5(&25'$&,21 EQHVWRSRUODOODQXUD TXHDGRTXLHUVHGLODWDED GHXQRVFXDUHQWDPROLQRV HOSHU¿OVHUHFRUWDED HQYLpQGRORV'RQ)ULVDUGR SRUJLJDQWHVORVWRPDED KDEODQGRFRQVXHVFXGHUR HVWDVUD]RQHVOHGDED ³'HDTXHOORVJLJDQWHV3DQFKR TXHYHVFRQVXODUJDHVSDGD VHUiEXHQVHUYLFLRD'LRV TXLWDUVLPLHQWHWDQPDOD´ ¢4XpJLJDQWHV"GLMR3DQFKR TXHDORVPROLQRVPLUDED DTXHOORVTXHDOOtORVYHV 'RQ)ULVDUGRFRQWHVWDED ORVGHORVEUD]RVWDQODUJRV TXHDODVGRVOHJXDVOOHJDED ³0LUHELHQYXHVWUDPHUFHG 3DQFKR*UDQ]DOHDYLVDED TXHDTXHOORVQRVRQJLJDQWHV VRQPROLQRVDFODUDED \FDGDEUD]RHVXQDVSD TXHVHPXHYHDOVHUYROWHDGD´ ³%LHQSDUHFHDPLJR3DQFKR TXHGHVWRQRVDEHVQDGD TXtWDWHVLWLHQHVPLHGR TXHYR\DHQWUDHQEDWDOOD´ 'LFLHQGRHVWRD5RFLQDQWH ODVHVSXHODVOHDSOLFDED VLQDWHQGHUDODVYRFHV TXHVXHVFXGHUROHGDED TXHVRQPROLQRVVHxRU \QRJLJDQWHVJULWDED SHURpOSHQVDQGRHQJLJDQWHV ODVYRFHVQROHHVFXFKDED ³1RQPHIX\DGHVFREDUGHV DYRFHVDOWDVJULWDED TXHHVXQVRORFDEDOOHUR HOTXHDWRGRVRVDWDFDED´ 0DQXHO*RQ]iOH]&DEUHUD (QHVWRPRYLyVHHOYLHQWR ODVJUDQGHVDVSDVJLUDED ORFXDOTXHYLR'RQ)ULVDUGR GHVWHPRGROHVJULWDED ³DXQTXHPRYiLVPiVEUD]RV TXH%ULDUHRDJLWDED TXHORKDEUpLVGHSDJDU GHFtDPLHQWUDVFDUJDED´ 'LFLHQGRHVWRD'XOFLQHD )ULVDUGRVHHQFRPHQGDED SLGLpQGROHTXHHQWDOWUDQFH VRFRUULHVH\D\XGDUD %LHQFXELHUWRGHURGHOD FRQODQ]DHQULVWUHPRQWDED HPELVWLyFRQWUDXQPROLQR GiQGROHIXHUWHODQ]DGD (OYLHQWRPRYLyODVDVSDV ODODQ]DOHGHVWUR]DED DFDEDOOR\FDEDOOHUR SRUORVDLUHVORVODQ]DED IXHURGDQGRSRUHOFDPSR \PDOWUHFKRVHTXHGDED DFXGLy3DQFKRFRUULHQGR TXHVRFRUUHUOHGHVHDED OHKDOOyLQPyYLOGHOJROSH TXH5RFLQDQWHOHGDED ³£9iJDPH'LRVGLMR3DQFKR DOYHUTXHQRVHPHQHDED OHGLMHTXHVRQPROLQRV SHURQXQFDPHHVFXFKDED´ ³£&DOODDPLJR3DQFKRFDOOD 'RQ)ULVDUGROHURJDED FRVDVGHOVDELR)UHVWyQ TXHHQPROLQRVORVWURFDED SRUTXLWDUPHDPLODJORULD TXHGHOYHQFLPLHQWRKDOODUD QRYDOGUiQVXVPDODVDUWHV FRQWUDERQGDGGHPLHVSDGD´ 'LRVORKDJDFRPRSXHGH 3DQFKR*UDQ]DFRQWHVWDED VXELyORDVX5RFLQDQWH TXHELHQGHVSDOGDGRHVWDED &DPLQRGHO3XHUWR/iSLFH VXVSDVRVHQFDPLQDED SRUVHUOXJDUGHDYHQWXUDV TXHPXFKDJHQWHWRPDED DQGDEDPX\SHVDURVR TXHVXODQ]DOHIDOWDED KDEODQGRFRQVXHVFXGHUR HVWDKLVWRULDOHFRQWDED ³'RQ'LHJR3pUH]GH9DUJDV DTXLHQVHURPSLyODHVSDGD GHVJDMyXQWURQFRGHHQFLQD TXHFRQWUDPRURVXVDED WDQWRVPRURVPDFKDFy TXHHO0DFKXFDOHOODPDEDQ GHQRPEUHVXVKHUHGHURV 9DUJDV0DFKXFDWRPDEDQ \RSLHQVRKDFHURWURWDQWR GHOSULPHUWURQFRTXHKDOODUD SRUKDFHUWDOHVKD]DxDV FRPRQDGLHLPDJLQDUD 'RQ)ULVDUGR\3DQFKR*UDQ]D XQRDORWURSODWLFDED VREUHTXLpQSXHGHTXHMDUVH TXHHQORVOLEURVQRFRQVWDED /OHJyODKRUDGHFRPHU VXHVFXGHURUHFRUGDED FRPHW~FXDQWRWHSOD]FD 'RQ)ULVDUGRFRQWHVWDED &RQHVWDOLFHQFLD3DQFKR VREUHHOEXUURFRPRHVWDED 5RPDQFHGHO&DEDOOHUR)ULVDUGR DODYH]TXHLEDFRPLHQGR WDPELpQODERWDHPSLQDED 3RUODQRFKHXQDUERODGR VLUYLpUDOHVGHSRVDGD GHXQRGHHOORV'RQ)ULVDUGR UDPDVHFDGHVJDMDED S~VROHHQODSXQWDHOKLHUUR TXHGHVXODQ]DJXDUGDED 1RGXUPLHUD'RQ)ULVDUGR TXHHQ'XOFLQHD3HQVDED QLFHQDQLGHVD\XQD GHVRxDUVHVXVWHQWDED 3RUFRQWUDULRVXHVFXGHUR VHXQVXHxRVHODSDVDED \VHJXLUtDGXUPLHQGR VLHODPRQROHOODPDUD DOOHYDQWDUVHGLRXQWLHQWR DODERWDTXHOOHYDED VHDÀLJLyDOYHUODPiVÀDFD TXHGHODQRFKHSDVDGD (UDQODVWUHVGHODWDUGH FXDQGRHOVROPiVIXHUWHGDED 3XHUWR/iSLFHDOROHMRV \DFODURVHGLYLVDED 'RQ)ULVDUGRDVXHVFXGHUR HVWDVOHFFLRQHVOHGDED ³$XQTXHPHYHDVHQSHOLJUR QRVDTXHV3DQFKRODHVSDGD DQRVHUTXHJHQWHEDMD IXHUDODTXHPHDWDFDED TXHVLIXHUDQFDEDOOHURV QRIXHUDDFFLyQELHQPLUDGD´ (VWDQGRHQHVWDVUD]RQHV SRUHOFDPLQRDVRPDEDQ GRVIUDLOHVGH6DQ%HQLWR TXHHQGURPHGDULRVPRQWDEDQ WUDtDQVXVDQWHRMRV \TXLWDVROHVOOHYDEDQ YHQtDGHWUiVXQFRFKH FRQFXDWURTXHDFRPSDxDEDQ HQHOFRFKHXQDYL]FDtQD KDFLD6HYLOODYLDMDED GRQGHHVWDEDVXPDULGR TXHDODV,QGLDVVHSDVDED (QYLpQGROHV'RQ)ULVDUGR DVtDVXHVFXGHURKDEODED ³DTXHOORVGRVEXOWRVQHJURV SULQFHVDOOHYDQUDSWDGD´ ³6RQIUDLOHVGH6DQ%HQLWR´ HOHVFXGHURDFODUDED ³<DWHKHGLFKRDPLJR3DQFKR TXHGHHVWRQRVDEHVQDGD´ 3XHVWRHQPLWDGGHOFDPLQR GHVWHPRGROHVJULWDED ³7pQJDVHDOSXQWRHVWDJHQWH GHVFRPXQDO\HQGLDEODGD \GDGOLEUHDODSULQFHVD DODFXDOOOHYiLVIRU]DGD RSDJDUpLVFRQODYLGD SRUFDVWLJRGHPLHVSDGD´ 'HWXYLpURQVHORVIUDLOHV \DGPLUDGRVVHTXHGDEDQ DVtGHVXPDODHVWDPSD FXDOODVUD]RQHVTXHGDED 0LUHVHxRUFDEDOOHUR XQPRQMHOHFRQWHVWDED TXHVRPRVGH6DQ%HQLWR QRVRPRVJHQWHHQGLDEODGD ³1RYDOHQSDODEUDVEODQGDV 'RQ)ULVDUGRUHSOLFDED TXH\R\DRVFRQR]FRELHQ JHQWHPDODFDQDOODGD´ 0DQXHO*RQ]iOH]&DEUHUD 'RQ)ULVDUGRVLQPiVWUHJXD FRQWUDHOSULPHURFDUJDED WHPLHUDHOIUDLOHODIXULD GHTXLHQ¿HUROHDWDFDED SRUPLHGRDVHUHQVDUWDGR GHODPXODVHWLUDED HOVHJXQGRUHOLJLRVR GHOJUDQSiQLFRWHPEODED SXVRSLHVHQSROYRURVD \DOJDORSHVHDOHMDED 3DQFKR*UDQ]DHOHVFXGHUR VREUHHOFDtGRVHODQ]DED ORVKiELWRVSRUGHVSRMR GHODEDWDOODWRPDED ORVPR]RVTXHQRHQWHQGtDQ GHORVGHVSRMRVTXHKDEODED DUUHPHWHQFRQWUD3DQFKR VLQGHMDUOHSHORHQEDUED 0ROLpURQOHOXHJRDFRFHV SRUORVVXHORVORWLUDEDQ VLQDOLHQWR\VLQVHQWLGR TXHGyFXDQGRVHDOHMDEDQ 'RQ)ULVDUGRDODGHOFDUUR GHVWDPDQHUDOHKDEODED ³YXHVWUDKHUPRVXUDVHxRUD GHUREDGRUIXHOLEUDGD VDEHGTXHVR\'RQ)ULVDUGR FDEDOOHURGHJUDQIDPD DYHQWXUHUR\FDXWLYR SRUHODPRUGHXQDGDPD 'XOFLQHDGHO7RERVR HVDKHUPRVXUDHVOODPDGD RVSLGRTXHDOOiYROYiLV \VHDSRUYRVLQIRUPDGD 3HUODV 6DEHGTXHVR\'RQ)ULVDUGR FDEDOOHURGHJUDQIDPD DYHQWXUHUR\FDXWLYR SRUHODPRUGHXQDGDPD E C$3,78/2,; A48Ë)8('21'(/($9,12 /$/8&+$&2175$(/9,=&$,12 CXDQWRGLMR'RQ)ULVDUGR XQHVFXGHURHVFXFKDED HUDXQMLQHWHYL]FDtQR GHORVTXHHOFRFKHOOHYDED HOYL]FDtQRD'RQ)ULVDUGR HQPDODMHUJDUHWDED VLQRGHMDEDLUDOFRFKH RPRUtDRORPDWDED ³&DEDOOHURTXHPDODQGHV TXHSRUHO'LRVTXHPHFULDUD VLQRGHMDVLUDOFRFKH HOYL]FDtQRWHPDWDUD´ ³6LIXpUDGHVFDEDOOHUR 'RQ)ULVDUGRUHSOLFDED WXVDQGH]\DWUHYLPLHQWR \DWXYLHVHVFDVWLJDGD´ ³¢&RQTXH\RQRFDEDOOHUR" HOYL]FDtQRSUHJXQWDED DJXDSUHVWRJDWROOHYDV VLODQ]DDUURMDV\HVSDGD´ £/RYHUHGHVGLMR$JUDMHV 'RQ)ULVDUGRUHSOLFDED DOVXHORDUURMyVXODQ]D DVLyURGHOD\HVSDGD HPELVWLyFRQWUDHOYL]FDtQR TXHWDPELpQGHHOODWLUDED TXLHQQRWHQLHQGRURGHOD FRJLyGHOFRFKHXQDDOPRKDGD DUUHPHWLpURQVHHQWUDPERV FRQ¿HUH]DLQXVLWDGD ODVGHPiVJHQWHVTXLVLHURQ TXHODSHQGHQFLDDFDEDUD DPHQD]DEDHOYL]FDtQR PDWDUDTXLHQOHHVWRUEDUD ODVHxRUDGHDTXHOFRFKH WHPHURVD\DGPLUDGD GHVYLiQGRVHGHDOOtXQSRFR GHOHMRVORVFRQWHPSODED HOYL]FDtQRD'RQ)ULVDUGR DVHVWyJUDQFXFKLOODGD TXHDGiUVHODVLQURGHOD WRGRHOFXHUSROHUDMDUD 'RQ)ULVDUGRWUDVHOJROSH D'XOFLQHDFODPDED 0DQXHO*RQ]iOH]&DEUHUD DSUHVWiQGRVHDOGHVTXLWH FRQODURGHOD\ODHVSDGD HOYL]FDtQRSRUVXSDUWH ODLQWHQFLyQOHDGLYLQDED DJXDUGDQGRD'RQ)ULVDUGR ELHQFXELHUWRSRUODDOPRKDGD 6HQGDVHVSDGDVSRUDOWR WUDVODURGHODRODDOPRKDGD FRQSDUWLUORHQGRVPLWDGHV XQRDORWURDPHQD]DED PLHQWUDVWDQWRDTXHOODJHQWH TXHDOYL]FDtQRDFRPSDxDED WHPHURVDSRUVXVXHUWH DO&LHORVHHQFRPHQGDED /DVHVSDGDVFRUWDGRUDV SRUDPERV\DOHYDQWDGDV GHHQRMDGRVFRPEDWLHQWHV FLHOR\WLHUUDDPHQD]DEDQ (OFROpULFRYL]FDtQR JUDQJROSHGLRFRQODHVSDGD DUUDQFDQGRPHGLDRUHMD \PiVGHPHGLDFHODGD 'RQ)ULVDUGRIXULEXQGR GRVPDQRVHFKyDVXHVSDGD FHUUDQGRFRQWUDHOYL]FDtQR JUDQJROSHOHGHVFDUJDED DTXHOWHUULEOHPDQGREOH HQODFDEH]DDFHUWDED GHOYL]FDtQRTXHGHOJROSH SRUERFD\QDUL]VDQJUDED GHOFDPSRGHODEDWDOOD KX\yVXPXODHVSDQWDGD \HQWUHVSRUFXDWURFRUFRYRV DOYL]FDtQRGHUULEDED YLpQGROHFDHU'RQ)ULVDUGR GHVXFDEDOORVDOWDED \HQOOHJiQGRVHDOYL]FDtQR UHQGLFLyQOHGHPDQGDED SRUTXHVLQRVHULQGLHVH ODFDEH]DODFRUWDED QDGDUHVSRQGLyHOYL]FDtQR SRUORWXUEDGRTXHHVWDED \FXPSOLHUD'RQ)ULVDUGR TXHFLHJRGHLUDHVWDED GHQRPHGLDUODVHxRUD TXHHOHSLVRGLRREVHUYDED /OHJiQGRVHD'RQ)ULVDUGR SRUIDYRUOHGHPDQGDED SHUGRQDVHDOHVFXGHUR TXHHQHOVXHORVHHQFRQWUDED DORFXDOTXH'RQ)ULVDUGR HVWDUHVSXHVWDOHGDED SRUFLHUWRKHUPRVDVHxRUD \RELHQFRQWHQWRTXHGDUD HQKDFHUORTXHSHGtV PDVHQFRQGLFLyQSDFWDGD TXHVHSUHVHQWHHQ7RERVR D'XOFLQHDPLDPDGD SRUTXHGLVSRQJDGHpO FRPRPiVOHDFRPRGDUD /DVWHPHURVDVVHxRUDV WULVWHV\GHVFRQVRODGDV SURPHWLHURQTXHVtKDUtD DTXHOORTXHGHPDQGDED 3HUODV /DVHVSDGDVFRUWDGRUDV SRUDPERV\DOHYDQWDV GHHQRMDGRVFRPEDWLHQWHV FLHOR\WLHUUDDPHQD]DEDQ L C$3,78/2; G5$&,26265$=21$0,(1726 $48Ë/26'266(&58=$%$1 (175('21)5,6$5'2<3$1&+2 $/7,(03248(&$%$/*$%$1 AOJRPDOWUDWDGR3DQFKR OHYDQWDGRVHHQFRQWUDED PX\DWHQWRDODEDWDOOD TXH'RQ)ULVDUGROLEUDED HQVXFRUD]yQD'LRV SRUODYLVWRULDURJDED GRQGHtQVXODJDQDQGR JREHUQDGRUOHQRPEUDED YLHQGRTXHDVX5RFLQDQWH 'RQ)ULVDUGRFDEDOJDED KLQFDGRDQWHpOGHURGLOODV VXVSURPHVDVUHFODPDED 6HDYXHVWUDPHUFHGVHUYLGR D'RQ)ULVDUGRURJDED QRPEUDUPHJREHUQDGRU GHODtQVXODJDQDGD 'RQ)ULVDUGRDVXHVFXGHUR HVWDUHVSXHVWDOHGDED ³£DGYHUWLGKHUPDQR3DQFKR TXHODDYHQWXUDSDVDGD QRIXHDYHQWXUDGHtQVXOD TXHORIXHGHHQFUXFLMDGD HQODVFXDOHV3DQFKRDPLJR 'RQ)ULVDUGRFRQWLQXDED VHVDFDQFDEH]DVURWDV \DOJXQDRUHMDFRUWDGD´ 6HJXLGRGHVXHVFXGHUR TXHHQVXMXPHQWRPRQWDED HQWUyVHOXHJRHQXQERVTXH TXHDOOtGHFHUFDVHKDOODED VHJXtDOH3DQFKRDOWURWH FXDQWRVXMXPHQWRGDED GLyOHYRFHVDVXDPR SRUORDWUiVTXHORGHMDED HQOOHJDQGRD'RQ)ULVDUGR GHVWDPDQHUDOHKDEODED ³SDUpFHPHPLVHxRU 3DQFKR*UDQ]DOHREVHUYDED TXHUHIXJLDUVHHQLJOHVLD QRVIXHUDFRVDDFHUWDGD SRUVLDOD6DQWD+HUPDQGDG OHIXHUDQRWLFLDGDGD 0DQXHO*RQ]iOH]&DEUHUD SRUHOPDOWUHFKRYL]FDtQR GHODEDWDOODSDVDGD´ ³£&DOODGLMR'RQ)ULVDUGR ¢GyQGHOHtVWHTXHIXHGDGD SULVLyQDORVFDEDOOHURV SRUORVPXHUWRVTXHFDXVDEDQ"´ 'RQ)ULVDUGRDVXHVFXGHUR ORVWHPRUHVOHTXLWDED TXHGHOD6DQWD+HUPDQGDG VLQWUDEDMRORVDFDUD ³3HURGLPHSRUWXYLGD 'RQ)ULVDUGRSUHJXQWDED ¢YLVWHMDPiVHQOD7LHUUD PiVYDORUHQODEDWDOOD"´ 'RQ)ULVDUGRVXVGHVWUH]DV D3DQFKROHUHODWDED \FRQWDQGRVXVKD]DxDV RUJXOORVRVHPRVWUDED (OHVFXGHURVXPLVR DGPLUDFLyQOHPRVWUDED PLHQWUDVTXHHQOHHU\HVFULELU VXLJQRUDQFLDFRQIHVDED 4XHVHFXUHGHODRUHMD VXHVFXGHUROHURJDED ODTXHOHFRUWyHOYL]FDtQR TXHPXFKDVDQJUHWLUDED (VR\DIXHUDFXUDGR 'RQ)ULVDUGRFRQWHVWDED VLGH)LHUDEUiVWXYLHUD EiOVDPRTXHQROOHYDED 3HUR¢TXpEiOVDPRHVHVH" 3DQFKR*UDQ]DSUHJXQWDED EiOVDPRHVTXHXQDJRWD \WRGDKHULGDHVFXUDGD ³6LDOJXQDYH]PHSDUWLHUDQ HQGRVSRUXQDWDMDGD MXQWDXQDSDUWHDODRWUD TXHSUHVWRVHUiFXUDGD´ OXHJRPHGDVDEHEHU GRVWUDJRVTXHPHEDVWDUD YHUiVTXHOXHJRPiVVDQR TXHXQDPDQ]DQDTXHGDED´ 3RUHVHEiOVDPR3DQFKR VXtQVXODUHQXQFLDUD D'RQ)ULVDUGRSHGtD UHFHWDTXHQROHGDED &DOODDKRUDDPLJR3DQFKR 'RQ)ULVDUGROHURJDED F~UDPH\DHVWDRUHMD TXHGXHOHPiVTXHGHVHDUD 3DQFKRGHDTXHOODVDOIRUMDV KLODV\XQJHQWRVDFDED FRQHOODVD'RQ)ULVDUGR HOGRORUOHDSDFLJXDED &XDQGR'RQ)ULVDUGRYLHUD FyPRTXHGyVXFHODGD DVtDORV&LHORVMXUy SXHVWDVXPDQRHQODHVSDGD ³<RKDJRDTXtMXUDPHQWR FRPRHOGH0DQWXDMXUDED QRFRPHUSDQGHPDQWHOHV QLFRQPXMHUHVIROJDUD KDVWDQRWRPDUYHQJDQ]D GHDTXHVWDGHVDJXLVDGD´ $HVWHSXQWRVXHVFXHUR PHPRULDOHUHIUHVFDED DGYLHUWDYXHVWUDPHUFHG TXHVLDO7RERVROOHJDED DQWHYXHVWUD'XOFLQHD WHQGUiODGHXGDSDJDGD´ ³%LHQKDVDSXQWDGR3DQFKR 'RQ)ULVDUGRFRQWHVWDED 5RPDQFHGHO&DEDOOHUR)ULVDUGR GHDOJ~QRWURFDEDOOHUR WRPDUpQXHYDFHODGD \QRSLHQVHV3DQFKRDPLJR TXHKXHOHDSDMDTXHPDGD TXHWDOKLFLHUD0DPEULQR TXHD6DFULSDQWHKXPLOODED´ ³¢4XpKDUHPRVVLHQ YDULRVGtDV3DQFKR*UDQ]D SUHJXQWDEDQRWRSDPRV FDEDOOHURVGHTXLHQWRPDUOD FHODGD" ¢FXPSOLUiHVHMXUDPHQWR HOTXHDWDQWROHREOLJDED" FRPRGHGRUPLUYHVWLGR \GRUPLUHQGHVFDPSDGD \RWUDVPLOHVSHQLWHQFLDV FRPRHOGH0DQWXDMXUDED \TXHVXPHUFHGDKRUD DOMXUDUUHYDOLGDED´ ³(QHVRWHHQJDxDV3DQFKR 'RQ)ULVDUGRUHSOLFDED SURQWRYHUDVFDEDOOHURV SRUDTXHVWDHQFUXFLMDGD´ ³$'LRVSOD]JDGLMR3DQFKR TXHIXHUDODKRUDOOHJDGD GHJDQDUPHODWDOtQVXOD TXHFDUDWHQJRSDJDGD´ ³<DWHKHGLFKRDPLJR3DQFKR TXHFXDQGRtQVXODIDOWDUD 6REUDGLVDR'LQDPDUFD SRUUHLQRWHODHQWUHJDUD´ ³'HMHPRVHVWR\FRPDPRV 'RQ)ULVDUGRUHFODPDED \OXHJRHQDOJ~QFDVWLOOR EXVFDUHPRVODSRVDGD DOOtHOEiOVDPRWHQGUHPRV TXHGHQDQWHVWHDQXQFLDED SRUTXHPHFXUHVODRUHMD TXHOOHYRPHGLRUDMDGD´ ³$TXtWUD\RXQDFHEROOD 3DQFKR*UDQ]DFRQWHVWDED \PHQGUXJRVGHSDQGXUR TXHDVXPHUFHGQRFXDGUDUD´ ³£4XpPDOORHQWLHQGHW~ 3DQFKR 'RQ)ULVDUGRUHSOLFDED DFDEDOOHURVDQGDQWHV HOQRFRPHUOHVKRQUDED \OXHJRVLHPSUHFRPtDQ ORTXHPiVDPDQRKDOODEDQ \HVWRVXSupUDVORELHQ VLHQKLVWRULDVWHYHUVDUDV $XQTXH\ROH\HUDVPXFKDV HQHOODVQXQFDVHKDOODEDQ TXHFDEDOOHURVFRPLHVHQ TXHHQÀRUHVVHORSDVDEDQ SHURKDVHGHHQWHQGHU TXHVLQFRPHUQRSDVDEDQ FRPLHQGRSRUGHVFDPSDGRV YLDQGDVU~VWLFDVKDOODGDV DVtTXHQRWHDFRQJRMHV SRUORTXHDPtPHJXVWDUD QLHQVDFDUDFDEDOOHURV GHORVTXLFLRVGRQGHHVWDEDQ´ ³3HUGRQHYXHVWUDPHUFHG 3DQFKR*UDQ]DOHURJDED TXHGHDTXtHQDGHODQWH IUXWDVHFDOHOOHYDUD´ ³1RGLJR\R3DQFKRDPLJR TXHVyORIUXWD\DQWDEDQ PDVFRPtDQGHRWUDV\HUEDV TXHSRUORVFDPSRVKDOODEDQ´ 0DQXHO*RQ]iOH]&DEUHUD &RPLHURQGHODVDOIRUMDV GHORTXH3DQFKROOHYDED SHURDFDEiURQORSURQWR TXHODOX]\DOHVIDOWDED 0RQWDURQ\FDEDOJDURQ SRUKDOODUSURQWRSRVDGD SHURIDOWyOHVHOVRO VLQORJUDUORTXHGHVHDEDQ MXQWRDFKR]DVGHFDEUHURV DOOtODQRFKHSDVDEDQ FRQSHVDGXPEUHGH3DQFKR ORTXHD'RQ)ULVDUGRKROJDED C C$3,78/2;, C(1$521&21/26&$%5(526 <<$'(638e6'(&(1$'26 &217(03/$1'281$6%(//27$6 $/$%Ï7,(03263$6$'26 CRQiQLPRORVFDEUHURV WRPDURQD'RQ)ULVDUGR \D3DQFKRTXHOHDWUDtD HORORUGHXQEXHQJXLVDGR SDUDFHQDUORVFDEUHURV KLFLHURQSRUHVWRIDGR JUDQGHVWDVDMRVGHFDEUD HQXQFDOGHURJXLVDGR SRQLHQGR]DOHDVSRUPHVD HOVXHORIXHDGHUH]DGR \GHEXHQDYROXQWDG IXH'RQ)ULVDUGRLQYLWDGR VHQWiURQVHDODUHGRQGD GHOPDQWHOLPSURYLVDGR 'RQ)ULVDUGRSRUDVLHQWR WXYRXQGRUQDMRYROFDGR TXHGDQGR3DQFKRGHSLH DVHQWDUVHIXLQYLWDGR SRU'RQ)ULVDUGRTXHTXLVR TXHVHVHQWDUDDVXODGR DJUDGHFLy3DQFKR*UDQ]D HODSUHFLRGHPRVWUDGR PDVUHFKD]DQGRHOHQYLWH QRTXLVRFRPHUVHQWDGR ³3DQ\FHEROODSUH¿HUR HQPLULQFyQDSDUWDGR TXHJDOOLSDYR\PDQWHOHV GHHPSHUDGRU\VHQWDGR´ ³$SHVDUGHORFXDO3DQFKR KDVGHVHQWDUWHDPLODGR SRUTXHKRPEUHTXHVHKXPLOOD VHUiSRU'LRVHQVDO]DGR´ 1RHQWHQGtDORVFDEUHURV DTXHOMHULJRQFLRHPSOHDGR GHFDEDOOHURVDQGDQWHV HQWUHHOVHxRU\VXFULDGR PLHQWUDVFRPtDQFDOODEDQ \HVWiEDQOHVREVHUYDQGR WDVDMRVTXHFRPRHOSXxR LEDQORVGRVHPEDXODQGR 7HQGLHURQVREUH]DOHDV SDUDGHVSXpVGHOJXLVDGR 0DQXHO*RQ]iOH]&DEUHUD JUDQFDQWLGDGGHEHOORWDV \TXHVRSHWUL¿FDGR 1XQFDDQGXYRHOFXHUQR RFLRVR QLYDFtRQLOOHQDGR TXHSURQWRYDFLDUDXQ]DTXH GHORVGRVTXHKDEtDQOOHYDGR 'RQ)ULVDUGRVDWLVIHFKR GHWDQEXHQYLQR\JXLVDGR PHWLyPDQRHQODVEHOORWDV DJDUUDQGRJUDQSXxDGR FRQWHPSODQGRDWHQWDPHQWH ODVEHOORWDVGHOSXxDGR VHGHVKL]RHQPLOUD]RQHV \DODEDQ]DVGHOSDVDGR ³£'LFKRVRVVLJORVDTXHOORV GHOIHOL]WLHPSRGRUDGR GRQGH³ORWX\R´\³ORPtR´ QXQFDIXHWpUPLQRXVDGR WRPyHOKRPEUHGHODWLHUUD HOIUXWR\DVD]RQDGR VLQTXHUDVJDUDVXSLHO ODUHMDGHOFRUYRDUDGR /DVVROtFLWDVDEHMDV DOOiHQORVULVFRVIRUPDGR VXSDQDOGHULFDPLHO RIUHFHQ\DHODERUDGR /RVYDOLHQWHVDOFRUQRTXHV VLQPiVDUWL¿FLRXVDGR RIUHFtDQVXVFRUWH]DV SDUDUHIXJLR\WHFKDGR 7RGRHUDSD]\DPLVWDG WRGRFRQFRUGLD\DJUDGR ODVHQWUDxDVGHODWLHUUD QRODVKLULyHOFRUYRDUDGR /DVKHUPRVDV]DJDOHMDV GHYDOOHQHQYDOOHVDOWDQGR SRPSRVDPHQWHYHVWLGDV FRQKRMDVGHOYHUGHSUDGR 1LHOIUDXGHQLODPDOLFLD HUDQWpUPLQRDFXxDGR QLFRQYHUGDG\OODQH]D HVWXYRQXQFDPH]FODGR /D-XVWLFLDVLHPSUHHVWDED HQVXWpUPLQRDMXVWDGR QLIDYRUHVQLLQWHUHVHV ODKDEtDQPHQRVSUHFLDGR (VDOH\GHOHQFDMH D~QQRVHKDEtDDVHQWDGR QRKDEtDQDGDTXHMX]JDU QLKDEtDTXLHQIXHVHMX]JDGR /DKRQHVWLGDGHQODV GRQFHOODV SRUWRGRVIXHUHVSHWDGR ODSHUGLFLyQOHVYHQtD SRUVXJXVWRGHEXHQJUDGR 1XHVWURVGHWHVWDEOHVVLJORV \DWRGRORKDQWUDVWRFDGR ODKRQHVWLGDGHQHOGH&UHWD QRKD\DUHIXJLRDGHFXDGR DQGDQGRIXHURQORVVLJORV \ODVPDOGDGHVGHJUDGR FUHiURQVHORVFDEDOOHURV DQGDQWHVGHEUD]RDUPDGR $HVWDRUGHQSHUWHQH]FR OHVGHFtD'RQ)ULVDUGR DJUDGH]FRHODJDVDMR \HODFRJLPLHQWRGDGR DXQTXHSRUOH\QDWXUDO WRGRHOPXQGRHVWiREOLJDGR FRQFDEDOOHURVDQGDQWHV \RRVORDJUDGH]FRGHJUDGR 5RPDQFHGHO&DEDOOHUR)ULVDUGR (VFXFKDEDQORVFDEUHURV FXiQIHOL]IXHUDHOSDVDGR TXH'RQ)ULVDUGRGLMHUD FRQWRQRHQIHUYRUL]DGR 3DQFKRWDPELpQOH HVFXFKDED DXQTXHVLQSHUGHUERFDGR FRQVXVYLVLWDVDO]DTXH GHXQDOFRUQRTXHFROJDGR /HRIUHFLHURQTXHHVFXFKDUD SRUTXHPD\RUIXHUDKRQUDGR XQURPDQFHTXHDOUDEHO FDQWDEDXQHQDPRUDGR $SHQDVHQGHFLUHVWR D~QQRKXELHVHQWHUPLQDGR OHVOOHJyHOVRQGHXQUDEHO \HOTXHORKXERWRFDGR 5RJiURQOHTXHFDQWDVH GHOUDEHODFRPSDxDGR DTXHOURPDQFHGHDPRUHV ORFXDOKL]RGHEXHQJUDGR $VtFDQWDEDHO$QWRQLR ³5RPDQFHGHHQDPRUDGR´ PLHQWUDVWRFDEDHOUDEHO PX\¿QDPHQWHWHPSODGR 5RPDQFH ³<RVH2ODOODTXHPHDGRUDV DXQTXHQRORKDVFRQIHVDGR QLD~QFRQORVRMRVVLTXLHUD TXHKDVWDPLUDQGRKDV FDOODGR <RVHELHQTXHWXPHTXLHUHV DXQTXHQRORKDVGHFODUDGR DPRUTXHIXHFRQRFLGR QXQFDIXHUDGHVGLFKDGR %LHQHVYHUGDGTXHWDOYH] 2ODOODPHKDVGHPRVWUDGR TXHWLHQHVGHEURQFHHODOPD \HOEODQFRSHFKRDFHUDGR $OOiHQWUHWXVUHSURFKHV GHXQYLYLUWDQUHFDWDGR WDOYH]ODHVSHUDQ]DPXHVWUD GHVHRQXQFDORJUDGR $EDOiQ]DVHDOVHxXHOR PLIHTXHQXQFDKDORJUDGR QLFUHFHUSRUHVFRJLGR QLPHQJXDUSRUUHFKD]DGR 6LHODPRUHVFRUWHVtD FRQODWX\DKDVGHPRVWUDGR TXHHO¿QGHPLVHVSHUDQ]DV KDGHVHUHO¿QVRxDGR <VLVRQVHUYLFLRVSDUWH GHSHFKRGLJQR\KRQUDGR PXFKRVGHORVTXHWHKLFH IRUWDOHFHQPHPLHVWDGR 6LKXELHUDVPLUDGRHQHOOR KDEUiVVLQGXGDREVHUYDGR TXH\RPHSRQJRORVOXQHV ORTXHHQGRPLQJRKHOOHYDGR &RPRHODPRU\ODJDOD FDPLQDQGHOPLVPRODGR HQWRGRWLHPSRDWXVRMRV TXLVHPRVWUDUPHHGXFDGR 'HMRHOEDLODUSRUWXFDXVD QLP~VLFDVKHFRQWDGR TXHKDVHVFXFKDGRDGHVKRUD GHVSXpVGHOJDOORFDQWDGR 1RFXHQWRODVDODEDQ]DV TXHGHWLKD\DFRQWDGR TXHDXQTXHYHUGDGHUDV 0DQXHO*RQ]iOH]&DEUHUD KDFHQ TXHPHVLHQWDPDOPLUDGR 7HUHVDGHO%HUURFDO \RDODEiQGRWHKDFRQWDGR ³WDOSLHQVDTXHDGRUDDXQ iQJHO´ \YLHQHDDGRUDUDXQGLDEOR 0HUFHGDORVPXFKRVGLMHV \DORVFDEHOORVUL]DGRV \DKLSyFULWDVKHUPRVXUDV TXHHQJDxDQDOPiVSLQWDGR 'HVPHQWtOD\HQRMyVH VXSULPRVHODKDOOHYDGR GHVD¿yPH\\DVDEHV FXDQWRDOOtKXERSDVDGR 1RWHTXLHUR\RDPRQWyQ QLWHSUHWHQGRSHQVDGR XQLUPHHQEDUUDJDQtD PLGHVLJQLRHVHOHYDGR &R\XQGDVWLHQHODLJOHVLD TXHVRQGHOD]RDSUHWDGR LQFOLQDDO\XJRWXFXHOOR TXH\RORSRQGUpDWXODGR <VLQRGHVGHDTXtMXUR SRUHOVDQWRPiVVDJUDGR QRVDOLUGHDTXHVWDVVLHUUDV VLQRSDUDHQFDSXFKDGR´ %LHQSDUHFLyDORVSUHVHQWHV DTXHOURPDQFHHVFXFKDGR WDQKiELOPHQWHWDxLGR WDQGXOFHPHQWHFDQWDGR 3XHVWR\D¿QDOURPDQFH TXHDWRGRVKXERDJUDGDGR DSUHVWiURQVHDGRUPLU HQOXJDUDFRPRGDGR ³4XLHUR3DQFKRTXHPHFXUHV ODRUHMDGHDTXHVWHODGR TXHPHYDGROLHQGRPXFKR \WLpQHPHSUHRFXSDGR´ 9LHQGRXQFDEUHURODKHULGD TXHQROHKXERVDQDGR YHQGyOHXQJHQWRFRQVDO \URPHURPDFKDFDGR A C$3,78/2;,, E1(67(48('$&217$'2 48(*5,6267202085,(5$ '(0$5&(/$(1$025$'2 EQHVWROOHJDEDXQPR]R GHODDOGHKHODGHDOODGR FRQWDQGRHOWULVWHVXFHVR TXHGLMRKDEHUHVFXFKDGR TXH*ULVyVWRPRHUDPXHUWR VHUiPDxDQDHQWHUUDGR ORVDPRUHVGH0DUFHOD ODYLGDOHKDEtDQFRVWDGR HODXGLWRULRSUHVHQWH HVFXFKiEDOHDVRPEUDGR URJDQGRTXHSURVLJXLHUD FRQHOUHODWRLQLFLDGR ³<FXpQWDVHTXH*ULVyVWRPR GHMDUDHQYLGDWHVWDGR TXHHOGtDTXHIXHVHPXHUWR IXHUDHQHOFDPSRHQWHUUDGR \DOSLHGHODSHxD\IXHQWH GHO$OFRUQRTXHOODPDGR TXHDOOtSRUSULPHUDYH] IXHYHUOD\TXHGDUSUHQGDGR ORVDEDGHVVHQHJDEDQ DFXPSOLUFRQORWHVWDGR FRQ$PEURVLR\ORVSDVWRUHV DQGDHOSXHEORDOERURWDGR´ 1RGHMDUpGHLUDYHUOR GHFtDHOUHFLpQOOHJDGR WRGRVKDUHPRVORPLVPR VLDOJXLHQQRVJXDUGDHOJDQDGR 3LGLy'RQ)ULVDUGRD3HGUR TXHDVtHUDHOPR]ROODPDGR TXLpQIXHUDDTXHOOD0DUFHOD \HOSDVWRUHQDPRUDGR $VtUHVSRQGLHUD3HGUR HQORTXHIXHSUHJXQWDGR ³(UDDTXHOPXHUWRXQKLGDOJR HQOD]RQDDYHFLQGDGR HVWXGLDQGRHQ6DODPDQFD ODUJRWLHPSRKXERSDVDGR UHJUHViQGRVHDOOXJDU FRQIDPDGHPX\OHWUDGR (QFLHQFLDVGHODVHVWUHOODV HUDPX\GRFWR\YHUVDGR HO³FULV´GHOVRO\ODOXQD 0DQXHO*RQ]iOH]&DEUHUD GDEDSRUDQWLFLSDGR´ ³(FOLSVH´VHOODPDHVR DFODUDED'RQ)ULVDUGR QRUHSDUDQGRHQQLxHFHV SURVLJXLyHOPR]RFRQWDQGR DVLPLVPRDGLYLQDED HODxR³HVWLO´RPDOR ³HVWpULO´TXHUpLVGHFLU UHFWL¿Fy'RQ)ULVDUGR $VXSDGUH\VXVDPLJRV PXFKROHVKXERD\XGDGR HOHVFXFKDUVXVFRQVHMRV SDUDVDFDUEXHQVHPEUDGR 6HPEUDGHVWHDxRFHEDGD TXHHOWULJRQRHVDGHFXDGR HQHVWHVHPEUDGJDUEDQ]RV TXHVHUiPiVDFHUWDGR ³$VWURORJtD´HVODFLHQFLD LQWHUUXPSLy'RQ)ULVDUGR SXHVGHWRGRHVRVDEtD GLMRHOPR]RFRQWLQXDQGR ³$OFDERGHSRFRVPHVHV GHVSXpVGHKDEHUUHJUHVDGR UHPDQHFLyGHSDVWRU FRQSHOOLFR\VXFD\DGR ORSURSLRKLFLHUDVXDPLJR TXH$PEURVLRHUDOODPDGR FRPSDxHURHQ6DODPDQFD HQORVWLHPSRVGHO¿QDGR 2OYLGyVHPHGHFLU TXH*ULVyVWRPRHUDGDGR DFRPSRQHUJUDQGHVFRSODV SRUHOORPX\FHOHEUDGR &XDQGRORVYHFLQRVYLHURQ GHLPSURYLVRHOFDPELRGDGR VLQDGLYLQDUODVFDXVDV TXHGyVHHOSXHEORDGPLUDGR &RQWDEDFRQJUDQKDFLHQGD PXFKRGLQHUR\JDQDGR FRQPXHEOHV\ELHQHVUDtFHV TXHGHOSDGUHKXERKHUHGDGR 0XGyVHOXHJRDSDVWRU SRUDQGDUHQGHVSREODGR HQSRVGHDTXHOOD0DUFHOD GHTXLHQPXULyHQDPRUDGR 4XLHURGHFLURVDKRUD SRUGDURVELHQHQWHUDGR FRVDVGHDTXHOODUDSD]D TXHMDPiVIXHUDHVFXFKDGR (VOD0DUFHODKHUHGHUD GH*XLOOHUPRHOKDFHQGDGR TXHGDQGRDOPRULUVXVSDGUHV GHXQVDFHUGRWHDOFXLGDGR &UHFLyXQDQLxDSUHFLRVD FRPRQXQFDVHKXERFULDGR TXLHQDORVTXLQFHODYLHUD TXHGiEDVHHQDPRUDGR &XLGDEDVXWtRGHOOD HQPRGRPX\UHFDWDGR PLUDQGRTXHQRHVWXYLHUD VRODHQOXJDUDSDUWDGR HOJUDGRGHVXKHUPRVXUD HUDSRUWRGRVQRWDGR SRUTXHODGLHVHHQPXMHU IXHVXWtRLPSRUWXQDGR PDVHOQRTXLVRFDVDUOD TXL]iSRULQWHUHVDGR KDVWDTXHIXHUDPD\RU \HOLJLHUDGHVXDJUDGR $ORVPXFKRVSUHWHQGLHQWHV TXHODKXELHURQFRUWHMDGR OHVGLMRTXHQRGHVHDED 5RPDQFHGHO&DEDOOHUR)ULVDUGR FDPELDUWDQMRYHQGHHVWDGR FRQHVWDVMXVWDUD]RQHV TXHVXWtRKXERHVFXFKDGR GHMDEDGHLPSRUWXQDUOD HQORGHWRPDUHVWDGR SRUTXHGHFtDPX\ELHQ \HVWDEDHQHOORDFHUWDGR TXHHQORGHWRPDUSDUHMD QRIXHUDHOKLMRIRU]DGR /DPHOLQGURVD0DUFHOD TXHUXHJRVQRKXER HVFXFKDGR UHPDQHFLyGHSDVWRUD SDUDJXDUGDUVXJDQDGR DVtFRPRVDOLyDOFDPSR DQGDQWUDVHOODURQGDQGR KLGDOJRV\ODEUDGRUHV SRUVXVDPRUHVSRU¿DQGR PDVHQHVWDVOLEHUWDGHV TXH0DUFHODVHKDWRPDGR VXKRQHVWLGDG\UHFDWR VXIULHURQQLQJ~QPHQJXDGR DWRGRVVXVSUHWHQGLHQWHV WUDWDEDFRQGXOFHDJUDGR DQDGLHGDEDHVSHUDQ]D TXHDWRGRVKDUHFKD]DGR <FRQHVWDVFRQGLFLRQHV PiVGDxROOHYDFDXVDGR TXHVLDOJXQDSHVWLOHQFLD KXELpUDOHVDFDUUHDGR SRUTXHVXDIDEOHKHUPRVXUD DWRGRVKDGHVWUR]DGR VXGHVGpQ\GHVHQJDxR KDOHVGHVHVSHUDQ]DGR <DVRQOHJLyQHQODVLHUUD GHFXDQWRVKDGHVGHxDGR \HVF~FKDQVHORVODPHQWRV GHWDQWRGHVHQJDxDGR QRTXHGDKD\DQLHQFLQD TXH\DQRHVWpVHxDODGR FRQHOQRPEUHGH0DUFHOD HQVXFRUWH]DJUDEDGR DTXtVHHVFXFKDXQSDVWRU GHVXDPRUGHVHQJDxDGR DOOiVHHVFXFKDXQDHQGHFKD GHXQDPRUGHVHVSHUDGR &XDOSDVDWRGDODQRFKH EDMRXQDHQFLQDVHQWDGR \DODPDxDQDVLJXLHQWH KiOODOHHOVROWUDQVSRUWDGR \GHVWHGHDTXpOGHDTXpOORV YDOD0DUFHODWULXQIDQGR SRUYHUTXLHQODGRPHxDUD YDPRVWRGRVHVSHUDQGR <GDQGRVHxRUSRUFLHUWR WRGRFXDQWRKHUHODWDGR FLHUWRHVWDPELpQTXHPXULHUD *ULVyVWRPRHQDPRUDGR 2VDFRQVHMRVHxRU HVWDUPDxDQDDVXODGR´ ³,UpDVXHQWLHUURORMXUR OHSURPHWLy'RQ)ULVDUGR´ 3DQFKRGHRtUDOFDEUHUR HVWDEDPiVTXHHQGLDEODGR DFRPRGyVHHQODFXDGUD MXQWRDVXEXUURDFRVWDGR DOOtGXUPLyFRPRSXGR TXHQRFRPRHQDPRUDGR VLQRFRPRKRPEUHPROLGR SRU5RFLQDQWH\HODVQR B C$3,78/2;,,, FRQHOORVGRVFDEDOOHURV \WUHVPR]RVDVXODGR S(&8(17$&202(1/$6,(55$ PRQWDQGRFDEDOORQHJUR WRGRELHQDGHUH]DGR )8(*5,6267202(17(55$'2 (QHQFRQWUiQGRVHWRGRV &21/$63/$7,&$66$%526$6 KXELpURQVHVDOXGDGR '('21)5,6$5'2<9,9$/'2 SUHJXQWiQGRVHGLMHURQ LUDOHQWLHUURQRPEUDGR XQRGHORVGHDFDEDOOR ASHQDVSLQWDGRHOGtD OHGLMRDORWUR³9LYDOGR GHHQWLHUURWDQVHxDODGR HODVLVWLUDHVWHHQWLHUUR FLQFRGHDTXHOORVFDEUHURV VHUiWLHPSRELHQHPSOHDGR´ GHVSLHUWDQD'RQ)ULVDUGR ³HVRPHSDUHFHDPt SUHJXQWiURQOHVLHVWDED UHVSRQGLyOHHOWDO9LYDOGR HQFXPSOLUFRQORDFRUGDGR \QRHPSOHDUDVyORXQGtD DOHQWLHUURGH*ULVyVWRPR VLQRFXDWURKXELHVH IXHUDQHOORVDVXODGR HPSOHDGR´ FRQ5RFLQDQWH\MXPHQWR 'RQ)ULVDUGR3UHJXQWyOHV TXH3DQFKRKDEtD TXpVDEtDQGHO¿QDGR HQDOEDUGDGR GH*ULVyVWRPR\0DUFHOD HPSUHQGLHURQHOFDPLQR SRUTXLHQPXULyHQDPRUDGR KDFLDHOOXJDUVHxDODGR FRQWHVWyOHHOFDPLQDQWH $~QQRHUDFXDUWRGHOHJXD TXHWRGRORKXERHVFXFKDGR FXDQWROOHYDUDQDQGDGR FRQWDGRSRUORVSDVWRUHV WRSDURQFRQVHLVSDVWRUHV FRQTXLHQVHKDEtDWRSDGR TXHLEDQDOPLVPRPDQGDGR 0DQXHO*RQ]iOH]&DEUHUD 9ROYLyOXHJRDSUHJXQWDU HOWDOOODPDGR9LYDOGR ODVFDXVDVTXHOHPRYtDQ DVHUFDEDOOHURDUPDGR DOOtOHGLRPLOUD]RQHV DTXLHQOHKXERSUHJXQWDGR GHVHUFDEDOOHURDQGDQWH FRPRDVtIXHUDOODPDGR $SHQDVHVWROHR\HURQ TXHIXHSRUORFRWRPDGR ORGH&DEDOOHUR$QGDQWH OHIXHWDPELpQSUHJXQWDGR 'RQ)ULVDUGRDTXtWRPDED ODYDUDGHPHGLUODUJR \DOOtOHVGLHUDGH+LVWRULD GLVFXUVRELHQGHWDOODGR ³¢1RKDQOHLGRYXHVWUDV PHUFHGHV SUHJXQWyOHVGRQ)ULVDUGR ORVDQDOHVGH,QJODWHUUD GRQGH$UWXURIXH³HQFRUYDGR"´ 6HJ~QWUDGLFLyQDQWLJXD IXHHO5H\$UWXURHQFDQWDGR TXHGyFRQYHUWLGRHQFXHUYR \KDGHYROYHUDOUHLQDGR SXHVHQWLHPSRVGHHVWHUH\ VHFXHQWDTXHIXHURQFUHDGRV ORVGHOD7DEOD5HGRQGD ORVFDEDOOHURVDUDPDGRV *LQHEUDIXH\4XLQWDxRQD FRQ/DQ]DURWHGHO/DJR GRQGHQDFLyDOTXHOURPDQFH WDQVDELR\WDQGHFDQWDGR 1XQFDIXHUDFDEDOOHUR GHGDPDVWDQELHQVHUYLGR FRPRORIXH/DQ]DURWH GHOD%UHWDxDYHQLGR 3XHVGHVGHHQWRQFHVVHxRUHV ORVFDEDOOHURV³DQGDQGR´ SRUWRGDVSDUWHVGHOPXQGR KDQLGRVHGLODWDQGR $OOt$PDGtVGH*DXOD \)HOL[PDUWHVHKDQGDGR \DTXHO7LUDQWHHO%ODQFR QXQFDEDVWDQWHORDGR (VWRHVODFDEDOOHUtD OHVGHFtD'RQ)ULVDUGR HQODFXDOFRQRWURVPXFKRV \RWDPELpQKHSURIHVDGR YR\SRUHVWDVVROHGDGHV EXVFDQGRSRUGHVFDPSDGR DYHQWXUDVTXHOLEUDU FRQPLVyOREUD]RDUPDGR´ &RQWDQFUHFLGRGLVFXUVR GHMDEDELHQGHPRVWUDGR TXHDQGDEDIDOWRGHMXLFLR RWHQtDORYROFDGR 6LHQGRGLVFUHWR\DOHJUH HOWDQOODPDGR9LYDOGR SRUSDVDUVLQSHVDGXPEUH DVtGLMRD'RQ)ULVDUGR ³6HJ~QFUHRFDEDOOHUR YXHVWUDPHUFHGKDWRPDGR PiVHVWUHFKDSURIHVLyQ TXH&DUWXMRHQFDSXFKDGR´ ³7DQHVWUHFKDELHQSRGtD UHSXVRDOOt'RQ)ULVDUGR WDQQHFHVDULDORGXGR TXHRWUDDOJXQDVHKD\DGDGR´ 3RUTXHDGHFLUODYHUGDG 5RPDQFHGHO&DEDOOHUR)ULVDUGR QRKDFHPHQRVHOVROGDGR TXHKDFHHOPLVPRFDSLWiQ TXHVHORKXELHVHRUGHQDGR UH]DHOUHOLJLRVRDO&LHOR DFXELHUWR\VRVHJDGR DFWXDPRVORVFDEDOOHURV GH'LRVFRPREUD]RDUPDGR VROGDGRV\FDEDOOHURV VLHPSUHFXPSOHQORPDQGDGR QRGHEDMRGHFXELHUWD VLQRFRQVRORHUL]DGR WRGDVODVFRVDVGHJXHUUD KiFHQVHVLHPSUHVXGDQR VLQGXGDFRQPiVWUDEDMR TXHDTXHOORVTXHHVWiQ UH]DQGR 1RTXLHURGHFLUFRQHVR TXHIXHUDPHMRUHVWDGR HOGHFDEDOOHURDQGDQWH TXHVHUXQPRQMH HQFODXVWUDGR VLQRTXHHOVHUFDEDOOHUR HVPiVGXUR\DSRUUHDGR PiVVHGLHQWRPiVKDPEULHQWR PiVSLRMRVR\YDSXOHDGR´ ³(QHVRTXHGRGHDFXHUGR FRQWHVWyOHHOWDO9LYDOGR HQRWUDVPXFKDVGLVLHQWR TXHQXQFDVRQGHPLDJUDGR (ODUWHGHFDEDOOHURV OHGHFtDD'RQ)ULVDUGR HVJHQHUDORSLQLyQ TXHHVWiGHYLFLRVSODJDGR $OOtH[SXVRHOFDPLQDQWH ODVFDXVDVGHOGHVDJUDGR DFXDQWDVGXGDVPRVWUDED FRQWHVWyOH'RQ)ULVDUGR <HVTXHPXFKRVFDEDOOHURV FXDQGRHOSHOLJURHVOOHJDGR QXQFDVHHQFRPLHQGDD'LRV FRPRHVFULVWLDQRREOLJDGR HQFRPLpQGDQVHDVXGDPD FRQWDQWDJDQD\GHJUDGR FRPRDTXLHQHVWiHQHQHO&LHOR TXHWRGRVODKDQHQGLRVDGR ³(VRHVDVtODYHUGDG OHFRQWHVWy'RQ)ULVDUGR \TXLHQWDOFRVDQRKLFLHUH QXQFDIXHUDELHQPLUDGR´ ³&RQWRGRHVRVHxRU UHSOLFiEDOH9LYDOGR XQHVFU~SXORPHTXHGD VREUHHOFDEDOOHURDUPDGR \HVTXHWUDEDQGRVSDODEUDV XQRFRQHORWURDUPDGR \DUUHPHWHHOXQRDORWUR GHPRGRHQFROHUL]DGR HOXQRFDHPXHUWRDOVXHOR DVXGDPDHQFRPHQGDGR VLQHQFRPHQGDUVHD'LRV TXHWLHPSRQROHKDTXHGDGR 6LGHFDEDOOHURDQGDQWH HVDQGDUHQDPRUDGR ORHVWDUiYXHVWUDPHUFHG TXHHQHOORVKDSURIHVDGR´ 'HOOLQDMH\ODSURVDSLD \DOFXUQLDIXHSUHJXQWDGR GHODKHUPRVD'XOFLQHD ODGDPDGH'RQ)ULVDUGR $TXtFRQXQJUDQVXVSLUR FRQWHVWyOH'RQ)ULVDUGR ³'XOFLQHDGHO7RERVR 0DQXHO*RQ]iOH]&DEUHUD HVVXOLQDMHOODPDGR VXFDOLGDGHVSULQFHVD SXHVWLpQHPHGHYDVDOOR VXKHUPRVXUDVREUHKXPDQD TXHSRHWDVOHKDQFDQWDGR 6XIUHQWHFDPSRVHOtVHRV FDEHOORVGHRURGRUDGR VXVFHMDVDUFRVGHOFLHOR VXVRMRVVROHVTXHPDQGR VXVPHMLOODVVRQGRVURVDV VXVODELRVDFRUDODGRV EODQFDVSHUODVVRQVXVGLHQWHV HVVXFXHOORDODEDVWUDGR GHEODQFRPiUPROVXSHFKR VXVPDQRVPDU¿OWRUQHDGR VXEODQFXUDHVFRPRQLHYH GRQGHHOVROQXQFDDSHJDGR GHODVSDUWHVTXHDODYLVWD VXKRQHVWLGDGKDRFXOWDGR QLFRQWRGRHQWHQGLPLHQWR SXHGHVHULPDJLQDGR´ 'HOOLQDMH\ODSURVDSLD TXHOHSUHJXQWy9LYDOGR DTXt'RQ)ULVDUGRGDED GLVFXUVRELHQGHWDOODGR FLWyOHDSHOOLGRVQREOHV TXHODKLVWRULDKDQMDORQDGR ³'HO7RERVRGHOD0QDFKD HVVXOLQDMHOODPDGR \QDGLHHQHVWRUHSOLTXH TXHQRTXLHUDVHUSUREDGR´ (QSOiWLFDVWDQVDEURVDV SRUWRGRVHUDHVFXFKDGR SRUGRQGHYLHURQTXHHOMXLFLR IDOWiEDOHD'RQ)ULVDUGR 7DQVyOR3DQFKRFUH\HUD YHUGDGHVGH'RQ)ULVDUGR SRUTXHELHQVDEtDTXLpQHUD TXHMXQWRVVHKXELHURQFULDGR 'XOFLQHDGHO7RERVR WHQtDOHGHVFRQ¿DGR TXHQXQFDR\HUDWDOQRPEUH WHQLHQGRHO7RERVRDOODGR (QHVWRSRUHQWUHVLHUUDV \SRUVHLVKRPEUHVSRUWDGR D*ULVyVWRPRHQODVDQGDV OOHYDQDVHUHQWHUUDGR HOGLIXQWRFRQVXVDQGDV IXHHQHOVXHORFRORFDGR FRQÀRUHVOLEURV\HVFULWRV SRUWRGDVSDUWHVURGHDGR ³0LUD$PEURVLRVLHOOXJDU HVHOVLWLRVHxDODGR GRQGH*ULVyVWRPRTXLVR TXHDOPRULUIXHUDHQWHUUDGR´ ³$TXtHVGLMR$PEURVLR pOPLVPRORKXERFRQWDGR DTXtFRQRFLyD0DUFHOD \DTXtIXHGHVHQJDxDGR´ %ULQGyD'RQ)ULVDUGROXHJR \DFXDQWRVYDQDVXODGR XQSDQHJtULFRH[WHQVR VHQWLGR\HPRFLRQDGR ³(VWHFXHUSRTXHSLDGRVRV HVWiLVVHxRUHVPLUDQGR HVHOFXHUSRGH*ULVyVWRPR TXHHQWRGRIXHGHVGLFKDGR DPDED\IXHDERUUHFLGR DGRUy\IXHGHVGLFKDGR GLyOHPXHUWHXQDSDVWRUD GHTXLHQPXULyHQDPRUDGR ³/DKLVWRULDGHVXVDPRUHV 5RPDQFHGHO&DEDOOHUR)ULVDUGR TXHHVWiLVGHPLHVFXFKDQGR PRVWUDUDQELHQORVSDSHOHV TXHWRGRVDQGiLVPLUDQGR VLQRGHMiUDPHGLFKR HQWHVWDPHQWRHO¿QDGR TXHIXHUDQGDGRVDOIXHJR GHVSXpVTXHIXHUDHQWHUUDGR´ ³£6HUtDGHJUDQFUXHOGDG KDEODEDRWUDYH]9LYDOGR SULYDUDODKXPDQLGDG GHWDQYDOLRVROHJDGR 7HUXHJRGLVFUHWR$PEURVLR TXHPHVHDUHJDODGR ORVSDSHOHVTXHGHOIXHJR VDOYDUpHQHVWHSXxDGR HQWUHORVFXDOHVVHHQFXHQWUD XQRTXHHVWiWLWXODGR ³/D&DQFLyQ'HVHVSHUDGD´ FRPSXHVWDSRUHO¿QDGR´ ³&RQVLHQWRHQHOOR\RVSLGR VHiLVSRUWRGRVHVFXFKDGR TXHOHiLVFRQYR]FODUD ODVTXHMDVGHOGHVGLFKDGR´