Sanmartín Ortí, Pau. Otra historia del formalismo ruso

Anuncio
Dissidences
Hispanic Journal of Theory and Criticism
Volume 2 | Issue 4
Article 10
11-30-2012
Sanmartín Ortí, Pau. Otra historia del formalismo
ruso
Andrés Pérez-Simón
Follow this and additional works at: http://digitalcommons.bowdoin.edu/dissidences
Recommended Citation
Pérez-Simón, Andrés (2008) "Sanmartín Ortí, Pau. Otra historia del formalismo ruso," Dissidences: Vol. 2: Iss. 4, Article 10.
Available at: http://digitalcommons.bowdoin.edu/dissidences/vol2/iss4/10
This Review / Reseña is brought to you for free and open access by the Journals at Bowdoin Digital Commons. It has been accepted for inclusion in
Dissidences by an authorized administrator of Bowdoin Digital Commons. For more information, please contact jmontgom@bowdoin.edu.
Sanmartín Ortí, Pau. Otra historia del formalismo ruso
Keywords / Palabras clave
Russian Formalism, Formalismo ruso, Teoría literaria, Literary theory
This review / reseña is available in Dissidences: http://digitalcommons.bowdoin.edu/dissidences/vol2/iss4/10















 ! "#$%&'!()




*+,,*+!+*++$!$!-!*
)*!!*,*+*.!(/
0!!/'!!++*+*
*!1*02,'**+**
&'!*!+!!!!)* +*)*!
!*++!"+$,/3*'*$*4
+0*!5*!!1!-,*+!!+*!!,*
*!6,!-!6+(!*'(-+/+*,76"*'*
84!! +(*0
,*++$*!+!(4+*
'*+!!+!*!+*)*!33!*!9!!3*
'"!***"++9!****+++'
Dissidences. Hispanic Journal of Theory and Criticism 4/5 (2008) 1
!!+*!0*+)++***+!
.+*+-:!!7*!;!(++*!+!
'!+!.* "-#<((*(,/!3
+,+*!*,!!!++*"*!5*! +!:+-
-*(*.*=0!+!'*!!++!*
!++$*>-+-)*!?*3!+!+*+- !+*)+
!,!!*!!(!+5@ !6!*AB*
!!++$+-!$+!*-!*
)*!CDCE-!!!*+$)*!*!'B*+(5**
*,,*6*++*!++$(3!!$+3
+,//*"!,*!++$-!$+!0
!1FCG*)*!!!$*"$!!+++!
CDH++*'!$!1***!'
- ** ,*+++1!!0, CDH*,"$
,*+!*++$+4!)*!!3+!*!(!!
**'0,!+!!*!++!!-+*)+ !(
*!6++(+5* +0;,3!6!! +!
++++!+!*!3)*+*!'*5!
+!(+!*.*=**7*!!(*
I/0* +-!(*@CDDA(**7*!!(*
I/0$+*!+!(!)*!,/@CDDJA0!++!
.*=(!,!+!*!+-**3-,
+*!+-!+$,*3*,*++$*!++!*+!3
++*$+0>*$+?+!!$/+
Dissidences. Hispanic Journal of Theory and Criticism 4/5 (2008) 2
+*!'+,*!!1*!*"!*!++!+!3+,
+0CDJ.*=*!!**++!!++!
+!*,!+*!!*!!!*
!1*6!!*!5*! +!07**!++!+
*!'!'*5!+'*++!**,*
*7!0
*,++.*=**,3!+$(**
*!+*)*!))++**7*!!,*+
<+ICDHK0*!!!*+-('+(
' !++!*!*!()+!!4!)*!!<+I
-"!)"!!!3*!!+!-!!
'0!+*+!!!++$*!+*)*!*+$+
! +!+1*L!++*MN+!((!+**!*!+0
! !*,*++$*'!$!1**!*+-CDHE(+!
, **)+$!!!,*!+*!)+ !(*!+*
*!,!O=,!6'(=*'!=!+'!)+!,*!
+*3!$+!)*!*!!0
*+4+**,*+-!+'$*)+,6!+
!,*!+*)*!!!,*++$CDJJ(!!'!!'!!
CD2J(CD2D!$+*-!,!*!!0*
!*+-!,$5+3)*/9*5+9!
$+!,*)*!!!3+!*5+!,*++!
)!!4!!,*!* !07*+!(!
+* !,/**:!!7*!+!@CD2JA(CDHC/=
Dissidences. Hispanic Journal of Theory and Criticism 4/5 (2008) 3
(!=,*+*4!3+*, 4!*
I/0,*,*++$-!#;!)CDH,/
7+O!+*!,*+*++)+*!:!!
7*!,*3$*!'!6*,!/=(!=0
O!)+$!)*!!)*!!!
*!*+!)"*!+*!/+-
!+*!-!$+++!!(**'#!!0
+!!+O!41*6+(+*)*!
!*++0+5+/*+ *+!-
M-*()-(+!*!++!,**
,,*)+*3+!++*M +0**
+$3!*6!026!!$*+*(5+4
)*!!++>-7*-?I!+-,0*!(
+-,!6!!6++3++**$+!
!(!=*'!=6'(O=,!0!**M+*(*!
!(!O=,!>!+!+!?@CDJA(>N!+!)N
(!)-!+!,+!?@CDJ2A!4!,*+!! !!**
!!&!0!)6+*+3.0I0+-+**M
+!+!*!!(!3O=,!!+,$!
+"!*!1!'-!*!***<*
:!(!*!'+*,+$+*!+*0*/**
*M!-!3 !-*"*)O=,!
++*++$*)*!!M +'
*",*0*!!!+,+!*!'(*!
Dissidences. Hispanic Journal of Theory and Criticism 4/5 (2008) 4
:!+B++$!!*O=,!!+
644,!)*!3!!,,!!!+*
*6!4!9*!!+!!!5* !3
!+,0
+!*!6!+!**+$O=,!(*!+*
)*!*!3+!($*+$6!'*!0
5*4*++$+5+*!!+'!*)*!!!
!)+!+'***+*L!+!+5@PA(*
!++$*!*/ +@OQA!,0OQ
!+!(++$)*!!(!+
=*'!=(!I=0CDC2(CDCHOQ,*+!'*5!+*+'!!,
*/ ++!*()+I=0!!!1!*!,!
OQ+*+++*!(+ +*!)!!!!0
!*+*L!+!+5+)+*CDCH(!$*!
+!*!+!* !O=,!3CD-+!'/
0!+6!+*+- !!+$+$
!!!3!!*!*!!!!!CA!!!+!
*+*L!+!+5!+!,+!!*+*(
)*+*6!3+3'+!'++*!
**OQBA!*+-O=,!*!+'!!
!*!+!*$+!*!,(++
+!('+)*!0)*+*!!*!)!!
**,$+*+*!+5!+*4++$O=,!(+BKA
3O=,!+++*OQ!CDCH!*!!+
Dissidences. Hispanic Journal of Theory and Criticism 4/5 (2008) 5
-!CDCDCD(!!+*!!'*5!+*+'!
)+!I=0
!!!!+!!++*3O=,!+
**+*L!+!+5!'*'+**)*!
!0+!'+-!$+***+-('0!
3*+-+5,*+*+*,+$O=,!*+$!
:!!7*!;!(+'!$*!/!!O=,!!
36!*!+,*)+!*0!+*!!!
3!@A!+,*-!+**+$*+-(O=,!
3!>!)*P+*!3OQ*-!*
)*!!+*!*-6,**+*!53*
)*!!+"1!!+53!,?@KCA0'!$
3-+**-!$+*+-O=,!('/!)+!
**,*++$-!*)*!!0
(-+'!6*!!>-!?(>?
!33!*!*+-!+*6!+!!,*)*!!0
*" -*!++$-!$+#$++!)5+
4*0'*-!*)*!!!!CDCE#CCDC#E(
CDE#K0)!+)+!!)*!,/*
*I=(=*'!=3!!+-*+$+!!'
+*'+-(='!=0CDCE=*'!=,*+>!++$**,?
43+!!*+,+$*3!6*!+*)!(3
!++6** +)!(*!!!
*L!+!@CJA0R-+3!I=3"*!!!
Dissidences. Hispanic Journal of Theory and Criticism 4/5 (2008) 6
()+*!!!+*++!OQ+!CDC2(CDCH0
*!!!+*++!=*'!=,*+!+ *,!(>*+
+?*3!***!"+$!)*"+$
F!G++(!1!!>!++$**,?0
!!!1!=*'!=(I=+1!!,=,!=)*4
!,**/!+*F"G*"*!)!!(!!!!
!,**/ ++"!**)+*!,*!!!
*!*+FSG*6,6!4!**0
!*!)!*!+*)*!@CDC#EA++-,
O=,!(6'+1=*'!=0*)'!#'*+*
!)+**(*!;!*!!0
,++"+*!!++!+4!+
**,*!)*!!0O=,!(=*'!=*4*(I*
!+'9O=,!('*'*&:9!3+-,(
6'!!*!3!4!!!0!!*,***
*'!@CDEA6'!**!,+!**
*++$++!+'3+!!!!!!9)*$+
!6++!6+9(!,*+*+$6+*!!,!(
!,!06'!+,'!4!3*!5*!1!-
!+!,*+$*+*!/0!!'!=(
<*;+*@CDCA*"*)+$*!+!!$+!
+!*-!*+(+-!4*+
++;+--()(@CDJA0!4!+*!
!!>+ $+?@CDA(>*-+-*?@CDEA!
Dissidences. Hispanic Journal of Theory and Criticism 4/5 (2008) 7
!(!+!*!+!6!!1!0>*-+-*?3
+*!!*!,6!+!*3-!+++**!*!!!
+!1**'*.*=@CDDA(+** !
+**<-(+'))0R*!(>
+ $+?!$*+* !K*'!MN(
;!(+1'*!!(, +))FG0*!1*1
,*++$!!++!5+$!!*!+-!3 !
-++**6'-!)+-!(+!0
CDE+***+"*+(
5**!+*)*!0!*+*)(+4*+
!!1!!$*$+>*!)!/"!!!(!
+*!*+$!,''+$+**'+4?@KHJA0
=*'!=('*!!+I*!!!*!3 *
!+- +6!0**+!'*+!!+1!*
!+$6)+!,*!+!*+*+ )**+0)*!
CDE!,*+5*'!)++,+!+-,
=,!=6'P"!=!-'!=(*=*'!=3+-,!
*,!*!!!+-!*4!0+6')+-*!
+,!1=*'!=+*,*)',*+P6'(
++*('+!>!!*+0!!'(**,)(*
4!*3+*+*'?@+0CHA03=*'!=!,
!!*!!3*6)+)+!6*5*,*++$+*+'*
)*!0&+**6*+'!*4!+*
+,+CDK(3+!!!**!!+!
Dissidences. Hispanic Journal of Theory and Criticism 4/5 (2008) 8
*!+!!*+)'*!!!(++*3*
*+*0*+*!+CDJ++,+!
+"+!'+!4!(*'!!+'!
6!*!*0*+!!)4*+*
+-,!)!'+!*+*'!*
+**!!!!!!!0=*'!=!!+,,!)++$
++)6,+(!!+'"6!*(6++*)*+
-!*!**!+)+)*+3+!!
!*!)+++!!*+*0
CDJO=,!+*)+$*+*!!)
**+**-+!*'3!5,*+!*
)*$!)6T<!(=0=*'!=!-5!-(!
-+*!,*O=,!'*:!0*,!>!
!+/'(*/!!*!+!3=*'!=-,+*
+)6,+@CD2A(*3!:!!OQ+
+*)++*,!?@CKA0=*'!=+*!
+**+!+$*!*+*!,/* !' ++*
+'+O=,!!!**(+**+**3!
6! !6'0CDD6'!+,*!+*)!
+!!'!>O=,!!*+*-(OQ?@+0CKA0
-,*!+!++5*"+$OQ
CD(CDD3+!*"*'O=,!'*'!+50
CDK=*'!=,*+>+)+?+!
*+-+*+)+)+$*!)*!!0!
Dissidences. Hispanic Journal of Theory and Criticism 4/5 (2008) 9
,3*!'+!++)!$=*'!=!6!/++$+3
!+/++0*,!>!'++$*
+-*+5+)'('"*(*++*'
!+!*,=*'!=! +(!!,/!!+!+
!CDK?@CEA0*!'('**=*'!=!
)*!+,!-!$+#,6)+!!+$($4
*6'33!,''!+,'*!-!$+!0!$+!
!+!!=*'!=*!+!!*&$!+!' +!CDKE(CDK2
3*!+'*+!)+*-+!!*
3'+*+,*>+)+?0
3*6*!!3**'+,*+)!*)*!,
-,+*+/*I/+*$++6
OQ0*+*I/!$*-+)+**,
'*M0'* )**!!!*!@CDA!
+**)4!(*/!+!!*!+*!)*!!0
3*+-!$+*,3+,($*!!'
**3+$*!5*!'!!)*!!!(+'+3*!*!
4!!I//*"!,*,/*OQ0U
!++**!(-,*)*7.,*
?@CDEA4!!-(*!+**'*
!+*!N,*(0!4I/+!*!)*!!,/
*!***!!+$+!! +!+!
!*!!0!*,!!!3*)6!+)+*!*(!*
*+,+!!!!$*!+!)*!$)+!0*,!
Dissidences. Hispanic Journal of Theory and Criticism 4/5 (2008) 10
I/>')-,!!',(!(!+-*!-+*!-+!+!
,+!!,*)!!'()!0+!!(!+**()!
,!-+!)!+',*+?@2A0+!!6*'/!* +
*! +*3++"6*!'!*!+*
+$'!!3! +!!6*,+!
3)+5**!*!!+*!(-!0!)+!*+*!I/
(*!)*!!+),!*!+*!V!+,!WI/!
1!*!+-!6!,!4+!
+*!3+,+'*!+*FKG03
-,3+*CDE#K+(!)+!I/(*!+*
!'!3+**!(+!!!+"+*(+,
OQ0+*3+!)+$-!+++!'
**,!+'+$!!+,*-!!
+,(!/'!$*)*!!0



FCG3)5+*!!1*!+3!*,!!,*
++$*)*!!4!!!,*!*6,6!
***-!6+0

FG)++*!!!4!6'++!
* !++$-=!*!>-(7+0?<
-(00'))0;*N0D#EDB>-!+*
Dissidences. Hispanic Journal of Theory and Criticism 4/5 (2008) 11
<0?MN(;!(KE0K@KAJ2J#JD20!*!(+$+
*!('))>4*!!*!('!
<-!?*!6!JJK#J2K*!50

FKG4*+<*>,)*(--!)-I=--+*!
+*(++(0-(-N!,!)
++*--N))*!-!(-!!)N-+-N**(+!
!*+-!'++)X!-**#,++4)
+*!+(?@JHCA0



I=-=-*0>-,*)*7.,*0?!0
P-I!0!N,*(0!0+-*;*3!.'0
!0!,(.'0!&)4!CDD0JH#KJ0

<*70Y0>I=--!+I-!-+-*-
:++():+-@!A0?+!(0K#E@CDHAJ2J#JHH0

Dissidences. Hispanic Journal of Theory and Criticism 4/5 (2008) 12
Descargar