AN 34C2B8@28~>!34< @B?3E2D? 0ZVSMKMSYXO] IoYe?WhZ DX=.Y![i!kd!j[ij!Z[!Z_W]d ij_* Ye!%'!,%+*( fWhW!c[Z_h!Z[!kdW!\ehcW!ht f_ZW bW! ^[ce]beX_dW! ]b_Yei_bWZW! [d! bW! iWd]h[ ^kcWdW+ @\SXMSZSY!NOV!^O]^ IoYe?WhZ DX=.Y! ! [i! kd! j[ij! Z[! W\_d_ZWZ Z[b!XehedWje+! Ab! a_j! Yedj_[d[! lWh_Wi! fbWYWi Z[! j[ij! Yecfk[ijWi! feh! kd! \_bjhe! Z[! c[c* XhWdW! feheiW)! Yedj_[d[! jWcX_y d! jkXei! Z[ [diWoei! bb[dei! Z[! h[WYj_le! o! kdW! iebkY_ d Z[!bWlWZe+!!Gei!h[WYj_lei!Yedj_[d[d!ikijWd* Y_Wi!gk[!hecf[d!bei![h_jheY_jei!o!fheZkY[d kdW!fh[Y_f_jWY_ d![if[Y}\_YW!Z[!bW!^[ce]be* X_W)! bk[]e! kd! Yed`k]WZe! Z[! t Y_Ze! X h_Ye WYefbWZe! W! kd! YebehWdj[! Wpkb! i[! \_`W! W! bWi Yed\_]khWY_ed[i!Y_i*Z_eb!Z[!bW!^[ce]beX_dW ]b_Yei_bWZW+ ?kWdZe!bW!iWd]h[![i!WZ_Y_edWZW!Wb!h[WYj_le bei! [h_jheY_jei! ied! _dc[Z_WjWc[dj[! b_iWZei o! bW! ^[ce]beX_dW! jejWb! fh[Y_f_jW+! Ab! Yed`k* ]WZe! Z[! t Y_Ze! X h_Ye! i[! kd[! _dc[Z_WjW* c[dj[! W! bW! Yed\_]khWY_ d! Y_i*Z_eb! Z[! bW ^[ce]beX_dW! ]b_Yei_bWZW+! PdW! Wb}YkejW! Z[ [ijW! c[pYbW! Yed! [b! h[WYj_le! [i! Wfb_YWZW ieXh[! bW! fbWYW! Z[b! j[ij! o! bW! ^[ce]beX_dW jejWb!b_Xh[!e!Yed`k]WZW!f[hcWd[Y[![d![b!\_b* jhe+!OeZe![b![nY[ie!Z[!Yed`k]WZe!Yebeh[W* Ze![i![b_c_dWZe!feh!bW!iebkY_ d!Z[!bWlWZe+ Ab!fh[Y_f_jWZe![i!lWbehWZe!feh!bW!c[Z_ZW!Z[ bW! _dj[di_ZWZ! Z[! bW! YebehWY_ d! Wpkb! &^[ce* ]beX_dW! ]b_Yei_bWZW'! e! he`W! &^[ce]beX_dW jejWb'![d![b!c[Z_Zeh!IoYe?WhZ MA=@AM!EE bW! b[YjkhW! eXj[d_ZW! [i! fhefehY_edWb! Wb! feh* Y[djW`[!Z[!DX=.Y![d!bW!ck[ijhW+ 2YX^OXSNY!NOV!^O]^&!,.!^O]^ D3)3S]ZY]S^S`Y]'^O]^] +!b!,.!_XSNKNO] Gei!Z_ifei_j_lei!j[ij!ied!fbWYWi!Z[!fbt ij_Ye YkX_[hjWi!Z[!kdW!c[cXhWdW!\_bjhe+ B+)BOKM^S`Y! +!b!,.!b!*(,!W< NebkY_ d!jWcf d!Z[!]b_Y_dWc_ZW!gk[!Yedj_* [d[! _ed[i! Ud! Z[! t Y_Ze! X h_Ye! Yed`k]WZe Yed!kd!YebehWdj[!o!Z[j[h][dj[i+ B,)CYV_MSqX!NO!VK`KNY! +!b!,(*!W< NebkY_ d!Z[!IW?b!jWcfedWZW!W!bW!ceh\eb_dW o!Z[j[h][dj[i+ =K^O\SKVO]!XOMO]K\SY]!XY! ]_WSXS]^\KNY]!OX!OV!US^ * OkXei! YWf_bWh[i! e! c_Yhef_f[jWi! &2! G' fWhW!bW!ck[ijhW+! * H_Yhef_f[jWi!Z[!/2! G o!fkdjWi!Z[!f_f[jW Wfhef_WZWi!fWhW!bW!Wfb_YWY_ d!Z[!bW!c[p* YbW!Yed![b!h[WYj_le!o!Z[!bW!M/,NebkY_ d!Z[ bWlWZe+! * IoYe?WhZ MA=@AM!EE! fWhW! bW! c[Z_Y_ d YkWdj_jWj_lW!Z[b!h[ikbjWZe+ 2_SNKNY]!c!Z\OMK_MSYXO] EQ@!!!KWhW!kie![nYbki_le!Z[!Z_W]d ij_Ye!%' ,%+*(+ * M.,M[WYj_le! o! M/,NebkY_ d! Z[! bWlWZe Yedj_[d[d!Wp_ZW!i Z_YW!&-+-2$')!kd!Yec* fk[ije!j n_Ye+ * Ab! M.,M[WYj_le! Yedj_[d[! \ehcWc_ZW &3+/$'! kd! Yecfk[ije! j n_Ye! [! _hh_jWdj[ fWhW!bW!f_[b!o!e`ei+ * GW!M/,NebkY_ d!Z[!bWlWZe!Yedj_[d[!ceh* \eb_dW!&2-!cceb,G'!kd!Yecfk[ije!j n_Ye+ 4]ZOMSPSMSNKN!KXKVp^SMK! IoYe?WhZ DX=.Y!c_Z[!bW!^[ce]beX_dW!]b_* Yei_bWZW! jejWb! &CDX'! o! ! ZW! kd! lWbeh! [ijWd* ZWh_pWZe!Z[!DX=.Y+ 4]^KXNK\SdKMSqX =n_i*N^_[bZ! Ke?! =N! jhWXW`W! [d! [ijh[Y^W YebWXehWY_ d!Yed![b!GWXehWjeh_e!Z[!h[\[h[d* Y_W! Akhef[e! &AMG'! [d! bW! c[Z_ZW! Z[! bW ^[ce]beX_dW!]b_Yei_bWZW+!IoYe?WhZ DX=.Y Ykcfb[! Yed! bWi! h[Yec[dZWY_ed[i! Z[! bW @??O o!Z[!EB??+ BKXQY]!NO!WONSNK! MWd]ei!Z[!c[Z_ZW7!0*.5$!DX=.Y Edj[hlWbei!Z[!c[Z_ZW7!-+.$!DX=.Y .2 FKVY\O]!NO!\OPO\OXMSK!>cMY2K\Nu 7L0+M 1+2*3+0$!DX=.Y @\OMS]SqX Ab!Ye[\_Y_[dj[!Z[!lWh_WY_ d!&?Q'![i!_d\[h_eh W!kd!2$!fWhW!jeZe![b!hWd]e!Z[!c[Z_ZW+ <SWS^KMSYXO]!NOV!^O]^! * GW!fh[i[dY_W!Z[!YWdj_ZWZ[i![b[lWZWi!Z[ ]bkYeiW)! X_b_hhkX_dW)! b}f_Zei! o! \hkYjeiWc_* dW! [d! ck[ijhWi! Z[! iWd]h[! Yed! lWbeh[i dehcWb[i! Z[! DX=.Y! &2+.$'! e! [b[lWZei &6+4$'!de!^Wd!fh[i[djWZe!_dj[h\[h[dY_Wi [d!bei!lWbeh[i!eXj[d_Zei+ * GW! ^[ce]beX_dW! fh[*]b_Yei_bWZW! de! _dj[h* \_[h[!Yed![b!j[ij+! *! Hk[ijhWi!^[ceb_pWZWi!Yed!YedY[djhWY_e* d[i! fbWict j_YWi! Z[! DX! <0! ],.--! cG fk[Z[d! _dj[h\[h_h! [d! bei! h[ikbjWZei! Z[b j[ij+ * GWi! YedY[djhWY_ed[i! Z[! DX! Yecfh[d* Z_ZWi![djh[!3*.5!],.--!cG ied!Wkject j_* YWc[dj[! Yehh[]_Zei! feh! IoYe?WhZ MA=@AM!EE+ 4CD018<8303!H 2?>C4BF028~> ;S^]!]SX!KL\S\! GW!\[Y^W!_cfh[iW![d![b![dlWi[!eh_]_dWb!Z[b a_j!de![i!lt b_ZW!fWhW!bei!fheZkYjei!de!Yed* i[hlWZei![djh[!/*5 ?![d!ik![dlWi[!eh_]_dWb+ Al_j[!bW![nfei_Y_ d!Z[!bei! h[WYj_lei!W! j[c* f[hWjkhWi! ikf[h_eh[i! W! /2 ?! o! W! ^kc[ZW* Z[i!h[bWj_lWi!ikf[h_eh[i!W!4-$+!Ie!Yed][* bWh+ ;S^]!KLSO\^Y] * B+)BOKM^S`Y Z[X[! Yedi[hlWhi[! Wb[`WZe Z[! bW! bkp)! W! j[cf[hWjkhW! [djh[! /*5 ?+! Ab M.,M[WYj_le!de!Z[X[!i[h!!kj_b_pWZe!_dc[* Z_WjWc[dj[! Z[ifky i! Z[! iWYWhbe! Z[b! h[\h_* ][hWZeh! i_d! Wj[cf[hWh! Wdj[i+! N[! Z[X[ WYedZ_Y_edWh! W! j[cf[hWjkhW! WcX_[dj[ &/-*/2 ?'!Wdj[i!Z[!ik!kie+!KWhW!Wj[cf[* hWh![b!M.,M[WYj_le!ct i!ht f_ZWc[dj[!cWd* j[d]W![b!jkXe!h[WYj_le![d!bW!cWde!Y[hhWZW ZkhWdj[! 0-! i[]kdZei+! Ab! h[WYj_le! M. fk[Z[!i[h!WbcWY[dWZe!feh!kd!ct n_ce!Z[ 3! ^ehWi! W! j[cf[hWjkhW! WcX_[dj[i! Wdj[i Z[!ik!kie+!Al_j[!bW!bkp!iebWh!Z_h[YjW+ .3 * B,)CYV_MSqX!NO!VK`KNY Z[X[!Yedi[hlWh* i[!W!j[cf[hWjkhW!WcX_[dj[!&.2*/2 ?'+!GW iebkY_ d!Z[!bWlWZe!&M/'!Z[X[![ijWh!W!j[c* f[hWjkhW!WcX_[dj[!YkWdZe!lWoW!W!i[h!kj_b_* pWZe+! * D3)3S]ZY]S^S`Y]'^O]^ Z[X[d!Yedi[hlWhi[ W! j[cf[hWjkhW! WcX_[dj[! &.2*/2 ?'+ =bcWY[d[! bWi! fbWYWi! j[ij! ! [d! ik! [dlWi[ eh_]_dWb!o![l_j[!^kc[ZWZ[i!h[bWj_lWi!_d\[* h_eh[i!Wb!/$!o!ikf[h_eh[i!W!4-!$+!GWi!fbW* YWi!j[ij!Z[X[d![ijWh!W!j[cf[hWjkhW!WcX_* [dj[!YkWdZe!lWoWd!W!i[h!kiWZWi+ =_O]^\K GWi!ck[ijhWi!Z[!iWd]h[!fk[Z[d!Yedi[hlWh* i[!ZkhWdj[!.-!Z}Wi![djh[!/*5 ?+!Al_jWh!kj_b_* pWh!ck[ijhWi!^[ceb_pWZWi+!Ie!Yed][bWh+ @B?2438=84>D?!34< D4CD 2YX]OTY]!]YL\O!OV!WYNY! NO!YZO\KMSqX" * Ie!c[pYbWh!h[WYj_lei!Z[!bej[i!Z_\[h[dj[i+ * =j[cf[hWh![b!M.,M[WYj_le!W!j[cf[hWjkhW WcX_[dj[!&/-*/2 ?'!Wdj[i!Z[!kiWhbe+ * Ie! jeYWh! bW! c[cXhWdW! Yed! bW! fkdjW! Z[ bWi!c_Yhef_f[jWi+ * ?WcX_Wh!bW!fkdjW!Z[!bW!c_Yhef_f[jW!Z[i* fky i!Z[!YWZW!Wfb_YWY_ d+ =_O]^\K Kk[Z[!i[h!kj_b_pWZW!iWd]h[!YWf_bWh!e!l[de* iW!Yed!e!i_d!W• WZ_h!kd!Wdj_YeW]kbWdj[!&IWB) A@O= o!D[fWh_dW'+ 2YX^\YV!SX^O\XY!NO!MKVSNKN KWhW! Wi[]khWh! ! kd! Yedjheb! Z[! YWb_ZWZ WZ[YkWZe!o!l[h_\_YWh!bW![\_YWY_W!Z[!bW!h[Wb_* pWY_ d!Z[b!j[ij+!An_ij[!kdW!iebkY_ d!Z[!Yed* jheb!Z_ifed_Xb[!fWhW!hWj_\_YWh!gk[!bei!lWbeh[i eXj[d_Zei!Yed!IoYe?WhZ DX=.Y!ied!WZ[* YkWZei+ Ie!kj_b_pWh!ejhWi!ikijWdY_Wi!Yedjheb!Z_\[h[d* j[i!W!bWi!fhefehY_edWZWi!feh![b!\WXh_YWdj[+ @\YMONSWSOX^Y + @\OMSZS^KMSqX!NO!VK!ROWYQVYLSXK!! = WZ_h!2! G Z[!iWd]h[!Yecfb[jW![d![b!jkXe!Z[![diWoe!fh[bb[dWZe!Yed![b M.,M[WYj_le+!H[pYbWh!X_[d!!o!Z[`Wh!h[feiWh!ZkhWdj[!/!c_dkjei!f[he!i_d!ikf[hWh!bei!0 c_dkjei+ >Y^K" =i[] h[i[!Z[!gk[![b!jkXe!YWf_bWh![ijt !Yecfb[jWc[dj[!lWY}e!Z[ifky i!Z[!bW c[pYbW+! , 0ZVSMKMSqX!NO!VK!W_O]^\K! H[pYbWh!dk[lWc[dj[!Yed![b!\_d!Z[!eXj[d[h!kdW!ikif[di_ d!^ece]y d[W+ @[fei_jWh!/2! G Z[!bW!c[pYbW!ieXh[![b!O@,@_ifei_j_le*j[ij!cWdj[d_[dZe!bW!c_Yhef_f[jW i[fWhWZW!Wb!c[dei!-+2!Yc!Z[!bW!fbWYW!Z[b!j[ij+!@[`Wh!f[d[jhWh!Yecfb[jWc[dj[!bW c[pYbW!h[WYj_lW![d!bW!c[cXhWdW!Z[b!Z_ifei_j_le+ Aif[h[!Wfhen_cWZWc[dj[!.-!i[]kdZei+ >Y^K" Al_j[!bW!\ehcWY_ d!Z[!XkhXk`Wi!Z[!W_h[+ - 0ZVSMKMSqX!NO!VK!B,)CYV_MSqX!NO!VK`KNY! = WZ_h!/2! G Z[!bW!M/,NebkY_ d!Z[!bWlWZe!ieXh[!bW!fbWYW!Z_ifei_j_le)!Z[`Wh f[d[jhWh!bW!iebkY_ d!Z[!bWlWZe!Yecfb[jWc[dj[!ieXh[!bW!c[cXhWdW+!Aif[h[!kd!c}d_ce Z[!.-!i[]kdZei+ >Y^K" Al_j[!gk[!i[!\ehc[d!XkhXk`Wi!Z[!W_h[+ . <OM^_\K!NOV!\O]_V^KNY G[W![b!h[ikbjWZe!Z[djhe!Z[!bei!2!c_dkjei!i_]k_[dj[i!kj_b_pWdZe!IoYe?WhZ MA=@AM!EE+! >Y^K" GWi!_dijhkYY_ed[i!fWhW!bW!b[YjkhW!i[![dYk[djhWd!Z[djhe!Z[b!cWdkWb!Z[ _dijhkYY_ed[i!Z[!IoYe?WhZ MA=@AM!EE+ .4 @?C81<4C!20EC0C!34!B4CE<D03?C!4BB~>4?C @\YLVOWK @Y]SLVO!MK_]K CYV_MSqX Ab!fh[Y_f_jWZe!de!YkXh[ Yecfb[jWc[dj[!!bW!ikf[h* \_Y_[!Z[!bW!c[cXhWdW!Z[b+ O@,@_ifei_j_lei*j[iji &cWdY^Wi!XbWdYWi!ieXh[!bW ikf[h\_Y_[!Z[!bW!c[cXhWdW'+ GW!c[pYbW!Z[b!h[WYj_le!i[!^W!W• W* Z_Ze!cko!Z[ifWY_e!e!ieXh[!bei XehZ[i!Z[!bW!fbWYW!j[ij+ M[Wb_pWh!Z[!dk[le!bW!c[pYbW!o!W• W* Z_h!ht f_ZWc[dj[!bW!c[pYbW!ieXh[![b Y[djhe!Z[!bW!fbWYW!j[ij+ PdW!XkhXk`W!Z[!W_h[!i[!^W!\ehcW* Ze![d![b!cec[dje!Z[!WZ_Y_edWh!bW c[pYbW![d!bW!fbWYW!j[ij+ =dWb_pWh!Z[!dk[le!bW!ck[ijhW+ OecWdZe!bW!fh[YWkY_ d!Z[!gk[!de i[!\ehc[d!XkhXk`Wi!Z[!W_h[+ =bcWY[dWc_[dje!_dYehh[Yje!Z[!bWi fbWYWi!O[ij+ M[Wb_Y[!Z[!dk[le!bW!fhk[XW!kj_b_p* WdZe!kdW!dk[lW!fbWYW!O[ij+ =ki[dY_W!Z[!fh[Y_f_jWZe ieXh[!bW!c[cXhWdW!Z[b O@,@_ifei_j_le*j[ij+ GW!c[pYbW!h[Wb_pWZW!Wdj[i!Z[!bW _dYkXWY_ d!^W!i_Ze!_dYecfb[jW)!o [b!jkXe!YWf_bWh!de!^W!i_Ze!lWY_WZe Yecfb[jWc[dj[+ =dWb_pWh!Z[!dk[le!bW!ck[ijhW+ H[pYbWdZe!X_[d![b!h[WYj_le!o!Wi[* ]kht dZei[!gk[![b!jkXe!YWf_bWh![ijt Yecfb[jWc[dj[!lWY}e!Wdj[i!Z[!bW _dYkXWY_ d+ IoYe?WhZ MA=@AM!EE ck[ijhW![d!bW!fWdjWbbW!DX YedY+!jee!bem!&?edY[d* jhWY_ d!Z[!DX!cko!XW`W'+ GW!YedY[djhWY_ d!Z[!^[ce]beX_dW fh[i[dj[![d!bW!ck[ijhW![i!_d\[h_eh Wb!hWd]e!Z[!c[Z_ZW+ =dWb_pWh!Z[!dk[le!bW!c[pYbW!kj_b_p* WdZe!.-! G Z[!iWd]h[![dj[hW7!bb[d[ i_ckbjt d[Wc[dj[!/!jkXei!YWf_bWh[i o!c[pYb[![b!Yedj[d_Ze!Z[!WcXei [d!ejhe!jkXe!Z[![diWoe!Yed![b M.,M[WYj_le+!N[]khWc[dj[![b _dijhkc[dje!W^ehW!i_!b[!ceijhWht ![b h[ikbjWZe![nWYje+ IoYe?WhZ MA=@AM!E ck[ijhW![d!bW!fWdjWbbW M[ZkY[!DX!YedY+ &M[ZkY_h!YedY[djhWY_ d!Z[ DX'+ GW!YedY[djhWY_ d!Z[!^[ce]beX_dW Z[!bW!ck[ijhW![i!ikf[h_eh!Wb!hWd]e Z[!c[Z_ZW+ H[pYb[![b!M.,M[WYj_le!fhel[d_[dj[ Z[!Zei!jkXei!Z[![diWoe!&1--! G'!o WdWb_Y[!Z[!dk[le!bW!ck[ijhW! &2! G'+!N[]khWc[dj[![b!_dijhkc* [dje!W^ehW!i_!b[!ceijhWht ![b h[ikbjWZe![nWYje+ Ab!lebkc[d!Z[!bW!M/,NebkY_ d!Z[ bWlWZe!W• WZ_ZW!W!bW!ck[ijhW![i _dik\_Y_[dj[+ =dWb_Y[!Z[!dk[le!bW!ck[ijhW+ =i[]kht dZei[!gk[![b!lebkc[d!Z[ bW!M/,NebkY_ d!Z[!bWlWZe![i [nWYjWc[dj[!/2! G+ Ab!M.,M[WYj_le!de!^W!i_Ze!Wj[cf[* hWZe!W!j[cf[hWjkhW!WcX_[dj[!&/-* /2 ?'!Wdj[i!Z[!ik!kie+ M[Wb_Y[!Z[!dk[le![b!j[ij)!Wi[]k* ht dZei[!gk[![b!M.,M[WYj_le!^W i_Ze!Wj[cf[hWZe!W!j[cf[hWjkhW WcX_[dj[!Wdj[i!Z[!ik!kie+ Ab!M.,M[WYj_le!^W!i_Ze!WbcWY[dW* Ze!W!j[cf[hWjkhW!WcX_[dj[!e!de fhej[]_Ze!Z[!bW!bkp!iebWh!Z_h[YjW+ M[Wb_Y[!Z[!dk[le![b!j[ij!kj_b_pWdZe kd!M.,M[WYj_le!gk[!^WoW!i_Ze WbcWY[dWZe!Yehh[YjWc[dj[)!h[\h_* ][hWZe!o!fhej[]_Ze!Z[!bW!bkp!iebWh+ GW!!ck[ijhW!kj_b_pWZW![hW D[ceb_pWZW+ M[Wb_Y[!Z[!dk[le![b!j[ij!kj_b_pWdZe kdW!ck[ijhW!Z[!iWd]h[!\h[iYW+ Ab!M.,M[WYj_le!de!^W!i_Ze!Wj[cf[* hWZe!W!j[cf[hWjkhW!WcX_[dj[!&/-* /2 ?'!Wdj[i!Z[!ik!kie+ M[Wb_Y[!Z[!dk[le![b!j[ij)!Wi[]k* ht dZei[!gk[![b!M.,M[WYj_le!^W i_Ze!Wj[cf[hWZe!W!j[cf[hWjkhW WcX_[dj[!Wdj[i!Z[!ik!kie+ GW!!ck[ijhW!kj_b_pWZW![hW D[ceb_pWZW+ M[Wb_Y[!Z[!dk[le![b!j[ij!kj_b_pWdZe kdW!ck[ijhW!Z[!iWd]h[!\h[iYW+ QWbeh[i!eXj[d_Zei!ct i XW`ei!Z[!bei![if[hWZei+ GW!M/,NebkY_ d!Z[!bWlWZe de!i[!^W!WXiehX_Ze![d![b _dj[h_eh!Z[!bW!c[cXhWdW!Z[ bW!fbWYW!j[ij+ .5