DQH[R 'HVFULSFLyQ\DQiOLVLVGHODGLVFDSDFLGDGPRWUL] /$',6&$3$&,'$'0275,=5tRVD /DGLVFDSDFLGDGPRWUL]HVGHILQLGDFRPR ´«XQDDOWHUDFLyQGHODSDUDWRPRWRUFDXVDGDSRUXQIXQFLRQDPLHQWRGHILFLHQWHGHOVLVWHPDQHUYLRVRFHQWUDO GHO VLVWHPD PXVFXODU GHO VLVWHPD yVHR R GH XQD LQWHUUHODFLyQ GH WRGRV WUHV VLVWHPDV TXH GLILFXOWD R LPSRVLELOLWDODPRYLOLGDGIXQFLRQDOGHXQDRGLYHUVDVSDUWHVFRUSRUDOHVµ%DVLO%ROHD6RUR&DPDWVS ´(V WRGD SHUVRQD LQFDSD] GH DWHQGHU SRU HOOD PLVPD WRWDO R SDUFLDOPHQWH ODV QHFHVLGDGHV GH VX YLGD LQGLYLGXDO \ VRFLDO QRUPDO FRPR FRQVHFXHQFLD GH XQD GHILFLHQFLD FRQJpQLWD R QR \ TXH OH SURGXFH XQD VHFXHODHQVXVFDSDFLGDGHVItVLFDV\RPRWULFHVµ2ULRO0DUWtQH] 3DUDFODVLILFDUODGLVFDSDFLGDGPRWUL]GHEHUiWHQHUVHHQFXHQWD%DVLO%ROHD6RUR&DPDWV (OPRPHQWRHQTXHVHSURGXFHODDOWHUDFLyQFRQJpQLWDTXHH[LVWHGHVGHHOQDFLPLHQWR\DVHDSRU FDXVDVJHQpWLFDVRVREUHYHQLGDVRDGTXLULGDVHSURGXFHDFRQVHFXHQFLDGHIDFWRUHVDPELHQWDOHVX RUJiQLFRV /D GXUDFLyQ GH OD DOWHUDFLyQ WHPSRUDO VX GXUDFLyQ HV GHWHUPLQDGD \ KD\ XQ UHWRUQR D OD FDVL QRUPDOLGDGRSHUPDQHQWHGXUDQWHWRGDODYLGD /DHYROXFLyQGHODDOWHUDFLyQGHJHQHUDWLYDHPSHRUDFRQHOSDVRGHOWLHPSRKDVWDOOHJDUDODPXHUWH RQRGHJHQHUDWLYDVHPXHVWUDHVWDEOHHQHOWLHPSR $ FRQWLQXDFLyQ VLQWHWL]DUHPRV DTXHOODV GLVFDSDFLGDGHV PRWULFHV PiV IUHFXHQWHV HQ HO FRQWH[WR HVFRODU EDViQGRQRV SULQFLSDOPHQWH HQ ODV DSRUWDFLRQHV GH %DVLO %ROHD 6RUR&DPDWV )DJRDJD 5tRVD\2ULRO0DUWtQH] (VSLQDEtILGD /D(VSLQD%tILGDHVXQDPDOIRUPDFLyQFRQJpQLWDTXHFRQVLVWHHQXQHUURUGHXQLyQHQWUHHOWXERQHXUDO \ ORV DUFRV YHUWHEUDOHV SRVWHULRUHV GXUDQWH HO SHUtRGR SUHQDWDO FXDUWD VHPDQD GHO HPEDUD]R 6H SURGXFH XQ HUURU HQ HO FLHUUH GH OD FROXPQD YHUWHEUDO GH WDO IRUPD TXH DOJXQDV YpUWHEUDV TXHGDQ DELHUWDV \ OD PpGXOD HVSLQDO HQWUD HQ FRQWDFWR FRQ HO H[WHULRU 6XV VHFXHODV VRQ IUHFXHQWHPHQWH LUUHYHUVLEOHV &XDQGR XQ QLxR R XQD QLxD QDFH FRQ (VSLQD %tILGD SXHGH SUHVHQWDU XQD HYLGHQWH SURWXEHUDQFLDHQODHVSDOGDH[FHSWXDQGROD(VSLQD%tILGD2FXOWDTXHQRLPSOLFDVLQWRPDWRORJtD(O DQiOLVLVGHVXFRQWHQLGRSHUPLWHHVWDEOHFHUXQDSULPHUDFODVLILFDFLyQ (VSLQD%tILGD2FXOWDGHVFULWDFRPRODDIHFWDFLyQGHODHVWUXFWXUDyVHDGHODUFRDQWHULRURSRVWHULRU YHUWHEUDO&RPRKHPRVFRPHQWDGRQRSURGXFHPDQLIHVWDFLRQHVFOtQLFDVVLJQLILFDWLYDV (VSLQD %tILGD FRQ 0HQLQJRFHOH HQ OD SURWXEHUDQFLD KD\ PHQLQJHV \ OtTXLGR FHIDORUUDTXtGHR 3UHFLVDWUDWDPLHQWRTXLU~UJLFR\JHQHUDOPHQWHQRSURGXFHVHFXHODV (VSLQD%tILGDFRQ0LHORPHQLQJRFHOH HQ OD SURWXEHUDQFLD KD\ PpGXOD OtTXLGRFHIDORUUDTXtGHR\ PHQLQJHV &RQVLGHUDGD OD PRGDOLGDG PiV JUDYH GDGR TXH SURGXFH XQ PD\RU Q~PHUR GH VHFXHODVPRWLYDGDVSRUODJUDYHDIHFWDFLyQGHODPpGXOD\ODVGLILFXOWDGHVGHGUHQDMHGHOOtTXLGR FHIDORUUDTXtGHR 'HVWDFDQDOJXQDVVHFXHODVTXHSXHGHQSUHVHQWDUVH 3DUiOLVLV\IDOWDGHVHQVLELOLGDGGHODPXVFXODWXUDHQHUYDGDSRUGHEDMRGHOQLYHOGHODOHVLyQ 6RQSDUiOLVLVLUUHYHUVLEOHVFRPSRUWDQGRORVSUREOHPDVGHFLUFXODFLyQVDQJXtQHDSURSLDVGH FXDOTXLHU]RQDSDUDOL]DGD 0DOIRUPDFLRQHV\GHIRUPLGDGHVDVRFLDGDV )UHFXHQWHPHQWHVHDFRPSDxDGHKLGURFHIDOLD8QDXPHQWRGHOtTXLGRFHIDORUUDTXtGHRHQORV YHQWUtFXORVFHUHEUDOHVSRUXQDGHVFRPSHQVDFLyQHQWUHODSURGXFFLyQ\ODHOLPLQDFLyQGHpVWH 3RUHOORVHFRORFDHQORVSULPHURVGtDVGHYLGDXQDYiOYXODHQORVYHQWUtFXORVFHUHEUDOHVGHO QLxR XQLGD D XQ WXER GH SOiVWLFR TXH DFDED HQ HO SHULWRQHR \ TXH UHDOL]DUi OD IXQFLyQ GH GUHQDUHOOtTXLGRDOPDFHQDGRHQYLiQGRORDOWRUUHQWHVDQJXtQHRGRQGHVHHOLPLQD&XDQGRVH SURGXFHKLGURFHIDOLDKD\SRVLELOLGDGHVGHUHSHUFXVLRQHVHQHOiPELWRFRJQLWLYR\GHOiUHDGHO OHQJXDMH ,QFRQWLQHQFLDGHHVItQWHUHVYHVLFDO\DQDO (Q IXQFLyQGHOOXJDUGHODFROXPQDGRQGH VH SURGX]FD OD SURWXEHUDQFLDWDPELpQSRGUiGHWHUPLQDUVH XQD PD\RU R PHQRU JUDYHGDG &XDQWR PiV SUy[LPD DO FUiQHR OD DIHFFLyQ VHUi PD\RU \ FRQVHFXHQWHPHQWHPHQRUVHUiODDXWRQRPtD 3DUiOLVLVFHUHEUDO3&LQIDQWLO $IHFWDQGR D XQ SRU PLO GH ORV QHRQDWRV VH GHILQH FRPR XQ WUDVWRUQR GHO WRQR SRVWXUDO \ GHO PRYLPLHQWRGHFDUiFWHUSHUVLVWHQWHSHURQRLQYDULDEOHVHFXQGDULRDXQDDJUHVLyQQRSURJUHVLYDHQXQ FHUHEURLQPDGXURDQWHVGHORVDxRVGHHGDG (OORLPSOLFDTXHODVVHFXHODVHVWDUiQSUHVHQWHVDORODUJRGHWRGDODYLGDSHURDOJXQDVFDSDFLGDGHV IXQFLRQDOHVSRGUiQVHUUHKDELOLWDGDVRKDELOLWDGDVGDGRTXHODDJUHVLyQWLHQHOXJDUHQXQFHUHEURHQ GHVDUUROORWDOGHVDUUROORFXOPLQDDORVDxRV /DVFDXVDVGHOD3&VHGHWHUPLQDQHQIXQFLyQGHODHWDSDHQODTXHKDWHQLGROXJDUODDJUHVLyQ 3HUtRGR SUHQDWDO GXUDQWH HO SHUtRGR LQWUDXWHULQR VH SXHGHQ HQFRQWUDU FDXVDV JHQpWLFDV FURPRVyPLFDV R ELHQ LQIHFFLRQHV LQWUDXWHULQDV HO HIHFWR GH DOJXQDV GURJDV R Wy[LFRV FRPR HO DOFRKROODGLDEHWHVPDWHUQDWUDXPDWLVPRVHQWUHRWURV 3HUtRGRSHULQDWDOHVGHFLUHQHOPRPHQWRGHOSDUWR&OiVLFDPHQWHODFDXVDPDVFRQRFLGDHVHO VXIULPLHQWR IHWDO GXUDQWH HO SDUWR TXH SURGXFH XQD DQR[LD R IDOWD GH LUULJDFLyQ VDQJXtQHD HQ HO FHUHEURGHOQLxRRGHODQLxD 3HUtRGR SRVWQDWDO 3RGHPRV FLWDU FRPR FDXVDV PiV LPSRUWDQWHV ODV LQIHFFLRQHV VREUH WRGR OD PHQLQJLWLV\ODVHSVLVWHPSUDQDODVLQWR[LFDFLRQHV\ORVWUDXPDWLVPRVFUDQHRHQFHIiOLFRV 6HSXHGHFODVLILFDUVHJ~QODWRSRJUDItDGHODDIHFWDFLyQ 0RQRSOHMLDR0RQRSDUHVLDDIHFWDFLyQGHXQDVRODH[WUHPLGDG 'LSOHMLDR'LSDUHVLDDIHFWDFLyQ GH GRV H[WUHPLGDGHV JHQHUDOPHQWH ODVLQIHULRUHVRDIHFWDFLyQ GHWUHVRPiVH[WUHPLGDGHVSHURFRQJUDQSUHGRPLQDQFLDGHODVLQIHULRUHV 3DUDSOHMLDR3DUDSDUHVLDDIHFWDFLyQGHDPERVPLHPEURVLQIHULRUHV 7ULSDUHMLD R 7ULSOHVLD DIHFWDFLyQ GH ODV H[WUHPLGDGHV LQIHULRUHV \ GH XQD VXSHULRU R GH OD PXVFXODWXUDGHODFDUD\FXHOOR *HQHUDOPHQWHHOVXILMR³SOHMLD´VHUHILHUHDODDIHFWDFLyQWRWDO\³SDUHVLD´DODSDUFLDO (VWDQRPHQFODWXUDVHVXHOHXWLOL]DUFRPRVLQyQLPRDRWURVGLIHUHQWHVJUDGRVRQLYHOHVGHDIHFWDFLyQ6HFRQVWDWDTXHQRKD\ XQDFXHUGRHQWUHORVQHXUyORJRVSDUDGHOLPLWDUVXVLJQLILFDGR 7HWUDSOHMLDR7HWUDSDUHVLDDIHFWDFLyQGHORVPLHPEURVVXSHULRUHVHLQIHULRUHV\JHQHUDOPHQWHGH FDUD\FXHOOR +HPLSOHMLDR+HPLSDUHVLDDIHFWDFLyQGHODSLHUQD\GHOEUD]RGHOPLVPRODGR 6HSXHGHQFODVLILFDUWDPELpQVHJ~QHOWLSRGHDOWHUDFLyQGHOFRQWUROGHOPRYLPLHQWR (VSiVWLFRVXSRQHXQGHODVSDUiOLVLVFHUHEUDOHVLPSOLFDODFRQWUDFFLyQLQYROXQWDULDGH ORVP~VFXORVHVSDVPRV\DTXHHOWRQRPXVFXODUHVWiDXPHQWDGRGHELGRDODLPSRVLELOLGDGGH UHODMDU\FRQWUDHUUHFtSURFDPHQWHORVP~VFXORVDJRQLVWDV\DQWDJRQLVWDV&XDQGRVHSURGXFHOD H[WHQVLyQRODIOH[LyQGHXQDSDUWHGHOFXHUSRVHGDQPRYLPLHQWRVHQRWUDVSDUWHVFRUSRUDOHV\ VH PDQLILHVWDQ D WUDYpV GH XQ PRYLPLHQWR URWR \ FULVSDGR VLHQGR DGHPiV ORV P~VFXORV KLSHULUULWDEOHVKLSHUWyQLFRVHKLSHUFRQWUiFWLOHV/RVWUDVWRUQRVSRVWXUDOHVPiVKDELWXDOHVVRQ PLHPEURVLQIHULRUHVHQH[WHQVLyQ\DGGXFFLyQSLHVHQSXQWLOODV PLHPEURV VXSHULRUHV FRQ VHPLIOH[LyQ GH FRGR GRUVR GH OD PDQR GLULJLGD KDFLD OD FDUD GHGRV OHVLRQDGRV\SXOJDUSHJDGRDODSDOPDGHODPDQR ODPtPLFDGHODFDUD\HOKDEODUHVXOWDQWDPELpQDIHFWDGDV $WHWyVLFRVXSRQHXQGHODVSDUiOLVLVFHUHEUDOHVVHFDUDFWHUL]DSRUODVFRQWUDFFLRQHV LQYROXQWDULDV GH ODV H[WUHPLGDGHV GLVWDOHV (O WRQR PXVFXODU SUHVHQWD IOXFWXDFLRQHV HVSDVPyGLFDVHVGHFLUTXHHOWRQRYDUtDGHKLSRWRQtDDKLSHUWRQtDVHJ~QODDFWLYLGDGYROXQWDULD\ FRQ PRYLPLHQWRV LQYROXQWDULRV DQRUPDOHV H LQFRQWURODGRV 'H WDO IRUPD TXH FXDQGR VH LQWHQWD UHDOL]DUXQPRYLPLHQWRYROXQWDULRVXUJHQXQDVHULHGHFRQWUDFWXUDVPXVFXODUHVSDUDVLWDULDVTXH WLHQGHQDODH[WHQVLyQGHORVVHJPHQWRVDUWLFXODUHVEDMRPRYLPLHQWRVOHQWRVGHVFRRUGLQDGRVH LQYROXQWDULRV SHUWXUEDQGR HO HVIXHU]R FRQWUiFWLO \ KDFLHQGR TXH OD DFFLyQ UHVXOWH FRPSOHMD \ GLILFXOWRVD (VWD IDOWD GH FRRUGLQDFLyQ WDPELpQ DIHFWD D OD DUWLFXODFLyQ GHO OHQJXDMH TXH VH XQH D ODV GLILFXOWDGHVSDUDFRRUGLQDUODUHVSLUDFLyQ\ODHPLVLyQGHOVRQLGR $Wi[LFR HV XQD IRUPD GH SDUiOLVLV FHUHEUDO TXH HQ RFDVLRQHV YD XQLGD D XQ FRPSRQHQWH HVSiVWLFR R DWHWyVLFR (O WRQR PXVFXODU VXHOH HVWDU GLVPLQXLGR \ OD HVWDELOLGDG SRVWXUDO HV GHILFLHQWH (O QLxR R OD QLxD WLHQH GLILFXOWDGHV HQ PDQWHQHU XQD SRVLFLyQ GHWHUPLQDGD \ OD FRRUGLQDFLyQGHODVKDELOLGDGHVHVGHIHFWXRVD/DPDUFKDVXHOHVHULQVHJXUDUtJLGD\FRQFDtGDV IUHFXHQWHVSRUWDQWRSUHVHQWDWDPELpQDOWHUDFLRQHVGHOHTXLOLEULR (QRWUDVFODVLILFDFLRQHVWDPELpQVHLQFOX\HQ +LSHUWRQtDHVWDGRSHUPDQHQWHGHDXPHQWRGHOWRQRPXVFXODU +LSRWRQtDHOWRQRPXVFXODUHVWiGLVPLQXLGR 'LVWRQtDVHPDQLILHVWDFRQXQFRQMXQWRGHFRQWUDFFLRQHVHVSDVPyGLFDVTXHSURGXFHQSRVWXUDV FRQWUDKHFKDVHVSDVPRVGHWRUVLyQGHWURQFRFXHOORREUD]RV\DVHDQGHH[WHQVLyQRIOH[LyQ (QJHQHUDOSXHGHQREVHUYDUVHIRUPDVPL[WDVFRPELQiQGRVHKDELWXDOPHQWHHVSDVWLFLGDG\DWHWRVLV (QIHUPHGDGHVQHXURPXVFXODUHV 'HQWUR GH HVWD FDWHJRUtD VH SXHGHQHQJOREDUXQJUDQQ~PHURGHHQIHUPHGDGHVTXHWLHQHQ DOJXQDV FDUDFWHUtVWLFDVFRPXQHV&DVLWRGDVHOODVSURGXFHQXQDKLSRWRQtDHQODPXVFXODWXUDFRQSpUGLGDGH IXHU]D\GHIRUPDFLRQHVDQDWyPLFDVVLHQGRSULQFLSDOPHQWHGHFDUiFWHUJHQpWLFR$OJXQDVGHHOODVVRQ SURJUHVLYDV HQ OD HYROXFLyQ H LQFOXVR SXHGHQ OOHYDU D OD PXHUWH GH OD SHUVRQD DIHFWDGD HQ pSRFDV PX\ WHPSUDQDV GH OD YLGD \ HQ JHQHUDO VRQ HQIHUPHGDGHV PX\ OLPLWDGRUDV FRPSRUWDQGR XQD DOWD GHSHQGHQFLD 'LVWURILDPXVFXODUGH'XFKHQQH (VLQFXUDEOH\VHWUDVPLWHSRUKHUHQFLDUHFHVLYDOLJDGDDOVH[RODVPDGUHVVRQSRUWDGRUDVGHOJHQTXH GHVHQFDGHQDODHQIHUPHGDG\ODSDGHFHQORVKLMRVYDURQHVHQXQ+D\XQDLQFLGHQFLDGHFDGD YDURQHVQDFLGRVYLYRV6HPDQLILHVWDSUHFR]PHQWHDORVDxRVFRQSUREOHPDVPRWRUHV \DODHGDGGHDxRVVHSLHUGHODFDSDFLGDGGHGHDPEXODFLyQVLHQGRVXHVSHUDQ]DGHYLGDHQWUH ORV\ORVDxRVSRUDIHFWDFLyQGHODPXVFXODWXUDFDUGLDFDRUHVSLUDWRULD $WURILDHVSLQDOLQIDQWLO /DOHVLyQSULPDULDVHORFDOL]DHQODVFpOXODVGHODVWDDQWHULRUGHODPpGXODHVSLQDO(VXQDHQIHUPHGDG DXWRVyPLFDUHFHVLYDORVSRUWDGRUHVVRQHOSDGUH\ODPDGUHTXLHQHVQRSDGHFHQODHQIHUPHGDG6H PDQLILHVWD HQ ORV SULPHURV PHVHV GH YLGD \ GD OXJDU D XQD JUDQ KLSRWRQtD /D PDQLIHVWDFLyQ GH OD HQIHUPHGDGVHSURGXFHDSDUWLUGHORVyPHVHVGHYLGD\DSDUHFHXQUHWURFHVRHQODHYROXFLyQ PRWUL] GHO QLxR SURGXFLpQGRVH SRVWHULRUPHQWH XQ HVWDQFDPLHQWR 0HQRV GHO GH ORV QLxRV VH PDQWLHQHQVHQWDGRVVLQDSR\R\HVH[WUDxRTXHOOHJXHQDJDWHDUGHWDOIRUPDTXHFDVLQXQFDOOHJDQD FDPLQDUFRPSRUWDQGRWDPELpQSUREOHPDVGHGHVYLDFLRQHVGHFROXPQD 3ROLRPLHOLWLV 'DGR HO p[LWR GH ODV FDPSDxDV GH YDFXQDFLyQ OD 3ROLRPHOLWLV HVWi SUiFWLFDPHQWH HUUDGLFDGD GH ORV SDtVHVLQGXVWULDOL]DGRV(VXQDHQIHUPHGDGLQIHFFLRVDFDXVDGDSULQFLSDOPHQWHSRUXQYLUXVTXHDIHFWD DOVLVWHPDQHUYLRVRFHQWUDODWUDYpVGHOVLVWHPDFLUFXODWRULRHQVXIRUPDPiVJUDYHOHVLRQDODVFpOXODV QHUYLRVDV PRWULFHV SULQFLSDOPHQWH GHO DVWD DQWHULRU GH OD PpGXOD HVSLQDO D QLYHO OXPEDU \ FHUYLFDO SURGXFLpQGRVHHQFRQVHFXHQFLDODSDUiOLVLVWRWDORSDUFLDOGHORVJUXSRVPXVFXODUHVTXHGHSHQGHQGH HVWDVFpOXODV(OJUDGRGHGHELOLGDGPXVFXODUGHSHQGHGHOSRUFHQWDMHGHFpOXODVGHVWUXLGDV 3DUiOLVLVGHOSOH[REUDTXLDO (V OD SDUiOLVLV WRWDO R SDUFLDO GH OD PXVFXODWXUD GHO PLHPEUR VXSHULRU SRU XQD DIHFWDFLyQ QHXUROyJLFD LPSRUWDQWH GHO SOH[R EUDTXLDO 3XHGH VHU GH RULJHQ REVWpWULFR R WUDXPiWLFR HVSHFLDOPHQWH D UDt] GH DFFLGHQWHVGHWUiQVLWR 'XUDQWHXQSDUWRGLItFLOFXDQGRVHDSOLFDXQDIXHU]DGHWUDFFLyQDODFDEH]DPLHQWUDVVHSURGXFHODVDOLGD GHOKRPEURODWUDFFLyQGHOSOH[RHQpVWDVFRQGLFLRQHVSXHGHOHVLRQDUODVUDtFHVVXSHULRUHVSURYRFDQGR XQD SDUiOLVLV GH OD H[WUHPLGDG VXSHULRU R GH ODV UDtFHV LQIHULRUHV GHVDUUROODQGR XQD SDUiOLVLV GH ORV P~VFXORVGHODPDQR7DPELpQSXHGHFRPSRUWDUODIDOWDGHVHQVLELOLGDGHQDOJXQD]RQDGHOEUD]R(OQLYHO GHJUDYHGDGGHSHQGHGHODH[WHQVLyQGHODOHVLyQGHVLKDKDELGRXQDURWXUDSDUFLDORWRWDOGHORVWHMLGRV QHUYLRVRVYDLQDGHPLHOLQDD[yQRILEUDQHUYLRVD\FRQVHFXHQWHPHQWHSXHGHDIHFWDUWRGRHOEUD]RRVyOR DXQDSDUWHGHOPLVPR /HVLRQHVPHGXODUHV /DV FDXVDV SXHGHQ VHU PX\ GLYHUVDV ELHQ SRU PDOIRUPDFLyQ FRQJpQLWD SRU HQIHUPHGDGHV R SRU WUDXPDWLVPRVHQODFROXPQDYHUWHEUDO(QWRGRVORVFDVRVSURGXFHQXQDSpUGLGDGHODPRYLOLGDG\GHOD VHQVLELOLGDGGHORVP~VFXORVHQHUYDGRVSRUGHEDMRGHOQLYHOGHODOHVLyQ 'HSHQGLHQGRGHOOXJDUGHODOHVLyQPHGXODUSUHVHQWDUiPDVRPHQRVJUXSRVPXVFXODUHVDIHFWDGRV6L ODOHVLyQVHSURGXFHDQLYHOGHOFXHOORTXHGDUiQDIHFWDGRVORVVHJPHQWRVPHGXODUHVFHUYLFDOHVGDQGR OXJDUDXQDDIHFWDFLyQGHODVH[WUHPLGDGHVVXSHULRUHVDGLVWLQWRQLYHO\XQDDIHFWDFLyQWRWDOGHOWURQFR\ H[WUHPLGDGHV LQIHULRUHV WHWUDSOHMLD 6L OD OHVLyQ VH SURGXFH HQ OD ]RQD DOWD GH OD HVSDOGD DIHFWDUi SDUFLDOPHQWHDOWURQFR\DEGRPHQ\OHVLRQDUiWRWDOPHQWHODVH[WUHPLGDGHVLQIHULRUHVSDUDSOHMLDDOWD\ SRU~OWLPRVLODOHVLyQVHSURGXFHHQOD]RQDEDMDGHODHVSDOGDDIHFWDUiSDUWHGHOD]RQDDEGRPLQDO\ OHVLRQDUiWRWDOPHQWHODVH[WUHPLGDGHVLQIHULRUHVSDUDSOHMLDEDMD ,QGHSHQGLHQWHPHQWH GH ODV SDUiOLVLV TXH SXHGDQ SUHVHQWDUVH GHEHQ REVHUYDUVH XQD VHULH GH FRPSOLFDFLRQHV2ULRO0DUWtQH] $OWHUDFLRQHVGHODWHPSHUDWXUDFRUSRUDOORVPHFDQLVPRVGHWHUPRUUHJXODFLyQFXWiQHDHVWiQ DOWHUDGRV SRU OR TXH ORV FDPELRV GH WHPSHUDWXUD VXPDGRV D OD LQVHQVLELOLGDG GH ODV ]RQDV DIHFWDGDVSXHGHQSURGXFLUSUREOHPDVGHKLSHURKLSRWHUPLD ÒOFHUDV SRU SUHVLyQ GH PX\ IiFLO DSDULFLyQ GHELGR D OD IDOWD GH VHQVLELOLGDG OD IDOWD GH PRYLPLHQWR \ IDOWD GH WRQR YDVRPRWRU (VWDV OODJDV VRQ GH PX\ GLItFLO FXUDFLyQ \ SXHGHQ SURGXFLULQIHFFLRQHVLPSRUWDQWHVKDVWDHQHOKXHVRRVWHRPLHOLWLVGHELGRDORVSUREOHPDVGH LQFRQWLQHQFLD ,QIHFFLRQHV GHO WUDFWR XULQDULR SXHGHQ DSDUHFHU LQIHFFLRQHV UHSHWLGDV GH RULQD GHELGR D OD LQFRQWLQHQFLDGHHVItQWHUHV\DORVVRQGDMHV 3UREOHPDV UHVSLUDWRULRV HVWRV SUREOHPDV VRQ GHELGRV D IUDFWXUDV GH FRVWLOODV HQ HO SURSLR DFFLGHQWH R D OD GHELOLGDG GH ORV P~VFXORV TXH LQWHUYLHQHQ HQ OD UHVSLUDFLyQ PXVFXODWXUD LQWHUFRVWDO\GLDIUDJPiWLFD 7UDVWRUQRV GLJHVWLYRV GHELGRV IUHFXHQWHPHQWH D OD SDUiOLVLV GH ORV PRYLPLHQWRV LQWHVWLQDOHV TXHSURYRFDHVWUHxLPLHQWRFUyQLFRHLQFOXVRODSUHVHQFLDGHIHFDORPDV 7URPERIOHELWLV +D\ XQD OHQWLILFDFLyQ GH OD FLUFXODFLyQ VDQJXtQHD VREUH WRGR HQ ODV ]RQDV SDUDOL]DGDVGDGRTXHQRH[LVWHHOHIHFWRGHERPEDGHODFRQWUDFFLyQPXVFXODUSHULIpULFD )UDFWXUDVyVHDVGHELGDVDOSURSLRDFFLGHQWHRSRVWHULRUHV(VWHDVSHFWRHVPX\LPSRUWDQWH\D TXHDOQRH[LVWLUVHQVLELOLGDGSXHGHQSDVDUGHVDSHUFLELGDV &RQWUDFWXUDV PXVFXODUHV \ DQTXLORVLV DUWLFXODUHV 'HEHQ HYLWDUVH D WUDYpV GH ODV PRYLOL]DFLRQHV SDVLYDV GH ODV iUHDV SDUDOL]DGDV \ WUDWDPLHQWR SRVWXUDO 7DPELpQ SXHGHQ DSDUHFHURVLILFDFLRQHVSDUDUWLFXODUHVOODPDGDVRVWHRPDV (VSDVWLFLGDG (VSHFLDOPHQWH HQ OHVLRQHV GH WLSR LQFRPSOHWR 6H PDQLILHVWDQ GH IRUPD HVSRQWiQHDHLQFRQWURODGDSURGXFLGRVGHIRUPDUHIOHMDODSpUGLGDGHOFRQWUROGHORVP~VFXORV DJRQLVWDV\DQWDJRQLVWDVDQWHHVWtPXORVGHHVWUpVJROSHVIUtRHQWUHRWURV $PSXWDFLRQHV (VODSpUGLGDWRWDORSDUFLDOGHXQDH[WUHPLGDG/DVFDXVDVSULQFLSDOHVVRQ2ULRO0DUWtQH] &RQJpQLWDV IDOWD GH IRUPDFLyQ HPEULRQDULD GH WRGD R XQD SDUWH GH OD H[WUHPLGDG 'LVWLQJXLPRV $PHOLDDXVHQFLDWRWDOGHXQDRPiVH[WUHPLGDGHV 0HURPHOLDDXVHQFLDSDUFLDOGHXQDRPiVH[WUHPLGDGHVTXHSXHGHFODVLILFDUVHHQ 0HURPHOLDWHUPLQDODIHFWDQGRDODV]RQDVGLVWDOHVGHOPLHPEUR 0HURPHOLDLQWHUFDODUR)RFRPHOLDDIHFWDDOD]RQDFHQWUDOGHODH[WUHPLGDGFRQVHUYDQGROD SUR[LPDO\ODGLVWDO 7UDXPiWLFDV 3URGXFLGDV SRU DFFLGHQWHV ODERUDOHV R GH WUiILFR TXHPDGXUDV HOHFWURFXFLyQ DWHQWDGRV 7XPRUDOHVSRUWXPRUHVSULPDULRVRPHWiVWDVLV 9DVFXODUHVHVSHFLDOPHQWHHQSHUVRQDVDGXOWDVDIHFWDGDVGHGLDEHWHVRDUWHULRVFOHURVLV 3RUUHJODJHQHUDOODVSHUVRQDVDPSXWDGDVXWLOL]DQSUyWHVLVTXHFRPSHQVDQODSpUGLGDGHODH[WUHPLGDG SULQFLSDOPHQWHODLQIHULRU 7UDXPDWLVPRFUiQHRHQFHIiOLFR 6X RULJHQ HV XQ LPSDFWR FUDQHDO FRQ SpUGLGD GH FRQVFLHQFLD FRPD TXH VXHOH HVWDU DVRFLDGR D IUDFWXUDVFUDQHDOHVSXGLHQGRGHMDUVHFXHODVPRWULFHVVHQVRULDOHVFRJQLWLYDVFRPSRUWDPHQWDOHVRGH OHQJXDMHHQIXQFLyQGHOD]RQDFHUHEUDODIHFWDGD\GHODGXUDFLyQGHOHVWDGRGHDQR[LDFHUHEUDO3RU WRGR HOOR ODV FRQVHFXHQFLDV SXHGHQ LPSOLFDU GLVWLQWDV GLVFDSDFLGDGHV \D VHDQ ItVLFDV LQWHOHFWXDOHV VHQVRULDOHVRLPSOLFDUXQDSOXULGHILFLHQFLD $UWULWLVFUyQLFDMXYHQLO (V XQD YDULDQWH GH OD DUWULWLV UHXPDWRLGHD TXH DSDUHFH DQWHV GH ORV DxRV FXUVDQGR EURWHV 6X HWLRORJtD HV SRU DKRUD GHVFRQRFLGD (V PX\ LQFDSDFLWDQWH VL ORV EURWHV VRQ IUHFXHQWHV OOHJDQGR D UHTXHULUUHSRVRDEVROXWRXKRVSLWDOL]DFLyQ $IHFFLyQLQIODPDWRULDGHOWHMLGRFRQHFWLYRFRQSUHGRPLQLRDUWLFXODUTXHHYROXFLRQDSURJUHVLYDPHQWHSRUFULVLVUHSHWLWLYDVKDFLD XQDH[WHQVLyQJHQHUDO\VLPpWULFD$IHFWDSULQFLSDOPHQWHDORVWHQGRQHV\DODVDUWLFXODFLRQHV)DJRDJDS DQH[R /LVWDGRFRPSOHWRGHFDWHJRUtDVGHO GLDULRGHFDPSRGHO&HQWUR /,67$'2'(&$7(*25Ì$6'(/',$5,2'(&$032'(/&(1752 3$57,&,3$17(0$5Ì$ &$7(*25Ë$6 62&$87,1'0$5,$7$ 62&$87,1'0$5,$7% 62&$87,1'0$5,$7 62&$87,1'0$5,$7 62&$87,1'0$5,$7$ 62&$87,1'0$5,$7% 62&$87,1'0$5,$7 62&$87,1'0$5,$7 62&&21)12500$5,$7$ 62&&21)12500$5,$7% 62&&21)12500$5,$7 62&&21)12500$5,$7 62&&21)12500$5,$7$ 62&&21)12500$5,$7% 62&&21)12500$5,$7 62&&21)12500$5,$7 62&,17*58320$5,$/$,*125$17$ 62&,17*58320$5,$/$,*125$17% 62&,17*58320$5,$/$,*125$17 62&,17*58320$5,$/$,*125$17 62&,17*58320$5,$/$5(&+$=$17$ 62&,17*58320$5,$/$5(&+$=$17% 62&,17*58320$5,$/$5(&+$=$17 62&,17*58320$5,$/$5(&+$=$17 62&,17*58320$5,$/$$&(37$1$7 62&,17*58320$5,$/$$&(37$1%7 62&,17*58320$5,$/$$&(37$17 62&,17*58320$5,$/$$&(37$17 62&,17*58320$5,$62162/,'$5,267$ 62&,17*58320$5,$62162/,'$5,267% 62&,17*58320$5,$62162/,'$5,267 62&,17*58320$5,$62162/,'$5,267 62&,170$5,$*5832*(1(5$&21)/,&727$ 62&,170$5,$*5832*(1(5$&21)/,&727% 62&,170$5,$*5832*(1(5$&21)/,&727 62&,170$5,$*5832*(1(5$&21)/,&727 62&,170$5,$*5832/26,*125$7$ 62&,170$5,$*5832/26,*125$7% 62&,170$5,$*5832/26,*125$7 62&,170$5,$*5832/26,*125$7 62&,170$5,$*5832/26$&(37$7$ 62&,170$5,$*5832/26$&(37$7% 62&,170$5,$*5832/26$&(37$7 62&,170$5,$*5832/26$&(37$7 $16$&7'2&(;,*(1&,$7$ $16$&7'2&(;,*(1&,$7% $16$&7'2&(;,*(1&,$7 $16$&7'2&(;,*(1&,$7 $16$&7'2&3(50,6,9,'$'7$ $16$&7'2&3(50,6,9,'$'7% $16$&7'2&3(50,6,9,'$'7 $16$&7'2&3(50,6,9,'$'7 $16$&7,78''(/2%6(59$'257$ $16$&7,78''(/2%6(59$'257% $16$&7,78''(/2%6(59$'257 $16$&7,78''(/2%6(59$'257 $16'(6&5,3&,210$5,$$&7,78'(67$ $16'(6&5,3&,210$5,$$&7,78'(67% $16'(6&5,3&,210$5,$$&7,78'(67 $16'(6&5,3&,210$5,$$&7,78'(67 $16'(6&5,3&,210$5,$&$5$&7(5,67,&$63(5621$/(67$ $16'(6&5,3&,210$5,$&$5$&7(5,67,&$63(5621$/(67% $16'(6&5,3&,210$5,$&$5$&7(5,67,&$63(5621$/(67 $16'(6&5,3&,210$5,$&$5$&7(5,67,&$63(5621$/(67 $16'(6&5,3&,210$5,$,17(5$&&,210$5,$2%6(59$'25$7$ $16'(6&5,3&,210$5,$,17(5$&&,210$5,$2%6(59$'25$7% $16'(6&5,3&,210$5,$,17(5$&&,210$5,$2%6(59$'25$7 $16'(6&5,3&,210$5,$,17(5$&&,210$5,$2%6(59$'25$7 $16(675$7(*,$67$ $16(675$7(*,$67% $16(675$7(*,$67 $16(675$7(*,$67 $16(675$7(*,$6$'$37$7$5($67$ $16(675$7(*,$6$'$37$7$5($67% $16(675$7(*,$6$'$37$7$5($67 $16(675$7(*,$6$'$37$7$5($67 $16(675$7(*,$6&203(16$/,0,7$&,21(67$ $16(675$7(*,$6&203(16$/,0,7$&,21(67% $16(675$7(*,$6&203(16$/,0,7$&,21(67 $16(675$7(*,$6&203(16$/,0,7$&,21(67 $16(675$7(*,$6'$$32<2$0$5,$7$ $16(675$7(*,$6'$$32<2$0$5,$7% $16(675$7(*,$6'$$32<2$0$5,$7 $16(675$7(*,$6'$$32<2$0$5,$7 $16(675$7(*,$6(;,*('8&+$$0$5,$7$ $16(675$7(*,$6(;,*('8&+$$0$5,$7% $16(675$7(*,$6(;,*('8&+$$0$5,$7 $16(675$7(*,$6(;,*('8&+$$0$5,$7 $16(675$7(*,$6(;3/,&$6(17,'2'($'$37$&,21(6$/*58327$ $16(675$7(*,$6(;3/,&$6(17,'2'($'$37$&,21(6$/*58327% $16(675$7(*,$6(;3/,&$6(17,'2'($'$37$&,21(6$/*58327 $16(675$7(*,$6(;3/,&$6(17,'2'($'$37$&,21(6$/*58327 $16(675$7(*,$6)$&,/,7$48((/$32<2/2'(1/26&203$f(5267$ $16(675$7(*,$6)$&,/,7$48((/$32<2/2'(1/26&203$f(5267% $16(675$7(*,$6)$&,/,7$48((/$32<2/2'(1/26&203$f(5267 $16(675$7(*,$6)$&,/,7$48((/$32<2/2'(1/26&203$f(5267 $16(675$7(*,$6)$&,/,7$48(0$5,$1(*2&,(/$6$'$37$&,21(67$ $16(675$7(*,$6)$&,/,7$48(0$5,$1(*2&,(/$6$'$37$&,21(67% $16(675$7(*,$6)$&,/,7$48(0$5,$1(*2&,(/$6$'$37$&,21(67 $16(675$7(*,$6)$&,/,7$48(0$5,$1(*2&,(/$6$'$37$&,21(67 $16(675$7(*,$6)$&,/,7$'25$'(,17(55(/$&,21(60$5,$*58327$ $16(675$7(*,$6)$&,/,7$'25$'(,17(55(/$&,21(60$5,$*58327% $16(675$7(*,$6)$&,/,7$'25$'(,17(55(/$&,21(60$5,$*58327 $16(675$7(*,$6)$&,/,7$'25$'(,17(55(/$&,21(60$5,$*58327 $16(675$7(*,$6,1752'8&(6,//$'(58('$67$ $16(675$7(*,$6,1752'8&(6,//$'(58('$67% $16(675$7(*,$6,1752'8&(6,//$'(58('$67 $16(675$7(*,$6,1752'8&(6,//$'(58('$67 $16(675$7(*,$602',),&$$'$37$&,21(67$ $16(675$7(*,$602',),&$$'$37$&,21(67% $16(675$7(*,$602',),&$$'$37$&,21(67 $16(675$7(*,$602',),&$$'$37$&,21(67 $16(675$7(*,$65()8(5=$/$720$'('(&,6,21(6'(0$5,$7$ $16(675$7(*,$65()8(5=$/$720$'('(&,6,21(6'(0$5,$7% $16(675$7(*,$65()8(5=$/$720$'('(&,6,21(6'(0$5,$7 $16(675$7(*,$65()8(5=$/$720$'('(&,6,21(6'(0$5,$7 $16(675$7(*,$67$5($648(125(48,(5(1$'$37$&,217$ $16(675$7(*,$67$5($648(125(48,(5(1$'$37$&,217% $16(675$7(*,$67$5($648(125(48,(5(1$'$37$&,217 $16(675$7(*,$67$5($648(125(48,(5(1$'$37$&,217 $16(675$7(*,$675$%$-$/$(03$7,$'(/*58327$ $16(675$7(*,$675$%$-$/$(03$7,$'(/*58327% $16(675$7(*,$675$%$-$/$(03$7,$'(/*58327 $16(675$7(*,$675$%$-$/$(03$7,$'(/*58327 $167$5($6$&7,9,'$'6,10275,&,'$'352<'(9,'(27$ $167$5($6$&7,9,'$'6,10275,&,'$'352<'(9,'(27% $167$5($6$&7,9,'$'6,10275,&,'$'352<'(9,'(27 $167$5($6$&7,9,'$'6,10275,&,'$'352<'(9,'(27 $167$5($6$&7,9,'$'6,10275,&,'$'62&,2*5$0$7$ $167$5($6$&7,9,'$'6,10275,&,'$'62&,2*5$0$7% $167$5($6$&7,9,'$'6,10275,&,'$'62&,2*5$0$7 $167$5($6$&7,9,'$'6,10275,&,'$'62&,2*5$0$7 $167$5($6$&7,9,'$'6,10275,&,'$'9$/25$&,21'($&7,78'(67$ $167$5($6$&7,9,'$'6,10275,&,'$'9$/25$&,21'($&7,78'(67% $167$5($6$&7,9,'$'6,10275,&,'$'9$/25$&,21'($&7,78'(67 $167$5($6$&7,9,'$'6,10275,&,'$'9$/25$&,21'($&7,78'(67 $167$5($6$&7,9,'$'(6'((;35(6,217$ $167$5($6$&7,9,'$'(6'((;35(6,217% $167$5($6$&7,9,'$'(6'((;35(6,217 $167$5($6$&7,9,'$'(6'((;35(6,217 $167$5($6$&7,9,'$'(6'(6(16,%,/,=$&,217$ $167$5($6$&7,9,'$'(6'(6(16,%,/,=$&,217% $167$5($6$&7,9,'$'(6'(6(16,%,/,=$&,217 $167$5($6$&7,9,'$'(6'(6(16,%,/,=$&,217 $167$5($6+0%,1',9,'8$/7$ $167$5($6+0%,1',9,'8$/7% $167$5($6+0%,1',9,'8$/7 $167$5($6+0%,1',9,'8/$7 $167$5($6+0%3$5(-$6275,267$ $167$5($6+0%3$5(-$6275,267% $167$5($6+0%3$5(-$6275,267 $167$5($6+0%3$5(-$6275,267 $167$5($6,1,&,$&,21'(3257,9$7$ $167$5($6,1,&,$&,21'(3257,9$7% $167$5($6,1,&,$&,21'(3257,9$7 $167$5($6,1,&,$&,21'(3257,9$7 $167$5($6-8(*2&203(7,7,927$ $167$5($6-8(*2&203(7,7,927% $167$5($6-8(*2&203(7,7,927 $167$5($6-8(*2&203(7,7,927 $167$5($6-8(*2&223(5$7,927$ $167$5($6-8(*2&223(5$7,927% $167$5($6-8(*2&223(5$7,927 $167$5($6-8(*2&223(5$7,927 $167$5($65(/$-$&,217$ $167$5($65(/$-$&,217% $167$5($65(/$-$&,217 $167$5($65(/$-$&,217 27526&/$6(612,03$57,'$6 27526*5$%$&,21'(9,'(2 27526/$$&7,78''(/263$'5(6+$&,$/$,19(67,*$&,21 27526/$&5((1&,$'(/*5832&/$6(+$&,$/$,1&/86,21 27526/$0$(675$&2022%6(59$'25$7$ 27526/$0$(675$&2022%6(59$'25$7% 27526/$0$(675$&2022%6(59$'25$7 27526/$0$(675$&2022%6(59$'25$7 275260$5,$12$6,67($/$6(6,21 27526275$6(675$7(*,$6'(/$'2&(17( 2752635(6(17$&,21'(/$2%6(59$'25$ 2752635(6(17$&,21'(/*5832 DQH[R /LVWDGRFRPSOHWRGHFDWHJRUtDVGHO GLDULRGHFDPSRGHO&HQWUR /,67$'2'(&$7(*25Ì$6'(/',$5,2'(&$032'(/&(1752 3$57,&,3$17(6/2/$<-25', &$7(*25Ë$6 62&$87,1'-25',7$ 62&$87,1'-25',7% 62&$87,1'-25',7 62&$87,1'-25',7 62&$87,1'-25',7$ 62&$87,1'-25',7% 62&$87,1'-25',7 62&$87,1'-25',7 62&$87,1'/2/$7$ 62&$87,1'/2/$7% 62&$87,1'/2/$7 62&$87,1'/2/$7 62&$87,1'/2/$7$ 62&$87,1'/2/$7% 62&$87,1'/2/$7 62&$87,1'/2/$7 62&&21)1250-25',7$ 62&&21)1250-25',7% 62&&21)1250-25',7 62&&21)1250-25',7 62&&21)1250-25',7$ 62&&21)1250-25',7% 62&&21)1250-25',7 62&&21)1250-25',7 62&&21)1250/2/$7$ 62&&21)1250/2/$7% 62&&21)1250/2/$7 62&&21)1250/2/$7 62&&21)1250/2/$7$ 62&&21)1250/2/$7% 62&&21)1250/2/$7 62&&21)1250/2/$7 62&,17*5832-25',/2,*125$17$ 62&,17*5832-25',/2,*125$17% 62&,17*5832-25',/2,*125$17 62&,17*5832-25',/2,*125$17 62&,17*5832-25',/25(&+$=$17$ 62&,17*5832-25',/25(&+$=$17% 62&,17*5832-25',/25(&+$=$17 62&,17*5832-25',/25(&+$=$17 62&,17*5832-25',/2$&(37$17$ 62&,17*5832-25',/2$&(37$17% 62&,17*5832-25',/2$&(37$17 62&,17*5832-25',/2$&(37$17 62&,17*5832-25',62162/,'$5,267$ 62&,17*5832-25',62162/,'$5,267% 62&,17*5832-25',62162/,'$5,267 62&,17*5832-25',62162/,'$5,267 62&,17*5832/2/$/$,*125$17$ 62&,17*5832/2/$/$,*125$17% 62&,17*5832/2/$/$,*125$17 62&,17*5832/2/$/$,*125$17 62&,17*5832/2/$/$5(&+$=$17$ 62&,17*5832/2/$/$5(&+$=$17% 62&,17*5832/2/$/$5(&+$=$17 62&,17*5832/2/$/$5(&+$=$17 62&,17*5832/2/$/$$&(37$17$ 62&,17*5832/2/$/$$&(37$1%7 62&,17*5832/2/$/$$&(37$17 62&,17*5832/2/$/$$&(37$17 62&,17*5832/2/$62162/,'$5,267$ 62&,17*5832/2/$62162/,'$5,267% 62&,17*5832/2/$62162/,'$5,267 62&,17*5832/2/$62162/,'$5,267 62&,17-25',*5832*(1(5$&21)/,&727$ 62&,17-25',*5832*(1(5$&21)/,&727% 62&,17-25',*5832*(1(5$&21)/,&727 62&,17-25',*5832*(1(5$&21)/,&727 62&,17-25',*5832/26,*125$7$ 62&,17-25',*5832/26,*125$7% 62&,17-25',*5832/26,*125$7 62&,17-25',*5832/26,*125$7 62&,17-25',*5832/26$&(37$7$ 62&,17-25',*5832/26$&(37$7% 62&,17-25',*5832/26$&(37$7 62&,17-25',*5832/26$&(37$7 62&,17/2/$*5832*(1(5$&21)/,&727$ 62&,17/2/$*5832*(1(5$&21)/,&727% 62&,17/2/$*5832*(1(5$&21)/,&727 62&,17/2/$*5832*(1(5$&21)/,&727 62&,17/2/$*5832/26,*125$7$ 62&,17/2/$*5832/26,*125$7% 62&,17/2/$*5832/26,*125$7 62&,17/2/$*5832/26,*125$7 62&,17/2/$*5832/26$&(37$7$ 62&,17/2/$*5832/26$&(37$7% 62&,17/2/$*5832/26$&(37$7 62&,17/2/$*5832/26$&(37$7 $16$&7'2&7$ $16$&7'2&7% $16$&7'2&7 $16$&7'2&7 $16$&7,78''(/2%6(59$'257$ $16$&7,78''(/2%6(59$'257% $16$&7,78''(/2%6(59$'257 $16$&7,78''(/2%6(59$'257 $16$&7,78''(/2%6(59$'25,17(5$&&,212%6(59$'25$$8;,/,$5(( 0$(675$7$ $16$&7,78''(/2%6(59$'25,17(5$&&,212%6(59$'25$$8;,/,$5(( 0$(675$7% $16$&7,78''(/2%6(59$'25,17(5$&&,212%6(59$'25$$8;,/,$5(( 0$(675$7 $16$&7,78''(/2%6(59$'25,17(5$&&,212%6(59$'25$$8;,/,$5(( 0$(675$7 $16$&7,78''(/2%6(59$'25,17(5$&&,212%6(59$'25$$8;,/,$5((7$ $16$&7,78''(/2%6(59$'25,17(5$&&,212%6(59$'25$$8;,/,$5((7% $16$&7,78''(/2%6(59$'25,17(5$&&,212%6(59$'25$$8;,/,$5((7 $16$&7,78''(/2%6(59$'25,17(5$&&,212%6(59$'25$$8;,/,$5((7 $16$&7,78''(/2%6(59$'25,17(5$&&,212%6(59$'25$0$(675$7$ $16$&7,78''(/2%6(59$'25,17(5$&&,212%6(59$'25$0$(675$7% $16$&7,78''(/2%6(59$'25,17(5$&&,212%6(59$'25$0$(675$7 $16$&7,78''(/2%6(59$'25,17(5$&&,212%6(59$'25$0$(675$7 $16$8;,/,$5(('$&216,*1$6<5(68(/9(&21)/,&726&21-25',7$ $16$8;,/,$5(('$&216,*1$6<5(68(/9(&21)/,&726&21-25',7% $16$8;,/,$5(('$&216,*1$6<5(68(/9(&21)/,&726&21-25',7 $16$8;,/,$5(('$&216,*1$6<5(68(/9(&21)/,&726&21-25',7 $16$8;,/,$5((',6(f$$&7,9,'$'(6$/7(51$7,9$67$ $16$8;,/,$5((',6(f$$&7,9,'$'(6$/7(51$7,9$67% $16$8;,/,$5((',6(f$$&7,9,'$'(6$/7(51$7,9$67 $16$8;,/,$5((',6(f$$&7,9,'$'(6$/7(51$7,9$67 $16$8;,/,$5((,16,67($-25',358'(1&,$7$ $16$8;,/,$5((,16,67($-25',358'(1&,$7% $16$8;,/,$5((,16,67($-25',358'(1&,$7 $16$8;,/,$5((,16,67($-25',358'(1&,$7 $16$8;,/,$5((,17(59,(1(&8$1'2-25',+$&(75$03$67$ $16$8;,/,$5((,17(59,(1(&8$1'2-25',+$&(75$03$67% $16$8;,/,$5((,17(59,(1(&8$1'2-25',+$&(75$03$67 $16$8;,/,$5((,17(59,(1(&8$1'2-25',+$&(75$03$67 $16$8;,/,$5((275267$ $16$8;,/,$5((275267% $16$8;,/,$5((275267 $16$8;,/,$5((275267 $16$8;,/,$5((321(/,0,7(6$-25',</2/$7$ $16$8;,/,$5((321(/,0,7(6$-25',</2/$7% $16$8;,/,$5((321(/,0,7(6$-25',</2/$7 $16$8;,/,$5((321(/,0,7(6$-25',</2/$7 $16$8;,/,$5((5(&8(5'$$-25',$'$37$&,21(6,17(5,25,=$&,217$ $16$8;,/,$5((5(&8(5'$$-25',$'$37$&,21(6,17(5,25,=$&,217% $16$8;,/,$5((5(&8(5'$$-25',$'$37$&,21(6,17(5,25,=$&,217 $16$8;,/,$5((5(&8(5'$$-25',$'$37$&,21(6,7(5,25,=$&,217 $16'(6&5,3&,21-25',$&7,78'(67$ $16'(6&5,3&,21-25',$&7,78'(67% $16'(6&5,3&,21-25',$&7,78'(67 $16'(6&5,3&,21-25',$&7,78'(67 $16'(6&5,3&,21-25',&$5$&7(5,67,&$63(5621$/(67$ $16'(6&5,3&,21-25',&$5$&7(5,67,&$63(5621$/(67% $16'(6&5,3&,21-25',&$5$&7(5,67,&$63(5621$/(67 $16'(6&5,3&,21-25',&$5$&7(5,67,&$63(5621$/(67 $16'(6&5,3&,21-25',,17(5$&&,21-25',$8;,/,$5((7$ $16'(6&5,3&,21-25',,17(5$&&,21-25',$8;,/,$5((7% $16'(6&5,3&,21-25',,17(5$&&,21-25',$8;,/,$5((7 $16'(6&5,3&,21-25',,17(5$&&,21-25',$8;,/,$5((7 $16'(6&5,3&,21-25',,17(5$&&,21-25',2%6(59$'25$7$ $16'(6&5,3&,21-25',,17(5$&&,21-25',2%6(59$'25$7% $16'(6&5,3&,21-25',,17(5$&&,21-25',2%6(59$'25$7 $16'(6&5,3&,21-25',,17(5$&&,21-25',2%6(59$'25$7 $16'(6&5,3&,21/2/$$&7,78'(67$ $16'(6&5,3&,21/2/$$&7,78'(67% $16'(6&5,3&,21/2/$$&7,78'(67 $16'(6&5,3&,21/2/$$&7,78'(67 $16'(6&5,3&,21/2/$&$5$&7(5,67,&$63(5621$/(67$ $16'(6&5,3&,21/2/$&$5$&7(5,67,&$63(5621$/(67% $16'(6&5,3&,21/2/$&$5$&7(5,67,&$63(5621$/(67 $16'(6&5,3&,21/2/$&$5$&7(5,67,&$63(5621$/(67 $16'(6&5,3&,21/2/$,17(5$&&,21/2/$$8;,/,$5((7$ $16'(6&5,3&,21/2/$,17(5$&&,21/2/$$8;,/,$5((7% $16'(6&5,3&,21/2/$,17(5$&&,21/2/$$8;,/,$5((7 $16'(6&5,3&,21/2/$,17(5$&&,21/2/$$8;,/,$5((7 $16'(6&5,3&,21/2/$,17(5$&&,21/2/$2%6(59$'25$7$ $16'(6&5,3&,21/2/$,17(5$&&,21/2/$2%6(59$'25$7% $16'(6&5,3&,21/2/$,17(5$&&,21/2/$2%6(59$'25$7 $16'(6&5,3&,21/2/$,17(5$&&,21/2/$2%6(59$'25$7 $16(675$7(*,$67$ $16(675$7(*,$67% $16(675$7(*,$67 $16(675$7(*,$67 $16(675$7(*,$6$'$37$7$5($67$ $16(675$7(*,$6$'$37$7$5($67% $16(675$7(*,$6$'$37$7$5($67 $16(675$7(*,$6$'$37$7$5($67 $16(675$7(*,$6&203(16$/,0,7$&,21(67$ $16(675$7(*,$6&203(16$/,0,7$&,21(67% $16(675$7(*,$6&203(16$/,0,7$&,21(67 $16(675$7(*,$6&203(16$/,0,7$&,21(67 $16(675$7(*,$6(;3/,&$6(17,'2'($'$37$&,21(6$/*58327$ $16(675$7(*,$6(;3/,&$6(17,'2'($'$37$&,21(6$/*58327% $16(675$7(*,$6(;3/,&$6(17,'2'($'$37$&,21(6$/*58327 $16(675$7(*,$6(;3/,&$6(17,'2'($'$37$&,21(6$/*58327 $16(675$7(*,$602',),&$$'$37$&,21(67$ $16(675$7(*,$602',),&$$'$37$&,21(67% $16(675$7(*,$602',),&$$'$37$&,21(67 $16(675$7(*,$602',),&$$'$37$&,21(67 $16(675$7(*,$67$5($648(125(48,(5(1$'$37$&,217$ $16(675$7(*,$67$5($648(125(48,(5(1$'$37$&,217% $16(675$7(*,$67$5($648(125(48,(5(1$'$37$&,217 $16(675$7(*,$67$5($648(125(48,(5(1$'$37$&,217 $16,17(5$&&,21-25',/2/$7$ $16,17(5$&&,21-25',/2/$7% $16,17(5$&&,21-25',/2/$7 $16,17(5$&&,21-25',/2/$7 $167$5($6$&7,9,'$'6,10275,&,'$'&/$6(67(25,&$67$ $167$5($6$&7,9,'$'6,10275,&,'$'&/$6(67(25,&$67% $167$5($6$&7,9,'$'6,10275,&,'$'&/$6(67(25,&$67 $167$5($6$&7,9,'$'6,10275,&,'$'&/$6(67(25,&$67 $167$5($6$&7,9,'$'6,10275,&,'$'352<'(9,'(27$ $167$5($6$&7,9,'$'6,10275,&,'$'352<'(9,'(27% $167$5($6$&7,9,'$'6,10275,&,'$'352<'(9,'(27 $167$5($6$&7,9,'$'6,10275,&,'$'352<'(9,'(27 $167$5($6$&7,9,'$'6,10275,&,'$'62&,2*5$0$7$ $167$5($6$&7,9,'$'6,10275,&,'$'62&,2*5$0$7% $167$5($6$&7,9,'$'6,10275,&,'$'62&,2*5$0$7 $167$5($6$&7,9,'$'6,10275,&,'$'62&,2*5$0$7 $167$5($6$&7,9,'$'(6'(6(16,%,/,=$&,217$ $167$5($6$&7,9,'$'(6'(6(16,%,/,=$&,217% $167$5($6$&7,9,'$'(6'(6(16,%,/,=$&,217 $167$5($6$&7,9,'$'(6'(6(16,%,/,=$&,217 $167$5($6+0%,1',9,'8$/7$ $167$5($6+0%,1',9,'8$/7% $167$5($6+0%,1',9,'8$/7 $167$5($6+0%,1',9,'8$/7 $167$5($6+0%3$5(-$6275,267$ $167$5($6+0%3$5(-$6275,267% $167$5($6+0%3$5(-$6275,267 $167$5($6+0%3$5(-$6275,267 $167$5($6,1,&,$&,21'(3257,9$7$ $167$5($6,1,&,$&,21'(3257,9$7% $167$5($6,1,&,$&,21'(3257,9$7 $167$5($6,1,&,$&,21'(3257,9$7 $167$5($6-8(*2&203(7,7,927$ $167$5($6-8(*2&203(7,7,927% $167$5($6-8(*2&203(7,7,927 $167$5($6-8(*2&203(7,7,927 $167$5($6-8(*2&223(5$7,927$ $167$5($6-8(*2&223(5$7,927% $167$5($6-8(*2&223(5$7,927 $167$5($6-8(*2&223(5$7,927 $167$5($6-8(*2/,%5(7$ $167$5($6-8(*2/,%5(7% $167$5($6-8(*2/,%5(7 $167$5($6-8(*2/,%5(7 27526&/$6(612,03$57,'$6 27526*5$%$&,21'(9,'(2 27526-25',$6,67($/$6(6,213(52123$57,&,3$ 27526-25',12$6,67($/$6(6,21 27526/$$8;,/,$5((&2022%6(59$'25$7$ 27526/$$8;,/,$5((&2022%6(59$'25$7% 27526/$$8;,/,$5((&2022%6(59$'25$7 27526/$$8;,/,$5((&2022%6(59$'25$7 27526/$&$,'$'(-25', 27526/$&5((1&,$'(/*5832&/$6(+$&,$/$,1&/86,21 27526/$0$(675$6867,787$ 27526/$2%6(59$'25$1238('(5(*,675$5/$6(6,21<1$',(/$5(*,675$ 27526/2/$12$6,67($/$6(6,21 2752612$6,67(/$0$(675$ 275262%6(59$&,21(6'(,17(5(63$5$(/,1)250( 27526275$6(675$7(*,$6'(/$'2&(17( 2752635(6(17$&,21'(/$2%6(59$'25$ 2752635(6(17$&,21'(/*5832 275265(75$626'(-25', DQH[R /LVWDGRFRPSOHWRGHFDWHJRUtDVGHODV HQWUHYLVWDVGHO&HQWUR /,67$'2'(&$7(*25Ë$6'(/$6(175(9,67$6&(1752 &$7(*25Ë$6 '(6&5,3&,21'(0$5,$',5(&725$<-()$'((678',26),1$/ '(6&5,3&,21'(0$5,$',5(&725$<-()$'((678',26,1,&,$/ '(6&5,3&,21'(0$5,$',5(&725$),1$/ '(6&5,3&,21'(0$5,$',5(&725$,1,&,$/ '(6&5,3&,21'(0$5,$($3 '(6&5,3&,21'(0$5,$-()$'((678',26),1$/ '(6&5,3&,21'(0$5,$-()$'((678',26,1,&,$/ '(6&5,3&,21'(0$5,$0$(675$'(('8&$&,21),6,&$),1$/ '(6&5,3&,21'(0$5,$0$(675$'(('8&$&,21),6,&$,1,&,$/ '(6&5,3&,21'(0$5,$0$5,$),1$/ '(6&5,3&,21'(0$5,$0$5,$,1,&,$/ '(6&5,3&,21'(0$5,$3$'5(6),1$/ '(6&5,3&,21'(0$5,$3$'5(6,1,&,$/ '(6&5,3&,21'(0$5,$36,&2/2*2 '(6&5,3&,21'(0$5,$78725$),1$/ '(6&5,3&,21'(0$5,$78725$,1,&,$/ (675$7(*,$6,1&/86,9$6'(/$0$(675$',5(&725$<-()$'((678',26),1$/ (675$7(*,$6,1&/86,9$6'(/$0$(675$',5(&725$<-()$'((678',26,1,&,$/ (675$7(*,$6,1&/86,9$6'(/$0$(675$',5(&725$),1$/ (675$7(*,$6,1&/86,9$6'(/$0$(675$',5(&725$,1,&,$/ (675$7(*,$6,1&/86,9$6'(/$0$(675$($3 (675$7(*,$6,1&/86,9$6'(/$0$(675$-()$'((678',26),1$/ (675$7(*,$6,1&/86,9$6'(/$0$(675$-()$'((678',26,1,&,$/ (675$7(*,$6,1&/86,9$6'(/$0$(675$0$(675$'(('8&$&,21),6,&$),1$/ (675$7(*,$6,1&/86,9$6'(/$0$(675$0$(675$'(('8&$&,21),6,&$,1,&,$/ (675$7(*,$6,1&/86,9$6'(/$0$(675$0$5,$),1$/ (675$7(*,$6,1&/86,9$6'(/$0$(675$0$5,$,1,&,$/ (675$7(*,$6,1&/86,9$6'(/$0$(675$3$'5(6),1$/ (675$7(*,$6,1&/86,9$6'(/$0$(675$3$'5(6,1,&,$/ (675$7(*,$6,1&/86,9$6'(/$0$(675$36,&2/2*2 (675$7(*,$6,1&/86,9$6'(/$0$(675$78725$),1$/ (675$7(*,$6,1&/86,9$6'(/$0$(675$78725$,1,&,$/ 25*$1,=$&,21(6&2/$5',5(&725$<-()$'((678',26),1$/ 25*$1,=$&,21(6&2/$5',5(&725$<-()$'((678',26,1,&,$/ 25*$1,=$&,21(6&2/$5',5(&725$),1$/ 25*$1,=$&,21(6&2/$5',5(&725$,1,&,$/ 25*$1,=$&,21(6&2/$5($3 25*$1,=$&,21(6&2/$5-()$'((678',26),1$/ 25*$1,=$&,21(6&2/$5-()$'((678',26,1,&,$/ 25*$1,=$&,21(6&2/$50$(675$'(('8&$&,21),6,&$),1$/ 25*$1,=$&,21(6&2/$50$(675$'(('8&$&,21),6,&$,1,&,$/ 25*$1,=$&,21(6&2/$50$5,$),1$/ 25*$1,=$&,21(6&2/$50$5,$,1,&,$/ 25*$1,=$&,21(6&2/$53$'5(6),1$/ 25*$1,=$&,21(6&2/$53$'5(6,1,&,$/ 25*$1,=$&,21(6&2/$536,&2/2*2 25*$1,=$&,21(6&2/$578725$),1$/ 25*$1,=$&,21(6&2/$578725$,1,&,$/ 27526$63(&7265(/(9$17(6',5(&725$<-()$'((678',26),1$/ 27526$63(&7265(/(9$17(6',5(&725$<-()$'((678',26,1,&,$/ 27526$63(&7265(/(9$17(6',5(&725$),1$/ 27526$63(&7265(/(9$17(6',5(&725$,1,&,$/ 27526$63(&7265(/(9$17(6($3 27526$63(&7265(/(9$17(6-()$'((678',26),1$/ 27526$63(&7265(/(9$17(6-()$'((678',26,1,&,$/ 27526$63(&7265(/(9$17(60$(675$'(('8&$&,21),6,&$),1$/ 27526$63(&7265(/(9$17(60$(675$'(('8&$&,21),6,&$,1,&,$/ 27526$63(&7265(/(9$17(60$5,$),1$/ 27526$63(&7265(/(9$17(60$5,$,1,&,$/ 27526$63(&7265(/(9$17(63$'5(6),1$/ 27526$63(&7265(/(9$17(63$'5(6,1,&,$/ 27526$63(&7265(/(9$17(636,&2/2*2 27526$63(&7265(/(9$17(678725$),1$/ 27526$63(&7265(/(9$17(678725$,1,&,$/ 62&,$/,=$&,21'(0$5,$',5(&725$<-()$'((678',26),1$/ 62&,$/,=$&,21'(0$5,$',5(&725$<-()$'((678',26,1,&,$/ 62&,$/,=$&,21'(0$5,$',5(&725$),1$/ 62&,$/,=$&,21'(0$5,$',5(&725$,1,&,$/ 62&,$/,=$&,21'(0$5,$($3 62&,$/,=$&,21'(0$5,$-()$'((678',26),1$/ 62&,$/,=$&,21'(0$5,$-()$'((678',26,1,&,$/ 62&,$/,=$&,21'(0$5,$0$(675$'(('8&$&,21),6,&$),1$/ 62&,$/,=$&,21'(0$5,$0$(675$'(('8&$&,21),6,&$,1,&,$/ 62&,$/,=$&,21'(0$5,$0$5,$),1$/ 62&,$/,=$&,21'(0$5,$0$5,$,1,&,$/ 62&,$/,=$&,21'(0$5,$3$'5(6),1$/ 62&,$/,=$&,21'(0$5,$3$'5(6,1,&,$/ 62&,$/,=$&,21'(0$5,$36,&2/2*2 62&,$/,=$&,21'(0$5,$78725$),1$/ 62&,$/,=$&,21'(0$5,$78725$,1,&,$/ DQH[R /LVWDGRFRPSOHWRGHFDWHJRUtDVGHODV HQWUHYLVWDVGHO&HQWUR /,67$'2'(&$7(*25Ë$6'(/$6(175(9,67$6&(1752 &$7(*25Ë$6 '(6&5,3&,21'(-25',$8;,/,$5((),1$/ '(6&5,3&,21'(-25',$8;,/,$5((,1,&,$/ '(6&5,3&,21'(-25',',5(&725$),1$/ '(6&5,3&,21'(-25',',5(&725$,1,&,$/ '(6&5,3&,21'(-25',($3 '(6&5,3&,21'(-25',-25',),1$/ '(6&5,3&,21'(-25',-25',,1,&,$/ '(6&5,3&,21'(-25',0$(675$'((($ '(6&5,3&,21'(-25',0$(675$'(((, '(6&5,3&,21'(-25',0$(675$'(('8&$&,21),6,&$+),1$/ '(6&5,3&,21'(-25',0$(675$'(('8&$&,21),6,&$+,1,&,$/ '(6&5,3&,21'(-25',0$(675$'(('8&$&,21),6,&$7 '(6&5,3&,21'(-25',021,725$'(&20('25 '(6&5,3&,21'(-25',3$'5(6 '(6&5,3&,21'(-25',78725$),1$/ '(6&5,3&,21'(-25',78725$),1$/ '(6&5,3&,21'(-25',78725$,1,&,$/ '(6&5,3&,21'(/2/$$8;,/,$5((),1$/ '(6&5,3&,21'(/2/$$8;,/,$5((,1,&,$/ '(6&5,3&,21'(/2/$',5(&725$),1$/ '(6&5,3&,21'(/2/$',5(&725$,1,&,$/ '(6&5,3&,21'(/2/$($3 '(6&5,3&,21'(/2/$/2/$),1$/ '(6&5,3&,21'(/2/$/2/$,1,&,$/ '(6&5,3&,21'(/2/$0$(675$'((($ '(6&5,3&,21'(/2/$0$(675$'(((, '(6&5,3&,21'(/2/$0$(675$'(('8&$&,21),6,&$+),1$/ '(6&5,3&,21'(/2/$0$(675$'(('8&$&,21),6,&$+,1,&,$/ '(6&5,3&,21'(/2/$0$(675$'(('8&$&,21),6,&$7 '(6&5,3&,21'(/2/$021,725$'(&20('25 '(6&5,3&,21'(/2/$3$'5(6 '(6&5,3&,21'(/2/$78725$),1$/ '(6&5,3&,21'(/2/$78725$),1$/ '(6&5,3&,21'(/2/$78725$,1,&,$/ (675$7(*,$6,1&/86,9$6'(/$0$(675$$8;,/,$5((),1$/ (675$7(*,$6,1&/86,9$6'(/$0$(675$$8;,/,$5((,1,&,$/ (675$7(*,$6,1&/86,9$6'(/$0$(675$',5(&725$),1$/ (675$7(*,$6,1&/86,9$6'(/$0$(675$',5(&725$,1,&,$/ (675$7(*,$6,1&/86,9$6'(/$0$(675$($3 (675$7(*,$6,1&/86,9$6'(/$0$(675$-25',),1$/ (675$7(*,$6,1&/86,9$6'(/$0$(675$-25',,1,&,$/ (675$7(*,$6,1&/86,9$6'(/$0$(675$/2/$),1$/ (675$7(*,$6,1&/86,9$6'(/$0$(675$/2/$,1,&,$/ (675$7(*,$6,1&/86,9$6'(/$0$(675$0$(675$'(('8&$&,21 ),6,&$+),1$/ (675$7(*,$6,1&/86,9$6'(/$0$(675$0$(675$'(('8&$&,21 ),6,&$+,1,&,$/ (675$7(*,$6,1&/86,9$6'(/$0$(675$0$(675$'(('8&$&,21 ),6,&$7 (675$7(*,$6,1&/86,9$6'(/$0$(675$0$(675$(($ (675$7(*,$6,1&/86,9$6'(/$0$(675$0$(675$((, (675$7(*,$6,1&/86,9$6'(/$0$(675$021,725$'(&20('25 (675$7(*,$6,1&/86,9$6'(/$0$(675$3$'5(6'(-25', (675$7(*,$6,1&/86,9$6'(/$0$(675$3$'5(6'(/2/$ (675$7(*,$6,1&/86,9$6'(/$0$(675$78725$),1$/ (675$7(*,$6,1&/86,9$6'(/$0$(675$78725$),1$/ (675$7(*,$6,1&/86,9$6'(/$0$(675$78725$,1,&,$/ ,17(5$&&,21-25',/2/$$8;,/,$5((),1$/ ,17(5$&&,21-25',/2/$$8;,/,$5((,1,&,$/ ,17(5$&&,21-25',/2/$',5(&725$),1$/ ,17(5$&&,21-25',/2/$',5(&725$,1,&,$/ ,17(5$&&,21-25',/2/$($3 ,17(5$&&,21-25',/2/$-25',),1$/ ,17(5$&&,21-25',/2/$-25',,1,&,$/ ,17(5$&&,21-25',/2/$/2/$),1$/ ,17(5$&&,21-25',/2/$/2/$,1,&,$/ ,17(5$&&,21-25',/2/$0$(675$'((($ ,17(5$&&,21-25',/2/$0$(675$'(((, ,17(5$&&,21-25',/2/$0$(675$'(('8&$&,21),6,&$+),1$/ ,17(5$&&,21-25',/2/$0$(675$'(('8&$&,21),6,&$+,1,&,$/ ,17(5$&&,21-25',/2/$0$(675$'(('8&$&,21),6,&$7 ,17(5$&&,21-25',/2/$021,725$'(&20('25 ,17(5$&&,21-25',/2/$3$'5(6 ,17(5$&&,21-25',/2/$78725$),1$/ ,17(5$&&,21-25',/2/$78725$),1$/ ,17(5$&&,21-25',/2/$78725$,1,&,$/ 25*$1,=$&,21(6&2/$5$8;,/,$5'(((),1$/ 25*$1,=$&,21(6&2/$5$8;,/,$5'(((,1,&,$/ 25*$1,=$&,21(6&2/$5',5(&725$),1$/ 25*$1,=$&,21(6&2/$5',5(&725$,1,&,$/ 25*$1,=$&,21(6&2/$5($3 25*$1,=$&,21(6&2/$5-25',),1$/ 25*$1,=$&,21(6&2/$5-25',,1,&,$/ 25*$1,=$&,21(6&2/$5/2/$),1$/ 25*$1,=$&,21(6&2/$5/2/$,1,&,$/ 25*$1,=$&,21(6&2/$50$(675$'((($ 25*$1,=$&,21(6&2/$50$(675$'(((, 25*$1,=$&,21(6&2/$50$(675$'(('8&$&,21),6,&$+),1$/ 25*$1,=$&,21(6&2/$50$(675$'(('8&$&,21),6,&$+,1,&,$/ 25*$1,=$&,21(6&2/$50$(675$'(('8&$&,21),6,&$7,1,&,$/ 25*$1,=$&,21(6&2/$5021,725$'(&20('25 25*$1,=$&,21(6&2/$53$'5(6'(-25', 25*$1,=$&,21(6&2/$53$'5(6'(/2/$ 25*$1,=$&,21(6&2/$578725$),1$/ 25*$1,=$&,21(6&2/$578725$),1$/ 25*$1,=$&,21(6&2/$578725$,1,&,$/ 27526$63(&7265(/(9$17(6$8;,/,$5((),1$/ 27526$63(&7265(/(9$17(6$8;,/,$5((,1,&,$/ 27526$63(&7265(/(9$17(6',5(&725$),1$/ 27526$63(&7265(/(9$17(6',5(&725$,1,&,$/ 27526$63(&7265(/(9$17(6($3 27526$63(&7265(/(9$17(6-25',),1$/ 27526$63(&7265(/(9$17(6-25',,1,&,$/ 27526$63(&7265(/(9$17(6/2/$),1$/ 27526$63(&7265(/(9$17(6/2/$,1,&,$/ 27526$63(&7265(/(9$17(60$(675$'((($ 27526$63(&7265(/(9$17(60$(675$'(((, 27526$63(&7265(/(9$17(60$(675$'(('8&$&,21),6,&$+),1$/ 27526$63(&7265(/(9$17(60$(675$'(('8&$&,21 ),6,&$+,1,&,$/ 27526$63(&7265(/(9$17(60$(675$'(('8&$&,21),6,&$7 27526$63(&7265(/(9$17(6021,725$'(&20('25 27526$63(&7265(/(9$17(63$'5(6'(-25', 27526$63(&7265(/(9$17(63$'5(6'(/2/$ 27526$63(&7265(/(9$17(678725$),1$/ 27526$63(&7265(/(9$17(678725$),1$/ 27526$63(&7265(/(9$17(678725$,1,&,$/ 62&,$/,=$&,21'(-25',$8;,/,$5((),1$/ 62&,$/,=$&,21'(-25',$8;,/,$5((,1,&,$/ 62&,$/,=$&,21'(-25',',5(&725$),1$/ 62&,$/,=$&,21'(-25',',5(&725$,1,&,$/ 62&,$/,=$&,21'(-25',($3 62&,$/,=$&,21'(-25',-25',),1$/ 62&,$/,=$&,21'(-25',-25',,1,&,$/ 62&,$/,=$&,21'(-25',0$(675$'((($ 62&,$/,=$&,21'(-25',0$(675$'(((, 62&,$/,=$&,21'(-25',0$(675$'(('8&$&,21),6,&$+),1$/ 62&,$/,=$&,21'(-25',0$(675$'(('8&$&,21),6,&$+,1,&,$/ 62&,$/,=$&,21'(-25',0$(675$'(('8&$&,21),6,&$7 62&,$/,=$&,21'(-25',021,725$'(&20('25 62&,$/,=$&,21'(-25',3$'5(6 62&,$/,=$&,21'(-25',78725$),1$/ 62&,$/,=$&,21'(-25',78725$),1$/ 62&,$/,=$&,21'(-25',78725$,1,&,$/ 62&,$/,=$&,21'(/2/$$8;,/,$5'(((),1$/ 62&,$/,=$&,21'(/2/$$8;,/,$5'(((,1,&,$/ 62&,$/,=$&,21'(/2/$',5(&725$),1$/ 62&,$/,=$&,21'(/2/$',5(&725$,1,&,$/ 62&,$/,=$&,21'(/2/$($3 62&,$/,=$&,21'(/2/$/2/$),1$/ 62&,$/,=$&,21'(/2/$/2/$,1,&,$/ 62&,$/,=$&,21'(/2/$0$(675$'((($ 62&,$/,=$&,21'(/2/$0$(675$'(((, 62&,$/,=$&,21'(/2/$0$(675$'(('8&$&,21),6,&$+),1$/ 62&,$/,=$&,21'(/2/$0$(675$'(('8&$&,21),6,&$+,1,&,$/ 62&,$/,=$&,21'(/2/$0$(675$'(('8&$&,21),6,&$7 62&,$/,=$&,21'(/2/$021,725$'(&20('25 62&,$/,=$&,21'(/2/$3$'5(6 62&,$/,=$&,21'(/2/$78725$),1$/ 62&,$/,=$&,21'(/2/$78725$),1$/ 62&,$/,=$&,21'(/2/$78725$,1,&,$/ DQH[R &DQWLGDGGHUHJLVWURVSRUFDWHJRUtDVGHOGLDULR GHFDPSRGHO&HQWUR &$17,'$''(5(*,67526'(/',$5,2'(&$032'(/&(1752 3$57,&,3$17(0$5Ì$ &Ï',*26 62&$87,1'0$5,$7$ 62&$87,1'0$5,$7% 62&$87,1'0$5,$7 62&$87,1'0$5,$7 62&$87,1'0$5,$7$ 62&$87,1'0$5,$7% 62&$87,1'0$5,$7 62&$87,1'0$5,$7 62&&21)12500$5,$7$ 62&&21)12500$5,$7% 62&&21)12500$5,$7 62&&21)12500$5,$7 62&&21)12500$5,$7$ 62&&21)12500$5,$7% 62&&21)12500$5,$7 62&&21)12500$5,$7 62&,17*58320$5,$/$,*125$17$ 62&,17*58320$5,$/$,*125$17% 62&,17*58320$5,$/$,*125$17 62&,17*58320$5,$/$,*125$17 62&,17*58320$5,$/$5(&+$=$17$ 62&,17*58320$5,$/$5(&+$=$17% 62&,17*58320$5,$/$5(&+$=$17 62&,17*58320$5,$/$5(&+$=$17 62&,17*58320$5,$/$$&(37$1$7 62&,17*58320$5,$/$$&(37$1%7 62&,17*58320$5,$/$$&(37$17 62&,17*58320$5,$/$$&(37$17 62&,17*58320$5,$62162/,'$5,267$ 62&,17*58320$5,$62162/,'$5,267% 62&,17*58320$5,$62162/,'$5,267 62&,17*58320$5,$62162/,'$5,267 62&,170$5,$*5832*(1(5$&21)/,&727$ 62&,170$5,$*5832*(1(5$&21)/,&727% 62&,170$5,$*5832*(1(5$&21)/,&727 62&,170$5,$*5832*(1(5$&21)/,&727 62&,170$5,$*5832/26,*125$7$ 62&,170$5,$*5832/26,*125$7% 62&,170$5,$*5832/26,*125$7 &$17,'$''( 5(*,67526 62&,170$5,$*5832/26,*125$7 62&,170$5,$*5832/26$&(37$7$ 62&,170$5,$*5832/26$&(37$7% 62&,170$5,$*5832/26$&(37$7 62&,170$5,$*5832/26$&(37$7 $16$&7'2&(;,*(1&,$7$ $16$&7'2&(;,*(1&,$7% $16$&7'2&(;,*(1&,$7 $16$&7'2&(;,*(1&,$7 $16$&7'2&3(50,6,9,'$'7$ $16$&7'2&3(50,6,9,'$'7% $16$&7'2&3(50,6,9,'$'7 $16$&7'2&3(50,6,9,'$'7 $16$&7,78''(/2%6(59$'257$ $16$&7,78''(/2%6(59$'257% $16$&7,78''(/2%6(59$'257 $16$&7,78''(/2%6(59$'257 $16'(6&5,3&,210$5,$$&7,78'(67$ $16'(6&5,3&,210$5,$$&7,78'(67% $16'(6&5,3&,210$5,$$&7,78'(67 $16'(6&5,3&,210$5,$$&7,78'(67 $16'(6&5,3&,210$5,$&$5$&7(5,67,&$63(5621$/(67$ $16'(6&5,3&,210$5,$&$5$&7(5,67,&$63(5621$/(67% $16'(6&5,3&,210$5,$&$5$&7(5,67,&$63(5621$/(67 $16'(6&5,3&,210$5,$&$5$&7(5,67,&$63(5621$/(67 $16'(6&5,3&,210$5,$,17(5$&&,210$5,$2%6(59$'25$7$ $16'(6&5,3&,210$5,$,17(5$&&,210$5,$2%6(59$'25$7% $16'(6&5,3&,210$5,$,17(5$&&,210$5,$2%6(59$'25$7 $16'(6&5,3&,210$5,$,17(5$&&,210$5,$2%6(59$'25$7 $16(675$7(*,$67$ $16(675$7(*,$67% $16(675$7(*,$67 $16(675$7(*,$67 $16(675$7(*,$6$'$37$7$5($67$ $16(675$7(*,$6$'$37$7$5($67% $16(675$7(*,$6$'$37$7$5($67 $16(675$7(*,$6$'$37$7$5($67 $16(675$7(*,$6&203(16$/,0,7$&,21(67$ $16(675$7(*,$6&203(16$/,0,7$&,21(67% $16(675$7(*,$6&203(16$/,0,7$&,21(67 $16(675$7(*,$6&203(16$/,0,7$&,21(67 $16(675$7(*,$6'$$32<2$0$5,$7$ $16(675$7(*,$6'$$32<2$0$5,$7% $16(675$7(*,$6'$$32<2$0$5,$7 $16(675$7(*,$6'$$32<2$0$5,$7 $16(675$7(*,$6(;,*('8&+$$0$5,$7$ $16(675$7(*,$6(;,*('8&+$$0$5,$7% $16(675$7(*,$6(;,*('8&+$$0$5,$7 $16(675$7(*,$6(;,*('8&+$$0$5,$7 $16(675$7(*,$6(;3/,&$6(17,'2'($'$37$&,21(6$/*58327$ $16(675$7(*,$6(;3/,&$6(17,'2'($'$37$&,21(6$/*58327% $16(675$7(*,$6(;3/,&$6(17,'2'($'$37$&,21(6$/*58327 $16(675$7(*,$6(;3/,&$6(17,'2'($'$37$&,21(6$/*58327 $16(675$7(*,$6)$&,/,7$48((/$32<2/2'(1/26&203$f(5267$ $16(675$7(*,$6)$&,/,7$48((/$32<2/2'(1/26&203$f(5267% $16(675$7(*,$6)$&,/,7$48((/$32<2/2'(1/26&203$f(5267 $16(675$7(*,$6)$&,/,7$48((/$32<2/2'(1/26&203$f(5267 $16(675$7(*,$6)$&,/,7$48(0$5,$1(*2&,(/$6$'$37$&,21(67$ $16(675$7(*,$6)$&,/,7$48(0$5,$1(*2&,(/$6$'$37$&,21(67% $16(675$7(*,$6)$&,/,7$48(0$5,$1(*2&,(/$6$'$37$&,21(67 $16(675$7(*,$6)$&,/,7$48(0$5,$1(*2&,(/$6$'$37$&,21(67 $16(675$7(*,$6)$&,/,7$'25$'(,17(55(/$&,21(60$5,$*58327$ $16(675$7(*,$6)$&,/,7$'25$'(,17(55(/$&,21(60$5,$*58327% $16(675$7(*,$6)$&,/,7$'25$'(,17(55(/$&,21(60$5,$*58327 $16(675$7(*,$6)$&,/,7$'25$'(,17(55(/$&,21(60$5,$*58327 $16(675$7(*,$6,1752'8&(6,//$'(58('$67$ $16(675$7(*,$6,1752'8&(6,//$'(58('$67% $16(675$7(*,$6,1752'8&(6,//$'(58('$67 $16(675$7(*,$6,1752'8&(6,//$'(58('$67 $16(675$7(*,$602',),&$$'$37$&,21(67$ $16(675$7(*,$602',),&$$'$37$&,21(67% $16(675$7(*,$602',),&$$'$37$&,21(67 $16(675$7(*,$602',),&$$'$37$&,21(67 $16(675$7(*,$65()8(5=$/$720$'('(&,6,21(6'(0$5,$7$ $16(675$7(*,$65()8(5=$/$720$'('(&,6,21(6'(0$5,$7% $16(675$7(*,$65()8(5=$/$720$'('(&,6,21(6'(0$5,$7 $16(675$7(*,$65()8(5=$/$720$'('(&,6,21(6'(0$5,$7 $16(675$7(*,$67$5($648(125(48,(5(1$'$37$&,217$ $16(675$7(*,$67$5($648(125(48,(5(1$'$37$&,217% $16(675$7(*,$67$5($648(125(48,(5(1$'$37$&,217 $16(675$7(*,$67$5($648(125(48,(5(1$'$37$&,217 $16(675$7(*,$675$%$-$/$(03$7,$'(/*58327$ $16(675$7(*,$675$%$-$/$(03$7,$'(/*58327% $16(675$7(*,$675$%$-$/$(03$7,$'(/*58327 $16(675$7(*,$675$%$-$/$(03$7,$'(/*58327 $167$5($6$&7,9,'$'6,10275,&,'$'352<'(9,'(27$ $167$5($6$&7,9,'$'6,10275,&,'$'352<'(9,'(27% $167$5($6$&7,9,'$'6,10275,&,'$'352<'(9,'(27 $167$5($6$&7,9,'$'6,10275,&,'$'352<'(9,'(27 $167$5($6$&7,9,'$'6,10275,&,'$'62&,2*5$0$7$ $167$5($6$&7,9,'$'6,10275,&,'$'62&,2*5$0$7% $167$5($6$&7,9,'$'6,10275,&,'$'62&,2*5$0$7 $167$5($6$&7,9,'$'6,10275,&,'$'62&,2*5$0$7 $167$5($6$&7,9,'$'6,10275,&,'$'9$/25$&,21'($&7,78'(67$ $167$5($6$&7,9,'$'6,10275,&,'$'9$/25$&,21'($&7,78'(67% $167$5($6$&7,9,'$'6,10275,&,'$'9$/25$&,21'($&7,78'(67 $167$5($6$&7,9,'$'6,10275,&,'$'9$/25$&,21'($&7,78'(67 $167$5($6$&7,9,'$'(6'((;35(6,217$ $167$5($6$&7,9,'$'(6'((;35(6,217% $167$5($6$&7,9,'$'(6'((;35(6,217 $167$5($6$&7,9,'$'(6'((;35(6,217 $167$5($6$&7,9,'$'(6'(6(16,%,/,=$&,217$ $167$5($6$&7,9,'$'(6'(6(16,%,/,=$&,217% $167$5($6$&7,9,'$'(6'(6(16,%,/,=$&,217 $167$5($6$&7,9,'$'(6'(6(16,%,/,=$&,217 $167$5($6+0%,1',9,'8$/7$ $167$5($6+0%,1',9,'8$/7% $167$5($6+0%,1',9,'8$/7 $167$5($6+0%,1',9,'8/$7 $167$5($6+0%3$5(-$6275,267$ $167$5($6+0%3$5(-$6275,267% $167$5($6+0%3$5(-$6275,267 $167$5($6+0%3$5(-$6275,267 $167$5($6,1,&,$&,21'(3257,9$7$ $167$5($6,1,&,$&,21'(3257,9$7% $167$5($6,1,&,$&,21'(3257,9$7 $167$5($6,1,&,$&,21'(3257,9$7 $167$5($6-8(*2&203(7,7,927$ $167$5($6-8(*2&203(7,7,927% $167$5($6-8(*2&203(7,7,927 $167$5($6-8(*2&203(7,7,927 $167$5($6-8(*2&223(5$7,927$ $167$5($6-8(*2&223(5$7,927% $167$5($6-8(*2&223(5$7,927 $167$5($6-8(*2&223(5$7,927 $167$5($65(/$-$&,217$ $167$5($65(/$-$&,217% $167$5($65(/$-$&,217 $167$5($65(/$-$&,217 27526&/$6(612,03$57,'$6 27526*5$%$&,21'(9,'(2 27526/$$&7,78''(/263$'5(6+$&,$/$,19(67,*$&,21 27526/$&5((1&,$'(/*5832&/$6(+$&,$/$,1&/86,21 27526/$0$(675$&2022%6(59$'25$7$ 27526/$0$(675$&2022%6(59$'25$7% 27526/$0$(675$&2022%6(59$'25$7 27526/$0$(675$&2022%6(59$'25$7 275260$5,$12$6,67($/$6(6,21 27526275$6(675$7(*,$6'(/$'2&(17( 2752635(6(17$&,21'(/$2%6(59$'25$ 2752635(6(17$&,21'(/*5832 727$/ DQH[R &DQWLGDGGHUHJLVWURVSRUFDWHJRUtDVGHOGLDULR GHFDPSRGHO&HQWUR &2',*26 62&$87,1'-25',7$ 62&$87,1'-25',7% 62&$87,1'-25',7 62&$87,1'-25',7 62&$87,1'-25',7$ 62&$87,1'-25',7% 62&$87,1'-25',7 62&$87,1'-25',7 62&$87,1'/2/$7$ 62&$87,1'/2/$7% 62&$87,1'/2/$7 62&$87,1'/2/$7 62&$87,1'/2/$7$ 62&$87,1'/2/$7% 62&$87,1'/2/$7 62&$87,1'/2/$7 62&&21)1250-25',7$ 62&&21)1250-25',7% 62&&21)1250-25',7 62&&21)1250-25',7 62&&21)1250-25',7$ 62&&21)1250-25',7% 62&&21)1250-25',7 62&&21)1250-25',7 62&&21)1250/2/$7$ 62&&21)1250/2/$7% 62&&21)1250/2/$7 62&&21)1250/2/$7 62&&21)1250/2/$7$ 62&&21)1250/2/$7% 62&&21)1250/2/$7 62&&21)1250/2/$7 62&,17*5832-25',/2,*125$17$ 62&,17*5832-25',/2,*125$17% 62&,17*5832-25',/2,*125$17 62&,17*5832-25',/2,*125$17 62&,17*5832-25',/25(&+$=$17$ 62&,17*5832-25',/25(&+$=$17% 62&,17*5832-25',/25(&+$=$17 62&,17*5832-25',/25(&+$=$17 62&,17*5832-25',/2$&(37$17$ 62&,17*5832-25',/2$&(37$17% 62&,17*5832-25',/2$&(37$17 62&,17*5832-25',/2$&(37$17 62&,17*5832-25',62162/,'$5,267$ &$17'(5(*,67526 62&,17*5832-25',62162/,'$5,267% 62&,17*5832-25',62162/,'$5,267 62&,17*5832-25',62162/,'$5,267 62&,17*5832/2/$/$,*125$17$ 62&,17*5832/2/$/$,*125$17% 62&,17*5832/2/$/$,*125$17 62&,17*5832/2/$/$,*125$17 62&,17*5832/2/$/$5(&+$=$17$ 62&,17*5832/2/$/$5(&+$=$17% 62&,17*5832/2/$/$5(&+$=$17 62&,17*5832/2/$/$5(&+$=$17 62&,17*5832/2/$/$$&(37$1$7 62&,17*5832/2/$/$$&(37$1%7 62&,17*5832/2/$/$$&(37$17 62&,17*5832/2/$/$$&(37$17 62&,17*5832/2/$62162/,'$5,267$ 62&,17*5832/2/$62162/,'$5,267% 62&,17*5832/2/$62162/,'$5,267 62&,17*5832/2/$62162/,'$5,267 62&,17-25',*5832*(1(5$&21)/,&727$ 62&,17-25',*5832*(1(5$&21)/,&727% 62&,17-25',*5832*(1(5$&21)/,&727 62&,17-25',*5832*(1(5$&21)/,&727 62&,17-25',*5832/26,*125$7$ 62&,17-25',*5832/26,*125$7% 62&,17-25',*5832/26,*125$7 62&,17-25',*5832/26,*125$7 62&,17-25',*5832/26$&(37$7$ 62&,17-25',*5832/26$&(37$7% 62&,17-25',*5832/26$&(37$7 62&,17-25',*5832/26$&(37$7 62&,17/2/$*5832*(1(5$&21)/,&727$ 62&,17/2/$*5832*(1(5$&21)/,&727% 62&,17/2/$*5832*(1(5$&21)/,&727 62&,17/2/$*5832*(1(5$&21)/,&727 62&,17/2/$*5832/26,*125$7$ 62&,17/2/$*5832/26,*125$7% 62&,17/2/$*5832/26,*125$7 62&,17/2/$*5832/26,*125$7 62&,17/2/$*5832/26$&(37$7$ 62&,17/2/$*5832/26$&(37$7% 62&,17/2/$*5832/26$&(37$7 62&,17/2/$*5832/26$&(37$7 $16$&7'2&7$ $16$&7'2&7% $16$&7'2&7 $16$&7'2&7 $16$&7,78''(/2%6(59$'257$ $16$&7,78''(/2%6(59$'257% $16$&7,78''(/2%6(59$'257 $16$&7,78''(/2%6(59$'257 $16$&7,78''(/2%6(59$'25,17(5$&&,212%6(59$'25$$8;,/,$5((0$(675$7$ $16$&7,78''(/2%6(59$'25,17(5$&&,212%6(59$'25$$8;,/,$5((0$(675$7% $16$&7,78''(/2%6(59$'25,17(5$&&,212%6(59$'25$$8;,/,$5((0$(675$7 $16$&7,78''(/2%6(59$'25,17(5$&&,212%6(59$'25$$8;,/,$5((0$(675$7 $16$&7,78''(/2%6(59$'25,17(5$&&,212%6(59$'25$$8;,/,$5((7$ $16$&7,78''(/2%6(59$'25,17(5$&&,212%6(59$'25$$8;,/,$5((7% $16$&7,78''(/2%6(59$'25,17(5$&&,212%6(59$'25$$8;,/,$5((7 $16$&7,78''(/2%6(59$'25,17(5$&&,212%6(59$'25$$8;,/,$5((7 $16$&7,78''(/2%6(59$'25,17(5$&&,212%6(59$'25$0$(675$7$ $16$&7,78''(/2%6(59$'25,17(5$&&,212%6(59$'25$0$(675$7% $16$&7,78''(/2%6(59$'25,17(5$&&,212%6(59$'25$0$(675$7 $16$&7,78''(/2%6(59$'25,17(5$&&,212%6(59$'25$0$(675$7 $16$8;,/,$5(('$&216,*1$6<5(68(/9(&21)/,&726&21-25',7$ $16$8;,/,$5(('$&216,*1$6<5(68(/9(&21)/,&726&21-25',7% $16$8;,/,$5(('$&216,*1$6<5(68(/9(&21)/,&726&21-25',7 $16$8;,/,$5(('$&216,*1$6<5(68(/9(&21)/,&726&21-25',7 $16$8;,/,$5((',6(f$$&7,9,'$'(6$/7(51$7,9$67$ $16$8;,/,$5((',6(f$$&7,9,'$'(6$/7(51$7,9$67% $16$8;,/,$5((',6(f$$&7,9,'$'(6$/7(51$7,9$67 $16$8;,/,$5((',6(f$$&7,9,'$'(6$/7(51$7,9$67 $16$8;,/,$5((,16,67($-25',358'(1&,$7$ $16$8;,/,$5((,16,67($-25',358'(1&,$7% $16$8;,/,$5((,16,67($-25',358'(1&,$7 $16$8;,/,$5((,16,67($-25',358'(1&,$7 $16$8;,/,$5((,17(59,(1(&8$1'2-25',+$&(75$03$67$ $16$8;,/,$5((,17(59,(1(&8$1'2-25',+$&(75$03$67% $16$8;,/,$5((,17(59,(1(&8$1'2-25',+$&(75$03$67 $16$8;,/,$5((,17(59,(1(&8$1'2-25',+$&(75$03$67 $16$8;,/,$5((275267$ $16$8;,/,$5((275267% $16$8;,/,$5((275267 $16$8;,/,$5((275267 $16$8;,/,$5((321(/,0,7(6$-25',</2/$7$ $16$8;,/,$5((321(/,0,7(6$-25',</2/$7% $16$8;,/,$5((321(/,0,7(6$-25',</2/$7 $16$8;,/,$5((321(/,0,7(6$-25',</2/$7 $16$8;,/,$5((5(&8(5'$$-25',$'$37$&,21(6,17(5,25,=$&,217$ $16$8;,/,$5((5(&8(5'$$-25',$'$37$&,21(6,17(5,25,=$&,217% $16$8;,/,$5((5(&8(5'$$-25',$'$37$&,21(6,17(5,25,=$&,217 $16$8;,/,$5((5(&8(5'$$-25',$'$37$&,21(6,7(5,25,=$&,217 $16'(6&5,3&,21-25',$&7,78'(67$ $16'(6&5,3&,21-25',$&7,78'(67% $16'(6&5,3&,21-25',$&7,78'(67 $16'(6&5,3&,21-25',$&7,78'(67 $16'(6&5,3&,21-25',&$5$&7(5,67,&$63(5621$/(67$ $16'(6&5,3&,21-25',&$5$&7(5,67,&$63(5621$/(67% $16'(6&5,3&,21-25',&$5$&7(5,67,&$63(5621$/(67 $16'(6&5,3&,21-25',&$5$&7(5,67,&$63(5621$/(67 $16'(6&5,3&,21-25',,17(5$&&,21-25',$8;,/,$5((7$ $16'(6&5,3&,21-25',,17(5$&&,21-25',$8;,/,$5((7% $16'(6&5,3&,21-25',,17(5$&&,21-25',$8;,/,$5((7 $16'(6&5,3&,21-25',,17(5$&&,21-25',$8;,/,$5((7 $16'(6&5,3&,21-25',,17(5$&&,21-25',2%6(59$'25$7$ $16'(6&5,3&,21-25',,17(5$&&,21-25',2%6(59$'25$7% $16'(6&5,3&,21-25',,17(5$&&,21-25',2%6(59$'25$7 $16'(6&5,3&,21-25',,17(5$&&,21-25',2%6(59$'25$7 $16'(6&5,3&,21/2/$$&7,78'(67$ $16'(6&5,3&,21/2/$$&7,78'(67% $16'(6&5,3&,21/2/$$&7,78'(67 $16'(6&5,3&,21/2/$$&7,78'(67 $16'(6&5,3&,21/2/$&$5$&7(5,67,&$63(5621$/(67$ $16'(6&5,3&,21/2/$&$5$&7(5,67,&$63(5621$/(67% $16'(6&5,3&,21/2/$&$5$&7(5,67,&$63(5621$/(67 $16'(6&5,3&,21/2/$&$5$&7(5,67,&$63(5621$/(67 $16'(6&5,3&,21/2/$,17(5$&&,21/2/$$8;,/,$5((7$ $16'(6&5,3&,21/2/$,17(5$&&,21/2/$$8;,/,$5((7% $16'(6&5,3&,21/2/$,17(5$&&,21/2/$$8;,/,$5((7 $16'(6&5,3&,21/2/$,17(5$&&,21/2/$$8;,/,$5((7 $16'(6&5,3&,21/2/$,17(5$&&,21/2/$2%6(59$'25$7$ $16'(6&5,3&,21/2/$,17(5$&&,21/2/$2%6(59$'25$7% $16'(6&5,3&,21/2/$,17(5$&&,21/2/$2%6(59$'25$7 $16'(6&5,3&,21/2/$,17(5$&&,21/2/$2%6(59$'25$7 $16(675$7(*,$67$ $16(675$7(*,$67% $16(675$7(*,$67 $16(675$7(*,$67 $16(675$7(*,$6$'$37$7$5($67$ $16(675$7(*,$6$'$37$7$5($67% $16(675$7(*,$6$'$37$7$5($67 $16(675$7(*,$6$'$37$7$5($67 $16(675$7(*,$6&203(16$/,0,7$&,21(67$ $16(675$7(*,$6&203(16$/,0,7$&,21(67% $16(675$7(*,$6&203(16$/,0,7$&,21(67 $16(675$7(*,$6&203(16$/,0,7$&,21(67 $16(675$7(*,$6(;3/,&$6(17,'2'($'$37$&,21(6$/*58327$ $16(675$7(*,$6(;3/,&$6(17,'2'($'$37$&,21(6$/*58327% $16(675$7(*,$6(;3/,&$6(17,'2'($'$37$&,21(6$/*58327 $16(675$7(*,$6(;3/,&$6(17,'2'($'$37$&,21(6$/*58327 $16(675$7(*,$602',),&$$'$37$&,21(67$ $16(675$7(*,$602',),&$$'$37$&,21(67% $16(675$7(*,$602',),&$$'$37$&,21(67 $16(675$7(*,$602',),&$$'$37$&,21(67 $16(675$7(*,$67$5($648(125(48,(5(1$'$37$&,217$ $16(675$7(*,$67$5($648(125(48,(5(1$'$37$&,217% $16(675$7(*,$67$5($648(125(48,(5(1$'$37$&,217 $16(675$7(*,$67$5($648(125(48,(5(1$'$37$&,217 $16,17(5$&&,21-25',/2/$7$ $16,17(5$&&,21-25',/2/$7% $16,17(5$&&,21-25',/2/$7 $16,17(5$&&,21-25',/2/$7 $167$5($6$&7,9,'$'6,10275,&,'$'&/$6(67(25,&$67$ $167$5($6$&7,9,'$'6,10275,&,'$'&/$6(67(25,&$67% $167$5($6$&7,9,'$'6,10275,&,'$'&/$6(67(25,&$67 $167$5($6$&7,9,'$'6,10275,&,'$'&/$6(67(25,&$67 $167$5($6$&7,9,'$'6,10275,&,'$'352<'(9,'(27$ $167$5($6$&7,9,'$'6,10275,&,'$'352<'(9,'(27% $167$5($6$&7,9,'$'6,10275,&,'$'352<'(9,'(27 $167$5($6$&7,9,'$'6,10275,&,'$'352<'(9,'(27 $167$5($6$&7,9,'$'6,10275,&,'$'62&,2*5$0$7$ $167$5($6$&7,9,'$'6,10275,&,'$'62&,2*5$0$7% $167$5($6$&7,9,'$'6,10275,&,'$'62&,2*5$0$7 $167$5($6$&7,9,'$'6,10275,&,'$'62&,2*5$0$7 $167$5($6$&7,9,'$'(6'(6(16,%,/,=$&,217$ $167$5($6$&7,9,'$'(6'(6(16,%,/,=$&,217% $167$5($6$&7,9,'$'(6'(6(16,%,/,=$&,217 $167$5($6$&7,9,'$'(6'(6(16,%,/,=$&,217 $167$5($6+0%,1',9,'8$/7$ $167$5($6+0%,1',9,'8$/7% $167$5($6+0%,1',9,'8$/7 $167$5($6+0%,1',9,'8$/7 $167$5($6+0%3$5(-$6275,267$ $167$5($6+0%3$5(-$6275,267% $167$5($6+0%3$5(-$6275,267 $167$5($6+0%3$5(-$6275,267 $167$5($6,1,&,$&,21'(3257,9$7$ $167$5($6,1,&,$&,21'(3257,9$7% $167$5($6,1,&,$&,21'(3257,9$7 $167$5($6,1,&,$&,21'(3257,9$7 $167$5($6-8(*2&203(7,7,927$ $167$5($6-8(*2&203(7,7,927% $167$5($6-8(*2&203(7,7,927 $167$5($6-8(*2&203(7,7,927 $167$5($6-8(*2&223(5$7,927$ $167$5($6-8(*2&223(5$7,927% $167$5($6-8(*2&223(5$7,927 $167$5($6-8(*2&223(5$7,927 $167$5($6-8(*2/,%5(7$ $167$5($6-8(*2/,%5(7% $167$5($6-8(*2/,%5(7 $167$5($6-8(*2/,%5(7 27526&/$6(612,03$57,'$6 27526*5$%$&,21'(9,'(2 27526-25',$6,67($/$6(6,213(52123$57,&,3$ 27526-25',12$6,67($/$6(6,21 27526/$$8;,/,$5((&2022%6(59$'25$7$ 27526/$$8;,/,$5((&2022%6(59$'25$7% 27526/$$8;,/,$5((&2022%6(59$'25$7 27526/$$8;,/,$5((&2022%6(59$'25$7 27526/$&$,'$'(-25', 27526/$&5((1&,$'(/*5832&/$6(+$&,$/$,1&/86,21 27526/$0$(675$6867,787$ 27526/$2%6(59$'25$1238('(5(*,675$5/$6(6,21<1$',(/$5(*,675$ 27526/2/$12$6,67($/$6(6,21 2752612$6,67(/$0$(675$ 275262%6(59$&,21(6'(,17(5(63$5$(/,1)250( 27526275$6(675$7(*,$6'(/$'2&(17( 2752635(6(17$&,21'(/$2%6(59$'25$ 2752635(6(17$&,21'(/*5832 275265(75$626'(-25', 7RWDOV DQH[R &DQWLGDGGHUHJLVWURVSRUFDWHJRUtDVGHODV HQWUHYLVWDVGHO&HQWUR &$17,'$''(5(*,67526 (175(9,67$6&(1752 &Ï',*26 '(6&5,3&,21'(0$5,$',5(&725$<-()$'((678',26),1$/ '(6&5,3&,21'(0$5,$',5(&725$<-()$'((678',26,1,&,$/ '(6&5,3&,21'(0$5,$',5(&725$),1$/ '(6&5,3&,21'(0$5,$',5(&725$,1,&,$/ '(6&5,3&,21'(0$5,$($3 '(6&5,3&,21'(0$5,$-()$'((678',26),1$/ '(6&5,3&,21'(0$5,$-()$'((678',26,1,&,$/ '(6&5,3&,21'(0$5,$0$(675$'(('8&$&,21),6,&$),1$/ '(6&5,3&,21'(0$5,$0$(675$'(('8&$&,21),6,&$,1,&,$/ '(6&5,3&,21'(0$5,$0$5,$),1$/ '(6&5,3&,21'(0$5,$0$5,$,1,&,$/ '(6&5,3&,21'(0$5,$3$'5(6),1$/ '(6&5,3&,21'(0$5,$3$'5(6,1,&,$/ '(6&5,3&,21'(0$5,$36,&2/2*2 '(6&5,3&,21'(0$5,$78725$),1$/ '(6&5,3&,21'(0$5,$78725$,1,&,$/ (675$7(*,$6,1&/86,9$6'(/$0$(675$',5(&725$<-()$'((678',26),1$/ (675$7(*,$6,1&/86,9$6'(/$0$(675$',5(&725$<-()$'((678',26,1,&,$/ (675$7(*,$6,1&/86,9$6'(/$0$(675$',5(&725$),1$/ (675$7(*,$6,1&/86,9$6'(/$0$(675$',5(&725$,1,&,$/ (675$7(*,$6,1&/86,9$6'(/$0$(675$($3 (675$7(*,$6,1&/86,9$6'(/$0$(675$-()$'((678',26),1$/ (675$7(*,$6,1&/86,9$6'(/$0$(675$-()$'((678',26,1,&,$/ (675$7(*,$6,1&/86,9$6'(/$0$(675$0$(675$'(('8&$&,21),6,&$),1$/ (675$7(*,$6,1&/86,9$6'(/$0$(675$0$(675$'(('8&$&,21),6,&$,1,&,$/ (675$7(*,$6,1&/86,9$6'(/$0$(675$0$5,$),1$/ (675$7(*,$6,1&/86,9$6'(/$0$(675$0$5,$,1,&,$/ (675$7(*,$6,1&/86,9$6'(/$0$(675$3$'5(6),1$/ (675$7(*,$6,1&/86,9$6'(/$0$(675$3$'5(6,1,&,$/ (675$7(*,$6,1&/86,9$6'(/$0$(675$36,&2/2*2 (675$7(*,$6,1&/86,9$6'(/$0$(675$78725$),1$/ (675$7(*,$6,1&/86,9$6'(/$0$(675$78725$,1,&,$/ 25*$1,=$&,21(6&2/$5',5(&725$<-()$'((678',26),1$/ 25*$1,=$&,21(6&2/$5',5(&725$<-()$'((678',26,1,&,$/ 25*$1,=$&,21(6&2/$5',5(&725$),1$/ 25*$1,=$&,21(6&2/$5',5(&725$,1,&,$/ 25*$1,=$&,21(6&2/$5($3 25*$1,=$&,21(6&2/$5-()$'((678',26),1$/ 25*$1,=$&,21(6&2/$5-()$'((678',26,1,&,$/ 25*$1,=$&,21(6&2/$50$(675$'(('8&$&,21),6,&$),1$/ &$17'( 5(*,67526 25*$1,=$&,21(6&2/$50$(675$'(('8&$&,21),6,&$,1,&,$/ 25*$1,=$&,21(6&2/$50$5,$),1$/ 25*$1,=$&,21(6&2/$50$5,$,1,&,$/ 25*$1,=$&,21(6&2/$53$'5(6),1$/ 25*$1,=$&,21(6&2/$53$'5(6,1,&,$/ 25*$1,=$&,21(6&2/$536,&2/2*2 25*$1,=$&,21(6&2/$578725$),1$/ 25*$1,=$&,21(6&2/$578725$,1,&,$/ 27526$63(&7265(/(9$17(6',5(&725$<-()$'((678',26),1$/ 27526$63(&7265(/(9$17(6',5(&725$<-()$'((678',26,1,&,$/ 27526$63(&7265(/(9$17(6',5(&725$),1$/ 27526$63(&7265(/(9$17(6',5(&725$,1,&,$/ 27526$63(&7265(/(9$17(6($3 27526$63(&7265(/(9$17(6-()$'((678',26),1$/ 27526$63(&7265(/(9$17(6-()$'((678',26,1,&,$/ 27526$63(&7265(/(9$17(60$(675$'(('8&$&,21),6,&$),1$/ 27526$63(&7265(/(9$17(60$(675$'(('8&$&,21),6,&$,1,&,$/ 27526$63(&7265(/(9$17(60$5,$),1$/ 27526$63(&7265(/(9$17(60$5,$,1,&,$/ 27526$63(&7265(/(9$17(63$'5(6),1$/ 27526$63(&7265(/(9$17(63$'5(6,1,&,$/ 27526$63(&7265(/(9$17(636,&2/2*2 27526$63(&7265(/(9$17(678725$),1$/ 27526$63(&7265(/(9$17(678725$,1,&,$/ 62&,$/,=$&,21'(0$5,$',5(&725$<-()$'((678',26),1$/ 62&,$/,=$&,21'(0$5,$',5(&725$<-()$'((678',26,1,&,$/ 62&,$/,=$&,21'(0$5,$',5(&725$),1$/ 62&,$/,=$&,21'(0$5,$',5(&725$,1,&,$/ 62&,$/,=$&,21'(0$5,$($3 62&,$/,=$&,21'(0$5,$-()$'((678',26),1$/ 62&,$/,=$&,21'(0$5,$-()$'((678',26,1,&,$/ 62&,$/,=$&,21'(0$5,$0$(675$'(('8&$&,21),6,&$),1$/ 62&,$/,=$&,21'(0$5,$0$(675$'(('8&$&,21),6,&$,1,&,$/ 62&,$/,=$&,21'(0$5,$0$5,$),1$/ 62&,$/,=$&,21'(0$5,$0$5,$,1,&,$/ 62&,$/,=$&,21'(0$5,$3$'5(6),1$/ 62&,$/,=$&,21'(0$5,$3$'5(6,1,&,$/ 62&,$/,=$&,21'(0$5,$36,&2/2*2 62&,$/,=$&,21'(0$5,$78725$),1$/ 62&,$/,=$&,21'(0$5,$78725$,1,&,$/ 7RWDOHV DQH[R &DQWLGDGGHUHJLVWURVSRUFDWHJRUtDVGHODV HQWUHYLVWDVGHO&HQWUR &$17,'$''(5(*,67526 (175(9,67$6&(1752 &Ï',*26 '(6&5,3&,21'(-25',$8;,/,$5((),1$/ '(6&5,3&,21'(-25',$8;,/,$5((,1,&,$/ '(6&5,3&,21'(-25',',5(&725$),1$/ '(6&5,3&,21'(-25',',5(&725$,1,&,$/ '(6&5,3&,21'(-25',($3 '(6&5,3&,21'(-25',-25',),1$/ '(6&5,3&,21'(-25',-25',,1,&,$/ '(6&5,3&,21'(-25',0$(675$'((($ '(6&5,3&,21'(-25',0$(675$'(((, '(6&5,3&,21'(-25',0$(675$'(('8&$&,21),6,&$+),1$/ '(6&5,3&,21'(-25',0$(675$'(('8&$&,21),6,&$+,1,&,$/ '(6&5,3&,21'(-25',0$(675$'(('8&$&,21),6,&$7 '(6&5,3&,21'(-25',021,725$'(&20('25 '(6&5,3&,21'(-25',3$'5(6 '(6&5,3&,21'(-25',78725$),1$/ '(6&5,3&,21'(-25',78725$),1$/ '(6&5,3&,21'(-25',78725$,1,&,$/ '(6&5,3&,21'(/2/$$8;,/,$5((),1$/ '(6&5,3&,21'(/2/$$8;,/,$5((,1,&,$/ '(6&5,3&,21'(/2/$',5(&725$),1$/ '(6&5,3&,21'(/2/$',5(&725$,1,&,$/ '(6&5,3&,21'(/2/$($3 '(6&5,3&,21'(/2/$/2/$),1$/ '(6&5,3&,21'(/2/$/2/$,1,&,$/ '(6&5,3&,21'(/2/$0$(675$'((($ '(6&5,3&,21'(/2/$0$(675$'(((, '(6&5,3&,21'(/2/$0$(675$'(('8&$&,21),6,&$+),1$/ '(6&5,3&,21'(/2/$0$(675$'(('8&$&,21),6,&$+,1,&,$/ '(6&5,3&,21'(/2/$0$(675$'(('8&$&,21),6,&$7 '(6&5,3&,21'(/2/$021,725$'(&20('25 '(6&5,3&,21'(/2/$3$'5(6 '(6&5,3&,21'(/2/$78725$),1$/ '(6&5,3&,21'(/2/$78725$),1$/ '(6&5,3&,21'(/2/$78725$,1,&,$/ (675$7(*,$6,1&/86,9$6'(/$0$(675$$8;,/,$5((),1$/ (675$7(*,$6,1&/86,9$6'(/$0$(675$$8;,/,$5((,1,&,$/ (675$7(*,$6,1&/86,9$6'(/$0$(675$',5(&725$),1$/ (675$7(*,$6,1&/86,9$6'(/$0$(675$',5(&725$,1,&,$/ (675$7(*,$6,1&/86,9$6'(/$0$(675$($3 (675$7(*,$6,1&/86,9$6'(/$0$(675$-25',),1$/ &$17'(5(*,67526 (675$7(*,$6,1&/86,9$6'(/$0$(675$/2/$,1,&,$/ (675$7(*,$6,1&/86,9$6'(/$0$(675$0$(675$'(('8&$&,21 ),6,&$+),1$/ (675$7(*,$6,1&/86,9$6'(/$0$(675$0$(675$'(('8&$&,21 ),6,&$+,1,&,$/ (675$7(*,$6,1&/86,9$6'(/$0$(675$-25',,1,&,$/ (675$7(*,$6,1&/86,9$6'(/$0$(675$/2/$),1$/ (675$7(*,$6,1&/86,9$6'(/$0$(675$0$(675$'(('8&$&,21 ),6,&$7 (675$7(*,$6,1&/86,9$6'(/$0$(675$0$(675$(($ (675$7(*,$6,1&/86,9$6'(/$0$(675$0$(675$((, (675$7(*,$6,1&/86,9$6'(/$0$(675$021,725$'(&20('25 (675$7(*,$6,1&/86,9$6'(/$0$(675$3$'5(6'(-25', (675$7(*,$6,1&/86,9$6'(/$0$(675$3$'5(6'(/2/$ (675$7(*,$6,1&/86,9$6'(/$0$(675$78725$),1$/ (675$7(*,$6,1&/86,9$6'(/$0$(675$78725$),1$/ (675$7(*,$6,1&/86,9$6'(/$0$(675$78725$,1,&,$/ ,17(5$&&,21-25',/2/$$8;,/,$5((),1$/ ,17(5$&&,21-25',/2/$$8;,/,$5((,1,&,$/ ,17(5$&&,21-25',/2/$',5(&725$),1$/ ,17(5$&&,21-25',/2/$',5(&725$,1,&,$/ ,17(5$&&,21-25',/2/$($3 ,17(5$&&,21-25',/2/$-25',),1$/ ,17(5$&&,21-25',/2/$-25',,1,&,$/ ,17(5$&&,21-25',/2/$/2/$),1$/ ,17(5$&&,21-25',/2/$/2/$,1,&,$/ ,17(5$&&,21-25',/2/$0$(675$'((($ ,17(5$&&,21-25',/2/$0$(675$'(((, ,17(5$&&,21-25',/2/$0$(675$'(('8&$&,21),6,&$+),1$/ ,17(5$&&,21-25',/2/$0$(675$'(('8&$&,21),6,&$+,1,&,$/ ,17(5$&&,21-25',/2/$0$(675$'(('8&$&,21),6,&$7 ,17(5$&&,21-25',/2/$021,725$'(&20('25 ,17(5$&&,21-25',/2/$3$'5(6 ,17(5$&&,21-25',/2/$78725$),1$/ ,17(5$&&,21-25',/2/$78725$),1$/ ,17(5$&&,21-25',/2/$78725$,1,&,$/ 25*$1,=$&,21(6&2/$5$8;,/,$5'(((),1$/ 25*$1,=$&,21(6&2/$5$8;,/,$5'(((,1,&,$/ 25*$1,=$&,21(6&2/$5',5(&725$),1$/ 25*$1,=$&,21(6&2/$5',5(&725$,1,&,$/ 25*$1,=$&,21(6&2/$5($3 25*$1,=$&,21(6&2/$5-25',),1$/ 25*$1,=$&,21(6&2/$5-25',,1,&,$/ 25*$1,=$&,21(6&2/$5/2/$),1$/ 25*$1,=$&,21(6&2/$5/2/$,1,&,$/ 25*$1,=$&,21(6&2/$50$(675$'((($ 25*$1,=$&,21(6&2/$50$(675$'(((, 25*$1,=$&,21(6&2/$50$(675$'(('8&$&,21),6,&$+),1$/ 25*$1,=$&,21(6&2/$50$(675$'(('8&$&,21),6,&$+,1,&,$/ 25*$1,=$&,21(6&2/$50$(675$'(('8&$&,21),6,&$7,1,&,$/ 25*$1,=$&,21(6&2/$5021,725$'(&20('25 25*$1,=$&,21(6&2/$53$'5(6'(-25', 25*$1,=$&,21(6&2/$53$'5(6'(/2/$ 25*$1,=$&,21(6&2/$578725$),1$/ 25*$1,=$&,21(6&2/$578725$),1$/ 25*$1,=$&,21(6&2/$578725$,1,&,$/ 27526$63(&7265(/(9$17(6$8;,/,$5((),1$/ 27526$63(&7265(/(9$17(6$8;,/,$5((,1,&,$/ 27526$63(&7265(/(9$17(6',5(&725$),1$/ 27526$63(&7265(/(9$17(6',5(&725$,1,&,$/ 27526$63(&7265(/(9$17(6($3 27526$63(&7265(/(9$17(6-25',),1$/ 27526$63(&7265(/(9$17(6-25',,1,&,$/ 27526$63(&7265(/(9$17(6/2/$),1$/ 27526$63(&7265(/(9$17(6/2/$,1,&,$/ 27526$63(&7265(/(9$17(60$(675$'((($ 27526$63(&7265(/(9$17(60$(675$'(((, 27526$63(&7265(/(9$17(60$(675$'(('8&$&,21),6,&$+),1$/ 27526$63(&7265(/(9$17(60$(675$'(('8&$&,21 ),6,&$+,1,&,$/ 27526$63(&7265(/(9$17(60$(675$'(('8&$&,21),6,&$7 27526$63(&7265(/(9$17(6021,725$'(&20('25 27526$63(&7265(/(9$17(63$'5(6'(-25', 27526$63(&7265(/(9$17(63$'5(6'(/2/$ 27526$63(&7265(/(9$17(678725$),1$/ 27526$63(&7265(/(9$17(678725$),1$/ 27526$63(&7265(/(9$17(678725$,1,&,$/ 62&,$/,=$&,21'(-25',$8;,/,$5((),1$/ 62&,$/,=$&,21'(-25',$8;,/,$5((,1,&,$/ 62&,$/,=$&,21'(-25',',5(&725$),1$/ 62&,$/,=$&,21'(-25',',5(&725$,1,&,$/ 62&,$/,=$&,21'(-25',($3 62&,$/,=$&,21'(-25',-25',),1$/ 62&,$/,=$&,21'(-25',-25',,1,&,$/ 62&,$/,=$&,21'(-25',0$(675$'((($ 62&,$/,=$&,21'(-25',0$(675$'(((, 62&,$/,=$&,21'(-25',0$(675$'(('8&$&,21),6,&$+),1$/ 62&,$/,=$&,21'(-25',0$(675$'(('8&$&,21),6,&$+,1,&,$/ 62&,$/,=$&,21'(-25',0$(675$'(('8&$&,21),6,&$7 62&,$/,=$&,21'(-25',021,725$'(&20('25 62&,$/,=$&,21'(-25',3$'5(6 62&,$/,=$&,21'(-25',78725$),1$/ 62&,$/,=$&,21'(-25',78725$),1$/ 62&,$/,=$&,21'(-25',78725$,1,&,$/ 62&,$/,=$&,21'(/2/$$8;,/,$5'(((),1$/ 62&,$/,=$&,21'(/2/$$8;,/,$5'(((,1,&,$/ 62&,$/,=$&,21'(/2/$',5(&725$),1$/ 62&,$/,=$&,21'(/2/$',5(&725$,1,&,$/ 62&,$/,=$&,21'(/2/$($3 62&,$/,=$&,21'(/2/$/2/$),1$/ 62&,$/,=$&,21'(/2/$/2/$,1,&,$/ 62&,$/,=$&,21'(/2/$0$(675$'((($ 62&,$/,=$&,21'(/2/$0$(675$'(((, 62&,$/,=$&,21'(/2/$0$(675$'(('8&$&,21),6,&$+),1$/ 62&,$/,=$&,21'(/2/$0$(675$'(('8&$&,21),6,&$+,1,&,$/ 62&,$/,=$&,21'(/2/$0$(675$'(('8&$&,21),6,&$7 62&,$/,=$&,21'(/2/$021,725$'(&20('25 62&,$/,=$&,21'(/2/$3$'5(6 62&,$/,=$&,21'(/2/$78725$),1$/ 62&,$/,=$&,21'(/2/$78725$),1$/ 62&,$/,=$&,21'(/2/$78725$,1,&,$/ 727$/ DQH[R (QFXHVWDVREUHODLQFOXVLyQHQODVVHVLRQHVGH (GXFDFLyQ)tVLFDGLULJLGDDPDHVWURV 4h(67,21$5,$/60(675(6'¶('8&$&,Ï)Ë6,&$ /$,1&/86,Ï'(/¶$/801$7$0%',6&$3$&,7$70275,8 $/(66(66,216'¶('8&$&,Ï)Ë6,&$ $PEO¶REMHFWLXG¶HVWXGLDUODVLWXDFLyDFWXDOUHVSHFWHDODLQFOXVLyGHO¶DOXPQDWDPEGLVFDSDFLWDWPRWULXHQ OHV VHVVLRQV G¶(GXFDFLy )tVLFD HQ O¶HWDSD G¶(GXFDFLy 3ULPjULD D &DWDOXQ\D VRO OLFLWHP OD VHYD FRO ODERUDFLy /HVGDGHVREWLQJXGHVVHUDQWUDFWDGHVHVWDGtVWLFDPHQWLFRQILGHQFLDOPHQW $FRQWLQXDFLyOLRIHULPXQDEUHXH[SOLFDFLyGHOVFRQFHSWHVTXHHVWUHEDOODUDQHQDTXHVWHVWXGL &RQVLGHUHPDOXPQDWDPEGLVFDSDFLWDWPRWULXDTXHOOTXHSUHVHQWDSULQFLSDOPHQWXQDOLPLWDFLyHQOD PRELOLWDWIXQFLRQDOG¶XQDRGLYHUVHVSDUWVFRUSRUDOVQHQVLQHQHVDPEHVSLQDEtILGDSDUjOLVLFHUHEUDO QR DVVRFLDGD D DOWUHV GLVFDSDFLWDWV OHVLRQV PHGXO ODUV DPSXWDFLRQV GLVWUzILHV PXVFXODUV HQWUH G¶DOWUHV /¶(VFRODLQFOXVLYD 8QD HVFROD LQFOXVLYD pV XQD HVFROD RQ WRWV L WRWHV WHQHQ FDEXGD LQGHSHQGHQWPHQW GH OHV VHYHV FDUDFWHUtVWLTXHVGLILFXOWDWVLULWPHVHQHOSURFpVG¶DSUHQHQWDWJHSDUWLQWGHODSUHPLVVDTXHTXDOVHYRO DOXPQH pV HGXFDEOH HQ XQ HQWRUQ RUGLQDUL /¶HVFROD LQFOXVLYD FHUFD XQD HGXFDFLy GH TXDOLWDW VHQVH H[FHSFLRQVFRQWHPSODO¶HVFRODFRPDPRWRUGHFDQYLVRFLDOLG¶DFWLWXGVLHVEDVDHQXQDILORVRILDGHOD LJXDOWDW L OD GHPRFUjFLD RQ OD GLYHUVLWDW pV XQ YDORU TXH FRKHVLRQD HO JUXS L PLOORUD OD TXDOLWDW GH O¶HQVHQ\DPHQW 3HUWDQWODLQFOXVLyHQODVHVVLyG¶(GXFDFLy)tVLFDFRPSRUWDLQFORXUHWRWO¶DOXPQDWDWRWHVOHVDFWLYLWDWV IDFLOLWDQWODVHYDSDUWLFLSDFLyDFWLYDLHIHFWLYD1RKHPG¶HQWHQGUHODLQFOXVLyFRPDVVLPLODFLyGHPRGHOV R HWQRFHQWULVPH 1R HV WUDFWD GHO SUHGRPLQL G¶XQD PDQHUD GH IHU VREUH XQD DOWUD VLQy G¶XQD FRQYLYqQFLDHQODGLYHUVLWDWQLWRWVIDUHPODFODVVHDOHVIRVTXHVSHUTXqKLKDJLXQDOXPQHDPEEDL[D YLVLyQLH[FORXUHPO¶DOXPQHFHFSHUTXqQRKLYHJL 4XDQ SDUOHP G¶XQD (GXFDFLy )tVLFD LQFOXVLYD WRW O¶DOXPQDW FRPSDUWHL[ HO PDWHL[ HVSDL VHQVH GLIHUqQFLHVUHFRQVLGHUDQWO¶HQVHQ\DPHQWLODVHYDRUJDQLW]DFLyDPEHOUHFRO]DPHQWSHGDJzJLFLVRFLDO TXH VLJXL QHFHVVDUL L PDQWHQLQW OHV PpV DOWHV H[SHFWDWLYHV SHU D O¶DSUHQHQWDWJH GH WRWV L WRWHV 3HU WDQW OHV DFWLYLWDWV VHJUHJDGHV QR VHUDQ FRQVLGHUDGHV LQFOXVLYHV /D LQFOXVLy SUHVVXSRVD VHPSUH FRPSDUWLUDPEHOJUXSHOSURFpVG¶DSUHQHQWDWJH L HQDTXHVWFRQWH[WODGLYHUVLWDWFRKHVLRQDHOJUXSL O¶HQULTXHL[RIHULQWPpVSRVVLELOLWDWVG¶DSUHQHQWDWJHDWRWKRP (Q GHWHUPLQDGHV FLUFXPVWjQFLHV SRW HVWDU LQGLFDGD O¶DFWLYLWDW LQGLYLGXDO IRUD GHO JUXS SHUz VHUj GH PDQHUDH[FHSFLRQDOLPROWMXVWLILFDGDPDLFRPDSURFHGLPHQWKDELWXDO '$'(6352)(66,21$/6 7LWXODFLyRQVTXHSRVVHHL[ 0HVWUHHVSHFLDOLVWDHQ(GXFDFLy)tVLFD 0HVWUHHVSHFLDOLVWDHQDOWUHVHVSHFLDOLWDWV '¶DOWUHVWLWXODFLRQVHVSHFLILFDU $Q\VG¶H[SHULqQFLDLPSDUWLQW(GXFDFLy)tVLFD 1RPGHOFHQWUH 0XQLFLSL &HQWUHXUEj &HQWUHUXUDO DQ\V &HQWUHS~EOLF &HQWUHFRQFHUWDW &HQWUHSULYDW ,QGLTXL HO QRPEUH G¶DOXPQHV DPE GLVFDSDFLWDW PRWULX HVFRODULW]DW DO VHX FHQWUH HVSHFLILFDQW HO WLSXV G¶DIHFWDFLy 1~PHURG¶DOXPQHVBBBBBBB 7LSXVG¶DIHFWDFLy 6¶HODERUHQ$GDSWDFLRQV&XUULFXODUVVHJRQVOHVQHFHVVLWDWVHGXFDWLYHVGHO¶DOXPQHDPEGLVFDSDFLWDWPRWULX SHUDOHVVHVVLRQVG¶(GXFDFLy)tVLFD"6Ë 12 /HVLQVWDO ODFLRQVGHOVHXFHQWUHHVWDQDGDSWDGHV" 9HVWLGRUV 6Ë 12 3DWL 6Ë 12 *LPQjV 6Ë 12 $OWUHVHVSDLVG¶(GXFDFLy)tVLFD 6Ë 12 6DQLWDULV 6Ë 12 $VFHQVRUVLQRQ¶KLKDGHL[DUHQEODQF6Ë 12 /LGHPDQHPTXHH[SUHVVLHOVHXDFRUGRGHVDFRUGUHVSHFWHDXQVHJXLWG¶LWHPV 7RWDOPHQWHQGHVDFRUG %DVWDQWHQGHVDFRUG %DVWDQWG¶DFRUG 7RWDOPHQWG¶DFRUG (VFULJXLODVHYDRSLQLyPDUFDQWXQD;DODJUDHOODGHUHVSRVWHV *UjFLHVSHUODVHYDFRO ODERUDFLy WRWDO EDVWDQW EDVWDQW GHVDFRUG GHVDFRUG G·DFRUG /DLQFOXVLyG¶DOXPQDWDPEGLVFDSDFLWDWPRWULX'0DOHVVHVVLRQVG¶(GXFDFLy )tVLFD()pVSRVVLEOH /¶DGPLQLVWUDFLyGHGLFDHOVPLWMDQVVXILFLHQWVSHUIDFLOLWDUDTXHVWDLQFOXVLy /DIRUPDFLyLQLFLDOGHOSURIHVVRUDWpVDGHTXDGDSHUDIURQWDUODLQFOXVLyGHOV DOXPQHVDPE'0DOHVVHVVLRQVG¶() /DIRUPDFLySHUPDQHQWGHOSURIHVVRUDWpVDGHTXDGDSHUDIURQWDUODLQFOXVLy GHOVDOXPQHVDPE'0DOHVVHVVLRQVG¶() (QHOPHXFHQWUHOHVEDUUHUHVDUTXLWHFWzQLTXHVHVFRODUVVyQXQREVWDFOHSHUD ODSDUWLFLSDFLyGHO¶DOXPQDWDPE'0DOHVVHVVLRQVG¶() (QWLQFSURXDPEHOPDWHULDOG¶(GXFDFLy)tVLFDGHOPHXFHQWUH SHUWUHEDOODUDGHTXDGDPHQWDPEWRWO¶DOXPQDW /¶jUHDG¶()HVWjYDORUDGDSHOFODXVWUHFRPODUHVWDG¶jUHHVHGXFDWLYHV /¶DOXPQDWDPE'0pVFRQVFLHQWGHOHVVHYHVOLPLWDFLRQVDODVHVVLyG¶() 5HERDVVHVVRUDPHQWSHUSDUWGHO¶(TXLSG¶$VVHVVRUDPHQW3VLFRSHJDJzJLF 7LQFVXILFLHQWLQIRUPDFLyVREUHOD'0GHOPHXDOXPQH (OVSDUHVLPDUHVGHOVDOXPQHVVHQVH'0HVWDQG¶DFRUGUHVSHFWHDODLQFOXVLy &UHFTXHSHUGRQDUUHVSRVWDHGXFDWLYDHILFDoDOHVQHFHVVLWDWVHGXFDWLYHVGH O¶DOXPQHDPE'0HQDOJXQVFDVRVFDOGULDGHULYDUORDXQDHVFRODG¶(GXFDFLy (VSHFLDO &UHFTXHUHERHOVXSRUWQHFHVVDULSHUSDUWGHOFODXVWUH (OVSDUHVLPDUHVGHO¶DOXPQDWDPE'0HVWDQG¶DFRUGUHVSHFWHDODVHYD SDUWLFLSDFLyDOHVVHVVLRQVG¶() /DSUHVqQFLDGHO¶DOXPQHDPE'0DIDYRUHL[OHVDFWLWXGVUHVSHFWXRVHVGHOJUXS HQYHUVODGLYHUVLWDW (OPHVWUHG¶(GXFDFLy(VSHFLDOHPGyQDVXSRUWDOHVVHVVLRQVG¶()RQ SDUWLFLSDDOXPQDWDPE'0 /¶DOXPQDWVHQVH'0HVPRVWUDIDYRUDEOHDODLQFOXVLyGHOVHXFRPSDQ\DPE '0DODVHVVLyG¶() 7LQFHOVFRQHL[HPHQWVVXILFLHQWVSHUHODERUDU$GDSWDFLRQV&XUULFXODUV 'LVSRVRG¶LQIRUPHVPqGLFVVREUHO¶DOXPQDWDPE'0 /DSUHVqQFLDGHO¶DOXPQHDPE'0GLILFXOWDODGLQjPLFDGHOHVVHVVLRQVG¶() 7LQFVXILFLHQWVUHFXUVRVGLGjFWLFVSHUIDFLOLWDUODSDUWLFLSDFLyDFWLYDLHIHFWLYDGH O¶DOXPQDWDPE'0DODVHVVLyG¶() (OPLOORUVHULDTXHXQPHVWUHGHVXSRUWGRQpVVXSRUWLQGLYXDOLW]DWDO¶DOXPQH DPE'0DEDQGDGHOJUXSDOHVVHVVLRQVG¶() /DLQFOXVLyGHO¶DOXPQDWDPE'0HQOHVVHVVLRQVG¶()DIDYRUHL[ODVHYD VRFLDOLW]DFLy WRWDO DFRUG (OFHQWUHDGRSWDPHVXUHVRUJDQLW]DWLYHVJHQHUDOVSHUDIDYRULUODLQFOXVLy (QOHVPHVXUHVLQFOXVLYHVTXHDGRSWDO¶RUJDQLW]DFLyGHOFHQWUHO¶()pV WRWDO EDVWDQW EDVWDQW GHVDFRUG GHVDFRUG G·DFRUG FRQVLGHUDGDFRPTXDOVHYRODOWUDjUHD (QODVHVVLyG¶()O¶DOXPQHDPE'0UHSVXSRUWSHUSDUWGHOVVHXVFRPSDQ\V $OHVKRUHVGHSDWLO¶DOXPQHDPE'0FRPSDUWHL[MRFVPRWRUVDPEODUHVWDGH FRPSDQ\V $OHVKRUHVGHSDWLO¶DOXPQHDPE'0FRPSDUWHL[HVSRUWVDPEODUHVWDGH FRPSDQ\V (QODVHVVLyG¶()pVKDELWXDOTXHO¶DOXPQHDPE'0VLJXLTXLLQLFLDOHV LQWHUDFFLRQVDPEHOVVHXVFRPSDQ\V (QHOPRPHQWGHIRUPDUHTXLSVRJUXSVO¶DOXPQHDPE'0HVPRVWUDSDVVLX 4XDQHVIRUPHQJUXSVRHTXLSVO¶DOXPQHDPE'0pVWULDWHQGDUUHUOORF /¶DOXPQHDPE'0V¶KRSDVVDEpIHQW() (QHOFDVGHGLVSRVDUGHYHVWLGRUVO¶DOXPQHDPE'0HQIDXVDPEQRUPDOLWDW (QHOFDVGHGLVSRVDUGHGXW[HVO¶DOXPQHDPE'0HQIDXVDPEQRUPDOLWDW (QODSUHVDGHGHFLVLRQVTXHDIHFWHQDODLQFOXVLyGHO¶DOXPQHDPE'0DOHV VHVVLRQVG¶()HPVHQWRVXILFLHQWPHQWUHFRO]DWGD 7LQFGLILFXOWDWVSHUDGDSWDUOHVWDVTXHVPRWULXVGHPDQHUDTXHIDFLOLWLQOD LQFOXVLy /¶DOXPQHDPE'0SDUWLFLSDKDELWXDOPHQWDOVMRFVPRWRUV /¶DOXPQHDPE'0SDUWLFLSDKDELWXDOPHQWDOVHVSRUWV /¶DOXPQHDPE'0PLOORUDHOVHXDSUHQHQWDWJHHQXQHQWRUQLQFOXVLX /¶DOXPQHDPE'0DFFHSWDOHVQRUPHVLYDORUVKDELWXDOPHQW VHQVHSURYRFDUFRQIOLFWHVHQODGLQjPLFDGHOJUXS /¶DOXPQHDPE'0HVPRVWUDVROLGDULDPEHOVVHXVFRPSDQ\V (OJUXSFODVVHV¶LPSOLFDPpVHQODVHVVLyTXDQKLSDUWLFLSDWRWO¶DOXPQDW LQFORHQWDTXHOOTXHSUHVHQWD'0 5HERVXSRUWSHUDODLQFOXVLyGHO¶DOXPQDWDPE'0SHUSDUWGHOD,QVSHFFLy WRWDO DFRUG 'LVSRVRDODVHVVLyGHOVXSRUWGHODILJXUDGHOYHWOODGRUDDX[LOLDUG¶(GXFDFLy(VSHFLDO 12 (QFDVSRVLWLXTXLQWLSXVGHVXSRUWRIHUHL[DOOODUJGHODVHVVLy" 6Ë (QHOFDVTXHKDJLLPSDUWLWFODVVHVHQPpVG¶XQFLFOHGH3ULPjULDHQTXLQWLQFPpVGLILFXOWDWVSHU DGDSWDUOHVWDVTXHVPRWULXV"3HUTXq" /¶DOXPQHDPE'0DVVLVWHL[KDELWXDOPHQWDOHVVRUWLGHVH[FXUVLRQVHWFYLQFXODGHVDPEO¶jUHD"6Ë 12(QFDVQHJDWLXSHUTXq" 9ROHXDIHJLUDOJXQFRPHQWDULRSLQLyHWFUHVSHFWHDODLQFOXVLyGHO¶DOXPQDWDPE'0DOHVVHVVLRQV G¶()" DQH[R &XHVWLRQDULRVREUHODDFWLWXGKDFLDODLQFOXVLyQ GHORVDOXPQRVFRQGLVFDSDFLGDGGLULJLGRDORV FRPSDxHURVGHOJUXSRFODVH &8(67,21$5,262%5(811,f218(9248(9$(16,//$'(58('$6 6LHOSULPHUGtDGHFODVHYHVDXQQLxRQXHYR5D~OTXHWLHQHTXHLUHQVLOODGHUXHGDV D QROHGLUtDQDGD E OHSUHJXQWDUtDFyPRVHOODPD F SUHJXQWDUtDDRWURVFRPSDxHURVVLVDEHQTXLpQHV 6L5D~OTXLHUHMXJDUFRQHOEDOyQFRQPLJUXSRGHDPLJRVHQHOUHFUHR D OHGLUtDTXHQRSXHGHSRUTXHYDHQVLOODGHUXHGDV E OHGLUtDTXHVt F OHGLUtDTXHIXHUDDMXJDUFRQRWURVQLxRV (QODFODVHGH(GXFDFLyQ)tVLFD D FUHRTXH5D~OQRSXHGHKDFHUODSRUTXHYDHQVLOODGHUXHGDV E FUHRTXH5D~OODSXHGHKDFHUFRQQRVRWURV F FUHRTXHHOPDHVWURORWHQGUiTXHD\XGDUPiVSHURTXHODSXHGHKDFHU 6LXQGtDYDLVFRQODFODVHDODSOD\DSLHQVDVTXH5D~OSRGUiYHQLUFRQYRVRWURV\EDxDUVHFRQHO UHVWR"3RUTXp" 6L5D~OPHGLMHUDTXHFXDQGRVHDPD\RUTXLHUHVHUSLORWRGHFRFKHVGHFDUUHUDV\PHSUHJXQWDUDORTXH SLHQVRGHHOOR\ROHGLUtDTXH 6LFXDQGRVHDPRVPD\RUHV5D~OTXLHUHLUDODGLVFRWHFDFRQPLJR D (OHJLUtDXQDGLVFRWHFDVLQHVFDOHUDVHQODSXHUWD E OHGLUtDTXHQRSRUTXHYDHQVLOODGHUXHGDV F OHGLUtDTXHVHEXVFDUDRWURJUXSRGHDPLJRV DQH[R 5HVXOWDGRVGHOFXHVWLRQDULRVREUHDFWLWXGHV GHO&HQWUR &8(67,21$5,262%5(811,f218(9248(9$(16,//$'(58('$6 &(1752²129,(0%5( 6LHOSULPHUGtDGHFODVHYHVDXQQLxRQXHYR5D~OTXHWLHQHTXHLUHQVLOODGHUXHGDV G QROHGLUtDQDGD H OHSUHJXQWDUtDFyPRVHOODPD I SUHJXQWDUtDDRWURVFRPSDxHURVVLVDEHQTXLpQHV 6L5D~OTXLHUHMXJDUFRQHOEDOyQFRQPLJUXSRGHDPLJRVHQHOUHFUHR J OHGLUtDTXHQRSXHGHSRUTXHYDHQVLOODGHUXHGDV K OHGLUtDTXHVt L OHGLUtDTXHIXHUDDMXJDUFRQRWURVQLxRV (QODFODVHGH(GXFDFLyQ)tVLFD M FUHRTXH5D~OQRSXHGHKDFHUODSRUTXHYDHQVLOODGHUXHGDV N FUHRTXH5D~OODSXHGHKDFHUFRQQRVRWURV O FUHRTXHHOPDHVWURORWHQGUiTXHD\XGDUPiVSHURTXHODSXHGHKDFHU 6LXQGtDYDLVFRQODFODVHDODSOD\DSLHQVDVTXH5D~OSRGUiYHQLUFRQYRVRWURV\EDxDUVHFRQHO UHVWR"3RUTXp" 6Ì 12² (6&20212627526 6Ë3(52&21$<8'$ 6Ë3(52,*8$/1238('(%$f$56( 38('((175$5(1(/$*8$*$7($1'2&202/$ 0$5Ë$ 6Ë3(526,10(7(56((1(/$*8$ 6Ë3(52&21)/27$'25 1238('(029(56(325/$$5(1$ 1238('(1$'$5 6L5D~OPHGLMHUDTXHFXDQGRVHDPD\RUTXLHUHVHUSLORWRGHFRFKHVGHFDUUHUDV\PHSUHJXQWDUDORTXH SLHQVRGHHOOR\ROHGLUtDTXH 6Ì 12 &202&8$/48,(53(5621$ (68132&23(/,*52623(526Ë 1238('(68%,5$/&2&+( 1232548(6,<$9$(16,//$6Ï/2/( )$/7$5Ë$0$7$56( 1232548(38('(7(1(581$&&,'(17( 6Ë3(52&267$5Ë$68%,5/2<%$-$5/2'(/&2&+( 6Ë3(521(&(6,7$5Ë$81$<8'$17( /($&216(-$5Ë$27522),&,23(526,48,(5( ,17(17$5/2$'(/$17( 6Ë32548('(-$/$6,//$6(6,(17$(1(/&2&+(<12 3$6$1$'$ 6LFXDQGRVHDPRVPD\RUHV5D~OTXLHUHLUDODGLVFRWHFDFRQPLJR G (OHJLUtDXQDGLVFRWHFDVLQHVFDOHUDVHQODSXHUWD H OHGLUtDTXHQRSRUTXHYDHQVLOODGHUXHGDV I OHGLUtDTXHVHEXVFDUDRWURJUXSRGHDPLJRV DQH[R 5HVXOWDGRVGHOFXHVWLRQDULRVREUHDFWLWXGHV GHO&HQWUR &8(67,21$5,262%5(811,f218(9248(9$(16,//$'(58('$6 &(1752²129,(0%5( 6LHOSULPHUGtDGHFODVHYHVDXQQLxRQXHYR5D~OTXHWLHQHTXHLUHQVLOODGHUXHGDV D QROHGLUtDQDGD E OHSUHJXQWDUtDFyPRVHOODPD F SUHJXQWDUtDDRWURVFRPSDxHURVVLVDEHQTXLpQHV 6L5D~OTXLHUHMXJDUFRQHOEDOyQFRQPLJUXSRGHDPLJRVHQHOUHFUHR D OHGLUtDTXHQRSXHGHSRUTXHYDHQVLOODGHUXHGDV E OHGLUtDTXHVt F OHGLUtDTXHIXHUDDMXJDUFRQRWURVQLxRV (QODFODVHGH(GXFDFLyQ)tVLFD D FUHRTXH5D~OQRSXHGHKDFHUODSRUTXHYDHQVLOODGHUXHGDV E FUHRTXH5D~OODSXHGHKDFHUFRQQRVRWURV F FUHRTXHHOPDHVWURORWHQGUiTXHD\XGDUPiVSHURTXHODSXHGHKDFHU 6LXQGtDYDLVFRQODFODVHDODSOD\DSLHQVDVTXH5D~OSRGUiYHQLUFRQYRVRWURV\EDxDUVHFRQHO UHVWR"3RUTXp" 6Ì 12 6Ë3(52&21$<8'$ 6Ë3(52(67$1'26Ï/2$/$25,//$'(/0$5 6Ë32548(6$%(1$'$5 6Ë32548(7(1*281$0,*248(/2+$&( 126(38('(,5(16,//$325/$$5(1$ 6,6(&$(38('(+$&(56('$f2</$ 5(63216$%,/,'$'(6'(/260$(67526 6($+2*$5Ë$ 6L5D~OPHGLMHUDTXHFXDQGRVHDPD\RUTXLHUHVHUSLORWRGHFRFKHVGHFDUUHUDV\PHSUHJXQWDUDORTXH SLHQVRGHHOOR\ROHGLUtDTXH 6Ì 12 6Ë32548(+$<&2&+(6(63(&,$/(6 6Ë3(52(1&,5&8,7263$5$3(5621$6,*8$/(6 48(e/ 6Ë&2135(&$8&,Ï1 6Ë32548((6811,f2 6Ë32548(38('(+$&(5/248(48,(5$ 6Ë&2181&2&+((63(&,$/6,7,(1(',1(52 12+$<&2&+(6'(&$55(5$63$5$,19È/,'26 1238('(68%,5$/&2&+( 48(6(/23,(16('(18(92 38('(6(53(/,*5262 6LFXDQGRVHDPRVPD\RUHV5D~OTXLHUHLUDODGLVFRWHFDFRQPLJR J (OHJLUtDXQDGLVFRWHFDVLQHVFDOHUDVHQODSXHUWD K OHGLUtDTXHQRSRUTXHYDHQVLOODGHUXHGDV L OHGLUtDTXHVHEXVFDUDRWURJUXSRGHDPLJRV DQH[R &XHVWLRQDULRVREUHODSDUWLFLSDFLyQGHXQ FRPSDxHURXVXDULRGHVLOODGHUXHGDV\GH PXOHWDVHQODVHVLyQGH(GXFDFLyQ)tVLFD\HQHO UHFUHRDGPLQLVWUDGRDOJUXSRFODVH &8(67,21$5,262%5(/$&/$6('(('8&$&,Ï1)Ë6,&$ &UHHVTXHWRGRVORVQLxRV\QLxDVSXHGHQSDUWLFLSDUHQODFODVHGH(GXFDFLyQ)tVLFD"PDUFDFRQXQD; ODUHVSXHVWD 6Ë 12 $9(&(6 6LKDVPDUFDGR12R$9(&(6H[SOLFDSRUTXpDOJXQRVQLxRV\QLxDVQRSXHGHQSDUWLFLSDU (QHOFDVRGHTXHXQQLxRRXQDQLxDYD\DFRQPXOHWDVFUHHVTXHSXHGHKDFHUODFODVHGH(GXFDFLyQ )tVLFD"PDUFDFRQXQD;ODUHVSXHVWD 6Ë 12 $9(&(6 6LKDVPDUFDGR12R$9(&(6H[SOLFDSRUTXpDOJXQRVQLxRV\QLxDVQRSXHGHQSDUWLFLSDU (Q HO FDVR GH TXH XQ QLxR R XQD QLxD YD\D HQ VLOOD GH UXHGDV FUHHV TXH SXHGH KDFHU OD FODVH GH (GXFDFLyQ)tVLFD"PDUFDFRQXQD;ODUHVSXHVWD 6Ë 12 $9(&(6 6LKDVPDUFDGR12R$9(&(6H[SOLFDSRUTXpDOJXQRVQLxRV\QLxDVQRSXHGHQSDUWLFLSDU (QHOFDVRGHTXHXQQLxRRXQDQLxDYD\DFRQPXOHWDVFUHHVTXHSXHGHMXJDUHQHOSDWLRFRQHOUHVWR GHQLxRV\QLxDV"PDUFDFRQXQD;ODUHVSXHVWD 6Ë 12 $9(&(6 6LKDVPDUFDGR12R$9(&(6H[SOLFDSRUTXpDOJXQRVQLxRV\QLxDVQRSXHGHQSDUWLFLSDU (QHOFDVRGHTXHXQQLxRRXQDQLxDYD\DHQVLOODGHUXHGDVFUHHVTXHSXHGHMXJDUHQHOSDWLRFRQHO UHVWRGHQLxRV\QLxDV"PDUFDFRQXQD;ODUHVSXHVWD 6Ë 12 $9(&(6 6LKDVPDUFDGR12R$9(&(6H[SOLFDSRUTXpDOJXQRVQLxRV\QLxDVQRSXHGHQSDUWLFLSDU DQH[R 5HVXOWDGRVGHOFXHVWLRQDULRVREUHOD SDUWLFLSDFLyQGHXQFRPSDxHURXVXDULRGHVLOOD GHUXHGDV\GHPXOHWDVHQODVHVLyQGH (GXFDFLyQ)tVLFD\HQHOUHFUHRDGPLQLVWUDGRDO JUXSRFODVHGHO&HQWUR &8(67,21$5,262%5(/$&/$6('(('8&$&,Ï1)Ë6,&$ &(1752QFODVHGH&XUVRGH3ULPDULD 7RWDODOXPQRV (GDGQLxRGHDxRVGHDxRV\GHDxRV )HFKD &UHHVTXHWRGRVORVQLxRV\QLxDVSXHGHQSDUWLFLSDUHQODFODVHGH(GXFDFLyQ)tVLFD"PDUFDFRQXQD; ODUHVSXHVWD 6Ë 12 $9(&(6 6L KDV PDUFDGR 12 R $ 9(&(6 H[SOLFD SRU TXp DOJXQRV QLxRV \ QLxDV QR SXHGHQ SDUWLFLSDU 5(68/7$'26 6Ë 1 12 $9(&(6 (;3/,&$&,21(6 5(63(&72$³12´ ³3RUTXHDDOJXQRVOHVFXHVWDPXFKR\DOJXQRVSHJDQ´ ³3RUTXHQROHJXVWDODJLPQDVLD´ 5(63(&72$³$9(&(6´ ³3RUTXHQRSXHGHKDFHUDOJ~QHMHUFLFLR´ (QHOFDVRGHTXHXQQLxRRXQDQLxDYD\DFRQPXOHWDVFUHHVTXHSXHGHKDFHUODFODVHGH(GXFDFLyQ )tVLFD"PDUFDFRQXQD;ODUHVSXHVWD 6Ë 12 $9(&(6 6L KDV PDUFDGR 12 R $ 9(&(6 H[SOLFD SRU TXp DOJXQRV QLxRV \ QLxDV QR SXHGHQ SDUWLFLSDU 5(68/7$'26 6Ë 1 12 $9(&(6 (;3/,&$&,21(6 5(63(&72$³12´ ³'HSHQGHGHTXpDFWLYLGDGHVQR\DTXHOHFRVWDUi´ ³3RUTXHQRSXHGHKDFHUORPLVPRSHURDYHFHVVt´ 5(63(&72$³$9(&(6´ ³3HURDOJXQDVFRVDVQRSXHGH´ (Q HO FDVR GH TXH XQ QLxR R XQD QLxD YD\D HQ VLOOD GH UXHGDV FUHHV TXH SXHGH KDFHU OD FODVH GH (GXFDFLyQ)tVLFD"PDUFDFRQXQD;ODUHVSXHVWD 6Ë 12 $9(&(6 6L KDV PDUFDGR 12 R $ 9(&(6 H[SOLFD SRU TXp DOJXQRV QLxRV \ QLxDV QR SXHGHQ SDUWLFLSDU 5(68/7$'26 6Ë 1 12 $9(&(6 (;3/,&$&,21(6 5(63(&72$³12´ ³3RUTXHQRSXHGHFRUUHU´ ³3RUTXHQRVHDJXDQWDGHSLH´ ³3RUTXH\RFUHRTXHQRSXHGHKDFHUOR´ ³3RUTXHQRSXHGHMXJDUDI~WEROQLD/D3DVWRUDSRUTXHORPDWDUtDQ´ 5(63(&72$³$9(&(6´ ³'HSHQGHGHTXHDFWLYLGDGHVQRSRUTXHOHFRVWDUiQ´ ³3RUTXHKD\XQRVMXHJRVPiVGLItFLOHV´ ³3RUTXHVLKDFHPRVDFWLYLGDGHVGHSLHQRSXGHSRQHUVHGHSLH´ ³$YHFHVQRSXGHKDFHUDOJ~QHMHUFLFLR´ ³3HURDOJXQDVFRVDVQRSXHGH´ ³1RSRUTXHSXHGHFKRFDUFRQDOJXQRV\KDFHUQRVPXFKRGDxR´ ³3RUTXHVLHUHVSDUDOtWLFRQRORSXHGHKDFHU3HURVLWDQVRORYDSRUDOJ~QSUREOHPDQRWDQJUDYHVtTXH SXHGH´ ³3HURDYHFHVQRSXHGH´ (QHOFDVRGHTXHXQQLxRRXQDQLxDYD\DFRQPXOHWDVFUHHVTXHSXHGHMXJDUHQHOSDWLRFRQHOUHVWR GHQLxRV\QLxDV"PDUFDFRQXQD;ODUHVSXHVWD 6Ë 12 $9(&(6 6L KDV PDUFDGR 12 R $ 9(&(6 H[SOLFD SRU TXp DOJXQRV QLxRV \ QLxDV QR SXHGHQ SDUWLFLSDU 5(68/7$'26 1 12 $9(&(6 6Ë (;3/,&$&,21(6 5(63(&72$³12´ ³'HSHQGHGHTXpMXHJRVVLVRQGHFRUUHUWHQHPRVTXHLUPiVGHVSDFLR´ ³3RUTXHMXJDPRVDI~WERO´ ³3HURMXJDUtDPRVDRWUDFRVD´ 5(63(&72$³$9(&(6´ (QHOFDVRGHTXHXQQLxRRXQDQLxDYD\DHQVLOODGHUXHGDVFUHHVTXHSXHGHMXJDUHQHOSDWLRFRQHO UHVWRGHQLxRV\QLxDV"PDUFDFRQXQD;ODUHVSXHVWD 6Ë 12 $9(&(6 6L KDV PDUFDGR 12 R $ 9(&(6 H[SOLFD SRU TXp DOJXQRV QLxRV \ QLxDV QR SXHGHQ SDUWLFLSDU 5(68/7$'26 6Ë 1 12 $9(&(6 (;3/,&$&,21(6 5(63(&72$³12´ ³3RUTXHMXJDPRVDI~WERO´ 5(63(&72$³$9(&(6´ ³$I~WEROQRSXHGHMXJDUSRUTXHQRSXHGHFKXWDU´ ³3RUTXHKD\XQRVMXHJRVPiVGLItFLOHV´ ³3HURVLQRSXHGHMXJDUtDPRVDRWUDFRVD´ &20(17$5,26 /ODPDODDWHQFLyQTXHODPD\RUtDFRQWHVWDQDILUPDWLYDPHQWHSULQFLSDOPHQWHHQODVSUHJXQWDV\ TXH KDFHQ UHIHUHQFLD DO QLxR R QLxD XVXDULR GH PXOHWDV FRPR OD FRPSDxHUD REMHWR GHO HVWXGLR GH FDVR (Q ODV SUHJXQWDV UHIHULGDV D XVXDULRV GH VLOOD GH UXHGDV ODV UHVSXHVWDV DILUPDWLYDV GLVPLQX\HQ SUREDEOHPHQWHSRUHOGHVFRQRFLPLHQWR 3DUHFH TXH DO FRPSDUWLU OD HVFRODUL]DFLyQ GHVGH HO LQLFLR GH SULPDULD FRQ OD FRPSDxHUD XVXDULD GH PXOHWDVODRSLQLyQHVPiVIDYRUDEOHGDGRTXHHOFRQRFLPLHQWRGHODVFDSDFLGDGHVHVPD\RUTXHHQHO FDVRGHVLOODGHUXHGDVVLPSOHPHQWHKLSRWpWLFR DQH[R 5HVXOWDGRVGHOFXHVWLRQDULRVREUHOD SDUWLFLSDFLyQGHXQFRPSDxHURXVXDULRGHVLOOD GHUXHGDV\GHPXOHWDVHQODVHVLyQGH (GXFDFLyQ)tVLFD\HQHOUHFUHRDGPLQLVWUDGRDO JUXSRFODVHGHO&HQWUR &8(67,21$5,262%5(/$&/$6('(('8&$&,Ï1)Ë6,&$ &(1752QFODVHGH$GH3ULPDULD 7RWDODOXPQRV (GDGQLxRVGHDxRVGHDxRV\GHDxRV )HFKD &UHHVTXHWRGRVORVQLxRV\QLxDVSXHGHQSDUWLFLSDUHQODFODVHGH(GXFDFLyQ)tVLFD"PDUFDFRQXQD; ODUHVSXHVWD 6Ë 12 $9(&(6 6L KDV PDUFDGR 12 R $ 9(&(6 H[SOLFD SRU TXp DOJXQRV QLxRV \ QLxDV QR SXHGHQ SDUWLFLSDU 5(68/7$'26 6Ë 1 12 $9(&(6 (;3/,&$&,21(6 5(63(&72$³12´ ³3RUTXHORVSURIHVRUHVQRSXHGHQHVWDUSDUDWRGRVORVQLxRV\QLxDV´ 5(63(&72$³$9(&(6´ ³3RUTXHKD\MXHJRVTXHQRSXHGHQMXJDUSRUDOJXQDGLVFDSDFLGDGItVLFD´ ³3RUTXHSRUHMHPSORXQQLxRGHUXHGDVRPXOHWDVQRSXHGHKDFHUWRGRVORVMXHJRVGHFODVH´ ³3RUTXHXQQLxRRQLxDVRQDOpUJLFRVRWLHQHQXQSUREOHPD´ ³3RUTXHQROHJXVWDHOMXHJR´ ³3RUTXHDYHFHVVHURPSHQODPDQRRDOJXQDSDUWHGHOFXHUSR\QRSXHGHQKDFHUOD(GXFDFLyQ)tVLFD´ ³3RUTXHKD\QLxRV\QLxDVTXHOOHYDQVLOODGHUXHGDVRWLHQHQDOJXQDHQIHUPHGDG´ ³3RUTXHDORPHMRUHVWiQHQIHUPRVQRSXHGHQFRUUHURWLHQHQDVPD´ ³3RUTXHYDHQVLOODGHUXHGDVRFRQPXOHWDV´ ³3RUTXHVLOOHYDVDQGDOLDVRFKDQFODVTXHVHDEURFKDQ1RSRUTXHVHFDHQ´ ³3RUTXHKD\GRVQLxRVTXHXQRHVPLQXVYiOLGR\KD\XQDTXHHVEDMLWD\OHKDQRSHUDGRODVSLHUQDV\SRU WDQWRQRWRGRVORSXHGHQKDFHU´ ³3RUTXHSXHGHWHQHUDOJ~QVtQWRPD´ (QHOFDVRGHTXHXQQLxRRXQDQLxDYD\DFRQPXOHWDVFUHHVTXHSXHGHKDFHUODFODVHGH(GXFDFLyQ )tVLFD"PDUFDFRQXQD;ODUHVSXHVWD 6Ë 12 $9(&(6 6L KDV PDUFDGR 12 R $ 9(&(6 H[SOLFD SRU TXp DOJXQRV QLxRV \ QLxDV QR SXHGHQ SDUWLFLSDU 5(68/7$'26 6Ë 1 12 $9(&(6 (;3/,&$&,21(6 5(63(&72$³12´ ³3RUTXHHQWRGRVORVMXHJRVQHFHVLWDQODVPDQRV´ ³1RSXHGHQSRUTXHXQQLxRFRQPXOHWDVVHSXHGHKDFHUPXFKRPDO´ ³3RUTXHWLHQHQTXHFRUUHU\QRSXHGHQ´ ³3RUTXHQRSXHGHFRUUHUQLSXHGHMXJDUDMXHJRVVLOOHYDPXOHWDV´ 5(63(&72$³$9(&(6´ ³3RUTXHQRSXHGHFRUUHUQRSXHGHKDFHUODFXHUGDHWF´ ³3RUTXHDOJXQDVDFWLYLGDGHVQRVRQDGHFXDGDV´ ³3RUTXHVLMXJDPRVDKDFHUFDUUHUDVpOQRSXHGHKDFHUOR´ ³3RUTXHVLHVXQDFODVHGHODQ]DUODSHORWDRSDViUQRVODVt<VLHVGHHMHUFLFLRVWDPELpQ´ ³3RUTXHWDPELpQOHSXHGHVSDVDUXQDKRMDSDUDTXHFRQWHVWHSUHJXQWDVGHHGXFDFLyQItVLFD´ ³3RUTXHDORPHMRUQRSXHGHQFRUUHU\MXJDUFRPRWRGRV´ ³3RUTXHDORPHMRUWLHQHQDOJXQDGLILFXOWDG´ ³3RUTXHQRSXHGHQVDOWDU\FRUUHUPXFKR´ ³3RUTXHQRWLHQHODPLVPDIDFLOLGDGGHPRYLPLHQWR´ ³6L YDV HQ PXOHWDV SRU HMHPSOR QR SXHGHV FRUUHU QL MXJDU D MXHJRV TXH WHQJDV TXH XWLOL]DU SHORWD 1R SXHGHKDFHUOR´ ³3RUTXHGHSHQGHGHTXpMXHJRVSRUHMHPSORQRSXHGHVDOWDUODVYDOODVQRSXHGHFRUUHUPXFKR´ ³3RUTXHQRSXHGHFRUUHU\VLQRVRWURVFRUUHPRVSXHGHVHUTXHORSRGDPRVWLUDU´ ³/RSXHGHKDFHUSHURPiVDSRFRDSRFR\FDPELDQGRXQSRFRHOHMHUFLFLR´ (Q HO FDVR GH TXH XQ QLxR R XQD QLxD YD\D HQ VLOOD GH UXHGDV FUHHV TXH SXHGH KDFHU OD FODVH GH (GXFDFLyQ)tVLFD"PDUFDFRQXQD;ODUHVSXHVWD 6Ë 12 $9(&(6 6L KDV PDUFDGR 12 R $ 9(&(6 H[SOLFD SRU TXp DOJXQRV QLxRV \ QLxDV QR SXHGHQ SDUWLFLSDU 5(68/7$'26 6Ë 1 12 $9(&(6 (;3/,&$&,21(6 5(63(&72$³$9(&(6´ ³3RUTXHHQODVFDUUHUDVFRQODVPDQRVSXHGHQKDFHUODVFDUUHUDV´ ³3RUTXHHOORVQRSXHGHQVDOWDUHWF´ ³3RUTXHXQRVMXHJRVQRHVQHFHVDULRQLVDOWDUQLFRVDVGHpVDV´ ³3RUTXHKD\DOJXQDVFRVDVTXHQRSXHGHQKDFHU´ ³3RUTXHVLMXJDPRVDI~WEROpOQRSXHGHFKXWDU´ ³3RUTXHVLHVXQDFODVHGHSDVDUODSHORWDRODQ]DUODVtTXHSXHGH´ ³3RUTXHDYHFHVSXHGHKDFHUODVDFWLYLGDGHV´ ³3RUTXHGHSHQGHGHTXpFRVDVWDPELpQODVSXHGHKDFHU´ ³3RUTXHQRKDFHQHOHMHUFLFLRDOJXQRVTXHORVRWURVSRGHPRVKDFHU´ ³$OJXQDVDFWLYLGDGHVODVSXHGHKDFHU\DOJXQDVQR´ ³3RUTXHQRSXHGHFRUUHUQLVDOWDU´ ³3RUTXHQRSXHGHFRUUHUQRSXHGHFRJHUODSHORWD´ ³3RUTXHQRSXHGHQPRYHUVHPX\ELHQ\QRSXHGHQKDFHUORPLVPR´ ³6LYDHQVLOODGHUXHGDVSXHGHVMXJDUSHURQRDWRGRVORVMXHJRV\DGHPiVVHSXHGHKDFHUPDO´ ³3RUTXH WDPSRFR SXHGH VDOWDU YDOODV QR SXHGH FRUUHU PXFKR QR SXHGH MXJDU D I~WERO WDPSRFR DO YROHLERO´ ³3RUTXHKD\FRVDVTXHQRSXHGHKDFHUSRUHMHPSORVDOWDURMXJDUDI~WERO´ ³/RSXHGHKDFHUSHURPiVDSRFRDSRFR\FDPELDQGRXQSRFRHOHMHUFLFLR´ (QHOFDVRGHTXHXQQLxRRXQDQLxDYD\DFRQPXOHWDVFUHHVTXHSXHGHMXJDUHQHOSDWLRFRQHOUHVWR GHQLxRV\QLxDV"PDUFDFRQXQD;ODUHVSXHVWD 6Ë 12 $9(&(6 6L KDV PDUFDGR 12 R $ 9(&(6 H[SOLFD SRU TXp DOJXQRV QLxRV \ QLxDV QR SXHGHQ SDUWLFLSDU 5(68/7$'26 6Ë 1 12 $9(&(6 (;3/,&$&,21(6 5(63(&72$³12´ ³3RUTXHQRSXHGHPRYHUVHWDQUiSLGDPHQWH\VHSXHGHKDFHUPiVPDOWRGDYtD´ ³3RUTXHVLOHGDODSHORWDOHKDUiPiVGDxR´ ³3RUTXHVLVRQSRUHMHPSORFKXWHVPX\IXHUWHVFRQXQDSHORWDOHSXHGHVKDFHUPXFKRGDxR´ 5(63(&72$³$9(&(6´ ³3RUTXHVLMXJDPRVDXQMXHJRGHFRUUHUFRPRSRUHMHPSORHOHVFRQGLWHRDOSLOODSLOOD´ ³3RUTXHGHSHQGHGHORVMXHJRVSRUHMHPSORDYROHLEROQRSXHGHMXJDUDI~WEROWDPSRFR´ ³6LMXJDPRVDSULQFHVDVVtSXHGHMXJDUSHURVLMXJDPRVDSLOODSLOODSXHGHKDFHUVHGDxR\VHWLHQHTXH HYLWDU´ ³3RUTXHSXHGHMXJDUHQHOSDWLRGHDUHQDQRSXHGHFRUUHUQRSXHGHMXJDUFRQODSHORWD´ ³3RUTXHQRSXHGHMXJDUDI~WERO\DEiVTXHWSRUTXHVRQMXHJRVTXHVHKDFHQFRQSHORWD´ ³$YHFHVSXHGHMXJDUSRUTXHORVQLxRVTXHMXHJDQFRQpOORSXHGHQD\XGDUDMXJDU´ ³3XHGHQMXJDUDMXHJRVWUDQTXLORVSHURQRUPDOPHQWHDORVGHFRUUHUQRSXHGHQMXJDU´ ³3XHGHMXJDUSHURDMXHJRVTXHQRVHDQPX\PRYLGRV´ ³3XHGHSDUWLFLSDUHQMXHJRVWUDQTXLORV´ ³3RUTXH\RKHLGRFRQODVPXOHWDV\QRSRGtDFRUUHU´ (QHOFDVRGHTXHXQQLxRRXQDQLxDYD\DHQVLOODGHUXHGDVFUHHVTXHSXHGHMXJDUHQHOSDWLRFRQHO UHVWRGHQLxRV\QLxDV"PDUFDFRQXQD;ODUHVSXHVWD 6Ë 12 $9(&(6 6L KDV PDUFDGR 12 R $ 9(&(6 H[SOLFD SRU TXp DOJXQRV QLxRV \ QLxDV QR SXHGHQ SDUWLFLSDU 5(68/7$'26 6Ë 1 12 $9(&(6 (;3/,&$&,21(6 8QFDVRGDH[SOLFDFLyQDO6Ë ³6tSRUTXHHQODFODVHWHQHPRVXQQLxRTXHYDHQVLOODGHUXHGDV\FRJHODSHORWD\ODWLUD3RUHMHPSOR FXDQGRMXJDPRVDSHORWDFD]DGRUDHVWHQLxRTXHVHOODPD;;;ORKDFH´ 5(63(&72$³12´ ³3RUTXHVLORWLUDVDOVXHORVHKDUiPXFKRGDxR´ 5(63(&72$³$9(&(6´ ³3RUTXHQRSXHGHVDOWDURFRUUHU´ ³3RUTXHQRSXHGHMXJDUDI~WEROYROHLEROSLFKL´ ³6LYDVHQVLOODGHUXHGDVSXHGHVMXJDUSRUHMHPSORDODSHRQ]DDSHORWDFD]DGRUDDHQWUHQDUHOHTXLSR GHI~WERO7RGRHVWRORSXHGHKDFHUSHURKD\FRVDVTXHQR´ ³3RUTXHDYHFHVGHSHQGLHQGRGHOMXHJRTXHVHDSXHGHQRQRSXHGHQ´ ³3RUTXHQRSXHGHMXJDUDI~WEROQLDVDOWDU´ ³6LHVXQMXHJRTXHSXHGHKDFHUORORKDFH\VLQRQR´ ³3RUTXHVLMXJDPRVDXQMXHJRGHFRUUHUpOQRSXHGHFRUUHU6LMXJDPRVDXQMXHJRWUDQTXLORVtSXHGH´ ³3RUTXHWLHQHTXHMXJDUDMXHJRVTXHQRWHQJDQTXHKDFHUPXFKRHVIXHU]R´ ³3RUTXHSXHGHMXJDUDMXHJRVWUDQTXLORV´ ³3RUTXHSRUHMHPSORQRVDOWDVQRSXHGHVKDFHUFRVDVHWF´ &20(17$5,26 'HVWDFDTXHVyORVHUHVSRQGH³12´HQRFDVLRQHVHQHOWRWDOGHUHVSXHVWDV(OUHVWRVHUHSDUWHFRQ XQDOLJHUDYHQWDMDGHO³$9(&(6´VREUHHO³6Ë´ (V SRVLEOH TXH GLFKR UHVXOWDGR UHIOHMH SRU XQ ODGR OD HVFRODUL]DFLyQ GH ORV GRV QLxRV REMHWR GHO HVWXGLRGHVGHHOSULQFLSLRGHODHWDSD\SRURWURHOHVIXHU]RGHOSURIHVRUDGRGH(GXFDFLyQ)tVLFDSRU DGDSWDUHQORSRVLEOHODVDFWLYLGDGHV (QHVWHVHQWLGRODSHUFHSFLyQGHODVOLPLWDFLRQHV\FDSDFLGDGHVGHOXVXDULRGHVLOODGHUXHGDVFRPR VXFRPSDxHURHVPXFKRPiVDMXVWDGDTXHUHVSHFWRDOGHPXOHWDV DQH[R (VWXGLRVRFLRPpWULFR LQIRUPHGHOHVWXGLRVRFLRPpWULFR FHQWUR\FHQWUR ,1752'8&&,Ï1 (VWHLQIRUPHHVHOUHVXOWDGRGHOHVWXGLRVRFLRPpWULFRUHDOL]DGRDODVFODVHVGHGHSULPDULDGHORVGRV FHQWURVHVFRODUHVGHUHIHUHQFLD([SRQGUHPRVHQSULPHUOXJDUODVLWXDFLyQJUXSDOVXVUHODFLRQHVtQWHUH LQWUDJUXSDOHVDORODUJRGHOFXUVRPDUFDGDSRUWUHVPRPHQWRVHQHOWLHPSRRFWXEUHGHOIHEUHURGHO \MXQLRGHOPLGLpQGRVHHQGRVVXSXHVWRVFRQFUHWRVFRPSDUWLUMXHJRV\RWUDVWDUHDVPRWULFHV HQODVHVLyQGH(GXFDFLyQ)tVLFD\ODUHDOL]DFLyQGHXQWUDEDMRGHJUXSRHQHODXOD 3DUD FDGD XQD GH HVWDV VLWXDFLRQHV VH SDVy XQ FXHVWLRQDULR FRQ FXDWUR SUHJXQWDV FRQ HO REMHWLYR GH REVHUYDUFXDWURDVSHFWRVGHFDGDLQGLYLGXR (OHFFLRQHVFRPSDxHURV\FRPSDxHUDVFRQORVTXHVHTXLHUHUHDOL]DUODDFWLYLGDG 5HFKD]RVFRPSDxHURV\FRPSDxHUDVFRQTXLpQQRVHTXLHUHUHDOL]DUODDFWLYLGDG 3HUFHSFLyQSRVLWLYDFRPSDxHURV\FRPSDxHUDVTXHFUHHTXHORRODHVFRJHUiQ 3HUFHSFLyQQHJDWLYDFRPSDxHURV\FRPSDxHUDVTXHFUHHTXHORRODUHFKD]DUiQ $ SDUWLU GH ORV UHVXOWDGRV JOREDOHV GHO JUXSRFODVH VH REWHQGUi XQD YLVLyQ SDQRUiPLFD GH ODV LQWHUUHODFLRQHV JUXSDOHV FHQWUiQGRQRV SRVWHULRUPHQWH HQ ORV WUHV DOXPQRV FRQ GLVFDSDFLGDG PRWUL] DQDOL]DQGRHQSURIXQGLGDGVXVLWXDFLyQUHVSHFWRDOUHVWRGHOJUXSRFODVH\VXHYROXFLyQHQHVWHDVSHFWRD ORODUJRGHOHVWXGLR /LVWDGRGHDOXPQRVGHOJUXSRFODVH&(1752 -RDQD ¬QJHOD 7RPjV 0DQHO )UHGHULF ,YiQ 0D\WH -XDQ &DUPH ,VD )UDQFHVF 'HQtV %LELDQD 0DWHR 5REHUW 'jOLD 3DWULFLD 0DUtDVXMHWRGHOHVWXGLRGHFDVR 0RLVpV 6HUJL &RQUDG ,JQDVL /LVWDGRGHDOXPQRVGHOJUXSRFODVH&(1752 -RUGLVXMHWRGHOHVWXGLRGHFDVR 0RQWVH 0DUWD 0LJXHOÈQJHO 0LUHLD 7HUHVD 5RFtR 3HUH /RODVXMHWRGHOHVWXGLRGHFDVR /OXtV 0HUFq /tGLD )UDQFLQD 2OJD 5DIDHO $OXPQRGHQXHYRLQJUHVRHQHOVHJXQGRWULPHVWUHORTXHLPSOLFDTXHQRHVWiUHIOHMDGDVXRSLQLyQHQHOSULPHUR &DWD )HUQDQGD &DUORV <DVRQH )HUUDQ 2ULRO -DQD Ì1',&(662&,20e75,&26*/2%$/(6 &(1752 ËQGLFH $VRFLDFLyQ ËQGLFH 'LVRFLDFLyQ ËQGLFH &RKHUHQFLD ,QWHQVLGDG 6RFLDO ('8&$&,Ð1)Ì6,&$ 2FWXEUH )HEUHUR -XQLR ËQGLFH $VRFLDFLyQ ËQGLFH 'LVRFLDFLyQ ËQGLFH &RKHUHQFLD ,QWHQVLGDG 6RFLDO $8/$ 2FWXEUH )HEUHUR -XQLR (OtQGLFHGHDVRFLDFLyQPXHVWUDXQDWHQGHQFLDDODEXHQDSUHGLVSRVLFLyQSRUSDUWHGHORVDOXPQRVSDUD IRUPDUJUXSRVDODKRUDGHUHDOL]DUDFWLYLGDGHVPRWULFHVRMXHJRVGHQWURGHODFODVHGH(GXFDFLyQ)tVLFD SHVHDTXHHVXQJUXSRTXHVHFRQRFHSRFR(VWDEXHQDSUHGLVSRVLFLyQH[LVWHWDPELpQHQODVLWXDFLyQGH DXODSHURHQPHQRUJUDGR'XUDQWHHOFXUVRHVWHtQGLFHDXPHQWDHQODVLWXDFLyQGH(GXFDFLyQ)tVLFDOR TXHSRQHGHPDQLILHVWRXQPHMRUFRQRFLPLHQWRHQWUHORVDOXPQRV\VHPDQWLHQHHQODVLWXDFLyQGHDXOD ÌQGLFH GH DVRFLDFLyQ 3URSRUFLyQ GH UHFLSURFLGDGHV SRVLWLYDV HQWUH FRPSDxHURV GRV FRPSDxHURV VH HOLJHQ P~WXDPHQWH HQWUHHOWRWDOGHUHFLSURFLGDGHVSRVLWLYDVSRVLEOHV(VWHtQGLFHRVFLODHQWUH\ ÌQGLFH GH GLVRFLDFLyQ 3URSRUFLyQ GH UHFLSURFLGDGHV QHJDWLYDV HQWUH FRPSDxHURV GRV FRPSDxHURV VH UHFKD]DQ P~WXDPHQWHHQWUHHOWRWDOGHUHFLSURFLGDGHVQHJDWLYDVSRVLEOHV(VWHtQGLFHRVFLODHQWUH\ ÌQGLFHGHFRKHUHQFLD3URSRUFLyQGHUHFLSURFLGDGHVSRVLWLYDVHQWUHODVHOHFFLRQHVTXHUHDOPHQWHVHKDQKHFKR(VWHtQGLFH WDPELpQRVFLODGHVGHD ÌQGLFHGHLQWHQVLGDGVRFLDO0HGLDGHHOHFFLRQHV\UHFKD]RVHPLWLGRVSRUFDGDXQRGHORVDOXPQRVGHODFODVH (OtQGLFHGHGLVRFLDFLyQQRHVGHPDVLDGRDOWR\KD\FXDWURDOXPQRVTXHFHQWUDOL]DQEDVWDQWHHOUHFKD]R ,YiQ 5REHUW 0DUtD \ 0RLVpV OR TXH QRV OOHYD D FRQFOXLU TXH ORV DOXPQRV QR VH DJUXSDQ FRQ FRQGXFWDV QHJDWLYDV R FRQ OD ILQDOLGDG GH KDFHU IUDFDVDU ODV DFWLYLGDGHV 6X FRKHVLyQ HV PDQLILHVWDPHQWHPHMRUDEOH (OtQGLFHGHFRKHUHQFLDHVPHGLRGXUDQWHWRGRHOFXUVRFRQXQGHVFHQVRHQHOVHJXQGRWULPHVWUH\VX SRVWHULRUUHFXSHUDFLyQHQHOWHUFHUR(VWHtQGLFHVHLQWHUSUHWDUtDFRPRXQDEXHQDSUHGLVSRVLFLyQSRUSDUWH GH ORV PLHPEURV GHO JUXSR SDUD IRUPDU DXWpQWLFRV JUXSRV HQ OD FODVH GH (GXFDFLyQ )tVLFD (VWD SUHGLVSRVLFLyQH[LVWLUtDWDPELpQHQODVLWXDFLyQGHDXODSHURHQPHQRUJUDGR /DLQWHQVLGDGVRFLDOVHPDQWLHQHDOUHGHGRUGHOGLH]HQORVWUHVWULPHVWUHVEDMDQGRHQHOVHJXQGRMXQWR FRQORVRWURVWUHVIDFWRUHVFRPHQWDGRVDQWHULRUPHQWH\UHFXSHUiQGRVHHQHOWHUFHUR Ì1',&(662&,20e75,&26*/2%$/(6 &(1752 ('8&$&,Ð1)Ì6,&$ ËQGLFH $VRFLDFLyQ ËQGLFH 'LVRFLDFLyQ ËQGLFH &RKHUHQFLD ,QWHQVLGDG 6RFLDO 2FWXEUH 0DU]R -XQLR ËQGLFH $VRFLDFLyQ ËQGLFH 'LVRFLDFLyQ ËQGLFH &RKHUHQFLD ,QWHQVLGDG 6RFLDO $8/$ 2FWXEUH 0DU]R -XQLR (OtQGLFHGHDVRFLDFLyQPXHVWUDXQDEXHQDSUHGLVSRVLFLyQSRUSDUWHGHORVDOXPQRVSDUDIRUPDUJUXSRV SDUDUHDOL]DUDFWLYLGDGHVPRWULFHVRMXHJRVGHQWURGHODFODVHGHHGXFDFLyQItVLFD$SHVDUTXHHOtQGLFH EDMDFRQVLGHUDEOHPHQWHHQODVGRVVLWXDFLRQHVpVWDVHPDQWLHQHVLHPSUHGHQWURGHXQYDORUPHGLR 3XHVWRTXHHOtQGLFHGHGLVRFLDFLyQQRHVGHPDVLDGRDOWR\TXHHOUHFKD]RHVWiEDVWDQWHFHQWUDOL]DGRHQ FXDWURSHUVRQDV0LJXHOÉQJHO<DVRQH)HUUDQ\-DQDSRGHPRVGHFLUTXHHOJUXSR QRVHDJUXSDFRQFRQGXFWDVQHJDWLYDVRSDUD³GHVWUXLU´ODVDFWLYLGDGHV\TXHSRGUtDFRKHVLRQDUVHPiVGH ORTXH\DORHVWi (O tQGLFH GH FRKHUHQFLD HV DOWR DO SULQFLSLR GH FXUVR OR TXH VH LQWHUSUHWDUtD SRVLWLYDPHQWH FRPR XQD SUHGLVSRVLFLyQSRUSDUWHGHORVPLHPEURVGHODFODVHDIRUPDUDXWpQWLFRVJUXSRVGHWUDEDMR3HURGXUDQWH HOFXUVREDMDSDXODWLQDPHQWH /DLQWHQVLGDGVRFLDOVHPDQWLHQHHQWRUQRDOGLH]HQORVWUHVWULPHVWUHVGHVWDFDQGR~QLFDPHQWHHODXPHQWR GHHVWHtQGLFHHQHOVHJXQGRWULPHVWUH\VXSRVWHULRUGHVFHQVRHQHOWHUFHURWDPELpQVHSXHGHREVHUYDU HVWHIHQyPHQRHQHOQ~PHURGHHOHFFLRQHVUHFLELGDVHQODPD\RUtDGHDOXPQRVTXHVHDQDOL]DQGHIRUPD LQGLYLGXDO &(1752 VLWXDFLyQDXOD )LJXUD0DSDVVRFLRPpWULFRVGHODVVLWXDFLRQHVGHODFODVHGH(GXFDFLyQ)tVLFD\ HQHODXODHQFODVHFRUUHVSRQGLHQWHVDODDGPLQLVWUDFLyQGHRFWXEUHGH VLWXDFLyQ(GXFDFLyQ)tVLFD 2&78%5( 1RV HQFRQWUDPRV FRQ XQ JUXSR FODVH TXH VH FRQRFH UHODWLYDPHQWH SRFR FRQ XQRV tQGLFHV GH DVRFLDFLyQ PHGLREDMRV \ SHUR TXH PXHVWUD XQD FLHUWD SUHGLVSRVLFLyQSRUSDUWHGHORVDOXPQRVDIRUPDUJUXSRVHQ(GXFDFLyQ)tVLFDRHQHO DXOD (O JUXSR PDQWLHQH XQD FLHUWD FRKHUHQFLD D OD KRUD GH UHDOL]DU HVWDV HOHFFLRQHV tQGLFHV GH FRKHUHQFLD PHGLRV HQWUH \ (Q JHQHUDO HO JUXSR HV WDQ VyOR VHSDUDEOHFRQHOFULWHULRGHFKLFRVFKLFDVDSHVDUGHTXHH[LVWHQEDVWDQWHVHOHFFLRQHV HQWUH PLHPEURV GH HVWRV GRV VXEJUXSRV +D\ PXFKRV DOXPQRV TXH VH HQFXHQWUDQ VHSDUDGRVGHORTXHVHUtDHOQ~FOHRGHODFODVHPLHPEURVGHODVSRVLFLRQHVFHQWUDOHV GHO VRFLRJUDPD \ HQ ODV SRVLFLRQHV PiV SHULIpULFDV FRPR VH SXHGH REVHUYDU HQ OD ILJXUD /RV FKLFRV PiV QXPHURVRV TXH ODV FKLFDV GHQWUR GHO JUXSRFODVH WLHQHQ XQD FODUD GLVWULEXFLyQ HQWUH PLHPEURVLQWHJUDGRV\PLHPEURVSHULIpULFRV(QWUHORVLQWHJUDGRV\HQSRVLFLyQGHOtGHUHVHQFRQWUDPRV D 7RPjV 0DQHO )UHGHULF -XDQ )UDQFHVF \ 6HUJL WDQWR HQ OD VLWXDFLyQ GH (GXFDFLyQ)tVLFDFRPRHQODGHDXOD(QWUHHOORVIRUPDQXQJUXSRUHODWLYDPHQWHFRPSDFWRFRQEDVWDQWHV UHFLSURFLGDGHV H[FHSWXDQGR 7RPjV TXH SDUHFH HVWDU IXHUD GH HVWH JUXSR R SRU OR PHQRV SDUFLDOPHQWHUHFLELHQGRPXFKDVHOHFFLRQHVGHFKLFDV (QHORWURH[WUHPRHQFRQWUDPRVD,YiQUHFKD]DGRSRUFDVLWRGDODFODVH\UHFKD]RV\FRQ WDQ VROR XQD UHFLSURFLGDG SRVLWLYD FRQ 6HUJL HQ OD VLWXDFLyQ GH (GXFDFLyQ )tVLFD 7DPELpQ HQFRQWUDPRVD'HQtV0DWHR\0RLVpVIRUPDQGRXQWUtRFRQUHFLSURFLGDGHVSRVLWLYDVHQWUH HOORV \ TXH QR UHFLEHQ DSHQDV HOHFFLRQHV GHO H[WHULRU 5REHUW WDPELpQ FRQVLGHUDGR UHFKD]DGR PDQWLHQH UHFLSURFLGDGHV SRVLWLYDV FRQ GRV PLHPEURV GHO Q~FOHR GHO JUXSR GH ORV FKLFRV -XDQ \ )UHGHULF HQ ODV GRV VLWXDFLRQHV \ &RQUDG TXH WDPELpQ HV UHFKD]DGR PDQWLHQH UHFLSURFLGDG SRVLWLYDFRQGRVFKLFDV,VD\%LELDQD $SHVDUGHTXHUHVXOWDGLItFLOH[SOLFDUHOSRUTXpGHHVWDVLWXDFLyQGHWDQWRVPLHPEURV HQ HO FHQWUR \ WDQWRV HQ OD SHULIHULD OODPD OD DWHQFLyQ TXH PXFKRV GH ORV PLHPEURV PiV HVFRJLGRV VRQ FRPSDxHURV GH FODVH GHVGH (GXFDFLyQ ,QIDQWLO 3RGHPRV GHGXFLU (QHVWHHVWXGLRFRQVLGHUDPRVOtGHUHVDDTXHOORVDOXPQRVTXHKDQUHFLELGRHOHFFLRQHVSRUSDUWHGHPiVGHXQWHUFLRGHVXV FRPSDxHURVGHFODVH 5HFLSURFLWDG(OHFFLyQRUHFKD]RP~WXRHQWUHGRVLQGLYLGXRV&XDQGRVHWUDWDGHHOHFFLRQHVVHOODPDUHFLSURFLGDGSRVLWLYD &XDQGRORTXHHVPXWXRHVHOUHFKD]RKDEODUHPRVGHUHFLSURFLGDGQHJDWLYD 5HFKD]DGRD6XMHWRVTXHUHFLEHQXQDJUDQFDQWLGDGGHUHFKD]RVSRUSDUWHGHOUHVWRGHODFODVH TXHH[LVWHXQQ~FOHRQXPHURVRGHDOXPQRVTXHVHFRQR]FDQGHKDFHPXFKRVDxRV\ EDVWDQWHVPLHPEURVQXHYRVTXHD~QQRKDQHQFRQWUDGRVXOXJDU $GHPiVREVHUYDPRVTXHKD\GRVFKLFDVPHMRUFRQVLGHUDGDVTXHHOUHVWR0D\WH\3DWULFLDWDQWR HQ OD VLWXDFLyQ GH (GXFDFLyQ )tVLFD FRPR HQ OD GH DXOD (Q XQ VHJXQGR SODQR WHQHPRV D ­QJHOD &DUPH\%LELDQD3RGUtDPRVFRQVLGHUDUODSRVLELOLGDGGHLQFOXLUHQHVWHVXEJUXSRD'jOLD SXHVWRTXHVHHQFXHQWUDHQXQDSRVLFLyQLQWHUPHGLDHQODVHVLyQGH(GXFDFLyQ)tVLFDSHURQRDVtHQHO DXODGRQGHRFXSDSRVLFLRQHVPiVDOHMDGDVGHOFHQWUR )LQDOPHQWHHQXQDSRVLFLyQPiVVHSDUDGDHQFRQWUDPRVD-RDQD,VD\0DUtDTXHRFXSDQ ODVSRVLFLRQHVPiVSHULIpULFDVHQODVGRVVLWXDFLRQHV&RQVLGHUDGDVLJQRUDGDVHQODVLWXDFLyQGHDXOD -RDQD\0DUtDWDPELpQORHVWiQHQODVLWXDFLyQGH(GXFDFLyQ)tVLFD (O JUXSR VH GLVWULEX\H GH IRUPD PiV KHWHURJpQHD TXH HO GH ORV FKLFRV SHUR HV XQ JUXSRGLVSHUVRFRQSRFDVUHFLSURFLGDGHVSRVLWLYDV\SRFDVHOHFFLRQHV (Q ORV GRV JUXSRV WDPELpQ GHVWDFDU HO JUDQ Q~PHUR GH RSRVLFLRQHV GH VHQWLPLHQWRV FHQWUDGRV HQ DOJXQRVPLHPEURVFRQFUHWRVGHOJUXSR,YiQ0DUtD\&RQUDGTXHSXHGHGHQRWDUXQDIDOWD GHFRQRFLPLHQWRGHORVFRPSDxHURV\XQDYLVLyQSRFRUHDOLVWDGHVXSRVLFLyQDQWHHOJUXSR ,JQRUDGRD (O VXMHWR TXH HVFRJH D RWURV FRPSDxHURV HQ XQD FDQWLGDG PHGLD SHUR TXH DSHQDV UHFLEH HOHFFLRQHV QL WDPSRFRPXFKRVUHFKD]RV 2SRVLFLyQGHVHQWLPHQWRV6HWUDWDGHXQDUHODFLyQHQWUHGRVVXMHWRVGRQGHXQRHVFRJHDORWUR\HVWHVHJXQGRORUHFKD]D 3XHGHVHUGHELGRDGLYHUVRVPRWLYRVHOTXHUHFKD]DVHDSURYHFKDGHOTXHHVFRJHXQDYLVLyQSRFRUHDOLVWDGHOTXHHVFRJH« SHURVLHPSUHVRQGHVWDFDEOHVSRUTXHPXHVWUDQXQDVLWXDFLyQSRFRQDWXUDO VLWXDFLyQDXOD )LJXUD0DSDVVRFLRPpWULFRVUHVXOWDQWHVGHODDGPLQLVWUDFLyQGHIHEUHURGH VLWXDFLyQ(GXFDFLyQ)tVLFD )(%5(52 (OJUXSRFODVHFRQWLQ~DFRQRFLpQGRVHUHODWLYDPHQWHSRFRtQGLFHVGHDVRFLDFLyQ\EDMRV\ ODFRKHUHQFLDGHVXVHOHFFLRQHVGHFUHFHOHYHPHQWHtQGLFHVPHGLRVGHFRKHUHQFLDHQWUH\ 6LQRVILMDPRVHQHOJUiILFRHQFRQWUDPRVXQJUXSRPXFKRPiVGLVWULEXLGRTXHHQHOSULPHUWULPHVWUH GRQGH WHQtDPRV PXFKRV LQGLYLGXRV HQ OD SDUWH FHQWUDO \ PXFKRV HQ OD SHULIHULD GLIHUHQFLD PX\ PDUFDGDVREUHWRGRHQODVLWXDFLyQGHDXOD3DUHFHVHUTXHDOJXQRVVXMHWRVHPSLH]DQDVHUDFHSWDGRV SRUHOUHVWRGHODFODVHRFRPRPtQLPRSRUXQDSDUWHGHHOOD (Q FXDQWR D ORV FKLFRV FRQWLQ~DQ VLHQGR PXFKR PiV QXPHURVRV GHQWUR GHO JUXSRFODVH WLHQHQ XQ QXHYR PLHPEUR ,JQDVL 5HGXFHQ VX Q~PHUR GH OtGHUHV D WUHV 7RPjV TXH FRQWLQ~D UHFLELHQGRPXFKDVHOHFFLRQHVGHODVFKLFDV\0DQHO\)UDQFHVFTXHVHVLW~DQHQOD]RQD FHQWUDO HQ ODV GRV VLWXDFLRQHV 7DPELpQ KD\ TXH GHVWDFDU TXH 3HUH HV OtGHU GHO JUXSR HQ (GXFDFLyQ )tVLFD \ VH HQFXHQWUD HQ XQD EXHQD VLWXDFLyQ HQ HO DXOD VHJXQGR FtUFXOR FRQ VLHWH HOHFFLRQHVUHFLELGDV &RPSOHWDQHOJUXSR)UHGHULF5REHUW\6HUJL(VWH~OWLPRVHHQFXHQWUDFRPROtGHUHQOD VLWXDFLyQGH(GXFDFLyQ)tVLFD\RFXSDXQDSRVLFLyQLQWHUPHGLDHQODGHDXOD&RPRPLHPEURVPiV H[WHULRUHV WHQHPRV D ,YiQ UHFKD]DGR HQ ODV GRV VLWXDFLRQHV SRU PiV GH OD PLWDG GH OD FODVH 'HQtV 0DWHR 0RLVpV &RQUDG \ ,JQDVL HVWH ~OWLPR LJQRUDGR HQ ODV GRV VLWXDFLRQHVKHFKRQRUPDOVLFRQVLGHUDPRVTXHHVWRWDOPHQWHQXHYRHQODFODVH 8Q DVSHFWR D GHVWDFDU GH OD RUJDQL]DFLyQ GH HVWH VXEJUXSR GH ORV FKLFRV HV TXH HQWUH ORV PHQRV HVFRJLGRVSRUHOUHVWRVHHPSLH]DQDIRUPDUSHTXHxRVJUXSRVSRUHMHPSOR'HQtV0DWHR\ 0RLVpVTXHIRUPDQXQWUtRPiVRPHQRVELHQDYHQLGR (QODVFKLFDVGHVWDFD0D\WHFRPR~QLFDTXHHVWiHQXQDVLWXDFLyQGHOtGHUWDQWRHQODVHVLyQGH (GXFDFLyQ )tVLFD FRPR HQ HO DXOD (Q OD SULPHUD VLWXDFLyQ GHVWDFD WDPELpQ %LELDQD HQ XQD EXHQDSRVLFLyQWDPELpQHQODVLWXDFLyQGHDXOD­QJHODHVOtGHUHQODVLWXDFLyQGHDXODHVWDQGR HQXQDSRVLFLyQLQWHUPHGLDHQ(GXFDFLyQ)tVLFD &RPSOHWDQHOJUXSR-RDQDTXHHVWDIXHUDGHORVFtUFXORVHQODVLWXDFLyQGHDXOD,VDIXHUDGH ORVFtUFXORVHQODVLWXDFLyQGH(GXFDFLyQ)tVLFD\WDPELpQ'jOLD\3DWULFLDpVWD~OWLPDHQOD PLVPDVLWXDFLyQTXH-RDQD &RPR PiV DSDUWDGDV WHQHPRV D &DUPH \ D 0DUtD TXH VH HQFXHQWUDQ VHSDUDGDV GHO VXEJUXSRGHODVFKLFDVHQODVGRVVLWXDFLRQHV$XQTXHWLHQHQSDUWLFXODULGDGHVGLVWLQWDV0LHQWUDVTXH &DUPH DSHQDV UHFLEH HOHFFLRQHV R UHFKD]RV 0DUtD UHFLEH DOJXQD HOHFFLyQ PiV SHUR HVWi EDVWDQWH PiV UHFKD]DGD UHFKD]RV HQ OD VLWXDFLyQ GH DXOD PiV GH XQD FXDUWD SDUWH SRU WUHV UHFKD]RVHQODVLWXDFLyQGH(GXFDFLyQ)tVLFD (O VXEJUXSR FRQWLQ~D GLVSHUVR FRQ DOJXQDV UHFLSURFLGDGHV SRVLWLYDV \ EDVWDQWHV HOHFFLRQHV VREUHWRGRHQWUHORVPLHPEURVFHQWUDOHVGHOVXEJUXSR &RQWLQ~DQ H[LVWLHQGR PXFKDV RSRVLFLRQHV GH VHQWLPLHQWRV TXL]iV PiV GLVSHUVDV TXH HQ HO SULPHU WULPHVWUHSHURPLHPEURVFRPR,YiQ0DWHRR5REHUWFRQWLQ~DQREWHQLHQGRPXFKDV HQWUH ODV GRV VLWXDFLRQHV FRQVLGHUDPRV TXH SXHGHQ VHU SRU VXV UHVSXHVWDV PLHPEURV SRFR UHDOLVWDVFRQODVSHUVRQDVTXHORVURGHDQHLQFOXVRSXHGHQOOHJDUDGLVWRUVLRQDUDOUHVWRGHOJUXSR (QODDGPLQLVWUDFLyQGHOWHVWVRFLRPpWULFRGHFRQWUROORVUHVXOWDGRVKDQVLGRPX\SDUHFLGRVDORV\D REWHQLGRV HQ HO WHVW VRFLRPpWULFR TXH DFDEDPRV GH DQDOL]DU FRQ DOJXQDV GLIHUHQFLDV TXH FUHHPRV FRQYHQLHQWHUHPDUFDU (QSULPHUOXJDU/RVtQGLFHVGHDVRFLDFLyQ\GLVRFLDFLyQVRQPiVDOWRVTXHHQHOWHVWVRFLRPpWULFR VWDQGDUG$GHPiVGHWHQHUHQFXHQWDTXHDKRUDWRGRVYDORUDQDWRGRV\SRUWDQWRHVQRUPDOTXH H[LVWDXQDXPHQWRHQHOQ~PHURGHHOHFFLRQHV\UHFKD]RV\PiVSRVLELOLGDGHVGHUHFLSURFLGDGHV SRVLWLYDVRQHJDWLYDVGDODVHQVDFLyQGHTXHHVWHJUXSRVHFRQRFHPHMRUGHORTXHSDUHFH\TXH VXVPLHPEURVVRQPiVFRQVFLHQWHVGHODUHDOLGDGGHOJUXSRFODVHGHORTXHVHPXHVWUDHQHOWHVW VRFLRPpWULFRVWDQGDUG (QVHJXQGROXJDUORVUHFKD]RVTXHUHFLEH0DUtDHQODSUXHEDGHFRQWUROHQODVLWXDFLyQGH HGXFDFLyQItVLFDVRQEDVWDQWHPiVDOWRVTXHHQODDGPLQLVWUDFLyQGHOWHVWVRFLRPpWULFRDQDOL]DGR DQWHULRUPHQWH (Q OD VLWXDFLyQ HQ HO DXOD WLHQH XQRV QLYHOHV SDUHFLGRV HQWUH ODV GRV SUXHEDV 3XHVWR TXH HQ OD SUXHED GH FRQWURO ORV DOXPQRV QR HUDQ WDQ FRQVFLHQWHV GH FXDQGR HVWDEDQ HPLWLHQGR HOHFFLRQHV R UHFKD]RV WXYLHURQ PiV OLEHUWDG SDUD UHFKD]DU D 0DUtD TXH HQ OD SUXHEDVWDQGDUG )LQDOPHQWHVXFHGHDOJRSDUHFLGRFRQ,JQDVLHQODVLWXDFLyQGHDXOD7HQLHQGRHQFXHQWDTXH HVQXHYDLQJUHVRGHHVWHWULPHVWUHSRGHPRVKDEODUTXHHQODSUXHEDGHFRQWUROVHOHUHFKD]DPiV FODUDPHQWHPLHQWUDVTXHHQODVWDQGDUGHOJUXSRVHFRKtEHDOHPLWLUHOUHFKD]RSXHVQRHVWiELHQ YLVWR UHFKD]DU DO QXHYR WDQ VROR SRU VHUOR (Q OD VLWXDFLyQ GH HGXFDFLyQ ItVLFD VX VLWXDFLyQ HUD SDUHFLGDHQODVGRVSUXHEDV VLWXDFLyQDXOD )LJXUD0DSDVVRFLRPpWULFRVUHVXOWDQWHVGHODDGPLQLVWUDFLyQHQHOPHVGHMXQLRGH VLWXDFLyQ(GXFDFLyQ)tVLFD -81,2 (O JUXSRFODVH VH FRQRFH PiV TXH DO LQLFLR GHO FXUVR SXHV VXV tQGLFHV GH DVRFLDFLyQ D SHVDU GH FRQWLQXDUVLHQGREDMRV\SDUDODVVLWXDFLRQHVGH(GXFDFLyQ)tVLFD\DXODUHVSHFWLYDPHQWH VRQ VLJQLILFDWLYDPHQWH PiV DOWRV TXH HQ HO SULPHU WULPHVWUH /D FRKHUHQFLD GH ODV HOHFFLRQHV UHDOL]DGDVSRUORVDOXPQRVVRQPHGLDV\'HVWDFDTXHODGLVWULEXFLyQHVSRFRKRPRJpQHD HQWUH ORV PLHPEURV GHO JUXSR SXHV OD PD\RUtD VH HQFXHQWUDQ HQ ORV GRV FtUFXORV PiV FHQWUDOHV \ EDVWDQWHV HVWiQ HQ OD SHULIHULD (QWUH ORV PLHPEURV FHQWUDOHV H[LVWHQ PXFKDV UHFLSURFLGDGHV \ HOHFFLRQHV SRVLWLYDV PLHQWUDV TXH ORV PiV DSDUWDGRV UHFLEHQ PXFKDV RSRVLFLRQHV GH VHQWLPLHQWRV VREUHWRGRORVFKLFRV (QORTXHDORVFKLFRVVHUHILHUHHOJUXSRHVWiDEVROXWDPHQWHGLYLGLGRHQGRV(OSULPHURHVWiIRUPDGR SRU 7RPjVOtGHUWDQWRHQODVLWXDFLyQGH(GXFDFLyQ)tVLFDFRPRHQODGHDXOD\~QLFRTXHPDQWLHQH UHFLSURFLGDGHVSRVLWLYDVFRQPLHPEURVGHOVXEJUXSRGHODVFKLFDV 0DQHOOtGHUHQ(GXFDFLyQ)tVLFD )UHGHULF6HUJL3HUH\)UDQFHVFOtGHUHVHQODVGRVVLWXDFLRQHV 5REHUWVHSDUDGRGHOJUXSRHQODVLWXDFLyQGHDXODSHUROtGHUHQ(GXFDFLyQ)tVLFD &RQUDGTXHHQHOSULPHUWULPHVWUHHUDUHFKD]DGR\HQHOVHJXQGRHVWDEDVHSDUDGRGHOJUXSRHQ ODVLWXDFLyQGHDXOD (QWUH HOORV KD\ PXFKDV UHFLSURFLGDGHV SRVLWLYDV VREUHWRGR HQ OD VLWXDFLyQ GH (GXFDFLyQ )tVLFD \ WDPELpQPXFKDVHOHFFLRQHV 0iVVHSDUDGRVGHOJUXSRDQWHULRUHVWiQ,YiQTXHFRQWLQ~DVLHQGRHOPiVUHFKD]DGRSRUSDUWHGHO JUXSRFODVH'HQtV0DWHR0RLVpV\,JQDVL/RVFLQFRHVWiQVHSDUDGRVGHOUHVWR GHORVFKLFRVHQODVGRVVLWXDFLRQHVDSHQDVUHFLEHQHOHFFLRQHV\DFXPXODQPXFKDVRSRVLFLRQHVGH VHQWLPLHQWRV GHO JUXSR +DQ FUHDGR GRV SHTXHxDV DJUXSDFLRQHV HQWUH HOORV XQD SDUHMD ,YiQ \ ,JQDVL\XQWUtR'HQtV0DWHR\0RLVpV 3RURWURODGRODVFKLFDVIRUPDQXQQ~FOHRFHQWUDOFRQ­QJHOD0D\WH~QLFDFKLFDOtGHUHQODV GRVVLWXDFLRQHV,VDPXFKRPiVYDORUDGDHQHODXODTXHHQ(GXFDFLyQ)tVLFD%LELDQD\ 'jOLD(QWUHHOODVH[LVWHQEDVWDQWHVUHFLSURFLGDGHVSRVLWLYDVVREUHWRGRFHQWUDGDVHQ0D\WH DVtFRPREDVWDQWHVHOHFFLRQHVSRVLWLYDVHQWUHHOODV (Q OD VLWXDFLyQ GH (GXFDFLyQ )tVLFD WDPELpQ IRUPD SDUWH GH HVWH VXEJUXSR 0DUtD SHUR HQ OD VLWXDFLyQ GH DXOD VH HQFXHQWUD PiV DSDUWDGD GHO JUXSR DVt FRPR -RDQD &DUPH \ 3DWULFLD WDQ VyOR VHSDUDGD HQ OD VLWXDFLyQ GH DXOD 7RGDV PDQWLHQHQ DOJXQD UHFLSURFLGDG SRVLWLYD FRQ DOJ~QPLHPEURPiVFHQWUDOGHOJUXSRH[FHSWR-RDQD\0DUtDHVWDQGR-RDQDHVSHFLDOPHQWH UHFKD]DGDSRUHOJUXSR /D VLWXDFLyQ H[FHSWR DOJXQRV FDVRV LQGLYLGXDOHV FRQWLQ~D VLHQGR PX\ SDUHFLGD D ORV DQWHULRUHV WULPHVWUHV8QJUXSRQXPHURVRHQODSDUWHFHQWUDOGHOVRFLRJUDPDTXHDFXPXODQODPD\RUSDUWHGHODV HOHFFLRQHVSRVLWLYDVUHFLELGDV\XQVHJXQGRJUXSRGHLQGLYLGXRVIXHUDGHORVFtUFXORVFRQFpQWULFRVGHO VRFLRJUDPDHQVLWXDFLyQGHPDUJLQDFLyQGHQWURGHOJUXSRFODVH &RQUHVSHFWRDODSUXHEDGHFRQWUROODVGLIHUHQFLDVVLJXHQVLHQGRSRFDVGHVWDFDQGR 5HFLEHQ PiV UHFKD]RV HQ OD SUXHED GH FRQWURO TXH HQ OD VWDQGDUG &DUPH ,VD (Q ODV GRV VLWXDFLRQHV\3DWUtFLDHQODVLWXDFLyQGHHGXFDFLyQItVLFD /DVLWXDFLyQGH,JQDVLVLJXHVLHQGRODPLVPD\DOLJXDOTXH0RLVpVUHFLEHPiVUHFKD]RV HQODSUXHEDGHFRQWUROTXHHQODVWDQGDUGHQODVLWXDFLyQGHDXOD(QFDPELRHQ0DUtD\DQR H[LVWHQGLIHUHQFLDVVLJQLILFDWLYDV VLWXDFLyQDXOD \DXODFRUUHVSRQGLHQWHVDODDGPLQLVWUDFLyQGHOPHVGHRFWXEUHGH )LJXUD0DSDVVRFLRPpWULFRVGHODVVLWXDFLRQHVGHODFODVHGH(GXFDFLyQ)tVLFD VLWXDFLyQ(GXFDFLyQ)tVLFD &(1752 2FWXEUH 3RGHPRVKDEODUGHXQJUXSRTXHDXQTXHWLHQHEXHQDSUHGLVSRVLFLyQSDUDHOORD~QQRVHFRQRFHPX\ ELHQ tQGLFH GH DVRFLDFLyQ L HV GHFLU EDMRV GRQGH H[LVWH XQD JUDQ SURSRUFLyQ GH UHFLSURFLGDGHV SRVLWLYDV tQGLFHV GH FRKHUHQFLD \ DOWRV \ ORV VXEJUXSRV TXH FRQIRUPDQ HO JUXSRFODVHHVWiQPX\ELHQGHOLPLWDGRV(OJUXSRHVPX\VLPLODUWDQWRHQODVHVLyQGH(GXFDFLyQ)tVLFD FRPRHQODGHODXODIRUPDQGRHQORVGRVFDVRVWUHVVXEJUXSRVFRQFDUDFWHUtVWLFDVPX\VLPLODUHVHQFDGD XQDGHODVGRVVLWXDFLRQHV /D SULPHUD VHSDUDFLyQ TXH GHEH UHDOL]DUVH HV OD GH FKLFRVFKLFDV ([LVWHQ PX\ SRFDV HOHFFLRQHV HQWUH FKLFRV\FKLFDV\PXFKRVUHFKD]RVPX\FRP~QHQODHGDGTXHWLHQHQHVWRVDOXPQRV/RVFKLFRVIRUPDQ HQWUHHOORVXQVRORVXEJUXSRPLHQWUDVTXHODVFKLFDVIRUPDQGRVFRQFDUDFWHUtVWLFDVPX\GLIHUHQFLDGDV (QODVLWXDFLyQGHODFODVHGH(GXFDFLyQ)tVLFDHOVXEJUXSRGHORVFKLFRVHVWiIRUPDGRSRU3HUHOtGHU /OXtV5DIDHO&DUORV)HUUDQ\2ULRO(QWUHHOORVH[LVWHQPXFKDVUHFLSURFLGDGHV SRVLWLYDVFRQHOHFFLRQHVSRVLWLYDVHQWUHVXVPLHPEURV8QSRFRPiVVHSDUDGRHQFRQWUDPRVD-RUGL TXHWDQVyORUHFLEHODHOHFFLyQGH3HUH\D0LJXHOÉQJHOTXHPDQWLHQHUHFLSURFLGDGSRVLWLYDFRQ GRVFKLFDV (QODVLWXDFLyQGHDXODHVWRVGRVFKLFRVPiVVHSDUDGRVGHOUHVWRHVWiQGHQWURGHOJUXSRVRQGHORVTXH UHFLEHQPHQRVHOHFFLRQHVSHURVHSXHGHFRQVLGHUDUTXHHVWiQGHQWURGHOJUXSRGHORVFKLFRV(VWROOHYD DODFRQFOXVLyQTXHWDQWR-RUGLFRPR0LJXHOÉQJHOHVWiQPHMRUFRQVLGHUDGRVSRUVXVFRPSDxHURV HQODVLWXDFLyQGHDXODTXHHQODGH(GXFDFLyQ)tVLFDDSHVDUGHTXH0LJXHOÉQJHOHVWiUHFKD]DGRSRU SDUWHGHOJUXSR (QUHIHUHQFLDDODVFKLFDVKHPRVFRQVLGHUDGRRSRUWXQRUHDOL]DUXQDGLYLVLyQHQGRVVXEJUXSRVVXEJUXSR \VXEJUXSRSXHVWRTXHH[LVWtDXQUHGXFLGRJUXSRGHFKLFDVFRQFDUDFWHUtVWLFDVGLVWLQWDVDOUHVWR (QODVLWXDFLyQGHODVHVLyQGH(GXFDFLyQ)tVLFDHOVXEJUXSRGHODVFKLFDVHVWiFRPSXHVWR0LUHLD\ 2OJDOtGHUHVDVtFRPRSRU7HUHVD/ROD0HUFq)HUQDQGD\-DQD(OJUXSRD SHVDUGHVHUEDVWDQWHFRPSDFWRSUHVHQWDDOJXQRVUHFKD]RVPiVHQWUHVXVPLHPEURVDVtFRPRDOJXQDV RSRVLFLRQHV GH VHQWLPLHQWRV 0HUFq0LUHLD -DQD0HUFq \ 0LUHLD-DQD (VWD VLWXDFLyQ QR HV QDWXUDO \ SXHGHVHUXQIRFRSUREOHPiWLFRGHQWURGHOJUXSR7DPELpQH[LVWHXQKHFKRFXULRVRQRUHFLEHQQLQJXQD HOHFFLyQSRUSDUWHGHORVFKLFRVGHODFODVHDVtFRPRWDPSRFRUHDOL]DQQLQJXQDHOHFFLyQSRVLWLYDKDFLD HOORV 6HSDUDGDV GH HVWH JUXSR HQFRQWUDPRV D 5RFtR FRQVLGHUDGD FRPR LJQRUDGD DSHQDV UHFLEH XQD HOHFFLyQ\WDPSRFRHVUHFKD]DGD\D<DVRQHFRQVLGHUDGDFRPRUHFKD]DGD (QODVLWXDFLyQGHDXODH[LVWHQXQSDUGHYDULDFLRQHVTXHFRQYLHQHUHPDUFDU(QSULPHUOXJDU7HUHVD HV FRQVLGHUDGD OtGHU (Q VHJXQGR OXJDU 5RFtR HQWUD GHQWUR GHO JUXSR TXHGiQGRVH PiV VHSDUDGD -DQDFRQVLGHUDGDUHFKD]DGDDVtFRPR<DVRQHTXHHVWiUHFKD]DGDHQDPEDVVLWXDFLRQHV(Q WHUFHUOXJDUILQDOPHQWHGHVDSDUHFHQODVRSRVLFLRQHVGHVHQWLPLHQWRVHQWUH0LUHLD0HUFq\-DQD /RVUHFKD]RVHQWUHHOODVVHGDQWDQVRORHQODVLWXDFLyQGHODVHVLyQGH(GXFDFLyQ)tVLFD 3RUORTXHVHUHILHUHDOVXEJUXSRGHODVFKLFDVpVWHHVWiIRUPDGRSRU0RQWVH0DUWD/tGLD )UDQFLQD\&DWD(QODVLWXDFLyQGHDXODVLQHPEDUJR)UDQFLQDVHHQFXHQWUDLJQRUDGDSRU HOUHVWRGHOJUXSRUHFLELHQGR~QLFDPHQWHODHOHFFLyQGH0RQWVH(VWHJUXSRHVPHQRVFRPSDFWRTXH ORVRWURVGRV\HQODVLWXDFLyQGH(GXFDFLyQ)tVLFDWLHQHGRVRSRVLFLRQHVGHVHQWLPLHQWRVFRQFUHWDGDVHQ &DWDTXHUHFLEHHOUHFKD]RGHGRVGHODVFRPSDxHUDVDODVTXHHVFRJH0RQWVH\)UDQFLQD (QODGHDXODH[LVWHXQDRSRVLFLyQGHVHQWLPLHQWRVHQWUH/tGLD\)UDQFLQD(VWHVXEJUXSRUHFLEH \HQYtDHOHFFLRQHVDORVRWURVVXEJUXSRVTXHFRQILJXUDQODFODVHH[LVWLHQGRLQFOXVRDOJXQDUHFLSURFLGDG SRVLWLYD 0$5=2 )LJXUD0DSDVVRFLRPpWULFRVUHVXOWDQWHVGHOD DGPLQLVWUDFLyQGHOPHVGHPDU]RGHO VLWXDFLyQ(GXFDFLyQ)tVLFD VLWXDFLyQDXOD (OJUXSRSUHVHQWDDOJXQRVFDPELRVLQWHUJUXSDOHVUHVSHFWRDODSULPHUDDGPLQLVWUDFLyQSULQFLSDOPHQWHHQ HOVXEJUXSRGHODVFKLFDVPLHQWUDVTXHWDPELpQH[LVWHXQDYDULDFLyQLQWUDJUXSDOPX\LPSRUWDQWHHQOD SRVLFLyQ TXH RFXSD HO VXEJUXSR GH ODV FKLFDV FRQ UHVSHFWR DO UHVWR GH OD FODVH $ SHVDU GH HOOR ORV tQGLFHVJOREDOHVDSHQDVYDUtDQGLVPLQX\HVHQVLEOHPHQWHHOtQGLFHGHFRKHUHQFLDTXHSDVDGHVHUDOWRD PHGLR (QORTXHVHUHILHUHDORVFKLFRVFRQYLHQHUHPDUFDUTXHHOJUXSRHVPiVKHWHURJpQHRHQODVLWXDFLyQGH (GXFDFLyQ )tVLFD TXH HQ OD GH DXOD 6LJXHQ H[LVWLHQGR XQ JUDQ Q~PHUR GH UHFLSURFLGDGHV \ HOHFFLRQHV SRVLWLYDVSHURWDPELpQDXPHQWDQODVRSRVLFLRQHV GH VHQWLPLHQWRV PX\ SHUVRQDOL]DGDV HQ &DUORV TXHHVSURWDJRQLVWDGHGRVHQODVLWXDFLyQGH(GXFDFLyQ)tVLFD\GHRWUDVGRVHQODGHDXOD(OKHFKRGH TXHXQDVRODSHUVRQDVHDSURWDJRQLVWDGHWDQWDVRSRVLFLRQHVGHVHQWLPLHQWRVSXHGHVLJQLILFDUTXHQRHV PX\ FRQVFLHQWH GH OD UHDOLGDG TXH OH URGHD \ ORV FRPSDxHURV SXHGHQ DSURYHFKDUVH GH pO R pO GH VXV FRPSDxHURVHQIXQFLyQGHFDGDFDVR (Q OD VLWXDFLyQ GH (GXFDFLyQ )tVLFD -RUGL \ 0LJXHO ÉQJHO VLJXHQ IXHUD GHO JUXSR D SHVDU TXH -RUGL UHFLEH FXDWUR HOHFFLRQHV OR TXH VXSRQH XQ DXPHQWR FRQVLGHUDEOH HQ FRPSDUDFLyQ FRQ HO SULPHU WULPHVWUH(QODVLWXDFLyQGHDXOD )HUUDQ VH TXHGD DSDUWDGRGHOJUXSRMXQWRFRQ-RUGL\0LJXHO ÉQJHOFRQWDQVRORWUHVHOHFFLRQHVUHFLELGDV (O VXEJUXSR GH ODV FKLFDV SUHVHQWD XQ FDPELR PX\ LPSRUWDQWH SURYRFDGR SRU OD ULYDOLGDG HQWUH )HUQDQGD\-DQD(VWDULYDOLGDGSURYRFDHOSRVLFLRQDPLHQWRGHOUHVWRGHPLHPEURVGHOVXEJUXSR KDFLDXQRXRWURODGRORTXHUHSHUFXWHHQPXFKRVFRQIOLFWRV\ODGLVJUHJDFLyQGHOJUXSR$SHVDUGHTXH D~QH[LVWHQPXFKDVUHFLSURFLGDGHVHOSULPHUVtQWRPDFRQTXHQRVHQFRQWUDPRVHVTXHODVGRVOtGHUHVHQ HOSULPHUWULPHVWUH0LUHLDL2OJD\DQRVHHVFRJHQ$GHPiV2OJDSLHUGHVXHVWDWXVGHOtGHUHQOD VLWXDFLyQGH(GXFDFLyQ)tVLFDVLHQGRVXVWLWXLGDSRU0LUHLD\7HUHVD 'RQGHUHFLEtDWDQVRORGRVODPLWDGTXHHQHVWHVHJXQGRWULPHVWUH (QVHJXQGROXJDUHQODVLWXDFLyQGHDXOD)HUQDQGDHVFRJHD2OJDSRUTXH³PHFDHPX\ELHQ´\2OJDOD UHFKD]D GHWHFWiQGRVH OD RSRVLFLyQ GH VHQWLPLHQWRV SRUTXH ³)HUQDQGD QR FRQItD HQ Pt´ )HUQDQGD UHFKD]DD0LUHLDSRUTXH³+DFHYHUTXHHVPLDPLJDSHURQRORHV2OJDPHORGLMR´ <DVRQHHVFRJHGLUHFWDPHQWHD-DQD\QRHVFRJHQLD0LUHLDQLD2OJD7DQWR<DVRQHFRPR -DQDTXHGDQVHSDUDGDVGHOJUXSRHQODVGRVVLWXDFLRQHVGHODPLVPDIRUPDTXH)HUQDQGDSLHUGHPXFKR HVWDWXVVRFLDOFRQHOFRQIOLFWR\FRPLHQ]DDDSXQWDUDOVXEJUXSRGHODVFKLFDVFRQHOHFFLRQHVGLULJLGDV DVXVFLQFRPLHPEURVHQODVGRVVLWXDFLRQHV 7HUHVDHVWiFODUDPHQWHGHSDUWHGH-DQDGDGRTXHODHVFRJHDOWLHPSRTXHUHFKD]DHQSULPHUOXJDU D )HUQDQGD (VFRJH D 2OJD SHUR D 0LUHLD VyOR OD HVFRJH HQ OD VLWXDFLyQ GH (GXFDFLyQ )tVLFD UHFRUGHPRVTXH0LUHLDVHPRVWUDEDSDUWLGDULDGH)HUQDQGD (OUHVWRGHOVXEJUXSRQRWHUPLQDGHGHILQLUVH5RFtR/ROD\0HUFqHVFRJHQWDQWRD0LUHLD FRPR D 2OJD (Q FXDQWR D /ROD FRPHQWDU TXH HVWi VHSDUDGD GHO JUXSR HQ OD VLWXDFLyQ GH (GXFDFLyQ )tVLFDUHFLELHQGRSRFDVHOHFFLRQHV\WDQVRORXQUHFKD]RHVGHFLUTXHQRHVWHQLGDHQFXHQWDDODKRUD GHUHDOL]DUJUXSRVSDUDMXJDU (QUHVXPHQH[LVWHXQHQIUHQWDPLHQWRHQWUHGRVPLHPEURVGHOVXEJUXSRTXHHVWiSURYRFDQGRXQDUXSWXUD WRWDOHQWRGDVXHVWUXFWXUD+D\SDUWLGDULDVGHORVGRVEDQGRV\DOJXQDVD~QQRKDQGHILQLGRVXSRVWXUD )LQDOPHQWHHOVXEJUXSRGHODVFKLFDVYDUtDHVSHFWDFXODUPHQWHVXHVWDWXVDQWHHOUHVWRGHOJUXSR3DVDQ GH VHU XQ VXEJUXSR GHVSOD]DGR GHO JUDQ JUXSR GH ODV FKLFDV D SRVHHU D FXDWUR GH ORV PLHPEURV PiV HVFRJLGRVSRUWRGDODFODVH 0DUWD /tGLD \ &DWD VRQ OtGHUHV WDQWR HQ (GXFDFLyQ )tVLFD FRPR HQ HO DXOD PLHQWUDV TXH 0RQWVH HV OtGHU HQ OD VLWXDFLyQ GH (GXFDFLyQ )tVLFD 6RQ HO ~QLFR VXEJUXSR TXH PDQWLHQH UHFLSURFLGDGHVSRVLWLYDVFRQPLHPEURVGHORVRWURVVXEJUXSRV\GHHOODVVHYDORUDVXVLPSDWtDHOEXHQ WUDWRKDFLDORVGHPiVVXEXHQUHQGLPLHQWRHQORVGHSRUWHVVREUHWRGRHQORVFDVRVGH0RQWVH\0DUWD\ HOVHUWUDEDMDGRUDV (O JUXSR PDQWLHQH XQD DOWD SURSRUFLyQ GH UHFLSURFLGDGHV \ HOHFFLRQHV SRVLWLYDV SHUR )UDQFLQD VH HQFXHQWUDPiVDSDUWDGD'HOVXEJUXSRGHODVFKLFDVWDQVRORUHFLEHODHOHFFLyQGH0RQWVHHQDPEDV VLWXDFLRQHV\ODGH0DUWDHQODVLWXDFLyQGH(GXFDFLyQ)tVLFD &RQ UHVSHFWR D OD SUXHED GH FRQWURO ODV SRVLFLRQHV GH OtGHUHV \ UHFKD]DGRV TXHGDQ SOHQDPHQWH FRQWUDVWDGDV$SHVDUGHHOORVXUJHQGRVGLIHUHQFLDVTXHFRQYLHQHUHVDOWDU /D FDQWLGDG GH HOHFFLRQHV TXH UHFLEH /ROD HV VXSHULRU HQ OD SUXHED GH FRQWURO D OD SUXHED VWDQGDUG WDQWR HQ OD VLWXDFLyQ GH HGXFDFLyQ ItVLFD FRPR HQ OD GH DXOD $ SHVDU GH HVWR FRQYLHQH FRPSUREDUVLHQODWHUFHUDDGPLQLVWUDFLyQFRQWLQ~DH[LVWLHQGRHVWDVLWXDFLyQSXHVHQWRQFHVSRGUtDQ VDFDUVHFRQFOXVLRQHV\QRVHUDOJRFDVXDORSDVDMHUR /D PLVPD VLWXDFLyQ WLHQH )HUQDQGD SXHV UHFLEH PiV HOHFFLRQHV HQ ODV GRV VLWXDFLRQHV HQ OD SUXHEDGHFRQWUROTXHHQODVWDQGDUG6LDHVWRDxDGLPRVTXHODVLWXDFLyQGH)HUQDQGDHVXQWDQWR HVSHFLDOSRUVXUHODFLyQFRQ-DQDSXHGHTXHH[LVWDXQDSUHVLyQHQHVWHVXEJUXSRSRUSDUWHGH DOJXQR GH VXV PLHPEURV -DQD TXL]iV SDUD TXH )HUQDQGD QR VHD HVFRJLGD GH PDQHUD TXH VXV FRPSDxHUDVQRODHVFRJHQFRQFODULGDGSHURODYDORUDQPX\SRVLWLYDPHQWH -81,2 VLWXDFLyQDXOD )LJXUD0DSDVVRFLRPpWULFRVUHVXOWDQWHVGHODDGPLQLVWUDFLyQGHOPHVGHMXQLRGH VLWXDFLyQ(GXFDFLyQ)tVLFD 3RGUtDPRVDILUPDUTXHHOJUXSRHVWiSDVDQGRGHILQLWLYDPHQWHSRUXQDHWDSDGHFDPELRDSHVDUGHTXHHQ HVWDVHGDGHVVHVXHOHQSURGXFLUFDPELRVSXHVORVtQGLFHVGHDVRFLDFLyQ\FRKHUHQFLDVRQPHQRUHVTXH HQ ODV RWUDV GRV DGPLQLVWUDFLRQHV 1R VH WUDWD GH TXH VH FRQR]FDQ PHQRV TXH DQWHV VLQR TXH DQWH HO FDPELRDOJXQRVVXMHWRVQHFHVLWDQUHFRORFDUVHGHQWURGHODQXHYDHVWUXFWXUDGHOJUXSR /RVFKLFRVFRQWLQ~DQIRUPDQGRXQJUXSRFRQPXFKDVHOHFFLRQHVUHFtSURFDVFHQWUDGDVSULQFLSDOPHQWHHQ 3HUH/OXtV5DIDHO\&DUORVTXHVHHVFRJHQPXWXDPHQWHDH[FHSFLyQGHODRSRVLFLyQ GH VHQWLPLHQWRV HQWUH /OXtV \ &DUORV GRQGH &DUORV HVFRJH D /OXtV SRUTXH OR FRQVLGHUD ³DPLJR VX\R´ SHUR/OXtVORUHFKD]DSRU³PROHVWDUPXFKR´/RVFKLFRVPHMRUFRQVLGHUDGRVHQHODXODTXHHQ(GXFDFLyQ )tVLFD SRU HO UHVWR GH VXEJUXSRV VRQ XQD FODUD PLQRUtD GHQWUR GHO DXOD GH IRUPD TXH FXDQGR GHEHQ HVFRJHUFRPSDxHURVHVFRJHQDORVSRFRVPLHPEURVTXHIRUPDQVXSURSLRVXEJUXSR $SDUWDGRVGHQWURGHHVWHVXEJUXSRVHHQFXHQWUDQHQODVLWXDFLyQGH(GXFDFLyQ)tVLFD-RUGLTXHVt VHHQFXHQWUDGHQWURGHOVXEJUXSRHQODVLWXDFLyQGHDXOD0LJXHOÉQJHOPX\UHFKD]DGRHQDPEDV VLWXDFLRQHV )HUUDQ TXH SLHUGH PXFKDV GH ODV HOHFFLRQHV TXH UHFLEtD HQ ORV GRV WULPHVWUHV DQWHULRUHV\2ULROTXHHQODVLWXDFLyQGHDXODVtTXHVHHQFXHQWUDDFHSWDGRGHQWURGHOVXEJUXSR VLHQGRXQRGHORVTXHPiVHOHFFLRQHVUHFLEHGHWRGRHOJUXSRFODVH(QODVLWXDFLyQGHDXODVHHQFXHQWUD WDPELpQDSDUWDGR&DUORVUHFLELHQGRDSHQDVHOHFFLRQHVRUHFKD]RVLJQRUDGR (OVXEJUXSRGHODVFKLFDVFRQWLQ~DQVXSURFHVRGHFDPELRLQWHUQRGHOTXHSXHGHDSUHFLDUVHDOJXQDV FRQVHFXHQFLDVHQHVWDWHUFHUDDGPLQLVWUDFLyQ(QSULPHUOXJDU)HUQDQGDVHHQFXHQWUDIXHUDGHHVWH VXEJUXSRGHODVFKLFDV\IRUPDSDUWHGHOVXEJUXSR(QVHJXQGROXJDUODVGLIHUHQFLDVHQWUHODVLWXDFLyQ GH(GXFDFLyQ)tVLFD\ODGHDXODUHVSHFWRDOUHVWRGHOJUXSRFODVHVRQPiVTXHQRWDEOHVHQODVLWXDFLyQ GH DXOD QLQJXQR GH VXV PLHPEURV UHFLEH PiV GH FLQFR HOHFFLRQHV SRVLWLYDV PLHQWUDV TXH HQ OD GH (GXFDFLyQ )tVLFD VH GLVWULEX\H HO JUXSR GH IRUPD SDUHFLGD D ODV DQWHULRUHV DGPLQLVWUDFLRQHV (Q WHUFHU OXJDUODPD\RUtDGHPLHPEURVHVFRJHD0LUHLD\2OJDOtGHUHQODVLWXDFLyQGH(GXFDFLyQ)tVLFD DSHVDUGHTXHHQWUHHOODVQRKD\HOHFFLyQSRVLWLYDDOJXQD (Q OD VLWXDFLyQ GH (GXFDFLyQ )tVLFD SRGHPRV FRQVLGHUDU PiV DSDUWDGDV D /ROD TXH FRQWLQ~D VLQ FRQWDU GHPDVLDGR D OD KRUD GH KDFHU JUXSRV SDUD MXJDU <DVRQH OD PiV UHFKD]DGD GH OD FODVH \ -DQD 2WURDVSHFWRDWHQHUHQFXHQWDHVTXHHPSLH]DQDKDEHUDOJXQDVHOHFFLRQHV\UHFLSURFLGDGHVSRVLWLYDV HQWUHHVWHVXEJUXSR\ORVFKLFRVORTXHSXHGHPRVWUDUXQLQLFLRGHPDGXUDFLyQHQWUHORVGRVVXEJUXSRV 3RGHPRVLQWHUSUHWDUTXHODVDOLGDGH)HUQDQGDGHHVWHVXEJUXSRKDFRQWULEXLGRDVXHVWDELOL]DFLyQ 3RURWURODGRHOVHJXQGRVXEJUXSRGHODVFKLFDVWLHQHDKRUDXQPLHPEURGHPiVDSHVDUGHTXHD~Q HVWi DSDUWDGD GHO VXEJUXSR HQ ODV GRV VLWXDFLRQHV 8Q LPSHGLPHQWR TXH SXHGH HQFRQWUDUVH )HUQDQGD D VXDFHUFDPLHQWRDHVWHVXEJUXSRHVODUHFLSURFLGDGQHJDWLYDTXHPDQWLHQHFRQ0RQWVH/DV GRVUHFRQRFHQTXHVHSHOHDQ\VHLQVXOWDQDSHVDUGHTXHHQQLQJ~QPRPHQWRGHOFXHVWLRQDULRH[SOLFDQ ORVPRWLYRV (O UHVWR GHO JUXSR FRQWLQXD PDQWHQLHQGR PXFKDV VLPLOLWXGHV FRQ OR DQDOL]DGR HQ OD DGPLQLVWUDFLyQ GH IHEUHURGH/tGLD\&DWDVRQOtGHUHVWDQWRHQ(GXFDFLyQ)tVLFDFRPRHQHODXOD\0DUWD ORHVHQHVWD~OWLPD0LHQWUDVTXHHQODVLWXDFLyQGH(GXFDFLyQ)tVLFDWRGRHOVXEJUXSRHVWiPX\MXQWRHQ XQD]RQDGHOVRFLRJUDPDHQODGHDXODWDQWR0RQWVHFRPR)UDQFLQDHVWiQDSDUWDGDVGHOUHVWR GHOVXEJUXSR)UDQFLQDYXHOYHDHVWDULJQRUDGDSRUHOUHVWRGHOJUXSRFODVH (OJUXSRFRQWLQ~DPDQWHQLHQGRUHFLSURFLGDGHVSRVLWLYDVFRQPLHPEURVGHORVRWURVGRVVXEJUXSRV\VXV PLHPEURVVRQHQJHQHUDOGHORVPiVHVFRJLGRVSRUHOUHVWRGHODFODVH 6L WHQHPRV HQ FXHQWD OD DGPLQLVWUDFLyQ GHO WHVW GH FRQWURO SRGUHPRV FRPSUREDU TXH QXHYDPHQWH ODV GLIHUHQFLDVVRQPtQLPDVHQVXVtQGLFHVJOREDOHVHLQGLYLGXDOHVVLHQGRpVWDVODV~QLFDVGLIHUHQFLDVDWHQHU HQFXHQWD (QODVLWXDFLyQGHHGXFDFLyQItVLFD/RODUHFLEHPiVHOHFFLRQHVHQODSUXHEDGHFRQWUROTXHHQOD SUXHEDVWDQGDUG$SHVDUGHHVWDUELHQYDORUDGDKDVWDSHUVRQDVRSLQDQTXHOHVJXVWDUtDPXFKRR HQRUPHPHQWHIRUPDUJUXSRFRQHOOD HQ OD FODVH GHHGXFDFLyQItVLFDOXHJRQRHVHVFRJLGDSRUVXV FRPSDxHURVWDQVROR&DWDODHOLJHSDUDVXJUXSR (Q OD VLWXDFLyQ GH DXOD KDVWD WUHV SHUVRQDV WLHQHQ OD PLVPD VLWXDFLyQ TXH /ROD HQ HGXFDFLyQ ItVLFD7DQWR)UDQFLQDFRPR)HUQDQGD\&DUORVUHFLEHQPXFKDVPiVHOHFFLRQHVHQOD SUXHEDGHFRQWUROTXHHQODVWDQGDUG'HVWDFDUTXH)HUQDQGD\DHVWDEDHQXQDSRVLFLyQSDUHFLGDHQ HOSULPHUWULPHVWUH\SXGLHUDVHUTXHHVWXYLHUDPX\ELHQYDORUDGDSRUPLHPEURVGHOVXEJUXSRGHODV FKLFDVKDVWDSHUVRQDVTXHOXHJRQRVHDWUHYHUtDQDHVFRJHUODSDUDVXJUXSRWDQVyORODHVFRJHQ SHUVRQDV '$726<$1É/,6,6,1',9,'8$/(6 (Q HVWH DSDUWDGR VH OOHYDUi D FDER XQ DQiOLVLV GH ORV WUHV FDVRV REMHWR GH HVWXGLR GH DOJXQDV GH VXV FDUDFWHUtVWLFDV\GHODHYROXFLyQGHVXVLWXDFLyQGHQWURGHOFRQWH[WRGHOJUXSRFODVH3DUDGHVDUUROODUHVWH DSDUWDGRQRVEDVDUHPRVSULQFLSDOPHQWHHQWUHVDVSHFWRV ËQGLFHV VRFLRPpWULFRV LQGLYLGXDOHV HOHFFLRQHV UHFLELGDV UHFKD]RV UHFLELGRV \ HVWDWXV VRFLRPpWULFR HQ WUHV PRPHQWRV D OR ODUJR GHO FXUVR HVFRODU RFWXEUH IHEUHURPDU]R\MXQLR 6RFLRJUDPDLQGLYLGXDOHQFDGDXQRGHHVWRVWUHVPRPHQWRVMXQWRDORVGDWRVLQGLYLGXDOHVGHFDGD VXMHWR &XDGURUHVXPHQGHORVtQGLFHVVRFLRPpWULFRVGHFDGDXQRGHHOORV\FRPHQWDULRJHQHUDO (VWDWXVVRFLRPpWULFR3RVLFLyQUHODWLYDGHXQVXMHWRHQUHODFLyQDOUHVWRGHOJUXSR6XYDORUYDUtDHQWUH\± &(17520$5Ì$ $ ÌQGLFHVVRFLRPpWULFRVLQGLYLGXDOHV (3(OHFFLRQHV3RVLWLYDV5HFLELGDV (1(OHFFLRQHV1HJDWLYDV5HFLELGDV (6 (VWDWXV 6RFLRPpWULFR HQ SDUpQWHVLV HO RUGHQ TXH RFXSD HQ OD FODVH VHJ~Q ORV UHVXOWDGRVGHHVWHtQGLFH ('8&$&,Ð1)Ì6,&$ 2FWXEUH )HEUHUR $8/$ -XQLR 2FWXEUH )HEUHUR -XQLR (3 (3 (1 (1 (6 (6 (QODVLWXDFLyQGHHGXFDFLyQItVLFDPHMRUDFODUDPHQWH0DUtDHVPiVDFHSWDGDDPHGLGDTXHSDVDHO FXUVR\HOFODURUHFKD]RTXHUHFLEtDDSULQFLSLRGHFXUVRVHGLVLSDKDVWDUHFLELURSRUWULPHVWUH6X HVWDWXVVRFLRPpWULFRPHMRUDFODUDPHQWHSDVDQGRGHVHUFODUDPHQWHQHJDWLYRDEDVWDQWHSRVLWLYR (VWD VLWXDFLyQ SHUR QR VH YH UHIOHMDGD HQ OD VLWXDFLyQ GH DXOD GRQGH D SHVDU GH UHFLELU DOJXQDV HOHFFLRQHV PiV TXH DO SULQFLSLR GHO FXUVR XQD PiV FDGD WULPHVWUH TXH SDVD WDPELpQ DXPHQWD ORV UHFKD]RV UHFLELGRV 3HUR SRGUtDPRV DILUPDU TXH 0DUtD HV WHQLGD FDGD YH] PiV HQ FXHQWD SRU VXV FRPSDxHURVWDQWRHQHODVSHFWRSRVLWLYRSDUDMXJDUPHGLDQWHMXHJRVDGDSWDGRVHQODHGXFDFLyQItVLFD FRPRHQHOQHJDWLYRHQHODXODGRQGHVXFDUiFWHUOHLPSLGHVHUDFHSWDGDFRPSOHWDPHQWHSRUHOUHVWRGH VXVFRPSDxHURV 6RFLRJUDPDV\GDWRVLQGLYLGXDOHV 2&78%5( ('8&$&,Ð1)Ì6,&$ 0$5,$ )LJVRFLRJUDPDLQGLYLGXDOGH0DUtDHQODVLWXDFLyQ GHFODVHGHHGXFDFLyQItVLFDFRUUHVSRQGLHQWHDODDGPLQLVWUDFLyQGHRFWXEUHGH ,1',&(662&,20(75,&26,1',9,'8$/(6'(0$5Ë$ 67$78662&,20(75,&2 66 &RQH[LyQ$IHFWLYD &$ 3RSXODULGDG 3RS $QWLSDWtD $QW ([SDQVLYLGDG ([SS ([SDQVLYLGDG([SQ $WHQFLyQSHUFHSWLYD $US $WHQFLyQSHUFHS$SQ 5HDOLVPRSHUFHSWLYR 53S 5HDOLVPRSHUFHS5SQ 0DUtD WLHQH XQ VWDWXV VRFLRPpWULFR PX\ EDMR FRQ XQ ± RFXSD HO DQWHSHQ~OWLPR OXJDU HQ OD FODVH GHELGRHQJUDQSDUWHDTXHHVXQDGHODVSHUVRQDVPiVUHFKD]DGDVGHODFODVH\VyORHVHVFRJLGDSRU XQDFRPSDxHUD%LELDQD3XHVWRTXH0DUtDQRHVFRJHD%LELDQDVLQRTXHODUHFKD]DVXFRQH[LyQ DIHFWLYDYLQFXODFLyQDIHFWLYDFRQDTXHOORVFRQTXHVHUHODFLRQDHVGH (YLGHQWHPHQWHDOUHFLELUWDQVRORXQDHOHFFLyQVXSRSXODULGDGHVPX\EDMDPLHQWUDVTXHJHQHUD XQD DOWD DQWLSDWtD HQ VXV FRPSDxHURV PX\ DOWR FRQ QXHYH UHFKD]RV UHFLELGRV &XULRVDPHQWH 0DUtD HV OD ~QLFD SHUVRQD TXH HPLWH FXDWUR UHFKD]RV HQ WRGD OD FODVH HPLWLHQGR HO UHVWR FLQFR H[SDQVLYLGDG QHJDWLYD PLHQWUDV TXH HQ FXDQWR D HPLVLRQHV SRVLWLYDV KDFH FLQFR H[SDQVLYLGDG SRVLWLYD 'H ODV FLQFR HOHFFLRQHV TXH HOOD HVSHUD UHFLELU QR UHFLEH QLQJXQD DWHQFLyQ SHUFHSWLYD SRVLWLYD \ UHDOLVPRSHUFHSWLYRSRVLWLYRUHVXOWDGRVPX\EDMRV'HORVUHFKD]RVTXHHVSHUDVRQDFHUWDGRV UHDOLVPR SHUFHSWLYR QHJDWLYR DOWR SHUR HQ UHDOLGDG UHFLEH QXHYH DWHQFLyQ SHUFHSWLYD QHJDWLYD DOJREDMR 6LJXLHQGRODVDSRUWDFLRQHVGH*RQ]DOH]$OYDUH]-SVHHQWLHQGHSRU &21(;,Ï1$)(&7,9$LQGLFDODSURSRUFLyQGHHOHFLRQHVUHFLELGDVSRUHOVXMHWRTXHpOFRUUHVSRQGH 3238/$5,'$'tQGLFHREWHQLGRDSDUWLUGHODVHOHFFLRQHVSRVLWLYDVUHFLELGDV $17,3$7Ë$tQGLFHREWHQLGRDSDUWLUGHORVUHFKD]RVUHFLELGRV (;3$16,9,'$'326,7,9$LQGLFDODSURSRUFLyQGHFRPSDxHURVTXHVRQHOHJLGRVSRUHOVXMHWR (;3$16,9,'$'1(*$7,9$LQGLFDODSURSRUFLyQGHFRPSDxHURVTXHVRQUHFKD]DGRVSRUHOVXMHWR $7(1&,Ï13(5&(37,9$326,7,9$LQGLFDODSURSRUFLyQTXHGHWRGDVODVHOHFFLRQHVUHFLELGDVFRUUHVSRQGHQDODVSUHYLVWDV LQLFDOPHQWHSRUHOVXMHWR $7(1&,Ï13(5&(37,9$1(*$7,9$LQGLFDODSURSRUFLyQTXHGHWRGRVORVUHFKD]RVUHFLELGRVFRUUHVSRQGHQDORVSUHYLVWRV LQLFDOPHQWHSRUHOVXMHWR 5($/,602 3(5&(37,92 326,7,92 LQGLFD OD SRUSRUFLyQ GH SHUFHSFLRQHV SRVLWLYDV TXH HVSHUD HO VXMHWR \ DTXHOODV TXH HIHFWLYDPHQWHDFLHUWD 5($/,602 3(5&(37,92 1(*$7,92 LQGLFDODSRUSRUFLyQGHSHUFHSFLRQHVQHJDWLYDVTXHHVSHUDHOVXMHWR\DTXHOODVTXH HIHFWLYDPHQWHDFLHUWD 6LREVHUYDPRVODILJXUDYHPRVTXH0DUtDHPLWHHOHFFLRQHVDFKLFRV\DFKLFDV'HHVWDVFLQFR HOHFFLRQHV WUHV VRQ RSRVLFLRQHV GH VHQWLPLHQWRV FRQ ÉQJHOD 0D\WH \ 6HUJL $GHPiV 0DUtDHVUHFKD]DGDSRUQXHYHSHUVRQDVWRGDVHOODVPX\GLVSDUHV\SHUWHQHFLHQWHVDGLVWLQWRVVXEJUXSRV \GHGLYHUVRVWDWXVVRFLDO(VWRQRVGDDHQWHQGHUTXHHVUHFKD]DGDSRUJUDQSDUWHGHODFODVHHQJHQHUDO \QRVyORSRUXQVXEJUXSRHQFRQFUHWR7UHVGHHVWRVUHFKD]RVVRQFRUUHVSRQGLGRVSRU0DUtDPLHQWUDV TXHRWURVWUHVHUDQRSRVLFLRQHVGHVHQWLPLHQWRVDQWHULRUPHQWHFRPHQWDGDV /D~QLFDHOHFFLyQTXHUHFLEHHVUHFKD]DGDGHPDQHUDTXH0DUtDPLVPDVHFLHUUDOD~QLFDSXHUWDTXHHQ HVWHPRPHQWRSDUHFHTXHWLHQHDELHUWDSDUDUHODFLRQDUVHFRQHOUHVWRGHODFODVH'DODVHQVDFLyQTXHQR TXLHUHVHUSDUWHGHOJUXSR (QUHVXPHQSRGHPRVKDEODUGH0DUtDFRPRXQDGHODVSHUVRQDVPiVUHFKD]DGDV\PHQRVHVFRJLGDV GHOJUXSR\SRUORWDQWRFRQXQRGHORVVWDWXVVRFLRPpWULFRVPiVEDMRV7DPELpQGHVWDFDQHQHOODXQJUDQ Q~PHURGHRSRVLFLRQHVGHVHQWLPLHQWRVHQORVGRVVHQWLGRVWDQWRDORVTXHHOLJHFRPRDOD~QLFDTXHOD HVFRJHGDQGRXQDJUDQLPSUHVLyQGHIDOWDGHDWHQFLyQ\UHDOLVPRFRQORVRWURVPLHPEURVGHODFODVH VREUHWRGRHQHODVSHFWRSRVLWLYR $8/$ 0$5Ì$ )LJ6RFLRJUDPDLQGLYLGXDOGH0DUtDHQODVLWXDFLyQ GHDXODFRUUHVSRQGLHQWHDODDGPLQLVWUDFLyQGHRFWXEUHGHO ,1',&(662&,20(75,&26'(0$5Ë$ 67$78662&,20(75,&266 &RQH[LyQDIHFWLYD &$ 3RSXODULGDG3RS $QWLSDWtD $QW ([SDQVLYLGDG ([SS ([SDQVLYLGDG([SQ $WHQFLyQSHUFHS $3S $WHQFLyQSHUFHS$3Q 5HDOLVPRSHUFHS 53S 5HDOLVPRSHUFHS53Q 0DUtDRFXSDHOOXJDUQ~PHURGHHQHO6WDWXV6RFLRPpWULFRXQOXJDUPX\EDMRGHQWURGHODFODVH FRQ XQ ± TXH FRQFXHUGD FRQ VX VLWXDFLyQ HQ OD SHULIHULD GHO JUiILFR GH OD ILJXUD (Q FDPELR VX FRQH[LyQDIHFWLYDHVGHORPiVDOWDSRVLEOHSHURFRPRHVIUXWRGHTXHFRUUHVSRQGHOD~QLFDHOHFFLyQ TXHUHFLEHQRTXHUHPRVWHQHUODGHPDVLDGRHQFXHQWDDXQTXHODYDORUDPRVSRVLWLYD 7LHQH XQD PX\ EDMD SRSXODULGDG FRQ HOHFFLyQ \ JHQHUD PD\RU DQWLSDWtD FRQ FXDWUR UHFKD]RV TXH QR VLPSDWtD 3XHVWR TXH QR DFLHUWD OD ~QLFD HOHFFLyQ TXH UHFLEH WDQWR VX DWHQFLyQ SHUFHSWLYDSRVLWLYDFRPRVXUHDOLVPRSHUFHSWLYRSRVLWLYRHVFHURDSHVDUGHTXHHOODHVSHUDUHFLELUWUHV HOHFFLRQHV(QFDPELRVtDFLHUWDXQUHFKD]RGHORVFXDWURTXHHVSHUDUHFLELUHOGH%LELDQDSRUOR TXHVXDWHQFLyQSHUFHSWLYDQHJDWLYDHVGHEDVWDQWHEDMR'HODPLVPDIRUPDUHFLEHFXDWURUHFKD]RV \DFLHUWDHO\DFRPHQWDGRDQWHULRUPHQWH\VXUHDOLVPRSHUFHSWLYRQHJDWLYRHVGHWDPELpQ 6LREVHUYDPRVHOVRFLRJUDPDLQGLYLGXDOGHODILJXUDSRGUHPRVHQFRQWUDUTXHSUHGRPLQDQORVUHFKD]RV HQWRUQRD0DUtDHPLWLHQGRGRVDFKLFRV5REHUW\,YiQ\DWUHVFKLFDVÉQJHOD,VD \'jOLD/RVUHFKD]RVTXHUHFLEHSURYLHQHQGHWUHVFKLFRVGLVWLQWRVDORVTXHUHFKD]D0RLVpV )UHGHULF\0DQHO\GHXQDFKLFD%LELDQDFRQODTXHPDQWLHQHXQDPiVTXHFXULRVD UHODFLyQSXHVWRTXHQRHVWDQVyORTXHH[LVWDXQDRSRVLFLyQGHVHQWLPLHQWRVFRQHOOD0DUtDHOLJHD %LELDQD\pVWDODUHFKD]DVLQRTXHHQODVLWXDFLyQGHODFODVHGHHGXFDFLyQItVLFDODRSRVLFLyQGH VHQWLPLHQWRVHVDODLQYHUVD%LELDQDHOLJHD0DUtD\0DUtDODUHFKD]D6LQFHUDPHQWHQRVKDVLGRPX\ GLItFLOHQFRQWUDUXQDH[SOLFDFLyQOyJLFDDHVWDUHODFLyQTXHQRVHDODIDOWDGHUHDOLVPRSRUSDUWHGH0DUtD\ ODFRQIXVLyQJHQHUDOTXHH[LVWHHQWRGRHOJUXSRFODVH 7DPELpQGHVWDFDUTXH0DUtDHPLWHFXDWURHOHFFLRQHVPiVGRVDFKLFRV'HQtV\7RPjV\GRV PiVDPLHPEURVGHOVXEJUXSRGHODVFKLFDVHQFRQFUHWRDVXVOtGHUHV0D\WH\3DWUtFLDFRQOD TXHH[LVWHXQDUHFLSURFLGDGSRVLWLYDGpELO\HVOD~QLFDHOHFFLyQTXHUHFLEH (Q UHVXPHQ SRGHPRV KDEODU GH 0DUtD FRPR DOJXLHQ TXH FDVL QR HV HOHJLGD SHUR WDPSRFR HV H[FHVLYDPHQWH UHFKD]DGD D SHVDUGH TXH RFXSD XQR GH ORV OXJDUHV PiV EDMRV GHO VWDWXV VRFLRPpWULFR GHQWURGHODFODVH'HVWDFDSRUVXSRFDSHUFHSFLyQGHODUHDOLGDGTXHODURGHD\VXSRFDDWHQFLyQKDFLD HOOD OR TXH OD FRQIXQGH HQ VXV HOHFFLRQHV \ VXV UHFKD]RV \ WDPELpQ D DTXHOORV TXH OD HOLJHQ R OD UHFKD]DQ 6HHQWLHQGHSRUUHFLSURFLGDGGpELODTXHOODFRQXQDLQWHQVLGDGSUHIHUHQFLDOPHQRUGHPDQHUDTXHODVXPDGHODVGRV SXQWXDFLRQHV\DVHDHOFDVRGHHOHFFLRQHVRGHUHFKD]RVHVLQIHULRUD(QWHQGHPRVTXHH[LVWHXQDUHFLSURFLGDGIXHUWH FXDQGRODVXPDHVLJXDORVXSHULRUD )(%5(52 ('8&$&,Ð1)Ì6,&$ )LJ6RFLRJUDPDLQGLYLGXDOGH0DUtDHQODVLWXDFLyQGHODFODVHGH(GXFDFLyQ)tVLFD FRUUHVSRQGLHQWHDODDGPLQLVWUDFLyQGHIHEUHURGH ,1',&(662&,20(75,&26'(0$5Ë$ 67$78662&,20(75,&266 &RQH[LyQDIHFWLYD &$ 3RSXODULGDG 3RS $QWLSDWtD $QW ([SDQVLYLGDG ([SS ([SDQVLYLGDG([SQ $WHQFLyQSHUFHS $3S $WHQFLyQSHUFHS$3Q 5HDOLVPRSHUFHS 53S 5HDOLVPRSHUFHS53Q /DVLWXDFLyQGH0DUtDH[SHULPHQWDXQDPHMRUDGXUDQWHHOVHJXQGRWULPHVWUHSXHVUHFLEHPiVHOHFFLRQHV SRSXODULGDGSRUGHODDQWHULRUDGPLQLVWUDFLyQ\HVFDSD]GHPDQWHQHUXQDFRQH[LyQDIHFWLYD FRQ WRGDV DTXHOODV SHUVRQDV TXH OD HOLJHQ $GHPiV JHQHUD PHQRU DQWLSDWtD SRU GHO SULPHU WULPHVWUH GH PDQHUD TXH SRGHPRV KDEODU GH TXH SDUHFH TXH VH HVWi LQWHJUDQGR HQ HO JUXSR HQ HVWD VLWXDFLyQ GH HGXFDFLyQ ItVLFD 2WUR DVSHFWR TXH UHIXHU]D HVWH SHQVDPLHQWR HV TXH VX H[SDQVLYLGDG KD DXPHQWDGRGHVGHHOSULPHUWULPHVWUHDKRUDHOLJH\UHFKD]DDPiVSHUVRQDVORTXHGDXQDVHQVDFLyQGH PD\RUFRQRFLPLHQWRGHOJUXSRSRUVXSDUWH )LQDOPHQWHUHVSHFWRDORVtQGLFHVVRFLRPpWULFRVLQGLYLGXDOHVGH0DUtDGHVWDFDUTXHHVXQDSHUVRQDPiV DWHQWD DFLHUWD XQ SRUFHQWDMH PiV DOWR GH HOHFFLRQHV R UHFKD]RV UHFLELGRV SHUR PHQRV UHDOLVWD HVWRV DFLHUWRV FRQVWLWX\HQ XQD SURSRUFLyQ PHQRU GH ORV TXH HOOD HVSHUDED HQ UHODFLyQ FRQ OD SULPHUD DGPLQLVWUDFLyQ(PSLH]DSXHVDDGTXLULUKDELOLGDGHVTXHOHSHUPLWHQDGLYLQDUDTXpFRPSDxHURVDVOHV FDHELHQRPDOSHURVLJXHVLHQGRXQWDQWRIDQWDVLRVDHQVXVH[SHFWDWLYDV $O REVHUYDU ORV JUiILFRV GH OD ILJXUD SRGHPRV GDUQRV FXHQWD TXH 0DUtD HPLWH HOHFFLRQHV D FKLFRV0DQHO0RLVpV\,JQDVL\DFKLFDV­QJHOD%LELDQD\3DWUtFLD&RQ WUHVGHHOORVIRUPDUHFLSURFLGDGSRVLWLYD0RLVpV%LELDQD\3DWUtFLDSHURQRVTXHGDUHPRVFRQHOFDVR GH %LELDQD SDUD HMHPSOLILFDU OD HYROXFLyQ GH 0DUtD HQ HO SHUtRGR GH WLHPSR WUDQVFXUULGR HQWUH OD SULPHUD\ODVHJXQGDDGPLQLVWUDFLyQ (QODSULPHUDDGPLQLVWUDFLyQ%LELDQDHUDOD~QLFDTXHHVFRJtDD0DUtDSHURpVWDTXHQRGHPRVWUDED XQD YROXQWDG SRU LQWHJUDUVH HQ HO JUXSR QR WDQ VyOR KDFtD FDVR RPLVR VLQR TXH DGHPiV OD UHFKD]DED $KRUDKDELHQGRJDQDGRHQHVWUDWHJLDVVRFLDOHVSDUDSHUFLELUODVLQWHQFLRQHVGHORVGHPiVVHGDFXHQWD GHODVGH%LELDQD\OHFRUUHVSRQGHFRQXQDUHFLSURFLGDG 0DUtDHPLWHWDPELpQUHFKD]RVUHSDUWLGRVHQSDUDFKLFDV&DUPH,VD\'jOLD\SDUD FKLFRV)UHGHULF0DWHR\5REHUW7DQVyORHOGH0DWHRHVFRUUHVSRQGLGRQHJDWLYDPHQWH\ UHFLEH WDPELpQUHFKD]RVGH-XDQ \ )UDQFHVF 1R H[LVWHQLQJXQDRSRVLFLyQGHVHQWLPLHQWRVHQ HVWDDGPLQLVWUDFLyQ 'LVWLQWRVVRQORVPRWLYRVTXHVHDOXGHQDODKRUDGHHVFRJHURUHFKD]DUD0DUtDSHURSXHGHQDJUXSDUVH HQ GRV VX FDUiFWHU \ VX OLPLWDFLyQ /RV TXH OD HOLJHQ OR KDFHQ WDQWR SRUTXH ³0H OOHYR ELHQ FRQ HOOD´ 0RLVpVR³(VXQDEXHQDFRPSDxHUDWHGHMDODVFRVDV(VDJUDGDEOH´­QJHODFRPRSRUTXH ³0HJXVWDD\XGDUDODJHQWH\FRPRPXFKRVQRTXLHUHQLUFRQHOOD«´%LELDQD$ODKRUDGHVHU UHFKD]DGDORHVWDQWRSRUTXH³6LHPSUHJULWD´-XDQ³6LHPSUHVHKDGHKDFHUORTXHHOODGLFH´'jOLD R³(VPX\FRQWHVWRQDSDUHFHTXHTXLHUDTXHOHD\XGHV\OXHJRWHFRQWHVWD£GpMDPH´0DWHR FRPRTXH³&XDQGRWHQHPRVDOJXQDDFWLYLGDGFRPRFRUUHUHOODQRORSXHGHKDFHU´)UDQFHVF 3RUVXSDUWH0DUtDHVPX\VLQFHUDDODKRUDGHDUJXPHQWDUORVUHFKD]RVTXHHOODKDHPLWLGR0LHQWUDV TXH SDUD MXVWLILFDU ODV HOHFFLRQHV DOXGH D UD]RQHV FRPR ³6RQ PLV PHMRUHV DPLJRV´ R ³(V PL YHFLQD´ R ³-XHJD FRQPLJR PH GHMD HO WDPDJRFKL´ D OD KRUD GH UHFKD]DU OOHJD KDVWD HO LQVXOWR FRQ MXVWLILFDFLRQHV FRPR ³(V WRQWR´ )UHGHULF ³3DUHFH XQ FHUGR´ 'jOLD ³(V XQD FKXOD´ &DUPH R ³(V XQ VXEQRUPDO´5REHUW(VWRHVXQDPXHVWUDGHVXFDUiFWHUFRQIOLFWLYR 5HVXPLHQGRSRGHPRVFRQVLGHUDUTXHODVLWXDFLyQGH0DUtDPHMRUDFRQVLGHUDEOHPHQWHFRQUHVSHFWRDOD SULPHUDDGPLQLVWUDFLyQ1RWDQVyORUHFLEHPiVHOHFFLRQHV\PHQRVUHFKD]RVVLQRTXHWDPELpQPXHVWUD XQD PD\RU DWHQFLyQ KDFLD VX SURSLR JUXSR HPLWH PiV HOHFFLRQHV \ PiV UHFKD]RV $GHPiV ODV HOHFFLRQHV TXH UHFLEH VDEH FDSWDUODV \ ODV FRUUHVSRQGH FRQ XQD UHFLSURFLGDG SRVLWLYD &RPR SXQWR QHJDWLYR UHFRUGDU TXH VLJXH VLHQGR GHPDVLDGR IDQWDVLRVD D OD KRUD GH HVSHUDU HOHFFLRQHV \ UHFKD]RV SXHVHVSHUDGHPDVLDGRV 6LFRPSDUDPRVODVLWXDFLyQGH0DUtDHQODSUXHEDVWDQGDUG\HQODGHFRQWUROFRPSUREDUHPRVTXHQR KD\DSHQDVGLIHUHQFLDV5HFLEHXQDHOHFFLyQPiVSRUSDUWHGH&RQUDG\DOJ~QTXHRWURUHFKD]RGH PiV(VWRHVQRUPDOVLVHWLHQHHQFXHQWDFRPR\DVHFRPHQWyFRQDQWHULRULGDGTXHWRGRVVHYDORUDQD WRGRVHQHVWDSUXHEDGHFRQWUROPLHQWUDVTXHHQODSUXHEDVWDQGDUGWDQVRORVHQRPEUDDXQRVSRFRVGH PHPRULD\HVPXFKRPiVSUREDEOHTXHXQVXMHWRUHFLEDPiVHOHFFLRQHV\PiVUHFKD]RV $8/$ )LJ6RFLRJUDPDLQGLYLGXDOGH0DUtDHQODVLWXDFLyQGHDXODFRUUHVSRQGLHQWHDOD DGPLQLVWUDFLyQGHIHEUHURGH ,1',&(662&,20(75,&26'(0$5Ë$ 67$78662&,20(75,&266 &RQH[LyQDIHFWLYD &$ 3RSXODULGDG 3RS $QWLSDWtD $QW ([SDQVLYLGDG ([SS ([SDQVLYLGDG([SQ $WHQFLyQSHUFHS $3S $WHQFLyQSHUFHS$3Q 5HDOLVPRSHUFHS 53S 5HDOLVPRSHUFHS53Q /RV tQGLFHV HQ ORV TXH VH PXHYH 0DUtD VRQ PX\ SDUHFLGRV D ORV GHO SULPHU WULPHVWUH FRQ DOJXQDV VDOYHGDGHV3RGUtDPRVDILUPDUGHHVWDIRUPDTXHODPHMRUDH[SHULPHQWDGDHQODVLWXDFLyQGHODFODVHGH HGXFDFLyQ ItVLFD QR KD UHSHUFXWLGR HQ HVWD VLWXDFLyQ GRQGH VX HVWDWXV VRFLRPpWULFR VL PHMRUD SHUR QR FRQVLGHUDEOHPHQWH UHFLEH PiV HOHFFLRQHV SHUR WDPELpQ PiV UHFKD]RV &RPR PXFKR SRGUtDPRV SODQWHDUQRVVLHODXPHQWRGHWDOHVSRVLWLYRV\QHJDWLYRVHVLQGLFDWLYRGHTXHHVPiVWHQLGDHQFXHQWDSRU VXVFRPSDxHURVDXQTXHQRVHDSDUDHOHJLUOD /RTXHVtREVHUYDPRVDGLIHUHQFLDGHOSULPHUWULPHVWUH\TXHWDPELpQKHPRVREVHUYDGRHQODVLWXDFLyQ GHHGXFDFLyQItVLFDHVTXH0DUtDHVWiPiVDWHQWDDORVHVWtPXORVUHFLELGRVSRUSDUWHGHVXVFRPSDxHURV VREUHWRGR D ORV SRVLWLYRV $WHQFLyQ 3HUFHSWLYD SRVLWLYD 6X DWHQFLyQ SHUFHSWLYD QHJDWLYD VLJXH VLHQGREDMDHQHVWDVHJXQGDDGPLQLVWUDFLyQ6XUHDOLVPRSHUFHSWLYRDXQTXHKDPHMRUDGRUHVSHFWR DODSULPHUDDGPLQLVWUDFLyQHVWiD~QOHMRVGHGHPRVWUDUXQDPDGXUH]HQHVWRVDVSHFWRVVRFLDOHV$FLHUWD ODVGRVSHUVRQDVTXHODHOLJHQSHURHVSHUDFLQFRHOHFFLRQHVUHDOLVPRSHUFHSWLYRSRVLWLYRPLHQWUDV TXH DFLHUWD XQR GH ORV WUHV UHFKD]RV TXH HVSHUD SHUR HQ UHDOLGDG UHFLEH VHLV UHDOLVPR SHUFHSWLYR QHJDWLYR 6X FRQH[LyQ DIHFWLYD VH UHGXFH D OD PLWDG SXHV VL HQ OD SULPHUD DGPLQLVWUDFLyQ FRUUHVSRQGtDDOD~QLFDHOHFFLyQSRVLWLYDTXHUHFLEtDHQHVWDRFDVLyQVRQGRVODVTXHUHFLEH\WDQVROR FRUUHVSRQGH D XQD OD GH 0RLVpV PLHQWUDV TXH QR UHVSRQGH D OD GH ÉQJHOD 3XHVWR TXH HO Q~PHURGHHOHFFLRQHVTXHUHFLEHHVWDQUHGXFLGRQRSRGHPRVKDEODUGHXQDGLIHUHQFLDVLJQLILFDWLYDWDQ FODUD FRPR SRGUtDPRV SHQVDU DO FRPSDUDU ORV tQGLFHV VRFLRPpWULFRV LQGLYLGXDOHV GH OD SULPHUD \ OD VHJXQGDDGPLQLVWUDFLyQ 6LREVHUYDPRVODILJXUDREVHUYDUHPRVTXH0DUtDUHFLEHGRVHOHFFLRQHVSRVLWLYDV0RLVpV\ÉQJHOD DQWHULRUPHQWHFRPHQWDGDVGHODVFXDOHVUHVSRQGHSRVLWLYDPHQWHDXQDGHHOODVPHGLDQWHODUHFLSURFLGDG SRVLWLYD5HFLEHHQFDPELRVHLVUHFKD]RV&XDWURGHFKLFRV7RPiV-XDQDOTXHFRUUHVSRQGH FRQXQDUHFLSURFLGDGQHJDWLYD)UDQFHVF\5REHUW\GRVGHFKLFDV-RDQD\3DWUtFLD (VWH ~OWLPR UHFKD]R UHFLELGR SXHGH VHU VLJQLILFDWLYR HQ UHODFLyQ DO FDUiFWHU GH 0DUtD DO TXH \D KHPRV DOXGLGR HQ OD VLWXDFLyQ GH OD FODVH GH HGXFDFLyQ ItVLFD HQ HVWD PLVPD DGPLQLVWUDFLyQ (Q OD SULPHUD DGPLQLVWUDFLyQ 3DWUtFLD HOHJtD D 0DUtD (Q HVWD VHJXQGD OD UHFKD]D SRUTXH ³/H GD LJXDO OR TXH KDJDPRV´3RGUtDUHIHULUVHFRQHVWDRSLQLyQDTXH0DUtDQRUHVSRQGHDORVVLJQRVTXHOHGLULJH3DWUtFLD SDUD WUDWDU GH HQWDEODU XQD DPLVWDG \ VX FDUiFWHU GLItFLO YXHOYH D DSDUHFHU \D KDEODPRV GH pO HQ OD VLWXDFLyQGHODFODVHGHHGXFDFLyQItVLFDFRQVLJXLHQGRTXHDTXHOODSHUVRQDTXHDQWHULRUPHQWHODHOHJtD DOFRQRFHUODPHMRUODUHFKDFH 3RURWUDSDUWH0DUtDHPLWHFLQFRHOHFFLRQHVGLULJLGDVWRGDVHOODVDFKLFRV0DQHO,YiQ0RLVpV 6HUJL H ,JQDVL 'H HOODV WDQ VyOR XQD HV FRUUHVSRQGLGD $ OD KRUD GH HPLWLU UHFKD]RV WDPELpQVHGLULJHKDFLDORVFKLFRV'HODVFLQFRFXDWURYDQGLULJLGDVDHOORV)UHGHULF-XDQ0DWHR \&RQUDG/DRWUDYDHPLWLGDD'jOLD /RVGRVFRPSDxHURVTXHHVFRJHQD0DUtDORKDFHQSRUGLVWLQWRPRWLYR0RLVpVSRUTXH³0HOOHYRELHQ FRQ HOOD´ \ ÉQJHOD SRUTXH ³&RPR HVWi VROD PH JXVWD MXJDU FRQ HOOD 6H SRQH FRQWHQWD´ (V SRU PRWLYRVGHVLPSDWtD\QRSRUVXFDSDFLGDGGHWUDEDMRSRUORTXHHVHVFRJLGD(QFDPELRHVUHFKD]DGD WDQWRSRUVXDQWLSDWtDFRPRSRUVXSRFDFDSDFLGDGGHWUDEDMR3RUXQODGR-XDQODUHFKD]DSRUTXH³0H FDH PDO´ )UDQFHVF SRUTXH ³6H TXHMD WRGR HO UDWR´ \ 3DWUtFLD SRUTXH ³/H GD LJXDO OR TXH KDJDPRV´(VWDRSLQLyQUHIOHMDQRWDQVyORXQDVSHFWRGHOFDUiFWHUDSiWLFRVLQRWDPELpQHORWURDVSHFWR SULQFLSDOGH0DUtDGHOTXHVHTXHMDQVXVFRPSDxHURVTXHQRKDFHQDGDHQFODVH &RQUHIHUHQFLDDHVWHVHJXQGRDVSHFWR-RDQDODUHFKD]DSRUTXH³1RKDFHQDGD´7RPjVSRUTXH ³1XQFD KDFH QDGD VLHPSUH HVSHUD TXH OH KDJDQ ODV FRVDV´ \ 5REHUW SRUTXH ³1XQFD DFDED ORV WUDEDMRV´ $ODKRUDGHHVFRJHUORKDFHFRQPRWLYRVPX\GLYHUVRVWDQWRVTXHGHVFRQFLHUWDQSRUVXIDOWDHQFLHUWRV PRPHQWRV GH UHDOLVPR 0DUtD GD PRWLYRV FRPR ³$QWHV HUD PL QRYLR´ ³+DFH PXFKDV WRQWHUtDV´ R ³(V QXHYR´FRPRPRWLYRVSDUDHOHJLUDORVSRVLEOHVLQWHJUDQWHVGHVXJUXSRGHWUDEDMRLGHDOORTXHGHQRWDXQD HYLGHQWHIDOWDGHPDGXUH]\UHDOLVPR&XDQGRUHFKD]DORKDFHSRUTXH³VRQPX\WRQWRV´ &RPSDUiQGRORFRQODSUXHEDGHFRQWUROFRPSUREDPRVTXHQRH[LVWHQJUDQGHVGLIHUHQFLDVFRQUHVSHFWRD OD SUXHED VWDQGDUG TXH DFDEDPRV GH FRPHQWDU VDOYR OD PD\RU FDQWLGDG GH HOHFFLRQHV \ UHFKD]RV UHFLELGRV\DH[SOLFDGRVHQODVLWXDFLyQGHFODVHGHHGXFDFLyQItVLFDHQODPLVPDDGPLQLVWUDFLyQ (QUHVXPHQDSHVDUGHTXHHVWDPiVDWHQWDDDTXHOORTXHVXFHGHDVXDOUHGHGRUVXVLWXDFLyQGHQWURGH ODFODVHQRKDPHMRUDGRGHPDVLDGRHQUHODFLyQFRQODSULPHUDDGPLQLVWUDFLyQ1RULQGHHQFODVH\QRFDH ELHQ\SRUHVWRHVUHFKD]DGD$ODKRUDGHHVFRJHUORVPRWLYRVGH0DUtDVRQFRQIXVRV\GHQRWDQXQD FLHUWDLQPDGXUH] -81,2 ('8&$&,Ð1)Ì6,&$ )LJ6RFLRJUDPDLQGLYLGXDOGH0DUtDHQODVLWXDFLyQGHODFODVHGH(GXFDFLyQ)tVLFD FRUUHVSRQGLHQWHDODDGPLQLVWUDFLyQGHMXQLRGH ,1',&(662&,20(75,&26'(0$5Ë$ 67$78662&,20(75,&266 &RQH[LyQDIHFWLYD &$ 3RSXODULGDG 3RS $QWLSDWtD $QW ([SDQVLYLGDG ([SS ([SDQVLYLGDG([SQ $WHQFLyQSHUFHS $3S $WHQFLyQSHUFHS$3Q 5HDOLVPRSHUFHS 53S 5HDOLVPRSHUFHS53Q (Q HVWD WHUFHUD DGPLQLVWUDFLyQ VH FRQILUPD OD WHQGHQFLD D OD LQFOXVLyQ GH 0DUtD GHQWUR GHO JUXSR 6X HVWDWXV VRFLRPpWULFR FRQWLQ~D DXPHQWDQGR GH PDQHUD TXH VX PHMRUD HV PiV TXH DSUHFLDEOH VL OD FRPSDUDPRV FRQ OD DGPLQLVWUDFLyQ UHDOL]DGD HQ RFWXEUH GHO 6L D SULQFLSLR GH FXUVR VX HVWDWXV VRFLRPpWULFRHUD±RFXSDQGRHOOXJDUGHODFODVHDKRUDHVGHHOOXJDUHQODFODVH8QD PHMRUDFRQVLGHUDEOH 6X FRQH[LyQ DIHFWLYD HV EDVWDQWH DOWD OR TXH YLHQH D FRQILUPDUQRV TXH KD DSUHQGLGR FRQ HO WLHPSR D HQWHQGHUDVXVFRPSDxHURV\DFRUUHVSRQGHUSRVLWLYDPHQWHVXVHOHFFLRQHV(QHVWDRFDVLyQUHVSRQGHD GH ODV HOHFFLRQHV TXH UHFLEH ­QJHOD 0D\WH 'jOLD 0RLVpV /DV RWUDV GRV HOHFFLRQHVTXHUHFLEHVRQFRPRSXHGHYHUVHHQODILJXUDGH-RDQD\%LELDQD$SHVDUGH FRUUHVSRQGHUDGHODVHOHFFLRQHV0DUtDQRVHPXHVWUDQLGHPDVLDGRDWHQWDQLGHPDVLDGRUHDOLVWDFRQ HVWDVHOHFFLRQHVDWHQFLyQSHUFHSWLYDSRVLWLYD\UHDOLVPRSHUFHSWLYRSRVLWLYR5HPDUFDUTXHHV ODRFDVLyQTXHUHFLEHFRQGLIHUHQFLDPiVHOHFFLRQHVSRSXODULGDG 0DUtDHVHOHJLGDSULQFLSDOPHQWHSRUGRVPRWLYRVHOSULPHURSRUVLPSDWtD-RDQDODHOLJHSRUTXH³HV DPLJD´ \ HQ WpUPLQRV SDUHFLGRV VH H[SUHVD ­QJHOD FXDQGR VH MXVWLILFD HQ TXH ³HV PX\ EXHQD FRPSDxHUDVHOHSXHGHSHGLUIDYRUHV7HWUDWDELHQ´\DGHPiV³HVPX\DPLJDPtDGHVGHSHTXHxD´'H ODPLVPDPDQHUD0D\WHWDPELpQMXVWLILFDVXHOHFFLyQSRUTXHHV³GHPLPHMRUHVDPLJDV´ /D VHJXQGD PRWLYDFLyQ D OD KRUD GH VHU HOHJLGD HV TXH D SHVDU GH VX OLPLWDFLyQ SDUD DOJXQRV GH VXV FRPSDxHURV HV XQD FRPSDxHUD PiV 3RU HMHPSOR %LELDQD MXVWLILFD VX HOHFFLyQ SRUTXH ³0H JXVWD D\XGDUOD$XQTXHYD\DFRQPXOHWDVHV QRUPDOFRPRQRVRWURV´7DPELpQ'jOLDVHUHILHUHDOPLVPR WHPD FXDQGR FRPHQWD TXH ³6DEH MXJDU PHMRU TXH DOJXQR GH OD FODVH´ )LQDOPHQWH 0RLVpV VH MXVWLILFDHQWpUPLQRVSDUHFLGRVDOGHFLUTXH³(VXQDQLxDQRUPDOSXHGHKDFHUWRGDVODVDFWLYLGDGHV\PH OOHYRPX\ELHQFRQHOOD´ 3RURWUDSDUWHUHFLEHUHFKD]RVGHORVTXHFRUUHVSRQGHQHJDWLYDPHQWHWDQVRORD0DWHR/RV RWURV UHFKD]RV TXH UHFLEH VRQ GH )UHGHULF &DUPH H ,VD 'H OD PLVPD IRUPD TXH QR VH PXHVWUDQLDWHQWDQLUHDOLVWDFRQODVHOHFFLRQHVSRVLWLYDVTXHUHFLEHWDPSRFRVHPXHVWUDFRQORVUHFKD]RV DWHQFLyQSHUFHSWLYDQHJDWLYDUHDOLVPRSHUFHSWLYRQHJDWLYR $ODKRUDGHVHUUHFKD]DGDORHVSRUVXPDOFDUiFWHURSRUORPHQRVFRLQFLGHQHQHVWHDVSHFWRODVFXDWUR SHUVRQDVTXHUHFKD]DQD0DUtD3RUHMHPSORPLHQWUDV&DUPHMXVWLILFDVXUHFKD]RFRQXQ³'LFHTXHQR TXLHUHLUFRQPLJR³,VDWDPELpQVHUHILHUHDODIDOWDGHFRQWDFWRTXHPDQWLHQHFRQHOOD³1RMXHJRFRQ HOOD7DPSRFRKDEORPXFKRFRQHOOD´&RPHQWDULRVPiVFODURVVRQORVGH)UHGHULFTXHGLFHTXH0DUtD WLHQH³PDOFDUiFWHUFRQPLJR´DVtFRPRHOGH0DWHRTXHVHMXVWLILFDGLFLHQGRTXH0DUtD³(VODPiV ERUGH6LHPSUHVHHQIDGD´ 6L REVHUYDPRVODILJXUDSRGHPRVDSUHFLDUTXH0DUtDHVFRJHDVLHWHFRPSDxHURVFKLFDV\ FKLFRVUHFLELHQGRUHFLSURFLGDGHVSRVLWLYDV(O~QLFRPRWLYRGHHOHFFLyQH[SOtFLWRHVODDPLVWDGKDFLD &RQUDG$VXYH]HPLWHUHFKD]RVORVDFKLFRVUHFLELHQGRXQDUHFLSURFLGDGQHJDWLYD/RVPRWLYRVGH UHFKD]R VyOR VH H[SOLFLWDQ KDFLD 0DWHR ³SRUTXH VLHPSUH VH EXUOD´ \ 'HQtV ³SRUTXH VLHPSUH MXHJD D I~WERO´ )LQDOPHQWH DO FRQWUDVWDUHVWRVUHVXOWDGRV FRQ OD SUXHED GH FRQWURO FRPSUREDPRV TXH0DUtD UHFLEH XQ Q~PHURSDUHFLGRGHHOHFFLRQHV\UHFKD]RVUHFLEHHOHFFLRQHV\UHFKD]RVGHVWDFDQGRTXHHQHVWD SUXHEDH[LVWHQGRVRSRVLFLRQHVGHVHQWLPLHQWRVFRQUHVSHFWRDGRVSHUVRQDVTXHHOODHOLJH-XDQ\ 6HUJL\TXHODUHFKD]DQ (Q UHVXPHQ OD VLWXDFLyQ GH 0DUtD PHMRUD D OR ODUJR GHO FXUVR UHFLELHQGR PiV HOHFFLRQHV \ PHQRV UHFKD]RVDPHGLGDTXHSDVDHOFXUVR$GHPiVVXDOWDFRQH[LyQDIHFWLYDQRVPXHVWUDTXHHVFDSD]GH LQWHUSUHWDUDTXHOORVVLJQRVGHODVSHUVRQDVPiVFHUFDQDV\GDUVHFXHQWDGHVXVLQWHQFLRQHVSDUDSRGHU UHVSRQGHUDHOODVPHGLDQWHODUHFLSURFLGDG$SHVDUGHVXPHMRUDHQHVWHDVSHFWRHVSRFRUHDOLVWDFRQHO Q~PHURGHHOHFFLRQHV\UHFKD]RVTXHYDDUHFLELUHVSHUDEDVWDQWHVPiVGHORVTXHDFLHUWD(VHOHJLGD SRUVXVLPSDWtD\SRUTXHDOJXQRVGHVXVFRPSDxHURVVHKDQGDGRFXHQWDTXHHVXQDFRPSDxHUDPiV LQGHSHQGLHQWHPHQWHGHVXOLPLWDFLyQ(VUHFKD]DGDSRUVXPDOFDUiFWHU $8/$ )LJ6RFLRJUDPDLQGLYLGXDOGH0DUtDHQODVLWXDFLyQGHDXODFRUUHVSRQGLHQWHDOD DGPLQLVWUDFLyQGHMXQLRGH ,1',&(662&,20(75,&26'(0$5Ë$ 67$78662&,20(75,&266 &RQH[LyQDIHFWLYD &$ 3RSXODULGDG 3RS $QWLSDWtD $QW ([SDQVLYLGDG ([SS ([SDQVLYLGDG([SQ $WHQFLyQSHUFHS $3S $WHQFLyQSHUFHS$3Q 5HDOLVPRSHUFHS 53S 5HDOLVPRSHUFHS53Q 6L HQ OD VLWXDFLyQ GH OD FODVH GH HGXFDFLyQ ItVLFD SRGtDPRV FRQILUPDU HQ HVWD WHUFHUD DGPLQLVWUDFLyQ OD LQFOXVLyQGH0DUtDGHQWURGHOJUXSRQRWDQVRORQRSRGHPRVKDFHUORPLVPRHQODVLWXDFLyQGHDXOD SXHV0DUtDFRQWLQ~DPDQWHQLHQGRXQHVWDWXVVRFLRPpWULFRQHJDWLYRRFXSDQGRXQRGHORV~OWLPRV OXJDUHV GHODFODVHVLQRTXHSRGHPRV DILUPDUTXHVXPHMRUDHQODVLWXDFLyQGHHGXFDFLyQItVLFDQRVH UHIOHMDHQHODXOD (QORTXHVtVHPDQWLHQHHVHQVXJUDGRGHFRQH[LyQDIHFWLYDSXHVFRUUHVSRQGHGRVGHODVWUHV HOHFFLRQHVTXHUHFLEH$GHPiV\DGLIHUHQFLDGHODVLWXDFLyQGHHGXFDFLyQItVLFDSHURFRQJUDQSDUHFLGR DODVHJXQGDDGPLQLVWUDFLyQHQHVWDPLVPDVLWXDFLyQGHDXODHVPXFKRPiVDWHQWDDWHQFLyQSHUFHSWLYD SRVLWLYD\DOJRPiVUHDOLVWDUHDOLVPRSHUFHSWLYRSRVLWLYRFRQODVHOHFFLRQHVUHFLELGDVTXHFRQ ORVUHFKD]RVDWHQFLyQSHUFHSWLYDQHJDWLYD\UHDOLVPRSHUFHSWLYRQHJDWLYR 'HODVWUHVHOHFFLRQHVTXHUHFLEHSRSXODULGDGTXHVRQODVGH­QJHOD3DWUtFLD\0RLVpV FRUUHVSRQGH D GRV 3DWUtFLD \ 0RLVpV PLHQWUDV TXH FRQ ­QJHOD PDQWLHQH XQD RSRVLFLyQ GH VHQWLPLHQWRVSXHVWRTXH0DUtDODUHFKD]D(VWDVHOHFFLRQHVVRQSRUPRWLYRVGHWUDEDMRDXQTXHGHMDQ HQWUHYHUDGHPiVXQDEXHQDUHODFLyQDQLYHOSHUVRQDOHQWUH0DUtD\ORVWUHVFRPSDxHURVTXHODHVFRJHQ ­QJHODGLFHGH0DUtDTXH³(VPX\EXHQDFRPSDxHUD\VDEHWUDEDMDUHQJUXSR´PLHQWUDVTXH3DWUtFLD GLFHTXH³&RODERUDPXFKR´\0RLVpVTXH³$YHFHVHQFODVHKDFHPRVFRVDVGLYHUWLGDV\VLYR\ FRQHOODPHUtRPiV\VHKDFHPHMRUODWDUHD´ /RVUHFKD]RVTXHUHFLEHFKLFDV\FKLFRVWDPELpQVRQSRUPRWLYRGHVXUHQGLPLHQWRHQHODXODDOD KRUD GH KDFHU WUDEDMRV GH PDQHUD TXH ODV RSLQLRQHV GHO UHQGLPLHQWR GH 0DUtD HQ FODVH VRQ FRQWUDGLFWRULRV-RDQDSRUHMHPSORGLFHTXH³1RTXLHUHKDFHUQDGD´RSLQLyQFRUURERUDGDSRU0D\WH TXHGLFHTXH³1RKDFHQDGD7DQVRORPLUD´0DWHRWDPELpQRSLQDDOJRSDUHFLGR³&DVLQXQFD KDFHORVGHEHUHV1RHVWXGLD´GLFH7DPELpQ5REHUWRSLQDTXH³1RKDFHWUDEDMR\GHMDDORVGHPiV TXHORKDJDQ1RSDUWLFLSD1RWLHQHLQWHUpV´'jOLDSRUVXSDUWHRSLQDTXH³/RWLHQHQTXHKDFHUWRGR ORVGHPiV´FXDQGRVHWUDEDMDHQJUXSRFRQHOOD7DPELpQUHILULpQGRVHDODFDSDFLGDGGHWUDEDMDUHQJUXSR SHURHQXQPDWL]GLVWLQWRVHSURQXQFLD)UDQFHVFFXDQGRGLFHTXH0DUtD³+DFHORTXHQRWRFD´FRPR GDQGRDHQWHQGHUTXHQRWDQVyORQRWUDEDMDVLQRTXHFUHDGLVWRUVLyQHQHOWUDEDMRHQJUXSR 3RUVXSDUWH0DUtDHVFRJHDVLHWHFRPSDxHURV'HHOORVVRQFKLFRV0DQHO0RLVpVFRQTXLHQ PDQWLHQH UHFLSURFLGDG SRVLWLYD 6HUJL \ &RQUDG \ VRQ FKLFDV 0D\WH TXH OD UHFKD]D \ IRUPD XQD RSRVLFLyQ GH VHQWLPLHQWRV %LELDQD \ 3DWUtFLD FRQ TXLHQ IRUPD OD VHJXQGD UHFLSURFLGDG SRVLWLYD $ YHFHV HOLJH SRU VLPSDWtD FRPR HQ HO FDVR GH 3DWUtFLD \ RWUDV SRUTXH ³$ YHFHVKDFHPRVWUDEDMRVMXQWRVELHQ´FXDQGRMXVWLILFDODHOHFFLyQGH%LELDQD\0DQHO $ODKRUDGHUHFKD]DUHPLWHVXVVHLVUHFKD]RVHQIXQFLyQGHPRWLYRVSHUVRQDOHV$VtFXDQGRKDEODGH ODVFKLFDVDODVTXHUHFKD]DORVRWURVGRVVRQ-XDQ\0DWHRFRQTXLHQIRUPDXQDUHFLSURFLGDG QHJDWLYDFRPHQWDGH­QJHODTXH³0HFDHPDO´GH,VDTXH³7LHQHFDUDGHFHUGR´GH'jOLD TXH³6HHQIDGDPXFKRHVPX\PDQGRQD´\GH­QJHOD³1RPHKDFHFDVR´7HQLHQGRHQFXHQWDTXH FRQHVWD~OWLPDWLHQHXQDRSRVLFLyQGHVHQWLPLHQWRVHVSUREDEOHTXHHQHVWDVLWXDFLyQHQFRQFUHWR0DUtD QRVHSDYHUTXH­QJHODWLHQHXQDEXHQDSUHGLVSRVLFLyQDIRUPDUJUXSRFRQHOODHQHODXODHLQWHUSUHWH VXVDFFLRQHVFRPRXQSDVRWLVPRKDFLDVXSHUVRQD 6LFRPSDUDPRVODSUXHEDVWDQGDUGFRQODSUXHEDGHFRQWUROREVHUYDUHPRVUHVXOWDGRVFDVLLGpQWLFRVHQWUH ODV GRV HQ pVWD UHFLEH GRV HOHFFLRQHV \ VLHWH UHFKD]RV \ WDPELpQ PDQWLHQH XQD RSRVLFLyQ GH VHQWLPLHQWRVFRQ0D\WH (Q UHVXPHQORVEXHQRVUHVXOWDGRVGH OD VLWXDFLyQ GH OD FODVH GH HGXFDFLyQ ItVLFD QR VH WUDVODGDQ DOD VLWXDFLyQGHDXODFRQORTXHSRGHPRVFRQFOXLUTXH0DUtDQRVHKDLQFOXLGRGHQWURGHOJUXSR\TXHHQ HVWHFDVRQRVHKDQWUDQVIHULGRDRWURViPELWRVODVUHODFLRQHVVRFLDOHVTXHKD\DSRGLGRDGTXLULUPLHQWUDV UHDOL]DEDDFWLYLGDGHVHQODFODVHGHHGXFDFLyQItVLFD &8$'525(680(10$5Ì$ 6,78$&,Ð1'(('8&$&,Ð1)Ì6,&$ 6,78$&,Ð1'($8/$ 2FWXEUH )HEUHUR -XQLR 2FWXEUH )HEUHUR -XQLR 66 &$ 3RSXODULGDG $QWLSDWtD ([S ([S $3 $3 53 53 (VWDWXV6RFLRPpWULFR660HMRUDFODUDPHQWHHQODHGXFDFLyQItVLFDGHIRUPDJUDGXDOWULPHVWUH DWULPHVWUH(QFDPELRHVWDPHMRUDQRVHUHIOHMDWDPELpQHQODVLWXDFLyQGHODXODGRQGHODPHMRUD GHOHVWDWXVVRFLRPpWULFRGH0DUtDWLHQHSRFDVLJQLILFDFLyQ &RQH[LyQ$IHFWLYD&$0DQWLHQHEXHQRVtQGLFHVGH&RQH[LyQ$IHFWLYDH[FHSWRHQODVLWXDFLyQ GH HGXFDFLyQ ItVLFD GH OD SULPHUD DGPLQLVWUDFLyQ (Q JHQHUDO UHFLEH SRFDV HOHFFLRQHV \ FRUUHVSRQGHSRVLWLYDPHQWHDODPD\RUSDUWH 3RSXODULGDG0HMRUDHQODVGRVVLWXDFLRQHVDXQTXHHQODGHHGXFDFLyQItVLFDHVWDPHMRUDHVPiV HYLGHQWH$OSULQFLSLRGHFXUVRDSHQDVUHFLEHHOHFFLRQHVSRVLWLYDVHQFDGDVLWXDFLyQGXUDQWHOD SULPHUDDGPLQLVWUDFLyQ 66(VWDWXVVRFLRPpWULFR &$&RQH[LyQDIHFWLYD ([S([SDQVLYLGDG $3$WHQFLyQ\SHUFHSFLyQ 535HDOLVPRSHUFHSWLYR $QWLSDWtD'LVPLQX\HGUiVWLFDPHQWHHQWUHODSULPHUD\ODVHJXQGDDGPLQLVWUDFLyQHQODVLWXDFLyQGH HGXFDFLyQItVLFDPRVWUDQGRXQDUHDFFLyQSRUSDUWHGHODFODVHDODSRVLEOHLQFOXVLyQGH0DUtDHQ ODVWDUHDVPRWULFHVHTXLOLEUiQGRVHHQODWHUFHUDDGPLQLVWUDFLyQ3HURHQFODVHHVWDHYROXFLyQQRVH YHUHIOHMDGD\VHPXHYHHQXQRVtQGLFHVSDUHFLGRVDORODUJRGHWRGRHOFXUVR ([SDQVLYLGDG3RVLWLYD([S6HPXHYHHQWRUQRDODVVHLVHOHFFLRQHVGXUDQWHHOFXUVRWDQWRHQ OD HGXFDFLyQ ItVLFD FRPR HQ HO DXOD DXQTXH D PHGLGD TXH YD DYDQ]DQGR PXHVWUD XQD PD\RU H[SDQVLYLGDG ([SDQVLYLGDG 1HJDWLYD ([S 7LHQH XQD HYROXFLyQ FDVL LJXDO TXH OD H[SDQVLYLGDG SRVLWLYD 'HQRWDXQPHMRUFRQRFLPLHQWRGHOJUXSR\XQGHVHRPiVIXHUWHGHSHUWHQHQFLDDOJUXSRDPHGLGD TXHDYDQ]DHODxR $WHQFLyQ \ 3HUFHSFLyQ 3RVLWLYD $3 1R HV PX\ DOWD HQ OD VLWXDFLyQ GH HGXFDFLyQ ItVLFD PRVWUDQGRSRFDDWHQFLyQKDFLDORVHVWtPXORVH[WHUQRVSURYHQLHQWHVGHDTXHOODVSHUVRQDVTXHOD HOLJHQ(QODVLWXDFLyQGHDXODHQFDPELR\DSHVDUGHHPSH]DUFRQXQDDWHQFLyQ\SHUFHSFLyQ SRVLWLYD QXOD DFDED PRVWUDQGR XQD EXHQD DWHQFLyQ KDFLD HVRV HVWtPXORV H[WHUQRV SURYHQLHQWHVGHODVSRFDVSHUVRQDVTXHODHOLJHQ $WHQFLyQ\3HUFHSFLyQ1HJDWLYD$36HPXHYHHQYDORUHVPHGLREDMRVGXUDQWHWRGRHOFXUVR HQDPEDVVLWXDFLRQHV1RHVXQDSHUVRQDHVSHFLDOPHQWHDWHQWDDORVHVWtPXORVH[WHUQRVHQIRUPD GHUHFKD]R 5HDOLVPR3HUFHSWLYR3RVLWLYR53(QDPEDVVLWXDFLRQHV0DUtDHVH[FHVLYDPHQWHRSWLPLVWD FXDQGRHVSHUDHOHFFLRQHVSRUSDUWHGHVXVFRPSDxHURVDXQTXHHQODVGRVH[LVWHXQDWHQGHQFLD KDFLDHOUHFRQRFLPLHQWRGHODVLWXDFLyQSRUVXSDUWHXQSRFRPiVPDUFDGRHQODVLWXDFLyQGHDXOD 5HDOLVPR3HUFHSWLYR1HJDWLYR53&RQtQGLFHVPX\SDUHFLGRVDOUHDOLVPRSHUFHSWLYRSRVLWLYR HQHVWDRFDVLyQODGLIHUHQFLDUDGLFDHQTXHHVHUHDOLVPR\DH[LVWtDHQFLHUWDPHGLGDHVGHFLUTXH 0DUtD\DVHVDEtDUHFKD]DGDSRUDOJXQRVGHVXVFRPSDxHURVHVSHFLDOPHQWHHQODVLWXDFLyQGH HGXFDFLyQItVLFD &(1752-25', $ ÌQGLFHVVRFLRPpWULFRVLQGLYLGXDOHV (3(OHFFLRQHV3RVLWLYDV5HFLELGDV (1(OHFFLRQHV1HJDWLYDV5HFLELGDV (6 (VWDWXV 6RFLRPpWULFR HQ SDUpQWHVLV HO RUGHQ TXH RFXSD HQ OD FODVH VHJ~Q ORV UHVXOWDGRVGHHVWHtQGLFH ('8&$&,Ð1)Ì6,&$ $8/$ 2FWXEUH 0DU]R -XQLR 2FWXEUH 0DU]R -XQLR (3 (3 (1 (1 (6 (6 'HVGHXQSULQFLSLRQRKDFRQWDGRGHPDVLDGRSDUDVXVFRPSDxHURVDODKRUDGHIRUPDUJUXSRHQODFODVH GH(GXFDFLyQ)tVLFD\DSHVDUGHPHMRUDUHQHOVHJXQGRWULPHVWUHHQHOWHUFHURKDDFDEDGRSHRUTXHDO LQLFLRGHOFXUVR (QODVLWXDFLyQGHDXODQRKDKDELGRGLIHUHQFLDVVLJQLILFDWLYDVHQWUHHOSULPHUR\HOVHJXQGRWULPHVWUHSHUR HQ HO WHUFHUR KD PHMRUDGR VX VLWXDFLyQ HQ HO VHQWLGR TXH KD SRGLGR HQWUDU GHQWUR GHO VXEJUXSR GH ORV FKLFRVDSHVDUGHUHFLELUPiVUHFKD]RV % 6RFLRJUDPDV\GDWRVLQGLYLGXDOHV 2&78%5( ('8&$&,Ð1)Ì6,&$ -25', /2/$ )LJ6RFLRJUDPDLQGLYLGXDOGH-RUGLHQODVLWXDFLyQGHODFODVH GH(GXFDFLyQ)tVLFDFRUUHVSRQGLHQWHDODDGPLQLVWUDFLyQGHRFWXEUHGH Ë1',&(662&,20(75,&26,1',9,'8$/(6'(-25', 67$78662&,20(75,&2 66 &RQH[LyQDIHFWLYD &$ 3RSXODULGDG 3RS $QWLSDWtD $QW ([SDQVLYLGDG ([SS ([SDQVLYLGDG([SQ $WHQFLyQSHUFHSWLYD $3S $WHQFLyQSHUFHSWLYD$3Q 5HDOLVPRSHUFHSWLYR53S 5HDOLVPRSHUFHSWLYR53S 9LVWRV VXV UHVXOWDGRV FXDQWLWDWLYRV SRGHPRV KDEODU GH XQ FKLFR FRQ XQ HVWDWXV VRFLRPpWULFR PHGLR FRQ XQD SXQWXDFLyQ GH ± RFXSD HO FDWRUFHDYR OXJDU GH OD FODVHPRWLYDGRWDQWRSRUODVSRFDVHOHFFLRQHVFRPRORVSRFRVUHFKD]RVUHFLELGRVHV PiV LJQRUDGR TXH UHFKD]DGR HQ OD FODVH 6X FRQH[LyQ DIHFWLYD HV UHODWLYDPHQWH DOWD SHURQRGHEHVHUWRPDGDH[FHVLYDPHQWHHQFXHQWDSRUTXHUHFLEHHOHFFLRQHV WDQ VyOR 6X SRSXODULGDG HV PX\ EDMD WDQ VyOR XQ GH OD FODVH OR HOLJH \ VX DQWLSDWtDQRHVPXFKRPiVDOWDGHPDQHUDTXHSRFRVORHOLJHQ\SRFRVOHUHFKD]DQ -RUGL HPLWH FLQFR HOHFFLRQHV H[SDQVLELOLGDG SRVLWLYD \ QLQJ~Q UHFKD]R H[SDQVLELOLGDG QHJDWLYD 'H OD HOHFFLyQ TXH UHFLEH OD DFLHUWD DWHQFLyQ SHUFHSWLYD SRVLWLYD DXQTXH pO HVSHUD FLQFR UHDOLVPRSHUFHSWLYREDVWDQWHEDMR3XHVWRTXHQRHPLWHUHFKD]RVQRSRGHPRVHYDOXDUVXUHDOLVPR SHUFHSWLYRQHJDWLYRTXHHVSXHVWRTXHHVIUXWRGHODGLYLVLyQSRUORWDQWRQRSRGHPRVHYDOXDUOR FRPRWDO(QFDPELRGHORVUHFKD]RVTXHUHFLEHpOQRDFLHUWDDQLQJXQRDWHQFLyQSHUFHSWLYD $ QLYHO SHUVRQDO DO REVHUYDU ORV JUiILFRV GH OD ILJXUD SRGHPRV REVHUYDU TXH -RUGL HPLWH HOHFFLRQHVSRVLWLYDVDFKLFRV3HUH/OXtV&DUORV0LJXHOÉQJHO\2ULRO\QRHPLWH QLQJ~QUHFKD]RH[SDQVLELOLGDGQHJDWLYD'HHVWDVHOHFFLRQHVVyORXQDHVUHFtSURFDFRQ3HUHTXHHV XQDGHODVGRV~QLFDVSHUVRQDVTXHORHVFRJHQODRWUDHV)UDQFLQD 5HFLEH FXDWUR UHFKD]RV WUHV GHO SULPHU VXEJUXSR GH FKLFDV 7HUHVD 5RFtR \ 0HUFq \ XQ FXDUWR GHXQRGHORVFKLFRVDORVTXH HOLJH &DUORV 3RU OR WDQWR FRQ HVWH FRPSDxHUR WLHQH XQD UHODFLyQGHRSRVLFLyQGHVHQWLPLHQWRVHQHOVHQWLGRTXH-RUGLHOLJHD&DUORVSHURpVWHOHUHFKD]D (QUHVXPHQSRGHPRVFRQVLGHUDUD-RUGLFRPRXQPLHPEURFRQHOHVWDWXVPHGLREDMR HQ OD FODVH TXH UHFLEH SRFDV HOHFFLRQHV \ SRFRV UHFKD]RV VX VLWXDFLyQ VH DVHPHMD PiVDOROYLGDGRRLJQRUDGRTXHQRHPLWHUHFKD]RDOJXQRDQLQJ~QFRPSDxHUR\TXH HV SRFR DWHQWR \ UHDOLVWD HQ OD VLWXDFLyQ GH DGLYLQDU TXLpQ OR HVFRJHUi \ TXLpQ OR UHFKD]DUi $8/$ -25', /2/$ )LJ6RFLRJUDPDLQGLYLGXDOGH-RUGLHQODVLWXDFLyQ GHDXODFRUUHVSRQGLHQWHDODDGPLQLVWUDFLyQGHRFWXEUHGH ,1',&(662&,20(75,&26'(-25', 67$78662&,20(75,&2 66 &RQH[LyQDIHFWLYD &$ 3RS $QWLSDWtD ([SDQVLYLGDG ([SS ([SDQVLYLGDG([SQ 3RSXODULGDG $QW $WHQFLyQSHUFHSWLYD $3S $WHQFLyQSHUFHSWLYD$3Q 5HDOLVPRSHUFHSWLYR53S 5HDOLVPRSHUFHSWLYR53S (O (VWDWXV 6RFLRPpWULFR GH -RUGL GHQWUR GHO JUXSR FODVH GLILHUH HVSHFWDFXODUPHQWH GHSHQGLHQGR GH OD VLWXDFLyQHQODTXHVHHQFXHQWUH6LHQODVHVLyQGH(GXFDFLyQ)tVLFDHUDPHGLREDMRDTXtHVPHGLRDOWR SXHVWRTXHFRQXQRFXSDHOVpSWLPROXJDU6XFRQH[LyQDIHFWLYDHVUHODWLYDPHQWHDOWDWHQLHQGR HQFXHQWDTXHGHFXDWURHOHFFLRQHVTXHUHFLEHGRVVRQUHFtSURFDVSRUVXSDUWH(QODVLWXDFLyQGHDXOD DXPHQWDVXSRSXODULGDGHQUHODFLyQDOGHODFODVHGHHGXFDFLyQItVLFD\GLVPLQX\HVXDQWLSDWtD IUHQWHDOGHODVHVLyQGH(GXFDFLyQ)tVLFD -RUGLHPLWHFLQFRHOHFFLRQHVH[SDQVLYLGDGSRVLWLYD\HVHO~QLFRGHODFODVHTXHQRHPLWHUHFKD]RV H[SDQVLYLGDGQHJDWLYD'HODVFXDWURHOHFFLRQHVTXHUHFLEHDFLHUWDGRVDWHQFLyQSHUFHSWLYDSRVLWLYD DXQTXHHVSHUDTXHOHHOLMDQFXDWURUHDOLVPRSHUFHSWLYRSRVLWLYREDVWDQWHPiVDOWRTXHHQOD VLWXDFLyQ GH OD VHVLyQ GH (GXFDFLyQ )tVLFD 'H ODV SHUVRQDV TXH OH UHFKD]DQ -RUGL DFLHUWD XQD DWHQFLyQ SHUFHSWLYD QHJDWLYD DXQTXH pO HVSHUDED VHU UHFKD]DGR SRU WUHV UHDOLVPR SHUFHSWLYR QHJDWLYRXQSRFREDMR 6L REVHUYDPRVODILJXUDSRGHPRV HYLGHQFLDU TXH -RUGL HPLWHHOHFFLRQHVDFKLFRV'RVGHHOODV UHFLEHQUHFLSURFLGDGIXHUWH3HUH\/OXtV\ODVRWUDVWUHVQRODUHFLEHQ0LJXHOÉQJHO&DUORV \ 2ULRO &RPR KHPRV FRPHQWDGR DQWHULRUPHQWH QR HPLWH UHFKD]R DOJXQR 5HFLEH FXDWUR HOHFFLRQHVDGHPiVGHODVGRVUHFtSURFDV\DFRPHQWDGDV5DIDHO\)HUUDQORHOLJHQSDUDIRUPDU SDUWHGHVXJUXSRHQHODXOD (VUHFKD]DGRSRUGRVGHOVXEJUXSRGHODVFKLFDV/RODTXHHVHORWURVXMHWRGHOHVWXGLRGHFDVRV\ 2OJDXQDGHODVOtGHUHVGHODVFKLFDV6LHQHOFDVRGH/RODHVVXTXLQWRUHFKD]R\SRUORWDQWROH RWRUJDXQHQVXVUHFKD]RVHQHOFDVRGH2OJDHVHOSULPHURHVRVLJQLILFDTXHHVODSHUVRQDTXH2OJD PiV UHFKD]D $ SHVDU GH HVWR -RUGL QR ODV UHFKD]D DXQTXH Vt HVSHUD TXH /ROD QR TXLHUD IRUPDU SDUWHGHVXJUXSR (Q UHVXPHQ SRGHPRV FRQVLGHUDU TXH OD VLWXDFLyQ GH -RUGL GHQWUR GHO DXOD HV PXFKR PHMRU TXH HQ OD VHVLyQ GH (GXFDFLyQ )tVLFD SXHV WLHQH XQ PHMRU HVWDWXV VRFLRPpWULFR \ UHFLEH PiV HOHFFLRQHV SULQFLSDOPHQWH GHO JUXSR GH ORV FKLFRV \ PHQRV UHFKD]RV GHO VXEJUXSR GH ODV FKLFDV $ SHVDU GH HVWR VLJXH VLQ HPLWLU UHFKD]R DOJXQR (V XQ SRFR PiV DWHQWR \ HV PiV UHDOLVWD HQ VX UHODFLyQ FRQ ORV GHPiVHQHODXOD 0$5=2 6(6,Ð1'(('8&$&,Ð1)Ì6,&$ )LJ6RFLRJUDPDLQGLYLGXDOGH-RUGLHQODVLWXDFLyQGHODVHVLyQ GH(GXFDFLyQ)tVLFDFRUUHVSRQGLHQWHDODDGPLQLVWUDFLyQGHPDU]RGH ,1',&(662&,20(75,&26'(-25', 67$78662&,20(75,&2 66 &RQH[LyQDIHFWLYD &$ 3RSXODULGDG 3RS $QWLSDWtD ([SS ([SDQVLYLGDG([SQ $WHQFLyQSHUFHSWLYD $3S $WHQFLyQSHUFHSWLYD$3Q 5HDOLVPRSHUFHSWLYR53S 5HDOLVPRSHUFHSWLYR53S ([SDQVLYLGDG $QW (Q HVWH VHJXQGR WULPHVWUH HO HVWDWXV VRFLRPpWULFR GH -RUGL DXPHQWD VHQVLEOHPHQWH SDVDQGR D VHU SRVLWLYRDKRUDHVGHSRVLWLYRRFXSDQGRHOWUHFHDYROXJDUHQODFODVH6XSRVLFLyQFRQWLQ~DVLHQGR PHGLD (VWH UHVXOWDGR WLHQH VX SULQFLSDO PRWLYR HQ HO DXPHQWR GH VX SRSXODULGDG \ HO GHVFHQVR GH OD DQWLSDWtD TXH JHQHUD HQ VXV FRPSDxHURV HQ RWUDV SDODEUDV HV PiV HOHJLGR \ PHQRV UHFKD]DGR TXH DQWHV 3HURHVWRVQRVRQORV~QLFRVFDPELRVVXUJLGRVHQ-RUGL2WURFDPELRHVHOLQLFLRGHOUHFKD]RDDOJXQRV FRPSDxHURVFRPRSULQFLSLRGHOUHDOLVPRSHUFHSWLYRQHJDWLYR\ODDWHQFLyQSHUFHSWLYDQHJDWLYDHPSLH]DD GDUVHFXHQWDTXHKD\SHUVRQDVHQODFODVHTXHQRVRQGHVXDJUDGR\GHMDGHFRQVLGHUDUDWRGRVVXV FRPSDxHURV FRPR ³DPLJRV´ SRU LJXDO $GHPiV DXPHQWD VX UHDOLVPR SHUFHSWLYR SRVLWLYR VLHQGR PiV FRQVHFXHQWHFRQTXLpQHOLJH\TXLHQHVORHOLJHQ 6LREVHUYDPRVODILJXUDSRGHPRVFRQVWDWDUTXH-RUGLHPLWHFXDWURHOHFFLRQHVSRVLWLYDVDPLHPEURV GHO VXEJUXSR GH FKLFRV GH ODV FXDOHV VRQ FRUUHVSRQGLGDV 3HUH FRQ HO TXH \D PDQWHQtD XQD UHFLSURFLGDGSRVLWLYDHQHOSULPHUWULPHVWUH\2ULRO'HODVRWUDVGRVTXHUHDOL]DQRUHFLEHUHVSXHVWD /OXtV \ &DUORV D SHVDU GH TXH HVSHUD XQD UHFLSURFLGDG SRU VX SDUWH 5HFLEH DGHPiV ODV HOHFFLRQHV SRVLWLYDV GH /ROD ~QLFD FKLFD TXH OR HOLJH \ GH 0LJXHO ÉQJHO DO TXH UHFKD]D IRUPiQGRVH XQD RSRVLFLyQ GH VHQWLPLHQWRV TXH GHQRWD OD IDOWD GH UHDOLVPR QR VyOR HQ -RUGL UHDOLVPR SHUFHSWLYRQHJDWLYR VLQRWDPELpQHQ0LJXHOÉQJHOUHDOLVPRSHUFHSWLYRSRVLWLYR $VXYH] HPLWH FXDWUR HOHFFLRQHV QHJDWLYDV D WUHV FKLFDV 0LUHLD 7HUHVD \ )HUQDQGD \ XQ FKLFR 0LJXHOÉQJHO\DFRPHQWDGRDQWHULRUPHQWH\UHFLEHRWUDVGRV0HUFq\<DVRQH -RUGLHVHOHJLGRRUHFKD]DGRSRUFULWHULRVGHVLPSDWtDRDQWLSDWtDHQODVLWXDFLyQGH(GXFDFLyQ)tVLFD\HQ QLQJ~QPRPHQWRVHKDFHUHIHUHQFLDDVXOLPLWDFLyQ(O~QLFRTXHKDFHPtQLPDUHIHUHQFLDDHOORHV3HUH \ OR KDFH GH IRUPD SRVLWLYD ³VRQ ORV PiV GHSRUWLVWDV´ GLFH HQ UHIHUHQFLD D DTXHOORV D ORV TXH KD HVFRJLGR HQWUH ORV TXH HVWi -RUGL /DV RWUDV WUHV HOHFFLRQHV TXH UHFLEH FRPR \D KHPRV FRPHQWDGR DQWHULRUPHQWHVHUHILHUHQDFULWHULRVGHVLPSDWtD$VtPLHQWUDV0LJXHOÉQJHOORHOLJHSRUTXH³(VXQR GHORVTXHPHMRUVHSRUWDFRQPLJR´/RODORHVFRJHSRUTXH³(VXQRGHPLVPHMRUHVDPLJRV´\FRQHVWR PLVPRVHMXVWLILFD2ULROHQVXHOHFFLyQDOGHFLUTXH³(VDPLJR´ 3RUVXSDUWH-RUGLWDPELpQHOLJHRUHFKD]DHQIXQFLyQGHODVLPSDWtDTXHOHJHQHUDQVXVFRPSDxHURV'H DTXHOORVDORVTXHHOLJHGLFHTXH³DYHFHVTXHGDPRVHQFDVDGHDOJXQR\MXJDPRV´HQFODUDDOXVLyQD TXH DTXHOORV TXH KD HVFRJLGR VRQ VX JUXSR GH UHIHUHQFLD PLHQWUDV TXH GH ORV UHFKD]DGRV GLFH TXH ³KDFHQEURPDVWRQWDV´ 6L FRPSDUDPRV OD SUXHED VWDQGDUG FRQ OD SUXHED GH FRQWURO SRGHPRV FRPSUREDU TXH QR H[LVWHQ GLIHUHQFLDVVXVWDQFLDOHVHQWUHODVGRVDGPLQLVWUDFLRQHVSXHVWRTXHHOQXPHURGHHOHFFLRQHV\UHFKD]RV DVtFRPRDOJXQRVGHVXVtQGLFHVVRQPX\SDUHFLGRVHQWUHVt (QUHVXPHQ-RUGLKDPHMRUDGRXQSRFRVXVLWXDFLyQHQODVHVLyQGH(GXFDFLyQ)tVLFDSXHVSDUHFHTXH HPSLH]DDHQWUDUGHQWURGHOQ~FOHRGHOVXEJUXSRGHORVFKLFRV$GHPiVQRJHQHUDWDQWDDQWLSDWtDFRPR HQ HO SULPHU WULPHVWUH /H VLJXH IDOWDQGR PDGXUH] \ UHDOLVPR D OD KRUD GH LQWHUSUHWDU ODV DFFLRQHV \ ODV LQWHQFLRQHVGHVXVFRPSDxHURVHQUHIHUHQFLDDpO $8/$ )LJ6RFLRJUDPDLQGLYLGXDOGH-RUGLHQODVLWXDFLyQGHDXOD FRUUHVSRQGLHQWHDODDGPLQLVWUDFLyQGHPDU]RGH ,1',&(662&,20(75,&26'(-25', 67$78662&,20(75,&2 66 &RQH[LyQDIHFWLYD &$ 3RSXODULGDG 3RS $QWLSDWtD ([SS ([SDQVLYLGDG([SQ $WHQFLyQSHUFHSWLYD $3S $WHQFLyQSHUFHSWLYD$3Q 5HDOLVPRSHUFHSWLYR53S 5HDOLVPRSHUFHSWLYR53S ([SDQVLYLGDG $QW (Q HVWH VHJXQGR WULPHVWUH HO HVWDWXV VRFLRPpWULFR GH -RUGL HQ OD VLWXDFLyQ GH DXOD GLVPLQX\H VHQVLEOHPHQWHHQHOSULPHUWULPHVWUHHUDSHURDOLJXDOTXHHQHOSULPHUWULPHVWUHHVPiVDOWRTXHHQ ODVLWXDFLyQGHODVHVLyQGH(GXFDFLyQ)tVLFDHQHVWHVHJXQGRWULPHVWUH -RUGLPDQWLHQHHOPLVPRtQGLFHGHSRSXODULGDGSHURDXPHQWDODDQWLSDWtDTXHJHQHUDUHFLEHPiV UHFKD]RV1RH[LVWHQGLIHUHQFLDVVLJQLILFDWLYDVFRQODVLWXDFLyQGH(GXFDFLyQ)tVLFDHQFXDQWRDQXPHUR GH HOHFFLRQHV R UHFKD]RV UHFLELGRV VLHQGR ORV GRV PX\ SDUHFLGRV 'RQGH Vt KD\ GLIHUHQFLD HV HQ OD DWHQFLyQ\HOUHDOLVPRQHJDWLYRVGRQGH-RUGLHPSLH]DDGDUPXHVWUDVGHTXHHVFDSD]GHHPSDWL]DUFRQ DOJXQRVGHVXVFRPSDxHURV\FRPSUHQGHUVXVLQWHQFLRQHV(VWRVGRVtQGLFHVDXQTXHDOJREDMRV\ GLILHUHQGHODQXODFDSDFLGDGHQHVWRVDVSHFWRVGHPRVWUDGDSRU-RUGLHQHOSULPHUWULPHVWUH -RUGLHOLJHDFXDWURFKLFRV3HUH/OXtV&DUORV\2ULROORVPLVPRVTXHHQODVLWXDFLyQ GH(GXFDFLyQ)tVLFD\PDQWLHQHXQDUHFLSURFLGDGSRVLWLYDFRQHOSULPHUR\HO~OWLPRGHHOORVGHODPLVPD IRUPD TXH HQ OD VLWXDFLyQ GH (GXFDFLyQ )tVLFD \ D SHVDU GH TXH HVSHUD ODV HOHFFLRQHV GH ORV FXDWUR 7DPELpQUHFKD]DDFXDWURSHUVRQDV0LUHLD7HUHVD0HUFq\<DVRQHWRGDVHOODVFKLFDV \TXH\DUHFKD]DEDHQODVLWXDFLyQGH(GXFDFLyQ)tVLFD'HHVWRVFXDWURUHFKD]RVGRV7HUHVD\0HUFq VRQUHFtSURFRV $GHPiVGHODVGRVUHFLSURFLGDGHVSRVLWLYDV\QHJDWLYDV\DFRPHQWDGDVDQWHULRUPHQWH-RUGLUHFLEHGRV HOHFFLRQHVSRVLWLYDVSRUSDUWHGHGRVFKLFDVXQDGHFDGDVXEJUXSRGHODVFKLFDV/RODSRUSDUWHGHO VXEJUXSR \ )UDQFLQD SRU SDUWH GHO VXEJUXSR 5HFLEH DGHPiV GH ODV GRV UHFLSURFLGDGHV ORV UHFKD]RVGHGRVFKLFDV/tGLD\)HUQDQGD (Q OD VLWXDFLyQ GH DXOD -RUGL FRQWLQ~D VLHQGR HVFRJLGR R UHFKD]DGR SRU VXV FRPSDxHURV PiV SRU FULWHULRVGHVLPSDWtDRDQWLSDWtDTXHQRSRUVXUHQGLPLHQWRHQHODXOD/RVTXHORUHFKD]DQVHTXHMDQGH TXHHVSHVDGRJULWDRTXLHUHVHUHOFHQWURGHDWHQFLyQPLHQWUDVTXHORVTXHORHOLJHQORKDFHQSRUTXHOR FRQVLGHUDQVXDPLJR$Vt)UDQFLQDFRPHQWDTXH-RUGLHV³0X\EXHQDPLJR\PHJXVWDHVWDUFRQpO 7LHQHPXFKRVSUREOHPDVSHURWUDEDMDELHQDXQTXHHVKDEODGRU´ 3RU VX SDUWH -RUGL UHFKD]D SRU DQWLSDWtD SHUR D OD KRUD GH HOHJLU QR VyOR OR KDFH SRU VLPSDWtD VLQR WDPELpQ PRVWUDQGR FRQRFLPLHQWR GH TXLpQ OH DFHSWD \ TXLHQ QR OR TXH VH UHIOHMD OXHJR HQ VX DWHQFLyQ SHUFHSWLYD \ VX UHDOLVPR SHUFHSWLYR VXSHULRUHV DO SULPHU WULPHVWUH 'LFH GH 2ULRO TXH ³VLHPSUH OH TXLHUH D\XGDU´ OR TXH PXHVWUD HVWD FDSDFLGDG GH GDUVH FXHQWD GH ODV DFFLRQHV H LQWHQFLRQHV GH ODV SHUVRQDVHQWRUQRDpO &RPSDUDQGRORVGDWRVHQWUHODSUXHEDVWDQGDUG\ODGHFRQWUROSRGHPRVREVHUYDUTXHORVUHVXOWDGRVDO LJXDOTXHHQODVLWXDFLyQGHODFODVHGHHGXFDFLyQItVLFDVRQPX\SDUHFLGRVHQWUHVt -81,2 ('8&$&,Ð1)Ì6,&$ )LJ6RFLRJUDPDLQGLYLGXDOGH-RUGLHQODVLWXDFLyQGH(GXFDFLyQ)tVLFDFRUUHVSRQGLHQWH DODDGPLQLVWUDFLyQGHMXQLRGH ,1',&(662&,20(75,&26'(-25', 67$78662&,20(75,&2 66 &RQH[LyQDIHFWLYD &$ 3RSXODULGDG 3RS $QWLSDWtD $QW ([SDQVLYLGDG ([SS ([SDQVLYLGDG([SQ $WHQFLyQSHUFHSWLYD $3S $WHQFLyQSHUFHSWLYD$3Q 5HDOLVPRSHUFHSWLYR53S 5HDOLVPRSHUFHSWLYR53S -RUGL JHQHUD PiV HOHFFLRQHV TXH QXQFD SHUR VRQ HQ VX PD\RU SDUWH QHJDWLYDV 7DQ VyOR UHFLEH GRV HOHFFLRQHV SRVLWLYDV PLHQWUDV TXH VLHWH VRQ ODV QHJDWLYDV 'H DKt HO IXHUWH GHVFHQVR GH VX HVWDWXV VRFLRPpWULFRTXHSDVDGHVHUSRVLWLYRDVHUQHJDWLYR$KRUD-RUGLRFXSDHOOXJDUGLHFLRFKR GHQWURGHODFODVHXQRGHORV~OWLPRVVLHQGRHOSHRUOXJDUHQODVWUHVDGPLQLVWUDFLRQHV 6X tQGLFH GH SRSXODULGDG GHVFLHQGH D OD PLWDG \ DXPHQWD HO GH DQWLSDWtD SDVD GH D 6X H[SDQVLYLGDGSRVLWLYD\QHJDWLYDVHPDQWLHQHLQDOWHUDGD(OVHJXQGRDVSHFWRTXHGHVWDFDHVDODXPHQWR GHVXDWHQFLyQ\UHDOLVPRSHUFHSWLYRVVLHQGRHOUHDOLVPRDOWR(VWRQRVOOHYDDSHQVDUTXH-RUGLHV PX\FRQVFLHQWHGHVXVLWXDFLyQ\HQTXpSHUVRQDVJHQHUDUHFKD]R -RUGLHOLJHDFLQFRPLHPEURVGHOVXEJUXSRGHORVFKLFRV3HUH/OXtV5DIDHO&DUORV\ 2ULROVLHQGRFRUUHVSRQGLGRSRUGRVGHHOORV&DUORV\2ULRO6XPRWLYRGHHOHFFLyQKDFLDHOORVHV TXH³VLHPSUHPHD\XGDQHQWRGRORTXHSXHGHQ´ $ODKRUDGHUHFKD]DUORGLULJHDODVFKLFDV(QFRQFUHWRFXDWURGHOVXEJUXSR0LUHLD7HUHVD 5RFtR \ /ROD VLHQGR FRUUHVSRQGLGR QHJDWLYDPHQWH SRU 0LUHLD 7HUHVD \ /ROD \ D XQD GHO VXEJUXSRGHODVFKLFDV0DUWDFRQTXLHQPDQWLHQHWDPELpQXQDUHFLSURFLGDGQHJDWLYD -RUGLUHFLEHUHFKD]RVWDPELpQGHRWUDVFXDWURSHUVRQDV0LJXHOÉQJHO~QLFRFKLFRTXHORUHFKD]D /tGLD)HUQDQGD\-DQD -RUGL VLJXH VLHQGR HOHJLGR SRU PRWLYRV GH VLPSDWtD ORV GRV UHIOHMDQ TXH -RUGL HV VX DPLJR \ HV UHFKD]DGRSULQFLSDOPHQWHSRUPRWLYRVGHDQWLSDWtD³HVSHVDGRKDFHWRQWHUtDVVHHQIDGD«´+D\GRV FRPSDxHURV0LJXHOÉQJHO\0LUHLDTXHVHUHILHUHQDVXVOLPLWDFLRQHVDODKRUDGHUHFKD]DUOR 0LJXHO ÉQJHO FRPHQWD TXH ³SXHGH KDFHUVH GDxR TXH PHMRU SUHYHQLU´ \ 0LUHLD TXH ³FXHVWD PXFKR OOHYDUORHQORVMXHJRV´ -RUGL HOLJH D DTXHOORV TXH FUHH TXH OH D\XGDQ PiV HQ FODVH \ UHFKD]D FDVL SRU HOLPLQDFLyQ SXHV GH DTXHOORVTXHUHFKD]DVXEUD\DTXH³QRKDEORPXFKRFRQHOORV´PDUFDQGRDVtTXHPiVTXHXQUHFKD]R HPLWH FDUHQFLD GH HOHFFLyQ /D ~QLFD H[FHSFLyQ D HVWH FDVR HV /ROD GH OD TXH GLFH TXH ³VLHPSUH TXLHUHWHQHUUD]yQ´ &RQYLHQH TXL]iV DKRQGDU HQ OD UHODFLyQ HQWUH -RUGL \ GRV GH VXV FRPSDxHURV FRPR SHUVRQDV LPSRUWDQWHVFDVLVLHPSUHDSDUHFHQHQORVVRFLRJUDPDVLQGLYLGXDOHVGH-RUGLSDUDpO\VREUHWRGRSRUODV FDUDFWHUtVWLFDVGHHVWDVGRVUHODFLRQHV &RQ/ROD6LHQODVHJXQGDDGPLQLVWUDFLyQUHFLEtDXQDHOHFFLyQSRVLWLYDSRUVXSDUWHTXHpOQR FRUUHVSRQGtDHQOD~OWLPDDGPLQLVWUDFLyQPDQWLHQHQXQUHFKD]RUHFtSURFR$Vt-RUGLRSLQDGH HVWRTXH³6L/RODQRIXHUDHQVLOODGHUXHGDVQRFRPSDUWLUtDFRQPLJRORVMXHJRV1XQFDPH HVFRJHUtD³ (V HYLGHQWH SXHV TXH -RUGL HQWLHQGH HVWD HOHFFLyQ UHFLELGD HQ OD VHJXQGD DGPLQLVWUDFLyQFRPRXQLQWHUpVSRUSDUWHGH/RODTXHVHHQFXHQWUDHQXQDVLWXDFLyQTXHQRHV QDWXUDOSDUDHOODGHQRTXHGDUVH VROD \ TXH ODVGHPiVODGHMHQGHODGR6LDxDGLPRVTXH/ROD RSLQD GH -RUGL TXH HV ³$QWLSiWLFR D YHFHV &XDQGR VH HQIDGD SDUHFH XQ WHUUHPRWR´ SRGUtDPRV DxDGLU TXH HO LQWHQWR GH DFHUFDPLHQWR GH /ROD KDFLD -RUGL QR KD IXQFLRQDGR SRUTXH pO OR KD HQWHQGLGRFRPRXQJHVWRGHLQWHUpV\HOODKDYLVWRTXHpOQRHUDVLPSiWLFRFRQHOOD &RQ &DUORV H[LVWH XQ KHFKR TXH FRQYLHQH H[SOLFDU DTXt SXHV VHJ~Q QRV FRQWy GXUDQWH OD WHUFHUDDGPLQLVWUDFLyQ\TXHHUDGHVFRQRFLGRLQFOXVRSRUHOSURIHVRUDGRDpOVHOHHVFDSyODVLOOD GH-RUGLPLHQWUDVMXJDEDQ\VHVHQWtDFXOSDEOHGHORVXFHGLGR'HPDQHUDTXHODHYROXFLyQSRU SDUWHGH&DUORVGHVGHHOUHFKD]R\FRQVLJXLHQWHIRUPDFLyQGHRSRVLFLyQGHVHQWLPLHQWRVGDGDOD HOHFFLyQ UHFLELGD SRU SDUWH GH -RUGL HQ OD SULPHUD DGPLQLVWUDFLyQ KDVWD OD UHFLSURFLGDG HQ OD ~OWLPD VH H[SOLFD EDVWDQWH ELHQ HQ ODV SDODEUDV GHO SURSLR &DUORV FXDQGR FRPHQWD TXH ³6RPRV PX\ DPLJRV < DXQTXH VH PH FD\y PH GHFtD SRVWHULRUPHQWH ³TXH QR SDVD QDGD FROHJD´´ 3RU WDQWRODHYROXFLyQGHODUHODFLyQHQWUHHOORVGRVVHSXHGHGLYLGLUHQWUHVHWDSDV 2SRVLFLyQGHVHQWLPLHQWRV'RQGH&DUORVVHDSURYHFKDGH-RUGLSXHV-RUGLHOLJHD&DUORV HVSHUDQGRXQDUHFLSURFLGDGSRVLWLYDSHURHQOXJDUGHHVWR&DUORVORUHFKD]D (OHFFLyQ GH -RUGL H LQGLIHUHQFLD GH &DUORV 0LHQWUDV H[LVWH HVWD RSRVLFLyQ GH VHQWLPLHQWRV VXFHGHHODFFLGHQWHGH-RUGL(QWRQFHV&DUORVGHMDGHUHFKD]DUOR\VLQWLpQGRVHFXOSDEOHSRU ORVXFHGLGRWUDWDGHHYLWDUORHQORSRVLEOH 5HFLSURFLGDG SRVLWLYD HQWUH DPERV &DUORV GHVFXEUH HQ -RUGL DOJR PiV TXH OD SHUVRQD FRQ OLPLWDFLRQHVGHODTXHVHDSURYHFKDED\HQWHQGLHQGRORVHVWtPXORVH[WHUQRVSURYHQLHQWHVGH -RUGL QR KD\ TXH ROYLGDU TXH &DUORV HV HO SURWDJRQLVWD GH PXFKDV RSRVLFLRQHV GH VHQWLPLHQWRV D OR ODUJR GH WRGR HO FXUVR SXHV OH FXHVWD HQWHQGHU ORV HVWtPXORV H[WHUQRV \ H[SUHVDUORVVX\RVSURSLRVRSLQDTXHHVPX\EXHQDPLJRVX\RSRUSHUGRQDUOHORTXHSDVyHQ HODFFLGHQWH $8/$ )LJ6RFLRJUDPDLQGLYLGXDOGH-RUGLHQODVLWXDFLyQGHDXOD FRUUHVSRQGLHQWHDODDGPLQLVWUDFLyQGHMXQLRGH ,1',&(662&,20(75,&26'(-25', 67$78662&,20(75,&2 66 &RQH[LyQDIHFWLYD &$ 3RSXODULGDG 3RS $QWLSDWtD ([SS ([SDQVLYLGDG([SQ $WHQFLyQSHUFHSWLYD $3S $WHQFLyQSHUFHSWLYD$3Q 5HDOLVPRSHUFHSWLYR53S 5HDOLVPRSHUFHSWLYR53S ([SDQVLYLGDG $QW -RUGLPDQWLHQHVXHVWDWXVVRFLRPpWULFRGHQWURGHOJUXSRDXQTXHPHMRUDQGROHYHPHQWHVXSRVLFLyQSDVD GH VHU HO D VHU HO 0DQWLHQH WDQWR OD DQWLSDWtD TXH JHQHUD FRPR OD TXH HPLWH \ DXPHQWD VX VLPSDWtD \ VX H[SDQVLYLGDG SRVLWLYD 6X FRQH[LyQ DIHFWLYD VH PDQWLHQH LQDOWHUDEOH HQ HO HOLJH D OD PLWDGGHORVTXHOHHVFRJHQDpO 6X DWHQFLyQSHUFHSWLYDSRVLWLYDVHPXHYH HQWRUQR DO WDPELpQ GH OD PLVPD PDQHUD TXH OR KDFHHO UHDOLVPRSHUFHSWLYRTXHDXPHQWDUHVSHFWRDOWULPHVWUHDQWHULRU0LHQWUDVTXHVXDWHQFLyQSHUFHSWLYDVH PDQLILHVWDHQODPLVPDSURSRUFLyQTXHHQHOWULPHVWUHDQWHULRUVXUHDOLVPRSHUFHSWLYRVHUHGXFHXQSRFR HQ HVWD ~OWLPD DGPLQLVWUDFLyQ $ SHVDU GH VHU HVWRV GRV ~OWLPRV tQGLFHV PHGLREDMRV VH PXHVWUD XQD WHQGHQFLDHQ-RUGLDVHUFRQVFLHQWHGH VXHQWRUQR\GHODVLQWHQFLRQHVTXHWLHQHQVXVFRPSDxHURVGH FODVHDODFHUFDUVHDpO (QHVWHFDVR-RUGLVLJXHHOLJLHQGRWDQVyORDFKLFRV3HUH/OXtV5DIDHO)HUUDQ\2ULRO PDQWHQLHQGRUHFLSURFLGDGSRVLWLYDFRQWUHVGHHOORV3HUH/OXtV\2ULRO/DVUD]RQHVGHHOHFFLyQ VRQ ³SRUTXH HVWXGLD PXFKR´ ³SRUTXH HV WUDEDMDGRU´ R ELHQ SRUTXH ³PH FDH ELHQ \ HV VLPSiWLFR´ $ OD KRUD GH UHFKD]DU WDQ VyOR OR KDFH D FKLFDV 0LUHLD FRQ TXLpQ WLHQH XQD RSRVLFLyQ GH VHQWLPLHQWRV ³6LHPSUHYDFRQ/ROD\VLHPSUHGLFHTXHQRPLUHDOD/ROD0HFRPHQWDTXHQLPLUHD/RODQLODPLUHD HOOD 0H GLFH ³KD\ XQD EDUUHUD \ QR PLUHV´ 7HUHVD VLHQGR UHFtSURFR HO UHFKD]R ³6LHPSUH OH KDJR EURPDVFRPRµ7HUHVDOD0DFKR¶\FXDQGRORKDJRPHSHJDHQODFDUD´\VXPDPRVD/ROD\-DQD 5HVSHFWR D OD SULPHUD DILUPD TXH ³PH FDH PDO 6LHPSUH TXLHUH WHQHU OD UD]yQ 0H GLFH µQR PH PLUHV¶&XDQGRPHQRVHVWpFRQHOODPHMRU´(QFXDQWRD-DQDODUHFKD]D³SRUTXHHVXQSRFRDQWLSiWLFD\ PDOKDEODGD´7RGDVVRQDGHPiVGHOVXEJUXSRGHODVFKLFDV $ODKRUDGHUHFLELUHOHFFLRQHVLQGHSHQGLHQWHPHQWHGHODVWUHVUHFLSURFLGDGHVSRVLWLYDV-RUGLUHFLEHODV HOHFFLRQHVGH0LUHLD)UDQFLQD\&DUORV&RQ0LUHLDIRUPDXQDRSRVLFLyQGHVHQWLPLHQWRV GRQGH-RUGLUHFKD]DD0LUHLDSRUTXH³HVDPLJDGH/ROD\PHGLFHTXHQRODPLUHQLDHOODQLD/ROD\ 0LUHLDORHVFRJHSRUTXH³FRPRQRPHOOHYRGHPDVLDGRELHQFRQpOPHFRQFHQWURPiV´(VWDRSRVLFLyQGH VHQWLPLHQWRVSDUHFHSXHVPiVGHELGDDXQDIDOWDGHUHDOLVPRGH0LUHLDTXHDRWURVPRWLYRV$GLIHUHQFLD GHRWURVWULPHVWUHV\DXQTXH-RUGLVLJXHVLHQGRHVFRJLGRSRUPRWLYRVGHVLPSDWtDDOJXQRVKDEODQGHVXV SRWHQFLDOLGDGHVDODKRUDGHHVFRJHUORSDUDVXJUXSR³WLHQHPXFKDVLGHDVHVPX\FRPXQLFDWLYR´« -RUGLHVUHFKD]DGRDGHPiVGHODUHFLSURFLGDGQHJDWLYDTXHPDQWLHQHFRQ7HUHVDSRU0DUWDSRU 5RFtR\0HUFq/RVPRWLYRVGHUHFKD]RVHPDQWLHQHQFRQUHVSHFWRDOVHJXQGRWULPHVWUHVLHQGR OD DQWLSDWtD HO SULPHU PRWLYR ³HV XQ SHVDGR QR PH OOHYR ELHQ FRQ pO«´ DXQTXH WDPELpQ DOJXQRV FRPHQWDQRWURVDVSHFWRVQHJDWLYRV³JULWDVHFRSLD«´ 7DQWR HQ HVWD VLWXDFLyQ GH DXOD FRPR HQ OD HGXFDFLyQ ItVLFD QR H[LVWHQ JUDQGHV GLIHUHQFLDV HQWUH HVWD DGPLQLVWUDFLyQ \ OD DGPLQLVWUDFLyQ GH FRQWURO $ GHVWDFDU WDQ VyOR \ FRPR DOJR QDWXUDO SRU ORV PRWLYRV DQWHULRUPHQWHFRPHQWDGRVTXHUHFLEHXQQ~PHURPD\RUWDQWRGHHOHFFLRQHVFRPRGHUHFKD]RVDXQTXH QLQJXQRGHORVGRVOOHJDDVHUVLJQLILFDWLYR (QUHVXPHQ-RUGLPHMRUDOHYHPHQWHVXHVWDWXVPDQWHQLpQGRORSRVLWLYR\HQXQDSRVLFLyQLQWHUPHGLDGHO JUXSRPDQWHQLHQGRUHFKD]RVFRQODVFKLFDVGHOVXEJUXSRSULQFLSDOPHQWH\HOHFFLRQHVFRQORVFKLFRV TXHORHVFRJHQ\DQRWDQVyORSRUVLPSDWtDVLQRSRUVXVFDSDFLGDGHVGHWUDEDMRHQJUXSR &8$'525(680(1-25', 6,78$&,Ð1'(('8&$&,Ð1)Ì6,&$ 6,78$&,Ð1'($8/$ 2FWXEUH 0DU]R -XQLR 2FWXEUH 0DU]R -XQLR 66 &$ 3RSXODULGDG $QWLSDWtD ([S ([S $3 $3 53 53 (VWDWXV6RFLRPpWULFR66(Q(GXFDFLyQ)tVLFDVHGHWHFWDXQSHTXHxRDXPHQWRHQHOVHJXQGR WULPHVWUHSHURHQHOWHUFHUREDMDVLJQLILFDWLYDPHQWHKDVWDWHQHUXQRGHORVPiVEDMRVGHODFODVH (QHODXODDXQTXHGHVFLHQGHOHYHPHQWHVHDILDQ]DHQXQDVLWXDFLyQLQWHUPHGLDGHOJUXSR &RQH[LyQ$IHFWLYD&$(Q(GXFDFLyQ)tVLFDDFDEDFRQSRFRVDPLJRVSHURPX\VLJQLILFDWLYRV &$ HOPi[LPR$WRGRVORVTXHORHVFRJHQpOWDPELpQORVHOLJH(QHODXODVHPDQWLHQHHQHO DORODUJRGHWRGRHOFXUVR 3RSXODULGDG(Q(GXFDFLyQ)tVLFDSHVHDPHMRUDUHOQ~PHURGHHOHFFLRQHVUHFLELGDVGXUDQWHHO VHJXQGRWULPHVWUHYXHOYDDORVUHVXOWDGRVGHLQLFLRGHFXUVRHOHFFLRQHVUHFLELGDV(QHODXODVH PDQWLHQHHQWRUQRDODVHOHFFLRQHVUHFLELGDVSDUDDFDEDUDXPHQWDQGRFRQVLGHUDEOHPHQWHHVWH tQGLFHDOILQDOGHFXUVR $QWLSDWtD $XPHQWD HQ ODV GRV VLWXDFLRQHV D OR ODUJR GHO FXUVR SHUR OR KDFH GH IRUPD PiV VLJQLILFDWLYDHQODVLWXDFLyQGH(GXFDFLyQ)tVLFDGRQGHOOHJDDUHFLELUUHFKD]RGHXQDWHUFHUDSDUWH GHODFODVHHQHOWHUFHUWULPHVWUH $WHQFLyQ \ 3HUFHSFLyQ 3RVLWLYD $3 6H PDQWLHQH HQ HO GXUDQWH WRGR HO FXUVR +D SUHVWDGR EDVWDQWH DWHQFLyQ D ORV HVWtPXORV H[WHUQRV HQ IRUPD GH HOHFFLyQ WDQWR HQ (GXFDFLyQ )tVLFDFRPRHQHODXOD $WHQFLyQ \ 3HUFHSFLyQ 1HJDWLYD $3 ,QH[LVWHQWH HQ (GXFDFLyQ )tVLFD HQ ORV GRV SULPHURV WULPHVWUHV DFDED VLHQGR GH XQ YDORU PHGLR (Q HO DXOD GHVFLHQGH VX SHUFHSFLyQ GH ORV HVWtPXORVH[WHUQRVHQIRUPDGHUHFKD]RDORODUJRGHOFXUVRDFDEDQGRHQXQtQGLFHPHGLREDMR 5HDOLVPR 3HUFHSWLYR 3RVLWLYR 53 (Q OD VLWXDFLyQ GH (GXFDFLyQ )tVLFD -RUGL HV H[FHVLYDPHQWHRSWLPLVWDHQODVHOHFFLRQHVTXHFUHHTXHUHFLELUiPLHQWUDVTXHHQHODXODVHOHYH PiV DVHQWDGR HQ HO JUXSR \ PX\ UHDOLVWD FRQ DTXHOORV FRPSDxHURV TXH FUHH TXH OR HVFRJHUiQ SULQFLSDOPHQWHHQHOWHUFHUWULPHVWUH 5HDOLVPR3HUFHSWLYR1HJDWLYR53(QODVLWXDFLyQGH(GXFDFLyQ)tVLFDQRHVUHDOLVWDHQODV VLWXDFLRQHV GH UHFKD]R KDVWD HO WHUFHU WULPHVWUH GRQGH OR HV HQ XQ (Q OD GH DXOD DXQTXHXQSRFRPiVUHDOLVWDXQDWHUFHUDSDUWHGHORVUHFKD]RVHQORVGRVSULPHURVWULPHVWUHV GHVFLHQGHKDFLDHOILQDOGHFXUVR &(1752/2/$ ÌQGLFHVVRFLRPpWULFRVLQGLYLGXDOHV (3(OHFFLRQHV3RVLWLYDV5HFLELGDV (1(OHFFLRQHV1HJDWLYDV5HFLELGDV (6 (VWDWXV 6RFLRPpWULFR HQ SDUpQWHVLV HO RUGHQ TXH RFXSD HQ OD FODVH VHJ~Q ORV UHVXOWDGRVGHHVWHtQGLFH ('8&$&,Ð1)Ì6,&$ $8/$ 2FWXEUH 0DU]R -XQLR 2FWXEUH 0DU]R -XQLR (3 (3 (1 (1 (6 (6 /RODTXHHQXQSULPHUPRPHQWRVHHQFXHQWUDGHQWURGHOVXEJUXSRGHODVFKLFDVHQODVLWXDFLyQ GHMXHJRVHTXHGDDSDUWDGDHQHOVHJXQGRWULPHVWUHFXDQGRHPSLH]DQDFRQWDUPHQRVSDUDMXJDUFRQ HOODGLVPLQX\HQODVHOHFFLRQHVTXHUHFLEH\WDPELpQORVUHFKD]RV(QHOWUDEDMRHQFODVHVXVLWXDFLyQ HV PiV FRQVWDQWH D SHVDU GH TXH WLHQH XQ SLFR SRVLWLYR HQ HO VHJXQGR WULPHVWUH PiV HOHFFLRQHV \ PHQRVUHFKD]RVTXHHQQLQJ~QRWURWULPHVWUHTXHQRVDEHRQRSXHGHPDQWHQHU3XHGHDIHFWDUVX SDUWLGLVPR D IDYRU GH )HUQDQGD TXH DFDED GHMDQGR HO JUXSR SDUD SDVDU DO VXEJUXSR GH ODV FKLFDV $ 6RFLRJUDPDV\GDWRVLQGLYLGXDOHV 2&78%5( ('8&$&,Ð1)Ì6,&$ -25', /2/$ )LJ6RFLRJUDPDLQGLYLGXDOGH/RODHQODVLWXDFLyQGHODFODVH GHHGXFDFLyQItVLFDFRUUHVSRQGLHQWHDODDGPLQLVWUDFLyQGHRFWXEUHGHO ,1',&(662&,20(75,&26'(/2/$ 67$78662&,20(75,&2 66 &RQH[LyQDIHFWLYD &$ 3RSXODULGDG 3RS $QWLSDWtD $QW ([SDQVLYLGDG ([SS ([SDQVLYLGDG ([SQ $WHQFLyQSHUFHSWLYD $3S $WHQFLyQ3HUFHSWLYD$3Q 5HDOLVPRSHUFHSWLYR53S 5HDOLVPR3HUFHSWLYR53Q 9LVWRV VXV UHVXOWDGRV FXDQWLWDWLYRV /ROD RFXSD HO RFWDYR OXJDU HQ FXDQWR VX VWDWXV VRFLRPpWULFR PHGLRDOWRDSHVDUGHTXHpVWHQRHVPX\HOHYDGR(VWH6WDWXVVHIXQGDPHQWDHQXQQXPHURSDUHFLGR GH HOHFFLRQHV \ UHFKD]RV TXH UHFLEH UHFLEH HOHFFLRQHV \ UHFKD]RV 6X FRQH[LyQ DIHFWLYD HV UHDOPHQWHDOWDGHORVFLQFRVXMHWRVTXHODHOLJHQHOODHVFRJHDFXDWURORTXHQRVPXHVWUDDXQDSHUVRQD PX\YLQFXODGDDIHFWLYDPHQWHDDTXHOODVSHUVRQDVFRQODVTXHVHUHODFLRQDEiVLFDPHQWHGHOVXEJUXSR GHODVFKLFDV /ROD HVWi HQ OD PHGLD GH SRSXODULGDG HVH VRQ FLQFR HOHFFLRQHV TXH HV OR TXH VH SHGtD D FDGD PLHPEURGHODFODVHTXHHVFRJLHUD\JHQHUDPHQRUDQWLSDWtDTXHVLPSDWtDFXDWURUHFKD]RV3XHVWRTXH HQ HO FXHVWLRQDULR VH OH SLGH TXH HVFRMD D FLQFR \ UHFKDFH D FLQFR HVR HV MXVWDPHQWH OR TXH KDFH H[SDQVLYLGDGSRVLWLYD\QHJDWLYD HOHFFLRQHVRUHFKD]RV )LQDOPHQWHSRGHPRVFRPSUREDUTXH/RODHVXQDSHUVRQDEDVWDQWHUHDOLVWDFRQDTXHOODVSHUVRQDVFRQ ODV TXH HVWi YLQFXODGD DIHFWLYDPHQWH SXHV WDQWR VX DWHQFLyQ SHUFHSWLYD SRVLWLYD FRPR VX UHDOLVPR SHUFHSWLYR SRVLWLYR VRQ DOWRV (Q FDPELR QR VH HVSHUD OD PD\RUtD GH UHFKD]RV TXH OH GLULJHQ \ VX DWHQFLyQSHUFHSWLYDQHJDWLYD\VXUHDOLVPRSHUFHSWLYRQHJDWLYRVRQEDMRV $QLYHOSHUVRQDODOREVHUYDUHOJUiILFRGHODILJXUDSRGHPRVYHUTXH/RODHPLWHHOHFFLRQHVWRGDV HOODV GLULJLGDV D PLHPEURV GHO VXEJUXSR GH ODV FKLFDV 0LUHLD 0HUFq 2OJD &DWD \ )HUQDQGDVLHQGRFRUUHVSRQGLGDSRUFXDWURGHHOODV7DPELpQHPLWHUHFKD]RVDFKLFRV0LJXHO ÉQJHO/OXtV\)HUUDQ\DORVGRVVDWpOLWHVGHOVXEJUXSRGHODVFKLFDV<DVRQH\ -DQDVLHQGRHVWH~OWLPRUHFtSURFRSRUSDUWHGH-DQD5HFLEHUHFKD]RVGHPLHPEURVGHORVWUHV VXEJUXSRV&DUORVGHORVFKLFRV&DWD\-DQDGHOVXEJUXSRGHODVFKLFDV\/tGLDGHO VXEJUXSRGHODVFKLFDV &DEHGHVWDFDUWDPELpQODUHODFLyQGHRSRVLFLyQGHVHQWLPLHQWRVFRQ&DWDDODTXHHOLJHSHUR&DWDOD UHFKD]D(VWRSXHGHVHUGHELGRDTXH&DWDVHDSURYHFKHGH/RODHQFLHUWDVVLWXDFLRQHV\TXH/RODQR VDEH YHU FRPR \D KHPRV FRPHQWDGR DQWHULRUPHQWH VX SHUFHSFLyQ \ UHDOLVPR SHUFHSWLYR QHJDWLYR HV EDMR (Q UHVXPHQ /ROD VH PXHVWUD EDVWDQWH LQWHJUDGD HQ HO JUXSR FODVH HQ OD VLWXDFLyQ GH HGXFDFLyQ ItVLFD JUDFLDVVREUHWRGRDVXIXHUWHYLQFXODFLyQFRQHOVXEJUXSRGHODVFKLFDV&RQRFHPX\ELHQDODPD\RUtD GHPLHPEURVGHHVHVXEJUXSR\VHVLHQWHELHQFRQHOODV(QFDPELRPXHVWUDXQFLHUWRGHVFRQRFLPLHQWR GHODVRSLQLRQHVQHJDWLYDVTXHSXHGDJHQHUDUHQWUHVXVFRPSDxHURVKDVWDHOSXQWRTXHHVUHFKD]DGD SRUXQDFRPSDxHUDDODFXDOHOLJH\/RODQRHVFRQVFLHQWHGHHOOR $8/$ -25', /2/$ )LJ6RFLRJUDPDLQGLYLGXDOGH/RODHQODVLWXDFLyQ GHDXODFRUUHVSRQGLHQWHDODDGPLQLVWUDFLyQGHRFWXEUHGHO ,1',&(662&,20(75,&26'(/2/$ 67$78662&,20(75,&2 66 &RQH[LyQ$IHFWLYD &$ 3RSXODULGDG3RS $QWLSDWtD ([SDQVLYLGDG ([SDQVLYLGDG([SQ ([SS $QW $WHQFLyQSHUFHSWLYD$3S $WHQFLyQSHUFHSWLYD$3Q 5HDOLVPRSHUFHSWLYR53S 5HDOLVPRSHUFHSWLYR53Q /RODRFXSDHOGLHFLVHLVDYROXJDUHQODFODVHHQFXDQWRHOHVWDGRVRFLRPpWULFRFRQXQDSXQWXDFLyQGH± XQOXJDUEDVWDQWHEDMR$SHVDUGHTXHUHFLEHWUHVHOHFFLRQHVUHFLEHPiVUHFKD]RVFXDWURORTXH SURYRFD VX EDMR VWDWXV VRFLDO (Q FDPELR VX FRQH[LyQ DIHFWLYD HV DOWD SXHV HOLJH D XQD JUDQ SDUWH GH DTXHOODVSHUVRQDVTXHODHOLJHQGHODVWUHVTXHODHOLJHQHOODHVFRJHDGRVTXHVLJXHDSR\DQGRQXHVWUD LGHDGHSHUVRQDPX\YLQFXODGDDDTXHOORVFRQORVTXHVHUHODFLRQD 6XSRSXODULGDGHVUHODWLYDPHQWHEDMD\JHQHUDPD\RUDQWLSDWtDTXHQRVLPSDWtDFRPRVHKDFRPHQWDGR DQWHULRUPHQWH UHFLEH WUHV HOHFFLRQHV \ FXDWUR UHFKD]RV \ FRQWLQXD HVFRJLHQGR \ UHFKD]DQGR D FLQFR SHUVRQDVH[SDQVLYLGDGWDQWRSRVLWLYDFRPRQHJDWLYD /ROD DFLHUWD WRGDV ODV HOHFFLRQHV TXH UHFLEH DWHQFLyQ SHUFHSWLYD SRVLWLYD DXQTXH HVSHUD UHFLELU FLQFRHOHFFLRQHVGHODVFXDOHVVyORUHFLEHWUHVUHDOLVPRSHUFHSWLYRSRVLWLYRPHQRUTXHODDWHQFLyQ SHUFHSWLYDSHURLJXDOPHQWHEDVWDQWHDOWR6yORDFLHUWDXQRGHORVFXDWURUHFKD]RVTXHUHFLEHDWHQFLyQ SHUFHSWLYD QHJDWLYD EDVWDQWH EDMR 'H ORV FLQFR TXH HOOD HVSHUDED VRODPHQWH XQR VH FXPSOH UHDOLVPR SHUFHSWLYR WDPELpQ EDVWDQWH EDMR OR TXH GHPXHVWUD TXH HQ FXDQWR D DTXHOORV TXH OD UHFKD]DQODUHDOLGDGQRVHFRUUHVSRQGHFRQORTXHHOODRSLQD 6LREVHUYDPRVODILJXUDSRGHPRVDSUHFLDUTXH/RODHPLWHHOHFFLRQHVWRGDVHOODVDPLHPEURVGHO VXEJUXSRGHODVFKLFDVDXQTXHXQDGHHVWDVHOHFFLRQHVVHDXQVDWpOLWHGHOVXEJUXSR-DQD'H HVWDV HOHFFLRQHV GRV VRQ UHFtSURFDV FRQ0LUHLD \ FRQ )HUQDQGD \ XQD HV XQD RSRVLFLyQ GH VHQWLPLHQWRVFRQ-DQD'HQWURGHHVHVXEJUXSRGHODVFKLFDVHPLWHGRVUHFKD]RV5RFtR\ <DVRQH $ SHVDU GH HVWR WUHV GH VXV UHFKD]RV VRQ SDUD FKLFRV -RUGL 0LJXHO ÉQJHO \ /OXtV \ HO ~QLFRUHFKD]RTXHUHFLEHSRUSDUWHGHORVFKLFRVHVHOGH&DUORV)LQDOPHQWHGHORWURVXEJUXSRGH ODVFKLFDVUHFLEHGRVUHFKD]RVODPLWDGGHOJUXSR/tGLD\&DWD&RPRHVWDGtVWLFDPHQWHVHKD FRPHQWDGRVXSHUFHSFLyQGHORVUHFKD]RVTXHUHFLEHHVPX\EDMR\HVWRWDPELpQSXHGHREVHUYDUVHHQ ODWRWDODXVHQFLDGHUHFKD]RVUHFtSURFRVHQODILJXUD (Q UHVXPHQ KDEODPRV GH DOJXLHQ QR PX\ HVFRJLGR \ WDPSRFR PX\ UHFKD]DGR DXQTXH UHFLEH PiV UHFKD]RV TXH HOHFFLRQHV SRU OR WDQWR QR SRGHPRV GHFLU TXH HVWp GHPDVLDGR LQWHJUDGD HQ OD FODVH DXQTXHVtORHVWiGHQWURGHOVXEJUXSRGHODVFKLFDV(OODHVPX\FRQVFLHQWHGHTXLpQOHHOLJH\TXLHQHV VRQVXVDPLJDVSHURQRHVFRQVFLHQWHGHTXLpQODUHFKD]DDSHVDUTXHVDEHTXHHVUHFKD]DGD(VXQD SHUVRQDUHDOLVWDHQXQVHQWLGRSHURORHVSRFRHQHORWUR 0$5=2 ('8&$&,Ð1)Ì6,&$ )LJ6RFLRJUDPDLQGLYLGXDOGH/RODHQODVLWXDFLyQGHODFODVH GHHGXFDFLyQItVLFDFRUUHVSRQGLHQWHDODDGPLQLVWUDFLyQGHPDU]RGHO ,1',&(662&,20(75,&26'(/2/$ 67$78662&,20(75,&2 66 &RQH[LyQDIHFWLYD &$ 3RSXODULGDG 3RS $QWLSDWtD $QW ([SDQVLYLGDG ([SS ([SDQVLYLGDG ([SQ $WHQFLyQSHUFHSWLYD $3S $WHQFLyQ3HUFHSWLYD$3Q 5HDOLVPRSHUFHSWLYR53S 5HDOLVPR3HUFHSWLYR53Q /D VLWXDFLyQ GH /ROD D SHVDU GH TXH VX HVWDWXV VRFLRPpWULFR VH PDQWLHQH HQ OD SULPHUD DGPLQLVWUDFLyQ IXH GH HPSHRUD SXHVWR TXH DVt OR PXHVWUDQ PXFKRV GH ORV tQGLFHV VRFLRPpWULFRV LQGLYLGXDOHV $KRUD/RODHVPHQRVHOHJLGD\PHQRVUHFKD]DGD(VPHQRVHOHJLGDSRUTXHUHFLEHWDQVyORHOHFFLRQHV HQ OD SULPHUD DGPLQLVWUDFLyQ UHFLELy eVWDV SURYLHQHQ GH &DWD \ )HUQDQGD FRQ OD TXH PDQWLHQHXQDUHFLSURFLGDGSRVLWLYDORTXHVHSXHGHDSUHFLDUHQHOGHFRQH[LyQDIHFWLYDPXFKRPiV EDMDTXHHOGHODSULPHUDDGPLQLVWUDFLyQ\GH0LJXHOÉQJHO\&DUORVSRUSDUWHGHORVFKLFRV $HVWRVGRV/RODORVUHFKD]DIRUPiQGRVHSRUWDQWRXQDRSRVLFLyQGHVHQWLPLHQWRV3XHVWRTXHVRQGRV GHORVDOXPQRVTXHPiVRSRVLFLRQHVGHVHQWLPLHQWRVSURWDJRQL]DQHVPX\SUREDEOHTXHHVWDVYHQJDQ GDGDVQRSRU/RODVLQRSRUODIDOWDGHDWHQFLyQGH0LJXHOÉQJHO\&DUORV/RODHVHOHJLGD~QLFDPHQWHSRU VLPSDWtD $Vt 0LJXHO ÉQJHO GLFHTXH HOOD ³(V GH ODV TXH PHMRU VH SRUWD FRQPLJR´ OR TXH XQLGR DO UHFKD]R GH /ROD GHPXHVWUD OD IDOWD GH UHDOLVPR SRU VX SDUWH &DWD TXH ³0H FDH PX\ ELHQ´ )HUQDQGD TXH ³(V GH PLV PHMRUHV DPLJRV 0H FDH PX\ ELHQ´ \ ILQDOPHQWH &DUORV ³(V PX\ EXHQD DPLJD \ VLHPSUH QRV SRUWDPRV PX\ ELHQ´ GHQRWDQGR WDPELpQ IDOWD GH UHDOLVPR HQ HO PLVPR VHQWLGRTXH0LJXHO­QJHO /RODDGHPiVVHKDGHVXELFDGRXQSRFRGHQWURGHOJUXSRFODVHSRUODVLWXDFLyQFRPHQWDGDHQHODQiOLVLV GHWRGRHOJUXSRHQWUH)HUQDQGD\-DQD'HHVWDPDQHUDVXUHDOLVPR\VXDWHQFLyQSHUFHSWLYD SRVLWLYDGLVPLQX\HVLJQLILFDWLYDPHQWH$KRUDHVFDSD]WDQVRORGHHVSHUDUODHOHFFLyQGH)HUQDQGD 7DPELpQHVPHQRVUHFKD]DGRFRPRKHPRVGLFKRDQWHULRUPHQWHSRUTXHVyOR2ULROHPLWHXQUHFKD]R KDFLDHOODMXVWLILFDGRVHJ~QpOSRUTXH³(VDQWLSiWLFD(VPX\SHJRQD´3XHVWRTXH/RODQRHVSHUDHVWH UHFKD]R\QRHVFDSD]SRUWDQWRGHDGLYLQDUORVXDWHQFLyQ\UHDOLVPRSHUFHSWLYRHVGH 3RUVXSDUWH/RODUHDOL]DXQDHOHFFLyQPiV'HODVVHLVTXHHPLWHHQHVWDDGPLQLVWUDFLyQFLQFRVRQSDUD PLHPEURVGHOVXEJUXSRGHODVFKLFDV0LUHLD7HUHVD0HUFq2OJD\)HUQDQGD $xDGHHQODVHOHFFLRQHVD-RUGLGHOVXEJUXSRGHORVFKLFRV(VWDVHOHFFLRQHVODVUHDOL]DSRUTXH³6RQ PLVPHMRUHVDPLJRVORVTXHPiV´ 6LJXH UHFKD]DQGR D FLQFR FRPSDxHURV VLHQGR GRV GHO VXEJUXSR GH ODV FKLFDV <DVRQH \ -DQD TXHPDQWLHQHQXQDPDODUHODFLyQFRQ)HUQDQGD~QLFDUHFLSURFLGDGSRVLWLYDGH/ROD\ORVRWURV WUHV FKLFRV 0LJXHO ÉQJHO &DUORV TXH OD HOLJHQ \ )HUUDQ $ pVWRV ORV UHFKD]D SRUTXH ³$OJXQRVKDFHQWUDPSDV\QRPHFDHQPX\ELHQ´ &RPR\DFRPHQWDPRVHQHOLQIRUPHJUXSDOGHHVWDVHJXQGDDGPLQLVWUDFLyQ/RODUHFLEHPXFKDVPiV HOHFFLRQHVHQODSUXHEDGHFRQWUROTXHHQODSUXHEDVWDQGDUG(VWRSRGUtDVHUH[SOLFDGRHQHOVHQWLGRHQ TXHGHELGRDOFRQIOLFWRH[LVWHQWHHQHOVXEJUXSRGHODVFKLFDVKD\FRPSDxHUDVTXHHOHJLUtDQD/ROD\ TXHGHELGRDHVWDVLWXDFLyQQRPDWHULDOL]DQVXVLQWHQFLRQHV (Q UHVXPHQ SRGHPRV FRQFOXLU TXH /ROD HPSHRUD VX VLWXDFLyQ HQ OD FODVH GH HGXFDFLyQ ItVLFD SRUTXH H[LVWHXQFRQIOLFWRHQHOVXEJUXSRGHODVFKLFDVTXHODGHVFRORFD5HFLEHPHQRVHOHFFLRQHV\PHQRV UHFKD]RVFRQORTXHPDQWLHQHVXHVWDWXVVRFLRPpWULFRSHURHVPHQRVDWHQWD\UHDOLVWDFRQORVHVWtPXORV H[WHUQRV $8/$ )LJ6RFLRJUDPDLQGLYLGXDOGH/RODHQODVLWXDFLyQ GHDXODFRUUHVSRQGLHQWHDODDGPLQLVWUDFLyQGHPDU]RGHO ,1',&(662&,20(75,&26'(/2/$ 67$78662&,20(75,&2 66 &RQH[LyQ$IHFWLYD &$ 3RSXODULGDG3RS $QWLSDWtD ([SDQVLYLGDG ([SDQVLYLGDG([SQ ([SS $QW $WHQFLyQSHUFHSWLYD$3S $WHQFLyQSHUFHSWLYD$3Q 5HDOLVPRSHUFHSWLYR53S 5HDOLVPRSHUFHSWLYR53Q 6L FRPHQWiEDPRV TXH OD VLWXDFLyQ GH /ROD HPSHRUDED HQ OD FODVH GH HGXFDFLyQ ItVLFD GXUDQWH HVWD VHJXQGDDGPLQLVWUDFLyQQRVHSXHGHGHFLUORPLVPRGHODVLWXDFLyQGHDXODSXHVVXHVWDWXVVRFLRPpWULFR SDVD GH QHJDWLYR D SRVLWLYR HQ OD SULPHUD DGPLQLVWUDFLyQ \ HQ HVWD VHJXQGD \ UHFLEH PiV HOHFFLRQHV\PHQRVUHFKD]RVTXHHQODSULPHUDDGPLQLVWUDFLyQ 6LHQODSULPHUDDGPLQLVWUDFLyQUHFLEtDHOHFFLRQHVDKRUDUHFLEH&DUORVSRUORVFKLFRV2OJD \)HUQDQGDSRUHOVXEJUXSRGHODVFKLFDVDPEDVFRQUHFLSURFLGDGHVSRVLWLYDSRUSDUWHGH/ROD\ )UDQFLQD \ &DWD SRU SDUWH GHO VXEJXSR GH ODV FKLFDV 6XV FRPSDxHURV OD HOLJHQ SULQFLSDOPHQWHSRUVLPSDWtD$Vt)UDQFLQDRSLQDTXH/ROD³(VPX\EXHQDDPLJD\PHJXVWDHVWDU FRQ HOOD \ FRPR DKRUD HVWi DVt RSHUDGD´ PLHQWUDV TXH 2OJD FRPHQWD TXH ³&RQ HOOD HV PX\ GLYHUWLGR´3RUVXSDUWH&DWDODHVFRJHSRUTXH³0HFDHELHQ´)HUQDQGDSRUTXH³(VGHODVTXH PiV FRQR]FR´ \ &DUORV SRUTXH ³(V PX\ EXHQD DPLJD \ VLHPSUH QRV SRUWDPRV PX\ ELHQ´ 'H ODV FLQFR HOHFFLRQHV TXH UHFLEH HOOD DFLHUWD GRV DWHQFLyQ SHUFHSWLYD SRVLWLYD SHUR HVSHUDED FXDWUR UHDOLVPR SHUFHSWLYR (VWRV tQGLFHV VRQ PHGLRV \ DXQTXH VXSRQHQ XQ OLJHUR GHVFHQVR HQ FRPSDUDFLyQ FRQ OD SULPHUD DGPLQLVWUDFLyQ QR QRV ROYLGHPRV GH ORV FDPELRV VXUJLGRV GHQWUR GHO VXEJUXSR GH ODV FKLFDV TXH KDQ GHVFRORFDGR D PXFKRV GH VXV PLHPEURV VLJXHQ VLHQGR EDVWDQWH EXHQRV\PXHVWUDQXQDFLHUWDLQWHJUDFLyQGH/RODHQHOJUXSRFODVH 7DQVyORUHFLEHXQUHFKD]RDQWLSDWtDTXHSURYLHQHGH5DIDHOTXHORMXVWLILFDGLFLHQGRTXH³6H EXUODGHORTXHKDJR´/RODHVFDSD]GHDGLYLQDUHVWHUHFKD]RDWHQFLyQSHUFHSWLYDQHJDWLYDSHUR FRPR HVSHUD UHFKD]RV PiV QR SRGHPRV GHFLU TXH VHD PX\ UHDOLVWD HQ HVWH DVSHFWR UHDOLVPR SHUFHSWLYRQHJDWLYR 3RUVXSDUWH/RODHPLWHVHLVHOHFFLRQHVGLULJLGDVXQDDFKLFRV-RUGL\ODVRWUDVDFLQFRDPLHPEURV GHOVXEJUXSRGHODVFKLFDV7HUHVD5RFtR0HUFq2OJD\)HUQDQGD$ODKRUDGH UHFKD]DUORKDFHDFLQFRSHUVRQDVXQFKLFR)HUUDQ\FXDWURFKLFDV0RQWVH5RFtR<DVRQH \ -DQD 7DQWR FXDQGR HOLJH FRPR FXDQGR UHFKD]D OR KDFH SRU FULWHULRV GH VLPSDWtD VLHPSUH SRUTXHOHFDHQELHQRQROHFDHQELHQ 6L FRPSDUDPRV OD SUXHED VWDQGDUG FRQ OD SUXHED GH FRQWURO REVHUYDUHPRV TXH /ROD UHFLEH PiV HOHFFLRQHV \ UHFKD]RV HQ OD SUXHED FRQWURO TXH HQ OD VWDQGDUG VLQ OOHJDU D XQD FDQWLGDG TXH QRV KDJD SHQVDUHQGLIHUHQFLDVVLJQLILFDWLYDV(VWRFRPRVHKDFRPHQWDGRDQWHULRUPHQWHHQYDULDVRFDVLRQHVHV EDVWDQWHIUHFXHQWH (Q UHVXPHQ VX VLWXDFLyQ PHMRUD SRUTXH UHFLEH PiV HOHFFLRQHV \ PHQRV UHFKD]RV \ HQ JHQHUDO VH PXHVWUDPiVDWHQWDTXHUHDOLVWDDQWHHVWRVHVWtPXORVH[WHUQRVTXHUHFLEH$GHPiVHPLWHPiVHOHFFLRQHV \PiVUHFKD]RVKDFLDHOUHVWRGHOJUXSR -81,2 ('8&$&,Ð1)Ì6,&$ )LJ6RFLRJUDPDLQGLYLGXDOGH/RODHQODVLWXDFLyQ GHODFODVHGHHGXFDFLyQItVLFDFRUUHVSRQGLHQWHDODDGPLQLVWUDFLyQGHMXQLRGHO ,1',&(662&,20(75,&26'(/2/$ 67$78662&,20(75,&2 66 &RQH[LyQ$IHFWLYD &$ 3RSXODULGDG3RS $QWLSDWtD ([SDQVLYLGDG ([SDQVLYLGDG([SQ ([SS $WHQFLyQSHUFHSWLYD$3S $QW $WHQFLyQSHUFHSWLYD$3Q 5HDOLVPRSHUFHSWLYR53S 5HDOLVPRSHUFHSWLYR53Q &RQILUPDQGR QXHVWUDV H[SHFWDWLYDV OD VLWXDFLyQ GH /ROD HPSHRUD VLJQLILFDWLYDPHQWH HQ HVWH WHUFHU WULPHVWUH VWDWXV VRFLRPpWULFR ± RFXSDQGR HO GHFLPRQRYHQR OXJDU XQR GH ORV ~OWLPRV GH OD FODVH UHFLELHQGRWDQVyORXQDHOHFFLyQSRUGRVUHFKD]RVORTXHODFRQYLHUWHHQLJQRUDGDSRUHOUHVWRGHOJUXSR /D~QLFDHOHFFLyQSRVLWLYDTXHUHFLEHSRSXODULGDGSURYLHQHGH&DWDVHJ~QHOOD´(VDPLJD\QRV OOHYDPRV PX\ELHQPHFDHELHQ´$HVWDHOHFFLyQ/RODUHVSRQGHFRQXQDHOHFFLyQSRVLWLYDKDFLD&DWD WDPELpQ&RQH[LyQDIHFWLYD$SHVDUGHHVWDVLWXDFLyQSXHVWRTXHQRDGLYLQDTXH&DWDODHOLJHVX DWHQFLyQSHUFHSWLYDSRVLWLYD\VXUHDOLVPRSHUFHSWLYRSRVLWLYRVRQQXORVVXYDORUHVGH /RVGRVUHFKD]RVTXHUHFLEHVRQGHGRVFKLFRV-RUGLSRUTXH³6LHPSUHTXLHUHWHQHUUD]yQ´\0LJXHO ÉQJHOSRUTXH³1RTXLHURTXHVHDUULHVJXHDMXJDUSRUTXHOHSXHGHSDVDUDOJRPHMRUSUHYHQLU´&RPR SXHGHDSUHFLDUVHXQRHVSRUXQPRWLYRGHDQWLSDWtD\HORWURVHUHILHUHDVXOLPLWDFLyQ-RUGLHVUHFKD]DGR SRU0LJXHOÉQJHOSRUHVHPLVPRPRWLYR(OODDGLYLQDHVWRVGRVUHFKD]RVDWHQFLyQSHUFHSWLYDQHJDWLYD SHURHVSHUDEDPXFKRVPiVUHDOLVPRSHUFHSWLYRQHJDWLYR3RUWDQWRFRQWLQ~DPRVWUDQGRXQD FLHUWDIDOWDGHPDGXUH]\UHDOLVPRHQHVWDVLWXDFLyQ 3RUVXSDUWH/RODHOLJH\UHFKD]DDFLQFRSHUVRQDVH[SDQVLYLGDGHVSRVLWLYD\QHJDWLYD(OLJHD FLQFR FKLFDV ODV GRV OtGHUHV GHO VXEJUXSR GH ODV FKLFDV 0LUHLD \ 2OJD \ D WUHV FKLFDV GHO VXEJUXSRGHODVFKLFDV/tGLD &DWD \ )HUQDQGD &RQWLQ~D HOLJLHQGR SRUTXH ³0H FDHQ PX\ELHQ\VRQPX\VLPSiWLFDV´$ODKRUDGHUHFKD]DUORKDFHDGRVFKLFDVGHOVXEJUXSRGHODVFKLFDV <DVRQH\7HUHVD\DWUHVFKLFRV-RUGLFRQTXLHQPDQWLHQHXQDUHFLSURFLGDGQHJDWLYD/OXtV \)HUUDQ$HVWRVORVUHFKD]DSRUTXH³1RHVWR\WDQWRWLHPSRFRQHOORV\DOJXQRVVRQWRQWRV\ DQWLSiWLFRV´ 6LFRPSDUDPRVHVWRVUHVXOWDGRVFRQORVGHODSUXHEDGHFRQWUROYROYHPRVDHQFRQWUDUQRVFRQODPLVPD VLWXDFLyQGHVFULWDHQODDGPLQLVWUDFLyQSUHFHGHQWH(VGHFLUUHFLEHPXFKDVPiVHOHFFLRQHVHQODSUXHED GHFRQWUROTXHHQODSUXHEDVWDQGDUG&RPR\DH[SOLFDPRVHQVXPRPHQWRHVSRVLEOHTXHWHQJDUHODFLyQ FRQODVLWXDFLyQGHOVXEJUXSRGHODVFKLFDV (QUHVXPHQODVLWXDFLyQHQODFODVHGHHGXFDFLyQItVLFDGH/RODKDLGRHPSHRUDQGRDORODUJRGHWRGRHO FXUVRKDVWDHOSXQWRGHQRUHFLELUDSHQDVHOHFFLRQHVRUHFKD]RV(VWDVLWXDFLyQSRGUtDVHUGLVWLQWDSRUTXH HQODSUXHEDGHFRQWUROUHFLEHPXFKDVPiVHOHFFLRQHVTXHHQODSUXHEDVWDQGDUG([LVWHXQDVLWXDFLyQ TXHLPSLGHTXH/RODUHFLEDODVHOHFFLRQHVTXHGHEHUtDUHFLELUSRUVXVFDUDFWHUtVWLFDV\VXLQFOXVLyQGHQWUR GHOJUXSR $8/$ )LJ6RFLRJUDPDLQGLYLGXDOGH/RODHQODVLWXDFLyQ GHDXODFRUUHVSRQGLHQWHDODDGPLQLVWUDFLyQGHMXQLRGHO ,1',&(662&,20(75,&26'(/2/$ 67$78662&,20(75,&2 66 &RQH[LyQ$IHFWLYD &$ 3RSXODULGDG3RS $QWLSDWtD ([SDQVLYLGDG ([SDQVLYLGDG([SQ ([SS $QW $WHQFLyQSHUFHSWLYD$3S $WHQFLyQSHUFHSWLYD$3Q 5HDOLVPRSHUFHSWLYR53S 5HDOLVPRSHUFHSWLYR53Q 3DUHFH TXH OD PDOD VLWXDFLyQ GH /ROD HQ OD FODVH GH HGXFDFLyQ ItVLFD VH WUDVODGD DO DXOD SXHV VX VLWXDFLyQHPSHRUDFODUDPHQWHSDVDQGRVXVWDWXVVRFLRPpWULFRDVHUQHJDWLYRDKRUD\HQOD VHJXQGDDGPLQLVWUDFLyQ6XFRQH[LyQDIHFWLYDGHMDGHH[LVWLUSXHVQRFRUUHVSRQGHQLQJXQDGHODV WUHVHOHFFLRQHVTXHUHFLEHSRSXODULGDG (VWDVWUHVHOHFFLRQHVSURYLHQHQGHFKLFDV'RVGHHOODVGHOVXEJUXSRGHODVFKLFDV7HUHVDSRUTXH ³(VEXHQDFRPSDxHUD´\0HUFqSRUTXH³/RHQWLHQGHHOWUDEDMRPX\ELHQ´\XQDGHOVXEJUXSRGH ODV FKLFDV)UDQFLQDSRUTXH³&RPR HQ HGXFDFLyQ ItVLFD QR SXHGH KDFHU PXFKR SUHILHUR HVWDU FRQ HOOD HQ FODVH´ /DV HOHFFLRQHV SRU OR WDQWR QR VRQ SRU PRWLYRV GH VLPSDWtD FODUDPHQWH VLQR SULQFLSDOPHQWH SRU UHQGLPLHQWR R SRU VX OLPLWDFLyQ 'H HVWDV HOHFFLRQHV WDQ VyOR DGLYLQD XQD DWHQFLyQ SHUFHSWLYD SRVLWLYD DXQTXH HVSHUDED RWUDV WUHV TXH QR VH KDQ GDGR UHDOLVPR SHUFHSWLYR 6LJXHSXHVPRVWUDQGRXQFLHUWRUHDOLVPR\PDGXUH]DODKRUDGHHQWHQGHUODVLQWHUDFFLRQHVVRFLDOHVFRQ VXVFRPSDxHURVSHURHQPHQRUJUDGRTXHHQHOUHVWRGHOFXUVR 5HFLEH GRV UHFKD]RV DQWLSDWtD TXH SURYLHQHQ GH GRV FKLFRV -RUGL SRUTXH ³0H FDH PDO 6LHPSUH TXLHUHWHQHUODUD]yQ0HGLFH ³QR PH PLUHV´ &XDQGR PHQRV HVWpFRQHOODPHMRU´<GH/OXtV SRUTXH³7HGLVWUDHKDEODPXFKRWHHQWUHWLHQH\QRWHGHMDKDFHUWXWUDEDMR´(OODDGLYLQDORVGRV UHFKD]RV DWHQFLyQ SHUFHSWLYD QHJDWLYD SHUR HVSHUDED RFKR UHDOLVPR SHUFHSWLYR QHJDWLYR 3RUWDQWRDXQTXHWLHQHELHQFODURGHVGHGyQGHSXHGHQSURYHQLUORVUHFKD]RVQRHVUHDOLVWDDODKRUDGH HYDOXDUVXVLWXDFLyQHQODFODVHSXHVHVSHUDXQDSRVLFLyQPXFKRPHQRUGHODTXHWLHQH 3RUVXSDUWHHOLJHDVHLVSHUVRQDVVHLVFKLFDV0D\WH\2OJDGHOVXEJUXSR\0DUWD/tGLD &DWD\)HUQDQGDGHOVXEJUXSR\UHFKD]DDFLQFRGRVFKLFDVGHOVXEJUXSR<DVRQH \-DQD\DWUHVFKLFRV0LJXHOÉQJHO/OXtV\&DUORV(VPX\SDUFDDODKRUDGH MXVWLILFDUVH HQ VXV HOHFFLRQHV \ VXV UHFKD]RV 3RUTXH OH FDHQ ELHQ \ WUDEDMDQ ELHQ HQ FODVH R SRU OR FRQWUDULR6LFRPSDUDPRVORVUHVXOWDGRVGHODSUXHEDVWDQGDUGFRQODSUXHEDGHFRQWUROQRREVHUYDPRV GLIHUHQFLDVVLJQLILFDWLYDVHQWUHODVGRVSUXHEDV (QUHVXPHQ/RODHPSHRUDVXVLWXDFLyQHQHODXODWDPELpQ\GHODPLVPDIRUPDTXHHQHGXFDFLyQItVLFD UHFLEH SRFDV HOHFFLRQHV \ SRFRV UHFKD]RV DXQTXH DTXt QR HVWi LJQRUDGD SRU HO UHVWR GHO JUXSR FODVH FRPR HQ OD VLWXDFLyQ GH HGXFDFLyQ ItVLFD $GHPiV QR HV SHUFHSWLYD QL UHDOLVWD FRQ HVWRV HVWtPXORV H[WHUQRVTXHUHFLEH &8$'525(680(1/2/$ 6,78$&,Ð1'(('8&$&,Ð1)Ì6,&$ 6,78$&,Ð1'($8/$ 2FWXEUH 0DU]R -XQLR 2FWXEUH 0DU]R -XQLR 66 &$ 3RSXODULGDG $QWLSDWtD ([S ([S $3 $3 53 53 (VWDWXV 6RFLRPpWULFR 66 (Q OD VLWXDFLyQ GH HGXFDFLyQ ItVLFD GLVPLQX\H SDXODWLQDPHQWH DXQTXHHQWUHODVHJXQGD\WHUFHUDDGPLQLVWUDFLyQHVWHGHVFHQVRHVPiVHYLGHQWH(QODVLWXDFLyQ GH DXOD VLJXH OD HYROXFLyQ GHO JUXSR HQ JHQHUDO WHQLHQGR XQ SLFR SRVLWLYR HQ OD VHJXQGD DGPLQLVWUDFLyQSDUDFDHUDtQGLFHVXQSRFRPiVEDMRVHQODWHUFHUD\~OWLPD &RQH[LyQ $IHFWLYD &$ (Q (GXFDFLyQ )tVLFD PXHVWUD XQD FLHUWD GHVXELFDFLyQ GXUDQWH OD VHJXQGDDGPLQLVWUDFLyQFRLQFLGHQWHFRQWRGRHOFRQIOLFWRHQHOVXEJUXSRGHODVFKLFDVDXQTXH HQJHQHUDOFRUUHVSRQGHPX\ELHQDVXVDPLJDV\HVWDPX\ELHQDVHQWDGD(QODVLWXDFLyQGHFODVH HQFDPELRSLHUGHSURJUHVLYDPHQWHODFDSDFLGDGGHUHVSRQGHUGHIRUPDSRVLWLYDDDTXHOORVTXHOD HOLJHQ 3RSXODULGDG'HFUHFHHQODHGXFDFLyQItVLFDGHIRUPDPX\FODUD(QODVLWXDFLyQGHDXODVLJXHOD PLVPD HYROXFLyQ TXH HQ HO VWDWXV VRFLRPpWULFR FRQ XQ SLFR SRVLWLYR GXUDQWH OD VHJXQGD DGPLQLVWUDFLyQ $QWLSDWtD7LHQHXQDWHQGHQFLDDGLVPLQXLUDORODUJRGHOFXUVRHQODVGRVVLWXDFLRQHVOOHJDQGRD UHFLELUODPLWDGGHUHFKD]RVDILQDOGHFXUVRTXHDOSULQFLSLR ([SDQVLYLGDG SRVLWLYD ([S 6H PDQWLHQH HQWUH ODV FLQFR \ VHLV HOHFFLRQHV HQ ODV GRV VLWXDFLRQHVDORODUJRGHWRGRHOFXUVR ([SDQVLYLGDGQHJDWLYD([S$OLJXDOTXHHQODH[SDQVLYLGDGSRVLWLYDHOQ~PHURGHUHFKD]RV TXHHPLWHRVFLODHQWUHORVFLQFR\ORVVHLVDORODUJRGHOFXUVRHQDPEDVVLWXDFLRQHV $WHQFLyQ\3HUFHSFLyQ3RVLWLYD$3&DGDYH]HVPHQRVDWHQWDFRQODVHOHFFLRQHVTXHUHFLEH HQDPEDVVLWXDFLRQHVSHUGLHQGRKDVWDPiVGHODPLWDGHQHVWHtQGLFHWDQWRHQHGXFDFLyQItVLFD FRPRHQHODXOD $WHQFLyQ \ 3HUFHSFLyQ 1HJDWLYD $3 6X HYROXFLyQ HV FRQWUDULD D OD DWHQFLyQ SHUFHSWLYD SRVLWLYD$PHGLGDTXHDYDQ]DHOFXUVRHVPiVFRQVFLHQWHGHTXpSHUVRQDVODUHFKD]DQKDVWDHO SXQWRGHDGLYLQDUWRGRVORVUHFKD]RVTXHUHFLEHHQODWHUFHUDDGPLQLVWUDFLyQ 5HDOLVPR 3HUFHSWLYR 3RVLWLYR 53 'HVFLHQGH VLJQLILFDWLYDPHQWH HQ DPEDV VLWXDFLRQHV \ SDVD GH XQ QLYHO PHGLR DOWR D XQ QLYHO PHGLREDMR R EDMR 6LHPSUH HVSHUD EDVWDQWHV PiV HOHFFLRQHVGHODVTXHHQUHDOLGDGUHFLEH 5HDOLVPR3HUFHSWLYR1HJDWLYR53(QQLQJ~QPRPHQWRPXHVWUDXQRVtQGLFHVTXHGHPXHVWUHQ TXHHVXQDSHUVRQDUHDOLVWDHQHVWHDVSHFWRSXHVHOODHVSHUDVLHPSUHPXFKRVPiVUHFKD]RVGH ORV TXH HQ UHDOLGDG UHFLEH HVWR OH KDFH DFHUWDU FRQ PiV IDFLOLGDG ORV TXH UHFLELUi FRPR SXHGH FRPSUREDUVHHQODDWHQFLyQSHUFHSWLYDQHJDWLYD DQH[R 3UXHEDFRQWUROHVWXGLRVRFLRPpWULFR 358(%$62&,20e75,&$'(&21752/ ,QWHUSUHWDFLyQGHORVVtPERORV 2FXDOTXLHUQ~PHURHQD]XO(VODSXQWXDFLyQUHFLELGDRHPLWLGDSRU HODOXPQRHQFXHVWLyQ\VHFRQVLGHUDQHOHFFLRQHV\ORVUHFKD]RV y /RV R HQWUH SDUpQWHVLV D]XOHV LQGLFDQ UHFLSURFLGDG SRVLWLYD<RORHOLMR\pOPHHOLJHWDPELpQDPL /RV HQWUH SDUpQWHVLV URMRV LQGLFDQ UHFLSURFLGDG QHJDWLYD <R OR UHFKD]R\pOPHUHFKD]DDPt [y[y[/DV´[µPDUFDQRSRVLFLRQHVGHVHQWLPLHQWRV6LOD[HV D]XO\DFRPSDxDDXQHVTXHHVDSHUVRQDHOLJLySHURIXHUHFKD]DGD 6LSRUHOFRQWUDULROD[HVURMD\DFRPSDxDDXQRXQHVTXHHVD SHUVRQDUHFKD]ySHURIXHHOHJLGD y (V OD H[SHFWDWLYD GH VHU HOHJLGR R UHFKD]DGR 6L DO ODGR GH XQ Q~PHURDSDUHFHXQDTXLHUHGHFLUTXHTXLpQKDHPLWLGRODSXQWXDFLyQ HVSHUD VHU UHFKD]DGR SRU OD SHUVRQD D OD TXH KD SXQWXDGR 6L SRU HO FRQWUDULR DSDUHFH XQD HV TXH OD SHUVRQD TXH KD HPLWLGR OD SXQWXDFLyQHVSHUDVHUHVFRJLGDSRUODSHUVRQDSXQWXDGD y,QGLFDQVLODVH[SHFWDWLYDVGHHOHFFLyQRUHFKD]RVHFXPSOHQR QR([LVWHQFXDWURSRVLEOHVVLWXDFLRQHV /D SHUVRQD TXH KD HPLWLGR OD SXQWXDFLyQ HVSHUDED VHU UHFKD]DGD SRU OD SHUVRQD SXQWXDGD \ HIHFWLYDPHQWH DVt KD VLGR /D SHUVRQD TXH KD HPLWLGR OD SXQWXDFLyQ HVSHUDED VHU HOHJLGDSRUODSHUVRQDSXQWXDGD\HIHFWLYDPHQWHDVtKDVLGR /D SHUVRQD TXH KD HPLWLGR OD SXQWXDFLyQ HVSHUDED VHU HOHJLGD SRU OD SHUVRQD SXQWXDGD \ HQ FDPELR KD VLGR UHFKD]DGD$HVWRVHOHOODPDXQDIDOVDSHUFHSFLyQ /D SHUVRQD TXH KD HPLWLGR OD SXQWXDFLyQ HVSHUDED VHU UHFKD]DGD\HQFDPELRKDVLGRHOHJLGD$HVWRWDPELpQVHOH OODPDXQDIDOVDSHUFHSFLyQ &(17520$5,$ $'0,1,675$&,Ð1)(%5(52 &ODVHGHHGXFDFLyQItVLFD -RDQD $QJHOD 7RPiV 0DQHO )UHGHULF ,YiQ 0D\WH -XDQ &DUPH ,VD )UDQFHVF 'HQLV %LELDQD 0DWHR 5REHUW 'jOLD 3DWULFLD 0RLVpV 6HUJL &RQUDG ,JQDVL 1~PHURGHHOHFFLRQHV UHFLELGDVHPLWLGDV 6XPDWRULRSXQWXDFLRQHVGH HOHFFLyQUHFLELGDV 0HGLDGHSXQWXDFLRQHVGH HOHFFLyQUHFLELGD 1~PHURGHUHFKD]RVUHFLELGRV HPLWLGRV (OHFFLRQHVTXH0DUtDUHFLEHGH (OHFFLRQHVHPLWLGDVSRU0DUtD VXVFRPSDxHURV [ [ $'0,1,675$&,Ð1)(%5(52 7UDEDMRHQFODVH -RDQD $QJHOD 7RPiV 0DQHO )UHGHULF ,YiQ 0D\WH -XDQ &DUPH ,VD )UDQFHVF 'HQLV %LELDQD 0DWHR 5REHUW 'jOLD 3DWULFLD 0RLVpV 6HUJL &RQUDG ,JQDVL 1~PHURGHHOHFFLRQHV UHFLELGDVHPLWLGDV 6XPDWRULRSXQWXDFLRQHVGH HOHFFLyQUHFLELGDV 0HGLDGHSXQWXDFLRQHVGH HOHFFLyQUHFLELGD 1~PHURGHUHFKD]RVUHFLELGRV HPLWLGRV (OHFFLRQHVTXH0DUtDUHFLEHGH (OHFFLRQHVHPLWLGDVSRU0DUtD VXVFRPSDxHURV $'0,1,675$&,Ð1-81,2 &ODVHGHHGXFDFLyQItVLFD -RDQD $QJHOD 7RPiV 0DQHO )UHGHULF ,YiQ 0D\WH -XDQ &DUPH ,VD )UDQFHVF 'HQLV %LELDQD 0DWHR 5REHUW 'jOLD 3DWULFLD 0RLVpV 6HUJL &RQUDG ,JQDVL 1~PHURGHHOHFFLRQHV UHFLELGDVHPLWLGDV 6XPDWRULRSXQWXDFLRQHVGH HOHFFLyQUHFLELGDV 0HGLDGHSXQWXDFLRQHVGH HOHFFLyQUHFLELGD 1~PHURGHUHFKD]RVUHFLELGRV HPLWLGRV (OHFFLRQHVTXH0DUtDUHFLEHGH (OHFFLRQHVHPLWLGDVSRU0DUtD VXVFRPSDxHURV [ [ [ [ $'0,1,675$&,Ð1-81,2 7UDEDMRHQFODVH -RDQD $QJHOD 7RPiV 0DQHO )UHGHULF ,YiQ 0D\WH -XDQ &DUPH ,VD )UDQFHVF 'HQLV %LELDQD 0DWHR 5REHUW 'jOLD 3DWULFLD 0RLVpV 6HUJL &RQUDG ,JQDVL 1~PHURGHHOHFFLRQHV UHFLELGDVHPLWLGDV 6XPDWRULRSXQWXDFLRQHVGH HOHFFLyQUHFLELGDV 0HGLDGHSXQWXDFLRQHVGH HOHFFLyQUHFLELGD 1~PHURGHUHFKD]RVUHFLELGRV HPLWLGRV (OHFFLRQHVTXH0DUtDUHFLEHGH (OHFFLRQHVHPLWLGDVSRU0DUtD VXVFRPSDxHURV [ [ [ [ &(1752-25', $'0,1,675$&,Ð10$5=2 &ODVHGHHGXFDFLyQItVLFD 0RQWVH 0DUWD 0LJXHOÉQJHO 0LUHLD 7HUHVD 5RFtR 3HUH /ROD /OXtV 0HUFq /tGLD )UDQFLQD 2OJD 5DIDHO &DWD )HUQDQGD &DUORV <DVRQH )HUUDQ 2ULRO -DQD 1~PHURGHHOHFFLRQHV UHFLELGDVHPLWLGDV 6XPDWRULRSXQWXDFLRQHVGH HOHFFLyQUHFLELGDV 0HGLDGHSXQWXDFLRQHVGH HOHFFLyQUHFLELGD 1~PHURGHUHFKD]RVUHFLELGRV HPLWLGRV (OHFFLRQHVTXH-RUGLUHFLEHGH VXVFRPSDxHURV [ [ (OHFFLRQHVHPLWLGDVSRU-RUGL [ [ $'0,1,675$&,Ð10$5=2 7UDEDMRHQFODVH 0RQWVH 0DUWD 0LJXHOÉQJHO 0LUHLD 7HUHVD 5RFtR 3HUH /ROD /OXtV 0HUFq /tGLD )UDQFLQD 2OJD 5DIDHO &DWD )HUQDQGD &DUORV <DVRQH )HUUDQ 2ULRO -DQD 1~PHURGHHOHFFLRQHV UHFLELGDVHPLWLGDV 6XPDWRULRSXQWXDFLRQHVGH HOHFFLyQUHFLELGDV 0HGLDGHSXQWXDFLRQHVGH HOHFFLyQUHFLELGD 1~PHURGHUHFKD]RVUHFLELGRV HPLWLGRV (OHFFLRQHVTXH-RUGLUHFLEHGH VXVFRPSDxHURV [ (OHFFLRQHVHPLWLGDVSRU-RUGL [ $'0,1,675$&,Ð1-81,2 &ODVHGHHGXFDFLyQItVLFD 0RQWVH 0DUWD 0LJXHOÉQJHO 0LUHLD 7HUHVD 5RFtR 3HUH /ROD /OXtV 0HUFq /tGLD )UDQFLQD 2OJD 5DIDHO &DWD )HUQDQGD &DUORV <DVRQH )HUUDQ 2ULRO -DQD 1~PHURGHHOHFFLRQHV UHFLELGDVHPLWLGDV 6XPDWRULRSXQWXDFLRQHVGH HOHFFLyQUHFLELGDV (OHFFLRQHVTXH-RUGLUHFLEHGH VXVFRPSDxHURV [ (OHFFLRQHVHPLWLGDVSRU-RUGL [ 0HGLDGHSXQWXDFLRQHVGH HOHFFLyQUHFLELGD 1~PHURGHUHFKD]RVUHFLELGRV HPLWLGRV (OHFFLRQHVTXH-RUGLUHFLEHGH VXVFRPSDxHURV [ (OHFFLRQHVHPLWLGDVSRU-RUGL $'0,1,675$&,Ð1-81,2 7UDEDMRHQFODVH 0RQWVH 0DUWD 0LJXHOÉQJHO 0LUHLD 7HUHVD 5RFtR 3HUH /ROD /OXtV 0HUFq /tGLD )UDQFLQD 2OJD 5DIDHO &DWD )HUQDQGD &DUORV <DVRQH )HUUDQ 2ULRO -DQD 1~PHURGHHOHFFLRQHV UHFLELGDVHPLWLGDV 6XPDWRULRSXQWXDFLRQHVGH HOHFFLyQUHFLELGDV 0HGLDGHSXQWXDFLRQHVGH HOHFFLyQUHFLELGD [ 1~PHURGHUHFKD]RVUHFLELGRV HPLWLGRV &(1752/2/$ $'0,1,675$&,Ð10$5=2 &ODVHGHHGXFDFLyQItVLFD -RUGL 0RQWVH 0DUWD 0LJXHOÉQJHO 0LUHLD 7HUHVD 5RFtR 3HUH /OXtV 0HUFq /tGLD )UDQFLQD 2OJD 5DIDHO &DWD )HUQDQGD &DUORV <DVRQH )HUUDQ 2ULRO -DQD 1~PHURGHHOHFFLRQHV UHFLELGDVHPLWLGDV 6XPDWRULRSXQWXDFLRQHVGH HOHFFLyQUHFLELGDV 0HGLDGHSXQWXDFLRQHVGH HOHFFLyQUHFLELGD 1~PHURGHUHFKD]RVUHFLELGRV HPLWLGRV (OHFFLRQHVTXH/RODUHFLEHGH VXVFRPSDxHURV [ [ (OHFFLRQHVHPLWLGDVSRU/ROD [ [ $'0,1,675$&,Ð10$5=2 7UDEDMRHQFODVH -RUGL 0RQWVH 0DUWD 0LJXHOÉQJHO 0LUHLD 7HUHVD 5RFtR 3HUH /OXtV 0HUFq /tGLD )UDQFLQD 2OJD 5DIDHO &DWD )HUQDQGD &DUORV <DVRQH )HUUDQ 2ULRO -DQD 1~PHURGHHOHFFLRQHV UHFLELGDVHPLWLGDV 6XPDWRULRSXQWXDFLRQHVGH HOHFFLyQUHFLELGDV 0HGLDGHSXQWXDFLRQHVGH HOHFFLyQUHFLELGD 1~PHURGHUHFKD]RVUHFLELGRV HPLWLGRV (OHFFLRQHVTXH/RODUHFLEHGH VXVFRPSDxHURV [ [ [ [ [ (OHFFLRQHVHPLWLGDVSRU/ROD [ [ [ [ $'0,1,675$&,Ð1-81,2 &ODVHGHHGXFDFLyQItVLFD -RUGL 0RQWVH 0DUWD 0LJXHOÉQJHO 0LUHLD 7HUHVD 5RFtR 3HUH /OXtV 0HUFq /tGLD )UDQFLQD 2OJD 5DIDHO &DWD )HUQDQGD &DUORV <DVRQH )HUUDQ 2ULRO -DQD 1~PHURGHHOHFFLRQHV UHFLELGDVHPLWLGDV 6XPDWRULRSXQWXDFLRQHVGH HOHFFLyQUHFLELGDV 0HGLDGHSXQWXDFLRQHVGH HOHFFLyQUHFLELGD 1~PHURGHUHFKD]RVUHFLELGRV HPLWLGRV (OHFFLRQHVTXH/RODUHFLEHGH VXVFRPSDxHURV [ [ (OHFFLRQHVHPLWLGDVSRU/ROD [ [ $'0,1,675$&,Ð1-81,2 7UDEDMRHQFODVH -RUGL 0RQWVH 0DUWD 0LJXHOÉQJHO 0LUHLD 7HUHVD 5RFtR 3HUH /OXtV 0HUFq /tGLD )UDQFLQD 2OJD 5DIDHO &DWD )HUQDQGD &DUORV <DVRQH )HUUDQ 2ULRO -DQD 1~PHURGHHOHFFLRQHV UHFLELGDVHPLWLGDV 6XPDWRULRSXQWXDFLRQHVGH HOHFFLyQUHFLELGDV 0HGLDGHSXQWXDFLRQHVGH HOHFFLyQUHFLELGD 1~PHURGHUHFKD]RVUHFLELGRV HPLWLGRV (OHFFLRQHVTXH/RODUHFLEHGH VXVFRPSDxHURV [ [ [ [ (OHFFLRQHVHPLWLGDVSRU/ROD [ [ [ [ DQH[R 'LDULRGHFDPSRGHO&HQWUR 6(6,Ï11 '(6(37,(0%5('( (OJUXSRFODVHHVWiFRPSXHVWRSRUDOXPQRV\DOXPQDVGHORVFXDOHVVRQQLxRV\ VRQQLxDV(QWUHpVWRVVHHQFXHQWUD0DUtDXVXDULDGHPXOHWDVGHELGRDXQDGLVJHQHVLD QHXURQDO $QWHV GH LQLFLDUVH OD VHVLyQ REVHUYR FRPR 0DUtD FUX]D HQ VROLWDULR SRU HO JLPQDVLR $ SHVDU GH VHU XVXDULD GH PXOHWDV REVHUYR VX JUDQ DXWRQRPtD SUHVHQWDQGR XQD OHYH VHPLIOH[LyQ GH SLHUQDV \ GHIRUPLGDGHV HQ ORV SLHV OR TXH OLPLWD OD PDUFKD VHJXUD 0H OODPDODDWHQFLyQVXH[SUHVLyQIDFLDOXQDH[SUHVLyQXQWDQWRWULVWH\GXUD 6HLQLFLDODVHVLyQSUHVHQWiQGRPHODPDHVWUDDORVDOXPQRV\DOXPQDV(QHVWHFHQWUR PH SUHVHQWDQ FRPR SURIHVRUD GH 8QLYHUVLGDG TXH FRODERUDUi FRQ OD DVLJQDWXUD $ ORV DOXPQRV OHV OODPD OD DWHQFLyQ \ SUHJXQWDQ VL HVWDUp WRGR HO FXUVR 'HFLPRV TXH Vt FRPHQWDQGRTXHHVWDUpXQSULPHUPHVREVHUYDQGR/RVDOXPQRVUHFLEHQODLQIRUPDFLyQ FRQJUDQQDWXUDOLGDG (OJUXSRHVWDVHQWDGRHQHOVXHORGHIRUPDRUGHQDGD\PLUDQGRKDFLDODPDHVWUDeVWD FRQWLQ~D ODVHVLyQH[SOLFDQGRODGLQiPLFD GH OD DVLJQDWXUD 3DUHFH LQWHUHVDUOHV\WRGRV HVFXFKDQ$FRQWLQXDFLyQSUHJXQWDDOJUXSRTXpDFWLYLGDGHVItVLFDVKDQSUDFWLFDGRDOR ODUJRGHOYHUDQR/DPD\RUtDFRPHQWDQTXHKDQUHDOL]DGRGLYHUVDVSUiFWLFDVGHSRUWLYDV &XDQGROOHJDHOWXUQRD0DUtDpVWDLQIRUPDTXHKDMXJDGRFRQVXVSULPRVDOMXHJRGHOD ³ERPED´ 5 5 5 5 (OJUXSRVHQWDGRHQFtUFXOR8QMXJDGRUHQHOFHQWUReVWHFXHQWDHQYR]DOWDGHD PLHQWUDV TXH VXV FRPSDxHURV VH YDQ SDVDQGR XQ EDOyQ GH XQR D RWUR VLJXLHQGR OD WUD\HFWRULDGHOFtUFXOR$OOOHJDUDHOMXJDGRUGHOFHQWURJULWD³%RPED´\HOMXJDGRUTXH WLHQHHOEDOyQHQHVHPRPHQWRHVHOTXHSDVDDHVWDUHQHOFHQWUR &RQVLGHURDSULRULTXHHVXQKHFKRPX\VLJQLILFDWLYRGDGRTXHHVXQMXHJRHVWiWLFRTXH QRSUHFLVDGHVSOD]DPLHQWR $QWHVGHLQLFLDUVHHOSULPHUMXHJRHQHOWLHPSRGHHVSHUDREVHUYRD0DUtDVHQWDGDHQHO VXHORDSXQWDQGRFRQODPXOHWDDVXVFRPSDxHURVFRPRVtGHXQDPHWUDOOHWDVHWUDWDUD\ pVWRVDGLVWDQFLDOHUHVSRQGtDFRQHOEUD]RDSXQWiQGRODORTXHSURYRFDVRQULVDVD0DUtD &RPLHQ]DODSDUWHSUiFWLFDFRQHOMXHJRGHO³VWRS´ 3DUDQ WUHV FRPSDxHURV LGHQWLILFiQGROHV FRQ XQ SDxXHOR (O REMHWLYR GH pVWRV HV HO GH 5 5 /DGLVJHQHVLDQHXURQDOHVXQDPDOIRUPDFLyQFRQJpQLWDGHOWXERQHXURQDOTXHHQHVWHFDVRSURYRFD XQDSDUDSDUHVLDDIHFWDFLyQSDUFLDOGHORVPLHPEURVLQIHULRUHV PRYLOL]DUDWRGRHOJUXSRFODVHLQWHQWDQGRWRFDUOHV$OVHUWRFDGRVWLHQHQTXHTXHGDUVH HVWiWLFRV FRQ ORV EUD]RV HQ FUX] (O UHVWR GH FRPSDxHURV SXHGHQ VDOYDUORV VL VH DSUR[LPDQDHOORV\OHGDQXQDSDOPDGDHQHOGRUVRGHODPDQRVLQKDEHUVLGRWRFDGRV SRUORVTXHSDUDQ /D SULPHUD UHDFFLyQ GH 0DUtD HV OD GH GHMDU ODV PXOHWDV HQ HO VXHOR \ GHVSOD]DUVH HQ FXDGUXSHGLD/DPDHVWUDOHDGYLHUWHTXHVHSRQJDGHSLH\TXHFRMDXQDPXOHWDeVWDVH D\XGDGHODVGRVPXOHWDVGHVSOD]iQGRVHFLUFXODUPHQWHSRUODVDODRFXSDQGRODV]RQDV H[WHULRUHV \ HVFRQGLpQGRVH WUDV ODV FROXPQDV 9D HVTXLYDQGR D ORV FRPSDxHURV \ D SHVDUGHODSUR[LPLGDGGHOMXJDGRUFRQHOEDOyQVHREVHUYDTXHQRODWLHQHQHQFXHQWD SDUD HOLPLQDUOD HV FRPR Vt OD LJQRUDVHQ $ SHVDU GH HOOR VH FRQVWDWD XQ FDPELR GH H[SUHVLyQGHODFDUDXQDFDUDDOHJUHVRQULHQWHTXHGHQRWDTXHVHORHVWiSDVDQGRELHQ DSHVDUGHODVOLPLWDFLRQHV 3RVWHULRUPHQWHODPDHVWUDSURSRQHHOMXHJRGHOD³DUDxD´ /RVMXJDGRUHVVHVLW~DQHQHOH[WUHPRGHODVDOD\RWURFRPSDxHUR³ODDUDxD´VHORFDOL]DHQHOFHQWUR GHODVDOD$ODVHxDOORVMXJDGRUHVWLHQHQTXHFUX]DUHOHVSDFLRGHMXHJRVFRQHOREMHWLYRTXHQROHVDWUDSH ³ODDUDxD´DQWHVGHOOHJDUDORWURH[WUHPRGHODVDOD$PHGLGDTXH³ODDUDxD´YDDWUDSDQGRORVVLW~DHQOD PLWDGGHOHVSDFLRORVFRQYLHUWHHQHVWDWXDVSDUDGLILFXOWDUHOGHVSOD]DPLHQWRGHORVMXJDGRUHVGDGRTXHVL WRFDQDXQDHVWDWXDVHFRQVLGHUDQDWUDSDGRV $LPDJHQGHOMXHJRDQWHULRUODLJQRUDQHQHOPRPHQWRTXHSXHGHQHOLPLQDUODLQFOXVRXQR GHORVMXJDGRUHVTXHDWUDSDFXDQGRYDGHWUiVGHHOODKDFHYHUTXHWURSLH]D\SRUWDQWR VHOHHVFDSD1RHVWRFDGDKDVWDTXHGDUODSHQ~OWLPD &RPRHVODSULPHUDVHVLyQ\ODPD\RUtDQRKDQWUDtGRURSDGHUHFDPELRODPDHVWUDOHV LQVWDDTXHYD\DQDOYHVWXDULRDUHIUHVFDUVH7RGDVODVQLxDVHQWUDQPHQRV0DUtD(OODVH TXHGDVHQWDGDHQHOFHQWURGHODVDODMXQWRDXQDSDUWHGHOJUXSRGHQLxRV8QRGHHOORV UHFODPD OD DWHQFLyQ GH OD PDHVWUD GHPRVWUiQGROH TXH VDEtD KDFHU OD YHUWLFDO $ FRQWLQXDFLyQ 0DUtD FRPHQWD TXH HOOD WDPELpQ VDEH KDFHU OD YHUWLFDO SHUR GDGD OD GLVWDQFLDFRQODPDHVWUDpVWDQRODR\H\0DUtDVHTXHGDVRODHQHOFHQWURDUURGLOODGD FRQ ODV PXOHWDV H[WHQGLGDV VREUH HO VXHOR KDVWD TXH WUHV FRPSDxHURV OD URGHDQ FRUULHQGRHQFtUFXOR\VDOWDQGRODVPXOHWDV0DUtDYXHOYHDVRQUHtU3RVWHULRUPHQWHDQWH HO UHFODPR GH OD PDHVWUD MXVWDPHQWH FXDQGR VDOH HO UHVWR GHO JUXSR GH QLxDV GHO YHVWXDULRHOODHQWUDDFRJHUVXFKDTXHWDGHFKiQGDO\VDOHHQVROLWDULR &RPHQWDULRVDODVHVLyQ &RPR OD PDHVWUD LQGLFD TXH HQ ORV MXHJRV GH SHUVHFXFLyQ HQ YH] GH WRFDU D ORV FRPSDxHURVORVKDQGHFRJHUSRUODFLQWXUDHOORSURYRFDFDtGDVFRQWLQXDV3HQVDQGR HQ ODV IXWXUDV DGDSWDFLRQHV HV LPSRUWDQWH VXJHULU D OD PDHVWUD TXH XQ DOXPQR VH FRQVLGHUDDWUDSDGRFXDQGRORWRFDQGHWDOIRUPDTXHFXDQGRSURSRQJDODDGDSWDFLyQ SDUD 0DUtD VHUi OD PiV VLPLODU DO UHVWR GHO JUXSR \ DGHPiV SUHVHUYDUHPRV OD VHJXULGDGGHWRGRV\WRGDVHYLWDQGRFDtGDVLQQHFHVDULDV &RPR0DUtDWLHQHODWHQGHQFLDDRFXSDUORVHVSDFLRVODWHUDOHVGHOMXHJRSDUDHYLWDU SRVLEOHVFKRTXHVFRQORVFRPSDxHURVDQWHODLQFHUWLGXPEUHTXHJHQHUDQORVMXHJRV 5 5 5 5 5 GHSHUVHFXFLyQFRQVLGHURTXHVHOHKDGHWUDQVPLWLUFRQILDQ]DSDUDTXHVHGHVSODFH SRUHOFHQWURGHOD]RQDGHMXHJRGHDKtODLPSRUWDQFLDGHODILJXUDGHOSURIHVRUGH DSR\R³KDFHUGHVRPEUD´SDUDHYLWDUJROSHVGHVXVFRPSDxHURV $QWHODDFWLWXGGHORVMXJDGRUHVTXHDWUDSDQVLPXODQGRFDtGDVSDUDDVtGDUYHQWDMDD 0DUtDRELHQHYLWDQGRQRWRFDUODDOJUXSRFODVHVHOHKDGHUHFRUGDUTXH0DUtDWLHQH ORVPLVPRVGHUHFKRV\REOLJDFLRQHVHVGHFLUTXHVLVHOHFRPSHQVDQODVGLILFXOWDGHV HV SDUD IDFLOLWDU VX DFFHVR DO MXHJR \ TXH QR SULYD GH TXH VHD WRFDGD R DWUDSDGD FRPRORVGHPiVHQORVMXHJRVGHSHUVHFXFLyQ &RPR HQ YDULDV RFDVLRQHV 0DUtD VH KD TXHGDGR DO PDUJHQ GH ORV FRPSDxHURV &RQVLGHURTXHODPDHVWUDWLHQHTXHFRQWURODUPiVFRQODPLUDGDODVLWXDFLyQHVSDFLDO SDUDTXHpVWDQRVHTXHGHVRODRELHQFXDQGRVHLQLFLDHOMXHJRTXHHVWpMXQWRDVXV FRPSDxHURV\QRHQXQH[WUHPRGHODVDOD 'HEH UHFRUGDUVH D OD PDHVWUD TXH LQGLTXH D 0DUtD TXH VH GHVSODFH FRQ ODV GRV PXOHWDVQRVyORFRQXQDSDUDHYLWDU TXH VX HVSDOGD VXIUD GH PiV GHVYLDFLRQHV \ SDUDJDUDQWL]DUVXHTXLOLEULR 6(6,Ï11 '(6(37,(0%5('( (QWURDODVHVLyQ\ORVQLxRV\QLxDVHVWiQVHQWDGRVHQHOVXHORGHOJLPQDVLRGHIRUPD RUGHQDGD &XDQGR GR\ ODV EXHQDV WDUGHV 0DUtD PH UHVSRQGH FRQ EXHQDV QRFKHV /H SUHJXQWRODUD]yQ\HOODPHFRQWHVWDTXHSRUTXHVHHVWiDEXUULHQGR -XVWDPHQWHHQHVHPRPHQWRODPDHVWUDLQLFLDODVHVLyQFRPHQWDQGRODVDFWLYLGDGHVTXH UHDOL]DUiQ HQ HO SDWLR 6H RUJDQL]D XQD ILOD OLGHUDGD SRU 0DUtD 2EVHUYR TXH HO JUXSR VLJXHRUGHQDGDPHQWH\TXHQRODDGHODQWDKDVWDTXHOOHJDQDODSLVWDSROLGHSRUWLYD 6H RUJDQL]DQ FXDWUR ILODV OD FRPSRVLFLyQ GH pVWDV ODV GHFLGH OD PDHVWUD 0H OODPD OD DWHQFLyQODDFWLWXGGHOJUXSRGH0DUtDTXHHQXQSULQFLSLRQRGHPXHVWUDGHVFRQWHQWR/D PDHVWUDSURSRQHHOMXHJRGHO³W~QHOFRQSHORWD´ *UXSRVGHFLQFRMXJDGRUHVXQRGHWUiVGHRWURDXQDGLVWDQFLDHQWUHpVWRVGHXQPHWUR DSUR[LPDGDPHQWH$ODVHxDOHOSULPHUMXJDGRUSDVDUiODSHORWDSRUHQFLPDGHODFDEH]D DO FRPSDxHUR TXH OH SURVLJXH \ DVt VXFHVLYDPHQWH KDVWD TXH OD SHORWD OOHJD DO ~OWLPR MXJDGRUeVWHVHGHVSOD]DUiKDFLDGHODQWHKDVWDDOFDQ]DUDOSULPHUMXJDGRUVLWXiQGRVHD ODGLVWDQFLDGHXQPHWURSDViQGROHGHQXHYRHOEDOyQWDO\FRPRVHKDDFRUGDGR<DVt VXFHVLYDPHQWHKDVWDDOFDQ]DUXQDOtQHDSUHGHWHUPLQDGD¢$YHUTXpHTXLSRODDOFDQ]D DQWHV" &XDQGROHWRFDD0DUtDSHUFLERTXHHOODQRORSXHGHFRJHUFRQODVGRVPDQRVGDGRTXH HVWiQRFXSDGDVSRUODVPXOHWDV/DUHDFFLyQTXHWLHQHHVODGHGHMDUODVPXOHWDVHQHO VXHOR\DUURGLOODUVHSDUDDVtWHQHUODVPDQRVOLEUHV/DPDHVWUDOHLQGLFDTXHVHOHYDQWH\ TXHORKDJDFRPRHODxRSDVDGRFRQXQDPDQR/RLQWHQWD\DSHVDUGHODVGLILFXOWDGHV HYLGHQWHVSDVDHOEDOyQ6HGHWHFWDTXHHOULWPRGHHVHJUXSRHPSLH]DDVHUPXFKRPiV OHQWR TXH HO GHO UHVWR GH WDO IRUPD TXH ORV FRPSRQHQWHV HPSLH]DQ D GHVDQLPDUVH /D PDHVWUDUHDFFLRQDGLFLHQGRTXHQRKD\FRPSHWLFLyQ&XDQGROHWRFDGHVSOD]DUVHD0DUtD 5 5 5 5 5 KDFLDHOLQLFLRGHODILODHQOtQHDUHFWDERWDQGRHOEDOyQPLHQWUDVTXHHOUHVWRGHOJUXSROR KDFH HQ ]LJ]DJ HQWUH ORV FRPSDxHURV VH REVHUYD GH QXHYR VXV OLPLWDFLRQHV (V LPSRVLEOHTXHSXHGDERWDUHOEDOyQVtWLHQHODVGRVPDQRVFRJLGDVDODVPXOHWDV(OULWPR GH HVH JUXSR D~Q HV PiV OHQWR ORV PLHPEURV HPSLH]DQ D GHVHVSHUDUVH /D PDHVWUD LQGLFDD0DUtDTXHORUHDOLFHFRPRHODxRDQWHULRUSHUR0DUtDQRSXHGH/RLQWHQWDYDULDV YHFHV GHVFRQWURODQGR HO EDOyQ KDVWD TXH OOHJD DO LQLFLR GH OD FROD < HQ HVH PRPHQWR ILQDOL]DHOMXHJRGHWDOIRUPDTXHVLHQORVRWURVJUXSRVFDGDPLHPEURVHKDGHVSOD]DGR FRPRPtQLPRWUHVYHFHVHQHOJUXSRGH0DUtDWDQVRORHQXQDRFDVLyQ /DPDHVWUDVHMXVWLILFDGLFLHQGRTXHRWUDVYHFHVSURSRQHD0DUtDTXHUHDOLFHODDFWLYLGDG HQ VROLWDULR GHVSOD]DUVH FRQ EDOyQ SHUR TXH KD SULRUL]DGR OD QHFHVLGDG GH 0DUtD GH FRPSDUWLU DFWLYLGDGHV JUXSDOHV \ DGHPiV KD DSURYHFKDGR SDUD TXH \R REVHUYH VXV GLILFXOWDGHV (OVHJXQGRMXHJRTXHSURSRQHHVXQ³UHOHYROLQHDO´ 2UJDQL]DJUXSRVGHVHLVFRPSRQHQWHVWUHVHQILODLQGLDDXQDGLVWDQFLDGHXQRVPHWURVGHORV RWURVWUHVFRPSDxHURVTXHWDPELpQHVWDUiQRUGHQDGRVHQILODLQGLD(OSULPHURGHODILODLQLFLDHOUHFRUULGR KDFLDORVFRPSDxHURVTXHWLHQHGHODQWHERWDQGRXQEDOyQGHWDOIRUPDTXHFXDQGRVHHQFXHQWUHDXQ PHWURGHGLVWDQFLDGHOSULPHUROHSDVDUiHOEDOyQVLWXiQGRVHHO~OWLPRGHODILOD(OMXJDGRUTXHSRVHHHO EDOyQLQLFLDUiGHQXHYRHOSURFHVRKDVWDDOFDQ]DUDOSULPHUMXJDGRUGHODRWUDILOD\DVtVXFHVLYDPHQWHKDVWD TXHWRGRVVHKDOODQGHVSOD]DGRFRQHOEDOyQ¢4XpHTXLSRILQDOL]DDQWHV" /D DGDSWDFLyQ TXH SURSRQH OD PDHVWUD HV OD GH DFRUWDU OD GLVWDQFLD GH 0DUtD 0H GR\ FXHQWDUiSLGDPHQWHTXHHQQLQJ~QPRPHQWRWLHQHHQFXHQWDFyPRVHGHVSOD]DUi0DUtD FRQHOEDOyQ&XDQGRHVRRFXUUHODUHDFFLyQGH0DUtDHVODGHDUURGLOODUVHVREUHHOVXHOR GH FHPHQWR \ GHVSOD]DUVH ERWDQGR HO EDOyQ /D PDHVWUD OH UHFULPLQD TXH QR FRQWLQ~H SRUTXHSXHGHOHVLRQDUVHODVURGLOODV&RPRHQODRFDVLyQDQWHULRU0DUtDGHGLFDXQVLQILQ GHHVIXHU]RVSDUDFRRUGLQDUVXGHVSOD]DPLHQWRFRQHOGRPLQLRGHOEDOyQ/DIUXVWUDFLyQ HVFRQWLQXDKDVWDTXHHOODGHFLGHFKXWDUHOEDOyQFRQORVSLHV/DPDHVWUDPHSUHJXQWD TXpPHSDUHFH\\ROHFRQWHVWRTXHPHMRUDVtSHURTXHQRREVWDQWHLUHPRVDFODUDQGR ORVFULWHULRVGHDGDSWDFLyQILQDOL]DGRHOSULPHUPHVGHREVHUYDFLyQ 3DUDILQDOL]DUVHFLHUUDODMRUQDGDFRQHOMXHJRGH³PDWDU´ /RVMXJDGRUHVVHGLVWULEX\HQHQGRVJUXSRVVHSDUDGRVSRUXQDOtQHDFHQWUDO(OHVSDFLR HVWiGHOLPLWDGR(OREMHWLYRGHOMXHJRHVHOLPLQDUDOHTXLSRFRQWUDULR3DUDHOORFXDQGRVH ODQ]D HO EDOyQ GH HVSXPD H LPSDFWD D XQ DGYHUVDULR WRFiQGROR HQ FXDOTXLHU SDUWH FRUSRUDO H[FHSWXDQGR OD FDUD \ ORV SLHV \ FDH SRVWHULRUPHQWH HO EDOyQ DO VXHOR VH FRQVLGHUDPXHUWReVWHVHGHVSOD]DKDFLDXQRGHORVGRVH[WUHPRVODWHUDOHVGHOFDPSR GHORVMXJDGRUHVDGYHUVDULRVGHQRPLQDGD]RQDGHPXHUWRV\GHVGHDOOtLQWHQWD³PDWDU´D XQDGYHUVDULR'HQRFRQVHJXLUORWLHQHTXHHVSHUDUKDVWDTXHVXVFRPSDxHURVOHSDVHQ HOEDOyQRELHQTXHORSXHGDFRQVHJXLUSRUTXHHOEDOyQKDHQWUDGRDVX]RQDGHMXHJRVR ELHQ SRUTXH VH OR SDVH HO UH\ eVWH HVWi ORFDOL]DGR HQ HO WHUFHU ODWHUDO GHO FDPSR TXH TXHGDOLEUHGHIRUPDIURQWDO\WLHQHHOSRGHUGHWHQHUGRVYLGDVHQHOLQLFLRGHOMXHJR6t FRQVLJXHPDWDUDXQDGYHUVDULRVXPDXQDWHUFHUDYLGDSDViQGRVHODDDOJ~QFRPSDxHUR TXHHVWpHQDOJXQDGHODVGRV]RQDVODWHUDOHVGHPXHUWRVSRUORTXHVHSRGUiOLEHUDU\ WUDVODGDUVHDOFDPSRGHMXHJRFRQVXHTXLSR(QHOPRPHQWRTXHXQHTXLSRVHTXHGDWDQ VyORFRQGRVMXJDGRUHV\HOUHVWRHVWiQPXHUWRVHOUH\SDVDDOD]RQDGHMXHJRFRQVXV GRV YLGDV \ VHUi FXDOTXLHU FRPSDxHUR PXHUWR TXH DVXPD HO URO GH UH\ KDVWD TXH 5 5 5 HOLPLQHQDORULJLQDORELHQKDVWDTXHVHFRQVLJDDXPHQWDUHOQ~PHURGHMXJDGRUHVHQHO WHUUHQRGHMXHJRDWUHVGHWDOIRUPDTXHHOUH\UHJUHVDUiGHQXHYRDOD]RQDGHPXHUWRV /D PDHVWUD HOLJH GRV FDSLWDQHV DO D]DU VLHQGR DTXHOORV TXH DFLHUWHQ HO Q~PHUR VHOHFFLRQDGR SRU HOOD \ SRU Pt eVWRV HVFRJHQ D VXV FRPSDxHURV \ FRPR QR HUD GH H[WUDxDUOD~OWLPDSRUVHUHOHJLGDHV0DUtDORFXDOSDUHFHQRVRUSUHQGHUOH&XDQGROOHJD DOD]RQDGHMXHJRFRPHQWD³VLPHYDQDPDWDUHQVHJXLGD´7DO\FRPRHOODSUHYHtDOD PDWDQ GH ODV SULPHUDV QR REVWDQWH WHQJR TXH DQRWDU TXH HOOD LQWHQWDED HVFRQGHUVH GHWUiVGHDOJXQDMXJDGRUD\HQRWUDVRFDVLRQHVKHHVFXFKDGRDXQFRPSDxHURLQGLFDUD ORVMXJDGRUHVGHVXHTXLSRTXHFXEULHVHQD0DUtD&XDQGROOHJDDOFDPSRGHPXHUWRVOD PDHVWUDOHLQGLFDTXHSDVHHOEDOyQDOUH\SDUDTXHpVWHLQWHQWHPDWDUDXQDGYHUVDULR\ SDVDUOH OD YLGD D HOOD 3RVWHULRUPHQWH DQWH HO FDQVDQFLR GH HVSHUDU D TXH OH SDVHQ HO EDOyQSDUDSRGHUWHQHUODRSRUWXQLGDGGHVDOYDUVH0DUtDVHVLHQWDHQHOVXHORGLFLHQGR TXHVHDEXUUHPXFKtVLPR7UDVHVWRODPDHVWUDIXHU]DTXHOHSDVHQHOEDOyQ\DSHVDUGH ODVLQGLFDFLRQHVGHpVWDFRPRHQODRFDVLyQDQWHULRUTXHSDVHHOEDOyQDOUH\SDUDTXH pVWHLQWHQWHPDWDUDXQDGYHUVDULR\OHSDVHODYLGDHOODGHFLGHODQ]DUHOEDOyQKDFLDVXV DGYHUVDULRVVHQWDGDHQHOVXHOR\ODQ]iQGRORFRQODPDQR/DUHDFFLyQGHpVWRVKDVLGR FXULRVDHQYH]GHDOHMDUVHVHKDQLGRDSUR[LPDQGRSDUDGDUPiVIDFLOLGDGHVD0DUtD$O ILQDOHOUH\OHKDSDVDGRXQDYLGD\0DUtDKDYXHOWRDOFDPSRSHURVHJXLGDPHQWHDOFDER GHXQRVFXDWURPLQXWRVKDYXHOWRDOD]RQDGHPXHUWRVKDVWDILQDOL]DUODVHVLyQ (Q HO GHVSOD]DPLHQWR KDFLD HO JLPQDVLR VH KD TXHGDGR OD ~OWLPD HQ VROLWDULR +H DSURYHFKDGR SDUD FRPHQWDUOH TXp HV OR TXH PHQRV OH KD JXVWDGR \ PH KD FRQWHVWDGR TXHVHKDDEXUULGRPXFKRHQHOMXHJRGHPDWDU£\UD]RQHVWHQtD $O OOHJDU DO JLPQDVLR FRPR 0DUtD QR VH GXFKD OD PDHVWUD KD SURSXHVWR TXH MXHJXH D ³PDUFDU JRO D ODV SRUWHUtDV GH ORV FRQWUDULRV´ FRQ WUHV FRPSDxHURV TXH WDPSRFR VH GXFKDQSRUTXHUHDOL]DQDFWLYLGDGHVItVLFDVH[WUDHVFRODUHV /RV MXJDGRUHV GLVWULEXLGRV SRU ORV ODWHUDOHV GHO HVSDFLR &DGD XQR WLHQH GHOLPLWDGD VX SRUWHUtD FRQ XQ SDU GH FRQRV (O MXHJR FRQVLVWH HQ ODQ]DU HO EDOyQ URGDQGR KDFLD FXDOTXLHURWURFRPSDxHURFRQHOILQGHFRQVHJXLUTXHpVWHHQWUHDODSRUWHUtD\PDUFDUXQ JRO &RPR WRGRV HVWiQ HQ HO VXHOR HQ VLWXDFLRQHV VLPLODUHV D OD GH 0DUtD pVWD VH KD PRVWUDGRPX\ULVXHxD\SDUWLFLSDWLYD 'H QXHYR KD VDOLGR GHO JLPQDVLR HQ VROLWDULR PLHQWUDV TXH HO UHVWR GH FRPSDxHUDV OR KDFHQHQVXEJUXSRVGHVSXpVGHODGXFKD &RPHQWDULRVDODVHVLyQ 3RUORTXHKHREVHUYDGRODPDHVWUDQRKDWHQLGRHQFXHQWDODVDGDSWDFLRQHVSDUD 0DUtDFRQHOREMHWRGHIDFLOLWDUVXSDUWLFLSDFLyQDFWLYDHQORVMXHJRVSURSXHVWRVSRU WDQWR OD PDHVWUD WLHQH TXH SUHYHU ODV DGDSWDFLRQHV FRQ DQWHODFLyQ VLQ GHMDU HQ HYLGHQFLDODVOLPLWDFLRQHVGH0DUtD (Q DTXHOODV VLWXDFLRQHV TXH VH GHVFRQR]FDQ ODV SRVLEOHV DGDSWDFLRQHV FRQVLGHUR TXH VHWLHQHTXHSUHJXQWDUD0DUtD 6HJXUR TXH SRU VX YLYHQFLD SXHGH IDFLOLWDU ODV 5 5 5 5 5 5 5 VROXFLRQHV &XDQGR OD PDHVWUD SURSRQH HO MXHJR GHO W~QHO \ DQWH OD IDOWD GH DGDSWDFLyQ VH REVHUYDTXHORVPLHPEURVGHVXJUXSRUHDOL]DQPHQRVGHVSOD]DPLHQWRVTXHORVGHO UHVWR3RUWDQWRQRWHQHPRVTXHSHUGHUGHYLVWDTXHODOHQWLWXGGH0DUtDQRSXHGH FRQGLFLRQDUODPRWULFLGDGGHVXVFRPSDxHURV (QHOMXHJRGHPDWDUODPDHVWUDQRSURSRQHODVSRVLEOHVDGDSWDFLRQHVHQIXQFLyQGH ORVGLVWLQWRVUROHVTXHSXHGHDGTXLULUHOMXJDGRU(VSRUHVWRTXHVHKDGHSHQVDUFRQ DQWHODFLyQHQODDGDSWDFLyQGHWRGRV ORV UROHV GHOMXHJR1RVHSXHGHSHUPLWLUTXH VXV FRPSDxHURV GHFLGDQ SRU HOOD HV GHFLU TXH UHDOLFHQ OD DFFLyQ GH pVWD SDUD REWHQHUXQEHQHILFLRDGRSWDQGR0DUtDXQUROFRPSOHWDPHQWHSDVLYR $QWHODHQWUDGD\VDOLGDGHOFDPSRGHMXHJRVREVHUYRTXH0DUtDVHTXHGDVLHPSUH VRODVLQLQWHUDFFLyQDOJXQDFRQVXVFRPSDxHURV\FRPSDxHUDV3LHQVRTXHVHWLHQH TXH SRWHQFLDU HQ HO JUXSR FODVH XQD DFWLWXG PiV DWHQWD \ VRFLDO HQ ORV GHVSOD]DPLHQWRVQRGHMiQGRODHQVROLWDULR 6(6,Ï11 '(6(37,(0%5('( /DVHVLyQSUiFWLFDWDQVyORKDVLGRGHPLQXWRV\DTXHVHKDDSURYHFKDGRSDUDSDVDU ORV FXHVWLRQDULRV VREUH HO VRFLRJUDPD GH OD FODVH GH (GXFDFLyQ )tVLFD \ ODV FUHHQFLDV UHVSHFWRDODSDUWLFLSDFLyQGHORVDOXPQRVFRQGLVFDSDFLGDGHQORVMXHJRVGHSDWLR\HQOD VHVLyQGH(GXFDFLyQ)tVLFD0HKDOODPDGRODDWHQFLyQODOHQWLWXGGHUHVSXHVWDGH0DUtD HVWDEDPX\SHQVDWLYD\KDVLGROD~OWLPDHQHQWUHJDUORVFXHVWLRQDULRV0HVXJLHUHTXH VXULWPRHQJHQHUDOHVPXFKRPiVOHQWRTXHHOGHVXVFRPSDxHURV 5HIHUHQWH D VXV UHVSXHVWDV DO FXHVWLRQDULR VREUH OD SDUWLFLSDFLyQ GH ORV DOXPQRV FRQ GLVFDSDFLGDG HQ ODV VHVLRQHV GH (GXFDFLyQ )tVLFD GHVWDFD VX FRQYHQFLPLHQWR GH TXH WRGRVORVDOXPQRVSXHGHQSDUWLFLSDUWDQWRHQODVVHVLRQHVFRPRHQORVMXHJRVGHSDWLR H[FHSWXDQGRORVDOXPQRVXVXDULRVGHVLOODGHUXHGDVTXHLQGLFDTXH³DYHFHV´QRSXHGHQ SDUWLFLSDUGHODVVHVLRQHV &XDQGR EDMDPRV DO JLPQDVLR OD PDHVWUD GD OD FRQVLJQD GH TXH VH VLHQWHQ RUGHQDGDPHQWH&RPR0DUtDWLHQHODWHQGHQFLDGHDUURGLOODUVHpVWDOHUHFXHUGDTXHVH VLHQWHFRPRORVGHPiV'DGRHOHVFDVRWLHPSRTXHGLVSRQHSDUDODSDUWHSUiFWLFDGHFLGH SURSRQHU XQ MXHJR GH DQLPDFLyQ ³HO KHFKLFHUR´ \ RWUR GH YXHOWD D OD FDOPD ³HO WHOHJUDPD´5HVSHFWRDOSULPHUR 3DUDQ WUHV FRPSDxHURV LGHQWLILFiQGROHV FRQ XQ SDxXHOR (O REMHWLYR GH pVWRV HV HO GH PRYLOL]DUDWRGRHOJUXSRFODVHLQWHQWDQGRWRFDUOHV$OVHUWRFDGRVWLHQHQTXHTXHGDUVH HVWiWLFRV FRQ ORV EUD]RV HQ FUX] (O UHVWR GH FRPSDxHURV SXHGHQ VDOYDUORV VL VH DSUR[LPDQDHOORV\OHGDQXQDSDOPDGDHQHOGRUVRGHODPDQRVLQKDEHUVLGRWRFDGRV SRUORVTXHSDUDQ 6H REVHUYD TXH 0DUtD FRQWLQ~D SURWHJLpQGRVH WUDV ODV FROXPQDV VLHQGR VX GHVSOD]DPLHQWRHQXQUDGLRGHXQRVFXDWURPHWURV/DKDQWRFDGRYDULDVYHFHVSHURQR REVWDQWH OD KDQ VDOYDGR \ DVt PLVPR HOOD WDPELpQ KD VDOYDGR VLQ SUREOHPDV D VXV 5 5 5 5 5 FRPSDxHURV 6H OH REVHUYD ULVXHxD \ PRWLYDGD SRU HO MXHJR /D PDHVWUD SURSRQH SRVWHULRUPHQWH TXH VH VDOYH SDVDQGR HQWUH ODV SLHUQDV \ 0DUtD GHPXHVWUD XQD JUDQ DXWRQRPtDFRQWURODQGRODUHSWDFLyQ\HOGRPLQLRGHODVPXOHWDV(QODVLJXLHQWHYDULDQWH TXH FRQVLVWHHQUHDOL]DUXQVDOWRVREUH HOFRPSDxHURKHFKL]DGRODPDHVWUDLQGLFDTXH 0DUtD VHDXQRGHORVMXJDGRUHVTXHSDUH 5D]RQD WDO GHFLVLyQ SRUTXH 0DUtD QR SXHGH VDOWDU 'DGD OD JUDQ LQFHUWLGXPEUH \ DQWH HO HVSDFLR UHGXFLGR KD WRFDGR D YDULRV FRPSDxHURVDSURYHFKDQGRVXGHVSLVWHHLQGXGDEOHPHQWHVXPRWLYDFLyQHVPX\DOWD(Q HVWDV GRV RFDVLRQHV DPSOtD VX HVSDFLR GH UHFRUULGR QR REVWDQWH KH DQRWDGR YDULRV DPDJRVFXDQGRVXVFRPSDxHURVSDVDEDQSUy[LPRVDHOOD 5HIHUHQWHDOMXHJRGHO³WHOHJUDPD´ *UXSRV GH FLQFR HQ ILOD LQGLD VHQWDGRV HQ HO VXHOR D XQD GLVWDQFLD GH XQRV FLQFXHQWD FHQWtPHWURVHQWUHORVMXJDGRUHVGHOPLVPRJUXSR(OMXHJRFRQVLVWHHQTXHHO~OWLPRGHOD ILOD WLHQH TXH LGHDU XQ PHQVDMH TXH PHGLDQWH HO WDFWR D WUDYpV GHO FRQWDFWR FRQ OD HVSDOGD TXH WLHQH GHODQWH \ VLQ KDEODU WLHQH TXH SDVDU HO PHQVDMH DO FRPSDxHUR TXH WLHQHGHODQWH\pVWHDVXYH]WUDQVPLWLUOR$VtVXFHVLYDPHQWHKDVWDTXHOOHJDDOSULPHUR 6HWUDWDGHFRPSUREDUVLHOPHQVDMHKDOOHJDGRILGHGLJQDPHQWH 'DGDV ODV FDUDFWHUtVWLFDV SURSLDV GHO MXHJR 0DUtD KD SDUWLFLSDGR DFWLYDPHQWH VLQ QHFHVLGDG GH DGDSWDU HO MXHJR 6X JUXSR VH REVHUYDED PX\ FRKHVLRQDGR HVWDEOHFLpQGRVHSRVLWLYDVLQWHUUHODFLRQHVHQWUHVXVPLHPEURV +D ILQDOL]DGR OD VHVLyQ FRQ XQ FXDUWR GH KRUD GH DQWHODFLyQ SDUD GHMDU PDUJHQ SDUD OD GXFKD /DPDHVWUDUHSDUWHXQDVDXWRUL]DFLRQHVVREUHXQDVDOLGDSDUDTXHODVILUPHQORVSDGUHV WRGRVORVQLxRVYDQDUHFRJHUHOLPSUHVRH[FHSWXDQGR0DUtDTXHVHTXHGDVHQWDGDHQOD HVTXLQD GHO HVSDFLR TXH WLHQH DVLJQDGD (V XQ FRPSDxHUR SRU LQGLFDFLRQHV GH OD PDHVWUDTXHOHKDFHOOHJDUHOLPSUHVR &RPR HQ OD VHVLyQ DQWHULRU SURSRQH XQ MXHJR SDUD RFXSDU SRVLWLYDPHQWH HO WLHPSR GH HVSHUDDDTXHOORVTXHHVWiQMXVWLILFDGRVTXHQRVHGXFKHQHQWUHHOORV0DUtD(QHVWD RFDVLyQHVHOGH³SDVDUVHXQPHQVDMHRUDOPHQWH´ /RV DOXPQRV VHQWDGRV HQ HO VXHOR HQ FtUFXOR 8QR DO ODGR GH RWUR 8Q MXJDGRU LQLFLD HO MXHJR SDVDQGR XQ PHQVDMH RUDO DO FRPSDxHUR PiV SUy[LPR \ DVt VXFHVLYDPHQWH KDVWD OOHJDU DO ~OWLPR SDUWLFLSDQWH 6H WUDWD GH FRPSUREDU VL HO PHQVDMH KD OOHJDGR ILGHGLJQDPHQWH $OHVWDUVHQWDGRVHQHOVXHORWDPSRFRSUHVHQWDQLQJXQDGLILFXOWDG /DPDHVWUDPHLQIRUPDTXHQRVHUiSRVLEOHTXH0DUtDVHGXFKHORVPLpUFROHVSRUTXHD ODV ¶ KRUDV YLHQH OD DPEXODQFLD SDUD WUDVODGDUOD DO FHQWUR GH UHKDELOLWDFLyQ 1R REVWDQWHOHKHFRPHQWDGRTXHDSHVDUGHHOORORVPDUWHVVtTXHSXHGH(OODORKDYLVWR GLILFXOWRVRSRUVXOHQWLWXG\SRUODSRVLEOHUHVSXHVWDGHODPDGUH/HKHLQVLVWLGRTXHHO KiELWR KLJLpQLFR HV XQ REMHWLYR SDUD WUDEDMDU HQ WRGRV \ WRGDV \ TXH QR GHEH KDEHU H[FHSFLRQHV/RKHPRVGHMDGRSDUDKDEODUORFRQORVSDGUHVHOGtDGHODHQWUHYLVWD 5 5 5 5 5 5 5 7DPELpQ PH KD FRPHQWDGR TXH OD DFWLWXG GH ORV SDGUHV HV PX\ SRVLWLYD UHVSHFWR D OD LQYHVWLJDFLyQTXHLQLFLR\TXHQRSRQHQQLQJ~QSUREOHPDHQODUHFRJLGDGHGDWRV'HHVD UHXQLyQ VH GHVSUHQGH XQD LQIRUPDFLyQ PX\ LQWHUHVDQWH SDUD ODV VHVLRQHV HVWiQ SHQGLHQWHV GH TXH OHV VXEYHQFLRQHQ XQD VLOOD GH UXHGDV SDUD IDFLOLWDU ODV VDOLGDV GH 0DUtD/DVGRVFRLQFLGLPRVTXHVHUiXQPDWHULDODWHQHUSUHVHQWHHQODVVHVLRQHVGDGR TXH IDFLOLWDUi OD SDUWLFLSDFLyQ DFWLYD GH 0DUtD HQ DTXHOORV MXHJRV TXH SUHFLVHQ GHVSOD]DPLHQWRV\FRQWUROGHLPSOHPHQWRV &RPHQWDULRVDODVHVLyQ 0HOODPDODDWHQFLyQODDXWRQRPtDGH0DUtDDSHVDUGHVXVOLPLWDFLRQHV7LHQHXQ JUDQ FRQWURO GH ODV PXOHWDV WDQWR HQ ORV GHVSOD]DPLHQWRV FRPR FXDQGR WLHQH TXH UHDOL]DU DOJXQD KDELOLGDG FRQFUHWD FRPR SXHGH VHU WRFDU D XQ FRPSDxHUR HQ VLWXDFLyQGHSHUVHFXVLyQ 3RU ORV FRPHQWDULRV TXH PH KDFH OD PDHVWUD UHFRMR XQD DFWLWXG UHFHSWLYD DQWH PL SUy[LPDLQWHUYHQFLyQ 3LHQVR TXH VL GLVSRQHPRV GH XQD VLOOD GH UXHGDV WDO \ FRPR PH KD DYDQ]DGR OD PDHVWUD SDUD DTXHOORV MXHJRV TXH SUHFLVDQ GHVSOD]DPLHQWRV \ GRPLQLR GH XQ LPSOHPHQWRSULQFLSDOPHQWHHOEDOyQVHUiXQPDWHULDOIDFLOLWDGRUGHODDXWRQRPtDGH 0DUtD 5HLWHURODLPSRUWDQFLDGHODPLUDGDSHULIpULFDSRUSDUWHGHODPDHVWUD\ODQHFHVLGDG GHODILJXUDGHOSURIHVRUGHDSR\RSDUD³KDFHUVRPEUD´\DVtDXPHQWDUODVHQVDFLyQ GHVHJXULGDGGH0DUtD 6(6,Ï11 '(2&78%5('( 6H REVHUYD FRPR HQ FDGD VHVLyQ TXH ORV DOXPQRV \ DOXPQDV HVWiQ GLVWULEXLGRV SRU HO HVSDFLR RUGHQDGDPHQWH FDGD XQR HVWi HQFLPD GH XQD VHxDO DPDULOOD GH SLH H[FHSWXDQGR0DUtDTXHHVWiWXPEDGDSRUTXHGLFHTXHHVWiFDQVDGD+HGHDQRWDUTXH KR\ODKHREVHUYDGRHQHOSDWLR\WDOFRPRKHUHJLVWUDGRVHKDSDVDGRXQRVPLQXWRV MXJDQGRDWRFDU\SDUDU (OSULPHUMXHJRTXHUHDOL]DQHVHOGH³ORVSDTXHWHV´ (OJUXSRGLVWULEXLGRSRUHOHVSDFLRFRUULHQGRDXQULWPRVXDYH&XDQGRODPDHVWUDGLJD ³SDTXHWHV GH´ \ DxDGH XQ Q~PHUR ORV MXJDGRUHV WLHQHQ TXH UHXQLUVH FRQ WDQWRV FRPSDxHURVFRPRQ~PHURLQGLFDGRSRUpVWD (Q OD RUJDQL]DFLyQ GH ORV JUXSRV SDUD UHXQLUVH HQ SDTXHWHV QR VH REVHUYD QLQJXQD GLVFULPLQDFLyQ KDFLD 0DUtD (V DFHSWDGD HQ FXDOTXLHU JUXSR TXH VH YD RUJDQL]DQGR DO D]DU 5 5 5 5 5 5 (OVLJXLHQWHMXHJRTXHSURSRQHODPDHVWUDHVHOGH³ODVOHWUDVHQHOVXHOR´ 6HRUJDQL]DQJUXSRVGH$ODFRQVLJQDGHODPDHVWUDWLHQHQTXHGLVHxDUHQWUHWRGRVORV FRPSRQHQWHVGHOJUXSRFRQORVFXHUSRV WXPEDGRVHQHOVXHORODOHWUDPD\~VFXODTXH LQGLTXH 5HVSHFWR D HVWD WDUHD 0DUtD QR SUHVHQWD QLQJXQD GLILFXOWDG $FHSWD VLQ RSRVLFLyQ ODV GHFLVLRQHVGHOOtGHUGHOJUXSR 3DUDILQDOL]DUFLHUUDODVHVLyQFRQHOMXHJRGH³ODSDODEUDFRRSHUDWLYD´ *UXSRVGH$LPDJHQGHOMXHJRDQWHULRUODPDHVWUDGLUiXQDSDODEUDGHFXDWUROHWUDV &DGDJUXSRUHSUHVHQWDUiXQDOHWUDFRQORVFXHUSRVWXPEDGRVHQHOVXHORSHURDSULRUL WHQGUiTXHSRQHUVHGHDFXHUGRFRQORVRWURVSDUDDFRUGDUODOHWUD\VXUHSUHVHQWDFLyQHQ HOHVSDFLR 'H HVWH MXHJRPHDWUDHODFRPSRVLFLyQGHOJUXSRGRQGHHVWi0DUtD&RLQFLGHQODVGRV QXHYDVDOXPQDVGHOFXUVR\HOFRPSDxHURUHSHWLGRUGHODxRSDVDGR6HOHVREVHUYDDOR ODUJR GH OD HYROXFLyQ GHO MXHJR XQD DFWLWXG SDVLYD QR GHFLGHQ QL DSRUWDQ QLQJXQD SURSXHVWD R HVWUDWHJLD DO UHVWR GH FRPSDxHURV QL LQFOXVR FXDQGR OD PDHVWUD GD OD FRQVLJQDTXHVHVLHQWHQ\TXHOOHJXHQDXQDFXHUGR$QWHHOFDRVJHQHUDOGHOPRPHQWR OHVSLGHTXHUHIOH[LRQHQHQWUHWRGRVRUGHQDGDPHQWHGHFLGLHQGRFRRSHUDWLYDPHQWHVREUH FyPRWLHQHQTXHRUJDQL]DUVH+HGHUHJLVWUDUODVJUDQGHVGLILFXOWDGHVTXHSUHVHQWDHVWD DFWLYLGDGSDUDTXHHOJUXSRVHDFDSD]GHRUJDQL]DUVHSDUDFRQVHJXLUHOFRPHWLGR(VXQ SHUIHFWR VRFLRJUDPD$SHVDUGHORVWUHV FXDUWRV GH KRUD GHVWLQDGRV SDUD HOORKDVLGR LPSRVLEOHFRQVHJXLUODUHDOL]DFLyQGHODSDODEUD/DVGLVFXVLRQHVHQWUHHOORV\HOODVVRQHO GHQRPLQDGRUFRP~QLQGHSHQGLHQWHPHQWHGHODVLQWHUYHQFLRQHVFRQVWDQWHVGHODPDHVWUD SDUDFRQVHJXLUXQDWRPDGHGHFLVLRQHVGHPRFUiWLFD (Q ORV WLHPSRV GH HVSHUD SDUD OD UHDOL]DFLyQ GH OD SDODEUD FRRSHUDWLYD D 0DUtD VH OH REVHUYDVLHPSUHDUURGLOODGD\DVHDHVWiWLFDRHQGHVSOD]DPLHQWRV(QHOFDVRSULPHUR HVIUHFXHQWHTXHMXHJXHFRQODVPXOHWDVUHDOL]DQGRGLIHUHQWHVPDQLSXODFLRQHV /D PDHVWUD ILQDOL]D OD VHVLyQ VROLFLWDQGR DO JUXSR FODVH TXH SDUD OD VHVLyQ VLJXLHQWH UHGDFWHQ ODV GLILFXOWDGHV TXH KDQ REVWDFXOL]DGR OD RUJDQL]DFLyQ GHO JUXSR SDUD OD UHDOL]DFLyQGHO~OWLPRMXHJR &RPHQWDULRVDODVHVLyQ 6H REVHUYD TXH DQWH ODV SURSXHVWDV FRRSHUDWLYDV 0DUtD QR SUHVHQWD GLILFXOWDGHV GDGR TXH WRGR HO JUXSR WLHQH TXH FRRSHUDU SDUD FRQVHJXLU FRPXQLWDULDPHQWH HO REMHWLYR 1R REVWDQWHVHUHJLVWUDWDO\FRPRPHKDDYDQ]DGRODPDHVWUDWXWRUDTXHWLHQHXQDDFWLWXG SDVLYDDQWHORVDSUHQGL]DMHV(QHVWDRFDVLyQQRKDWRPDGRQLQJXQDGHFLVLyQUHVSHFWRD OD UHDOL]DFLyQ GH ODV OHWUDV (OOD REHGHFH ODV FRQVLJQDV GH ORV OtGHUHV VLQ SUHVHQWDU RSRVLFLyQDOJXQD 5 5 5 5 5 5 6(6,Ï11 '(2&78%5('( ,QLFLD OD PDHVWUD OD VHVLyQ UHFRJLHQGR OD UHGDFFLyQ GH FDGD QLxR UD]RQDQGR ODV GLILFXOWDGHVRUJDQL]DWLYDVGHO~OWLPRMXHJRGHODVHVLyQDQWHULRU&XDQGRQRPEUDD0DUtD pVWD VH GHVSOD]D HQ URGLOODV SDUD DSUR[LPDUVH D OD PDHVWUD SDUHFH QR VRUSUHQGHU D QDGLH VX PDQHUD GH WUDVODGDUVH DQWH HO JUXSR /ODPD OD DWHQFLyQ OH HQWUHJD GH OD UHGDFFLyQGDGRTXHODVDFDGHXQ&'\HOWDPDxRGHOSDSHOHVHOPiVSHTXHxRGHWRGRV ORVHQWUHJDGRV7DQVyORKDHVFULWRFXDWUROtQHDV 3DUDFRPHQ]DUODVHVLyQSURSRQH³VDOWRVDODFXHUGD´ 3DUD HOOR ORV DOXPQRV HVWiQ GLVWULEXLGRV SRU HO HVSDFLR \ UHDOL]DQ LQGLYLGXDOPHQWH GLYHUVRVWLSRVGHVDOWRVVHJ~QODFRQVLJQDGHODPDHVWUD &RPR 0DUtD QR SXHGH KDFHUOR OH SURSRQH TXH GLEXMH FRQ OD FXHUGD VREUH HO VXHOR GLYHUVDVILJXUDVJHRPpWULFDV)LQDOL]DGDODWDUHDOHSODQWHDTXHODQFHODFXHUGDKDFLDHO WHFKR\TXHLQWHQWHFRJHUODDQWHVTXHFDLJDDOVXHOR$SHVDUGHOWUDEDMRLQGLYLGXDOL]DGR VHREVHUYDD0DUtDPRWLYDGDSRUODDFFLyQ 3RVWHULRUPHQWHLQGLFDTXH 5 5 3RU SDUHMDV \ FRJLGRV SRU OD FLQWXUD LQWHQWHQ VDOWDU FRRUGLQDGDPHQWH VLQ \ FRQ GHVSOD]DPLHQWR $0DUtDOHSURSRQHTXHGHVGHODSRVLFLyQGHVHQWDGDLQWHQWHKDFHUHO³KHOLFySWHUR´FRQOD FXHUGD(VGHFLUTXHGHYXHOWDVDODFXHUGDSRUHQFLPDGHODFDEH]DVLPXODQGRODKpOLFH GHXQKHOLFySWHUR7DPELpQVHOHREVHUYDPRWLYDGD /DWHUFHUDSURSXHVWDGHODMRUQDGDHVODGH $JUXSDUVHSRUSDUHMDV\GHVSOD]DUVHSRUHOHVSDFLRFRJLGRVSRUXQDFXHUGDORFDOL]DGD HQORVWRELOORVGHDPERV $0DUtDOHLQGLFDTXHGHMHODPXOHWDSUy[LPDDODFRPSDxHUDODLQWHULRU\TXHVHFRMDQ SRUODFLQWXUDSDUDDVtWHQHUXQDPD\RUHVWDELOLGDGHQHOWUDVODGR\DVHJXUDUSRUWDQWRVX HTXLOLEULR$DPEDVVHOHVREVHUYDPX\UHFHSWLYDV $FRQWLQXDFLyQSURSRQHODVRJDWLUD /D FODVH VH GLYLGH HQ GRV JUXSRV &DGD XQR HQIUHQWDGR DO RWUR PHGLDQWH XQD FXHUGD JUXHVDGHXQRVPHWURV/DGLVWDQFLDHQWUHJUXSRHVGHXQRVWUHVPHWURV&DGDJUXSR VHGLVSRQGUiHQILODLQGLDFRJLHQGRODFXHUGDFRQODPDQRPiVSUy[LPD$ODVHxDOWLHQHQ TXHLQWHQWDUGHVSOD]DUDORWURJUXSRKDFLDVXFDPSRFRQVLJXLHQGRTXHHOSULPHURGHOD ILODFRPRPtQLPRLQYDGDVXWHUUHQR 5 5 5 5 5 5 (QXQSULQFLSLR0DUtDVHVLW~DODVHJXQGDGHODILODGHVXJUXSR&RPROOHYDODVPXOHWDVOH GLILFXOWDHODJDUUH\SRUHOORODPDHVWUDLQGLFDTXHODVGHMH\VHFRMDDODFXHUGD(QHVH PRPHQWRVHREVHUYDTXH0DUtDFDHDOVXHORGDGDVXLQHVWDELOLGDG/DUHDFFLyQGHpVWD HVODGHOHYDQWDUVHFRQODPD\RUQDWXUDOLGDG\DUURGLOODUVH(PSLH]DHOMXHJR\ODPDHVWUD UHFXHUGD DO FRPSDxHUR SUy[LPR TXH QR VH ROYLGH GH FRJHUOD SRU OD FLQWXUD &RPR OD SUHVLRQDQ OD PDHVWUD UHDFFLRQD FRORFiQGROD OD ~OWLPD 'HVGH HVD SRVLFLyQ 0DUtD VH VLHQWHPiVOLEUH\PHOODPDODDWHQFLyQFyPRVHGLYLHUWH 3DUDILQDOL]DUVHMXHJDD³ODERPEDFRQWUHVEDORQHV´ (OJUXSRVHQWDGRHQFtUFXOR8QMXJDGRUHQHOFHQWUReVWHFXHQWDHQYR]DOWDGHD PLHQWUDV TXH VXV FRPSDxHURV VH YDQ SDVDQGR WUHV EDORQHV GH XQR D RWUR TXH HVWiQ UHSDUWLGRVSRUHOJUXSRVLJXLHQGRODWUD\HFWRULDGHOFtUFXOR$OOOHJDUDHOMXJDGRUGHO FHQWURJULWD³%RPED´\ORVFRPSDxHURVTXHWHQJDQHOEDOyQHQHVHPRPHQWRVRQORVTXH SDVDUiQDHVWDUHQHOFHQWUR\DVtVXFHVLYDPHQWHKDVWDTXHTXHGHWDQVyORXQMXJDGRU FRQ ORV WUHV EDORQHV &XDQGR HQ HO WHUUHQR GH MXHJR TXHGDQ SRFRV MXJDGRUHV HO TXH SRVHH HO EDOyQ VL OD GLVWDQFLD FRQ VX FRPSDxHUR PiV SUy[LPR HV JUDQGH WLHQH TXH DSUR[LPiUVHORHQFDUUHUDWHQLHQGRTXHUHJUHVDUDOOXJDUGHSDUWLGD /D DGDSWDFLyQ TXH SURSRQH OD PDHVWUD D 0DUtD FXDQGR OD GLVWDQFLD FRQ HO FRPSDxHUR PiVSUy[LPRHVJUDQGHHVTXHFXDQGRWLHQHHOEDOyQGHEHSDVDUORFRQXQODQ]DPLHQWR HQYH]GHGHVSOD]DUVHFRQpOSRUODVGLILFXOWDGHVTXHWLHQHSDUDLQFRUSRUDUVH\HOWLHPSR TXHWHQGUtDTXHGLVSRQHUDQWHHOULWPRWDQYLYRGHOMXHJR 0LHQWUDV OD PD\RUtD VH GXFKD ORV FXDWUR FRPSDxHURV \ FRPSDxHUDV TXH QR OR KDFHQ UHDOL]DQSRULQLFLDWLYDSURSLDODYHUWLFDOSXHQWH0DUtDVHORVTXHGDPLUDQGRKDVWDTXHPH OODPDSDUDHQVHxDUPHTXHHOODWDPELpQKDFHODYHUWLFDO/DDGDSWDFLyQTXHUHDOL]DHVOD GHVRVWHQHUVHVREUHORVEUD]RVLQWHQWDGRTXHHOFXHUSRHVWpKRUL]RQWDOUHVSHFWRDOVXHOR GHWDOIRUPDTXHORVSLHVQRWRTXHQDOVXHOR&RQVWDWRODJUDQIXHU]DGHEUD]RV $QWH HO UHFODPRGHVXKHUPDQDPD\RU 0DUtD HV OD SULPHUD HQ DEDQGRQDU OD VDOD SDUD GLULJLUVHHQDPEXODQFLDFRPRWRGRVORVPLpUFROHVDOFHQWURGHUHKDELOLWDFLyQ &RPHQWDULRVDODVHVLyQ 5HFRMR TXH OD PDHVWUD DSOLFD FRQ PXFKR VHQWLGR FRP~Q ODV DGDSWDFLRQHV SHUR FRPR FUtWLFD FRQVWUXFWLYD KH GH DQRWDU TXH HO WUDEDMR LQGLYLGXDOL]DGR QR UHVSRQGH D XQD SURJUDPDFLyQSUHYLDVHJ~QODVQHFHVLGDGHVHGXFDWLYDVGH0DUtD 62&,2*5$0$'(/$8/$ '(2&78%5('( 0DUtD KD OOHJDGR VLHWH PLQXWRV WDUGH &RPR HQ OD RFDVLyQ DQWHULRU TXH SDVDPRV HO VRFLRJUDPDGHODFODVHGH(GXFDFLyQ)tVLFDHVODPiVOHQWDGHOJUXSR6tODPHGLDKD FRQWHVWDGRHQXQRVPLQXWRV0DUtDKDSUHFLVDGR 5 5 5 5 5 5 5 &RPR VH KD TXHGDGR OD ~OWLPD OD WXWRUD SURSRQH DO UHVWR FRUUHJLU XQDV GLYLVLRQHV OODPiQGRPHODDWHQFLyQTXHLQLFLDODDFWLYLGDGVLQTXHKD\DILQDOL]DGR0DUtD 6(6,Ï11 '(2&78%5('( $O LQLFLDU OD VHVLyQ OD PDHVWUD H[SOLFD DO JUXSR TXH OHV YR\ D JUDEDU HQ YtGHR $SHQDV GLVWRUVLRQD HO FRPSRUWDPLHQWR GH ORV QLxRV \ QLxDV H[FHSWXDQGR HQ DOJXQD DFFLyQ SXQWXDOTXHVHDSUR[LPDQDODFiPDUDSDUDVDOXGDU %DMR HO ULWXDO LQLFLDO GH FDGD VHVLyQ VHQWDGRV RUGHQDGDPHQWH HQ HO VXHOR SURSRQH OD SULPHUDDFWLYLGDG 5 &RUUHUDOUHGHGRUGHOJLPQDVLR\FXDQGRGLJDXQQ~PHURGHODOORVDOXPQRVWLHQHQTXHHMHFXWDU XQDDFFLyQFRQFUHWDTXHSUHYLDPHQWHKDDVLJQDGRDFDGDQ~PHUR FRUUHUKDFLDGHODQWH HVWLUDUVHERFDDEDMR\OHYDQWDUVHUiSLGDPHQWH UHDOL]DUXQVDOWRYHUWLFDO VDOWRVODWHUDOHVKDFLDODGHUHFKD FRUUHUKDFLDDWUiV GDUVDOWRVFRQODSLHUQDL]TXLHUGD FDPELDUGHGLUHFFLyQ VDOWRVODWHUDOHVKDFLDODL]TXLHUGD GDUVDOWRVFRQODSLHUQDGHUHFKD UHDOL]DUXQJLURGH 0DUtD SDUWLFLSD DFWLYDPHQWH GH OD WDUHD \ HQ DTXHOODV DFFLRQHV TXH QR SXHGH UHDOL]DU SRUVHUODVFRQVLJQDVPX\UiSLGDVODVFRPSHQVDGHVSOD]iQGRVHKDFLDGHODQWH $FRQWLQXDFLyQSURSRQH 3RUSDUHMDVXQRGHODQWHGHORWURLQWHQWDUHPSXMDUODHVSDOGDGHOFRPSDxHURDGHODQWDGRFDPELiQGRVH SRVWHULRUPHQWHORVUROHV /DVLJXLHQWHWDUHDFRQVLVWHHQTXHXQMXJDGRUWLHQHTXHHVWDUWXPEDGRHQHOVXHORERFDDEDMR\HORWUR WLHQHTXHLQWHQWDUJLUDUOR\VLWXDUORERFDDUULED$LPDJHQGHORWURMXHJRVHFDPELDQORVUROHV &XDQGRLQGLFDODPDHVWUDTXHVHIRUPHQODVSDUHMDV0DUtDVHTXHGDVROD$QWHHOORHVOD PDHVWUDTXLHQVHEULQGDDVHUVXSDUHMD6HREVHUYDPRWLYDGDSRUODDFWLYLGDG &RPRSHQ~OWLPRMXHJRH[SOLFDHOGHDUUDQFDUFHEROODV *UXSRVGHFXDWUR7UHVVHQWDGRVHQHOVXHORFRJLGRVSRUODFLQWXUD\HOFXDUWRGHSLHIUHQWHDVXV FRPSDxHURV\FRJLHQGRSRUODPDQRDOSULPHURGHODILOD&XDQGRVHGDODVHxDOHOMXJDGRUGHSLHLQWHQWD DSOLFDQGRODIXHU]DTXHHOSULPHURVHVXHOWHGHVXFRPSDxHUR\DVtVXFHVLYDPHQWHKDVWDTXHTXHGHWDQ VyORXQMXJDGRUHQHOVXHOR 5 5 5 5 5 5 $OGHFLUODPDHVWUDTXHVHRUJDQLFHQHQJUXSRVGHFXDWUR0DUtDGHQXHYRVHTXHGDVLQ 5 JUXSRSRUORTXHVXJLHUHTXHORFRQIRUPHFRQXQJUXSRLQFRPSOHWRGHWUHVQLxRVeVWRV KDQUHDFFLRQDGRGHMDQGRD0DUtDDWUiV\EXVFDQGRDRWURVGRVMXJDGRUHVTXHHVWDEDQ HQRWURSXQWRGHODVDODFRQHOILQGHSURSRQHUOHVTXHIRUPHXQRGHHOORVSDUWHGHOJUXSR 0DUtD ORV YD VLJXLHQGR HQ WDO FRPHWLGR &XDQGR OD PDHVWUD VH GD FXHQWD UHFULPLQD DO JUXSR\OHVUHFXHUGDTXHHVHOODODSHUVRQDDVLJQDGD$SHVDUGHHOORXQDYH]TXHKD HPSH]DGRHOMXHJRQRVHREVHUYDUHFKD]RDOJXQR$0DUtDVHOHSHUFLEHPX\PRWLYDGD\ ULVXHxDQRVXSRQLpQGROHGLILFXOWDGDOJXQD 3DUDILQDOL]DUH[SOLFDHOMXHJRGHODSHORWDVHQWDGD 5 (OJUXSRHVWiGLVSHUVRSRUODVDOD6LHWHGHHOORVSRVHHQXQEDOyQHVSXPD&XDQGRGDODVHxDOpVWRV LQWHQWDQLPSDFWDUDVXVFRPSDxHURVVLFDHHOEDOyQDOVXHORVHFRQVLGHUD³PXHUWR´3DUDHOORVHVLHQWDQHQ HOVXHOR\OD~QLFDPDQHUDGH³VDOYDUVH´HVGHFLUYROYHUDVHUMXJDGRUGHSLHHVFRJLHQGRHOEDOyQGHOVXHOR SRUHOD]DU/RVTXHWLHQHQEDOyQQRSXHGHQGHVSOD]DUVHFRQpO /D PDHVWUD KD UHSDUWLGR HO EDOyQ D VLHWH MXJDGRUHV HQWUH HOORV VH HQFXHQWUD 0DUtD &XDQGR VH OR SDVD XQ FRPSDxHUR VH OR DUUHEDWD &RPR OD PDHVWUD QR OR KD YLVWR OD UHDFFLyQGH0DUtDHVODGHVHQWDUVHHQXQULQFyQHQHOVXHOR\SRQHUVHDOORUDU&XDQGR ODPDHVWUDVHGDFXHQWDOHSDVDRWUREDOyQ\RWURFRPSDxHURLQWHQWDGHQXHYRTXHGDUVH FRQpOSHURFRPRODPDHVWUDORREVHUYD0DUtDVHSXHGHKDFHUFRQHOEDOyQ\DVtLQLFLDU HOMXHJR ,QWHQWD ODQ]DU HO EDOyQ KDFLD VXV FRPSDxHURV \ HQ HO WHUFHU LQWHQWR FRQVLJXH ³PDWDU´ D XQR SHUR DO TXHGDUVH VLQ EDOyQ UiSLGDPHQWH KD SDVDGR D VHQWDUVH &RPR HVWi HQ XQ H[WUHPR GH OD VDOD MXQWR D XQD FROXPQD WLHQH JUDQGHV GLILFXOWDGHV SDUD KDFHUVH FRQ DOJ~QEDOyQDSHVDUTXHYDULRVOHKDQSDVDGRPX\SUy[LPRV $PHGLGDTXHHYROXFLRQDHOMXHJRPLHQWUDVTXHHOUHVWRGHOJUXSRHVWiPX\PRWLYDGRD 0DUtD VH OH REVHUYD WULVWH FDQVDGD GH OD VLWXDFLyQ GH HVSHUD 1R REVWDQWH WHQJR TXH DQRWDU TXH QR SUHVHQWD LQTXLHWXGHV SDUD LQWHQWDU DOFDQ]DU ORV EDORQHV SUy[LPRV D HOOD 1R HV MXJDGRUD GH SLH KDVWD TXH OD PDHVWUD VH SRQH FHUFD GH HOOD \ OH SDVD XQ EDOyQ SDUDTXHVHVDOYH$SDUWLUGHDKtLQWHQWDODQ]DUHOEDOyQYDULDVYHFHVSDUDLPSDFWDUDVXV FRPSDxHURV H LQFOXVR UHFXSHUD RWUR XQD YH] TXH KD ODQ]DGR HO VX\R 7HQJR TXH UHJLVWUDUTXHKDQVLGRYDULDVODVYHFHVTXHVXVFRPSDxHURVHVWiQSUy[LPRVDHOOD\OD KDQLJQRUDGRGDGRTXHDOWHQHUODFHUFDQRKDQLQWHQWDGR³PDWDUOD´ (QHOWLHPSRGHHVSHUDDODGXFKDODPDHVWUDSURSRQHTXHORVWUHVQLxRVTXHHVWiQHQOD 5 5 5 VDODMXQWRD0DUtDMXHJXHQD³PDUFDUJRODODSRUWHUtDGHORVFRQWUDULRV´ 6H GLVWULEX\HQ SRU ORV H[WUHPRV GHOLPLWDQGR FDGD XQR VX ]RQD GH SRUWHUtD FRQ XQRV FRQRVWHQLHQGRTXHLQWHQWDUODQ]DUHOEDOyQKDFLDXQRGHORVFRPSDxHURVFRQHOREMHWR GHLQWURGXFLUORHQODSRUWHUtDGHVXDGYHUVDULR &RPRHQRWUDVRFDVLRQHVDOHVWDUWRGRVVHQWDGRVHQHOVXHORQRVXSRQHGLILFXOWDGSDUD 0DUtD &RPHQWDULRVDODVHVLyQ &XDQGRVHRUJDQL]DQORVJUXSRVSRUGHFLVLyQGHORVDOXPQRVVHSHUFLEHTXH0DUtDHV 5 5 UHFKD]DGDIUHFXHQWHPHQWHSHURXQDYH]TXHVHLQLFLDODWDUHDQRVHREVHUYDQFRQIOLFWRV 6(6,Ï11 '(2&78%5('( 'H QXHYR UHJLVWUR OD VHVLyQ FRQ YLGHR (Q FRQWDGDV RFDVLRQHV OODPD OD DWHQFLyQ D DOJXQRVPLHPEURVGHOJUXSRTXHVHVLW~DQGHODQWHGHODFiPDUDVDOXGDQGR /DMRUQDGDGHKR\YHUVDVREUHODVDFWLYLGDGHVFRRSHUDWLYDV3RUHOORODSULPHUDWDUHDTXH SURSRQHHVODTXHVLJXH /RVQLxRV\QLxDVVHVLW~DQDOUHGHGRUGHXQSDUDFDtGDV7RGRVGHEHQFRJHUORFRQODVGRVPDQRV$OD FRQVLJQDGHODPDHVWUDWLHQHQTXH 5 5 VXELUOR\EDMDUOR GHVSOD]DUVHKDFLDODGHUHFKD\SRVWHULRUPHQWHKDFLDODL]TXLHUGDHO SDUDFDtGDVTXHGDDODDOWXUDGHODFLQWXUD VXELUOR \ DSUR[LPDUVH WRGR HO JUXSR SDUD FRQVHJXLU TXH HO SDUDFDtGDVTXHGHKLQFKDGRSRUHQFLPDGHVXVFDEH]DV tGHP TXH HO DQWHULRU SHUR HQ HVWD RFDVLyQ WLHQHQ TXH LQWHQWDU VHQWDUVHTXHGDQGRHOSDUDFDtGDVFRJLGRSRUODVPDQRV\SRUGHEDMR GHORVJO~WHRV GHQXHYRHOSDUDFDtGDVDODDOWXUDGHODFLQWXUDODPDHVWUDGHSRVLWD HQ HO LQWHULRU RQFH JORERV FRQ HO REMHWR TXH ORV PDQWHHQ VLQ TXH FDLJDQDOVXHOR /DSULPHUDOLPLWDFLyQTXHREVHUYRHQODSULPHUDWDUHDHVTXHDOVRVWHQHU0DUtDFRQORV 5 FRGRV ODV PXOHWDV WLHQH GLILFXOWDG SDUD DJDUUDU HO SDUDFDtGDV $QWH HOOR OD PDHVWUD VH VLW~DGHWUiVGHHOODFRJLHQGRWDPELpQHOSDUDFDtGDVSDUDIDFLOLWDUOHHOHTXLOLEULR (Q OD VHJXQGD DFWLYLGDG 0DUtD SUHVHQWD JUDQGHV GLILFXOWDGHV SDUD GHVSOD]DUVH FRQ HO 5 SDUDFDtGDV6XUHVSXHVWDHVODGHFRJHUOR FRQXQDPDQRDSHVDUGHODPXOHWDTXHOD VRVWLHQHSRUHOFRGR\FRQODRWUDVHDSR\DDODVHJXQGDPXOHWD3HURGDGDODYHORFLGDG GHO UHVWR GHO JUXSR RSWD SRU VROWDU HO SDUDFDtGDV \ VHJXLU HO GHVSOD]DPLHQWR GH VXV FRPSDxHURV DQGDQGR /DPDHVWUDUHFULPLQD DO JUXSR VX DOWD YHORFLGDG UHFRUGDQGR TXH WRGRV WLHQHQ TXH SDUWLFLSDU D SHVDU GH OD REVHUYDFLyQ \ GH OD FRQVHFXHQWH FRUUHFFLyQ 0DUtDQRSXHGHUHDOL]DUODWDUHDSRUODVGLILFXOWDGHVTXHHQWUDxDSDUDHOOD $VtPLVPROHUHVXOWDLPSRVLEOHUHDOL]DUHOWHUFHU\FXDUWRMXHJR0DUtDLQWHQWDLQLFLDUODV DFWLYLGDGHV SHUR FXDQGR WRGRV VH GHVSOD]DQ KDFLD HO LQWHULRU GHO SDUDFDtGDV HOOD VH TXHGD HQ HO SXQWR GH SDUWLGD REVHUYDQGR ODV DFFLRQHV GH VXV FRPSDxHURV \ FRPSDxHUDV (V HQ OD ~OWLPD WDUHD FXDQGR 0DUtD SDUWLFLSD PiV DFWLYDPHQWH 3DUD HOOR RSWD SRU DUURGLOODUVH \ GHVGH HVD SRVLFLyQ FRODERUD FRQ VXV FRPSDxHURV PDQWHDQGR HO SDUDFDtGDV6HOHREVHUYDFRQXQDH[SUHVLyQ ULVXHxD $QWH OD IDWLJD GHFLGH GHVFDQVDU VHQWiQGRVH HQ XQ ODWHUDO GHO JLPQDVLR REVHUYDQGR FRPR MXHJDQ VXV FRPSDxHURV /D PDHVWUDVHDFHUFDDHOOD\OHGDXQJORERVXJLULpQGROHTXHMXHJXHDGDUWRTXHVFRQODV PDQRVVLQTXHFDLJDDOVXHOR $FRQWLQXDFLyQODPDHVWUDLQGLFDDWRGRHOJUXSRTXH 5 5 5 3RUSDUHMDVWLHQHQTXHVRVWHQHUXQJORERSRUODHVSDOGDFRQHOREMHWLYRGHTXHQRFDLJDDOVXHOR PLHQWUDVGHGHVSOD]DQSRUHOHVSDFLR8QDYH]FRQVHJXLGRFRQWURODUHOGHVSOD]DPLHQWRLQWURGXFH P~VLFD $0DUtDOHUHVXOWDFRPSOLFDGRHQVLWXDFLyQHVWiWLFDVRVWHQHUHOJORERSRUODHVSDOGDSRU OR TXH GHFLGH DUURGLOODUVH 3RU WDQWR HO GHVSOD]DPLHQWR WDPELpQ HV PX\ GLILFXOWRVR FD\HQGRFRQVWDQWHPHQWHHOJORERDOVXHOR(VSRUHOORTXHODPDHVWUDVXJLHUHD0DUtD\ DVXFRPSDxHUDTXHVHVLW~HQXQDDOODGRGHODRWUD\TXHVRVWHQJDQHOJORERHQWUHORV EUD]RVLQWHULRUHV(VWDDGDSWDFLyQIDFLOLWDODDFFLyQD0DUtDSRUORTXHVHOHREVHUYDPiV PRWLYDGD 3RVWHULRUPHQWHODPDHVWUDVHxDOD 3RUSDUHMDVGHSLHSDVDUVHXQJORERFRPRVLMXJDUDQDOYROHLERO$FRQWLQXDFLyQGHVGHODSRVLFLyQGH VHQWDGRV 2EVHUYRTXH0DUtDDOQRSRGHUFRQWURODUHOJORERGHVGHODSRVLFLyQGHSLHRSWDSRUVHQWDUVHORFXDO HVDFHSWDGRSRUVXFRPSDxHUDUHDOL]DQGRORPLVPR3HUFLERTXHODDFWLYLGDGOHUHVXOWDPX\PRWLYDGRUD 6HFLHUUDODVHVLyQFRQHOMXHJRGH³ODDUDxD´ /RVMXJDGRUHVVHVLW~DQHQHOH[WUHPRGHODVDOD\RWURFRPSDxHUR³ODDUDxD´VHORFDOL]DHQHOFHQWUR GHODVDOD$ODVHxDOORVMXJDGRUHVWLHQHQTXHFUX]DUHOHVSDFLRGHMXHJRVFRQHOREMHWLYRTXHQROHVDWUDSH ³ODDUDxD´DQWHVGHOOHJDUDORWURH[WUHPRGHODVDOD$PHGLGDTXH³ODDUDxD´YDDWUDSDQGRORVVLW~DHQOD PLWDGGHOHVSDFLRORVFRQYLHUWHHQHVWDWXDVSDUDGLILFXOWDUHOGHVSOD]DPLHQWRGHORVMXJDGRUHVGDGRTXHVL WRFDQDXQDHVWDWXDVHFRQVLGHUDQDWUDSDGRV 5 5 5 5 &RPRHQRFDVLRQHVDQWHULRUHV0DUtDVHTXHGDGHODV~OWLPDVSDUDVHUDWUDSDGDDSHVDU 5 TXH HQ YDULDV RFDVLRQHV ³OD DUDxD´ OD WLHQH SUy[LPD SHUR pVWD GHFLGH QR DWUDSDUOD H LQFOXVRHQXQDGHHOODVVLPXODQRSRGHUDWUDSDUOD $O ILQDOL]DU OD VHVLyQ SUHJXQWR D 0DUtD FyPR VH OR KD SDVDGR \ PH UHVSRQGH TXH PX\ ELHQSRUTXHHUDQDFWLYLGDGHVQXHYDV &RPHQWDULRVDODVHVLyQ 2EVHUYR XQD JUDQ GLILFXOWDG SDUD 0DUtD FRPSDUWLU MXHJRV FRQ VXV FRPSDxHURV GRQGH WHQJDQ TXH DSUHKHQGHU DOJ~Q PDWHULDO FRPR HO SDUDFDtGDV \ D OD YH] UHDOL]DU DOJ~Q GHVSOD]DPLHQWR 'DGDV VXV OLPLWDFLRQHV HOOD QR SXHGH VHJXLU HO ULWPR GH VXV FRPSDxHURV 5 '(2&78%5('( 6HLQLFLDODVHVLyQFRQHOMXHJR³ODVHVTXLQDVSRUSDUHMDV´ /DV HVTXLQDV VRQ ODV RFKR FROXPQDV GHO JLPQDVLR (Q FDGD XQD GH HOODV KD\ GRV SDUWLFLSDQWHVWRFDQGRODFROXPQDFRQODPDQRGHUHFKD6HORFDOL]DQWUHVFRPSDxHURVHQ HOFHQWURGHODVDOD$ODVHxDOWRGRVGHEHQGHFDPELDUGHFROXPQDGHWDOIRUPDTXHORV GHOFHQWURGHEHQDOFDQ]DUXQDOLEUH(OTXHVHTXHGDVLQFROXPQDSDVDDOFHQWUR 0DUtDHVXQDGHODVMXJDGRUDVGHOFHQWURFRPRWLHQHGLILFXOWDGSDUDWRFDUXQDFROXPQD OLEUHODPDHVWUDOHVXJLHUHTXHVHDFHUTXHDHOODVGHWDOIRUPDTXHODGLVWDQFLDHVPHQRU UHVSHFWRDVXVRWURVFRPSDxHURVTXHWDPELpQHVWiQHQHOFHQWUR8QDYH]TXHFRQVLJXH HOREMHWLYRFXDQGRVHWUDVODGDGHFROXPQDDFROXPQDGHFLGHSDUWLUGHVGHODPLWDGGHO UHFRUULGR1LQJ~QFRPSDxHURVHKDTXHMDGRGHODYHQWDMD6HOHREVHUYDPX\PRWLYDGD SRUODDFWLYLGDG 3URVLJXHODVHVLyQFRQHOMXHJR³GHORVFLHQSLHV´ 6H RUJDQL]DQ SRU JUXSRV GH FXDWUR XQR GHWUiV GH RWUR VHQWDGRV HQ HO VXHOR FRQ ODV SLHUQDVVHSDUDGDV\FRJLGRVSRUODFLQWXUD$ODVHxDOWRGRVORVQLxRV\QLxDVWLHQHQTXH JLUDU OHQWDPHQWH KDFLD OD L]TXLHUGD \ TXHGDU FRQ ODV PDQRV DSR\DGDV HQ HO VXHOR HO FXHUSRSDUDOHORDOVXHOR\ODVSLHUQDVSRUHQFLPDGHOFRPSDxHURTXHWLHQHDGHODQWH7DQ VyORHO~OWLPRQLxRRQLxDDSR\DPDQRV\SLHVHQHOVXHOR &RPRHQVHVLRQHVDQWHULRUHV0DUtDQRHVHVFRJLGDHQQLQJ~QJUXSR(VODPDHVWUDOD TXHODLQFRUSRUDHQXQRGHHOORVVLQSHUFLELUVHUHFKD]RDOJXQR$ORUJDQL]DUVHORVJUXSRV GH FXDWUR \ DQWH ODV GLILFXOWDGHV SDUD FRQVHJXLU HO REMHWLYR OD PDHVWUD SURSRQH TXH VH SRQJDQSRUSDUHMDVSDUDUHGXFLUODGLILFXOWDG'HQXHYR0DUtDVHTXHGDVLQFRPSDxHUD KDVWDTXHODPDHVWUDKDLQWHUFHGLGRRUJDQL]DQGRXQJUXSRGHWUHV0LHQWUDVTXHLQWHQWDQ UHDOL]DU OD KDELOLGDG VH REVHUYD D XQD 0DUtD PX\ ULVXHxD \ DFWLYD DFHSWDGD SRU VXV FRPSDxHUDV\UHDOL]DQGRODDFWLYLGDGVLQGLILFXOWDG 3DUDILQDOL]DUODVHVLyQH[SOLFDHOMXHJRGHOFRFRGULORTXHHVHOPLVPRTXHHOGHODDUDxD GHODVHVLyQDQWHULRUSHURFRQODVLJXLHQWHYDULDQWH /RV MXJDGRUHV VH VLW~DQ HQ HO H[WUHPR GH OD VDOD \ RWUR FRPSDxHUR ³HO FRFRGULOR´ VH 6(6,Ï11 5 5 5 5 5 5 ORFDOL]DHQHOFHQWURGHODVDOD$ODVHxDOORVMXJDGRUHVWLHQHQTXHFUX]DUHOHVSDFLRGH MXHJRVFRQHOREMHWLYRTXHQROHVDWUDSH³HOFRFRGULOR´DQWHVGHOOHJDUDORWURH[WUHPRGHOD VDOD$PHGLGDTXHHO³FRFRGULOR´YDWRFDQGRDORVSDUWLFLSDQWHVpVWRVVHFRQYLHUWHQHQ QXHYRVFRFRGULORVKDVWDTXHTXHGDXQMXJDGRUVLQVHUDWUDSDGR $LPDJHQTXHHQODVHVLyQDQWHULRUDSHVDUGHTXH0DUtDSDVDSUy[LPDDORVFRFRGULORV pVWRV OD LJQRUDQ SDUD DWUDSDUOD H[FHSWXDQGR XQR GH HOORV TXH FXDQGR KD LQWHQWDGR WRFDUODKDVDOLGRRWURFRFRGULORKDLPSHGLUORFRJLpQGRORSRUODFLQWXUD(QRWUDVRFDVLRQHV VHREVHUYDFRPRXQRGHHOORVKDFHYHUTXHWLHQHGLILFXOWDGSDUDDWUDSDUODHQOHQWHFLHQGR ODPDUFKD+DVLGRGHODVFXDWUR~OWLPDVHQVHUWRFDGD (Q OD VHJXQGD UHSHWLFLyQ OD PDHVWUD UHFXHUGD D ORV FRFRGULORV TXH VL WLHQHQ D 0DUtD FHUFDODWLHQHQTXHWRFDUFRPRDRWURFRPSDxHUR\GHHVWDIRUPDODKDQDWUDSDGRUiSLGR /DUHDFFLyQGH0DUtDDQWHODGLILFXOWDGGHWRFDUDVXVFRPSDxHURVHVODGHDUURGLOODUVH HQHOVXHORSHURDQWHODUHFULPLQDFLyQGHODPDHVWUDVHKDSXHVWRGHSLHHYLGHQFLiQGRVH VXVOLPLWDFLRQHV-XVWDPHQWHHQHVHPRPHQWRKDILQDOL]DGRODVHVLyQSRUIDOWDGHWLHPSR &RPHQWDULRVDODVHVLyQ 0DUtD VDEH FRPSHQVDU HQ DOJXQDV RFDVLRQHV ODV OLPLWDFLRQHV HQ VLWXDFLRQHV FRPSHWLWLYDV&RPRKHUHJLVWUDGRHQVHVLRQHVDQWHULRUHVHVQHFHVDULRUHFRUGDUDOJUXSR ODQHFHVLGDGGHFRPSHQVDUODVOLPLWDFLRQHVWUDEDMDQGRGHHVHPRGRORVGHUHFKRV\ODV REOLJDFLRQHVGHWDOIRUPDTXHQRODLJQRUHQHQVLWXDFLRQHVGHDWUDSH 6HWLHQHTXHWHQHUHQFXHQWDWRGRVORVUROHVGHOMXHJRSDUDTXH0DUtDSXHGDSDUWLFLSDUGH XQDPDQHUDPiVHTXLWDWLYD 6(6,211 '(2&78%5('( /DVHVLyQGHOGtDGHKR\VHLPSDUWHHQHOJLPQDVLRGHOFHQWURSVLFRSHGDJyJLFRDXQRV FLHQWR FLQFXHQWDPHWURVGHODHVFXHOD $QWHV GH LQLFLDU OD PDUFKD OD PDHVWUD H[SOLFD HO FRQWHQLGRGHODVHVLyQ (OJUXSRVHGHVSOD]DKDFLDHOFHQWUR\VHREVHUYDTXH0DUtDVHTXHGDODXOWLPDGHODILOD \ D PHGLGD TXH DYDQ]D HO WUDVODGR OD GLVWDQFLD FRQ HO JUXSR HV PD\RU 2SWR SRU DFRPSDxDUOH /OHJDGRVDOJLPQDVLRHOJUXSR\DHVWiVHQWDGRHQORVEDQFRVVXHFRV6HGLVWLQJXHQGRV HVSDFLRV HO GH ORV QLxRV \ HO GH ODV QLxDV &RPR 0DUtD QR WLHQH VLWLR HQWUH ODV QLxDV GHFLGHVHQWDUVHDGLVWDQFLDHQHOEDQFRPiVSUy[LPRDODSXHUWD$PHGLGDTXHH[SOLFD ODDFWLYLGDGODPDHVWUD0DUtDVHDSUR[LPDDOJUXSRGHODVQLxDV\VHVLHQWDHQHOVXHOR /D SULPHUD WDUHD TXH SURSRQH HV OD GH UHDOL]DU XQ FDOHQWDPLHQWR OLEUH LQWHQWDQGR 5 5 5 5 5 5 5 5 PRYLOL]DUODVGLIHUHQWHVSDUWHVFRUSRUDOHV0LHQWUDVTXHHOUHVWRGHOJUXSRYDUHDOL]DQGR GLIHUHQWHVPRYLOL]DFLRQHV0DUtDHVWiVHQWDGDHQHOVXHORREVHUYDQGRDVXVFRPSDxHURV WDQ VyOR HV HQ HO LQLFLR GH OD DFWLYLGDG FXDQGR PRYLOL]D OD ]RQD GH OD FDEH]D \ GH ORV KRPEURV 3RVWHULRUPHQWHODPDHVWUDRUJDQL]DXQFLUFXLWR 5 /DSULPHUDWDUHDTXHWLHQHQTXHUHDOL]DUHVVDOWDUDOSRWURFRQODVSLHUQDVDELHUWDVDFRQWLQXDFLyQXQD YROWHUHWDOHVLJXHFDUUHUDSRUHOEDQFRVXHFRSDUDILQDOL]DUHQODVHVSDOGHUDVLQWHQWDQGRVXELUKDVWDORPiV DOWR\EDMDU /DVYDULDQWHVTXHSURSRQHHQODVVLJXLHQWHVUHSHWLFLRQHVVRQ VDOWDULQWHULRUGHOSRWURDSR\RGHPDQRV\SLHUQDVVHPLIOH[LRQDGDV YROWHUHWDKDFLDDWUiV GHVSOD]DUVH HQ FXDGUXSHGLD VREUH HO EDQFR VXHFR VLQ DSR\DU ODV PDQRV\ORVSLHVDOVXHOR FROJDGRVHQODHVSDOGHUD LQWHQWDU VXELUODVSLHUQDVH[WHQGLGDVDOD DOWXUDGHODFDGHUD /DDGDSWDFLyQSDUD0DUtDHVODTXHVLJXH 6LQ ODV PXOHWDV VH GHVSOD]D DSR\DQGR ODV URGLOODV HQ HO VXHOR KDVWD HO SRWUR &RQ OD D\XGDGHODPDHVWUDVXEHDpO\GHVFLHQGH$FRQWLQXDFLyQVHGHVSOD]DDODFROFKRQHWD\ UHDOL]D ODV YROWHUHWDV D LPDJHQ GH VXV FRPSDxHURV \ SRVWHULRUPHQWH DVFLHQGH D OD HVSDOGHUD LQWHQWDQGR HOHYDU ODV SLHUQDV VHJ~Q VXV SRVLELOLGDGHV 3DUD GHVSOD]DUVH DXWyQRPDPHQWHKDFLDODILODGHHVSHUDXQDFRPSDxHUDSRUFRQVLJQDGHODPDHVWUDOH DSUR[LPDODVPXOHWDV 0DUtDSDUWLFLSDFRQPXFKRLQWHUpV\VHOHSHUFLEHPRWLYDGDSRUODVWDUHDV $O UHJUHVDU DO FHQWUR HVFRODU OD PDHVWUD VXJLHUH DO JUXSR TXH QR VH GXFKH \ TXH VH QXPHUHQVHJ~QHOQ~PHURGHSDUWLFLSDQWHV (OMXHJRFRQVLVWHHQJROSHDUXQJORERKDFLDDUULEDVLQTXHFDLJDDOVXHORDPHGLGDTXH VH QRPEUDQ FRUUHODWLYDPHQWH ORV GLIHUHQWHV Q~PHURV (O MXJDGRU TXH OH FDH HO JORER DO VXHORTXHGDHOLPLQDGR 0DUtD VHDUURGLOODHQHOVXHOR(QXQSULQFLSLRORVQLxRV\QLxDVSDUWLFLSDQWHVRSWDQSRU JROSHDU HO JORER KDFLD DUULED \ GH IRUPD YHUWLFDO (Q HO PRPHQWR TXH OD HOLPLQDQ UHVSRQGHQFRQODQ]DPLHQWRVKDFLDDUULEDSHURKDFLDGHODQWHGHWDOIRUPDTXHLPSOLFDXQ PD\RUGHVSOD]DPLHQWRSDUDHOMXJDGRUTXHGHEHJROSHDUGHQXHYRHOJORER8QDYH]TXH VHLQWURGXFHGHQXHYR0DUtDVHSHUFLEHTXHORVGHVSOD]DPLHQWRVGHOJORERVRQPHQRUHV IDFLOLWDQGRGHHVWDPDQHUDODSDUWLFLSDFLyQGH0DUtD &RPHQWDULRVDODVHVLyQ 1RVHSHUFLEHJUDQGHVGLILFXOWDGHVSDUD0DUtDHQDFWLYLGDGHVGHFDUiFWHULQGLYLGXDOL]DGR /DPDHVWUDDGDSWDGDODVDFWLYLGDGHVSDUDTXHSXHGDUHDOL]DUODWRWDOLGDGGHHOODVWDO\ FRPRUHDOL]DHOUHVWRGHOJUXSR 5 5 5 5 5 &XDQGR OH SUHJXQWR D OD PDHVWUD VREUH OD GLQiPLFD GH ORV GHVSOD]DPLHQWRV KDFLD HO 5 FHQWURSHGDJyJLFRPHGLFHTXHQRUPDOPHQWHDVLJQDDGRVRWUHVFRPSDxHUDVSDUDTXH DFRPSDxHQD0DUtD(OKHFKRGHTXHKR\QRORKDKHFKRHVSRUTXHHVWDEDSUy[LPDD HOOD 6(6,Ï11 '(2&78%5('( /DVHVLyQSLYRWDDOUHGHGRUGHGRVWDUHDV/DSULPHUDHVODGHQRPLQDGDPLQLROLPSLDGD /D FODVH VHRUJDQL]DHQJUXSRGHFXDWUR D FLQFR SDUWLFLSDQWHV &DGD JUXSR HVFRJH XQ GHSRUWHROtPSLFRHOFXDOUHSUHVHQWDFXDQGRODPDHVWUDORLQGLFD(OJUXSRTXHORDFLHUWD SDVDDUHSUHVHQWDUVXGHSRUWH\DVtVXFHVLYDPHQWH (Q HVWD DFWLYLGDG 0DUtD QR OH KD VXSXHVWR QLQJXQD GLILFXOWDG (Q HO PRPHQWR GH UHSUHVHQWDUVXGHSRUWHFLFOLVPRHOODORKDKHFKRGHVGHODSRVLFLyQGHDUURGLOODGD6HOH REVHUYD ULVXHxD D OR ODUJR GH OD UHSUHVHQWDFLyQ VLQ UHFKD]R DOJXQR SRU SDUWH GH ORV FRPSDxHURV 8Q GHWDOOH D UHJLVWUDU HV FXDQGR HO JUXSR TXH UHSUHVHQWD XQD FDUUHUD GH FRFKHV GH IyUPXODFRJHFRQQDWXUDOLGDGODVPXOHWDVGH0DUtDSDUDVLPXODUHOWURIHR (OVHJXQGRMXHJRHV³ODSHORWDHQYHQHQDGD´ /D FODVH VH GLYLGH HQ GRV HTXLSRV HQ FDPSRV FRQWUDULRV 6H LQLFLD HO MXHJR LQWHQWDQGR ODQ]DUHOEDOyQKDFLDORVDGYHUVDULRVLQWHQWDQGRTXHLPSDFWHFRQXQDSDUWHFRUSRUDO6L XQMXJDGRUHVWRFDGRWLHQHTXHSDVDUDOHTXLSRFRQWUDULR)LQDOL]DHOMXHJRFXDQGRWRGRV ORVSDUWLFLSDQWHVVHDJOXWLQDQHQHOPLVPRFDPSR /D UHDFFLyQ GH 0DUtD HV OD GH FRPHQWDU D OD PDHVWUD TXH OD WRFDUiQ HQVHJXLGD eVWD FRQWHVWDTXHDOHVWDUDUURGLOODGDVHHVFRQGDGHWUiVGHVXVFRPSDxHURV6HREVHUYDTXH VHWUDVODGDSRUHOLQWHULRUGHOJUXSRKDVWDTXHUHFODPDHOEDOyQSDUDODQ]DUVLWXiQGRVH GHODQWHGHOJUXSR(QYH]GHGLULJLUVHDORVFRPSDxHURVORUHFODPDDODPDHVWUDODFXDO UHFXHUGD TXH WRGRV WLHQHQ TXH SDUWLFLSDU 7UDV FRQVHJXLU HO EDOyQ \ ODQ]DUOR DO FDPSR FRQWUDULR VH REVHUYD D XQD 0DUtD GHVDILDQWH FRQ VXV DGYHUVDULRV SHUR FXULRVDPHQWH pVWRVDSHVDUGHODSUR[LPLGDGQROHODQ]DQHOEDOyQSDUDLPSDFWDUOD &XDQGRHOJUXSRVHGXFKDSHUPDQHFHHQHOJLPQDVLRFRPRHQRWUDVRFDVLRQHVMXJDQGR FRQXQFRPSDxHURGHVGHODSRVLFLyQGHVHQWDGRVHQHOVXHORDSDUDUHOEDOyQTXHQR HQWUHHQOD]RQDSRVWHULRUGHQXHVWURWHUUHQRFRPRVtGHSRUWHUtDVGHI~WEROVHWUDWDVH &RPRHVXQDDFWLYLGDGVLQGLILFXOWDGSDUD0DUtDVHOHREVHUYDPX\SDUWLFLSDWLYD 5 5 5 5 5 &RPHQWDULRVDODVHVLyQ 6H FRQVWDWD TXH HQ ODV WDUHDV GH FRPSRQHQWH H[SUHVLYR \ FRODERUDWLYR VH IDFLOLWD OD SDUWLFLSDFLyQDFWLYDGH0DUtD '(2&78%5('( 6(6,Ï11 'HHVWDMRUQDGDWHQJRTXHVXEUD\DUTXHHVODSULPHUDVHVLyQHQTXH0DUtDVHGHVSOD]D HQVLOODGHUXHGDVTXHODPDHVWUDODKDXWLOL]DGRSDUDIDFLOLWDUODSDUWLFLSDFLyQGHpVWDHQ ODV SURSXHVWDV GH FDUiFWHU PiV GHSRUWLYDV /D VLOOD OD KDQ WUDtGR ORV SDGUHV SDUD TXH IXHVHGHH[FXUVLyQHOGtDVLJXLHQWH 'RVQLxRVKDQWUDVODGDGRODVLOODKDVWDHOSDWLR0DUtDVHVLHQWDDQWHVXVFRPSDxHURV\ pVWRVORDFHSWDQFRQODPD\RUQDWXUDOLGDGVLQSHUFLELUH[WUDxH]DHQHOJUXSR $FRQWLQXDFLyQODPDHVWUDGLYLGHHOJUXSRHQGRVXQRVHFHQWUDHQHOKRFNH\\HORWURHO EiGPLQWRQ$ODPLWDGGHODVHVLyQFDPELDQGHGHSRUWH (OREMHWLYRTXHSHUVLJXHHVGHFDUiFWHULQWURGXFWRULRLQWHQWDQGRTXHORVQLxRV\QLxDVVH IDPLOLDULFHQFRQORVLPSOHPHQWRV (QHOJUXSRGHKRFNH\ 'LVWULEX\HXQVWLFN\XQDSDVWLOODSRUQLxRGHWDOIRUPDTXHOLEUHPHQWHSRUHOHVSDFLRWLHQHQTXH H[SHULPHQWDUWRGDVODVSRVLELOLGDGHVGHPDQLSXODFLyQGHOVWLFNSUREDQGRGLIHUHQWHVIRUPDVGHDJDUUDUOR GLYHUVDVPDQHUDVGHFRQGXFLUODSDVWLOOD\GLIHUHQWHVIRUPDVGHODQ]DU 3RVWHULRUPHQWHRUJDQL]DGRVJUXSRVHQILODLQGLDGHODQWHGHXQDSRUWHUtD7LHQHQTXHFRQGXFLUOD SDVWLOODFRQHOVWLFNHLQWURGXFLUODHQODSRUWHUtDËGHPGHVGHXQDGLDJRQDO )LQDOL]DSURSRQLHQGRTXHVHSRQJDQSRUSDUHMDV\UHDOLFHQODQ]DPLHQWRVGHODSDVWLOODKDFLDVX FRPSDxHURTXHHVWiHQIUHQWHDXQRVFLQFRPHWURV 3DUD0DUtDODGLILFXOWDGHVGREOH8QDSRUTXHWLHQHTXHGRPLQDUODVLOODGHUXHGDV\RWUD SRUTXH WLHQH TXH FRQWURODU HO VWLFN $ SHVDU GH ODV GLILFXOWDGHV SURJUHVLYDPHQWH YD FRQWURODQGRPHMRUODVLWXDFLyQ &XDQGR WLHQH TXH GHVSOD]DUVH KDFLD OD SRUWHUtD VH REVHUYD XQD JUDQ OHQWLWXG GH WDO IRUPDTXHHQOHQWHFHHOQ~PHURGHUHSHWLFLRQHVGHVXVFRPSDxHURV$SHVDUGHHOORQR VHHVFXFKDQLQJ~QFRPHQWDULRQHJDWLYRSRUSDUWHGHpVWRV&XDQGRODPDHVWUDSURSRQH ODYDULDQWHHQGLDJRQDOVXVFRPSDxHURVGHILODRSWDQSRUUHDOL]DUVXDFFLyQFXDQGR0DUtD VHKDOODHQODPLWDGGHOUHFRUULGR 5 5 5 5 5 5HVSHFWR D OD ~OWLPD DFWLYLGDG VH REVHUYD TXH 0DUtD WLHQH PXFKDV GLILFXOWDGHV SDUD UHFHSFLRQDUODSDVWLOOD\ODQ]DUODGHQXHYRDVXFRPSDxHUD(VPXFKRPiVOHQWDTXHHO UHVWR/ODPDODDWHQFLyQODDFWLWXGGHVXFRPSDxHUDGLVWDQWHVLQSURYRFDULQWHUUHODFLyQ FRQ0DUtDTXHDFW~DGHOPLVPRPRGR $VtPLVPRFRQHOJUXSRGHEiGPLQWRQODPDHVWUDSURSRQHDFWLYLGDGHVGHLQWURGXFFLyQDO PDQHMRGHODUDTXHWD\HOYRODQWH &DGDQLxRFRQXQDUDTXHWD\XQYRODQWH7LHQHQTXHJROSHDUORYHUWLFDOPHQWHKDFLDDUULED \UHFHSFLRQDUORFRQODUDTXHWD ([SHULPHQWDUGLIHUHQWHVWLSRVGHFRJHUODUDTXHWD\GHJROSHDUHOYRODQWH 3RUSDUHMDVVHQWDGRVHQHOVXHORFRQWDUHOPi[LPRQ~PHURGHSDVHVGHYRODQWHVLQTXH FDLJDDOVXHOR 6H REVHUYD TXH HQ HVWDV DFWLYLGDGHV 0DUtD SUHVHQWD PD\RUHV GLILFXOWDGHV GDGR OD FRPSOHMLGDG GH FRQWURODU OD UDTXHWD \ HO YRODQWH 6H REVHUYD D XQD 0DUtD GHVPRWLYDGD FXDQGRQRFRQWURODODVLWXDFLyQTXHMiQGRVHUHLWHUDGDPHQWH1RREVWDQWHFXDQGRVHKD VHQWDGR HQ HO VXHOR \ KD FRPSDUWLGR ORV SDVHV FRQ XQ FRPSDxHUR VH OH SHUFLEH PX\ PRWLYDGD GDGR TXH HQ PiV GH XQD RFDVLyQ UHFLEH \ JROSHD HIHFWLYDPHQWH HO YRODQWH 7HQJRTXHREVHUYDUTXHVXFRPSDxHURGHMXHJRVHVPX\GLQiPLFRSHUPLWLHQGRD0DUtD VXV DFFLRQHV GDGR TXH VX UHDFFLyQ HV OD GH DSUR[LPDUVH D 0DUtD SDUD IDFLOLWDUOH ORV SDVHV$GLIHUHQFLDGHODFRPSDxHUDGHKRFNH\pVWHKDGLQDPL]DGRHOMXHJRFRQWDJLDQGR D0DUtD &RPHQWDULRVDODVHVLyQ $ SHVDU GHODGLILFXOWDGTXHKDHQWUDxDGRSDUD0DUtDPHKDVRUSUHQGLGRVXUHVSXHVWD FXDQGROHKHSUHJXQWDGRTXHHVORTXHPHQRVOHKDEtDJXVWDGRGHODVHVLyQGHKR\6X UHVSXHVWDKDVLGR³TXHWRGROHKDEtDJXVWDGR´ +DEODQGR FRQ XQD FRPSDxHUD GH FODVH PH KD GLFKR TXH OH KDEtD VRUSUHQGLGR JUDWDPHQWH YHU SDUWLFLSDU D 0DUtD HQ OD VLOOD GH UXHGDV \ FyPR SRGtD MXJDU D HVRV GRV GHSRUWHV 6(6,Ï11 '(2&78%5('( 1R VH UHDOL]y OD VHVLyQ GH (GXFDFLyQ )tVLFD GDGR TXH HO FHQWUR HVFRODU VH DFRJLy D OD KXHOJDHQFRQWUDGHOD/H\GH&DOLGDGGH(QVHxDQ]D 5 5 5 5 5 5 6(6,Ï11 '(2&78%5('( $ SDUWLU GH HVWD VHVLyQ FRODERUR FRQ OD PDHVWUD HQ ODV DGDSWDFLRQHV GH ODV WDUHDV \ DVXPRHOUROGHSURIHVRUDGHDSR\R (Q HO JLPQDVLR GHVSXpV GH SDVDU OD OLVWD OD PDHVWUD GLVWULEX\H DO JUXSR HQ GRV 6H LPSDUWHODVHVLyQHQORVSDWLRVH[WHULRUHV(OFLQFXHQWDSRUFLHQWRVHGHVSOD]DDOD]RQD GHOKRFNH\\HOUHVWDQWHDODGHOEiGPLQWRQ$FRUGDPRVTXH\RDVXPDpVWD~OWLPD (OGLVHxRGHODVDFWLYLGDGHVHVHOTXHVLJXH (QOD]RQDGHOKRFNH\ ,QGLYLGXDOPHQWH FRQ XQ VWLFN \ XQD SDVWLOOD UHDOL]DU GLIHUHQWHV FRQGXFFLRQHV 3RUSDUHMDVXQRHQIUHQWHGHRWURSDVDUVHODSDVWLOODËGHPHQ PRYLPLHQWR 3DUWLGRGHKRFNH\IOH[LELOL]DQGRODQRUPDWLYD (QHOHVSDFLRGHOEiGPLQWRQ 3RUSDUHMDVVHSDUDGDVSRUODUHGUHDOL]DUSDVHVGHYRODQWHFRQ HOREMHWRTXHQRFDLJDHQHOVXHOR /LPSLDUHOFDPSR 6HUHSDUWHQFXDWURYRODQWHVSRUFDPSR/RVQLxRVGLVWULEXLGRVOLEUHPHQWHSRUFDGD]RQD GH MXHJRLQWHQWDQGRFXEULUHOPi[LPR GH HVSDFLR 7LHQHQ TXHSDVDUHOYRODQWHDORWUR FDPSRGHWDOIRUPDTXHLQWHQWDQPDQWHQHUHOVX\RORPiVOLPSLRGHYRODQWHV&XDQGRVH GDODVHxDOGHSDUDUHOMXHJRJDQDHOHTXLSRTXHPHQRVQ~PHURGHYRODQWHVWLHQHHQVX ]RQD 3DUWLGRGHEiGPLQWRQHQIRUPDGHYROHLERO (QFDGDFDPSRKD\VHLVMXJDGRUHVWUHVGHODQWH\RWURVWUHVRFXSDQOD]RQDGHGHWUiV$ LPDJHQGHOYROHLEROWLHQHQTXHLQWHQWDUTXHHOYRODQWHFDLJDDOFDPSRFRQWUDULRVLQTXH VHD UHFHSFLRQDGR SRU ORV DGYHUVDULRV /RV VDTXHV GH YRODQWH \ ODV URWDFLRQHV GH ORV MXJDGRUHVVHUHDOL]DQGHODPLVPDIRUPDTXHHQHOYROHLEROSHUPLWLpQGRVHLQFOXVRTXH SXHGDQUHDOL]DUWUHVSDVHVGHYRODQWHHQWUHWUHVMXJDGRUHVGHXQPLVPRHTXLSRDQWHV GHSDVDUORDOFDPSRFRQWUDULR 'HHVWDVHVLyQFRLQFLGRFRQODPDHVWUDHQTXH0DUtDSDUWLFLSDPX\DFWLYDPHQWH\FRQ JUDQ LQWHUpV (Q OD ]RQD GH EiGPLQWRQ GRQGH HVWR\ ORFDOL]DGD UHDOL]D WRGDV ODV DFWLYLGDGHV SHUR GDGD VX LPSRVLELOLGDG GH DJDUUDU OD UDTXHWD \ OD PXOHWD D OD YH] GHFLGLPRVTXHMXHJXHGHVGHODSRVLFLyQGHDUURGLOODGD'HHVWDIRUPD0DUtDVHVLHQWH PiV OLEUH\FRQPD\RUFDSDFLGDGGHGHVSOD]DPLHQWR (Q QLQJ~Q PRPHQWRVHREVHUYD UHFKD]RSRUVXVFRPSDxHURVGHMXHJR &RPRHQHOUHVWRGHFRPSDxHURVSUHVHQWDHQDOJXQDVRFDVLRQHVGLILFXOWDGHQUHDOL]DU VDTXHV\UHFHSFLRQHV(QHOSDUWLGRVHPXHVWUDHQIDGDGDFRQXQFRPSDxHURSRUTXHVH DYDQ]D D HOOD \ QR OH SHUPLWH TXH UHFHSFLRQH HO YRODQWH HQYLDGR SRU ORV DGYHUVDULRV 5 5 5 5 5 5 &RPRHQRWUDVVLWXDFLRQHVVLPLODUHVHQYH]GHLQWHQWDUVROXFLRQDUORFRQVXFRPSDxHUR VHFUX]DGHEUD]RVPRVWUiQGRVHWULVWH\UHFODPDQGRODLQWHUYHQFLyQGHODGXOWR 5HVSHFWR D VX SDUWLFLSDFLyQ HQ OD ]RQD GHO KRFNH\ OD PDHVWUD GHFLGH TXH OD SULPHUD DFWLYLGDG FRQGXFFLyQ GHO VWLFN \ GH OD SDVWLOOD OR KDJD GHVGH OD SRVLFLyQ GH VHQWDGD &XDQGR SURSRQH OD VHJXQGD DFWLYLGDG SHUFLER D GLVWDQFLD XQRV WUHLQWD PHWURV TXH 0DUtD FRQWLQXDVRODSHURHQFDPELRSDUWLFLSD HQ HOSDUWLGRFRQODDGDSWDFLyQTXHHQ YH]GHFRQGXFLUODSDVWLOODFRQHOVWLFNORKDFHFRQORVSLHV &XDQGR OH SUHJXQWR D OD PDHVWUD GHO SRUTXp QR KD SDUWLFLSDGR GH ODV DFWLYLGDGHV SRU SDUHMDV PH FRQWHVWD TXH SHQVDED TXH HV GLILFXOWRVR SDUD 0DUtD GDGDV ODV GLVWDQFLDV FRQ HO FRPSDxHUR /H UHVSRQGR TXH VL RUJDQL]D XQ WUtR UHSURGXFLHQGR XQ WULiQJXOR \ 0DUtD VH VLW~D HQ HO FHQWUR ODV GLVWDQFLDV VRQ PHQRUHV 5iSLGDPHQWH DFHSWD OD VXJHUHQFLDGLFLHQGRTXHSDUDODSUy[LPDRFDVLyQSRQGUiDWRGRHOJUXSRHQWUtRV\DVt WRGRVSDUWLFLSDQGHODPLVPDSURSXHVWD &RPHQWDULRVDODVHVLyQ 0DUtD KD SDUWLFLSDGR PX\ DFWLYDPHQWH HQ OD VHVLyQ &RQ OD PDHVWUD KHPRV FRLQFLGLGR TXH VLQ OD SUHVHQFLD GHO SURIHVRU GH DSR\R QR KXELHUD SRGLGR GLVHxDU XQD VHVLyQ GH HVWDVFDUDFWHUtVWLFDVGDGRTXHOHKXELHUDVLGRGLILFXOWRVRFRQWURODUDDPERVJUXSRV &UHHPRV TXH HVWUDWpJLFDPHQWH HQ HVWH WLSR GH VHVLRQHV HV LPSRUWDQWH TXH \R QR DVXPDGLUHFWDPHQWHHOVHJXLPLHQWRGH0DUtDSDUDQRFUHDUXQDGHSHQGHQFLDFRQPLJR $SDUWLUGHKR\ODPDHVWUDSDVDWDPELpQDDGRSWDUHOUROGHREVHUYDGRUDSDUWLFLSDQWH 6(6,Ï11 '(129,(0%5('( 6HLQLFLDODMRUQDGDFRQODUHVSXHVWDDXQFXHVWLRQDULRUHVSHFWRDODVDFWLWXGHVKDFLDODV SHUVRQDVXVXDULDVGHVLOODGHUXHGDV&RPRKDRFXSDGRXQWHUFLRGHODVHVLyQWDQVyOR KDGDGRWLHPSRDODPDHVWUDSURSRQHUHOMXHJRGH³YROYHUDFDVD´ 3RUSDUHMDVVHRUJDQL]DQGRVFtUFXORVXQRLQWHULRU\RWURH[WHULRU/DGLVWDQFLDHQWUHORV PLHPEURV GHO PLVPR JUXSR HV GH XQ PHWUR \ PHGLR DSUR[LPDGDPHQWH \ FRQ HO FRPSDxHURGHXQPHWUR/RVMXJDGRUHVGHOLQWHULRUHVWiQFRQORVSLHVVHSDUDGRVGHWDO IRUPD TXH SXHGH SDVDU UHSWDQGR VX FRPSDxHUR $ OD VHxDO ORV MXJDGRUHV GHO FtUFXOR H[WHULRUFRUUHQHQVHQWLGRFRQWUDULRDODVDJXMDVGHOUHORMDOUHGHGRUGHVXVFRPSDxHURV &XDQGRODSURIHVRUDGLFH³DFDVD´WRGRVGHEHQUHJUHVDUGHQXHYRDQWHVXFRPSDxHUR TXHHVWiHQHOFtUFXORLQWHULRUVLQUHWURFHGHUHQQLQJ~QFDVRSDVDQGRHQWUHVXVSLHUQDV HQ UHSWDFLyQ \ VXELHQGR D OD HVSDOGD GH pVWH (O ~OWLPR HQ OOHJDU TXHGD HOLPLQDGR VHQWiQGRVHHQHOVXHORMXQWRDVXSDUHMD*DQDOD~OWLPDHQVHUHOLPLQDGD &XDQGRODPDHVWUDSURSRQHTXHOLEUHPHQWHVHRUJDQLFHQSRUSDUHMDV0DUtDVHTXHGDOD ~OWLPD\VHUH~QHFRQODFRPSDxHUDTXHWDPSRFRKDVLGRHVFRJLGD 5 5 5 5 5 5 5 +DVLGRFXULRVDODH[FODPDFLyQGH0DUtDFXDQGRVHKDH[SOLFDGRHOMXHJR(QVHJXLGDKD FRPHQWDGR³\\RTXp´+HPRVFRLQFLGRHQTXHODPHMRUDGDSWDFLyQFXDQGRDVXPHHOURO GH MXJDGRU LQWHULRU HV TXH VX FRPSDxHUD PDUTXH HO JHVWR GH VXELUVH D VX HVSDOGD VLWXDQGRXQDSLHUQDDODDOWXUDGHODFLQWXUD\FRJLpQGRVHDORVKRPEURVGH0DUtD(QHO FDVR GH VHU MXJDGRUD GHO FtUFXOR H[WHULRU KHPRV FRQVLGHUDGR TXH pVWD VH GHVSOD]DVH SRU HO LQWHULRU GHO FtUFXOR FRQ OD ILQDOLGDG GH UHGXFLU HO UHFRUULGR 1R KD SUHVHQWDGR GLILFXOWDGHQSDVDUUHSWDQGRHQWUHODVSLHUQDVGHVXFRPSDxHUD\HQVXELUDVXHVSDOGD GHMDQGRODVPXOHWDVHQHOVXHOR (QWRGRPRPHQWRVHREVHUYDD0DUtDPX\SDUWLFLSDWLYD\ULVXHxD &RPHQWDULRVDODVHVLyQ (V LQWHUHVDQWH FRPSUREDU FRPR 0DUtD UHFODPD VXV DGDSWDFLRQHV HQ VLWXDFLRQHV FRPSHWLWLYDV\DODSDUFyPRVXVFRPSDxHURVORDSUXHEDQVLQREMHFLyQDOJXQD 6(6,Ï11 '(129,(0%5('( /D VHVLyQ VH GHVDUUROOD HQ HO SDWLR GHO FHQWUR LQLFLiQGRVH FRQ OD H[SOLFDFLyQ GH FyPR WRPDU ODV SXOVDFLRQHV FDUGLDFDV $ FRQWLQXDFLyQ OD PDHVWUD SURSRQH OD VLJXLHQWH DFWLYLGDG 2UJDQL]DODFODVHHQJUXSRVGHFXDWURGLVWULEXLGRVHQHOUHFWiQJXORTXHFRQIRUPDODVOtQHDVGHO FDPSRGHEDORQFHVWR$ODVHxDOWLHQHQTXHGHVSOD]DUVHVLJXLHQGRXQULWPROHQWR\DOXQtVRQRGHWDO IRUPDTXHFXDQGRGHQXQDYXHOWDDOUHFWiQJXORWLHQHQTXHFRQWURODUODVSXOVDFLRQHV\FRPSDUDUHO UHVXOWDGR/DYDULDQWHTXHIRUPXODSRVWHULRUPHQWHHVODGHDXPHQWDUHOQ~PHURGHYXHOWDVKDVWDOOHJDUD FXDWUR /DDGDSWDFLyQTXHSHQVDPRVSDUD0DUtDHVODGHGHVSOD]DUVHDORDQFKRGHOFDPSRUHDOL]DQGRXQ UHFRUULGRGHLGD\YXHOWDGHSHQGLHQGRODVUHSHWLFLRQHVGHpVWDHQIXQFLyQGHOQ~PHURGHYXHOWDVTXH WLHQHQTXHUHDOL]DUVXVFRPSDxHURVGHJUXSRFRQHOREMHWLYRGHFRLQFLGLUFRQHOORVHQHOPRPHQWRTXH UHJUHVDQDOSXQWRLQLFLDO 0DUtDVHPXHVWUDFRQWHQWDFRQODDGDSWDFLyQ\VHOHREVHUYDFRQJUDQHQWXVLDVPR/DDFWLWXGGHVX JUXSRHVIDYRUDEOHDHVWDPRGLILFDFLyQ 3RVWHULRUPHQWHSURSRQHTXHUHDOLFHQHVWLUDPLHQWRV0LHQWUDVTXHODPDHVWUDRUJDQL]DHOFLUFXLWRTXH GHEHUiQUHDOL]DUORVQLxRV\ODVQLxDV\RGLULMRODDFWLYLGDG2EVHUYRTXHGHVGHHOLQLFLR0DUtDQRSDUWLFLSD OHLQVWRDTXHORKDJDSHURHOODFRQWHVWDTXH³QRTXLHUHSRUTXH\DKDFHPXFKRVHVWLUDPLHQWRV´/H UHFXHUGRTXHDSHVDUGHHOORHVQHFHVDULRKDFHUORVSRUORVEHQHILFLRVLQWUtQVHFRVDODDFWLYLGDGSHURHOOD VHQLHJD\VHDSDUWDGHOJUXSR(QHVHPRPHQWRHVFXFKRH[FODPDFLRQHVGHOUHVWRHPLWLHQGRHQWUHRWURV FRPHQWDULRV³TXHYD\DFDUDODGH0DUtD´³TXHHOODORWLHQHTXHKDFHUFRPRORVGHPiV´³DKSXHV\R WDPSRFRKDJR´)UHQRHVWRVFRPHQWDULRVGLFLHQGRTXHQRHVFRUUHFWDODDFWLWXGGH0DUtD\TXH\DOR WUDWDUpFRQHOODFXDQGRVHLQLFLHHOFLUFXLWR (OFLUFXLWRFRQVWDGHFLQFRHVWDFLRQHV 6DOWRVDODFRPEDGHIRUPDLQGLYLGXDO/RVQLxRV\QLxDVWLHQHQTXHUHDOL]DUGLIHUHQWHVWLSRVGHVDOWRV 5 5 5 5 5 5 5 7UDVODGDUFRQODVPDQRVXQDSHORWDPHGLFLQDOGHGRVNLORVKDVWDXQFRQRVLWXDGRDXQRVVLHWH PHWURVUHJUHVDUGHQXHYRDODOtQHDGHVDOLGD &RUUHUHQ]LJ]DJHQWUHFRQRVVHSDUDGRVDXQRVGRVPHWURV 6DOWDUDSLHVMXQWRVFXDWURFXHUGDVVHSDUDGDVHQWUHHOODVDGRVPHWURV\DXQDDOWXUDUHVSHFWRGHO VXHORGHVHVHQWDFHQWtPHWURV 6DOWDUDSLHVMXQWRV\DSDWDFRMDXQDILODGHVHLVDURVSUy[LPRVHQWUHVtËGHPVDOWDQGRORVDURVGH GRVHQGRV\GHWUHVHQWUHV $SURYHFKDQGRTXHHOJUXSRHVWiGLVWULEXLGRSRUODVGLIHUHQWHVHVWDFLRQHVGHOFLUFXLWRQRVDFHUFDPRV ODPDHVWUD\\RD0DUtD\OHFRPHQWDPRVTXHDOHVWDUHQODHVWDFLyQGHVDOWDUDODFXHUGD\FRPRQR SXHGHVDOWDUTXHUHDOLFHORVHVWLUDPLHQWRV'HQXHYRVHQLHJDURWXQGDPHQWHPRVWUiQGRVHFRQWUDULD DJDFKDQGRODFDEH]D\FRQLQWHQFLyQGHOORUDU$QWHWDODFWLWXGFRQVLGHUDPRVTXHQRHVRSRUWXQRIRU]DUOD SHURTXHDOGtDVLJXLHQWHKDEODUiODPDHVWUDFRQHOODSDUDDQDOL]DUVXFRPSRUWDPLHQWR 0HTXHGRGLQDPL]DQGRHQODSULPHUDYXHOWDODHVWDFLyQQ~PHURXQR\HQODVHJXQGDUHSHWLFLyQOD FLQFR0LHQWUDVWDQWRODPDHVWUDYDVLJXLHQGRD0DUtDHQODSULPHUDUHSHWLFLyQPiVGLUHFWDPHQWH\HQOD VHJXQGDXQSRFRPiVDGLVWDQFLDGiQGROHGHYH]HQFXDQGRDOJXQDVFRQVLJQDV 0DUtDSDUWLFLSDVLQGLILFXOWDGHQHOFLUFXLWRSUHVFLQGLpQGRVHGHODSULPHUDHVWDFLyQSRUVXLPSRVLELOLGDG GHVDOWDUDODFXHUGD(QODHVWDFLyQQ~PHURGRVWUDVODGDXQEDOyQGHXQNLORSHURFRPRQRSXHGHFRJHUOR FRQODVPDQRVORWLHQHTXHWUDVODGDUHQWUHORVPXVORV\ODVURGLOODV2EVHUYRDGLVWDQFLDTXHVHOHHVFDSD HOEDOyQUHLWHUDGDPHQWHSRUORTXHODPDHVWUDGHFLGHTXHORFKXWHFRQORVSLHV5HVSHFWRDODHVWDFLyQ Q~PHURFXDWURFRPRQRSXHGHVDOWDUODFXHUGDODPDHVWUDOHLQGLFDTXHLQWHQWHSDVDUODFRQHODSR\RGH ODVPXOHWDV $OILQDOL]DUODVHVLyQPHDFHUFRDHOODSDUDTXHPHHQVHxHFRPRWUDVODGDHOEDOyQPHGLFLQDOHQWUHODV SLHUQDV\YDORUDUDVtVXVGLILFXOWDGHV/DUHVSXHVWDHVTXHQRTXLHUHKDFHUOR /DLQWHUSUHWDFLyQTXHKDJRHQHVHLQVWDQWHHVTXHQRHVUHVLVWHQWHDODVIUXVWUDFLRQHV\DO FRPHQWiUVHORDODPDHVWUDLQWHUSUHWDTXHWDOYH]0DUtDHVWiHQRMDGDFRQPLJR$OSUHJXQWDUOHODFDXVD SLHQVDTXHKDWHQLGRFHORVFXDQGRKHLPSDUWLGRODVHVLyQGHHVWLUDPLHQWRVGDGRTXHQRKHHVWDGR SHQGLHQWHGHHOOD6HJ~QHOODPHHVWiGHVDILDQGRUHFODPDQGRGHHVWDPDQHUDPLDWHQFLyQ\TXH SUREDEOHPHQWHVHDSRUHOORTXHQRKDTXHULGRPRVWUDUPHODKDELOLGDGDOILQDOL]DUODVHVLyQ &RPHQWDULRVDODVHVLyQ 3RUORDFRQWHFLGRHQODVHVLyQHOJUXSRFODVHDFHSWDODVDGDSWDFLRQHVGH0DUtDSHURDVXYH]OH UHFODPDWDPELpQODVPLVPDVREOLJDFLRQHV 4XHGDSHQGLHQWHUHVROYHUODDFWLWXGGHVDILDQWHGH0DUtDFXDQGRVHKDQHJDGRDUHDOL]DUORV HVWLUDPLHQWRV 7HQHPRVTXHREVHUYDUHQODSUy[LPDVHVLyQVXDFWLWXGKDFLDPt '(129,(0%5('( 6(6,Ï11 1RVHLPSDUWLyODVHVLyQGHELGRDTXHODPDHVWUDGH(GXFDFLyQ)tVLFDWXYRTXHDFRPSDxDUDOWHDWURD ORVJUXSRVGH(GXFDFLyQ,QIDQWLO '(129,(0%5('( 6(6,Ï11 5 5 5 5 5 5 5 5 /DSULPHUDDFWLYLGDGTXHSURSRQHODPDHVWUDHVHO³UHOHYROLQHDOHQFDUUHUD´ 2UJDQL]DFLQFRJUXSRVGHFLQFRFRPSRQHQWHVLQWHQWDTXHWRGRVHVWpQORPiVHTXLSDUDGRVSRVLEOHV HQFXDQWRDODYHORFLGDGJOREDO7RGRVORVQLxRVHVWiQHQXPHUDGRVGHXQRDFLQFR&XDQGRODPDHVWUD GLFHXQRGHHVRVQ~PHURVVDOHQORVQLxRVDORVTXHFRUUHVSRQGHWHQLHQGRTXHUHFRUUHUXQRVPHWURV OOHJDUDXQDOtQHDGHUHIHUHQFLD\JLUDUFRQHOILQGHLQWHQWDUOOHJDUHOSULPHURDODOtQHDGHSDUWLGDDQWHV TXHVXVDGYHUVDULRV /DDGDSWDFLyQTXHSURSRQHD0DUtDHVODGHUHDOL]DUHOGHOUHFRUULGRPDUFDGRFRQXQFRQR WHQLHQGRTXHUHJUHVDUDODOtQHDGHVDOLGD&RQHVWDPHGLGDMXVWDVHREVHUYDDXQD0DUtDPX\ FRPSHWLWLYD/ODPDODDWHQFLyQTXHHQGRVRFDVLRQHVLQWHQWDKDFHUWUDPSDVDYDQ]iQGRVHDGRVPHWURV GHODOtQHDGHVDOLGDFXDQGROHWRFDFRUUHUKDVWDTXHODPDHVWUDOHOODPDODDWHQFLyQ2EVHUYRFyPRVH LQWHUUHODFLRQDYHUEDOPHQWHFRQODFRPSDxHUDPiVSUy[LPDDHOOD\FyPRDQLPDDVXVFRPSDxHURVGH HTXLSR 3URVLJXHODVHVLyQFRQHOMXHJRGH³EODQFR\QHJUR´ /DFODVHVHGLYLGHHQGRVHTXLSRVDXQRORGHQRPLQDQHJUR\DORWUREODQFR6HVLHQWDQHQILODLQGLD XQRDOODGRGHORWUR\DXQDGLVWDQFLDGHXQPHWURUHVSHFWRDORWURHTXLSR&XDQGRODPDHVWUDGLFHHO QRPEUHGHXQRGHHVWRVHTXLSRVpVWHWLHQHTXHGHVSOD]DUVHDOUHIXJLRTXHHVWiPDUFDGRFRQXQDOtQHD GHFDPSRDXQRVPHWURV(ORWURHTXLSRLQWHQWDWRFDUDOPi[LPRGHDGYHUVDULRVDQWHVGHOOHJDUDO UHIXJLR/RVMXJDGRUHVWRFDGRVVDOHQGHOFDPSRGHMXHJRDOD]RQDGHHOLPLQDGRV$VtPLVPRVHHOLPLQD XQMXJDGRUFXDQGRFRPHWHXQHUURUGHDWHQFLyQUHDOL]DQGRODDFFLyQFRQWUDULDDOQRPEUDUVHDXQRGHORV HTXLSRV)LQDOL]DHOMXHJRFXDQGRWRGRVORVPLHPEURVGHXQHTXLSRHVWiQHOLPLQDGRV /DYDULDQWHTXHSURSRQHHVFDPELDUODSRVLFLyQGHVDOLGDWXPEDGRVERFDDEDMR\PLUDQGRDO DGYHUVDULRPDQWHQLpQGRVHHOPHWURGHGLVWDQFLD 3DUDFRPSHQVDUODPRYLOLGDGUHGXFLGDGH0DUtDOHDVLJQDPRVXQMXJDGRUILMRGHOHTXLSR FRQWUDULR\HOODVLHPSUHSDUWHGHODSRVLFLyQGHSLH(OUHFRUULGRDVXUHIXJLRVHUHGXFHD XQRVPHWURVHQFDPELRFXDQGRWLHQHTXHLQWHQWDUWRFDUDVXDGYHUVDULRGLUHFWRWLHQH TXH OOHJDU KDVWD OD OtQHD GH UHIXJLR GHO JUXSR FRQWUDULR /D FRQVLJQD TXH UHFLEH VX DGYHUVDULRHVODGHGHVSOD]DUVHFRQSDVRVGHKRUPLJDXQSLHGHODQWHGHORWUR(QHO PRPHQWRTXHORDWUDSDWRFDQGRFRQODPXOHWDDODHVSDOGDVHOHDVLJQDRWURMXJDGRU ILMR (QODSULPHUDUHSHWLFLyQ0DUtDHVHOLPLQDGDHQODTXLQWDRFDVLyQ3HUFLERTXHVHVLW~D DUURGLOODGDHQHOVXHORMXQWRDPt\ODPDHVWUD\DGLVWDQFLDGHOJUXSRGHHOLPLQDGRV/D PDHVWUD OODPD OD DWHQFLyQ GH 0DUtD FXDQGR pVWD GHVDQLPD DO ~OWLPR MXJDGRU GH VX HTXLSRTXHTXHGDHQOD]RQDGHMXHJR$QWHODLQWHUYHQFLyQGHODPDHVWUDFDPELDGH DFWLWXG\HPSLH]DDO]DUODYR]DQLPiQGROH (QODVHJXQGDUHSHWLFLyQGHOMXHJRVHTXHGDOD~OWLPDGHVXHTXLSR2EVHUYRTXHHQHO JUXSRGHFRPSDxHURVHOLPLQDGRVQDGLHODDQLPD (Q OD WHUFHUD UHSHWLFLyQ HV HOLPLQDGD HQ OD VHJXQGD RFDVLyQ 0DUtD GH QXHYR VH DUURGLOOD SUy[LPD D QRVRWUDV VLQ PRVWUDU LQWHUpV HQ LQWHUUHODFLRQDUVH FRQ VXV FRPSDxHURVHOLPLQDGRV 7HQJRTXHVXEUD\DUODDFWLWXGGH0DUtDHQHVWHMXHJRPX\SRVLWLYDPRVWUiQGRVHPX\ PRWLYDGD ULVXHxD \ EURPHDQGR DOJXQDV YHFHV FRQ OD PDHVWUD ,QFOXVR HQ PiV GH DOJXQDRFDVLyQGHVDItDDVXVDGYHUVDULRV5HVSHFWRDpVWRVOHVWHQHPRVTXHUHFRUGDU TXHQRHQOHQWH]FDQHOSDVRSDUDGDUPiVYHQWDMDD0DUtDTXHHOODVHWLHQHTXHHVIRU]DU 5 5 5 5 5 5 5 5 FRPRWRGRV\WRGDV 3DUDILQDOL]DUODVHVLyQVHFLHUUDFRQHOMXHJRGHO³HVFRQGLWH´ 8QDMXJDGRUDHVODTXH³SDUD´\HOUHVWRWLHQHQTXHEXVFDUHQHOHVSDFLROXJDUHVGRQGH HVFRQGHUVH (O DOXPQR TXH ³SDUD´ FLHUUD ORV RMRV \ FXHQWD KDVWD YHLQWH $O DEULUORV GH QXHYRGHEHREVHUYDUHOHVSDFLR\ORFDOL]DUDFXDOTXLHUDGHVXVFRPSDxHURV6tHVDVt GLFHHQYR]DOWDVXQRPEUH\GyQGHHVWiHVFRQGLGR3XHGHGHVSOD]DUVHSDUDORFDOL]DUD VXVFRPSDxHURVPLHQWUDVTXHHOUHVWRSXHGHDSURYHFKDUSDUDDOFDQ]DUOD]RQDGRQGH HVWiODMXJDGRUDHQHOLQLFLRGHOMXHJRFRQHOREMHWRGHOOHJDUDQWHVTXHHOOD\VDOYDUVH (O ~OWLPR MXJDGRU SXHGH VDOYDU D WRGRV ORV FRPSDxHURV TXH KDQ VLGR YLVWRV VL OOHJD DQWHV TXH HO DOXPQR TXH´ SDUD´ JULWDQGR ³VDOYDGR \ VDOYDGRV PLV FRPSDxHURV´ 6t OD DOXPQD TXH ³SDUD´ VH HTXLYRFD DO GHFLU GyQGH KD YLVWR HO ~OWLPR FRPSDxHUR TXHGDQ WRGRVVDOYDGRVWHQLHQGRGHQXHYRTXHDVXPLUHOUROGH³SDUDU´ (Q OD SULPHUD UHSHWLFLyQ 0DUtD KD VLGR OD ~OWLPD HQ VHU ORFDOL]DGD SHUR GDGR TXH OD DOXPQDTXH³SDUD´VHHTXLYRFDDOLQGLFDUHOOXJDUVDOYDDWRGRVVXVFRPSDxHURV9DULRV VHDSUR[LPDQDHOODSDUDDJUDGHFpUVHORSRUORTXHREVHUYDPRVTXHOHSURYRFDXQDJUDQ VDWLVIDFFLyQ 5 5 &RPHQWDULRVDODVHVLyQ 7DQWR0DUtDFRPRHOJUXSRDFHSWDQODVFRPSHQVDFLRQHVGHODVWDUHDVFRPSHWLWLYDVVLQ REMHFLyQDOJXQD&RLQFLGLPRVFRQODPDHVWUDHQTXH0DUtDVHPXHVWUDPiVSDUWLFLSDWLYD\ PRWLYDGDSRUODDFWLYLGDG &XDQGROHSUHJXQWRDODPDHVWUDVREUHODDFWLWXGGH0DUtDHQODVHVLyQQ~PHURPH FRPHQWDTXHDOKDEODUFRQHOODOHGLMRTXHQRTXHUtDKDFHUHVWLUDPLHQWRVSRUTXH\DORV KDFtD HQ UHKDELOLWDFLyQ /D UHVSXHVWD GH OD PDHVWUD KD VLGR OD GH FRQYHQFHUOH VREUH OD QHFHVLGDGGHpVWRVHQODVHVLyQGH(GXFDFLyQ)tVLFD\TXHWLHQHTXHFRPSDUWLUDLPDJHQ GHORVFRPSDxHURVWRGDVODVDFWLYLGDGHVTXHVHSODQWHDQ 6(6,Ï11 '(129,(0%5('( (QHVWDVHVLyQVHLQLFLDODVDFWLYLGDGHVSUHSDUDWRULDVGHVHQVLELOL]DFLyQGHODMRUQDGDGH MXHJRV PRWRUHV VHQVLELOL]DGRUHV TXH WHQGUi OXJDU HO GtD GH QRYLHPEUH 3DUD HOOR FHQWUDPRVODFODVHHQODVGRVVLJXLHQWHVDFWLYLGDGHV 3UHVHQWDFLyQGHODVFDUDFWHUtVWLFDVGHODVLOODGHUXHGDV 0DQHMR GH OD VLOOD GH UXHGDV 3URSRQJR HO MXHJR GH ³LU D WRFDU´ &RQVLVWHHQTXHORVDOXPQRVVHGHVSOD]DQOLEUHPHQWHSRUHOHVSDFLR HQVLOODVGHUXHGDV$ODVHxDOWLHQHQTXHWRFDUXQFRORUGHWHUPLQDGR XQPDWHULDOXQDSDUWHFRUSRUDOVLHPSUHFRQUHVSHFWRDORVGHPiVR D ORV REMHWRV )LQDOL]DGD OD DFWLYLGDG WLHQHQ TXH GHPRVWUDU FyPR JLUDQPHMRUODVLOOD $OGLVSRQHUGHWUHFHVLOODVGHUXHGDVORVTXHQRWLHQHQSDUWLFLSDQLJXDOPHQWHGHOMXHJR FDPELiQGRVHSRUVXVFRPSDxHURVFDGDWUHVFRQVLJQDV 'DGRTXHVHLQLFLDFRQXQFXDUWRGHKRUDGHUHWUDVRVXPiQGRVHHOWLHPSRGHWUDVODGRGH ODVVLOODVGHUXHGDVPiVHOFXDUWRGHKRUDTXHVHGHGLFDDODGXFKDWDQVyORVHFXHQWD FRQXQFXDUWRGHKRUDGHDFWLYLGDG$SHVDUGHOSRFRWLHPSRORVQLxRVVHPXHVWUDQPX\ LQWHUHVDGRVSRUODSUiFWLFDPDQLIHVWDQGRVXLQWHUpVSRUSURORQJDUODH[SHULHQFLDHQODV VLJXLHQWHVVHVLRQHV $VtPLVPRD0DUtDHVWiPX\PRWLYDGDUHFRJLHQGRVXVDWLVIDFFLyQFXDQGRDOILQDOL]DUOD VHVLyQOHGHFLPRVTXHLQIRUPHDVXVFRPSDxHURVFyPRVHJLUDPiVHILFD]PHQWHFRQOD VLOOD &RPHQWDULRVDODVHVLyQ 6HREVHUYDDXQD0DUtDPRWLYDGDSRUODSUiFWLFDDVtFRPRHOUHVWRGHOJUXSR 5 5 5 5 5 5 5 5 (V OD WHUFHUD RFDVLyQ TXH SURWDJRQL]R XQD H[SOLFDFLyQ (O JUXSR HVWi DWHQWR \ OD 5 FRRUGLQDFLyQFRQODPDHVWUDHVH[FHOHQWH 6(6,Ï11 '(129,(0%5('( 3DUDHVWDVHVLyQKHPRVLQYLWDGRD/DLD$UPHQJROPDHVWUDGH(GXFDFLyQ(VSHFLDOTXH HVWXGLDSVLFRSHGDJRJtDWUDEDMDHQXQDDVRFLDFLyQGHSHUVRQDVFRQGLVFDSDFLGDGPRWUL] \VHWLHQHTXHGHVSOD]DUFRQODD\XGDGHPXOHWDV (OREMHWLYRHVHOGHIDFLOLWDUXQHVSDFLRGHUHIOH[LyQVREUHODVOLPLWDFLRQHV\FDSDFLGDGHV GH ODV SHUVRQDV FRQ GLVFDSDFLGDG (V SRU HOOR TXH VH LQLFLD FRQ XQD SUR\HFFLyQ GH XQ YtGHRHQHOTXHVHSUHVHQWDGLYHUVDVH[SHULHQFLDVGHLQWHJUDFLyQHVFRODU$SDUWLUGHDKt VHLQLFLDXQGHEDWHGRQGHVHUHFRJHODVLQTXLHWXGHVGHORVQLxRV\QLxDV /ODPDODDWHQFLyQTXHFXDQGRVHSUR\HFWDQLPiJHQHVVREUHODGLVFDSDFLGDGLQWHOHFWXDO WUHVQLxRVVHUtHQFRQVWDQWHPHQWH$OILQDOL]DUHOYtGHRODPDHVWUDLQWHUYLHQHLQWHQWDQGR TXH UHIOH[LRQHQ VREUH OD UHVSXHVWD WDQ LUUHVSHWXRVD GH ORV QLxRV TXH VH KDQ UHtGR 3RVWHULRUPHQWHFRQWLQ~DQODVLQWHUYHQFLRQHVGHOJUXSRFODVH\SULQFLSDOPHQWHJLUDQVREUH HOFRQRFLPLHQWRGHSHUVRQDVSUy[LPDVFRQGLVFDSDFLGDGHOUHVSHWRKDFLDORVGHPiV\HO FRQFHSWRGHTXHWRGRV\WRGDVVRPRVGLIHUHQWHV$OJXQRVDSURYHFKDQODVLWXDFLyQSDUD FRPHQWDU VX H[SHULHQFLD SHUVRQDO GH FyPR VH KDQ VHQWLGR FXDQGR RWURV QLxRV ORV KDQ LURQL]DGRSRUDOJXQDFDUDFWHUtVWLFDSHUVRQDO &XDQGRLQWHUYLHQH0DUtDWDQVyORVHOLPLWDDGHFLUTXHFRQRFHDXQDSHUVRQDFLHJDFRQOD TXHFRPSDUWtDODUHKDELOLWDFLyQKDVWDKDFHSRFRWLHPSR6XGLVFXUVRUHFXHUGDDODGHXQD QLxD PiV SHTXHxD $ SHVDU GH TXH /DLD OH LQYLWD D LQWHUYHQLU PiV D PHQXGR SDUD TXH FRPHQWHVXH[SHULHQFLD0DUtDVRQUtHSHURQRDxDGHQDGDQXHYR )LQDOL]DODVHVLyQFRQODSUR\HFFLyQGHXQYtGHRVREUHHVTXtDGDSWDGRDODVSHUVRQDVFRQ GLVFDSDFLGDG (O JUXSR VH TXHGD PX\ VRUSUHQGLGR SRU ODV FDSDFLGDGHV TXH PXHVWUD HO FROHFWLYR1RREVWDQWHFXDQGRVDOHXQDSHUVRQDGREOHDPSXWDGDGHSLHUQDVDOJXQRVVH WDSDQ ORV RMRV $SURYHFKDPRV HVWD UHVSXHVWD SDUD DQDOL]DUOD \ FRQFOXLPRV TXH OR LPSRUWDQWHHVFRPSDUWLUODHVFRODUL]DFLyQFRQWRGDVODVSHUVRQDVLQGLVWLQWDPHQWHGHODV FDUDFWHUtVWLFDVSHUVRQDOHVSDUDIDFLOLWDUHOFRQRFLPLHQWRPXWXR &RPHQWDULRVDODVHVLyQ 7DQWRODPDHVWUDFRPR/DLD\\RFRLQFLGLPRVTXHKDVLGRPX\LQWHUHVDQWHODUHVSXHVWD GHOJUXSRFODVH\TXHKDVHUYLGRSDUDDPSOLDUVXFRQRFLPLHQWRVREUHODUHDOLGDGGHODV SHUVRQDVFRQGLVFDSDFLGDG 0DUtDSRGtDKDEHUDSRUWDGRVXH[SHULHQFLDSHUVRQDOSHURORKDHYLWDGRTXHGiQGRVHHQ XQ VHJXQGR SODQR D SHVDU GH OD LQYLWDFLyQ GH /DLD 6H SXHGH LQWHUSUHWDU VX HVFDVD DSRUWDFLyQFRPRXQDPXHVWUDGHVXLQPDGXUH] 5 5 5 5 5 5 6(6,Ï11 '(129,(0%5('( 6HLQLFLDODVHVLyQFRQODVLJXLHQWHWDUHD (O JUXSR FODVH HQ FtUFXOR WLHQHQ TXH FRUUHU DOUHGHGRU GHO JLPQDVLR GXUDQWH FXDWUR PLQXWRVDSUR[LPDGDPHQWH 3HUFLELPRV TXH D 0DUtD QR OH PRWLYD OD DFWLYLGDG GDGR TXH VROLFLWD D OD PDHVWUD LU DO ODYDER\FXDQGRUHJUHVDVHGHWLHQHDREVHUYDUDORVDOXPQRVGHHGXFDFLyQLQIDQWLOKDVWD TXHODPDHVWUDOHUHFODPDVXSUHVHQFLDHQHOJLPQDVLR $FRQWLQXDFLyQLQGLFDTXHVHRUJDQLFHQSRUSDUHMDV&RPRHVKDELWXDO0DUtDVHTXHGDVLQ VHU HVFRJLGD WHQLHQGR TXH LQWHUYHQLU OD PDHVWUD /DV WDUHDV TXH VXJLHUH VRQ ODV TXH VLJXHQ /DV SDUHMDV VH FRJHQ SRU ODV PDQRV SRU HQFLPD GH OD FDEH]D $ OD VHxDO WLHQHQ TXH VHQWDUVH\OHYDQWDUVHGHOVXHORGHPDQHUDFRRUGLQDGD /DDGDSWDFLyQTXHUHDOL]DPRVHVODGHD\XGDUOHHQODDFFLyQVRVWHQLpQGRODSRUODVD[LODV FRQHOREMHWRGHDXPHQWDUVXHTXLOLEULR $EGRPLQDOHV8QRGHODSDUHMDWXPEDGRHQHOVXHORFRQODVSLHUQDV VHPLIOH[LRQDGDV \ ODV PDQRV GHWUiV GH OD FDEH]D /RV SLHV VRQ FRJLGRV SRU VX FRPSDxHUR $ OD VHxDO WLHQH TXH OHYDQWDU HO WURQFR XQRVQRYHQWDJUDGRV\UHJUHVDUGHQXHYRDOVXHOR /DFDUUHWLOOD8QRGHSLH\VRVWLHQHDVXFRPSDxHURSRUODVURGLOODV eVWH WXPEDGR ERFD DEDMR FRQ ORV EUD]RV H[WHQGLGRV \ ODV PDQRV DSR\DGDV HQ HO VXHOR 7LHQHQ TXH GHVSOD]DUVH D OR ODUJR GHO JLPQDVLR &RPR 0DUtD QR SXHGH HVWDU GH SLH \ FRJHU ODV SLHUQDV GH OD FRPSDxHUD RSWDPRV SRU TXHVHDUURGLOOHHQHOVXHOR\FRMDXQDGHODVGRVSLHUQDV/DRWUDODVRVWHQJR\R (O~OWLPRMXHJRTXHSURSRQHODPDHVWUDHVHOGH³YROYHUDFDVD´ 3RUSDUHMDVVHRUJDQL]DQGRVFtUFXORVXQRLQWHULRU\RWURH[WHULRU/DGLVWDQFLDHQWUHORV PLHPEURV GHO PLVPR JUXSR HV GH XQ PHWUR \ PHGLR DSUR[LPDGDPHQWH \ FRQ HO FRPSDxHURGHXQPHWUR/RVMXJDGRUHVGHOLQWHULRUHVWiQFRQORVSLHVVHSDUDGRVGHWDO IRUPD TXH SXHGH SDVDU UHSWDQGR VX FRPSDxHUR $ OD VHxDO ORV MXJDGRUHV GHO FtUFXOR H[WHULRUFRUUHQHQVHQWLGRFRQWUDULRDODVDJXMDVGHOUHORMDOUHGHGRUGHVXVFRPSDxHURV &XDQGR ODSURIHVRUDGLFH³DFDVD´WRGRVGHEHQUHJUHVDUGHQXHYRDQWHVXFRPSDxHUR TXHHVWiHQHOFtUFXORLQWHULRUVLQUHWURFHGHUHQQLQJ~QFDVRSDVDQGRHQWUHVXVSLHUQDV HQ UHSWDFLyQ \ VXELHQGR D OD HVSDOGD GH pVWH (O ~OWLPR HQ OOHJDU TXHGD HOLPLQDGR VHQWiQGRVHHQHOVXHORMXQWRDVXSDUHMD*DQDOD~OWLPDHQVHUHOLPLQDGD 5 5 5 5 5 5 5 5 &RPR HQ XQD VHVLyQ DQWHULRU OD DGDSWDFLyQ TXH UHDOL]DPRV FXDQGR DVXPH HO URO GH MXJDGRULQWHULRUHVTXHVXFRPSDxHUDPDUTXHHOJHVWRGHVXELUVHDVXHVSDOGDVLWXDQGR XQDSLHUQDDODDOWXUDGHODFLQWXUD\FRJLpQGRVHDORVKRPEURVGH0DUtD(QHOFDVRGH VHU MXJDGRUD GHO FtUFXOR H[WHULRU KHPRV FRQVLGHUDGR TXH pVWD VH GHVSOD]DVH SRU HO LQWHULRUGHOFtUFXORFRQODILQDOLGDGGHUHGXFLUHOHVSDFLRGHUHFRUULGR1RKDSUHVHQWDGR GLILFXOWDGHQSDVDUUHSWDQGRHQWUHODVSLHUQDVGHVXFRPSDxHUD\HQVXELUDVXHVSDOGD GHMDQGRODVPXOHWDVHQHOVXHOR &RPRGDWRDQHFGyWLFRWHQJRTXHDQRWDUORDFRQWHFLGRHQHVWHMXHJR/RVDOXPQRVHVWiQ DOERURWDGRV\QRVLJXHQODVFRQVLJQDVGHODPDHVWUDeVWDORVUHFULPLQDFRPHQWDQGRTXH WDQWR \R FRPR HOOD SRQGUHPRV OD QRWD GHO WULPHVWUH \ DYDQ]D TXH FRLQFLGLPRV TXH WDQ VyOR XQR GH HOORV PHUHFH VHU DSUREDGR 8Q DOXPQR FRQWHVWD ³\R \D Vp TXLHQ HV´ \ D FRQWLQXDFLyQFRQMXQWDPHQWHFRQWUHVFRPSDxHURVGLFHQHOQRPEUHGH0DUtD/DPDHVWUD OHVSUHJXQWDSRUTXpHOOD\pVWRVOHUHVSRQGHQ³SRUTXHVHSRUWDELHQ\VHHVIXHU]D´ 3HUFLELPRV TXH 0DUtD VDOH PX\ UHIRU]DGD SRU ODV REVHUYDFLRQHV GH VXV FRPSDxHURV UHIOHMiQGRVHHQVXFDUDJUDQVDWLVIDFFLyQ\DOHJUtD1RREVWDQWHQRVOODPDODDWHQFLyQTXH QRKD\DHPLWLGRQLQJ~QFRPHQWDULRDOUHVSHFWR &RPHQWDULRVDODVHVLyQ 2EVHUYDPRV D XQD 0DUtD FRQ IDOWD GH LQLFLDWLYD \ PX\ GHSHQGLHQWH GHO DGXOWR 7LHQH GLILFXOWDGHVSDUDLQWHUDFWXDUFRQVXVFRPSDxHURV (V PX\ VLJQLILFDWLYR TXH UHLWHUDGDPHQWH VHD OD ~OWLPD HQ VHU HVFRJLGD FXDQGR VH RUJDQL]DQSDUHMDVRSHTXHxRVJUXSRV 6(6,Ï11 '(129,(0%5('( &RQWLQXDQGRFRQODVDFWLYLGDGHVGHVHQVLELOL]DFLyQPHGLDQWHODYLYHQFLDFLyQ\VLPXODFLyQ GHODVGLVFDSDFLGDGHVSURSRQHPRVODVVLJXLHQWHVDFWLYLGDGHVHQVLOODGHUXHGDV ³6WRS´3DUDQWUHVFRPSDxHURVLGHQWLILFiQGROHVFRQXQSDxXHOR(OREMHWLYRGHpVWRVHVHO GH PRYLOL]DU D WRGR HO JUXSR FODVH LQWHQWDQGR WRFDUOHV $O VHU WRFDGRV WLHQHQ TXH TXHGDUVHHVWiWLFRVFRQORVEUD]RVHQFUX](OUHVWRGHFRPSDxHURVSXHGHQVDOYDUORVVL VH DSUR[LPDQ D HOORV \ OH GDQ XQD SDOPDGD HQ HO GRUVR GH OD PDQR VLQ KDEHU VLGR WRFDGRVSRUORVTXHSDUDQ (QHVWHMXHJR0DUtDSDUWLFLSDPX\PRWLYDGDEULQGiQGRVHHQYDULDVRFDVLRQHVDSDUDU $FRQWLQXDFLyQRUJDQL]DPRVGRVJUXSRV8QRGHHOORVVHGHVSOD]DFRQPLJRDOD]RQDGHO YROHLEROVHQWDGR\HORWURVHTXHGDFRQODPDHVWUDSDUDSDUWLFLSDUGHOEDORQFHVWRHQVLOOD GHUXHGDV$PEDVQRVSURSRQHPRVGDUOHVDFRQRFHUHOGHSRUWHDGDSWDGRDODVSHUVRQDV FRQGLVFDSDFLGDGPRWUL] 5 5 5 5 5 5 5 (QXQSULQFLSLRQRVSODQWHDPRVXQFDPELRGHJUXSRHQODPLWDGGHODVHVLyQSHURDQWHOD IDOWD GH WLHPSR DFRUGDPRV TXH HQ OD VLJXLHQWH VHVLyQ LQYHUWLUtDPRV ORV JUXSRV +H GH FRQVWDWDU TXH WDO GHFLVLyQ QR IXH ELHQ DFHSWDGD SRU HO JUXSR TXH SUDFWLFD YROHLERO VHQWDGRSRUTXHSUHIHUtDQSUDFWLFDUEiVTXHWHQVLOODGHUXHGDV $QWHPLGLVWDQFLDFRQ0DUtDOHSUHJXQWRDODPDHVWUDFXiOKDVLGRVXFRPSRUWDPLHQWR 2EVHUYDTXHSDUWLFLSDPX\DFWLYDPHQWH\PX\PRWLYDGD1RKDJHQHUDGRLQWHUDFFLRQHV FRQVXVFRPSDxHURV\KDVLGRDOILQDOFXDQGRVHKDHQIDGDGRSRUTXHTXHUtDVDFDUWRGDV ODVIDOWDVGHEDQGDIDYRUDEOHVDVXHTXLSR/DPDHVWUDOHKDFRQWHVWDGRTXHQRSRGtDVHU SRUTXHWHQtDTXHURWDUHQWUHWRGRVVXVFRPSDxHURVGHHTXLSR+DSURWHVWDGRGHQXHYR SHURKDFRQWLQXDGRHQOD]RQDGHMXHJR (Q FXDQWR D OD FRPXQLFDFLyQ FRQ HO UHVWR GHO JUXSR OD PDHVWUD PH FRQILUPD TXH HO Q~PHURGHLQWHUDFFLRQHVHVEDMRFRQVWDWiQGRVHSRUHOHVFDVRGLiORJRDQWHODGLILFXOWDG TXHOHVVXSRQHFRQWURODUHOPDQHMRGHODVLOODGHUXHGDV\HOEDOyQ $OILQDOL]DUODVHVLyQPHDSUR[LPRD0DUtD\OHSUHJXQWRFyPRVHORKDSDVDGR\TXpKD DSUHQGLGR VRUSUHQGLpQGRPH TXH PH HVTXLYD GH PDQHUD SHUVLVWHQWH KDVWD TXH PH UHVSRQGH LUUHVSHWXRVDPHQWH FRQ XQ ³GpMDPH HQ SD]´ /H FRQWHVWR TXH QR PHUH]FR WDO UHVSXHVWD\VXUHDFFLyQHVEDMDUODFDEH]D\DQGDUUiSLGDPHQWHSDUDGHMDUPHDWUiV &RPHQWDULRVDODVHVLyQ $QWH OD UHVSXHVWD LUUHVSHWXRVD GH 0DUtD OD PDHVWUD SLHQVD TXH KD VLGR XQD IRUPD GH PDQLIHVWDUVXVFHORVSRUTXHKHHVWDGRFDVLODWRWDOLGDGGHODVHVLyQFRQHORWURJUXSR0H FRPHQWD TXH LQWHQWD VLHPSUH DWUDHU OD DWHQFLyQ GHO DGXOWR \ FXDQGR QR OR FRQVLJXH VH HQIDGD1RREVWDQWHLQGDJDUiVXVPRWLYRV /DPDHVWUDPHDYDQ]DORVUHVXOWDGRVPiVVLJQLILFDWLYRVGH0DUtDGHOFXHVWLRQDULRTXHVH KDSDVDGRDOJUXSRFODVHUHVSHFWRDODUHSHUFXVLyQGHODMRUQDGDGHORVMXHJRVPRWRUHV VHQVLELOL]DGRUHV (Q OD SUHJXQWD ¢VL WLHQHV R WXYLHVHV XQD GLVFDSDFLGDG TXp FRVDV PHMRUDUtDVGHODHVFXHOD"UHVSRQGH³MXJDUFRQHOQLxRFRQGLVFDSDFLGDG´\HQHOVLJXLHQWH tWHP¢\TXpFRVDVPHMRUDUtDVGHOEDUULR"HVFULEH³KDFHUDPLJRV´&RQHVWDVUHVSXHVWDV UHIOHMDODVROHGDGGH0DUtDHQHOHVSDFLRGHOSDWLR\HQVXWLHPSROLEUH3RU~OWLPRHVGH UHVDOWDU VX FRPHQWDULR FXDQGR VH OH SUHJXQWD ¢FyPR WH KDV VHQWLGR YLHQGR D WXV FRPSDxHURV UHDOL]DQGR HVWH WLSR GH MXHJRV TXH UHSUHVHQWDEDQ DOJXQD GLVFDSDFLGDG" \ UHVSRQGHWDQVyORTXH³PX\ELHQ´ 6(6,Ï11 '(',&,(0%5('( 1RVHLPSDUWHODVHVLyQGHELGRDTXHODPDHVWUDWLHQHTXHDFRPSDxDUDORVJUXSRVGH (GXFDFLyQ,QIDQWLODXQDREUDGHWHDWUR 5 5 5 5 5 5 6(6,Ï11 '(',&,(0%5('( 3URVHJXLPRVFRQODVDFWLYLGDGHVGHVHQVLELOL]DFLyQ\ODVSURSXHVWDVTXHUHDOL]DPRVVRQ 5 ODVVLJXLHQWHV ´$WRFDUDORVFRPSDxHURVTXHQRWLHQHQVLOODµ&LQFRGHOJUXSRVHGHVSOD]DQVLQVLOODGHUXHGDV\HO UHVWRWLHQHQTXHLQWHQWDUWRFDUOHV(QHOPRPHQWRTXHORFRQVLJXHQVHFDPELDQORVUROHV ³8QGRVWUHVSLFDSDUHG´8QFRPSDxHURHVHOTXHSDUDVLWXDGRGHODQWHGHXQDSDUHG (OUHVWRSDUWLUiGHXQDOtQHDGHOFDPSRTXHHVWiDXQRVTXLQFHPHWURV&XDQGRHODOXPQR TXHSDUDJROSHDVXDYHPHQWHODSDUHG\DODYH]JULWD³XQGRVWUHVSLFDSDUHG´HOUHVWR GHFRPSDxHURVDYDQ]DQHOPi[LPRHVSDFLRLQWHQWDGRTXHGDUVHHVWiWLFRVDOILQDOL]DUOD IUDVH &XDQGR HO TXH SDUD VH JLUD \ REVHUYD TXH VH PXHYH DOJXQR GH HOORV LQGLFD HO QRPEUH \ pVWH WLHQH TXH UHJUHVDU D OD OtQHD GH LQLFLR (O REMHWLYR GH ORV MXJDGRUHV GH FDPSRHVHOGHVHUHOSULPHURHQWRFDUDOTXHSDUD(OMXJDGRUPiVGLVWDQFLDGRHVHOTXH SDUDHQODSUy[LPDUHSHWLFLyQ (QQLQJ~QFDVRORVFRPSDxHURVTXHQRWHQtDQVLOODKDQUHFODPDGRODTXHRFXSDED0DUtD HQHVWRVMXHJRVLQLFLDOHV $HOODODREVHUYDPRVPX\FRPSHWLWLYDHVSHFLDOPHQWHHQHOVHJXQGRMXHJRLQWHQWDQGRHQ WRGR PRPHQWR VHU OD SULPHUD HQ WRFDU DO MXJDGRU TXH SDUD SHUR FXULRVDPHQWH QR OR FRQVLJXH &RQVWDWDPRVTXHHVWDEOHFHHVFDVDVLQWHUDFFLRQHVFRQVXVFRPSDxHURVQRSUHVHQWDQGR HQQLQJ~QPRPHQWRODLQLFLDWLYD(QODVVLWXDFLRQHVFRQIOLFWLYDVFRQVXVFRPSDxHURVHQ YH]GHUHVROYHUODVSHUVRQDOPHQWHUHFODPDODLQWHUYHQFLyQGHODPDHVWUD $LPDJHQGHODVHVLyQDQWHULRUQRVGLVWULEXLPRVORVJUXSRVXQRVHGLULJHDOD]RQDGHO EDORQFHVWRHQVLOODGHUXHGDV\HORWURDODGHOYROHLEROVHQWDGR(QHVWDRFDVLyQ0DUtDVH ORFDOL]DHQHVWHVHJXQGRHVSDFLR 6H PXHVWUD PX\ GHVDILDQWH FRQPLJR H LQFOXVR GLUtD TXH PX\ SURYRFDGRUD (Q GHWHUPLQDGDV VLWXDFLRQHV OD SHUFLER SDVLYD \ OH SUHJXQWR HO SRU TXp GH VX DFWLWXG UHVSRQGLpQGRPH FRQ XQ ³SRUTXH QR´ $QWH WDO FRQWHVWDFLyQ OH LQVWR D TXH SDUWLFLSH D LPDJHQ GH VXV FRPSDxHURV \ HIHFWLYDPHQWH FRQWLQXD FRQ OD VHVLyQ VLQ SUHVHQWDU JUDQ LQWHUpVSRUODSUiFWLFDGHOYROHLEROVHQWDGR &RPHQWDULRVDODVHVLyQ 0DUtD FRQWLQXD HQ OD OtQHD GH QR SUHVHQWDU LQLFLDWLYD HQ OD LQWHUDFFLyQ FRQ VXV FRPSDxHURV \ HQ ODV VLWXDFLRQHV FRQIOLFWLYDV TXH VH JHQHUDQ FRQ HOORV UHFODPD OD LQWHUYHQFLyQGHODPDHVWUDHQYH]GHUHVROYHUODVSHUVRQDOPHQWH 5 5 5 5 5 6LJXHGLVWDQWHFRQPLJRDSHVDUGHPLVLQWHQWRVGHDSUR[LPDFLyQ3HQVDPRVTXHHVXQ 5 UHFODPRGHDWHQFLyQ 6(6,Ï11 6(6,Ï11 '(',&,(0%5('( (VWHGtDOOXHYHLQWHQVDPHQWH\SRUWDQWRQRVHSXHGHLPSDUWLUVHVLyQSUiFWLFDSRUTXHSRU 5 ORVODWHUDOHVDOWRVGHOJLPQDVLRDOHVWDUHQGHVFXELHUWRHQWUDDJXD 2SWDPRVSRUFRQWLQXDUFRQODVDFWLYLGDGHVGHVHQVLELOL]DFLyQSUR\HFWDQGRGRVYLGHRVFRQ HOREMHWRTXHUHFRQR]FDQODVFDSDFLGDGHVGHODVSHUVRQDVFRQGLVFDSDFLGDG (O SULPHU YLGHR YHUVD VREUH XQD FRUHRJUDItD FRPSDUWLGD HQWUH SHUVRQDV FRQ \ VLQ GLVFDSDFLGDG < HO VHJXQGR HV XQD SUHVHQWDFLyQ GH ODV PRGDOLGDGHV GHSRUWLYDV GH ODV SDUDROLPSLDGDV 2EVHUYDPRV D XQD 0DUtD TXH H[SUHVD JUDQ LQWHUpV DSUREDFLyQ SRU OD SURSXHVWD \ HQ 5 DOJXQDVRFDVLRQHVPDQLILHVWDJUDQDGPLUDFLyQSRUODVLPiJHQHVTXHVHHPLWHQ 0LHQWUDVTXHHOUHVWRGHOJUXSRSDUWLFLSDPX\DFWLYDPHQWHDOILQDOL]DUODSUR\HFFLyQGHORV GRVYLGHRV0DUtDSHUPDQHFHPX\SDVLYD7DQVyORKDLQWHUYHQLGRHQXQDRFDVLyQDQWH QXHVWUR UHFODPR 1RV OODPD OD DWHQFLyQ VX HQWRQDFLyQ GH YR] TXH OD FDWDORJDPRV GH LQIDQWLOORTXHDSURYHFKDODPDHVWUDSDUDLQGLFDUOHTXHKDEOHFRUUHFWDPHQWH$VtPLVPR VX OLPLWDGD DSRUWDFLyQ TXH YHUVD VREUH OD SRVLELOLGDG GH OD SUiFWLFD GH ODV DFWLYLGDGHV DFXiWLFDV GH XQD SHUVRQD DPSXWDGD GH XQ EUD]R TXH REVHUYy HQ XQD LQVWDODFLyQ GHSRUWLYD/RTXHFRQVWDWDPRVVXSRFDFDSDFLGDGGHDQiOLVLV &RPHQWDULRVDODVHVLyQ 5 &RQVWDWDPRV TXH 0DUtD WLHQH XQ FRPSRUWDPLHQWR LQIDQWLO TXH QR OH FRUUHVSRQGH D VX HGDGTXHYDGHVGHVXIRUPDGHH[SUHVLyQDVXHVFDVDFDSDFLGDGGHUHIOH[LyQ '(',&,(0%5('( 'H OD KRUD \ PHGLD GH VHVLyQ XQD OD RFXSDQ FRQ HO HQVD\R GH OD REUD GH WHDWUR GH 5 1DYLGDG\ODPHGLDKRUDUHVWDQWHVHREVHUYDHOYLGHRTXHVHUHJLVWUyVREUHODMRUQDGDGH MXHJRVPRWRUHVVHQVLELOL]DGRUHVGHOGtDGHQRYLHPEUH 0LHQWUDV TXH OD PD\RUtD GHO JUXSR VH PRWLYD SRU ODV LPiJHQHV HVWDEOHFLpQGRVH 5 LQWHUDFFLRQHV YHUEDOHV HQWUH ORV FRPSDxHURV REVHUYDPRV TXH 0DUtD QR JHQHUD LQWHUDFFLyQDOJXQD\DODYH]QRODVUHFLEHSRUSDUWHGHORVFRPSDxHURVSUy[LPRVDHOOD &RPHQWDULRVDODVHVLyQ 7DQWRHQHOHVSDFLRGHHQVD\RGHODREUDGHWHDWURGH1DYLGDGFRPRHQODYLVXDOL]DFLyQ GHO YLGHR 0DUtD QR WDQ VyOR QR JHQHUD LQWHUDFFLRQHV FRQ VXV FRPSDxHURV VLQR TXH WDPELpQQRODVUHFLEHSRUSDUWHGHHOORV 5 '(',&,(0%5('( $QWHV GH LQLFLDUVH OD VHVLyQ OD PDHVWUD SUHJXQWD D 0DUtD SRU TXp QR KD YHQLGR FRQ OD EROVDSDUDGXFKDUVHeVWDFRQWHVWDGLFLHQGRTXH³VXKHUPDQDVHKDEtDROYLGDGR´$QWH WDO UHVSXHVWDODPDHVWUDOHREVHUYDTXH OD UHVSRQVDELOLGDG HV VX\D \ TXH QR WLHQHTXH GHSHQGHUGHVXKHUPDQD1RVOODPDODDWHQFLyQVXWRQRGHYR]HVXQWRQRLQIDQWLOTXHQR FRUUHVSRQGHDVXHGDGHLQFOXVRFXDQGRJHVWLFXOD /DSULPHUDWDUHDTXHSURSRQHSDUDLQWURGXFLUODVHVLyQHVODVLJXLHQWH &RUUHUVXDYHPHQWHVLQGHVSOD]DPLHQWR $FRQWLQXDFLyQ &RUUHUDJDFKDUVHVHPLIOH[LRQDUSLHUQDV\GDUXQVDOWRHQYHUWLFDO 'HVSOD]DUVHHQFXDGUXSHGLDGDQGRWUHVSDVRVKDFLDGHODQWHKDFLD DWUiVKDFLDODL]TXLHUGD\KDFLDODGHUHFKD /HYDQWDU ODV SLHUQDV PHGLDQWH OD IXHU]D GH EUD]RV DSR\iQGRVH VREUHODVPDQRV (VWLUDGRVERFDDEDMRUHDOL]DUHOPRYLPLHQWRGHSLHVGHFURO 'HURGLOODVGHMDUVHFDHUVREUHODVPDQRV\SRVWHULRUPHQWHYROYHUDOD VLWXDFLyQLQLFLDO (Q SRVLFLyQ GH DJDFKDGRV VHPLIOH[LyQ GH SLHUQDV LPSXOVDU ODV SLHUQDVKDFLDDWUiV\TXHGDUVHHVWLUDGRVYROYLHQGRDODVLWXDFLyQGH SDUWLGD 0DUtDSDUWLFLSDVLQGLILFXOWDGHQWRGDVODVDFWLYLGDGHVH[FHSWXDQGROD~OWLPDSRUIDOWDGH IXHU]DGHODSLHUQDL]TXLHUGD 3RVWHULRUPHQWH OD PDHVWUD FRPHQWD TXH VH RUJDQLFHQ SRU SDUHMDV SDUD UHDOL]DU ODV VLJXLHQWHVWDUHDV 8QR GH OD SDUHMD WXPEDGR HQ HO VXHOR FRQ ODV SLHUQDV VHPLIOH[LRQDGDV\HOFRPSDxHUROHFRJHSRUORVWRELOORV$ODVHxDO WLHQHTXHUHDOL]DUDEGRPLQDOHV 8QRHQIUHQWHGHRWURFRQODVSLHUQDVVHPLIOH[LRQDGDVHQSRVLFLyQGH DJDFKDGRV $ OD LQGLFDFLyQ WLHQHQ TXH LQWHQWDU GHVHTXLOLEUDU DO FRPSDxHUR LPSXOViQGROH KDFLD DWUiV PHGLDQWH HO WRTXH GH PDQRV SHOHDGHJDOORV ËGHPSHURHQHVWDRFDVLyQHVWDUiQGHSLHVREUHXQDSLHUQD 8QR GHODQWH GH RWUR HO GH DWUiV WLHQH TXH HPSXMDU OD HVSDOGD GHO 5 6(6,Ï11 5 5 5 FRPSDxHURFRQHOREMHWLYRGHKDFHUORDYDQ]DUKDVWDXQDVHxDOeVWH VHUHVLVWHLQWHQWDQGRDVXYH]GHVSOD]DUDVXFRPSDxHURKDFLDDWUiV 6LQRSRVLFLyQHODOXPQRTXHHVWiDGHODQWHWLHQHTXHGHVSOD]DUDVX FRPSDxHUR TXH HVWi FRJLGR SRU OD FLQWXUD GH pVWH FRQ ODV SLHUQDV VHSDUDGDV 0DUtDSDUWLFLSDPX\DFWLYDPHQWHHQWRGDVODVSURSXHVWDV/DDGDSWDFLyQTXHVHSURSRQH HVTXHHQYH]GHSRQHUVHGHSLHHQDTXHOODVDFWLYLGDGHVTXHORUHTXLHUHQVHVLW~HGH URGLOODVGHWDOIRUPDTXHVHSXHGDDSOLFDUODIXHU]DFRQVHJXULGDG 2EVHUYDPRV TXH OD FRPSDxHUD GH MXHJRV HV PX\ FRODERUDWLYD IDFLOLWDQGR ODV PRGLILFDFLRQHV\FRPSDUWLHQGRODVDGDSWDFLRQHV6HKDJHQHUDGRXQDJUDQLQWHUUHODFLyQ HQWUHDPEDV 3DUDFHUUDUODVHVLyQVXJLHUHGRVDFWLYLGDGHVGHUHODMDFLyQ 3RU SDUHMDV XQR WXPEDGR ERFDDUULED \ VX FRPSDxHUR WLHQH TXH PRYLOL]DUOHVXDYHPHQWHXQDSLHUQD 7XPEDGR ERFD DEDMR HO FRPSDxHUR UHDOL]D XQ PDVDMH VXDYH HQ OD HVSDOGD 1RVOODPDODDWHQFLyQODUHVSXHVWDGH0DUtDFXDQGRPHDFHUFRDHOOD\OHLQGLFRTXHVHD PiV VXDYH HQ OD PRYLOL]DFLyQ GH OD SLHUQD GH VX FRPSDxHUD 1R DFHSWD OD VXJHUHQFLD UHDFFLRQDQGR FRQ XQ HQIDGR GHVSOD]iQGRVH D XQ ULQFyQ GH OD VDOD FDEL]EDMD \ UHFRJLpQGRVHVREUHVtPLVPD&XDQGRQRVDFHUFDPRVODPDHVWUD\\R\OHFRPHQWDPRV TXHHVDDFWLWXGQRHVFRUUHFWDUHJUHVDGHQXHYRDODDFWLYLGDG &RPHQWDULRVDODVHVLyQ 2EVHUYDPRVTXH0DUtDFRQWLQXDLQIDQWLOL]DQGRVXVH[SUHVLRQHVYHUEDOHVSULQFLSDOPHQWH FDGDYH]TXHWLHQHTXHUHVSRQGHUDODGXOWR (ODQiOLVLVTXHKDFHODPDHVWUDUHVSHFWRDODUHVSXHVWDGHVPHVXUDGDGH0DUtDDQWHPL FRUUHFFLyQHVTXHpVWDQHFHVLWDOODPDUPLDWHQFLyQXWLOL]DQGRHVWHWLSRGHHVWUDWHJLDV 6(6,Ï11 '(',&,(0%5('( 0DUtD KD HQWUDGR D OD VHVLyQ PX\ FRPXQLFDWLYD \ ULVXHxD LQFOXVR OD PDHVWUD OH KD REVHUYDGRTXHHVWDED³PX\GHEURPD´DORTXHKDDVHQWLGRFRQODFDEH]D 6HLQLFLDODVHVLyQFRQHOMXHJRGHORV³SHVFDGRUHV\ORVSHFHV´ 'RVMXJDGRUHVVRQORVTXHSDUDQeVWRVGHIRUPDLQGLYLGXDOWLHQHQTXHWRFDUDFXDOTXLHU RWURFRPSDxHURVLORFRQVLJXHQWLHQHQTXHGDUOHODPDQR\SDVDUDSDUDUGLVHxiQGRVH XQDFDGHQD&XDQGRODFDGHQDHVVXILFLHQWHPHQWHLQWHQWDUiQHQYH]GHWRFDUURGHDUDO 5 5 5 5 5 5 5 5 MXJDGRU TXH SURSRQHQ WRFDU < DVt VXFHVLYDPHQWH KDVWD TXH TXHGH XQ MXJDGRU VLQ VHU WRFDGR*DQDHOHTXLSRTXHFRQVLJDODFDGHQDPiVODUJD /DDGDSWDFLyQTXHSURSRQHPRVSDUD0DUtDHVODVLJXLHQWH &XDQGR HV WRFDGD DO QR SRGHU GDU OD PDQR D VXV FRPSDxHURV GH FDGHQD WLHQH TXH DWUDSDUGHIRUPDLQGLYLGXDODFXDOTXLHUFRPSDxHURGHMXHJRV$OWRFDUOR\DVHDFRQOD PDQRVLHVWiSUy[LPRRFRQODPXOHWDHYLWDQGRJROSHVSDVDDODFDGHQDTXHSHUWHQHFH 0DUtD 2EVHUYDPRVTXHKDWRFDGRDFXDWURMXJDGRUHVGHFDPSRORTXHKDSURYRFDGRXQDJUDQ UHFHSWLYLGDGSRUSDUWHGHVXVFRPSDxHURVGHFDGHQD&UHHPRVTXHFRQHVWDDGDSWDFLyQ VHKDVHQWLGRPX\~WLOSRUORVFRPHQWDULRVTXHKDKHFKRDODPDHVWUD³KHSLOODGRD´ $FRQWLQXDFLyQODPDHVWUDSURSRQHGLYHUVDVWDUHDVFRQHVWUXFWXUDVLPLODU 'LVWULEX\H OD FODVH HQ JUXSRV GH FXDWUR 'RV HVWiQ HQ XQ H[WUHPR GHO JLPQDVLR\ORVRWURVGRVIUHQWHDHOORVHQDPEDVVLWXDFLRQHVXQRGHODQWH GHORWUR$ODVHxDOGHIRUPDLQGLYLGXDOWLHQHQTXHWUDVODGDUXQDSHORWD GH SLQJSRQJ DO RWUR H[WUHPR GHO FDPSR VRSODQGR \ UHSWDQGR ERFD DEDMR $Vt DOWHUQDWLYDPHQWH KDVWD TXH SDVDQ YLDULDV YHFHV WRGRV ORV MXJDGRUHV ËGHPSHURFRQGXFLHQGRXQDSHORWDGHHVSXPDFRQODIUHQWH 6HQWDGRVFRQODVSLHUQDVVHSDUDGDVODQ]DUODSHORWDDORWURH[WUHPRGHO FDPSRLQWHQWDQGRTXHUXHGHVREUHODVOtQHDV ËGHPGHURGLOODV ËGHP GH SLH ODQ]DQGR FRQ OD PDQR GHUHFKD \ D FRQWLQXDFLyQ FRQ OD L]TXLHUGD ËGHPODQ]DQGRHOEDOyQFRQHOSLHGHUHFKR\OXHJRFRQHOL]TXLHUGR /DV GRV ~OWLPDV DFWLYLGDGHV 0DUtD ODV KD HMHFXWDGR GHVGH OD SRVLFLyQ GH DUURGLOODGD &RPR HV PiV KDELOLGRVD FRQ OD SLHUQD L]TXLHUGD LQWHQWD KDFHU WRGRV ORV ODQ]DPLHQWRV FRQpVWD/DPDHVWUDODDQLPDDTXHWUDEDMHFRQHOVHJPHQWRPHQRVGRPLQDQWHSRUTXH GHQRVHUDVtQRDYDQ]DUiHQVXDSUHQGL]DMH 6LJXLHQGRODGLQiPLFDKDELWXDODSHQDVHVWDEOHFHFRQWDFWRFRQVXVFRPSDxHURVHLQFOXVR VHPXHVWUDGHVDILDQWHFRQVXSDUHMDHQORVODQ]DPLHQWRVGHEDOyQFRQODPDQR(QPiV GHXQDRFDVLyQQROHIDFLOLWDODUHFHSFLyQGHEDOyQVLWXiQGRVHHQOtQHDGHWLUR$HOORKD\ TXHDxDGLUVXIDOWDGHUHVSHWRFXDQGRODQ]DFRQODSLHUQDQRGRPLQDQWHORTXHSURYRFD GHVFRQWUROHQHOODQ]DPLHQWR/DPDHVWUDKDWHQLGRTXHOODPDUOHODDWHQFLyQFRPHQWDQGR TXHQRHVMXVWRVXFRPSRUWDPLHQWR\FDPELDODFRPSDxHUDGHMXHJRVSRUXQDGHFDUiFWHU PiVIXHUWH 6HILQDOL]DODVHVLyQFRQHOMXHJRGHODSDVWRUD (OJUXSRGLVSHUVRSRUHOHVSDFLR\XQMXJDGRUFRQXQEDOyQGHHVSXPDeVWHSXHGHRSWDU HQ FXDQWR OR SRVHH SRU JULWDU ³SLHV TXLHWRV´ \ SRU WDQWR VXV FRPSDxHURV WLHQHQ TXH TXHGDUVH HVWiWLFRV HQ HO SXQWR GHO HVSDFLR GRQGH VH HQFXHQWUDQ \ D FRQWLQXDFLyQ 5 5 5 5 5 5 LQWHQWDU WRFDU D XQ FRPSDxHUR ODQ]DQGR HO EDOyQ LPSDFWDQGR FXDOTXLHU SDUWH FRUSRUDO H[FHSWXDQGRODFDUD\FD\HQGRHOEDOyQDOVXHOR2ELHQWLHQHODSRVLELOLGDGGHGDUWUHV SDVRVFRQHOEDOyQHQODPDQRFRQHOREMHWLYRGHDSUR[LPDUVHDVXVFRPSDxHURV\GHFLU ³SLHVTXLHWRV´(QHOPRPHQWRTXHXQMXJDGRUHVWRFDGRSDVDDOD]RQDGHHOLPLQDGRV\ WDQVyORSXHGHVDOYDUVHFXDQGRLPSDFWDQDOMXJDGRUTXHORKDHOLPLQDGR /DDGDSWDFLyQSDUD0DUtDHVTXHFXDQGRFRQVLJXHHOEDOyQVHJULWD³SLHVTXLHWRV´\WLHQH DGHPiV OD SRVLELOLGDG GH GDU ORV WUHV SDVRV FRQ HO EDOyQ HVWDQGR VXV FRPSDxHURV HVWiWLFRV (OOD GHFLGH VL LQWHQWD WRFDU D VXV FRPSDxHURV FKXWiQGROR FRQ ORV SLHV R ODQ]iQGRORFRQODPDQR /D SULPHUD UHDFFLyQ GH 0DUtD HV OD GH DUURGLOODUVH SRUTXH VLHPSUH KD MXJDGR GH HVD PDQHUD\SXHGHODQ]DUFRQODPDQR&XDQGRODPDHVWUDOHUHFXHUGDTXHWLHQHTXHMXJDU GH SLH VH PXHVWUD GHVFRQWHQWD 1R REVWDQWH SDUWLFLSD FRQ OD DGDSWDFLyQ VXJHULGD 2EVHUYDPRVTXHHQVHJXLGDODHOLPLQDQSRUORTXHHQRWUDVRFDVLRQHVOHFRQFHGHUHPRV GRVYLGDVSDUDSURORQJDUVXSHUPDQHQFLDHQHOFDPSR &RPHQWDULRVDODVHVLyQ 5HVXOWDPX\VLJQLILFDWLYRVXIDOWDGHUHVSHWRDODFRPSDxHUDGHMXHJRVTXHQRSUHVHQWD KDELOLGDG FRQ HO VHJPHQWR L]TXLHUGR \ TXH DGHPiV WLHQH XQ FDUiFWHU GpELO 1RV SUHJXQWDPRV ¢FyPR 0DUtD WLHQH WDQ SRFD HPSDWtD KDFLD ODV SHUVRQDV TXH SUHVHQWDQ GLILFXOWDGHV" (QHO~OWLPRMXHJRKHPRVRSWDGRSRUODDGDSWDFLyQGHMXJDUGHSLHDSHVDUGHTXH0DUtD VHVLHQWHPiVFyPRGDMXJDQGRGHVGHODSRVLFLyQGHURGLOODV3HURGDGRTXHHVXQMXHJR SRSXODUHQORVHVSDFLRVGHSDWLRKHPRVFRQVLGHUDGRTXHVtWDQWRHOODFRPRHOUHVWRGHO JUXSRFODVHDFHSWDQODVDGDSWDFLRQHVSXHGHVHUXQPRWLYRIDFLOLWDGRUGHODLQWHUDFFLyQGH pVWDFRQVXVFRPSDxHURVHQWLHPSROLEUH 6(6,Ï11 '((1(52'( /DSULPHUDMRUQDGDGHOVHJXQGRWULPHVWUHVHLPSDUWHHQODSLVWDSROLGHSRUWLYDGHVFXELHUWD GHOFHQWUR&RPRHVKDELWXDOORVQLxRV\ODVQLxDVVDOHQGHOJLPQDVLRSHURSUHYLDPHQWH ODPDHVWUDOHVLQWURGXFHJOREDOPHQWHHQODVWDUHDVDHMHFXWDU /DSULPHUDSURSXHVWDHV³ODFDUUHUDGHOQ~PHUR´ *UXSRVGHFLQFRHQILODLQGLD\GHWUiVGHXQDOtQHD/RVMXJDGRUHVVHHQXPHUDQGHOXQR DOFLQFRHQIXQFLyQGHORUGHQTXHRFXSDQHQODILOD&XDQGRODPDHVWUDGLFHXQQ~PHUR ORV MXJDGRUHV D TXH OHV FRUUHVSRQGD VDOHQ FRUULHQGR KDVWD WRFDU RWUD OtQHD GHO FDPSR VLWXDGDDXQRVTXLQFHPHWURVWHQLHQGRTXHUHJUHVDUDOSXQWRGHVDOLGD*DQDHOMXJDGRU TXHOOHJXHDQWHVDVXJUXSR 5 5 5 5 5 (Q HVWD RFDVLyQ OD DGDSWDFLyQ SURSXHVWD SDUD 0DUtD HV OD GH UHGXFLU GRV WHUFLRV VX UHFRUULGRFRPSHQViQGRVHVXOHQWLWXG2EVHUYDPRVTXHODPRGLILFDFLyQHVHTXLOLEUDGDGH WDO IRUPD TXH VX SDUWLFLSDFLyQ HV PX\ DFWLYD \ FRPSHWLWLYD FRQVLJXLHQGR HQ GRV RFDVLRQHVOOHJDUODSULPHUD\EDMRODDQLPDFLyQFRQWLQXDGHVXVFRPSDxHURV$VtPLVPR 0DUtD DQLPDDOUHVWRGHFRPSDxHURVSDUD TXH OOHJXHQ ORV SULPHURV OR TXH PRWLYDTXH VHDQ QXPHURVDV ODV RFDVLRQHV HQ ODV TXH VH LQWHUUHODFLRQD FRQ pVWRV HPLWLHQGR FRPHQWDULRV DO UHVSHFWR 3HUFLELPRV HQ VX URVWUR VHxDOHV GH VDWLVIDFFLyQ FXDQGR VH FRQVLJXHHOp[LWR\DVtPLVPRVHxDOHVGHJUDQSUHRFXSDFLyQFXDQGRHVDODLQYHUVD 3RVWHULRUPHQWHOHSURVLJXH³ODFDUUHUDGHORVDURV´ /D PLVPD GLVSRVLFLyQ TXH HQ HO MXHJR DQWHULRU $ OD VHxDO VDOH FRUULHQGR HO SULPHU MXJDGRUFRQFLQFRDURVHQODPDQR\KDGHVLWXDUORVHQHOVXHORDXQDGLVWDQFLDHQWUHDUR \DURGHXQRVGRVPHWURVSUHYLDLQGLFDFLyQGHODPDHVWUDFRQWLQXDQGRHOUHFRUULGRKDVWD SLVDU XQD OtQHD GHO FDPSR VLWXDGD D XQRV TXLQFH PHWURV GHVGH OD OtQHD GH VDOLGD $ OD YXHOWD UHFRJH ORV DURV \ ORV SDVD DO FRPSDxHUR GH ILOD \ DVt VXFHVLYDPHQWH *DQD HO HTXLSRTXHDFDEHSULPHUR 'DGDV ODV GLILFXOWDGHV GH 0DUtD SDUD WUDVODGDU ORV DURV VH RSWD SRU OD UHDOL]DFLyQ GH FDUUHUDOLQHDOKDVWDODPLWDGGHOUHFRUULGRDOOOHJDUDOOtWLHQHTXHJLUDU\UHJUHVDUGHQXHYR DODVHxDOGHVDOLGD'HHVWDPDQHUDVHFRQVLJXHXQDFRPSHQVDFLyQHTXLOLEUDGDFRQHO UHVWRGHFRQWULQFDQWHV1RREVWDQWHODPDHVWUDDXPHQWDODYHQWDMDUHGXFLHQGRHOQ~PHUR GH FRPSRQHQWHV GHO JUXSR D FXDWUR OR TXH SURYRFD JUDQ DFHSWDFLyQ SRU SDUWH GH VXV FRPSDxHURVGHJUXSR\HQFDPELRGHVDFXHUGRSRUSDUWHGHOUHVWRFXDQGRHQPiVGHXQD RFDVLyQVRQORVSULPHURVHVFXFKiQGRVHIUDVHVFRPR³\DOHVYDOHWDQVyORVRQFXDWUR´ &XDQGROHSUHJXQWRDODPDHVWUDSRUTXHGHMDWDQWDYHQWDMDPHUHVSRQGHTXHORSODQWHD FRPRHVWUDWHJLDSDUDTXHORVFRPSRQHQWHVGHOJUXSRGH0DUtDODDFHSWHQVLQSUREOHPDV SULQFLSDOPHQWHSHQVDQGRHQXQRGHHOORVTXHHVPX\FRPSHWLWLYR $FRQWLQXDFLyQSURSRQHXQDYDULDQWHGHOMXHJRDQWHULRU /RVQLxRVHQHOLQWHULRUGHORVFLQFRDURVVRVWHQLGRVDODDOWXUDGHODFLQWXUDDODVHxDO FRUUHQVXMHWDQGRORVDURVGHWDOIRUPDTXHWLHQHQTXHIOH[LRQDUVHSDUDLUFRORFiQGRORVHQ HOVXHOR$OUHJUHVRWLHQHQTXHLUUHFRJLHQGRORVDURVGHOVXHOR\VLWXDUVHGHQWURGHHOORVD LPDJHQGHOLQLFLR (QHVWDRFDVLyQODPDHVWUDGHFLGHODPLVPDDGDSWDFLyQTXHHQHOMXHJRDQWHULRUORTXH SURYRFDSURWHVWDSRUSDUWHGH0DUtDSRUTXHORFRQVLGHUDPX\IiFLO$QWHWDOUHDFFLyQHQ OD VHJXQGD UHSHWLFLyQ OD PDHVWUD DxDGH GRV IOH[LRQHV GH SLHUQDV HQ GRV SXQWRV GHO UHFRUULGRWDQWRHQODLGDFRPRHQODYXHOWDFRPSHQVDQGRODVSDUDGDVGHVXVDGYHUVDULRV FDGD YH] TXH GHMDQ R UHFRJHQ XQ DUR GHO VXHOR /D UHDFFLyQ GH 0DUtD HV GLVWLQWD VH FRQWUDUtDDQWHODGLILFXOWDGSHURUHDFFLRQDGLFLHQGR³HVV~SHUIiFLO´ /DFXDUWDSURSXHVWDHVODGHO³UHOHYRHQFDUUHUD´ /DPLVPDGLVSRVLFLyQTXHHQORVMXHJRVDQWHULRUHV$ODVHxDOVDOHHOSULPHURGHFDGDILOD FRQ XQ WHVWLJR HQ OD PDQR KDVWD DOFDQ]DU RWUD OtQHD VLWXDGD D XQRV TXLQFH PHWURV 5 5 5 5 5 5 UHJUHVDQGRGHQXHYRDOSXQWRGHSDUWLGDSDVDQGRHOWHVWLJRDOFRPSDxHURTXHOHVLJXH $Vt VXFHVLYDPHQWH KDVWD TXH SDVDQWRGRV ORV FRPSRQHQWHV GHO JUXSR *DQD HO HTXLSR TXHOOHJXHHOSULPHUR /D DGDSWDFLyQ TXH SURSRQHPRV SDUD 0DUtD HV OD PLVPD TXH HQ HO SULPHU MXHJR GH OD VHVLyQGHKR\UHGXFLHQGRGRVWHUFLRVGHUHFRUULGR /DTXLQWDSURSXHVWDHVOD³FDUUHUDHQ]LJ]DJHQWUHFRQRV´ ËGHP GLVSRVLFLyQ&LQFRFRQRVSRUJUXSR D XQRV WUHV PHWURV GH ODOtQHDGHVDOLGD\D XQDGLVWDQFLDHQWUHFRQR\FRQRGHXQPHWUR\PHGLR$ODVHxDOVDOHHOSULPHURGHODILOD \FXDQGROOHJDDORVFRQRVFRUUHHQ]LJ]DJKDVWDOOHJDUDO~OWLPRFRQWLQXDHOUHFRUULGR KDVWDOOHJDUDXQDOtQHDTXHHVWiDXQRVGLH]PHWURVUHJUHVDQGRGHQXHYRDOSXQWRGH VDOLGD SDVDQGR SUHYLDPHQWH HQ ]LJ]DJ HQWUH ORV FRQRV SRVWHULRUPHQWH VDOH VX FRPSDxHURPiVSUy[LPR\DVtVXFHVLYDPHQWHKDVWDTXHKD\DQSDVDGRWUHVYHFHVFDGD MXJDGRU(OHTXLSRTXHOOHJDSULPHURHVHOTXHJDQD /D DGDSWDFLyQ SDUD 0DUtD HV OD GH UHGXFLU HO HVSDFLR GH UHFRUULGR D XQ FLQFXHQWD SRU FLHQWRSHURVLQREYLDUORVGHVSOD]DPLHQWRVHQ]LJ]DJHQWUHFRQR\FRQRWDQWRHQODLGD FRPRHQODYXHOWD /DVH[WDSURSXHVWDHVOD³FDUUHUDGHSLFDV´ /D FODVH VH GLYLGH HQ GRV JUXSRV FRORFDGRV HQ XQD HVTXLQD GHO UHFWiQJXOR TXH FRQIRUPDQODVOtQHDVH[WHULRUHVGHOSDWLR$PERVVHORFDOL]DQHQGLDJRQDO(QORVRWURV GRVH[WUHPRVWDQWDVSLFDVFRPRMXJDGRUHVSRUHTXLSR$ODVHxDOVDOHHOSULPHURGHFDGD JUXSRVHGLULJHDODHVTXLQDTXHWLHQHGHODQWH\UHFRJHXQDSLFDGHOVXHOR\FRUUHUiFRQ HOODKDVWDGHMDUODHQODHVTXLQDFRQWUDULDUHJUHVDQGRGHQXHYRDVXILOD&XDQGRVHFRJH XQDSLFD\DVDOHHOVLJXLHQWHMXJDGRUGHOHTXLSR*DQDHOHTXLSRTXHOOHJXHDQWHVDVX HVTXLQD (Q HVWD RFDVLyQ D 0DUtD OH KHPRV UHGXFLGR HO UHFRUULGR D XQ FLQFXHQWD SRU FLHQWR VXVWLWX\HQGRODSLFDSRUWHVWLJRSDUDTXHORSXHGDWUDVODGDU +HPRV SHUFLELGR TXH KD VLGR HQ HVWD DFWLYLGDG GRQGH PHQRV LQWHUUHODFLRQHV KD HVWDEOHFLGRFRQVXVFRPSDxHURVQRPRVWUDQGRQLQJXQDLQLFLDWLYD\QRUHFLELHQGRQLQJ~Q FRPHQWDULR $FRQWLQXDFLyQODPDHVWUDSURSRQHSDUDILQDOL]DUODVHVLyQHO³MXHJRGHODSDVWRUD´\SDUD HOOR VH GHVSOD]DQ DO JLPQDVLR 2EVHUYDPRV TXH 0DUtD HV OD ~OWLPD HQ VDOLU GHO SDWLR SROLGHSRUWLYR\TXHQRVHLQWHUUHODFLRQDFRQQDGLH (OJUXSRGLVSHUVRSRUHOHVSDFLR\XQMXJDGRUFRQXQEDOyQGHHVSXPDeVWHSXHGHRSWDU HQ FXDQWR OR SRVHH SRU JULWDU ³SLHV TXLHWRV´ \ SRU WDQWR VXV FRPSDxHURV WLHQHQ TXH TXHGDUVH HVWiWLFRV HQ HO SXQWR GHO HVSDFLR GRQGH VH HQFXHQWUDQ \ D FRQWLQXDFLyQ LQWHQWDU WRFDU D XQ FRPSDxHUR ODQ]DQGR HO EDOyQ LPSDFWDQGR FXDOTXLHU SDUWH FRUSRUDO H[FHSWXDQGRODFDUD\FD\HQGRHOEDOyQDOVXHOR2ELHQWLHQHODSRVLELOLGDGGHGDUWUHV SDVRVFRQHOEDOyQHQODPDQRFRQHOREMHWLYRGHDSUR[LPDUVHDVXVFRPSDxHURV\GHFLU 5 5 5 5 5 5 5 5 ³SLHVTXLHWRV´(QHOPRPHQWRTXHXQMXJDGRUHVWRFDGRSDVDDOD]RQDGHHOLPLQDGRV\ WDQVyORSXHGHVDOYDUVHFXDQGRLPSDFWDQDOMXJDGRUTXHORKDHOLPLQDGR /DDGDSWDFLyQSDUD0DUtDHVVLPLODUDODVHVLyQDQWHULRUHQTXHVHSUDFWLFyHVWHMXHJR FXDQGRFRQVLJXHHOEDOyQVHJULWD³SLHVTXLHWRV´\WLHQHDGHPiVODSRVLELOLGDGGHGDUORV WUHVSDVRVFRQHOEDOyQHVWDQGRVXVFRPSDxHURVHVWiWLFRV(OODGHFLGHVLLQWHQWDWRFDUD VXV FRPSDxHURV FKXWiQGROR FRQ ORV SLHV R ODQ]iQGROR FRQ OD PDQR $GHPiV OH FRQFHGHPRVWUHVYLGDVWUHVSRVLELOLGDGHVSDUDSURORQJDUVXSHUPDQHQFLDHQHOMXHJRODV FXDOHVSXHGHUHFXSHUDUHQFDVRGHDJRWDUXQDRGRVHQHOPRPHQWRTXHHOLPLQDDXQ FRPSDxHUR 0DUtD VH PXHVWUD PX\ PRWLYDGD SRU OD SURSXHVWD GH DGDSWDFLyQ D LPDJHQ GH VXV FRPSDxHURVLQFOXVRXQSDUGHHOORVSLGHQXQDDFODUDFLyQUHVSHFWRDODVPRGLILFDFLRQHV &XDQGRWLHQHODRSFLyQGHLPSDFWDUDXQFRPSDxHURGHFLGHODQ]DUHOEDOyQFRQODPDQR +DVLGRFXULRVDODUHVSXHVWDGHXQFRPSDxHURHOFXDODOHVWDUDXQPHWURGHGLVWDQFLD GH 0DUtD OH KD LPSDFWDGR FRQ HO EDOyQ WUHV YHFHV VHJXLGDV (OOD VH GHPXHVWUD PX\ GHVFRQWHQWDSRUVXDFWLWXG\VHGLULJHDXQDHVTXLQDGHOD]RQDGHHOLPLQDGRVDGLVWDQFLD GH XQRV VLHWH PHWURV GHO UHVWR KDVWD TXH XQD FRPSDxHUD OD OODPD SDUD TXH VH VLHQWH MXQWR D HOODFRQHOILQGHDQLPDUFRQMXQWDPHQWH D ORV MXJDGRUHV GH VX HTXLSRSDUDTXH HOLPLQHQ DO PLVPR MXJDGRU TXH OHV KD LPSDFWDGR FRQ HO EDOyQ 'DGR OR DFRQWHFLGR GHFLGLPRVTXHXQPLVPRMXJDGRUQRSXHGHLPSDFWDUFRQHOEDOyQGRVYHFHVVHJXLGDVD 0DUtDORFXDOHVDFHSWDGRSRUWRGRV (OMXHJRFRQWLQXDKDVWDTXHOOHJDHOHVSDFLRGHODGXFKD(VHQHVHPRPHQWRFXDQGRORV QLxRVTXHMXVWLILFDQTXHQRWLHQHQTXHGXFKDUVHSRUTXHUHDOL]DQDFWLYLGDGHVGHSRUWLYDV H[WUDHVFRODUHV MXHJDQ OLEUHPHQWH (QWUH HOORV HVWi 0DUtD GDGR TXH HQOD]D FRQ ODV DFWLYLGDGHV GH UHKDELOLWDFLyQ 2EVHUYDPRV TXH GHFLGHQ FRQWLQXDU FRQ HO MXHJR GH ³OD SDVWRUD´ /D SULPHUD UHDFFLyQ GH pVWD HV OD GH GHMDU ODV PXOHWDV \ MXJDU DUURGLOODGD UHIXJLiQGRVH FRQVWDQWHPHQWH GHWUiV GH ODV FROXPQDV SDUD HYLWDU TXH OD LPSDFWHQ D SHVDU GH ODV REVHUYDFLRQHV GH OD PDHVWUD &RQVLJXH HQ GRV RFDVLRQHV PDWDU D GRV OtGHUHV OR TXH SURYRFD OD IXULD GH pVWRV GH WDO PDQHUD TXH FXDQGR HVWiQ HOLPLQDGRV DQLPDQFRQVWDQWHPHQWHDORVFRPSDxHURVGHFDPSRSDUDTXHLPSDFWHQFRQHOEDOyQD 0DUtD &RPHQWDULRVDODVHVLyQ &RLQFLGLPRV HQ OD REVHUYDFLyQ HQ TXH HV OD VHVLyQ HQ TXH PiV VH KD LQWHUUHODFLRQDGR FRQ ORV FRPSDxHURV LQLFLDQGR FRQYHUVDFLRQHV FRQ HOORV 6X SDUWLFLSDFLyQ KD VLGR FRQVWDQWHPHQWHDFWLYDGHPRVWUDQGRJUDQLQWHUpVSRUODHYROXFLyQGHORVMXHJRV &RQVLGHUDPRVPX\SRVLWLYDODUHDFFLyQGHORVGRVOtGHUHVTXHKDHOLPLQDGRHQHOWLHPSR GHMXHJROLEUHSRUTXHKDVWDODIHFKDHQMXHJRVGHHVWDVFDUDFWHUtVWLFDVVHODLJQRUDED\D SHVDUGHTXHGHVHDEDQVXHOLPLQDFLyQFUHHPRVTXHHVXQDIRUPDGHWHQHUODHQFXHQWD HQWUDQGRHQODGLQiPLFDKDELWXDOGHLQWHUUHODFLyQJHQHUDGDSRUORVMXHJRV 7DPELpQYDORUDPRVPX\SRVLWLYDODDFHSWDFLyQGHODVDGDSWDFLRQHVWDQWRGH0DUtDFRPR GHOUHVWRGHOJUXSR 5 5 5 5 5 5 6(6,Ï11 '((1(52'( 3DUDLQLFLDUODVHVLyQODPDHVWUDSURSRQHHOMXHJRGH³ODFDGHQD´FRQWUHVMXJDGRUHV 7UHVMXJDGRUHVVRQORVTXHSDUDQeVWRVGHIRUPDLQGLYLGXDOWLHQHQTXHWRFDUDFXDOTXLHU RWURFRPSDxHURVtORFRQVLJXHQWLHQHQTXHGDUOHODPDQR\SDVDUDSDUDUIRUPiQGRVH XQD FDGHQD 7DQ VyOR SXHGHQ WRFDU ORV MXJDGRUHV TXH HVWiQ HQ HO H[WUHPR *DQD HO HTXLSRTXHFRQVLJDODFDGHQDPiVODUJD 1RV SURSRQHPRV SRQHU D SUXHED D 0DUtD QR UHFRUGDQGR VX DGDSWDFLyQ 3HQVDPRV D SULRUL TXH HQ VLWXDFLRQHV VLPLODUHV HOOD WLHQH TXH VHU OR VXILFLHQWHPHQWH DXWyQRPD SDUD VROLFLWDUOD /DUHDFFLyQGH0DUtDHVODGHGHVSOD]DUVHSUy[LPDDQRVRWUDVTXHHVWDPRVORFDOL]DGDV HQ XQ ODWHUDO H[WUHPR GHO JLPQDVLR HQ IRUPD OLQHDO KDFLHQGR UHFRUULGRV GH XQRV WUHV PHWURVGHLGD\YXHOWDSDVDGRVGRVPLQXWRVpVWDVHDFHUFDD~QPiVDODPDHVWUDSDUD TXHMDUVH³SRUTXHVXVFRPSDxHURVQRODWRFDQ´ (QHVHLQVWDQWHODPDHVWUDUH~QHDOJUXSRODFODVHSDUDUHFRUGDUODDGDSWDFLyQGH0DUtD VLPLODUDODUHDOL]DGDHQHOMXHJRGH³ORVSHVFDGRUHV\ORVSHFHV´GHODVHVLyQQ~PHUR &XDQGR HV WRFDGD DO QR SRGHU GDU OD PDQR D VXV FRPSDxHURV GH FDGHQD WLHQH TXH DWUDSDUGHIRUPDLQGLYLGXDODFXDOTXLHUFRPSDxHURGHMXHJRV$OWRFDUOR\DVHDFRQOD PDQRVLHVWiSUy[LPRRFRQODPXOHWDHYLWDQGRJROSHVSDVDDODFDGHQDTXHSHUWHQHFH 0DUtD 3RVWHULRUPHQWHSURSRQHXQDYDULDQWHGHOMXHJR &XDQGRVHFRQVLJXHXQDFDGHQDGHFLQFRMXJDGRUHVORVFXDWURSULPHURVVHOLEHUDQ\HO ~OWLPR WLHQHTXHFRQVHJXLUWRFDUDRWURVFXDWURMXJDGRUHV\DVtVXFHVLYDPHQWHKDVWDOD VHxDOGHODPDHVWUD 2EVHUYDPRV D SHVDU GH OD DGDSWDFLyQ D XQD 0DUtD SDVLYD GHVSOD]iQGRVH SRU ORV ODWHUDOHV GHO FDPSR \ PX\ SUy[LPD D OD PDHVWUD GH WDO IRUPD TXH FXDQGR pVWD KD LQGLFDGRHOILQDOGHOMXHJR0DUtDQRKDVLGRWRFDGD (OVHJXQGRMXHJRHVHOGHO³JXVDQR´ /DPLVPDRUJDQL]DFLyQ\GLQiPLFDTXHHOSULPHUMXHJRSHURFRQODPRGLILFDFLyQGHTXH WRGRVVHGHVSOD]DQDQGDQGR\TXHFXDQGRVRQWRFDGRVVHWLHQHQTXHFRJHUSRUODFLQWXUD FRQIRUPDQGRXQDILODLQGLD 5 5 5 5 5 /DHVWUDWHJLDTXHKDSURSXHVWRODPDHVWUDHVTXH0DUtDVHDXQDGHORVWUHVMXJDGRUHV TXH SDUDQ \D TXH GH QR DVXPLU HO SULPHU OXJDU WHQGUtD VHULDV GLILFXOWDGHV SDUD GHVSOD]DUVHFRQODVPXOHWDV\WHQHUTXHFRJHUDVXFRPSDxHURSRUODFLQWXUD 1RVOODPDODDWHQFLyQTXHHQYDULDVRFDVLRQHVGHMDSDVDUDGRVFRPSDxHURVTXHVHJ~Q OD PDHVWUD ³QR OH KDFHQ JUDFLD´ &RPR WDQ VyOR WRFD D FXDWUR MXJDGRUHV OD PDHVWUD OH FRPHQWD HQ OD VLJXLHQWH UHSHWLFLyQ GHO MXHJR TXH WLHQH TXH SDUDU GH QXHYR ³SRUTXH VH WLHQHTXHHVIRU]DU´<GHHVWDPDQHUDSURWDJRQL]DGHQXHYRHOMXHJRLQWHQWDQGRWRFDUD WRGRV ORV MXJDGRUHV SUy[LPRV D HOOD SHUR GDGD OD UHDFFLyQ GHO SULPHUR TXH WRFD QR TXHUtD UHFRQRFHU TXH 0DUtD OH KDEtD WRFDGR DEDQGRQDQGR OD ]RQD GHO MXHJR \ PRVWUiQGRVH PX\ HQIDGDGR KDVWD TXH QR LQWHUYLHQH OD PDHVWUD SURYRFD SDVLYLGDG HQ 0DUtDUHFXSHUDQGRSRVWHULRUPHQWHODDFWLYLGDGXQDYH]UHVXHOWRHOFRQIOLFWR$SHVDUGH HOORKDFRQVHJXLGRWRFDUDFLQFRMXJDGRUHV2EVHUYDPRVTXHHOFRPSRUWDPLHQWRGHOUHVWR GH FRPSDxHURV TXH KD WRFDGR HQ ODV GRV UHSHWLFLRQHV KD VLGR FRUUHFWR VLQ SHUFLELUVH QLQJ~QUHFKD]RKDFLDpVWD (OWHUFHUMXHJRHV³ODFD]DGHODGYHUVDULR´ (O JUXSR GLVWULEXLGR OLEUHPHQWH SRU HO HVSDFLR \ VHLV DOXPQRV FRQ XQ DUR JUDQGH (O REMHWLYRGHpVWRVHVHOGHSHUVHJXLUDFXDOTXLHUFRPSDxHURLQWHQWDQGRLQWURGXFLUOHHQHO DURHYLWDQGRODQ]DUOR6tORFRQVLJXHQVHFDPELDQORVUROHV $LPDJHQGHOMXHJRDQWHULRUODPDHVWUDSURSRQHTXHXQRGHORVVHLVMXJDGRUHVTXHLQLFLDQ HOMXHJRVHD0DUtD/DDGDSWDFLyQTXHSURSRQHPRVHVTXHHQYH]GHLQWURGXFLUHODURHQ XQMXJDGRUORTXHWLHQHTXHKDFHUHVWRFDUORFRQHODUR (Q XQ SULQFLSLR DFW~D SDVLYDPHQWH SHUR D PHGLGD TXH HYROXFLRQD HO MXHJR VH YD PRWLYDQGR OOHJDQGR D WRFDU D WUHV MXJDGRUHV HQWUH HOORV XQR TXH FRPR KD GLFKR OD PDHVWUD DQWHULRUPHQWH ³QR OH FDH HQ JUDFLD´ $ OD YH] KD VLGR DWUDSDGD WUHV YHFHV JHQHUiQGRVHLQWHUDFFLRQHVYHUEDOHVPX\SRVLWLYDVFRQVXVFRPSDxHURV\REVHUYDQGRD XQD0DUtDPiVULVXHxD 3DUDILQDOL]DUVHFLHUUDFRQHOMXHJRGH³ORVUHOHYRVGHFDQJXURV´ *UXSRV GH FLQFR GHWUiV GH XQD OtQHD GHO H[WUHPR GHO FDPSR $ OD VHxDO VDOHQ ORV SULPHURV GH FDGD JUXSR FRQ XQD SHORWD GH HVSXPD HQWUH ORV WRELOORV VDOWDQGR D SLHV MXQWRVVLQSHUGHUOD(QFDVRGHTXHFDLJDWLHQHQTXHFRQWLQXDUGHVGHHOOXJDUGHOHVSDFLR GRQGHKDFDtGR&XDQGROOHJDQDORWURH[WUHPRGHOFDPSRJLUDQ\WLHQHQTXHUHJUHVDUD ODOtQHDGHVDOLGDSDVDQGRHOEDOyQDOVLJXLHQWHMXJDGRU*DQDHOHTXLSRTXHOOHJXHDQWHV /DDGDSWDFLyQTXHSURSRQHPRVSDUD0DUtDHVODGHUHGXFLUVXUHFRUULGRHQXQFLQFXHQWD SRUFLHQWRORFXDOHVDFHSWDGRSRUWRGRVVLQREMHFLyQDOJXQD2EVHUYDPRVHQODSULPHUD UHSHWLFLyQTXHpVWDSDUWLFLSDPX\DFWLYDPHQWHODSHUFLELPRVPX\FRPSHWLWLYDDQLPDQGR D VXV FRPSDxHURV GH JUXSR \ HVWDEOHFLHQGR LQWHUUHODFLRQHV FRQ ORV PiV SUy[LPRV 3RGHPRV GHFLU TXH HV OD DFWLYLGDG KDVWD HO PRPHQWR TXH KD JHQHUDGR PiV FRPXQLFDFLyQ3HURDSHVDUGHHOORHVHQODVHJXQGDUHSHWLFLyQFXDQGRREVHUYDPRVTXH 0DUtDQRVHPXHVWUDPRWLYDGDSRUODUHFHSFLyQGHOEDOyQGHVSOD]iQGRVHOHQWDPHQWH\ 5 5 5 5 5 5 5 FDEL]EDMD$OILQDOL]DUVXUHFRUULGRVHVLHQWDHQXQULQFyQPLUDQGRGHUHRMRDODPDHVWUD 'HFLGLPRV QR WHQHUOD HQ FXHQWD SHQVDQGR HQ TXH WLHQH TXH DSUHQGHU D UHVROYHU VXV SUREOHPDV FRQ VXV FRPSDxHURV VLQ OD QHFHVLGDG GH UHFODPDU FRQVWDQWHPHQWH OD LQWHUYHQFLyQ GHO DGXOWR 2EVHUYDPRV SRVWHULRUPHQWH TXH XQ FRPSDxHUR GH JUXSR VH VLHQWDDVXODGR\OHKDFHUHtU3HURHQODWHUFHUDUHSHWLFLyQVHQLHJDDSDUWLFLSDUFXDQGR OH SDVDQ HO UHOHYR /DPDHVWUDOHFRPHQWD TXH WLHQH TXH KDFHUOR SRUTXH GH QR VHU DVt SHUMXGLFD D VX JUXSR SHUR pVWD UHDFFLRQD OORUDQGR &XDQGR OD PDHVWUD OH SUHJXQWD SRU TXpOORUD0DUtDOHUHVSRQGHSRUTXHHQODVHJXQGDUHSHWLFLyQOHKDQKHFKRGDxRHQXQSLH FXDQGROHSDVDEDQODSHORWD\TXHHUDSRUHVRSRUORTXHKDWDUGDGRHQFRJHUODSRUORV WRELOORVORTXHKDSURYRFDGRHQIDGRHQVXVFRPSDxHURV$FODUDGDODVLWXDFLyQODPDHVWUD OH UHFXHUGD TXH WLHQH TXH SDUWLFLSDU FRPR ORV GHPiV SHUR HOOD VH QLHJD KD KDFHUOR -XVWDPHQWHHQHVHLQVWDQWHILQDOL]DODVHVLyQSRUTXHGHEHQLUDODGXFKD &RPHQWDULRVDODVHVLyQ 1RVOODPDODDWHQFLyQTXHHQHOSULPHUMXHJR0DUtDQRKDUHFODPDGRVXDGDSWDFLyQWDQ VyORVHKDOLPLWDGRDHPLWLUODTXHMDGHTXHQRODWHQtDQHQFXHQWD 6HJXLPRVREVHUYDQGRTXHDQWHORVFRQIOLFWRVTXHVHJHQHUDQDWUDYpVGHOMXHJR0DUtD SLGHODLQWHUYHQFLyQGHODPDHVWUD\HQQLQJ~QFDVRLQWHQWDVROXFLRQDUORV +HPRVFRQVLGHUDGRTXHODDFWLWXGHQHO~OWLPRMXHJRHVLQFRUUHFWDVREUHWRGRFXDQGRVH KD QHJDGR D SDUWLFLSDU $QDOL]DQGR OD VLWXDFLyQ OD PDHVWUD PH KD FRPHQWDGR TXH PDxDQDKDEODUiFRQ0DUtDSDUDGHFLUOHTXHHOODWLHQHODPLVPDFDSDFLGDGTXHHOUHVWRGH FRPSDxHURV SDUD UHVROYHU ORV SRVLEOHV SUREOHPDV TXH VXUJHQ \ TXH SXHGH VHU WDQ DXWyQRPDFRPRHOORV1RREVWDQWHOHUHFRUGDUiTXHQRSXHGHQHJDUVHDSDUWLFLSDUGHODV DFWLYLGDGHV\GHVHUDVtWRPDUiODVPHGLGDVRSRUWXQDV 6(6,Ï11 '((1(52'( /D PDHVWUD PH FRPHQWD DQWHV GH LQLFLDU OD VHVLyQ OD FRQYHUVDFLyQ TXH KD PDQWHQLGR FRQ 0DUtD HQ OD KRUD GHO SDWLR UHVSHFWR D OR DFRQWHFLGR HQ OD VHVLyQ GHO GtD DQWHULRU ([SUHVD TXH KD LQVLVWLGR HQ TXH HOOD WLHQH OD PLVPD FDSDFLGDG TXH HO UHVWR GH FRPSDxHURV SDUD UHVROYHU ORV SRVLEOHV FRQIOLFWRV TXH VH JHQHUDQ D WUDYpV GHO MXHJR \ TXH QR WLHQH HGDG SDUD GHSHQGHU FRQVWDQWHPHQWH GH OD LQWHUYHQFLyQ GHO DGXOWR SDUD UHVROYHUORV)LQDOL]DODFRQYHUVDFLyQLQVLVWLpQGROHTXHVLHOODHVFDSD]GHHVWDEOHFHUXQ GLiORJRFRQHOORVHQHVDVVLWXDFLRQHV³ODFRQVLGHUDUiQFRPRXQRGHHOORV´ &XDQGROHSUHJXQWRVREUHVtOHKDFRPHQWDGRDOJRUHVSHFWRDODDFWLWXGGHQHJDFLyQD SDUWLFLSDUHQXQDDFWLYLGDGHQODVHVLyQDQWHULRU\ODVSRVLEOHVFRQVHFXHQFLDVHQVHVLRQHV IXWXUDVPHGLFHTXHKDSUHIHULGRGHMDUORSDUDRWUDRFDVLyQGDGRTXHQROHKDSDUHFLGRHO PRPHQWRRSRUWXQRSDUDKDFHUOR $ PHGLGD TXH YDPRV KDEODQGR ORV QLxRV YDQ HQWUDQGR DO JLPQDVLR \ YDQ RFXSDQGR HO OXJDU GHO HVSDFLR TXH WLHQHQ DVLJQDGR 0LHQWUDV TXH WRGRV HVWiQ VHQWDGRV HQ HO VXHOR 5 5 5 5 5 REVHUYDPRV TXH 0DUtD HVWi WXPEDGD ERFD DEDMR FRQ HO DEULJR SXHVWR \ MXJDQGR FRQ XQRV FURPRV TXH OH KD GDGR HVWD PDxDQD XQ FRPSDxHUR GH FODVH $ SHVDU GH TXH OD PDHVWUDHPSLH]DDSDVDUODOLVWDHOODQRKDFHQLQJ~QJHVWRSDUDGHMDUHVDSRVLFLyQ(V SRU OR TXHODPDHVWUDOHOODPDODDWHQFLyQ HQ DOWR GLFLHQGR ³0DUtD PtUDWH \ PLUD D WXV FRPSDxHURV¢HQTXpFUHHVTXHWHGLIHUHQFLDV FRQ HOORV"´ pVWD QR UHDFFLRQD \ QR GLFH QDGDDQWHWDODFWLWXGODPDHVWUDSURVLJXHREVHUYiQGROHORVLJXLHQWH³VLQRHUHVFDSD]GH GHFLUOR OD UHVSXHVWD OD GLUi XQ FRPSDxHUR´ \ HV FXDQGR FRQWHVWD GLFLHQGR ³TXH HVWi WXPEDGD´DORTXHDxDGHODPDHVWUD³\DGHPiVOOHYDVDEULJR\MXHJDVFRQFURPRVSRU WDQWRORSULPHURTXHKDUiVHVVDFDUWHHODEULJR´/DUHDFFLyQGHpVWDHVODGHVDFDUVHHO DEULJRSHURDQWHVGHGHVSOD]DUVHDOYHVWXDULRSHUFLELPRVTXHORVFURPRVVHORVSRQHHQ HOEROVLOORGHOSDQWDOyQGHOFKiQGDOSRUORTXHODPDHVWUDWLHQHGHQXHYRTXHOODPDUOD DWHQFLyQ SDUD TXH ORV GHMH HQ HO EROVLOOR GHO DEULJR 2EVHUYDPRV TXH VH GHVSOD]D DO YHVWXDULRHQURGLOODVSHURORKDFHVLQSURWHVWDU\VLQPDQLIHVWDUHQIDGRDOJXQR &RQWLQ~DODPDHVWUDFRQODOLVWD\SRVWHULRUPHQWHH[SOLFDVLQWpWLFDPHQWHODVDFWLYLGDGHV TXHUHDOL]DUiQHQHOSDWLRH[WHULRU (OSULPHUMXHJRHVGH³YHORFLGDGGHUHDFFLyQ´ 2UJDQL]DODFODVHHQFLQFRJUXSRVGHFXDWURFRPSRQHQWHV&DGDXQRGHHOORVHQILODLQGLD GHWUiV GH XQD OtQHD /D VHSDUDFLyQ HQWUH JUXSR HV GH XQRV GRV PHWURV &XDQGR OD PDHVWUD OR LQGLFD VDOHQ ORV SULPHURV GH FDGD HTXLSR \ pVWRV VH WXPEDQ ERFD DEDMR PDQWHQLHQGRODGLVWDQFLDGHGRVPHWURVGHVHSDUDFLyQDXQRVRFKRPHWURVGHGLVWDQFLD FRQ VX JUXSR \ KDFLHQGR FRLQFLGLU HO DSR\R GH OD EDUELOOD FRQ OD OtQHD GHO FDPSR GH MXHJRV(QWUHpVWRV\ORVJUXSRVVHORFDOL]DHOMXJDGRUFHQWUDOFRQXQEDOyQTXHHVWiSRU WDQWR HQ HO FHQWUR GHO HVSDFLR &XDQGR pVWH OR GHFLGH ODQ]D HO EDOyQ YHUWLFDOPHQWH \ FXDQGR ORV MXJDGRUHV TXH HVWiQ WXPEDGRV HVFXFKDQ HO SULPHU ERWH WLHQHQ TXH OHYDQWDUVHORPiVUiSLGDPHQWHSRVLEOHJLUDU\FRUUHUSDUDFRJHUHOEDOyQDQWHVTXHVXV FRPSDxHUR (O SULPHUR TXH OR FRQVLJD RWRUJD XQ SXQWR SDUD VX HTXLSR FRQVHFXHQWHPHQWHJDQDHOHTXLSRTXHVXPHHOPD\RUQ~PHURGHSXQWRV3RVWHULRUPHQWH VHGHVSOD]DQDOILQDOGHVXJUXSR\HVHOSULPHURGHODILODTXLHQSDVDDWXPEDUVH\DVt VXFHVLYDPHQWHKDVWDTXHSDUWLFLSDQWRGRVORVMXJDGRUHV /DPDHVWUDGHFLGHTXH0DUtDDVXPDHOUROGHMXJDGRUFHQWUDOSRUTXHFRQVLGHUDTXHHQHO PRPHQWRGHDSUR[LPDUVHDODSHORWDDSHVDUGHTXHVHOHKXELHUDUHGXFLGRODGLVWDQFLD GHUHFRUULGRSRGtDQJROSHDUODVLQTXHUHU/RTXHDFHSWDPDQLIHVWDQGRLQWHUpV 'HVSXpVGHODWHUFHUDUHSHWLFLyQORVHTXLSRVVLWXDGRVHQORVH[WUHPRVLQFUHSDQD0DUtD SDUD TXH HO ODQ]DPLHQWR QR VHD YHUWLFDO SRUTXH GH VHU DVt VLHPSUH VRQ ORV MXJDGRUHV FHQWUDOHVORVTXHSXHGHQDFFHGHUFRQPiVIDFLOLGDGDODSHORWD/DUHDFFLyQGH0DUtDKD VLGR PX\ VLJQLILFDWLYD GDGR TXH HQ QLQJ~Q PRPHQWR KD VROLFLWDGR OD LQWHUYHQFLyQ GH OD PDHVWUDLQFOXVRVHKDGDGRODDQpFGRWDGHTXHFXDQGRXQFRPSDxHURVHKDDSUR[LPDGR DODPDHVWUDUHFODPDQGRVXLQWHUYHQFLyQHQHOFRQIOLFWRpVWDOHKDFRPHQWDGRHQDOWRTXH ³QRYLQLHVHDSURWHVWDU´\³TXHORUHVXHOYDFRQ0DUtD´$OILQDO0DUtDGHFLGHODQ]DUHOEDOyQ D PiV GLVWDQFLD VREUHSDVDQGR D ORV MXJDGRUHV TXH HVWiQ WXPEDGRV OR TXH SURYRFD DFHSWDFLyQSRUSDUWHGHWRGRV /DVHJXQGDDFWLYLGDGHV³HOUHOHYRGHOFKiQGDO´ 5 5 5 7DQWR HQ OD SULPHUD UHSHWLFLyQ FRPR HQ OD VHJXQGD 0DUtD RFXSD HO ~OWLPR UHOHYR 6H DFXHUGDTXHUHGXFLUVXUHFRUULGRDXQFLQFXHQWDSRUFLHQWR\TXHGDGDVVXVGLILFXOWDGHV SRUWHQHUODVPDQRVRFXSDGDVFRQODVPXOHWDVGHFLGLPRVTXHVHDXQFRPSDxHURTXHOH DWHODFKDTXHWDDODFLQWXUD&RPRREVHUYDPRVTXHFXDQGROHWRFDD0DUtDHOUHVWRGH JUXSRV\DKDQILQDOL]DGRDSHVDUGHTXHHOODUHDOL]DLJXDOPHQWHHOUHFRUULGRODPDHVWUDOH SURSRQHTXHRFXSHHOSULPHUUHOHYR 6XDFWLWXGHVPX\SRVLWLYD\FRPSHWLWLYDDLPDJHQTXHODGHVXVFRPSDxHURV1XPHURVDV VRQODVYHFHVTXHLQLFLDFRQYHUVDFLRQHVFRQpVWRV\DQRWDPRVTXHHVODSULPHUDYH]HQ HOFXUVRTXHORVDQLPDSHURHQHVWDRFDVLyQJULWDQGRIXHUWH'RVVRQORVTXHFRODERUDQ FRQHOODSDUDDWDUOHODFKDTXHWDUHDOL]iQGRORFRQWRWDOQRUPDOLGDG\UHVSHWR 7HQJR TXH VHxDODU HO FRPHQWDULR GH XQ DGYHUVDULR FXDQGR 0DUtD LQLFLD VX GHVSOD]DPLHQWR\FRQVLJXHOOHJDUHQHVWDVHULHODSULPHUDDQWHODUHGXFFLyQGHOHVSDFLR eVWHGLFHHQDOWR³YD\DPRUUR´ORTXHLQGXFHDODPDHVWUDDFRPHQWDUWDPELpQHQDOWROD MXVWLILFDFLyQGHODVDGDSWDFLRQHV 6HILQDOL]DFRQHOMXHJRGH³PDWDUFRQUH\´ 5 5 /RVQLxRVHQODPLVPDGLVSRVLFLyQTXHHQHOMXHJRDQWHULRU(QFLPDGHODOtQHDVHHQFXHQWUDXQD FKDTXHWDGHFKiQGDO$ODVHxDOGHODPDHVWUDORVSULPHURVGHFDGDJUXSRWLHQHQTXHFRJHUODGHOVXHOR SRQpUVHOD\VDOLUFRUULHQGRKDVWDXQDOtQHDDXQRVTXLQFHPHWURVWHQLHQGRTXHJLUDU\UHJUHVDUGHQXHYRDO SXQWRGHVDOLGD&XDQGROOHJDDQWHVXJUXSRWLHQHQTXHVDFDUVHODFKDTXHWDGHOFKiQGDO\SDViUVHODDO FRPSDxHURVLJXLHQWHGHODILOD\DVtVXFHVLYDPHQWHKDVWDTXHSDVDQWRGRVORVMXJDGRUHV*DQDHOHTXLSR TXHOOHJXHDQWHV /RVMXJDGRUHVVHGLVWULEX\HQHQGRVJUXSRVVHSDUDGRVSRUXQDOtQHDFHQWUDO(OHVSDFLRHVWi GHOLPLWDGR(OREMHWLYRGHOMXHJRHVHOLPLQDUDOHTXLSRFRQWUDULR3DUDHOORFXDQGRVHODQ]DHOEDOyQGH HVSXPDHLPSDFWDDXQDGYHUVDULRWRFiQGRORHQFXDOTXLHUSDUWHFRUSRUDOH[FHSWXDQGRODFDUD\ORVSLHV\ FDHSRVWHULRUPHQWHHOEDOyQDOVXHORVHFRQVLGHUDPXHUWReVWHVHGHVSOD]DKDFLDXQRGHORVGRVH[WUHPRV ODWHUDOHVGHOFDPSRGHORVMXJDGRUHVDGYHUVDULRVGHQRPLQDGD]RQDGHPXHUWRV\GHVGHDOOtLQWHQWD ³PDWDU´DXQDGYHUVDULR'HQRFRQVHJXLUORWLHQHTXHHVSHUDUKDVWDTXHVXVFRPSDxHURVOHSDVHQHOEDOyQ RELHQTXHORSXHGDFRQVHJXLUSRUTXHHOEDOyQKDHQWUDGRDVX]RQDGHMXHJRVRELHQSRUTXHVHORSDVHHO UH\eVWHHVWiORFDOL]DGRHQHOWHUFHUODWHUDOGHOFDPSRTXHTXHGDOLEUHGHIRUPDIURQWDO\WLHQHHOSRGHUGH WHQHUGRVYLGDVHQHOLQLFLRGHOMXHJR6tFRQVLJXHPDWDUDXQDGYHUVDULRVXPDXQDWHUFHUDYLGD SDViQGRVHODDDOJ~QFRPSDxHURTXHHVWpHQDOJXQDGHODVGRV]RQDVODWHUDOHVGHPXHUWRVSRUORTXHVH SRGUiOLEHUDU\WUDVODGDUVHDOFDPSRGHMXHJRFRQVXHTXLSR(QHOPRPHQWRTXHXQHTXLSRVHTXHGDWDQ VyORFRQGRVMXJDGRUHV\HOUHVWRHVWiQPXHUWRVHOUH\SDVDDOD]RQDGHMXHJRFRQVXVGRVYLGDV\VHUi FXDOTXLHUFRPSDxHURPXHUWRTXHDVXPDHOUROGHUH\KDVWDTXHHOLPLQHQDORULJLQDORELHQKDVWDTXHVH FRQVLJDDXPHQWDUHOQ~PHURGHMXJDGRUHVHQHOWHUUHQRGHMXHJRDWUHVGHWDOIRUPDTXHHOUH\UHJUHVDUi GHQXHYRDOD]RQDGHPXHUWRV /DPDHVWUDDQWHVGHH[SOLFDUODVDGDSWDFLRQHVTXHKHPRVSHQVDGRSDUD0DUtDFRPHQWD DVXVFRPSDxHURV³TXHYDQDLUDSRUHOOD´SRUORTXHVXUJHQFRPHQWDULRVFRPR³QRWH SUHRFXSHV \D WH GHIHQGHUHPRV´ $SURYHFKD OD PDHVWUD HVWD VLWXDFLyQ SDUD H[SOLFDU OD DGDSWDFLyQ 6HOHFRQFHGHQWUHVYLGDVWLHQHWUHVRSRUWXQLGDGHVKDVWDTXHSXHGDVHUHOLPLQDGD\ HQHOPRPHQWRHQTXHDJRWHDOJXQDGHHOODV\PDWHDXQDGYHUVDULRVHOHVXPDXQD YLGD &XDQGR REWLHQH HO EDOyQ VH JULWD ³VWRS´ \ ORV DGYHUVDULRV WLHQHQ TXH TXHGDUVH HVWiWLFRVHQHOHVSDFLR(OODSXHGHODQ]DUHOEDOyQFRQHOSLHRODPXOHWDVLWRFDXQ DGYHUVDULRpVWHSDVDDOD]RQDGHPXHUWRVËGHPVLHVWiHQOD]RQDGHPXHUWRV6H DFXHUGDTXHDOURGDUHOEDOyQSRUHOVXHORXQDGYHUVDULRHVWiPXHUWRFXDQGROHWRFD DORVSLHV (QORVSULPHURVFLQFRPLQXWRVGHMXHJRD0DUtDQRVHODKDWHQLGRHQFXHQWDGDGRTXH QDGLH OH KD SDVDGR HO EDOyQ \ QLQJ~Q FRQWUDULR OD KD LQWHQWDGR PDWDU &XDQGR KHPRV REVHUYDGR TXH XQR GH pVWRV HVWi SUy[LPD D HOOD \ GHFLGH ODQ]DU HO EDOyQ KDFLD RWUR FRPSDxHURPiVDOHMDGRKHPRVGHFLGRLQWHUYHQLU/DPDHVWUDSDUDHOMXHJRFRPHQWDQGR TXHD0DUtDVHOHRWRUJDQXQDVYHQWDMDVSDUDSRGHUMXJDUHQODVPLVPDVFRQGLFLRQHVTXH HO UHVWR \TXHSRUWDQWRODWLHQHQTXH WHQHU SUHVHQWHHQWRGDVODVVLWXDFLRQHVFRPROD TXH VH KD GDGR DQWHULRUPHQWH GLFLHQGR OLWHUDOPHQWH ³OD WHQpLV TXH PDWDU FRPR D ORV GHPiV´$VtPLVPRUHFXHUGDDORVFRPSDxHURVGHMXHJRTXHOHSDVHQODSHORWDORTXH PRWLYD D TXH DO FDER GH XQRV LQVWDQWHV OR KDJDQ (Q HVH PRPHQWR HV OD PDHVWUD TXH JULWD ³VWRS´ SRUTXH 0DUtD VH ROYLGD GH KDFHUOR /D UHDFFLyQ GH pVWD KD VLGR OD GH DUURGLOODUVHGHMDUODVPXOHWDVHLQWHQWDUODQ]DUHOEDOyQFRQODPDQR'DGRHOWLHPSRTXH KDWUDQVFXUULGROHUHFXHUGDODPDHVWUDTXHQRSXHGHGHMDUODVPXOHWDV\TXHWLHQHTXH ODQ]DU GHVGH OD SRVLFLyQ GH SLH OR TXH HV DSUREDGR UiSLGDPHQWH SRU ORV DGYHUVDULRV HVFXFKiQGRVH FRPHQWDULRV FRPR ³GH QR VHU DVt VH SLHUGH PXFKR WLHPSR´ &XDQGR SRVWHULRUPHQWHKDFRQVHJXLGRSRVHHUHOEDOyQKDQVLGRVXVFRPSDxHURVORVTXHVHOR KDQFRORFDGRHQHOPHMRUSXQWRGHOVXHORSDUDTXHORSXGLHVHODQ]DU+DFRQVHJXLGRWUHV YHFHVPDWDUDVXVDGYHUVDULRVORTXHKDPRWLYDGRODDSUREDFLyQGHVXVFRPSDxHURVFRQ JULWRVGHDOHJUtD\GHYH]HQFXDQGRKDUHFLELGRXQDVSDOPDGDVHQODHVSDOGD 1RREVWDQWHVHKDGDGRGHQXHYRODVLWXDFLyQGHTXHXQDGYHUVDULRDSHVDUGHWHQHUOD SUy[LPD KD GHFLGLGR QR PDWDUOD SRU OR TXH OD PDHVWUD LQWHUYLHQH GLFLHQGR ³0DUtD HVWi DTXt´ HYLGHQFLDQGR OD SUR[LPLGDG $ SDUWLU GH HVH PRPHQWR KDQ LQWHQWDGR PDWDUOD PiV YHFHVOOHJDQGRDDJRWDUGRVYLGDV(QXQDGHODVRFDVLRQHVODLQWHQWDQPDWDULPSDFWDQGR HO EDOyQ DODVURGLOODV\ODPDHVWUDGLFHTXHQRHVYiOLGRTXHOHODQFHQHOEDOyQGHODV URGLOODVSDUDDEDMR3RVWHULRUPHQWHHOODWLHQHHOEDOyQ\PDWDDXQDGYHUVDULR&RPROH WRFDDORVSLHVXQFRPSDxHURTXHHVWiHQOD]RQDGHPXHUWRVSURWHVWDGLFLHQGR³TXHQR HVWi GH DFXHUGR TXH D 0DUtD QR OH SXHGDQ LPSDFWDU FRQ HO EDOyQ GH ODV URGLOODV SDUD DEDMR\VtHQFDPELRHOODSXHGHPDWDUSRUORVSLHV´$SHVDUGHTXHODPDHVWUDLQWHQWD TXH HQWUH HQ UD]yQ FXDQGR pVWH FRQVLJXH HO EDOyQ VH OR ODQ]D LQWHQFLRQDOPHQWH IXHUWHPHQWHDODFDUDGH0DUtD/DUHDFFLyQGHpVWDHVODGHOORUDUSRUHOGDxRTXHOHKDQ KHFKR&RPRREVHUYDPRVTXHODFDUDODWLHQHVRQURMDGDGHFLGLPRVTXHODDFRPSDxRDOD IXHQWH SDUD TXH VH UHIUHVTXH PLHQWUDV TXH OD PDHVWUD VDQFLRQD DO FRPSDxHUR /H SUHJXQWRSRUTXpOORUD\PHFRQWHVWDTXH³QRHVWDQWRSRUHOGRORUVLQRSRUTXHWRGRVLEDQ 5 5 DSRUHOOD´ORTXHDSURYHFKRSDUDGHFLUOHTXHHVPX\SRVLWLYRSRUTXHHVXQLQGLFDGRUGH TXHODWLHQHQSUHVHQWHFRPRDWRGRV\TXHODUHDFFLyQGHpVWRVHVQRUPDOGDGRTXHHUD ODMXJDGRUDTXHPiVWLHPSRKDSHUPDQHFLGRHQOD]RQDGHMXHJRVVLQVHUHOLPLQDGD3RU WDQWR TXHUtD GHFLU TXH LQGLYLGXDOPHQWH KDEtD JDQDGR HO MXHJR (VWR OH KDFH VRQUHtU \ SRQHUVH DOHJUH $ FRQWLQXDFLyQ OH UHFXHUGR HO VHQWLGR GH OD FRPSHQVDFLyQ GH ODV OLPLWDFLRQHV HQ VLWXDFLRQHV FRPSHWLWLYDV FRQFOX\HQGR TXH HV XQD VROXFLyQ SDUD TXH SXHGDMXJDUHQODVPLVPDVFRQGLFLRQHVTXHORVGHPiV 1RVWUDVODGDPRVDOJLPQDVLRSRUTXHHVODKRUDGHODGXFKD&RPRHOODYDDUHKDELOLWDFLyQ \ QR WLHQH TXH GXFKDUVH MXHJD FRQ ORV FRPSDxHURV TXH WDPSRFR OR KDFHQ SRUTXH HQOD]DQFRQDFWLYLGDGHVH[WUDHVFRODUHV (OMXHJRTXHSUDFWLFDQHV³ODSDVWRUD´ (OJUXSRGLVSHUVRSRUHOHVSDFLR\XQMXJDGRUFRQXQEDOyQGHHVSXPDeVWHSXHGHRSWDU HQ FXDQWR OR SRVHH SRU JULWDU ³SLHV TXLHWRV´ \ SRU WDQWR VXV FRPSDxHURV WLHQHQ TXH TXHGDUVH HVWiWLFRV HQ HO SXQWR GHO HVSDFLR GRQGH VH HQFXHQWUDQ \ D FRQWLQXDFLyQ LQWHQWDU WRFDU D XQ FRPSDxHUR ODQ]DQGR HO EDOyQ LPSDFWDQGR FXDOTXLHU SDUWH FRUSRUDO H[FHSWXDQGRODFDUD\FD\HQGRHOEDOyQDOVXHOR2ELHQWLHQHODSRVLELOLGDGGHGDUWUHV SDVRVFRQHOEDOyQHQODPDQRFRQHOREMHWLYRGHDSUR[LPDUVHDVXVFRPSDxHURV\GHFLU ³SLHVTXLHWRV´(QHOPRPHQWRTXHXQMXJDGRUHVWRFDGRSDVDDOD]RQDGHHOLPLQDGRV\ WDQVyORSXHGHVDOYDUVHFXDQGRLPSDFWDQDOMXJDGRUTXHORKDHOLPLQDGR /D PDHVWUD SUHJXQWD D ORV FRPSDxHURV Vt VH DFXHUGDQ GH ODV DGDSWDFLRQHV \ UiSLGDPHQWHXQRGHHOORVUHVSRQGHFRQODGHVFULSFLyQGHpVWDV 6HOHFRQFHGHQWUHVYLGDVWLHQHWUHVRSRUWXQLGDGHVKDVWDTXHSXHGDVHUHOLPLQDGD\ HQHOPRPHQWRHQTXHDJRWHDOJXQDGHHOODV\PDWHDXQDGYHUVDULRVHOHVXPDXQD YLGD &XDQGRFRQVLJXHHOEDOyQVHJULWD³SLHVTXLHWRV´\WLHQHDGHPiVODSRVLELOLGDGGHGDU ORVWUHVSDVRVFRQHOEDOyQHVWDQGRVXVFRPSDxHURVHVWiWLFRV(OODSXHGHODQ]DUHO EDOyQFRQHOSLHRODPXOHWDVLWRFDXQDGYHUVDULRpVWHSDVDDOD]RQDGHPXHUWRV 6L OD PDWDQ \ OH TXHGD XQD R GRV YLGDV QR SXHGH HO PLVPR DGYHUVDULR LQWHQWDU PDWDUODGDGDODSUR[LPLGDG +HPRV REVHUYDGR TXH KDQ MXJDGR FRQ HOOD FRQ OD Pi[LPD QDWXUDOLGDG WHQLpQGROD SUHVHQWH UHJXODUPHQWH +DQ VLGR P~OWLSOHV ODV RFDVLRQHV TXH OD KDQ LQWHQWDGR PDWDU FRPR YDULDV VRQ ODV YHFHV TXH KD HOLPLQDGR 7HQJR TXH UHJLVWUDU OD UHDFFLyQ TXH KDQ WHQLGRFRQHOODJUDQSDUWHGHMXJDGRUHVHOLPLQDGRVFXDQGRKDPDWDGRDOFRPSDxHURTXH ORVKDEtDHOLPLQDGR&XDQGRKDLQLFLDGRHOODQ]DPLHQWRKDFLDpVWHVHHVFXFKDEDQJULWRV GH DQLPDFLyQ \ FXDQGR KD FRQVHJXLGR HO ILQ OD KDQ URGHDGR UHFLELHQGR SDOPDGDV D OD HVSDOGD(VHQHVWHPRPHQWRFXDQGRFRQVLGHUDPRVTXH0DUtDVHKDVHQWLGRDFHSWDGD\ YDORUDGD &RPHQWDULRVDODVHVLyQ +DVLGRPX\VLJQLILFDWLYRTXH0DUtDQRKD\DVROLFLWDGRODLQWHUYHQFLyQGHODPDHVWUDSDUD UHVROYHUODVVLWXDFLRQHVFRQIOLFWLYDVFRQVXVFRPSDxHURV 5 5 5 5 &RLQFLGLPRV HQ SHQVDU HQ TXH KD VLGR OD VHVLyQ PiV FRPSOHMD KDVWD HO PRPHQWR HQ FXDQWRLQWHUDFFLRQHVYDORUiQGRODPX\SRVLWLYDPHQWH &RQVWDWDPRVTXHWRGRVKDQLQFRUSRUDGRHOVHQWLGRGHODVDGDSWDFLRQHV\TXHJUDFLDVD HOODV D 0DUtD VH OH H[LJH PiV D IDYRU GH VX DXWRQRPtD \ DXWRHVWLPD 3HQVDPRV TXH WDPELpQHVPX\VLJQLILFDWLYRORTXHKDRFXUULGRHQORVGRV~OWLPRVMXHJRVSRUTXH\DQRVH ODLJQRUD &UHHPRVTXH0DUtDVHKDVHQWLGRPX\DFHSWDGD\YDORUDGDSULQFLSDOPHQWHHQHO~OWLPR MXHJR 5 '((1(52'( /DPDHVWUDLQLFLDODVHVLyQFRQHOMXHJRGHO³UHVFDWH´ &XDWURMXJDGRUHVVRQORVTXHSDUDQHOUHVWRGLVWULEXLGRVOLEUHPHQWHSRUHOHVSDFLR$OD VHxDO ORV TXH SDUDQ WLHQHQ TXH WRFDU DO UHVWR GH FRPSDxHURV 6L OR FRQVLJXHQ FDGD MXJDGRU TXH SDUD WLHQH DVLJQDGD XQD ]RQD GHO FDPSR SDUD VLWXDU D ORV TXH KD WRFDGR eVWRVSHUPDQHFHQHVWiWLFRVKDVWDTXHVRQVDOYDGRVSRUDOJ~QFRPSDxHUR(QHOFDVRGH FRLQFLGLU HQ XQD PLVPD ]RQD YDULRV WRFDGRV SXHGHQ GDUVH OD PDQR RUJDQL]DQGR XQD FDGHQDGHWDOIRUPDTXHVLVDOYDQDXQRGHORVH[WUHPRVHOUHVWRVHFRQVLGHUDVDOYDGR SRUTXHKDSDVDGRODFRUULHQWH 8QR GH ORV FXDWUR MXJDGRUHV TXH SDUD HV 0DUtD (Q OD SULPHUD UHSHWLFLyQ WDQ VyOR KD WRFDGR D XQ MXJDGRU 6X DFWLWXG OD FDWDORJDPRV GH SDVLYD GDGR TXH WDQ VyOR LQWHQWD HOLPLQDUDDTXHOORVTXHVHFUX]DQFRQHOOD(QXQDRFDVLyQVHGLVFXWHFRQXQFRPSDxHUR SRUTXHpVWHRSLQDTXHQRKDVLGRWRFDGR5HVSHFWRDODVHJXQGDUHSHWLFLyQGHOMXHJROD PDHVWUD FRQVLGHUD RSRUWXQR TXH 0DUtD VLJD SDUDQGR (VWD YH] OD REVHUYDPRV PiV GLQiPLFDGHVSOD]iQGRVHSRUHOHVSDFLRHLQWHQWDQGRLQWHUFHSWDUDVXVFRPSDxHURV (OVLJXLHQWHMXHJRHV³HOJXVDQR´ /DFODVHVHRUJDQL]DHQGRVJUXSRVXQRHQIUHQWHGHORWUR/RVMXJDGRUHVGHFDGDHTXLSR VHFRJHQSRUODFLQWXUDXQRGHWUiVGHRWURH[FHSWXDQGRHOSULPHURTXHFRJHODVPDQRV GHOSULPHUMXJDGRUGHORWURHTXLSR$ODVHxDO£DYHUTXHJUXSRGHVSOD]DDORWURKDFLDVX FDPSRVLQVHSDUDUVHGHODFLQWXUDVLQURPSHUVH /DUHDFFLyQGH0DUtDHVODGHDUURGLOODUVHHQHOVXHORSDUDFRJHUODFLQWXUDGHOFRPSDxHUR TXHWLHQHGHODQWH$QWHODREVHUYDFLyQGHODPDHVWUDHQTXHLQVLVWHTXHVHSRQJDGHSLH OD MXJDGRUD GH DWUiV SRU LQLFLDWLYD SURSLD OH IDFLOLWD HO DSR\R SDUD TXH WHQJD PiV HVWDELOLGDG 2EVHUYDPRV TXH 0DUtD LQWHUDFFLRQD GH IRUPD YHUEDO FRQVWDQWHPHQWH FRQ ODV FRPSDxHUDVSUy[LPDVDHOODPRVWUiQGRVHPX\ULVXHxD\DODYH]PX\FRPSHWLWLYD 5 6(6,Ï11 5 5 5 5 /DWHUFHUDWDUHDHV³HOUHOHYRGHODFURTXHWD´ /RV JUXSRV VH FRPSRQHQ GH FLQFR MXJDGRUHV 8QR GHWUiV GHO RWUR $ OD VHxDO VDOH HO SULPHURGHFDGDILODWXPEiQGRVHHQHOVXHOR7LHQHQTXHGHVSOD]DUVHJLUDQGRDOUHGHGRU GHVXHMHKRUL]RQWDOVLPXODQGRVHUXQDFURTXHWDTXHVHUHER]DKDVWDOOHJDUDXQDOtQHD VLWXDGD D XQRV PHWURV 8QD YH] DOFDQ]DGD pVWD VDOH HO VLJXLHQWH MXJDGRU \ DVt VXFHVLYDPHQWH KDVWD TXH SDUWLFLSDQ WRGRV ORV PLHPEURV GHO JUXSR (O MXHJR FRQVLVWH KDEHUTXLHQOOHJDSULPHUR /DHVWUDWHJLDGHODPDHVWUDHVODGHRUJDQL]DUORVJUXSRVORPiVKRPRJpQHRVSRVLEOHV\ DGHPiVMXHJDFRQODLQIHULRULGDGQXPpULFDUHGXFLHQGRXQMXJDGRUHQHOJUXSRGH0DUtD $ SHVDU GH HVWDV DGDSWDFLRQHV pVWD VH GHVSOD]D PX\ OHQWDPHQWH LQGHSHQGLHQWHPHQWH GHTXHHVWiHQFRQGLFLRQHVVLPLODUHVDOUHVWRGHMXJDGRUHVQRREVHUYDQGRPDOHVWDUSRU SDUWHGHORVPLHPEURVGHVXJUXSR 3DUDILQDOL]DUVHSURSRQHHOMXHJRGHO³W~QHOUHSWDQGR´ /D RUJDQL]DFLyQ GH ORV JUXSRV HV VLPLODU DO MXHJR DQWHULRU SHUR ORV MXJDGRUHV VH HQFXHQWUDQFRQODVSLHUQDVVHSDUDGDVVLHQGRODGLVWDQFLDHQWUHMXJDGRUHVGHXQPLVPR HTXLSR GH XQ PHWUR \ PHGLR DSUR[LPDGDPHQWH $ OD VHxDO HO ~OWLPR MXJDGRU VH WXPED ERFDDEDMRGHVSOD]iQGRVHKDFLDGHODQWHSDVDQGRHQWUHODVSLHUQDVGHVXVFRPSDxHURV \ VLJXLHQGR HO W~QHO KDVWD OOHJDU DO SULPHU MXJDGRU &XDQGR OR FRQVLJXH VH FRORFD D OD GLVWDQFLD GH XQ PHWUR \ PHGLR GHO TXH HUD SULPHUR \ VDOH HO VLJXLHQWH FRPSDxHUR TXH RFXSD HO ~OWLPR OXJDU GH OD ILOD < DVt VXFHVLYDPHQWH KDVWD DOFDQ]DU XQD OtQHD SUHGHWHUPLQDGD¢$YHUTXpHTXLSRODDOFDQ]DDQWHV" (VWHMXHJRQRSUHVHQWDJUDQGLILFXOWDGSDUD0DUtDVXFRPSDxHUDSUy[LPDWDQVyORWLHQH TXHGHVSOD]DUODVPXOHWDVFRQORVSLHVKDFLDGHODQWHFXDQGROHWRFDUHSWDUD0DUtDGHWDO IRUPDTXHFXDQGROOHJDDVHUODSULPHUDVHSXHGHSRQHUGHSLHVLQSUHFLVDUODD\XGDGH QDGLH 6HREVHUYDD0DUtDPX\FRPXQLFDWLYDJHQHUDQGRGLiORJRVFRQVXVFRPSDxHURVeVWRV VHPXHVWUDQPX\SRVLWLYRVFRQHOODSRUORTXHREVHUYDPRVTXHHVPX\ELHQDFHSWDGD &RPHQWDULRVDODVHVLyQ +HPRVFRLQFLGLGRHQODFRQVLGHUDFLyQTXH0DUtDWLHQHXQDDFWLWXGFDGDYH]PiVDELHUWD\ XQD H[SUHVLyQ IDFLDOPiVULVXHxD,QFOXVR DO KDEODU FRQ HO DGXOWR ILMD OD PLUDGD FXDQGR DQWHULRUPHQWHEDMDEDFRQVWDQWHPHQWHODFDEH]D$HOORDxDGLPRVTXHVXIRUPDGHKDEODU KDFDPELDGRGHMDQGRDWUiVHOWRQRLQIDQWLOTXHOHFDUDFWHUL]DEDGtDVDWUiV 6(6,Ï11 '((1(52'( 5 5 5 5 5 5 /DVHVLyQVHLQLFLDFRQHOMXHJRGHO³SLOODSLOODFRQQRPEUHV´ 7RGRVORVDOXPQRVGLVWULEXLGRVSRUXQHVSDFLRGHOLPLWDGR/DPDHVWUDGLUiHOQRPEUHGH 5 XQRGHHOORVORTXHVXSRQGUiTXHHVHOMXJDGRUTXHSDUDeVWHLQWHQWDUiWRFDUDOPi[LPR GHMXJDGRUHVFRQHOREMHWLYRGHHOLPLQDUORVKDVWDTXHODPDHVWUDQRPEUDDRWURMXJDGRU *DQDHOMXHJRHOTXHTXHGHHO~OWLPRHQOD]RQDGHMXHJR /D DGDSWDFLyQ SDUD 0DUtD TXH SURSRQH OD PDHVWUD HV OD GH RWRUJDUOH WUHV YLGDV FRQ OD FRQGLFLyQGHTXHVLSLHUGHXQDYLGDHOMXJDGRUTXHOHKDWRFDGRQRSXHGHYROYHUODDWRFDU GDGDODSUR[LPLGDGHYLGHQWH(QHOPRPHQWRHQTXHHVQRPEUDGDVHJULWD³VWRS´\WRGRHO JUXSR WLHQH TXH TXHGDU LQPyYLO 0DUtD SXHGH GDU HO Q~PHUR GH SDVRV LOLPLWDGRV KDVWD DFHUFDUVHDODSHUVRQDTXHGHFLGDWDQVyORSXHGHLQWHUUXPSLUVXDFFLyQVLODPDHVWUDHQ HVHUHFRUULGRQRPEUDDRWURMXJDGRU /D UHDFFLyQ GHO JUXSR FODVH DO H[SOLFDU OD DGDSWDFLyQ KD VLGR OD GH TXHMDUVH SRUTXH FRQVLGHUDQTXHVHOHGDPXFKDYHQWDMDD0DUtD/DPDHVWUDWLHQHTXHLQWHUYHQLUGHQXHYR MXVWLILFDQGR OD UD]yQ GH ODV PRGLILFDFLRQHV 1R REVWDQWH FXDQGR 0DUtD HOLPLQD D XQD MXJDGRUD pVWD VH PXHVWUD HQIDGDGD \ HQ WRWDO GHVDFXHUGR DFRJLpQGRVH HQ TXH OD DGDSWDFLyQHVH[FHVLYD $SHVDUGHHOORVHREVHUYDDXQD0DUtDPX\SDUWLFLSDWLYD\PX\PRWLYDGDSRUODGLQiPLFD \HYROXFLyQGHOMXHJR /DVLJXLHQWHSURSXHVWDHVODGHUHDOL]DU³VDOWRVDSLHVMXQWRVVLQLPSXOVR´ 6HRUJDQL]DQFXDWURJUXSRVGHFLQFRMXJDGRUHV$ODVHxDOORVSULPHURVGHFDGDILODTXH HVWiQVLWXDGRVVREUHXQDOtQHDGHOFDPSRWLHQHQTXHUHDOL]DUXQVDOWRFRQORVSLHVMXQWRV KDFLD GHODQWH LQWHQWDQGR OOHJDU OR PiV OHMRV SRVLEOH (O TXH OR FRQVLJD VXPD XQ SXQWR SDUDVXHTXLSR*DQDHOHTXLSRTXHPiVSXQWRVFRQWDELOLFH /DPDHVWUDRUJDQL]DORVJUXSRVGHPDQHUDHTXLWDWLYD0DUtDSDUWLFLSDVLQJUDQGLILFXOWDG\ D\XGiQGRVH GH ODV PXOHWDV FRQVLJXH UHLWHUDGDPHQWH UHDOL]DU HO VDOWR PiV ODUJR OR TXH SURYRFD LUD HQ VXV DGYHUVDULRV \ JUDQGHV DOHJUtDV D VXV FRPSDxHURV GH JUXSR PRVWUiQGRVH PX\ DIHFWXRVRV FRQ HOOD PHGLDQWH DEUD]RV $QWH WDO UHDFFLyQ OD PDHVWUD LQGLFDDOMXJDGRUTXHPiVSURWHVWDTXHLQWHQWHUHDOL]DUHOPLVPRVDOWRFRQD\XGDGHODV PXOHWDV$OQRFRQVHJXLUORODPDHVWUDDSURYHFKDSDUDYDORUDUODVFDSDFLGDGHVGH0DUtD (Q HVH SURFHVR QR OD REVHUYDPRV DOWHUDGD SRU ODV FUtWLFDV GH VXV FRPSDxHURV DFHSWDQGRFRQQDWXUDOLGDGORVKDODJRVTXHUHDOL]DODPDHVWUDKDFLDHOOD 3URVLJXHODVHVLyQFRQHOMXHJRGH³ODQ]DUHOSHVR´ %DMR OD PLVPD RUJDQL]DFLyQ \ GLVSRVLFLyQ GH ORV MXJDGRUHV TXH HQ HO MXHJR DQWHULRU HO SULPHUR GH FDGD JUXSR WLHQH TXH ODQ]DU XQD SHORWD PHGLFLQDO GH XQ NLOR OR PiV OHMRV SRVLEOH 3DUDTXH0DUtDSXHGDUHDOL]DUHOODQ]DPLHQWRVHOHSHUPLWHTXHVHDUURGLOOHHQHOVXHOR (QHVWDRFDVLyQVXVUHVXOWDGRVVRQLQIHULRUHVDORVGHOUHVWRGHDGYHUVDULRVGLUHFWRV &RQWLQXDFRQHO³ODQ]DPLHQWRGHMDEDOLQD´ ËGHPDODGLVSRVLFLyQ\RUJDQL]DFLyQGHORVGRVMXHJRVDQWHULRUHVSHURDXQDGLVWDQFLDGH 5 5 5 5 5 5 5 5 XQRVPHWURVVHOHVVLW~DDQWHFDGDJUXSRXQDURHQHOVXHOR$ODVHxDOHOSULPHURGH FDGDJUXSRODQ]DXQDSLFDGHSOiVWLFRTXHVLPEROL]DVHUODMDEDOLQDLQWHQWDQGRGLULJLUOD GHQWURGHODURKDFHUGLDQD3RUFDGDDFLHUWRVHOHVDVLJQDQGRVSXQWRV (QORVWLHPSRVGHHVSHUDREVHUYDPRVTXH0DUtDVHUHODFLRQDFRQVWDQWHPHQWHFRQVXV FRPSDxHURVGHJUXSRUHVXOWDQGRVHUODVUHODFLRQHVPX\SRVLWLYDV 3DUD ILQDOL]DU VH GHVSOD]DQ DO JLPQDVLR 2EVHUYDPRV TXH 0DUtD HV OD SULPHUD YH] TXH VDOH GHO SDWLR DFRPSDxDGD FRPSDUWLHQGR FRQYHUVDFLRQHV FRQ ORV FRPSDxHURV PiV SUy[LPRV\HVWDQGRUHFHSWLYDDODGLQiPLFDVRFLDOHQJHQHUDO6HGDODFLUFXQVWDQFLDTXH GRV QLxDV MXHJDQ D VXELUVH D OD HVSDOGD GH OD RWUD SDUD VHU WUDVODGDGD FRPR VL GH XQ FDEDOOR \ XQ MLQHWH VH WUDWDUD (OOD VROLFLWD D XQD FRPSDxHUD TXH OD VXED D OD HVSDOGD &XDQGRORKDFH\HPSLH]DDFDPLQDUWURSLH]D\0DUtDFDHVXDYHPHQWHDOVXHORORTXH SURYRFDODSUHRFXSDFLyQGHVXDOUHGHGRUDUURSiQGRODFRQVWDQWHPHQWHKDVWDTXHVHKDQ DVHJXUDGRTXHHUDXQDFDtGDVLQLPSRUWDQFLD 6HFLHUUDODVHVLyQFRQHOMXHJRGH³ODSDVWRUD´ (OJUXSRGLVSHUVRSRUHOHVSDFLR\XQMXJDGRUFRQXQEDOyQGHHVSXPDeVWHSXHGHRSWDU HQ FXDQWR OR SRVHH SRU JULWDU ³SLHV TXLHWRV´ \ SRU WDQWR VXV FRPSDxHURV WLHQHQ TXH TXHGDUVH HVWiWLFRV HQ HO SXQWR GHO HVSDFLR GRQGH VH HQFXHQWUDQ \ D FRQWLQXDFLyQ LQWHQWDU WRFDU D XQ FRPSDxHUR ODQ]DQGR HO EDOyQ LPSDFWDQGR FXDOTXLHU SDUWH FRUSRUDO H[FHSWXDQGRODFDUD\FD\HQGRHOEDOyQDOVXHOR2ELHQWLHQHODSRVLELOLGDGGHGDUWUHV SDVRVFRQHOEDOyQHQODPDQRFRQHOREMHWLYRGHDSUR[LPDUVHDVXVFRPSDxHURV\GHFLU ³SLHVTXLHWRV´(QHOPRPHQWRTXHXQMXJDGRUHVWRFDGRSDVDDOD]RQDGHHOLPLQDGRV\ WDQVyORSXHGHVDOYDUVHFXDQGRLPSDFWDQDOMXJDGRUTXHORKDHOLPLQDGR /D DGDSWDFLyQ SDUD 0DUtD HV VLPLODU D ODV VHVLRQHV DQWHULRUHV HQ TXH VH SUDFWLFy HVWH MXHJRFXDQGRFRQVLJXHHOEDOyQVHJULWD³SLHVTXLHWRV´\WLHQHDGHPiVODSRVLELOLGDGGH GDUORVWUHVSDVRVFRQHOEDOyQHVWDQGRVXVFRPSDxHURVHVWiWLFRV(OODGHFLGHVLLQWHQWD WRFDUDVXVFRPSDxHURVFKXWiQGRORFRQORVSLHVRODQ]iQGRORFRQODPDQR$GHPiVOH FRQFHGHPRVWUHVYLGDVWUHVSRVLELOLGDGHVSDUDSURORQJDUVXSHUPDQHQFLDHQHOMXHJRODV FXDOHVSXHGHUHFXSHUDUHQFDVRGHDJRWDUXQDRGRVHQHOPRPHQWRTXHHOLPLQDDXQ FRPSDxHUR (Q HO PRPHQWR HQ TXH OH TXLWDQ XQD YLGD SRUTXH KD VLGR LPSDFWDGD HVH MXJDGRUGDGDODSUR[LPLGDGQRSXHGHYROYHUDLQWHQWDUOR 2EVHUYDPRV TXH 0DUtD VRQUtH DELHUWDPHQWH PRVWUiQGRVH PX\ GLQiPLFD \ VLQ HVFRQGHUVH GHWUiV GH ODV FROXPQDV FRPR KDFtD HQ XQ SULQFLSLR (O JUXSR HVWi PX\ SHQGLHQWHGHODHYROXFLyQGHpVWDWHQLHQGRPX\SUHVHQWHHOQ~PHURGHYLGDVTXHSRVHH 0DUtD &RPHQWDULRVDODVHVLyQ 2EVHUYDPRV TXH D OR ODUJR GH OD VHVLyQ 0DUtD JHQHUD LQWHUDFFLRQHV YHUEDOHV FRQ VXV FRPSDxHURVPiVSUy[LPRV\ODYH]HVVROLFLWDGDSRUpVWRVPRVWUDQGRHQDOJXQDRFDVLyQ DSUREDFLyQGHVXVUHVXOWDGRVPHGLDQWHDEUD]RV 5 5 5 5 5 5 +DVLGRLQWHUHVDQWHTXHHOJUXSRVHFXHVWLRQDVHODDGDSWDFLyQGHOSULPHUMXHJR\TXHXQD YH]UD]RQDGDSRUODPDHVWUDHQJHQHUDOODKD\DQDFHSWDGR$VtPLVPRWDPELpQHVGH LQWHUpVUHJLVWUDUODUHDFFLyQGHDOJXQRVFRPSDxHURVHQHOVHJXQGRMXHJRFXDQGR0DUtD REWHQtDUHVXOWDGRVIDYRUDEOHVSDUDVXHTXLSR 6H SHUFLEH TXH FDGD YH] DFHSWDQ FRQ PiV QDWXUDOLGDG OD FRPSHQVDFLyQ GH ODV OLPLWDFLRQHVGH0DUtDHQVLWXDFLRQHVFRPSHWLWLYDVYpDVHFRQHOHMHPSORGHOMXHJRGH³OD SDVWRUD´HQTXH\DWLHQHQLQFRUSRUDGDVODVPRGLILFDFLRQHV (Q ODV DFWLYLGDGHV TXH WHQJD TXH UHDOL]DU ODQ]DPLHQWRV VH DFXHUGD TXH ODV UHDOLFH VHQWDGDHQXQDVLOODHQYH]GHDUURGLOODUVHHQHOVXHOR 6(6,Ï11 '((1(52'( 5 5 'DGR TXH GXUDQWH GRV VHPDQDV PH GHVSOD]R D 1LFDUDJXD SDUD FRODERUDU HQ XQ 5 SURJUDPD GH FRRSHUDFLyQ HQWUH OD 8QLYHUVLGDG GH %DUFHORQD \ OD 8QLYHUVLGDG 1DFLRQDO $XWyQRPD GH 1LFDUDJXD /HyQ ODV FXDWUR VLJXLHQWHV VHVLRQHV VRQ REVHUYDGDV SRU OD PDHVWUDGH(GXFDFLyQ)tVLFD (OSULPHUMXHJRTXHSURSRQHHVHOGHO³UHVFDWH´ 5 7UHVDOXPQRVVRQORVSHUVHJXLGRUHV\HOUHVWRORVSHUVHJXLGRV/RVMXJDGRUHVTXHVRQ DWUDSDGRVSRUHOSHUVHJXLGRUORVOOHYDDFDVD]RQD\DSDFWDGDSUHYLDPHQWH\VHTXHGDQ HQHVHHVSDFLRFRQHOEUD]RH[WHQGLGR(QHOFDVRGHTXHVHDQPiVGHXQRVHFRJHQGH ODPDQR\XQRGHHOORVFRQHOEUD]RH[WHQGLGRGHWDOIRUPDTXHFXDQGRXQFRPSDxHUR WRTXHHOEUD]RORVVDOYDDWRGRVSDVDUODFRUULHQWH (OMXHJRILQDOL]DFXDQGRVRQWRFDGRVWRGRVORVMXJDGRUHV (OVLJXLHQWHMXHJRHVHOGH³ODVVHUSLHQWHV´ 5 0DWHULDOXQSDxXHORSRUFDGDMXJDGRUTXHKDFHGHFROD (QOD]RQDGHMXHJRVHREVHUYDQGRVVHUSLHQWHV&DGDXQDGHHOODVHVWiIRUPDGDSRUWUHV MXJDGRUHVFRJLGRVGHODPDQR(OSULPHURTXHHVOD³FDEH]D´GLULJHDOJUXSR\HO~OWLPR TXHHVOD³FROD´OOHYDXQSDxXHORHQODPDQROLEUH /DVVHUSLHQWHVWLHQHQTXHSHUVHJXLUDOUHVWRGHFRPSDxHURVSXGLpQGRORVWRFDUORVGRV MXJDGRUHV H[WUHPRV ³FDEH]D´ ³FROD´ (O FRPSDxHUR TXH HV WRFDGR FRJH HO SDxXHOR \ RFXSDHOOXJDUGHOD³FROD´PLHQWUDVTXHOD³FDEH]D´TXHGDOLEUH\HOMXJDGRUGHHQPHGLR RFXSDVXOXJDU /D~OWLPDSURSXHVWDHVODGH³FRUWDUODFRODGHO]RUUR´ 5 0DWHULDOXQSDxXHORSRUFDGDMXJDGRU 7RGRV ORV MXJDGRUHV GLVWULEXLGRV SRU HO HVSDFLR GH MXHJR &DGD XQR GH HOORV OOHYD XQ SDxXHORDWUiVFRJLGRSRUODFLQWXUDVLPXODQGRODFRODGHO]RUUR $ODVHxDOVHKDGHLQWHQWDUFRQVHJXLUWDQWDV³FRODV´FRPRSXHGDVHUSRVLEOH$OMXJDGRU TXHOHTXLWDQOD³FROD´VDOHGHOWHUUHQRGHMXHJR\VHGHVSOD]DDOD]RQDGHDFWLYLGDGHV $OOtWLHQHTXHUHDOL]DUFLQFRIOH[LRQHVGHSLHUQDVFLQFRVDOWRVYHUWLFDOHV3RVWHULRUPHQWH VHLQFRUSRUDDOMXHJRFRQHOREMHWLYRGHFRQVHJXLUXQD³FROD´(QFDVRGHFRQVHJXLUODVH ODFRORFDHQODFLQWXUD *DQDHOMXJDGRUTXHPiV³FRODV´KD\DFRQVHJXLGR /DPDHVWUDHVFULEH 'HVSXpVGHSDVDUOLVWDKHFRPHQ]DGRDH[SOLFDUODVDFWLYLGDGHVTXHWHQtDQTXHUHDOL]DU &XDQGR GHVFULER XQR GH ORV MXHJRV 0DUtD GLFH HQ YR] DOWD ³ HVWH MXHJR \D OR KHPRV MXJDGR HQ HO HVSODL´ \ D FRQWLQXDFLyQ H[SOLFD HO MXHJR GHO ³FRZER\ \ ORV LQGLRV´ OR TXH PRWLYDTXHRWUDFRPSDxHUDTXHYDFRQHOODDOHVSODLVHFXQGHODGHVFULSFLyQ'DGRTXH VHDODUJDQHQODH[SOLFDFLyQOHVKHGLFKR³TXHOHVSDUHFtDVLRWURGtDORH[SOLFDEDQSDUD TXH WRGD OD FODVH SXGLHUD MXJDU´ +DQ HPSH]DGR D UHtUVH \ KH REVHUYDGR FRPSOLFLGDG HQWUHODVGRVHVWDEDQFRQWHQWtVLPDV (Q HO MXHJR GHO ³UHVFDWH´ KD SDUWLFLSDGR DFWLYDPHQWH \ DGHPiV VH OD YHtD FRQWHQWD \ FRUUtDSDUDTXHQRODSLOODUDQ 6HKDDFHUFDGRSDUDGHFLUPHTXHXQDFRPSDxHUDTXHHQHVHPRPHQWRDWUDSDEDQROR HVWDEDKDFLHQGRELHQ+HSDUDGRHOMXHJR\OHKHGLFKR³TXHORTXHPHHVWDEDGLFLHQGR TXH OR GLMHUD HQ YR] DOWD´ (V SRU HOOR TXH VH GLULJH 0DUtD D HVWD FRPSDxHUD FRPHQWiQGROH³PLUDFXDQGRDWUDSDVWLHQHVTXHDFRPSDxDUDODSHUVRQDDWXFDVD]RQD UHVWULQJLGD /D FRPSDxHUD OH GD ODV JUDFLDV \ OH UHVSRQGH TXH ³QR VH KDEtD HQWHUDGR ELHQGHOMXHJR´&RPRUHVXOWDGROHFRPHQWR³PHJXVWDPXFKRTXHHVWpVDWHQWDJUDFLDV´ REVHUYiQGROHPiVFRQWHQWD (Q HO VLJXLHQWH MXHJR ³ODV VHUSLHQWHV´ 0DUtD HPSLH]D VLHQGR XQD GH ODV VHUSLHQWHV 2EVHUYRTXHWRFDDVXVFRPSDxHURVFRQODVPXOHWDVSRUORTXHSDURHOMXHJR\DFODURDO JUXSRTXHSXHGHWRFDUFRQODVPXOHWDV /RVFRPSDxHURVKDQDFHSWDGRFXDQGRHOODHV³FDEH]D´TXHGLULMDHOMXHJRSDUDGHFLGLUD TXLHQ WLHQHQ TXH DWUDSDU REVHUYDQGR HQ GHWHUPLQDGDV VLWXDFLRQHV GH GLVFUHSDQFLDV XQDDFWLWXGQHJRFLDGRUDFRQVXVFRPSDxHURVGHVHUSLHQWH &XDQGR0DUtDKDSDVDGRDVHUMXJDGRUDGHMXHJRODKDQDWUDSDGRHQYDULDVRFDVLRQHV 0HKDJXVWDGRYHUDORVFRPSDxHURVFRPRODFRJtDQSRUHOEUD]RFRQPXFKDGHOLFDGH]D \DGHPiVVHJXtDQVXULWPR (Q HO ~OWLPR MXHJR ³FRUWDU OD FROD DO ]RUUR´ FRPHQWDU TXH KD HPSH]DGR ELHQ OH KDQ TXLWDGR HO SDxXHOR \ HOOD KD LGR D OD ]RQD GH DFWLYLGDGHV SDUD UHDOL]DU ORV HMHUFLFLRV SURSXHVWRV LQFRUSRUiQGRVH SRVWHULRUPHQWH DO MXHJR 3HUR HQ OD WHUFHUD RFDVLyQ TXH OD KDQ WRFDGR VH KD TXHGDGR HQ HO VLWLR SURWHVWDQGR \ GLFLHQGR HQ YR] DOWD ³TXH HOOD QR MXJDEDPiV´\KDHPSH]DGRDOORUDU(VSRUHOORTXHPHKHDFHUFDGR\OHKHGLFKR³TXHVL KDEtDXQSUREOHPDTXHPHORGLMHUD´\HOODVHTXHGDHQVLOHQFLRQRTXHULHQGRKDEODU1R REVWDQWHLQVLVWR\OHSUHJXQWR³¢TXLHUHVXQDVYHQWDMDV"\HOODUHVSRQGH³TXHQRTXHQR TXLHUR MXJDU SRUTXH WRGRV YDQ SRU Pt´ 3DUR HO MXHJR \ GLJR DO JUXSR FODVH TXH 0DUtD 5 5 5 5 5 ³WLHQHFXDWURYLGDV\TXHVLXQROHTXLWDHOSDxXHOR\DQRSXHGHTXLWDUOHPiV´REVHUYDQGR TXHWRGRVORDFHSWDQ &RQWLQ~DHOMXHJRFRQQRUPDOLGDGSHUFLELHQGRODUHDFFLyQGH0DUtDFXDQGRXQRGHVXV FRPSDxHURVOHTXLWDHOSDxXHOR\VHORTXHGD(OODHQVHJXLGDOHGLFH´PHORWLHQHVTXH GDU\DTXHGLVSRQJRWRGDYtDGHGRVYLGDV´ &XDQGRWRGRVKDQDFDEDGRGHGXFKDUVHKHHQWUDGRDOYHVWXDULRFRQHOILQGHKDEODUFRQ HOOD/HKHSUHJXQWDGR³¢SRUTXpQRKDUHFODPDGRVXVYHQWDMDV"UHVSRQGLpQGRPH³TXHDO SULQFLSLRWRGRLEDELHQ\TXHQRVDEtDHOSRUTXp´ /HKHGLFKRTXHLJXDOTXHHVFDSD]GHH[SOLFDUORVMXHJRVTXHSUDFWLFDIXHUDGHFODVHDVt FRPRGHLQWHUYHQLUSDUDREVHUYDUTXHXQDFRPSDxHUDQRKDEtDHQWHQGLGRELHQHOMXHJR WLHQH TXH VHU FDSD] GH UHFODPDU ODV DGDSWDFLRQHV GH ORV MXHJRV SRUTXH GH QR VHU DVt SXHGRSHQVDUTXHQRODVQHFHVLWD/HLQVLVWRTXHHOODWLHQHODVXILFLHQWHDXWRQRPtDSDUD UHFODPDU\TXHDSDUWLUGHDKRUDWLHQHTXHVHUFDSD]GHEXVFDUVROXFLRQHVSDUDUHVROYHU DTXHOODV VLWXDFLRQHVTXHQROHJXVWDQ R TXH QR HVWi GH DFXHUGR $xDGR TXH WLHQH TXH FRPXQLFDUVHPiVFRQVXVFRPSDxHURV\SDFWDUFRQHOORVVLQQHFHVLGDGGHUHFXUULUDPt LQWHUYHQFLyQ SDUD UHVROYHU VXV SUREOHPDV 1R REVWDQWH OH FRPHQWR TXH ³VL YH TXH KDEODQGR FRQ HOORV QR UHVXHOYH QDGD HQWRQFHV VL LQWHUYHQGUp´ &RQWHVWD ³TXH YDOH TXH HVWiGHDFXHUGR´ &RPHQWDULRVDODVHVLyQ ,QWHUSUHWR HQ HVWD VHVLyQ TXH 0DUtD SDVD GH SUHVHQWDU LQLFLDWLYDV D UHIXJLDUVH HQ ORV OORURVFXDQGRVXUJHQFRQIOLFWRVFRQVXVFRPSDxHURV 6H FRQVWDWD TXH LQWHUDFFLRQD SRVLWLYDPHQWH FRQ VXV FRPSDxHURV \ TXH WLHQH DFWLWXG QHJRFLDGRUD HQ HO MXHJR GH OD ³VHUSLHQWH´ $Vt PLVPR HV GH UHJLVWUDU OD DFWLWXG GH ORV FRPSDxHURVFXDQGRSDVDDSHUWHQHFHUDODVHUSLHQWHUHVSHWDQGRVXULWPRGHDPEXODFLyQ \ODPXHVWUDGHGHOLFDGH]DFXDQGRODFRJHQSRUHOEUD]R (V PX\ LQWHUHVDQWH OD GHVFULSFLyQ TXH UHDOL]D OD PDHVWUD UHVSHFWR D VX LQWHUYHQFLyQ FXDQGR0DUtDOORUDSRUTXHODDWUDSDQFRQVHFXWLYDPHQWHHQHO~OWLPRMXHJR\FyPRLQVLVWH HQTXHHOODWLHQHTXHVHUORVXILFLHQWHPHQWHDXWyQRPDFRPRSDUDUHVROYHUORVFRQIOLFWRV FRQVXVFRPSDxHURVVLQODQHFHVLGDGGHUHFODPDUODLQWHUYHQFLyQGHODGXOWR$VtPLVPR HV GH JUDQ LQWHUpV FXDQGR OH FRPHQWD TXH WDPELpQ WLHQH TXH FRPSURPHWHUVH FRQ ODV DGDSWDFLRQHVVROLFLWiQGRODVFXDQGRODVFRQVLGHUHQHFHVDULDV 6(6,Ï11 '((1(52'( (OSULPHUMXHJRHV³/RTXHKDFHHOUH\´ 3RU SDUHMDV HO ³UH\´ VH SRQH GHODQWH \ HO RWUR FRPSDxHUR OR VLJXH D P GH GLVWDQFLD LPLWDQGR WRGR OR TXH KDFH FDPELR GH GLUHFFLyQ JLURV HWF (O FRPSDxHUR GHEH KDFHU UiSLGDPHQWHORPLVPRTXHHOUH\VLQSHUGHUODGLVWDQFLD 5 5 5 5 5 'HVSXpVVHSURSRQHQHMHUFLFLRVSRUSDUHMDV LQWHQWDUSLVDUORV]DSDWRVGHOFRPSDxHUR LQWHQWDUWRFDUODHVSDOGDGHOFRPSDxHUR XQMXJDGRUFRQODVSDOPDVGHODPDQRKDFLDDUULED(ORWURFRQODV SDOPDVKDFLDDEDMRHQFLPDGHODVGHVXFRPSDxHURFHUFDSHURVLQ WRFDUVH(OTXHWLHQHODVSDOPDVKDFLDDUULEDWLHQHTXHLQWHQWDUWRFDU ODVGHVXFRPSDxHURTXHLQWHQWDUiHYLWDUHOWRTXH ³3DVDU SRU GHEDMR GHO SXHQWH´ 3RU SDUHMDV 8QR GH HOORV HVWi HVWLUDGRHQHOVXHORDXQRVPERFDDEDMR(ORWURHQODOtQHDGH VDOLGD eVWH GHEH FRUUHU KDVWD VX FRPSDxHUR \ VDOWDU VREUH pO &XDQGR HOOR RFXUUH HO MXJDGRU GHO VXHOR KDFH XQ ³SXHQWH´ \ VX FRPSDxHUR GHEH LQLFLDU HO UHJUHVR SDVDQGR SRU GHEDMR 8QD YH] OR KDUHDOL]DGRDPERVYDQKDFLDODOtQHDGHVDOLGD\FXDQGROOHJDQVH LQYLHUWHQORVUROHV &DUUHUDVGHUHOHYRVFRQWHVWLJROLQHDO 6HILQDOL]DODVHVLyQFRQXQDDFWLYLGDGGHUHODMDFLyQ (VWLUDGRVHQHOVXHORFRQORVRMRVFHUUDGRVWLHQHQTXHUHVSLUDUSURIXQGDPHQWHYHFHV VHJXLGDV3RVWHULRUPHQWHSHQVDUHQXQD SDUWH GHOFXHUSRTXHKDQWUDEDMDGR\WHQVDUOD FRQWDQGR KDVWD'HVSXpVGHMDUODUHODMDGD 6H UHSLWH FRQ RWUDV SDUWHV GHO FXHUSR 6H FRQFOX\HFRQHVWLUDPLHQWRVPXVFXODUHV 5HVSHFWRDHVWDVHVLyQODPDHVWUDHVFULEH /DSDUHMDGH0DUtDKDVLGRVLHPSUHODPLVPDFRPSDxHUDODKHHOHJLGR\DTXHQRVXHOH PRVWUDUPXFKDLQWHUUHODFLyQFRQHOOD+R\FRQVWDWRTXHKDKDELGRFRPXQLFDFLyQHLQFOXVR VHKDQJDVWDGREURPDV (QHOHMHUFLFLRDOSULQFLSLR0DUtDLQWHQWDEDSLVDUFRQHOSLHSHURHQVHJXLGDKDXWLOL]DGR OD PXOHWD \D TXH OH UHVXOWDED PiV IiFLO FRPR PH KD FRPHQWDGR DO SUHJXQWDUOH /H KH SUHJXQWDGRDVXFRPSDxHUDVLOHLPSRUWDED\PHKDUHVSRQGLGRTXHQR (QHOHMHUFLFLR0DUtDKDRSWDGRSRUVHQWDUVH\VXFRPSDxHUDKDKHFKRORPLVPR/DV KHHVWDGRREVHUYDQGR\UHtDQ\KDEODEDQGXUDQWHHOMXHJR'HVSXpVPHKDOODPDGRSDUD SHGLUPHSHUPLVRSDUDLUDOVHUYLFLR (QHOHMHUFLFLRKHRSWDGRSRUUHGXFLUODGLVWDQFLDGHUHFRUULGRGHDPEDVVLHQGRHQOD VHJXQGDUHSHWLFLyQFXDQGRODKHUHGXFLGRDXQPiVSDUDPHMRUDUODFRPSHQVDFLyQFRQHO UHVWRGHOJUXSR2WUDDGDSWDFLyQDWHQHUHQFXHQWDHQHVWDDFWLYLGDGHVODFRODERUDFLyQ GH OD FRPSDxHUD GH 0DUtD SDUD IDFLOLWDUOH ODV PXOHWDV FXDQGR OR UHTXHUtD (Q HVWD VHJXQGD VHULH KDQ TXHGDGR HQ VHJXQGR OXJDU HPSDWDQGR FRQ RWUD SDUHMD \ OR KDQ FHOHEUDGRVLQKDEHUTXHMDVSRUSDUWHGHORVGHPiV (QHOHMHUFLFLRKHGHFLGLGRDXPHQWDUDHOQ~PHURGHFRPSRQHQWHVGHOJUXSRGH0DUtD UHGXFLHQGRODVGLVWDQFLDVGHUHFRUULGRTXHWHQtDIRUPDWULDQJXODUFRQXQDMXJDGRUDHQ 5 5 5 5 5 5 FDGD YpUWLFH (Q YH] GH HQWUHJDU HO WHVWLJR EDVWDED FRQ WRFDU D OD FRPSDxHUD \ TXHGDUVHHQVXOXJDU6yORORKDQSRGLGRKDFHUXQDYH]\DTXH0DUtDKDLGRDSRQHUVH DJXDHQXQDSHTXHxDKHULGDTXHVHKDKHFKRHQXQDURGLOODHQODDFWLYLGDGDQWHULRU /D DFWLYLGDG GH UHODMDFLyQ QR KD UHTXHULGR DGDSWDFLyQ \ 0DUtD KD SDUWLFLSDGR FRPR ORV GHPiV 0LHQWUDV HO UHVWR GH FRPSDxHURV KDQ LGR D OD GXFKD 0DUtD KD SHGLGR MXJDU D ³/D 3DVWRUD´FRQORVFRPSDxHURVTXHQRVHGXFKDQ (OJUXSRGLVSHUVRSRUHOHVSDFLR\XQMXJDGRUFRQXQEDOyQGHHVSXPDeVWHSXHGHRSWDU HQ FXDQWR OR SRVHH SRU JULWDU ³SLHV TXLHWRV´ \ SRU WDQWR VXV FRPSDxHURV WLHQHQ TXH TXHGDUVH HVWiWLFRV HQ HO SXQWR GHO HVSDFLR GRQGH VH HQFXHQWUDQ \ D FRQWLQXDFLyQ LQWHQWDU WRFDU D XQ FRPSDxHUR ODQ]DQGR HO EDOyQ LPSDFWDQGR FXDOTXLHU SDUWH FRUSRUDO H[FHSWXDQGRODFDUD\FD\HQGRHOEDOyQDOVXHOR2ELHQWLHQHODSRVLELOLGDGGHGDUWUHV SDVRVFRQHOEDOyQHQODPDQRFRQHOREMHWLYRGHDSUR[LPDUVHDVXVFRPSDxHURV\GHFLU ³SLHVTXLHWRV´(QHOPRPHQWRTXHXQMXJDGRUHVWRFDGRSDVDDOD]RQDGHHOLPLQDGRV\ WDQVyORSXHGHVDOYDUVHFXDQGRLPSDFWDQDOMXJDGRUTXHORKDHOLPLQDGR &XDQGR KH HPSH]DGR D FRPHQWDU ODV DGDSWDFLRQHV DO MXHJR ORV DOXPQRV QR PH KDQ GHMDGRDFDEDUGLFLHQGRTXH\DVHDFRUGDEDQGHODVYHQWDMDVGH0DUtD &RPHQWDULRVDODVHVLyQ (VSRVLWLYDODHVWUDWHJLDGHODPDHVWUDWDQWRHQHPSDUHMDUD0DUtDFRQXQDFRPSDxHUD FRQ OD TXH QR WHQtD GHPDVLDGD UHODFLyQ FRPR HQ ODV DGDSWDFLRQHV GH ODV WDUHDV (V LQWHUHVDQWH FRPR 0DUtD WRPD GHFLVLRQHV \ WDPELpQ VX UHODFLyQ FRQ OD PDHVWUD 6H FRQVWDWDTXHODPDHVWUDLQGDJDHQODVUHVSXHVWDVGH0DUtD 6XEUD\R HO FRPHQWDULR GH TXH ORV DOXPQRV YDQ LQFRUSRUDQGR ODV DGDSWDFLRQHV FRQ QDWXUDOLGDG 6(6,Ï11 '()(%5(52'( (O JUXSR VH GHVSOD]D D XQD SLVWD GH DWOHWLVPR PXQLFLSDO \D TXH KD\ XQ HQFXHQWUR GH HVFXHODV0DUtDSDUWLFLSDHQWRGDVODVSUXHEDVDWOpWLFDVFRQODVDGDSWDFLRQHVTXH\DVH KDQDSOLFDGRHQRWUDVVHVLRQHV 6(6,Ï11 5 5 5 5 '()(%5(52'( /DVHVLyQVHLQLFLDFRQXQDH[SOLFDFLyQWHyULFDVREUHODVDFWLYLGDGHVTXHYDQDUHDOL]DU\ 5 TXpSDUWHVFRUSRUDOHVVHGHVDUUROODUiQFRQODVPLVPDV\SRUTXp7RGDVODVDFWLYLGDGHV VHUHDOL]DQHQJUXSRVGH 'RV DOXPQRV FRJLGRV GH ODV PDQRV IRUPDQ XQ FtUFXOR (O WHUFHUR IXHUDGHOFtUFXORKX\HDODSDWDFRMDPLHQWUDVVXVFRPSDxHURVGHEHQ LQWHQWDUHQOD]DUORHQWUHVXVEUD]RV 8Q MXJDGRU LQWHQWD DWUDSDU D XQ VHJXQGR (O WHUFHUR GHEH LQWHQWDU HYLWDUORLQWHUSRQLpQGRVHHQWUHHOORV &DGDPLHPEURGHOJUXSRGHWLHQHXQDOHWUDDEF7RGRVFRUUHQ OLEUHPHQWH SHUR FXDQGR R\HQ VX OHWUD GHEHQ VHQWDUVH \ VXV FRPSDxHURVFRUUHUDUHXQLUVHFRQpO 8QR HQ PHGLR FRQ ORV EUD]RV HQ FUX] /RV RWURV GRV DUURGLOODGRV D FDGD ODGR DJDUUiQGROR GH OD PDQR eVWRV WLUDQ GH VX FRPSDxHUR KDFLDVt(OTXHHVWiHQPHGLRLQWHQWDUiQRGHVHTXLOLEUDUVH &RQ OD PLVPD GLVSRVLFLyQ TXH HQ HO HMHUFLFLR DQWHULRU ORV DOXPQRV GHORVODWHUDOHVHVWDUiQVHQWDGRVFRQODVSLHUQDVDELHUWDV\FRQODV SODQWDV GH ORV SLHV HQ FRQWDFWR eVWRV LQWHQWDUiQ OHYDQWDUVH IOH[LRQDQGRORVEUD]RV\VLQGREODUODVSLHUQDV(OFRPSDxHURGHHQ PHGLRLQWHQWDUiD\XGDUORVWLUDQGRGHVXVPDQRV\D\XGiQGRVHGHOD IOH[LyQGHSLHUQDV 8Q MXJDGRU VH VLW~D HQ SRVLFLyQ GH SRWUR $ P HO VHJXQGR HQ SXHQWH LQYHUWLGR (O WHUFHUR GHEHUi VDOWDU VREUH HO SULPHUR SDVDUi SRU GHEDMR GHO VHJXQGR \ DGRSWDUi OD SRVWXUD GHO SULPHUR \ DVt VXFHVLYDPHQWH 'RVHQFXFOLOODVFRQORVRMRVFHUUDGRV(OWHUFHURLQWHQWDUiKDFHUOHV SHUGHU HO HTXLOLEULR PHGLDQWH HPSXMRQHV VXDYHV eVWRV GHEHUiQ PDQWHQHUHOHTXLOLEULRFRQORVEUD]RVSHURVLQDSR\DUVHHQHOVXHOR /DPDHVWUDHVFULEH 'HFLGR IRUPDU ORV JUXSRV GH WUHV SRQLHQGR MXQWR D 0DUtD D GRV FRPSDxHUDV GH FRPSOH[LyQSDUHFLGD\FRQODVTXHVHOOHYDELHQ 5HVSHFWRDODVDFWLYLGDGHVFRPHQWDUTXHHQODSULPHUDKDKDELGRPXFKDFRPXQLFDFLyQ HQWUHHOODV\QRKHWHQLGRTXHLQWHUYHQLU+DQDFRUGDGRTXHFXDQGRHOODWHQtDTXHIRUPDU HOFtUFXORVXFRPSDxHUDODDJDUUDUtDSRUXQEUD]R\ORFHUUDUtDDODWUDSDUDODMXJDGRUD TXHKX\H (QORVHMHUFLFLRV\QRKHWHQLGRTXHLQWHUYHQLU\DTXHQRKDUHTXHULGRDGDSWDFLyQ/D KHYLVWRPX\FRQWHQWDSDUWLFLSDWLYD\PX\FRPSHWLWLYD (Q ORV HMHUFLFLRV \ 0DUtD KD PRVWUDGR PXFKD PRWLYDFLyQ \ EXHQ KXPRU ULpQGRVH FDGDYH]TXHHOODRVXVFRPSDxHUDVVHFDtDQRQRSRGtDQOHYDQWDUVH0HOODPDQSDUD TXH YHD FyPR MXHJDQ \ KDFHUPH SDUWtFLSH GH VXV ULVDV (QWUH HOODV FRPHQWDQ OR TXH KDFHQPDO\FyPRPHMRUDUOR (Q HO HMHUFLFLR FXDQGR 0DUtD KDFH GH SRWUR VH SRQH GH URGLOODV FRQ HO WURQFR KDFLD GHODQWH/DVFRPSDxHUDVFXDQGR0DUtDGHEHVDOWDUWDPELpQVHSRQHQGHURGLOODVSDUD IDFLOLWDUVXSDVRFRPRVLHVWXYLHUDKDFLHQGRHOVDOWRGHYDOODV 5 5 5 (QOD~OWLPDDFWLYLGDGVHFRORFDGHURGLOODV\FXDQGRODFRPSDxHUDOHWRFDORKDFHPX\ VXDYHPHQWH 3DUDILQDOL]DUFRPHQWDUTXH0DUtDVHPXHVWUD~OWLPDPHQWHPX\PRWLYDGDFRPXQLFDWLYD \SDUWLFLSDWLYD(PSLH]DDPDGXUDU\DQRKDEODFRPRXQDQLxDSHTXHxD &RPHQWDULRVDODVHVLyQ (V LQWHUHVDQWH TXH HQ HVWD VHVLyQ ODV SURSLDV FRPSDxHUDV DGDSWDQ MXQWR D 0DUtD ODV DFWLYLGDGHV VLQ UHTXHULU OD LQWHUYHQFLyQ GH OD PDHVWUD 'HVWDFD WDPELpQ HO FDPELR GH DFWLWXGGH0DUtDPXFKRPiVPDGXUDTXHDOLQLFLRGHODREVHUYDFLyQ 127$$&/$5$725,$ $ SDUWLU GH OD VLJXLHQWH VHVLyQ KDVWD OD ~OWLPD VHPDQD GH PD\R ODV VHVLRQHV FRUUHVSRQGLHQWHVDORVPLpUFROHVHVWiQUHJLVWUDGDVSRUODPDHVWUDGH(GXFDFLyQ)tVLFD GDGR TXH HQ HO VHJXQGR VHPHVWUH HVWD VHVLyQ FRLQFLGH FRQ PL GRFHQFLD HQ OD 8QLYHUVLGDG 6(6,Ï11 '()(%5(52'( /DPDHVWUDLQLFLDODVHVLyQFRQ³/DFDUUHUDGHOQ~PHUR´ (QJUXSRVGHHQILODLQGLDVHQWDGRVHQHOVXHOR\DXQDGLVWDQFLDHQWUHHOORVGHP &DGD PLHPEUR GHO JUXSR WLHQH XQ Q~PHUR &XDQGR OD PDHVWUD GLJD XQ Q~PHUR HO SRVHHGRU GH HVWH Q~PHUR VDOGUi GH OD ILOD SRU OD GHUHFKD OR URGHDUi \ UHJUHVDUiDVXSRVLFLyQLQLFLDOGDQGRXQDYXHOWDFRPSOHWDDOJUXSR 3URSRQHODYDULDQWHGHGHFLUGRVQ~PHURV /DPDHVWUDRSWDSRUUHGXFLUXQPLHPEURHQHOJUXSRGH0DUtD$SHVDUGHHOORGDGRTXH ODVLWXDFLyQGHGHVYHQWDMDFRQWLQ~DVLHQGRVLJQLILFDWLYD0DUtDHVSRQWiQHDPHQWHDGDSWD ODDFWLYLGDG6HVLW~DGHSLH\HQYH]GHGDUWRGDODYXHOWDKDFHODPLWDGGHOUHFRUULGR/D PDHVWUDORDFHSWD\DQWHVXFRPHQWDULRHORJLRVR0DUtDVHSRQHPX\FRQWHQWD 0DUtDVHPXHVWUDPX\DWHQWDDOHUWDQGRDORVFRPSDxHURVTXHVHGHVSLVWDQ(VWiPX\ FRQWHQWD \ SDUWLFLSDWLYD JHQHUDQGR LQWHUDFFLRQHV FRQWLQXDV FRQ VXV FRPSDxHURV GH JUXSR 3RVWHULRUPHQWHSURSRQHXQDDFWLYLGDGGHODVHVLyQDQWHULRU 'RVDOXPQRVFRJLGRVGHODVPDQRVIRUPDQXQFtUFXOR(OWHUFHURIXHUDGHOFtUFXORKX\HD ODSDWDFRMDPLHQWUDVVXVFRPSDxHURVGHEHQLQWHQWDUHQOD]DUORHQWUHVXVEUD]RV 5 5 5 5 5 5 /DDGDSWDFLyQHVODPLVPD2EVHUYDPRVDXQD0DUtDPX\VRQULHQWH\PX\PRWLYDGDSRU ODGLQiPLFDGHODVHVLyQ $FRQWLQXDFLyQSURSRQHHOMXHJRGH³/DVOHWUDV´ (QJUXSRVGHORVJUXSRVGHEHQGLVHxDUODIRUPDGHODOHWUDTXHGLJDODPDHVWUDFRQORV FXHUSRVWHQGLGRVHQHOVXHOR(O~OWLPRJUXSRHQFRQVHJXLUORTXHGDHOLPLQDGR 3HUFLELPRVTXHODVFRPSDxHUDVGH0DUtDVHSRQHQPX\SUy[LPDVDHOODSDUDIDFLOLWDUOH ORVPRYLPLHQWRV&XDQGRVRQHOLPLQDGDV0DUtDVHVLHQWDHQXQOXJDUGHOFDPSROHMRVGH OD]RQDGHHOLPLQDGRV(QHOPRPHQWRTXHVXVFRPSDxHUDVVHGDQFXHQWDKDEODQHQWUH HOODV\GHFLGHQLUMXQWRD0DUtD /DSHQ~OWLPDDFWLYLGDGHVWDPELpQUHSHWLGDGHODVHVLyQDQWHULRU *UXSRVGH8QRHQPHGLRFRQORVEUD]RVHQFUX]/RVDOXPQRVGHORVODWHUDOHVHVWDUiQ VHQWDGRV FRQ ODV SLHUQDV DELHUWDV FRQ ODV SODQWDV GH ORV SLHV HQ FRQWDFWR eVWRV LQWHQWDUiQOHYDQWDUVHIOH[LRQDQGRORVEUD]RV\VLQGREODUODVSLHUQDV(OFRPSDxHURGHHQ PHGLRLQWHQWDUiD\XGDUORVWLUDQGRGHVXVPDQRV\D\XGiQGRVHGHODIOH[LyQGHSLHUQDV 0DUtD FRQVLJXH SRQHUVH GH SLH MXQWDPHQWH FRQ VX FRPSDxHUD PRVWUiQGRVH PX\ FRQWHQWD\VRQULHQWHSRUHOORJUR 3RU~OWLPRVHSURSRQHQHMHUFLFLRVGHUHODMDFLyQVLPLODUHVDORVGHODVHVLyQDQWHULRU &RPHQWDULRVDODVHVLyQ 3HUFLER D 0DUtD DOHJUH FRPXQLFDWLYD FRQ LQLFLDWLYD HQ ODV UHODFLRQHV FRQ VXV FRPSDxHURV \ HQ OD UHDOL]DFLyQ GH ODV DFWLYLGDGHV 6H REVHUYD XQD HYROXFLyQ PX\ SRVLWLYD H[SUHViQGRVH FODUDPHQWH \ DOHMiQGRVH GHO LQIDQWLOLVPR TXH OD FDUDFWHUL]DED DO SULQFLSLR GHO FXUVR 1R REVWDQWH PH OODPD OD DWHQFLyQ OD DFWLWXG GH 0DUtD FXDQGR HV HOLPLQDGDHQHO~OWLPRMXHJR¢TXpQHFHVLGDGWLHQHGHDOHMDUVHGHOUHVWRGHOJUXSR"¢SRU TXp OR KDFH"(VFXULRVDWDPELpQODUHVSXHVWD GH VXV FRPSDxHUDV HQ YH] GH OODPDUOD SDUDTXHYD\DFRQHOODVDOD]RQDGHHOLPLQDGRVVRQHOODVODVTXHYDQDVXHQFXHQWUR 6(6,Ï11 '()(%5(52'( (QODVHVLyQSURSRQJRODVVLJXLHQWHVDFWLYLGDGHVFRQFXHUGD &DGD DOXPQR FRQ XQD FXHUGD GHEHUi VDOWDU KDFLD GHODQWH \ FRQWDU FXiQWRVVDOWRVUHDOL]DËGHPKDFLDDWUiV 6DOWDU FRQ OD SLHUQD GHUHFKD D OD SDWD FRMD OXHJR FRQ OD L]TXLHUGD +DFLDGHODQWH\KDFLDDWUiV&RPELQDQGRODVSRVLELOLGDGHV 'DUWUHVVDOWRVKDFLDGHODQWHJLUDUODFXHUGDGHL]TXLHUGDDGHUHFKD\ GHQXHYRGDUWUHVVDOWRV ËGHPTXHHODQWHULRUSHURFUX]DQGRORVEUD]RV\VDOWDU 5 5 5 5 5 5 5 5 &RQ ORV EUD]RV H[WHQGLGRV VREUH OD FDEH]D KDFHU PROLQRV H LU EDMDQGRHOFXHUSRVLQFUX]DUORVEUD]RV &RQ OD FXHUGD SOHJDGD HQ GREOHFHV HVWLUDGD FRQ ORV EUD]RV H[WHQGLGRVVREUHODFDEH]DGDUXQVDOWRLQIHULRUVLQVROWDUODFXHUGD 3RU SDUHMDV /D FXHUGD XQH HO SLH GHUHFKR GH XQ MXJDGRU \ HO L]TXLHUGRGHORWUR6HMXHJDD³SLOODU´8QDSDUHMDSDUD\GHEHDWUDSDU DOUHVWR/DSDUHMDWRFDGDTXHGDHOLPLQDGD 6DOWDUDODFRPEDWRGRHOJUXSR'RVKDFHUJLUDUODFXHUGD\HOUHVWR HQILODGHEHQLUVDOWDQGR /DPDHVWUDHVFULEHGHFDGDHMHUFLFLR 0DUtDKDFHILJXUDVJHRPpWULFDVFRQODFXHUGDFtUFXORFXDGUDGRUHFWiQJXOR 3URSRQJR D 0DUtD TXH GH URGLOODV KDJD ³FXOHEULOODV´ FRQ OD FXHUGD FDPELDQGR GH PDQR 'LJRD0DUtDTXHVHHQUROOHHQODPXxHFDODSDUWHGLVWDOGHODFXHUGD'HURGLOODV\ GHVSXpVVHQWDGDWLHQHTXHGLEXMDUHQHODLUHHOVLJQRGHODPXOWLSOLFDFLyQ 0DUtDVHFRORFDHVWLUDGDERFDDUULED/DFXHUGDDJDUUDGDSRUORVH[WUHPRV\SDVDQGR SRUODSODQWDGHORVSLHV'HEHWLUDUGHHOODKDVWDWHQHUORVSLHVHQYHUWLFDOHQ ËGHPTXHHOUHVWRGHOJUXSRSHURGHURGLOODV 0DUtD WLHQH OD FXHUGD GREODGD SRU OD PLWDG VHQWDGD FRQ ORV EUD]RV HVWLUDGRV SRU HQFLPDGHODFDEH]D7LHQHTXHLUEDMDQGRORVEUD]RVSDVDUODFXHUGDSRUGHEDMRGH ODVSLHUQDVOHYDQWDQGRHOWUDVHUR\VXELUODSRUGHWUiVGHODHVSDOGDTXHGDQGRHQOD SRVLFLyQLQLFLDO /RV DOXPQRV SLGHQ HOHJLU D VX SDUHMD $ HOOD QR OD KDQ HVFRJLGR MXQWR FRQ WUHV FRPSDxHURVPiV/DRWUDQLxDQRHOHJLGDDOYHUTXHGRVVRQFKLFRVGHFLGHMXQWDUVH FRQ0DUtDDXQTXHQRPXHVWUDPXFKRHQWXVLDVPR0HDFHUFRDHOOD\OHGLJRTXHVL WLHQHDOJ~QSUREOHPD0HGLFHTXHQR/HVFRPHQWRTXHQRWHQGUiQORVSLHVDWDGRV SDUD TXH 0DUtD VH GHVSODFH PiV FyPRGDPHQWH /D FRPSDxHUD GH 0DUtD PH SUHJXQWDVLODGHEHFRJHUSRUORVKRPEURV/HGLJRTXHFRPRpVWDHVPiVDOWDPHMRU DJDUUDUODSRUODFLQWXUD6HLQLFLDHOMXHJRSLOODQGRHOODV2EVHUYRTXHODFRPSDxHUD GH0DUtDHVWiVHULD\QDGDFRPXQLFDWLYDFRQHOODGHMDQGRTXHpVWDVHDTXLHQSLOOH (QFDPELR0DUtDHVWiGLYLUWLpQGRVH\UtH0HDFHUFRDODFRPSDxHUDGH0DUtD\OH H[SOLFRTXHHVXQMXHJRSRUSDUHMDV\TXHVRQODVGRVODVTXHGHEHQSLOODU\GHFLGLUD TXp SDUHMD HOLPLQDQ (O FRPHQWDULR IXQFLRQD \ DPEDV FRODERUDQ KDVWD HO ILQDO GHO MXHJRFRQXQDDFWLWXGSRVLWLYDFRPXQLFDWLYD\DOHJUH 0DUtD\\RKDFHPRVURGDUODFXHUGD0HGR\FXHQWDGHORVFRPSDxHURVTXHOHFDHQ PHMRU\ORVTXHQR\DTXHDFHOHUDHOPRYLPLHQWRGHODFXHUGDSDUDHOLPLQDUDORVTXH OHFDHQPDO'HVSXpVGHFLGRTXHHOHOLPLQDGRRFXSHPLSXHVWR(OODSUHJXQWDVLGHEH GHMDUGHURGDU/HSUHJXQWRVLTXLHUHGHMDUGHKDFHUOR\PHFRQWHVWDTXHQR&DGD YH]TXHUXHGDKDFHFRPHQWDULRVFRQWLQXRVDVXVFRPSDxHURV³WLHQHVTXHGDUOHPiV IXHUWH´³PiVUiSLGR´ 5 5 5 &XDQGRVXPDGUHYLHQHDEXVFDUODOHSLGHTXHODGHMHPLQXWRVPiV/DPDGUHOHGLFH TXH OD DPEXODQFLD HVSHUD 6H GHPRUD HQ SRQHUVH HO DQRUDN FRPR SURYRFDQGR 0LHQWUDVWDQWRKDEORFRQODPDGUHFRPHQWiQGROHORVFDPELRVSRVLWLYRVTXHREVHUYRHQ 0DUtDVXHYROXFLyQ\ORELHQTXHVHORSDVD0DUtDVHGDFXHQWDGHTXHKDEODPRVGHHOOD \HQVHJXLGDVHDFHUFDHLQWHUYLHQHHQODFRQYHUVDFLyQ &RPHQWDULRVDODVHVLyQ (V LQWHUHVDQWH TXH VLHQGR XQD VHVLyQ GH DFWLYLGDGHV LQGLYLGXDOHV OD PDHVWUD DGDSWD WRGDV HOODV SDUD TXH 0DUtD SXHGD SDUWLFLSDU LQGLYLGXDOL]DQGR ODV SURSXHVWDV SHUR WUDEDMDQGRFRQHOJUXSR 6HGHVSUHQGHGHWRGRHOORODFDSDFLGDGGRFHQWHGHODPDHVWUDSDUDGDUUHVSXHVWDDODV QHFHVLGDGHVGHOJUXSRVLQH[FOXLUDQDGLH 0HOODPDODDWHQFLyQODDFWLWXGGHODFRPSDxHUDGH0DUtDHQHOMXHJR8QDDSDWtDTXH GHVDSDUHFH QR VDEHPRV VL GH PDQHUD VLQFHUD FRQ OD LQWHUYHQFLyQ GH OD PDHVWUD TXH FRQVLJXHTXHODFRPSDxHUDGH0DUtDHQWLHQGDTXHODFRPSHQVDFLyQGHODVOLPLWDFLRQHV GHEHVHUMXVWDWDQWRSDUD0DUtDFRPRSDUDHOUHVWRGHOJUXSR (V LQWHUHVDQWH OD FRQYHUVDFLyQ GH OD PDHVWUD FRQ OD PDGUH GH 0DUtD UHFRQRFLHQGR VX FDPELR GHDFWLWXGVXHYROXFLyQHYLGHQFLDGD HQ TXH VH OR SDVD ELHQ HQ OD FODVH HQVX SDUWLFLSDFLyQ\FRQWDFWRFRQORVFRPSDxHURV 6(6,Ï11 '()(%5(52'( 6HGHGLFyODVHVLyQDODVHQVLELOL]DFLyQUHVSHFWRDODVSHUVRQDVFRQGLVFDSDFLGDG3DUD HOOR VH FRQWy FRQ OD SUHVHQFLD GH ;DYLHU %XUJXHUD GHSRUWLVWD XVXDULR GH PXOHWDV HVSHFLDOLVWDHQDFWLYLGDGHVHQODQDWXUDOH]D ;DYLHU LQLFLy OD VHVLyQ H[SOLFDQGR ODV PRGDOLGDGHV GHSRUWLYDV TXH SUDFWLFDED SDVDQGR GHVSXpVDKDEODUGHODYLGDFRWLGLDQDGHOFROHFWLYRGHSHUVRQDVFRQGLVFDSDFLGDGPRWUL] ODV DFWLWXGHV GH ORV GHPiV ODV EDUUHUDV DUTXLWHFWyQLFDV HO GHUHFKR DO WUDEDMR D OD HGXFDFLyQ \ DO RFLR (O JUXSR VH PXHVWUD PX\ FXULRVR UHVSHFWR D ODV PRGDOLGDGHV GHSRUWLYDV TXH H[SOLFD ;DYLHU \ KDFH QXPHURVDV SUHJXQWDV UHVSHFWR D ODV SHUVRQDV XVXDULDVGHVLOODGHUXHGDVFyPRFRQGXFHHOFRFKHFyPRYDDOODYDERFyPRVHYLVWH 0DUtDHQFDPELRVHPXHVWUDSDVLYD\QRKDFHSUHJXQWDV (QHOPRPHQWRTXHVHGLULJHDOJUXSR\KDEODGH0DUtDOHVSUHJXQWDTXpSLHQVDQGHHOOD FRPR FRPSDxHUD 8Q SDU GH DOXPQRV FRQWHVWDQ TXH OD D\XGDQ D EDMDU ODV HVFDOHUDV \ RWUR GLFH TXH HV XQD EXHQD DPLJD 2WUR DxDGH TXH HQ ODV H[FXUVLRQHV OD D\XGDQ D HPSXMDU OD VLOOD GH UXHGDV SRUTXH OHV JXVWD KDFHUOR $ OR TXH 0DUtD FRPHQWD TXH OHV JXVWDWDQWRTXHTXLHUHQPRQWDUVHHQVXVLOOD /RVPLpUFROHVSRUODWDUGHXQDDPEXODQFLDWUDVODGDD0DUtDDOFHQWURGHUHKDELOLWDFLyQ 5 5 5 5 (V LQWHUHVDQWH FXDQGR ;DYLHU SUHJXQWD TXLpQ VDEH TXp SDWRORJtD WLHQH 0DUtD 8QR FRQWHVWDTXH³XQGtDPHORGLMRVHFD\y´$QWHHOOR;DYLHUVHORSUHJXQWDDODPLVPD 0DUtD\VRUSUHQGHQWHPHQWHGLFH³1RVpORVDEHPLPDGUH´ ;DYLHU OHV SUHJXQWD TXH VL SUHILHUHQ TXH 0DUtD HVWp FRQ HOORV R HQ XQD HVFXHOD GH (GXFDFLyQ(VSHFLDO7RGRVVHPXHVWUDQSDUWLGDULRVGHTXHHVWpFRQHOORV $OILQDOFXDQGROHSUHJXQWDD0DUtDVLHVWiFRQWHQWDGHVXVFRPSDxHURVpVWDVHFDOOD\ QRFRQWHVWD &XDQGRODPDHVWUDOHVSLGHTXHVHGHVSLGDQGH;DYLHU\OHGHQODVJUDFLDV0DUtDQROR KDFH\VHYDODSULPHUD &RPHQWDULRVDODVHVLyQ (V FXULRVD OD DFWLWXG GH 0DUtD DQWH DOJXLHQ FRQ XQD GLVFDSDFLGDG VLPLODU 6H PXHVWUD GLVWDQWHQRVHGHVSLGHQRFRQWHVWDSDUHFHTXHKD\DOJ~QFRQIOLFWRHQODDFHSWDFLyQGH VXUHDOLGDGTXHVHSRQHGHPDQLILHVWRFXDQGRGLFHGHVFRQRFHUFXiOHVVXGLVFDSDFLGDG GHVSOD]DQGRODUHVSXHVWDDVXPDGUH (O JUXSR VH PXHVWUD PX\ LQWHUHVDGR WDQWR SRU HO GHSRUWH DGDSWDGR FRPR SRU OD YLGD FRWLGLDQD3RGHPRVFRQFOXLUTXHWLHQHXQEXHQQLYHOGHVHQVLELOL]DFLyQ\GHFRQRFLPLHQWR KDFLD ODV SHUVRQDV FRQ GLVFDSDFLGDG PRWUL] TXH VH PDQLILHVWD DO RSLQDU TXH 0DUtD QR GHEHHVWDUHQXQDHVFXHODGHHGXFDFLyQHVSHFLDO 6(6,Ï11 5 5 5 5 5 '()(%5(52'( 'DGRTXHOOXHYHODPDHVWUDGHFLGHSUR\HFWDUHQHODXODHOYtGHRGHOHQFXHQWURDWOpWLFR TXHWXYROXJDUHOGHIHEUHUR 5 '()(%5(52'( 6HGHGLFyODVHVLyQDODVHQVLELOL]DFLyQUHVSHFWRDODVSHUVRQDVFRQGLVFDSDFLGDG3DUD HOOR VH FRQWy FRQ OD SUHVHQFLD GH /XLV 3UDGDO XQD SHUVRQD FLHJD TXH HV DERJDGR ILVLRWHUDSHXWD\P~VLFR /DVHVLyQVHFHQWUyVREUHODDXWRQRPtDGHODVSHUVRQDVFLHJDV\VXGHUHFKRDOOHYDUXQD YLGDSOHQDHQVRFLHGDGSHVHDODVGLILFXOWDGHVTXHVXSRQHODFHJXHUD 7RGRHOJUXSRVHPXHVWUDPX\DWHQWR\IRUPXODSUHJXQWDVFRQVWDQWHPHQWHLQFOXVRVREUH ODYLYHQFLDGHODFHJXHUDVXRULJHQVREUHODYLGDFRWLGLDQD/HVOODPyPXFKRODDWHQFLyQ OD PDQHUD GH XWLOL]DU HO RUGHQDGRU SRUWiWLO OD DGDSWDFLyQ DO VLVWHPD %UDLOOH WRGRV VH SXVLHURQDVXDOUHGHGRUREVHUYDQGRFyPR/XLVWUDEDMDEDFRQHO3& 5 6(6,Ï11 5 (QHVWRVPRPHQWRVTXHHOJUXSRVHOHYDQWDDOUHJUHVDUDVXVVLOODV0DUtDYHTXHODVX\D HVWi RFXSDGD SRU RWUR QLxR 6H HQIDGD \ SLGH OD LQWHUYHQFLyQ GH OD PDHVWUD SDUD TXH LQWHUFHGDFRQHOILQGHUHFXSHUDUVXOXJDU3RFRGHVSXpVVXFHGHORPLVPR\0DUtDRSWD SRUVHQWDUVHHQHOVXHORHQXQULQFyQFDEL]EDMD6HTXHGDDOOtKDVWDTXHSRFRGHVSXpV ILQDOL]DODVHVLyQ\VHYDODSULPHUDVLQGHVSHGLUVHGH/XLV &RPHQWDULRVDODVHVLyQ $OLJXDOTXHFXDQGR;DYLHUOHVYLVLWy0DUtDWDPSRFRIRUPXODSUHJXQWDV\VHPDQWLHQHDO PDUJHQ GHODDFWLYLGDG0X\SDVLYDSDUHFH TXHOHLQFRPRGDODSUHVHQFLDGHSHUVRQDV FRQ GLVFDSDFLGDG 6X PDUFKD SUHFLSLWDGD GH OD VHVLyQ VLQ GHVSHGLUVH GH /XLV SXHGH LQWHUSUHWDUVHFRPRXQDDFWLWXGLUUHVSHWXRVDKDFLDRWUDVSHUVRQDVFRQGLVFDSDFLGDG 6(6,Ï11 5 5 '()(%5(52'( 1RKD\VHVLyQSUiFWLFDSRUOOXYLD6HSUR\HFWDXQYtGHRHQHODXODVREUHORVVHQWLGRV 5 '(0$5=2'( (QODVHVLyQVHWUDEDMDHOHTXLOLEULRPHGLDQWHODVVLJXLHQWHVDFWLYLGDGHV /DSULPHUDHV³/DVHVWDWXDVFRQ]DQFRV´ /RVDOXPQRVFRQ]DQFRVUHSDUWLGRVOLEUHPHQWHSRUHOHVSDFLR6HGHVSOD]DQFRUULHQGRR FDPLQDQGR\FXDQGRODPDHVWUDKDFHVRQDUHOVLOEDWRWLHQHQTXHTXHGDUVHTXLHWRVFRPR HVWDWXDV 9DULDQWH FXDQGR R\HQ GRV VLOEDWRV GHEHQ OHYDQWDU OD SLHUQD GHUHFKD 6L VRQ WUHV OD L]TXLHUGD 0DUtD VXVWLWX\H ORV ]DQFRV SRU ODV PXOHWDV VLJXLHQGR ODV PLVPDV FRQVLJQDV 6X SDUWLFLSDFLyQHVPX\DFWLYDPRVWUiQGRVHPX\PRWLYDGDSRUHOMXHJR 3DUD OD VLJXLHQWH DFWLYLGDG OD PDHVWUD UHSDUWH HQWUH ORV DOXPQRV GLYHUVRV GLEXMRV FRQ ILJXUDVDUHDOL]DUSRUSDUHMDV\WUtRV0DUtDEXVFDODSRVLFLyQTXHOHUHVXOWDPiVFyPRGD\ SDUWLFLSDVLQSUREOHPDV1RREVWDQWHFXDQGRVHRUJDQL]DQOLEUHPHQWHODVSDUHMDV\WUtRV 0DUtDWLHQHGHSDUHMDDXQDFRPSDxHUDFRQODTXHQRKD\DILQLGDG\DFLWDGDHQODVHVLyQ QDODTXHGHQRPLQDUHPRV³3DWULFLD´0DUtD\3DWULFLDVHPXHVWUDQPX\SDVLYDV\OD PDHVWUD OHV WLHQH TXH DGYHUWLU TXH GHEHQ KDFHU OD DFWLYLGDG FRPR HO UHVWR GHO JUXSR &XDQGRIRUPDQWUtRVHOJUXSRGH0DUtDHVGH3DWULFLDVLJXHHQHOJUXSR\ODDFWLWXGGH 0DUtDFDPELD\VHPXHVWUDSDUWLFLSDWLYD\PX\DFWLYDFRQODVRWUDVGRVFRPSDxHUDV 5 6(6,Ï11 5 5 2EVHUYDPRV TXH 0DUtD QR VXHOH EXVFDU JUXSRV HVSHUDQGR VHQWDGD D TXH ORV FRPSDxHURVOHGLJDQDOJRSDUDXQLUVHDHOORV &RPHQWDULRVDODVHVLyQ 6H HYLGHQFLD XQ FRQIOLFWR HQWUH 0DUtD \ 3DWULFLD DO FXDO GHEHUHPRV SUHVWDU DWHQFLyQ 'HERDQRWDUTXHWDQWR3DWULFLDFRPR0DUtDVXHOHQVHUODV~OWLPDVHQVHUHVFRJLGDVHQORV JUXSRVWDOYH]VHDXQSUREOHPDGHFDUiFWHU (VQHFHVDULRVHJXLUODDFWLWXGSDVLYDGH0DUtDHQHOPRPHQWRGHRUJDQL]DUVHJUXSRV 6(6,Ï11 '(0$5=2'( /DVHVLyQVHGHGLFDDHMHUFLFLRVGHIXHU]D &DOHQWDPLHQWRFDUUHUDVXDYHGXUDQWHPLQ$ODVHxDOWXPEDUVHHQ FXFOLOODV \ GDU SDVRV SLHUQDV MXQWDV \ WRFDUVH ODV SXQWDV GH ORV SLHVWRUVLyQGHWURQFRGHUHFKDL]TXLHUGDFDPLQDUKDFLHQGRPROLQRV GH EUD]RV DGHODQWH \ DWUiV PRYLOL]DFLyQ GH GLYHUVDV DUWLFXODFLRQHV JLURVGHUHFKDL]TXLHUGDKDFLDGHODQWHDWUiV\FRPSOHWR 4XLWDUODFRODDO]RUURSRUSDUHMDVFDGDXQROOHYDXQSDxXHORGHWUiV GHOSDQWDOyQ$ODVHxDOVHWUDWDGHTXLWDUHOSDxXHORDODSDUHMDVLQ TXHOHTXLWHQHOVX\R 3HOHDGHJDOORV3RUSDUHMDV\HQFXFOLOODVFRQXQDGHODVPDQRVHQ ODHVSDOGDVHWUDWDGHGHVHTXLOLEUDUDOFRPSDxHUR /XFKD LQJOHVD SRU SDUHMDV IUHQWH SRU IUHQWH 6H WUDWD GH FRORFDUVH GHWUiVGHODGYHUVDULR\URGHDUORSRUODFLQWXUDFRQORVEUD]RV /DV WRUWXJDV 3RU SDUHMDV XQR WXPEDGR ERFD DEDMR (O RWUR GHEH LQWHQWDUJLUDUORERFDDUULEDVLQWRFDUOHODFDEH]D -XHJRGHPDWDUFRQUH\/RVMXJDGRUHVVHGLVWULEX\HQHQGRVJUXSRVVHSDUDGRV SRUXQDOtQHDFHQWUDO(OHVSDFLRHVWiGHOLPLWDGR(OREMHWLYRGHOMXHJRHVHOLPLQDUDO HTXLSRFRQWUDULR3DUDHOORFXDQGRVHODQ]DHOEDOyQGHHVSXPDHLPSDFWDDXQ DGYHUVDULRWRFiQGRORHQFXDOTXLHUSDUWHFRUSRUDOH[FHSWXDQGRODFDUD\ORVSLHV\ FDHSRVWHULRUPHQWHHOEDOyQDOVXHORVHFRQVLGHUDPXHUWReVWHVHGHVSOD]DKDFLD XQRGHORVGRVH[WUHPRVODWHUDOHVGHOFDPSRGHORVMXJDGRUHVDGYHUVDULRV GHQRPLQDGD]RQDGHPXHUWRV\GHVGHDOOtLQWHQWD³PDWDU´DXQDGYHUVDULR'HQR FRQVHJXLUORWLHQHTXHHVSHUDUKDVWDTXHVXVFRPSDxHURVOHSDVHQHOEDOyQRELHQ TXHORSXHGDFRQVHJXLUSRUTXHHOEDOyQKDHQWUDGRDVX]RQDGHMXHJRVRELHQ SRUTXHVHORSDVHHOUH\eVWHHVWiORFDOL]DGRHQHOWHUFHUODWHUDOGHOFDPSRTXH TXHGDOLEUHGHIRUPDIURQWDO\WLHQHHOSRGHUGHWHQHUGRVYLGDVHQHOLQLFLRGHO MXHJR6tFRQVLJXHPDWDUDXQDGYHUVDULRVXPDXQDWHUFHUDYLGDSDViQGRVHODD DOJ~QFRPSDxHURTXHHVWpHQDOJXQDGHODVGRV]RQDVODWHUDOHVGHPXHUWRVSRUOR 5 5 5 5 5 5 5 5 5 TXHVHSRGUiOLEHUDU\WUDVODGDUVHDOFDPSRGHMXHJRFRQVXHTXLSR(QHO PRPHQWRTXHXQHTXLSRVHTXHGDWDQVyORFRQGRVMXJDGRUHV\HOUHVWRHVWiQ PXHUWRVHOUH\SDVDDOD]RQDGHMXHJRFRQVXVGRVYLGDV\VHUiFXDOTXLHU FRPSDxHURPXHUWRTXHDVXPDHOUROGHUH\KDVWDTXHHOLPLQHQDORULJLQDORELHQ KDVWDTXHVHFRQVLJDDXPHQWDUHOQ~PHURGHMXJDGRUHVHQHOWHUUHQRGHMXHJRD WUHVGHWDOIRUPDTXHHOUH\UHJUHVDUiGHQXHYRDOD]RQDGHPXHUWRV /DPDHVWUDHVFULEH (QHOHMHUFLFLRRUJDQL]RJUXSRV\0DUtDHVWiHQHOTXHFRUUHHQHOFDPSRGHYROHLERO SDUD TXH SXHGD LU D VX ULWPR HV PiV UHGXFLGR TXH ORV RWURV ±FDPSR GH EiVTXHW \ I~WERO(QODDFWLYLGDGGHFXFOLOODV0DUtDORKDFHGHSLHGHVSOD]iQGRVHDSLHVMXQWRV(Q ODDFWLYLGDGGHORVPROLQRVFRQEUD]RV0DUtDKDVHJXLGRFDPLQDQGR 3DUDHOUHVWRGHDFWLYLGDGHVXQQLxRODKDHOHJLGRFRPRSDUHMDGHMXHJR(QODDFWLYLGDG KHRtGRTXH0DUtDOHGHFtDDVXFRPSDxHURTXHQROHFRJLHVHHQVHJXLGD\TXHHOODQR OHFRJHUtDHOSDxXHORVLQRTXHOHWRFDUtDFRQODPXOHWD'HVSXpVPHKDQFRPHQWDGROR SDFWDGR \ OHV KH GLFKR TXH PX\ ELHQ (O FRPSDxHUR OH KD GLFKR D 0DUtD ³YHV FRPR OH SDUHFHELHQ"´$OILQDOL]DUODDFWLYLGDGOHVSHJXQWRFyPRKDQTXHGDGR3ULPHUREURPHDQ ³D´/XHJRPHGLFHQTXHHVPHQWLUD³DDIDYRUGHOQLxR´ (Q OD DFWLYLGDG0DUtDVHKDSXHVWRDUURGLOODGD\VXFRPSDxHURHQFXFOLOODV0DUtDVH GHMDEDFDHUDOPtQLPRURFH+HLQWHUYHQLGRREVHUYDQGRTXHGHEtDQKDFHUORELHQ (QODDFWLYLGDGKDQYHQLGRDSUHJXQWDUPHFyPRORSRGtDKDFHU0DUtD/HVKHGLFKRTXH VLHOODVHSRQtDGHWUiV\DVHFRQVLGHUDEDTXHKDEtDKHFKRSXQWR6HKDQPRVWUDGRGH DFXHUGR (Q XQD RFDVLyQ pO QR KD FRQWURODGR OD IXHU]D \ 0DUtD VH KD FDtGR 1R VH KD TXHMDGR\VHKDTXHGDGRHVWLUDGDHQHOVXHORPXHUWDGHULVDeOOHKDSUHJXQWDGRD0DUtD VLOHKDKHFKRGDxR\OHSLGHSHUGyQ(OODOHGLFHTXHQROHKDGROLGR\VLJXHQMXJDQGR (QODDFWLYLGDGOHVKHWHQLGRTXHGHFLUTXHVHWUDWDEDGHKDFHUIXHU]D\QRGHKDFHU FRVTXLOODV4XHWHQtDQTXHKDFHUORELHQ (QHOMXHJRVHDSOLFDQODVDGDSWDFLRQHVKDELWXDOHVSDUD0DUtD 6HOHFRQFHGHQWUHVYLGDVWLHQHWUHVRSRUWXQLGDGHVKDVWDTXHSXHGDVHUHOLPLQDGD\ HQHOPRPHQWRHQTXHDJRWHDOJXQDGHHOODV\PDWHDXQDGYHUVDULRVHOHVXPDXQD YLGD &XDQGR REWLHQH HO EDOyQ VH JULWD ³VWRS´ \ ORV DGYHUVDULRV WLHQHQ TXH TXHGDUVH HVWiWLFRVHQHOHVSDFLR(OODSXHGHODQ]DUHOEDOyQFRQHOSLHRODPXOHWDVLWRFDXQ DGYHUVDULRpVWHSDVDDOD]RQDGHPXHUWRVËGHPVLHVWiHQOD]RQDGHPXHUWRV6H DFXHUGDTXHDOURGDUHOEDOyQSRUHOVXHORXQDGYHUVDULRHVWiPXHUWRFXDQGROHWRFD DORVSLHV 0DUtDSLHUGHODVYLGDVPX\UiSLGDPHQWH+HLGRDKDEODUFRQVX³UH\´\OHKHGLFKRTXH OH GLHUD XQD YLGD PiV $ 0DUtD OH KH FRPHQWDGR TXH WHQtD TXH VHU PiV UiSLGD HQ ORV GHVSOD]DPLHQWRV \ TXH EXVFDVH HVWUDWHJLDV SDUD HYLWDU TXH OD PDWHQ $O UHVWR GH FRPSDxHURVOHVKHSXHVWRODFRQGLFLyQTXHD0DUtDQRVHOHSRGtDLPSDFWDUGHFLQWXUD 5 5 5 5 5 5 5 SDUDDEDMR(QWRQFHV0DUtDVHHVFRQGHGHWUiVGHXQFRPSDxHURVLQTXHpVWHVHTXHMH (QXQPRPHQWRGHOMXHJRXQFRPSDxHURODWLHQHDWLUR\FRPHQWDHQYR]DOWD³QRODPDWR SRUTXHPHGDOiVWLPD´+HSDUDGRHOMXHJR\OHKHGLFKRTXHHVRQRORGLJDMDPiV4XH HOODWLHQHVXVYHQWDMDV\TXHSRUWDQWRVLVHDJRWDQVHDJRWDQSHURQRHVMXVWRGDUOHPiV TXHODVTXHWLHQH4XHQXQFDGLJDPiVODSDODEUDOiVWLPDUHILULpQGRVHD0DUtD+DJRXQD UHIOH[LyQ DO JUXSR VREUH ODV RSRUWXQLGDGHV TXH WHQHPRV HQ QXHVWUD VRFLHGDG HQ FRPSDUDFLyQFRQRWUDV\TXHHOVHQWLPLHQWRGHOiVWLPDQRHVSRVLWLYRSDUDIDYRUHFHUHO GHVDUUROORGHODVSHUVRQDV(OQLxRPHFRPHQWDTXHQRORGLUiPiV\TXHORKDHQWHQGLGR &RPHQWDULRVDODVHVLyQ 0H OODPD OD DWHQFLyQ FyPR 0DUtD \ VX FRPSDxHUR EXVFDQ ODV DGDSWDFLRQHV R ODV VROLFLWDQDVtFRPRODSRVLWLYDDFWLWXGGHODPDHVWUDHQODUHVROXFLyQ (VLQWHUHVDQWHWDPELpQHOFRQIOLFWRTXHVXUJHFRQOD³OiVWLPD´TXHIDFLOLWDODFRPSUHQVLyQ GHODVYHQWDMDVMXVWDVSDUDSRGHUFRPSHQVDUODVOLPLWDFLRQHV(OHTXLOLEULRFRQWUDSXHVWRDO ³GHMDUJDQDU´6LQGXGDHVWHSHTXHxRFRQIOLFWRKDHQULTXHFLGRDOJUXSR\KDD\XGDGRD PHMRUDUODFRPSUHQVLyQGHOSRUTXpGHODVDGDSWDFLRQHVGHORVMXHJRV 6(6,Ï11 '(0$5=2'( (VWD VHVLyQ HV XQD FRQWLQXDFLyQ GH OD Q \ VH VLJXH WUDEDMDQGR HO HTXLOLEULR /D GLQiPLFDHVVLPLODURUJDQL]iQGRVHORVPLVPRVJUXSRVGHTXHHQODVHVLyQDQWHULRU/D PDHVWUD UHSDUWH GLEXMRV FRQ ODV ILJXUDV D UHDOL]DU 'HEHQ SRQHUVH GH DFXHUGR SDUD UHDOL]DUODVILJXUDV\XQDYH]FRQVHJXLGDVHFDPELDQORVGLEXMRVFRQRWURVJUXSRV )LQDOL]D OD VHVLyQ SUHJXQWDQGR TXp GLILFXOWDGHV KDQ HQFRQWUDGR FRQ HO ILQ GH TXH H[SUHVHQORVSRVLEOHVSUREOHPDVGHFRPXQLFDFLyQ\UHODFLyQ 0DUtD VH UH~QH FRQ GRV FRPSDxHUDV SDUD KDFHU HO JUXSR &XDQGR VH UHSDUWHQ ORV GLEXMRV0DUtDVHPXHVWUDGLVWDQWHGHVSOD]iQGRVHGHURGLOODVFRQH[SUHVLyQGHHQIDGR $OSUHJXQWDUOHODPDHVWUDSRUORTXHOHVXFHGHOHGLFHTXHQRTXLHUHMXJDUSRUTXHHVWi 3DWULFLD HQVXJUXSR/DPDHVWUDLQWHQWD KDFHUOH FRPSUHQGHU TXH VH WUDWDGHFRPSDUWLU FRQWRGRVORVFRPSDxHURVVHDQTXLHQHVVHDQ 0LHQWUDV HVWRVXFHGHDQWHHOUHFODPR GHO UHVWR GH JUXSRV OD PDHVWUDYDKDFLDHOORV\ 0DUtD HQ YH] GH UHXQLUVH FRQ VX JUXSR VH TXHGD VHQWDGD HQ HO VXHOR HQ XQ ODWHUDO HQIDGDGD/DPDHVWUDUHJUHVDMXQWRD0DUtD\OHSUHJXQWDVREUHVXDFWLWXG/HGLFHTXH QROORUH\TXHUD]RQH/DPDHVWUDVHDOHMDGHQXHYRSDUDDWHQGHUDORVRWURVJUXSRV\VXV FRPSDxHUDV GH WUtR VH DFHUFDQ SDUD TXH YD\D FRQ HOODV KD KDFHU ODV ILJXUDV $QWH HO VLOHQFLRGH0DUtD3DWULFLDFRPHQWD³YiPRQRV´ /DPDHVWUDVHDFHUFDGHQXHYR\OHGLFHD0DUtDTXHFRQTXpJUXSROHJXVWDUtDHVWDU (OOD HOLJH HO JUXSR GRQGH HVWi VX FRPSDxHUR GH MXHJRV GHO GtD DQWHULRU FRQ HO TXH VH 5 5 5 5 5 5 5 OOHYDPX\ELHQDOTXHGHQRPLQDUHPRV³&RQUDG´/DPDHVWUDSUHJXQWDDOJUXSRVLDFHSWD D0DUtD\pVWHQRSRQHSUREOHPDVSDUDDFHSWDUOD0DUtDQRPXHVWUDLQLFLDWLYDDOIRUPDU ODVILJXUDV\DGRSWDXQSDSHOPX\SDVLYR1RREVWDQWHMXJXHWHDFRQ&RQUDG &XDQGRODPDHVWUDUH~QHDOJUXSR\OHVSUHJXQWDTXpGLILFXOWDGHVKDQHQFRQWUDGR0DUtD VHVLHQWDMXQWRD&RQUDGVLJXLHQGRFRQVXDFWLWXGSDVLYD1RFRPHQWDQDGD\VHOLPLWDD REVHUYDUFDPELDQGRODSRVLFLyQFRUSRUDOHQWUHWXPEDGD\DUURGLOODGD $OLQGLFDUODPDHVWUDTXHVHGLULMDQDODGXFKD0DUtDVHOHDFHUFDDUURGLOODGDFRQVXYR] LQIDQWLO OH SLGH TXH OD GHMH MXJDU \ OD PDHVWUD VH QLHJD UHVSRQGLpQGROH TXH VL QR KD VXGDGRHVFXOSDVX\D\TXHGHEHLUDODGXFKDFRPRORVGHPiV1RREVWDQWHILQDOL]DOD VHVLyQVLQTXH0DUtDVHGXFKH &RPHQWDULRVDODVHVLyQ 6HHYLGHQFLDTXH&RQUDGHVWiSDVDQGRDVHUXQEXHQDPLJRDVtFRPRHOUHFKD]RPXWXR TXHVLHQWHQHOOD\3DWULFLD 2EVHUYDPRVD0DUtDDSiWLFD\GHVPRWLYDGD&RLQFLGLPRVFRQODPDHVWUDTXH0DUtDHVWi KDFLHQGRXQDUHJUHVLyQHQVXFRPSRUWDPLHQWR&UHHPRVTXHQRGHMDGHVHUXQDPDQHUD GHOODPDUODDWHQFLyQDODGXOWRDQWHVXVFRQIOLFWRV $QWH OD DFWLWXG GH 0DUtD TXH DFDEy VLQ GXFKDUVH OD PDHVWUD GHFLGH KDEODU FRQ HOOD DO ILQDOL]DUODVHVLyQ'HVXFRQYHUVDFLyQUHGDFWDHOVLJXLHQWHLQIRUPH (OODQRTXHUtDGXFKDUVHSRUTXHGHFtDTXHQRKDEtDVXGDGR/HWXYHTXHGHFLUTXHGHEtD KDFHUOR \ TXH VL KXELHVH WUDEDMDGR HQ OD VHVLyQ KDEUtD VXGDGR FRPR ORV GHPiV /H FRPHQWpTXHQRPHKDEtDJXVWDGRVXDFWLWXGTXHHVSHUDEDDOJRPiVGHHOODGDGRTXH ~OWLPDPHQWHKDEtDPHMRUDGRPXFKRHQVXVUHVXOWDGRV/HGLMHTXHGHEtDPDGXUDU\TXH PHKDEtDGHIUDXGDGRDOQRUHVSHWDUQLYDORUDUDVXVFRPSDxHUDV4XHORTXHGHEtDKDEHU KHFKRHUDKDEODUFRQHOODV\QRFRPSRUWDUVHFRPRXQDQLxDSHTXHxD /HFRPHQWpTXHVHKDEtDDFDEDGRDQGDUGHURGLOODV\TXHWHQtDTXHXWLOL]DUODVPXOHWDV SDUDIRUWDOHFHUORVEUD]RV4XHWHQtDTXHHVIRU]DUVH\H[LJLUVHPiV\DTXHEXVFDQGROD SRVWXUDPiVFyPRGDVHSHUMXGLFDED'HQRKDFHUFDVRVHUtDWDQGXUDFRQHOODFRPRFRQ HOUHVWR6HDFDEDURQODVFRQWHPSODFLRQHV'HEtDHVIRU]DUVHFRPRHOUHVWR\DTXHHOOD HUDLJXDOTXHORVGHPiV /H GLMH TXH D OD ODUJD OR DJUDGHFHUtD \D TXH YHUtD ORV SURJUHVRV TXH SXHGH OOHJDU D KDFHU(OODFDOODED\VHH[FXVDEDGLFLHQGRTXHHQHOJUXSRGH3DWULFLDHOODQRWHQtDTXH HVWDU\DTXHHUDQ\D0HHQIDGp\OHGLMHTXH\RKDEtDGLFKRTXHHQHVHJUXSRVHUtDQ /HGLMHTXHSHQVDUDHQORTXHOHKDEtDGLFKR\TXHDOGtDVLJXLHQWHHQODKRUDGHOSDWLROR KDEODUtDPRV /D DFRPSDxp KDVWD OD VDOLGD \ VX PDGUH PH GLMR TXH 0DUtD QR TXHUtD GXFKDUVHHQODHVFXHOD$OSUHJXQWDUOHD0DUtDSRUTXpVLKD\DOJ~QPRWLYRFRQFUHWRGLMR TXHQRORVDEtD$SURYHFKRSDUDLQVLVWLUOHTXHPDxDQDORKDEODUtDPRV $OGtDVLJXLHQWHHVSHURD0DUtDHQHOSDWLRSHURHOODQRYLHQH3RUODWDUGHODORFDOL]R\OH 5 5 5 5 5 GLJR TXH OD KH HVWDGR HVSHUDQGR TXH SRU TXp QR KD YHQLGR 0H FRQWHVWD TXH VH KD TXHGDGRHQHODXODDFDEDQGRWUDEDMRVSHQGLHQWHV/HGLJRTXHODHVSHURPDxDQDDOD PLVPDKRUD $O GtD VLJXLHQWH PH FRPHQWy TXH LQWHQWDUtD PHMRUDU \ TXH VH SRUWDUtD ELHQ 6X DFWLWXG VLJXLyVLHQGRLQIDQWLOUHVSRQGLHQGRFRQPRQRVtODERV\FDEL]EDMD 'HOLQIRUPHGHGX]FRODYROXQWDGGHODPDHVWUDSDUDTXH0DUtDVHDPiVUHVSRQVDEOHGH VXV DFWRV H[LJLpQGROH PiV PDGXUH] GH DFXHUGR FRQ VX HGDG ³VH DFDEDURQ ODV FRQWHPSODFLRQHV´±VLF7DOYH]KDVWDHVHPRPHQWRKDEtDQSULPDGRPiVORVGHUHFKRV TXHODVREOLJDFLRQHV 7DPELpQ VRQ FXULRVDV VXV UHVSXHVWDV FRQ PRQRVtODERV UHWUDtGDV FRPR TXHULHQGR LJQRUDUHOFRQIOLFWR 6(6,Ï11 '(0$5=2'( /DPDHVWUDHVFULEH +H UHSHWLGR HO FRQWHQLGR GH OD VHVLyQ DQWHULRU (VWD YH] ORV JUXSRV ORV FRPSXVH \R DPSOLiQGRORVWRGRVDFRPSRQHQWHV SDUDDXPHQWDUODIXHU]D3RUVXDFWLWXGGHGX]FR TXHD0DUtDQROHJXVWyVXJUXSRSHVHDTXHHUDQFRPSDxHUDVGLVWLQWDV1RREVWDQWH FXDQGRORSUHJXQWpVLKDEtDDOJXQDFRPSDxHUDTXHQROHJXVWDUDGLMRTXHQR 2EVHUYR TXH VH GHVSOD]D GH QXHYR GH URGLOODV VLQ ODV PXOHWDV /H GLJR TXH FRMD ODV PXOHWDV UHFRUGDQGR QXHVWUD FRQYHUVDFLyQ /R KDFH GH PDOD JDQD 6LJXH FRQ VX FRPSRUWDPLHQWR LQIDQWLO \ SDVLYR VLQ FRODERUDU FRQ VXV FRPSDxHUDV /H UHFXHUGR TXH WUDEDMDHQJUXSR\TXHGHEHDSR\DUDVXVFRPSDxHUDVHQORTXHKDFHQ'HFLGHFRODERUDU PiV\VHPXHVWUDPiVDFWLYD\SDUWLFLSDWLYD $O KDFHU OD UHIOH[LyQ HQ JUXSR VREUH ODV GLILFXOWDGHV TXH KDQ HQFRQWUDGR DO WRFDUOH D 0DUtDKDEODFRPRVLHVWXYLHUDFDQWDQGRVHSDUDQGRPXFKRODVVtODEDV/HKDJRUHSHWLU WUHV YHFHV \ VLJXH KDFLHQGR OR PLVPR 'LFH ³HQ HO HMHUFLFLR >KDFLHQGR HO JHVWR \ ULpQGRVH@(VWRHVORTXHPHKDQGLFKRTXHGLJD´8QDFRPSDxHUDGLFHTXHHVRQRHV YHUGDG \ H[SOLFD HO HMHUFLFLR TXH OHV KD UHVXOWDGR PiV GLItFLO \D TXH WHPtDQ TXH 0DUtD FD\HVH 1RGDWLHPSRDUHVROYHUHOFRQIOLFWR\DTXHYLHQHQDEXVFDUODFRQODDPEXODQFLDSDUDOD UHKDELOLWDFLyQ $OGtDVLJXLHQWHLQWHQWRKDEODUFRQHOODGHOWHPDSHURVHFLHUUDHQVtPLVPDVLQGHFLUQDGD /RLQWHQWDUpHOSUy[LPROXQHV &RPHQWDULRVDODVHVLyQ 6HJXLPRV HQ HO SURFHVR GH UHJUHVLyQ GH 0DUtD FRQ VXV DFWLWXGHV LQIDQWLOHV \ VLQ 5 5 5 5 5 5 5 5 HQIUHQWDUVH D ORV FRQIOLFWRV (V LQWHUHVDQWH FRPR OD PDHVWUD QR LJQRUD HO FRQIOLFWR H LQWHQWD SRQHU VROXFLyQ $Vt PLVPR SDUHFH KDEHU HQWUDGR HQ XQ SURFHVR GH H[LJHQFLD D 0DUtDTXHQRKDEtDREVHUYDGRKDVWDHOPRPHQWR 6(6,Ï11 '(0$5=2'( (OLQLFLRGHODVHVLyQYLHQHPDUFDGRSRUXQFRQIOLFWRSURWDJRQL]DGRSRU0DUtD'HQXHYR VH GHVSOD]D GH URGLOODV GHMDQGR ODV PXOHWDV D XQ ODGR /D PDHVWUD OH GLFH GHODQWH GH WRGRV TXH UHFXHUGH OD FRQYHUVDFLyQ TXH KDEtDQ WHQLGR VREUH HOOR \ TXH OH GLMHVH TXp KDEtDQFRQFOXLGR&RQYR]LQIDQWLOIORMDFDEL]EDMD\FRQODWHQFLDHQWUHSDODEUD\SDODEUD UHVSRQGH³TXHWHQtDTXHHVIRU]DUPHFRPRORVGHPiV´$OJXQRVFRPSDxHURVGH0DUtDVH TXHMDQ ³SRU WX FXOSD HVWDPRV SHUGLHQGR HO WLHPSR´ $O ILQDO FRJH ODV PXOHWDV \ OHQWDPHQWHVHSRQHGHSLHGHPRUiQGRVH 3RVWHULRUPHQWH OD PDHVWUD RUJDQL]D OD FODVH SRU SDUHMDV 0DUtD QR KDFH QLQJ~Q JHVWR SDUDFRORFDUVHFRQDOJXLHQ3DWULFLDVHTXHGDVLQFRPSDxHUD\SRUHOLPLQDFLyQOHWRFD FRQ 0DUtD /D PDHVWUD GHWLHQH OD VHVLyQ \ OH GLFH D 0DUtD TXH VH HVIXHUFH HQ EXVFDU DOJ~QFRPSDxHUR\KDFHUHSHWLUODDFFLyQ0DUtDHVWDEDVHQWDGDHQHOVXHOR\VHOHYDQWD OHQWDPHQWHHOSURFHVRVHUHSLWHTXHGDQGRGHQXHYRHPSDUHMDGDV3DWULFLD\0DUtD 6HLQLFLDQODVDFWLYLGDGHVFRQEDOyQ 6XMHWDQGRODSHORWDHVSDOGDFRQHVSDOGDDODDOWXUDGHORVRPySODWRV'HEHQGHVSOD]DUVH VLQTXHHOEDOyQVHFDLJD ËGHPVXMHWiQGRORSRUORVKRPEURVVLWXDGRVDFDGDODGR 2EVHUYDPRVTXHSDUD0DUtDDPEDVWDUHDVODVSXHGHUHDOL]DUVLQJUDQGLILFXOWDG$SHVDU GHODVGLIHUHQFLDVHQWUHDPEDVSHUFLELPRVXQDLQWHUDFFLyQYHUEDOSRVLWLYD 3RVWHULRUPHQWHODPDHVWUDSURSRQHODVLJXLHQWHWDUHD )UHQWHDIUHQWHGHSLH8QMXJDGRUDJDUUDHOEDOyQSRUVXVODWHUDOHV(ORWURSRUODSDUWH VXSHULRU H LQIHULRU 'HEHQ ERWDU HO EDOyQ \ UHFRJHUOR PDQWHQLHQGR OD SRVWXUD GH ODV PDQRV ËGHPFRQODQ]DPLHQWRYHUWLFDO ËGHPSHURUHFXSHUDQGRHOEDOyQHQVDOWR 'DGR TXH 0DUtD GHEH VRVWHQHUVH FRQ ODV PXOHWDV HOOD \ 3DWULFLD UHDOL]DQ OD DFWLYLGDG VHQWDGDV (Q OD WHUFHUD YDULDQWH 3DWULFLD Vt VDOWD 6HJXLPRV REVHUYDQGR FRPXQLFDFLyQ YHUEDOHQWUHHOODVFRPHQWDQGRHOMXHJR $FRQWLQXDFLyQODPDHVWUDLQGLFDTXHWLHQHQTXHIRUPDUWUtRV/DUHDFFLyQGH0DUtDHVOD GH TXHGDUVH VHQWDGD \ GHFLUOH D 3DWULFLD TXH VHD HOOD OD TXH HVFRMD D DOJXLHQ \ DVt OR KDFH/DDFWLYLGDGHVODTXHVLJXH 8QRDOODGRGHRWURVXMHWDQGRGRVEDORQHVFRQORVKRPEURV'HVSOD]DUVHVLQTXHFDLJD 5 5 5 5 5 5 5 5 QLQJ~QEDOyQ 0DUtDSDUWLFLSDVLQSUREOHPDVREVHUYDQGREXHQDFRPXQLFDFLyQFRQVXVFRPSDxHUDV &XDQGRILQDOL]DODVHVLyQ0DUtDLQVLVWHHQTXHQRGHEHGXFKDUVH\DTXHQRKDVXGDGR /DPDHVWUDGHEHLQVLVWLUGHQXHYRHQTXHGHEHGXFKDUVHFRPRWRGRV(QHVWDRFDVLyQ 0DUtDVHGXFKD &RPHQWDULRVDODVHVLyQ 6HFRQVWDWDTXHKD\XQDPD\RUH[LJHQFLDSRUSDUWHGHODPDHVWUDHQHOFRPSRUWDPLHQWR GH0DUtD &RLQFLGLPRVFRQODPDHVWUDHQODSRFDLQLFLDWLYDTXHPXHVWUD0DUtDHQODRUJDQL]DFLyQGH ORVJUXSRV 6(6,Ï11 '(0$5=2'( (MHUFLFLRVSRUSDUHMDV\WUtRVFRQEDOyQ 3RUSDUHMDVDPGHSLH3DVHVDODDOWXUDGHOSHFKRËGHPYDULDQGR OD SRVLFLyQ GH SDVH \ GH UHFHSFLyQ YDULDQGR ODV WUD\HFWRULDV GHO EDOyQ\SDVHFRQERWH 3RUSDUHMDV8QRODQ]DERPEHDQGR\HORWURGHYXHOYHFRQODFDEH]D 5 5 5 5 9HUVHVLyQQ 5 8QR ODQ]D ERPEHDQGR &XDQGR OD SHORWD SDVD SRU HQFLPD GH OD FDEH]DGHOFRPSDxHURpVWHGHEHKDFHUPHGLRJLUR\UHFHSFLRQDUOD GHHVSDOGDVDpO\DQWHVGHTXHFDLJDDOVXHOR 8QR ODQ]D OD SHORWD FRQ ERWH 6X FRPSDxHUR GH HVSDOGDV D pO &XDQGR HVWH ~OWLPR R\H HO ERWH GHEH JLUDUVH SDUD UHFHSFLRQDU HO EDOyQ -XHJRGH³PDWDUFRQUH\´MXJDQGRFRQGRVEDORQHVFRQODFRQVLJQD GHTXHQRSXHGHQSDVDUODSHORWDFRQHOEUD]RRODVPDQRVVLQRFRQ FXDOTXLHURWUDSDUWHGHOFXHUSR /DPDHVWUDHVFULEH 0DUtDHVWiHPSDUHMDGDFRQ3DWULFLDFRPRHOGtDDQWHULRU7RGRVORVHMHUFLFLRVORVUHDOL]D VHQWDGDHQXQDVLOOD +R\HVWR\FRQWHQWD\DTXH0DUtDKDHVWDGRDWHQWDFRPXQLFDWLYDSDUWLFLSDWLYDPRWLYDGD (QWUHODVGRVKDEtDEXHQDUHODFLyQ\GLiORJR1ROHKHWHQLGRTXHOODPDUODDWHQFLyQQL XQD VROD YH] &XDQGR KDEODED FRQPLJR OR KDFtD VLQ LQIDQWLOLVPRV FRQ YR] FODUD \ DOWD GHPRVWUDQGRTXHFXDQGRTXLHUHVDEHKDFHUODVFRVDVELHQ/DKHIHOLFLWDGRGLFLpQGROH TXHVLHPSUHGHEHDFWXDUDVt\QRSDUDYHUPHFRQWHQWDVLQRSDUDGHPRVWUDUVHGHORTXH HVFDSD]\TXHGHHVWDIRUPDSRGUiVXSHUDUUHWRV (QHOHMHUFLFLRDOSULQFLSLR3DWULFLDOHGDEDHOSDVHSRUGHODQWH'HVSXpVKDKDEODGR FRQ 0DUtD \ KD YHQLGR D GHFLUPH VL SRGtD FRORFDUVH GHWUiV \D TXH 0DUtD VHQWDGD QR SRGtDKDFHUHOPHGLRJLUR/HVGLMHTXHVtSHURREVHUYpTXHQROHVVDOtDELHQ0HDFHUTXp DHOODV\OHVSUHJXQWp³¢TXpHVORTXHQRKDFpLVELHQ"´3DWULFLDGLFHTXHHVFXOSDVX\D TXHQRHOHYDVXILFLHQWHPHQWHHOEDOyQ/HVGLJRTXpVHSXHGHKDFHU3DWULFLDPHFRQWHVWD TXHERPEHDUOD\WLUDUVXDYH/RKDFHQ\HOUHVXOWDGRHVEXHQR0DUtDOHYDQWDHOSXOJDU KDFLDDUULED\ODVGRVVHUtHQ (QHOHMHUFLFLR3DWULFLDHVWiFRORFDGDEDVWDQWHFHUFDGH0DUtD\DOERWDUODSHORWDpVWD VHHOHYDPXFKR\0DUtDQRODSXHGHDWUDSDU0DUtDOHGLFHD3DWULFLD³$OpMDWH\QRWLUHV WDQIXHUWH´eVWDORKDFH\OHVVDOHELHQ/HGLFHD0DUtDTXHWLHQHUD]yQ\VHUtHQ (QHOMXHJRGHPDWDUFRQUH\OHVUHFXHUGRODVQRUPDV\ODVYHQWDMDVGH0DUtD'LVSRQJR TXH WHQJD YLGDV &RPR HO UHVWR GHO JUXSR FKXWD PX\ IXHUWH FRQ HO SLH HOLPLQR HVWD RSFLyQ H[FHSWXDQGR D 0DUtD )LQDOPHQWH HOOD HV OD ~QLFD QR HOLPLQDGD GH VX HTXLSR 0LHQWUDVHVTXLYDXQODQ]DPLHQWRVHUHVEDOD\FDHSHURQRVHTXHMD/HSUHJXQWRVLVH KDKHFKRGDxR\GLFHTXHXQSRFR/HGLJRVLTXLHUHTXHMXHJXHFRQHOOD6HUtH\GLFH TXHVt(QWRQFHVOHSURSRQJRTXHFXDQGROHWRTXHWLUDUDOGHFLUVWRS\RODQ]DUpHOEDOyQ SRU HOOD $ OD VHJXQGD RFDVLyQ TXH VXFHGtD KXER SURWHVWDV SRU SDUWH GHO HTXLSR FRQWUDULRGLFLHQGR³QRHVMXVWR´³WLHQHYHQWDMDV\DKRUDOHGDPiV´5HDFFLRQRGLFLpQGROH D 0DUtD TXH GHEH WLUDU HOOD DXQTXH SXHGH XWLOL]DU ODV PDQRV SDUD HOOR DVt WLHQH PiV IXHU]DGHWLUR &XDQGRYDPRVKDFLDHOYHVWXDULR0DUtDPHGLFH³GHPLHTXLSROD~QLFDTXHKDJDQDGR KHVLGR\R0HTXHGDEDQYLGDV´/HFRQWHVWRTXHHOMXHJRQRKDEtDILQDOL]DGR\TXHHUD XQHPSDWH1RKDEtDJDQDGRUHV$SURYHFKRSDUDIHOLFLWDUODSRUVXDFWLWXGDQLPiQGRODD VHJXLUDVt 'DGRTXHODWLHQHQTXHYHQLUDEXVFDUFRQODDPEXODQFLDFRPHQWRDWRGRVORVTXHQRVH GXFKDQTXHSXHGHQMXJDUD³/D3DVWRUD´0DUtDVHPXHVWUDPX\DOHJUH\SDUWLFLSDPX\ DFWLYDPHQWH (OJUXSRGLVSHUVRSRUHOHVSDFLR\XQMXJDGRUFRQXQEDOyQGHHVSXPDeVWHSXHGHRSWDU HQ FXDQWR OR SRVHH SRU JULWDU ³SLHV TXLHWRV´ \ SRU WDQWR VXV FRPSDxHURV WLHQHQ TXH TXHGDUVH HVWiWLFRV HQ HO SXQWR GHO HVSDFLR GRQGH VH HQFXHQWUDQ \ D FRQWLQXDFLyQ 5 5 5 5 5 5 LQWHQWDU WRFDU D XQ FRPSDxHUR ODQ]DQGR HO EDOyQ LPSDFWDQGR FXDOTXLHU SDUWH FRUSRUDO H[FHSWXDQGRODFDUD\FD\HQGRHOEDOyQDOVXHOR2ELHQWLHQHODSRVLELOLGDGGHGDUWUHV SDVRVFRQHOEDOyQHQODPDQRFRQHOREMHWLYRGHDSUR[LPDUVHDVXVFRPSDxHURV\GHFLU ³SLHVTXLHWRV´(QHOPRPHQWRTXHXQMXJDGRUHVWRFDGRSDVDDOD]RQDGHHOLPLQDGRV\ WDQVyORSXHGHVDOYDUVHFXDQGRLPSDFWDQDOMXJDGRUTXHORKDHOLPLQDGR /DDGDSWDFLyQSDUD0DUtDHVTXHFXDQGRFRQVLJXHHOEDOyQVHJULWD³SLHVTXLHWRV´\WLHQH DGHPiV OD SRVLELOLGDG GH GDU ORV WUHV SDVRV FRQ HO EDOyQ HVWDQGR VXV FRPSDxHURV HVWiWLFRV (OOD GHFLGH VL LQWHQWD WRFDU D VXV FRPSDxHURV FKXWiQGROR FRQ ORV SLHV R ODQ]iQGRORFRQODPDQR &RPHQWDULRVDODVHVLyQ (V LQWHUHVDQWH HO FDPELR GH DFWLWXG GH 0DUtD PX\ ULVXHxD \ HVSHFLDOPHQWH HO GH VX UHODFLyQFRQ3DWULFLD3DUHFHTXHVXVUHQFLOODVLQLFLDOHVKDQGHVDSDUHFLGRDSHVDUTXHVH KDQ YLVWR REOLJDGDV D FRPSDUWLU DFWLYLGDGHV HQ ODV ~OWLPDV VHVLRQHV 3XHGH TXH HO FRPSDUWLUMXHJRVKD\DVLGRXQGHVHQFDGHQDQWHGHVXVPHMRUHVUHODFLRQHV (V LQWHUHVDQWH FyPR EXVFDQ ODV DGDSWDFLRQHV HQ DOJXQRV HMHUFLFLRV SUHJXQWDQGR VXV GXGDVDODPDHVWUD 3RU~OWLPRVHHYLGHQFLDHOFRQIOLFWRFXDQGRODVYHQWDMDVUHVSHFWRD0DUtDVRQH[FHVLYDV (Q HVWH FDVR OD PDHVWUD UHFRQRFH TXH KD VLGR H[FHVLYDPHQWH PDJQiQLPD \ FUHR GH LQWHUpV FXDQGR UHODWD FyPR PRGLILFD OD VLWXDFLyQ SDUD TXH VHD MXVWD \ GH XQD IRUPD DEVROXWDPHQWHQRUPDOL]DGD 6(6,Ï11 '(0$5=2'( $OSULQFLSLRGHODVHVLyQFXDQGRODPDHVWUDSDVDOLVWD0DUtDTXHHVWiVHQWDGDHQHOVXHOR VLPXODFDHUFRPHQWDQGRTXH³ODVSLHUQDVOHKDFHQGDxRSRUTXHHQODMRUQDGDDQWHULRUGH (GXFDFLyQ)tVLFDVHFD\y\VHJROSHy´DxDGH³TXHIXHFXDQGRHOODVHTXHGyOD~OWLPDHQ VHUHOLPLQDGDHQHOMXHJRGHPDWDU´ /D VHVLyQ GH KR\ YHUVD VREUH HO GHVDUUROOR GH ODV KDELOLGDGHV PRWULFHV EiVLFDV \ PiV FRQFUHWDPHQWH GHO GRPLQLR GHO EDOyQ 3DUD HOOR GLVWULEX\H XQR SRU SHUVRQD \ SURSRQH GLYHUVDVWDUHDVTXHWHQGUiQTXHUHDOL]DUDORODUJRGHODVHVLyQ\GHPDQHUDLQGLYLGXDO 'H SLH HO EDOyQ VRVWHQLGR FRQ ODV GRV PDQRV ODQ]DPLHQWR YHUWLFDO KDFLD DUULED 5HFHSFLRQDUORFRQORVEUD]RVH[WHQGLGRVSRUHQFLPDGHODFDEH]D /DUHDFFLyQGH0DUtDHVODGHDUURGLOODUVH\UHDOL]DUODDFFLyQ$QWHHOOROHSRQHPRVXQD VLOOD SDUD TXH VH VLHQWH \ DVHJXUH XQ DMXVWH SRVWXUDO FRUUHFWR 7UDV YDULDV UHSHWLFLRQHV REVHUYDPRV TXH QR HV ~WLO SRUTXH WLHQH PHQRV SRVLELOLGDG GH UHDFFLyQ FXDQGR VH OH GHVFRQWURODHOEDOyQ 5 5 5 5 5 5 5 /DVHJXQGDWDUHDHVVLPLODUDODDQWHULRUFRQODGLIHUHQFLDTXHVHODQ]DGHVGHODDOWXUDGH ODIUHQWH'HVGHODSRVLFLyQGHDUURGLOODGD0DUtDUHDOL]DVLQGLILFXOWDGHOHMHUFLFLR /D WHUFHUD SURSXHVWD HV VLPLODU D ODV GRV DQWHULRUHV SHUR ODQ]DQGR HO EDOyQ GHVGH OD SRVLFLyQ GH VHQWDGRV SRVWHULRUPHQWH HQ FXFOLOODV \ SRU ~OWLPR WXPEDGRV ERFD DUULED GHF~ELWRGRUVDO&RPRHQFXFOLOODVHVLPSRVLEOHSDUDHOODVHFRORFDGHURGLOODV (QODFXDUWDDFWLYLGDGHODOXPQDGRSDUWHGHODSRVLFLyQGHF~ELWRGRUVDOODVURGLOODVHQHO SHFKRGHWDOIRUPDTXHODSHORWDHVWiVREUHODVSODQWDVGHORVSLHV7LHQHQTXHLQWHQWDU ODQ]DUODYHUWLFDOPHQWH\UHFHSFLRQDUODHQSRVLFLyQGHVHQWDGRV $QWHODGLILFXOWDGSDUD0DUtDDOQRSRGHUSRQHUODSHORWDHQHTXLOLEULRVREUHODVSODQWDVGH ORV SLHV VH RSWD FRQ TXH pVWD VH OD SRQJD HQWUH ODV URGLOODV VHPLIOH[LRQDGDV \ TXH UHDOLFHXQGHVSOD]DPLHQWRKDFLDHOSHFKRGHWDOIRUPDTXHUHFHSFLRQHHOEDOyQFRQODV PDQRV &RQWLQXDQGRHQODSRVLFLyQGHF~ELWRGRUVDOWLHQHQTXHVXMHWDUODSHORWDFRQORVWRELOORV ODQ]DUOD KDFLD OD FDEH]D \ UHFHSFLRQDUOD HQ SRVLFLyQ GH VHQWDGRV /D DGDSWDFLyQ TXH SURSRQHPRVD0DUtDHVLJXDODODDQWHULRU 3RVWHULRUPHQWH ORV EUD]RV HQ FUX] SDVDUVH OD SHORWD GH XQD PDQR D RWUD YDULDQGR OD SRVLFLyQ GHORVEUD]RV\DFRPSDxDQGR FRQ GHVSOD]DPLHQWRV ODWHUDOHVGHWURQFR0DUtD VXVWLWX\HODSRVLFLyQGHSLHSRUODGHDUURGLOODUVH 3DUDILQDOL]DUSURSRQHYDULRVHMHUFLFLRVFX\RGHQRPLQDGRUFRP~QHVHOUHERWH\DVHDFRQ XQEUD]RHQFUX]\JROSHDUDOWHUQDWLYDPHQWHRHOEDOyQHVGLULJLGRKDFLDDUULEDUHERWDQGR VREUH HO GRUVR \ OD SDOPD GH OD PDQR ËGHP SHUR YDULDQGR OD SDUWH FRUSRUDO GRQGH VH UHDOL]DHOUHERWHDQWHEUD]RFRGRKRPEUR±JROSHDQGRKDFLDGHODQWH\IUHQDQGRFRQOD PDQRTXHHVWiDXQDGLVWDQFLDGHXQSDOPRDSUR[LPDGDPHQWH&RPRHQORVHMHUFLFLRV DQWHULRUHV0DUtDVHDUURGLOOD 2EVHUYDPRV TXH DO VHU WDUHDV LQGLYLGXDOL]DGDV ODV LQWHUDFFLRQHV KDQ VLGR PHQRUHV $ SHVDUGHHOORKDSUHVHQWDGRXQDDFWLWXGDELHUWDSRVLWLYD\SDUWLFLSDWLYDKDEODQGRFRQXQ WRQRPiVDOWR\PHQRVLQIDQWLOH[FHSWXDQGRDOILQDOGHODVHVLyQWDO\FRPRFRPHQWDUp SRVWHULRUPHQWH 5HJLVWUDPRV TXH FXDQGR VH OH HVFDSD HO EDOyQ QR OR UHFODPD D ORV FRPSDxHURV PiV SUy[LPRV \D TXH FXHQWD TXH VHD pVWH R HO DGXOWR TXLHQ VH OR IDFLOLWH (Q WDQ VyOR XQD RFDVLyQ DJUDGHFH OD FRODERUDFLyQ GH XQ FRPSDxHUR 1R REVWDQWH REVHUYDPRV TXH VXV FRPSDxHURVWLHQHQXQDDFWLWXGSRVLWLYD\FRODERUDWLYDFRQ0DUtDIDFLOLWiQGROHODSHORWDHQ WRGDVODVRFDVLRQHVTXHORUHTXHUtD 3RURWURODGRSHUFLELPRVTXHHVSRFRUHVLVWHQWHDORVDSUHQGL]DMHVWLHQGHDGHVSLVWDUVH FRQIDFLOLGDGPRVWUiQGRVHIDOWDGHDWHQFLyQ5HFODPDODDWHQFLyQFRQWLQXDGHODPDHVWUD OODPiQGRODFRQVWDQWHPHQWHSDUDTXHODUHIXHUFH 5 5 5 5 5 5 5 5 5 5 &XDQGR OD PDHVWUD FRPHQWD TXH SDVHQ D ODV GXFKDV WLHQH TXH OODPDUOH OD DWHQFLyQ SRUTXHVHGHVSOD]DDOYHVWXDULRDUURGLOODGD3HUFLELPRVUHVLVWHQFLDVEDViQGRQRVHQVXV FRPHQWDULRV ³QR KH VXGDGR´ \ ³TXH WDQ VyOR OOHYD GH UHFDPELR OD URSD LQWHULRU´ 3RVWHULRUPHQWHWRGDYtDVLQFDPELDUVHYDDOODYDERLQWHUSUHWDQGRODSURIHVRUDTXHHVWi LQWHQWDQGRSHUGHUHOWLHPSR&XDQGRFDVLWRGDVODVQLxDVKDQVDOLGRODPDHVWUDHQWUDDO YHVWXDULRDSUHJXQWDUVtWRGDVVHKDEtDQGXFKDGR\0DUtDDVLHQWHTXHVt$QWHODPHQWLUD OHGLFHTXHYD\DDOGHVSDFKRSDUDDYHULJXDUVXVUD]RQHV(QWUDFRQHOOD\OHGLFHTXHVH VLHQWH FyPRGDPHQWH UHDFFLRQDQGR 0DUtD FRQ XQD DFWLWXG GH HQFLHUUR PRVWUiQGRVH FDEL]EDMDKRPEURVHQFRJLGRV\HOSHORFXEULpQGROHODFDUD(VLQFDSD]GHDUWLFXODUXQD UHVSXHVWD UHVSRQGLHQGR FRQ PRQRVtODERV \ FRQ XQD H[SUHVLyQ YHUEDO LQIDQWLO TXH QR FRUUHVSRQGHDVXHGDG$OILQDOFRQVLJXHH[WUDHUTXHHVWiHQIDGDFRQODPDHVWUDSHURQR OR UD]RQD $QWH VX OLPLWDGD FDSDFLGDG GH FRODERUDU OH SLGH TXH UHGDFWH XQ HVFULWR H[SOLFDQGRODFDXVD\TXHVHORHQWUHJXHDOGtDVLJXLHQWHSRUTXHGHQRVHUDVtWHQGUiTXH VDQFLRQDUOD &RPHQWDULRVDODVHVLyQ 1RV OODPD OD DWHQFLyQ OD IRUPD HQ TXH 0DUtD UHFXHUGD TXH VH TXHGy OD ~OWLPD HQ VHU HOLPLQDGDHQHOMXHJRGH³PDWDU´GHODVHVLyQDQWHULRUORTXHKDFHSHQVDUORVLJQLILFDWLYRV TXHVRQSDUDHOODHVWRVORJURV /DSRFDUHVLVWHQFLDDORVDSUHQGL]DMHVODIDOWDGHDWHQFLyQ\HOUHFODPRGHODGXOWRSDUD TXHOHUHIXHUFHHVXQFRQWLQXR&RPRGLFHODPDHVWUD³0DUtDTXLHUHTXHVHHVWpSRUHOOD´ /DDFWLWXGGHQRVROLFLWDUHOEDOyQFXDQGRVHOHGHVFRQWUROD\HVSHUDUDTXHVHORSDVHQ QRV KDFH SHQVDU TXH 0DUtD WLHQH TXH DSUHQGHU D VROLFLWDU OD D\XGD FXDQGR OR SUHFLVD FRPRLQGLFDGRUGHDXWRQRPtD\QRHVSHUDUDTXHVHDQORVGHPiVTXHWHQJDQODLQLFLDWLYD FRPR VL GH XQ GHUHFKR DGTXLULGR VH WUDWDVH $ SDUWLU GH DKRUD OD PDHVWUD VH SURSRQH WUDEDMDUODVROLFLWXGGHD\XGD 6(6,Ï11 '(0$5=2'( 3RUSDUHMDV\FRQEDORQHV &RQ GRV EDORQHV 8QR IUHQWH D RWUR EUD]RV H[WHQGLGRV \ VXMHWDQGR ORVEDORQHVFRQODVSDOPDVGHODPDQR'HEHQKDFHUSUHVLyQGHWDO IRUPDTXHDPHGLGDTXHVHGHVSOD]DQQRFDLJDQORVEDORQHV 'HODGRGHEHQVXMHWDUXQDSHORWDKRPEURFRQKRPEUR\ODRWUDFRQ ODV SDOPDV GH OD PDQR SRU HQFLPD GH OD FDEH]D 'HEHQ KDFHU SUHVLyQGHWDOIRUPD TXHDPHGLGDTXHVHGHVSOD]DQQRFDLJDQORV EDORQHV &DGD MXJDGRU SDVD XQ EDOyQ D VX SDUHMD 'HEHQ DXPHQWDU SURJUHVLYDPHQWHODYHORFLGDGGHOSDVH 5 5 5 5 5 8QEDOyQ(OTXHODQ]DGHEHSDVDUHOEDOyQ\GXUDQWHODUHFHSFLyQ WLHQH TXH KDFHU XQD IOH[LyQ GH SLHUQDV WRFDQGR FRQ ODV PDQRV DO VXHOR 6HIRUPDQGRVJUXSRVHQILODLQGLDGHODQWHGHGRVFROFKRQHWDV$OD VHxDOWLHQHQTXHVDOLUFRUULHQGR\DOOOHJDUDQWHODFROFKRQHWDKDFHQ XQD SDUDGD ODQ]DQ HO EDOyQ \ VDOWDQ D SLHV MXQWRV OXHJR GDQ XQD YROWHUHWD KDFLD GHODQWH \ UHFHSFLRQDQ HO EDOyQ ËGHP FDPLQDQGR HQ FXDGUXSHGLD\UHDOL]DUODYROWHUHWDËGHPVDOWDQGRHQFXFOLOODVFRQOD SHORWDHQODEDUULJD\KDFHUODYROWHUHWDLQWHQWDQGRTXHODSHORWDQR VHHVFDSHËGHPFRQODSHORWDVXMHWDHQWUHORVSLHV (MHUFLFLRV LQGLYLGXDOHV FRQ EDOyQ UHDOL]DQGR GLYHUVRV WLSRV GH DXWRSDVHVFRPSURPHWLHQGRGLYHUVDVSDUWHVFRUSRUDOHV /DPDHVWUDHVFULEH 5 7RGRV ORV HMHUFLFLRV SRU SDUHMDV 0DUtD ORV KD UHDOL]DGR VHQWDGD HQ XQD VLOOD 8QD FRPSDxHUDHOLJHD0DUtD\&RQUDGYLHQHDGHFLUPHTXHWDPELpQTXLHUHIRUPDUSDUHMDFRQ HOOD 0DUtD GLFH TXH QR OH LPSRUWD TXH VHDQ WUHV \ DFHSWR VX SURSXHVWD SHUR TXH VH SRQJDQ GH DFXHUGR HQ FyPR VROXFLRQDUiQ FDGD HMHUFLFLR SDUD TXH ORV WUHV SXHGDQ SDUWLFLSDU (Q HO HMHUFLFLR 0DUtD HQ YR] DOWD PH OODPD SDUD TXH YHD FyPR UHDOL]DQ HO HMHUFLFLR 5 2EVHUYRFRRUGLQDFLyQHQWUHHOORVHLQWX\RTXHHVSHUDPLIHOLFLWDFLyQ (OHMHUFLFLRQROHVVDOHPX\ELHQDOSULQFLSLR\VHOHVFDHODSHORWDSRUORTXHODFDPELR 5 SRU XQD GH HVSXPD SDUD TXH 0DUtD SXHGD DSR\DU ELHQ HO KRPEUR 3HUR HQFLPD GH OD FDEH]D PDQWHQJR OD SHORWD RULJLQDO GH YROHLERO $ SHVDU GH HVWD PRGLILFDFLyQ VLJXH KDELHQGRGLILFXOWDGHV\GHFLGHQKDFHUORSRUSDUHMDVURWDQGRORVUROHV (OHMHUFLFLRHPSLH]DQDKDFHUORHQWUtRSHURFRPROHVUHVXOWDPX\GLILFXOWRVDRSWDQSRU 5 OD VROXFLyQ GH KDFHUOR SRU SDUHMDV URWDQGR (O TXH TXHGD OLEUH UHFRJH ORV EDORQHV TXH FDHQ0DUtDPHSUHJXQWDVLHOODGHEHUHFRJHUWDPELpQORVEDORQHV\OHFRQWHVWRTXHKDJD ORTXHKDQKDEODGRHQJUXSR&RQUDGSURSRQHTXHVHDpO\ODRWUDQLxDTXLHQHVUHFRMDQ VLHPSUHORVEDORQHV\DVt0DUtDSDUWLFLSDHQHOMXHJRFRQVWDQWHPHQWH/HVSDUHFHELHQ\ DVtORKDFHQ (Q HO HMHUFLFLR HQ OD SULPHUD YDULDQWH GHO HMHUFLFLR 0DUtD QR FRUUH QL ODQ]D HO EDOyQ 5 6yORKDFHODYROWHUHWD(QODVHJXQGDSURSXHVWDORKDFHLJXDOTXHVXVFRPSDxHURV(QOD WHUFHUD \ FXDUWD QR KDFH HO HMHUFLFLR HQ FXFOLOODV SHUR VH GHVSOD]D FRQ XQD SHORWD GH HVSXPD VXMHWD HQWUH ORV PXVORV /D YHR PX\ PRWLYDGD \ PH FRPHQWD TXH QR VH OH HVFDSDODSHORWD 0LHQWUDV HVSHUDTXHOHWRTXHVXWXUQRKDFHXQHMHUFLFLRTXHFRQVLVWHHQHVWDUVHQWDGD 5 DQWHODSDUHG\JROSHDUODSHORWDGHYROHLEROFRQWUDODSDUHG\UHFLELUOD/HGLJRTXHDYHU VLORSXHGHKDFHUYHFHVVHJXLGDVPLHQWUDVTXHXQFRPSDxHURVHHQFDUJDGHUHFRJHU HOEDOyQVLVHOHFDH8QDYH]ORKDUHDOL]DGROHGLJRDYHUVLSXHGHOOHJDUD\TXH OXHJRORLQWHQWHFRQODPDQRGHUHFKDKDVWD\SRVWHULRUPHQWHFRQODL]TXLHUGD$OFDER GHXQUDWRYLHQHHOFRPSDxHUR\PHFRPHQWDTXH0DUtDQRTXLHUHFRQWLQXDU0HDFHUFRD HOOD \ OH SUHJXQWR SRU TXp &RQWHVWD TXH HVWi FDQVDGD \ TXH SUHILHUH YHU FyPR VXV FRPSDxHURVIDOODQ\DVtGLYHUWLUVH/HSUHJXQWRVLKDKHFKRHOHMHUFLFLRGHODQ]DUFRQXQD VRODPDQR0HGLFHTXHVtSHURTXHVyORFRQODL]TXLHUGDSRUTXHHV]XUGD\DVtOHUHVXOWD PiVIiFLO/HGLJRTXHHVEXHQRKDFHUORFRQODPDQRTXHQRGRPLQDSDUDJDQDUIXHU]D\ KDELOLGDG\TXHWLHQHTXHHVIRU]DUVH\QREXVFDUH[FXVDVFRPRTXHHVWiFDQVDGDRTXH QROHDSHWHFH (Q ORV HMHUFLFLRV LQGLYLGXDOHV WDUHD &RQUDG FRJH OD VLOOD \ OD FRORFD HQ HO VLWLR GH 0DUtD (OOD VH VLHQWD \ QR OH GD ODV JUDFLDV (Q YR] DOWD OH GLJR ³&RQUDG JUDFLDV SRU FRORFDUPH OD VLOOD´ 7RGRV VH UtHQ \ HOOD PH PLUD (Q VX FDUD YHR TXH QR OH KD KHFKR QLQJXQDJUDFLDORTXHDFDERGHGHFLU/HGLJRTXHHVRHVORTXHHOODGHEtDKDEHUGLFKR\ HQYR]EDMDPHUHVSRQGH³JUDFLDV´/HGLJR³¢JUDFLDVDTXLpQ"´\HOODUHVSRQGH³JUDFLDVD &RQUDG´\ORVGRVHPSLH]DQDUHtUVH ,QLFLDORVHMHUFLFLRVLQGLYLGXDOHV\FDGDYH]TXHVHOHFDHODSHORWD\XQFRPSDxHURVHOD GHYXHOYH HOOD OH GD ODV JUDFLDV \ PH PLUD FRPR GLFLHQGR ³KH DSUHQGLGR OD OHFFLyQ´ $GHPiVUHFODPDPLDWHQFLyQSDUDTXHYHDFyPRORKDFH &RPHQWDULRVDODVHVLyQ (VLQWHUHVDQWHFyPRODPDHVWUDDFHSWDODSURSXHVWDGH0DUtDGHKDFHUXQWUtR\TXHVHDQ GRV FRPSDxHURV ORV TXH OD HVFRMDQ FRPR FRPSDxHUD (V SRVLWLYR HO IRPHQWR GH OD VRFLDOL]DFLyQFXDQGRODPDHVWUDOHVLQGLFDTXHFRQVHQV~HQODSDUWLFLSDFLyQGHORVWUHVHQ ORVHMHUFLFLRVGHSDUHMDV 6LJRGHWHFWDQGRHOHTXLOLEULRHQWUHODVDGDSWDFLRQHV\ODVH[LJHQFLDVD0DUtDGHODQWHGH WRGRHOJUXSR 2EVHUYR TXH OD PDHVWUD FRQVLJXH TXH 0DUtD VHD FRQVFLHQWH TXH GHEH DJUDGHFHU OD D\XGDTXHOHEULQGDQORVFRPSDxHURV\QRLJQRUDUORVFRPRKDFtDKDVWDHOPRPHQWR 6(6,Ï11 '($%5,/'( 0DUtDQRDVLVWHDODVHVLyQGHOGtDGHKR\SRUTXHWLHQHYLVLWDPpGLFD /DPDHVWUDPHFRPHQWDODMXVWLILFDFLyQUHGDFWDGDSRU0DUtDUHVSHFWRDVXVUD]RQHVGH QRGXFKDUVHODVHVLyQ/LWHUDOPHQWHGLFH ³0HKHHQIDGDGRFRQODPDHVWUD\OD0HUFKHSRUTXHQRTXHUtDGXFKDUPHSRUTXH\DPH GXFKDUtDHQODSLVFLQD´ &RPRODPDHVWUDOHGLMRTXHHUDXQUD]RQDPLHQWRLQVXILFLHQWH\SRUODFRQYHUVDFLyQTXH WXYRFRQHOODUHIHUHQWHDVXFRPSRUWDPLHQWRWDQLQIDQWLOFRQWLQXyHVFULELHQGR ³2WUR GtD RV FRQWHVWDUp FXDQGR PH SUHJXQWpLV \ QXQFD PiV WHQGUp HO FRPSRUWDPLHQWR TXHWXYHD\HU$SDUWLUGHDKRUDPLFRPSRUWDPLHQWRVHUiHOGHXQDQLxDTXHHPSLH]DD 5 5 5 5 5 VHUJUDQGH3HUGyQSRUORGHD\HU´ /DPDHVWUDUHGDFWDFRQHVWDIHFKDXQLQIRUPHVREUHPLREVHUYDFLyQ\SUHVHQFLDHQVXV 5 VHVLRQHV7UDQVFULERVXFRQWHQLGROLWHUDOPHQWH +R\FRPRQRKDYHQLGR0DUtDKHDSURYHFKDGRSDUDKDEODU\SUHJXQWDUOHVTXpOHVSDUHFtDDHOORVHO TXHW~YLQLHUDVORVGtDVTXHOHVWRFD(GXFDFLyQ)tVLFD\TXpSLHQVDQGH0DUtD &RQWHVWDURQTXHPX\ELHQTXHGHVGHTXHYLHQHV0DUtDSXHGHSDUWLFLSDUPiV\DTXHW~ HVWiV SHQGLHQWH GH HOOD \ DVt \R SXHGR DWHQGHUORV \ REVHUYDUORV D HOORV DXQTXH W~ WDPELpQHVWiVSRUHOORV\ORKDFHV 4XHODD\XGDTXHUHFLERGHWLQRODWHQJRSRUSDUWHGHRWURVSURIHVRUHV/RVQLxRVGLFHQ TXH VH QRWD TXH VRPRV DPLJDV \D TXH ³RV OOHYiLV PX\ ELHQ \ RV OR FRPHQWiLV WRGR´ 3RVWHULRUPHQWHPHSUHJXQWDQSRUTXpKDEtDGHFLGLGRKDFHUKR\HVWHWLSRGHSUHJXQWDV HQ FODVH /HV FRQWHVWR ³YRVRWURV TXp FUHpLV"´ -XDQ FRQWHVWD ³FRPR 0DUtD QR HVWi TXLHUHV VDEHU TXp HV OR TXH SHQVDPRV´ 6HUJLR GLFH ³VL HVWXYLHUD 0DUtD QR OH KDUtD JUDFLD RtU VHJ~Q TXp FRVDV $GHPiV WRGRV VDEHPRV HO FDUiFWHU TXH WLHQH \ QRVRWURV TXHUUtDPRVKDFHUXQELHQ\HOODSHQVDUtDTXHOHHVWDPRVKDFLHQGRGDxR´ /HFRQWHVWRTXH\RTXLHURVDEHUTXpSLHQVDQHOORV\TXHRWURGtDWHQGUpXQDFKDUODFRQ 0DUtDSDUDVDEHUTXpHVORTXHSLHQVDHOOD\FRQTXLpQRTXLHQHVWLHQHPiVUHODFLyQ\SRU TXp/HVSUHJXQWRSRUTXpPiVGHODPLWDGGHODFODVHQRVRQDPLJRVGH0DUtD7RGRV GLFHQTXHVtORVRQ/HVFRPHQWRTXHORVDPLJRVVLHPSUHHVWiQMXQWRVTXHVHD\XGDQVH FXHQWDQVXVFRVDVVHSUHRFXSDQFXDQGRGHWHFWDQTXHHVWiQWULVWHVSUHJXQWDQGR³¢TXp WHSDVD"¢SXHGRD\XGDUWH"VDEHVTXHSXHGHVFRQWDUFRQPLJRSDUDWRGR´6DEHUMXJDU \FRPSDUWLU9DORUDUORVp[LWRV\IUDFDVRV4XHHOFRQFHSWRTXH\RWHQJRGHODDPLVWDG QRORYHRHQHOORV &RQUDGHQVHJXLGDPHGLFHTXHpOVLVHFRQVLGHUDDPLJRGH0DUtD\TXHFXDQGRODYH VROD VLHPSUH OH SUHJXQWD VL TXLHUH MXJDU ³VL YH TXH HVWR\ VROR PH GLFH TXH Vt SHUR VL HVWR\FRQRWURVDPLJRVQRTXLHUH´/HGLJRTXHWLHQHUD]yQ\TXHHVHO~QLFRTXHYHRTXH VHSUHRFXSDSRUHOOD4XHORVKHYLVWRMXJDU\D0DUtDUHtUVHDFDUFDMDGDVFRQpO4XH FXDQGRODYHWULVWHRHQIDGDGDOHSUHJXQWDTXpOHSDVD6HJ~Q&RQUDGHVRHVODDPLVWDG HOSUHRFXSDUVHSRUORVGHPiVHOD\XGDUVH\VDEHUFRPSDUWLUOREXHQR\ORPDOR 0DQHOGLFHTXHpOVtHVDPLJRGH0DUtD4XHOHGLFHGHMXJDUFRQpOHQHOSDWLRSHURTXH HOODQRTXLHUH/HSUHJXQWRTXHDTXpVHUHILHUHFXDQGRGLFHTXHMXHJXHFRQHOODDI~WERO R D RWURV MXHJRV" eO UHVSRQGH TXH D I~WERO /H FRQWHVWR ³QR FUHHV TXH D HOOD QR OH DSHWHFH MXJDU D I~WERO" 3RUTXH VRLV PXFKRV \ HOOD SXHGH SHQVDU TXH SDUD QR WRFDU HO EDOyQ OR PHMRU HV QR MXJDU R TXH OH SXHGHQ KDFHU GDxR OD SXHGHQ WLUDU UHFLELU XQ EDORQD]R$FRQWLQXDFLyQOHGLJR³SRUTXpQROHSURSRQHVTXHVHDHOODODTXHGHFLGDD TXpMXJDU"´eOFRQWHVWDTXHDYHFHVVtORKDFHSHURTXH0DUtDVLHPSUHOHGLFHTXHQR 5 5 5 )UHGHULFFRPHQWDTXHpODYHFHVMXHJDFRQHOODDMXHJRVFRPRHOSLOODSLOODDOHVFRQGLWH HWFSHURTXHSRFDVYHFHV\DTXHHQVHJXLGDVHFDQVDRVHHQIDGD'HVSXpVGHHVWH FRPHQWDULR WRGRV HPSLH]DQ D OHYDQWDU OD PDQR SDUD LQWHUYHQLU ÈQJHOD GLFH TXH YDQ MXQWDVDXQHVSODLORVViEDGRV\TXHDOOtWDPELpQMXHJDQSHURTXHGHSHQGHGHOGtDTXH WHQJDSDUWLFLSDPiVRPHQRV4XHHOODODFRQVLGHUDDPLJDVX\D\TXHSDUWLFLSDPiVHQOD HVFXHODTXHHQHOHVSODL4XHWDQWR0HUFKHFRPR\RQRVSUHRFXSDPRVSRUHOODDOPLVPR WLHPSRTXHOHH[LJLPRV 6HUJLR LQWHUYLHQH ³\R HVWR\ FDQVDGR GH GHFLUOH TXH YHQJD D MXJDU $OJXQDV YHFHV VH KDFH OD GHVSLVWDGD R KDFH TXH QR PH R\H HQWRQFHV \R PH YR\ 6L QR TXLHUH FRQWHVWDUPHQRYR\DLUGHWUiVGHHOOD$GHPiVPXFKDVYHFHVVHFRPSRUWDFRPRXQD QLxDSHTXHxDRFRQVHQWLGDVHHQIDGDSRUQDGD\HPSLH]DDOORUDU´ 5REHUWGLFHTXH-\0$>GRVPDHVWURV@VLHPSUHVHHQIDGDQFRQHOODSRUTXHHQFODVHQR WUDEDMD \ SLHUGH HO WLHPSR /H GLFHQ TXH FRPR VLJD DVt WHQGUi TXH UHSHWLU FXUVR < HV FXDQGRHOODFRJHODVPXOHWDVFRQUDELD\ODVWLUDDOVXHORVHHQFRJHGHEUD]RV\HPSLH]D DOORUDU&XDQGROHSUHJXQWDQSRUTXpOORUDPXFKDVYHFHVQRFRQWHVWD\VLORKDFHKDEOD FRPRXQDQLxDSHTXHxD 0DWHR RSLQD TXH OH SDUHFH PX\ ELHQ TXH W~ >0HUFKH@ YHQJDV \D TXH 0DUtD QHFHVLWD GHVDUUROODUODIXHU]DVREUHWRGRHQORVEUD]RV<TXHVLHQGRGRVODVTXHFRQWURODPRVHOOD VHGLVWUDHPHQRV\WUDEDMDPiV5HFRQRFHTXHQRWLHQHPXFKDDPLVWDGFRQHOODSRUTXH HVXQDQLxDPX\FDOODGD4XHDpOOHJXVWDPXFKRKDEODU\TXHVHDEXUUHFRQHOOD 0DLWHGLFH³FXDQGRGLFHVKR\WUDEDMDUHPRVHQSDUHMDVWUtRVRHQJUXSRVFDVLVLHPSUHOD YR\ D EXVFDU SHUR HOOD SRQH FDUD FRPR VL QR TXLVLHUD WUDEDMDU FRQPLJR < FXDQGR WHQHPRV TXH KDEODU SDUD GHFLGLU TXp KDUHPRV R WLHQH TXH D\XGDU SDUWLFLSD SRFR \ VLHPSUH WHQHPRV TXH GHFLGLU QRVRWUDV´ /H SUHJXQWR VL HOODV GLDORJDQ R VL OH SUHJXQWDQ TXpOHSDUHFHORTXHKDQDFRUGDGRSDUDVDEHUVLHOODHVWiGHDFXHUGRRQRRVLSURSRQH RWUDFRVD&DUPHGLFH³(OODDWRGRGLFHTXHVtDXQTXHPX\SRFDVYHFHVHV0DUtDODTXH OOHYDODLQLFLDWLYD<RFUHRTXHQROHJXVWDKDEODU\FXDQGRORKDFH\QRVRWUDVQRHVWDPRV GHDFXHUGRVHHQIDGD\VHTXHGDVHQWDGDKDVWDTXHW~R0HUFKHYHQtDDSUHJXQWDUOHTXp OHSDVD3HURFXDQGRPHKDWRFDGRRKHGHFLGLGRVHUVXSDUHMDQRVKHPRVOOHYDGRPX\ ELHQ\KD\GLiORJRHQWUHQRVRWUDVQRVKHPRVUHtGRPXFKR\DTXHFXDQGRTXLHUHHVPX\ GLYHUWLGD´ 'jOLD H[SOLFD TXH D HOOD OH VXFHGH OR PLVPR FRQ 0DUtD (Q ORV WUDEDMRV HQ SDUHMD OD UHODFLyQIXQFLRQDPHMRU\HOSUREOHPDYLHQHFXDQGRVRQRPiVTXHHVFXDQGRHOODVH DSDUWD\SDUWLFLSDSRFR/HSUHJXQWR³&XDQGRVHDSDUWDODGHMiLVROHSUHJXQWiLVSRUTXp OR KDFH"´ )UDQFHVF GLFH ³/R TXH SDVD HV TXH ODV QLxDV OD GHMiLV DO PDUJHQ \ KDFpLV EURPDVHQWUHYRVRWUDV<RRVKHYLVWRPXFKDVYHFHV´7RPiVGLFHTXHQRHVYHUGDG\D TXHODVQLxDVFXDQGRKDFHQEURPDVORKDFHQFRQWRGRHOJUXSR\QRDSDUWDQD0DUtDDO FRQWUDULRODD\XGDQ/RTXHSDVDHVTXHD0DUtDOHJXVWDTXHVHORGHQWRGRKHFKR &HQWURGHHGXFDFLyQHQHOWLHPSROLEUH 5 5 5 5 5 5 3DWULFLDGLFH³<RPXFKDVYHFHVKHWHQLGRTXHVHUVXSDUHMD\DTXHQDGLHQRVKDHOHJLGR &RPR W~ VLHPSUH GLFHV TXH SURFXUHPRV TXH ODV SDUHMDV \ WUtRV VHDPRV SDUHFLGDV HQ SHVR \ DOWXUD \R FUHR TXH PL FRPSOH[LyQ QR VH SDUHFH HQ QDGD D HOOD $O SULQFLSLR QR WHQtDPRVPX\EXHQDUHODFLyQSHURDKRUDPHORSDVRPX\ELHQFRQHOOD\SDVDORPLVPR FRQORVWUtRV\HQJUXSR´ %LELDQD GLFH ³/RV QLxRV PHQRV &RQUDG FXDQGR WX GLFHV DJUXSDURV HQ SDUHMDV R WUtRV QXQFD OD HOLJHQ $O FRQWUDULR VLHPSUH YDQ D EXVFDU D ORV DPLJRV D SHVDU TXH HVWRV SXHGDQSDUHFHUVHD0DUtD>HQFRPSOH[LyQ@(OORVWUDEDMDQFRQ0DUtDVLW~ORGLFHVSHUR QRVDOHGHHOORV´ ,VDFRPHQWD³<RHVWR\GHDFXHUGRFRQODFRPSDxHUDDQWHULRU$OSULQFLSLRW~PHSRQtDV GHSDUHMDFRQHOOD\ODYHUGDGHVTXHQXQFDKHWHQLGRQLQJ~QSUREOHPD(VFLHUWRTXHQR KDEOD PXFKR DXQTXH D Pt PH SDVD OR PLVPR 3HUR FRQ RWUDV FRPSDxHUDV KDEOR PiV GHELGRDTXHVRQHOODVODVTXHHPSLH]DQDH[SOLFDUPHSUHJXQWDUPH\SRUWDQWRVLHPSUH WHQHPRVWHPDVGHTXpKDEODU´ ,YiQLQWHUYLHQH³<RMXHJRFRQ0DUtDDI~WERO\FXDQGRHOODVXEHODVHVFDOHUDVSDUDLUDOD FODVHFDVLVLHPSUHOHOOHYRODPRFKLOD\OHD\XGRHQWRGRORTXHSXHGR<RPHFRQVLGHUR DPLJRGHHOOD´ 3URSRQJRTXHSDUDPDxDQDPHWUDLJDQSRUHVFULWRFyPRVHUiDSDUWLUGHDKRUDODUHODFLyQ FRQ HOOD FyPR HVWDEDQ DFWXDQGR \ FyPR DFWXDUiQ 0DWHR FRPHQWD ³HO FDPELR OR WHQGUHPRVTXHKDFHUTXHQRVHQRWHPXFKRSRFRDSRFRSDUDTXHHOODQRVRVSHFKH\ SXHGDLPDJLQDUVHTXHKDSDVDGRDOJR\TXHQRVHKDHQWHUDGR´ 0iV GH OD PLWDG GH OD FODVH GLFH TXH D SDUWLU GH DKRUD FXDQGR OD YHDQ VROD OH SUHJXQWDUiQVLTXLHUHMXJDU\TXHVHDHOODODTXHSURSRQJDORVMXHJRV6LODYHQHQIDGDGD VHSUHRFXSDUiQSUHJXQWiQGROHTXpOHSDVD6LHOODHQHVHPRPHQWRQRTXLHUHUHVSRQGHU HVSHUDUiQDTXHVHOHSDVHHOHQIDGR\YROYHUiQDSUHJXQWDUOHSRUTXpVHKDHQIDGDGR TXp HV OR TXH KD SDVDGR 4XH OD D\XGDUiQ HQ FODVH FRQ ODV PDWHULDV TXH D HOOD OH FXHVWDQ R QR HQWLHQGH 4XH KDEODUiQ FRQ HOOD GH FXDOTXLHU WHPD H[SOLFiQGROH DOJXQD SHOtFXODFRQWDQGRFKLVWHVTXpHVORTXHKDFHORVILQHVGHVHPDQDRFXDQGRVDOHQGHO FROHJLRTXHHQHOYHVWXDULROHSUHJXQWDUiQVLQHFHVLWDVXD\XGD &RPHQWDULRVDODVHVLyQ (VWHLQIRUPHFUHRTXHVHUiPX\LQWHUHVDQWHSDUDFRPSOHWDUODLQIRUPDFLyQREWHQLGDHQHO VRFLRJUDPD&RQVWDWDPRVTXHHOSODQWHDPLHQWRGHODPDHVWUDHVPX\SRVLWLYR\DTXHKD IDFLOLWDGRTXHORVFRPSDxHURVGH0DUtDVHH[SUHVHQ\UHIOH[LRQHQVREUHVXUHODFLyQFRQ HOODOOHJDQGRDSODQWHDUVHFyPRGHEHQVHUVXVUHODFLRQHVHQHOIXWXUR(YLGHQFLDPRVDVt TXH OD VHVLyQ GH (GXFDFLyQ )tVLFD HV XQ HVSDFLR GRQGH OD LQWHUUHODFLyQ VRFLDO HV PX\ LPSRUWDQWH\D\XGDDGHWHFWDUORVSRVLEOHVFRQIOLFWRVRDILQLGDGHVH[LVWHQWHVHQHOJUXSR (Q HVWH VHQWLGR HV PX\ LQWHUHVDQWH HO DQiOLVLV TXH KDFHQ GHO FRPSRUWDPLHQWR \ OD SHUVRQDOLGDGGH0DUtD 5 5 5 5 5 5 5 0HOODPDODDWHQFLyQODWUDQVSDUHQFLDFRQODTXHODPDHVWUDKDEODGH0DUtDGHPt\OD VLQFHULGDG GH VXV FRPSDxHURV \ FRPSDxHUDV &yPR DQDOL]DQ VX UHODFLyQ FRQ 0DUtD \ FyPRLQWHUSUHWDQ\YDORUDQPLSUHVHQFLDHQODVVHVLRQHV 'HVWDFDUHQFDPELRSRVLWLYRTXHVHKDGDGRHQODVUHODFLRQHVHQWUH3DWULFLD\0DUtD\ FRQILUPDUODH[FHOHQWHUHODFLyQTXHWLHQHFRQ&RQUDG &RPR HMHPSOR GH ORV HVFULWRV SUHVHQWDGRV SRU ORV FRPSDxHURV HO GtD VLJXLHQWH WUDQVFULERHOSUHVHQWDGRSRU3DWULFLD\DTXHODPDHVWUDORFRQVLGHUyHOPiVVLJQLILFDWLYR MXJDUpPiVFRQHOOD\OHKDUpPiVFDVR\KDEODUpPiV PLUDUpODVFRVDVDQWHVGHGHFLUOHSDUDTXHQROHVLHQWHQPDO VHUpVLQFHUDFRQHOOD\FRQWRGRV OHGLUpODVFRVDVTXHTXLHURTXHPHMRUH OHSUHJXQWDUpVLTXLHUHD\XGD\VLQROHSUHJXQWDUpSRUTXp ODGHIHQGHUp ODD\XGDUpSHURQRHVWDUpWRGRHOGtDHQFLPDGHHOOD LQWHQWDUpKDFHUOHFRVDVSDUDTXHQRVHHQIDGH PHJXVWDUtDGDUOHWRGRSDUDVXFRPRGLGDG KDUpODVFRVDVTXHSXHGDVLHPSUHTXHHOODWDPELpQFRODERUH 5 '($%5,/'( /DPDHVWUDHVFULEH /DVHVLyQTXHWHQtDSUHSDUDGDHUDGHEiVTXHWSHURHPSH]yDOORYHU\QRVHSXGROOHYDU D FDER 1RV TXHGDPRV HQ HO JLPQDVLR $QWHV GH HPSH]DU ODV DFWLYLGDGHV HVWXYH KDEODQGRFRQGRVFRPSDxHURVGH0DUtDSDUDTXHH[SOLFDUDQDRWURVGRVTXHQRKDEtDQ YHQLGRHOGtDDQWHULRUORTXHHVWXYLPRVKDEODQGR\ORTXHWHQtDQTXHKDFHU (PSH]DPRVFRQXQMXHJRQXHYR³7RGRVSXHQWHV´ 'HOLPLWR HO HVSDFLR GH UHFRUULGR GH 0DUtD D FLQFR PHWURV DSUR[LPDGDPHQWH \ OH RWRUJR WUHV YLGDV VL OD DWUDSDQ WLHQH WUHV RSRUWXQLGDGHV SDUD FRQWLQXDU FRPR MXJDGRUD GH FDPSR $O WHQHU TXH SDVDU HQWUH ODV SLHUQDV GH VXV FRPSDxHURV VH GHVSOD]D HQ FXDGUXSHGLD\WDQVyORFRJHODVPXOHWDVFXDQGRVHOHKDQDJRWDGRODVWUHVYLGDV\SDVDD VHUMXJDGRU³SXHQWH´ /DYHRPX\DQLPDGD(QXQDRFDVLyQOHOODPRODDWHQFLyQ\DTXHDOSDVDUSRUHOSXHQWH 5 6(6,Ï11 /RVMXJDGRUHVVHVLW~DQHQHOH[WUHPRGHODVDOD\RWURFRPSDxHURODDUDxDVHORFDOL]DHQHOFHQWURGH ODVDOD'HODQWHGHpVWHWUHVMXJDGRUHVORVSXHQWHVXQRDOODGRGHORWURFRQODVSLHUQDVVHSDUDGDV$OD VHxDOORVSDUWLFLSDQWHVWLHQHQTXHFUX]DUHOHVSDFLRGHMXHJRFRQHOREMHWLYRTXHQROHVDWUDSH³ODDUDxD´ DQWHVGHOOHJDUDORWURH[WUHPRGHODVDODUHIXJLR\FRQODFRQGLFLyQGHSDVDUHQWUHODVSLHUQDVGHORV MXJDGRUHVTXHDFW~DQGHSXHQWHVLQFOX\HQGROD³DUDxD´$PHGLGDTXHpVWDYDDWUDSDQGRORVVLW~DMXQWRD ORVFRPSDxHURVSXHQWHV*DQDHO~OWLPRMXJDGRUTXHOOHJDDOUHIXJLRVLQVHUFRJLGRSRUODDUDxD 5 5 5 5 OHYDQWDODFDEH]D\OHGLJRTXHODEDMHSDUDHYLWDUKDFHUOHGDxRDOFRPSDxHUR/DVLJR REVHUYDQGR\DOFDERGHXQUDWRYXHOYHDOHYDQWDUGHPDVLDGRODFDEH]DKDFLpQGROHGDxR HQ OD HQWUHSLHUQD \ pVWH FDH HQFLPD GH HOOD 0H DFHUFR HQIDGDGD \ OH GLJR ³WH GDV FXHQWD TXH SRU QR FRUUHJLU KDV DFDEDGR KDFLpQGROH GDxR"\ DGHPiV SRGtDQ KDEHUWH KHFKRGDxRDWL´(OODVHYDKDFLDXQODGRGHOJLPQDVLRPX\HQIDGDGD\GLFLHQGRTXHQR TXLHUHMXJDUDSXQWRGHOORUDU/HGLJRTXHVLPHKXELHUDKHFKRFDVRGHVGHHOSULQFLSLR WRGR VH KXELHUD HYLWDGR 0H FRQWHVWD TXH QR TXHUtD KDFHUOH GDxR TXH VH OR HVWDED SDVDQGRWDQELHQTXHQRVHDFRUGDEDGHORTXHWHQtDTXHKDFHU4XHTXHUtDHYLWDUTXHOD SLOODUDQ/HFRQWHVWRTXHPHSDUHFHPX\ELHQSHURTXHODHQWUHSLHUQDGHORVFKLFRVDO LJXDOTXHHOSHFKRGHODVFKLFDVVRQSDUWHVPX\VHQVLEOHV/HSLGRTXHVHGLVFXOSHDVX FRPSDxHUR(OODYDKDFLDpVWH\OHSLGHTXHODSHUGRQH\TXHORVLHQWHSUHJXQWiQGROHVL \DHVWiELHQeOOHFRQWHVWDTXHQRSDVDQDGDTXH\DHVWiELHQ &RQWLQ~DQMXJDQGR\GHYH]HQFXDQGRVXGRURVDVHHVWLUDHQHOVXHORULHQGRGLFLHQGR TXHQRSXHGHPiVDXQTXHVLJXHMXJDQGRSRFRGHVSXpV 6LJRFRQHOMXHJRGH³/DERPED´FRQGRVEDORQHVPHGLFLQDOHVGH.J (OJUXSRVHQWDGRHQFtUFXOR8QMXJDGRUHQHOFHQWUReVWHFXHQWDHQYR]DOWDGHD PLHQWUDV TXH VXV FRPSDxHURV VH YDQ SDVDQGR XQ EDOyQ GH XQR D RWUR VLJXLHQGR OD WUD\HFWRULDGHOFtUFXOR$OOOHJDUDHOMXJDGRUGHOFHQWURJULWD³%RPED´\HOFRPSDxHUR TXHWLHQHHOEDOyQHQHVHPRPHQWRHVHOTXHSDVDDHVWDUHQHOFHQWUR $0DUtDOHGLJRTXHHVWDUiHQHOFHQWURGHOFtUFXORFRQWDQGR/RDFHSWDGHEXHQJUDGR\D TXH GLFH HVWDU PX\ FDQVDGD 3RVWHULRUPHQWH SDVD D VHU MXJDGRUD GH JUXSR \ SDUWLFLSD PX\DFWLYDPHQWH )LQDOL]DGRHOMXHJRPHSLGHQMXJDUDO³FRFRGULOR´ /RV MXJDGRUHV VH VLW~DQ HQ HO H[WUHPR GH OD VDOD \ RWUR FRPSDxHUR ³HO FRFRGULOR´ VH ORFDOL]DHQHOFHQWURGHODVDOD$ODVHxDOORVMXJDGRUHVWLHQHQTXHFUX]DUHOHVSDFLRGH MXHJRVFRQHOREMHWLYRTXHQROHVDWUDSH³HOFRFRGULOR´DQWHVGHOOHJDUDORWURH[WUHPRGHOD VDOD$PHGLGDTXHHO³FRFRGULOR´YDWRFDQGRDORVSDUWLFLSDQWHVpVWRVVHFRQYLHUWHQHQ QXHYRVFRFRGULORVKDVWDTXHTXHGDXQMXJDGRUVLQVHUDWUDSDGR 0DUtD SDUWLFLSD FRQ ODV PLVPDV DGDSWDFLRQHV TXH SURSRQJR HQ HO MXHJR GHO ³WRGRV SXHQWH´ 3DUDILQDOL]DUOHVH[SOLFRODJLPFDQDHQODTXHSDUWLFLSDUiQMXQWRFRQORVDOXPQRVGHOD HVFXHODGH(GXFDFLyQ(VSHFLDOSUy[LPDDVXFHQWUR\TXHKDQSUHSDUDGRORVDOXPQRVGH OD 8QLYHUVLGDG 4XH HO WHPD HV ³8QLYHUVLWDULRV SRU XQ GtD´ \ WRGRV VH SRQHQ PX\ FRQWHQWRV 0LHQWUDVTXHORVRWURVVHGXFKDQ0DUtDPHSLGHSHUPLVRSDUDUHSDUWLUODVLQYLWDFLRQHV GHODILHVWDGHVXFXPSOHDxRVTXHWHQGUiOXJDUHOSUy[LPRYLHUQHV &RPHQWDULRVDODVHVLyQ 5 5 5 5 5 5 6HJXLPRVFRQVWDWDQGRHOHTXLOLEULRDGDSWDFLRQHVH[LJHQFLDVTXHODPDHVWUDOOHYDDFDER HQ ODV VHVLRQHV FRQ UHVXOWDGRV PX\ EXHQRV HYLGHQFLDGRV HQ HO SURJUHVLYR FDPELR GH DFWLWXGGH0DUtDHQVXPRWLYDFLyQ\EXHQQLYHOGHSDUWLFLSDFLyQ 6(6,Ï11 '($%5,/'( 3RU XQD UHXQLyQ GHO &RQVHMR GH (VWXGLRV GH (GXFDFLyQ (VSHFLDO HQ OD 8QLYHUVLGDG QR SXGHDVLVWLUDODVHVLyQ3RUWDQWRHVODPDHVWUDODTXHUHFRJHODSDUWLFLSDFLyQGH0DUtD /DPDHVWUDHVFULEH (VWDVHPDQDPHWRFDYLJLODUHOSDWLR$OOt0DUtDPHFRPHQWDTXHDVXILHVWDIXHURQ FRPSDxHURV \ PH GHVFULEH ORV UHJDORV TXH UHFLELy 3RVWHULRUPHQWH MXHJD FRQ FRPSDxHURVDI~WEROPLHQWUDVTXHODVQLxDVHVWiQYLHQGRHQODVDODGHYtGHRXQFOLSGH 4XHHQ\DTXHHQODILHVWDGH6DQW-RUGLGHDEULOWHQGUiQTXHEDLODUOR 0DUtD MXJy DFWLYDPHQWH \ XQ FRPSDxHUR GHO JUXSR PH FRPHQWD TXH KDQ PRQWDGR XQD OLJXLOOD\TXHHOODHVWiLQFOXLGD ,QLFLR OD VHVLyQFRQHOMXHJR³7RGRVSXHQWHV´ >GHVFULWR HQ OD VHVLyQ DQWHULRU@ /H GLJRD 0DUtDVLUHFXHUGDODVDGDSWDFLRQHV\ORTXHWLHQHTXHKDFHU\PHFRQWHVWDTXHVtTXH HVWDYH]LUiFRQFXLGDGRSDUDQRKDFHUGDxRDQDGLH$OFDERGHXQUDWRXQFRPSDxHUR VHPHDFHUFD\GLFHTXH0DUtDQRTXLHUHKDFHUGHSXHQWH\DTXHKDDJRWDGRVXVWUHV YLGDV 0H DFHUFR \ 0DUtD PH GLFH TXH OD ~OWLPD YLGD OD KD SHUGLGR SRU FXOSD GH XQ FRPSDxHURTXHOHKDFHUUDGRHOSDVR/HGLJRTXHQREXVTXHH[FXVDV\TXHQRHFKHODV FXOSDV DO RWUR TXH WLHQH TXH UHVSHWDU ODV UHJODV GHO MXHJR \ TXH SRU WDQWR VDEH SHUIHFWDPHQWH OR TXH WLHQH TXH KDFHU 1R KDFH QLQJ~Q FRPHQWDULR QL VH HQIDGD FRORFiQGRVHGHSXHQWH 2EVHUYR TXH DQLPD D VXV FRPSDxHURV SDUD TXH SDVHQ SRU VX SXHQWH UHODFLRQiQGRVH YHUEDOPHQWH FRQ QRUPDOLGDG FRQ VXV FRPSDxHURV \ FRPSDxHUDV PiV FHUFDQRV D HOOD SDViQGRVHORPX\ELHQ (OVHJXQGRMXHJRHVHO³SLOODSLOODFRQQRPEUHV´ 7RGRVORVDOXPQRVGLVWULEXLGRVSRUXQHVSDFLRGHOLPLWDGR/DPDHVWUDGLUiHOQRPEUHGH XQRGHHOORVORTXHVXSRQGUiTXHHVHOMXJDGRUTXHSDUDeVWHLQWHQWDUiWRFDUDOPi[LPR GHMXJDGRUHVFRQHOREMHWLYRGHHOLPLQDUORVKDVWDTXHODPDHVWUDQRPEUDDRWURMXJDGRU *DQDHOMXHJRHOTXHTXHGHHO~OWLPRHQOD]RQDGHMXHJR /DDGDSWDFLyQTXHSURSRQJRSDUD0DUtDHVODKDELWXDO2WRUJDUOHYLGDVHOJLPQDVLRHV PiVSHTXHxRTXHHOSDWLRGRQGHOHFRQFHGRFRQODFRQGLFLyQGHTXHVLODWRFDQSRU WDQWRSLHUGHXQDYLGDHOMXJDGRUTXHOHKDWRFDGRGDGDODSUR[LPLGDGHYLGHQWHQRSXHGH YROYHUODDWRFDUH[FHSWXDQGRFXDQGRTXHGDQSRFRVSRUWRFDU(QHOPRPHQWRHQTXHHV QRPEUDGD VH JULWD ³VWRS´ \ WRGR HO JUXSR WLHQH TXH TXHGDU LQPyYLO 0DUtD SXHGH GDU HO Q~PHUR GH SDVRV LOLPLWDGRV KDVWD DFHUFDUVH D OD SHUVRQD TXH GHFLGD WDQ VyOR SXHGH 5 5 5 5 5 5 LQWHUUXPSLUVXDFFLyQVLQRPEURHQHVHUHFRUULGRDRWURMXJDGRU 0DUtDQRJDQDSHURVLHPSUHTXHGDGHODV~OWLPDV\VHPXHVWUDPX\DFWLYD\PRWLYDGD 6HJXLPRVFRQHOMXHJRGH³HVFULELUHOQRPEUHHQODHVSDOGD´ *UXSRV GH VHQWDGRV HQ ILOD LQGLD (O ~OWLPR HVFULEH XQD SDODEUD HQ OD HVSDOGD GHO VLJXLHQWH\pVWHDOSULPHURGHODILOD6HWUDWDGHFRPSUREDUVLHOPHQVDMHVHUHSURGXFH FRUUHFWDPHQWH 0DUtDSDUWLFLSDVLQGLILFXOWDG $QWHVGHLUVHDODGXFKDOHVUHFXHUGRTXHDOGtDVLJXLHQWHKDUiQEiVTXHW\DTXHTXHGy SHQGLHQWHODVHPDQDDQWHULRU &RPHQWDULRVDODVHVLyQ 'HVWDFDPRV OD SDUWLFLSDFLyQ DFWLYD GH 0DUtD \ VX DFHSWDFLyQ GH ODV REVHUYDFLRQHV UHDOL]DGDVSRUODPDHVWUD 6(6,Ï11 '($%5,/'( /DPDHVWUDHVFULEH (VODSULPHUDVHVLyQGHLQLFLDFLyQDOEDORQFHVWR\WLHQHOXJDUHQODSLVWDSROLGHSRUWLYD /RV GLVSRQJR HQ SDUHMDV FRQ HO FULWHULR GH DJUXSDU D DTXHOORV TXH QR WLHQHQ PXFKD UHODFLyQPXWXD4XLHURREVHUYDUVXUHDFFLyQVLVHD\XGDQVLGLDORJDQ /DV DFWLYLGDGHV TXH SURSRQJR VRQ 0DUtD VLHPSUH VHQWDGD HQ XQD VLOOD GH UXHGDV \ SUy[LPDDXQDFDQDVWD XQRIUHQWHDRWURDXQDGLVWDQFLDGHPUHDOL]DUSDVHVDODDOWXUD GHOSHFKR SDVHSRUHQFLPDGHODFDEH]DVLQVDOWR tGHPFRQHOSDVHERPEHDGR\DOUHFLELUGDUXQVDOWR0DUtDVLQVDOWR SDVH FRQ ERWH \ FDGD YH] FRQ PD\RU GLVWDQFLD HQWUH OD SDUHMD HQ 0DUtDODVHSDUDFLyQHVPHQRU SDVHLQWHQWDQGRGHVSOD]DUDOFRPSDxHURGHGHUHFKDDL]TXLHUGDVLQ TXH FDLJD HO EDOyQ DO VXHOR D 0DUtD GH OH SDVDUi HO EDOyQ VLQ H[DJHUDU ORV SDVHV PLHQWUDV TXH HOOD Vt OR KDUi SDUD GHVSOD]DU DO FRPSDxHUR VHDXPHQWDODGLVWDQFLDHQWUHODSDUHMD8QRFRUUHERWDQGRODSHORWD FRQ OD PDQR GHUHFKD GD OD YXHOWD DO FRPSDxHUR UHJUHVD D OD SRVLFLyQLQLFLDO\OHHQYtDODSHORWDURGDQGRSRUHOVXHORËGHPFRQOD PDQRL]TXLHUGD&RPR0DUtDWLHQHGLILFXOWDGHVSDUDFRQWURODUDODYH] 5 5 5 5 5 5 5 5 5 VLOOD\ERWHOHSURSRQJRTXHKDJDFXDWURLQWHQWRVGHFDQDVWDFRQOD PDQRGHUHFKDPLHQWUDVTXHVXFRPSDxHURFXDQGRHOODDFDEDKDFH HOPLVPRHMHUFLFLRTXHHOUHVWR tGHPSHURHOTXHQRWLHQHODSHORWDKDFHPDUFDMHGHOFRPSDxHURVLQ SRGHUOHTXLWDUODSHORWD0DUtDWLUDDFDQDVWDFRQODPDQRL]TXLHUGD &XDQGR OH WRFD D VX FRPSDxHUR GHEH GHVSOD]DUVH KDFLD DWUiV PLHQWUDV0DUtDOHPDUFD HQWUDGD D FDQDVWD SRU OD GHUHFKD (O FRPSDxHUR HQWUD SRU OD L]TXLHUGDSDUDUHFRJHUHOUHERWHFDPELDQGRHOURO0DUtDHVWiIXHUD GHODFDQDVWDERWDQGRFRQODPDQRGHUHFKDLQWHQWDQGRFRQVHJXLUXQ EXHQ GRPLQLR GH EDOyQ 6X FRPSDxHUR HVWi FRQ HOOD FRQWURODQGR FXDQGR OH WRFD WLUDU D FDQDVWD SDUD KDFHU HO HMHUFLFLR \ SDVDUOH GH QXHYRHOEDOyQD0DUtD tGHPSHURSRUHOODGRL]TXLHUGR tGHP SHUR FRQ GREOH SDVR SUHYLR D ODQ]DU D FDQDVWD (Q HVWH HMHUFLFLRHOJUXSRRFXSD XQD VROD FDQDVWD \D TXH 0DUtD HVWi HQ OD RWUDWLUDQGRSRUHOFHQWURSHURDQWHVGHWLUDUGHEHGDUERWHV /HSUHJXQWRD0DUtDVLKDPHWLGRDOJXQDFDQDVWD\PHGLFHTXHQRSRUTXHHVPX\DOWD\ HQFDPELRODVGHOFHQWURGHUHKDELOLWDFLyQVRQPiVEDMDV/HGLJRTXHDKRUDORLPSRUWDQWH QR HV HQFHVWDU VLQR TXH DSUHQGD D WHQHU XQD EXHQD WpFQLFD GH ODQ]DPLHQWR \ TXH OR GHPiVYHQGUiVROR4XHVLORKDFHFRUUHFWDPHQWHFXDQGRMXHJXHSDUWLGRVHQHOFHQWUR WHQGUiPiVSUHFLVLyQHQHOWLUR\VHJXURTXHDFLHUWD $FRQWLQXDFLyQOHSUHJXQWRFRQTXpPDQRERWDPHMRUODSHORWD0HUHVSRQGHTXHFRQODV GRV SHUR TXH OR KDFH PHMRU FRQ OD L]TXLHUGD SRUTXH HV ]XUGD /H GLJR TXH D SDUWLU GH DKRUDDODV>KRUDGHOSDWLR@OHGDUpXQDSHORWDGHEiVTXHWSDUDTXHYD\DSUDFWLFDQGR\ TXH FXDQGR YROYDPRV GH YDFDFLRQHV GH 6HPDQD 6DQWD TXH VLJD WUD\HQGR OD VLOOD GH UXHGDV \D TXH YDPRV D HPSH]DU D WUDEDMDU ORV GHSRUWHV \ TXH OD QHFHVLWDUi SDUD ORV HMHUFLFLRVFRQGHVSOD]DPLHQWRV\SDUDORVSDUWLGRV 3LHQVRTXHKDQVLGRXQDFLHUWRODVSDUHMDVGHKR\1RKDKDELGRQLQJ~QHQIUHQWDPLHQWR HQWUHHOORV\WDQWRHOFRPSRUWDPLHQWRFRPRHODSUHQGL]DMHKDQVLGRPX\EXHQRV$QWHV GHLUDODGXFKDOHVKHGLFKRTXHHQHOWHUFHUWULPHVWUHWUDEDMDUtDPRVORVGHSRUWHV\TXH MXJDUiQ XQRV SDUWLGLOORV HQ IRUPD GH OLJXLOOD 4XH HVSHUR PXFKR GH HOORV \ TXH QR PH GHIUDXGHQ4XHPHKDJXVWDGRPXFKRVXFRPSRUWDPLHQWR\VXVJDQDVGHVXSHUDUVH\ OHVKHSUHJXQWDGRVLHOORVWHQtDQODPLVPDVHQVDFLyQ0HUHVSRQGHQTXHHVODDVLJQDWXUD TXHPiVOHVJXVWDDXQTXHDYHFHVUHFRQRFHQTXHWHQJRTXHHQIDGDUPHFRQHOORV1RV GHVSHGLPRVKDVWDGHVSXpVGHYDFDFLRQHV &RPHQWDULRVDODVHVLyQ (VLQWHUHVDQWHFRPRODPDHVWUDLQWHQWDIDFLOLWDUODVRFLDOL]DFLyQDJUXSDQGRDFRPSDxHURV TXHQRWLHQHQGHPDVLDGDUHODFLyQ\FyPRUHVSRQGHHOJUXSRVLQFUHDUFRQIOLFWR'HVWDFD WDPELpQODUHDFFLyQSRVLWLYDGH0DUtDFRQVXFRPSDxHUR\YLFHYHUVD (VGHVXEUD\DUTXHODVDGDSWDFLRQHVD0DUtDQRLPSOLFDQTXHVXFRPSDxHURULQGDPHQRV TXHHOUHVWRGHOJUXSR\TXHQRVHPRGLILTXHVXWDUHDDSUHQGLHQGRDUHODFLRQDUVHDVX 5 5 5 5 YH]FRQ0DUtD \'($%5,/'( 6(6,Ï11\ (VWDVVHVLRQHVQRVHUHJLVWUDQSRUTXHHOGtDQRDVLVWH0DUtDDOFHQWURHVFRODU\HO 5 QR VH LPSDUWLy FODVH GH (GXFDFLyQ )tVLFD SRUTXH DO FHOHEUDUVH HO GtD GH 6DQW -RUGL VH RUJDQL]DURQDORODUJRGHODMRUQDGDHVFRODUDFWLYLGDGHVGHFDUiFWHUFXOWXUDO 6(6,Ï11 '($%5,/'( $QWHVGHLQLFLDUVHODVHVLyQFXDQGRORVDOXPQRVHVWiQVHQWDGRVHQHOVXHORDODHVSHUD GHTXHODPDHVWUDSDVHODOLVWDREVHUYRDXQD0DUtDGLDORJDQWHTXHLQWHUDFW~DFRQVXV FRPSDxHURVPiVSUy[LPRV\TXHLQLFLDFRQYHUVDFLRQHV(QGHILQLWLYDVHOHSHUFLEHPX\ VRFLDO\GLQiPLFD /DMRUQDGDGHOGtDGHKR\JLUDDOUHGHGRUGHODH[SUHVLyQ/DPDHVWUDGDODFRQVLJQDTXH VHRUJDQLFHQHQJUXSRVGHVLHWHFRQHOILQGHH[SUHVDUFRODERUDWLYDPHQWHODVLPiJHQHV TXH UHFRJHQ WUHV LOXVWUDFLRQHV GRV UHIHUHQWHV D DQLPDOHV \ OD WHUFHUD DO WUDEDMR HQ HO FDPSR $OGDUODVHxDOSDUDTXHVHRUJDQLFHQHQJUXSRV0DUtDVHTXHGDVHQWDGDHQHOVXHORVLQ SUHVHQWDULQLFLDWLYDDOJXQDVLHQGRVXFRPSDxHUR\DPLJR&RQUDGTXLHQVHDSUR[LPDD HOOD$VtPLVPRVHREVHUYDTXHRWURFRPSDxHURTXHVHKDLQFRUSRUDGRUHFLHQWHPHQWHD ODFODVHVHTXHGDWDPELpQVHQWDGRHQHOVXHOR\VLQJUXSR$QWHWDOUHVSXHVWDODPDHVWUD LQWHUYLHQHFRPHQWDQGRTXHWDQWRpVWHFRPR0DUtD\&RQUDGWLHQHQTXHWRPDULQLFLDWLYDV SDUDDJUXSDUVHFRQHOUHVWRGHFRPSDxHURVSRUORTXHKDFHVHQWDUDWRGRVORVDOXPQRV HQHOVXHOR\YXHOYHDGDUODFRQVLJQDTXHVHUH~QDQHQJUXSRVGHVLHWH3HUFLELPRVTXH 0DUtDVHOHYDQWD\VHGHVSOD]DPX\OHQWDPHQWHKDFtDXQJUXSRGHFLQFRFRPSDxHURVVLQ GHWHFWDUUHFKD]RDOJXQRKDFLDHOOD (Q HO SHUtRGR HQ TXH GHFLGHQ ODV DFFLRQHV D OOHYDU D FDER SDUD OD UHSUHVHQWDFLyQ REVHUYDPRVTXHLQWHUYLHQHHQQXPHURVDV RFDVLRQHV UHVSHFWR D ODWRPDGHGHFLVLRQHV ,QWHUDFW~DFRQVXVFRPSDxHURVGLDORJDPX\DQLPDGDPHQWH\VRQUtHIUHFXHQWHPHQWH $ SHVDU GH HOOR FXDQGR OD PDHVWUD LQGLFD TXH VX JUXSR LQLFLH OD H[SRVLFLyQ 0DUtD LQWHUYLHQHFRPHQWDQGRTXHQRHVSRVLEOHSRUTXHQROHVKDGDGRWLHPSRKDSRQHUVHGH DFXHUGR $QWH OD LQVLVWHQFLD GH OD PDHVWUD UHDOL]DQ OD UHSUHVHQWDFLyQ HQ GRQGH 0DUtD SDUWLFLSDDFWLYDPHQWH\REVHUYiQGRVHELHQLQWHJUDGDHQHOFRQMXQWRGHOJUXSR 5 5 5 5 5 &RPHQWDULRVDODVHVLyQ 2EVHUYDPRVDXQD0DUtDPiVGLQiPLFDTXHSUHVHQWDLQLFLDWLYDVHQODVLQWHUDFWXDFLRQHV FRQVXVFRPSDxHURV\TXHVRQUtHPiVIUHFXHQWHPHQWH 6(6,Ï11 '($%5,/'( (VWD VHVLyQ FRQVLVWLy HQ XQ HQFXHQWUR FRQ DOXPQRV GH XQD HVFXHOD GH (GXFDFLyQ (VSHFLDO SUy[LPD DO FHQWUR TXH DFRJH DOXPQRV FRQ GLVFDSDFLGDG LQWHOHFWXDO 6H LQYLWDURQ DPERV JUXSRV D OD 8QLYHUVLGDG FRQ HO REMHWR GH SDUWLFLSDU HQ XQD JLQFDQD \ IDFLOLWDUHOFRQRFLPLHQWRHQWUHDPERVFROHFWLYRV6HRUJDQL]DURQJUXSRVPL[WRVGHDPERV FHQWURV \ IXHURQ URWDQGR SRU ODV GLVWLQWDV SUXHEDV O~GLFDV 2EVHUYDPRV TXH 0DUtD SDUWLFLSDHQODVDFWLYLGDGHVVLVHOHUHFODPDPRVWUDQGRSRFDLQLFLDWLYD 1RREVWDQWHQRVOODPDODDWHQFLyQHQODSUXHEDGHODVVLOODV (OMXHJRFRQVLVWHHQTXHHOJUXSRHVWiDXQDGLVWDQFLDGHXQRVWUHVPHWURVGHODVVLOODV FRQWDELOL]iQGRVH XQD PHQRV TXH MXJDGRUHV $O HVFXFKDU OD P~VLFD WLHQHQ TXH EDLODU \ FXDQGRVHSDUDWLHQHQTXHGHVSOD]DUVHDEXVFDUXQDVLOOD(ODOXPQRTXHVHTXHGDVLQ VLOODHVTXLHQSLHUGH /DUHDFFLyQGH0DUtDHQHVWHFDVRVtHVDFWLYD\WRPDODLQLFLDWLYDGHVLWXDUVHDXQPHWUR \PHGLRGHGLVWDQFLDFRQHOILQGHFRPSHQVDUVXOHQWLWXGORTXHDFHSWDHOUHVWRGHJUXSR FRQQDWXUDOLGDG (QODSUXHEDGHODVVLOODVGHUXHGDVXQFLUFXLWRGHKDELOLGDGHVVXSDUWLFLSDFLyQHVPX\ SRVLWLYD REVHUYDPRV JUDQ PRWLYDFLyQ DO PRVWUDU VX GRPLQLR GH OD VLOOD VLQWLpQGRVH FyPRGD DO MXJDU GH WDO IRUPD TXH LQWHQWD SURORQJDU DO Pi[LPR VX SHUPDQHQFLD HQ HO MXHJR (Q JHQHUDO SUHVHQWy HVFDVD LQWHUUHODFLyQ FRQ ORV DOXPQRV GH OD HVFXHOD GH HGXFDFLyQ HVSHFLDO\VHPRVWUyUHWLFHQWHDSDUWLFLSDUFXDQGRHUDUHTXHULGDSRUSDUWHGHODVDOXPQDV GHOD8QLYHUVLGDGRUJDQL]DGRUDVGHODJLQFDQD &RPHQWDULRVDODVHVLyQ 6X DFWLWXG HV SDVLYD HQ JHQHUDO H[FHSWXDQGR HQ GRV DFWLYLGDGHV (YLWy OD LQWHUUHODFLyQ FRQ ORV DOXPQRV GH OD HVFXHOD GH HGXFDFLyQ HVSHFLDO \ FRQ ODV GLQDPL]DGRUDV GH OD XQLYHUVLGDG (VLQWHUHVDQWHHOUHFODPRTXHKDFH0DUtDGHODQHFHVDULDDGDSWDFLyQHQHOMXHJRGHODV VLOODV(VXQLQGLFDGRUTXHWDQWRHOODFRPRVXVFRPSDxHURVGHFODVHWLHQHQLQWHULRUL]DGDV ODVDGDSWDFLRQHV 5 5 5 5 5 5 5 5 '(0$<2'( 6(6,Ï11 2EVHUYRTXHDOLQLFLRGHODVHVLyQFXDQGRORVDOXPQRVHVWiQVHQWDGRVHQHOVXHORGHVGH 5 KDFHGRVVHPDQDV0DUtDVHVLW~DHQODSULPHUDILODMXQWRDVXDPLJR&RQUDG/HSUHJXQWR DODPDHVWUDODUD]yQ\PHFRQWHVWD³SRUTXHGHHVDPDQHUDODWLHQHPiVFRQWURODGD´ 0LHQWUDVTXHODPDHVWUDSDVDOLVWD0DUtDLQWHUDFW~DFRQVWDQWHPHQWHFRQVXVFRPSDxHURV 5 PiVSUy[LPRVJHQHUDQGRLQWHUUHODFLRQHVYHUEDOHV\PRVWUiQGRVHPX\VRQULHQWH /DSULPHUDDFWLYLGDGTXHVHSURSRQHHVODGHYDORUDUHOHQFXHQWURGHOGtDDEULOFRQHO 5 FHQWUR GH (GXFDFLyQ (VSHFLDO 6RQ YDULDV ODV RFDVLRQHV HQ TXH 0DUtD LQWHUUXPSH OD H[SRVLFLyQGHVXVFRPSDxHURVHPLWLHQGRRSLQLRQHVORTXHPRWLYDDTXHODPDHVWUDOH FRUULMDUHFRGiQGROHTXHFDGDXQRWLHQHVXWXUQRGHLQWHUYHQFLyQ&XDQGROHWRFDDHOODVH H[SUHVD FRQ XQ WRQR PX\ LQIDQWLO VLHQGR VX FRPHQWDULR PX\ HVFXHWR /D PDHVWUD OH UHFXHUGDTXHVHH[SUHVHFRQHOWRQRGHYR]DFRUGHFRQVXHGDG'DGRTXHKDKDELGR PXFKRV SUREOHPDV GH DWHQFLyQ HQ HO JUXSR \ TXH ORV FRPHQWDULRV KDQ VLGR SRFRV OHV HQFDUJDSDUDHOSUy[LPRGtDTXHOHHQWUHJXHQSRUHVFULWRVXYLYHQFLDGHODMRUQDGD\HO FRQWHQLGRGHORTXHKDQGLFKRORVFRPSDxHURVTXHKDQSDUWLFLSDGR /DVHJXQGDDFWLYDGTXHSURSRQHHVHOMXHJRGH³YROYHUDFDVD´ 5 3RUSDUHMDVVHRUJDQL]DQGRVFtUFXORVXQRLQWHULRU\RWURH[WHULRU/DGLVWDQFLDHQWUHORV PLHPEURV GHO PLVPR JUXSR HV GH XQ PHWUR \ PHGLR DSUR[LPDGDPHQWH \ FRQ HO FRPSDxHURGHXQPHWUR(QHOFHQWURVHXELFDXQMXJDGRUTXHQRWLHQHSDUHMD$ODVHxDO ORV MXJDGRUHV GHO FtUFXOR H[WHULRU FRUUHQ HQ VHQWLGR FRQWUDULR D ODV DJXMDV GHO UHORM DOUHGHGRUGHVXVFRPSDxHURV&XDQGRODSURIHVRUDGLFH³DFDVD´WRGRVGHEHQUHJUHVDU GH QXHYR DQWH VX FRPSDxHUR TXH HVWi HQ HO FtUFXOR LQWHULRU VLQ UHWURFHGHU HQ QLQJ~Q FDVR VLWXiQGRVH GHODQWH GH pVWH (O ~OWLPR HQ OOHJDU SDVD DO FHQWUR OLEHUiQGRVH HO MXJDGRUTXHHVWDEDDOOt\FRQIRUPDQGRSDUHMDFRQHOFRPSDxHURTXHTXHGDVLQMXJDGRU 9DULDQWHV/RVMXJDGRUHVGHOFtUFXORH[WHULRUFXDQGRHVFXFKDQXQDSDOPDGDWLHQHQTXH GHVSOD]DUVHKDFLDODGHUHFKDDGRVSDOPDGDVKDFLDODL]TXLHUGD\DORtUHOVLOEDWRWLHQHQ TXHVLWXDUVHGHODQWHGHOFRPSDxHUR 7DQ VyOR WLHQH TXH PRGLILFDUVH OD GLVWDQFLD GH UHFRUULGR GH 0DUtD &RPR HQ HGLFLRQHV 5 DQWHULRUHVHOODORKDFHSRUHOLQWHULRUGHOFtUFXOR/RLQWHUHVDQWHHVTXHHOODUHFODPDHVWD DGDSWDFLyQ &XDQGRODPDHVWUDLQGLFDTXHVHRUJDQLFHQSRUSDUHMDV&RQUDGODHVFRJH$pVWDVHOH 5 SHUFLEH PX\ PRWLYDGD SRU OD GLQiPLFD GHO MXHJR DQLPDQGR ODV DFFLRQHV GH pVWH (Q YDULDVRFDVLRQHVREVHUYRTXH0DUtD]DUDQGHD\JROSHDFRQODPXOHWDDPLVWRVDPHQWHD &RQUDG\TXHpVWHDODYH]OHUHVSRQGHVLQFDXVDUQLQJXQDGDxRItVLFR&XDQGRpVWHSDVD DO FHQWUR REVHUYR TXH FRQ HO FRPSDxHUR TXH OH WRFD FRPSDUWLU HO MXHJR LQWHUDFW~D YHUEDOPHQWHSUHVHQWDQGRLQLFLDWLYDVHQODFRPXQLFDFLyQ 7DQVyORHQXQDRFDVLyQSDVDDOFHQWUR\QRHVGHELGRDVXOHQWLWXGVLQRDODSHQDOL]DFLyQ TXH LPSRQH OD PDHVWUD FXDQGR REVHUYD HQ XQD UHSHWLFLyQ TXH 0DUtD QR VLJXH ODV FRQVLJQDVGHFDPELRGHVHQWLGRFRQHOREMHWRGHHVWDUPiVSUy[LPDDVXFRPSDxHUR\GH HVWDPDQHUDQROOHJDUOD~OWLPD (OWHUFHUMXHJRHVHOGHO³SXHQWH´ /RVMXJDGRUHVVHVLW~DQHQHOH[WUHPRGHODVDOD\RWURFRPSDxHURODDUDxDVHORFDOL]DHQHOFHQWURGH ODVDOD'HODQWHGHpVWHWUHVMXJDGRUHVORVSXHQWHVXQRDOODGRGHORWURFRQODVSLHUQDVVHSDUDGDV$OD VHxDOORVSDUWLFLSDQWHVWLHQHQTXHFUX]DUHOHVSDFLRGHMXHJRVFRQHOREMHWLYRTXHQROHVDWUDSH³ODDUDxD´ DQWHVGHOOHJDUDORWURH[WUHPRGHODVDODUHIXJLR\FRQODFRQGLFLyQGHSDVDUHQWUHODVSLHUQDVGHORV MXJDGRUHVTXHDFW~DQGHSXHQWHVLQFOX\HQGROD³DUDxD´$PHGLGDTXHpVWDYDDWUDSDQGRORVVLW~DMXQWRD ORVFRPSDxHURVSXHQWHV*DQDHO~OWLPRMXJDGRUTXHOOHJDDOUHIXJLRVLQVHUFRJLGRSRUODDUDxD /DDGDSWDFLyQTXHSUHYpODPDHVWUDHVODGHGHOLPLWDUHOHVSDFLRGHUHFRUULGRGH0DUtDD FLQFR PHWURV DSUR[LPDGDPHQWH \ RWRUJDUOH WUHV YLGDV VL OD DWUDSDQ WLHQH WUHV RSRUWXQLGDGHV SDUD FRQWLQXDU FRPR MXJDGRUD GH FDPSR $O WHQHU TXH SDVDU HQWUH ODV SLHUQDV GH VXV FRPSDxHURV VH GHVSOD]D HQ FXDGUXSHGLD \ WDQ VyOR FRJH ODV PXOHWDV FXDQGRVHOHKDQDJRWDGRODVWUHVYLGDV\SDVDDVHUMXJDGRU³SXHQWH´ 6H REVHUYD D XQD 0DUtD PX\ FRPSHWLWLYD \ HQWUHJDGtVLPD DO MXHJR (Q OD SULPHUD UHSHWLFLyQVHTXHGDODSHQ~OWLPDHQVHUDWUDSDGD(QODVHJXQGDURQGDFXDQGROHDJRWDQ ODVHJXQGDYLGD0DUtDQLHJDTXHOHKD\DQDWUDSDGR$QWHHOORODPDHVWUDOHFRQILUPDTXH OHKDQWRFDGR\HOODUHVSRQGHFRQXQHQIDGRFUX]DQGRORVEUD]RVSRUGHODQWHFDEL]EDMD \ VHQWiQGRVH HQ HO VXHOR/DPDHVWUD UHDFFLRQD DSUR[LPiQGRVH D pVWD \ UHFODPiQGROH TXHFRQWLQ~HSDUWLFLSDQGRORTXHDFHSWDUiSLGDPHQWH(QHOPRPHQWRTXHOHDJRWDQOD WHUFHUDYLGD\SDVDDVHUMXJDGRUD³SXHQWH´ODPDHVWUDLQWHUYLHQHSDUDUHFRUGDUOHTXHVH WLHQH TXH SRQHU GH SLH FRQ OD D\XGD GH ODV PXOHWDV SRUTXH HO KHFKR GH DGRSWDU OD SRVLFLyQ GH DUURGLOODGD QR GHMD HO HVSDFLR VXILFLHQWH SDUD TXH SDVHQ VXV FRPSDxHURV HQWUHODVSLHUQDV &RPHQWDULRVDODVHVLyQ 'HQXHYRHQHOVHJXQGRMXHJRUHFODPDODDGDSWDFLyQSDUDFRPSHQVDUVXVOLPLWDFLRQHV\ VHREVHUYDXQDHVWUHFKDUHODFLyQFRQVXFRPSDxHUR&RQUDG 6(6,Ï11 '(0$<2'( 5 5 5 5 5 /DPDHVWUDHVFULEH $QWHV GH H[SOLFDU OD DFWLYLGDG TXH LEDQ D KDFHU KH UHFRJLGR HO WUDEDMR TXH OHV KDEtD PDQGDGRHOGtDDQWHULRU7RGRVORVKDQWUDtGRH[FHSWXDQGRDOXPQRVHQWUHHOORV0DUtD /HVKHSUHJXQWDGRSRUTXpQRORKDQKHFKRKDFLHQGRXQDOODPDGDDODUHVSRQVDELOLGDG $QWHVXVLOHQFLROHVFRPHQWRTXHQRFRPSDUWLUiQODVHVLyQGHVXVFRPSDxHURVKDVWDTXH KD\DQUHGDFWDGRHOWUDEDMR 5 0DUtDUHDFFLRQDGLFLHQGRTXHQRSLHQVDKDFHUORSRUTXHQRVHDFXHUGDGHORTXHGLMR\ PXFKRPHQRVGHORGHVXVFRPSDxHURV/HFRQWHVWRTXHKDJDPHPRULD\TXHGHMHGH EXVFDUH[FXVDV$OUHVWROHVH[SOLFRODDFWLYLGDGTXHKDUiQLQWURGXFFLyQDODVGDQ]DVGH ILQDOGHFXUVR'DGRTXHHOFRQWHQLGRVHUiQGDQ]DVWtSLFDVGHOD8QLyQ(XURSHD\TXH FDGDJUXSRFODVHOOHYDHOQRPEUHGHXQSDtVPLHPEURDVXJUXSROHKDWRFDGREDLODUXQD GDQ]D DOHPDQD +R\ SRU WDQWR KDUp XQD LQWURGXFFLyQ GH ORV SDVRV PiV EiVLFRV GH OD FRUHRJUDItD 0LHQWUDV TXH HQVD\DQ ORV SDVRV 0DUtD QR KDFH VX WUDEDMR \ VH TXHGD PLUDQGR D VXV FRPSDxHURV/HGLJRTXHVLQRVHSRQHDKDFHUORTXHOHWRFDVHDFDEDUiODFODVH\QROR WHQGUiKHFKR,QVLVWHHQTXHQRVDEHTXpSRQHU/HUHVSRQGRTXHKDJDPHPRULD\TXH WDQVyORHVIRU]iQGRVHXQSRFRVHJXURTXHORFRQVHJXLUi4XHVLHOUHVWRGHFRPSDxHURV \DHVWiQILQDOL]DQGRHVHWUDEDMRWDPELpQHOODSRGUtDHVWDUHQWUHHOORV3HURTXHVLVLJXH HQHVWDDFWLWXGQROHTXHGDUiPiVUHPHGLRTXHFDVWLJDUOD/HSUHJXQWRVLOHSDVDDOJRVL WLHQHDOJ~QSUREOHPDSHURGLFHTXHQR&RQWLQXDGLFLHQGRTXHQRVDEHTXpSRQHUTXH QRVHDFXHUGDDFRPSDxiQGRORGHOORURV\SXFKHURV &XDQGR VyORTXHGD0DUtDSRUILQDOL]DU HO WUDEDMR&RQUDGPHSLGHLQVLVWHQWHPHQWHVLOD SXHGHD\XGDU/HGLJRTXHVtSHURTXHVHUiHOODODTXHGHEHUiUHGDFWDUHOWUDEDMR4XH VyORODSXHGHD\XGDUDUHFRUGDUORTXHVHGLMR3RVWHULRUPHQWHVHDFHUFD&RQUDG\PH GLFHTXHHOOiSL]GH0DUtDQRWLHQHSXQWD3RUHOORPHDFHUFRDHOOD\PHFXHQWDTXHRWUR FRPSDxHUROHKDURWRODSXQWD(OQLxRPHGLFHTXHHVPHQWLUDTXHHV0DUtDODTXHKD WLUDGRHOOiSL]DOVXHOR 5LxR D 0DUtD GLFLpQGROH TXH QR PH JXVWDQ ODV PHQWLUDV \ PXFKR PHQRV TXH DFXVH D RWURVVLQUD]yQTXH\DKDEODUHPRVGHWRGRHVWR/HGLJRTXHHVLQMXVWD\HJRtVWD $OFDERGHXQUDWRYHRD0DUtD\D&RQUDGEDLODQGRFRQHOUHVWRGHFRPSDxHURV/HVGLJR VL 0DUtD KDDFDEDGRHOWUDEDMR\GLFH TXH QR 3RU WDQWR UHFULPLQR D DPERV VX DFWLWXG &RQUDGPHSLGHGLVFXOSDV\0DUtDQRGLFHQDGD/HGLJRTXHYD\DDDFDEDUHOWUDEDMR $O ILQDOL]DU FXDQGR YDQ D ODV GXFKDV &RQUDG PH HQWUHJD HO WUDEDMR GH 0DUtD \ OH SUHJXQWR SRU TXp QR OR KDFH 0DUtD /R PLUR +D HVFULWR PX\ SRFR /H SHJXQWR VL FUHH QRUPDOKDFHUVyORHVRHQXQDKRUD\PHGLD1RUHVSRQGH\SRQHFDUDGHHQIDGDGD/H FXHVWLRQRVXDFWLWXGGHRIHQGLGD\OHSUHJXQWRVLFUHHTXHKR\KDDSURYHFKDGRHQWLHPSR R DSUHQGLGR DOJR 'LFH TXH QR /H GLJR TXH KR\ WLHQH OD DVLJQDWXUD VXVSHQGLGD \ TXH FRPR OD VLJXLHQWH VHPDQD WHQJR YLJLODQFLD GH SDWLR KDEODUHPRV PX\ HQ VHULR GH WRGR HVWR 0LHQWUDV HO JUXSR VH GXFKD \ HVSHUD D OD DPEXODQFLD PH SLGH FRPR VL QR KXELHUD SDVDGRQDGDMXJDUD³/D3DVWRUD´FRQORVFRPSDxHURVTXHQRVHGXFKDQ/HGLJRTXHQR VHORPHUHFHTXHGHEHUtDHVWDUFDVWLJDGDSHURTXHSXHGHMXJDU1RREVWDQWHOHDGYLHUWR TXH FXDQGR KDEOHPRV OH GHMDUp FODUDV XQDV QRUPDV GH DFWXDFLyQ TXH WLHQH WDQWR GHUHFKRVFRPRGHEHUHV\TXHVLQRFXPSOHVXVGHEHUHVWHQGUiVDQFLRQHV /H YXHOYR D LQVLVWLU GH TXH GH HOOD \ GH VX HVIXHU]R GHSHQGH TXH VHD XQD SHUVRQD UHVSRQVDEOH4XHHVSHURPXFKRGHHOODSHURTXHWHQGUiTXHGHPRVWUDUOR\QRSDUDTXH 5 5 5 5 5 5 5 \RHVWpFRQWHQWDVLQRSDUDTXHVHGHFXHQWDGHTXHVLVHORSURSRQHSXHGHVXSHUDUXQ UHWR \ FRQVHJXLUOR /R TXH QR GHEH KDFHU HV EXVFDU H[FXVDV SDUD TXH ORV GHPiV OH VROXFLRQHQVXVSUREOHPDVFRPRKR\KDSDVDGRFRQ&RQUDG &RPHQWDULRVDODVHVLyQ 6H FRQILUPDODDFWLWXGFRQIOLFWLYDGH0DUtDLQFDSD]GHHQIUHQWDUVHDORVSUREOHPDV6X OHQWLWXG SDUD KDFHU HO WUDEDMR HV XQ LQGLFDGRU TXH FRQILUPD HO FRPHQWDULR GH VX WXWRUD UHVSHFWRDVXVSUREOHPDVGHDSUHQGL]DMHHQHODXOD\VXVSUREOHPDVGHDWHQFLyQ (QHVWHVHQWLGRHOSHGLUMXJDUD³/D3DVWRUD´GHVSXpVGHKDEHUUHFLELGRXQDODUJDULxDGH OD PDHVWUD LQGLFD TXH WLHQGH D LJQRUDU ODV GLILFXOWDGHV \ D QR HQIUHQWDUVH D ODV VLWXDFLRQHVTXHQROHJXVWDQ/DPDHVWUDLQWHQWDFODULILFDUGHUHFKRV\REOLJDFLRQHVSHUR ODUHFHSWLYLGDGGH0DUtDHVPX\OLPLWDGD 6(6,Ï11 '(0$<2'( /DVHVLyQGHOGtDGHKR\VHFHQWUDHQODUHDOL]DFLyQGHWUHVWDUHDVSDUDSRVWHULRUPHQWH GHOLEHUDUORVJUXSRVVREUHODGLQiPLFDGHRUJDQL]DFLyQH[SOLFDFLyQFRRUGLQDFLyQ\WRPD GHGHFLVLRQHV 3DUDHOORSURSRQHTXHVHRUJDQLFHQHQJUXSRVGHVLHWH\WLHQHFDGDXQRGHHOORVTXH LQWHUSUHWDU OD WDUHD DVLJQDGD PHGLDQWH XQ GLEXMR $ OD VHxDO GHEHQ HIHFWXDUOD FRQMXQWDPHQWH FRQ HO UHVWR GH JUXSRV 3RVWHULRUPHQWH WLHQHQ TXH RUJDQL]DUVH SDUD UHDOL]DU ODVHJXQGDWDUHDHQEDVHDODH[SOLFDFLyQIDFLOLWDGDSRUHOJUXSRTXHDFDEDGH HMHFXWDUODDODYH]GHVFULELUODWDUHD\DHIHFWXDGDDOJUXSRTXHOHFRUUHVSRQGHOOHYDUODD FDER\DVtVXFHVLYDPHQWHKDVWDOOHJDUDODWHUFHUDWDUHD /DVWDUHDVVRQODVTXHVLJXHQ $HQILODXQRGHWUiVGHRWUR\DXQDGLVWDQFLDGHXQEUD]R7LHQHQTXHGHVSOD]DUVHHQ FDUUHUDOLEUHPHQWHSRUHOHVSDFLRPDQWHQLHQGRHORUGHQGHILOD\GLVWDQFLDV %ËGHPGLVSRVLFLyQTXHHQODDFWLYLGDGDQWHULRU7HQGUiQTXHFRUUHUSRUHOH[WUHPRGHO JLPQDVLRGDQGRYXHOWDVFLUFXODUHV(O ~OWLPR MXJDGRU FRQ YHORFLGDG PRGHUDGD SDVDDO SULQFLSLRGHODILODVDOLHQGRHOSUy[LPRFXDQGRHODQWHULRUKDOOHJDGRDOLQLFLRGHODILOD & ËGHP GLVSRVLFLyQ TXH HQ ODV DFWLYLGDGHV DQWHULRUHV SHUR FRQ OD VDOYHGDG TXH FRQ OD PDQR GHUHFKD VH DSR\DQ VXDYHPHQWH VREUH HO KRPEUR GHUHFKR GHO FRPSDxHUR TXH WLHQHQ GHODQWH \ FRQ OD PDQR L]TXLHUGD VRVWLHQHQ HO SLH L]TXLHUGR GH OD SLHUQD VHPLIOH[LRQDGD SDWD FRMD GHO FRPSDxHUR TXH WLHQHQ GHODQWH $ OD VHxDO WLHQHQ TXH GHVSOD]DUVHGDQGRVDOWRVVREUHHOSLHOLEUHËGHPFDPELDQGRGHSLHUQDGHVDOWR &XDQGRODPDHVWUDLQGLFDTXHVHRUJDQLFHQHQJUXSRVGHVLHWH0DUtDFRPRHVKDELWXDO VH TXHGD VHQWDGD HQ HO VXHOR GHVSOD]iQGRVH OLJHUDPHQWH KDFLD VX DPLJR &RQUDG $O 5 5 5 5 REVHUYDUODPDHVWUDTXHDPERVHVWiQVLQJUXSRLQGLFDTXHWRGRVORVDOXPQRVUHJUHVHQ GHQXHYRDODGLVSRVLFLyQLQLFLDOGHODVHVLyQFRQHOILQGHRUJDQL]DUGHQXHYRORVJUXSRV SRUORTXHVHHVFXFKDQFRPHQWDULRVGHGHVDFXHUGR\FXOSDELOL]DQGRD0DUtD\D&RQUDG ³HV SRU FXOSD GH HOORV´ GH OD QXHYD UHRUJDQL]DFLyQ /D PDHVWUD SURSRQH TXH FRPR PtQLPRGRVFRPSRQHQWHVVHDQQLxDV\WUHVQLxRVREVHUYDQGRHQHVWDRFDVLyQTXH0DUtD VH HVIXHU]D SRU UHXQLUVH FRQ ORV FRPSDxHURV PiV SUy[LPRV D HOOD QR SHUFLELHQGR UHFKD]RDOJXQR /DSULPHUDWDUHDTXHWLHQHQTXHHIHFWXDUHOJUXSRGH0DUtDHVOD³&´$QRWDPRVTXHQR LQWHUDFFLRQD FRQ VXV FRPSDxHURV UHVSHFWR D OD WRPD GH GHFLVLRQHV PDQWHQLpQGRVH DO PDUJHQ&XDQGRVHGLVSRQHQDUHDOL]DUODDFWLYLGDGHOODGHFLGHVLWXDUVHSDUDOHODPHQWHDO JUXSRDFRPSDxiQGRORVHQVXGHVSOD]DPLHQWR\VDOWDQGRVREUHXQDSLHUQD 3RVWHULRUPHQWH WLHQHQ TXH H[SOLFDU OD DFWLYLGDG DO JUXSR TXH OH FRUUHVSRQGH HIHFWXDUOD 3HUFLELPRV TXH 0DUtD HVWi DO PDUJHQ GH DPERV JUXSRV QR LQWHUYLQLHQGR HQ OD H[SOLFDFLyQ'DGDODOHQWLWXGGHOSURFHVRDOJUXSRGH0DUtDQROHGDWLHPSRGHUHFLELUOD H[SOLFDFLyQGHODWDUHDTXHOHVWRFDUHDOL]DU$QWHHOORODPDHVWUDLQGLFDTXHVHVLHQWHQ WRGRVORVJUXSRV\TXHUHIOH[LRQHQUHVSHFWRDORDFRQWHFLGR\VHFHQWUHQHQHODQiOLVLVGH ODRUJDQL]DFLyQ\ODFRRUGLQDFLyQ(QHVWDRFDVLyQ0DUtDLQWHUYLHQHHQYDULDVRFDVLRQHVD ODYH]TXHORVLPXOWDQHDFRQORV]DUDQGHRVDPLVWRVRVFRQ&RQUDGVLHQGRFRUUHVSRQGLGD SRUpOORTXHDFHSWDJUDWDPHQWH\DTXHSHUFLELPRVTXHVRQUtHDELHUWDPHQWH 3RVWHULRUPHQWHUHDOL]DQODWDUHD³$´TXHQRSUHVHQWDQLQJXQDGLILFXOWDGSDUD0DUtD )LQDOL]DODVHVLyQFRQODVLJXLHQWHSURSXHVWDGHYXHOWDDODFDOPD /RVJUXSRVVHQWDGRVHQFtUFXORFRJLGRVGHODVPDQRVGHORVFRPSDxHURVPiVSUy[LPRV \FRQODVSLHUQDVVHSDUDGDVWRFiQGRVHFRQORVSLHVGHOFRPSDxHURPiVSUy[LPR6HJ~Q ODVFRQVLJQDVGHODPDHVWUDWLHQHQTXHIOH[LRQDUHOWURQFRVXFHVLYDPHQWHFDGDMXJDGRU KDFLDGHODQWHKDFLDDWUiVGHODGR -XVWDPHQWH HV HQ HVWD DFWLYLGDG GRQGH REVHUYDPRV D XQD 0DUtD PiV SDUWLFLSDWLYD FRPXQLFDWLYD \ ULVXHxD SUHVHQWDQGR LQLFLDWLYDV HQ OD FRPXQLFDFLyQ YHUEDO FRQ VXV FRPSDxHURV &RPHQWDULRVDODVHVLyQ 7RGDYtD OH IDOWD D 0DUtD PiV LQLFLDWLYD HQ OD RUJDQL]DFLyQ GH JUXSRV GH WUDEDMR FRQILUPiQGRVHXQDHVWUHFKDUHODFLyQFRQ&RQUDG 1R REVWDQWHGHSHQGLHQGRGHODDFWLYLGDG VH PXHVWUD PiVSDUWLFLSDWLYDHLQLFLDGRUDGH ODVLQWHUDFFLRQHVFRQORVFRPSDxHURVPiVSUy[LPRV '(0$<2'( 6(6,Ï11 5 5 5 5 5 5 5 (VWD VHVLyQ QR VH UHJLVWUD SRUTXH HO JUXSR FODVH HVWi GH FRORQLDV HQ &DOD &DQ\HOOHV 5 *LURQD UHDOL]DQGR DFWLYLGDGHV HQ OD QDWXUDOH]D /D YDORUDFLyQ TXH KDFH OD PDHVWUD UHVSHFWR D OD SDUWLFLSDFLyQ \ DFWLWXG GH 0DUtD HV PX\ SRVLWLYD (Q JHQHUDO VH LQWHUUHODFLRQDFRQVWDQWHPHQWHFRQVXVFRPSDxHURVGHFODVH\SDUWLFLSDDFWLYDPHQWHHQ WRGDV ODV DFWLYLGDGHV PRWULFHV SURSXHVWDV URFyGURPR QDWDFLyQ WHQLV FRQ OD VLOOD GH UXHGDVH[FHSWXDQGRHOHVTXtDFXiWLFRDQWHODVGLILFXOWDGHVGHHTXLOLEULRVHSDVHDHQOD ODQFKDFRQORVHGXFDGRUHV 6(6,Ï11 '(0$<2'( /D VHVLyQ JLUD DOUHGHGRU GH OD SUiFWLFD GH OD GDQ]D DOHPDQD TXH UHSUHVHQWDUiQ HQ HO IHVWLYDOGHFLHUUHGHOSUHVHQWHFXUVRTXHWHQGUiOXJDUHO~OWLPRGtDGHFODVHGHMXQLR /D PDHVWUD LQLFLD OD VHVLyQ FRQ OD HVFXFKD GH OD P~VLFD PLHQWUDV YD SDVDQGR OLVWD 2EVHUYRTXH0DUtDDSURYHFKDSDUDLQWHUDFFLRQDUYHUEDOPHQWHFRQVXVFRPSDxHURVPiV SUy[LPRVDHOODPRVWUiQGRVHPX\DQLPDGD\ULVXHxD $ PHGLGD TXH VH HQVD\D OD GDQ]D D 0DUtD VH OH SHUFLEH PX\ SDUWLFLSDWLYD JHQHUDQGR FRQYHUVDFLRQHVFRQORVFRPSDxHURVPiVSUy[LPRVHLQWHUDFFLRQDQGRFRQODPLUDGDFRQ DTXHOORVTXHHVWiQPiVGLVWDQFLDGRVDHOOD (Q YDULDV RFDVLRQHV LQWHUYLHQH YHUEDOPHQWH HQ DOWR FXDQGR OD PDHVWUD IRUPXOD DOJXQD SUHJXQWDDOJUXSRUHVSHFWRDODVHYROXFLRQHVGHODGDQ]D 8QDGHODVILJXUDVFRQVLVWHHQURGHDUDO0DUtD\DVXFRPSDxHURFRORFDQGRODVPDQRVOR PiV SUy[LPDV D ORV FXHUSRV GH DPERV /D UHDFFLyQ GH 0DUtD HV OD GH VHQWDUVH HQ HO VXHORSDUDQGRODGDQ]DFRPHQWDQGR³TXHHVWiPX\FDQVDGDGHWDQWDVPDQRV´(VWD PLVPDUHVSXHVWDODWLHQHFXDQGRVXFRPSDxHURGHGDQ]DODFRJHHQXQDGHODVILJXUDV SRUGHWUiVGHODHVSDOGD &RPHQWDULRVDODVHVLyQ &RQVWDWRTXHHVHQHVWDVHVLyQKDVWD OD IHFKD GRQGH PiV KD LQWHUDFFLRQDGR FRQVXV FRPSDxHURV JHQHUDQGR KDELWXDOPHQWH ODV FRQYHUVDFLRQHV $Vt PLVPR VH OH KD REVHUYDGRPX\PRWLYDGDSRUODGDQ]D\DODYH]PX\ULVXHxD 7DPELpQFDEHUHJLVWUDUTXHHVODVHVLyQTXHPiVVHKDLQWHUUHODFLRQDGRFRQODPDHVWUD KDFLHQGRFRPHQWDULRVUHVSHFWRDODGLQiPLFDGHODGDQ]D 1RREVWDQWHWHQJRTXHDQRWDUVXUHDFFLyQFXDQGRVHKDVHQWLGRSURWDJRQLVWDHQHOJUXSR HVGHFLUFXDQGRODURGHDEDQWRGRHOJUXSRRFXDQGRVXFRPSDxHURODKDFRJLGRSRUORV KRPEURV 6(6,Ï11 '(0$<2'( 5 5 5 5 5 5 5 /DVHVLyQVHUHDOL]DHQHODXODYLVLRQDQGRHOYtGHRGHODVFRORQLDVGHODVHPDQDDQWHULRU 5 '(0$<2'( &RQWLQ~DFRQODSUiFWLFDGHODGDQ]DGHILQDOGHFXUVR 6H UHDOL]DQ YDULDV UHSHWLFLRQHV REVHUYDQGR TXH 0DUtD VH LQWHUUHODFLRQD DO SULQFLSLR GH FDGDVHULHFRQHOPLVPRFRPSDxHURVLHQGRHOODODTXHLQLFLDODFRQYHUVDFLyQ 3RVWHULRUPHQWHFRQHOILQGHGHVDUUROODUODFDSDFLGDGGHREVHUYDFLyQ\SRGHUHPLWLUXQ MXLFLR MXVWR OD PDHVWUD RUJDQL]D OD FODVH HQ JUXSRV GH FXDWUR &DGD JUXSR WLHQH TXH UHSUHVHQWDUDOUHVWRGHPLHPEURVGHFODVHODGDQ]DDSUHQGLGD0LHQWUDVWDQWRORVJUXSRV UHVWDQWHVWLHQHQTXHHYDOXDUODHMHFXFLyQGHORVTXHGHPXHVWUDQ 'HQXHYR0DUtDFXDQGRHVWiREVHUYDQGRHVODTXHJHQHUDLQWHUUHODFLRQHVYHUEDOHVFRQ RWUR FRPSDxHUR 7DQ VyOR LQWHUYLHQH HQ YR] DOWD HQ XQD RFDVLyQ SDUD FRPXQLFDU D OD PDHVWUD TXH XQ FRPSDxHUR GHO JUXSR FRQ HO TXH HVWDED KDEODQGR DO LQLFLR GH ODV UHSHWLFLRQHV GH OD GDQ]D HVWi FRPSRUWiQGRVH GH IRUPD LQFRUUHFWD GDGR TXH DO QR VLWXDUVHFRQHOJUXSRQRSXHGHQDFRUGDUODQRWDFRQVHQVXDGDGHORVRWURVSDUWLFLSDQWHV 7DOKHFKRSURYRFDODUHFULPLQDFLyQGHODPDHVWUDKDFLDHVHFRPSDxHUR (QJHQHUDOVHOHREVHUYDPX\ULVXHxD\PRWLYDGDSRUODGDQ]D &RPHQWDULRVDODVHVLyQ 6LQRLQWHUDFFLRQDPiVFRQVXVFRPSDxHURVHVGHELGRDODVFDUDFWHUtVWLFDVGHODVHVLyQ DLPDJHQGHOUHVWRGHOJUXSR3RUWDQWRVHFRQVWDWDTXHODVFDUDFWHUtVWLFDVLQWUtQVHFDVGH ODVWDUHDVSXHGHQGHWHUPLQDUODIUHFXHQFLDGHODVLQWHUDFFLRQHV\DVHDQYHUEDOHVFRPR JHVWXDOHV 5 5 6(6,Ï11 6(6,Ï11 5 5 5 5 '(0$<2'( /DPDHVWUDHVFULEH +R\KHPRVSUDFWLFDGRGHQXHYRODGDQ]D(VWDYH]HQHOSDWLRSDUDHQVD\DUODHQHOOXJDU GRQGH KDEUi OD ILHVWD /RV DOXPQRV KDQ SDUWLFLSDGR FRQ LQWHUpV LQFOX\HQGR D 0DUtD 5HVSHFWR D pVWD GHVWDFR VX SDUWLFLSDFLyQ DFWLYD KDEODQGR DQLPRVDPHQWH FRQ ORV FRPSDxHURVPiVFHUFDQRV '(-81,2'( 6(6,Ï11 5 (Q HO LQLFLR GH OD VHVLyQ SHUFLELPRV D 0DUtD TXH JHQHUD LQWHUDFFLRQHV FRQ GRV FRPSDxHURV TXH HVWiQ D XQD GLVWDQFLD GH XQRV WUHV PHWURV TXH VRQ MXVWDPHQWH ORV ~QLFRVTXHHVWiQVHQWDGRVHQHOVXHORSRUTXHHOUHVWRHVWiQHQHOYHVWXDULR&XDQGROD PDHVWUD GHFLGH SDVDU OLVWD REVHUYDPRV TXH 0DUtD QR HVWi VHQWDGD HQ OD SULPHUD ILOD MXQWR D &RQUDG VLQR WRGR OR FRQWUDULR ORFDOL]iQGROD DO ILQDO GH OD VDOD /D PDHVWUD OH LQGLFDTXHVHVLW~HHQHOOXJDUDVLJQDGR\pVWDDFFHGHSHURGHVSOD]iQGRVHGHURGLOODV $QWHHOORODPDHVWUDOHOODPDODDWHQFLyQGRVYHFHVKDVWDTXHFRQVLJXHTXHUHJUHVHDO OXJDU GH SDUWLGD \ VH SRQJD GH SLH SDUD GHVSOD]DUVH HQ PDUFKD 0DUtD UHDFFLRQD FRQ PXHVWUD GH HQIDGR FDEL]EDMD \ IUXQFLHQGR ORV ODELRV KDVWD OOHJDU D OD SULPHUD ILOD VHQWiQGRVHFRQWRWDOQRUPDOLGDG (QHVWDVHVLyQODPDHVWUDGHFLGHFDPELDUODFRUHRJUDItDGHWDOIRUPDTXHQRVHFHQWUD WDQWR HQ 0DUtD FRPSHQVDQGR OD PRYLOLGDG UHGXFLGD \ FRQVLJXLHQGR SDUDOHODPHQWH HTXLSDUDUHOULWPRGH0DUtDFRQHOGHOUHVWRGHORVPLHPEURVGHOJUXSRFODVH $ OR ODUJR GH OD VHVLyQ REVHUYDPRV TXH 0DUtD VRQUtH UHJXODUPHQWH LQLFLDQGR LQWHUDFFLRQHVFRQORVFRPSDxHURVPiVSUy[LPRV&XDQGRVHFRQIXQGHDOJ~QSDUWLFLSDQWH GHOJUXSRHQODUHDOL]DFLyQGHODVHYROXFLRQHVpVWDORVUHFWLILFD 6H OH SHUFLEH PX\ GLDORJDQWH \ QRV OODPD OD DWHQFLyQ TXH HQ YDULDV RFDVLRQHV JROSHD VXDYHPHQWHDVXVFRPSDxHURVPiVSUy[LPRVFRQODPXOHWDRELHQOHVWRFDFRQHOSLH/D UHDFFLyQGHpVWRVQRHVHOGHUHVSRQGHUFRQXQDDJUHVLyQ\DVHDYHUEDORJHVWXDOVLQR TXHOHFRQWHVWDQFRQXQDVRQULVDRELHQLQLFLDQXQDFRQYHUVDFLyQ &RPHQWDULRVDODVHVLyQ 2EVHUYDPRVDXQD0DUtDPX\VRQULHQWHGLDORJDQWH\VRFLDEOHJHQHUDQGRLQWHUDFFLRQHV HQWUHORVFRPSDxHURVPiVSUy[LPRV\UHFLELHQGRUHFLSURFLGDG 6(6,Ï11 '(-81,2'( $SDUWLUGHHVWDIHFKD\DSXHGRGHQXHYRREVHUYDUODVVHVLRQHVGHORVPLpUFROHVGDGR TXHKDILQDOL]DGRODGRFHQFLDHQOD8QLYHUVLGDG 6H GD OD FLUFXQVWDQFLD TXH SRU PRWLYRV ODERUDOHV OOHJR FRQ PHGLD KRUD GH UHWUDVR &XDQGR HQWUR HQ HO SDWLR HO JUXSR HVWD GHVFDQVDQGR \ ORFDOL]R D OD PDHVWUD TXH HVWi KDEODQGRFRQ0DUtDLQVLVWLHQGRTXHSDUWLFLSHeVWDTXHHVWiVHQWDGDHQODEDUDQGLOODOD REVHUYRFDEL]EDMDGLFLHQGRFRQVWDQWHPHQWH³QR´FRQODFDEH]D&XDQGROHSUHJXQWRDOD PDHVWUDTXpOHSDVDPHFRPHQWDTXHHOODQRKDYLVWRORTXHKDRFXUULGRSRUTXHHVWDED SHQGLHQWHGHRWURVHFWRUGHODFODVHSHURSRUORTXHOHKDEtDQLQIRUPDGRUHVXOWDTXHXQ FRPSDxHUR KD ODQ]DGR D 0DUtD XQD SLHGUHFLWD TXH OD KD KHFKR FDHU $ SHVDU GH ODV GLVFXOSDVTXHKDUHFLELGRSRUSDUWHGHpVWH0DUtDVHPXHVWUDPX\HQIDGD\KDGHFLGLGR QRWDQVyORGHMDUGHSDUWLFLSDUVLQRTXHDGHPiVKDH[SUHVDGRVXQHJDWLYDDSDUWLFLSDUHQ HOIHVWLYDOILQDOGHFXUVRDQWHODVIDPLOLDV 5 5 5 5 5 5 /D PDHVWUD LQVLVWH TXH HQWUH D OD VHVLyQ MXQWR D VXV FRPSDxHURV (OOD FRQWLQ~D QHJiQGRVH FDEL]EDMD \ VLQ GHFLU QDGD $QWH WDO DFWLWXG OD PDHVWUD GHFLGH SRU YH] SULPHUD FDVWLJDUOD FRPHQWiQGROH TXH WLHQH TXH LU D FODVH D SRU SDSHO \ XQ EROtJUDIR 0DUtD GH QXHYR VH QLHJD D GHVSOD]DUVH \ REVHUYR FRPR OD PDHVWUD VH PXHVWUD PiV HQIDGDGDUHLWHUDQGRGHQXHYRTXHYD\DDODFODVH0DUtDUHDFFLRQDFRQOORURV$QWHWDO FRPSRUWDPLHQWRODPDHVWUDOHUHFXHUGDTXHQRHVXQDQLxDSHTXHxD\TXHUHDFFLRQHGH PDQHUD PDGXUD GH DFXHUGR FRQ VX HGDG $O ILQDO FRQVLJXH TXH WDQWR 0DUtD FRPR HO FRPSDxHURTXHOHKDSURYRFDGRODFDtGDVHGHVSODFHQKDFLDODFODVH $OILQDOL]DUODVHVLyQODPDHVWUDVHUH~QHFRQDPERV\FRQGRVFRPSDxHURVPiVTXHKD FDVWLJDGRSRUPDOFRPSRUWDPLHQWR/HVFRPHQWDTXHUHIOH[LRQHQVREUHORTXHKDQKHFKR PDOHQODVHVLyQ\GHFyPRGHEtDQGHKDEHUVHFRPSRUWDGRWHQLHQGRTXHHVFULELUORHQ SDSHO\HQWUHJDUORDOGtDVLJXLHQWHDODVQXHYHGHODPDxDQD &RPHQWDULRVDODVHVLyQ (V OD SULPHUD YH] TXH 0DUtD HV FDVWLJDGD D LPDJHQ GHO UHVWR GHO JUXSR FXDQGR VH FRPSRUWD LQFRUUHFWDPHQWH &RQVLGHUR TXH HV XQD IRUPD GH UHFRUGDUOH TXH HV FRPR WRGRV TXH WLHQH XQRV GHUHFKRV SHUR WDPELpQ XQDV REOLJDFLRQHV \ TXH QR VH OH SXHGH SHUPLWLU TXH DEDQGRQH OD VHVLyQ SRU VX WHUTXHGDG D SHVDU GH OD LQWHUYHQFLyQ GH OD PDHVWUD 6(6,Ï11 '(-81,2'( 5 5 5 $O LQLFLDU OD VHVLyQ OD PDHVWUD UHFXHUGD TXH QLQJXQR GH ORV FXDWURV TXH HVWDEDQ 5 FDVWLJDGRV HQ OD VHVLyQ DQWHULRU OH KD HQWUHJDGR OD UHGDFFLyQ SHQGLHQWH &XDQGR OH SUHJXQWDD0DUtDUHVSRQGHTXHVHODKDROYLGDGRHQFDVD 2EVHUYRTXHWDQWRODHQWUDGDFRPRHQODVDOLGDGHOSDWLRORKDFHHQVROLWDULR/DGLVWDQFLD 5 FRQHOJUXSRDXPHQWDSURJUHVLYDPHQWHOOHJDQGRDGLVWDQFLDUVHKDVWDXQRVPHWURV /DSUiFWLFDGHKR\VLJXHVLHQGRHOHQVD\RGHODGDQ]D0DUtDFRQWLQ~DSDUWLFLSDQGRPX\ 5 DFWLYDPHQWH VRQULHQWH \ PX\ PRWLYDGD SRU OD HYROXFLyQ GH OD GDQ]D 'DGDV ODV FDUDFWHUtVWLFDVGHODDFWLYLGDGODVLQWHUDFFLRQHVHQWUHORVFRPSDxHURVVRQPiVUHGXFLGDV TXH HQ ODV VHVLRQHV HQ TXH SURSRQH MXHJRV PRWRUHV 3RU WDQWR VH MXVWLILFD TXH ODV UHODFLRQHVHQWUHORVGLVWLQWRVPLHPEURVGHOJUXSRVHDQPHQRUHVTXHHQRWUDVRFDVLRQHV 1R REVWDQWH VXHOH FRPXQLFDUVH SULQFLSDOPHQWH PHGLDQWH OD PLUDGD FRQ OD FRPSDxHUD TXHFRPSDUWHJUDQSDUWHGHODGDQ]D $QRWRTXHHQODVHYROXFLRQHVODPDHVWUDWLHQHTXHUHFRUGDUDORVFRPSDxHURVGHILODGH 5 0DUtD TXHQRVHDFHOHUHQ\TXHDMXVWHQHOGHVSOD]DPLHQWRDOGH0DUtDSDUDQRGHMDUOD DWUiV &RPHQWDULRVDODVHVLyQ 5 6H FRQVWDWD WDO \ FRPR KH GHVFULWR HQ RWUDV RFDVLRQHV TXH ODV FDUDFWHUtVWLFDV GH ODV WDUHDVSXHGHQGHWHUPLQDUHOJUDGRGHFRPXQLFDFLyQHQWUHORVPLHPEURVGHOJUXSR (V LQWHUHVDQWH FRPR OD PDHVWUD DGDSWD OD GDQ]D SDUD TXH WRGRV SXHGDQ SDUWLFLSDU HGXFDQGRHOUHVSHWRDORVULWPRVGHWRGRVLQGLVWLQWDPHQWHGHODVFDUDFWHUtVWLFDV '(-81,2'( (O GHVSOD]DPLHQWR GH LGD \ VDOLGD DO SDWLR OR KDFH D LPDJHQ GH OD VHVLyQ DQWHULRU HQ VROLWDULRDXPHQWDQGRSURJUHVLYDPHQWHODGLVWDQFLD &RPR HQ OD VHVLyQ DQWHULRU OD LQWHUDFFLyQ FRQ OD FRPSDxHUD PiV SUy[LPD HV PX\ SRVLWLYD PRVWUiQGRVH LQWHUHVDGD SRU HO HQVD\R GH OD GDQ]D &DEH GHVWDFDU TXH ORV FRPSDxHURVGHILODLQWHQWDQVHJXLUKRPRJpQHDPHQWHHOULWPRPiVDGHFXDGRSDUD0DUtD VLQSHUFLELUTXHODGHMHQDWUiVHQQLQJXQDGHODVUHSHWLFLRQHV 2EVHUYR FXDQGR HVWi HVSHUDQGR SDUD EHEHU DJXD GH OD IXHQWH TXH XQ FRPSDxHUR HO ~OWLPRTXHVHKDLQFRUSRUDGRDFODVHOHDEUHHOJULIRSDUDTXHSXHGDEHEHUVLQTXHHOODOR KD\DVROLFLWDGReVWHHVSHUDTXHWHUPLQHSDUDGHVSOD]DUVHMXQWRDHOODKDVWDHOFHQWURGHO SDWLRGRQGHHVWiODPDHVWUD\HOUHVWRGHOJUXSR &XDQGRILQDOL]DODVHVLyQ\VHGLULJHQDOJLPQDVLRSDUDGXFKDUVHODPDHVWUDREVHUYDTXH XQSRUFLHQWRGHODOXPQDGRQROOHYDODURSDSDUDGXFKDUVHSRUORTXHOHVSURSRQHTXH GHFLGDQXQMXHJRSDUDSUDFWLFDU$FXHUGDQXQiQLPHPHQWHMXJDUDODSDVWRUD (OJUXSRGLVSHUVRSRUHOHVSDFLR\XQMXJDGRUFRQXQEDOyQGHHVSXPDeVWHSXHGHRSWDU HQ FXDQWR OR SRVHH SRU JULWDU ³SLHV TXLHWRV´ \ SRU WDQWR VXV FRPSDxHURV WLHQHQ TXH TXHGDUVH HVWiWLFRV HQ HO SXQWR GHO HVSDFLR GRQGH VH HQFXHQWUDQ \ D FRQWLQXDFLyQ LQWHQWDU WRFDU D XQ FRPSDxHUR ODQ]DQGR HO EDOyQ LPSDFWDQGR FXDOTXLHU SDUWH FRUSRUDO H[FHSWXDQGRODFDUD\FD\HQGRHOEDOyQDOVXHOR2ELHQWLHQHODSRVLELOLGDGGHGDUWUHV SDVRVFRQHOEDOyQHQODPDQRFRQHOREMHWLYRGHDSUR[LPDUVHDVXVFRPSDxHURV\GHFLU ³SLHVTXLHWRV´(QHOPRPHQWRTXHXQMXJDGRUHVWRFDGRSDVDDOD]RQDGHHOLPLQDGRV\ WDQVyORSXHGHVDOYDUVHFXDQGRLPSDFWDQDOMXJDGRUTXHORKDHOLPLQDGR /DVDGDSWDFLRQHVSDUD0DUtDVRQODVKDELWXDOHV 6HOHFRQFHGHQWUHVYLGDVWLHQHWUHVRSRUWXQLGDGHVKDVWDTXHSXHGDVHUHOLPLQDGD\ HQHOPRPHQWRHQTXHDJRWHDOJXQDGHHOODV\PDWHDXQDGYHUVDULRVHOHVXPDXQD YLGD &XDQGRFRQVLJXHHOEDOyQVHJULWD³SLHVTXLHWRV´\WLHQHDGHPiVODSRVLELOLGDGGHGDU ORVWUHVSDVRVFRQHOEDOyQHVWDQGRVXVFRPSDxHURVHVWiWLFRV(OODSXHGHODQ]DUHO EDOyQFRQHOSLHRODPXOHWDVLWRFDXQDGYHUVDULRpVWHSDVDDOD]RQDGHPXHUWRV 6L OD PDWDQ \ OH TXHGD XQD R GRV YLGDV QR SXHGH HO PLVPR DGYHUVDULR LQWHQWDU PDWDUODGDGDODSUR[LPLGDG /D PDHVWUD QR UHFXHUGD HVWDV DGDSWDFLRQHV WDQ VyOR LQGLFD TXH FXDQGR SDVH HO EDOyQ 5 6(6,Ï11 5 5 5 5 5 5 SUy[LPRD0DUtDVHFRQVLGHUDUiTXHSHUWHQHFHDpVWDORTXHSURYRFDHOGHVDFXHUGRGH XQ FRPSDxHUR H[FODPDQGR ³£DOD´ $QWH WDO UHDFFLyQ OD PDHVWUD OR FDVWLJD QR SDUWLFLSDQGR 7DODGDSWDFLyQFRQGXFHDTXHORVFRPSDxHURVVHGLVWDQFLHQGH0DUtDSDUDTXHQRSXHGD EHQHILFLDUVH GH OD SUR[LPLGDG GHO EDOyQ 6X UHFRUULGR HV SRU HO H[WHULRU GHO FDPSR LQWHQWDQGRFXEULUVHSRUODVFROXPQDVLQWHUDFFLRQDQGRWDQVyORFRQORVFRPSDxHURVTXH LQWHQWDQLPSDFWDUODFRQHOEDOyQ 5HVSHFWR D OD WHUFHUD DGDSWDFLyQREVHUYDPRV TXH HQ UHLWHUDGDV YHFHV VX FRPSDxHUR &RQUDGLQWHQWDLPSDFWDUODSHURFRPRQRSXHGHUHSHWLUHOLQWHQWRVRQYDULDVODVRFDVLRQHV TXHODGHVHVWLPDUHGXFLpQGRVHODGLQiPLFDHQWUHDPERV 1RREVWDQWHVHOHREVHUYDPX\VRQULHQWH\SDUWLFLSDWLYDVLJXLHQGRODHYROXFLyQGHOMXHJR &RPHQWDULRVDODVHVLyQ +HPRV DFRUGDGR TXH HV H[FHVLYR FRQVLGHUDU TXH HO EDOyQ HV GH 0DUtD FXDQGR SDVD SUy[LPD D HOOD H[FHSWXDQGR FXDQGR OR WRFD FRQ OD PXOHWD 6L XQ MXJDGRU XQD YH] TXH RWURLPSDFWDFRQHOEDOyQD0DUtD\FRPRUHVXOWDGRSLHUGHXQDYLGDSXHGHQYROYHUORD LQWHQWDU XQD YH] TXH KD\D ODQ]DGR HO EDOyQ KDFLD RWUR FRPSDxHUR 'H HVWD PDQHUD OD GLQiPLFDGHOMXHJRHVPD\RU /D PDHVWUD PH FRPHQWD OD FRQYHUVDFLyQ TXH KD PDQWHQLGR FRQ HO DOXPQR TXH KD FDVWLJDGR FXDQGR pVWD KD LQFOXLGR XQD QXHYD DGDSWDFLyQ SDUD 0DUtD /H KD GLFKR TXH KLFLHVHXQHMHUFLFLRGHHPSDWtD\TXHVHSXVLHUDHQOXJDUGHHOOD$OILQDOVHKDGLULJLGRD 0DUtDSDUDSHGLUOHGLVFXOSDV 6(6,Ï11 '(-81,2'( 2EVHUYDPRV D 0DUtD VHQWDGD HQ HO VXHOR LQWHUDFFLRQDQGR YHUEDOPHQWH FRQ &RQUDG HO FRPSDxHURPiVSUy[LPRDHOOD6HOHSHUFLEHPX\ULVXHxD 8QD YH] TXH OD PDHVWUD SDVD OLVWD SUHJXQWD DO JUXSRFODVH TXH DFXHUGHQ WUHV MXHJRV SDUDSUDFWLFDUHQODVHVLyQGHKR\$FXHUGDQ³ODSDVWRUD´³HOSXHQWH´HO³SLOODSLOODFRQ QRPEUHV´ 3HURDQWHVGHLQLFLDUVHHOSULPHUMXHJRSURSRQJRDODPDHVWUDKDFHUXQDIRWRGHJUXSR 7RGRVVHFRORFDQHQXQD]RQDGHOJLPQDVLRH[FHSWXDQGRD0DUtDTXHVHTXHGDDXQRV RFKRPHWURVVHQWDGDHQHOVXHOR/DPDHVWUDWLHQHTXHGHVSOD]DUVHKDFLDGRQGHHVWDHOOD HLQVLVWLUOHTXHQRSXHGRKDFHUODIRWRVLIDOWDHOODSRUTXHWRGRVIRUPDQSDUWHGHOJUXSR 7UDVYDULDVLQVLVWHQFLDVDFFHGHDKDFHUVHODIRWRSHURODREVHUYRFDEL]EDMDHQIDGDGD\ HQFRUYDGDGHKRPEURVGHWDOIRUPDTXHFXDQGRODKDJRVHWDSDODFDUD (QHOSULPHUMXHJR³ODSDVWRUD´GHVFULWRHQODVHVLyQDQWHULRUDFRUGDPRVDGHPiVGHODV DGDSWDFLRQHVKDELWXDOHVTXHVt0DUtDHVTXLYDHOEDOyQFXDQGRLQWHQWDQLPSDFWDUODFRPR 5 5 5 5 5 5 5 QRSXHGHFRJHUORSRUTXHODVPDQRVODVWLHQHRFXSDGDVSRUODVPXOHWDVHOEDOyQSDVDD HOODJULWDQGR³SLHVTXLHWRV´\PLHQWUDVTXHVXVFRPSDxHURVSXHGHQGDUWUHVSDVRVFRQHO EDOyQHQODPDQRHOODHQFDPELRSXHGHDXPHQWDUDFLQFR /D PDHVWUDLQVLVWHHQTXHQDGLHVHSXHGHSURWHJHUFRQODVFROXPQDV$SHVDUGHHVWD REVHUYDFLyQ0DUtDFRQWLQ~DGHVSOD]iQGRVHSRUHOSHUtPHWURGHODVDODWDOYH]SDUDHYLWDU ORVSRVLEOHVFKRTXHVFRQORVFRPSDxHURV $ SHVDU GH OD SUR[LPLGDG FRQ ORV FRPSDxHURV TXH WLHQHQ HO EDOyQ HQ QXPHURVDV RFDVLRQHVGHVHVWLPDQLPSDFWDUODGHWDOPDQHUDTXHWDQVyORSLHUGHXQDYLGDDORODUJR GHO MXHJR &RPR HQ HGLFLRQHV DQWHULRUHV SDUWLFLSD PX\ DQLPDGDPHQWH VLJXLHQGR OD GLQiPLFDGHOMXHJRFRQH[SUHVLyQULVXHxD (OVLJXLHQWHMXHJR³HOSXHQWH´ /RVMXJDGRUHVVHVLW~DQHQHOH[WUHPRGHODVDOD\RWURFRPSDxHURODDUDxDVHORFDOL]DHQHOFHQWURGH ODVDOD'HODQWHGHpVWHWUHVMXJDGRUHVORVSXHQWHVXQRDOODGRGHORWURFRQODVSLHUQDVVHSDUDGDV$OD VHxDOORVSDUWLFLSDQWHVWLHQHQTXHFUX]DUHOHVSDFLRGHMXHJRFRQHOREMHWLYRTXHQROHVDWUDSH³ODDUDxD´ DQWHVGHOOHJDUDORWURH[WUHPRGHODVDODUHIXJLR\FRQODFRQGLFLyQGHSDVDUHQWUHODVSLHUQDVGHORV MXJDGRUHVTXHDFW~DQGHSXHQWHVLQFOX\HQGROD³DUDxD´$PHGLGDTXHpVWDYDDWUDSDQGRORVVLW~DMXQWRD ORVFRPSDxHURVSXHQWHV*DQDHO~OWLPRMXJDGRUTXHOOHJDDOUHIXJLRVLQVHUFRJLGRSRUODDUDxD /DVDGDSWDFLRQHVSDUD0DUtDVRQ 'HOLPLWDUHOHVSDFLRGHUHFRUULGRDFLQFRPHWURVDSUR[LPDGDPHQWH 2WRUJDUOH WUHV YLGDV VL OD DWUDSDQ WLHQH WUHV RSRUWXQLGDGHV SDUD FRQWLQXDU FRPR MXJDGRUDGHFDPSR $OWHQHUTXHSDVDUHQWUHODVSLHUQDVGHVXVFRPSDxHURVVHGHVSOD]DHQFXDGUXSHGLD \ WDQ VyOR FRJH ODV PXOHWDV FXDQGR VH OH KDQ DJRWDGR ODV WUHV YLGDV \ SDVD D VHU MXJDGRU³SXHQWH´ /D PDHVWUD GHFLGH HO MXJDGRU TXH LQLFLD HO MXHJR SHUR 0DUtD VH DFHUFD D HOOD SDUD UHFRUGDUOHTXHHVHOODODTXHOHWRFDLQLFLDUOR/DPDHVWUDUHFWLILFD\UHFXHUGDDOJUXSRTXH HV 0DUtD OD TXH ³SDUD´ &RPR VXV FRPSDxHURV VH GHVSOD]DQ HQ FDUUHUD H[FHSWXDQGR FXDQGRSDVDQHQWUHODVSLHUQDVGHORVTXHDFW~DQFRPRSXHQWHV0DUtDWLHQHGLILFXOWDG SDUD DWUDSDUORV $Vt TXH GHFLGLPRV UHFWLILFDU H LQLFLDU GH QXHYR HO MXHJR GLFLHQGR TXH WRGRVWLHQHQTXHGHVSOD]DUVHHQFXDGUXSHGLD'HHVWDPDQHUDHTXLSDUDPRVODYHORFLGDG GH 0DUtD FRQ OD GHO UHVWR GHO JUXSR 7RGRV DFHSWDQ FRQ QRUPDOLGDG HVWD PRGLILFDFLyQ H[FHSWXDQGR D &RQUDG TXH FRPHQWD ³$K FODUR 0DUtD LUi PiV UiSLGD SRUTXH HOOD HVWi PiVKDELWXDGD´$SHVDUGHOFDQVDQFLRTXHSURYRFDHVWHWLSRGHGHVSOD]DPLHQWRWRGRV SDUWLFLSDQFRQLQWHUpV 5 5 5 5 (OWHUFHUMXHJRHVHO³SLOODSLOODFRQQRPEUHV´ 7RGRVORVDOXPQRVGLVWULEXLGRVSRUXQHVSDFLRGHOLPLWDGR/DPDHVWUDGLUiHOQRPEUHGH XQRGHHOORVORTXHVXSRQGUiTXHHVHOMXJDGRUTXHSDUDeVWHLQWHQWDUiWRFDUDOPi[LPR GHMXJDGRUHVFRQHOREMHWLYRGHHOLPLQDUORVKDVWDTXHODPDHVWUDQRPEUDDRWURMXJDGRU *DQDHOMXHJRHOTXHTXHGHHO~OWLPRHQOD]RQDGHMXHJR /D DGDSWDFLyQ TXH SURSRQH OD PDHVWUD SDUD 0DUtD HV OD GH RWRUJDUOH WUHV YLGDV FRQ OD FRQGLFLyQGHTXHVLODWRFDQSRUWDQWRSLHUGHXQDYLGDHOMXJDGRUTXHOHKDWRFDGRGDGD ODSUR[LPLGDGHYLGHQWHQRSXHGHYROYHUODDWRFDU(QHOPRPHQWRHQTXHHVQRPEUDGDVH JULWD³VWRS´\WRGRHOJUXSRWLHQHTXHTXHGDULQPyYLO0DUtDSXHGHGDUHOQ~PHURGHSDVRV LOLPLWDGRVKDVWDDFHUFDUVHDODSHUVRQDTXHGHFLGDWDQVyORSXHGHLQWHUUXPSLUVXDFFLyQ VLODPDHVWUDHQHVHUHFRUULGRQRPEUDDRWURMXJDGRU 0DUtD SDUWLFLSD DFWLYDPHQWH \ PX\ HQWUHJDGD DO MXHJR 2EVHUYDPRV TXH OD LQWHUDFFLyQ FRQORVFRPSDxHURVHVPX\UHGXFLGDSRUTXHODGLQiPLFDGHOMXHJRQRODIDFLOLWD $O ILQDOL]DU OD VHVLyQ LQWHQWR SDVDUOH OD HQWUHYLVWD ILQDO /D VRUSUHVD HV TXH VH QLHJD D UHVSRQGHU \ TXH OR ~QLFR TXH GHVHD HV PDUFKDUVH GHO GHVSDFKR GH OD PDHVWUD /H FRPHQWR VL HVWi HQIDGD FRQPLJR \ UHVSRQGH TXH Vt OH SUHJXQWR SRU ODV FDXVDV \ QR UHVSRQGH'HFLGHDEULUODSXHUWD\DEDQGRQDUHOGHVSDFKR &RPHQWDULRVDODVHVLyQ (QJHQHUDOSDUWLFLSDDFWLYDPHQWHHQODVHVLyQPRVWUDQGRLQLFLDWLYD 6RUSUHQGHVXDFWLWXGFXDQGRKDJRODIRWRGHJUXSR\FXDQGRLQWHQWRSDVDUODHQWUHYLVWD ILQDOFXDQGRFRQHOODQRKHWHQLGRQLQJ~QHQIUHQWDPLHQWR 6(6,Ï11 '(-81,2'( 1RVHLPSDUWHODVHVLyQSRUTXHUHFODPDQDODPDHVWUDSDUDTXHFRODERUHHQHOHQVD\RGH FDQFLRQHVHQLQJOpVGHOIHVWLYDOGHILQDOGHFXUVR 'HODMRUQDGDGHKR\UHVDOWRHOLQWHQWRGHQXHYRGHHQWUHYLVWDUD0DUtD$QWHVXQHJDWLYD LQWHUFHGH OD PDHVWUD \ D SHVDU GH VX FRODERUDFLyQ 0DUtD FRQWLQ~D QHJiQGRVH 7UDV OD LQVLVWHQFLDGHODPDHVWUDDFXHUGDQTXHDOGtDVLJXLHQWHUHVSRQGHUiFRQODD\XGDGHpVWD SRUHVFULWRDODVSUHJXQWDVGHODHQWUHYLVWD &XDQGR VDOH GHO GHVSDFKR LQWHQWR GHVSHGLUPH GH HOOD SHUR QR HV SRVLEOH SRUTXH PH LJQRUD 3RVWHULRUPHQWHWHQHPRVODHQWUHYLVWDFRQODPDGUHFRQHOILQKDFHUXQDGHYROXFLyQGHOD H[SHULHQFLD \ FDGD YH] TXH KDEODPRV GH 0DUtD URPSH D OORUDU 8QD GH ODV IUDVHV TXH 5 5 5 5 5 5 5 5 5 FRQVLGHURPX\VLJQLILFDWLYDUHVSHFWRDOFRPSRUWDPLHQWRGH0DUtDHVFXDQGRGLFHTXH³QR ODSXHGHFRQWURODUTXHFDGDYH]VHOHHVFDSDPiVGHODVPDQRV´ &RPHQWDULRVDODVHVLyQ 0HFXHVWDHQWHQGHUHVHHQIUHQWDPLHQWRTXHKDHVWDEOHFLGR0DUtDFRQPLJRFXDQGRQRKD KDELGRQLQJ~QFRQIOLFWRFRQHOOD7DOYH]PLSUHVHQFLDDORODUJRGHOFXUVRQRKDSDVDGR LQDGYHUWLGD VDELHQGR TXH HVWDED DOOt SRU HOOD OR FXDO OH KD WHQLGR TXH SURYRFDU XQ UHFKD]RKDFLDPt $O GtD VLJXLHQWH FRQWHVWy D OD HQWUHYLVWD SRU HVFULWR JUDFLDV D OD D\XGD GH OD PDHVWUD VLHQGRVXUHVSXHVWDPX\HVFXHWD 5 5 DQH[R 'LDULRGHFDPSRGHO&HQWUR 6(6,Ï11 '(6(37,(0%5('( 6H LQLFLD OD SULPHUD VHVLyQ HQ HO DXOD FRQ HO REMHWR GH UHFRUGDU FXiOHV WLHQHQ TXH VHU ODV DFWLWXGHV YDORUHV \ QRUPDV GH OD DVLJQDWXUD 0H SUHVHQWD DO JUXSR FODVH FRPR DOXPQD GH SUiFWLFDV FRPHQWiQGROHV TXH HVWDUp REVHUYDQGR GXUDQWH XQ PHV \ TXH SRVWHULRUPHQWH FRODERUDUpFRQHOODHQODDVLJQDWXUD2EVHUYRTXHORVDOXPQRVQRVHVRUSUHQGHQ\TXHPH DFRJHQFRQODPD\RUQDWXUDOLGDG (OJUXSRHVWiFRPSXHVWRSRUXQWRWDOGHDOXPQRV\DOXPQDVGHORVFXDOHVVRQQLxRV\ QLxDV (QWUH HOORV VH HQFXHQWUD XQD FRPSDxHUD TXH SUHVHQWD DFRQGURSODVLD \ SRU WDQWR HVWDWXUD EDMD ¶ P OD OODPDUp /ROD \ XQ FRPSDxHUR FRQ 2VWHRJpQHVLV ,PSHUIHFWD KXHVRVGHFULVWDO\GHHVWDWXUDWDPELpQEDMDFPOROODPDUp-RUGL6HGHVSOD]DHQXQD VLOODGHUXHGDVDGDSWDGDDVXHVWDWXUD $OUHFRUUHUFRQODPLUDGDHODXODPHOODPDODDWHQFLyQTXHODVPHVDVVRQGHGRVRFXSDGDV SULQFLSDOPHQWHSRUHOPLVPRVH[RH[FHSWXDQGRD-RUGLTXHHVWiVRORGHELGRDTXHVXPHVD HVPiVEDMDTXHODGHOUHVWRGHOJUXSR /DPDHVWUDGH(GXFDFLyQ)tVLFD()UHSDUWHXQDKRMDFRQHOOLVWDGRGHQRUPDVDFWLWXGHV\ YDORUHVTXHGHEHQWHQHUVHHQFXHQWDHQODDVLJQDWXUDDORODUJRGHOFXUVR9DQRPEUDQGRD XQDOXPQRGHFDGDPHVDSDUDTXHOHDXQDIUDVH\VHFRPHQWHSRVWHULRUPHQWHVXVLJQLILFDGR /R SULPHUR TXH PH OODPD OD DWHQFLyQ HV OD DFWLWXG GH -RUGL SRUTXH LQWHQWD LQWHUYHQLU FRQVWDQWHPHQWHUD]yQSDUDTXHODPDHVWUDUHFXHUGHTXHVHKDGHVROLFLWDUODSDODEUD0HKD KHFKR SHQVDU HQ OR TXH PH FRPHQWy HQ OD SULPHUD UHXQLyQ TXH WXYH FRQ HOOD HO YLHUQHV SDVDGR´DHVWHDOXPQRVHOHKDQGHSRQHUOtPLWHVSRUTXHGHQRVHUDVtLQWHQWDSURWDJRQL]DU FRQWLQXDGDPHQWHODVHVLyQ´ 7UHVVRQODVIUDVHVHQTXHLQWHUYLHQH-RUGL\TXHSRUVXVFRPHQWDULRVWHKDFHSHQVDUHQVX UHFRQRFLPLHQWRGHODVOLPLWDFLRQHV\GHVXVUHSHUFXVLRQHVHQODGLQiPLFDGHODVHVLyQ 5 5 5 5 /DDFRQGURSODVLDHVXQWUDVWRUQRJHQpWLFRGHOFUHFLPLHQWRyVHRTXHWLHQHOXJDUGHVGHHOQDFLPLHQWR(O WRUVRGHORVQLxRV\QLxDVHVUHODWLYDPHQWHQRUPDOVLHQGRODVSLHUQDV\ORVEUD]RVPiVELHQFRUWRV6H FDUDFWHUL]DQ HQ JHQHUDO SRU XQD FDEH]D JUDQGH IUHQWH SURPLQHQWH \ OD QDUL] DFKDWDGD HQ VX SDUWH VXSHULRUHQWUHORVRMRV/RVGLHQWHVSXHGHQHVWDUDPRQWRQDGRV\DYHFHVQRHVWiQDOLQHDGRV6XHOHQ SUHVHQWDUORUGRVLVSDQWRUULOODVDUTXHDGDV\ORVSLHVFRUWRVSODQRV\DQFKRV/DVPDQRVVRQSHTXHxDV\ ORV GHGRV UHFKRQFKRV H[LVWLHQGR XQD VHSDUDFLyQ HQWUH ORV GHGRV PHGLR \ DQXODU PDQR WULGHQWH KWWSZZZQDFHUVDQRRUJSiJLQDGHOD0DUFKRI'LPHV%LUWK'HIHFWV)RXQGDWLRQ 3RU 2VWHRJpQHVLV ,PSHUIHFWD VH FRQVLGHUD OD IRUPDFLyQ LPSHUIHFWD GH ORV KXHVRV SURYRFDGD SRU OD PXWDFLyQGHXQJHQUHVSRQVDEOHGHSURGXFLUXQDSURWHtQDHVHQFLDOFROiJHQRWLSR,TXHHVODTXHIDFLOLWD ODULJLGH]DORVKXHVRV6HPDQLILHVWDSULQFLSDOPHQWHSRUXQDIUDJLOLGDGyVHDGHWDOIRUPDTXHORVKXHVRV VHIUDFWXUDQDQWHFXDOTXLHULPSDFWRRLQFOXVRVLQFDXVDHYLGHQWH$GHPiVVHFDUDFWHUL]DSRUXQDFDUD HQ IRUPD WULDQJXODU GHIRUPLGDGHV yVHDV H[WUHPLGDGHV VXSHULRUHV LQIHULRUHV SHFKR \ FUiQHR ODV HVFOHUyWLFDV D]XOHV VRUGHUD SURJUHVLYD GHQWLQRJpQHVLV LPSHUIHFWD WRQR GH YR] DJXGR HVWDWXUD EDMD P~VFXORV GpELOHV WHQGHQFLD D PDJXOODUVH OD SLHO HVFROLRVLV HVWUHxLPLHQWR VXGRUDFLyQ H[FHVLYD FRHILFLHQWH LQWHOHFWXDO PHGLRDOWR \ HO WRQR YLWDO FRQ WHQGHQFLD DO RSWLPLVPR \ OD HXIRULD KWWSZZZPLQRULDVRUJFDVWHOODSiJLQDGHOD)('(5$+8&()HGHUDFLyQ(VSDxRODGH(QIHUPHGDGHV 5DUDV$VRFLDFLyQ1DFLRQDOGH+XHVRVGH&ULVWDO ³6DEHUDFHSWDUODVUHJODVGHOMXHJRWHD\XGDUiDWHQHUXQDDFWLWXGPiVWROHUDQWH-XHJD OLPSLR´ ,QWHUYLHQHSXQWXDOL]DQGRODH[SOLFDFLyQTXHGDEDODDOXPQDTXHODOHtDSRQLHQGRHOHMHPSOR TXHFXDQGRVHWHQtDQTXHRUJDQL]DUSDUHMDVWRGRVWHQtDQTXHVHUPiVWROHUDQWHVDFHSWDQGRD FXDOTXLHUFRPSDxHUR&XHVWLyQDSURYHFKDGDSRUODPDHVWUDSDUDUHFRUGDUTXHWRGRVVRPRV GLIHUHQWHV\TXHSRUWDQWRWHQHPRVTXHUHVSHWDU\DFHSWDUODGLYHUVLGDG ³$FHSWDODVSURSLDVOLPLWDFLRQHV´ 3RQHFRPRHMHPSORHOKHFKRGHQRSRGHUUHDOL]DUHOVDOWRGHDOWXUDFRPRHOUHVWRGHOJUXSR FODVH ³9DORUDWXSURSLRSURJUHVR&RPSDUDORVQXHYRVUHVXOWDGRVTXHYDVREWHQLHQGRFRQORV DQWHULRUHV´ -RUGLFRPHQWDTXHORLPSRUWDQWHHVVHJXLUHVIRU]iQGRVH )LQDOL]DGD OD OHFWXUD OD PDHVWUD SURSRQH VDOLU DO SDWLR SDUD MXJDU OLEUHPHQWH H[FHOHQWH RSRUWXQLGDG SDUD REVHUYDU D -RUGL SHUR DQWH OD OOXYLD HQYtD D XQD DOXPQR SDUD YHU VL HO JLPQDVLR HVWi GHVRFXSDGR 0LHQWUDV VXEH HO DOXPQR RLJR HO FRPHQWDULR GH -RUGL ¢D Pt TXLpQ PH EDMD DO JLPQDVLR" 0H KDFH SHQVDU HQ OD GHSHQGHQFLD FRQ HO DGXOWR 3RVWHULRUPHQWHKDEODQGRFRQODPDHVWUDPHKDGLFKRTXHQRHVGHH[WUDxDUHVHFRPHQWDULR SRUTXH-RUGLVLHPSUHWLHQHTXHLUDFRPSDxDGRHQHODVFHQVRUSRUXQDGXOWRTXHWLHQHOODYH GHOPLVPR\TXHHOODQRGLVSRQHGHXQDFRSLD2EVHUYRDFRQWLQXDFLyQODUHODFLyQGH-RUGL FRQVXVFRPSDxHURV\DQRWRTXHpVWHQRVHGHVSOD]DGHVXPHVD\VtHQFDPELRORKDFHQ VXVFRPSDxHURVSDUDKDEODUFRQpO $VtPLVPRPHOODPDODDWHQFLyQ/ROD(VOD~QLFDHQHVHHVSDFLRGHHVSHUDTXHVHDFHUFD DPtSDUDSUHJXQWDUPHVLHVWDUpHQWRGDVODVVHVLRQHVGHOFXUVR &RPRHOJLPQDVLRHVWiRFXSDGRODPDHVWUDDSURYHFKDODPHGLDKRUDUHVWDQWHGHODVHVLyQ SDUD LQFLGLU HQ HO FRQRFLPLHQWR GHO SURSLR FXHUSR \ HQ OD SUHPLVD TXH WRGRV WHQHPRV OLPLWDFLRQHV\FDSDFLGDGHVUHILULpQGRVHYDULDVYHFHVD-RUGLFXHVWLyQWUDWDGDFRQODPi[LPD QRUPDOLGDG&XDQGRODSURIHVRUDLQGLFDTXHWRGRVVHWLHQHQTXHSRQHUGHSXQWLOODVRIOH[LRQDU ODURGLOODFRQHOILQGHORFDOL]DUORVP~VFXORVTXHLQWHUYLHQHQROYLGDGHDVHJXUDUVHTXH-RUGL ORKDJDHQODVLOODSRUORTXHpVWHVHOLPLWDDREVHUYDUDORVGHPiV 3UHJXQWDDORVDOXPQRVVLWLHQHQDOHUJLDV\-RUGLGLFHTXHVtFRPHQWDQGRTXHVHODSURGXFHQ ORVJORERVFXDQGRORVKLQFKDSURYRFiQGROHLQIODPDFLyQHQORVRMRV $O ILQDOL]DU OD VHVLyQ DSURYHFKR SDUD FRPHQWDU D OD PDHVWUD TXH PH SUHRFXSDED OD JUDQ GHSHQGHQFLDGH-RUGLFRQODDX[LOLDUGH(GXFDFLyQ(VSHFLDOHQHOSDWLR(OODPHFRQWHVWDTXH VXIXQFLyQHVDVHJXUDUODLQWHJULGDGGH-RUGL\TXHSRUWDQWRHOQRSXHGHPH]FODUVHHQORV MXHJRVFRQVXVFRPSDxHURVSRUTXHSXHGHQJROSHDUOR\OHVLRQDUOR$xDGLUTXHHVWDDX[LOLDUHV DGHPiVVXFDQJXUR\SRUWDQWRKD\XQDUHODFLyQPX\HVWUHFKDHQWUHDPERV 5HVSHFWRD/RODDQRWDUTXHVHKDFRPSRUWDGRFRQDEVROXWDQRUPDOLGDG\TXHODVUHODFLRQHV 5 5 5 5 5 5 FRQHOJUXSRVRQPX\ULFDV\SRVLWLYDV '(6(37,(0%5('( 6(6,Ï11 $OSDVDUSRUHOSDWLRREVHUYRFyPRHVWiMXJDQGR-RUGLFRQXQJUXSRGHVLHWHQLxDV-XHJDQD ³WRFDU\SDUDU´ (O JUXSR HVWi GLVSHUVR HQ XQ HVSDFLR GHOLPLWDGR \ XQD QLxD LQLFLD HO MXHJR ³SDUDQGR´ LQWHQWDQGRDOFDQ]DUDVXVDGYHUVDULRVWRFiQGROHVFRQODPDQRHQDOJXQDSDUWHGHOFXHUSR (QHOPRPHQWRTXHFRQVLJXHWRFDUDXQMXJDGRUVHFDPELDQORVUROHV 2EVHUYRTXHFXDQGR³SDUD´-RUGLDSHVDUGHHVWDUSUy[LPRDHOODVSUHVHQWDGLILFXOWDGHVSDUD WRFDUODV1RREVWDQWHREVHUYRTXHVRQUtH\TXHVHORHVWiSDVDQGRELHQ&RQHVWDSULPHUD LQIRUPDFLyQ DQRWR TXH QR FRPSHQVDQ ODV GLILFXOWDGHV HQ HO MXHJR DFRUGDQGR ODV DGDSWDFLRQHVSDUDTXHSXHGDMXJDUHQFRQGLFLRQHVPiVMXVWDV 3RVWHULRUPHQWHVHLQLFLDODVHVLyQHQHOSDWLRSROLGHSRUWLYR/DSURIHVRUDLQGLFDTXHGHQVHLV YXHOWDVDOSDWLR0LHQWUDVTXHHOUHVWRGHOJUXSRORKDFHSRUODSHULIHULD-RUGL\/RODORUHDOL]DQ SRU HO SHUtPHWUR GHO FDPSR GH EiVTXHW /D PDHVWUD OHV LQGLFD TXH FXHQWHQ ODV YXHOWDV FRQWURODQGRHOULWPR2EVHUYRTXH/RODVHDYDQ]DD-RUGLSHURTXHDPLWDGGHUHFRUULGR\DVH SDUD\HPSLH]DDFDPLQDUFRPELQDQGRODPDUFKDFRQODFDUUHUD(QFDPELR-RUGLDSHVDU TXHVXULWPRLQLFLDOHVPX\YHOR]HVPiVUHJXODU\UHDOL]DXQWRWDOGHWUHVYXHOWDV$DPERV VHOHVREVHUYDPRWLYDGRV/DPDHVWUDVXJLHUHD-RUGLTXHGHVFDQVHSRUTXHVXVSXOVDFLRQHV HVWiQPX\DOWDV $FRQWLQXDFLyQODPDHVWUDSURSRQHXQDVVHULHVGHHMHUFLFLRVGHWpFQLFDGHFDUUHUD5HJLVWUR TXHPLHQWUDVHOUHVWRGHOJUXSRHVWiVLWXDGRHQHOFHQWURGHOSDWLRGHIRUPDRUGHQDGDHQILODV \ UHDOL]DQGR ODV DFWLYLGDGHV /ROD \ -RUGL HVWiQ HQ HO H[WUHPR D XQRV GLH] PHWURV GH VXV FRPSDxHURV LQLFLDQGR GLYHUVRV MXHJRV FRQ GRV UXHGDV GH FRFKH 7DQWR -RUGL FRPR /ROD LQWHQWDQ GHVSOD]DU OD UXHGD FRQ HO REMHWR GH TXH QR FDLJD $ GLVWDQFLD VH REVHUYD XQ JUDQ FRQWUROHVSHFLDOPHQWHHQHOFDVRGH-RUGLGDGRTXHWLHQHTXHGRPLQDUODVLOODGHUXHGDV\HO LPSOHPHQWRSRUORTXHUHJLVWURTXHWLHQHXQJUDQGRPLQLRGHODVLOODGHUXHGDV )LQDOL]DGDHVWDDFWLYLGDGDPERVMXHJDQDSDVDUVHODUXHGD\SRVWHULRUPHQWHGHFLGHQMXJDUD FDUUHUDV GH YHORFLGDG FUX]DQGR WRGR HO SDWLR $ SHVDU GH TXH /ROD OOHJD PXFKR DQWHV TXH -RUGL VH REVHUYDTXHpVWHVHORSDVD PX\ ELHQ 7UDVYDULDVFDUUHUDVODPDHVWUDLQWHUYLHQH LQGLFiQGROHVTXHGHVFDQVHQ\SDUDHOOROHVSURSRQHTXHVHVLW~HQHQOD]RQDGHORVEDQFRV TXH HVWi ORFDOL]DGD HQ HO HVSDFLR FRQWLQXR GH OD SLVWD SROLGHSRUWLYD (OORV REHGHFHQ \ WUDQVFXUULGRVXQRVFLQFRPLQXWRVFRJHQXQDSHORWDGHSOiVWLFR\HPSLH]DQDUHDOL]DUSDVHV 3RVWHULRUPHQWHFRJHQXQDUR\ORDSR\DQVREUHODEDUDQGLOODVLPXODQGRXQDFHVWDGHEiVTXHW 8QR OR VRVWLHQH FRQ OD PDQR \ HO RWUR LQWHQWD KDFHU FHVWD ,QWHUUXPSH HO MXHJR /ROD GLULJLpQGRVHDPtSUHJXQWiQGRPHSRU TXp QR MXHJR FRQ HOORV /H UHVSRQGR TXH GXUDQWH XQ PHVQRSXHGRKDFHUORSRUTXHHVWR\REVHUYDQGRODFODVHTXHLPSDUWHODPDHVWUDGDGRTXH HVWR\HQXQSHUtRGRGHSUiFWLFDVSHURTXHILQDOL]DGRHOPHVLQGXGDEOHPHQWHTXHMXJDUpFRQ HOORV0LHQWUDVWDQWRODPDHVWUDSURSRQHDOJUXSRVDOWDUDODVYDOODVDFWLYLGDGTXHWDPSRFR 5 5 5 5 SXHGHQ UHDOL]DU GDGR TXH HYLGHQWHPHQWH D -RUGL OH HV LPSRVLEOH \ /ROD QR SXHGH HMHFXWDU VDOWRVEUXVFRVSRUVXIUDJLOLGDGDUWLFXODUGHELGRDODRSHUDFLyQGHSLHUQDVTXHVXIULyHOFXUVR SDVDGRSDUDDXPHQWDUODHVWDWXUD $FRQWLQXDFLyQGHFLGHQGHVSOD]DUVHDRWUD]RQDGHOSDWLR\HOLJHQHOHVSDFLRGHORWURSDWLR FRQWLJXR GRQGH KD\ XQRV EDQFRV GH PDGHUD /ROD FRJH XQD UXHGD GH FRFKH \ XQ DUR VLWXiQGRORVVREUHHOEDQFR/DUXHGDFXPSOHFRQHOFRPHWLGRGHDVHJXUDUTXHHODURQRFDLJD DOVXHORGHWDOIRUPDTXHYXHOYHQDVLPXODUXQDFHVWDGHEiVTXHW$PERVVHSDVDQODSHORWD HLQWHQWDQKDFHUFHVWDSHURVLQFRPSHWLFLyQ3RVWHULRUPHQWH/RODFRJHRWUDUXHGDGHFRFKH\ ODSRQHVREUHODRWUDUHWLUDQGRHODUR\GHFLGHQMXJDUXQRFRQWUDXQRLQWHQWDQGRKDFHUFRPR HOORVGLFHQPDWHVDSHVDUGHOEORTXHR7UDQVFXUULGRVXQRVVHLVPLQXWRVVHVLHQWDQXQJUXSR GHFXDWURQLxDVHQHOEDQFR\SUy[LPRVDODFHVWD\HQHVHLQVWDQWHREVHUYRTXHDPERVVH GHVSOD]DQDOD]RQDGHOODYDER/RODVHUHIUHVFD\VHVLHQWDMXQWRD-RUGL/HVSUHJXQWRTXp KDFHQ\/RODPHFRQWHVWDTXHHVWiQDKtSRUTXH\DQRSXHGHQMXJDU/HVYXHOYRDSUHJXQWDU ODUD]yQSRUODTXpQRSXHGHQVHJXLUMXJDQGR\PHUHVSRQGHGHQXHYR/RODGLFLHQGRTXHOHV KDQRFXSDGROD]RQDGHMXHJRV/HVVXJLHURTXHQHJRFLHQFRQVXVFRPSDxHUDVOD]RQDGHO EDQFRGDGRTXHHUDPX\JUDQGH\TXHSRGtDQGHVSOD]DUVHDORWURH[WUHPR3DUHFHTXHOHV FRQYHQFHORTXHOHVGLJR\VHGLULJHQGHQXHYRKDFLDHOEDQFRVLHQGR/RODODTXHLQGLFDD VXV FRPSDxHUDV GH PDQHUD PX\ LPSRVLWLYD TXH OHV GHMHQ MXJDU \ TXH SDUD HVWR WDQ VyOR WLHQHQ TXH GHVSOD]DUVH D XQRV GRV PHWURV < DVt OR KDFH HO JUXSR GH QLxDV VLQ RSRVLFLyQ DOJXQD /ROD \ -RUGL GHFLGHQ FDPELDU OD GLVSRVLFLyQ GH OD FHVWD \ SRU HOOR LQWURGXFHQ HQWUH ODV GRV UXHGDVXQDURHQSRVLFLyQYHUWLFDO9XHOYHQDMXJDUDO³XQRFRQWUDXQR´LQWHQWDQGREORTXHDU DODGYHUVDULRFRQHOREMHWLYRGHDQRWDUFDQDVWD$SHVDUGHTXHHVWiQVRORVMXJDQGRVHOHV REVHUYDTXHHVWiQPX\PRWLYDGRV\HQWUHJDGRVHQVXVMXHJRV &XDQGR ODPDHVWUDLQGLFDODILQDOL]DFLyQ GH OD VHVLyQ /ROD VH YD DO YHVWXDULR SHUR -RUGLVH TXHGDFRQXQFRPSDxHURMXJDQGRDOMXHJRDQWHULRU0HOODPDODDWHQFLyQTXHHOFRPSDxHUR SRQHHOEUD]RL]TXLHUGRGHWUiVGHODHVSDOGD/HSUHJXQWRSRUTXpORKDFH\PHGLFHTXHDVt MXHJDPHMRUFRQ-RUGL 6HDSUR[LPDODDX[LOLDUGH(GXFDFLyQ(VSHFLDO\VHILQDOL]DHOMXHJRpVWDDFRPSDxDD-RUGLD OD UHFHSFLyQ GHO FROHJLR \ OR GHMD DOOt D OD HVSHUD GH TXH SDVH OD PRQLWRUD GH FRPHGRU D UHFRJHUOR $SURYHFKR HVH HVSDFLR GH WLHPSR SDUD KDEODU FRQ pO /H SUHJXQWR FXiO HV HO GHSRUWHTXpPiVOHJXVWD\PHFRQWHVWDTXHHOEDORQFHVWRSHURTXHQRREVWDQWHOHJXVWDUtD MXJDUDOWHQLVGHPHVD/HGLJRTXHSUy[LPDPHQWHORSRGUHPRVKDFHU\PHFRQWHVWDFyPR GDGR TXH pO HV PX\ EDMLWR \ QR OOHJD D OD PHVD 5iSLGDPHQWH OH FRQWHVWR TXH SRGHPRV SHQVDUHQDOJXQDDGDSWDFLyQSDUDSRQHUODPHVDDVXDOWXUD\SRGHUSUDFWLFDUHVHGHSRUWH 6HTXHGDSHQVDWLYR\DVLHQWHFRQODFDUDLQWHQWDGRFRPXQLFDUPHVXDOHJUtD 0HGHVSLGRGHpO\GHVGHHOWHUFHUSLVRREVHUYRTXHHVWiXQRVGLH]PLQXWRVHQHOFHQWURGHO YHVWtEXORHQVROLWDULRKDVWDTXHEDMDODPRQLWRUDGHOFRPHGRUFRQVXJUXSR\ORWUDVODGDDOD ]RQDGHMXHJRV(VWRPHKDFHSHQVDUHQORVWLHPSRVGHVROHGDGDORVTXHHVWiVRPHWLGRSRU VXGHSHQGHQFLDGHODGXOWRHQORVWUDVODGRV &RPHQWDULRVDODVHVLyQ 5 5 5 5 5 $QWH OD SURSXHVWD GH DFWLYLGDGHV WDQ LQGLYLGXDOL]DGDV HQ HO FDVR GH REVHUYDU TXH FRQWLQ~D FRQ HVWD GLQiPLFD D OR ODUJR GHO UHVWR GH VHVLRQHV VXJHULU D OD PDHVWUD TXH SURSRQJD FRPR PtQLPR GRV DFWLYLGDGHV O~GLFDV DO LQLFLR \ DO ILQDO GH OD VHVLyQ SDUD IDFLOLWDUODLQWHUUHODFLyQGH/ROD\-RUGLFRQHOJUXSR $ SHVDU TXH OD PDHVWUD QR SUHWHQGH UHDOL]DU $&,V PRWLYDUOH SDUD TXH PH IDFLOLWH HODERUDUODVFRQHOILQGHRUGHQDUPLLQWHUYHQFLyQ 'DGDV ODV JUDQGHV OLPLWDFLRQHV GH PRYLOLGDG GH /ROD \ -RUGL FXDQGR LQWHUYHQJD WHQJR TXH EXVFDU HVWUDWHJLDV SDUD IDFLOLWDU OD LQWHUUHODFLyQ HQWUH HOORV \ VXV FRPSDxHURV HQ DTXHOORVHVSDFLRVGHODVHVLyQTXHWLHQHQTXHUHDOL]DUXQWUDEDMRPiVLQGLYLGXDOL]DGR 6R\ FRQVFLHQWH GH ODV JUDQGHV OLPLWDFLRQHV TXH WLHQH OD PDHVWUD SDUD SRGHU GDU XQD UHVSXHVWD HGXFDWLYD D ODV QHFHVLGDGHV GH WRGR HO JUXSR 6H KDFH LQGLVSHQVDEOH HO SURIHVRUDGRGHDSR\RHQHVWDVVLWXDFLRQHVWDQKHWHURJpQHDV '(6(37,(0%5('( 5 6(6,Ï11 &RPRVHKDQSDVDGRORVFXHVWLRQDULRVVREUHODFODVHGHHGXFDFLyQItVLFD\ODSDUWLFLSDFLyQ GHO DOXPQDGR FRQ GLVFDSDFLGDG PRWUL] DVt FRPR HO VRFLRJUDPD GHO JUXSR QR KD KDELGR WLHPSRSDUDUHDOL]DUODSDUWHSUiFWLFD 1R REVWDQWH KH REVHUYDGR TXH HQ HO HVSDFLR GH HVSHUD SDUD VXELU D FODVH ILQDOL]DGR HO WLHPSRGHSDWLR/RODMXHJDFRQXQJUXSRGHQLxDVDUHHTXLOLEUDUVHQRFDHUHQFLPDGHRFKR UXHGDVGHFRFKHVXSHUSXHVWDV$GLVWDQFLDQRVHREVHUYDGLILFXOWDGDOJXQDMXHJDFRQWRWDO QRUPDOLGDGOLGHUDQGRDOJUXSR(QFDPELR-RUGLHVWDPX\SUy[LPRDODSXHUWDHQVROLWDULRDOD HVSHUDTXHYHQJDODDX[LOLDUGH(GXFDFLyQ(VSHFLDOSDUDDFRPSDxDUORDODFODVH7DQVyORVH OHKDDSUR[LPDGRXQDFRPSDxHUDSDUDWRFDUOHODFDEH]D\pVWHQLVHKDLQPXWDGR3LHQVRTXH VLQRHVWXYLHUDWDQOLPLWDGRKDVWDTXpSXQWRDFHSWDUtDHVHWLSRGHUHODFLyQ +HPRVWHQLGRTXHHVSHUDUD-RUGLSDUDSDVDUORVFXHVWLRQDULRVHYLGHQFLiQGRVHODOHQWLWXGGH VXVWUDVODGRV0HOODPDODDWHQFLyQTXHPLHQWUDV/RODUHVSRQGHODVUHVSXHVWDVDODPLVPD YHORFLGDG TXH HO UHVWR GHO JUXSR H LQFOXVR HV XQD GH ODV SULPHUDV TXH HQWUHJD ORV FXHVWLRQDULRV -RUGL HV HO PiV OHQWR (V HO ~OWLPR HQ UHVSRQGHU HO SULPHU FXHVWLRQDULR \ HO SHQ~OWLPRHQHOVRFLRJUDPDGDGRTXHODFRPSDxHUDTXHORKDFHHQ~OWLPROXJDUGHRULJHQ UXPDQR SUHVHQWD JUDQGHV GLILFXOWDGHV SDUD WUDQVFULELU ORV QRPEUHV \ DSHOOLGRV GH VXV FRPSDxHURV\FRPSDxHUDV 5HYLVDQGRODUHVSXHVWDTXHGD/RODDODVSUHJXQWDVIRUPXODGDVUHVSHFWRDODSDUWLFLSDFLyQGH ODVSHUVRQDVFRQPRYLOLGDGUHGXFLGDHQODFODVHGH(GXFDFLyQ)tVLFD\HQORVMXHJRVPRWRUHV GH SDWLR UHFRQRFH TXH QR VLHPSUH SXHGHQ SDUWLFLSDU HQ ODV VHVLRQHV HVJULPLHQGR TXH ORV TXHVRQXVXDULRVGHPXOHWDVQRSXHGHQFRUUHU\QRSXHGHQVDOWDUDODFXHUGD\ORVTXHVRQ XVXDULRV GH VLOOD GH UXHGDV QR SXHGHQ VDOWDU WDPSRFR D OD FXHUGD HQWUH RWUDV FRVDV $Vt PLVPRFRQVLGHUDTXHQRVLHPSUHSXHGHQMXJDUDWRGRVORVMXHJRVGHOSDWLRSRUTXHORVQLxRV XVXDULRVGHPXOHWDVSUHVHQWDQOLPLWDFLRQHVHQODFDUUHUDWDO\FRPRHOODDQRWD³SRUTXH\RKH LGR FRQ ODV PXOHWDV \ QR SRGtD FRUUHU´ \ UHVSHFWR D ORV QLxRV R QLxDV XVXDULRV GH VLOOD GH UXHGDVGHQXHYRLQGLFDTXHQRSXHGHQVDOWDU 5 5 5 (QFDPELRVXFRPSDxHUR-RUGLFRQVLGHUDTXHWDQWRORVQLxRV\QLxDVXVXDULRVGHPXOHWDV\ GHVLOODGHUXHGDVSXHGHQMXJDUVLQSUREOHPDDOJXQRDODVDFWLYLGDGHVO~GLFDVGHOSDWLR1R REVWDQWH UHFRQRFH TXH HO KHFKR GH SUHVHQWDU XQD GLVFDSDFLGDG ItVLFD SXHGH OLPLWDU OD SDUWLFLSDFLyQ HQ OD VHVLyQ GH (GXFDFLyQ )tVLFD GDGR TXH QR WRGRV ORV MXHJRV VRQ SUDFWLFDEOHV&XDQGRVHUHILHUHDORVDOXPQRVXVXDULRVGHPXOHWDVUHVSRQGHTXHQRVLHPSUH SXHGHQSDUWLFLSDUSRUTXHHQWRGRVORVMXHJRVVHQHFHVLWDQODVPDQRVHQFDPELRFXDQGRVH FHQWUDHQORVDOXPQRVXVXDULRVGHVLOODGHUXHGDVFRQVLGHUDTXH³DYHFHV´SXHGHQSDUWLFLSDU GDGRTXHFRQODVPDQRVSXHGHLPSXOVDUODVLOODGHUXHGDV &RPHQWDULRDODVHVLyQ 0LHQWUDV TXH /ROD UHFRQRFH TXH QR WRGDV ODV DFWLYLGDGHV VRQ SUDFWLFDEOHV PH OODPD OD DWHQFLyQ TXH -RUGL OR UHFRQR]FD WDQ VyOR UHVSHFWR D ORV MXHJRV GHO iUHD \ HQ FDPELR QR FRQVLGHUHOLPLWDGRUODVLWXDFLyQGHOSDWLRFXDQGRpOHVWiYLJLODGRSRUODDX[LOLDUGH(GXFDFLyQ (VSHFLDOHQXQOXJDUSURWHJLGRGHOSDWLR 6(6,Ï11 '(6(37,(0%5('( /RV DOXPQRV \ DOXPQDV HVWiQ VHQWDGRV HQ HO HVSDFLR SUy[LPR D OD HQWUDGD GHO SDWLR SROLGHSRUWLYR 6H GLVWULEX\HQ HQ GRV JUXSRV HO GH ORV QLxRV \ HO GH ODV QLxDV (QWUH ORV SULPHURVORFDOL]DPRVD-RUGL\HQWUHODVVHJXQGDVD/RODHYLGHQFLiQGRVHODDFHSWDFLyQGH DPERV3DUDLQLFLDUODVHVLyQODPDHVWUDSURSRQHTXHVHRUJDQLFHQHQJUXSRVGHFLQFRFRQHO REMHWRGHMXJDU³DWRFDU´ &RQVLVWHHQTXHORVFLQFRTXHDWUDSDQWLHQHQTXHWRFDUDVXVFRPSDxHURV TXHKX\HQHQFDUUHUDFRQHOREMHWRGHHOLPLQDUORVKDVWDTXHQRTXHGHQLQJ~Q MXJDGRURMXJDGRUDHQHOWHUUHQRGHMXHJR/RVTXHVRQHOLPLQDGRVVDOHQDO H[WHULRUGHOD]RQDGHMXHJRV $QWHV GHRUJDQL]DUORVJUXSRVODPDHVWUD UHFXHUGD TXH -RUGL DO WHQHUGLILFXOWDGSDUDWRFDU DWUDSDUi FXDQGR XQ MXJDGRU HVWi D XQ PHWUR GH GLVWDQFLD /ROD UHLYLQGLFD HQ HVH PRPHQWR TXHHOODWDPELpQVHDFRJHDHVDDGDSWDFLyQSHUFLELpQGRVHVXDFHSWDFLyQSRUHOUHVWRGHOD FODVH $Vt PLVPR QR VH REVHUYD QLQJ~Q UHFKD]R WDQWR KDFLD -RUGL FRPR D /ROD FXDQGR VH RUJDQL]DQORVJUXSRV 3RVWHULRUPHQWH VH GHVSOD]DQ DO SDWLR SROLGHSRUWLYR /D PDHVWUD GHOLPLWD OD ]RQD GH MXHJRV XWLOL]DQGRODPLWDGGHODSLVWD(QHOSULPHUJUXSRSDUWLFLSD-RUGLeVWHLQGLFDDODPDHVWUDTXH UHFXHUGH DO JUXSR OD DGDSWDFLyQ GHO PHWUR GH GLVWDQFLD &XDQGR HO JUXSR DWUDSDGRU HVWi HODERUDQGR ODV HVWUDWHJLDV SDUD HOLPLQDU D ORV FRPSDxHURV -RUGL GLFH ³\R LUp D SRU /ROD´ 3DUHFHTXHWLHQHFODURTXHFRQHOODFRPSHQVDVXVGLILFXOWDGHVGHPRYLOLGDGUHGXFLGD<DVtOR KDFHFRQVWDQWHPHQWHLQWHQWDDWUDSDUODFRQVLJXLpQGRORUHODWLYDPHQWHSURQWRSRVWHULRUPHQWH SHUVLJXH D RWURV FRPSDxHURV SHUR QR HV FDSD] GH DWUDSDU D QDGLH PiV 1R REVWDQWH VH REVHUYD TXH HVWi PX\ PRWLYDGR SRU OD DFWLYLGDG +H GH DQRWDU TXH DQWHV GH LQLFLDU OD SHUVHFXFLyQHOJUXSRDQRWDGRUPHSLGHTXHOHVPLGDHOWLHPSRTXHGHVWLQDQSDUDHOLPLQDUDO UHVWRGHOJUXSR\TXHDOILQDOL]DUHOMXHJRGRVGHHOORVPHSUHJXQWDQSRUHOUHVXOWDGRHQWUH HOORVHVWi-RUGL 5 5 5 5 5 5 &XDQGRWRFDDOJUXSRGH/RODVHREVHUYDTXHHVWiPX\PRWLYDGDSRUODSUiFWLFDGHOMXHJR LQWHQWDQGR DWUDSDU D FXDOTXLHU FRPSDxHUR R FRPSDxHUD SUy[LPD D HOOD \ DFRJLpQGRVH D OD DGDSWDFLyQGHOPHWURGHGLVWDQFLD$SHVDUGHHOORQRDWUDSDDQDGLH (QHOUHVWRGHWXUQRVVHREVHUYD 4XH ORV FRPSDxHURV \ FRPSDxHUDV GH /ROD \ -RUGL ORV WLHQHQ PX\ DFHSWDGRV GH WDO IRUPDTXHFXDQGRHVWiQSUy[LPRVDORVDWUDSDGRUHVHVWRVQRGXGDQHQDWUDSDUORVFRPR DORVGHPiV1RREVWDQWHHQXQDRFDVLyQSDUDSURORQJDUHOWLHPSRGHSHUPDQHQFLDGH -RUGLHQHOWHUUHQRGHMXHJRODPDHVWUDVXJLHUHDOJUXSRDWUDSDGRUTXHQRORDWUDSHQWDQ UiSLGDPHQWH &XDQGRVRQDWUDSDGRVVHREVHUYDODSRVLWLYDLQWHUUHODFLyQFRQVXVFRPSDxHURVWDPELpQ HOLPLQDGRV 1R REVWDQWH HO JUXSRFODVH VXHOH DJUXSDUVH SRU VH[RV (Q WDQ VyOR GRV RFDVLRQHVVHREVHUYDD/ROD\D-RUGLKDEODQGRVLQFRQIOLFWRDOJXQR (Q HVRV HVSDFLRV GH HOLPLQDFLyQ TXH VRQ HQ GHILQLWLYD GH HVSHUD SHUFLER TXH /ROD JHQHUD MXHJRV FRQ ODV UXHGDV GH FRFKH R ELHQ UHDOL]D GLYHUVDV KDELOLGDGHV PRWULFHV SULQFLSDOPHQWH OD UXHGD DUUDVWUDQGR D XQ SHTXHxR JUXSR GH FRPSDxHUDV /D PDHVWUD LQWHUYLHQH UHFRUGDQGR D /ROD TXH QR UHDOLFH OD UXHGD SRUTXH HO LPSDFWR FRQ HO VXHOR SXHGHSHUMXGLFDUOHODVDUWLFXODFLRQHV (QOD~OWLPDUHSHWLFLyQGHOMXHJRODPDHVWUDDQLPDD-RUGLDSHVDUTXHHVWiHOLPLQDGRD TXHVHLQFRUSRUHDOJUXSRGHDWUDSDGRUHVFRQHOREMHWRGHD\XGDUORV/RODUHFODPDHQWUDU D LPDJHQ GH pO SHUR OD PDHVWUD OH FRQWHVWD TXH HOOD KD SDUWLFLSDGR PiV WLHPSR 3RVWHULRUPHQWHSURSRQHTXHHQWUH/ROD 6HREVHUYDHQJHQHUDOTXHDPERVHVWiQPX\PRWLYDGRVSRUHVWHMXHJR\TXHHVWiQPX\ELHQ DFHSWDGRVSRUWRGRVORVPLHPEURVGHOJUXSR )LQDOL]DFRQXQSDUWLGRGHI~WERORUJDQL]DQGRHOJUXSRGHQLxDVFRQWUDORVQLxRV/DPDHVWUD LQGLFD TXH ODV QLxDV TXH QR TXLHUHQ SDUWLFLSDU MXHJXHQ HQ HO SDWLR FRQWLQXR D OD SLVWD D ORV MXHJRVTXHHOODVGHFLGDQ0LHQWUDVTXHGRVVHVLHQWDQHQXQEDQFRDKDEODUHOUHVWRMXHJDD SLHVTXLHWRV /ROD GHFLGHMXJDUDI~WEROSDUWLFLSDQGR PX\DFWLYDPHQWH\OXFKDQGRFRQVWDQWHPHQWHSRUHO EDOyQ -RUGL DFW~D FRPR FRODERUDGRU GHO DUELWUDMH TXH UHDOL]D OD PDHVWUD 3DUD HOOR VH GHVSOD]DSRUODOtQHDODWHUDOGHOD]RQDGHMXHJRVLJXLHQGRODHYROXFLyQGHpVWHHLQGLFDQGRD ODPDHVWUDFXDOTXLHUDFFLyQPHUHFHGRUDGHSHQDOL]DU$SHVDUGHTXHVXUROQRHVWDQDFWLYR VHSHUFLEHTXH-RUGLHVWiPRWLYDGRSRUVXUROGHD\XGDQWHGHOiUELWUR &RPHQWDULRVDODVHVLyQ 6HREVHUYDODH[FHOHQWHDFHSWDFLyQGH/ROD\-RUGLSRUSDUWHGHVXVFRPSDxHURV (Q ORV MXHJRV GH SHUVHFXFLyQ OD PDHVWUD GHEHUtD SHQVDU HQ DOJXQD DGDSWDFLyQ SDUD IDFLOLWDUXQDPD\RUSHUPDQHQFLDGH-RUGL\/RODHQHOWHUUHQRGHMXHJRV (OKHFKRTXHDPERVKD\DQFRPSDUWLGRWRGDODVHVLyQFRQVXVFRPSDxHURVKDIDFLOLWDGR 5 5 5 5 5 5 5 5 5 ODLQWHUUHODFLyQFRQpVWRV 6HWLHQHTXHHVWDEOHFHUXQDHVWUDWHJLDSDUDTXH-RUGLDVXPDXQUROPiVDFWLYRFXDQGROD PDHVWUDSURSRQHXQDDFWLYLGDGGHSRUWLYDFRPRODGHOI~WERO 6(6,Ï11 '(2&78%5('( $OHQWUDUDOFROHJLRFRQODSULPHUDSHUVRQDTXHPHHQFXHQWURHVFRQODDX[LOLDUGH(GXFDFLyQ (VSHFLDO/RSULPHURTXHPHGLFHHVTXH-RUGLHVWDUiGHEDMDODUJRWLHPSRSRUTXHHQHOGtD DQWHULRU HQ HO HVSDFLR GH MXHJRV RUJDQL]DGRV SRU ORV PRQLWRUHV GH FRPHGRU VH FD\y \ VH JROSHyHOIpPXU\ODFDEH]D(OSURQyVWLFRPpGLFRLQGLFDTXHOHWLHQHQTXHRSHUDUGHOIpPXU\ SRUWDQWRHVWDUiYDULRVPHVHVVLQDVLVWLUDOFROHJLR $O KDEODU FRQ OD PDHVWUD WDPELpQ PH LQIRUPD GHO DFRQWHFLPLHQWR FRPHQWiQGRPH TXH VXV FRPSDxHURVHVWiQPX\FRQVWHUQDGRV (OREMHWLYRGHODVHVLyQHVHOWUDEDMRGHODVKDELOLGDGHVPRWULFHVEiVLFDV3DUDHOORODSULPHUD DFWLYLGDGTXHSURSRQHHV³DFRJHUODUXHGD´ (QHOFHQWURGHOSDWLRGLEXMDFRQODVUXHGDVGHFRFKHXQUHFWiQJXORODGLVWDQFLDHQWUHHOODVHV GHGRVPHWURV(OQ~PHURWRWDOGHUXHGDVTXHFRPSRQHQHOUHFWiQJXORHVXQDPHQRVTXHHO WRWDO GH DOXPQRV (O JUXSR WLHQH TXH SDUWLU GH OD OtQHD H[WUHPD GHO SDWLR \ GHVSOD]DUVH FRUULHQGR KDVWD DOFDQ]DU XQD UXHGD OLEUH (O TXH VH TXHGD VLQ UXHGD VH YD D OD ]RQD GH HOLPLQDGRV\VHUHWLUDRWUDUXHGD$VtKDVWDTXHTXHGDWDQVyORXQMXJDGRU /DDGDSWDFLyQTXHSURSRQHD/RODHVTXHSDUWDGHODPLWDGGHOFDPSRSDUDDVHJXUDUTXHVX HVIXHU]R VHUi SURSRUFLRQDO D VX OLPLWDGD ]DQFDGD 7UDV YDULDV UHSHWLFLRQHV OD PDHVWUD OH LQGLFD TXH GHVFDQVH /ROD VH GLULJH KDFLD GRQGH HVWR\ REVHUYDQGR 0H GLFH TXH HVWi PX\ FDQVDGD\HVSRUHOORTXHOHFRQWURORODVSXOVDFLRQHV&RQWDELOL]RSRUORTXHOHUHLWHURTXH GHVFDQVH $SURYHFKDPRV SDUD FRQYHUVDU FRQWiQGRPH TXH ³VH FDQVD PX\ UiSLGDPHQWH SRUTXH KDFH WDQ VyOR XQ PHV TXH SXHGH FRUUHU´ /H SUHJXQWR OD UD]yQ \ PH FRQWHVWD TXH GXUDQWH QXHYH PHVHV KD HVWDGR FRQ DSDUDWRV GDGR TXH OD RSHUDURQ SDUD DODUJDUOH ODV SLHUQDV,QVLVWHHQTXH³QROORUyHQQLQJ~QPRPHQWR´\TXH³OHTXHGDQWUHVRSHUDFLRQHVPiV´ 0HOODPDODDWHQFLyQODQDWXUDOLGDGFRQODTXHKDEODGHVXVLWXDFLyQ $FRQWLQXDFLyQHVUHFODPDGDSRUODPDHVWUDSDUDTXHVHLQFRUSRUHHQHOMXHJRGH³FRUUHUHQ ]LJ]DJ´ &RQ OD PLVPD GLVSRVLFLyQ GH ODV UXHGDV HQ UHFWiQJXOR OD SURIHVRUD GD OD FRQVLJQD TXH FRUUDQXQRGHWUiVGHRWURHQ]LJ]DJ 6H REVHUYD TXH /ROD SDUWLFLSD VLQ GLILFXOWDG SHUR FXDQGR VH VLHQWH FDQVDGD DEDQGRQD OD DFWLYLGDGSDUDTXHOHFRQWUROHODVSXOVDFLRQHV )LQDOL]DGD OD DFWLYLGDG GH QXHYR HV UHFODPDGD SRU OD PDHVWUD SDUD MXJDU DO ³UHOHYR GH ODV UXHGDVFRQEDOyQ´ 5 5 5 5 5 5 2UJDQL]D GRV ILODV VHSDUDGDV D XQRV GLH] PHWURV GH FLQFR UXHGDV GH FRFKH /D GLVWDQFLD HQWUH UXHGDV HV GH XQRV GRV PHWURV /RV DOXPQRV D XQRV FLQFR PHWURV GH ODV UXHGDV VH UHSDUWHQ HQ GRV JUXSRV XQR GHWUiV GH RWUR H[FHSWXDQGR XQ FRPSDxHUR R FRPSDxHUD TXH HVWi DO RWUR H[WUHPR GH ODV UXHGDV (O SULPHUR GH OD ILOD YD FKXWDQGR XQ EDOyQ GH I~WERO FRQWLQXDGDPHQWH FKXWHV FRUWRV KDVWD OOHJDU D ODV UXHGDV DO OOHJDU DOOt VH GHVSOD]D HQWUH UXHGD\UXHGDHQ]LJ]DJFRQWURODQGRVLHPSUHHOEDOyQ&XDQGROOHJDQDOD~OWLPDOHHVSHUD XQFRPSDxHURDOFXDOGHEHSDVDUHOEDOyQLQLFLDQGRHOUHFRUULGRDODLQYHUVDTXHGiQGRVHHQ HVD]RQDKDVWDTXHYHQJDRWURFRPSDxHURFRQHOEDOyQ /D UHVSXHVWD GH /ROD HV ELHQ FXULRVD &RPR OH FXHVWD PD\RU HVIXHU]R TXH ORV GHPiV HO KHFKRGHGHVSOD]DUVHYHOR]PHQWH\FRQWURODUHOLPSOHPHQWRVXDGDSWDFLyQHVODGHFKXWDUHO EDOyQDJUDQGLVWDQFLDFKXWHVODUJRVSDUDDVtWHQHUXQPD\RUPDUJHQSDUDFRUUHUVLQEDOyQ\ SRU WDQWR WHQHU PHQRU GLILFXOWDG &RPR HO JUXSR GH /ROD HV PiV OHQWR TXH HO RWUR TXH SRU FLHUWRHVWiFRQVWLWXLGRSRUQLxRVH[FHSWXDQGRDFXDWURQLxDVTXHVRQODVPiVKDELOLGRVDVOD PDHVWUD LQFRUSRUD RWUR EDOyQ SDUD IDFLOLWDU XQD PD\RU PRYLOLGDG GHO JUXSR \ HYLWDU ORV H[FHVLYRVWLHPSRVGHHVSHUD /D FXDUWD WDUHD HV VLPLODU D OD DQWHULRU SHUR FRQ OD YDULDQWH TXH WLHQHQ TXH GHVSOD]DUVH FRUULHQGR KDFLD DWUiV $TXt REVHUYDPRV XQD PD\RU GLILFXOWDG SDUD /ROD WHQLHQGR TXH UHHTXLOLEUDUVH FRQWLQXDPHQWH &RPR HQ OD DFWLYLGDG DQWHULRU FRPSHQVD ODV GLILFXOWDGHV FRQ FKXWHVODUJRV/ODPDODDWHQFLyQTXHQLQJ~QFRPSDxHURRFRPSDxHUDDGYHUVDULRVHGLVJXVWD SRUODYHQWDMD /DSHQ~OWLPDDFWLYLGDGHVHO³UHOHYRFKXWDQGRHOEDOyQ´ &RQODPLVPDGLVSRVLFLyQTXHHQODVGRVDFWLYLGDGHVDQWHULRUHVODFODVHFRQWLQ~DGLYLGLGD HQGRVJUXSRV5HWLUDODVUXHGDVSURSRQLHQGRTXHVHGHVSODFHQHQOtQHDUHFWDFKXWDQGRHO EDOyQFKXWHVFRUWRVKDVWDHQFRQWUDUDOFRPSDxHURTXHHVWiHQHORWURH[WUHPRGHOD]RQDGH MXHJRV $LPDJHQGHODVWDUHDVDQWHULRUHV/RODVHGHVSOD]DUHDOL]DQGRFKXWHVODUJRV 3DUDILQDOL]DUSURSRQHHOMXHJRGH³PDWDU´ /RVMXJDGRUHVVHGLVWULEX\HQHQGRVJUXSRVVHSDUDGRVSRUXQDOtQHDFHQWUDO(OHVSDFLR HVWiGHOLPLWDGR(OREMHWLYRGHOMXHJRHVHOLPLQDUDOHTXLSRFRQWUDULR3DUDHOORFXDQGRVH ODQ]DHOEDOyQGHHVSXPDHLPSDFWDDXQDGYHUVDULRWRFiQGRORHQFXDOTXLHUSDUWHFRUSRUDO H[FHSWXDQGRODFDUD\FDHSRVWHULRUPHQWHHOEDOyQDOVXHORVHFRQVLGHUDPXHUWReVWHVH GHVSOD]DKDFLDHOH[WUHPRGHOFDPSRGHORVMXJDGRUHVDGYHUVDULRVGHQRPLQDGD]RQDGH PXHUWRV\GHVGHDOOtLQWHQWD³PDWDU´DXQDGYHUVDULR'HQRFRQVHJXLUORWLHQHTXHHVSHUDU KDVWDTXHVXVFRPSDxHURVOHSDVHQHOEDOyQRELHQTXHORSXHGDFRQVHJXLUSRUTXHHOEDOyQ KDHQWUDGRDVX]RQDGHMXHJRV &RPR OD PDHVWUD QR DGDSWD HO MXHJR SDUD TXH /ROD SURORQJXH VX SHUPDQHQFLD HQWUH VXV FRPSDxHURV GH HTXLSR OD ³PDWDQ´ HQ HO SULPHU ODQ]DPLHQWR $ SHVDU TXH LQWHQWD VDOYDUVH FRPRODGLVWDQFLDFRQVXVDGYHUVDULRVHVPX\JUDQGHQRSXHGHFRQVHJXLUHOFRPHWLGR\VH SDVD WRGR HO WLHPSR TXH GXUD OD DFWLYLGDG HQ OD ]RQD GH PXHUWRV 1R REVWDQWH HVWi PX\ PRWLYDGDSRUODHYROXFLyQGHOMXHJRUHFODPDQGR FRQVWDQWHPHQWHDVXVFRPSDxHURVTXHOH 5 5 5 5 5 5 SDVHQ HO EDOyQ H LQFOXVR GLQDPL]D D VXV FRPSDxHUDV TXH FRPSDUWHQ OD ]RQD GH PXHUWRV SDUDTXHJULWHQDODYH]³SDVDUQRVHOEDOyQ´ &RPHQWDULRVDODVHVLyQ /RODQRHVUHFKD]DGDHQQLQJ~QPRPHQWRSRUVXVFRPSDxHURVGHJUXSR6XHOHRFXSDU HQODVILODVHQWUHHOSULPHUR\FXDUWROXJDU1DGLHVHRSRQHDVXHOHFFLyQ (V DFWLYD GLQDPL]DGRUD FRODERUD FRQ OD PDHVWUD HQ HO UHWLUR GHO PDWHULDO \ DQWH ODV GLILFXOWDGHVHVFDSD]GHEXVFDUDGDSWDFLRQHVTXHOHIDFLOLWHQODUHDOL]DFLyQGHODVWDUHDV 6H FRQVWDWD TXH HQ ORV MXHJRV FRPSHWLWLYRV D OD PDHVWUD OH IDOWDQ UHFXUVRV SDUD FRPSHQVDUODVGLILFXOWDGHVGH/ROD 6(6,Ï11 '(2&78%5('( /DVHVLyQGHODMRUQDGDGHKR\WLHQHOXJDUHQHOJLPQDVLR&XDQGRHQWURORVDOXPQRVHVWiQ VHQWDGRVHQORVEDQFRVVXHFRV\FRPRHQODVMRUQDGDVDQWHULRUHVORVQLxRVVHDJUXSDQHQXQ EDQFR\ODVQLxDVVHUHSDUWHQHQGRVEDQFRVHQWUHHOODVHQFRQWUDPRVD/ROD &XDQGRVDFRODFiPDUDGHYLGHRVHRUJDQL]DXQFLHUWRUHYXHORPD\RULWDULDPHQWHSRUSDUWHGH ORV QLxRV TXH LQWHQWDQ FDSWDU PL DWHQFLyQ SDUD TXH ORV JUDYH 8QD YH] TXH LQWHUYLHQH OD PDHVWUDFRPHQWiQGROHVODSULPHUDSURSXHVWDHOJUXSRHPSLH]DDROYLGDUVHGHODSUHVHQFLD GHODFiPDUD /D VHVLyQ JLUD DOUHGHGRU GH ODV KDELOLGDGHV PRWULFHV EiVLFDV 3DUD HOOR LQLFLD OD PDHVWUD OD VHVLyQLQGLFDQGRTXH 7RGRVORVDOXPQRVVHVLW~HQHQHOH[WUHPRGHODVDODXQRDOODGRGHORWUR&XDQGRGDOD VHxDOWLHQHQTXHGHVSOD]DUVHUHDOL]DQGRGLYHUVRVHMHUFLFLRVGHWpFQLFDGHFDUUHUD\ FXDGUXSHGLDV &RPRVRQDFWLYLGDGHVUHDOL]DEOHVSRU/RODQRVXSRQHQLQJXQDGLILFXOWDGSDUDVHJXLUHO ULWPRGHODVHVLyQH[FHSWXDQGRHQXQDGHHOODVVNLSLQJHOHYDFLyQDOWHUQDWLYDGHODVURGLOODV DODDOWXUDGHODFDGHUDTXHDOFRQWHQHUHOVDOWRODPDHVWUDOHLQGLFDTXHVHGHVSODFHHQ PDUFKD\TXHPDUTXHHOPRYLPLHQWRGHSLHUQDVSHURVLQLPSXOVLyQ /DVLJXLHQWHSURSXHVWDYHUVDVREUHHO³VDOWRGHDOWXUD´ (QODPLWDGGHOHVSDFLRFRORFDXQVDOWyPHWURODGLVWDQFLDHQWUHORVSDORVHVGHXQRV PHWURV$WDXQDFXHUGDGHVDOWDUHQFDGDSDOR\DXQDGLVWDQFLDUHVSHFWRGHOVXHORGH FHQWtPHWURV/RVQLxRVSDUWHQGHODOtQHDGHVDOLGDH[WUHPRGHOFDPSRGHGRVHQGRV WHQLHQGRTXHSDVDUSRUGHEDMRGHODFXHUGDVLQWRFDUOD3RVWHULRUPHQWHGHIRUPDLQGLYLGXDO WLHQHQTXHVDOWDUODFXHUGDKDFLHQGRODWLMHUDFRQODVSLHUQDV 5 5 5 5 5 5 5 5 $SHVDUGHODEDMDDOWXUDSDUD/ROD\DOHVXSRQHJUDQGLILFXOWDGSRUHOORODPDHVWUDVHxDOD TXHQRVDOWHVLQRTXHSDUHGHODQWHGHODFXHUGD\TXHODVXSHUHFRQXQSDVRODUJR$PHGLGD TXHDXPHQWDODDOWXUD/RODSDUWLFLSDVHJ~QODLQGLFDFLyQDQWHULRUSHURFRPRHOLQFUHPHQWRHV GHWUHLQWDFHQWtPHWURVPiVpVWDSXHGHVHJXLUFRQODDFWLYLGDGVLQH[FHVLYDGLILFXOWDG /D~OWLPDWDUHDHVODGHOVDOWRGHDOWXUDKDFLDDWUiV3DUDDVHJXUDUODFDtGDODPDHVWUD SRQHODFROFKRQHWDTXLWDPLHGRV $LPDJHQGHODDFWLYLGDGDQWHULRUODFXHUGDHVWiDXQRVFHQWtPHWURVUHVSHFWRDOVXHOR SRUORTXHODGLILFXOWDGHVFRQWURODGDDSHVDUGHODHVWDWXUDGH/ROD $ OR ODUJR GH OD VHVLyQ VH SHUFLEH D XQD /ROD GLQiPLFD \ PX\ SDUWLFLSDWLYD RFXSDQGR ORV WLHPSRV GH HVSHUD FRQ VDOWRV \ UXHGDV VREUH OD FROFKRQHWD TXLWDPLHGRV DUULQFRQDGD HQ HO JLPQDVLR DUUDVWUDQGR SULQFLSDOPHQWH D RWUDV FRPSDxHUDV D UHDOL]DU KDELOLGDGHV VLPLODUHV $Vt PLVPR FRPR HQ ODV VHVLRQHV DQWHULRUHV /ROD VH PXHVWUD PX\ FRODERUDWLYD FRQ OD PDHVWUDRIUHFLpQGRVHFRQVWDQWHPHQWHSDUDWUDVODGDUPDWHULDO3RU~OWLPRFRPHQWDUGHQXHYR TXHQRHVUHFKD]DGDSRUQLQJXQDFRPSDxHUDFXDQGRVHRUJDQL]DQGLYHUVDVILODV(OOXJDUTXH HOODGHFLGHHVUHVSHWDGRSRUWRGDVLQFOXVRHQPiVGHXQDRFDVLyQODDEUD]DQ &RPHQWDULRVDODVHVLyQ &XDQGR ODV WDUHDV WLHQHQ XQ FDUiFWHU LQGLYLGXDOL]DGR \ DVXPLEOH SRU /ROD VH SHUFLEH XQD SDUWLFLSDFLyQ DFWLYD LQWHUUHODFLRQiQGRVH SRVLWLYDPHQWH FRQ HO UHVWR GH ORV PLHPEURV GHO JUXSRPD\RULWDULDPHQWHFRQODVQLxDV 6(6,Ï11 '(2&78%5('( /DVHVLyQJLUDDOUHGHGRUGHOMXHJRGH³ORVSDVHV´/DPDHVWUDRUJDQL]DGRVJUXSRVHOGH ODV QLxDV \ HO GH ORV QLxRV SHUR FRPR ORV VHJXQGRV VRQ QXPpULFDPHQWH LQIHULRUHV D ODV SULPHUDV LQFOX\H D GRV QLxDV 3UHJXQWD DO JUXSR GH QLxDV TXLpQ TXLHUH LU FRQ HO GH QLxRV \ /RODHVXQDGHHOODV1RREVHUYRQLQJ~QUHFKD]RQLRLJRFRPHQWDULRVQHJDWLYRV (OMXHJRGH³ORVSDVHV´FRQVLVWHHQ 6HRUJDQL]DQGRVHTXLSRV(OREMHWLYRHVHOGHFRQVHJXLUYHFHVSDVDUVHHOEDOyQHQWUH ORVMXJDGRUHVGHWDOIRUPDTXHQRVHDLQWHUFHSWDGRSRUORVDGYHUVDULRV(QHOPRPHQWRTXH HVLQWHUFHSWDGRVHLQLFLDHOMXHJRGHQXHYR1RHVYiOLGRGHYROYHUHOEDOyQDOFRPSDxHURTXH KDSDVDGRHOEDOyQ&XDQGRVHKDQFRQVHJXLGRORVSDVHVLQLFLDHOMXHJRHOHTXLSR FRQWUDULR*DQDHOMXHJRHOHTXLSRTXHKD\DFRQWDELOL]DGRHOPD\RUQ~PHURGHYHFHVORV SDVHV /RODSDUWLFLSDPX\DFWLYDPHQWHOXFKDQGRFRQVWDQWHPHQWHSRUHOEDOyQ\UHFODPDQGRHOSDVH GHVXVFRPSDxHURVGHMXHJR7DQVyORDEDQGRQDGRVYHFHVHOMXHJRXQRSDUDGHVFDQVDU\ RWURSDUDEHEHUDJXD 5 5 5 5 5 5 5 5 /DPDHVWUDOHVXJLHUHTXHRFXSHORVHVSDFLRVH[WHULRUHVGHOD]RQDGHMXHJRFRQHOREMHWR TXH QR OD WDSHQ VXV FRPSDxHURV 6H REVHUYD TXH VLJXH OD UHFRPHQGDFLyQ SHUR HV PX\ IUHFXHQWHREVHUYDUODHQHOFHQWURGHOFDPSRORTXHOHGLILFXOWDDOWHQHUHOEDOyQHOSDVHDVXV FRPSDxHURVGDGDODSUR[LPLGDG\ODDOWXUDGHVXVDGYHUVDULRV(VSRUHOORTXHODPDHVWUD FRPHQWDD/RODTXHFXDQGRHVWpHQHVDVLWXDFLyQUHDOLFHHOSDVHSRUHQFLPDGHODFDEH]D\ KDFLDDUULED &RPHQWDULRDODVHVLyQ (QHVWHWLSRGHMXHJRVQRVHREVHUYDJUDQGLILFXOWDGSDUD/RODSDUWLFLSDQGRPX\DFWLYDPHQWH 7DQVyORGHEHWHQHUVHHQFXHQWDODVDGDSWDFLRQHVFXDQGRHVWiHQHOFHQWURGHOD]RQDGH MXHJRV\WLHQHTXHSDVDUHOEDOyQDVXVFRPSDxHURVSDUDTXHQRODREVWUX\DQWDQIiFLOPHQWH 6(6,21(61\ \'(2&78%5('( 1RVHUHJLVWUDQODVVHVLRQHVSRUDXVHQFLDGH/RODHQIHUPHGDG 6(6,Ï11 '(2&78%5('( /DSULPHUDWDUHDHVODGH³VHJXLUODVOtQHDV´ /D PDHVWUD RUJDQL]D D WRGR HO JUXSR FODVH HQ XQD ILOD XQR GHWUiV GH RWUR VREUH OD OtQHD FHQWUDOGHOSDWLRSROLGHSRUWLYR6HJ~QODVFRQVLJQDV\VLJXLHQGRDOSULPHURGHODILODWLHQHQ TXHGHVSOD]DUVHVLHPSUHSLVDQGRODVOtQHDVGHOFDPSR\DVHDKDFLDODGHUHFKDRKDFLDOD L]TXLHUGD (Q XQD GHODVRFDVLRQHVSURSRQHTXH OD SULPHUD GH OD ILOD VHD /ROD1RSUHVHQWDSDUDHOOD QLQJXQD GLILFXOWDG H[FHSWXDQGR FXDQGR WLHQH TXH GLVFULPLQDU HQWUH HO ODGR GHUHFKR \ HO L]TXLHUGR /DYDULDQWHTXHUHDOL]DHVODTXHVLJXH 'LVWULEX\HDOJUXSRHQGRVILODVVLWXDGRVHQGRVSXQWRVHTXLGLVWDQWHVGHOFDPSR$ODVHxDO GDGLIHUHQWHVFRQVLJQDVGHRULHQWDFLyQFRQHOREMHWLYRTXHQRVHHQFXHQWUHQ ËGHP SHUR FRUULHQGR 3RVWHULRUPHQWH FXDQGR GD OD FRQVLJQD FDGD JUXSR VH KD GH UHXQLU FRJLGRVGHODVPDQRV\RUJDQL]DQGRXQFtUFXORLQWHQWDQGRKDFHUORDQWHVTXHHORWURJUXSR $FRQWLQXDFLyQGLVSHUVRVSRUHOHVSDFLRFXDQGRGDODVHxDOWLHQHQTXHDJUXSDUVHHQFtUFXOR HQXQD]RQDSUHGHWHUPLQDGDDYHUTXpJUXSRORUHDOL]DDQWHV 5 5 5 5 5 5 5 5 3DUDILQDOL]DUFDGDJUXSRVHFRJHGHODPDQRIRUPDQGRXQDOtQHD(OMXJDGRUGHXQH[WUHPR LQLFLDODPDUFKD\HOUHVWRORVLJXHVLQVROWDUVHODVPDQRV$VtGLULJHDOJUXSRKDVWDHO³W~QHO´ TXHIRUPDQODVPDQRVGHOSULPHU\VHJXQGRMXJDGRUGHORWURH[WUHPR\DVtVXFHVLYDPHQWH SDVDUiHQWUHHOVHJXQGR\WHUFHURKDVWDOOHJDUDOILQDO¢&XiOGHORVJUXSRVILQDOL]DDQWHV" 3DUD/RODQRSUHVHQWDGLILFXOWDGVHJXLUHOULWPRGHORVFRPSDxHURVLQFOX\HQGRFXDQGRFRUUHQ 6LJXHODGLQiPLFDFRQJUDQPRWLYDFLyQ /DVHJXQGDSDUWHGHODVHVLyQVHFHQWUDHQHOMXHJRGHO³UHOHYRFRQEDOyQGHEDORQFHVWR´ 2UJDQL]DGRVILODVGHDOXPQRV$QWHHOORVDURVVHSDUDGRVHQWUHVtFRQXQDGLVWDQFLDGHXQ PHWUR\PHGLR(QHORWURH[WUHPRXQMXJDGRUGHFDGDJUXSR$ODVHxDOHOSULPHUMXJDGRUVH GHVSOD]D KDFLD ORV DURV ERWDQGRXQEDOyQ WHQLHQGR TXH ERWDUOR XQD YH] HQWUH DUR \ DUR \ GHQWURGHODUR&XDQGRILQDOL]DHOUHFRUULGROHSDVDHOEDOyQDOFRPSDxHURTXHHVWiHQHORWUR H[WUHPReVWHWLHQHTXHLQLFLDUHOSURFHVRDODLQYHUVD /ODPD OD DWHQFLyQ OD YHORFLGDG \ HO GRPLQLR GH EDOyQ SRU SDUWH GH /ROD QR FUHiQGRVH GLIHUHQFLDVFRQHOUHVWRGHSDUWLFLSDQWHVH[FHSWXDQGRHQHOFDVRGHORVYDURQHV /DWDUHDSRVWHULRUHVVLPLODUSHURHQHVWDRFDVLyQUHWLUDORVDURVWHQLHQGRTXHERWDUHOEDOyQ R ELHQ FRQ OD PDQR GHUHFKD R L]TXLHUGD VHJ~Q ODV FRQVLJQDV GH OD PDHVWUD &RPR HQ OD VLWXDFLyQDQWHULRUQRVXSRQHJUDQGLILFXOWDGSDUD/ROD )LQDOL]DHVWHJUXSRGHUHOHYRVFRQODVLJXLHQWHYDULDQWH 3RUSDUHMDVWLHQHQTXHSDVDUVHGHVSOD]iQGRVHHQFDUUHUDHOEDOyQ 7DO\FRPRRFXUUHDQWHULRUPHQWH/RODSDUWLFLSDDFWLYDPHQWHWDQVyORVXFRPSDxHUDWLHQHTXH SUHFLVDUHOSDVHVHJ~QODDOWXUDGHODVPDQRVGH/ROD 3DUDFHUUDUODVHVLyQSURSRQHHOMXHJRGH³PDWDU´ /RVMXJDGRUHVVHGLVWULEX\HQHQGRVJUXSRVVHSDUDGRVSRUXQDOtQHDFHQWUDO(OHVSDFLR HVWiGHOLPLWDGR(OREMHWLYRGHOMXHJRHVHOLPLQDUDOHTXLSRFRQWUDULR3DUDHOORFXDQGRVH ODQ]DHOEDOyQGHHVSXPDHLPSDFWDDXQDGYHUVDULRWRFiQGRORHQFXDOTXLHUSDUWHFRUSRUDO H[FHSWXDQGRODFDUD\FDHSRVWHULRUPHQWHHOEDOyQDOVXHORVHFRQVLGHUDPXHUWReVWHVH GHVSOD]DKDFLDHOH[WUHPRGHOFDPSRGHORVMXJDGRUHVDGYHUVDULRVGHQRPLQDGD]RQDGH PXHUWRV\GHVGHDOOtLQWHQWD³PDWDU´DXQDGYHUVDULR'HQRFRQVHJXLUORWLHQHTXHHVSHUDU KDVWDTXHVXVFRPSDxHURVOHSDVHQHOEDOyQRELHQTXHORSXHGDFRQVHJXLUSRUTXHHOEDOyQ KDHQWUDGRDVX]RQDGHMXHJRV 7DQVyORGDWLHPSRSDUDMXJDURFKRPLQXWRVGHpVWRV/RODSDUWLFLSDHOFLQFXHQWDSRUFLHQWR GDGR TXH DEDQGRQD OD ]RQD GH MXHJRV SDUD EHEHU DJXD 'XUDQWH VX SHUPDQHQFLD VH OH REVHUYDPX\GLQDPL]DGRUD\SDUWLFLSDWLYD &RPHQWDULRVDODVHVLyQ $XQTXH VHD UHLWHUDWLYR VXEUD\DU TXH VX SDUWLFLSDFLyQ HV PX\ DFWLYD VLJXLHQGR OD FODVH VLQ 5 5 5 5 5 5 5 5 5 5 GLILFXOWDG1RKDVLGRQHFHVDULRUHDOL]DUQLQJXQDPRGLILFDFLyQHQORVUHOHYRVGDGRTXHVHJXtD ELHQHOULWPRGHORVFRPSDxHURV 6HREVHUYDDXQD/RODVRFLDEOHGLQDPL]DGRUD\JHQHUDGRUDGHLQWHUUHODFLRQHVSRVLWLYDVQR REVHUYiQGRVHUHFKD]RSRUSDUWHGHVXVFRPSDxHURV\FRPSDxHUDV 6(6,Ï11 '(2&78%5('( $QWH OD FHOHEUDFLyQ GH OD ILHVWD GH OD FDVWDxDGD HO MXHYHV GH RFWXEUH SURWDJRQL]D OD VHVLyQODUHSURGXFFLyQFRQMXQWDGHODOHWUD³P´ 6HSUHWHQGHTXHWRGRVORVFXUVRVSDUWLFLSHQHQODUHSUHVHQWDFLyQGHOQRPEUHGHODHVFXHOD &DGDFODVHUHSURGXFLUiXQDOHWUD3DUDHOORORVQLxRV\QLxDVVHQWDGRVHQHOVXHORGLVHxDUiQ FRODERUDWLYDPHQWHODOHWUDDVLJQDGD /D SULPHUD WDUHD TXH SURSRQH OD PDHVWUD HV TXH HO JUXSR VH GLVWULEX\D HQFLPD GH OD OHWUD GLEXMDGDHQHOVXHOR8QDYH]REVHUYDGRHOSXQWRGHOHVSDFLRTXHRFXSDFDGDPLHPEURGHO JUXSRLQGLFDTXHFRUUDQOLEUHPHQWHSRUHOHVSDFLR\DODVHxDOWLHQHQTXHUHJUHVDUDOPLVPR SXQWRTXHRFXSDEDQ\FRQHOPLVPRRUGHQ &RPRYDULDQWHVH[SXVRTXH FXDQGR UHJUHVDEDQ D OD OHWUD SRGtDQ HVFRJHU FXDOTXLHU HVSDFLR VLQ UHSHWLUHODQWHULRU VH GLVWULEX\HUDQ VHJ~Q HO FRORU GH OD FDPLVHWD /RV GHO FRORU EODQFR RFXSDEDQHOFLQFXHQWDSRUFLHQWR\ORVGHFRORUHORWURFLQFXHQWDUHVWDQWH ILQDOL]ySURSRQLHQGRODUHSURGXFFLyQGHODOHWUDSHURHQHVWDRFDVLyQVLQ HVWDU GLEXMDGD HQ HO VXHOR 7HQtDQ TXH RUJDQL]DUVH SRU HVWDWXUDV GH PHQRUDPD\RU 'DGDVODVFDUDFWHUtVWLFDVGHODVWDUHDVSDUD/RODQROHVXSXVRQLQJXQDGLILFXOWDG3DUWLFLSyD LPDJHQ GHO UHVWR GH FRPSDxHURV 0H OODPy OD DWHQFLyQ HO FRPSRUWDPLHQWR GH pVWD FXDQGR FRUUtD OLEUHPHQWH SRU HO HVSDFLR &LQFR IXHURQ ODV YHFHV TXH LQFUHSy D VXV FRPSDxHURV GiQGROHVXQJROSHHQODHVSDOGDFRQODLQWHQFLyQGHHPSXMDUORV$SHVDUGHHVWDDFWLWXGGH /RODQLQJ~QFRPSDxHURRFRPSDxHUDVHPRVWUyHQIDGDGRQRGHYROYLHQGRHOHPSXMyQ 7DPELpQPHVRUSUHQGLyFRQTXHQDWXUDOLGDGGHIHQGtDTXHHOODWHQtDTXHVHUODSULPHUDGHOD ILODFXDQGRODPDHVWUDLQGLFyTXHVHRUJDQL]DVHQSRUHVWDWXUDV /DVLJXLHQWHSURSXHVWDIXHMXHJRGH³WRFDU\SDUDU´ (OJUXSRFODVHHVWiGLVSHUVRHQXQHVSDFLRGHOLPLWDGR\FXDWURQLxRV³SDUDQ´&XDQGRVHGD OD VHxDO GH LQLFLR pVWRV WLHQHQ TXH LQWHQWDU HOLPLQDU D VXV DGYHUVDULRV WRFiQGROHV FRQ OD PDQRHQDOJXQDSDUWHGHOFXHUSR(QHOPRPHQWRTXHORFRQVLJXHQORVTXHHVWiQWRFDGRVVH WUDVODGDQDOFDPSRGHHOLPLQDGRV*DQDHOMXJDGRUTXHVHTXHGHHO~OWLPRVLQWRFDU 5 5 5 5 5 7DQVyORVHUHDOL]DQGRVUHSHWLFLRQHV(QXQDGHHOODV/RODHVMXJDGRUDGHFDPSR\HQOD VHJXQGDIRUPDSDUWHGHOHTXLSRTXH³SDUD´(QODSULPHUDVLWXDFLyQODPDHVWUDVXJLHUHTXH /ROD VHD WRFDGD GH ODV ~OWLPDV DVt SXHGH SURORQJDU VX SHUPDQHQFLD HQ HO FDPSR (Q OD VHJXQGDUHSHWLFLyQODPDHVWUDUHFXHUGDTXH/RODSXHGHDFRJHUVHDOPHWURGHGLVWDQFLDHV GHFLUFXDQGRLQWHQWDWRFDUDXQFRPSDxHUR\pVWHSDVDDXQPHWURGHGLVWDQFLDGH/RODVH FRQVLGHUDUi WRFDGR $ SHVDU GH VX SHTXHxD ]DQFDGD HOLPLQD D YDULRV MXJDGRUHV \ WLHQH PD\RUGLILFXOWDGFXDQGRTXHGDQSRFRVHQHOWHUUHQR/HVXJLHURDODPDHVWUDTXHUHGX]FDHO HVSDFLR\REVHUYDPRVTXHIDFLOLWDODSHUVHFXFLyQ3HUFLERFRPRHVKDELWXDODXQD/RODTXH SDUWLFLSDPX\DFWLYDPHQWHDSHVDUGHOFDQVDQFLRTXHOHVXSRQHVHJXLUHOULWPRGHFDUUHUDGH VXVFRPSDxHURV &RPRHQODDQWHULRUVHVLyQILQDOL]DFRQHOMXHJRGH³PDWDU´ 5 3DUD LU SUHSDUDQGR PL SUy[LPD LQWHUYHQFLyQ VXJLHUR D OD PDHVWUD TXH RWRUJXH WUHV YLGDV WLHQH WUHV RSRUWXQLGDGHV KDVWD TXH SXHGD VHU HOLPLQDGD D /ROD SDUD SURORQJDU VX SHUPDQHQFLDHQHOMXHJR&XDQGRVHORFRPXQLFD/RODVRQUtHGHVDWLVIDFFLyQ\HOUHVWRGHO JUXSRORDFHSWDIDYRUDEOHPHQWH/D~QLFDGLILFXOWDGTXHVHUHFRJHHVHQORVODQ]DPLHQWRVGHO EDOyQGDGRTXHLPSOLFDQXQPD\RUHVIXHU]RSDUDHOODHOFRQVHJXLULPSDFWDUHOEDOyQKDFLDXQ DGYHUVDULR R ELHQ LQWHQWDU SDVDUOR D VXV FRPSDxHURV ³PXHUWRV´ D XQRV PHWURV $QWH HO SRFRWLHPSRGHOTXHVHGLVSXVRVLHWHPLQXWRVDSUR[LPDGDPHQWHWDQVyORDJRWyGRVYLGDV &RPHQWDULRVDODVHVLyQ 6H GHWHFWD OD QHFHVLGDG GH FRPSHQVDU ODV GLILFXOWDGHV GH /ROD SULQFLSDOPHQWH HQ VLWXDFLRQHVO~GLFDVFRPSHWLWLYDV &XDQGR OH SUHJXQWR D OD PDHVWUD VREUH OD DFWLWXG LQFUHSDQWH GH /ROD GDGR TXH HV OD SULPHUD YH] TXH OD REVHUYR PH FRQWHVWD TXH HV PX\ KDELWXDO HQ HOOD FRQILUPiQGRPH TXHWLHQHXQFDUiFWHUGRPLQDGRU 5 /RVMXJDGRUHVVHGLVWULEX\HQHQGRVJUXSRVVHSDUDGRVSRUXQDOtQHDFHQWUDO (OHVSDFLRHVWiGHOLPLWDGR(OREMHWLYRGHOMXHJRHVHOLPLQDUDOHTXLSRFRQWUDULR 3DUDHOORFXDQGRVHODQ]DHOEDOyQGHHVSXPDHLPSDFWDDXQDGYHUVDULR WRFiQGRORHQFXDOTXLHUSDUWHFRUSRUDOH[FHSWXDQGRODFDUD\FDH SRVWHULRUPHQWHHOEDOyQDOVXHORVHFRQVLGHUDPXHUWReVWHVHGHVSOD]DKDFLDHO H[WUHPRGHOFDPSRGHORVMXJDGRUHVDGYHUVDULRVGHQRPLQDGD]RQDGHPXHUWRV \GHVGHDOOtLQWHQWD³PDWDU´DXQDGYHUVDULR'HQRFRQVHJXLUORWLHQHTXHHVSHUDU KDVWDTXHVXVFRPSDxHURVOHSDVHQHOEDOyQRELHQTXHORSXHGDFRQVHJXLU SRUTXHHOEDOyQKDHQWUDGRDVX]RQDGHMXHJRV 5 5 5 6(6,Ï11 '(2&78%5('( 6HLQLFLDODVHVLyQFRQHOMXHJRGH³WRFDU\SDUDU´ (OJUXSRFODVHHVWiGLVSHUVRHQXQHVSDFLRGHOLPLWDGR\FXDWURQLxRV³SDUDQ´&XDQGRVHGD OD VHxDO GH LQLFLR pVWRV WLHQHQ TXH LQWHQWDU HOLPLQDU D VXV DGYHUVDULRV WRFiQGROHV FRQ OD PDQRHQDOJXQDSDUWHGHOFXHUSR(QHOPRPHQWRTXHORFRQVLJXHQORVTXHHVWiQWRFDGRVVH WUDVODGDQDOFDPSRGHHOLPLQDGRV*DQDHOMXJDGRUTXHVHTXHGHHO~OWLPRVLQWRFDU $/RODOHRWRUJDPRVGRVYLGDVWLHQHGRVRSRUWXQLGDGHVKDVWDTXHSXHGHVHUHOLPLQDGDSDUD SURORQJDU VX HVWDQFLD HQ HO FDPSR GH MXHJR OR TXH OH SURYRFD XQD DPSOLD VRQULVD GH DFHSWDFLyQVLQREMHFLyQDOJXQDSRUSDUWHGHOUHVWRGHOJUXSR$JRWDGDVXSULPHUDYLGD\DQWH HOYLVLEOHFDQVDQFLRODPDHVWUDLQGLFDD/RODTXHVDOJDGHOFDPSRGHMXHJRSDUDGHVFDQVDU 3RVWHULRUPHQWHSURSRQHHOMXHJRGH³UHOHYROLQHDOWUDQVSRUWDQGRXQDSHORWDGHWHQLV´ 2UJDQL]DGRVILODVGHDOXPQRV(QHORWURH[WUHPRDXQRVTXLQFHPHWURVXQFRPSDxHURGH 5 5 5 FDGDJUXSR$ODVHxDOHOSULPHUMXJDGRUVHGHVSOD]DFRUULHQGRKDFLDHOFRPSDxHURTXHHVWi HQHORWURH[WUHPRSDViQGROHODSHORWDGHWHQLVeVWHWLHQHTXHLQLFLDUHOSURFHVRDODLQYHUVD /DDGDSWDFLyQTXHIRUPXODODPDHVWUDSDUD/RODHVODVLJXLHQWH 6H VLW~D D XQ WHUFLRGHGLVWDQFLDUHVSHFWR D VXV FRPSDxHURV GH ILOD ,QLFLD HO SULPHU UHOHYR GHVSOD]iQGRVHKDFLDVXFRPSDxHURTXHHVWiVLWXDGRHQHORWURH[WUHPRGHOFDPSR8QDYH] SDVDGD ODSHORWDHVSHUDDLPDJHQGHORWURHTXLSRDUHFLELUODGHQXHYR$FRQWLQXDFLyQVH GLULJHKDFLDODILODGHFRPSDxHUDVSDUDSDVDUGHQXHYRHOUHOHYRSHURHOODORKDFHGHVGHHO SXQWRGHSDUWLGDLQLFLDODXQWHUFLRGHOUHFRUULGR\URGiQGRODSRUHOVXHOR 7DQWR /ROD FRPR HO UHVWR GHO JUXSR DFHSWD OD FRPSHQVDFLyQ GH OD OLPLWDFLyQ VLQ HVFXFKDU QLQJ~QFRPHQWDULRQHJDWLYRQLREVHUYDUDFWLWXGHVFRQWUDULDV /DWHUFHUDWDUHDHVHO³ODQ]DPLHQWR\UHFHSFLyQGHXQDSHORWDGHWHQLV´ 6H RUJDQL]DQ ILODV GH FLQFR DOXPQRV D XQD GLVWDQFLD GH WUHV PHWURV (O SULPHUR GH OD ILOD ODQ]DODSHORWDDOVHJXQGR\pVWHWLHQHTXHUHFHSFLRQDUODFRQXQDPDQR\DVtVXFHVLYDPHQWH KDVWDTXHOOHJDGHQXHYRDOSULPHUR (OMXHJRTXHVLJXHHVVLPLODUDODQWHULRUSHURFRQODVLJXLHQWHYDULDQWH /RVJUXSRVGHFLQFRHQFtUFXOR\QXPHUDGRVFDGDMXJDGRUGHOXQRDOFLQFR(OSULPHURODQ]D OD SHORWD YHUWLFDO \ KDFLD DUULED GHELpQGROD FRJHU HO VHJXQGR FRQ XQD PDQR \ DVt FRQWLQXDGDPHQWH KDVWD TXH WRGRV ORV MXJDGRUHV SDVDQ SRU ORV GRV UROHV WUDV YDULDV UHSHWLFLRQHV 5 5 5 5 'DGDVODVFDUDFWHUtVWLFDVGHHVWDVWDUHDVQRVXSRQHGLILFXOWDGDOJXQDSDUD/RODPRVWUDQGR XQDJUDQFDSDFLGDGHQODUHFHSFLyQGHODSHORWDFRQXQDPDQR1RREVWDQWHYDULDVVRQODV YHFHVTXHODREVHUYRGLVFXWLHQGRFRQVXVFRPSDxHUDVUHFODPDQGRPHMRUHVODQ]DPLHQWRVGH SHORWD /DTXLQWDWDUHDTXHH[SRQHODPDHVWUDHVOD³UHFHSFLyQGHODSHORWD´ 7RGRHOJUXSRFODVHGLVWULEXLGRSRUHOH[WUHPRGHOSDWLR/DPDHVWUDHQHOFHQWURFRQFXDWUR SHORWDVGHWHQLV&XDQGRODVODQ]DKDFLDHODOXPQDGRpVWHWLHQHTXHLQWHQWDUUHFHSFLRQDU\ GHVSOD]DUVH KDFLD GRQGH HVWi OD PDHVWUD SDUD SDVDUOH OD SHORWD 8QD YH] FRQVHJXLGR HO REMHWLYR SDVDQ DO ODWHUDO GHO FDPSR D OD HVSHUD TXH HO UHVWR GH FRPSDxHURV FRQVLJDQ HO SURSyVLWR)LQDOL]DHOMXHJRFXDQGRQRTXHGHQLQJ~QDOXPQRHQHOH[WUHPRGHOFDPSR /DYDULDQWHTXHIRUPXODHVODVLJXLHQWH (QYH]GHVHUODPDHVWUDODTXHODQ]DODVSHORWDVVRQFXDWURDOXPQRV(QHOPRPHQWRTXH FRQVLJXHXQFRPSDxHURUHFHSFLRQDUODSHORWDVHGLULJHKDFLDHOFHQWURGHOFDPSR\FDPELD GHUROHQWUDQGRDOLQWHULRUHOMXJDGRUTXHSUHYLDPHQWHKDODQ]DGRODSHORWD (Q HVWRV GRV ~OWLPRV MXHJRV /ROD WDPELpQ SDUWLFLSD PX\ DFWLYDPHQWH 6LJQLILFDWLYDPHQWH WHQJRTXHUHJLVWUDUTXHHQODTXLQWDWDUHDHVXQDGHODVSULPHUDVMXJDGRUDVTXHUHFHSFLRQDOD SHORWD 3DUDILQDOL]DUSURSRQHHO³ODQ]DPLHQWRVLPXOWiQHRGHGRVSHORWDV´ /RVJUXSRGHFLQFRFRQGRVSHORWDVGHWHQLV'RVDOXPQRVDXQDGLVWDQFLDGHWUHVPHWURV WLHQHQTXHSDVDUVHODVGRVSHORWDVDODYH]\UHFHSFLRQDUODVFRQXQDPDQR(QHOTXLQWRIDOOR FDPELDQORVSDUWLFLSDQWHV 'DGRHOSRFRWLHPSRTXHVHGLVSRQH/RODQROOHJDSDUWLFLSDU\DTXHWDQVyORSXHGHSDUWLFLSDU XQDSDUHMD$QWHODHVSHUDVHPXHVWUDGHVFRQWHQWDGHVSOD]iQGRVHDXQULQFyQGHOSDWLR\ VHQWiQGRVHHQHOVXHOR&XDQGROHSUHJXQWRTXpOHSDVDPHGLFHTXHVLHPSUHHVODPLVPD FRPSDxHUDODTXHWLHQHODSHORWD &RPHQWDULRVDODVHVLyQ 3RU OD WLSRORJtD GH WDUHDV QR KD VXSXHVWR GLILFXOWDG SDUD /ROD SDUWLFLSDQGR GLQiPLFDPHQWH /DPDHVWUDKDFRPSHQVDGRHTXLOLEUDGDPHQWHHOUHOHYROLQHDOFRQSHORWDGHWHQLV $SULRULVHREVHUYDXQDDFHSWDFLyQGHODVPHGLGDVGHFRPSHQVDFLyQGHODVOLPLWDFLRQHV HQ VLWXDFLRQHV FRPSHWLWLYDV SRU SDUWH WDQWR GH /ROD FRPR GH VXV FRPSDxHURV \ FRPSDxHUDV 5 5 5 5 5 5 5 5 5 6(6,Ï11 '(129,(0%5('( 'H QXHYRVHLQFRUSRUDHQODVHVLyQ-RUGL\GHVWDFRODSDUWLFLSDFLyQSRUYH]SULPHUDGHOD DX[LOLDUGH(GXFDFLyQ(VSHFLDO /DPDHVWUDLQLFLDODVHVLyQFRQHOMXHJRGH³VDOWDUODVSLHUQDV´ ,QGLFDDORVQLxRVTXHVHRUJDQLFHQHQGRVILODVGHLJXDOQ~PHURGHFRPSRQHQWHV6HQWDGRV HQ HO VXHOR FRQ ODV SLHUQDV H[WHQGLGDV \ D XQD GLVWDQFLD HQWUH FRPSDxHURV GH ILOD GH XQ PHWUR $ OD VHxDO VDOH HO SULPHU MXJDGRU GH FDGD JUXSR \ WLHQH TXH VDOWDU D SLHV MXQWRV ODV SLHUQDVGHVXVFRPSDxHURVFXDQGROOHJDDOILQDOJLUDSRUHOH[WHULRUGHODILODGLULJLpQGRVHDO SULQFLSLRFRQHOILQGHVDOWDUODVSLHUQDVGHORVFRPSDxHURVUHVWDQWHVKDVWDOOHJDUDOVLWLRTXH GHMDOLEUH$VtVXFHVLYDPHQWHKDVWDTXHSDVDQWRGRVORVMXJDGRUHV*DQDHOHTXLSRTXHDQWHV KDILQDOL]DGR 7DQWR/RODFRPR-RUGLVRQORVSULPHURVGHFDGDILOD6HREVHUYDDXQ-RUGLPX\PRWLYDGR LQWHUDFWXDQGR FRQ VXV FRPSDxHURV GH ILOD FRQVWDQWHPHQWH PRVWUDQGR pVWRV JHVWRV GH DIHFWR $Vt PLVPR /ROD VH LQWHUUHODFLRQD FRQ VXV FRPSDxHUDV VLQ SHUFLELU QLQJXQD FRQWUDULHGDG /DDGDSWDFLyQTXHSURSRQHODPDHVWUDHVODVLJXLHQWH $O HVWDU FRQWUDLQGLFDGRV ORV VDOWRV SDUD /ROD \ DQWH OD LPSRVLELOLGDG GH -RUGL GH VDOWDU ORV VLW~D HQ HO LQWHULRU GH ODV ILODV 'HVGH OD DOWXUD GHO SULPHU MXJDGRU D OD VHxDO UHDOL]DQ XQD FDUUHUDOLQHDOKDVWDOOHJDUDOILQDOGHOJUXSRWHQLHQGRTXHJLUDUSRUHOH[WHULRU\UHJUHVDUGH QXHYRDOLQLFLRGHODILODRFXSDQGRORVSULPHURVOXJDUHV &XDQGRHVWiQHQORVSUHSDUDWLYRVDPERVSDUWLFLSDQWHVVHREVHUYDQPX\FRPSHWLWLYRVHQWUH HOORV'DGRHOWLHPSRGHDUUDQTXHGHODVLOOD\ODYHORFLGDGGH/RODpVWDOOHJDDVXVLWLRFRQ PHGLRUHFRUULGRGHGLIHUHQFLD$ODVLJXLHQWHUHSHWLFLyQOHVXJLHURDODPDHVWUDTXHOHFRQFHGD D -RUGL PHGLD SLVWD GH YHQWDMD &XDQGR VH OR SURSRQH D /ROD VH PXHVWUD FRQWUDULDGD FXHVWLRQDQGRHOSRUTXpSHURDQWHUD]RQDPLHQWRGHODPDHVWUDORDFHSWDVLQGLILFXOWDG/ODPD ODDWHQFLyQTXHHOUHVWRGHOJUXSRQRSRQHQLQJXQDREMHFLyQ /DVLJXLHQWHWDUHDHVODGH³ORVGHVSOD]DPLHQWRVODWHUDOHV´ 7DO\FRPRHVWiGLVSXHVWDODFODVHHQGRVILODVOHVLQGLFDTXHVHSRQJDQGHSLH/DPDHVWUD GD FRQVLJQDV UHVSHFWR DO Q~PHUR GH SDVRV ODWHUDOHV \D VHD KDFLD OD GHUHFKD R KDFLD OD L]TXLHUGDTXHWLHQHTXHUHDOL]DUFDGDILODGHWDOIRUPDTXHDOILQDOGHOMXHJRVHFRQVLJXHXQD ILOD~QLFD 3DUD /ROD HVWD DFWLYLGDG QR OH VXSRQH QLQJXQD GLILFXOWDG SHUR Vt HQ FDPELR SDUD -RUGL $O REVHUYDUODPDHVWUDODVOLPLWDFLRQHVGHpVWHSDUDUHDOL]DUORVGHVSOD]DPLHQWRVODWHUDOHVFRQOD VLOODGHUXHGDVOHFRPHQWDTXHJLUHODVLOODVHJ~QODGLUHFFLyQVHxDODGD\TXHUHDOLFHWDQWRV LPSXOVRVGHODVLOODFRPRSDVRVSURSXHVWRVGHWDOPDQHUDTXHDOILQDOL]DUWLHQHTXHUHDOL]DU GHQXHYRPHGLRJLURSDUDVLWXDUVHGHQXHYRFRPRVXVFRPSDxHURV 5 5 5 5 5 5 5 $O SULQFLSLR OH FXHVWD FRRUGLQDU ORV GHVSOD]DPLHQWRV \ ORV PHGLRV JLURV SHUR DQWH OD LQWHUYHQFLyQ GH OD DX[LOLDU GH (GXFDFLyQ (VSHFLDO TXH OH PDUFD FyPR WLHQHQ TXH VHU ORV PHGLRVJLURVUiSLGDPHQWHORVDVLPLOD )LQDOL]DODVHVLyQFRQHOMXHJRGH³PDWDU´ /RVMXJDGRUHVVHGLVWULEX\HQHQGRVJUXSRVVHSDUDGRVSRUXQDOtQHDFHQWUDO(OHVSDFLRHVWi GHOLPLWDGR(OREMHWLYRGHOMXHJRHVHOLPLQDUDOHTXLSRFRQWUDULR3DUDHOORFXDQGRVHODQ]DHO EDOyQ GH HVSXPD H LPSDFWD D XQ DGYHUVDULR WRFiQGROR HQ FXDOTXLHU SDUWH FRUSRUDO H[FHSWXDQGR OD FDUD \ FDH SRVWHULRUPHQWH HO EDOyQ DO VXHOR VH FRQVLGHUD PXHUWR eVWH VH GHVSOD]D KDFLD HO H[WUHPR GHO FDPSR GH ORV MXJDGRUHV DGYHUVDULRV GHQRPLQDGD ]RQD GH PXHUWRV \ GHVGH DOOt LQWHQWD ³PDWDU´ D XQ DGYHUVDULR 'H QR FRQVHJXLUOR WLHQH TXH HVSHUDU KDVWDTXHVXVFRPSDxHURVOHSDVHQHOEDOyQRELHQTXHORSXHGDFRQVHJXLUSRUTXHHOEDOyQ KDHQWUDGRDVX]RQDGHMXHJRV &RQMXQWDPHQWHWDQWRODPDHVWUDFRPRODDX[LOLDUDFRUGDPRVTXHFXDQGRLQWHQWHQLPSDFWDU FRQHOEDOyQD-RUGLDQWHVWLHQHTXHGDUXQERWHHQHOVXHOR7DQWRD/RODFRPRDpVWHVHOH FRQFHGHQWUHVYLGDVWUHVRSRUWXQLGDGHVDQWHVGHSDVDUDOFDPSRGHPXHUWRVSDUDSURORQJDU VXSHUPDQHQFLDHQHOHVSDFLRGHMXHJR&XDQGRSRVHHQHOEDOyQHLQWHQWDQODQ]DUORFRQWUD VXV DGYHUVDULRV VH JULWD ³VWRS´ WHQLHQGR TXH SHUPDQHFHU HVWiWLFRV HQ HO HVSDFLR 6t FRQVLJXHQLPSDFWDUFRQHOEDOyQDDOJ~QMXJDGRUVHFRQVLGHUDPXHUWR $O FRPXQLFDU OD PDHVWUD ODV DGDSWDFLRQHV GH -RUGL UiSLGDPHQWH /ROD SLGH EHQHILFLDUVH GH HOODV HVWi HQ HO RWUR JUXSR DO FRQILUPDUOR OD PDHVWUD QR SRQH QLQJXQD RWUD REMHFLyQ HQ FDPELRVXVFRPSDxHUDVGHMXHJRHQQLQJ~QPRPHQWRKDQUHFODPDGRODFRPSHQVDFLyQGHODV OLPLWDFLRQHVGH-RUGLSDUD/ROD &RPRHVODSULPHUDVHVLyQHQTXHSDUWLFLSD-RUGLGHVSXpVGHODFDtGDHQHOSDWLRHQTXHVH IUDFWXUyHOIpPXUSHUFLELPRVDXQ-RUGLWHPHURVRGHVSOD]iQGRVHSRUHOODWHUDOGHOHVSDFLR LQWHQWDQGRQRFKRFDUFRQQLQJ~QFRPSDxHUR$QWHHVHFRPSRUWDPLHQWRFRQODDX[LOLDUYHPRV QHFHVDULRTXHVHVLW~HSUy[LPRDpOKDFHUVRPEUDFRQODILQDOLGDGGHGDUOHVHJXULGDG\TXH FRPSUXHEHTXHHODGXOWROHSXHGHSUHVHUYDUGHXQDSRVLEOHFDtGD &RPHQWDULRVDODVHVLyQ /R PiV VLJQLILFDWLYR GH KR\ HV OD LQFRUSRUDFLyQ GH OD DX[LOLDU GH (( HQ OD VHVLyQ OR TXH DVHJXUDSDUD-RUGLXQDPD\RUDWHQFLyQ 6H REVHUYD FRPR KH DQRWDGR DQWHV D XQ -RUGL WHPHURVR WDQ VyOR HQ HO MXHJR GH ³PDWDU´ DQWHODVLQFHUWLGXPEUHVFRQWLQXDV 5 5 5 5 5 5 5 6(6,Ï11 '(129,(0%5('( /DFODVHGHOGtDGHKR\YHUVDVREUHOD³LQLFLDFLyQDOYROHLERO´3DUDLQLFLDUODVHVLyQSURSRQH XQDDFWLYLGDGGRQGHVHWUDEDMDQODVKDELOLGDGHVPRWULFHVEiVLFDV (OJUXSRFODVHHQILODLQGLDDXQDGLVWDQFLDGHXQEUD]R$ODVHxDOWLHQHQTXHGHVSOD]DUVH HQFDUUHUDOHQWDVLJXLHQGRODVOtQHDVH[WUHPDVGHOFDPSR3RVWHULRUPHQWHSURSRQHGLVWLQWRV WLSRVGHGHVSOD]DPLHQWRVFRQHOGHQRPLQDGRUFRP~QGHOVDOWR)LQDOL]DFRQPDUFKD UHDOL]DQGRHOHYDFLRQHVGHEUD]RVTXHIDFLOLWDQODVUHVSLUDFLRQHVDPSOLDV 7DQWRSDUD/RODFRPRSDUD-RUGLORVGHVSOD]DPLHQWRVORVHMHFXWDQVLJXLHQGRODVOtQHDV LQWHULRUHVGHOFDPSRGHYROHLERO/DSULPHUDUHDOL]DODVKDELOLGDGHVTXHLQGLFDODPDHVWUDVLQ GLILFXOWDGHQFDPELRFRPR-RUGLQRSXHGHUHDOL]DUVDOWRVORVXVWLWX\HSRUFDUUHUDFRQWLQXD &XDQGRVHPXHVWUDFDQVDGRODDX[LOLDUGH(GXFDFLyQ(VSHFLDOVHDSUR[LPDDpOFRQHOREMHWR GHUHDOL]DUWDPELpQODVHOHYDFLRQHVGHEUD]RV\DVtPLVPRSUDFWLFDUHVWLUDPLHQWRV\PRYLOLGDG DUWLFXODUWDQWRGHODFDEH]DFRPRGHORVKRPEURV /DSDUWHFHQWUDOGHODVHVLyQODSURWDJRQL]DHO³WRTXHGHGHGRVHQYROHLERO´ 'LVWULEX\HDOJUXSRSRUSDUHMDV&DGDXQDGHpVWDVHVWiQVHSDUDGDVSRUODFXHUGDTXH VLPXODODUHGGHOYROHLEROTXHHVWiDXQDGLVWDQFLDGHOVXHORGHXQPHWUR\VHWHQWD FHQWtPHWURV/RVQLxRV\ODVQLxDVWLHQHQTXHUHDOL]DUWRTXHVGHGHGRVFRQHOEDOyQ LQWHQWDQGRIDFLOLWDUHOSDVHDOFRPSDxHURSDUDTXHpVWHORGHYXHOYDVLQJUDQGLILFXOWDGËGHP SHURFRQWDELOL]DQGRHOPi[LPRQ~PHURGHSDVHVHQWUHODVSDUHMDV)LQDOL]DRUJDQL]DQGR JUXSRVGHFXDWUR\SURSRQLHQGRXQSDUWLGRGHGRVFRQWUDGRVFRQHOREMHWLYRGHTXHLQWHQWHQ TXHFDLJDHOEDOyQHQHOFDPSRFRQWUDULR&DGDYH]TXHHOORRFXUUHHVXQSXQWRSDUDHO HTXLSR*DQDTXLHQREWHQJDHOPD\RUQ~PHURGHSXQWRV /DDGDSWDFLyQTXHSURSRQHSDUD/ROD\SDUD-RUGLHVODGHGLVPLQXLUODDOWXUDGHODFXHUGD SURSRUFLRQDOPHQWHDODGHpVWRV$PERVHPSLH]DQDUHDOL]DUORVSDVHVFRQODFRQGLFLyQGH TXH/RODWLHQHTXHIDFLOLWDUODGHYROXFLyQGH-RUGLLQWHQWDQGRTXHHOEDOyQGpXQERWHHQHO VXHORHQWUHODFXHUGD\pVWH/DDX[LOLDUGH((VHVLW~DSUy[LPDD-RUGLSDUDUHFRJHUODSHORWD FDGDYH]TXHIDOODODUHFHSFLyQ 8QFRPSDxHURTXHHVWiUHVIULDGRVHDFHUFDDpVWRV\OHVSURSRQHFRPSDUWLUHOMXHJR $FHSWDQ\VHVLW~DHQHOFDPSRGH/ROD/RVWUHVFRPSDUWHQODDFWLYLGDGPX\DFWLYDPHQWH 3HURFRPRREVHUYDPRVTXHODFXHUGDGLILFXOWDODSUHFLVLyQGHORVSDVHVGHFLGLPRVTXHORV UHDOLFHQVLQFXHUGD(QHVWDRFDVLyQHOFRPSDxHURFRQWDELOL]DHOQ~PHURGHSDVHVHQWUH/ROD \-RUGL7UDQVFXUULGRVFLQFRPLQXWRVODDX[LOLDUSURSRQHTXH/RODYXHOYDDODFXHUGDFRQHO FRPSDxHURPLHQWUDVTXHD-RUGLORLQWURGXFHHQHOVDTXHGHEDOyQGDGRVXLQWHUpVWHQLHQGR TXHH[SHULPHQWDUGLIHUHQWHVVDTXHV\UHFHSFLRQDQGRHOODHOEDOyQHVWiVLWXDGDIUHQWHDpOD XQRVWUHVPHWURV6HILQDOL]DFRQHOSDUWLGR-RUGLFRQWUD/ROD\HOFRPSDxHUR &RPHQWDULRVDODVHVLyQ $SHVDUGHTXH/ROD\-RUGLHVWiQGLVWDQFLDGRVGHOJUXSRJUDQSDUWHGHODVHVLyQQRYDHQ 5 5 5 5 5 5 GHWULPHQWRGHVXLQWHUpVSDUWLFLSDFLyQ\PRWLYDFLyQ 7HQJRTXHUHJLVWUDUHOFRQWUROGHODPDHVWUDTXHWLHQHGHOJUXSR\FyPRHVFDSD]GHKDFHU ODVFRUUHFFLRQHVSHUWLQHQWHVWDQWRODVGLULJLGDVD/RODFRPRD-RUGLVLQURPSHUFRQHOULWPR GHODVHVLyQ 0HVRUSUHQGHODFDSDFLGDGGHDGDSWDFLyQGHODVWDUHDVSRUSDUWHGHODDX[LOLDUGH(( 6(6,Ï11 '(129,(0%5('( (Q HVWD MRUQDGDQRDVLVWH/RODSRUHVWDU HQIHUPD &RQ -RUGL QRV LQWURGXFLPRVHQODVHVLyQ FRQXQFXDUWRGHKRUDGHUHWUDVRSRUTXHORKHHQWUHYLVWDGRGXUDQWHODPHGLDKRUDGHOSDWLR\ DGHPiV KD WHQLGR TXH UHOOHQDU HO FXHVWLRQDULR VREUH OD HOHFFLyQ GH ORV FRPSDxHURV SDUD RUJDQL]DUJUXSRVGHWUDEDMRHQHODXOD /RVDOXPQRVMXHJDQD³SDVDUSRUGHEDMRGHOW~QHO´ /DPDHVWUDSURSRQHTXHVHGLVWULEX\DQHQGRVJUXSRVQLxRV\QLxDVDXQDGLVWDQFLDHQWUH HOORVGHXQRVPHWURV(QFDGDXQRGHHOORVORVQLxRVVHHPSDUHMDQRUJDQL]DQGRXQDILOD\ VHFRJHQSRUODVPDQRVFRQORVEUD]RVDO]DGRV\SRUHQFLPDGHODFDEH]DGHWDOIRUPDTXH HQWUHWRGRVGLVHxDQXQW~QHO/DGLVWDQFLDHQWUHODVSDUHMDVRVFLODHQWUHFLQFXHQWDDQRYHQWD FHQWtPHWURV$ODVHxDOVDOHODTXHHVWiVLWXDGDHQHO~OWLPROXJDU\FRJLGRVSRUODPDQRVH GHVSOD]DQKDVWDHOSULQFLSLRGHODILODHVWUXFWXUDQGRHOW~QHOGHWDOIRUPDTXHJDQDHOJUXSR TXHDQWHVOOHJXHDXQDOtQHDILMDGDGHDQWHPDQR /D PDHVWUD LQFRUSRUD UiSLGDPHQWH D -RUGL HQ HO JUXSR GH ORV YDURQHV /D DGDSWDFLyQ TXH IRUPXODHVTXHLQLFLHODDFWLYLGDG SDVDQGRLQGLYLGXDOPHQWHSRUHOW~QHO\FXDQGROOHJDDOILQDO ODDX[LOLDUGH((OHD\XGDIDFLOLWDQGRHOJLURGHODVLOODSDUDLQFRUSRUDUVHODWHUDOPHQWHFRPR VXVFRPSDxHURVRFXSDQGRHOHVSDFLRSHURVLQFRPSDxHUR $SHVDUGHOLQWHUpVGH-RUGLHQDFHOHUDUORPiVSRVLEOHHOULWPRGHVXJUXSRVHYHGLVPLQXLGR $OJDQDUHOJUXSRGHODVQLxDVDOJXQRVQLxRVVHKDQRIHQGLGRFRPHQWDQGRDODPDHVWUDTXH ODFXOSDGHOUHVXOWDGRODWLHQHODOHQWLWXGGH-RUGL$QWHHVWRVFRPHQWDULRVSHUPDQHFHFDOODGR \H[SHFWDQWHDODLQWHUYHQFLyQGHODPDHVWUDODFXDOLQVLVWHTXHWRGRV\WRGDVWLHQHQGHUHFKR DSDUWLFLSDULQGHSHQGLHQWHPHQWHGHODYHORFLGDG 3RVWHULRUPHQWHODPDHVWUDVXJLHUHD-RUGLTXHSDVHDOJUXSRGHODVQLxDV\TXHVHLVGHpVWDV DOJUXSRGHORVQLxRVFRQHOILQGHFRPSHQVDUODUDSLGH]GHpVWRV(VFXULRVDODUHVSXHVWDGHO JUXSRGHODVQLxDVFRQVLJXLHQGRODYLFWRULDeVWDVDXPHQWDQODGLVWDQFLDHQWUHFRPSDxHUDVD FDVL XQ PHWUR \ PHGLR \ FXDQGR OH WRFD GHVSOD]DUVH D -RUGL GH IRUPD HVSRQWiQHD VDOH DOJXQD MXJDGRUD \ OH LPSXOVD OD VLOOD GH UXHGDV OR FXDO HV LQWHUUXPSLGR UiSLGDPHQWH SRU OD DX[LOLDUGH((SRUHOULHVJRTXHFRPSRUWDSDUD-RUGL(OORSURYRFDD~QPiVHQRMRHQHOJUXSR GH ORV QLxRV DFRJLpQGRVH D TXH ODV QLxDV KDFHQ WUDPSDV \ TXH DGHPiV HQ VX JUXSR SDUWLFLSDQXQVXEJUXSRGHQLxDVOHQWDV$QWHWDOHVFRPHQWDULRVODPDHVWUDWLHQHTXHLQWHUYHQLU GHQXHYRHQHOFRQIOLFWR 5 5 5 5 5 5 5 (OVLJXLHQWHMXHJRHVHO³UHOHYROLQHDOHQFDUUHUD´ 2UJDQL]DFLQFRJUXSRVGHFXDWURDFLQFRQLxRVHQILOD/DGLVWDQFLDHQWUHJUXSRVHVGHXQRV WUHVPHWURV6LWXDGRVWUDVXQDOtQHDGHVDOLGDHOSULPHUPLHPEURFRQXQDURSHTXHxRHQOD PDQRWLHQHTXHGHVSOD]DUVHHQFDUUHUDKDVWDOOHJDUDOH[WUHPRGHOFDPSRPHWURVGRQGH OH HVSHUDXQMXJDGRUGHOHTXLSR/HSDVD HO DUR \ VH TXHGD HQ HVH OXJDU PLHQWUDV TXH VX FRPSDxHURLQLFLDHOUHFRUULGRDODLQYHUVD\DVtVXFHVLYDPHQWHKDVWDTXHHO~OWLPRMXJDGRUGH XQJUXSROOHJDDVHUHOSULPHURHQOOHJDUDODOtQHDGHLQLFLR $QWHODOHQWLWXGGHDOJ~QJUXSRGHFXDWURMXJDGRUHVODPDHVWUDORFRPSHQVDFRQHODXPHQWR GHXQPLHPEURPiVHQORVJUXSRVPiVYHORFHV&RPR-RUGLSLHUGHWLHPSRHQHODUUDQTXHGH ODVLOODGHUXHGDV\VXYHORFLGDGHVPHQRUTXHODGHVXVDGYHUVDULRVGHFLGLPRVTXHUHFRUUHUi XQ WHUFLR GHO UHFRUULGR GH WDO PDQHUD TXH XQD FRPSDxHUD VH VLW~D D XQRV PHWURV SDUD FRJHU HO DUR\VHORSDVDDOFRPSDxHURTXHHVWiDORWURH[WUHPRGHOFDPSRpVWHLQLFLDGH QXHYRHOUHFRUULGRKDFLD-RUGLSDViQGROHHODURSDUDTXHORWUDVODGHDOLQLFLRGHODILOD3DUD HOORRFXSDHO~OWLPRUHOHYR /D PDHVWUDHVWiVLJXLHQGRD-RUGL\UHFRUGDQGRODVDGDSWDFLRQHVHQODSULPHUDUHSHWLFLyQ 8QDYH]DVLPLODGDVSRUHOJUXSRHVODDX[LOLDUGH((TXLHQUHDOL]DHOVHJXLPLHQWR $ -RUGL VH OH REVHUYD PX\ SDUWLFLSDWLYR FRQ JUDQ LQWHUpV KDFLD OD HYROXFLyQ GHO MXHJR LQWHUDFWXDQGR FRQVWDQWHPHQWH FRQ VXV FRPSDxHURV GH HTXLSR \ DQLPDQGR D ORV TXH VH GHVSOD]DQ /D DFWLWXG GHO JUXSR KDFLD pO WDPELpQ HV PX\ SRVLWLYD \ GH DFHSWDFLyQ GH ODV DGDSWDFLRQHV 3DUDILQDOL]DUSURSRQHHOMXHJRGH³PDWDU´ /RVMXJDGRUHVVHGLVWULEX\HQHQGRVJUXSRVVHSDUDGRVSRUXQDOtQHDFHQWUDO(OHVSDFLRHVWi GHOLPLWDGR(OREMHWLYRGHOMXHJRHVHOLPLQDUDOHTXLSRFRQWUDULR3DUDHOORFXDQGRVHODQ]DHO EDOyQ GH HVSXPD H LPSDFWD D XQ DGYHUVDULR WRFiQGROR HQ FXDOTXLHU SDUWH FRUSRUDO H[FHSWXDQGR OD FDUD \ FDH SRVWHULRUPHQWH HO EDOyQ DO VXHOR VH FRQVLGHUD PXHUWR eVWH VH GHVSOD]D KDFLD HO H[WUHPR GHO FDPSR GH ORV MXJDGRUHV DGYHUVDULRV GHQRPLQDGD ]RQD GH PXHUWRV \ GHVGH DOOt LQWHQWD ³PDWDU´ D XQ DGYHUVDULR 'H QR FRQVHJXLUOR WLHQH TXH HVSHUDU KDVWDTXHVXVFRPSDxHURVOHSDVHQHOEDOyQRELHQTXHORSXHGDFRQVHJXLUSRUTXHHOEDOyQ KDHQWUDGRDVX]RQDGHMXHJRV &RPRHQODDQWHULRURFDVLyQDFRUGDPRVTXHFXDQGRLQWHQWHQLPSDFWDUFRQHOEDOyQD-RUGL DQWHVWLHQHTXHGDUXQERWHHQHOVXHOR6HOHFRQFHGHWUHVYLGDVWUHVRSRUWXQLGDGHVDQWHV GH SDVDU DO FDPSR GH PXHUWRV SDUD SURORQJDU VX SHUPDQHQFLD HQ HO HVSDFLR GH MXHJR &XDQGRSRVHHHOEDOyQHLQWHQWDODQ]DUORFRQWUDVXVDGYHUVDULRVVHJULWD³VWRS´WHQLHQGRTXH SHUPDQHFHU HVWiWLFRV HQ HO HVSDFLR 6t FRQVLJXH LPSDFWDU FRQ HO EDOyQ D DOJ~Q MXJDGRU VH FRQVLGHUDPXHUWR 5 5 5 5 5 5 /ODPDODDWHQFLyQTXHYDULDVVRQODVYHFHVTXHSXHGHQ³PDWDU´D-RUGLSHURORVDGYHUVDULRV ORHYLWDQ&RQWLQXDPRVSHUFLELHQGRDXQ-RUGLWHPHURVRGHVSOD]iQGRVHWDQVyORSRUHOODWHUDO GHOHVSDFLRLQWHQWDQGRQRFKRFDUFRQQLQJ~QFRPSDxHURDSHVDUGHTXHODDX[LOLDUGH((VH VLW~DSUy[LPRDpOKDFLHQGRVRPEUDFRQODILQDOLGDGGHGDUOHVHJXULGDG\TXHFRPSUXHEH TXHHODGXOWROHSXHGHSUHVHUYDUGHXQDSRVLEOHFDtGD &RPHQWDULRVDODVHVLyQ (V QHFHVDULR WUDEDMDU HQ HO JUXSR HO FRQFHSWR GH GHUHFKRV \ REOLJDFLRQHV UHVSHFWR D OD FRPSHQVDFLyQGHODVOLPLWDFLRQHVHQVLWXDFLRQHVFRPSHWLWLYDV +D VLGR FXULRVD OD DGDSWDFLyQ GHO JUXSR GH ODV QLxDV HQ HO MXHJR GH SDVDU SRU GHEDMR GHO W~QHO1RVKDKHFKRSHQVDUTXHHODXPHQWRGHGLVWDQFLDHQWUHFRPSDxHURVSXHGHVHUXQD EXHQDVROXFLyQ (V QHFHVDULR VHJXLU UHFRUGDQGR D ORV QLxRV TXH SDUD JDQDU QR WLHQHQ TXH DXPHQWDU OD YHORFLGDGGH-RUGLSRUHOULHVJRTXHFRPSRUWDLPSXOVDQGRODVLOODGHUXHGDV 6(6,Ï11 '(129,(0%5('( &RPRVHLQLFLDHOSHUtRGRGHSUHSDUDFLyQGHODMRUQDGDGHMXHJRVPRWRUHVVHQVLELOL]DGRUHV TXHWHQGUiOXJDUHOGtDWUHVGHGLFLHPEUHVHGHGLFDHVWDSULPHUDVHVLyQDODUHVSXHVWDGHGRV FXHVWLRQDULRV TXH UHFRJHQ ODV DFWLWXGHV KDFLD ODV SHUVRQDV FRQ PRYLOLGDG UHGXFLGD \ ODV SHUVRQDV LQYLGHQWHV /ODPD OD DWHQFLyQ OD UHVSXHVWD TXH RPLWH -RUGL UHVSHFWR D OD SULPHUD SUHJXQWDGHOFXHVWLRQDULRUHIHULGDVREUHFXiOVHUtDVXUHDFFLyQVtHQHOSULPHUGtDGHFODVH YLHVHDXQQLxRFLHJR\XQQLxRXVXDULRGHVLOODGHUXHGDV0LHQWUDVTXHHQHOSULPHUFDVR UHVSRQGH TXH SUHJXQWDUtD D ORV RWURV FRPSDxHURV VL VDEHQ TXLpQ HV HQ HO VHJXQGR OH SUHJXQWDUtD FyPR VH OODPD 5HVSHFWR DO UHVWR GH SUHJXQWDV FRQWHVWD PX\ IDYRUDEOHPHQWH UHFRQRFLHQGRORVGHUHFKRV\ODVFDSDFLGDGHVGHDPERVFDVRVLJXDOTXH/RODDORODUJRGH WRGDVODVSUHJXQWDVGHOFXHVWLRQDULR 3DUDILQDOL]DUODVHVLyQVHSUR\HFWDXQYLGHRVREUHORVMXHJRV3DUDOtPSLFRVGH%DUFHORQD (QXQSULQFLSLRXQVHFWRUGHOJUXSRGHORVQLxRVVHPXHVWUDGLVFRQIRUPHFRQODYLVXDOL]DFLyQ GHOYLGHRSRUTXHQRSRGtDQEDMDUDOSDWLRDMXJDU&XDQGRVHOHVUD]RQDVREUHODFRQYHQLHQFLD GH FRQRFHU ODV GLIHUHQWHV PRGDOLGDGHV GHO GHSRUWH DGDSWDGR D ODV SHUVRQDV FRQ GLVFDSDFLGDG VH PRVWUDURQ PiV UHFHSWLYRV GH WDO IRUPD TXH D PHGLGD TXH VH LEDQ PRVWUDQGR ODV LPiJHQHV VH OHV REVHUYDQ VRUSUHQGLGRV PX\ UHFHSWLYRV \ HPLWLHQGR FRQVWDQWHPHQWH H[FODPDFLRQHV GH UHFRQRFLHQGR GH ODV FDSDFLGDGHV 1R REVWDQWH XQ SHTXHxRJUXSRGHWUHVQLxRVVHUtHQHQDOJXQDRFDVLyQUHDOL]DQGRFRPHQWDULRVGHVSHFWLYRV SRUORTXHWHQHPRVTXHLQWHUYHQLUFRQHOILQGHTXHUHIOH[LRQHQVREUHVXFRPSRUWDPLHQWRWDQ LUUHVSHWXRVR 5 5 5 5 7DQWR/RODFRPR-RUGLVHVLHQWHQPX\PRWLYDGRVSRUHOYLGHR$WHQWRVFRQVWDQWHPHQWHDODV LPiJHQHVODSULPHUDVHVRUSUHQGHFXDQGRHQHOWHQLVPHVDVHREVHUYDDXQDMXJDGRUDFRQ DFRQGURSODVLDFRPHQWDQGR³DQGDVLHVLJXDOTXH\R´(QFDPELR-RUGLFXDQGRREVHUYDHO EDORQFHVWRHQVLOODGHUXHGDVFRPHQWDDVXVFRPSDxHURV³\DYHUpLVFXDQGRMXJXHPRVRV GDUpXQDSDOL]D´DQWHWDOFRPHQWDULRODPDHVWUDUHDFFLRQDFRQUDSLGH]SDUDLQGLFDUOHTXHODV GLILFXOWDGHV VRQ SDUD WRGRV GDGR TXH VH WLHQH TXH FRQWURODU OD VLOOD \ HO EDOyQ \ TXH MXVWDPHQWHpOWHQGUiTXHYLJLODUVXDFWXDFLyQSRUTXHGHQRVHUDVtSRGUtDFDHU5HVSHFWRDO UHVWRGHGHSRUWHVORVFRPHQWDULRVWDQWRGH/RODFRPRGH-RUGLVRQFRQVWDQWHV &RPHQWDULRVDODVHVLyQ $SHVDUGHTXHWDQWR/RODFRPR-RUGLHVWiQDFHSWDGRVHQHOJUXSRVHREVHUYDXQSHTXHxR VHFWRUGHODFODVHLUUHVSHWXRVRFRQHOFROHFWLYRGHSHUVRQDVFRQGLVFDSDFLGDG1RREVWDQWH ODPD\RUtDVHSHUFLEHLQWHUHVDGDFRQODLQIRUPDFLyQTXHWUDQVPLWHQODVLPiJHQHVGHOYLGHR &UHR TXH HQ HVWD VHVLyQ DPERV VH KDQ VHQWLGR SRVLWLYDPHQWH SURWDJRQLVWDV UHFRQRFLHQGR TXH OD SUiFWLFD GHSRUWLYD HV SRVLEOH SDUD WRGRV \ WRGDV VLHPSUH \ FXDQGR VH DGDSWHQ ODV PRGDOLGDGHVGHSRUWLYDVDODVFDUDFWHUtVWLFDVGHODVSHUVRQDV (VFXULRVDODUHVSXHVWDGH-RUGLHQHOFXHVWLRQDULRVREUHDFWLWXGHVKDFLDODVSHUVRQDVFLHJDV &yPRHOGHVFRQRFLPLHQWRSXHGHFRQGLFLRQDUVXDFWLWXGWHQLHQGRHQFXHQWDTXHDOSUHVHQWDU XQD PRYLOLGDGUHGXFLGDDSULRULWHQGUtD TXH VHU PiV UHFHSWLYR FRQ HO FROHFWLYR GH SHUVRQDV FRQGLVFDSDFLGDG 6(6,Ï11 '(129,(0%5('( 6HLQLFLDODVHVLyQFRQODSURSXHVWDGHFRUUHUSRUODOtQHDH[WHULRUGHOSDWLR7DQWR/RODFRPR -RUGLDLPDJHQTXHHQVHVLRQHVDQWHULRUHVVHGHVSOD]DQVLJXLHQGRODVOtQHDVGHOFHQWURGHO SDWLRUHGXFLHQGRDVtHOHVSDFLRGHUHFRUULGR 3RVWHULRUPHQWH OD PDHVWUD GD OD FRQVLJQD TXH UHDOLFHQ GLYHUVRV HMHUFLFLRV UHVSLUDWRULRV FRQ GHVSOD]DPLHQWR&RPR-RUGLSUHVHQWDGLILFXOWDGHQFRQWURODUODVLOODGHUXHGDV\HMHFXWDUODV DFWLYLGDGHVGHUHVSLUDFLyQHQXQSULQFLSLRODDX[LOLDUGH((VHGHVSOD]DDOFHQWURGHOSDWLR\ OHGLULJHGLYHUVRVHMHUFLFLRVUHVSLUDWRULRVUHDOL]DQGRGLVWLQWDVHOHYDFLRQHVGHEUD]RV8QDYH] FRQWURODGRVORVHMHUFLFLRV-RUGLLQWHQWDUHDOL]DUORVFRQGHVSOD]DPLHQWRLPSXOVDQGRODVLOODGH UXHGDV \ HQ HO UHFRUULGR HQWUH LPSXOVR H LPSXOVR UHDOL]D YDULDV UHSHWLFLRQHV GH XQ PLVPR HMHUFLFLRUHVSLUDWRULR $FRQWLQXDFLyQSURSRQH³VHJXLUHOULWPR´ (OJUXSRVHVLW~DHQILODLQGLDXQRGHWUiVGHRWUR\HQFLPDGHODVOtQHDVH[WHULRUHVGHOFDPSR (O SURSyVLWR HV HO GH VHJXLU XQ ULWPR FRQVWDQWH GH WDO IRUPD TXH WLHQHQ TXH PDQWHQHU ODV GLVWDQFLDV 5 5 5 5 5 5 5 3DUD/RODHVWDDFWLYLGDGQRSUHVHQWDGLILFXOWDGSHURVtSDUD-RUGLVLWXDGRDOILQDOGHODILOD1R SXHGH PDQWHQHU OD GLVWDQFLD FRQ HO FRPSDxHUR GH GHODQWH GH WDO IRUPD TXH OOHJD XQ PRPHQWRTXHHOSULPHURGHODILODORDOFDQ]D\HVHQHVHPRPHQWRFXDQGRODPDHVWUDGDSRU ILQDOL]DGDODSURSXHVWD 3URVLJXHODVHVLyQFRQHO³MXHJRGHODVFXDWURHVTXLQDV´ 6HRUJDQL]DQJUXSRVGHFLQFR&DGDXQRVLWXDGRHQXQH[WUHPRGHXQFXDGUDGRGHXQRV PHWURVGHODGR&XDQGRODPDHVWUDGDODFRQVLJQDGHIRUPDDOWHUQDWLYDORVGRVJUXSRVTXH FRQIRUPDQXQDGLDJRQDOWLHQHQTXHFDPELDUGHOXJDULQWHQWDQGRQRFKRFDU&DGDJUXSRWLHQH TXHVHJXLUHOPLVPRULWPRGHFDUUHUD /DV YDULDQWHV TXH VH SURSRQHQ VRQ TXH FDPELHQ ORV FXDWUR JUXSRV D OD YH] VLJXLHQGR OD GLDJRQDOGHOFDPSR\DFRQWLQXDFLyQWLHQHQTXHFDPELDUHQVHQWLGRGHODVDJXMDVGHOUHORM FRQHOJUXSRTXHWLHQHQGHODQWH (QHVWDRFDVLyQODPDHVWUDLQGLFDTXHORVJUXSRVVHRUJDQLFHQOLEUHPHQWH&XDQGR-RUGLVH VLW~D HQ HOJUXSRGHXQRGHVXVDPLJRVpVWHOHFXHVWLRQDVXSUHVHQFLDFRPHQWiQGROHTXH ³VLHPSUH WLHQHV TXH YHQLU FRQ QRVRWURV´ $QWH WDO UHDFFLyQ XQ MXJDGRU GH RWUR JUXSR FRQIRUPDGR SRU YDURQHV OR UHFODPD \ -RUGL UHDFFLRQD GLFLHQGR ³EXHQR´ GHVSOD]iQGRVH DO RWURJUXSRVLQPRVWUDUFRQWUDULHGDGDOJXQD $QWHODGLILFXOWDGGHVHJXLUHOULWPRGHVXVFRPSDxHURVODPDHVWUDSURSRQHTXH-RUGLVHVLW~H DGRVWHUFLRVGHOUHFRUULGRUHVSHFWRDVXJUXSRFRQHOREMHWRGHTXHSXHGDQOOHJDUDODYH] 3HUR DQWH WDO DGDSWDFLyQ /ROD UHFODPD TXH WDPELpQ HV QHFHVDULR UHGXFLU VX GLVWDQFLD GH UHFRUULGR/DPDHVWUDUHFRJHVXREVHUYDFLyQLQGLFiQGROHTXHVHVLW~HDXQWHUFLRGHGLVWDQFLD UHVSHFWR D VX JUXSR $PEDV DGDSWDFLRQHV VRQ ODV DGHFXDGDV D OD YHORFLGDG GH VXV FRPSDxHURV (OVLJXLHQWHMXHJRHVHOGH³GHQWUR\IXHUD´ (OJUXSRVHGLVWULEX\HHQFtUFXORDOUHGHGRUGHODVOtQHDVGHOFHQWURGHODSLVWDGHEiVTXHW(Q XQSULQFLSLRHVWiQDXQRVWUHLQWDFHQWtPHWURVGHGLVWDQFLDGHODOtQHDGHOFtUFXOR&XDQGRGDOD FRQVLJQD GH ³GHQWUR´ ORV MXJDGRUHV WLHQHQ TXH UHDOL]DU XQ VDOWR \ HQWUDU HQ HO LQWHULRU GHO FtUFXORGHWDOIRUPDTXHGHEHQUHDFFLRQDUUiSLGDPHQWHDQWHODVVXFHVLYDVFRQVLJQDV³GHQWUR IXHUD´ /DYDULDQWHTXHSURSRQHHVTXHORVVDOWRVVRQODWHUDOHV 3DUD/RODUHGXFHODGLVWDQFLDGHVDOWRDXQFLQFXHQWDSRUFLHQWR$-RUGLDOQRSRGHUVDOWDUOH DVLJQDHOUROGHiUELWURWHQLHQGRTXHREVHUYDUORVMXJDGRUHVTXHVHHTXLYRFDQ7UDQVFXUULGDV YDULDV UHSHWLFLRQHV/RODFRPHQWDDOD PDHVWUD TXH HVWi FDQVDGD \ VL SXHGHFRPSDUWLUFRQ -RUGLHODUELWUDMH$DPERVVHOHVREVHUYDPRWLYDGRVSRUHOUROGHiUELWURV\HOUHVWRGHOJUXSR ORDFHSWDFRQWRWDOQRUPDOLGDG (ODQWHSHQ~OWLPRMXHJRHVXQDYDULDQWHGHODVFXDWURHVTXLQDVSUDFWLFDGRDQWHULRUPHQWH $XPHQWDODGLVWDQFLDGHODGRGHOFXDGUDGRDXQRVTXLQFHPHWURV/RVJUXSRVGLVWULEXLGRVSRU FDGDH[WUHPR&XDQGRGDODVHxDOVHWLHQHQTXHGHVSOD]DUDOFHQWURGHOFXDGUDGRVLJXLHQGR HO ULWPR GHO JUXSR \ FRQ HO REMHWLYR GH OOHJDU DO FHQWUR IUHQDU \ QR FKRFDU FRQ QLQJ~Q RWUR 5 5 5 5 5 5 5 MXJDGRU /DPDHVWUDVLJXHFRQHOPLVPRFULWHULRGHUHGXFLUODGLVWDQFLDGHUHFRUULGRWDQWRGH/RODFRPR GH -RUGL 6H REVHUYD D HVWH ~OWLPR WHPHURVR VLQ DOFDQ]DU QXQFD HO FHQWUR GHO HVSDFLR SRU PLHGRDFKRFDUFRQDOJ~QFRPSDxHUR\FDHU /DSHQ~OWLPDDFWLYLGDGHVHO³MXHJRGHODWUHQ]D´ /D FODVH GLVWULEXLGD HQ GRV JUXSRV &DGD XQR VH FRJH GH OD PDQR IRUPDQGR XQD OtQHD (O MXJDGRU GHXQH[WUHPRLQLFLDODPDUFKD\HOUHVWRORVLJXHVLQVROWDUVHODVPDQRV'HHVWD IRUPDGLULJHDOJUXSRKDVWDHO³W~QHO´TXHIRUPDQODVPDQRVGHOSULPHU\VHJXQGRMXJDGRUGHO RWURH[WUHPR\DVtVXFHVLYDPHQWHSDVDUiHQWUHHOVHJXQGR\WHUFHURKDVWDOOHJDUDOILQDO ¢&XiOGHORVJUXSRVILQDOL]DDQWHV" /RODVLJXHODDFWLYLGDGVLQGLILFXOWDGWRGRORFRQWUDULRTXH-RUGL7UDVYDULDVDGDSWDFLRQHVTXH UHDOL]DODPDHVWUDSRUHQVD\R\HUURUVHGHFOLQDSRUTXHVHVLW~HHQHOH[WUHPRLQLFLDQGROD PDUFKD GHO JUXSR VLQ HVWDU FRJLGR GH ODV PDQRV GH VXV FRPSDxHURV \ SDVDQGR HQWUH HO ³W~QHO´ GHO SULPHU \ VHJXQGR MXJDGRU GH WDO PDQHUD TXH PLHQWUDV pVWRV YDQ UHDOL]DQGR OD WUHQ]D-RUGLGDXQDYXHOWDDOUHGHGRUGHWRGRHOJUXSRLQWHQWDGRFRLQFLGLUODYXHOWDFRPSOHWD FRQODILQDOL]DFLyQGHODWUHQ]D )LQDOL]DFRQHOMXHJRGH³PDWDU´ /RVMXJDGRUHVVHGLVWULEX\HQHQGRVJUXSRVVHSDUDGRVSRUXQDOtQHDFHQWUDO(OHVSDFLR HVWi GHOLPLWDGR (O REMHWLYR GHO MXHJR HV HOLPLQDU DO HTXLSR FRQWUDULR 3DUD HOOR FXDQGR VH ODQ]DHOEDOyQGHHVSXPDHLPSDFWDDXQDGYHUVDULRWRFiQGRORHQFXDOTXLHUSDUWHFRUSRUDO H[FHSWXDQGR OD FDUD \ FDH SRVWHULRUPHQWH HO EDOyQ DO VXHOR VH FRQVLGHUD PXHUWR eVWH VH GHVSOD]D KDFLD HO H[WUHPR GHO FDPSR GH ORV MXJDGRUHV DGYHUVDULRV GHQRPLQDGD ]RQD GH PXHUWRV \ GHVGH DOOt LQWHQWD ³PDWDU´ D XQ DGYHUVDULR 'H QR FRQVHJXLUOR WLHQH TXH HVSHUDU KDVWDTXHVXVFRPSDxHURVOHSDVHQHOEDOyQRELHQTXHORSXHGDFRQVHJXLUSRUTXHHOEDOyQ KDHQWUDGRDVX]RQDGHMXHJRV /DVDGDSWDFLRQHVSDUD/ROD\-RUGLVRQODVPLVPDVTXHHQVHVLRQHVDQWHULRUHV &XDQGRLQWHQWDQLPSDFWDUFRQHOEDOyQD-RUGLDQWHVWLHQHTXHGDUXQERWHHQHOVXHOR6HOHV FRQFHGHQWUHVYLGDVWUHVRSRUWXQLGDGHVDQWHVGHSDVDUDOFDPSRGHPXHUWRVSDUDSURORQJDU ODSHUPDQHQFLDGHDPERVHQHOHVSDFLRGHMXHJR&XDQGRSRVHHQHOEDOyQHLQWHQWDQODQ]DUOR FRQWUDVXVDGYHUVDULRVVHJULWD³VWRS´R³SLHVTXLHWRV´WHQLHQGRTXHSHUPDQHFHUHVWiWLFRVHQ HOHVSDFLR6tFRQVLJXHQLPSDFWDUFRQHOEDOyQDDOJ~QMXJDGRUVHFRQVLGHUDPXHUWR &RPR-RUGLWLHQHQGLILFXOWDGSDUDODQ]DUHOEDOyQHLPSDFWDUDXQFRPSDxHURVHOHSHUPLWH TXHWLUHHOEDOyQURGDQGRSRUHOVXHOR\VtHQVXUHFRUULGRWRFDDXQDGYHUVDULRVHFRQVLGHUD PXHUWR$GLIHUHQFLDGHODVRWUDVRFDVLRQHVPLHQWUDVTXHDOD/RODVXVFRPSDxHUDVOHWLHQHQ TXH SDVDU OD SHORWD SRU WXUQR D -RUGL VH OD SDVDQ FDGD WUHV YHFHV TXH ODQ]DQ VXV FRPSDxHURV \ FXDQGR RFXUUH HO FDSLWiQ GH MXHJR GH VX HTXLSR JULWD ³SLHV TXLHWRV´ (VWD DGDSWDFLyQSURYRFDFHORVDOFRPSDxHURGH-RUGLPiVDYHQWDMDGRFRPHQWDQGRTXHSUHILHUH TXHORPDWHQ\DVtSDVDUDOFDPSRGHPXHUWRVSRUTXHSRGUiGLVSRQHUPiVYHFHVGHOEDOyQ 5 5 5 5 5 /DPDHVWUDWLHQHTXHLQWHUYHQLUSDUDKDFHUOHFRPSUHQGHUODQHFHVLGDGGHODVDGDSWDFLRQHV $GHVWDFDUFRPRSURJUHVLYDPHQWH-RUGLYDJDQDQGRFRQILDQ]D\YDRFXSDQGROD]RQDFHQWUDO GHOFDPSRGHMXHJRFRQVLJXLHQGRUHGXFLUGRVYLGDVD/ROD\PDWDUDXQDGYHUVDULR&XDQGR ILQDOL]DODVHVLyQ\OHSUHJXQWDPRVODDX[LOLDUGH((\\RFyPRVHORKDSDVDGRFRQWHVWDTXH ³PX\ ELHQ´ SRUTXH KD FRQVHJXLGR ³PDWDU´ \ TXH \D WLHQH OD PLVPD FRQILDQ]D TXH FXDQGR MXJDEDDODSHORWDFD]DGRUDDQWHVGHODFDtGD &RPHQWDULRVDODVHVLyQ $SHVDUGHTXHD-RUGLVHOHKDGDGRPiVRSRUWXQLGDGHVTXHDOUHVWRGHFRPSDxHURVHQHO MXHJR GH PDWDU SDUD ODQ]DU OD SHORWD DO FDPSR FRQWUDULR KD VLGR HILFD] SRUTXH VH KD GHPRVWUDGRTXHpOSRGtDVHUHIHFWLYRJDQDQGRGHQXHYRFRQILDQ]DHQVtPLVPR (V LQWHUHVDQWH UHJLVWUDU TXH DSDUHQWHPHQWH HQ JHQHUDO DFHSWD HO JUXSR ODV DGDSWDFLRQHV UHIHULGDVDODFRPSHQVDFLyQGHODVOLPLWDFLRQHVHQVLWXDFLRQHVFRPSHWLWLYDV 7DPELpQ HV LQWHUHVDQWH DQRWDU FyPR OD PDHVWUD KD LQWHQWDGR EXVFDU OD DGDSWDFLyQ PiV RSRUWXQDSDUD-RUGLHQHOMXHJRGHODWUHQ]D7UDVYDULDVSURSXHVWDV\HQEDVHGHOUHVXOWDGR KDLGRDMXVWDQGRODDGDSWDFLyQ/DDFWLWXGGHODFODVHKDVLGRUHVSHWXRVDHQWRGRHOSURFHVR VLQREVHUYDUVHQLQJXQDDFWLWXGFRQWUDULDDODE~VTXHGDPiVLGyQHDGHODDGDSWDFLyQ 5 5 5 5 6(6,Ï11 6(6,Ï11 '(129,(0%5('( &RPRHVWDVHVLyQFRLQFLGHFRQODMRUQDGDGHMXHJRVPRWRUHVVHQVLELOL]DGRUHVTXHRUJDQL]R HQHOFHQWURHVFRODUQ~PHURQRSXHGRUHJLVWUDUORDFRQWHFLGR '(129,(0%5('( /DVHVLyQODSURWDJRQL]D/DLD$UPHQJROTXHHVPDHVWUDHQ(GXFDFLyQ(VSHFLDOHVWXGLDQWH GHSVLFRSHGDJRJtDWUDEDMDHQXQDDVRFLDFLyQYLQFXODGDFRQODGLVFDSDFLGDGPRWUL]\DGHPiV HVXVXDULDGHPXOHWDV (OREMHWLYRGHVXSUHVHQFLDHVHOGHIDFLOLWDUXQHVSDFLRGHUHIOH[LyQVREUHODVOLPLWDFLRQHV\ ODV FDSDFLGDGHV GH ODV SHUVRQDV FRQ GLVFDSDFLGDG 3DUD HOOR LQLFLD OD VHVLyQ FRQ OD SUR\HFFLyQGHXQYtGHRHQHOTXHVHSUHVHQWDQGLYHUVDVH[SHULHQFLDVGHLQWHJUDFLyQHVFRODU $SDUWLUGHDKtVHLQLFLDXQGHEDWHGRQGHVHUHFRJHQODVLQTXLHWXGHVGHOJUXSRFODVH 2EVHUYR D XQ -RUGL PX\ DWHQWR D OD HYROXFLyQ GH OD VHVLyQ 6X FDUD HV PX\ GHVFULSWLYD UHIOHMDQGRHOLQWHUpVSRUHOFRQWHQLGRGHODVHVLyQ1RREVWDQWHWDQWR/RODFRPRHOUHVWRGHO JUXSRWDPELpQVHOHVSHUFLEHPX\LQWHUHVDGRVSHQGLHQWHVGHODVLPiJHQHVGHOYtGHR\GHODV DSRUWDFLRQHVGH/DLD 5 5 5 0HOODPDODDWHQFLyQODUHDFFLyQGH-RUGLFXDQGRVHSUR\HFWDQXQDVLPiJHQHVGHQLxRVFRQ GLVFDSDFLGDG LQWHOHFWXDO 6H UtH \ EXVFD OD FRPSOLFLGDG GH ORV FRPSDxHURV PiV SUy[LPRV PHGLDQWHODPLUDGDFRQHOILQGHWUDQVPLWLUOHVVXULVD &XDQGR KHPRV SUHJXQWDGR OD UD]yQ SRU OD TXH XQRV QLxRV VH KDQ UHtGR FXDQGR VH SUR\HFWDEDQHVDVLPiJHQHV-RUGLKDFRQWHVWDGRHQEDMLWR³SRUTXHHUDQVXEQRUPDOHV´$QWH WDOUHVSXHVWDKHPRVDSURYHFKDGRSDUDLQIRUPDUOHVVREUHODWHUPLQRORJtDUHVSHWXRVD\KHPRV IDFLOLWDGR HOHPHQWRV GH UHIOH[LyQ UHVSHFWR DO FRQFHSWR GH QRUPDOL]DFLyQ 3RVWHULRUPHQWH LQWHUYLHQHODPDHVWUDGLFLHQGRD-RUGLTXHVXUHVSXHVWDHVWRWDOPHQWHLUUHVSHWXRVDLQFLGLHQGR HQTXHSLHQVHTXHpOWLHQHXQDGLVFDSDFLGDGPRWUL]\TXHHVWiDFHSWDGRHQHOFHQWURSHUR TXH SUREDEOHPHQWH VH SXHGH HQFRQWUDU FRQ QLxRV GH RWURV FHQWURV HVFRODUHV TXH SRU GHVFRQRFLPLHQWRSXHGHQUHtUVHGHpO$GHPiVDUJXPHQWDODVDGDSWDFLRQHVTXHVHUHDOL]DQ SDUD TXHSXHGDWHQHUXQDSDUWLFLSDFLyQ DFWLYD HQ OD VHVLyQ GH (GXFDFLyQ )tVLFD \ TXHSRU GHVJUDFLDQRHQWRGRVORVFHQWURVVHYDDHQFRQWUDUFRQHVWDUHDOLGDG-RUGLDVLHQWHFRQOD FDEH]D\QRUHDOL]DQLQJ~QRWURFRPHQWDULRDOUHVSHFWR /DLD LQWHUYLHQH FRPHQWDQGR DO JUXSR TXH SUREDEOHPHQWH VL QR HVWXYLHUDQ DFRVWXPEUDGRV D FRPSDUWLU OD HVFRODULGDG FRQ /ROD OHV VRUSUHQGHUtDQ DO HQFRQWUDUVH SRU SULPHUD YH] D XQD SHUVRQDGHFDUDFWHUtVWLFDVVLPLODUHV/RODDFHSWDHVWDREVHUYDFLyQFRQWRWDOQRUPDOLGDG 3RVWHULRUPHQWHVRQYDULDVODVLQWHUYHQFLRQHVGHOJUXSRFODVHVLHPSUHDWHQWRDODVUHVSXHVWDV GH/DLDFRQFOX\pQGRVHTXHWRGRV\WRGDVVRPRVGLIHUHQWHV\TXHHVQHFHVDULRHOUHVSHWRD ODGLIHUHQFLD 6(6,Ï11 '(129,(0%5('( $OHVWDUSUy[LPRVDODMRUQDGDGHVHQVLELOL]DFLyQTXHWHQGUiOXJDUHOGtDGHGLFLHPEUHVH DSURYHFKDQ ODV VLOODV GH UXHGDV SDUD LQLFLDU OD YLYHQFLDFLyQ \ OD VLPXODFLyQ GH XQD GLVFDSDFLGDG(VSRUHOORTXHODVHVLyQJLUDDOUHGHGRUGHOGRPLQLRGHODVLOODGHUXHGDV\FRQ WDOILQSURSRQHPRVORVVLJXLHQWHVMXHJRV 2FXSDUOLEUHPHQWHHOHVSDFLR\DODVHxDOWRFDUXQREMHWRXQFRORUXQD SDUWH FRUSRUDO VLHPSUH FRQ UHVSHFWR D ORV GHPiV D ORV REMHWRV \ DO HVSDFLR $ WRFDU D ORV FRPSDxHURV TXH QR WLHQHQ VLOOD &LQFR GHO JUXSR VH GHVSOD]DQVLQVLOODGHUXHGDV\HOUHVWRWLHQHQTXHLQWHQWDUWRFDUOHV(QHO PRPHQWRTXHORFRQVLJXHQVHFDPELDQORVUROHV 6WRS3DUDQWUHVFRPSDxHURVLGHQWLILFiQGROHVFRQXQSDxXHOR(OREMHWLYR GHpVWRVHVHOGHPRYLOL]DUDWRGRHOJUXSRFODVHLQWHQWDQGRWRFDUOHV$O VHU WRFDGRV WLHQHQ TXH TXHGDUVH HVWiWLFRV FRQ ORV EUD]RV HQ FUX] (O UHVWRGHFRPSDxHURVSXHGHQVDOYDUORVVLVHDSUR[LPDQDHOORV\OHGDQ XQDSDOPDGDHQHOGRUVRGHODPDQRVLQKDEHUVLGRWRFDGRVSRUORVTXH SDUDQ 8QGRVWUHVSLFDSDUHG8QFRPSDxHURHVHOTXHSDUDVLWXDGRGHODQWH GHXQDSDUHG(OUHVWR SDUWLUi GH XQD OtQHDGHOFDPSRTXHHVWiDXQRV TXLQFHPHWURV&XDQGRHODOXPQRTXHSDUDJROSHDVXDYHPHQWHODSDUHG 5 5 5 5 5 \DODYH]JULWD³XQGRVWUHVSLFDSDUHG´HOUHVWRGHFRPSDxHURVDYDQ]DQ HO Pi[LPR HVSDFLR LQWHQWDGR TXHGDUVH HVWiWLFRV DO ILQDOL]DU OD IUDVH &XDQGR HO TXH SDUD VH JLUD \ REVHUYD TXH VH PXHYH DOJXQR GH HOORV LQGLFDHOQRPEUH\pVWHWLHQHTXHUHJUHVDUDODOtQHDGHLQLFLR(OREMHWLYR GHORVMXJDGRUHVGHFDPSRHVHOGHVHUHOSULPHURHQWRFDUDOTXHSDUD (OMXJDGRUPiVGLVWDQFLDGRHVHOTXHSDUDHQODSUy[LPDUHSHWLFLyQ $EXVFDUODVLOOD7RGRHOJUXSRDXQDGLVWDQFLDGHXQRVTXLQFHPHWURVGH ODV VLOODV GH UXHGDV $ OD VHxDO WLHQHQ TXH WRFDU XQD VLOOD VXELUVH \ UHJUHVDUDOSXQWRGHLQLFLR 7DQWR /ROD FRPR -RUGL SDUWLFLSDQ PX\ DFWLYDPHQWH GH HVWD VHVLyQ 6H OHV SHUFLEH PX\ PRWLYDGRV SRU ODV SURSXHVWDV (Q QLQJ~Q PRPHQWR VH KD REVHUYDGR FRQIOLFWR DOJXQR UHVDOWDQGRODFRQWLQXDLQWHUDFFLyQGHDPERVFRQVXVFRPSDxHURV1RREVWDQWHUHVDOWRHODOWR tQGLFHGHFRPSHWLWLYLGDGREVHUYDGRHQ-RUGL &RPHQWDULRVDODVHVLyQ 3RUODFRQYHUVDFLyQPDQWHQLGDFRQ/RODVHGHVSUHQGHVXJUDQLQWHUpVSRUODSUiFWLFDGHKR\ FRQILUPDQGRTXH³VHORKDSDVDGRPX\ELHQSRUTXHMXJDED´<FXDQGROHSUHJXQWRTXpOHKD SDUHFLGRHOKHFKRTXHVXVFRPSDxHURVVHVLHQWHQHQVLOODGHUXHGDVFRQWHVWD³TXHOHSDUHFH PX\ELHQSRUTXHDVtFRPSUXHEDQORGLItFLOTXHHVLUHQVLOOD´ 5HVSHFWR D -RUGL KHPRV FRLQFLGLGR MXQWR FRQ OD PDHVWUD \ OD DX[LOLDU GH (( TXH QR WLHQH FRQFLHQFLD GH VX OLPLWDFLyQ 1RV VRUSUHQGHQ H[FODPDFLRQHV FRPR ³DKRUD QRV WRFD VHU SDUDOtWLFRV´2EVHUYDPRVDXQ-RUGLPX\FRPSHWLWLYRLQWHQWDQGRPHGLUVHFRQVWDQWHPHQWHFRQ VXV FRPSDxHURV $ SHVDU GH VX GRPLQLR SHUFLELPRV TXH QR OOHJD D VHU HO SULPHUR HQ GHWHUPLQDGRV MXHJRV OR TXH OH SURYRFD UDELD 6H GD FXHQWD TXH VXV FRPSDxHURV DO WHQHU PiV IXHU]D SXHGHQ WHQHU PiV PRYLOLGDG TXH pO /D DX[LOLDU GH (( OH UHFXHUGD FRQVWDQWHPHQWHTXHODVHVLyQGHKR\YHUVDVREUHORVMXHJRVPRWRUHVVHQVLELOL]DGRUHV\TXH HOREMHWLYRQRHVHOGHJDQDU&RQVLGHURTXHHVGHLQWHUpVDGMXQWDUHOFRQWHQLGRGHODVGRV FRQYHUVDFLRQHVPDQWHQLGRFRQpOUHVSHFWRDODVHVLyQ &XDQGROHSUHJXQWRVREUHODH[SHULHQFLDPHFRPHQWDTXH³OHKDJXVWDGRPXFKRSRUTXHVXV FRPSDxHURV LEDQ HQ VLOOD GH UXHGDV´ SHUR DO GHFLUOH GH TXp VL SHQVDED TXH WRGRV KDQ DSUHQGLGRODVGLILFXOWDGHVFRQWHVWDTXH³VtPHQRV3HUH´&RLQFLGHTXH3HUHHVHOFRPSDxHUR GHFODVHTXHPHMRUGRPLQLR\FRQWUROKDWHQLGRGHODVLOODGHUXHGDV 3RVWHULRUPHQWH OD DX[LOLDU GH (( LQWHQWD UHFDEDU PiV GDWRV UHVSHFWR DO FRPHQWDULR HPLWLGR ³VRPRV SDUDOtWLFRV´\OHFRQWHVWDTXHSRUTXH³QRPRYtDQODVSLHUQDV\SDUHFtDQSDUDOtWLFRV´ DFRPSDxiQGRVH GH ULVDV $QWH WDO UHDFFLyQ OH GLFH TXH Vt LQWHUSUHWD TXH VH UtH GH ODV SHUVRQDV FRQ PRYLOLGDG UHGXFLGD \ OH UHVSRQGH ³QR KRPEUH \R VR\ EXHQR QR´ 3RVWHULRUPHQWHDxDGHTXHSHQVDEDTXHVXVFRPSDxHURVQRGRPLQDUtDQODVLOODGHUXHGDV\ TXHOHVWHQGUtDTXHHQVHxDU3HURODKDQGRPLQDGRELHQ³0HKDGDGRXQSRFRGHUDELDQR SRGHUKDFHUGHSURIH´&RQILUPDTXHOHKDJXVWDGRPXFKRODVHVLyQSRUTXH³LEDQHQVLOODGH UXHGDV´\TXHKDTXHGDGRHQ³HPSDWHFRQ3HUH\TXHKDJDQDGRD/XLVVtKXELHVHSHUGLGR PHKXELHUDVDELGRUHDOPHQWHPX\PDO´ $OSURIXQGL]DUFRQODDX[LOLDUGH((UHVSHFWRDOFRPSRUWDPLHQWRGH-RUGLPHFRPHQWDTXHOH 5 5 5 REVHUYDTXHKDDXPHQWDGRVXLQWROHUDQFLDTXHHVLUUHVSHWXRVRTXHQRUHFRQRFHORVOtPLWHV \TXHHQRFDVLRQHVHVPX\LPSHUWLQHQWHWDQWRFRQHODGXOWRFRPRFRQVXVLJXDOHV2EVHUYD TXHDQWHWDODFWLWXGVXVFRPSDxHURVQRHVWiQWDQSHQGLHQWHVGHpO\HOORSURYRFDXQPD\RU DLVODPLHQWRHQHOJUXSRFODVH 6(6,Ï11 '(',&,(0%5('( -RUGL DVLVWH FRQ YHLQWH PLQXWRV GH UHWUDVR (QWUH WDQWR /ROD SDUWLFLSD D LJXDO TXH VXV FRPSDxHURVGHODSULPHUDDFWLYLGDG³ODFDUUHUDHQWUHEDQFRV´ 'HVSOD]DUVH HQ FDUUHUD DOUHGHGRU GH ORV EDQFRV VLWXDGRV HQ FtUFXOR HQ HO FHQWUR GHO JLPQDVLR3RVWHULRUPHQWHSURSRQHGLIHUHQWHVWLSRVGHGHVSOD]DPLHQWRV 3HURFRPRHOUHVWRGHDFWLYLGDGHVJLUDQDOUHGHGRUGHGLVWLQWRVVDOWRVHQWUHEDQFRVWDQWR/ROD FRPR -RUGL QR SXHGHQ SDUWLFLSDU 6H GD OD DQRPDOtD TXH OD DX[LOLDU GH (( GHVFRQRFtD HO FDPELR GH KRUDULR GH ORV OXQHV SDVDQGR OD VHVLyQ D ODV QXHYH GH OD PDxDQD SRU GLVSRQLELOLGDGGHOJLPQDVLRUHVXOWiQGROHLQFRPSDWLEOHHODSR\RGH-RUGLFRQHOGHRWURDOXPQR GHOFHQWURHVFRODU3RUWDQWRDVXPRHQHVWDRFDVLyQHODSR\RGLUHFWRDDPERV /DDGDSWDFLyQTXHUHDOL]RHVODTXHVLJXH &XDWUR FRQRV HQ OtQHD \ D XQD GLVWDQFLD GH XQ PHWUR \ PHGLR HQWUH HOORV $O ILQDOL]DU HO UHFRUULGR GHOLPLWR XQ FXDGUDGR GH GRV PHWURV SRU GRV 7DQWR /ROD FRPR -RUGL WLHQHQ TXH GHVSOD]DUVH KDFLD GHODQWH HQWUH ORV FRQRV OOHJDU DO UHFWiQJXOR \ UHDOL]DU XQ JLUR GH WUHVFLHQWRV VHVHQWD JUDGRV VDOLU GH DOOt \ YROYHU DO SXQWR GH LQLFLR 3RVWHULRUPHQWH YDUtR OD GLUHFFLyQ GH GHVSOD]DPLHQWR H LQFRUSRUR SDUD /ROD HQ FXDWUR RFDVLRQHV XQRV ]DQFRV GH LQLFLDFLyQ ËGHPERWDQGRXQDSHORWD 2EVHUYR TXH DPERV VH PRWLYDQ SRU OD SURSXHVWD \ IUHFXHQWHPHQWH LQWHUDFFLRQDQ FRQ ORV FRPSDxHURVPiVSUy[LPRVTXHHVWiQHQODFROD 3RVWHULRUPHQWHSURSRQJR 8QRDOODGRGHRWURDXQPHWUR\PHGLRGHGLVWDQFLDGHODSDUHG7LHQHQTXHLQWHQWDUVXPDU HOPi[LPRQ~PHURGHSDVHVHQWUHDPERVVLQTXHVHGHVFRQWUROHHOEDOyQ0i[LPRSXHGHGDU XQERWHHQHOVXHOR6HHPSLH]DFRQODPDQRGHUHFKD\VHFRQWLQ~DFRQODL]TXLHUGD 3DUDILQDOL]DU 8QRDGLVWDQFLDGHORWURDXQRVGRVPHWURV7LHQHQTXHUHDOL]DUSDVHVFRQGHVSOD]DPLHQWRHQ OtQHDUHFWD6HMXHJDFRQODYDULDFLyQGHOERWHVLQERWHPDQRGHUHFKD\PDQRL]TXLHUGD 7DQWR/RODFRPR-RUGLSUHVHQWDQPD\RUGLILFXOWDGFXDQGRWLHQHQTXHPDQLSXODURGHVSOD]DU XQ EDOyQ FRQ OD PDQR L]TXLHUGD DXPHQWiQGRVH D pVWH ~OWLPR FXDQGR OD VLOOD HVWi HQ PRYLPLHQWR 5 5 5 5 5 5 $OSUHJXQWDUOHVTXpOHVKDSDUHFLGRODVHVLyQ\TXpKDQDSUHQGLGRFRLQFLGHQTXH³VHORKDQ SDVDGRPX\ELHQ´\³TXHKDQFRPSUREDGRTXHFRQHOEUD]RL]TXLHUGRODGLILFXOWDGHVPD\RU´ &RPHQWDULRVDODVHVLyQ $ SHVDU GH TXH VH KD WHQLGR TXH UHDOL]DU XQD SURSXHVWD PiV LQGLYLGXDOL]DGD \ D VX YH] PHQRV VRFLDOL]DQWH FRQ HO JUXSR DPERV KDQ SDUWLFLSDGR PX\ DFWLYDPHQWH VRQULHQWHV JHQHUiQGRVHXQDH[FHOHQWHLQWHUUHODFLyQHQWUHHOORV\FRQORVFRPSDxHURVSUy[LPRVDOD]RQD GHMXHJR 6(6,Ï11 '(',&,(0%5('( 6HGDODFLUFXQVWDQFLDTXHWDQVyORDVLVWHQQXHYHDOXPQRVDODFODVHHOUHVWRHVWiFRQJULSH\ HQWUHpVWRV-RUGL$VtPLVPRODPDHVWUDHVWiGHEDMD\SRUWDQWRTXLHQLPSDUWHODVHVLyQHV XQDPDHVWUDVXVWLWXWD /DSULPHUDSURSXHVWDTXHUHDOL]DHVODGH³VDFDUODFRODDO]RUUR´ 7RGR HO JUXSR H[FHSWR WUHV FRQ OD FXHUGD FRJLGD GHQWUR GHO SDQWDOyQ SRU HO WUDVHUR VLPXODQGRXQDFROD$ODVHxDOORVTXHQRWLHQHQFXHUGDWLHQHQTXHLQWHQWDUSLVDUODFRODGH ORVRWURVFRPSDxHURV(QHOPRPHQWRTXHORFRQVLJXHQVHFDPELDQORVUROHV /RODSDUWLFLSDVLQGLILFXOWDGREVHUYiQGROHDODPDHVWUDTXHSDUDMXJDUOHUHFRUWHODFXHUGD $FRQWLQXDFLyQODPDHVWUDLQGLFDTXHMXHJXHQD³HTXLOLEULRVHQODFXHUGD´ &DGD GRV FRQ XQD FXHUGD HQ HO VXHOR VLWXiQGRVH HQ XQ H[WUHPR 'HVFDO]RV WLHQHQ TXH GHVSOD]DUVHDORODUJRGHODFXHUGDDQGDQGRKDFLDGHODQWHËGHPKDFLDDWUiV /DYDULDQWHTXHUHDOL]DHVTXHVHVLW~HQHQFDGDH[WUHPRGHODFXHUGD/RVGRVMXJDGRUHVD ODYH]VHGHVSOD]DQKDFLDGHODQWHDOFRLQFLGLUHQHOUHFRUULGRWLHQHQTXHFRQWLQXDUODGLUHFFLyQ VLQWRFDUFRQORVSLHVHQHOVXHORFRJLpQGRVHSRUHOWURQFRSDUDIDFLOLWDUHOSDVR\FRQWLQXDUOD PDUFKD 3DUDILQDOL]DUODVHVLyQSURSRQH³VDOWRVDODFXHUGD´ &DGDWUHVFRQXQDFXHUGDWLHQHQTXHUHDOL]DUGLIHUHQWHVWLSRVGHVDOWRV'RVGHHOORVGDQDOD FXHUGD\HOWHUFHURUHDOL]DVDOWRVVHJ~QGLYHUVRVMXHJRVSRSXODUHV &RPR /ROD WLHQH FRQWUDLQGLFDGRV ORV VDOWRV OH DGDSWDPRV OD DFWLYLGDG WHQLHQGR TXH SDVDU IURQWDOPHQWH SRU GHEDMR GH OD FXHUGD VLQ WRFDUOD ËGHP SHUR DxDGLHQGR GRV FXHUGDV GLVWDQFLDGDVDXQPHWUR\PHGLRWDQWR/RODFRPRHOUHVWRGHFRPSDxHURVWLHQHQTXHLQWHQWDU SDVDU SRU ODV FXHUGDV GH IRUPD FRRUGLQDGD VLQ WRFDU QLQJXQD GH HOODV /D YDULDQWH TXH UHDOL]DPRVHVHOGHDXPHQWDUHOQ~PHURGHFRPSRQHQWHVTXHSDVDQDODYH]SRUGHEDMRGH ODVFXHUGDV\FRJLGRVSRUODVPDQRV 5 5 5 5 5 5 5 5 (QXQSULQFLSLR/RODVHPXHVWUDGHVFRQWHQWDFRQODDGDSWDFLyQSRUTXHUHFODPDODUHDOL]DFLyQ GH VDOWRV FRPR HO UHVWR GH FRPSDxHURV $ SHVDU GH TXH OH FRPHQWDPRV TXH OH HVWi FRQWUDLQGLFDGR HOOD OR UHEDWH GLFLHQGR ³TXH HQ VX FDVD MXHJD D VDOWDU OD FRPED \ QR SDVD QDGD´ 8QDDQpFGRWDVLJQLILFDWLYDVHGDFXDQGRSUHJXQWRD/ROD\DVXVFRPSDxHUDVSRUTXpQR/ROD QR KDFH JLUDU OD FXHUGD (OODV PH FRQWHVWDQ TXH HV GHELGR D OD DOWXUD /D DGDSWDFLyQ TXH SURSRQJRHVTXHFXDQGROHWRTXHGDUDODFRPEDVHVXEDHQXQEDQFRVXHFR/RODVRQUtH\HO UHVWRGHJUXSRORDFHSWDFRQQDWXUDOLGDG &RPHQWDULRVDODVHVLyQ 3XHGRFRQFOXLUFRPHQWDQGRTXHKHREVHUYDGRXQD/RODPX\SDUWLFLSDWLYDHQODOtQHDGHOR KDELWXDO\PX\FRPXQLFDWLYDFRQVXVFRPSDxHUDV (V LQWHUHVDQWH OD FRQFLHQFLD TXH WLHQH /ROD UHVSHFWR D OD QHFHVLGDG TXH VH OH DGDSWH HO PDWHULDO\PHKDVRUSUHQGLGRVXUHVSXHVWDFXDQGRTXHUtDSDUWLFLSDUGHORVVDOWRVDSHVDUGH VXFRQWUDLQGLFDFLyQ 6(6,Ï11 '(',&,(0%5('( /D PDHVWUD FRQWLQXD GH EDMD \ HO JUXSR VLJXH VLHQGR GH QXHYH FRPSRQHQWHV GHELGR D OD JULSHUHFRUGHPRVTXHHQWUHpVWRVHVWi-RUGL /DSULPHUDDFWLYLGDGTXHSURSRQHODPDHVWUDVXVWLWXWDHV³HOWUHQFLHJR´ *UXSR GHFLQFRFRQORVRMRVYHQGDGRVPHQRVHO~OWLPR(QILODLQGLDDXQDGLVWDQFLDGHXQ EUD]R (O TXH GLULJH HO WUHQ HV HO ~OWLPR \ SDUD HOOR VH HVWDEOHFH XQ FyGLJR GH GLUHFFLyQ &XDQGR GD XQD SDOPDGD DO KRPEUR GHUHFKR GHO FRPSDxHUR TXH WLHQH DGHODQWH pVWH OR WUDQVPLWH D VX YH] DO RWUR FRPSDxHUR DYDQ]DGR KDVWD TXH OOHJD DO SULPHUR WHQLHQGR TXH GLULJLUVHKDFLDHOODGRGHUHFKR6tODSDOPDGDHVHQHOKRPEURL]TXLHUGRHOWUHQVHGLULJHKDFLD HOODGRL]TXLHUGRVLODSDOPDGDHVDODYH]DDPERVKRPEURVHOWUHQDYDQ]DKDFLDGHODQWHVL VRQGRVSDOPDGDVHOWUHQYDKDFLDDWUiV\VLODSDOPDGDVHORFDOL]DHQODFDEH]DHOWUHQVH SDUD /D DGDSWDFLyQ TXH UHDOL]D OD PDHVWUD SDUD /ROD HV OD TXH VLJXH pVWD UHFLEH OD LQIRUPDFLyQ FRPR HO UHVWR GHO JUXSR SHUR FRPR QR SXHGH DFFHGHU D ORV KRPEURV QL D OD FDEH]D GHO FRPSDxHURDYDQ]DGRORVXVWLWX\HUHVSHFWLYDPHQWHSRUODFLQWXUD\HOWUDVHUR (OVLJXLHQWHMXHJRHV³UHDFFLyQDODSDOPDGD´ (OJUXSRHQILODLQGLDDXQDGLVWDQFLDHQWUHMXJDGRUHVGHXQRVGRVPHWURV&XDQGRODPDHVWUD HPLWH XQDSDOPDGDWLHQHQTXHGDUXQSDVRKDFtDDGHODQWHVLGDGRVSDOPDGDVHOSDVRHV KDFtDDWUiV(OTXHVHHTXLYRFDHVWiHOLPLQDGR 5 5 5 5 5 5 5 5 /RODVHTXHGDODSHQ~OWLPDREVHUYiQGRODPX\PRWLYDGD\FRPSHWLWLYD 3DUDILQDOL]DUODVHVLyQSURSRQH³HORVRGRUPLOyQ´ 7RGRVHQFtUFXORH[FHSWXDQGRHORVRTXHHVWiHQHOFHQWURFRQORVRMRVYHQGDGRV(QWUHVXV SLHUQDVVHHQFXHQWUDXQEDOyQHVSXPD/DPDHVWUDLQGLFDTXpMXJDGRUDWUDYpVGHXQDVHxDO QR YHUEDO WLHQH TXH GLULJLUVH DO FHQWUR H LQWHQWDU DUUHEDWDU HO EDOyQ VLQ VHU SHUFLELGR SRU HO RVR6LpVWHWRFDDOMXJDGRUVHFDPELDQORVSDSHOHV\GHQRVHUDVtFRQWLQXDSDUDQGRKDVWD FRQVHJXLU WRFDU D XQ FRPSDxHUR 1R REVWDQWH HQ DPEDV VLWXDFLRQHV WLHQH TXH UHFRQRFHU PHGLDQWHHOWDFWR\DWUDYpVGHODFDUDGHTXpMXJDGRUVHWUDWD &RPHQWDULRVDODVHVLyQ /ROD QR WLHQH GLILFXOWDG SDUD VHJXLU OD VHVLyQ 6H REVHUYD PX\ DFWLYD GLQDPL]DGRUD SDUWLFLSDWLYD\JHQHUDGRUDGHLQWHUUHODFLRQHVSRVLWLYDVFRQVXVFRPSDxHURV 5 5 5 6(6,21(61\ 6(6,Ï11 <'(',&,(0%5('( 1RVHLPSDUWHFODVHGH(GXFDFLyQ)tVLFDSRUTXHHQODMRUQDGDGHOGtDUHDOL]DQORVHQVD\RV GHODREUDWHDWUDOGH1DYLGDG\HOWLHQHOXJDUVXUHSUHVHQWDFLyQ '((1(52'( 6HLQLFLDHOVHJXQGRWULPHVWUHFRQODVVLJXLHQWHVWDUHDV 'HVSOD]DUVHHQFDUUHUDSRUODVOtQHDVH[WHULRUHVGHOSDWLRËGHPDxDGLHQGRDODVHxDOVDOWRV GHWLMHUD &RPR HQRWUDVRFDVLRQHVODPDHVWUD RSWD SRU XQ UHFRUULGR LQWHULRU PiV UHGXFLGRWHQLHQGR TXHVHJXLUODVOtQHDVGHOFDPSRGHYROHLERO/RODUHDOL]DORVVDOWRVGHWLMHUDPX\VXDYHPHQWH WDQ VyOR PDUFDQGR OD DFFLyQ HQ FDPELR -RUGL UHDOL]D GRV LPSXOVRV VHJXLGRV GH OD VLOOD GH UXHGDVGHMDQGRTXHVHGHVSODFHKDVWDTXHSLHUGHYHORFLGDG 3RVWHULRUPHQWHHOJUXSRVHRUJDQL]DSRUSDUHMDV 8QRHQIUHQWHGHRWURDXQDGLVWDQFLDGHXQPHWURWLHQHQTXHUHDOL]DUFLQFRVDOWRVODWHUDOHV DO VH[WR JLUDQ VH GDQ OD HVSDOGD \ FRQWLQXDQGR HQ OD PLVPD GLUHFFLyQ WLHQHQ TXH UHDOL]DU RWURVFLQFRVDOWRVWHQLHQGRTXHJLUDUGHQXHYR\DVtVXFHVLYDPHQWHKDVWDOOHJDUDOILQDOGHOD SLVWD 5 5 5 5 /DDGDSWDFLyQTXHSURSRQHODPDHVWUDSDUDDPERVHVODTXHVLJXH/RODUHDOL]DORVFLQFRV VDOWRVODWHUDOHVHQGLUHFFLyQDVXGHUHFKD\PLUDQGRD-RUGLpVWHSDUDOHODPHQWHUHDOL]DFLQFR LPSXOVRV GH OD VLOOD GH UXHGDV HVWDQGR SRU WDQWR ODWHUDO D /ROD $ OD YH] LQLFLDQ HO PLVPR SURFHVR JLUDQGR -RUGL OD VLOOD KDFLD HO VHQWLGR FRQWUDULR \ /ROD UHDOL]DQGR ORV FLQFR VDOWRV ODWHUDOHVKDFLDODL]TXLHUGD 2EVHUYDPRVTXHODLQWHUUHODFLyQGHpVWRVHVPX\SRVLWLYD\FRUGLDOHVWDEOHFLHQGRFRQWLQXDV FRQYHUVDFLRQHV /OHJD XQ PRPHQWR HQ TXH DPERV PXHVWUDQ FDQVDQFLR \ GHFLGHQ GHVSOD]DUVHDOD]RQDGHORVEDQFRVFRQHOILQGHFRJHUXQEDOyQ\MXJDUFRQpO&XDQGRVH SHUFDWD OD DX[LOLDU GH (( OHV SUHJXQWD ³TXp KDFHQ DOOt´ \ HOORV OH FRQWHVWDQ ³TXH HVWiQ FDQVDGRV´ /HV WLHQH TXH UHFRUGDU TXH OD FODVH VH UHDOL]D HQ HO LQWHULRU GHO SDWLR VHJ~Q ODV FRQVLJQDVGHODPDHVWUD\TXHVLHVWiQFDQVDGRVVHORWLHQHQTXHFRPXQLFDUDODPDHVWUD &RQVHFXHQWHPHQWH VH GHVSOD]DQ KDFLD HO FHQWUR GHO FDPSR \ SDVDQ D HVFXFKDU OD H[SOLFDFLyQGHOVLJXLHQWHMXHJRUHVXOWDQGRVHUHO³UHOHYROLQHDOHQFDUUHUD´ 2UJDQL]D FLQFR JUXSRV GH FXDWUR QLxRV HQ ILOD /D GLVWDQFLD HQWUH JUXSRV HV GH XQRV WUHV PHWURV6LWXDGRVWUDVXQDOtQHDGHVDOLGDHOSULPHUPLHPEURFRQXQDURSHTXHxRHQODPDQR WLHQH TXH GHVSOD]DUVH HQ FDUUHUD KDVWD OOHJDU DO H[WUHPR GHO FDPSR PHWURV GRQGH OH HVSHUD XQ MXJDGRU GHO HTXLSR /H SDVD HO DUR \ VH TXHGD HQ HVH OXJDU PLHQWUDV TXH VX FRPSDxHURLQLFLDHOUHFRUULGRDODLQYHUVD\DVtVXFHVLYDPHQWHKDVWDTXHHO~OWLPRMXJDGRUGH XQJUXSROOHJDDVHUHOSULPHURHQOOHJDUDODOtQHDGHLQLFLR &RPRHQRFDVLRQHVVLPLODUHV-RUGLSLHUGHWLHPSRHQHODUUDQTXHGHODVLOODGHUXHGDV\VX YHORFLGDGHVPHQRUTXHODGHVXVDGYHUVDULRV'HFLGLPRVTXHUHFRUUHUiXQWHUFLRGHOHVSDFLR GHWDOPDQHUDTXHXQFRPSDxHURVHVLW~DDXQRVPHWURVSDUDFRJHUHODUR\VHORSDVDDO FRPSDxHURTXHHVWiDORWURH[WUHPRGHOFDPSRpVWHLQLFLDGHQXHYRHOUHFRUULGRKDFLD-RUGL SDViQGROHHODURSDUDTXHORWUDVODGHDOLQLFLRGHODILOD(VWDYH]RFXSDHOSULPHUUHOHYR 2EVHUYDPRVTXH-RUGLVHGLULJHDOHTXLSRQXWULGRGHORVYDURQHVVLHQGRDFHSWDGRSRUWRGRV ORV PLHPEURV VLQ SHUFLELU UHFKD]R DOJXQR (VWDEOHFH LQWHUUHODFLRQHV FRQ WRGRV VXV FRPSRQHQWHVVLHQGRFRUUHVSRQGLGR6HPXHVWUDPX\FRPSHWLWLYRDQLPDQGRFRQVWDQWHPHQWH DVXVFRPSDxHURV 3DUDOHODPHQWH HQFRQWUDPRV TXH /ROD VH LQWHUUHODFLRQD WDPELpQ SRVLWLYDPHQWH FRQ ORV PLHPEURV GH VX HTXLSR SHUR WLHQH TXH DEDQGRQDU HO MXHJR SRUTXH OH GXHOH XQD SLHUQD 6H GHVSOD]DKDFLDHOHVSDFLRGRQGHHVWDPRVODDX[LOLDUGH((\\RSDUDFRPHQWDUQRVORRFXUULGR \ SRVWHULRUPHQWH VH GLULJH DO JUXSR GH YDURQHV LQLFLDQGR FRQYHUVDFLRQHV FRQ HOORV \ PX\ FRQFUHWDPHQWHFRQ-RUGLFRPHQWDQGRODVDFWXDFLRQHVGHORVPLHPEURVGHHVHHTXLSR &RPRSHQ~OWLPDDFWLYLGDGODPDHVWUDSURSRQH³HOODQ]DPLHQWRGHDUR´ (OJUXSRFODVHWUDVXQDOtQHDGHOH[WUHPRGHOFDPSRVLHQGRODGLVWDQFLDHQWUHMXJDGRUHVGHXQ PHWUR\PHGLR$ODVHxDOHOSULPHURWLHQHTXHODQ]DUHODURORPiVOHMRVSRVLEOH\DUDVGHO VXHORSRVWHULRUPHQWHORUHDOL]DHOVLJXLHQWH\DVtKDVWDTXHWRGRVKD\DQODQ]DGRVXDUR6H FRPHQWDFXiOHVHODURTXHPiVOHMRVKDOOHJDGR\DODFRQVLJQDWRGRVGHEHQORFDOL]DUVXDUR UHFRJHUORGHOVXHOR\UHJUHVDUHQFDUUHUDDODGLVSRVLFLyQLQLFLDO 5 5 5 5 5 5 3DUD/RODHVWDDFWLYLGDGQROHVXSRQHGLILFXOWDGDOJXQD\SDUD-RUGLWDQVyORFXDQGRWLHQHTXH FRJHU VX DUR GHO VXHOR $O QR OOHJDU SLGH OD FRODERUDFLyQ GHO FRPSDxHUR PiV SUy[LPR VROLFLWDQGRVXUHFHSFLyQ\HQQLQJ~QFDVRKHPRVREVHUYDGRQHJDFLyQ$VtPLVPRSUHVHQWD GLILFXOWDGSDUDODQ]DUIURQWDOPHQWHSRUORTXHGHFLGHODQ]DUFRQODPDQRGHUHFKDFRORFDQGR ODVLOODGHODGR\HQHVDPLVPDGLUHFFLyQ &RPR/RODOHGXHOHODSLHUQDVHGHVSOD]DDQGDQGRDUHFRJHUVXDURSHURDSHVDUGHHOORVH PXHVWUD PX\ PRWLYDGD SRU OD DFWLYLGDG D LJXDO TXH -RUGL &RQVWDQWHPHQWH HVWDEOHFHQ \ UHFLEHQ DPERV LQWHUDFFLRQHV YHUEDOHV FRQ VXV FRPSDxHURV HQ HO HVSDFLR GH ORV ODQ]DPLHQWRV )LQDOL]DFRQODWDUHD³TXHQRFDLJDHODUR´ 'LVWULEXLGRV OLEUHPHQWH SRU HO HVSDFLR \ FRQ XQ DUR HQ OD PDQR WLHQHQ TXH UHDOL]DU ODQ]DPLHQWRVYHUWLFDOHVGHpVWHKDFLDDUULEDFRQHOSURSyVLWRGHUHFHSFLRQDUORVLQTXHFDLJDDO VXHOR $LPDJHQGHODWDUHDDQWHULRUSDUD/RODQRSUHVHQWDQLQJXQDGLILFXOWDGLQWHUUHODFLRQiQGRVH FRQVXVFRPSDxHURVFRQODPi[LPDHVSRQWDQHLGDG 0LHQWUDV WDQWR OD DX[LOLDU GH (GXFDFLyQ (VSHFLDO DSURYHFKD HVWD DFWLYLGDG SDUD DVHJXUDUVH TXH -RUGL UHDOL]D ORV ODQ]DPLHQWRV GH DUR GHO MXHJR DQWHULRU GH OD IRUPD PiV HIHFWLYD /H SURSRQHGLIHUHQWHVSRVLFLRQHVGHODVLOODSDUDFRPSUREDUVLODUHVSXHVWDTXHGDEDHQHOMXHJR DQWHULRUHUDODPiVFRUUHFWDUHVXOWDQGRVHUODPiVDGHFXDGD $OVDOLUGHODVHVLyQ-RUGLOHGLFHDODDX[LOLDUGH((TXHOHDEURFKHHOFRUGyQGHXQDGHODV ]DSDWLOODVGHSRUWLYDV(OODOHFRQWHVWDTXH\DWLHQHHGDGSDUDKDFHUORVRORSHURpOOHUHVSRQGH FRQXQ³QRVp´/DDX[LOLDUUHFODPDODFRODERUDFLyQGHGRVGHVXVFRPSDxHURVSDUDTXHOH HQVHxHQ\DSHVDUGHODVH[SOLFDFLRQHVWDQGLGiFWLFDVGHpVWRV-RUGLORLQWHQWDYDULDVYHFHV\ QR FRQVLJXH DQXGDUVH HO FDO]DGR &RPR \D QR TXHGD PiV WLHPSR OH DQLPD D TXH VLJD SUDFWLFDQGRHQORVSUy[LPRVGtDV &RPHQWDULRVDODVHVLyQ (VWDVHVLyQVHFDUDFWHUL]DSRUODVP~OWLSOHVLQWHUUHODFLRQHVGHDPERVFRQORVFRPSDxHURV\ YLFHYHUVD /RVFRPSDxHURVLQFRUSRUDQODVDGDSWDFLRQHVGHORVMXHJRV\DSUDFWLFDGRVDQWHULRUPHQWHFRQ WRWDOQRUPDOLGDG +D VLGR LQWHUHVDQWH HO UHFODPR TXH KD KHFKR OD DX[LOLDU GH (( FXDQGR KDQ DEDQGRQDGR OD VHVLyQSRUFDQVDQFLRHLEDQDLQLFLDUXQMXHJRFRQEDOyQUHFRUGiQGROHVTXHHVODPDHVWUDOD TXHGLULJHODVHVLyQ3LHQVRTXHHVLPSRUWDQWHSRUTXHYDQLQFRUSRUDQGRODIXQFLyQGHFDGD XQD GH QRVRWUDV HYLWDQGR ORV SRVLEOHV VRODSDPLHQWRV GH GLUHFFLyQ SRU SUREOHPDV GH HQWHQGLPLHQWR\FRRUGLQDFLyQ 5 5 5 5 5 5 5 5 5 &UHR GH LQWHUpV UHJLVWUDU HO FRPHQWDULR GH OD DX[LOLDU DQWH OD UHVSXHVWD GH -RUGL FXDQGR LQWHQWDED DQXGDUVH HO FRUGyQ GH OD ]DSDWLOOD GHSRUWLYD &RQVLGHUD TXH DO HVWDU WDQ VREUHSURWHJLGRSRUORVSDGUHVVXDXWRQRPtDVHYHPX\OLPLWDGDFRQUHVSHFWRDORVKiELWRV KLJLpQLFRV 4XH DQWH HO DSUHQGL]DMH GH QXHYDV DFWLYLGDGHV VH PXHVWUD PX\ LQVHJXUR \ D OD YH]SUHVHQWDPXFKDYHUJHQ]DFXDQGRWLHQHOLPLWDFLRQHV 6(6,Ï11 '((1(52'( 6H LQLFLD OD VHVLyQ HQ HO JLPQDVLR REVHUYDQGR TXH -RUGL HVWi HQ XQR GH ORV H[WUHPRV GHO EDQFRGRQGHHVWiQORFDOL]DGRVWRGRVORVYDURQHVGHOJUXSR\TXH/RODHVWiVHQWDGDMXQWRD VXVFRPSDxHUDVVLWXDGDHQHOFHQWURGHOEDQFR&RQWLQXDGDPHQWHVHLQWHUUHODFLRQDQDPERV FRQVXVFRPSDxHURV &XDQGRODPDHVWUDLQLFLDODH[SOLFDFLyQGHODVHVLyQHVLQWHUUXPSLGDSRU-RUGLSRUORTXHOH OODPDODDWHQFLyQUHFRUGiQGROHTXHQRSXHGHGHWHQHUXQDH[SOLFDFLyQeVWHVRQUtH\PLUDDO FRPSDxHUR GH VX L]TXLHUGD HO FXDO UHDFFLRQD WDSiQGROH OD ERFD /D PDHVWUD LQWHUYLHQH GH QXHYR FRPHQWDQGR TXHQRHVFRUUHFWR TXH OH WDSH OD ERFD H LQVLVWH D -RUGL TXH WLHQH TXH DSUHQGHUDUHVSHWDUDORVGHPiV 3RVWHULRUPHQWHGLULJHDOJUXSRDOSDWLRH[WHULRU/DSULPHUDSURSXHVWDHVODGHGDUYXHOWDVDO SDWLR \ OD DGDSWDFLyQ TXH SURSRQH SDUD /ROD \ SDUD -RUGL HV OD PLVPD TXH HQ OD VHVLyQ DQWHULRU&RPRYDULDQWHILQDOL]DODWDUHDFRQHMHUFLFLRVUHVSLUDWRULRVORVFXDOHVUHDOL]DQDPERV VLQGLILFXOWDG /DVLJXLHQWHDFWLYLGDGHV³SDVDUSRUGHEDMRGHOW~QHO´ 6HGLVWULEX\HQHQGRVJUXSRVDXQDGLVWDQFLDHQWUHHOORVGHXQRVPHWURV(QFDGDXQRGH HOORVORVQLxRVVHHPSDUHMDQRUJDQL]DQGRXQDILOD\VHFRJHQSRUODVPDQRVFRQORVEUD]RV DO]DGRV \ SRU HQFLPD GH OD FDEH]D GH WDO IRUPD TXH HQWUH WRGRV GLVHxDQ XQ W~QHO /D GLVWDQFLD HQWUH ODV SDUHMDV RVFLOD HQWUH FLQFXHQWD D QRYHQWD FHQWtPHWURV $ OD VHxDO VDOH OD TXHHVWiVLWXDGDHQHO~OWLPROXJDU\FRJLGRVSRUODPDQRVHGHVSOD]DQKDVWDHOSULQFLSLRGHOD ILODHVWUXFWXUDQGRHOW~QHOGHWDOIRUPDTXHJDQDHOJUXSRTXHDQWHVOOHJXHDXQDOtQHDILMDGD GHDQWHPDQR (QHVWDRFDVLyQDGLIHUHQFLDGHODVHVLyQQ~PHURTXLQFHQRSURSRQHQLQJXQDDGDSWDFLyQQL SDUD-RUGLQLSDUD/RODeVWDUHDFFLRQDGHVSOD]iQGRVHLQGLYLGXDOPHQWH\DOOOHJDUDOILQDOGHO W~QHO DO]D ORV EUD]RV FRPR VL WXYLHUD XQD FRPSDxHUD (Q QLQJ~Q PRPHQWR VH HQOHQWHFH OD YHORFLGDG GH HVH JUXSR (Q FDPELR D SHVDU GH TXH -RUGL YD FRQ XQ FRPSDxHUR pVWH OH DGHODQWD YDULDV YHFHV \ GDGR VX ULWPR GH GHVSOD]DPLHQWR ORV FRPSDxHURV TXH OH VLJXHQ WLHQHQTXHGLVPLQXLUODYHORFLGDGRHQRWUDVRFDVLRQHVOHHPSXMDQODVLOODGHUXHGDV /DDX[LOLDUGH(GXFDFLyQ(VSHFLDO\\RREVHUYDPRVODUHVSXHVWDGHOJUXSR\SDUDOHODPHQWH GLDORJDPRV VREUH OD DGDSWDFLyQ PiV DGHFXDGD /OHJDPRV D OD FRQFOXVLyQ TXH HV XQ MXHJR GLItFLOGHFRPSHQVDUODVGLILFXOWDGHV\TXHVHWHQGUtDTXHSURSRQHUVLQFRPSHWLFLyQXQLHQGR LQFOXVRDORVGRVJUXSRVGHIRUPDFRRSHUDWLYD 5 5 5 5 5 5 5 (OWHUFHUMXHJRHV³¢DYHUTXHJUXSROOHJDDQWHV"´ /D FODVH GLYLGLGD HQ GRV JUXSRV /RV MXJDGRUHV GH FDGD JUXSR HVWiQ XQR DO ODGR GH RWUR \ GHWUiV GH XQD OtQHD OOHJDQGR D RFXSDU HQWUH WRGRV OD PLWDG GHO FDPSR $PERV JUXSRV VH VLW~DQ HTXLGLVWDQWHV UHVSHFWR D OD OtQHD FHQWUDO GHO SDWLR \ HQ GLDJRQDO SDUD HYLWDU FKRTXHV HQWUHHOORV$ODVHxDOWLHQHQTXHGHVSOD]DUVHHQFDUUHUDKDVWDODPLWDGGHOFDPSRLQWHQWDQGR OOHJDUDQWHVTXHHORWURJUXSR 'DGRHOWLHPSRGHDUUDQTXHTXHSUHFLVD-RUGLSDUDDGTXLULUYHORFLGDGFRQODVLOODGHUXHGDV VDOH GH OD GLVWDQFLD GH GRV WHUFLRV UHVSHFWR D OD OtQHD FHQWUDO HQ FDPELR /ROD SDUWH GH OD GLVWDQFLD GH XQ WHUFLR 2EVHUYDPRV TXH HO JUXSR DVXPH FRQ QRUPDOLGDG OD YHQWDMD $O FRPSHQVDUOHVFRQHTXLOLEULRODVGLVWDQFLDVDUHFRUUHUDPERVVHSUHVHQWDQPX\PRWLYDGRVSRU ODFRPSHWLFLyQ 3RVWHULRUPHQWH QRV GHVSOD]DPRV DO JLPQDVLR PLHQWUDV TXH HO UHVWR GHO JUXSR UHDOL]D GLIHUHQWHVWLSRVGHDEGRPLQDOHVSRUSDUHMDVODDX[LOLDUGH(GXFDFLyQ(VSHFLDO\\RRSWDPRV SRU GHVSOD]DUQRV D OD ]RQD GH FROFKRQHWDV \ OHV SURSRQHPRV TXH ODV UHDOLFHQ LQGLYLGXDOPHQWH3DUDWDOILQHVQHFHVDULRGHVSOD]DUD-RUGLDODFROFKRQHWDORTXHUHDOL]DOD DX[LOLDUFRQJUDQKDELOLGDG\FXLGDGR $DPERVOHVUHVXOWDQPX\GLILFXOWRVDVODHMHFXFLyQGHODVDEGRPLQDOHVFRUWDVHVSRUHOORTXH SURSRQHPRVDFWLYLGDGHVDOWHUQDWLYDVFRPR 7XPEDGRVHQODFROFKRQHWDUHDOL]DUJLURVVREUHVtPLVPRVËGHPWUDVODGDQGRXQDSHORWDGH HVSXPDGHFLGLHQGRFRQTXHSDUWHFRUSRUDOODFRJHQ 8QR HQIUHQWH GHO RWUR D XQD GLVWDQFLD GH GRV PHWURV FDGD XQR FRQ XQ EDOyQ SHTXHxR GH HVSXPD $ OD VHxDO ODQ]DU HO EDOyQ D OD YH] ËGHP LQWHQWDQGR FRLQFLGLU HQ OD PLWDG GHO UHFRUULGR3RU~OWLPRXQRODQ]DYHUWLFDOPHQWHODSHORWD\HORWURWLHQHTXHLPSDFWDUODFRQOD VX\D 5HFRJHPRV XQD JUDQ PRWLYDFLyQ SRU ODV DFWLYLGDGHV SURSXHVWDV HVFXFKiQGRVH FRQWLQXDGDPHQWH FRPHQWDULRV IDYRUDEOHV DFRPSDxDGRV GH ULVDV &XDQGR -RUGL UHDOL]D ORV JLURV VH PXHVWUD HVSHFLDOPHQWH DQLPDGR \ GLYHUWLGR /D LQWHUDFFLyQ HQWUH DPERV HV PX\ SRVLWLYD (O JUXSR REVHUYD ODV HYROXFLRQHV GH -RUGL LQFOXVR GRV FRPSDxHUDV VH DFHUFDQ D pO HQ HO PRPHQWRGHORVJLURVPRVWUiQGRVHJUDWDPHQWHVRUSUHQGLGDV/HKHSUHJXQWDGRDODDX[LOLDU GH((VLHOJUXSRHVWiDFRVWXPEUDGRDYHUD-RUGLVLQODVLOOD\PHKDFRQWHVWDGRTXHQR$ SHVDU GH HOOR ORV FRPSDxHURV KDQ DFWXDGR PX\ QDWXUDOPHQWH VLQ HVFXFKDUVH QLQJ~Q FRPHQWDULRGHVSHFWLYR 3DUDILQDOL]DUODVHVLyQODPDHVWUDSURSRQHHOMXHJR³ODSDVWRUD´ (OJUXSRGLVSHUVRSRUHOHVSDFLR\XQMXJDGRUFRQXQEDOyQGHHVSXPDeVWHSXHGHRSWDUHQ FXDQWR OR SRVHH SRU JULWDU ³SLHV TXLHWRV´ \ SRU WDQWR VXV FRPSDxHURV WLHQHQ TXH TXHGDUVH HVWiWLFRVHQHOSXQWRGHOHVSDFLRGRQGHVHHQFXHQWUDQ\DFRQWLQXDFLyQLQWHQWDUWRFDUDXQ 5 5 5 5 5 FRPSDxHUR ODQ]DQGR HO EDOyQ LPSDFWDQGR FXDOTXLHU SDUWH FRUSRUDO H[FHSWXDQGR OD FDUD \ FD\HQGRHOEDOyQDOVXHOR2ELHQWLHQHODSRVLELOLGDGGHGDUWUHVSDVRVFRQHOEDOyQHQOD PDQR FRQ HO REMHWLYR GH DSUR[LPDUVH D VXV FRPSDxHURV \ GHFLU ³SLHV TXLHWRV´ (Q HO PRPHQWRTXHXQMXJDGRUHVWRFDGRSDVDDOD]RQDGHHOLPLQDGRV\WDQVyORSXHGHVDOYDUVH FXDQGRLPSDFWDQDOMXJDGRUTXHORKDHOLPLQDGR /ROD SDUWLFLSD VLQ QHFHVLGDG GH QLQJXQD DGDSWDFLyQ UHVXOWDQGR VHU PX\ GLQDPL]DGRUD (Q FDPELR-RUGLSUHILHUHQRFRPSDUWLUHVWHMXHJRGDGRTXHIXHFRQpVWHFXDQGRVHFD\y\VH IUDFWXUyHOIpPXUHQHOWULPHVWUHSDVDGR(VSRUHOORTXHOHKHPRVSURSXHVWRXQDDFWLYLGDGGH SUHFLVLyQ 6LHWHDURVGHWDPDxRSHTXHxRV\XQFRQRDXQDGLVWDQFLDGHGRVPHWURV(OMXHJRFRQVLVWH HQLQWURGXFLUHOPi[LPRGHDURVHQHOFRQR $SHVDUTXHUHDOL]DHOMXHJRLQGLYLGXDOPHQWHOHDQLPDPRVDVXSHUDUORVUHVXOWDGRVREWHQLGRV GHWDOIRUPDTXHVHKDPDQWHQLGRPX\SHQGLHQWHGHVXSURSLDHYROXFLyQ &RPHQWDULRVDODVHVLyQ &RQVLGHUDPRV GH JUDQ LQWHUpV OD DFWLWXG FRPSUHQVLYD \ UHVSHWXRVD GHO JUXSR FXDQGR KDQ REVHUYDGRTXH-RUGLUHDOL]DEDODVDFWLYLGDGHVIXHUDGHODVLOODGHUXHGDVHVSHFLDOPHQWHFRQ ORVJLURV 5HFRQRFHPRVTXHQRWRGRVORVMXHJRVFRPSHWLWLYRVSXHGHQDGDSWDUVHSRUORTXHVHWHQGUtD TXHEXVFDUODSUHVHQWDFLyQGHpVWRVGHVGHXQSODQWHDPLHQWRFRRSHUDWLYR 6(6,Ï11 '((1(52'( (QWURHQHOFHQWURHVFRODUFRLQFLGLHQGRFRQODKRUDGHOSDWLR\HQHOUHFRUULGRPHFUX]RFRQ /ROD eVWD DEDQGRQD HO MXHJR PRPHQWiQHDPHQWH SDUD KDEODU FRQPLJR 0H SUHJXQWD ³¢KR\ KDUHPRVODFODVHFRQWLJR"´FRQWHVWR³¢SRUTXpORSUHJXQWDV"´\PHUHVSRQGH³SRUTXHPHOR SDVRPX\ELHQFRQWLJR´\DFRQWLQXDFLyQPHUHJDODXQDJUDQVRQULVD 6HLQLFLDODVHVLyQFRQHOMXHJR³WRFDU\SDUDU´ (OJUXSRFODVHHVWiGLVSHUVRHQXQHVSDFLRGHOLPLWDGR\FXDWURQLxRV³SDUDQ´&XDQGRVHGD OD VHxDO GH LQLFLR pVWRV WLHQHQ TXH LQWHQWDU HOLPLQDU D VXV DGYHUVDULRV WRFiQGROHV FRQ OD PDQRHQDOJXQDSDUWHGHOFXHUSR(QHOPRPHQWRTXHORFRQVLJXHQORVTXHHVWiQWRFDGRVVH WUDVODGDQDOFDPSRGHHOLPLQDGRV*DQDHOMXJDGRUTXHVHTXHGHHO~OWLPRVLQWRFDU (QODSULPHUDUHSHWLFLyQ/RODIRUPDSDUWHGHOJUXSRTXH³SDUD´/DFRQVLJQDTXHGDODPDHVWUD SDUD TXH /ROD SXHGD HOLPLQDUHVTXH FXDQGR VH DSUR[LPH D XQ FRPSDxHUR D XQ PHWUR GH GLVWDQFLD WLHQH TXH GHFLU VX QRPEUH HQ DOWR \ DxDGLU ³WRFDGR´ $GHPiV LQGLFD TXH WDQ VyOR pVWDSXHGHHOLPLQDUD-RUGL 5 5 5 5 5 5 2EVHUYDPRVDXQD/RODPX\SDUWLFLSDWLYD\GLQiPLFDHQWUHJDGDDOUROTXHVHOHKDDVLJQDGR $VtPLVPRRFXUUHFRQ-RUGLHOFXDOHVHOLPLQDGRFDVLDOILQDOGHHVWDVHULH (QODVHJXQGDUHSHWLFLyQODPDHVWUDGHFLGHTXHVHD-RUGLXQRGHORVPLHPEURVGHOJUXSRTXH ³SDUD´ &RPR HQ HO MXHJR DQWHULRU DPERV VH PXHVWUDQ PX\ PRWLYDGRV D SHVDU GH ODV GLILFXOWDGHVTXHWLHQHSDUDWRFDUDORVFRPSDxHURV < HV HQ OD ~OWLPD UHSHWLFLyQ FXDQGR DPERV IRUPDQ SDUWH GHO JUXSR TXH KX\H $ /ROD VH OH HOLPLQD D OD PLWDG GHO MXHJR \ REVHUYDPRV TXH OD SHUPDQHQFLD GH -RUGL HQ HO HVSDFLR GH MXHJRHVPD\RUGHELGRDTXHXQDGHODVMXJDGRUDVTXHSDUDQFXDQGRORKDWHQLGRSUy[LPR SDUDWRFDUKDGHFLGLGRGHVHVWLPDUODSRVLELOLGDGSDUiQGRVHGHWUiVGHpOLQLFLDQGRHOJHVWRGH WRFDU\DFRQWLQXDFLyQFDPELDUGHGLUHFFLyQHVFDVLDOILQDOGHOMXHJRFXDQGRHVWRFDGR (Q ORV HVSDFLRV HQ TXH /ROD \ -RUGL HVWiQ HQ OD ]RQD GH HOLPLQDGRV REVHUYDPRV TXH OD SULPHUDVHVLHQWDMXQWRDOJUXSRGHQLxDV\HOVHJXQGRFRQHOGHQLxRVLQWHUDFFLRQDGRDPERV YHUEDOPHQWH FRQ ORV FRPSDxHURV \ PRVWUDQGR LQLFLDWLYDV HQ OD FRPXQLFDFLyQ QR SHUFLELpQGRVHUHFKD]RDOJXQR /DVLJXLHQWHSURSXHVWDHV³HOUHOHYRGHODVFXHUGDV´ /DFODVHRUJDQL]DGDHQJUXSRVGHFXDWUR(QILODLQGLDGHWUiVGHXQDOtQHD\DXQDGLVWDQFLD HQWUHORVJUXSRVGHXQRVGRVPHWURV$ODVHxDOGHODPDHVWUDVDOHHOSULPHUMXJDGRUGHFDGD JUXSRVDOWDQGRDODFXHUGDKDVWDOOHJDUDXQDOtQHDVLWXDGDDXQRVTXLQFHPHWURV&XDQGR OOHJD DOOt WLHQH TXH JLUDU \ UHJUHVDU GH QXHYR DO SXQWR GH VDOLGD SDVDQGR DO FXHUGD DO FRPSDxHURTXHOHVLJXH\DVtVXFHVLYDPHQWHKDVWDTXHWRGRVSDUWLFLSDQ*DQDHOHTXLSRTXH OOHJDDQWHV /DDGDSWDFLyQTXHSURSRQHODPDHVWUDSDUD/RODHVODGHUHGXFLUHOHVSDFLRGHUHFRUULGRDXQ WHUFLRIDFLOLWiQGROHXQDFXHUGDPiVFRUWDTXHODGHOUHVWRGHFRPSDxHURV5HVSHFWRD-RUGL GHFLGLPRV TXH VH GHVSODFH HQ FDUUHUD OOHYDQGR HQ ODV SLHUQDV OD FXHUGD UHGXFLHQGR HO UHFRUULGRDXQFLQFXHQWDSRUFLHQWR &XDQGRODPDHVWUDLQGLFDTXHVHRUJDQLFHQORVJUXSRVREVHUYDPRVTXH/RODSURWDJRQL]DOD RUJDQL]DFLyQGHXQRGHHOORV\TXH-RUGLHVUHFODPDGRSRUHOGHQLxRVSDUDTXHSDUWLFLSHQ FRQ HOORV &RPR HVH JUXSR HV PX\ QXPHURVR VRQ RFKR OD PDHVWUD WLHQH TXH UHFRUGDU HO Q~PHURGHFRPSRQHQWHVSRUJUXSR$OILQDODFXHUGDQODGLYLVLyQHQGRVSHUPDQHFLHQGR-RUGL FRQHOJUXSRGHQLxRVGHPD\RUOLGHUD]JR 2EVHUYDPRV TXH DPERV VH HQWUHJDQ DO MXHJR PRVWUiQGRVH PX\ FRPSHWLWLYRV \ DQLPDQGR FRQJULWRVDVXVFRPSDxHURV1RVOODPDODDWHQFLyQHQHVWDRFDVLyQTXHPLHQWUDV/RODHV DQLPDGD SRU VXV FRPSDxHUDV FXDQGR OH WRFD SURWDJRQL]DU HO UHOHYR -RUGL HV LJQRUDGR SHUFLELpQGRVHSRUODDFWLWXGGHVXJUXSR±KDEODQGRHQWUHHOORVVLQPLUDUOR 3DUDILQDOL]DUVHFLHUUDODVHVLyQFRQHOMXHJRGH³PDWDU´ /RVMXJDGRUHVVHGLVWULEX\HQHQGRVJUXSRVVHSDUDGRVSRUXQDOtQHDFHQWUDO(OHVSDFLRHVWi GHOLPLWDGR(OREMHWLYRGHOMXHJRHVHOLPLQDUDOHTXLSRFRQWUDULR3DUDHOORFXDQGRVHODQ]DHO EDOyQ GH HVSXPD H LPSDFWD D XQ DGYHUVDULR WRFiQGROR HQ FXDOTXLHU SDUWH FRUSRUDO 5 5 5 5 5 5 5 5 H[FHSWXDQGR OD FDUD \ FDH SRVWHULRUPHQWH HO EDOyQ DO VXHOR VH FRQVLGHUD PXHUWR eVWH VH GHVSOD]D KDFLD HO H[WUHPR GHO FDPSR GH ORV MXJDGRUHV DGYHUVDULRV GHQRPLQDGD ]RQD GH PXHUWRV \ GHVGH DOOt LQWHQWD ³PDWDU´ D XQ DGYHUVDULR 'H QR FRQVHJXLUOR WLHQH TXH HVSHUDU KDVWDTXHVXVFRPSDxHURVOHSDVHQHOEDOyQRELHQTXHORSXHGDFRQVHJXLUSRUTXHHOEDOyQ KDHQWUDGRDVX]RQDGHMXHJRV /DYDULDQWHTXHSURSRQHHVTXHORVPXHUWRVSXHGHQGLVWULEXLUVHSRUODVWUHVOtQHDVODWHUDOHV GHORVH[WUHPRVGHOFDPSRFRQHOILQGHGLQDPL]DUPiVLQWHQVDPHQWHHOMXHJR 3UHJXQWDPRVDOJUXSRFODVHVtUHFXHUGDQODVDGDSWDFLRQHVSDUD/ROD\-RUGL\UiSLGDPHQWH FRQWHVWDXQRGHHOORVHVSHFLILFiQGRODV &XDQGRLQWHQWHQLPSDFWDUFRQHOEDOyQD-RUGLDQWHVWLHQHTXHGDUXQERWHHQHOVXHOR7DQWR D/RODFRPRDpVWHVHOHFRQFHGHQWUHVYLGDVWUHVRSRUWXQLGDGHVDQWHVGHSDVDUDOFDPSRGH PXHUWRVSDUDSURORQJDUVXSHUPDQHQFLDHQHOHVSDFLRGHMXHJR&XDQGRSRVHHQHOEDOyQH LQWHQWDQODQ]DUORFRQWUDVXVDGYHUVDULRVVHJULWD³VWRS´WHQLHQGRTXHSHUPDQHFHUHVWiWLFRVHQ HOHVSDFLR6tFRQVLJXHQLPSDFWDUFRQHOEDOyQDDOJ~QMXJDGRUVHFRQVLGHUDPXHUWR 6L/RODSDUWLFLSDPX\DFWLYDPHQWHOLGHUDQGRHQVXJUXSRODHODERUDFLyQGHHVWUDWHJLDVD-RUGL VHOHREVHUYDPiVSDVLYR$SHVDUGHTXHHQYDULDVRFDVLRQHVOHKDQSDVDGRHOEDOyQQRHV KDVWD HO ILQDO GHO MXHJR TXH UHFODPD OD SHORWD JULWDQGR ³VWRS´ WDO \ FRPR OR KDFH IUHFXHQWHPHQWH/ROD2EVHUYDPRVTXHVXJUXSRQROHIDFLOLWDHOEDOyQSRUORTXHOHSURYRFD XQHQIDGRGLFLHQGR³HVTXHQRPHKDFHQFDVR´SHURFXDQGRYDDLQWHUYHQLUODDX[LOLDUGH(( SDUDUHFRUGDUTXH-RUGLSDUWLFLSDHQODVPLVPDVFRQGLFLRQHVTXHORVGHPiVILQDOL]DHOMXHJR 1R REVWDQWH UHFRJHPRV TXH VRQ YDULDV ODV RFDVLRQHV TXH FXEUHQ D -RUGL SDUD TXH QR OH WRTXHHOEDOyQ\DVtPLVPROHKDQHPSXMDGRYDULDVYHFHVODVLOODSDUDIDFLOLWDUOHHOJLUR\SRGHU REVHUYDUDODGYHUVDULRFRQEDOyQ+DQSHUPDQHFLGRHQOD]RQDGHMXHJRVSHUGLHQGRDPERV WDQVyORXQDYLGD &RPHQWDULRVDODVHVLyQ /DVDGDSWDFLRQHVVRQDFHSWDGDVSRUWRGRV3DUHFHVHUTXH\DIRUPDSDUWHGHODGLQiPLFDGH ODVVHVLRQHV\TXHORVQLxRV\DODVWLHQHQLQWHJUDGDV 0LHQWUDV TXH HQ HO FDVR GH /ROD SHUFLELPRV TXH D SHQDV WLHQH GLILFXOWDG SDUD VHJXLU ODV SURSXHVWDV \ TXH OD UHVSXHVWD GHO JUXSR HV PX\ UHFHSWLYD HQ HO GHO -RUGL VH SHUFLEHQ GLIHUHQFLDV PX\ QRWDEOHV $ SHVDU GH ODV DGDSWDFLRQHV QR VH OH WLHQH WDQ SUHVHQWH HQ VLWXDFLRQHVFRPSHWLWLYDV(VXQDFXHVWLyQDWUDEDMDUFRQHOJUXSRFODVH 0H KD OODPDGR OD DWHQFLyQ HO FRPHQWDULR TXH PH KD KHFKR /ROD HQ OD KRUD GHO SDWLR ,QWHUSUHWR TXH KD FDSWDGR PL IXQFLyQ HQ OD FODVH \ YDORUR PX\ SRVLWLYDPHQWH VX UHVSXHVWD SRUTXHHVXQLQGLFDGRUGHTXHDFHSWDFRQQDWXUDOLGDGODVDGDSWDFLRQHVTXHOHSURSRQHPRV HQVLWXDFLRQHVTXHQRSXHGHSDUWLFLSDUFRQVXVFRPSDxHURV 5 5 5 5 5 6(6,Ï11 '((1(52'( /DVHVLyQGHOGtDGHKR\HVLPSDUWLGDSRUXQDSURIHVRUDLQYLWDGDGHOD)HGHUDFLyQ&DWDODQD GH9ROHLERO$LPDJHQGHODVVHVLRQHVDQWHULRUHVHQTXHVHKDGHVDUUROODGRHVWHFRQWHQLGR VHRSWDSRUUHDOL]DUXQWUDEDMRPiVLQGLYLGXDOL]DGRFRQ/ROD\-RUGLGHELGRDTXHODDOWXUDGH OD UHG HVH[FHVLYDSDUDHOORV$VtSXHV PLHQWUDV TXH HO UHVWRGHOJUXSRVHORFDOL]DHQXQD HVTXLQD GHO FDPSR SROLGHSRUWLYR DDPERV VH OHV VLW~D HQ OD HQWUDGD GH OD SLVWD FRQ OD UHG DGDSWDGDDVXDOWXUD /DSURSXHVWDGHDFWLYLGDGHVTXHUHDOL]DODDX[LOLDUGHHGXFDFLyQHVSHFLDOHVODTXHVLJXH 8QRHQIUHQWHGHORWURDXQDGLVWDQFLDGHXQRVWUHVPHWURV3DVHVGH GHGRVERWDQGRHOEDOyQHQWUHDPERV$YHUVLFRQVLJXHQUHDOL]DU SDVHVVHJXLGRV ËGHPSHURVLQERWH ËGHPFRQODUHG ËGHPDODQWHULRULQWURGXFLHQGRHOVDTXH 8QRHQIUHQWHGHORWURWLHQHQTXHUHDOL]DUWRTXHVGHDQWHEUD]R $ SHVDU GHO WUDEDMR PiV LQGLYLGXDOL]DGR VH PXHVWUDQ PX\ PRWLYDGRV SRU HO DSUHQGL]DMH /D LQWHUDFFLyQYHUEDOHQWUHDPERVHVPX\QXPHURVDHQGHWULPHQWRFRQHOUHVWRGHOJUXSRGDGD ODGLVWDQFLD &RPHQWDULRVDODVHVLyQ (O KHFKR GH UHDOL]DU DFWLYLGDGHV GH FDUiFWHU PiV LQGLYLGXDOL]DGR IDFLOLWD D SULRUL PiV LQWHUUHODFLyQSRVLWLYDHQWUH-RUGL\/RODHQGHWULPHQWRGHOUHVWRGHOJUXSR 6(6,Ï11 '((1(52'( 1RVHLPSDUWHODFODVHGH(GXFDFLyQ)tVLFDGHELGRDTXHHOJUXSRFODVHDVLVWHDXQDREUDGH WHDWUR 127$$&/$5$725,$ $SDUWLUGHODVLJXLHQWHVHVLyQKDVWDODGHOGtDGHIHEUHURLQFOXVLYHHOUHJLVWURORUHDOL]DOD DX[LOLDU GH (GXFDFLyQ (VSHFLDO GDGR TXH GXUDQWH HVDV GRV VHPDQDV FRRSHUR HQ OD 8QLYHUVLGDG1DFLRQDO$XWyQRPDGH1LFDUDJXD/HyQ1LFDUDJXD 5 5 5 5 6(6,Ï11 '((1(52'( (VWD VHVLyQ VH LPSDUWH DO LQLFLR HQ HO SDWLR SDVDQGR SRVWHULRUPHQWH DO JLPQDVLR 3DUD GLQDPL]DU DO JUXSR OD PDHVWUD SURSRQH XQ FDOHQWDPLHQWR EDVDGR HQ GHVSOD]DPLHQWRV HQ FDUUHUDFRPELQiQGRORVFRQGLVWLQWDVKDELOLGDGHVPRWULFHVHVSHFLDOPHQWHFRQVDOWRV0LHQWUDV TXH/RODSDUWLFLSDGHODWRWDOLGDGGHDFWLYLGDGHV-RUGLUHDOL]DXQWUDEDMRPiVLQGLYLGXDOL]DGR GLULJLGR SRU OD DX[LOLDU 6X UHFRUULGR HV SRU HO LQWHULRU GHO SDWLR VXVWLWX\HQGR ORV VDOWRV SRU HMHUFLFLRVGHIOH[LELOLGDGGHOWUHQVXSHULRU\FRPELQiQGRORFRQHMHUFLFLRVUHVSLUDWRULRV (QHOJLPQDVLRODPDHVWUDVXJLHUHDOJUXSRODUHDOL]DFLyQGHGLYHUVDVYROWHUHWDV/RODSDUWLFLSD VLQ GLILFXOWDG JHQHUDQGR \ UHFLELHQGR LQWHUDFFLRQHV SRVLWLYDV FRQ ORV FRPSDxHURV PiV SUy[LPRV (Q FDPELR-RUGLDOWHQHUTXHUHDOL]DU XQWUDEDMRPiVLQGLYLGXDOL]DGRFRQODDX[LOLDUGH(( VXV LQWHUDFFLRQHV VRQ PX\ UHGXFLGDV JHQHUDGRV SRU OD DSUR[LPDFLyQ GH DOJ~Q FRPSDxHUR SDUDDQLPDUOR /DVWDUHDVTXHSURSRQHODDX[LOLDUVRQ FXDWURVHULHVGHDEGRPLQDOHV JLURVHQVHQWLGRKRUL]RQWDOVREUHODFROFKRQHWDFURTXHWD ËGHPFRQSHORWD /DDX[LOLDUIUHQWHDpODXQDGLVWDQFLDGHXQRVGRVPHWURVUHDOL]DFLyQGH GLYHUVRVSDVHVFRQSHORWD 6HKDREVHUYDGRDXQ-RUGLPX\PRWLYDGRSRUODVWDUHDVDOWHUQDWLYDVDSHVDUGHOWUDEDMRPiV LQGLYLGXDOL]DGR &RPHQWDULRVDODVHVLyQ 6HFRQVWDWDTXHHOWUDEDMRLQGLYLGXDOL]DGRQRIDFLOLWDODVLQWHUDFFLRQHVFRQORVFRPSDxHURVGHO JUXSRFODVH 6(6,Ï11 '((1(52'( (OSULPHUMXHJRHV³WRFDU\SDUDU´ (OJUXSRFODVHHVWiGLVSHUVRHQXQHVSDFLRGHOLPLWDGR\FXDWURQLxRV³SDUDQ´&XDQGRVHGD OD VHxDO GH LQLFLR pVWRV WLHQHQ TXH LQWHQWDU HOLPLQDU D VXV DGYHUVDULRV WRFiQGROHV FRQ OD PDQRHQDOJXQDSDUWHGHOFXHUSR(QHOPRPHQWRTXHORFRQVLJXHQORVTXHHVWiQWRFDGRVVH WUDVODGDQDOFDPSRGHHOLPLQDGRV*DQDHOMXJDGRUTXHVHTXHGHHO~OWLPRVLQWRFDU $DPERVVHOHVRWRUJDQWUHVYLGDV\SDUDWRFDUDXQFRPSDxHURWLHQHTXHSDVDUDXQPHWUR GHGLVWDQFLD\GHFLUVXQRPEUH 5 5 5 5 5 5 5 5 /RODSDUWLFLSDPX\DFWLYDPHQWHFRPRHVKDELWXDOHQHOODGHPRVWUDQGRJUDQFRPSHWLWLYLGDGH LQWHUpV SRU OD HYROXFLyQ GHO MXHJR &XDQGR HV HOLPLQDGD VH VLW~D MXQWR DO JUXSR GH QLxDV LQWHUDFFLRQDQGRFRQVWDQWHPHQWHFRQpVWDV 5HVSHFWRD-RUGLGHERUHJLVWUDUVXFRPSRUWDPLHQWRHQOD]RQDGHMXHJRV6HPXHVWUDPX\ QHUYLRVRJLUDQGRODVLOODPX\EUXVFDPHQWHSRUORTXHODDX[LOLDUGH((OHOODPDODDWHQFLyQ FRPHQWiQGROHTXHGHEHWHQHUPXFKRPiVFXLGDGR\PHGLUVXVUHDFFLRQHVSRUTXHGHQRVHU DVtSXHGHFDHU\OHVLRQDUVH 3RVWHULRUPHQWHODPDHVWUDSURSRQHTXHVHSRQJDQSRUSDUHMDVSDUDUHDOL]DUSDVHVFRQEDOyQ &RPR D -RUGL OH WRFD FRQ &DUORV TXH HVWDED MXQWR D pO HO GtD TXH VH IUDFWXUy HO IpPXU VH HQIDGD /D DX[LOLDU WLHQH TXH LQWHUFHGHU SDUD UHFRUGDUOH TXH &DUORV QR WXYR OD FXOSD GH VX FDtGD \ TXH IXH DFFLGHQWDO LQVLVWLHQGR TXH IXH XQ KHFKR SXQWXDO \ TXH PHMRU TXH SRQJD SUHFDXFLRQHVSHURTXHQRSLHQVHFRQVWDQWHPHQWHHQHOORSRUTXHGHVHUDVtOREORTXHDUi$O ILQDOFRQVLJXHTXHSDUWLFLSHFRQ&DUORV 3DUDILQDOL]DUODPDHVWUDSURSRQHDFWLYLGDGHVFRQSHORWDGHYROHLEROSRUSDUHMDVGLVWULEXLGDV OLEUHPHQWHSRUHOHVSDFLR-RUGLUHDOL]DXQWUDEDMRLQGLYLGXDOL]DGREDVDGRHQWRTXHVGHGHGRV \GHVDTXHVPLHQWUDVTXH/RODSDUWLFLSDVLQGLILFXOWDG &RPHQWDULRVDODVHVLyQ 6RUSUHQGHODUHDFFLyQGH-RUGLFXDQGRVHHQIDGDHQHOMXHJRJLUDQGRODVLOODEUXVFDPHQWH SRUORTXHSXHGHVXSRQHUOHXQDFDtGD\VRUSUHQGHWDPELpQVXUHDFFLyQDQWHHOFRPSDxHUR TXHHVWDEDSUy[LPRDpOHOGtDGHODIUDFWXUDGHOIpPXU 6(6,Ï11 '()(%5(52'( 6H LQLFLD OD VHVLyQ FRQ GHVSOD]DPLHQWR HQ FDUUHUD DOUHGHGRU GHO SDWLR /D DGDSWDFLyQ SDUD -RUGL\/RODHVODKDELWXDOUHDOL]DQGRHOUHFRUULGRSRUHOLQWHULRUGHOFDPSR\UHGXFLpQGROR 0LHQWUDVTXH/RODSDUWLFLSDVLQGLILFXOWDGODDX[LOLDUREVHUYDTXHWLHQHTXHUHFRUGDUD-RUGLOD DGDSWDFLyQ6HJ~QVXRSLQLyQFRPHQWDTXHD-RUGLVHOHWLHQHQTXHUHFRUGDUFRQVWDQWHPHQWH ODVDGDSWDFLRQHVSRUTXHHVWiKDELWXDGRDODGHSHQGHQFLDFRQHODGXOWR\FRPRH[SUHVDHOOD ³HVWiPX\DFRVWXPEUDGRTXHXQDGXOWRHVWpSHQGLHQWHGHpO´ 3RVWHULRUPHQWHODPDHVWUDSURSRQHHO³UHOHYRHQFDUUHUD´ 2UJDQL]D FLQFR JUXSRV GH FXDWUR QLxRV HQ ILOD /D GLVWDQFLD HQWUH JUXSRV HV GH XQRV WUHV PHWURV6LWXDGRVWUDVXQDOtQHDGHVDOLGDHOSULPHUPLHPEURFRQXQDURSHTXHxRHQODPDQR WLHQH TXH GHVSOD]DUVH HQ FDUUHUD KDVWD OOHJDU DO H[WUHPR GHO FDPSR PHWURV GRQGH OH HVSHUD XQ MXJDGRU GHO HTXLSR /H SDVD HO DUR \ VH TXHGD HQ HVH OXJDU PLHQWUDV TXH VX FRPSDxHURLQLFLDHOUHFRUULGRDODLQYHUVD\DVtVXFHVLYDPHQWHKDVWDTXHHO~OWLPRMXJDGRUGH XQJUXSROOHJDDVHUHOSULPHURHQOOHJDUDODOtQHDGHLQLFLR 5 5 5 5 5 5 5 5 &RPRHQRFDVLRQHVVLPLODUHV-RUGLSLHUGHWLHPSRHQHODUUDQTXHGHODVLOODGHUXHGDV\VX YHORFLGDG HV PHQRU TXH OD GH VXV DGYHUVDULRV GHFLGLpQGRVH TXH UHFRUUHUi XQ WHUFLR GHO UHFRUULGRGHWDOPDQHUDTXHXQFRPSDxHURVHVLW~DDXQRVPHWURVSDUDFRJHUHODUR\VHOR SDVD DO FRPSDxHUR TXH HVWi DO RWUR H[WUHPR GHO FDPSR pVWH LQLFLD GH QXHYR HO UHFRUULGR KDFLD-RUGLSDViQGROHHODURSDUDTXHORWUDVODGHDOLQLFLRGHODILOD /D DFWLWXG UHJLVWUDGD GH -RUGL HV SDVLYD SHUGLHQGR LQFOXVR OD YHQWDMD RWRUJDGD &XDQGR OD DX[LOLDUOHSUHJXQWDVREUHVXFRPSRUWDPLHQWRpOOHUHVSRQGHFRQ³QRSXHGRFRUUHUPiVSRUTXH PH GXHOH OD HVSDOGD´ eVWD LQWHUSUHWD TXH HVWi PLQWLHQGR GDGR TXH ~OWLPDPHQWH DEXVD GH HOOR /H UHFXHUGD TXH D SHVDU GH TXH VHD XQD FRPSHWLFLyQ OR LPSRUWDQWH HV SDUWLFLSDU \ FRODERUDUFRQVXJUXSR6HJ~QODDX[LOLDUFRQVLGHUDTXH-RUGLUHFXUUHDODPHQWLUDSRUTXHHV XQDIRUPDGHGHIHQGHUVHDQWHVXVOLPLWDFLRQHV (QFDPELR/RODSDUWLFLSDHQLJXDOGDGGHFRQGLFLRQHVTXHHOUHVWRGHFRPSDxHURVJHQHUDQGR LQWHUDFFLRQHVSRVLWLYDVFRQORVPLHPEURVGHVXJUXSR /DWHUFHUDSURSXHVWDHVHOMXHJR³TXHQRFDLJDODSLFD´ (O JUXSR FODVH HQ FtUFXOR D XQD GLVWDQFLD HQWUH MXJDGRU GH XQ PHWUR \ PHGLR VRVWHQLHQGR FDGDXQRGHHOORVXQDSLFDGHSOiVWLFR$ODVHxDO\HQVHQWLGRGHODVDJXMDVGHOUHORMGHMDQ VXSLFD\WLHQHQTXHFRJHUODGHOFRPSDxHURTXHWLHQHQDGHODQWHDQWHVGHTXHFDLJDDOVXHOR /DDX[LOLDURSWDSRUUHDOL]DUXQWUDEDMRPiVLQGLYLGXDOL]DGRIDFLOLWiQGROHXQDSLFDGHWDPDxR PiVSHTXHxD6HVLW~DHQIUHQWHGH-RUGLDXQDGLVWDQFLDGHXQPHWUR\PHGLR&XDQGRHOOD VXHOWDODSLFDpVWHGHEHFRJHUODDQWHVGHTXHFDLJDDOVXHOR /DSURSXHVWDHVPX\ELHQDFHSWDGDSRU-RUGLPRVWUiQGRVHPRWLYDGRSRUODDFWLYLGDG'DGDV ODVFDUDFWHUtVWLFDVGHODWDUHDODLQWHUDFFLyQFRQHOJUXSRFODVHHVPX\SXQWXDO 5HVSHFWRD/RODDQRWDUTXHSDUWLFLSDFRQHOUHVWRGHOJUXSRVLQGLILFXOWDGHYLGHQWHJHQHUDQGR UHODFLRQHVSRVLWLYDVFRQVXVFRPSDxHURVPiVSUy[LPRV &RPHQWDULRVDODVHVLyQ /ODPDODDWHQFLyQHOFRPSRUWDPLHQWRGH-RUGLHQODVGRVSULPHUDVDFWLYLGDGHV(OKHFKRGH WHQHUTXHUHFRUGDUODVDGDSWDFLRQHVKDELWXDOHVHQODVGRVSULPHUDVDFWLYLGDGHVKDFHSHQVDU TXHWLHQHTXHGLVPLQXLUODGHSHQGHQFLDFRQODDX[LOLDUGH(( 7DPELpQHVLQWHUHVDQWHUHJLVWUDUODDSUHFLDFLyQTXHKDFHpVWDVREUHODUHFXUUHQFLDGH-RUGL DODPHQWLUDFXDQGRVHHYLGHQFLDQVXVOLPLWDFLRQHV 6(6,Ï11 '()(%5(52'( /D VHVLyQ JLUD VREUH HO FRQWHQLGR GHO YROHLERO 6LJXLHQGR OD GLQiPLFD KDELWXDO OD PDHVWUD GLVWULEX\HDOJUXSRFODVHHQOD]RQDGHODUHGVLWXDGDDXQH[WUHPRGHOFDPSRH[FHSWXDQGR D/ROD\D-RUGLTXHVHORFDOL]DQDODHQWUDGDGHOSDWLRFRQXQDUHGDGDSWDGDDVXDOWXUD 5 5 5 5 5 5 5 5 5 0LHQWUDVTXHHOUHVWRGHOJUXSRFODVHUHDOL]DGLYHUVRVJHVWRVWpFQLFRV/ROD\-RUGLMXQWRDOD DX[LOLDUGH((HIHFW~DQDFWLYLGDGHVVLPLODUHVDODVHVLyQQ~PHURGHOGHHQHUR3HURD GLIHUHQFLDGHpVWD/RODVHPXHVWUDFRQWUDUtDGHUHDOL]DUODVHVLyQFRQ-RUGLPDQLIHVWDQGRVX LQWHUpV SRU FRPSDUWLU ODV DFWLYLGDGHV FRQ RWUD FRPSDxHUD $QWH HO FRQIOLFWR LQWHUYLHQH OD PDHVWUD \ FRPHQWD TXH OD UHG HV PX\ DOWD SHUR DQWH OD LQVLVWHQFLD RSWD SRU GHMDU D /ROD SDUWLFLSDUFRQHOUHVWR<FRPRHUDSUHYLVLEOH/RODQRFRQWURODODVLWXDFLyQSRUORTXHSURSRQH D VX FRPSDxHUD OOHYDU D FDER ODV SURSXHVWDV XWLOL]DQGR FRPR UHG OD EDUDQGLOOD GHO SDWLR VLWXiQGRVHHQODSDUWHPiVDOWD3HURFRPRODGLILFXOWDGHUDPD\RUSDUDODFRPSDxHUDGHELGR DTXHODEDUDQGLOODHVWDEDH[FHVLYDPHQWHDOWDSDUDHOODDFDEDHQIDGiQGRVHFRQ/ROD$QWH HOOR/RODVHTXHGDVHQWDGDPRVWUiQGRVHPX\FRQWUDULDGDHQHOEDQFRGHOSDWLRMXQWRDXQD FRPSDxHUDTXHHVWiOHVLRQDGD &XDQGR VH TXHGD VROR -RUGL GHFLGH GHVSOD]DUVH KDFLD OD SRUWHUtD GH I~WERO /D DX[LOLDU REVHUYDTXHMXHJDVRORGHIRUPDVLPEyOLFDDVHUSRUWHURGHI~WERO\TXHVHORHVWiSDVDQGR ELHQ/HSURSRQHMXJDUFRQpODSHQDOWLVORTXHDFHSWDPX\PRWLYDGR(OODOHODQ]DHOEDOyQ FRQ OD PDQR \ pO WLHQH TXH SDUDUOD 3RVWHULRUPHQWH OR KDFH FRQ HO SLH $FXHUGDQ TXH VL HO EDOyQ WRFD SUHYLDPHQWHDODVLOODDSHVDU GH TXH VH KD\D LQWURGXFLGR HQ OD SRUWHUtD QR VH FRQVLGHUDJRO 6H REVHUYD D XQ -RUGL PX\ PRWLYDGR SRU OD SUiFWLFD TXH pO GHFLGH D SHVDU GH TXH ODV LQWHUDFFLRQHVWDQVyORVRQFRQHODGXOWR &RPHQWDULRVDODVHVLyQ 6RUSUHQGHODUHDFFLyQGH/RODDOQRTXHUHUSDUWLFLSDUFRQ-RUGLGHIRUPDPiVLQGLYLGXDOL]DGD 5 5 6(6,Ï11 5 6(6,Ï11 6(6,Ï11 '()(%5(52'( 1RVHLPSDUWLyODVHVLyQGH(GXFDFLyQ)tVLFDSRUTXHHOJUXSRFODVHVHGHVSOD]yDO0XVHRGH OD&LHQFLD '()(%5(52'( /DVHVLyQVHGHVDUUROOyHQHODXODSRUTXHHUDXQGtDOOXYLRVR/DPDHVWUDLPSDUWLyHOWHPDGH ODVFDSDFLGDGHVItVLFDVEiVLFDV7DQWR/RODFRPR-RUGLVHPRVWUDURQUHFHSWLYRV '()(%5(52'( $QWHV GH LQLFLDUVH OD VHVLyQ /ROD VH DSUR[LPD D Pt SDUD FRPHQWDUPH TXH HVD WDUGH OD KRVSLWDOL]DEDQSDUDRSHUDUOHGHORVIpPXUHVSDUDDODUJDUORV0HVRUSUHQGHFRQODQDWXUDOLGDG 5 5 5 FRQTXHORFRPHQWDSDUHFHDSULRULQRHVWDUQHUYLRVDSRUHODFRQWHFLPLHQWR /D VHVLyQ VH LPSDUWH HQ HO JLPQDVLR LQLFLiQGRVH FRQ GHVSOD]DPLHQWRV DOUHGHGRU GH XQRV EDQFRVVLWXDGRVHQFtUFXOR0LHQWUDVTXHHOJUXSRFODVHORKDFHSRUHOH[WHULRU/ROD\-RUGLOR KDFHQSRUHOLQWHULRUGLVPLQX\HQGRGHHVDPDQHUDHOHVSDFLRDUHFRUUHU 3RVWHULRUPHQWH OD PDHVWUD SURSRQH TXH UHDOLFHQ GLYHUVRV VDOWRV FRPELQDGRV FRQ FDUUHUD /ROD VLJXH HO ULWPR GH VXV FRPSDxHURV PDUFDQGR ORV VDOWRV \ -RUGL VXEVWLWX\H ORV VDOWRV VHJ~QODVHxDOGHODPDHVWUD\SRULQGLFDFLRQHVGHODDX[LOLDUFRQODSDUDGDGHODVLOOD $ FRQWLQXDFLyQ OD PDHVWUD FRORFD FXDWUR EDQFRV SDUDOHORV D XQD GLVWDQFLD GH XQRV WUHV PHWURVHQWUHEDQFR\EDQFR(OJUXSRFODVHWLHQHTXHUHDOL]DUGLVWLQWRVWLSRVGHVDOWRV&RPR pVWRV HVWiQ FRQWUDLQGLFDGRV SDUD /ROD \ -RUGL OD DX[LOLDU GH (( OHV SURSRQH XQD DFWLYLGDG DOWHUQDWLYD 6LW~D VHLV FRQRV HQ OtQHD D XQD GLVWDQFLD HQWUH FRQR \ FRQR GH XQ PHWUR \ PHGLR DSUR[LPDGDPHQWH 6HJ~Q ODV FRQVLJQDV GH OD DX[LOLDU WLHQHQ TXH FRUUHU HQWUH FRQR \ FRQR KDFLD DGHODQWH \ KDFLD DWUiV 3RVWHULRUPHQWH /ROD VH GHVSOD]D ODWHUDOPHQWH PLHQWUDV TXH -RUGLUHDOL]DXQJLURGHJUDGRVFDGDGRVFRQRVËGHPSHUR/RODVHGHVSOD]DOLEUHPHQWH\ -RUGLUHDOL]DHOJLURGHJUDGRVHQFDGDFRQRUHJUHVDQGRHQFDUUHUDKDFLDDGHODQWH\HQ ]LJ]DJ&XDQGRLQGLFDD-RUGLTXHGHFLGDODIRUPDGHGHVSOD]DUVH/RODHVUHFODPDGDSRUOD PDHVWUD SDUD TXH SDVH SRU GHEDMR GH ORV EDQFRV UHSWDFLRQHV D LPDJHQ TXH HO UHVWR GH FODVH +DVWDHVHPRPHQWRODVLQWHUDFFLRQHVVRQPX\HVFDVDVHQWUH-RUGL\/RODVHJ~QODDX[LOLDU -RUGLHVWiPX\SUHRFXSDGRSRUTXHWDPELpQORKRVSLWDOL]DQHVDVHPDQD &RPRHOJUXSRSUDFWLFDUHSWDFLRQHVGHFLGLPRVTXH-RUGLWDPELpQODVUHDOLFH/DDX[LOLDUGH(( ORGHVSOD]DDOVXHOR'HIRUPDDOWHUQDWLYDFRQODDX[LOLDUVRVWHQHPRVXQDURYHUWLFDOTXHHVWi HQFRQWDFWRFRQHOVXHORGHWDOIRUPDTXH-RUGLWLHQHTXHSDVDUHQWUHDUR\DURTXHHVWiQD XQDGLVWDQFLDGHXQPHWUR\PHGLRKDVWDOOHJDUDOFXDUWRDURUHJUHVDQGRGHQXHYRDOSXQWR GH VDOLGD &XDQGR HO JUXSR FODVH REVHUYD OD HYROXFLyQ GH pVWH HQ HO VXHOR OR DQLPDQ YHUEDOPHQWHUHFRQRFLHQGRVXVFDSDFLGDGHV &RPRSHQ~OWLPDDFWLYLGDGODPDHVWUDFRORFDFXDWURVEDQFRVVXHFRVHQOtQHD DxDGLHQGRXQDFROFKRQHWD 7LHQHQTXHUHSWDUERFDDEDMRKDVWDOOHJDUDOILQDOGHOUHFRUULGRDFRQWLQXDFLyQUHDOL]DQXQD YROWHUHWDVREUHODFROFKRQHWD /ROD OOHYD D FDER OD WDUHD VLQ GLILFXOWDG HVWDEOHFLHQGR FRQYHUVDFLRQHV FRQ ORV FRPSDxHURV PiVSUy[LPRV&XDQGRLQFRUSRUDPRVD-RUGLHQHOLQLFLRGHOUHFRUULGRHOJUXSRVHTXHGDHQ VLOHQFLR D PHGLGD TXH SURJUHVD SRU ORV EDQFRV HV DQLPDGR FRQ DSODXVRV &RPR QR HV DFRQVHMDEOH OD YROWHUHWD RSWDPRV SRUTXH UHDOLFH JLURV HQ HO HMH KRUL]RQWDO OD FURTXHWD $O ILQDOL]DUHOUHFRUULGRREVHUYDPRVDXQ-RUGLULVXHxR 3DUDILQDOL]DUODPDHVWUDSURSRQH³YROWHUHWDV´ 'HWUHVHQWUHV\FRJLGRVSRUODPDQRVREUHODFROFKRQHWDTXLWDPLHGRV 5 5 5 5 5 5 5 /ROD SDUWLFLSD DFWLYDPHQWH JHQHUDQGR FRQYHUVDFLRQHV FRQWLQXDGDPHQWH /XHJR OD PDHVWUD LQWURGXFHXQDYDOODSDUDSDVDUSRUHOOD\UHDOL]DUSRVWHULRUPHQWHODYROWHUHWD(QHVHPRPHQWR /RODVHDSUR[LPDDOD]RQDGRQGHHVWDPRVORFDOL]DGRV-RUGLODDX[LOLDU\\R-RUGL\DKDEtD ILQDOL]DGRVXVHULHGHDEGRPLQDOHV\HQHVHPRPHQWRHVWDEDUHFLELHQGRXQPDVDMHSRUSDUWH GHODDX[LOLDU/HSURSRQJRD/RODTXHVHWXPEHSDUDUHODMDUVH\FRQVLJRDWUDYpVGHOPDVDMH XQD PD\RU GLVWHQVLyQ $Vt PLVPR OD DX[LOLDU DSURYHFKD SDUD UHODWLYL]DUOH D -RUGL VX KRVSLWDOL]DFLyQ &RPHQWDULRVDODVHVLyQ (V FXULRVR OD UHDFFLyQ GH DPERV DQWH OD KRVSLWDOL]DFLyQ 0LHQWUDV TXH /ROD SDUHFH TXH OR DFHSWD FRQ OD Pi[LPD QRUPDOLGDG D SHVDU GH VX SUHRFXSDFLyQ -RUGL HVWi PXFKR PiV FHUUDGRQRJHQHUDQGRLQWHUDFFLyQFRQVXDOUHGHGRU 9DORUDPRV HQ HO GtD GH KR\ PX\ LQWHUHVDQWH HO HVSDFLR GH OD UHODMDFLyQ GDGR TXH KHPRV FRQVHJXLGRDSUR[LPDUQRVDVXSUHRFXSDFLyQ\KHPRVFRQWULEXLGRDUHODWLYL]DUVXVDQJXVWLDV 5 5 6(6,21(61 6(6,Ï11 \'()(%5(52'( 1L-RUGLQL/RODDVLVWHQDOFHQWURSRUHQFRQWUDUVHKRVSLWDOL]DGRV(OSULPHURGHELGRDTXHWLHQH TXHUHFLELUXQWUDWDPLHQWRSDUDIRUWDOHFHUVXHVWUXFWXUDyVHD\ODVHJXQGDWDO\FRPRLQGLFR HQODVHVLyQDQWHULRUSRUTXHOHKDQRSHUDGRGHDPERVIpPXUHVFRQHOREMHWRGHLQFUHPHQWDU VXHVWDWXUD '(0$5=2'( /RODVLJXHDXVHQWHSRUODRSHUDFLyQ /DPDHVWUDLQLFLDODVHVLyQFRQXQDVYXHOWDVDOSDWLR\DWRTXHGHVLOEDWRUHDOL]DQGLYHUVDV PRGDOLGDGHVGHVDOWR/DDGDSWDFLyQTXHSURSRQHODDX[LOLDUGH((SDUD-RUGLHVTXHDFDGD WUHVWRTXHVGHVLOEDWRGHEHUHDOL]DUXQJLURFRQODVLOODGH /DVLJXLHQWHWDUHDFRQVLVWHHQ³GHVSOD]DUVHFRRSHUDWLYDPHQWH´ (OJUXSRFODVHHQGRVILODVPLUDQGRKDFLDHOPLVPRODWHUDOODVGRV/RVTXHTXHGDQGHWUiV DJDUUDQODFLQWXUDGHOTXHWLHQHQGHODQWH/RVGHODILODGHODQWHUDVHFRJHQGHODVPDQRV$OD VHxDOFRUUHQWRGRVDODYH] /DDGDSWDFLyQSDUD-RUGLHVODGHVLWXDUORDXQH[WUHPRGHODSULPHUDILODVLJXLHQGRHOPLVPR UHFRUULGR \ DO PLVPR ULWPR TXH HO UHVWR GHO JUXSR 6H REVHUYD TXH SDUWLFLSD FRQ LQWHUpV JHQHUDQGRLQWHUDFFLRQHVYHUEDOHVFRQORVFRPSDxHURVPiVSUy[LPRV 5 5 5 5 5 6H SURSRQHODYDULDQWHGHLUHQJUXSRV GH WUHVHQOtQHDFRJLGRVGHODVPDQRV\DODVHxDO GHEHQ GHVSOD]DUVH KDVWD HO ILQDO GHO SDWLR (Q HVWH FDVR -RUGL VH VLW~D HQ OD PLWDG GHO UHFRUULGRLQWHQWDQGRLQFRUSRUDUVHDOJUXSRMXVWRFXDQGROOHJDQDOILQDOGHOUHFRUULGR (QODVLJXLHQWHSURSXHVWDORVWUtRVIRUPDQXQFtUFXORFRJLGRVGHODVPDQRVGHVSOD]iQGRVHD ODYH]KDVWDHOILQDOGHOSDWLR(QHVWHRFDVLyQDLPDJHQGHODVLWXDFLyQDQWHULRU-RUGLVHVLW~D HQODPLWDGGHOUHFRUULGR (QHVWDVGRV~OWLPDVDFWLYLGDGHV-RUGLHVWiLQFOXLGRHQHOJUXSRGHQLxRVFRPRHVKDELWXDO /yJLFDPHQWHVHJHQHUDQPiVLQWHUDFFLRQHVYHUEDOHVFXDQGRVHHQFXHQWUDQWRGRVHQODOtQHD ILQDOGHOSDWLRFRPHQWDQGRODMXJDGD 3RVWHULRUPHQWHSURSRQHHOMXHJRGH³ORFDOL]DUDOFRPSDxHUR´ (O JUXSR VHRUJDQL]DSRUSDUHMDV$ODVHxDOVHVHSDUDQODVSDUHMDVVHGLVSHUVDQ\FRUUHQ OLEUHPHQWHSRUHOHVSDFLR$ODQXHYDVHxDOVHWUDWDGHORFDOL]DUDOFRPSDxHUR\UHXQLUVH 6HUHDOL]DXQDYDULDQWHGLYLGLHQGRHQGRVHOHVSDFLR$FDGDODGRKDEUiXQPLHPEURGHFDGD SDUHMD &RUUHQ OLEUHPHQWH HQ FDGD XQR GH ORV HVSDFLRV $ OD VHxDO GHEHQ IRUPDUVH ODV SDUHMDVHQODOtQHDGHGLYLVLyQ 6H REVHUYD TXH -RUGL VH GHVSOD]D SUy[LPR D OD OtQHD FHQWUDO GH GLYLVLyQ SDUWLFLSDQGR DFWLYDPHQWHGHODDFWLYLGDG\PRVWUiQGRVHPX\FRPSHWLWLYR &RQWLQ~DFRQHOMXHJRGH³DYHUTXLpQOOHJDDQWHV´ 6LJXLHQGRFRQODGLYLVLyQGHOHVSDFLRHQGRVORVPLHPEURVGHFDGDSDUHMDVHVLW~DQD FDGDODGRGHODOtQHDGLYLVRULDDXQRVPGHGLVWDQFLDGHHOODGHWDOPDQHUDTXHFDGD SDUHMDTXHGDFDUDDFDUD$ODVHxDOVHWUDWDGHYHUTXpSDUHMDVHUH~QHDQWHVHQODOtQHD GLYLVRULD /D DGDSWDFLyQ SDUD -RUGL HV OD GH UHGXFLU HQ VX GLVWDQFLD GH OD OtQHD GLYLVRULD /D DGDSWDFLyQHVDFHSWDGDFRQWRWDOQRUPDOLGDGSRUWRGRVREVHUYiQGRVHDXQ-RUGLPX\DFWLYR\ SDUWLFLSDWLYR 3DUDILQDOL]DUVHSURSRQHHOMXHJRGHO³SDxXHOR´ /RVGRVJUXSRVIUHQWHSRUIUHQWHDXQDGLVWDQFLDPtQLPDGHPHWURV(QODPLWDGGH ODGLVWDQFLDHOMXJDGRUTXHVRVWLHQHHOSDxXHORDOLQHDGRFRQORV~OWLPRVMXJDGRUHVGH XQ H[WUHPR /RV MXJDGRUHV VH QXPHUDQ HQ VHFUHWR HYLWDQGR TXH VX Q~PHUR VHD FRQRFLGRSRUHOHTXLSRFRQWUDULR(OMXJDGRUTXHVRVWLHQHHOSDxXHORGLUiXQQ~PHUR FRPSUHQGLGR HQ HO Q~PHUR WRWDO GH MXJDGRUHV GH FDGD HTXLSR /RV MXJDGRUHV TXH WHQJDQ HVH Q~PHUR GHEHUiQ FRUUHU KDVWD HO SDxXHOR FRQVHJXLUOR \ UHJUHVDU D VX HTXLSR DQWHV GH TXH VHD WRFDGR SRU HO FRPSDxHUR DGYHUVDULR /RV MXJDGRUHV TXH QR KDQFRQVHJXLGROOHJDUDVXHTXLSRFRQHOSDxXHORRORVWRFDGRVHQVXLQWHQWRVHUiQ HOLPLQDGRV /RV SDUWLFLSDQWHV TXH TXHGHQ LUiQ DVXPLHQGR ORV Q~PHURV GH ORV HOLPLQDGRVVHJ~QVXFULWHULR/RVHOLPLQDGRVSRGUiQVHUVDOYDGRVVLHQHOUHFRUULGRGH UHJUHVRHOFRPSDxHURTXHWLHQHHOSDxXHORORVWRFD3DUDHOORVHDFXHUGDSUHYLDPHQWH 5 5 5 5 5 5 5 5 XQD ]RQD GRQGH HVWiQ ORFDOL]DGRV IRUPDQGR XQD FDGHQD GiQGRVH OD PDQR GH WDO IRUPD TXH VL VDOYDQ DO SULPHUR pVWH SDVD OD FRUULHQWH DO UHVWR GH FRPSDxHURV HOLPLQDGRVVDOYiQGRVHWRGRV (QHVWHMXHJRKDKDELGRPXFKDVGLILFXOWDGHVSDUDSRGHUFRPSHQVDUODPRYLOLGDGUHGXFLGDGH -RUGL(QXQSULQFLSLRODQLxDTXHWLHQHHOPLVPRQ~PHURTXH-RUGLFRUUHPXFKR\DXQTXHVH KDDFRUGDGRTXHVHGHEtDUHDOL]DUXQVDOWRDODSDWDFRMDHQHOPRPHQWRGHODVDOLGDSDUD FRPSHQVDU HO WLHPSR GH DUUDQTXH GH OD VLOOD GH UXHGDV QR HV VXILFLHQWH SDUD HTXLSDUDU D -RUGLDSHVDUTXHpVWHHVWiPiVDYDQ]DGR /DPDHVWUDGHFLGHFRQWLQXDUFRQODUHGXFFLyQGHODGLVWDQFLD\FDPELDUDODDGYHUVDULDSRU XQDMXJDGRUDPiVOHQWDFRQODFRQVLJQDGHYHUTXLpQOOHJDDQWHVDOSDxXHORHOLPLQDQGROD SHUVHFXFLyQSRVWHULRU3URSRQHDGHPiVTXHHOMXJDGRUTXHOOHJXHDQWHVDOSDxXHORQRWDQ VyOR FRQVLJXH HOLPLQDU D VX DGYHUVDULR VLQR DGHPiV ORJUD VDOYDU D WRGRV VXV FRPSDxHURV HOLPLQDGRV$QRWRTXHWDOHVPHGLGDVQRVRQELHQUHFLELGDVSRUWUHVFRPSDxHURVGHOHTXLSR FRQWUDULRPRVWUiQGRVHGHVFRQWHQWRV(VSRUHOORTXHWDQWRODPDHVWUDFRPRODDX[LOLDUGH(( VH GLULJHQ DO JUXSR FRQ HO ILQ GH KDFHUOHV FRPSUHQGHU GH OD QHFHVLGDG GH FRPSHQVDU ODV OLPLWDFLRQHVPHGLDQWHODVDGDSWDFLRQHV 'HODVWUHVRFDVLRQHVTXHHVQRPEUDGRHOQ~PHURGH-RUGLWDQVyORHVHQODWHUFHUDHQTXH OOHJDDQWHVGHODGYHUVDULRORTXHSURYRFDTXHMDVSRUSDUWHGHXQFRPSDxHURGHHTXLSR-RUGL OHUHVSRQGHFRQXQ³\RQRWHQJRODFXOSD´MXVWLILFiQGRVHGHHVWDPDQHUDGHVXVOLPLWDFLRQHV 3HUR FXDQGR FRQVLJXH HQ OD ~OWLPD UHSHWLFLyQ OOHJDU DQWHV DO SDxXHOR TXH VX DGYHUVDULR VDOYDQGRFRQVHFXHQWHPHQWHDOUHVWRGHFRPSDxHURVTXHHVWiQHOLPLQDGRVUHFLEHPXOWLWXGGH PXHVWUDVGHDOHJUtD\DJUDGHFLPLHQWR2EVHUYDPRVTXHVDOHGHODVHVLyQPX\UHIRU]DGRSRU ORTXHODDX[LOLDUGH((OHWLHQHTXHUHFRUGDUTXHQRSUHVXPDGHVXp[LWRDQWHORVDGYHUVDULRV PiVFRPSHWLWLYRVSRUTXHSRUXQODGRWLHQHQGLILFXOWDGGHDFHSWDUODVDGDSWDFLRQHV\SRUTXH DGHPiVDSHVDUGHTXHpOKD\DOXFKDGRSRUODYLFWRULDOHUHFXHUGDTXHHVSRVLEOHSRUTXHVH SURSRQHQODVDGDSWDFLRQHV &RPHQWDULRVDODVHVLyQ 3HUFLELPRV TXH HQ GHWHUPLQDGDV VLWXDFLRQHV XQ VHFWRU GH OD FODVH HVWi HQ FRQWUD GH ODV DGDSWDFLRQHVSRUTXHFRQVLGHUDQTXHVHOHGDPXFKDYHQWDMDD-RUGL3RUORTXHSUHFLVDGHOD LQWHUYHQFLyQ GH OD PDHVWUD SDUD KDFHUOHV FRPSUHQGHU OD QHFHVLGDG GH FRPSHQVDU ODV OLPLWDFLRQHVHQVLWXDFLRQHVFRPSHWLWLYDVGHIRUPDMXVWDSDUDWRGRV 0H OODPD OD DWHQFLyQ OD REVHUYDFLyQ TXH UHDOL]D OD DX[LOLDU GH (( FXDQGR -RUGL FRQVLJXH VDOYDUDWRGRVVXVFRPSDxHURVHQHOMXHJRGHOSDxXHOR&XDQGROHSUHJXQWRODUD]yQGHVX SODQWHDPLHQWRPHFRPHQWDTXHpVWHVXHOHVHUSRFRUHVSHWXRVRFRQVXVFRPSDxHURVFXDQGR FRQVLJXH JDQDUORV UHFUHiQGRVH HQ OD YLFWRULD \ UHFRUGiQGROHV FRQVWDQWHPHQWH TXH ORV KD JDQDGR 5 5 5 5 '(0$5=2'( 6(6,Ï11 'H QXHYR /ROD VH LQFRUSRUD HQ ODV VHVLRQHV $O RSHUDUOH ORV IpPXUHV SDUD DODUJDUOH ODV SLHUQDVWLHQHTXHGHVSOD]DUVHHQVLOODGHUXHGDVGDGRTXHYDFRQH[WHQVRUHVyVHRV\WLHQH TXH WHQHU ODV SLHUQDV H[WHQGLGDV 2EVHUYDPRV TXH WLHQH GLILFXOWDGHV SDUD LPSXOVDU OD VLOOD SRUTXHQRHVWiDGDSWDGDDVXDOWXUDGHWDOIRUPDTXHODVPDQRVOHOOHJDQMXVWRDODUR\VX EUD]DGDHVSHTXHxD &RPR OD SURIHVRUDVHUHWUDVDODDX[LOLDUGH((GHFLGHODSURSXHVWDLQLFLDOFRQHOREMHWRGH PRYLOL]DUDOJUXSRFODVH$VtODSULPHUDDFWLYLGDGHVODGHFRUUHUDOUHGHGRUGHOSDWLR&RPRHV KDELWXDO/RODVHGHVSOD]DSRUODV OtQHDVFHQWUDOHVGHOSDWLRGDGRTXHHOUHFRUULGRHVPHQRU (QFDPELR-RUGLGHFLGHKDFHUORSRUODVOtQHDVGHOH[WHULRUGHOFDPSRDLPDJHQGHOUHVWRGHO JUXSRFODVH7DOKHFKRSURYRFDTXHLQWHUFHGDODDX[LOLDUGH((UHFRUGiQGROHTXHORKDJDSRU HO LQWHULRU SULQFLSDOPHQWH SRU VHJXULGDG $QWH OD DFWLWXG GHVDILDQWH GH -RUGL OD DX[LOLDU OH FRPHQWDTXHQROHYDDSURSRQHUQLQJXQDRWUDDGDSWDFLyQ\TXHVHDpOTXLHQGHFLGDFyPR SDUWLFLSDUDORODUJRGHODVHVLyQ (QHVHPRPHQWRVHLQFRUSRUDODSURIHVRUDGH(GXFDFLyQ)tVLFD\ODVHJXQGDSURSXHVWDGHOD VHVLyQGHKR\HVODTXHVLJXH (OJUXSRFODVHVHQWDGRVHQHOVXHORIRUPDQGRXQFtUFXORVLHQGRODGLVWDQFLDHQWUHORVQLxRV GHXQPHWURDSUR[LPDGDPHQWH3RULQGLFDFLRQHVGHODSURIHVRUDWLHQHQTXHUHDOL]DUGLYHUVRV PRYLPLHQWRV GH SLHUQDV FRPR IOH[LRQHV WLMHUDV FUX]DU ODV SLHUQDV DOWHUQDWLYDPHQWH \ PRYLOL]DFLyQGHORVWRELOORV &RPR/RODQRSXHGHPRYLOL]DUODVSLHUQDVODDX[LOLDUOHSURSRQHGLYHUVRVHMHUFLFLRVGHVWLQDGRV DODPRYLOL]DFLyQGHORVWRELOORVHQFDPELR-RUGLUHDOL]DODVDFWLYLGDGHVVLQDSDUHQWHGLILFXOWDG 3RVWHULRUPHQWHVHMXHJDDO³UDWyQ\DOJDWR´ /DPLVPDGLVSRVLFLyQTXHHQODDFWLYLGDGDQWHULRU8QMXJDGRUHVHOUDWyQ\HORWURHOJDWR/D GLVWDQFLDHQWUHHOORVHVODGHXQRVFLQFRPHWURV$ODVHxDOHOUDWyQWLHQHTXHDWUDSDUDOJDWR SRUHOH[WHULRUGHOFtUFXORDQWHVGHTXHOOHJXHDOSXQWRGHSDUWLGDLQLFLDO /DHVWUDWHJLDTXHGHFLGHODSURIHVRUDHVODGHSRQHUD/ROD\D-RUGLMXQWRVHQODVHULHGDGR TXH DPERV VH GHVSOD]DQ HQ VLOOD GH UXHGDV \ GH HVWD IRUPD VH HTXLSDUD OD YHORFLGDG GH FDUUHUD &RPR /ROD HV PiV OHQWD TXH -RUGL GHELGR D OD UHGXFLGD DPSOLWXG GHO LPSXOVR VH DFXHUGD PRGLILFDU OD GLVWDQFLD HQWUH HOORV SURSRQLHQGR PiV HVSDFLR FXDQGR HOOD HV SHUVHJXLGD R UHGXFLHQGR FXDQGR DVXPH HO URO GH SHUUR $ DPERV VH OHV REVHUYD PX\ FRPSHWLWLYRV \ HQWUHJDGRV HQ OD SHUVHFXFLyQ 2EVHUYDPRV FRPR HV KDELWXDO TXH LQWHUDFFLRQDQYHUEDOPHQWHFRQORVFRPSDxHURVSUy[LPRVDHOORVFRPHQWDQGRODVMXJDGDVGH ORVRWURVMXJDGRUHV 5 5 5 5 5 5 $FRQWLQXDFLyQMXHJDQ³DQRPRYHUODVSLHUQDV´ *UXSRVGHFXDWURFRJLGRVGHODPDQR\GLVHxDQGRXQFtUFXOR6LQPRYHUODVSLHUQDVWLHQHQ TXHHVWLUDUORVEUD]RV\GHVSOD]DUHOWURQFRKDFLDDWUiVVLQVROWDUVHGHODVPDQRV 0LHQWUDVTXH/RODUHDOL]DODVDGDSWDFLRQHVSURSXHVWDVSRUODDX[LOLDU-RUGLGHFLGHGDUYXHOWDV DOUHGHGRUGHOSDWLRQRDFRJLpQGRVHDODVPRGLILFDFLRQHVSURSXHVWDVD/ROD (VWLUDPLHQWRV GH EUD]RV \ PRYLOLGDG DUWLFXODU GH ORV KRPEURV PDVDMHDQGR OD DX[LOLDU ORV KRPEURV SRU VROLFLWXG GH /ROD MXVWLILFDGD SRUTXH WLHQH VREUHFDUJDGD HVD ]RQD FRUSRUDO DO WHQHUTXHGHVSOD]DUVHHQVLOODGHUXHGDV\QRHVWDUKDELWXDGD 3RVWHULRUPHQWHVHVLW~DQGHODQWHGHODEDUDQGDGHOSDWLR\/RODVHFRORFDODWHUDOPHQWHDOD EDUDQGDFRJLpQGRVHDORVEDUURWHV\UHDOL]DQGRHVWLUDPLHQWRVGHEUD]RV 3DUDILQDOL]DUVHSUDFWLFDHOMXHJRGH³PDWDU´ /RVMXJDGRUHVVHGLVWULEX\HQHQGRVJUXSRVVHSDUDGRVSRUXQDOtQHDFHQWUDO(OHVSDFLR HVWiGHOLPLWDGR(OREMHWLYRGHOMXHJRHVHOLPLQDUDOHTXLSRFRQWUDULR3DUDHOORFXDQGRVH ODQ]DHOEDOyQGHHVSXPDHLPSDFWDDXQDGYHUVDULRWRFiQGRORHQFXDOTXLHUSDUWHFRUSRUDO H[FHSWXDQGRODFDUD\FDHSRVWHULRUPHQWHHOEDOyQDOVXHORVHFRQVLGHUDPXHUWReVWHVH GHVSOD]DKDFLDHOH[WUHPRGHOFDPSRGHORVMXJDGRUHVDGYHUVDULRVGHQRPLQDGD]RQDGH PXHUWRV\GHVGHDOOtLQWHQWD³PDWDU´DXQDGYHUVDULR'HQRFRQVHJXLUORWLHQHTXHHVSHUDU KDVWDTXHVXVFRPSDxHURVOHSDVHQHOEDOyQRELHQTXHORSXHGDFRQVHJXLUSRUTXHHOEDOyQ KDHQWUDGRDVX]RQDGHMXHJRV /DVDGDSWDFLRQHVSDUD/ROD\-RUGLVRQODVPLVPDVTXHHQVHVLRQHVDQWHULRUHV &XDQGRLQWHQWDQLPSDFWDUFRQHOEDOyQD-RUGLDQWHVWLHQHTXHGDUXQERWHHQHOVXHOR6HOHV FRQFHGHQWUHVYLGDVWUHVRSRUWXQLGDGHVDQWHVGHSDVDUDOFDPSRGHPXHUWRVSDUDSURORQJDU ODSHUPDQHQFLDGHDPERVHQHOHVSDFLRGHMXHJR&XDQGRSRVHHQHOEDOyQHLQWHQWDQODQ]DUOR FRQWUDVXVDGYHUVDULRVHQHOFDVRGH-RUGLVHOHSHUPLWHTXHORODQFHURGDQGRVHJULWD³VWRS´ R³SLHVTXLHWRV´WHQLHQGRTXHSHUPDQHFHUHVWiWLFRVHQHOHVSDFLR6tFRQVLJXHQLPSDFWDUFRQ HOEDOyQDDOJ~QMXJDGRUVHFRQVLGHUDPXHUWR 'HODREVHUYDFLyQUHDOL]DGDUHVDOWDPRVODDFWLWXGQHJDWLYDGH-RUGLHQHOMXHJRFXDQGRD/ROD OHSDVDQHOEDOyQ\VHJULWD³SLHVTXLHWRV´pOGHVSOD]DODVLOODKDFLDDWUiVSDUDDXPHQWDUOD GLVWDQFLDUHVSHFWRDHOOD(VWDUHVSXHVWDHVDSURYHFKDGDSRUODDX[LOLDUGH((SDUDKDFHUOH UHIOH[LRQDUVREUHVXFRQGXFWD\ODUHSHUFXVLyQTXHSXHGHWHQHUHQHOUHVWRGHOJUXSRUHVSHFWR D OD DFHSWDFLyQ GH ODV DGDSWDFLRQHV \ VX FXPSOLPLHQWR SRU SDUWH GH WRGRV \ WRGDV 1R REVWDQWHREVHUYRD/ROD\D-RUGLPX\FRPXQLFDWLYRVFRQVXVFRPSDxHURVHVSHFLDOPHQWH /ROD &RPHQWDULRVDODVHVLyQ 0HOODPDODDWHQFLyQODUHVSXHVWDGHODDX[LOLDUGH((FXDQGR-RUGLQRDSOLFDODDGDSWDFLyQ KDELWXDOHQHOSULPHUMXHJR$OSUHJXQWDUOHSRUTXpOHGHMDTXHpOGHFLGDODVDGDSWDFLRQHVGH OD VHVLyQ GH KR\ HOOD PH FRQWHVWD TXH HV QHFHVDULR H[LJLUOH FRQ HO ILQ TXH SHUFLED ODV 5 5 5 5 5 5 DGDSWDFLRQHV FRPR XQD QHFHVLGDG SDUD SRGHU SDUWLFLSDU DFWLYDPHQWH FRPR HO UHVWR GH FRPSDxHURV \ FRPR PHGLR GH SUHVHUYDU VX LQWHJULGDG ItVLFD SRU OR TXH WLHQH TXH LQWHULRUL]DUODVSDUDSRGHUDSOLFDUODVHQ FXDOTXLHU VLWXDFLyQ VLPLODU \HVSRUHOORTXHVHWLHQH TXHWUDEDMDUVXUHVSRQVDELOLGDG3RURWUDSDUWHFRQVLGHUDTXHWLHQHTXHVHUPiVUHVSHWXRVR FRQ ODV QRUPDWLYDV GH ORV MXHJRV \ TXH QR SXHGH FDHU HQ ODV WUDQVJUHVLRQHV FRQWLQXDV SRUTXHSURYRFDHIHFWRVQHJDWLYRVHQHOUHVWRGHOJUXSRVREUHWRGRFRQORVFRPSDxHURVPiV FRPSHWLWLYRV D ORV TXH FXHVWD DFHSWDU OD FRPSHQVDFLyQ GH ODV GLILFXOWDGHV HQ VLWXDFLRQHV FRPSHWLWLYDV (VWH KHFKR \D OR KD REVHUYDGR HQ HO HVSDFLR GH MXHJRV TXH RUJDQL]DQ ORV PRQLWRUHVGHFRPHGRU $SHVDUGHORVH[WHQVRUHV/RODKDSDUWLFLSDGRDFWLYDPHQWH(OKHFKRGHTXHODPDHVWUD\OD DX[LOLDUHVWpQKDELWXDGDVKDWUDEDMDUFRQODIUDJLOLGDGGH-RUGLSHUPLWHTXHVHEHQHILFLHGHODV PHGLGDVGHVHJXULGDG\SXHGDSDUWLFLSDUVLQWHPHUDTXHVHDJROSHDGDSRUVXVFRPSDxHURV 6(6,Ï11 '(0$5=2'( (QHVWDMRUQDGDQRFRQWDPRVFRQODSUHVHQFLDGH/RODSRUTXHKDWHQLGRTXHLUDXQDUHYLVLyQ SRVWRSHUDWRULD$VtPLVPRDFRQVHFXHQFLDGHODVHVLyQDQWHULRUODDX[LOLDUGH((GHFLGHQR LQGLFDU ODV DGDSWDFLRQHV HQ ORV MXHJRV KDELWXDOHV GH WDO IRUPD TXH -RUGL UHFXHUGH ODV PRGLILFDFLRQHVVLQQHFHVLGDGGHODLQWHUYHQFLyQGHODGXOWR 6HLQLFLDODVHVLyQFRQODUHDOL]DFLyQGHODVYXHOWDVDOSDWLR(QHVWDRFDVLyQ-RUGLQRSRQH QLQJ~QSUREOHPDHQUHDOL]DUODVVLJXLHQGRODVOtQHDVFHQWUDOHVGHOFDPSR 3RVWHULRUPHQWHODPDHVWUDSURSRQHHOMXHJRGH³ORVWUtRV´ /RVQLxRVVHGLVWULEX\HQHQJUXSRVGHWUHV$ODVHxDOVHGHVSOD]DQOLEUHPHQWHSRUHOHVSDFLR HQ GLVSHUVLyQ &XDQGR VH GD OD FRQVLJQD GH DJUXSDUVH WLHQHQ TXH ORFDOL]DU D VXV FRPSDxHURV\HQFRQWUDUVHSDUDRUJDQL]DUHOWUtR$YHUTXHWUtRVHUH~QHDQWHV (Q HVWD DFWLYLGDG QR KD VLGR QHFHVDULR UHFXUULU D QLQJXQD PRGLILFDFLyQ -RUGL SDUWLFLSD PX\ DFWLYDPHQWHJHQHUDQGR\UHFLELHQGRLQWHUDFFLRQHVYHUEDOHV /DWHUFHUDDFWLYLGDGHVOD³FDUUHUDSRUWUtRV´ 3RUWUtRVHQOtQHDFRJLGRVGHODPDQRWLHQHQTXHGHVSOD]DUVHHQFDUUHUDKDVWDHOILQDOGHOD SLVWD$YHUTXLHQOOHJDDQWHV 3DUDFRPSHQVDUVXPRYLOLGDGUHGXFLGDVHVLW~DDGHOUHFRUULGRUHVSHFWRDVXJUXSRGHWDO IRUPD TXH WLHQHQ TXH LQWHQWDU OOHJDU D OD YH] D OD OtQHD ILQDO GHO FDPSR WDQWR pO FRPR VXV FRPSDxHURVGHJUXSR (Q OD SULPHUD UHSHWLFLyQ -RUGL D SURSXHVWD GH OD PDHVWUD SDUWLFLSD HQ XQ JUXSR GH QLxDV SHURDOLQFRUSRUDUVHRWUDFRPSDxHUDOHLQGLFDHQODVHJXQGDUHSHWLFLyQTXHSDVHDXQRGHORV JUXSRV GH QLxRV 7DO SURSXHVWD HV DFHSWDGD SRU WRGRV ORV PLHPEURV GH HVH JUXSR H[FHSWXDQGRXQMXJDGRUTXHPXHVWUDVXGHVFRQWHQWRDWUDYpVGHVXDFWLWXGFRUSRUDO\IDFLDO 5 5 5 5 5 5 5 5 &XDQGROHSUHJXQWRDODDX[LOLDUVREUHODUHDFFLyQGHpVWHPHLQGLFDTXHQROHH[WUDxDSRUTXH HVPX\FRPSHWLWLYR (QHVWDVHJXQGDVHULHHOJUXSRGH-RUGLHVHOSULPHURTXHFUX]DODOtQHDILQDOGHOFDPSRSHUR OD PDHVWUD WLHQH TXH LQWHUYHQLU GLFLHQGR TXH HOORV QR KDQ JDQDGR SRUTXH -RUGL KD HQWUDGR SRVWHULRUPHQWH\TXHSRUWDQWRWLHQHQTXHFRRUGLQDUVHHQWUHHOORVSDUDFRQVHJXLUHOREMHWLYR GH HQWUDU WRGRV MXQWRV HQ HO PLVPR HVSDFLR GH WLHPSR OR FXDO VH FRQVLJXH HQ HO UHVWR GH VHULHV &DGDYH]TXHHQWUDQHQODPHWDREVHUYDPRVTXH-RUGLLQLFLDHOULWXDOGHFKRFDUODVPDQRV FRQVXVFRPSDxHURVVLHQGRFRUUHVSRQGLGRSRUWRGRV /DYDULDQWHTXHVHSURSRQHHVTXHORVWUtRVVHFRMDQGHODPDQRIRUPDQGRXQFtUFXOR\VH GHVSODFHQ KDVWD HO ILQDO GHO FDPSR (Q HVWD RFDVLyQ FRPR KDFH GRV MRUQDGDV DQWHULRUHV -RUGLVHVLW~DHQODPLWDGGHOUHFRUULGR /DTXLQWDWDUHDHVODTXHVLJXH (OJUXSRFODVHVHQWDGRVHQHOVXHORIRUPDQGRXQFtUFXORVLHQGRODGLVWDQFLDHQWUHORVQLxRV GHXQPHWURDSUR[LPDGDPHQWH3RULQGLFDFLRQHVGHODSURIHVRUDWLHQHQTXHUHDOL]DUGLYHUVRV PRYLPLHQWRV GH SLHUQDV FRPR IOH[LRQHV WLMHUDV FUX]DU ODV SLHUQDV DOWHUQDWLYDPHQWH \ PRYLOL]DFLyQGHORVWRELOORV $LPDJHQGHODVHVLyQDQWHULRU-RUGLUHDOL]DODVGLYHUVDVDFFLRQHVVLQGLILFXOWDG1RREVWDQWH WLHQHTXHLQWHUYHQLUODDX[LOLDUSDUDUHFRUGDUOHTXHIUHQHODVLOODGHUXHGDV 3RVWHULRUPHQWHVHMXHJDDO³UDWyQ\DOJDWR´ /DPLVPDGLVSRVLFLyQTXHHQODDFWLYLGDGDQWHULRU8QMXJDGRUHVHOUDWyQ\HORWURHOJDWR/D GLVWDQFLDHQWUHHOORVHVODGHXQRVFLQFRPHWURV$ODVHxDOHOUDWyQWLHQHTXHDWUDSDUDOJDWR SRUHOH[WHULRUGHOFtUFXORDQWHVGHTXHOOHJXHDOSXQWRGHSDUWLGDLQLFLDO $OQRHVWDU/ROD-RUGLWLHQHPiVGLILFXOWDGHVSRUTXHHODGYHUVDULRHVPiVYHOR]SRUORTXHOD PDHVWUDSURSRQHDXPHQWDURUHGXFLUODODGLVWDQFLDHQWUHHOORVHQIXQFLyQGHVtDVXPHHOURO GHSHUURRJDWR$SHVDUGHHVWDPHGLGDKDKDELGRSUREOHPDVHQDMXVWDUODVHTXLOLEUDGDPHQWH SRUORTXH-RUGLHVDWUDSDGRPX\UiSLGDPHQWH$QWHODDFWLWXGGHpVWHHQHOTXHVHSHUFLEH GHVFRQWHQWRSRUHOUHVXOWDGRODPDHVWUDOHFRPHQWDTXH³ORLPSRUWDQWHHVSDUWLFLSDU\TXHQR VHGHEHGDUWDQWDLPSRUWDQFLDDOUHVXOWDGR´ 3DUDILQDOL]DUVHMXHJDD³PDWDU´ /RVMXJDGRUHVVHGLVWULEX\HQHQGRVJUXSRVVHSDUDGRVSRUXQDOtQHDFHQWUDO(OHVSDFLR HVWiGHOLPLWDGR(OREMHWLYRGHOMXHJRHVHOLPLQDUDOHTXLSRFRQWUDULR3DUDHOORFXDQGRVH ODQ]DHOEDOyQGHHVSXPDHLPSDFWDDXQDGYHUVDULRWRFiQGRORHQFXDOTXLHUSDUWHFRUSRUDO H[FHSWXDQGRODFDUD\FDHSRVWHULRUPHQWHHOEDOyQDOVXHORVHFRQVLGHUDPXHUWReVWHVH GHVSOD]DKDFLDHOH[WUHPRGHOFDPSRGHORVMXJDGRUHVDGYHUVDULRVGHQRPLQDGD]RQDGH PXHUWRV\GHVGHDOOtLQWHQWD³PDWDU´DXQDGYHUVDULR'HQRFRQVHJXLUORWLHQHTXHHVSHUDU KDVWDTXHVXVFRPSDxHURVOHSDVHQHOEDOyQRELHQTXHORSXHGDFRQVHJXLUSRUTXHHOEDOyQ 5 5 5 5 5 5 5 5 KDHQWUDGRDVX]RQDGHMXHJRV /DV DGDSWDFLRQHV SDUD-RUGLVRQODVPLVPDV TXH HQ VHVLRQHV DQWHULRUHV VLQ VHU QHFHVDULR UHFRUGDUODVQLDpVWHQLDOUHVWRGHOJUXSR &XDQGRLQWHQWDQLPSDFWDUFRQHOEDOyQDpVWHDQWHVWLHQHTXHGDUXQERWHHQHOVXHOR6HOH FRQFHGHQWUHVYLGDVWUHVRSRUWXQLGDGHVDQWHVGHSDVDUDOFDPSRGHPXHUWRVSDUDSURORQJDU ODSHUPDQHQFLDHQHOHVSDFLRGHMXHJR&XDQGRSRVHHHOEDOyQHLQWHQWDODQ]DUORURGDQGR FRQWUDVXVDGYHUVDULRVVHJULWD³VWRSRSLHVTXLHWRV´WHQLHQGRTXHSHUPDQHFHUHVWiWLFRVHQHO HVSDFLR6tFRQVLJXHLPSDFWDUFRQHOEDOyQDDOJ~QMXJDGRUVHFRQVLGHUDPXHUWR /DPDHVWUDGLFHDGRVQLxRVTXHHVFRMDQDVXJUXSRREVHUYiQGRVHTXH-RUGLHVHOHJLGRHO SHQ~OWLPR GH WRGRV $ SHVDU GH HOOR HV DFHSWDGR SRU WRGRV VXV PLHPEURV LQFOX\HQGR HO FRPSDxHUR TXH KD PRVWUDGR VX GHVFRQWHQWR HQ HO MXHJR GH ³ORV WUtRV´ FXDQGR VH KD LQFRUSRUDGR-RUGLHQODVHJXQGDVHULH 7DQVyORVHWLHQHTXHUHFRUGDUODDGDSWDFLyQTXHSDUDLQWHQWDULPSDFWDUFRQHOEDOyQD-RUGL SUHYLDPHQWHWLHQHTXHGDUXQERWHHQHOVXHORORFXDOHVDFHSWDGRSRUORVDGYHUVDULRV 3HUFLELPRV TXH DSHQDV VH GHVSOD]D SRU HO HVSDFLR VLWXiQGRVH SRU HO FHQWUR GHO FDPSR $ PHGLGDTXHREVHUYDTXHQRORLQWHQWDQPDWDUDSHVDUGHODSUR[LPLGDGVHYDDSUR[LPDQGRD ODOtQHDFHQWUDOGHOFDPSR &RPHQWDULRVDODVHVLyQ 2EVHUYDPRVTXHHQVLWXDFLRQHVFRPRODVTXHVHSXHGHQJHQHUDUFRQHOMXHJRGH³PDWDU´HQ ODV TXH -RUGL GLVSRQH GH WUHV YLGDV VXV FRPSDxHURV OR LJQRUDQ D SHVDU GH OD SUR[LPLGDG SUHILULHQGRLQWHQWDUHOLPLQDUDRWURDGYHUVDULRLQGHSHQGLHQWHPHQWHTXHODGLVWDQFLDVHDPD\RU $VtPLVPRHVVLJQLILFDWLYRTXHORKD\DQHVFRJLGRHO~OWLPRGHVXHTXLSR $ODQDOL]DUODVHVLyQFRQODDX[LOLDUGH((PHFRPHQWDODUHSHUFXVLyQSRVLWLYDGHODMRUQDGD DQWHULRUGDGRTXHpOKDGHFLGLGRODVDGDSWDFLRQHVH[FHSWXDQGRHQHOMXHJRGHOUDWyQ\GHO JDWRGDGDODQRYHGDG&RQVLGHUDTXHHVPX\LPSRUWDQWHTXHLQFRUSRUHODVDGDSWDFLRQHVSRU OD UHSHUFXVLyQTXHSXHGDWHQHUHQODVDFWLYLGDGHVO~GLFDVGHOUHVWRGHODMRUQDGDHVFRODUR ELHQIXHUDGHODHVFXHODGHWDOIRUPDTXHQRSUHFLVHFRQVWDQWHPHQWHGHODLQWHUYHQFLyQGHO DGXOWR $SHVDUGHHOORPXHVWUDVXGHVFRQWHQWRSRUODDFWLWXGHQODTXLQWDWDUHDHQTXHOHLQGLFDTXH WLHQH TXH IUHQDU OD VLOOD GH UXHGDV 0H FRPHQWD TXH VLHPSUH VH OH WLHQHQ TXH UHFRUGDU ODV FRQVLJQDVEiVLFDVORTXHFRQGXFHVHJ~QHOODDTXHHODGXOWRSLHQVHSRUpO\FRQGLFLRQHVX GHSHQGHQFLD '(0$5=2'( 6(6,Ï11 'DGR TXH HVWiEDPRV SDVDQGR HO VRFLRJUDPD GHO VHJXQGR WULPHVWUH HVWD VHVLyQ KD VLGR 5 5 5 5 5 5 5 5 UHFRJLGDSRUODDX[LOLDUGH(( /DPDHVWUDLQLFLDODVHVLyQFRQHOMXHJRGH³WRFDU\SDUDU´ (OJUXSRFODVHHVWiGLVSHUVRHQXQHVSDFLRGHOLPLWDGR\FXDWURQLxRV³SDUDQ´&XDQGRVHGD OD VHxDO GH LQLFLR pVWRV WLHQHQ TXH LQWHQWDU HOLPLQDU D VXV DGYHUVDULRV WRFiQGROHV FRQ OD PDQRHQDOJXQDSDUWHGHOFXHUSR(QHOPRPHQWRTXHORFRQVLJXHQORVTXHHVWiQWRFDGRVVH WUDVODGDQDOFDPSRGHHOLPLQDGRV*DQDHOMXJDGRUTXHVHTXHGHHO~OWLPRVLQWRFDU /DDGDSWDFLyQTXHSURSRQHODPDHVWUDSDUDWRFDUDXQMXJDGRUHVTXHpVWHWLHQHTXHSDVDUD XQ PHWUR GH GLVWDQFLD GH -RUGL R GH /ROD 7DQ VyOR KD\ XQD REMHFLyQ SRU SDUWH GH XQ FRPSDxHUR TXH FRPHQWD TXH FRQVLGHUD HVWD PHGLGD LQMXVWD SDUD -RUGL SRUTXH OD GLVWDQFLD WLHQHTXHVHUPD\RUSURSRQLHQGRPHWURV1RREVWDQWHVHPDQWLHQHODSURSXHVWDLQLFLDO (QODSULPHUDUHSHWLFLyQDPERVVRQWRFDGRVFDVLDOILQDOGHOMXHJR(QFDPELRHQODVHJXQGD VHULHORVKDQWRFDGRGHORVSULPHURVSRUORTXHVHKDQGHVSOD]DGRDOD]RQDGHHOLPLQDGRV JHQHUDQGRFRQYHUVDFLRQHVFRQVXVFRPSDxHURV<HQODWHUFHUDMXJDGDSRULQGLFDFLyQGHOD PDHVWUDKDQVLGRWRFDGRVGHORV~OWLPRVGHHVWDIRUPDDVHJXUDXQDPD\RUSHUPDQHQFLDHQ OD]RQDGHMXHJRV 3RVWHULRUPHQWHSURVLJXHXQFLUFXLWRFRQFLQFRHVWDFLRQHV FRUUHUHQ]LJ]DJHQWUHFRQRV VDOWDUDSLHVMXQWRVGHQWURGHORVDURVVHSDUDGRVHQWUHVtPHGLRPHWUR /RV DURV D XQD GLVWDQFLD HQWUH Vt GH XQRV VHWHQWD FHQWtPHWURV FRUUHU SRQLHQGRXQSLHGHQWURGHFDGDDUR WUHVDURVSUy[LPRVVDOWDUGHXQDURDRWURDSLHVMXQWRV VDOWRDODFXHUGDLQGLYLGXDO YDOODV GH DWOHWLVPR D XQD GLVWDQFLD GH XQRV PHWURV GHVSOD]DUVH HQ FDUUHUD\VDOWDUODVVXFHVLYDPHQWH &RPRHVWiEDPRVSDVDQGRHOVRFLRJUDPDD-RUGLpVWHVHKDLQFRUSRUDGRDOFLUFXLWRFXDQGR HVWDEDILQDOL]iQGRVHHVGHFLUHQOD~OWLPDSUXHED(QFDPELR/RODKDSDUWLFLSDGRDFWLYDPHQWH GHODVLJXLHQWHPDQHUD 'HVSOD]DUVHHQ]LJ]DJHQWUHODVYDOODV (MHUFLFLRVGHPRYLOL]DFLyQGHORVWRELOORV (VWLUDPLHQWRVGHEUD]RV\PRYLOLGDGGHWURQFRXWLOL]DQGRXQDFXHUGD &RPHQWDULRVDODVHVLyQ $QWH ODV FDUDFWHUtVWLFDV GH ODV WDUHDV OD DX[LOLDU REVHUYD TXH HQ HO SULPHU MXHJR FRPR HV KDELWXDOODVLQWHUDFFLRQHVGHDPERVKDQVLGRQXPHURVDVFXDQGRVHKDOODEDQHQOD]RQDGH HOLPLQDGRV1RREVWDQWHHQODVHJXQGDSDUWHGHODVHVLyQHOKHFKRGHUHDOL]DUXQWUDEDMRPiV LQGLYLGXDOL]DGR\HQXQD]RQDDSDUWDGDGHOJUXSRSDUDSURWHJHUORVGHDOJ~QSRVLEOHJROSHKD GHWHUPLQDGRTXHODLQWHUUHODFLyQVHDPHQRU\TXHWDQVyORVHGpHQWUHDPERV 5 5 5 5 5 5 6(6,Ï11 '(0$5=2 &RQWLQ~RSDVDQGRHOVRFLRJUDPDSRUORTXHODREVHUYDFLyQGHODVHVLyQHVUHFRJLGDSRUOD 5 DX[LOLDUGH(GXFDFLyQ(VSHFLDO /DSULPHUDSURSXHVWDHVODGHGDUYXHOWDVDOSDWLR&RPRHVKDELWXDO-RUGLUHDOL]DHOUHFRUULGR 5 SRUHOLQWHULRU/RODQRSDUWLFLSDGHHVWDDFWLYLGDGSRUTXHFRLQFLGHFRQODDGPLQLVWUDFLyQGHO VRFLRJUDPD 3RVWHULRUPHQWHVHMXHJDDOD³FDUUHUDHQGLDJRQDO´ 5 *UXSRV GH FLQFR VLWXDGRV DO H[WUHPR GH FDGD YpUWLFH GH XQ FXDGUDGR VHxDOL]DGR FRQ XQ FRQR/DGLVWDQFLDGHORVODGRVHVGHPHWURV$ODVHxDOWLHQHQTXHFUX]DUVHHQFDUUHUD ORVH[WUHPRVGHFDGDGLDJRQDOVLQFKRFDUGHVSOD]iQGRVHDOYpUWLFHFRQWUDULRHLQWHQWDQGRLUD OD PLVPD YHORFLGDG GH WDO IRUPD TXH FDGD JUXSR WLHQH TXH DOFDQ]DU HO YpUWLFH DO PLVPR WLHPSR /DDGDSWDFLyQTXHVHSURSRQHSDUD-RUGLHVTXHVHVLW~HDOFHQWURGHOUHFRUULGRUHGXFLHQGR 5 GHHVWDPDQHUDVXHVSDFLRGHGHVSOD]DPLHQWR\HYLWDQGRHOFUXFHHQWUHORVMXJDGRUHVHQOD ]RQDFHQWUDOGHOFDPSR $SHVDUGHTXHHVWpDGLVWDQFLDGHOJUXSRHQHOLQLFLRGHOMXHJRVHREVHUYDTXHDOOOHJDUDO 5 ILQDO GHO UHFRUULGR -RUGL HVWDEOHFH FRPXQLFDFLyQ FRQ VXV FRPSDxHURV FRPHQWDQGR OR DFRQWHFLGR 6H REVHUYD D XQ -RUGL PX\ FRPSHWLWLYR OXFKDQGR SRU OOHJDU MXQWR D VXV FRPSDxHURVDOYpUWLFHFRUUHVSRQGLHQWH /D WHUFHUD SURSXHVWD HV HO ³ERWH \ WLUR D OD FDQDVWD´ 3DUD SURWHJHU GH ORV SRVLEOHV JROSHV 5 SURFHGHQWHVGHORVEDORQHV-RUGL\/RODWLHQHQTXHUHDOL]DUXQWUDEDMRPiVLQGLYLGXDOL]DGR\ VHSDUDGRGHOJUXSR /DHVWUDWHJLDTXHXWLOL]DODDX[LOLDUGHHGXFDFLyQHVSHFLDOHVODGHLQFRUSRUDUXQDSHORWDPiV EODQGDSDUD-RUGLWUDEDMDQGRGLYHUVRVSDVHVHQXQSULQFLSLRFRQHOODKDVWDTXHVHLQWURGXFH GHQXHYR/ROD 3DUD ODQ]DU D FDQDVWD OD DX[LOLDU FRORFD XQ QHXPiWLFR GH FRFKH HQFLPD GH XQ EDQFR GHO SDWLRGHHVWDIRUPDSXHGHQUHDOL]DUGLYHUVDVHQWUDGDVDLPDJHQGHOJUXSRFODVH 6HREVHUYDTXHLQWHUDFFLRQDQSRVLWLYDPHQWHHQWUHHOORVPRVWUiQGRVHPX\PRWLYDGRVSRUODV SURSXHVWDV &RPHQWDULRVDODVHVLyQ $OWHQHUTXHUHFXUULUDXQWUDEDMRPiVLQGLYLGXDOL]DGRFRQHOILQGHSURWHJHUWDQWRD/RODFRPR D-RUGLGHSRVLEOHVJROSHVGHEDORQHVVHKDPRWLYDGRDTXHHOQ~PHURGHLQWHUDFFLRQHVFRQ HOUHVWRGHOJUXSRKD\DQVLGRPHQRUHVUHVSHFWRDRWUDVVHVLRQHV 5 '(0$5=2 -RUGLQRSDUWLFLSDHQODVHVLyQSRUSUHYHQFLyQSRUTXHKDFHGRVGtDVVHJROSHyODSLHUQDHQ FDVD\GLFHTXHVLHQWHGRORU 3RURWURODGRQRVHQFRQWUDPRVFRQXQD/RODWULVWH$OLQGDJDUODUD]yQPHFRPHQWDODDX[LOLDU GH((TXHHVGHELGRDOLQLFLRGHOSHUtRGRGHUHKDELOLWDFLyQ\UHFXHUGDHOGRORUTXHOHSURGXFtD ORVHMHUFLFLRVGHILVLRWHUDSLDGHODRSHUDFLyQGHOFXUVRDQWHULRU 6HLQLFLDODVHVLyQFRQODDFWLYLGDGGHGDUYXHOWDVDOFDPSR&RPRHVKDELWXDO/RODODVUHDOL]D SRUHOLQWHULRU 3RVWHULRUPHQWHODPDHVWUDSURSRQHHOMXHJRGH³3LFKLFRQEDWHGHEpLVERO´ (OJUXSRVHRUJDQL]DHQGRVHTXLSRVXQRHVHOODQ]DGRU\HORWURHOUHFHSWRU(OSULPHURVH ORFDOL]D GHWUiV GH XQD OtQHD \ HO VHJXQGR GLVWULEXLGRV SRU HO HVSDFLR GRQGH VH VLW~DQ ODV EDVHVTXHWLHQHQTXHUHFRUUHUHOHTXLSRODQ]DGRU(O³SLFKL´TXHSHUWHQHFHDOHTXLSRUHFHSWRU VHVLW~DHQXQDEDVHSUy[LPDDODOtQHDGHORWURHTXLSR3DUDOHODPHQWHQRVHQFRQWUDPRVFRQ HO³SDVDGRUGHSHORWD´TXHHVPLHPEURGHOHTXLSRODQ]DGRU 6HLQLFLDHOMXHJRFXDQGRHO³SDVDGRU´ODQ]DODSHORWDDOFRPSDxHURTXHGLVSRQHGHOEDWHGH EpLVEROeVWHWLHQHTXHJROSHDUODSHORWD\GLULJLUODDOWHUUHQRGHEDVHVLQWHQWDQGRHQYLDUODDO HVSDFLR YDFtR GH FRQWUDULRV /RV DGYHUVDULRV LQWHQWDQ DWUDSDU HO EDOyQ DO YXHOR SDUD DVt HOLPLQDUDOODQ]DGRU3HURSXHGHTXHHOEDOyQWRTXHDOVXHORRDODSDUHG\GHEHQHQWRQFHV UHFXSHUDUOR\SDVDUORDO³SLFKL´DODWUDSDUHOEDOyQJULWDUi³SLFKL´(VWHHVSDFLRGHWLHPSRVHUi XWLOL]DGRSRUHOODQ]DGRUSDUDSDVDUSRUHOUHFRUULGRGHEDVHV\SDUDDYDQ]DUORVFRPSDxHURV \DSRVLFLRQDGRVHQHOODV6LHQHOUHFRUULGRKD\YDULRVMXJDGRUHVHQEDVHVQRSRGUiQXQFD KDEHUPiVGHXQRSRUEDVHVHUiHOLPLQDGRDTXHOTXHOOHJXHHO~OWLPRDODPLVPD3DUDQR 5 6(6,Ï11 5 5 5 VHU HOLPLQDGRV HO ODQ]DGRU \ HO UHVWR GH FRPSDxHURV GHO UHFRUULGR GHEHUiQ HVWDU HQ XQD EDVHHQHOPRPHQWRTXHHO³SLFKL´JULWH6LVHFRQVLJXHKDFHUXQDFDUUHUDFRPSOHWDSRUXQ VRORODQ]DPLHQWRSDVDUSRUWRGDV\FDGDXQDGHODVEDVHVKDVWDOOHJDUDVXOtQHDHQWRQFHV VHVDOYDQWRGRVORVHOLPLQDGRV'HQRKDEHUQLQJXQRFREUDUiXQDYLGD\SRGUiSDVDUODDXQ IXWXURMXJDGRUHOLPLQDGR&DGDYH]TXHVHFRQVLJXHUHDOL]DUXQFLUFXLWRGHEDVHVVHFRQVLJXH XQSXQWRSDUDHOHTXLSR &XDQGRKDQVLGRWRGRVHOLPLQDGRVORVGRVHTXLSRVLQWHUFDPELDQUROHV*DQDHOHTXLSRTXH PiVSXQWRVVXPHHVGHFLUTXHPiVYXHOWDVKD\DQFRQVHJXLGR 1RWDHO³SLFKL´QXQFDSRGUiVDOLUGHVXEDVH &RPR /ROD GHPXHVWUD PLHGR SRU VL OD JROSHDQ VROLFLWD D OD PDHVWUD QR SDUWLFLSDU HQ HVWH MXHJR(VSRUHOORTXHODDX[LOLDUGH((ODVHSDUDGHOJUXSRFRQHOILQGHTXHVHWUDQTXLOLFH\ VH VLHQWD VHJXUD /D DX[LOLDU OH SURSRQH TXH UHDOLFH GLYHUVRV SDVHV FRQ SHORWD GH WHQLV SRVWHULRUPHQWH LQWURGXFH HQ HO MXHJR XQ FRQR SDViQGROH SHORWD \ HOOD WLHQH TXH LQWHQWDU LQWURGXFLUOD GHQWUR GH OD EDVH GHO FRQR LQYHUWLGR 3RVWHULRUPHQWH VH LQFRUSRUD XQ FRPSDxHURTXHHVHOLPLQDGRHQHOMXHJRGH³SLFKL´SRULQLFLDWLYDSURSLD\FRQODSHORWDGH WHQLVHOFRQR\ODFDQDVWDGHEDORQFHVWRFUHDQGLYHUVRVMXHJRV0iVWDUGHVHLQFRUSRUDRWUR FRPSDxHUR \ VH OHV REVHUYD MXJDQGR D HQFHVWDU OD SHORWD GH WHQLV )LQDOL]D OD VHVLyQ \ FRQVWDWRTXH/RODVDOHPiVDQLPDGDTXHDOLQLFLR &RPHQWDULRVDODVHVLyQ 2EVHUYDPRVDXQD/RODWHPHURVDSRUHOLQLFLRGHODUHKDELOLWDFLyQORTXHOHFRQGXFHDVHU PHQRV FRPXQLFDWLYD $ SHVDU GH HOOR KD VLGR LQWHUHVDQWH OD DFWLWXG GH ORV FRPSDxHURV HOLPLQDGRVFXDQGRSRULQLFLDWLYDSURSLDVHKDQSXHVWRDMXJDUFRQHOOD 6(6,Ï11 '(0$5=2 6HLQLFLDODVHVLyQFRQHOMXHJRGH³WRFDU\SDUDU´ (OJUXSRFODVHHVWiGLVSHUVRHQXQHVSDFLRGHOLPLWDGR\FXDWURQLxRV³SDUDQ´&XDQGRVHGD OD VHxDO GH LQLFLR pVWRV WLHQHQ TXH LQWHQWDU HOLPLQDU D VXV DGYHUVDULRV WRFiQGROHV FRQ OD PDQRHQDOJXQDSDUWHGHOFXHUSR(QHOPRPHQWRTXHORFRQVLJXHQORVTXHHVWiQWRFDGRVVH WUDVODGDQDOFDPSRGHHOLPLQDGRV*DQDHOMXJDGRUTXHVHTXHGHHO~OWLPRVLQWRFDU (QODSULPHUDUHSHWLFLyQWDQWR/RODFRPR-RUGLQRVRQDWUDSDGRUHV/DPDHVWUDLQGLFDDpVWRV TXH QR ORV LQWHQWHQ WRFDU KDVWD HO ILQDO &XDQGR VRQ HOLPLQDGRV REVHUYDPRV TXH LQWHUDFFLRQDQYHUEDOPHQWHFRQRWURVFRPSDxHURVHOLPLQDGRV-RUGLORKDFHFRQHOJUXSRGH QLxRV\/RODFRQHOGHQLxDV (QODVHJXQGDUHSHWLFLyQ/RODSDVDDOJUXSRGHDWUDSDGRUHV&RPRHVKDELWXDOVHUHFXHUGD TXH pVWD DWUDSD FXDQGR HO MXJDGRU TXH KX\H HVWi D XQ PHWUR GH GLVWDQFLD GH HOOD /D RWUD FRQGLFLyQ TXH SURSRQH OD PDHVWUD HV TXH WDQ VyOR HV HOOD OD TXH SXHGH HOLPLQDU D -RUGL 2EVHUYDPRVDXQD/RODPX\DFWLYDLQWHQWDQGRDWUDSDUDFXDOTXLHUFRPSDxHURSUy[LPDDHOOD SHURWDQVyORORFRQVLJXHFRQ-RUGL&XDQGRVXFHGHpVWHGLVFXWHFRQ/RODSRUTXHFRQVLGHUD 5 5 5 5 5 TXHVXGLVWDQFLDHUDPD\RUWHQLHQGRTXHLQWHUYHQLUODDX[LOLDUSDUDYHULILFDUTXHHVWDEDDXQ PHWURGHGLVWDQFLD (Q OD WHUFHUD VHULH HV -RUGL TXLHQ SDVD DO HTXLSR GH DWUDSDGRUHV 6H OH REVHUYD PX\ FRPSHWLWLYRLQWHQWDQGRDWUDSDUDFXDOTXLHUFRPSDxHURVHJ~QODDGDSWDFLyQGHODUHSHWLFLyQ DQWHULRU SHUR QR FRQVLJXH DWUDSDU D QDGLH 0LHQWUDV WDQWR /ROD GHVFDQVD SRUTXH VH VLHQWH IDWLJDGDPRVWUiQGRVHPX\FRPXQLFDWLYDFRQODVFRPSDxHUDVHOLPLQDGDV 3RVWHULRUPHQWHOHVLJXHHOMXHJRGHO³SDxXHOR´ /RV GRV JUXSRV IUHQWH SRU IUHQWH D XQD GLVWDQFLD PtQLPD GH PHWURV (Q OD PLWDG GH OD GLVWDQFLD HO MXJDGRU TXH VRVWLHQH HO SDxXHOR DOLQHDGR FRQ ORV ~OWLPRV MXJDGRUHV GH XQ H[WUHPR/RVMXJDGRUHVVHQXPHUDQHQVHFUHWRHYLWDQGRTXHVXQ~PHURVHDFRQRFLGRSRUHO HTXLSR FRQWUDULR (O MXJDGRU TXH VRVWLHQH HO SDxXHOR GLUi XQ Q~PHUR FRPSUHQGLGR HQ HO Q~PHURWRWDOGHMXJDGRUHVGHFDGDHTXLSR/RVMXJDGRUHVTXHWHQJDQHVHQ~PHURGHEHUiQ FRUUHUKDVWDHOSDxXHORFRQVHJXLUOR\UHJUHVDUDVXHTXLSRDQWHVGHTXHVHDWRFDGRSRUHO FRPSDxHUR DGYHUVDULR /RV MXJDGRUHV TXH QR KDQ FRQVHJXLGR OOHJDU D VX HTXLSR FRQ HO SDxXHOR R ORV WRFDGRV HQ VX LQWHQWR VHUiQ HOLPLQDGRV /RV SDUWLFLSDQWHV TXH TXHGHQ LUiQ DVXPLHQGR ORV Q~PHURV GH ORV HOLPLQDGRV VHJ~Q VX FULWHULR /RV HOLPLQDGRV SRGUiQ VHU VDOYDGRVVLHQHOUHFRUULGRGHUHJUHVRHOFRPSDxHURTXHWLHQHHOSDxXHORORVWRFD3DUDHOOR VHDFXHUGDSUHYLDPHQWHXQD]RQDGRQGHHVWiQORFDOL]DGRVIRUPDQGRXQDFDGHQDGiQGRVHOD PDQRGHWDOIRUPDTXHVLVDOYDQDOSULPHURpVWHSDVDODFRUULHQWHDOUHVWRGHFRPSDxHURV HOLPLQDGRVVDOYiQGRVHWRGRV $ LPDJHQ GH OD VHVLyQ DQWHULRU HQ OD TXH VH SURSXVR HVWH MXHJR SDUD SRGHU FRPSHQVDU OD PRYLOLGDGUHGXFLGDGH-RUGLVHOHVLW~DPiVDYDQ]DGRDGHOFDPSRUHVSHFWRDVXHTXLSR \ VX DGYHUVDULD XQD QLxD QR PX\ YHOR] WLHQH TXH UHDOL]DU WUHV VDOWRV D OD SDWD FRMD HQ HO PRPHQWR GH OD VDOLGD SDUD FRPSHQVDU HO WLHPSR GH DUUDQTXH GH OD VLOOD GH UXHGDV $ GLIHUHQFLD GH OD VHVLyQ DQWHULRU DFRUGDPRV LQFRUSRUDU GRV SDxXHORV HQ HO PRPHQWR TXH OD PDHVWUDGLFHHOQ~PHURGH-RUGLGHWDOIRUPDTXHSRQHORVEUD]RVHQFUX]FRQHOILQGHTXHOD GLVWDQFLD HQWUH ORV SDxXHORV VHD OD VXILFLHQWH FRPR SDUD HYLWDU HO SRVLEOH FKRTXH HQWUH ORV MXJDGRUHV/DFRQVLJQDHVODGH¢DYHUTXLHQOOHJDDQWHV"\HOTXLHQORFRQVLJDSXHGHVDOYDU DWRGRVVXVFRPSDxHURVHOLPLQDGRV (QHVWDRFDVLyQWRGRVDFHSWDQFRQQRUPDOLGDGHVWDVDGDSWDFLRQHV'HODVFLQFRYHFHVTXH HVOODPDGRHOQ~PHURGH-RUGLHQQLQJXQDRFDVLyQKDOOHJDGRDFRQVHJXLUSULPHURHOSDxXHOR SRUORTXHHVFXFKRTXHODPDHVWUDOHLQVLVWHTXHVHHVIXHUFHPiV ([FHSWXDQGRHQXQDVHULHHVDQLPDGRSRUVXVFRPSDxHURVR\pQGRVHHQGRVYHFHVODTXHMD GHpVWRVSRUTXHGHFtDQTXHODDGYHUVDULDGHpVWHKDEtDKHFKRWUDPSDVDOUHDOL]DUWDQVyOR GRVVDOWRVDODSDWDFRMDSRUORTXHWLHQHTXHLQWHUFHGHUODPDHVWUD $SHVDUGHHVWDUPiVDYDQ]DGRTXHHOUHVWRGHFRPSDxHURVFXDQGRSDVDQSUy[LPRVDpO\ KDQ FRQVHJXLGR XQ UHVXOWDGR SRVLWLYR -RUGL ORV OODPD SDUD GDUOHV XQ WRTXH GH PDQRV \ IHOLFLWDUORV 5HVSHFWR D /ROD FRPHQWDU TXH QR TXLHUH SDUWLFLSDU SRUTXH GLFH D OD PDHVWUD TXH HVWi FDQVDGD 2EVHUYR TXH VH GHVSOD]D MXQWR D Pt H LQWHUDFFLRQD YHUEDOPHQWH FRQ XQD 5 5 5 5 5 FRPSDxHUDTXHHVWiOHVLRQDGD&XDQGROHSUHJXQWRHOSRUTXpQRSDUWLFLSDPHFRQWHVWDFRQ ODVVLJXLHQWHVSDODEUDV³SRUTXHVR\PiVOHQWDTXHHOUHVWR´\³SRUTXHQRVpMXJDU´$QWHHOOR OH DQLPR D SDUWLFLSDU FRPHQWiQGROH TXH OH SRGHPRV DSOLFDU XQD DGDSWDFLyQ VLPLODU D OD GH -RUGL0HUHVSRQGHTXHSUHILHUHGHVFDQVDUSRUTXHDGHPiVDODWDUGHWLHQHTXHSDVDUYLVLWD FRQHOPpGLFRUHKDELOLWDGRUDxDGLHQGRTXHOHSUHRFXSDTXHOHSRQJDQGHSLHSRUTXHHVPX\ GRORURVR$SHVDUGHTXHLQVLVWRHQTXHVHUtDEHQHILFLRVRSDUDHOODGLVWUDHUVHMXJDQGRHOOD SUHILHUH QR KDFHUOR 3RVWHULRUPHQWH VH GHVSOD]D MXQWR DO JUXSR \ REVHUYR TXH DQLPD FRQVWDQWHPHQWH D ORV MXJDGRUHV TXH SDUWLFLSDQ JHQHUDQGR LQWHUDFFLRQHV YHUEDOHV FRQ JUDQ SDUWHGHORVPLHPEURVGHOHTXLSRGH-RUGL &RPHQWDULRVDODVHVLyQ $OSUHJXQWDUOHDODPDHVWUDODUD]yQSRUODTXHKDSURSXHVWRDOJUXSRHQHOSULPHUMXHJRTXH GHMHQSDUDHOILQDOHOWRFDUD-RUGLR/ROD\GHOSRUTXpQRUHFXUUHDRWRUJDUWUHVYLGDVSDUD FDGD XQR GH HOORV WUHV SRVLELOLGDGHV PiV SDUD SHUPDQHFHU HQ HO FDPSR GH MXHJR PH UHVSRQGHSRUTXHQRUHVXOWDHIHFWLYRSURSRQHUOHVYLGDVGDGRTXHORVHOLPLQDQUiSLGDPHQWH &XDQGRFRPHQWRFRQODDX[LOLDUHOUHVXOWDGRGHODVHVLyQPHLQVLVWHHQTXHVXEUD\HODDFWLWXG GH -RUGL FRQ /ROD HQ OD WHUFHUD UHSHWLFLyQ GHO SULPHU MXHJR 3DUHFH VHU TXH QR DFHSWD ODV DGDSWDFLRQHVVX\DVHQ/ROD\SRUHOORWLHQHODQHFHVLGDGGHWUDQVJUHGLUODQRUPDWLYD 6(6,Ï11 5 '(0$5=2 'DGRTXHHUDXQGtDOOXYLRVRODFODVHIXHWHyULFD 5 '(0$5=2 /DVHVLyQVHLPSDUWLyHQHOJLPQDVLR/DSULPHUDWDUHDFRQVLVWLyHQGDUYXHOWDVDOUHGHGRUGH pVWHFRPELQDQGRFDUUHUDFRQGLIHUHQWHVVDOWRV /DDGDSWDFLyQSDUD/ROD\-RUGLHVODGHGHOLPLWDUVX]RQDGHDFFLyQPHGLDQWHEDQFRVGHWDO IRUPDTXHHOORVVHGHVSOD]DQSRUHOLQWHULRUPLHQWUDVTXHHOUHVWRGHODFODVHORKDFHSRUHO H[WHULRU6HREVHUYDFRPRDPERVVHGHVSOD]DQHQVLOODGHUXHGDVFDPELDQGRODGLUHFFLyQ\D VHD KDFLD GHODQWH R KDFLD DWUiV 3RVWHULRUPHQWH OD PDHVWUD OHV RUJDQL]D XQ FLUFXLWR FRQ FRQRVFXHUGDV\SLFDV6HLQLFLDFRQXQGHVSOD]DPLHQWRHQ]LJ]DJHQWUHORVFRQRVXQWRWDO GH OD GLVWDQFLD HQWUH HOORV HV GH XQRV GRV PHWURV SRVWHULRUPHQWH WLHQHQ TXH VHJXLU SDUDOHODPHQWH HO UHFRUULGR GH OD FXHUGD TXH HVWi VLWXDGD HQ HO VXHOR SDUD SDVDU HQWUH ODV SLFDV OD GLVWDQFLD HQWUH HOODV HV GH XQRV FP /DV YDULDQWHV TXH SURSRQH HV OD GH PRGLILFDUODGLUHFFLyQGHGHVSOD]DPLHQWRLQFOX\HQGRJLURVDOUHGHGRUGHODVSLFDV $ DPERV VH OHV SHUFLEH LQWHUHVDGRV SRU ODV SURSXHVWDV SHUR DO VHU GH FDUiFWHU PiV LQGLYLGXDOL]DGR QR JHQHUDQ QL UHFLEHQ LQWHUUHODFLRQHV FRQ VXV FRPSDxHURV 0H OODPD OD DWHQFLyQ TXH FXDQGR QR HVWi OD DX[LOLDU GH (( KD WHQLGR TXH VDOLU GH OD VDOD GXUDQWH GLH] 5 6(6,Ï11 5 5 PLQXWRV\GDGRTXHODPDHVWUDHVWiGDQGRFRQVLJQDVDOUHVWRGHOJUXSRFODVHHOORVDFXHUGDQ GLYHUVDVIRUPDVGHUHFRUULGRGHOFLUFXLWR (QODVHJXQGDWDUHDHOJUXSRFODVHWLHQHTXHUHDOL]DUGLYHUVRVGHVSOD]DPLHQWRVVREUHEDQFRV VXHFRVHQWRWDOGLVSXHVWRVHQGLVSRVLFLyQOLQHDOSDUDILQDOL]DUFRQXQDYROWHUHWDVREUHXQD FROFKRQHWD (QHOFDVRGH/ROD\-RUGLODDX[LOLDUOHVSURSRQHXQFLUFXLWRSDUDOHORFRQHOPLVPRPDWHULDO TXH HQ HO DQWHULRU /D GLIHUHQFLD HV TXH DKRUD HV OLQHDO MXJDQGR FRQ ODV GLUHFFLRQHV \ ORV JLURVHQWUHFRQRV 2EVHUYDPRVTXHGDGRTXHHVWDPELpQXQFLUFXLWRH[FOXVLYRSDUDHOORVQRKD\LQWHUDFFLRQHV FRQHOUHVWRGHOJUXSRFODVHWDQVyORSHUFLERLQWHUDFFLRQHVYHUEDOHVHQWUHHOORVTXHQRVRQ PX\QXPHURVDV$SHQDVVRQUtHQ 0LHQWUDVTXHODPDHVWUDYDUtDHOGLVHxRGHFLUFXLWRSDUDHOUHVWRGHOJUXSRFODVH-RUGL\/ROD UHDOL]DQGLYHUVRVHVWLUDPLHQWRV\HMHUFLFLRVGHPRYLOLGDGDUWLFXODUEUD]RVKRPEURV\WRELOORV SRUVROLFLWXGGHpVWRV\DTXHGLFHQTXHHVWiQFDQVDGRV $O ILQDOL]DU OD VHVLyQ OHV SUHJXQWR TXp OHV KD SDUHFLGR \ /ROD PH UHVSRQGH ³TXH HV PiV GLYHUWLGRFRQORVMXHJRV´PLHQWUDVTXHSDUD-RUGL\DOHKDHVWDGRELHQ &RPHQWDULRVDODVHVLyQ 6H FRQVWDWD TXH FXDQGR WLHQHQ TXH UHDOL]DU DFWLYLGDGHV GH FDUiFWHU PiV LQGLYLGXDOL]DGR VH UHGXFHQ ODV LQWHUDFFLRQHV FRQ ORV FRPSDxHURV GH WDO IRUPD TXH WDQ VyOR VH JHQHUDQ HQWUH HOORV &RPR H[SUHVD /ROD ³HV PiV GLYHUWLGR FRQ ORV MXHJRV´ OR TXH PH KDFH SHQVDU TXH HVWUDWpJLFDPHQWH SDUD DXPHQWDU OD VRFLDOL]DFLyQ HV QHFHVDULR HQ VLWXDFLRQHV VLPLODUHV LQLFLDU \ ILQDOL]DU OD VHVLyQ FRQ GRV MXHJRV DVHJXUDQGR DVt ODV SRVLEOHV LQWHUDFFLRQHV HQWUH /ROD\-RUGLFRQHOUHVWRGHOJUXSRFODVH 6(6,Ï11 5 5 5 5 5 5 5 '($%5,/ 1RKXERVHVLyQSRUTXHHOJUXSRSDUWLFLSyHQHOFRQFLHUWRGHSULPDYHUDTXHRUJDQL]yHOFHQWUR 5 '($%5,/ 6H LQLFLD OD VHVLyQ ³GDQGR YXHOWDV HQ FDUUHUD DO SDWLR´ &RPR HV KDELWXDO 5 6(6,Ï11 -RUGL\/RODUHDOL]DQHOUHFRUULGRSRUHOLQWHULRU /DVLJXLHQWHWDUHDHVHOMXHJRGHO³SLFKLFRQEDWHGHEpLVERO´ 5 (OJUXSRVHRUJDQL]DHQGRVHTXLSRVXQRHVHOODQ]DGRU\HORWURHOUHFHSWRU(OSULPHURVH ORFDOL]D GHWUiV GH XQD OtQHD \ HO VHJXQGR GLVWULEXLGRV SRU HO HVSDFLR GRQGH VH VLW~DQ ODV EDVHVTXHWLHQHQTXHUHFRUUHUHOHTXLSRODQ]DGRU(O³SLFKL´TXHSHUWHQHFHDOHTXLSRUHFHSWRU VHVLW~DHQXQDEDVHSUy[LPDDODOtQHDGHORWURHTXLSR3DUDOHODPHQWHQRVHQFRQWUDPRVFRQ HO³SDVDGRUGHSHORWD´TXHHVPLHPEURGHOHTXLSRODQ]DGRU 6HLQLFLDHOMXHJRFXDQGRHO³SDVDGRU´ODQ]DODSHORWDDOFRPSDxHURTXHGLVSRQHGHOEDWHGH EpLVEROeVWHWLHQHTXHJROSHDUODSHORWD\GLULJLUODDOWHUUHQRGHEDVHVLQWHQWDQGRHQYLDUODDO HVSDFLR YDFtR GH FRQWUDULRV /RV DGYHUVDULRV LQWHQWDQ DWUDSDU HO EDOyQ DO YXHOR SDUD DVt HOLPLQDUDOODQ]DGRU3HURSXHGHTXHHOEDOyQWRTXHDOVXHORRDODSDUHG\GHEHQHQWRQFHV UHFXSHUDUOR\SDVDUORDO³SLFKL´DODWUDSDUHOEDOyQJULWDUi³SLFKL´(VWHHVSDFLRGHWLHPSRVHUi XWLOL]DGRSRUHOODQ]DGRUSDUDSDVDUSRUHOUHFRUULGRGHEDVHV\SDUDDYDQ]DUORVFRPSDxHURV \DSRVLFLRQDGRVHQHOODV6LHQHOUHFRUULGRKD\YDULRVMXJDGRUHVHQEDVHVQRSRGUiQXQFD KDEHUPiVGHXQRSRUEDVHVHUiHOLPLQDGRDTXHOTXHOOHJXHHO~OWLPRDODPLVPD3DUDQR VHU HOLPLQDGRV HO ODQ]DGRU \ HO UHVWR GH FRPSDxHURV GHO UHFRUULGR GHEHUiQ HVWDU HQ XQD EDVHHQHOPRPHQWRTXHHO³SLFKL´JULWH6LVHFRQVLJXHKDFHUXQDFDUUHUDFRPSOHWDSRUXQ VRORODQ]DPLHQWRSDVDUSRUWRGDV\FDGDXQDGHODVEDVHVKDVWDOOHJDUDVXOtQHDHQWRQFHV VHVDOYDQWRGRVORVHOLPLQDGRV'HQRKDEHUQLQJXQRFREUDUiXQDYLGD\SRGUiSDVDUODDXQ IXWXURMXJDGRUHOLPLQDGR&DGDYH]TXHVHFRQVLJXHUHDOL]DUXQFLUFXLWRGHEDVHVVHFRQVLJXH XQSXQWRSDUDHOHTXLSR &XDQGRKDQVLGRWRGRVHOLPLQDGRVORVGRVHTXLSRVLQWHUFDPELDQUROHV*DQDHOHTXLSRTXH PiVSXQWRVVXPHHVGHFLUTXHPiVYXHOWDVKD\DQFRQVHJXLGR 1RWDHO³SLFKL´QXQFDSRGUiVDOLUGHVXEDVH (QHVWDVHJXQGDHGLFLyQSDUWLFLSDQDFWLYDPHQWHWDQWR/RODFRPR-RUGL/DVDGDSWDFLRQHVTXH SODQWHDPRVVRQODVTXHVLJXHQ &RORFDUXQDVEDVHVLQWHULRUHVHQHOLQWHULRUGHOFDPSR\SDUDOHORDOGHOUHVWRFRQHOILQGH GLVPLQXLUHOUHFRUULGRGHDPERV\DXPHQWDUHOQ~PHURGHEDVHVSDUDTXHQRORVHOLPLQHQ UiSLGDPHQWH $Vt PLVPR OD SULPHUD EDVH VH VLW~D D GRV PHWURV GH OD VDOLGD SDUD FRPSHQVDU HO WLHPSR GH DUUDQTXH GH OD VLOOD GH UXHGDV &RPR HO UHFRUULGR HV PiV UHGXFLGRVHOHVGDODRSRUWXQLGDGTXHORUHDOLFHQGRVYHFHVDOSULQFLSLR\ODILQDOVLHPSUH TXHQRVHHOLPLQHQHQODSULPHUDUHSHWLFLyQ&DGDUHFRUULGRUHDOL]DGRVXPDUiXQSXQWR SDUDHOHTXLSR &XDQGRHVWiQHVSHUDQGRDEDWHDUODSHORWDDDPERVVHOHVUHFXHUGDTXHVHVLW~HQHQXQ H[WUHPRGHOFDPSRSDUDQRUHFLELUQLQJ~QLPSDFWRGHEDOyQ &XDQGRHVWiQUHDOL]DQGRHOUHFRUULGRHQWUHODVEDVHVODDX[LOLDUGH((³KDFHVRPEUD´FRQ VXFXHUSRFRQHOREMHWLYRTXHQRUHFLEDQQLQJ~QEDORQD]RWDQWRSRUSDUWHGHOFRPSDxHUR EDWHDGRUFRPRSRUSDUWHGHORVDGYHUVDULRVFXDQGRSDVDQHOEDOyQD³SLFKL´ $PHGLGDTXHYDQDYDQ]DQGRSRUODVEDVHV\HOEDOyQHVWiSRUGHWUiVGHHOORVODDX[LOLDU GH((DFW~DGH³VSHDNHU´SDUDLQIRUPDUOHVVREUHODXELFDFLyQGHOEDOyQ\SRGHUGLVSRQHU GHHVWDPDQHUDGHPiVGDWRVTXHOHD\XGHQDGHFLGLUVREUHVXVGHVSOD]DPLHQWRV 5 (OJUXSRFODVHDFHSWDFRQQRUPDOLGDGODVDGDSWDFLRQHVSURSXHVWDVSDUDDPERV 2EVHUYDPRVTXHWDQWR/RODFRPR-RUGLSDUWLFLSDQPX\DFWLYDPHQWHJHQHUDQGRLQWHUDFFLRQHV FRQORVFRPSDxHURVPiVSUy[LPRVHQODVLWXDFLyQGHDWDTXHRELHQFXDQGRHVWiQHOLPLQDGRV (Q FDPELR HQ OD VLWXDFLyQ GH GHIHQVD QR VH SHUFLEHQ WDQWDV LQWHUUHODFLRQHV FRQ VXV FRPSDxHURV WDO YH] SRU OD GLILFXOWDG TXH HQWUDxD UHFHSFLRQDU HO EDOyQ GHVGH OD VLOOD GH UXHGDV 3RU OD DFWLWXG GH /ROD FRLQFLGLPRV HQ TXH HVWD GLILFXOWDG OH SURYRFD XQD JUDQ GHVPRWLYDFLyQ KDFLD HO MXHJR GDGR TXH DQWHV GH RSHUDUVH SRGtD UHFHSFLRQDU HO EDOyQ D LPDJHQTXHHOUHVWRGHFRPSDxHURV(QFDPELRODUHVSXHVWDGH-RUGLHVODGHGHVSOD]DUVH SRUOD]RQDGHGHIHQVDVLJXLHQGRHOUHFRUULGRGHVXVDGYHUVDULRV\HPLWLHQGRSDUDOHODPHQWH FRPHQWDULRVVREUHODHMHFXFLyQGHpVWRV &RPHQWDULRVDODVHVLyQ (VLQWHUHVDQWHFRQODQRUPDOLGDGTXHDFHSWDHOJUXSRFODVHODVDGDSWDFLRQHVSURSXHVWDVSDUD -RUGL\SDUD/ROD 3DUHFHVHUTXHODOLPLWDFLyQGHPRYLOLGDGSURYRFDHQ/RODXQDGHVPRWLYDFLyQKDFLDODSUiFWLFD HQ VLWXDFLRQHV GHWHUPLQDGDV DO FRPSDUDU VX DXWRQRPtD FRQ OD TXH WHQtD DQWHV GH OD RSHUDFLyQ 6H FRQVWDWD TXH GHSHQGLHQGR GH ODV FDUDFWHUtVWLFDV GHO MXHJR ODV LQWHUUHODFLRQHV VHUiQ PD\RUHVRPHQRUHV 6(6,Ï11 5 5 5 5 5 '($%5,/ 'DGRTXHHUDXQGtDOOXYLRVRODFODVHIXHWHyULFD /DV VHVLRQHV GH ORV GtDV \ GH DEULO QR VH UHJLVWUDQ SRUTXH FRLQFLGLHURQ FRQ ODV YDFDFLRQHVGH6HPDQD6DQWD 5 5 '($%5,/ 3DUDLQLFLDUODVHVLyQODPDHVWUDSURSRQH³GDUYXHOWDVDOSDWLRHQFDUUHUD´VLPXOWDQHiQGRODV FRQ GLIHUHQWHV WLSRV GH VDOWRV &RPR HV KDELWXDO /ROD \ -RUGL UHDOL]DQ HO UHFRUULGR SRU HO LQWHULRU \ OD $X[LOLDU GH (GXFDFLyQ (VSHFLDO OHV GD FRQVLJQDV FXDQGR HO UHVWR WLHQHQ TXH UHDOL]DUGLIHUHQWHVVDOWRVYHUWHEUDGDVDOUHGHGRUGHGLIHUHQWHVJUDGRVGHJLURVGHODVLOODGH UXHGDVRODHPLVLyQGHXQQ~PHURGHWHUPLQDGRGHSDOPDGDVHQWUHLPSXOVRHLPSXOVRGHOD VLOOD /DVLJXLHQWHSURSXHVWDHV³HOUHOHYRHQFDUUHUD´ 2UJDQL]D FLQFR JUXSRV GH FXDWUR QLxRV HQ ILOD /D GLVWDQFLD HQWUH JUXSRV HV GH XQRV WUHV 5 6(6,Ï11 5 PHWURV6LWXDGRVWUDVXQDOtQHDGHVDOLGDHOSULPHUPLHPEURFRQXQDURSHTXHxRHQODPDQR WLHQH TXH GHVSOD]DUVH HQ FDUUHUD KDVWD OOHJDU DO H[WUHPR GHO FDPSR PHWURV GRQGH OH HVSHUD XQ MXJDGRU GHO HTXLSR /H SDVD HO DUR \ VH TXHGD HQ HVH OXJDU PLHQWUDV TXH VX FRPSDxHURLQLFLDHOUHFRUULGRDODLQYHUVD\DVtVXFHVLYDPHQWHKDVWDTXHHO~OWLPRMXJDGRUGH XQJUXSROOHJDDVHUHOSULPHURHQOOHJDUDODOtQHDGHLQLFLR &RPR HQ HGLFLRQHV VLPLODUHV -RUGL \ HQ HVWD RFDVLyQ WDPELpQ /ROD SLHUGHQ WLHPSR HQ HO DUUDQTXH GH OD VLOOD GH UXHGDV \ VX YHORFLGDG HV PHQRU TXH OD GH VXV DGYHUVDULRV GHFLGLpQGRVHTXHUHFRUUHUiQXQWHUFLRGHOUHFRUULGRGHWDOPDQHUDTXHXQFRPSDxHURVHVLW~D DXQRVPHWURVSDUDFRJHUHODUR\VHORSDVDDOFRPSDxHURTXHHVWiDORWURH[WUHPRGHO FDPSR pVWHLQLFLDGHQXHYRHOUHFRUULGR KDFLD -RUGL R /ROD SDViQGROHV HO DURSDUDTXHOR WUDVODGHQDOLQLFLRGHODILOD 2EVHUYDPRV TXH DPERV VH VLHQWHQ PX\ FRPSURPHWLGRV SRU OD HYROXFLyQ GHO MXHJR PRVWUiQGRVHPX\FRPSHWLWLYRV(OUHVWRGHOJUXSRFODVHSRUVXDFWLWXG\DWLHQHLQWHULRUL]DGR HVWDVDGDSWDFLRQHVQRWHQLHQGRTXHLQVLVWLUODPDHVWUDSDUDUHFRUGDUODV 3DUDILQDOL]DUVHSURSRQHXQSDUWLGRGHEDORQFHVWR&RPRQRSXHGHQSDUWLFLSDUSRUHOULHVJR TXHVXSRQHFRPSDUWLUHOHVSDFLRGHMXHJRODDX[LOLDUORVFRQYRFDDOH[WUHPRGHOSDWLRSDUD UHDOL]DUGLIHUHQWHVWLSRVGHSDVHFRQSHORWDILQDOL]DQGRFRQXQWUDEDMRGHDEGRPLQDOHVHQOD VLOOD$SHVDUGHOWUDEDMRPiVLQGLYLGXDOL]DGRVHOHVREVHUYDPX\PRWLYDGRVSRUODVWDUHDVGH WDO IRUPD TXH OD LQWHUDFFLyQ HQWUH HOORV HV PX\ SRVLWLYD PRVWUiQGRVH PX\ FRPXQLFDWLYRV \ ULVXHxRV &RPHQWDULRVDODVHVLyQ (QWLHQGR TXH QR WHQHPRV TXH VDFULILFDU OD PRWULFLGDG GHO UHVWR GHO JUXSR FODVH SRU /ROD \ -RUGL SHUR FUHR TXH VH SRGUtD EXVFDU XQ PHMRU HTXLOLEULR HQWUH WDUHDV GH JUDQ \ SHTXHxR JUXSRSDUDHYLWDUODUHODFLyQDLVODGDHQWUH-RUGL\/RODHQDOJXQDVDFWLYLGDGHVHQFRQFUHWR &UHRTXHVHSRGUtDQRUJDQL]DUYDULRVJUXSRVHQFODVHGHWDOIRUPDTXHGHPDQHUDURWDWRULD SXGLHVHQFRPSDUWLUFRQDPERVODWDUHDSURSXHVWDFRQHOREMHWRGHDXPHQWDUODVRFLDOL]DFLyQ 6(6,Ï11 '($%5,/ $ LPDJHQ GH OD VHVLyQ DQWHULRU LQLFLD OD DFWLYLGDG ³GDQGR YXHOWDV DO SDWLR´ VLPXOWDQHDQGR OD FDUUHUDFRQVDOWRV/DDX[LOLDUGH((VHHQFDUJDGHSURSRQHUOHVDFWLYLGDGHVDOWHUQDWLYDVDORV VDOWRVJLUDQGRHQHVWDRFDVLyQDOUHGHGRUGHODPRYLOLGDGGHORVWRELOORVHQHOFDVRGH/ROD\ GHODVSLHUQDVHQHOGHO-RUGL $Vt PLVPR FRQWLQ~D FRQ HO WUDEDMR GHO EDORQFHVWR SURSRQLHQGR GLIHUHQWHV WLSRV GH SDVHV WLURVDFDQDVWD\ILQDOL]DQGRFRQSDUWLGR'HQXHYRODDX[LOLDUDGDSWDODSURSXHVWDHQOD]RQD HTXLGLVWDQWH GH GRQGH VH XELFD HO JUXSR SDUD HYLWDU TXH UHFLEDQ DOJ~Q JROSH GH EDOyQ 3DUDOHODPHQWHOHVSURSRQHDFWLYLGDGHVVLPLODUHVDOUHVWRGHOJUXSRDGLIHUHQFLDTXHODFDQDVWD HVWiPiVEDMDDXQPHWUR\PHGLRDSUR[LPDGDPHQWHGHOVXHOR/DFDQDVWDTXHKDQLGHDGROD 5 5 5 5 5 5 PDHVWUD\ODDX[LOLDUHVXQDSDSHOHUDGHSOiVWLFRFRUWDGDSRUODPLWDG\DVLGDDXQDIDURODGHO SDWLRPHGLDQWHXQDFXHUGD(OSDUWLGRVHVXEVWLWX\HSRUXQ³XQRFRQWUDXQR´HVGHFLUWLHQHQ TXHFRQVHJXLUUHDOL]DUXQWDQWRDFDQDVWDVLQTXHOHVVHDLQWHUFHSWDGRHOEDOyQ &RPR HQ OD VHVLyQ DQWHULRU OD LQWHUUHODFLyQ HQWUH DPERV HV SRVLWLYD D SHVDU GH OD GLVWDQFLD FRQHOUHVWRGHOJUXSRFODVH(QQLQJ~QPRPHQWRVHOHVSHUFLELyGHVPRWLYDGRVSRUODVWDUHDV DGDSWDGDV &RPHQWDULRVDODVHVLyQ 3RU ODV FDUDFWHUtVWLFDV GH OD VHVLyQ -RUGL \ /ROD VH FRPXQLFDURQ H LQWHUUHODFLRQDURQ SULQFLSDOPHQWHHQWUHHOORV\FRQODDX[LOLDUGH((H[FHSWXDQGRHQODHQWUDGD\HQODVDOLGDGH ODVHVLyQ 5 6(6,Ï11 '(0$<2 'DGRTXHHUDXQGtDOOXYLRVRODFODVHIXHWHyULFD 5 '(0$<2 /RODQRDVLVWHDODVHVLyQSRUTXHWLHQHYLVLWDDOPpGLFR &RPRHVKDELWXDO~OWLPDPHQWHVHLQLFLDODVHVLyQFRQ³GDUYXHOWDVDOSDWLR´HQFDUUHUD-RUGL VHWUDVODGDSRUHOLQWHULRUFRQXQUHFRUULGRLQIHULRUDOUHVWRGHOJUXSRFODVH 3RVWHULRUPHQWHODPDHVWUDSURSRQHXQ³XQRFRQWUDXQR´HQEDORQFHVWR 3RUSDUHMDV\DXQDGLVWDQFLDGHPHWURVGHODFDQDVWDHOTXHSRVHHHOEDOyQWLHQHTXH FRQVHJXLUKDFHUXQWDQWRHQODFHVWDVLQTXHVHDLQWHUFHSWDGRHOEDOyQSRUVXDGYHUVDULR &RPRODDX[LOLDUGH((HVWiDWHQGLHQGRDRWURQLxRFRQSDUiOLVLVFHUHEUDOTXHKDOOHJDGR PLQXWRVWDUGHGHELHQGRGHDFRPSDxDUORDODXODODPDHVWUDPHVXJLHUHTXHDWLHQGDD-RUGL MXJDQGRFRQpODO³XQRFRQWUDXQR´/DUHODFLyQTXHVXUJHHVPX\SRVLWLYDSHUFLELpQGRORPX\ PRWLYDGRSRUODHYROXFLyQGHOMXHJR $ FRQWLQXDFLyQ OD PDHVWUD GD OD FRQVLJQD GH TXH SRU SDUHMDV UHDOLFHQ GLIHUHQWHV WLSRV GH SDVH SRU OR TXH KH RSWDGR SRQHUPH MXQWR D HOORV D XQD GLVWDQFLD GH XQRV FLQFR PHWURV UHVSHFWRDOUHVWRGHOJUXSR\UHDOL]DUFRQ-RUGLODVWDUHDVHQFRPHQGDGDV /D FXDUWD DFWLYLGDG HV OD GH HQWUDU D FDQDVWD FRQ GRV SDVRV FRQ HO EDOyQ HQ OD PDQR 3RU VHJXULGDGGH-RUGLDGDSWRODFDQDVWD FRPRHQODVHVLyQQ\pVWHLQWHQWDFRRUGLQDUODV GLIHUHQWHV DFFLRQHV $ SHVDU GH WUDEDMDU LQGLYLGXDOPHQWH VH OH REVHUYD PRWLYDGR SRU HO DSUHQGL]DMH 3DUD ILQDOL]DU OD PDHVWUD SURSRQH XQ SDUWLGR GH EDORQFHVWR &RPR HQ HVH PRPHQWR VH LQFRUSRUDODDX[LOLDUGH((GHFLGLPRVMXJDUD³XQ´HQWUHORVWUHV (O MXHJR FRQVLVWH HQ FRQVHJXLU UHDOL]DU SXQWRV OR DQWHV SRVLEOH 6H DFXHUGD HO OXJDU GH LQLFLR GHO ODQ]DPLHQWR GHO SULPHU MXJDGRU VL FRQVLJXH HQFHVWDU VXPD GRV SXQWRV SXGLHQGR LQWHQWDUORGHQXHYRGHVGHHOOXJDUTXHKDUHFHSFLRQDGRHOEDOyQ\VLORFRQVLJXHVHOHVXPD XQSXQWRKDVWDTXHFRPHWHXQIDOORWHQLHQGRTXHUHFHSFLRQDUHOEDOyQHOFRPSDxHURTXHOH VXFHGHHLQLFLDUGHQXHYRHOMXHJRGHVGHHOSXQWRGHOHVSDFLRTXHKDUHFHSFLRQDGRHOEDOyQ -RUGL SDUWLFLSD PX\ DQLPDGDPHQWH OR REVHUYDPRV ULVXHxR \ PX\ FRPSHWLWLYR 3HUR LQGHSHQGLHQWHPHQWHGHVXLQWHUpVSRU ODVWDUHDVSURSXHVWDVVXLQWHUDFFLyQFRQHOJUXSRHV QXODH[FHSWXDQGRFRQORVDGXOWRV 5 5 6(6,Ï11 5 5 5 5 5 5 &RPHQWDULRVDODVHVLyQ 6LJRGHIHQGLHQGRODSUHPLVDGHTXH-RUGLWLHQHTXHFRPSDUWLUDOPi[LPRODVWDUHDVFRQVXV FRPSDxHURV\QRFRQHODGXOWR 5 '(0$<2 /DVHVLyQQRVHUHJLVWUDSRUTXHHOJUXSRFODVHVDOHGHH[FXUVLyQ 5 '(0$<2 $ LPDJHQ GH ODV VHVLRQHV DQWHULRUHV VH LQLFLD OD VHVLyQ ³GDQGR YXHOWDV DO SDWLR´ /H VLJXHQ HMHUFLFLRV GH LQLFLDFLyQ DO EDORQFHVWR 3RU VHJXULGDG OD DX[LOLDU GH (GXFDFLyQ (VSHFLDO VH GHVSOD]DDORWURH[WUHPRGHOFDPSRGHMXHJRSDUDWUDEDMDUPiVLQGLYLGXDOPHQWHFRQ-RUGL\ FRQ/ROD (QXQLQLFLROHVSURSRQHGLIHUHQWHVWLSRVGHSDVHVHVWiWLFRV\SRVWHULRUPHQWHGHVSOD]iQGRVH FRQODVLOODGHUXHGDV/DSHQ~OWLPDWDUHDHVODGH³WLURDFDQDVWD´SULPHURHVWiWLFRV\OXHJR FRQGHVSOD]DPLHQWRV+D\TXHUHFRUGDUTXHODFDQDVWDVHDGDSWDUHGXFLHQGRODDOWXUDWDO\ FRPRVHLQGLFDHQODVHVLyQQ3HUFLELPRVTXHODGLILFXOWDGDXPHQWDFXDQGRWLHQHQTXH FRQWURODU HOEDOyQ\VXVGHVSOD]DPLHQWRV HQ OD VLOOD 1R REVWDQWH VH OHV REVHUYD PRWLYDGRV SRUODUHDOL]DFLyQGHODVWDUHDVPRWULFHVDSHVDUGHTXHODFRPXQLFDFLyQHQWUHDPERVHVPX\ UHGXFLGD )LQDOL]DFRQXQ³´YHUGHVFULSFLyQHQODVHVLyQ/ODPDODDWHQFLyQODUHDFFLyQGH/ROD TXHVLQGHFLUQDGDDODDX[LOLDUVHGHVSOD]DKDFLDOD]RQDGHORVEDQFRVGRQGHVHORFDOL]DQ GRV FRPSDxHUDV TXH QR UHDOL]DQ OD VHVLyQ SRUTXH HVWiQ OHVLRQDGDV 3RU HOOR OD DX[LOLDU VH GHVSOD]DKDFLDDOOtSDUDUHFULPLQDUD/RODVXDFWLWXGUHFRUGiQGROHTXHQRSXHGHVDOLUGHOD FODVHDVXOLEUHDOEHGUtR3RVWHULRUPHQWHOHSLGHMXJDUFRQ-RUGLDO³´\ODDX[LOLDUOHFDVWLJD GLFLpQGROHTXHQR &RPHQWDULRVDODVHVLyQ 'DGDVODVFDUDFWHUtVWLFDVGHODVHVLyQHVOyJLFRTXHODLQWHUDFFLyQGH/ROD\-RUGLFRQVXV FRPSDxHURVVHDQXODH[FHSWXDQGRFXDQGR/RODVHGLULJHDODVGRVFRPSDxHUDVTXHHVWiQ VHQWDGDVHQORVEDQFRV +D\TXHVHxDODUTXHODUHODFLyQHQWUH-RUGL\/RODHQHVWDRFDVLyQKDVLGRPX\UHGXFLGD 5 6(6,Ï11 6(6,Ï11 5 5 5 5 6(6,Ï11 '(0$<2 /DVHVLyQGHKR\VHFHQWUDHQHOMXHJRGHO³SLFKLFRQEDWHGHEpLVERO´ 5 (OJUXSRVHRUJDQL]DHQGRVHTXLSRVXQRHVHOODQ]DGRU\HORWURHOUHFHSWRU(OSULPHURVH ORFDOL]D GHWUiV GH XQD OtQHD \ HO VHJXQGR GLVWULEXLGRV SRU HO HVSDFLR GRQGH VH VLW~DQ ODV EDVHVTXHWLHQHQTXHUHFRUUHUHOHTXLSRODQ]DGRU(O³SLFKL´TXHSHUWHQHFHDOHTXLSRUHFHSWRU VHVLW~DHQXQDEDVHSUy[LPDDODOtQHDGHORWURHTXLSR3DUDOHODPHQWHQRVHQFRQWUDPRVFRQ HO³SDVDGRUGHSHORWD´TXHHVPLHPEURGHOHTXLSRODQ]DGRU 6HLQLFLDHOMXHJRFXDQGRHO³SDVDGRU´ODQ]DODSHORWDDOFRPSDxHURTXHGLVSRQHGHOEDWHGH EpLVEROeVWHWLHQHTXHJROSHDUODSHORWD\GLULJLUODDOWHUUHQRGHEDVHVLQWHQWDQGRHQYLDUODDO HVSDFLR YDFtR GH FRQWUDULRV /RV DGYHUVDULRV LQWHQWDQ DWUDSDU HO EDOyQ DO YXHOR SDUD DVt HOLPLQDUDOODQ]DGRU3HURSXHGHTXHHOEDOyQWRTXHDOVXHORRDODSDUHG\GHEHQHQWRQFHV UHFXSHUDUOR\SDVDUORDO³SLFKL´DODWUDSDUHOEDOyQJULWDUi³SLFKL´(VWHHVSDFLRGHWLHPSRVHUi XWLOL]DGRSRUHOODQ]DGRUSDUDSDVDUSRUHOUHFRUULGRGHEDVHV\SDUDDYDQ]DUORVFRPSDxHURV \DSRVLFLRQDGRVHQHOODV6LHQHOUHFRUULGRKD\YDULRVMXJDGRUHVHQEDVHVQRSRGUiQXQFD KDEHUPiVGHXQRSRUEDVHVHUiHOLPLQDGRDTXHOTXHOOHJXHHO~OWLPRDODPLVPD3DUDQR VHU HOLPLQDGRV HO ODQ]DGRU \ HO UHVWR GH FRPSDxHURV GHO UHFRUULGR GHEHUiQ HVWDU HQ XQD EDVHHQHOPRPHQWRTXHHO³SLFKL´JULWH6LVHFRQVLJXHKDFHUXQDFDUUHUDFRPSOHWDSRUXQ VRORODQ]DPLHQWRSDVDUSRUWRGDV\FDGDXQDGHODVEDVHVKDVWDOOHJDUDVXOtQHDHQWRQFHV VHVDOYDQWRGRVORVHOLPLQDGRV'HQRKDEHUQLQJXQRFREUDUiXQDYLGD\SRGUiSDVDUODDXQ IXWXURMXJDGRUHOLPLQDGR&DGDYH]TXHVHFRQVLJXHUHDOL]DUXQFLUFXLWRGHEDVHVVHFRQVLJXH XQSXQWRSDUDHOHTXLSR &XDQGRKDQVLGRWRGRVHOLPLQDGRVORVGRVHTXLSRVLQWHUFDPELDQUROHV*DQDHOHTXLSRTXH PiVSXQWRVVXPHHVGHFLUTXHPiVYXHOWDVKD\DQFRQVHJXLGR 1RWDHO³SLFKL´QXQFDSRGUiVDOLUGHVXEDVH /DVDGDSWDFLRQHVTXHSODQWHDPRVHQXQSULQFLSLRVRQODVPLVPDVTXHHQODVGRVHGLFLRQHV DQWHULRUHV &RORFDUXQDVEDVHVLQWHULRUHVHQHOLQWHULRUGHOFDPSR\SDUDOHORDOGHOUHVWRFRQHOILQGH GLVPLQXLUHOUHFRUULGRGHDPERV\DXPHQWDUHOQ~PHURGHEDVHVSDUDTXHQRORVHOLPLQHQ UiSLGDPHQWH $Vt PLVPR OD SULPHUD EDVH VH VLW~D D GRV PHWURV GH OD VDOLGD SDUD FRPSHQVDUHOWLHPSRGHDUUDQTXHGHODVLOODGHUXHGDV &XDQGRHVWiQHVSHUDQGRDEDWHDUODSHORWDDDPERVVHOHVUHFXHUGDTXHVHVLW~HQHQXQ H[WUHPRGHOFDPSRSDUDQRUHFLELUQLQJ~QLPSDFWROHVLYRGHEDOyQ &XDQGRHVWiQUHDOL]DQGRHOUHFRUULGRHQWUHODVEDVHVODDX[LOLDUGH(GXFDFLyQ(VSHFLDO ³KDFHVRPEUD´HVGHFLUORVSURWHJHFRQVXFXHUSRFRQHOREMHWLYRTXHQRUHFLEDQQLQJ~Q EDORQD]R WDQWR SRU SDUWH GHO FRPSDxHUR EDWHDGRU FRPR SRU SDUWH GH ORV DGYHUVDULRV FXDQGRSDVDQHOEDOyQD³SLFKL´ $PHGLGDTXHYDQDYDQ]DQGRSRUODVEDVHV\HOEDOyQHVWiSRUGHWUiVGHHOORVODDX[LOLDU 5 GH (GXFDFLyQ (VSHFLDO DFWXDUi GH ³VSHDNHU´ SDUD LQIRUPDUOHV VREUH OD XELFDFLyQ GHO EDOyQ\SRGHUGLVSRQHUGHHVWDPDQHUDGHPiVGDWRVTXHOHD\XGHQDGHFLGLUVREUHVXV GHVSOD]DPLHQWRV &RPR/RODHVPiVOHQWDTXH-RUGLQRVHQFRQWUDPRVFRQODQHFHVLGDGGHLQFRUSRUDUOHPiV EDVHVHQVXUHFRUULGRVLHQGRGHXVRH[FOXVLYRSDUDHOOD$VtVHGHFLGHTXHODVEDVHVGH/ROD VHLGHQWLILFDQSRUORVFRQRVSXGLHQGRSDUDUVHWDPELpQHQODVEDVHVGH-RUGLLGHQWLILFDGDVSRU XQDFUX]GHWL]DHQVXHOR $SHVDUGHHVWDVPHGLGDV/RODGLFHDODDX[LOLDUGH((TXHVHVLHQWHULGtFXODSRUVXOHQWLWXG eVWDOHDQLPDDVHJXLUFRPHQWiQGROHTXHODOHQWLWXGHVWUDQVLWRULD\TXHORLPSRUWDQWHHVTXH SDUWLFLSHGHDKtODVDGDSWDFLRQHVSURSXHVWDV 2EVHUYDPRVTXHYDLQWHUDFFLRQDQGRFRQVXVFRPSDxHURVSHURQRFRQODPLVPDLQWHQVLGDG GH DQWHV GH OD RSHUDFLyQ $Vt PLVPR UHFRJHPRV TXH VRQ WDQWR /ROD FRPR -RUGL ORV TXH VXHOHQLQLFLDUODVFRQYHUVDFLRQHVFRQVXVFRPSDxHURV5HVSHFWRDpVWHORSHUFLELPRVHQXQ ODWHUDOGHOFDPSRFXDQGRIRUPDSDUWHGHOHTXLSREDWHDGRUSDUDHYLWDUHOJROSHGHXQEDOyQ 6H OH REVHUYD PX\ HQWUHJDGR SRU OD HYROXFLyQ GHO MXHJR PRVWUiQGRVH PX\ FRPSHWLWLYR \ PDQLIHVWDQGRDOHJUtDSRUODYLFWRULDGHVXVFRPSDxHURVDO]DQGRHOSXxRFDGDYH]TXHpVWRV FRQVLJXHQUHDOL]DUXQDFDUUHUDVHJXLGDDOFLUFXLWR (QODVLWXDFLyQGHGHIHQVDDSHVDUGHTXHSUHVHQWDQJUDQGHVGLILFXOWDGHVSDUDUHFHSFLRQDUHO EDOyQ D -RUGL VH OH REVHUYD PX\ HQWUHJDGR VLJXLHQGR OD HYROXFLyQ GH OD FDUUHUD GH ORV FRQWULQFDQWHVHLQFOXVRDYHFHVVHGHVSOD]DSDUDOHORVDHOORVHPLWLHQGRFRPHQWDULRV(QRWUDV RFDVLRQHVVHOHSHUFLEHHVWiWLFRHQOD]RQDGHMXHJRVPRVWUDQGRHYLGHQFLDVGHQHUYLRVLVPR FDGDYH]TXHORVDGYHUVDULRVYDQDYDQ]DQGRHQWUHEDVH\EDVH (Q FDPELR D /ROD VH OH REVHUYD PHQRV DSDVLRQDGD SRU HO MXHJR LQLFLDQGR LQWHUDFFLRQHV YHUEDOHV SXQWXDOHV FRQ VXV FRPSDxHURV PiV SUy[LPRV 3RGHPRV DILUPDU TXH HQ HVWD VLWXDFLyQGHGHIHQVDVHOHSHUFLEHVROLWDULD\GHVPRWLYDGDSRUODHYROXFLyQGHOMXHJR7DOYH] HOKHFKRGHHVWDUHQVLOODGHUXHGDVVHDODFDXVD &RPHQWDULRVDODVHVLyQ 6XEUD\RXQDREVHUYDFLyQLPSRUWDQWHGHODVHVLyQGHKR\UHJLVWURTXH/ROD\-RUGLVXHOHQVHU ORVTXHLQLFLDQODVLQWHUDFFLRQHVFRQORVRWURV /RODVHPXHVWUDFRQPHQRUFDSDFLGDGGHGLQDPL]DUFRPXQLFDFLRQHVFRQORVRWURV&UHHPRV TXH GHVGH TXH YD HQ VLOOD GH UXHGDV DO VHQWLUVH PiV OLPLWDGD OH FRQGLFLRQD VX FRPSRUWDPLHQWRHQHOJUXSRPRVWUiQGRVHPiVVROLWDULD\UHWUDtGD 6(6,Ï11 '(0$<2 'DGRTXHHUDXQGtDOOXYLRVRODFODVHIXHWHyULFD 5 5 5 5 5 5 5 6(6,Ï11 '(0$<2 /DVHVLyQVLJXHFHQWUiQGRVHHQHOMXHJRGH³SLFKLFRQHOEDWHGHEpLVERO´(QORVSUHSDUDWLYRV GHO PDWHULDO REVHUYR TXH /ROD FRODERUD DQLPDGDPHQWH FRQ OD PDHVWUD D\XGiQGROH D WUDVODGDUHOPDWHULDOGHODVEDVHV3DUDOHODPHQWHLQWHUDFW~DYHUEDOPHQWHFRQORVFRPSDxHURV PiVSUy[LPRV 0LHQWUDVWDQWR-RUGLHVWiFDVWLJDGRSRUODDX[LOLDUGH((GHWUiVGHODEDUDQGLOODGHOEDQFR(O PRWLYRHVHOGHQRLQWHULRUL]DUODVDGDSWDFLRQHV\QRDSOLFDUODVHQVLWXDFLRQHVGHMXHJROLEUH FRQVXVFRPSDxHURV /DPDHVWUDRUJDQL]DORVJUXSRVVLWXDQGRD/ROD\D-RUGLHQGLVWLQWRVHTXLSRV6HDFXHUGD TXHGDGRTXHHOUHFRUULGRGHDPERVHVPiVUHGXFLGRVHOHVGDODRSRUWXQLGDGTXHORUHDOLFHQ GRVYHFHVDOSULQFLSLR\ODILQDO&DGDUHFRUULGRUHDOL]DGRVXPDPHGLRSXQWRSDUDHOHTXLSR (QODVLWXDFLyQGHDWDTXHREVHUYRTXH-RUGLDOHVWDUHQHOODWHUDOGHOFDPSRSDUDSURWHJHUVH GH ORV EDORQHV \ DQWH OD GLVWDQFLD TXH OH VHSDUD GHO UHVWR GH FRPSDxHURV XQRV FXDWUR PHWURVQRUHJLVWURLQWHUDFFLyQDOJXQDH[FHSWXDQGRFXDQGRFRQVLJXHKDFHUXQDYXHOWDGHVX UHFRUULGRGHEDVHVTXHH[SUHVDVXDOHJUtDGDQGRSDOPDGDVDYDULRVGHVXVFRPSDxHURV\ JHVWLFXODQGRFRQHOSXxRHQDOWRHOVLJQRGHYLFWRULD (Q OD VHJXQGD YXHOWD KDFH WUDPSDV UHDOL]DQGR XQ UHFRUULGR PHQRU OR TXH SURYRFD OD UHFULPLQDFLyQGHODDX[LOLDUGH((QRYDOLGDQGRVXFDUUHUDHQHOFyPSXWRILQDOGHSXQWRV &XDQGRIRUPDSDUWHGHOHTXLSRGHIHQVLYRDLPDJHQGHODVHVLyQDQWHULRUVLJXHPX\GHFHUFD ODHYROXFLyQGHVXVDGYHUVDULRVFXDQGRUHFRUUHQODVEDVHVGHVSOD]iQGRVHSDUDOHORVDHOORVH LQWHQWDQGRGHVDOHQWDUORV3RUORTXHODDX[LOLDUGH((LQWHUYLHQHUHFRUGiQGROHTXHRFXSHXQ ODWHUDOGHOFDPSRSDUDTXHQROHJROSHHQHQORVGHVSOD]DPLHQWRV $ GLIHUHQFLD GH -RUGL FXDQGR /ROD VH HQFXHQWUD HQ OD VLWXDFLyQ GH DWDTXH D SHVDU GH XELFDUVH WDPELpQ HQ XQD HVTXLQD GHO FDPSR SDUD HYLWDU JROSHV GH EDOyQ LQWHUDFFLRQD YHUEDOPHQWHFRQVXVFRPSDxHUDVUHFODPiQGROHVVXDWHQFLyQ$SHVDUGHTXHODHOLPLQDQHQ ODSULPHUDUHSHWLFLyQHQODVHJXQGDVHOHREVHUYDPX\PRWLYDGD\HQWUHJDGD (QFXDQWRDVXDFWLWXGHQGHIHQVDFRPRWLHQHGLILFXOWDGHQUHFHSFLRQDUHOEDOyQVHPDQWLHQH PX\SDVLYDVLJXLHQGRFRQODPLUDGDHOUHFRUULGRGHOEDOyQ&XDQGRVHFDQVD\DQWHODFDORU GH OD MRUQDGD GH KR\ GHFLGH GHVSOD]DUVH SUy[LPD D OD PDHVWUD \ D ORV HOLPLQDGRV FRELMiQGRVH HQ OD VRPEUD 2EVHUYR TXH DSURYHFKD OD VLWXDFLyQ SDUD LQWHUDFFLRQDU YHUEDOPHQWHFRQORVFRPSDxHURVPiVSUy[LPRV &RPHQWDULRVDODVHVLyQ (VGHLQWHUpVUHJLVWUDUHOFDVWLJRGH-RUGLSRUSDUWHGHODDX[LOLDUGH((SRUTXHQRLQWHULRUL]D ODVDGDSWDFLRQHV\QRODVDSOLFDHQVLWXDFLyQGHMXHJROLEUHFRQVXVFRPSDxHURV 5 5 5 5 5 5 5 5 5 7DPELpQ VH KD GH VXEUD\DU ODV GLVWLQWDV DFWLWXGHV HQWUH -RUGL \ /ROD FXDQGR HVWiQ HQ OD HVTXLQDGHOFDPSRHQDWDTXHSURWHJLpQGRVHGHORVJROSHVPLHQWUDVTXH-RUGLQRPXHVWUD LQWHUpV SRU LQWHUDFFLRQDU \ SDUDOHODPHQWH QR UHFLEH LQLFLDWLYDV GH VXV FRPSDxHURV /ROD VH PXHVWUD PiV GLQDPL]DGRUD JHQHUDQGR LQWHUDFFLRQHV YHUEDOHV FRQ ORV PiV SUy[LPRV \ UHFODPiQGROHVODDWHQFLyQ 6(6,Ï11 5 '(0$<2 1RKD\VHVLyQSRUTXHWLHQHQHOHQVD\RGHOFDQWRFRUDOGHILQDOGHFXUVR 5 '(0$<2 6HFRQWLQ~DFRQHOMXHJRGHODVHVLyQDQWHULRU³SLFKLFRQEDWHGHEpLVERO´3DUDURPSHUFRQOD SDVLYLGDGHQODVLWXDFLyQGHGHIHQVDGH-RUGL\/RODSURSRQHPRVODVLJXLHQWHDGDSWDFLyQ 6H VLW~DQ D XQRV FXDWUR PHWURV TXH VXSRQH HO FLQFXHQWD SRU FLHQWR GHO UHFRUULGR HQWUH EDVHV HQ OtQHD UHFWD GHVGH HO LQWHULRU GHO FDPSR GH OD FXDUWD EDVH SDUD HYLWDU SRVLEOHV FKRTXHV&XDQGRHODGYHUVDULRRFXSDODWHUFHUDEDVHDOLQLFLDUODFDUUHUDKDFLDODFXDUWDWLHQH TXH LQWHQWDUDOFDQ]DUODDQWHVTXHORKDJDQ-RUGLR/ROD(QHOFDVRTXHDVtVHDFRQVLJXHQ PHGLRSXQWRSDUDVXHTXLSR /D SURSXHVWD HV DFHSWDGD SRU WRGRV FRQ QRUPDOLGDG GH HVWD PDQHUD FRQVHJXLPRV PD\RU PRWLYDFLyQSRUSDUWHGH-RUGL\/ROD$PHGLGDTXHORSRQHPRVHQSUiFWLFDQRVGDPRVFXHQWD TXHWHQHPRVTXHUHGXFLUXQPHWURHOUHFRUULGRGH/RODGDGDVXOHQWLWXG\TXHWDQVyORSXHGHQ HQIUHQWDUVHFRQDTXHOORVDGYHUVDULRVTXHVHKDQSDUDGRHQODWHUFHUDEDVHSDUDFRQWURODUODV HYROXFLRQHV 6H YH OD QHFHVLGDG GH TXH XQ DGXOWR DFW~H GH iUELWUR FRQWURODQGR TXLHQ OOHJD DQWHV D OD WHUFHUD EDVH SDUD HYLWDU GLVFXVLRQHV LQQHFHVDULDV 7DOHV DFRPRGDFLRQHV VRQ DFHSWDGDVSRUWRGRVVLQSUHVHQWDUREMHFLyQDOJXQD 2EVHUYDPRVHQHVWDRFDVLyQTXHDPERVQRWDQVyORJHQHUDQFRPXQLFDFLRQHVYHUEDOHVVLQR TXHWDPELpQUHFLEHQWDQWRHQDWDTXHFRPRHQGHIHQVD$PERVKDQFRQVHJXLGROOHJDUDQWHV TXHXQDGYHUVDULRSRUORTXHKDQVXPDGRPHGLRSXQWRSDUDFDGDHTXLSRUHVSHFWLYDPHQWHOR TXHKDDXPHQWDGRHOLQWHUpVSRUVXVFRPSDxHURVGHHTXLSR $O ILQDOL]DU HO MXHJR DO SUHJXQWDUOHV FyPR VH OR KDQ SDVDGR FRQ OD QXHYD DGDSWDFLyQ KDQ UHVSRQGLGR TXH ³KD VLGR PiV GLYHUWLGR´ \ ³TXH VH OR KDQ SDVDGR PXFKR PHMRU´ 6DOHQ GHO HVSDFLRGHMXHJRVFRPHQWDQGRDVXVFRPSDxHURVFyPRKDQFRQVHJXLGRFRODERUDUFRQHOORV FRQPHGLRSXQWRPiV &RPHQWDULRVDODVHVLyQ /DDX[LOLDUGH((PHFRPHQWDTXH/RODLQWHULRUL]DODVDGDSWDFLRQHVFRQIDFLOLGDGSHURTXHD 5 6(6,Ï11 5 5 5 -RUGLVHODVWLHQHQTXHUHFRUGDUSRUTXHKDELWXDOPHQWHQRODVUHFODPDFRPR/ROD3LHQVDTXH VH GHEH D TXH pVWH HVSHUD TXH VHD HO DGXOWR TXLHQ GHFLGD SRU pO VROXFLRQiQGROH ORV SUREOHPDV&UHHTXHODVREUHSURWHFFLyQHQODTXHHVWiLQPHUVROHSHUMXGLFDVXDXWRQRPtD (V LQWHUHVDQWH FRPR OD DGDSWDFLyQ LQFRUSRUDGD HQ VLWXDFLyQ GH GHIHQVD KD DXPHQWDGR OD SDUWLFLSDFLyQWDQWRGH-RUGLFRPRGH/ROD 7DO \ FRPR DILUPDQ KDVLGRPiVPRWLYDGRUSDUD HOORV\DODYH]VRQPiVUHFRQRFLGRVSRUHOUHVWRGHFRPSDxHURV\DTXHFRQVXDFWXDFLyQ SXHGHQFRODERUDUHQDXPHQWDUODSXQWXDFLyQILQDO $GLIHUHQFLDGHODVVHVLRQHVDQWHULRUHVQRWDQVyORKDQJHQHUDGRFRQYHUVDFLRQHVVLQRTXH WDPELpQKDQUHFLELGRODVLQLFLDWLYDVGHORVRWURV 6(6,Ï11 '(-81,2 6HFRQWLQ~DFRQHOMXHJRGHODVHVLyQDQWHULRU³SLFKLFRQEDWHGHEpLVERO´7DQWR/RODFRPR -RUGLVHOHVREVHUYDPX\FRPSURPHWLGRVFRQHOMXHJR(QODVLWXDFLyQGHDWDTXHREVHUYRTXH DPERV LQWHUDFFLRQDQ FRQ ORV FRPSDxHURV PiV SUy[LPRV SHUR FRQ PD\RU LQWHQVLGDG HQ HO FDVR GH /ROD 5HVSHFWR D -RUGL OD DX[LOLDU GH (( OH WLHQH TXH UHFRUGDU TXH VH VLW~H HQ XQ H[WUHPRGHOFDPSRSDUDSURWHJHUVHGHORVSRVLEOHVEDORQD]RV&DGDYH]TXH-RUGLFRQVLJXH UHDOL]DU XQD YXHOWD HQWUH VXV EDVHV OR FHOHEUD FRPR HV KDELWXDO HQ ODV ~OWLPDV VHVLRQHV HOHYDQGR HO SXxR YLWRUHDQGR OD YLFWRULD \ SDVDQGR GHODQWH GH VXV FRPSDxHURV (Q HVWD RFDVLyQQRSHUFLERUHFHSWLYLGDGDOJXQDSRUHOORJURGH-RUGL (QFXDQWRDODGHIHQVDLQGLFDUTXHODDX[LOLDUUHDMXVWDODGLVWDQFLDGHDPERVUHVSHFWRDOD FXDUWD EDVH GH ORV DGYHUVDULRV OR TXH VH DFHSWD FRQ WRWDO QRUPDOLGDG 0LHQWUDV TXH /ROD SDUWLFLSD FRQ OHJDOLGDG -RUGL HQ FDPELR LQWHQWD KDFHU WUDPSDV FXDQGR OD DX[LOLDU HVWi D GLVWDQFLDGHpO2ELHQUHGXFHHOUHFRUULGRRGLVFXWHFRQORVDGYHUVDULRVGLFLHQGRTXHpOKD OOHJDGRDQWHV\GHHVDIRUPDOHVLQWHUUXPSHHOUHFRUULGR(OORSURYRFDHOHQIDGRGHODDX[LOLDU UHFULPLQiQGROHVXFRPSRUWDPLHQWRGLFLpQGROHTXHVLFRQWLQ~DDVtVXVFRPSDxHURVQRYDQKD DFHSWDUODVDGDSWDFLRQHV $QRWRDGHPiVXQDGLVFXVLyQHQWUH-RUGL\XQRGHORVOtGHUHVGHFODVH3HUHeVWHFRQVLJXH GDUXQDYXHOWDVLQLQWHUUXSFLRQHVHQWUHODVEDVHVORTXHFRQVLJXHXQSXQWRSDUDVXHTXLSR\ DGHPiVVDOYDDXQFRPSDxHUR$SHVDUGHWDOHYLGHQFLD-RUGLOHGLVFXWHDOILQDOGHODVHVLyQ GLFLpQGROH TXH QR KD FRQVHJXLGR GDU OD YXHOWD \ pO HQ FDPELR VL OR KD FRQVHJXLGR 7DO FRPHQWDULR SURYRFD OD LUD GH 3HUH WHQLHQGR TXH LQWHUFHGHU OD PDHVWUD SDUD UHVROYHU HO FRQIOLFWR (Q FXDQWR D ODV LQWHUDFFLRQHV HQ GHIHQVD FRPHQWDU TXH VRQ PHQRUHV TXH HQ DWDTXH D LPDJHQTXHHOUHVWRGHOJUXSR &RPHQWDULRVDODVHVLyQ $-RUGLVHOHWLHQHTXHUHFRUGDUDVSHFWRVWDQEiVLFRVFRPRHVHOGHVXVHJXULGDGHQHOMXHJR 5 5 5 5 5 5 5 /DVWUDPSDVTXHLQWHQWDKDFHU-RUGLQRIDFLOLWDQODFRPXQLFDFLyQSRVLWLYDFRQDOJXQRVGHVXV FRPSDxHURV 6(6,Ï11 '(-81,2 &RQWLQ~DQFRQODSUiFWLFDGHOMXHJR³SLFKLFRQEDWHGHEpLVERO´(QODVLWXDFLyQGHDWDTXHOD DX[LOLDU GH (( WLHQH TXH UHFRUGDU D -RUGL UHLWHUDGDPHQWH TXH VH SRQJD HQ OD VRPEUD QR LQWHUDFFLRQDQGR FRQ QLQJXQR GH VXV FRPSDxHURV PLHQWUDV TXH /ROD VL OR KDFH LQLFLDQGR \ UHFLELHQGR LQWHUDFFLRQHV YHUEDOHV FRQ ORV PiV SUy[LPRV D HOOD 5HVSHFWR HQ OD GHIHQVD D DPERV VH OHV REVHUYD PX\ PRWLYDGRV FRQ OD DGDSWDFLyQ SDFWDGD \ FRPR HQ HGLFLRQHV DQWHULRUHVODVLQWHUDFFLRQHVVRQPHQRUHVSRUODSURSLDGLQiPLFDGHOMXHJR &RPHQWDULRVDODVHVLyQ $-RUGLVHOHWLHQHTXHVHJXLUUHFRUGDQGRFRQVLJQDVEiVLFDVSDUDSUHVHUYDUVXVHJXULGDG 6(6,21(61\ \'(-81,2 7DPSRFR SXHGR UHJLVWUDU ODV VHVLRQHV SRUTXH HVWR\ SDVDQGR ORV VRFLRJUDPDV GH ILQDO GH FXUVR1RREVWDQWHFXDQGRVROLFLWRLQIRUPDFLyQVREUHHOFRPSRUWDPLHQWRGHDPERVHQHVWDV VHVLRQHVWDQWRODPDHVWUDFRPRODDX[LOLDUGH((QRGHVWDFDQQLQJ~QDVSHFWRUHOHYDQWH/D VHVLyQGHOGtDJLUyDOUHGHGRUGHOMXHJR³SLFKLFRQEDWHGHEpLVERO´\ODGHOODPDHVWUD GLVHxyXQFLUFXLWRGHKDELOLGDGHVPRWULFHVDGDSWiQGRORD/ROD\D-RUGLSRUORTXHUHDOL]DURQ XQWUDEDMRPiVLQGLYLGXDOL]DGREDMRODVXSHUYLVLyQGHODDX[LOLDUGH(( 6(6,Ï11 '(-81,2 &RLQFLGH FRQ OD ILHVWD UHFUHDWLYD GH ILQDO GH FXUVR GH OD HVFXHOD 6H SURSRQHQ GLIHUHQWHV HVWDFLRQHV O~GLFDV \ VH RUJDQL]DQ WDQWRV JUXSRV FRPR HVWDFLRQHV &DGD JUXSR HVWi FRQIRUPDGRSRUUHSUHVHQWDQWHVGHFDGDFXUVRGHWDOIRUPDTXHWRGRVSDUWLFLSDQGHWRGDVODV DFWLYLGDGHVLQGHSHQGLHQWHPHQWHGHODHGDGGHHVWDIRUPDVHSRWHQFLDODVRFLDOL]DFLyQ 1R SXHGR UHDOL]DU HO VHJXLPLHQWR GH /ROD \ -RUGL SRUTXH HQ XQD GH ODV HVWDFLRQHV IDOWD XQ HGXFDGRU\PHVLHQWRFRQODUHVSRQVDELOLGDGGHFRODERUDUFRQODRUJDQL]DFLyQGHWDOIRUPD TXHSRULQLFLDWLYDSURSLDDVXPRODVXVWLWXFLyQ(QODHVWDFLyQTXHHVWR\HVODGHOUHOHYR&RPR HQ HGLFLRQHV DQWHULRUHV HO UHFRUULGR GH -RUGL \ /ROD VH UHGXFH D XQD WHUFHUD SDUWH GHO UHFRUULGR/DDGDSWDFLyQHVELHQUHFLELGDSRUWRGRVORVFRPSRQHQWHVGHDPERVJUXSRVSRUOR TXHDFHSWDQFRQWRWDOQRUPDOLGDGODFRPSHQVDFLyQ 5HFRMRSRVWHULRUPHQWHODSDUWLFLSDFLyQGH/ROD\-RUGLDORODUJRGHODMRUQDGD/DDX[LOLDUGH 5 5 5 5 5 5 5 ((UHVDOWDODSDUWLFLSDFLyQDFWLYDGHDPERVHQWRGDVODVHVWDFLRQHV\DTXHVHKDSHQVDGRHQ VXDGDSWDFLyQ&RQWLQ~DGLFLHQGRTXHORVREVHUYDPX\LQWHUDFWLYRVFRQVXVFRPSDxHURVGH RWUDVFODVHV\GHGLIHUHQWHVHGDGHV1RVHUHJLVWUDQLQJ~QDVSHFWRQHJDWLYRUHVSHFWRDODV UHODFLRQHVVRFLDOHVPiVELHQDOFRQWUDULRVHSHUFLEHXQDWRWDODFHSWDFLyQGHDPERVHQVXV JUXSRVUHVSHFWLYRV &RPHQWDULRVDODVHVLyQ (VLQWHUHVDQWHVXEUD\DUFRPRORVFRPSDxHURVGHODVRWUDVFODVHVDFHSWDQFRQQRUPDOLGDGOD DGDSWDFLyQGHODVGLIHUHQWHVHVWDFLRQHVGHMXHJR $VtPLVPRHOp[LWRGHOUHVXOWDGRGHODVHVLyQGHKR\VHGHEHHQWUHRWURVDVSHFWRVDTXHOD PDHVWUD \ OD DX[LOLDU GH (( KDQ SHQVDGR FRQ DQWHODFLyQ ODV DGDSWDFLRQHV QHFHVDULDV SDUD FRQVHJXLUODSDUWLFLSDFLyQDFWLYD\HIHFWLYDGHDPERVHQODMRUQDGDUHFUHDWLYD 5 5 DQH[R 'LDULRVGHFDPSRGHOUHFUHRGHDPERVFHQWURV '(2&78%5('( &(17525(&5(26'(0$5Ë$ 6(6,Ï11 &RPR 0DUtD WLHQH TXH ILQDOL]DU XQ WUDEDMR GH DXOD VH WUDVODGD DO SDWLR FRQ GLH] PLQXWRV GH UHWUDVR UHVSHFWRDOUHVWRGHFRPSDxHURVGHFODVH6HLQFRUSRUDHQXQJUXSRGHFLQFRQLxDV\XQQLxR(OMXHJR TXHHVWiQUHDOL]DQGRHVHOGHWRFDU\SDUDU&RQVLVWHHQTXHXQMXJDGRUHVHOSHUVHJXLGRU\HOUHVWRKX\HQ HQFDUUHUDSDUDQRVHUWRFDGRVSRUpO(QHOPRPHQWRTXHWRFDDXQMXJDGRURMXJDGRUDVHFDPELDQORV UROHV 6HREVHUYDTXH0DUtDLQWHQWDVHJXLUODHYROXFLyQGHOMXHJRSHURWDQVyORHQXQDRFDVLyQDORODUJRGHORV TXLQFHPLQXWRVGHGXUDFLyQHVWRFDGDSRUVXVFRPSDxHURV0HOODPDODDWHQFLyQODDFWLWXGGHODMXJDGRUD TXHSHUVLJXH0DUtDpVWDHQOHWHFHODFDUUHUDKDVWDTXHIDFLOLWDTXHODWRTXH $SHVDUGHODFDVLQXODLQWHUDFFLyQFRQVXVFRPSDxHURVGHMXHJRHOODVHYDGHVSOD]DQGRFRQVWDQWHPHQWH VLJXLHQGR D VXV FRPSDxHURV \ SHUFLER TXH D SHVDU GH HOOR OH PRWLYD OD VLWXDFLyQ SRUTXH VRQUtH FRQVWDQWHPHQWH (Q HO GHVSOD]DPLHQWR KDFLD HO JLPQDVLR HVWi SUy[LPD D VXV FRPSDxHURV GH MXHJR SHUR VLQ LQWHUDFFLyQ DOJXQD 6(6,Ï11 '(2&78%5('( (Q HVWD RFDVLyQ HV OD PDHVWUD GH (GXFDFLyQ )tVLFD OD TXH YLJLOD HO SDWLR (Q OD ]RQD GRQGH VH XELFD UHSDUWHFXHUGDVERORV\SHORWDVGHSHWDQFDSDUDTXHMXHJXHQOLEUHPHQWHORVQLxRV\QLxDV0DUtDHQWUDD OD]RQDFRQXQFXDUWRGHKRUDPiVWDUGHTXHHOUHVWR6HDFHUFDDODPDHVWUD\pVWDOHVXJLHUHTXHYD\DD MXJDUFRQXQJUXSRGHFXDUWRGHSULPDULDDORVERORV'XUDQWHORVTXLQFHPLQXWRVUHVWDQWHVVHREVHUYDD XQD 0DUtD PX\ SRFR FRPXQLFDWLYD VHULD \ QR SUHVHQWDQGR QLQJXQD LQLFLDWLYD SDUD UHODFLRQDUVH FRQ VXV FRPSDxHURVGHMXHJRV (OJUXSRVHRUJDQL]DSRUWXUQRVSDUDODQ]DU\0DUtDORKDFHGHVGHODSRVLFLyQGHDUURGLOODGD(VFXDQGROH SDVDQODSHORWDFXDQGRVHJHQHUDQPiVLQWHUUHODFLRQHVFRQHOOD /D PDHVWUD VXJLHUH DO JUXSR TXH ODQFH OD SHORWD GHVGH XQD PD\RU GLVWDQFLD 7DO \ FRPR HOOD LQGLFD HO JUXSRREHGHFHDODFRQVLJQDH[FHSWXDQGR0DUtDTXHODQ]DGHVGHHOOXJDULQLFLDOVLQREVHUYDUVHQLQJXQD RSRVLFLyQGHOUHVWRGHSDUWLFLSDQWHV &XDQGRILQDOL]DHOWLHPSRGHSDWLR0DUtDVHGHVSOD]DHQVROLWDULRKDFLDHOJLPQDVLR 6(6,Ï11 '(2&78%5('( /RFDOL]RD0DUtDVHQWDGDHQHOVXHORMXQWRDODHVFDOHUDGHHQWUDGDDOSDWLRJUDQGH6HKDSDVDGRWRGRHO WLHPSRREVHUYDQGRGHVGHHVDVLWXDFLyQDORVQLxRV\QLxDVGHHGXFDFLyQLQIDQWLOTXHVHXELFDQHQHOSDWLR LQIHULRU 7DQ VyOR HQ XQD RFDVLyQ UHJLVWUR TXH LQWHUDFFLRQD YHUEDOPHQWH FRQ XQD DOXPQD GH HGDG PiV WHPSUDQDVLHQGRpVWDODTXHLQLFLDODFRQYHUVDFLyQ &RPHQWDULRVDODREVHUYDFLyQ &XDQGR SUHJXQWR D VXV FRPSDxHUDV GH FODVH VL HV KDELWXDO TXH 0DUtD WHQJD HVH FRPSRUWDPLHQWR PH FRQWHVWDQDILUPDWLYDPHQWH $OFRQWUDVWDUORFRQODPDHVWUDGH(GXFDFLyQ)tVLFDPHFRPHQWDTXHFXDQGRHOODYLJLODHOSDWLRDOOOHYDU PDWHULDOO~GLFRODDQLPDDSDUWLFLSDU3HURFXDQGRHOODQRHVWiGHVFRQRFHHOFRPSRUWDPLHQWRGHpVWD 6(6,Ï11 '(0$5=2'( 0DUtDQREDMyDOSDWLRSRUTXHVHTXHGyHQHODXODILQDOL]DQGRORVHMHUFLFLRVGHFODVH 6(6,Ï11 '(0$5=2'( (QHVWDRFDVLyQWDPSRFRODORFDOL]RHQHOSDWLRGHELGRDTXHVHHQFXHQWUDHQHOYHVWXDULRGHOJLPQDVLR FRPLHQGR HO ERFDGLOOR \ REVHUYDQGR D XQDV FRPSDxHUDV GH VH[WR TXH HVWiQ HODERUDQGR XQ PXUDO GH IRWRJUDItDVSDUDFROJDUORDOOt 3UHVHQWDXQDDFWLWXGSDVLYDUHDOL]DQGRFRPHQWDULRVHVSRQWiQHRVHQIXQFLyQGHODVIRWRV 6(6,Ï11 '(-81,2'( (QWUDDOSDWLRGHVSXpVGHPLQXWRVGHVXLQLFLRVLHQGRXQLQGLFDGRUGHVXOHQWLWXGHQODVDOLGDGHODXOD\ HQ HO GHVSOD]DPLHQWR /RV SULPHURV PLQXWRV VH OD ORFDOL]D HQ VROLWDULR VHQWDGD HQ HO VXHOR HQ XQD HVTXLQD\FRPLHQGRHOERFDGLOOR'HYH]HQFXDQGRVHJLUDKDFLDDWUiV\REVHUYDORTXHDFRQWHFHHQHO SDWLRGH(GXFDFLyQ,QIDQWLO7DQVyORFRQYHUVDGXUDQWHWUHVPLQXWRVDSUR[LPDGDPHQWHFRQXQDDOXPQD GHSULPHURGH3ULPDULD )LQDOL]DGRHVWHSHUtRGRGHWLHPSRVHGHVSOD]DDORWURH[WUHPRGHOSDWLRGRQGHXQJUXSRGHFRPSDxHURV GH FODVH MXHJDQ D ODV FDUWDV (Q QLQJ~Q LQVWDQWH SUHVHQWD LQLFLDWLYDV SDUD LQFRUSRUDUVH DO JUXSR 1L HOOD LQWHUDFFLRQDYHUEDOPHQWH\JHVWXDOPHQWHFRQHOORVQLYLFHYHUVD 3RVWHULRUPHQWHSDVDDREVHUYDUDXQJUXSRGHWHUFHURGHSULPDULDTXHMXHJDQDO7,&2 7$&2 &RQVLVWHHQODQ]DUXQDFiSVXODGHSORPRKDFLDRWUDVVHLVTXHHVWiQDOLQHDGDVDXQPHWUR \PHGLRGHGLVWDQFLD(OMXHJRFRQVLVWHHQGHUULEDUHOPi[LPRGHFiSVXODV (QWUHORVLQWHJUDQWHVGHOJUXSRVHHQFXHQWUDVXFRPSDxHUR/XtV(QYDULDVRFDVLRQHVKDEODFRQpO\VHOH REVHUYDVRQULHQWHVLJXLHQGRODHYROXFLyQGHOMXHJR(QQLQJ~QPRPHQWRLQWHUDFFLRQDYHUEDOPHQWHFRQORV MXJDGRUHVGHWHUFHURGHSULPDULD &XDQGRILQDOL]DHOHVSDFLRGHOSDWLRREVHUYRTXH0DUtDVHGHVSOD]DHQVROLWDULRKDFLDHOJLPQDVLR 6(6,Ï11 '(-81,2'( &RPR HQHOGtDDQWHULRUOOHJDXQRVPLQXWRVWDUGH\GHGLFDPLQXWRVDHVWDUVHQWDGDHQVROLWDULR FRPLHQGRHOERFDGLOOR\REVHUYDQGRHOSDWLRGHORVGH(GXFDFLyQ,QIDQWLO 3RVWHULRUPHQWHVHGHVSOD]DDORWURH[WUHPRGHOSDWLRFRQFUHWDPHQWHGRQGHMXHJDXQRGHORVJUXSRVGHOD FODVHGHWHUFHURGH3ULPDULD\DLPDJHQGHD\HUREVHUYDHOMXHJRGHO7,&27$&23HURFRPRKR\HVWR\ JUDEDQGR FRQ YtGHR FUHR TXH LQWX\H TXH OD HVWR\ VLJXLHQGR D SHVDU GH PL GLVWDQFLD GH PHWURV \ GHFLGHDOHMDUVHGHHVHJUXSRGHVSOD]iQGRVHKDFLDRWURGHQLxDVGHVXFODVH'HMRGHJUDEDU\REVHUYR TXHHVWiQMXJDQGRDDGLYLQDUORTXHUHSUHVHQWDXQDFRPSDxHUD$HOODODSHUFLERVRQULHQWH\FRQYHUVDQGR FRQHOODV 3RVWHULRUPHQWH VH GLVXHOYH HO JUXSR \ 0DUtD VH GLULJH FRQ XQD FRPSDxHUD GHO JUXSR DQWHULRU KDFLD OD VDOLGDGHOSDWLRFRQHOILQGHLUDOJLPQDVLRSDUDREVHUYDUHOEDLOHTXHHVWiHQVD\DQGRXQJUXSRGHFODVH /DPDHVWUDTXHFRQWURODHOSDWLROHVLQGLFDTXHQRSXHGHQVDOLUGHOUHFLQWRSRUORTXHGHFLGHQLUDORWUR H[WUHPRGHOSDWLRSDUDMXJDUDOMXHJRWUDGLFLRQDOGHOD5D\XHOD0LHQWUDVTXHHOODVMXHJDQDQLPDGDPHQWH KDJRYHUTXHJUDERLPiJHQHVGHOSDWLRHQJHQHUDOKDVWDTXHPHDSUR[LPRDHOODV(QHVWDRFDVLyQDFW~DQ FRQWRWDOQRUPDOLGDG $OILQDOL]DUHOSDWLR0DUtDVDOHFRQVXFRPSDxHUDKDFLDHOJLPQDVLRLQWHUDFWXDQGRYHUEDOPHQWH &(17525(&5(26'(/2/$<-25', 6(6,Ï11 '(2&78%5('( (QHVWDRFDVLyQREVHUYRD/ROD6HSDVDWRGRHOSDWLRMXJDQGRDODSHORWDFD]DGRUD 'LVWULEXLGRVOLEUHPHQWHSRUHOHVSDFLR\XQEDOyQ4XLHQFRJHHOEDOyQSXHGHGDUWUHV SDVRVODUJRVSDVRVGHJLJDQWHFRQpOHQODPDQRDOWHUFHURHOUHVWRGHOJUXSRVH LQPRYLOL]D\pVWHWLHQHTXHLQWHQWDULPSDFWDUHOEDOyQKDFLDXQDSDUWHFRUSRUDOGHFXDOTXLHU MXJDGRUVLQTXHERWHHQHOVXHOR(QHOFDVRGHTXHQRSXHGDFRJHUORHOMXJDGRUHVWi ³PXHUWR´HOLPLQDGR7DQVyORVHVDOYDUHFXSHUDVHUMXJDGRUGHFDPSRHQHOPRPHQWR TXHKDQ³PDWDGR´DOTXLHQORKDHOLPLQDGR 6H REVHUYD D XQD /ROD PX\ DFWLYD \ PX\ FRPSHWLWLYD TXH LQWHUDFFLRQD FRQVWDQWHPHQWH FRQ VXV FRPSDxHURV 3HUFLER TXH JUDQ SDUWH GH ORV SDUWLFLSDQWHV GH OD RWUD FODVH GH TXLQWR FXDQGR SRVHHQ HO EDOyQ OD LJQRUDQ D SHVDU GH VX DFWLWXG GHVDILDQWH (Q FDPELR VXV FRPSDxHURV GH FODVH VDOYR HQ WUHV RFDVLRQHVQRODLJQRUDQFXDQGRODWLHQHQSUy[LPD 3DUD SURORQJDU VX SHUPDQHQFLD HQ HO MXHJR SDFWDQ TXH WLHQH GRV YLGDV HV GHFLU TXH Vt OD PDWDQ GRV YHFHVSXHGHSHUPDQHFHUHQHOFDPSR$JRWDGDVODVGRVYLGDVDODWHUFHUDRFDVLyQTXHODLPSDFWDQFRQ HOEDOyQSDVDDHVWDU³PXHUWD´ (Q HO PRPHQWR TXH HVWi FDQVDGD HOOD VH UHJXOD SHUPXWDQGR VX SUHVHQFLD HQ HO FDPSR FRQ XQD FRPSDxHUDHOLPLQDGD&XDQGR\DKDEDMDGRSXOVDFLRQHVKD\XQFDPELRGHURO 6(6,Ï11 '(2&78%5('( 'DGR TXH -RUGL FRQWLQ~D UHFXSHUiQGRVH HQ FDVD PH FHQWUR HQ /ROD ,QLFLD VX WLHPSR GH SDWLR FRPSDUWLpQGROR FRQ RFKR FRPSDxHUDV eVWDV VH ORFDOL]DQ VHQWDGDV HQ ODV HVFDOHUDV SUy[LPDV D UHFHSFLyQRMHDQGRXQOLEUR3HUPDQHFHDOOtKDVWDTXHILQDOL]DHOGHVD\XQR 3RVWHULRUPHQWH VH GLULJH KDFLD XQ JUXSR GH FXDWUR FRPSDxHUDV TXH HVWiQ HQVD\DQGR XQD FRUHRJUDItD RWUR JUXSR GH VLHWH QLxDV ODV HVWiQ REVHUYDQGR (Q XQ SULQFLSLR VH VLW~D FRQ HO JUXSR REVHUYDGRU SHUR WUDQVFXUULGRVXQRVFXDWURPLQXWRVVHDSUR[LPDDOGHODFRUHRJUDItDUHFODPDQGRSDUWLFLSDUGHODGLQiPLFD eVWDVVHQLHJDQMXVWLILFiQGRVHFRQTXHHOJUXSR\DHVWiFRPSOHWR (QRMDGD /ROD VH DFHUFD D RWUD FRPSDxHUD GHO JUXSR REVHUYDGRU LQVWiQGROH TXH VH RUJDQLFH RWUR SDUD FUHDUXQDFRUHRJUDItDeVWDFRQWHVWDTXHQRSXHGHVHUSRUTXHIDOWDQGRVFRPSDxHUDV\TXHFRPR/RODQR VXHOHDSRUWDUHQODFRUHRJUDItDPHMRUHVSHUDUDHOODV$SHVDUGHODUHVSXHVWDYDULDVVRQODVYHFHVTXHOD REVHUYRLQFLWDQGRDRWUDVFRPSDxHUDVTXHHVWiQMXJDQGRDODSHORWDFD]DGRUDDPRQWDUODFRUHRJUDItD 3HURFLQFRPLQXWRVDQWHVGHILQDOL]DUHOSDWLRFRQVLJXHVXFRPHWLGR 0LHQWUDVWDQWRPHOODPDODDWHQFLyQODSHUVHFXFLyQTXHUHDOL]DWUDVXQFRPSDxHURGHFODVH,QWHQWDHQXQ SDU GH RFDVLRQHV ODQ]DUOH D OD HVSDOGD XQD EROVD TXH OOHYD FRQVLJR ORV GtDV GH (GXFDFLyQ )tVLFD TXH FRQWLHQHXQDSHTXHxDWRDOOD\XQVXpWHUGHUHFDPELR&XDQGROHSUHJXQWRDVXFRPSDxHURHOPRWLYRGLFH TXHODKDLQFUHSDGRYHUEDOPHQWHSHURTXHQRREVWDQWHTXHHVPX\KDELWXDOREVHUYDUD/RODFXDQGRVH HQIDGDFRQODEROVDHQODPDQR\GHWUiVGHDOJ~QFRPSDxHUR 6(6,Ï11 '(129,(0%5('( 0HFHQWURHQODREVHUYDFLyQGHOFRPSRUWDPLHQWRGH-RUGLHQHOSDWLR%DMDGHODFODVHFRQGLH]PLQXWRVGH UHWUDVR$FRPSDxDGRSRU3HSDOXPQRGHFXDUWRFXUVRTXHSUHVHQWDXQDSDUiOLVLVFHUHEUDOTXHOHDIHFWD WDQWR OD PRYLOLGDG GH PDQRV FRPR GH SLHUQDV WHQLHQGR TXH XWLOL]DU XQD VLOOD GH UXHGDV HOpFWULFD \ OD DX[LOLDUGH(GXFDFLyQ(VSHFLDOVHVLW~DQSUy[LPRVDXQEDQFRRULHQWDGRKDFLDHOSDWLRJHQHUDO0LHQWUDV TXHODDX[LOLDUD\XGDD3HSDTXHFRPDHOERFDGLOOR-RUGLGHVD\XQDREVHUYDQGRDORVFRPSDxHURVTXH HVWiQMXJDQGRDI~WERO7DQVyORHQORV~OWLPRVFLQFRPLQXWRVSUHYLRVDODILQDOL]DFLyQGHOWLHPSRGHSDWLR VHDSUR[LPDXQFRPSDxHUR\HVWDEOHFHFRQYHUVDFLyQFRQpOSRVWHULRUPHQWHORKDFHQFXDWURFRPSDxHUDV PiV 6(6,Ï11 '(-81,2'( /RODVHGHVSOD]DHQVLOODGHUXHGDVSRUODRSHUDFLyQTXHKDHVWDGRVRPHWLGDSDUDSURORQJDUODORQJLWXGGH VXVSLHUQDV$OOOHYDUKLHUURVHQODSLHUQDVVHWLHQHTXHSURWHJHUGHSRVLEOHVLPSDFWRVFRQORVFRPSDxHURV RFRQORVREMHWRV'HDKtTXHODORFDOL]RFRQODDX[LOLDUGH(GXFDFLyQ(VSHFLDOMXQWRD-RUGL\D3HSD GLVWDQFLDGHOUHVWRGHFRPSDxHURVTXHSUDFWLFDQMXHJRVGLYHUVRV -XQWRDHOORVXQJUXSRGHFRPSDxHURVTXHYDQHQWUDQGR\VDOLHQGRGHOHVSDFLRGRQGHVHHQFXHQWUDQ$ SHVDU GH TXH WDQWR -RUGL FRPR /ROD FRPSDUWHQ OD PLVPD VLWXDFLyQ REVHUYR TXH pVWD FRQYHUVD PiV D PHQXGRFRQORVFRPSDxHURVTXH-RUGL7DOYH]VHDGHELGRDTXHpVWHHVWiHQIDGDGRSRUTXHODPDHVWUDOH KDGLFKRTXHQRSXHGHSDUWLFLSDUGHODVHVLyQGH(GXFDFLyQ)tVLFDSRUTXHVHKDROYLGDGRODJRUUDTXHOH SURWHJHGHOVRO1RHVKDVWDHOILQDOGHOSDWLRTXHVHLQFRUSRUDFRQHOJUXSRGH/ROD DQH[R 0RGHORGHODVHQWUHYLVWDV (175(9,67$$',5(&725#'(&(1752 120%5(<$3(//,'26 ('$'BBBBBBBBDxRV )(&+$ (6&8(/$ &XiOHVODUHVSXHVWDHVFRODUGHVGHYXHVWURFHQWURDODV1((\FRQFUHWDPHQWHODVTXHVHGHULYDQGH ODGLVFDSDFLGDGPRWUL]" GHVGHHOFXUUtFXOR\ GHVGHODRUJDQL]DFLyQLQQRYDFLyQ\GHVDUUROORSURIHVLRQDO &XiOHVVRQODVGLILFXOWDGHVGHODLQFOXVLyQGHODOXPQDGRFRQGLVFDSDFLGDGPRWUL]HQODVVHVLRQHVGH ()" 3URSXHVWDVGHPHMRUDQHFHVLGDGHV (175(9,67$$/$$8;,/,$5'(('8&$&,Ï1(63(&,$/ 120%5(<$3(//,'26 )(&+$ (6&8(/$ &UHHVTXHHVSRVLEOHODLQFOXVLyQGHODOXPQDGRFRQGLVFDSDFLGDGPRWUL]HQODFODVHGH()"5D]RQDUOD UHVSXHVWD &RQVLGHUDVTXHODVLWXDFLyQDFWXDOGHHVWDHVFXHODSHUPLWHGDUUHVSXHVWDDODVQHFHVLGDGHVHGXFDWLYDV GHODOXPQDGRFRQGLVFDSDFLGDGPRWUL]HQODVHVLyQGH()" FDVRQHJDWLYRGLILFXOWDGHVSURSXHVWDVGHPHMRUD 9DORUDORVVLJXLHQWHVDVSHFWRVGHODOXPQRREMHWRGHOHVWXGLRGHFDVR SHUVRQDOLGDG DXWRQRPtD VRFLDOL]DFLyQ PRWLYDFLyQ ODDFWLWXGGHORVSDGUHV DFWLWXGDQWHODVDFWLYLGDGHVGHHQVHxDQ]DDSUHQGL]DMH GLILFXOWDGHVREVHUYDGDVHQODVDFWLYLGDGHVRHVSDFLRVTXHDSR\DV SDUWLFLSDFLyQDFWLYDSDVLYD 'HTXpPDQHUDGDVDSR\RHQODVHVLyQGH()" (175(9,67$$/$$8;,/,$5'(('8&$&,Ï1(63(&,$/),1$/ 120%5(<$3(//,'26 )(&+$ (6&8(/$ 9DORUDORVDVSHFWRVSRVLWLYRV\QHJDWLYRVGHODH[SHULHQFLDUHIHULGRVD HQ JHQHUDO FyPR GLUtDV TXH KD WUDQVFXUULGR HO SUHVHQWH FXUVR UHVSHFWR D OD LQFOXVLyQ GHO DOXPQ# FRQ GLVFDSDFLGDG PRWUL] DFWLWXG PRWULFLGDG VRFLDELOLGDG" GHVWDFDUtDV DOJR HVSHFLDOPHQWHUHOHYDQWH" FyPRYDORUDUtDVODDFWLWXGGHOJUXSRFODVHDQWHODVDGDSWDFLRQHVGHODVWDUHDVDORODUJRGH HVWHFXUVR" FyPRYDORUDUtDVODDFWLWXGGHOJUXSRFODVHHQORVKRUDULRVGHWLHPSROLEUHSDWLR\GHFRPHGRU FXDQGRMXHJDQ" ORVHIHFWRVGHODFDtGDGH-RUGL TXpDVSHFWRVFUHHVTXHKD\TXHVHJXLUSRWHQFLDQGRSDUDPHMRUDUODVRFLDOL]DFLyQ" ODH[SHULHQFLDWHKDDSRUWDGRDOJRSURIHVLRQDOPHQWH" RWURVDVSHFWRVTXHTXLHUDVFRPHQWDU (175(9,67$$/5(35(6(17$17('(/(48,32'($6(625$0,(172 36,&23('$*Ï*,&2($3 120%5(<$3(//,'26 ('$'BBBBBBBBDxRV )(&+$ &(1752 )DFLOLWDVDVHVRUDPLHQWRDOiUHDGH()" FDVRDILUPDWLYRFXiQGR\TXpWLSR FDVRQHJDWLYRSRUTXp" &UHHVTXHHVSRVLEOHODLQFOXVLyQGHODOXPQDGRFRQGLVFDSDFLGDGPRWUL]HQODFODVHGH()"5D]RQDUOD UHVSXHVWD &RQVLGHUDVTXHODVLWXDFLyQDFWXDOGHODHVFXHODSHUPLWHGDUUHVSXHVWDDODVQHFHVLGDGHVHGXFDWLYDV GHODOXPQDGRFRQGLVFDSDFLGDGPRWUL]HQODVHVLyQGH()" FDVRQHJDWLYRGLILFXOWDGHVSURSXHVWDVGHPHMRUD &yPRYHVHOIXWXURGHODLQFOXVLyQGHODOXPQDGRFRQGLVFDSDFLGDGPRWUL]HQODVHVLyQGH()"&yPRWH JXVWDUtDTXHIXHUD" (175(9,67$$/$78725$ 120%5(<$3(//,'26 ('$'BBBBBBBBDxRV )(&+$ (6&8(/$ &UHHVTXHHVSRVLEOHODLQFOXVLyQGHODOXPQDGRFRQGLVFDSDFLGDGPRWUL]HQODFODVHGH()"5D]RQDUOD UHVSXHVWD &RQVLGHUDVTXHODVLWXDFLyQDFWXDOGHHVWDHVFXHODSHUPLWHGDUUHVSXHVWDDODVQHFHVLGDGHVHGXFDWLYDV GHODOXPQDGRFRQGLVFDSDFLGDGPRWUL]HQODVHVLyQGH()" FDVRQHJDWLYRGLILFXOWDGHVSURSXHVWDVGHPHMRUD &yPRDIHFWDDOJUXSRODPRELOLGDGUHGXFLGDGHVXFRPSDxHUR" 9DORUDODLQFOXVLyQGHODOXPQRFRQGLVFDSDFLGDGHQHODXOD SHUVRQDOLGDG DXWRQRPtD VRFLDOL]DFLyQ PRWLYDFLyQ DFWLWXGDQWHODVDFWLYLGDGHVGHHQVHxDQ]DDSUHQGL]DMH GLILFXOWDGHVREVHUYDGDVHQHOUHVWRGHDVLJQDWXUDV SDUWLFLSDFLyQDFWLYDSDVLYD SDUWLFLSDFLyQHQWRGDVODVDFWLYLGDGHVH[WUDRUGLQDULDVTXHVHRUJDQL]DQILQHVGH FXUVRILHVWDVVDOLGDV &XiOHVVXFRPSRUWDPLHQWRKDELWXDOHQHOSDWLR"TXpMXHJRVDFWLYRSDVLYRUHODFLRQHV 4XpUHODFLyQPDQWLHQHVFRQHOSURIHVRUGH()" (175(9,67$$/$60$(675$6'(('8&$&,Ï1(63(&,$/ 120%5(<$3(//,'26 ('$'BBBBBBBBDxRV )(&+$ (6&8(/$ )DFLOLWDVDSR\RDOiUHDGH()" FDVRDILUPDWLYRFXiQGR\TXpWLSR FDVRQHJDWLYRSRUTXp" &UHHVTXHHVSRVLEOHODLQFOXVLyQGHODOXPQDGRFRQGLVFDSDFLGDGPRWUL]HQODFODVHGH()"5D]RQDUOD UHVSXHVWD 3DUDILQDOL]DUFRQVLGHUDVTXHODVLWXDFLyQDFWXDOGHHVWDHVFXHODSHUPLWHGDUUHVSXHVWDDODV QHFHVLGDGHVHGXFDWLYDVGHODOXPQDGRFRQGLVFDSDFLGDGPRWUL]HQODVHVLyQGH()" FDVRQHJDWLYRGLILFXOWDGHVSURSXHVWDVGHPHMRUD (175(9,67$$/$60$(675$6'(('8&$&,Ï1)Ë6,&$ 120%5(<$3(//,'26 ('$'BBBBBBBBDxRV )(&+$ (6&8(/$ $ORODUJRGHWXH[SHULHQFLDGRFHQWHHVODSULPHUDYH]TXHWLHQHVXQDDOXPQ#FRQGLVFDSDFLGDG PRWUL]" FDVRDILUPDWLYR FyPRWHVHQWLVWHDOVDEHUOR" FXiOFUHHVTXHVHUiHOSUREOHPDSULQFLSDO" FyPRWHSODQWHDVGDUUHVSXHVWDDODVQHFHVLGDGHVHGXFDWLYDVGHOJUXSR" FyPRGDUiVUHVSXHVWDDODV1((GHODOXPQDGRFRQGLVFDSDFLGDGPRWUL]" FDVRQHJDWLYR FXiQWRVFDVRVKDVWHQLGR" FyPRGDVUHVSXHVWDDODVQHFHVLGDGHVHGXFDWLYDVGHOJUXSR" FyPRGDVUHVSXHVWDDODV1((GHODOXPQDGRFRQGLVFDSDFLGDGPRWUL]\ FRQFUHWDPHQWHGHODOXPQRGHOHVWXGLRGHFDVR" 5HDOL]DVDGDSWDFLRQHVFXUULFXODUHV" FDVRDILUPDWLYRFXiOHV\FyPR" FDVRQHJDWLYRSRUTXp" 4XpDSR\RUHFLEHVGHORVFRPSDxHURVGHOFHQWUR" 4XpUHODFLyQWLHQHVFRQHOPDHVWURWXWRU" 4XpUHODFLyQWLHQHVFRQHOSVLFyORJRGHOFHQWUR"&HQWUR 5HFLEHVDSR\RH[WHULRU" FDVRDILUPDWLYRGHTXLpQ\FyPR FDVRQHJDWLYRFXiOFUHHVTXHGHEHUtDVHU\FyPR &RQVLGHUDVTXHWLHQHVODIRUPDFLyQQHFHVDULDSDUDSRGHUGDUUHVSXHVWDHGXFDWLYDHILFD]DODV1((GHO DOXPQDGRFRQGLVFDSDFLGDGPRWUL]" HQFDVRQHJDWLYRFXiOHVVRQODVQHFHVLGDGHVIRUPDWLYDV" &UHHVTXHHVSRVLEOHODLQFOXVLyQGHODOXPQDGRFRQGLVFDSDFLGDGPRWUL]HQODFODVHGH()"5D]RQDUOD UHVSXHVWD &RQVLGHUDVTXHODVLWXDFLyQDFWXDOGHHVWDHVFXHODSHUPLWHGDUUHVSXHVWDDODVQHFHVLGDGHVHGXFDWLYDV GHODOXPQDGRFRQGLVFDSDFLGDGPRWUL]" FDVRQHJDWLYRGLILFXOWDGHVSURSXHVWDVGHPHMRUDDFFHVLELOLGDG\PDWHULDODGDSWDGR &yPRDIHFWDDOJUXSRODPRELOLGDGUHGXFLGDGHVXFRPSDxHUR" 9DORUDODSDUWLFLSDFLyQGHODOXPQRFRQGLVFDSDFLGDGHQODVHVLyQGH()HQHOFDVRGHTXH\DORKXELHUD WHQLGRHQHOFXUVRDQWHULRU SHUVRQDOLGDG GLILFXOWDGHVPRWULFHVDXWRQRPtD KiELWRVKLJLpQLFRV VRFLDOL]DFLyQ PRWLYDFLyQ DFWLWXGDQWHODVDFWLYLGDGHVGHHQVHxDQ]DDSUHQGL]DMH DQWHTXpWLSRGHFRQWHQLGRVSUHVHQWDPD\RUGLILFXOWDG" SDUWLFLSDFLyQDFWLYDSDVLYD SDUWLFLSDFLyQHQWRGDVODVDFWLYLGDGHVH[WUDRUGLQDULDTXHVHRUJDQL]DQGHVGHOD DVLJQDWXUDILQHVGHFXUVRILHVWDVVDOLGDVFRORQLDV &XiOHVVXFRPSRUWDPLHQWRHQHOSDWLR" &yPR VH WH LQIRUPy VREUH OD SDWRORJtD \ ODV FDUDFWHUtVWLFDV GHO DOXPQR R DOXPQD FRQ PRYLOLGDG UHGXFLGD" (175(9,67$$/$60$(675$6'(('8&$&,Ï1)Ë6,&$ $),1$/'(&8562 120%5(<$3(//,'26 ('$'BBBBBBBBDxRV )(&+$ (6&8(/$ 9DORUDORVDVSHFWRVSRVLWLYRV\QHJDWLYRVGHODH[SHULHQFLDUHIHULGRVD HQ JHQHUDO FyPR GLUtDV TXH KD WUDQVFXUULGR HO SUHVHQWH FXUVR UHVSHFWR D OD LQFOXVLyQ GHO DOXPQ# FRQ GLVFDSDFLGDG PRWUL] DFWLWXG PRWULFLGDG VRFLDELOLGDG" GHVWDFDUtDV DOJR HVSHFLDOPHQWHUHOHYDQWH" FyPRYDORUDUtDVODDFWLWXGGHOJUXSRFODVHDQWHODVDGDSWDFLRQHVGHODVWDUHDVDORODUJRGH HVWHFXUVR" TXpDVSHFWRVFUHHVTXHKD\TXHVHJXLUSRWHQFLDQGRSDUDPHMRUDUODVRFLDOL]DFLyQ" ODH[SHULHQFLDWHKDDSRUWDGRDOJRSURIHVLRQDOPHQWH" RWURVDVSHFWRVTXHTXLHUDVFRPHQWDU (175(9,67$$/$021,725$'(&20('25 120%5(<$3(//,'26 )(&+$ (6&8(/$ &UHHV TXH HV SRVLEOH OD LQFOXVLyQ GHO DOXPQDGR FRQ GLVFDSDFLGDG PRWUL] HQ ORV MXHJRVPRWRUHV"5D]RQDUODUHVSXHVWD ¢&XiOHVHOFRPSRUWDPLHQWRGHOQLxRREMHWRGHHVWXGLRHQORVMXHJRVPRWRUHVTXHRUJDQL]iLVHQHO HVSDFLRSUHYLRDOFRPHGRU" 9DORUDORVVLJXLHQWHVDVSHFWRVGHOQLxRREMHWRGHOHVWXGLR SHUVRQDOLGDG DXWRQRPtD VRFLDOL]DFLyQ PRWLYDFLyQ DFWLWXGDQWHODVDFWLYLGDGHVO~GLFDVPRWULFHVTXHRUJDQL]DV SDUWLFLSDFLyQDFWLYDSDVLYD 'HVFULEHODDFWLWXG\ODUHODFLyQGHODOXPQRFRQGLVFDSDFLGDGPRWUL]FRQVXVFRPSDxHURVHQHO FRPHGRU (175(9,67$$3$'5(6<0$'5(6 120%5(<$3(//,'26 ('$'BBBBBBBBDxRV )(&+$ (6&8(/$ &UHHLPSRUWDQWHTXHVXKLM#SDUWLFLSHHQODFODVHGH()"SRUTXp"3RVLEOHVGLILFXOWDGHVYLYHQFLDGHO KLM#3URSXHVWDVGHPHMRUD 4XpFUHHTXHGHEHUtDDSRUWDUOD()DORVQLxRV\QLxDVFRQGLVFDSDFLGDGPRWUL]" +DFHDFWLYLGDGItVLFDIXHUDGHODHVFXHOD" FDVRDILUPDWLYRFXiOGyQGHFXiQGR FDVRQHJDWLYRUD]yQGHVFRQRFLPLHQWRHOQLxRQRTXLHUH 3DUWLFLSDHQMXHJRVFRQDPLJRVKHUPDQRVHQODFDOOHHQILQGHVHPDQDSDUTXHV &XiOHVHOFRPSRUWDPLHQWRHQFDVD"VLHVPRYLGRVHGHQWDULRVLMXHJDFRQEDORQHV 9DDFRORQLDVRFDVDOV" FDVRQHJDWLYRSRUTXp" FDVRSRVLWLYREHQHILFLRVGLILFXOWDGHV\ODYLYHQFLDGHOQLxRRQLxDHQMXHJRVPRWRUHVUHODFLyQFRQ FRPSDxHURV (175(9,67$$/36,&Ï/2*2 120%5(<$3(//,'26 )(&+$ (6&8(/$ &UHHVTXHHVSRVLEOHODLQFOXVLyQGHODOXPQDGRFRQGLVFDSDFLGDGPRWUL]HQODFODVHGH()"5D]RQDUOD UHVSXHVWD &RQVLGHUDVTXHODVLWXDFLyQDFWXDOGHHVWDHVFXHODSHUPLWHGDUUHVSXHVWDDODVQHFHVLGDGHVHGXFDWLYDV GHODOXPQDGRFRQGLVFDSDFLGDGPRWUL]HQODVHVLyQGH()" FDVRQHJDWLYRGLILFXOWDGHVSURSXHVWDVGHPHMRUD 9DORUDORVVLJXLHQWHVDVSHFWRVGHOQLxRREMHWRGHOHVWXGLR SHUVRQDOLGDG DXWRQRPtD VRFLDOL]DFLyQ PRWLYDFLyQ ODDFWLWXGGHORVSDGUHV ¢4XpUHODFLyQWLHQHVFRQODPDHVWUDGH(GXFDFLyQ)tVLFD" (175(9,67$$/801$'2&21',6&$3$&,'$'0275,= 120%5(<$3(//,'26 ('$'BBBBBBBBDxRV )(&+$ *5832 (6&8(/$ 7HJXVWDYHQLUDOFROHJLR" 4XpDVLJQDWXUDHVODTXHPiVWHJXVWD\FXiOODTXHPHQRV3RUTXp" 7H JXVWD OD FODVH GH ()" HQ FDVR TXH QR VHD FLWDGD HQ OD SUHJXQWD DQWHULRU 3RU TXp HQ DPERV FDVRV TXpHVORTXHPiVWHJXVWDGHODFODVHGH()"\ORTXHPHQRV" FyPRWHJXVWDUtDTXHIXHUDODFODVHGH()" 7LHQHVSUREOHPDVSDUDFDPELDUWHGXFKDUWHHWF"3LGHVD\XGDDWXVFRPSDxHURVFXDQGR ODQHFHVLWDVDOSURIHVRU"9LYHQFLD 6LHPSUHKDVSDUWLFLSDGRHQODFODVHGH()" FDVRQHJDWLYRSRUTXp 3DUWLFLSDV HQ OD FODVH HQ VROLWDULR R FRPSDUWHV ODV DFWLYLGDGHV FRQ WXV FRPSDxHU#V" 7H JXVWD" 9LYHQFLD 7LHQHVSUREOHPDVSDUDFDPELDUWHGXFKDUWHHWF"3LGHVD\XGDDWXVFRPSDxHURVFXDQGRODQHFHVLWDV DOSURIHVRU"9LYHQFLD (QODKRUDGHSDWLRDTXpVXHOHVMXJDU\FRQTXLpQ"9LYHQFLD +DFHVDOJ~QGHSRUWHIXHUDGHODHVFXHOD" FDVRSRVLWLYRYLYHQFLD FDVRQHJDWLYRSRUTXp"WHJXVWDUtDSUDFWLFDUDOJXQR" %DMDVDODFDOOHDMXJDUFRQWXVDPLJRV"RHOILQDOGHVHPDQD" FDVRDILUPDWLYRDTXp\FRQTXLpQ9LYHQFLD FDVRQHJDWLYRSRUTXp"9LYHQFLD +DVLGRRYDVGHFRORQLDVRDDOJ~QFDVDO"FDVRDILUPDWLYRTXpMXHJRV\DFWLYLGDGHVVXHOHVSUDFWLFDU" 4XpHVORTXHPiV\ORTXHPHQRVWHJXVWD"&yPRWHJXVWDUtD"9LYHQFLDFDVRQHJDWLYRSRUTXp" (175(9,67$$/801$'2&21',6&$3$&,'$'0275,=ILQDO 120%5(<$3(//,'26 ('$'BBBBBBBBDxRV )(&+$ *5832 (6&8(/$ &yPRKDVYLYLGRHVWHDxRODFODVHGH()"7HKDJXVWDGR"9LYHQFLD 4XpDFWLYLGDGHVWHKDQJXVWDGRPiVGHODFODVHGH()" 4XpDFWLYLGDGHVWHKDQJXVWDGRPHQRVGHODFODVHGH()" +DVKHFKRQXHYRVDPLJRVHQODFODVHGH()"(QFDVRDILUPDWLYRMXHJDVFRQHOORVIXHUDGHOD HVFXHODRGHODFODVHGH()" 4XpKDVKHFKRGXUDQWHODKRUDGHOSDWLR"9LYHQFLD DQH[R 7UDQVFULSFLyQGHODVHQWUHYLVWDVGHO&HQWUR (175(9,67$$/&(1752 3DGUH\0DGUHGH0DUtDDOXPQDREMHWRGHOHVWXGLRGHO&HQWUR )(&+$GHRFWXEUHGH 0%XHQRFRQHFWRODJUDEDGRUD\SDVRDODSULPHUDSUHJXQWDVLSRGpLVDO]DUODYR]RVOR DJUDGHFHUp¢&UHpLVLPSRUWDQWHTXHYXHVWURKLMRSDUWLFLSHHQODFODVHGH()" 0$'5(6t 0¢6t" 3$'5(3RUVXSXHVWR 0¢<SRUTXp" 3$'5(<RORHQFXHQWUREiVLFRORHQFXHQWUREiVLFRSRUTXHGHVGHPLSXQWRGHYLVWDVL HQ DOJ~Q PRPHQWR OD QLxD SXHGH GHMDU ODV PXOHWDV KD GH VHU D EDVH GH PDFKDFDU ItVLFDPHQWHSHURQRVHKDKDEODGRWDPSRFRGHOWHPDGHOSUREOHPDTXHHOODWLHQH¢QR" (OODWLHQHXQSUREOHPDHQTXHHVXQDGLVJHQHVLDQHXURQDORVHDHVRVLJQLILFDTXHHOOD WLHQHXQDPDQFDRVHDXQDIDOWDGHQHUYLRVHQODSDUWHRVHDHQODSDUWHGLJDPRVGHOD WLELD KDFLD DEDMR ¢QR" 'H OD URGLOOD KDFLD DEDMR (QWRQFHV ORV PpGLFRV QRUPDOPHQWH VLHPSUHQRVKDQGLFKRTXHSRGUtDOOHJDUDFDPLQDU<RHQWLHQGRTXHGHEHUtDOOHJDUXQGtD D FDPLQDU OR TXH SDVD HV TXH HV XQ SUREOHPD GHVGH HO SXQWR GH YLVWD GH PRWLYDFLyQ ¢0RWLYDFLyQSRUTXp"3XHVSRUTXHFUHRTXHSRVLEOHPHQWHVLIRU]DVHORTXHHVODSDUWH VXSHULRUGHDUULEDGHODSLHUQDORVFXDGULFHSVSRGUtDOOHJDUDGHMDUODVPXOHWDV(QWRQFHV DKt FUHR TXH VHUtD LPSRUWDQWH QR Vp 1RVRWURV OR KHPRV LQWHQWDGR SHUR TXH KXELHVH DOJXQDSHUVRQDRDOJXLHQTXHODOOHJDVHDPRWLYDU 04XHODOOHJDVHDPRWLYDU« 3$'5( $ PRWLYDU \R FUHR TXH Vt (V XQ SUREOHPD \R HQWLHQGR« KD HVWDGR HQ HO 5 +RVSLWDOKD\EXHQRVSURIHVLRQDOHVKDHVWDGRHQHOFHQWURGHUHKDELOLWDFLyQTXHWDPELpQ ORVKD\SHURQRVRWURVQRSHUGHPRVODVHVSHUDQ]DVGHTXHODQLxDXQGtDSXHGDWHQHU DXWRQRPtDHYLGHQWHPHQWHHOSUREOHPDVHOHYDDQRWDUVLHPSUH¢QR"3HUR« 0¢3HURRVKDQGLFKRTXHVLQPXOHWDVSRGUtDOOHJDUDFDPLQDU" 3$'5((OODKDFDPLQDGR 0¢HQHOFHQWURGHUHKDELOLWDFLyQ" 3$'5('HSHTXHxDHOODKDOOHJDGRDFDPLQDU(QHOFHQWURGHUHKDELOLWDFLyQQRQRVKDQ GLFKR QXQFD QDGD 2 VHD D YHU QDGD PH UHILHUR GH TXH QR QRV KDQ GDGR XQD XQD UHVSXHVWDQLDILUPDWLYDQLSRVLWLYDPiVELHQXQWDOYH]¢QR"3HURFODURQRVRWURVODKHPRV YLVWR FDPLQDU D HOOD FRPR ODV PXxHFDV GH )DPRVD R VHD LED FDPLQDQGR SDP SDP SDP SDP &ODUR FRQ ORV DxRV OD FUtD VH KD LGR TXL]iV VH KD LGR DSROWURQDQGR VH KD KDELWXDGR D ODV FRVDV D ODV PXOHWDV \ DO ILQDO SXHV QR R VHD ¢VDEHV" SUHILHUH OD FRPRGLGDG SRU HVR WH FRPHQWDED DQWHV FRQ OR GHO WHPD GH OD GXFKD TXH Vt TXH HOOD HYLGHQWHPHQWHVHGXFKDSHURTXHOXHJRWUDEDMRYDVDWHQHUSDUDVDFDUODGHODGXFKD 0<D 3$'5(3RUTXHHVPX\OHQWD2VHDPX\OHQWDSRUHOSUREOHPDTXHWLHQH\SRUTXHHOOD 5 \DPHQWDOPHQWHHVOHQWDHQHVWRVVHQWLGRV 0\D\D\D 3$'5(<DORYHUiVRVHDDKRUDOOHYDVXQRVGtDV¢QRFRQHOOD" 06tGHVGHSULQFLSLRGHFXUVR 3$'5( ([DFWRFXDQGROOHYHVPiVWLHPSR \D WH SHUFDWDUiVGHHOOR¢QR"%XHQRTXL]i PHHVWR\VDOLHQGRXQSRFRGHODSUHJXQWD¢QR" 0 1R QRTXHYDPX\LQWHUHVDQWH(QWRQFHV YRVRWURV FRQVLGHUiLV TXHVtTXHHVPX\ LPSRUWDQWH¢QR"TXHSDUWLFLSH0DUtD 3$'5(VtVt 0$'5(VtVt 3$'5( 6t Vt SRU VXSXHVWR 'H KHFKR D SDUWH GH TXH YD DO FHQWUR GH UHKDELOLWDFLyQ WDPELpQ OD OOHYDPRV D OD SLVFLQD ,QFOXVR XQD YH] XQD PXMHU PH GLMR XQD PXMHU TXH OOHYDEDXQJUXSRGHXQRVFUtRVTXHHVWDEDHQVHxiQGRORVDQDGDU 0$'5(8QDPRQLWRUD 3$'5(8QDPRQLWRUDVtODYLRQDGDU\WLHQHPXFKDHQYHUJDGXUDFRQORVEUD]RVGHELGR DVXSUREOHPDFODURVLWHILMDV\DOHYHUiVODFRQVWLWXFLyQ<QRVGLMRTXHRVHDTXHOD FUtDSRGUtDKDFHUXQEXHQSDSHOHQWHPDGHODQDWDFLyQ3HURQRVRWURVORGLMLPRV\HOOD QRHOODQRHVWDEDPXFKRSRUODODERURVHDHVRGHPDFKDFDUVHPXFKR« 0/DFRPSHWLFLyQQROHJXVWD 3$'5(1RQR1RTXL]iVQROHJXVWDSXHVSRUTXHDORPHMRU\DWLHQHXQDPHQWDOLGDG GHSHUGHGRUDSRUVXSURSLRSUREOHPDSRGUtDVHUQRVHTXL]iVHVWR\KDEODQGRPiVGH« \HQGRPiVOHMRVGHORTXHHVHQVt¢QR"SHURSRUVXSXHVWRQRVRWURV\DYHVODPDGUHOD 5 OOHYDDKDFHUGHSRUWH 0¢'yQGHORKDFpLV" 3$'5($TXtPLVPR 0¢(QXQDLQVWDODFLyQPXQLFLSDO" 0$'5(1RDTXtHQODSLVFLQDGHDTXt 3$'5($TXtDTXtPLVPRHQODSLVFLQDGHDTXt 0£$K'HDTXtGHO$&(//GHDTXtGHOSROLGHSRUWLYRPXQLFLSDO 3$'5(6tGHO$&(//VtH[DFWDPHQWH 0£$K<D\D\D 0$'5((VWDGHDTXtDOODGRPLVPR 06LVtVtVt¢2VKDEpLVSXHVWRHQFRQWDFWR"%XHQROXHJRRVORFRPHQWDUpORGHOD )HGHUDFLyQ&DWDODQDGH'HSRUWHVSDUD0LQXVYiOLGRVGHVXVHUYLFLRHQHO+RVSLWDOGH6DQ 5DIDHO 0$'5(6tHVWXYRXQYHUDQRIXp 0¢6t"¢<TXp" 0$'5(%LHQ 3$'5(%LHQELHQHVWXYRELHQ 0 ¢&RQ 'H )LYH" 1R OR FRQRFpLV DO 'H )LYH" >7pFQLFR GH 1DWDFLyQ GH OD )HGHUDFLyQ &DWDODQDGH'HSRUWHVSDUD0LQXVYiOLGRV)tVLFRV@ 3$'5(6t 0$'5(&XDQGRKDLGRDOOtDODGRFWRUD« 3$'5(6tXQVHxRUDVtDVtPiVELHQEDMLWRDVtUHJRUGHWH¢WHUHILHUHV" 06tTXHWLHQHSROLRTXHYHQGHFXSRQHV 3$'5(6tTXHYHQGHFXSRQHV 06t 3$'5(6t 0 $KRUD HV HO 3UHVLGHQWH GH OD )HGHUDFLyQ \ HV HO TXH PRYLOL]D WRGDV ODV DFWLYLGDGHV DFXiWLFDVHQ6DQ5DIDHO 3$'5(6tVtTXHORFRQR]FR 0/RKDEpLVFRQRFLGR¢QR" 3$'5(6tVtORFRQR]FR 0$'5(6tXQYHUDQRHVWXYRDOOtHQ-XOLRWRGRHOPHVGH-XOLR\HQGR 03HURDHOODQROHPRWLYDODFRPSHWLFLyQ¢QR" 3$'5(1RHOODHOMXHJR 0(OODHOMXHJRSDViUVHORELHQ 3$'5(6tVtEiVLFDPHQWHHOODYDDODSLVFLQDMXHJD« 0$'5($HOODODSLVFLQDOHJXVWD 06HVLHQWHDXWyQRPD« 3$'5(6tPXFKRPiVSRUTXHDKtHV« 0$'5(3RUTXHQDGD 3$'5(1DGD\DKtODKD\GLIHUHQFLDFRQRWURVQLxRV\DHVPiV«+RPEUHDYHUVLHO 5 QLxRQDGDELHQSXHVHYLGHQWHPHQWHODGLIHUHQFLDVLHPSUHHV« 0$'5(%XHQRSHURHOODQRYDDOFXUVLOORHOODYDVRODYDSRUOLEUH\YD«QRKDFH«QR VHYHFRQORVRWURVQLxRVRVHD« 0¢1RFRPSDUWHODDFWLYLGDGFRQRWURVQLxRV" 0$'5(1RSRUTXHYDPRVSRUOLEUH\YDVROD 0$K\D 0$'5( %XHQR YD FRQPLJR \R HVWR\ FRQ HOOD \ OH GLJR ³YD YHQJD YDPRV D QDGDU YDPRVDODSLVFLQD´ 3$'5( %XHQR DQWHV Vt &XDQGR KDFtDQ OD SLVFLQD TXH LEDQ GH DTXt Vt KDFtD ODV DFWLYLGDGHVLJXDO 0<D\D\D\D 3$'5(&RPRFXDOTXLHUD 02VHDTXHKDFHSUiFWLFDOLEUHHQODVDFWLYLGDGHVDFXiWLFDV 3$'5( 6t Vt EXHQR HV TXH YD SRU OLEUH R VHD QR YD D FXUVLOOR SUHGHWHUPLQDGR VLPSOHPHQWH 0<HQWRQFHV¢&XiOHVDYLYHQFLDGHYXHVWUDKLMDFXDQGRYLHQHGHODFODVHGH(GXFDFLyQ )tVLFD () (V SRVLWLYD HV QHJDWLYD YLHQH FRQWHQWD QR YLHQH FRQWHQWD« OR TXH RV VXJLHUH 3$'5(1RGHVFRQWHQWDQRYLHQH 5 0$'5(/DFODVHTXHPiVOHJXVWDHVODGH() 0¢6t" 0$'5(6t 0(VTXHOHFDPELDODH[SUHVLyQ 0$'5(1LPDWHPiWLFDVQLQDGDGH« 0(VOD()¢\HQTXpPRPHQWRKDYHQLGRFRQGLVJXVWRRXQSRFRGHVFRQFHUWDGD" 0$'5(6tFXDQGRHVGHYXHOWD2VHDSDUDYHQLUDOSVLFR>HOJLPQDVLRGHOD(VFXHODGH 5 (GXFDFLyQ (VSHFLDO SUy[LPD DO &HQWUR @ FXDQGR YD DO SVLFR 3DUD YHQLU QR PX\ FRQWHQWD SHUR FXDQGR YXHOYH« TXH VH KDEtD DEXUULGR SRUTXH QR KDEtD SRGLGR KDFHU QDGD\TXHVHKDEtDDEXUULGR« 0¢<OHKDEtDVSUHJXQWDGRTXHHVORTXHKDEtDQKHFKRHQHOSVLFR" 0$'5(6tTXHVDOWDEDQDSRWUR\QRVpTXpPiVPHKDGLFKR 3$'5( 6t HMHUFLFLRV TXH QR SXHGH KDFHU HOOD &ODUR HO SRWUR QR SXHGH VDOWDU QR OR SXHGHVDOWDUGHQLQJXQDGHODVPDQHUDV 03HURVyORHQHVDVLWXDFLyQ¢QR" 0$'5(6t 0&XDQGRKD\DFWLYLGDGHVPiVJLPQiVWLFDV 0$'5(&XDQGRVRQMXHJRVVHORSDVDPX\ELHQ 00X\ELHQ¢<QRWiLVXQFDPELRGHHOODHQVXFRPSRUWDPLHQWRHOGtDTXHYLHQHGHOD FODVHGH()"¢9LHQHPiVULVXHxD"2QRRYHLVTXH« 3$'5(6tKRPEUHDOJRPHMRUVt 0$'5( +RPEUH FXDQGR VDOH DO PHGLRGtD FXDQGR YLHQH FDVWLJDGD GH QR KDFHU ORV GHEHUHVQRYLHQHFRQWHQWD« 0¢'HODFODVHQR" 0$'5(&RPRFXDQGRVDOHGHKDFHUJLPQDVLD 0<D\D\D\D 0$'5((ORWURGtDVDOtDOORUDQGR\WRGR 0¢'HTXp" 0$'5(6tGHTXHODKDEtDQWHQLGRFDVWLJDGDKDVWDODXQD+DVWDODXQDHUDODXQDTXH HVWXYHHVSHUDQGRHQODSXHUWD<VDOtDOORUDQGR\WRGR<VDOtDODSURIHVRUDWDPELpQ\PH GLMR ³0LUD VDOH OORUDQGR SHUR KD HVWDGR WRGD OD KRUD GHO SDWLR KDVWD DKRUD \ QR OR KD KHFKR´ 3$'5( 1R \ FRPR VH FUXFH VH SRQH FDEH]RQD \ QL SURIHVRU QL QDGD 6H SRQH PX\ 5 WHUFDHVPX\WHUFDHQILQ« 0 ¢< SHQViLV YRVRWURV TXH KD\ GLILFXOWDGHV SDUD OD SDUWLFLSDFLyQ GH YXHVWUD KLMD HQ OD FODVH"2QRSHQViLVTXHQRGHEHKDEHUQLQJXQDGLILFXOWDG$SULRUL 3$'5(+RPEUHVtGLILFXOWDGVLHPSUHKDQGHKDEHU$YHUGLILFXOWDGSRUHOSUREOHPDTXH 5 HOODWLHQH$KRUDTXHQRVRWURVVDEHPRVGHRWURVQLxRVGHKDEODUFRQORVWXWRUHV\WDO TXH OD QLxD HVWi DFHSWDGD SRU ORV FRPSDxHURV ,QFOXVR KDFH XQRV DxRV FXDQGR VH TXHGDEDDOFRPHGRUWHQtDODPDQtDGHOOHJDUVLHPSUHSDPSDPSDPOOHJDU\RVHDHQ OXJDUGHKDFHUFRODVHSRQtDODSULPHUD\HUDXQDIRUPDGHDFHSWDFLyQGHWRGDODFODVH +DVWDTXHOOHJyHOSURIHVRU\OHGLMR³QRW~VLKDVOOHJDGRODRFWDYDODQRYHQDODGpFLPD ROD~OWLPDW~WHTXHGDVDKt´3HURHOODLEDSXPSXPSXP«<VHFRORFDEDODSULPHUD 2VHD\HUDXQDIRUPDGHDFHSWDFLyQGHWRGDODFODVH,QFOXVRHODxRSDVDGRHOPDHVWUR 7XWRUGLMRTXHSDUDORVGLFWDGRVSRUTXHYDPRVHVPX\OHQWDTXHHOULWPRGHWUDEDMRGH ODFODVHVHDGHFXDPXFKRDODVX\D<HVR\HVR\DHVFRVDGHOSURIHVRU¢QR"<HQHVWH VHQWLGRHVXQH[FHOHQWHSURIHVLRQDO 06tVtORHV 3$'5(6tVtVt(QWRQFHVEXHQR« 0$'5((OODYDFRQODFODVHDOULWPRGHHOORV 0<D\D\D 3$'5(1RHOODORTXHFODURHOODVtPiVRPHQRVDVXULWPRKDFHSHURVLODVDFDVGHO 5 ULWPR\D«VHSRQHDPLUDUODVPRVFDV\OHGDLJXDORVHDQR« 0<D\D 3$'5(1RVpHVUDURHVWRHVXQDFRVDTXH«QRUPDOPHQWHORVQLxRVFXDQGRWLHQHQ SUREOHPDV VXHOHQ YROFDUVH HQ ORV HVWXGLRV ¢QR" 3XHV QR HV HO FDVR GH HOOD 3RU OR PHQRVHVORTXHWHQJRRtGR 0 <D \ ¢TXp FUHpLV TXH SXHGH DSRUWDU OD () D ORV QLxRV FRQ GLVFDSDFLGDG PRWUL] HVSHFLDOPHQWHSDUDORVQLxRVFRQGLVFDSDFLGDGPRWUL]" 3$'5( +RPEUH\RFUHRPiVRPHQRV \D WH OR KHFRQWHVWDGRDQWHV¢QR"3DUDPtHV EiVLFR 0¢<TXpOHVSXHGHD\XGDUEi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« 0\D\DTXHVHSLQFKD 3$'5(8QDSHUVRQDTXHVHGURJDQRYDDXQJLPQDVLRSRUTXHQRSXHGH6XFXHUSR QR«(QWRQFHVHVXQDIRUPDGHXQSRFRDTXHOODIUDVHTXHGHFtDPRVGH³PHQVVDQDLQ FRUSRUHVDQR´HVRFODUR\RHVWR\WRWDOPHQWHGHDFXHUGR 0¢<W~TXpSLHQVDV" 0$'5(4XH\DORFUHRTXHORTXHQHFHVLWDHVKDFHUPXVFXODWXUD\UHIRU]DUVHSXHVOR 5 TXHFRPRORSXHGHKDFHUHQXQJLPQDVLR3RUHMHPSORHOPpGLFROHKDGLFKRTXHWHQtD TXHKDFHUKDFHIXHUWHHVWR\ORKDFHIXHUWHYDPRVDYHUGHSHTXHxDVLHPSUHQRVORKD GLFKR 0&XDGULFHSV¢QR"+DFHUIXHUWHFXDGULFHSV 0$'5(6tVtHQWRQFHVSRGUtDDQGDU'HODURGLOODSDUDDUULEDORWLHQHELHQVLHVWROR SRQHIXHUWHSXHGHDQGDU(VORTXHQRVKDQGLFKRVLHPSUH 3$'5($SDUWHTXHHVXQDIRUPDGHUHODFLRQDUVHWDPELpQ\DQRVLPSOHPHQWHORTXHHV HO WHPD ItVLFR H[FOXVLYDPHQWH VLQy TXH VL W~ KDFHV GHSRUWH WH UHODFLRQDV LQFOXVLYH FRQ SHUVRQDV HQ HVWH FDVR FRQ SHUVRQDV GH WX PLVPR« VL YDV« D YHU VL PH H[SOLFR WH SXHGHV UHODFLRQDU FRQ SHUVRQDV FRQ GLVFDSDFLGDG PRWUL] \ FRQ SHUVRQDV VLQ GLVFDSDFLGDGPRWUL](QWRQFHVHVXQDIRUPDGHHQFRQWUDUVDOLGDV¢QR"SDUDWRGR¢QR" <RFRQFUHWDPHQWHWHQJRDPLPDGUHTXHWLHQH3DUNLQVRQ 0¢$KVL" 3$'5( 6t \ YD D OD DVRFLDFLyQ GH 3DUNLQVRQLDQRV \ EXHQR GDGR TXH YD SXHV VH HQFXHQWUD PHQWDOPHQWH PXFKR PHMRU R VHD QR VH GHSULPH WDQWR %XHQR VXSRQJR TXH VDEHVXQSRFRGHTXpYDHOWHPDHVWH 06tVt 3$'5((QWRQFHVFODUR¢SRUTXpQRVHGHSULPH"3XHVSRUTXHWLHQHXQDUHODFLyQFRQ RWUDVSHUVRQDVTXHWLHQHVXPLVPRSUREOHPD<HQHVWHFDVRSXHVLJXDO<RSRUORPHQRV KDEOR SRU Pt SDUD QRVRWURV HV EiVLFR QR Vp TXL]iV VL YD DO FHQWUR GH UHKDELOLWDFLyQ D KDFHUJLPQDVLDOHKDFHQUHKDELOLWDFLyQHQWRQFHV\DKDFHQFRVDVSDUDTXHVHSDYDOHUVH SRUHOODPLVPD<QRVRWURVGHKHFKRYDDXQJLPQDVLR 0¢+DFHDFWLYLGDGItVLFDIXHUDGHODHVFXHOD"<DPHKDEpLVGLFKRTXHQDWDFLyQ 5 3$'5(6t 0%XHQR 3$'5((QHO$&(// 0(QHO$&(//¢QR"<¢FXiQWDVYHFHVDODVHPDQD" 0$'5(7UHV 3$'5('RVRWUHV¢QR" 0$'5(7UHV 07UHVYHFHV 0$'5('RVYDDFHQWURGHUHKDELOLWDFLyQ\WUHVGtDVDODSLVFLQD 0 $XQTXH WLHQH WRGD OD VHPDQD RFXSDGD ¢6XHOH SDUWLFLSDU FRQ ORV MXHJRV FRQ VXV DPLJRVRKHUPDQDVHQODFDOOHORVILQHVGHVHPDQDSDUTXH«VXHOHSDUWLFLSDUHOOD"(Q YHUDQR«¢RQRVXHOHVHUPiVHVWiWLFD" 0$'5(1RHVGHFDOOHEXHQRHVTXHQLQJXQDVRQGHFDOOHHVWDQLxDQRHVGHFDOOHHQ YHUDQRHVWiHQFDVD$KRUDHQLQYLHUQRORVViEDGRVYDDOHVSODL 0 ¢3DUWLFLSD GH ORV MXHJRV" ¢< TXp YLYHQFLD WLHQH" ¢4Xp WH FRPHQWD" ¢7H FRPHQWD DOJR" 0$'5(0DODQRHVSRUTXHWLHQHJDQDVGHLU$KRUDHOViEDGRHPSH]DURQ\QRSXGRLU 5 SRUTXHWHQtDGHEHUHV\OHKHGLFKRTXHVLWLHQHGHEHUHVQRSXHGHLU(VTXHKDHVWDGR ViEDGR\GRPLQJRWRGRHOGtDKDFLHQGRGHEHUHVFODURSRUTXHHVPX\OHQWD&ODURHORWUR GtDGHFtD³TXLHURLU´\OHGLMH³VLTXLHUHVLUHVSDEtODWHKD]ORVGHEHUHV\HQWRQFHVSXHGHV LU´2VHDTXHPDODQRHVVHORSDVDELHQ 3$'5(<DGHPiVDOOtKDFHQWDOOHUHV 0$'5(1RSHURORVWDOOHUHVVRQORVYLHUQHV\HOODORVYLHUQHVQRYD 3$'5(¢(OYLHUQHVKDFHQORVWDOOHUHV" 0$'5(6t 0¢<HOViEDGRTXpVXHOHQKDFHUPiVVDOLGDV" 0$'5(-XHJRV 0-XHJRV¢QR"6XHOHQVHUPiVO~GLFRV 3$'5(<DOJXQDH[FXUVLyQWDPELpQ 0(QFDVD¢FXiOVXHOHVHUVXFRPSRUWDPLHQWR"(VPX\PRYLGD« 0$'5(6tTXHHVPRYLGDVt 0¢<VXHOHMXJDUEDVWDQWHRQR"2HVXQSRFR«¢FyPRHVGHPRYLGD" 0$'5(3DUDMXJDUQRHVPRYLGDHOODVHPHWHHQVXKDELWDFLyQ\OHSXHGHGDUDOOtHOGtD 5 HQWHUR 03HURMXHJDFRQDOJ~QRUGHQDGRU«RMXHJD« 0$'5(QRQRVHFXDOTXLHUFRVDXQSDSHOXQOiSL]WDPSRFR« 3$'5((VTXH\RFUHRTXHVHSLHUGHHQODLPDJLQDFLyQ1RVpHVTXH« 0$'5( &XDQGRVHSRQHDMXJDUDORUGHQDGRU WDPELpQMXHJDSHURYD\D«TXHHOODQR QHFHVLWDQDGDHVTXHHOODVHPHWHHQVXKDELWDFLyQTXHOHSXHGHGDUODWDUGHHQWHUD\ QRVHHQWHUD 3$'5(<FRJHXQPXxHFRVHORPLUD\« 0$'5(<DODSHORWDOHJXVWDPXFKRMXJDU/RTXHSDVDHVTXHHQFDVDQROHGHMR 0£$K¢1ROHGHMDVMXJDUDODSHORWD" 0$'5($ODSHORWDVtFRJHODPXOHWDODYDFKXWDQGR\« 3$'5($OI~WERO 0 3HUR HV ¢FXiQGR VXHOH MXJDU D OD SHORWD" ¢(Q TXp VLWXDFLRQHV OD YHV MXJDQGR" ¢&XiQGRODGHMDVMXJDUDSHORWD" 0$'5(6LEDMDDOSDWLR 0$KWHQpLVXQSDWLR« 0$'5(6t 0¢4XpYLYtVHQXQDSODQWDEDMD" 0$'5(1RGHXQODGRHVSODQWDEDMD\GHORWURHVHOWHUFHUR(VWiHQODPRQWDxD\KD\ XQSDWLR 0<HQWRQFHVTXpMXHJDDKt¢QR" 0$'5((QWRQFHVVtTXHSXHGHMXJDU$GHPiVHVWiFHUUDGR\HOSDWLR\ODSHORWDQRVH OHSXHGHHVFDSDU 0¢<TXpVXHOHMXJDUDFKXWDUHOEDOyQ" 0$'5(6t 0¢(OODHQVROLWDULRRFRQJHQWH" 0$'5(1RFRQODSHORWDLJXDOVRODTXHFRQJHQWH 3$'5($TXtFXDQGRMXHJDDOI~WEROVHYHTXHPXFKDVYHFHVPHORKDGLFKRVHYHTXH ODSRQHQGHSRUWHUD 06t 3$'5( < SHJD XQDV SDUDGDV FRQ OD FDEH]D SRUTXH HV PX\ EUXWD R VHD FRPR HVWi DFRVWXPEUDGDDFDHUVHFUHRHKHVPLRSLQLyQTXL]iVHVXQSRFRSHUVRQDOSHURFRPR 5 HVWiDFRVWXPEUDGDDFDHUVHQRWLHQHPLHGR(QWRQFHVOHWLUDQDORPHMRUXQSHORWD]R\R VHFDH\DWHILMDUiVVLDOJXQDYH]VHFDHSRUTXHHVOyJLFRVHFDHVHTXHGDPLUDQGR\VH UtH2VHDHVPX\«HVWiDFRVWXPEUDGDDFDHUVH\KDFHUVHGDxRHQWRQFHV«ORDJXDQWD ELHQORTXHHVHOGRORU¢QR" 06t 3$'5( (QWRQFHV OD SRQHQ GH SRUWHUD 8Q GtD YHQtD FRQ OD FDUD DVt XQ SRFR PHGLR UDVJXxDGDSRUTXHOHKDEtDQVROWDGRXQSHORWD]R\GLFH³SHURQRPHKDQPHWLGRJROTXH ODKHSDUDGRFRQODFDUD´'LJR³£QR\DORYHR´ 0¢<VXHOHLUGHFRORQLDVRFDVDOHV" 0$'5(6tKDLGR 3$'5(+DLGRHKFXDQGRKDLGROHKDHQFDQWDGR$KRUD~OWLPDPHQWHHVWHDxRQRIXH SHUREXHQR\DWHKHFRPHQWDGRDQWHV 0$'5(8QDxRIXHGRVYHFHV 3$'5(6tXQDxRIXHGRVYHFHV 0 ¢< HOOD YHQtD FRQWHQWD" ¢< GH ORV MXHJRV RV FRPHQWDED DOJR R QR« HUD WHPD GH FRPHQWDULRORGHORVMXHJRV"6LKDEtDSDUWLFLSDGRVLQRKDEtDSDUWLFLSDGRVLKDEtDVLVH KDEtDDEXUULGR« 0$'5((VTXHQRH[SOLFDPXFKRLJXDOGLFHQRPHDFXHUGRQRVH« 5 02VHD¢QRKD\QLQJ~QGDWRTXHRVKD\DOODPDGRODDWHQFLyQUHVSHFWRDORVMXHJRV" 3$'5(1R 0 ¢< DOJ~QGDWRTXHSHQVpLVTXHHV LPSRUWDQWH SDUD WHQHU HQFXHQWDSDUDHOWUDEDMR TXH RV KH FRPHQWDGR FRQ UHVSHFWR D OD PDQHUD GH VHU GH 0DUtD SDUD HQWHQGHUOD XQ SRFRPiVTXHPHTXHUiLVH[SOLFDU" 3$'5(%XHQRHOODDYHUHOODWLHQH«HVOLVWD2VHDLQWHOLJHQWHQRVpSHUROLVWDVt$ 5 YHUPHH[SOLFROLVWDHVSRUTXHHOODHQVXSUREOHPDLQWHQWDVDFDUYHQWDMDDHVR<DWHLUiV ILMDQGR SRUTXH VLHPSUH LQWHQWD« \ QR QR GH KHFKR HMHPSOR TXH WH KH FRPHQWDGR DQWHVTXHFXDQGRVHTXHGDEDDOFRPHGRUFODFODFODFODFRQVXPXOHWD\VHSRQtDOD SULPHUD$FHSWDGRSRUWRGDODFODVH\WDO <EXHQRVLYHTXHHVWiVPXFKRSRUHOOD\DORYHUiVWHLUi«7HLQWHQWDUiFRPRVHGLFH YXOJDUPHQWHOOHYDUDOKXHUWR 0<D 3$'5(&RPRWRGRVORVQLxRV 0&ODURFRPRWRGRVORVQLxRVFRPRWRGRVORVQLxRV 3$'5(3HURpVWDPiVpVWDPiVSRUTXHDSDUWHEXVFDUiRVHDSRUTXHHOODVLHPSUH 5 EXVFD HQFDULxDU DO SURIHVRU HV PX\ GH DTXHOOD PDQHUD TXLHUH TXH OH SUHVWHQ XQD DWHQFLyQVHJXLGDRVHDKDGHVHUDOJXLHQTXHHVWpH[FOXVLYDPHQWHSRUHOOD\DWHILMDUiV « ¢'LDOJRQR"GLULJLpQGRVHDODPXMHU 0$'5(4XHVDFDSURYHFKRGHORTXHWLHQH 04XLHUHGHFLUTXHHVPX\LQWHOLJHQWH¢QR"TXHPHQXGD« 0$'5(1RQRVLSXHGHDVtVHTXHGDDVt(OODVLHPSUHPHQRVGHORTXHSXHGH 0<D\D\D\D 3$'5((VStULWXGHVDFULILFLRQRWLHQH4XL]iVVHDSRUODHGDGSRUTXHYROYLHQGRDORGHO 5 SUREOHPDItVLFR\REXHQR\RHQWHQGHPRVTXHHVRKDGHVDOLUGHHOOD/RTXHSDVDTXH FODURWDPELpQHQWHQGHPRVTXHKDEUtDTXHKDEHUDOJXQDIRUPDGHSRGHUOOHJDUDPRWLYDUOD \ HVH HV HO SUREOHPD TXH QR DFDEDPRV GH YHU FyPR PRWLYDUOD 1R Vp VXSRQJR TXH DKRUDFXDQGRVHKDJDXQSRFRPiVPD\RUSXHVRELHQGLJDSXHVVLJRDGHODQWHRELHQ GLJDSXHVQRFRMRODVLOODGHUXHGDV\PHDSROWURQR 0¢3HURYRVRWURVSHQViLVTXHHVQHFHVDULRTXHHOODXWLOLFHXQDVLOODGHUXHGDV" 3$'5(£3XI1RVRWURVQRHVTXHQRFUHRTXHQHFHVLWHXQDVLOODGHUXHGDVVRPRVORV SULPHURVTXHSHQVDPRVTXHSRGUtDKDFHUDOJRPiV3HURFODURHVORTXHVXHOHRFXUULU OOHJDXQPRPHQWRHQTXHRELHQGLFHV³HVWR\ELHQFRPRHVWR\\PHDSROWURQR´RELHQ³YR\ DLQWHQWDUOR\DYHUFyPRVDOH´/OHJDHVHPRPHQWRHQTXHKDGHGHFLGLU&UHRTXH\D YHUHPRV 0¢<FRQRFpLVRRVKDQGLFKRFDVRVFRPRHOGHHOODTXHKDWHQLGRTXHXWLOL]DUVLOODGH 5 UXHGDV" 0$'5((VTXHQRKD\PXFKRV 3$'5((VTXHFDVRVFRPRXQDGLVJHQHVLDQHXURQDOHQODVGRVSLHUQDVQRVGLMHURQHQ 6DQ-XDQGH'LRVTXHHUDQRVpTXpPpGLFRIXHTXHHUDODSULPHUDTXHFRQRFtDSRUTXH QRUPDOPHQWHXQDGLVJHQHVLDSRGtDVHUHQXQDSLHUQDSHURHQODVGRVDODYH]« 0(UDDWtSLFR 3$'5( (UD PX\ PX\ DWtSLFR (UD XQ FDVR V~SHU« SRUTXH LQFOXVR HQ XQ SULQFLSLR SHQVDURQTXHSRGtDVHUHVSLQDEtILGDSHURHVSLQDEtILGDQRHVOHKDQKHFKR\DXQSDUGH UHVRQDQFLDV\QR\HVQDGDPiVHVRIDOWDGHQHUYLRV 0<D\D\D\D%XHQRYRVRWURVORTXHSUHYpHLV¢QR"HVTXHGHSHQGHGHODIXHU]DGH YROXQWDGTXHWHQJDGHYROXQWDGSRGUiVHUPiVDXWyQRPDRPHQRVDXWyQRPD 3$'5( <R FUHR TXH Vt 2 VHD \R QR VR\ PpGLFR SHUR HQWLHQGR TXH HV HVR XQD FXHVWLyQ«HVFRVDGHHOODQRVRWURVORLQWHQWDUHPRVKHPRVLQWHQWDGRWRGR<RD6DQ -XDQGH'LRVODKHPRVOOHYDGRDFHQWURGHUHKDELOLWDFLyQQRVp\DQRVDEHPRVTXpQRV TXHGDSRUKDFHU(VWDPRVVDOLHQGRTXL]iVXQSRFRGHOWHPD 0$KQRQRQRVLTXLHUHVERUUR 3$'5(1RVLHQWRQFHVHVHVR 0%XHQRKDEpLVLGRDORVPHMRUHVFHQWURVDORVPHMRUHVHVSHFLDOLVWDVORVWHQpLVHQHO FHQWURGHUHKDELOLWDFLyQ\HQHO+RVSLWDO<HQHOFHQWURGHUHKDELOLWDFLyQVRQUHFRQRFLGRV MXVWDPHQWHSRUVXSURIHVLRQDOLGDG¢QR" 0$'5(6tSRUHVRHVGLIHUHQWH(Q6DQ-XDQGH'LRVODPDFKDFDEDQPiVRVHDOD SRQtDQ\£KD](VPiVSDUDQLxRVPiVJUDQGHV/HSRQtDQLJXDO³KD]YHFHVHVWRFRQ ODVSLHUQDV´ 0¢(Q6DQ-XDQGH'LRV" 0$'5(6t 3$'5(6tSHURHUDFXDQGRODQLxDPiVDQGDED 0$'5(&ODURODPDFKDFDEDQPiV$TXtORKDFHQGLIHUHQWHDTXtMXHJDQPiVFRQHOORV ORVOOHYDQ« 3$'5( 1R LQWHQWDQ SUHVLRQDUOD WDQWR &ODUR QRVRWURV WDPELpQ LQWHQWDPRV VHJXLU ODV GLUHFWULFHVTXHVLJXHQHQFHQWURGHUHKDELOLWDFLyQ¢QR"1ROHSUHVLRQDPRVRVHDGHYH] HQFXDQGRDORPHMRU³HVRHVFRVDWX\DVLTXLHUHVXQGtD´SHURTXHHVRLJXDOORGHFLPRV XQDYH]FDGDGRVDxRVRFDGDDxROHGHMDPRVFDHUVLHOODHVODTXHTXLHUHVHJXLUGH HVDPDQHUDR«LQWHQWDPRVQRTXHKDJDHOUHFRUULGRSHUR« 0¢<DOOtHQHOFHQWURGHUHKDELOLWDFLyQODOOHYDXQSVLFyORJRRQR" 0$'5(6t 3$'5(6t 07DPELpQODOOHYDXQSVLFyORJR¢<TXpRVGLFHHOSVLFyORJR" 3$'5(eO\DPHGLMRHOSVLFyORJRTXHTXL]iV«1RVHODYHUGDGVLQFHUDPHQWHQRPH JXVWyPXFKRORTXHPHGLMRODSVLFyORJDHQHVWHFDVR4XHDYHFHVH[LVWtDHOSUREOHPD SVLFROyJLFRORWHQtDQORVSDGUHV2VHDTXL]iVXQSRFRSRUODIRUPDHQTXH\RYHtDTXH VHJ~QORTXH\RHQWHQGtHVTXHSHQVDEDTXHTXL]iV\RSUHVLRQDEDPiVGHODFXHQWD 1RDODQLxDSRUTXH\RGHKHFKRDODQLxDQR«VLQyDOPLVPRFHQWUR¢QR"4XL]iVSHQVy HVR¢QR" 02VHDTXHWHGDXQDFLHUWDGHVFRQILDQ]DODSVLFyORJDGHOFHQWURGHUHKDELOLWDFLyQRHO 5 SVLFyORJR 3$'5( 1R GH KHFKR VROR KH KDEODGR XQD YH] FRQ HOOD QR XQD YH] QR PLHQWR GRV YHFHV/DVHJXQGDYH]IXHSUHJXQWDUPHXQRVWHPDVMXUtGLFRV\WDO3HURQR 0¢<QRRVSDVDQLQIRUPHVGHODHYROXFLyQGHHOOD"3RUTXH¢DHOODODYLVLWDHOSVLFyORJR WDPELpQ"¢7LHQHWUDWDPLHQWRSVLFROyJLFR" 3$'5(6tHOODWLHQHXQDILFKDHQXQRUGHQDGRU\WDO\OHYDQWUDWDQGRSHURWDPSRFR QRV« 0$'5(1RVGDQGDWRV 3$'5(1RGDQPXFKDLQIRUPDFLyQ 0¢<QRODSHGtVYRVRWURV" 3$'5($OJXQDYH]KHPRVLGRDSHGLUOD 0&ODURSRUTXHRVSXHGHLQWHUHVDUGHFLUEXHQRTXpHVWiLVWUDEDMDQGRFRQHOOD\FXiOHV ODSHUVSHFWLYDGHIXWXURSRUTXHDKRUDYDDHQWUDUHQODDGROHVFHQFLD\TXpYDDRFXUULU FXDQGRSDVHDVHFXQGDULD¢QR"<KDFLDGyQGHYDDLU+RPEUHVtTXHHVLPSRUWDQWHVt TXHHVLPSRUWDQWHTXHUHFDEpLVWDPELpQGDWRVSRUTXHWHQpLVWRGRHOGHUHFKRGHUHFLELU LQIRUPDFLyQ ¢< DOJ~Q GDWR PiV D WHQHU HQ FXHQWD DVt HQ FXHQWD SDUD FRQRFHU XQ SRTXLWR PiV D 0DUtD"4XHSHQViLVTXHVHDVLJQLILFDWLYR 0$'5(1RVH 0¢<DHVWiWRGRUHFRJLGR" 3$'5( +RPEUH LJXDO DKRUD FXDQGR VDOJDPRV SRU OD SXHUWD QRV DFRUGDPRV GH DOJR PiVSHURQRVp 0$VtDYRWHSURQWR\DHVWi¢QR" 3$'5(1RVpPiVRPHQRVFUHRTXHWHKHPRVGDGR\DXQDLGHDGHFyPRHVHOOD¢QR" (VPiVELHQYDJROHWDHQWRGRVORVDVSHFWRVHVOLVWDUHFODPDPXFKRODDWHQFLyQGHO« 0'HODGXOWR 3$'5('HODGXOWRH[DFWR<EXHQRTXHHVVRFLDEOH/RTXHSDVDHVTXHHVRVtTXHHV VRFLDEOHKDVWDFLHUWRSXQWR3XHVVXSRQJRTXHPHGLUiVDKRUDTXHFRPRWRGRVORVQLxRV 5 PLHQWUDVKDFHQORTXHHOODTXLHUHODVFRVDVIXQFLRQDQELHQ 0&RQORVDUUHEDWRV 3$'5((YLGHQWHPHQWHPHYDVDFRQWHVWDUTXHFRPRWRGRVORVQLxRV 0&RPRWRGRVORVQLxRV 3$'5(6tQRSHURHVWDHVGHDTXHOODVTXHVLRVHDKD\QLxRVTXHSDFWDQTXHDOILQDO DFDEDQSDFWDQGRpVWDQRSDFWD 02DFHSWDQGRXQSRTXLWRPiV 3$'5(([DFWDPHQWHDFDEDQSDFWDQGR%XHQRVtSHURGHHVWDPDQHUD¢QR"eVWDQR pVWDWLHQHTXHVHUFRPRHOODGLFHVLQR«<DVHFDEUHD\VHSRQHDOORUDU 0<KDFHUDELHWDVSDWDOHWDV« 3$'5(SDWDOHWDVDPDQVDOYD 0¢$OJRPiV" 3$'5(3UHVXPLGDFRPRWRGDVODVQLxDV 0<TXpELHQTXHVHDSUHVXPLGDTXpELHQ$GHPiVHVJXDStVLPDVHSDUHFHPXFKRDWL >PLUDQGRDODPDGUH@ 3$'5(6HPHSDUHFHQWRGDVDHOOD 03HUREXHQRHOODHVSUHVXPLGD¢QR" 3$'5(6tHVSUHVXPLGD/XHJRRWUDFRVDTXHTXL]iVVtTXHVHQRVHVWDEDSDVDQGRD 5 YHFHVVHRULQDSHURQRSRUTXHQRWHQJD« 0(OFRQWURO 3$'5(2VHDHOKiELWRRTXHWHQJDXQGHVFRQWUROVLQyVLPSOHPHQWHSRUTXHVHROYLGD HVWi FRQ DOJR TXH OH JXVWD \ YD DJXDQWDQGR DJXDQWD DJXDQWD \ FODUR FXDQGR VH GD FXHQWDTXHWLHQHTXHLUODODYDERYDFRUULHQGRSDPSDPSDP\QROOHJDDWLHPSR2 VHDQRHVXQSUREOHPD 0$VtKD\SUREOHPDGHOHQWLWXG¢QR" 3$'5( 6t HV XQ SUREOHPD GH OHQWLWXG \ YDJDQFLD HQWRQFHV KD\ DOJR TXH OH JXVWD R DQGD DOJXQD FRVD TXH OH JXVWD \ DJXDQWD DJXDQWD DJXDQWD DJXDQWD \ DO ILQDO « EXHQR HVWD PDxDQD VLQ LU PiV OHMRV SXHV LJXDO TXH QR TXHUtD OHYDQWDUVH \ HVWDED DJXDQWDQGRDJXDQWDQGR\FXDQGRVHOHYDQWySXHV\DQROHGLRWLHPSRGHLUDOVHUYLFLR 0&ODUR 3$'5( (OODIXHDOVHUYLFLRQRHVTXH VH RULQDVH HQFLPD VLQR R VHD VH RULQyHQFLPD SHURTXHVHTXHGyDPLWDG¢HQWLHQGHV" 0\D\D\D\D 3$'5((VROHVXHOH« 03HURHVRVXHOHVHUHQFDVDVHJXUR¢RWDPELpQHQRWUROXJDU" 3$'5(DTXtHQHOFROHJLRHVWHDxRQRVpSHURDOJXQDYH]OHKDSDVDGR 0$'5( 6tVREUHWRGRFXDQGRVHTXHGDEDDFRPHU1RDKRUD\DQR(QHOFHQWURGH UHKDELOLWDFLyQ OH KD SDVDGR DOJXQD YH] WDPELpQ TXH PiV GH XQD YH] YLQR FRQ ORV SDQWDORQHV« 0FDPELDGRV¢QR" 0$'5(%XHQRRWURVXQRVSDQWDORQHVJUDQGtVLPRVGDEDYXHOWDV« 0¢3HURVHJXURTXHHQHOFHQWURGHUHKDELOLWDFLyQVt\DTXtQR"6HJXURTXHPiVYHFHV HQHOFHQWURGHUHKDELOLWDFLyQTXHDTXt¢RQR" 0$'5(6tDTXtGHVGHTXHQRVHTXHGDDFRPHUPHSDUHFHTXHQR0HSDUHFHTXHQR DTXtHQHOFROHJLRPHSDUHFHTXHQR 0<ODUHODFLyQFRQYRVRWURVTXHWDOELHQ¢QR"¢9HLVXQDGLIHUHQFLDFRQORVRWURVGRV KLMRV" 3$'5(%XHQRFDGDXQRHVGLIHUHQWH 06t 3$'5(6RQQLxDVPX\GLIHUHQWHV/DVWUHVFDGDXQDWLHQHXQDFRVD/RTXHSDVDHV TXHHVWDWLHQHHOEDFKLOOHUDWRFDOOHMHURGHODVRWUDVGRV 04XpLQWHUHVDQWH 3$'5(6tQRQRHVWDEXHQRH[WUDHVXVFRQFOXVLRQHVGHORTXHKDFHQODVRWUDVGRV 0¢(VODSHTXHxD" 3$'5(6t 0¢<ODPiVPLPDGD" 5 3$'5(6tHVRHVLQHYLWDEOH3HURHVTXHQR\DSRUQRVRWURVPLVPRVVLQRSRUODVRWUDV ODVRWUDVWDPELpQTXLHUDVRQR« 0$'5(/DVRWUDVDKRUDQRWDQWRSHURGHSHTXHxLWDHUD« 06~SHUSURWHJLGD 0$'5(6tVtVt 0¢/DVRWUDVTXpHGDGWLHQHDKRUD" 0$'5(\ 0$KEXHQRVHOOHYDQSRFRWLHPSR 0$'5( 1R VRQ PX\ JUDQGHV SHUR QR Vp TXH OD YHtDQ DVt WDQ LQGHIHQVD FXDQGR HUD SHTXHxDVtODOOHYDEDQPDOFULDGDODFRJtDQLJXDOTXHVLIXHUDXQPXxHFR 3$'5(&ODURDKRUDOHPHWHQPiVFDxD 5 0¢/HH[LJHQPiV" 3$'5(6t 0$'5($KRUDVHHQIDGDQFRQHOOD 3$'5(/DPHGLDQDOHHQFKXID\VHORGLFH³HUHVXQDPLPDGDDVtQRYDVDKDFHUQXQFD QDGD´ 0$'5(1RSHURGHSHTXHxDVtTXHODWHQtDQODPLPDEDQPiVHOODVTXHQRVRWURV 0¢9RVRWURVVLHPSUHOHKDEpLVH[LJLGRLJXDOTXHDOUHVWRGHKLMRVRQRRSRUHOKHFKRGH 5 WHQHUXQDPRYLOLGDGUHGXFLGD«" 3$'5( 1R VL WH GHFLPRV OD YHUGDG OR PLVPR QR OH KHPRV H[LJLGR \ KHPRV GH VHU VLQFHURV QR« £RMR 7DPSRFR HV TXH OD KD\DPRV PLPDGR H[DJHUDGDPHQWH ¢QR" SHUR ELHQSRUHMHPSORXQGHWDOOHHOWHPDGHORVSODWRVORVSODWRVTXHDKRUDFDGDYH]ORVODYR PiV\RSRUFLHUWRSHUREXHQR 0¢4XpSDVD"¢4XpSDVDTXHKD\XQFRQIOLFWR" 3$'5(/DJUDQGHQRODJUDQGH\ODPHGLDQDDORPHMRUODYDEDQSODWRVGHVGHORVGLH] DxRVRDVt 0$'5(+DFHUVHODFDPD\HVR 3$'5(6tDHVWDOHKHPRVLGRDJXDQWDQGRXQSRFRPiVSHURDKRUD\DQR 0$'5(&RQHVWDIXH« 00iVWDUGtR¢QR" 3$'5(6tDKRUDHVWR\DQRHVWHDxRSDVDGR\DVHOHH[LJH 0$KRUDHPSH]iLVDH[LJLUOH\D 3$'5(6tQR$KRUD\DOHH[LJLPRVORGHOWHPDGHODYDUORVSODWRVGHYH]HQFXDQGR SRUORPHQRVTXHKDJDDOJRSRUTXH\D~OWLPDPHQWHODVRWUDVVHFDEUHDEDQ³KRPEUHHV TXHHVWDWDPSRFR«´6t\KDVGHHVWDUHQFLPDGHHOOD« 0$'5(<FODURKD\FRVDVTXHWDPSRFRSXHGHKDFHUVDFDUODPHVDHVTXHQRSXHGH VDFDUODSRUTXHFODURORVSODWRVVLHPSUHOOHYDQDOJRGHFRPLGD 0&ODUR\FRQODVPXOHWDV« 0$'5(&ODUR\DORKDKHFKRDOJXQDYH]\GHMDHOSDVLOORWRGROOHQRGHFRVDV«SXHV HV« 0&ODURHOWUDEDMROXHJRHVWULSOH 3$'5(1R\DOHSRQHPRVRWUDVFRVDV 0$'5( +RPEUH VL WLHQH TXH SRQHU PHMRU TXH SRQJD OD PHVD TXH QR TXH OD VDTXH +RPEUHVLURPSHXQSODWRSXHVVHURPSHSHURFODURVLHQFLPDPHYDGHMDQGRHOSDVLOOR OOHQR« 0'HUHVWRV¢QR" 0$'5(/OHQRGHFRPLGDSXHV« 0¢<YRVRWURVUHFRQRFpLVTXHQROHKDEpLVH[LJLGRGHODPLVPDPDQHUDTXHDOUHVWR" 5 3$'5(1RQRQRQR(VTXHWDPSRFRVHOHSXHGHH[LJLUORPLVPRSRUORTXHDFDEDGH GHFLU HOOD QR VH QR VH OH SXHGH 2 VHD KD\ FRVDV TXH QR ODV SXHGH KDFHU 2 VHD OH SXHGHVHQFRPHQGDUORPLVPRTXHWXWUDEDMRFRQORTXHQRVDFDEDVGHGHFLUOHEXVFDV XQDVDOLGDSDUDTXHVHLQWHJUHGHQWURGHORVKiELWRVGHORVMXHJRV\GHODJLPQDVLD\GH WRGR HVWR« QRVRWURV OH SRGHPRV KDFHU TXH KDJD RWUDV WDUHDV HQ FDVD SHUR ODV TXH SXHGHKDFHURVHDHVDQRSRGUiKDFHUOD 0&ODURHQFDPELRODYDUORVSODWRVVt(QWRQFHVODYDUORVSODWRVVt 0$'5(7DPSRFRHVWiGHSLH6HVXEHDXQDEDQTXHWDVHSRQHGHURGLOODV\HQWRQFHV ODYD 3$'5(<KDFHUVHODFDPDSXHVWDPELpQVLOXHJRWLHQHVTXHHFKDUXQSRFRODPDQR SXHVODKHFKDVODPDQRSHURKDFHUVHODFDPD\ODVFRVDVTXHSXHGHKDFHUVtTXHVHODV SHGLPRV&ODURHVTXHWDPELpQDYHUKDEtDYHFHVDKRUD\DODVPXOHWDVODVPDQHMDPX\ ELHQSHUR« 0$'5(3HURVHFDHPXFKR 3$'5( 3HUR VH FDH PXFKR WDPELpQ HQWRQFHV D YHU KD\ FRVDV TXH GLFHV EXHQR OD 5 SXHGHVPDQGDUFRVDVSHURDYHUVLSRUPDQGDUOHXQDFRVDVHWHYDDFDHU\VHWHYDD KDFHUGDxR¢QR"1RVHQRVRWURVLQWHQWDPRVTXHPiVRPHQRVKDJDFRVDVSHURFODUR« HQWHQGHPRVTXHHQDOJXQDVHVPHMRUTXHKDJDRWURWLSRGHIDHQD 0<ODUHODFLyQFRQODVKHUPDQDVHVORTXHKDEpLVGLFKR¢QR"(QXQSULQFLSLRPXFKD V~SHUSURWHFFLyQ\OXHJR« 3$'5(1RSHURQRHVPDOD 0(VFDULxRVD 3$'5(6tODVGLVFXVLRQHV« 07tSLFDVGHORVQLxRVGHODHGDG 3$'5((VQRUPDOGLVFXWLUVHGLVFXWHQ$YHUODPHGLDQDVHGLVFXWHFRQWRGRVSRUTXH QRUPDOPHQWHGLFHQTXHORVPHGLDQRV\VHYHTXHHVYHUGDGODPHGLDQDVHGLVFXWHFRQ ODJUDQGH\FRQDSHTXHxDFRQODJUDQGHSRUTXHVHTXLHUHSDUHFHUDODJUDQGH\FRQOD SHTXHxDSXHVSRUTXHRVHD 0$'5(/DSHTXHxDVHUiLJXDOTXHHOOD 3$'5( (QWRQFHV OD JUDQGH YD XQ SRFR SXHV EXHQR LPDJtQDWH FRQ TXLQFH DxRV DKRUD« 0<DHPSLH]DDVHUXQDPXMHU¢QR" 3$'5(7LHQHHVSHMRVSRUWRGDODFDVD«EXHQR 0-DMDFRQTXpFDUDGHSHQDORGLFHV 3$'5(<EXHQRHVORTXHKD\HQWUHWRGDV(VXQDUHODFLyQQRUPDOHQWUHKHUPDQRV 0$'5( 3HUR OXHJR VL OD WLHQHQ TXH GHIHQGHU OD GHILHQGHQ 3RUTXH YD D FHQWUR GH UHKDELOLWDFLyQXQGtD\PHGLMR³HVTXHOD&DUPHQXQGtDHVWDEDKDEODQGRGHOD0DUtD SXHV\ROHYR\DGHFLU«´3XHVDVt\\ROHGLMH³¢<W~TXpOHYDVDGHFLU"´ ³3XHVTXHQRHVWDEDVHJXUDSRUTXHVLQR\ROHGHFtDTXHPLKHUPDQDQRKDEODGHHOOD´ 0<D\D 0$'5(2VHDTXHVLODWLHQHQTXHGHIHQGHUODGHILHQGHQSHURTXHEXHQR 3$'5(1RKD\XQDV~SHUSURWHFFLyQSHURVLKD\DOJRGHSURWHFFLyQVLJXHKDELpQGROD 5 1RSXHGHVW~GHXQSOXPD]RERUUDUXQDUHODFLyQTXHKDKDELGRKDVWDDKRUDPX\V~SHU SURWHFWRUD\GHFLUQRDKRUDQRKD\UHODFLyQRGHSURWHFFLyQVLHPSUH/RTXHSDVDTXH FODURTXHpVWDFDGDYH]HVPiV³SXD´YDEXVFDQGRVLHPSUHVDFDUHOPi[LPRSURYHFKR\ HQWRQFHVFODUROOHJDXQPRPHQWRTXHODRWUDOHSDUDHOFDUUR³£(K8QPRPHQWRTXH\R WDPELpQHVWR\DTXt´¢QR" 0<D 3$'5((VWRDQWHVDKRUD\DPiVLQIDQWLO\VHORGHFtDQWDPELpQORVSURIHVRUHV$KRUD \DQRHVWDQLQIDQWLO\RFUHRTXHKDKHFKRXQFDPELRDKRUDOD0DUtD(QILQQRVpTXp PiVSRGHPRVGHFLUGHHOOD 03XHV\DPHKDEpLVLQIRUPDGRGHPXFKRVDVSHFWRV 3$'5(6tQR/RTXHSDVDHVTXHVLFUHRTXHVHTXHGDXQDFRVDHQHOWLQWHURVLHPSUH QRVSRGHPRVSRQHUHQFRQWDFWRFRQWLJR«GHDOJXQDPDQHUD« 06tDKRUDRVGDUpODWDUMHWD0XFKtVLPDVJUDFLDVDORVGRV (175(9,67$$/&(1752 0DUtDDOXPQDREMHWRGHOHVWXGLRGHO&HQWUR )(&+$GHRFWXEUHGH 0+ROD0DUtDFRPR\DWHKHFRPHQWDGRYDPRVDKDFHUXQDHQWUHYLVWDVREUHODVFODVHV GH (GXFDFLyQ )tVLFD /RTXHPHGLJDV HV DQyQLPR YDOH" %XHQR HPSHFHPRV ¢4Xp HGDGWLHQHV" 0$5Ì$'LH]DxRV 0¢'HTXpJUXSRHUHV" 0$5Ì$'HTXLQWR 00DUtD¢WHJXVWDYHQLUDOFROHJLR"£)tMDWHTXpSUHJXQWDTXHWHKDJR7~VpVLQFHUD 5 ¢WHJXVWDRQRWHJXVWD" 0$5Ì$6t 0¢6t" 0$5Ì$6tSHURPHJXVWDPiVTXHGDUPHGRUPLGD 0 £¢£7H JXVWD PiV TXHGDUWH GRUPLGD" ¢2 VHD TXH SUHILHUHV GRUPLU DQWHV TXH LU DO 5 FROHJLR" £8\%XHQRSHURFRPRWLHQHV TXHYHQLUDOFROHWRGRVORVGtDV«VHJXUDPHQWH KDEUiQDVLJQDWXUDVTXHWHJXVWDQPiVRPHQRV$YHUGLPHFXiOHVODDVLJQDWXUDTXH PiVWHJXVWD\FXiOHVODTXHPHQRV"\GLPHSRUTXp¢&XiOHVODDVLJQDWXUDTXHPiVWH JXVWD" 0$5Ì$3XHV(GXFDFLyQ)tVLFD() 0¢()HVODDVLJQDWXUDTXHPiVWHJXVWD"¢<ODTXHPHQRV" 0$5Ì$&DWDOiQ\PDWHPiWLFDV 0¢<SRUTXpQRWHJXVWDQHOFDWDOiQ\ODVPDWHPiWLFDV" 0$5Ì$3XHVSRUTXHHVR\DORKHKHFKRHODxRSDVDGR 0¢<OD()"7DPELpQKDVKHFKRHODxRSDVDGR¢SRUTXpWHJXVWDHQWRQFHV" 0$5Ì$3RUTXHKDFHPRVMXHJRV\PHJXVWD 0¢3RUORVMXHJRVSRUTXHWHJXVWDMXJDU" 0$5Ì$6t 06t¢<HVORTXHPiVWHJXVWDGHODFODVHGH()"/RVMXHJRV¢<KD\DOJRTXHQRWH JXVWHGHODFODVHGH()" 0$5Ì$0HJXVWDWRGR 0 2 VHD WRGR VLHPSUH WH JXVWD WRGR ¢$OJXQD YH] QR WH KD JXVWDGR DOJR TXH W~ UHFXHUGHV" 0$5Ì$0HKDJXVWDGRWRGR 0$O]DODYR]SRUTXHVLQRQRWHHVFXFKDUHPRVOXHJR2VHDTXHWHKDJXVWDGRVLHPSUH 5 WRGR¢7HJXVWDUtDTXHIXHVHGLIHUHQWHODFODVHR\DWHJXVWDFRPRHV"2WXGLUtDV«³$ PLPHJXVWDUtDSDUDPHMRUDUODFODVHGH()TXHVHKLFLHVHHVWR´¢2\DWHJXVWDWDOFRPR HVHQODDFWXDOLGDG" 0$5Ì$&RPRHV 0 &RPR HV 2 VHD TXH W~ \D HVWiV FRQWHQWtVLPD FRQ OD FODVH ¢QR" 0X\ ELHQ ¢1RUPDOPHQWHWLHQHVSUREOHPDVSDUDFDPELDUWHRGXFKDUWH" 0$5Ì$>GLFHTXHQRFRQODFDEH]D@ 0 'LPH DOJR FRQ OD YR] SRUTXH FRQ HO PRYLPLHQWR GH OD FDEH]D SRFR OR YR\ D SRGHU HVFULELU 0$5Ì$1R 09DOHQRPX\ELHQ¢<QRHVQHFHVDULRSHGLUD\XGDDWXVFRPSDxHURVSDUDGXFKDUWH" 0$5Ì$1R 03HUR¢YHUGDGTXHQRWHGXFKDVHQODHVFXHOD" 0$5Ì$1R 01RWHGXFKDVHQODHVFXHOD¢'yQGHWHGXFKDVQRUPDOPHQWHDSDUWHGHFDVD" 5 0$5Ì$3XHVHQODSLVFLQD 0(QODSLVFLQD¢<DOOtQHFHVLWDVD\XGD" 0$5Ì$0LPDGUH 07XPDGUH¢<SRUTXp"¢4XpGLILFXOWDGHVWLHQHV" 0$5Ì$3XHVSDUDODYDUPHODFDEH]D 01RVHWHHVFXFKD« 0$5Ì$3DUDODYDUPHODFDEH]D 03DUDODYDUWHODFDEH]DQHFHVLWDVD\XGD¢3RUTXpQRSXHGHVODYDUWHODFDEH]DFRQODV GRVPDQRV" 0$5Ì$6tSHURDSR\iQGRPH 0¢SDUDTXp" 0$5Ì$3HURDSR\iQGRPH 03HURDSR\iQGRWH$KPX\ELHQ¢6LHPSUHKDVSDUWLFLSDGRGHODFODVHGH()GHVGH SHTXHxLWD"¢1RWHDFXHUGDVFXDQGRKLFLVWHDTXtSULPHUR" 0$5Ì$'HVGH3 0£$K(VWDEDVGHVGH3¢<GHVGH3KDVSDUWLFLSDGRRQRWHDFXHUGDV" 0$5Ì$1RPHDFXHUGR 03HURHQSULPHUFXUVRFXDQGRWHQtDVVHLVDxRVVLTXHSDUWLFLSDEDV¢QR" 5 0$5Ì$$OJXQDVYHFHV 0$OJXQDVYHFHV¢QRVLHPSUH" 0$5Ì$6t 0¢<SRUTXpHUDQDOJXQDVYHFHV" 0$5Ì$3XHVSRUTXHKDFHPRVRWUDVFRVDV 0&RPRSRUHMHPSORVLPHORSXHGHVH[SOLFDU«SRUTXHHUHVXQED~OFHUUDGR\FRPRQR PHH[SOLTXHVPiVFRVDVQRVDEUpTXpKD\GHQWURGHOED~O 0$5Ì$1RORVp 0¢3RUTXpQRSRGtDVSDUWLFLSDUDYHFHV" 0$5Ì$3XHVSRUTXHKDFHPRVFRVDVPX\GLItFLOHV 0¢0X\GLItFLOHV"¢&yPRSRUHMHPSOR"$YHUGDPHXQDSLVWD 0$5Ì$£$Kt\RTXHVp« 09HQJDGtPHOR« 0$5Ì$1RORVH 0¢$YHUTXpHVGLItFLOSDUDWL" 0$5Ì$<RTXHVp 0 ¢1R WH DFXHUGDV" £8\ TXH QR VH DFXHUGD GH ODV FRVDV GLItFLOHV« ¢$KRUD HQ OD DFWXDOLGDGWRGRHVIiFLOSDUDWL"¢7RGRORSXHGHVKDFHU" 0$5Ì$1RDOJXQDVFRVDVQRSHURQRPHDFXHUGRSHURHODxRSDVDGR« 0¢1RWHDFXHUGDV" 0$5Ì$1R 0¢4XpFRVDVQRSRGtDVKDFHU" 0$5Ì$3XHV« 0+D]PHPRULD 0$5Ì$£$\QRPHDFXHUGR 0&XDQGRYDVDOJLPQDVLR¢KD\DOJRTXHQRSXHGDVKDFHU" 0$5Ì$6LPXFKDVFRVDV 0&RPRSRUHMHPSOR« 0$5Ì$3XHVODELFLFOHWD 0/DELFLFOHWDQRODSXHGHVKDFHU¢4XpPDV" 0$5Ì$3RUTXHQROOHJR 0$KSRUTXHQROOHJDVDORVSHGDOHV 0$5Ì$6LSRUTXHVLVHVXEHVLTXHOOHJRSHURKDVWDDEDMRQROOHJR 0¢<TXpPiVQRSXHGHVKDFHU"¢<DQRWHDFXHUGDV" 0$5Ì$<DHVWi 0<DHVWi%XHQR1RUPDOPHQWHODFODVHGH()ODFRPSDUWHVFRQWXVFRPSDxHURV¢QR" 0$5Ì$6L 0¢+DFHVDOJXQDYH]DFWLYLGDGHVHQVROLWDULRRVLHPSUHSDUWLFLSDVFRQWXVFRPSDxHURV" 5 0$5Ì$3XHV«VRODWDPELpQ 0$VRODV<FyPRWHJXVWDPiV¢&RQORVFRPSDxHURVRDVRODV" 0$5Ì$&RQORVFRPSDxHURV 0¢<SRUTXpFRQORVFRPSDxHURVPiVTXHDVRODV" 0$5Ì$3XHVFRQORVFRPSDxHURV« 03RUIDYRUDO]DODYR] 0$5Ì$<RVRODPHDEXUUR 03RUTXHVRODWHDEXUUHVHQFDPELRFRQORVFRPSDxHURV¢TXpSDVD" 0$5Ì$1RPHDEXUUR 0£$K¢7HORSDVDVPHMRU" 0$5Ì$6L 0 ¢7H GLYLHUWHV" (V SRUTXH WH GLYLHUWHV ¢QR" ¢< SRU DOJR PDV" 2 VHD TXH SUHILHUHV KDFHUORFRQORVFRPSDxHURV¢QR"¢/DFODVH" 0$5Ì$6L 0¢(QODKRUDGHOSDWLRDTXpVXHOHVMXJDU" 5 0$5Ì$$QDGD\RPHTXHGRVHQWDGD\\DHVWi 0$O]DODYR]TXHQRWHHVFXFKR 0$5Ì$0HTXHGRVHQWDGD\\DHVWi 07HTXHGDVVHQWDGD\\DHVWi« 0$5Ì$$OPRU]DQGR 03HUR\RWHKHYLVWRMXJDQGRDOJXQDYH]RVHDTXHDOJXQDVYHFHVMXHJDV¢QR" 0$5Ì$6L 0¢<DTXpMXHJDVFXDQGRSDUWLFLSDVDOJXQDYH]" 0$5Ì$3XHVDOKLOR\« 0$FRUWDUHOKLOR 0$5Ì$6L 0<¢$TXpPDV" 0$5Ì$8QDYH]MXJXpDORVERORV<\DHVWi 03HURQRUPDOPHQWHWHTXHGDVVHQWDGDGLFHV¢<SRUTXpWHTXHGDVVHQWDGD" 0$5Ì$3RUTXHTXLHUR 03RUTXHW~TXLHUHV¢6L"¢3UHILHUHVHVWDUVHQWDGDTXHMXJDQGR" 0$5Ì$1R 0<HQWRQFHV¢SRUTXpQRMXHJDV" 0$5Ì$3XHVSRUTXHPHTXHGDSRFRUDWRSDUDHOSDWLRDYHFHV\DYHFHV\SRUTXHQR 5 HQFXHQWURDPLVFRPSDxHURV 0¢<GyQGHHVWiQWXVFRPSDxHURVVLWLHQHQTXHHVWDUWRGRVHQHOSDWLR" 0$5Ì$<DSHURDOJXQRVVHTXHGDQDKtFRPRDOJXQDVQLxDVTXHVHTXHGDQDKt 0¢6HTXHGDQGyQGH" 0$5Ì$ (Q OD FODVH FDPELDQGR DO SH]« SHUR PXFKDV YHFHV VH TXHGDQ OD ÈQJHOD OD 3DWULFLD\OD'DOLD 02VHDTXHWXVDPLJXLWDVVHTXHGDQHQODFODVHDYHFHV<FRQHOODVQRSXHGHVMXJDU 0$5Ì$1R 0¢<QRWLHQHVRWURVDPLJXLWRVSDUDMXJDU" 5 0$5Ì$6tSHURVRQPiVSHTXHxRVODVQLxDV%XHQRGRVQLxDV 0¢4XpVRQGHRWUDFODVH" 0$5Ì$6tGH3 0¢'H3"¢<MXHJDVFRQHOODV" 0$5Ì$6tFRQOD0DUtDPiV 0¢<DTXpMXHJDVDFRUWDUHOKLOR" 0$5Ì$1R 0¢$TXp"'tPHOR 0$5Ì$1RFRQHO%DE\%RUQ 0¢(OTXp" 0$5Ì$&RQHO%DE\%RUQXQPXxHFRTXHHVXQEHEp 0¢<DTXpMXJiLVFRQHOPXxHFR" 0$5Ì$3XHVDPDPiV 0$PDPiV¢\VHOODPD%DE\" 0$5Ì$%DE\%RUQ 0³%RU´¢<TXpTXLHUHGHFLU³%RU´" 0$5Ì$³%RU´ 0³%RU´¢&yPRVHHVFULEH" 0$5Ì$%HDOWDRHUUHHQH 0¢<TXpTXLHUHGHFLU"0XxHFR« 0$5Ì$%HEp 0%HEp<MXJiLVDPDPiV«¢<HVRFRQORVGH3" 0$5Ì$1R\R\OD0DUtD 0¢4XHHVWXDPLJXLWDGHFODVH" 0$5Ì$1RGH3 0 'H 3 0X\ ELHQ ¢< HV D HVR D OR TXH VXHOHV MXJDU QRUPDOPHQWH" ¢7H TXHGDV 5 VHQWDGDRMXHJDVFRQHO%DE\%RUQ\DOJXQDVYHFHVDFRUWDUHOKLORRORVERORV"¢<DOJR PiV" 0$5Ì$1R 0¢<FXiQGRWHJXVWDPiVGHWRGDVHVDVRFDVLRQHV" 0$5Ì$&XDQGRMXHJRFRQOD0DUtDDO%DE\%RUQ 0¢$KVL"¢7HORSDVDVPHMRUMXJDQGRFRQHOPXxHFR"¢7HJXVWDMXJDUFRQHOPXxHFRD PDPiV" 0$5Ì$6L 00X\ELHQ¢$OJXQDYH]WHKDVVHQWLGRPDOHQHOSDWLRWHKDVHQWULVWHFLGRHQHOSDWLR" 0$5Ì$1R 06LHPSUHWHORKDVSDVDGRELHQHQHOSDWLR 0$5Ì$6L 01RUHFXHUGDVQLQJXQDH[SHULHQFLDQHJDWLYD« 0$5Ì$1R 06LHPSUHWHORKDVSDVDGRELHQ0X\ELHQ 0$5Ì$6L 0¢+DFHVDOJ~QGHSRUWHIXHUDGHODHVFXHOD" 5 0$5Ì$6tSHURQRDTXt 0¢(QGyQGHORKDFHV" 0$5Ì$3XHVHQHOFHQWURGHUHKDELOLWDFLyQ 0(QHOFHQWURGHUHKDELOLWDFLyQ 0$5Ì$6L 0¢<TXpSUDFWLFDV"&XpQWDPHORTXHWHQJRPXFKDVJDQDVGHVDEHUOR 0$5Ì$)~WERO 0£)~WERO¢-XHJDVDI~WERO" 0$5Ì$6t 0¢<TXpPDV" 0$5Ì$<DWHQLV 0$WHQLV¢<WHJXVWDKDFHUOR"¢3RUTXpWHORSDVDVELHQ" 0$5Ì$3XHV«QRORVpSRUTXHPHORSDVRELHQ 0¢6yORSRUTXHWHORSDVDVELHQ" 0$5Ì$6t 0%XHQR<QDWDFLyQ¢KDFHVQDWDFLyQ"£$K7HKDEtDVROYLGDGRGHDOJR\\RORVDEtD 5 £HK¢&RQTXLpQKDFHVQDWDFLyQ" 0$5Ì$&RQQDGLH6ROD 0¢6ROD"£$\4XHXQSDMDULWRPHKDGLFKRTXHKDFHVQDWDFLyQFRQPDPi 0$5Ì$6tSHUR\RVRODQDGR 0£$K7~QDGDVW~VROD&RQPDPiQR¢<WHORSDVDVELHQKDFLHQGRQDWDFLyQ" 0$5Ì$(QODSLVFLQDSHTXHxDPHMRUSRUTXHHVWiPX\FDOHQWLWD<D\HUIXL 0£$K¢<WHJXVWDKDFHUORVRODRWHJXVWDKDFHUORHQFRPSDxtD" 0$5Ì$6ROD 03UHILHUHVKDFHUORVROD¢1RQRWDVDIDOWDUPiVQLxRVSDUHFRPSDUWLUODDFWLYLGDG"¢< SRUTXpWHJXVWDODQDWDFLyQ"'tPHOR 0$5Ì$3XHVSRUTXHPLUDSRUTXH\RTXHVH« 0£¢3RUTXH\RTXHVH«"$O]DODYR]TXHQRWHYDPRVDHVFXFKDU 0$5Ì$(VTXHQRVH« 0¢3RUTXHQRVDEHV"2VHDW~KDFHVODQDWDFLyQ\QRVDEHVSRUTXp"$OJRKDEUiTXHWH JXVWDUi \ GLUiV ³¢4Xp ELHQ YR\ D QDWDFLyQ´ R GLFHV« ³RRRRK YR\ D QDWDFLyQ´ ¢4Xp GLFHV" 0$5Ì$1DGD 01RGLFHVQDGDSHUR¢TXpSLHQVDV" 0$5Ì$3XHVTXHPHJXVWDODSLVFLQDSHTXHxD 0£$K7~GLFHV³TXHELHQPHYR\DODSLVFLQDSHTXHxDFRQHODJXDFDOHQWLWD´¢QR" 0$5Ì$6t$\HUHVWDEDDUGLHQGR 0¢$\HUDUGLHQGR"3HUR¢FyPRDUGtD" 0$5Ì$3XHVPXFKR0X\FDOLHQWH 0¢7HTXHPy" 0$5Ì$1R 0£$K¢3HURHQWUDVWHHQHODJXD" 0$5Ì$6L 0(QWRQFHVHVWDEDV~SHUFDOHQWLWD¢QR" 0$5Ì$6t 0<DKtW~V~SHUDJXVWLWR¢QR" 0$5Ì$6t 0£+D\DPLJD«%XHQR¢%DMDVDODFDOOHDMXJDUFRQWXVDPLJRV" 0$5Ì$$ODFDOOHQRSRUTXHPHYR\DFDVDGHOD0DULDPXFKDVYHFHV 5 0¢4XLpQHV0DULD" 0$5Ì$/DGH3 0£$K/DGH3¢4XpHVYHFLQDWX\D" 0$5Ì$1RYHFLQDQR3RUTXH«>KDEODPX\EDMLWRQRVHOHHQWLHQGHFDVL@ 0¢TXpTXpTXp"4XHQRWHHVFXFKR 0$5Ì$9HFLQDQR(VXQDDPLJDTXH« 0+DEODKDFLDDTXtTXHVLQRQRWHJUDEDUHPRV 0$5Ì$(VXQDDPLJDTXHSXHVTXH\RYLYRDUULEDHQODPRQWDxDHQWRQFHVEDMDVXQD PRQWDxD 0¢%DMDV«" 0$5Ì$8QDPRQWDxD\DOODGRGHXQEDUTXHVHOODPDHOEDUGH3HGURSXHVDOOtDOODGR YLYH\HQWRQFHVSXHVYR\PXFKDVYHFHV 0¢<DTXpMXHJDVFRQHOOD" 0$5Ì$$O%DE\%RUQ 0£$K¢7DPELpQFRQWLQ~DVMXJDQGRDO%DE\%RUQ" 0$5Ì$6t\DPiVFRVDV 0¢$TXpFRVDV"¢-XHJRVGHPRYLPLHQWRQRKDFHV" 0$5Ì$ 6t $ HVFRQGHU« (OOD WLHQH XQ SHOXFKH \ HOOD VH WDSD ORV RMRV FXHQWD KDVWD YHLQWH SHUR HOOD QR VDEH \ WLHQH TXH FRQWDU GLH] YHFHV GRV GRV YHFHV GLH] < \R HVFRQGRHOSHOXFKH 0<WXHVFRQGHVHOSHOXFKH 0$5Ì$6t 0$K\WLHQHTXHGHVFXEULUOR 0$5Ì$6tWLHQHTXHHQFRQWUDUOR 0¢'yQGHHVWiHVFRQGLGR" 0$5Ì$3XHVORHVFRQGRGHEDMRGHODFDPDXQDYH]ORHVFRQGtGHEDMRGHODUPDULR 0£$KtYD<WXPXFKDVGLILFXOWDGHVSDUDORFDOL]DUOR¢QR" 0$5Ì$6tSRUTXHKDEtDXQDFRVDDVtGHEDMRGHODUPDULR« 0¢8QDFRVDTXH" 0$5Ì$3XHVFRPRXQMXHJR\HORULQDOGHO%DE\%RUQ\\RVHORHVFRQGtVDTXpHORULQDO GHO%DE\%RUQVDTXpHVR\ORSXVHDOILQDOGHWRGR<OXHJRPHWtRWUDYH]HVR\PHWtHVR \QRORHQFRQWUDED 0£$KtYD2VHDTXHMXHJDVDOHVFRQGLWHFRQHO%DE\%RUQ¢QR" 0$5Ì$6t 0$HVFRQGHUDO%DE\%RUQ¢<DTXpPiVMXHJDV"-XHJRVGHFDUUHUDVQRKDFHV 0$5Ì$1R 0<WHJXVWDKDFHUHVRVMXHJRVFRQWXDPLJD¢<QRWLHQHVRWUDDPLJDFRQTXLHQMXJDU" 5 0$5Ì$6tODÈQJHOD\OD3DWULFLDSHURFRQHOODVQRMXHJR 0¢3RUTXp" 0$5Ì$3RUTXHHVWiQPiVDEDMR<HVWiQPHQRVDEDMRTXHOD0DULD 0¢$KODVWLHQHVPiVOHMRV"/DVWLHQHVPiVOHMRV¢QR" 0$5Ì$1RPiVFHUFD$OD0DUtDODWHQJRPiVFHUFD 06tPiVFHUFD6t\DODÈQJHOD¢\DTXLpQPiV" 0$5Ì$$OD3DWULFLD 0$OD3DWULFLDODVWLHQHVPiVOHMRV 0$5Ì$ 1R DO UHYpV /D 0DUtD OD WHQJR XQ SRFR OHMRV SHUR QR PX\ OHMRV HQWRQFHV \R EDMR XQD FXHVWD SHUR QR OD PRQWDxD VXER ODV HVFDOHUDV GH PL FDVD EDMR OD FXHVWD \ OXHJREDMRKD\FRPRGRVSXHUWDVDVtXQDSDUDDUULED\RWUDSDUDDEDMR\OXHJRXQSRFR PiV³SD´EDMRSXHVHVODFDVDGHODÈQJHOD\OXHJRXQSRTXLWRPiV³SD´EDMRHVODFDVD GHOD3DWULFLD 0£$K3XHVHQWRQFHVHVWiPiVOHMRV¢QR"ODÈQJHOD\OD3DWULFLDTXHODGHOD0DUtD 0$5Ì$6t 01RPiVFHUFD 0$5Ì$1R 0 $K DKRUD \D QRV YDPRV DFODUDQGR HO FRQFHSWR GH FHUFD \ OHMRV &HUFD SUy[LPR \ OHMRVPiVGLVWDQFLD%XHQR¢<HOILQDOGHVHPDQDVXHOHVMXJDU" 0$5Ì$1R 0¢1R" 0$5Ì$6ROD 06ROD 0$5Ì$&RQHO%DE\%RUQSRUTXHOHFDPELR 0¢<MXHJDVHQFDVD" 0$5Ì$6t 0¢<\DQRYHVDOD0DUtD" 0$5Ì$3HURFRQXQDYHFLQDWDPELpQMXHJRTXHHVPiVSHTXHxDTXHDKRUDYDD3 5 SHURQRDTXtYDDXQFROH 0$KFRQXQDYHFLQDGH3 0$5Ì$$O0RQWVHUUDW4XHDQWHVLEDOD0DUtD\OD<DHG 0¢<OD" 0$5Ì$/D<DHG 0<DHG<WDPELpQMXHJDVFRQHOODDO%DE\%RUQ¢QR" 0$5Ì$1RSXHVDVXSDUTXH 0¢&yPR" 0$5Ì$(QVXSDWLR 0$KHQVXSDWLR 0$5Ì$3RUTXHWLHQHXQSDWLR\WLHQHJDOOLQDV 0¢<DTXpMXHJDV" 0$5Ì$3XHVQRVH 0£¢1RVDEHVQRPHVDEHVFRQWDUDTXpMXHJDV"9DGtPHOR«4XH\RTXLHURVDEHUOR« 0$5Ì$1RRRR 09DGLPHDTXpMXHJDV<DTXHGDSRFR6RORTXHGDXQDSUHJXQWD\\DGHVFDQVDPRV 0$5Ì$3XHV«$\\RTXHVp 0'LFHVTXHKD\JDOOLQDV 0$5Ì$6t 04XHWLHQHXQSDWLR 0$5Ì$6t 0¢(QWRQFHVDTXpMXHJDV" 0$5Ì$3XHVDXQRVJORERV\WLUDUORVSDUDDEDMR3RUTXHGHVGHHOSDWLRRORVWLUDPRVHQ ODSDUHGRORVWLUDPRVDDEDMR 0<VLORVWLUiLVDEDMRHQWRQFHV¢TXHSDVD" 0$5Ì$1RSDVDQDGD 0¢4XHYXHODQ" 0$5Ì$6HH[SORWDQ 0¢([SORWDQ" 0$5Ì$6t 0¢<RVTXHGiLVVLQJORERV" 0$5Ì$6t 0<ORVWLUiLVDEDMR¢4XpDODFDOOH" 0$5Ì$1RSRUTXHHVWiHOSDWLR\DEDMRKD\XQDFRVD<HQWRQFHVORVWLUDPRVDOOt\VX KHUPDQRWDPELpQ\ORVDPLJRVWDPELpQGHVXKHUPDQR 0¢<OXHJRSRGpLVUHFXSHUDUGHQXHYRORVJORERV" 0$5Ì$1R6HURPSHQ 0$K¢VHURPSHQ" 0$5Ì$&ODURSRUTXHH[SORWDQ\VDOHHODJXD 0¢$KTXHORVJORERVWLHQHQDJXD" 0$5Ì$6tSRUTXHWLHQHQXQDPDQJXHUDHQHOSDWLR<XQRHO$OH[SHURQRHOGHDTXtHO DPLJR GH 0LJXHO SXHV XQD YH] KL]R GRV JORERV JUDQGHV \ XQR ³WRSH´ JUDQGH TXH HUD PiVJUDQGHTXHXQDSHUD 0/OHQRGHDJXD<ORVWLUiLV 0$5Ì$6t 0$EDMR\UHYLHQWDQ 0$5Ì$6t+DFHQ£3$0 03XHVWHQGUpLVTXHWHQHUPXFKRVJORERV¢QR"¢4XLpQFRPSUDORVJORERV" 0$5Ì$/RVWLHQHQHOORVTXHVRQYHFLQRV 0$K¢<DHVRHVDORTXHMXJiLV" 0$5Ì$6t 0¢$HVWDOODUJORERV" 0$5Ì$<DO%DE\%RUQ 0<DO%DE\%RUQ0X\ELHQ¢+DVLGRDOJXQDYH]GHFRORQLDV" 0$5Ì$6t 0¢<TXpWDOWHORKDVSDVDGR" 0$5Ì$%LHQ 0¢6L"¢4XpHVORTXHPiVWHKDJXVWDGRGHODVFRORQLDV" 5 0$5Ì$ 3XHV MXJDU FRQ ORV GHPiV QLxRV \ TXH OD ÈQJHOD WDPELpQ YD DO HVSODL GH FRORQLDVGHOHVSODL 0¢<DTXpMXJiLV"¢$TXpMXJDEDLV" 0$5Ì$3XHV\R\ODVRWUDVQLxDVOD/DLD« 0¢/D/DLD" 0$5Ì$6tOD/DLDOD0yQLFDXQDGHFXDUWROD0yQLFDGHFXDUWRWDPELpQODÈQJHOD\ DQWHVLEDOD3DWULFLDSHURQRYDDKRUDSXHV\RHOODVQRVpGRQGHHVWDEDQ3HUR\R\OD *ORULDWDPELpQTXHHVWDEDHODxRSDVDGR\DKRUD\DQRHVWi«\\DHVWi<\RMXJDEDD I~WEROFRQXQSURIHVRU 0¢$I~WERO" 0$5Ì$6t 0¢<QRWHQtDVQLQJ~QSUREOHPDSDUDMXJDUDI~WERO" 0$5Ì$1RSRUTXHPHSRQtDGHURGLOODV\KDEtDXQDSRUWHUtD\\RODVSDUDEDWRGDV 0£$KKDFtDVGHSRUWHUD 0$5Ì$6t 00X\ELHQ¢<HVRHVORTXHPiVWHJXVWyGHODVFRORQLDV" 0$5Ì$6t 06L¢<YDVDOHVSODLHOViEDGRSRUODWDUGH" 5 0$5Ì$¢<FyPRORVDEHVTXHHVHOViEDGR" 01RQR<RWHSUHJXQWRSRUTXHORVHVSODLVQRUPDOPHQWHVHRUJDQL]DQORVViEDGRVSRU ODWDUGH¢7XYDVDOHVSODL" 0$5Ì$$KRUDQRSRUTXHWHQJRGHEHUHV 03RUTXHWLHQHVGHEHUHV¢<FXDQGRQRWLHQHVGHEHUHVYDVDOHVSODL" 0$5Ì$ (VWH DxR QR SRUTXH KH WHQLGR PXFKRV GHEHUHV \ KDFH GRV GtDV R WUHV TXH FRPHQ]y\WRGRVHVRVGtDV\WDPELpQORKDFHQHOYLHUQHVGHVSXpVGHOFROH 0<WDPELpQKDFHVGHEHUHV 0$5Ì$1RSRUTXHWHQJRTXHLUDOFHQWURGHUHKDELOLWDFLyQ 0$KDOFHQWURGHUHKDELOLWDFLyQ<QRSXHGHV« 0$5Ì$<MXHJRFRQHORUGHQDGRUDOOt<XQDYH]PHVDOLyHO7DU]iQDKt 0¢(QHORUGHQDGRUGHOFHQWURGHUHKDELOLWDFLyQ" 0$5Ì$6L3RUTXHKDEtDXQDVFHQVRUTXHKDEtDFDVDGRVXQSHVFDGRUHO7DU]iQ« XQRGHQRVpFyPRHVOODPDGHXQDSHOtFXOD« 6HFDHXQREMHWR 0(VSHUDTXHORUHFRJHUHPRV 0$5Ì$'HXQDSHOtFXOD«\\DHVWi 0 ¢$K R VHD TXH HO YLHUQHV SRU OD WDUGH HQ HO FHQWUR GH UHKDELOLWDFLyQ MXHJDV FRQ HO 5 RUGHQDGRU" 0$5Ì$6tSHURDKRUDKDJRRWUDVFRVDV 0&RPRSRUHMHPSOR« 0$5Ì$3XHVKDFHUSX]]OHV 0£3X]]OHVWDPELpQ¢<TXpHVORTXHPiVWHJXVWDGHOFHQWURGHUHKDELOLWDFLyQ" 0$5Ì$3XHVHORUGHQDGRU 0(ORUGHQDGRU 0$5Ì$6L 0¢0iVTXHMXJDU" 0$5Ì$6t 06LPHKDVGLFKRTXHMXJDEDVDI~WERO¢QR"HQHOFHQWURGHUHKDELOLWDFLyQWDPELpQ 0$5Ì$6tSHURORVPLpUFROHV 0DK¢<WHJXVWDPiVHORUGHQDGRUTXHMXJDUDI~WERO" 0$5Ì$6t 0%XHQRPX\ELHQ<FXDQGRLEDVDOHVSODLHODxRSDVDGRTXHMXHJRVVROtDVSUDFWLFDU ¢7DPELpQI~WEROFRPRHQODVFRORQLDV"¢2TXp" 0$5Ì$1RSXHVPXFKRVMXHJRVXQDYH]KLFLPRVHOGHXQSD\DVR 0(OGHXQSD\DVR« 0$5Ì$ 6tTXHXQSD\DVRGHFtDDORV PRQLWRUHV TXH XQ SD\DVR KDEtD FRJLGRQXHVWUD PHULHQGD<HUDXQDDFWLYLGDG<IXLPRVSRUHOODEHULQWR\WRGRHVR 0¢$EXVFDUHOSD\DVR" 0$5Ì$6tSHURQRORHQFRQWUDPRVSRUTXHHUDQHOORVTXHGHFtDQTXHKDEtDXQSD\DVR SHURQRKDEtD 0¢(UDQORVPRQLWRUHVTXHVHGLVIUD]DURQGHSD\DVR" 0$5Ì$1RSRUTXHSXVLHURQIOHFKDVDVtSRUDOOt\HQWRQFHVDPtPHOOHYDEDQDFDEDOOLWR 0¢$WLDFDEDOOLWR" 0$5Ì$6t 0¢$VL"¢4XLpQWHOOHYDEDDFDEDOOLWR" 0$5Ì$ 3XHV OD 1XFR TXH VH OODPD (OHQD SHUR FRPR KD\ GRV (OHQDV SXHV D XQD OD OODPDPRV1XFR\DODRWUD(OHQD 0¢/D1XFRHVXQDPRQLWRUDGHHVSODLXQDSURIHVRUDGHOHVSODL" 0$5Ì$6t 06L¢<HVRIXHORTXHPiVWHJXVWy" 0$5Ì$6t 0¢<DOJRPiVTXHGHFLUFRQUHVSHFWRDWXH[SHULHQFLDGHLUGHFRORQLDV" 0$5Ì$1R 0¢7HORSDVDVWHELHQFRQWXVFRPSDxHURV"¢WHGLYHUWLVWHPXFKR" 0$5Ì$6t 0¢6L"¢7RGRIXHSRVLWLYR" 0$5Ì$6t 0¢1DGDQHJDWLYR"&RPRGLUtD9DQ*DDO 0$5Ì$1R 07RGRSRVLWLYR¢<DOJRPiVFRQUHVSHFWRDDOJ~QFRPHQWDULRGHORTXHKHPRVGLFKR KDVWDDKRUD" 0$5Ì$1R 0<RKDJRFRPRORVSHULRGLVWDV£HK¢4XLHUHVDPSOLDUODLQIRUPDFLyQ" 0$5Ì$1R 0¢<DHVWiVFDQVDGD" 0$5Ì$6t3HUR\RTXLHURGHFLUXQDFRVDTXHOHKDSDVDGRDPLKHUPDQDHOGRPLQJR SXHVTXHPLVGRVKHUPDQDV\PLPDGUHIXHURQDFRPSUDUPHHVWDVEDPEDVHVWDV« 06L 0$5Ì$<HQWRQFHVSXHV«KD\DYHUTXHHVORTXHLEDDGHFLUSXHVXQJLWDQRGHHVRV GH DTXHOORV SXHV PL KHUPDQD WHQtD OD FDUWHUD SRU GHWUiV \ YLQR XQ JLWDQR \ OH UREy OD FDUWHUD\HOGLQHUR\OXHJRVHODWLUy 0¢$VL"4XHWULVWH¢QR" 0$5Ì$6L<HUDQHXURV 0¢HXURVTXHOHUREDURQ" 0$5Ì$6t<TXHWHQLD 04XpSHQD3HUREXHQR¢KDUHFXSHUDGRODFDUWHUDRQR" 0$5Ì$/DFDUWHUDVLSHURHOGLQHURQR$Kt«<OXHJRVHSRQHHOPyYLOSRUGHWUiVSRUTXH ORWHQtDDVt¢QR"<OXHJRVHORSRQHDOUHYpV\OHGLFH³$QGD\DTXHWHKDQUREDGROD FDU«EXHQR\DTXHWHKDQUREDGRHOGLQHUR«´OHGLFHPLPDGUHDPLKHUPDQD³<DTXHWH KDQUREDGRHOGLQHUR¢DKRUDTXLHUHVTXHWHUREHQHOPyYLO"´ 0 <DSHUREXHQRSHURDKRUD\DQRVHORKDQUREDGRHOPyYLO¢QR"+DWHQLGRPDOD VXHUWHSHURDIRUWXQDGDPHQWHDHOODQROHKDSDVDGRQDGD¢QR" 0$5Ì$1R 0 %XHQR HO GLQHUR VH SXHGH UHFXSHUDU /D VDOXG QR ¢QR" 3LHQVD HQ HVR $Vt QRV PRWLYDPRVSDUDWUDEDMDUSDUDJDQDUPiVGLQHUR\SRGHUWHFRPSUDURWUDVEDPEDV¢1R 0DUtD" 0$5Ì$6L 0%XHQR¢FHUUDPRV"0XFKtVLPDVJUDFLDV0DUtD (175(9,67$$/&(1752 00'LUHFWRUDGHO&HQWUR )(&+$GHRFWXEUHGH 0 ¢&XiO HV OD UHVSXHVWD HVFRODU GHVGH YXHVWUR FHQWUR D ODV 1HFHVLGDGHV (GXFDWLYDV (VSHFLDOHV1((\FRQFUHWDPHQWHODVTXHVHGHULYDQGHODGLVFDSDFLGDGPRWUL]" 00%XHQRHQSULQFLSLRQXHVWURFHQWURHVWiUHVSRQGHDWRGRVORVDOXPQRVTXHWLHQHQ 5 1(( VHDQ FRQFUHWDPHQWH VL KDEODPRV GH ORV TXH WLHQHQ GLVFDSDFLGDG PRWUL] SXHV WHQHPRV GRV DOXPQRV XELFDGRV HQ SULPHUR \ HQ TXLQWR TXH VRQ 0LTXHO \ 0DUtD < D SDUWH GH ORV TXH WLHQHQ GLVFDSDFLGDG PRWUL] KD\ PXFKRV DOXPQRV TXH WLHQHQ 1(( (QWRQFHVODLGHDHVODGHDGDSWDUDWRGRVORVDOXPQRVVHJ~QVXVQHFHVLGDGHV $YHUGDGRTXHHOREMHWLYRGHOFHQWURHVDWHQGHUDODGLYHUVLGDGHQWRQFHVORTXHVHKDFH HV LQWHQWDU DSOLFDU XQD QXHYD PHWRGRORJtD PHGLDQWH JUXSRV IOH[LEOHV TXH GH QXHYR QR WLHQH QDGD SRUTXH \D KDFH PXFKRV DxRV TXH VH UHDOL]D VREUH WRGR HQ ((88 3HUR OD LGHD HV SRGHU DWHQGHU D WRGRV VHJ~Q VXV QHFHVLGDGHV (QWRQFHV GHVGH HO FHQWUR \ GHVGHHO'HSDUWDPHQWRGH2ULHQWDFLyQGHODHVFXHODORTXHVHKDFHHVDWHQGHUDHVWRV DOXPQRVSULPHURGHWHFWDUORVDWHQGHUORV\GHULYDUORVDORVFHQWURVTXHQHFHVLWHQ (QFRQFUHWRFRQHVWRVGRVDOXPQRVODHVFXHODHVWiDGDSWDGDDUTXLWHFWyQLFDPHQWHSHUR WDQWRXQDOXPQRFRPRHORWURVHPXHYHQFRQ 0/DVPXOHWDV 00 8QRFRQPXOHWDV\HORWURSXHGH DQGDU SHUIHFWDPHQWH 1R WHQHPRVSUREOHPDV< GHVGH HO FHQWUR HVWDPRV DELHUWRV D FXDOTXLHU QHFHVLGDG GH FXDOTXLHU WLSR TXH SXHGDQ WHQHU HVWRV DOXPQRV (QWRQFHV SRU HMHPSOR VL 0DUtD YD GH H[FXUVLyQ D &ROOVHUROD \ QHFHVLWD DGDSWDFLRQHV GHVGH OD GLUHFFLyQ GHO SDUTXH QDWXUDO QRV IDFLOLWDURQ XQ MHHS DGDSWDGR2VHDGHVGHODHVFXHODVtTXHKD\HVWDSUHRFXSDFLyQ\HVWDPRWLYDFLyQSDUD DGDSWDU7DPELpQFRRSHUDPRVFRQODDVRFLDFLyQGHSHUVRQDVFRQGLVFDSDFLGDGPRWUL] SHURODYHUGDGHVTXH~OWLPDPHQWHQRKDIXQFLRQDGRGXUDQWHHOFXUVR 0¢1R" 00 1DGD GXUDQWH HO FXUVR DQWHULRU QR IXQFLRQy SRUTXH ORV GH HVWD DVRFLDFLyQ GH SHUVRQDVFRQGLVFDSDFLGDGPRWUL]VRQYROXQWDULRV(QWRQFHVQRVRWURVOHVKDFHPRVOOHJDU 5 WRGDVODVVDOLGDVTXHKDFHQHVWRVGRVDOXPQRVSDUDTXHSXHGDQWHQHUXQDSHUVRQDTXH OHV D\XGH < OD YHUGDG HV TXH ~OWLPDPHQWH GHVGH OD DVRFLDFLyQ GH SHUVRQDV FRQ GLVFDSDFLGDGPRWUL]QRVGLMHURQTXHDOVHUYROXQWDULRVQRSRGtDQJDUDQWL]DUVXSUHVHQFLD HQFDGDVDOLGD 0£4XpEDUEDULGDG 00(QWRQFHVDYHFHVQRYLHQHQ\FUHRTXHODV~OWLPDVFXDWURRFLQFRYHFHVTXHVDOLy 0DUtD QR YLQLHURQ (QWRQFHV HVWR OR TXH KL]R HV UHSHUFXWLU HQ WRGR HO JUXSR \D TXH HO WXWRUWXYRTXHFDUJDUVHD0DUtDDOKRPEUR\OOHYDUODDWRGRVORVVLWLRV3RUTXHODIDPLOLD WDPSRFR WUDtD XQD VLOOD GH UXHGDV HQ FRQGLFLRQHVHQWRQFHV VH KD KDEODGR FRQ ODV IDPLOLDVFRQODDVRFLDFLyQGHSHUVRQDVFRQGLVFDSDFLGDGPRWUL]SDUDYHUTXHUHDOLGDG WHQHPRVSDUDTXHHODOXPQRQXQFDVHSLHUGDORTXHVHKDFHHQHOFHQWUR3HURDYHFHV WDPSRFRWHQHPRVGHVGHIXHUDORTXHQHFHVLWDUtDPRVUHDOPHQWH 07RGRHODSR\RTXHSUHFLViLVQR" 003HURGHVGHODHVFXHODHVWDPRVDELHUWRVDTXHFXDOTXLHUWLSRGHDOXPQRWHQJDODV 1(( TXH WHQJD \ PiV VL VRQ PRWULFHV TXH HQ SULQFLSLR QR WLHQHQ TXH SHUMXGLFDU SDUD QDGD DO UHVWR GHO JUXSR 3RGHU IDFLOLWDUOHV \ SRGHU DFUHFHQWDU OD UHODFLyQ FRQ HVWRV DOXPQRV 00X\ELHQ¢(QWRQFHVRVSODQWHiLVDGDSWDFLRQHVFXUULFXODUHV" 00'HVGHHOFXUUtFXORVLKDFHIDOWDDGDSWDFLRQHVFXUULFXODUHVVHKDFHQSHURFRPRWH 5 KH GLFKR DQWHV DO KDFHU JUXSRV IOH[LEOHV HQ ODV iUHDV LQVWUXPHQWDOHV GH /HQJXD \ 0DWHPiWLFDVHVWRGDODIDFLOLGDGGHTXHKD\DOXPQRVTXHHVWiQKDFLHQGRTXLQWRFRPR 0DUtD\FRPRHVWiPDOGH/HQJXD\0DWHPiWLFDVSXHGHLUDRWURWLSRGHJUXSRV,UDXQR GHFXDUWRDRWURTXHVHFUHHQXHYR7LHQHVODIDFLOLGDGSDUDTXHXQDOXPQRSXHGDLUD WUHVRFXDWURJUXSRV(VWRKDFHXQRHYLWDVEDVWDQWHVUHSHWLFLRQHVHODOXPQRVDEHTXH KDFH /HQJXD \ 0DWHPiWLFDV DO PLVPR WLHPSR TXH HO UHVWR 6yOR FDPELDQ GH JUXSR (QWRQFHVGHVGHHOFXUUtFXORHVWRHVWiVROXFLRQDGR5HVSHFWRDOD(GXFDFLyQ)tVLFD() D YHU FRPR QRVRWURV QR VRPRV HVSHFLDOLVWDV HQ () OR TXH KDFHPRV HV GDUOH WRGD OD SULRULGDGDODPDHVWUDHVSHFLDOLVWDTXHHOODGHFLGDFRQMXQWDPHQWHFRQQRVRWURV\DTXH HO 'HSDUWDPHQWR GH 2ULHQWDFLyQ KDFH XQ VHJXLPLHQWR GH HVWRV FDVRV \ VH OH GD WRWDO DXWRQRPtDSRUTXHODHVSHFLDOLVWDHVHOODQR" 06t 001RVRWURVFRQILDPRVHQHOODQRVRWURVQRHQWHQGHPRV 0<D 00 3HUR HQ SULQFLSLR QRVRWURV HQ FRQFUHWR FRQ ORV PRWULFHV QR LQFLGLPRV SRUTXH QR VRPRVODVSHUVRQDVPiVHQWHQGLGDV$WHQGHPRVPiVDWRGRORTXHVHUtDHODVSHFWRGHO FXUUtFXORGHiUHDVLQVWUXPHQWDOHV 0¢<FRQUHVSHFWRDOFXUUtFXORGHiUHDVLQVWUXPHQWDOHVFXiOHVODUHVSXHVWDGHVGHOD 5 RUJDQL]DFLyQLQQRYDFLyQ\GHVDUUROORSURIHVLRQDO" 00(VWDHVWDHVODLGHDRVHDFXDQGROOHJDPRVDTXtREVHUYDPRVTXHFDGDYH]VHGD PiV GLYHUVLGDG GH DOXPQRV SRU ODV HVWUXFWXUDV IDPLOLDUHV ODV HVWUXFWXUDV VRFLDOHV TXH KD\HQWRQFHVDOFUHDUHVWHWLSRGHRUJDQL]DFLyQGHJUXSRIOH[LEOHKDIDFLOLWDGRPXFKROD WDUHD SDUD WRGRV HVWRV DOXPQRV ,QQRYDFLyQ HQWUH FRPLOODV SRUTXH QR HV LQQRYDU SHUR TXpSRGHPRVKDFHUSDUDTXHORVDOXPQRVDSUHQGDQVHJ~QVXVQHFHVLGDGHV'HKHFKR OOHYDPRVWUHVFXUVRVKDFLpQGRORORTXHIDFLOLWDORVJUXSRVIOH[LEOHVHVTXHQRVRODPHQWH ORVDOXPQRVTXHWLHQHQSUREOHPDVSDUDDSUHQGHUVLQRORVDOXPQRVTXHDGHPiVDSUHQGHQ PiVTXHWLHQHQPiVFDSDFLGDGHQWRQFHVSXHGHQLUSDUDDUULED 0<D 00 (QWRQFHV DWHQGHPRV D WRGRV HK ORV GH 1(( HQWUH FRPLOODV \ ORV TXH SXHGHQ GRWDGRVVXSHUGRWDGRVRVLPSOHPHQWHTXHSXHGHQLUTXHSXHGHQKDFHUPiVGHORTXH HOORVKDFHQHQFODVH(QWRQFHVGHVGHHVWDySWLFDSLHQVRTXHODHVFXHODSXHGHDWHQGHUD PXFKRV PiV DOXPQRV +DFH TXH PXFKRV DOXPQRV TXH WHQGUtDV TXH DWHQGHU IXHUD GHO DXOD\DQRORKDFHVSRUTXHWLHQHQFXDWURKRUDVGHJUXSRIOH[LEOHGH0DWHPiWLFDVWUHVGH /HQJXDHQWRQFHVORVUHIXHU]RV\DVHKDFHQ3HURDGHPiVHQSHTXHxRVJUXSRVFXiQWR PiVSHTXHxRVHVHOJUXSRTXLHUHGHFLUTXHKD\PiVGLILFXOWDGHV\HQWRQFHVOHVDWLHQGHQ GLYHUVRVSURIHVRUHV(VRTXLHUHGHFLUTXHGHVGHODHVFXHODWRGRHOSURIHVRUDGRWLHQHTXH HVWDUGHDFXHUGRFRQHVWDPHWRGRORJtDSDUDSDUWLFLSDUWRGRVKDFHPRVJUXSRVIOH[LEOHV 00X\ELHQ6LWHSDUHFHSDVDPRVDODVLJXLHQWHSUHJXQWD¢&XiOHVVRQODVGLILFXOWDGHV 5 GHODLQFOXVLyQGHODOXPQDGRFRQGLVFDSDFLGDGPRWUL]HQODVVHVLRQHVGH()"¢&XiOHV VRQODVTXHSUHYpV"<DVDEHPRVTXHQRHUHVHVSHFLDOLVWDSHURSRUODVUHODFLRQHVTXH WLHQHVFRQODPDHVWUDGH() 00 $ YHUHQSULQFLSLRORVDOXPQRVQR WLHQHQ GLILFXOWDGHV SRUTXH HOOD DGDSWD HK HOOD DGDSWD VXVFODVHVHQWRQFHVWLHQHPXFKRHQFXHQWDDYHUSULPHURVHKDFHXQWUDEDMR PX\ LPSRUWDQWH GHQWUR GH ODV DXODV HQ OR TXH HV OD WXWRUtD HQWRQFHV HVWRV DOXPQRV FXDQGROOHJDQDOFROHJLRVHLQWHQWDPXFKRTXHVHDGDSWHQDODFODVHTXHORVDOXPQRVORV HQWLHQGDQVHOHVWUDEDMDPXFKRODLGHDGHTXHQLHVXQLQ~WLOQLHV³WRQWR´QLQHFHVLWD PiVVLQRTXHKD\GLIHUHQFLDVVtVHOHSXHGHD\XGDUSHURVREUHSURWHJHUOHQR(QWRQFHV FODURGHVGHTXHHQWUDHQ3VLWXHVWiVKDFLHQGRHVWHWUDEDMROOHJDXQPRPHQWRTXH FRQHVWRVDOXPQRVVRQPX\WROHUDQWHVSHUGyQVRQPX\VROLGDULRV\HQWRQFHVDFHSWDQHO SUREOHPD (QWRQFHV VDEHQ SRU HMHPSOR TXH VL OOHYD GRGRWLV HV SRUTXH QR FRQWUROD HVItQWHUHV/RVDEHQSHURQROHVSUHRFXSD3HURQRKD\SUREOHPDSRUTXHHVWiWUDEDMDGR GHVGH HO SULPHU PRPHQWR HQWRQFHV FXDQGR OOHJD OD () HV XQD FODVH PiV QR YHQ GLIHUHQFLDV6DEHQTXHXQRQRSRGUiFRUUHUWDQWRSRUTXHYDFRQPXOHWDVRTXHDORWUROH YDDFRVWDUPiVYDDOOHJDUHO~OWLPRSHURDORPHMRUODPDHVWUDGH()\DKDFHJUXSRVGH WDOPDQHUDSDUDTXHSXHGDSULYLOHJLDUVHHVWHDOXPQR(QWRQFHVQRVHFUHDQGLIHUHQFLDVQL SLHQVR TXH KD\DQ GLIHUHQFLDV D YHU ODV GLILFXOWDGHV D OR PHMRU ODV SXHGH H[SOLFDU OD HVSHFLDOLVWDGH()FXDQGRGLFH´KRPEUHHVWRQRVDEUtDFyPRKDFHUORRFyPRDGDSWDUOR´ \VHUtDPX\FRQFUHWRGHOFXUUtFXORGH()3HURHQFXDQWRDODUHODFLyQFRQORVDOXPQRVR HQ UHODFLyQ FRQ OD FODVH \R SLHQVR TXH HVWR HVWi FRPR PX\ FRQWURODGR \ TXH HVWi UHDOPHQWHTXHVHHVWiOOHYDQGRELHQHK" 0&RPSUHQGR 004XHVHSXHGHPHMRUDUQRKD\GXGDTXHSRGHPRVKDFHUORPXFKRPHMRUVHJXUR\ TXHKD\TXHDSUHQGHU\KD\TXHLUSRUHVHFDPLQR3RUTXHSXHGHQOOHJDUPXFKRVPiV DOXPQRVSHURQRSLHQVRTXHHVWHWHQJDTXHVHUXQPRWLYRGHEXHQRGHGLILFXOWDGGHQWUR GHODVDXODV\PHQRVWDPSRFRHQOD()DOPHQRVFRQORVDOXPQRVTXHWHQHPRVDKRUD 0<D 00 &ODUR WHQHPRV GRV FDVRV PX\ FRQFUHWRV 6L QRV OOHJD XQ DOXPQR FRQ VLOOD GH 5 UXHGDVSXHVVHJXUDPHQWHORTXHWHQGUtDPRVTXHKDFHUGHFDUDDWRGRHOSURIHVRUDGR QR VyOR OD SHUVRQD GH () HV WUDEDMDU WRGRV SDUD GHFLU ³EXHQR \ DKRUD TXH OOHJD XQ DOXPQRFRQ1((\FRQVLOODGHUXHGDVTXpKD\TXHKDFHU"¢FyPRQRVORPRQWDPRV" ¢HQODVDXODVTXpKDFHPRV"´(QWRQFHVKD\TXHVHUHVWRKD\TXHLUFRQMXQWDPHQWH 0<D 00$YHUSRUHMHPSORD\HUWXYLPRVXQDUHXQLyQHQODFXDOVHSUHVHQWDEDQWRGRVORV FDVRVGHORVDOXPQRVTXHSUHVHQWDQDOJXQDQHFHVLGDGTXHQR1((WRGRVSHURDOJXQD QHFHVLGDG/RVDOXPQRVTXHHVWiQDWHQGLGRVIXHUDFyPRKD\TXHWUDWDUDHVWRVDOXPQRV GHQWURGHOFROHJLRTXpSDVDVLYHPRVDWDOQLxDTXHQRUPDOPHQWHVHGLVSHUVD\YDSRUHO FROHJLR4XpDFWLWXGKHPRVGHWRPDUWRGRV 0<D 00 (QWRQFHV VH KDQ WUD]DGR XQDV OtQHDV JHQHUDOHV SDUD TXH HVWRV DOXPQRV HQ FRQFUHWRVHDQGLH]VHDQTXLQFHVHDQGLHFLRFKRHKTXHHQSULQFLSLRKDEORGHGLHFLRFKR SRUTXH VRQ GLHFLRFKR 7RGRV VDEHPRV OD SUREOHPiWLFD TXH WLHQHQ VLQ HQWUDU HQ SHTXHxRV GHWDOOHV HKQRHQODVPLQXFLDV QR SHUR TXp SUREOHPD WLHQHQ GyQGH HVWiQ DWHQGLGRV\FyPRKD\TXHWUDWDUORVSRUTXpEXHQROXHJRVHGDQFRVDVFRPRDTXHOOD³DK HVTXHWDOSURIHVRUDPHKDGLFKRTXH´QRQRQRWRGRVVDEHPRVORTXHOHRFXUUHDO DOXPQR\WRGRVORVDWHQGHPRVGHODPLVPDPDQHUD(QWRQFHVODLGHDHVTXHVLHPSUHHO SURIHVRUDGRFRQR]FDDWRGRVORVDOXPQRVSDUDD\XGDUOHVGHODPLVPDPDQHUDSDUDTXH QR KD\DQ GLIHUHQFLDVHQ GHILQLWLYD HO REMHWLYR HV PHMRUDU OD HGXFDFLyQ GH WRGRV ORV DOXPQRVHQFRQFUHWRORVTXHSUHVHQWDQ1(( 00X\ELHQ3XHVPXFKtVLPDVJUDFLDV 00$Wt (175(9,67$$/&(1752 &5&0DHVWUDGH(GXFDFLyQ)tVLFDGH0DUtD )(&+$GHRFWXEUHGH 0 $ OR ODUJRGHWXH[SHULHQFLDGRFHQWH¢(VODSULPHUDYH]TXHWLHQHVXQDOXPQRFRQ GLVFDSDFLGDGPRWUL]" &(VWDFKLTXLWDODWHQJR\RGHVGHTXHHQWUyHQ3>(GXFDFLyQ,QIDQWLO@3XHVItMDWHDKRUD HVWiHQTXLQWRSXHVWRGRVHVWRVDxRV 0¢3HURKDVLGRODSULPHUD" & £$K 6t Vt Vt < DKRUD WHQJR RWUR FKDYDO TXH WH FRPHQWp TXH HVWi HQ SULPHUR TXH WDPELpQWLHQHSUREOHPDV\VREUHWRGRGHODSDUWHGHHTXLOLEULRSRUTXHHORWURFKDYDOWLHQH SUREOHPDVGHHVSLQDEtILGD 0¢<FyPRWHVHQWLVWHDOVDEHUORTXHWHQtDVXQDDOXPQDFRQGLVFDSDFLGDGPRWUL]" &%XHQRHVXQDFRVDTXHQRPHKHSODQWHDGRQXQFDSRUTXHQRVp\RYHtDDODFKLTXLWD 5 TXHVHJ~QTXHFRVDVFXDQGRHUDQPiVSHTXHxRVSXHVHQWRQFHV\RFRPRKDJRPXFKRV MXHJRVVLPEyOLFRVSXHVWUDEDMDEDPHSRGtDGHGLFDUPiVDHOODPLHQWUDVHOUHVWRSXHV KDFtDRWURWLSRGHWUDEDMRSHURDKRUDDOVHUPiVPD\RUWHQJRWDPELpQTXHGHGLFDUPHDO JUXSRFODVH\QRPHKDDIHFWDGRHVWR\RVpTXHHVXQSUREOHPDSDUDPtTXHQHFHVLWDUtD SXHVWHQHURWUDSHUVRQDGHDSR\R\DKRUDSXHVHVWR\HQFDQWDGDGHTXHYHQJDVW~TXH PHYDVDDSRUWDUPXFKDVFRVDV 0(VSHUR &<WHQJRJDQDVGHTXHHPSLHFHV+RPEUHW~«WRGDHVWDPDWHULDODFRQRFHV\RSDUD Pt WRGR HVWR HV PX\ QXHYR <R GHQWUR GH PLV OLPLWDFLRQHV SXHV \D KDV YLVWR TXH YR\ DGDSWDQGRODVVHVLRQHVSDUDTXHHOODSXHGDSDUWLFLSDU 0¢&yPRWHSODQWHDVGDUODVUHVSXHVWDVWDQWRODVQHFHVLGDGHVGHWRGRHOJUXSRFRPROD GHODDOXPQDFRQGLVFDSDFLGDGPRWUL]" &3XHVWHQJRTXHPLUDUVLHPSUHEXHQRSODQLILFDUPHODVHVLyQ\HQWRQFHVEXVFDUFRVDV GRQGHHOODSXHGDWDPELpQSXHVWUDEDMDUFRQHOJUXSR\VREUHWRGRTXHHOUHVWRGHOJUXSR QROHVDIHFWHPXFKRSRUTXHDYHFHVKD\UHFKD]RV¢QR"3RUTXHGLFHVEXHQRHVTXHW~ IDYRUHFHVDHVWDSHUVRQDSRU« 5 >VHFRUWDODFLQWD@ & &XDQGR HUD PiV SHTXHxD VLHPSUH GHFtD HV TXH W~ VLHPSUH HVWiV FRQ 0DUtD \ 5 QRVRWURVQR\QRVRWURVWDPELpQWHQHFHVLWDPRV0DUtDSXHVDHOODODVGLVWDQFLDVVHODV KDFHVPiVFRUWDVVHODVUHGXFHV«HQWRQFHV\ROHVPHQWDOL]DEDDHOORVOHVGHFtDTXH FODURTXHODVFRQGLFLRQHVTXHWLHQHQHOORVQRODVWLHQHHOOD\TXHSRUHVRVHOHVGDEDOD SHTXHxDYHQWDMDSHURTXHVHJ~QHQTXpRWURWLSRGHMXHJRVSXHVTXHQRTXHHOODWHQtD TXH SDUWLFLSDU LJXDO \ UHQGLU DO FRPR WRGRV <R OR TXH QR SRGtD HUD V~SHU SURWHJHUOD WDPSRFR SRUTXH HQWRQFHV QR OD HVWDED IRUPDQGR D HOOD SDUD TXH IXHUD XQD SHUVRQD DXWyQRPD TXH WXYLHUD XQRV« EXHQR TXH VXSLHUD YDORUDU ODV FXDOLGDGHV TXH WLHQHTXHWLHQHXQDGHILFLHQFLDSHURTXHHOUHVWRGHOFXHUSRORWLHQHGHPDUDYLOODRVHD VREUHWRGRODSDUWHLQWHOHFWXDOODSDUWHVXSHULRU¢QR" 05HDOL]DVDGDSWDFLRQHVFXUULFXODUHV" 5 &3XHVVt\RVLHPSUHWHQJRSHQGLHQWHVWRGRVORVFKDYDOHVTXHVpTXHVRQORVTXHPH WUDHQ XQ SRTXLWR FRQ OD FRVD GH SHQVDU TXH TXp SXHGR KDFHU SDUD TXH OD FODVH VHD EDVWDQWHKRPRJpQHDSDUDWRGRV 0<D¢SHURODVWLHQHVHVFULWDVRQRODVDGDSWDFLRQHV" &1RQR 0¢<QRKDVVROLFLWDGRQLQJXQDPRGLILFDFLyQGHOFXUUtFXOXP" &1R 0¢<SRUTXp" &3RUTXH\RGHQWURGHODSODQLILFDFLyQTXHKDJRGHWRGDVODVVHVLRQHVTXHKDQGHKDFHU \ GH WRGRV ORV FRQWHQLGRV SXHV HQWRQFHV OR KDJR SDUD WRGD OD FODVH SHUR WDPELpQ FRQWDQGRFRQHOORVOXHJRHOFDVRHVTXHQRORUHIOHMRDOOt 03HUR¢UHFLEHVDSR\RGHORVFRPSDxHURVGHOFHQWUR" 5 &3XHVWHYR\DVHUVLQFHUDQR 01R &1R(VWR\\RVROD<RVROD 0¢<TXpUHODFLyQWLHQHVFRQHOPDHVWURWXWRU" & %XHQDEXHQD<RPHUHODFLRQRELHQFRQWRGRHOPXQGRVLHPSUHTXHKD\DOJXQD« DGHPiV\RKDEORFRQWRGRVORVSURIHVRUHVHQFXDQWRDFDERODVDFWLYLGDGHVOHVGLJRWRGR ORTXHKHPRVKHFKRGyQGHKHLQFLGLGRPiVVREUHWRGRFXDQGRKDFHPRVMXHJRVDQLYHO GH PDWHPiWLFDV R GH FRPSUHQVLyQ RUDO R GH P~VLFD« <R SXHV KDEOR FRQ WRGR HO SURIHVRUDGR\OHVH[SOLFRSXHVORTXHKDJR\FXDQGRWHQJRTXHFRPHQWDUDOJXQDFRVD« VREUHWRGRGHFDUDDOILQDOGHFXUVRTXHVHKDFHORGHOIHVWLYDOJLPQiVWLFR(VWR\\RVROD SHUREXHQROHVH[SOLFRDHOORVWRGRORTXHYDPRVDKDFHU 01RTXHGDSRUWL¢QR" &6tVt 0¢4XpUHODFLyQWLHQHVFRQHOSVLFyORJRGHOFHQWUR" 5 &¢&RQpO"3XHVFXDQGRSDVDSRUDTXtSXHVVLHPSUHORFRMR¢QR"$TXHOORTXHORYDV SHOOL]FDQGR¢QR"3HURVHQWDUQRV\WHQHUXQFDUDDFDUDQRORKHPRVWHQLGRQXQFD&RVDV DVtGHSDVLOORV¢QR" 0<D¢5HFLEHVDOJ~QWLSRGHDSR\RGHOH[WHULRU" 5 &1R 0¢<FRQVLGHUDVTXHVHUtDQHFHVDULR" &<RSLHQVRTXHVt¢QR"/RVUHIXHU]RVVLHPSUHVRQEXHQRV¢QR" 0¢<TXLpQSLHQVDVTXHORGHEHUtDRIUHFHU" &6XSRQJRTXHHOHTXLSRGLUHFWLYRWHQGUtDTXHVROLFLWDUOR 0¢$GyQGH" & 3XHV«$XQTXHHOODORSLGHSDUDORV FKDYDOHV TXH OHVFXHVWDTXHWLHQHQSUREOHPDV $QWHVYHQtDXQDGHO(TXLSRGH$VHVRUDPLHQWR3VLFRSHGDJyJLFR($3SDUDXQDQLxDTXH WHQtDSUREOHPDVGHYLVLyQ 0<D &<HQWRQFHVSXHVYHQtDFDGDTXLQFHGtDVKDFtDHOVHJXLPLHQWRGHODQLxD\OHGDEDDO WXWRUSDXWDVGHFyPRWHQtDTXHWUDEDMDULQFOXVROHSXVLHURQXQDPHVDFRQVXODPSDULWD SDUDTXHWXYLHUDPiVOX]\DYHFHVYHQtDLQFOXVRDYHUFyPRODQLxDWUDEDMDEDGHQWURGH ODFODVHGH() 0<D<W~SLHQVDVTXHVHUtDQHFHVDULR¢QR"3HGLUXQDSR\RGHO($3 &<RFUHRTXHVtFODUR 0¢3ULQFLSDOPHQWHGHO($3" &'HO($3\GHQRVpTXpRWUDVHQWLGDGHVVHSXHGHFRQVHJXLU(VRPHORWLHQHVTXH GHFLUW~TXHHUHVODTXHHVWiVPHWLGDHQWRGRHVWR¢QR" 06tVt &0HWLHQHVTXHDVHVRUDU 0/RTXHKDJDIDOWD¢&RQVLGHUDVTXHWLHQHVODIRUPDFLyQQHFHVDULDSDUDSRGHUGDUOD 5 UHVSXHVWD HGXFDWLYD HILFD] D ODV QHFHVLGDGHV HGXFDWLYDV HVSHFLDOHV GHO DOXPQDGR FRQ GLVFDSDFLGDGPRWUL]" &<RSLHQVRTXHQR 0¢4XpQR" &4XHQRQRQR 0¢4XpQRODWLHQHV" &<RGLUtDTXHQRSRUTXH\RQRPHKHHVSHFLDOL]DGRHQHVR6LHPSUHSXHVPLUDGHQWUR GH OR TXH KH LGR REVHUYDQGR SXHV KH LGR DGDSWDQGR ¢QR" 3HUR HV XQD FRVD TXH PH WHQJR \R SODQWHDGD GH LU D KDFHU FXUVLOORV SDUD SRGHU WUDEDMDU FRQ QLxRV FRQ HVWDV QHFHVLGDGHV 0¢<GHKDFHU«GHLQVFULELUWHDDOJ~QFXUVRTXpWLSRVGHFRQWHQLGRVWHJXVWDUtDUHFLELU" 5 ¢&XiOHVVHUtDQWXVQHFHVLGDGHVIRUPDWLYDV" & 3XHV WRGR OR TXH VHD UHIHUHQWH GHQWUR GHO DXOD GH () &ODUR TXH HV OD SDUWH TXH LPSDUWR\R¢QR" 0¢()\GLVFDSDFLGDGPRWUL]"¢3RUFXUVRV" &6tUHFXUVRV 0¢3ULQFLSDOPHQWHUHFXUVRV" &5HFXUVRVFODUR 0¢3LHQVDVTXHHQJHQHUDOHVSRVLEOHODLQFOXVLyQGHODOXPQDGRFRQGLVFDSDFLGDGPRWUL] HQODVHVLyQHQODFODVHGH()" &([FOXVLyQQRSDUDQDGD 0/DLQFOXVLyQ &£$K/DLQFOXVLyQ6tVt\RORWHQJR 0(QJHQHUDOSLHQVDVTXHVt &6tSRUTXHHODxRSDVDGROD-HIDGH(VWXGLRVPHGLMRTXHKDEtDHVWDGRKDEODQGRFRQ HOLQVSHFWRU\TXHOHKDEtDGLFKRTXHFODURTXHHVWi0\0DUtDSXHVTXHHVWH« >VHFRUWDODFLQWD@ PHGLMHURQTXHHVWRVQLxRVSXHVDODKRUDGH()QRYHQGUtDQDPLDVLJQDWXUD(QWRQFHV 5 -HUDHOWXWRUGH0DUtDHODxRSDVDGR\VHORFRPHQWpOHGLMHHVXQDSHQDSRUTXHHV TXH0DUtDHVWiV~SHUPRWLYDGDOHHQFDQWDYHQLUDPLFODVHLQFOXVRFXDQGRPHOROOHYRD KDFHUHVDV-RUQDGDVD&DQ'UDJyDKDFHUDWOHWLVPRHOODVLHPSUHYLHQH£HK<SDUWLFLSD HQWRGRHOODQRVHFRUWD\SXHVVHORFRPHQWDPRVHQWUH-\\R\OHGLMLPRVDOD-HIDGH (VWXGLRVTXHYHtDPRVDEVXUGRTXHHVWRVQLxRVVHTXHGDUDQVLQKDFHUXQDDFWLYLGDGTXH OHV JXVWDED \ TXH OHV PRWLYDED SDUD WHQHUORV HQ XQD FODVH SXHV D UHIRU]DUOHV HQ PDWHPiWLFDVROHQJXDFXDQGRQRORQHFHVLWDEDQ\HQFDPELRHQHVWRVt<VHTXHGyDVt \HQWRQFHVFRQWLQXDURQYLQLHQGR\ELHQ2VHDTXHQROOHJDURQDH[FOXLUORVGHODFODVHVH KDEtDFRPHQWDGRSHURQRVHOOHJyDODSUiFWLFD0HMRU 0<D\D¢7~FRQVLGHUDVTXHODHVFXHODSHUPLWHGDUXQDUHVSXHVWDDODVQHFHVLGDGHV HGXFDWLYDVGHODOXPQDGRFRQGLVFDSDFLGDGPRWUL]HQHOiUHD" &6tVtVtVt 0¢6HGDXQDUHVSXHVWD" 5 & 6H GD XQD UHVSXHVWD \ DGHPiV WDPELpQ VH SUHRFXSDQ GH YHU FyPR YDQ« EXHQR VXSRQJRTXHVHSUHRFXSDQSRUTXHVR\\RODTXHWUDQVPLWRWRGRORTXHYDQKDFLHQGR\ FyPRYDQHYROXFLRQDQGR¢QR" 0¢0DWHULDODGDSWDGRWHKDFHIDOWD" &6tSRUTXHW~PHKDVFRPHQWDGRTXHKDVYLVWRKDVGHWHFWDGRTXH0DUtDVLWXYLHUDXQD VLOODGHUXHGDVSRGUtDKDFHUPXFKDVPiVFRVDVFRVDTXH\RQRPHKDEtDGDGRFXHQWD (V TXH OD PXOHWDV OH LPSLGHQ PXFKR SRUTXH VL ODV WLHQH TXH OOHYDU ODV GRV WLHQH TXH FRJHU XQD SHORWD WLHQH TXH FRJHU XQD PD]D WLHQH TXH FRJHU XQD SLFD \D OR YHV OR SULPHURTXHKDFHHVVHGHVKDFHGHODVPXOHWDV\VHSRQHSXHVGHURGLOODV 0¢<ODDFFHVLELOLGDGSLHQVDVTXHKD\SUREOHPDVGHDFFHVLELOLGDGSDUD0DUtD" &<RFUHRTXHQRQR 0¢3LHQVDVTXHWLHQHVDOJXQDJUDQGLILFXOWDGHQHOiUHDSDUDGDUODUHVSXHVWDD0DUtD" 'LUtDV³HVWDHVODJUDQGLILFXOWDGTXH\RPHHQFXHQWUR´RGLFHV³WDOFRPRHVWiODVLWXDFLyQ DFWXDO\R\DGR\UHVSXHVWD\QRHQFXHQWURJUDQGHVGLILFXOWDGHV´ &<RGHPRPHQWRYHRTXHQRSHURFRQORTXHW~PHKDVGLFKRGH«HVRPHWLHQHDPt PX\PDUFDGD\WHQJRJDQDVGHYHUGHYHU\RFUHRTXHVtTXHVHYDDSRGHUDGHODQWDU PXFKR 5 03HURDSULRULGLFHV« &1RQR 07DOFRPRGDVODUHVSXHVWD\DHVFRKHUHQWH\FRUUHFWD &6L\RGHPRPHQWR«FRKHUHQWH\FRUUHFWD\DGHPiVSRUTXHYHRODPRWLYDFLyQGHORV 5 QLxRVSRUTXH\RYHRTXHHVWiQPX\DJXVWRGHQWURGHPLFODVH\HQWRQFHVHVXQDFRVD TXHPHKDFHSHQVDUTXHWDQPDOQRORKDJR 0<QRQRHQDEVROXWRQRWHHTXLYRFDV¢&yPRDIHFWDDOJUXSRODPRYLOLGDGUHGXFLGD GHVXFRPSDxHUR" &(VR\DORHVWiVYLHQGRW~TXHHOORVHQUHDOLGDGQLOHVDIHFWDQLOHVGHVDIHFWDORTXH 5 SDVDTXHFXDQGRWLHQHQTXHEXVFDUJUXSRV\DYHVTXHDHOODHVOD~OWLPDTXHODHOLJHQ HVXQDSHUVRQDTXHHVWi\QRHVWiVHSXHGHGHFLUSUiFWLFDPHQWHFRPR\RQRPRQWRODV DFWLYLGDGHVGLULJLGDVVLQyHQWUHORVJUXSRV«DHOODQRODHOLJHQODGHMDQVLHPSUHSDUDHO ILQDO\DOILQDO 0 3HUR OD PRYLOLGDG UHGXFLGD GH HOOD ¢QR DIHFWD SDUD QDGD HQ OD PRWULFLGDG GH VXV FRPSDxHURV" & 1R SDUD QDGD SDUD QDGD SRUTXH ORV FRPSDxHURV LQFOXVR \D OR KDV YLVWR WX TXH HO WUDWR HV EXHQR1RHVTXHKD\DXQDJUDQ « V~SHU SURWHJHUOD R QR Vp FyPR WHSRGUtD GHFLUTXHODYDORUHQPXFKRQRODYDORUDQHVRKD\TXHVHUUHDOSDUDGDUQRVFXHQWDGH TXHQRSHURTXHWDPSRFROHVGLVWRUVLRQD<DORYHV 0<D\D &6LHVWiHVWi\\DHVWiVHDGDSWDQ 0 ¢3XHGHV YDORUDU OD SDUWLFLSDFLyQ GH OD DOXPQD FRQ GLVFDSDFLGDG HQ HVWH FDVR GH 5 0DUtD HQ OD VHVLyQ GH ()" 3RU HMHPSOR SDUD HPSH]DU ¢FXiO HV OD SHUVRQDOLGDG GH 0DUtD" &<RODYHRXQDSHUVRQDPX\FHUUDGDPX\SDVLYDH[WHULRUL]DSRFRVRODPHQWHFXDQGR HOODVHORHVWiSDVDQGRELHQVHUtH3HURSRUORJHQHUDOODSRVHGHHOODHVVHULD¢QR"HV XQD QLxD TXH \R FUHR TXH HVFRQGH PXFKR GHQWUR < TXH D OR PHMRU HVWDUtD ELHQ HO SVLFyORJRTXHOHKLFLHUDSXHVXQDEXHQDXQEXHQVHJXLPLHQWR\GHWHFWDUHOSUREOHPD<R HOSUREOHPDPHORLQWX\RSRUTXHORKHYLYLGRWRGRORGHHOODSHURQRFRPRWXWRUDSRUTXH \R QR KH VLGR QXQFD WXWRUD VXSRQJR TXH VL KXELHUD VLGR WXWRUD PH KXELHUD LPSOLFDGR PXFKRPiV 0¢<TXpSUREOHPDLQWX\HV" &3XHVHVRGHTXHHVXQDQLxDTXHDQLYHOIDPLOLDU«DKRUDQRVpFyPRHVWDUiSHUR\R 5 ORYHtDFXDQGRWHQtDODVGRVKHUPDQDVTXHVRQPiVPD\RUHVDKRUDHVWiQKDFLHQGROD (62\TXHFRQOD0DUtDQXQFDMXJDEDQDODKRUDGHOSDWLRVLHPSUHODWHQtDQGHODGR OHV HVWRUEDED'HVSXpVODDFWLWXGGHOSDGUH FXDQGR YHQtD D EXVFDUOD OD FRJtD FRPR VL IXHUDXQVDFR£$ODODVHQWDEDHQODPRWRQRHV«KDEtDXQDFDUHQFLDGHDIHFWLYLGDGDKt HQODIDPLOLD 0<D<HVRSLHQVDVTXHOHHVWiPDUFDQGR &(VRHVORTXHOHKDPDUFDGRDODQLxD<ODQLxDQRULQGHPiVSRUHVWR<RFUHRTXHHO SVLFyORJRWHQGUtDTXHKDFHUXQDEXHQDH[SORUDFLyQ¢HKTXHVt"<RFUHRTXHVt 0¢<DOJRPiVFRQUHVSHFWRDVXSHUVRQDOLGDGDGHVWDFDU" &<RFUHRTXHWRGRWRGRYLHQHGHDTXtWRGRYLHQHGHDTXtXQDYH]TXHODQLxDVXHOWH HVFXSDWRGRORTXHWLHQHGHQWURDORPHMRUUHDFFLRQD\FDPELDSRUFRPSOHWRSHURKD\ TXHWUDEDMDUSULPHURODSDUWHFRJQLWLYDGHHOOD 0 ¢4Xp GLUtDV GH OD DXWRQRPtD \ GH VXV GLILFXOWDGHV PRWULFHV" ¢/D FRQVLGHUDV 5 DXWyQRPD" & <R FUHR TXH SRGUtD VHU PXFKR PiV DXWyQRPD SHUR HOOD VH DSDODQFD OH JXVWD UH]DJDUVHHVTXHQRVHQRVHSRUTXHGHSHQGHWDPELpQGHFyPRYHQJDODQLxDVLOD QLxDYLHQHHVWLPXODGDSRUTXHWRGROHKDVDOLGRELHQHOODVLTXHVDEHVHVREUHHVIXHU]D SHURVLHVWiDOJROHKDVDOLGRPDOWRGRHVROHEDMD\ODDSDWtDIORUHFH 0'HORVKiELWRVKLJLpQLFRV¢TXpUHPDUFDUtDV" 5 &1RVHSRUTXH£DK8QDYH]TXHHPSHFHPRV 03RUTXHDKRUDQRVHGXFKD &$KRUDQRVHGXFKDQRSXHGRKDEODUGHDOJRSRUTXHQRORVp 09DOHYDOH &1RVpVLODQLxDVHGHVYLVWHVRODVLHOODORKDFHWRGRVLWLHQHXQDDXWRQRPtDSURSLDQR ORVp1RORVp 0¢5HVSHFWRDODVRFLDOL]DFLyQFRQVXVFRPSDxHURV"<DKDVDYDQ]DGRDQWHV« 5 &(OODHOODVHUHODFLRQDODSHQDHVTXHQRHVXQDQLxDOtGHU\HQWRQFHV«SHURSRUTXH HV PX\ FHUUDGD VL HOOD IXHUD PiV DELHUWD PiV FRPXQLFDWLYD \R FUHR TXH WHQGUtD PiV PiVDPLJRVORTXHOHIDOWDHVHVRDEULUVH 0<D\D¢<WLHQHSUREOHPDVGHLQWHUUHODFLyQFRQVXVFRPSDxHURV" &1RHOODVHDGDSWDDWRGRHOPXQGRSHURSRGUtDWHQHUPHMRUUHODFLyQ<TXHORVDPLJRV ODEXVFDUDQPiVSHURHVODIDOWDGHFRPXQLFDFLyQ\RODYHRTXHQRVpTXHOHFXHVWD\D YHVFXDQGRKDEODVFRQHOODDYHFHVWHKDEODHQPRQRVtODERVVtQRRWURVGtDVWHH[SOLFD XQ SRTXLWR PiV« GHSHQGH GH FyPR WHQJD HO GtD < \R FUHR TXH FRQ ORV FRPSDxHURV GHEHVHULJXDO 0&XiOHVODPRWLYDFLyQ«¢4XpSHUFLEHVHQFXDQWRDODPRWLYDFLyQDODFODVHGH()" &<RODYHRELHQQRVHVLW~WDPELpQWHKDVGDGRFXHQWD¢QR" 06tVt &6REUHWRGRHQODSDUWHGHMXHJRVTXHHOODSDUWLFLSDPXFKR\VHORSDVDSLSDDKRUD 5 VHJ~QTXHWLSR«FXDQGRKDFHQRWURWLSRGHDFWLYLGDGHVVLYHTXHOHFXHVWDHPSLH]D\ GHVSXpV HQVHJXLGD OR GHMD SRUTXH VH DEXUUH VH FDQVD 3HUR SRU OR GHPiV \R OD YHR ELHQ 0(QWRQFHVODDFWLWXGYDULDHQIXQFLyQGHODVGLILFXOWDGHV &&ODUR3RUHVR\RODVFODVHVODVWHQJRTXHKDFHUDGDSWDGDVSHQVDQGRHQHOODV\TXH VHDQPRWLYDQWHV\TXHHOODSXHGDSDUWLFLSDUDO 0¢$QWHTXpWLSRGHFRQWHQLGRVSUHVHQWDPD\RUGLILFXOWDG" &%XHQRSXHV¢FRQWHQLGRV"3XHVHQODSDUWHHQODTXHWHQJDTXHXWLOL]DUODVSLHUQDV TXHHVORTXHOHSULYDDHOODHVGHFLUHQORTXHQRVHSXHGHGHIHQGHU3RUTXHFXDQGR KDFHQ WUDEDMRV DVt GH FXDGUXSHGLD HOOD OR KDFH GH PDUDYLOOD QR QHFHVLWD FRORFDU ODV URGLOODV¢QR"SRUTXHVRQODVPDQRV\ORVSLHV<FRPRHOODWLHQHIXHU]DHQORVEUD]RV SXHV OR KDFH DKRUD FXDQGR WLHQH TXH KDFHU FDUUHUD GHSRUWHV VREUHWRGR SDUD ERWDU EDORQHV«\RFUHRTXHSDUDHOI~WEROQRWHQGUtDPXFKRSUREOHPD¢QR"1RVH 0¢0HFRPHQWDEDVDQWHVTXHFRQODVDFWLYLGDGHVPiVFRPSHWLWLYDV" &0iVFRPSHWLWLYDVVt7RGRORTXHVHDGHSRUWHV3RUTXHHQDWOHWLVPRUHODWLYDPHQWHHQ ORTXHHVODSDUWHGHODQ]DPLHQWRVHVROHFXHVWD/HFXHVWD7RGRORTXHWHQJDTXHHOOD DJXDQWDU WRGR HO SHVR \ DJXDQWDU HO HTXLOLEULR QR SXHGH HQWRQFHV FRQ XQ REMHWR VL HV SHVDGRQRORSXHGHKDFHU 0<D¢<FXDQGRPHGHFtDVGHORVDSDUDWRVFXDQGRYDLVODJLPQDVLR" &(OSRWURQRQRORVDOWD<HOODTXLHUHSRUTXHPLUDTXHVHHQIDGD\HOODTXLHUHKDFHUOR ³0DUtD « \R PH SRQJR´ EXHQR D YHFHV \R OD GHMR ³«PLUD V~EHWH FRPR SXHGDV QR OOHJDUiVDKDFHUORPLVPRTXHORVGHPiVSHURHVLJXDOW~LQWpQWDORKD]ORTXHSXHGDV´\ \DHVWi/DVHVSDOGHUDVOHHQFDQWDQSRUTXHHOODSXHGHKDFHUFDQWLGDGGHFRVDVHQODV HVSDOGHUDVHQORVEDQFRVVXHFRVWDPELpQSRUTXHKDJRPXFKDVYDULDFLRQHVGHFRVDV\ WDPELpQVREUHWRGRORTXHHVODSDUWHGHHTXLOLEULROHFRORFRXQDSHUVRQDDEDMRFRQODV SLHUQDV DELHUWDV \ HOOD OH VXMHWD GH ORV KRPEURV \ YD KDFLHQGR HTXLOLEULRV HQFLPD GHO EDQFR<GHPDUDYLOOD\HOODVHSRQHSXHVPLUDVHFUHFH<FODURQHFHVLWDXQDSR\R 0 <D \D \D /D SDUWLFLSDFLyQ \D PH KDV GLFKR YDUtD HV PiV DFWLYD R SDVLYD GHSHQGLHQGRGHOFRQWHQLGR &'HSHQGLHQGRGHOFRQWHQLGRVt 0 ¢< SDUWLFLSD HQ WRGDV ODV DFWLYLGDGHV H[WUDRUGLQDULDV TXH VH RUJDQL]DQ GHVGH OD 5 DVLJQDWXUDFRPRILQHVGHFXUVRILHVWDVVDOLGDVFRORQLDV«" & 6t %XHQR HQ ODV FRORQLDV QR OR Vp SRUTXH \R ODV FRORQLDV ODV WUDEDMR FRQ HO FLFOR VXSHULRUVXSRQJRTXHHVWHDxRVLKDFHPRV«\RVHORFRPHQWpDOD'LUHFWRUDDYHUVL SRGUtDPRVFRQVHJXLUGHTXH«PHQWDOL]DUDORVSDGUHVTXHHVWDQLxDYLQLHUDDKDFHUODV DFWLYLGDGHV GH DYHQWXUD TXH KDEtD HVWDGR KDEODQGR FRQWLJR \ TXH W~ PH KDEtDV GLFKR TXHFRQRFtDVDXQDSHUVRQDGHOD)HGHUDFLyQ>&DWDODQDGH'HSRUWHVSDUD0LQXVYiOLGRV )tVLFRV@ SDUD KDFHU ODV DGDSWDFLRQHV SDUD HOOD HQ HO PHV GH PD\R TXH HV FXDQGR WHQGUHPRVODVFRORQLDVTXHSXGLHUDYHQLU\PHGLMRTXHYDOHTXHHOOD\DORPLUDUtDPRV 2VHDTXH\RHQORVRWURVFXUVRVQRKHLGRGHFRORQLDVFXDQGRHUDSHTXHxDVtHOODIXH 5 HQ3HQSUHHVFRODU3\3IXLPRVDODVÈQIRUDV\VHORSDVyPX\ELHQ$KRUDDSDUWLU GHSULPHURKDVWDFXDUWRPHSDUHFHTXHQRKDKHFKRFRORQLDV 0¢4XpVRQODVÈQIRUDV" &ÈQIRUDV8QDFDVDGHSD\pVTXHHVWiQRPHDFXHUGRSRUGRQGHHQXQSXHEORQRV IXLPRVWUHVGtDV 0<HOODYLQR &(OODYLQRVtVt<VHORSDVyGHPDUDYLOOD3HURFODURtEDPRVDXQDFDVDJUDQMD 0<D &<HQWRQFHVSXHVDFWLYLGDGHV«\HOODSRUODPRQWDxDLEDFRQVXVPXOHWDV\WRGR,ED ELHQVtVt/RTXHSDVDHVTXHQRKDFtDPRVGHSRUWHVGHDYHQWXUD3XHVFDPLQDUKDFHU PDUFKDREVHUYDUODQDWXUDOH]DORVDQLPDOHVHLQFOXVRXQDJLPQFDQDTXHVHPRQWyHQ EXVFD GHOWHVRURSRUODQRFKHTXHLEDQ FRQ ODV OLQWHUQDV HOOD WDPELpQ OR KL]R%XVFDU SLVWDV¢QR"\OHHUORVPHQVDMHVTXHWHSRQtDQORVSLUDWDV\WRGRHVR 02VHDTXHHOODSDUWLFLSDEDDFWLYDPHQWH &6tSDUWLFLSyVtVt3HURGHSULPHURDFXDUWRPHSDUHFHTXHQRKDQKHFKRQLQJXQDV 5 FRORQLDV 0¢<DFWLYLGDGHVGHILQHVGHFXUVRILHVWDV«" & 6t ORV IHVWLYDOHV TXH PRQWR \R DTXt D ILQDO GH FXUVR 0DUtD VDOH VDOH \ HOOD HV OD 5 SULPHUDTXHPHGLFH³\RWDPELpQ£HK´6DOHVtVt'HVSXpVODPDHVWUDGHP~VLFDPRQWD WRGRORTXHHVHOIHVWLYDOGH6DQW-RUGLKDFHXQDHVSHFLHGHEDLOHV\WRGRHVR\0DUtD WDPELpQSDUWLFLSDRVHDTXHHVXQDQLxDTXHQRVHODH[FOX\HTXHSDUWLFLSDHQWRGR6t VtLJXDOLJXDOTXHHOUHVWRGH« 0¢<DOJRPiVDGHVWDFDUFRQUHVSHFWRDVXFRPSRUWDPLHQWRHQODVHVLyQGH()SDUD DPSOLDUPiVLQIRUPDFLyQ"2SLHQVDVTXH\DVHUHFRJHFRQ« &<RFUHRTXHFRQ« 0«FRQWRGRORTXHKDVGLFKRKDVWDHOPRPHQWR &«FRQWRGRORTXHWHKHGLFKR\DHVWiWRGR 0¢&XiOHVVXFRPSRUWDPLHQWRHQHOSDWLR" & ¢(Q HO SDWLR" £$\ <R OD YHR PX\ VROD 0X\ VROD PX\ VROD 3RUTXH HOOD WH OR KH FRPHQWDGRTXHVHVLHQWDHQXQULQFyQVHFRPHHOERFDGLOORREXVFD«ORTXHSDVDHV TXHFXDQGRDPLPHWRFDSDWLR\RVtTXHODOODPR\PHODOOHYRHLQFOXVROHGLJRDORV RWURVFRPSDxHURVSXHVTXHMXHJXHQFRQHOOD(OODWDPELpQHQLQYLHUQRHOIUtRFODURDOQR QR TXHUHU MXJDU R TXH ORV FRPSDxHURV QR OD YDQ D EXVFDU SRUTXH HOOD QR WLHQH OD VXILFLHQWHFDSDFLGDGGHLUDEXVFDUDORVFRPSDxHURV\GHEULQGDUVHGHMXJDUFRQHOORV SXHVVR\\RODTXHOHVGLJRDORVGHPiVTXHMXHJXHQFRQHOODHQLQYLHUQRFRQHOIUtRSXHV HOOD VH TXHGD HQ XQ ULQFRQFLWR \ QR KDFH QDGD (VR HV OR TXH WHQHPRV TXH WUDEDMDU PXFKRHVWHDxR(QODKRUDGHOSDWLRSRUTXHDKRUDPLUDHVWDPDxDQDKDQYHQLGR\DORV SLQWRUHVQRVYDQDSLQWDUXQDVFKDUUDQFDVXQDVQRUPDOHV\RWUDVHQHVSLUDOXQWUHVHQ UD\DDYHUSRUTXHTXLHURTXHPHMXHJXHQDOOtFRQSHUVRQDVKDFHUJUXSLWRVDODKRUDGHO SDWLR'HVSXpV\ROHVVDFRFXHUGDV\DORKDVYLVWRORVERORVXQRVFKDYDOHVMXHJDQD I~WERORWURVDEiVTXHWSDUDVHJXQGRWULPHVWUHTXLHURFDPELDUORGHOI~WEROSRUTXHVLQyVH SDVDQ WRGR HO DxR MXJDQGR DO I~WERO \ TXLHUR TXH PH WRTXHQ PiV GHSRUWHV TXH WUDEDMDPRV HQ OD FODVH GH () FRPR HV HO KRFNH\ HO EiVTXHW TXH WDPELpQ OR TXLWDUp SRUTXH\DORHVWiQWUDEDMDQGRHQHOSULPHUWULPHVWUHHOEiVTXHWHOKDQGEROHOKRFNH\\ HOYROH\DKRUDKHPRVFUHDGRODHVFXHODGHLQLFLDFLyQSHURVRODPHQWHVHKDQDSXQWDGR 5 GLH]FKDYDOHV<OXHJRORVPRQLWRUHVKDQPRQWDGRXQRVWDOOHUHVTXHHOORVGLFHQTXHHV PX\³FKXOL´SDUDGHVSXpVGH«QRVpDQWHVGHFRPHURSDUDGHVSXpVGHFRPHUQRVp HOORVQRVHTXLHUHQSHUGHUORVWDOOHUHV 0<D &<HQWRQFHVSXHVVRODPHQWHVHKDQDSXQWDGRGLH]FKDYDOHVXQDSHQD¢QR" 0<D\D3HURVXFRPSRUWDPLHQWRVXHOHVHUSDVLYRVLQRLQWHUYLHQHVW~¢QR" & 6L QR LQWHUYHQJR \R Vt <R OD YHR TXH HV HOOD TXH QR VH TXH OH IDOWD DUUDQFDU \ EULQGDUVHPiVTXHQRVHWLHQHTXHDSDODQFDU\SHQVDUTXHVHDQORVGHPiVORVTXHOD WHQJDQTXHEXVFDUSRUTXHSRUHVWDYtDQRORYDDFRQVHJXLU(OODVHWLHQHTXHEULQGDU\ EXVFDUFODUR 0¢<TXLpQWHLQIRUPySRU~OWLPRVREUHODSDWRORJtD\ODVFDUDFWHUtVWLFDVGHODOXPQDGR" 5 &$PLPHORFRPHQWyODWXWRUD 0/DWXWRUD &/DWXWRUDVtVtFXDQGRYLQR3RUTXHORVSDGUHVFRQPLJRQRPHKDQGLFKRQDGD³R\H TXHUHPRVKDEODUFRQODSURIHVRUDGH()\GHFLUOHSXHVHOGLDJQyVWLFRGHODQLxD¢QR"TXH HV OR TXH WLHQH´ <R SRUTXH PH LQWHUHVD VDEHU FyPR HVWi PL DOXPQD \ \R SXHV PH KH SUHRFXSDGRKHKDEODGRFRQORVWXWRUHVVLHPSUH 0<D\D &&ODUR 03HURIXHODWXWRUD &6tVtVtVt 0%XHQRDOJRPiVDGHVWDFDUR« &1RVpHVRORWLHQHVTXHGHFLUORW~DYHU 0%XHQRSXHVPXFKtVLPDVJUDFLDV¢9DOH" &(VSHURTXHWHKD\DUHVXHOWRDOJRFRQORTXHWHKHGLFKR 0&ODURTXHVt &$GHPiVFRPR\DKDEODPRVFDGDGtDW~\\R 0%XHQRSHURFRPRHVWRHVSDUDUHJLVWUDUOR &9DOH (175(9,67$$/&(1752 0$7XWRUDGH0DUtD )(&+$GHRFWXEUHGH 0 /D SULPHUD SUHJXQWD TXH WH IRUPXOR HV VL FUHHV TXH HV SRVLEOH OD LQFOXVLyQ GHO DOXPQDGRFRQGLVFDSDFLGDGPRWUL]HQODFODVHGH(GXFDFLyQ)tVLFD() 0$6tPHSDUHFHVLHPSUHTXHWHQJDQORVPHGLRV\ODVFRVDVSDUDTXHHVWDLQWHUDFFLyQ VHDSRVLEOH 0¢3HURW~QROHYHVGLILFXOWDGDSULRUL" 0$1RQR 0&RQVLGHUDVTXHHVSRVLEOH" 0$6tVtFODUR 06LHPSUH\FXDQGRKD\DORVPHGLRV¢\«" 0$%XHQRORVPHGLRV\ODFRVDVSDUDJDUDQWL]DUODEXHQDLQWHJUDFLyQ¢QR" 06t 0$ 4XH WRGR VHD TXH SRU HMHPSOR HQ HVWH FDVR 0DUtD SXHV SXHGD KDFHU WRGDV ODV FRVDV EXHQR TXH SXHGH KDFHU HQ VXV OtPLWHV TXH ODV KDJD ELHQ ¢QR" 1R Vp VL PH H[SOLFRELHQ 06t 0$%XHQRHVTXHHQFDVWHOODQRQRPHH[SOLFRWDQELHQ 01RWHSUHRFXSHV 0$(VPiVGLItFLO 0 ¢&RQVLGHUDV TXH OD VLWXDFLyQ DFWXDO GH HVWD HVFXHOD SHUPLWH GDU UHVSXHVWD D ODV QHFHVLGDGHVHGXFDWLYDVGHODOXPQDGRFRQGLVFDSDFLGDGPRWUL]HQODVVHVLRQHVGH()" ¢9HVGLILFXOWDGHVRQR"<VLYHVGLILFXOWDGHVTXpLQWHQWDUtDVPHMRUDU 0$$YHU\RWDPSRFRQR«VtTXHVpPiVRPHQRVTXpKDFHODPDHVWUDGH()ORTXH SDVDTXH\RWDPSRFRQRVpTXpPHGLRVWLHQHSDUDHVWRVFDVRVQRVpVLPHH[SOLFR3RU ORWDQWRWDPSRFRQRVpVL0DUtDVLJXHELHQODVFODVHVEXHQRVXSRQJRTXHVtSRUTXHOD PDHVWUD GH () VLQR PH FRPHQWDUtD DOJR 3HUR SRU HMHPSOR HQ HO WHPD GH OD GXFKD HO WHPD GH GXFKDUVH TXH HV XQ WHPD GH GHVSXpV SRU HMHPSOR ORV ODYDERV QR VRQ 5 DGHFXDGRVSDUDHOOD 0$GDSWDGRV" 0$6t\SRUHVWR\DFRQHOODKD\XQDSHTXHxDGLIHUHQFLDSRUTXHSRUHMHPSOR0DUtDQR 5 VHGXFKD<HVWDVFRVDV«FODURFRQORVPDWHULDOHV\RWUDVFRVDVTXHWLHQHODPDHVWUDGH () \R WDPSRFR QR OR Vp VL VRQ ORV PiV DGHFXDGRV R VL QR SRUTXH WDPSRFR \R QR Vp 5 WRGRVORVPDWHULDOHVTXHWLHQHSHURVXSRQJRTXHVtSRUTXH0DUtDYLHQHFRQWHQWDGH() QRKHWHQLGRHQORVTXLQFHGtDVTXHWDPSRFRKDFHVHPDQDVTXHKHHPSH]DGRHOFXUVR QRKHWHQLGRQLQJ~QSUREOHPDTXH0DUtDPHH[SOLTXHTXHQRKDSRGLGRKDFHUDOJRTXH Vt«<\RVXSRQJRTXHELHQ¢QR"TXHODVTXHQRWLHQHGLILFXOWDGHVSDUDKDFHUOR,QFOXVR FUHRTXHODPDHVWUDGH()FRPREXHQDSURIHVLRQDO\DORDGHFXD¢QR" 0<DSHURDTXtORTXHHVWDPRVUHFRJLHQGRVRODPHQWHHVODYLVLyQGHODWXWRUD 0$&ODURSHURXQDYLVLyQPX\OLPLWDGD 00X\OLPLWDGDSHURTXHFRPSOHPHQWDDODVTXHYR\UHFDEDQGR¢HQWLHQGHV" 0$6tVtVtVt 0¢&yPRSLHQVDVTXHDIHFWDODPRYLOLGDGUHGXFLGDGH0DUtDDOUHVWRGHOJUXSR"¢3XHGH DIHFWDURQR"¢&yPRORYHVFRPRWXWRUD" 0$ 1R QR (Q HO FDVR GH PRYLOLGDG HVSHFtILFD PRYLOLGDG QR /R TXH SDVD TXH 0DUtD 5 WLHQHXQFDUiFWHUTXHTXHHVGLItFLOHVPX\GLItFLO<RVXSRQJRTXHDFDXVDGHVXSRFD PRYLOLGDGORKDWUDVSDVDGRHQWRGRVORVDVSHFWRV<FRQHVWRVtTXHKD\SUREOHPDVSHUR FRQORRWURQR 0¢/DPRYLOLGDGUHGXFLGDQRDIHFWDDOUHVWRGHOJUXSR" 0$ 1R QR QR &ODUR WDPELpQ HV TXH VROR KDFH WUHV VHPDQDV TXH KD HPSH]DGR HO FXUVRVR\QXHYDSHURQRWLHQHQLQJ~QSUREOHPDQR 0¢3XHGHVYDORUDUODLQFOXVLyQGHODOXPQRGH0DUtDHQHVWHFDVRHQHODXOD"¢&XiOHV VXSHUVRQDOLGDG"7~\DPHDYDQ]DVTXHWDQVRORODWLHQHVKDFHTXLQFHGtDV 0$6tEXHQRGHVGHSULQFLSLRGHFXUVR 0/DOOHYDVGHVGHSULQFLSLRGHFXUVR 0$6tSHURFRQHVWHWLHPSR\D« 0¢7~FRQRFHVD«" 0$6tSHURODFRQRFtDSRFRODFRQRFtDGHSRUHMHPSORFXDQGRHVWDEDHQFXDUWRHOOD FXDQGRHVWDEDHQFXDUWR\RLEDDKDFHUUHIXHU]RFRQVXWXWRU 0<\DODFRQRFtDV 0$6t 00X\ELHQ 0$<PiVRPHQRV\DVpVtSRUGyQGHYDQORVWLURV 0(QWRQFHV¢TXpGLUtDVGHODSHUVRQDOLGDGGH0DUtD" 0$(VPX\LQIDQWLO 00X\LQIDQWLO 0$3HURPXFKR3DUDPtXQDFRVDH[DJHUDGD 0¢&yPR" 0$([DJHUDGD7DQWRHQODPDQHUDGHKDFHUFRPRHQODPDQHUDGHKDEODUTXHKDEOD 5 FRPR FRPR XQ QLxR SHTXHxR 1R HO YRFDEXODULR QR VLQR HO WRQR TXH XWLOL]D < DXWRQRPtDHVPX\OHQWDSHURDODKRUDGHHVFULELUFRQWRGRQRWHUPLQDQXQFDQXQFD ORVHMHUFLFLRVQRWHKDFHQXQFDORVGHEHUHV6HUiFRPRVLHOODGLMHUDSXHVFRPRWHQJR HVWDSRFDPRYLOLGDGSXHVWDPELpQPHGHMDUiQSDVDUTXHQRKDJDORVGHEHUHVRTXHQR KDJDODVFRVDV«<WLHQHVTXHHVWDUPXFKRPXFKRHQFLPDGHHOOD3HUR\RFUHRTXHGH PDQHUDH[DJHUDGD%XHQR\RQRVpVL«\RWDPSRFRKHWHQLGRHQWUHYLVWDFRQODIDPLOLD SHURQRVpVL0DUtDDSDUWHGHLUDOFHQWURTXHYDYDDXQSVLFyORJRRDDOJXQDFRVD 0$O]DODYR]SRUTXHVLQR« 0$9DOHSXHVFRPRQRKHKHFKRODHQWUHYLVWDFRQORVSDGUHVWDPSRFRVpVXVSDGUHV« 5 VpORTXHPHKDQFRQWDGRSRUTXHVLHPSUHKD\HOKLVWRULDOGHODOXPQRORTXHSDVDTXH WDPSRFRQRKHYLVWRQRPHKHHQWUHYLVWDGRFRQORVSDGUHVD~Q 0<D 0$<WDPSRFRQRVpPX\ELHQVXVSDGUHVFRPR«VLODPLPDQVLQRODPLPDQFyPROD WUDWDQ«WDPSRFRORVpTXpLGHDWLHQHQGHHOODWDPSRFRORVp0RWLYDFLyQ« 06t6RFLDOL]DFLyQ¢FyPRVHVRFLDOL]DHQHOJUXSR" 0$0X\SRFRWLHQHSRFDVDPLJDV<«VtSRFDV$GHPiVSRUHMHPSORSDUDWUDEDMDU 5 QDGLHTXLHUHLUFRQHOODSHURQRSRUTXH« 0¢(QHODXODWDPSRFR" 0$1RQR3HURQRSRUTXH«HVSRUTXHHVTXHQRKDFHQDGDQRKDFHQDGD\ODJHQWH \DORVDEHTXHSDUDWUDEDMDUSXHV«EXHQRFRPRQRHVXQDWUDEDMDGRUDSXHVVHUiPiV XQHVWRUERTXHGLJDPRVDVtTXHQRXQDD\XGD 0(QWLHQGR 0$<QRODTXLHUHQ3HURHVTXHHOODWDPELpQVHGDPXFKR£(K<RQRFXOSRDORVRWURV DOXPQRVQLDOXPQDV 0(OODSRQHVXJUDQLWRGHDUHQD¢QR" 0$*UDQRQRPXFKRHVTXH«SHURPXFKRPXFKRPXFKRPXFKR<FXDQGRKDEODV 5 FRQHOODWHGDVFXHQWDGHTXHQRTXHOHGDLJXDOKD\\RQRVp<PRWLYDFLyQVtODWLHQHV TXHDQLPDUPXFKRSHURFODUROOHJDXQPRPHQWRTXHVHDFDEDODSDFLHQFLD\HOODVtTXH HVWi PRWLYDGD SRU HMHPSOR FXDQGR KDFH ODV FRVDV Vt TXH WH GLFH ³SXHV PLUD KR\ KH KHFKRHVWR«´3HURHOODVDEHFXDQGRORKDFHELHQ\FXDQGRORKDFHPDOHK\RTXHVpD YHFHV FXDQGR WHQHPRV TXH KDFHU PXOWLSOLFDFLRQHV HOOD KDFH XQD \ QR TXLHUH TXH ORV RWURVORUHFRMDQSRUTXHVHGDUiQFXHQWDGHGHORPDOTXHORKDKHFKRHVWiFRPRPX\ SRFRPRWLYDGDVt 0(QWRQFHVGHVSUHQGRTXHVXDFWLWXGQRHVSRVLWLYDDQWHODVDFWLYLGDGHVGHHQVHxDQ]D DSUHQGL]DMH6XDFWLWXGHVPX\SDVLYD¢QR" 0$0X\SDVLYDVt 0¢<WLHQHGLILFXOWDGHVHQHOUHVWRGHODVDVLJQDWXUDV" 5 0$6t 0¢&RJQLWLYDV"¢2TXpRWURWLSRGHGLILFXOWDGHV" 0$3HURHVPiVSRUVX«QRQRQRWLHQHGLILFXOWDGHVFRJQLWLYDVSHURHVPiVSRUVX OHQWLWXG TXH QR WHUPLQD ODV FRVDV SHUR WLHQH XQD FRPSUHQVLyQ EXHQD 1R QR QR HV PDOD 0¢/HDIHFWDODPRYLOLGDGUHGXFLGDHQODVRFLDOL]DFLyQGHODVDFWLYLGDGHV" 0$6tSHURQRHV«QRHVSRUTXHWHQJDGLILFXOWDGHVFRJQLWLYDV 0'HFRPSUHQVLyQQR 0$1R\RFUHRTXHQRHVTXHWDPELpQHQTXLQFHGtDVTXHKHWHQLGRWDPSRFRQRKH SRGLGRREVHUYDUPXFKRSHURHVTXHHVWiDYHFHVHQ%DELD 0(Q%DELD 0$6tVtVt+D\TXHGHFLU³0DUtDHVSDELOD´ 5 07LHQHSUREOHPDVGHDWHQFLyQ 0$ 'H DWHQFLyQ PiV TXH FRJQLWLYRV GH DWHQFLyQ 3RUTXH ODV WDEODV GH PXOWLSOLFDU ODV VDEH\ODVGLYLVLRQHVODVKDFHELHQ\FXDQGRWLHQHTXHHVFULELUODVFRVDODVHVFULEH3HUR SDUDFRQWHVWDUWUHVSUHJXQWDVVHSXHGHWLUDUXQDKRUD3HURSRUTXHPHGLDKRUDVHHVWi PLUDQGRKDFLDRWURVLWLR³9D0DUtDHVSDELODYHQJD0DUtD´<FXHVWDPXFKR\FXDQGROH GLFHVXQDFRVDSXHVWDPELpQVHFLHUUD\QRWHKDEOD³0DUtD¢TXpSDVD"´<XQDFDUDGH HQIDGDGD\QRVp<RHVTXHLJXDOODFRQR]FRSRFR\PLUDQRVpSHUR«QRVp 0/DSDUWLFLSDFLyQ\DPHKDVGLFKRTXHVXHOHVHUPiVSDVLYD¢QR" 0$6t 03RUORTXHVHGHVSUHQGH« 0$6tHQODHVFXHODHQODFODVHTXHGLJDPRVVt3RUHMHPSORHQ()HQFRVDGHMXHJRV WDPSRFRORVp 0(QODFODVHQRPHLQWHUHVDHQODFODVH 0$(QODFODVHHQODFODVHVtVt 0<FODUR« 0$ 3HUR QR HV SRUTXH WDPSRFR ORV RWURV DOXPQRV OD GHVSUHFLHQ SRUTXH WHQJD HVWD 5 GLILFXOWDG£HK(VTXHQRDGHPiV0DUtDHVWiPX\LQWHJUDGDFRQHVWHFRQHVWH« 0*UXSR 0$ 6t Vt Vt (V PiV SRU HO WHPD TXH VDEHQ WRGRV TXH QR WUDEDMD GH TXH QR VH HVIXHU]D« HV PiV SRU HVWR TXH SRU RWUD FRVD HK" 3HUR OD WUDWDQ FRPR VL IXHUD RWUR DOXPQRPiVQRSRUTXHWHQJDGLILFXOWDGHVODGHVSUHFLDQQLQDGDQRWLHQHQDGDTXHYHU 0 3UHYpV HQ HVWH FXUVR TXH HOOD SDUWLFLSH GH DFWLYLGDGHV FRPSOHPHQWDULDV ILHVWDV VDOLGDV« 0$&ODURVtVt 03HURWHIDOWDQGDWRVSDUDGHVFULELUPHVXFRPSRUWDPLHQWRHQHVWDVDFWLYLGDGHVQR" 0$0HIDOWDQPXFKRVGDWRVVt 0'DWRV 0$ 3RU HMHPSOR Vp GDWRV GHO DxR SDVDGR 4XH HO WHPD GH VDOLGDV LED EDVWDQWH PDO SRUTXHQRYHQtDQQRYHQtDQ1RVpFRPRVHOODPDQ« 0/RVGHODDVRFLDFLyQGHSHUVRQDVFRQGLVFDSDFLGDGPRWUL] 0$6t 0(VTXHPHORKDDYDQ]DGRODGLUHFWRUD 0$ 1R YHQtDQ \ SRU HMHPSOR VX WXWRU HO DxR SDVDGR D YHFHV OD WHQtD TXH FDUJDU HQ EUD]RV FODUR \ \R HVWR QR OR KDUp HV TXH QR OR KDUp $GHPiV VX IDPLOLD WDPSRFR QR FRODERUD PXFKR FRQ HVWH WHPD /H SRQtDQ XQ FRFKHFLWR XQ FDUULWR GH QLxRV SHTXHxRV SDUDHOODHVTXH 0<D 0$&ODURWDPSRFRFRQR]FRPXFKRDVXIDPLOLDSHURPHGDODLPSUHVLyQGHTXH«QROD D\XGDQPXFKR 0¢<W~TXpSUHYpVSDUDHVWDVVDOLGDVGHHVWHDxR" 0$%XHQR\RTXHYHQJDQEXHQRXQRVGHHVWRVGHHVWDQRVpFRPRVHOODPDQ« 0/DDVRFLDFLyQGHSHUVRQDVFRQGLVFDSDFLGDGPRWUL]YROXQWDULRV 0$6tVtVt2VLQRSXHVTXHOHSRQJDQRWURPHGLRSHURHVTXH\RQRSRGUpFDUJDUFRQ 0DUtDHQORVEUD]RV(VTXHVLQR\RQRVpFyPRSRGUpKDFHUORQRORVp$GHPiVSXHV TXHVXIDPLOLDSXHVVHLQWHUHVHWDPELpQXQSRTXLWR\RTXHVp 03HURHVWiVSHQGLHQWHGHKDEODUFRQHOORV¢QR"3DUDVROXFLRQDUOR 0$ 6t FODUR Vt HVWR\ SHQGLHQWH %XHQR OD VROXFLyQ HV HVWD TXH GHVGH DTXt TXH VH SLGDQJHQWHGHHVWDIHGHUDFLyQRTXHWDPELpQVXVSDGUHVFRODERUHQXQSRTXLWRSRQLHQGR QRVpXQDVLOODRHVTXHQRVpWDPSRFRQRVpODVRSFLRQHVTXHKD\ 0(QWLHQGR 0$ 6L VLPSOHPHQWH HV SHGLU TXH YHQJDQ \ HV TXH HQ VHJ~Q TXH H[FXUVLRQHV KDEUi 5 DOJXLHQ SXHV \D HVWi VROXFLRQDGR SHUR SRU HMHPSOR HO DxR SDVDGR WDPELpQ DXQTXH YLQLHUD JHQWH OD WHQtDQ TXH DUUDVWUDU« HPSXMDU FRQ XQ FRFKHFLWR SHTXHxR \ 0DUtD HV GHPDVLDGR JUDQGH \ QR SRGtDQ WDPSRFR 3HUR VXV SDGUHV WDPSRFR QR SRQtDQ QLQJ~Q LQWHUpVGHTXHVXKLMDSXHVWXYLHUDHVWHSUREOHPD 0<D 0$¢6DEHV"<HVWRPHGDDPLXQSRFRGHPLHGRSRUTXHVpORTXHSDVyHODxRSDVDGR \RQRPHYR\DFDUJDUD0DUtDHVTXHQRSRGUp1RHVTXHQRTXLHUDHVTXH« 0(VTXHQRSXHGHV« 0$<WDPSRFRTXHQRFUHRTXHSDUDHOODVHDEHQHILFLRVRYHUTXHODHVWR\FDUJDQGR 0(QHOSDWLREXHQRGXUDQWHHOSRFRWLHPSRTXHODKDVSRGLGRREVHUYDU¢SXHGHVGDUPH PiVGDWRVGHFXiOHVVXFRPSRUWDPLHQWR" 0$(QHOSDWLRQRSRUTXHDGHPiV\RVLHPSUHHVWR\JXDUGDQGRORVSHTXHxRV\WDPSRFR HQHOSDWLRQR« 0$KQRWLHQHPiVGDWRV« 0$1RWHQJRPiVGDWRV 0<SRU~OWLPR¢TXpUHODFLyQPDQWLHQHVFRQODPDHVWUDGH()" 0$¢&RQUHVSHFWRGH0DUtD" 06tODYLQFXODFLyQFRQHOiUHDGH() 0$ %XHQRSRUHMHPSORHOODPHH[SOLFD WRGR OR TXH KDFHQ HQ()GHSDUWHGHWHRUtD\ 5 FRVDV GH HVWDV \ FRPSOHPHQWDPRV EDVWDQWH FRQ QDWXUDOHV /OHYDPRV XQD UHODFLyQ GH LQIRUPDFLyQ\HYLGHQWHPHQWHGHFRPSRUWDPLHQWRGHFyPRYDHOJUXSR\VLOHVYDELHQR QR«\FRVDVGHHVWDV 00X\ELHQ 0$)OXLGD 08QDUHODFLyQPX\IOXLGD 0$6tVtVt 03XHVPX\ELHQ 0$ 3HUR PH SUHRFXSD EDVWDQWH HO WHPD GH 0DUtD HK SRUTXH DGHPiV WDPSRFR QR Vp 5 FyPR FRJHUORQRORVp<QRSRUHOWHPDGHODPRYLOLGDGHKTXHQRTXHHVWRQRPH SUHRFXSDQDGDSHURQDGDHVHQHORWURWHPDTXHHVWiWDPELpQTXHODYHRFRPRPX\ GHVPRWLYDGD\\RWDPSRFRVpVLOHGR\PXFKDFDxDROHGR\SRFDRWHQJRTXHGHFLUOH ³0DUtD HVSDELOD PiV R PHQRV«´ ¢VDEHV" 2 GHFLUOH« HV TXH QR Vp QR OR Vp 6t \ WDPELpQ YHR TXH HO DOXPQDGR QR « PH SUHRFXSD PiV WDPELpQ HVWH DVSHFWR GH 0DUtD TXHQRHORWUR 0¢&yPRFyPR"¢(OUHVWRGHODOXPQDGR" 0$1RHOUHVWRGHODOXPQDGREXHQRGHODFODVHTXHOHSUHRFXSDPiVHODVSHFWRGH TXH0DUtDQRTXLHUDWUDEDMDUGHTXHVHDWDQOHQWDGHTXH« 0$SDWtD¢QR" 0$6tHVWDDSDWtDTXHQRORRWURSRUTXHDGHPiVVLHPSUHKDQVXELGRFRQHOODGHVGH SHTXHxRVHVWiQFRQHOODQRWLHQHQQLQJ~QSUREOHPDFRQHVWRVLODWLHQHQTXHD\XGDUOD D\XGDQ TXLHUR GHFLU TXH HQ HVWH SUREOHPD QR KD\ QLQJXQR (V PiV HQ HO RWUR HQ HO SHUVRQDOHQHOTXHVHFRPSRUWHFRPRXQDQLxDSHTXHxD\\DQRVpVLWDPELpQGHVGH FDVDKD\DOJ~QSUREOHPD\HVWRQRORVp 03UREDEOHPHQWH 0$6tVXSRQJRTXHVt 03HURQDGDHVJUDWXLWR 0$1RQRSHUREXHQR 0¢<DOJRPiVVREUHRUHVSHFWRD0DUtD" 0$1R 0<DORKDVGLFKRWRGR 0$6t\RFUHRTXHVt 03DUDGtDVTXHODWLHQHVYHRTXHWXDQiOLVLVFRLQFLGHFRQWRGDODLQIRUPDFLyQTXHKH LGR UHFDEDQGR Vt %XHQR SXHV PXFKtVLPDV JUDFLDV \ WH HQWUHYLVWR D ILQDOHV GH FXUVR FXDQGRKD\DVUHFDEDGRPiVGDWRVGHDFXHUGR" 0$0X\ELHQ (175(9,67$$/&(1752 )/3VLFyORJRGHO&HQWUR )(&+$GHGLFLHPEUHGH 0%XHQR)¢FUHHVTXHHVSRVLEOHODLQFOXVLyQGHDOXPQDGRFRQGLVFDSDFLGDGPRWUL]HQ ODFODVHGH(GXFDFLyQ)tVLFD()HQJHQHUDO" ) &UHR TXH QR VRODPHQWH HV SRVLEOH VLQR TXH WHQGUtD TXH VHU «R VHD QHFHVDULR WHQGUtD TXH VHU QHFHVDULR &RQ WRGR « YDPRV D YHU QR HVWDPRV TXL]iV QR HVWDPRV SUHSDUDGRV R PHQWDOL]DGRV SDUD LQFOXLUORV ¢QR" SDUD KDFHU OD LQFOXVLyQ ¢&XiQGR VH SXHGH KDFHU" 2 VHD QR KDEUtD QL TXH KDEODU GH HVWR SHUR \D TXH OR KDV SUHJXQWDGR SDUWLHQGRKR\GtDSDUWLHQGRGHXQRVEXHQRVGLDJQyVWLFRVHKGLIHUHQFLDOHVGHHVWHWLSR GH QLxRV FRQ HVWDV GLVFDSDFLGDGHV PRWULFHV \R FUHR TXH D SDUWLU GH DKt \ FRQ EXHQD SUHGLVSRVLFLyQ FUHR TXH HV V~SHU UHQWDEOH SDUD OD FRPXQLGDG SDUD ORV FRPSDxHURV \ SDUDHVDSHUVRQDHVXQDIRUPD\DGHYLGDGHVDOLUGHVXLQGLYLGXDOLGDG\VLQWRQL]DUFRQ VX« R VHD VX FXHUSR VLQWRQL]DU FRQ ORV GHPiV ¢QR" FRVDV TXH LQGLYLGXDOPHQWH pO QR SRGUtD KDFHU (OLPLQDQGR TXH QR VHD H[FHVLYDPHQWH FRPSHWLWLYR GLVHxDQGR ODV DFWLYLGDGHV TXH« FRPSHQVDGDV TXLHUR GHFLU TXH FRPSHQVHQ HVDV GLVFDSDFLGDGHV R TXHDSXQWDQHQHVHGLDJQyVWLFR0HQRVKDEODUPHQRVGHUDWRVLQGLYLGXDOHVHQVROLWDULR \ PiV GHQWUR GHO JUXSR <R FUHR TXH HV V~SHU UHQWDEOH \ REOLJDGR \ SRFR D SRFR HQ EUHYHWLHPSRKDEUtDTXHKDEODU\DGHRWURHVWLOR\DGHYLGD¢QR" <QRKDEODUGHLQFOXVLyQQLGHLQWHJUDFLyQQLGHWDOPiVTXHXQDIRUPDGHYLYLUHVXQD 5 IRUPDGHYLGD\VHSXHGHRVHDHVSRVLEOHHVSRVLEOH'LItFLOSHURSRVLEOHGLItFLOKR\ GtDGLItFLO 0<GLItFLOSULQFLSDOPHQWHSRUTXp" ) 3RUTXH TXL]iV ORV« HO SURIHVRUDGR QR HVWi SLHQVD R QR HVWi SUHSDUDGR R QR HVWi 5 PHQWDOL]DGR SDUD« HV GHFLU SDUD KDFHUVH FDUJR R UHVSRQVDELOL]DUVH GH HVWH WLSR GH GLVFDSDFLGDGHVPRWULFHV3LHQVDTXHHVROHVREUHSDVD\TXHQRHVFRVDGHHOORVKDVWD LQFOXVRTXHQRHVGHHOORV3RUORWDQWR\RWDPSRFRFUHRTXHVHDDUUHJODUXQFXUUtFXOXPR VHD SRU DGDSWDUOR \ WDO HV DOJR PiV TXH XQD DGDSWDFLyQ FXUULFXODU R VHD HV YLGD HV VDEHUFRORFDUHVGHFLUHOFXHUSRHQGLIHUHQWHVGLPHQVLRQHV\VHUFDSDFHVGHVHQWLU\FRQ ORVGHPiVWDPELpQFRVDVTXHHOORVVRORVQRSRGUtDQSHURHVGLItFLOHVGLItFLOSRUTXHHO SURIHVRUDGRQRHVWiTXL]iVWRGDYtDSUHSDUDGRFUHRTXHKD\TXHVHUPiVDWUHYLGRVQR VpVLHVWR\UHVSRQGLHQGR\DDDOJRTXHYLHQHOXHJR(OHTXLSRGLUHFWLYRQRVRODPHQWH\D ODHVFXHODVLQRTXHYLHQHGHPiVOHMRV¢QR" 06tDKRUDRUJDQL]DPRVODHVFXHODHQJHQHUDOQRODHVFXHODHQHVSHFtILFR )&ODURGHSHQGH\DGHODHVWUXFWXUDGHOLGHDULRGHODILORVRItD\WDO\\RFUHRTXHHQOD QXHVWUD KD\ XQD SUHGLVSRVLFLyQ SDUD LU SURJUHVDQGR SHUR QR VRODPHQWH D QLYHO GH LQFOXVLyQVRODPHQWHHQ()VLQRTXHVHDPiVWUDQVYHUVDOVLQRTXHVHD«TXHLPSOLTXH DVSHFWRV PiV IRUPDOHV HQ WDPELpQ HQ PDWHULDV R GLMHVHV PiV IRUPDOHV GHVGH PDWHPiWLFDV OHQJXDMH RWURV HVWLORV WDPELpQ ¢QR" 7DPELpQ DKt KD\ TXH« KD\ TXH DPSOLDUOR &UHRTXHODHVFXHODHVWiHQODOtQHDGH«HVWiWUDEDMDQGR\HVWiSUHGLVSRQLHQGRD« 5 0$KRUD\DWHUHILHUHVDODHVFXHODGH« )6tVtVt(QJHQHUDO« 0«GHWXFHQWUR )6tVtVt(QJHQHUDOKD\TXHVHUDWUHYLGRVGLVHxDUQRVRODPHQWHHOFXUUtFXORSRUHO 5 FXUUtFXOXPVLQRLGHDUHVRVGHUHFKRVRVHDORVPRPHQWRVHMHVWUDQVYHUVDOHVH[WHQGHUOR DODYLGDRVHDQRSDUDTXHSDVHDOQLxRDOOtGHyGHODPDxDQDDGHODWDUGHHV DOJRPiVTXHHVR(VDOJRPiVTXHHVR(QWRQFHVHVWRYLHQH\DGHODDGPLQLVWUDFLyQR VHD WHQGUi TXH OD HVFXHOD S~EOLFD R WDO KD\ TXH LU GHVFHQGLHQGR \R QR FRQR]FR VL D QLYHO«HVWRHVWiH[WHQGLGRPX\H[WHQGLGRRSRFRH[WHQGLGRSHUR\RFRQHOSURIHVRUDGR TXHKDEOR\WDOHVPX\«QRHVTXHVHDUHDFLRSLHQVDTXHDYHFHVQRHVSDSHOGHpO 0¢4XHQRHV" )4XHQRHVSDSHOIXQFLyQGHpO 0<D ) < HVWR HVWi FDPELDQGR HVWi FDPELDQGR \ VH HVWi PHQWDOL]DQGR GH TXH KD\ TXH FRQYLYLU \ GH TXH EXHQR TXH QR VRODPHQWH OD HVFXHOD HV OD YLGD HV OD YLGD GHVGH OD HGXFDFLyQ TXH FRQYLYH FRQ ORV DPLJRV HQ HO EDUULR TXH YD D OD HVFXHOD HWF HWF (QWRQFHVKD\TXHDGDSWDUPXFKDVFRVDV$TXtHVWiDSDUWLUGHXQRVPtQLPRV\RGLUtD TXH FRQWHPSOH D WRGRV \ TXH TXHGHQ FRQWHPSODGRV WRGRV \ PHQRV WLHPSR DVLODGRV WDQWRVLHVHQOHQJXDMHPDWHVRWDO\FRPSDUWLHQGRPiVWLHPSRFRQORVGHPiV(VWR« HV GLItFLO HV GLItFLO FODUR KD\ TXH PHQWDOL]DU DO SURIHVRUDGR \ HQ JHQHUDO GH ORV HWLTXHWDMHV&ODURDPiVGLILFXOWDGHVFODURSXHVPiVWLHPSRHQVROLWDULR $ PiV \R TXH Vp TXp HMHPSORV SRQHUWH SHUR TXH VH WUDWD GH GDU ODV D\XGDV VLHPSUH 5 FRPRDLVODGRVDOPDUJHQVHWLHQHTXH«KD\TXHTXLWDUHVRVHWLTXHWDMHV%XVFDUHVDV RSRUWXQLGDGHVTXHGDQDWRGRHOPXQGR2VHD\HQFRQFUHWRDHVWHWLSRGHQLxRV4Xp PiV HV TXH HO FHQWUR KD GH VHU PX\ FUHDWLYR HVWDV SHUVRQDV KDQ GH KDFHU R VXV FXUVLOORVR«\VL«\QRWDQWRGHSHQGHUGHHVSHFLDOLVWDVQRVpFRPRGHFLUWH 0<D ) <R HQ QXHVWUR FDVR \R GLUtD TXH QR HV TXH VHD SLRQHUD R QR HVWR OR FRQRFHUiV W~ PHMRUSHURSRUORPHQRVDPLPHVDWLVIDFHYHUTXHHVWiQDELHUWRV\TXHWLUDQDGHODQWH HVWHWLSRGHLQFOXVLyQ¢QR" 0 ¢< W~ SLHQVDV TXH HQ OD VLWXDFLyQ DFWXDO GH HVWH FHQWUR GD UHVSXHVWD D ODV QHFHVLGDGHVHGXFDWLYDVGHODOXPQRFRQGLVFDSDFLGDGPRWUL]HQODVVHVLRQHVGH()" )<RFUHRTXHKDQVLGR«YDPRVDYHUHVWiQVLHQGRFRQVFLHQWHVTXL]iVPiVDKRUDPiV SUHGLVSXHVWRVPiVSUHGLVSXHVWRVSRUTXHDQWHVVtVHHFKDEDPDQRGHOFXUUtFXOXPGHO GLVHxR FXUULFXODU GH QLxRV FRQ HVWH WLSR GH GLVFDSDFLGDGHV \ EXHQR SXHV LJXDO KDEUtD TXHKDFHUXQFXUUtFXOXPDGDSWDGR\TXLpQORKDFH\FyPRVHKDFH«\FODURHVWRYD SDVDQGR HO WLHPSR HO WLHPSR HO WLHPSR \ YHPRV TXH TXL]iV QR KD\ TXH« LJXDO HVR VXSRQHVHJUHJDUDFHSWDU«QR\VHHVWiGDQGRFXHQWDTXHFRQORVLJXDOHV\HVWRSRUOR PHQRVHQORTXHHVWR\YLHQGR 0¢<HQQXHVWURFHQWUR" )(QQXHVWURFHQWUR 0(QSDUWLFXODU )(VWRTXHGDUHVSXHVWDVLQHVWDUHVSHUDQGRDKDFHUXQDDGDSWDFLyQFXUULFXODUHVWi GDQGR UHVSXHVWD \ FUHR TXH \D D SDUWLU GH DTXt VH SXHGH H[WUDSRODU \ JHQHUDOL]DU DFWXDFLRQHV 0¢<FRQORVGDWRVTXHW~WLHQHVTXpGLILFXOWDGHVREVHUYDVHQODLQFOXVLyQGHODDOXPQR FRQGLVFDSDFLGDGPRWUL]"2FXiOHVVHUtDQWXVSURSXHVWDVGHPHMRUD )3XHVORTXH«YDPRVDYHU\RODVSURSXHVWDGHPHMRUD\RGLUtDTXHLUtDQ«UHVSHWDU SRUHMHPSORHQSULQFLSLRHVDLQGLYLGXDOLGDGIRUPDFLyQGHOSURIHVRUDGRGHOSURIHVRUDGR RVHDDOHQWDUORVHOHIHFWRHVHGHODVHWLTXHWDVTXpSDVDTXHVL\DSDUWHQGHTXHVLHO QLxRRQLxDWDO«\DHVSHUDQPHQRVODVH[SHFWDWLYDVEDMDQ 0%DMDQVt )%DMDQ(OHQFXDGUHGHODVUHVSXHVWDVHOLPLQDUGLFH³DXQQLxRGLIHUHQWH´DYHFHVVH 5 HOLPLQD ³D XQ QLxR GLIHUHQWH HQVHxDQ]D GLIHUHQWH´ 2 VHD HVRV HWLTXHWDMHV KD\ TXH LU HOLPLQiQGRORVELHQGHVGHODDGPLQLVWUDFLyQRELHQGHVGHHOFHQWURHVWRKD\TXH«HVR VHUtDQ SURSXHVWDV ¢QR" /D OLPLWDFLyQ GH ODV RSRUWXQLGDGHV R VHD IDYRUHFHU ¢QR" HVDV RSRUWXQLGDGHVPHMRUDSUHQGHUFRQORVGHPiV\QRWDQWRVRORVTXHHVKDVWDKDFHSRFR HQ JHQHUDO VH YD KDFLHQGR VH YD KDFLHQGR (O HPSOHR GH UHFXUVRV OD DXWRULGDG GH OD GLUHFFLyQ VL FUHH EXHQR TXH HVWR VH WLHQH TXH SRQHU HQ PDUFKD DXQTXH YD\DPRV GHVIDVDGRVRVHLQLFLHSXHVKD\TXHLQLFLDUORDPELHQWHRUGHQDGRVDQR 0¢SHURSLHQVDVTXHQRVHGDHODPELHQWH" )4XLHURGHFLUTXHVHKDGHIDYRUHFHU 0$KVHKDGHIDYRUHFHU )6HKDGHIDYRUHFHUPXFKRWRGRHVWRGHVGHODGLUHFFLyQTXHFUHRTXHDKtHVWHHTXLSR 5 GLUHFWLYR WLHQH ODV LGHDV PX\ FODUDV HQ FRPR DWLHQGH D OD GLYHUVLGDG GHVGH DJUXSDFLRQHVPH]FODVPH]FODGRV\WDOEXHQRVGLDJQyVWLFRVGHVGHEXHQRLUSDVDQGR DDOHQWDUDORVSURIHVRUHVTXHWRPHQFRQFLHQFLD¢QR"TXHHVRVHVWLORVDOJXQRVHVWLORV HVWiQ\DFDGXFRV¢QR" 06t )4XHORTXHKDFHQDYHFHVHVVHJUHJDUPiV 06tVt )(WLTXHWDUPiVPHQRVH[SHFWDWLYDVORTXHGHFtDPRV\WDO\OLVWR3HURSDUDHVRKD\ TXH IDYRUHFHU PHGLRV WDPELpQ /R PLVPR TXH DKRUD SRU HMHPSOR VL KD\ EXHQD SUHGLVSRVLFLyQEXHQDDUPRQtD\EXHQDSUHSDUDFLyQVLWHYLHQHXQHVSHFLDOLVWDFRPRW~ SXHGHVVHUORFRQ« 0&RQ0DUtD" )1RFRQODPDHVWUDGH()HVWiFRPRHVWiUHFHSWLYDHVWDSHUVRQDYDDFRJHUOXHJR XQDDXWRQRPtDSDUDGLVHxDUVXVFODVHVHMHUFLFLRVEDMDUDORVQLxRVTXHWHQJDTXHEDMDU HK«VDEHULQWHUSUHWDUSXHVODVLQGLFDFLRQHVGHORVHVSHFLDOLVWDVRGHORVGLDJQyVWLFRVTXH KD\\WDOSUHYHUVHFXHODVHWFHWF<OXHJRLUPHWLHQGRQRVRODPHQWHTXHVtTXHKD\ VLQRLUSDVDQGRDODVDXODVWDPELpQDDVSHFWRVPiVIRUPDOHVWDPELpQ 1R DTXt \R« EXHQR QR Vp \R FUHR TXH KD\ WDUHDV SRU DKt TXH VHDQ UHDOLVWDV 5 SURYRFDGRUDV\RSDUDPLORSULQFLSDOHVVLQWRQL]DUHTXLSRVGLUHFWLYRVFRQHOSURIHVRUDGR VLQWRQL]DUSUHGLVSRQHUORV\DQLPDU\TXHREVHUYHQSXHVQRVpHVWHWLSRGHYHQWDMDVTXH KD\ 2 VHD TXH QR YD\DPRV HQ OD OtQHD GH OD LQWHJUDFLyQ R VHD GH PHWHU QLxRV TXH HVWDEDQVHJUHJDGRVDYHUTXpSDVD¢QR" 0<D )<DSDUWHODVFRVDVDSDUWHQRHVRQRFUHRTXHVHDYLGD« 0¢4XpUHODFLyQWLHQHVFRQODPDHVWUDGH()" )3XHV\RGLUtDXQDUHODFLyQ\DV~SHUHVWUHFKD\WDOSHUR\RGLUtDDQLYHOSURIHVLRQDO 5 TXHHVWDHVODFXHVWLyQ\RGLUtDTXHPiVTXHFRUUHFWDPiVTXHFRUUHFWD3RUTXHFXDQGR QRVLQWHUHVDSXHVREVHUYDUDXQQLxRWLHQHVODVSXHUWDVDELHUWDVIDFLOLWDWHIDFLOLWDWRGDOD LQIRUPDFLyQ TXH W~ OH SXHGDV SHGLU WH DQWLFLSD FRQGXFWDV R FRPSRUWDPLHQWRV HQ TXp PRPHQWRVSXHGHFRODERUDUPiVRSXHGHFRODERUDUPHQRVFRQTXLpQHVFXiOHVVRQVXV GHPDQGDVVLOHKDFHVDOJXQDLQGLFDFLyQ³QRVLQWHUHVDSXHVHVWHQLxRTXHVHOHWUDEDMH SXHV XQD FRRUGLQDFLyQ SLHVPDQRV R«´ HQ ILQ HOOD HVWi WRWDOPHQWH UHFHSWLYD TXLHUR GHFLUTXHHVXQDSURIHVLRQDOPX\DELHUWD\TXHHOHQWHQGLPLHQWR\FRRUGLQDFLyQHVPXWXR 0 ¢3HUR WHQpLV DOJXQD HVWUXFWXUD GH FRRUGLQDFLyQ RV YDLV UHXQLHQGR PHQVXDOPHQWH R SRUODQHFHVLGDGHVTXHVXUJHQ" )1RQRVHJ~QORVGtDVHVWRHVXQDGHODVFRVDVTXH«HOODFDGDYH]EXHQRSRUOR PHQRV GHVGH HO HTXLSR GLUHFWLYR FXDQGR QRV UHXQLPRV PiV TXH QDGD FRQ OD -HID GH (VWXGLRV\WDOSXHVVLHPSUHHVTXHFDGDYH]VHYDHQIDWL]DQGRPiVTXH«HVGHFLUODV DFWLYLGDGHV GH () VRQ IDYRUHFHGRUDV QR VRODPHQWH GH LQWHJUDFLyQ \ WDO VLQR GH SUHGLVSRQHU DO QLxR D FRJHU PD\RU DXWRQRPtD PD\RU QLYHO GH FRQFHQWUDFLyQ GH VXSHUDFLyQHWFHWF\TXHSRWHQFLDQGRXQDVHULHGHHMHUFLFLRVELHQVLQFURQL]DGRVELHQ SURJUDPDGRV SXHGHQ HOLPLQDU OXHJR VHFXHODV LQFOXVR GH FDUD D ORV DSUHQGL]DMHV \ WDO HQWRQFHVFDGDYH]VHHVWiWUDEDMDQGRPiV<HVDWUDYpVGHOHTXLSRGLUHFWLYRRFXDQGR KDFHQ VXV UHXQLRQHV TXH HOOD \D VH HQFDUJD GH WUDQVPLWLU FXDQGR KDFHQ ODV UHXQLRQHV GH« 0<D )6tVtSXHVHOYDORUGHVGHHODXODHQODSLVFLQDGHVGHHOWLSRGHHMHUFLFLRVTXHKDFHQ OD SURIHVRUD GH () TXH QR VRQ HMHUFLFLRV« ORV FOiVLFRV TXL]iV VLQR TXH KD\ XQD YDULHGDG\RFUHRTXHKD\XQDYDULHGDGGHHMHUFLFLRVPX\ULFRVFDSDFHVGHVDFDUDORV QLxRV XQ SRFR IXHUD GH Vt PLVPRV R VHD TXH VDOJDQ D FRPSDUWLU HO HVSDFLR HO iPELWR VRFLDO 06tVt )(VRHVPX\«QRVHHVWR\RQRVR\HOTXHGLQDPL]D\WDOHVFXDQGRKDEODPRVLQFOXVR FRQHOLQVSHFWRUeOHVHOTXHFUHHPiVTXHQDGLHHQHVWRWDPELpQ<\RVLHPSUHGHILHQGR HVDODLQWHOLJHQFLDDWUDYpVGHOPRYLPLHQWR\WRGRHVWRVHYDWUDQVPLWLHQGRSRFRDSRFR HQODPHGLGDTXHHOHTXLSRGLUHFWLYRYDYLHQGRTXHVHSXHGHLQFOXLU\HVDSHUVRQDHVPX\ UHFHSWLYDSXHVVHYDQGLVHxDQGR\GHKHFKRQRVHOLPLWDQDKDFHUODVFOiVLFDVRHVWH WLSRGHDFWLYLGDGHV« 06HQVLELOL]DGRUDV ) 6HQVLELOL]DGRUDV \ WDO \R FUHR TXH HVWDPRV HQ OtQHD &UHR \ FRQWDPRV FRQ XQD SURIHVRUD TXH \R FUHR TXH HV YDPRV HQFDQWDGRUD 4XH QR OH LPSRUWD« HV TXH HV UHFHSWLYDHVTXHORYLYHHVTXHORYLYH 06tVtVt )(VTXHORYLYH\HQWRQFHVSXHVEXHQRVLVHWLHQHTXHUHFLFODUVHUHFLFODVLWLHQHTXH 5 HVFXFKDU\WDOSXHVHVFXFKD<TXHWLHQH\DXQEDJDMH\DGHLQVWUXPHQWRV\PHGLRVPX\ ULFR 0 (QWRQFHV D YHU \R GHGX]FR TXH W~ KDELWXDOPHQWH WH VXHOHV UHXQLU FRQ HO HTXLSR GLUHFWLYR\HVHOHTXLSRGLUHFWLYRTXHHOTXHGLVSHUVDODLQIRUPDFLyQDORVHVSHFLDOLVWDV )6tVtVREUHWRGR\RPHUH~QRPiVFRQOD-HIDGH(VWXGLRV 0<D ) 6REUHWRGR OR TXH FRQFLHUQH D OD RULHQWDFLyQ HFKDU XQ YLVWD]R \ VHJXLPLHQWR GH ORV QLxRV TXH SUHRFXSDQ ¢QR" ELHQ SRUTXH KD\ SUREOHPDV GH QR Vp GH DSUHQGL]DMH R GH FHORVRGHHQILQGHKiELWRV«ORTXHHVWiSDVDQGRRSUREOHPDVGHWLSRHPRFLRQDOTXH TXHGDQ EORTXHDGRV TXH HVWiQ SXHV XQ SRTXLWR GHVFRQWH[WXDOL]DGRV TXH HVWiQ SDViQGRORPDOTXHVXIUHQ\EXHQRSXHVDUDt]GHWRGRHVWRSXHVYDVDOLHQGR«VDOHQ HVWRVWHPDV 0<D )<VREUHWRGRDTXHOORVQLxRVTXHSUHVHQWDQXQDVGLVFDSDFLGDGHVRXQDVFDSDFLGDGHV LQIHULRUHV D« SXHV KD\ TXH SRQHUORV VREUH OD PHVD KD\ TXH FRPHQWDU ¢QR" 2 VL KD\ TXHKDFHUDOJXQDDGDSWDFLyQR«EXHQRVLPSOHPHQWHXQDPRGLILFDFLyQGHDOJXQDVFRVDV ¢QR"<HQHVWRVFDVRVVDOLyHOWHPDSRUHMHPSORGH0DUtDGH0LJXHO>RWURQLxRGHOFHQWUR TXHSUHVHQWDPRYLOLGDGUHGXFLGD±HVSLQDEtILGD@\\DQRKHPRVYXHOWRDWRFDUORSRUTXH VHHVWiOOHYDQGRDFDERDWUDYpVGHHVWDH[SHULHQFLDEXHQRVHHVWiGDQGRUHVSXHVWD\ ODPLVPDQLxDRGLFH³DQWHVKDFtDDOJXQDFRVD\VLQRSXHVPHTXHGDEDVRODR«\DKRUD KD\ DOJXQDV FRVDV TXH QR PH JXVWDQ´ OR GLFH ELHQ FODUR SHUR HOOD SUHILHUH HVWDU FRQ HO JUXSR 0<D\D )/XHJRHVWiPX\DWHQGLGDDQLYHORVHDGHOFHQWURGHUHKDELOLWDFLyQHVWDHVODQLxDTXH WLHQH GLVJHQHVLDQHXURQDOEXHQRSXHVHVWiDWHQGLGD\OHGDQORVHMHUFLFLRVHVSHFtILFRV TXHWLHQHTXHKDFHUUHIXHU]RGHDXWRHVWLPDFRQYLYHWDPELpQFRQVXVLJXDOHV 0<D¢(QWRQFHVWHSDUHFHTXHSDVHPRV\DDKDEODUGHOFDVRGH0DUtD" ) 6t 3RU VXSXHVWR DKRUD VL W~ TXLHUHV KDFHU XQD VtQWHVLV GH OR TXH \R KH SRGLGR H[SOLFDUDORPHMRUGHIRUPDXQSRFRGHVRUGHQDGDGLFLHQGR³R\H)\RKHHQWHQGLGRHQ HVWHSXQWRWDOFRVD¢WHSDUHFHDVt\WDORTXp"´RVDFDVWXVSURSLDVFRQFOXVLRQHV« 01RQRVLHUHVPX\H[SOtFLWR )%XHQRSHUROXHJRDODKRUDGHUHGDFWDU\WDOWHHQFRQWUDUiVTXHQRVKHPRVLGRGHXQ VLWLRDRWUR 0(VKDELWXDOHQWRGDVODVHQWUHYLVWDV )¢6L"QRHVWR\IDPLOLDUL]DGR« 01RUPDOPHQWHVHHVUHGXQGDQWH+DVUHGXQGDGRFRQODSUHJXQWDQ~PHURFXDWURKDV UHGXQGDGRODSUHJXQWDQ~PHURGRV )(VTXH\DWHGLJRODSUHJXQWDLQFOXVLyQQRHVTXH\RWHGLJD« 0<DWHYLHORWURGtDHOOLEURGH$LQVFRZ )«HVTXH\DQRKDEUtDTXHKDEODUGH« 0<D ) (V TXH HV XQD IRUPD GH YLYLU GH YLYLU MXQWRV HV TXH HQFRJH QR VROR OD HVFXHOD HO 5 EDUULRODFRPXQLGDGHVTXH«HVTXHHVPX\DPSOLR 06tVt ) < TXH VHD EXHQR TXH QRV KHPRV GH HGXFDU WRGRV FODUR HO SURIHVRUDGR QRV HVWi SLOODQGRDYHFHVGHLPSURYLVR³6L\RQRHVWR\SUHSDUDGRVL\RQRHVWR\WDO´FODURHVTXH HQWUDPRVHQXQDOtQHDGHVHJUHJDFLyQ¢QR"/RVOLVWRVHVWXSHQGRORVTXHIXQFLRQDQ\ ORV RWURV ¢4Xp" %XHQR \D« DVt \D HPSLH]D D KDEHU XQ KRUPLJXHR HQ OD FRPXQLGDG HGXFDWLYDFDGDYH]PiVHK\FXDQGRKD\QLxRVSRUHMHPSOR\DQRGHGLVFDSDFLGDGHV[ LQFOXVR FRQGXFWXDOHV ³$K HVR QR HV« SXHV KDEUi TXH VDFDUORV TXH SUHSDUHQ XQRV FHQWURVHVSHFLDOHVSDUDHOORVWLSR8(&VTXHVHKDQLGRFUHDQGRSRUDKtFRQGXFWXDOHV QR Vp TXp QR Vp FXDQWRV«´ < DKRUD SXHV VH WUDWD \ HQWRQFHV TXp SDVD SXHV TXH HO UpJLPHQLQWHUQRGHGLVFLSOLQDSXHVQRIXQFLRQDQRGDODUHVSXHVWDKDEUiTXHPRGLILFDU DOJR D QLYHO GH LQVWLWXFLyQ WDPELpQ GDU UHVSXHVWDV HK HVWR SXHGH VHUYLU SDUD« SHUR SDUD HVWR YDPRV D YHU HO SRUTXp GH HVWRV FRPSRUWDPLHQWRV ³2\H W~ OD KDFHV W~ OD SDJDV´ 1R SXHV YDPRV D YHU SRUTXH HQ HVWRV FDVRV PHMRU KDEODU FRQ OD IDPLOLD HGXFDUORV HO FHQWUR SXHV WLHQH XQRV PHGLDGRUHV KD\ XQRV DVLVWHQWHV VRFLDOHV FRPSUHQGHPRVODUHDOLGDGGHOFKDYDOTXHVHYHDDFHSWDGRFRPSUHQGLGRHWFHWFLJXDO HVWiKDFLHQGRXQDVSURWHVWDVFRQWUDLQVWLWXFLyQRFRQWUDHOPHGLRFRQWUDODIDPLOLDHWF (QWRQFHVSRFRDSRFRHOSURIHVRUDGRWDPELpQ\DFDPELDHPSLH]D³7~WHFDOODV´1RD VDFDUORKDEODPRV\DVHHPSLH]DDFDPELDU 0<D ) 3RU OR PHQRV HQ HVWH WHUUHQR HPSH]DPRV DKRUD D FDPELDU HPSH]DPRV SHUR KD\ PXFKRTXHUHFRUUHUPXFKRTXHUHFRUUHU%LHQDKRUD 0%XHQRVLWHSDUHFHSDVDPRVDYDORUDUDVSHFWRVGH0DUtD¢&XiOHVVXSHUVRQDOLGDG" 5 )<RGLUtDTXHHVWDQLxDYDPRVDYHUDQLYHOGHHVWUXFWXUDGHSHUVRQDOLGDGVXEtDFRQ XQD SHUVRQDOLGDG HVWUXFWXUDGD \R GLUtD FRQ HTXLOLEULR IXHUWH SHUR D PHGLGD TXH KD LGR FUHFLHQGRGHVGHTXH\ROD«FXDQGR\RODFRQRFtIXHHQVHJXQGRWHUFHURGHSULPDULD HOOD HPSLH]D D GDUVH FXHQWD GH VXV GH VX GLVFDSDFLGDG \ OR YLYH R VHD HPSLH]D D GHELOLWDUVHDQWHHVDUHDOLGDG(PSLH]DDVHULQYDGLGDDVHULQYDGLGDSRUODVGLIHUHQFLDV TXHHOODHPSLH]DDQRWDU3DUWLHQGRGHOiPELWRIDPLOLDUFRQUHVSHFWRDODVKHUPDQDV\ HOODHOWUDWRGLIHUHQFLDGRUHOODVHHQFXHQWUDTXHHVWiHQGHVYHQWDMDFRQUHVSHFWRDODV KHUPDQDV HOODV YDQ D FRPHU D FDVD SHUR HOOD FRPR YD HQ PXOHWDV HWF HWF HV XQD PROHVWLD QR SXHGH LU VHWLHQHTXHTXHGDU DTXt (VWR XQ GtD OR KD SRGLGR YLYLU QRUPDO SHUR KD LGRPLQiQGROD(PSLH]DDGHELOLWDUVHHPRFLRQDOPHQWHHPRFLRQDOPHQWHODQLxD HPSLH]DDGHELOLWDUVHDPRVWUDUVHLQVHJXUDDEDMDUODDXWRHVWLPDDDSDUHFHUFHORWLSLDV DKDFHUXQDVUHJUHVLRQHVHPSLH]DDILMDUVHHQXQDVHWDSDVPiVLQIDQWLOHVTXHODVTXHOH FRUUHVSRQGHQFRQPDQLIHVWDFLRQHVGHHQXUHVLVHQFRSUHVLV\WDO 0¢'HQHXURVLV" )(QXUHVLV 0(QXUHVLV ) (QXUHVLV Vt TXH HV HO KDFHUVH SLSt R VHD LQFRQWLQHQFLD SHUR QR HV TXH VHD OD LQFRQWLQHQFLD QR VLQR TXH D HVDV HGDGHV TXH VH VXSRQH TXH WLHQHQ TXH WHQHU FRQWURODGRV\DORVHVItQWHUHVSXHVEXHQRVHKDFHQGXUDQWHHOGtDDTXtHVXQDIRUPDGH SURWHVWDU FRQWUD DOJR WDPELpQ \ HVR OR TXH SDVD HV TXH OH HVWi GHELOLWDQGR HPRFLRQDOPHQWHVXHVWDELOLGDGHPRFLRQDOHPSLH]DDWDPEDOHDUVHFXDOTXLHUVLWXDFLyQXQ SRFR GLIHUHQFLDGRUD OR HQFDMD PDO OR SDVD PDO VXIUH SHUR HOOD HPSLH]D D VDFDU HVD DJUHVLYLGDGGHSURWHVWDUGHSURWHVWDUSHUROOHJDXQPRPHQWRTXHQRTXHXQDxR\RWUR DxR \ QR UHFLEH FRPSHQVDFLyQ HOOD VLJXH TXHGiQGRVH HQ HO FRPHGRU VH FLWD D ORV SDGUHVDYHUVLKD\PDQHUDGH«VHOODPDDORVVHUYLFLRVVRFLDOHVQRSXGRVHUKDVWDTXH \DSRUILQDKRUDHPSLH]DTXHQRVHKDFHHOSLSt\DQRVHKDFHODHQFRSUHVLVTXHEXHQR HVKDFHUVHFDFDHQFLPD 2VHDTXHDTXtHPSH]DED\DDKDEHUWUDVWRUQRV\DGHSHUVRQDOLGDG<HQWRQFHVVHKD 5 TXHGDGRXQSRFRHQXQDHWDSDXQSRFRUHJUHVLYD$KRUD\DEXVFDDIHFWREXVFDPXFKR DIHFWRVHHVWiRULJLQDQGRPXFKDLQVHJXULGDGHVDGHSHQGHQFLDFXDQGRDQWHVODYHtDV PiV DXWyQRPD PiV FRPSHWLWLYD $KRUD QR DKRUD \D VH HVWi JHQHUDQGR HVRV KiELWRV HVRV VtQWRPDV GH E~VTXHGD GH DWHQFLyQ GHO DGXOWR OODPDU OD DWHQFLyQ OD OHQWLWXG OD SDUVLPRQLDHOKDEODUDYHFHVHOEXVFDUQLxRVPiVSHTXHxRVTXHKD\DSDUDMXJDU\WDO &RQWRGRDKRUDEXHQRHVFXDQGRHPSLH]DDGDUVHFXHQWDGHTXHKD\FDPELRVHQHOOD DYDQ]DRVHHVWDQFD¢QR" 0<D )$YDQ]DHQHOVHQWLGRGHTXHKD\QLxRV\QLxDVGHVXHGDGSXHVTXHWLHQHQ\DRWURWLSR GHLQWHUHVHVVRFLDOHVGHUHODFLyQGHKDEODUTXHVLPHHQFXHQWURJXDSDTXHVLPHYLVWR DVtTXHVLPHDUUHJOR\WDOHOODHPSLH]DDILMDUVHXQSRFRHQVXLPDJHQHQVXItVLFR\VH DUUHJODPX\ELHQ¢4XpTXLHUHGHFLU"$KtVHTXLHUHHQFRQWUDUJXDSDDVtPLVPDHVWDUD JXVWR FRQ HOOD PLVPD \ FUHDU XQ DPELHQWH D VX DOUHGHGRU PiV DJUDGDEOH %LHQ SRU OR WDQWRHOKHFKRGHHVWDUSXHVFRQHOJUXSRSRUORPHQRVKDFLHQGRDKtODVDFWLYLGDGHVGH ()OHHVWiEHQHILFLDQGRPXFKRSRUTXHHVWiVDOLHQGRGHGHQWURKDFLDIXHUD &RVDVTXHHOODQRSRGUtDVHQWLUQLSHQVDUHPSLH]DDVHQWLUDKRUDVDEHTXHDOJXLHQVH 5 HVWi ILMDQGR HQ HOOD WDPELpQ SHUR WLHQH WRGDYtD HVH YLQDJULOOR ¢QR" HVD DFLGH] GH UHFKD]DUWHGHUHFKD]DUDODKRUDGHORVSDWLRV\WDO¢QR"SUHILHUHLUVHFRQ«SDUDKDFHU HVTXHPDVTXL]iVGHORTXHHOODQRUHFLELyRVHDDIHFWR\DWHQFLyQRWDOORTXLHUHGDUHOOD ¢QR"%LHQTXHPiVKD\SRUDKt"6tKD\PiVFRVDVDYHUKD\OXHJRODLPDJHQTXHHOOD WLHQHGHODIDPLOLD 07HUHILHUHVDKRUDDODDXWRQRPtD" 5 )6tODDXWRQRPtDODHVWiSHUGLHQGRHVWiSHUGLHQGRDXWRQRPtD 0¢(VWiSHUGLHQGRDXWRQRPtD" ) 6t HVWDED SHUGLHQGR DXWRQRPtD SHUR SRU PHFDQLVPRV GH GHIHQVD LQDGHFXDGRV /ODPDGDVGHDWHQFLyQYROYHUVHPiVSHTXHxDRVHDUHJUHVDU¢QR" 0<D )(ODSHJRRVHDHOOD]RDIHFWLYRILUPHQRTXHGyWDPEDOHDQGRFRPRGLFLHQGR³KRPEUH VL PH GHMDQ DTXt D FRPHU EXHQR DXQTXH PLV KHUPDQDV QR VH TXHGHQ EDK SRU OR PHQRV\RPHWHQJRTXHDGDSWDUDXQTXHPHVHSDPDOTXHWHQJDVHQWLPLHQWRVGHUDELD GHWDOSHUR\RDGHODQWH¢QR"´1R+DFtDODVPLO\XQD\WHQtDPHFDQLVPRVLQDGHFXDGRV \ OXHJR OH SDVDQ IDFWXUD %DMDQGR OD DXWRHVWLPD KDFLHQGR OD HQXUHVLV \ HQFRSUHVLV SXHV«\DHVXQSRFRPDOGDGXQSRFRSHUYHUVLyQHVGHFLUYR\DGDUOHVGRQGHPiVOHV GXHOH 4XpSURYRFDSXHVHQFDVDPDODPELHQWHVHHQIDGDQHQVHJXLGDTXHVLFDVWLJRVTXHVL 5 WDO«\VLHPSUHHQFLPD³TXHVLQRKDFHVHVWR«´ODVDPHQD]DVORVFDVWLJRV\DYHFHV HOODFRPRHVLQWHOLJHQWHFRPRHVOLVWDTXHKDFHSXHVDYHFHVSURYRFDTXHORVSDGUHV UHIXHUFHQ MXVWR OD FRQGXFWD TXH HOOD TXLHUH OLEUDUVH ³$K SXHV WH FDVWLJDUHPRV VLQ LU DO HVSODL WH FDVWLJDUHPRV VLQ QR VH TXp´ HOOD HQFDQWDGD R VHD HOOD HVWDED KDFLHQGR XQ DOHMDPLHQWRWDPELpQVRFLDO<HQWRQFHVHQFDVD³PLSDGUHHVFRPRXQJXDUGLDFLYLOVDEH WRGRQRVHVStDQRVHVStD\WDO´¢QR"$KSXHVHQWRQFHVVRORGHEHUHV\PiVGHEHUHV\ VLQR3DP3DPVRSDSRYDVRSDSRYLHQH 0<D )+DSURYRFDGR\HOODVHHVWiGDQGRFXHQWDGH«RVHDTXHWLHQHWRGDYtDHVWHODVWUH DKtSRUHMHPSORDXWRQRPtD«<HVDDXWRQRPtDFUHRTXHODYROYHUiFUHRTXHODSXHGH YROYHU D DILDQ]DU D VDFDUOD D WUDYpV MXVWR GH OD () TXH HV GRQGH HOOD VH« WLHQH XQ HVStULWXFRPSHWLWLYRGHVXSHUDUVHSXHGHTXHVHHFKHSDUDDWUiVDQWHHMHUFLFLRVQXHYRV QRYHGRVRVRWDOSHURVLVHOHGHVJUDQDQELHQTXHHVORTXHKHGLFKRDOSULQFLSLRELHQ VHFXHQFLDGRVELHQSDXWDGRVDVXQLYHO« IHQRPHQDO ¢<OXHJRTXpPiVWHQHPRVSRU DTXt" 0/DVRFLDOL]DFLyQPRWLYDFLyQ\DFWLWXGGHORVSDGUHV¢4XpGLUtDV" )'HDOJXQDIRUPDYDQVDOLHQGR« 0¢/DPRWLYDFLyQFyPRODYHVKDFLDORVDSUHQGL]DMHV" )¢'HHOOD" 06t )<RGLUtDTXHHVEDMDODPRWLYDFLyQHVEDMDSRUTXHVLQRVHPRYHUtDPiVWUDWDUtDGH 5 FRPSHQVDUVREUHVDOLHQGRXQSRFRRVHDHVDIDOWDGHFDSDFLGDGDQLYHO\DGHPRWULFLGDG SXHV WUDWDUtD GH FRPSHQVDUOD SXHV FRQ XQ EXHQ VDEHU KDFHU FRQ KDFHU ORV HMHUFLFLRV VLHPSUHELHQ\WDOSHURFRPRKDKDELGRLEDDGHFLUHVHEORTXHRHPRFLRQDOLQWHOHFWXDO HVWi PiV SHQGLHQWH GH HVH GRORU GH PXHODV GH OD DWHQFLyQ GH ORV SDGUHV GH OD LQIHULRULGDGGHODVLWXDFLyQGHGHVFRPSHQVDFLyQTXHVHHQFXHQWUDHQILQFRQUHVSHFWRR GHGHVYHQWDMDTXHVHHQFXHQWUD« VHFRUWDODFLQWD )¢3RGtDPRVKDEODUGH«tEDPRVDGHFLUGHXQDOtQHDDOJRGHSUHVLYDRWDO"<RQRPH 5 DWUHYHUtDDWDQWRSHURVHSRGUtDHVWDURULJLQDQGRXQHVWDGRSRUHMHPSORGHLQIHULRULGDG DIHFWLYDGHDOJRGHLQIHOLFLGDGHQDOJXQRVPRPHQWRV« 3HURFRQWRGRKHGLFKRTXHSXHGHUHODQ]DUVHDWUDYpVMXVWRGHOD()SRUTXHWLHQHHVH 5 HVStULWXOHTXHGDWRGDYtDHODIiQGHVXSHUDU\MXVWDPHQWHGRQGHHOODTXL]iVSRGUtDPRV SHQVDUTXHYDDIDOODUPHQRVHQWRQFHVVLDKtTXHGDFRPSHQVDGDVHYHDFHSWDGDSDVD GHGHQWURKDFLDDIXHUDWDPELpQSXHGHSDVDUSXHGHVXELUODDXWRHVWLPDWLHQHTXHVXELU \SDVDUXQSRFRDORVDSUHQGL]DMHVDPHWHUVHPiVHQHOPXQGRGHODOHFWXUDHQILQHQHO PXQGR PiV GH KDFHU KLSyWHVLV UHODFLRQDU DEVWUDHU« TXH WRGR HVWR OR WLHQH VDEH UHODFLRQDU VDEH DEVWUDHU SHUR TXL]iV OR TXH HV PiV IRUPDO D YHFHV OH SXHGH IDWLJDU SHURSRUHVRVKiELWRVTXHOHHVWiQSDVDQGRIDFWXUD%LHQHQWRQFHVDTXt\RKDEtDGLFKR DQWHVQRVRODPHQWHHOFHQWURRORVFHQWURVVHKDQGHTXHGDUHQHVWDDGDSWDFLyQYDPRV DOODPDUOHDXQTXH\RQROHTXLHUROODPDUDGDSWDFLyQODVDFWLYLGDGHVGH()SURSLFLDV\ TXHOHYDQDD\XGDUDVDOLU¢TXpSDVDDODVRWUDVPiVIRUPDOHV" 3HUR KD\ TXH FRQRFHU \ HQ HVWR OR KDEOR FRQ OD WXWRUD HVWH WLSR GH QLxRV KD\ XQDV 5 VHFXHODVKD\XQDVLQFLGHQFLDVGHODVFDUDFWHUtVWLFDVGHODHQIHUPHGDGGDQSDVRWDPELpQ D XQDV VHFXHODV QR VROR KD\ XQD IDWLJD ItVLFD TXH SURJUHVLYDPHQWH SXHGH OOHYDU D XQ GHWHULRUR SRUTXH DIHFWD D OD PXVFXODWXUD \ FODUR SXHGH SDVDU OXHJR D OD DWHQFLyQ FRQFHQWUDFLyQ\PRPHQWRVGHTXHGDUVHDYHFHVVLQJDQDVQLGHKDFHU«HQWRQFHVDTXt TXHHVORTXHKD\TXHHVFXFKDUPXFKRDODSDUWHPpGLFDWDPELpQ 0<D )<FODURTXHSDVDTXHVLHOSURIHVRUDGRQRWLHQHLQIRUPDFLyQQRYDDFRPSUHQGHUHO SRUTXp LJXDO HVWi XQ GtD DVt R HVWi GLVWUDtGD R YD WDQ OHQWD R WDO YDQ D UHIRU]DU OD FRQGXFWDUHDFWLYDGHHOOD³SXHVDKRUDQRORKDJRSXHVDKRUDQRVpTXpSXHVDKRUDQR VpFXDQWRV´LJXDOHVWiQGDQGRGDQGRHQIDOVR 0 <D SRUTXH W~ HO RWUR GtD WH UHXQLVWH FRQ HO FHQWUR GH UHKDELOLWDFLyQ ¢\ TXp WH 5 FRPHQWDURQ" )3XHVHVWRTXHKDEORPHHVWiQFRQILUPDQGRHVWRTXHQRHVVRODPHQWHODGLVJHQHVLD QHXURQDOVLQRTXHHVWRDPHGLGDTXHYDQDYDQ]DQGRHQHGDGYDKDELHQGRHQILQXQDV VHFXHODVRVHYDQDSHUFLELUXQRVVtQWRPDVORTXHSURYRFDQORVVtQWRPDVHVFDQVDQFLR IDWLJD SHUR TXH WDPELpQ SDVD D QLYHO FRJQLWLYR D SURFHVRV FRJQLWLYRV ¢QR" TXL]iV UHWLHQH PHQRVVHIDWLJDDQWHVODPRWLYDFLyQ SXHGH EDMDU« \ FODUR GD OD VHQVDFLyQ GH SHUH]RVRVGHYDJRVGHTXHWXQR«HQWRQFHVFODURHOTXHGHVFRQRFHHVDVLWXDFLyQWDO <HQWRQFHVKDEODPRVTXHVHUtDLGHDOGLVHxDUWDUHDVEUHYHVRVHDFRUWDVGLH]PLQXWRV FLQFR PLQXWRV« \ RWUD DFWLYLGDG 3DUD LU TXL]iV DPSOLDQGR \ TXH WHQJD RSFLyQ D XQRV PRPHQWLWRVGHGHVFDQVR 0$Mi )1RDKRUDGHVFDQVD\WDOVLQRTXHVDEHTXHHVFRUWRSHURODQLxDVHFRQFHQWUD\WDO 5 PX\ ELHQ SXHV HVWXSHQGR HQWUH TXH FDPELD GH DFWLYLGDG \ WDO SXHV KD KDELGR RWUR SHULRGRGHGHVFDQVR<TXHHVWDQLxDSXHVTXHSXHGHWHUPLQDUHQVLOODGHUXHGDVQRV FRPHQWDURQ<FODURDOOtHVGRQGHHVWDPRVHVWLPXODQGR\SRWHQFLDQGRWRGRORTXHWLHQH EUD]RV \ WDO DO Pi[LPR SRUTXH DO QR WHQHU PXVFXODWXUD HQ SLHUQDV \ WDO OR YHPRV PX\ GLItFLOORYHQPX\GLItFLO(VWRHVORTXH« 0/RTXHKD\ )6tORTXHKD\<ODIDPLOLDDKRUD« 0¢&XiOHVODDFWLWXGGHORVSDGUHV" )/RVSDGUHV\RKHYLVWREXHQR\RYR\DVHUPX\FODUR¢QR" 0&ODUR )4XHQRDFHSWDEDQ«\\RGLUtDTXHQRKDQDFHSWDGRD~QODUHDOLGDGSXUD\GXUDGHVX KLMD 1R OD KDQ DFHSWDGR < QR OR KDQ HVWR \D QR SXHGR PiV TXH KDEODU FRPR H[SHULHQFLD¢QR"SHURQRORSXHGROOHYDU«QRORSXHGRJHQHUDOL]DUDHVWRV¢QR"SXHV TXH OR KDQ YLYLGR SXHV FRPR XQD GHVJUDFLD FRQ VHQWLPLHQWR GH FXOSD HWF HWF \ \D HQWUH OD SDUHMD SXHV« QR OR KDQ OOHYDGR ELHQ QR OR KDQ OOHYDGR ELHQ VH KDQ YROFDGR TXL]iVPiVHQODVKHUPDQDVHOODVFODURVLPHR\HQPHFRUUHUiQHKPHSXHGHFRUUHU 5 01RQRHVDQyQLPRWRGR )6tQRQRSHURPHUHILHURTXH«\\RQRVpVLHV«QRSRGHPRVHFKDUODVFXOSDV\ WDO SHUR VX DFWLWXG KD LGR XQ SRFR SRU DKt QR DFHSWDU < FRPR QR DFHSWDQ HVWR OR KD PDPDGRODQLxDORKDPDPDGRODQLxDVREUHWRGRDSDUWLUTXHWLHQH\DVHLVVLHWHDxRVOR KD PDPDGR \ KD HPSH]DGR D UHDFFLRQDU \ D UHSURGXFLU HVTXHPDV VLPLODUHV QR DFHSWDFLyQSXHV\RWDPSRFRORDFHSWR 0<D )3HUR\RSRUORTXHGHVFXEUtHQHOFHQWURGHUHKDELOLWDFLyQHOKLVWRULDOPpGLFRGHHVWD 5 QLxDQRHVWiFRPSOHWRQRHVWiGHELGDPHQWHVHFXHQFLDGRSODVPDGR\VHJXLGRELHQ(VWD ~OWLPDGRFWRUDPHSDUHFHTXHHVODGRFWRUD5HVODTXHVHHVWiHQFDUJDQGRDKRUDGH UHFRSLODU\YROYHUFDVLDGLDJQRVWLFDURVHDUHFRSLODUWRGRORTXHSXHGDREWHQHUSRUDKt\ XQSRFRKLVWRULDUORELHQSRUTXHQRKD\XQGLDJQyVWLFRGHSXxR\OHWUDQRQRH[LVWH 01RH[LVWH" )(PSLH]DDKRUDDUHFRSLODU\KLVWRULDUOR\DODSDU\DGLDJQRVWLFDQGRGHQXHYR 04XpEDUEDULGDG )<TXpTXLHURGHFLUFRQHVWRTXHQRVHKDKDEODGRQRVHOHVKDKDEODGRDORVSDGUHV 5 1RVHOHVKDSUHSDUDGR 0'HOIXWXUR ) 1R GHO IXWXUR QL GH OR TXH OD UHDOLGDG GH OD HQIHUPHGDG TXp LPSOLFDED TXp SRGtD LPSOLFDUDORODUJRGH« 0+D\HVHYDFtR )+D\HVHYDFtR\QRVRODPHQWHHVHYDFtRVLQRTXHKD\TXHEDVWDQWH 0¢+D\TXH" )3LQFKpEDVWDQWHRVHDSXVHHOGHGRHQODOODJD 06tVt )3DUDTXHQRVHFRQWLQXDUDVHFXHVWUDQGRLQIRUPDFLyQ 0<D ) %XHQR ¢4Xp TXLHUR GHFLU FRQ HVWR" 4XH OD PLVPD GRFWRUD IUHQWH D HO GLDJQyVWLFR LQFRPSOHWR WDPSRFR WHQtD FODUR GH TXp GHFLUOHV TXp QR GHFLUOHV GH FyPR HQIRFDU R FyPRQRHQIRFDU<\RGLJREXHQR³WHUPLQDVLTXLHUHVRVHDGDWHXQWLHPSREUHYH\WDO SHURORVSDGUHVORVSDGUHVWLHQHTXHVDEHUTXpWLHQHVXKLMDVLVHVDEHQFDXVDVSXHV DGHODQWH\VXHYROXFLyQ´ 0&ODUR )(OSURQyVWLFRTXHHVWRFRQOOHYD\WDOHLQFOXVRVLHOORVQHFHVLWDQXQDD\XGDSVLFROyJLFD SRUTXHPiVTXHODPtDSXHVORVWHQpLVTXHDWHQGHURHQFDX]DUORVDHOORV\WDO<HQILQ DKtTXHGDPRVTXHHOORVYDQD«PiVTXHDODQLxDTXHODQLxDWHQGUiTXHLUDKDFHUVXV HMHUFLFLRV IXQFLRQDOHV R OR TXH WHQJD TXH KDFHU« YDQ D EXVFDU HVD D\XGD GH WHUDSLD IDPLOLDU (OORV WLHQHQ D OD SVLFyORJD WDPELpQ DOOt \ KD\ TXH LU SXHV LQVLVWLHQGR HQ TXH 5 IXQGDPHQWDOPHQWHKD\TXHSUHSDUDUDORVSDGUHVIRUWDOHFHUDORVSDGUHV 0(YLGHQWHPHQWH ) 3RUTXH HOORV KDEtDQ GH DOJXQD IRUPD QHJDGR OD UHDOLGDG KDEtDQ JLUDGR DO QR YHUOD SXHV FXDQGR VDOtD EXHQR GHOHJDEDQ« SXHV HO FROHJLR WDO SHUR D YHU VL ORV VHUYLFLRV VRFLDOHVQRVpTXp«EXHQRSXHVHOFHQWURGHUHKDELOLWDFLyQ«XQSRFRLEDQGHOHJDQGR &ODUR FXDOTXLHU LQGLFDFLyQ TXH VH OHV KDFtD SDUD PRGLILFDU DOJR HQ SULQFLSLR SRQtDQ WUDEDV \ \R OR YL GLFLHQGR ³HVWD QLxD QR SXHGH VHJXLU DVt YD D KDFHU XQ FXDGUR GH WUDVWRUQRVGHSHUVRQDOLGDGJUDYHV\WDOSRUTXHYDPRVDYHUVLSRGHPRVVROXFLRQDUTXH SXHGD FRPHU FRQ VXV KHUPDQDV ELHQ DTXt R ELHQ HQ FDVD TXH DOJXLHQ YHQJD FRQ XQ FRFKHDUHFRJHUODVRDUHFRJHUODVTXHODVWUDLJDR«´1RKXERPDQHUD 01RKXERPDQHUD ) /XHJR \D Vt FODUR OXHJR \D FXDQGR YLHURQ TXH HVWR ORV VHUYLFLRV VRFLDOHV R ORV GHO LQVWLWXWR\WDOSRQHQFRPRXQDHVSHFLHGHFyPRVHOODPDGHDPEXODQFLD\WDO\\DHVWi VROXFLRQDGR 0¢<YDHQDPEXODQFLDDFDVDDFRPHU" )6tVtVt1RDKRUDYLHQHODPDGUHSRUTXHKDQWHQLGRDUUHJODGRHOWHPDORDUUHJODURQ QRVpGHTXpPDQHUDSHUR\D« 09LHQHODPDGUHDEXVFDUODV )6tVtVt 0$OPHGLRGtD )([DFWR<HVWRGHKDEHUORKHFKRXQRVDxRVDQWHV« 0<D¢<DOJRPiVFRQUHVSHFWRDODDFWLWXGGHORVSDGUHV" )<RFUHRTXHFRQHVWR« 0<DKDVGLFKREDVWDQWH )6tSHUR\RFUHRTXHHVWRKD\TXHUHSDUWLUORHQWUHWRGRV2VHDHVDQRLQIRUPDFLyQHV HOGHUHFKRTXHHOORVWLHQHQDWHQHUWRGDODLQIRUPDFLyQ 0&ODUR ) < OXHJR HOORV SXHGHQ HMHUFHU HO GHUHFKR GH GHFLU OD SULYDFLGDG GH WUDVSDVDU R QR WUDVSDVDU HVD LQIRUPDFLyQ /R FRUUHFWR HV TXH HVD LQIRUPDFLyQ D SDUWH GH FRQRFHUOD OD KDQGHKDEODUFRQHOFHQWURFRQHOFROHJLRFRQHOHQWRUQRIDPLOLDUHV\WDOKDQGHVDEHU FyPR SXHGH UHSHUFXWLU HQ OD HVFRODULGDG HWF HWF HQ OD PDGXUH] HQ VX FUHFLPLHQWR ItVLFRWDO«SHUREXHQR<ODVQLxDVVXVKHUPDQDVWDPELpQORVSDGUHVLQIRUPDUELHQ\D 5 ODQLxDSRUVXSXHVWR'HFLUOHSXHVEXHQRTXpWLHQHTXpQRWLHQH\TXHKDEUiPRPHQWRV SXHVTXHVLVHFDQVDRHVWiGHPDOKXPRURVLWLHQHLGHDVRVHHQFXHQWUDHQLQIHULRULGDG GHFRQGLFLRQHVRYHTXHORVRWURVQLxRV\WDO«SXHVTXHEXHQRDQLPDUODDVXSHUDU< OXHJRDYHFHVFRODERUDQPHMRUTXHORVDGXOWRV2VHDVLOHVKDH[SOLFDGRODVFRVLWDVDVX QLYHO VRQ QLxRV TXH WLHQH HQIHUPHGDGHV SXHV \D GH GLItFLO FXUD R GH SURQyVWLFR PX\ LQFLHUWROHVGDQOHFFLRQHVSHURFODURFXDQGRVHOHGDFRQWRGRELHQSDXWDGRPX\FODUR SHUIHFWR %LHQ SDUD ORV SDGUHV SRUTXH FDPELDQ GH DFWLWXG ELHQ SDUD OD IDPLOLD ORV KHUPDQRV\ELHQSDUDQRVRWURVSRUTXHFODUR\RWHSXHGRDVHJXUDUTXHVLDKRUDW~OH SUHJXQWDVDODSURIHVRUDTXHODKDWHQLGRWHGLUi³$KTXHQLxDPHVDFDGHTXLFLRHVTXH QRKD\PDQHUD´ 0<D\D\D\D )³/DEDWDPLHQWUDVHVWiQWHUPLQDQGR\DPHGLDKRUDDQWHVORVHMHUFLFLRVHOODD~QVHHVWi SRQLHQGRODEDWD´ 0 < KD VDOLGR HO WHPD GH OD VRFLDOL]DFLyQ \D DO SULQFLSLR KDV FRPHQWDGR TXH WHQtD GLILFXOWDGHVHQODVRFLDOL]DFLyQ¢3XHGHVPDWL]DUXQSRTXLWR" ) 9DPRV D YHU \R RSLQR TXH HVWD QLxD DO KDFHU HVWD UHJUHVLyQ DO HQFHUUDUVH DO HQFRQWUDUVHGLIHUHQWHDOQR«DOQRDFHSWDUFRPRGHELHUDVXVLWXDFLyQSRUTXHKDEtDXQD FRQWDPLQDFLyQ GHVGH XQRV LQLFLRV WDPELpQ HQ HO iPELWR IDPLOLDU \ WDO HOOD VH YD HQFHUUDQGR WLHQGH D UHSOHJDUVH SDUD QR TXHGDU HQ HQWUHGLFKR \ VL HQFLPD ODV VLWXDFLRQHV VRQ FRPSHWLWLYDV OD HQVHxDQ]D HQ JHQHUDO LQFOX\HQGR D WRGRV HV FRPSHWLWLYRGHVGHOD()VLVHHQIRFDEDSXHVFODURHVWDQLxDWLHQGHDDEVWHQHUVH<VL QRYLYH\QRVDOH\QRVLHQWHHQWRQFHVVHUHSOLHJD\HVFDSD]GHGHFLUTXHQR\TXHQR \TXHQRFXDQGRODYLHQHQDEXVFDUSHURQRHVSRUTXHQRTXLHUDORHVWiGHVHDQGRHO SUREOHPDHVTXHQRVHSLHQVHTXHQRVHYDQDUHtURSRURPHQRVDSRQHUODHQVLWXDFLyQ GHLQIHULRULGDG(QWRQFHVFODURGRQGHYD«HPSLH]DDUHFXUULUDQLxRVPiVSHTXHxRV\ DKRUD HVWi HQ HVD FULVLV HVWDPRV WUDEDMDQGR HVD FULVLV TXH \D HPSLH]D D QRWDU GH SRUTXp WLHQH TXH LU FRQ HVWD QLxD PiV SHTXHxD FXDQGR WHQGUtD TXH« FXDQGR \D HVWi FUHFLHQGRItVLFD\VH[XDOPHQWHHWFHWF/DWUDQVIRUPDFLyQTXHHPSLH]DDKDEHU\TXH HOOD \D VHHPSLH]DDGDUFXHQWD\\DVHDUUHJODPiV\HVWiPiVFRTXHWDSXHVVLPH JXVWD HVWH QLxR SXHV VL VH HVWi ILMDQGR HQ PL«R VHD TXH DKRUD SRGUtD VHU « HV HO PRPHQWRGHFyPRGDUHVHSDVR$KRUDHVFUXFLDOSRUTXHVLQRGDHVHSDVRGHPDGXUH] VRFLDOVHQRVSXHGHUHSOHJDU3RUORWDQWROHIDOWDQSXHVHVWUDWHJLDVFRPSHWHQFLDVRFLDO 5 KDELOLGDGHVHVORTXHOHIDOWDKDELOLGDGHVVRFLDOHV$OLJXDOSXHVTXHHQOXJDUGHGHFLU ³QRSRUTXHQR´SXHVGHFLUSRQHUVHHQOXJDUGHORVRWURVWHQHUDOWHUQDWLYDV³3LHQVRTXH D TXp SRGHPRV MXJDU R TXp HVWR« QR Vp PH JXVWDUtD LU SHUR HV TXH QR PH HQFXHQWUR«WDORDKRUD«´QRVp 0<D )2VHDLUFXDQGRHVHQSHUVSHFWLYDGHORVGHPiVFXDQGRYLHQHQDEXVFDUODDKRUD\D SXP SRU UHVSXHVWD XQ SRUWD]R &ODUR QR WLHQH KDELOLGDGHV SDUD« QR GDU VLHPSUH QR WLHQHDOWHUQDWLYDSDUDHQYH]GHGDUXQVDOWRKDFHUDOJRGLIHUHQWHQRORWLHQHWRGDYtD2 ODV FRQVHFXHQFLDV R EHQHILFLRV GH LU R QR LU WDO &ODUR VL WRGR OR HVWi YLHQGR EDMR XQD ySWLFDQHJDWLYD« 0(QWLHQGR )&ODURSDUDHOODHVPiVIiFLOHQWRQHVVHHYDGHRVHDFRQGHFLUTXHQRVHSLHQVD\D TXH«ORPLVPRTXHKDFtDQORVSDGUHV\DHVWiWRGRVROXFLRQDGR³3XHVPHGDLJXDOSXHV QRVpTXp´ 0<D\D ))DOWDPDGXUDUHVDVKDELOLGDGHVKD\TXHPDGXUDUODVTXHYD\DQIRUPDQGRSDUWHGHVX 5 SDWULPRQLRGHVXFUHFLPLHQWREXHQRTXHHVWiKDFLHQGR\TXHDKRUDHVYLWDO(OODYDORUD PXFKRODFODVHGH()ODHVWiYDORUDQGRSRUORTXHKHGLFKRDQWHVODHPSLH]DDYDORUDU 0¢$QWHVQRODYDORUDED" ) $QWHV \DWHGLJRXQULQFyQDTXtVROD R QR LED R WDO SDUD XQDFRVDTXHDORPHMRU KDFtD 0¢<FyPRSXHGHVHUTXHDPLPHGLMRTXHVLHPSUHKDSDUWLFLSDGRDFWLYDPHQWHGHOD VHVLyQGH()" )¢(OOD" 06t&XDQGROHKLFHODHQWUHYLVWD¢4XpLQWHUSUHWDFLyQKDFHV" )<RGLUtDTXHHUDXQSRFRSXHVSDUDHYDGLUHOEXOWR(VXQPHFDQLVPRGHGHIHQVD$Vt QR PH KDFH OD VLJXLHQWH SUHJXQWD HVWD SHUVRQD (V TXH HV LQWHOLJHQWH (OOD DVt QR PH KDFHODVLJXLHQWHSUHJXQWDHOSRUTXp\WDO¢QR" 0<D\D\D )2ELHQJHQHUDOL]DGHXQDFRVDTXHKDKHFKR\DKRUDGLFH³$\%LHQELHQSHURHVWR\ 5 HQIDGDGDFRQ0HUFKH´ 0¢$VL"¢<SRUTXp" ) 6t SRUTXH PH HVWi KDFLHQGR XQRV HMHUFLFLRV TXH QR \ PH KD UHxLGR \ QR Vp \ WDO %XHQRQRVpVLGLMRODSDODEUDUHxLURTXp 06tVtDKRUDWHORFRPHQWDUp ) < DO RWUR GtD SXHV SHUIHFWR 3RU HVR KH GLFKR TXH KD\ TXH VLQWRQL]DU KD\ TXH DFRPRGDURJUDGXDUSDUDQRSRQHUODHQVLWXDFLyQGHFODUDLQIHULRULGDG 01RQR )1RTXHQRHVFRPSHWLWLYR¢HQWLHQGHV" 01RQRHUDHMHUFLFLRVGHIOH[LELOLGDG )1RSHURHOOD« 0 1R TXLVR KDFHUORV SRUTXH \D ORVKDFtD HQ HO FHQWUR GH UHKDELOLWDFLyQ GLMR < IXH XQ UHWRFRQPLJR\OOHJDPRVDODFRQFOXVLyQFRQODPDHVWUDGH()TXHVHPROHVWyGHTXH\R GLHVHUHVSXHVWDDWRGRHOJUXSR'HTXH\ROLGHUDVHHOJUXSR<HQWRQFHVFXDQGROHKLFH OD REVHUYDFLyQ GH TXH HOOD ORV SRGtD KDFHU HOOD PH GLMR TXH QR ORV TXHUtD KDFHU VHQFLOODPHQWH SRUTXH \D ORV KDFtD HQ UHKDELOLWDFLyQ < D SHVDU GH TXH OH LQWHQWDPRV MXVWLILFDUTXHHUDEHQHILFLRVDVHVDVDFWLYLGDGHVGHIOH[LELOLGDGHOODVHQHJyURWXQGDPHQWH \ODPDHVWUDLQWHQWySURIXQGL]DUHQHOSRUTXp )6tVt 0 < HO RWUR GtD WDPELpQ VH HQIDGy FRQPLJR SRUTXH PH GLMR ³GpMDPH HQ SD]´ FXDQGR 5 KLFLPRVXQDGLVWULEXFLyQGHJUXSRVHOODVHTXHGyFRQODPDHVWUDMXJDQGRDOEiVTXHWHQ VLOODGHUXHGDV\\RPHTXHGpKDFLHQGRYROHLERO&XDQGROHSUHJXQWpTXHFyPROHKDEtD LGR HO EiVTXHW HQ VLOOD GH UXHGDV QR PH TXLVR FRQWHVWDU < OR ~QLFR TXH PH GLMR IXH ³'pMDPHHQSD]´<ODPDHVWUDWHQtDTXHDYHULJXDUHOSRUTXp<OOHJDPRVDODFRQFOXVLyQ GHTXHHOODLQWX\HGHTXHWHQJRXQDUHODFLyQEDVWDQWHGLUHFWDFRQHOOD\HOGtDTXH\RQR HVWR\HQXQDDWHQFLyQHVSHFLDOL]DGDFRQHOODVLQRTXHHVWR\FRQHOUHVWRGHOJUXSRWLHQH FHORV¢SXHGHVHU" )6tSRUHVRGHFtDFHORVDORVKHUPDQRVH[DFWDPHQWHYDEXVFDQGR 0<PHYDSURYRFDQGR )6tVHHVWiRULJLQDQGRHVDEDMDGDGHDXWRQRPtDGHGHSHQGHQFLDGHGHE~VTXHGDGHO DIHFWRYDEXVFDQGRHODIHFWRWUHPHQGDPHQWH 0<WLHQHFHORVGHTXH\RQRHVWpFHQWUDGDFRQHOOD )&ODURHQWRQFHVFODURKDEUiTXHXWLOL]DUDOJXQDRWUDHVWUDWHJLDGHVGHIDFLOLWDU«EXHQR TXHHOLMDDOJXQDYH]TXHRSWHSRUHOHJLUSRUXQDPELHQWHXRWUR 01RSRUTXHORFDPELDPRVHORXQDVHVLyQGHSHQGHRXQVHFWRUGHODVHVLyQOH WRFDFRQODPDHVWUDRWURVHFWRUFRQPLJRSRUTXHKDFHPRVGLVWULEXFLyQGHJUXSRV )6tVtVt 0 3HUR EXHQR HOOD WLHQH TXH WUDEDMDU WDPELpQ OD DFHSWDFLyQ GH TXH QR WLHQH XQD GHSHQGHQFLDFRQPLJR )6tVtH[DFWDPHQWHVHSLHQVDHQHOJUXSRVHSLHQVDHQHOOD 0<DHVWi )<OLVWR\\DVHLUiHGXFDQGRXQSRFR6LKD\XQDILUPH]DSHURFRQFDULxRTXLHURGHFLU FRQFRPSDxHULVPR\WDOORYDVDSRGHUGLVWLQJXLUSRUTXHVLQRWHYDVDDVIL[LDURQRVYDD DVIL[LDU\HOODPLVPDYDDYROYHUDFDHUHQODWUDPSD<HVR³1RWDOQRVpTXpQRVp FXDQWRV´HVTXHQRWLHQHRWURWLSRGHUHFXUVR/HIDOWD\SLHQVD³¢<SRUTXp0HUFKHPH KDSHGLGRTXHKDJDHVWRRSRUTXp\ROHUHVSRQGRDVt"¢\SRUTXpQRSUXHERGHKDFHUOR GH RWUD PDQHUD"´ 3RU HVWR HV OR TXH KD\ TXH WUDEDMDU FRQ HOOD HVWH FRPR KLOR FRQGXFWXDODYHUTXHFDSWHTXpHVORTXHKD\TXLHQORWLHQHGHFXDQWDVPDQHUDVVH SXHGHVROXFLRQDUFXiQWDVDOWHUQDWLYDVSXHGHSUHVHQWDUFXiOHVODPHMRUSRUTXpHVOD PHMRU«<OXHJRSXHVDQLPDUODDTXHSDVHDUHDOL]DUODDODSUDFWLFD 0&ODUR )(QILQ 0%XHQR\\DSRU~OWLPR¢DOJXQDPDWL]DFLyQVREUHORTXHKHPRVFRPHQWDGRKDVWDKRUD R\DFRQVLGHUDVTXHWHSDUHFHTXHKDVVLGRVXILFLHQWHPHQWHH[SOtFLWR" )6tVtVtVt4XHEXHQRTXHYDPRVGHVIDVDGRVHQFXDQWRDODVUHVSXHVWDVDQLxRV FRQGLVFDSDFLGDG 03HURHQJHQHUDO ) (Q JHQHUDO QR DTXt < HQWRQFHV IDOWDED UHGRQGHDU TXH IDOWDQ SHUVRQDV SXHV FRPR 0HUFKH5tRV 0D\SRUIDYRU )1RQRQRHQVHULR 03URIHVRUDGRGHDSR\R )6LKHOXFKDGRDKRUDHVTXHVHSDQTXHQRVHWUDWDVRORGHYHQGHUHOSURGXFWR\\D HVWiVLQRFRQHOGtDDGtDTXHYHDQTXHORVUHVXOWDGRV\HOHVIXHU]RTXHVHKDFHTXHVH WUDGXFHHQEHQHILFLRQRVRORGHORVQLxRVVLQRSDUDWRGRV2VHDIDOWDIDOWDSHUR\RFUHR TXHHVWiLVSHJDQGRIXHUWHTXHVHHVWiSHJDQGRIXHUWHDKRUD 5 0%XHQRSXHVPXFKtVLPDVJUDFLDV )<VLYLHQHDWUDYpVGHOD()PHMRUPHMRUW~4XHQRYHQJDGH«GHOFXUDTXHVHVXED DOS~OSLWR\GDEXHQRVFRQVHMRV1RVpFRPRGHFLUWH¢QR"'HVGHODSUiFWLFDQRVp 00X\ELHQ3XHVPXFKtVLPDVJUDFLDV (175(9,67$$/&(1752 $9DOH 0(VWDHQWUHYLVWDHVDQyQLPDSHURQRREVWDQWHPHLQGLFDVQRPEUH\DSHOOLGRV $6t$36 0¢(GDG" $ 0+R\HVWDPRVDGHDEULOGHO¢(OFHQWUR" $7UHEDOORDO($3+*« 0 $K WLHQH TXH VHU HQ FDVWHOODQR SRUTXH OD WUDQVFULELUp HQ FDVWHOODQR 6L HUHV WDQ $36PLHPEUR(TXLSRGH$VHVRUDPLHQWR3VLFRSHGDJyJLFR )(&+$GHDEULOGHO 0«HVWR\LQWHQWDQGRUHFDEDUFXiOHVODSHUFHSFLyQGHODLQFOXVLyQFRQGLVFDSDFLGDGGH WRGDVDTXHOODVSHUVRQDVTXHHVWiLVLQWHUYLQLHQGRHQHOFDVRGH0DUtD DPDEOH $6tVt(VWR\WUDEDMDQGRHQHO($3+*GH%DUFHORQD 0/DSULPHUDSUHJXQWDHVTXHVLIDFLOLWDVHODVHVRUDPLHQWRDOiUHDGH(GXFDFLyQ)tVLFD () $$YHUQR« 0$TXtHQHVWHFHQWURHVFRODU $ (Q HVWH FHQWUR HVFRODU ¢HQ HVWH FRQFUHWDPHQWH" 1R (Q HO DVHVRUDPLHQWR GLUHFWDPHQWH DO iUHD GH () QR KH LQWHUYHQLGR HQ HVWH PRPHQWR +H WUDEDMDGR FRQ ODV WXWRUDV GH ORV DOXPQRV \ GHO DOXPQR TXH QRV RFXSD \ FRQ IDPLOLDV GH GHWHUPLQDGRV DOXPQRV HQ SODQ GH GDU RULHQWDFLyQ SHUVRQDO \ DFDGpPLFD SHUR QR ItVLFD QR (Q () FRQFUHWDPHQWHQRKHPRVLQWHUYHQLGR 5 01RKDEpLVLQWHUYHQLGR $1R(QHVWHFDVRQR 0¢3RUTXHQRKDVLGRQHFHVDULRRSRUSODQWHDPLHQWRRSRUTXp" $$YHU\RDHVWHFHQWURYHQJRTXLQFHQDOPHQWHRVHDGRVPDxDQDVFDGDPHV3RUTXH HVXQFHQWURPXQLFLSDOHQTXHVHLQDXJXUDHVWHDxRODLQWHUYHQFLyQGLUHFWDGHO($3KDVWD DKRUDQRYHQtDHO($3DLQWHUYHQLU(VSHUHPRVTXHDFRQWLQXDFLyQVHSXHGDLUSLGLHQGR PiVLQWHUYHQFLyQPiVVHJXLGDVHPDQDOFRPRPtQLPRHWF(QWRQFHV\RKHWUDEDMDGRD GHPDQGDGHOSURIHVRUDGRGH(GXFDFLyQ(VSHFLDO((\GHODFRRUGLQDGRUDSHGDJyJLFD \GDGRTXHHVXQDLQWHUYHQFLyQGLJDPRVSXQWXDOPX\FRUWLWDVLHPSUHVHKDSULRUL]DGR GHWHUPLQDGDVRULHQWDFLRQHVDVHUYLFLRVH[WUDHVFRODUHVSRUHMHPSORHYDOXDUHOFDVRMXQWR FRQ OD WXWRUD R FRQ OD SHUVRQD GH (( OD FRRUGLQDFLyQ HYDOXDU HVWH FDVR SUHVHQWDU HO DQiOLVLV D OD IDPLOLD IDFLOLWDU OD FRPSUHQVLyQ IDPLOLDU GHO SURFHVR GH HQVHxDQ]D DSUHQGL]DMH \ FDVL VLHPSUH HQ PRWLYR GH SHGLU SXHV HYDOXDFLyQ QHXURSVLFROyJLFD GH XQ KRVSLWDORGHRWURVHUYLFLRPiVDOOiGHODHVFXHODSURSLDPHQWHGLFKD 0<D\D $ +H KHFKR HVWH SDVR GH DFRPSDxDPLHQWR GHO DVHVRUDPLHQWR GHO FHQWUR KDFLD RWURV VHUYLFLRV 0<D\D2VHDTXH« $+DQVLGRHVWDVLQWHUYHQFLRQHVODVTXHPiVKHPRVKHFKR 0 2 VHD TXH SRU OD SURSLD LGLRVLQFUDVLD GH OD HVFXHOD QR VH KD SRVLELOLWDGR TXH W~ DFFHGDVDOD() $2VHD\RFUHRTXHHQOD()KDSXHVWRDVHVRUDPLHQWRGHVGHODXQLYHUVLGDG6LHPSUH KHVDELGRTXHHVWDEDLVYRVRWUDV 01RQRQR $7UDEDMDQGRPiVRPHQRVRSXGLHQGRDVHVRUDU¢QR" 01RQRQRHVWHFXUVRHV« $$KSXHVDPtPHKDEODURQGHVGHPX\DOSULQFLSLR\DPLPHSDUHFLySXHVTXH\DLJXDO OOHYDEDLVWLHPSR 01RSRUTXHHPSHFpHVWHFXUVR $$KWDPELpQHVFRVDQXHYDHQWRQFHV" 06tVt $9DOHYDOH 0 3HUR ¢W~ FUHHV TXH VL VH IDFLOLWDVH XQD PD\RU SHUPDQHQFLD HQ HO FHQWUR VHUtD QHFHVDULRHODVHVRUDPLHQWRSRUYXHVWUDSDUWHDODVHVLyQGH()RQR" $$KVt$YHUHVRVLHPSUHYLHQHGDGRSRUODGHPDQGDGHOSURIHVRUGH()\GHOPLVPR WXWRU\GHODLGLRVLQFUDVLDGHODOXPQR¢QR"2VHDHVWDFRODERUDFLyQHQRWURVFDVRVKD H[LVWLGR HQ TXH QRV VHQWiEDPRV HO SURIHVRU GH () OD SHUVRQD TXH D\XGDED D QLYHO ILVLRWHUDSLD DO DOXPQR R D QLYHO DGDSWDFLyQ GH ORV SURJUDPDV D QLYHO GLGiFWLFR FDUD DO DOXPQR \ \R (Q HVWH WULiQJXOR SXHV Vt TXH tEDPRV HODERUDQGR D YHFHV SXHV VHQWLPLHQWRV UHODFLRQHV SHUVRQDOHV FDSDFLGDG GH DSUHQGL]DMH FRPSUHQVLyQ GH« HWF¢QR"(VWR\R« 0/RKDVKHFKR $+HWUDEDMDGRHQHVWHVHQWLGRHQRWURVFHQWURVSHURHQHVWHPRPHQWR\HQHVWHFHQWUR 5 QRVHKDGDGRHVWDGHPDQGDWRGDYtD 0 $K PX\ ELHQ ¢&UHHV TXH HV SRVLEOH OD LQFOXVLyQ GHO DOXPQDGR FRQ GLVFDSDFLGDG PRWUL]HQODFODVHGH()"(QJHQHUDOWHGLJRSRUWRGDODH[SHULHQFLDTXHWLHQHV $ 6t HQ JHQHUDO Vt SRUTXH Vt KH YLVWR SURIHVLRQDOHV GH () WUDEDMDQGR FRQ DOXPQRV 5 GLVFDSDFLWDGRV PRWULFHV \ WDO \ IDFLOLWDQGR SXHV HO DFHUFDPLHQWR FXDQWR PiV PHMRU GHO DOXPQRDOHMHUFLFLR\GHOJUXSRGHDOXPQRVDHVWHDOXPQRHQHOVHQWLGRGHFRPSDUWLUOD H[SHULHQFLD¢QR"6HDHQVLOODGHUXHGDVXRWURTXHHUDSDUDOtWLFRSHURTXHFDPLQDEDVROR TXHFDPLQDPX\PD\RU\WHQtDHOFDPLQDUPX\LQVHJXURFRQPXFKDVFDtGDVHWF¢QR" HUDXQSDUDOtWLFRFHUHEUDOSHURVtKHYLVWRTXHHVWRVHKDGDGRVHKDGDGRFRQJXVWRSRU SDUWH GHO DOXPQR SRU SDUWH GHO SURIHVRUDGR \ WDPELpQ FRQ FRPSUHQVLyQ SRU SDUWH GHO DOXPQDGR DKRUD HV FLHUWR OR TXH KDEOiEDPRV GH TXH KDVWD FLHUWR PRPHQWR SRUTXH PLHQWUDVVRQMXHJRVPiVRPHQRVQHJRFLDEOHV\FRQPXFKDVYDULHGDGHVHVWDLQWHJUDFLyQ HVIiFLODODTXHHQWUDPRVHQXQMXHJRGHSRUWLYRHQTXHORVFKDYDOHVSXHVOXFKDQWRGRV FRQWRGRVSDUDODSHORWDTXLHQWRTXHPiVSHORWDVHVTXLHQJDQDSXHVDYHFHVHQHVWH DIiQSRUHOMXHJRSXHVOHVKDFHROYLGDUXQSRFRHVWHFRPSDxHURSXHVTXHQRHVWDQKiELO LJXDOHOFRPSDxHURWDPELpQVHTXHGDXQSRFRPiVOHQWRIXHUDGHOSHORWyQTXHVLJXHQD ODSHORWDHQGHWHUPLQDGRVFDVRVHWF 3HUR GLUtDPRV KDVWD FXDUWR R DVt VH QHJRFLDED EDVWDQWH ELHQ HO FRPSDUWLU ¢QR" OD LQWHUDFFLyQDOXPQRVSURIHVRU\DOXPQRFRQGLVFDSDFLGDG 0¢<W~TXHGHWHFWDVPiVSUREOHPDVDSDUWLUGHWHUFHUFLFOR\VHFXQGDULD" $<RKHWUDEDMDGRHQ((\WDQWRHQHOSDWLR()SDWLROLEUHGHMXHJROLEUHFRPRGHQWUR GHODVDFWLYLGDGHVGHFODVHFDSWiEDPRVTXHKDVWDFXDUWRHODOXPQDGRHVPX\UHFHSWLYR D OD JXtD \ HO OLGHUD]JR GHO SURIHVRU QHFHVLWD SLGH \ DFHSWD FRQ PXFKR JXVWR SHUR D SDUWLUGHTXLQWR\DVRQPX\FDSDFHVDOPHQRVHQODVHVFXHODVGRQGH\RKHWUDEDMDGROHV YHPRVPX\FDSDFLWDGRVSDUDRUJDQL]DUVXVFRVDVSRUHMHPSORMXHJRVWLSRJLPQFDPDR MXHJRVWLSRPDWHPiWLFDHQMXHJRVHQHOSDWLR(QWRQFHVHVTXHORVGHTXLQWR\VH[WR\D HUDQ FRPR ORV PRQLWRUHV TXH SUHSDUDEDQ SDUD TXH MXJDUDQ ORV PiV SHTXHxRV ORV GH SiUYXORVORVGHFLFORLQLFLDO\PHGLDQRHWF¢QR"<HVWDDXWRQRPtDHVWDFDSDFLGDGGH YLJLODU HOORV PLVPRV GHQWUR GHO JUXSR OD GLQiPLFD TXLpQ KDFH TXLpQ QR KDFH TXLpQ ROYLGDTXLpQUHFXHUGD«HODXWRFRQWUROTXH\DYDQWHQLHQGRGHVtPLVPRV\GHOSHTXHxR JUXSRGHFRPSDxHURVDYHFHVOHVGDEDXQQLYHOGHFRPSHWHQFLDPiVDOHMDGRFDGDYH] PiV GH XQ QLYHO GH HVWRV QLxRV GLVFDSDFLWDGRV TXH HQ PXFKRV FDVRV HQ QLYHOHV LQIHULRUHV HUDQ PX\ PX\ LQWHJUDGRV PX\ DFHSWDGRV \ PX\ FRPSUHQGLGRV SHUR TXH D HVWDV HGDGHV SDUHFH TXH HO SDVR GH ORV FRPSDxHURV GH TXLQWR \ VH[WR HV XQ SDVR GH JUDQGHVSDVRV\GHPXFKRDGHODQWR\HOORVFRPRTXHVHTXHGDUDQVLQSRGHUFRPSHWLU\D D QLYHO GH FODVH D YHFHV HQ FRPSHWHQFLD GH HVWXGLRV GH FDSDFLGDG GH DSUHQGL]DMH D QLYHOGHSDWLRSXHVKDELOLGDGHVHVWDVGHRUJDQL]DFLyQ\GHJHVWLyQ\GHFUtWLFD\WDO +HPRV YLYLGR HQ PXFKRV FDVRV TXH KDVWD HQ FXDUWR OD LQWHJUDFLyQ QRV HUD IiFLO SRU GHFLUOR GH DOJXQD IRUPD \ YLpQGRPH D PL WDPELpQ FRPR PDHVWUD GH DXOD RUGLQDULD \ FRPRSURIHGH((\WDOQRVUHVXOWDEDDWRGRVPiVIiFLOKDVWDFXDUWRTXHOXHJRVHQRV KDFtDODFRVDXQSRFRPiVGLItFLO\RGLUtDTXHSRUHOQLYHOTXHOOHJDQDDOFDQ]DUHOJUXSR FODVHQRVp 06tVt $,JXDOSXHVHVXQDH[SHULHQFLDPiVRPHQRVODUJDRPiVRPHQRVFRUWDQRVpSHUR QRVPRYtDPRVXQSRFRFRQHVWHSDUiPHWURHQODVHVFXHODV 0 &XDQGR HPSLH]DQ D SDUWLU GH TXLQWR SRGUtDPRV GHFLU D PDUJLQDU DO DOXPQR FRQ GLVFDSDFLGDG $<RGLUtDTXHVLQTXHUHU« 02DQRWHQHUORHQFXHQWDDQRWHQHUORWDQHQFXHQWD $6LQTXHUHUSRUTXHOHVYDQDSUHFLDQGROHVTXLHUHQ\RDKRUDYR\UHFRUGDQGRFDVRV QLxRVFRQFUHWRVFRPRHOORVKDEODEDQGHOJUXSR\HOJUXSRKDEODEDGHHOORVSRUHMHPSOR ¢QR"3XHV\RFUHRTXHQRHVSRU«HVTXHHVVXLPSXOVRQDWXUDOOHVOOHYDDDYDQ]DUD XQRV QLYHOHV TXH WDO YH] RWURV QR SXHGHQ OOHJDU WHQGUtDPRV VLHPSUH TXH KDFHU GLVWLQFLRQHV GH XQD SHUVRQD D RWUD SRUTXH SXHV WDPELpQ FXHVWD XQ SRFR JHQHUDOL]DU ¢QR" 0&ODUR $3HURSRUHMHPSORHVWHSDUDOtWLFRTXH\ROHHQVHxpDOHHUFXDQGRpOHVWDEDHQQLYHOGH WHUFHURGHSULPDULDVHKDEtDLQWHQWDGRHQVHxDUOHFRPRDWRGRVSHURQROOHJDPRVDOQLYHO GH OHFWXUD KDVWD HVWDV HGDGHV ¢QR" SXHV pO HPSH]y D YHUEDOL]DU FXDQGR HVWDED HQ FXDUWR\D³<RFRQHVWDVSLHUQDVQRYR\DQLQJXQDSDUWH´ 0<D $ < WHQHU \D TXH HPSH]DU D WUDEDMDU SXHV VX DXWRHVWLPD VX LPDJHQ FRUSRUDO VXV 5 FDSDFLGDGHV VXVSRVLELOLGDGHVVXVKDELOLGDGHV SURSLDV \ HPSH]y \D D YHUEDOL]DUOR OR TXH\RSLHQVRTXH\DGHEtDOOHYDUWLHPSRSHUFLELpQGROR 0&ODUR $ < HUD MRYHQFLWRHVWDEDHQFXDUWRFRQ HGDG GH TXLQWR \ PHGLR VH[WR HK SRUTXH GH SHTXHxtQ FRPR QR FDPLQDED HPSH]y HO SDUYXODULR \D PD\RUFLWR HQ FRPSDUDFLyQ GHO JUXSRFODVH¢QR" 0<D\D $3RUTXHFXDQGRYLQRVyORLEDDJDWDV 0<D $3HURVtTXHHOORVWLHQHQODSHUFHSFLyQGHODGLIHUHQFLDORTXHQRVKDFHSHQVDUHQTXH 5 KD\DVXIULPLHQWR\WDOEDVWDQWHWHPSUDQRSHURTXH\DOOHJDDVHUYHUEDOL]DGRSRUHOJUXSR FODVHHQODVWXWRUtDVDYHFHVSXHVTXH\DSXHVGLFHQ³3XHVDQGD\DSXHVDKRUDDPt TXHHVWpRWURHQODPHVDFRQHVHSRUTXH\R\DKHHVWDGREDVWDQWHWLHPSR´¢QR" 0&RPSUHQGR $ (O FRPSDxHUR DXQTXH OH DSUHFLD DXQTXH OR FRPSUHQGH SRUTXH WRGD OD YLGD OH KDQ 5 YLVWR FRPR XQ FRPSDxHUR SHUR TXH D YHFHV HOORV SXHV \D TXLHUHQ LU PiV UiSLGR \ SUHILHUHQWHQHUXQFRPSDxHURSXHVTXHVHDPiVFRPSHWHQWHRORTXHVHD¢QR"2VLQR MXHJRSXHVVHUiSRUSDUDUODSHORWDRVHUiSRUHQFHVWDUPHMRURORTXHVHD¢QR" 06tVt $1RVpSUHJ~QWDPHW~TXHQRPHHQUROOHSRUGRQGHQRWHLQWHUHVH 01RQRTXHPX\ELHQTXHPX\LQWHUHVDQWH¢&RQVLGHUDVTXHHQODVLWXDFLyQDFWXDOOD HVFXHOD SHUPLWH GDU UHVSXHVWDV D ODV 1HFHVLGDGHV HGXFDWLYDV GHO DOXPQDGR FRQ GLVFDSDFLGDGPRWUL]HQODVHVLyQGH()"(VDOJRTXHGLFHV³\RFUHRHQODLQFOXVLyQHV SRVLEOH SRU WRGDV ODV H[SHULHQFLDV«´ SHUR ¢/D HVFXHOD HVWi SUHSDUDGD SDUD GDU HVWD UHVSXHVWD"3RUODH[SHULHQFLDTXHWLHQHV $ +RPEUH \R GLJR TXH HQ ODV SULPDULDV HQ ODV HVFXHODV GH SULPDULD TXH KHPRV LGR 5 FRQRFLHQGR SXHV SRU VHPLQDULRV TXH KHPRV KHFKR \ TXH YDV R\HQGR GH RWURV SURIHV ¢QR"TXHVLPLUDTXHWHYR\DOHHU«4XHHQSULPDULDHOSURIHVRUDGRHQWUDDODVQXHYH\ VDOHDODVFLQFR\HVWiWRGRHOGtDORVPLVPRVSURIHVRUHVDOOtHQWRQFHV\RFUHRTXHHVWD XQLIRUPLGDGGHKRUDULRSUHVWDSRVLELOLGDGHVGHDGDSWDFLyQGHOKRUDULRGHODVVHVLRQHVGH OD DWHQFLyQ LQGLYLGXDO« KD\ HVFXHODV HQ TXH HO SURIHVRUDGR SXHV FRPSDUWH FRQ ORV SURIHVRUHVGHVRSRUWHHOSURIHVRUGH((VLWLHQHQDOJXLHQPiVSXHVSDUDOHQJXDMHRSDUD JUXSRVGHGLYHUVLGDGRORTXHVHDORVUHFXUVRVKXPDQRVWLHQHWRGRVGHQXHYHDFLQFR HQWRQFHV HVWiQ EDVWDQWH GLVSXHVWRV HQ JHQHUDO EDVWDQWH GLVSXHVWRV D SDUWLFLSDU HQ XQ SUR\HFWRFRP~QTXHSXHGDVHULQWHJUDGRU\RFUHRTXHVHSXHGHJHQHUDOL]DUEDVWDQWHD SDUWHGHODVHVFXHODVHQODVTXH\RKD\DWUDEDMDGRFUHRTXHVHSXHGHJHQHUDOL]DUSRUOR TXH\RYHQJRR\HQGR¢QR"\TXHORVHVSDFLRVHOSDWLRODVDODSXHVGHPXOWLXVRVRWDO SXHV ORV HVSDFLRV VH DGDSWDQ VH RIUHFHQ QR VRQ HVSDFLRV H[FOXVLYRV DTXt HVWH GHSDUWDPHQWRDTXtHORWUR¢QR"HQFDPELRODySWLFDTXHVHWLHQHGHQWURGHORVLQVWLWXWRV GH VHFXQGDULD H[FHSWXDQGR FDVRV PX\ H[FHSFLRQDOHV HQ JHQHUDO HV RWUD ySWLFD HO SURIHVRUDGR WLHQH VX KRUDULR WLHQH VX GHSDUWDPHQWR \ WLHQH VXV HVSDFLRV \ VXV FRPSHWHQFLDV PX\ DFRWDGDV HQWRQFHV HO JUXSR GH JHVWLyQ GH ORV ,(6 WLHQH PD\RUHV GLILFXOWDGHVHQSRVLEOHVDGDSWDFLRQHVRIHUWDVDGDSWDGDVDFLHUWRDOXPQDGR3RUORWDQWR \RGLUtDPXFKRPiVIiFLOHQSULPDULDTXHHQVHFXQGDULDHVWDSRVLELOLGDGGHDGDSWDU\WDO 0¢3HURSULQFLSDOPHQWHSRUODGHGLFDFLyQGHOSURIHVRUDGR" $ 3RU SRGHURIUHFHUIOH[LELOLGDGGHSURJUDPDV HQ HVSDFLRV GLYHUVRVFRQDJUXSDFLRQHV GLYHUVDV\HQSURIHVRUDGRGLYHUVR 0¢<HVRQRORYHVSRVLEOHHQVHFXQGDULD" $(QVHFXQGDULDSXHVFXHVWDPiVSRUTXHHOSURIHVRUGH()WLHQHXQDH[SHFWDWLYDTXH VHVLHQWHWUDLFLRQDGDVLKDFHFRQFHVLRQHVDDOJ~QWLSRGHFDPELRSDUHFHTXHOHVFXHVWD PiV FDPELDUSRUDGDSWDUSDUHFHTXHHVWiQPiVDIHUUDGRVDXQSURJUDPDHVWiQGDUHO TXHFRQYLHQHDHVWDVHGDGHV\TXH\DGLJRH[FHSWXDQGRFLHUWRVLQVWLWXWRVHQORVTXH\R KHFRQRFLGR\KHWHQLGRODVXHUWHGHSRGHUFRODERUDUHQDGDSWDFLRQHVFXUULFXODUHVGH() \GHRWUDVPXFKDVPDWHULDV¢QR"SHURTXHSDUHFHTXHHQHOFRP~QGHORVLQVWLWXWRVHO SURIHVRU HVWi FRQ XQD ySWLFD PiV SHJDGD D XQ SURJUDPD GLJDPRV TXH SDUD HOORV HV 5 ySWLPRHVWiQGDUDGHFXDGRSUiFWLFR\TXHSRUWDQWRODSRVLELOLGDGGHTXHDSULQFLSLRGH FXUVR ³\R WHQJR HVWRV GRV DOXPQRV TXH WHQJR TXH HVWDV \ HVWDV \ HVWDV VHVLRQHV FDPELDUODVPRGLILFDUODVRHQYH]GHKDFHUHVDKDFHUODRWUDHWF´(VWDySWLFDSDUHFH TXHQRVHGHFRQWDQWDIDFLOLGDGSDUHFHTXHOHVHVPiVH[WUDxRKDEODUGHHVWHFDPELRGH ySWLFD 0<D\D $1RVRORHQOD()WDPELpQHQRWUDV« 0<DSHURFHQWUiQGRORHQOD()SLHQVDVTXHHVPiVIOH[LEOHHQWRQFHVHOSURIHVRUGH() 5 GH SULPDULD TXH HO GH VHFXQGDULD HVWi PiV SUy[LPR HQWRQFHV D ODV DGDSWDFLRQHV FXUULFXODUHVHOGHSULPDULDTXHHOGHVHFXQGDULD¢LQWHUSUHWRHVR" $6t6t6t<QRVRODPHQWHSRUTXHHVGH()VLQyVtSRUTXHODLQVWLWXFLyQSULPDULD\D OOHYDPXFKRVDxRVGHSUiFWLFDGHLQWHJUDFLyQGHDOXPQRVSRUVXVFDUDFWHUtVWLFDV\SRUVX IOH[LELOLGDGHOSURIHVRUDGRGHSULPDULDKDOOHJDGRDWHQHUp[LWRVRDYDORUDUKDDSUHQGLGR D YDORUDU p[LWRV HQ OD HYDOXDFLyQ GH ORV SURJUHVRV GHO DOXPQDGR VHD GLJDPRV HO PiV QRUPDOL]DGR\HOPiVHVSHFLDOHQFDPELRHQVHFXQGDULDSRUORTXHVHDVHKDHQWUDGR PX\WDUGHHQODySWLFDSRUHMHPSORHQ%DUFHORQDKDFHSRFRVDxRVTXHHVWiQDSOLFDQGR OD(62IXHGRQGHPiVWDUGHVHDSOLFyOD(62 0<D $ 6L YDV D 0DUHVPH R YDV DO 9DOOpV D %DGDORQD R 6DEDGHOO KD\ PiV SUiFWLFD HQ OD 5 LQWHJUDFLyQWDOYH]DOOtSRGHPRVHQFRQWUDULQVWLWXWRVPiVLQWHJUDGRUHVFRQPiVSUiFWLFD PH FRQVWD DOJ~Q LQVWLWXWR GHO 9DOOpV HQ TXH VH HVWi KDFLHQGR DOJ~Q WUDEDMR EXHQR GH LQWHJUDFLyQ¢QR"3HURDTXtHQ%DUFHORQDGRQGH\RDKRUDHVWR\SDUHFHTXHKD\PHQRV H[SHULHQFLDGHFODXVWURHQFXDQWRDGDSWDFLyQHQFXDQWRDYDORUDFLyQ\HYDOXDFLyQGHVGH XQDVySWLFDVDGDSWDWLYDV(VWRHVORTXH\RTXLHURGHFLU&RPRySWLFDGHOSURIHVRUDGRQR SRUTXHORVLQVWLWXWRVQRWHQJDQUHFXUVRVSRUTXHORVWLHQHQWLHQHQVXPDWHULDOWLHQHQVXV HVSDFLRV\WDOWLHQHQORVYDULDEOHV\WDOTXHVHSUHVWDQDGDURIHUWDVDGHFXDGDVSHURKD KDELGR ~OWLPDPHQWH HVWi KDELHQGR XQD WHQGHQFLD D WUDQVIRUPDU ORV YDULDEOHV HQ PRQRJUiILFRVGHODVPDWHULDVFRPXQHV 0<D $1RHQYHUGDGHURVFDQDOHVGHGLYHUVLILFDFLyQFXUULFXODU 0(QWLHQGR $ <R HVWR OR KH YLYLGR HQ HVWRV DxRV TXH KH HVWDGR HQ VHFXQGDULD KD KDELGR XQD WHQGHQFLD SRU SHGLUOR HO SURIHVRUDGR SRU WHPRU D TXH QR VDOLHUDQ EDVWDQWH SUHSDUDGRV SDUDSRGHUDFFHGHUDOEDFKLOOHUDWRHWF¢QR"WDPELpQVHWHQGUtDTXHHVWXGLDULQVWLWXWRSRU LQVWLWXWRHVWRSHURKD\XQSRFRHVWHHVWLORSDUHFHHQ%DUFHORQD 00X\LQWHUHVDQWHPX\LQWHUHVDQWH<\DSRU~OWLPR¢&yPRYHVHOIXWXURGHODLQFOXVLyQ GHODOXPQDGRFRQGLVFDSDFLGDGPRWUL]HQODVHVLyQGH()"¢&yPRWHJXVWDUtDTXHIXHUD" $%XHQR\RKHYDORUDGRPXFKRORVSDUDOtPSLFRVSRUHMHPSORHQ%DUFHORQD\RFUHRTXH IXH XQD HVFXHOD GH RSLQLyQ S~EOLFD GLJDPRV \ FDGD YH] TXH VH KDFHQ PDUFKDV R FRPSHWLFLRQHVSXHVGHFLHJRVRGHFyPRVHDHQTXHHOFLXGDGDQRVHYDIDPLOLDUL]DQGR FRQ ODV FRPSHWHQFLDV GLYHUVDV TXH FDGD TXLHQ SRGHPRV WHQHU \ FRQ OD FDSDFLGDG GH SODFHUTXHWHQHPRVGHUHFKRDGHVDUUROODUSXHV\RFUHRTXHODySWLFDGHOFLXGDGDQRSRU WDQWRHOSDGUHGHIDPLOLDRHOSURIHVRUDGRYDQHQWUDQGRHQXQDySWLFDSXHVPiVDPSOLD PiVFRPSUHQVLYDGLJDPRVQRWDQHVWUHFKLWDGHORTXHVRQFRPSHWLFLRQHVGHpOLWH\EDVWD \D¢QR"(QWRQFHVDPLPHGDODLPSUHVLyQTXHFRPRFLXGDGDQtDVHHVWiSDVDQGRGHVGH XQDVpSRFDVHQTXHHOQLxRHQVLOODGHUXHGDV\RGLFODVHDXQRHQTXHQRVDOLyGHVX FDVD\IXHHVFRODUL]DGRKDVWDDxRVHQFDVDQRIXHDQLQJ~QFHQWURKDVWDYHUORSXHV SRUDFDOOHYHUODJHQWHTXHHVWi\HQGRDOFLQHHVWiHQWUDQGRHQDOPDFHQHV\SRUWDQWR YHRTXHFRPRFLXGDGDQRHOFLXGDGDQRORHVWiFRPSUHQGLHQGR/RTXHQRVpHVFyPROD /H\ GH &XDOLGDGWHQGUiFRPSUHQGLGDHVWD IRUPD GH WUDEDMR QR Vp D YHUDTXpQLYHOHV VREUHWRGR D QLYHOHV GH DGROHVFHQFLD TXH HV FXDQGR \R FUHR TXH HO SODFHU SRU OD FRPSHWLFLyQSRUHOPRYLPLHQWRSRUHOHVWDUHQSRGHUPiVHWFHVXQVHQWLPLHQWRTXHVH H[SUHVDPX\IXHUWHPHQWHHQHODGROHVFHQWH¢QR"DYHUFyPRHVWROOHJDUiDORVLQVWLWXWRV VLHQYH]GHLQWHJUDFLyQORTXHFRPSUHQGHUHPRVHVFODVLILFDFLyQGHDOXPQRV\SRUWDQWR KDEUiXQDVFODVHVGHDOXPQRVGH()VRORSDUDORVTXHWHQJDVGLILFXOWDGHVPRWULFHV\SRU WDQWRORVGHpOLWHLUiQFRQORVGHpOLWH\ORVPHGLDQRVFRQORVPHGLDQRVQRVpVLHVTXHOR TXHYDDFRPSUHQGHUOD&DOLGDGHVODFODVLILFDFLyQQRODFDOLGDG 0<D $ /D FDOLGDG LQGXVWULDO HV VHSDUDU HO REMHWR FRQ WDUD GHO TXH QR WLHQH WDUD VL HV XQD YLVLyQPDWHULDOLVWDGHODFRVDGHODFDOLGDGRVLODFDOLGDGSDVDUtDSRUODFRPSUHQVLYLGDG ODPRGLILFDELOLGDGODDGDSWDFLyQ¢QR" 06t $ < VREUHWRGR OD FRODERUDFLyQ TXH HV D GRQGH YDPRV D TXH HO FLXGDGDQR SXHGD FRODERUDUFRQVXVFRQJpQHUHVDSDUWHSXHVVXGLIHUHQFLDV¢QR" 0&ODURFODUR $&UHRTXHYDSRUDKt 02VHDSLHQVDVTXHSXHGHVHUGHFLVLYDOD/H\GH&DOLGDG¢QR" $6t 04XHLQIOX\HHQODUHVSXHVWDHGXFDWLYD\TXHSXHGHDIHFWDUDODLQFOXVLyQ $ 4XH SXHGH GDU PiV R PHQRV SRVLELOLGDGHV GH TXH HO HVWLOR LQWHJUDGRU \ DGDSWDWLYR OOHJXHDODVHGDGHVDGROHVFHQWHVRQRRYXHOYDDTXHGDUUHOHJDGRDODVHGDGHVSXHVGH ORVSHTXHxLWRVDSDUYXODULR\SULPDULD 0 2 VHD W~ REVHUYDV TXH HQ DGROHVFHQFLD SXHGHQ KDEHU VHULRV SUREOHPDV GH SDUWLFLSDFLyQDFWLYD¢<HQSULPDULDFRQOD/H\GH&DOLGDG" $ <R QR DKRUD HVWRV ~OWLPRV DxRV \R KH HVWDGR PiV HQ VHFXQGDULD TXH HQ SULPDULD SHUR\RFUHRTXHHQSULPDULDVREUHSULPDULDKDQSDVDGRPXFKDVOH\HVGHHGXFDFLyQ\HO SURIHVRUDGRGHSULPDULDTXHHQVXVFHQWURVKDFUHDGRHVFXHODHVFXHODHQHOVHQWLGRGH XQHVWLORSURSLRGHOFHQWURGHHVWHFODXVWUR\KDFUHDGRXQRVFULWHULRVDSHVDUGHFLHUWDV OH\HVGHHGXFDFLyQSXHVKDQDFWXDGRGHXQDIRUPDFRKHUHQWHDGDSWDEOHGHPRFUiWLFD\ VROLGDULDDSHVDUGH¢QR" 0<D\D $ < HVWRV FHQWURV TXH WLHQHQ OD VXHUWH GH WUDEDMDU FRQ XQD SODQWLOOD PiV R PHQRV FRKHVLRQDGDFRQXQRVSDUiPHWURVGHJXtDSXHVYiOLGRVSDUDWRGRV\WDOHVWRVFHQWURVD SHVDUGHOD/H\GH&DOLGDGSXHVDFWXDUDQ«DKRUDELHQHQFHQWURVHQTXHKD\PXFKR FDPELR HQ OD SODQWLOOD SRUTXH SXHV VRQ FHQWURV PHQRV DIRUWXQDGRV SRU HO GHVWLQR \ ORV GHVWLQRV¢QR" 0<D $3XHVVtLJXDOHVWiQVHULDPHQWHDIHFWDGRVSRUXQHVWLORGH/H\QRHVWRQRORVp 5 02VHDOHGDVPXFKDLPSRUWDQFLDDODRUJDQL]DFLyQLQWHUQDGHOFHQWUR $<RVt 0<SLHQVDVTXHSXHGHVHUPX\GHFLVLYD« $PX\GHFLVLYDYDUtDPXFKRVHJ~QHOGHVWLQR 0«HQFXDQWRDODUHVSXHVWD $6t 00X\ELHQ $<RFUHRTXHVt\ODFRRUGLQDFLyQSHGDJyJLFD¢QR" 5 0 0X\ LQWHUHVDQWH ¢< DOJR PiV TXH DxDGLU UHVSHFWR D OD LQFOXVLyQ GHO DOXPQDGR FRQ GLVFDSDFLGDGHQODVVHVLRQHVGH()" $%XHQRVREUHWRGRTXHRVHWLHQHTXH«VHWLHQHTXHHYLWDUGHWRGDVIRUPDVTXHHVWR TXHGHDODEXHQDYROXQWDGGHGHWHUPLQDGRSURIHVRUDGRRVHDTXHQRVHWLHQHTXHFHMDU HQ« 0¢&yPR" $1RVHWLHQHTXHSDUDUHQLQVLVWLUHQSHGLUUHFXUVRVSHUVRQDOHVUHFXUVRVPDWHULDOHV UHFXUVRVLQIRUPiWLFRVHVWDOXFKDSRUORVUHFXUVRVSHUVRQDOHV\PDWHULDOHVRHVSDFLDOHV QRVHSXHGHGHMDUSRUTXHFXHVWDPXFKRHQORVFHQWURVS~EOLFRVREWHQHUORV 0<D $ 3RU WDQWR HV XQD OXFKD SRU DGDSWDU SRU HO DVFHQVRU 3RU HMHPSOR XQ LQVWLWXWR PX\ JUDQGH GH %DUFHORQD FRPR HV HO ,(6 9DOO G¶+HEURQ QR WLHQH DVFHQVRUHV \ WLHQH XQRV WHFKRVPX\DOWRVSRUWDQWRHVXQJUDQLQVWLWXWRTXHQRSXHGHDFHSWDUVLOODVGHUXHGDV 0&ODUR $<HQWRQFHV\RFUHRTXHODOXFKDGHOSURIHVRUDGRSRUHVWRVPHGLRVHVEiVLFD\DGHPiV 5 SRUHOWUDEDMRGHIRUPDFLyQGHOSURIHVRUDGRHQIDYRUGHODFRPSUHQVLyQGHOKHFKRGHOD LQWHJUDFLyQ GHO GHUHFKR D HVWDU HVFRODUL]DGR HQ XQ PHGLR OR PiV QRUPDOL]DGR SRVLEOH HWF¢QR"&UHRTXHHVXQKHFKRTXHHQODS~EOLFDVHUiGHWRGDODYLGDRVHD\RFUHR TXHKD\DOUpJLPHQRHOSROtWLFRTXHKD\HQHO'HSDUWDPHQWRGH(QVHQ\DPHQWVLHPSUH VH HVWDUi SLGLHQGR SRUTXH OD SREODFLyQ VLHPSUH QHFHVLWDUi PiV \ ORV UHFXUVRV SDUD OD S~EOLFDVRQDOJRHVFDVRV 0\D $6RQHVFDVRVVtVt3HUREXHQRVHKDGHVHJXLUHQODEUHFKD¢1R" 0%XHQRSXHVPXFKtVLPDVJUDFLDV $6tDWLSRUTXHVLHPSUHYDELHQUHIOH[LRQDUXQSRFRGHDGXOWRDDGXOWRYDELHQ6t (175(9,67$$/&(1752 $3*-HIDGH(VWXGLRV\0DHVWUDGH(GXFDFLyQ(VSHFLDO )(&+$GHVHWLHPEUHGH 0¢0HSRGUtDVLQGLFDUFyPRIDFLOLWDVHODSR\RDOiUHDGH(GXFDFLyQ)tVLFD()" 5 $ (Q HVWRV PRPHQWRV FRPR PDHVWUD HQ IXQFLRQHV GH (GXFDFLyQ (VSHFLDO (( QR IDFLOLWRHODSR\RDODSURIHVRUDGH()XQDSR\RHVSHFtILFRGHOiUHDVt 0¢<DTXpHVGHELGR" $(QSULPHUOXJDUDTXHODSURIHVRUDDFWXDOPHQWHWLHQHPXFKRVFRQRFLPLHQWRVGH((\ GH HVSLQD EtILGD HQ FRQFUHWR TXH VRQ ORV DOXPQRV TXH HQ HVWH FDVR QRV RFXSDQ TXH WLHQHQGLVFDSDFLGDGPRWUL]<WLHQHPXFKDIRUPDFLyQDOUHVSHFWR<SRURWUDSDUWHSRUTXH SLHQVRTXHHQJHQHUDOHOPDHVWURGH((WLHQHXQDVIXQFLRQHVGHGLQDPL]DUGHSURFXUDU LQIRUPDFLyQ WHQHU FRQWDFWRV HVSHFtILFRV SHUR SRVLEOHPHQWH QR WHQJD TXH VHU HVSHFLDOLVWDHQWRGDVODViUHDVGHOFXUUtFXOXP(VGHFLUQRWLHQHTXHVDEHUP~VLFDSDUD SRGHU GHFLU HO QLxR WLHQH TXH« R HQ HVWH FDVR () SRUTXH VHJXUDPHQWH TXH OD HVSHFLDOLVWD WLHQH PiV UHFXUVRV FRQRFH PiV PDWHULDOHV« \ WLHQH PiV IRUPDFLyQ HVSHFtILFD¢HK" 06t $6tTXH\RSXHGRIDFLOLWDU\WHQHUFRQWDFWRFRQHOFHQWURGHUHKDELOLWDFLyQHQHVWHFDVR FRQMXQWDPHQWHFRQODWXWRUD\ODHVSHFLDOLVWDSDUDYHUFyPRSRGHPRVDGDSWDUFyPRHVWi LQIOX\HQGR HQ RWUDV iUHDV GHO DSUHQGL]DMH HQ VX FUHFLPLHQWR SHUVRQDO TXp VRSRUWH OH SRGHPRVGDUGHVGHRWURWLSR\iPELWRVTXHHQHVWHFDVRVHUtDQPiVHVSHFtILFRVPtRV 0<D\D¢<SXHGHFRQGLFLRQDUWXVLWXDFLyQDFWXDOODERUDO" $6t$SDUWHTXL]iVTXHHVORTXHSULPHURTXHWHQtDPRVTXHKDEHUGLFKR¢QR"'HTXH 5 HQHVWRVPRPHQWRV\DKHGLFKRTXHKDJRIXQFLRQHVGH((SHURTXHHQXQSULQFLSLRPL KRUDULRWLHQHTXHHVWDUGHGLFDGRDORTXHHVGLQDPL]DFLyQSHGDJyJLFDGHFHQWURJHQHUDO FRPRSDUWHGHOHTXLSRGLUHFWLYR\HQSULQFLSLRPLVIXQFLRQHVVRQHVWDV¢HK" 0<D $1RHVDVXPLUODHVSHFLDOLGDGGH(((VFLHUWRTXHHVWDPRVSHQGLHQWHVGHTXHYHQJD DOJXLHQDRFXSDUHVWDSOD]D 0 'H DFXHUGR < EXHQR \D KD VLGR PX\ FODULILFDGRUD OD UHVSXHVWD QR GH SRUTXp FRQVLGHUDVTXHQRHVQHFHVDULRHOVRSRUWHHQODVHVLyQGH()(QWRQFHVSDVDPRVDOD VHJXQGDSUHJXQWD $ 3HUGRQD TXL]iV PH KH ROYLGDGR GHFLU TXH HO VRSRUWH HQ HVWH FDVR HVWDUtD HQ OD 5 FXHVWLyQPiVWpFQLFDGHOFXUUtFXOXPQRHQODSUiFWLFDGLDULDTXHVHUtDORTXH\RHQWLHQGR SRUVRSRUWHDOiUHDGH()6LTXHVLHODOXPQRQHFHVLWDXQDPRGLILFDFLyQFXUULFXODUDTXt VtTXHSLHQVRTXHWHQJRTXHLQWHUYHQLU\R\ODSHUVRQDTXHHVWiRFXSDQGRODSOD]DGH ()3RUTXHFRQpOODYLVLyQGHOFXUUtFXOXP\GHDVSHFWRVSHGDJyJLFRVHQJHQHUDOTXHVH SXHGHQDSOLFDUDHVWDiUHDRDRWUD¢QR" 06t $ < DGHPiV WRGR OR TXH VHUtD PiV OD FXHVWLyQ IRUPDO GH FyPR KDFHU HVWH WLSR GH GRFXPHQWR 0<D\D $3HURWHQGUtDTXHVHUFRQMXQWDPHQWHFRQODHVSHFLDOLVWDTXHHVODTXHGHVSXpVWLHQHOD SUiFWLFDGLDULD\ORVUHFXUVRVPiVHVSHFtILFRV 0¢<W~QRFRQVLGHUDVDSURYHFKDQGR\DHVWDVLWXDFLyQTXHHOLGHDOFXDQGRKDEODPRV GH DSR\R SRU SDUWH GHO SURIHVRU GH (( HO LGHDO HV TXH WXYLHVH ORV VXILFLHQWHPHQWH FRQRFLPLHQWRV \ TXH KXELHVHQ VXILFLHQWHV SURIHVRUHV WDPELpQ GH DSR\R SDUD SRGHU FRODERUDU FRQ HO PDHVWUR GH () HQ OR TXH HV OD RUJDQL]DFLyQ GH OD VHVLyQ" 3RUTXH ORV QLxRVGHYXHVWURFHQWURTXHSUHVHQWDQPRYLOLGDGUHGXFLGDSRUORTXHKHREVHUYDGRKDVWD HOPRPHQWRFUHRTXHSRGUtDPRVIDFLOLWDUODSDUWLFLSDFLyQDFWLYDFRQXQDD\XGDH[WHULRU 3DUD TXH HO SURIHVRU SXHGD GDU UHDOPHQWH SXHGD GDU UHVSXHVWD D ODV QHFHVLGDGHV GH WRGR HO JUXSR \ TXH WDQ VROR VLPSOHPHQWH FRQ XQ DSR\R SXGLpVHPRV REWHQHU XQD SDUWLFLSDFLyQPiVDFWLYD¢7~FUHHVTXHVLHOPDHVWURGH((HVWXYLHVHIRUPDGRHQWRGDV ODViUHDVXQDGHVXVIXQFLRQHVWDPELpQVHUtDODGHGDUHODSR\RDODVHVLyQGH()FRPR VH KDFH HQ PDWHPiWLFDV \ HQ EDVH FRPR VH KDFH KDFLD HO PRGHOR GH OD HVFXHOD LQFOXVLYD" (V GHFLU ³QR VHJUHJXHPRV HQ HO DXOD HVSHFLDO GHPRV HO DSR\R HQ HO DXOD RUGLQDULD´ $ 6t Vt 2EYLDPHQWH VLHPSUH GHVGH HO SXQWR GH YLVWD LQFOXVLYR SRUTXH HQ RWURV 5 DVSHFWRV GHO FXUUtFXOXP ORV DOXPQRV QRUPDOPHQWH QR VDOHQ GHO DXOD VLQR TXH HV OD HVSHFLDOLVWDODSHUVRQDGH((TXHHQWUD 3HURDPtPHSDUHFHTXHHVWRHVXQSRFRSHGLUSHUDVDOROPR\TXHUHUTXHXQDSHUVRQD VHSDGHWRGRVORViPELWRV«%XHQRXQDFRVDHVTXHVHDPRVORVSURIHVRUHVGHSULPDULD VRPRVORVJHQHUDOLVWDV\HVRHVYHUGDGSHURVtTXHKD\XQDVHVSHFLDOLGDGHVFRQFUHWDV TXHHV()P~VLFDLGLRPD\(((QWRQFHVVtTXHSRQHPRVORVSLHVHQODWLHUUDORTXHVt TXHHVFLHUWRHVTXHHVXQSRFRGLItFLOSLHQVRORGHTXHHVWDIRUPDFLyQVHDUHDOPHQWH HQWRGRVORViPELWRVHQWRGRVORVFDPSRV\ORTXHHVFLHUWR\QRHVWiPDOGHOWRGRHV TXH VLQy GLUHFWDPHQWH R OHJDOPHQWH R D QLYHO GH GHFUHWR \ WDO HVWi HVWLSXODGR HQ OD SUiFWLFDVtTXHSDVDTXHODDGPLQLVWUDFLyQ\ORVFROHJLRVOHGDPRVDHVSHFLDOL]DGRVHQ DOXPQRVGH1((0HH[SOLFRKD\FHQWURVTXHWLHQHQQLxRVFRQGLVFDSDFLGDGHVPRWRUDV ORVRWURVSVtTXLFRVGHQWURGHODVSVtTXLFDVORVKD\TXHWLHQHQDOXPQDGRFRQ6tQGURPH GH'RZQORVKD\TXHWLHQHQGpILFLWDXGLWLYR«<HQWRQFHVODSHUVRQDGH((TXHHVWiHQ DTXHO WHDWUR Vt TXH REYLDPHQWH D SDUWH GH OD IRUPDFLyQ JHQHUDO TXH WLHQH KDFH XQD HVSHFtILFDGHQWURGHODIRUPDFLyQSHUPDQHQWHGHOSURIHVRUDGRRHVSHFtILFDRODPLVPD )XQGDFLyQ6tQGURPHGH'RZQ 0<D $<HQWRQFHVVtTXHGDUHVSXHVWD\HVPXFKRPiVIiFLOSDUDHOFODXVWURHQJHQHUDO SRUTXHFRPSDUWHDGHPiVXQWLSRGHHVWUDWHJLDVGHUHFXUVRVGHFRQRFLPLHQWRV\SDUDHO SURIHVRU GH (( TXH PLHQWUDV HVWi HQ HO FHQWUR VH HVSHFLDOL]D HQ DTXHOOR &XDQGR GHVSXpVSDVDDRWUR\VHHQFXHQWUDFRQORVPRWRUHVREYLDPHQWHKDUiXQDIRUPDFLyQHQ DTXHOVHQWLGR 0&RPSUHQGR $¢(K"3RUTXHXQDFRVDHVDQLYHOJHQHUDO\DQLYHOLGtOLFR\ODRWUDFRVDHVHOGtDDGtD \ REYLDPHQWH OD FXHVWLyQ \D GH LQWHULRULGDG SURIHVLRQDO ¢QR" 'H TXH FXDQGR WH HQFXHQWUDV FRQ XQRV DOXPQRV GHWHUPLQDGRV WLHQHV TXH GDUOHV UHVSXHVWD \ VL QR OD WLHQHVWLHQHVTXHEXVFDUWHIRUPDFLyQ 0([DFWDPHQWH $(QHVWHFDVREXHQRSXHVPHSDUHFHTXH\DWHKHUHVSRQGLGR¢QR" 06tVt0X\ELHQ3DVDPRVHQWRQFHVVLWHSDUHFHDODVHJXQGDSUHJXQWD $6t 0¢&UHHVTXHHVSRVLEOHODLQFOXVLyQGHODOXPQDGRFRQGLVFDSDFLGDGPRWUL]HQODVHVLyQ 5 GH()" $ 6t \R SLHQVR TXH Vt < PiV HQ HO FDVR TXH QRV RFXSD SRUTXH SLHQVR TXH HV LPSRUWDQWHFRQFUHWDU¢HK"6LIXHUDXQDGLVWURILDPXVFXODU\GHSHQGHGHTXpJUDGR\GH TXp WLSR GH GLVWURILD WH FRQWHVWDUtD RWUD FRVD (Q QXHVWUR FDVR ORV DOXPQRV OOHYDQ XQD SUyWHVLVFRUWD\DXQTXHVHDFRQD\XGDGHODSUyWHVLVRGHODPXOHWDKDFHQPDUFKDSRU HOORVPLVPRVPiVOHQWDPHQWHVXEHQ\EDMDQHVFDOHUDV«(QWRQFHV\RSLHQVRTXHHOORV KD\ PXFKRV DVSHFWRV GH OD () TXH ORV SXHGHQ UHDOL]DU 2EYLDPHQWH QR SXHGHQ KDFHU XQD FDUUHUD GH UHVLVWHQFLD ¢QR" 3HUR Vt TXH D OR PHMRU SXHGHQ FURQRPHWUDU R OOHYDU KDFHU RWURV DVSHFWRV TXH SXHGHQ D\XGDU HQ DTXHO PRPHQWR D OD SURIHVRUD \ GHVSXpV HOORVSXHGHQKDFHURWURWLSRGHHMHUFLFLRVTXHDORPHMRUWLHQHQPiVFDSDFLGDGTXHKDQ GHVDUUROODGRPiVODVH[WUHPLGDGHVVXSHULRUHV\WLHQHQPiVIXHU]DTXHORVFRPSDxHURV (QWRQFHVSXHGHQVHUYLUGHPRGHORRGHHMHPSOR\\DWHGLJR\RQRHQWLHQGRPXFKRGHO iUHD SHUR D PL PH SDUHFH TXH HQ HVWH FDVR TXH QRV RFXSD Vt TXH HVWRV DOXPQRV SXHGHQHVWDUGHQWURGHOFODVHGH()DGDSWDQGRREYLDPHQWHDOJXQRVHMHUFLFLRV\RWURV REYLDPHQWH QR ORV SXHGHQ KDFHU \ QR ORV WLHQHQ TXH KDFHU SRUTXH OR TXH HVWi \ \R SLHQVR TXHHVWRWLHQHTXHSULPDUVLHPSUH HV TXH OR TXH QR SRGHPRVKDFHUFRQHVWRV DOXPQRV\DRWURVFRQRWURWLSRGHGLVFDSDFLGDGHVHQIUHQWDUORVVLHPSUHDOIUDFDVR 0&ODUR $1RSRUTXHUHUTXHKDJDORTXHKDFHWRGRHOPXQGRWLHQHQTXHLU\PLHQWUDVRWURVYDQ FRUULHQGR HOORV LU DQGDQGR FRQ OD PXOHWD TXH ORV RWURV WDUGDQ PLQXWRV \ HOORV D OR PHMRUWDUGDQKRUDV(VWRHVHQIUHQWDUORVDOIUDFDVR\DTXHpOQRSXHGHKDFHUOR\HVR QR HV EXHQR SDUD HO GHVDUUROOR LQWHJUDO \ SHUVRQDO TXH FRPR (( HV OR TXH D PL PH LQWHUHVDVREUHWRGR 01RVLQWHUHVDDWRGRVHYLWDUOR¢QR"/DVIUXVWUDFLRQHVLQQHFHVDULDV $([DFWRH[DFWR 0%XHQR\SDUDILQDOL]DU¢&RQVLGHUDVTXHODVLWXDFLyQGHHVWDHVFXHODSXHGHSHUPLWLU GDUUHVSXHVWDDODVQHFHVLGDGHVHGXFDWLYDVGHODOXPQRFRQGLVFDSDFLGDGPRWUL]HQODV VHVLRQHVGH()"6tRQR\TXpGLILFXOWDGHVGHWHFWDV¢QR"'HVGHODVGRVYHUWLHQWHVTXH DVXPHV WDQWR FRPR SURIHVRUD FRPR HVSHFLDOLVWD GH (( \ FRPR PLHPEUR GHO HTXLSR GLUHFWLYR¢4XpGLILFXOWDGHVSXHGHVHQFRQWUDU\FXiOHVVRQODVSURSXHVWDVGHPHMRUD" $%XHQRPLUD\R« 08QSRTXLWRKDFHUODFDUWDGHORVUH\HVPDJRV¢QR" $6tSHUIHFWR\RWHDJUDGH]FRORTXHKDVGLFKRGHOD((GHVGHODSHUVSHFWLYDSRUTXH HQSULQFLSLRDKRUDQRHVWR\LQYROXFUDGDGLUHFWDPHQWHDOSHURVtTXHHVYHUGDGTXH HVFRPSHWHQFLDFRPRHTXLSRGLUHFWLYRWHQHUHQFXHQWDHVWRVDVSHFWRV\DSDUWHQXHVWUR 5 SUR\HFWRHGXFDWLYRDVtORUHFRJH(QWRQFHV\RSLHQVRTXHVtTXHHVWHFROHJLRSXHGHGDU UHVSXHVWD D HVWRV DOXPQRV REYLDPHQWH HV XQ FDPLQR TXH KHPRV HPSH]DGR \ TXH VH WLHQHTXHLUDPSOLDQGR\PHMRUDQGRPXFKtVLPR <\DKHGLFKRDQWHVTXHODSURIHVRUDGH()DSDUWHGHTXHHVPX\WLHQHIRUPDFLyQHQ 5 HVWHDVSHFWR<DQWHVPHKDVGDGRXQDLGHD\HVYHUGDGTXHLJXDOTXHORVUHIXHU]RVGHO FROHJLRGHODVSHUVRQDVTXHOLEUDQVHRFXSDQGHD\XGDUGHQWURGHODXODVLHPSUHDOWXWRUD SRGHU DGDSWDU R D\XGDU DO DOXPQR D KDFHU XQ HMHUFLFLR R XQ WUDEDMR GHWHUPLQDGR SRVLEOHPHQWH \ HVR HV XQD FRVD TXH QR VH KDEtD WHQLGR KDVWD DKRUD HQ FXHQWD VH WHQGUtD TXH WHQHU HQ FXHQWD WDPELpQ D OD KRUD GH FRQWDU FRQ OD () SDUD SURJUDPDU WDPELpQUHIXHU]RV(QHVRPHKDVGDGRXQDLGHD\WHGR\ODUD]yQSLHQVRTXHHVWRHV XQDSURSXHVWDGHPHMRUD\VHSXHGHLQFOXLUDGHPiV\D < D SDUWH FRQWDPRV FRQ WRGD HVWD H[SHULHQFLD TXH HVWH DxR FRQ WX FRODERUDFLyQ TXH 5 SLHQVRTXHQRVYDDVHUPX\~WLO<KD\ODVHQVLELOLGDGSRUSDUWHGHOFODXVWURHQJHQHUDO GHSRGHUFDPLQDUHQHVWDOtQHD<RSLHQVRTXHGHWRGRHVWRDSDUWLUGHODxRTXHYLHQHVH SRGUiHQIRFDUGHGLIHUHQWHIRUPD $SDUWHGHTXHWDPELpQWHQHPRVHOVRSRUWH\«SHURQRVRORPRUDOVLQyHQFRQFUHWRGHO LQVSHFWRU¢QR"4XHYLHQHWHGDHVWHDUWtFXORHVWDELEOLRJUDItDHVWRTXHWHSXHGHD\XGDU HVWDH[SHULHQFLD«¢QR"'HKHFKRQRVKDIDFLOLWDGRHOTXHQRVSRQJDPRVHQFRQWDFWR FRQWLJR\HVXQDPDQHUDGHSRGHUGLQDPL]DUHOiUHDGH()FRQORVDOXPQRVGH1(( 00X\ELHQ¢<DOJRPiVTXHDxDGLUDOUHVSHFWRTXHFRQVLGHUHVTXHVHDRSRUWXQRSDUD LQFOXLUHQHVWDHQWUHYLVWD"&RQRFLHQGRHOREMHWLYRGHODLQYHVWLJDFLyQ $ $KRUD HQ SULQFLSLR \R SLHQVR TXH QR TXH GHVSXpV OR EXHQR HV TXH HVWDV FRVDV VH JHQHUDOLFHQOOHJXHQDWRGRHOPXQGR\WRGRHOPXQGRSXHGDWHQHUDFFHVRDHVWHWLSRGH FRVDV 3RUTXH D YHFHV KD\ FRVDV TXH VRQ PX\ VLPSOHV PX\ REYLDV FRPR OR TXH GHFtDPRVDQWHVHOUHIXHU]R\ORFRQVWDTXHPLVFRPSDxHURVWDPSRFRHVXQDFRVDTXH QXQFDVHWLHQHHQFXHQWD2SRUTXH\DQRKDFHQ()SRUTXHVRQFDVRVJUDYHVRSRUTXH VHDGDSWDVREUHODPDUFKDQRTXHGDUHJLVWUDGR\TXHGDDFDUJRGHODSURIHVRUD¢QR" 0&ODUR $3RUTXHHOKHFKRGHHVWDUDODLUHOLEUHGHTXHQRTXHGHFRQVWDQFLDSRUHVFULWRGHTXH QR«SDUHFHTXHQRQHFHVLWHWDQWRVRSRUWH\ELHQPLUDGRQRHVDVt 'H WRGDV IRUPDV \R SLHQVR TXH DO DFDEDU WRGR HVWH SURFHVR \ HO REMHWLYR GH HVWD LQYHVWLJDFLyQSRGUHPRVKDFHUXQDYDORUDFLyQ\YHUFyPRHOFROHJLRTXHHVORTXHKHPRV DSRUWDGR\TXpDVSHFWRVSRVLWLYRV\TXpDVSHFWRDORPHMRUYDOGUtDODSHQDPHMRUDU6L HVTXHVHGDHOFDVR 00X\ELHQ3XHVPXFKtVLPDVJUDFLDVSRUWXFRODERUDFLyQ $'HQDGD$WL (175(9,67$$/&(1752 &5&0DHVWUDGH(GXFDFLyQ)tVLFDGH0DUtD )(&+$GHMXQLRGH 09DPRVDVLWHSDUHFHYDORUDUORVDVSHFWRVSRVLWLYRV\QHJDWLYRVGHODH[SHULHQFLDTXH KH HVWDGR REVHUYDGR < SDUD HPSH]DU WH SUHJXQWDUtD TXH ¢FyPR GLUtDV TXH KD WUDQVFXUULGR HO SUHVHQWH FXUVR UHVSHFWR D OD LQFOXVLyQ GH 0DUtD GH OD DOXPQD FRQ GLVFDSDFLGDG PRWUL] FyPR YDORUDUtDV VX DFWLWXG VX PRWULFLGDG VX VRFLDELOLGDG« TXp GHVWDFDUtDVHVSHFLDOPHQWH" & \R ¢GH HOOD" <R OD KH YLVWR PX\ DFWLYD \ FRQ JDQDV GH UHODFLRQDUVH FRQ ORV 5 FRPSDxHURVDXQTXHDHOODOHFXHVWDVRQORVFRPSDxHURVORVTXHYDQPiVDEXVFDUODD HOOD QR WLHQGHDLUDEXVFDUOHVSHUROD KH YLVWRIHOL]SRUTXHHOODVHUHtDVHORSDVDED ELHQGHYH]HQFXDQGRVDFDEDVXJHQLRSHURELHQ\RODKHYLVWRPX\ELHQ 0¢<ODDFWLWXGHQWRQFHVHVSRVLWLYD" & 0X\ SRVLWLYD EXHQR SRVLWLYD PXFKR QR SRUTXH HOOD SRGtD KDEHUVH HVIRU]DGR XQ 5 SRTXLWRPiVSHURFDVLDILQDOGHFXUVROHKHYLVWRXQDHYROXFLyQSRUTXHDOSULQFLSLRHOOD HUDXQSRTXLWRPiVUHWUDtGD\\DFDVLDOILQDOHVWDEDPiVFRPXQLFDWLYDPiVSDUWLFLSDWLYD 0¢<VXPRWULFLGDGHQFXDQWRDODYDQFHPRWUL]" 5 & %LHQ SRUTXH HOOD DKRUD \D QR VH DUURGLOOD WDQ IUHFXHQWHPHQWH DEDQGRQDQGR ODV PXOHWDVVLQRTXHFXDQGRWHQtDTXHWUDEDMDUFRQHOODVORKDFtD\VHJ~QTXpFRVDVSXHV SUHJXQWDEDVLORWHQtDTXHKDFHUVLQHOODVRFyPR 0¢<KDLGR«" &<KDLGRHYROXFLRQDQGRHK\RODKHYLVWRPXFKRPHMRUPiViJLOPiVUiSLGDTXHDO SULQFLSLR 0¢6L"¢<GHODVRFLDELOLGDGTXpGHVWDFDUtDV" 5 & %LHQ OR TXH SDVD TXH WHQLHQGR HQ FXHQWD OD DFWLWXG TXH WLHQH HOOD TXH HV EDVWDQWH FHUUDGD TXH OH FXHVWD \ GHSHQGH GHO GtD TXH WLHQH SRUTXH KD\ GtDV TXH HVWi HQFDQWDGRUD\RWURVGtDVTXHVHFLHUUDHQEDQGD\TXHQRKD\IRUPDGH«GHTXHHOOD SXHVTXLHUDKDFHU3HURHQPLFODVHODKHYLVWRPX\ELHQHVWRKDEODQGRSXHVHQHOSDWLR RFXDQGRKDWHQLGRDOJ~QSUREOHPDSXQWXDOFRQDOJ~QDOXPQRHOODQRH[WHULRUL]DVLQRTXH VHUHWUDH\FXDQGRVHOHSUHJXQWDQRKDEODVLQRTXHVHHQFRJHGHKRPEURV'HTXHWRGR OHGDLJXDO\GHTXHQRVDEH\TXHQRVDEH\QRWHH[SOLFDHOSUREOHPD 03HURHQODUHODFLyQFRQVXVFRPSDxHURVSRUORTXHPHKDVGLFKRQRUPDOPHQWHVRQ VXVFRPSDxHURVORVTXHYDQKDFLDHOOD\QRHOODKDFLDVXVFRPSDxHURV &6tHOODQRVXHOHLUDEXVFDUORVSRUTXHFXDQGRKDFHPRVDVtGHJUXSRV³9HQJDDKRUD 5 YDLVDHOHJLUJUXSRV´HOODVLHPSUHVHTXHGDDOILQDOQRWLHQGHDLUDEXVFDUOHVTXHHVXQD GHODVFRVDVTXHKHLQFLGLGRPXFKRGXUDQWHHOFXUVRTXHSRUTXpQRLEDHOOD 03HURXQDYH]TXHVHFRQIRUPDEDQORVJUXSRVW~YHtDVTXH« & 0X\ ELHQ OD UHODFLyQ EXHQD HOOD SDUWLFLSDED VH OR SDVDED SLSD \ LQFOXVR VH 5 DSDODQFDED XQ SRTXLWR ¢HK" SRUTXH TXHUtD HOOD VHU HO FHQWUR \ VHQWLUVH DUURSDGD \ TXHULGDTXHHVOREXHQR¢1R" 03HURW~QRKDVYLVWRSUREOHPDVGHUHFKD]RR« &1RQXQFDDOFRQWUDULRDOFRQWUDULRLQFOXVRFXDQGROHVSDVpODHQFXHVWDTXHW~WLHQHV 5 TXH SDUD KDFHU XQ SRTXLWR OD UHIOH[LyQ GH FyPR HV 0DUtD HOORV OD YDORUDQ PXFKR \ OD TXLHUHQODTXLHUHQTXHHVOREXHQR 0¢&yPRYDORUDUtDVODDFWLWXGGHOJUXSRFODVHDQWHODVDGDSWDFLRQHVGHODVWDUHDVDOR 5 ODUJRGHOFXUVR" &4XHQRVHKDQTXHMDGRDOFRQWUDULRHOORVKDQSDUWLFLSDGR\QRKDQKHFKRQLQJ~QWLSR GH FRPHQWDULR SRUTXH D YHFHV VREUHWRGR FXDQGR HOORV WHQtDQ TXH SRQHUVH HQ OD VLWXDFLyQGH0DUtDDH[FHSFLyQGHDOJXQRTXH\DWLHQGHDTXHMDUVHSRUWRGR«SHURQR 7RGRVKDQWUDEDMDGRLJXDO\ELHQ 0¢<FXDQGRW~SURSRQtDVSRUHMHPSORFRPSHQVDUODVOLPLWDFLRQHVGDQGRXQDVYHQWDMDV 5 HQ ORV MXHJRV EXHQR YHQWDMDV SDUD FRPSHQVDU ODV OLPLWDFLRQHV LQWHUSUHWDV TXH HVDV PHGLGDVODVYDORUDEDQSRVLWLYDPHQWHTXHODVHQWHQGtDQ" &<RFUHRTXHVLSRUTXHDOFRQWUDULRLQFOXVRDYHFHVOHUHFRUGDEDQD0DUtDODVYLGDV TXHWHQtDR«QXQFDKHYLVWRQLQJ~QWLSRGHUHFKD]RDOFRQWUDULR 0¢<SRUSDUWHGH0DUtDWDPELpQW~YDORUDVTXHODVKDDFHSWDGRSRVLWLYDPHQWH" 5 & 6H SRQtD V~SHU FRQWHQWD FXDQGR OH GDEDV HVDV YHQWDMDV VH SRQtD ³X\ TXH ELHQ X\ TXHELHQYDOH´<HOODVDEtDDSURYHFKDUHVDVYHQWDMDV 0¢4XpDVSHFWRVFUHHVTXHKD\TXHVHJXLUSRWHQFLDQGRSDUDPHMRUDUODVRFLDOL]DFLyQGH 5 0DUtD"<DPHORKDVDYDQ]DGRDQWHVXQSRTXLWRSHUR« &(OFDUiFWHUHOFDUiFWHUPiVTXHQDGDTXHHOODURPSDORTXHWLHQHGHQWUR8QDYH]TXH HOODVXHOWHWRGRORTXHWLHQH\RFUHRTXHDYDQ]DUiPXFKRPiV 0¢7~TXpGLUtDV" &4XHHVXQDQLxDLQWURYHUWLGDXQSRTXLWRFHUUDGD 04XHHOSUREOHPD« &9LHQHGHDKt 09LHQHGHHOOD &9LHQHGHHOOD 01RSRUODDFWLYLGDGTXHW~SURSRQHV &1RQRQRQRHVGHHOODHVXQDDFWLWXGGHHOODDORPHMRUHOODVHFUHHTXHHVQRVp 5 FRPR GHFLUOR FRPR XQ HVFXGR TXH WLHQH FXDQGR HQ YH] GH EHQHILFLDUOD OD HVWi HVWURSHDQGR <R FUHR TXH HQ FXDQWR HOOD VH GH FXHQWD GH TXH FRQ HVD DFWLWXG QR FRQVLJXH QDGD TXH VH HVWi SHUMXGLFDQGR \ FDPELH HOOD DYDQ]DUi SHUR HQ WRGRV ORV DVSHFWRV 0¢<FRQVWDWDVTXHWDPELpQHQHODXODWLHQHSUREOHPDV" 5 &(QFODVHPiVSUREOHPDVHQHODXODTXHHQPLFODVHSRUTXHODHQWUHYLVWDTXHWXYLPRV FRQ OD PDGUH GHFtD TXH HOOD YHQtD D OD HVFXHOD PX\ FRQWHQWD SRUTXH OH WRFDED FODVH FODVHGH()HQFDPELRFXDGROHWRFDEDRWUDiUHDSXHVQRTXHODQLxDQRTXHUtDHVWXGLDU \QRTXHUtDKDFHUQDGD\HVRHVORTXHODSUHRFXSDDHOOD 0¢<SRUTXpSLHQVDVTXHYLHQHWDQPRWLYDGDDODFODVHGH()" &3RUTXHOHJXVWDSRUTXHHOODVHHQFXHQWUDPX\SDUWLFLSDWLYD\DGHPiVSRUTXHVHYH LJXDOTXHHOUHVWRGHORVFRPSDxHURVLJXDO 0¢$SHVDUGHVXVOLPLWDFLRQHV" &6tVtVt6HUiSRUODVSURSXHVWDVSRUTXHOHIDFLOLWDPRVTXHSDUWLFLSHDOLJXDOTXHORV GHPiV<RFUHRTXHVtSRUTXHHOODVHHQFXHQWUDPX\LQWHJUDGDGHQWURGHOJUXSR\VDEH TXHVLWHQJRTXHUHxLUDDOJXQR\ODWHQJRTXHUHxLUDHOODTXHORVWUDWRDWRGRVLJXDOQR KDJRGLIHUHQFLDVGHQLQJ~QWLSR 03HURVHJXURTXHHQDOJXQRVDVSHFWRVSLHQVDVTXHVtTXHKD\PiVGLIHUHQFLDV &3XHVQRORVp<RFUHRTXHGHEHKDEHUODVFXDQGRODQLxDQRULQGH3RUTXH\RKHYLVWR 5 XQDHYROXFLyQGH0DUtD\XQDPHMRUtDHQWRGR 0¢(QFXiQWRWLHPSRKDVYLVWRHVDHYROXFLyQ" &3XHVQRVpVXSRQJRTXHDSDUWLUGHPHGLDGRVGHOSULPHUWULPHVWUH3RUTXHDOSULQFLSLR SDUHFtDTXHOHFRVWDEDXQSRFRQRQRVp<RD0DUtDVLHPSUHODKHYLVWRELHQHQPL FODVHODQLxD« 06LHPSUHWHKDSDUWLFLSDGR &6t$ORPHMRUHVSRUTXHWHQHPRVDILQLGDGODVGRVFRQJHQLDPRV\« 0 /XHJR WDO YH] SXHGH VHU SRU ORV MXHJRV TXH W~ SURSRQHV ODV DFWLYLGDGHV TXH OH PRWLYDQ¢QR" &7DPELpQVtVt<SRUTXH« 00iVTXHHQHODXOD &6t\SRUTXHYHTXHVXVFRPSDxHURVQRODUHFKD]DQDOFRQWUDULRODEXVFDQ\TXLHUH 5 TXHHOODTXHVHDXQDPiVLJXDOTXHHOORV 0 ¢3HUR FXDQGR SURSRQHV DFWLYLGDGHV R GLVHxDV ODV DFWLYLGDGHV W~ SLHQVDV HQ HO PRPHQWRTXHGLVHxDVODVDFWLYLGDGHV« & 4XH HOOD SXHGD SDUWLFLSDU LJXDO TXH ORV GHPiV 7RGDV ODV DFWLYLGDGHV ODV KDJR 5 SHQVDQGR HQ TXH WHQJR D 0DUtD TXH WLHQH XQDV OLPLWDFLRQHV TXH HOOD SXHGD GLVIUXWDU MXQWRFRQORVFRPSDxHURV6LHPSUHODVWHQJRTXHDGDSWDU\YDULDUODVSDUDHVRSDUDTXH SXHGDQFRPSHWLUEXHQRSDUDTXHSXHGDQSDUWLFLSDUWRGRVSRUTXH\RQRKDJRWUDEDMRVGH FRPSHWLFLyQSRUTXHVLKD\XQDFRPSHWLFLyQHQWRQFHVHVFXDQGRKD\SUREOHPDV 0<D &3RUTXHWRGRVTXLHUHQJDQDU\HQWRQFHVVtTXHODUHFKD]DUtDQSLHQVR 0¢(LQWHQWDVQRSRWHQFLDUODFRPSHWLFLyQ" &1RSRUHVRSRUTXH« 0<HQODVDFWLYLGDGHVTXHUHVSRQGDQDWRGRVTXHWDPSRFRHOUHVWRGHOJUXSRVHYHD DIHFWDGDSRU0DUtD¢QR" &6tVtLQFOXVRVHJ~QTXpWLSRVGHMXHJRVTXHHPSLH]DXQRTXHHVHOTXHWLHQHTXH 5 SLOODUHOODPHGLFH³<RWDPELpQTXLHURSLOODU´\HOODSLOODLJXDOTXHORVGHPiV 02VHDTXHDVXPHWRGRVORVUROHV &7RGRVORVUROHV7RGRORTXHKDFHQVXVFRPSDxHURVORKDFHHOODLJXDO 02VHDW~SLHQVDTXHDKtHVWiHOTXLGGHODFXHVWLyQ¢QR" 5 &(OTXLGSRUTXHHOODHVSRUHVRVtVt<TXHHOODKDFHORPLVPRTXHHOUHVWRTXH\RQR KDJRQLQJXQDGLIHUHQFLD\HVRHVORTXHYDORUDHOOD<HQWRQFHVHQHVHPRPHQWRTXHHOOD HVWiWUDEDMDQGRQRVHDFXHUGDGHTXHWLHQHXQDGLILFXOWDG 0(OKHFKRGHTXH\RHVWXYLHVHREVHUYiQGRWH¢WHKDKHFKRVHQWLULQFyPRGDHQDOJXQD RFDVLyQ" &$OFRQWUDULRQXQFDQXQFD,QFOXVRHQODYDORUDFLyQTXHKHKHFKRGHILQDOGHFXUVROR 5 SRQJRPX\FODURTXHDJUDGH]FRPXFKRHOTXHKD\DVYHQLGRSRUTXHPHKDVHQVHxDGR PXFKR QR D QLYHO SURIHVLRQDO EXHQR WDQWR D QLYHO SURIHVLRQDO FRPR SHUVRQDO SDUD Pt KDVVLGRPLiQJHOGHODJXDUGDWHORGLJRHQVHULR0HKDVGDGRXQDFDUJDGHPRUDO\GH SRVLWLYLGDG TXH QR Vp H[SUHVDU FRQ SDODEUDV OR TXH VLHQWR <R PH KH VHQWLGR PX\ YDORUDGDSRUWtPHJXVWDUtDTXHVLHPSUHYLQLHUDV¢4XpSDODEUDHK" 0¢3HURTXpWHKHSRGLGRDSRUWDUVL\RHVWDEDREVHUYDQGR" &¢4XpPHKDVSRGLGRDSRUWDU"6HJXULGDGHQPtPLVPDSRUTXH\RDYHFHVWHQtDPLHGR GHQRVDEHUKDFHUELHQPLWUDEDMR\QRHVWDUSHQGLHQWHGH0DUtD<W~PHGHFtDVTXH\R SXHVTXHHVWDEDKDFLpQGRORELHQ 02VHDWHKHDVHJXUDGRWDOYH]« &6tPHKDVGDGRPXFKDFRQILDQ]D 03HURSRUHOKHFKRGHFRLQFLGLUHQ« &1R\SRUORTXHPHGHFtDV3RUORTXHPHGHFtDVTXHORYHtDVWRGRPX\ELHQPX\ ELHQ4XHYHtDVD0DUtDTXHHVWDEDTXHWRGDVODVDFWLYLGDGHVHVWDEDQPX\DGDSWDGDVD HOOD$FXpUGDWHDOSULQFLSLRTXH\RGHFtD³%XHQRHVWR\HVSHUDQGRDTXHPHGLJDVHVWR\ HVSHUDQGR´<W~PHGHFtDV³1RVLQRHVQDGDVLQRHVQDGD\DYHUiV´<PHKDVGDGR PXFKDVHJXULGDG\PXFKDFRQILDQ]D 0<DSRUTXHDOSULQFLSLRSDUDUHPRQWDUQRVXQSRFR\RHVWDEDPXFKRPiVGLVWDQWHHQ 5 OD REVHUYDFLyQ HO SULPHU PHV \ PHGLR GHELGR DO SODQWHDPLHQWR LQLFLDO TXH WHQtD GH OD WHVLV³\RPHSRQJRDREVHUYDU\OXHJRLQWHUYHQJR´FXDQGROXHJRPHGtFXHQWDTXHHQ HVHPHV\PHGLRQRWHQtDQLQJ~QVHQWLGRHVHSODQWHDPLHQWRSRUTXHVLQGDUPHFXHQWD LEDGHH[SHUWDLQIDOLEOH$PHGLGDTXHSDVDEDQODVVHPDQDVPHGLFXHQWDTXHWDQWRW~ FRPRODPDHVWUDGHODRWUDHVFXHODDGDSWiEDLV\TXHFRQVHJXtDLVHVDSDUWLFLSDFLyQ <KDVWDTXHFDtHQHOOR\ORKDEOpFRQPLGLUHFWRUGHWHVLVQRHPSHFpDDSXQWDUDOJXQD FRQVLJQD SDUD FRODERUDU HQ WX WUDEDMR /R PiV LPSRUWDQWH HUD DQDOL]DU YXHVWUR SHQVDPLHQWR FRPR GRFHQWHV SRQHUPH HQ YXHVWUR OXJDU < TXH HVWR QR LED UHxLGR FRQ GDURVDOJ~QDVHVRUDPLHQWRSXQWXDOVLORSHGtDLV3RUHVRHQDOJ~QMXHJRFRPSHWLWLYRDO SULQFLSLR WH GHFtD ³GHQWUR GH XQ PHV \ PHGLR WH OR GLUp GHQWUR GH XQ PHV´ < WUDV HQ FDPELR GH SODQWHDPLHQWR WH IDFLOLWp GRV R WUHV FRQVLJQDV PX\ EiVLFDV SDUD DSOLFDU HQ VLWXDFLRQHV GH FRPSHWLFLyQ QR" TXH W~ UiSLGDPHQWH ODV DSOLFDVWH /XHJR KH HVWDGR REVHUYiQGRWH \ UHFRJLHQGR WX WUDEDMR &UHR TXH HO KHFKR GH TXH WH FRQILUPDVH R WH DILUPDVHTXHFRQVLGHUDEDGHTXHORTXHHVWDEDVUHDOL]DQGRHQPLRSLQLyQHUDHIHFWLYR WDPELpQWHKDGDGRPXFKDVHJXULGDG &0XFKDPXFKDVHJXULGDGPXFKDFRQILDQ]DGHYHUGDG3RUTXH\RSHQVDEDTXHDOR 5 PHMRU FRPR HVWR\ VLHPSUH DFRVWXPEUDGD D WUDEDMDU FRQ QLxRV TXH QR WLHQHQ HVWDV « SXHVDOJXQDGLVFDSDFLGDGSXHVTXHPHIDOWDEDQUHFXUVRVSHURW~FXDQGRPHGLMLVWHTXH ORHVWDEDKDFLHQGRPX\ELHQSXHVPHGLVWHXQDFDUJDPX\SRVLWLYD 07HGLVWHFXHQWDTXHQRQHFHVLWDEDVWDQWRVUHFXUVRVFRPRSHQVDEDVTXHSUHFLVDEDV TXH\DHVWDEDVDGDSWDQGRFRUUHFWDPHQWH &6tVtVtVt 0<DIDFLOLWDEDVODSDUWLFLSDFLyQ &6tEXHQRSHURDORPHMRUHVSRUORTXH\RVLHPSUHWHKHGLFKRTXHKHWHQLGRODVXHUWH GH TXH OD GLVFDSDFLGDG TXH WLHQH 0DUtD SXHV TXH QR PH KD VXSXHVWR D PL PXFKR SUREOHPDTXHDORPHMRUHOSUREOHPDORKXELHUDWHQLGRFRQXQQLxRFLHJRSRUTXHQXQFD KHWUDEDMDGRRFRQXQ« 0 ¢1R FUHHV TXH KXELHUDV WHQLGR HO PLVPR" SRUTXH 0DUtD HV PX\« \R MXVWDPHQWH KDFHXQPRPHQWRSHQVDEDHQHVWDDSUHFLDFLyQWX\DFDGDYH]TXHORFRPHQWDVGHTXH 0DUtDQRWLHQHWDQWDVGLILFXOWDGHVSHUR0DUtDWLHQHODVGRVPDQRVLQPRYLOL]DGDVFRQODV PXOHWDVHVWiPX\OLPLWDGDSDUDUHDOL]DUDFWLYLGDGHV\W~KDVVDELGREXVFDUHVWUDWHJLDV YiOLGDV SDUD TXH SDUWLFLSH VHJXUR TXH RWUR SURIHVRU HQ RWUD VLWXDFLyQ VLPLODU D OD WX\D HQFRQWUDUtD SUREDEOHPHQWH LQFOXVR PiV GLILFXOWDGHV GH ODV TXH W~ DSUHFLDV HQ XQ SULQFLSLR <R FUHR TXH VL DOJXQD YH] WH HQFXHQWUDV FRQ XQ DOXPQR FLHJR WDO FRPR KDV KHFKRFRQ0DUtDVDEUiVEXVFDUORVUHFXUVRVLJXDOTXHKDVKHFKRFRQHOOD & %XHQR WH LUp D EXVFDU D WL HQVHJXLGD HK" 3RUTXH GH YHUGDG HV TXH OR SLHQVR PXFKDVYHFHV\QRVpTXHDGDSWDFLRQHVSRGUtDKDFHUFRQpO 0 3HUR \D YHUtDV WHQGUtDV DSR\R GHO FHQWUR GH UHFXUVRV -RDQ $PDGHV WHQGUtDV DVHVRUDPLHQWR\OHIDFLOLWDUtDVODSDUWLFLSDFLyQWDO\FRPRORKDVKHFKRFRQ0DUtDSRUTXH ORLPSRUWDQWHHVODDFWLWXG\W~GHPXHVWUDVVHUXQDSURIHVLRQDOFRQXQDDFWLWXGUHDOPHQWH UHVSRQVDEOH & <D SHUR FRQ XQ QLxR TXH WLHQH GLILFXOWDG YLVXDO VL TXH QHFHVLWDUtD HO DSR\R GH RWUD SHUVRQDQR" 02GHXQDOXPQRFRODERUDGRU &$K3HURWHQGUtDTXHLUURWiQGRORSDUDTXHQRVLHPSUHHVWXYLHUDHOPLVPRFKDYDO 0&ODURHVORTXHKDEtDPRVKDEODGR &(VRVtTXHVHUtDEXHQR 0 3HUR \D YHUtDV FRQ GRV R WUHV FRQVLJQDV UiSLGDPHQWH OR LQWURGXFLUtDV 4XH HV OD DFWLWXG&DUPHQTXHHVODDFWLWXGTXHHVORTXHYDORUR &1RVpDORPHMRUHVSRUTXHQRORKHWUDWDGRQXQFD\SRUTXHW~PHYHVDPtFRQPX\ EXHQRVRMRV'HYHUGDG 0 1R QR TXH YD ¢< DOJ~Q DVSHFWR TXH TXLHUDV FRPHQWDU GH HVWH SHULRGR GH REVHUYDFLyQ TXH KH UHDOL]DGR TXH W~ SLHQVHV TXH DOJ~Q GHWDOOH TXH VHD QHFHVDULR UHJLVWUDURTXHTXLVLHUDVUHVDOWDU" &3XHVORTXHWHKHGLFKRDOSULQFLSLRTXHPHHQFDQWDUtDSRGHUEXVFDUDOJ~QPHGLRSDUD FDPELDUOHD0DUtDHOFDUiFWHU 03HURHVORTXHW~GLFHVHQFXDQWRDODVRFLDOL]DFLyQGHHOOD¢QR" &6tVt3RUTXHHVXQDSHQDSRUTXHHVXQDQLxDTXH\RFUHRTXHSRGUtDWULXQIDUSHUR TXHKD\DOJRTXHODWLHQHORWLHQHSRUGHQWURTXHQRORH[WHULRUL]D\HVROHKDFHFHUUDUVH \DOQRVHUFRPXQLFDWLYDQLH[SUHVLYDVHHVWiKDFLHQGRGDxRTXHHVORTXHPHJXVWDUtD EXVFDUDOJ~QUHFXUVRSDUDSRGHUODD\XGDU\URPSHUHVDEDUUHUDTXHWLHQH 02VHDHQWXRSLQLyQSRGUtDVOOHJDUDXQDFRQFOXVLyQPHSDUHFHTXHHOFDUiFWHUGHO 5 DOXPQRHVGHWHUPLQDQWHHQFXDQWRDVXVRFLDOL]DFLyQHQODVHVLyQGH()TXHSRUPXFKRV PHGLRVTXHW~OHSURSRQJDVDFWLYLGDGHV« &1RVRORHQ()WHKDEORDQLYHOGH«HQWRGRHQWRGR 0(QWRGRSHURTXHDGHPiVWHUHSHUFXWHHQODVHVLyQ &0HUHSHUFXWHVt 07~HVWiVEXVFDQGRHVWUDWHJLDVIDFLOLWDGRWDVSHURSRUPXFKDVHVWUDWHJLDVTXHLQWHQWH MXVWDPHQWHFRQVHJXLUTXHVHVRFLDOLFHVLHOFDUiFWHUGHOQLxR« &(VFHUUDGR 0«HVOLPLWDGRHVTXHQR«TXHQRVHSXHGHEHQHILFLDUGHHVDVHVWUDWHJLDV &1RSRUTXHHOODQRDEUHODSXHUWDSDUDTXH\RSXHGDD\XGDUOD 0<DFFHGHUDHOOD & < DFFHGHU 3RUTXH GHVSXpV FXDQGR OD FRMR \ KDEOR FRQ HOOD D SDUWH HOOD Vt TXH VH DEUHSHURQRPXFKRQRPXFKRVHDEUHSRTXLWRSHURDTXtHVGRQGH\RHVGRQGHPH SUHRFXSD 0¢<HQHOSDWLR"¢TXpKDVREVHUYDGRHQHOSDWLR" &(QHOSDWLRVL\RQRHVWR\HOODQRSDUWLFLSDODYHRTXHYDGHDPEXODQGRPLUDQGRORTXH 5 KDFHQHOUHVWRVLHPSUHWLHQGHDEXVFDUDQLxRVPiVSHTXHxRVSHURFRQORVQLxRVGHOD FODVHSRFDVYHFHVYDDEXVFDUORV 02VHDQRKD\XQDWUDQVIHUHQFLDGHODDGDSWDFLyQGHORVMXHJRVHQODKRUDGHOSDWLR 5 &1R\RFUHRTXHQRTXHSRFDVYHFHV 0<W~TXpSLHQVDV¢TXHGHSHQGHGHHOODRGHORVFRPSDxHURV" & <R FUHR TXH HV GH HOOD SRUTXH OHV SDVp XQD HQFXHVWD D ORV FKDYDOHV TXH PH H[SOLFDUDQHOSRUTXp\HOORVGHFtDQTXH FODUR TXH HVWiQ XQ SRTXLWR FDQVDGRV GH LUOD D EXVFDUDHOOD\TXHHOODGLJDTXHQRTXLHUHRTXHHVWiXQUDWLWRMXJDQGR\TXHHQVHJXLGD VHFDQVD\VHYD<TXHHOORVSXHVDODKRUDGHOSDWLRORTXHTXLHUHQHVMXJDU\VLHOOD SXHVQRTXLHUHSXHVTXH\DQRODYDQDEXVFDUPiV 0<D\D+DVKHFKRXQDEXHQDFDSWDFLyQGHLQIRUPDFLyQUHVSHFWRD0DUtDDORODUJRGH HVWHDxRTXHVLQGXGDHVPX\LQWHUHVDQWHSDUDODLQYHVWLJDFLyQ &%XHQRHVTXHD0DUtDODWHQJRGHVGHORVFXDWURDxRV 0¢<DOJXQDRWUDFRQVLGHUDFLyQR\DGDPRVSRUILQDOL]DGDODHQWUHYLVWD" &3XHV\RTXLHURTXHYXHOYDVHOFXUVRTXHYLHQH\HORWUR\HORWUR-HMH3HUR\DVp TXHW~WLHQHVPXFKRWUDEDMR\TXHVR\XQSRTXLWRHJRtVWD 0 3HUR VL \R TXLHUR YROYHU \D WH KH GLFKR TXH \R WHQJR PXFKDV JDQDV GH FRPSDUWLU FRQWLJRHVWDVH[SHULHQFLDV\TXH\RDSUHQGRWDPELpQPXFKtVLPRGHWRGRHOSURFHVR &3HURGHPLSRFRDSUHQGHVSRFRDSUHQGHV 0 0XFKtVLPR (O TXHKDFHU GRFHQWH \ WX H[SHULHQFLD VH DFXPXOD HQ WX GtD D GtD \ VLHPSUHVHDSUHQGHGHODVSHUVRQDVTXHKDFpLVYXHVWURWUDEDMRFRQWDQWDPRWLYDFLyQ2 VHD TXH \R OR TXH GHVHR HV VHJXLU WUDEDMDQGR FRQWLJR \ QR Vp SRGHUQRV D\XGDU PXWXDPHQWH &%XHQRW~PHWLHQHVTXHD\XGDUDPt 01RODVGRVODVGRV¢9DOH"3XHVPXFKtVLPDVJUDFLDV &9HQJDDWL (175(9,67$),1$/$/(48,32',5(&7,92'(/&(1752 0('LUHFWRUD $3*-HIDGH(VWXGLRV\0DHVWUDGH(GXFDFLyQ(VSHFLDO )(&+$GHMXOLRGH 0¢4XpYDORUDFLyQKDFpLVGHODH[SHULHQFLDGHVGHHOSXQWRGHYLVWDGHOFHQWURHVFRODU" 5 0( $ YHU \R OR KHPRV YDORUDGR R VHD KDEODUHPRV XQ SRFR HQ SOXUDO ¢QR" SRUTXH OD YDORUDFLyQ \D OD KHPRV KHFKR FRQ $3* 3HQVDPRV TXH KD VLGR PX\ SRVLWLYD QR VRODPHQWH\DGHFDUDDORVDOXPQRV\GHODDOXPQDHQFRQFUHWDGH0DUtDVLQyTXH\R SLHQVRTXHDQLYHOHVFRODUWDPELpQKDVLGRPX\LPSRUWDQWH+DVLGRLPSRUWDQWHHOWUDEDMR FRQ OD HVSHFLDOLVWD GH (GXFDFLyQ )tVLFD () \R SLHQVR TXH HO SRGHU WUDEDMDU FRQMXQWDPHQWHFRQXQDSHUVRQDFRPRW~TXHOHKDVDSRUWDGRPXFKDVLGHDVHOWUDEDMR TXHKDEpLVKHFKRFRQ,JQDVL3XLJGHOOtYRO\WRGRORTXHVHKDLGRPHUPDQGRGHQWURGHO DXOD KD VLGR DSDUWH GH JUDWDPHQWH PX\ JUDWR KD VLGR UHDOPHQWH XQ WUDEDMR PX\ ~WLO 3RUTXHVLODPDHVWUDGH()KDWHQLGRPXFKRVHVWtPXORVSRUTXHKDWHQLGRPXFKDD\XGD SRUSDUWHWX\D\HQWRQFHVUHDOPHQWHHOOD\DHVXQDSHUVRQDPX\WUDEDMDGRUDGHVLHPSUH HVXQDSHUVRQDTXHUHDOPHQWHOHJXVWDLQQRYDU\\RSLHQVRTXHKDEpLVLQQRYDGRPXFKR HQHVWHFDPSR¢QR"RVHDTXHHOWUDEDMRKDVLGRWRFDUDGRVRWUHVYHUWLHQWHVGHVGHHO SXQWRGHYLVWDGHOWUDEDMRFRQODQLxDTXHKDVLGRXQWUDEDMR\RSLHQVRTXHPX\GXUR PX\GXURSRUTXH0DUtDHVXQDQLxDPX\GLItFLOTXHQRDFHSWDODVD\XGDVVLHPSUHTXH KHPRVWHQLGRXQWUDEDMRGLItFLOFXDQGRVHKDQKHFKRVDOLGDVIXHUDSHURTXHMXQWDPHQWH FRQ OD PDHVWUD GH () HVWH WUDEDMR GH SRGHU DFHSWDU VXV SURSLDV GLILFXOWDGHV GH SRGHU DFHSWDUDORVPRQLWRUHVTXHODDFRPSDxDEDQGHSRGHUOOHJDUXQSRFRPiVSLHQVRTXH SRTXLWR SHURVHKDFRQVHJXLGRTXHHO WUDEDMR GH ODV FKDUODV FRQ HO JUXSRFRQWRGRHO JUXSRHQWHUR« 0/DVFRQIHUHQFLDV 0(/DVFRQIHUHQFLDVKDQVLGRPX\EHQHILFLRVDVSLHQVRTXHORVDOXPQRVWRGR\TXH\D HVWiQ DFRVWXPEUDGRV \ TXH VH YDORUy HQ HO FRQVHOO HVFRODU TXH HVWiQ PX\ DFRVWXPEUDGRV D DFHSWDU D 0DUtD XQD FRVD HV DFHSWDU D 0DUtD SRUTXH VLHPSUH KD 5 HVWDGR GHQWURGHOJUXSR\YDOH\RWUDFRVDHVYHUORTXHVLJQLILFDUHDOPHQWHWHQHUXQD GLVFDSDFLGDG\IXHUDGHODHVFXHOD\RSLHQVRTXHKDDELHUWRDHVWRVDOXPQRVORVRMRV\ ODVIDPLOLDVHQHOFRQVHMRHVFRODUORYDORUDURQSRVLWLYDPHQWH $3*6t\RTXLHURLQVLVWLUHQHVWHDVSHFWRSRUTXHODVIDPLOLDVKLFLHURQFRQVWDUTXHHVWH WUDEDMROHVKDEtDSDUHFLGRPX\SRVLWLYRPX\HQULTXHFHGRUSDUDVXVKLMRVSHURKDVWDHO SXQWRTXHDSXQWDURQTXHSRVLEOHPHQWHVHSRGUtDKDEHUDPSOLDGRDRWURVFXUVRV\DRWURV QLYHOHVGHOFROHJLR1RVRWURVDUJXPHQWDPRVTXHFRPRHUDXQWUDEDMRFRQODILQDOLGDGGH FRODERUDU FRQ OD WHVLV WX\D GH OD 0HUFKH 5tRV HQ HVWH FDVR SHUR WDPELpQ FRQ OD FRQWUDSDUWLGDGHOFROHJLRGHREWHQHUODPRGLILFDFLyQFXUULFXODUGHHVWDDOXPQDHQHOFDVR TXH VH YLHUD QHFHVDULR TXH KDEtD TXHGDGR UHVWULQJLGR VROR D HVWH FXUVR D HVWH QLYHO SHUR TXH HQ IXWXUDV FRODERUDFLRQHV TXH HVSHUDPRV TXH SRGDPRV UHDOL]DU VH SXHGD WHQHUHQFXHQWD<SLHQVRTXHHOGtDGHODMRUQDGDGHORVMXHJRVVHQVLELOL]DGRUHVKDLGR WDPELpQ PX\ ELHQ HQ HVWH DVSHFWR HQ WRGR PRPHQWR HO FROHJLR KD KHFKR GLIXVLyQ GH WRGRVHVWRVDVSHFWRVWDPELpQSRUXQGtDXQLYHUVLWDULRVLHPSUHKDLQIRUPDGRDO&RQVHMR HVFRODU SXQWXDOPHQWH GH WRGRV HVWRV DVSHFWRV KD HQYLDGR LQIRUPDFLyQ D WRGDV ODV IDPLOLDVSRUPHGLRGHXQFRPXQLFDGRTXHHQYLDPRVPHQVXDOPHQWHFRQWRGRV« 0((VWiHQODSiJLQDZHE $3* (VWi HQ OD SiJLQD ZHE \ \R SLHQVR TXH WDPELpQ OD IDPLOLD QRVRWURV YHPRV XQD 5 DFWLWXGGLIHUHQWHTXL]iVPiVWUDQTXLOD 0¢+DEpLVGHWHFWDGRXQFDPELRGHDFWLWXGHQODIDPLOLDHQHVWHFXUVR" $3*6tHVLQFLSLHQWHSHUR\RSLHQVRTXHFXDOLWDWLYDPHQWHLPSRUWDQWH<SRURWUDSDUWH« 0<¢DTXpSHQViLVTXHVHGHEH" $3*<RSLHQVRTXHHOSRGHUKDEODU 0(+DEODU $3* 3RGHU WHQHU OD RSLQLyQ GH XQD SHUVRQD H[WHUQD DO FROHJLR SRUTXH HVWR HV PX\ LPSRUWDQWH\HOYHUTXHH[LVWtDXQDSUHRFXSDFLyQ\TXHORTXHVHTXHUtDHUDEHQHILFLDUD OD DOXPQD \ GHVDUUROODU DO Pi[LPR VXV FDSDFLGDGHV VX LQWHJUDFLyQ VXV UHODFLRQHV VRFLDOHV VX DXWRHVWLPD \R SLHQVR TXH HVWR GH DOJXQD PDQHUD OD IDPLOLD OR KD YLYLGR SRVLWLYDPHQWH 0<\RSLHQVRTXH« $3*4XHWHQHPRVTXHLQVLVWLUVXSRQJR¢QR" 0<\RSLHQVRTXHWDPELpQFUHRTXHIXHLPSRUWDQWHFRQODIDPLOLDHOPRPHQWRTXH\ROHV 5 FRPHQWpFXiOIXHHOFDPELRGHDFWLWXGPtRGHOSULQFLSLRGHODWHVLVDOPHV\PHGLRTXHHQ SULQFLSLR\RLEDGHH[SHUWDLQIDOLEOH\RSHQVDEDTXHQRSDUWLFLSDEDWDQDFWLYDPHQWHFRPR SDUWLFLSD HQ ODV VHVLRQHV \ OD LGHD HV TXH ORV PDHVWURV QR WLHQHQ VXILFLHQWHPHQWH FRQRFLPLHQWRVFRPRSDUDFRQVHJXLUODSDUWLFLSDFLyQ\HQHOPRPHQWRTXHGXUDQWHPHV\ PHGLR UHFRJt TXH HOOD SDUWLFLSDED DFWLYDPHQWH HQ ODV VHVLRQHV )XH FXDQGR \R OHV FRPHQWp D HOORV PL FDPELR GH DFWLWXG D YHU GH TXp PDQHUD SRGtD FRODERUDU FRQ OD PDHVWUD HQ OD HODERUDFLyQ GH QXHYDV HVWUDWHJLDV SHUR TXH \R LED D DQDOL]DU ODV HVWUDWHJLDV GH OD PDHVWUD (VR IXH FRQVLGHUDEOH SRUTXH OHV GLMH TXH OD QLxD \D HVWDED PX\ ELHQ LQFOXLGD HQ HVWH FHQWUR HVFRODU \ TXH VH SRGtDQ VHQWLU WDPELpQ PX\ DIRUWXQDGRV 0(<RSLHQVRTXHHVWRHOGHFLUOHVFRPRGHFtD$3*ODSHUVRQDH[WHUQDTXHHVODTXHOR 5 KDEOD FODUR SRUTXH VLQy VLHPSUH HV OD WXWRUD \ HO HTXLSR GLUHFWLYR HUD XQD SHUVRQD H[WHUQD TXH LED D KDFHU XQ DQiOLVLV TXH KDEtD FRPSUREDGR TXH HVWDED LQFOXLGD TXH SRGtD RtUFRVDVQXHYDVSRUTXHDOILQ \ DO FDERWRGRVYDPRVDGHFLUORPLVPRSHURGH PDQHUDVGLIHUHQWHVRtDFRVDVQXHYDV\\RFUHRTXHHQHOIRQGRVHYDQKDFLHQGRODLGHD GHTXHEXHQRHVFDSD]SXHGHKHPRVGHH[LJLUOHPiVSRUTXHWRGRVYDPRVGLFLHQGROR PLVPRHOORVKDFHQTXHHQHOWHUUHQRFXUULFXODUQRVHVDEHSRUTXHDODKRUDOHLPSRUWD ELHQSRFRDSUHQGHUSRUTXHWLHQHXQDSRVWXUDVLHPSUHGHSDVLYLGDGWRWDO\EXHQRKDFHHO PtQLPR\SRVLEOHPHQWHSRUTXHHQFDVDWDPSRFRWLHQHH[LJHQFLDRVHDHVTXHQRVRWURV FUHHPRV TXH DTXt ODIDPLOLDSRVLEOHPHQWH WDPELpQ IDOOD KD FRJLGR XQD DFWLWXG FRQ TXH 0DUtDWDPELpQHVPX\UHEHOGH¢QR"SXHVVXSRQJRTXHDOILQDOWDPELpQGHMDQ«HQWRQFHV HOWUDEDMDUWRGRHVWHWHPDVREUHWRGRHQHOGHSRUWH\WDO\RSLHQVRTXHOHVKDDELHUWRXQ SRFRHOFDPSR¢QR"XQSRFRPiVGHGHFLUSXHV³DK¢KD\SRVLELOLGDGHVSRGHPRVKDFHU DOJXQDFRVD"$KPLUDSXHVHVWiELHQLQWHJUDGD´\RSLHQVRTXHWRGRHVWRDODIDPLOLDOHV KDSDUHFLGR«SRUTXHHORWURGtDLQFOXVRQRVODHQFRQWUDPRVSRUHOFDPLQROHVGLMLPRV TXHWHQtDQTXHYHQLUDILUPDUXQSDSHOSDUDODPRGLILFDFLyQFXUULFXODUFRQIRUPHHVWiQGH DFXHUGR\WDO\ODYLPRVFRPRGLFH$3*PiVVRVHJDGD³$KSXHVVt\DYHQGUp\WDO´ 8QDDFWLWXGXQSRFRPiVUHODMDGDORFXDOHVWRHQHVWDIDPLOLD\DTXLHUHGHFLUPXFKR 0<D 0(2VHDVLFRPSDUiUDPRVFRQRWUDIDPLOLDSXHVGLUtDPRV³R\HHVWDPRVHQXQQLYHO«´ SHURVLHQGRODIDPLOLDTXHHVQRVSDUHFHTXHHVWRHV\DXQJUDQDYDQFH¢QR"FRQORFXDO VLORPLUDPRVWRGRJOREDOPHQWHORTXHGHFtDPRV¢QR"HQWRGRVORVDVSHFWRV\RSLHQVR TXHVHKDOOHJDGRDPXFKRQRVpVLDORTXHW~HVSHUDEDVSHURFRPRTXHQRVRWURVQR VDEtDPRV H[DFWDPHQWH GyQGH LEDV D OOHJDU QL FyPR VH LED D SURGXFLU VDEtDPRV WX LQWHQFLyQ GH WUDEDMR ¢QR" HQWRQFHV SDUD QRVRWURV YLVWR GyQGH KHPRV OOHJDGR KD VLGR UHDOPHQWH PX\ SRVLWLYR \ SDUD QRVRWURV VH KD OOHJDGR D PiV GH OR TXH HVSHUiEDPRV ¢QR"HQWRQFHVDYHUTXpHVORTXHSDVD(QWRQFHV\DORYDORUDPRVPX\PX\ELHQ $3* 6t SRUTXH DGHPiV QRVRWUDV GRV KHPRV FRPHQWDGR PXFKDV YHFHV TXH GHVGH HO 5 FXUVR TXH OOHJDPRV DO FROHJLR KDVWD HVWH DxR QXQFD KDEtDPRV YLVWRVRQUHtUDOD0DUtD+DVLGRHOSULPHUDxRTXHODKHPRVYLVWRVRQUHtU¢QR"FRQWRGR OR TXH HVWR LPSOLFD \ HVR TXL]iV HV OR PiV LPSRUWDQWH \ SLHQVR TXH VLQ HVWH WUDEDMR FRQMXQWR \ FRQ WX H[SHULHQFLD \ FRQ WX WUDEDMR FRQ OD PDHVWUD GH () TXL]iV QR HVWH FDPELR QR VH KXELHUD SURGXFLGR HQ 0DUtD ¢QR" 3RUTXH LQVLVWR TXH WHQGUtDPRV TXH FRQWLQXDU WUDEDMDQGR WRGRV HVWRV DVSHFWRV TXH VH KDQ HPSH]DGR D PRGLILFDU SDUD TXH UHDOPHQWHEXHQRSXHV\DIRUPDUDQSDUWHGHXQDDFWLWXGGLIHUHQWHGH0DUtDUHVSHFWRD ORVGHPiVDOWUDEDMRHVFRODU\EXHQRDVXGHVDUUROORHQJHQHUDO 0((OKHFKRGHODVGXFKDVSRUHMHPSORHOKHFKRGHGXFKDUVHRVHDW~ORYLYLVWHPX\ 5 ELHQ¢QR"FXDQGRYLVWHTXHODQLxDVHSRQtDODGXFKD\VHGXFKDED\WDOEXHQRQRVRWURV WDPELpQORYLYLPRVHVWRSRUTXHQRVSDUHFtDTXHQROOHJDUtD 0<D 0((QHVWHDVSHFWRHVTXHFODURVRQSHTXHxDVFRVDVSHURPX\LPSRUWDQWHVSDUDHOOD\ SDUDQRVRWURV 02VHDTXHORYDORUiLVPX\SRVLWLYDPHQWHWDPELpQODUHSHUFXVLyQ 0(0X\SRVLWLYDPHQWH 0¢<HQHOJUXSRFODVHQRKDKDELGRQLQJ~QSUREOHPDFRQPLJRQR" 0( < GHO JUXSR FODVH HV TXH FODUR QXFD KDQ SXHVWR SHJDV OR TXH SDVD TXH QXQFD KHPRV VDELGR HV UHDOPHQWH QR Vp VL OR VDEHPRV DKRUD D 0DUtD VLHPSUH OD KDQ DFHSWDGR¢QR"SRUTXHSXHVSRUTXHHVWiDOOtGHQWURFRQHOORV\VLHPSUHODDFHSWDQSHUR HOQLYHOGHUHODFLyQTXHWLHQHQFODURFRPRTXHHOODQRVHGHMDQRQRIiFLOPHQWHQRGHMD HQWUDUDYHFHVQRVSUHRFXSDYHUUHDOPHQWHVtHVWiDFHSWDGDSHUR¢\ODUHODFLyQ"$TXt HVGRQGHIDOODEXHQRHVWRHVXQWUDEDMRTXHWDPELpQHOODWLHQHTXHLUKDFLHQGRRVHDHOOD WLHQHTXHLUFUHFLHQGR\YHUUHDOPHQWHFyPRVHPXHYHSRUTXHFODURHOODVLHPSUHHVSHUD TXHYHQJDQORVGHPiV 0&ODUR 0(<DTXtHVWHWUDEDMRVHKDLGRKDFLHQGRWDPELpQFRQODWXWRUD\WDOSDUDTXHYHDTXH 5 HOODKDGHDFHUFDUVHDORVRWURVSHURHOODHVWiPX\DFRVWXPEUDGDDTXHODJHQWHYDDHOOD ¢QR"FRPRVLHOODQRQHFHVLWDVHDQDGLH\SUHFLVDPHQWHQHFHVLWDPXFKRGHODUHODFLyQGH ODVFRPSDxHUDVHQWRQFHVHVWREXHQR« $3*6LEDVWDQWHDPHQXGRHOODVHSHUPLWtDHOOXMRGHUHFKD]DUODD\XGDGHORVGHPiV 5 QRSRUFXHVWLyQItVLFDVLQyLQFOXVRDQLYHOHVFRODU¢QR"HQODUHDOL]DFLyQGHDOJ~QWUDEDMR DOJ~QWHPD\PXFKDVYHFHVKDGHMDGRDVXVFRPSDxHURVFRQXQSDOPRGHQDULFHVSRU GHFLUORGHDOJXQDPDQHUD\HVRWDPSRFRKDEHQHILFLDGRTXHODGLQiPLFDGH0DUtDFRQHO JUXSRVHDIOXLGD\SRVLWLYDQRHVWiLJQRUDGDSHURWDPSRFRKD\XQDUHODFLyQSLHQVR\RR KDKDELGRXQDUHODFLyQORVXILFLHQWHPHQWHVDQD¢QR" 0<D\D\D $3* 1L LJQRUDGD QL UHFKD]DGD DFHSWDGD SHUR XQ DFHSWDGR DTXHOOR HQWUH FRPLOODV DFHSWDQGRTXHHVXQDFRPSDxHUD\SRUTXHWLHQHVXVGLILFXOWDGHV\SRUTXHHVXQDPiV SHURSRFR« 0 &UHR TXH VHUiQ LQWHUHVDQWHV ORV UHVXOWDGRV GHO VRFLRJUDPD FXDQGR ORV DQDOLFH HQ VHWLHPEUH $3*([DFWRDORPHMRUQRVOOHYDPRVVRUSUHVD 06tVtDYHUTXpSLHQVDQORVQLxRVUHVSHFWRD0DUtD $3*([DFWDPHQWH 0 6t Vt QRV SRGUi GDU EDVWDQWHV LQGLFDGRUHV ¢< DOJR PiV DO UHVSHFWR" 2 \D FRQVLGHUiLVTXHKDEpLVDEDUFDGRXQSRTXLWRWRGR¢QR" $3*<RSLHQVRTXHVt 0/DSURIHVRUDHOJUXSRFODVHORVQLxRV« $3*6tVt 0¢<FRQORVFRPSDxHURVFRQORVPDHVWURVKDEpLVFRQVLGHUDGRTXHWDPELpQKDVLGR SRVLWLYDODUHODFLyQ" 0(<RSLHQVRTXHORVPDHVWURVFXDQGRORKHPRVSODQWHDGRHQHOFODXVWURVLHPSUHVH KDQ SODQWHDGR GH PDQHUD PX\ SRVLWLYD WDPELpQ SRUTXH EXHQR VH KDQ LGR KDFLHQGR YDORUDFLRQHV /D PDHVWUD GH () VLHPSUH KD LGR H[SOLFDQGR \ HQWRQFHV HO QLYHO GH SDUWLFLSDFLyQ\RSLHQVRTXHKDVLGRIDYRUDEOHWDPELpQWRGRVWRGRHOFODXVWURORKDYLVWR LQWHUHVDQWHHKDGHPiVVLHQGRODQLxDTXHHUDKDSDUHFLGRFRPRPX\LQWHUHVDQWHTXHVH KLFLHUD HVWH WUDEDMR FRQ HOOD ¢QR" HQWRQFHV WRGRV FRQVLGHUDQGR OR PLVPR ³$K HV TXH 0DUtD«´VLHPSUHHVODTXHMD¢QR"³$\HVTXHOD0DUtD«´SRUTXHWRGRVVDEHPRVFRPR HV0DUtDSHURORKDQYLVWRWDPELpQGHPDQHUDPX\SRVLWLYD(OUHVXOWDGRHQJHQHUDOPX\ VDWLVIDFWRULRRVHDQRKDEUtDQDGDTXHGHFLUSRUTXHWDPELpQSRGUtDPRVYDORUDUEXHQR DKRUDYDPRVDYHUORVDVSHFWRVQHJDWLYRV 0&ODUR 0(<QRORVHQFRQWUDUtDPRVSRUTXH$3*\\RORKHPRVKHFKRDYHUVLGHHVWHWUDEDMR 5 WXYLpUDPRVTXHVDFDUYHQWDMDVGHVYHQWDMDVDVSHFWRVSRVLWLYRV\QHJDWLYRVQRKHPRV HQFRQWUDGRQLQJXQRGHQHJDWLYR¢QR"FXDQGRKHPRVLGRELHQ«HVTXHQRKD\QDGDTXH GLJDVHVTXHKDIDOODGRRHVTXHHVWRQRKDVLGRWDQSURYHFKRVRFRPRHVSHUiEDPRVR HVTXHHVWRHQHOIRQGROHKDKHFKRGDxR«1RQRQRQRRVHDHQHOFRQMXQWRGHOD PDHVWUD GH () FRQ HOOD GH W~ FRQ HOOD FRQ HO JUXSR FODVH YRVRWUDV GRV WUDEDMDQGR FRQMXQWDPHQWH DO FRQWUDULR HV TXH WRGR KD VLGR ¢QR" ODV MRUQDGDV TXH VH KDQ KHFKR IXHUDGHODHVFXHODHOWUDEDMRGHXQGtDHQODXQLYHUVLGDGSRUXQGtDXQLYHUVLWDULRVWRGR WRGRWRGRKDTXHGDGRWDQELHQHQJOREDGRTXHQRKD\QLQJ~QDVSHFWRQHJDWLYR 0%XHQR $3*3RUORWDQWRWDPELpQGDUWHODVJUDFLDVDWt\HVSHUDUSRGHUFRQWLQXDUFRQWXD\XGD\ FRODERUDFLyQ 0( 6t HVWRHVFDVLFRPRGLMpUDPRVXQFKDQWDMH+DVHVWDGRPX\ELHQSHUR«MDMDMD SXHGHVSDUDUVLTXLHUHVSHUR« 02VGR\ODVJUDFLDVSRUKDEHUPHDFRJLGR¢QR"\SRUKDEHUPHEULQGDGRODRSRUWXQLGDG GHUHDOL]DUODREVHUYDFLyQHQYXHVWURFHQWUR\TXHFRPRYRVRWURV\DKDEpLVFRPHQWDGR LQGXGDEOHPHQWHDTXtVHKDLQLFLDGRXQDERQLWDKLVWRULDGHDPRU-DMDMD $3*(QFDQWDGDV 0<JUDFLDVSRUHOWLHPSRTXHPHKDEpLVGHGLFDGR« $3*(QDEVROXWR 0'DGRTXHDKRUDHVWiLVHQILQDOL]DFLyQGHOFXUVRRVDJUDGH]FRHOSRGHUGHGLFDUPHHVWH HVSDFLR(VPX\YDOLRVR $3* $O FRQWUDULR W~ WH KDV DGDSWDGR D QXHVWURV KRUDULRV TXH VLHPSUH WH KDV LGR DGDSWDQGRRVHDTXHQLQJ~QSUREOHPD (175(9,67$$/&(1752 0$7XWRUDGH0DUtD )(&+$GHPD\RGH 0 %XHQR FUHR OR TXH QRV TXHGy SHQGLHQWH HUD TXH PH GHVFULELHVHV FRPR HV 0DUtD ¢4XpGLUtDVUHVSHFWRDVXSHUVRQDOLGDGGHVSXpVGHHVWRVPHVHV" 0$$YHU0DUtDHVSDUDPtHODGMHWLYRTXHODGHVFULELUtDPiVHVTXHHVPX\LQIDQWLO 5 DXQ\HVWDPELpQXQ«HVPX\LQRFHQWH(VPX\LQRFHQWH\FRQSRFDFRVDVHFRQIRUPD \ VLHPSUH SDUHFH TXH HVWi FRQWHQWD FRQ ODV FRVDV SHUR QR HQ OD HVFXHOD VLQR TXH YDPRVGHH[FXUVLyQ\WHKDFHFRPHQWDULRVTXHDYHFHVSDUHFHQFRPRGHPiV«FRPR GHQLxDSHTXHxDSHURSRUTXHHVWiFRQWHQWD\WHGHVFULEHORTXHYH\WHFXHQWDFRVDV\ HVPX\VRFLDEOHHQHVWHDVSHFWR/RTXHSDVDTXHHQODHVFXHODSXHV«HVWiFRPRXQ SRFRHVWDQFDGDHQORVFRQWHQLGRV\FRVDVGHHVWDV\W~FXDQGROHH[LJHVXQSRTXLWR EXHQROHH[LJHVORTXHHOODSXHGHGDUSXHVVHEORTXHD\OXHJRHVFRPRPX\WR]XGDHV FRPR\RYHR1RVHFRPRGHFLUOR6tWR]XGD 06tVL 0$&RPRWR]XGD<OXHJRWLHQHWDPELpQODUHDFFLyQHVWDTXH\RGLJRTXHHVXQSRFR LQIDQWLO SRUTXH VH EORTXHD QR KDEOD KDFH ³PRUURV´ QR Vp FRPR GHFLUOR \ OXHJR QR WH KDEOD\OXHJROHGLFHV³YDH[SOtFDPHTXpWHSDVD´\QRQRWHKDEOD6HSRQHQRVp FRPRGHFLUOR 06LEXHQRTXHVHPXHVWUDHQIDGDGDFDEL]EDMD« 0$6tVtEXHQRORTXHSDVDTXHOXHJRFXDQGROHKDQSDVDGRGLH]PLQXWRVSXHVVLJXH FRQODUHODFLyQQRUPDO\FRUULHQWHWHH[SOLFDFRVDV\VHUtHFRQWLJR\WHGLFH³$\HUIXLQR VpGRQGH´FRPRVLORTXHKXELHUDSDVDGRKDFHGLH]PLQXWRVQROHLPSRUWDUD%XHQRHV TXHQROHLPSRUWDQROHLPSRUWDHVTXHQRVp 5 )XLPRVFRQHOSVLFyORJRGHQXHVWURFHQWURDOFHQWURGHUHKDELOLWDFLyQSDUDTXHWDPELpQ 5 QRV H[SOLFDUDQ XQ SRTXLWR D YHU VL 0DUtD SXHV VL HOOD SRU HMHPSOR WHQtD GLILFXOWDGHV DxDGLGDVRVLSRGtDVHJXLUHOULWPRGHODFODVH\QRVGLMHURQTXHSRGtDVHJXLUORTXHQR KDEtD QLQJ~Q SUREOHPD SDUD DVLPLODU ORV FRQWHQLGRV GH TXLQWR OR TXH SDVD HV TXH WDPELpQWHQtDPRVTXHWHQHUHQFXHQWDTXHOHWHQtDPRVTXHSRQHUFRPRXQRVOtPLWHV\ WHQHUHQFXHQWDTXHVHFDQVDXQSRFRPiVTXHORVGHPiV\ORKLFLPRVSHURDXQDVtHOOD QR GD WRGR OR TXH SXHGD GDU 1R OR GD \ QR KD\ PDQHUD FXDQGR VH FLHUUD GH HVWD PDQHUDQRKD\PDQHUDGHHQWUDUOH 0¢3HURHVWRHVDQWHODVGLILFXOWDGHVGHDSUHQGL]DMH" 0$6tVt%XHQRGHDSUHQGL]DMHSHURWDPELpQSRUHMHPSORFXDQGRYDPRVGHH[FXUVLyQ 5 \ QRUPDOPHQWH HVWH« QRUPDOPHQWH QR FDVL VLHPSUH HVWH FXUVR QRV KD YHQLGR XQ DFRPSDxDQWH XQ PRQLWRU GHO FHQWUR GH UHKDELOLWDFLyQ \ HOOD VH KD QHJDGR WRWDOPHQWH TXHEXHQRLQFOXVRGHFLUOHSXHVTXHQROHD\XGH\TXHQROHVLJDSRUTXHHOODORVDEH KDFHUVROD\TXHQRTXLHUHTXHOHOOHYHODVLOODSRUTXHOHWLUD«SHURGLFLHQGRFRQHVWDV SDODEUDV \ FRQ HVWH WRQR < FODUR ORV GH OD DVRFLDFLyQ GH SHUVRQDV FRQ GLVFDSDFLGDG PRWUL]\DYLHQHQSUHSDUDGRVSRUTXHORVDEHQORTXHSDVDTXHSRUHMHPSORHQOD~OWLPD VDOLGDTXHIXHHQODFRORQLDVYLQRXQFKLFRTXHFRPR\DORVDEtD\DPHGLMR³<R\DVH« \DPHKDQGLFKRFRPRHV0DUtD´<GLMR³\RYR\DHVSHUDUDTXHHOODPHSLGDODD\XGD QR YR\ D LU VLHPSUH GHWUiV´ \ IXQFLRQy \ 0DUtD HVWXYR HQFDQWDGtVLPD FRQ HVWH FKLFR TXLHURGHFLUTXHFDPELyWRWDOPHQWH3HURHVTXHQRVDEHVFyPRFDHUODSRUTXHDGHPiV HV PX\ UHWLFHQWH D TXH W~ OH D\XGHV HQ ILQ HV HVWR (V PX\ EXHQD FKLFD HV PX\ LQRFHQWH\HVHQFDQWDGRUD\WRGRVORVQLxRV\QLxDVGHODFODVHHVWiQYROFDGRVHQHOODOR TXHSDVDHVTXHWDPELpQVDEHQTXHFXDQGREXHQRTXHHVPX\PRUUXGDQRVpFRPR GHFLUORTXHHVPX\WR]XGDSHURPXFKRSDUDPtH[DJHUDGR 0<D¢<VXHOHKDEODUGHPDQHUDPX\LQIDQWLO«" 0$6tWDPELpQ 0«¢FRPRSDVDHQHOJLPQDVLRDYHFHV" 5 0$6tVtHVTXHSDUDPtWRGDHVFRPR«OHIDOWDPDGXUDU1RVpKD\DOJXQRVDVSHFWRV FRPR SRU HMHPSOR« EXHQR HVWR QR Vp VL« VL VH WLHQH TXH WHQHU HQ FXHQWD HQ OD HQWUHYLVWDSRU HMHPSOR DKRUD \D WLHQH OD PHQVWUXDFLyQ HQ ODV FRORQLDV OD WXYR SXHV FRPRVLQRODWXYLHUDQRVH«HVTXHQRHVUHVSRQVDEOH\HQHVWDVFRVDV\RQRODSXHGR D\XGDUHOODWLHQHTXHVHUUHVSRQVDEOHGHHVWDVFRVDV«<RSRUHMHPSORHOODDYHFHVQR VHSRQtDORVSOiVWLFRVRORVKLHUURVTXHOOHYD« 0)pUXODV 0$«\OHKDFtDYROYHUDTXHVHORSRQLHUD³9DYHQJD0DUtDTXHQRVpTXp«´SHUROR GHODPHQVWUXDFLyQKDVWDTXHQRODYLTXHLEDPDQFKDGDSXHV\ROHGLMH³0DUtDHVWRVt TXHWLHQHVTXHVHUW~WLHQHVTXHVHUUHVSRQVDEOHHQHVWDVFRVDV«´SHURSDUHFHTXHDXQ QROHWRFDEDHVWR\QRHVWiSUHSDUDGDHVTXHQRHVWiSUHSDUDGDHVFRPRPX\GHMDGD 3RUHMHPSORWDPELpQWHQtDWRGRV~SHUGHVRUGHQDGR\WDPELpQHOFDMyQ«TXLHURGHFLUTXH 5 HVFRPR«VtOHIDOWDPDGXUDUD0DUtD3HUR\RWDPELpQQRVpVLHVTXHHOODQRTXLHUHHK 0&RPRVLHVSHUDUDDTXHORVGHPiVOHUHVROYLHUDQVXVGLILFXOWDGHVQR" 5 0$ 6t Vt Vt Vt /R HVSHUD SHUR FXDQGR W~ OXHJR OD LQWHQWDV D\XGDU D VXSHUDU VH EORTXHD \DYHFHVQRKD\PDQHUDTXHQRTXLHUHTXHQRTXLHUH\HVWDPELpQ«FODUR TXHWDPELpQOHLQIOX\HHOSUREOHPDPRWUL]TXHWLHQHHVPX\OHQWDSHURDODKRUDGHKDFHU XQHMHUFLFLRPLHQWUDVORVRWURVKDFHQRFKRRSHUDFLRQHVHOODHQXQDKRUDQRFRSLDQLOD SULPHUD\FXDQGROHLQVLVWHV³9DYHQJD0DUtD´HVFXDQGRWHPLUDSRQHPRUURV\VH SRQHGHEUD]RVFUX]DGRV\\DHVWi 0<FDEL]EDMD\\DQRKDFHQDGD 0$6t<QRKDFHQDGD\QRKDFHQDGD 0<FRQJDQDVGHFRQXQDLPDJHQFRPRVLWXYLHUDJDQDVGHOORUDU¢QR" 0$6tVtVtVt<FRQHVWDFDUD«EXHQRKDFLHQGRSXFKHURVQRVpFRPRGHFLUOR 06tVt 0$%XHQRQRVp<QRVDEHVFRPRHQWUDUOH&DGDYH]TXHYDPRVGHH[FXUVLyQFXDQGR 5 YROYHPRVVLHPSUHVLHPSUHVLHPSUHHVWDEDHQIDGDGD\VXPDGUHGHFtD³3HUR0DUtDVL FDGDYH]TXHYDPRVHVDVtSXHVQRSRGUiVLUGHH[FXUVLyQ´\\RWDPELpQVHORH[SOLFDED ³0DUtDVLYLHQHDOJXLHQGHODDVRFLDFLyQGHSHUVRQDVFRQGLVFDSDFLGDGPRWUL]HVSRUTXH QRV«EXHQRVRPRVSULYLOHJLDGRVSRUTXHHODxRSDVDGRQRYHQtDQDGLH\ORWHQHPRVTXH DSURYHFKDUTXHQRVYLHQHDD\XGDU«´<QRQRKD\PDQHUD\FDGDYH]TXHKDEtDXQD H[FXUVLyQ\ROHGHFtD³¢7~YLHQHVGHH[FXUVLyQ"´$YHUFRPRUHDFFLRQDED\HOODGHFtD ³Vt´<OHGLJR³SXHVXQHVSHFWiFXORFRPRHORWURGtDQRTXLHURTXHPHORPRQWHV´ 3RUTXHHQHOPHWURQRVDEHVHOHVSHFWiFXORTXHPHPRQWDEDSRUTXHTXHUtDLUGHSLp\ 5 WHQtDPRVODVLOODGHUXHGDVSDUDVHQWDUVH\WHQtDPRVWDPELpQVLWLRVYDFtRVHQHOPHWUR SXHV QR TXHUtD VHQWDUVH \ \R OH GHFtD ³0DUtD VLpQWDWH´ \ WRGR HO PXQGR OD HVWDED PLUDQGR SHUR HOOD QR VH VHQWy HQ WRGR HO YLDMH \ QR KXER PDQHUD TXLHUR GHFLU TXH FXDQGRHOODGLFHXQDFRVDODGLFH 0<D\D 0$<DQWHVGHODVH[FXUVLRQHVWDQWRODPDHVWUDGH()FRPR\ROHGHFtDPRV³£¢4Xp YLHQHVGHH[FXUVLyQ"´³6t´³SXHVWHQGUiVTXHKDFHUORTXHQRVRWUDVGLJDPRV£HK"´³6t VtVt´3HUROXHJRHQODVH[FXUVLRQHVKDFtDORTXHHOODTXHUtD4XLHURGHFLUTXHHVGXUD 3HUROXHJRHVHVWRTXHVHOHSDVD\WHH[SOLFDODFRVDVTXHVLYDDSLVFLQD«H[SOLFD PXFKDVFRVDVGHOFHQWURGHUHKDELOLWDFLyQHOODGLFHTXHHVWiFRQWHQWDHOODHVWiFRQWHQWD \IHOL]ORTXHSDVDTXHFXDQGRKD\XQDGLILFXOWDGRDOJRSXHVVHSDUD\QRORKDFH 0 ¢(QWRQFHV VXV DSUHQGL]DMHV VRQ PiV OHQWRV HQ HO DXOD TXH HO UHVWR GH VXV FRPSDxHURV" 0$0XFKRPiVOHQWRVSHURGHXQDPDQHUDH[DJHUDGD 5 0¢6L" 0$6t 0¢3UHVHQWDXQUHWUDVRLPSRUWDQWH" 0$ 6t SDUD PL Vt 3RU HMHPSOR HQ « \ GHELGR D HVWR SRU HMHPSOR HQ FODVH GH PDWHPiWLFDVOOHYDXQJUXSRLQIHULRU\DVt\WRGRODPDHVWUDFDGD«FDVLFDGDVHPDQDPH YLHQH \ PH GLFH PXFKDV YHFHV ³0DUtD VH WLHQH TXH TXHGDU VLQ SDWLR SRUTXH QR KD WHUPLQDGRODVFRVDV«SRUTXHQLODVKDFRSLDGR«³<DXQDVtWDPELpQVXSURIHVRUDVDEH ORTXH\ROHGLMHTXHIXLPRVDOFHQWURGHUHKDELOLWDFLyQQ\QRVGLMHURQTXHOHWHQtDPRV TXHSRQHUXQRVOtPLWHV«\\DORKDFHSHURQLDVtQLDVtQRVKDIXQFLRQDGRSRUTXHQRHV TXHVHDOHQWD %XHQR Vt HV TXH HV OHQWD SHUR HV TXH QR FRSLD QL ODV FRVDV SDUD OXHJR KDFHUODV HQ FDVD3RUTXHQRVpFyPRGHFLUORSRUTXHDYHFHVDTXtSXHGHVGHFLUOR³FRSLD\OXHJRHQ FDVDORKDFHV´SHURHVTXHWDPSRFR4XLHURGHFLUTXHSDUDPtHVH[DJHUDGDPHQWHOHQWD \HVWROHKDFHTXHHVWpUHWUDVDGDHQWRGRHQWRGR 5 0<D\D\D¢<ODUHODFLyQFRQVXVFRPSDxHURV" 5 0$%LHQPX\ELHQ 0¢6t" 0$6tWLHQHQPXFKDSDFLHQFLDFRQHOOD 0¢/RVFRPSDxHURVFRQHOOD" 0$6t6tVt$YHFHVWDPELpQVHFDQVDQSRUTXHHVQRUPDOSRUTXHWRGRHOPXQGRWLHQH XQ OtPLWH SHUR Vt WRGR HO PXQGR OD DFRJH \ OD D\XGDQ \ PX\ PX\ ELHQ 6RQ PX\ FRPSUHQVLYRV 0 ¢< HV VRFLDEOH" ¢(OOD WLHQH LQLFLDWLYDV FRQ HOORV R VRQ HOORV ORV TXH WLHQHQ ODV 5 LQLFLDWLYDVFRQHOOD" 0$<RGLUtDTXHHVDOUHYpVPiVHOORVFRQHOODTXHQRHOODFRQHOORV6RQHOORVORVRWURV VLHPSUHRHOODVTXLHQODEXVFDQVtORTXHSDVDTXHHOODWLHQHUHODFLyQFRQWRGRVHK"< SRUHMHPSORFXDQGRHQODVH[FXUVLRQHVHOODOOHYDODVLOOD\WRGRHOPXQGRHVWiSHQGLHQWH GHHOOD\PXFKRVGHODFODVHSXHVTXLHUHQVHUHOODRTXLHUHQVHUHOORVTXHODOOHYHQ\ 0DUtDFXDQGRXQFRPSDxHURODOOHYDQRGLFHQDGDHVFXDQGRHVHOPRQLWRURDOJXLHQ 0(ODGXOWR 0$6tHODGXOWRTXHVHQLHJDWRWDOPHQWHVtVtHVFXULRVRSHURPLUD 06tVtTXHHVFXULRVR¢<TXpGLUtDVGHODDFWLWXGGHORVSDGUHV" 0$%LHQ\RKHWHQLGRWUHVHQWUHYLVWDVFRQORVSDGUHV\ODVGRV~OWLPDVIXHURQGHVSXpV 5 GHODHQWUHYLVWDTXHHOSVLFyORJRGHOFHQWUR\\RIXLPRVDOFHQWURGHUHKDELOLWDFLyQ<VHOR H[SOLTXp\HOORVWDPELpQPHGLMHURQTXHHQFDVDKDFtDQORPLVPRTXHODD\XGDEDQTXH KDEtDQ QRWDGR TXH DO OOHJDU D FDVD VH SRQtD D KDFHU FRVDV« <R QR TXLHUR GHFLU TXH 0DUtDQRKD\DPHMRUDGRTXHVtTXHKDPHMRUDGR\HVWR\RORYHRPX\SRVLWLYRDXQTXH VHDSRFRXQSRFRKHPRVPHMRUDGRSRUTXHHOODVtTXHDOJXQDVYHFHVSXHVOHHQWUHJDV ODVFRVDV\ODVWUDH\WHGLFHSXHVFRPRODVKDKHFKR\FRPRQRHKORTXHSDVDTXH QRTXHHYLGHQWHPHQWHQROOHJDODQLYHOGHORVRWURV 0<D¢4XpHVTXHWLHQHXQDDFWLWXGPiVSDVLYDHQFODVH" 0$6tVt 00X\SDVLYDSRGUtDPRVGHFLU" 5 0$6tDYHFHVSRUHMHPSORVHQLHJDDEXVFDUODVFRVDV\WRGRFXDQGRDYHFHVGHFLPRV SXHVDKRUDWHQpLVTXHVDFDUQRVpTXH«<GLFH³HVTXH\RORKHGHMDGRHQFDVD´³0DUtD E~VFDOR´<VyORTXHOHGLJDVHVWR\DVHHQIDGD\OXHJRQROREXVFD\OXHJR\RPHHQIDGR SRUTXHYR\DOOt\ORHQFXHQWUR<PHHQIDGRPXFKRFRQHOODSRUTXHHVTXHOHGLJR³HVTXH W~ QR SRQHV LQWHUpV 0DUtD´ GLJR ³\R QR WH H[LMR QL PiV QL PHQRV TXH ORV RWURV LJXDO´ WHQLHQGR HQ FXHQWDV VXV GLILFXOWDGHV SHUR OH H[LMR OR PLVPR WDPELpQ SRUTXH HOOD WLHQH FDSDFLGDGHV 0&ODUR 0$<KD\TXHSRWHQFLDUODVSRUTXHVLQRPDOYDPRV<VXVSDGUHVORYHQ/RTXHSDVD 5 TXH\RSLHQVRTXHVXVSDGUHVQRHVWiQQRVpQRORVYHRQLSUHSDUDGRVQL«WDPSRFRQR VH VL VRQ FRQVFLHQWHV GH ODV GLILFXOWDGHV GH 0DUtD QR OR Vp SRUTXH HQ HO FHQWUR GH UHKDELOLWDFLyQQRVGLMHURQTXHWHQtDQTXHHVWXGLDUPiVHOFDVRGH0DUtD\TXHWHQGUtDQ TXHKDEODUFRQORVSDGUHV\RWDPSRFRQRVpVLORKDQKHFKR\WDPSRFRQRVpVLVDEHQ OR TXH VDEHPRV HO SVLFyORJR \ \R FXDQGR IXLPRV DOOt QR OR Vp QR Vp FRPR HVWiQ ORV SDGUHV +DEODPRV FRQ HOORV \R KDEOR FRQ HOORV \ OD PDGUH VH SUHRFXSD £HK 4XLHUR GHFLUQRHVTXHQRVHSUHRFXSHQ<LQFOXVROHGLMHURQTXHQRVpVLORKDQKHFKRTXHOH SRQGUtDQ XQDPDHVWUDGHUHIXHU]RSHUR WDPSRFR QR Vp VL OR KDQ KHFKR GLUtD TXH QR SRUTXHVLQR0DUtDPHORKDEUtDGLFKRVHJXUR 0<D\D 0$3HURTXHVXVSDGUHVVtHK\HQODFRORQLDV« 03HURDYHUKDJRPHPRULDTXHRVGLMHURQ¢TXHHUDUHJUHVLYR" 0$6t<TXHOOHJDUtDXQPRPHQWRTXH0DUtDQRSRGUtDQL« 04XHWHQGUtDTXHGHVSOD]DUVHHQVLOODGHUXHGDV¢QR" 0$7RWDOPHQWH 03RUGHELOLGDGPXVFXODU 0$6t<HQFDPELR\RPHSDUHFH«ORVSDGUHVQRVpVLORVDEHQHVWRD~Q1RWHQJRQL LGHD1RVp 0¢<DOJ~QRWURGDWRVREUHVXFDUiFWHU"¢(VVHULDRDOHJUH"¢&yPRODSHUFLEHV" 0$(QODFODVH\RGLUtDWDQWRHQODFODVHFRPRHQORVSDWLRVHKSRUTXHDYHFHVHQORV SDWLRVQRVpEXHQRVXSRQJRTXHWXWDPELpQKDVYLVWRTXHHVWiPiVELHQVROD<HQOD FODVH GLUtD QR Vp QL VL WULVWH VL DOHJUH SHUR SDVLYD (Q FDPELR FXDQGR YDPRV GH H[FXUVLyQ\HVWR\DYHFHVPHVLHQWRFRQHOOD\HVPX\KDEODGRUD\WHH[SOLFDODVFRVDV \ HVWi PX\ FRQWHQWD \ PX\ GLYHUWLGD 4XLHUR GHFLU TXH QR Vp HV TXH HV FRPR GRV 5 FDUiFWHUHVPX\GLIHUHQWHVTXHWLHQH0DUtDSRUTXHWHH[SOLFDPXFKDFRVDVGHVXFDVDGH VXSDGUHGHVXPDGUHGHVXVKHUPDQDVGHOFHQWURGHUHKDELOLWDFLyQKDEODPXFKRGHpO SHUR HQ SRVLWLYR HK TXH HVWi PX\ FRQWHQWD \ PX\ ELHQ TXLHUR GHFLU FXDQGR VDOLPRV SXHV SHUIHFWR SHUR HQ OD FODVH TXH HV GRQGH KD\ XQDV H[LJHQFLDV TXH KD\ XQRV HMHUFLFLRV D KDFHU SXHV \D HVWi DVt FRPR PX\ SDVLYD 7ULVWH QR VHUtD OD SDODEUD VLQR SDVLYD 0&RPRVLQROHPRWLYDVH¢QR" 5 0$1RQRHVTXHQROHPRWLYDSDUDQDGD 01ROHPRWLYD 0$1RQR\WDPSRFRQRVpFyPRKDFHUORSRUTXHDYHFHVLQFOXVROHGLJR³PLUDW~SDUD PDxDQD KD\HVWRHVWR\HVWRW~TXpFUHHVTXHSXHGHVKDFHUORSDUDPDxDQD"´\GLFH ³HVWR´\EXHQRDYHFHVORKDFH\DYHFHVQR4XLHURGHFLUTXHQRVpHVTXHHVFRPR PX\GLItFLOGHVDEHUFyPRHV0DUtDSRUTXHHOODVHFLHUUDVHFLHUUD\QRKD\PDQHUDHV GLItFLO 00PP¢\DOJ~QRWURGDWRSDUD«" 0$1R\RFUHRTXH\DORKHPRVGLFKREDVWDQWH¢QR" 0¢«TXHQRVD\XGHDHQWHQGHUPiVD0DUtD" 0$¢6LKHPRVHQWHQGLGRPiVD0DUtD" 01RDOJ~QGDWRPiVTXHQRVD\XGHDHQWHQGHUPiVD0DUtDGHVSXpVGHWRGRVHVWRV RFKRPHVHVGHFRPSDUWLUFRQHOODHODXOD 0$%XHQRFRPRFRQFOXVLyQGLUtDTXHQRVpVL0DUtDHV«EXHQRDKRUDHPSLH]DDGDUVH 5 FXHQWDGHORVSUREOHPDVTXHYDDWHQHU\\RFUHRTXHSRUHVWHPRWLYR\DGHFLGHSXHV SRQHUVHFRPRXQDEDUUHUD\GHFLUEXHQRKDVWDDTXtDTXtPHSDUR(VWDHVODVHQVDFLyQ TXHPHGDDPL 0¢&yPRVLQRDFHSWDVHORVHIHFWRVGHODGLVFDSDFLGDG" 0$6tVt,QFRQVFLHQWHPHQWHHKSRUTXHFXDQGR«\RFUHRTXHHOODHYLGHQWHPHQWHORYH ODVGLILFXOWDGHV\FXDQGRSRUHMHPSORIXLPRVDODVFRORQLDVORSUREyGHKDFHUWRGRHKQR HVTXHVHQHJDUD3RUHMHPSORODHVFDODGDODSUREySRUTXHPHGHFtDTXHWHQtDPXFKD IXHU]DHQORVEUD]RV\\ROHGHFtDSXHVTXHELHQSRUTXHVHWLHQHTXHWHQHUPXFKD\ FRQHOPRQLWRUSXHVHOODFRQORVEUD]RV\ODtEDPRVDO]DQGR\OHGLMH³FXDQGRWHTXLHUDV SDUDU WH SDUDV´ \ HOOD GLMR ³SXHV KDVWD DTXt´ \ KDVWD DTXt 7H TXLHUR GHFLU TXH \R PH SHQVDED TXH VHJ~Q TXp FRVDV HOOD PH GLUtD ³QR QR HVWR \R QR OR KDJR SRUTXH QR OR SXHGRKDFHU´<QRQRQRORGHFtD4XLHURGHFLUTXHQRORPXHVWUDORTXHSDVDTXHFODUR YDFUHFLHQGR\VHGDFXHQWDGHODVGLILFXOWDGHV\SDUDPtHVFRPRVLKXELHUDGLFKR³KDVWD DTXtKDVWDDTXtKHOOHJDGRSRUTXHKDVWDDTXtWRGRHOPXQGRHVWiSRUPLWRGRHOPXQGR PHD\XGD\VLFUH]FRPiVSXHVWDOYH]QRPHD\XGD´ 0<D 0$3HURHVWRHVXQDSHUFHSFLyQPX\SHUVRQDOTXHWHQJRHK" 06tVt 0$3HURHVFRPRVLHOODGHFLGLHUDQRFUHFHU7DQWRSRUODPDQHUDGHKDEODUFRPRSRUOD PDQHUDGHDFWXDUFRPRSRUODPDQHUDGHHQIDGDUVHSRUWRGRFRQODOHWUDTXHWLHQH 0¢6L"¢8QDOHWUDPX\LQIDQWLO" 0$0XFKR0X\JUDQGHPX\«EXHQRLQIDQWLO 0¢&RQSRFDFDSDFLGDGGHH[SUHVLyQ" 0$6t6tVt0X\SRFRHQODFRVDVGHFODVHHKPX\SRFRDXWyQRPD 0¢6t" 0$ 6t EXHQR SRUTXH VLHPSUH WLHQHV TXH GHFLU OR TXH KD\ TXH KDFHU WLHQHV TXH D\XGDUOHSRUHMHPSORFRUWDQGR\WRGR 0¢/DWLHQHVTXHD\XGDU" 0$1RD\XGDUOHSHURTXHVHYHTXHQRDYDQ]DVRQFDUDFWHUtVWLFDVTXHPHGHPXHVWUDQ SDUDPtSXHVTXHHVPiVLQIDQWLOTXHORVRWURVSRUHVWRSRUODOHWUDSRUODPDQHUDGH FRQWDU HV PX\ GHVRUGHQDGD (VWR QR TXLHUH GHFLU TXH HOOD QR VDEH QL GyQGH WLHQH ODV FRVDVHV«QRVp(OGHVRUGHQTXHGHEHWHQHUHQVXLQWHULRUORPXHVWUDHQHOH[WHULRU 0<D<KDVGLFKRTXHHVSRFRDXWyQRPDHQODFODVH 0$6t 02VHDODPRYLOLGDGUHGXFLGDOHDIHFWDDVXDXWRQRPtD 0$3HUR\RQRVpVLHVXQHIHFWRGLUHFWRRHVTXHHOODHVDVt+D\JHQWHTXHWDPELpQHQ 5 OD FODVH QR WLHQH QLQJXQD GLILFXOWDG PRWRUD \ WDPELpQ HV« ¢\D KDV HQWHQGLGR OR TXH WLHQHVTXHKDFHU"³D\QR´4XLHURGHFLUPX\GHVSLVWDGDQRVpVLODSDODEUDVHUtDSRFR DXWyQRPDSHURGHVSLVWDGD\SRURWDQWRWLHQHVTXHGHFLUOH³0DUtDDKRUDWLHQHVTXHKDFHU HVWRYHQJD0DUtD«´ 0&RQSUREOHPDVGHDWHQFLyQ 0$6tVt3HURSRUGHVSLVWDGD\QRVpQRVpFRPRGHVFULELUOR 01RQR\DORKDVGHVFULWRPX\ELHQORKDVGHVFULWRPX\ELHQ 0$ 1RRR SHUR WH TXLHUR GHFLU TXH SRU RWUD SDUWH HV HQFDQWDGRUD FXDQGR TXLHUH HV 5 HQFDQWDGRUD \ PX\ VRFLDEOH \ WH H[SOLFD ODV FRVDV /R TXH SDVD TXH FRQ HVWRV WHPDV SXHV«\HVPX\VRFLDEOH\DWUHYLGDSRUORTXHWHKHGLFKRGHODVFRORQLDVHOODQRWHQtD QLQJ~QSUREOHPD\TXHUtDKDFHUORWRGR\QRVORSDVDPRVSLSDVHORSDVyPX\ELHQ<D PtPHGDEDXQSRFRGHPLHGRSRUTXHFRPRHQODVXOWLPDVVDOLGDVKDEtDUHDFFLRQDGRGH HVWDPDQHUDSHQVDED\DYHUiVSHURPX\ELHQQRVORSDVDPRVPX\ELHQ\HOODHVWDED FRQWHQWDIHOL]« 0¢<VHKDLQWHUUHODFLRQDGRFRQORVQLxRV" 0$0XFKR 0¢&RQVXVFRPSDxHURV" 0$ 0XFKR Vt Vt < IXLPRV D MXJDU D WHQLV \ HOOD FRQ OD VLOOD GH UXHGDV IXLPRV QR Vp GyQGH \ HOOD FRQ OD VLOOD GH UXHGDV« \ FXDQGR SRUTXH HQ DTXHO OXJDU KDEtD DOJXQDV EDUUHUDVDUTXLWHFWyQLFDVTXHQRSRGtDPRVLUFRQODVLOOD\KDEtDVLHPSUHDTXHOFKLFRR DOJXLHQR\RTXHOHOOHYDEDODVPXOHWDV\FXDQGRWHQtDTXHEDMDUSXHVODVFRJtD«TXLHUR GHFLUWHHQHVHDVSHFWRVtTXHHUDDXWyQRPDSHURHQVXVFRVDVPiVSHUVRQDOHVQRORHV 06tVt 0$ < HVWR PX\ GHFLGLGD \ PX\ DWUHYLGD HQ HVWRV DVSHFWRV SHUR HQ ODV FRVDV GH OD HVFXHODTXHHVORTXH\RSRUHMHPSORPiVPHILMR« 0&ODUR 0$«RFRQODVTXHPHUHODFLRQRPiVFRQHOODSXHVHV«KD\FRPRXQDSDUDGDQRVp FRPRGHFLUOR 08QEORTXHR" 0$8QEORTXHRVt 0%XHQRSXHVPXFKtVLPDVJUDFLDV 0$$Wt (175(9,67$$/&(1752 0DGUHGH0DUtDDOXPQDREMHWRGHOHVWXGLRGHO&HQWUR 0DHVWUDGH(GXFDFLyQ)tVLFD )(&+$GHMXQLRGH 0¢&yPRPHH[SOLFDUtDVFyPRHV0DUtDVLQRODFRQRFLHVH" 0$'5(%XHQR0DUtD« 0¢&yPRYHVDWXKLMDFyPRODGHILQLUtDV" 5 0$'5(0X\TXHSDVDPXFKRGHWRGRTXH\RTXHVpTXHEXHQRFDVRQRKDFHQXQFD HVLJXDOSXHGHGHFLUORTXHTXLHUDVTXH« 0¢&DVRQRKDFHQR" 0$'5(4XHYDHOODVLHPSUHYDDORVX\RVLHPSUHWLHQHTXHVHUORTXHHOODGLJD\QRVp TXpPDV 0$(675$()%XHQRSRUTXHHVWiHQODHGDGHVWD 0¢<W~FyPRODYHVDOHJUHXQDQLxDDOHJUH«" 5 0$'5(6tQRDOHJUHVt 0(VXQDQLxDDOHJUH 0$'5(6t 0¢6RFLDEOH"¢6HUHODFLRQDFRQPXFKDJHQWHRHVPiVLQWURYHUWLGD" 5 0$'5(/HFXHVWDOHFXHVWD 0/HFXHVWDUHODFLRQDUVH 0$'5(6t6HUHODFLRQDPiVFRQQLxRVPiVSHTXHxRVTXHHOODRVHDHVPX\LQIDQWLO\ FRQ QLxRV PiV SHTXHxRV VH UHODFLRQD PHMRU TXH FRQ ORV GH VX HGDG D YHU FRQ ORV JUDQGHV\DQRGLJDPRV 06tVt 0$'5(6tHV« 0¢<HVDFWLYDHQFDVDRQR" 5 0$'5( 0(VWUDQTXLOD" 0$'5( (V WUDQTXLOD VH PHWH HQ VX KDELWDFLyQ \ \D SXHGHV« HV PX\ WUDQTXLOD GHPDVLDGRWUDQTXLOD 0$(675$()3HURHQODKDELWDFLyQVHODDUUHJODHOODHV« 0$'5(6t 0$(675$()«HVVX]RQD\HOODVHUHVSRQVDELOL]D 0$'5( 6H OD DUUHJOD VH OD UHFRJH \ VLQR \D VDEH OR TXH KD\ WRGR DO VXHOR \ D OD EDVXUD 0$(675$()$KPX\ELHQ 0$'5( (V XQ« FXDQGR WLHQH PX\ OOHQD OD PHVD SRUTXH WLHQH OD PHVD PX\ JUDQGH 5 FXDQGRODWLHQHPX\OOHQDGHSDSHOHV\FRVD«EXHQRKDFHSRFRYHQJDWRGRDOVXHOR\OD HVFRED\DODEDVXUD 0$(675$()¢<TXpGLFHHOOD" 0$'5(1DGDYLHQH\ORUHFRJHHQHOSDVLOORORUHFRJH 0$(675$()-D-D-D&ODURPX\ELHQHVRHVWiPX\ELHQ 0$'5(6tVt\ODFDPDVHODKDFHHOODFDGDGtD<RODVViEDQDVVHODVFDPELRSRUTXH HVXQDFDPDTXHHVXQSXHQWH\YDPHWLGDHQODSDUHG\ODViEDQDOHFXHVWDSRQHUODV SHURYD\DFXDQGRVHODFDPELRVHODKDJR\RSHURHOODVHODHVWLUDPiVRPHQRVELHQ\« 02VHDTXHHVUHVSRQVDEOHWDPELpQFRQODVWDUHDVHQFDVD« 0$'5(6tHOODVDEHTXHFXDQGROOHJDPLHQWUDV\ROHSRQJRODFRPLGDHOODWLHQHTXH UHFRJHUVXKDELWDFLyQ 0¢<FRQYRVRWURVFyPRHV" 5 0$'5((VGHH[SOLFDUSRFR\HVPX\FDULxRVD 0(VUHVHUYDGD 0$'5(6t 00DUtDSRGUtDPRVGHFLUTXHHVUHVHUYDGD 0$(675$()6t 0<FDULxRVD 0$'5(&DULxRVDHVPX\FDULxRVD 0&RQYRVRWURV 0$'5(6t 06tTXHORHV 0$(675$()6tTXHORHVHVTXHHVPX\VHQVLEOHHVXQDQLxDPX\WLHUQDPX\WLHUQD 07LHQHXQDVRQULVDTXH« 0$(675$()6tVt 0«TXH\DORGLFHWRGR¢<DOJ~QRWURDVSHFWRDGHVWDFDUGH0DUtD"3DUDHQWHQGHUOD XQSRTXLWRPiVVREUHVXIRUPDGHVHUVXFDUiFWHU« 0$'5(1R 0(VXQSRFRLQFRQVWDQWH¢QR"FRQODVWDUHDVGHOFROHJLR¢QR" 5 0$'5(6tWLHQHPXFKRJHQLR 0<WLHQHPXFKRJHQLR 0$'5( 6t FRQ WRGR OR WUDQTXLOD TXH HV WLHQH PXFKR JHQLR \ PX\ PDOD OHFKH HK $ YHFHVDYHFHVWDPELpQWLHQHPX\« 0$(675$()¢3HURHOODKDEODH[WHULRUL]DORTXHWLHQHRVHORFDUJD\VRODPHQWHSRU JHVWRVGHVFDUJDHOJHQLR"¢1ROHURPSHDGHFLUORTXH«" 0$'5(1RKDEODUQRKDEOD 0$(675$()9HVHVRHVORPDORTXHVHORWUDJD4XHVHORWUDJD\« 0$'5(6tQRKDEODUQRKDEODPXFKR 0$(675$()(OJHQLRORWLHQHSDUDFRQHOODPLVPDHVGRQGHWHQGUtDPRVTXHPLUDUD YHUGHTXpIRUPDHOODVXHOWDWRGRORTXHWLHQH\SLHQVRTXHVHSRGUtDDGHODQWDUPXFKR $KtHVGRQGHOHYHR\R 0$PLHVTXHPHOODPDODDWHQFLyQDYHFHVFXDQGRVHQLHJD¢QR" 5 0$(675$()6tVt 0&XDQGRVHQLHJDTXHOHIRUPXODVXQDSUHJXQWD\OHGLFHV³£+ROD¢TXpWDO0DUtD"´< QRWHFRQWHVWD¢(VRWDPELpQORKDFHFRQYRVRWURV" 0$'5(6t 0¢2HVFRQODJHQWHTXHQRFRQRFH"&RPRHQHOFDVRPtR 0$'5(1RORKDFHEDVWDQWH\FXDQGRDORPHMRUOHVDOXGDOHGLFHQ³KROD0DUtD´VHUtH \\DHVWiRVHDQRGLFH³KROD´SRUTXHVHUtDORPiVQRUPDO¢QR"FRQWHVWDUKRODQRHOOD VHUtH\\DHVWi3RUTXH\RDYHFHVOHGLJR³KLMDSHURFRQWHVWD´\HOODGLFH³6L\DOHKH GLFKRKROD´<GLJR³1RVHORKDVGLFKRVLQROHKDVGLFKRQDGD´ 02VHDTXHHVVXPDQHUDGHVHU¢QR" 0$'5(6t 00DQHUDGHVHUPXFKRPiVLQWURYHUWLGD\TXHFXDQGROHDSHWHFHELHQ\TXHFXDQGRQR QRFRQWHVWD¢QR" 0$'5(6t 0&DEL]EDMLWD\FRQWLQXDFDPLQDQGR¢QR" 0$'5(6tVt 0(VVHJ~QOHYD¢QR" 0$'5(6tHV«SRUTXHFRQWRGRORFKDUODWDQDTXHHVOXHJRHV«SHURFXDQGRDHOODOH 5 YD ELHQ FXDQGRDHOODHVFRPRVLVH OH HQFKXIDUDQ ODV SLODV HQWRQFHV HVFXDQGRGLFH ³DKRUDYR\DKDEODU\YR\DVROWDU´SHURVLQRQR&RQXQ³KROD´XQKRODQRQRFRQWHVWD 0$(675$()<RFUHRTXHHOODORTXHEXVFDVRQPRPHQWRVGLFH³HVWHPRPHQWRHVHO 5 PtRDKRUDDTXtPHWLHQHTXHHVFXFKDUWRGRHOPXQGR\KDEOR&XDQGRPHSLGHQTXH\R KDEOHFRPRQRHVPLPRPHQWRPHQLHJR\QRORKDJR´¢YHUGDG"'HEHVHUHVR 0$'5(6t\RQRVpSRUTXpSHURHVDVt 0$(675$()6tVt 0<ODUHODFLyQFRQVXVKHUPDQDVELHQ¢QR" 0$'5(6tVHSHOHDQPXFKRSHUREXHQR 06HSHOHDQPXFKR 0$(675$()%XHQRSHURHVRSDVDHQWRGDVODVFDVDV 0&ODURHVORKDELWXDO 0$(675$()&RQORVKHUPDQRVHV«£EXI 02VHDTXH«\ORTXHWHSUHRFXSDPiVGH0DUtDHQODDFWXDOLGDGHVORVHVWXGLRVORV SUREOHPDVGHDWHQFLyQ¢QR"TXHWLHQH 0$'5(6t 0<GHUHVSRQVDELOLGDGFXDQGRWLHQHTXHKDFHUORVHMHUFLFLRV 0$'5(6t« 06HGLVWUDH" 5 0$'5(6tTXHDYHFHVRVHDYHUVLHOODVHSRQHDKDFHUORORKDFHSHURFRPRHOODQR TXLHUDSXHVQRSXHGHVGHFLUOHORTXHVHDSRUTXH« 0(VHVRTXHDWLWDPELpQWHSDVDTXHFXDQGRHOODQRTXLHUHKDFHUDOJRHVLPSRVLEOH 0$'5(&XDQGRHOODQRTXLHUHHVLPSRVLEOHVtVt 06HSRQHFDEL]EDMDHPSLH]DDOORUDU« 0$'5(6tVt 0$(675$()¢<TXpWLHQH«" 0$'5(<QRHVGHOORUDU 0¢QR" 0$'5(1R1RVHOORUDDYHFHVFXDQGRFRJHJHQLR\HVWRSHURQRQRQRHVTXHVH SRQJDDOORUDU1RHOODQRORKDFH\\DHVWi 0'LFHTXHQR\SXQWR 0$'5(6t 0$(675$()¢3HURYHUGDGTXHWLHQHXQDFKLFDGHUHIXHU]RTXHOHD\XGD" 0$'5(6tVt\ODSREUHFKLFD« 0$(675$()¢<DHOODODWUDWDLJXDO" 0$'5()DWDO 0$(675$()¢3HURQRKDVEXVFDGRTXHVHDXQFKLFR"3RUTXH\RYHRTXHHOODFRQHO KRPEUHWLHQGHDVHUPiVPDQHMDEOH3RUTXHDKRUDFXDQGRKHPRVLGRDODVFRORQLDV« 6HFRUWDODFLQWD 0<HQODVH[FXUVLRQHV¢SRUTXpYHQtDHQIDGDGDHQODVH[FXUVLRQHV" 0$'5(3RUWRGRYHQtDHQIDGDGDSRUWRGR3RUTXHQREXHQRHVTXHVHYHTXHHOODLED \PHGHFtDQEXHQRHVTXHLEDHQHOPHWUR\QRVHTXHUtDVHQWDUWHQtDTXHLUGHSLp£(Q HO PHWUR PRYLpQGRVH < HOOD GH SLp FRQ ODV PXOHWDV 3DUD FDHUVH 1L TXHUtD OD VLOOD QL TXHUtDVHQWDUVHODJHQWHOHGHMDEDORVDVLHQWRV\QRQRTXHUtD6HHQIDGDEDSRUHVRVH HQIDGDEDSRUTXHODFKLFDODOOHYDEDHQODVLOODTXHTXHUtDLUHOODVROD 0$(675$()2TXHODOOHYDEDQORVFRPSDxHURV 0$'5(1R\VHHQIDGDED 0$(675$()6tVt 0$'5(<YHQtD\OOHJDEDFRQXQRVPRUURVDVtOOHJDEDDVtFRQXQRVPRUURVDVt\\D HVWi 0¢7~TXHSLHQVDVTXHUHFKD]DODVLOOD" 0$'5(1R 0¢1R" 0$'5(1RSRUTXHQR 0/DVLOODQRHVSUREOHPD 0$'5(1R(VTXHODD\XGHQ« 04XHODD\XGHQDFHSWDUTXHQHFHVLWDD\XGD 5 0$'5(6t 0/HPROHVWD 0$'5(6tOHPROHVWDTXHOHD\XGHQ 0$(675$()1RSHUR\RHVDD\XGDQRODKHYLVWRTXHHOODODUHFKDFHFXDQGRYLHQHXQ FKLFRHKQR3RUTXHHOWUDWRGHHOODHVFRPSOHWDPHQWHGLIHUHQWHLQFOXVROHOODPDEDHK FRPR GLFLHQGR ³(K TXH W~ HVWiV DTXt SRU Pt´ 2 VHD TXH \D VDEHV 2 VHD TXH \D QR EXVFDED OD D\XGD GH ORV FRPSDxHURV < HQWRQFHV HUDQ ORV FRPSDxHURV TXH OH GHFtDQ ³+D\GpMDQRVTXHODOOHYHPRVXQUDWR´\HOODWRGDFRQWHQWD³Vt´3HURTXH\DQRHUDHOODOD TXH SHGtD (UDQ ORV FRPSDxHURV TXH OD TXHUtDQ D HOOD ¢QR" 3RUTXH QRVRWURV WDPELpQ TXHUHPRVDFRPSDxDUD0DUtD¢QR" 0 ¢< WH KD KHFKR DOJ~Q FRPHQWDULR GH OD FODVH GH () GH HVWH DxR" 1XQFD WH KD FRPHQWDGRQDGDGHVSXpVGHVDOLUGHODFODVH« 0$'5(1R 0$(675$()6LVHORKDSDVDGRELHQTXpHVORTXHKDKHFKR« 0$'5(6tTXHKDMXJDGR\HVRVtTXHPHORGLFH 02VHDWHORKDLGRH[SOLFDQGR 0$'5(3HUROXHJRFRPHQWDULRVQR3XHVTXHKHMXJDGRDHVWR\KHPHWLGRXQJROR TXH«HQHOFHQWURGHUHKDELOLWDFLyQWDPELpQMXHJDDEiVTXHWROXHJRVLHPSUHPHGLFH ³KHPRVJDQDGR´6LHPSUHYLHQHFRQHO³+HPRVJDQDGR´6LHVRVtSHUROXHJRQR« 0$(675$ () 2 VHD TXH WDPSRFR WH KD KDEODGR FXDQGR QRVRWURV DTXt HQ () KDFHQ WUDEDMRVHQJUXSR\XQRVMXHJRVTXHWLHQHQTXHSDUWLFLSDUFRQXQJUXSR«VLHOJUXSROH KDJXVWDGRR« 0$'5(1R 0$(675$()1RQDGD 01RKDVYLVWRQLQJXQDSUHIHUHQFLDSRUODFODVHFRQUHVSHFWRDODVRWUDVDVLJQDWXUDV 0$'5(¢3RUODFODVHGHJLPQDVLD" 06t 0$'5(6t/DFODVHGHJLPQDVLDVtOHJXVWD 5 0¢(OODWHORKDGLFKRTXHOHJXVWD" 0$'5(6tHVORTXHPiVOHJXVWD 0(VORTXHPiVOHJXVWD 0$'5('HOFROHJLRGHWRGR« 0(VTXHODPDHVWUDHVPXFKDPDHVWUDHK" 0$(675$()$KRUDTXH\ROHJXVWHQRORVpOHJXVWDQ« 0/DOOHYDFRQXQDPDQRL]TXLHUGD«PDGUHGH'LRV 0$(675$()+RPEUHSRUTXH\RTXLHURTXHVHDHOOD«TXHHOODWLHQHSRWHQFLDO 0$'5(&ODUR\OXHJRORVMXHJRVOHJXVWDQPXFKRORVMXHJRVOHJXVWDQ 02VHDVLHPSUHYLHQHPiVPRWLYDGD¢QR" 0$'5(6t&RQODJLPQDVLDHVTXHOHJXVWD(VTXHLQFOXVRMXJDUDI~WEROTXHGLFHPL PDULGR ³-ROLQHV D OD ~QLFD QLxD TXH OH JXVWD MXJDU D I~WERO HV OD TXH QR SXHGH MXJDU GLJDPRV´3RUTXHDODVRWUDVHOI~WEROHVTXHQLOHKDEOHV 0$(675$()<D\D(VYHUGDGVXVKHUPDQDVQRTXHUtDQI~WEROFXDQGRMXJDEDQDTXt TXHWRFDEDSRUHMHPSORTXHKDFtDI~WEROPL[WRVLHPSUHVHQHJDEDQ 0$'5(<ODKHUPDQDPD\RUDOOtHVWXYRMXJDQGRHQOD(62« 0$(675$()¢6L"£$QGD\DWRPD1RTXHUtDVHQOD(*%HQODSULPDULDSXHVWRPD 0 %XHQR SXHV« ¢QLQJ~Q RWUR GDWR D GHVWDFDU GH 0DUtD SDUD HQWHQGHUOD XQ SRTXLWR PiV" 0$'5(3XHVQRVpQRVpTXpGHFLUWH 00iVRPHQRV\DSDUHFHTXHKHPRVUHFRJLGR« 0$(675$()6t\DHVWi 0%XHQRSXHVPXFKtVLPDVJUDFLDVDODVGRV (175(9,67$$/&(1752 0DUtDDOXPQDREMHWRGHOHVWXGLRGHO&HQWUR )(&+$\GHMXQLRGH 00DUtD¢&yPRKDVYLYLGRHVWHDxRODFODVHGH()"¢7HKDJXVWDGR" 0$5Ì$1R« 08QSRTXLWRPiVIXHUWH0DUtDSRUTXHVLQRQRSRGUHPRVJUDYDU 0$5Ì$1RORVp 0¢1RORVDEHVVLWHKDJXVWDGR" 0$5Ì$1R 0¢7HKDJXVWDGRRQRWHKDJXVWDGR"¢&XiQGRWHKDJXVWDGRPiVODFODVHGH()" 0$5Ì$1RORVp 0¢1RORVDEHV0DUtD"6t«DOJRVDEUiV« 0$5Ì$4XHQRORVp 0 +D\ GtDVTXHWHKHYLVWRTXHWHORKDVSDVDGRPX\ELHQRWURVGtDVWDOYH]PHQRV ¢1RSXHGHVKDFHUPHPRULDFXDQGRWHKDJXVWDGRPiVODFODVHGH()" 0$5Ì$<RTXHVp 0¢&yPR" 0$5Ì$4XHQRORVp 01RVDEHV«¢1RVDEHVVLWHKDJXVWDGR"¢QR" 0$5Ì$1R 0¢1RVDEUtDVGHFtUPHOR" 0$5Ì$1R 0¢1RVDEHVGHFtUPHOR0DUtD" 0$5Ì$4XHQR« 0<RSLHQVRTXHVtTXHORVDEHVSHURTXHQRPHORTXLHUHVGHFLU 0$5Ì$4XHQR 0¢SRUTXpQR" 0$5Ì$3RUTXHQR 0¢<SRUTXpQRPHORTXLHUHVGHFLU0DUtD" 0$5Ì$3RUTXHQRTXLHUR 0£1RTXLHUHVGHFLUPHQDGD¢HVWiVHQIDGDGDFRQPLJR" 0$5Ì$6t 0¢3RUTXp"¢3RUTXpHVWiVHQIDGDGDFRQPLJR"<RQRHVWR\HQIDGDGDFRQWLJR0DUtD« ¢4XpKD\DOJRTXHQRWHKDJXVWDGRGHPL" 0$5Ì$6t 0 ¢6t" ¢4Xp HV OR TXH QR WH KD JXVWDGR GH PL" 'tPHOR SRUTXH VLQR QR DSUHQGHUp ¢4XpHVORTXHQRWHKDJXVWDGR0DUtD"¢SRUTXpHVWiVHQIDGDGDFRQPLJR"6LQRPHOR GLFHV« 0$5Ì$3RUTXHVt 0 3HUR SRUTXH Vt QR HV XQD UHVSXHVWD« 1R PH GD GDWRV QXQFD OR VDEUp \ ILQDOL]DUHPRV HO FXUVR \ QR VDEUp SRU TXp HVWDV HQIDGDGD FRQPLJR \ SRU TXp QR PH TXLHUHVFRQWHVWDU£9DGtPHOR 0$5Ì$1R 0¢1RPHORTXLHUHVGHFLU" 0$5Ì$1R 02VHDTXHHVWiVPX\HQIDGDGDHK¢1RTXLHUHVKDFHUODHQWUHYLVWD" 0$5Ì$1R 03XHVVLWHKHQRVHVFRJLGRDWLHQHVWHFXUVR« 0$5Ì$3XHVHVFRJHDRWUR 0¢TXp" 0$5Ì$4XHHVFRMDVDRWUR 0 ¢4Xp HVFRMD D RWUR" 1R QR WH DFXHUGDV TXH DO SULQFLSLR GH FXUVR WH SDVp XQD HQWUHYLVWD HQ WX FODVH \ DKRUD QHFHVLWDPRV KDFHU OD PLVPD HQWUHYLVWD SDUD YHU TXp KD RFXUULGR DORODUJRGHOFXUVR\HUDVW~ OD SHUVRQDHVFRJLGD6LW~QRPHUHVSRQGHVHO HVWXGLR TXH HVWDPRV KDFLHQGR VREUH OD (GXFDFLyQ )tVLFD () HQ OD HVFXHOD IDOWDUDQ GDWRV«QRSRGUHPRVFRPSDUDUHOSULQFLSLRGHOFXUVRFRQHOILQDO 0$5Ì$<DPLTXp 0¢4Xp"<DWLTXH«SXHVItMDWHQRSXHGRKDFHUHOHVWXGLRGHWRGRHODxR<WRGR«< QRSRGUHPRVGHFLUTXpKDRFXUULGRHQHVWDHVFXHOD<WRGRSRUTXHWHQLHJDVDFRQWHVWDU <RSLHQVRTXHVtTXHSXHGHVFRODERUDU0DUtD 0$5Ì$1R 0¢QRTXLHUHVFRODERUDU" 0$5Ì$1R 0¢4Xp" 0$5Ì$4XHQRORYR\DKDFHU 0¢4XHQR«" 0$5Ì$4XHQRORYR\DKDFHU 0¢QRORTXLHUHVKDFHU0DUtD" 0$5Ì$1R 03XHVItMDWHHQWXHVFXHODRFXUULUiTXHHQXQFXUVRQRVIDOWDUDQGDWRVSRUTXH« 0$5Ì$3XHVHVFRJHDRWUR\\DHVWi 0 1R SRUTXH WH HVFRJLPRV D WL DO SULQFLSLR GHO FXUVR \ QHFHVLWDPRV VDEHU TXp KD SDVDGRDORODUJRGHOFXUVRFRQWLJR$OSULQFLSLRGHOFXUVRWHKLFLPRVXQDHQWUHYLVWD¢WH DFXHUGDV QR" FRPR UHSUHVHQWDQWH GH TXLQWR $KRUD KD SDVDGR HO FXUVR \ WDQ VROR WH TXLHURKDFHUWUHVSUHJXQWDVQRPiV6LQRWHYR\DUREDUPXFKRWLHPSR&RQODSRVLFLyQ TXHW~WLHQHVGHTXHQRTXLHUHVFRQWHVWDUHVWDPRVSHUGLHQGRPXFKRWLHPSR6LLQWHQWDV KDFHU VROR XQ PtQLPR HVIXHU]R SRU UHVSRQGHU D ODV SUHJXQWDV TXH WH KDJR VDOGUHPRV UiSLGRGHDTXt1LFLQFRPLQXWRVHVWDUHPRVMXQWDV 0$5Ì$4XLHURLUPHDKRUD 0¢&yPR" 0$5Ì$4XHTXLHURLUPHDKRUD 0¢7HTXLHUHVLUDKRUD" 0$5Ì$6t 0¢<QRTXLHUHVFRQWHVWDUDODHQWUHYLVWD" 0$5Ì$1R 03RUTXHHVWiVHQIDGDGDFRQPLJR 0$5Ì$6t 0¢6RORSRUTXHHVWiVHQIDGDGDFRQPLJR" 0$5Ì$1RSRUTXHQRTXLHUR 0¢<VLWHKDFHODHQWUHYLVWDODPDHVWUDGH()" 0$5Ì$1R 0¢<VLWHODKDFHPDPiODHQWUHYLVWD">GLFHTXHQRFRQODFDEH]D@¢7DPSRFR"¢SRU TXpQRSRUTXpQRHVWDQRFKHORFRQVXOWDVFRQODDOPRKDGDHLQWHQWDVSHQVDUHQORTXH WHHVWR\GLFLHQGR"TXHVLQRFRODERUDVDKRUDFRQODHQWUHYLVWDQRVYDQDIDOWDUGDWRV 0$5Ì$3XHVFRJHDRWURTXHWHGLJDORTXHTXLHUD 01RSRUTXHQRSXHGHVHUSRUTXHW~HUHVXQDSHUVRQDPX\LPSRUWDQWHHQHVWHHVWXGLR HQTXLQWRSRUTXHW~HUHVODUHSUHVHQWDQWHGHTXLQWR 0$5Ì$3XHVFRJHDRWUR 0 1R SRUTXH WH KLFLPRV D WL« HO SULPHU GtD FRODERUDVWH PX\ ELHQ HQ HO SULQFLSLR GH FXUVRTXHWHKLFLPRVODHQWUHYLVWD 0$5Ì$1R 0¢1RWHDFXHUGDVTXHHVWXYLPRVKDEODQGRHQODVDODGHLQIRUPiWLFD"(QHOSULPHUSLVR ¢RHUDHQODVDODGHHVWXGLR"0HSDUHFHTXHHUDHQODVDODGHHVWXGLR¢WHDFXHUGDVR QR"4XHHVWDEDVGHVD\XQDQGR 0$5Ì$4XH\RTXLHURLUPHDKRUD 0¢3HURSRUTXHHVWiVFDQVDGD" 0$5Ì$1R 0¢(QWRQFHVSRUTXpWHTXLHUHVLUDKRUD" 0$5Ì$3RUTXHTXLHURLUPH 03RUTXHTXLHUHVLUWHDKRUD 0$5Ì$6t 0¢<QRSRGUtDVGHFLUPHSRUTXpHVWiVWDQHQIDGDGDFRQPLJR"¢&LHUURHOFDVHWH\PH ORGLFHV" 0$5Ì$1R 0¢1LWDPSRFRFRQHVR" 0$5Ì$1R 0 (QWRQFHV ItMDWH \R PH YR\ D LU GH YDFDFLRQHV \ QR YR\ D VDEHU SRU TXp HVWDV HQIDGDGDFRQPLJR 0$5Ì$£3XHVSUHJ~QWDVHORDRWUR<\DHVWi 0¢(VWiVHQIDGDGDSRUTXHWHKHHVFRJLGRDWLSDUDKDFHUODHQWUHYLVWD"¢(VSRUHVR" 0$5Ì$1RSRUTXHWHQJRTXHFRPHUPHHOERFDGLOOR\\RQRTXLHURHVWDUDTXt 03RUTXHWLHQHVTXHFRPHUWHHOERFDGLOOR\QRTXLHUHVHVWDUDTXt 0$5Ì$£1R 0(QWRQFHVSXHVGLPHPiVFRVDV 0$5Ì$3XHVSRUTXH\RQRTXLHURHVWDUDTXt 01RTXLHUHVHVWDUDTXt 0$5Ì$1R 0¢<VLPDxDQDWHKDJRODHQWUHYLVWDDODXQDGHOPHGLRGtD"¢WDPSRFR" 0$5Ì$1R 02VHDQRTXLHUHVFRODERUDU¢QR" 0$5Ì$1R 03XHVSDUHFHPHQWLUDFRQGLH]DxRVTXHW~WLHQHVWHHVWiVFRPSRUWDQGRFRPRXQDQLxD SHTXHxD« 0$5Ì$4XHQRTXLHUR\QRYR\DFRQWHVWDUDKRUD<QRTXLHUR 0<SRUTXpQRTXLHUHV"VyORGLPHHOSRUTXp 0$5Ì$4XHQR 0&XDQGRPHGLJDVHOSRUTXpQRTXLHUHVRPHORUD]RQHVHQWRQFHV\DWHGHMRWUDQTXLOD 6RORGLPHSRUTXpQRTXLHUHV 0$5Ì$3RUTXHQRTXLHUR3RUTXHQRTXLHURQRTXLHURQRTXLHUR3RUTXHQRTXLHURPH YR\\D 0¢7HYDV"0HHQWULVWHFHPXFKR£HK0X\ELHQJUDFLDV0DUtD >VHYD/RLQWHQWDPRVHOGtDVLJXLHQWHMXQWRFRQODPDHVWUDGH()@ 0%XHQRKR\HVGtD\HVWDPRVFRQODPDHVWUDGH()\0DUtDUHXQLGDVSDUDIRUPXODU D 0DUtD XQDV SUHJXQWDV VREUH HVWH FXUVR ¢YDOH" 0DUtD ¢TXp HV OR TXH PiV WH KD JXVWDGRGHODFODVHGH()" 0$5Ì$>HQVLOHQFLR@ &8\«¢QRWHKDJXVWDGRQDGD"¢1RKDKDELGRQLQJ~QMXHJRTXHW~WHORKD\DVSDVDGR PX\ELHQ\TXHPHLEDVSLGLHQGRGHUHSHWLUOR" 0¢$OJ~QGtDUHFXHUGDVTXHQRWHKD\DJXVWDGR" &3HURGLORGLORYHUEDOPHQWH 0¢,QWHUSUHWDPRVTXHVLHPSUHWHKDJXVWDGRODFODVH"¢4XLHUHVGHFLUTXHVt" 0$5Ì$6t 06t¢VLHPSUHWHKDJXVWDGRODFODVH" 0$5Ì$6t 0¢6t\SRUTXpWHKDJXVWDGRODFODVH" 0$5Ì$>VHHQFRJHGHKRPEURV@ &¢&yPRTXHQRORVDEHV«" 04XHUDUR¢QR" & 3RUTXH OR KDFtDV W~ VROD R OR KDFtDV FRPSDUWLpQGROR FRQ WRGRV WXV FRPSDxHURV \ KDEtDFRPSDxHURVTXHWLHQHVPiVDILQLGDGTXHWHORSDVDVPHMRU«¢HUDSRUHVRRTXp" 3HURH[SOtFDPHORW~KLMD6LW~QRPHORGLFHV\RQRVp«QRVpTXpTXLHUHVGHFLUPH 0$5Ì$>VHHQFRJHGHKRPEURV@ &¢(VRTXHHV" 0$5Ì$4XHQRORVp & ¢&yPR TXH QR VDEHV" 0DUtD SLHQVD XQ SRTXLWR VL QR HV XQD SUHJXQWD TXH GLJDV ³£RVWUDV4XpPHHVWiSUHJXQWDQGRQRHQWLHQGRORTXHPHHVWiSUHJXQWDQGR«´¢HVHVR" 0$5Ì$6t &6t¢TXp" 0$5Ì$1RORVp &%XHQRSXHVH[SOLFDDOJ~QMXHJRTXHWHKD\DJXVWDGRPXFKR\TXH« 0$5Ì$(OSXHQWH &(OSXHQWH¢<ORVDEUtDVH[SOLFDUFyPRVHMXHJDDHVWHMXHJR\SRUTXpWHKDJXVWDGR HVHMXHJR" 0$5Ì$1R &¢1RTXp"<GpMDWHGHFKXSDUORVGHGRV 0$5Ì$4XHQRORVp &¢&yPRTXHQRORVDEHV"2\H¢TXpWHSDUHFHVLHVWHWLSRGHSUHJXQWDVWHORKDFHPRV SRUHVFULWRWHJXVWDPiVHVFULELUTXHKDEODUOR"¢4XpWHSDUHFH0HUFKH" 0¢6t"3XHVVHORYDPRVDKDFHUSRUHVFULWR & 3RU HVFULWR HK 7H YLHQHV DTXt \ OR FRQWHVWDV FRQPLJR \ OR HVFULELPRV %XHQR OR HVFULEHV W~¢YDOH"3RUTXH\RQRYR\DHVFULELU%XHQR\RWDPELpQWHQGUpTXHHVFULELU SRUTXH\RWDPELpQWHSHGtTXHPHKLFLHUDVXQDHQWUHYLVWDDPL« 06t &<\RWDPELpQTXLHUR\OD'LUHFWRUD\OD-HIDGH(VWXGLRV\OD7XWRUD«KHPRVVDOLGR HOHJLGDV« SRUTXH SRGtD KDEHU VDOLGR RWUDV SURIHVRUDV« SHUR GLMLPRV QR QR QR QRV KDJDVVRUWHRQRVRIUHFLPRVYROXQWDULDV 0%XHQRHQWRQFHV¢ORHVFULELUiVFRQ&DUPHQ" &¢6t" 0¢6tWHJXVWDPiVHVFULELUTXHKDEODU"9DOH¢4XpLQWHUSUHWRTXHVtFRQHOJHVWRGHOD FDUD" &9DOH 0 &RQ HO PRYLPLHQWR GH OD FDEH]D LQWHUSUHWR TXH Vt TXH WH JXVWD PiV HVFULELU TXH KDEODU¢(QWRQFHVFRODERUDUiVFRQQRVRWURVHVFULELHQGR"¢6t" &¢6t0DUtD" 09DOHPX\ELHQSXHVPXFKtVLPDVJUDFLDV0DUtD &3XHVHQWRQFHVTXHGDPRVDVt« DQH[R 7UDQVFULSFLyQGHODVHQWUHYLVWDVGHO&HQWUR (175(9,67$$/&(1752 0 %XHQR VL WH SDUHFH SDVDPRV D OD SULPHUD SUHJXQWD ¢&XiO HV OD UHVSXHVWD HVFRODU 05'LUHFWRUDGHO&HQWUR)(&+$GHRFWXEUHGH GHVGHYXHVWURFHQWURDODV1HFHVLGDGHV(GXFDWLYDV(VSHFLDOHV1((\FRQFUHWDPHQWH ODV TXH VH GHULYDQ GH OD GLVFDSDFLGDG PRWUL]" <D VHD GHVGH HO FXUUtFXOXP GHVGH OD RUJDQL]DFLyQLQQRYDFLyQ\GHVDUUROORSURIHVLRQDO 05%XHQRDQWHVPHJXVWDUtDH[SOLFDUXQSRFRODKLVWRULDRODWUD\HFWRULDTXHKDOOHYDGR 5 OD HVFXHOD (O FROHJLR HV HO VpSWLPR DxR TXH HVWi HQ IXQFLRQDPLHQWR D~Q QR VH KDQ DFDEDGRGHGREODUODVGRVOtQHDVTXHWHQHPRVODHVFXHODHVWDUiFRPSOHWDHOFXUVRTXH YLHQH'HVGHHOSULQFLSLRGHVGHODLQDXJXUDFLyQGHODHVFXHODVHKDQDFRJLGRDOXPQRV FRQGLYHUVDVGLVFDSDFLGDGHVVREUHWRGRItVLFDVHKLVWyULFDPHQWHQRVRWURVORDWULEXLPRV DO JUDQ Q~PHUR GH DOXPQRV TXH WHQHPRV HQ FRPSDUDFLyQ D SRGtDPRV GHFLU D ORV FHQWURV GHO 'LVWULWR 3RU XQ ODGR HO KHFKR GH ODV EDUUHUDV $O QR WHQHU EDUUHUDV DUTXLWHFWyQLFDV\SRURWURODGRSXHVHOERFDDERFDSRUTXHQRVKDQOOHJDGRDOXPQRVGH IXHUDGHO'LVWULWR¢QR"KDVWDTXHGHDOJXQDPDQHUDVHSLGLySRUIDYRUDO($3>(TXLSRGH $VHVRUDPLHQWR 3VLFRSHGDJyJLFR@ \ D ,QVSHFFLyQ \ D 'HOHJDFLyQ >GHO 'HSDUWDPHQWR GH (GXFDFLyQ GH OD *HQHUDOLWDW GH &DWDOXQ\D@ SXHV QR DFRJHU PiV DOXPQRV FRQ GLVFDSDFLGDGHVSRUTXHQRGiEDPRVDEDVWR (QWRQFHVGHDOJXQDPDQHUDHOWHPDGH OD(GXFDFLyQ(VSHFLDO((RGHORVDOXPQRV FRQ1((KD\LQIOXLGRHQORTXHHVODRUJDQL]DFLyQGHOFHQWURSLHQVRTXHKHPRVWHQLGROD VXHUWHSXHVGHWHQHUXQEXHQDVHVRUDPLHQWRSRUSDUWHGHOSVLFRSHGDJRJRGHO($3GHOD ]RQDWDPELpQKDFRLQFLGRTXHOD-HIDGH(VWXGLRVHVXQDGHODVSHUVRQDVTXHOOHYDOD ((GHOFHQWURHVRWDPELpQKDLQIOXLGRDQLYHOGHRUJDQL]DFLyQ\GHVSXpVSXHVTXHGH DOJXQD PDQHUD HO SURIHVRUDGR JOREDOPHQWH SXHV KD DFRJLGR D HVWRV QLxRV FRQ SUiFWLFDPHQWHWRWDOQRUPDOLGDGSULPHUR FRQ DQJXVWLD KDVWDTXHSXHVWLHQHVDODVHVRU TXH WH H[SOLFD SXHV HO DOXPQR FDGD DxR VH KDFH XQ FODXVWUR H[FOXVLYDPHQWH SDUD H[SOLFDU D WRGR HO SURIHVRUDGR VREUHWRGR DO SURIHVRUDGR QXHYR TXH FDGD DxR VH LQFRUSRUDHVWDPRVHQWUHHO\DKRUDHOGHODSODQWLOODQXHYDFDGDDxRSXHV 5 VHKDFHQXQDVVHVLRQHVHVSHFLDOHVSDUDH[SOLFDUODVFDUDFWHUtVWLFDVGHFDGDXQRGHORV DOXPQRV HVWR VH KDFH FRQ HO SURIHVRUDGR FRQ ORV PRQLWRUHV GH FRPHGRU \ FRQ ORV PRQLWRUHV GH H[WUDHVFRODUHV HK D SDUWH SXHV GH DOJXQDV UHXQLRQHV FRQ HO $03$ >$VRFLDFLyQGH0DGUHV\3DGUHV@FRQODMXQWDGHO$03$SDUDH[SOLFLWDUSXHVFDGDXQR GH ORV QLxRV TXp GLILFXOWDGHV WLHQH R TXp QHFHVLGDGHV WLHQH \ GH TXp PDQHUD SXHV OD HVFXHODSXHGHD\XGDU 0¢<TXLpQGDHVDLQIRUPDFLyQ" 05-HOSVLFRSHGDJRJRGHO($3(VXQSRFRHOTXHKDHODERUDGRORVGLFWiPHQHV\HO 5 TXHKDFHHOVHJXLPLHQWR\DVHVRUDVREUHORVDOXPQRV(QWRQFHVKDFHXQSDUGHFXUVRV FUHDPRV XQD FRPLVLyQ GH $WHQFLyQ D OD 'LYHUVLGDG TXH HVWiQ SXHV UHSUHVHQWDGRV ORV GLIHUHQWHVFLFORVHGXFDWLYRV(VWDVUHXQLRQHVDOJXQDYH]VHKDQKHFKRFRQHO$03$GH OD HVFXHOD VREUHWRGR GH FDUD D RUJDQL]DU DFWLYLGDGHV GRQGH SDUWLFLSDUDQ WRGRV ORV DOXPQRVH[WUDHVFRODUHVHWFHWF\DSDUWLUGHDKtKD\XQGRFXPHQWRHODERUDGRTXHHV HVWHTXHVLTXLHUHVOXHJRWHOOHYDVXQFRSLDSHURTXHD~QQRHVWiDSUREDGRWRWDOPHQWH SRUHOFODXVWURSRUTXHDKRUDMXVWRKDEtDPRVTXHGDGRHVWHPHVSDUDKDFHUEXHQRXQD UHXQLyQ GH (( \ \D OOHYDUOR GLUHFWDPHQWH DO FODXVWUR D YHU TXH HV XQ SRFR FRPR VH WUDEDMDODGLYHUVLGDGHQODHVFXHODSRUTXHHVFULWRHVFULWRHVWRHQVHLVFXUVRV\FXDWUR SXHVTXHOOHYDPRVQRVRWUDVDTXtSXHVFDGDDxRVHYDKDFLHQGRDOJXQDFRVLOOD¢QR"\ HVWH VHUtD XQ SRFR HO GRFXPHQWR EDVH GH OR TXH HV WRGR HO WHPD GH OD GLYHUVLGDG \ HVSHFtILFDPHQWH SXHV GH ODV 1(( ¢QR" GHVGH HO SODQ GH DFRJLGD GHO DOXPQR FXDQGR OOHJDGHFXDOTXLHUDOXPQRSXHVKDVWDFyPRVHRUJDQL]DSXHVRTXpHQWHQGHPRVSRU ((¢QR"(VWRWDPELpQLPSOLFDUiXQDUHYLVLyQGHOSULPHU3UR\HFWRHGXFDWLYRTXHVHKL]R HQ OD HVFXHOD SRUTXH VH KL]R HO SULPHU DxR TXH VH LQDXJXUy SUiFWLFDPHQWH HQWRQFHV FODUR KDEtD VHLV SURIHVRUHV TXH \D QLQJXQR GH HOORV HVWi HQ HO FHQWUR \ HO SUR\HFWR HGXFDWLYRGHFHQWURSXHVHVWiHQUHYLVLyQ\DGHPiVKD\TXHLQFRUSRUDUWRGDXQDVHULH GH FRVDV ¢QR" SRUTXH OD UHDOLGDG OD OOHYD ¢QR" 2 VHD OD UHDOLGDG QRV KD OOHYDGR D HQFRQWUDUQRVFRQHVWHWLSRGHDOXPQDGR (QWRQFHVUHVSXHVWDVGHVGHHOFXUUtFXOXPWDPELpQYDPX\UHIHULGRGHSHQGHGHODOXPQR \D VDEHV ¢QR" GHSHQGH GHO iUHD VL QHFHVLWD XQD DGDSWDFLyQ HO FXUVR SDVDGR PH SDUHFHTXHWHQtDPRVVHLVDOXPQRVFRQDGDSWDFLRQHVFXUULFXODUHVLQGLYLGXDOHV$&,\D VHDQGH(GXFDFLyQ)tVLFD()RGHWRGDVODViUHDVRGHXQiUHDHVSHFtILFD¢QR"\HVD 5 VHUtD XQD GH ODV D\XGDV RUJDQL]DWLYDV HO $&, 'HVSXpV SXHV EXHQR ORV GLIHUHQWHV DJUXSDPLHQWRVHQJUXSRVIOH[LEOHVHVRHVXQSRFRORTXHKDFHPRVWRGDVODVHVFXHODV VREUHWRGRHQODViUHDVLQVWUXPHQWDOHVORVGHVGREODPLHQWRVORVSHTXHxRVJUXSRV\OR TXHVRQVRSRUWHHVSHFtILFRGH((¢QR"GHSHQGLHQGRGHODVGLILFXOWDGHVTXHWHQJDQORV RODVQHFHVLGDGHVTXHWHQJDQORVDOXPQRV 00HKDOODPDGRODDWHQFLyQTXHWHQpLVSODQGHDFRJLGD¢QR" 5 05$YHUVtORTXHIDOWDHVH[SOLFLWDUORGHDOJXQDPDQHUDHOGRFXPHQWR\DORUHFRJH WDQWRVHUtDSXHVHOWLSRGHDOXPQDGRTXHOOHJDPiV~OWLPDPHQWHDOXPQDGRTXHSURYLHQH GHIXHUDVREUHWRGRVXGDPHULFDQR\SRURWURODGRSXHVRVHDHOSODQGHDFRJLGDJOREDO GHOFHQWURTXpSDVDGHVGHHOSULPHUGtDTXHXQRVSDGUHVSLGHQLQIRUPDFLyQSDUDEXHQR SXHVSDUDPDWULFXODUDVXKLMRHQODHVFXHODRVHDWRGRHVWRHV\DORGHFDGDDxR¢QR" TXHWLHQHVRUJDQL]DGRSDUDORVDOXPQRVGH3ODVSXHUWDVDELHUWDVHWFHWF\GHVSXpV \DFRPRPiVHVSHFtILFDPHQWHFXDQGRKD\DOJ~QDOXPQRSXHVTXHGHDOJXQDPDQHUD YDDQHFHVLWDUPiVDFRPSDxDPLHQWRHQVXHQWUDGD¢QR"\VREUHWRGRSXHV\DGHSHQGH GHO DOXPQR TXp 1(( WHQJD SXHV WDPELpQ ¢QR" RWUR WLSR GH VHJXLPLHQWR HV XQD FRVD TXHYDPRVKDFLHQGRSRGUtDPRVGHFLUPHFiQLFDPHQWH\PHMRUDQGRFDGDDxRSHURTXH IDOWDH[SOLFLWDUOR\TXHEXHQRTXHWRGRHOPXQGRTXHHVWpWUDEDMDQGRHQHOFHQWURSXHV VHSDORTXHKD\TXHKDFHURGHTXpPDQHUDIDYRUHFHUHVWDDFRJLGD 0 0PPP PX\ ELHQ 6L WH SDUHFH HQWRQFHV \D SDVDPRV D OD VHJXQGD SUHJXQWD 5 ¢&XiOHV FUHHV TXH VRQ ODV GLILFXOWDGHV GH OD LQFOXVLyQ GHO DOXPQDGR FRQ GLVFDSDFLGDG PRWUL]HQODVVHVLRQHVGH()"6LFUHHVTXHKD\GLILFXOWDGHVHQODLQFOXVLyQRQR 05 $ YHU HVWD HV XQD SUHJXQWD TXH VXSRQJR TXH WH FRQWHVWDUi PXFKR PHMRU ODV SURIHVRUDVGH() 06tSHUREXHQRTXpLQIRUPDFLyQWHKDOOHJDGR 05¢'HVGHIXHUD"3LHQVRTXHDYHUTXHGLILFXOWDGHVKD\\PXFKDVHK\HVWRDOJXQDV 5 YHFHV OR KHPRV KDEODGR 1R ~QLFDPHQWH UHODFLRQDGDV FRQ OD () \ VLQy WDPELpQ FRQ DFWLYLGDGHV GH DOJXQD PDQHUD HVSHFLDOHV ¢QR" FRPR SXHGHQ VHU ODV VDOLGDV ODV H[FXUVLRQHV HWF HWF \D WH H[SOLFR SRU TXp %XHQR QRVRWURV WHQHPRV XQ UHFXUVR KXPDQRTXHHVODDX[LOLDUGH(GXFDFLyQ(VSHFLDO((2IHOLD $QWHV HUDQ HGXFDGRUHV SHUR EXHQR DKRUD VRQ FXLGDGRUDV 7HQHPRV XQD SHUVRQD D MRUQDGDFRPSOHWDPiVGLH]KRUDVGHRWUDPRQLWRUDSDUDWHQHUSXHVEXHQRSDUDDSR\DU D WRGRV HVWRV DOXPQRV \ DO SURIHVRUDGR HQ OR TXH HV GHVSOD]DPLHQWRV HQ OR TXH HV ODYDERVFRPHGRU\DOJXQDVDFWLYLGDGHVHQWUHHOODV()SDWLRVVDOLGDVEXHQRSDUDODV VDOLGDVVLHPSUHWHQHPRVODFRODERUDFLyQGHODDVRFLDFLyQGHSHUVRQDVFRQGLVFDSDFLGDG PRWUL] 9DOH HQWRQFHVSDUDODVVDOLGDVH[FXUVLRQHVFRORQLDVWHQHPRVODFRODERUDFLyQGHORV PRQLWRUHVGHODDVRFLDFLyQTXHVRQYROXQWDULRV\TXHVRQYROXQWDULRVSDUDDOXPQRVFRQ GLVFDSDFLGDGHVPRWULFHV<DKRUDSRUTXpWHH[SOLFDED\RWRGRHVWREXHQRSRUORGH ODVGLILFXOWDGHV¢QR" 3RUXQODGRSXHVEXHQRKD\XQVRSRUWHKXPDQRHVEXHQRHQ()FXDQGRHOSURIHVRUDGR DYHFHVFRPR\DHVSHUVRQDOTXHKDFHXQSDUGHDxRVRWUHVRFXDWURTXHHVWiHQHO FHQWUR\DFRQRFHDODOXPQR\\DVDEHODVSRVLELOLGDGHVTXHWLHQH\\DWLHQHSXHVVXV SURJUDPDFLRQHVDGDSWDGDVRODPDQHUDGHDGDSWDUODVDFWLYLGDGHVSXHVDYHFHVSLGHQ ODFRODERUDFLyQGHODSHUVRQDGHDSR\RRDYHFHVQR /R TXH Vt TXH QRV HVWiEDPRV SODQWHDQGR \ D YHFHV HVWR HV XQD GH ODV GXGDV TXH 5 WHQHPRV\DKRUDPLVPRORKDEODEDFRQODVHFUHWDULDGHOFHQWUR>XQDGHODVPDHVWUDVGH ()@¢QR"HVGHTXHDYHFHVSXHVTXHFXDQGRHODOXPQRVHYDKDFLHQGRPD\RUORTXH HV (GXFDFLyQ LQIDQWLO FLFOR LQLFLDO FXDQGR HO DOXPQR HV SHTXHxR OD PD\RUtD GH DFWLYLGDGHVTXHVHKDFHQVHSXHGHQDGDSWDUDPHGLGDTXHHODOXPQRVHYDKDFLHQGR PD\RU HV PiV GLItFLO (QWRQFHV DTXt HO SODQWHDPLHQWR R OD GXGD ¢QR" TXH HOODV PH GHFtDQ³KD\DOJ~QWLSRGHDFWLYLGDGTXHQRODKDFHPRVSRUTXHVLQyHVWHDOXPQRQROD SRGUtDKDFHUQLDGDSWiQGROD¢QR"SRUTXHHVXQWLSRGHDFWLYLGDGPiV«RDORPHMRUHV TXHQRVDEHPRV´ 0<D 05<HVWR\D« 03RUODVFDUDFWHUtVWLFDVLQWUtQVHFDVGHODSURSLDDFWLYLGDG 5 05<HQWRQFHVGHFtD³FODURDYHFHVGHMDVGHKDFHUFRVDVTXHSRGtDVKDFHUODVFRQORV GHPiVDOXPQRVSXHVSDUDTXHHORWURDOXPQRQRGHMHGHSDUWLFLSDUSRUTXHHQFLPDVL KD\SUREOHPDGHLQWHJUDFLyQHQORVJUXSRV«´ORVQLxRVHQSULQFLSLRSXHVQRKD\QLQJXQR ¢QR"<HVWDHVXQDGHODVGXGDV\HVWRWDPELpQQRVKDSDVDGRSRUHVRWHGHFtDORGH ODVVDOLGDVFRQDOJXQDVVDOLGDV&RQDOJXQDVDOLGDTXHTXLHUHVKDFHUSXHVTXHYHVTXH HQ DOJXQR GH ORV PRPHQWRV SXHV KD\ XQD EDUUHUD DUTXLWHFWyQLFD HVD VDOLGD \D QR VH SXHGHKDFHU 0<D 053RUTXHVLQyHVHDOXPQR«SHURHQWRQFHVFODURHVSRUXQR<HVWRHVDYHFHV 5 XQD GH ODV FRVDV ILORVyILFDV TXH « GH GXGDV TXH KHPRV WHQLGR ¢QR" 3RUTXH KDVWD DKRUD Vt TXH KD LGR WRGR JLUDQGR HQ IXQFLyQ GH IDFLOLWDU DO Pi[LPR OD SDUWLFLSDFLyQ GH WRGRGHWRGRHODOXPQDGR\DSDUWHGHHVWRSXHVFDGD«VLWLHQHVGRVSHUVRQDVHQHO JLPQDVLRRHQHOSDWLRFRPRSXHGHVHUODHGXFDGRUDRODDX[LOLDU\ODSURIHVRUDGH() SXHV WRGR OR TXH SXHGD FRODERUDU SXHGHQ KDEHU GRV SHUVRQDV HYLGHQWHPHQWH TXH HV PXFKRPHMRUHQWRQFHVHVTXHDYHFHVKD\RYHUEXFNLQJ\QRFRLQFLGHQKRUDULRV¢QR" SHUREXHQRKD\DOXPQRVSXHVTXHVDFDUORVGHODVLOODGHUXHGDVSURSRQHUXQDDFWLYLGDG GH FROFKRQHWD GH URGDMH \ WDO QHFHVLWDV RWUR VRSRUWH SDUD SRGHU KDFHUOR SRUTXH VLQy WLHQHV D ORVRWURVDOXPQRVTXHWDPSRFR HV HO HVSDFLR GHO JLPQDVLR QRHVTXHVHD XQDPDUDYLOOD¢QR"7DPELpQXQSRFRYHUORVFRQGLFLRQDPLHQWRVGHORVPDWHULDOHV\GH ORV HVSDFLRV GHO FHQWUR 'H WRGDV PDQHUDV D YHU YLVWR DVt FRPR GHVGH IXHUD ¢QR" SRUTXH\RQRHVWR\GHQWUR« 0&ODUR 05«GHODXODGH()HORODVSURIHVRUDVTXHKD\DKRUDRODVTXHHQDOJ~QRWURDxR KDQ SRGLGR KDFHU D YHU QR QXQFD QL ORV WXWRUHV GHO DXOD ¢QR" VH KDQ PDQLIHVWDGR EXHQR QLQJXQD SUREOHPiWLFD SDUD QR DGDSWDU OD DFWLYLGDG TXH VH KLFLHUD 6t TXH SURYRFD HQ GHWHUPLQDGRV DOXPQRV SXHGH SURYRFDU DQJXVWLD FXDQGR QR WLHQHV FODUR FyPRRUJDQL]DUHODXODHQIXQFLyQGHODOXPQRFyPRRUJDQL]DUODVPDWHULDV\HQWRQFHV EXHQRSRUHVWRWRGRHVWHJUXSRGHVGHHODVHVRUGHO($3SXHVKDVWDHOSURSLRFLFORHQ ORTXHHVODRUJDQL]DFLyQGHOFHQWUR\ORVVRSRUWHVTXHSRGDPRVWHQHUGHHGXFDGRUD\ GH (( \ GHVGREODPLHQWR GH JUXSRV SXHV VH LQWHQWDUi DFRPSDxDU DO SURIHVRUDGR ¢QR" VREUHWRGRGLJRTXHFRPRFDGDDxRKHPRVFDPELDGR« 0<D 05%DVWDQWHGHOSURIHVRUDGR« 0<D 05 «FXDQGRHOSURIHVRUDGR\DFRQRFH ODVFDUDFWHUtVWLFDVSXHVHYLGHQWHPHQWH\DQR KD\WDQWRSUREOHPDHQWRQFHVKD\PiVPHMRUDFXDQGRHOSURIHVRUDGRHVQXHYR\EXHQR SXHVOHGLFHVHVXQQLxRFRQSDUiOLVLVFHUHEUDOWHWUDSOpJLFRHQHODXODSXHVGHHQWUDGD DKtQRVIDOWDIRUPDFLyQ¢QR"SRUTXHDRPHMRUHVXQDIRUPDFLyQTXHVHKDGDGRHQ((\ 5 DORPHMRUSXHVWDPELpQORKDVGDGRFXDQGRKDFtDVODFDUUHUDKDFHDxRV\QRHVXQ IRUPDFLyQDFWXDOL]DGD¢QR" 0<D 052VHDHQHVWRSLHQVRTXHQR«HVTXHDGHPiVEXHQRTXH\RVHSDHVTXHQRKD\ QDGD ¢QR" D QR VHU TXH KDJDV XQ SRVWJUDGR GH (( \ VH WUDEDMHQ ODV QHFHVLGDGHV HGXFDWLYDVODVGLVFDSDFLGDGHVPRWULFHV\WDO¢QR"SHURFRPRWXWRUQRWLHQHV¢QR"PLOHV UHFXUVRV GH LQIRUPiWLFD \ HVWH DxR SRU HMHPSOR KHPRV GHFLGLGR LU D ORV VHPLQDULRV GH ((SRUTXHWDPELpQYDQPX\KR\HPSLH]DXQRLUiOD-HIDGH(VWXGLRVEXHQRSRUTXH HVSURIHVRUDGH((SHURWDPELpQWRGRPX\DOHQWRUQRGHODVWHFQRORJtDV¢QR" 0<D 05'HODLQIRUPDFLyQ\ODFRPXQLFDFLyQTXHHVRHVRWUD<RHVTXHPHHQUROORPXFKR HK" 01RQRTXHYDTXHYDTXHHVWiPX\ELHQHVPX\LQWHUHVDQWHWRGRORTXHGLFHV 051REXHQRVXSRQJRTXH« 0<YDVGDQGRPXFKDSLQFHODGDV« 05GHXQODGRDRWURSRUTXH« 0YDVGDQGRPXFKDVSLQFHODGDV\VHQRWDTXHY