el\jkifZc`dX el\jkiX[\Z`j`e nnn%]f\`%fi^ ¶hl\j\cZXdY`fZc`d}k`Zf6 µ>WidejWZegk[[bYb_cW[ij|YWcX_WdZe5µ9ce[ijej[W\[YjW57bebWh]eZ[bW^_ijeh_W" beifk[XbeiZ[jeZe[bckdZe^Wd[d\h[djWZebei_cfWYjeiZ[[l[djeic[j[eheb]_Yei [njh[ceiYece^khWYWd[i"i[gkWi"jehc[djWioj[cf[hWjkhWickoXW`WieWbjWi$7b]kdW][dj[" [d[if[Y_WbbWiYeckd_ZWZ[ic|ifeXh[iZ[Z_\[h[dj[ifWhj[iZ[bckdZe"^Wdik\h_ZeckY^e W YWkiW Z[ [ijei [l[djei$ Bei [l[djei c[j[eheb]_Yei [njh[cei eYWi_edWd _dkdZWY_ed[i" WbkZ[ioi[gkWi"WZ[c|iZ[[iYWi[pZ[Wb_c[djei"Z[ijhkYY_dZ[^e]Wh[ioYkbj_leiobk]Wh[i Z[jhWXW`e"Wkc[djeZ[[d\[hc[ZWZ[iofhZ_ZWZ[l_ZWi$ Bei [l[djei c[j[eheb]_Yei [njh[cei ied fWhj[ Z[ bei Y_Ybei Z[ bW dWjkhWb[pW #bei YWcX_ei dWjkhWb[i Z[b Yb_cW [d bWJ_[hhW# o [i feYe be gk[ feZ[cei ^WY[h fWhW [l_jWhbei" WfWhj[ Z[ eh]Wd_pWh dk[ijhWi ieY_[ZWZ[i fWhW fhej[][h W bW ][dj[ c|i lkbd[hWXb[$ F[he bei [ijkZ_ei Y_[djÓYei Z[ck[ijhWd W^ehW gk[ bWi WYj_l_ZWZ[i ^kcWdWi [d jeZe [b ckdZe [ij|d Wkc[djWdZe [nfed[dY_Wbc[dj[ bWi fheXWX_b_ZWZ[i Z[ gk[ [ijei [l[djei c[j[eheb]_Yei [njh[ceieYkhhWdWdYedc|i\h[Yk[dY_WocWoeh_dj[di_ZWZ$ BW cWoehW Z[ bei Y_[djÓYei gk[ [ijkZ_Wd [b Yb_cW Z[ bW J_[hhW WÓhcWd gk[ [b Yb_cW [ij| YWcX_WdZe Z[Ód_j_lWc[dj[ W^ehW" o gk[ [ij[ YWcX_e [i ikcWc[dj[ f[b_]heie o gk[ [i fheleYWZefehWYj_l_ZWZ[i^kcWdWi$ ( YWi_bWc_jWZZ[ bW[d[h]WiebWh[i WXiehX_ZWfehbW ikf[hÓY_[Z[bWJ_[hhW obWYWb_[djW [d[h]W iebWh ) * bWJ_[hhWobWWjci\[hW h[Ô[`WdkdWfWhj[Z[bW [d[h]WiebWhZ[lk[bjW Wb[ifWY_e i_d[cXWh]e"fWhj[Z[bW [d[h]Wh[Ô[`WZWgk[ZW WjhWfWZW[dbWWjci\[hW fehbei]Wi[iZ[[\[Yje _dl[hdWZ[he$;ie^WY[gk[ bWikf[hÓY_[Z[bWJ_[hhWobW Wjci\[hWXW`Wi[h[YWb_[dj[d Xkdj]\iX hWZ_WY_d _d\hWhhe`W k`\iiX el\jkifZc`dX$el\jkiX[\Z`j`e ¶Zdfj\^\e\iX\cZXdY`fZc`d}k`Zf6 <cZXdY`fZc`d}k`Zf[\fi`^\e_ldXef\jfZXj`feX[fgfihl\_XpdlZ_fj^Xj\jZfefZ`[fjZfdf ^Xj\j[\\]\Zkf`em\ieX[\ifhl\_Xehl\[X[fXkiXgX[fj\ecXXkdj]\iX[\el\jkifgcXe\kX% <jfj^Xj\ji\k`\e\e\cZXcfi[\cjfc#p\jf_XZ\hl\cXk\dg\iXkliX^\e\iXc[\cXXkdj]\iX j\`eZi\d\ek\`ek\iÔi`\e[fZfecfjgXkife\jd\k\fifc^`ZfjeXkliXc\j[\cXK`\iiX% Bei ]Wi[i Z[ [\[Yje _dl[hdWZ[he ied ][d[hWZei feh ckY^Wi Z[ bWi WYj_l_ZWZ[i gk[ \ehcWd fWhj[Z[bceZe[dgk[bW][dj[l_l[[dbWiieY_[ZWZ[i_dZkijh_Wb[i"jWb[iYece0 BWgk[cWZ[YecXkij_Xb[iYece[bYWhXdo[b]WifWhWbei^e]Wh[i"^eif_jWb[i"\|Xh_YWio [iYk[bWi$ BWgk[cWZ[]Wieb_dWfWhW[b\kdY_edWc_[djeZ[Wkjei"WkjeXki[i"Wl_ed[iocWgk_dWh_Wi kj_b_pWZWi[dbWW]h_YkbjkhW$ ;bYkbj_leZ[Wb_c[djei[d]hWdZ[ibWj_\kdZ_eiofbWdjWY_ed[icko[nj[diWigk[kj_b_pWd \[hj_b_pWdj[igkc_Yeioi[[dYk[djhWdb[`eiZ[ZedZ[i[Yedikc[dbeiWb_c[djei$ BWjWbWZ[ijhkYj_lWZ[beiXeigk[igk[dWjkhWbc[dj[WokZWdW[l_jWh[bYWcX_eYb_c|j_Ye fWhWfheZkY_hcWZ[hWefWhW[ijWXb[Y[hfbWdjWY_ed[iZ[Ykbj_leiYecebeigk[i[kj_b_pWd fWhWbWfheZkYY_dZ[W]heYecXkij_Xb[i$ 9edikc_hX_[d[ifheZkY_Zeickob[`eiZ[beifWi[iZedZ[i[Yedikc[d$ ;dfeYWifWbWXhWi"[bYWcX_eYb_c|j_Ye[ifheleYWZefehkdj_feZ[ÉceZ[beZ[Z[iWhhebbeÊ#kd ceZeZ[eh]Wd_pWhdk[ijhWiieY_[ZWZ[igk[Z[f[dZ[ckY^eZ[YecXkij_Xb[iYedjWc_dWdj[i Yece[bYWhXd"[bf[jhb[eo[b]Wiogk[Z[ijhko[[bc[Z_eWcX_[dj[dWjkhWb$ >Wo]hWdZ[iZ_\[h[dY_Wi[dbWYkejWZ[h[ifediWX_b_ZWZgk[deiYehh[ifedZ[feh][d[hWh[b YWcX_e Yb_c|j_Ye" jWdje [djh[ Z_ij_djei fWi[i Yece [djh[ Z_ij_djei ]hkfei ieY_Wb[i Yece h_Yei o feXh[i$ Bei fWi[i h_Yei _dZkijh_Wb_pWZei Yece ;ijWZei Kd_Zei" ;khefW o @Wfd ied h[ifediWXb[iZ[^WX[h[c_j_Zejh[iYkWhjWifWhj[iZ[bjejWbZ[]Wi[iZ[[\[Yje_dl[hdWZ[he gk[i[[dYk[djhWd[dbWWjci\[hW"Wkdgk[deiedc|igk[[b'+Z[bWfeXbWY_dckdZ_Wb$ BeifWi[ic|ifeXh[i"jWb[iYecebeiW\h_YWdei"^Wd`k]WZekdfWf[bckY^ec[deh[d][d[hWh [bfheXb[cWZ[bYWcX_eYb_c|j_Ye$BW_Z[Wi[]dbWYkWbgk_[d[iYWh]WdYedcWoehYkejWZ[ h[ifediWX_b_ZWZ feh ^WX[h fheleYWZe [b YWcX_e Yb_c|j_Ye Z[X[d [cfh[dZ[h bWi cWoeh[i WYY_ed[ifWhWh[iebl[h[bfheXb[cW[iYedeY_ZWYeceÉ`kij_Y_WYb_c|j_YWÊ$ Ki_dWj[hce[bYjh_YWZ[ IWieb[dIkZ|\h_YW ]hekdZmeha `dgXZkfj\ecX^\ek\#cXjZfdle`[X[\j pjljd\[`fj[\m`[X ;bYWcX_eYb_c|j_Ye[ij|Wkc[djWdZebW_dY_Z[dY_WZ[[l[djeic[j[eheb]_Yei[njh[ceiooW j_[d[kd[dehc[_cfWYje[dbW][dj[obWiYeckd_ZWZ[i[djeZe[bckdZe$;bYWcX_eYb_c|j_Ye oW[ibWYWkiWZ_h[YjWZ[)&&$&&&ck[hj[iYWZWWe"oZ[`WWY_[djeiZ[c_bbed[iZ[f[hiedWi W\[YjWZWi ]hWl[c[dj[ feh fheXb[cWi Yece i[gkWi" [iYWi[p Z[ Wb_c[djei [ _dkdZWY_ed[i$ I_d[cXWh]e"[ickofheXWXb[gk[bWi_jkWY_di[W]hWl[XWijWdj[i_dk[ijhei]eX_[hdeide WZefjWdc[Z_ZWikh][dj[iW^ehWc_ice$ JWcX_di[^WZ[ceijhWZegk[[bYWcX_eYb_c|j_YeW\[YjWh|Wbeifk[XbeiZ[ceZeZ_ij_dje[d Z_\[h[dj[ifWhj[iZ[bckdZe$IWX[ceigk[bWiYeckd_ZWZ[igk[l_l[d[dfWi[ic|ifeXh[i" [dbk]Wh[i_di[]kheiYecebbWdkhWi_dkdZWXb[iepedWiYeij[hWi"e[dcWbWiYedZ_Y_ed[iZ[ l_l_[dZW"feZhWd[d\h[djWh_cfWYjeickY^ef[eh[igk[bW][dj[gk[l_l[[dfWi[iebk]Wh[i c|ih_Yei$ I_ de i[ WZefjWd c[Z_ZWi kh][dj[i" jWcX_d [i fei_Xb[ gk[ [b Yb_cW YWcX_[ Z[ cWd[hW _hh[l[hi_Xb[oYWjWijhÓYW#kdWfei_X_b_ZWZYWbWc_jeiWZ[dec_dWZWÉYWcX_eYb_c|j_YeZ[lWijWZehÊ$ Ck`[h[ibWlWdZehefW[dW]kWi Z[_dkdZWY_d[dkdYWcfWc[dje Z[Z[ifbWpWZei_dj[hdei[d7hWh[" IecWb_W WdeeY^[h:[]^Wj_%?H?D }]i`ZXp\cZXdY`fZc`d}k`Zf Ü\h_YWik\h_h|kdWYkejWcWoehZ[bei_cfWYjeiZ[bYWcX_eYb_c|j_Ye"fehYedjhWij[YedejhWi h[]_ed[iZ[bckdZe$;d\h[djWh|i[gkWi"[iYWi[pZ[ Wb_c[djei[_dkdZWY_ed[ic|ii[l[hWi i_ de [l_jWcei [b YWcX_e Yb_c|j_Ye Z[lWijWZeh$ Bei Y_[djÓYei WÓhcWd gk[" Z[ de Wfb_YWhi[ c[Z_ZWiZh|ij_YWi"[bYWcX_eYb_c|j_YefeZhWi_]d_ÓYWh0 BWfhZ_ZWZ[bWc_jWZZ[bWYei[Y^WZ[beiYkbj_leiZ[Ü\h_YWfWhW(&(&$ :[Y[dWiZ[c_b[iZ[f[hiedWii[l[h|dZ[ifbWpWZWiZ[iki^e]Wh[i[djeZe[bYedj_d[dj[o i[Yedl[hj_h|d[dh[\k]_WZeiYb_c|j_Yei$ FheXb[cWiZ[WYY[ieWbW]kWfWhW(+&c_bbed[iZ[f[hiedWic|i[dÜ\h_YW^WY_W[b(&(&"o fWhW,&&c_bbed[iZ[f[hiedWic|i^WY_W[b(&+&$ \j`e[`jg\ejXYc\hl\cfj^fY`\iefj \dgi\e[XeXZZ`fe\j Bei ]eX_[hdei Z[ jeZe [b ckdZe oW ^Wd WZc_j_Ze gk[ [b YWcX_e Yb_c|j_Ye [i kd ]hWd f[b_]heogk[Z[X[d^WY[hWb]eWbh[if[Yje$;d'//("bei]eX_[hdeiZ[bckdZei[h[kd_[hed o ÓhcWhed bW 9edl[dY_d CWhYe Z[ bWi DWY_ed[i Kd_ZWi ieXh[ [b 9WcX_e 9b_c|j_Ye$ ;ij[ WYk[hZe_dj[hdWY_edWbh[YedeY[gk[[bYWcX_eYb_c|j_Ye[ikdW]hWdWc[dWpWfWhWbW][dj[$ JWcX_dh[YedeY[gk[beifWi[ih_Yei"ieXh[gk_[d[ih[YW[bWcWoehYkejWZ[h[ifediWX_b_ZWZ feh^WX[h][d[hWZe[bfheXb[cWc[Z_Wdj[ikYedikce[nY[i_leZ[beih[YkhieiZ[bckdZe" Z[X[hWdWikc_h[bb_Z[hWp]efWhWiebkY_edWhbe"ofhel[[hÓdWdY_Wc_[djeWbeifWi[ifeXh[i Yece\ehcWZ[fW]eZ[begk[Wc[dkZebbWcWceiikÇZ[kZWYb_c|j_YWÈ$ CX[\l[XZc`d}k`ZX\jcX[\l[Xhl\X[\l[XecfjgXj\ji`Zfj\em`ikl[[\jl^iXeZlfkX[\i\jgfejXY`c`[X[ \e_XY\i^\e\iX[f\cgifYc\dX[\cZXdY`fZc`d}k`Zf#hl\\jlegifYc\dXhl\X]\ZkXd}jhl\XeX[`\X cfjgXj\jpZfdle`[X[\jd}jgfYi\j% FeXbWZeh[i_dZ][dWicWhY^WdZe[d cWd_\[ijWY_dYWcf[i_dW I^[_bWC[ded \c]iXZXjf[\cfj^fY`\iefj 7kdgk[ [ij[ WYk[hZe fWhW Z[j[d[h [b YWcX_e Yb_c|j_Ye i[ be]h ^WY[ c|i Z[ (& Wei" bei ]eX_[hdei^Wd^[Y^eckofeYeZ[iZ[[djedY[ifWhW[d\h[djWh[bfheXb[cWo[l_jWhgk[i[ W]hWl[$Oi[dei[ij|WYWXWdZe[bj_[cfe$Bei[ijkZ_eiY_[djÓYei_dZ_YWdgk[i_deWZefjWcei c[Z_ZWikh][dj[i[dbeifhn_ceiWei"Z[ifkii[h|ckojWhZ[oi[^WXh|bb[]WZeWfkdjei Z[_dÔ[n_df[b_]heieioi_dh[jehde$ Bec|i]hWl[[igk[bei]eX_[hdeiWfWh[dj[c[dj[[ij|d[cf[pWdZeWh[l[hj_h[bfeYeWlWdY[ gk[i[^WXWbe]hWZe$;dbWid[]eY_WY_ed[iieXh[[bYb_cWWY[b[XhWhi[[dZ_Y_[cXh[Z[(&'' [d:khXWd" IkZ|\h_YW [d eYWi_d Z[ bW '-° h[kd_d WdkWb Z[bei]eX_[hdeiieXh[[bYWcX_e Yb_c|j_YebbWcWZW9EF'-"Wb]kdeifWi[ifeZ[heieiYece;ijWZeiKd_Zei"7kijhWb_W"@Wfd oZ[;khefWgk_[h[d0 :_iebl[h[bWYk[hZegk[[ijWXb[Y[gk[beifWi[ic|ih_YeiZ[X[di[hgk_[d[ic|i^W]Wd fWhW[d\h[djWh[bYWcX_eYb_c|j_YeoWokZ[dWbeifWi[ic|ifeXh[iW[cfh[dZ[hWYY_ed[i fWhWc_d_c_pWhbeifheXb[cWigk[ij[eYWi_edW$ ?djheZkY_h dk[lWi febj_YWi f[b_]heiWi" jWb[i Yece bW [nfWdi_d Z[b Yec[hY_e Z[ YWhXede [bYec[hY_eZ[Z[h[Y^eiWYedjWc_dWhoH;::h[ZkYY_dZ[bWi[c_i_ed[iZ[h_lWZWiZ[ bWZ[\eh[ijWY_doZ[]hWZWY_dZ[beiXeigk[i$;bYec[hY_eZ[YWhXedeWkc[djW[bh_[i]e Z[bWZl[d_c_[djeZ[kdYWcX_eYb_c|j_YeYWjWijhÓYeob[i_edWWbWiYeckd_ZWZ[ioiki c[Z_eiZ[l_ZW$ gfihl]iXZXjXecfj^fY`\iefj1 gf[\i[\cXj\dgi\jXjmjgf[\i[\cfjgl\Ycfj BWhWpdfehbWYkWbbei]eX_[hdei^Wd\hWYWiWZe^WijWW^ehW[dWlWdpWh[dfeiZ[beiYWcX_ei kh][dj[igk[d[Y[i_jWcei"[ifehgk[^WoWb]kdWif[hiedWioeh]Wd_pWY_ed[ickofeZ[heiWigk[ degk_[h[dgk[[ijeiYWcX_eiikY[ZWd$CkY^eiZ[[bbei]WdWdckY^i_ceZ_d[heYedWYj_l_ZWZ[i gk[fheleYWdYWcX_eYb_c|j_Ye"YecebWc_d[hWZ[YWhXdobW[nfbejWY_dZ[f[jhb[eo]Wi1 i_[dZefhef_[jWh_eiZ[]hWdZ[ibWj_\kdZ_eiofbWdjWY_ed[i1_dl_hj_[dZe[dYecfWWiZ[Wl_WY_d1 \WXh_YWdZeWkjei"gkc_YeioWY[heoYecfhWdZeol[dZ_[dZeZ[h[Y^eiZ[YedjWc_dWY_d$ F[he[bbei`kdjeideZ[X[hWdi[hc|ifeZ[heieigk[beic_bbed[iZ[f[hiedWioYeckd_ZWZ[i [d jeZe [b ckdZe gk[ lWd W [d\h[djWh [iYWi[p Z[ Wb_c[djei" \WbjW Z[ l_l_[dZW" feXh[pW" fheXb[cWi fWhW WYY[Z[h W [b[c[djei X|i_Yei gk[ d[Y[i_jWd fWhW ieXh[l_l_h #[ _dYbkie bW ck[hj["i_de[l_jWceigk[[bYWcX_eYb_c|j_Yei[W]hWl[Wdc|i$ ;b cej_le fh_dY_fWb feh [b YkWb bei ]eX_[hdei [ij|d \hWYWiWdZe [d [d\h[djWh [b YWcX_e Yb_c|j_Ye[i[bc_icecej_lefeh[bYkWbde[ij|dfhel[o[dZeikÓY_[dj[i[cfb[ei"^eif_jWb[i o [iYk[bWi0 [ij|d Z[cWi_WZe WXeYWZei W Yk_ZWh bei _dj[h[i[i Z[ kdW f[gk[W YWdj_ZWZ Z[ f[hiedWio[cfh[iWifeZ[heiWi"ode[ij|dbeikÓY_[dj[c[dj[fh[eYkfWZeifehbei_dj[h[i[i Z[bWcWoehWZ[bWfeXbWY_d$ cXjjfclZ`fe\j IebkY_edWh[bfheXb[cWZ[bYWcX_eYb_c|j_Yedei[n_][YWcX_Wh[bi_ij[cW$D[Y[i_jWceikdW ]hWdjhWdi\ehcWY_dZ[bceZe[dgk[l_l[bW][dj[[dbWiieY_[ZWZ[i_dZkijh_Wb_pWZWi"ofhej[][h Wi_c_ice bei ceZei Z[ l_ZW gk[ j_[d[d kd _cfWYje c[deh [d [b c[Z_eWcX_[dj[ dWjkhWb$ I_]d_ÓYWgk[j[d[ceigk[0 <o`^`ic\jXel\jkifj^fY`\iefjhl\i\gi\j\ek\ecfj`ek\i\j\j[\cX^\ek\pcXjZfdle`[X[\j#ode beiZ[bWi]hWdZ[i[cfh[iWioiki]WdWdY_Wi"ogk[[ijWXb[pYWddk[lWidehcWifWhW]WhWdj_pWh gk[Wii[W$ <o`^`ic\jXcfjgXj\j#\dgi\jXjpg\ijfeXjX[`e\iX[Xjgk[][d[hWdckY^WYedjWc_dWY_dgk[ [cfh[dZWdWYY_ed[ifWhWh[ZkY_h[iWYedjWc_dWY_d$ ;\aXi\cZXiYe#\cg\kic\fp\c^Xj\e\cjlYjl\cfo]WhWdj_pWhgk[jeZeiojeZWi[d[bckdZe feZWcei kiWh \k[dj[i Z[ [d[h]W b_cf_W o Éh[delWXb[Ê fWhW dk[ijhWi l_l_[dZWi" jhWdifehj[" [iYk[bWi"^eif_jWb[io\|Xh_YWi$ EfkXcXid}jYfjhl\jofhej[][hbeiZ[h[Y^eiZ[bWiYeckd_ZWZ[igk[l_l[d[d[bbei$ :XdY`Xi \c df[f \e hl\ gif[lZ`dfj p XZZ\[\dfj X cfj Xc`d\ekfj# fWhW gk[ c|i f[hiedWi fk[ZWdfheZkY_hoYedikc_hWb_c[djeiXk[deioWi[gk_Xb[i"Ykbj_lWZeibeYWbc[dj[oZ[cWd[hW jWbgk[i[fhej[`W[bc[Z_eWcX_[dj[dWjkhWb$ =fikXc\Z\icfjj`jk\dXj[\kiXejgfik\gYc`ZfpZfeki`Yl`iXjld`e`jkiXid}j\dgc\fj[`^efjY[hYW Z[ZedZ[l_l[bW][dj["Z[ceZejWbgk[j[d]Wdgk[l_W`Whc[deifWhW_hWjhWXW`Wh$ :l`[Xid\aficfji\ZlijfjeXkliXc\j#[cfeZ[hWdZeWjWb[\[YjeWbWiYeckd_ZWZ[igk[Z[f[dZ[d c|iZ_h[YjWc[dj[Z[[bbei$ >XiXek`qXihl\kf[fjpkf[XjfYk\e^Xdfjcfhl\e\Z\j`kXdfjgXiXm`m`ileXm`[X]\c`qpjXeX# ]WhWdj_pWdZeWbc_icej_[cfegk[deki[ceiZ[cWi_WZeogk[h[kj_b_Y[ceioh[Y_Yb[ceijeZe begk[feZWcei$ ¶Zdfcf\e]i\ekXdfj6 FWhWZ[j[d[h[bYWcX_eYb_c|j_YeZ[lWijWZehoYedijhk_hkdckdZec[`ehZedZ[bW][dj[l_lW X_[doi[]khWoiki_d]h[ieioc[Z_eiZ[l_ZW[ijdiWblW]kWhZWZei"d[Y[i_jWcei0 7YY_ed[i kh][dj[i o Yecfhec_ie Z[ jeZei bei ]eX_[hdei" [d [if[Y_Wb Z[ bei fWi[i h_Yei _dZkijh_Wb_pWZei"fWhWbb[lWhWYWXe[ijei]hWdZ[iYWcX_ei[dbWcWd[hW[dgk[\kdY_edWd dk[ijhWiieY_[ZWZ[ioYcekiWceibeih[YkhieiZ[bWdWjkhWb[pW$ Gk[ bei fWi[i h_Yei fW]k[d ik Z[kZW Yb_c|j_YW o b[i fhel[Wd Z_d[he W bei fWi[i c|i feXh[iZ[Ü\h_YW"7i_Wo7ch_YWBWj_dWfWhWgk[[bbeijWcX_dfk[ZWdbb[lWhWYWXe[ijWi jhWdi\ehcWY_ed[i$ Gk[bei_dj[h[i[iZ[bW][dj["bWiYeckd_ZWZ[iobeijhWXW`WZeh[iojhWXW`WZehWieYkf[dkd bk]WhY[djhWb[dbWjecWZ[Z[Y_i_ed[iieXh[Ycei[fheY[iW[ijWjhWdi\ehcWY_d"o]WhWdj_pWh gk[dk[ijhWileY[ii[Wd[iYkY^WZWiogk[jeZeibeiYWcX_eigk[ikY[ZWdh[if[j[ddk[ijhei Z[h[Y^eiodk[ijheic[Z_eiZ[ikij[dje$ kgl\[\jZfeki`Yl`i D[Y[i_jWceigk[bei]eX_[hdei[iYkY^[dbWileY[iZ[beifeXh[i"bWiYeckd_ZWZ[iobW][dj[ YecdYkWdZei[h[dWd[dIkZ|\h_YW[dZ_Y_[cXh[oc|iWZ[bWdj[[dejhei[ifWY_ei$BWc[`eh cWd[hW Z[ ^WY[hbe [i eh]Wd_p|dZedei `kdjei" fehgk[ i_ kd_cei dk[ijhWi leY[i j[dZh[cei c|ifei_X_b_ZWZ[iZ[i[h[iYkY^WZei$>WockY^WicWd[hWi[dbWigk[fk[Z[i_dlebkYhWhj[o Yedjh_Xk_h$Fk[Z[i0 Fi^Xe`qXileXi\le`eYed][dj[gk[l_l[ojhWXW`W[djkYeckd_ZWZ"fWhWZ_\kdZ_h[b c[diW`[ feh bW `kij_Y_W Yb_c|j_YW o fbWd_ÓYWh Wb]kdWi WYY_ed[i gk[ fk[ZWd [cfh[dZ[h `kdjeifWhW^WY[hbWh[Wb_ZWZ$ <jZi`Y`ic\Xkli\gi\j\ekXek\\c\Zkfof[Z_hb[Wb]eX_[hdegk[Z[Ó[dZWWYY_ed[i[dh]_YWi YedjhW[bYWcX_eYb_c|j_Yeogk[dei[Z[`[fh[i_edWh[_dj_c_ZWhfehbWi]hWdZ[i[cfh[iWi ebei]eX_[hdeiZ[beifWi[ih_Yei_dZkijh_Wb_pWZei$ ;`]le[`i\cd\ejXa\[\cXaljk`Z`XZc`d}k`ZXc[Z_Wdj[c[diW`[iZ[j[njeefeh?dj[hd[j"W jhWliZ[beic[Z_eiieY_Wb[iYece<WY[XeeaoJm_jj[h$ JldXik\XleXgifk\jkX\h[dj[WkdWeÓY_dW]kX[hdWc[djWbbeYWbekdW\|Xh_YWeki_dW beYWbgk[[ij][d[hWdZeckY^WYedjWc_dWY_dob[i_edWdZeWbWYeckd_ZWZbeYWb$ JldXik\XleXfi^Xe`qXZ`ecfZXcfle^ilgfgk[^W]WYWcfWWifehbW`kij_Y_WYb_c|j_YW" e_dYbkieYh[Whkdei_de[n_ij[kdeWbgk[fk[ZWiikcWhj[$ CWhY^WZ[h[Y_YbWZeh[iZ[ Z[i[Y^eifehikZ[h[Y^eWb jhWXW`e"[dF_[j[hcWh_jpXkh]" IkZ|\h_YW ]hekdZMeha jfYi\8d`^fj[\cXK`\iiX@ek\ieXZ`feXc IeceibW\[Z[hWY_dWcX_[djWb_ijWZ[XWi[c|i]hWdZ[Z[bckdZe"Yed-, ]hkfeidWY_edWb[ioY[hYWZ[+$&&&]hkfeibeYWb[iZ[WYj_l_ijWi[djeZeibei Yedj_d[dj[i$ 9ed c|i Z[ ( c_bbed[i Z[ c_[cXhei o YebWXehWZeh[i [d jeZe [bckdZe"h[Wb_pWceiYWcfWWiieXh[beifheXb[cWiWcX_[djWb[ioieY_Wb[i c|iWYkY_Wdj[i$?cfk]dWcei[bceZ[beWYjkWbZ[]beXWb_pWY_d[Yedc_YW W][dY_WZW feh bWi ]hWdZ[i [cfh[iWi" o fhecel[cei iebkY_ed[i gk[ Yedjh_Xk_h|dWbWZl[d_c_[djeZ[ieY_[ZWZ[iWcX_[djWbc[dj[ikij[djWXb[io ieY_Wbc[dj[`kijWi$9edeY[c|iieXh[[b]hkfeZ[7c_]eiZ[bWJ_[hhWc|i Y[hYWde[dbWif|]_dWiZ[dk[ijhei]hkfei$ 9eckdYWj[Yed[b]hkfec_[cXheZ[7c_]eiZ[bWJ_[hhW[djkfWiol_i_jW mmm$\e[_$eh]fWhW_dlebkYhWhj[$ >[cWdj^WM_j^WdW][ \e[ 9^h_ije\\[h7iacWd ]hekdZMeha \e[ nnn%]f\`%fi^