(67$%,/,'$''(/<$38129 &RQFHSWRVGHHVWDELOLGDG (ODVSHFWRPiVLPSRUWDQWHHQHOHVWXGLRGHXQVLVWHPDGHFRQWUROHV GHWHUPLQDUVLHOPLVPRHVHVWDEOH(QWpUPLQRVPX\JHQHUDOHVVHGLFH TXHXQVLVWHPDHVHVWDEOHVLHVWDQGRLQLFLDOPHQWHFHUFDGHO SXQWRGH RSHUDFLyQGHVHDGRSHUPDQHFHDOOt 8QPpWRGRPX\JHQHUDOSDUDHVWXGLDUODHVWDELOLGDGGHVLVWHPDVQR OLQHDOHVHVODWHRUtDLQWURGXFLGDSRUHOPDWHPiWLFRUXVR$/\DSXQRY HQ(VWHPpWRGRUHFLpQIXHGLIXQGLGRHQORVDxRV\VHKDQ GHVDUUROODGRQXPHURVRVUHILQDPLHQWRVGHOPLVPR/RVFULWHULRVGH HVWDELOLGDGGH/\DSXQRYHVWiQUHIHULGRVDODVWUD\HFWRULDVGHXQ VLVWHPDFXDQGRHOHVWDGRLQLFLDOHVWiSUy[LPRDOSXQWRGHHTXLOLEULR x 3XQWRGHHTXLOLEULR [ W I >W [W @ [W Q Wt I u o FRQWLQXD Q Q 6HVXSRQHTXHH[LVWHVROXFLyQ~QLFD VW W [ FRUUHVSRQGLHQWHD FDGDFRQGLFLyQLQLFLDO [ W [ (OHVWDGR[ HVSXQWRGHHTXLOLEULRGHVL (QWRQFHV VW W [ I W [ { W t [ W t W t 6HDVXPLUiTXH HVXQHTXLOLEULRGH7RPDQGR ] ] I W ] [ [ I W ] [ \QRVHSLHUGHJHQHUDOLGDG (QWRQFHVVHWLHQHHOHTXLOLEULR I W W t 6L [W V W W W t W t 6XSyQJDVHDKRUDTXH [W z SHURFHUFDGHpO x (TXLOLEULRHVWDEOH (OSXQWRGHHTXLOLEULR HVHVWDEOH VLSDUDFDGD H! Wt G WH! WDOTXH [ G W H V W W [ H (VXQLIRUPHPHQWHHVWDEOH VLSDUDFDGD H TXH [ G H W t W ! G H ! W t V W W [ H W (VLQHVWDEOH VLQRHVHVWDEOH G )LJXUD H W t W WDO x ,QWHUSUHWDFLyQ 'DGRVORVVLJXLHQWHVHVSDFLRV\QRUPDV & Q >W f FRQWLQXDV %& Q >W f DFRWDGDV FRQWLQXDV VXEHVSDFLR GH & Q [ V VXS [ W [ %& Q W>W f %&Q HV%DQDFK $KRUDVHGHILQHHORSHUDGRU 7W Q o & Q >W f@ [ W o V W [ HVXQHTXLOLEULRHVWDEOHVLL 3DUDFDGDWt FW ! 7WR % %& Q >W f % 7W ^Q Q FW ` % o %& Q >W f HV FRQWLQXR HQ Q x (MHPSOR 9DQGHU3RO [ [ [ [ [ [ H )LJXUD (OHTXLOLEULR[ [ HVLQHVWDEOHDXQTXHODVWUD\HFWRULDVVRQ DFRWDGDVSXHVWLHQGHQDOFLFOROtPLWH x (MHPSOR 3pQGXOR T O J )LJXUD J" VHQ T " T J T VHQ T " [ T [ T ­ [ ° ® °̄ [ 6ROXFLyQ [ J FRV [ " [ J VHQ [ " [ J FRV [ D " 'DGRHOHQWRUQR%H HVSRVLEOHHQFRQWUDUD WDOTXHODVROXFLyQHVWp GHQWURGH%H$KRUDVHHOLJHXQDG WDOTXH%G HVWpGHQWURGHHVWD FXUYD(QWRQFHVVHVDWLVIDFHODGHILQLFLyQGHHVWDELOLGDG%G HV LQGHSHQGLHQWHGHW HOVLVWHPDHVDXWyQRPR H G )LJXUD x (MHPSOR0DVVHUD VLVWHPDQRDXWyQRPR /DVROXFLyQHV [W [ W W VHQ W W [ W [W H[S^ VHQ W W FRV W W VHQ W W FRV W W ` 3DUDWt [W [W 6LVHGHILQH FW H[S VHQ W W FRV W W VHQ W W FRV W W VXS H[S VHQ W W FRV W W VHQ W W FRV W W W tW HQWRQFHVFW HVILQLWRSDUDFDGDW ILMR\VHWLHQH [ W d FW [ W (QWRQFHVGDGRXQH !OD FRQGLFLyQGHHVWDELOLGDGVHVDWLVIDFHVLVH HOLJH G H FW (VWRPXHVWUDTXH HVXQHTXLOLEULRHVWDEOH3RU RWUDSDUWHVHREVHUYDTXH F W QRHVWiDFRWDGDFRQ W (VWRLPSOLFD TXH G o FRQ W o f 2VHDGDGRH ! QRHVSRVLEOHHQFRQWUDU XQ G H LQGHSHQGLHQWHGH W QR HVXQHTXLOLEULRXQLIRUPHPHQWH HVWDEOH x (TXLOLEULRDVLQWyWLFDPHQWHHVWDEOH(OHTXLOLEULR HV DVLQWyWLFDPHQWHHVWDEOHVL HVHVWDEOH HVDWUDFWLYR G W ! [ G W V W W W [ o W o f (OHTXLOLEULR HV XQLIRUPHPHQWHDVLQWyWLFDPHQWHHVWDEOHVL HVXQLIRUPHPHQWHHVWDEOH HVXQLIRUPHPHQWHDWUDFWLYR G ! WDOTXH [ G W t VW W W [ o XQLI HQ [ \ W FRQ W o f R ELHQ H ! 7 H WDO TXH [ G W t VW W W [ H W t 7 H x 2EVHUYDFLRQHV D %G W HTXLOLEULR ^[ Q [ G W ` HVODUHJLyQGHDWUDFFLyQGHO E/DFRQGLFLyQQRHVVXSHUIOXDSXHGHH[LVWLUXQVLVWHPDTXH FXPSOH\QRFXPSOH % H $ )LJXUD F6LHORULJHQHVHVWDEOH\DWUDFWLYRHQWRQFHVHVXQLIRUPHPHQWH DWUDFWLYRSDUDXQVLVWHPDDXWyQRPR x (TXLOLEULRJOREDOPHQWHDVLQWyWLFDPHQWHHVWDEOH(OHTXLOLEULR HVJOREDOPHQWHDVLQWyWLFDPHQWHHVWDEOH VL (VHVWDEOH [ RVHD V W W W [ o FXDOTXLHUFRQGLFLyQLQLFLDO [ (VDWUDFWLYR FRQ W of SDUD (QHVWHFDVRODUHJLyQGHDWUDFFLyQHV JOREDOPHQWHDWUDFWLYR Q (OHTXLOLEULR HVJOREDOPHQWHXQLIRUPHPHQWHDVLQWyWLFDPHQWH HVWDEOHVL (VXQLIRUPHPHQWHHVWDEOH (VXQLIRUPHPHQWHJOREDOPHQWHDWUDFWLYR 0 H ! 7 7 0 H WDO TXH [ 0 W t V W W W [ H W t 7 0 H x (TXLOLEULRH[SRQHQFLDOPHQWHHVWDEOH (OHTXLOLEULR HV H[SRQHQFLDOPHQWHHVWDEOHVL D E G ! WDO TXH VWW [ D [ H E W W W t W [ %G (OHTXLOLEULRHV JOREDOPHQWHH[SRQHQFLDOPHQWHHVWDEOH VLOR Q DQWHULRUYDOHSDUDWRGR [ x 5HJLyQGHDWUDFFLyQ 6LVWHPDVYDULDQWHVHQW W 6 W ^[ [W o W o f` 6LVWHPDVLQYDULDQWHVHQW 6 ^[ [W o W o f` 5HJLyQ 6 DFRQMXQWRLQYDULDQWHGHODHFXDFLyQGLIHUHQFLDOWRGDVROXFLyQTXH FRPLHQ]DHQ6 SHUPDQHFH HQ6 EHVDELHUWD FHVFRQHFWDGD x (MHPSOR &RQWLQXRGHHTXLOLEULRV 6,1)5,&&,21LQHVWDEOH &21)5,&&,21HVWDEOH U K ,QHVW $VLQW(VW )LJXUD 6,1)5,&&,21HVWDEOH &21)5,&&,21DVLQWHVW &21)5,&&,21 HVWDEOH x &DVRHVSHFLDOGHVLVWHPDVSHULyGLFRV\DXWyQRPRV [ W I W [W HV SHULyGLFR FRQ SHUtRGR 7 VL I W 7 [ I W [ W t [ Q 3DUDXQVLVWHPDSHULyGLFR V W 7 W 7 [ V W W [ W t W t [ Q [ W W W7 W7 6LHOVLVWHPDHVDXWyQRPRI QRGHSHQGHH[SOtFLWDPHQWHGHWVH SXHGHSHQVDUTXHHOVLVWHPDHVSHULyGLFRFRQ7 FXDOTXLHUD 3RUORWDQWRORVUHVXOWDGRVSDUDVLVWHPDVSHULyGLFRVYDOHQWDPELpQ SDUDVLVWHPDVDXWyQRPRV I W [ W HV x 7HRUHPD 6XSyQJDVH TXH HO VLVWHPD [ W SHULyGLFR (QWRQFHV HO HTXLOLEULR HV XQLIRUPHPHQWH HVWDEOH VL \ VRORVLHVHVWDEOH 'HPRVWUDFLyQ D(VWDELOLGDGXQLIRUPH HVWDELOLGDG E(VWDELOLGDG HVWDELOLGDGXQLIRUPH6XSyQJDVHW>7@ \GHItQDVH P [ W VXS VW W W [ W t &RPR HVHTXLOLEULRHVWDEOH GW WDOTXHP[W HVILQLWRSDUDWRGR[ %GW3RGUtDRFXUULUTXHDO YDULDUW HQ>fGWQRHVWpDFRWDGRIXHUDGH6LQHPEDUJRFRPR GW GW7 VRORHVQHFHVDULRHVWXGLDUGWRFRQW HQ>7@ (QWRQFHV G LQGHSHQGLHQWHGHWWDOTXH P [ W f [ %G \ W > 7 @'HItQDVH K [ [ VXS P [ W W> 7 @ TXHHVFRQWLQXDHQ [ G K [ H x 7HRUHPD6XSyQJDVHTXHHOVLVWHPD [ W I W [W HV SHULyGLFR(QWRQFHVHOHTXLOLEULR HVXQLIRUPHPHQWH DVLQWyWLFDPHQWHHVWDEOHVL\VRORVLHVDVLQWyWLFDPHQWHHVWDEOH x 'HILQLFLyQ )XQFLRQHVFODVH. \FODVH/ 8QDIXQFLyQ I FUHFLHQWH\I o HVGHFODVH. VLHVFRQWLQXDHVWULFWDPHQWH (V GH FODVH / VL HV FRQWLQXD VREUH >f HVWULFWDPHQWH GHFUHFLHQWH I f \ I U o FRQ U o f 7HRUHPD (OHTXLOLEULR GH [ W I W [W HVHVWDEOH VLLSDUD FDGDW H[LVWHXQQ~PHURGW\XQDIXQFLyQIW GHFODVH. WDO TXH VW W [ d I W [ W t W [ %G W (OHTXLOLEULRHVXQLIRUPHPHQWHHVWDEOH VLLH[LVWHG! \XQDI GH FODVH. WDOTXH VW W [ d I [ W t W t [ %G 3UXHED D HVHVWDEOH 3DUDH GDGRWRPDU G H FRQGLFLyQGHHVWDELOLGDG W > @ PtQ IW H G W \VHYHULILFDOD IW H GW IWH GHW E HVWDEOH GWIW [ )LJXUD 7RPDUW7RPDUH ! G!7RPDU G P H ORVSRVLEOHVG$KRUDVHGHILQHODIXQFLyQ W FRPRVXSUHPRGH \ W H o G P H W TXHHVQRGHFUHFLHQWH\SRVLWLYDDGHPiV TXHGDGHILQLGD IW T W \ W 6LVHWRPDODIXQFLyQFRQWLQXD T WR d \ W HQWRQFHV GP \W TW H )LJXUD 3DUDHVWDELOLGDGXQLIRUPHODGHPRVWUDFLyQHVVLPLODU x /HPD (OHTXLOLEULR HVDWUDFWLYR VLLSDUDFDGDWt H[LVWHUW \ SDUDFDGD[ %UW H[LVWHVW[ GHFODVH/ WDOTXH V W W W [ d V W [ W t VW[W [ [W W )LJXUD (OHTXLOLEULRHVXQLIRUPHPHQWHDWUDFWLYRVLLH[LVWHU! \V GHFODVH/ WDOTXH V W W W [ d V W W W t [ %U 3UXHED D HVDWUDFWLYR VWR[WoFRQWof VWWW[o E DWUDFWLYR UWVW[ 3DUDFDGD H ! VHD 7 H HOPiVSHTXHxRQ~PHURWDOTXH VW W W [ H W t 7 H FRQ [ %U W 6HD\ W [ \ H H o 7 H VHYHULILFDTXH SDUDH VXILFLHQWHPHQWHJUDQGH\\ H o f FRQ H o (QWRQFHVWRPDU V W [ t \ W [ 7H \W[Ho7H VW[ H )LJXUD W I W [ W HVXQLIRUPHPHQWH x 7HRUHPD (OHTXLOLEULR GH [ DVLQWyWLFDPHQWHHVWDEOHVLH[LVWHU! I GHFODVH.\V GHFODVH/ WDOTXH V W W W [ d I [ V W [ [ W W t [ %U VWIT[T VWIT[T IT[T T[WT W )LJXUD T[T T[T T[T x /HPD 6XSRQJDIo HVFRQWLQXDI I HVQR GHFUHFLHQWH\IU! U!(QWRQFHVH[LVWHXQDIXQFLyQD GH FODVH. WDOTXHDUd IUU0iVD~QVLIUof FRQUo fD SXHGHHOHJLUVHFRQODPLVPDSURSLHGDG 3UXHED 7RPDUXQDVHFXHQFLDHVWULFWDPHQWHFUHFLHQWH^TL` GH Q~PHURVSRVLWLYRVof \XQDVHFXHQFLDHVWULFWDPHQWHFUHFLHQWH ^NL`o'HILQLU D U U NI U T N LI TL VL d U d T U TL >NLI U NLI TL @ VL TL U d TL TL TL ID D NIT NIT T T T I U )LJXUD x )XQFLRQHV'HILQLGDV 8QDIXQFLyQ9[ Q o VHGLFHORFDOPHQWHGHILQLGDSRVLWLYDVL (VFRQWLQXD 9 W W t ([LVWHD GHFODVH. WDOTXH 9 W [ t D [ W t [ %U ^[ [ d U` U ! 9 DT[T > @ U D[ [ )LJXUD 8QDIXQFLyQ9 HVGHILQLGDSRVLWLYD VLORDQWHULRUYDOHSDUDWRGR[ Q U f 8QDIXQFLyQ 9 HVUDGLDOPHQWHQRDFRWDGD VL 9 W [ t D [ W t [ Q DU o f FRQUo f \ D FRQWLQXDWDOTXH x 2WUDFDUDFWHUL]DFLyQGHIXQFLRQHV PiVIiFLOGHYHULILFDU /HPD 8QDIXQFLyQFRQWLQXDTXHQRGHSHQGHGHOWLHPSR:Q o HVORFDOPHQWHGHILQLGDSRVLWLYD VL\VyORVL : : [ ! [ z % ^[ [ d U` : HVGHILQLGDSRVLWLYD VL\VyORVL : : [ ! [ z U ! WDO TXH LQI : [ ! [ tU HVWDFRQGLFLyQHYLWDTXHXQD IXQFLyQ SXHGDWHQGHUDVLQWyWLFDPHQWHDFHURHM[[ : HVUDGLDOPHQWHQRDFRWDGD VL\VRORVL : [ o f FRQ [ of /HPD8QDIXQFLyQFRQWLQXD9 [Q o HVORFDOPHQWHGHILQLGD SRVLWLYDVL\VyORVL :Q o ORFDOPHQWHGHILQLGDSRVLWLYDWDOTXH 9 W W t W t [ %U U ! 9 W [ t : [ 2VHD9 GRPLQDD: HQWRGRLQVWDQWHHQ%U 'HPRVWUDFLyQ D6L: HVORFGHISRV E6LGHILQLUIS LQI:[ Sd ««[««d U ISHVQRGHFUHFLHQWHSXHVDODXPHQWDUSHOtQILPRQRGHFUHFHSXHV VHWRPDVREUHXQDUHJLyQPHQRU3RUXQOHPDDQWHVYLVWR D GH FODVH. WDOTXH D S d I S S > U @ (QWRQFHV D [ d I [ d : [ [ %U RVHD:[HVORFDOPHQWHGHILQLGDSRVLWLYD 8QDIXQFLyQFRQWLQXD9[Qo HVGHILQLGDSRVLWLYD VL\VyORVL :Q o GHILQLGDSRVLWLYDWDOTXH W t 9 W 9 W [ t : [ W t [ Q 8QDIXQFLyQ 9 HVUDGLDOPHQWHQRDFRWDGD VL\VRORVLH[LVWHXQD IXQFLyQ:Qo UDGLDOPHQWHQRDFRWDGDWDOTXH 9 W [ t : [ W t [ Q x )XQFLyQ GHFUHFLHQWH 8QD IXQFLyQFRQWLQXD9[ Qo VH GLFH GHFUHFLHQWH VL XQDIXQFLyQE GHFODVH. WDOTXH9W[d E[ W t [ %U ^[[ d U` x (MHPSOR:[[ [[ ­: HVGHILQLGDSRVLWLYDSXHV ®: [ ! ¯ HVUDGLDOPHQWHQRDFRWDGD : [ [ o f x (MHPSOR 9 W [ [ W [ [ x (MHPSOR 9 W [ [ HVGHILQLGDSRVLWLYDSXHVGRPLQDD: 1RHVGHFUHFLHQWHSXHV [z 9 FUHFHFRQW H W [ [ [ of QRHVGHILQLGDSRVLWLYDSXHVQRGRPLQDQLQJXQD: GHILQLGDSRVLWLYD (VGHFUHFLHQWH x (MHPSOR : [ [ [ VHQ [ ­: HVORFDOPHQWHGHISRV ®: [ [ ! VL [ [ z \ [ S ¯ x 'HULYDGDGH9W[ HQODVWUD\HFWRULDVGH [ I > W [@ 6XSyQJDVHTXH9 WLHQHGHULYDGDVFRQWLQXDVHQVXVDUJXPHQWRV6HD 9 HOJUDGLHQWHGH9 FRQUHVSHFWRD[6XSyQJDVHTXH[ HV VROXFLyQGHODHFXDFLyQGLIHUHQFLDO\VHDODIXQFLyQWo9>W[W@ (QWRQFHV G9 >W [W @ w 9 >W [W @ w 9 >W [W @ [ w 9 >W [W @ [ Q wW w [ w [Q GW 9 w9 w9 w [ w [Q [ § [ · ¨ ¸ ¨ ¸ ¨ [ ¸ © Q¹ G9 >W [W @ w 9 >W [W @ 9 >W [W @ I >W [W @ wW GW 6HGHQRPLQD I >W [W @ G9 GW 9 W [ GHULYDGDGH9DORODUJRGHODVWUD\HFWRULDV GHOD HFXDFLyQGLIHUHQFLDO 9 > W [ W @ 9 > W R [ W @ ³WR 9 >W [ W @ GW W SDUD[ VROXFLyQGHODHFXDFLyQGLIHUHQFLDO ,QWHUSUHWDFLyQ 6LODWUD\HFWRULDGHOVLVWHPDSDVDSRU[R HQWROD YHORFLGDGGHFDPELRGH9W[WHQWR HV9 W R [ R 6L9 HV LQGHSHQGLHQWHGHW \HOVLVWHPDHVDXWyQRPR 9 HVLQGHSHQGLHQWHGH W ^ [ W I > W [ W @ W t ` x &RQMXQWRLQYDULDQWH 8QFRQMXQWR0 Q HVXQFRQMXQWRLQYDULDQWH GH OD HFXDFLyQ GLIHUHQFLDO FDGD[0 H[LVWHXQWR WDOTXH VL SDUD VW W R [R 0 W t W R 2 VHD SDUD FDGD HVWDGR HQ 0 SXHGH HQFRQWUDUVH XQ WLHPSR LQLFLDO WDO TXH OD WUD\HFWRULD UHVXOWDQWH SHUPDQHFH HQ 0 HQ WRGR WLHPSR IXWXUR x (MHPSORV 3DUD [ R W R V W R [ R WUD\HFWRULD UHVXOWDQWH FRPR VXEFRQMXQWRGHQ HVXQFRQMXQWRLQYDULDQWH Q 8QHTXLOLEULR 8QDVROXFLyQSHULyGLFD x 3XQWR OtPLWH 6XSyQJDVH [RQ WR 8Q SXQWR SQ VH GHQRPLQD SXQWR OtPLWH GH OD WUD\HFWRULD VWR [R VL H[LVWH XQD VHFXHQFLD ^WL` GH Q~PHURV UHDOHV HQ >WR f WDO TXH WLof \ OtP S VWL W R [ R L of GH VW[ 2HTXLYDOHQWHPHQWHS HVSXQWROtPLWH VL GDGRV H! 7f H[LVWH Wt7 S VW W [ H WDO TXH x &RQMXQWR OtPLWH (O FRQMXQWR GH WRGRV ORV SXQWRV OtPLWHV GH VWR[R VH GHQRPLQD FRQMXQWR OtPLWH GH VWR [R \ VH GHQRWD :WR[R x /HPD 6HD [ R W R \ VXSyQJDVH TXH V WR [R VHD DFRWDGD(QWRQFHV:WR[R HVQRYDFtRFHUUDGR\DFRWDGR Q x /HPD 6HD [ R W R \ VXSyQJDVH VWR[R DFRWDGD (QWRQFHVGLVW>VWWR[:WR[R@o FRQWof Q 3DUDVLVWHPDVSHULyGLFRV\ DXWyQRPRV x /HPD 6XSyQJDVHTXHHOVLVWHPD ^ [ W I > W [ W @ ` HVSHULyGLFR \WyPHVH [ R W R 6LVWR[R HVDFRWDGDOXHJR:WR[R HVXQFRQMXQWRLQYDULDQWHGHOVLVWHPD Q 3DUDVLVWHPDVDXWyQRPRV [ W I >[ W @ VW [ R VW W W [R W t W t [R Q x 'RPLQLR GH DWUDFFLyQ 6XSyQJDVH TXH VHD XQ HTXLOLEULR DWUDFWLYR GHO VLVWHPD DXWyQRPR (O GRPLQLR GH DWUDFFLyQ ' VH GHILQHFRPR ' ^ [ Q VW [ o FRQW o f` x 3XQWRV FRQHFWDGRV 6HD 6Q 'RV SXQWRV [ H \ VH GLFHQ FRQHFWDGRVHQ 6 VLH[LVWHXQFDPLQRHQWUH[ H\ WRWDOPHQWHLQFOXLGR HQ 6 (VWD SURSLHGDG HV VLPpWULFD \ WUDQVLWLYD 7RGR HO FRQMXQWR 6 VHGLFHFRQHFWDGRVLWRGRSDUGHSXQWRVGH6 VRQFRQHFWDGRVHQ6 ^ [ W I > [ W @` (QWRQFHV ' HV DELHUWR FRQHFWDGR H x /HPD 6XSyQJDVH TXH LQYDULDQWH HV XQ HTXLOLEULR DWUDFWLYR GH