Perspectivas de la Bioética en Iberoamérica

PERSPETIVADELABIOETICAINDD
1&341&$5*7"4%&-"#*0²5*$"&/*#&30".²3*$"
ª1SPHSBNBEF#JPÏUJDBEFMB0SHBOJ[BDJØO1BOBNFSJDBOBEFMB4BMVE
0SHBOJ[BDJØO.VOEJBMEFMB4BMVE0140.4
1SJNFSBFEJDJØOFOFTQB×PMBHPTUPEF
"WFOJEB1SPWJEFODJB1JTP1SPWJEFODJB$BTJMMB54BOUJBHP$IJMF
5FMÏGPOP
'BY
IUUQXXXQBIPPSHTQBOJTICJPIPNFIUN
CJPFUJDB!DIJPQTPNTPSH
3FHJTUSPEF1SPQJFEBE*OUFMFDUVBM/P
*4#/
%JTF×PZEJBHSBNBDJØO'BCJPMB)VSUBEP$ÏTQFEFT
*NQSFTPFO"OESPT*NQSFTPSFT
*NQSFTPFO$IJMF
/JOHVOBQBSUFEFFTUBQVCMJDBDJØOJODMVZFOEPFMEJTF×PEFMBDVCJFSUBQVFEFTFSSFQSPEVDJEB
BMNBDFOBEBPUSBOTNJUJEBQPSNFEJPBMHVOPZBTFBFMÏDUSJDPRVÓNJDPNFDÈOJDPØQUJDP
EFHSBCBDJØOPGPUPDPQJBTJOBVUPSJ[BDJØOQSFWJBEFMFEJUPS
PERSPETIVADELABIOETICAINDD
1&341&$5*7"4%&-"#*0²5*$"
&/*#&30".²3*$"
-FP1FTTJOJt$ISJTUJBOEF1BVMEF#BSDIJGPOUBJOFt'FSOBOEP-PMBT
$PPSEJOBEPSFT
5SBEVDDJØO
"EBJM4PCSBM.BSÓB4UFMB(POÎBMWFT.BSUB(MVLNBO
&EJDJØOFOFTQB×PM
«MWBSP2VF[BEB
PERSPETIVADELABIOETICAINDD
PERSPETIVADELABIOETICAINDD
¶OEJDF
&MEFTBGÓPEFVOBQFSTQFDUJWBJCFSPBNFSJDBOBFOCJPÏUJDB
"EWFSUFODJBQBSBMPTMFDUPSFTEFFTUFMJCSP
*OUSPEVDDJØO
1ĒģĥĖ*
3FnFYJPOFTEFTEFFMDPOUFYUPJCFSPBNFSJDBOP
&MDPOUFYUPIJTUØSJDPEFMBCJPÏUJDBIJTQBOPBNFSJDBOB
%JFHP(SBDJB
*OUSPEVDDJØO
&MQFSÓPEPQSJNJUJWPZMBÏQPDBEFMEFTDVCSJNJFOUPMBÏUJDBEFMEPO
&MQSPCMFNBÏUJDPEFMBDPORVJTUBMBTSB[POFTNPSBMFTEFMEFTQPUJTNP
-BÏQPDBDPMPOJBMMBÏUJDBEFMQBUFSOBMJTNP
-BÏQPDBEFMBJOEFQFOEFODJBMBTWJDJTJUVEFTEFMBÏUJDBEFMB
BVUPOPNÓBFO"NÏSJDB-BUJOB
3FGFSFODJBT
-PTEJTDVSTPTEFMBCJPÏUJDBFO"NÏSJDB-BUJOB
+PTÏ"MCFSUP.BJOFUUJZ.BSUB-VDÓB1ÏSF[
*OUSPEVDDJØO
3FDFQDJØOEFMBCJPÏUJDBFOMBEÏDBEBEF
-BBTJNJMBDJØOEFMBCJPÏUJDBFOMBEÏDBEBEF
-BSFDSFBDJØOEFMBCJPÏUJDBFOMBEÏDBEBEF
$PODMVTJØO
3FGFSFODJBT
-B0SHBOJ[BDJØO1BOBNFSJDBOBEFMB4BMVE014
ZMBCJPÏUJDBMBUJOPBNFSJDBOB
'FSOBOEP-PMBT
*NQMJDBDJØOEFMB0SHBOJ[BDJØO1BOBNFSJDBOBEFMB4BMVE014
&EVDBDJØOZFOUSFOBNJFOUP
*OWFTUJHBDJØOZBCPHBDÓB
%FTBGÓPTQBSBFMGVUVSP
3FGFSFODJBT
PERSPETIVADELABIOETICAINDD
-BCJPÏUJDBFO"NÏSJDB-BUJOBZFO$PMPNCJB
"MGPOTP-MBOP&TDPCBS4+
6CJDBDJØOEFMUFNB
*NQBDUPEFMBCJPÏUJDBFOMBDVMUVSBVOJWFSTBMDPOUFNQPSÈOFB
1SJNFSBFUBQBEFMBCJPÏUJDBFO-BUJOPBNÏSJDBiFMUSBTQMBOUFw
5SBTQMBOUFZEFTBSSPMMPEFMBCJPÏUJDBFO-BUJOPBNÏSJDB
4FHVOEBFUBQBDPOTPMJEBDJPOEFMBCJPÏUJDBFO-BUJOPBNÏSJDB
3ÈQJEBEJGVTJØOEFMBCJPÏUJDBFO-BUJOPBNÏSJDB
1SPTZDPOUSBT
3FGFSFODJBT
6OBIJTUPSJBQFSTPOBMEFMBCJPÏUJDBFO"NÏSJDB-BUJOB&MEFTBGÓPBDUVBMBMB
QSPGFTJØONÏEJDBZMBJOnVFODJBEFMBTFNQSFTBTGBSNBDPRVÓNJDBT
+BNFT%SBOF
-PTQSJODJQJPTEFMBCJPÏUJDB
&MQBQFMEFMB0SHBOJ[BDJØO1BOBNFSJDBOBEF4BMVE014
6OQSPZFDUPCJPÏUJDPFODVSTP
-BJOnVFODJBEFMBJOEVTUSJBGBSNBDÏVUJDB
$PODMVTJØO
1ĒģĥĖ**
3FnFYJPOFTEFTEFWPDFTQJPOFSBTFOMPTEJWFSTPTQBÓTFT
3FGFSFODJBTEFCJPÏUJDBFO"SHFOUJOB
+PTÏ"MCFSUP.BJOFUUJZ.BSUB-VDÓB1ÏSF[
*OUSPEVDDJØO
$FOUSPTEFFTUVEJP
$PNJUÏTDPNJTJPOFTZDPOTFKPTEFÏUJDB
1PMÓUJDBTQÞCMJDBT
1VCMJDBDJPOFT
-BCJPÏUJDBFO#PMJWJBBOUFDFEFOUFTZQSPZFDDJPOFT
+BWJFS-VOB0SPTDP&EVBSEP
1SFDVSTPSFTZBOUFDFEFOUFTJOJDJBMFT
$POUFYUPJOTUJUVDJPOBMEFMBCJPÏUJDBFO#PMJWJB
$PNJUÏ/BDJPOBMEF#JPÏUJDB
3FMBDJPOFTJOUFSJOTUJUVDJPOBMFT
1VCMJDBDJPOFT
.PUJWBDJPOFTZPSJFOUBDJPOFTGVUVSBTEFM$/#
&M*OTUJUVUPEF#JPÏUJDBEFMB6OJWFSTJEBE$BUØMJDB#PMJWJBOB6$#
FO$PDIBCBNCB
"TPDJBDJØO#PMJWJBOBEF#JPÏUJDBZ%FSFDIP(FOÏUJDP
$PODMVTJPOFT
#JCMJPHSBGÓB
6OBSBEJPHSBGÓBEFMBCJPÏUJDBFO#SBTJMWPDFTQJPOFSBTQSPHSBNBT
JOTUJUVDJPOBMFTZFEVDBUJWPTZQFSTQFDUJWBT
-FP1FTTJOJZ$ISJTUJBOEF1BVMEF#BSDIJGPOUBJOF
*OUSPEVDDJØO
PERSPETIVADELABIOETICAINDD
-PTQSJNFSPTDPOHSFTPTEFCJPÏUJDBZTBMVEFO#SBTJM
-B4PDJFEBE#SBTJMF×BEF#JPÏUJDB4##
*OJDJBUJWBTFEVDBUJWBTJOTUJUVDJPOBMFTCSBTJMF×BT
²UJDBEFMBJOWFTUJHBDJØOFOTFSFTIVNBOPT
6OBFWBMVBDJØOQSPTQFDUJWB
3FGFSFODJBT
#JPÏUJDBFO$IJMF
.JHVFM,PUUPX
*OUSPEVDDJØO
'POEPIJTUØSJDP
-PTDPNJFO[PTEFMBCJPÏUJDB
*OTUJUVDJPOFT
%FMJCFSBDJPOFTCJPÏUJDBTFJOnVFODJBTDVMUVSBMFT
3FGFSFODJBT
#JPÏUJDBFO$VCBSFTQPOTBCJMJEBEZTPMJEBSJEBE
+PTÏ3BNØO"DPTUB4BSJFHP
6OBQFSTQFDUJWBEFTEF$VCBEFMOVFWPQBSBEJHNBEFSFMBDJPOFTTBOJUBSJBT
"QPSUFTEFTEF$VCBBMBCJPÏUJDBHMPCBMTVTUFOUBCMF
-BCJPÏUJDBDPNPOVFWPTBCFS{ÏUJDBBQMJDBEBPNFUBÏUJDB $PODMVTJØO
3FGFSFODJBT
%JOBNJTNPEFMEJÈMPHPCJPÏUJDPFO&TQB×B
'SBODFTD"CFM4+Z/VSJB5FSSJCBT
*OUSPEVDDJØO
*OTUJUVUP#PSKBEF#JPÏUJDB*##
4FHVOEPQFSÓPEPEFMBCJPÏUJDBFO&TQB×B
1FSÓPEPEFSFWJTJØOQSPZFDDJØOFJOUFHSBDJØO
3FGFSFODJBT
1BOPSBNBNFYJDBOPEFMEFTBSSPMMPEFMBCJPÏUJDB-BNFEJDJOBHFOØNJDB
FO.ÏYJDPDPNPVOPEFMPTNBZPSFTSFUPTCJPÏUJDPT
(FSBSEP+JNÏOF[4ÈODIF[$ÏTBS'SBODJTDP-BSB«MWBSF[Z"MCFSUP"SFMMBOP.ÏOEF[
1MBOUFBNJFOUPEFMQSPCMFNB
-BDPOTUSVDDJØOEFMBCJPÏUJDBFO.ÏYJDP
-BCJPÏUJDBZMBQMBUBGPSNBEFMBNFEJDJOBHFOØNJDBFO.ÏYJDP
3FnFYJPOFTmOBMFT
3FGFSFODJBT
3FGFSFODJBTMFHBMFT
)JTUPSJBEFMEFTBSSPMMPEFMBCJPÏUJDBFO1BSBHVBZ
.BSUB"TDVSSB
4JUVBDJØOHFPHSÈmDB*OEJDBEPSFTEFNPHSÈmDPTZEFTBMVEFOUSFPUSPT
-FZFTEFDSFUPTEFM1PEFS&KFDVUJWPZSFTPMVDJPOFTNJOJTUFSJBMFT
"TPDJBDJPOFTDJWJMFT
$PNJUÏTEFÏUJDBZEFCJPÏUJDB
&OTF×BO[B
1VCMJDBDJPOFT
PERSPETIVADELABIOETICAINDD
$VSTPTKPSOBEBTZDPOHSFTPT
%FDMBSBDJØO6OJWFSTBMTPCSF#JPÏUJDBZ%FSFDIPT)VNBOPT
$PODMVTJØO
3FGFSFODJBT
#JPÏUJDBFO1FSÞ
3PCFSUP-MBOPT;VMPBHB
*OUSPEVDDJØO
)POPSJP%FMHBEPQSFDVSTPS
*OJDJPTEFMNPWJNJFOUPCJPÏUJDPQFSVBOP
-B"TPDJBDJØO1FSVBOBEF#JPÏUJDB"41&#*0
"TQFDUPTMFHBMFT
-PTDPNJUÏTEFÏUJDBEFMBJOWFTUJHBDJØOFOTBMVEFO1FSÞ
&M*OTUJUVUPEF4BMVE$SJTUØGPSJT%FOFLF*4%&/
QPSMBTFOEB
EFMBCJPÏUJDB
$PODMVTJPOFT
3FGFSFODJBT
#JPÏUJDBFO1PSUVHBM
+PSHF#JTDBJBZ8BMUFS0TTXBME
*OTUJUVDJPOFT
"DUJWJEBEFTQSJODJQBMFT
1VCMJDBDJPOFT
-BFOTF×BO[BEFMBCJPÏUJDB
*OWFTUJHBDJØOCJPNÏEJDB
-FZFTEFJNQPSUBODJBCJPNÏEJDB
7ÓODVMPTJOUFSOBDJPOBMFT
3FGFSFODJBT
%JSFDDJPOFT
#JCMJPHSBGÓB
-BIJTUPSJBEFMBCJPÏUJDBFO3FQÞCMJDB%PNJOJDBOB
.JHVFM4VB[P
"OUFDFEFOUFTFMOBDJNJFOUP
&UBQBEFGPSNBMJ[BDJØO
EFTBSSPMMP
*OUFSOBDJPOBMJ[BDJØO
$SFDJNJFOUPFYUFOTJØOZEFTBSSPMMP
"TQFDUPTMFHBMFT
-BTJUVBDJØOBDUVBMEFMBCJPÏUJDBFO3FQÞCMJDB%PNJOJDBOB
3FGFSFODJBT
1ĒģĥĖ***
$VFTUJPOFTFTQFDÓmDBTSFMJHJØOZNVKFSFT
#JPÏUJDBZSFMJHJØOFO"NÏSJDB-BUJOB
.ÈSDJP'BCSJEPT"OKPT
i1VFOUFTBMGVUVSPwQVFOUFTDPNVOFT
{&YJTUFVODPOnJDUPFOUSFMBSB[ØOZMBSFMJHJØOFOMBCJPÏUJDB PERSPETIVADELABIOETICAINDD
3FMJHJØOZCJPÏUJDBFOVODPOUFYUPEFJOKVTUJDJBTQFSTJTUFOUFT
.ÈTBMMÈEFMEPHNBUJTNP
#JPÏUJDBZUFPMPHÓBFOMBDVFTUJØOEFMBUSBTDFOEFODJB
{)BCSÈVOBSFMJHJØOJNQMÓDJUBFOMBCJPÏUJDB #JPÏUJDBMBJDBZCJPÏUJDBSFMJHJPTBFMEFTBGÓPEFMEJTDVSTP
#JPÏUJDBZSFMJHJØOFMEFTBGÓPEFTVTMVHBSFTFOMBTPDJFEBE
3FGFSFODJBT
-BCJPÏUJDBZMBTNVKFSFTFO"NÏSJDB-BUJOBVOFOTBZPCJPHSÈmDP
ZHFOFBMØHJDP
%FCPSB%JOJ[Z%JSDF(VJMIFN
6OQBOPSBNBHFOFBMØHJDP
&OUSFNÏEJDPTZUFØMPHPTMBTNVKFSFTGFNJOJTUBT
&OUSFQSPUBHPOJTUBTBDBEÏNJDBTFJOUFSMPDVUPSBTQÞCMJDBT
.VKFSFTZOVFWPTEFTBGÓPT
3FGFSFODJBT
1ĒģĥĖ*7
1BTBEPQSFTFOUFZEFTBGÓPTGVUVSPT
6OBMFDUVSBDSÓUJDBEFMBCJPÏUJDBMBUJOPBNFSJDBOB
(FSNÈO$BMEFSØO-FHBSEB
*EFOUJmDBOEPVOBQFSTQFDUJWBEFBDFSDBNJFOUP
&MUSBCBKPEFMPTQJPOFSPTEFMIVNBOJTNPNÏEJDP
6OBSFTQFUVPTBNJSBEBSFUSPTQFDUJWB
-BFNFSHFODJBEFMBSFnFYJØOCJPÏUJDBBDFSDBEFDVFTUJPOFT
MBUJOPBNFSJDBOBT
-BBmSNBDJØOEFJEFBMFTNPSBMFTZFMSJFTHPEFMiQBOnFUJTNPwCJPÏUJDP
-BBQFSUVSBEFMBCJPÏUJDBIBDJBMPTHSBOEFTUFNBTEFMBWJEB
-BCÞTRVFEBEFMFTUBUVUPFQJTUFNPMØHJDPEFMBCJPÏUJDB
6OBPCTFSWBDJØOmOBM
3FGFSFODJBT
6OBNJSBEBQSPTQFDUJWBQBSBJEFOUJmDBSEFTBGÓPTBQBSUJSEFMDPOUFYUP
IJTUØSJDPIJTQBOPBNFSJDBOP
)VCFSU-FQBSHOFVS
*OUSPEVDDJØOTJUVBOEPFMDPOUFYUPIJTUØSJDP
-BQFSTQFDUJWBVOJWFSTBMJTUBEFMBCJPÏUJDBSFTVSHFSFMBUJWJ[BEB
QFSPDPOGVFS[B
-BDPNQMFNFOUBDJØOZFMQBSBMFMJTNPEFMPTOÞDMFPTCJPÏUJDPT
JEFOUJmDBEPT
$PTUPTFDPOØNJDPTZTPDJBMFT
&WBMVBDJØOHFOFSBM
'SFOUFBMBTBNFOB[BTQMBOFUBSJBTNFEJBOUFMBCJPÏUJDBZBEFNÈTEFFMMB
3FGFSFODJBT
PERSPETIVADELABIOETICAINDD
"MHVOPTSFUPTQBSBFMGVUVSPEFMBCJPÏUJDBFO*CFSPBNÏSJDB
-FP1FTTJOJZ$ISJTUJBOEF1BVMEF#BSDIJGPOUBJOF
"MHVOPTQVOUPTEJHOPTEFSFnFYJØO
6OBPCTFSWBDJØOmOBM
3FGFSFODJBT
"QÏOEJDFT
4FMFDDJØOEFQSPHSBNBTGPSNBUJWPTFOCJPÏUJDB
4FMFDDJØOEFJOTUJUVDJPOFTEFCJPÏUJDB
4FMFDDJØOEFQVCMJDBDJPOFTQFSJØEJDBTEFCJPÏUJDB
1VCMJDBDJPOFTEFM1SPHSBNBEF#JPÏUJDB0140.4
4PCSFMPTBVUPSFTZUSBEVDUPSFT
"VUPSFT
5SBEVDUPSFT
PERSPETIVADELABIOETICAINDD
&MEFTBGÓPEFVOBQFSTQFDUJWB
JCFSPBNFSJDBOBFOCJPÏUJDB
"EWFSUFODJBQBSBMPTMFDUPSFTEFFTUFMJCSP
$
PNPTFTF×BMBFOMB*OUSPEVDDJØOFTUFMJCSPFTGSVUPEFVOQSPMPOHBEPQSPDFTP
EFEJÈMPHPFJOUFSDBNCJPEFDPSSFTQPOEFODJBFOUSFEJGFSFOUFTJOUFSMPDVUPSFT&M
QSFTFOUFWPMVNFODPOUJFOFMBUSBEVDDJØOSFWJTBEBEFDBQÓUVMPTJODMVJEPTFOFMWP
MVNFOi#JPÏUJDBOB*CFSPBNÏSJDB)JTUØSJBF1FSTQFDUJWBTw-1FTTJOJZ$EF1EF
#SBDIJGPOUBJOFPSHBOJ[BEPSFT&EJDPFT-PZPMBZ$FOUSP6OJWFSTJUBSJP4ÍP$BNJMP
4BP1BVMP
FEJUBEBZFOSJRVFDJEBDPOBQÏOEJDFT
-B DPOUSJCVDJØO EFM 1SPHSBNB EF #JPÏUJDB EF MB 0SHBOJ[BDJØO 1BOBNFSJDBOB EF
MB4BMVE014
EFSJWØEFVOBJOWJUBDJØOEF-FPDJS1FTTJOJBQBSUJDJQBSFOFMMJCSP
CSJOEBOEPMBQFSTQFDUJWBRVFPGSFDFFTUBBUBMBZBJOUFSOBDJPOBM&OVOBSFBMJEBEUBO
EJOÈNJDBDPNPMBRVFFTUFWPMVNFOJOUFOUBmKBSQBSUFEFMPRVFTFQFOTØZFTDSJ
CJØEVSBOUFTVFMBCPSBDJØOUJFOFBIPSBNFOPTVSHFODJBWJHFODJBPJNQPSUBODJB"M
FEJUBSMPTDPMBCPSBEPSFTEFM1SPHSBNBBQPSUBSPOTVFYQFSJFODJBFEJUPSJBMSFmOBOEP
ZNFKPSBOEPTJOUBYJTFTUJMPZQSPQJFEBEEFMMFOHVBKFTJONPEJmDBSBQSFDJBDJPOFTP
KVJDJPT EF WBMPS FYDFQUP DVBOEP IBCÓB JOGPSNBDJPOFT JOFYBDUBT P FSSPSFT GÈDUJDPT
-BTBQPSUBDJPOFTEF«MWBSP2VF[BEBZ"OESFB«HVJMBZMBTNÓBTB×BEFOTJOBMUFSBSZ
DPSSJHFOTJODPSSPNQFS&TOFDFTBSJPBEWFSUJSRVFFTUFWPMVNFOOPSFQMJDBMBTWFSTJPOFT
RVFDPOTFNFKBOUFUÓUVMPZQBSFDJEBJOUFODJØODJSDVMBSÈOFOJOHMÏTZQPSUVHVÏT&TUB
ÞMUJNBRVFUFOFNPTBMBWJTUBBMQSFQBSBSFTUBBEWFSUFODJBQSFTFOUBSFQFUJDJPOFTZ
EFUBMMFT RVF TØMP QBSDJBMNFOUF IFNPT DPOTFSWBEP )FNPT B×BEJEP JOGPSNBDJPOFT
RVFKV[HBNPTÞUJMFTZSFMFWBOUFTDPNPBQÏOEJDFTZSFGFSFODJBTBTJUJPT*OUFSOFURVF
FOSJRVFDFOFTUBWFSTJØO
%FCFEFTUBDBSTFFOFTUFMJCSPMBIFUFSPHFOFJEBEEFMBTNJSBEBT/PFYJTUFVOJGPSNJ
EBEFOMPTQMBOUFBNJFOUPT5BNQPDPIBZIPNPHFOFJEBEFOMBEFOTJEBEJOUFMFDUVBM
EFMBTDPOUSJCVDJPOFT&MUFNBCJPÏUJDPFOSJHPSEFWFSEBEOPOBDJØFTQPOUÈOFB
NFOUFFOUJFSSBTTVEBNFSJDBOBTZGVFSFDJCJEPEFNBOFSBEFTJHVBMFOMPTEJTUJOUPT
QBÓTFT 1BSUF EF MB CJPÏUJDB JCFSPBNFSJDBOB FT JNQPSUBDJØO Z BEBQUBDJØO "MHVOBT
-PMBT'FEJUPS
%JÈMPHPZDPPQFSBDJØOFOTBMVE%JF[B×PTEFCJPÏUJDBFOMB0144BO
UJBHPEF$IJMF6OJEBEEF#JPÏUJDB0140.4
PERSPETIVADELABIOETICAINDD
1FSTQFDUJWBTEFMB#JPÏUJDBFO*CFSPBNÏSJDB
WPDFTRVFDMBNBOQPSNBZPSPSJHJOBMJEBEOPTJFNQSFTPOJOUFMFDUVBMNFOUFBUSBDUJWBT
PTPMWFOUFT-BWFSEBEFSBPSJHJOBMJEBEFTMBBMVEJEBQPSFMJOUFMFDUVBMNFYJDBOP-FP
QPMEP;FBDVBOEPEFDÓBRVF-BUJOPBNÏSJDBEFCÓBUFOFSmMPTPGÓBiTJONÈTw&MBGÈO
EFPSJHJOBMJEBETVHFSÓBTFDPOGVOEFFOOVFTUSPFOUPSOPDPOMBCÞTRVFEBBGBOPTB
EFJEFOUJEBEQSPQJBBCBOEPOBOEPMPTEFSSPUFSPTEFMBDVMUVSBFVSPQFBZEFM*NQFSJP
EFM/PSUF"SHVNFOUBCBRVFIBDJFOEPCVFOBmMPTPGÓBiTJONÈTwTFIBDÓBimMPTPGÓB
MBUJOPBNFSJDBOBwQVFTMPTHSJFHPTDVBOEPmMPTPGBCBOZDSFBCBOOPTFQSFHVOUBCBO
TJMPRVFIBDÓBOFSBHSJFHPCBCJMØOJDPPFHJQDJP$POTUSVZFSPOVOJNQPOFOUFMFHBEP
QBSBMBIVNBOJEBEIBDJFOEPmMPTPGÓBiTJONÈTw$SFPRVFFMÏOGBTJTEFCFQPOFSTF
FOMBFYQSFTJØOiCVFOBmMPTPGÓBwQPSRVFSFTVNFMBFYJHFODJBEFDBMJEBEZVOJWFSTBMJ
EBERVFUPEBUBSFBJOUFMFDUVBMTVQPOF
$POMBCJPÏUJDBPDVSSFBMHPQBSFDJEP%FFMMPEBOUFTUJNPOJPMBTQÈHJOBTRVFTJHVFO
-BNFOUBCMFNFOUFBWFDFTMBCÞTRVFEBEFPSJHJOBMJEBEZBVUFOUJDJEBETFSFEVDFB
QJOUPSFTDPTiBOUJÓTNPTwBOUJJNQFSJBMJTNPBOUJFVSPQFÓTNPBOUJJOUFMFDUVBMJTNP
'VFSB EFM QJOUPSFTRVJTNP DSJPMMJ[BOUF UBM BDUJUVE OP TVFMF BDPNQB×BSTF EF BQPS
UBDJPOFTRVFNFSF[DBOFOUSBSBMBDFSWPEFMBJOUFMFDUVBMJEBENVOEJBMDPOFOUJEBE
QSPQJB4JOBVUPDSÓUJDBUBMFTBGBOFTEFTFNCPDBOFOWFSCBMJTNPQBOnFUBSJPZEFNB
HØHJDP)BZDBVTBTWBMJPTBTZEJHOBTEFFODPNJPEFHSBEBEBTQPSMBTVQFSmDJBMJEBE
ZMBEFNBHPHJBFOMBBDUJWJEBEQPMÓUJDBZMBQSPEVDDJØOJOUFMFDUVBM&MMPIBDFEVEBS
EFMQSPZFDUPEFVOBCJPÏUJDBHFTUBEBFOZQBSB*CFSPBNÏSJDBZOPBQPSUBBSHVNFOUPT
QBSBVOEJÈMPHPTJOPDPOTJHOBTQBSBVOBMVDIB"MHVOBQFSTQFDUJWBDSÓUJDBNFTVSBEB
TFFODVFOUSBFOFTUFWPMVNFO$POTJEFSBDJPOFTBEJDJPOBMFTQVFEFODPOTVMUBSTFFO
BMHVOBTQVCMJDBDJPOFTZTJUJPTXFCQPSFKFNQMPXXXQBIPPSHCJPFUJDBZXXX
VDIJMFDMCJPFUJDBRVFSFNJUFOBBCVOEBOUFNBUFSJBM
$PNPIPOFTUPUSBCBKPJOUFMFDUVBMÏTUFFTQFSBEFMEJÈMPHPDPOTVTMFDUPSFTZMFDUPSBT
BDFSDBSTFBVOBJNQPTJCMFQFSGFDDJØO%FTPCSBTBCFORVJFOFTFTDSJCFOPFEJUBOMJCSPT
RVFMBMFUSBOVODBDBQUVSBUPUBMNFOUFFMQFOTBNJFOUP&OTVBQBSFOUFQFSNBOFODJB
FTUÈTVKFUBBJOUFSQSFUBDJPOFTZNBMFOUFOEJEPT/POPTSFTUBNPTBOJOHVOBQPMÏNJDB
QFSPOPRVFSFNPTDSFBSEFCBUFQPSFMMÞEJDPBGÈOEFDSFFSOPTQSPUBHPOJTUBTEFVO
EFTBSSPMMPRVFQBSBCJFOPQBSBNBMOPEFQFOEFEFOBEJFFOQBSUJDVMBSQFSPTÓEF
VOBFWPMVDJØODPNPMBRVFWBUJDJOBO1FTTJOJZEF#BSDIJGPOUBJOFFOTVDBQÓUVMPmOBM
&TBFWPMVDJØOFTQPSBIPSBNÈTFTQFSBO[BRVFQSPOØTUJDPZNÈTQSPGFDÓBRVFIFDIP
DPODSFUP
-PMBT ' 4PCSF BNFSJDBOJ[BE &O /PUBT BM .BSHFO &OTBZPT 4BOUJBHP EF $IJMF $PMFDDJØO
5SBWFTÓB&EJUPSJBM$VBUSP7JFOUPT
1PSFKFNQMP-PMBT'FEJUPS
#JPÏUJDBZDVJEBEPEFMBTBMVE&RVJEBE$BMJEBE%FSFDIPT4BOUJB
HPEF$IJMF1SPHSBNB3FHJPOBMEF#JPÏUJDB0SHBOJ[BDJØO1BOBNFSJDBOBEFMB4BMVE
PERSPETIVADELABIOETICAINDD
&MEFTBGÓPEFVOBQFSTQFDUJWBJCFSPBNFSJDBOBFOCJPÏUJDB"EWFSUFODJBQBSBMPTMFDUPSFTEFFTUFMJCSP
0CTÏSWFTFRVFFMUSBUBNJFOUPEFNVDIPTQBÓTFTGBMUBFOFTUBSFDPQJMBDJØOEFQFSTQFD
UJWBT&MMPEFNVFTUSBMBOFDFTJEBEEFDPNQMFUBSMPRVFGBMUBFOVOBGVUVSBFEJDJØO
BNQMJBEB1PSDJFSUPMBTPNJTJPOFTOPPCFEFDFOBOJOHÞOEFTJHOJPEFMPTFEJUPSFT
TJOPTPMBNFOUFBMBQSFNVSBDPORVFTFSFDPQJMØFMNBUFSJBM1PSFTPFTUBFEJDJØOOP
UJFOFMBQBMBCSBiIJTUPSJBwFOFMUÓUVMPQPSRVFEFSFDVFOUPIJTUØSJDPUJFOFQPDPZTÓ
NVDIPEFVOQFSTQFDUJWJTNPRVFFTOFDFTBSJPBTJNJMBSQPOEFSBSZDSJUJDBS
"QPSUBDJPOFTÞUJMFTTFFODVFOUSBOFOMBSFWJTUB"DUB#JPFUIJDB*44/
Z
VOBDSØOJDBEFTVDFTPTSFMFWBOUFTEFTEFIBDFNÈTEFEPTMVTUSPTFOFMCPMFUÓO#JPÏUJDB
*OGPSNB*44/
+VOUPDPOMPTBHSBEFDJNJFOUPTBUPEPTRVJFOFTQBSUJDJQBSPOFOFTUBJOJDJBUJWBoFTQF
DJBMNFOUFMBTJFNQSFJHOPSBEBMBCPSFEJUPSJBMoEFCFBEWFSUJSTFRVFFTUFMJCSPBVO
DVBOEPQSPEVDJEPDPOFMBQPZPEFM1SPHSBNBEF#JPÏUJDBEFMB014EFM$FOUSP
6OJWFSTJUBSJP 4ÍP $BNJMP Z EFM$FOUSP*OUFSEJTDJQMJOBSJPEF&TUVEJPTFO#JPÏUJDB
$*&#
EFMB6OJWFSTJEBEEF$IJMFOPDPNQSPNFUFBFTUBTJOTUJUVDJPOFTZUPEBTMBT
BmSNBDJPOFTTPOEFFYDMVTJWBSFTQPOTBCJMJEBEEFRVJFOFTMBTFNJUFO
'FSOBOEP-PMBT
"NCBTQVCMJDBDJPOFTEJTQPOJCMFTFOXXXQBIPPSHCJPFUJDB
PERSPETIVADELABIOETICAINDD
PERSPETIVADELABIOETICAINDD
*OUSPEVDDJØO
$
BEBOVFWPMJCSPUJFOFTVQSPQJBIJT
UPSJBNBSDBEBBWFDFTQPSVOQMB
OFBNJFOUP SBDJPOBM SJHVSPTP DPNP MBT
EJTFSUBDJPOFT Z UFTJT Z PUSBT EFTEF VOB
JOTQJSBDJØO JOEJWJEVBM PSJHJOBM &TUF MJ
CSP1FSTQFDUJWBTEFMB#JPÏUJDB*CFSPBNF
SJDBOBTVSHJØEFVOBOJNBEPDPMPRVJP
BDDJEFOUBMFOVOWJBKFFOUSF4ÍP1BVMP
Z'P[EF*HVB[ÞDPOOVFTUSPBNJHPEF
DBNJOPTCJPÏUJDPT5SJTUSBN&OHFMIBSEU
DVBOEPWJOPB#SBTJMQBSBQBSUJDJQBSFO
FM7$POHSFTP#SBTJMF×PEF#JPÏUJDBFO
'P[ EF *HVB[Þ 1BSBOÈ
FO %F
BMMÓQSPWJOPMBJOTQJSBDJØOQBSBQSFQBSBS
VOWPMVNFOEFFOTBZPTRVFBHSVQBTFB
MPTQJPOFSPTSFTQPOTBCMFTEFMBEJGVTJØO
EFMBCJPÏUJDBFO"NÏSJDB-BUJOBFM$B
SJCFZMB1FOÓOTVMB*CÏSJDB
&OFMNFNPSBOEPFOFMDVBMFYQSFTÈCB
NPTFMPCKFUJWPEFFTUFQSPZFDUPEJKJNPT
BMPTDPMBCPSBEPSFTRVFMBCJPÏUJDBFNFS
HJØQSÈDUJDBNFOUFIBDFDVBUSPEÏDBEBT
DPNPVOBOVFWBÈSFBEF
MB FEVDBDJØO Z EF MB TFOTJCJMJEBE ÏUJDB
EFEJDBEB B MB QSFTFSWBDJØO Z FM DVJEB
EP EF MB WJEB IVNBOB F JODMVTP EF MB
WJEBDØTNJDPFDPMØHJDBBOUFMPTBWBODFT
UFDOPDJFOUÓmDPT FYUSBPSEJOBSJPT FO MBT
DJFODJBT EF MB WJEB Z EF MB TBMVE $BEB
PERSPETIVADELABIOETICAINDD
QBSUFEFMNVOEPUJFOFTVIJTUPSJBQFDV
MJBSFOUÏSNJOPTEFMEFTBSSPMMPEFMBCJP
ÏUJDBEJTF×BEBQPSEJWFSTBTQFSTPOBMJEB
EFT QJPOFSBT Z DPOUFYUPT DVMUVSBMFT BTÓ
DPNP QPS MBT DJSDVOTUBODJBT FTQFDÓmDBT
EFDBEBQBÓT/VFTUSPQSPZFDUPBQVOUB
BQSFTFOUBSFOTBZPTEFMPTJOWFTUJHBEPSFT
SFTQPOTBCMFTEFMBBQBSJDJØOEFMBCJPÏUJ
DBFOTVTSFTQFDUJWBTSFHJPOFTEJDJFOEP
FO QSJNFSB QFSTPOB TVT JOUVJDJPOFT BTÓ
DPNPTVTFYQFSJFODJBTZDPOUSJCVDJPOFT
QBSBTVEFTBSSPMMP
-B FTQFSBO[B FT QSFTFOUBS VOB IJTUPSJB
DSÓUJDB EF MBT EJTDVTJPOFT DPOUSPWFSTJBT
Z QSFPDVQBDJPOFT EF VOB CJPÏUJDB RVF
GPSNØTVQSPQJBJEFOUJEBEFOUJFSSBTMB
UJOPBNFSJDBOBT1BSBBMDBO[BSVOBEJGV
TJØONÈTHSBOEFFMQSPZFDUP1FSTQFDUJWBT
EFMB#JPÏUJDB*CFSPBNFSJDBOBGVFQMBOFB
EP QBSB TFS QVCMJDBEP FO USFT JEJPNBT
JOHMÏTFTQB×PMZQPSUVHVÏT
&TUF MJCSP FT SFTVMUBEP EF EPT B×PT EF
USBCBKP JOUFOTP DPOUBDUPT Z EJÈMPHPT
oUFMFGØOJDPTZQPS*OUFSOFUoDPSSFTQPO
EFODJBFTDSJUBPSFVOJPOFTDPOMPTBNJ
HPT EF MB DBVTB EJTQFSTPT QPS "NÏSJDB
-BUJOBFM$BSJCFZMB1FOÓOTVMB*CÏSJDB
0QUBNPT QPS BEPQUBS MB DBUFHPSÓB EF
i*CFSPBNÏSJDBiDPNPFYQSFTJØOHFPHSÈ
1FSTQFDUJWBTEFMB#JPÏUJDBFO*CFSPBNÏSJDB
mDBJODMVTJWBHFOFSBMBKVTUBEBBMSFTVM
UBEP mOBM EF MBT DPOUSJCVDJPOFT EF MPT
QSFDVSTPSFTEFMBCJPÏUJDBFOFTUBTQBSUFT
EFM HMPCP /VFTUSB QFSTQFDUJWB EF CÞT
RVFEBEFCÓBTFSBCJFSUBFJODMVTJWBQBSB
QFSNJUJSMBQBSUJDJQBDJØOEFVOOÞNFSP
NBZPSEFQBÓTFT"VORVFOPUFOFNPTMB
QBSUJDJQBDJØOEFUPEPTMPTEFMBSFHJØO
DPOUSBSJBNFOUFBOVFTUSPEFTFPFOVOB
FEJDJØOTJHVJFOUFQPESFNPTJODMVJSNÈT
QBÓTFTRVFUFOHBOVOBIJTUPSJBCJPÏUJDB
RVFDPNVOJDBS$SFFNPTRVFMBQBSUJDJ
QBDJØOEFEPDFOBDJPOFTFTZBVOMPHSP
ZTF×BMBRVFOVFTUSPPCKFUJWPTFBMDBO[Ø
DBTJ DPNQMFUBNFOUF -PT SFMBUPT BRVÓ
QSFTFOUBEPTFOTVEJWFSTJEBEEFQVOUPT
EFWJTUBPGSFDFOVOBiGPUPHSBGÓBwEFMBT
NÈTFYQSFTJWBTSFBMJ[BDJPOFTZQFSTQFDUJ
WBTGVUVSBTEFMBCJPÏUJDBFOMBSFHJØO
/VFTUSBDPODFQDJØOEFFTUFUSBCBKPOPT
MMFWØ B EJWJEJS FM MJCSP FO USFT HSVQPT
EF DVFTUJPOFT &O VO QSJNFS CMPRVF
EF SFnFYJPOFT QSFTFOUBNPT FM DPOUFYUP
IJTUØSJDP EF MB CJPÏUJDB IJTQBOPBNFSJ
DBOB %JFHP (SBDJB
MPT EJTDVSTPT EF
MBCJPÏUJDBFO"NÏSJDB-BUJOBZMBTSFGF
SFODJBTEFMBCJPÏUJDBFO"SHFOUJOB+PTÏ
"MCFSUP.BJOFUUJZ.BSUB1ÏSF[
MB0S
HBOJ[BDJØO1BOBNFSJDBOBEFMB4BMVEZ
MBCJPÏUJDB'FSOBOEP-PMBT
MBCJPÏUJDB
FO"NÏSJDB-BUJOBZ$PMPNCJB"MGPOTP
-MBOP&TDPCBS
ZmOBMNFOUFVOBIJT
UPSJBQFSTPOBMEFMBCJPÏUJDBFO"NÏSJDB
-BUJOBEFTEFMBQFSTQFDUJWBEFVOCJPFUJ
DJTUBOPSUFBNFSJDBOP+BNFT%SBOF
&O FM TFHVOEP HSVQP IBZ SFnFYJPOFT
EFTEF WPDFT QJPOFSBT EF EJWFSTPT QBÓ
TFT #SBTJM -FP 1FTTJOJ Z $ISJTUJBO EF
PERSPETIVADELABIOETICAINDD
1 EF #BSDIJGPOUBJOF
#PMJWJB +BWJFS
-VOB0SPTDP&EVBSEP
$IJMF.JHVFM
,PUUPX
$VCB+PTÏ3BNØO"DPTUB4B
SJFHP
&TQB×B 'SBODFTD "CFM Z /VSJB
5FSSJCBT
.ÏYJDP$ÏTBS-BSB"MCFSUP
"SFMMBOPZ(FSBSEP+JNÏOF[
3FQÞCMJDB
%PNJOJDBOB.JHVFM4VB[P
1BSBHVBZ
.BSUB"TDVSSB
1FSÞ3PCFSUP-MBOPT
;VMPBHB
Z 1PSUVHBM +PSHF #JTDBJB Z
8BMUFS0TTXBME
&OFMUFSDFSCMPRVFQBSBQSPCBSMBBN
QMJUVEEFMBCJPÏUJDBFOMBSFHJØOJODMVJ
NPTEPTDVFTUJPOFTFTQFDÓmDBTCJPÏUJDB
Z SFMJHJØO FO "NÏSJDB -BUJOB .ÈSDJP
'BCSJEPT"OKPT
ZCJPÏUJDBZNVKFSFTFO
"NÏSJDB-BUJOB%FCPSB%JOJ[Z%JSDF
(VJMIFN
&O MB DPODMVTJØO QSFTFOUB
NPTUSFTUFYUPTRVFIBDFOVOBEJTDVTJØO
QSPTQFDUJWBEFMNPWJNJFOUPCJPÏUJDPMB
JOUFSFTBOUF MFDUVSB DSÓUJDB EF (FSNÈO
$BMEFSØO BDFSDB EF MB CJPÏUJDB MBUJOPB
NFSJDBOB FM BOÈMJTJT EFM USBUBEP QPS
)VCFSU-FQBSHOFVSZMBSFnFYJØOEFMPT
DPPSEJOBEPSFT TPCSF BMHVOPT EFTBGÓPT
QBSBFMGVUVSPEFMBCJPÏUJDBJCFSPBNF
SJDBOB
&TQFSBNPTRVFFTUFUSBCBKPTFBOPTØMP
VOB JOEJDBDJØO CJCMJPHSÈmDB EFM BMDBO
DF TJFNQSF DSFDJFOUF EF MB MJUFSBUVSB
CJPÏUJDB EF OVFTUSPT QBÓTFT TJOP RVF
TF DPOWJFSUB BEFNÈT FO VOB SFGFSFODJB
IJTUØSJDBGVOEBNFOUBMQBSBMPTRVFoFO
FM QSFTFOUF Z FM GVUVSPo JOWFTUJHVFO Z
FTUVEJFO MPT UFNBT SFMBDJPOBEPT DPO
MBIJTUPSJBEFMEFTBSSPMMPEFMBCJPÏUJDB
FO*CFSPBNÏSJDB&OMPTB×PTDPOP
DJNPT BMHVOPT FTGVFS[PT JOJDJBMFT QBSB
VO QBOPSBNB IJTUØSJDP EF MB CJPÏUJDB
*OUSPEVDDJØO
FOFMDPOUFYUPMBUJOPBNFSJDBOP3FDPS
EBNPT FOUSF PUSBT QVCMJDBDJPOFT VOB
FEJDJØOFTQFDJBMEF#PMFUÓOEFMB0mDJOB
4BOJUBSJB 1BOBNFSJDBOB 0SHBOJ[B
DJØO 1BOBNFSJDBOB EF MB 4BMVE 014
FOEPTUFYUPTEFMPTDPPSEJOBEPSFT
QVCMJDBEPT FO MPT QFSJØEJDPT 4BÞEF FN
%FCBUFZ0.VOEPEB4BÞEFFO
ZVOOÞNFSPNPOPHSÈmDPEFM+PVSOBMPG
.FEJDJOFBOE1IJMPTPQIZQVCMJDBEPFO
/BUVSBMNFOUF IB TJEP KVTUP B
QBSUJSEFFTUBÞMUJNBEÏDBEBMBQSJNFSB
EFMTJHMPWFJOUJVOPFOMBDVBMDPOUBNPT
DPOTJHOJmDBUJWPTBWBODFTFOFEVDBDJØO
oDPOMBFTQFDJBMJ[BDJØOZMBTNBFTUSÓBTo
QVCMJDBDJPOFTZMBQSFTFODJBEFDPNJTJP
OFTZDPNJUÏTFONBUFSJBEFJOWFTUJHB
DJØOFOTFSFTIVNBOPTPFOGVODJPOFT
DPOTVMUJWBT TPMJDJUBEBT QPS MPT HPCJFS
OPT 1BSDJBM DPNP FT FM NFSP BDUP EF
EFNPTUSBSMPTOVFWPTBWBODFTCJPÏUJDPT
KVTUJmDBSÓBMBFYJTUFODJBEFVOBQVCMJDB
DJØODPNPÏTUB
/VFTUSPT BHSBEFDJNJFOUPT NÈT TJODF
SPTBMPTDPMBCPSBEPSFTMPTiBNJHPTEF
MB DBVTB CJPÏUJDBw RVJFOFT QFSNJUJFSPO
RVFmOBMNFOUFDPOWJSUJÏSBNPTFOSFB
MJEBEFMTVF×PEFFTUFQSPZFDUPDVMUJWBEP
QPSNVDIPT
-PTDPPSEJOBEPSFT
1")08)0IBQVCMJDBEPVOOÞNFSPFTQF
DJBMTPCSFCJPÏUJDBFOTVCPMFUÓOPmDJBMFO
B×PTBOUFTEFFTUBCMFDFSFM1SPHSBNB3FHJPOBM
EF#JPÏUJDB&MOÞNFSPQSFTFOUBWBSJPTBSUÓDV
MPTUSBEVDJEPTEFBVUPSFTEF&&66$BOBEÈ
Z&VSPQB&O"NÏSJDB-BUJOBIBZEBUPTBDFSDB
EFMEFTBSSPMMPEFMBCJPÏUJDBFO"SHFOUJOB#SB
TJM$PMPNCJB$IJMF.ÏYJDPZ1FSÞEFTEFMB
QFSTQFDUJWBEFMBÏUJDBNÏEJDB
1FTTJOJ-
i0EFTFOWPMWJNFOUPEBCJP
ÏUJDBOB"NÏSJDB-BUJOBw4BÞEFFN%FCBUF
QQ 1FTTJOJ - i0 EFTFOWPMWJ
NFOUPEBCJPÏUJDBOB"NÏSJDB-BUJOBoBMHVNBT
DPOTJEFSBÎÜFTo QBSUF *w 0 .VOEP EB 4BÞEF
QQ 1FTTJOJ - i0 EFTFO
WPMWJNFOUPEBCJPÏUJDBOB"NÏSJDB-BUJOBoBM
HVNBTDPOTJEFSBÎÜFToQBSUF**w0.VOEPEB
4BÞEFQQ
%SBOF+'FE
DzF+PVSOBMPG.FEJDJOF
BOE1IJMPTPQIZ"'PSVNGPS#JPFUIJDTBOE1IJ
MPTPQIZPG.FEJDJOF
PERSPETIVADELABIOETICAINDD
PERSPETIVADELABIOETICAINDD
1ĒģĥĖ*
3FnFYJPOFTEFTEFFMDPOUFYUPJCFSPBNFSJDBOP
PERSPETIVADELABIOETICAINDD
PERSPETIVADELABIOETICAINDD
&MDPOUFYUPIJTUØSJDPEFMBCJPÏUJDB
IJTQBOPBNFSJDBOB
%JFHP(SBDJB
*OUSPEVDDJØO
-
PTQFSÓPEPTIJTUØSJDPTQPSMPTRVFIB
QBTBEPMBTPDJFEBEIJTQBOPBNFSJDB
OBTPODVBOEPNFOPTDVBUSPFMQSJNJ
UJWPFOFMRVFJNQFSØVOUJQPQBSUJDVMBS
EFÏUJDBRVFIFEFOPNJOBEPiÏUJDBEFM
EPOw FM EF MB $PORVJTUB RVF JNQVTP
VOBÏUJDBEFHVFSSBZEFTPNFUJNJFOUP
GPS[BEPRVFMMBNBSÏiÏUJDBEFMEFTQPUJT
NPwFMQFSÓPEPEFMB$PMPOJBDPOVO
NPEFMP ÏUJDP EF OVFWP DPSUF MB iÏUJDB
QBUFSOBMJTUBwZmOBMNFOUFMBiÏUJDBEF
MB BVUPOPNÓBw RVF DPNFO[Ø DPO MPT
NPWJNJFOUPT JOEFQFOEFOUJTUBT EF MPT
TJHMPT97***Z9*9ZRVFBÞOEJTUBEF
FTUBSDPNQMFUP
-BJOEFQFOEFODJBMBMMFWBSPOBDBCPMPT
DSJPMMPTFODPOUSBEFMBEPNJOBDJØOFV
SPQFB DPO NVZ QPDB QBSUJDJQBDJØO EF
MBQPCMBDJØOJOEÓHFOB²TUBRVFEØGVFSB
EFMQSPDFTPEFNPDSÈUJDPZFOVOBTJUVB
DJØOQFPSRVFMBRVFUVWPFOMPTTJHMPT
EFMB$PMPOJBQPSRVFOPTFIBMMBCBZB
QSPUFHJEB QPS FM QBUFSOBMJTNP EF MBT
-FZFT EF *OEJBT EF &MMP QFSNJUF
FOUFOEFSQPSRVÏMBTPDJFEBEMBUJOPBNF
SJDBOBEFMÞMUJNPTJHMPFTUÈEJWJEJEBFO
EPTFTUSBUPTTPDJBMFTNVZEJGFSFODJBEPT
VOPCVSHVÏToRVFIBBTJNJMBEPQFSGFD
PERSPETIVADELABIOETICAINDD
UBNFOUFMBSFWPMVDJØOMJCFSBMRVFUJFOF
VOUJQPEFBTJTUFODJBTBOJUBSJBTJNJMBSBM
EFDVBMRVJFSPUSPQBÓTPDDJEFOUBMZRVF
QPSUBOUPUJFOFMPTNJTNPTQSPCMFNBT
CJPÏUJDPT RVF DVBMRVJFS PUSB TPDJFEBE
PDDJEFOUBM EFTBSSPMMBEBo Z PUSP NVZ
QPCSFoRVFDBSFDFEFQPEFSFDPOØNJDP
ZTPDJBMZRVFQPSFMMPUBNQPDPQVFEF
IBDFSVTPEFTVTEFSFDIPTDJWJMFTDPNP
FMEFSFDIPBMBWJEBZBMBJOUFHSJEBEGÓ
TJDBNVZDFSDFOBEPTQPSMBTEVSBTDPO
EJDJPOFTFOMBTRVFWJWF&OFTUFTFDUPS
EF MB QPCMBDJØO OVNÏSJDBNFOUF NÈT
JNQPSUBOUF MPT QSPCMFNBT CJPÏUJDPT
GVOEBNFOUBMFTTPOMPTSFMBDJPOBEPTDPO
MB KVTUJDJB Z MB EJTUSJCVDJØO EF SFDVSTPT
FTDBTPT&MFTUVEJPEFNPEFMPTDPNPFM
MBUJOPBNFSJDBOP QVFEF TFSWJS QBSB RVF
FTUPT UFNBT IBTUB BIPSB QPDP USBUBEPT
QPSMBCJPÏUJDBEFMPTQBÓTFTEFM1SJNFS
.VOEPBERVJFSBOMBSFMFWBODJBRVFMFT
DPSSFTQPOEF
-BCJPÏUJDBIBTJEPZFTVONPWJNJFO
UP CÈTJDBNFOUF OPSUFBNFSJDBOP 4VT
QMBOUFBNJFOUPT TPO EJGÓDJMNFOUF USBT
QMBOUBCMFT TJO NPEJmDBDJPOFT B PUSPT
QBÓTFT BVO FO FM DBTP EF DPOEJDJPOFT
FDPOØNJDBT TPDJBMFT Z DVMUVSBMFT NVZ
TFNFKBOUFT B MBT OPSUFBNFSJDBOBT
1FSTQFDUJWBTEFMB#JPÏUJDBFO*CFSPBNÏSJDB
DPNPTVDFEFFOFMDBTPEF&VSPQBFO
HFOFSBMZEFMB&VSPQBMBUJOBPNFEJ
UFSSÈOFB FO QBSUJDVMBS %SBOF (SBDJB
-BTEJGFSFODJBT
TPONVDIPNBZPSFTDVBOEPTFUSBUBEF
DVMUVSBT EJTUJOUBT EF MBT PDDJEFOUBMFT
ZBTFBOEFTBSSPMMBEBTDPNPMBKBQPOF
TB #BJ 4IJSBJ *TIJJ P FTUÏO FO WÓBT EF EFTBSSPMMP DPNP
MB DIJOB 3FO;POH 2JV PMBOJHFSJBOB(CBEFHFTJO
%FBIÓMBJNQPSUBODJBEFMPT
FTUVEJPT USBOTDVMUVSBMFT Z EF MB IJTUP
SJBEFMPTQSPQJPTQVFCMPT'VFSBEFFTF
DPOUFYUPOPFTDPNQSFOTJCMFMBÏUJDBEF
VOQVFCMPPEFVOBÏQPDBOJUBNQPDP
TVCJPÏUJDB
&O FTUF USBCBKP NF QSPQPOHP FTUVEJBS
FMDPOUFYUPIJTUØSJDPEFMBCJPÏUJDBMBUJ
OPBNFSJDBOB&MMPFTOFDFTBSJPQPSRVF
DVBOEPNFOPTMBDVMUVSBEFFTUPTQVF
CMPTOPQSPDFEFEFMBUSBEJDJØOBOHMP
TBKPOBTJOPEFMBMBUJOBZNFEJUFSSÈOFB
MP RVF MF DPOmFSF QFDVMJBSJEBEFT NVZ
FTQFDÓmDBT&OMPRVFTJHVFWBNPTBJO
UFOUBSSFDPOTUSVJSCSFWFNFOUFMBIJTUP
SJBEFFTUPTQVFCMPTQBSBMVFHPEFmOJS
MBTDBSBDUFSÓTUJDBTÏUJDBTEFDBEBVOPEF
TVTQFSÓPEPTQSJODJQBMFT
&MQFSÓPEPQSJNJUJWPZMBÏQPDB
EFMEFTDVCSJNJFOUPMBÏUJDBEFM
EPO
-BNBZPSÓBEFMBTDVMUVSBTQSJNJUJWBTFT
EFDJSEJTUJOUBTEFMBPDDJEFOUBM
QBSFDF
IBCFSDPJODJEJEPFOUFOFSVOBDPODFQ
DJØO SFMJHJPTB EFM NVOEP Z EF MB WJEB
-BÓO &OUSBMHP -BT DVMUVSBT
QSFDPMPNCJOBTEFMDPOUJOFOUFBNFSJDB
PERSPETIVADELABIOETICAINDD
OP OP TPO VOB FYDFQDJØO B FTUB SFHMB
"QFTBSEFTVSJRVÓTJNBWBSJFEBEUPEBT
FMMBTDPJODJEFOFOFOUFOEFSMBSFBMJEBE
ZMPTBDPOUFDJNJFOUPTEFMBWJEBDPNP
VODPNQMFKPTJTUFNBEFQPEFSFTVOPT
CVFOPTZNBMPTPUSPTFYQSFTJØOZTÓN
CPMP EF MBT CVFOBT P NBMBT SFMBDJPOFT
EF MPT NPSUBMFT DPO MB EJWJOJEBE Z EF
ÏTUB DPO MPT NPSUBMFT %F BIÓ RVF MPT
GFOØNFOPT OBUVSBMFT Z MPT BDPOUFDJ
NJFOUPT EF MB WJEB BQBSF[DBO TJFNQSF
DPNPiEPOFTwEFMBEJWJOJEBEPDPNP
iEFVEBTwDPOUSBÓEBTDPOFMMB-BEJBMÏ
DUJDBEFMEPOEFVEBFTQBSUJDVMBSNFOUF
DMBSBFOMPTDBTPTEFFOGFSNFEBEMBTB
MVEFTVOEPOEFMBEJWJOJEBETJHOPEF
BHSBEPEJWJOPFOUBOUPMBFOGFSNFEBE
FTVODBTUJHPQPSMPTQFDBEPTDPNFUJEPT
PFMSFTVMUBEPEFMBBDUVBDJØOEFFTQÓSJ
UVT NBMJHOPT &TUF UJQP EF JOUFSQSFUB
DJPOFT QBSFDF DPNÞO B QSÈDUJDBNFOUF
MB UPUBMJEBE EF MBT DVMUVSBT QSFDPMPN
CJOBT(VFSSB
ZEF
ÏM DPOTFSWBNPT UFTUJNPOJPT MJUFSBSJPT
EFBMUPWBMPSFTQFDJBMNFOUFNBZBT3J
WFSB4ÈFO[EF4BOUB
.BSÓB
&TUFUJQPEFJOUFSQSFUBDJØONÓUJDPNÈ
HJDB Z SFMJHJPTB EF MB SFBMJEBE OP EFT
BQBSFDJØDPOMBMMFHBEBEFMPTFTQB×PMFT
B"NÏSJDBFO&OQSJNFSMVHBS
QPSRVFMPTJOEÓHFOBTTJHVJFSPODPOTFS
WBOEP TVT DSFFODJBT TFHVOEP QPSRVF
MPTFTQB×PMFTMMFHBSPOQSPWJTUPTEFVOB
NFOUBMJEBEOPNFOPTQSPWJEFODJBMJTUB
RVF MB EF MPT JOEÓHFOBT BNFSJDBOPT TJ
CJFOMBSFMJHJØORVFQSPGFTBCBOoMBDSJT
UJBOBoFSBDJFSUBNFOUFEJTUJOUBEFUPEBT
MBTFYJTUFOUFTFOFM/VFWP.VOEP
&MDPOUFYUPIJTUØSJDPEFMBCJPÏUJDBIJTQBOPBNFSJDBOB%JFHP(SBDJB
#BTUBMFFSMBTDBSUBTEF$SJTUØCBM$PMØO
BM 3FZ EF &TQB×B $PMØO P MBT
EFWJBKFEF"NÏSJDP7FTQVDJP"NFSJHP
7FTQVDDJ QBSB DPOWFODFSTF EF
RVF JOUFSQSFUBSPO FM EFTDVCSJNJFOUP
DPNPVOiEPOwRVFMBEJWJOJEBEMFIB
CÓBPUPSHBEPBÏMZBMPTSFZFTEF&TQB×B
-PTBDPOUFDJNJFOUPTQPTJUJWPTTJHVJFSPO
WJÏOEPTF DPNP EPOFT Z MPT OFHBUJWPT
DPNPSFWFTFTEFCJEPTBMBEVSF[BEFMPT
DPSB[POFTEFMPTDPORVJTUBEPSFTZTPCSF
UPEP EF MPT JOEÓHFOBT BNFSJDBOPT &M
EFTDVCSJNJFOUP EFM OVFWP DPOUJOFOUF
GVFFODVBMRVJFSDBTPVOEPONBSBWJ
MMPTP&MIFDIPEFRVF$SJTUØCBM$PMØO
MMFHBSBB"NÏSJDBJOFTQFSBEBNFOUFiQPS
DBTVBMJEBEwMFIJ[PTVQPOFSRVFBRVFMMP
FSB VO SFHBMP EFM DJFMP Z RVF BTÓ EFCÓB
JOUFSQSFUBSTF$PNFO[ØVOBJOUFSQSFUB
DJØOSFMJHJPTBZQSPWJEFODJBMJTUBEFMIF
DIPBNFSJDBOPRVFJCBBUFOFSJODBMDV
MBCMFTDPOTFDVFODJBT9JSBV
6OB
QSJNFSB GVF MB NJUJmDBDJØO EFM JOEJP Z
EFMBTPDJFEBEBNFSJDBOBT&OMBTDBSUBT
EF$PMØOFTDPOUJOVBMBSFGFSFODJBBMP
RVF QPEFNPT MMBNBS MB iMFZFOEB CMBO
DBwBNFSJDBOBDPOJOEJPTRVFWJWFOFO
iFTUBEPEFOBUVSBMF[BwTJOMFZFTOJ&TUB
EPZDPOVOBJEFBEJTUJOUBBMBNFEJFWBM
FVSPQFBTPCSFMPRVFFTQPSFKFNQMPMB
NPSBMJEBETFYVBM
)BTUB UBM QVOUP MMFHB FTUF QSPDFTP EF
NJUJmDBDJØO EFM IFDIP BNFSJDBOP RVF
UBOUP$PMØODPNPMPTQSJNFSPTEFTDV
CSJEPSFT FMBCPSBO UPEB VOB iVUPQÓBw
RVFMFTMMFWBBTJUVBSFM1BSBÓTP5FSSFOBM
FOMB[POBTVSEFMDPOUJOFOUFBNFSJDBOP
%JDF$PMØOFOFMSFMBUPEFTVUFSDFSWJB
KFRVFFTUÈFOFMIFNJTGFSJPTVSEFCBKP
PERSPETIVADELABIOETICAINDD
EF MB MÓOFB FRVJOPDDJBM $PMØO &TUFUFNBUVWPHSBOSFQFSDVTJØO
FOMBMJUFSBUVSBNÏEJDBZBRVFFMMVHBS
EFM1BSBÓTP5FSSFOBMEFCÓBTFSQPSEFm
OJDJØOFMNÈTCFMMPZTBMVEBCMFEFUPEPT
MPTFYJTUFOUFT$JTOFSPTTT
&M
NJUPEFM1BSBÓTPZEFMBCPOEBEOBUVSBM
EFMPTRVFBMMÓIBCJUBCBOEJPMVHBSBUPEB
MBMJUFSBUVSBFVSPQFBTPCSFFMiNJUPEFM
CVFO TBMWBKFw IBCJUBOUF EF MP RVF EJP
FOUPODFTFOMMBNBSTFiFTUBEPEFOBUVSB
MF[Bw/PTFSÓBDPNQSFOTJCMFMBEPDUSJOB
QPMÓUJDB NPEFSOB EF )PCCFT Z -PDLF
B 3PVTTFBV Z ,BOU TJO FTUF QSFDFEFO
UF4ØMPEFTEFÏMGVFQPTJCMFFMBCPSBSMB
EJTUJODJØOFOUSFiFTUBEPEFOBUVSBMF[Bw
ZiFTUBEPDJWJMwZQPSUBOUPEFmOJSMBT
DBSBDUFSÓTUJDBTEFMMMBNBEPiDPOUSBUPTP
DJBMw %PVDIFU -BT DPOTFDVFO
DJBTEFFTUPMBTWFSFNPTNÈTBEFMBOUF
&MQSPCMFNBÏUJDPEFMB
DPORVJTUBMBTSB[POFTNPSBMFT
EFMEFTQPUJTNP
1PSNÈTRVFMBTSFMBDJPOFTEFMPTFTQB×P
MFTDPOMPTJOEÓHFOBTDPNFO[BSBOTJFOEP
FYDFMFOUFT OP UBSEBSPO FO EFUFSJPSBSTF
-B DPBDDJØO Z MB GVFS[B TVTUJUVZFSPO
QBVMBUJOBNFOUFBMBMJCFSBMJEBEZMBDP
FYJTUFODJB QBDÓmDB &M GBNPTP TFSNØO
EFGSBZ"OUPOJPEF.POUFTJOPTEFMB×P
FO MB JTMB EF -B &TQB×PMB GVF MB
QSJNFSBEFOVODJBQÞCMJDBEFRVFMBTDP
TBTIBCÓBODBNCJBEP)BOLF
1FSF×BTT
1PDPBQPDPMB
UFTJTEFMCVFOTBMWBKFGVFTVTUJUVJEBQPS
MBEFMNBMTBMWBKFRVFEFCÓBTFSUSBUBEP
DBTJDPNPVOTFSJSSBDJPOBM4FJNQVTP
FMVTPTJTUFNÈUJDPEFMBGVFS[BDPOFMmO
1FSTQFDUJWBTEFMB#JPÏUJDBFO*CFSPBNÏSJDB
EFBUSBFSMPTBMBWFSEBEFSBSFMJHJØOZBM
TFSWJDJP EFM 3FZ EF &TQB×B &TUB BDUJ
UVETFBDSFDFOUØBQBSUJSEFDPO
PDBTJØOEFMBDPORVJTUBEF.ÏYJDPQPS
)FSOÈO $PSUÏT &O MB BSFOHB RVF FTUF
ÞMUJNPIBDFBTVTUSPQBTBOUFTEFFNCBS
DBSQBSBFTFMVHBSOPRVFEBZBOBEBEFMB
BOUFSJPSVUPQÓBEFMJOEJP OBUVSBMNFOUF
CVFOPZNBOTP.VZQPSFMDPOUSBSJP
$PSUÏTWFBMPTJOEJPTDPNPTFSFTQFSWFS
TPTRVFFTQSFDJTPHBOBSBVORVFTFBQPS
MBGVFS[BQBSBMBDJWJMJ[BDJØOZMBNPSBM
DSJTUJBOBT1FSF×B
"MBGBTF
EF DPFYJTUFODJB QBDÓmDB TVDFEF QVFT
MBEFMBDPORVJTUBCÏMJDBZBMBiMFZFO
EBCMBODBwMBiMFZFOEBOFHSBw.PMJOB
&MJOEJPOPFTZBFMiCVFOTBMWB
KFwTJOPVOiQFSSPTVDJPwBMRVFIBZRVF
TPKV[HBSZFTDMBWJ[BS7JWFFOiFTUBEPEF
OBUVSBMF[BwQFSPFTFFTUBEPFTEFCFTUJB
MJEBEFTFMCFMMVNPNOJVNDPOUSBPNOFT
EFɨPNBT)PCCFT
-PT DPORVJTUBEPSFT DPOTJEFSBSÈO RVF
B MPT JOEJPT IBZ RVF TPNFUFSMPT QPS MB
GVFS[BCVTDBOEPFOMBSFMBDJØODPOFMMPT
OP FM CJFO EF MPT JOEJPT TJOP FM EF MPT
DPORVJTUBEPSFTZEF&TQB×B"MBÏUJDB
EFMEPOTVDFEFMBÏUJDBEFMiEFTQPUJTNPw
Z MB iUJSBOÓBw 5PEB MB mMPTPGÓB DMÈTJDB
BDFQUØTJOEJTDVTJØOBMNFOPTEFTEFFM
UJFNQP EF "SJTUØUFMFT RVF FM HPCJFSOP
EFMFTDMBWPEFCFIBDFSTFEFBDVFSEPDPO
MBTDPOWFOJFODJBTEFMBNPOPDPOMBTEFM
FTDMBWP "SJTUØUFMFT C "FTUP"SJTUØUFMFTMPMMBNBiEFTQP
UJTNPwDVBOEPMPSFBMJ[BFMBNPEFVOB
DBTBZiUJSBOÓBwDVBOEPMPIBDFVONP
OBSDB "SJTUØUFMFT B
"N
CPTTFEJGFSFODJBOEJDF"SJTUØUFMFTEFM
PERSPETIVADELABIOETICAINDD
HPCJFSOPEFMPTIJKPTZBRVFFMQBESFOP
CVTDBTVQSPQJPCFOFmDJPDPNPFOMBT
SFMBDJPOFTEFTQØUJDBTZUJSÈOJDBTTJOPFM
CFOFmDJPEFMPTHPCFSOBEPT"SJTUØUFMFT
C
&OFTUPDPOTJTUF
FMQBUFSOBMJTNP
/PIBZEVEBEFRVFBQBSUJSEFMB
ÏUJDBEFMBDPORVJTUBBNFSJDBOBTFIJ[P
DMBSBNFOUF EFTQØUJDB /P TFSÓB DPSSFD
UP EFOPNJOBSMB iUJSÈOJDBw ZB RVF MB
DPSPOB FTQB×PMB JOUFOUØ FWJUBS EFTEF
MBEFHSBEBDJØOEFMJOEJP1FSF×B
QFSPEFTEFMVFHPUBNQPDP
UVWPDBSÈDUFSQBUFSOBMJTUB-BÏUJDBRVF
TFJNQVTPFOFTUPTB×PTGVFDMBSBNFOUF
EFTQØUJDB'SBODJTDPEF7JUPSJBDPOTJEF
SBCBRVFBTÓTFIBCÓBIFDIPMBDPORVJT
UBEF1FSÞ
ZQPSFTPMMBNBCB
EFTQFDUJWBNFOUF B MPT EÏTQPUBT EF MPT
JOEJPT JODBT iQFSVMFSPTw $POUSB FMMPT
MFWBOUØTVTJOWFDUJWBTFOi/PNF
FTQBOUBOOJNFFNCBSB[BOMBTDPTBTRVF
WJFOFOBNJTNBOPTFYDFQUPUSBNQBTEF
CFOFmDJPTZDPTBTEF*OEJBTRVFTFNF
IJFMBMBTBOHSFFOFMDVFSQPFONFOUÈO
EPNFMBTw7JUPSJB
-BDBSUBFTUÈGFDIBEBFMEFOPWJFNCSF
EFZFTUPEBVOBJOWFDUJWBDPOUSB
MPTDPORVJTUBEPSFTEFM1FSÞi%FTUPTEFM
1FSÞUJNFPRVFTFBOEFBRVFMMPTRVJWP
MVOUEJWJUFTmFSJ:QPSBMHVOPTTFEJKP
*NQPTTJCJMFFTUEJWJUFNJOUSBSFJOSFHOVN
DBFMPSVNw7JUPSJB
7JUPSJBEJDFRVFiOPFOUJFOEFMBKVTUJDJB
EFBRVFMMBHVFSSBw7JUPSJB
QVFT iB MP RVF ZP IF FOUFOEJEP EF MPT
NJTNPT RVF FTUVWJFSPO FO MB QSØYJNB
CBUBMMBEF5BCBMJQBOVODB5BCBMJQBOJ
&MDPOUFYUPIJTUØSJDPEFMBCJPÏUJDBIJTQBOPBNFSJDBOB%JFHP(SBDJB
MPT TVZPT IBCÓBO IFDIP OJOHÞO BHSB
WJP B MPT DSJTUJBOPT OJ DPTB QPS EPOEF
MFT EFCJFSBO IBDFS MB HVFSSBw 7JUPSJB
&O TV PQJOJØO iOP IBCÓB
OJOHVOBDBVTBNÈTEFHVFSSBNÈTRVF
QBSBSPCBSMPTw7JUPSJB
i:
DSFP RVF NÈT SVJOFT IBO TJEP MBT PUSBT
DPORVJTUBTEFTQVÏTBDÈw7JUPSJB
&O TVPQJOJØO MPTJOEJPTiQJFO
TBORVFMPTFTQB×PMFTMPTUJSBOJ[BOZMFT
IBDFO HVFSSB JOKVTUBNFOUFw 7JUPSJB
-B UFTJT EF 7JUPSJB FT RVF
iMBHVFSSBNÈYJNFDPOMPTWBTBMMPTIBTF
EFUPNBSZQSPTFHVJSQPSCJFOEFMPTWB
TBMMPTZOPEFMQSÓODJQFw7JUPSJB
-P QSJNFSP TFSÓB iQBUFSOBMJTNPw
ZMPTFHVOEPiUJSBOÓBw7JUPSJBDSFFRVF
MPT QFSVMFSPT FTUÈO BDUVBOEP UJSÈOJDB
NFOUF FO CFOFmDJP QSPQJP Z QPS FTP
MFTSPCBOUPEBTTVTSJRVF[BTi/JTÏQPS
EPOEF QVFEBO SPCBS Z EFTQPKBS B MPT
USJTUFTEFMPTWFODJEPTEFDVBOUPUJFOFO
ZOPUJFOFOw7JUPSJB
i4ØMPIBZVOBNBOFSBEFKVTUJmDBSMBUJ
SBOÓBEFMPTDPORVJTUBEPSFTZFTQFOTBS
RVFMPTJOEJPTOPTPOQFSTPOBTTJOPBOJ
NBMFT NPOBT &O WFSEBE TJ MPT JOEJPT
OP TPO IPNCSFT TJOP NPOBT OPO TVOU
DBQBDFT JOKVSJBF 1FSP TJ TPO IPNCSFT
Z QSØKJNPT FU RVPE JQTF QSBF TF GFSVOU
WBTBMMPT EFM FNQFSBEPS OPO WJEFP RVP
NPEPFYDVTBSBUPEPTDPORVJTUBEPSFTEF
ÞMUJNBJNQJFEBEZUJSBOÓBOJTÏRVFUBO
HSBOEFTFSWJDJPIBHBOBTVNBHFTUBEEF
FDIBSMF B QFSEFS TVT WBTBMMPTw 7JUPSJB
-B BDDJØO EF MPT DPORVJTUBEPSFT FT UBO
JOKVTUJmDBCMFRVF7JUPSJBFTDSJCFi4JZP
PERSPETIVADELABIOETICAINDD
EFTFBTFNVDIPFMBS[PCJTQBEPEF5PMF
EP RVF FTUÈ WBDP Z NF MP IPWJFTFO EF
EBSQPSRVFZPmSNBTFPBmSNBTFMBJOP
DFODJBEFFTUPTQFSVMFSPTTJOEVEBOPMP
PTBSBIBDFS"OUFTTFTFRVFMBMFOHVBZ
MBNBOPRVFZPEJHBOJFTDSJCBDPTBUBO
JOIVNBOB Z GVFSB EF UPEB DSJTUJBOEBE
"MMÈMPIBZBOZEÏKFOOPTFOQB[w7JUP
SJB
&MKVJDJPEF7JUPSJBDPJODJEFDPOFMRVF
FOTVTPCSBTQPMÏNJDBTWFOÓBEFGFOEJFO
EP #BSUPMPNÏ EF -BT $BTBT FTQFDJBM
NFOUFFOMBUJUVMBEBi#SFWÓTJNBSFMBDJØO
EFMBEFTUSVDDJØOEFMBT*OEJBTw
'SFOUFBÏMVOHSBOBSJTUPUÏMJDPZDSPOJT
UBPmDJBMEFM&NQFSBEPS$BSMPT7+VBO
(JOÏTEF4FQÞMWFEBEFGFOEJØFOTVMJ
CSP i%FNPDSBUFT TFDVOEVTw RVF
FMEFTQPUJTNPBNFSJDBOPFSBÏUJDBNFOUF
DPSSFDUP %F MB EJTQVUB EF 7BMMBEPMJE
EPOEF BNCPT TF FOGSFO
UBSPO1BHEFO
TVSHJØBMNFOPT
VOBJEFBDMBSBFMHPCJFSOPEFTQØUJDPEF
MPT JOEJPT EFCÓB DFEFS QBTP B PUSP NÈT
IVNBOP FO RVF GVFSBO USBUBEPT OP
DPNP BOJNBMFT P DPNP FTDMBWPT TJOP
DPNPIJKPT"MEFTQPUJTNPEFMBÏQPDB
EFMBDPORVJTUBJCBBTVDFEFSFMQBUFSOB
MJTNPEFMQFSÓPEPDPMPOJBM
{5VWPDPOTFDVFODJBTFTUBÏUJDBEFMEFT
QPUJTNPQBSBMBWJEBEFMPTJOEJPTBNFSJ
DBOPT 1PSTVQVFTUPRVFTÓ-BTEFOVO
DJBTEF#BSUPMPNÏEF-BT$BTBTTPOVO
CVFOUFTUJNPOJPEFMBTEFTUSVDDJPOFTZ
NVFSUFTRVFFTUBQPMÓUJDBEFHVFSSBQSP
EVKPi&OFTUFUJFNQPZBMPTSFMJHJPTPT
EF4BODUP%PNJOHPIBCÓBODPOTJEFSB
EPMBUSJTUFWJEBZBTQÏSSJNPDBQUJWFSJP
1FSTQFDUJWBTEFMB#JPÏUJDBFO*CFSPBNÏSJDB
RVFMBHFOUFOBUVSBMEFTUBJTMBQBEFDÓBZ
DØNPTFDPOTVNÓBOTJOIBDFSDBTPEFMMP
MPTFTQB×PMFTRVFMPTQPTFÓBONÈTRVFTJ
GVFSBOVOPTBOJNBMFTTJOQSPWFDIPEFT
QVÏT EF NVFSUPT TPMBNFOUF QFTÈOEPMFT
EFRVFTFMFTNVSJFTFOQPSMBGBMUBRVF
FOMBTNJOBTEFPSPZFOMBTPUSBTHSBO
KFSÓBTMFTIBDÓBOOPQPSFTPFOMPTRVF
MFTRVFEBCBOVTBCBOEFNÈTDPNQBTJØO
OJ CMBOEVSB DFSDB EFM SJHPS Z BTQFSF[B
DPO RVF PQSJNJS Z GBUJHBS Z DPOTVNJS
MPTTPMÓBO:FOUPEPFTUPIBCÓBFOUSFMPT
FTQB×PMFT NÈT Z NFOPT QPSRVF VOPT
FSBODSVEFMÓTJNPTTJOQJFEBEOJNJTFSJ
DPSEJBTØMPUFOJFOEPSFTQFDUPBIBDFSTF
SJDPTDPOMBTBOHSFEFBRVFMMPTNÓTFSPT
PUSPTNFOPTDSVFMFTZPUSPTFTEFDSFFS
RVFMFTEFCÓBEPMFSMBNJTFSJBZBOHVTUJB
EFMMPTQFSPUPEPTVOPTZPUSPTMBTBMVE
ZTVTWJEBTZTBMWBDJØOEFMPTUSJTUFTUÈDJ
UBPFYQSFTBNFOUFBTVTJOUFSFTFTTPMPT
QBSUJDVMBSFT Z UFNQPSBMFT QPTQPOÓBOw
-BT$BTBT
-BÏQPDBDPMPOJBMMBÏUJDBEFM
QBUFSOBMJTNP
-B ÏQPDB EF MB DPMPOJB TF BQBSUB UBOUP
EF MB GBTF PQUJNJTUB EFM iCVFO TBMWBKFw
DPNPEFMBQFTJTNJTUBEFMiQFSSPTVDJPw
-BJEFPMPHÓBEFFTUBUFSDFSBGBTFTFSÈJO
UFSNFEJBFMJOEJPFTMJCSFQFSPEFCFTFS
DPOTJEFSBEP DPNP VO NFOPS EF FEBE
DPNPVOOJ×PQFRVF×PRVFOFDFTJUBEF
UVUFMB &TUP TF BEWJFSUF ZB FO MBT -FZFT
EF#VSHPTEF.PMJOB
QFSPBERVJFSFDBSUBEFOBUVSBMF[BFOMBT
-FZFT/VFWBTEF*OEJBTEF$PNP
IB FTDSJUP -VDJBOP 1FSF×B FTUBT MFZFT
TPO MB DPOTFDVFODJB EF MB MBCPS UFØSJDB
PERSPETIVADELABIOETICAINDD
MMFWBEB B DBCP QPS MB &TDVFMB EF 4BMB
NBODBDPO7JUPSJB$PWBSSVCJBT4PUP
Z$BOP1FSF×B
&MQBUFSOBMJTNPFTMBTPMVDJØORVFQSP
QPOF -BT $BTBT FO TVT MJCSPT Z 7JUPSJB
FOMBi3FMFDUJPEF*OEJTwEF7JUPSJB
OPBDFQUBMBUFTJTEFRVFMPTJOEJPTTFBO
QPS OBUVSBMF[B TFSFT JSSBDJPOBMFT 5BN
QPDPBDFQUBMBUFTJTEF"SJTUØUFMFTEFRVF
iIBZ RVJFOFT QPS OBUVSBMF[B TPO FTDMB
WPTw7JUPSJB
"QFTBSEF
RVFFOTVPQJOJØOMPTJOEJPTTFQBSFDFO
NVDIPBMPTBOJNBMFTOPDSFFRVFTFBO
iBNFOUFTPJEJPUBTw
i&O SFBMJEBE OP TPO JEJPUBT TJOP RVF
UJFOFO B TV NPEP VTP EF SB[ØO &T
FWJEFOUFRVFUJFOFODJFSUPPSEFOFOTVT
DPTBTRVFUJFOFODJVEBEFTEFCJEBNFO
UFSFHJEBTNBUSJNPOJPTCJFOEFmOJEPT
NBHJTUSBEPT TF×PSFT MFZFT QSPGFTPSFT
JOEVTUSJBT DPNFSDJP UPEP MP DVBM SF
RVJFSF VTP EF SB[ØO "EFNÈT UJFOFO
UBNCJÏO VOB GPSNB EF SFMJHJØO Z OP
ZFSSBO UBNQPDP FO MBT DPTBT RVF TPO
FWJEFOUFT B PUSPT MP RVF FT JOEJDJP EF
VTP EF SB[ØO %JPT Z MB OBUVSBMF[B OP
MFTBCBOEPOBOFOMPRVFFTJOEJTQFOTB
CMFQBSBMBFTQFDJFZMPQSJODJQBMFOFM
IPNCSFFTMBSB[ØOZFTJOÞUJMMBQPUFO
DJBRVFOPTFSFEVDFBMBDUP"TJNJTNP
IVCJFSBO FTUBEP UBOUPT NJMFT EF B×PT
TJODVMQBTVZBGVFSBEFMFTUBEPEFTBMWB
DJØOQVFTUPRVFIBOOBDJEPFOQFDBEP
Z DBSFDFO EFM CBVUJTNP Z OP UFOESÓBO
VTPEFSB[ØOQBSBJOWFTUJHBSMPOFDFTB
SJP QBSB MB TBMWBDJØO 1PS MP RVF DSFP
RVF FM IFDIP EF RVF OPT QBSF[DBO UBO
JEJPUBT Z SPNPT QSPWJFOF FO TV NBZPS
&MDPOUFYUPIJTUØSJDPEFMBCJPÏUJDBIJTQBOPBNFSJDBOB%JFHP(SBDJB
QBSUF EF TV NBMB Z CÈSCBSB FEVDBDJØO
QVFTUBNCJÏOFOUSFOPTPUSPTWFNPTRVF
NVDIPTIPNCSFTEFMDBNQPCJFOQPDP
TF EJGFSFODJBO EF MPT CSVUPT BOJNBMFTw
7JUPSJB
5SBTFTUP7JUPSJBDPOUFTUBBMBSHVNFOUP
FODPOUSBSJPRVFOFHBCBMBSBDJPOBMJEBE
BMPTJOEJPTBQBSUJSEFMBBVUPSJEBEEF
"SJTUØUFMFT EJDJFOEP RVF MP WFSEBEFSB
NFOUF BDPSEF DPO MB NFOUF EF "SJTUØ
UFMFTFTiRVFIBZFOFMMPTVOBOFDFTJEBE
OBUVSBMEFTFSSFHJEPTZHPCFSOBEPTQPS
PUSPTTJÏOEPMFTNVZQSPWFDIPTPFMFTUBS
TPNFUJEPTBPUSPTDPNPMPTIJKPTOFDF
TJUBO FTUBS TPNFUJEPT B MPT QBESFT Z MB
NVKFSBMNBSJEPw7JUPSJBDG
"SJTUØUFMFTBC
"RVÓTFWF
DMBSPDØNPMBTPMVDJØOEF7JUPSJBFTMB
QBUFSOBMJTUB
7JUPSJBOPEFKBEFUFOFSEVEBTTPCSFFTUF
QVOUP ²TUBT MF MMFWBO B DPOTJEFSBS FTF
BSHVNFOUPDPNPNFSBNFOUFQSPCBCMF
QFSPQPSFMMPNJTNPWÈMJEPQBSBEJSJHJS
MB DPOEVDUB QSÈDUJDB OP IBZ RVF PMWJ
EBSRVFMBFTDVFMBTBMNBOUJOBRVFQBSUF
EF7JUPSJBGVFMBDSFBEPSBEFMBEPDUSJOB
NPSBM EFM QSPCBCJMJTNP
)F BRVÓ VO
UFYUPCBTUBOUFTJHOJmDBUJWP
i)BZPUSPUÓUVMPRVFOPQPESÓBBmSNBS
TFDPOTFHVSJEBEQFSPTÓEJTDVUJSTFZRVF
QBSFDFMFHÓUJNPQBSBBMHVOPT:POPNF
BUSFWPBEBSMPQPSCVFOPOJBDPOEFOBS
MPFOBCTPMVUP&TUFUÓUVMPFTÏTUFFTPT
CÈSCBSPTBVORVFDPNPTFIBEJDIPOP
TFBOEFMUPEPJODBQBDFTEJTUBOTJOFN
CBSHPUBOQPDPEFMPTSFUSBTBEPTNFO
UBMFT RVF QBSFDF OP TPO JEØOFPT QBSB
DPOTUJUVJS Z BENJOJTUSBS VOB SFQÞCMJDB
PERSPETIVADELABIOETICAINDD
MFHÓUJNB EFOUSP EF MÓNJUFT IVNBOPT Z
QPMÓUJDPT 1PS MP DVBM OP UJFOFO MFZFT
BEFDVBEBTOJNBHJTUSBEPTZOJTJRVJFSB
TPOTVmDJFOUFNFOUFDBQBDFTQBSBHPCFS
OBSMBGBNJMJB)BTUBDBSFDFOEFDJFODJBT
Z BSUFT OP TØMP MJCFSBMFT TJOP UBNCJÏO
NFDÈOJDBT Z EF VOB BHSJDVMUVSB EJMJ
HFOUF EF BSUFTBOPT Z EF PUSBT NVDIBT
DPNPEJEBEFT RVF TPO IBTUB OFDFTBSJBT
QBSBMBWJEBIVNBOB
1PESÓBFOUPODFTEFDJSTFRVFQBSBVUJMJ
EBEEFUPEPTFMMPTQVFEFOMPTSFZFTEF
&TQB×BFODBSHBSTFEFMBBENJOJTUSBDJØO
ZHPCJFSOPEFBRVFMMPTCÈSCBSPTOPN
CSBSMFT NJOJTUSPT Z HPCFSOBEPSFT QBSB
TVTQVFCMPTZBVOEBSMFTOVFWPTQSÓO
DJQFTNJFOUSBTDPOTUBTFRVFFSBDPOWF
OJFOUFQBSBTVCJFOFTUBS
4FSÓB EJGÓDJM DPOWFODFSTF EF UPEP FTUP
QPSRVF TJ UPEPT GVFSPO JODBQBDFT OP
IBZ EVEB EF RVF OP TØMP TFSÓB MÓDJUP Z
NVZ DPOWFOJFOUF TJOP RVF IBTUB MPT
QSÓODJQFT FTUBSÓBO PCMJHBEPT B IBDFSMP
MPNJTNPRVFTJGVFSBOEFMUPEPOJ×PT
:QBSFDFRVFIBZMBNJTNBSB[ØOQBSB
FTPTCÈSCBSPTRVFQBSBMPTBNFOUFTQPS
RVFOBEBPQPDPNÈTQVFEFOIBDFSQBSB
HPCFSOBSTF RVF MPT EFmDJFOUFT NFOUB
MFT : TPO DBTJ DPNP MBT NJTNBT mFSBT
Z CFTUJBT QVFT OP VTBO BMJNFOUPT NÈT
FMBCPSBEPTOJBQFOBTNFKPSFTRVFFMMBT
-VFHPEFMBNJTNBNBOFSBQPESÓBOTFS
DPOmBEPT B MB UVUFMB EF IPNCSFT NÈT
JOUFMJHFOUFT
: TF DPOmSNB FTUB UFTJT DPO DJFSUB WF
SPTJNJMJUVE 1PSRVF TJ QPS VO BDBTP
QFSFDJFSBOUPEPTMPTBEVMUPTEFBRVFMMBT
SFHJPOFTZRVFEBSBOÞOJDBNFOUFMPTOJ
1FSTQFDUJWBTEFMB#JPÏUJDBFO*CFSPBNÏSJDB
×PTZMPTBEPMFTDFOUFTRVFUJFOFOBMHÞO
VTPEFSB[ØOQFSPEFOUSPUPEBWÓBEFMPT
B×PT EF MB JOGBODJB Z QVCFSUBE QBSFDF
DMBSPRVFQPEÓBOMPTQSÓODJQFTUPNBSMPT
CBKP TV UVUFMB Z HPCFSOBSMPT NJFOUSBT
FTUVWJFSBOFOTFNFKBOUFFTUBEP4JFTUP
TF BENJUF QBSFDF DJFSUP RVF OP TF IB
EF OFHBS RVF QVFEB IBDFSTF MP NJTNP
DPOMPTQBESFTEFMPTCÈSCBSPTTVQVFTUB
MBJODBQBDJEBENFOUBMRVFMFTBUSJCVZFO
MPTRVFIBOFTUBEPBMMÓMBDVBMEJDFORVF
FTNVDIPNBZPSRVFMBRVFUJFOFOMPT
OJ×PTBEPMFTDFOUFTFOPUSBTOBDJPOFT
:BMBWFSEBERVFIBTUBQPESÓBGVOEBS
TF FTUB DPOEVDUB FO FM QSFDFQUP EF MB
DBSJEBE QVFTUP RVF FMMPT TPO OVFTUSPT
QSØKJNPTZFTUBNPTPCMJHBEPTBQSPDV
SBSTVCJFO-PBDFQUPDPNPEJKF
TJO
BmSNBSMP BCTPMVUBNFOUF Z BVO DPO MB
DPOEJDJØOEFRVFTFIBHBQPSFMCJFOZ
VUJMJEBEEFMPTNJTNPTZOPDPNPQSF
UFYUPEFMMVDSPEFMPTFTQB×PMFT2VFFO
FTUPFTUÈUPEPFMQFMJHSPQBSBMBTBMNBT
Z TV TBMWBDJØO FUFSOB 5BNCJÏO QBSB
FTUBBSHVNFOUBDJØOQVFEFWBMFSMPRVF
TFEJKPBOUFTEFRVFBMHVOPTTPOTJFSWPT
QPS OBUVSBMF[B : UBMFT QBSFDFO TFS FT
UPTCÈSCBSPTRVFFOQBSUFQPESÓBOQPS
FTUBSB[ØOTFSHPCFSOBEPTDPNPTJFSWPTw
7JUPSJB
"QBSUJSEFFTUPTUFYUPTQVFEFFOUFOEFS
TF NVZ CJFO MB NFOUBMJEBE EF 7JUPSJB
Z MB EF MBT -FZFT EF *OEJBT -PT JOEJPT
TPO IPNCSFT OP BOJNBMFT Z QPS UBO
UP NFSFDFO OVFTUSP SFTQFUP QFSP TPO
IPNCSFT CÈSCBSPT B MPT RVF IBZ RVF
QSPUFHFS DPNP B IJKPT NVZ QFRVF×PT
7JUPSJB QSPQPOF BDUVBS DPO FMMPT EF
PERSPETIVADELABIOETICAINDD
NBOFSB QBUFSOBMJTUB Z FWJUBS MB UJSBOÓB
1PS FTP DMBNB DPOUSB MPT EFTNBOFT EF
MPTDPORVJTUBEPSFTZFOVOBDBSUBBM1
"SDPTEJDFiOPOWJEFPRVPNPEPFYDVTBS
BFTUPTDPORVJTUBEPSFTEFÞMUJNBJNQJF
EBEZUJSBOÓBw7JUPSJB
+PTÏ EF "DPTUB FT PUSP EF MPT HSBOEFT
UFØSJDPT EFM QSPUFDUPSBEP QBUFSOBMJTUB
EF MPT JOEJPT &O TV PCSB i%F 1SPDV
SBOEB *OEPSVN 4BMVUFw EFmOF
B MPT JOEJPT DPNP iCÈSCBSPTw Z BmSNB
RVFiTFHÞOMBEFmOJDJØOEFQSFTUJHJPTPT
BVUPSFT CÈSCBSPT TPO BRVFMMPT RVF TF
BQBSUBOEFMBSFDUBSB[ØOZEFMBQSÈDUJ
DBIBCJUVBMEFMPTIPNCSFTRVJBSFDUB
SBUJPOFFUIPNJOVNDPNNVOJDPOTVFUV
EJOFBCIPSSFOU
1PSFTPTVFMFOEFTUBDBS
MPTFTDSJUPSFTNÈTJMVTUSFTMBJODBQBDJEBE
EF MPT CÈSCBSPT TV mFSF[B JODMVTP TVT
UÏDOJDBTZUSBCBKPTTJHOJmDBOEPMPMFKPT
RVFFTUÈOEFMBQSÈDUJDBVTVBMEFMPTEF
NÈT IPNCSFT Z MP QPDP RVF UJFOFO EF
TBCJEVSÓBZBDUJWJEBESBDJPOBMw"DPTUB
&TUB FT MB UFTJT RVF QSFTJEF UPEB MB DP
MPOJ[BDJØOFTQB×PMBRVFMPTJOEJPTTPO
CÈSCBSPTFOFTUFTFOUJEPQPSFTPUJFOFO
GVFS[B DPSQPSBM QFSP OP WJHPS SBDJPOBM
ZFTQJSJUVBMZOFDFTJUBOQPSOBUVSBMF[B
UVUFMB 4PO DPNP MPT BSUFTBOPT EF i-B
3FQÞCMJDBwEF1MBUØOFOUBOUPRVFMPT
FTQB×PMFT TPO MPT HVBSEJBOFT Z MPT HP
CFSOBOUFT
+PTÏEF"DPTUBEJTUJOHVFUSFTOJWFMFTEF
CBSCBSJFEFNFOPSBNBZPS-BNFOPS
FTMBQSPQJBEFMBT*OEJBT0SJFOUBMFT-PT
QVFCMPTEFMBT*OEJBT0DDJEFOUBMFTFTUÈO
&MDPOUFYUPIJTUØSJDPEFMBCJPÏUJDBIJTQBOPBNFSJDBOB%JFHP(SBDJB
FOMPTOJWFMFTTFHVOEPZUFSDFSP&OFM
TFHVOEPFTUÈOMPTNFKJDBOPTZMPTQFSVB
OPTFOFMUFSDFSPDBTJUPEPTMPTEFNÈT
QVFCMPT BNFSJDBOPT : B×BEF +PTÏ EF
"DPTUB
i" UPEPT FTUPT IPNCSFT P NFEJPIPN
CSFTFTQSFDJTPEBSMFTJOTUSVDDJØOIVNB
OB QBSB RVF BQSFOEBO B TFS IPNCSFT
FEVDBSMPTDPNPBOJ×PT:TJDPOIBMB
HPT TF EFKBO FTQPOUÈOFBNFOUF QSPNP
DJPOBSUBOUPNFKPSEFOPTFSBTÓOPTF
MFTIBEFEFKBSBTVTVFSUFTJTFSFTJTUFO
DPOUFSRVFEBEBTVQSPQJBSFHFOFSBDJØO
Z EFTWBSÓBO DPOUSB TVT QSPQJPT NBFT
USPT Z NÏEJDPT IBZ RVF PCMJHBSMFT QPS
MBGVFS[BZIBDFSMFTBMHVOBDPOWFOJFOUF
QSFTJØOQBSBRVFOPQPOHBOPCTUÈDVMPT
BM&WBOHFMJPZIBZRVFIBDFSMFTDVNQMJS
TVT PCMJHBDJPOFT Z DPOWFOESÈ IBDFSMFT
GVFS[BQBSBRVFTFUSBTMBEFOEFMBTFMWB
B MB DPOWJWFODJB IVNBOB EF MB DJVEBE
ZFOUSFOBVORVFTFBVOQPDPBSFHB×B
EJFOUFTFOFMSFJOPEFMPTDJFMPTw"DPT
UB
+PTÏEF"DPTUBOPEVEBFOBQMJDBSBMPT
JOEJPT BNFSJDBOPT MBT EVSBT QBMBCSBT
EFM -JCSP EF MB 4BCJEVSÓB B QSPQØTJUP
EF MPT $BOBOFPT i" TBCJFOEBT EF RVF
FSBOEFNBMBDFQBEFNBMJDJBDPOHÏOJ
UBZRVFTVNBOFSBEFTFSOPDBNCJBSÓB
OVODB&SBOSB[BNBMEJUBEFTEFTVPSJ
HFOw4BQ
:"DPTUBB×BEF
i)BZQPSDPOTJHVJFOUFTVKFUPTRVFFT
UÈOBGFDUBEPTEFVOBNBMJDJBDPOHÏOJUB
Z IFSFEJUBSJB QPS BTÓ EFDJS TV NPEP
EFQFOTBSFTUÈUBOQFSUJOB[ZQFSWFSTB
NFOUF BSSBJHBEP RVF DBTJ FT JNQPTJCMF
FYUJSQBSMP
&TUBFTQVFTMBQSJNFSB
PERSPETIVADELABIOETICAINDD
ZQSJODJQBMDBVTBQPSMBRVFFOFTUBTSF
HJPOFTTFIBEFFTQFSBSUBOQPDPGSVUP
EFUBOUPFTGVFS[PTPOSB[BNBMEJUBDBTJ
QSJWBEB EF MPT BVYJMJPT EJWJOPT Z EFT
UJOBEB B MB QFSEJDJØOw "DPTUB -PT UFYUPT TF QPESÓBO NVMUJQMJDBS
TJOOJOHÞOFTGVFS[P"DPTUB
$POFTUBTZPUSBTNVDIÓTJNBTGSBTFTTJ
NJMBSFT +PTÏ EF "DPTUB OP FTUÈ KVTUJm
DBOEP MB UJSBOÓB EF MPT DPORVJTUBEPSFT
.VZBMDPOUSBSJPMPRVF"DPTUBQSPQP
OF FT FM QBUFSOBMJTNP QPS FTP FTDSJCF
BDUPTFHVJEP
i5SBJHPBDPMBDJØOUPEPFTUPOPQPSRVF
EÏ NJ BQSPCBDJØO FO NPEP BMHVOP BM
QPEFSUJSÈOJDPZBMBDSVFMEBEUBOBKF
OBTBMBTFOTF×BO[BTEF$SJTUP
RVFTFIB
VTBEP DPO MPT QVFCMPT EF MPT JOEJPT P
QPSRVFQJFOTFRVFTFMPTIBEFNBOEBS
DPNPBTJFSWPTPQPSRVFOPBCPSSF[DBZ
DPOEFOFDPOUPEBFOFSHÓBMPTDSÓNFOFT
EFMPTNBMWBEPTZMBBWBSJDJBEFMPTRVF
DPOWJFSUFOMPTCJFOFTUSBCBKPTZTVEPSFT
EF FTUPT NJTFSBCMFT FYDMVTJWBNFOUF FO
TVQSPQJPQSPWFDIPBCVTBOEPEFMBNB
OFSBNÈTJOJDVBEFTVUPSQF[Bw"DPTUB
&TUBFTMBNFOUBMJEBEDPOMBRVFMPTFT
QB×PMFT JOUFOUBO HPCFSOBS MBT DPMPOJBT
BNFSJDBOBT EFTEF BQSPYJNBEB
NFOUFIBTUBMBÏQPDBEFMBJOEFQFOEFO
DJB-PTJOEJPTGVFSPOQSPUFHJEPTDPNP
OJ×PTOPDPNPFTDMBWPTMPRVFFTUBCB
QSPIJCJEPQPSMBT-FZFTEF*OEJBT
&TUP
OPRVJFSFEFDJSRVFOPIVCJFSBFTDMBWPT
FMUSÈmDPEFOFHSPTBGSJDBOPTB"NÏSJDB
1FSTQFDUJWBTEFMB#JPÏUJDBFO*CFSPBNÏSJDB
TF SFBMJ[Ø QSFDJTBNFOUF QBSB RVF FMMPT
MMFWBSBO B DBCP MBT UBSFBT NÈT QFTBEBT
²TUPT OP FTUBCBO DPOUFNQMBEPT FO MB
-FZFT EF *OEJBT Z QPS UBOUP B FMMPT TÓ
QPEÓB USBUÈSTFMFT DPNP B FTDMBWPTDPO
GPSNFBMBMFHJTMBDJØONFEJFWBMRVF"M
GPOTP 9 SFDPQJMØ FO MBT i1BSUJEBTw %F
FTUF NPEP MB TPDJFEBE DPMPOJBM RVFEØ
FTUSBUJmDBEBFOVOBVUÏOUJDPTJTUFNBEF
DBTUBTFOFMDVBMMPTFTQB×PMFTPDVQBCBO
FMOJWFMTVQFSJPSMVFHPWFOÓBOMPTFTQB
×PMFTBNFSJDBOPTPDSJPMMPTEFTQVÏTMPT
NFTUJ[PTNF[DMBEFFVSPQFPTFJOEJPT
NÈT BCBKP FTUBCBO NVMBUPT NF[DMB EF
FVSPQFPT Z BGSJDBOPT
FO VO OJWFM JO
GFSJPS MPT [BNCPT NF[DMB EF JOEJPT Z
BGSJDBOPT
NÈTBCBKPMPTJOEJPTZFOÞM
UJNPMVHBSMPTOFHSPTFTDMBWPT$PNPFT
FWJEFOUFFMQBUFSOBMJTNPOPMMFHØBFTUF
ÞMUJNPOJWFM
&OFMPSEFOEFMBNFEJDJOBFTUBEJWJTJØO
FODBTUBTUVWPDPOTFDVFODJBTQPTJUJWBTZ
OFHBUJWBT6OFGFDUPQPTJUJWPGVFMBQSP
IJCJDJØOUBKBOUFQPSQBSUFEFMBT-FZFT
/VFWBTEFEFUSBCBKPTJOIVNBOPT
ZEFHSBEBOUFT4FQSPIJCJØRVFMPTJOEJPT
MMFWBTFOQFSTPOBMNFOUFDBSHBTDPOTØMP
MBTFYDFQDJPOFTJNQVFTUBTQPSMBGBMUBEF
BOJNBMFT P DBNJOPT Z TJFNQSF DPNP
GBFOBTWPMVOUBSJBTZNPEFSBEBTZOVO
DBGPS[BEBTZTJONFOPTDBCPEFMBTBMVE
EFMBWJEBZEFMBDPOTFSWBDJØOEFMPTJO
EJPTZQBHÈOEPMFTFOUPEPDBTPQPSTV
USBCBKPRVFEFCFTFSBDFQUBEPQPSFMMPT
WPMVOUBSJBZMJCSFNFOUF1FSF×B
4FQSPIJCJFSPOUBNCJÏOMPTNBMPT
USBUPTZBCVTPTDBTUJHBOEPTFWFSBNFOUF
BMPTRVFNBUBSBOPIJSJFSBOBDVBMRVJFS
JOEJP -B DPOTFDVFODJB OFHBUJWB GVF FM
PERSPETIVADELABIOETICAINDD
QBUFSOBMJTNP NÈT BDFOESBEP &M CJFO
EFMJOEJPWFOÓBEFmOJEPQPSFMFTQB×PM
PQPSFMDSJPMMPOPQPSFMJOEJPNJTNP
"M mOBM TF BDBCBCB IBDJFOEP MP RVF FM
FTQB×PM Z FM DSJPMMP DPOTJEFSBCBO CJFO
EFMJOEJPRVFFOMBNBZPSÓBEFMPTDBTPT
OPFSBPUSBDPTBRVFFMQSPQJPCJFOEFM
FTQB×PMZEFMDSJPMMP
-FKPTEFSFTPMWFSMPTQSPCMFNBTFYJTUFO
UFTMBUFTJTEFMBJOGFSJPSJEBEOBUVSBMEFM
JOEJPZEFMBOFDFTJEBEEFTVUVUFMBOP
IJ[PTJOPJODSFNFOUBSMPT&TUPFTFWJEFO
UFFOFMDBNQPEFMBBTJTUFODJBTBOJUBSJB
7JÏOEPTF NFOPTQSFDJBEP Z SFDIB[BEP
QPSMBTPDJFEBEEFMPTCMBODPTZDSJPMMPT
FMJOEJPTFSFGVHJØFOTVTUSBEJDJPOFTZ
SFUPSOØ B MB NFEJDJOB DSFFODJBM EF TVT
BOUFQBTBEPT-BNFEJDJOBPDDJEFOUBMOP
MFTMMFHØBUSBWÏTEFMPTNÏEJDPTPEFMPT
DJSVKBOPTTJOPBUSBWÏTEFMPTNJTJPOFSPT
RVFDPNPNFEJPEFFWBOHFMJ[BDJØOSFB
MJ[BSPOVOBJNQPSUBOUFMBCPSGVOEBOEP
IPTQJUBMFTZFEVDBOEPTBOJUBSJBNFOUFB
MBQPCMBDJØO
&ODPODMVTJØOQPEFNPTEFDJSRVFEV
SBOUFMPTTJHMPTEFMBDPMPOJBBMJOEJPTF
MF DPODFEJFSPO VOPT DJFSUPT EFSFDIPT
DJWJMFT oFM EFSFDIP B MB WJEB Z B MB JO
UFHSJEBE GÓTJDBo QFSP ÏTUPT OVODB TF
DPOWJSUJFSPO FO EFSFDIPT QPMÓUJDPT SB
[ØOQPSMBDVBMWJWJFSPOFOVOQSPGVO
EP FTUBEP EF NBSHJOBDJØO TPDJBM &TUP
MFTMMFWØBSFQMFHBSTFZFODFSSBSTFFOTVT
BOUJHVBTUSBEJDJPOFTNPUJWPQPSFMRVF
MB BTJTUFODJB TBOJUBSJB RVFEØ SFEVDJEB
FOHSBONFEJEBBTVTBOUJHVBTQSÈDUJ
DBTDSFFODJBMFTZBMBBTJTUFODJBPDDJEFO
UBMSFDJCJEBOPEFNÏEJDPTZDJSVKBOPT
&MDPOUFYUPIJTUØSJDPEFMBCJPÏUJDBIJTQBOPBNFSJDBOB%JFHP(SBDJB
TJOPEFNJTJPOFSPT&MQBUFSOBMJTNPEF
MBÏQPDBEFMBDPMPOJBQSPUFHJØTVWJEB
QFSPBMBWF[MPTTFHSFHØTPDJBMNFOUF
FWJUBOEPTVQSPNPDJØOZIBDJFOEPRVF
OPQVEJFSBOSFDJCJSMPTCFOFmDJPTEFMB
NFEJDJOBPDDJEFOUBM
-PT FVSPQFPT SFTJEFOUFT FO "NÏSJDB
Z MPT DSJPMMPT QPS PUSB QBSUF TF CFOF
mDJBSPO EF MBT QSÈDUJDBT NÏEJDBT PDDJ
EFOUBMFT RVF MPT FTQB×PMFT MMFWBSPO B
"NÏSJDB &M TJHMP 97* GVF EF VO HSBO
FTQMFOEPSFOMBNFEJDJOBFTQB×PMBRVF
SFQFSDVUJØ DMBSBNFOUF FO MB BNFSJDBOB
(VFSSB 4F GVOEBSPO GB
DVMUBEFTEFNFEJDJOBFOMBTQSJODJQBMFT
VOJWFSTJEBEFT .ÏYJDP -JNB
(VBUFNBMB2VJUP
#PHPUÈ-B)BCBOB$BSB
DBT
EFMBTRVFTBMJFSPONÏEJDPT
GPSNBEPTDPOMPTFTUÈOEBSFTFVSPQFPT
"EFNÈTFODPOMBQSPNVMHBDJØO
EFMBT-FZFT/VFWBTEF*OEJBTFMFKFS
DJDJP NÏEJDP QBTØ B FTUBS DPOUSPMBEP
QPSFM5SJCVOBMEFM1SPUPNFEJDBUPRVF
DPNFO[ØTVBDUJWJEBEFO4FJOJ
DJØBTÓVOQSPDFTPEFnPSFDJNJFOUPEF
MBNFEJDJOBIJTQBOPBNFSJDBOBRVFGVF
JODSFNFOUÈOEPTFJOJOUFSSVNQJEBNFOUF
IBTUBmOBMFTEFMTJHMP97***
%FFTUFNPEPFOMBTPDJFEBEJOEJBOB
TF FTUBCMFDJFSPO WBSJPT UJQPT EJTUJOUPT
EF BTJTUFODJB TBOJUBSJB SFMBDJPOBEPT
DPOFMTJTUFNBEFDBTUBTEFMBTPDJFEBE
-PT NÏEJDPT HSBEVBEPT FO VOJWFSTJ
EBEFTBUFOEÓBOMBTBMVEEFMFTUSBUPTV
QFSJPS EF MB TPDJFEBE DPNQVFTUP QPS
OPCMFTZHPCFSOBOUFTWFOJEPTEF&TQB
PERSPETIVADELABIOETICAINDD
×BZQPSDSJPMMPTQPTFFEPSFTEFMQPEFS
FDPOØNJDP -PT DJSVKBOPT Z CBSCFSPT
DVJEBCBO EF NFTUJ[PT Z NVMBUPT RVF
BEFNÈT VUJMJ[BCBO MPT SFDVSTPT EF MB
NFEJDJOB QPQVMBS 6O TFDUPS EF JOEÓ
HFOBTTFCFOFmDJØEFMBNFEJDJOBPDDJ
EFOUBMJNQBSUJEBQPSMPTNJTJPOFSPTFM
SFTUPMBNBZPSÓBFSBOBUFOEJEPQPSMPT
QSPQJPTNÏEJDPTJOEÓHFOBT'JOBMNFO
UF MPT FTDMBWPT OFHSPT FSBO BUFOEJEPT
DPOQSPDFEJNJFOUPTQSPQJPTEFMBNF
EJDJOB QPQVMBS BGSJDBOB 5PEPT FTUPT
UJQPT EF NFEJDJOB FYDFQUP FM ÞMUJNP
GVFSPO QBUFSOBMJTUBT QFSP EF EJGFSFOUF
NPEP-BNFEJDJOBFVSPQFBDPOTJEFSB
CBBMFOGFSNPDPNPNFOPSEFFEBEP
DPNPJOWÈMJEPNPSBMZQPSUBOUPJO
DBQBDJUBEP QBSB EFDJEJS MBT DVFTUJPOFT
SFMBDJPOBEBTDPOTVQSPQJPDVFSQP&M
DBTPEFMJOEJPFSBBMHPEJTUJOUPQVFTB
ÏMTFMFDPOTJEFSBCBNFOPSEFFEBEBVO
FO FTUBEP EF TBMVE SB[ØO QPS MB DVBM
FMQBUFSOBMJTNPTFFYUFOEÓBBUPEBTMBT
EJNFOTJPOFTEFTVWJEB5BNCJÏODBCF
EFDJSRVFFMJOEJPFSBWJTUPZUSBUBEPFO
UPEPTMPTDBTPTZTJOFYDFQDJØODPNP
VOFOGFSNP&OFMCMBODPZFMDSJPMMPFM
QBUFSOBMJTNPFSBVOBFYDFQDJØORVFTF
FKFSDÓBTØMPFODBTPEFFOGFSNFEBEFO
FM NFTUJ[P Z TPCSF UPEP FO FM JOEJP FM
QBUFSOBMJTNPFSBMBSFHMBRVFBGFDUBCB
BUPEPTMPTBTQFDUPTEFTVWJEB-BSB[B
FSBWJTUBZUSBUBEBDPNPVOBFOGFSNF
EBE&TUPGVFQBSUJDVMBSNFOUFDMBSPFO
FMDBTPEFMOFHSPFOFMRVFMBSB[BZFM
DPMPS EF MB QJFM MF DPOEFOBSPO B BMHP
QFPS RVF FM QBUFSOBMJTNP BM EFTQPUJT
NPZMBUJSBOÓB
1FSTQFDUJWBTEFMB#JPÏUJDBFO*CFSPBNÏSJDB
-BÏQPDBEFMBJOEFQFOEFODJB
MBTWJDJTJUVEFTEFMBÏUJDBEFMB
BVUPOPNÓBFO"NÏSJDB-BUJOB
%VSBOUF MPT TJHMPT EF MB DPMPOJB MB TP
DJFEBEBNFSJDBOBFTUVWPDPNQVFTUBQPS
WBSJPT FTUSBUPT VOP TVQFSJPS DPNQVFT
UP QPS MPT HPCFSOBOUFT FVSPQFPT PUSP
NFEJP NBZPSJUBSJBNFOUF GPSNBEP QPS
DSJPMMPT Z PUSP JOGFSJPS GPSNBEP QPS
JOEÓHFOBT$POFMUJFNQPTFWJPRVFMPT
EPTQSJNFSPTUFOÓBOJOUFSFTFTDMBSBNFOUF
DPOUSBQVFTUPTZBRVFFMCJFOEFMBDPSP
OB oRVF SFQSFTFOUBCBO MPT HPCFSOBOUFT
FVSPQFPToZFMEFMPTDPMPOPTOPUFOÓBO
QPSRVÏDPJODJEJS&TPFYQMJDBRVFFOFM
TJHMP97***DPNFO[BSBOMBTMVDIBTJOUFT
UJOBTQPSFMQPEFSQPMÓUJDPEFMBTDPMPOJBT
-BPDBTJØOMBCSJOEØMBJOWBTJØOGSBODFTB
EF&TQB×BZMBQSJTJØOEFMNPOBSDBFTQB
×PM'FSOBOEP7**FO&O"NÏSJDB
TFPSHBOJ[BSPOKVOUBTMPDBMFTZWJSSFJOB
MFTRVFUPNBSPOFMNBOEPQPMÓUJDPEFMBT
DJVEBEFT Z UFSSJUPSJPT DPMPOJBMFT &TUBT
KVOUBTFTUBCBOEJSJHJEBTQPSDSJPMMPTRVF
EFFTUBNBOFSBTFIJDJFSPODPOFMQPEFS
FGFDUJWPEFMBTDPMPOJBTFODPOUSBEFMBT
BVUPSJEBEFTFTQB×PMBT&TUFQSPDFTPRVF
UVWP MVHBS FOUSF TF DPOTP
MJEØ B×PT EFTQVÏT FOUSF Z FOGPSNBEFBVUPSJEBEQPMÓUJDBBVUØOP
NB JOEFQFOEJFOUF EF MB DPSPOB FTQB
×PMB &O FTUP JOnVZFSPO MB EFDMBSBDJØO
EF JOEFQFOEFODJB OPSUFBNFSJDBOB EF
MB3FWPMVDJØO'SBODFTBEF
Z FO HFOFSBM FM DMJNB JOUFMFDUVBM EF MB
*MVTUSBDJØO GSBODFTB -PT HSBOEFT SFWP
MVDJPOBSJPT IJTQBOPBNFSJDBOPT "OUP
OJP/BSJ×P'SBODJTDP.JSBOEB4JNØO
#PMÓWBSFOUSFPUSPT
FSBOQSPEVDUPEFMB
PERSPETIVADELABIOETICAINDD
CVSHVFTÓBDSJPMMBSJDBZDVMUBRVFIBCÓB
FTUVEJBEPFO&VSPQBZDPOPDÓBMBJEFPMP
HÓBMJCFSBMZMBJNQPSUBODJBRVFQBSBVOB
QPMÓUJDBEFNPDSÈUJDBUFOÓBMBOVFWBEPD
USJOBEFMPTEFSFDIPTIVNBOPT/BSJ×P
USBEVKPFJNQSJNJØFO#PHPUÈ
MB
%FDMBSBDJØOEFMPT%FSFDIPTEFM)PN
CSF RVF IBCÓB QSPNVMHBEP QPDP BOUFT
MB "TBNCMFB $POTUJUVZFOUF GSBODFTB FO
&TJOUFSFTBOUFSFTBMUBSRVFDPNP
UBNCJÏOTVDFEJØFO&TQB×BoEPOEFMBT
$PSUFT RVF QSPDMBNBSPO FO MB
QSJNFSB$POTUJUVDJØOMJCFSBMFTUVWJFSPO
DPNQVFTUBT FO VO BMUP QPSDFOUBKF QPS
NÏEJDPTo MPT QSPDFTPT EF JOEFQFOEFO
DJB EF MBT OVFWBT OBDJPOFT BNFSJDBOBT
FTUVWJFSPO MJEFSBEPT FO NFEJEB NVZ
FMFWBEB UBNCJÏO QPS NÏEJDPT (VFSSB
/PFOWBOPMBNFEJDJOB
FSBVOBEFMBTQSPGFTJPOFTNÈTFTUJNBEBT
QPSMBOVFWBCVSHVFTÓBDSJPMMB
-BTDPOTUJUVDJPOFTEFMPTOVFWPTQBÓTFT
BNFSJDBOPTTFFMBCPSBSPOTJHVJFOEPMPT
NPEFMPT OPSUFBNFSJDBOP GSBO
DÏT
ZFTQB×PM
&TUPRVJF
SFEFDJSRVFQBSUJFSPOEFMBBmSNBDJØO
EFMBTPCFSBOÓBQPQVMBSZEFMSFDPOPDJ
NJFOUPEFVOPTEFSFDIPTJOOBUPTFJO
BMJFOBCMFT FO UPEPT MPT TFSFT IVNBOPT
MPTMMBNBEPTEFSFDIPTDJWJMFTZQPMÓUJDPT
'SFOUF BM WJFKP NPEFMP EFM &TUBEP QB
UFSOBMJTUBFMOVFWPBmSNBCBRVFUPEPT
MPT TFSFT IVNBOPT TPO BEVMUPT Z BVUØ
OPNPT FT EFDJS TVKFUPT EF EFSFDIPT
RVFOBEJFQVFEFWJPMBS4ÈODIF["HFTUB
%FFTUFNPEPFMMVHBSRVFFOFM
WJFKP NPEFMP PDVQØ FM QBUFSOBMJTNP MP
PDVQBBIPSBMBJEFBEFBVUPOPNÓB5P
EPTMPTDJVEBEBOPTJODMVJEPTMPTJOEJPT
&MDPOUFYUPIJTUØSJDPEFMBCJPÏUJDBIJTQBOPBNFSJDBOB%JFHP(SBDJB
FSBODPOTJEFSBEPTBVUØOPNPTZEFCÓBO
TFS USBUBEPT DPNP JHVBMFT FO FM OVFWP
&TUBEPEFNPDSÈUJDP
4JCJFOEFTEFVOQVOUPEFWJTUBGPSNBM
FTUP DPOTUJUVZØ VO JOEJTDVUJCMF BWBODF
FOPUSPTBTQFDUPTQSPWPDØVODMBSPSFUSP
DFTP&OMPTIFDIPTFMJOEJPOPHBOØFO
QSFTUJHJPPFOOJWFMTPDJBMFOFTUBOVFWB
GBTFTJOPRVFTJHVJØFTUBOEPDPNQMFUB
NFOUFNBSHJOBEPEFOUSPEFMBEJOÈNJ
DB TPDJBM EF FTUPT QVFCMPT .ÈT BÞO BM
OPFTUBSZBQSPUFHJEPQPSMBTFTUSVDUVSBT
EFM WJFKP &TUBEP QBUFSOBMJTUB TF FODPO
USØ DPNQMFUBNFOUF JOEFGFOTP GSFOUF B
MPTJOUFSFTFTFDPOØNJDPTZTPDJBMFTEFMB
CVSHVFTÓBDSJPMMB"TÓTFFYQMJDBOMBTHVF
SSBTEFQFSTFDVDJØOEFJOEJPTRVFTFFN
QSFOEJFSPO FO EJWFSTPT QBÓTFT IJTQBOP
BNFSJDBOPTFOMBTFHVOEBNJUBEEFMTJHMP
9*9ZRVFFOBMHVOPTDBTPTDPOEVKFSPO
QSÈDUJDBNFOUFBTVFYUFSNJOJP
-B SFWPMVDJØO QFSNJUJØ B MB CVSHVFTÓB
DSJPMMBPSHBOJ[BSTFTFHÞOOVFWPTQBUSP
OFT EF DPOEVDUB NVZ TJNJMBSFT B MPT
FVSPQFPT Z OPSUFBNFSJDBOPT " QBSUJS
EFMBJOEFQFOEFODJBEFMBTDPMPOJBTFT
QB×PMBTFOFGFDUPDBEBWF[TFIJ[PNÈT
FWJEFOUFVOBFTUSVDUVSBTPDJBMEFDBSÈD
UFS DMBSBNFOUF CJQPMBS FO MPT OVFWPT
QBÓTFT BNFSJDBOPT DPO VOB CVSHVFTÓB
EF VTPT Z DPTUVNCSFT FVSPQFPT Z QSJ
NFSNVOEJTUBTZVOBBNQMJBDMBTFNF
OFTUFSPTBNVZBUFOJEBBMBTUSBEJDJPOFT
JOEJBTZOFHSBTZEFDBSBDUFSÓTUJDBTDMB
SBNFOUFUFSDFSNVOEJTUBT
&TUF UJQP EF FTUSVDUVSB TPDJBM UVWP JN
QPSUBOUFTDPOTFDVFODJBTTBOJUBSJBT%FT
EFMBÏQPDBEFMBJOEFQFOEFODJBMBTDMB
PERSPETIVADELABIOETICAINDD
TFTCVSHVFTBTEJTGSVUBSPOEFVOBTBOJEBE
NVZTJNJMBSBMBPDDJEFOUBMFOUBOUPRVF
MBBUFODJØOTBOJUBSJBEFMBTDMBTFTNFOFT
UFSPTBTGVFNVZEFmDJFOUF&OMPTQBÓTFT
MBUJOPBNFSJDBOPT TF DVNQMJØ FM QSJODJ
QJPEFRVFFMFKFSDJDJPEFEFSFDIPTDJWJ
MFTZQPMÓUJDPTFTJNQPTJCMFDVBOEPOPWB
BDPNQB×BEPQPSFMEFEFSFDIPTFDPOØ
NJDPTTPDJBMFTZDVMUVSBMFT6OEFSFDIP
DJWJMZQPMÓUJDPFTFMEFSFDIPBMBWJEBZB
MBJOUFHSJEBEGÓTJDB/PIBZEVEBEFRVF
MBTQFSTPOBTCJFOTJUVBEBTFDPOØNJDBZ
TPDJBMNFOUFQVFEFOHFTUJPOBSFTFEFSF
DIPTJOBZVEBEFM&TUBEP1FSPRVJFOFT
TF FODVFOUSBO FO TJUVBDJPOFT FDPOØNJ
DBTZTPDJBMFTNVZEFmDJFOUFTOPQVFEFO
IBDFSVTPEFTVTEFSFDIPTFDPOØNJDPT
TPDJBMFTZDVMUVSBMFTFOUSFMPTRVFFTUÈFM
EFSFDIPBMBBTJTUFODJBTBOJUBSJB%JDIP
EFPUSBNBOFSBFOFTUPTDBTPTMPTEFSF
DIPTDJWJMFTZQPMÓUJDPTZFODPODSFUPFM
EFSFDIP B MB BVUPOPNÓB TF RVFEBO FO
EFSFDIPTNFSBNFOUFGPSNBMFTQFSPOP
SFBMFT4VFKFSDJDJPSFBMFYJHFVOBTDPO
EJDJPOFTCÈTJDBTRVFEFTEJDIBEBNFOUF
BÞOOPTFEBOFOBNQMJPTTFDUPSFTEFMB
TPDJFEBEMBUJOPBNFSJDBOB
-B DBSBDUFSÓTUJDB UÓQJDB EF MPT TJTUFNBT
TBOJUBSJPT QSPQJPT EF MPT QBÓTFT FO WÓBT
EFEFTBSSPMMPFTRVFFOMBTHSBOEFTDJV
EBEFT IBZ DFOUSPT TBOJUBSJPT NVZ CJFO
FRVJQBEPT FO MPT DVBMFT TF BUJFOEF BM
TFDUPS EF QPCMBDJØO RVF QVFEF QBHBS
FTPT TFSWJDJPT QFSP FM SFTUP UJFOF VOB
BTJTUFODJB NÏEJDB NVZ QSFDBSJB 1PS
UBOUP MPT QSPCMFNBT CJPÏUJDPT NÈT
JNQPSUBOUFT BMMÓ TPO MPT SFMBDJPOBEPT
DPO MB KVTUJDJB Z MB EJTUSJCVDJØO EF SF
DVSTPT FTDBTPT " NVDIPT TFDUPSFT EF
1FSTQFDUJWBTEFMB#JPÏUJDBFO*CFSPBNÏSJDB
MB QPCMBDJØO OP MFT IB MMFHBEP BÞO MB
BMUBUFDOPMPHÓBTBOJUBSJBOJUBNQPDPFM
NPWJNJFOUP EF BVUPOPNJ[BDJØO EF MPT
FOGFSNPT1PSUBOUPFTUBTDVFTUJPOFTOP
TPOBMMÓQSJPSJUBSJBTBVORVFTÓTFEBOFO
MPTTFDUPSFTBEJOFSBEPTRVFBDVEFOBMPT
DFOUSPTEFBMUBUFDOPMPHÓBEFMBTHSBOEFT
DJVEBEFT&OMPTQBÓTFTFOWÓBTEFEFTB
SSPMMP MB TPDJFEBE FTUÈ EJWJEJEB FO EPT
HSVQPTNVZBMFKBEPTFMVOPEFMPUSPMB
CVSHVFTÓBBDBVEBMBEBZMBHSBONBTBEF
MBQPCMBDJØOFTUPIBDFRVFFYJTUBOEPT
TBOJEBEFTDPNQMFUBNFOUFEJTUJOUBTVOB
EFMBTDVBMFTUJFOFMPTQSPCMFNBTQSPQJPT
EFMBTBOJEBEPDDJEFOUBMFOUBOUPMBPUSB
OP(SBDJB
&TVOIFDIPDBSBDUFSÓTUJDPEFMPTQBÓTFT
FOWÓBTEFEFTBSSPMMPoDPODSFUBNFOUFEF
NVDIPT QBÓTFT MBUJOPBNFSJDBOPT DPNP
$IJMF $PTUB 3JDB 1BOBNÈ 7FOF[VF
MB P .ÏYJDPo RVF TJ CJFO MB TFHVSJEBE
TPDJBM DVCSF MB BTJTUFODJB TBOJUBSJB EF
HSBOQBSUFEFMBQPCMBDJØOFTBBTJTUFO
DJBUJFOFVODBSÈDUFSGVOEBNFOUBMNFOUF
UFSDJBSJPZDPFYJTUFDPOVOBNVZQPCSF
BTJTUFODJB QSJNBSJB DBSBDUFSJ[BEB QPS
MB EFTOVUSJDJØO MB GBMUB EF TFSWJDJPT EF
BHVBQPUBCMFZBMDBOUBSJMMBEPMBGBMUBEF
FEVDBDJØO Z DVMUVSB EFmDJFOUF IJHJFOF
QFSTPOBMEFTFNQMFPZNBSHJOBMJTNP
&TUPQFSNJUFFOUFOEFSQPSRVÏMPTQSP
CMFNBTCJPÏUJDPTZMBTFOTJCJMJEBECJPÏUJ
DBEFMBTPDJFEBEMBUJOPBNFSJDBOBBDUVBM
TPONVZEJTUJOUPTTFHÞOFMOJWFMRVFTF
BOBMJDF-BTDMBTFTCVSHVFTBTSFDJCFOVOB
BTJTUFODJBNÏEJDBEFUJQPPDDJEFOUBMTJ
NJMBSBMBEFMPTPUSPTQBÓTFTEFM1SJNFS
.VOEPZTFQMBOUFBOMPTNJTNPTQSP
PERSPETIVADELABIOETICAINDD
CMFNBTNPSBMFTRVFIPZQSFPDVQBOBMMÓ
BVUPOPNÓB EF MPT QBDJFOUFT DPOTFOUJ
NJFOUPJOGPSNBEPSFDIB[PEFMQBUFSOB
MJTNPQSPCMFNBTEFSFQSPEVDDJØOBTJT
UJEBEJBHOØTUJDPQSFOBUBMUSBTQMBOUFTEF
ØSHBOPTFOUSFPUSPT"OBMJ[BEBMBCJPÏUJ
DBMBUJOPBNFSJDBOBFOFTUFOJWFMQPESÓB
EFDJSTFRVFFTTJNJMBSBMBRVFTFSFBMJ[B
FODVBMRVJFSPUSPMVHBSEFMNVOEP
1FSP TJ TF FOGPDBO MPT QSPCMFNBT EF MB
CJPÏUJDB EFTEF MB QFSTQFDUJWB EF MBT QFS
TPOBT NFOFTUFSPTBT RVF FO FTUPT QBÓTFT
TPOMBNBZPSÓBEFMBQPCMBDJØOFOUPODFT
TFBEWJFSUFRVFFOTVNBZPSÓBDBSFDFOEF
TFOUJEP&MQSPCMFNBEFMDPOTFOUJNJFOUP
JOGPSNBEP EFKB EF TFS SFMFWBOUF DVBOEP
TFWJWFFOTJUVBDJØOEFHSBOQFOVSJBZTF
UJFOFDPNPQSPCMFNBQSJNBSJPZDPUJEJB
OPFMEFMBBMJNFOUBDJØOZIBTUBFMEFMB
TVCTJTUFODJB"FTUFNFEJPTPDJBMOPMMFHB
MBNFEJDJOBEFUFSDFSOJWFMRVFFTMBRVF
IBQSPWPDBEPFMEFTBSSPMMPEFMBCJPÏUJDB
FO MPT QBÓTFT EFM 1SJNFS .VOEP Z BE
RVJFSF UPEB TV JNQPSUBODJB MB NFEJDJOB
EFQSJNFSOJWFM"RVÓMPTQSPCMFNBTQSJP
SJUBSJPTOPUJFOFORVFWFSDPOFMQSJODJQJP
ÏUJDPEFBVUPOPNÓBTJOPDPOMPTQSJODJ
QJPTEFKVTUJDJBZOPNBMFmDFODJB
)BTUB BIPSB FTUPT QSPCMFNBT OP IBO
TJEPPCKFUPEFVOHSBOEFTBSSPMMPFOMB
CJPÏUJDBEFMBTÞMUJNBTEÏDBEBT.JPQJ
OJØOFTRVFFMDPOUBDUPDPOMBSFBMJEBE
MBUJOPBNFSJDBOB QVFEF TFS VOB NBHOÓ
mDB PDBTJØO QBSB GPNFOUBS TV FTUVEJP
/P QPEFNPT PMWJEBS RVF FTUPT TPO MPT
QSPCMFNBTRVFBGFDUBOBM5FSDFS.VOEP
RVFIPZQPSIPZFTMBNBZPSQBSUFEF
MBIVNBOJEBE
&MDPOUFYUPIJTUØSJDPEFMBCJPÏUJDBIJTQBOPBNFSJDBOB%JFHP(SBDJB
3FGFSFODJBT
"DPTUB + %F 1SPDVSBOEB *OEPSVN 4BMVUF .BESJE $POTFKP 4VQFSJPS EF
*OWFTUJHBDJPOFT$JFOUÓGJDBT
"SJTUØUFMFT
1PMÓUJDB.BESJE*OTUJUVUPEF&TUVEJPT1PMÓUJDPT
#BJ,4IJSBJ:BOE*TIJJ.
*O+BQBO$POTFOTVT)BT-JNJUT)BTUJOHT$FOUFS
3FQPSU
+VOFQQ
$JTOFSPT%
4JUJP/BUVSBMF[BZ1SPQJFEBEFTEFMB$JVEBEEF.ÏYJDP.ÏYJDP
+PBO#MBODPEF"MDÈ[BS
$PMØO$
5FYUPTZEPDVNFOUPTDPNQMFUPT3FMBDJPOFTEFWJBKFTDBSUBTZNFNPSJBMFT
.BESJE"MJBO[B&EJUPSJBM
%PVDIFU.
"OUISPQPMPHJFFUIJTUPJSFBVTJÒDMFEFTMVNJÒSFT1BSJT.BTQFSP
%SBOF+'
#FDPNJOHB(PPE%PDUPS5IF1MBDFPG7JSUVFBOE$IBSBDUFSJO.FEJDBM
&UIJDT,BOTBT$JUZ4IFFUBOE8BSE
(CBEFHFTJO4
#JPFUIJDT"O"GSJDBO1FSTQFDUJWF#JPFUIJDT
+VMFQQ
(SBDJB % * QSPCMFNJ FUJDJ EFMMB .FEJDJOB OFMMBSFB MJOHVJTUJDB TQBHOPMB *O
7JBGPSB $ FE 7FOUBOOJ EJ #JPFUJDB 1BEPWB 'POEB[JPOF -BO[B(SFHPSJBOB
-JCSFSJB&EJUSJDF
(SBDJB%
5IF*OUFMMFDUVBM#BTJTPG#JPFUIJDTJO4PVUIFSO&VSPQFBO$PVOUSJFT
#JPFUIJDT
"QSJMQQ
(VFSSB'
5IF1SFDPMVNCJBN.JOE-POEPO4FNJOBS1SFTT
(VFSSB'
.FEJDJOBDPMPOJBMFO)JTQBOPBNÏSJDB&O-BÓO&OUSBMHP1EJS
)JTUPSJB6OJWFSTBMEFMB.FEJDJOB7PM*7#BSDFMPOB4BMWBU
(VFSSB'
&MNÏEJDPQPMÓUJDP.BESJE"GSPEJTJP"HVBEP
(VFSSB'
-BNFEJDJOBQSFDPMPNCJOB.BESJE&EJDJPOFTEF$VMUVSB)JTQÈOJDB
)BOLF-
-BMVDIBQPSMBKVTUJDJBFOMBDPORVJTUBEF"NÏSJDB.BESJE*TUNP
-BÓO&OUSBMHP1
&OGFSNFEBEZQFDBEP#BSDFMPOB5PSBZ
-BT$BTBT#
)JTUPSJBEFMBT*OEJBT.BESJE3JWBEFOFZSB
.PMJOB.
-BMFZFOEBOFHSB.BESJE/FSFB
1BHEFO"
5IF'BMMPG/BUVSBM.BO5IF"NFSJDBO*OEJBOBOEUIF0SJHJOTPG
$PNQBSBUJWF&UIOPMPHZ$BNCSJEHF$BNCSJEHF6OJWFSTJUZ1SFTT
1FSF×B-
-BJEFBEFKVTUJDJBFOMBDPORVJTUBEF"NÏSJDB.BESJE.BQGSF
2JV3;
8IBUIBT#JPFUIJDTUPPGGFSUIF%FWFMPQJOH$PVOUSJFT#JPFUIJDT
"QSJMQQ
PERSPETIVADELABIOETICAINDD
1FSTQFDUJWBTEFMB#JPÏUJDBFO*CFSPBNÏSJDB
3JWFSB.FE
$IJMBN#BMBNEF$IVNBZFM.BESJE)JTUPSJB
4ÈFO[EF4BOUB.BSÓB$FE
1PQPM7VI.BESJE)JTUPSJB
4ÈODIF["HFTUB-
-BEFNPDSBDJBFO)JTQBOPBNÏSJDB.BESJE3JBMQ
7FTQVDDJ"
$BSUBTEF7JBKF.BESJE"MJBO[B
7JUPSJB ' 3FMFDUJP EF JOEJBT .BESJE $POTFKP 4VQFSJPS EF *OWFTUJHBDJPOFT
$JFOUÓGJDBT
9JSBV3FE
*EFBZRVFSFMMBEFMB/VFWB&TQB×B.BESJE"MJBO[B
PERSPETIVADELABIOETICAINDD
-PTEJTDVSTPTEFMBCJPÏUJDBFO"NÏSJDB-BUJOB
+PTÏ"MCFSUP.BJOFUUJZ.BSUB-VDÓB1ÏSF[
*OUSPEVDDJØO
-
BCJPÏUJDBOBDJØFO&TUBEPT6OJEPT
Z DPO FM UJFNQP GVF BEPQUBEB Z
BEBQUBEB
QPS PUSPT QBÓTFT FOUSF FMMMPT
MPT EF "NÏSJDB -BUJOB &TUB ÞMUJNB TF
IBEFTBSSPMMBEPEVSBOUFUSFJOUBB×PTFO
USFTFUBQBTDVCSJFOEPEÏDBEBTDPNFO
[BOEPFOMPTB×PT
SFDFQDJØOBTJNJ
MBDJØOZSFDSFBDJØO$PNPQJPOFSPEFM
QSPDFTP QPS FM DVBM MB CJPÏUJDB GVF JOT
UJUVDJPOBMJ[BEB FO "SHFOUJOB OP QVFEP
FWJUBSVOBDJFSUBSFGFSFODJBBNJQSPQJB
FYQFSJFODJBDPNPEFQPOFOUF.BJOFUUJ
.BJOFUUJ .BJOFUUJ .BJOFUUJ KVTUJmDBEB QPS FM DP
NFOUBSJP EF VO CJPFUJDJTUB BNFSJDBOP
CJFODPOPDJEPiJEFOUJmDBSFMPSJHFOEF
MB CJPÏUJDB FO &&66 FT VOB DVFTUJØO
EFDJFSUBDPOUSPWFSTJBDPOTJEFSBCMF1FSP
MBIJTUPSJBMBUJOPBNFSJDBOBEFMBCJPÏUJDB
FT B VO HSBOEFHSBEP MB IJTUPSJBEFVO
IPNCSFw%SBOF
3FDFQDJØOEFMBCJPÏUJDBFOMB
EÏDBEBEF
&MUÏSNJOPiSFDFQDJØOwOPTFEFCFFO
UFOEFS DPNP JOUSPEVDDJØO GPSNBM EF
MB EJTDJQMJOB oQVFTUP RVF FO MPT B×PT
MB QBMBCSB OP FSB DPNÞO JODMVTP
PERSPETIVADELABIOETICAINDD
FO &&66o TJOP FO UBOUP SFGFSFODJB
BDØNPMBTJUVBDJØODVMUVSBMFIJTUØSJDB
FOMBSFHJØOQPTJCJMJUØPJNQJEJØTVJOJ
DJP-PTB×PTTFDBSBDUFSJ[BSPOQPSMB
SFBDDJØOEFSFTJTUFODJBPSFDIB[PBFTUF
OVFWPNPWJNJFOUPQPSQBSUFEFRVJFOFT
BEIFSÓBOBVOFUIPTDÓWJDPZQSPGFTJPOBM
USBEJDJPOBM $PNP NPSBMJEBE MJCFSBM Z
TFDVMBSMBCJPÏUJDBQSPNPWÓBMBBVUPOP
NÓBEFMQBDJFOUFJOUSPEVDJFOEPMBJEFB
EFÏTUFDPNPTVKFUPNPSBMFONFEJDJOB
ZBDFOUVBOEPTVQBQFMDPNPBHFOUFSB
DJPOBM Z MJCSF FODBSHBEP EF EFDJTJPOFT
DFOUSBMFTFOMBSFMBDJØOUFSBQÏVUJDB&T
UBTJEFBTFSBOFYUSB×BTBMBBOUJHVBÏUJDB
NÏEJDBUPEBWÓBSFJOBOUFFO"NÏSJDB-B
UJOBRVFTFHVÓBTJFOEPDPOGFTJPOBMoEF
BDVFSEPDPOMBEPDUSJOBZMBBVUPSJEBE
NPSBMFTEFMDBUPMJDJTNPSPNBOPoZQB
UFSOBMJTUB -PT NÏEJDPT QSBDUJDBCBO TF
HÞOFMiQBQFMEFEPNJOBDJØOwEFMRVF
IBCMB.BY8FCFSFOFMDVBMMBBVUPSJ
EBEEFMNÏEJDPFTTVQSFNBZFTPCMJHB
DJØOEFMQBDJFOUFTPNFUFSTFBFMMB.BD
LMJOZ-VOB
*OJDJBMNFOUF MB CJPÏUJDB GVF QFSDJCJEB
DPNP iQSPEVDJEB FO MPT &&66w FT
EFDJSVOBDFSDBNJFOUPBMBNFEJDJOBZ
BMPTDVJEBEPTNÏEJDPTEFFTUJMPOPSUF
1FSTQFDUJWBTEFMB#JPÏUJDBFO*CFSPBNÏSJDB
BNFSJDBOP &TUBT JEFBT QPS PUSB QBSUF
EFCÓBOFODPOUSBSSFTJTUFODJBQPSRVFMBT
BDUJUVEFT NBSYJTUBT BOUJBNFSJDBOBT TF
IBCÓBO BUSJODIFSBEP FO -BUJOPBNÏSJDB
-B CJPÏUJDB OP TF QPESÓB USBTQMBOUBS B
FTUFDPOUFYUPTJODPOTJEFSBSEJGFSFODJBT
DVMUVSBMFTZQPMÓUJDBTZQPSMPUBOUPTV
TJHOJmDBEPEFCÓBDBNCJBSFOFTBTTPDJF
EBEFTQBSUJDVMBSFT
"SHFOUJOB GVF QJPOFSB FO FTUF QSPDFTP
EFSFDFQDJØO&MQSJNFS1SPHSBNB*CF
SPBNFSJDBOPEF#JPÏUJDBGVFFTUBCMFDJEP
FOFM*OTUJUVUPEF)VNBOJEBEFT.ÏEJ
DBTEFMB'VOEBDJØO+PTÏ.BSÓB.BJOFUUJ
&O FM %S +PTÏ "MCFSUP
.BJOFUUJGVOEØFMJOTUJUVUPZEFTFNQF×Ø
VOQBQFMJNQPSUBOUFFOMBTBDUJWJEBEFT
UFNQSBOBT FO MB SFHJØO .ÈT BEFMBOUF
TF EFTBSSPMMBSPO QSPHSBNBT FEVDBUJWPT
FO MB &TDVFMB -BUJOPBNFSJDBOB EF #JP
ÏUJDB CBKP MB EJSFDDJØO EF +VBO $BSMPT
5FBMEJ%VSBOUFNVDIPTB×PTFSVEJUPT
EF&&66IBOQBSUJDJQBEPFOFTUFQSP
ZFDUP&MDFOUSPIBQVCMJDBEPMBSFWJTUB
2VJSØOEFTEF ZQSPEVDJEPWBSJBT
NPOPHSBGÓBTTPCSFÏUJDBNÏEJDB'JHVF
SPBZ'VFO[BMJEB
&TUF JOTUJUVUP GPNFOUØ FTUVEJPT CJPÏUJ
DPT MBUJOPBNFSJDBOPTCBKP MB JOnVFODJB
EFMBFTDVFMBFTQB×PMBEFIJTUPSJBEFMB
NFEJDJOB DPOEVDJEB QPS 1FESP -BÓO
&OUSBMHP &TUF FOGPRVF QSPQPOF VOB
UFPSÓBEFMBNFEJDJOBCBTBEBFOMBBOUSP
QPMPHÓBNÏEJDBmMPTØmDBJOTQJSBEBQPS
MB mMPTPGÓB FYJTUFODJBM Z IFSNFOÏVUJDB
FVSPQFB%JDIPNPWJNJFOUPJOUFMFDUVBM
DSFØ DPOEJDJPOFT GBWPSBCMFT QBSB MB SF
DFQDJØO EFM NPWJNJFOUP NÏEJDP OPS
PERSPETIVADELABIOETICAINDD
UFBNFSJDBOP EF MBT IVNBOJEBEFT FO MB
CJPÏUJDBMBUJOPBNFSJDBOB
-BQSJNFSBEÏDBEBEFM*OTUJUVUPEF)V
NBOJEBEFT.ÏEJDBTSFHJTUSBMBSFDFQDJØO
EFFTUBTEJTDJQMJOBTFTUJNVMBEBFOQBSUF
QPS FM WÓODVMP QFSTPOBM F JOTUJUVDJPOBM
JOJDJBEP QPS FM NÏEJDP Z mMØTPGP )
5SJTUSBN&OHFMIBSEU+SFOUPODFTFOFM
*OTUJUVUP EF )VNBOJEBEFT .ÏEJDBT EF
MB6OJWFSTJEBEEFM5FYBTFO(BMWFTUPO
*OTUJUVUFGPS.FEJDBM)VNBOJUJFTPGUIF
6OJWFSTJUZ PG 5FYBT .FEJDBM #SBODI
Z
FMCJPFUJDJTUBNÏEJDP&ENVOE1FMMFHSJ
OPEJSFDUPSEFMJOnVZFOUF*OTUJUVUPEF
7BMPSFT )VNBOPT FO .FEJDJOB *OTUJ
UVUF PG )VNBO 7BMVFT JO .FEJDJOF
EF
8BTIJOHUPO%$&TBDPOFYJØODPOMBT
IVNBOJEBEFT NÏEJDBT FYQMJDB QPS RVÏ
"SHFOUJOBZ&TQB×BGVFSPOMPTQSJNFSPT
QBÓTFTRVFJOJDJBSPOMBCJPÏUJDBFO"NÏ
SJDB-BUJOBZ&VSPQBSFTQFDUJWBNFOUF
&M NPWJNJFOUP EF MBT IVNBOJEBEFT
NÏEJDBT FTUBCB FO DPOTPOBODJB DPO MB
BOUSPQPMPHÓBNÏEJDBEF-BÓO&OUSBMHP
BDVZBFTDVFMBEFQFOTBNJFOUPTFBTPDJB
SPOBMHVOPTFTUVEJPTPTMBUJOPBNFSJDBOPT
&TDPCBS
-BSFDFQDJØO
EFMBCJPÏUJDBDPNPQBSUFEFMBQFSTQFD
UJWBUFØSJDBEFMBTIVNBOJEBEFTNÏEJDBT
TJHOJmDØQPSMPUBOUPVOBBDUJUVEDSÓ
UJDBQPSRVFEFTBmØTVQPTJDJPOFTZKVJ
DJPTEFWBMPSPDVMUPT%VSBOUFMPTB×PT
MBiNFEJDJOBQPTNPEFSOBwFNFSHJØ
DPNP DSÓUJDB EFM SB[POBNJFOUP NÏEJDP
QPTJUJWJTUB UFOÓB MBSHP BMDBODF MFKBOP Z
BGFDUBCBBMPCKFUPNÏUPEPZNFUBEFMB
QSPQJBNFEJDJOB&TEFDJSMBNFEJDJOB
ZB OP FSB VOB iDJFODJB OPSNBMw FO FM
-PTEJTDVSTPTEFMBCJPÏUJDBFO"NÏSJDB-BUJOB+PTÏ"MCFSUP.BJOFUUJZ.BSUB-VDÓB1ÏSF[
TFOUJEP EF ,VIO TJOP RVF QBTBCB QPS
VOBSFWPMVDJØONPSBM4VSHJØFOUPODFT
DJFSUB MJUFSBUVSB DSÓUJDB TPCSF NFEJDJOB
JODMVZFOEP FM DÏMFCSF .FEJDBM /ÏNFTJT
EF *WBO *MMJDI *MMJDI MBT JDPOP
DMBTUBT DPOGFSFODJBT 3FJUI EF *BO ,FO
OFEZ iDzF 6ONBTLJOH PG .FEJDJOFw
,FOOFEZ Z FM BOÈMJTJT TPDJBM
DSÓUJDPEFMQPEFSNÏEJDPDBQJUBMJTUBQPS
QBSUFEFFTDSJUPSFTBNFSJDBOPTDPNP7J
DFOUF /BWBSSP /BWBSSP WÏBTFUBNCJÏOFMDBQÓUVMP
-BiNFEJDJOBQPTNPEFSOBwEFCFTVSF
MBUJWJTNP B TV OBUVSBMF[B DBEB WF[ NÈT
DPNQSFOTJWBJOUFSQSFUBUJWBZFWBMVBUJWB
FO TVNB B TV SFnFYJWJEBE -B mMPTPGÓB
EF MB NFEJDJOB BCBSDB MB BOUSPQPMPHÓB
MBFQJTUFNPMPHÓBZMBBYJPMPHÓBNÏEJDBT
&MÞMUJNPFTUBEJPJODMVJSÓBMBCJPÏUJDBFO
TVTBTQFDUPTEFTBMVEDMÓOJDBZQÞCMJDB
%F FTUB NBOFSB FO "NÏSJDB -BUJOB MB
CJPÏUJDB FT FM OVFWP QBSBEJHNB NÏEJ
DP IVNBOJTUB Z TPCSF UPEP VOB ÏUJDB
iJNQMJDBEBwNÈTCJFORVFiBQMJDBEBwB
MBNFEJDJOBRVFEFSJWØEFMBBYJPMPHÓB
JOUSÓOTFDB B MB QSPGFTJØO NÏEJDB &O
DPOUSBTUFDPOFMEFTBSSPMMPBNFSJDBOPEF
MBCJPÏUJDBoRVFJNQMJDØBNÏEJDPTUFØ
MPHPTmMØTPGPTZBCPHBEPToMPTQSPUBHP
OJTUBTMBUJOPBNFSJDBOPTEFMBEJTDJQMJOB
GVFSPOQSJODJQBMNFOUFNÏEJDPTZPUSPT
QSPGFTJPOBMFTEFMPTDVJEBEPTNÏEJDPT
-BBTJNJMBDJØOEFMBCJPÏUJDBFO
MBEÏDBEBEF
&M EJTDVSTP BDBEÏNJDP Z QÞCMJDP EF MB
EJTDJQMJOB TF JOTUJUVDJPOBMJ[Ø FO MB SF
HJØO TJHVJFOEP FM NPEFMP BNFSJDBOP
PERSPETIVADELABIOETICAINDD
$POMBSFTUBVSBDJØOEFMBEFNPDSBDJBZ
MB JOUSPEVDDJØO EF OVFWBT UFDOPMPHÓBT
NÏEJDBT oUBMFT DPNP MPT DVJEBEPT JO
UFOTJWPTFMUSBTQMBOUFZMBSFQSPEVDDJØO
BTJTUJEBoFMJOUFSÏTQÞCMJDPZBDBEÏNJ
DPQPSMBCJPÏUJDBTFBNQMJØFOMPTB×PT
-BBTJNJMBDJØOTFIBSFnFKBEPFOMB
CJPÏUJDB BNFSJDBOB EF EPT NBOFSBT FM
BVNFOUP EF MJUJHJPT QPS OFHMJHFODJB FO
MB BTJTUFODJB NÏEJDB Z FM NPWJNJFOUP
QPS MPT EFSFDIPT EFM QBDJFOUF JNJUBSPO
GBDUPSFTRVFIBCÓBODPOEVDJEPBTVOB
DJNJFOUP FO &&66 DPO MB SFTUBVSB
DJØO EF MB EFNPDSBDJB WJOP VO JOUFSÏT
SFOPWBEPFOMBmMPTPGÓBNPSBMZQPMÓUJDB
ZFOMBGPSNBDJØOEFMQMVSBMJTNPJEFPMØ
HJDPZEFMDPOTFOTPRVFEFTQVÏTGVFSPO
BQMJDBEPTBMBNFEJDJOBZTFDPOWJSUJFSPO
FODPNQPOFOUFTEPNJOBOUFTEFMBOVF
WBCJPÏUJDBUBMDPNPFO&&66-PMBT
&O MB GVOEBDJØO .BJOFUUJ MBO[Ø
VOB TFHVOEB FUBQB EF JOTUJUVDJPOBMJ[B
DJØO FO EPT BNCJFOUFT BDBEÏNJDPT MB
&TDVFMB .ÏEJDB Z FM %FQBSUBNFOUP EF
'JMPTPGÓBEFMB6OJWFSTJEBE/BDJPOBMEF
-B 1MBUB -B DÈUFESB EF )VNBOJEBEFT
.ÏEJDBT QSPQPSDJPOØ MB PQPSUVOJEBE
QBSBVOBmMPTPGÓBEFMBNFEJDJOBDPNP
NFEJUBDJØO QPTnFYOFSJBOB EFM BSUF DV
SBUJWPDPOUSBVONPEFMPSFEVDDJPOJTUB
&MNPEFMP'MFYOFSJNQMJDBCBFMBOUJHVP
QBSBEJHNBNÏEJDPQPTJUJWJTUBEFMBNF
EJDJOBSFTUSJOHJEPBMBTDJFODJBTOBUVSB
MFTBQMJDBEBT-BCJPÏUJDBMBUJOPBNFSJDB
OBBEPQUØVOOVFWPQBSBEJHNBNÏEJDP
RVFFNQMFBCBMBTDJFODJBTZMBTIVNBOJ
EBEFTQBSBEFTBSSPMMBSVOBUFPSÓBZVOB
QSÈDUJDBEFMBNFEJDJOB&OMPTB×PT
1FSTQFDUJWBTEFMB#JPÏUJDBFO*CFSPBNÏSJDB
FMJOTUJUVUPDPOUJOVØBTJNJMBOEPMBCJP
ÏUJDBBMBBDUVBMmMPTPGÓBEFMBNFEJDJOB
-B DÈUFESB EF "OUSPQPMPHÓB 'JMPTØmDB
JOUSPEVKP MB CJPÏUJDB DPNP GFOØNFOP
DVMUVSBMFTEFDJSMBDPODFQDJØOEFVOB
SFWPMVDJØOCJPMØHJDBRVFUSBOTGPSNØMB
OBUVSBMF[BIVNBOBZVOBOVFWBNPSBMJ
EBEDÓWJDBTPCSFMPTDVJEBEPTNÏEJDPT
&M mOBM EF MB EÏDBEB BUFTUJHVØ MB nP
SBDJØO EF DFOUSPT JOTUJUVUPT Z HSVQPT
QSPGFTJPOBMFT FO MB SFHJØO &M *OTUJUVUP
$PMPNCJBOPEF&TUVEJPT#JPÏUJDPT#P
HPUÈ$PMPNCJB
GVFGVOEBEPFO
BOJNBEPQPSMBFOTF×BO[BOPUBCMFEF"M
GPOTP-MBOP&TDPCBS4+EFMB6OJWFS
TJEBE+BWFSJBOB&O7FOF[VFMBFMEPDUPS
"VHVTUP -FØO $ BVUPS EF VO UFYUP
DMÈTJDPEFÏUJDBNÏEJDBFOGVFSFT
QPOTBCMF EFM BSUÓDVMP TPCSF CJPÏUJDB FO
"NÏSJDB -BUJOB FO MB QSJNFSB FEJDJØO
EF MB &ODZDMPQFEJB PG #JPFUIJDT -FØO
$ -B 6OJWFSTJEBE
$BUØMJDB EF $IJMF DSFØ VOB VOJEBE EF
CJPÏUJDBFOMB&TDVFMBEF.FEJDJOBFO
Z QBSUJDJQBSPO FO FTUF QSPHSBNB
MPTEPDUPSFT"MFKBOESP4FSBOJZ.BOVFM
-BWBEPT-B1POUJmDJB6OJWFSTJEBE$B
UØMJDBEF3ÓP(SBOEFEP4VMFO1PSUP
"MFHSF #SBTJM FTUBCMFDJØ VO QSPHSBNB
HSBEVBEPFOCJPÏUJDBFOEJSJHJEP
QPS+PBRVJN$MPUFUmMØTPGPEF#BSDF
MPOB&TQB×B
"MBFUBQBEFBTJNJMBDJØOEFMBCJPÏUJDB
TJHVJØ MB FUBQB DSÓUJDB EF SFDFQDJØO FO
"NÏSJDB -BUJOB -B OBUVSBMF[B SBEJDBM
EF MB CJPÏUJDB MBUJOPBNFSJDBOB WB NÈT
BMMÈ EF MB mMPTPGÓB EF MB NFEJDJOB Z TF
DPOWJFSUFFOVOBmMPTPGÓBEFMBDVMUVSB
PERSPETIVADELABIOETICAINDD
Z MB UFDOPMPHÓB NPWJÏOEPTF EFTEF MB
NFUBNFEJDJOBBMBNFUBÏUJDBBMCVTDBS
VODVFTUJPOBNJFOUPGVOEBNFOUBMEFMB
UFDOPDJFODJB
-BOPWFEBEZMBTFSJFEBEEFMPTQSPCMF
NBT SFGFSFOUFT B MB WJEB NPEFMBO VOB
DSJTJTCJPÏUJDBEFMBFSBUFDOPMØHJDB&O
FTUB OVFWB DSJTJT WJUBM Z OPSNBUJWB IBZ
USFT UFNBT FOUSFMB[BEPT MB DBUÈTUSPGF
FDPMØHJDB MB SFWPMVDJØO CJPMØHJDB Z MB
NFEJDBMJ[BDJØO EF MB WJEB -B CJPÏUJ
DB TVSHJØ DPNP SFTVMUBEP EF DBNCJPT
EF HSBO FOWFSHBEVSB FO OVFTUSB DPN
QSFOTJØOEFMBDPOEJDJØOIVNBOBZFO
OVFTUSBDBQBDJEBEBVNFOUBEBEFUSBOT
GPSNBSFMDVFSQP%FTEFTVTDPNJFO[PT
FMDBNJOPMBUJOPBNFSJDBOPBMBCJPÏUJDB
IBTJEPVOBCÞTRVFEBEFMTFSIVNBOP
FOFMTFOUJEPEFVOBCÞTRVFEBEFCBTF
FO MB BOUSPQPMPHÓB mMPTØmDB DFOUSBEB
FOMBOVFWBDBQBDJEBEEFBMUFSBSFMDVFS
QPZEFDSFBSVOBNPSBMJEBEBMUFSOBUJWB
%SBOF
-BSFDSFBDJØOEFMBCJPÏUJDBFOMB
EÏDBEBEF
&OMPTB×PTMBCJPÏUJDBMBUJOPBNFSJ
DBOBTFSFDPOTUSVZØVTBOEPGPSNBTRVF
JODPSQPSBO USBEJDJPOFT JOUFMFDUVBMFT Z
NPSBMFTUÓQJDBTEFMBSFHJØO&OMBNB
ZPSÓBEFMPTQBÓTFTFMNPWJNJFOUPTFPS
HBOJ[ØFOUSFTÈSFBTBDBEÏNJDBJOWFTUJ
HBDJØODJFOUÓmDBZFEVDBDJØOTVQFSJPS
DVJEBEPT NÏEJDPT DPOTVMUBT EF TBMVE
DMÓOJDB Z QÞCMJDB DPNJUÏT IPTQJUBMBSJPT
EF ÏUJDB
Z QPMÓUJDB QÞCMJDB TFSWJDJPT
EFDPOTVMUPSÓBZSFDPNFOEBDJPOFTBMBT
BVUPSJEBEFT FO DVFTUJPOFT OPSNBUJWBT
-PTEJTDVSTPTEFMBCJPÏUJDBFO"NÏSJDB-BUJOB+PTÏ"MCFSUP.BJOFUUJZ.BSUB-VDÓB1ÏSF[
Z SFHVMBUJWBT
$PODVSSFOUFNFOUF MBT
BTPDJBDJPOFTSFHJPOBMFTTFEFTBSSPMMBSPO
F JNQVMTBSPO FM NPWJNJFOUP CJPÏUJDP
MBUJOPBNFSJDBOP FO DPOTFDVFODJB VOB
JEFOUJEBEÏUJDBSFHJPOBMEJTUJOUJWBTFIB
DPOWFSUJEP FO NPEFMP EF FTUF NPWJ
NJFOUP
'VOEBEBFOMB&TDVFMB-BUJOPBNF
SJDBOBEF#JPÏUJDB&-"#&
EFMB'VO
EBDJØO.BJOFUUJGVFMBQSJNFSBJOJDJBUJWB
EFUSBCBKPBDBEÏNJDPFOFTUBÈSFBEFJO
nVFODJBDVMUVSBM&TVOQSPHSBNBEFFO
USFOBNJFOUPRVFGPSNBSFDVSTPTIVNB
OPTQBSBFMMJEFSB[HPEFMBEJTDJQMJOBFO
MPTQBÓTFTEFPSJHFOEFMPTQBSUJDJQBOUFT
ZQSPQPSDJPOBVOGPSPQBSBFMJOUFSDBN
CJPDVMUVSBMZDJFOUÓmDP&MDVSTPJOUFS
OBDJPOBMEFCJPÏUJDBEF&-"#&EVSBOUF
MPTB×PTGVFQSFTJEJEPQPSQSPGFTPSFT
QSPNJOFOUFT EF DFOUSPT JOUFSOBDJPOBMFT
JNQPSUBOUFT &M $FOUSP 0ODPMØHJDP EF
&YDFMFODJB'VOEBDJØO.BJOFUUJ
DSFØMB
'FEFSBDJØO-BUJOPBNFSJDBOBEF#JPÏUJDB
FOEJDJFNCSFEF
&O+BNFT%SBOFEF&&66GVF
DPNJTJPOBEPQPSMB0SHBOJ[BDJØO1BOB
NFSJDBOBEF4BMVE014
QBSBWJTJUBSWB
SJPTQBÓTFTZQSPEVDJSVOJOGPSNFTPCSF
FM EFTBSSPMMP EF MB CJPÏUJDB FO "NÏSJDB
-BUJOB&TUFJOnVZFOUFJOGPSNFQSPQVTP
EJWFSTPTQBTPTQBSBFMEFTBSSPMMPSFHJPOBM
QPTUFSJPSEFMBEJTDJQMJOB%SBOFZ'VFO
[BMJEB
&OFMNJTNPB×P
MB014QVCMJDØVOBFEJDJØOFTQFDJBMEF
CJPÏUJDB DPPSEJOBEB QPS 4VTBO 4DIPMMF
$POOPS Z )FSOÈO 'VFO[BMJEB1VFMNB
JOUSPEVDJFOEP GPSNBMNFOUF MB CJPÏUJDB
FO "NÏSJDB -BUJOB 4DIPMMF $POOPS Z
PERSPETIVADELABIOETICAINDD
'VFO[BMJEB
'VFMBQSJNFSBDPN
QJMBDJØORVFBCPSEØBTVOUPTEJWFSTPTZTF
QSPQVTJFSPOEJTUJOUBTQFSTQFDUJWBTTPCSF
MB EJTDJQMJOB "EFNÈT MB 014 QJPOFSB
FOUSF MBT PSHBOJ[BDJPOFT JOUFSOBDJPOBMFT
EFTBMVEDSFØFM1SPHSBNB3FHJPOBMEF
#JPÏUJDB
DPOTFEFFO4BOUJBHPEF
$IJMFQFSPDPOBDUJWJEBEFTEFTDFOUSBMJ[B
EBTQBSBTFSWJSBUPEPTMPTQBÓTFTNJFN
CSPT&TUFQSPHSBNBEJTF×BEPQBSBEF
TBSSPMMBSVOBQPMÓUJDBBNQMJBFOCJPÏUJDB
ZTVTEJTDJQMJOBTBTPDJBEBTTFFODVFOUSB
FOVOBOVFWBFUBQBCBKPMBEJSFDDJØOEFM
EPDUPS'FSOBOEP-PMBT4UFQLF1SPHSB
NB3FHJPOBMEF#JPÏUJDB
-BFUBQBEFSFDSFBDJØOSFWFMBVOBUFSDFSB
DBSBDUFSÓTUJDBEFMBCJPÏUJDBMBUJOPBNFSJ
DBOBTVQSFPDVQBDJØOHMPCBM-BCJPÏ
UJDB FT FODJDMPQÏEJDB QPS EFmOJDJØO FT
FUJNPMØHJDBNFOUF iÏUJDB EF MB WJEBw Z
iWJEBEFMBÏUJDBw
QFSPTFNÈOUJDBNFOUF
OPDJSDVOTDSJUBBMCJPTUFDOPMØHJDPOJBM
FUIPT MJCFSBM DBSBDUFSÓTUJDPT EFM NPEFMP
OPSUFBNFSJDBOP&ODPOUSBTUFDPOÏTUF
FM NPEFMP MBUJOPBNFSJDBOP BDFOUÞB VO
CJPT IVNBOP Z VO FUIPT DPNVOJUBSJP
1PS FTP MB CJPÏUJDB FT BIPSB VO NPWJ
NJFOUPQPMÓUJDPPEFSFGPSNBTPDJBMNÈT
RVFVOBEJTDJQMJOBBDBEÏNJDBSFTUSJOHJ
EBBMEPNJOJPEFMPTDVJEBEPTNÏEJDPT
&OMBCJPÏUJDBMBUJOPBNFSJDBOBMPTQSJO
DJQJPTEFTPMJEBSJEBEZKVTUJDJBEFTFNQF
×BOFMQBQFMDFOUSBMRVFUJFOFMBBVUPOP
NÓBFOMBCJPÏUJDBOPSUFBNFSJDBOB"TÓ
MBT QPMÓUJDBT TBOJUBSJBT MBUJOPBNFSJDBOBT
JODMVZFOFMBDDFTPVOJWFSTBMBMPTDVJEB
EPTNÏEJDPTZBDFOUÞBOMBKVTUJDJBZMB
FRVJEBE EJTUSJCVUJWBT FO MB BTJHOBDJØO
EFSFDVSTPTEFTBMVE
1FSTQFDUJWBTEFMB#JPÏUJDBFO*CFSPBNÏSJDB
&TUFOPFTMVHBSQBSBVOFYBNFOEFQSP
HSFTPT CJPÏUJDPT FO EJWFSTPT QBÓTFT MBUJ
OPBNFSJDBOPTPQBSBVOBSFWJTJØOEFMPT
QSPCMFNBTCJPÏUJDPTQFDVMJBSFTBMBSFHJØO
.BJOFUUJ1JT%JF[Z5FBMEJ
&TRVJTBCFM1JT%JF[Z5FBMEJ
-B CJPÏUJDB TF IB DPOWFSUJEP
FODBNQPEFOVFWPTEFTBGÓPTFO"NÏSJDB
-BUJOB 6OB VOJGPSNJEBE EF TVQFSmDJF
QBSFDFPDVMUBSVODPOKVOUPSJDPZIFUF
SPHÏOFPEFBDUJWJEBEFT/PTØMPJOnVFO
DJBTFVSPQFBTZDSJTUJBOBTTJOPUBNCJÏO
MBT USBEJDJPOFT JOUFMFDUVBMFT JOEÓHFOBT
TPO NVZ JNQPSUBOUFT FO FM EFTBSSPMMP
EF MB CJPÏUJDB MBUJOPBNFSJDBOB /P UJF
OFTVQSPQJBmMPTPGÓBFODPOUSBTUFDPO
MBQFSDFQDJØORVFTFUJFOFEFMBCJPÏUJDB
BOHMPBNFSJDBOBQFSPTÓTVQSPQJPFTUJMP
EFMJUFSBUVSBZEFOBSSBUJWB&MDPOUFYUP
IJTUØSJDP QBSUJDVMBS FM FUIPT DVMUVSBM Z
MBSFBMJEBETPDJBMEF-BUJOPBNÏSJDBIBO
QPEJEPJOGVOEJSOVFWBWJEBFOMBDPNV
OJEBEHMPCBMEFMBCJPÏUJDB6OTÓOUPNB
EFMPTOVFWPTUJFNQPTFTRVFFMTFHVOEP
DPOHSFTPEFMB"TPDJBDJØO*OUFSOBDJPOBM
EF#JPÏUJDBPDVSSJØFO#VFOPT"JSFT"S
HFOUJOBFOZFMTFYUPFO#SBTJMJB
#SBTJM FO 6OB iOVFWB CJPÏUJDB
CSBTJMF×BwPiCJPÏUJDBEVSBwDPNFO[ØB
QSPTQFSBS FO B×PT SFDJFOUFT *OTQJSBEB
QPSMBSFBMJEBETPDJBMDPOUSBEJDUPSJBEFM
QBÓT FYQMPSB QFSTQFDUJWBT BMUFSOBUJWBT
B MBT DPSSJFOUFT CJPÏUJDBT USBEJDJPOBMFT
(BSSBGB
$PODMVTJØO
&TUF DBQÓUVMP SFMBUB FM EFTBSSPMMP EF MB
CJPÏUJDBFO"NÏSJDB-BUJOBEVSBOUFMBT
ÞMUJNBTUSFTEÏDBEBTFOUÏSNJOPTEFUSFT
FUBQBTSFDFQDJØOBTJNJMBDJØOZSFDSFB
DJØO -B CJPÏUJDB MMFHØ QSJNFSP DPNP
VOB FYUSB×B Z MVFHP FYQFSJNFOUØ VOB
USBOTGPSNBDJØO DVMUVSBM 5SBTQMBOUBEB
BVOBUJFSSBRVFOPFSBTVIÈCJUBUiOB
UVSBMwIBBERVJSJEPTVQSPQJPDBSÈDUFS
ZWP[EJTUJOUJWPTZTFIBDPOWFSUJEPFO
VO FNQSFOEJNJFOUP JOUFMFDUVBM Z QPMÓ
UJDP GVFSUF -PMBT -PMBT
&ODPNQBSBDJØODPOFMFTUJMPOPSUFBNF
SJDBOP QSFTFOUB VO BDFSDBNJFOUP NÈT
UFØSJDPZNÈTmMPTØmDP$PNPCÞTRVF
EBEFVOBCJPÏUJDBDSÓUJDBZSBEJDBMNB
OJmFTUBVOBÏQPDBHMPCBMiQPTCJPÏUJDBw
%SBOF
"VORVFFTUÈMF
KPTEFTFSVOTJTUFNBUFØSJDPVOJmDBEP
PVOBTPMBQFSTQFDUJWBDPIFSFOUFSFQSF
TFOUBTJOFNCBSHPMBFUIJDBTQFTFTQF
SBO[BÏUJDB
EFMOVFWPNJMFOJP
3FGFSFODJBT
%SBOF+'
6OJWFSTBM.FEJDBM&UIJDT2VJSØO
KVOJPQQ
%SBOF+'
#JPFUIJDBM1FSTQFDUJWFTGSPN*CFSP"NFSJDB5IF+PVSOBMPG.FEJDJOF
F1IJMPTPQIZ
QQ
%SBOF+''VFO[BMJEB)
.FEJDBM&UIJDTJO-BUJO"NFSJDBBOFXJOUFSFTUF
DPNNJUNFOU,FOOFEZ*OTUJUVUFPG&UIJDT+PVSOBM
QQ
&TDPCBS5SJBOB+
)VNBOJTUJDF4PDJBM&EVDBUJPOGPS1IZTJDJBOT5IF&YQFSJFODF
PERSPETIVADELABIOETICAINDD
-PTEJTDVSTPTEFMBCJPÏUJDBFO"NÏSJDB-BUJOB+PTÏ"MCFSUP.BJOFUUJZ.BSUB-VDÓB1ÏSF[
PG UIF $PMPNCJBO 4DIPPM PG .FEJDJOF 5IF +PVSOBM PG .FEJDJOF BOE 1IJMPTPQIZ
QQ
'JHVFSPB13'VFO[BMJEB)
#JPFUIJDTJO*CFSP"NFSJDBFUIF$BSJCCFBO5IF
+PVSOBMPG.FEJDJOFBOE1IJMPTPQIZ
QQ
(BSSBGB7
"CJPFUIJDBMSBEJPHSBQIZPG#SB[JM"DUB#JPFUIJDB
QQ
*MMJDI * -JNJUT UP .FEJDJOF .FEJDBM /FNFTJT 5IF &YQSPQJBUJPO PG )FBMUI
-POEPO.BSJPO#PZBST1VCMJTIFST-UE
,FOOFEZ*
5IF6ONBTLJOHPG.FEJDJOF-POEPO"MMFOBOE6OXJO
-FØO$FDDIJOJ"
-BUJO"NFSJDBJOUIF5XFOUJFUI$FOUVSZ*O8BSSFO53
PSH&ODZDMPQFEJBPG#JPFUIJDT/FX:PSL.BD.JMMBO
-PMBT 4UFQLF ' &M EJTDVSTP CJPÏUJDP 6OB BOÏDEPUB QFSTPOBM 2VJSØO EJDJFNCSFQQ
-PMBT4UFQLF'
#JPÏUJDB4BOUJBHPEF$IJMF&EJUPSJBM6OJWFSTJUBSJB
-PMBT 4UFQLF ' #JPÏUJDB Z "OUSPQPMPHÓB .ÏEJDB 4BOUJBHP EF $IJMF
.FEJUFSSÈOFP
-PMBT4UFQLF'
#JPFUIJDTBOEUIFDVMUVSFPGMJGFBDPOUSJCVUJPOUPQFBDF#JPÏUJDB
*OGPSNBQQ
.BDLMJO3'MPSFODJB-
#JPFUIJDTJO"SHFOUJOB"$PVOUSZ3FQPSU#JPFUIJDT
QQ
.BJOFUUJ+"
#JPFUIJDBM1SPCMFNTJOUIF%FWFMPQJOH8PSME"7JFXGSPN-BUJO
"NFSJDB6OJUBT"2VBSUFSMZGPSUIF"SUTBOE4DJFODFT
+VOFQQ
.BJOFUUJ+"$PNQMFKP#JPÏUJDP1JHNBMJØO/BSDJTPZ,OPDL"DUBQTJRVJÈUSQTJDPM
"N-BU
QQ
.BJOFUUJ + " 0VU PG "NFSJDB 5IF 4DIPMBTUJD BOE .VOEBOF #JPFUIJDBM
4DFOF JO "SHFOUJOB *O 4JNQØTJP 5SBOTDVMUVSBM %JNFOTJPOT PG .FEJDBM &UIJDT
DPQBUSPDJOBEPQPS'JEJB3FTFBSDI'PVOEBUJPOF(FPSHFUPXO6OJWFSTJUZ$FOUFS
GPS UIF "EWBODFE 4UVEZ PG &UIJDT /BUJPOBM "DBEFNZ PG 4DJFODFT 8BTIJOHUPO
%$EFBCSJM
.BJOFUUJ+PTÏ"1JT%JF[(Z5FBMEJ+$
#JPFUIJDTJO-BUJO"NFSJDB*O
-VTUJH"0SH#JPFUIJDT:FBSCPPL7PM3FHJPOBM%FWFMPQNFOUJO#JPFUIJDT
%PSESFDIU5IF/FUIFSMBOET,MVXFS"DBEFNJD1VCMJTIFSTQQ
.BJOFUUJ+PTÏ"
.FEJDBM&UIJDT)JTUPSZPG5IF"NFSJDBT-BUJO"NFSJDB*O
8BSSFO53PSH&ODZDMPQFEJBPG#JPFUIJDT/FX:PSL.BDNJMMBO
.BJOFUUJ+PTÏ"
*OTFBSDIPG#JPFUIJDT"QFSTPOBMQPTUTDSJQU5IF+PVSOBMPG
.FEJDJOFBOE1IJMPTPQIZ
QQ
/BWBSSP7
5IF1PMJUJDBM&DPOPNZPG)FBMUI$BSF5IF*OUFSOBUJPOBM+PVSOBMPG
)FBMUI4FSWJDFTQQ
PERSPETIVADELABIOETICAINDD
1FSTQFDUJWBTEFMB#JPÏUJDBFO*CFSPBNÏSJDB
4DIPMMF$POOPS4Z'VFO[BMJEB)
#JPFUIJDT*TTVFTBOE1FSTQFDUJWFT8BTIJOH
UPO1BO"NFSJDBO)FBMUI0SHBOJ[BUJPO1")04DJFOUJGJD1VCMJDBUJPO
5FBMEJ+$1JT%JF[(Z&TRVJTBCFM0
#JPFUIJDTJO-BUJO"NFSJDB
*O -VTUJH " PSH #JPFUIJDT :FBSCPPL 7PM 3FHJPOBM %FWFMPQNFOU JO
#JPFUIJDT%PSESFDIU5IF/FUIFSMBOET,MVXFS"DBEFNJD1VCMJTIFST
QQ
PERSPETIVADELABIOETICAINDD
-B0SHBOJ[BDJØO1BOBNFSJDBOBEFMB4BMVE014
Z
MBCJPÏUJDBMBUJOPBNFSJDBOB
'FSOBOEP-PMBT
&
O VO BSUÓDVMP QVCMJDBEP FO -PMBT EFMJOFÏ DVÈM FSB FO
BRVFMMB ÏQPDB MB TJUVBDJØO EF MB ÏUJDB
CJPNÏEJDBDIJMFOBTVTQSJODJQBMFTDVFT
UJPOFTZTVTQSPHSFTPTQPUFODJBMFT$IJMF
FTUBCBFOFTFFOUPODFTCBKPFMSÏHJNFO
NJMJUBS Z MBT BTPDJBDJPOFT QSPGFTJPOBMFT
IBCÓBO QFSEJEP FM DPOUSPM ÏUJDP EF TVT
BTPDJBEPT MBT FTDVFMBT NÏEJDBT EFEJDB
CBO OP NÈT EF EFM UJFNQP BDBEÏ
NJDP B FOTF×BS BTQFDUPT IVNBOJTUBT Z
ÏUJDPT EF MB NFEJDJOB Z MB CJPÏUJDB OP
BQBSFDÓB FO QMBOFT EF FTUVEJPT UÓUVMPT
EFQVCMJDBDJPOFTPBTPDJBDJPOFT
%VSBOUFMPTB×PTDPNFO[ØVONPWJ
NJFOUPGVFSUFMB6OJWFSTJEBEEF$IJMF
FTUBCMFDJØVOB$PNJTJØOEF#JPÏUJDBBO
UFTEFMBGPSNBMJ[ØFOZPS
HBOJ[ØFMNJTNPB×PVOBSFVOJØOCBKP
FMUÓUVMPiJOTUJUVDJPOBMJ[BDJØOEFMBCJP
ÏUJDBi&OTFFTUBCMFDJØFM$FOUSP
*OUFSEJTDJQMJOBSJPEF&TUVEJPTFO#JPÏUJ
DBZDPNFO[ØGPSNBMNFOUFFMUSBCBKPEF
DPNQJMBDJØOEFMBJOGPSNBDJØOFYJTUFOUF
Z MB GPSNBDJØO EF BMJBO[BT FTUSBUÏHJDBT
DPO PUSBT JOTUJUVDJPOFT -PMBT &OUSF MBT JOTUJUVDJPOFT TFMFDDJPOBEBT
MB 0SHBOJ[BDJØO 1BOBNFSJDBOB EF MB
4BMVEEFNPTUSØTFSMBNÈTJNQPSUBOUF
PERSPETIVADELABIOETICAINDD
TVQSFTUJHJPFOUSFUSBCBKBEPSFTEFTBMVE
FMBNQMJPBMDBODFEFTVTBDUJWJEBEFTZFM
DPNQSPNJTPEFTVTBVUPSJEBEFTQSJODJ
QBMFTFOBRVFMMBÏQPDBIBOTJEPJNQPS
UBOUFT QBSB FTUBCMFDFS VOB BTPDJBDJØO
GSVDUÓGFSB
*NQMJDBDJØOEFMB0SHBOJ[BDJØO
1BOBNFSJDBOBEFMB4BMVE014
&O MB 0SHBOJ[BDJØO 1BOBNFSJ
DBOB EF MB 4BMVE 014 1BO "NFSJDBO
)FBMUI 0SHBOJ[BUJPO 1")0
0mDJOB
3FHJPOBM EF MB 0SHBOJ[BDJØO .VOEJBM
EFMB4BMVE0.4
FOBTPDJBDJØODPOMB
6OJWFSTJEBEEF$IJMFZFMHPCJFSOPDIJ
MFOPDSFBSPOVO1SPHSBNB3FHJPOBMEF
#JPÏUJDBQBSB-BUJOPBNÏSJDBZFM$BSJCF
4V QSPQØTJUP FSB SFTQPOEFS B MBT OFDF
TJEBEFT EF FTPT QBÓTFT Z UFSSJUPSJPT RVF
IBCÓBOJOJDJBEPQSPDFTPTEFSFGPSNBEF
TVTTJTUFNBTEFTBMVEEFNFKPSÓBEFTV
JOGSBFTUSVDUVSBDJFOUÓmDBZRVFQSPQPS
DJPOBCBOTFSWJDJPTNÏEJDPTZTBOJUBSJPT
BMBTQPCMBDJPOFT-PMBT
1BSBFM
FTUBCMFDJNJFOUPEFFTUFQSPHSBNBFOMB
014GVFJNQPSUBOUFMBDPOUSJCVDJØOEF
+BNFT %SBOF Z EF )FSOÈO 'VFO[BMJEB
%SBOFZ'VFO[BMJEB
-BJOJDJBUJWBEFMB014GVFTJNVMUÈOFB
1FSTQFDUJWBTEFMB#JPÏUJDBFO*CFSPBNÏSJDB
DPO FM FTUBCMFDJNJFOUP EF MB $PNJTJØO
*OUFSOBDJPOBMEF#JPÏUJDBEFMB6/&4
$0 DSFBEB QBSB BGSPOUBS MPT EFTBGÓPT
QMBOUFBEPTQPSMBJOWFTUJHBDJØOHFOØNJ
DBZFMBWBODFEFMDPOPDJNJFOUPFOMBT
DJFODJBTCJPMØHJDBT&OTFDSFØFO
MBTFEFEFMB0.4FO(JOFCSBVOBVOJ
EBEFODBSHBEBEFMBÏUJDBFMDPNFSDJPZ
MPTEFSFDIPTIVNBOPTDPNPDPOUSBQBS
UFBMQSPHSBNBEFMB014
&EVDBDJØOZFOUSFOBNJFOUP
%VSBOUF MPT QSJNFSPT B×PT TF PCUVWJF
SPO SFDVSTPT QBSB QSPHSBNBT EJSJHJEPT
BMFOUSFOBNJFOUPEFVODVBESPEFQSP
GFTJPOBMFTGBNJMJBSJ[BEPTDPOMBCJPÏUJDB
FOMBT"NÏSJDBTZFM$BSJCF4FFTUBCMF
DJFSPO QSPHSBNBT BWBO[BEPT FO MPT OJ
WFMFTEFNBFTUSÓBZEJQMPNBEPFOWBSJBT
VOJWFSTJEBEFTZTFDSFBSPODVSTPTDPSUPT
P QBUSPDJOBEPT FO NÈT EF WFJOUJDJODP
QBÓTFTFYQPOJFOEPBNÈTEFUSFTDJFOUPT
QSPGFTJPOBMFTBTVTDPODFQUPTZQSPDFEJ
NJFOUPT"MHVOPTEFFTUPTQSPHSBNBTEF
NBFTUSÓBGVFSPODSFBEPTFOMB6OJWFSTJ
EBEEF$IJMFFOFM*OTUJUVUP5FDOPMØ
HJDP EF 4BOUP %PNJOHP */5&$
FO
MB 6OJWFSTJEBE /BDJPOBM EF 4BO .BS
DPTFO-JNB1FSÞZFOMB6OJWFSTJEBE
/BDJPOBM EF $VZP FO "SHFOUJOB DPO
MBBZVEBEFMQSPGFTPS%JFHP(SBDJBEF
MB 6OJWFSTJEBE $PNQMVUFOTF EF .B
ESJE &TQB×B "EFNÈT MPT QSPGFTPSFT
EFMQSPHSBNBQBSUJDJQBCBOFOBDUJWJEB
EFT FEVDBUJWBT FO PUSBT JOTUJUVDJPOFT Z
EFTBSSPMMBCBO VOB TFSJF EF TFNJOBSJPT
EFEJDBEPT B MB EJEÈDUJDB EF MB CJPÏUJDB
QBSBQSPGFTJPOBMFTEFUPEPFMDPOUJOFO
UF6OBTÓOUFTJTEFFTUBTBDUJWJEBEFTZEF
PERSPETIVADELABIOETICAINDD
MBTQVCMJDBDJPOFT
FTUÈEJTQPOJCMFFOFM
TJUJPXXXQBIPPSHCJPÏUJDB
4FQSFQBSBSPOZEJTUSJCVZFSPOBEFNÈT
EJWFSTPT NBUFSJBMFT FEVDBUJWPT JODMV
ZFOEP WBSJPT MJCSPT VTBEPT BIPSB FY
UFOTBNFOUF DPO QSPQØTJUPT FEVDBUJWPT
6OB CJCMJPUFDB WJSUVBM EF CJPÏUJDB GVF
BHSFHBEBBMBCJCMJPUFDBWJSUVBMEFTBMVE
VOQSPZFDUPEFTBSSPMMBEPFODPNÞODPO
MB#JCMJPUFDB3FHJPOBMEF.FEJDJOB#*
3&.&EF4BP1BVMP#SBTJM
&M QFSÓPEP JOJDJBM UBNCJÏO JNQMJDØ MB
MFHJUJNBDJØO EF MB CJPÏUJDB FO FM DPO
UFYUP EF VOB PSHBOJ[BDJØO JOUFSOBDJP
OBMEFTFSWJDJP"MHVOPTDSÓUJDPTEJKFSPO
RVFFSBVOMVKPZFODJFSUPHSBEPVOB
QSFPDVQBDJØO JSSFMFWBOUF FO DPOUSBTUF
DPOOFDFTJEBEFTEFTBMVENÈTBQSFNJBO
UFTZVSHFOUFT&SBOFDFTBSJPEFNPTUSBS
DØNPQPESÓBTFSBQMJDBEBFOMBQSÈDUJDB
Z TFS SFMFWBOUF B MBT OFDFTJEBEFT SFBMFT
-BCJPÏUJDBTFPDVQBEFMBDBMJEBEEFMPT
TFSWJDJPT Z EF MB FYDFMFODJB EF MB JOWFT
UJHBDJØO DPNQPOFOUFT FTFODJBMFT EF MB
TBUJTGBDDJØOEFMQBDJFOUFZEFMBDPSSFDUB
KFSBSRVÓBEFQPMÓUJDBT-BPSJFOUBDJØOIB
DJBMBHFOUFGVFFWJEFODJBEBUBNCJÏOFO
MBTBDDJPOFTEJSJHJEBTBNFKPSBSFMFOUSF
OBNJFOUPEFMPTFTUVEJBOUFTFJODPSQPSBS
MBCJPÏUJDBFOMPTQMBOFTEFFTUVEJPQBSB
EJWFSTBTQSPGFTJPOFTJODMVZFOEPMBNF
EJDJOBMBFOGFSNFSÓBZMBTDJFODJBTCJPMØ
HJDPBNCJFOUBMFTFOEJWFSTPTDPOUFYUPT
*OWFTUJHBDJØOZBCPHBDÓB
"EFNÈT EFM FOUSFOBNJFOUP EF QSPGF
TJPOBMFT Z EF GPSNBEPSFT EF PQJOJØO
FM QSPHSBNB UBNCJÏO SFTQPOEÓB B MBT
-B0SHBOJ[BDJØO1BOBNFSJDBOBEFMB4BMVE014
ZMBCJPÏUJDBMBUJOPBNFSJDBOB'FSOBOEP-PMBT
EFNBOEBT EF JOGPSNBDJØO Z EF EFGFO
TB EF HSVQPT Z EF PSHBOJ[BDJPOFT 4VT
NJFNCSPTDPOUFTUBCBOQSFHVOUBTZEB
CBO QBSFDFSFT TPCSF NBUFSJBT EF QPMÓUJ
DBT QÞCMJDBT Z MB QVFTUB FO QSÈDUJDB EF
QBVUBT ÏUJDBT $PNFO[Ø B QVCMJDBS VO
CPMFUÓO EF OPUJDJBT USJNFTUSBM #JPÏUJDB
*OGPSNB *44/ Z VOB SF
WJTUB BDBEÏNJDB "DUB #JPFUIJDB *44/
DPOUJOVBDJØO EFTEF EF MPT $VBEFSOPT EFM 1SPHSBNB 3FHJP
OBM EF #JPÏUJDB
RVF FO BMHVOPT B×PT
TFDPOWJSUJFSPOFOMFDUVSBFTUÈOEBSQBSB
MPT FTUVEJPTPT Z NÏEJDPT MBUJOPBNFSJ
DBOPT Z EFM $BSJCF $PNP QBSUF EF TV
QPMÓUJDB EF EJGVTJØO UBNCJÏO IBO TJEP
QSFTFOUBEPTDBTPTCJPÏUJDPTFOGPSNBEF
IJTUPSJFUBT JMVTUSBEBT DØNJDT
QBSB MBT
BVEJFODJBT KØWFOFT ÞUJMFT FO MB TBMB EF
DMBTFT Z VTBEBT FO EJWFSTPT BNCJFOUFT
6O QSPHSBNB FTQFDJBM TPCSF TBMVE PSBM
ZCJPÏUJDBGVFJOJDJBEPFOFMDPOUFYUPEF
VODPOWFOJPDPOFM/*)'PHBSUZ*OUFS
OBUJPOBM$FOUFSDPOVOCPMFUÓOEFOPUJ
DJBT4BMVE0SBMZ#JPÏUJDB*44/
Z PUSBT QVCMJDBDJPOFT SFVOJPOFT
FTQFDJBMFTZFTUVEJPTEFMBTJUVBDJØOEFMB
FOTF×BO[BEFCJPÏUJDBFOFTDVFMBTEFOUB
MFT&MQSPHSBNBUBNCJÏOIBBZVEBEPFO
MBUSBEVDDJØOEFQBVUBTJOUFSOBDJPOBMFT
ZFOMBPSHBOJ[BDJØOEFTFNJOBSJPTTPCSF
TV DPOUFOJEP QBSB EJWFSTPT QÞCMJDPT Z
IBTJEPGVOEBNFOUBMQBSBSFVOJSBHFOUF
EFEJWFSTBTÈSFBTEFFTUVEJPZPSJFOUBDJP
OFTQBSBEJTFNJOBSFMNBUFSJBM
1PDPEFTQVÏTEFTVFTUBCMFDJNJFOUPFM
1SPHSBNBEF#JPÏUJDBEFMB014DPNFO
[ØBSFDPHFSEBUPTTPCSFQFSTPOBTFJOT
UJUVDJPOFT PSHBOJ[BOEP CBTFT EF EBUPT
PERSPETIVADELABIOETICAINDD
TPCSFPQPSUVOJEBEFTEFFOUSFOBNJFOUP
QSPZFDUPTEFJOWFTUJHBDJØOZQVCMJDBDJP
OFTZEBOEPBDPOPDFSSFTF×BTEFFEJ
DJPOFTCJPNÏEJDBTBHFODJBTEFmOBODJB
NJFOUPDØEJHPTEFÏUJDBZMFHJTMBDJPOFT
SFMFWBOUFT 6O $PNJUÏ $POTVMUJWP *O
UFSOBDJPOBMJOUFHSBEPQPSSFOPNCSBEPT
CJPFUJDJTUBTZMBDPOUSJCVDJØOEFMPTSF
QSFTFOUBOUFTEFMB014FOMPTQBÓTFTIBO
BZVEBEP B FTUBCMFDFS MPT QSJODJQJPT EF
BDDJØOEFM1SPHSBNBEF#JPÏUJDB
$POVOQSFTVQVFTUPMJNJUBEPQFSPVOB
FmDJFOUFBDDJØOEFPCUFODJØOEFSFDVS
TPTZMBDPPQFSBDJØOEFMB6OJWFSTJEBE
EF$IJMFZEFMHPCJFSOPDIJMFOPFM1SP
HSBNB EF #JPÏUJDB EF MB 014 TF VCJDØ
DPNP SFGFSFOUF OP TØMP FO MB SFHJØO
TJOP UBNCJÏO FO PUSBT QBSUFT EFM NVO
EP &O FM DPOUFYUP EF MB DPPQFSBDJØO
UÏDOJDBMBDSFBDJØOEFDPNJUÏTEFÏUJDB
EFJOWFTUJHBDJØOZEFDVJEBEPTDMÓOJDPT
FMFTUBCMFDJNJFOUPEFDPNJTJPOFTOBDJP
OBMFTEFCJPÏUJDBZFMFOUSFOBNJFOUPEF
QSPGFTJPOBMFT IBO TJEP MBT QSJPSJEBEFT
$POUSJCVZFOBVOBBENJOJTUSBDJØONF
KPSEFSFDVSTPTBVODPODFQUPNÈTBN
QMJP EF DBMJEBE oJODMVZFOEP QSJODJQJPT
ÏUJDPToBMBTBUJTGBDDJØODSFDJFOUFFOUSF
JOWFTUJHBEPSFTEFMÈSFBEFMBTBMVEZNÏ
EJDPTZBVOBNFKPSDPODJFODJBQÞCMJDB
TPCSFDVFTUJPOFTEFJOUFSÏTHFOFSBM
-BCJPÏUJDBVUJMJ[BFMEJÈMPHPQBSBMMFHBS
B EFDJTJPOFT ÏUJDBT TPTUFOJCMFT Z EFTBGÓB
UPEPT Z DBEB EPHNB DSFFODJB V PQJ
OJØOQBSBEBSSFTQVFTUBTBMBTDVFTUJPOFT
BDVDJBOUFTQMBOUFBEBTQPSMBDJFODJBZMB
UFDOPMPHÓBBQMJDBEBTBMPTBTVOUPTIVNB
OPT&MDBSÈDUFSEJBMØHJDPZEFQBSUJDJQB
1FSTQFDUJWBTEFMB#JPÏUJDBFO*CFSPBNÏSJDB
DJØOEFUPEPTMPTJOUFSFTBEPTFOEFDJTJP
OFTSFMBUJWBTBMBTBMVETFIBBDFOUVBEPB
USBWÏTEFMUSBCBKPEFMQSPHSBNB"MHVOBT
BDUJWJEBEFTZQSPEVDUPTEFMBCJPÏUJDBEF
MB014TFQSFTFOUBOFOMBUBCMB
KPSFT FO MB JOWFTUJHBDJØO Z MB DPPQFSB
DJØOTPOUBNCJÏOQSPEVDUPEFMBTFOTJ
CJMJEBEEFMBCJPÏUJDBBVORVFFTEJGÓDJM
FWBMVBSMBT
5BCMB3FTVNFOEFBDUJWJEBEFTZQSPEVDUPTEFM1SPHSBNBEF#JPÏUJDBEF014
$VSTPT
1VCMJDBDJPOFT
*OUFSWFODJPOFT
"MJBO[BT
0USBTBDUJWJEBEFT
&OUSFOBNJFOUP
&TQFDJBMJ[BDJØO
&MBCPSBDJØO
EFQMBOFTEF
FOTF×BO[B
1FSJØEJDP
BDBEÏNJDP
#PMFUÓO
-JCSPT
3FTQVFTUBTB
DVFTUJPOFT
&TUBCMFDJNJFOUP
EFDPNJUÏTEF
ÏUJDB
*OTUJUVDJPOFT
BDBEÏNJDBT
0USPTØSHBOPT
*OEVTUSJB
"CPHBDÓB
3FTF×BT
#BTFTEFEBUPT
%JTFNJOBDJØO
QÞCMJDBEF
JOGPSNBDJPOFT
&O MBT "NÏSJDBT Z FM $BSJCF FM QFOTB
NJFOUP CJPÏUJDP Z MB QSÈDUJDB EF MB EF
MJCFSBDJØOTPOQBSUJDVMBSNFOUFSFMFWBO
UFT"MHVOPTQBÓTFTFYIJCFOJOFRVJEBEFT
FOFMBDDFTPBMBTBMVEMBQPCSF[BBGFDUB
DBTJ MB NJUBE EF MB QPCMBDJØO Z MB DP
SSVQDJØO FT VOB QFSNBOFOUF BNFOB[B
-BJOFTUBCJMJEBEQPMÓUJDBZMBJOnVFODJB
QFOFUSBOUF EFM DBQJUBM USBOTOBDJPOBM
BGFDUBOMBDPOUJOVJEBEEFEFDJTJPOFTHV
CFSOBNFOUBMFT-PTQSPGFTJPOBMFTEFMPT
DVJEBEPTNÏEJDPTZEFMBJOWFTUJHBDJØO
EFMBTBMVEFOHFOFSBMTJFOUFOGSVTUSB
DJØOZDØMFSBQPSOPDPOUBSDPOSFDVSTPT
TVmDJFOUFT QBSB EFTFNQF×BS BEFDVBEB
NFOUFTVQBQFM
&M 1SPHSBNB EF #JPÏUJDB TVQFSWJTB MB
DBMJEBE EF MBT BDUJWJEBEFT BDBEÏNJDBT
MBUJOPBNFSJDBOBT Z EFM $BSJCF FTUBCMF
DF OVFWPT QSPHSBNBT FEVDBUJWPT Z EF
JOWFTUJHBDJØO QSPNVFWF MB DSFBDJØO EF
JOTUJUVDJPOFTZBZVEBBMPTJOUFSFTBEPTB
QSFQBSBSQSPZFDUPTEFJOWFTUJHBDJØOQBSB
MBTBHFODJBTJOUFSOBDJPOBMFTEFmOBODJB
NJFOUP &O MBT SFVOJPOFT EFM $POTFKP
$POTVMUJWP *OUFSOBDJPOBM FTUBCMFDJEP
QPS FM BOUJHVP EJSFDUPS EF MB 014 4JS
(FPSHF"MMFZOFTFIBOBCPSEBEPWBSJPT
BTVOUPT EF JNQPSUBODJB -PMBT -PMBT Z "HBS -PMBT Z 2VF[BEB
)BIBCJEPQSPHSFTPTFOBMHVOPTQBÓTFT
BVORVFDPONFOPTJOUFOTJEBEPJNQBD
UPFOPUSPT/PPCTUBOUFiCJPÏUJDBiTF
IBDPOWFSUJEPFOVOBQBMBCSBFTUÈOEBS
Z MBT JOTUJUVDJPOFT TPMJDJUBO DPOTFKP Z
EJSFDDJØO&MFTUBCMFDJNJFOUPEFDPNJ
TJPOFTZEFDPNJUÏTOBDJPOBMFTEFÏUJDB
FTVOBCVFOBNFEJEBEFMUSBCBKPEFMB
014ZPUSPTPSHBOJTNPT1SÈDUJDBTNF
%FTBGÓPTQBSBFMGVUVSP
PERSPETIVADELABIOETICAINDD
$PO FM FTUBCMFDJNJFOUP QJPOFSP EF MB
CJPÏUJDBMB0SHBOJ[BDJØO1BOBNFSJDBOB
EFMB4BMVE014
EFNPTUSØRVFIBCÓB
JEFOUJmDBEP VOB OFDFTJEBE HFOVJOB Z
SFTQPOEJEPBQSPQJBEBNFOUFBFMMB
1BSBDPOUJOVBSEFTFNQF×BOEPTVQBQFM
MB014EFCFDPOTPMJEBSTVDBSÈDUFSDPNP
-B0SHBOJ[BDJØO1BOBNFSJDBOBEFMB4BMVE014
ZMBCJPÏUJDBMBUJOPBNFSJDBOB'FSOBOEP-PMBT
PSHBOJ[BDJØOCBTBEBFOFMDPOPDJNJFO
UPRVFGPNFOUBOPTØMPMBBERVJTJDJØOZ
FMVTPEFJOGPSNBDJPOFTSFMFWBOUFTTJOP
UBNCJÏO DPOTJEFSBS MBT JNQMJDBDJPOFT
NPSBMFTEFMDPOPDJNJFOUPZEFMBBDDJØO
FmDJFOUF&TUPFTQPTJCMFFOVOQSPHSB
NBRVFJODPSQPSBBFYQFSUPTSFTQFUBEPT
JOEFQFOEJFOUFNFOUF EF TV QBÓT EF PSJ
HFO BmMJBDJØO BDBEÏNJDB P QSPGFTJØO
-BT SFMBDJPOFT FOUSF MPT SFQSFTFOUBOUFT
EF MB 014 Z FM 1SPHSBNB EF #JPÏUJDB
TPO CVFO FKFNQMP EFM FTGVFS[P DPODFS
UBEPQBSBEFTBSSPMMBSMBBDDJØOFOGPDBEB
FOQBÓTFT)BZBZVEBFTQFDJBMJ[BEBEJT
QPOJCMFFOMBNBZPSÓBEFFMMPTHSBDJBTB
FTUBBMJBO[B
-B 014 IB SFTQPOEJEP BEFDVBEBNFO
UFBMBTOFDFTJEBEFTFOMBSFHJØOEFMBT
"NÏSJDBTZEFM$BSJCFFONVDIBTÈSFBT
-PMBT 1BSB FWBMVBS TV NJTJØO
EF TFSWJDJP QÞCMJDP FO CJPÏUJDB Z TV
JOnVFODJBFOMBJOWFTUJHBDJØOZMPTDVJ
EBEPTNÏEJDPTFTQSFDJTPIBDFSBMHVOBT
DPOTJEFSBDJPOFT
$VBOEP TF FTUBCMFDF MB CJPÏUJDB DPNP
DBNQP MFHÓUJNP EF BDUJWJEBE JOUFMFD
UVBMZGVFOUFEFEJSFDDJØOQBSBMBBDDJØO
BQSPQJBEB FT NVZ HSBOEF FM SJFTHP EF
GPSNBSBVOHSVQPEFHFOUFDPOWFODJEB
EFTVTVQFSJPSJEBEFONBUFSJBTEFKVJDJP
NPSBM Z OFDFTJUBEP EF SFDPOPDJNJFO
UP-BQSPGFTJPOBMJ[BDJØOEFMBCJPÏUJDB
OP FT SFDPNFOEBCMF FO FTUF QVOUP EFM
EFTBSSPMMP EFM DBNQP &OUSFOBS QSPGF
TJPOBMFTFOMBEFMJCFSBDJØOZMBEJGVTJØO
EFMPTQSJODJQJPTCJPÏUJDPTFOUSFQPCMB
DJPOFTNÈTCJFORVFQSPNPWFSFMDPOP
DJNJFOUPBDBEÏNJDPBWBO[BEPEFCFTFS
PERSPETIVADELABIOETICAINDD
MB QSJPSJEBE BVORVF FTF DPOPDJNJFOUP
FT JNQSFTDJOEJCMF QBSB MPT QSPHSFTPT
GVUVSPT Z MBT DPOUSJCVDJPOFT PSJHJOBMFT
-PTWFSEBEFSPTFYQFSUPTOPDPOGVOEFO
MB EFMJCFSBDJØO ÏUJDB DPO FM BEPDUSJOB
NJFOUPQPMÓUJDPZDPNQSFOEFOMBOFDF
TJEBEWJUBMEFMBUPMFSBODJBZEFMEJÈMPHP
UBO FTFODJBMFT QBSB MB CJPÏUJDB /P MFT
TFEVDFO MBT EFNBOEBT EFNBHØHJDBT EF
PSJHJOBMJEBEFJNQFSJBMJTNPZTFFTGVFS
[BOFOEFTDVCSJSSFTQVFTUBTBQSPCMFNBT
QFSFOOFT
-B FEVDBDJØO EF MB QPCMBDJØO FT QBSUF
EFMFTGVFS[PCJPÏUJDP1VFTUPRVFTVGVO
EBNFOUP FT FM EJÈMPHP MPT JOEJWJEVPT
EFCFOBERVJSJSMBDBQBDJEBEEFEFCBUJS
&TUPJNQMJDBVOFTGVFS[PDPODFSUBEPEF
QBSUF EF FYQFSUPT JOTUJUVDJPOFT BDBEÏ
NJDBTHSVQPTEFBVUPBZVEBZTFSWJDJPT
QÞCMJDPT-BHFOUFEFCFQFSDJCJSRVFMB
TBMVE FT VOB DPOTUSVDDJØO TPDJFUBSJB Z
QFSTPOBM BZVEBEB QPS FM USBCBKP QSPGF
TJPOBM 6OB DPNVOJEBE CJFO JOTUSVJEB
OPJNQPOFEFNBOEBTJSSFBMFTTPCSFMPT
QSPWFFEPSFT EF TFSWJDJPT FT NÈT JOGPS
NBEBDPOmBEBFOTVTQSPQJPTSFDVSTPT
Z EFTBSSPMMB VO TFOUJEP EF TPMJEBSJEBE
DPNPDPOEJDJØOQSFWJBQBSBVOBCVFOB
DBMJEBEEFWJEB
-BCJPÏUJDBFOMB014WBBSFDJCJSBQPZP
TFHÞOMBFWPMVDJØOEFMDBNQP4VQSF
TFODJBFOFMEFCBUFNPSBMTFKVTUJmDBQPS
EJWFSTBTSB[POFT(SVQPTSBEJDBMFTQVF
EFO VUJMJ[BSMB QBSB TPTUFOFS TVT DPOWJD
DJPOFT P QBSB EJTFNJOBS DSFFODJBT QBS
UJDVMBSFT -B JOEVTUSJB QVFEF FODPOUSBS
BSHVNFOUPTQBSBJOUFSWFODJPOFTBHSFTJ
WBTRVFQSPEV[DBOMVDSPT-PTHPCJFSOPT
1FSTQFDUJWBTEFMB#JPÏUJDBFO*CFSPBNÏSJDB
QVFEFO FNQMFBS FM EJTDVSTP CJPÏUJDP
QBSB MFHJUJNBS QSÈDUJDBT JOBEFDVBEBT P
BVUPSJUBSJBT $PNP ØSHBOP UÏDOJDP EF
DPPQFSBDJØO 014 HBSBOUJ[B MB OFVUSB
MJEBE EF FTQFDJBMJTUBT FO DVFTUJPOFT EF
JOUFSÏTDPNÞOBMBTNJOPSÓBTZBMBTNB
ZPSÓBT1VFEFBZVEBSBSFEVDJSFMQFMJHSP
EFMVTPFSSØOFPEFBSHVNFOUPTNPSBMFT
DPONFUBTFDPOØNJDBTPQPMÓUJDBT
&MEFTBGÓPFTUSBCBKBSQPSFMCJFODPNÞO
EFMBHFOUFEFMBT"NÏSJDBTZEFM$BSJCF
MJCSF EF BQSFNJPT FDPOØNJDPT P JEFP
MØHJDPT HP[BOEP EF MB DPOmBO[B Z EFM
SFTQFUPEFTVTJOUFSMPDVUPSFTZFWJUBOEP
MBEJTDSJNJOBDJØOZMBFYDMVTJØO1PSRVF
FODVFTUJPOFTEFMBTBMVEUPEPTDVFOUBO
ZMBNFUBTJHVFTJFOEPiTBMVEQBSBUPEPT
QPSUPEPTDPOUPEPTw
3FGFSFODJBT
%SBOF+''VFO[BMJEB)
.FEJDBM&UIJDTJO-BUJO"NFSJDBBOFXJOUFSFTU
BOEDPNNJUNFOU,FOOFEZ*OTUJUVUFPG&UIJDT+PVSOBM
QQ
-PMBT ' #JPFUIJDT JO $IJMF 1SFTFOU BOE GVUVSF TUBUVT *O $POOPS 44 'VFO[BMJEB1VFMNB ) FET #JPFUIJDT *TTVFT BOE 1FSTQFDUJWFT 8BTIJOHUPO %$
1BO"NFSJDBO)FBMUI0SHBOJ[BUJPOQQ
-PMBT'
#JPÏUJDBFOMB6OJWFSTJEBEEF$IJMF"OBMFTEFMB6OJWFSTJEBEEF$IJMF
4FYUB4FSJF/QQ
-PMBT'
-BCJPÏUJDBFOFMDPOUFYUPEFMPTQSPHSBNBTHMPCBMFTEFTBMVE3FWJTUB
1BOBNFSJDBOBEF4BMVE1ÞCMJDB
QQ
-PMBT ' FEJU
#JPÏUJDB Z DVJEBEP EF MB TBMVE &RVJEBE $BMJEBE %FSFDIPT
4BOUJBHP EF $IJMF 1SPHSBNB 3FHJPOBM EF #JPÏUJDB 0SHBOJ[BDJØO 1BOBNFSJDBOB
EFMB4BMVE
-PMBT'FEJU
%JÈMPHPZDPPQFSBDJØOFOTBMVE%JF[B×PTEFCJPÏUJDBFOMB014
4BOUJBHPEF$IJMF6OJEBEEF#JPÏUJDB0140.4
-PMBT ' "HBS - FET
*OUFSGBDFT CFUXFFO CJPFUIJDT BOE UIF FNQJSJDBM
TPDJBM TDJFODFT 4BOUJBHP EF $IJMF 1SPHSBNB 3FHJPOBM EF #JPÏUJDB 0SHBOJ[BDJØO
1BOBNFSJDBOBEFMB4BMVE
-PMBT'2VF[BEB"FET
1BVUBTÏUJDBTEFJOWFTUJHBDJØOFOTVKFUPTIVNBOPT
OVFWBTQFSTQFDUJWBT4BOUJBHPEF$IJMF1SPHSBNB3FHJPOBMEF#JPÏUJDB0SHBOJ[BDJØO
1BOBNFSJDBOBEFMB4BMVE
PERSPETIVADELABIOETICAINDD
-BCJPÏUJDBFO"NÏSJDB-BUJOBZFO$PMPNCJB
"MGPOTP-MBOP&TDPCBS4+
6CJDBDJØOEFMUFNB
-
BCJPÏUJDBOBDJØFO&TUBEPT6OJEPT
FO MB TFHVOEB NJUBE EFM TJHMP 99
DPNP VO iQSPEVDUPw UÓQJDBNFOUF OPS
UFBNFSJDBOPDPODSFUBNFOUFDPNPVOB
iOVFWBÏUJDBwDPODBSBDUFSÓTUJDBTOPSUF
BNFSJDBOBTZQBSBTPMVDJPOBSQSPCMFNBT
OPSUFBNFSJDBOPT *ODMVTJWF OP OBDJØ
DPNPVOBTPMBCJPÏUJDB:BFOTVPSJHFO
FODPOUSBNPT EPT UFOEFODJBT CJFO EJT
UJOUBTRVFMVFHPTFNVMUJQMJDBOBTBCFS
MBEF7BO3FOTTFMBFS1PUUFSQSFTFOUBEB
i-B SFBMJEBE FT RVF FYJTUFO DVBUSP "NÏSJDBT
DBEB VOB EF MBT DVBMFT SFQSFTFOUB IJTUØSJDB
NFOUFVOUFSSJUPSJPVOBFYQFSJFODJBVOFTUJMP
VONPEPEFTFSQSPQJPTDVBUSP"NÏSJDBTRVF
CVTDBOQPSEJWFSTPTDBNJOPTTVGPSNBQSPQJB
EF FYQSFTJØO TV DVMUVSB MB "NÏSJDB JOEPIJT
QBOB DPO VOB TVQFSmDJF EF LN
DVBESBEPTMB"NÏSJDBQPSUVHVFTB#SBTJM
DPO
LN DVBESBEPT MB "NÏSJDB JOHMFTB
PBOHMPTBKPOB64"
DPOLNDVB
ESBEPT Z MB "NÏSJDB BOHMPGSBODFTB $BOBEÈ
DPO LN DVBESBEPT 4ØMP MB QSJNF
SB UJFOF RVF WFS DPO $PMØO MB IJTUPSJB EF MBT
EFNÈT DPNFO[Ø B×PT BVO TJHMPT NÈT UBSEFw
&MOPNCSFEF"NÏSJDBiTFBQMJDBQPSQSJNFSB
WF[BM/VFWP.VOEPFOMB$PTNPHSBQIJBF*O
USPEVDUJP FO 4BJOU%JFV -PT 7PTHPT -PSFOB
FMEFBCSJMEFQPSFYBHFSBEBHSBUJUVE
BMDBSUØHSBGPJUBMJBOP"NÏSJDP7FTQVDDJUFYUP
EFMQPFUB.BUUIJBT3JOHNBOONBQBBEKVOUP
EFMDBSUØHSBGPMPSFOÏT.BSUJO8BMETFFNàMMFSw
(BMJOEP
&OFTUFFTUVEJPOPTSFGFSJSF
NPTBMBTBNÏSJDBTJOEPIJTQBOBZQPSUVHVFTB
RVF TPMFNPT EFOPNJOBS "NÏSJDB -BUJOB B MB
DVBMTFB×BEFOMPTQBÓTFTEFM$BSJCF
PERSPETIVADELABIOETICAINDD
FOTVMJCSP#JPFUIJDT#SJEHFUPUIF'VUVSF
1PUUFS
RVJFOBDV×BFMWPDBCMP
MBO[BMBJEFBEFVOBOVFWBEJTDJQMJOBZ
VO NPWJNJFOUP NVOEJBM B GBWPS EF MB
WJEB Z FM NFEJPBNCJFOUF FO QFMJHSP
$PODJCF MB CJPÏUJDB iFO FNFSHFODJBw
DPNP VO EJÈMPHP FOUSF EPT DVMUVSBT P
TBCFSFT oFM DJFOUÓmDP Z FM ÏUJDPo DPO
NJSBT B MB TVQFSWJWFODJB EFM IPNCSF Z
EFMQMBOFUB5JFSSB
-B EF DzF ,FOOFEZ *OTUJUVUF PG &UIJDT
EF MB 6OJWFSTJEBE EF (FPSHFUPXO FO
8BTIJOHUPO&MNJTNPB×PFORVF1P
UUFSMBO[BTVMJCSPZTVQSPQVFTUBEFVOB
OVFWB EJTDJQMJOB (FPSHFUPXO GPSNBMJ[B
MB CJPÏUJDB MB JOTUJUVDJPOBMJ[B BM EBSMF
TPQPSUF BDBEÏNJDP Z MB FOGPDB DPNP
VOB NBDSPÏUJDB NÏEJDB UFOEFODJB RVF
WBBQSFWBMFDFSFOMBTTJHVJFOUFTEÏDBEBT
FO&TUBEPT6OJEPT
-B CJPÏUJDB OBDF FO VO DPOUFYUP DJFO
UÓmDP Z FO VO NBSDP TFDVMBS oFT EF
&OFM.D"SEMF-BCPSBUPSZ%FQBSUNFOUPG0ODP
MPHZEFMB6OJWFSTJEBEEF8JTDPOTJO
&MBNCJFOUFTFDVMBSWBMFEFDJSOPDPOGFTJPOBM
RVJFSF QPOFS EF SFMJFWF FM IFDIP EF RVF FTUB
OVFWBÏUJDBOPFTUÈFMBCPSBEBQPSSFQSFTFOUBO
UFT EF BMHVOB SFMJHJØO .ÈT BÞO OP TF QVFEF
EFDJS TJRVJFSB RVF FTUÏ FMBCPSBEB ZB RVF VOB
EFMBTDBSBDUFSÓTUJDBTEFMBOVFWBÏUJDBPCJPÏUJDB
DPOTJTUFFORVFOPFTUÈUFSNJOBEBOJQPTJCMF
1FSTQFDUJWBTEFMB#JPÏUJDBFO*CFSPBNÏSJDB
DJS OP SFMJHJPTPo DPNP VO JOUFOUP EF
IVNBOJ[BS MB OVFWB CJPUFDOPMPHÓB FO
SÈQJEP DSFDJNJFOUP Z EF EBSMF DBCJEB
BM QBDJFOUF DPNP QFSTPOB QBSB FGFD
UPT QSÈDUJDPT FO MB UPNB EF EFDJTJPOFT
RVFUJFOFORVFWFSDPOTVUSBUBNJFOUP
3BNTFZ
*NQBDUPEFMBCJPÏUJDBFOMB
DVMUVSBVOJWFSTBMDPOUFNQPSÈOFB
1PTJCMFNFOUF DPO OJOHVOB PUSB ÈSFB
EF FTUVEJP Z EFM TBCFS IVNBOP FO MB
IJTUPSJB SFDJFOUF EF MB DVMUVSB VOJWFS
TBM IB TVDFEJEP DPNP DPO MB CJPÏUJDB
TF IB EFTBSSPMMBEP SÈQJEBNFOUF NPEJ
mDBFORVJFOMBFTUVEJBMBGPSNBEFWFS
Z NBOFKBS MB SFBMJEBE QSFTFOUF BCBSDB
BNQMJBT [POBT EF JOUFSÏT OP TØMP EFM
QSPGFTJPOBMTJOPEFMIPNCSFNFEJPDVM
UPFTUÈMMBNBEBBFKFSDFSVOJOnVKPEF
NBZPS JNQPSUBODJB FO MB WJEB QÞCMJDB
Z DBSBDUFSJ[B Z SFnFKB NÈT mFMNFOUF MB
ÏQPDBDPOUFNQPSÈOFB
-PT EPT DPNQPOFOUFT FTFODJBMFT EF MB
CJPÏUJDBCJPTZFUIPTTPORVJ[ÈMPTEPT
UØQJDPTQPSMPTDVBMFTFMIPNCSFBDUVBM
EFNVFTUSB NBZPS JOUFSÏT Z BUSBDDJØO
i²UJDBwTFIBDPOWFSUJEPFOMPTÞMUJNPT
B×PTFOVOUÏSNJOPVOJWFSTBMVTVBMJO
NFOUF MP FTUBSÈ 4F TJHVF USBCBKBOEP FO FMMB
EF NBOFSB FTQFDJBM FO MBT VOJWFSTJEBEFT 4JO
QSFUFOEFSFODFSSBSMBFOVOBEFmOJDJØOQPESÓB
TFSWJS EF PSJFOUBDJØO MB BQSPYJNBDJØO MJHFSB
NFOUFNBRVJMMBEBRVFPGSFDFFM1SPHSBNBEF
#JPÏUJDB EF 014 i#JPÏUJDB FT FM VTP DSFBUJWP
EFM EJÈMPHP JOUFSEJTDJQMJOBSJP QBSB GPSNVMBS
BSUJDVMBS Z FO MP QPTJCMF SFTPMWFS BMHVOPT EF
MPTQSPCMFNBTRVFQMBOUFBBMBTPDJFEBEBDUVBM
MBJOWFTUJHBDJØOZMBJOUFSWFODJØOTPCSFMBWJEB
MBTBMVEZFMNFEJPBNCJFOUFw
PERSPETIVADELABIOETICAINDD
UFSFTBOUFEJHOPEFFTUVEJBSTFFODVBOUP
DPOEVDUBIVNBOBCVFOBPNBMBNPSBM
NFOUF &T VO UÏSNJOP NÈT QSPQJP EF
VOBTPDJFEBETFDVMBSBVUØOPNBZQMV
SBMJTUB
RVFFMEFiNPSBMwRVFFSBNÈT
DPNÞOFOUJFNQPTQBTBEPT
1SJNFSBFUBQBEFMBCJPÏUJDBFO
-BUJOPBNÏSJDBiFMUSBTQMBOUFw
"OUFDFEFOUFT
%BEPFMJOVTJUBEPEFTBSSPMMPEFMBCJP
ÏUJDB QSJNFSP "SHFOUJOB MVFHP $P
MPNCJB $IJMF .ÏYJDP #SBTJM Z EFNÈT
QBÓTFTMBUJOPBNFSJDBOPTTFQSPEVKPVO
iUSBTQMBOUFwEFMBCJPÏUJDBB"NÏSJDB-B
UJOBTJOBUFOEFSBMBEJGFSFODJBEFiUJF
SSBTwZTJOQSFHVOUBSTFTJEJDIBiQMBOUBw
iHFSNJOBSÓBw FO QBÓTFT EF UJFSSBT UBO
EJTUJOUBT P TJO BWFSJHVBS TJ FTUF OVFWP
iNFEJDBNFOUPwFSBBQUPQBSBDVSBSMPT
NBMFTUBOEJGFSFOUFTEFFTUPTQVFCMPT
"RVÓ OPT PDVQBSFNPT EFM OBDJNJFOUP
Z EFTBSSPMMP EF MB CJPÏUJDB FO "NÏSJDB
-BUJOB BEFNÈT EF #SBTJM Z MBT JTMBT EFM
$BSJCF
"EWJSUJFOEP RVF TPO NBZPSFT MBT EJGF
SFODJBT DVMUVSBMFT QPMÓUJDBT Z SFMJHJPTBT
RVF MPT EFOPNJOBEPSFT DPNVOFT EF
FTUPTPQBÓTFTQPCSF[BTVCEFTB
SSPMMP WJPMFODJB JOFTUBCJMJEBE QPMÓUJDB
SFMJHJØO
WBNPT B USBUBS EF JOEJDBS BM
HVOPTEBUPTIJTUØSJDPTEFMOBDJNJFOUPZ
EFTBSSPMMPEFFTUBEJTDJQMJOBFOMBSFHJØO
QSPDVSBOEPMVFHPEFTUBDBSTVTGPSUBMF[BT
ZGBMFODJBT/VFTUSPFTUVEJPPCKFUJWPZ
KVTUPFOMPQPTJCMFGVFSBEFPGSFDFSVOB
BDUVBMJ[BEB JOGPSNBDJØO B FSVEJUPT Z
-BCJPÏUJDBFO"NÏSJDB-BUJOBZFO$PMPNCJB"MGPOTP-MBOP&TDPCBS4+
OPFSVEJUPTCJPFUJDJTUBTOPMBUJOPBNFSJ
DBOPT QSFUFOEF BQPSUBS UBNCJÏO B MPT
NJTNPT JCFSPBNFSJDBOPT QPS VOB QBS
UFEBUPTZSFnFYJPOFTEFMBTGPSUBMF[BTEF
MBCJPÏUJDBDPOUJOFOUBMQBSBBQSPQJBSMBT
ZNFKPSBSMBTZQPSPUSBVOBCSFWFWJ
TJØOEFTVTGBMFODJBTZMJNJUBDJPOFTQBSB
DPSSFHJSMBTZTVQFSBSMBTFOMBNFEJEBEF
MPQPTJCMF
6OBOUFDFEFOUFEJHOPEFDPOTJEFSBSFTMB
FOTF×BO[BEFMBÏUJDBZEFMBEFPOUPMPHÓB
NÏEJDBT QSPNPWJEB QPS MB 'FEFSBDJØO
1BOBNFSJDBOBEF'BDVMUBEFTZ&TDVFMBT
EF.FEJDJOB'&1"'&.
FOMBTOVNF
SPTBT FTDVFMBT EF MPT EJGFSFOUFT QBÓTFT
5BMFOTF×BO[B TJSWJØ QBSB RVFMVFHPTF
DPOWJSUJFSBFOCJPÏUJDBNÏEJDB
IFDIP
QPTJUJWPBQFTBSEFFTUBSFEVDDJØORVF
QSFWBMFDJØFOMPTQSJNFSPTMVTUSPT
-B CJPÏUJDB DPNP UBM GVF EFTDPOPDJEB
FO OVFTUSPT QBÓTFT MBUJOPBNFSJDBOPT FO
MBEÏDBEBEFTVBQBSJDJØOFOMPT&TUBEPT
6OJEPT
GVFSBEFMEFTBSSP
MMPEFMBTIVNBOJEBEFTZEFMBÏUJDBZEF
BMHVOBTBMVTJPOFTFOMBTBVMBTEFNFEJDJ
OBFO"SHFOUJOB$PMPNCJB7FOF[VFMB
ZQPTJCMFNFOUFFOPUSPTQBÓTFTMBUJOPB
NFSJDBOPT
$POUSBTUFFOUSFEPTDVMUVSBT
/VFTUSPTQSPCMFNBTUÓQJDPTEVSBOUFMPT
TJHMPT9*9Z99EJGFSÓBOEFMPTEF&T
UBEPT6OJEPT4FUSBUBCBEFQBÓTFTRVF
BDBCBCBOEFFTUSFOBSTVJOEFQFOEFODJB
EF &TQB×B P 1PSUVHBM DPO FM MBTUSF EF
QPCSF[B TVCEFTBSSPMMP Z EPNJOBDJØO
EFNJOPSÓBTQPMÓUJDBTZFDPOØNJDBTRVF
FYQMPUBCBO B MPT JOEJWJEVPT JNQJEJFO
PERSPETIVADELABIOETICAINDD
EPFMFTUBCMFDJNJFOUPEFWFSEBEFSBTEF
NPDSBDJBT1PSPUSBQBSUFFMEFTBSSPMMP
DJFOUÓmDP Z UFDOPMØHJDP FSB FTDBTP QPS
GBMUBEFSFDVSTPTIVNBOPTZmOBODJFSPT
.BJOFUUJ
-BNPSBMDBUØMJDBVOBEFMBTGVFOUFTEF
MBÏUJDBNÏEJDB
EJSJHÓBMBWJEBQSJWBEB
ZQÞCMJDBEFDBTJUPEPTMPT&TUBEPTMB
UJOPBNFSJDBOPT-BTFDVMBSJ[BDJØOMFO
UB Z EJGÓDJM FO BMHVOPT QBÓTFT .ÏYJDP
6SVHVBZ$IJMFFOUSFPUSPT
BDFMFSBEB
Z UBSEÓB FO PUSPT $PMPNCJB
BDBSSFØ
MBEJTNJOVDJØOEFMBBVUPSJEBEQÞCMJDB
ZQSJWBEBEFMB*HMFTJB$BUØMJDBZEFMB
NPSBM RVF FMMB QSFEJDBCB TJO RVF GVF
SB TVTUJUVJEB QPS VOB ÏUJDB DJWJM %F
3PVY DBQB[ EF GSFOBS MPT BCV
TPTEFMPTQPMÓUJDPTEFUVSOPZMPTSJDPT
UFSSBUFOJFOUFT Z MB EJMBQJEBDJØO EF MBT
SJRVF[BTOBUVSBMFTZSFDVSTPTEFMNFEJP
BNCJFOUF
-BSFWPMVDJØOCJPÏUJDB
0CTFSWB.BJOFUUJRVFFTUFCJPTUFDOJm
DBDJØOEFMBWJEB
ZFTUFFUIPTTFDVMBSJ
[BDJØOEFMBNPSBM
BEWJFOFOEFMDBN
CJP IJTUØSJDP RVF SFTVMUB EFM QSPHSFTP
CJPUFDOPMØHJDP FO &TUBEPT 6OJEPT Z
EFMDBSÈDUFSMJCFSBMZTFDVMBSEFMBÏUJDB
QSPUFTUBOUF &TUPT EPT IFDIPT DPOUSBT
UBCBO DPO MB DVMUVSB iQSFUÏDOJDBi MBUJ
OPBNFSJDBOBZDPOVOBNPSBMSFMJHJPTB
EJGFSFOUF
"MIBDFSFMiUSBTQMBOUFwEFFTUBCJPÏUJDB
oNÏEJDB QSJODJQJBMJTUB VUJMJUBSJTUBo OP
TFUVWPFODVFOUBFTUFDPOUSBTUFEFTDP
OPDJNJFOUPRVFQVFEFFYQMJDBSMBTNV
DIBTEJmDVMUBEFTRVFTFFYQFSJNFOUBSPO
1FSTQFDUJWBTEFMB#JPÏUJDBFO*CFSPBNÏSJDB
FO FTUB QSJNFSB FUBQB QBSB TV BDFQUB
DJØOFTUVEJPZEJGVTJØO
5SBTQMBOUFZEFTBSSPMMPEFMB
CJPÏUJDBFO-BUJOPBNÏSJDB
.ÈT DPODSFUBNFOUF USBTQMBOUBS VOB
CJPÏUJDBPDVQBEBFOIVNBOJ[BSCJPUFD
OPMPHÓB BWBO[BEB F JOTQJSBEB FO VOB
ÏUJDBBOHMPTBKPOBBQBÓTFTQPDPEFTBSSP
MMBEPT oUFDOPMØHJDB Z DVMUVSBMNFOUFo
JOnVFODJBEPTGVFSUFNFOUFQPSMBNPSBM
DBUØMJDB DPO VOB USBEJDJØO NÏEJDB IJ
QPDSÈUJDB Z QBUFSOBMJTUB OP QPEÓB NF
OPT RVF FODPOUSBS TFSJBT EJmDVMUBEFT
1PSDJUBSBMHVOBT
"SHFOUJOB*OTUJUVUPEF
)VNBOJEBEFT.ÏEJDBTZ&-"#&
t
t
t
t
t
RVF OP EFTQFSUBSB JOUFSÏT FO VO
DPNJFO[P
RVF OP TF FOUFOEJFSB QPS RVÏ Z
DVÈOEPTFFNQF[ØBFTUVEJBSMB
RVFOPTFTVQJFSBVUJMJ[BSDVBOEPTF
USBUØEFBQMJDBSMB
RVFFNQF[BSBBTFSDPOPDJEBZFT
UVEJBEBTØMPDPNPVOBOVFWBÏUJDB
NÏEJDBDPNPGVFFMDBTPEF"SHFO
UJOB Z 7FOF[VFMB Z FO QBSUF $P
MPNCJB
RVFMBEFTDPOPDJFSBOMPT&TUBEPTZ
VOJWFSTJEBEFT
%JDF.BJOFUUJSFmSJÏOEPTFBFTUBQSJNF
SB FUBQB i-B JOTUJUVDJPOBMJ[BDJØO EF MB
CJPÏUJDBMBDSFBDJØOEFDFOUSPTEFJOWFT
UJHBDJØO DÈUFESBT VOJWFSTJUBSJBT DPNJ
UÏTEFÏUJDBFOMPTIPTQJUBMFTDPNJTJPOFT
OBDJPOBMFTEFCJPÏUJDBFUDFTIBTUBFM
NPNFOUP QPDP TJHOJmDBUJWB Z
EFTEFMVFHPUBNQPDPTFDVNQMFOQSP
HSBNÈUJDBNFOUFMBTUSFTGVODJPOFTQSJO
DJQBMFT EF MPT FTUVEJPT CJPÏUJDPT FEV
DBUJWBBTJTUFODJBMZQPMÓUJDBw.BJOFUUJ
PERSPETIVADELABIOETICAINDD
&MNÏEJDPBSHFOUJOP+PTÏ"MCFSUP.BJ
OFUUJ NJFNCSP EF MB 'VOEBDJØO +PTÏ
.BSÓB .BJOFUUJ SBEJDBEB FO MB MPDBMJ
EBE EF (POOFU DFSDB EF MB DJVEBE EF
-B1MBUB"SHFOUJOBUJFOFFMNÏSJUPEF
IBCFSJOJDJBEPFMNPWJNJFOUPEFIVNB
OJ[BDJØOEFMBNFEJDJOBRVFQSFDFEJØBM
iUSBTQMBOUFwEFMBCJPÏUJDBEF&&66B
"NÏSJDB-BUJOBFOUSFZ
.BJOFUUJJOTQJSBEPFO1FESP-BÓO&O
USBMHPGVOEØBMMÓFOFM*OTUJUVUP
EF)VNBOJEBEFT.ÏEJDBTRVFQSPOUP
EJGVOEJØTVTJEFBMFTIVNBOÓTUJDPTFOFM
$POP 4VS EF -BUJOPBNÏSJDB B USBWÏT
EF DPOGFSFODJBT DVSTPT Z EF MB SFWJTUB
2VJSØO
"QSJODJQJPTEFMBEÏDBEBEFM.BJOFU
UJ WJTJUØ FM ,FOOFEZ *OTUJUVUF PG &UIJDT EF
MB6OJWFSTJEBEEF(FPSHFUPXOFO8BT
IJOHUPOFJOWJUØBCJPFUJDJTUBTEFFTFDFO
USPQBSBEJDUBSDPOGFSFODJBTFOFM*OTUJUVUP
EF(POOFU&ENVOE1FMMFHSJOP5SJTUSBN
&OHFMIBSEU+BNFT%SBOFZPUSPT
.ÈT BEFMBOUF B mOFT EF MPT PDIFOUB
+VBO$BSMPT5FBMEJDPOFMSFTQBMEPEF
.BJOFUUJGVOEØMB&TDVFMB-BUJOPBNF
SJDBOBEF#JPÏUJDB&-"#&
MBDVBMPS
HBOJ[Ø Z EJDUØ EVSBOUF WBSJPT B×PT VO
QSPHSBNB EF FOTF×BO[B EF MB CJPÏUJDB
EFEPTNFTFTEFEVSBDJØODPOMBDPMB
CPSBDJØOEFCJPFUJDJTUBTEFM,FOOFEZ*OT
UJUVUFPG&UIJDT
-BCJPÏUJDBFO"NÏSJDB-BUJOBZFO$PMPNCJB"MGPOTP-MBOP&TDPCBS4+
$PMPNCJBFOUSBFOBDDJØO
&OUSFZTJORVFTFDPOPDJFSB
QÞCMJDBNFOUF MB CJPÏUJDB DPNFO[Ø FO
$PMPNCJBVONPWJNJFOUPEFIVNBOJ
[BDJØO EF MB NFEJDJOB QSPQJDJBEP QPS
HSBOEFTIVNBOJTUBTEF#PHPUÈZ.FEF
MMÓORVFEJFSPODPNJFO[PBOVFWBTFT
DVFMBTQBSBTVQFSBSMPTEFTNBOFTEFMPT
FTUVEJBOUFTEFMBTFTDVFMBTQÞCMJDBTFDP
EF MBT DÏMFCSFT SFWVFMUBT VOJWFSTJUBSJBT
EF &VSPQB "M GVOEBSMBT FTUPT
IVNBOJTUBTTFFTGPS[BSPOFODPOUSJCVJS
BMBGPSNBDJØOJOUFHSBMEFMGVUVSPHBMF
OP7BMFMBQFOBNFODJPOBSB'FSOBOEP
4ÈODIF[5PSSFT+BJNF&TDPCBS5SJBOB
+VBO.FOEP[B7FHBFOUSFPUSPT
-B "TPDJBDJØO $PMPNCJBOB EF 'BDVM
UBEFT EF .FEJDJOB "4$0'".&
m
MJBM EF MB 'FEFSBDJØO 1BOBNFSJDBOB EF
"TPDJBDJPOFT EF 'BDVMUBEFT &TDVFMBT
EF .FEJDJOB '&1"'&. EJSJHJEB QPS
"CFM %VF×BT 1BUSØO DPOUSJCVZØ OP
TØMPDPOFMEJTF×PFJNQMBOUBDJØOEFVO
QSPHSBNBEFFOTF×BO[BEFMBÏUJDBNÏ
EJDBTJOPDPOFMÏOGBTJTFOMBGPSNBDJØO
JOUFHSBMRVFEFCÓBEBSTFBMPTFTUVEJBO
UFTEFNFEJDJOB
:B FO MB EÏDBEB EF MPT Z TJO FTQF
DJBMDPOFYJØODPO"SHFOUJOB'FSOBOEP
4ÈODIF[5PSSFTRVJFOIBCÓBTJEPEFDB
OP EF NFEJDJOB Z SFDUPS EF MB 6OJWFS
TJEBE/BDJPOBMEF$PMPNCJBGVOEØFO
EJDJFNCSF EF DPO VO HSVQP EF
QSPGFTJPOBMFTEFEJWFSTBTSBNBTFM*OTUJ
UVUP$PMPNCJBOPEF&TUVEJPT#JPÏUJDPT
*$&#
FMDVBMIBNBOUFOJEPEFTEFFO
UPODFTVOTFNJOBSJP
PERSPETIVADELABIOETICAINDD
4FHVOEBFUBQBDPOTPMJEBDJPOEF
MBCJPÏUJDBFO-BUJOPBNÏSJDB
-B TFHVOEB FUBQB TF DB
SBDUFSJ[BQPSVOJOUFOTPEFTBSSPMMPEFMB
CJPÏUJDBFOUPEPTMPTQBÓTFTMBUJOPBNFSJ
DBOPTZEFM$BSJCFEFCJEPBNJKVJDJP
BUSFTIFDIPT
#PMFUÓOEFMB0SHBOJ[BDJØO
1BOBNFSJDBOBEFMB4BMVE
014
&O4VTBO4DIPMMF$POOPSZ)FS
OÈO 'VFO[BMJEB1VFMNB EF MB 014 FO
8BTIJOHUPOQVCMJDBSPOVOOÞNFSPEFM
CPMFUÓOEFMBPSHBOJ[BDJØODPOVOBTFSJF
EF BSUÓDVMPT RVF BQBSFDJFSPO MVFHP FO
GPSNBEFMJCSPTPCSFEJWFSTPTUØQJDPTEF
CJPÏUJDBFTDSJUPTQPSOPUBCMFTBVUPSJEB
EFTFOMBNBUFSJBDVZBBNQMJBEJGVTJØO
QSÈDUJDBNFOUF JOUSPEVKP GPSNBMNFOUF
MBCJPÏUJDBFO-BUJOPBNÏSJDB
&KFNQMBSFT EF FTUF CPMFUÓO Z MVFHP EFM
MJCSP MMFHBSPO B NBOPT EF NÏEJDPT Z
QSPGFTJPOBMFTEFMBTBMVEJOUFSFTBEPTFO
IBDFS VOB QSJNFSB BQSPYJNBDJØO B UBO
OPWFEPTBEJTDJQMJOB
'&-"*#&
&ONJFOUSBTUSBCBKBCBFOMB"TP
DJBDJØO $PMPNCJBOB EF 'BDVMUBEFT EF
.FEJDJOB"4$0'".&
GVOEÏFM$FO
USP/BDJPOBMEF#JPÏUJDB$&/"-#&
RVFTFIBQSFPDVQBEPEFMFTUVEJPZEJ
GVTJØOEFMBCJPÏUJDBEFOUSPZGVFSBEF
$PMPNCJB3FDJFOUFNFOUF$&/"-#&
IPZ WJODVMBEP BM *OTUJUVUP EF #JPÏUJDB
EF MB 1POUJmDJB 6OJWFSTJEBE +BWFSJBOB
1FSTQFDUJWBTEFMB#JPÏUJDBFO*CFSPBNÏSJDB
DPOUSJCVZØ DPO FmDBDJB B MB GVOEBDJØO
EFMB"TPDJBDJØO/BDJPOBM$PMPNCJBOB
EF #JPÏUJDB "/"-#&
Z BM FTUBCMFDJ
NJFOUPEFMB$PNJTJØO*OUFSTFDUPSJBMEF
#JPÏUJDB DSFBEB QPS %FDSFUP 1SFTJEFO
DJBMFOKVOJPEF
&O $&/"-#& EFDJEJØ GVOEBS
VOB 'FEFSBDJØO -BUJOPBNFSJDBOB EF
*OTUJUVDJPOFT EF #JPÏUJDB '&-"*#&
NÈT QBSB QSPNPWFS MB GVOEBDJØO EF
JOTUJUVUPT Z DFOUSPT FO UPEPT MPT QBÓTFT
RVFQBSBGFEFSBSMPTRVFUPEBWÓBOPFYJT
UÓBO$&/"-#&QBSBEBSBDPOPDFSB
'&-"*#&PSHBOJ[ØBQBSUJSEFTVGVO
EBDJØO GPSPT Z BTBNCMFBT FO EJWFSTPT
QBÓTFT EFM DPOUJOFOUF BNFSJDBOP Z EFM
$BSJCF
:B FO '&-"*#& FNQF[Ø B PS
HBOJ[BS DPOHSFTPT MBUJOPBNFSJDBOPT EF
CJPÏUJDBFOPSEFOBQSPNPWFSTVDPOP
DJNJFOUPZEJGVTJØO&MQSJNFSPGVFFO
4BP 1BVMP #SBTJM FO FM TFHVOEP
FO #PHPUÈ $PMPNCJB FO DPO MB
BTJTUFODJBEFNJMRVJOJFOUBTQFSTPOBTFM
UFSDFSPFOMB$JVEBEEF1BOBNÈFO
ZFMDVBSUPFO1VFSUP3JDPFO
'&-"*#&QVCMJDBDVBUSPWFDFTBMB×PVO
CPMFUÓODPOFMOPNCSFEF#*07¶/$6
-0RVFEBBDPOPDFSMBTEJWFSTBTBDUJWJ
EBEFT EF MB CJPÏUJDB FO -BUJOPBNÏSJDB
$&/"-#&UJFOFUBNCJÏOFMNÏSJUPEF
IBCFS JOJDJBEP FO MPT QSPHSBNBT
EF FTQFDJBMJEBE FO CJPÏUJDB FM QSJNFSP
EFMPTDVBMFTGVFFMBCPSBEPZEJDUBEPFO
MB6OJWFSTJEBEEF&M#PTRVFFO#PHPUÈ
&OMBBDUVBMJEBETFEJDUBOEJQMPNBEPTZ
QPTHSBEPTEFFTQFDJBMJ[BDJØOZNBFTUSÓB
PERSPETIVADELABIOETICAINDD
FOMBTDJVEBEFTEF#PHPUÈ$BMJZ.FEF
MMÓO-B6OJWFSTJEBEEF&M#PTRVFDVFO
UB DPO VO 1SPHSBNB EF %PDUPSBEP FO
#JPÏUJDBFMQSJNFSPEFFTUFHÏOFSPFOFM
QBÓTTJFOEP$PMPNCJBVOPEFMPTTJUJPT
EPOEFTFEJDUBONÈTDVSTPTEFQPTHSBEP
FO-BUJOPBNÏSJDB
1SPHSBNB3FHJPOBMEF#JPÏUJDB
EFMB014
0USP IFDIP EFDJTJWP IB TJEP MB GVOEB
DJØO B DPNJFO[PT EF FO MB DJV
EBEEF4BOUJBHPEF$IJMFEFM1SPHSBNB
3FHJPOBMEF#JPÏUJDBEFMB0SHBOJ[BDJØO
1BOBNFSJDBOBEFMB4BMVE0140.4
FOFTUSFDIBDPMBCPSBDJØODPOMB6OJWFS
TJEBEEF$IJMF
'VFSBEFMBQPZPDPODFQUVBMZFDPOØNJ
DPBNÞMUJQMFTBDUJWJEBEFTFMQSPHSBNB
IBPGSFDJEPBQBSUJSEFZBQSPGF
TJPOBMFTEJWFSTPTVOB.BFTUSÓBFO#JP
ÏUJDBCBKPMBEJSFDDJØOEF%JFHP(SBDJB
(VJMMÏO RVF NBSDB VO WFSEBEFSP IJUP
FOFMTØMJEPFTUVEJPZQSPGVOEJ[BDJØOEF
MBCJPÏUJDBFO-BUJOPBNÏSJDB
&O MPT ÞMUJNPT B×PT FM
1SPHSBNBEF#JPÏUJDBTFFODVFOUSBCBKP
MBEJSFDDJØOEFMQSPGFTPSEPDUPS'FSOBO
EP-PMBT4UFQLF
3ÈQJEBEJGVTJØOEFMBCJPÏUJDBFO
-BUJOPBNÏSJDB
" QBSUJS EF FM QSFTJEFOUF EF
'&-"*#&SFDPSSJØMPTQSJODJQBMFTQBÓTFT
EF -BUJOPBNÏSJDB JOWJUBOEP B GVOEBS
DFOUSPTFJOTUJUVUPT&ODBEBVOPJEFO
UJmDØBVOMÓEFSRVFTFIJDJFSBDBSHPEFM
-BCJPÏUJDBFO"NÏSJDB-BUJOBZFO$PMPNCJB"MGPOTP-MBOP&TDPCBS4+
FTUVEJPZEJGVTJØOEFMBCJPÏUJDBZRVF
BTJTUJFSBBMPTGPSPTZBTBNCMFBTBOVBMFT
EF '&-"*#& &M QSJNFSP TF SFBMJ[Ø FO
(POOFU "SHFOUJOB FO EJDJFNCSF EF
B×P Z TJUJP EF TV GVOEBDJØO FM
TFHVOEP FO 7JMMB EF -FZWB $PMPNCJB
FM UFSDFSP FO -JNB 1FSÞ FM DVBSUP FO
(VBOBKVBUP .ÏYJDP FM RVJOUP FO 4BP
1BVMP#SBTJM
FOFMDVBMFMTFO
DJMMPGPSPEFB×PTBOUFSJPSFTTFDPOWJSUJØ
FOFM1SJNFS$POHSFTP-BUJOPBNFSJDBOP
EF#JPÏUJDB
1SPTZDPOUSBT
&OMBBDUVBMJEBEMBCJPÏUJDBMBUJOPBNFSJ
DBOBQSFTFOUBBWBODFTZNÏSJUPTBDPN
QB×BEPT EF GBMMBT Z EFmDJFODJBT &OUSF
MBT QSJNFSBT EFCFNPT SFDPOPDFS BMHP
EFEFTPSEFOZGBMUBEFVOJmDBDJØOEFSF
DVSTPTIVNBOPTZFDPOØNJDPTJNQSP
WJTBDJØOTFSFQJUFPNJUFPTFTVTQFOEF
VOBPCSBDFOUSPSFWJTUBFUD
BVTFODJB
EF VOB JEFOUJEBE QSPQJB UFOEFNPT B
SFQFUJS MP RVF TF IBDF FO PUSPT QBÓTFT
FOFTQFDJBMFO&TUBEPTVOJEPTZ&TQB×B
TJOQSPQPOFSOPTVOBCJPÏUJDBDPOGVO
EBNFOUBDJØOUFOEFODJBTUFNBTZQSP
CMFNBTQSPQJPT
ZGBMUBEFJOUFSÏTFOMB
CJPÏUJDB QPS QBSUF EF BMHVOPT &TUBEPT
QSFEPNJOBMPRVFMMBNBSÓBNPTCJPÏUJDB
QSJWBEBPQBSUJDVMBSDVMUJWBEBFOGPSNB
EF DPNJUÏT DPNJTJPOFT DFOUSPT JOTUJ
UVUPT QVCMJDBDJPOFT QSPHSBNBT EF QSF
ZQPTHSBEPFOUSFPUSPTUPEPMPDVBMFT
PSHBOJ[BEPFOCVFOBQBSUFQPSMBTVOJ
WFSTJEBEFTZIPTQJUBMFT1FSPMPT&TUBEPT
PDVQBEPTFOQSPCMFNBTVSHFOUFTEFPS
EFO QÞCMJDP QPMÓUJDP Z FDPOØNJDP OP
BMDBO[BO B QSFTUBS BUFODJØO Z mOBODJB
PERSPETIVADELABIOETICAINDD
DJØOBMBMFHJTMBDJØOZBMFTUBCMFDJNJFO
UP EF MB SFTQFDUJWB DPNJTJØO P DPOTFKP
OBDJPOBMEFCJPÏUJDB&YJTUFNÈTCJPÏUJDB
QPMÓUJDBPQÞCMJDBFO&TUBEPT6OJEPTZ
FO &VSPQB RVF FO OVFTUSPT QBÓTFT MBUJ
OPBNFSJDBOPTZEFM$BSJCF
&OUSF MPT NÏSJUPT FT KVTUP SFDPOPDFS
RVFBQFTBSEFMPTFTDBTPTSFDVSTPTFDP
OØNJDPT Z DJFOUÓmDPT MB CJPÏUJDB TF IB
EFTBSSPMMBEPBNQMJBNFOUFFODBTJUPEPT
MPTQBÓTFTEF-BUJOPBNÏSJDBZRVFTFIBO
PSHBOJ[BEPDVSTPTEFQPTHSBEPEFFTQF
DJBMJ[BDJØONBFTUSÓBZEPDUPSBEP
2VJTJFSB EFTUBDBS MB QSFTFODJB FO DBEB
QBÓTEFBMHVOPTMÓEFSFTRVFWJFOFOQSP
NPWJFOEPMBCJPÏUJDBFOGPSNBEFGPSPT
DVSTPT QVCMJDBDJPOFT &OUSF PUSPT TJO
TFSFYIBVTUJWP
.ÏYJDP
.BOVFM7FMBTDP4VÈSF[
GBMMFDJEP
Z'FSOBOEP$BOP
$PTUB3JDB )FSOÈO$PMMBEP
(VBUFNBMB $BSMPT-BSB3PDIF
1BOBNÈ
&EVBSEP4PVTB-FOOPYZ
-VJT1JDBSE
$VCB
+PTÏ"DPTUBZ%BOJFM1JFESB
1VFSUP3JDP +PSHF'FSSFSZ)FMFOB-VHP
7FOF[VFMB "VHVTUP-FØOZ"MGSFEP
$BTUJMMP7BMMFSZ
&DVBEPS
&NJMJP$FSF[PZ.BSZEF
.BSUÓOF[
1FSÞ
3PCFSUP-MBOPT
$IJMF
'FSOBOEP-PMBTZ"MFKBOESP
4FSBOJ
1BSBHVBZ "MCFSUP-FØO
6SVHVBZ 0NBS'SBODB
#PMJWJB
.JHVFM.BO[BOFSB
#SBTJM
7PMOFJ(BSSBGB+PTÏ&EVBSEP
EF4JRVFJSB-FP1FTTJOJ
$PMPNCJB +BJNF&TDPCBS5SJBOB
'FSOBOEP4ÈODIF[5PSSFT
"MGPOTP-MBOP&TDPCBS
3FQÞCMJDB
%PNJOJDBOB"OESÏT1FSBMUB
1BSBmOFTEFMBEÏDBEBEFMPTQSÈDUJ
DBNFOUFUPEPTMPTQBÓTFTMBUJOPBNFSJDB
1FSTQFDUJWBTEFMB#JPÏUJDBFO*CFSPBNÏSJDB
OPTPSHBOJ[BCBOBDUJWJEBEFTEFCJPÏUJDB
DPOHSFTPTGPSPTQBOFMFTKPSOBEBTDP
NJUÏTIPTQJUBMBSJPTJOTUJUVUPTZDFOUSPT
SFWJTUBTMJCSPTDVSTPTEFQSFZQPTHSBEP
ZEFNBOFSBFTQFDJBMGPSNBCBOBTPDJB
DJPOFTOBDJPOBMFT)BTUBQSÈDUJDB
NFOUFUPEPTMPTQBÓTFTSFBMJ[BOUPEBTP
DBTJUPEBTFTUBTBDUJWJEBEFT
3FGFSFODJBT
(BMJOEP'
&M'FOØNFOPEFMBT4FDUBT'VOEBNFOUBMJTUBT-BDPORVJTUBFWBOHÏMJDB
EF"NÏSJDB-BUJOB/BWBSSB&EJUPSJBM7FSCP%JWJOP
.BJOFUUJ+PTÏ"1JT%JF[(Z5FBMEJ+$
#JPFUIJDTJO-BUJO"NFSJDB*O
-VTUJH"0SH
#JPFUIJDT:FBSCPPL7PM3FHJPOBM%FWFMPQNFOUJO#JPFUIJDT
%PSESFDIU5IF/FUIFSMBOET,MVXFS"DBEFNJD1VCMJTIFSTQQ
1PUUFS7BO3FOTTFMBFS
#JPFUIJDT#SJEHFUPUIF'VUVSF/FX:PSL1SFOUJDF)BMM
3BNTFZ1
5IF1BUJFOUBT1FSTPO&YQMPSBUJPOTJO.FEJDBM&UIJDT/FX)BWFO
:BMF6OJWFSTJUZ1SFTT
3PVY ' 'VOEBNFOUPT EF VOB ÏUJDB DJVEBEBOB *O $PMPNCJB VOB DBTB QBSB
UPEPTEFCBUFÏUJDP4BOUB'FEF#PHPUÈ1SPHSBNBQPSMB1B[$PNQB×ÓBEF+FTÞT
PERSPETIVADELABIOETICAINDD
6OBIJTUPSJBQFSTPOBMEFMBCJPÏUJDBFO"NÏSJDB
-BUJOB&MEFTBGÓPBDUVBMBMBQSPGFTJØONÏEJDBZMB
JOnVFODJBEFMBTFNQSFTBTGBSNBDPRVÓNJDBT
+BNFT%SBOF
-PTQSJODJQJPTEFMBCJPÏUJDB
&
O MPT B×PT %BO $BMMBIBO Z ZP
WJBKBNPTKVOUPTBMSFEFEPSEFMNVO
EP&OBRVFMMBÏQPDB%BOFSBFMDPPS
EJOBEPSEF$PNNPOXFBM.BHB[JOFVOB
SFWJTUBDBUØMJDBEFSFMJHJØOZQPMÓUJDBEF
/VFWB:PSL:PFTUBCBFOMB6OJWFSTJ
EBEEF:BMFFOVOBCFDBMVFHPEFNJ
TVTQFOTJØO EFM TBDFSEPDJP EFCJEP B VO
BSUÓDVMPNÓPRVFBCPHBCBQPSFMDBNCJP
FO MBT FOTF×BO[BT EF MB *HMFTJB TPCSF FM
DPOUSPM EF MB OBUBMJEBE .JFOUSBT %BO
IBDÓBVOBJOWFTUJHBDJØOEFQPMÓUJDBTQÞ
CMJDBTEFMBCPSUPFOEJWFSTBTDVMUVSBTZP
FTUVEJBCBEJWFSTBTQPMÓUJDBTQÞCMJDBTEFM
DPOUSPMEFMBOBUBMJEBE-PRVFSFDVFSEP
NÈT EF FTF UJFNQP FSB RVF ÏM B×PSBCB
BTVFTQPTBZOJ×PTZTFQSFHVOUBCBTJ
OP QPESÓB EFKBS TV USBCBKP FO MB $PN
NPOXFBM QBSB FTUBCMFDFS VO JOTUJUVUP
QBSBFMFTUVEJPEFQSPCMFNBTÏUJDPTFOMB
NFEJDJOBDPOUFNQPSÈOFB
-BTDVFTUJPOFTÏUJDBTFONFEJDJOBFTUB
CBO QSFTFOUFT FO MB DPODJFODJB QÞCMJDB
EFTQVÏTEFMB4FHVOEB(VFSSB.VOEJBM
1SJNFSP MPT DIPDBOUFT DSÓNFOFT ÏUJDPT
EF MPT NÏEJDPT OB[JT SFWFMBEPT FO MPT
KVJDJPT EF /VSFNCFSH %FTQVÏT EF MB
HVFSSBFMHPCJFSOPEF&&66JOWJSUJØ
PERSPETIVADELABIOETICAINDD
DBOUJEBEFTFOPSNFTEFEJOFSPFOJOWFT
UJHBDJØO NÏEJDB -BT DVFTUJPOFT ÏUJDBT
QSFTFOUFT FO MPT QSPZFDUPT EF JOWFTUJ
HBDJØOFSBTVQVFTUBNFOUFTPMVDJPOBEBT
QPS VO FUJDJTUB FQJTDPQBM VO TBDFSEPUF
+PIO'MFUDIFS
FNQMFBEPFOMPT*OTUJUV
UPT/BDJPOBMFTEF4BMVE/*)
1FSPÏM
UFOÓBNVZQPDBBVUPSJEBEZMPTQSPZFD
UPT EF JOWFTUJHBDJØO EFNBTJBEP OVNF
SPTPT DPNP QBSB RVF VOB TPMB QFSTPOB
QVEJFSBTVQFSWJTBSMPTDPOFmDBDJB
-PT GSVUPT EF MB FOPSNF JOWFSTJØO EFM
HPCJFSOPOVFWPTUSBUBNJFOUPTZUFDOP
MPHÓBT MMFHBCBO B MB QSÈDUJDB DMÓOJDB FO
VOB DPSSJFOUF DPOTUBOUF $BEB OVFWP
EFTBSSPMMP TVTDJUBCB QSPCMFNBT ÏUJDPT
FTQFDÓmDPT -BT DVFTUJPOFT BTPDJBEBT BM
QSJODJQJPZFMmOBMEFMBWJEBRVFWFOÓBO
EFBOUFTEFMB4FHVOEB(VFSSB.VOEJBM
TF UPSOBCBO NÈT Z NÈT QSPNJOFOUFT
$VFTUJPOFT BTPDJBEBT B MB QSPDSFBDJØO
DPNPFMBCPSUPZFMDPOUSPMEFMBOBUB
MJEBE FSBO EJTDVUJEBT FYUFOTBNFOUF FO
MPTNFEJPTEFDPNVOJDBDJØOFOMFHJTMB
UVSBTGFEFSBMFTZFTUBUBMFTZFOMBTDPSUFT
-BUFOEFODJBHFOFSBMFSBRVJUBSSFTUSJD
DJPOFTMFHBMFT-BEJTDVTJØOFSBJOUFOTB
Z MB HFOUF CVTDBCB EJTDFSOJNJFOUP ÏUJ
DP-PTDMÓOJDPTOFDFTJUBCBOBZVEBDPO
1FSTQFDUJWBTEFMB#JPÏUJDBFO*CFSPBNÏSJDB
DVFTUJPOFTÏUJDBTDVBOEPMBTUFDOPMPHÓBT
EFMBQPTHVFSSBMMFHBSBOBMPTMFDIPTEFM
IPTQJUBM.VDIBTEFÏTUBTQFSNJUÓBOFY
UFOEFSMBWJEBEFQBDJFOUFTNPSJCVOEPT
ZDSFBSPOEVEBTTPCSFFMQBQFMEFMBNF
EJDJOBVOBWF[RVFVOQBDJFOUFFOUSBCB
FOFMQSPDFTPEFMNPSJS
/P GBMUBCBO MBT DVFTUJPOFT NÈT mMPTØ
mDBTTPCSFMBOBUVSBMF[BEFMBQSPGFTJØO
NÏEJDBZMBTNFUBTEFMBNFEJDJOB&O
MPTB×PTIBCÓBQSPCMFNBTÏUJDPTFO
UPEPT MPT BTQFDUPT EF ÏTUB RVF SFRVF
SÓBO FTUVEJP TFSJP PSJFOUBDJPOFT QBSB
MPT QSPGFTJPOBMFT Z QPMÓUJDBT QÞCMJDBT
FmDBDFT
%BOZZPIBCMÈCBNPTEFFTPTUFNBTEV
SBOUFOVFTUSPTSFDPSSJEPT4PCSFMBQSPMJ
GFSBDJØOEFMPTQSPCMFNBTÏUJDPTDSFBEPT
QPSMBNFEJDJOBDJFOUÓmDBDPOUFNQPSÈ
OFB OP IBCÓB EVEB -B JODFSUJEVNCSF
FSB TBCFS TJ TF QPESÓB FODPOUSBS BZVEB
mOBODJFSB QBSB FTUBCMFDFS VO JOTUJUVUP
QBSBFMFTUVEJPEFMPTQSPCMFNBTÏUJDPT
FO NFEJDJOB {1PESÓB ÏM FODPOUSBS CBT
UBOUFTSFDVSTPTQBSBDPNFO[BSVOJOTUJ
UVUPDPNPÏTUF $VBOEP SFUPSOBNPT EF FTF WJBKF %BO
QVCMJDØ TV MJCSP TPCSF FM BCPSUP RVF
UFOESÓB VO JNQBDUP JNQPSUBOUF FO MPT
KVFDFT EF MB $PSUF 4VQSFNB OPSUFBNF
SJDBOB DVBOEP TF TFOUFODJØ FM DBTP 3PF
WT 8BEF %FTQVÏT ÏM SFDJCJØ MB BZVEB
mOBODJFSB RVF OFDFTJUBCB EFKØ TV QP
TJDJØO FO $PNNPOXFBM Z DPNFO[Ø FM
)BTUJOHT $FOUFS FO &TF QSJNFS
JOTUJUVUPEFÏUJDBNÏEJDBNBSDØVOQBTP
JNQPSUBOUF IBDJB FM FTUBCMFDJNJFOUP EF
VOB OVFWB EJTDJQMJOB BDBEÏNJDB RVF
PERSPETIVADELABIOETICAINDD
WJOPBMMBNBSTFiCJPÏUJDBw&MUÏSNJOPTF
BUSJCVZFB7BO3FOTTFMBFS1PUUFSDVZP
MJCSP #JPFUIJDT #SJEHF UP UIF GVUVSF GVF
QVCMJDBEPFO
"DUVBMNFOUF FT JOJNBHJOBCMF MB JEFB
EFMBNFEJDJOBBQBSUBEBEFMBCJPÏUJDB
FOFMTFOUJEPEFVOBOÈMJTJTGPSNBMZTJT
UFNÈUJDP-BOVFWBCJPÏUJDBFSBNVDIP
NÈTBNQMJBZNÈTDPNQMFKBRVFMBÏUJDB
NÏEJDBUSBEJDJPOBM6OBWF[FTUBCMFDJEB
TFEJTFNJOØSÈQJEBNFOUFBMSFEFEPSEFM
NVOEP Z FT IPZ VOB EF MBT EJTDJQMJOBT
RVF EFmOFO OVFTUSB ÏQPDB /BEJF QP
ESÓB QSFTVNJS FOUFOEFS MB DVMUVSB NF
EJFWBMTJOFTUVEJBSTFSJBNFOUFMBUFPMPHÓB
Z FO FM GVUVSP OBEJF QPESÈ FOUFOEFS
MB DVMUVSB NÏEJDB EF IPZ TJO FTUVEJBS
MB CJPÏUJDB -B EJTDJQMJOB EF MB CJPÏUJDB
OPTEFmOFQPSRVFMBNFEJDJOBZMBTBMVE
TPOIPZQBSBOPTPUSPTMPRVFGVFSPOMB
SFMJHJØOZMBTBMWBDJØOQBSBMBHFOUFEF
MB&EBE.FEJB&OGFSNFEBEFTDJSVHÓBT
FYQFSJNFOUPTFOWFKFDJNJFOUPNFKPSÓBT
HFOÏUJDB FOUSF PUSPT QSPCMFNBT OPT
QSFPDVQBO Z OPT JEFOUJmDBO -BT QSF
HVOUBTÏUJDBTTFMJHBODPODBEBBTQFDUP
EFMBNFEJDJOBDPOUFNQPSÈOFB-BTBTP
DJBDJPOFT QSPGFTJPOBMFT DPNP MB 0SHB
OJ[BDJØO.VOEJBMEFMB4BMVE0.4
MB
0SHBOJ[BDJØO1BOBNFSJDBOBEFMB4BMVE
014
MB"NFSJDBO.FEJDBM"TTPDJBUJPOT
"."
ZBTPDJBDJPOFTNÏEJDBTTJNJMBSFT
FODBEBQBÓTUJFOFORVFQSFPDVQBSTFQPS
MPT FTUÈOEBSFT ÏUJDPT QBSB MB JOWFTUJHB
DJØOZMBQSÈDUJDBNÏEJDBT
1PUUFS7BO3FOTTFMBFS
#JPFUIJDT#SJE
HFUPUIF'VUVSF&OHMFXPPE$MJĊT/+1SFO
UJDF)BMM
6OBIJTUPSJBQFSTPOBMEFMBCJPÏUJDBFO"NÏSJDB-BUJOB+BNFT%SBOF
)BDJBmOBMFTEFMTJHMP9*9ZDPNJFO[PT
EFM 99 MBT BTPDJBDJPOFT NÏEJDBT Z MBT
BVUPSJEBEFTBMFNBOBTIBCÓBOEFTBSSPMMB
EPSFHMBTÏUJDBTQBSBMBJOWFTUJHBDJØOZMB
QSÈDUJDBNÏEJDBT4BCFNPTTJOFNCBS
HP RVF SÈQJEBNFOUF FTBT OPSNBT GVF
SPO SFDIB[BEBT QPS MPT NÏEJDPT OB[JT
RVJFOFTTVCTUJUVZFSPOMBCBTFDMÈTJDBEFM
BNPS B MB IVNBOJEBE FYQSFTBEB FO FM
$ØEJHP )JQPDSÈUJDP QPS VOB DSFFODJB
FOMBFVHFOFTJB
&O/VSFNCFSHEFTQVÏTEFMB4FHVOEB
(VFSSB .VOEJBM TF SFBMJ[BSPO KVJDJPT
QBSBUSBUBSMPTDSÓNFOFTDPOUSBMBIVNB
OJEBEDPNFUJEPTQPSNÏEJDPT-PTKVF
DFT FO /VSFNCFSH GPSNVMBSPO TV QSP
QJP DØEJHP ÏUJDP QBSB MB JOWFTUJHBDJØO
NÏEJDB1FSPFTFDØEJHPOPFSBEJGFSFOUF
EFMBTSFHVMBDJPOFTBMFNBOBTSFDIB[BEBT
UBOFWJEFOUFNFOUFQPSMPTNÏEJDPTOB
[JT-PRVFGBDJMJUØMBTWJPMBDJPOFTÏUJDBT
OB[JTOPGVFMBBVTFODJBEFSFHVMBDJPOFT
ÏUJDBTTJOPMBDBSFODJBEFVOBWJHJMBODJB
DPOUJOVBEBQPSMBTPSHBOJ[BDJPOFTQSP
GFTJPOBMFT VOB TVQFSWJTJØO QSPGFTJPOBM
EFMBTBDUJWJEBEFTNÏEJDBTZVOÏOGBTJT
FO MPT DPNQPOFOUFT ÏUJDPT EF MB NFEJ
DJOBQSPGFTJPOBM&TBFTVOBMFDDJØORVF
OPTFQVFEFPMWJEBSTJOFMQFMJHSPEFRVF
BMHPTJNJMBSTVDFEBEFOVFWP
)BCMP EF MB %JSFDUJWF PO )VNBO &YQFSJNFO
UBUJPO QSPNVMHBEB QPS FM .JOJTUSP 1SVTJBOP
EF "TVOUPT 3FMJHJPTPT &EVDBUJWPT Z .ÏEJDPT
FO&OFM.JOJTUSPEFM*OUFSJPSEFM
3FJDIQVCMJDØOPSNBTÏUJDBTDMBSBTZDPODSFUBT
QBSBMBJOWFTUJHBDJØODPOTFSFTIVNBOPT4FUSB
UBCBEFOPSNBTBÞONÈTFTQFDÓmDBTZEFNÈT
MBSHP BMDBODF RVF MBT QSJNFSBT EJSFDUSJDFT EF
/VSFNCFSHZ)FMTJOLJ
PERSPETIVADELABIOETICAINDD
&M $ØEJHP EF /VSFNCFSH GVF TFHVJEP
QPSMBTEJSFDUSJDFTÏUJDBTRVFQSPNVMHB
SPOFMHPCJFSOPEF&&66MB"TPDJB
DJØO.ÏEJDB.VOEJBM8."
MB"TP
DJBDJØO.ÏEJDB"NFSJDBOB"."
ZMB
%FDMBSBDJØOEF)FMTJOLJ&OMPTB×PT
TF QVCMJDBSPO NVDIPT BSUÓDVMPT TPCSF
JOWFTUJHBDJØO NÏEJDB FO &&66 QFSP
TJOEBSNVDIBBUFODJØOBMBTDVFTUJPOFT
ÏUJDBTQPSRVFTFQFOTBCBRVFFM$ØEJHP
Z MBT SFHVMBDJPOFT TVCTFDVFOUFT IBCÓBO
QSPQPSDJPOBEP VOB EJSFDDJØO NÈT RVF
BEFDVBEB QBSB FWJUBS QSPCMFNBT ÏUJDPT
"EFNÈTMBTWJPMBDJPOFTÏUJDBTDPNFUJEBT
QPSMPTNÏEJDPTOB[JTQFOTBCBMBHFOUF
OPQPESÓBOTVDFEFSFO"NÏSJDB
&OUPODFTFO)FOSZ,#FFDIFS
QSPGFTPS EF BOFTUFTJB FO MB VOJWFSTJEBE
EF )BSWBSE QVCMJDØ FO DzF /FX &O
HMBOE +PVSOBM PG .FEJDJOF VO BSUÓDVMP
RVFEFUBMMBCBBMSFEFEPSEFQSPZFDUPT
EF JOWFTUJHBDJØO RVF WJPMBCBO FTUÈOEB
SFT ÏUJDPT &SB JOEFDFOUF MB TFNFKBO[B
FOUSFUBMFTGBMUBTZMBTRVFIBCÓBODPNF
UJEPMPTOB[JT-BTWJPMBDJPOFTÏUJDBTRVF
FMEPDUPS#FFDIFSSFWFMØUVWJFSPODPNP
WÓDUJNBTBQBDJFOUFTWVMOFSBCMFTVTBSPO
FMEJOFSPEFMHPCJFSOPZQSPCBCMFNFO
UFUVWJFSPODPNPBHFOUFTBCVFOPTNÏ
EJDPTBNFSJDBOPT
3FHMBTZOPSNBTFYJTUÓBOEFTEFNVDIP
BOUFT -P RVF OP FYJTUÓB FSB MB FmDB[
TVQFSWJTJØO JO TJUV EF MB JOWFTUJHBDJØO
.VDIBTWÓDUJNBTFSBOQBDJFOUFTRVFIB
CÓBOJEPBQFEJSBZVEBBTVTEPDUPSFTZTF
#FFDIFS)FOSZ,
&UIJDBMBOE$MJOJ
DBM3FTFBSDI/FX&OHMBOE+PVSOBMPG.FEJDJOF
QQ
1FSTQFDUJWBTEFMB#JPÏUJDBFO*CFSPBNÏSJDB
DPOWJSUJFSPOFOTVKFUPTEFJOWFTUJHBDJØO
TJOTFSJOGPSNBEPTPTJOEBSTVDPOTFO
UJNJFOUP-PTDPOUSPMFTÏUJDPTFTUBCMFDJ
EPTOPGVODJPOBCBOQPSRVFMPTNÏEJDPT
Z MPT JOWFTUJHBEPSFT UFOÓBO JODFOUJWPT
QFSTPOBMFTQBSBQFSTFHVJSMPTRVFDSFÓBO
PCKFUJWPTDJFOUÓmDPTJNQPSUBOUFT
-BT SFWFMBDJPOFT EFM EPDUPS )FOSZ
#FFDIFS TF×BMBSPO MB OFDFTJEBE EF VOB
FYUFOTB SFGPSNB FO MB FEVDBDJØO Z MB
QSÈDUJDBNÏEJDBT6SHÓBNÈTTVQFSWJTJØO
QPS FM HPCJFSOP Z QPS PSHBOJ[BDJPOFT
QSPGFTJPOBMFT NÏEJDBT -B JEFB EF %BO
$BMMBIBOEFVOJOTUJUVUPQBSBFMFTUVEJP
EFDVFTUJPOFTÏUJDBTFOMBJOWFTUJHBDJØO
NÏEJDB Z MB QSÈDUJDB DMÓOJDB QBSFDÓB VO
QBTPNVZBQSPQJBEP
&MQBQFMEFMB0SHBOJ[BDJØO
1BOBNFSJDBOBEF4BMVE014
-B0SHBOJ[BDJØO.VOEJBMEF4BMVEFY
QSFTØ TV DPNQSPNJTP DPO MB ÏUJDB FO
NFEJDJOBFOFMQSFÈNCVMPEFTVDPOTUJ
UVDJØO-B0SHBOJ[BDJØO1BOBNFSJDBOB
EF4BMVEIBCÓBIFDIPMPNJTNPNVDIP
BOUFT Z FTUBCMFDJØ VO $PNJUÏ EF ²UJDB
FO8BTIJOHUPOQBSBFYBNJOBSUPEPTMPT
QSPZFDUPTEFJOWFTUJHBDJØOEFOUSPEFTV
SFHJØO &M EPDUPS (FPSHF "MMFZOF MVF
HPEJSFDUPSEFMB014EJSJHJØFMDPNJUÏ
JOTUJUVDJPOBMEFÏUJDBEFMB014QPSNV
DIPT B×PT %VSBOUF TVT B×PT DPNP EJ
SFDUPS NBOUVWP FM ÏOGBTJT
FOMBÏUJDBEFOUSPEFMBPSHBOJ[BDJØO
&M EPDUPS $BSMJMF (VFSSB EF .BDFEP
EVSBOUF TV QFSÓPEP DPNP EJSFDUPS EF
MB014
SFDPOPDJØRVFMB
SFWJTJØO EF MPT QSPZFDUPT EF JOWFTUJHB
PERSPETIVADELABIOETICAINDD
DJØO OP FSB TVmDJFOUF QBSB HBSBOUJ[BS
FM SFTQFUP IBDJB MPT TVKFUPT IVNBOPT
#BKPTVBENJOJTUSBDJØOTFPSHBOJ[ØVOB
DPOGFSFODJB TPCSF CJPÏUJDB FO "NÏSJDB
-BUJOB -BT QVCMJDBDJPOFT EF CJPÏUJ
DB PSJHJOBEBT EF MB PmDJOB EF MB 014
FO 8BTIJOHUPO GVFSPO EJTUSJCVJEBT FO
MPT QBÓTFT MBUJOPBNFSJDBOPT 1FSP FTP
OPFSBTVmDJFOUF4FSFRVFSÓBBEFNÈT
QSFQBSBSBMPTMBUJOPBNFSJDBOPTFOCJP
ÏUJDBZEFTQVÏTPSHBOJ[BSDPNJUÏTJOT
UJUVDJPOBMFTEFSFWJTJØOQBSBTVQFSWJTBS
BDUJWJEBEFTEFJOWFTUJHBDJØOJOTJUV&TB
OFDFTJEBESFRVFSÓBEFMB014VOOVFWP
DPNQSPNJTP FO MVHBS EF TFS VO QSP
ZFDUP MJHBEP B 8BTIJOHUPO TF EFDJEJØ
FOUSFOBSFOCJPÏUJDBBQSPGFTJPOBMFTFO
DBEBQBÓTEF"NÏSJDB-BUJOBZEFM$B
SJCFDPOFMmOEFDFSDJPSBSTFEFRVFMB
JOWFTUJHBDJØOMBQSÈDUJDBZMBFEVDBDJØO
NÏEJDBTFTUVWJFTFODPNQSPNFUJEBTDPO
MBOVFWBEJTDJQMJOB
6OBGBMUBÏUJDBDPNQMFKBNPUJWØMBEF
DJTJØO EF BNQMJBS MPT QSPZFDUPT CJPÏUJ
DPT EF MB 014 $JFSUBT DPNQB×ÓBT GBS
NBDÏVUJDBT BNFSJDBOBT EFTFBCBO IBDFS
GVFSBEF&&66MPTFOTBZPTSFRVFSJEPT
QBSBMBBQSPCBDJØOEFESPHBT&OQBÓTFT
NÈTQPCSFTEF"NÏSJDB-BUJOBFSBNÈT
GÈDJMSFDMVUBSTVKFUPTQBSBFTUPTFOTBZPT
UBNCJÏO MP FSB FWJUBS MBT SFTUSJDDJPOFT
JNQVFTUBTQPSFMHPCJFSOPZMBTBTPDJB
DJPOFTNÏEJDBTQSPGFTJPOBMFTEF&&66
$VBOEPBMHÞOFOTBZPDPOESPHBTDBVTØ
DPOTFDVFODJBTQFSKVEJDJBMFTQBSBMPTTV
KFUPTTPCSFUPEPNVKFSFT
MB014GVF
DVMQBEBQPSMBTGBMUBT&TPDSFØVOBDSJ
TJT6OBDPOTFDVFODJBGVFMBEFDJTJØOEF
DSFBS DPNJUÏT EF TVQFSWJTJØO ÏUJDB FO
6OBIJTUPSJBQFSTPOBMEFMBCJPÏUJDBFO"NÏSJDB-BUJOB+BNFT%SBOF
DBEB QBÓT QBSB QSPWFFS EJSFDUBNFOUF MB
TVQFSWJTJØO EF MB JOWFTUJHBDJØO NÏEJDB
FO TVKFUPT IVNBOPT $PMBCPSÏ DPO MB
014QBSBFTUBCMFDFSFTFQSPZFDUP
'VFSPOBMHVOBTUSBOTHSFTJPOFTÏUJDBTEF
MBTDPNQB×ÓBTGBSNBDÏVUJDBTQFSTJHVJFO
EPTVTJOUFSFTFTFDPOØNJDPTMPRVFDSFØ
MBOFDFTJEBEEFUSBFSMBCJPÏUJDBEFVOB
NBOFSBNÈTBHSFTJWBB"NÏSJDB-BUJOB
4FIBIFDIPNVDIPQFSPRVFEBCBTUBO
UF QPS IBDFS 4FHVJSFNPT WJODVMBEPT B
USBWÏT EF MPT WBMPSFT RVF DPNQBSUJNPT
ZUBNCJÏOQPSMBOFDFTJEBEEFBGSPOUBS
BNFOB[BTBMBNFEJDJOBQSPGFTJPOBMRVF
UPEBWÓBOPTBGFDUBO
1BSUJDJQÏFOFMQSPZFDUPEFCJPÏUJDBFO
MB014EVSBOUFMPTB×PT&OMPTDP
NJFO[PTEFMPTWJBKÏQPSUPEBMBSF
HJØOQBSBJEFOUJmDBSQFSTPOBTRVFRVF
SÓBOUSBCBKBSFOFTFDBNQP5SBCBKÏDPO
MBTPmDJOBTEFMB014FODBEBQBÓTWJTJUÏ
ØSHBOPTPmDJBMFTEFHPCJFSOPZIPTQJUB
MFTEFVOJWFSTJEBEFTZFTDVFMBTNÏEJDBT
QBSBJOGPSNBSBMBTQFSTPOBTJOUFSFTBEBT
TPCSFFMQMBOEFMB014-PRVFDPNV
OJRVÏFONJTDPOUBDUPTGVFMBOFDFTJEBE
VSHFOUFEFVOBCJPÏUJDBRVFGVODJPOBTF
MPDBMNFOUFFOUPEBMBSFHJØOQBSBUSBUBS
MPTQSPCMFNBTÏUJDPTFOMBQSÈDUJDBDMÓOJDB
ZFOMBJOWFTUJHBDJØONÏEJDB5BNCJÏO
DPNVOJRVÏ NJ DPOWJDDJØO QFSTPOBM EF
RVF VOB CJPÏUJDB MBUJOPBNFSJDBOB UFO
ESÓB RVF TFS EFTBSSPMMBEB QBSB BNQMJBS
FOSJRVFDFSZFOBMHVOPTDBTPTDPSSFHJS
MBTQFSTQFDUJWBTOPSUFBNFSJDBOBTZFVSP
QFBT&TFQSPZFDUPNBSDØFMQSJODJQJPEF
FTUBEJTDJQMJOBFO"NÏSJDB-BUJOBQSP
NPWJEB Z QBUSPDJOBEB QPS VOB PSHBOJ
PERSPETIVADELABIOETICAINDD
[BDJØONÏEJDBEFMBSHPBMDBODF014
SFTQPOTBCMFQPSFMDBSÈDUFSZMBDBMJEBE
EFMBNFEJDJOBFOMBSFHJØO
6OB DPTB FT TFHVSB FO MPT B×PT WFOJ
EFSPT MB CJPÏUJDB OP WB B EFDMJOBS FO
JNQPSUBODJBPSFUSPDFEFSFOMBTQSFPDV
QBDJPOFT QSJPSJUBSJBT EF PSHBOJ[BDJPOFT
QSPGFTJPOBMFT DPNP MB 014 &TP OP
QVFEF PDVSSJS QPSRVF IBZ JODMVTP NB
ZPSFT QFMJHSPT IPZ RVF MPT QSFTFOUBEPT
QPS MBT WJPMBDJPOFT ÏUJDBT BOUFSJPSFT 4F
IBO SFBMJ[BEP EJWFSTPT DPOHSFTPT Z TF
NJOBSJPTTPCSFÏUJDBFOMBJOWFTUJHBDJØO
NÏEJDBZTFIBEFNPTUSBEPMBOFDFTJEBE
EFDPOUJOVBSMBBZVEBBMB014ZPUSPT
QSPHSBNBTJOEFQFOEJFOUFT-BTDVFTUJP
OFTCJPÏUJDBTTPCSFQBTBOFMÈSFBEFMBJO
WFTUJHBDJØONÏEJDB)PZMBQSPQJBBMNB
EFMBQSPGFTJØONÏEJDBFTUÈFOQFMJHSP
)FOSZ #FFDIFS FT VOP EF MPT HJHBOUFT
EFMBÏUJDBNÏEJDB*NQVMTØBHPCJFSOPT
PSHBOJ[BDJPOFT EF TBMVE Z BTPDJBDJPOFT
EF JOWFTUJHBDJØO B EFTBSSPMMBS SFHMBT Z
QPMÓUJDBTÏUJDBTFTQFDJBMNFOUFFOFMÈSFB
EFM DPOTFOUJNJFOUP JOGPSNBEP 1FSP
IJ[PNÈTRVFFTP&OTVMJCSPEFmOFT
EF MPT TF×BMØ RVF QPS HSBOEF RVF
TFB TV JNQPSUBODJB MBT SFHMBT ÏUJDBT FO
NFEJDJOB OVODB TFSÈO TVmDJFOUFT QBSB
IBDFS MB NFEJDJOB WFSEBEFSBNFOUF ÏUJ
DB&OTVUSBCBKPmOBMFYQSFTØRVFTØMP
QSPGFTJPOBMFTNÏEJDPTDBQBDFTJOGPSNB
EPTDPNQBTJWPTZSFTQPOTBCMFTQVFEFO
0USBWFSTJØOEFMBIJTUPSJBEFMBCJPÏUJDBJCFSP
BNFSJDBOBFT%SBOF+BNFT'
#JPFUIJ
DBM1FSTQFDUJWFT'SPN*CFSP"NFSJDBDzF+PVS
OBMPG.FEJDJOFBOE1IJMPTPQIZ
#FFDIFS)FOSZ,.%
3FTFBSDIBOE
UIF*OEJWJEVBM.BTT-JUUMF#SPXOBOE$P
1FSTQFDUJWBTEFMB#JPÏUJDBFO*CFSPBNÏSJDB
BTFHVSBS RVF MB NFEJDJOB DVNQMB TVT
PCKFUJWPTÏUJDPT&MQSPZFDUPMBUJOPBNF
SJDBOP EF MB CJPÏUJDB RVF TF PSJHJOB FO
MB 014 BTQJSBCB B DSFBS MB TVQFSWJTJØO
FmDB[EFMBJOWFTUJHBDJØOZGPSNBSQSP
GFTJPOBMFTNÏEJDPTDPNQSPNFUJEPTDPO
MPT BMUPT JEFBMFT ÏUJDPT EF MB NFEJDJOB
QSPGFTJPOBM
6OQSPZFDUPCJPÏUJDPFODVSTP
%VSBOUF NJT SFDPSSJEPT B USBWÏT EF
"NÏSJDB-BUJOBFODPOUSÏNVDIPTNÏEJ
DPTJOUFSFTBEPTFOMBOVFWBEJTDJQMJOBZ
QFSTPOBTRVFIBDÓBOZBMPRVFZPJOUFO
UBCB QSPNPWFS &O "SHFOUJOB TBCÓB EF
VOQSPHSBNBFOIVNBOJEBEFTNÏEJDBT
CBKP MB EJSFDDJØO EF +PTÏ "MCFSUP .BJ
OFUUJ²MZZPGVJNPTGPSNBEPTFOÏUJDB
NÏEJDBQPSMPTNJTNPTJOUFMFDUVBMFTFT
QB×PMFT+PTÏ"MCFSUPQSPQPSDJPOØVOB
BZVEBJNQPSUBOUFQBSBFMEJTF×PEFVO
QSPZFDUPEFCJPÏUJDBEFMB014BUSBWÏT
EF"NÏSJDB-BUJOB%FTEFTVTJEFBTZMBT
EFNJFNCSPTEFMBTPmDJOBTMFHBMFTEFMB
014ZEFQSPGFTJPOBMFTNÏEJDPTFOMPT
EJGFSFOUFT QBÓTFT FNFSHJØ VO QSPZFDUP
MBUJOPBNFSJDBOPEFCJPÏUJDBFTUBCMFDJEP
FO4BOUJBHPEF$IJMFRVFSFQSFTFOUØVO
FTGVFS[PEFDPMBCPSBDJØOFOUSFMB014
MB 6OJWFSTJEBE EF $IJMF Z FM HPCJFSOP
DIJMFOP
"×PTEFTQVÏTVOMJCSPEFNJBVUPSÓBIBTJEP
QVCMJDBEPFOMPT&&665SBUBCBEFMBWJSUVE
ZEFMDBSÈDUFSFOMBÏUJDBNÏEJDB$G%SBOF+B
NFT'#FDPNJOH"(PPE%PDUPS,BOTBT
$JUZ 4IFFE BOE 8BSE )B TJEP USBEVDJEP BM
FTQB×PM Z FTUÈ EJTQPOJCMF FO "NÏSJDB -BUJOB
%SBOF+'
{$ØNPTFSVOCVFONÏEJDP 4BOUBGÏEF#PHPUÈ4BO1BCMP
.FSFmFSPB+PTÏ-VJT"SBOHVSFOZ1FESP-BÓO
&OUSBMHP
PERSPETIVADELABIOETICAINDD
.JGPSNBDJØOBDBEÏNJDBQFSTPOBMJODMV
ZØMBUFPMPHÓBDBUØMJDBFOMB6OJWFSTJEBE
(SFHPSJBOBFO3PNBZmMPTPGÓBÏUJDBFO
MB6OJWFSTJEBEEF.BESJE.ÈTBEFMBOUF
FTUVEJÏ NFEJDJOB F IJDF VOB SFTJEFODJB
FO QTJRVJBUSÓB DPO ,BSM .FOOJOHFS FO
5PQFLB ,BOTBT %FCJEP B NJ GPSNB
DJØOFOUFPMPHÓBDPOPDÓBBMPTUFØMPHPT
MBUJOPBNFSJDBOPT %VSBOUF NJT SFDP
SSJEPTWJTJUÏBBMHVOPTRVFHP[BCBOEF
SFDPOPDJNJFOUP JOUFSOBDJPOBM Z UFOÓBO
JOUFSÏT QBSUJDVMBS FO MB KVTUJDJB TPDJBM
JODMVZFOEP MB BQMJDBDJØO EF MB KVTUJDJB
BMDVJEBEPNÏEJDP5BNCJÏOIJDFDPO
UBDUP DPO WBSJPT KFSBSDBT DBUØMJDPT QPS
FKFNQMP FM $BSEFOBM &WBSJTUP "SOT
:P KV[HBCB JNQPSUBOUF EFTBSSPMMBS VOB
QFSTQFDUJWB TPDJBM EF MB KVTUJDJB FO CJP
ÏUJDBRVFFO&&66Z&VSPQBFSBFO
FMNFKPSEFMPTDBTPTVOBQSFPDVQBDJØO
NBSHJOBM -BT VOJWFSTJEBEFT DBUØMJDBT Z
MBTFTDVFMBTNÏEJDBTRVFWJTJUÏUFOÓBOZB
VO DPNQPOFOUF EF ÏUJDB RVF EFTFBCBO
BNQMJBS&OQPDPTB×PTDPOMBBZVEBEF
VOB CBTF EF ÏUJDB NÏEJDB ZB FYJTUFOUF
TF FTUBCMFDJØ VOB OVFWB EJTDJQMJOB MBUJ
OPBNFSJDBOBEFCJPÏUJDBZDPNFO[ØTV
QSPQJPEFTBSSPMMP
&OIBCMÏFOMBDFSFNPOJBEFMBJO
BVHVSBDJØOEFM1SPHSBNBEF#JPÏUJDBFO
4BOUJBHPEF$IJMF%JF[B×PTNÈTUBSEF
FO FYQVTF FO MB 6OJWFSTJEBE EF
$IJMF JOUFOUBOEP EFTDSJCJS DØNP IB
CÓBNPTQSPDFEJEPFOFMEFTBSSPMMPEFMB
CJPÏUJDB Z DØNP UFOÓBNPT UPEBWÓB RVF
BWBO[BSÏTUBOPEFCFSÓBEFDMJOBSFOJN
QPSUBODJB QFSP QPESÓB GBMMBS B NFOPT
RVF DJFSUPT QFMJHSPT GVFSBO SFDPOPDJ
EPT&OFTBDIBSMBNFSFGFSÓBBTQFDUPT
6OBIJTUPSJBQFSTPOBMEFMBCJPÏUJDBFO"NÏSJDB-BUJOB+BNFT%SBOF
JNQPSUBOUFTEFMBQSPGFTJØONÏEJDBRVF
QJFOTP FTUÈO IPZ CBKP BNFOB[B Z RVF
MB CJPÏUJDB EFCF BCPSEBS &O SFBMJEBE
FTUÈO NÈT BNFOB[BEPT UBM WF[ IPZ RVF
FO
-BTWJPMBDJPOFTEFFTUÈOEBSFTEFMBJOWFT
UJHBDJØONÏEJDBQPSMBTDPNQB×ÓBTGBS
NBDÏVUJDBTIBCÓBOHFOFSBEPMBDBNQB×B
PSJHJOBMEFCJPÏUJDBFO014ZNJJNQMJ
DBDJØOQFSTPOBMDPOMBCJPÏUJDBFO"NÏ
SJDB-BUJOB&MMBTOPIBOEFTBQBSFDJEP
-PTB×PTNPTUSBSPORVFIBCÓBNÏEJDPT
RVF USBCBKBCBO FO MB NFEJDJOB DMÓOJDB
DPOWFSUJEPT FO WFOEFEPSFT EF BMHVOBT
DPNQB×ÓBTGBSNBDÏVUJDBTZQSPNPUPSFT
EFDJFSUBTESPHBT&OMPTB×PTIBCÓB
VOBBNFOB[BBMBQSPGFTJØONÏEJDBRVF
QSPWFOÓB EF MBT DPNQB×ÓBT GBSNBDÏVUJ
DBT Z FTP TJHVF TVDFEJFOEP EFTQVÏT EF
UPEP MP RVF TF IB IFDIP EVSBOUF FTUF
QSJNFS QFSÓPEP 6O FOMBDF FOUSF CJPF
UJDJTUBTEFMBQSJNFSBHFOFSBDJØOoDPNP
ZPoZMPTRVFBIPSBFTUÈOMMFWBOEPFTB
CBOEFSBFTMBQSFPDVQBDJØODPNÞOQPS
MBJOnVFODJBEFVOBJOEVTUSJBBHSFTJWB
NFOUFDBQJUBMJTUBTPCSFMBQSPGFTJØONÏ
EJDBMBQSÈDUJDBEFMBNFEJDJOBZMBÏUJDB
QFSTPOBMEFMPTNÏEJDPT
4JO VO GVFSUF DPNQSPNJTP DPO FTUÈO
EBSFT ÏUJDPT USBEJDJPOBMFT Z QSJODJQJPT
CJPÏUJDPTMBNFEJDJOBQJFSEFTVDBSÈDUFS
QSPGFTJPOBMZMPTNÏEJDPTTFQSFDJQJUBO
IBDJB MB DPOEJDJØO EF FNQMFBEPT -B
NBOFSBNÈTSÈQJEBEFEFTUSVJSMBNFEJ
DJOBDPNPQSPGFTJØOFTOPIBDFSDBTPP
SFEVDJS MB JNQPSUBODJB EF MB CJPÏUJDB Z
EFMBTPCMJHBDJPOFTÏUJDBTQSPGFTJPOBMFT
$BEBGBMUBÏUJDBFOMBJOWFTUJHBDJØONÏ
PERSPETIVADELABIOETICAINDD
EJDBPMBQSÈDUJDBDMÓOJDBJOWJUBBMDPOUSPM
FYUFSJPSZDPOFYDFTJWPDPOUSPMFYUFSOP
MBQSPGFTJØONÏEJDBEFTBQBSFDF
-BJOnVFODJBEFMBJOEVTUSJB
GBSNBDÏVUJDB
-BJOEVTUSJBGBSNBDÏVUJDBUJFOFDBEBEÓB
NÈTDPOUSPMEFMBJOWFTUJHBDJØONÏEJDB
4VJOnVFODJBFTFOPSNFQBSBEFUFSNJOBS
RVÏESPHBTTPOBQSPCBEBT$VBOEPVOB
ESPHBFTUÈFOFMNFSDBEPMBJOEVTUSJBTF
NPWJMJ[BQBSBJOTUSVJSBMPTNÏEJDPT-B
JOTUSVDDJØOIJTUØSJDBNFOUFZQPSEFmOJ
DJØOPGSFDJEBQPSMBVOJWFSTJEBEoZCBKP
FMDPOUSPMEFMBQSPGFTJØOoFTUÈTJFOEP
HSBEVBMNFOUF SFBMJ[BEB QPS HJHBOUFTDBT
DPNQB×ÓBTGBSNBDÏVUJDBT-BFEVDBDJØO
DPOUJOVBFTOFDFTBSJBQBSBDPOTFSWBSMB
DPNQFUFODJB QSPGFTJPOBM NÏEJDB -BT
SFVOJPOFT RVF QSPQPSDJPOBO DSÏEJUPT
EFGPSNBDJØOQFSNBOFOUFQBSBNÏEJDPT
TPOPSHBOJ[BEBTDBEBWF[NÈTGSFDVFOUF
NFOUFQPSMBTDPNQB×ÓBTGBSNBDÏVUJDBT
&MMBTQVCMJDJUBOQBHBOMPTDPOGFSFODJT
UBTZFMJHFOMPTBTVOUPTRVFTFUSBUBSÈO
.VDIPT EF MPT DPOGFSFODJTUBT TPO FN
QMFBEPTEFMBTDPNQB×ÓBT-BFEVDBDJØO
DPUJEJBOB PDVSSF FO MBT PmDJOBT EF MPT
NÏEJDPT QSPQPSDJPOBEB QPS WFOEFEP
SFT EF DPNQB×ÓBT GBSNBDÏVUJDBT " MPT
FODBSHBEPTEFWFOUBTTFMFTFOTF×BDØNP
NBOJQVMBSBMPTNÏEJDPTNÈTRVFBQSP
QPSDJPOBSJOGPSNBDJPOFTDJFOUÓmDBT
&MTJTUFNBEFBQSPCBDJØOEFNFEJDBDJP
OFT FTUÈ JOnVFODJBEP QPS MB JOEVTUSJB
GBSNBDÏVUJDBZQPSMPUBOUPMBNBZPSÓB
EFMBTOVFWBTESPHBTBQSPCBEBTOPTPO
OVFWBTUFSBQJBTTJOPBNFOVEPJNJUB
1FSTQFDUJWBTEFMB#JPÏUJDBFO*CFSPBNÏSJDB
DJPOFT EF ESPHBT ZB EJTQPOJCMFT -PT
WFOEFEPSFT FOUSFHBO SFHBMPT B MPT NÏ
EJDPTJOWJUBOBTVTGBNJMJBTBMBTDFOBT
ZPUSPTUJQPTEFEJWFSTJØOBRVFMMPTRVF
SFDIB[BONBOJQVMBSFJOTJTUFOFOTFSIP
OFTUPT TPCSF MBT JOGPSNBDJPOFT RVF DP
NVOJDBO TPO QSJNFSP BNPOFTUBEPT
EFTQVÏTTFMPTCBKBEFDBUFHPSÓBZmOBM
NFOUFTFMPTFYPOFSB
6OB GPSNB EF FTDBQBS EF FTUF DPOUSPM
TFSÓB RVF MPT NÏEJDPT TF DFOUSFO FO MB
MJUFSBUVSB NÏEJDB FTUÈOEBS Z FO MBT JO
GPSNBDJPOFT EF MBT QSJODJQBMFT SFWJTUBT
NÏEJDBT1FSPJODMVTPFTBÈSFBEFMBFEV
DBDJØO QSPGFTJPOBM OP FT JONVOF B JO
nVFODJBTEFMBJOEVTUSJB-BTDPNQB×ÓBT
FNQMFBOBQFSTPOBTQBSBFTDSJCJSBSUÓDV
MPTQBHBOBNÏEJDPTBDBEÏNJDPTiQBSB
TFS BVUPSFTw Z FOWJBSMPT B MBT SFWJTUBT
QBSB QVCMJDBDJØO &M QPSDFOUBKF EF BS
UÓDVMPT iNBOVGBDUVSBEPTw EJmFSF TFHÞO
MB SFWJTUB QFSP FM IFDIP BUFTUJHVB VOB
NBOJQVMBDJØO JODMVTP EF MB DJFODJB EF
MBNFEJDJOB-BTDPNQB×ÓBTGBSNBDÏVUJ
DBTQBHBOQBSBiGBCSJDBSwBSUÓDVMPTQBSB
JOnVFODJBS FM DPOUFOJEP EF QSPHSBNBT
FEVDBUJWPTZmOBMNFOUFJOUFOUBOIBDFS
RVFTVTWFOEFEPSFTFOTF×FOBNÏEJDPT
DØNPQSBDUJDBSMBNFEJDJOBVTBOEPTVT
QSPEVDUPT
-BDVFTUJØOEFMBFRVJEBEZMBKVTUJDJBFO
FMBDDFTPBMPTDVJEBEPTNÏEJDPTOFDFTJUB
FTQFDJBMBUFODJØOFOMBCJPÏUJDBMBUJOPB
NFSJDBOB -PT QSFDJPT EF MPT NFEJDB
"OHFMM.BSTIB
DzF5SVUIBCPVU%SVH
$PNQBOJFT/:3BOEPN)PVTF
.F FOUSFWJTUÏ DPO WFOEFEPSFT EF HSBOEFT mS
NBTGBSNBDÏVUJDBTRVJFOFTNFEJFSPOFWJEFO
DJBTQBSBQSPCBSMPRVFEJHP
PERSPETIVADELABIOETICAINDD
NFOUPTFYDMVZFOBNJMMPOFTEFQPCSFT
6OBFYQMJDBDJØOQBSBFMDPTUPDBEBWF[
NBZPSEFNFEJDBDJPOFTQSFTDSJQUBTWJOP
EF VOB GVFOUF JOVTVBM FM EPDUPS 1FUFS
3PTUBOUJHVPWJDFQSFTJEFOUFEFDPNFS
DJBMJ[BDJØOEF1m[FS&OUSFWJTUBEPQPS
VOQFSJPEJTUBEF57FMEPDUPS3PTUTF
×BMØRVFMBTDPNQB×ÓBTTPOMBDBVTBEFM
DPOUJOVPBVNFOUPEFMPTQSFDJPTEFMBT
ESPHBT-BHFOUFMBTOFDFTJUBZTBDSJmDBSÈ
DVBMRVJFS PUSB DPNQSB JODMVTP EF BMJ
NFOUPT 4J MPT QBDJFOUFT TF FODVFOUSBO
EFTFTQFSBEPT QPS BGFSSBSTF B MB WJEB OP
TØMP BHPUBSÈO BIPSSPT QPS VOB ESPHB
QSPWFDIPTB TJOP RVF QSPCBCMFNFOUF
OPJSÈOBMPTUSJCVOBMFTBRVFKBSTF
-BKVTUJDJBTPDJBMFOMPTDVJEBEPTNÏEJ
DPTIJTUØSJDBNFOUFVOGPDPEFBUFODJØO
EF MPT UFØMPHPT EF "NÏSJDB -BUJOB FT
IPZVOBEFMBTNÈTJNQPSUBOUFTDVFTUJP
OFTFOCJPÏUJDB-BCJPÏUJDBTFQSFPDVQB
EFNVDIPTBTQFDUPTEFMBNFEJDJOBDPO
UFNQPSÈOFB QFSP FM DPNQPSUBNJFOUP
EF MB JOEVTUSJB GBSNBDÏVUJDB OP QVFEF
TFSPMWJEBEP
$PODMVTJØO
{2VJÏOQVFEFDFSDJPSBSTFEFRVFMBCJP
ÏUJDBTJHBTJFOEPWJUBMBUSBWÏTEF"NÏ
SJDB-BUJOBQSPUFHFSMBJOUFHSJEBEEFMPT
QSPGFTJPOBMFT NÏEJDPT MB TPMJEF[ EF MB
DJFODJBNÏEJDBBMPTTVKFUPTEFJOWFTUJ
HBDJØOZNBOUFOFSMBNFEJDJOBDFOUSBEB
FO MPT NÈT OFDFTJUBEPT {2VJÏO QVFEF
BZVEBS B MPT NÏEJDPT B NBOUFOFS TVT
QSPNFTBTQÞCMJDBTZDFSDJPSBSTFEFRVF
MB FEVDBDJØO NÏEJDB Z MB JOWFTUJHBDJØO
%S3PTU.JOVUFT+VOF
6OBIJTUPSJBQFSTPOBMEFMBCJPÏUJDBFO"NÏSJDB-BUJOB+BNFT%SBOF
DPOTFSWFO TV JOUFHSJEBE " NFOPT RVF
MBT BTPDJBDJPOFT NÏEJDBT QSPGFTJPOB
MFT EFmFOEBO VOB DJFODJB NÏEJDB TØMJ
EB VOB JOWFTUJHBDJØO ÏUJDB TFHVSB VOB
QSÈDUJDB DFOUSBEB FO FM QBDJFOUF Z KVT
UJDJBTPDJBMFOMPTTJTUFNBTEFDVJEBEPT
NÏEJDPTMBQSPGFTJØONÏEJDBFTUBSÈFO
TFSJPQFMJHSP)BZHSBWFTEFTBGÓPTQBSBMB
CJPÏUJDBFO"NÏSJDB-BUJOB
-PTMÓEFSFTEFMB014BDFQUBSPOMBSFT
QPOTBCJMJEBEEFMBTWJPMBDJPOFTÏUJDBTZ
FOSFTQVFTUBPSHBOJ[BSPOVOQSPHSBNB
EJTF×BEP QBSB USBFS MB EJTDJQMJOB EF MB
CJPÏUJDBB DBEB OBDJØO FO "NÏSJDB -B
PERSPETIVADELABIOETICAINDD
UJOB Z FM $BSJCF $PO VOB DPOTJTUFOUF
PSJFOUBDJØO TF IBO QSPEVDJEP CVFOPT
FGFDUPT-BCJPÏUJDBEFCFDPOUJOVBSTJFO
EPFOTF×BEBZBQMJDBEBFOUPEPTMPTOJ
WFMFTEFMBNFEJDJOBDPOUFNQPSÈOFB
&O VO DJFSUP NPNFOUP MBT QFSTPOBT
RVF UVWJFSPO MB PQPSUVOJEBE EF JOJDJBS
MBCJPÏUJDBFO"NÏSJDB-BUJOBTFUFOESÈO
RVFSFUJSBSZEFKBSFMUSBCBKPBPUSPT4JZP
EFTFNQF×ÏVOQBQFMBMQSJODJQJPBHSB
EF[DPBRVJFOFTNFEJFSPOFTBPQPSUVOJ
EBE2VJFOFTFTUBNPTFOCJPÏUJDBBTQJSB
NPTBNFUBTTJNJMBSFTZQBSUJDJQBNPTFO
VOBDPNVOJEBEBMSFEFEPSEFMNVOEP
PERSPETIVADELABIOETICAINDD
1ĒģĥĖ**
3FnFYJPOFTEFTEFWPDFTQJPOFSBTFOMPT
EJWFSTPTQBÓTFT
PERSPETIVADELABIOETICAINDD
PERSPETIVADELABIOETICAINDD
3FGFSFODJBTEFCJPÏUJDBFO"SHFOUJOB
+PTÏ"MCFSUP.BJOFUUJZ.BSUB-VDÓB1ÏSF[
*OUSPEVDDJØO
&
TUB QSFTFOUBDJØO EF JOTUJUVDJPOFT
CJPÏUJDBT BSHFOUJOBT OP QSFUFOEF
TFSFYIBVTUJWBTJOPUBOTØMPJMVTUSBUJWB
EFMBDUVBMEFTBSSPMMPEFMBEJTDJQMJOBFO
FM QBÓT 4F QBTB SFWJTUB B MPT JOTUJUVUPT
BDBEÏNJDPT DFOUSPT EF FTUVEJP JOWFT
UJHBDJØO Z EPDFODJB
BTJTUFODJBMFT P EF
TFSWJDJP TPDJBM DPNJUÏT DPNJTJPOFT Z
DPOTFKPTEFÏUJDB
ZEFQPMÓUJDBTQÞCMJDBT
MFHJTMBDJØOZKVSJTQSVEFODJB
$FOUSPTEFFTUVEJP
" QBSUJS EF MPT QSJNFSPT BOUFDFEFOUFT
RVFDPOGPSNBOFMEFTBSSPMMPEFMBCJP
ÏUJDB FO "SHFOUJOB WBMF EFDJS FM *OTUJ
UVUP EF )VNBOJEBEFT .ÏEJDBT EF MB
'VOEBDJØO .BJOFUUJ Z TV DPOUJOVJEBE
FOMBDÈUFESBVOJWFSTJUBSJBIPNØOJNBZ
MB&TDVFMB-BUJOPBNFSJDBOBEF#JPÏUJDB
&-"#&
TFIBFYUFOEJEPIPZFMDVMUJWP
EFMBEJTDJQMJOBQSÈDUJDBNFOUFBUPEPFM
QBÓT&OUSFMPTDFOUSPTEFFTUVEJPEJTUJO
"HSBEFDFNPTMBJOGPSNBDJØOBQPSUBEBQPS1F
ESP')PPGU+VBO$BSMPT5FBMEJZ&EVBSEP-
5JOBOU
$ÈUFESB EF 'JMPTPGÓB .ÏEJDB 'BDVMUBE EF
$JFODJBT.ÏEJDBT6OJWFSTJEBE/BDJPOBMEF-B
1MBUB mMPTPmBNFEJDB!BUMBTNFEVOMQFEVBS
IUUQXXXNFEVOMQFEVBS
PERSPETIVADELABIOETICAINDD
HVJNPTMBTBTPDJBDJPOFTQSPGFTJPOBMFTMBT
DÈUFESBTVOJWFSTJUBSJBTZPUSPTJOTUJUVUPT
ZQSPHSBNBTMJTUBEPTBDPOUJOVBDJØO
B
"TPDJBDJPOFTQSPGFTJPOBMFT
t
t
t
t
t
"DBEFNJB "SHFOUJOB EF ²UJDB FO
.FEJDJOB
"TPDJBDJØO"SHFOUJOBEF#JPÏUJDB
"TPDJBDJØO"SHFOUJOBEF*OWFTUJHB
DJPOFT²UJDBT
#JP4VS"TPDJBDJØOEF#JPÏUJDBZ
%FSFDIPT)VNBOPT#T"T
'FEFSBDJØO-BUJOPBNFSJDBOBEF*OT
UJUVDJPOFTEF#JPÏUJDB'&-"*#&
C
$ÈUFESBTVOJWFSTJUBSJBT
t
t
t
t
$ÈUFESBEF²UJDB#JPNÏEJDB6OJ
WFSTJEBEEFM4BMWBEPS
$ÈUFESB EF 'JMPTPGÓB .ÏEJDB 'B
DVMUBE EF $JFODJBT .ÏEJDBT 6OJ
WFSTJEBE /BDJPOBM EF -B 1MBUB
$ÈUFESBEF1PTUHSBEPEF)VNBOJ
EBEFT.ÏEJDBT'BDVMUBEEF$JFO
DJBT .ÏEJDBT 6OJWFSTJEBE /BDJP
OBMEF-B1MBUB
.BFTUSÓBFO#JPÏUJDBEFMB'BDVMUBE
EF.FEJDJOBEFMB6OJWFSTJEBE/B
DJPOBMEF$VZP
1FSTQFDUJWBTEFMB#JPÏUJDBFO*CFSPBNÏSJDB
t
t
t
t
t
t
t
.BFTUSÓBFO#JPÏUJDBEFMB'BDVMUBE
EF .FEJDJOB 6OJWFSTJEBE /BDJP
OBMEF$ØSEPCB
.BFTUSÓBFO#JPÏUJDBEFMB1POUJmDJB
6OJWFSTJEBE $BUØMJDB "SHFOUJOB
.BFTUSÓB FO #JPÏUJDB +VSÓEJDB
'BDVMUBE EF $JFODJBT +VSÓEJDBT Z
4PDJBMFT 6OJWFSTJEBE/BDJPOBMEF
-B1MBUB
.BFTUSÓB FO ²UJDB "QMJDBEB DPO
PSJFOUBDJØO FO #JPÏUJDB 'BDVMUBE
EF'JMPTPGÓB6OJWFSTJEBEEF#VFOPT
"JSFT
.BFTUSÓB FO ²UJDB "QMJDBEB DPO
PSJFOUBDJØO FO #JPÏUJDB 6OJWFSTJ
EBEEF-BOÞT
.BFTUSÓBFO²UJDB#JPNÏEJDB6OJ
WFSTJEBE$BUØMJDB"SHFOUJOB
6OJEBE "DBEÏNJDB EF #JPÏUJDB
'BDVMUBE EF .FEJDJOB 6OJWFSTJ
EBEEF#VFOPT"JSFT
t
t
t
t
t
t
t
UBE EF $JFODJBT #JPNÏEJDBT 6OJ
WFSTJEBE"VTUSBM
*OTUJUVUPEF#JPÏUJDB6OJWFSTJEBE
$BUØMJDBEF-B1MBUB
*OTUJUVUP EF #JPÏUJDB 6OJWFSTJ
EBE EFM .VTFP 4PDJBM "SHFOUJOP
o6.4"
*OTUJUVUPEF#JPÏUJDBZ)VNBOJEB
EFT.ÏEJDBT'VOEBDJØO.BJOFUUJ
*OTUJUVUP EF ²UJDB #JPNÏEJDB 'B
DVMUBE EF $JFODJBT EF MB 4BMVE
1POUJmDJB 6OJWFSTJEBE $BUØMJDB
"SHFOUJOB#VFOPT"JSFT
1SPHSBNB EF #JPÏUJDB 'VOEBDJØO
'SBUFSOJUBT3PTBSJP4BOUB'F
1SPHSBNB 5FNÈUJDP *OUFSEJTDJQMJ
OBSJPFO#JPÏUJDB6OJWFSTJEBE/B
DJPOBMEF.BSEFM1MBUB
1SPZFDUP #JPÏUJDB 'BDVMUBE -BUJ
OPBNFSJDBOB EF $JFODJBT 4PDJBMFT
'-"$40"SHFOUJOB
D
1SPHSBNBTFJOTUJUVUPT
t
t
t
t
t
t
t
t
$FOUSP $VZBOP EF &TUVEJPT
#JPÏUJDPT
$FOUSPEF#JPÏUJDBEFMB6OJWFSTJ
EBE+VBO"HVTUÓO.B[B
$FOUSP EF #JPÏUJDB 6OJWFSTJEBE
$BUØMJDBEF$ØSEPCB
$FOUSP EF &TUVEJPT #JPNÏEJDPT
6OJWFSTJEBE$"&$&#VFOPT"JSFT
$FOUSP EF *OWFTUJHBDJPOFT #JPÏUJ
DBT6OJWFSTJEBE/BDJPOBMEFM4VS
$FOUSP EF *OWFTUJHBDJPOFT EF 'J
MPTPGÓB +VSÓEJDB Z 'JMPTPGÓB 4PDJBM
6OJWFSTJEBE/BDJPOBMEF3PTBSJP
$FOUSP EF *OWFTUJHBDJPOFT ²UJDBT
3J[JFSJ 'SPOEJ[J 6OJWFSTJEBE EF
-BOÞT
%FQBSUBNFOUPEF#JPÏUJDB'BDVM
PERSPETIVADELABIOETICAINDD
$PNJUÏTDPNJTJPOFTZDPOTFKPT
EFÏUJDB
-B QSJNFSB OPUJDJB RVF TF UJFOF EF MPT
DPNJUÏTEFÏUJDBFO"SHFOUJOBFTBUSBWÏT
EFMBSUÓDVMPEF+PTÏ"MCFSUP.BJOFUUJFO
2VJSØO QQ i'JMØ
TPGPTBM)PTQJUBMMPTDPNJUÏTIPTQJUBMB
SJPTEFÏUJDBwTFHVJEPEFPUSPEF+VBO
$BSMPT 5FBMEJ Z +PTÏ "MCFSUP .BJOFUUJ
i)PTQJUBM &UIJDT $PNJUÏTw #VMMFUJO PG
1")0QQ
&O FTUF ÞMUJNP TF JEFOUJmDBSPO DJODP
DPNJUÏTEFÏUJDBFMEFM)PTQJUBMEF$MÓ
OJDBTEF#VFOPT"JSFTFMEFM4FSWJDJPEF
/FPOBUPMPHÓB EFM )PTQJUBM *UBMJBOP EF
#VFOPT"JSFTFMEFM$FOUSP0ODPMØHJDP
3FGFSFODJBTEFCJPÏUJDBFO"SHFOUJOB+PTÏ"MCFSUP.BJOFUUJZ.BSUB-VDÓB1ÏSF[
EF&YDFMFODJBEFMB'VOEBDJØO.BJOFUUJ
FMEFM)PTQJUBM&NJMJP$JWJUEF.FOEP[B
ZFMEFM)PTQJUBMEF&OGFSNFEBEFT*OGFD
DJPTBT'SBODJTDP.V×J[EFMB$JVEBEEF
#VFOPT"JSFT-B&TDVFMB-BUJOPBNFSJDB
OBEF#JPÏUJDBEFMB'VOEBDJØO.BJOFUUJ
BTVNJØ MB JOJDJBUJWB OP HVCFSOBNFOUBM
EFMB3FE3FHJPOBMEF$PNJUÏTEF²UJDB
DVZBT BDUJWJEBEFT DPOTPMJEBSPO
PCKFUJWPTEFDPPQFSBDJØODPODPNJUÏTEF
CJPÏUJDBZFTQFDJBMJTUBTEFEJTUJOUPTQBÓTFT
EF "NÏSJDB -BUJOB )BTUB MB 3FE
DPOUØ DPO FM BQPZP JOTUJUVDJPOBM EF MB
'VOEBDJØO.BJOFUUJZBQBSUJSEF
ÏTUFTFMPIBCSJOEBEPMBBTPDJBDJØODJWJM
#JP4VSEF#JPÏUJDBZ%FSFDIPT)VNB
OPT4JCJFOOPFYJTUFIBTUBIPZFO"S
HFOUJOBVOTJTUFNBOBDJPOBMEFSFWJTJØO
ÏUJDBEFMBJOWFTUJHBDJØOCJPNÏEJDBVOB
OVFWBQSPQVFTUBTFHFOFSØSFDJFOUFNFO
UFJNQVMTBEBQPS#JP4VSDPOMBDSFB
DJØO EFM $POTFKP EF ²UJDB Z %FSFDIPT
)VNBOPT QBSB MBT *OWFTUJHBDJPOFT #JP
NÏEJDBT FO MB 4FDSFUBSÓB EF %FSFDIPT
)VNBOPT EFM .JOJTUFSJP EF +VTUJDJB Z
%FSFDIPT )VNBOPT EF MB /BDJØO 'J
OBMNFOUFFOMBEÏDBEBEFMTFDSFBSPO
USFT DPNJTJPOFT OBDJPOBMFT EF CJPÏUJDB
VOB FO KVSJTEJDDJØO EF MB 4FDSFUBSÓB EF
$JFODJBZ5ÏDOJDBEFMB1SFTJEFODJBEFMB
/BDJØOZEPTFOFM.JOJTUFSJPEF4BMVE
/BDJPOBMQFSPUPEPTFMMPTGVFSPOJOUFO
UPTGSVTUSBEPT"DPOUJOVBDJØOMJTUBNPT
SFGFSFODJBT BSHFOUJOBT TPCSF FM QSFTFO
UF SVCSP TFHÞO FM FTUVEJP &6-"#03
4JTUFNB EF 3FHVMBDJØO ²UJDB EF MB *O
WFTUJHBDJØO#JPNÏEJDBFO&VSPQBZ-B
UJOPBNÏSJDB&VMBCPS81"SHFOUJOB
1
i3FWJTJØO²UJDBEFMB*OWFTUJHBDJØO
#JPNÏEJDBFO"SHFOUJOBw
PERSPETIVADELABIOETICAINDD
t
t
t
t
t
t
t
t
t
t
t
t
(PCJFSOP EF MB DJVEBE EF #VFOPT
"JSFT 3FTPMVDJØO 44
DSFB'PSP"%)0$FO#JPÏUJDB
1SPWJODJB EF #VFOPT "JSFT -FZ
TPCSF 1SPUFDDJØO EF
1FSTPOBT RVF QBSUJDJQBO FO *OWFT
UJHBDJPOFT#JPNÏEJDBT
1SPWJODJB EF $BUBNBSDB -FZ
TPCSF $SFBDJØO EFM $P
NJUÏEF²UJDBEFMB*OWFTUJHBDJØO
1SPWJODJBEF$IBDP-FZ
TPCSF $POTFKP 1SPWJODJBM EF
#JPÏUJDB
1SPWJODJB EF +VKVZ -FZ TPCSF $POTFKP 1SPWJODJBM EF
#JPÏUJDB
1SPWJODJBEF3ÓP/FHSP-FZ
TPCSF3FHVMBDJØOEFMB*OWFTUJ
HBDJØO$MÓOJDB
1SPWJODJBEF3ÓP/FHSP-FZ
TPCSF%FSFDIPTEFMPT1BDJFOUFT
1SPWJODJBEF5VDVNÈO-FZ
TPCSF%FSFDIPTEFMPT1BDJFOUFT
3FQÞCMJDB "SHFOUJOB "ENJOJTUSB
DJØO /BDJPOBM EF .FEJDBNFOUPT
"MJNFOUPT Z 5FDOPMPHÓB %JTQPTJ
DJØOEF#VFOBT1SÈDUJDBT
EF 'BSNBDPMPHÓB EF *OWFTUJHBDJØO
$MÓOJDB
3FQÞCMJDB "SHFOUJOB %FDSFUP EFM
1PEFS &KFDVUJWP /BDJPOBM DSFB MB $PNJTJØO /BDJPOBM
EF²UJDB#JPNÏEJDB
3FQÞCMJDB"SHFOUJOB-FZ
1PEFS&KFDVUJWP/BDJPOBMDSFB
MPT$PNJUÏT)PTQJUBMBSJPTEF²UJDB
3FQÞCMJDB "SHFOUJOB -FZ 3FHM "SU ‹ $/
TPCSF 1SP
UFDDJØOEF%BUPT1FSTPOBMFTZ)B
CFBT%BUB
1FSTQFDUJWBTEFMB#JPÏUJDBFO*CFSPBNÏSJDB
t
3FQÞCMJDB "SHFOUJOB .JOJTUFSJP
EF 4BMVE %JTQPTJDJØO i/PSNBTQBSBTPMJDJUBSBVUPSJ[BDJP
OFT QBSB SFBMJ[BS JOWFTUJHBDJØO FO
'BSNBDPMPHÓB$MÓOJDBw
"$POWFODJPOFTTPCSF%FSFDIPT
)VNBOPTSFDFQUBEBTQPSMB
$POTUJUVDJØO/BDJPOBMBSU
JODTZSFG
t
1PMÓUJDBTQÞCMJDBT
&O"SHFOUJOBoDPNPFOUPEPFMNVOEP
ZQBSUJDVMBSNFOUFFO"NÏSJDB-BUJOBo
TFIBBCJFSUPIPZVOBBHFOEBQPMÓUJDBEF
BMUB TFOTJCJMJEBE NPSBM IBDJB MB SFWPMV
DJØO CJPNÏEJDB Z TV NBOJQVMBDJØO EF
MBWJEBFOHFOFSBMZEFMBWJEBIVNBOB
FOQBSUJDVMBSTPCSFUPEPIBDJBMBTOVF
WBT GPSNBT EF OBDFS QSPDSFBS Z NPSJS
-PTUFNBTEFVOBÏUJDBEFMBWJEBZTJTF
RVJFSFUBNCJÏOEFVOBWJEBEFMBÏUJDB
SFRVJFSFO EF GVOEBNFOUBDJØO CJPÏUJDB
FOMBEFMJCFSBDJØONPSBMQSPQJBEFVOB
TPDJFEBE DJWJM EFNPDSÈUJDB Z QMVSBMJTUB
3FHJTUSBNPT FO TFHVJEB BMHVOPT FKFN
QMPTEFMBQSPEVDDJØOOPSNBUJWBFOMF
HJTMBDJØOZKVSJTQSVEFODJBEFCJPQPMÓUJDB
BSHFOUJOBEVSBOUFMBÞMUJNBEÏDBEB
t
t
t
t
t
t
1BSB FM QFSÓPEP WÏBTF +PTÏ "
.BJOFUUJ (VTUBWP 1JT %JF[ +VBO $BSMPT 5F
BMEJi#JPFUIJDTJO-BUJO"NFSJDBw
#JPFUIJDT:FBSCPPLWPM3FHJPOBM%F
WFMPQNFOUT JO #JPFUIJDT ,MVXFS
"DBEFNJB 1VCMJTIFST ɨF /FUIFSMBOET
7ÏBTF UBNCJÏO +VBO $BSMPT 5FBMEJ (VTUBWP
1JT %JF[ BOE 0TDBS &TRVJ[BCFM i#JPFUIJDT JO
-BUJO"NFSJDBw#"OESFX-VTUJH
&E
#JPFUIJDT :FBSCPPL 7PMVNFO ,MVXFS "DBEFNJB 1VCMJTIFST ɨF
/FUIFSMBOET
PERSPETIVADELABIOETICAINDD
%FDMBSBDJØO6OJWFSTBMEF%FSFDIPT
)VNBOPTEFMBT/BDJPOFT6OJEBT
EF
%FDMBSBDJØO"NFSJDBOBEFMPT%F
SFDIPT Z %FCFSFT EFM )PNCSF EF
$POWFODJØO"NFSJDBOBTPCSF%F
SFDIPT)VNBOPTEFi1BDUP
EF4BO+PTÏEF$PTUB3JDBwBQSP
CBEBQPSMFZ
1BDUP *OUFSOBDJPOBM EF %FSFDIPT
&DPOØNJDPT4PDJBMFTZ$VMUVSBMFT
Z 0CTFSWBDJØO (FOFSBM EFM$PNJUÏ1*%&4$i&MEFSFDIP
BMEJTGSVUFEFMNÈTBMUPOJWFMQPTJ
CMFEFTBMVEw
1BDUP *OUFSOBDJPOBM EF %FSFDIPT
$JWJMFT Z 1PMÓUJDPT Z TV 1SPUPDPMP
'BDVMUBUJWP-FZ
$POWFODJØO*OUFSOBDJPOBMTPCSFMB
&MJNJOBDJØO EF UPEBT MBT 'PSNBT
EF%JTDSJNJOBDJØODPOUSBMB.VKFS
-FZ
$POWFODJØO TPCSF MPT %FSFDIPT
EFM/J×P-FZ
ZPUSBTDPO
WFODJPOFTTPCSFEFSFDIPTIVNBOPT
DPO KFSBSRVÓB DPOTUJUVDJPOBM BSU
JODTZZDPODT$/
#0USBTOPSNBTMFHBMFTEF
"SHFOUJOB
t
t
#BODPEFEBUPTHFOÏUJDPT
%FUFSNJOBDJØOEFMNPNFOUPEFMB
NVFSUFEFMBQFSTPOBBSU
SFGEFDSFHM
3FGFSFODJBTEFCJPÏUJDBFO"SHFOUJOB+PTÏ"MCFSUP.BJOFUUJZ.BSUB-VDÓB1ÏSF[
t
t
t
t
t
t
t
t
t
t
&KFSDJDJPEFMBNFEJDJOBZBDUJWJEB
EFTEFDPMBCPSBDJØO
&NCBSB[PT JODPNQBUJCMFT DPO MB
WJEB$"#"
&YQFSJNFOUBDJØO DPO TFSFT IVNB
OPT1#"
FUD
-FZ CÈTJDB EF 4BMVE EF MB $JVEBE
"VUØOPNB#VFOPT"JSFT
1SFWFODJØOZMVDIBDPOUSBFM)*7
4*%"
1SPHSBNB NÏEJDP PCMJHBUPSJP
1.0
3ÏHJNFOEFUSBTQMBOUFTEFØSHBOPT
ZNBUFSJBMBOBUØNJDP
4BMVETFYVBMZQSPDSFBDJØOSFTQPO
TBCMF
4JTUFNBEFQSFTUBDJPOFTCÈTJDBTEF
BUFODJØOJOUFHSBMBGBWPSEFMBTQFS
TPOBTDPOEJTDBQBDJEBE
4JTUFNB OBDJPOBM EF TFHVSP EF TB
MVE
$4FOUFODJBTKVEJDJBMFT
SFMFWBOUFT
t
t
1SPOVODJBNJFOUPTEFMB$4+/FTQ
FODBVTBTi#BIBNPOEF[w
i#3&W1PMJDÓB'FEFSBM"SHFOUJ
OBw
$POTVMUBS QVCMJDBDJPOFT TMFZFT ZP KPSOBEBT
QSPWJODJBMFTFOMFHJTMBUVSBCPOBFSFOTFWHSEF
.BJOFUUJ+"Z5FBMEJ+$i#JPÏUJDBFJOWFT
UJHBDJØOFOTBMVEwZ)PPGU1'i$PNFOUBSJP
BMB-FZwFE$ÈNBSBEF%JQVUBEPT-B
1MBUB JE i5SBOTHÏOJDPT #JPUFDOPMPHÓB
FOFMBHSPwFE$ÈNBSBEF4FOBEPSFT-B1MBUB
PERSPETIVADELABIOETICAINDD
t
t
t
t
i$BNQPEØOJDP EF #FWJBDRVBw
i54W(PC$JVEBEEF#T"TT
BOFODFGBMJBw
i1PSUBMEF#FMÏOw
i7È[RVF['FSSÈw
1VCMJDBDJPOFT
-B QSPEVDDJØO BSHFOUJOB FO NBUFSJB
CJPÏUJDBFTDPOTJEFSBCMFFTUJNVMBEBQPS
FMCPPNEFMPTFTUVEJPTCJPÏUJDPTFOMB
FOTF×BO[B TVQFSJPS QBSUJDVMBSNFOUF
QPSQBSUFEFMBTGBDVMUBEFTNÏEJDBKV
SÓEJDBUFPMØHJDBZmMPTØmDBRVFTPOMPT
GPSPT EF NBZPS BUSBDDJØO &M MBSHP DB
NJOPQSFQBSBUPSJPEFMBCJPÏUJDBDPOMBT
IVNBOJEBEFTNÏEJDBTFOMB'VOEBDJØO
.BJOFUUJFTVOFKFNQMPEFQSPEVDDJØO
CJCMJPHSÈmDB HSBDJBT B VOB MÓOFB FEJUP
SJBM JOTUJUVDJPOBMNFOUF TPTUFOJEB -B
SFWJTUB2VJSØODPOTVTWPMÞNFOFTB
MBGFDIBZVOBTFSJFEFMJCSPTQPSFMNJT
NPTFMMPTPOQSFDMBSPTUFTUJNPOJPTEFM
QFOTBNJFOUPIVNBOJTUBFOMBNFEJDJOB
EFMBTFHVOEBNJUBEEFMTJHMPQBTBEP
*HVBMNFOUFEFPUSPTUSJCVOBMFTZNBHJTUSBEPT
OBDJPOBMFTZQSPWJODJBMFTFTQGBMMPTiCJPÏUJDPTw
EFM KVF[ FO MP QFOBM EF .BS EFM 1MBUB 1FESP
'FEFSJDP)PPGUBQBSUJSEFMB×P3FWJT
UBT&M%FSFDIP-B-FZ-B-FZ#VFOPT"JSFT
-FYJT /FYPT+VSJTQSVEFODJB "SHFOUJOB
%F
JHVBMNPEPDPOTVMUBS+VSJTQSVEFODJB&YUSBOKF
SBFTQGBMMPTEFUSJCVOBMFTOPSUFBNFSJDBOPTFO
NBUFSJBEFEFSFDIPBMBWJEBFTUBEPWFHFUBUJWP
JOUFSSVQDJØOEFUSBUBNJFOUPTEFTPQPSUFWJUBMZ
FVUBOBTJB
PERSPETIVADELABIOETICAINDD
-BCJPÏUJDBFO#PMJWJBBOUFDFEFOUFTZQSPZFDDJPOFT
+BWJFS-VOB0SPTDP&EVBSEP
1SFDVSTPSFTZBOUFDFEFOUFT
JOJDJBMFT
/
PIBZSFHJTUSPEFBDUJWJEBECJPÏUJDB
FO #PMJWJB TJOP B QBSUJS EF DVBOEPFMTBDFSEPUFKFTVJUB.JHVFM.BO
[BOFSB QSPQPOF B MBT BVUPSJEBEFT EF MB
6OJWFSTJEBE$BUØMJDB#PMJWJBOB6$#
MBDSFBDJØOEFVO$FOUSPEF#JPÏUJDB
$BTJFOMBNJTNBÏQPDB+PTÏ.BSÓB"M
WBSBEP -VJT )VSUBEP (ØNF[ +BWJFS-VOB0SPTDPZBMHVOPTPUSPTTF
JOUFSFTBOQPSMBTJHOJmDBDJØOZBMDBODFT
EFMBCJPÏUJDBDMÓOJDBBMFMBCPSBSMPTQSJ
NFSPTCPSSBEPSFTEFMB-FZEFM&KFSDJDJP
1SPGFTJPOBM .ÏEJDP DPNP VOB OFDF
TJEBE QBSB MB QSFWFODJØO EF MB MMBNBEB
iNBMB QSÈDUJDB QSPGFTJPOBMw RVF DP
NJFO[BBQSFPDVQBSQPSMBQSFTFOUBDJØO
DBEBWF[NÈTGSFDVFOUFEFDBTPT
0USPBOUFDFEFOUFEFBQSPYJNBDJØOBMB
CJPÏUJDBZFTUBWF[FTUBUBMTFEBFOTFQ
UJFNCSFEFDVBOEPBQSPQØTJUPEFM
FTUBCMFDJNJFOUPEFM1SPHSBNB3FHJPOBM
EF #JPÏUJDB 13#
EF MB 0SHBOJ[BDJØO
1BOBNFSJDBOBEFMB4BMVE0140.4FO
4BOUJBHPEF$IJMFoDPNPSFTVMUBEPEFMB
MÓOFBQSPHSBNÈUJDB)#&1SPNPDJØOEF
MB#JPÏUJDBEFMB014oMB4FDSFUBSÓBEF
PERSPETIVADELABIOETICAINDD
4BMVEEFMHPCJFSOPCPMJWJBOPSFDJCJØMB
EPDVNFOUBDJØO QFSUJOFOUF TPMJDJUBOEP
NJ BTFTPSBNJFOUP QBSB JOUFSQSFUBSMB Z
FNJUJSVOBPQJOJØOTPCSFMBBQSPCBDJØO
EFM1SPHSBNBRVFTFEBSÓBBDPOPDFSFO
MB 9997** 3FVOJØO EFM $POTFKP %J
SFDUJWPEFMB0140.4DPOWPDBEBFO
8BTIJOHUPOQBSBmOFTEFTFQUJFNCSFEF
FTFB×P$VNQMÓFMFODBSHPNB
OJGFTUBOEPFOFTBPQPSUVOJEBERVFiQPS
MB JNQPSUBODJB RVF SFWJTUF MB DSFBDJØO
EFM13#DPOVOBUSBTDFOEFODJBRVFTV
QFSBMPNFSBNFOUFTFDUPSJBMSFGFSJEPB
DBQBDJUBSPEJGVOEJSMBTQPUFODJBMJEBEFT
EFM DPOPDJNJFOUP Z NBOFKP DPUJEJBOP
EF MB CJPÏUJDB OP TPMBNFOUF FOUSF MPT
SFDVSTPT IVNBOPT EF TBMVE TJOP NÈT
CJFOHFOFSBMJ[BSMPTBMBQPCMBDJØOFOTV
DPOKVOUP TF DPOTJEFSB BMUBNFOUF SFDP
NFOEBCMFBQPZBSDPNPQBÓTMBJOJDJBUJWB
EF MB 0140.4 Z MB 6OJWFSTJEBE EF
$IJMF QBSB QPOFSMP FO QSÈDUJDB MP RVF
SFEVOEBSÈFOVOFOPSNFCFOFmDJPQBSB
MPTQBÓTFTEFMBSFHJØOZFOQBSUJDVMBS
QBSB #PMJWJB EPOEF TF UJFOF FTDBTB FY
QFSJFODJB TPCSF FM UFNB EF CJPÏUJDBw
3FDPNFOEBCBBEFNÈTRVFFM13#EF
OVFWBDSFBDJØOBQMJDBTFNÏUPEPTFJOT
USVNFOUPTEFFOTF×BO[BPDBQBDJUBDJØO
VOJGPSNFT P BM NFOPT TJNJMBSFT QBSB
1FSTQFDUJWBTEFMB#JPÏUJDBFO*CFSPBNÏSJDB
UPEPT FTUPT QBÓTFT DPO FM mO EF GBDJMJ
UBSFMJOUFSDBNCJPEFFYQFSJFODJBTZEF
DPPQFSBDJØOUÏDOJDBEFTUBDBOEPMBVUJ
MJEBE RVF UFOESÓB MB FMBCPSBDJØO EF VO
%JDDJPOBSJP EF #JPÏUJDB VO WFSEBEFSP
JOTUSVNFOUP EF USBCBKP Z DPOTVMUB 'J
OBMNFOUF NJ EPDVNFOUP QSPQPOÓB
SFRVFSJS BM 13# BTFTPSBNJFOUP QBSB MB
PSHBOJ[BDJØOEFM*OTUJUVUP#PMJWJBOPEF
#JPÏUJDBDBQBDJUBSBVOQSJNFSHSVQPEF
SFDVSTPT IVNBOPT TFMFDDJPOBEPT FO FM
QBÓTEFBDVFSEPDPOVOTJTUFNBRVFQP
ESÓBTFSBDPSEBEPFOUSFMB4FDSFUBSÓBEF
4BMVEMB6OJWFSTJEBE$BUØMJDB#PMJWJB
OBZFM$PMFHJP.ÏEJDPBTFTPSBNJFOUP
QBSBFTUBCMFDFSMPTDPNJUÏTEFÏUJDBDMÓOJ
DBZEFSFWJTJØOEFJOWFTUJHBDJØOCJPNÏ
EJDBZSFNJTJØOEFVOMPUFCÈTJDPJOJDJBM
EFJOGPSNBDJØOCJPÏUJDB
-BNFOUBCMFNFOUF UPEBT BRVFMMBT SF
DPNFOEBDJPOFT OP GVFSPO UPNBEBT
FO DVFOUB IBTUB FM B×P DVBOEP
DPJODJEFOUFNFOUF MB 0mDJOB EF 3FMB
DJPOFT *OUFSOBDJPOBMFT EFM .JOJTUFSJP
EF4BMVEZ1SFWJTJØO4PDJBM.414
EF
#PMJWJBNFQJEFJOUFSQSFUBSFMEPDVNFO
UP $% EF MB 014 i&WBMVBDJØO
EFM 1SPHSBNB 3FHJPOBM EF #JPÏUJDBw
DPOTUBUÈOEPTF RVF EF BDUJWJEBEFT
RVF IBCSÓBBQPZBEP FM 13#FO MPTTFJT
B×PT USBOTDVSSJEPT oFOUSF TFNJOBSJPT
UBMMFSFT DPOGFSFODJBT Z DVSTPT EFTEF TV
FTUBCMFDJNJFOUPo FM TF SFBMJ[BSPO
FO $IJMF TFHVJEP QPS .ÏYJDP $FOUSP
"NÏSJDB$BSJCF-BUJOPPUSPTQBÓTFTEF
4VEBNÏSJDB F JODMVTP /PSUFBNÏSJDB
&VSPQB Z $BSJCF *OHMÏT QFSP OJOHVOB
FO #PMJWJB &TUB TJUVBDJØO GVF NBOJGFT
PERSPETIVADELABIOETICAINDD
UBEBBOUFMBSFQSFTFOUBDJØOEFMB014
0.4FO#PMJWJBZNPUJWØMBPSHBOJ[B
DJØOEFVOHSVQPEFUSBCBKPJOUFHSBEP
QPS SFQSFTFOUBOUFT EFM .JOJTUFSJP EF
4BMVE Z 1SFWJTJØO 4PDJBM EFM 7JDFNJ
OJTUFSJP EF &EVDBDJØO 4VQFSJPS $JFO
DJB Z 5FDOPMPHÓB EF MB 0140.4 FO
#PMJWJB EF MB "DBEFNJB #PMJWJBOB EF
.FEJDJOB EF MB "TBNCMFB 1FSNBOFO
UFEF%FSFDIPT)VNBOPTEFM$PMFHJP
.ÏEJDP%FQBSUBNFOUBMEF-B1B[ZEF
MB 'BDVMUBE EF .FEJDJOB EF MB 6OJWFS
TJEBE .BZPS EF 4BO "OESÏT 6.4"
EF-B1B[RVJFOFTFMEFTFQUJFNCSF
EFTVTDSJCFOFM"DUBEF$POGPS
NBDJØOEFM$PNJUÏ*NQVMTPSEF²UJDBZ
#JPÏUJDBFO#PMJWJBQBSBDPOTUJUVJSVOB
JOTUJUVDJØOEFBTFTPSÓBQSPNPDJØOGPS
NBDJØOJOWFTUJHBDJØOZWJHJMBODJBEFMPT
QSJODJQJPTEFÏUJDBZCJPÏUJDBRVFEFTB
SSPMMF Z HFOFSF DVMUVSB JOTUJUVDJPOBM FO
FMTFDUPSTBMVEDPOFMmOEFDPOUSJCVJSB
MBMFHJTMBDJØOFOFMNBSDPEFMEFTBSSPMMP
IVNBOPDPOFRVJEBEZKVTUJDJBTPDJBMFT
&OMBPQPSUVOJEBENFOPNCSBODPPSEJ
OBEPSEFEJDIP$PNJUÏ
$POUFYUPJOTUJUVDJPOBMEFMB
CJPÏUJDBFO#PMJWJB
$BCF EFTDSJCJS DPO NBZPS EFUBMMF MPT
QSJODJQBMFT QSPQØTJUPT Z PSJFOUBDJPOFT
BTÓ DPNP MB PSHBOJ[BDJØO Z BDUJWJEBEFT
EFM$PNJUÏ/BDJPOBMEF#JPÏUJDB$/#
EFM*OTUJUVUPEF#JPÏUJDB*#
EFMB6OJ
WFSTJEBE$BUØMJDB#PMJWJBOBEFMBDJVEBE
EF$PDIBCBNCBZEFMB"TPDJBDJØO#P
MJWJBOBEF#JPÏUJDB%FSFDIP(FOÏUJDPZ
#JPUFDOPMPHÓB"#*0%(&
-BCJPÏUJDBFO#PMJWJBBOUFDFEFOUFTZQSPZFDDJPOFT+BWJFS-VOB0SPTDP&EVBSEP
$PNJUÏ/BDJPOBMEF#JPÏUJDB
"OUFDFEFOUFT
/BDJØDPNP$PNJUÏ*NQVMTPSEF²UJDB
Z#JPÏUJDB$*&#
FMEFTFQUJFNCSFEF
NFEJBOUF BDUB EF DPOGPSNBDJØO
mSNBEBQPSSFQSFTFOUBOUFTEFM.JOJTUF
SJPEF4BMVEEFM.JOJTUFSJPEF&EVDB
DJØOEFMB0140.4EFMB"TBNCMFB
1FSNBOFOUFEF%FSFDIPT)VNBOPTEF
MB"DBEFNJB#PMJWJBOBEF.FEJDJOBEFM
$PMFHJP.ÏEJDPZEFMB6.4"&M$*&#
HP[B EFM SFDPOPDJNJFOUP JOUFSOBDJPOBM
EFM13#EFMB0140.4BTÓDPNPEF
MB'FEFSBDJØO-BUJOPBNFSJDBOBEF*OTUJ
UVDJPOFTEF#JPÏUJDB'&-"*#&
EFMB
3FE -BUJOPBNFSJDBOB Z EFM $BSJCF EF
#JPÏUJDBZEFM$PNJUÏ*OUFSOBDJPOBMEF
#JPÏUJDB$*#
EFMB0SHBOJ[BDJØOEFMBT
/BDJPOFT6OJEBTQBSBMB&EVDBDJØOMB
$JFODJBZMB$VMUVSB6/&4$0
4VTBDDJPOFTFTUÈOPSJFOUBEBTBVOBCJP
ÏUJDBIVNBOBPNJDSPCJPÏUJDBZBVOB
FDPMØHJDB P NBDSPCJPÏUJDB B USBWÏT EF
USFT MÓOFBT QSJODJQBMFT DPOEVDJEBT QPS
MBT DPNJTJPOFT EF $BQBDJUBDJØO *OWFT
UJHBDJØOZ1SPZFDDJØOBMB$PNVOJEBE
SFTQFDUJWBNFOUF
"DUJWJEBEFT
1PDP BOUFT EF DPOTUJUVJSTF FM $*&#
FMHSVQPRVFMFEJPPSJHFOPSHBOJ[ØVO
$VSTPEF#JPÏUJDBJNQBSUJEPQPSMBCJP
FUJDJTUB FTQB×PMB *TPMJOB 3JB×P (BMÈO
EFMBMEFBHPTUPEF
&OOPWJFNCSFEFMMFWØBDBCP
VO4FNJOBSJPEF&OTF×BO[BEF#JPÏUJDB
PERSPETIVADELABIOETICAINDD
DPNPMBQSJNFSBBDUJWJEBEEFM13#FO
#PMJWJBZCBKPMPTBVTQJDJPTEFMB3FQSF
TFOUBDJØOEFMB0140.4FOFTUFQBÓT
DPOUBOEPBEFNÈTDPOVOB3FTPMVDJØO
.JOJTUFSJBMFNJUJEBQPSFM.JOJTUFSJPEF
4BMVEZ1SFWJTJØO4PDJBM.414
&O DPBVTQJDJP DPO FM *OUFSOBUJPOBM
$PMMFHF PG 4VSHFPOT 4FDDJØO #PMJWJB MB
0140.4ZMB"DBEFNJB#PMJWJBOBEF
.FEJDJOB FM $*&# PSHBOJ[Ø FOUSF ZFMEFBCSJMEFFM4FNJOBSJP
#JPÏUJDB.ÏEJDBQBSUJDJQBOEPDPNPJO
WJUBEPQSJODJQBM(BCSJFM%&NQBJSFEF
7FOF[VFMB
6OB×PEFTQVÏTEFTVDSFBDJØOSFBMJ
[ØFOMBDJVEBEEF-B1B[FOUSFBM
EFTFQUJFNCSFEFFM1SJNFS$PO
HSFTP#PMJWJBOPEF#JPÏUJDB&OMBPQPS
UVOJEBE TF DPOUØ DPO MB QBSUJDJQBDJØO
EFMQSFTJEFOUFEFMB'&-"*#&&EVBSEP
4PVTB-FOOPY1BOBNÈ
ZMPTJOWJUBEPT
JOUFSOBDJPOBMFT7PMOFJ(BSSBGB#SBTJM
4FSHJP$FDIFUUP"SHFOUJOB
Z3PCFSUP
.BODJOJ EFM 13# $IJMF
BEFNÈT EFM
3FQSFTFOUBOUFEFMB0140.4FO#P
MJWJB+PTÏ"OUPOJP1BHÏT
%VSBOUF MB SFBMJ[BDJØO EFM 1SJNFS
$POHSFTP#PMJWJBOPEF#JPÏUJDBTFJOT
UBMBSPOMPTDPNJUÏTEFQBSUBNFOUBMFTEF
CJPÏUJDB DPO FOUSFHB EF EPDVNFOUPT
Z NBUFSJBMFT CÈTJDPT BQPSUBEPT BMHVOPT
EFFMMPTQPSFM13#BUSBWÏTEF3PCFSUP
.BODJOJ
&OFTBNJTNBPQPSUVOJEBETFFNJUJØ
MBi%FDMBSBDJØOEF-B1B[wDPNQSPNF
UJFOEPBMPTDPNJUÏTEFQBSUBNFOUBMFTB
MBEJGVTJØOEFMBCJPÏUJDBBUSBWÏTEFMPT
1FSTQFDUJWBTEFMB#JPÏUJDBFO*CFSPBNÏSJDB
TJHVJFOUFTDPNQPOFOUFTÏUJDBBGBWPSEF
MBWJEBCJPÏUJDBDPOJEFOUJEBECBTBEBFO
FMSFDPOPDJNJFOUPEFTFSFTIVNBOPTDPO
JHVBMFTEFSFDIPTCÞTRVFEBEFMCJFOMB
KVTUJDJB Z MB QSFWFODJØO EFM EB×P FO FM
EFTFNQF×PTPDJBMJOTUJUVDJPOBMDJFOUÓ
mDPQPMÓUJDPZQSPGFTJPOBMQSÈDUJDBNÏ
EJDBDPNQSPNFUJEBDPOMBCJPÏUJDBZFM
CJFOFTUBS IVNBOP JOUFHSBM QSPUFDDJØO
EFMFOUPSOPOBUVSBMZMBCJPEJWFSTJEBE
&OUSFmOFTEFPDUVCSFZQSJODJQJPTEF
OPWJFNCSFEFFM$*&#PSHBOJ[ØFM
DVSTPi²UJDBFOMB*OWFTUJHBDJØOZ#VF
OBT 1SÈDUJDBT $MÓOJDBTw FO DPBVTQJDJP
DPO FM $PMFHJP .ÏEJDP %FQBSUBNFOUBM
EF-B1B[ZDPOUBOEPDPO+BJNF4PUPZ
+VMJB5PMFEP$PMPNCJB
DPNPQSPGFTP
SFTJOWJUBEPT
$POFMBVTQJDJPEFM.414MB&NCB
KBEBEF'SBODJBFO#PMJWJBFM*OTUJUVUP
#PMJWJBOPEF#JPMPHÓBEFMB"MUVSBZMB
'BDVMUBE EF .FEJDJOB EF MB 6.4" FM
$*&# MMFWØ B DBCP FM TFNJOBSJP i²UJDB
FO MB *OWFTUJHBDJØO #JPNÏEJDB FO )V
NBOPTwMPTEÓBTZEFNBS[P
EF DPO MB QBSUJDJQBDJØO EF -BV
SB3VFEBZ3PCFSUP.BODJOJEFM13#
$IJMF
%FMBMEFBHPTUPEFMTFSFB
MJ[Ø FO $PDIBCBNCB FM 4FHVOEP $PO
HSFTP#PMJWJBOPEF#JPÏUJDBRVFDPOFM
BQPZPEFMB0140.4GVFPSHBOJ[BEP
QPSFM$/#FODPSSFTQPOEFODJBDPOMB
6OJWFSTJEBE.BZPSEF4BO4JNØO'VF
QSFTJEJEP QPS FM EJSFDUPS EFM *# EF MB
6OJWFSTJEBE $BUØMJDB EF $PDIBCBNCB
.JHVFM.BO[BOFSBZDPOUØDPOMBQBS
UJDJQBDJØOEF+PTÏ"MCFSUP.BJOFUUJ1F
PERSPETIVADELABIOETICAINDD
ESP')PĊU4FSHJP$FDIFUUPZ1BUSJDJB
6SCBOEEF"SHFOUJOB0TWBMEP$IÈWF[
EF7FOF[VFMBZ3BJNVOEP3JODØOEF
&TQB×B
%VSBOUF FM $/# FGFDUVØ
VO 'PSP "CJFSUP EF 1PMÓUJDBT EF 4BMVE
NFEJBOUF EJF[ TFNJOBSJPT -FHJTMBDJØO
Z 0SHBOJ[BDJØO 4BOJUBSJB .BSDP EF
$PNQFUFODJBT*OTUJUVDJPOBMFTZ(FTUJØO
FO4BMVEDPO1BSUJDJQBDJØO$JVEBEBOB
/JWFMFT EF "UFODJØO Z &TUSVDUVSBDJØO
6SCBOP3VSBM EF MBT 3FEFT EF 4FSWJ
DJP3FHVMBDJPOFTQBSBMB$POTUSVDDJØO
Z &RVJQBNJFOUP EFM 4FDUPS 4BMVE FO
1SPDVSB EF VOB .BZPS $PCFSUVSB FO
"UFODJØO 1SJNBSJB 1PMÓUJDBT EF 3FDVS
TPT)VNBOPTFO4BMVE4VTUFOUBCJMJEBE
'JOBODJFSB EFM 4FDUPS 4BMVE "DDFTP
6OJWFSTBMEF4BMVEZ+VTUJDJB4BOJUBSJB
1PMÓUJDBT EF .FEJDBNFOUPT F *OTVNPT
.ÏEJDPT1SFTFSWBDJØOZ#FOFmDJPEFMB
1FSTPOBFOFM1SPDFTPEF*OWFTUJHBDJØO
Z %FTBSSPMMP 5FDOPDJFOUÓmDP #BTFT EF
VOB 1SPQVFTUB 'JOBM QBSB VOB /VFWB
1PMÓUJDBEF&TUBEPFOFM4FDUPS4BMVE
&OTFQUJFNCSFEF4VTBOB7J
EBMDPPSEJOBEPSBEF#JPÏUJDBEFM.JOJT
UFSJPEF4BMVEFO$ØSEPCB"SHFOUJOB
EFTBSSPMMØFM$JDMPEF$POGFSFODJBT5B
MMFSi#JPÏUJDB$MÓOJDBZ0SHBOJ[BDJØOEF
MPT$PNJUÏT)PTQJUBMBSJPTEF#JPÏUJDBw
-PT EÓBT Z EF OPWJFNCSF EF
FM$/#SFBMJ[ØFM$VSTPEF*OUSP
EVDDJØO B MB #JPÏUJDB PSHBOJ[BEP KVO
UBNFOUF DPO 7PMHB *×ÓHVF[ EJSFDUPSB
EFM *OTUJUVUP EF #JPMPHÓB .PMFDVMBS EF
MB6.4"&MDVSTPDPOUØDPOMBTFYQP
TJDJPOFTEF.BSUIB1BDIFDP3VUI(VJ
-BCJPÏUJDBFO#PMJWJBBOUFDFEFOUFTZQSPZFDDJPOFT+BWJFS-VOB0SPTDP&EVBSEP
MMÏOEF.BMEPOBEP#FBUSJ[.POUPZBZ
&NNB"QBSJDJPFOUBOUPRVFMBNPEF
SBDJØOFTUVWPBDBSHPEF7JPMFUB"SBHØO
Z%BZTJ(VUJÏSSF[UPEBTJOUFHSBOUFTEFM
$/# $BTJ TJNVMUÈOFBNFOUF FM DPPS
EJOBEPS EFM $/# EFTBSSPMMØ FM NJTNP
DVSTP QBSB QFSTPOFSPT EFM *OTUJUVUP EF
#JPMPHÓB.PMFDVMBSEFMB6.4"FOUSF
FMZFMEFOPWJFNCSFEF
FO #PMJWJB 'FEFSBDJØO %FQBSUBNFOUBM
EF 1SPGFTJPOBMFT EF -B 1B[ 3FTJEFODJB
EFM)PTQJUBM0CSFSPEFMB$/44PDJF
EBE #PMJWJBOB EF 6SPMPHÓB 4PDJFEBE
#PMJWJBOB EF .FEJDJOB *OUFSOB 4PDJF
EBE.ÏEJDBEF$POTVMUB1SJWBEB40
.&$01
Z "TPDJBDJØO #PMJWJBOB EF
#JPÏUJDBZ%FSFDIP(FOÏUJDPZ#JPUFD
OPMPHÓB"#*0%(&
&OIPNFOBKFBMBNFNPSJBEFVOP
EFMPTQSJODJQBMFTQSPQVMTPSFTEFMB#JP
ÏUJDBFO#PMJWJB-VJT)VSUBEP(ØNF[
EFMBMEFPDUVCSFEFTFFGFD
UVØFO-B1B[FM5FSDFS$POHSFTP#PMJ
WJBOPEF#JPÏUJDBDPOFMUFNBi#JPÏUJDB
Z 1MVSBMJEBEw PSHBOJ[BEP QPS FM $/#
DPOMBDPMBCPSBDJØOEFMB6/&4$0EF
.ÏYJDP MB 3FE -BUJOPBNFSJDBOB Z EFM
$BSJCF EF #JPÏUJDB Z MB 0140.4 FO
#PMJWJB &O FTB PQPSUVOJEBE QBSUJDJ
QBSPO MB EJSFDUPSB EF MB 6/&4$0 FO
.ÏYJDP"MZB4BBEBZFMQSFTJEFOUFEF
MB 3FE -BUJOPBNFSJDBOB Z EFM $BSJCF
EF#JPÏUJDBBEFNÈTEF7PMOFJ(BSSBGB
#SBTJM
+VBO $BSMPT 5FBMEJ "SHFOUJ
OB
+PTÏ&EVBSEPEF4JRVJFSB#SBTJM
Z
4VTBOB7JEBM"SHFOUJOB
&OUSF FTUBT SFVOJPOFT GVF QBSUJDVMBS
NFOUFJNQPSUBOUFFM4FNJOBSJP3FHJP
OBM TPCSF #JPÏUJDB PSHBOJ[BEP QPS FM
.JOJTUFSJP EF +VTUJDJB Z %FSFDIPT )V
NBOPTEF"SHFOUJOBRVFQPSJORVJFUVE
EF+VBO$BSMPT5FBMEJTFPSHBOJ[ØFOMB
DJVEBEEF#VFOPT"JSFTFOUSFFMZFM
EFOPWJFNCSFEFQBSBFMBOÈMJTJT
EFVOUFSDFSFTCP[PEFUFYUPQSFQBSBEP
QPSFMHSVQPEFSFEBDDJØOEFMB6/&4
$0 FO UPSOP B VOB %FDMBSBDJØO 6OJ
WFSTBM EF #JPÏUJDB &O MB PQPSUVOJEBE
MBSFQSFTFOUBDJØOCPMJWJBOBFYQVTPVOB
QPOFODJBDPODSFUBDPNPFMSFTUPEFMPT
QBÓTFTJOWJUBEPTDPOJOUFSQSFUBDJPOFTZ
DPNFOUBSJPTBEJDIPCPSSBEPSEFKBOEP
FODMBSPRVFÏTUFSFQSFTFOUBCBNÈTFMJO
UFSÏTEFM1SJNFS.VOEPFOFMEFTBSSPMMP
UFDOPMØHJDPZDJFOUÓmDPRVFMBJOUFODJØO
EFSFTPMWFSMBTDPOEJDJPOFTEFQPCSF[B
FOGFSNFEBEIBNCSFZNJTFSJBRVFQPS
MBJOKVTUJDJBTPDJBMZFDPOØNJDBHPMQFB
EVSBNFOUF B VO HSBO QPSDFOUBKF EF MB
QPCMBDJØOEFOVFTUSPTQBÓTFT
-PTJOUFHSBOUFTEF$/#QBSUJDJQB
SPO Z QBSUJDJQBO DPNP DPOGFSFODJTUBT
FO DVSTPT DJDMPT EF DPOGFSFODJBT Z EJ
QMPNBEPTPSHBOJ[BEPTQPSEJWFSTBTJOT
UJUVDJPOFT FOUSF MBT RVF TF NFODJPOBO
MBTVOJWFSTJEBEFT.BZPSEF4BO"OESÏT
/VFTUSB4F×PSBEF-B1B[Z%FM7BMMF
$PMFHJP .ÏEJDP %FQBSUBNFOUBM EF -B
1B[$PMFHJPEF#JPRVÓNJDBZ'BSNBDJB
EF#PMJWJB$PNJTJØO&QJTDPQBM1BTUPSBM
4PDJBM3FQSFTFOUBDJØOEFMB0140.4
PERSPETIVADELABIOETICAINDD
1PTUFSJPSNFOUFFM$/#FOWJØBM.JOJT
UFSJP EF 3FMBDJPOFT &YUFSJPSFT Z $VMUP
EF#PMJWJBVOJOGPSNFDPNQMFUPEFMTF
NJOBSJP SFBMJ[BEP FO "SHFOUJOB KVOUP
DPO UPEBT MBT NPEJmDBDJPOFT RVF TF
1FSTQFDUJWBTEFMB#JPÏUJDBFO*CFSPBNÏSJDB
DPOTJEFSBSPO DPOWFOJFOUFT BM CPSSBEPS
EF MB %FDMBSBDJØO EF MB 6/&4$0 MBT
DVBMFT FO CVFOB NFEJEB JODPSQPSBO MB
QPTJDJØOSFJWJOEJDBUPSJBEFMUFNBTPDJBM
ZFDPMØHJDPRVFQSFPDVQBBMPTQBÓTFTEFM
5FSDFS.VOEPFYQSFTBEBFOMB$BSUBEF
#VFOPT"JSFT
0USBT SFVOJPOFT EFTUBDBCMFT GVFSPO FM
TJNQPTJP PSHBOJ[BEP FO .POUFWJEFP
FOQBSBDPOTJEFSBSUFNBTSFMBDJP
OBEPT DPO FM &TUBUVUP &QJTUFNPMØHJDP
EF#JPÏUJDBRVFEJPPSJHFOBVOBQVCMJ
DBDJØOEFMNJTNPOPNCSFFEJUBEBQPS
MB6OJWFSTJEBE/BDJPOBM"VUØOPNBEF
.ÏYJDP6/".
ZMB6/&4$0ZFM
TJNQPTJP TPCSF *OWFTUJHBDJØO FO 4FSFT
)VNBOPTZ1PMÓUJDBTEF4BMVE1ÞCMJDB
RVFTFMMFWØBDBCPFO#PHPUÈFOUSFFM
ZFMEFNBZPEF
%FM BM EFKVOJP EFFM
$/#PSHBOJ[ØVODJDMPEFDPOGFSFODJBT
ZUBMMFSFTTPCSFQPMÓUJDBTEFTBMVEÏUJDB
FOMBJOWFTUJHBDJØOZCJPÏUJDBMBUJOPBNF
SJDBOBBQSPQØTJUPEFMBWJTJUBB#PMJWJB
EF%BOJFM1JFESB)FSSFSBEF$VCB
6OBEFMBTQSJODJQBMFTZQFSNBOFO
UFTBDUJWJEBEFTEFM$/#BUSBWÏTEFTV
$PNJTJØOEF*OWFTUJHBDJØO
FTMBWBMJEB
DJØO ÏUJDB EF USBCBKPT EF JOWFTUJHBDJØO
FOWJBEPTQPSEJWFSTBTJOTUJUVDJPOFTFO
USFMBTRVFTFDVFOUBOFM.414MB014
JOTUJUVUPT EF JOWFTUJHBDJØO TPDJFEBEFT
DJFOUÓmDBT0/(TFJOWFTUJHBEPSFTQBS
UJDVMBSFT
&OMBHFTUJØOTFIBJOUFOTJm
DBEPMBMBCPSEFMB$PNJTJØOEF1SPZFD
DJØOBMB$PNVOJEBEDPOMBFNJTJØOEF
PERSPETIVADELABIOETICAINDD
VO QSPHSBNB SBEJBM TFNBOBM RVF QSP
NVFWF VO BDFSDBNJFOUP TFODJMMP EF MB
CJPÏUJDBBMBQPCMBDJØOFOHFOFSBM
0USBHSBONPUJWBDJØOEFM$/#FTMB
EFQSPNPWFSMBJODPSQPSBDJØOEFMBCJP
ÏUJDBZMBTIVNBOJEBEFTNÏEJDBTFOMPT
QSPHSBNBT DVSSJDVMBSFT EF MBT DBSSFSBT
QSPGFTJPOBMFTEFTBMVEZEFDJFODJBTTP
DJBMFT&OUBMTFOUJEPTFMPHSØVOCVFO
BWBODFFOEJDJFNCSFEFDPOMBSFB
MJ[BDJØOEFVOUBMMFSEFMBTDVBUSPGBDVM
UBEFT EF NFEJDJOB EF MBT VOJWFSTJEBEFT
FTUBUBMFTNÈTJNQPSUBOUFTEFMQBÓTFOFM
DVBMQBSUJDJQØBDUJWBNFOUFMBDPPSEJOB
DJØO EFM $/# DPNP ÞOJDB JOTUJUVDJØO
JOWJUBEB &O EJDIP UBMMFS TF BDPSEØ FM
FTUBCMFDJNJFOUPEFVOBVOJEBEPEFQBS
UBNFOUPFOMBFTUSVDUVSBGBDVMUBUJWBRVF
EJGVOEBMBFOTF×BO[BEFMB²UJDB.ÏEJ
DB #JPÏUJDB Z )VNBOJEBEFT .ÏEJDBT
EFNBOFSBIPSJ[POUBMFOMBTDBSSFSBTEF
TBMVEZDPOMBSFTQFDUJWBBEFDVBDJØOB
MPT SFRVFSJNJFOUPT EF MBT DÈUFESBT "D
UVBMNFOUF FM DPPSEJOBEPS EFM $/#
EJDUB MBT ÞOJDBT DÈUFESBT EF QSFHSBEP
FYJTUFOUFT FO FM QBÓT RVF DPSSFTQPOEFO
B)JTUPSJBEFMB.FEJDJOB6OJWFSTJEBE
/VFTUSB4F×PSBEF-B1B[
²UJDBZ4P
DJPMPHÓB .ÏEJDB 6OJWFSTJEBE 1SJWBEB
'SBO[5BNBZP
3FMBDJPOFTJOUFSJOTUJUVDJPOBMFT
&OUSFMBTSFMBDJPOFTOBDJPOBMFTNÈTJN
QPSUBOUFT DBCF EFTUBDBS MBT TPTUFOJEBT
DPO MPT NJOJTUFSJPT EF 4BMVE &EVDB
DJØO +VTUJDJB Z 3FMBDJPOFT &YUFSJPSFT
BTÓDPNPDPOMB$BKB/BDJPOBMEF4BMVE
$/4
TFSWJDJPT EFQBSUBNFOUBMFT EF
-BCJPÏUJDBFO#PMJWJBBOUFDFEFOUFTZQSPZFDDJPOFT+BWJFS-VOB0SPTDP&EVBSEP
TBMVE 4&%&4
VOJWFSTJEBEFT QÞCMJDBT
Z QSJWBEBT EFM TJTUFNB DPMFHJPT QSPGF
TJPOBMFT $PMFHJP EF "CPHBEPT EF -B
1B[$BKB1FUSPMFSBEF4FHVSJEBE4PDJBM
4FHVSP4PDJBM6OJWFSTJUBSJPTPDJFEBEFT
NÏEJDP DJFOUÓmDBT "DBEFNJB /BDJPOBM
EF $JFODJBT "DBEFNJB #PMJWJBOB EF
.FEJDJOB JOTUJUVUPT EF JOWFTUJHBDJØO
QBSUJDVMBSNFOUF FM *OTUJUVUP #PMJWJB
OP EF #JPMPHÓB EF MB "MUVSB Z FM *OTUJ
UVUP#PMJWJBOPEF(FOÏUJDB
$PNJTJØO
&QJTDPQBM 1BTUPSBM 4PDJBM EF MB *HMFTJB
$BUØMJDB 0/(T FO TBMVE NFEJPT EF
DPNVOJDBDJØO*OTUJUVUPEF#JPÏUJDBEF
MB6OJWFSTJEBE$BUØMJDBEF$PDIBCBN
CBZ"#*0%(&
&OFMQMBOPJOUFSOBDJPOBMFM$/#NBO
UJFOFSFMBDJPOFTDPOFM13#EFMB014
0.4 '&-"*#& MB 3FE -BUJOPBNFSJ
DBOBZEFM$BSJCFEF#JPÏUJDBFM$PNJUÏ
*OUFSOBDJPOBM EF #JPÏUJDB $*#
EF MB
6/&4$0 #*0463 Z MB "TPDJBDJØO
EF#JPÏUJDBEF"SHFOUJOBMB"TPDJBDJØO
#SBTJMFSBEF#JPÏUJDBMB'VOEBDJØO+PTÏ
.BSÓB.BJOFUUJEF-B1MBUBZQSJODJQBM
NFOUFDPOMBSFQSFTFOUBDJØOEFMB014
0.4FO#PMJWJB
3FQSFTFOUBDJPOFT
&OMBBDUVBMJEBEFMDPPSEJOBEPSEFM$/#
GPSNBQBSUFEFMPTEJSFDUPSJPTEF'&-"*
#&EFMB3FE-BUJOPBNFSJDBOBZEFM$B
SJCFEF#JPÏUJDBZEFM$*#EFMB6/&4
$0QPSVOQFSÓPEPEFDVBUSPB×PT
1VCMJDBDJPOFT
4JCJFOBUSBWÏTEFTVDPPSEJOBEPSZTVT
NJFNCSPTFM$*&#ZFM$/#UJFOFOWB
PERSPETIVADELABIOETICAINDD
SJBTQVCMJDBDJPOFTFOSFWJTUBTZGPMMFUPT
EFTUBDBOMBDPOUSJCVDJØOQBSBMBFMBCP
SBDJØO EFM EPDVNFOUP JOUFSOBDJPOBM
i&UIJDBMBOE1PMJDZ*OTTVFTJO*OUFSOBUJP
OBM 3FTFBSDI $MJOJDBM 5SJBMT JO %FWFMP
QJOH$PVOUSJFTwEFMB/BUJPOBM#JPFUIJDT
"EWJTPSZ$PNNJTTJPO/#"$
64"ZMB
RVFmHVSBFOFM&TUBUVUP&QJTUFNPMØHJDP
EF#JPÏUJDBQVCMJDBEPQPSMB6/".EF
.ÏYJDPZMB3FE-BUJOPBNFSJDBOBZEFM
$BSJCFEF#JPÏUJDBFO&OFMÈN
CJUPOBDJPOBMUVWPNVDIBJNQPSUBODJB
MBQVCMJDBDJØOEFMB3FWJTUB#PMJWJBOBEF
#JPÏUJDBKVOJPEF
ZMBi.FNPSJB
EFM'PSP"CJFSUPEF1PMÓUJDBTEF4BMVEw
EFBNCBTDPOMBDPMBCPSBDJØOEF
MB0140.4FO#PMJWJB
%FTEFTVTJOJDJPTMBDPPSEJOBDJØOHFOF
SBMEFM$*&#ZEFM$/#IBFTUBEPBNJ
DBSHPDPOMBDPMBCPSBDJØOEF-VJT)VS
UBEP(ØNF[
4BÞM1BOUPKB.BSUIB
1BDIFDP 3VUI (VJMMÏO EF .BMEPOB
EP &OSJRVF 7BSHBT 1BDIFDP #FBUSJ[
.POUPZB+BJNF.PMMJOFEP"WFSBOHBZ
&NNB"QBSJDJP
.PUJWBDJPOFTZPSJFOUBDJPOFT
GVUVSBTEFM$/#
-B SFBMJEBE EFM NVOEP BDUVBM FT BMUB
NFOUFDVFTUJPOBCMFQPSVODPOKVOUPEF
TJUVBDJPOFT BEWFSTBT RVF oDPNFO[BOEP
QPSMBHVFSSBZMBWJPMFODJBDPOTVTDPO
TFDVFODJBTEFNVFSUFZEFTPMBDJØOoTPO
VOB DPOTUBOUF IJTUØSJDB JOTVQFSBCMF Z
VOBSFBMJEBEBOUJCJPÏUJDBEFQFSTJTUFODJB
DPUJEJBOB 1PS PUSB QBSUF FM QPEFS QP
MÓUJDPUSBEJDJPOBMEFCJMJUBEPQPSFMEFT
HBTUF EF TVT FTRVFNBT JODBQBDJEBE EF
MPTMÓEFSFTQMBOFUBSJPTGSFOUFBMPTDBN
1FSTQFDUJWBTEFMB#JPÏUJDBFO*CFSPBNÏSJDB
CJPTFJOKVTUJDJBZDPSSVQDJØODSFDJFOUFT
FO CVFOB QBSUF EFM NVOEP EFUFSNJOB
VODPOKVOUPEFHSBWFTBDPOUFDJNJFOUPT
RVFOPTFYJHFOQFOTBSFOOVFWBTGPSNBT
EFDPOEVDDJØOQPMÓUJDBDPONBZPSDPN
QSPNJTPZQBSUJDJQBDJØODJVEBEBOB
&O CVFOB QBSUF EF -BUJOPBNÏSJDB MPT
NPWJNJFOUPTQPMÓUJDPTOPUJFOFOMÓOFBT
DMBSBTEFTPMVDJØOEFQSPCMFNBTFTUSVD
UVSBMFTSFTQPOEJFOEPNÈTBDPZVOUVSBT
PFYJHFODJBTEFSFJWJOEJDBDJØOJONFEJB
UBEFHSVQPTQPCMBDJPOBMFTTFDVMBSNFOUF
QPTUFSHBEPT RVF WJWFO FO MB QPCSF[B Z
MBNBSHJOBMJEBE"UPEPFTUPTFTVNBMB
HMPCBMJ[BDJØOFDPOØNJDBZMBTMFZFTEFM
NFSDBEPRVFTPNFUFOBMPTQBÓTFTCBKP
MB IFHFNPOÓB EF HSVQPT EF QPEFS RVF
USBTDJFOEFOFMDPOUSPMZTPCFSBOÓBEFMPT
QSPQJPT&TUBEPT
-BT GPSNBT EF BHSFTJØO FOUSF DJVEBEB
OPTWBFOBVNFOUPNVDIBTWFDFTDPNP
GSVUPEFSFJWJOEJDBDJPOFTTFDUPSJBMFTRVF
BUFOUBODPOUSBFMCJFODPNÞOZDPNP
FYQSFTJØOQBUÏUJDBEFFTFiTÈMWFTFRVJFO
QVFEBwRVFDBTJOBEJFDPOUSPMB
1PSPUSBQBSUFMPTBWBODFTUFDOPMØHJDPT
QSPWPDBO VO TFDVFTUSP FDPOØNJDP QPS
QBSUF EF RVJFOFT MPT QVFEFO QBHBS FO
EFUSJNFOUPEFMPTBWBODFTTPDJBMFTZTPO
VOBDBVTBBEJDJPOBMEFTPNFUJNJFOUPZ
EFQFOEFODJB FO VOB TPDJFEBE DPOUFN
QPSÈOFBRVFiDPTJmDBwBMBTQFSTPOBTZ
iTBDSBMJ[Bw MBT DPTBT DPO QSFPDVQBOUFT
NBOJGFTUBDJPOFT EF EFTIVNBOJ[BDJØO
FHPÓTNPZIFEPOJTNP
&ONVDIPTMVHBSFTFMMBUJOPBNFSJDBOP
DPOUFNQPSÈOFP FTUÈ EFTBSSBJHBEP EF MB
PERSPETIVADELABIOETICAINDD
UJFSSB IB QFSEJEP BQSFDJP Z iDPOUJOVJ
EBEwDPOFMMBSFTVMUÈOEPMFFONVDIPT
TFOUJEPT BKFOB B TVT JOUFSFTFT QPS FM
BGÈO EF PCUFOFS iCJFOFTw NBUFSJBMFT Z
BSUJmDJBMFT &TBT TPDJFEBEFT NBOUJFOFO
QFSNBOFOUF DPOnJDUP FOUSF MPT HSVQPT
IVNBOPTRVFMBTDPOGPSNBOQSPWPDBO
EP YFOPGPCJB SBDJTNP NBSHJOBDJØO Z
UFOEFODJBT FVHFOÏTJDBT 4ÞNFTF B UPEP
FTUP MPT GFOØNFOPT DSFDJFOUFT OP DPO
USPMBEPTEFDPOUBNJOBDJØOBNCJFOUBMZ
EFTFRVJMJCSJP EF MPT FDPTJTUFNBT SFTVM
UBOEPQSFPDVQBOUFMBJOVTJUBEBGSFDVFO
DJBEFEFTBTUSFTOBUVSBMFTRVFOPQBSFDFO
TFSDBTVBMFT
&MBCBOEPOPZPTVCTUJUVDJØOEFMNVO
EP OBUVSBM QSPWPDBO RVF MB OBUVSBMF[B
ZFMIPNCSFWBZBOQFSEJFOEPSJRVF[BZ
WBSJFEBEQPSRVFNVDIBTDVMUVSBTEFMB
UJFSSBFUOPDVMUVSBT
FTUÈOEFTBQBSFDJFO
EP B MB QBS EF NVDIBT FTQFDJFT WJWBT
QPSFTBTVFSUFEFiSFWPMVDJØOUFDOPMØHJ
DBwRVFOPTMMFWBBSFFNQMB[BSMPOBUVSBM
QPSMPOBUVSBMNPEJmDBEPPMPBSUJmDJBM
QPOJFOEP FO EVEB FM FTUBUVT FTFODJBM
CJPMØHJDPQTJDPNFOUBMTPDJBMFIJTUØSJ
DPEFMIPNCSF
"IPSB CJFO {DVÈM FT OVFTUSB QFSDFQ
DJØOEFMBCJPÏUJDBJOUFSOBDJPOBMBDUVBM $SFFNPT RVF TF IB WJTUP EFTWJSUVBEB
EFTEF TVT JOJDJPT QPSRVF FM NFOTBKF
GVOEBDJPOBM EF 1PUUFS EF VOB CJPÏUJDB
HMPCBM IB TJEP QPTUFSHBEP Z PQBDBEP
QPSVOBCJPÏUJDBSFEVDJEBBMJOUFSÏTVUJ
MJUBSJPEFMEFTBSSPMMPUFDOPMØHJDPZDJFO
UÓmDP RVF IB TBCJEP BQSPWFDIBS DPO
DSFDFTFMQSFUFYUPEFMQSFDFQUPBMUSVJTUB
EFMBiÏUJDBFOMBJOWFTUJHBDJØOwBMTFSWJ
-BCJPÏUJDBFO#PMJWJBBOUFDFEFOUFTZQSPZFDDJPOFT+BWJFS-VOB0SPTDP&EVBSEP
DJP EF FOPSNFT JOUFSFTFT IFHFNØOJDPT
EFEJWFSTBÓOEPMF4JCJFOTFCFOFmDJØMB
DJFODJBDPOBEFMBOUPTRVFBTVWF[TØMP
DPOWJFOFOBRVJFOFTQVFEFOBDDFEFSB
FMMPT MB CJPÏUJDB FO HFOFSBM UVWP QPDB
P OVMB JOnVFODJB FO FM NFKPSBNJFOUP
EFM NVOEP B UBM QVOUP RVF FM HSVFTP
EF MB QPCMBDJØO IVNBOB EFTDPOPDF TV
FYJTUFODJBPUFSNJOBQPSOPBTVNJSTV
JNQPSUBODJB
DJØOFTJHVBMNFOUFJOEJWJEVBMJTUBOPUB
CMFNFOUF JOnVJEB QPS FM QBSBEJHNB EF
MPT DVBUSP QSJODJQJPT FTUBCMFDJEPT QPS
#FBVDIBNQZ$IJMESFTTRVFFOQBSUF
QVEJFTFOTFSDPOUSBEJDUPSJPTPOPUJFOFO
MBNJTNBBQMJDBDJØOQBSBFMFKFSDJDJPEF
VOBCJPÏUJDBTBOJUBSJBUBOOFDFTBSJBFO
NVDIPT EF OVFTUSPT QBÓTFT DPO TFSJPT
QSPCMFNBTEFKVTUJDJBFJOFRVJEBEFOFM
BDDFTPBMPTTFSWJDJPTEFTBMVE
"M QBSFDFS MB CJPÏUJDB PDDJEFOUBM NB
ZPSNFOUF WJODVMBEB BM EFTBSSPMMP DJFO
UÓmDPVOJWFSTBMJ[ØUFOEFODJBTFJODMVZØ
B-BUJOPBNÏSJDBEPOEFIBQSFWBMFDJEP
IBTUBFMQSFTFOUFTJOQSFPDVQBSTFEFCVT
DBSBEFDVBDJPOFTBMBTEJWFSTBTSFBMJEBEFT
DVMUVSBMFT Z TPDJPBOUSPQPMØHJDBT &TUB
TVFSUFEFDPMPOJBMJTNPCJPÏUJDPTFEFKØ
QFSDJCJSJODMVTPFOMBTPSJFOUBDJPOFTEF
MPT QSJNFSPT CPSSBEPSFT EF MB %FDMBSB
DJØO 6OJWFSTBM EF #JPÏUJDB Z %FSFDIPT
)VNBOPTEFMB6/&4$0ZFOMBTSF
VOJPOFTRVFTFEJFSPOFO1BSÓTIBTUBTV
BQSPCBDJØO mOBMNFOUF BMHP NÈT DPO
TFOTVBEBDPOMPTJOUFSFTFTEFMPTQBÓTFT
EFM5FSDFS.VOEP
&TUFFTVONPNFOUPEFJOnFYJØOEFMB
CJPÏUJDB P TJ TF RVJFSF EF DVFTUJPOB
NJFOUPBMPMJNJUBEPEFTVTSFTVMUBEPT
{IBSFTQPOEJEPMBCJPÏUJDBBMBSFBMJEBE
MBUJOPBNFSJDBOB
-BCJPÏUJDBTFIBSFEVDJEPNÈTBMJOEJ
WJEVPRVFBMPTPDJBMZBNCJFOUBMNBO
UFOJFOEPVODBSÈDUFSBDBEÏNJDPDJFOUÓ
mDPRVFTJCJFOBHSFHØNVDIPBOÈMJTJT
EPDUSJOBM Z mMPTØmDP UVWP NVZ QPDP
JNQBDUPTPDJBMTBMWPQPSBRVFMMPTUFNBT
iOPWFEPTPTw GVFSUFNFOUF QVCMJDJUBEPT
DPNP TPO MBT BTPNCSPTBT QPTJCJMJEBEFT
EFMBCJPMPHÓBNPMFDVMBSMBDMPOBDJØOV
PUSPT
&OMPRVFTFSFmFSFBMBBQMJDBDJØONÏ
EJDPTBOJUBSJBEFMBCJPÏUJDBTVPSJFOUB
PERSPETIVADELABIOETICAINDD
-B SFTQVFTUB QVFEF TFS EJWFSTB QPSRVF
MBTSFBMJEBEFTEFMPTQBÓTFTMBUJOPBNFSJ
DBOPTTPOUBNCJÏOEJTUJOUBT4JOFNCBS
HP FT OFDFTBSJP TF×BMBS MBT DBSBDUFSÓTUJ
DBTHFOFSBMFTZMPTGBDUPSFTEFWFOUBKBEF
OVFTUSBSFHJØORVFQSPCBCMFNFOUFOP
IBOTJEPEFMUPEPDPNQSFOEJEPTPBQSP
WFDIBEPT QBSB DPOTUSVJS VOB CJPÏUJDB
NÈTQSPQJB&OUSFÏTUPT-BUJOPBNÏSJDB
TVNBMBIFSFODJBEFMBDVMUVSBVOJWFSTBM
ZFTQPTFFEPSBEFDVMUVSBTQSPQJBTRVF
DPOTUJUVZFO HSBOEFT BQPSUFT QBSB WJHP
SJ[BSZEBSMFVODBSÈDUFSEFSFOPWBDJØO
BMBDVMUVSBNVOEJBMDPOTJEFSBOEPRVF
FTBEFNÈTMBSFHJØODPONBZPSSJRVF[B
OBUVSBM CJPEJWFSTJEBE Z SFTFSWB FDPMØ
HJDBEFMQMBOFUBNPTUSBOEPVOBNQMJP
BCBOJDPEFQPUFODJBMJEBEFTZQPTJCJMJEB
EFTGVUVSBTBMBTRVFUBNCJÏOTFTVNBFM
EFTBSSPMMP DJFOUÓmDP Z UFDOPMØHJDP 1PS
PUSBQBSUFFOOVFTUSPTQBÓTFTTFNBOUJF
OFOMPTWBMPSFTUSBEJDJPOBMFTEFMBGBNJ
MJBDPOHSFHBEBZVOJEBMBDBMJEF[FOFM
1FSTQFDUJWBTEFMB#JPÏUJDBFO*CFSPBNÏSJDB
USBUPZFMUSBCBKPDPNVOJUBSJPRVFTPO
FYQSFTJPOFTEFVOBQPCMBDJØOTFOTJCMFB
MPJOEJWJEVBMZMPTPDJBM
$SFP RVF IBZ NBUFSJB QBSB DPOTUSVJS
VOBCJPÏUJDBMBUJOPBNFSJDBOBRVFUFOHB
VO TVTUFOUP FQJTUFNPMØHJDP EPDUSJOBM
ZmMPTØmDP
EFMPHFOFSBMVPDDJEFOUBM
B MP BNFSJDBOP Z BVUØDUPOP FTUVEJÈO
EPOPTQBSBDPOPDFSOPTNFKPSZBQMJDBS
VOBCJPÏUJDBEFGVFSUFDPOUFOJEPBOUSP
QPMØHJDPZTPDJBMTPCSFMBTIVFMMBTEFMB
UJFSSBFJEFOUJEBE1BSBFTUPTFSFRVJFSF
VOBCJPÏUJDBEFJOUFSWFODJØOZQBSUJDJ
QBDJØODBQB[EFBQSPYJNBSTFBMPTOJ
WFMFT FTUBUBMFT QSPNPWJFOEP QSPDFTPT
EF FEVDBDJØO DJVEBEBOB RVF MPHSFO
BKVTUFTUFNÈUJDPTZQSPHSBNÈUJDPTDPO
DPSEBOUFTDPOMBTSFBMJEBEFTZOFDFTJEB
EFTQSPQJBT
&OMPRVFIBDFBMBSFMBDJØOEFMBCJPÏ
UJDB DPO MB TBMVE IVNBOB FT OFDFTBSJP
FYUFOEFSMBCJPÏUJDBDMÓOJDBJOEJWJEVBMB
MB CJPÏUJDB TBOJUBSJB JODJEJFOEP FO MBT
QPMÓUJDBTEFTBMVEQBSBVONFKPSBNJFOUP
DPOTUBOUFEFMBDBMJEBEFOMPTTFSWJDJPTZ
VOBNBZPSTBUJTGBDDJØOEFMPTVTVBSJPT
TJOEJTUJODJØOBMHVOB
'JOBMNFOUFFTUBQFSDFQDJØOMBUJOPBNF
SJDBOB EFCF TFS JODPSQPSBEB FO MB GPS
NBDJØOJOUFSOBDJPOBMEFMBCJPÏUJDBOP
TØMPDPOVODSJUFSJPJOUFHSBEPSTJOPQPS
MB OFDFTJEBE Z PCMJHBDJØO RVF UFOFNPT
MPT MBUJOPBNFSJDBOPT EF NPTUSBS VOB
SFBMJEBE NVZ EJGFSFOUF B MB RVF QSFWB
MFDFFOPDDJEFOUFZQSFUFOEFQSJNBSFO
FMNVOEP
PERSPETIVADELABIOETICAINDD
&M*OTUJUVUPEF#JPÏUJDBEFMB
6OJWFSTJEBE$BUØMJDB#PMJWJBOB
6$#
FO$PDIBCBNCB
&MEFOPWJFNCSFEFFM$POTFKP
%JSFDUJWPEFM*OTUJUVUP4VQFSJPSEF&T
UVEJPT 5FPMØHJDPT *4&5
DPO MB QSF
TFODJB EF TV QSFTJEFOUF )BOT WBO EFO
#FSHZMBEFMSFDUPSEFMB6$#-VJT"O
UPOJP #P[B BQSPCBSPO MB DPOTUJUVDJØO
EFM $FOUSP EF #JPÏUJDB FM QSJNFSP EF
TVHÏOFSPFO#PMJWJBOPNCSBOEPDPNP
EJSFDUPS B .JHVFM .BO[BOFSB RVJFO
DPOUJOÞB FO FM DBSHP FO MB BDUVBMJEBE
&OFM$FOUSPEF#JPÏUJDBQBTØB
MMBNBSTF*OTUJUVUPEF#JPÏUJDB*#
&OUSFTVTPCKFUJWPTTFFODVFOUSB'P
NFOUBSMBJOWFTUJHBDJØOMBFEVDBDJØOZ
MBEJGVTJØOEFMBCJPÏUJDBFOEFGFOTBEFMB
WJEBIVNBOBEFTEFMBDPODFQDJØOIBT
UB TV UFSNJOBDJØO OBUVSBM RVF JODMVZF
FMDVJEBEPEFMFOUPSOPTPDJBMZNFEJP
BNCJFOUBM DPO QSPZFDDJØO VOJWFSTBM Z
UFPMPHBMUFOJFOEPDPNPQVOUPEFSFGF
SFODJBZPSJFOUBDJØOMBFOTF×BO[BEFMB
*HMFTJB$BUØMJDB1SPNPWFSFMEJÈMPHP
JOUFSEJTDJQMJOBSJP FOUSF DVMUJWBEPSFT EF
MBT DJFODJBT NÏEJDBT KVSÓEJDBT TPDJBMFT
DVMUVSBMFTFDPMØHJDBTmMPTØmDBTZUFPMØ
HJDBTUFOJFOEPDPNPCBTFVOBBOUSPQP
MPHÓBEFPSJFOUBDJØOIVNBOBZDSJTUJBOB
SFTQFUBOEPMPTHFOVJOPTWBMPSFTDVMUVSB
MFTGBNJMJBSFTZSFMJHJPTPTWJHFOUFTFOMB
QPCMBDJØO CPMJWJBOB DPO FTQFDJBM QSF
GFSFODJB QPS MBT QFSTPOBT NBSHJOBEBT Z
FNQPCSFDJEBTRVFBEPMFDFOEFVOBFMF
WBEBNPSCJMJEBEZNPSUBMJEBE
-BCJPÏUJDBFO#PMJWJBBOUFDFEFOUFTZQSPZFDDJPOFT+BWJFS-VOB0SPTDP&EVBSEP
6OBEFMBTBDUVBDJPOFTNÈTJNQPSUBOUFT
EFMBQSJNFSBFUBQBGVFMBPSHBOJ[BDJØO
EFM * &ODVFOUSP /BDJPOBM EF #JPÏUJ
DB $PDIBCBNCB
FOUSF FM Z FM EF
TFQUJFNCSFEFBCPDBEPBMFTUVEJP
EF MB -FZ EF 5SBTQMBOUF EF »SHBOPT Z
5FKJEPT RVF TF FODPOUSBCB CMPRVFBEB
QPS SB[POFT QPMÓUJDBT FO FM 1BSMBNFOUP
EF#PMJWJB
"QBSUJSEFTFIBEFEJDBEPBMBJO
WFTUJHBDJØO QSPDVSBOEP EBS SFTQVFTUBT
B MPT JOUFSSPHBOUFT NBZPSFT QMBOUFBEPT
B MB CJPÏUJDB &M IFDIP EF QFSUFOFDFS B
MB 6$# IB NBSDBEP MB MÓOFB EF PSJFO
UBDJØOEFOVFTUSPUSBCBKP&M*#PGSFDF
VO TFSWJDJP EF CJCMJPUFDB DPO NBUFSJBM
CJCMJPHSÈmDPZEPDVNFOUBDJØO
+VOUBNFOUFDPOFM$PNJUÏ/BDJPOBMEF
#JPÏUJDBMB6OJWFSTJEBE.BZPSEF4BO
4JNØO MB 6OJWFSTJEBE .BZPS EF 4BO
"OESÏTMB0140.4ZPUSBTJOTUJUVDJP
OFTPSHBOJ[ØFM**$POHSFTP#PMJWJBOP
EF #JPÏUJDB #JPÏUJDB Z 4VCEFTBSSPMMP
EFMBMEFBHPTUPEF
)B NBOUFOJEP NVDIPT DPOUBDUPT DPO
NVDIBT JOTUJUVDJPOFT FDMFTJÈTUJDBT HV
CFSOBNFOUBMFT QSPGFTJPOBMFT FEVDBUJ
WBTZVOJWFSTJUBSJBTmHVSBOEPFOMBCBTF
EF EBUPT EF CJPÏUJDB EF MB 6/&4$0
&OUSF MBT JOTUJUVDJPOFT FDMFTJÈTUJDBT EFM
7BUJDBOP FT DPOWFOJFOUF NFODJPOBS B
MB 1POUJmDJB "DBEFNJB QPS MB 7JEB FM
1POUJmDJP $POTFKP QBSB MB 1BTUPSBM EF
MB 4BMVE Z FM 1POUJmDJP $POTFKP QBSB
MB 'BNJMJB %FOUSP EF #PMJWJB DPMBCPSB
DPO MB $POGFSFODJB &QJTDPQBM #PMJWJB
OB QBSUJDVMBSNFOUF DPO MB $PNJTJØO
&QJTDPQBMEF%PDUSJOBZ'FBEFNÈTEF
PERSPETIVADELABIOETICAINDD
NBOUFOFS FTUSFDIBT SFMBDJPOFT DPO MBT
JHMFTJBTMPDBMFTEF#PMJWJBZTVTEJWFSTPT
PSHBOJTNPT
&M *# FT NJFNCSP GVOEBEPS EF MB 'F
EFSBDJØO *OUFSOBDJPOBM EF $FOUSPT F
*OTUJUVUPT EF #JPÏUJDB EF *OTQJSBDJØO
1FSTPOBMJTUB'*#*1
DVZBQSJNFSBBDUB
EFGVOEBDJØOTFmSNØFMEFKVOJPEF
FO3PNBTJFOEPSBUJmDBEBTVJO
DPSQPSBDJØOFM¡EFPDUVCSFEF
'VF NJFNCSP GVOEBEPS EF MB 'FEFSB
DJØO -BUJOPBNFSJDBOB EF *OTUJUVDJPOFT
EF #JPÏUJDB '&-"*#&
FO MB 7JMMB EF
-FZWB $PMPNCJB
FO OPWJFNCSF EF
6OPEFTVTPCKFUJWPTEFM*#IBTJEPMB
EJGVTJØOEFMBCJPÏUJDBQPSNFEJPEFQV
CMJDBDJPOFTFOMJCSPTSFWJTUBTGPMMFUPTZ
QFSJØEJDPT.FSFDFNFODJØOFTQFDJBMMB
$PMFDDJØO#*04JOJDJBEBFO
"QFTBSEFMBFTDBTF[EFSFDVSTPTIBDPO
TFHVJEPEFTBSSPMMBSVOBMÓOFBEFCJPÏUJDB
MBUJOPBNFSJDBOB EF JOTQJSBDJØO IVNB
OJTUB Z DSJTUJBOB RVF QVFEF FOSJRVFDFS
BMBDUVBMEFCBUF
-BTNPUJWBDJPOFTZPSJFOUBDJPOFTEFM*#
TFSFnFKBOFOMBTQVCMJDBDJPOFTEFMB$P
MFDDJØO#*04DPOMBTJHVJFOUFTÓOUFTJT
#JPÏUJDBEFMBOPTUSJEBE1PSVOBQBSUF
DPOUSBTUBDPOMBCJPÏUJDBOPSUFBNFSJDB
OB EF DV×P QSFEPNJOBOUFNFOUF VUJMJ
UBSJTUB Z QSBHNBUJTUB RVF TF DFOUSB FO
MBTDPOTFDVFODJBTEFMBBDDJØOIVNBOB
ZOPUJFOFFODVFOUBMBWJTJØOUSBOTDFO
EFOUFEFMIPNCSF*HVBMNFOUFTJSWFEF
DPOUSBQVOUPBMBCJPÏUJDBFVSPQFBRVF
1FSTQFDUJWBTEFMB#JPÏUJDBFO*CFSPBNÏSJDB
TJCJFOQSPGVOEJ[BFOMPTBTQFDUPTmMPTØ
mDPT TF PSJFOUB QSFGFSFOUFNFOUF IBDJB
FM EJÈMPHP DPOTFOTVBMJTUB RVF JNQMJDB
VOBWJTJØOSFMBUJWJTUBEFMBWFSEBE
-BCJPÏUJDBEFMBOPTUSJEBERVJFSFGVO
EBNFOUBS TVT WBMPSFT BYJPMØHJDPT Z TVT
QSJODJQJPTÏUJDPTFOVOBWJTJØOJOUFHSBM
EFM IPNCSF DPNP TFS QTJDPTPNÈUJDP
JNQVMTBEP B MB USBOTDFOEFODJB IBDJB
FM OPTPUSPT VOJWFSTBM BOUSPQPUFPMPHBM
%FTEFFTUBQFSTQFDUJWBDBCFSFGPSNVMBS
MPTQSJODJQJPTDMÈTJDPTEFOPNBMFmDFO
DJBKVTUJDJBBVUPOPNÓBZCFOFmDFODJB
#JPEFSFDIP &O FTUF ÈNCJUP FT JNQPS
UBOUFQSPNPWFSFMEJTDFSOJNJFOUPZSF
DPOPDJNJFOUP EF MPT BVUÏOUJDPT CJPEF
SFDIPT IVNBOPT GVOEBNFOUBEPT FO MB
EJHOJEBEOBUVSBMEFMIPNCSFSFDIB[BO
EP FYDMVTJPOFT F JOUFSQSFUBDJPOFT BCV
TJWBT&OFMBDUVBMEFCBUFJOUFSOBDJPOBM
BERVJFSFJNQPSUBODJBFMSFDPOPDJNJFOUP
EFMBPCKFDJØOEFDPODJFODJBZBTJNJT
NPFMEFTBSSPMMPEFMBUPMFSBODJBDPNP
WJSUVEÏUJDBUBOUPGSFOUFBMBJOUPMFSBODJB
DPNPBMBVMUSBUPMFSBODJB
0SUPHFOFTJB&TJNQPSUBOUFQSPNPWFSFM
EFSFDIP EF UPEP TFS IVNBOP B TFS HF
OFSBEPQPSMBSFMBDJØODPOZVHBMOBUVSBM
RVF HBSBOUJ[B BM OJ×P MB QFSUFOFODJB B
VOPTQBESFTJEFOUJmDBEPTZVOJEPTFOFM
BNPSGBNJMJBS-BPSUPHFOFTJBTFPQPOF
OPTØMPZFOQSJNFSMVHBSBMBCPSUPZBMB
FVHFOFTJBTJOPUBNCJÏOBMBEJTHFOFTJB
JODMVZFOEP MB GFSUJMJ[BDJØO FYUSBDPSQØ
SFB Z PUSBT UÏDOJDBT RVF FYQPOFO B MPT
FNCSJPOFT IVNBOPT B NBOJQVMBDJPOFT
DPOUSBSJBTBTVEJHOJEBE
PERSPETIVADELABIOETICAINDD
1PS FMMP TF EFCF JNQVMTBS MB JOWFTUJ
HBDJØO DPO DÏMVMBT USPODBMFT BEVMUBT P
VNCJMJDBMFTZSFDIB[BSMBDMPOBDJØOTFB
SFQSPEVDUJWBPUFSBQÏVUJDBZMBVUJMJ[B
DJØO EF DÏMVMBT USPODBMFT FNCSJPOBMFT
%FOUSPEFMBPSUPHFOFTJBBERVJFSFJN
QPSUBODJBMBQMBOJmDBDJØOGBNJMJBSOBUV
SBMDPNPBMUFSOBUJWBIVNBOJ[BOUFGSFOUF
BMBJOWBTJØOJOEJTDSJNJOBEBEFBOUJDPO
DFQUJWPTBMHVOPTEFFMMPTJBUSPHÏOJDPTZ
BCPSUJWPT
3FTQFDUP EFM FTUBUVUP POUPMØHJDP EFM
FNCSJØO IVNBOP MB DPODFQDJØO OPS
NBMTFDPSSFTQPOEFCJPMØHJDBNFOUFDPO
MBQFOFUSBDJØOEFMFTQFSNBUP[PJEFFOFM
ØWVMPPSJHJOBOEPVOOVFWPEJOBNJTNP
FOEØHFOPFOUFMÏRVJDPRVFFOUÏSNJOPT
NFUBGÓTJDPT TF EFOPNJOB iBMNBw %F
BRVÓ FM BQPZP B MB UFPSÓB EF MB BOJNB
DJØO JONFEJBUB EFM FNCSJØO IVNBOP
SFJOUFSQSFUBOEP MB QPTJDJØO BSJTUPUÏMJDB
UPNJTUB
0SUPUFSBQJB&OUÏSNJOPTEFTBMVEZFO
GFSNFEBEIBZRVFEFGFOEFSFMEFSFDIP
EFM QBDJFOUF B MB PSUPUFSBQJB P TFB B MB
DVSBDJØO Z BUFODJØO OBUVSBMFT EJHOBT
QSPQVHOBOEP MB IVNBOJ[BDJØO EF MB
NFEJDJOBEFTDBSUBOEPMBNBMBQSBYJTZ
PUSPT BCVTPT NÏEJDPT Z QSPNPWJFOEP
FM TFHVSP VOJWFSTBM NÏEJDP QBSB UPEB
MBQPCMBDJØO&TQFDJBMNFODJØONFSFDF
MBCJPÏUJDBEFMPTUSBTQMBOUFTEFDÏMVMBT
UFKJEPT Z ØSHBOPT QSPNPWJFOEP VOB
NBZPS TPMJEBSJEBE FO MBT EPOBDJPOFT Z
FOMBTNJTNBTPQFSBDJPOFTEFUSBTQMBOUF
EFGFOEJFOEPFMEFSFDIPEFMPTQBDJFOUFT
BMTFHVSPVOJWFSTBM
-BCJPÏUJDBFO#PMJWJBBOUFDFEFOUFTZQSPZFDDJPOFT+BWJFS-VOB0SPTDP&EVBSEP
0SUPUBOBTJB 1SPQVHOBNPT FM EFSFDIP
B MB PSUPUBOBTJB P NVFSUF OBUVSBM EJH
OBRVFTFPQPOFUBOUPBMBFVUBOBTJBP
NVFSUFQSPWPDBEBBQFUJDJØOEFMNJTNP
QBDJFOUFDPNPBMBEJTUBOBTJBPQSPMPO
HBDJØO JOEFCJEB P GÞUJM EF MB WJEB NF
EJBOUFQSPDFEJNJFOUPTEFTQSPQPSDJPOB
EPTPJOFRVJUBUJWPT&OFMEFCBUFTPCSF
MBMMBNBEBNVFSUFDFSFCSBMPFODFGÈMJDB
UFOFNPTMBDFSUF[BEFMBWBMJEF[EFMEJBH
OØTUJDP OFVSPMØHJDP EF NVFSUF CBTBEP
FO QBSÈNFUSPT TPCSF DFTBDJØO UPUBM F
JSSFWFSTJCMFEFMFODÏGBMPRVFGVFBDFQUB
EBQPSMB*HMFTJB$BUØMJDBFO
#JPÏUJDB FDPMØHJDB $PO FTUF UÏSNJOP TF
FYQSFTB VOB SFDUB DPNQSFOTJØO EF MB
FDPMPHÓB RVF SFDIB[B UBOUP MB BDUJUVE
QBTJWB GSFOUF B MBT BNFOB[BT FDPMØHJ
DBT DPNP FM FDPMPHJTNP RVF OP QPOF
BM IPNCSF FO FM DFOUSP EF MB DSFBDJØO
'SFOUFBQPTUVSBTFYUSFNBTGBWPSBCMFTP
EFTGBWPSBCMFT FO SFMBDJØO DPO MPT PSHB
OJTNPT HFOÏUJDBNFOUF NPEJmDBEPT FT
DPOWFOJFOUF NBOUFOFS VOB BDUJUVE EF
QSFDBVDJØOBQSPCBDJØOZFWBMVBDJØOEF
DBEBQSPZFDUPDBTPQPSDBTP
1FEBHPHÓBTFYVBM'SFOUFBMBFEVDBDJØO
MJCFSUBSJB Z IFEPOJTUB EF MB TFYVBMJEBE
IBZRVFUSBOTNJUJSVOBQFEBHPHÓBJOUF
HSBM QBSB MB FEVDBDJØO Z DPNQSFOTJØO
EF MB TFYVBMJEBE DPNP EJNFOTJØO BO
USPQPMØHJDB FO TVT USFT DPNQPOFOUFT
GVOEBNFOUBMFT VOJUJWB QSPDSFBUJWB Z
SFDSFBUJWB &M DPOUSPM SB[POBCMF EF MB
TFYVBMJEBE DMÈTJDBNFOUF MB WJSUVE EF
MB DBTUJEBE QFSNJUF B MPT KØWFOFT QSF
QBSBSTF BEFDVBEBNFOUF QBSB FM WFSEB
EFSPBNPSFMNBUSJNPOJPZMBGBNJMJB
PERSPETIVADELABIOETICAINDD
&TUBFEVDBDJØOFTBMNJTNPUJFNQPFM
NFKPS BOUÓEPUP QBSB MBT JOGFDDJPOFT EF
USBOTNJTJØOTFYVBMZMPTFNCBSB[PTJN
QSFWJTUPT
"TPDJBDJØO#PMJWJBOBEF#JPÏUJDB
Z%FSFDIP(FOÏUJDP
.PUJWBEPTQPSMBDPOEVDUBIVNBOBTV
SFMBDJØOCJPHFOÏUJDBZTVDPOUFYUPMFHBM
MPT BCPHBEPT «MWBSP .VOHVÓB #FDLFS
Z(VTUBWP4JWJMB1F×BSBOEBEFDJEJFSPO
JODVSTJPOBSFOFMFTUVEJPZEJWVMHBDJØO
EF MB CJPÏUJDB Z TV DPOOPUBDJØO MFHBM
JODMVZFOEPVOBOVFWBSBNBCJPUFDOJm
DBEBEFM%FSFDIPBDPSEFDPOMPTBEFMBO
UPTDJFOUÓmDPTIFDIPTRVFEJFSPODPNP
SFTVMUBEP MB DPOGPSNBDJØO EF MB "TP
DJBDJØO#PMJWJBOBEF#JPÏUJDB%FSFDIP
(FOÏUJDPZ#JPUFDOPMPHÓB"#*0%(&
FO BHSVQBDJØO DPOGPSNBEB QPS
QSPGFTJPOBMFTFODJFODJBTTPDJBMFTCJPMØ
HJDBTZEFMBTBMVE
4FNJOBSJPT DPO QBSUJDJQBDJØO EF FY
QPTJUPSFT JOUFSOBDJPOBMFT DPOGFSFODJBT
Z GPSPT OBDJPOBMFT F JOUFSDBNCJP EF
JOGPSNBDJØO DPO FOUJEBEFT TJNJMBSFT
FO FM JOUFSJPS Z FYUFSJPS EFM QBÓT DPOT
UJUVZFO QSJODJQBMNFOUF MBT mOBMJEBEFT
EF "#*0%(& -B QSFQBSBDJØO EF BO
UFQSPZFDUPTEFMFZFOCJPUFDOPMPHÓBSF
QSPEVDDJØOIVNBOBBTJTUJEBZHFOÏUJDB
TPOQBSUFEFMBTUBSFBTFOFMÈNCJUPMF
HJTMBUJWP-BBDFQUBDJØOEFVOBQSPQVFT
UB QBSB MB JODMVTJØO EF MBT NBUFSJBT EF
#JPÏUJDBZ%FSFDIP(FOÏUJDPFOFMQMBO
EFFTUVEJPTEFMBDBSSFSBEF%FSFDIPEF
MB 6.4" MB QSFQBSBDJØO EFM DVSTP EF
FTQFDJBMJ[BDJØOFOBNCBTZEJWFSTPTTF
1FSTQFDUJWBTEFMB#JPÏUJDBFO*CFSPBNÏSJDB
NJOBSJPT PSHBOJ[BEPT EFTEF IBO
TJEP IBTUB FM NPNFOUP MBT QSJODJQBMFT
BDUJWJEBEFTSFBMJ[BEBT
&MJOUFSÏTZMBEFEJDBDJØOQPSFMÈNCJUP
CJPMFHBMTFWJPQMBTNBEPFOFOMB
DPOGPSNBDJØOEFMB$PNJTJØOEF#JPÏUJ
DBZ%FSFDIP(FOÏUJDPEFM*MVTUSF$PMF
HJPEF"CPHBEPTEF-B1B[BDUVBMNFOUF
FODPNQMFUBDPPSEJOBDJØODPO"#*0%
(&&TUBTEPTFOUJEBEFTQFSNJUFOMMFOBS
MBTFYQFDUBUJWBTEFQSPGFTJPOBMFTJOUFSF
TBEPTFOMBSFMBDJØOFOUSFMBCJPNFEJDJ
OBMPTBWBODFTCJPUFDOPMØHJDPTMBDPO
EVDUBIVNBOBZFM%FSFDIP
$PODMVTJPOFT
&MQSJODJQJPEFTBSSPMMPZmOBMCJPMØHJDP
EF MB WJEB IVNBOB FTUÈO JOEJTDVUJCMF
NFOUFDPOEJDJPOBEPTQPSTVDPNQPOFO
UFHFOÏUJDPZÏTUFQPSFMFQJHFOPNB4JO
FNCBSHP MBT UÏDOJDBT EF SFQSPEVDDJØO
IVNBOBBTJTUJEBFMQSPZFDUPHFOPNBZ
FMNJUPEFMTFSIVNBOPJONPSUBMZQFS
GFDUPFTUÈOQFSNJUJFOEPMBNBOJQVMBDJØO
JOEJTDSJNJOBEBEFOVFTUSPNBUFSJBMQSJ
NJHFOJPFTFODJBEFMBIVNBOJEBEDPO
SJFTHPTZDPOTFDVFODJBT&MMPDPOTUJUVZF
VOBUFOUBEPDPOUSBMBJOUFHSJEBEFJOEJ
WJEVBMJEBECJPHFOÏUJDBTBTÓDPNPUBN
CJÏOFMSFHJTUSPZSFWFMBDJØOEFTVFTUSVD
UVSBFTVOBBHSFTJØODPOUSBMBJOUJNJEBE
5PEPFTUPGSFOUFBMPTFGFDUPTQPTJUJWPT
EFM NBOFKP EF FTUBT UFDOPMPHÓBT DPNP
TPOMBUFSBQJBHÏOJDBZFMBDDFTPBMFTUB
CMFDJNJFOUPEFMBJEFOUJEBECJPMØHJDB
&TUPT MPHSPT DJFOUÓmDPT CJPNÏEJDPT Z
CJPUFDOPMØHJDPTZFOCSFWFMBOBOPUFD
OPMPHÓBZMBDVÈOUJDBTFSÈOVOJOOFHB
CMFCFOFmDJPQBSBMBFWPMVDJØOCJPQTJDP
TPDJBMEFMBIVNBOJEBEQFSNJUJÏOEPOPT
USBTDFOEFSMPTMÓNJUFTEFMDPOPDJNJFOUP
QFSPBTJNJTNPTJOPTPODBOBMJ[BEPTZ
BSNPOJ[BEPTEFOUSPEFVONBSDPCJPÏ
UJDPZMFHBMQVFEFOUSBOTGPSNBSTFFOVO
BUFOUBEPDPOUSBMBEJHOJEBEEFMBFTQF
DJFIVNBOB
#JCMJPHSBGÓB
#*04*OJDJPEFMB7JEB)VNBOB‹FE
#*04'VOEBNFOUBDJØOEFMB#JPÏUJDBFOMB/PTUSJEBE
#*04#JPÏUJDBEFM5SBTQMBOUFEF»SHBOPT
#*04 'VOEBNFOUBDJØO EFM %FSFDIP FO MB 'JMPTPGÓB EF MB /PTUSJEBE ‹ FE
‹FE
#*04#JPÏUJDBEFMB*OTVGJDJFODJB3FOBM
#*04%FCBUF#JPÏUJDP$POUFNQPSÈOFP1SPCMFNBTZ)PSJ[POUF
#*04#JPÏUJDB&DPMPHÓBZ"HSPCJPUFDOPMPHÓB
#*040SUPUBOBTJB#JPÏUJDBEFMB.VFSUF/BUVSBM%JHOB‹FE
#*04'JMPTPGÓBEFMB/PTUSJEBE"OUSPQPUFPMPHBM
PERSPETIVADELABIOETICAINDD
-BCJPÏUJDBFO#PMJWJBBOUFDFEFOUFTZQSPZFDDJPOFT+BWJFS-VOB0SPTDP&EVBSEP
#*04.BOJQVMBDJPOFTMJOHàÓTUJDBTFOMB#JPÏUJDB
#*04-FZ.BSDPTPCSF%FSFDIPT4FYVBMFTZ3FQSPEVDUJWPT
$BSUBEF#VFOPT"JSFT
3FWJTUB#PMJWJBOBEF#JPÏUJDB
FOFSPKVOJPQQ
$PNJUÏ/BDJPOBMEF#JPÏUJDBEF#PMJWJB
)BDJBVOB%FDMBSBDJØO6OJWFSTBMEF
#JPÏUJDB4FNJOBSJP3FHJPOBMEFMB6/&4$0#VFOPT"JSFT"SHFOUJOBZEF
OPWJFNCSF3FWJTUB#PMJWJBOBEF#JPÏUJDB
FOFSPKVOJPQQ
(BSSBGB7,PUUPX.4BBEB"$PPSE
&TUBUVUP&QJTUFNPMØHJDPEFMB#JPÏUJ
DB.ÏYJDP6OJWFSTJEBE"VUØOPNBEF.ÏYJDP3FE-BUJOPBNFSJDBOBZEFM$BSJCF
EF#JPÏUJDBEFMB6/&4$0
4JWJMB1F×BSBOEB(
#JPÏUJDBZ%FSFDIP-B1B[&EJU$SFBUJWB
7BSHBT1BDIFDP&
*OWFTUJHBDJØOFO4BMVE"EFDVBEBZ1SPCBEB²UJDBNFOUF
3FWJTUB#PMJWJBOBEF#JPÏUJDB
FOFSPKVOJPQQ
7BSTJ3PTQJHMJPTJ&
%FSFDIP(FOÏUJDPZ1SPDSFÈUJDP-B1B["#*0%(&$PNJ
TJØOEF#JPÏUJDBZ%FSFDIP(FOÏUJDPEFM*MVTUSF$PMFHJPEF"CPHBEPTEF-B1B[
PERSPETIVADELABIOETICAINDD
PERSPETIVADELABIOETICAINDD
6OBSBEJPHSBGÓBEFMBCJPÏUJDBFO#SBTJMWPDFT
QJPOFSBTQSPHSBNBTJOTUJUVDJPOBMFTZFEVDBUJWPTZ
QFSTQFDUJWBT
-FP1FTTJOJZ$ISJTUJBOEF1BVMEF#BSDIJGPOUBJOF
*OUSPEVDDJØO
-
BCJPÏUJDBFO#SBTJMDVFOUBDPOQPDP
NÈT EF RVJODF B×PT EF WJEB BDBEÏ
NJDB Z EF BDUJWJEBEFT JOTUJUVDJPOBMFT
"ERVJFSF VOB QFSTQFDUJWB PSHÈOJDB EF
DBSÈDUFS BDBEÏNJDP EFTEF DPNJFO[PT
EFMBEÏDBEBEF/PIBZNVDIPT
FTUVEJPT IJTUØSJDPDSÓUJDPT BDFSDB EF MB
CJPÏUJDBCSBTJMF×BOJSFTQFDUPEF"NÏ
SJDB-BUJOBEFEJDBEPTBVOBFWBMVBDJØO
EFM QSPDFTP IJTUØSJDP CSBTJMF×P Z MBUJ
OPBNFSJDBOP 4DISBNN (BSSB
GB "OKPT 1FTTJOJ
-BCJPÏUJDBFO#SBTJMTFQVFEFDPOTJEF
SBS VOB FNQSFTB SFDJFOUF Z UBSEÓB MMF
OBEFBOTJFEBEQPSSFnFKBSFOUFOEFSZ
TPMVDJPOBS MPT WJFKPT Z OVFWPT EFTBGÓPT
QSPWPDBEPTQPSMBUFDOPDJFODJBBMBTB
MVEIVNBOBZBMBJOWFTUJHBDJØOCJPNÏ
EJDB"MBQBSUJFOFRVFIBDFSGSFOUFB
MPTiQSPCMFNBTEFTJFNQSFwQSPQJPTEF
VONVOEPNBSDBEPQPSMBEFTJHVBMEBE
TPDJBMZMBFYDMVTJØOZQPSBRVFMMPTJO
FTQFSBEPT RVF QSPWJFOFO EF MB SFWPMV
DJØOCJPUFDOPMØHJDBRVFBGFDUBOUPEBMB
HFOUFZBMBWJEBZTBMVEEFMBTPDJFEBE
-B CJPÏUJDB CSBTJMF×B FT KPWFO QPSRVF
IB FNFSHJEP DBTJ NFEJP TJHMP EFTQVÏT
PERSPETIVADELABIOETICAINDD
EF MB BQSPCBDJØO EFM DÏMFCSF $ØEJHP
EF /VSFNCFSH RVF FTUBCMFDJØ
EJSFDUSJDFT ÏUJDBT QBSB MB JOWFTUJHBDJØO
DPOTFSFTIVNBOPTZEPTEÏDBEBTNÈT
UBSEFEFMTVSHJNJFOUPEFMBCJPÏUJDBFO
&&66BQSJODJQJPTEFMPT
"VORVFBQBSF[DBFOVODPOUFYUPHMPCB
MJ[BEP Z EJOÈNJDP FO FM DVBM MPT QSJO
DJQBMFTQSPCMFNBTFOFMDPOKVOUPBDUVBM
EF DVFTUJPOFT CJPÏUJDBT IBCÓBO TJEP ZB
GPSNVMBEPTQPSFKFNQMPBCPSUPFVUB
OBTJBUSBTQMBOUFTEFØSHBOPT
MBCJPÏUJDB
CSBTJMF×BDPOUSJCVZØQSPQPOJFOEPQSP
CMFNBT FTQFDÓmDPT Z PSJHJOBMFT MJHBEPT
BMBSFBMJEBETPDJPFDPOØNJDBQPMÓUJDBZ
DVMUVSBM EF MPT QBÓTFT EF "NÏSJDB -BUJ
OBZFTQFDJBMNFOUFEFMBCSBTJMF×B1PS
FKFNQMP QSPCMFNBT EF TBMVE QÞCMJDB Z
EFTBGÓPTSFDVSSFOUFTRVFQSPWJFOFOEFTJ
UVBDJPOFTJOKVTUBTZEFFYDMVTJØOTPDJBM
-BCJPÏUJDBCSBTJMF×BFTVOFTGVFS[PUBS
EÓP QPSRVF DVBOEP FNFSHF PDVSSÓB ZB
VODBNCJPEFNPEFMPFOFMNPWJNJFOUP
CJPÏUJDP NVOEJBM 5BM USBOTJDJØO QBSB
EJHNÈUJDB GVF DBSBDUFSJ[BEB QPS PUSB
QBSUFQPSFMUSÈOTJUPEFTEFVOBCJPÏUJDB
NBSDBEBNFOUFJOEJWJEVBMJTUBoDFOUSBEB
FOMPTQSPCMFNBTÏUJDPTSFTVMUBOUFTEFBD
UPTQFSTPOBMFTFTEFDJSFOMPTEFSFDIPT
1FSTQFDUJWBTEFMB#JPÏUJDBFO*CFSPBNÏSJDB
IVNBOPTEFQSJNFSBHFOFSBDJØOoBVOB
CJPÏUJDBQÞCMJDBoEFDBSÈDUFSDPMFDUJWP
NÈTQSFPDVQBEBQPSMBEJNFOTJØOÏUJDB
EF MPT EFTBGÓPT QMBOUFBEPT QPS MB TBMVE
QÞCMJDBCBTBEBFOMPTEFSFDIPTIVNB
OPTEFTFHVOEBHFOFSBDJØOFTEFDJSEF
MPT EFSFDIPT TPDJBMFT &O VO DPOUFYUP
EF DSFDJFOUF DPNQMFKJEBE TF EFTQMJFHB
BCPSEBOEP QSFHVOUBT SFMBDJPOBEBT DPO
MPTEFSFDIPTEFUFSDFSBHFOFSBDJØOoDPO
MBTHFOFSBDJPOFTGVUVSBToZEFDVBSUBHF
OFSBDJØOoRVFBCBSDBOEFTBGÓPTBNCJFO
UBMFTZFDPMØHJDPT
)VCPQSJNFSPVOBEFQFOEFODJBEFVO
NPEFMP ÏUJDP FYUSBOKFSP oFM QBSBEJHNB
EFM QSJODJQJBMJTNP OPSUFBNFSJDBOPo
DBTJ IFHFNØOJDP FO MPT QSJNFSPT B×PTEFIJTUPSJBEFMBCJPÏUJDBNVOEJBM
'VFQPSBTÓEFDJSMPMBiJOGBODJBwEFMB
CJPÏUJDB CSBTJMF×B MB FUBQB EF MPT B×PT
4VSHJØFOUPODFTVONPWJNJFOUPDSÓ
UJDPSFTQFDUPEFNPEFMPTiJNQPSUBEPTw
QBSUJDVMBSNFOUF EFM NPEFMP QSJODJQJB
MJTUB BDFSDB EF MB TBMVE QÞCMJDB &OUSB
NPTBRVÓFOMBiBEPMFTDFODJBwEFMBCJP
ÏUJDBCSBTJMF×B.JFOUSBTMMFHÈCBNPTBMB
GBTFiBEVMUBwDPNFO[BNPTBIBDFSVOB
FWBMVBDJØOQSPGVOEBEPOEFFMQSJODJQBM
SFUP JNQMJDBCB iEJTUJOHVJS TJO TFQBSBS
Z VOJS TJO DPOGVOEJSw QSPCMFNBT CJPÏ
UJDPT EF DBSÈDUFS QFSTPOBM Z QSPCMFNBT
CJPÏUJDPTQÞCMJDPTFTEFDJSEJGFSFODJBS
FOUSF HSBEPT EF JNQPSUBODJB Z BMDBODF
EF BMHVOPT QSPCMFNBT QBSB JOUFHSBSMPT
FO VO EPNJOJP NBSDBEP QPS VOB NB
ZPSDPNQSFOTJØO1PESÓBNPTEFDJSRVF
FM NBSDP EF JOJDJP EF MB GBTF BEVMUB EF
MB CJPÏUJDB CSBTJMF×B FO TV CÞTRVFEB
QPS MB NBEVSF[ GVF FM QBUSPDJOJP EFM
PERSPETIVADELABIOETICAINDD
7* $POHSFTP .VOEJBM EF #JPÏUJDB FO
#SBTJMJB
RVFTFDFOUSØFOFMUFNB
i#JPÏUJDB1PEFSF*OKVTUJDJBi(BSSBGBZ
1FTTJOJ
-PTQSJNFSPTDPOHSFTPTEFCJPÏ
UJDBZTBMVEFO#SBTJM
"OUFT EF MB DPOTPMJEBDJØO EF MB CJPÏUJ
DBFOMBTPDJFEBECSBTJMF×BIBCÓBWBSJBT
JOTUJUVDJPOFT Z HSVQPT EF FTUVEJP RVF
EJBMPHBCBO BDFSDB EF FTUBT DVFTUJPOFT
FOFMNVOEPEFMBTBMVEDPOVOÏOGB
TJT GVFSUF FO MB IVNBOJ[BDJØO &O 4ÍP
1BVMPCBKPMBEJSFDDJØOEFMPTDBNJMJB
OPTVOBPSEFOSFMJHJPTBRVFUSBCBKBFO
TBMVE
ZFOBTPDJBDJØODPOWBSJBTPUSBT
FOUJEBEFT IPTQJUBMBSJBT F JOTUJUVDJPOFT
VOJWFSTJUBSJBTMJHBEBTBFTUFNJTNPÈN
CJUP DPOGFTJPOBMFT P OP DPOGFTJPOBMFT
TFQBUSPDJOØVOBTFSJFEFDVBUSPFWFOUPT
BOVBMFTFOCJPÏUJDBZTBMVEBDPNJFO[PT
ZBNFEJBEPTEFMPTB×PTFOMBDJV
EBEEF4ÍP1BVMP1FTTJOJZ#BSDIJGPO
UBJOF
&M 1SJNFS $POHSFTP EF #JPÏUJDB Z 4B
MVE Z EF KVOJP EF USBUØ
QSJODJQBMNFOUF EF DVFTUJPOFT CJPÏUJ
DBTFNFSHFOUFTTPCSFFMQSJODJQJPEFMB
WJEB FM TFHVOEP BM EF NBS[P EF
NBUFSJBTSFGFSFOUFTBMBNVFSUFZ
BMNPSJSFMUFSDFSPBMEFKVOJPEF
QSPQVTPVOBEJTDVTJØOQSPGVOEB
TPCSFCJPÏUJDBZHFOÏUJDBZFMDVBSUP
BMEFBHPTUPEF
EFCBUJØTPCSF
CJPÏUJDBZHMPCBMJ[BDJØO
0USBÈSFBEFUSBCBKPJNQPSUBOUFEFMPT
DBNJMJBOPT FT MB IVNBOJ[BDJØO Z MB SF
nFYJØO QBTUPSBM FO FM NVOEP EF MB TB
6OBSBEJPHSBGÓBEFMBCJPÏUJDBFO#SBTJM-FP1FTTJOJZ$ISJTUJBOEF1BVMEF#BSDIJGPOUBJOF
MVE&TBDPOTUJUVZFFMUFNBiCJPÏUJDBMBT
SFMJHJPOFTZMBÏUJDBUFPMØHJDBwEPOEFTF
QJFOTBO MBT DVFTUJPOFT ÏUJDBT EF MB WJEB
EFTEF MB QFSTQFDUJWB EF WBMPSFT ÏUJDPT
DSJTUJBOPT +VOUP DPO MB 1BTUPSBM EF MB
4BMVEEFMB$POGFSFODJB/BDJPOBMEFMPT
0CJTQPT #SBTJMF×PT $/##
FM *OTUJ
UVUP$BNJMJBOPEF1BTUPSBMEFMB4BMVE
*$"14
IBPSHBOJ[BEPTVDFTJWBNFOUF
B QBSUJS EF DPOHSFTPT OBDJP
OBMFTEFIVNBOJ[BDJØOZQBTUPSBMEFMB
TBMVE*$"14
&TBJOJDJBUJWBFYJHFMBIVNBOJ[BDJØOFO
MPTDVJEBEPTZTFSWJDJPTNÏEJDPTFOVOB
ÏQPDB EF DSFDJFOUF EFTQFSTPOBMJ[BDJØO
Z UFDOPMPHJ[BDJØO EF ÏTUPT CVTDBOEP
TPMVDJPOFTQBSBMPTQSPCMFNBTRVFIPZ
MMBNBSÓBNPTEFiCJPÏUJDBDMÓOJDBw)BDF
NPTGSFOUFBEJMFNBTÏUJDPTFNFSHFOUFT
DBVTBEPT QPS MB DJFODJB Z MB UFDOPMPHÓB
RVF JOUFSGFSJFSFO DPO MB OBUVSBMF[B IV
NBOB Z RVF EFTFBO DBNCJBSMB SFQSP
EVDDJØOBTJTUJEBUSBTQMBOUFTJOHFOJFSÓB
HFOÏUJDBDMPOBDJØOFOUSFPUSPT
-BSF
nFYJØOTFGVOEBFOVOBQFSTQFDUJWBÏUJDB
EJBMØHJDPUFPMØHJDB SFDFQUJWB B EFCBUJS
DPODJFOUÓmDPTUFØMPHPTmMØTPGPTZQSP
GFTJPOBMFTEFTBMVEFOMBWBOHVBSEJBEFM
QSPDFTP
&TF NPWJNJFOUP EF IVNBOJ[BDJØO Z
QBTUPSBMFOFMNVOEPEFMBTBMVETJHVF
IPZTVDVSTPOPSNBM
-B4PDJFEBE#SBTJMF×BEF#JPÏUJ
DB4##
&OFTUFNPNFOUPRVFQSFDFEFBMTVSHJ
NJFOUPEFVOBPSHBOJ[BDJØORVFSFÞOBZ
PSHBOJDF JOJDJBUJWBT CJPÏUJDBT FYQSFTJWBT
PERSPETIVADELABIOETICAINDD
FO FM QBÓT UFOFNPT MB "TPDJBDJØO #SB
TJMF×B EF ²UJDB .ÏEJDB "#3"%&.
RVFNÈTBMMÈEFMBEJTDVTJØOEFDVFTUJP
OFTÏUJDBTFONFEJDJOBSFnFYJPOBUBN
CJÏOBDFSDBEFDVFTUJPOFTCJPÏUJDBT&O
ÏTUB TF EFCF SFDPOPDFS FM MJEFSB[HP EF
"MGPOTP3FOBUP.FJSB
-B4PDJFEBE#SBTJMF×BEF#JPÏUJDB4##
DPNFO[Ø DPNP VO HSVQP JOGPSNBM
FM EF BHPTUP EF FO #PUVDBUV
41
6OJWFSTJEBEF &TUBEVBM 1BVMJTUB
6/&41
DPOFMMJEFSB[HPEF8JMMJBN
4BBE)PTTOFZGVFFTUBCMFDJEBGPSNBM
NFOUFFMEFGFCSFSPEF$VFOUB
DPONÈTEFNJFNCSPTEFWBSJBEBT
ÈSFBT FO MBT DJFODJBT EF MB WJEB Z EF MB
TBMVEJOWFTUJHBEPSFTEFDJFODJBTIVNB
OBTmMØTPGPTUFØMPHPTFOUSFPUSPTQPS
MPUBOUPUJFOFDBSÈDUFSQMVSBMJTUBZNVM
UJEJTDJQMJOBSJP
-B 4## DPNFO[Ø B QVCMJDBS FO TVQFSJØEJDPDJFOUÓmDPUSJNFTUSBM3FWJT
UB#SBTJMFJSBEF#JPÏUJDB"EFNÈTWBSJBT
TFDDJPOFTSFHJPOBMFTEFMB4##RVFFYJT
UFOMFHBMNFOUFNBOUJFOFOVOBJOUFOTB
BDUJWJEBE FEVDBUJWB Z EF QVCMJDBDJØO
QPSFKFNQMP3ÓP(SBOEFEP4VM1PSUP
"MFHSF
1BSBOÈ -POESJOB
4ÍP 1BVMP
-B4##QBUSPDJOØTFJTDPOHSFTPTOBDJPOBMFTEF
CJPÏUJDBFO#SBTJMJB#JPÏUJDBFOFM4JHMP
7FJOUJVOP
FO1PSUP"MFHSF34
FO #SBTJMJB TJNVMUÈOFBNFOUF DPO FM 7* $PO
HSFTP .VOEJBM EF #JPÏUJDB EFEJDBEP B #JPÏ
UJDB1PEFSF*OKVTUJDJBFO3FDJGF1&
BDFSDBEF#JPÏUJDBZ$JVEBEBOÓBFO'P[
EF*HVB[Þ13
DPOFMUFNBDFOUSBM.FEJP"N
CJFOUFZ7JEB)VNBOB1PSMBNJTNBÏQPDBTF
PSHBOJ[Ø FM 1SJNFS $POHSFTP EF #JPÏUJDB EFM
.FSDPTVSZFMGPSPEF3&%#*046/&4$0
FO4ÍP1BVMP41
RVFBCPSEØBMUFNB
#JPÏUJDBZ$POTUSVDDJØO4PDJBM)PZ
1FSTQFDUJWBTEFMB#JPÏUJDBFO*CFSPBNÏSJDB
41
3ÓP EF +BOFJSP 3ÓP EF +BOFJSP
#SBTJMJB%'
Z1FSOBNCVDP3FDJGF
-B CJPÏUJDB CSBTJMF×B QBSUJDJQB FO VO
EJÈMPHP DPOUJOVP DPO FM NPWJNJFOUP
CJPÏUJDPNVOEJBM"QBSUJSEFNV
DIPT CJPFUJDJTUBT CSBTJMF×PT QBSUJDJQBO
FO MB +VOUB %JSFDUJWB EF MB "TPDJBDJØO
*OUFSOBDJPOBM EF #JPÏUJDB *"#
-B
4##EJBMPHBJOUFOTBNFOUFDPOPUSBBTP
DJBDJØO FVSPQFB EF CJPÏUJDB FTUBCMFDJEB
FO(JKØO&TQB×BoMB4PDJFEBE*OUFSOB
DJPOBMEF#JPÏUJDB4*#*
oRVFCBKPMB
EJSFDDJØOEF.BSDFMP1BMBDJPTIBQBUSP
DJOBEPBMHVOPTDPOHSFTPTJOUFSOBDJPOB
MFTUPEPTFO&TQB×B&O-BUJOPBNÏSJDB
IB FTUBEP QSFTFOUF IBDF NVDIPT B×PT
FO MPT DPOHSFTPT MBUJOPBNFSJDBOPT EF
CJPÏUJDB QSPNPWJEPT QPS MB 'FEFSBDJØO
-BUJOPBNFSJDBOB EF *OTUJUVDJPOFT EF
#JPÏUJDB'&-"*#&
5BNCJÏONBOUJF
OFSFMBDJØODPOMB3FE#JPÏUJDB-BUJOPB
NFSJDBOBZEFM$BSJCFEFMB6/&4$0
FTUBCMFDJEB PmDJBMNFOUF FO $BODÞO
.ÏYJDP FO .ÈT SFDJFOUFNFOUF
BQBSUJSEFM7**$POHSFTP#SBTJMF×PEF
#JPÏUJDBEFBHPTUPBMEFTFQUJFN
CSFEF
JOnVZFEFDJTJWBNFOUFFO
FMFTUBCMFDJNJFOUPEFMB"TPDJBDJØO-BUJ
OP"NFSJDBOBEF#JPÏUJDB"-#"
&O FM EPNJOJP EF MB QSPEVDDJØO DJFO
UÓmDB MB DPNVOJEBE CJPÏUJDB CSBTJMF×B
TF IB PDVQBEP EF UFNBT EJWFSTPT MJHB
EPTBMBWJEBIVNBOB"MHVOPTUSBCBKPT
IBO TJEP USBEVDJEPT BM QPSUVHVÏT DPO
MB QBSUJDJQBDJØO JNQPSUBOUF EF MB DBTB
FEJUPSJBM &EJÎÜFT -PZPMB 1PS FKFNQMP
i'VOEBNFOUPT EF CJPÏUJDBw Z
i'VOEBNFOUPTEF#JPÏUJDB$SJTUÍ0SUP
PERSPETIVADELABIOETICAINDD
EPYBw
EF5SJTUBO&OHFMIBSEU+S
i1SJODJQJPTEF²UJDB#JPNÏEJDBw#FBV
DIBNQZ$IJMESFTT
i*OUSPEVDDJØOBMB
#JPÏUJDBw(VZ%VSBOE
%FMBQSFOTB
EF 6OJWFSTJEBEF EP 4BHSBEP $PSBÎÍP
#BVSV41
TFEFTUBDBMBPCSBEF'SBO
DJTDP #FMMJOP i'VOEBNFOUPT EF CJPÏ
UJDB BTQFDUPT BOUSPQPMØHJDPT NPSBMFT
Z POUPMØHJDPTw &EVTD #BVSV 6OEPDVNFOUPJNQPSUBOUFEF$*0.4
BQSPCBEP FO MBT i1BVUBT ÏUJDBT
JOUFSOBDJPOBMFT QBSB MB JOWFTUJHBDJØO
CJPNÏEJDBDPOTFSFTIVNBOPTwGVFQV
CMJDBEPFO#SBTJMFOVOBDPFEJDJØOQPS
&EJÎÜFT -PZPMB Z $FOUSP 6OJWFSTJUÈSJP
4ÍP$BNJMP1SBEP
*OJDJBUJWBT FTQFDÓmDBT EF JNQPSUBODJB
JOUFSOBDJPOBM TPO MBT SFVOJPOFT FOUSF
JOTUJUVDJPOFT CJPÏUJDBT EF 1PSUVHBM Z
#SBTJM MB QSJNFSB SFBMJ[BEB FO -JTCPB
MB TFHVOEB FO #SBTJMJB FO OPWJFNCSF
EFEVSBOUFFM$POHSFTP.VOEJBM
EF#JPÏUJDBDVZPUFNBQSJODJQBMGVFMB
FEVDBDJØO FO CJPÏUJDB &M UFSDFSP FO MB
JTMB EF "[PSFT FO 1POUB %FMHBEB FO
DPOFMUFNBi6OBPWBSJBTCJPÏ
UJDBTFOMBFWPMVDJØOEFMBTTPDJFEBEFTw
/FWFTZ-JNB
FMDVBSUPFO4ÍP
1BVMPFOTPCSFFMUFNBi#JPÏUJDB
Z7VMOFSBCJMJEBEw
&M USBCBKP JOUFHSBEPS Z EJBMØHJDP EF MB
4##FOFMQBÓTQSPQPSDJPOØDSFEJCJMJEBE
BM#SBTJMBOUFMB"TPDJBDJØO*OUFSOBDJPOBM
EF#JPÏUJDBQBSBFMQBUSPDJOJPFO
EFM 7* $POHSFTP .VOEJBM EF #JPÏUJ
DBFO#SBTJMJB%'1SPQPOJFOEPDPNP
UFNB DFOUSBM MBT SFMBDJPOFT FOUSF i#JP
ÏUJDB 1PEFS Z *OKVTUJDJBw FM DPOHSFTP
6OBSBEJPHSBGÓBEFMBCJPÏUJDBFO#SBTJM-FP1FTTJOJZ$ISJTUJBOEF1BVMEF#BSDIJGPOUBJOF
JOTDSJCJØFOMBBHFOEBEFMBTDVFTUJPOFT
CJPÏUJDBTNVOEJBMFTMPTUFNBTRVFQSP
WJFOFO EF MB FYDMVTJØO QSFTFOUF FO MB
QFSJGFSJB EFM QMBOFUB Z FO MPT MMBNBEPT
QBÓTFTFNFSHFOUFTPFOWÓBTEFEFTBSSPMMP
1FTTJOJ
'FJSBEF4BOUBOBEPOEFUSBCBKBMBSFQV
UBEBHFOFUJTUB&MJBOFEF"[FWFEP
*OJDJBUJWBTFEVDBUJWBTJOTUJUVDJP
OBMFTCSBTJMF×BT
&OFTUBTJOTUJUVDJPOFTTFIBGPSNBEPFM
/ÞDMFP *OUFSJOTUJUVDJPOBM EF #JPÏUJDB
-BTBDUJWJEBEFTTFEFTBSSPMMBOFOMBTÈSFBT
EFBZVEBFEVDBDJØOFJOWFTUJHBDJØO&O
MPRVFDPODJFSOFBFTUBÞMUJNBMB$PNJ
TJØOEF*OWFTUJHBDJØOZ²UJDBFO4BMVE
BTPDJBEB BM (SVQP EF *OWFTUJHBDJØO Z
&TUVEJPT(SBEVBEPTEF)$1"DSFBEP
FOFTSFTQPOTBCMFEFMBFWBMVBDJØO
EFBTQFDUPTÏUJDPT
&O#SBTJMFYJTUFONVDIBTJOJDJBUJWBTEF
EFTBSSPMMPFOCJPÏUJDBEFDBSÈDUFSDPOGF
TJPOBMPTFDVMBSFOJOTUJUVDJPOFTQÞCMJ
DBTPQSJWBEBT"EFNÈTFMUSBCBKPJOEF
QFOEJFOUFEFFYQFSUPTFOEJWFSTPTTJUJPT
EFMQBÓTDPNFO[ØBTFSEFTBSSPMMBEPNÈT
FYQSFTJWBNFOUF FO MB EÏDBEB EF )BZVOBDPOWJWFODJBTBOBZSFTQFUVPTB
DPO MPT WBMPSFT ÏUJDPT DBSBDUFSÓTUJDPT EF
DBEB JOJDJBUJWB Z TF CVTDB VO DPOUFYUP
NBSDBEP QPS FM QMVSBMJTNP oDBEB WF[
NÈTTFDVMBSJ[BEPoMBUPMFSBODJBZFMEJÈ
MPHP*OOVNFSBCMFTJOJDJBUJWBTEFNVFT
USBOMBWJUBMJEBEEFMBCJPÏUJDBUBNCJÏO
OPUPSJB FO MB NPUJWBDJØO EF MPT JOWFT
UJHBEPSFTKØWFOFTZFOMBSFBMJ[BDJØOEF
WBSJBEPT FWFOUPT KPSOBEBT TFNJOBSJPT
Z DPOHSFTPT BEFNÈT EF NVDIBT QVCMJ
DBDJPOFTFTQFDÓmDBTQSJODJQBMNFOUFEFM
DBNQPEFMBTBMVE4VSHFOSBNBTSFHJP
OBMFTEFMB4##DPNPMBEF3FDJGFDPO
EVDJEB QPS .BSJB $MBSB "MCVRVFSRVF
RVFPSHBOJ[ØVODPOHSFTPCSBTJMF×PEF
CJPÏUJDBVOHSVQPRVFFNFSHJØFO#FMP
)PSJ[POUF .(
GPSNBEP QPS (FSBM
EP%SVNPOE%JSDFV(SFDPZ"OUPOJP
.PUBZFO#BIÓBFOMB6OJWFSTJEBEEF
PERSPETIVADELABIOETICAINDD
-B6OJWFSTJEBE'FEFSBMEF3ÓP
(SBOEFEP4VM6'3(4
)PT
QJUBMEF$MÓOJDBTEF1PSUP"MFHSF
)$1"
&M $PNJUÏ EF ²UJDB FO *OWFTUJHBDJØO
$&*
EF6'3(4OBDJØFODPPS
EJOBEP QPS +PTÏ 3PCFSUP (PMEJN -BT
BDUJWJEBEFT EF FOTF×BO[B DPNFO[BSPO
FO DPO VO DVSTP JOUFOTJWP FO
CJPÏUJDB QSPNPWJEP B USBWÏT FM )$1"
FO FM DVBM QBSUJDJQØ FM QSPGFTPS 3PCFSU
7FBUDI EFM ,FOOFEZ *OTUJUVUF PG &UIJDT
"QBSUJSEFFMDVSTP$MÓOJDB.Ï
EJDBEF6'3(4JODMVZFFOTVQMBOEF
FTUVEJPTBTJHOBUVSBTMJHBEBTBMBCJPÏUJ
DB &O FM ÈSFB EF MB CJPÏUJDB DMÓOJDB TF
FTUBCMFDJØVOQSPHSBNBFOCBKPMB
DPPSEJOBDJØOEF$BSMPT'FSOBOEP'SBO
DJTDPOJ&OFM/ÞDMFPEF#JPÏUJDB
QSPNPWJØFM9*DVSTPEFJOUSPEVDDJØOZ
NBOUJFOFVOQPSUBMFO*OUFSOFUDPOTJEF
SBEPVOPEFMPTNFKPSFTFO#SBTJM
1FSTQFDUJWBTEFMB#JPÏUJDBFO*CFSPBNÏSJDB
-B1POUJmDJB6OJWFSTJEBE$BUØ
MJDBEF3ÓP(SBOEFEP4VM16$
34
1PSUP"MFHSF&M/ÞDMFPEF
&TUVEJPT#JPÏUJDPTZFM$PNJUÏEF
²UJDBEFMB*OWFTUJHBDJØO
#BKP MB EJSFDDJØO EF +PBRVÓO $MPUFU
BDUVBM EFDBOP EF MB VOJWFSTJEBE FYJT
UFO FO 16$34 EFTEF BTJHOB
UVSBT CJPÏUJDBT FO QSFHSBEPT EF NFEJ
DJOB&OUSFTVTJOWFTUJHBEPSFTEFCFNPT
NFODJPOBS B %ÏMJP ,JQFS +VTTBSB EF
"[BNCVKBZ.BSJÉOHFMB#BEBMPUJ&TMB
QSJNFSB VOJWFSTJEBE CSBTJMF×B DPO VO
QSPHSBNBBDBEÏNJDPEFFOUSFOBNJFOUP
FO QSPCMFNBTZEJMFNBTCJPÏUJDPTQBSB
QSPGFTJPOBMFT EF MB TBMVE &M OÞDMFP TF
DPOTUJUVZØFMEFKVOJPEFKVOUP
DPO FM $PNJUÏ EF #JPÏUJDB EFM )PTQJ
UBM 4BO -VDBT Z EF MB &TDVFMB .ÏEJDB
EF16$34BEKVOUPBMBTBENJOJTUSB
DJPOFTEFMBTEPTJOTUJUVDJPOFTZIBQV
CMJDBEPWBSJPTUSBCBKPTBMHVOPTFTDSJUPT
ZP DPPSEJOBEPT QPS +PBRVÓO $MPUFU
i#JPÏUJDB VNB BQSPYJNBÎÍPw $MPUFU
i#JPÏUJDB.FJPBNCJFOUFTBÞ
EFQÞCMJDBOPWBTUFDOPMPHÓBTwi%FPO
UPMPHJB NÏEJDB EJSFJUP QTJDPMPHJB F
NBUFSJBM HFOÏUJDP IVNBOPw $MPUFU
Z i#JPÏUJDB VNB WJTÍP QBOPSÉ
NJDBw$MPUFU'FJKØ0MJWFJSB
$MPUFU'FJKØ0MJWFJSB
6OJWFSTJEBEEF4ÍP1BVMP
641
4ÍP1BVMP41
&M*OTUJUVUP»TDBS'SFJSFIBQSPNPWJEP
NVDIBTSFVOJPOFTKPSOBEBTZTFNJOBSJPT
EFCJPÏUJDBFOMBTVOJWFSTJEBEFTQÞCMJDBT
PERSPETIVADELABIOETICAINDD
CSBTJMF×BTUPEPTTPCSFUFNBTDBOEFOUFT
FO#SBTJM&TDPOPDJEPDPNPFTDVFMBEF
MBCJPÏUJDBBVUPOPNJTUBPEFMBSFnFYJØO
BVUØOPNBEFGFOEJEBQPS.BSDP4FHSF
RVJFOFEJUØDPO$MBVEF$PIFOFMMJCSP
i#JPÏUJDBw4FHSFZ$PIFO
.ÈT
SFDJFOUFNFOUF.BSDP4FHSFQVCMJDØi"
RVFTUÍPÏUJDBFBTBÞEFIVNBOBw&OMB
QFSTQFDUJWB EF 4FHSF MB FYQSFTJØO iÏUJ
DBEFMBSFnFYJØOBVUØOPNBwJOEJDBTV
DBSÈDUFSQFSTPOBMZJOEJWJEVBMVOBÏUJDB
FO MB DVBM MPT TVKFUPT QPS NFEJP EF MB
JOUSPTQFDDJØOUSBFOBMBTVQFSmDJFTFO
TBDJPOFTRVFNVDIBTWFDFTFTUÈOFODPO
nJDUPFJOUFOUBOQFOTBSFOTVTQSPQJBT
TPMVDJPOFT QBSB FMMPT TF EFTFB VUJMJ[BS
VOB KFSBSRVÓB EF WBMPSFT EFUFSNJOBEB
QPSMBQFSTPOBDPOUPEBMBMJCFSUBEQP
TJCMF &T VOB ÏUJDB QBUFOUFNFOUF MJCFS
UBSJBFOMBDVBMFMiCJPFUJDJTUBwJOUFOUB
FMFHJS MP RVF DPOTJEFSB EF NBZPS P EF
NFOPS WBMPS FO DBEB TJUVBDJØO ZB TFB
RVFJNQMJRVFBPUSBQFSTPOBBMBDPNV
OJEBEPBMQMBOFUB
&OFM$PMFHJPEF4BMVE1ÞCMJDBFTEFT
UBDBCMF FM USBCBKP EF 1BVMP 'PSUFT RVF
MJEFSBMBSFnFYJØOFOCJPÏUJDBZDVFTUJP
OFT EF TBMVE QÞCMJDB &T DPPSEJOBEPS
BTPDJBEPEFi#JPÏUJDBF4BÞEF1ÞCMJDBw
'PSUFTZ;ØCPMJ
&MNB;ØCPMJZ
$SJTUJOB .B[[BSPMP SFnFYJPOBO BDFSDB
EFMBCJPÏUJDBFOFMDPOUFYUPEFMBQSÈD
UJDB EF FOGFSNFSÓB 0HVJTTP Z ;ØCPMJ
%BMUPO 3BNPT FTQFDVMB TPCSF
CJPÏUJDB FO PEPOUPMPHÓB Z FT UBNCJÏO
NJFNCSPDPSSFTQPOEJFOUFEFMB"DBEF
NJB1POUJmDJBQBSBMB7JEB3PNB
6OBSBEJPHSBGÓBEFMBCJPÏUJDBFO#SBTJM-FP1FTTJOJZ$ISJTUJBOEF1BVMEF#BSDIJGPOUBJOF
6OJWFSTJEBEEF#SBTJMJB6O#
/ÞDMFPEF&TUVEJPT.VMUJEJTDJQMJ
OBSJPT"WBO[BEPT/ÞDMFPEF&T
UVEJPTF*OWFTUJHBDJØOFO#JPÏUJDB
/&1&#
#SBTJMJB%'
"QBSUJSEFTVGVOEBDJØOFOFTUÈ
CBKP MB EJSFDDJØO EF 7PMOFJ (BSSBGB
&O BHPTUP EF FM /&1&# DSFØ TV
QSJNFSDVSTPEFQSFHSBEPMBUPTFOTVFO
CJPÏUJDB1VCMJDØBMHVOPTUSBCBKPTFOUSF
MPT DVBMFT TF FODVFOUSBO i0 NFSDBEP
IVNBOP FTUVEP CJPÏUJDP EB DPNQSB F
WFOEB EF QBSUFT EP DPSQPw #FSMJOHVFS
(BSSBGB
i"#JPÏUJDBOPTÏDV
MP99*w(BSSBGB$PTUB
i#JP
ÏUJDBDPUJEJBOBw#FSMJOHVFS
&OBTPDJBDJØODPOFMQSPHSBNBEFQPT
HSBEPFODJFODJBTEFMBTBMVEEFMB6O#
FTUF OÞDMFP PGSFDF EFTEF VOB
NBFTUSÓBZVOEPDUPSBEPZMJEFSBMB$È
UFESB6/&4$0EF#JPÏUJDB(BSSBGBZ
$PSEØO
(BSSBGBQSPQPOFFMDPODFQUPEFCJPÏUJ
DBEFMBTiTJUVBDJPOFTFNFSHFOUFTwPEF
MPTiQSPCMFNBTFYUSFNPTwPEFGSPOUFSB
&MDPODFQUPiFNFSHFOUFwTFSFmFSFBMBT
TJUVBDJPOFTRVFQSPWJFOFOEFMEFTBSSPMMP
BDFMFSBEPEFMBUFDOPDJFODJBFOMPTB×PT
1PS FKFNQMP USBTQMBOUFT EF ØSHB
OPTZUFKJEPTIVNBOPTFMQSPZFDUPEFM
(FOPNB)VNBOPZUPEPTMPTBTQFDUPT
EF MB HFOØNJDB MBT OVFWBT UFDOPMPHÓBT
SFQSPEVDUJWBT JODMVZFOEP MB DMPOBDJØO
SFQSPEVDUJWB Z UFSBQÏVUJDB MPT BMJNFO
UPTUSBTHÏOJDPTMBTQBUFOUFTMBQSFTFSWB
DJØO TVTUFOUBCMF Z MB CJPEJWFSTJEBE EFM
BNCJFOUFMBJOWFTUJHBDJØODPOBOJNBMFT
IVNBOPTZOPIVNBOPT-BCJPÏUJDBEF
PERSPETIVADELABIOETICAINDD
iTJUVBDJPOFT QFSTJTUFOUFTw FO DBNCJP
QMBOUFB FOGPDBS MPT QSPCMFNBT RVF IJT
UØSJDBNFOUFQFSNBOFDFOBQFTBSEFUPEB
MBFWPMVDJØOEFMBDJFODJBZEFMBTPDJFEBE
EFTEFFMJOJDJPEFMBIJTUPSJBEFMBIVNB
OJEBE&OUSFÏTUPTQPEFNPTNFODJPOBS
MBFYDMVTJØOTPDJBMMBEJTDSJNJOBDJØOFM
SBDJTNPJOFRVJEBEFTEFMUSBCBKPMBWVM
OFSBCJMJEBEMBWJPMFODJBMBEJTUSJCVDJØO
JOKVTUBEFSFDVSTPTFOFMDBNQPEFMBTB
MVEZFMBCPSUPZMBFVUBOBTJB(BSSBGB
,PUUPXZ4BBEB
&M$POTFKP'FEFSBMEF.FEJDJOB
$'.
#SBTJMJB%'
&M QSJNFS QFSJØEJDP CSBTJMF×P EF FTUBT
NBUFSJBT#JPÏUJDBBQBSFDFFODPO
VOBBNQMJBDJSDVMBDJØOFOFMDBNQPEFMB
TBMVEPDVQÈOEPTFQSFQPOEFSBOUFNFOUF
EFDVFTUJPOFTEFMÈSFBEFMBÏUJDBNÏEJ
DB"MHVOBTNPOPHSBGÓBTQVCMJDBEBTTPO
i4*%"Z#JPÏUJDBwi1BDJFOUFT5FSNJOB
MFTwi"CPSUP&VUBOBTJB&SSPSFT.ÏEJ
DPTwi*OWFTUJHBDJØOFOTFSFTIVNBOPTw
i²UJDBEFMBFOTF×BO[BBMPTQSPGFTJPOBMFT
EFTBMVEwi1PMÓUJDB%FNPHSÈmDBwi²UJ
DBEFMBBTJHOBDJØOEFSFDVSTPTFOTBMVEw
i²UJDB Z HFOÏUJDBw i²UJDB Z WJPMFODJBw
FOUSFPUSBT5PEBTMBTFEJDJPOFTFTUÈOEJT
QPOJCMFTFOXXXQPSUBMNFEJDPPSHCS
&OUSF PUSBT QVCMJDBDJPOFT EFM $'.
EFTUBDBNPT EPT USBCBKPT DPMFDUJWPT
i%FTBmPT ²UJDPTw QVCMJDBEP FO DPPSEJOBEPQPS+PTÏ&CFSJFOPT"TTBEF
i*OJDJBÎÍPË#JPÏUJDBw$PTUB(BSSBGBZ
0TFMLB RVF IB UFOJEP VO HSBO
JNQBDUPFOMBÈSFBEFMBTBMVE
1FSTQFDUJWBTEFMB#JPÏUJDBFO*CFSPBNÏSJDB
-B4PDJFEBE#SBTJMF×BEF5FPMP
HÓB.PSBM
&O FTUB TPDJFEBE IBZ BMHVOPT UFØMPHPT
NPSBMFTEFSFQVUBDJØOJOUFSOBDJPOBMFO
ÏUJDB UFPMØHJDB EFEJDBEPT B MB SFnFYJØO
CJPÏUJDB&OUSFPUSPT.ÈSDJP'BCSJEPT
"OKPT "MGPOTJBOVN 4ÍP 1BVMP 41
RVF USBCBKB FO DVFTUJPOFT EF CJPÏUJDB
UFPMØHJDBFOFMNVOEPEFMBFYDMVTJØO
FOVOBQFSTQFDUJWBEFMBUFPMPHÓBEFMBMJ
CFSBDJØO)BQSPEVDJEPNBUFSJBMEFSF
GFSFODJBQBSBUPEPTMPTQBÓTFTEF-BUJOP
BNÏSJDBFOMBDPMFDDJØO5FPMPHÓB.PSBM
FO "NÏSJDB -BUJOB &OUSF PUSPT UFYUPT
i#JPÏUJDB FO DMBWF MJCFSBDJPOJTUBw "O
KPT
"OUPOJP.PTFSEFM*OTUJUVUP
'SBODJTDBOPEF5FPMPHÓBEF1FUSØQPMJT
QVCMJDØi{#JPUFDOPMPHJBFCJPÏUJDB1BSB
POEFWBNPT w.PTFS
-FPOBSE
.BSUJO UFØMPHP JSMBOEÏT SFEFOUPSJTUB
RVFWJWJØNVDIPTB×PTFO#SBTJMZNV
SJØFOQVCMJDØVOUSBCBKPEFSJWB
EPEFTVUFTJTEPDUPSBMFOUFPMPHÓBNPSBM
DPO FM UÓUVMP i" ²UJDB .ÏEJDB F P 1B
DJFOUF5FSNJOBM-FJUVSBÏUJDPUFPMØHJDB
EPTDØEJHPTCSBTJMFJSPTEFÏUJDBNÏEJDBw
.BSUJO 6OB NFODJØO NFSFDF
UBNCJÏO -FPOBSEP #PĊ QJPOFSP EF MB
5FPMPHÓB EF MB -JCFSBDJØO FO "NÏSJDB
-BUJOB JOUFSOBDJPOBMNFOUF SFQVUBEP
6OB QBSUF TJHOJmDBUJWB EF TV FYUFOTB
QSPEVDDJØOBDBEÏNJDBFTVOBSFnFYJØO
BDFSDB EF MB UFPMPHÓB FO TVT SFMBDJPOFT
DPO MB FDPMPHÓB Z FM NFEJPBNCJFOUF
#PĊUBNCJÏOJOUFHSØFMHSVQPJOUFSOB
DJPOBMRVFTVTDSJCJØMBGBNPTB$BSUBEF
MB5JFSSBEPDVNFOUPRVFMB6/&4$0
VUJMJ[B EFTEF FOUPODFT DPO QSPQØTJUPT
FEVDBUJWPT 5SFT USBCBKPT TVZPT EFCFO
PERSPETIVADELABIOETICAINDD
TFS NFODJPOBEPT i(SJUP EPT QPCSFT
HSJUPEB5FSSBw#PĊ
i²UJDBEB
7JEBw#PĊ
Zi²UJDBF.PSBMB
CVTDBEPTGVOEBNFOUPTw#PĊ
$FOUSP6OJWFSTJUBSJP4ÍP$BNJ
MP4ÍP1BVMP41
0SHBOJTNP QJPOFSP FO #SBTJM QBUSP
DJOØ MPT DPOHSFTPT EF CJPÏUJDB Z TBMVE
BOUFEJDIPT FO FM QFSÓPEP RVF QSFDFEF
FM FTUBCMFDJNJFOUP EF MB 4PDJFEBE #SB
TJMF×BEF#JPÏUJDB&M$FOUSPQVCMJDB0
.VOEPEB4BÞEFRVFQSFTFOUBJOJOUF
SSVNQJEBNFOUFBQBSUJSEFUSB
CBKPT DJFOUÓmDPT FTQFDJBMJ[BEPT Z RVF
JOUSPEVKP MBT DVFTUJPOFT CJPÏUJDBT FO
FM QBÓT B mOBMFT EF MPT Z DPNJFO
[PT EF MPT 4F IBO QVCMJDBEP DJODP
FEJDJPOFT NPOPHSÈmDBT B TBCFS i#JPÏUJDBwWOTFQUJFNCSFPD
UVCSF
i#JPÏUJDB VOB QFSTQFDUJ
WB CSBTJMF×Bw W O B KBONBS
i#JPÏUJDBDVJEBSZTBMVEwW
OKVMJPTFQUJFNCSF
i#JPÏUJDB
QSJNFSBT JOTJOVBDJPOFT GVOEBDJPOFT
Z FYQFSJFODJBT FEVDBUJWBT CSBTJMF×BTw
WOKVMTFQU
i#JPÏUJDB
)VNBOJ[BDJØO FO TBMVE WVMOFSBCJMJ
EBEUFDOPDJFODJBZÏUJDBFOMBJOWFTUJ
HBDJØOwWOPDUEFD
1PSPUSB
QBSUFFOFM$FOUSP6OJWFSTJUBSJP
4ÍP$BNJMPQSPEVKPFMQSJNFSNBOVBM
CSBTJMF×P QBSB MPT QSPGFTJPOBMFT EF TB
MVEPSJHJOBMNFOUFUJUVMBEPi#JPÏUJDBF
4BÞEFwZEFTQVÏTi1SPCMFNBTEF#JP
ÏUJDBwRVFFOUVWPTVBFEJDJØO
BDUVBMJ[BEB Z BNQMJBEB 1FTTJOJ Z #BS
$G0.VOEPEB4BÞEFWO
6OBSBEJPHSBGÓBEFMBCJPÏUJDBFO#SBTJM-FP1FTTJOJZ$ISJTUJBOEF1BVMEF#BSDIJGPOUBJOF
DIJGPOUBJOF
5BNCJÏOBDPHJØFM
USBCBKPEF)VCFSU-FQBSHOFVSBVUPSEF
NVDIPT BSUÓDVMPT QVCMJDBEPT FO FM QF
SJØEJDP0.VOEPEB4BÞEFZBMHVOPT
MJCSPT DPNP i#JPÏUJDB OPWP DPODFJUP
B DBNJOIP EP DPOTFOTPw -FQBSHOFVS
Z EFM UFØMPHP .ÈSDJP 'BCSJ EPT
"OKPT#BSDIJGPOUBJOF
-B JOWFTUJHBDJØO TPCSF QSPCMFNBT EF
CJPÏUJDBFOFMmOBMEFMBWJEBHFOFSØMB
QVCMJDBDJØOEFVOBUSJMPHÓBEFUSBCBKPT
EF -FP 1FTTJOJ USBEVDJEB BM FTQB×PM
FO .ÏYJDP QPS &EJDJPOFT %BCBS 4PO
MJCSPT QVCMJDBEPT QPS &EJÎÜFT -PZPMB
i%JTUBOÈTJB BUÏ RVBOEP QSPMPOHBS B
WJEBw 1FTTJOJ i&VUBOBTJB QPS
RVFBCSFWJBSBWJEB w
Zi)VNB
OJ[BÎÍPFDVJEBEPTQBMJBUJWPTwSBFE
&OFMÈNCJUPEFMPTQSPCMFNBT
CJPÏUJDPT EFM QSJODJQJP EF MB WJEB GVF
QVCMJDBEP VO USBCBKP EF $ISJTUJBO EF
1BVMEF#BSDIJGPOUBJOFi#JPÏUJDBFJOÓ
DJPEBWJEBBMHVOTEFTBmPTw0USPTUSB
CBKPTEFFTUFBVUPSTPOi4BÞEF1ÞCMJDB
Ï #JPÏUJDB w #BSDIJGPOUBJOF Z DPO -FP 1FTTJOJ i#JPÏUJDB BMHVOT
EFTBmPTw #BSDIJGPOUBJOF 1FTTJOJ
&OFTUF$FOUSPDSFØQSPQJBNFO
UFMBQSJNFSB.BFTUSÓBFO#JPÏUJDBEFM
#SBTJM4VMÓOFBEFJOWFTUJHBDJØOFTCJP
ÏUJDBFOMBJOWFTUJHBDJØODPOTFSFTWJWPT
3FTQFDUPEFMBTSFMBDJPOFTJOUFSOBDJPOB
MFTFM$FOUSP6OJWFSTJUBSJP4ÍP$BNJMP
FTUÈBTPDJBEPDPOFM$FOUFSGPS$MJOJDBM
#JPFUIJDT EF (FPSHFUPXO 6OJWFSTJUZ Z
DzF ,FOOFEZ *OTUJUVUF EF 8BTIJOHUPO
%$&&66FM1SPHSBNBEF$VJEB
PERSPETIVADELABIOETICAINDD
EPT 1BMJBUJWPT EFM $PMFHJP .ÏEJDP EF
6OJWFSTJUZPG5PSPOUPZDPOFM*OTUJUVUP
EF #JPÏUJDB EF MB 6OJWFSTJEBE $BUØMJDB
1PSUVHVFTB1PSUVHBM
6OJWFSTJEBE6OJTJOPT4ÍP-FP
QPMEP34
&TB VOJWFSTJEBE NBOUJFOF BM *OTUJUV
UP )VNBOJUBT *)6
DVZP PCKFUJWP
QSJODJQBM FT CVTDBS SFTQVFTUBT QBSB MPT
HSBOEFTEFTBGÓPTEFOVFTUSPUJFNQPEFT
EFMBQFSTQFDUJWBEFMIVNBOJTNPTPDJBM
DSJTUJBOPJOUFHSBOEPFOTVFTGVFS[PUSFT
HSBOEFT FKFT RVF CVTDBO MB QSPNPDJØO
EFBDUJWJEBEFTUSBOTEJTDJQMJOBSJBTÏUJDB
USBCBKPZUFPMPHÓBQÞCMJDB
&M *)6 QSFUFOEF DPOUSJCVJS B MB SFBMJ
[BDJØOEFMBNJTJØOEF6OJTJOPTDPNP
VOJWFSTJEBE KFTVJUB EJBDPOÓB EF MB GF
QSPNPDJØOEFMBKVTUJDJBZEJÈMPHPDVM
UVSBMFJOUFSSFMJHJPTP&OUSFPUSBTJOJDJB
UJWBT QVCMJDB *)6 VO TFNBOBSJP FO
MÓOFBDPOQSPWPDBEPSFTUFNBTNPEFSOPT
EFMBDJFODJBFOJOUFSGB[DPOMBÏUJDB
&TBVOJWFSTJEBEQVCMJDØFMQSJNFSUSBCB
KPTPCSFCJPÏUJDBFO#SBTJMMBUSBEVDDJØO
EFDzF.BJO*TTVFTJO#JPFUIJDT-PTUF
NBTQSJODJQBMFTFOCJPÏUJDB
QPS"OESFX
$7BSHBFEJUBEPFOMPTFO&&66
USBEVDJEP QPS (VJEP &EHBSE 8FO[FM
DPO FM UÓUVMP i1SPCMFNBT EF #JPÏUJDBw
7BSHB
0USBTQVCMJDBDJPOFTTPO
i#JPÏUJDB1FSTQFDUJWBTFEFTBmPTw:VO
HFT
Zi#JPÏUJDB)FSNFOÐVUJDBF
DBTVÓTUJDBw:VOHFT
5BNCJÏOUSBEVKPFOVOUSBCBKPTP
CSFÏUJDBZmMPTPGÓBNPSBMNVZSFQVUBEP
1FSTQFDUJWBTEFMB#JPÏUJDBFO*CFSPBNÏSJDB
FO'SBODJBi%JDJPOÈSJPEF²UJDBZ'JMP
TPmB .PSBMw FO EPT WPMÞNFOFT PSHB
OJ[BEPT QPS .POJRVF $POUP4QFSCFS
4QFSCFS0USBUSBEVDDJØOGVFi#JPÏUJDB
TFHVOEPPFOGPRVFEBmMPTPmBEPEJSFD
UPw%}"HPTUJOP
$FOUSPTGFNJOJTUBTEFCJPÏUJDB
"OJT*OTUJUVUPEF#JPÏUJDB%FSFDIPT
)VNBOPTZ(ÏOFSP
"OJT CBKP MB EJSFDDJØO EF %FCPSB %J
OJ[ FT MB QSJNFSB PSHBOJ[BDJØO OP HV
CFSOBNFOUBM MBUJOPBNFSJDBOB EFEJDBEB
B MB JOWFTUJHBDJØO BTJTUFODJB UÏDOJDB Z
FEVDBDJØO FO CJPÏUJDB &TUBCMFDJEB FO
#SBTJMJBEFTBSSPMMBTVTBDUJWJEBEFTEFTEF
" QBSUJS EF FT PmDJBMNFO
UF VO HSVQP SFDPOPDJEP QPS FM $POTF
KP/BDJPOBMEF*OWFTUJHBDJØOEFM#SBTJM
$/1R
&M$FOUSPEF%PDVNFOUBDJØO
ZEF*OGPSNBDJØOEF"OJTFTVODFOUSP
EF SFGFSFODJB EF CJPÏUJDB QBSB MB 0S
HBOJ[BDJØO 1BOBNFSJDBOB EF MB 4BMVE
014
"OJTQSPNVFWFMBJOWFTUJHBDJØOZMBFEV
DBDJØOFOÏUJDBZCJPÏUJDBFOTVSFMBDJØO
DPOMPTEFSFDIPTIVNBOPTFMGFNJOJTNP
ZMBKVTUJDJBFOUSFMPTHÏOFSPT%JGVOEF
MB JOWFTUJHBDJØO Z BDDJPOFT FO CJPÏUJDB
RVFQSPNVFWBOZBTFHVSFOMPTEFSFDIPT
CÈTJDPT EF MBT NVKFSFT BDUVBOEP KVOUP
DPO PSHBOJ[BDJPOFT TPDJBMFT FEVDBUJWBT
ZQPMÓUJDBTRVFDPNQBSUFOFTPTJEFBMFT
5SBCBKB QPS NFEJP EF DVBUSP QSPHSB
NBT i%FGFOTBw DPPSEJOB MBT BDDJPOFT
QPMÓUJDBTEF"OJTTVUSBCBKPDPNPHSVQP
EF QSFTJØO FO FM QBSMBNFOUP CSBTJMF×P
PERSPETIVADELABIOETICAINDD
BTJTUJFOEPZDPPQFSBOEPFOMBEJTDVTJØO
MFHJTMBUJWB TPCSF UFNBT CJPÏUJDPT SFMB
DJPOBEPTDPOMBSFQSPEVDDJØOIVNBOB
i&EVDBDJØOwFTVOBTÓOUFTJTEFMBNJTJØO
JOTUJUVDJPOBMEFQSPNPDJØOEFMBÏUJDB
PGSFDFUSFTUBMMFSFTEFDBMJmDBDJØOFOUP
EPTMPTFTUBEPTCSBTJMF×PT%FGFOTB#JP
ÏUJDB Z )FSSBNJFOUBT i*OGPSNBDJØOw
NBOUJFOFFM$FOUSPEF%PDVNFOUBDJØO
Z EF *OGPSNBDJØO DPPSEJOBEP QPS EP
DVNFOUBMJTUBTFTQFDJBMJ[BEPTZCVTDBEJ
GVOEJSZEFNPDSBUJ[BSMBTJOGPSNBDJPOFT
CJPÏUJDBTFO#SBTJM&MQSPHSBNBEFi*O
WFTUJHBDJØOwFMQSJODJQBMEF"OJTEFTB
SSPMMBMBJOWFTUJHBDJØOUFØSJDBZFUOPHSÈ
mDBZUJFOFFMDPNQSPNJTPEFQSPNPWFS
MBQBSUJDJQBDJØOBDUJWBEFJOWFTUJHBEPSFT
KØWFOFTFOCJPÏUJDBFO#SBTJM
"OJTQBUSPDJOBMBFEJUPSB-FUSBT-JWSFTZ
MB QSPEVDUPSB EF WJEFP JOEFQFOEJFOUF
*NBHFOT-JWSFT -B QSJNFSB FTUJNVMB MB
EJTDVTJØOIVNBOBTPCSFÏUJDBCJPÏUJDB
GFNJOJTNPHÏOFSPEFSFDIPTIVNBOPT
KVTUJDJB Z EFTBSSPMMP TPDJBM *NBHFOT-J
WSFTQSPNVFWFZEFNPDSBUJ[BUFNBTSF
MBDJPOBEPTDPOMPTEFSFDIPTIVNBOPTZ
MBCJPÏUJDB
"MHVOBT QVCMJDBDJPOFT EF -FUSBT-JWSFT
TPOi$POnJUPT.PSBJTF#JPÏUJDBw%J
OJ[
i2VFN1PEF5FS"DFTTPËT
5FDOPMPHJBT 3FQSPEVUJWBT %JGFSFOUFT
1FSTQFDUJWBTEP%JSFJUP#SBTJMFJSPwDP
PSEJOBEBQPS%FCPSB%JOJ[F4BNBOUIB
#VHMJPOF i#JCMJPHSBmB #JPÏUJDB #SB
TJMFJSB w EF ,ÈUJB 4PBSFT
#SBHBi#JCMJPHSBmB&TUVEPT4PCSF7JP
MÐODJB 4FYVBM $POUSB B .VMIFS wEF,ÈUJB4PBSFT#SBHBi²UJDBOB
6OBSBEJPHSBGÓBEFMBCJPÏUJDBFO#SBTJM-FP1FTTJOJZ$ISJTUJBOEF1BVMEF#BSDIJGPOUBJOF
1FTRVJTB FYQFSJÐODJB EF USFJOBNFOUP
FN QBÓTFT TVMBGSJDBOPTw DPPSEJOBEP
QPS %FCPSB %JOJ[ %JSDF (VJMIFN F
6EP 4DIàLMFOL i#JPÏUJDB SFQSPEVÎÍP
FHÐOFSPOBTPDJFEBEFDPOUFNQPSÉOFBw
DPPSEJOBEP QPS .BSJB "OESÏB -PZPMB
i"ENJSÈWFM /PWB (FOÏUJDB CJPÏUJDB
F TPDJFEBEFw %JOJ[ i&OTBJPT
#JPÏUJDBEF4FSHJP$PTUBF%FCPSB%J
OJ[ "OJT&EJUPSB #SBTJMJFOTF
&M TJUJP
XXXBOJTPSHCSEFMBPSHBOJ[BDJØOQSF
TFOUBMBMJTUBDPNQMFUBEFQVCMJDBDJPOFT
3FEEF*OGPSNBDJØOFO#JPÏUJDB
3*#
#JPÏUJDB5FPSÓB'FNJOJTUBZ
"OUJSSBDJTUB#FMP)PSJ[POUF.(
#BKP MB EJSFDDJØO EF 'ÈUJNB 0MJWFJSB
TVPCKFUJWPFTEJGVOEJSZQPQVMBSJ[BSMB
CJPÏUJDBEFTEFMBQFSTQFDUJWBEFMBUFPSÓB
GFNJOJTUB Z BOUJSSBDJTUB &MMB FT BVUPSB
EFi&OHFOIBSJBHFOÏUJDBPTÏUJNPEJB
EB DSJBÎÍPw 0MJWFJSB Z i#JPÏ
UJDB VNB GBDF EB DJEBEBOJBw 0MJWFJSB
3*#FTFMTFHVOEPTJUJPGFNJOJTUB
EFM NVOEP FO CJPÏUJDB FM QSJNFSP FT
'FNJOJTU"QQSPBDIFTUP#JPFUIJDT'"#
,FOOFEZ*OTUJUVUF
ZUBNCJÏOUSBCBKBFO
UFPSÓBBOUJSSBDJTUB
&TDVFMB/BDJPOBMEF4BMVE1Þ
CMJDB&/41'*0$36;3ÓPEF
+BOFJSP3+
&OFTUBJOTUJUVDJØOUSBCBKB'FSNJO3P
MBOE4DISBNNRVFoKVOUPDPO.JHVFM
,PUUPXo QSPQPOF MB MMBNBEB iCJPÏUJDB
QSPUFDUPSBw$VBUSPSBÓDFTBMJNFOUBOTV
EFTBSSPMMP FM DPNQSPNJTP QPMÓUJDP
EFUPEPTMPT&TUBEPT
FMGVOEBNFOUP
ÏUJDP EFMB DPOWJWJBMJEBE MBTMJNJUB
PERSPETIVADELABIOETICAINDD
DJPOFTEFMQBSBEJHNBQSJODJQJBMJTUBOPS
UFBNFSJDBOP Z MB OFDFTJEBE EF VOB
ÏUJDB BEFDVBEB B "NÏSJDB -BUJOB RVF
SFnFKFMBSFBMJEBETPDJPFDPOØNJDBEFMPT
QBÓTFTFOWÓBTEFEFTBSSPMMP
%FTEF MB QFSTQFDUJWB EF 4DISBNN MB
CJPÏUJDB QSPUFDUPSB TF SFMBDJPOB DPO
MBTNFEJEBTRVFTFEFCFOBEPQUBSQBSB
SFTHVBSEBS B JOEJWJEVPT WVMOFSBCMFT Z
BQPCMBDJPOFTIVNBOBTRVFDBSFDFOEF
SFDVSTPT RVF BTFHVSFO MBT DPOEJDJPOFT
NÓOJNBTEFVOBWJEBIVNBOBDPOEJH
OJEBEZOPSFTUSJOHJEBBMBTVQFSWJWFODJB
4DISBNN
-B 'VOEBÎÍP 0TXBMEP $SV[ '*0
$36;
IB IFDIP VOB DPOUSJCVDJØO
JNQPSUBOUF B MB SFnFYJØO CJPÏUJDB FO
JOUFSGB[ DPO MB TBMVE QÞCMJDB "EFNÈT
EF JOWFTUJHBDJPOFT JNQPSUBOUFT TPCSF
FTUBÞMUJNBIBQSPNPWJEPJOUFSFTBOUFT
SFVOJPOFTTPCSFCJPÏUJDBDPOMBQBSUJDJ
QBDJØOEFFYQFSUPTJOUFSOBDJPOBMFT)B
QVCMJDBEP VOB FEJDJØO FTQFDJBM FO JO
HMÏT
EF$BEFSOPTEF4BÞEF1ÞCMJDBEJT
DVUJFOEP DVFTUJPOFT CJPÏUJDBT WPM 4VQMFNFOUP*
%FCFNPTUBNCJÏO
NFODJPOBS MB QVCMJDBDJØO PSHBOJ[BEB
FOQPS'FSNJO3PMBOE4DISBNN
Z.BSMFOF#SB[i#JPÏUJDBF4BÞEFOPT
UFNQPTQBSBNVMIFSFTFDSJBOÎBT w
&MDBQÓUVMPSFHJPOBMEF4##UJFOFWBSJPT
FYQFSUPTFOCJPÏUJDBUBMFTDPNP4FSHJP
3FHP.BSMFOF#SB[.BSJTB1BMÈDJPTZ
0MJOUP1FHPSBSP&TUFÞMUJNPIBQVCMJ
DBEP BMHVOPT USBCBKPT TPCSF ÏUJDB mMP
TØmDB BMHVOPT EF MPT NÈT JNQPSUBOUFT
TPOi²UJDBÏ+VTUJÎBw*OUSPEVÎÍP˲UJDB
DPOUFNQPSÉOFBw Z i²UJDB EPT NBJPSFT
1FSTQFDUJWBTEFMB#JPÏUJDBFO*CFSPBNÏSJDB
NFTUSFT BUSBWÏT EB IJTUØSJBw 1FHPSBSP
/ÞDMFPEF#JPÏUJDBEF-POESJOB
/#-
1BSBOÈ
&M/#-SFÞOFQFSTPOBTEFEJTUJOUBTÈSFBT
JOUFSFTBEBT FO MB SFnFYJØO Z EJTDVTJØO
EFDVFTUJPOFTÏUJDBTSFMBDJPOBEBTDPOMB
WJEB&OTVTJUJP8FCTFQVFEFMFFSi-B
CJPÏUJDBUJFOFVOQBQFMNVZJNQPSUBOUF
FOMBMVDIBQPSMBEFGFOTBEFMBEJHOJEBE
IVNBOBEFMBQFSTPOBZFOMBCBUBMMBQPS
MB KVTUJDJB -B SFnFYJØO Z MB EJTDVTJØO
TPOVOBEFMBTNBOFSBTEFMVDIBS&TUB
FT MB QSPQVFTUB EF /#- DVBOEP SFÞOF
QSPGFTJPOBMFTDPOVOBNFUBDPNÞOTF
SJFEBEBMUSBUBSMPTQSPCMFNBTÏUJDPTRVF
QVFEFOBGFDUBSMBWJEBEJBSJBEFUPEBMB
HFOUF BEFNÈT EF FTUJNVMBS MB QSPEVD
DJØOZEJGVTJØOEFMDPOPDJNJFOUPFOFTF
DBNQPw
&M/#-FTDPPSEJOBEPQPS+PTÏ&EVBSEP
EF 4JRVFJSB &OUSF PUSPT JOWFTUJHBEPSFT
TF FODVFOUSBO -FPOBSEP 1SPUB /JM[B
%JOJ[ Z -PVSFOÎP ;BODBOBSP 0GSFDF
VODVSTPEFQPTHSBEPFOCJØÏUJDBBQBS
UJSEFmOBMFTEFMPTZPSHBOJ[ØBM7*
$POHSFTP#SBTJMF×PEF#JPÏUJDBFO'P[
EFM*HVB[ÞFO&OUSFPUSPTUSBCB
KPT NFODJPOBNPT FM DPPSEJOBEP QPS
+PTÏ &EVBSEP EF 4JRVFJSB i²UJDB DJÐO
DJB F SFTQPOTBCJMJEBEFw 4JRVFJSB FU BM
²TUPTTPOBMHVOPTEFMPTDFOUSPTCSBTJMF
×PTEFCJPÏUJDBDPOTPMJEBEPTFOMPRVF
DPODJFSOF B QVCMJDBDJPOFT B JOWFTUJHB
DJØO Z B FODVFOUSPT EF EJTDVTJØO )BZ
UBNCJÏOJOJDJBUJWBTJOEJWJEVBMFTSFMFWBO
PERSPETIVADELABIOETICAINDD
UFT EF CJPFUJDJTUBT CSBTJMF×PT FO WBSJBT
VOJWFSTJEBEFT RVF DPNJFO[BO B IBDFS
EFFTUBEJTDJQMJOBVODPNQPOFOUFEFMB
GPSNBDJØOIVNBOJTUBFTQFDJBMNFOUFFO
MBTDJFODJBTEFMBWJEBZMBTBMVE
²UJDBEFMBJOWFTUJHBDJØOFOTFSFT
IVNBOPT
6OP EF MPT MPHSPT NÈT JNQPSUBOUFT EF
MB CJPÏUJDB CSBTJMF×B IB TJEP FM FTUBCMF
DJNJFOUPEFVOTJTUFNBQBSBFMDPOUSPM
TPDJBMEFMBJOWFTUJHBDJØOFOTFSFTIVNB
OPT FO #SBTJM %FTEF PDUVCSF EF FMQBÓTUJFOFTVTQSPQJBTQBVUBTÏUJDBTFO
MBJOWFTUJHBDJØOFOTFSFTIVNBOPTGVF
SPO GPSNVMBEPT CBKP UVUFMB CJPÏUJDB Z
IPNPMPHBEBT QPS FM $POTFKP /BDJPOBM
EF 4BMVE $/4
EFM .JOJTUFSJP EF 4B
MVE3FTQFDUPEFFTUFUFNBSFHJTUSBNPT
B(VJMMFSNP4BBE)PTTOFRVJFOFOEJF[
B×PTEFUSBCBKPQVEPFTUBCMFDFSVOQSP
DFTPEFDPOUSPMTPDJBMEFMBJOWFTUJHBDJØO
CSBTJMF×BFOTFSFTIVNBOPTRVFFTVOFT
UÓNVMPZVONPEFMPQBSBNVDIPTQBÓTFT
EFMNVOEP
&TF QSPDFTP NFSFDF VO QBOPSBNB IJT
UØSJDP#SBTJM
&OFM$/4
DSFØ VOB GVFS[B EF USBCBKP NVMUJEJT
DJQMJOBSJB MB DVBM CBTBEB FO EBUPT EF
MPT NJOJTUFSJPT EF 4BMVE EF $JFODJB Z
5FDOPMPHÓB Z EF &EVDBDJØO IB JEFOUJ
mDBEP DFSDB EF QFSTPOBMJEBEFT
F JOTUJUVDJPOFT JODMVZFOEP TPDJFEBEFT
DJFOUÓmDBTZUPEBDMBTFEFDPOTFKPTQSP
GFTJPOBMFT Z BTPDJBDJPOFT EF QFSTPOBT
DPOEFmDJFODJBTRVFGVFSPOJOWJUBEBTB
QBSUJDJQBSFOMBFMBCPSBDJØOEFOPSNBT
%FTQVÏTEFEJF[NFTFTEFBDUJWJEBETF
QSFTFOUØVOBQSPQVFTUBBM$/4RVFGPS
6OBSBEJPHSBGÓBEFMBCJPÏUJDBFO#SBTJM-FP1FTTJOJZ$ISJTUJBOEF1BVMEF#BSDIJGPOUBJOF
NØMBCBTFEFMBSFTPMVDJØO-BT
QBVUBTUJFOFOVODBSÈDUFSFTFODJBMNFOUF
CJPÏUJDPZGVFSPOFMBCPSBEBTFOVOBBD
UJUVEQMVSBMJTUB/PUJFOFOMBDPOmHVSB
DJØOEFDØEJHPDPOBSUÓDVMPTFOMPTRVF
iTF QSPIÓCFw P iTF QFSNJUFw OJ DBSÈD
UFS OPUBSJBM OJ NFSBNFOUF CVSPDSÈUJDP
%FBDVFSEPDPOMBTOPSNBTiOBEBFTB
QSJPSJ QSPIJCJEPw QFSP iOP TF QFSNJUF
DVBMRVJFSB QSÈDUJDBw UPEP EFQFOEF EF
VOBFWBMVBDJØOCJPÏUJDBEFMQSPZFDUPEF
JOWFTUJHBDJØO&MJOWFTUJHBEPSUJFOFSFT
QPOTBCJMJEBEDPNQMFUBFJOUSBOTGFSJCMFZ
EFCFIBDFSRVFTVQSPZFDUPEFJOWFTUJ
HBDJØO TFB BQSPCBEP QPS FM $PNJUÏ EF
²UJDBEF*OWFTUJHBDJØO$&1
EFMBJOT
UJUVDJØOFOMBDVBMFMFTUVEJPTFSÈSFBMJ
[BEP-PT$&1UJFOFOVOBDPNQPTJDJØO
NVMUJEJTDJQMJOBSJBZNÈTEFMBNJUBEEF
TVT NJFNCSPT QVFEFO TFS EF MB NJTNB
QSPGFTJØOEFCFOJODMVJSBHFOUFEFEJ
WFSTPT DBNQPT oCJPNFEJDJOB DJFODJBT
IVNBOBT DJFODJBT FYBDUBTo Z B QPS MP
NFOPT VO SFQSFTFOUBOUF EF MB DMJFOUFMB
EF MB JOTUJUVDJØO 5JFOFO BVUPOPNÓB Z
MJCFSUBEQBSBBDUVBSZQPSMPUBOUPTF
DPOWJFSUFO FO DPSSFTQPOTBCMFT QPS FM
DPNQPOFOUF ÏUJDP EF MB JOWFTUJHBDJØO
DVBOEPBQSVFCBOVOQSPZFDUP
EPDUPSFT FOGFSNFSBT EFOUJTUBT mTJPUF
SBQFVUBT TPDJØMPHPT KVSJTUBT mMØTPGPT
JOHFOJFSPT NBUFNÈUJDPT BOUSPQØMPHPT
Z SFQSFTFOUBOUFT EF MPT TVKFUPT EF JO
WFTUJHBDJØO 'SFJUBT -PCP Z )PTTOF
-BTOPSNBTCJPÏUJDBTTFBQMJDBO
B UPEBT MBT JOWFTUJHBDJPOFT DPO TVKFUPT
IVNBOPT FO DVBMRVJFS DBNQP EFM DP
OPDJNJFOUP DBQB[ EF DBVTBS iEB×PT GÓ
TJDPT QTÓRVJDPT NPSBMFT JOUFMFDUVBMFT
TPDJBMFT DVMUVSBMFT P FTQJSJUVBMFT B MPT
TFSFTIVNBOPTFODVBMRVJFSFUBQBEFMB
JOWFTUJHBDJØO Z FO TVT SFTVMUBEPTw JO
DMVZFOEPMBTDJFODJBTIVNBOBT
-PT $&1 TF EFCFO SFHJTUSBS FO MB $P
NJTJØO /BDJPOBM EF ²UJDB FO *OWFT
UJHBDJØO $0/&1
RVF TF SFMBDJPOB
EJSFDUBNFOUFDPOFM$/4VOBBHFODJB
MFHBMEFDPOUSPMTPDJBM"TÓMB$0/&1
ZMPT$&1GPSNBOVOTJTUFNBJOEFQFO
EJFOUFEFDPOUSPMTPDJBMEFMBÏUJDBFOMB
JOWFTUJHBDJØODPOTFSFTIVNBOPT#SBTJM
UJFOFDPNJUÏTEFÏUJDBDPOBMSFEF
EPSEFQFSTPOBTDPNPNJFNCSPT
6OBFWBMVBDJØOQSPTQFDUJWB
PERSPETIVADELABIOETICAINDD
-B $0/&1 TJFNQSF DPO MB QBSUJDJQB
DJØO NVMUJEJTDJQMJOBSJB EF MB TPDJFEBE
DJWJM Z DJFOUÓmDB FMBCPSØ PUSBT TJFUF
QBVUBT FTQFDÓmDBT EF EJSFDDJØO QBSB
DJFSUBT iÈSFBT UFNÈUJDBTw 5PEPT FTUPT
EPDVNFOUPTFTUÈOEJTQPOJCMFTFOXXX
DPOTFMIPTBVEFHPWCS&OIBCÓBO
TJEP QSFTFOUBEPT BMSFEFEPS EF QSPZFDUPTEFJOWFTUJHBDJØOEFTEFFTUV
EJPT SFUSPTQFDUJWPT IBTUB QSPZFDUPT EF
GBTFT**Z***DPODÏMVMBTUSPODBMFT
JOWP
MVDSBOEP BMSFEFEPS EF QFSTP
OBTIPZEFCJEBNFOUFQSPUFHJEBTQPSFM
TJTUFNB$0/&1$&11FTTJOJ
#SBTJMQPSJODSFÓCMFRVFQBSF[DBBQF
TBSEFUBOUBWJUBMJEBEFOMBEJTDJQMJOBOP
UJFOF $PNJTJØO /BDJPOBM EF #JPÏUJDB
-B4PDJFEBE#SBTJMF×BEF#JPÏUJDBTFIB
FTGPS[BEP QBSB RVF FTP PDVSSB Z CVTDB
FMNPNFOUPQPMÓUJDPNÈTGBWPSBCMFQBSB
FTUBCMFDFSMBZQBSBBTJTUJSBMHPCJFSOPBM
QBSMBNFOUPZBMBTPDJFEBEFOHFOFSBMFO
1FSTQFDUJWBTEFMB#JPÏUJDBFO*CFSPBNÏSJDB
SFMBDJØODPOMBTDVFTUJPOFTNÈTDPNQMF
KBTEFMBCJPÏUJDB
&M EFTBSSPMMP UFØSJDP EF MB CJPÏUJDB FO
#SBTJMFTTJOEVEBVOHSBOEFTBGÓP4P
CSFQBTØ FM MFHBMJTNP UFNQSBOP DPNP
SFGFSFODJBQBSBMBDSFBDJØOEFOPSNBTZ
BDUVBMNFOUFUJFOFVOFTQBDJPFOFMEJÈ
MPHP JOUFSEJTDJQMJOBSJP FO MB CÞTRVFEB
EFMDPOTFOTP1PSQBSUFEFMPTQSPGFTJP
OBMFTEFMEFSFDIPIBZFO#SBTJMVOHSBO
JOUFSÏT SFTQFDUP EF DVFTUJPOFT CJPÏUJDBT
RVF NVDIBT WFDFT SFRVJFSFO MB JOUFS
WFODJØOEFMPTUSJCVOBMFT)BZVOBHSBO
SFDFQUJWJEBEBMPTBOÈMJTJTZBMBTEJTDV
TJPOFTTPDJPBOUSPQPMØHJDBTmMPTØmDBTZ
UFPMØHJDBT)BZVOEJÈMPHPJOUFSEJTDJQMJ
OBSJPFOUSFMBTEJWFSTBTJOJDJBUJWBTZUBN
CJÏOTFSJFEBEDJFOUÓmDB
&MBMDBODFZMPTUFNBTEFMBCJPÏUJDBCSB
TJMF×BOPTIBDFODPODMVJSRVFIBZQPSMP
NFOPTTFJTHSVQPT&MQSJNFSPFTUÈGPS
NBEP QPS FTUVEJPT NFUPEPMØHJDPT RVF
JOUFOUBO FYQMJDBS MB QSPQJB CJPÏUJDB TV
HÏOFTJTJNQPSUBODJBNÏUPEPTZQSJODJ
QJPTZTVTSFMBDJPOFTDPOMBUFDOPDJFODJB
CVTDBOEPVOGVOEBNFOUPmMPTØmDPBO
USPQPMØHJDP&MTFHVOEPFTUÈDPOTUJUVJEP
FO TV NBZPSÓB QPS QSPGFTJPOBMFT EF TB
MVEZIVNBOJTUBTNÏEJDPTFOGFSNFSBT
QTJDØMPHPT UFØMPHPT Z mMØTPGPT FOUSF
PUSPT
TVUBSFBQSJODJQBMFTEJTDVUJSJO
UFSEJTDJQMJOBSJBNFOUFTPCSFÏUJDBQSPGF
TJPOBM ÏUJDB NÏEJDB DVJEBEPT NÏEJDPT
ZIVNBOJ[BDJØOEFTFSWJDJPT5FØMPHPT
FSVEJUPT F JOWFTUJHBEPSFT FO UFPMPHÓB
NPSBM DPOTUJUVZFO VO UFSDFS HSVQP FY
QSFTJWPRVFUSBFMBQFSTQFDUJWBÏUJDBSF
MJHJPTB MB MMBNBEB iCJPÏUJDB UFPMØHJDBw
PERSPETIVADELABIOETICAINDD
DPOVOÏOGBTJTFOMBTSFMJHJPOFTDSJTUJBOBT
ZBGSPCSBTJMF×BTFOFMDBTPEF#SBTJM-B
QSFTFODJBEFMBSFnFYJØOUFPMØHJDBQVFEF
BZVEBS TFHÞO FM UFØMPHP .ÈSDJP 'BCSJ
EPT"OKPTFOFMEFTBSSPMMPEFVOIPSJ
[POUFEFTFOUJEPVOBiNÓTUJDBwQBSBMB
CJPÏUJDB&MMBQVFEFBMJNFOUBSVOBQFST
QFDUJWBTPDJPIVNBOJUBSJBUSBOTGPSNBEP
SBFOMBDVBMTFWFBOUPEBTMBTDSJBUVSBT
DPOBNPSVOBQFSTQFDUJWBRVFTPCSFQB
TFMBEFTJHVBMEBEBUSBWÏTEFMBKVTUJDJBZ
MBTPMJEBSJEBEZBZVEFBQSPNPWFSEJT
DVTJPOFTZQSPQVFTUBTRVFUFOHBODPNP
NFUBVOGVUVSPKVTUPZGFMJ[QBSBUPEPT
6ODVBSUPHSVQPFTMBMMBNBEBiCJPÏUJDB
GFNJOJTUBw GPSNBEP CÈTJDBNFOUF QPS
NVKFSFT RVF EFmFOEFO VOB SFnFYJØO
TFOTJCMFBTVTQSPQJPTDMBNPSFTRVFTP
CSFQBTFBTJNFUSÓBTFJOKVTUJDJBTEFHÏOF
SPZMBTVNJTJØOEFMBNVKFSFOFMDPO
UFYUPTPDJPQPMÓUJDPMBTEJTDSJNJOBDJPOFT
EF SB[B FUD -PT JOWFTUJHBEPSFT EF VOB
iCJPÏUJDB TPDJPQPMÓUJDBw DPOTUJUVZFO BM
RVJOUPHSVQP4POMPTIFSBMEPTEFVOB
iCJPÏUJDBEFMBJOUFSWFODJØOwPiCJPÏUJDB
EVSBwFOMBTQBMBCSBTEF(BSSBGB)BZ
UBNCJÏO MB iCJPÏUJDB QSPUFDUPSBw BOUFT
NFODJPOBEBEFTBSSPMMBEBQPS4DISBNN
Z,PUUPXRVFDPOTJEFSBVOBOÈMJTJTEF
MBTFTUSVDUVSBTTPDJPQPMÓUJDBTRVFQSPEV
DFOBTJNFUSÓBTEFTJHVBMEBEFTZFYDMVTJP
OFT DPO QSPQVFTUBT EF USBOTGPSNBDJØO
FOMBEFGFOTBEFMBHFOUFFYDMVJEBZWVM
OFSBCMF EF MB TPDJFEBE RVF DMBNB QPS
NÈT KVTUJDJB Z FRVJEBE FO FTB NJTNB
MÓOFBTFFODVFOUSBOMBTÏUJDBTBQPSUBEBT
QPS MB 5FPMPHÓB EF MB -JCFSBDJØO B UJF
SSBTCSBTJMF×BT&MFTUVEJPEFMBCJPÏUJDB
UBNCJÏOIBEFTQFSUBEPFMJOUFSÏTEFMPT
QSPGFTJPOBMFTEFMEFSFDIPZNVDIBTQV
6OBSBEJPHSBGÓBEFMBCJPÏUJDBFO#SBTJM-FP1FTTJOJZ$ISJTUJBOEF1BVMEF#BSDIJGPOUBJOF
CMJDBDJPOFTFTUÈOBQBSFDJFOEP-B0SEFO
EF"CPHBEPTEF#SBTJM0"#
IBDSFBEP
DPNJTJPOFT EF iCJPÏUJDB Z EFSFDIPw FO
EJWFSTBTTFDDJPOFTSFHJPOBMFT&TUFFTFM
TFYUPHSVQPFTQFDÓmDPEFEJDBEPBFTUV
EJBSMBTJOUFSSFMBDJPOFTEFMBCJPÏUJDBDPO
FMEFSFDIPMBMFHJTMBDJØOZMBTQPMÓUJDBT
QÞCMJDBT
%FCJEPBUPEBFTBWJUBMJEBEEFMBTTFOTJ
CJMJEBEFTCSBTJMF×BTZEFMBTQFSTQFDUJWBT
CJPÏUJDBTUPEBTDPOTVDBSÈDUFSQSPQJP
FMEFTBGÓPEJBSJPFTMBQSÈDUJDBEFVOEJÈ
MPHPSFTQFUVPTPZUPMFSBOUFVOEJÈMPHP
JOUFSEJTDJQMJOBSJP NVMUJEJTDJQMJOBSJP Z
USBTEJTDJQMJOBSJPRVFFWJUFUPEPTMPTEPH
NBUJTNPTSFEVDDJPOJTUBTZFYDMVTJWJTUBT
&MEFTBGÓPNÈTHSBOEFQBSBMBCJPÏUJDBZ
QBSBMBCSBTJMF×BFOFTQFDJBMFTDPOTUSVJS
DPO IVNJMEBE SFTQFUBS MBT EJGFSFODJBT
ZQSPNPWFSMBVOJEBEFOMBEJWFSTJEBE
4JOPTPUSPTDPOTFHVJNPTHBSBOUJ[BSFTB
QFSTQFDUJWBEFVOJEBEZEFDPMBCPSBDJØO
FOUSFMBTEJWFSTBTQFSTQFDUJWBTMBCJPÏUJ
DB CSBTJMF×B TJO EVEB TF EFTBSSPMMBSÈ Z
FO VO GVUVSP NVZ QSØYJNP TFSÈ iIV
NJMEFNFOUFwPSHVMMPTBEFTÓNJTNB
&O QPDP UJFNQP MB CJPÏUJDB CSBTJMF×B
UVWPÏYJUPFOGPSKBSVOBJEFOUJEBEZDB
SBDUFSÓTUJDBT QSPQJBT FO FM DPOUFYUP EFM
NPWJNJFOUP CJPÏUJDP NVOEJBM UFOJFO
EP BIPSB VO JOOFHBCMF MJEFSB[HP FO FM
DPOUFYUPEFMPTQBÓTFTMBUJOPBNFSJDBOPT
5FOFNPTZBUSBCBKPTEFSFGFSFODJBDSÓUJ
DB FO MB CÞTRVFEB EF VO BDFSDBNJFOUP
CJPÏUJDP PSJHJOBMNFOUF MBUJOPBNFSJ
DBOP DPOTJHOBEP FO FM MJCSP DPMFDUJWP
i#BTFTDPODFJUVBJTEB#JPÏUJDBFOGPRVF
-BUJOPBNFSJDBOPw (BSSBGB ,PUUPX
4BBEB "M CVTDBS TV FTUBUVUP
FQJTUFNPMØHJDP OP TF QPESÈ FOUFOEFS
MB CJPÏUJDB FO OVFTUSP QBÓT TJO PCMJHB
UPSJBNFOUFMFFSZSFnFYJPOBSBDFSDBEFM
DPOUFOJEP EF FTUF USBCBKP %FCFNPT
NFODJPOBS RVF B NFEJBEPT EF MPT MPTQSJNFSPTFTUVEJPTDSÓUJDPTZBIBCÓBO
BQBSFDJEP "OKPT %SBOF 1FTTJOJ(BSSBGB$PTUBZ0TFMLB
)PTTOF
&OTVGBTFBEVMUBBMDBO[BOEPMBNBEV
SF[MBCJPÏUJDBCSBTJMF×BUJFOFVOBPSJHJ
OBMJEBEZVOBJEFOUJEBERVFFTQSFDJTP
SFTDBUBSZWBMPSBSTPCSFQBTBOEPFMDPN
QMFKP IJTUØSJDP EF OP QFOTBS QPS OPTP
USPTNJTNPTZEFJOGFSJPSJEBEEFCJEPB
FODPOUSBSOPTFOUSFMPTQBÓTFTFOWÓBTEF
EFTBSSPMMP#VTDBNPTQSBDUJDBSVOBCJP
ÏUJDBDPOSB[ØOZDPSB[ØOTFOTJCJMJEBE
ZDPNQSPNJTPDPOMPTNÈTWVMOFSBCMFT
EFMBTPDJFEBEVOBCJPÏUJDBRVFSFBMJDF
FMTVF×PEFVONFKPSZNÈTTBOPGVUVSP
GFMJ[QBSBUPEPT
3FGFSFODJBT
"OKPT .' /PUFT PO #JPFUIJDT JO #SB[JM #JPNFEJDBM &UIJDT /FXTMFUUFS PG
&VSPQFBO/FUXPSLGPS#JPNFEJDBM&UIJDT
QQ
"OKPT .' .FEJDBM FUIJDT JO UIF EFWFMPQJOH XPSME B MJCFSBUJPO UIFPMPHZ
QFSTQFDUJWF5IF+PVSOBMPG.FEJDJOFBOE1IJMPTPQIZ
QQ
"OKPT .' #JPFUIJDT JO B MJCFSBUJPOJTU LFZ *O %VCPTF &3 )BNFM 31
0A$POOFMM-+&ET
"NBUUFSPGQSJODJQMFTGFSNFOUJO64CJPFUIJDT7BMMFZ'PSHF
5SJOJUZ1SFTT*OUFSOBUJPOBM
PERSPETIVADELABIOETICAINDD
1FSTQFDUJWBTEFMB#JPÏUJDBFO*CFSPBNÏSJDB
#BSDIJGPOUBJOF$11FTTJOJ-
#JPÏUJDBBQBSUJSEF"NÏSJDB-BUJOB&O-B
WJEBWBMFCJPÏUJDBOVFWPTDBNJOPT-JNB$FOUSPEF&TUVEJPTZ1VCMJDBDJPOFTQQ
#BSDIJGPOUBJOF$11FTTJOJ-
#JPÏUJDBBMHVOTEFTBGJPT4ÍP1BVMP-PZPMB
#BSDIJGPOUBJOF$1
#JPÏUJDBFJOJDJPEBWJEBBMHVOTEFTBGJPT"QBSFDJEB*EFJBT
F-FUSBT
#BSDIJGPOUBJOF$1
1FSTQFDUJWBTEBCJPÏUJDBOB"NÏSJDB-BUJOBFPQJPOFJSJTNP
OP FOTJOP EF CJPÏUJDB OP $FOUSP 6OJWFSTJUÈSJP 4ÍP $BNJMP 41
0 .VOEP EB
4BÞEF
QQ
#FSMJOHVFS((BSSBGB7
0NFSDBEPIVNBOPFTUVEPCJPÏUJDPEBDPNQSBF
WFOEBEFQBSUFTEPDPSQP#SBTÓMJB&EJUPSB6O#
#FSMJOHVFS(
#JPÏUJDBDPUJEJBOB#SBTÓMJB&EJUPSB6O#
#PGG-
(SJUPEPTQPCSFTHSJUPEB5FSSB1FUSØQPMJT7P[FT
#PGG-
²UJDBEB7JEB3JPEF+BOFJSP4FYUBOUF
#PGG-
²UJDBF.PSBMBCVTDBEPTGVOEBNFOUPT1FUSØQPMJT7P[FT
$MPUFU+
#JPÏUJDBVNBBQSPYJNBÎÍP1PSUP"MFHSF&EJQVDST
$MPUFU + 0SH
#JPÏUJDB .FJP BNCJFOUF TBÞEF QÞCMJDB OPWBT UFDOPMPHJBT
%FPOUPMPHJB NÏEJDB EJSFJUP QTJDPMPHJB F NBUFSJBM HFOÏUJDP IVNBOP 1PSUP "MFHSF
&EJQVDST
$MPUFU + 'FJKØ " 0MJWFJSB .( #JPÏUJDB VNB WJTÍP QBOPSÉNJDB 1PSUP
"MFHSF&EJQVDST
$PTUB4*'(BSSBGB70TFMLB(
*OJDJBÎÍPË#JPÏUJDB#SBTÓMJB$POTFMIP
'FEFSBMEF.FEJDJOB
%h"HPTUJOP'
#JPÏUJDBTFHVOEPPFOGPRVFEBGJMPTPGJBEPEJSFJUP4ÍP-FPQPMEP
6OJTJOPT
%JOJ[%
$POGMJUPTNPSBJTF#JPÏUJDB#SBTÓMJB-FUSBT-JWSFT
%JOJ[%
"ENJSÈWFM/PWB(FOÏUJDBCJPÏUJDBFTPDJFEBEF#SBTÓMJB-FUSBT-JWSFT
6O#
%SBOF+'
#JPFUIJDBM1FSTQFDUJWFTGSPNJCFSPBNFSJDB5IF+PVSOBMPG.FEJDJOF
BOE1IJMPTPQIZ
'PSUFT 1 ;PCPMJ & #JPÏUJDB F 4BÞEF 1ÞCMJDB 4ÍP 1BVMP -PZPMB$FOUSP
6OJWFSTJUÈSJP4ÍP$BNJMP
'SFJUBT$#%-PCP.)PTTOF84
0JUPBOPTEFFWPMVÎÍPVNCBMBOÎP
EPTJTUFNB$&1$POFQ$BEFSOPTEFÏUJDBFNQFTRVJTBQQ
(BSSBGB7
"#JPFUIJDBM3BEJPHSBQIPG#SB[JM"DUB#JPFUIJDB
QQ
PERSPETIVADELABIOETICAINDD
6OBSBEJPHSBGÓBEFMBCJPÏUJDBFO#SBTJM-FP1FTTJOJZ$ISJTUJBOEF1BVMEF#BSDIJGPOUBJOF
(BSSBGB7$PTUB40TFMLB(0SHT
"CJPÏUJDBOPTÏDVMP99*#SBTÓMJB
&EJUPSB6O#
(BSSBGB7$PTUB4*
"#JPÏUJDBOPTÏDVMP99*#SBTÓMJB&EJUPSB6O#
(BSSBGB71FTTJOJ-0SHT
#JPÏUJDB1PEFSFJOKVTUJÎB4ÍP1BVMP&EJÎÜFT
-PZPMB&EJUPSBEP$FOUSP6OJWFSTJUÈSJP4ÍP$BNJMP
(BSSBGB 7 ,PUUPX . 4BBEB " 0SHT
#BTFT DPODFJUVBJT EB #JPÏUJDB
&OGPRVF-BUJOPBNFSJDBOP4ÍP1BVMP(BJB
(BSSBGB7$PSEØO+0SHT
1FTRVJTBTFNCJPÏUJDBOP#SBTJMEFIPKF4ÍP1BVMP
&EJUPSB(BJB
)PTTOF84
#JPÏUJDBoQSJODÓQJPTPVSFGFSFODJBJT0.VOEPEB4BÞEF
QQ
*OTUJUVUP $BNJMJBOP EF 1BTUPSBM EB 4BÞEF #PMFUJN *$"14 *OGPSNBUJWP EP *OTUJUVUP
$BNJMJBOPEF1BTUPSBMEB4BÞEF/ÞNFSPTFTQFDÓGJDPTNBJPEFOBOP
9*QNBSÎPEFOPBOP9**QNBJPEFOBOP9***
QKVMIPBHPTUPEFOBOP9***KVMIPEFBOP9*7OQ
-FQBSHOFVS ) #JPÏUJDB OPWP DPODFJUP B DBNJOIP EP DPOTFOTP 4ÍP 1BVMP
-PZPMB
.BSUJO-
"²UJDB.ÏEJDBFP1BDJFOUF5FSNJOBM-FJUVSBÏUJDPUFPMØHJDBEPTDØEJHPT
CSBTJMFJSPTEFÏUJDBNFEJDB"QBSFDJEB4BOUVÈSJP
.PTFS"
#JPUFDOPMPHJBFCJPÏUJDB1BSBPOEFWBNPT 1FUSØQPMJT7P[FT
/BUJPOBM)FBMUI$PVODJM
/BUJPOBM$PNNJTTJPOGPS3FTFBSDI&UIJDTo$POFQ
o#SB[JM3VMFTPOSFTFBSDIJOWPMWJOHIVNBOTVCKFDUT3FT$/4BOEPUIFST
#SBTJMJB.JOJTUÏSJPEB4BÞEF
/FWFT.$1-JNB.0SHT
#JPÏUJDBPVCJPÏUJDBTOBFWPMVÎÍPEBTTPDJFEBEFT
$PJNCSB4ÍP1BVMP&E(SÈGJDBEF$PJNCSB&EJUPSBEP$FOUSP6OJWFSTJUÈSJP
4ÍP$BNJMP
0HVJTTP5;PCPMJ&0SHT
²UJDBF#JPÏUJDB#BSVFSJ&E.BOPMF
0MJWFJSB ' &OHFOIBSJB HFOÏUJDB P TÏUJNP EJB EB DSJBÎÍP 4ÍP 1BVMP &EJUPSB
.PEFSOB‹&E
0MJWFJSB'
#JPÏUJDBVNBGBDFEBDJEBEBOJB4ÍP1BVMP&EJUPSB.PEFSOB
1FHPSBSP0
²UJDBÏ+VTUJÎB1FUSØQPMJT7P[FT
1FHPSBSP0
*OUSPEVÎÍP˲UJDBDPOUFNQPSÉOFB3JPEF+BOFJSP6BQÐ
1FHPSBSP 0 ²UJDB BUSBWÏT EPT NBJPSFT NFTUSFT BUSBWÏT EB IJTUØSJB 1FUSØQPMJT
7P[FT
1FTTJOJ-#BSDIJGPOUBJOF$1
1SPCMFNBTBUVBJTEFCJPÏUJDB‹FEJÎÍPSFWJTUB
FBNQMJBEB4ÍP1BVMP-PZPMB
PERSPETIVADELABIOETICAINDD
1FSTQFDUJWBTEFMB#JPÏUJDBFO*CFSPBNÏSJDB
1FTTJOJ-
#JPFUIJDT1PXFSBOE*OKVTUJDFTPNFQFSTPOBMUIPVHIUTGSPNB-BUJO
"NFSJDBOQFSTQFDUJWF*BC/FXTQQ
1FTTJOJ-
0EFTFOWPMWJNFOUPEBCJPÏUJDBOB"NÏSJDB-BUJOB4BÞEFFN%FCBUF
QQ
1FTTJOJ - 0 EFTFOWPMWJNFOUP EB #JPÏUJDB OB "NÏSJDB -BUJOB "MHVNBT
DPOTJEFSBÎÜFT1BSUF*0.VOEPEB4BÞEF
QQ
1FTTJOJ - 0 EFTFOWPMWJNFOUP EB CJPÏUJDB OB "NÏSJDB -BUJOB "MHVNBT
DPOTJEFSBÎÜFT1BSUF**0.VOEPEB4BÞEF
QQ
1FTTJOJ-
#VJMEJOHB/FX$VMUVSFPG&UIJDTJO3FTFBSDI*OWPMWJOH)VNBOTJO
#SB[JM/PUJ[JFEJ1PMJUÏJBQQ
1SBEP .BVSP . 1BOPSBNB EB CJPÏUJDB OP #SBTJM VN FTUVEP TPCSF B SFGMFYÍP
CJPÏUJDBEFTFOWPMWJEBOPQBÓT#SBTÓMJB%JTTFSUBÎÍPEF.FTUSBEPFN$JÐODJBT
EB4BÞEF#SBTÓMJB6OJWFSTJEBEFEF#SBTÓMJB
4DISBNN'3
"QFTRVJTBCJPÏUJDBOP#SBTJMFOUSFPBOUJHPFPOPWP$BEFSOPT
"EFOBVFS
QQ
4FHSF.$PIFO$0SHT
#JPÏUJDB4ÍP1BVMP&EVTQ
4FHSF.
"RVFTUÍPÏUJDBFBTBÞEFIVNBOB4ÍP1BVMP"UIFOFV
4JRVFJSB+&FUBM
²UJDBDJÐODJBFSFTQPOTBCJMJEBEF4ÍP1BVMP-PZPMB$FOUSP
6OJWFSTJUÈSJP4ÍP$BNJMP
4DISBNN '3 3FHP 4 #SB[ . 1BMÈDJPT . 0SHT
#JPÏUJDB SJTDPT F
QSPUFÎÍP3JPEF+BOFJSP&EJUPSB6'3+&EJUPSB'JPDSV[
7BSHB"$
1SPCMFNBTEF#JPÏUJDB4ÍP-FPQPMEP6OJTJOPT
:VOHFT+3
#JPÏUJDB1FSTQFDUJWBTFEFTBGJPT4ÍP-FPQPMEP6OJTJOPT
:VOHFT+3
#JPÏUJDB)FSNFOÐVUJDBFDBTVÓTUJDB4ÍP1BVMP-PZPMB
PERSPETIVADELABIOETICAINDD
#JPÏUJDBFO$IJMF
.JHVFM,PUUPX
*OUSPEVDDJØO
%
VSBOUF NVDIP UJFNQP MPT CJPFUJ
DJTUBTMBUJOPBNFSJDBOPTIBOEFGFO
EJEPMBJEFBEFRVFMBTQBSUJDVMBSJEBEFT
SFHJPOBMFTSFRVJFSFOVOBNPEBMJEBEEF
ÏUJDBBEBQUBEBBTVTQSPQJBTJEJPTJODSB
TJBT TPDJBMFT Z DVMUVSBMFT Z SFTQFUVPTBT
EFMBEJWFSTJEBEÏUOJDBEFTVQPCMBDJØO
6O OÞNFSP EF DPODPSEBODJBT IJTUØSJ
DBT Z TPDJBMFT QFSNJUFO RVF MB NBZPSÓB
EFMBTOBDJPOFTEFMBSFHJØODPNQBSUBO
VOEJTDVSTPCJPÏUJDPRVFBQFTBSEFWB
SJBDJPOFTMPDBMFTTFBUFTUJNPOJPEFBMHP
RVFTFIBMMBNBEPiGBNJMJBSJEBENPSBMw
8JMEFT %FTDSJCJS MB FTDFOB EF
MBCJPÏUJDBFOVOQBÓTEFCFBZVEBSBFO
UFOEFSZBEFTUBDBSUBOUPMBTWBSJBDJPOFT
DPNPMBTTFNFKBO[BT-BÏUJDBBQMJDBEBFT
FTQFDJBMNFOUFTFOTJCMFBMBTDJSDVOTUBO
DJBTMPDBMFTEFMBTQSÈDUJDBTTPDJBMFTZOP
FTTPSQSFTBRVFFM7*$POHSFTP.VOEJBM
EF#JPÏUJDBMMFWBEPBDBCPFO#SBTJMJBFO
IBZBBDFOUVBEPi#JPÏUJDB1PEFS
Z *OKVTUJDJBw DPNP TV UFNB QSJODJQBM
DPOTJEFSBOEPRVFMBTJOKVTUJDJBTTPDJBMFT
ZEFMPTDVJEBEPTEFTBMVETPOBMUBNFOUF
GSFDVFOUFTQPSUPEB"NÏSJDB-BUJOB
$IJMFIBTJEPÞOJDPFOTVNBSDBEPBJTMB
NJFOUPGÓTJDPTVHFPHSBGÓBQFDVMJBSVOB
PERSPETIVADELABIOETICAINDD
MBSHB FTUBCJMJEBE QPMÓUJDB oJOUFSSVNQJ
EBWJPMFOUBNFOUFFOMPTB×PToZVO
JOUFSÏT QJPOFSP FO MB MFHJTMBDJØO TPDJBM
FODPOUSBTUFDPOTVBDFQUBDJØOFYUSFNB
EBNFOUF WBDJMBOUF EF MFHJTMBDJØO TPCSF
DVFTUJPOFT UBMFT DPNP FM EJWPSDJP MPT
DPOUSBDFQUJWPTZFMBCPSUP1PSPUSBQBS
UFMBOBDJØODPNQBSUFDPOTVTWFDJOPT
SFHJPOBMFT VOB EFQFOEFODJB FDPOØNJ
DB EF QBÓTFT JOEVTUSJBMJ[BEPT VO GVFSUF
DPNQSPNJTPDPOMPTWBMPSFTEFNFSDB
EP DVFTUJPOFT TJO TPMVDJØO SFGFSFOUFT
BNJOPSÓBTÏUOJDBTZVOÓOEJDFEF(JOJ
EFTGBWPSBCMFNBSDBEPQPSDPOnJDUPTTP
DJBMFTFOWÓBTEFJSSVQDJØO
'POEPIJTUØSJDP
"MHVOBTOPUBTIJTUØSJDBTTPCSF$IJMFTJS
WFODPNPJOGPSNBDJØOBODJMBSQBSBJMVT
USBSZFOUFOEFSNFKPSFMQSFTFOUF1PDP
EFTQVÏTEFRVF1FESPEF7BMEJWJBGVO
EBSB MB DJVEBE EF 4BOUJBHP FO FM TJHMP
97*FMQSJNFSIPTQJUBMGVFDPOTUSVJEP
QPSMBTBVUPSJEBEFTFTQB×PMBTZNBOUF
OJEP QPS VOB PSEFO SFMJHJPTB %VSBOUF
NVDIPUJFNQPMBBZVEBNÏEJDBQÞCMJDB
DPOUJOVØ QSFEPNJOBOEP TPCSF MPT TFS
WJDJPT NÏEJDPT QSJWBEPT " MP MBSHP EF
MPTB×PTMPTSFDVSTPTQÞCMJDPTMMFHBSPOB
TFSFTDBTPTZMBDBSJEBEGVFQSFFNJOFOUF
1FSTQFDUJWBTEFMB#JPÏUJDBFO*CFSPBNÏSJDB
EVSBOUF NVDIP UJFNQP FO FM mOBODJB
NJFOUP EF MB HFTUJØO EF JOTUJUVDJPOFT
NÏEJDBT QÞCMJDBT IBTUB FM TJHMP 99
DVBOEPMPTBTVOUPTTBOJUBSJPTZNÏEJDPT
TF DPOWJSUJFSPO FO VOB SFTQPOTBCJMJEBE
MFHBMNFOUF SFDPOPDJEB Z DBEB WF[ NÈT
DPNQSFOTJWB EFM &TUBEP DPO MB DSFB
DJØOEFVOTFSWJDJPNÏEJDPOBDJPOBMFO
-PT FTUVEJPT NÏEJDPT GPSNBMFT TF JOJ
DJBSPO FO MB 6OJWFSTJEBE EF $IJMF FO
DPOGVFSUFJOnVFODJBFVSPQFB-B
ÏUJDBNÏEJDBMBFOTF×BCBOMPTQSPGFTPSFT
EFNFEJDJOBMFHBMCBKPMBFUJRVFUBEFMB
EFPOUPMPHÓBPDVQÈOEPTFQSJODJQBMNFO
UF EFM DØEJHP EF ÏUJDB EF MB QSPGFTJØO
-BTDVFTUJPOFTRVFTFSFmFSFOIPZBCJP
ÏUJDB UBMFT DPNP EFSFDIPT BTPDJBEPT B
MB TBMVE BDDFTP B MB BTJTUFODJB NÏEJDB
EJTDSJNJOBDJØOTPDJBMZNBSHJOBMJ[BDJØO
FSBOEJTDVUJEBTFOFMDBNQPEFMBTBMVE
QÞCMJDBFODPOUJOVJEBEDPOVOBUSBEJ
DJØO RVF TF SFNPOUBCB BM EJTDÓQVMP EF
37JSDIPX.BY8FTUFOIPGFSRVFFO
TF×ØFO$IJMFQPSNVDIPTB×PT&OUSF
TVT BMVNOPT FTUBCB 4BMWBEPS "MMFOEF
NÏEJDPRVFDPNPTFDSFUBSJPEF4BMVE
EFTQVÏTTFOBEPSZQPSmOQSFTJEFOUFEF
$IJMF UVWP VOB JOnVFODJB JNQPSUBOUF
FOQPMÓUJDBTTBOJUBSJBTQÞCMJDBTFOFMQBÓT
8BU[LJO FU BM 1PUUFS "VORVFMBCJPÏUJDBGVFJODPSQPSBEBTØMP
MFOUBNFOUFFOFMQMBOEFFTUVEJPTEFMPT
FTUVEJPT NÏEJDPT HSBEVBEPT QPS NV
DIPTB×PTMBUSBEJDJØOIBTJEPFOTF×BSMP
FTFODJBMEFMBTÏUJDBTNÏEJDBTBTÓDPNP
IBDFSFTGVFS[PTQBSBEFTBSSPMMBSQPMÓUJDBT
TBOJUBSJBTQÞCMJDBTZVODPODFQUPEFKVT
UJDJBTBOJUBSJB
PERSPETIVADELABIOETICAINDD
-PTEJTDJQMJOBEPTNJFNCSPTEFMB"TP
DJBDJØO .ÏEJDB $IJMFOB DPO TV DVPUB
ÏUJDBZFMGSFDVFOUFDPNQSPNJTPDPOFM
TFSWJDJPQÞCMJDPFOIPTQJUBMFTEFM&TUB
EPZEFMBVOJWFSTJEBEGVFSPOEFDJTJWPT
QBSB RVF MPT NÏEJDPT DIJMFOPT NBOUV
WJFTFO TV QSJWJMFHJBEB TJUVBDJØO TPDJBM
RVF B NFOVEP JNQMJDBCB FM QSFTUJHJP
JOUFSOBDJPOBM-BÏUJDBNÏEJDBOPQBSF
DÓB OFDFTJUBS FYUFOTJØO P EFMJCFSBDJØO
UBOUP NÈT QPSRVF MB DVMUVSB DIJMFOB F
JODMVTP MB QSÈDUJDB NÏEJDB IBCÓBO TJEP
TJFNQSF QBUFSOBMJTUBT EF VOB NBOFSB
BVUPSJUBSJB MPT NÏEJDPT FTUBCBO QPS
EFSFDIP QSPGFTJPOBM NPSBMNFOUF FO
MP DPSSFDUP Z TJO EVEB QPEÓBO UPNBS
EFDJTJPOFTFOOPNCSFEFTVTQBDJFOUFT
&M $PMFHJP .ÏEJDP EF $IJMF oMB "TP
DJBDJØO.ÏEJDB$IJMFOBoGVFDSFBEPFO
DPOVONBOEBUPQBSBFMBCPSBSVO
DØEJHPQSPGFTJPOBMEFÏUJDBZTVQFSWJTBS
MBBEFDVBEBQSÈDUJDBNPSBMEFMBNFEJ
DJOB -B DBMJEBE EF NJFNCSP FSB PCMJ
HBUPSJB QBSB UPEPT MPT NÏEJDPT Z DPOT
UJUVÓB VO SFRVJTJUP MFHBM QBSB SFBMJ[BS
UPEBDMBTFEFBDUJWJEBENÏEJDB#BKPFM
SÏHJNFO NJMJUBS EF 1JOPDIFU MB DBMJEBE
EF NJFNCSP EF MB "TPDJBDJØO .ÏEJDB
QBTØ B TFS WPMVOUBSJB Z BVORVF TV DØ
EJHPEFÏUJDBGVFTFBNQMJBEPZBDUVBMJ
[BEPSFHVMBSNFOUFMPTNÏEJDPTQVFEFO
IBTUBIPZFMVEJSGÈDJMNFOUFFMDPOUSPMZ
MBT TBODJPOFT TJFOEP OP NJFNCSPT &T
TVHFTUJWPRVFMB"TPDJBDJØO.ÏEJDBUFO
HBQPSNVDIPTB×PTVO%FQBSUBNFOUP
EF #JP
ÏUJDB FODBSHBEP EF FTUVEJBS MBT
DVFTUJPOFTNPSBMFTDPODFQUVBMFTZQSÈD
UJDBTFMBCPSBSSFTQVFTUBTBMPTQSPCMFNBT
ÏUJDPTEFHSBOSFMFWBODJBBEFNÈTEFSF
TPMWFSMPTDPOnJDUPTNPSBMFTFTQFDÓmDPT
#JPÏUJDBFO$IJMF.JHVFM,PUUPX
OPDVCJFSUPTQPSFM$PNJUÏEF²UJDBEF
MB"TPDJBDJØO
-B BNQMJB NBZPSÓB EF MPT DMÓOJDPT USB
CBKBCBBUJFNQPQBSDJBMZBNFOVEPB
UJFNQP DPNQMFUP FO MPT IPTQJUBMFT QÞ
CMJDPTRVFFSBONFKPSFRVJQBEPTZDPO
UBCBODPONFKPSFTQSPGFTJPOBMFTRVFFM
TFDUPS QSJWBEP QPS MP NFOPT IBTUB MPT
B×PT %VSBOUF MBT EÏDBEBT TJHVJFO
UFT MPT TFSWJDJPT NÏEJDPT QSJWBEPT FO
MB GPSNB EF FKFSDJDJP JOEJWJEVBM EF MB
QSPGFTJØOZFOVOQFRVF×POÞNFSPEF
DMÓOJDBT DPNFO[BSPO B QSPTQFSBS Z B
SFTUBSDBEBWF[NÈTNÏEJDPTEFMTFSWJDJP
EFIPTQJUBMEFNPEPRVFMBNBZPSÓBEF
FMMPT USBCBKB IPZ FYDMVTJWBNFOUF FO FM
TFDUPSQSJWBEPRVFSÈQJEBNFOUFTFBN
QMÓBEPOEFTFDVJEBBOPNÈTRVFVOB
RVJOUBQBSUFEFMBQPCMBDJØOUPUBM"D
UVBMNFOUFMBTJOTUBMBDJPOFTNÏEJDBTQSJ
WBEBTQSFTFOUBOVOOÞNFSPFYDFTJWPEF
NÏEJDPTZFTUÈOEPUBEBTEFJNQPSUBOUFT
SFDVSTPTJOTUSVNFOUBMFTFODPNQBSBDJØO
DPOFMTFDUPSQÞCMJDP-BTVOJWFSTJEBEFT
QSJWBEBT FYDFEFO FO OÞNFSP B MBT QÞ
CMJDBT EF NPEP RVF NÈT NÏEJDPT TF
HSBEÞBOFOFTDVFMBTSFDJÏODSFBEBTRVF
FOMBTUSBEJDJPOBMFTRVFPGSFDFOFOUSF
OBNJFOUPFOIPTQJUBMFTQÞCMJDPTZFTUJ
NVMBOGVFSUFTDPNQSPNJTPTTPDJBMFT
-PT DPODFQUPT EF KVTUJDJB TPO TVCTUBO
DJBMNFOUFFMDFOUSPEFMBTQSFPDVQBDJP
OFTCJPÏUJDBTFTQFDJBMNFOUFFOVOQBÓT
DPNP$IJMFRVFQSFTFOUBHSBOEFTEJTQB
SJEBEFTTPDJBMFTZEFSFOUB4JOFNCBSHP
MB KVTUJDJB EJTUSJCVUJWB TF NBOFKB NÈT
DPNPVOBDVFTUJØOQPMÓUJDBRVFÏUJDB-B
$POTUJUVDJØODIJMFOBQSPDMBNBFMEFSF
PERSPETIVADELABIOETICAINDD
DIP B DVJEBEPT NÏEJDPT P FO VOB WB
SJBDJØOJOUSPEVDJEBEVSBOUFFMSÏHJNFO
NJMJUBSBMBQSPUFDDJØOTBOJUBSJB%FTEF
MPT B×PT TF PSHBOJ[Ø Z mOBODJØ VO
TFSWJDJPOBDJPOBMEFDVJEBEPTNÏEJDPT
DPO BQSPYJNBEBNFOUF FM EFM 1SP
EVDUP*OUFSOP#SVUP1*#
QBSBDVCSJS
OFDFTJEBEFTEFTBMVEQÞCMJDBZBTJTUFODJB
NÏEJDBBMPTQPCSFTMPTEFTFNQMFBEPT
MBNBOPEFPCSBZTVGBNJMJB)BCÓBQPS
TVQVFTUPHSBOEFTDBSFODJBTFJOTVmDJFO
DJBTJODMVTPEFTQVÏTEFMCSFWFQFSÓPEP
EF MB QSFTJEFODJB EF "MMFOEF DVBOEP FM QSFTVQVFTUP GVF BV
NFOUBEPBEFM1*#
6OBDSJTJTJNQPSUBOUFFOFMBDDFTPBMPT
DVJEBEPT NÏEJDPT TF EFTFODBEFOØ MVF
HP EF RVF MB EJDUBEVSB NJMJUBS BDPSUØ
UPEPT MPT TFSWJDJPT TPDJBMFT JODMVZFOEP
MBBZVEBNÏEJDBRVFIBSFDVQFSBEPMFO
UBNFOUF FM ÓNQFUV Z TF IB CFOFmDJBEP
EFMBTSFGPSNBTJOTUJUVJEBTFO-PT
DVJEBEPTNÏEJDPTIBONFKPSBEPQBSBFM
EFMPTDIJMFOPTQSPUFHJEPTQPS
BTJTUFODJBNÏEJDBHSBUVJUBPTVCWFODJP
OBEBQPSJNQVFTUPTQFSPMPTQSPHSBNBT
mOBODJBEPT QPS FM &TUBEP UPEBWÓB TPO
JOGFSJPSFTBMPTTFSWJDJPTNÏEJDPTDVCJFS
UPTQPSTFHVSPTQSJWBEPTEFTBMVE"IPSB
TF FTUBCMFDF mSNFNFOUF VO TJTUFNB EF
DVJEBEPTEFTBMVEEFEPCMFOJWFMFOFM
DVBM VO OÞNFSP EF DMÓOJDBT BMUBNFOUF
TPmTUJDBEBT TF PDVQBO EF MPT BEJOFSB
EPTPGSFDJFOEPBDDFTPBMBTNÈTOVFWBT
UFDOPMPHÓBTZMPTBUSBDUJWPTEFMDVJEBEP
IPTQJUBMBSJPMVKPTP
-BQSÈDUJDBSFBMEFMBNFEJDJOBIBBMDBO
[BEP UBNCJÏO VO GVFSUF QSBHNBUJTNP
1FSTQFDUJWBTEFMB#JPÏUJDBFO*CFSPBNÏSJDB
TJFOEP MB GPSNBDJØO QFSNBOFOUF PGSF
DJEB FO HSBOEF QBSUF DPO FM QBUSPDJOJP
EJTGSB[BEPEFMBJOEVTUSJBGBSNBDÏVUJDB
"MHVOBTEFMBTQSJODJQBMFTDMÓOJDBTQSJWB
EBTTFIBODPOWFSUJEPFOPSHBOJ[BDJPOFT
EFDVJEBEPTEFTBMVEZSFRVJFSFOEFTVT
NÏEJDPT VO USBCBKP FDPOØNJDBNFOUF
FmDJFOUF
&OTVNBMBCJPÏUJDBFNFSHFFOVOQBÓT
RVF QPS NVDIBT EÏDBEBT IBCÓB DPOP
DJEPVOBQSPGFTJØONÏEJDBEFEJDBEBBM
TFSWJDJP QÞCMJDP Z ÏUJDP SFHVMBEB QPS
VOB BTPDJBDJØO NÏEJDB GVFSUF #BKP FM
SÏHJNFONJMJUBSEF1JOPDIFUTFEFCJMJUB
SPO MBT JOTUJUVDJPOFT QÞCMJDBT -PT TFS
WJDJPTTPDJBMFTJODMVZFOEPMBFEVDBDJØO
ZMBNFEJDJOBIBOTJEPDBTJUPUBMNFOUF
QSJWBUJ[BEPTZMBTBTPDJBDJPOFTQSPGFTJP
OBMFTIBOQFSEJEPFMQPEFSEFTVQFSWJTBS
EFVOBNBOFSBSFHVMBSMBDPOEVDUBÏUJDB
EFTVTNJFNCSPT"VORVFFTUPTGBDUPSFT
OP GBWPSFDFO VO SÈQJEP Z GVFSUF DPN
QSPNJTP DPO MB EFMJCFSBDJØO CJPÏUJDB
IBZVODSFDJNJFOUPDPOTUBOUFEFMJOUF
SÏTQPSFMUFNB
-PTDPNJFO[PTEFMBCJPÏUJDB
-PT IJTUPSJBEPSFT UJFOFO SBSBNFOUF MB
PQPSUVOJEBE EF SFHJTUSBS FM OBDJNJFOUP
EF VOB EJTDJQMJOB FTQFDJBMNFOUF TJ OP
FNFSHFFOSFMBDJØODPODBNCJPTDJFOUÓ
mDPT JNQPSUBOUFT &M TVSHJNJFOUP EF MB
CJPÏUJDBGVFMPDBMJ[BEPZTFHVJEPQPSMB
DSFBDJØOJONFEJBUBEFJOTUJUVDJPOFTMBT
RVFSFDMVUBSPOBVOOÞNFSPEFDBQBDJ
UBEPTFSVEJUPTRVFTFDPOWFSUJSÓBOSÈQJ
EBNFOUFFOTVTQBESFTGVOEBEPSFT&TB
FNFSHFODJB GVMHFOUF FO MPT &&66 OP
TFSFQJUJØFOPUSBQBSUFZFO"NÏSJDB-B
PERSPETIVADELABIOETICAINDD
UJOBTFEFCFSFMBUBSVOBIJTUPSJBNVDIP
NFOPTFNPDJPOBOUFQPSRVFMBEJTDJQMJ
OBTFJODPSQPSBEFNBOFSBNVZWBDJMBOUF
ZSFTFSWBEBBMBWJEBTPDJBMZBDBEÏNJDB
$IJMF OP NPTUSØ FO MPT B×PT OJO
HÞO DBTP EF JOTUJUVDJPOBMJ[BDJØO EF MB
CJPÏUJDBDPNPTÓPDVSSJØFO"SHFOUJOB
$PMPNCJB Z #SBTJM -FØO -B
OFDFTJEBE EF VO OVFWP BDFSDBNJFOUP B
MPT EJMFNBT ÏUJDPT QSFTFOUBEPT QPS MBT
QSÈDUJDBT DMÓOJDBT Z EF JOWFTUJHBDJØO FSB
DBTJJOFYJTUFOUFZMPTQSPCMFNBTGVFSPO
EJTDVUJEPTEFVOBNBOFSBRVFIJ[PQPDP
NÈTRVFDPSSPCPSBSMBTPQJOJPOFTUSBEJ
DJPOBMFT&ODPOUSBTUFDPOPUSPTQBÓTFT
MPT mMØTPGPT OP EFNPTUSBSPO OJOHÞO
JOUFSÏT UFNQSBOP QPS MB CJPÏUJDB Z MB
SFnFYJØO UFØSJDB BDFSDB EF DVFTUJPOFT
NÏEJDBTZCJPMØHJDBTFSBSFBMJ[BEBQSJODJ
QBMNFOUFQPSOVFTUSPTNÈTQSPNJOFOUFT
NÏEJDPT IVNBOJTUBT RVF FTUVEJBSPO MB
ÏUJDB mMPTØmDB QBSB PQJOBS BEFDVBEB
NFOUF TPCSF FMMBT 7JBM $PSSFB 3PB3FCPMMFEP
&OTFMMFWØ
BDBCPVOTJNQPTJPTPCSFMBÏUJDBNÏEJDB
CBKPFMMFNBi3FTQFUPZQSPNPDJØOEFMB
QFSTPOBIVNBOBFOMBNFEJDJOBNPEFS
OBw-BQBMBCSBiCJPÏUJDBwGVFJODPSQPSB
EBBMUÓUVMPEFMPT"OBMFTQFSPMBNBZPSÓB
EF MPT DIJMFOPT RVF DPOUSJCVZFSPO TØMP
SBSBNFOUF MB NFODJPOBSPO -BWBEPT
.POHF2VJOUBOBZ4FSBOJ
-BT FTDVFMBT EF NFEJDJOB FOTF×BCBO MB
ÏUJDB NÏEJDB USBEJDJPOBM Z FTDBTBNFOUF
QFSDJCÓBO FM DBNCJP IBDJB MB CJPÏUJDB
-PT QSJNFSPT DFOUSPT EF CJPÏUJDB JO
EJWJEVBMFT P DPNCJOBEPT DPO FTUVEJPT
IVNBOJTUBT TF DSFBSPO FO MBT QSJODJ
QBMFT FTDVFMBT NÏEJDBT &SBO VOJEBEFT
#JPÏUJDBFO$IJMF.JHVFM,PUUPX
BDBEÏNJDBT QFRVF×BT EFEJDBEBT QSJO
DJQBMNFOUF B MB FOTF×BO[B EF DVSTPT
PQDJPOBMFTRVFNÈTBEFMBOUFTFJODMV
ZFSPOFOMPTQMBOFTEFFTUVEJPPmDJBMFT
'JHVFSPB Z 'VFO[BMJEB &TUPT
DFOUSPT IBO BNQMJBEP BDUVBMNFOUF TVT
BDUJWJEBEFT PGSFDJFOEP QSPHSBNBT EF
QPTHSBEPEFNBFTUSÓBFOCJPÏUJDB
&O TF DSFØ VO DFOUSP JOUFSEJTDJ
QMJOBSJP EF CJPÏUJDB FO MB 6OJWFSTJEBE
EF$IJMFCBKPMBTVQFSWJTJØOEFMBSFD
UPSÓB FO FM DVBM GVF DPODFCJEP VOP EF
MPTQSJNFSPTMJCSPTEFCJPÏUJDB,PUUPX
-PT JOUFHSBOUFT EFM DVFSQP BDB
EÏNJDPOPUFOÓBOCBTUBOUFGBNJMJBSJEBE
DPOMBJEFBEFCJPÏUJDBQBSBJOUFSBDUVBS
BDUJWBNFOUFDPOFM$FOUSPRVFEFKØEF
GVODJPOBS EVSBOUF BMHÞO UJFNQP Z GVF
SFTUBCMFDJEPDPNP$FOUSP*OUFSEJTDJQMJ
OBSJPEF&TUVEJPTFO#JPÏUJDBEFEJDBEP
B BDUJWJEBEFT EF JOWFTUJHBDJØO Z B QSP
HSBNBTEFFOUSFOBNJFOUPEFHSBEVBEPT
BQPZBEPQPSGPOEPTJOUFSOBDJPOBMFT
&O TF BMDBO[Ø VO BDVFSEP FOUSF
MB0SHBOJ[BDJØO1BOBNFSJDBOBEFMB4B
MVE0140.4
FMHPCJFSOPDIJMFOPZ
MB 6OJWFSTJEBE EF $IJMF QBSB DSFBS FM
1SPHSBNB3FHJPOBMEF#JPÏUJDB13#
FODBNJOBEP B QSPNPWFS BDUJWJEBEFT
CJPÏUJDBTFO"NÏSJDB-BUJOBZFM$BSJCF
&OUSFTVTNÞMUJQMFTBDUJWJEBEFTFM13#
QVCMJDØMPT$VBEFSOPTEFM1SPHSBNB3F
HJPOBMEF#JPÏUJDBDPOBSUÓDVMPTFTDSJUPT
QPSFTQFDJBMJTUBTSFHJPOBMFTFJOTUJUVZØ
VO DVSTP EF EPT B×PT EF .BFTUSÓB FO
#JPÏUJDB &TF QSPHSBNB JOUFSOBDJPOBM
GVF SFBMJ[BEP QPS EPT QFSÓPEPT DPOTF
DVUJWPTFO4BOUJBHPEF$IJMFZFTPGSF
DJEP BDUVBMNFOUF FO MB 6OJWFSTJEBE
PERSPETIVADELABIOETICAINDD
EF$VZP"SHFOUJOB&M13#TFIBSF
PSHBOJ[BEP DPNP 6OJEBE EF #JPÏUJDB
BTJTUJEBQPSVO$POTFKP$POTVMUJWP*O
UFSOBDJPOBM$POUJOÞBQVCMJDBOEPVOB
SFWJTUB TFNFTUSBM BIPSB MMBNBEB "DUB
#JPFUIJDB Z IB EFTBSSPMMBEP TV QSPQJP
QSPHSBNB BDUJWP Z BMUBNFOUF QSPEVD
UJWP EF JOWFTUJHBDJØO Z FOUSFOBNJFOUP
-PMBT
%VSBOUFMPTB×PTMPTFTQFDJBMJTUBTDIJ
MFOPTDPNFO[BSPOBQVCMJDBSBMQSJODJ
QJPFTQPSÈEJDBNFOUFFOQFSJØEJDPTNÏ
EJDPT FO MBT BOUFEJDIBT QVCMJDBDJPOFT
PmDJBMFTEFMB014ZNÈTSFDJFOUFNFO
UFFOMBT"DUBTEFMBTSFVOJPOFTDFMFCSB
EBTFO$IJMFZPUSPTQBÓTFTMBUJOPBNFSJ
DBOPT6OOÞNFSPQFRVF×PEFBVUPSFT
IBQVCMJDBEPFOSFWJTUBTJOUFSOBDJPOBMFT
ZBMHVOPTTPONJFNCSPTEFMPTDPNJUÏT
FEJUPSJBMFT EF QSFTUJHJPTBT SFWJTUBT DJFO
UÓmDBT FO "SHFOUJOB #SBTJM $PMPNCJB
&&66Z(SBO#SFUB×B
-BWJEBDPSQPSBUJWBEFMBCJPÏUJDBDIJMFOB
FTEÏCJM-B"TPDJBDJØO.ÏEJDB$IJMFOB
IB DSFBEP VO (SVQP EF &TUVEJPT Z VO
%FQBSUBNFOUP EF #JPÏUJDB RVF BDPO
TFKB B MB +VOUB %JSFDUJWB FO DVFTUJPOFT
ÏUJDBT Z CJPÏUJDBT 6O 1SFNJP EF ²UJDB
BOVBM TF PUPSHB BM NFKPS FOTBZP QSF
TFOUBEP P QVCMJDBEP QPS VO NJFNCSP
DPMFHJBEP EF MB QSPGFTJØO NÏEJDB -B
4PDJFEBE$IJMFOBEF#JPÏUJDBGVOEBEB
IBDF EJF[ B×PT IB TPCSFEJNFOTJPOBEP
TVDBOUJEBEEFNJFNCSPTSFDVSSJFOEPB
QPMÓUJDBTEFBENJTJØOEFNBTJBEPMJCFSB
MFT-BTSFVOJPOFTQSPHSBNBEBTJOJDJBM
NFOUF QBSB TFS BOVBMFT IBO MMFHBEP B
TFSNVZJSSFHVMBSFT-BSFDJFOUFNVFSUF
QSFNBUVSBEFTVQSFTJEFOUFFOFKFSDJDJP
1FSTQFDUJWBTEFMB#JPÏUJDBFO*CFSPBNÏSJDB
MBO[BVOBTPNCSBEFJODFSUJEVNCSFTP
CSFFMGVUVSPEFFTUB4PDJFEBE
-B DPOEJDJØO EF NJFNCSP EF BTPDJB
DJPOFT SFHJPOBMFT DPNP MB 'FEFSBDJØO
-BUJOPBNFSJDBOB EF *OTUJUVDJPOFT EF
#JPÏUJDB '&-"*#&
Z FM 'PSP -BUJOP
BNFSJDBOPEF$PNJUÏTEF²UJDBEFMB*O
WFTUJHBDJØOFO4BMVE'-"$&*4
IBTJEP
FTQPSÈEJDBQFSP$IJMFUJFOFSFQSFTFOUB
DJØOFOFM$POTFKP%JSFDUJWPEF3&%
#*06/&4$0 FO MB 3FE EF #JPÏUJDB
QBSB"NÏSJDB-BUJOBZFM$BSJCFZFOFM
$POTFKP EFM $BQÓUVMP -BUJOPBNFSJDBOP
EFMB4PDJFEBE*OUFSOBDJPOBMEF#JPÏUJDB
4*#*
3FHVMBSNFOUF TF JOWJUB B BMHV
OPT QSPGFTJPOBMFT DIJMFOPT B QBSUJDJQBS
FOSFVOJPOFTSFHJPOBMFTZBDUJWJEBEFTEF
FOTF×BO[BBTÓDPNPFOFRVJQPTJOUFSOB
DJPOBMFT EF JOWFTUJHBDJØO QBUSPDJOBEPT
QPSMB6/&4$00.4014/BUJPOBM
*OTUJUVUFT PG )FBMUI /*)
4F IBO QV
CMJDBEP MJCSPT EF ÏUJDB Z CJPÏUJDB 3PB
ÏUJDBDMÓOJDBZCJPÏUJDB-BWBEPTZ
4FSÈO
CJPÏUJDB-PMBT&T
DSÓCBS1ÏSF[Z7JMMBSSPFM,PUUPX
CJPÏUJDB Z BOUSPQPMPHÓB NÏEJDB
-PMBT ,PUUPX Z #VTUPT UFPMPHÓBZCJPÏUJDB.JGTVE
CJPÏ
UJDBZTBMVEQÞCMJDB,PUUPX
CJP
ÏUJDB Z EFSFDIP 6HBSUF ZPUSBT
DVFTUJPOFTFTQFDÓmDBT#FDB
*OTUJUVDJPOFT
&M QSJODJQBM DPNQSPNJTP JOTUJUVDJPOBM
EFMBCJPÏUJDBFTMBDSFBDJØOZFMGVODJP
OBNJFOUPBQSPQJBEPEFDPNJUÏTIPTQJ
UBMBSJPT QBSB MB TVQFSWJTJØO EF BTQFDUPT
ÏUJDPT FO MB BTJTUFODJB NÏEJDB JOTUJUV
PERSPETIVADELABIOETICAINDD
DJPOBM Z MB QSPUFDDJØO EF MPT EFSFDIPT
EF MPT QBDJFOUFT -PT QSJNFSPT DPNJUÏT
FOIPTQJUBMFTDIJMFOPTTVSHFOFO
QFSP TØMP FO TF QVCMJDB VOB QSJ
NFSB OPSNBUJWB PCMJHBOEP B UPEPT MPT
IPTQJUBMFTJNQPSUBOUFTBGPSNBSVODP
NJUÏNÏEJDPEFÏUJDB1VCMJDBEPQPSFM
.JOJTUFSJP EF MB 4BMVE FM EPDVNFOUP
IB TJEP DBTJ DPNQMFUBNFOUF JHOPSBEP
TFGPSNBSPOBMHVOPTDPNJUÏTRVFOVODB
GVODJPOBOPUSPTBMFHBORVFOPFODVFO
USBONJFNCSPTBQSPQJBEPTZEJTQVFTUPT
Z MPT RVF TF DPOTUJUVZFSPO TJHVFO TJO
BDUVBSEFCJEPBMBDBSFODJBEFFYQFSJFO
DJB.BSUÓOF[
"DUVBMNFOUFMPT
IPTQJUBMFT RVF TJSWFO EF FTDVFMBT IBO
GPSNBEPmOBMNFOUFBTVTDPNJUÏTBNF
OVEPDPOGVODJPOFTNF[DMBEBTEFBTJT
UFODJBNÏEJDBFJOWFTUJHBDJØOZCBKPMB
EJGVOEJEBJNQSFTJØOEFRVFEFCFOFTUBS
GPSNBEPTQPSVOBNBZPSÓBEFNÏEJDPT
DPOMBQSFTFODJBBJTMBEBEFBMHÞOQSPGF
TJPOBMEFDVJEBEPTNÏEJDPTZTJQPTJCMF
EFVOBQFSTPOBMBJDBEFMBDPNVOJEBE
-PTDPNJUÏTIPTQJUBMBSJPTIBOTJEPNVZ
DPOTFSWBEPSFTZHFOFSBMNFOUFTØMPTJ
HVFO MB MFZ MBT SFHVMBDJPOFT PmDJBMFT P
MBT SFHMBT EF MB DBTB &M SFTQFUP QPS MB
WJEBTFDPOTJEFSBVOQSFDFQUPTVQSFNP
RVF TF TPCSFQPOF B UPEB EFDJTJØO SFGF
SFOUFBQSPDFEJNJFOUPTEFBDPSUBNJFOUP
EFMBWJEBPSFDIB[PEFUSBUBNJFOUPEF
QBSUFEFMPTQBDJFOUFTJODMVZFOEPBMPT
5FTUJHPT EF +FIPWÈ &O DBTPT FYUSFNB
EBNFOUF FYDFQDJPOBMFT VO DPNJUÏ IB
TJEPGBWPSBCMFBVOBQFUJDJØOEFEFTWÓP
EF MB FTUSJDUB MFUSB EF MB MFZ IPOSBOEP
VOBQFUJDJØOEFQBSUPQSFNBUVSPEFVO
OJ×P BOFODFGÈMJDP P BDFQUBOEP MB EFDJ
#JPÏUJDBFO$IJMF.JHVFM,PUUPX
TJØOJOGPSNBEBEFVOQBDJFOUFRVFSF
DIB[BUSBUBNJFOUPDSÓUJDP
1PS NÈT EF DJODP B×PT IB FTUBEP CBKP
FWBMVBDJØO FO FM 1BSMBNFOUP VOB MFZ
SFGFSJEBBMPTEFSFDIPTEFMPTQBDJFOUFT
Z TF FTUÈ SFGPSNVMBOEP EF UBM NBOFSB
RVF SFRVFSJSÈO PUSPT EPT P USFT B×PT
QBSBRVFTFMMFHVFBVOBDVFSEPEFmOJUJ
WP"VORVFGBWPSBCMFBMCJFOFTUBSEFMB
HFOUF IPTQJUBMJ[BEB FTB MFZ DPOUJOVBSÈ
TPTUFOJFOEP MB OFHBUJWB EF MPT DPNJUÏT
QBSBMJCFSBMJ[BSMBTEFDJTJPOFTEFmOBMEF
WJEB
&MFRVJWBMFOUFDIJMFOPEFMPT*3#*OTUJ
UVDJPOBM3FWJFX#PBSET
TPOMPTDPNJUÏT
EFCJPÏUJDBFOJOWFTUJHBDJØODBEBWF[NÈT
PCMJHBUPSJPT QSJODJQBMNFOUF QPSRVF FM
mOBODJBNJFOUPPmDJBMEFMPTQSPUPDPMPT
DPOTJEFSBSÈTPMBNFOUFMPTQSPZFDUPTRVF
IBZBOTJEPBQSPCBEPTQPSFMDPNJUÏEF
MB JOTUJUVDJØO EF MPT JOWFTUJHBEPSFT -B
DPNQPTJDJØOZMPTBDUPTEFFTUPTDPNJUÏT
TJHVFO TJFOEP BCTPMVUBNFOUF DBTVBMFT
QFSP TF QFSDJCFO FTGVFS[PT FO EJWFSTPT
OJWFMFT QBSB JNQPOFSMFT DFSUJmDBDJØO Z
BVNFOUBS FM OJWFM EF DBQBDJEBE EF TVT
NJFNCSPT,PUUPX
4ØMP
NVZ SFDJFOUFNFOUF MBT JOWFTUJHBDJPOFT
DPOTVKFUPTIVNBOPTZFOBOJNBMFTIBO
SFDJCJEPVOBBUFODJØOÏUJDBEJTUJOUBQPS
MPT DPNJUÏT BE IPD .VDIPT NJFNCSPT
EFDPNJUÏTBÞOTFCBTBOFOMB%FDMBSB
DJØOEF)FMTJOLJZFTUÈOBQFOBTFOUFSB
EPTEFMPTDPOnJDUPTTVSHJEPTBSBÓ[EFMB
WFSTJØONÈTSFDJFOUFEFFTFEPDVNFOUP
ZEFTVTNPEJmDBDJPOFT4FIBBQSPCBEP
NVZSFDJFOUFNFOUFVOBMFZRVFSFRVJFSF
MBSFHVMBDJØOFTUBOEBSEJ[BEBEFMBJOWFT
PERSPETIVADELABIOETICAINDD
UJHBDJØODPOTFSFTIVNBOPTZTFFTUÈEJT
DVUJFOEPFOEJWFSTPTOJWFMFTMBTNBOFSBT
QPTJCMFTEFDSFBSPSFGPS[BSBJOTUJUVDJP
OFTEFÏUJDBEFJOWFTUJHBDJØO
&OTFDSFØMB$PNJTJØO/BDJPOBM
EF *OWFTUJHBDJØO $JFOUÓmDB Z 5FDOP
MØHJDB $0/*$:5
DPO MB NJTJØO EF
TVQFSWJTBS Z mOBODJBS JOWFTUJHBDJPOFT
EF BMUB DBMJEBE $0/*$:5 TVQFSWJTB
BM'POEP/BDJPOBMEF%FTBSSPMMP$JFO
UÓmDP Z 5FDOPMØHJDP '0/%&$:5
EFEJDBEPBMBJOWFTUJHBDJØOCÈTJDBFOMBT
DJFODJBTEFMBWJEB&TJOUFSFTBOUFRVFMB
DPOTJEFSBDJØO ÏUJDB QSJNFSP BQBSFDJFSB
FODVBOEP$0/*$:5iTVHJSJØw
RVF MPT QSPUPDPMPT EF JOWFTUJHBDJØO TF
TPNFUJFSBOBVODPNJUÏJOTUJUVDJPOBMEF
ÏUJDB EF PUSB NBOFSB $0/*$:5 QP
EÓB TPMJDJUBS VOB DPOTVMUB ÏUJDB QSPQJB
&OUSFZMMFHØBTFSDBEBWF[
NÈTPCMJHBUPSJPDPOUBSDPOVOJOGPSNF
EFVO*3#6OB×PNÈTUBSEFTPNFUFS
FMQSPZFDUPBVOJOGPSNFÏUJDPGVFSFDP
NFOEBEPUBNCJÏOQBSBMBJOWFTUJHBDJØO
BOJNBMZDVBUSPB×PTNÈTUBSEFTFDPO
WJSUJØFOPCMJHBUPSJP%FCJØQBTBSIBTUB
QBSBRVFVOBDPQJBEFMEPDVNFO
UPEFDPOTFOUJNJFOUPJOGPSNBEPUVWJFSB
RVFTFSJODMVJEBFOMBQSPQVFTUBEFDPO
DFTJØOEFGPOEPTMPTFTUVEJPTHFOÏUJDPT
SFRVJFSFO OP TPMBNFOUF MB BQSPCBDJØO
TJOP EFUBMMBEPT DPNFOUBSJPT QPS QBSUF
EFVODPNJUÏEFÏUJDB
&TB CSFWF TFDVFODJB EF FWFOUPT TVHJFSF
RVFMBÏUJDBEFJOWFTUJHBDJØOGVFJODPS
QPSBEBNVZSÈQJEBNFOUFBMPTQSPUPDP
MPTEFDPODFTJØOEFSFDVSTPTTJOFNCBS
HP FO $0/*$:5 EFDJEJØ DSFBS
1FSTQFDUJWBTEFMB#JPÏUJDBFO*CFSPBNÏSJDB
TVQSPQJP$PNJUÏ$POTVMUJWPEF#JPÏ
UJDB²TUFDVFOUBDPODVBUSPNJFNCSPT
QFSNBOFOUFTFYQFSUPTFOJOWFTUJHBDJØO
CJPNÏEJDBZFODJFODJBTTPDJBMFTDPOFY
QFSJFODJBFOUSBCBKPEFDPNJUÏTZDPOP
DJNJFOUPEFMBCJPÏUJDBUFØSJDB%FTQVÏT
EFRVFFMDPNJUÏIVCJFSBFYBNJOBEPBM
HVOPTEFMPTQSPUPDPMPTBQSPCBEPTZm
OBODJBEPTFOFMQBTBEPBTÓDPNPTPMJDJ
UVEFTSFDJFOUFTRVFEØFOFWJEFODJBRVF
MBNBZPSÓBEFMPTDPNJUÏTJODMVTPMPTEF
IPTQJUBMFT Z FTDVFMBT VOJWFSTJUBSJBT OP
IBDÓBOVOUSBCBKPDVJEBEPTPFOMBFWB
MVBDJØOEFTVTBTQFDUPTÏUJDPT.VDIPT
EF FMMPT IBCÓBO EBEP VOB BQSPCBDJØO
QSP GPSNB P DPOmSNBEP TVNBSJBNFOUF
MB DPOGPSNJEBE DPO MB %FDMBSBDJØO EF
)FMTJOLJ 4JO FNCBSHP MB NBZPSÓB EF
FTUPT QSPUPDPMPT TVTDJUBCBO PCKFDJPOFT
RVF SFRVJSJFSPO FONJFOEBT DPSSFDDJP
OFT JNQPSUBOUFT P NÈT SBSBNFOUF FM
TJNQMFSFDIB[P
4F QVFEF FTQFSBS RVF $0/*$:5
'0/%&$:5TJFOEPMBJOTUJUVDJØOEF
mOBODJBNJFOUPEFJOWFTUJHBDJØONÈTJN
QPSUBOUFFOFMQBÓTQSPNVFWBQPMÓUJDBT
Z SFHVMBDJPOFT SFGFSFOUFT B MPT DPNJUÏT
EFÏUJDBEFMBJOWFTUJHBDJØOQPOJÏOEP
MPT BM EÓB Z TPNFUJFOEP B DFSUJmDBDJØO
&TPTFTGVFS[PTTFSÈOBQPZBEPTQPSMBMFZ
SFDJFOUFNFOUF BQSPCBEB RVF BVUPSJ[B
BM.JOJTUFSJPEF4BMVEZBMB$PNJTJØO
/BDJPOBM EF #JPÏUJDB oRVF FTUÈ TJFOEP
DSFBEBoBSFHVMBSZTVQFSWJTBSMBJOWFTUJ
HBDJØODPOTVKFUPTIVNBOPT
)VCPNVDIBEJTDVTJØOTPCSFWFOUBKBTZ
EFTWFOUBKBTEFDSFBSVOB$PNJTJØO/B
DJPOBM EF #JPÏUJDB -PT RVF BQSPCBCBO
PERSPETIVADELABIOETICAINDD
TVGPSNBDJØOUPNBCBOB'SBODJBDPNP
FKFNQMP EF VOB DPNJTJØO FmDJFOUF
NJFOUSBTRVFMPTPQPTJUPSFTTF×BMBCBOB
BMHVOBT DPNJTJPOFT JOFmDBDFT EF MB SF
HJØO-BQPTJDJØOGBWPSBCMFBMB$PNJ
TJØO/BDJPOBMIBTBMJEPFWFOUVBMNFOUF
WJDUPSJPTBQFSPNVDIBTEFMBTTVHFSFO
DJBTQSFTFOUBEBTOPGVFSPODPOTJEFSBEBT
ZQPTJCMFNFOUF$IJMFUFOESÈVOB$P
NJTJØOOPUPUBMNFOUFFmDB[
%FMJCFSBDJPOFTCJPÏUJDBTF
JOnVFODJBTDVMUVSBMFT
6OBIJTUPSJBEFMBCJPÏUJDBFTNÈTRVFMB
QSFTFOUBDJØO EF TVT QSPUBHPOJTUBT Z EF
TVT QSPEVDUPT .ÈT GVOEBNFOUBM RVJ
[ÈTFTMBIJTUPSJBEFTVTJEFBTQPSRVFMB
CJPÏUJDBFTVOBÏUJDBBQMJDBEBBQSÈDUJDBT
TPDJBMFTRVFQSFPDVQBOBUPEBMBHFOUFZ
RVFTFFONBSB×BODPOMPTQBUSPOFTDVM
UVSBMFTEFMEJTDVSTPNPSBMQSFWBMFDJFOUF
5SFT GVFS[BT JNQPSUBOUFT IBO JOnVFO
DJBEPFMEFTBSSPMMPEFJEFBTCJPÏUJDBTFO
$IJMF DPNP TVDFEJØ FO NVDIBT PUSBT
OBDJPOFT MBUJOPBNFSJDBOBT &O QSJNFS
MVHBS MBT CBTFT EF MB CJPÏUJDB BOHMP
TBKPOB FO QBSUJDVMBS FM QSJODJQJBMJTNP
GVFSPOBCTPSCJEBTDPNPMBFTDVFMBNÈT
DPIFSFOUF EF QFOTBNJFOUP EJTQPOJCMF
&OTFHVOEPUÏSNJOPMB*HMFTJB$BUØMJDB
EFTBSSPMMØ VO JOUFSÏT UFNQSBOP FO MPT
QSPCMFNBT CJPNÏEJDPT FTQFDJBMNFO
UF MPT ÓOUJNBNFOUF SFMBDJPOBEPT DPO
MBEPDUSJOB'JOBMNFOUFMBTGVFS[BTEFM
NFSDBEP IBO BDUVBEP DPO VO JNQBDUP
JNQPSUBOUFTPCSFMBTQSÈDUJDBTZWBMPSFT
CJPNÏEJDPT
"VORVF FM QSJODJQJBMJTNP GVF TBMVEBEP
DPNP TJTUFNB OPSNBUJWP USBOTQBSFOUF
#JPÏUJDBFO$IJMF.JHVFM,PUUPX
Z EF GÈDJM BDFQUBDJØO QSPOUP TF MMFHØ B
QFSDJCJSRVFMBJEFBEFDVBUSPQSJODJQJPT
FRVJWBMFOUFT OP TF BDFQUBCB GÈDJMNFOUF
FOVOBDVMUVSBEPOEFFMDPMPOJBMJTNPZ
MBTEJTUJODJPOFTEFDMBTFIBCÓBOTJEPQBS
UFJNQPSUBOUFEFMBIJTUPSJBZFODJFSUP
HSBEPFTUÈOIPZBDUJWBNFOUFQSFTFOUFT
1PSDPOTJHVJFOUFMBBVUPOPNÓBOPTFQP
EÓBBDFQUBSDPNPVOBDVBMJEBEVOJWFSTBM
QVFTMPTOPFEVDBEPTMPTFOGFSNPTMPT
KØWFOFTZBÞOFOHSBEPNÈTHSBOEFMB
QPCMBDJØO GFNFOJOB FSBO DPOTJEFSBEPT
MJNJUBEPT FO TV DBQBDJEBE NFOUBM -B
CFOFmDFODJB UBNCJÏO GVF DPSSPNQJEB
QPSVOBMBSHBUSBEJDJØOEFIFHFNPOÓBEF
DMBTFZEFDBUFHPSÓBQSPGFTJPOBMZMBBTJH
OBDJØOZFWBMVBDJØOEFWFOUBKBTUPEBWÓB
GVODJPOB CBKP FM MFNB iFM EPDUPS TBCF
NÈTw &O GPSNB QBSBMFMB MB OPNBMFm
DFODJBFSBNVZBNFOVEPSFDIB[BEBQPS
FMNÏEJDPZTFTJMFODJBCBOMPTSJFTHPTQP
TJCMFTEFGPSNÈOEPTFBTÓMBTJOGPSNBDJP
OFTEBEBTBMPTQBDJFOUFTPBMPTTVKFUPT
EFJOWFTUJHBDJØO5PEPTFTUPTQSPHSFTPT
PDVSSFO JO BCTFOUJB EF VOB EJTDVTJØO F
JMVTUSBOMBJOFmDBDJBEFMBCJPÏUJDBQBSB
QSPWPDBSVOBEFMJCFSBDJØOQÞCMJDBBDFSDB
EFBMHVOBTEFMBTDVFTUJPOFTTPDJBMNFOUF
NÈTSFMFWBOUFTDPNPFMBCPSUPMBDPO
USBDFQDJØO oJODMVZFOEP MB iQÓMEPSB EFM
EÓBEFTQVÏTwoMBFTUFSJMJ[BDJØOWPMVOUB
SJBMBFVUBOBTJBZQPSTVQVFTUPMBKVTUJ
DJBFOMPTDVJEBEPTNÏEJDPT5PEBTFTUBT
DVFTUJPOFTZBMHVOBTMFZFTZBFOWJHFODJB
oUSBTQMBOUF EF ØSHBOPT Z NVFSUF DFSF
CSBMoOPIBOTJEPTPNFUJEBTBEJTDVTJØO
QÞCMJDB &M DPOTFKP Z FM DPOPDJNJFOUP
BDBEÏNJDP FTQFDJBMJ[BEP TPO SBSBNFOUF
CVTDBEPTPSFTQFUBEPTZOPIBZFWJEFO
DJB EF RVF MPT MFHJTMBEPSFT TF FTGVFSDFO
PERSPETIVADELABIOETICAINDD
QPS BERVJSJS BMHVOB DMBTF EF FEVDBDJØO
CJPÏUJDB BOUFT EF EFDJEJS FO DVFTUJPOFT
EFJOUFSÏTOBDJPOBM
%FTEFRVFMPTNJTJPOFSPTDBUØMJDPTQBS
UJDJQBSBO FO MB DPORVJTUB EF "NÏSJDB
-BUJOBZFNQSFOEJFSBOWPMVOUBSJBNFO
UF UBSFBT DJWJMFT DPNP MB FEVDBDJØO FM
DVJEBEP IPTQJUBMBSJP Z MB HFSFODJB EF
DFNFOUFSJPT MB *HMFTJB $BUØMJDB IB HP
[BEP EF VOB QPTJDJØO EF QSFFNJOFODJB
FOBTVOUPTQPMÓUJDPTZDVMUVSBMFT)BTUB
IPZ BENJOJTUSB VO OÞNFSP TVTUBODJBM
EF MBT FTDVFMBT Z EF MBT VOJWFSTJEBEFT
NÈT JNQPSUBOUFT EFM QBÓT "MHVOPT EF
MPTQBSUJEPTQPMÓUJDPTQSJODJQBMFTDPOGÓBO
BCJFSUBNFOUF FO MB EPDUSJOB SFMJHJPTB Z
BQPZBOWJTJPOFTDPOTFSWBEPSBT$VBOEP
TVSHJØMBCJPÏUJDBMB*HMFTJBFTUBCBQSF
QBSBEB ZB QBSB EFGFOEFS QPTJDJPOFT Z
QBSB FEVDBS BM QÞCMJDP FO UÏSNJOPT EF
OP QFSNJUJS RVF FM MBJDJTNP JOUFSmSJFSB
FO MB EPDUSJOB SFMJHJPTB %F FTF NPEP
MPT UFNBT NÈT QPMÏNJDPT EF MB CJPÏ
UJDB OP IBO QPEJEP BMDBO[BS FM DBNQP
DJWJMZMPTMFHJTMBEPSFTTFIBONPTUSBEP
QPDPEJTQVFTUPTPJODBQBDFTEFBMNF
OPTEJTDVUJSDVFTUJPOFTDSÓUJDBTDPNPFM
BCPSUPMBFVUBOBTJBFMTVJDJEJPBTJTUJEP
FM VTP EF DÏMVMBT USPODPFNCSJPOBSJBT
MB QSPEVDDJØO Z EFTUJOP EF FNCSJPOFT
TPCSBOUFT FOUSF PUSPT UFNBT 5PEBWÓB
TF QSPEVDFO JORVJFUBOUFT DPOUSPWFSTJBT
TPCSF FM BDDFTP BM MFWPOPSHFTUSFM DPNP
DPOUSBDFQUJWP QPTUDPJUBM P BDFSDB EF MB
EJTUSJCVDJØOEFQSFTFSWBUJWPTQBSBFWJUBS
FMDPOUBHJPQPSFM)*7
0USB JOnVFODJB JNQPSUBOUF FO FM EF
TBSSPMMP EFM QFOTBNJFOUP CJPÏUJDP IB
1FSTQFDUJWBTEFMB#JPÏUJDBFO*CFSPBNÏSJDB
TJEP MB GVFSUF UFOEFODJB OFPMJCFSBM FO
MBFDPOPNÓBRVFFTUBCMFDFMBTQPMÓUJDBT
QÞCMJDBTZUJFOEFBEFTBMFOUBSBVNFOUPT
TVCTUBODJBMFT FO MPT QSPHSBNBT mTDBMFT
SFMBDJPOBEPT DPO NVDIBT OFDFTJEBEFT
TPDJBMFT JODMVTP MPT DVJEBEPT EF TBMVE
-PT FTUVEJPTPT EF CJPÏUJDB SFDPOPDFO
RVFTFIBOMMFWBEPBDBCPNFKPSBTQFSP
TFOFDFTJUBNVDIPNÈTFOVOQBÓTRVF
UPEBWÓB DVFOUB DPO NÈTEFEFTV
QPCMBDJØOCBKPMBMÓOFBEFMBQPCSF[BZ
FOFMDVBMMPTTFSWJDJPTQÞCMJDPTEFDVJ
EBEPTEFTBMVEUSBCBKBODPOGPOEPTFT
DBTPTQFSTPOBMNBMQBHBEPZNBMFOUSF
OBEP EFTØSEFOFT BENJOJTUSBUJWPT Z VO
HSBEPBMUPEFEFTDPOmBO[BQÞCMJDB
.JFOUSBTTFFTUÈFTDSJCJFOEPFTUFDBQÓUV
MPFTUBEÓTUJDBTOBDJPOBMFTJOGPSNBORVF
FOFMDBNQPEFMBTBMVEIBBVNFOUBEP
FO B×PT SFDJFOUFT MB EJTUBODJB FOUSF MPT
SJDPT Z MPT IBCJUBOUFT FEVDBEPT EF MBT
DJVEBEFTSFTQFDUPEFMPTQPCSFTOPFEV
DBEPT Z HFPHSÈmDBNFOUF BJTMBEPT &TUB
EÓTUJDBTPmDJBMFTEFNVFTUSBOUBNCJÏOVO
BVNFOUP FO MBT EJTQBSJEBEFT SFMBUJWBT B
DVJEBEPTNÏEJDPTZDPOEJDJØOEFTBMVE
EFCJEPBMBTJOKVTUJDJBTTPDJBMFTZFEVDBUJ
WBT&MDPNQSPNJTPTPDJBMEFMBCJPÏUJDB
JOUFOUBBMJWJBSFTUBTDBSFODJBTFOUSFOBO
EPQSPGFTJPOBMFTEFTBMVEQBSBRVFFTUÏO
NÈTFOUFSBEPTEFMBTJOKVTUJDJBTTPDJBMFT
QBSUJDJQBOEPFODPNJUÏTIPTQJUBMBSJPTEF
JOWFTUJHBDJØOEBOEPBTJTUFODJBBMQPEFS
MFHJTMBUJWP QBSB NFKPSBS MB DBMJEBE ÏUJDB
EFMFZFTQFSUJOFOUFTBNQMJBOEPMBFOTF
×BO[BEFQPTHSBEPQBSBDSFBSHFOFSBDJP
OFTEFQSPGFTJPOBMFTTFOTJCMFTBMPTQSP
CMFNBTÏUJDPTEFTVEJTDJQMJOB
&OTVNB$IJMFIBFNQF[BEPBFOUFSBSTF
MFOUBNFOUFEFMBJNQPSUBODJBEFMBCJPÏ
UJDBEFTBSSPMMBOEPVOBBDUJWJEBEBDBEÏ
NJDBNPEFSBEBRVFUPEBWÓBEFCFHBOBS
JOnVFODJB FO DBTPT EF GPSNVMBDJØO EF
QPMÓUJDBTPFOMPRVFDPODJFSOFBMBDPO
DJFODJB QÞCMJDB -PT MPHSPT QFSTPOBMFT
OPTJFNQSFEFTQSPWJTUPTEFSJWBMJEBEFT
IBO QSFEPNJOBEP TPCSF DPNJTJPOFT
JOTUJUVDJPOBMFT Z FM USBCBKP FO FRVJQP
FTUÈ HBOBOEP ÓNQFUV TØMP MFOUBNFOUF
SFQSPEVDJFOEP DPOEJDJPOFT Z SBTHPT
JHVBMNFOUFQSFTFOUFTFOPUSBTQBSUFTEF
"NÏSJDB-BUJOB
3FGFSFODJBT
#FDB+1
&MFNCSJØOIVNBOP4BOUJBHPEF$IJMF&EJUPSJBM.FEJUFSSÈOFP
&TDSÓCBS"1ÏSF[.Z7JMMBSSPFM3
#JPÏUJDB'VOEBNFOUPTZEJNFOTJØOQSÈDUJDB
4BOUJBHPEF$IJMF&EJUPSJBM.FEJUFSSÈOFP
'JHVFSPB1'VFO[BMJEB)
#JPFUIJDTJO*CFSP"NFSJDBBOEUIF$BSJCCFBO
5IF+PVSOBMPG.FEJDJOFBOE1IJMPTPQIZQQ
,PUUPX.
*OUSPEVDDJØOBMBCJPÏUJDB4BOUJBHPEF$IJMF&EJUPSJBM6OJWFSTJUBSJB
,PUUPX . *OUSPEVDDJØO B MB CJPÏUJDB B FE 4BOUJBHP EF $IJMF &EJUPSJBM
.FEJUFSSÈOFP
,PUUPX.
#JPÏUJDBFOTBMVEQÞCMJDB4BOUJBHPEF$IJMF&EJUPSJBM1VFSUPEF1BMPT
PERSPETIVADELABIOETICAINDD
#JPÏUJDBFO$IJMF.JHVFM,PUUPX
,PUUPX . &E
#JPÏUJDB F JOWFTUJHBDJØO DPO TFSFT IVNBOPT Z FO BOJNBMFT
4BOUJBHPEF$IJMF$0/*$:5
,PUUPX.FE
.BSDPTOPSNBUJWPTEFMBÏUJDBFOJOWFTUJHBDJØODJFOUÓGJDBDPOTFSFT
WJWPT4BOUJBHPEF$IJMF$0/*$:5&OQSFQBSBDJØO
,PUUPX . #VTUPT 3 "OUSPQPMPHÓB NÏEJDB 4BOUJBHP EF $IJMF &EJUPSJBM
.FEJUFSSÈOFP
-BWBEPT..POHF+*2VJOUBOB$Z4FSBOJ"&ET
1SPCMFNBTDPOUFNQP
SÈOFPTFOCJPÏUJDB4BOUJBHPEF$IJMF&EJDJPOFT6OJWFSTJEBE$BUØMJDBEF$IJMF
-BWBEPT.Z4FSBOJ"
²UJDBDMÓOJDB4BOUJBHPEF$IJMF&EJDJPOFT6OJWFSTJEBE
$BUØMJDBEF$IJMF
-FØO '+ %JF[ B×PT EF CJPÏUJDB FO "NÏSJDB -BUJOB IJTUPSJB SFDJFOUF Z SFUPT
BDUVBMFT&O-PMBT'&E
%JÈMPHPZDPPQFSBDJØOFOTBMVE%JF[B×PTEFCJPÏUJDBFO
MB0144BOUJBHPEF$IJMF6OJEBEEF#JPÏUJDB0140.4QQ
-PMBT'
#JPÏUJDB4BOUJBHPEF$IJMF&EJUPSJBM6OJWFSTJUBSJB
-PMBT ' #JPÏUJDB Z "OUSPQPMPHÓB .ÏEJDB 4BOUJBHP EF $IJMF 1VCMJDBDJPOFT
5ÏDOJDBT.FEJUFSSÈOFP-UEB
-PMBT'
ZFBST1")0#JPFUIJDT6OJU
"DUB#JPFUIJDB
QQ
.BSUÓOF[-
4JUVBDJØOEFMPT$PNJUÏTEF&UJDB)PTQJUBMBSJBFOFM4JTUFNBEF4BMVE
1ÞCMJDBDIJMFOP&O,PUUPX.&E
5FNÈUJDBZGVODJPOBNJFOUPEFMPT$PNJUÏT
JOTUJUVDJPOBMFTEFÏUJDBNÏEJDBCJPÏUJDB4BOUJBHPEF$IJMF$FOUSP*OUFSEJTDJQMJOBSJP
EF&TUVEJPTFO#JPÏUJDB6OJWFSTJEBEEF$IJMF
.JGTVE54+
&MSFTQFUPQPSMBWJEBIVNBOBCJPÏUJDB
.PSBMEFEJTDFSOJNJFOUP
UPNP**
SBFE4BOUJBHPEF$IJMF&EJDJPOFT1BVMJOBT$*%&
1PUUFS%
)PXEJETPDJBMNFEJDJOFFWPMWFBOEXIFSFJTJUIFBEJOH1MP4.FE
QQ%JTQPOJCMFFOXXXQMPTNFEJDJOFPSH%FTDBSHBEPFOPDUVCSF
EF
3PB 3" *OWFTUJHBDJØO DJFOUÓGJDB CJPNÏEJDB GVOEBNFOUPT ÏUJDPT Z
BOUSPQPMØHJDPT &O -BWBEPT . .POHF +* 2VJOUBOB $ Z 4FSBOJ " &ET
1SPCMFNBT DPOUFNQPSÈOFPT FO CJPÏUJDB 4BOUJBHP EF $IJMF &EJDJPOFT 6OJWFSTJEBE
$BUØMJDBEF$IJMFQQ
3PB3"
&UJDBZCJPÏUJDB4BOUJBHPEF$IJMF&EJUPSJBM"OESÏT#FMMP
6HBSUF++
&MEFSFDIPEFMBWJEB#JPÏUJDBZEFSFDIP4BOUJBHPEF$IJMF&EJUPSJBM
+VSÓEJDBEF$IJMF
7JBM$PSSFB+EF%
3FTQFUPZQSPNPDJØOEFMBQFSTPOBIVNBOB&O-BWBEPT
. .POHF +* 2VJOUBOB $ Z 4FSBOJ " &ET
1SPCMFNBT DPOUFNQPSÈOFPT FO
CJPÏUJDB4BOUJBHPEF$IJMF&EJDJPOFT6OJWFSTJEBE$BUØMJDBEF$IJMFQQ
7JFM#
-BNFEJDJOBTPDJBMJ[BEBZTVBQMJDBDJØOFO(SBO#SFUB×B6OJØO4PWJÏUJDB
Z$IJMF4BOUJBHPEF$IJMF&EJDJPOFTEFMB6OJWFSTJEBEEF$IJMF
PERSPETIVADELABIOETICAINDD
1FSTQFDUJWBTEFMB#JPÏUJDBFO*CFSPBNÏSJDB
8BJU[LJO)*SJBSU$&TUSBEB"-BNBESJE4
4PDJBMNFEJDJOFUIFOBOE
OPX-FTTPOTGSPN-BUJO"NFSJDB"N+1VCMJD)FBMUIQQ
8JMEFT,8
.PSBMBDRVBJOUBODFT/PUSF%BNF6OJWFSTJUZPG/PUSF%BNF
1SFTT
PERSPETIVADELABIOETICAINDD
#JPÏUJDBFO$VCBSFTQPOTBCJMJEBEZTPMJEBSJEBE
+PTÏ3BNØO"DPTUB4BSJFHP
$
VCBFTVOQBÓTRVFEVSBOUFEÏDBEBT
IBSFQSFTFOUBEPVODBTPTVJHÏOFSJT
FO FM DPOUFYUP EF "NÏSJDB -BUJOB QPS
RVFBEFTQFDIPEFMPTWBJWFOFTEFMBQP
MÓUJDB SFHJPOBM IB QFSNBOFDJEP FOGSBT
DBEPFOMBDPOTUSVDDJØOEFVOQSPZFDUP
TPDJBM EF PSJFOUBDJØO NBSUJBOB Z NBS
YJTUB1PSFTBSB[ØOQBSBBMHVOPTIBCSÈ
TJEPVOBTPSQSFTBMBSÈQJEBFJSSFWFSTJCMF
QSPQBHBDJØOEFMBCJPÏUJDBFOFMÈNCJUP
DVCBOP EBEB MB WPDBDJØO EFDVMUPQPS
MB MJCFSUBE JOEJWJEVBM RVF QSPNPWJØ MB
CJPÏUJDBNÏEJDBPSJHJOBMNFOUFQFOTBEB
FOVODPOUFYUPEFFDPOPNÓBDBQJUBMJTUB
MJCFSBM1BSBPUSPTRVFWJTMVNCSBSPOMPT
JEFBMFTEFKVTUJDJBZFRVJEBEEFMBCJP
ÏUJDB HMPCBM QPUUFSJBOB MP PDVSSJEP FO
$VCB IB TJEP VOB DPOTFDVFODJB MØHJDB
EFMBCÞTRVFEBEFVOBBMUFSOBUJWBEFTP
DJFEBETVTUFOUBCMF
6OBQFSTQFDUJWBEFTEF$VCBEFM
OVFWPQBSBEJHNBEFSFMBDJPOFT
TBOJUBSJBT
%FTEFMBJOTUBVSBDJØOEFmOJUJWBEFM3FBM
5SJCVOBMEFM1SPUPNFEJDBUPEF-B)B
CBOBFOIBTUBMBGVOEBDJØOQSJ
NFSPEFMB'FEFSBDJØO.ÏEJDBEF$VCB
FOZQPTUFSJPSNFOUFEFTVDPOUJ
OVBEPSFM$PMFHJP.ÏEJDP/BDJPOBMFO
PERSPETIVADELABIOETICAINDD
FM NPEFMP DVCBOP EF SFMBDJPOFT
TBOJUBSJBT TF DPSSFTQPOEJØ DPO FM QBSB
EJHNBDMÈTJDPQBUFSOBMJTUBBVORVFDPO
NBUJDFT QSPQJPT RVF BÞO FO MBT FUBQBT
DPMPOJBMZSFQVCMJDBOBMFEJTUJOHVJFSPO
&OMBQSPQVFTUBEFSFGPSNBVOJWFSTJUB
SJB EF 'SBODJTDP "SBOHP Z 1BSSF×P EF
QSJODJQJPT EFM TJHMP 9*9 FYJTUJØ FM QSP
QØTJUPEFJODMVJSMBFOTF×BO[BEFMBÏUJDB
QSPGFTJPOBMFOMPTFTUVEJPTEFNFEJDJOB
FO $VCB 4JO FNCBSHP FTUB JOUFODJØO
SFRVJSJØEFNVDIPUJFNQPQBSBTFSJN
QMFNFOUBEBFOMBQSÈDUJDB1BSBTVEFm
OJUJWBDPODSFDJØOGVFSPOEFUFSNJOBOUFT
MBTDPOGFSFODJBTEF&OSJRVF+PTÏ7BSP
OB TPCSF MPT 'VOEBNFOUPT EF MB .P
SBM oEJDUBEBT EFOUSP EF MPT DVSTPT RVF
JNQBSUJØFOUSFZFOMB3FBM
"DBEFNJBEF$JFODJBT.ÏEJDBT'ÓTJDBT
Z /BUVSBMFT EF -B )BCBOBo Z MB BDUJ
WJEBE EPDFOUF EF "OUPOJP +PWFS 1VJH
3BJNVOEPEF$BTUSPZ"MMP3BJNVOEP
EF$BTUSPZ#BDIJMMFSZ'SBODJTDP-BO
DÓTZ4ÈODIF[FOMBFOTF×BO[BEFMBÏUJDB
ZMPTEFCFSFTNPSBMFTEFMNÏEJDP%FM
HBEP
&O MB EÏDBEB EF MB BDDFTJCJMJEBE
BMPTTFSWJDJPTEFTBMVETFQPMBSJ[ØDBEB
WF[NÈTZNJFOUSBTMBTDMBTFTGBWPSFDJEBT
1FSTQFDUJWBTEFMB#JPÏUJDBFO*CFSPBNÏSJDB
EFMPTHSBOEFTOÞDMFPTVSCBOPTEJTGSVUB
SPO EF MPT NBZPSFT Z NFKPSFT SFDVSTPT
IVNBOPT Z UÏDOJDPT MB HFOFSBMJEBE EF
MBQPCMBDJØOTFWJPPCMJHBEBBBDFQUBSMBT
NJHBKBTQPMJUJRVFSBTEFVOTFDUPSQÞCMJ
DP DBEB WF[ NÈT PCTPMFUP JOTVmDJFOUF
Z EBOUFTDP &O UBOUP FTUP PDVSSÓB FO
FMTFOPEFMBDPOWVMTBTPDJFEBEDVCBOB
QSFSSFWPMVDJPOBSJB USBT MBT QVFSUBT EFM
$PMFHJP.ÏEJDP/BDJPOBMTFEFCBUÓBMB
DVFTUJØOEFVOBTVQVFTUBQMÏUPSBNÏEJDB
ZMBOFDFTJEBEEFSFDMBNBSMBSFTUSJDDJØO
EFMBGPSNBDJØOEFOVFWPTQSPGFTJPOBMFT
&M$ØEJHPEF.PSBMZFM+VSBNFOUPEF
)POPS EFM $PMFHJP .ÏEJDP /BDJPOBM
iEF JOEJTDVUJCMF WJHFODJB FO TV ÏQPDBw
%FMHBEP
OPFTDBQBSPOEFMB
FUJRVFUBJNQVFTUBQPSɨPNBT1FSDJWBM
BMQBUFSOBMJTNPNÏEJDPNPEFSOP
-BKVTUJDJBDPNPTPMJEBSJEBE
&MBEWFOJNJFOUPEFMQPEFSSFWPMVDJPOB
SJPFOSFWJSUJØUPUBMNFOUFFMFTDF
OBSJPOBDJPOBMBMQSFDPOJ[BSFMQSJODJQJP
NBSYJTUBEFJHVBMEBEFOFMBDDFTPBMPT
TFSWJDJPTEFTBMVEDPNPEFSFDIPIVNB
OP Z MB SFTQPOTBCJMJEBE EFM &TUBEP EF
QSPWFFS QSFTUBDJPOFT BEFDVBEBT Z BDDF
TJCMFTBUPEPT&TUPJNQMJDØFOMBQSÈD
UJDBMBBNQMJBDJØOZNPEFSOJ[BDJØOEF
MBTVOJEBEFTEFTBMVEZDPOFMMPFMJO
DSFNFOUP FYQPOFODJBM EF MB GPSNBDJØO
EFSFDVSTPTIVNBOPT
&M $PMFHJP .ÏEJDP /BDJPOBM EFWJOP
FOUPODFT FO FTDFOBSJP SBNBM EF MB JO
UFOTBMVDIBEFDMBTFTRVFTFEFTBSSPMMB
CB FO UPEB MB TPDJFEBE DVCBOB MP RVF
DVMNJOØ FO VOB DSJTJT Z MB BVUPEJTPMV
PERSPETIVADELABIOETICAINDD
DJØOEFMBJOTUJUVDJØOFO5SBTTV
EFTBQBSJDJØOZQPSDBTJWFJOUFB×PTMB
OPSNBUJWJEBE ÏUJDB FO FM DBNQP EF MB
TBMVE RVFEØ B DBSHP EFM .JOJTUFSJP EF
4BMVE 1ÞCMJDB IBTUB RVF B NFEJBEPT
EF MB EÏDBEB EF TF QSPNVMHBSBO
MPT1SJODJQJPTEFMB²UJDB.ÏEJDBZUVWP
MVHBSMBDPOTUJUVDJØOEFMBT$PNJTJPOFT
EF²UJDB.ÏEJDBFOUPEBTMBTVOJEBEFTZ
OJWFMFTPSHBOJ[BUJWPTEFM4JTUFNB/BDJP
OBMEF4BMVE
-B DPOTPMJEBDJØO EF VO 4JTUFNB /B
DJPOBM EF 4BMVE VOJmDBEP Z QÞCMJDP
B mOFT EF MB EÏDBEB EF DSFØ MBT
DPOEJDJPOFT QBSB SFCBTBS FM DSJUFSJP TP
DJBMEFNØDSBUBEFCVTDBSMBFRVJEBEFO
USF EFTJHVBMFT BM FTUJMP EF +PIO 3BXMT
EF PGSFDFS iUSBUBNJFOUPT EFTJHVBMFT B
TVKFUPTEFTJHVBMFTQBSBDSFBSJHVBMEBEEF
PQPSUVOJEBEFTw -B BUFODJØO EF TBMVE
SFWPMVDJPOBSJBPQUØQPSFMDPNQSPNJTP
NPSBMEFJOTQJSBDJØONBSUJBOBEFiDPO
UPEPTZQBSBFMCJFOEFUPEPTwFOFMDVBM
OPTFEPOBMPRVFTPCSBTJOPTFDPNQBS
UFMPRVFTFUJFOF
1BSB FM NPEFMP DVCBOP MB DVFTUJØO OP
FTUVWP FOUPODFT FO EFmOJS Z BTFHVSBS
VONÓOJNPEFDFOUFEFBUFODJØOEFTB
MVEQBSBUPEPTZRVFBQBSUJSEFÏTUFMB
HFTUJØOQPSMBQSPQJBTBMVETFSFNJUJFSB
BMJOUFSÏTZQPTJCJMJEBEFTFDPOØNJDBTJO
EJWJEVBMFToDPNPTFQMBOUFØMBTPDJBMEF
NPDSBDJBBNQBSÈOEPTFFOFMQSJODJQJP
EF VOJWFSTBMJEBE LBOUJBOPo TJOP RVF
FM NÈYJNP EF UPEBT MBT QPTJCJMJEBEFT
UFDOPMØHJDBT Z QSPGFTJPOBMFT EJTQPOJ
CMFT FTUVWJFSBO BM BDDFTP KVSÓEJDP FDP
OØNJDPHFPHSÈmDPZDVMUVSBMEFUPEPT
#JPÏUJDBFO$VCBSFTQPOTBCJMJEBEZTPMJEBSJEBE+PTÏ3BNØO"DPTUB4BSJFHP
MPTDJVEBEBOPT-PSFMFWBOUFGVFRVFFM
NPEFMPDVCBOPEFBUFODJØOEFTBMVEOP
DPQJØ FYBDUBNFOUF BM TPWJÏUJDP V PUSBT
FYQFSJFODJBT EFM EFTBQBSFDJEP iDBNQP
TPDJBMJTUBw TJOP RVF UPNØ MP NFKPS EF
MB NFEJDJOB TPDJBM JOEFQFOEJFOUFNFO
UFEFTVQSPDFEFODJBQBSBBTÓDPOTUSVJS
VOB BMUFSOBUJWB QSPQJB RVF IB SFTJTUJEP
MBQÏSEJEBEFSFGFSFOUFTJEFPMØHJDPTZMB
DSJTJTRVFBTPMØMBFDPOPNÓBDVCBOBEV
SBOUFMBEÏDBEBEF
-BNFOUBCMFNFOUF FO MB NBZPS QBSUF
EFM NVOEP TF IBO DSFBEP IPZ MÓNJUFT
BSUJmDJBMFT JNQVFTUPT QPS FM NFSDBEP
NJFOUSBT NJMMPOFT EF QFSTPOBT TVGSFO
Z NVFSFO JOOFDFTBSJBNFOUF EFCJEP B
BWBSPT JOUFSFTFT NFSDBOUJMFT Z B GBMUB
EFTPMJEBSJEBE.VDIPTEFMPTBDUVBMFT
QSPCMFNBTEFTBMVETPOEFNBHOJUVEUBM
RVFUSBTQBTBOMBTGSPOUFSBTOBDJPOBMFTZ
TVQPTJCMFTPMVDJØOSFRVJFSFEFMBDPPQF
SBDJØOZDPMBCPSBDJØOJOUFSOBDJPOBM
i-B FRVJEBE FO TBMVE TJHOJmDB JHVBMFT
PQPSUVOJEBEFT EF BDDFTP B MPT SFDVSTPT
EJTQPOJCMFTVOBEJTUSJCVDJØOEFNPDSÈ
UJDB EFM QPEFS Z EF MPT DPOPDJNJFOUPT
FO FM TJTUFNB EF TBMVE VOB QPMÓUJDB EF
TBMVERVFCFOFmDJFBUPEPTTJODPOTFOUJS
QSJWJMFHJPTEFCJEPBEJGFSFODJBTEFSB[B
HÏOFSP UFSSJUPSJP EJTDBQBDJEBE V PUSP
SBTHPEJTUJOUJWPHSVQBMPQFSTPOBMw%F
MB 5PSSF -ØQF[ .ÈSRVF[ (VUJÏSSF[ Z
3PKBT
"OUF FTUBT SFBMJEBEFT 3BGBFM "SBVKP
(PO[ÈMF[ QSPQVTP VO TJTUFNB EF QSJO
DJQJPT BMUFSOBUJWP B MB iNBOUSBw EF
(FPSHFUPXOBDDFTJCJMJEBEQBSUJDJQBDJØO
Z FRVJEBE SFTVMUBCBO B TV KVJDJP NÈT
BEFDVBEPT QBSB OVFTUSP DPOUFYUP QFSJ
GÏSJDP Z MP BSHVNFOUB EF MB TJHVJFOUF
NBOFSB i&O TPDJFEBEFT EFTBSSPMMBEBT
EPOEFMBHBSBOUÓBEFVOFTUBUVTEFWJEB
NFEJPJODMVJEBMBTBMVEOPDPOTUJUVZF
VOBQSFPDVQBDJØOQBSBMBNBZPSÓBEFMB
QPCMBDJØOFTBDFQUBCMFDPNPDVFTUJØO
QFSFOUPSJBMBEJTDVTJØOTPCSFFMFOGSFO
UBNJFOUPCFOFmDFODJBBVUPOPNÓBKVTUJ
DJB DPNP QSJODJQJPT RVF DPOEV[DBO B
MB EJTDVTJØO CJPÏUJDB 1FSP DVBOEP
TFFWBMÞBMBOFDFTJEBEEFVODBNCJPFT
USVDUVSBMFOOVFTUSBTTPDJFEBEFTTVCEF
TBSSPMMBEBTZTPDJBMNFOUFEFTQSPUFHJEBT
FMQSPCMFNBFOEJTDVTJØOOPFODVFOUSB
TPMVDJØOFOMBTSFMBDJPOFTJOUFSQFSTPOB
MFTy
TJOPFOFMQMBOPTPDJBMHMPCBMw
"SBVKP
-PHSBSMBTVTUFOUBCJMJEBEEFVOTJTUFNB
EF TBMVE DPO FTUBT DBSBDUFSÓTUJDBT QPS
QBSUFEFVOQBÓTQPCSFZBTFEJBEPDPNP
$VCBIBUFOJEPRVFCBTBSTFOFDFTBSJB
NFOUF FO VOB BNQMJB SFE EF BUFODJØO
QSJNBSJBZFOMBQBSUJDJQBDJØOEFMBQP
CMBDJØOFOMBDPOTUSVDDJØOEFTVQSPQJB
TBMVE -B WPMVOUBE QPMÓUJDB EF PGSFDFS
MBNÈTBNQMJBZBWBO[BEBDPCFSUVSBIB
SFRVFSJEPEFMBEFMJCFSBDJØOZMBDPODFS
UBDJØODPOMPTDJVEBEBOPTQBSBBTVNJS
TBDSJmDJPTZDBSFODJBTFOPUSBTFTGFSBTEF
MBWJEBZBMDBO[BSNFUBTTPDJBMFTDPNP
FMQMFOPBDDFTPBMFNQMFPMBFEVDBDJØO
ZMBBUFODJØOEFTBMVEFOUSFPUSPT
PERSPETIVADELABIOETICAINDD
&TUF JOUFOUP EF GVOEBNFOUBDJØO EFT
EF VOB QFSTQFDUJWB EFM 4VS TF DPSSFT
QPOEÓB DPO MPT QSJODJQJPT RVF BOJNBO
BMBTBMVEQÞCMJDBDVCBOBFOMBDVBMMB
1FSTQFDUJWBTEFMB#JPÏUJDBFO*CFSPBNÏSJDB
DPPQFSBDJØOEFTJOUFSFTBEBKVFHBVOJN
QPSUBOUFQBQFM%FTEFMBBZVEBCSJOEB
EBB$IJMFFOPB"SHFMJBFO
IBTUBMBPGSFDJEBBMPTEBNOJmDBEPTEF
MPT EFTBTUSFT OBUVSBMFT RVF BTPMBSPO MB
$BDIFNJSBQBLJTUBOÓFOF*OEP
OFTJBEFVOBWPDBDJØOEFTFSWJDJP
IBJNQSFHOBEPMBJNQSPOUBIJTUØSJDBEF
MBNFEJDJOBDVCBOBFOMBDPOUSJCVDJØO
BMUSVJTUBBMBTPMVDJØOEFQSPCMFNBTMP
DBMFTZHMPCBMFTEFTBMVE&OUFOEJEPBTÓ
FMEFCFSEFKVTUJDJBOPQVFEFFODPOUSBS
PUSBNFKPSFYQSFTJØORVFMBTPMJEBSJEBE
DJPOBSJPGVFMBDPODFQDJØOEFM1MBOEF
&TUVEJPT*OUFHSBEPQVFTUPFOWJHPSFO
FOFMDVBMMB6OJEBE(FOFSBMi&M
)PNCSFZTV.FEJPwGVOHJØDPNPFKF
WFSUJDBMEFMNJTNP&TUBJOOPWBEPSBFO
TF×BO[BTJHOJmDØVOUSFNFOEPQBTPEF
BWBODF UFØSJDP Z NFUPEPMØHJDP UBM WF[
OPTVmDJFOUFNFOUFDPNQSFOEJEPFOTV
NPNFOUPRVFQVTPFOFMDFOUSPEFMEJT
DVSTPBDBEÏNJDPMBDPOTJEFSBDJØOEFMPT
TJTUFNBTEFWBMPSFTJOEJWJEVBMFTZHSVQB
MFTFOFMEJBHOØTUJDPZUSBUBNJFOUPEFMPT
QSPCMFNBTEFTBMVE
-BCFOFmDFODJBDPNP
SFTQPOTBCJMJEBE
-B JODPSQPSBDJØO FO FM DVSTP BDBEÏNJ
DP EF ²UJDB Z %FPOUPMPHÓB
.ÏEJDB QPS QSJNFSB WF[ FO MB IJTUPSJB
EF MB FEVDBDJØO NÏEJDB DVCBOB DPNP
BTJHOBUVSB JOEFQFOEJFOUF Z FM MJCSP EF
UFYUPEFJHVBMOPNCSFRVFMBBTJHOBUV
SBQVFEFODPOTJEFSBSTFUFNQSBOFSPTFO
SFMBDJØODPOFMNPWJNJFOUPEFMBTJEFBT
EFMOVFWPQBSBEJHNBÏUJDPFOFMDPOUFY
UP JOUFSOBDJPOBM #BTUF SFDPSEBS RVF MB
QSJNFSBFEJDJØOEFi1SJODJQMFTPG#JPNF
EJDBM&UIJDTwEF#FBVDIBNQZ$IJMESFTT
TFQVCMJDØFTFNJTNPB×PEF
3FTPMWFS FO MP FTFODJBM FM QSPCMFNB EF
MBKVTUJDJBFOFMBDDFTPBMBBUFODJØOEF
TBMVEFTSFRVJTJUPJOEJTQFOTBCMFQFSPOP
TVmDJFOUFQBSBRVFFYJTUBVOUSBUPKVTUP
UBNCJÏOFOFMOJWFMEFMBTSFMBDJPOFTJO
UFSJOEJWJEVBMFT
-BJODPSQPSBDJØOEFMPTGBDUPSFTQTJDP
MØHJDPTZTPDJBMFTFOMBDPOTJEFSBDJØOEFM
QSPDFTP TBMVEFOGFSNFEBE RVF FTUBCB
UFOJFOEP MVHBS FO FM QMBOP JOUFSOBDJP
OBM BTÓ DPNP MBT OVFWBT DPOEJDJPOFT
DSFBEBTQPSMB3FWPMVDJØOFODVBOUPB
VOJWFSTBMJEBEFOFMBDDFTPBMPTTFSWJDJPT
ZMBQSPHSFTJWBFYUFOTJØOEFMBTBDDJPOFT
EFQSPNPDJØOZQSFWFODJØOEFMTVCTJTUF
NBEFBUFODJØOQSJNBSJBSFFOGPDBSPOMB
HFTUJØOEFTBMVEIBDJBMBNFEJDJOBTPDJBM
ZGBWPSFDJFSPORVFMBVOJWFSTJEBEDVCB
OBEFTEFDPNJFO[PTEFMBEÏDBEBEFMPT
FOTF×BSBMBTMMBNBEBTiIVNBOJEBEFT
NÏEJDBTw P iDJFODJBT TPDJBMFT BQMJDBEBT
B MB TBMVEw 6O QBTP BÞO NÈT SFWPMV
PERSPETIVADELABIOETICAINDD
i%FCFNPTBDFQUBSoTFBmSNBFOA²UJDB
ZEFPOUPMPHÓBNÏEJDBoRVFMBTDJFODJBT
OBUVSBMFTOPDPOUFNQMBOFOTÓNJTNBT
SFHMBTPOPSNBTFTQFDÓmDBTRVFEFmOBO
FM VTP EF QSPDFEJNJFOUPT B BQMJDBS FO
MB QSÈDUJDB MPT BWBODFT DJFOUÓmDPT Z FT
QPTJCMF RVF FO EFUFSNJOBEBT DJSDVOT
UBODJBTMBVUJMJ[BDJØOJODPSSFDUBEFOVF
WBTUÏDOJDBTQVFEBJOUFSQSFUBSTFPDPOT
UJUVZBFOTÓBDUPTEFEFTIVNBOJ[BDJØOw
"MPOTP7PO4NJUI3BNÓSF[Z0SUFHB
#JPÏUJDBFO$VCBSFTQPOTBCJMJEBEZTPMJEBSJEBE+PTÏ3BNØO"DPTUB4BSJFHP
.ÈT BEFMBOUF TF QSFDJTB i&M DPOPDJ
NJFOUP QPS QBSUF EFM FOGFSNP RVF TF
TPNFUFSÈ BM FYBNFO EF MBT NPMFTUJBT
RVFQVFEBPDBTJPOBSMFZEFMBOFDFTJEBE
EF SFBMJ[BSMP OP TØMP EFCFO HBOBS TV
BQSPCBDJØOTJOPUBNCJÏOTVDPOmBO[BZ
PCUFOFSTVDPMBCPSBDJØOw"MPOTP7PO
4NJUI3BNÓSF[Z0SUFHB
2VFEBQMBOUFBEBBTÓVOBWJTJØOEFMDPO
TFOUJNJFOUPJOGPSNBEPNVZQBSUJDVMBS
FMDVBMEFCFTFSEFTBSSPMMBEPFOFMNBSDP
EF SFMBDJPOFT JOUFSQFSTPOBMFT DBSBDUFSJ
[BEBTQPSMBDPOmBO[B&TUBQFSTQFDUJWB
DVCBOBFNQJF[BBBMFKBSTFZBEFMQBUFS
OBMJTNP DMÈTJDP "×PT EFTQVÏT FO VO
FOTBZPEFEPTQSFTUJHJPTPTBVUP
SFT&ENVOE1FMMFHSJNPZ%BWJEɨP
NBTNBEFmOJSÓBOFTUFUJQPEFSFMBDJØO
DPNPiCFOFmDFODJBEFDPOmBO[Bw
-B UPNB EF DPODJFODJB SFTQFDUP EF MPT
DBNCJPT EF MB TJUVBDJØO EF TBMVE EF MB
QPCMBDJØODVCBOBRVFZBFSBOQBUFOUFT
BMmMPEFMBEÏDBEBEFZMBDBQBDJ
EBEEFSFTQVFTUBFOHFOFSBMFYJUPTBEFM
TJTUFNB FO DPOEJDJPOFT EF FNFSHFODJB
oQVFTUB B QSVFCB DPO MB JOUSPEVDDJØO
UFSSPSJTUB EFM EFOHVF IFNPSSÈHJDP FO
OVFTUSP QBÓT o FWJEFODJB
SPO UBNCJÏO EFUFSNJOBEBT WVMOFSBCJMJ
EBEFT Z DPO FMMP MB OFDFTJEBE EF JN
QMFNFOUBSOVFWBTFTUSBUFHJBTZBDDJPOFT
&O FM UFSSFOP EF MB OPSNBUJWJEBE NP
SBM QSPGFTJPOBM TF IJDJFSPO QÞCMJDPT MPT
i1SJODJQJPTEFMB²UJDB.ÏEJDBw
ZTFDPOTUJUVZFSPOMBTDPNJTJPOFTEFÏUJ
DBNÏEJDBFOUPEBTMBTVOJEBEFTZOJWF
MFT EFM 4JTUFNB /BDJPOBM EF 4BMVE &O
MPKVSÓEJDPTFQSPNVMHØMB-FZEF4BMVE
PERSPETIVADELABIOETICAINDD
1ÞCMJDB &O MB PSHBOJ[BDJØO EF
MPTTFSWJDJPTEFTEFTFJOJDJØMBFY
QFSJFODJBEFMiNÏEJDPZMBFOGFSNFSBEF
MBGBNJMJBwDVZPQFSGFDDJPOBNJFOUPEF
WJOPFOFMTJTUFNBEFNFEJDJOBGBNJMJBS
BDUVBM'JOBMNFOUFFOMPBDBEÏNJDPTF
QVTP FO WJHPS VO OVFWP QMBO EF FTUV
EJPT
FTUSVDUVSBEPTPCSFMBCBTF
EFMPTQSPCMFNBTZOFDFTJEBEFTEFTBMVE
JEFOUJmDBEPT
-PT i1SJODJQJPT EF MB ²UJDB .ÏEJDBw
DPOTUJUVZFO FM QSJNFS DØEJHP EF DPO
EVDUB QSPGFTJPOBM SFEBDUBEP CBKP MBT
DPOEJDJPOFTFDPOØNJDBTZTPDJBMFTDSFB
EBT QPS MB 3FWPMVDJØO Z TØMP QPS FMMP
UJFOFOVOBMUPWBMPSIJTUØSJDPFOTÓNJT
NPT4JCJFOTVSFEBDDJØODPOTFSWBVO
FTUJMPBÞOQBUFSOBMJTUBBMBEFDVBSTFBMBT
OVFWBTDJSDVOTUBODJBTTFJOUSPEVDFOEF
UFSNJOBEPTQSFDFQUPTRVFSFnFKBOZBVO
DBNCJPEFFOGPRVF
i.BOUFOFSFOMPTDBTPTEFFOGFSNFEB
EFTEFDVSTPGBUBMBCTPMVUBPSFMBUJWBSF
TFSWBTPCSFFMEJBHOØTUJDPZQSPOØTUJDP
FOSFMBDJØODPOFMQBDJFOUFZTFMFDDJPOBS
BRVJÏOTFEFCFEBSFTBJOGPSNBDJØODPO
FMUBDUPOFDFTBSJPw1SJODJQJPTEFMB²UJ
DB.ÏEJDB
&T EFDJS RVF TØMP TF FTUBCMFDF SFTFSWB
SFMBUJWB FO MB JOGPSNBDJØO B QBDJFOUFT
Z GBNJMJBSFT QBSB FM DBTP EF FOGFSNF
EBEFT EF DVSTP GBUBM %FKB B EJTDSFDJØO
EFMFRVJQPEFTBMVEMBEFDJTJØOEFRVJÏO
TFSÈEFQPTJUBSJPEFMBNBMBOPUJDJBEFMP
DVBMOPTFFYDMVZFBMQSPQJPQBDJFOUFTJ
MBTDBSBDUFSÓTUJDBTEFTVQFSTPOBMJEBEBTÓ
MPQFSNJUFO
1FSTQFDUJWBTEFMB#JPÏUJDBFO*CFSPBNÏSJDB
0USPFMFNFOUPFOMBDPOTJEFSBDJØOEFM
QSJODJQJP EF BVUPOPNÓB QPS QBSUF EF
MPT i1SJODJQJPT EF MB ²UJDB .ÏEJDBw FT
FM EF DPOTFOUJNJFOUP JOGPSNBEP $PO
SFMBDJØO B FTUF QBSUJDVMBS TF FYQSFTB
i0CUFOFS BOUFT EF BQMJDBS DVBMRVJFS
NFEJEB EJBHOØTUJDB P UFSBQÏVUJDB RVF
QVFEB TJHOJmDBS VO BMUP SJFTHP QBSB FM
QBDJFOUFTVDPOTFOUJNJFOUPPFMEFTVT
GBNJMJBSFTFYDFQUPFOMPTDBTPTEFGVFS[B
NBZPSw1SJODJQJPTEFMB²UJDB.ÏEJDB
&T EFDJS TF JODMVZF FM DPOTFOUJNJFOUP
WPMVOUBSJP BVORVF OP TF QSFDJTB DVÈO
JOGPSNBEPEFCFSÈTFSÏTUFZMPQSFTDSJCF
QBSBMPTQSPDFEJNJFOUPTSJFTHPTPTZOP
BUPEPTDPNPZBTFEJTDVUÓBFOBRVFMMPT
NPNFOUPT &M TØMP IFDIP EF RVF VO
EPDVNFOUPJODMVZBFTUBDVFTUJØOJOEF
QFOEJFOUFNFOUF EF RVF MP IBZB IFDIP
EF GPSNB MJNJUBEB EFCF TFS BQSFDJBEP
DPNP VO BWBODF TJ DPOTJEFSBNPT RVF
WJODVMØBUPEPTMPTQSPGFTJPOBMFTDVCB
OPTEFMBTBMVEDPOTVDVNQMJNJFOUP
-B FYQBOTJØO EF MBT JOWFTUJHBDJPOFT
CJPNÏEJDBTZMBJOUSPEVDDJØOZQSPEVD
DJØOBVUØDUPOBEFUFDOPMPHÓBTNÏEJDBT
EFQVOUBNPUJWØRVFMBSFnFYJØOÏUJDB
FOFTUFDBNQPBEPQUBSBEFmOJUJWBNFO
UFUFNBTZDPOnJDUPTEFWBMPSFTRVFMF
IBO TJEP DBSBDUFSÓTUJDPT IBTUB MB BDUVB
MJEBE %FCFNPT EFTUBDBS MB MBCPS EF
&SOFTUP #SBWP .BUBSB[[P BM QSPNPWFS
FM DPMPRVJP TPCSF i1SPCMFNBT mMPTØm
DPT EF MB NFEJDJOBw RVF DPNFO[BEP
FOTFFYUFOEJØQPSWBSJPTDJDMPTZ
B×PT-BTQPOFODJBTQSFTFOUBEBTGVFSPO
QVCMJDBEBT FO GBTDÓDVMPT QPS MB FEJUP
PERSPETIVADELABIOETICAINDD
SJBM EFM *OTUJUVUP 4VQFSJPS EF $JFODJBT
.ÏEJDBTEF-B)BCBOB&TUFDPMPRVJP
OPTJOUSPEVKPFOVOVOJWFSTPUFNÈUJDP
IBTUBFTFNPNFOUPUSBUBEPGSBHNFOUB
SJBNFOUF P TJNQMFNFOUF EFTDPOPDJ
EP DPNP GVF FM EF MBT DVFTUJPOFT UFØ
SJDPmMPTØmDBT EFM PSJHFO Z FTFODJB EF
MB WJEB MB HFOØNJDB MBT OFVSPDJFODJBT
Z FM EJBHOØTUJDP NÏEJDP BNQBSBEP FO
MBTOVFWBTUFDOPMPHÓBTFOUSFPUSBT%F
MBT QPOFODJBT QSFTFOUBEBT i1SPCMFNBT
ÏUJDPT FO FM EFTBSSPMMP EF MB CJPMPHÓB Z
MBNFEJDJOBDPOUFNQPSÈOFBTwEF"CF
MBSEP3BNÓSF[.ÈSRVF[Z3BÞM)FSSFSB
7BMEÏTFTVOBCVFOBNVFTUSBQPSRVF
TFBEFOUSBFOMPTDPOnJDUPTÏUJDPTEFMB
JOWFTUJHBDJØODJFOUÓmDBFOIVNBOPTMPT
EFMBHFOÏUJDBNÏEJDBFMEJBHOØTUJDPEF
MBNVFSUFZMBEPOBDJØOZUSBTQMBOUFEF
ØSHBOPT Z UFKJEPT 3BNÓSF[ Z )FSSFSB
-BQSJNFSBSFnFYJØOUFØSJDBSFBMJ[BEBQPS
VOBVUPSDVCBOPTPCSFMBOVFWBUFOEFO
DJBEFMQFOTBNJFOUPÏUJDPRVFSFQSFTFO
UBCBMBCJPÏUJDBGVFFYQVFTUBQPS"OUPOJP
EF "SNBT EVSBOUF FM *** *OUFSOBUJPOBMFT
8JTTFOTDIBGUMJDIFT 4ZNQPTJVN 6CFS -FJ
UVOH6OE1MBOOVOH4PDJMBSF1SP[FTTF*N
5FSSJUPSJVN DFMFCSBEP FO 3PTUPDL BO
UJHVB3FQÞCMJDB%FNPDSÈUJDB"MFNBOB
FOZRVFGVFSBQVCMJDBEPB×PTNÈT
UBSEFFO$VCBCBKPFMUÓUVMPEFi&OUPS
OPBMBPSJFOUBDJØOmMPTØmDBEFMB#JPÏ
UJDBi%F"SNBT
&O DPNP BDUVBMJ[BDJØO EFM BQP
ZPCJCMJPHSÈmDPEFMBBTJHOBUVSB²UJDBZ
%FPOUPMPHÓB.ÏEJDBTFQVCMJDØi5FNBT
EF²UJDB.ÏEJDBw&TUFMJCSPDPOTUJUVZF
#JPÏUJDBFO$VCBSFTQPOTBCJMJEBEZTPMJEBSJEBE+PTÏ3BNØO"DPTUB4BSJFHP
VOBDFSDBNJFOUPBMQFOTBNJFOUPCJPÏUJ
DPQPSRVFPGSFDFVOBWJTJØONÈTIPMÓTUJ
DBEFMBJOUFSSFMBDJØOIPNCSFOBUVSBMF[B
ZEFMPTGBDUPSFTFDPOØNJDPTZTPDJBMFT
FOFMQSPDFTPTBMVEFOGFSNFEBE
iyMB DPOUSBEJDDJØO RVF TF HFOFSB BM
VTBS JOEJTDSJNJOBEBNFOUF FM EFTBSSPMMP
DJFOUÓmDPUÏDOJDPQPSMBTDPOTFDVFODJBT
RVF FTUP USBF QBSB FM IPNCSF UJFOF TV
TPMVDJØO DPO FM VTP FOFSHÏUJDP Z DPOT
DJFOUFEFFTFEFTBSSPMMPDJFOUÓmDPUÏDOJ
DPEJSJHJEPBSFBMJ[BSVOBBDUJWJEBEQSP
mMÈDUJDBQFSNBOFOUFFOFMNFEJPTPDJBM
QBSBMPHSBSMBSFQPTJDJØOZFRVJMJCSJPEF
MBOBUVSBMF[BPCUFOJFOEPBTÓVOOPSNBM
EFTBSSPMMP EFM BNCJFOUF FDPMØHJDP EFM
IPNCSFBQVOUPEFQBSUJEBEFUSBOTGPS
NBDJPOFTFOTVNFEJPTPDJBMw#PSSPUP
/Þ×F[ EF 7JMMBWJDFODJP Z .BSUÓOF[
-PT QSPQJPT BVUPSFT JEFOUJmDBO WBSJPT
QFMJHSPTRVFBDFDIBOBMBDBMJEBEEFMB
SFMBDJØONÏEJDPQBDJFOUFBTBCFS
t
t
t
t
%FTIVNBOJ[BDJØO QPS MB JOUFSGF
SFODJB QPTJCMF EF MB UFDOPMPHÓB FO
MBSFMBDJØOBGFDUJWBZFMQSPDFTPEF
DPNVOJDBDJØO F JOEJWJEVBMJ[BDJØO
EFMBSFMBDJØO
3FBMJ[BSVOBQFSDFQDJØOOPJOUFHSBM
EFMJOEJWJEVPFOGFSNP
&OGPRVFT OPTPMØHJDPT JODPSSFDUPT
EFCJEPBVOBNBSDBEBEFQFOEFODJB
EFMBUFDOPMPHÓB
&O FM OJWFM EF SJFTHP EF QSPEVDJS
JBUSPHFOJB
5SFTB×PTEFTQVÏT
DVBOEPTFEJ
TF×ØMBUSBNBDVSSJDVMBSEFMBFOUPODFT
PERSPETIVADELABIOETICAINDD
OVFWBDBSSFSBVOJWFSTJUBSJBEF5FDOPMP
HÓBEFMB4BMVEMBEJSFDDJØOEFM«SFBEF
%PDFODJBEFM.JOJTUFSJPEF4BMVE1ÞCMJ
DBEF$VCB.*/4"1
FTUBCBDPOTDJFOUF
EFMBOFDFTJEBEEFEPUBSBMBGPSNBDJØO
EFMPTSFDVSTPTIVNBOPTFOFTFDBNQP
EFVOBBNQMJBDPCFSUVSBEFMBT$JFODJBT
4PDJBMFTBQMJDBEBTBMBTBMVE&OMBNBMMB
DVSSJDVMBSTFJODMVZFSPOUSFTBTJHOBUVSBT
RVFDPOGPSNBSPOVOBEJTDJQMJOBHFOÏSJ
DBNFOUFEFOPNJOBEB4BMVEMBUFSDFSBZ
ÞMUJNBEFFTUBTBTJHOBUVSBTEFBDVFSEP
DPOTVVCJDBDJØOFOFMTFHVOEPB×PEF
MBFTQFDJBMJEBEi4BMVE***wDPOTUJUVZØFM
QSJNFSQSPHSBNBEFCJPÏUJDBJNQMFNFO
UBEPFOFEVDBDJØOTVQFSJPSEFQSFHSBEP
FOOVFTUSPQBÓToWJHFOUFEFTEFFMDVSTP
IBTUBFMoZQP
TJCMFNFOUF UBNCJÏO FM QSJNFSP EF TV
UJQP JNQBSUJEP FO "NÏSJDB -BUJOB &O
FTUF QSPHSBNB TF FOHBS[BSPO UFNBT TF
DVMBSNFOUFUSBUBEPTQPSMBÏUJDBNÏEJDB
DPO PUSPT EFM OVFWP FOGPRVF CJPÏUJDP
-PTSFTVMUBEPTEFMQSJNFSMVTUSPEFBQMJ
DBDJØOGVFSPOQVCMJDBEPTFOMBTNFNP
SJBTEFM5FSDFS5BMMFS*OUFSOBDJPOBMEFM
1SPHSBNB 3FHJPOBM EF #JPÏUJDB QBSB
"NÏSJDB-BUJOBZFM$BSJCF0140.4
DFMFCSBEPFO-B)BCBOBFOOPWJFNCSF
EFEFEJDBEPBMUFNBEF²UJDBEF
MB*OWFTUJHBDJØO$JFOUÓmDB«SFBEF%P
DFODJBEFM.*/4"1
4J CJFO MB FTQFDJBMJEBE EF 5FDOPMPHÓB
EFMB4BMVEQPSMPFTDBTPEFTVNBUSÓ
DVMB EVSBOUF TVT QSJNFSPT RVJODF B×PT
EF FYJTUFODJB UVWP VO JNQBDUP PCKFUJ
WBNFOUFMJNJUBEPFOFMDPOUFYUPHFOF
SBM EF MB FEVDBDJØO NÏEJDB DVCBOB FO
TF BEPQUØ VO QBTP USBTDFOEFOUF
1FSTQFDUJWBTEFMB#JPÏUJDBFO*CFSPBNÏSJDB
BM USBOTGPSNBS FM BOUJHVP QSPHSBNB EF
'JMPTPGÓB EF VOJWFSTBM BQMJDBDJØO QBSB
UPEBTMBTDBSSFSBTEFMBTDJFODJBTNÏEJDBT
FOFMQBÓTFOPUSPEFNBZPSBQMJDBDJØO
QSÈDUJDB'JMPTPGÓBZ4BMVE
&O FM DBNQP EFM DPOUSPM TPDJBM TPCSF
MBTBQMJDBDJPOFTNÏEJDBTEFMPTBWBODFT
DJFOUÓmDPUFDOPMØHJDPT SFTVMUØ EF HSBO
JNQPSUBODJBMBDSFBDJØOEFM$FOUSPQBSB
FM$POUSPM&TUBUBMEFMB$BMJEBEEFMPT
.FEJDBNFOUPT Z EFM $FOUSP
QBSB FM $POUSPM &TUBUBM EF MPT &RVJQPT
.ÏEJDPT
RVFDPOTUJUVZFOOVFT
USBT BHFODJBT FTUBUBMFT TVCPSEJOBEBT
EFTEF BM #VSØ 3FHVMBUPSJP EF MB
4BMVE-BGVOEBDJØOEFM$FOUSP$PPS
EJOBEPSEFMPT&OTBZPT$MÓOJDPT
QSPNPWJØ MB GPSNBDJØO EF DPNJUÏT EF
SFWJTJØO ÏUJDB QBSB DBEB FOTBZP DMÓOJDP
oGVOEBNFOUBMNFOUFQBSBMPTNVMUJDÏO
USJDPTo1PSPUSBQBSUFMBQVFTUBFOWJ
HPSEFMBTi/PSNBTEF#VFOBT1SÈDUJDBT
$MÓOJDBTwQSPNVMHBEBTQPSQSJNFSBWF[
FO NPEJmDBEBT FO Z QFS
GFDDJPOBEBT OVFWBNFOUF FO BTÓ
DPNPMBQSPNVMHBDJØOEFMi$ØEJHPEF
²UJDB EF MPT 5SBCBKBEPSFT EF MB $JFO
DJBw FO FTUJNVMBSPO FM JOUFSÏT
EFMPTJOWFTUJHBEPSFTZEJSFDUJWPTQPSFM
FTUVEJP EF MPT GVOEBNFOUPT ÏUJDPmMP
TØmDPTEFMBJOWFTUJHBDJØOBTÓDPNPEF
MPTQSPDFEJNJFOUPTFTUBOEBSJ[BEPTQBSB
MB FWBMVBDJØO EF QSPZFDUPT Z DPO FMMP
QSPNPWJFSPO FM TVSHJNJFOUP EF MPT ØS
HBOPTRVFWFMBSBOQPSTVDVNQMJNJFOUP
MPTDPNJUÏTJOTUJUVDJPOBMFTEFÏUJDBEFMB
JOWFTUJHBDJØODJFOUÓmDB
-B DFMFCSBDJØO FO $VCB EFM 1SJNFS
4JNQPTJP *OUFSOBDJPOBM TPCSF .VFSUF
PERSPETIVADELABIOETICAINDD
&ODFGÈMJDB oQPTUFSJPSNFOUF SFOPNCSB
EPDPNPEF.VFSUFZ$PNBoFO
BUSBKP MB QBSUJDJQBDJØO EF JNQPSUBOUFT
QFSTPOBMJEBEFT EF MB CJPÏUJDB JOUFSOB
DJPOBM %F FTUF JOUFSDBNCJP TVSHJFSPO
MBT JEFBT RVF DPODSFUBSPO MPT EPT QSJ
NFSPTDVSTPTJOUFSOBDJPOBMFTFGFDUVBEPT
FOOVFTUSPQBÓTi-BVOJWFSTJEBENÏEJDB
BOUF MPT QSPCMFNBT CJPÏUJDPT BDUVBMFTw
DFMFCSBEP FO FO MB TFEF EFM FO
UPODFT $FOUSP /BDJPOBM EF 1FSGFDDJP
OBNJFOUP .ÏEJDP oDVZBT BDUJWJEBEFT
EPDFOUFTGVFSPOBTVNJEBTQPSQSPGFTP
SFTDVCBOPTZOPSUFBNFSJDBOPToFi*O
USPEVDDJØO B MB CJPÏUJDBw PGSFDJEP FO
FOMBTFEFEFMBFOUPODFT'BDVMUBE
EF4BMVE1ÞCMJDBQPS+VBO$BSMPT5FBMEJ
FOSFQSFTFOUBDJØOEFMB&TDVFMB-BUJOPB
NFSJDBOBEF#JPÏUJDBDPOTFEFFO#VF
OPT"JSFT"SHFOUJOB
&TBQSJNFSBNJUBEEFMBEÏDBEBEF
GVFUFTUJHPEFMBDSFBDJØOEFDÈUFESBTEF
CJPÏUJDBFOMPTDFOUSPTEFFEVDBDJØONÏ
EJDB TVQFSJPS BTÓ DPNP EFM QSPDFTP EF
EJTDVTJØOEFMCPSSBEPSEFMB%FDMBSBDJØO
6OJWFSTBM EFM (FOPNB Z MPT %FSFDIPT
)VNBOPTRVFEFWJOPFOMBGVOEBDJØO
EFM$PNJUÏ/BDJPOBM$VCBOPEF#JPÏ
UJDBFO#BKPFMBVTQJDJPEFJOTUJ
UVDJPOFTDBUØMJDBTDPNFO[ØBDJSDVMBSMB
QSJNFSBQVCMJDBDJØOQFSJØEJDBEFEJDBEB
B UFNBT EF CJPÏUJDB MB IPZ EFTBQBSFDJ
EBSFWJTUB&UIPTZFOTFGVOEØFM
$FOUSP EF #JPÏUJDB +VBO 1BCMP ** RVF
QSPNPWJØMBDFMFCSBDJØOEFVOB+PSOBEB
"OVBM EF #JPÏUJDB Z MB QVCMJDBDJØO EF
PUSB SFWJTUB QSJNFSBNFOUF OPNCSBEB
"OBMFT EFM $FOUSP +VBO 1BCMP ** Z IPZ
SFCBVUJ[BEBDPNP#JPÏUJDB
#JPÏUJDBFO$VCBSFTQPOTBCJMJEBEZTPMJEBSJEBE+PTÏ3BNØO"DPTUB4BSJFHP
5PEPTFTUPTQSFDFEFOUFTFYQMJDBOMBSÈ
QJEB EJGVTJØO Z MB BWJEF[ DPO RVF GVF
SFDJCJEB MB QSJNFSB FEJDJØO EFM MJCSP
i#JPÏUJDB %FTEF VOB QFSTQFDUJWB DV
CBOBwRVFTBMJØBDJSDVMBDJØOBmOFTEF
&TUFUSBCBKPEFNÈTEFDVBSFOUB
BVUPSFTDVCBOPTSFQSFTFOUBMBDPOUJOVJ
EBEEFMQFOTBNJFOUPOBDJPOBMFOUPSOP
B MBT DVFTUJPOFT ÏUJDBT SFMBDJPOBEBT DPO
MBTBMVEZMBWJEBZBMBWF[NBSDBVOB
SVQUVSBDPOFMNPEFMPDMÈTJDPIFHFNØ
OJDP EFTEF OVFTUSB USBEJDJØO EF QFOTB
NJFOUPRVFOPFYBMUBMBJOEJWJEVBMJEBE
DPNP IB TJEP UÓQJDP Z UØQJDP FO MB MJ
UFSBUVSB CJPÏUJDB BOHMPTBKPOB TJOP RVF
SFDPOPDFFMQBQFMEFMJOEJWJEVPFOUBOUP
QBSUÓDJQFEFMBSFTQPOTBCJMJEBEDPMFDUJWB
DPOFMCJFOFTUBSEFUPEPT%Fi#JPÏUJDB
%FTEFVOBQFSTQFDUJWBDVCBOBwQVFEFO
FYUSBFSTFJOmOJEBEEFFKFNQMPTRVFDPO
mSNBOFTUFQVOUPEFJOnFYJØO
"M BOBMJ[BS MB OVFWB EJNFOTJØO EF MB
SFMBDJØO NÏEJDPQBDJFOUF FO OVFTUSPT
EÓBT 3JDBSEP (PO[ÈMF[ BmSNB i-PT
TVTUBODJBMFT Z SFDJFOUFT DBNCJPT FO
FM DPODFQUP PCKFUJWP Z GVODJPOFT BTÓ
DPNPFOMBSFMFWBODJBEFMPTEJGFSFOUFT
BTQFDUPTQPSDPOTJEFSBSFOFTUBSFMBDJØO
MBDPMPDBOBDUVBMNFOUFFOVOBTJUVBDJØO
EF USÈOTJUP EPOEF UBOUP FM QSPGFTJPOBM
DPNPFMTVKFUPZPCKFUPEFTVBUFODJØO
oFM IPNCSF TBOP P FOGFSNPo EFCFO JS
NPEJmDBOEPTVTBODFTUSBMFTDPODFQDJP
OFTBDFSDBEFMBHFTUJØONÏEJDBy
4F
USBUBQPSUBOUPEFVOQSPDFTPRVFQPOF
FO UFOTJØO OVFTUSBT SFTQPOTBCJMJEBEFT
DPNP FEVDBEPSFT NÏEJDPT QFSP RVF
UBNCJÏOTPNFUFBQSVFCBBUPEBTMBTJOT
UBODJBTEFMTJTUFNBEFTBMVEFOOVFTUSP
PERSPETIVADELABIOETICAINDD
NFEJPBTÓDPNPBMPTQSPQJPTVTVBSJPT
TJNCPMJ[BEPTBIPSBQPSFMDPMFDUJWPGB
NJMJBSw(PO[ÈMF[
3JDBSEP (PO[ÈMF[ USBF B DPMBDJØO VO
BTQFDUP RVF NÈT BEFMBOUF FO FM UFYUP
TFSÓBEFTBSSPMMBEPDPONBZPSÏOGBTJTQPS
/Þ×F[EF7JMMBWJDFODJPMBSFTQPOTBCJMJ
EBEEFMNÏEJDPDPNPFEVDBEPSPTFB
RVFFMCFOFmDJPWFSEBEFSPEFMQBDJFOUF
PTBOPTØMPTFBMDBO[BTJTFMFIBDFDPOT
DJFOUFEFTVTQSPQJBTOFDFTJEBEFTEFTB
MVE-FKPTEFMBDPFSDJØOQSPQJBEFMNP
EFMPQBUFSOBMJTUBPEFMBJOGPSNBDJØOOP
DPNQSPNFUJEBEFMNPEFMPBVUPOPNJTUB
NÈT QVSP JOWPMVDSBS BM QSPGFTJPOBM EF
MB TBMVE DPO MB FEVDBDJØO TBOJUBSJB EFM
VTVBSJPPCMJHBBVOQSPDFTPEFMJCFSBUJWP
ZBEFDJEJSKVOUPTMBTNFKPSFTPQDJPOFT
EFTPMVDJØO"DFQUBSFTUPJNQMJDBMBTV
QFSBDJØOEFMQBSBEJHNBQBUFSOBMJTUBUSB
EJDJPOBM
-BOFDFTJEBEEFVOBNBZPSTJNFUSÓBFO
MBTSFMBDJPOFTJOUFSQFSTPOBMFTQSPQJBTEF
MB BUFODJØO NÏEJDB DPOUFNQPSÈOFB FT
QSFDJTBEBQPS7BSÈO7PO4NJUIi%FO
USPEFMBÏUJDBDMÓOJDBHBOBVOMVHBSQSF
QPOEFSBOUFFMSFTQFUPBMBJOUFHSJEBEEFM
JOEJWJEVPZFTUPTFFKFSDFSÈFODVBMRVJFS
ÈNCJUPDMÓOJDPEPOEFTFFODVFOUSFZTFB
DVBM GVFSF TV BGFDUBDJØOw 7PO 4NJUI
&T NVZ TJHOJmDBUJWP RVF
7BSÈO 7PO 4NJUI VTF FM UÏSNJOP ÏUJDB
DMÓOJDB DSFBEP QPS .BSL 4JFHMFS Z OP
IBZBQVFTUPMÓNJUFTBMBPCTFSWBODJBEF
MBJOUFHSJEBEQMFOBZDPOFMMBBMSFTQFUP
EF MB DBQBDJEBE Z DPNQFUFODJB NPSBM
EFM QBDJFOUF P TBOP MB JEFB EF RVF FM
UJQPEFSFMBDJØOJOUFSQFSTPOBMFOMBBUFO
1FSTQFDUJWBTEFMB#JPÏUJDBFO*CFSPBNÏSJDB
DJØOEFTBMVEEFQFOEFEFMNPNFOUPEF
MBTJUVBDJØODMÓOJDBEFGPSNBUBMRVFFO
EJGFSFOUFTNPNFOUPTEFVONJTNPDBTP
QVFEFOBQMJDBSTFEJGFSFOUFTNPEFMPTEF
BUFODJØODPNPGVFQMBOUFBEPQPSɨP
NBT 4[BT[ Z .BSD )PMMFOEFS Z
EFTBSSPMMBEP QPTUFSJPSNFOUF QPS &[F
RVJFMZ-JOEB&NNBOVFM
-PJO
UFSFTBOUFFTRVF7PO4NJUISFDPNJFOEB
FKFSDFSMPFODVBMRVJFSÈNCJUPZDVBMRVJFS
BGFDUBDJØOZMPSFMBDJPOBDPOFMFODBSHP
TPDJBMEFMQSPGFTJPOBMEFMBTBMVEDPOTV
SFTQPOTBCJMJEBE
3BEBNÏT#PSSPUP$SV[Z3BNØO"OFJ
SPT3JCBQSPGVOEJ[BOFOFMSFTQFUPBMB
EJHOJEBEUSBEVDJEPFOVOBDPNVOJDB
DJØOSFTQPOTBCMFRVFTVTUFOUFVOBSFMB
DJØO TBOJUBSJB EF DBMJEBE Z TBUJTGBHB MBT
FYQFDUBUJWBTEFMPTVTVBSJPTi-BFTFODJB
EFM RVFIBDFS NÏEJDP TF SFTVNF FO MB
TBUJTGBDDJØOEFMBTOFDFTJEBEFTEFTBMVE
EFMIPNCSF/BEJFQVFEFTFSGFMJ[FOMB
JHOPSBODJBZNVDIPNFOPTTJTFUSBUBEF
BRVFMMPSFMBDJPOBEPDPOTVQSPQJBTBMVE
&MQBDJFOUFTØMPFTUBSÈTBUJTGFDIPDVBOEP
DPOP[DBUPEPDVBOUPEFTFFTPCSFTVTB
MVEPTVFOGFSNFEBE/BEJFDPNPFMNÏ
EJDPUJFOFMBQPTJCJMJEBEEFBDFSDBSTFBMP
NÈTÓOUJNPZTFOTJCMFEFMTFSIVNBOPw
#PSSPUPZ"OFJSPT3JCB
&M
EPNJOJPEFMPTQSPDFTPTDPNVOJDBUJWPT
FTMBWÓBQBSBBDFSDBSTFBiMPNÈTÓOUJNP
ZTFOTJCMFwFTUBCMFDJFOEPVOWÓODVMPFO
USFMPQSPQJBNFOUFUÏDOJDPZMPNPSBMFO
FMOJWFMEFMBTSFMBDJPOFTJOUFSQFSTPOBMFT
-B SFTQPOTBCJMJEBE TPDJBM EFM QSPGFTJP
OBMEFMBTBMVEFTIBDFSMBCFOFmDFODJB
TBUJTGBDJFOEP UPEBT MBT OFDFTJEBEFT EF
TBMVEEFMQBDJFOUFZOPTØMPMBTCJPMØHJ
PERSPETIVADELABIOETICAINDD
DBTDPNPIBTJEPUFOEFODJBDPNÞOEF
MBNFEJDJOBDVSBUJWB
'FSOBOEP/Þ×F[EF7JMMBWJDFODJPSFBMJ
[ØVOBQPSUFDPOTVDPODFQDJØOEFRVF
FMQSPDFTPEFDPOTFOUJNJFOUPJOGPSNB
EP EFCF TFS FTFODJBMNFOUF VOB BDDJØO
FEVDBUJWB FO MB DVBM FM SFTQFUP QPS MB
BVUPOPNÓB TFB DPODJMJBEP DPO MBT OF
DFTJEBEFTEFTBMVEEFMQBDJFOUFPTBOP
i/PEFCFNPTQMBOUFBSVOMÓNJUFBIBDFS
FMCJFOPBMVDIBSQPSMBTBMVEoBmSNBo
FMQSPCMFNBFTUÈFOBMFSUBSBMNÏEJDPEF
RVFTJQSJPSJ[BTØMPMPTBTQFDUPTEFMFRVJ
MJCSP CJPMØHJDP IBCSÈ PDBTJPOFT FO RVF
TVTBDDJPOFTEFCFOFmDFODJBFOFTUFTFO
UJEPQVFEBOFTUBSQSPEVDJFOEPEFTFRVJ
MJCSJPTQTJDPMØHJDPTZTPDJBMFTEFVOBJO
UFOTJEBENBZPS"VUPSJ[BSMPBJNQPOFS
TVCFOFmDFODJBFOFTUPTDBTPTTFSÓBBV
UPSJ[BSMPBBDDJPOFTDPOUSBMBTBMVEy
"M BOBMJ[BS FM QSJODJQJP EF BVUPOPNÓB
TJOFNCBSHPOPOPTFODPOUSBNPTFOMB
NJTNB TJUVBDJØO &TUF EFSFDIP EFM QB
DJFOUF EF TFS JOGPSNBEP DPOTVMUBEP Z
BQBSUJDJQBSFOMBTBDDJPOFTUPNBEBTFO
SFMBDJØODPOTVQSPQJBTBMVEMPDVBMFO
FTFODJBFTJODVFTUJPOBCMFSFRVJFSFEFMJ
NJUBDJPOFTCJFOQSFDJTBTQBSBFWJUBSRVF
TVVTPJOBEFDVBEPDPODMVZBFOVOEF
TBTUSF QBSB FM QSPQJP QBDJFOUFw /Þ×F[
EF7JMMBWJDFODJP
&TUFBVUPSDSJUJDBMBCFOFmDFODJBCJPMP
HJDJTUBBVMUSBO[BRVFPNJUFMPTQSPDFTPT
QTJDPMØHJDPTEFMVTVBSJPZQPSPUSBQBS
UF TF QSPOVODJB QPSRVF FM QSPDFTP EF
DPOTFOUJNJFOUPJOGPSNBEPZFMSFTQFUP
BMBBVUPOPNÓBEFMQBDJFOUFPTBOPFT
UÏOBCTPMVUBNFOUFDPNQSPNFUJEPTDPO
#JPÏUJDBFO$VCBSFTQPOTBCJMJEBEZTPMJEBSJEBE+PTÏ3BNØO"DPTUB4BSJFHP
FM CJFOFTUBS EF ÏTUPT EPOEF FM DSJUFSJP
UÏDOJDPEFMQSPGFTJPOBMEFMBTBMVEZTV
TJTUFNB EF WBMPSFT EFCFO BSSJCBS B MB
NFKPS EFDJTJØO QBSB UPEPT B USBWÏT EF
MBEFMJCFSBDJØO/PFMVEFFMEFCBUFDPO
MPTEFGFOTPSFTEFMBVUPOPNJTNPBDFSDB
EFRVFWJTUPBTÓFMQSPDFTPEFDPOTFOUJ
NJFOUPJOGPSNBEPQVFEFQSFTUBSTFQBSB
MBNBOJQVMBDJØOZBQFMBBRVFFMBDUVBS
SFTQPOTBCMF EFM QSPGFTJPOBM EF MB TBMVE
TFBMBTBMWBHVBSEBBOUFQPTJCMFTDPFSDJP
OFTFJNQPTJDJPOFT
&MBOÈMJTJTEFMPTQVOUPTEFDPOnVFODJB
EF FTUBT Z PUSBT DPOUSJCVDJPOFT B i#JP
ÏUJDB %FTEF VOB QFSTQFDUJWB DVCBOBw
FWJEFODJBRVFTJCJFOUPEBTTFBMFKBOEFM
QBUFSOBMJTNP DMÈTJDP UBNQPDP DBFO FO
MPTCSB[PTEFVOBVUPOPNJTNPBVMUSBO
[BQBSBQSPQPOFSVONPEFMPBMUFSOBUJWP
FORVFFMCJFOFTUBSEFMVTVBSJPTFBMDBO
[BEFTEFFMBDUVBSSFTQPOTBCMFEFRVJFO
QSFTUBMBBUFODJØOEFTBMVEZMBDPOmBO[B
NVUVB
-BDPOTPMJEBDJØOEFMBCJPÏUJDBFOOVFT
USPQBÓTTFDPOmSNØDPOMBGVOEBDJØOB
mOFTEFMPTEFOVFWBTJOTUJUVDJPOFT
RVFJODMVÓBOMBEJTDJQMJOBFOUSFFMPCKF
UPEFTVNJTJØODPNPGVFSPOFM$FOUSP
EF &TUVEJPT EF #JPÏUJDB EF MB 'BDVMUBE
EF $JFODJBT .ÏEJDBT EF )PMHVÓO RVF
DFMFCSBKPSOBEBTDJFOUÓmDBTBOVBMFTDPO
QBSUJDJQBDJØO JOUFSOBDJPOBM FM $FOUSP
EF &TUVEJPT )VNBOÓTUJDPT EFM *OTUJUV
UP4VQFSJPSEF$JFODJBT.ÏEJDBTEF-B
)BCBOB Z FM $PNJUÏ EF #JPÏUJDB EF MB
6OJWFSTJEBEEF-B)BCBOBRVFFODP
PSEJOBDJØODPOMB&TDVFMB-BUJOPBNFSJ
DBOB EF .FEJDJOB DPNFO[Ø B DFMFCSBS
PERSPETIVADELABIOETICAINDD
BOVBMNFOUFEFTEFVO&ODVFOUSP
EF #JPÏUJDB EF MB &EVDBDJØO 4VQFSJPS
-B GPSNBDJØO EF SFDVSTPT IVNBOPT FO
CJPÏUJDBTFGVFQFSGFDDJPOBOEPUBNCJÏO
ZBMPTUSBEJDJPOBMFTDVSTPTJOUSPEVDUP
SJPTTFTVNBSPOBTJHOBUVSBTDVSSJDVMBSFT
FO MBT NBFTUSÓBT EF (FOÏUJDB .ÏEJDB F
*OGPSNÈUJDBEFMB4BMVEBTÓDPNPDVSTPT
EF ²UJDB EF MB *OWFTUJHBDJØO $JFOUÓmDB
oFM QSJNFSP EF ÏTUPT BVTQJDJBEP QPS FM
*OTUJUVUP'JOMBZEF7BDVOBTZ4VFSPTFO
4FJOJDJØMBGPSNBDJØOFTQFDJBMJ[B
EBFOCJPÏUJDBFOFMOJWFMEFEJQMPNBEP
BCJFSUBDBTJBMVOÓTPOPEVSBOUFFMDVSTP
BDBEÏNJDPFOFM*OTUJUVUPEF
$JFODJBT#ÈTJDBTZ1SFDMÓOJDBTi7JDUPSJB
EF(JSØOwZMB'BDVMUBEEF$JFODJBT.Ï
EJDBTEF)PMHVÓOBMBTRVFTFTVNBSÓB
NÈTUBSEFMB'BDVMUBEEF$JFODJBT.Ï
EJDBTEF4BODUJ4QJSJUVT*NQPTJCMFTPT
MBZBSMBJOUFOTBBDUJWJEBEFEJUPSJBMFOUF
NBTEFCJPÏUJDBEFM$FOUSP'ÏMJY7BSFMB
PSHBOJ[BDJØOOPHVCFSOBNFOUBMRVFIB
TJEPEFUFSNJOBOUFFOMBEJWVMHBDJØOEF
MPTBVUPSFTOBDJPOBMFT
-B CJPÏUJDB NÏEJDB DVCBOB OP SFOJFHB
EFM BQPSUF RVF QBSB MB ÏUJDB DMÓOJDB IB
SFQSFTFOUBEPFMTJTUFNBEFQSJODJQJPTEF
#FBVDIBNQZ$IJMESFTTTJTFMFTBQMJDB
MBKFSBSRVJ[BDJØOQSFDPOJ[BEBQPS%JFHP
(SBDJBQFSPMFDPOmFSFVODPMPSQSPQJP
BM EFTUBDBS MB SFTQPOTBCJMJEBE DPO RVF
EFCFTFSFKFSDJEBMBCFOFmDFODJBZMBTP
MJEBSJEBEDPNPNÈYJNBTFYQSFTJPOFTEF
KVTUJDJB -B EÏDBEB USBOTDVSSJEB EFTEF
BMBGFDIBIBTJEPUFTUJHPUBOUPEFM
EFCBUFBDFSDBEFMBWBMJEF[EFMEJTDVSTP
CJPÏUJDPFOOVFTUSPNFEJPDPNPEFMB
FWPMVDJØO EFTEF FM SFTUSJDUJWP FOGPRVF
1FSTQFDUJWBTEFMB#JPÏUJDBFO*CFSPBNÏSJDB
CJPNÏEJDP IBDJB VOB NÈT BCBSDBEPSB
WJTJØOBNCJFOUBMJTUBQPUUFSJBOB
"QPSUFTEFTEF$VCBBMBCJPÏUJDB
HMPCBMTVTUFOUBCMF
i#JPÏUJDB %FTEF VOB QFSTQFDUJWB DV
CBOBw NBSDØ UÓNJEBNFOUF FM QVOUP EF
JOnFYJØO IBDJB MB CÞTRVFEB EFM FRVJMJ
CSJP OFDFTBSJP FOUSF CJPÏUJDB NÏEJDB Z
CJPÏUJDB HMPCBM :B FO TF FTUBCB
QSPEVDJFOEP VOB UPNB EF DPODJFODJB
BDFSDB EF MB JNQPSUBODJB EF MB CJPÏUJDB
HMPCBMEF1PUUFSQBSBFMEFTBSSPMMPUFØ
SJDPZNFUPEPMØHJDPEFMBEJTDJQMJOBFO
$VCBZDPNPFEJUPSDJFOUÓmDPEFFTUB
PCSB UVWF MB JOUFODJØO EF RVF FYJTUJF
SB BM NFOPT VOB NPEFTUB QSFTFODJB
EFEJDIPFOGPRVFFOÏTUB)BTUBDJFSUP
QVOUPFTUPTFMPHSØFJODMVTPTFBDPQJØ
NBUFSJBM TVmDJFOUF QBSB DPOGPSNBS VO
DBQÓUVMP UJUVMBEP i$JWJMJ[BDJØO NFEJP
BNCJFOUFZTBMVEw
&O i&M FTDFOBSJP QPTUNPEFSOP EF MB
CJPÏUJDBwBMSFnFYJPOBSTPCSFMBFODSV
DJKBEB EF MB OPDJØO EF QSPHSFTP BM RVF
DPOEVKPFMEFTBSSPMMPNBUFSJBMBVMUSBO
[B UÓQJDP EF MB NPEFSOJEBE oZ RVF ZB
FO FTPT NPNFOUPT TVGSÓB FM EFTCPRVF
EFMDBQJUBMJTNPOFPMJCFSBMoQMBOUFBNPT
DMBSBNFOUF MB OFDFTJEBE EF VOB CJPÏUJ
DB EF MB JOUFSWFODJØO i4J FYJTUF MB SFBM
WPMVOUBE EF TBMWBS B MB IVNBOJEBE EFM
IPMPDBVTUP FDPMØHJDP Z EF FNQSFOEFS
FM DBNJOP EFM EFTBSSPMMP TPTUFOJCMF TF
QSFDJTBEFVOBOVFWBNFOUBMJEBEEFVO
DPNQSPNJTPFmDB[DPOFMIPNCSFZDPO
MBWJEBEFVOBiOVFWBDVMUVSBwQMBOFUB
SJBiDPOUPEPTZQBSBFMCJFOEFUPEPTw
PERSPETIVADELABIOETICAINDD
y
$SFBSDPODJFODJBFOFMDBNQPFTQJ
SJUVBMZSFDMBNBSDBNCJPTFOMPTPDJBMZ
FDPOØNJDPFTFMHSBOSFUPEFDPSSJFOUFT
EF QFOTBNJFOUP BDUVBMFT DPNP MB CJP
ÏUJDB MB FDPTPGÓB Z MB FDPMPHÓB QPMÓUJDB
QFSPNÈTRVFEFÏTUBTFTFMHSBOEFTBGÓP
EFMBIVNBOJEBEDPOUFNQPSÈOFBTJOP
RVJFSFEFKBSEFTFSMPw"DPTUBZ(PO[È
MF[
0USP EF MPT BUJTCPT EF CJPÏUJDB HMPCBM
TVTUFOUBCMFQSFTFOUFTFOMBTEPTQSJNFSBT
FEJDJPOFTEFi#JPÏUJDB%FTEFVOBQFST
QFDUJWBDVCBOBwFTFMRVFFYQSFTBO6C
BMEP(PO[ÈMF[1ÏSF[+PSHF(SBV«WBMP
Z.BSÓB"OUPOJB"NBSJMMP.FOEP[BBM
DSJUJDBSFMÏOGBTJTFOMBTDVFTUJPOFTEFMB
DBMJEBEEFWJEBJOEJWJEVBMQSFTFOUFTFO
MPT FWFOUPT DMÓOJDPT BM QSJODJQJP Z mOBM
EF MB WJEB IVNBOB RVF TPO BÞO IPZ
UØQJDPSFDVSSFOUFEFMBCJPÏUJDBNÏEJDB
iyTJ FO CJPÏUJDB TF SFDPOPDF Z TF USB
CBKBFODPNJÈTUJDBNFOUFFOSFMBDJØODPO
MBDBMJEBEEFWJEBFOFMNPNFOUPEFMB
NVFSUFy
4FEFCFQSJPSJ[BSMBQPMÏNJ
DBBUPEPTMPTQSPCMFNBTHMPCBMFTTPDJB
MFTHSVQBMFTFJOEJWJEVBMFTRVFBGFDUBO
MBWJEBFMFDPTJTUFNBZMBDBMJEBEEFWJEB
EFMHÏOFSPIVNBOPZUBNCJÏOGPDBMJ
[BS TPCSF RVÏ DPOEJDJPOFT TPDJPFDPOØ
NJDBTEFWJEBRVÏHBSBOUÓBTKVSÓEJDBTZ
RVÏFEVDBDJØONPSBMOFDFTJUBFMIPNCSF
QBSBRVFTVTEFDJTJPOFTOPDPOTUJUVZBO
VOBWJPMBDJØOEFMPTQSJODJQJPTNPSBMFT
EFMBDVMUVSBVOJWFSTBMw(PO[ÈMF[(SBV
Z"NBSJMMP
&OTFQVCMJDBOEPTMJCSPTRVFNBS
DBOFMQSPDFTPEFDPOnVFODJBQMFOBEFM
QFOTBNJFOUP BNCJFOUBMJTUB Z CJPÏUJDP
#JPÏUJDBFO$VCBSFTQPOTBCJMJEBEZTPMJEBSJEBE+PTÏ3BNØO"DPTUB4BSJFHP
DVCBOPFOMBDPOTPMJEBDJØOEFVOBWJTJØO
QSPQJBEFMBCJPÏUJDBHMPCBMTVTUFOUBCMF
i&DPMPHÓBZTPDJFEBE&TUVEJPTwCBKPMB
FEJDJØO DJFOUÓmDB EF $BSMPT +FTÞT %FM
HBEP %ÓB[ Z ɨBMÓB . 'VOH 3JWFSØO
Zi$VCBWFSEF&OCVTDBEFVONPEFMP
QBSB MB TVTUFOUBCJMJEBEw UBNCJÏO DPO
MBFEJDJØODJFOUÓmDBEF$BSMPT+%FMHB
EP&OMBPDBTJØOFWJEFODJÏMBWPDBDJØO
EF MB CJPÏUJDB NÏEJDB QPS DPODFOUSBSTF
FOMBDVFTUJØOEFMBTSFMBDJPOFTJOUFSJO
EJWJEVBMFT EF MB BUFODJØO EF TBMVE Z MB
JOWFTUJHBDJØOCJPNÏEJDBZMBOFDFTJEBE
EFBNQMJBSFMIPSJ[POUFCJPÏUJDPi3FBM
NFOUFQPDPIBSFNPTTJOPTPDVQBNPT
EFMPTQSPCMFNBTQBSUJDVMBSFTEFMBTBMVE
ZOPMPTFOGSFOUBNPTFOTVJOUFHSBMJEBE
FOMBDPNQMFKBVSEJNCSFEFTVTSFMBDJP
OFTDPOMPTQSPDFTPTFDPOØNJDPTTPDJB
MFTZDVMUVSBMFTEFMEFTBSSPMMPw"DPTUB
&OFMNJTNPZBVTQJDJBEPQPSMB
FEJUPSJBM &-'04 EFM $FOUSP EF *OHF
OJFSÓB(FOÏUJDBZ#JPUFDOPMPHÓBTFDFMF
CSØFO-B)BCBOBFM1SJNFS5BMMFS/B
DJPOBM TPCSF 0SHBOJTNPT .PEJmDBEPT
(FOÏUJDBNFOUF0.(
-BTQPOFODJBT
GVFSPOQVCMJDBEBTFOMBQSFTUJHJPTBSFWJT
UB #JPUFDOPMPHÓB "QMJDBEB %F NJ BQPS
UF BM FWFOUP FYUSBJHP FTUBT DJUBT FO MBT
RVFDPOTJEFSPTFFYQSFTBVOJOUFOUPEF
PGSFDFSVOQVOUPNÈTEFSFGFSFODJBBMB
GVOEBNFOUBDJØO ÏUJDB EFM BOÈMJTJT BDFS
DB EFM JNQBDUP NFEJPBNCJFOUBM EF MPT
PSHBOJTNPT WJWPT BSUJmDJBMNFOUF EJTF
×BEPTi-BPCTFSWBODJBEFMQSJODJQJPEF
SFTQPOTBCJMJEBEBMGBWPSFDFSMBQSFTFSWB
DJØOEFMCJFODPNÞODPOUSJCVZFBDSFBS
VODPOUFYUPNBUFSJBMZTPDJBMBEFDVBEP
PERSPETIVADELABIOETICAINDD
BMFRVJMJCSJPEFMIPNCSFZMBOBUVSBMF[B
HBSBOUJ[BOEPBTÓRVFMPTWBMPSFTZEFSF
DIPTJOEJWJEVBMFTQVFEBOUFOFSSFBMJ[B
DJØOFGFDUJWBy
&MQSJODJQJPEFKVTUJDJB
TFSÈFGFDUJWPFONBUFSJBEFJOWFTUJHBDJØO
ZVUJMJ[BDJØOEFMPT0.(ZEFMBTCJP
UFDOPMPHÓBT FO HFOFSBM TJ TF BMDBO[B MB
OFDFTBSJBFRVJEBEFODPNQBSUJSMPTCF
OFmDJPT FWBMVBS Z FOGSFOUBS MPT SJFTHPT
QPUFODJBMFTZFMBDDFTPBMBJOGPSNBDJØO
HFOÏUJDBBDVNVMBEBZMBUSBOTGFSFODJBEF
UFDOPMPHÓBT&TUFQSPQØTJUPTØMPTFSÈQP
TJCMFTJTFFTUBCMFDFMBOFDFTBSJBDPPQFSB
DJØO/PSUF4VSMPRVFJNQMJDBSÓBTVQF
SBS MB JOKVTUB DPODFQDJØO OFPMJCFSBM EF
MBKVTUJDJBy
3FTQPOTBCJMJEBEZKVTUJ
DJBDPOTUJUVZFOFMJNQFSBUJWPÏUJDPQBSB
MBTJOWFTUJHBDJPOFTZVMUFSJPSVUJMJ[BDJØO
EFMPT0.(-BPCTFSWBODJBEFBNCPT
QSJODJQJPTFTDPOTVTUBODJBMQBSBRVFFTUF
MPHSP EF MB DVMUVSB SFQFSDVUB FO FM CF
OFmDJPEFMBTPDJFEBEFOTVDPOKVOUPZ
OP TFDPOWJFSUB FO VO BEJUBNFOUP NÈT
EFMFKFSDJDJPEFVOQPEFSIFHFNØOJDPw
"DPTUB"&&
6O FOGPRVF HMPCBM EF MB CJPÏUJDB OP
QVFEF TPTMBZBS MPT QSPCMFNBT EFM EFTB
SSPMMPZMBTSFMBDJPOFTFDPOØNJDBTZTP
DJBMFT RVF TVCZBDFO FO MBT BQMJDBDJPOFT
UFDOPMØHJDBTBMBWJEBTPDJBMQBSBMPDVBM
FM NBSDP UFØSJDPNFUPEPMØHJDP RVF IB
GVODJPOBEPFOFMÈNCJUPEFMBCJPÏUJDB
NÏEJDBSFTVMUBBRVÓJOTVmDJFOUF4JCJFO
ZB "SBVKP IBCÓB QMBOUFBEP VO TJTUFNB
SFGFSFODJBM BMUFSOBUJWP BM QSJODJQBMJTNP
BOHMPTBKØOQBSBFMBOÈMJTJTZTPMVDJØOEF
MPT QSPCMFNBT QSPQJPT EF VOB NBDSP
CJPÏUJDBNÏEJDBBDDFTJCJMJEBEFRVJEBE
ZQBSUJDJQBDJØO
FOFMQSFTFOUFTFQSFDJ
1FSTQFDUJWBTEFMB#JPÏUJDBFO*CFSPBNÏSJDB
TBRVFFMBDUVBSKVTUPEFCFTFSUBNCJÏO
SFTQPOTBCMF EBEP RVF MPT QSPDFTPT FO
KVFHPWBONÈTBMMÈEFMBTBMVEIVNBOB
oBVORVFMBJODMVZFoZTFFYUJFOEFOBMB
FTUBCJMJEBEEFMPTFDPTJTUFNBTZMBTVQFS
WJWFODJBEFMBWJEBFOHFOFSBM
&OFMi(MPTBSJPEF#JPÏUJDBwEF3BGBFM
5PSSFT "DPTUB BQBSFDFO EFmOJ
EPTFOVOBQVCMJDBDJØODVCBOBMPTUÏS
NJOPTEFiCJPÏUJDBBNCJFOUBMwiCJPÏUJDB
HMPCBMw Z iCJPÏUJDB QSPGVOEBw 5PSSFT
VOFMFNFOUPNÈTRVFBQVOUB
BMSFDPOPDJNJFOUPEFMBWJTJØOIPMÓTUJDB
EFMBEJTDJQMJOBFOOVFTUSPQBÓT
i#JPÏUJDB QBSB MB TVTUFOUBCJMJEBEw QV
CMJDBEPFOSFQSFTFOUBMBWFSEBEFSB
FDMPTJØOEFMBCJPÏUJDBHMPCBMTVTUFOUBCMF
FO$VCBOPTØMPQPSRVFFOUPEPFMMJ
CSPnPUBVOBVSBEFIPNFOBKFB1PUUFS
TJOPUBNCJÏOFJOEFQFOEJFOUFNFOUFEF
MBTEFTJHVBMEBEFTEFUPEBPCSBDPMFDUJWB
QPSTVTBQPSUFTBMBDPOTPMJEBDJØOEFMB
QFSTQFDUJWBBNCJFOUBMJTUBEFMBEJTDJQMJ
OB+FTÞT"SNBOEP.BSUÓOF[(ØNF[FO
TVBSUÓDVMPi1SPZFDUPTQBSBVOBCJPÏUJDB
HMPCBMwQFSmMBEFmOJUJWBNFOUFMPTQSJO
DJQJPT RVF EFCFO SFHJS MPT EFTUJOPT EF
VOB JOUFSQSFUBDJØO IPMÓTUJDB EF MB CJP
ÏUJDB i-B CJPÏUJDB NÏEJDB IB JOTJTUJEP
NÈT FO MB TPMJEBSJEBE HSVQBM GVOEBEB
FO MB ÏUJDB EFM UFOFS RVF FO MB TPMJEB
SJEBEHMPCBMCBTBEBFOFMNPEPEFTFS
y
%FTEFMBQFSTQFDUJWBTF×BMBEBTFSÓB
NVZEJGÓDJMEFTBSSPMMBSVOBSFTQPOTBCJMJ
EBE HMPCBM TPMJEBSJB 6O QSJODJQBMJTNP
EPOEF FM SFTQFUP B MB BVUPOPNÓB TFB
DPOTJEFSBEP VO QSJODJQJP EF KFSBSRVÓB
TVQFSJPSTFSÈNVZEJGÓDJMEFJOTFSUBSFO
PERSPETIVADELABIOETICAINDD
FMDPOUFYUPEFVOBSFTQPOTBCJMJEBEWFS
EBEFSBNFOUF TPMJEBSJB DPO QSPZFDDJP
OFTHMPCBMFTZOPJOEJWJEVBMFTPHSVQB
MFTy
&MQVFOUFDPODFCJEPQPS1PUUFS
GVF FM EFTBSSPMMP EF VOB ÏUJDB HMPCBM
QFSPMBTWJHBTPDJNJFOUPTEFFTUFQVFOUF
OPQVFEFOTFSPUSPTRVFMBTPMJEBSJEBE
Z SFTQPOTBCJMJEBE HMPCBMFTw .BSUÓOF[
&M NBUJ[ BOUFSJPSNFOUF BUSJCVJEP B MB
QFSTQFDUJWB DVCBOB EF MB CJPÏUJDB NÏ
EJDBoEFJOUFSQSFUBSMBCFOFmDFODJBDPO
SFTQPOTBCJMJEBEZMBKVTUJDJBDPNPTPMJ
EBSJEBEoRVFEBBIPSBQMFOBNFOUFDPO
TJEFSBEPQPSFTUFBVUPSFOFMDBTPEFMB
CJPÏUJDBHMPCBMTVTUFOUBCMFBMQSPQPOFS
RVFMPTQSJODJQJPTEFSFTQPOTBCJMJEBEZ
TPMJEBSJEBETPOMPTBEFDVBEPTQBSBTFS
WJSEFQVOUPEFQBSUJEBBVOQSPDFTPEF
EFMJCFSBDJØO Z CÞTRVFEB EF TPMVDJPOFT
NPSBMNFOUF WÈMJEBT B MPT DPOnJDUPT EF
WBMPSFTNPSBMFTQSPQJPTEFMBBQMJDBDJØO
EFMDPOPDJNJFOUPFOMBTDPOEJDJPOFTEF
VONVOEPJOKVTUBNFOUFFTDJOEJEP
-B DPODFQDJØO HMPCBM EF MB CJPÏUJDB Z
TV JOUFSSFMBDJØO DPO MB TVTUFOUBCJMJEBE
EFMEFTBSSPMMPDPOEVDFJOFWJUBCMFNFOUF
B MB CJPQPMÓUJDB BDDJØO DJVEBEBOB QBSB
BMDBO[BSRVFMBSFTQPOTBCJMJEBETPMJEBSJB
TFNBUFSJBMJDFFOQPMÓUJDBTRVFJODMVZBO
MBQBSUJDJQBDJØOQSPUBHØOJDBUBOUPEFMB
TPDJFEBEDJWJMDPNPEFMPT&TUBEPTZMBT
PSHBOJ[BDJPOFT JOUFSOBDJPOBMFT -PHSBS
MB WFSUFCSBDJØO Z DPIFSFODJB EF FTUPT
FTGVFS[PTEFQFOEFEFVODBNCJPTVTUBO
DJBMEFMBFEVDBDJØOFOWBMPSFTFOFMRVF
MPNPSBMEFKBFTUBSTFQBSBEPEFMDPOPDJ
NJFOUPDJFOUÓmDPZQBTBBTFSQBSUFDPOT
#JPÏUJDBFO$VCBSFTQPOTBCJMJEBEZTPMJEBSJEBE+PTÏ3BNØO"DPTUB4BSJFHP
UJUVUJWBEFÏTUF-BCJPÏUJDBBTÓJOUFSQSF
UBEBFTVOBDVFTUJØOEFUPEBMBTPDJFEBE
ZOPVOBUFNÈUJDBEFMBEJTDVTJØOBDBEÏ
NJDBFOUSFVOBFMJUFEFJOJDJBEPT
i-B CJPÏUJDB GPSNVMBEB QPS 1PUUFS SF
QSFTFOUBVOBSVQUVSBDVMUVSBMQSPGVOEB
4FFYJHFEFMIPNCSFMBSFDPODJMJBDJØOEF
MB NPSBMJEBE Z FM TBCFS DPNP FOUJEBE
ÞOJDBRVFMPNPSBMTFBJODPSQPSBEPBM
DPOPDJNJFOUP DPNP DPNQPOFOUF JN
QPSUBOUFEFMBPCKFUJWJEBEZMFHJUJNJEBE
EFM TBCFS 6OB QSPQVFTUB EF BDDJPOFT
QBSB MB GPSNBDJØO EF TVKFUPT SFTQPOTB
CMFTFOVOFOUPSOPDVMUVSBMEFDBNCJP
&MMBFTUÈMMBNBEBBQSPEVDJSVOBSFWPMV
DJØO EFM TBCFS IVNBOP Z GVF EFmOJEB
QPSTVBVUPSFOUÏSNJOPTRVFFOGBUJ[BO
FTUFSFDMBNPw%FMHBEP
-VJT-ØQF[#PNCJOPFOi&MTBCFSÏUJDP
EFBZFSBIPZw
SFUPNBFMUFNB
EFTEF MB MFHJUJNJEBE NPSBM EFM USBCBKP
DJFOUÓmDP Z TV JOFMVEJCMF DPNQSPNJTP
TPDJBMi1FOTBSFOMBDJFODJBZMBUFDOPMP
HÓBFTUBNCJÏONFEJUBSFOMBSFTQPOTBCJ
MJEBEEFRVJFOFTMBIBDFOZMBFKFDVUBO
QVFT{RVÏTFSÓBEFMBDSFBUJWJEBEDJFOUÓ
mDBTJOPTFQJFOTBFOTVTDPOTFDVFODJBT
TPDJBMFTZNPSBMFT /PFTQPSHVTUPRVF
FM DVMUP QPS MB OPWFEBE QPS MP PSJHJ
OBM OP QVFEF EFTDVJEBS TV TJHOJmDBEP
BYJPMØHJDP QVFT MB BQFUFODJB QPS DPTBT
OVFWBTIBHVJBEPBMIPNCSFEFDJFODJBB
FYUSFNBTBOHVTUJBT-BDJFODJBOPQVFEF
QFSNBOFDFSBMNBSHFOEFMPTDPOnJDUPT
TPDJBMFTZIVNBOPTQPSFTPMBGVODJØO
EFMDJFOUÓmDPOPFTTØMPMBEFQSPEVDJS
TBCFS PCKFUJWP OFVUSBM TJO RVF TV USB
CBKPTFBJOnVFODJBEPQPSMBTPDJFEBEFO
PERSPETIVADELABIOETICAINDD
RVFWJWFUSBCBKBZDSFBw-ØQF[#PNCJ
OP
&TUBSFWPMVDJØODVMUVSBMIBDJBMBSFTQPO
TBCJMJEBETPMJEBSJBFOFMVTPEFMDPOPDJ
NJFOUP JNQMJDB VO SFQMBOUFP EFM QBQFM
TPDJBM EF MB DJFODJB Z MB UFDOPMPHÓB &O
VOBÏQPDBFORVFFMDPOPDJNJFOUPCJP
MØHJDPZEJHJUBMNBSDBOFMQBTPEFMQSP
HSFTPDJFOUÓmDPSFTVMUBJOBDFQUBCMFRVF
FTUPTiDPNVOFTwFTUÏOTJFOEPPCKFUPEF
VO QSPDFTP EF QSJWBUJ[BDJØO HBMPQBOUF
RVFNBSHJOBBRVJFOFTDBSFDFOEFBDDF
TP Z OVUSF B EJGVTPT FOUFT DPSQPSBUJWPT
RVFNVFWFOMPTIJMPTEFVOQPEFSBWB
TBMMBEPS
iyMBCJPÏUJDBGVFQSPNPWJEBCBKPMBDPO
DJFODJBEFFTUBCMFDFSCBSSFSBTNPSBMFTB
MBTOVFWBTGPSNBTEFJOUFSWFODJØOFOMPT
QSPDFTPT CJPMØHJDPT RVF BDBSSFBCBO TF
SJPTCJPQFMJHSPT1FSPOPTFEFCFPMWJEBS
RVFFOMBDPOOPUBDJØORVFIBBMDBO[BEP
MBCJPÏUJDBFOMBBDUVBMJEBEJOUFSWJFOFO
PUSPTGBDUPSFTQPSFKFNQMPFMJOUFSÏTFO
RVFFYJTUBVOPSEFONÈTKVTUPEFEJTUSJ
CVDJØOEFMPTCFOFmDJPTEFMBDJFODJBZ
MBUÏDOJDBw'SFZSF
$BSMPT %FMHBEP FO i)FUFSPHFOFJEBE
TPDJBM FO MB $VCB BDUVBMw BTFHVSB RVF
USFT EF MPT QVOUPT EF SVQUVSB RVF MB
CJPÏUJDBIBJOUSPEVDJEPBMQFOTBNJFOUP
ÏUJDP DPOUFNQPSÈOFP UJFOFO WBMPS NF
UPEPMØHJDP QBSB FM BOÈMJTJT EF MBT EFT
JHVBMEBEFTTPDJBMFT
t
t
-BDPOTJEFSBDJØOEFMBOBUVSBMF[BZ
MBTBCJEVSÓBRVFFNBOBEFTVFTUV
EJPDPNPGVFOUFEFNPSBMJEBE
-BFYJHFODJBEFDPOTJEFSBSJOUFHSB
1FSTQFDUJWBTEFMB#JPÏUJDBFO*CFSPBNÏSJDB
t
EBTMBQFSTQFDUJWBTPDJBMHFOFSBMMB
DPNVOJUBSJBZMBJOEJWJEVBM
-BPSJFOUBDJØOWBMPSBUJWBFOMBCÞT
RVFEB EF FTUBEPT TPDJBMFT TVTUFO
UBCMFT RVF TVQFSFO MPT QSFTVQVFT
UPT QPMÓUJDPT EF MB ÏUJDB DBQJUBMJTUB
%FMHBEP
-BCJPÏUJDBHMPCBMTVTUFOUBCMFSFQSFTFOUB
FOUPODFTMBTÓOUFTJTEFFTUPTQSFTVQVFT
UPTZFOMB[BBMQFOTBNJFOUPCJPÏUJDPDPO
MB FDPMPHÓB QPMÓUJDB FO MB CÞTRVFEB EF
NPEFMPT EF PSHBOJ[BDJØO TPDJBM DPNP
BMUFSOBUJWBBMDBQJUBMJTNPOFPMJCFSBM
&M TJHMP 99* IBCÓB BmSNBEP 1PUUFS
EFCFTFSFMTJHMPEFMBCJPÏUJDBHMPCBMP
EFMPDPOUSBSJPQSFTFODJBSÈFMIPMPDBVT
UPEFMBTFYUBFYUJODJØO1FESP-VÓT4P
UPMPOHPFTPQUJNJTUBFMSFTQFDUPi:RVJ
[ÈTNBSDIBOEPBMPMBSHPEFFTFDBNJOP
FQPDBM BSSJCFNPT B MB UJFSSB QSPNFUJEB
EF VOB WJTJØO IPMÓTUJDB EF MB WJEB IV
NBOBZPUSBT
&OGPRVFJOUFHSBMZHMPCBM
EFMPRVFBUB×FBMBWJEBDVZBNFUÈGPSB
CÈTJDBTFBOPMBEFMBMVDIBZMBDPNQF
UFODJB MB TVQFSWJWFODJB EFM NÈT BQUP
TJOPMBEFMBGSBUFSOJEBEZMBDPPQFSBDJØO
FOUSF MPT TFSFT IVNBOPT FO BSBT EF MB
QSFTFSWBDJØOHMPCBMEFFTBWJEB1BSBFMMP
UBNCJÏOIBSÈGBMUBVOBCJPÏUJDBHMPCBMw
4PUPMPOHP
-BCÞTRVFEBEFVONPEFMPEFTPDJFEBE
TVTUFOUBCMF FT VOP EF MPT QJMBSFT EF MB
DPODFQDJØODVCBOBBDFSDBEFMBCJPÏUJ
DB HMPCBM JEFBM RVF TØMP FT QPTJCMF FO
VOFOUPSOPEFSFTQPOTBCJMJEBETPMJEBSJB
FKFSDJEBDPODFSUBEBNFOUFEFTEFUPEBMB
TPDJFEBE FM &TUBEP Z MB TPDJFEBE DJWJM
IBDJBEFOUSPZGVFSBEFMBTGSPOUFSBTOB
PERSPETIVADELABIOETICAINDD
DJPOBMFT IBDJFOEP WBMFS DPNP CSÞKVMB
MB NÈYJNB NBSUJBOB EF RVF i1BUSJB FT
IVNBOJEBEwUSBTNVUBEBUBMWF[FORVF
i1BUSJBFTMBCJPTGFSBwQPSMBDVBMZFOMB
DVBMMBIVNBOJEBEFYJTUF
-BCJPÏUJDBDPNPOVFWPTBCFS
{ÏUJDBBQMJDBEBPNFUBÏUJDB
-BJOUSPEVDDJØOEFMPTOVFWPTSFGFSFOUFT
EFMBCJPÏUJDBPSJHJOØVOBQSJNFSBMÓOFB
EFEFCBUFOBDJPOBMDFOUSBEBFOMBWBMJ
EF[EFTVEJTDVSTPQBSBMBTDPOEJDJPOFT
PCKFUJWBTZTVCKFUJWBTEFVOB$VCBRVF
FOMPTB×PTFTUBCBJONFSTBFOQSP
GVOEPT DBNCJPT FDPOØNJDPT Z TPDJBMFT
FODBNJOBEPT B MPHSBS MB TVQFSWJWFODJB
EFM QSPZFDUP TPDJBM SFWPMVDJPOBSJP 1Ï
SF['MPSFT4JOHIZ1BSFEFT
'JOBMNFOUF IB QSFWBMFDJEP VOB
UFOEFODJBNBZPSJUBSJBEFBVUPSFTDVCB
OPTRVFSFDPOPDJFSPOFMTJHOPQPTJUJWP
EFMBCJPÏUJDBBQFTBSEFVOBQBSUJEBEF
OBDJNJFOUP SVCSJDBEB FO VO DPOUFYUP
DFOUSBM EF DVMUVSB BOHMPTBKPOB Z FDP
OPNÓB DBQJUBMJTUB MJCFSBM DBSBDUFSÓTUJDBT
RVFSFRVFSÓBOTFSSFDSFBEBTEFTEFOVFT
USBJEFOUJEBE
&M SFDPOPDJNJFOUP EFmOJUJWP EF MB WB
MJEF[ EF MB CJPÏUJDB QBSB $VCB QSPWJOP
EFM DVSTP UFMFWJTJWP i²UJDB Z TPDJFEBEw
USBTNJUJEPFOQPSMBTFNJTPSBTEF
BMDBODFOBDJPOBMEFOUSPEFMQSPHSBNBEF
DVSTPT i6OJWFSTJEBE QBSB UPEPTw &O FM
UBCMPJEFEFBQPZPCJCMJPHSÈmDPFMBCPSB
EPQPS/BODZ-$IBDØO"SUFBHBZRVF
DJSDVMØ QSPGVTBNFOUF FO UPEP FM QBÓT
TFDPOTJHOBMPTJHVJFOUFi-BCJPÏUJDBTF
FTUÈDPOWJSUJFOEPFOVOJEJPNBVOJWFS
TBMEFEJNFOTJPOFTÏUJDBTSFMFWBOUFT&O
#JPÏUJDBFO$VCBSFTQPOTBCJMJEBEZTPMJEBSJEBE+PTÏ3BNØO"DPTUB4BSJFHP
TVFNQF×PEFSFTBMUBSFMQBQFMCFOÏmDP
RVFEFCFEFTFNQF×BSMBDJFODJBQBSBFM
CJFOFTUBSEFMBIVNBOJEBEPGSFDFTPMV
DJPOFT JOUFSEJTDJQMJOBSJBT Z TF PQPOF BM
JSSFTQFUP B MB DPSSVQDJØO Z B DVBMRVJFS
JOUFOUP EJTDSJNJOBUPSJP RVF BGFDUF B MB
IVNBOJEBEBMBEJHOJEBEEFMTFSIVNB
OPZSFQFSDVUBOFGBTUBNFOUFFOFMNFEJP
BNCJFOUF&OFTUBQFSTQFDUJWBDPOTUJUV
ZFVOBOFDFTJEBERVFMBCJPÏUJDBMMFHVF
BUPEPTMPTDJVEBEBOPTDPNPVOOVFWP
TBCFS1BSBFMMPFTJNQSFTDJOEJCMFFEVDBS
BMBQPCMBDJØOTPCSFTVTQSJODJQJPTGVO
EBNFOUBMFTFOMBFTGFSBEFMBFEVDBDJØO
ZTVTEFSFDIPTDPNPTVKFUPTQPUFODJBMFT
EFJOWFTUJHBDJØOFOUPEPTMPTDBNQPTEFM
TBCFSwWBSJPTBVUPSFT
"QFTBSEFMSFDPOPDJNJFOUPEFMBMFHJUJ
NJEBEEFMBCJPÏUJDBDPNPEJTDJQMJOBFO
FMDPOUFYUPDVCBOPMBEJTDVTJØOUFØSJDB
TPCSF TV MVHBS EFOUSP EF MB FTUSVDUVSB
EF MB ÏUJDB OP FT VO BTVOUP DPODMVJEP
1SFTUJHJPTBT QFSTPOBMJEBEFT EF FTUVEJPT
ÏUJDPTDPNP-VÓT-ØQF[#PNCJOPDPO
TJEFSBO RVF DPOmHVSB DPNP VOB ÏUJDB
BQMJDBEB B MPT QSPCMFNBT Z DPOnJDUPT
EFWBMPSFTNPSBMFTQSFTFOUFTFOMPTVTPT
UFDOPMØHJDPT EFM TBCFS DJFOUÓmDP Z TV
JNQBDUPFOMBDVMUVSBZMBTPDJFEBEDPO
UFNQPSÈOFB4JOFNCBSHPɨBMÓB'VOH
FOUJFOEF RVF iyFM TBCFS CJPÏUJDP FTUÈ
FOQMFOBDPOTUSVDDJØOy
VOPEFTVT
FMFNFOUPT DBSBDUFSÓTUJDPT FT DPOPDFS MB
WJODVMBDJØOFOUSFMBDPODFQDJØOZMBJOT
USVNFOUBDJØOFOMPDVBMTFEJGFSFODJBEF
HSBOQBSUFEFMBmMPTPGÓBDPOUFNQPSÈOFB
4VDBSÈDUFSHMPCBMZMPDBMMPFNQBSFOUBO
EF NPEP DFSDBOP DPO FM iBNCJFOUFw Z
QBEFDF EF MBT NJTNBT EJmDVMUBEFT PQF
PERSPETIVADELABIOETICAINDD
SBDJPOBMFTRVFBRVFKBOBFTUFÞMUJNPB
MBWF[RVFDPOKVHBUBNCJÏODPNPÏMMP
UFØSJDP Z MP FNQÓSJDP MP BCTPMVUP Z MP
DPOUBNJOBEP DPO DJFODJBT EJWFSTBT MB
DJSDVMBSJEBEEFTVTDPODFQUPTZTVQBQFM
NFEJBUPSJP UBOUP IPSJ[POUBM DPNP EF
NPEPWFSUJDBM
&TUF UJQP EF TBCFS FOHMPCB OP TØMP MPT
GFOØNFOPT FTQFDÓmDPT EF MB WJEB TJOP
UBNCJÏO TV JOUFSSFMBDJØO DPO MPT DPN
QPOFOUFT OP PSHÈOJDPT -VFHP EF
IFDIP TF IBDF QSFTFOUF FO UPEB MB SF
nFYJØO DJFOUÓmDB Z USBTDJFOEF BM DBSÈD
UFSOPSNBUJWPQFSPOPQVFEFFYDMVJSMP
&OUPODFTFOFTUBSFEBNBMHBNB{EØOEF
FODPOUSBSÓBNPTTVJEFOUJEBETVTUBOUJWB
ZNFUPEPMØHJDB &OMBUPUBMJEBE&OFMMP
TF EJGFSFODJB EF MB HFOFSBMJ[BDJØO mMP
TØmDB QSPQJBNFOUF EJDIB QFSP SFDPSSF
MB TVCKFUJWJEBE Z MB OBUVSBMF[B TJO RVF
QPEBNPT EBSMF QSJPSJEBE B OJOHVOB
EF MBT EPT QPSRVF BNCBT DPOTUJUVZFO
MP VOP DPO VOB QSFFNJOFODJB EJWFSTB
DPOUFYUVBMJ[BEB QPS FM EFWFOJSw 'VOH
&OVOBEFTVTPCSBTNÈTSFDJFOUFToi)B
DJBVOOVFWPTBCFS-BCJPÏUJDBFOMBSF
WPMVDJØODPOUFNQPSÈOFBEFMTBCFSwBÞO
FO QSFOTBo $BSMPT %FMHBEP SFBMJ[B VO
BOÈMJTJT MØHJDP IJTUØSJDP EFM EFTBSSPMMP
EFMBCJPÏUJDBDPNPEJTDJQMJOBEFTEFTV
EPCMF BMVNCSBNJFOUP DPNP CJPÏUJDB
NÏEJDB Z CJPÏUJDB HMPCBM Z QSPGVOEJ[B
FO RVF MP EJTUJOUJWP EF FMMB DPNP UFP
SÓBZBQMJDBDJØOÏUJDBFTIBCFSTFDPOTUJ
UVJEP FO VO OVFWP UJQP EF TBCFS i-B
CJPÏUJDBHMPCBMDPNQMFUBMBJOUFHSBDJØO
EFMOVFWPTBCFSZMBSVQUVSBDPOMBSB
1FSTQFDUJWBTEFMB#JPÏUJDBFO*CFSPBNÏSJDB
DJPOBMJEBEDMÈTJDBSFBMJ[BEBEFDPOKVOUP
FO MB FQJTUFNPMPHÓB EF TFHVOEP PSEFO
FM QFOTBNJFOUP EF MB DPNQMFKJEBE Z FM
IPMJTNP BNCJFOUBMJTUB y
&O mO MB
TVQFSBDJØOEFMBTOPDJPOFTUSBEJDJPOBMFT
EF TVQFSJPSJEBE IVNBOB CBTBEBT FO FM
DPOPDJNJFOUP DJFOUÓmDP FM SFTDBUF EFM
IPNCSFDPNPQFSTPOBZMBJOUFHSBDJØO
EFTVNVOEPTPDJBMZOBUVSBMw%FMHB
EP
$PODMVTJØO
-BCJPÏUJDBDPNPEJTDJQMJOBJSSVNQJØFO
$VCBJOJDJBMNFOUFDPNPÏUJDBCJPNÏEJ
DBZFOTVEFTBSSPMMPIBMPHSBEPDPOmHV
SBSVONPEFMPEFSFMBDJØOTBOJUBSJBCB
TBEPFOMBSFTQPOTBCJMJEBEMBDPOmBO[B
ZMBTPMJEBSJEBEDPOBQPSUFTDPODSFUPTB
MBUFPSÓBEFMDPOTFOUJNJFOUPJOGPSNBEP
MBEFmOJDJØOEFNVFSUFZMBDBMJEBEEF
WJEBDPNPDVFTUJØOÏUJDB
%VSBOUF MB ÞMUJNB EÏDBEB MB BDFQDJØO
EF MB EJTDJQMJOB DPNP CJPÏUJDB HMPCBM
TVTUFOUBCMFIBSFQVOUBEPDPOUBMGVFS[B
RVFTFIBJEPFRVJQBSBOEPFODVBOUPB
QSPEVDDJØODJFOUÓmDBDPOMBCJPNÏEJDB
6O QSPEVDUP EF FTUF FTGVFS[P JOUFMFD
UVBM IB TJEP TV DPNQSFOTJØO DPNP VO
OVFWPUJQPEFTBCFSRVFUSBTDFOEJFOEP
MPTFTUBODPTMFHBEPTQPSMBSBDJPOBMJEBE
NPEFSOB SFDPODJMJB BM IPNCSF DPO MB
OBUVSBMF[B -B OFDFTJEBE EF VO QVOUP
EF QBSUJEB RVF TF DPSSFTQPOEB DPO MB
QSPCMFNÈUJDBBNCJFOUBMHMPCBMIBDPOT
UJUVJEPBMBSFTQPOTBCJMJEBEZMBTPMJEBSJ
EBEDPNPTVTQSJODJQJPTSFDUPSFTZHVÓBT
EFFTUBCJPÏUJDBHMPCBMBMBDVCBOBDPN
QSPNFUJEB DPO VOB BDDJØO CJPQPMÓUJDB
FODBNJOBEB BM VTP SBDJPOBM Z FRVJUBUJ
WPEFMPTCJFOFTDPNVOFTFOFMNBSDP
EFVOBTPDJFEBETVTUFOUBCMFZVOPSEFO
NVOEJBMKVTUP
3FGFSFODJBT
"DPTUB + 3 #JPÏUJDB DJWJMJ[BDJØO Z EFTBSSPMMP TPTUFOJCMF &O %FMHBEP $+
0SH
$VCBWFSEF&OCVTDBEFVONPEFMPQBSBMBTVTUFOUBCJMJEBE1SJNFSB&EJDJØO
-B)BCBOB&EJUPSJBM+PTÏ.BSUÓ$PMFDDJØO5JFSSBZ&TQBDJPQQ
"DPTUB+3"
-PTPSHBOJTNPTNPEJGJDBEPTHFOÏUJDBNFOUF&MQPEFSCMBOEPEFM
5FSDFS.JMFOJP3FWJTUB#JPUFDOPMPHÓB"QMJDBEB/&TQFDJBM
QQ&&
"DPTUB +3 Z (PO[ÈMF[ .$ &M FTDFOBSJP QPTUNPEFSOP EF MB CJPÏUJDB &O
"DPTUB +3 &EJUPS DJFOUÓGJDP
#JPÏUJDB %FTEF VOB QFSTQFDUJWB DVCBOB 1SJNFSB
&EJDJØO-B)BCBOB1VCMJDBDJPOFT"DVBSJP$FOUSP'ÏMJY7BSFMBQQ
"MPOTP%7PO4NJUI73BNÓSF["Z0SUFHB"
²UJDBZ%FPOUPMPHÓB.ÏEJDB
UFYUP CÈTJDP FEJDJØO QSPWJTJPOBM
-B )BCBOB .JOJTUFSJP EF 4BMVE 1ÞCMJDB
$PMFDDJØOEFM&TUVEJBOUFEF.FEJDJOB
"SBVKP 3 )BDJB VOB CJPÏUJDB MBUJOPBNFSJDBOB &O "DPTUB +3 &EJUPS
DJFOUÓGJDP
#JPÏUJDB %FTEF VOB QFSTQFDUJWB DVCBOB 1SJNFSB &EJDJØO -B )BCBOB
1VCMJDBDJPOFT"DVBSJP$FOUSP'ÏMJY7BSFMBQQ
#FDB+10SH
²UJDBEFMB*OWFTUJHBDJØO$JFOUÓGJDB5FSDFS5BMMFS*OUFSOBDJPOBM
EFM1SPHSBNB3FHJPOBMEF#JPÏUJDB0140.4OPWJFNCSFEF-B)BCBOB
4BOUJBHP EF $IJMF &EJDJPOFT EFM 1SPHSBNB 3FHJPOBM EF #JPÏUJDB 0140.4
QQ
PERSPETIVADELABIOETICAINDD
#JPÏUJDBFO$VCBSFTQPOTBCJMJEBEZTPMJEBSJEBE+PTÏ3BNØO"DPTUB4BSJFHP
#PSSPUP 3 /Þ×F[ EF 7JMMBWJDFODJP ' Z .BSUÓOF[ ) 3FQFSDVTJØO EF MB
SFWPMVDJØODJFOUÓGJDPUÏDOJDBTPCSFFMQSPDFTPTBMVEFOGFSNFEBEZMBPSHBOJ[BDJØO
EF MB TBMVE QÞCMJDB &O 7BSJPT "VUPSFT 5FNBT EF ²UJDB .ÏEJDB * -B )BCBOB
%FQBSUBNFOUPEF1TJDPMPHÓB*OTUJUVUPEF$JFODJBT#ÈTJDBTZ1SFDMÓOJDBTi7JDUPSJB
EF(JSØOw.JOJTUFSJPEF4BMVE1ÞCMJDBQQ
#PSSPUP 3 Z "OFJSPT3JCB 3 -B DPNVOJDBDJØO IVNBOB Z MB DBMJEBE EF MB
BUFODJØONÏEJDB&O"DPTUB+3&EJUPSDJFOUÓGJDP
#JPÏUJDB%FTEFVOBQFSTQFDUJWB
DVCBOB1SJNFSB&EJDJØO-B)BCBOB1VCMJDBDJPOFT"DVBSJP$FOUSP'ÏMJY7BSFMB
QQ
%F"SNBT"
&OUPSOPBMBPSJFOUBDJØOGJMPTØGJDBEFMBCJPÏUJDB3FWJTUB$VCBOB
EF$JFODJBT4PDJBMFT
FOFSPBCSJMQQ
%F-B5PSSF&-ØQF[$.ÈSRVF[.FUBM
4BMVEQBSBUPEPTTÓFTQPTJCMF
1SJNFSB &EJDJØO -B )BCBOB 4PDJFEBE $VCBOB EF 4BMVE 1ÞCMJDB 4FDDJØO EF
.FEJDJOB4PDJBM
%FMHBEP ( 3BÓDFT IJTUØSJDBT EFM QFOTBNJFOUP CJPÏUJDP Z EF MB JOWFTUJHBDJØO
NÏEJDBFOTVKFUPTIVNBOPTFO$VCB&O"DPTUB+3#JPÏUJDB%FTEFVOBQFSTQFDUJWB
DVCBOB1SJNFSB&EJDJØO-B)BCBOB1VCMJDBDJPOFT"DVBSJP$FOUSP'ÏMJY7BSFMB
QQ
%FMHBEP $+ $PHOJDJØO QSPCMFNB BNCJFOUBM Z CJPÏUJDB &O "DPTUB +3
&EJUPSDJFOUÓGJDP
#JPÏUJDBQBSBMBTVTUFOUBCJMJEBE-B)BCBOB1SJNFSB&EJDJØO
1VCMJDBDJPOFT"DVBSJP$FOUSP'ÏMJY7BSFMBQQ
%FMHBEP $+ #JPÏUJDB EFTJHVBMEBE Z QPMÓUJDB &O *×JHVF[ - Z 1ÏSF[ 0&
0SHT
)FUFSPHFOFJEBETPDJBMFOMB$VCBBDUVBM-B)BCBOB$FOUSPEF&TUVEJPTEF
4BMVEZ#JFOFTUBS)VNBOPT6OJWFSTJEBEEF-B)BCBOBQQ
%FMHBEP$+
)BDJBVOOVFWPTBCFS-BCJPÏUJDBFOMBSFWPMVDJØODPOUFNQPSÈOFB
EFMTBCFS1SFNJPi&MFOB(JMi
-B)BCBOB1VCMJDBDJPOFT"DVBSJP$FOUSP
'ÏMJY7BSFMB
'SFZSF&
-BCJPÏUJDBFOGPRVFJNQSFTDJOEJCMF&O-ØQF[#PNCJOP-3%F
"SNBT"Z1PSUP.&0SHT
1PSVOBOVFWBÏUJDB1SJNFSB&EJDJØO-B)BCBOB
&EJUPSJBM'ÏMJY7BSFMBQQ
'VOH 5 -B CJPÏUJDB {VO OVFWP TBCFS &O "DPTUB +3 &EJUPS DJFOUÓGJDP
#JPÏUJDBQBSBMBTVTUFOUBCJMJEBE1SJNFSB&EJDJØO-B)BCBOB1VCMJDBDJPOFT"DVBSJP
$FOUSP'ÏMJY7BSFMBQQ
(PO[ÈMF[3
-BOVFWBEJNFOTJØOEFMBSFMBDJØONÏEJDPQBDJFOUFFOOVFTUSPTEÓBT
&O"DPTUB+3&EJUPSDJFOUÓGJDP
#JPÏUJDB%FTEFVOBQFSTQFDUJWBDVCBOB1SJNFSB
&EJDJØO-B)BCBOB1VCMJDBDJPOFT"DVBSJP$FOUSP'ÏMJY7BSFMBQQ
(PO[ÈMF[6(SBV+Z"NBSJMMP."
-BDBMJEBEEFWJEBDPNPVOQSPCMFNB
EFMBCJPÏUJDB&O"DPTUB+3&EJUPSDJFOUÓGJDP
#JPÏUJDB%FTEFVOBQFSTQFDUJWB
DVCBOB1SJNFSB&EJDJØO-B)BCBOB1VCMJDBDJPOFT"DVBSJP$FOUSP'ÏMJY7BSFMB
QQ
-ØQF[ #PNCJOP -3 ²UJDB DJFODJB Z SFTQPOTBCJMJEBE &O -ØQF[ #PNCJOP
-3$PNQ
&MTBCFSÏUJDPEFBZFSBIPZ5PNP**1SJNFSB&EJDJØO-B)BCBOB
&EJUPSJBM'ÏMJY7BSFMB
PERSPETIVADELABIOETICAINDD
1FSTQFDUJWBTEFMB#JPÏUJDBFO*CFSPBNÏSJDB
.BSUÓOF[ " 1SPZFDUPT QBSB VOB CJPÏUJDB HMPCBM &O "DPTUB +3 &EJUPS
DJFOUÓGJDP
#JPÏUJDB QBSB MB TVTUFOUBCJMJEBE 1SJNFSB &EJDJØO -B )BCBOB
1VCMJDBDJPOFT"DVBSJP$FOUSP'ÏMJY7BSFMBQQ
/Þ×F[EF7JMMBWJDFODJP'
#JPÏUJDBFMNÏEJDPVOFEVDBEPS&O"DPTUB+3
&EJUPS DJFOUÓGJDP
#JPÏUJDB %FTEF VOB QFSTQFDUJWB DVCBOB 1SJNFSB &EJDJØO -B
)BCBOB1VCMJDBDJPOFT"DVBSJP$FOUSP'ÏMJY7BSFMBQQ
1ÏSF[ . 'MPSFT +- 4JOHI $ Z 1BSFEFT ( ²UJDB NÏEJDB Z CJPÏUJDB &O
7BSJPTBVUPSFT-FDUVSBTEFGJMPTPGÓBTBMVEZTPDJFEBE1SJNFSB&EJDJØO-B)BCBOB
&EJUPSJBMEF$JFODJBT.ÏEJDBTQQ
1SJODJQJPTEFMB²UJDB.ÏEJDB
-B)BCBOB&EJUPSB1PMÓUJDB
3BNÓSF["Z)FSSFSB3
1SPCMFNBTÏUJDPTFOFMEFTBSSPMMPEFMBCJPMPHÓBZMB
NFEJDJOBDPOUFNQPSÈOFBT&O7BSJPTBVUPSFT1SPCMFNBTGJMPTØGJDPTEFMBNFEJDJOB
$PMPRVJP 5PNP * -B )BCBOB *OTUJUVUP 4VQFSJPS EF $JFODJBT .ÏEJDBT EF -B
)BCBOBQQ
4PUPMPOHP 1- -B CJPÏUJDB DPNP VOB EJTDJQMJOB DSÓUJDB &O "DPTUB +3
&EJUPSDJFOUÓGJDP
#JPÏUJDBQBSBMBTVTUFOUBCJMJEBE1SJNFSB&EJDJØO-B)BCBOB
1VCMJDBDJPOFT"DVBSJP$FOUSP'ÏMJY7BSFMBQQ
5PSSFT 3 (MPTBSJP EF CJPÏUJDB 1SJNFSB &EJDJØO -B )BCBOB 1VCMJDBDJPOFT
"DVBSJP$FOUSP'ÏMJY7BSFMB
77 "" ²UJDB Z TPDJFEBE 5BCMPJEF EFM DVSTP i6OJWFSTJEBE QBSB 5PEPTw -B
)BCBOB&EJUBEPQPS+VWFOUVE3FCFMEF
7PO 4NJUI 7 -B ÏUJDB DMÓOJDB &O "DPTUB +3 &EJUPS DJFOUÓGJDP
#JPÏUJDB
%FTEFVOBQFSTQFDUJWBDVCBOB1SJNFSB&EJDJØO-B)BCBOB1VCMJDBDJPOFT"DVBSJP
$FOUSP'ÏMJY7BSFMBQQ
PERSPETIVADELABIOETICAINDD
%JOBNJTNPEFMEJÈMPHPCJPÏUJDPFO&TQB×B
'SBODFTD"CFM4+Z/VSJB5FSSJCBT
*OUSPEVDDJØO
&
YQPOFNPTFMOBDJNJFOUPZEFTBSSPMMP
EFMBCJPÏUJDBFO&TQB×BEJTUJOHVJFO
EP USFT QFSÓPEPT VOP RVF TF FYUJFOEF
EFTEF B×P FO RVF GVOEBNPT FM
*OTUJUVUP#PSKBEF#JPÏUJDBFO4BOU$V
HBUEFM7BMMÒT#BSDFMPOB
FMQSJNFSPFO
&VSPQB
IBTUBDVBOEPDPODMVZFFM
UFSDFSFODVFOUSPEFM(SVQP*OUFSOBDJP
OBMEF&TUVEJPTEF#JPÏUJDBEFMB'FEF
SBDJØO *OUFSOBDJPOBM EF 6OJWFSTJEBEFT
$BUØMJDBT '*6$ *'$6
PSHBOJ[BEP
UBNCJÏOFO4BOU$VHBUDPOBNQMJBSF
QFSDVTJØO FO EJGFSFOUFT VOJWFSTJEBEFT
FTQB×PMBT
&M TFHVOEP BCBSDB EFTEF IBTUB
mOFTEF4POB×PTEFFYQBOTJØO
NBEVSBDJØOZDPOTPMJEBDJØOEFMBCJP
ÏUJDBFO&TQB×BZEFHSBOQSPGVTJØOMF
HJTMBUJWB FO SFMBDJØO DPO MPT QSPHSFTPT
NÏEJDPCJPMØHJDPT Z TV VUJMJ[BDJØO &T
UBNCJÏOFMNPNFOUPFORVFKVSJTUBTZ
mMØTPGPTDPNJFO[BOBJOUFSFTBSTFQPSMPT
EFCBUFTCJPÏUJDPT"QBSUJSEFMBT
EJWFSTBTFTDVFMBTZPSJFOUBDJPOFTCJPÏUJ
DBTFO&TQB×BDPNJFO[BOBEFmOJSTFZ
EJTUBODJBSTFDMBSBNFOUFFOTVTBDUJUVEFT
BOUF MB ÏUJDB Z MB MFHJTMBDJØO FOUSF VOB
ÏUJDBEFDPOWJDDJPOFTZVOBÏUJDBMBJDB
PERSPETIVADELABIOETICAINDD
&M UFSDFS QFSÓPEP TF FYUJFOEF EFTEF FM
IBTUBIPZ1PESÓBNPTEFOPNJOBS
MPEFSFWJTJØOQSPZFDDJØOFJOUFHSBDJØO
DPO QMBOUFBNJFOUPT NVZ QPMBSJ[BEPT
QPS MBT EJGFSFOUFT UFOEFODJBT QPMÓUJDBT
GVFSUFNFOUF DPOEJDJPOBEP QPS MPT GBD
UPSFT DJFOUÓmDPUÏDOJDPT FDPOØNJDPT Z
ÏUJDPSFMJHJPTPT &O DPOKVOUP VOB TJ
UVBDJØO EF NBZPS DPNQMFKJEBE RVF MB
EFMQFSÓPEPBOUFSJPSDPOVOBFTQFSBO[B
JMJNJUBEB FO MPT QSPHSFTPT DJFOUÓmDPT Z
UFDOPMØHJDPT
*OTUJUVUP#PSKBEF#JPÏUJDB
*##
4F GVOEØ FO QPS JOJDJBUJWB EF TV
BDUVBMQSFTJEFOUF'SBODFTD"CFMBMSF
HSFTP EF VOB FTUBEÓB EF DJODP B×PT FO
&TUBEPT 6OJEPT %FTEF FTF NPNFOUP
UVWPMBQPTJCJMJEBEEFBQPSUBSMPTDPOP
DJNJFOUPTZFYQFSJFODJBBERVJSJEPTDPO
FMUSBCBKPEFBMHPNÈTEFUSFTB×PTFOTV
UFTJT EPDUPSBM TPCSF mTJPMPHÓB GFUPQMB
DFOUBSJBEJSJHJEBQPS"OESÏ)FMMFHFST
)FMMFHFST " $JFOUÓmDP FYDFQ
DJPOBM QSPGFTPS EF 0CTUFUSJDJB Z (JOFDPMPHÓB
FO MB 6OJWFSTJEBE EF (FPSHFUPXO 8BTIJOH
UPO%$EPOEFGVOEBFODPOFMBQPZP
EF MB 'VOEBDJØO ,FOOFEZ FM BDUVBM ,FOOFEZ
*OTUJUVUFPG&UIJDT
1FSTQFDUJWBTEFMB#JPÏUJDBFO*CFSPBNÏSJDB
"MMÓWJWJØMBFYQFSJFODJBEFMOBDJNJFOUP
EFMPTEPTQSJNFSPTDFOUSPTEFCJPÏUJDB
EFMNVOEPFM,FOOFEZ*OTUJUVUF,*
Z
FM )BTUJOHT $FOUFS 3FHSFTØ B &TQB×B
DPO MB mSNF EFUFSNJOBDJØO EF JOJDJBS
VO*OTUJUVUPEF#JPÏUJDBMPNÈTQBSFDJEP
QPTJCMF BM NPEFMP RVF IBCÓB DPOPDJEP
FO &TUBEPT 6OJEPT DPO MBT BEBQUBDJP
OFTDPOWFOJFOUFTZHVJBEPQPSUSFTPCKF
UJWPTPQFSBUJWPT
DSFBSVOBCJCMJPUFDB
FTQFDJBMJ[BEB FO CJPÏUJDB DPNFO[BS
BJOTUJUVJSFMEJÈMPHPCJPÏUJDPFOIPTQJ
UBMFTDSFBOEPDPNJUÏTEFCJPÏUJDBZ
DPOTFHVJS MB JOEFQFOEFODJB JOTUJUVDJP
OBMGSFOUFBJOTUJUVDJPOFTFDMFTJÈTUJDBTZ
DJWJMFT5PEPTFTUPTQSPQØTJUPTIBOTJEP
MPHSBEPT HSBEVBMNFOUF %FTEF FM *## FTUÈ JOUFHSBEP DPNP JOTUJUVUP
VOJWFSTJUBSJPFOMB6OJWFSTJEBE3BNØO
-MVMMEF#BSDFMPOB
4J CJFO MPT JOJDJPT GVFSPO EJGÓDJMFT QPS
GBMUBEFNFEJPTUFOÓBNPTMBGVFSUFDPO
WJDDJØO EF RVF FM NFOTBKF TPCSF MB GF
DVOEJEBE EFM EJÈMPHP CJPÏUJDP oFOUSF
MBT DJFODJBT EF MB TBMVE Z MB ÏUJDBo FSB
OFDFTBSJPZVSHFOUF&TUPSFRVFSÓBBOUF
UPEP JOUSPEVDJS FM UÏSNJOP iCJPÏUJDBw
FOMBTPDJFEBEZFYQMJDBSFMDPODFQUPZ
SFRVJTJUPTEFFTFEJÈMPHP
&O &TQB×B FM UÏSNJOP iCJPÏUJDBw RVF
FNQF[BNPTBVUJMJ[BSFOGVFBDFQ
UBEPGÈDJMNFOUFQPSEJGFSFOUFTSB[POFT
QPSRVF TF EJTUBODJBCB EF MB QFSDFQ
%BOJFM $BMMBIBO mMØTPGP EPDUPSBEP FO )BS
WBSEZ8JMMJBSE(BZMJOQSPGFTPSEF1TJRVJBUSÓB
FOMB'BDVMUBEEF.FEJDJOBEFMB6OJWFSTJEBEEF
$PMVNCJB/VFWB:PSL
EFDJEJFSPODPNFO[BS
FOFM*OTUJUVUFPG4PDJFUZ&UIJDTBOEUIF-JGF
4DJFODF NÈT DPOPDJEP DPNP )BTUJOHT $FOUFS
PERSPETIVADELABIOETICAINDD
DJØO EF VOB ÏUJDB SFMJHJPTB OFHBUJWB
BVUPSJUBSJBZEPHNÈUJDBNVZDPOEJDJP
OBEBQPSMBFTUSFDIBWJODVMBDJØOFOUSFMB
KFSBSRVÓBEFMB*HMFTJB$BUØMJDBZFM&TUB
EP
QPSFMDMJNBTPDJPQPMÓUJDPEFVOB
&TQB×B FO USBOTJDJØO EFTEF MB NVFSUF
EF'SBODJTDP'SBODPFOIBTUBMB
BQSPCBDJØOFOMBT$PSUFTFTQB×PMBTEFMB
$POTUJUVDJØOEFDPOMBRVFTFJOJ
DJBMBEFNPDSBDJBZTVBQSFOEJ[BKFZ
FMDMJNBJOUFMFDUVBMRVFTFSFTQJSBCBFO
MBTVOJWFSTJEBEFTFODPODSFUPFOMPRVF
DPODJFSOFBMB$PNQB×ÓBEF+FTÞTNVZ
QSFQBSBEB QBSB FM EJÈMPHP JOUFSEJTDJQMJ
OBS Z DPO VOB HSBO DPODFOUSBDJØO EF
QSPGFTPSFTVOJWFSTJUBSJPTKFTVJUBTGPSNB
EPTFOVOJWFSTJEBEFTJOHMFTBTGSBODFTBT
CFMHBTBMFNBOBTJUBMJBOBTZBNFSJDBOBT
&M*##TFDSFBDBTJTJNVMUÈOFBNFOUFDPO
PUSBTEPTJOTUJUVDJPOFTJOJDJBEBTQPSKF
TVJUBTKVOUPDPOVOFOUPSOPEFQSPGFTP
SFTVOJWFSTJUBSJPT$SJTUJBOJTNPZ+VTUJ
DJB$+
Z"TPDJBDJØO*OUFSEJTDJQMJOBS
+PTÏEF"DPTUB"4*/+"
'VOEBEPZSFDPOPDJEPBMNJTNPUJFNQPRVFFM
*##&M1*HOBDJP4BMWBUNFEJØFOMBBQSPCB
DJØOEFBNCPTFTUBUVUPT$+QVCMJDBNFO
TVBMNFOUFVODVBEFSOPTPCSFUFNBTQPMÏNJDPT
EFBDUVBMJEBE)BTUBFMNPNFOUPTFIBOQVCMJ
DBEPUÓUVMPT
-B "TPDJBDJØO *OUFSEJTDJQMJOBS +PTÏ EF "DPT
UBGVFGVOEBEBZEJSJHJEBFOQPS"MCFSU
%PV DPOUJOVBOEP FM USBCBKP RVF SFBMJ[BCB
EFTEFMB$PNJTJØOEF1SPGFTPSFT6OJWFS
TJUBSJPT $013*
DPOTUJUVJEB FO TVT PSÓHFOFT
QSJODJQBMNFOUFQPSKFTVJUBT)BTUBFMNPNFOUP
TFIBOFEJUBEPWPMÞNFOFTQPSWBSJPTBVUPSFT
FTQFDJBMJTUBTFOMBTSFTQFDUJWBTNBUFSJBT-PTÞM
UJNPTUÓUVMPTTPOi&MQFOTBNJFOUPBMUFSOBUJWP
/VFWB WJTJØO TPCSF FM IPNCSF Z MB OBUVSBMF
[Bw i/VFWBT UFDOPMPHÓBT Z GVUVSP EFM
IPNCSFw i#JPÏUJDB MB DVFTUJØO EF MB
EJHOJEBEw
i*OWFTUJHBDJØOEFTBSSPMMPF
JOOPWBDJØODVFTUJPOFTÏUJDBTw
i*EFPMP
HÓBTDPOnJDUPTZUFOTJPOFTw
%JOBNJTNPEFMEJÈMPHPCJPÏUJDPFO&TQB×B'SBODFTD"CFM4+Z/VSJB5FSSJCBT
-BEFmOJDJØOEFCJPÏUJDBRVFFM*OTUJUVUP
BEPQUØGVFMBRVFDPOTUBFOMB&ODJDMP
QFEJBEF#JPÏUJDBi&TUVEJPTJTUFNÈUJDP
EFMBDPOEVDUBIVNBOBFOFMÈNCJUPEF
MBT DJFODJBT EF MB WJEB Z EF MB BUFODJØO
BMBTBMVEFYBNJOBOEPFTUBDPOEVDUBB
MBMV[EFMPTWBMPSFTZEFMPTQSJODJQJPT
NPSBMFTw 3FJDI 4JO FNCBSHP
FO TV EÓB QFOTÈCBNPT RVF QPEÓBNPT
FOSJRVFDFS FTUB EFmOJDJØO TF×BMBOEP
RVFFMEJÈMPHPEFCFQSPEVDJSTFFOUSFMBT
DJFODJBTZMBTIVNBOJEBEFTi-BCJPÏUJDB
FTFMFTUVEJPJOUFSEJTDJQMJOBSUSBOTEJTDJ
QMJOBS
PSJFOUBEPBMBUPNBEFEFDJTJPOFT
ÏUJDBTEFMPTQSPCMFNBTQMBOUFBEPTBMPT
EJGFSFOUFT TJTUFNBT ÏUJDPT QPS MPT QSP
HSFTPT NÏEJDPT Z CJPMØHJDPT FO FM ÈN
CJUPNJDSPTPDJBMZNBDSPTPDJBMNJDSPZ
NBDSPFDPOØNJDPZTVSFQFSDVTJØOFOMB
TPDJFEBEZTVTJTUFNBEFWBMPSFTUBOUP
FOFMNPNFOUPQSFTFOUFDPNPFOFMGV
UVSPw"CFM
&TUB EFmOJDJØO UJFOF MB WFOUBKB EF FO
USPODBSDPOMBJEFBEFMPTQSJNFSPTJOT
UJUVUPTZDPOMPTQSPCMFNBTEFMRVFIBDFS
CJPÏUJDPRVFEFTEFEJTPDJBMBCJP
ÏUJDBDMÓOJDBEFMBHMPCBMQPSJOJDJBUJWB
EF7BO3FOTTFMBFS1PUUFS
&OFTFB×P1PUUFSNVZNPMFTUPQPSMB
PSJFOUBDJØO DMÓOJDB EF MB CJPÏUJDB EFTB
SSPMMBEB FO FM ,* BDV×Ø FM UÏSNJOP EF
iCJPÏUJDBHMPCBMwQBSBTVCSBZBSTVJOUF
SÏTFOFMFOGPRVFFDPMØHJDP
&O QBMBCSBT EFM mMØTPGP )BOT +POBT TF
USBUB EF TVQFSBS MB EJNFOTJØO EF VOB
ÏUJDB EF DFSDBOÓBT QBSB BCSJSOPT B IP
SJ[POUFT EFM GVUVSP EF MB IVNBOJEBE Z
EF OVFTUSP QMBOFUB UFOJFOEP FO DVFO
PERSPETIVADELABIOETICAINDD
UB FM QSPHSFTP EF MB CJPMPHÓB NPMFDVMBS
Z MB DPNQSFOTJØO EF MB QSPHSBNBDJØO
HFOÏUJDB
&O FM EPDUPS "CFM EJSFDUPS EFM
*OTUJUVUP DPNFO[Ø B DPMBCPSBS FO MB
FTUSVDUVSBDJØO EFM $PNJUÏ EF ²UJDB
"TJTUFODJBM $&"
EFM )PTQJUBM 4BOU
+PBOEF%ÏVEF&TQMVHVFT#BSDFMPOB
DPOUJOVBOEPFMQSPZFDUPEFVODPNJUÏ
RVFDPNFO[ØTVUSBCBKPEPTB×PTBOUFT
&M$&"oQSJNFSPFO&TQB×BZ
ÞOJDPEVSBOUFNVDIPTB×PTBQFTBSEF
TVBOPOJNBUPoGVFFMGPSPFOFMDVBMTF
SFBMJ[ØQPSQSJNFSBWF[FMEJÈMPHPCJPÏ
UJDPUBMDPNP)FMMFHFSTMPQFOTØQBSBFM
ÈNCJUPDMÓOJDP
'VF UBNCJÏO FO DVBOEP FM *##
JOJDJØ TV QSFTFODJB JOUFSOBDJPOBM QBSUJ
DJQBOEP FO VO EFCBUF TPCSF CJPMPHÓB Z
ÏUJDB#JPMPHZBOE&UIJDT
BDFQUBOEPMB
JOWJUBDJØOEFTVTPSHBOJ[BEPSFT'POEB
UJPO *OUFSOBUJPOBMF )VNBOVN EF -V
HBOP 4VJ[B
Z 'POEBUJPO 1SPTQFDUJWF
EF #SVTFMBT &M EFCBUF DFMFCSBEP FOUSF
FM Z EF TFQUJFNCSF DPOHSFHØ B VO
SFTUSJOHJEP HSVQP EF QBSUJDJQBOUFT
DJFOUÓmDPT NPSBMJTUBT Z SFQSFTFOUBOUFT
EFMBKFSBSRVÓBEFMB*HMFTJB$BUØMJDB&O
USFMPTJOWJUBEPTFTUBCBOCVFOPTBNJHPT
EFM,*DPOFMEPDUPS)FMMFHFSTBMGSFOUF
&M EFCBUF QVTP EF NBOJmFTUP MB EJGÓDJM
DPODJMJBDJØO EF MBT QPTJDJPOFT GSFOUF B
MPT QSPCMFNBT USBUBEPT MB DPOUSBDFQ
DJØO IPSNPOBM QSPDSFBDJØO BTJTUJEB
oEPT B×PT BOUFT EF RVF OBDJFSB -FTMFZ
#SPXOHSBDJBTBMBGFDVOEBDJØOJOWJUSP
Z USBOTGFSFODJB FNCSJPOBSJBo FTUBUVUP
EFM FNCSJØO IVNBOP Z DVFTUJPOFT EF
1FSTQFDUJWBTEFMB#JPÏUJDBFO*CFSPBNÏSJDB
NPSBMGVOEBNFOUBM&MEJÈMPHPBMDBO[Ø
UBNCJÏOOJWFMFTQPMÏNJDPTDVBOEPQBSB
TPSQSFTB EF MPT DJFOUÓmDPT Z NPSBMJTUBT
FVSPQFPTSFQSFTFOUBOUFTEFMFQJTDPQBEP
OPSUFBNFSJDBOP OP BDFQUBSPO MPT DPO
DFQUPT EF TFDVMBSJ[BDJØO EF MB TPDJFEBE
OJ EF ÏUJDB MBJDB JOUFSQSFUBOEP RVF TF
QSPQVHOBCBMBMBJDJEBEEFMBTPDJFEBEZ
MBOFHBDJØOEF%JPT
4F WJP MB OFDFTJEBE EF QSPGVOEJ[BS FO
EJÈMPHP JOUFSEJTDJQMJOBS MPT DPODFQUPT
RVFVUJMJ[BEPTQPSDJFOUÓmDPTmMØTPGPT
PUFØMPHPTUJFOFODPOOPUBDJPOFTEJWFS
TBT 4F UPNØ DPODJFODJB EFM USBTGPOEP
DJFOUÓmDP P mMPTØmDP TPCSF FM RVF TF
BQPZBO QFSDFQDJPOFT EF TJHOJmDBEP EF
QBMBCSBT GVOEBNFOUBMFT DPNP iWJEBw
iEJHOJEBEwiQFSTPOBw
&OFMÈNCJUPNÈTBNQMJPEFDPMBCPSB
DJØOJOUFSOBDJPOBMFM1"SSVQF
HFOFSBMEFMB$PNQB×ÓBEF+FTÞT
BOJNØEFTEFTVTJOJDJPTFMEJÈMPHPCJP
ÏUJDP Z MB DSFBDJØO EFM (SVQP *OUFSOB
DJPOBMEF&TUVEJPTEF#JPÏUJDB(*&#
*&(#
DPOVOFTUBUVUPJOEFQFOEJFOUF
FOFMTFOPEFMB'FEFSBDJØO*OUFSOBDJP
OBM EF 6OJWFSTJEBEFT $BUØMJDBT 'SBO
DFTD "CFM UVWP VO QBQFM DSVDJBM FO TV
PSJHFOFOZGVFDPPSEJOBEPSDPO
FM1&EPVBSE#POÏ4+ZDPO+PIO$
)BSWFZEFMPTFODVFOUSPTJOUFSOBDJP
OBMFTDFMFCSBEPTBMPMBSHPEFTVFYJTUFO
DJB QSFTJEJFOEP TV 4UFFSJOH $PNNJUFF
"CFM
6O OVUSJEP HSVQP EF KFTVJUBT DJFOUÓm
DPT RVF PDVQBCBO DÈUFESBT FO VOJWFS
TJEBEFTQÞCMJDBTPQSJWBEBTZDPOUÓUVMPT
VOJWFSTJUBSJPT FO IVNBOJEBEFT mMPTP
GÓB UFPMPHÓB BOUSPQPMPHÓB
QVEJFSPO
FYQFSJNFOUBSMBTQPTJCJMJEBEFTRVFPGSF
DÓBFMEJÈMPHPCJPÏUJDPBMDPOGSPOUBSTVT
QPTJDJPOFTDPOPUSPTKFTVJUBTQSPGFTPSFT
EF mMPTPGÓB Z EF UFPMPHÓB Z QSPGFTPSFT
TFHMBSFTEFMDBNQPEFMBTDJFODJBT-BEJ
NFOTJØO EF DPPQFSBDJØO JOUFSOBDJPOBM
FOFMEJÈMPHPFOUSF*HMFTJBZNVOEPZMB
FTUSFDIBDPMBCPSBDJØOFOUSFKFTVJUBTZTF
HMBSFTOPOFDFTJUØTFSTVCSBZBEB
4BOU $VHBU GVF FM MVHBS FMFHJEP QBSB
DFMFCSBSMBTUSFTQSJNFSBTSFVOJPOFTEFM
(*&# FOUSF Z -BT EJTDV
TJPOFT EF FTUPT USFT FODVFOUSPT HJSBSPO
BMSFEFEPSEFMPTTJHVJFOUFTUFNBT
t
t
t
*OHFOJFSÓB HFOÏUJDB FYQFDUBUJWBT Z
SJFTHPTQBSBFMIPNCSFZFMNFEJP
BNCJFOUF 1PMÓUJDB EF EJSFDDJØO Z
DPOUSPMEFMBTJOWFTUJHBDJPOFT
*OJDJPEFMBWJEBIVNBOBZTVNB
OJQVMBDJØO
$PODFQUP EF OBUVSBMF[B Z SFWPMV
DJØOFQJTUFNPMØHJDB
PERSPETIVADELABIOETICAINDD
4JSFQBTBNPTBMHVOPEFMPTOPNCSFTEF
RVJFOFTQBSUJDJQBSPOFOMPTEPTQSJNF
SPTFODVFOUSPTEFM(*&#WFSFNPTRVF
DPOUJOVBSPO Z QPUFODJBSPO DSFBUJWB
NFOUF MB EJOÈNJDB FYQFSJNFOUBEB FO
FM EJÈMPHP CJPÏUJDP &OUSF MPT UFØMPHPT
FTQB×PMFT RVF DSFBSPO FTDVFMB .BOVFM
$VZÈT+BWJFS(BGP
+VBO.BTJÈ4P
QIJB6OJWFSTJEBEEF5PLZP
Z&EVBSEP
-ØQF[ "[QJUBSUF &OUSF MPT DJFOUÓmDPT
$BSMPT "MPOTP #FEBUF .BOVFM (BSDÓB
%PODFM 3BNØO .BSÓB /PHVÏT +VBO
3BNØO -BDBEFOB *HOBDJP /Þ×F[ EF
$BTUSP+VMJÈO3VCJP$BSEJFM
+BDPCP
$ÈSEFOBT
Z+PTFQ&HP[DVF
&OUSF
%JOBNJTNPEFMEJÈMPHPCJPÏUJDPFO&TQB×B'SBODFTD"CFM4+Z/VSJB5FSSJCBT
MPT mMØTPGPT "SUVSP +VODPTB "VHVTUP
)PSUBMZ&VTFCJP$PMPNFS%FTUBDBNPT
B QBSUJDJQBOUFT FYUSBOKFSPT DPNP ,MBVT
%FNNFS &EPVBSE #POÏ -VJT"SDIFS
ɨPNBT + ,JOH Z "OHFMP 4FSSB &OUSF
MPTNÏEJDPTNFSFDFOVOBNFODJØOFTQF
DJBM+PIO$)BSWFZ7ÓDUPS$POJMM
+PSEJ'POU+PTFQ.BSÓB%FYFVT9BWJFS
*HMFTJBT"OUPOJP5FKFEP-VÓT$BNQPT
+PBRVÓO1MB[B1FSF/#BSSJZ+PTFQ.
$BSSFSB
"DUJWBNFOUFQSFTFOUFFOFTUPTFODVFO
USPTEFTEFMBQFSTQFDUJWBEFFOGFSNFSÓB
Z QBTUPSBM TBOJUBSJB FTUVWP UBNCJÏO FM
)OP (BCJOP (PSPTUJFUB EF MB 0SEFO
)PTQJUBMBSJBEF4BO+VBOEF%JPTRVJFO
GBWPSFDJØBMNÈYJNPMBQVFTUBFONBS
DIBEFM$PNJUÏEF²UJDB"TJTUFODJBMFO
#BSDFMPOB
&M*##GVFUBNCJÏONJFNCSPGVOEBEPS
EF MB "TPDJBDJØO &VSPQFB EF $FOUSPT
EF ²UJDB .ÏEJDB &"$.&"&$&.
DVZBT CBTFT TF EJTF×BSPO FOUSF Z
-BJOJDJBUJWBEFMBDSFBDJØOEFMB
&"$.&TFEFCJØBMBHFTUJØOEF.BV
SJDF %F 8BDIUFS RVJFO IBCÓB USBCBKB
EPEFTEFBFOFM$FOUFSGPS
#JPFUIJDTJOUIF$MJOJDBM3FTFBSDI*OTUJUV
UF PG .POUSFBM DSFBEP BM NJTNP UJFN
QP RVF FM *## QPS FM %S %BWJE 3PZ
-PTOPNCSFTEFMPTBTJTUFOUFTTPMBNFOUFRVF
EBSPOSFDPHJEBTFOMBT"DUBTRVFOPTFIBOQV
CMJDBEP1BSBNÈTJOGPSNBDJØOWÏBTF"OVBSJP
EFMB$PNQB×ÓBEF+FTÞT&EJDJØOFOFTQB×PM
+FTVJUBTQQ
-BDSFBDJØOEF$PNJUÏTEF²UJDB"TJTUFODJBMIB
SFDJCJEPTJFNQSFFMmSNFBQPZPEFMB0SEFOZ
FTQFDJBMNFOUFEFMBDUVBM)OP(FOFSBM1BTDVBM
1JMFT&O#BSDFMPOBDPOUØBEFNÈTDPOMBDPMB
CPSBDJØOEFMPTIFSNBOPT'SBODJTDP4PMB+PTÏ
-VJT3FESBEP.JHVFM.BSUÓOFOUSFPUSPT
PERSPETIVADELABIOETICAINDD
WJODVMBEP DPNP QVOUP EF SFGFSFODJB
ÏUJDBBMPTWFJOUJTÏJTMBCPSBUPSJPTEFJO
WFTUJHBDJØOEFFTUFDFOUSPFO.POUSFBM
"CFM
&O%F8BDIUFS
GVF OPNCSBEP %JSFDUPS EFM .BBTUSJDIU
*OTUJUVUF GPS #JPFUIJDT -PT USFT DFOUSPT
DPNFO[BNPT B JOUFSDBNCJBS PQJOJPOFT
TPCSFDØNPQPUFODJBSFMEFTBSSPMMPEFMB
CJPÏUJDBFO&VSPQB&OFMDVSTPEFEJ
WFSTBTSFVOJPOFTTFJOWJUØBPUSPTDFO
USPT RVF QPEÓBO FTUBS JOUFSFTBEPT FO MB
JEFB Z FM EF TFQUJFNCSF EF TF
DFMFCSØMBBTBNCMFBDPOTUJUVZFOUFEFMB
"TPDJBDJØORVFIPZDVFOUBDPONÈTEF
DFOUSPT%F8BDIUFS
3FTVMUBFWJEFOUFRVFMBTSFnFYJPOFTTVS
HJEBT FOUSF Z UJFOFO DPNP
NBSDP EF SFGFSFODJB MBT SFTQVFTUBT ÏUJ
DBT BOUF MPT EJTUJOUPT EFTDVCSJNJFOUPT
DJFOUÓmDPT P UÏDOJDBT JOOPWBEPSBT EF
JOEVEBCMFJNQPSUBODJBTPDJBMVOJEBEFT
EF DVJEBEPT JOUFOTJWPT DPOUSB
DFQDJØO IPSNPOBM USBTQMBOUF
SFOBM Z DBSEÓBDP EJBH
OØTUJDPQSFOBUBMDBSJPUJQPT
FDP
HSBGÓB
$POUPEPFMDBNCJPNÈT
QSPGVOEPEFMBNFEJDJOBDPOTJTUFFOFM
SFDPOPDJNJFOUP EF MPT EFSFDIPT EF MPT
QBDJFOUFT DPNP BHFOUFT NPSBMFT BVUØ
OPNPT RVF PSJFOUB MB USBOTJDJØO EF MB
NFEJDJOBEFDPSUFQBUFSOBMJTUBBVOBEF
NPEFMPDPOUSBDUVBM
4FHVOEPQFSÓPEPEFMBCJPÏUJDB
FO&TQB×B
&TUF QFSÓPEP RVF EF NPNFOUP TJUVB
NPTFOUSFZFMmOEFMTJHMP99OPT
DPMPDBFOFMPKPEFVOIVSBDÈOoTJBE
NJUJNPTMBNFUÈGPSBoRVFMMFHBBUPEPT
1FSTQFDUJWBTEFMB#JPÏUJDBFO*CFSPBNÏSJDB
MPTDPOmOFTEFMB5JFSSB4FUSBUBEFVO
QFRVF×P HSBO EFTDVCSJNJFOUP UÏDOJDP
DVZP TÓNCPMP EF BQMJDBDJØO QSÈDUJDB
DPOPDFOIPZUPEPTMPTOJ×PTRVFWBOB
MBFTDVFMBFOMPTDJODPDPOUJOFOUFT&O
FGFDUPFOTFJOWFOUBFTUFTÓNCPMP
QSÈDUJDP!
&M QSPGFTPS -BDBEFOB OPT PGSFDF VOB
JOUFSFTBOUF SFMBDJØO TPCSF MPT QSFNJPT
/PCFM FO HFOÏUJDB FO TV PCSB i)JTUP
SJB/PCFMBEBEFMB(FOÏUJDB$PODFQUP
Z NÏUPEPw -BDBEFOB +3 4F
QFSGFDDJPOB FM EJBHOØTUJDP QSFOBUBM EF
NBMGPSNBDJPOFT GFUBMFT IBZ QSPHSFTPT
FO JONVOPMPHÓB Z UÏDOJDBT RVJSÞSHJDBT
RVFIBDFOQPTJCMFNFKPSBSOPUBCMFNFO
UFMPTSFTVMUBEPTEFUSBTQMBOUFTEFØSHB
OPTZUFKJEPTTFEFmOFMBNVFSUFDFSF
CSBM Z TF EFTDSJCF FM FTUBEP WFHFUBUJWP
QFSTJTUFOUF0DVSSFFMQSJNFSÏYJUPEFMB
GFDVOEBDJØOJOWJUSPZEFMBUSBOTGFSFO
DJBFNCSJPOBSJB'*75&
FO&O
TFQVCMJDBFM*OGPSNF#FMNPOUFO
FM RVF TF GPSNVMBO MPT USFT QSJODJQJPT
CÈTJDPTCJPÏUJDPTEFHSBOJOnVFODJBFO
UPEPFMNVOEPPDDJEFOUBMSFTQFUPBMBT
QFSTPOBTCFOFmDFODJBZKVTUJDJB
5SFTIFDIPTDPOEJDJPOBORVFIBZBNPT
TFMFDDJPOBEP FM QFSÓPEP QBSBFONBSDBSFTUFTFHVOEPQFSÓPEP
FMEJÈMPHPCJPÏUJDPTFFYQBOEFZTFIBDF
NÈTDPNQMFKP
HSBOEFTmHVSBTEFMB
CJPÏUJDB FO &TQB×B FOUSBO FO DPOUBDUP
EF NBOFSB DPNQSPNFUJEB WBMJFOUF Z
SFTQPOTBCMF EFTEF MB mMPTPGÓB FM EFSF
DzF#FMNPOU3FQPSU&UIJDBM1SJODJQMFTBOE
(VJEFMJOFTGPSUIF1SPUFDUJPOPG)VNBO4VCKFDUT
PG3FTFBSDI64(PWFSONFOU1SJOUJOH0ċDF
PERSPETIVADELABIOETICAINDD
DIP MB FDPOPNÓB Z MB QPMÓUJDB Z TF
BDFOUÞBONÈTMBTEJGFSFODJBTFOMBNB
OFSB EF FOGPDBS MBT USFT SBDJPOBMJEBEFT
oUÏDOJDPDJFOUÓmDB KVSÓEJDPQPMÓUJDB Z
ÏUJDBSFMJHJPTBoFOMBCÞTRVFEBEFMQSP
HSFTPIVNBOP
&TUPQFSNJUFEJTUJOHVJSFO&TQB×BUSFT
FOGPRVFTUFØSJDPQSÈDUJDPTDPNQMFNFO
UBSJPTEFMRVFIBDFSCJPÏUJDPZTVGVOEB
NFOUBDJØOEFTEFMB²UJDBEFTEFMB5FP
MPHÓBZEFTEFFM%FSFDIP#BSSFBV)
$BSBDUFSJ[B B FTUF QFSÓPEP MB CÞTRVFEB
EFMPNÈTFTQFDÓmDBNFOUFIVNBOPFOMB
BQMJDBDJØOEFMPTOVFWPTDPOPDJNJFOUPT
ZUFDOPMPHÓBTCJPNÏEJDBTMPRVFTFFY
QSFTBDPONÈTQSFDJTJØODPOFMDPODFQUP
iDBMJEBEEFWJEBwDPNPDPODFQUPCÈTJDP
EF UPEB JOWFTUJHBDJØO NÏEJDB Z EJTDV
TJØOCJPÏUJDB
$FSSBNPTFTUFQFSÓPEPDPOMBmSNBEFM
$POWFOJP &VSPQFP EF #JPNFEJDJOB Z
%FSFDIPT)VNBOPTmSNBEPFO0WJF
EP&TQB×B
&M1BSMBNFOUPFTQB×PMMP
SBUJmDØFMEFPDUVCSFEFZFOUSØ
FOWJHPSFOFTUFQBÓTFM¡EFFOFSPEF
DFSSÈOEPTFVODJDMPFOFMDVBMMB
CJPÏUJDBIBQBTBEPEFFWPMVDJPOBSQBSB
CJFOZQBSBNBMIBDJBFMCJPEFSFDIP
*OUFOUBSÏ FODVBESBS MBT EJGFSFOUFT DP
SSJFOUFT CJPÏUJDBT FO MPT TJHVJFOUFT FQÓ
HSBGFT CJPÏUJDB EFTEF VOB GVOEB
NFOUBDJØOÏUJDB
CJPÏUJDBEFTEFVOB
GVOEBNFOUBDJØO UFPMØHJDB CJPÏUJDB
EFTEF VOB GVOEBNFOUBDJØO KVSÓEJDB Z
#0&OÞNNJÏSDPMFTPDUVCSF
%JOBNJTNPEFMEJÈMPHPCJPÏUJDPFO&TQB×B'SBODFTD"CFM4+Z/VSJB5FSSJCBT
CJPÏUJDBEFTEFVOBQFSTQFDUJWBUFTUJ
NPOJBMZOBSSBUJWB
#JPÏUJDBEFTEFVOB
GVOEBNFOUBDJØOÏUJDB
6OJWFSTJEBE3BNØO-MVMM#BSDFMPOB
*OTUJUVUP#PSKBEF#JPÏUJDB*##
&OUSFZFM*OTUJUVUPIBEBEP
DPOUJOVJEBEZEFTBSSPMMPBTVUSBCBKPFT
QFDJBMNFOUFFODVBUSPÈNCJUPT
B
%PDFODJBZGPSNBDJØOFOCJPÏUJDB
C
*OWFTUJHBDJØO FO CJPÏUJDB &M *##
IB QBSUJDJQBEP FO WBSJPT QSPZFDUPT
EFMB6OJØO&VSPQFBFOUSFMPTRVF
EFTUBDBNPT 1SPZFDUP #JPNFE **
TPCSF )VNBO FNCSZPOJD BOE 'FUBM
5JTTVF USBTQMBOUBUJPO DPPSEJOBEP
QPS(VJEPEF8FSUZ3PO#FSHI
NBOT .FEJDJOF )FBMUIDBSF
BOE1IZMPTPQIZZ#BTJD&UIJDBM1SJO
DJQMFTJO&VSPQFBO#JPFUIJDTBOE#JP
MBX DPPSEJOBEP QPS 1FUFS ,FNQ
EF$PQFOIBHFOZDPFEJUBEPQPSFM
*##ZFM$FOUSFGPS&UIJDTBOE-BX
EF $PQFOIBHFO 3FOEUPSą ,FNQ
&ET
"EFNÈT EF MPT QSPZFDUPT DPMFDUJ
WPTFM*##IBEFTBSSPMMBEPUSBCBKPT
QSPQJPTEFJOWFTUJHBDJØOZSFnFYJØO
TPCSFEJTUJOUBTUFNÈUJDBTCJPÏUJDBT
DPOUBOEPBDUVBMNFOUFDPONÈTEF
UÓUVMPT "TJNJTNP EFTEF DVFOUBDPOMBSFWJTUBUSJNFTUSBM#JP
ÏUJDB %FCBU RVF SFDPHF UFNBT
CJPÏUJDPT BDUVBMFT FO VO MFOHVBKF
DMBSPZEJEÈDUJDP
1BSB NBZPS JOGPSNBDJØO WJTJUBS MPT TJUJPT
XXXJCCJPÏUJDBPSH XXXDBNQVTJCCJPÏUJDB
PSHXXXCJPÏUJDBEFCBUPSH
PERSPETIVADELABIOETICAINDD
D
"TFTPSBNJFOUP 1BSUJDJQB Z GPSNB
QBSUF EF DPNJUÏT EF ÏUJDB BTJTUFO
DJBM oNVDIPT EF FMMPT JNQVMTBEPT
EFTEF TVT JOJDJPT QPS FM *##o BTÓ
DPNP EF $PNJUÏT ²UJDPT EF *O
WFTUJHBDJØO $MÓOJDB FO EJTUJOUPT
DFOUSPT F JOTUJUVDJPOFT TBOJUBSJBT
QSPNPWJFOEPMBEJTDVTJØOEFDBTPT
DMÓOJDPT 5BNCJÏO QBSUJDJQB FO FM
$PNJUÏ EF #JPÏUJDB EFM (PCJFSOP
"VUØOPNP EF $BUBMV×B &TQB×B
EFTEF TVT PSÓHFOFT FO Z FO
EJGFSFOUFT DPNJTJPOFT Z HSVQPT EF
USBCBKPQBSBBTFTPSBSBMHPCJFSOPFO
DVFTUJPOFT CJPÏUJDBT RVF MVFHP QB
TBSÈOBTFSNBUFSJBMFHJTMBUJWB
E
$FOUSPEFEPDVNFOUBDJØOZCJCMJP
UFDB&MNBOFKPZHFTUJØOEFUPEB
FTUB UBSFB SFRVJFSF EF VOB EFEJDB
DJØOQMFOBZGVFMMFWBEPBDBCPQPS
'SBODFTD "CFM EFTEF TVT JOJDJPT Z
IBTUB&OFTFB×PTFQSPEVDF
TV SFMFWP DPNP EJSFDUPS QBTBOEP
BTFSQSFTJEFOUFEFMB'VOEBDJØOZ
NJFNCSP JOWFTUJHBEPS Z EPDFOUF
"TVNF FOUPODFT MB EJSFDDJØO MB MJ
DFODJBEBFO%FSFDIPZBCPHBEBFO
FKFSDJDJP /VSJB 5FSSJCBT &MMB DP
NFO[ØBJOUFSFTBSTFQPSMBCJPÏUJDB
FODVBOEPFOUSØFODPOUBDUP
DPOFM*##&OMBBDUVBMJEBE5FSSJ
CBTSFQSFTFOUBBM*OTUJUVUPFODVFT
UJPOFTCJPÏUJDBTDPOSFQFSDVTJØOKV
SÓEJDBDPNPFMSFDJFOUFEPDVNFOUP
TPCSFMBFVUBOBTJBFMBCPSBEPQPSFM
*## Z PUSP USBCBKP TPCSF FM UFNB
FMBCPSBEP EFTEF FM (PCJFSOP EF
$BUBMV×B
$GIUUQXXXVEEDMQSPOUVT@VEETJUFFEJD
CBTFQPSUCJCMJPUFDBIUNM
1FSTQFDUJWBTEFMB#JPÏUJDBFO*CFSPBNÏSJDB
%FOUSP EFM 1BUSPOBUP EFM *## DBCF
IBDFS FTQFDJBM SFGFSFODJB B +VBO 7J×BT
NÏEJDP DJSVKBOP FM QSJNFSP FO JN
QMFNFOUBS VOBT +PSOBEBT EF #JPÏUJDB
FODPMBCPSBDJØODPOFM*##MBTRVFTF
IBONBOUFOJEPMPTÞMUJNPTWFJOUFB×PT
%FTEFTVUBSFBDPNPEFDBOPEFMB'B
DVMUBE EF .FEJDJOB EF MB 6OJWFSTJEBE
EF -ÏSJEB MPHSØ RVF TF JOUSPEVKFSB FO
FM DVSSÓDVMP EF NFEJDJOB MB BTJHOBUVSB
EFCJPÏUJDB&OMBBDUVBMJEBEFT3FDUPS
.BHOÓmDPEFEJDIBVOJWFSTJEBEZIBIF
DIPTVJOHSFTPDPNP"DBEÏNJDP/VNF
SBSJPEFMB3FBM"DBEFNJBEF.FEJDJOB
EF$BUBMV×B
6OJWFSTJEBE$PNQMVUFOTF.BESJE
-BQSFTFODJBEFMBCJPÏUJDBFOMB6OJWFS
TJEBE$PNQMVUFOTFEF.BESJETFEFCF
TJOMVHBSBEVEBTB%JFHP(SBDJB(VJ
MMÏO&TEJGÓDJMSFTVNJSFOQPDBTMÓOFBTTV
USBCBKPDSFBUJWPDPNPNÏEJDPZmMØTPGP
4FJOUFHSBFOFMÈNCJUPEFMBCJPÏUJDBFO
DVBOEPWJTJUBEJWFSTBTVOJWFSTJEB
EFTEF&TUBEPT6OJEPTJOUFOUBOEPFO
DPOUSBSGVOEBNFOUBDJØOZNFUPEPMPHÓB
BMBTEFDJTJPOFTÏUJDBTFOMBDMÓOJDB%F
FTUBFYQFSJFODJBSFTVMUBOEPTUFYUPTGVO
EBNFOUBMFT i'VOEBNFOUPT EF MB CJPÏ
UJDBw(SBDJB
Zi1SPDFEJNJFOUPT
EF EFDJTJØO FO ÏUJDB DMÓOJDBw (SBDJB
+VOUPBTVTDMBTFTEFTUBDBTVDB
QBDJEBE EF TÓOUFTJT DPNP MP NVFTUSBO
BMHVOPT EF MPT NÈT SFDJFOUFT BSUÓDVMPT
DVZBMFDUVSBSFDPNFOEBNPTWJWBNFOUF
i%FMBCJPÏUJDBDMÓOJDBBMBCJPÏUJDBHMP
CBMUSFJOUBB×PTEFFWPMVDJØOw(SBDJB
Zi$POUSJCVDJØOEFMBTIVNBOJ
EBEFTNÏEJDBTBMBGPSNBDJØOEFMNÏEJ
DPw(SBDJB
PERSPETIVADELABIOETICAINDD
&OMBDÈUFESBEFCJPÏUJDBEF%JFHP(SB
DJBTFIBOGPSNBEPNVDIPTFTQFDJBMJTUBT
UBOUPNÏEJDPTDPNPmMØTPGPT&OUSFMPT
QSJNFSPT NFODJPOBNPT B 1JMBS /Þ×F[
$VCFSP RVF DPMBCPSØ DPO FM *## EV
SBOUF PODF B×PT +PTÏ 4BSBCJB *TPMJOB
3JB×P "[VDFOB $SVDFJSP .BOVFM EF
MPT3FZFT+VBO$BSMPT"MWBSF[Z1BCMP
)FSOBOEP &OUSF MPT mMØTPGPT -JEJB
'FJUP+PTÏ3BNØO"NPS1BO+PTÏ(BS
DÓB'ÏSF[Z'BCJP"MCFSUP(BS[ØO
.FODJØO FTQFDJBM NFSFDF +VBO 3BNØO
-BDBEFOB RVJFO TJFOEP ZB NBFTUSP FO
CJPÏUJDB oEFTEF TV QFSTQFDUJWB DPNP
CJØMPHPZSFGFSFOUFQBSBUPEBTMBTFTDVF
MBTEFCJPÏUJDBFTQB×PMBToRVJTPGPSNB
MJ[BSTVTFTUVEJPTDPOFMHSBEPEFNBHÓT
UFSEFMB6OJWFSTJEBE$PNQMVUFOTF
6OJWFSTJEBEEF7BMFODJB
-B MFDUVSB EFM MJCSP EF "EFMB $PSUJOB
i²UJDBNÓOJNB*OUSPEVDDJØOBMBmMPTP
GÓB QSÈDUJDBw QVCMJDBEP FO BCSJØ
FO&TQB×BVOBQFSTQFDUJWBRVFTJCJFOTF
JOUVÓBOPBDBCBCBEFFODPOUSBSMBDPO
DFQUVBMJ[BDJØO Z GPSNVMBDJØO OFDFTBSJBT
QBSBTVQFSBSFMJNQBDUPEFMJVTOBUVSBMJT
NPEFMBGPSNBDJØOmMPTØmDBFTDPMÈTUJDB
(SBDJBTBFMMBFOUSBNPTFOFMÈNCJUPEF
VOB ÏUJDB EJTDVSTJWB Z EJBMØHJDB RVF TF
DVJEBEFIBDFSKVTUJDJBBMTFSBVUØOPNPZ
EJBMØHJDPEFMIPNCSFZFYJHFQPSFMMPVO
NÓOJNP NPSBM RVF TØMP TF DPOTJEFSFO
KVTUBTMBTOPSNBTRVFIBOTJEPRVFSJEBT
QPS MPT BGFDUBEPT USBT VO EJÈMPHP DFMF
CSBEP FO DPOEJDJPOFT EF TJNFUSÓB &O
USBNPTQVFTFOVOBÏUJDBEFPOUPMØHJDB
ZVOJWFSTBMJTUBRVFQSPUFHFMBBVUPOPNÓB
%JOBNJTNPEFMEJÈMPHPCJPÏUJDPFO&TQB×B'SBODFTD"CFM4+Z/VSJB5FSSJCBT
TPMJEBSJBEFMIPNCSFZFTQPSUBOUPCBTF
mSNFQBSBFMEFSFDIPKVTUPQBSBMBQPMÓ
UJDBMFHÓUJNBZQBSBVOBSFMJHJØORVFTF
TPNFUFHVTUPTBBMBDSÓUJDBEFMBSB[ØO
6OJWFSTJEBE"VUØOPNBEF#BSDFMPOB
$PO VOB MBSHB FYQFSJFODJB DPNP QSP
GFTPSB EF mMPTPGÓB 7JDUPSJB $BNQT
$BUFESÈUJDB EF ²UJDB EF MB 6OJWFSTJEBE
"VUØOPNB EF #BSDFMPOB Z QSFTJEFOUB
EFM $PNJUÏ $POTVMUJWP EF #JPÏUJDB EFM
(PCJFSOP "VUØOPNP EF $BUBMV×B FO
TV NÈT SFDJFOUF MJCSP i-B WPMVOUBE EF
WJWJSw $BNQT Q FTUBCMFDF
mSNFNFOUF RVF MB CJPÏUJDB EFCF UFOFS
DPNPDBSBDUFSÓTUJDBTCÈTJDBTMBJOUFSEJTDJ
QMJOBSJFEBEZMBMBJDJEBE$PO5SJTUSBN
&OHFMIBSEU BENJUF RVF OP QPEFNPT
EFTDVCSJSVOBNPSBMJEBETFDVMBSDBOØOJ
DB EPUBEB EF DPOUFOJEP PCMJHÈOEPOPT
B iBmOBS FO FM QSPDFEJNJFOUP QBSB RVF
MBT EFDJTJPOFT BMDBODFO MB NÈYJNB DP
SSFDDJØOQPTJCMF6OQSPDFEJNJFOUPRVF
DPOTJTUJSÈFOFMEJÈMPHPMBEJTDVTJØOZMB
EFMJCFSBDJØOwFWJUBOEPBRVFMMBTQPTUVSBT
RVFQVFEBOOPTFSBDFQUBEBTQPSUPEPT
&OEFmOJUJWBMBCJPÏUJDBBTQJSBBBQMJDBS
VOBiNPSBMNÓOJNBwDVZPWBMPSOVDMFBS
FTMBEJHOJEBEEFMBQFSTPOBRVFTFFY
QSFTBFOMPTWBMPSFTCÈTJDPTEFMBNPEFS
OJEBEoMJCFSUBEJHVBMEBEZGSBUFSOJEBEo
TVTUSBUPEFMPTEFSFDIPTIVNBOPT
#JPÏUJDBQSPNPUPSBEFMEJÈMPHP
JOUFSOBDJPOBMQPMÓUJDPTPDJBMZ
DVMUVSBM
.BSDFMP1BMBDJPTNÏEJDPQPMÓUJDPZQSP
NPUPSEFMBCJPÏUJDBHMPCBMGVOEBEPSEF
MB4PDJFEBE*OUFSOBDJPOBMEF#JPÏUJDBFO
PERSPETIVADELABIOETICAINDD
MBRVFQSFTJEFTV$PNJUÏ$JFOUÓmDPEJ
SFDUPSEFMBSFWJTUB4*#*ZVOPEFMPTQBS
UÓDJQFTFOMBFMBCPSBDJØOZmSNBEFM$PO
WFOJP&VSPQFPTPCSF%FSFDIPT)VNBOPT
Z#JPNFEJDJOBFTVOBEFMBTmHVSBTNÈT
EFTUBDBEBT EF MB CJPÏUJDB FO &TQB×B
#JPÏUJDBZBUFODJØOQSJNBSJBEFTBMVE
/VFTUSP EFTFP FO FTUF QVOUP FT SFOEJS
IPNFOBKFBBRVFMMPTNÏEJDPToNVDIPT
EF FMMPT BHSVQBEPT FO MB 4PDJFEBE &T
QB×PMBEF.FEJDJOB'BNJMJBSZ$PNV
OJUBSJB4&.'*$
oZFRVJQPTEFTBMVE
RVF TF EFEJDBO B MB BUFODJØO QSJNBSJB
FTQFDJBMNFOUFBRVJFOFTUSBCBKBOFOMPT
QSPHSBNBT EF BUFODJØO EPNJDJMJBSJB FO
DVJEBEPTQBMJBUJWPT1"%&4
&ODVBO
UP TFBO DBQBDFT EF NBOUFOFS FM NFKPS
FTQÓSJUVEFMBUSBEJDJØOIJQPDSÈUJDBMPT
DPOPDJNJFOUPTCJPÏUJDPTOFDFTBSJPTZMB
DFSDBOÓBDPOMPTQBDJFOUFTZDJVEBEBOPT
TPOFMGVUVSPEFMBCJPÏUJDB
#JPÏUJDBEFTEFVOB
GVOEBNFOUBDJØOUFPMØHJDB
6OJWFSTJEBE1POUJmDJBEF$PNJMMBT
61$
.BESJE
-B$ÈUFESBEF#JPÏUJDBEFMB61$GVF
DSFBEB QPS +BWJFS (BGP /PQVEPWFSQVCMJDBEBFOWJEBTVPCSB
EF i#JPÏUJDB 5FPMØHJDBw (BGP RVF BHSVQBCB MPT TBCFSFT DJFOUÓmDPT Z
UFPMØHJDPTRVFIBCÓBEFTBSSPMMBEPFOTVT
DMBTFTMJCSPTZBSUÓDVMPT
"OVBMNFOUFEFTEFJOTUJUVDJPOBMJ
[ØEFTEFTV$ÈUFESBVOPTTFNJOBSJPTEF
EJTDVTJØORVFMFTPCSFWJWFOHSBDJBTBTVT
TFHVJEPSFTGPSNBEPTFOMPRVFQPEFNPT
1FSTQFDUJWBTEFMB#JPÏUJDBFO*CFSPBNÏSJDB
EFOPNJOBSiCJPÏUJDBDBUØMJDBEJBMPHBO
UFw-BDPMFDDJØOi%JMFNBT²UJDPTEFMB
.FEJDJOB"DUVBMwQVCMJDBEBFOMB61$
TJHVF TJFOEP VO SFGFSFOUF FO UPEPT MPT
UFNBT RVF USBUØ -BT UFDOPMPHÓBT EF SF
QSPEVDDJØO BTJTUJEB Z MB CJPUFDOPMPHÓB
HFOÏUJDB GVFSPO QBSB ÏM UFNBT QSFEJMFD
UPTEFTEFRVFEFGFOEJØTVUFTJTEPDUPSBM
TPCSFi&MBCPSUPZFMDPNJFO[PEFMBWJEB
IVNBOBi (BGP FO MB 6OJWFSTJ
EBE(SFHPSJBOBEF3PNBFO
(BMÈOZFMQSPGFTPSUJUVMBSEFMB'BDVM
UBE EF .FEJDJOB EF 4FWJMMB +PTÏ .BSÓB
3VCJP DVFOUBO DPO MB DPMBCPSBDJØO EF
PUSPTJOTUJUVUPTEFGVOEBNFOUBDJØOÏUJDB
*##6OJWFSTJEBE$PNQMVUFOTFZ6OJ
WFSTJEBE EF $PNJMMBT
&O 1BNQMPOB
#PTDP$PSEFJSPFOZFO;BSBHP
[B'SBODJTDP+BWJFS0CJTFOIBO
PSHBOJ[BEP NFNPSBCMFT +PSOBEBT /B
DJPOBMFTTPCSF$VJEBEPT1BMJBUJWPTFOMBT
RVFIBQBSUJDJQBEPFM*##
&O MB NJTNB MÓOFB RVF +BWJFS (BGP TF
NVFWF MB &TDVFMB EF 5FPMPHÓB 'VOEB
NFOUBM Z .PSBM EF (SBOBEB DPMBCP
SBEPSBEFMPTDVSTPTZFM.ÈTUFSEFMPT
)FSNBOPT EF 4BO +VBO EF %JPT Z MB
FTDVFMBEFMPT3FEFOUPSJTUBTEF.BESJE
RVF UJFOFO DPNP QSJODJQBMFT SFQSFTFO
UBOUFTB.BSDJBOP7JEBMZ+BWJFS&MJ[BSJ
"NCPTDPOUSJCVZFODPOMB61$ZDPO
MB 6OJWFSTJEBE $PNQMVUFOTF EF .B
ESJE$POEJGFSFOUFTNBUJDFTTFNVFWFO
FOFMDPOUFYUPEFVOBÏUJDBBVUØOPNBFO
FMDPOUFYUPEFMBGFDSJTUJBOB
6OJWFSTJEBE1SJWBEBEF/BWBSSB
0SEFO)PTQJUBMBSJB4BO+VBOEF%JPT
'PSNBFOCJPÏUJDBBMPTQSPGFTJPOBMFTTB
OJUBSJPTEFTVTIPTQJUBMFTEFDJEJEBNFOUF
JNQVMTBEB QPS FM )OP (FOFSBM 1BDVBM
1JMFT&O&TQB×BIBOTFHVJEPUBMJOJDJB
UJWBNÏEJDPTFOGFSNFSBTZQSPGFTJPOBMFT
TBOJUBSJPT Z FO UPEPT MPT DFOUSPT EF MB
0SEFOIBZIFSNBOPTZQSPGFTJPOBMFTTB
OJUBSJPTDPOVO.ÈTUFSFOCJPÏUJDB&TQF
DJBMNFODJØONFSFDFFM.ÈTUFSRVFEFT
EFPSHBOJ[BMB1SPWJODJB#ÏUJDBEF
MB0SEFO)PTQJUBMBSJB4BO+VBOEF%JPT
CBKPFMUÓUVMPi#JPÏUJDBZ)VNBOJ[BDJØO
EFMB"TJTUFODJBw4VEJSFDUPS+PTÏ.BSÓB
PERSPETIVADELABIOETICAINDD
-B CJPÏUJDB DPNP EJTDJQMJOB EPDFOUF Z
WJODVMBEB B MB JOTUJUVDJØO i0QVT %FJw
FTUÈ ÓOUJNBNFOUF MJHBEB B MB mHVSB EF
(PO[BMP)FSSBO[DBUFESÈUJDPEF)JTUP
MPHÓBZ"OBUPNÓB1BUPMØHJDBEFTEF
ZEFDBOPEFMB'BDVMUBEEF.FEJDJOBEF
MB6OJWFSTJEBEEF/BWBSSBFOUSFZ
5SBCBKØFOMB0SHBOJ[BDJØO.ÏEJ
DB$PMFHJBMEF&TQB×BEFTEFIBTUB
ZIBTJEPNJFNCSPEFM$PNJUÏ*O
UFSOBDJPOBMEF#JPÏUJDBEFMB6/&4$0
ZEFMB"DBEFNJB1POUJmDJBQPSMB7JEB
#JPÏUJDBEFTEFVOB
GVOEBNFOUBDJØOKVSÓEJDB
4F DBSBDUFSJ[B QPS MB JNQPSUBODJB DPO
DFEJEBBM%FSFDIPZBMBMFHJTMBDJØOTJO
EFTQSFDJBSMPTQSPCMFNBTÏUJDPTEFCBTF
%JTUJOHVJNPT DMBSBNFOUF MB FTDVFMB EF
.BSÓB $BTBEP DVZB PSJFOUBDJØO FT FM
%FSFDIPDPNPDPOmHVSBEPSEFMBÏUJDB
MB EF "OUPOJP #FSJTUBJO 4+ FTQFDJBMJ
[BEB FO %FSFDIP 1FOBM $SJNJOPMPHÓB
Z 7JDUJNPMPHÓB Z MB EF $BSMPT 3PNFP
$BTBCPOB FTQFDJBMJ[BEB FO DVFTUJPOFT
KVSÓEJDBTFOUPSOPBMHFOPNBIVNBOP
%JOBNJTNPEFMEJÈMPHPCJPÏUJDPFO&TQB×B'SBODFTD"CFM4+Z/VSJB5FSSJCBT
&Mi0CTFSWBUPSJEF#JPÒUJDBJ%SFUwZFM
.ÈTUFSEF#JPÏUJDBZ%FSFDIPEFMB6OJ
WFSTJEBEEF#BSDFMPOBEJSJHJEPQPS.B
SÓB$BTBEPJOUFOUBQSPNPWFSFMEJÈMPHP
VOJWFSTJEBETPDJFEBE DPO MB mOBMJEBE
EFJOnVJSBOUFMPTPSHBOJTNPTQÞCMJDPT
BENJOJTUSBUJWPT P QPMÓUJDPT RVF SFHVMBO
ZDPOUSPMBOMBTBDUJWJEBEFTEFJOWFTUJHB
DJØOZMBBQMJDBDJØOEFOVFWBTUFDOPMP
HÓBT1VCMJDBFODBTUFMMBOPFJOHMÏTDPO
KVOUBNFOUF DPO BMHVOPT FTQFDJBMJTUBT
%PDVNFOUPTEFPQJOJØOCJFOFMBCPSBEPT
ZDPOVOBBNQMJBEJGVTJØOFOMPTDÓSDVMPT
VOJWFSTJUBSJPT
&TJNQPSUBOUFNFODJPOBSB$BSMPT.B
SÓB3PNFP$BTBCPOBDBUFESÈUJDPEF%F
SFDIP 1FOBM EF MB 6OJWFSTJEBE EFM 1BÓT
7BTDPZEJSFDUPSEFMB$ÈUFESB*OUFSVOJ
WFSTJUBSJBEF%FSFDIPZ(FOPNB)VNB
OPDVZBBTFTPSÓBFTSFRVFSJEBGSFDVFOUF
NFOUF QPS PSHBOJTNPT JOUFSOBDJPOBMFT
DPNPMB0SHBOJ[BDJØO.VOEJBMEFMB4B
MVE0.4
ZMB0SHBOJ[BDJØOEF/BDJP
OFT6OJEBTQBSBMB&EVDBDJØOMB$JFODJB
ZMB$VMUVSB6/&4$0
%FTVDÈUFESB
IBOFHSFTBEP"JU[JCFS&NBMEJ1JMBS/J
DPMÈTZ4FSHJP3PNFP%FCFNPTEFTUBDBS
UBNCJÏOMBMBCPSJOWFTUJHBEPSBZEPDFOUF
EFMEJSFDUPSEFMB6OJEBEEF#JPÏUJDBZ
0SJFOUBDJØO4BOJUBSJBEFMB$PNVOJEBE
EF.BESJE+BWJFS4ÈODIF[$BSP
&O FTUF EJÈMPHP UJFOFO VO QBQFM SFMF
WBOUFMPTDBUFESÈUJDPTEF%FSFDIP1FOBM
"OUPOJP #FSJTUBJO EFM *OTUJUVUP 7BTDP
EF$SJNJOPMPHÓBZ+PTÏ-VÓT%JF[3JQP
MMÏTEFMB6OJWFSTJEBEEF.ÈMBHBUBN
CJÏO&TUIFS(JNÏOF[4BMJOBTSFDUPSBEF
MB 6OJWFSTJEBE 3BNØO -MVMM &ODBSOB
3PDB DBUFESÈUJDB EF %FSFDIP $JWJM EF
PERSPETIVADELABIOETICAINDD
#BSDFMPOB Z NBHJTUSBEB EFM 5SJCVOBM
4VQSFNP Z 'SBODJTDP +BWJFS #MÈ[RVF[
3VJ[ 1SPGFTPS 5JUVMBS EF 'JMPTPGÓB EFM
%FSFDIP EF MB 6OJWFSTJEBE 1ÞCMJDB EF
/BWBSSBRVFFYQMPSBMPTQSPCMFNBTCJP
ÏUJDPTEFTEFVODPNQPOFOUFKVSÓEJDPZ
BMSFWÏTSFnFYJPOBZGVOEBNFOUBMBEJ
NFOTJØOÏUJDBEFMPKVSÓEJDP
&T OFDFTBSJP NFODJPOBS BEFNÈT BM
.BHJTUSBEP &NÏSJUP EFM 5SJCVOBM 4V
QSFNP +PTÏ .BOVFM .BSUÓOF[1FSFEB
DVZB PSJFOUBDJØO Z NBHJTUFSJP FO MB
$PNJTJØO EF #JPÏUJDB EF MB 4PDJFEBE
&TQB×PMB EF (JOFDPMPHÓB Z 0CTUFUSJ
DJB 4&(0
IB TJEP GVOEBNFOUBM B
.BOVFM "NBSJMMB (VOEÓO QSFTJEFOUF
EFM (SVQP &VSPQFP EF %FSFDIP 'BS
NBDÏVUJDP B 3JDBSEP EF -PSFO[P
QSFTJEFOUF EF MB "TPDJBDJØO &TQB×PMB
EF %FSFDIP 4BOJUBSJP Z B 9BWJFS "CFM
-MVDI QSPGFTPS EF MB &TDVFMB +VEJDJBM
#JPÏUJDBEFTEFFMUFTUJNPOJPZMB
OBSSBUJWB
4PONVDIPTMPTNÏEJDPTDVZBWJEBTJSWF
EFNPEFMPEFQSBYJTNÏEJDBCBTBEBFO
DMBSPTDSJUFSJPTÏUJDPTQBSBMBTHFOFSBDJP
OFTGVUVSBT+PSEJ4BOT
+PSEJ(PM
"OUPOJP 5FKFEP .PJTÏT #SPHHJ
'SBODFTD 7JMBSEFMM $JSJM 3P[NBO .B
SJVT'P[&TUBOJTMBP#PSFO'SBODFTD.
%PNÏOFDI +PSEJ 4FUPBJO %PNJOHP
3VBOP+PTFQ.-BÕMMB4BHSBSJP.BUFV
-ZEJB(VJTBOZ$BSNFO$VBESBEP
3FDPSEBNPTTØMPBBRVFMMPTRVFEFTEFMPTJOJ
DJPTOPTØMPFOUSBSPOFOFMBSUFEFMEJÈMPHPCJP
ÏUJDPTJOPRVFMPQPUFODJBSPOEPDUPSFT.BSJVT
.PSMBOT.BSD"#SPHHJZ-JEJB#VJTÈORVF
OPTBOJNBSPOBDPNFO[BSDPOFMMPTMB4PDJFUBU
$BUBMBOBEF#JPÏUJDB
1FSTQFDUJWBTEFMB#JPÏUJDBFO*CFSPBNÏSJDB
1FSÓPEPEFSFWJTJØOQSPZFDDJØO
FJOUFHSBDJØO
4VPCKFUJWPFTMBFMFDDJØOEFWBMPSFTFOFM
QMBOPTPDJBMRVFQFSNJUBODPOTUSVJSVO
NVOEPNFKPSZNÈTTBMVEBCMFUFOEJFO
EPBTVQFSBSMBTWFSHPO[PTBTEJGFSFODJBT
FOUSFSJDPTZQPCSFTZFOUSFQPEFSPTPTZ
FYDMVJEPT*OUFOUBSFNPTSFTVNJSMPBUSB
WÏTEFMBTUSFTSBDJPOBMJEBEFTRVFIFNPT
NFODJPOBEP
3BDJPOBMJEBEUÏDOJDPDJFOUÓmDB
-BT EPT ÞMUJNBT EÏDBEBT EFM TJHMP 99
GVFSPO UFTUJHPT EFM FOUVTJBTNP HFOFSB
EP QPS MPT JOHFOJPT DJFOUÓmDPT oEFCJ
EBNFOUF NBHOJmDBEPT QPS MPT NFEJPT
EFDPNVOJDBDJØOTPDJBMDPONPUJWPEF
IBCFSTFDPOTFHVJEPMBTFDVFODJBDJØOEFM
HFOPNBIVNBOPoZQPSMBTQPTJCJMJEB
EFT BCJFSUBT QPS MPT USBCBKPT SFMBDJPOB
EPTDPOMBTDÏMVMBTUSPODBMFTTUFNDFMMT
Z TVT QSPTQFDUJWBT QPTJCJMJEBEFT QBSB
SFHFOFSBS UFKJEPT IVNBOPT MFTJPOBEPT
P EFHFOFSBEPT &M FOUVTJBTNP QPS MBT
QPTJCJMJEBEFT EF RVF VO EÓB QPEBNPT
QSFWFOJS F JODMVTP DVSBS FOGFSNFEB
EFT EFHFOFSBUJWBT EFM TJTUFNB OFSWJPTP
DFOUSBM QSPEVDF MB JMVTJØO EF RVF TJ MP
RVFSFNPTMPMPHSBSFNPT)PZNÈTRVF
OVODBDPSSFNPTFMQFMJHSPEFTVCPSEJ
OBS MB EJHOJEBE IVNBOB Z FM SFTQFUP B
MBT QFSTPOBT B MB DPOTFDVDJØO EF VOPT
MPHSPT DJFOUÓmDPT )PZ NÈT RVF OVO
DB UFOFNPT MB PCMJHBDJØO EF QFOTBS FM
NPEFMP EF TPDJFEBE RVF RVFSFNPT BM
IBDFSOVFTUSBTPQDJPOFTÏUJDBTZKVSÓEJ
DBT&OMBTPQDJPOFTÏUJDBTUBOUPMPTRVF
DPOGÓBONÈTFOMBOFVUSBMJEBEBYJPMØHJDB
EF MB DJFODJB DPNP RVJFOFT DPOTJEFSBO
PERSPETIVADELABIOETICAINDD
DPNP QSJODJQJP EF MB DPOEVDUB QSPGF
TJPOBMDPSSFDUBVOBÏUJDBEFSFTQPOTBCJ
MJEBETPDJBMFTUÈOEFBDVFSEPFOBQMJDBS
FMQSJODJQJPEFQSFDBVDJØOQPOEFSBOEP
MBTDPOTFDVFODJBTEFBQMJDBDJPOFTQSFDJ
QJUBEBTEFOVFWBTUFDOPMPHÓBTCJPHFOÏUJ
DBT&TUBBDUJUVEQPSDPOWJDDJØOPQPS
FM UFNPS RVF JOTQJSBO MBT QPTJCJMJEBEFT
EFTVVUJMJ[BDJØODPOmOFTCÏMJDPTFTFT
QFSBO[BEPSB
1PTUVMBNPT MB FOUSFHB EF JOGPSNBDJØO
BEFDVBEBZTVmDJFOUFFOUPEPTMPTOJWF
MFTEFMBTPDJFEBEQBSBRVFÏTUBQVFEB
GPSNBSTFVOBJEFBEFWFOUBKBTJODPOWF
OJFOUFTZQPTJCMFTSJFTHPTBMJOWFTUJHBSP
EFTBSSPMMBS VOB OVFWB UFDOPMPHÓB "EF
NÈTFTOFDFTBSJPFTQFDJmDBSQBSBRVJÏ
OFTTFSÈOMBTWFOUBKBTZQBSBRVJÏOFTMPT
JODPOWFOJFOUFT
3BDJPOBMJEBEÏUJDPSFMJHJPTB
-BT QPTJCJMJEBEFT RVF PGSFDFO MBT UFD
OPMPHÓBT CJPHFOÏUJDBT DSFBO JORVJFUVE
BMJNFOUBEB QPS MB QPTJCMF MFHJUJNBDJØO
DJFOUÓmDBTPDJBMÏUJDBZKVSÓEJDB1BSUJ
DJQBSFOFMEJÈMPHPCJPÏUJDPTVQPOFFTUBS
EJTQVFTUP B IBDFSTF QFSNFBCMF B PUSBT
QFSTQFDUJWBT SFWJTBS MPT KVJDJPT QSFWJPT
RVFQPSFMUJFNQPMPTDBNCJPTDPODFQ
UVBMFT P MB FWPMVDJØO DVMUVSBM QVFEFO
DPOTJEFSBSTF BOBDSØOJDPT &T OFDFTBSJB
VOBQVFTUBBMEÓBEFMPTDPOPDJNJFOUPT
DJFOUÓmDPTÏUJDPTZUFPMØHJDPT
&O UPEBT MBT SBDJPOBMJEBEFT OP FT TPS
QSFOEFOUF RVF FYJTUBO QPMBSJ[BDJPOFT
FOUSF MPT DJVEBEBOPT USBEVDJEBT FO MBT
DBNQB×BTQBSBMBTFMFDDJPOFTEFMPTSF
QSFTFOUBOUFT FO MBT $PSUFT FTQB×PMBT
%JOBNJTNPEFMEJÈMPHPCJPÏUJDPFO&TQB×B'SBODFTD"CFM4+Z/VSJB5FSSJCBT
-PRVFSFTVMUBTPSQSFOEFOUFFTRVFMPT
BOUBHPOJTNPT NÈT GVFSUFT QSPDFEBO EF
MBSFTJTUFODJBBBDFQUBSMBTFQBSBDJØOFO
USF*HMFTJBZ&TUBEPQPSQBSUFEFNVDIPT
DJVEBEBOPT mSNFNFOUF BQPZBEPT QPS
VOTFDUPSEFMFQJTDPQBEPOPTUÈMHJDPEFM
OBDJPOBMDBUPMJDJTNP Z UFNFSPTP EF MB
UÏDOJDBZEFTVTQPTJCMFTBCVTPT&WJEFO
UFNFOUF FTUP JNQSFHOB MBT EJTDVTJPOFT
EFQSPZFDUPTEFMFZTPCSFUPEPEFBRVF
MMPTRVFNÈTJODJEFODJBUJFOFOTPCSFMB
WJEBIVNBOBZMBGBNJMJB
3BDJPOBMJEBEKVSÓEJDPQPMÓUJDB
&O MPT ÞMUJNPT B×PT TF IBO QSPEVDJEP
USBOTGPSNBDJPOFT TVTUBODJBMFT FO MPT
TJTUFNBT TBOJUBSJPT NPEFSOPT 6OP EF
MPT QSJODJQBMFT BHFOUFT EF FTUF DBNCJP
FO &VSPQB FTQFDJBMNFOUF FO &TQB×B
FTFMDJVEBEBOPDVBOEPTFDPOWJFSUFFO
QBDJFOUF
&TUFQBÓTIBEFTBSSPMMBEPVOBMFHJTMBDJØO
JNQPSUBOUF EF SFDPOPDJNJFOUP EF MPT
EFSFDIPTEFMPTQBDJFOUFTFOMBBTJTUFODJB
TBOJUBSJBDPNPFYQSFTJØOEFMQSJODJQJP
EFBVUPOPNÓBCBKPMBmHVSBEFMEFSFDIP
BMBJOGPSNBDJØOZBMDPOTFOUJNJFOUPJO
GPSNBEP -B 'VOEBDJØO #JCMJPUFDB +P
TFQ-BQPSUF'#+-
oMJEFSBEBQPS"MCFSU
+PWFMM B USBWÏT EF JOJDJBUJWBT DPNP FM
'PSP&TQB×PMEF1BDJFOUFTRVFBHSVQB
BNÈTEFBTPDJBDJPOFTEFQBDJFOUFT
EFEJWFSTBTQBUPMPHÓBTBTÓDPNPBGBNJ
MJBSFTZWPMVOUBSJPT
ZMB6OJWFSTJEBEEF
1BDJFOUFTo GBDJMJUB MB GPSNBDJØO F JO
DSFNFOUBFMDPOPDJNJFOUPEFMPTDJVEB
7FSTJUJPXXXXFCQBDJFOUFTPSH
7FSTJUJPXXXVOJWFSTJEBEQBDJFOUFTPSH
PERSPETIVADELABIOETICAINDD
EBOPTVTVBSJPTEFMBTBOJEBESFTQFDUP
EFFOGFSNFEBEFTZTFSWJDJPTTBOJUBSJPT
#BKPMBEJSFDDJØOEF"MCFSU0SJPM#PTDI
TFIBIFDIPVOHSBOFTGVFS[PFOUPEPT
MPTFTUBNFOUPTQBSBBOBMJ[BSDSÓUJDBNFO
UFMBTBOJEBEFO&TQB×BFMQBQFMEFMBT
QSPGFTJPOFT TBOJUBSJBT Z FM DJVEBEBOP
DPNP OVFWP QSPUBHPOJTUB EFM TJTUFNB
4POJOJDJBUJWBTRVFSFBMNFOUFUJFOEFO
QVFOUFT BOUF VO GVUVSP RVF RVFSFNPT
NÈTTBMVEBCMFZNFKPS0SJPM
&OMBMÓOFBEFMBFYJHFODJBÏUJDB1BCMP
4JNØO-PSEBMVDIBQBSBDPOTFHVJSRVF
MBCJPÏUJDBEFMJCFSFTPCSFMPTWBMPSFTSF
MFWBOUFT EF MB PSHBOJ[BDJØO TBOJUBSJB
RVF MB EFmOFO JOUFSOBNFOUF Z MB EJGF
SFODJBOFYUFSOBNFOUFFOPSEFOBDPO
WFSUJSMBFOVOBJOTUJUVDJØOEFFYDFMFODJB
4JNØO 4JHVF DPO FMMP MB MÓOFB
USB[BEBQPSMPTDBUFESÈUJDPTEF²UJDBEF
7BMFODJB"EFMB$PSUJOBZ+FTÞT$POJMM
$PSUJOBZ$POJMM
%FTEFFMQVOUPEFWJTUBEFMBMFHJTMBDJØO
TPONVDIBTMBTEJTQPTJDJPOFTZOPSNBT
DPOSBOHPEFMFZQSPNVMHBEBTFO&TQB×B
EFTEFMPTB×PTZRVFBGFDUBOBUFNBT
CJPÏUJDPT 6OB DBSBDUFSÓTUJDB DPNÞO FT
MBEFUPNBSDPNPNPEFMPMPTQSPZFDUPT
EF-FZZMFHJTMBDJPOFTNÈTQSPHSFTJTUBTZ
MJCFSBMFTEF&VSPQB
t
5SBTQMBOUFT &M 3FBM %FDSFUP
EFEFEJDJFNCSFEF
SFHVMB MB EPOBDJØO FYUSBD
DJØO Z USBTQMBOUF EF ØSHBOPT IV
NBOPT BTÓ DPNP MB DPPSEJOBDJØO
UFSSJUPSJBM QBSB MMFWBS B DBCP FTUBT
BDUJWJEBEFTZTJHVFFOWJHPSMB-FZ
1FSTQFDUJWBTEFMB#JPÏUJDBFO*CFSPBNÏSJDB
t
t
t
EF EF PDUVCSF TPCSF
FYUSBDDJØOZUSBTQMBOUFEFØSHBOPT
5FSSJCBT
5FDOPMPHÓBT EF SFQSPEVDDJØO BTJT
UJEB-FZEFEFNBZP
TPCSF 5ÏDOJDBT EF 3FQSPEVD
DJØO )VNBOB "TJTUJEB 5FSSJCBT
*OWFTUJHBDJØO DPO TFSFT IVNBOPT
&TQB×B EJTQPOF EF VOB MFHJTMBDJØO
FTQFDÓmDB RVF SFHVMB UPEB QSÈDUJDB
EFJOWFTUJHBDJØODPOTVKFUPTIVNB
OPT QBSB MB VUJMJ[BDJØO EF OVFWPT
GÈSNBDPT Z QSPEVDUPT TBOJUBSJPT
4F SFDPHJØ FO MB -FZ EFM
.FEJDBNFOUP Z TF EFTBSSPMMØ QPT
UFSJPSNFOUF FO FM 3FBM %FDSFUP
EFEFGFCSFSPTPCSF&O
TBZPT$MÓOJDPTDPOFMmOEFBEBQUBS
MB OPSNBUJWB B MB DPSSFTQPOEJFOUF
EJSFDUJWBEFMB6OJØO&VSPQFB4JO
FNCBSHPFOFMDBNQPEFMBJOWFT
UJHBDJØOCJPNÏEJDBEFCFNPTNFO
DJPOBS FM 1SPZFDUP EF -FZ RVF TF
FODVFOUSB ZB FO BWBO[BEP USÈNJUF
EFEJTDVTJØOQBSMBNFOUBSJB
%FSFDIPT EF MPT QBDJFOUFT &M QSJ
NFS UFYUP QSPNVMHBEP GVF MB -FZ
(FOFSBM EF 4BOJEBE EF
EFBCSJMBSUTZ
DPOVOB
FYQMJDJUBDJØONBZPSZNÈTSJHVSPTB
FO MB -FZ TPCSF MB JOGPS
NBDJØOBVUPOPNÓBEFMQBDJFOUFZ
EPDVNFOUBDJØO DMÓOJDB 5FSSJCBT
&O FM ÈNCJUP FTQB×PM MPT
HPCJFSOPTBVUØOPNPTDPODPNQF
UFODJBT FO TBOJEBE IBO BCPSEBEP
UBNCJÏO FTUB DVFTUJØO TJFOEP FM
QSJNFSP FM EF MB $PNVOJEBE "V
UØOPNB EF $BUBMV×B DPO MB -FZ
PERSPETIVADELABIOETICAINDD
t
t
t
RVF SFHVMØ QPS QSJNFSB
WF[MPTEPDVNFOUPTEFWPMVOUBEFT
BOUJDJQBEBT "EWBODFE %JSFDUJWFT
DPNP JOTUSVNFOUP EF SFTQFUP B MB
BVUPOPNÓB EFM QBDJFOUF 5FSSJCBT
1SPUFDDJØOEFEBUPTQFSTPOBMFT4F
QSPNVMHØ MB -FZ EF EFEJDJFNCSFTPCSF1SPUFDDJØOEF
%BUPT EF $BSÈDUFS 1FSTPOBM RVF
BGFDUBBUPEBTMBTDVFTUJPOFTEFDPO
mEFODJBMJEBE5FSSJCBT
$ØEJHP 1FOBM &O FTQFDJBM BRVF
MMBTmHVSBTRVFDBFOEFOUSPEFMPT
UFNBT EF FTUVEJP EF MB CJPÏUJDB
&OUSF FMMBT DJUBNPT "CPSUP BSU
B "VYJMJP BM TVJDJEJP Z
FVUBOBTJBBSU
"CFMZ5FSSJ
CBT"SNFOHPMFUBM
-FTJPOFTBMGFUPBSUTZ
.BOJQVMBDJØOHFOÏUJDBBSUTZ
TT
%FOFHBDJØOEFBTJTUFODJBTBOJ
UBSJBBSU
2VJFCSBEFMTFDSFUP
QSPGFTJPOBMBSU
$POWFOJP&VSPQFPTPCSF%FSFDIPT
)VNBOPT Z #JPNFEJDJOB SBUJmDBEP QPS FM 1BSMBNFOUP FT
QB×PM FO FOUSØ FO WJHPS FO
4FUSBUBEFVOBOPSNBEFÈN
CJUPFVSPQFPZBRVFMMPTQBÓTFTRVF
MBIBZBOmSNBEPZSBUJmDBEPEFCFO
BEBQUBSTVTEJTQPTJDJPOFTJOUFSOBTB
TVT DPOUFOJEPT RVF SFHVMBO DVFT
UJPOFTDPNPFMDPOTFOUJNJFOUPMBT
WPMVOUBEFT BOUJDJQBEBT MB JOWFTUJ
HBDJØO DPO TVKFUPT IVNBOPT FUD
" MB GFDIB MB MFHJTMBDJØO FTQB×PMB
SFGFSFODJBEBZBIBTJEPBEBQUBEBFO
TV JOUFHSJEBE B MPT QSJODJQJPT EFM
$POWFOJP
%JOBNJTNPEFMEJÈMPHPCJPÏUJDPFO&TQB×B'SBODFTD"CFM4+Z/VSJB5FSSJCBT
3FGFSFODJBT
"CFM'
#JPÏUJDB0SÓHFOFTQSFTFOUFZGVUVSP.BESJE*OTUJUVU#PSKBEF#JPÒUJDBZ
'VOEBDJØO.BQGSFEF.FEJDJOB
"CFM'5FSSJCBT/FUBM
)BDJBVOBQPTJCMFEFTQFOBMJ[BDJØOEFMBFVUBOBTJB
#JPÒUJDB%FCBUQQ
"SNFOHPM3#PMBEFSBT.FUBM
*OGPSNFTPCSFMwFVUBOËTJBJMwBKVEBBMTVÕDJEJ
#BSDFMPOB1SPVT4DJFODF
#BSSFBV)
#JPÏUIJRVFFUÏUIJRVFEFMBWJF/35-FVWFO)FSWÏ
$BNQT7
-BWPMVOUBEEFWJWJS#BSDFMPOB"SJFM
$POJMM + ²UJDB Z FNQSFTB TBOJUBSJB &O 'FSSFS ++ .BSUÓOF[ +- &ET
#JPÏUJDB 6O EJÈMPHP QMVSBM )PNFOBKF B +BWJFS (BGP 4+ .BESJE 6OJWFSTJEBE
1POUJGJDJB$PNJMMBTQQ
$PSUJOB"
²UJDB.ÓOJNB*OUSPEVDDJØOBMBGJMPTPGÓBQSÈDUJDB.BESJE5FDOPT4"
$PSUJOB " $POJMM + %FNPDSBDJB QBSUJDJQBUJWB Z TPDJFEBE DJWJM VOB ÏUJDB
FNQSFTBSJBM#PHPUÈ4JHMPEFM)PNCSF4FSJF$POWFSTBDJPOFT
%F 8BDUIFS . 3FWJTJUJOH UIF 0SJHJOT &"$.& /FXTMFUUFS "QSJM
.BBTUSJDIU
(BGP+
#JPÏUJDBUFPMØHJDB.BESJE61$Z%FTDMÏFEF#SPXFS
(BGP+
&MBCPSUPZFMDPNJFO[PEFMBWJEBIVNBOB4BOUBOEFS4BM5FSSBF
(SBDJB%
1SPDFEJNJFOUPTEFEFDJTJØOFOÏUJDBDMÓOJDB.BESJE&VEFNB
(SBDJB%
%FMBCJPÏUJDBDMÓOJDBBMBCJPÏUJDBHMPCBMUSFJOUBB×PTEFFWPMVDJØO
4FMFDDJPOFTEF#JPÏUJDB#PHPUÈ*OTUJUVUPEF#JPÏUJDB$&/"-#&
(SBDJB%
$POUSJCVDJØOEFMBTIVNBOJEBEFTNÏEJDBTBMBGPSNBDJØOEFMNÏEJDP
)VNBOJUBT )VNBOJEBEFT .ÏEJDBT %JTQPOJCMF FO IUUQXXXGVOEBDJPONIN
PSHSFWJTUBIUNM$POTVMUBEPFMEFKVOJPEF
(SBDJB%
'VOEBNFOUPTEF#JPÏUJDB.BESJE&VEFNB
+POBT)
5PXBSEB1IJMPTPQIZPG5FDIOPMPHZ)BTUJOHT$FOU3FQ'FC
QQ
-BDBEFOB+3
#JPÏUJDBZ3FMJHJØO+BWJFS(BGP4+*O.FNPSJBN&O+BWJFS
(BGP3FMBUPEFVOIPNCSFQPSMBDJFODJB3FWJTUB-BUJOPBNFSJDBOBEF#JPÏUJDB/¡
OÞNFSPNPOPHSÈGJDP
$PMPNCJB6OJWFSTJEBE.JMJUBS/VFWB(SBOBEB
-BDBEFOB+3
)JTUPSJBi/PCFMBEBwEFMBHFOÏUJDBDPODFQUPZNÏUPEP%JTDVSTPEF
JOHSFTPDPNP"DBEÏNJDPEFOÞNFSPFOMB3FBM"DBEFNJBEF'BSNBDJB.BESJE
3FBM"DBEFNJBEF'BSNBDJB
-BDBEFOB +3 -B -FZ TPCSF UÏDOJDBT EF SFQSPEVDDJØO IVNBOB BTJTUJEB
$POTJEFSBDJPOFTDJFOUÓGJDBTZÏUJDBT%FSFDIPZ(FOPNB)VNBOP
PERSPETIVADELABIOETICAINDD
1FSTQFDUJWBTEFMB#JPÏUJDBFO*CFSPBNÏSJDB
0SJPM"
-MJCSF#MBODEFMFTPSHBOJU[BDJPOTTBOJUËSJFT#BSDFMPOB(FOFSBMJUBUEF
$BUBMVOZB
1PUUFS 73 #JPFUIJDT 5IF 4DJFODF PG 4VSWJWBM 1FSTQFDUJWFT JO #JPMPHZ BOE
.FEJDJOFQQ
3FJDI8
&ODZDMPQFEJBPG#JPFUIJDT7PM/VFWB:PSL.BD.JMMBO
3FOEUPSGG+%,FNQ1&ET
#BTJD&UIJDBM1SJODJQMFTJOFVSPQFBOCJPFUIJDT
BOECJPMBX7PM$PQFOIBHFO%FONBSL$FOUFSGPS&UIJDTBOE-BX#BSDFMPOB
*OTUJUVU#PSKBEF#JPÒUJDB
4JNPO1&E
²UJDBEFMBTPSHBOJ[BDJPOFTTBOJUBSJBT/VFWPTNPEFMPTEFDBMJEBE
.BESJE5SJBDBTUFMB
5FSSJCBT/
/VFWB-FZEF1SPUFDDJØOEF%BUPT1FSTPOBMFT-BCPS)PTQJUBMBSJB
QQ
5FSSJCBT/
/VFWBSFHVMBDJØOTPCSFUSBTQMBOUFEFØSHBOPT-BCPS)PTQJUBMBSJB
QQ
5FSSJCBT/
%FTUJOPTEFMPTFNCSJPOFTTPCSBOUFTEF53)"#JPÒUJDB%FCBU
QQ
5FSSJCBT/
%FSFDIPTDPOSBOHPEFMFZQSPTZDPOUSBTEFMB-FZCÈTJDB
#JPÒUJDB%FCBUQQ
5FSSJCBT/
-BTWPMVOUBEFTBOUJDJQBEBTZTVFTQFDJBMDPOTJEFSBDJØOFOFMQBDJFOUF
HFSJÈUSJDP3FWJTUB&TQB×PMBEF(FSJBUSÓBZ(FSPOUPMPHÓBNPOPHSÈGJDPEFCJPÏUJDB
EJDJFNCSFQQ
5FSSJCBT/
-BTWPMVOUBEFTBOUJDJQBEBTZTVQSPCMFNÈUJDBFOMBBQMJDBDJØOQSÈDUJDB
4BMVE 1ÞCMJDB Z %FSFDIP "ENJOJTUSBUJWP .BESJE $POTFKP (FOFSBM EFM 1PEFS
+VEJDJBM$VBEFSOPTEF%FSFDIP+VEJDJBMQQ
5FSSJCBT/
$ØNPTFFMBCPSBVOEPDVNFOUPEFWPMVOUBEFTBOUJDJQBEBT'PSNBDJØO
.ÏEJDB$POUJOVBEB#BSDFMPOBZ.BESJE%PZNBQQ
7J×BT+
3FQUFTEFMBDJSVSHJBBMTFHMF99*#BSDFMPOB3FBM"DBEÒNJBEF.FEJDJOB
EF$BUBMVOZB
8FSU(EF#FSHINBOT31-#PFS(+FUBM
&UIJDBMHVJEBODFPOIVNBO
FNCSZPOJDBOEGFUBMUJTTVFUSBOTQMBOUBUJPO"&VSPQFBOPWFSWJFX.FEJDJOF)FBMUI
$BSFBOE1IJMPTPQIZQQ
8PSME$PVODJMPG$IVSDIFT8$$
8PSME$POGFSFODFPO$IVSDIBOE4PDJFUZ
$ISJTUJBOT JO UIF 5FDIOJDBM BOE 4PDJBM 3FWPMVUJPOT PG PVS 5JNF 4BOUBOEFS 4BM
5ÏSSBF
8$$
$POGFSFODFPO'BJUI4DJFODFBOE'VUVSF7PM1MFOBSZ1SFTFOUBUJPO
3FQPSUTBOE3FDPNFOEBUJPOT$BNCSJEHF.BTTBDIVTFUUT64".*5
PERSPETIVADELABIOETICAINDD
1BOPSBNBNFYJDBOPEFMEFTBSSPMMPEFMBCJPÏUJDB
-BNFEJDJOBHFOØNJDBFO.ÏYJDPDPNPVOPEFMPT
NBZPSFTSFUPTCJPÏUJDPT
(FSBSEP+JNÏOF[4ÈODIF[$ÏTBS-BSB«MWBSF[Z"MCFSUP"SFMMBOP.ÏOEF[
1MBOUFBNJFOUPEFMQSPCMFNB
"
VORVFIBOQBTBEPNÈTEFUSFTEÏDB
EBTEFTEFRVFJOJDJØFTUBOVFWBEJT
DJQMJOBOPFYJTUFVODPODFQUPVOÓWPDPZ
EFVTPVOJWFSTBM&O"NÏSJDB-BUJOBIBZ
VODPOTFOTPNÈTPNFOPTHFOFSBMJ[BEP
EFRVFMBCJPÏUJDBFTiFMFTUVEJPEFMPTWB
MPSFTIVNBOPTZTVSFMBDJØODPOMBDJFODJB
ZMBUFDOPMPHÓBBQMJDBEBBEJWFSTPTÈNCJUPT
EFMBWJEBw,VUIZ
&ODJFSUB
GPSNBTFDPOTJEFSBRVFJOUFOUBIVNBOJ
[BSFMEFTBSSPMMPDJFOUÓmDPFTUBCMFDJFOEP
SFMBDJPOFT EJOÈNJDBT FOUSF MPT EFTBSSP
MMPTDJFOUÓmDPUFDOPMØHJDPTZMBTDJFODJBT
IVNBOÓTUJDBTQBSBMMFHBSBVOFRVJMJCSJP
FOUSFFMBWBODFEFMBDJFODJBZMPTMÓNJUFT
FOMPTDVBMFTEFCFEFQSPHSFTBS
-BDPOTUSVDDJØOEFMBCJPÏUJDBFO
.ÏYJDP
0SÓHFOFTEFMBCJPÏUJDBFO
.ÏYJDP.BOVFM7FMBTDP4VÈSF[
4F SFDPOPDF B .BOVFM 7FMBTDP4VÈ
SF[DPNPFMJOJDJBEPSEFMBCJPÏUJDBFO
.ÏYJDP'VFVOIPNCSFEFDJFODJBZEF
MFUSBTBVUPSEFTFJTMJCSPTZNÈTEF
USBCBKPTDJFOUÓmDPTQVCMJDBEPTFOSFWJT
UBTFTQFDJBMJ[BEBTUBOUPOBDJPOBMFTDPNP
PERSPETIVADELABIOETICAINDD
JOUFSOBDJPOBMFT %JDUØ NÈT EF DPOGFSFODJBTFO.ÏYJDPZFOFMNVOEP
GVFNJFNCSPEFNÈTEFTPDJFEBEFTZ
BDBEFNJBTEFNFEJDJOB$BSSBTDP3PKBT
"TJNJTNPSFDJCJØNÞM
UJQMFTDPOEFDPSBDJPOFTZEJTUJODJPOFTEF
BTPDJBDJPOFTVOJWFSTJEBEFTPSHBOJTNPT
QÞCMJDPTZQSJWBEPTBMSFEFEPSEFMNVO
EP BEFNÈT EF IBCFS TJEP HBMBSEPOBEP
DPOWBSJPTUÓUVMPTIPOPSBSJPTPUPSHBEPT
QPSHPCJFSOPTEFEJGFSFOUFTQBÓTFT
.BOVFM7FMBTDP4VÈSF[DSFØFONBS[P
EFKVOUPDPOFMFOUPODFT4FDSFUB
SJPEF4BMVE+FTÞT,VNBUF3PESÓHVF[MB
$PNJTJØO/BDJPOBMEF#JPÏUJDB$/#
1PTUFSJPSNFOUF FO GVF NJFN
CSPGVOEBEPSZQSJNFSQSFTJEFOUFEFMB
"DBEFNJB/BDJPOBM.FYJDBOBEF#JPÏ
UJDB"/.#
.BUFPT
&TUFFOUVTJBTUBQSPNPUPSEFMBCJPÏUJDB
FO.ÏYJDPBmSNBCBi-BCJPÏUJDBJOUF
SBDUÞBFOUSFMPTTJTUFNBTCJPMØHJDPTRVF
PCFEFDFO MFZFT GÓTJDBT Z MB DPODJFODJB
ÏUJDPNPSBM 4JO UFOFS SFMBDJØO DPO MBT
MFZFT GÓTJDBT QPOEFSB MB DPOEVDUB EF
RVJFOFT JOUFSWJFOFO P JOUFSmFSFO DPO
MBWJEB/PFTMBAÏUJDBEFMBWJEBTJOP
EFMFTUVEJPZMBSFnFYJØOTJTUFNÈUJDPTEF
MBDPOEVDUBIBDJBMBWJEBMBTBMVEZMPT
1FSTQFDUJWBTEFMB#JPÏUJDBFO*CFSPBNÏSJDB
EFSFDIPTIVNBOPTBMBMV[EFMPTBWBO
DFTEFMBTDJFODJBTCJPMØHJDBTZMBTOFDF
TBSJBTSFnFYJPOFTmMPTØmDBTEFMBÏUJDBw
7FMBTDP4VÈSF[
&O TF JOTUJUVZØ MB i#FDB .BOVFM
7FMBTDP4VÈSF[FO#JPÏUJDBwDSFBEBQPS
MB'VOEBDJØO1BOBNFSJDBOBEF4BMVEZ
&EVDBDJØO FO DPPQFSBDJØO DPO MB 0S
HBOJ[BDJØO 1BOBNFSJDBOB EF MB 4BMVE
014 QBSB FTUJNVMBS FOUSF MPT KØWFOFT
EPDFOUFT F JOWFTUJHBEPSFT FM EFTBSSPMMP
EFTVTDBQBDJEBEFTEFBOÈMJTJTCJPÏUJDP
-B$PNJTJØO/BDJPOBMEF
#JPÏUJDB
4ØMPIBTUBTFMFDPODFEFBMB$/#
FMDBSÈDUFSEFQFSNBOFOUF&MEFOP
WJFNCSFEFFM4FDSFUBSJPEF4BMVE
FOUVSOPEFTJHOBPmDJBMNFOUFB.BOVFM
7FMBTDP4VÈSF[ TFDSFUBSJP FKFDVUJWP EF
MBNJTNB1BSBTFQUJFNCSFEFMB
$/#BERVJFSFDBSÈDUFSEFØSHBOPEFT
DPODFOUSBEP EF MB 4FDSFUBSÓB EF 4BMVE
44"
DPOBVUPOPNÓBUÏDOJDBZPQFSB
UJWB-B$/#FTBDUVBMNFOUFMBSFTQPO
TBCMFEFEFmOJSMBQPMÓUJDBNFYJDBOBRVF
QMBOUFBFTUBEJTDJQMJOB4VTPCKFUJWPTTPO
FTUBCMFDFSMBTQPMÓUJDBTQÞCMJDBTEFTBMVE
WJODVMBEBTDPOMBCJPÏUJDBGVOHJSDPNP
ØSHBOP EF DPOTVMUB OBDJPOBM TPCSF UF
NBT FTQFDÓmDPT EF CJPÏUJDB Z QSPQJDJBS
EFCBUFTTPCSFDVFTUJPOFTCJPÏUJDBTDPOMB
QBSUJDJQBDJØOEFMPTEJWFSTPTTFDUPSFTEF
MBTPDJFEBEFOUSFPUSPT
"MBNVFSUFEFTVQSJNFSQSFTJEFOUFFKF
DVUJWP'FSOBOEP$BOP7BMMFTFFODBSHØ
EFTVEJSFDDJØODSFBOEPMBSFWJTUB4VN
NB #JPÏUJDB ØSHBOP PmDJBM EF EJGVTJØO
PERSPETIVADELABIOETICAINDD
EFMB$/#1PTUFSJPSNFOUF+VBO(BS
[B3BNPTBTVNJØEFGPSNBJOUFSJOBTV
TFDSFUBSÓBFKFDVUJWBIBTUBRVFFO
(VJMMFSNP 4PCFSØO"DFWFEP PDVQØ FM
QVFTUPEFEJSFDUPSFKFDVUJWPDBSHPRVF
EFTFNQF×BBDUVBMNFOUF
&OUSF MPT MPHSPT NÈT JNQPSUBOUFT EF
MB $/# TF FODVFOUSBO MB PSHBOJ[BDJØO
EFTJFUFDPOHSFTPTFOUSFZ
i#JPÏUJDB4BMVE%FSFDIPT)VNBOPTZ
3FTQPOTBCJMJEBE $JFOUÓmDBw i-B $VM
UVSB #JPÏUJDB QBSB FM %FTBSSPMMP )V
NBOPwi-B#JPÏUJDBFO'JOEFM4JHMPZ
)BDJBFM/VFWP.JMFOJPwi-B#JPÏUJDB
EFMBT$JFODJBTQBSBFM%FTBSSPMMPEFMB
$PODJFODJB )VNBOBw i#JP²UJDB EF
MPTBDPOUFDJNJFOUPTEFMB7JEB)VNB
OB%FMB"VSPSBBM0DBTPEFMB7JEBw
i#JPÏUJDBFOMB$BMJEBEEFMB"UFODJØO
.ÏEJDBwZi#JPÏUJDBFOMB$JFODJBZMB
4PDJFEBEw
%F MPT TFJT QSJNFSPT DPOHSFTPT TF QV
CMJDBSPO TVT SFTQFDUJWBT NFNPSJBT Z TF
DPOUØ DPO MB QBSUJDJQBDJØO BDUJWB EF
WBSJBT VOJWFSTJEBEFT NFYJDBOBT Z EFM
FYUSBOKFSP BEFNÈT EF VO TJOOÞNFSP
EF PSHBOJTNPT OBDJPOBMFT DPNP MB 4F
DSFUBSÓB EF 4BMVE 44"
FM *OTUJUVUP
.FYJDBOPEFM4FHVSP4PDJBM*.44
FM
*OTUJUVUP EF 4FHVSJEBE Z 4FSWJDJPT 4P
DJBMFT EF MPT 5SBCBKBEPSFT EFM &TUBEP
*4445&
FM4JTUFNB/BDJPOBMQBSBFM
%FTBSSPMMP*OUFHSBMEFMB'BNJMJB%*'
MBT 4FDSFUBSÓBT EF 4BMVE EF $IJBQBT
%JTUSJUP'FEFSBM+BMJTDPZ/VFWP-FØO
ZFM$FOUSPEF&TUVEJPTF*OWFTUJHBDJP
OFTEF#JPÏUJDBEF(VBEBMBKBSB$&*#
FOUSFPUSPT
1BOPSBNBNFYJDBOPEFMEFTBSSPMMPEFMBCJPÏUJDB(FSBSEP+JNÏOF[$ÏTBS-BSBZ"MCFSUP"SFMMBOP
&O FM ÈNCJUP JOUFSOBDJPOBM DPOUSJCV
ZFSPO B MB SFBMJ[BDJØO EF MBT SFVOJPOFT
MB 0SHBOJ[BDJØO .VOEJBM EF MB 4BMVE
0.4
MB 0SHBOJ[BDJØO 1BOBNFSJ
DBOB EF MB 4BMVE 014
FM 'POEP EF
MBT /BDJPOFT 6OJEBT QBSB MB *OGBODJB
6/*$&'
MB'FEFSBDJØO-BUJOPBNFSJ
DBOB EF *OTUJUVDJPOFT EF #JPÏUJDB '&
-"*#&
MB"TPDJBDJØO*OUFSOBDJPOBMEF
.ÏEJDPTQBSBMB1SFWFODJØOEFMB(VF
SSB/VDMFBS*11/8
ZFM.PWJNJFOUP
6OJWFSTBMEFMB3FTQPOTBCJMJEBE$JFOUÓ
mDB.634.ÏYJDP
%FMBTNFNPSJBTEFMPTFWFOUPTTFJOmF
SFOQVOUPTEFDPOFYJØOFOUSFMBCJPÏUJDB
ZMBSFTQPOTBCJMJEBEDJFOUÓmDBSFTBMUBOEP
RVFVOPEFMPTSBTHPTNÈTDBSBDUFSÓTUJDPT
EFMBUFDOPDJFODJBNPEFSOBDPOTJTUFFO
RVFTVEFTBSSPMMPTFEBFONFEJPEFDPO
USPWFSTJBTTPDJBMFTZDPOnJDUPTEFWBMPSFT
FOUSFMPTEJWFSTPTBHFOUFTRVFQBSUJDJQBO
FOTVDPOGPSNBDJØOFTEFDJSDPOnJDUPT
FOUSF MPT JOWFTUJHBEPSFT Z MB TPDJFEBE
QVFTUPRVFMBSFMBDJØOEFÏTUBDPOFMQP
EFSUFDOPDJFOUÓmDPTFIBNPEJmDBEPEF
MBTJNQMFBDFQUBDJØOQBTJWBZMBDPOmBO
[BQMFOBTFIBQBTBEPBMBQSFPDVQBDJØO
FJOUFSÏTQPSDPOUSPMBSTVTQPTJCMFTFGFD
UPTOFHBUJWPT
"VOBTÓFOMPTEJWFSTPT
DPOHSFTPTTFQVOUVBMJ[ØRVFFTUFNBSDP
EFDPOUSPWFSTJBTTPDJBMFTOPFTEFMUPEP
OVFWPZRVFUBNCJÏOIBCÓBTJEPTJHOJ
mDBUJWPFOFMDBTPEFMPTEFCBUFTBDFSDB
EFMBTFHVSJEBEEFMBJOEVTUSJBOVDMFBS
MB JOEVTUSJB RVÓNJDB P MB GBSNBDÏVUJDB
TFIBBHVEJ[BEPEFCJEPBMNBZPSJOUFSÏT
TPDJBMFOMPTSJFTHPTQBSBFMNFEJPBN
CJFOUFZMBTBMVEIVNBOBRVFDPOMMFWBO
MBTSFBMJ[BDJPOFTUFDOPDJFOUÓmDBT
PERSPETIVADELABIOETICAINDD
&O FTUPT TJFUF DPOHSFTPT QBSUJDJQBSPO
NÈTEFDPOGFSFODJBOUFTQSPDFEFOUFT
EF MVHBSFT DPNP "MFNBOJB "SHFOUJOB
#ÏMHJDB#SBTJM$BOBEÈ$IJMF$PMPN
CJB$PTUB3JDB$VCB&&66&TQB×B
'SBODJB (VBUFNBMB *OEJB *OHMBUFSSB
+BQØO .ÏYJDP /VFWB ;FMBOEB 1BOB
NÈ1FSÞ1PSUVHBM1VFSUP3JDP3FQÞ
CMJDB%PNJOJDBOB6SVHVBZZ7FOF[VF
MBUPEPTFMMPTBDBEÏNJDPTQSPGFTJPOBMFT
Z FTQFDJBMJTUBT QFSUFOFDJFOUFT B MBT NÈT
EJWFSTBTÈSFBTEFMTBCFSIVNBOP
-B$/#EF.ÏYJDPCBKPMBEJSFDDJØOEF
(VJMMFSNP4PCFSØO"DFWFEPIBUFOJEP
BDUVBDJPOFT JOUFSOBDJPOBMFT JNQPSUBO
UFTQPSFKFNQMPGVFMBSFQSFTFOUBOUFEF
.ÏYJDPQBSBDPMBCPSBSKVOUPDPOFM$P
NJUÏ *OUFSHVCFSOBNFOUBM EF &YQFSUPT
FO#JPÏUJDB$*(#
ZMB6/&4$0FOMB
FMBCPSBDJØOEFMB%FDMBSBDJØO6OJWFSTBM
EF#JPÏUJDBZ%FSFDIPT)VNBOPT
.ÈT SFDJFOUFNFOUF MB $/# QBSUJDJQØ
FOFMQSPZFDUP-BUJO"NFSJDBOBOE&V
SPQFBO&UIJDBM3FHVMBUJPO4ZTUFNTPG#JP
NFEJDBM3FTFBSDI$PNQBSBUJWF"OBMZTJTPG
UIFJS1FSUJOFODFBOE"QQMJDBUJPOGPS)V
NBO 4VCKFDUT 1SPUFDUJPO &6-"#03
RVFTVSHJØBQBSUJSEFMJOUFSÏTEFEJWFS
TPT QBÓTFT FVSPQFPT Z MBUJOPBNFSJDBOPT
EFFTUVEJBSBGPOEPTVTTJTUFNBTEFÏUJDB
FOJOWFTUJHBDJØODPNQBSUJSFYQFSJFODJBT
ZEJTF×BSOVFWPTFTRVFNBTQBSBSFTPMWFS
MPTEJMFNBTRVFQMBOUFBMBJOWFTUJHBDJØO
CJPNÏEJDB
$SFFNPTRVFFMNBZPSSFUPCJPÏUJDPFO
.ÏYJDP FT GPNFOUBS MB JOWFTUJHBDJØO
Z FOTF×BO[B DJFOUÓmDB FODBV[BEB FO FM
DBNJOP EF MB ÏUJDB 1PS UBOUP EFCF
1FSTQFDUJWBTEFMB#JPÏUJDBFO*CFSPBNÏSJDB
NPT EFTQMFHBS FTGVFS[PT QBSB NFKPSBS
MB DPNQSFOTJØO EF MPT QSPHSFTPT DJFO
UÓmDPTBMDBO[BEPTFOUFSSFOPTUBOOPWF
EPTPTDPNPMPTEFMBHFOÏUJDBIVNBOB
&T JNQPSUBOUF MB QBSUJDJQBDJØO EF MBT
JOTUJUVDJPOFT FEVDBUJWBT TPCSF UPEP FO
MPTQBÓTFTFOEFTBSSPMMPDPNPFMOVFTUSP
QBSB MB QSPNPDJØO Z MB NPEFSOJ[BDJØO
EFMBFOTF×BO[BEFMBDJFODJBZEFMBCJP
ÏUJDB
-BCJPÏUJDBFOMPTQSPHSBNBTEF
FTUVEJPEFMPTDFOUSPTFEVDBUJWPT
&O.ÏYJDPTFJNQBSUFOUSFTMJDFODJBUV
SBT PDIP NBFTUSÓBT Z VO EPDUPSBEP FO
#JPÏUJDBFMSFTUPEFMPTDVSTPTBVORVF
OPTPOFTQFDÓmDPTFOCJPÏUJDBTFSFmFSFO
B NBUFSJBT DVSSJDVMBSFT 4F IBO QPEJEP
JEFOUJmDBS DVSTPT ZP NBUFSJBT SF
MBDJPOBEBTDPOMBCJPÏUJDBRVFBQBSFDFO
FO EJGFSFOUFT OJWFMFT EF FTUVEJPT DPNP
TPO FM CBDIJMMFSBUP MJDFODJBUVSB NBFT
USÓB EPDUPSBEP QPTHSBEPT TFNJOBSJPT
ZPDVSTPTEFDBQBDJUBDJØOZDVSTPTPO
MJOF%FÏTUPTDVBUSPTPOBEJTUBODJBZ
FMSFTUPTPOQSFTFODJBMFTJNQBSUJÏOEPTF
FOEFMPTFTUBEPTEFMB3FQÞCMJDB
.FYJDBOB
"DFSDBEFMBEJTUSJCVDJØOQPSÈSFBTNÈT
EFMEFMBTNBUFSJBTTFJNQBSUFOFO
MBTGBDVMUBEFTEF.FEJDJOB&OGFSNFSÓB
0EPOUPMPHÓB 5SBCBKP 4PDJBM Z 1TJDP
MPHÓBFMSFTUPFOPUSBTDBSSFSBT&OFTUF
TFOUJEPFM*OTUJUVUPEF.FEJDJOB(FOØ
NJDB*/.&(&/
DPOFMmOEFQSP
NPWFSFMDPOPDJNJFOUPEFMPTQSJODJQJPT
CÈTJDPTEFMBTDJFODJBTHFOØNJDBTZTVT
BQMJDBDJPOFTQBSBNFKPSBSFMDVJEBEPEF
MBTBMVEIBJNQMFNFOUBEPEPTDVSTPTEF
PERSPETIVADELABIOETICAINDD
BMUBFTQFDJBMJEBE*OUSPEVDDJØOBMB.F
EJDJOB(FOØNJDBZ"QMJDBDJPOFT(FOØ
NJDBTFO.FEJDJOB*OUFSOB
ZVODVSTP
EFOUSPEFM1SPHSBNBEF.BFTUSÓBZ%PD
UPSBEPFO$JFODJBT.ÏEJDBT0EPOUPMØ
HJDBTZEFMB4BMVEEFMB6OJWFSTJEBE/B
DJPOBM"VUØOPNBEF.ÏYJDP6/".
"QMJDBDJPOFT(FOØNJDBTFO1FEJBUSÓB
VOBNBUFSJBEFFTUVEJPTÏUJDPTMFHBMFTZ
TPDJBMFTRVFQFSNJUFBMFTUVEJBOUFEFTB
SSPMMBS DSJUFSJPT DMBSPT TPCSF MPT MÓNJUFT
RVFQMBOUFBTVEFTBSSPMMP
%JWFSTPTHSVQPTDPMFHJBEPTEF
CJPÏUJDB
"QBSUFEFMB$/#FYJTUFOPUSPTHSVQPT
RVF IBO EFTUBDBEP FO MB DPOmHVSBDJØO
EFMBCJPÏUJDBFO.ÏYJDP/PUPEPTFMMPT
TF BVUPEFOPNJOBO DPNP UBMFT QFSP
QPSFMUJQPEFDVFTUJPOFTRVFBCPSEBOP
QPSMBFTUSVDUVSBZUBSFBTEFMPTNJTNPT
CJFO QVFEFO JODMVJSTF DPNP HSVQPT EF
FTUVEJPTCJPÏUJDPT
$PNJTJØO /BDJPOBM TPCSF FM (F
OPNB )VNBOP 'VF DSFBEB FM EF PDUVCSF EF DPO FM PCKFUP
EF BTFTPSBS BM 4FDSFUBSJP EF 4BMVE
FOEJGVTJØOEFQPMÓUJDBTZBDDJPOFT
SFMBUJWBT B MB JOWFTUJHBDJØO Z FOTF
×BO[BEFMBTDVFTUJPOFTSFMBUJWBTBM
HFOPNB IVNBOP &TUVWP JOUFHSB
EB QPS TFJT DPNJUÏT VOP EF FMMPT
EFEJDBEPBMFTUVEJPEFMPTBTVOUPT
ÏUJDPTMFHBMFTZTPDJBMFTDPOGPSNB
EP QPS MPT JOWFTUJHBEPSFT 3VCÏO
-:PVSLPXJU[LZ.BSDJB."MCB
.FESBOP.BSDP"OUPOJP"$BT
UJMMP"MFTTBOESB$$BOUPOJZ7ÓD
UPS . .BSUÓOF[ #VMMF(PZSJ -B
1BOPSBNBNFYJDBOPEFMEFTBSSPMMPEFMBCJPÏUJDB(FSBSEP+JNÏOF[$ÏTBS-BSBZ"MCFSUP"SFMMBOP
$PNJTJØOGVFEJTVFMUBFMEFBHPT
UPEFQPSEFDSFUPQSFTJEFODJBM
FO WJSUVE EF MB DSFBDJØO EFM */&
.&(&/
'VOEBDJØO .FYJDBOB QBSB MB 4B
MVE "$ '6/4"-6%
&T VOB
BTPDJBDJØO DJWJM TJO mOFT EF MVDSP
Z BM TFSWJDJP EF MB DPNVOJEBE JO
DMVJEB FO FM 3FHJTUSP /BDJPOBM EF
*OTUJUVDJPOFT Z &NQSFTBT $JFOUÓm
DBT Z 5FDOPMØHJDBT 3&/*&$:5
EFM$POTFKP/BDJPOBMEF$JFODJBZ
5FDOPMPHÓB$0/"$:5
4VNJ
TJØOFTDPOUSJCVJSBMDPOPDJNJFOUP
DJFOUÓmDPZUFDOPMØHJDPZBMFTUVEJP
EF QPMÓUJDBT FO NBUFSJB EF TBMVE
NFEJBOUF FM JNQVMTP EF MB JOWFT
UJHBDJØO MB GPSNBDJØO EF SFDVSTPT
IVNBOPTEFBMUPOJWFMZFMEFTBSSP
MMPUFDOPMØHJDP
)B SFBMJ[BEP FTUVEJPT TPCSF FM
iFTUBEP EFM BSUFw FO EJTUJOUPT QSP
CMFNBT EF TBMVE EFTUBDÈOEPTF MPT
QSPZFDUPT FO OVUSJDJØO FEVDBDJØO
QBSBMBTBMVEZNFEJDJOBHFOØNJDB
&OFTUFÞMUJNPUFNBEVSBOUFMBHFT
UJØOEF(VJMMFSNP4PCFSØO'6/
4"-6% QBSUJDJQØ BDUJWBNFOUF
KVOUPDPO+VMJP'SFOL.PSBoUJUVMBS
EFMB44"FOUSFZoZ(F
SBSEP+JNÏOF[4ÈODIF[oQSFTJEFOUF
EFM$POTPSDJP1SPNPUPSEFMB.F
EJDJOB(FOØNJDBFO.ÏYJDPoFOMB
DSFBDJØOEFM*/.&(&/
(SVQP EFM 1SPZFDUP 6OJWFSTJUBSJP
EFM(FOPNB)VNBOP16()
EF
MB 6/". $VFOUB DPO VO HSVQP
NVMUJEJTDJQMJOBSJPEFJOWFTUJHBDJØO
TPCSFFMHFOPNBIVNBOPRVFEJSJ
HFZBSUJDVMBMPTFTGVFS[PTRVFWJFOF
PERSPETIVADELABIOETICAINDD
SFBMJ[BOEP FTUB VOJWFSTJEBE TPCSF
FTUFUFNBZPUSPTBmOFT&M16()
JODMVZFQSPZFDUPTEFJOWFTUJHBDJØO
NVMUJEJTDJQMJOBSEFBQPZPUFDOPMØ
HJDPZBDUJWJEBEFTEFGPSNBDJØOEF
SFDVSTPT IVNBOPT FOUSFOBNJFOUP
Z DBQBDJUBDJØO BTÓ DPNP EJGVTJØO
FO MB DPNVOJEBE VOJWFSTJUBSJB EF
UFNBTEFCJPÏUJDB
$PNJTJØO *OUFSTFDSFUBSJBM EF #JP
TFHVSJEBE EF MPT 0SHBOJTNPT (F
OÏUJDBNFOUF.PEJmDBEPT$*#*0
(&.
&T FM HSVQP FTQFDJBMJ[BEP
EFJOGPSNBDJØOTPCSFTFHVSJEBEEF
MB CJPUFDOPMPHÓB RVF TF FODVFOUSB
EFOUSPEFMTJTUFNBEFM$POWFOJPEF
%JWFSTJEBE#JPMØHJDB&TUÈJOUFHSB
EBQPSDJFOUÓmDPTZFYQFSUPTTPCSF
CJPUFDOPMPHÓB NPEFSOB Z CJPTFHV
SJEBEZQPSSFQSFTFOUBOUFTEFFN
QSFTBSJPT TPDJFEBE DJWJM Z DÈNBSBT
EFDPNFSDJP
/ÞDMFP EF &TUVEJPT EF 4BMVE Z
%FSFDIP /&4%
EFM *OTUJUVUP
EF *OWFTUJHBDJPOFT +VSÓEJDBT EF MB
6/". 'VOEBEP FO QPS
'FSOBOEP $BOP 7BMMF WJODVMB EJ
WFSTPT EJTDVSTPT Z NFUPEPMPHÓBT
QPS NFEJP EF MB CJPÏUJDB Z MPT SF
MBDJPOBDPOFM%FSFDIP"MPMBSHP
EF MPT ÞMUJNPT B×PT FM /&4%
IBMPHSBEPSFVOJSBVOTJOOÞNFSP
EFFTQFDJBMJTUBTEFEJGFSFOUFTQBSUFT
EFM NVOEP FO FWFOUPT JOUFSOBDJP
OBMFT TFNJOBSJPT DPMPRVJPT DVS
TPTDPOGFSFODJBTZDMBVTUSPTBDBEÏ
NJDPT&TUFDFOUSPUJFOFVOBEFMBT
NÈTQSFTUJHJPTBTDBTBTFEJUPSJBMFTFO
UFNBT KVSÓEJDPT WJODVMBEPT DPO MB
CJPÏUJDB
1FSTQFDUJWBTEFMB#JPÏUJDBFO*CFSPBNÏSJDB
(SVQP*OUFSEJTDJQMJOBSEF#JPÏUJDB
EFMB6OJWFSTJEBE"VUØOPNB.F
USPQPMJUBOB $BNQVT 9PDIJNJMDP
6".9
%FTEF FOFSP EF IB SFBMJ[BEP NÈT EF VOB WFJOUFOB
EFDPOGFSFODJBTSFMBUJWBTBMBDJFODJB
HFOØNJDB Z B TV JNQBDUP TPDJBM Z
CJPÏUJDP
(SVQP EFM *OTUJUVUP 5FDOPMØHJDP
"VUØOPNP EF .ÏYJDP *5".
$PO VOB JEFOUJEBE BCJFSUBNFOUF
MBJDBTFIBEFTUBDBEPQPSTFSFMQSJ
NFSDFOUSPEFFTUVEJPTKVSÓEJDPTFO
JNQMFNFOUBS VO DVSTP EF CJPÏUJDB
EJSJHJEP B BCPHBEPT &TUF NJTNP
HSVQP IB SFBMJ[BEP BMHVOBT QVCMJ
DBDJPOFTFTQFDJBMJ[BEBTFOMBEJTDJ
QMJOB
(SVQPEF&TUVEJPT#JPÏUJDPTEFMB
6OJWFSTJEBE 1BOBNFSJDBOB 61
)B SFVOJEP B FTQFDJBMJTUBT FO MBT
ÈSFBT EF NFEJDJOB mMPTPGÓB Z %F
SFDIPQBSBIBDFSFTUVEJPTCJPÏUJDPT
EFTEFMBQFSTQFDUJWBDSJTUJBOBQFSTP
OBMJTUB
(SVQP EF &TUVEJPT EF MB 6OJWFS
TJEBE "OÈIVBD %F mMPTPGÓB DPO
TFSWBEPSB IB TJEP QJPOFSB FO FM
FTUVEJP EF MB CJPÏUJDB FO OVFTUSP
QBÓT&TUFHSVQPGVOEØEFOUSPEF
TVVOJWFSTJEBEMBTFHVOEBGBDVMUBE
EF CJPÏUJDB EFM NVOEP QSFDFEJEB
ÞOJDBNFOUFQPSMBEFM"UFOFP3FHJ
OB "QPTUPMPSVN EF 3PNB JNQBS
UJÏOEPTF MJDFODJBUVSB NBFTUSÓB Z
EPDUPSBEP
*OTUJUVUP 1PMJUÏDOJDP /BDJPOBM
*1/
+VOUP DPO MB 6/". FT
VOB JOTUJUVDJØO FEVDBUJWB MBJDB
HSBUVJUB MÓEFS FO MB HFOFSBDJØO
PERSPETIVADELABIOETICAINDD
BQMJDBDJØOEJGVTJØOZUSBOTGFSFODJB
EFM DPOPDJNJFOUP DJFOUÓmDP Z UFD
OPMØHJDPDSFBEBQBSBDPOUSJCVJSBM
EFTBSSPMMPFDPOØNJDPTPDJBMZQP
MÓUJDPEFMBOBDJØO'PSNBJOUFHSBM
NFOUF QSPGFTJPOBMFT FO MPT OJWFMFT
NFEJPTVQFSJPSTVQFSJPSZQPTHSB
EPSFBMJ[BJOWFTUJHBDJØOZFYUJFOEF
B MB TPDJFEBE TVT SFTVMUBEPT DPO
SFTQPOTBCJMJEBE ÏUJDB UPMFSBODJB Z
DPNQSPNJTP TPDJBM "VORVF FTUB
JOTUJUVDJØOOPUJFOFVOÞOJDPHSV
QP EF CJPÏUJDB SFDJFOUFNFOUF IB
DSFBEP MB .BFTUSÓB EF $JFODJBT FO
#JPÏUJDB
%FQBSUBNFOUPEF&TUVEJPTF*OWFT
UJHBDJPOFT EF #JPÏUJDB $&*#
EFM
*OTUJUVUP5FDOPMØHJDPZEF&TUVEJPT
4VQFSJPSFTEF0DDJEFOUF*5&40
$VFOUBDPOMBFTQFDJBMJEBEFOCJPÏ
UJDBJNQBSUJEBFOUSFTB×PTEFOUSP
EFMQSPHSBNBEFNBFTUSÓBT
$FOUSPEF&TUVEJPT²UJDPT-FHBMFT
Z 4PDJBMFT EFM *OTUJUVUP /BDJPOBM
EF .FEJDJOB (FOØNJDB &-4*
*/.&(&/
4FFODVFOUSBFOQF
SÓPEPEFJEFOUJmDBDJØOZTFMFDDJØO
EF SFDVSTPT IVNBOPT QBSB SFBMJ[BS
JOWFTUJHBDJPOFTBMUBNFOUFFTQFDJBMJ
[BEBT1SFUFOEFTFSVOBIFSSBNJFO
UB EF BQPZP EFM */.&(&/ QBSB
BCPSEBSMPTBTQFDUPTÏUJDPTMFHBMFT
ZTPDJBMFTEFMBNFEJDJOBHFOØNJDB
EF VOB NBOFSB QSÈDUJDB Z UFØSJDB
&MMPQFSNJUJSÈJODSFNFOUBSMBDPO
DJFODJBQÞCMJDBSFTQFDUPEFMPTQSP
DFEJNJFOUPTZQSPEVDUPTBTPDJBEPT
DPOMBFWBMVBDJØOFONBUFSJBEFJO
WFTUJHBDJØOZEPDFODJBFONFEJDJOB
HFOØNJDBZÈSFBTBmOFT
1BOPSBNBNFYJDBOPEFMEFTBSSPMMPEFMBCJPÏUJDB(FSBSEP+JNÏOF[$ÏTBS-BSBZ"MCFSUP"SFMMBOP
%FOUSP EF MPT MPHSPT NÈT JNQPSUBOUFT
EFM&-4*TFFODVFOUSBMBDPOTPMJEBDJØO
EFBMJBO[BTFTUSBUÏHJDBTDPOFM1SPHSBNB
EF &TUVEJPT -FHBMFT EF MB 'BDVMUBE EF
.FEJDJOBEFMB6OJWFSTJEBE7BOEFSCJMU
EJSJHJEPQPS&MMFO8SJHIU$MBZUPOMÓEFS
FOFMDBNQPEFMEFSFDIPZMBHFOÏUJDBZ
VOB EFTUBDBEB BTFTPSB EFM HPCJFSOP EF
&&66DPOFM1SPHSBNBEF#JPÏUJDBEF
MB0140.4ZFM$FOUSP*OUFSEJTDJQMJ
OBSJPEF&TUVEJPTFO#JPÏUJDBEFMB6OJ
WFSTJEBEEF$IJMFBNCPTEJSJHJEPTQPS
'FSOBOEP -PMBT 4UFQLF DPO FM 1VCMJD
1PQVMBUJPO 1SPKFDU JO (FOPNJDT 1(
FTQFDJBMNFOUFFOFMHSVQPJOUFSOBDJPOBM
EFUSBCBKP&UIJDTDPOTFEFFO$BOBEÈZ
DVZBDPPSEJOBDJØOTFFODVFOUSBBDBSHP
EF#BSUIB.BSÓB,OPQQFST
-BTPNJTJPOFTTPOJOFWJUBCMFTQFSPIF
NPTUPNBEPDPNPSFGFSFODJBBMPTHSV
QPTRVFZBUJFOFOVOBUSBEJDJØOTØMJEBZ
RVFFOUSFTVTBDUJWJEBEFTTFFODVFOUSBMB
EF QVCMJDBS EPDVNFOUPT Z BSUÓDVMPT FO
SFWJTUBTZMJCSPT-PRVFTÓUFOFNPTDMBSP
FTRVFUPEPTMPTHSVQPTBZVEBOBDSFBS
VOB DPODJFODJB HFOFSBMJ[BEB EF RVF FT
JNQSFTDJOEJCMF FM EJÈMPHP JOUFSEJTDJQMJ
OBSJP FOUSF MPT EJWFSTPT QSPGFTJPOBMFT
QBSBUSBUBSMPTUFNBTEFCJPÏUJDB
-BCJPÏUJDBZMPTDFOUSPTEF
JOWFTUJHBDJØOFO.ÏYJDP
/P UFOFNPT FM EBUP FYBDUP EF DVÈO
UPT DFOUSPT EF JOWFTUJHBDJØO CJPNÏEJDB
PQFSBODPOVOB$PNJTJØOEF²UJDB4F
EFUFDUØ RVF EFOUSP EF MB 6/". Z FO
FM*1/PQFSBOEJWFSTPTHSVQPTEFJOWFT
UJHBDJØO DJFOUÓmDB RVF NBOUJFOFO VOB
PERSPETIVADELABIOETICAINDD
SFEEFDPNVOJDBDJØODPOQSPGFTJPOBMFT
EFEJWFSTBTÈSFBTZSFBMJ[BOGPSPTEFCJP
ÏUJDB
&OFMTFDUPSEFMPT*OTUJUVUPT/BDJPOBMFT
EF4BMVEEFQFOEJFOUFTEFMB44"FM*OT
UJUVUPEF$BODFSPMPHÓBFMEF&OGFSNF
EBEFT3FTQJSBUPSJBTFMEF$JFODJBT.Ï
EJDBT Z /VUSJDJØO i4BMWBEPS ;VCJSBOi
FM *OTUJUVUP /BDJPOBM EF 4BMVE 1ÞCMJDB
Z FM *OTUJUVUP /BDJPOBM EF .FEJDJOB
(FOØNJDB*/.&(&/
TPOMPTÞOJDPT
RVFDVFOUBOBDUVBMNFOUFDPODPNJTJP
OFTEFÏUJDBDPOVOOÞNFSPNÓOJNPEF
TFJTNJFNCSPTZVONÈYJNPEFEPDF
'VFSBEFMÈNCJUPEFMPT*OTUJUVUPT/B
DJPOBMFTEF4BMVEZEFBDVFSEPDPOJO
GPSNBDJØOQSPQPSDJPOBEBQPSMB$PNJ
TJØO 'FEFSBM QBSB MB 1SPUFDDJØO DPOUSB
3JFTHPT 4BOJUBSJPT $0'&13*4
FYJT
UFOBMSFEFEPSEFJOTUJUVDJPOFTTBOJUB
SJBTUBOUPQÞCMJDBTDPNPQSJWBEBTRVF
UJFOFOSFHJTUSBEBBOUFMB$0'&13*4TVT
SFTQFDUJWBTDPNJTJPOFTEFÏUJDBMBTRVF
FO BMHVOBT PDBTJPOFT SFBMJ[BO GVODJP
OFTEFDPNJUÏTBTJTUFODJBMFTEFCJPÏUJDB
%FCFNPTSFDPOPDFSRVFBÞOTPOJOTVm
DJFOUFTTJUFOFNPTFODVFOUBRVFFTNV
DIÓTJNPNBZPSFMOÞNFSPEFIPTQJUBMFT
F JOTUJUVDJPOFT RVF SFBMJ[BO JOWFTUJHB
DJØODPOTFSFTIVNBOPTFO.ÏYJDP
-BCJPÏUJDBFOFMTJTUFNBMFHBM
&O.ÏYJDPTPONVDIBTMBTMFZFTRVFTF
SFmFSFOBEJWFSTPTBTQFDUPTDBUBMPHBEPT
QPS MPT FTQFDJBMJTUBT DPNP QSPCMFNBT
CJPÏUJDPT 4F TF×BMBSÈO MBT NÈT JNQPS
UBOUFT
1FSTQFDUJWBTEFMB#JPÏUJDBFO*CFSPBNÏSJDB
&O MB $POTUJUVDJØO 1PMÓUJDB EF MPT &T
UBEPT 6OJEPT .FYJDBOPT $1&6.
IBZ EJWFSTBT EJTQPTJDJPOFT SFMBUJWBT B
UFNBT CJPÏUJDPT UBMFT DPNP FM EFSFDIP
BM EFTBSSPMMP DJFOUÓmDP BQFHBEP B MPT
QSJODJQJPTDJFOUÓmDPTZÏUJDPTFMDVBMTF
USBEVDFFOMBPCMJHBDJØOEFQSPNPWFSZ
BQPZBSMBJOWFTUJHBDJØODJFOUÓmDBZUFD
OPMØHJDB "SU  GSBDDJØO 7
-B -FZ
EF$JFODJBZ5FDOPMPHÓB-$Z5
SFHMB
NFOUBSJBEFMBGSBDDJØO7EFMBSUÓDVMP
EFMB$1&6.UJFOFQPSPCKFUPSFHVMBS
MPTBQPZPTRVFFMHPCJFSOPGFEFSBMFTUÈ
PCMJHBEPBPUPSHBSBMPTJOWFTUJHBEPSFT
QBSBJNQVMTBSGPSUBMFDFSZEFTBSSPMMBSMB
JOWFTUJHBDJØODJFOUÓmDBZUFDOPMØHJDBEFM
QBÓT
6OP EF MPT QSJODJQJPT RVF FTUBCMFDF MB
-$Z5 FT RVF FM HPCJFSOP GFEFSBM FTUÈ
PCMJHBEPBOPBGFDUBSMBMJCFSUBEEFJO
WFTUJHBDJØO DJFOUÓmDB Z UFDOPMØHJDB TJO
QFSKVJDJPEFMBSFHVMBDJØOPMJNJUBDJPOFT
RVFQPSNPUJWPTEFTFHVSJEBEEFTBMVE
EFÏUJDBPEFDVBMRVJFSPUSBDBVTBEFJO
UFSÏTQÞCMJDPEFUFSNJOFOMBTEJTQPTJDJP
OFTMFHBMFT"SU'SBDD9
-B-FZ(FOFSBMEF4BMVE-(4
TF×BMB
UBNCJÏORVFFMEFTBSSPMMPEFMBFOTF×BO
[BZMBJOWFTUJHBDJØODJFOUÓmDBZUFDOPMØ
HJDBQBSBMBTBMVETPOJNQPSUBOUFTQBSB
MBOBDJØO"SU'SBDD7**
$POUJFOF
VOUÓUVMPFTQFDJBMEFEJDBEPBMBJOWFTUJ
HBDJØO QBSB MB TBMVE EJWJEJEP FO PDIP
BSUÓDVMPT MPT DVBMFT DPOUFNQMBO RVF
FTUBDMBTFEFJOWFTUJHBDJØODPNQSFOEFFM
EFTBSSPMMPEFBDDJPOFTRVFDPOUSJCVZBO
BMDPOPDJNJFOUPEFMPTQSPDFTPTCJPMØHJ
DPTZQTJDPMØHJDPTFOMPTTFSFTIVNBOPT
PERSPETIVADELABIOETICAINDD
FMDPOPDJNJFOUPEFMPTWÓODVMPTFOUSFMBT
DBVTBTEFFOGFSNFEBEMBQSÈDUJDBNÏEJ
DBZMBFTUSVDUVSBTPDJBMMBQSFWFODJØOZ
DPOUSPM EF MPT QSPCMFNBT EF TBMVE RVF
TFDPOTJEFSFOQSJPSJUBSJPTQBSBMBQPCMB
DJØO FM DPOPDJNJFOUP Z DPOUSPM EF MPT
FGFDUPTOPDJWPTEFMBNCJFOUFFOMBTBMVE
FMFTUVEJPEFMBTUÏDOJDBTZNÏUPEPTRVF
TFSFDPNJFOEFOPFNQMFFOQBSBMBQSFT
UBDJØOEFTFSWJDJPTEFTBMVEZMBQSPEVD
DJØOOBDJPOBMEFJOTVNPTQBSBMBTBMVE
"SU
-B -FZ EF MPT *OTUJUVUPT /BDJPOBMFT EF
4BMVE-*/4
FTUBCMFDFDPNPVOPEFMPT
PCKFUJWPTQSJNPSEJBMFTEFMQBÓTGPNFOUBS
MBJOWFTUJHBDJØOZFOTF×BO[BFONBUFSJB
EFTBMVEDPOFMmOEFEFTDSJCJSZFYQMJ
DBS FM PSJHFO EF MBT FOGFSNFEBEFT TV
QSFWFODJØO EJBHOØTUJDP Z USBUBNJFOUP
BTÓDPNPQSPDVSBSMBSFIBCJMJUBDJØOEFM
BGFDUBEP FM NBOUFOJNJFOUP Z QSPUFD
DJØOEFMBTBMVEEFMBTQFSTPOBT"SU
'SBDD**
.ÏYJDP IB DSFBEP VOB SFE FGFDUJWB Z
GVODJPOBM EF *OTUJUVUPT /BDJPOBMFT EF
4BMVE PSHBOJTNPT EFTDFOUSBMJ[BEPT EF
MB BENJOJTUSBDJØO QÞCMJDB GFEFSBM DPO
QFSTPOBMJEBEKVSÓEJDBZQBUSJNPOJPQSP
QJPTBHSVQBEPTFOFMTFDUPSTBMVERVF
UJFOFO DPNP PCKFUP QSJODJQBM MB JOWFT
UJHBDJØO DJFOUÓmDB EF BMUP OJWFM FO FTUF
DBNQP
0USPUFNBCJPÏUJDPDPOUFNQMBEPDPOT
UJUVDJPOBMNFOUF FT FM EFSFDIP EF UPEB
QFSTPOBBMBQSPUFDDJØOEFMBTBMVE"SU
$1&6.
RVFTFDVNQMFQPSNFEJP
EFM TJTUFNB EF TFHVSJEBE TPDJBM Z QBSB
1BOPSBNBNFYJDBOPEFMEFTBSSPMMPEFMBCJPÏUJDB(FSBSEP+JNÏOF[$ÏTBS-BSBZ"MCFSUP"SFMMBOP
RVJFOFT OP UJFOFO BDDFTP BM NJTNP B
USBWÏT EFM TJTUFNB EFM TFHVSP QPQVMBS
Z MPT *OTUJUVUPT /BDJPOBMFT EF 4BMVE
-B -(4 SFHMBNFOUBSJB EFM BSUÓDVMP 
$POTUJUVDJPOBMFTUBCMFDFMBDPODVSSFO
DJB EF MB 'FEFSBDJØO Z MPT &TUBEPT FO
NBUFSJBEFTBMVE%FUFSNJOBBMHVOBTEF
MBTÈSFBTDPOTJEFSBEBTDPNPNBUFSJBEF
TBMVCSJEBEHFOFSBMFOUSFMBTDVBMFTQP
EFNPT EFTUBDBS DPNP UFNBT QSJPSJUB
SJPTEFCJPÏUJDBMBPSHBOJ[BDJØODPOUSPM
ZWJHJMBODJBEFMBQSFTUBDJØOEFTFSWJDJPT
Z EF FTUBCMFDJNJFOUPT EF TBMVE MB QSP
UFDDJØOTPDJBMFOTBMVEKVTUJDJBEJTUSJCV
UJWB
MB QMBOJmDBDJØO GBNJMJBS MB TBMVE
NFOUBMMBDPPSEJOBDJØOEFMBJOWFTUJHB
DJØOQBSBMBTBMVEZFMDPOUSPMEFÏTUBFO
MPT TFSFT IVNBOPT FM DPOUSPM TBOJUBSJP
EF MB EJTQPTJDJØO EF ØSHBOPT UFKJEPT Z
TVTDPNQPOFOUFTDÏMVMBTZDBEÈWFSFTEF
TFSFTIVNBOPT
-B -*/4 FTUBCMFDF MB JNQPSUBODJB EF
QSPDVSBS MB SFIBCJMJUBDJØO NBOUFOJ
NJFOUP Z QSPUFDDJØO EF MB TBMVE EF MBT
QFSTPOBT 6OP EF MPT NBZPSFT MPHSPT
EF MPT *OTUJUVUPT FT FM EF QSPQPSDJPOBS
DPOTVMUBFYUFSOBBUFODJØOIPTQJUBMBSJBZ
TFSWJDJPTEFVSHFODJBTBMBQPCMBDJØORVF
SFRVJFSBBUFODJØONÏEJDBFOTVTÈSFBTEF
FTQFDJBMJ[BDJØOIBTUBFMMÓNJUFEFTVDB
QBDJEBEJOTUBMBEB
$POTUJUVDJPOBMNFOUFTFSFDPOPDFUBN
CJÏO FM EFSFDIP B VO NFEJP BNCJFOUF
BEFDVBEP "SU  $1&6.
&TUF BS
UÓDVMPEFMB-FZEF#JPTFHVSJEBEEF0S
HBOJTNPT (FOÏUJDBNFOUF .PEJmDBEPT
-#0(.
UJFOFFMPCKFUJWPEFSFEVDJS
BMNÈYJNPMPTQPTJCMFTSJFTHPTEFMBNB
PERSPETIVADELABIOETICAINDD
OJQVMBDJØO HFOÏUJDB Z BTÓ QSFWFOJS RVF
TFBBGFDUBEBMBTBMVEIVNBOBMBEJWFS
TJEBECJPMØHJDBFMNFEJPBNCJFOUFZMB
TBOJEBEWFHFUBMBOJNBMZBDVÓDPMB
&MÈSFBEF%FSFDIP1FOBMDPOUJFOFEJT
QPTJDJPOFT EJTQFSTBT 1PS FKFNQMP TF
DPOUFNQMBMBQSPIJCJDJØOEFMBFVUBOB
TJBFOUPEPTMPT&TUBEPTEFMB3FQÞCMJDB
TJO FNCBSHP FO NBUFSJB EF BCPSUP FO
USFDFFTUBEPTTFQFSNJUFFMDBVTBEPQPS
NPUJWPT FVHFOÏTJDPT Z FO EJF[ TF FTUB
CMFDF DPNP BUFOVBOUF P FYJNFOUF EF
SFTQPOTBCJMJEBEFMDBVTBEPDPONPUJWPT
EFVOBUÏDOJDBEFSFQSPEVDDJØOBSUJmDJBM
OPDPOTFOUJEBQPSMBNVKFS
&M $ØEJHP 1FOBM EFM %JTUSJUP 'FEFSBM
FO TV -JCSP 4FHVOEP TF×BMB EJTQPTJ
DJPOFT RVF DPOUFNQMBO TBODJPOFT QBSB
MPT EFMJUPT CJPUFDOPMØHJDPT QSPIJCJFO
EP DPOEVDUBT DPNP MB EJTQPTJDJØO EF
HBNFUPT OP BVUPSJ[BEB MBT UÏDOJDBT EF
SFQSPEVDDJØOBTJTUJEBOPDPOTFOUJEBMB
NBOJQVMBDJØO HFOÏUJDB DPO mOFT FVHF
OÏTJDPTZMBDMPOBDJØOIVNBOBDPOmOFT
SFQSPEVDUJWPT7FSBDSV[Z$IJBQBTIBO
FTUBCMFDJEP FO TVT SFTQFDUJWPT DØEJHPT
QFOBMFTMBTNJTNBTTBODJPOFT
&ONBUFSJBDJWJMTFIBFTUBCMFDJEPRVFFO
MPTKVJDJPTEFJOWFTUJHBDJØOEFMBQBUFS
OJEBETFBENJUFOMBTQSVFCBTCJPMØHJDBT
"TJNJTNPFODBTJUPEBTMBTEJTQPTJDJP
OFTDJWJMFTEFMQBÓTTFIBDFBMVTJØOBMBT
DPOTFDVFODJBTKVSÓEJDBTEFSJWBEBTEFMPT
NÏUPEPTEFGFDVOEBDJØOBTJTUJEB
4PONVDIPTMPTSFHMBNFOUPTEFSJWBEPT
EF MBT EJTQPTJDJPOFT NFODJPOBEBT RVF
OP IBO TJEP OPNCSBEPT 1PS FKFNQMP
1FSTQFDUJWBTEFMB#JPÏUJDBFO*CFSPBNÏSJDB
FM 3FHMBNFOUP FO NBUFSJB EF $POUSPM
4BOJUBSJPEFMBEJTQPTJDJØOEF»SHBOPT
5FKJEPTZ$BEÈWFSFTEF4FSFT)VNBOPT
FMDVBMFTEFBQMJDBDJØOFOUPEBMB3FQÞ
CMJDBNFYJDBOBZSFHVMBMPTBWBODFTDJFO
UÓmDPTMPHSBEPTFONBUFSJBEFUSBTQMBOUFT
EFØSHBOPTZUFKJEPTFOTFSFTIVNBOPT
DPNPNFEJPUFSBQÏVUJDPBWFDFTÞOJDP
QBSBDPOTFSWBSMBWJEBZMBTBMVEEFMBT
QFSTPOBT
SJFTHPTBMPTRVFTFTPNFUFSÈDPOMBDB
QBDJEBEEFMJCSFFMFDDJØOZTJODPBDDJØO
BMHVOB"SU
&MPUSPSFHMBNFOUPEFTVNBJNQPSUBODJB
FTFMEFMB-(4FONBUFSJBEF*OWFTUJHB
DJØOQBSBMB4BMVEFMDVBMQSPWFFFOMB
FTGFSB BENJOJTUSBUJWB FM DVNQMJNJFOUP
EFMB-(4FOMPSFGFSFOUFBMBJOWFTUJHB
DJØOQBSBMBTBMVEFOMPTTFDUPSFTQÞCMJDP
TPDJBMZQSJWBEP"SUEFMSFHMBNFOUP
"EFNÈTFTUBCMFDFMPTMJOFBNJFOUPTÏUJDPT
RVF EFCFSÈO TFHVJSTF FO MPT QSPUPDPMPT
EFJOWFTUJHBDJØOFOMPTDVBMFTQBSUJDJQFO
TFSFTIVNBOPTDPNPTVKFUPTEFJOWFTUJ
HBDJØO"SUEFMSFHMBNFOUP
-BCJPÏUJDBFOMBKVSJTQSVEFODJB
&OUSFPUSPTQSJODJQJPTRVFJNQPOFFMSF
HMBNFOUPTFFODVFOUSBOFMEFSFTQFUPEF
MBQSJWBDJEBE"SU
EFTFHVSJEBEEF
MBTQFSTPOBTTVKFUBTBJOWFTUJHBDJØO"SU
EFSFTQPOTBCJMJEBEEFMPTJOWFTUJHB
EPSFT"SU
ZEFMJCFSUBEQBSBQBSUJDJ
QBSFOVOBJOWFTUJHBDJØO"SU
&TUF
ÞMUJNPSFDPHJEPEFEFDMBSBDJPOFTJOUFS
OBDJPOBMFTTFUSBEVDFFO MB USBEJDJPOBM
GØSNVMBEFMDPOTFOUJNJFOUPJOGPSNBEP
FMDVBMFTEFmOJEPFOOVFTUSBMFHJTMBDJØO
DPNPFMBDVFSEPQPSFTDSJUPNFEJBOUFFM
DVBMFMTVKFUPEFJOWFTUJHBDJØOoPFOTV
DBTPTVSFQSFTFOUBOUFMFHBMoBVUPSJ[BTV
QBSUJDJQBDJØO DPO QMFOP DPOPDJNJFOUP
EFMBOBUVSBMF[BEFMPTQSPDFEJNJFOUPTZ
PERSPETIVADELABIOETICAINDD
/VFTUSPTJTUFNBGFEFSBMBENJUFRVFDBEB
&TUBEPFMBCPSFTVQSPQJBMFHJTMBDJØOMP
DBMMPDVBMQPESÓBHFOFSBSVOTJOOÞNF
SPEFEJTQPTJDJPOFTMFHBMFTRVFTJOEF
OPNJOBSTF CJPÏUJDBT UFOESÓBO JNQBDUP
PTFSFGFSJSÓBOBUFNBTCJPÏUJDPT
)BOTJEPQPDPTMPTUFNBTCJPÏUJDPTSF
TVFMUPT QPS MB WÓB EF BNQBSP &O FTUF
TFOUJEP UFOFNPT SFTPMVDJPOFT SFMBUJWBT
BM BCPSUP MB QSJWBDJEBE HFOÏUJDB MBT
QSVFCBT EJBHOØTUJDBT Z EF mMJBDJØO FM
USBTQMBOUFEFØSHBOPTZMBFVUBOBTJB
&ONBUFSJBEFBCPSUPFYJTUFOSFTP
MVDJPOFTFOUSFMBTDVBMFTTFEFCFOEFT
UBDBSMPTDSJUFSJPTPSJFOUBEPTBQFSNJUJS
FMBCPSUPFVHFOÏTJDP1PSDSJUFSJPKVSJT
QSVEFODJBMTFFYJNFEFSFTQPOTBCJMJEBE
QFOBM DVBOEP B KVJDJP EF EPT NÏEJDPT
FTQFDJBMJTUBTFYJTUBSB[ØOTVmDJFOUFQBSB
EJBHOPTUJDBS RVF FM QSPEVDUP QSFTFO
UB BMUFSBDJPOFT HFOÏUJDBT P DPOHÏOJUBT
MBT DVBMFT QVFEBO EBS DPNP SFTVMUBEP
EB×PT GÓTJDPT P NFOUBMFT Z QPOHBO FO
SJFTHPMBTPCSFWJWFODJBEFMQSPEVDUP&O
UPEP DBTP TF EFCF PCUFOFS FM DPOTFOUJ
NJFOUP MJCSF JOGPSNBEP Z SFTQPOTBCMF
EF MB NVKFS FNCBSB[BEB Z MB EFDJTJØO
EFCF GVOEBSTF FO VO EJDUBNFO NÏEJ
DP RVF DPOUFOHB JOGPSNBDJØO PCKFUJWB
WFSB[TVmDJFOUFZPQPSUVOB4FNBOBSJP
+VEJDJBM EF MB 'FEFSBDJØO Z TV (BDFUB
5PNP97'FCSFSPEF5FTJT1
+
1BOPSBNBNFYJDBOPEFMEFTBSSPMMPEFMBCJPÏUJDB(FSBSEP+JNÏOF[$ÏTBS-BSBZ"MCFSUP"SFMMBOP
&O NBUFSJB EF HFOÏUJDB TF FODPOUSBSPO
WFJOUF SFTPMVDJPOFT MBT DVBMFT FO UÏS
NJOPT HFOFSBMFT USBUBO TPCSF BTQFDUPT
SFMBUJWPT B MB QSJWBDJEBE HFOÏUJDB FTUB
CMFDJFOEPRVFEFTEFFMNPNFOUPFORVF
TFPGSFDFMBQSVFCBHFOÏUJDBQBSBTPMV
DJPOBSBMHVOBMJUJTSFMBUJWBBMBmMJBDJØO
TFEFCFODPOUFNQMBSBMHVOPTNFEJPTEF
TFHVSJEBE EF MB QSJWBDJEBE UBMFT DPNP
DJUBS BM JOEJWJEVP QBSB MB QSÈDUJDB EF
FYÈNFOFTFOVOMBCPSBUPSJPQSFWJBNFO
UF BDSFEJUBEP 4FNBOBSJP +VEJDJBM EF MB
'FEFSBDJØO Z TV (BDFUB 5PNP 99*7
"HPTUP EF 5FTJT 7*P$ $
1ÈHJOB
&O PUSB UFTJT BNQMJØ FM TFOUJEP EF MB
BOUFSJPS JNQPOJFOEP DPNP MÓNJUFT EF
DPOUSPMEFMBDDFTPBMBJOGPSNBDJØOHF
OÏUJDBDVBMRVJFSDSJUFSJPDPOTJEFSBEPQPS
FMKV[HBEPSDPOMBmOBMJEBEEFWFMBSQPS
RVFMBQSÈDUJDBEFEJDIBQFSJDJBMTFMMFWF
B DBCP DPO MBT NFEJEBT EF EJTDSFDJØO
EFSFTFSWBZTBOJUBSJBTQBSBTBMWBHVBSEBS
FMFTUBEPEFTBMVEEFMPTQSPHFOJUPSFTZ
EFM QSPQJP NFOPS 4F FTUBCMFDF RVF MB
JOGPSNBDJØO RVF TF PCUFOHB EF EJDIP
QSPDFEJNJFOUPDJFOUÓmDPTFSÈDPODSFUBZ
PCKFUJWBZTFVTBSÈTØMPQBSBSFTPMWFSMB
DVFTUJØODPOUSPWFSUJEB4FNBOBSJP+VEJ
DJBMEFMB'FEFSBDJØOZTV(BDFUB5PNP
99**/PWJFNCSFEF5FTJT**P
$$
1PS MP UBOUP MB QSVFCB HFOÏUJDB OP TF
EFCFJNQPOFSGPS[PTBNFOUFBRVJFOTF
MF SFQVUB MB mMJBDJØO UFOJFOEP FM EP
OBOUF EF MB NVFTUSB CJPMØHJDB EFSFDIP
B OFHBSTF BM EFTBIPHP EF MB NJTNB FO
DVZPDBTPTFQSFTVNFMBmMJBDJØO4FNB
PERSPETIVADELABIOETICAINDD
OBSJP+VEJDJBMEFMB'FEFSBDJØOZTV(BDF
UB5PNP99***&OFSPEF5FTJT
B $$97** 0USB JOUFS
QSFUBDJØOEFMBTDPSUFTKVEJDJBMFTFTUBCMF
DFFMEFSFDIPEFMPTNFOPSFTEFFEBEB
UFOFS VOB JEFOUJEBE Z PSJHFO HFOÏUJDP
4FNBOBSJP+VEJDJBMEFMB'FEFSBDJØOZTV
(BDFUB5PNP99***&OFSPEF
5FTJTB$$97***
0USP UFNB CJPÏUJDP EFCBUJEP BNQMJB
NFOUF Z RVF MMFHØ IBTUB MBT DPSUFT GVF
FMSFMBUJWPBMPTUSBTQMBOUFTEFØSHBOPT
"OUFSJPSNFOUF MB -(4 TF×BMBCB DPNP
DSJUFSJPQBSBSFBMJ[BSFMUSBTQMBOUFEFØS
HBOPTFOUSFWJWPTMBOFDFTBSJBSFMBDJØOEF
QBSFOUFTDPQPSDPOTBOHVJOJEBEQPSBm
OJEBEPDJWJMFOUSFEPOBOUFZSFDFQUPS
MB4VQSFNB$PSUFEF+VTUJDJBEFUFSNJOØ
RVFEJDIBEJTQPTJDJØOWJPMBCBFMEFSFDIP
BMBQSPUFDDJØOEFMBTBMVERVFZBIFNPT
NFODJPOBEP1BSBVOTFDUPSEFMBEPD
USJOBKVSÓEJDBZCJPÏUJDBFTUBSFTPMVDJØO
GPNFOUB FM DPNFSDJP JMFHBM EF ØSHBOPT
4FNBOBSJP+VEJDJBMEFMB'FEFSBDJØOZTV
(BDFUB5PNP97***"HPTUPEF
5FTJT1*9
1PS ÞMUJNP TF FODPOUSBSPO EPT SFTPMV
DJPOFTSFMBDJPOBEBTDPOMBFVUBOBTJBRVF
FOTÓOUFTJTSFDPOPDFORVFFTUBQSÈDUJDB
EFTEFVOQVOUPEFWJTUBNPSBMUJFOFBN
QMJBKVTUJmDBDJØOZSFTQBMEPQPSTVJOEV
EBCMFDPOUFOJEPIVNBOPTJOFNCBSHP
TF MF TBODJPOB QPS TV SFQFSDVTJØO FO MB
DPMFDUJWJEBEFODVBOUPTJHOJmDBVOBUFO
UBEPBMBJOWJPMBCJMJEBEIVNBOB2VJOUB
²QPDB*OTUBODJB1SJNFSB4BMB"QÏOEJDF
5PNP**5FTJT
1FSTQFDUJWBTEFMB#JPÏUJDBFO*CFSPBNÏSJDB
-BCJPÏUJDBFOMPTQSPZFDUPT
MFHJTMBUJWPT
&OUÏSNJOPTHFOFSBMFTFYJTUFOQSPQVFT
UBT QBSB JODMVJS FO MB $1&6. MB QSP
IJCJDJØOEFMBEJTDSJNJOBDJØOHFOÏUJDB
&OMB-(4TFRVJFSFJODMVJSMBPCKFDJØO
EFDPODJFODJBZDSFBSVODBQÓUVMPFTQF
DJBMRVFGPNFOUFMBJOWFTUJHBDJØODMÓOJDB
Z CÈTJDB EF MBT DÏMVMBT FTUBNJOBMFT EFM
BEVMUPZEFMSFDJÏOOBDJEP0USBJOJDJB
UJWBJOUFSFTBOUFFTMBRVFPCMJHBSÓBBMPT
QSPEVDUPSFTEFBMJNFOUPTUSBOTHÏOFUJDPT
BFUJRVFUBSTVTQSPEVDUPTEFGPSNBDMBSB
ZBMBWJTUBEFMPTDPOTVNJEPSFT
&O PUSBT JOJDJBUJWBT TF DPOUFNQMB MB
DSFBDJØO EF MFZFT OVFWBT 1PS FKFNQMP
FYJTUFVOBJOJDJBUJWBQBSBDSFBSMB-FZEF
MPT%FSFDIPTEFMPT&OGFSNPT5FSNJOB
MFTMBDVBM TFDPOTUJUVJSÓBEF BSUÓDVMPT
Z QFSNJUJSÓB B FTUPT FOGFSNPT FMBCPSBS
UFTUBNFOUPTWJUBMFTPFKFSDFSFMEFSFDIPB
TPMJDJUBSMBUFSNJOBDJØOWPMVOUBSJBEFTV
WJEB BDUJWB FVUBOBTJB
P QBTJWBNFOUF
PSUPUBOBTJB
-PT UFNBT CJPÏUJDPT HFOFSBO QPMÏNJDB
FOMPTEJGFSFOUFTHSVQPTQBSMBNFOUBSJPT
$PNPDMBSPFKFNQMPUFOFNPTMBFYJTUFO
DJBEFUSFTJOJDJBUJWBTEFMFZQBSBSFHVMBS
MBT UÏDOJDBT EF SFQSPEVDDJØO BTJTUJEB
-B QSJNFSB EF FMMBT QSPQVFTUB QPS VO
JOUFHSBOUFEFM1BSUJEP7FSEF&DPMPHJTUB
EF .ÏYJDP 17&.
DPOTUB EF BS
UÓDVMPT &OUSF TVT BTQFDUPT NÈT JOUFSF
TBOUFT JOUSPEVDJSÓB FO OVFTUSP TJTUFNB
MFHBMUÏSNJOPTDPNPiNBUFSJBMHFOÏUJDP
IVNBOPw iNBUFSOJEBE TVCSPHBEBw
iUSBOTGFSFODJB EF FNCSJPOFTw Z iQSF
FNCSJPOFTw 1FSNJUJSÓBMB JOWFTUJHBDJØO
PERSPETIVADELABIOETICAINDD
DPO FNCSJPOFT TVQFSOVNFSBSJPT EF MBT
UÏDOJDBTEFGFDVOEBDJØOJOWJUSPMBDSFB
DJØO EF RVJNFSBT DPO mOFT EF JOWFTUJ
HBDJØOFOJOGFSUJMJEBEIVNBOBUFTUEFM
IBNTUFS
ZMBBQMJDBDJØOEFEJBHOØTUJDPT
HFOÏUJDPTQSFOBUBMFT
&MQSPZFDUPEFMFZQSPQVFTUPQPSFM1BS
UJEP EF "DDJØO /BDJPOBM 1"/
DPN
QSFOEFSÓBBSUÓDVMPTJODMVJEPTEFOUSP
EFVODBQÓUVMPFTQFDJBMEFMB-(4&TUB
MFZ QSPIJCJSÓB MB FVHFOFTJB QPTJUJWB Z MB
TFMFDDJØOEFTFYPFOMPTFNCSJPOFTDPO
MB FYDFQDJØO EF FMFHJS FM TFYP TØMP FO
BRVFMMPTDBTPTFOMPTRVFFYJTUBMBQPTJCJ
MJEBEEFIFSFEBSVOBFOGFSNFEBEHFOÏUJ
DBMJHBEBBMTFYPQFSNJUJSÓBMBJOWFTUJHB
DJØOEFJEFOUJEBEEFEBUPTHFOÏUJDPTFO
MPTDBTPTRVFDPNQPSUFOVOSJFTHPQBSB
MBWJEBEFMOJ×PTBODJPOBSÓBMBNBOJQV
MBDJØOTPCSFNBUFSJBMHFOÏUJDPIVNBOPZ
MBDPNFSDJBMJ[BDJØOEFDÏMVMBTHFSNJOBMFT
PFNCSJPOFTZOPQFSNJUJSÓBMBDSFBDJØO
EFFNCSJPOFTTVQFSOVNFSBSJPT
1PSÞMUJNPMBJOJDJBUJWBEFMFZEFMHSV
QPQPMÓUJDPEFM1BSUJEPEFMB3FWPMVDJØO
%FNPDSÈUJDB13%
UJFOFBSUÓDVMPT
RVFTFBEJDJPOBSÓBOBMB-(41FSNJUJSÓB
FM EJBHOØTUJDP HFOÏUJDP QSFJNQMBOUBUP
SJPDPOFMmOEFQSFWFOJSFOGFSNFEBEFT
IFSFEJUBSJBT JOUSPEVDJSÓB MPT UÏSNJOPT
iFNCSJØOQSFJNQMBOUBUPSJPwZiFNCSJØO
QPTUJNQMBOUBUPSJPwQFSNJUJSÓBMBJOWFT
UJHBDJØO DPO FNCSJPOFT TVQFSOVNFSB
SJPTBVORVFTF×BMBDPNPMÓNJUFQBSBMB
JOWFTUJHBDJØO FM EÓB Z QSPIJCJSÓB FM
BMRVJMFSEFÞUFSPTZMBNPEJmDBDJØOEFM
QBUSJNPOJPHFOÏUJDPDPOmOFTFVHFOÏTJ
DPT1PSPUSBQBSUFDSFBSÓBCBODPTEFTF
1BOPSBNBNFYJDBOPEFMEFTBSSPMMPEFMBCJPÏUJDB(FSBSEP+JNÏOF[$ÏTBS-BSBZ"MCFSUP"SFMMBOP
NFOZEFFNCSJPOFTZBEFNÈTBMJHVBM
RVFMBTEPTJOJDJBUJWBTBOUFSJPSFTQFSNJ
UJSÓBMPTEJBHOØTUJDPTHFOÏUJDPTQSFOBUB
MFTQBSBEFUFDUBSEFGFDUPTDPOHÏOJUPT
-BCJPÏUJDBZMBQMBUBGPSNBEFMB
NFEJDJOBHFOØNJDBFO.ÏYJDP
/P QSFUFOEFNPT BOBMJ[BS UPEPT MPT BT
QFDUPT EFM EFTBSSPMMP EF MB DJFODJB HF
OØNJDB RVF FO MPT ÞMUJNPT B×PT IB
HFOFSBEPJOGPSNBDJØOBCVOEBOUFUBOUP
FODPNVOJDBDJPOFTDJFOUÓmDBTFTDSJUBTZ
FMFDUSØOJDBT DPNP FO MPT NFEJPT NBTJ
WPTEFDPNVOJDBDJØO-PRVFIBSFNPT
TFSÈVOCSFWFSFDVFOUPEFMPRVFDPOTJ
EFSFNPT MPT SFUPT CJPÏUJDPT JONFEJBUPT
RVFFOGSFOUBSÈOVFTUSPDFOUSP&-4*
"TQFDUPTHFOFSBMFTEFMBNFEJDJOB
HFOØNJDB
&M 1SPZFDUP EFM (FOPNB )VNBOP
1()
TFIBDPOTUJUVJEPFOVOPEFMPT
SFUPT DJFOUÓmDPUFDOPMØHJDPT NÈT HSBO
EFTRVFIBFOGSFOUBEPMBIVNBOJEBEZ
RVFQFSNJUFVONBZPSDPOPDJNJFOUPEF
OVFTUSB FTQFDJF )PZ TBCFNPT RVF MPT
TFSFT IVNBOPT DPNQBSUJNPT FM EF MB TFDVFODJB EFM HFOPNB IVNBOP
ÏTUBTFDPOTUJUVZFEFNJMMPOFTEF
OVDMFØUJEPT P MFUSBT " ( 5 $
GPS
NBOEP MPT DFSDB EF HFOFT RVF
BIÓTFBMCFSHBO&MSFTUBOUFEFMB
TFDVFODJB WBSÓB FOUSF DBEB JOEJWJEVP
TJFOEP MBT WBSJBDJPOFT NÈT DPNVOFT
BRVFMMBTFORVFDBNCJBVOBTPMBMFUSBFT
EFDJSMPTQPMJNPSmTNPTEFVOTPMPOV
DMFØUJEPDPOPDJEPTDPNP4/1TQPSTVT
TJHMBTFOJOHMÏT&MOÞNFSPEFQPTJCMFT
DPNCJOBDJPOFTRVFSFTVMUBOEFMBWBSJB
PERSPETIVADELABIOETICAINDD
DJØO HFOØNJDB EB DPNP SFTVMUBEP RVF
DBEBNJFNCSPEFOVFTUSBFTQFDJFUFOHB
DBSBDUFSÓTUJDBTHFOØNJDBTÞOJDBT
"M UÏSNJOP EFM 1() TF JEFOUJmDBSPO
MPT SFUPT NÈTJNQPSUBOUFT Z TFEFmOJF
SPODJODPÈSFBTQSJODJQBMFTFOMBTRVFTF
JOWFSUJSÓBOFTGVFS[PTZSFDVSTPTEVSBOUF
MPT QSØYJNPT EJF[ B×PT &TUBT ÈSFBT FT
UBSÓBOEFEJDBEBTBDPOWFSUJSMBJOGPSNB
DJØO HFOØNJDB FO SFBMJEBEFT UBOHJCMFT
QBSB MB QPCMBDJØO HFOFSBM NFEJBOUF FM
FTUVEJPEFMBFTUSVDUVSBZGVODJØOEFMPT
HFOFTZMBTQSPUFÓOBT4FQVFEFNFODJP
OBSDPNPVOBEFMBTÈSFBTRVFNÈTEFCF
JOUFSFTBSBMPTHPCJFSOPTMBFMBCPSBDJØO
EFM .BQB EF )BQMPUJQPT )BQ.BQ
QSPZFDUP DVZB mOBMJEBE FT BDFMFSBS FM
EFTDVCSJNJFOUP EF MPT HFOFT SFMBDJPOB
EPT DPO FOGFSNFEBEFT DPNVOFT DPNP
BTNB DÈODFS EJBCFUFT FOGFSNFEBEFT
DBSEJPWBTDVMBSFTFOUSFPUSBT
"DUVBMNFOUFFM*/.&(&/TFFODVFO
USB EFTBSSPMMBOEP FM )BQ.BQ EF MPT
NFTUJ[PT NFYJDBOPT $PO ÏM TF MPHSB
SÈ JEFOUJmDBS MBT QPTJDJPOFT FO MBT RVF
FYJTUFO WBSJBDJPOFT EFOUSP EFM HFOPNB
IVNBOPEFMPTNFYJDBOPTFTEFDJSMBT
WBSJBDJPOFT RVF DPOmFSFO JOEJWJEVBMJ
EBEBDBEBNJFNCSPEFOVFTUSBQPCMB
DJØO &TQFDJBM JOUFSÏT UFOESÈO BRVFMMBT
SFMBDJPOBEBT DPO MB TVTDFQUJCJMJEBE B
FOGFSNFEBEFTDPNVOFT1PSFMMPFTJN
QPSUBOUF JODPSQPSBSTF FO FM EFTBSSPMMP
EFMBQMBUBGPSNBDJFOUÓmDBRVFQFSNJUB
HFOFSBS CBTFT TØMJEBT QBSB USBOTGPSNBS
MBNFEJDJOBHFOØNJDBFOUFOEJEBDPNP
VOBNFEJDJOBNÈTQSFWFOUJWBQSFEJDUJWB
FJOEJWJEVBMJ[BEB&MMBDPOUSJCVJSÈBNF
1FSTQFDUJWBTEFMB#JPÏUJDBFO*CFSPBNÏSJDB
KPSBSMBDBMJEBEEFWJEBEFMPTJOEJWJEVPT
Z SFEVDJSÈ B MBSHP QMB[P MPT HBTUPT EF
BUFODJØOQFSNJUJFOEPVOBNFKPSEJTUSJ
CVDJØOEFSFDVSTPTZBQMJDBOEPFMQSJO
DJQJPCJPÏUJDPEFKVTUJDJBEJTUSJCVUJWB
3FnFYJPOFTmOBMFT
-BTJNQMJDBDJPOFTEFMBCJPÏUJDBZMBNF
EJDJOBHFOØNJDBWBONÈTBMMÈEFMBTWB
MPSBDJPOFT DJFOUÓmDBT "CBSDBO HSBOEFT
SFUPTÏUJDPTMFHBMFTZTPDJBMFTSB[ØOQPS
MBDVBMFM*/.&(&/IBDSFBEPTV$FO
USPEF&TUVEJPT²UJDPT-FHBMFTZ4PDJBMFT
EFMB.FEJDJOB(FOØNJDB"EFNÈTIB
FTUBCMFDJEPVODMBSPEFTMJOEFDPOPUSBT
JNQPSUBOUFT ÈSFBT EF MB JOWFTUJHBDJØO
DJFOUÓmDBDPOMBTRVFOPHVBSEBSFMBDJØO
"TÓMBNFEJDJOBHFOØNJDBEFTBSSPMMBEB
FO FM */.&(&/ OP TF SFMBDJPOB DPO
MB DMPOBDJØO EF TFSFT IVNBOPT OJ DPO
MBNBOJQVMBDJØOEFDÏMVMBTNBESFUBN
QPDPDPOMPTQSPDFEJNJFOUPTEFSFQSP
EVDDJØO BTJTUJEB NVDIP NFOPT DPO MB
NBOJQVMBDJØOEFFNCSJPOFTIVNBOPT
-B NFEJDJOB HFOØNJDB FO .ÏYJDP FTUÈ
EJSJHJEBBMFTUVEJPEFJOEJWJEVPTZBOB
DJEPT JEFOUJmDBOEP QSFEJTQPTJDJPOFT
HFOÏUJDBTBFOGFSNFEBEFTDPNVOFTDPO
FMmOEFGPSNVMBSSFDPNFOEBDJPOFTTP
CSFTVFTUJMPEFWJEBZBTÓSFUSBTBSPFWJUBS
MBNBOJGFTUBDJØOEFFTUBTFOGFSNFEBEFT
FO VOB QSJNFSB FUBQB -B WJODVMBDJØO
FOUSFCJPÏUJDBZNFEJDJOBHFOØNJDBEF
CFSÈQMBOUFBSNBSDPTEFSFGFSFODJBQBSB
BWBO[BS FO FM DPOPDJNJFOUP EF MB WJEB
ZMPTCFOFmDJPTQBSBMBIVNBOJEBEFO
QSFWFODJØOEFMBFOGFSNFEBEZQSPNP
DJØOEFMBTBMVE
PERSPETIVADELABIOETICAINDD
&M EFTBSSPMMP EF MB NFEJDJOB HFOØNJDB
USBF DPOTJHP NVDIBT DVFTUJPOFT CJPÏUJ
DBTRVFEFCFSÈOSFTPMWFSTFUSBTVOEFCBUF
JOUFSEJTDJQMJOBSJPFMDVBMEFCFSÈFONBS
DBSTF CBKP FM EJTDVSTP EF MPT EFSFDIPT
GVOEBNFOUBMFT JODMVJEPT FM EFSFDIP BM
EFTBSSPMMP DJFOUÓmDP Z UFDOPMØHJDP Z FM
EFSFDIP B MB TBMVE 6O NBSDP CJPÏUJDP
QSPHSFTJTUB MF JOEJDBSÈ B MPT DJFOUÓmDPT
MPTEFSFDIPTZPCMJHBDJPOFTFOFMFKFSDJ
DJPEFTVTGVODJPOFTUBMZDPNPTVDFEF
DPO DVBMRVJFS UJQP EF SFMBDJØO TPDJBM
QFSP SFDPOPDFSÈ MB QSPUFDDJØO EF TVT
QSPZFDUPTFYQFDUBUJWBTZFNQSFTBT
&OUSFMPTUFNBTRVFEFCFOTFSEFTBSSPMMB
EPTBNQMJBNFOUFTFFODVFOUSBFMEFDPO
TFOUJNJFOUPJOGPSNBEP&OUPEPUSBCBKP
EFJOWFTUJHBDJØOEFCFFYJTUJSMBJOGPSNB
DJØOOFDFTBSJBQBSBFMQBSUJDJQBOUFRVJFO
EFCFSÈDPOPDFSMBmOBMJEBEZDPOTFDVFO
DJBTEFMFYQFSJNFOUPZFYQSFTBSWPMVOUB
SJBNFOUFTVJOUFODJØOEFQBSUJDJQBS
0USPUFNBEFHSBOSFMFWBODJBFTFMSFMBUJ
WPBMBJOHFOJFSÓBHFOÏUJDBBNQMJBNFOUF
BDFQUBEB EFTEF FM QVOUP EF WJTUB ÏUJDP
QBSB USBUBS FOGFSNFEBEFT IFSFEJUBSJBT
QFSPOPQBSBNPEJmDBSFMDØEJHPHFOÏUJ
DPDPOmOFTFVHFOÏTJDPTPQBSBDBNCJBS
MBT DBSBDUFSÓTUJDBT GÓTJDBT F JOUFMFDUVBMFT
EFMJOEJWJEVP
6OUFSDFSUFNBFTFMSFMBUJWPBMBJOGPS
NBDJØO HFOÏUJDB 4F EFCF SFTQFUBS FM
QSJODJQJP EF BVUPOPNÓB QBSB RVF DBEB
JOEJWJEVPEFDJEBBDFQUBSPOPFMFTUVEJP
EFTVHFOPNBBEFNÈTUPEBMBJOGPSNB
DJØOEFCFTFSDPOmEFODJBMZTVFWFOUVBM
EJGVTJØOEFCFWFSTBSTPCSFBTQFDUPTFTUB
EÓTUJDPT
1BOPSBNBNFYJDBOPEFMEFTBSSPMMPEFMBCJPÏUJDB(FSBSEP+JNÏOF[$ÏTBS-BSBZ"MCFSUP"SFMMBOP
6ODVBSUPQSPCMFNBTFSFmFSFBMEFUFS
NJOJTNP HFOÏUJDP &O DBEB JOWFTUJHB
DJØOTFEFCFOUPNBSFODVFOUBOPTØMP
MPT GBDUPSFT HFOÏUJDPT QSFEJTQPOFOUFT
TJOPUBNCJÏOMPTGBDUPSFTBNCJFOUBMFT
TPCSFUPEPKVSÓEJDB-BDJFODJBBMJHVBM
RVF MBT BSUFT MB mMPTPGÓB Z MB MJUFSBUVSB
FTVOBDPOTUSVDDJØOIVNBOBZEFQFOEF
QPSUBOUPEFTVTGVFS[BTDSFBUJWBTFTEF
DJSEFMBTQFSTPOBT
&MEFSFDIPEFQBUFOUFTFOFMÈSFBEFMB
NFEJDJOBHFOØNJDBFTFMRVJOUPBTVOUP
RVF EFCF DPOTJEFSBSTF QVFT UJFOF NV
DIBT JNQMJDBDJPOFT FO MB JOWFTUJHBDJØO
CJPNÏEJDBZFOMBJOEVTUSJBFTNVZÞUJM
FO FM EJBHOØTUJDP Z USBUBNJFOUP EF FO
GFSNFEBEFTHFOÏUJDBTZQPSPUSBQBSUF
TFVTBQBSBPCUFOFSTVCTUBODJBTÞUJMFTFO
MB JOEVTUSJB GBSNBDÏVUJDB MB HMPCVMJOB
BOUJIFNPGÓMJDB"Z#IPSNPOBEFMDSF
DJNJFOUPJOTVMJOBIVNBOBJOUFSGFSPO
GBDUPSEFOFDSPTJTUVNPSBMWBDVOBTDPO
USBMBIFQBUJUJT#Z$ZDPOUSBMBJOnVFO
[B FOUSF PUSBT &T QFSUJOFOUF SFWJTBS FM
TJTUFNB EF QSPQJFEBE JOUFMFDUVBM QBSB
GPNFOUBSFMEFTBSSPMMPBUSBWÏTEFMBQSP
UFDDJØOEFMBDSFBUJWJEBE&TJOEJTQFOTB
CMFMBSFHVMBDJØOMPDBMZÏUJDBBUSBWÏTEF
PSHBOJTNPTNVMUJEJTDJQMJOBSJPT
-B CJPÏUJDB TJ RVJFSF EFTBSSPMMBS DBCBM
NFOUFTVNJTJØOEFCFBKVTUBSTFBUPEP
MP SFRVFSJEP QPS MPT JOEJWJEVPT EF MBT
TPDJFEBEFT BDUVBMFT TFBO ÏTUPT DJFOUÓm
DPTPOP%FCFSFDPOPDFSMBTSFTQVFTUBT
DJFOUÓmDBTZSFHVMBSMBTEFNBOFSBHFOF
SBMEFOUSPEFMPÏUJDBNFOUFQFSNJTJCMF
1BSBFMMPEFCFBQSPWFDIBSMBTBQPSUBDJP
OFTEFMBBVUPDPNQSFOTJØOEFMIPNCSF
Z QSPWFFS MPT FMFNFOUPT RVF MB DJFODJB
OPFTUÈFODPOEJDJPOFTEFPUPSHBS
)PZTPNPTDPOTDJFOUFTEFRVFMBDJFO
DJBOPQVFEFFKFSDFSTVQSPQJPDPOUSPM
BVORVF EJTQPOHB EF MPT NFEJPT UÏDOJ
DPTQBSBIBDFSMPGBMUBOMBEFDJTJØOZFM
DPNQSPNJTPJNQVFTUPTQPSMBTPDJFEBE
BMBDVBMTFEFTUJOBFMQSPHSFTPDJFOUÓmDP
-BJOUFSWFODJØOEFMBTPDJFEBEFOUSB×B
VOBSFTQPOTBCJMJEBEÏUJDBZTPDJBMQFSP
-BCJPÏUJDBOPFTUÈFODPOUSBEFMBUFD
OPDJFODJBTJOPFODPOUSBEFTVEFTBSSP
MMP BM NBSHFO EF WBMPSFT ÏUJDPT MFHBMFT
Z TPDJBMFT .ÏYJDP ZB UJFOF HBOBEP VO
MVHBSFTQFDJBMFOFMNVOEPEFMBCJPÏUJ
DBHSBDJBTBMPTEPDUPSFT.BOVFM7FMBTDP
4VÈSF[ Z (VJMMFSNP 4PCFSØO &TUBNPT
TFHVSPTEFRVFFOMPTB×PTWFOJEFSPTFTUB
OVFWBEJTDJQMJOBKVHBSÈVOQBQFMJNQPS
UBOUFFOMBUBSFBEFBQMJDBSMBÏUJDBBMPT
OVFWPTEFTDVCSJNJFOUPTEFMBNFEJDJOB
HFOØNJDB4ØMPBTÓUFOESFNPTVOBDJFO
DJBDBQB[EFSFTQFUBSMBTFYJHFODJBTEFMB
DPODJFODJBTPDJBMZVOBTPDJFEBEBMBBM
UVSBEFMDPOPDJNJFOUPDJFOUÓmDP
3FGFSFODJBT
$BSSBTDP3PKBT + " %JTUJODJØO i%S $MFNFOUF 3PCMFT $BTUJMMPw BM %S
.BOVFM 7FMBTDP 4VÈSF[ IVNBOJTUB VOJWFSTBM $JSVHÓB Z $JSVKBOPT PDUVCSFEJDJFNCSF
3FBM"DBEFNJB&TQB×PMB
%JDDJPOBSJPEFMB-FOHVB&TQB×PMB<WFSTJØOPOMJOF>
&TQB×B3"&%JTQPOJCMFFOIUUQXXXSBFFT
PERSPETIVADELABIOETICAINDD
1FSTQFDUJWBTEFMB#JPÏUJDBFO*CFSPBNÏSJDB
,VUIZ1PSUFS+
%FPOUPMPHÓBÏUJDBZCJPÏUJDBFOMBNFEJDJOB&O,VUIZ
1PSUFS+$PPSE
5FNBTBDUVBMFTEFCJPÏUJDB.ÏYJDP1PSSÞB
.BSUÓOF[ #VMMÏ (PZSJ 7. #JPÏUJDB Z EFSFDIP &O (BSDÓB 3BNÓSF[ 4
$PPSE
-PTWBMPSFTFOFMEFSFDIPNFYJDBOP6OBBQSPYJNBDJØO.ÏYJDP6/".
Z'$&
.BUFPT+)
.BOVFM7FMBTDP4VÈSF[NÏEJDPZNBFTUSP*ONFNPSJBN
(BDFUB.ÏEJDBEF.ÏYJDP
KVMJPBHPTUP
4BOUPT Z 7BSHBT - -B CJPÏUJDB DPNP VOB EJTDJQMJOB DSÓUJDB &O "DPTUB
4BSJFHP+3&E
#JPÏUJDBQBSBMBTVTUFOUBCJMJEBE-B)BCBOB1VCMJDBDJPOFT
"DVBSJP
7FMBTDP4VÈSF[.
%FSFDIPZTBMVETVQSPUFDDJØOZGPNFOUP#JPÏUJDBQBSB
FMSFTQFUPBMEFSFDIPBMBWJEBZMBQSPNPDJØOEFMBTBMVE&O.V×P[EF"MCB
.FESBOP.$PPSE
5FNBTTFMFDUPTEFTBMVEZEFSFDIP.ÏYJDP6/".
3FGFSFODJBTMFHBMFT
.ÏYJDP$POTUJUVDJØO1PMÓUJDBEFMPT&TUBEPT6OJEPT.FYJDBOPT
.ÏYJDP-FZEFCJPTFHVSJEBEEFPSHBOJTNPTHFOÏUJDBNFOUFNPEJGJDBEPT
.ÏYJDP-FZEFDJFODJBZUFDOPMPHÓB
.ÏYJDP-FZEFMPTJOTUJUVUPTOBDJPOBMFTEFTBMVE
.ÏYJDP-FZHFOFSBMEFTBMVE
.ÏYJDP 3FHMBNFOUP EF MB MFZ HFOFSBM EF TBMVE FO NBUFSJB EF DPOUSPM TBOJUBSJP EF MB
EJTQPTJDJØOEFSFHMBNFOUPEFMBMFZHFOFSBMEFTBMVEFONBUFSJBEFJOWFTUJHBDJØOQBSB
MBTBMVE
.ÏYJDP$ØEJHP1FOBMEFM%JTUSJUP'FEFSBM
PERSPETIVADELABIOETICAINDD
)JTUPSJBEFMEFTBSSPMMPEFMBCJPÏUJDBFO1BSBHVBZ
.BSUB"TDVSSB
-
B CJPÏUJDB FO 1BSBHVBZ OBDF B mOFT
EFMPTZQSJODJQJPTEFMPTFOMB
VOJWFSTJEBEFOFMÈNCJUPEFMBJOWFTUJ
HBDJØOZEFMBTBMVEVOJEBJOJDJBMNFOUF
BMPTQSJODJQJPTEF7BO3FOTTFOMBFS1P
UUFSZTJONVDIBBUFODJØOIBDJBMPTWB
MPSFTEFMQBÓTZMBUJOPBNFSJDBOPT%FTEF
FOUPODFT TV DSFDJNJFOUP IB TJEP MFOUP
QFSPDPOUJOVPDPOMBGPSNBDJØOEFDP
NJUÏTEFCJPÏUJDBFOMPTIPTQJUBMFTHSV
QPTEFFTUVEJPDVSTPTBOVBMFTZFMSFDP
OPDJNJFOUPEFVOB$PNJTJØO/BDJPOBM
FO)BTUBMBGFDIBMBTQFSTPOBTP
HSVQPT QJPOFSPT TF IBMMBO SFMBDJPOBEPT
EFVOBVPUSBGPSNBBMÈSFBEFMBTBMVE
DPNP FM QSPCMFNB EFUPOBOUF RVF MPT
VOF $BCF NFODJPOBS B +VMJB 3JWBSPMB
NÏEJDPQFEJBUSB&EVBSEP"RVJOPNÏ
EJDP FTQFDJBMJ[BEP FO "ENJOJTUSBDJØO
)PTQJUBMBSJB 3PTBMJOP 1JOUP NÏEJDP
HJOFDØMPHP Z &OSJRVF EF .FTUSBM NÏ
EJDPHFSJBUSBB0MHB-ØQF[EF#FOÓUF[
+VMJB$BSNFO.PSFMEF'FTUOFSZ%FP
MJOEB.BDJFMB"MCFSUP-FØOQSFTCÓUF
SPZBMBBVUPSBEFFTUFDBQÓUVMPFOUSF
PUSPT
"HSBEF[DP B +VMJB 3JWBSPMB .BSÓB &VHFOJB
.POUJFM 3PTBMJOP 1JOUP Z &OSJRVF EF .FT
USBM BM QSFTCÓUFSP "MCFSUP -FØO Z BM BCPHBEP
(VJMMFSNP%VBSUFQPSMBTDPOUSJCVDJPOFTZMB
SFWJTJØOEFFTUFNBUFSJBM
PERSPETIVADELABIOETICAINDD
"OUFTEFEFTDSJCJSMPTMPHSPTBDPOUFDJEPT
FODBEBVOPEFMPTÈNCJUPTQSFTFOUBSÏ
MB TJUVBDJØO HFPHSÈmDB Z EFNPHSÈmDB
BTÓDPNPBMHVOPTJOEJDBEPSFTSFMBDJPOB
EPTDPOMBCJPÏUJDBZMPTEFSFDIPTIVNB
OPTFOFMQBÓT&TUPQPSRVFFTOFDFTBSJP
TJUVBSBMMFDUPSFOMBSFBMJEBEEFVOQBÓT
DPO FTDBTP BDDFTP B MB TBMVE QPCSF[B
EFTUSVDDJØO EFM NFEJP BNCJFOUF GBMUB
EFTBOFBNJFOUPCÈTJDPZEFBHVBQPUB
CMF&OSFTVNFOGBMUBEFEFSFDIPTIV
NBOPT .JFOUSBT UBOUP MPT UFNBT RVF
TFBCPSEBOEFTEFFMJOJDJPIBTUBMBGFDIB
QPS MPT iFTQFDJBMJTUBT FO CJPÏUJDB FO FM
QBÓTwFTUÈOSFMBDJPOBEPTDPOTJUVBDJPOFT
RVF NÈT CJFO DPNQFUFO B QBÓTFT EFTB
SSPMMBEPT Z OP MPT BOUFSJPSNFOUF NFO
DJPOBEPTRVFTPOQFDVMJBSFTBMPTQBÓTFT
FOEFTBSSPMMP
4JUVBDJØOHFPHSÈmDB
*OEJDBEPSFTEFNPHSÈmDPTZEF
TBMVEFOUSFPUSPT
-B QPCMBDJØO UPUBM EF 1BSBHVBZ EF
BDVFSEP DPO FM ÞMUJNP DFOTP EF FTEFIBCJUBOUFTEFMPTDVB
MFT QFSUFOFDFO B DPNVOJEBEFT
JOEÓHFOBT BHSVQBEBT FO DJODP GBNJMJBT
MJOHàÓTUJDBTZHSVQPTÏUOJDPTZEJTUSJ
CVJEPTFODPNVOJEBEFTMBTDVBMFT
1FSTQFDUJWBTEFMB#JPÏUJDBFO*CFSPBNÏSJDB
TFIBMMBOFOMPDBMJEBEFTBMFKBEBTZEFEJ
GÓDJMBDDFTP
&T VO QBÓT FO FM DVBM EFTEF TV QSPQJB
HFPHSBGÓB MB JOFRVJEBE TF IBDF QSFTFO
UF&MUFSSJUPSJPOBDJPOBMFTEF
LN EJWJEJEP QPS FM 3ÓP 1BSBHVBZ FO
EPTÈSFBTCJFOEFmOJEBTFOFM$IBDPP
3FHJØO 0DDJEFOUBM DPO VOB TVQFSmDJF
EF LN IBCJUB FM EF MB
QPCMBDJØOZFOMB3FHJØO0SJFOUBMDPO
LN FM SFTUBOUF EFM
DVBM VO WJWF FO FM ÈSFB VSCBOB
-BQPCMBDJØOGPSNBVOBQJSÈNJEFDVZP
FYUSFNP TVQFSJPS TF IBMMB PDVQBEP QPS
MBTQFSTPOBTNBZPSFTEFB×PTDPOVO
ZMBCBTFDPOTUJUVJEBQPSQPCMBDJØO
KPWFODPOVOQFSTPOBTDPONFOPT
EFB×PT&TFTUFHSVQPFUBSJPFMNÈT
BCBUJEPQPSQSPCMFNBTDPNPMBQPCSF
[BEFTOVUSJDJØOBOFNJBGBMUBEFBDDFTP
B MB TBMVE Z BHVB QPUBCMF $PO WBMPSFT
QBSBMBNPSUBMJEBEJOGBOUJMEFQPS
DBEBOBDJEPTWJWPTQBSBMBQPCMB
DJØOHFOFSBMZEFQPSDBEB
OBDJEPTWJWPTFOMBQPCMBDJØOJOEÓHFOB
6OPTOJ×PTZOJ×BTNVFSFODBEB
B×PBOUFTEFBMDBO[BSMPTDJODPB×PTEF
WJEB&M
EFMBTOJ×BTZOJ
×PTNFOPSFTEFDJODPB×PTQBEFDFOEF
EFTOVUSJDJØOHMPCBMZVO
TF FODVFOUSB FO MB GSBOKB EF SJFTHP EF
EFTOVUSJDJØO -B NPSUBMJEBE NBUFSOB
PDVSSF DPO WBMPSFT UBO BMUPT DPNP EF
QPSDBEBSFDJÏOOBDJEPT
BMDBO[BOEPDJGSBTEFFOFMÈSFBSV
SBM&MQBSUPPDVSSFFOJOTUJUVDJPOFTEF
TBMVEFOTØMPFMEFMPTFNCBSB[PT
&M
EFMBTNVKFSFTFNCB
SB[BEBTQBEFDFEFEFTOVUSJDJØO&M
PERSPETIVADELABIOETICAINDD
EFMBQPCMBDJØOQFSTPOBT
OP
UJFOFBDDFTPBBHVBQPUBCMFVOOP
DVFOUBDPOOJOHÞOUJQPEFTBOFBNJFOUP
CÈTJDP1PSVMUJNPFM
QFSTPOBT
OPUJFOFDPCFSUVSBBTJTUFODJBM
NÏEJDBZVUJMJ[BMBNFEJDJOBUSBEJDJPOBM
DPNP QSJNFS USBUBNJFOUP FO FTQFDJBM
FOFMÈSFBSVSBM
6OBEFMBTSJRVF[BTEF1BSBHVBZFTRVF
BÞODPOTFSWBTVMFOHVBOBUJWBZFTVOP
EFMPTQPDPTQBÓTFTDPOEPTMFOHVBTPm
DJBMFTFMFTQB×PMZFMHVBSBOÓ&TUBÞMUJ
NBFTMBQSFEPNJOBOUFFOFMÈSFBSVSBM
IBCMBEBQPSFMEFMPTQPCMBEPSFT
NJFOUSBTRVFFMFTQB×PMFOFMÈSFBVSCB
OBMPIBCMBFM&ONVDIPTDBTPT
FMHVBSBOÓOPFOPSHVMMFDFBTVTIBCJUBO
UFT TJOP RVF DPOTJEFSBO TV FTUVEJP Z
BQSFOEJ[BKF VOB QÏSEJEB EF UJFNQP 4J
CJFOIBCMBSMPIBCJUVBMNFOUFOPFTNPUJ
WPEFFYDMVTJØOFMBOBMGBCFUJTNPFMEFT
FNQMFPFMNBZPSOÞNFSPEFIJKPTBTÓ
DPNP PUSBT GPSNBT EF EJTDSJNJOBDJØO
TFDPODFOUSBOFOQFSTPOBTRVFMPVTBO
&YDMVTJØO4PDJBMFO4BMVE
&MEFMBQPCMBDJØOQBSBHVBZBQSP
GFTBMBSFMJHJØO$BUØMJDB"QPTUØMJDB3P
NBOBVOPUSBTJHMFTJBTDSJTUJBOBTZ
MPTSFTUBOUFTMBTEFNÈTSFMJHJPOFTPTPO
BHOØTUJDPT 1PS ÞMUJNP BVO DVBOEP MB
QSJODJQBM BDUJWJEBE FDPOØNJDB EF 1B
SBHVBZ FT MB BHSJDVMUVSB Z FM EFTBSSPMMP
GPSFTUBMZFYJTUBOEJTQPTJDJPOFTFYQSFTBT
EFQSPUFDDJØOFMUSBCBKPBHSÓDPMBTFMMFWB
BDBCPTJOUFOFSFODVFOUBMPTNÈTNÓOJ
NPTDVJEBEPT1SVFCBEFFMMPFTMBDBEB
WF[NÈTQFMJHSPTBDPOUBNJOBDJØOEFMBT
BHVBTBTÓDPNPFMOBDJNJFOUPEFOJ×PT
)JTUPSJBEFMEFTBSSPMMPEFMBCJPÏUJDBFO1BSBHVBZ.BSUB"TDVSSB
DPONBMGPSNBDJPOFTEFCJEPBMBVUJMJ[B
DJØOEFBMHVOPTIFSCJDJEBT
-FZFTEFDSFUPTEFM1PEFS
&KFDVUJWPZSFTPMVDJPOFT
NJOJTUFSJBMFT
"VORVFOPFYJTUFOSFHMBTPQFSBUJWBTEJ
SFDUBTRVFFTUBCMF[DBOMJOFBNJFOUPTCJP
ÏUJDPTBMUSBUBNJFOUPNÏEJDPTÓFYJTUFO
SFHMBTQSPHSBNÈUJDBTEFSBOHPDPOTUJUV
DJPOBMRVFmKBOMBTCBTFTQBSBMBDSFBDJØO
EFBRVFMMBT&MMPFTJNQPSUBOUFQVFTTJ
ÏTUBTOPFYJTUJFSBOOPTFQPESÓBTJRVJFSB
DPOTJEFSBSMFHJTMBSTPCSFFMQVOUPTJOVOB
FWFOUVBMSFGPSNBEFMB$BSUB.BHOB
1PSFKFNQMPFM"SUEFMB$BSUB.BH
OBDPOTBHSBMBQSPUFDDJØOEFMBWJEBIV
NBOBFOHFOFSBMEFTEFMBDPODFQDJØOZ
QSPQVHOBRVFUPEBQFSTPOBTFBQSPUFHJ
EBQPSFM&TUBEPFOTVJOUFHSJEBEGÓTJDB
ZTÓRVJDBQBSBMPDVBMPCMJHBRVFFYJTUB
VOBMFZDPODSFUBRVFSFHVMFiyMBMJCFS
UBEEFMBTQFSTPOBTQBSBEJTQPOFSEFTV
QSPQJPDVFSQPTØMPDPOmOFTDJFOUÓmDPT
PNÏEJDPTw
0USB EF MBT BSJTUBT EFM NBSDP DPOTUJUV
DJPOBMTFFODVFOUSBFOFM$BQÓUVMP7*EF
FTFDVFSQPMFHBMFOFMDVBMTFDSJTUBMJ[BO
MBT OPSNBT iQSPHSBNÈUJDBTw RVF EFCFO
TFSPQFSBDJPOBMJ[BEBTDPOFMmOEFRVF
MPTEFSFDIPTBMBTBMVEDPOTBHSBEPTFOMB
$POTUJUVDJØOOPTFBOMFUSBNVFSUBFOFM
NÈYJNPPSEFOOBDJPOBM
"SUÓDVMP%FMEFSFDIPBMBWJEB
$BQÓUVMP7*EFMB4BMVE"SUÓDVMP%FMEFSF
DIPBMBTBMVE"SUÓDVMP%FMTJTUFNBOBDJP
OBMEFTBMVE"SUÓDVMP%FMSÏHJNFOEFCJFO
FTUBS TPDJBM "SUÓDVMP %FM OBSDPUSÈmDP EF
MBESPHBEJDDJØOZEFMBSFIBCJMJUBDJØO"SUÓDVMP
%FMDPOUSPMEFDBMJEBE
PERSPETIVADELABIOETICAINDD
"MPFYQVFTUPTFEFCFBHSFHBSRVFFYJT
UF PUSP UJQP EF OPSNBT QSPHSBNÈUJDBT
EF SBOHP DPOTUJUVDJPOBM RVF EFCFO TFS
BUFOEJEBT BM NPNFOUP EF DPOTJEFSBS B
MBCJPÏUJDBZRVFBUB×FOBFMMBQPSRVFTF
SFMBDJPOBOQPSFKFNQMPBMBMJCFSUBEP
BMBJHVBMEBEEFUPEPTMPTIBCJUBOUFTEF
MB3FQÞCMJDBPBMEFSFDIPBMBNCJFOUF
TBMVEBCMFRVFUJFOFOUPEPTMPTIBCJUBO
UFTQPSDJUBSTØMPBMHVOPTFKFNQMPT
4JHVJFOEPFMPSEFOEFQSFMBDJØOEFMFZFT
EFMEFSFDIPQPTJUJWPQBSBHVBZPOPQVF
EFOTPTMBZBSTFMPTUSBUBEPTJOUFSOBDJPOB
MFTRVFEFVOBVPUSBNBOFSBIBDFOBMB
NBUFSJB BOBMJ[BEB DPNP QPS FKFNQMP
MPTNFODJPOBEPTFOMB$POWFODJØO*O
UFSOBDJPOBMTPCSFMPT%FSFDIPTEFM/J×P
ZEFMB/J×BSFGSFOEBEBQPS1BSBHVBZ
FOPDUVCSFEF
&OFTUFPSEFOEFJEFBTFYJTUFOOPSNBT
RVF PQFSBDJPOBMJ[BO EJSFDUBNFOUF FO
QBSUF B MBT OPSNBT DPOTUJUVDJPOBMFT
SFGFSFODJBEBT FOUSF MBT DVBMFT TF QVFEF
DJUBS
B
$ØEJHP 4BOJUBSJP QSPNVMHBEP FO
Z%FDSFUPRVFSF
HMBNFOUB FM "SU EFM $ØEJHP
4BOJUBSJP
$BQÓUVMP**%FMB-JCFSUBE"SUÓDVMP%FMB
MJCFSUBEZEFMBTFHVSJEBEEFMBTQFSTPOBT"S
UÓDVMP%FMBQSPTDSJQDJØOEFMBFTDMBWJUVEZ
EFPUSBTTFSWJEVNCSFT"SUÓDVMP%FMBMJCFS
UBESFMJHJPTBZMBJEFPMØHJDB
$BQÓUVMP***%FMB*HVBMEBE"SUÓDVMP%F
MB JHVBMEBE EF MBT QFSTPOBT "SUÓDVMP %F
MBTHBSBOUÓBTEFMBJHVBMEBE"SUÓDVMP%FMB
JHVBMEBEEFEFSFDIPTEFMIPNCSFZEFMBNVKFS
4FDDJØO**%FM"NCJFOUF"SUÓDVMP%FMEF
SFDIPBVOBNCJFOUFTBMVEBCMF"SUÓDVMP%F
MBQSPUFDDJØOBNCJFOUBM
1FSTQFDUJWBTEFMB#JPÏUJDBFO*CFSPBNÏSJDB
C
-FZ RVF DSFB FM 4FSWJDJP
/BDJPOBMEF4BOFBNJFOUP"NCJFO
UBM4&/"4"
D
-FZ RVF NPEJmDB Z BD
UVBMJ[B MB -FZ /¡ RVF SF
QSJNFFMUSÈmDPJMÓDJUPEFFTUVQFGB
DJFOUFT Z ESPHBT QFMJHSPTBT Z PUSPT
EFMJUPT BmOFT Z FTUBCMFDF NFEJEBT
EF QSFWFODJØO Z SFDVQFSBDJØO EF
GBSNBDPEFQFOEJFOUFT
E
-FZRVFDSFBFM#BODP/B
DJPOBMEF»SHBOPT
F
-FZRVFFTUBCMFDFOPSNBT
TPCSFDPOUSPMEFM4*%"
G
-FZRVFSFHMBNFOUBMBFY
USBDDJØOZUSBTQMBOUFEFØSHBOPT
H
-FZRVFDSFBFM4JTUFNB
/BDJPOBMEF4BMVE
I
-FZEFQSPEVDUPTQBSBMB
TBMVEZPUSPT
1BSBMPTBUBRVFTEJSFDUPTBMPTEJTUJOUPT
CJFOFT KVSÓEJDPT DVZB QSPUFDDJØO GVF
DPOTBHSBEBQPSMB$BSUB.BHOBTFQSF
WJFSPOFOFM$ØEJHP1FOBMTBODJPOFTEF
NVMUBZPQFOBQSJWBUJWBEFMJCFSUBEEF
IBTUBB×PTBUSBWÏTEFEJTUJOUBTOPS
NBTEFDPOEVDUBDPNPQPSFKFNQMP
t
t
-PTBUBRVFTBMBWJEBEFMTFSIVNB
OP TF FODVFOUSBO QSFWJTUPT FO MPT
BSUÓDVMPTBEFM$ØEJHP1F
OBM
-PTBUFOUBEPTBMBTBMVEZBMBJOUF
HSJEBE GÓTJDB FTUÈO QSPTDSJQUPT QPS
MPTBSUÓDVMPTBEFM$ØEJHP
"SUÓDVMP)PNJDJEJPEPMPTP"SUÓDVMP
)PNJDJEJPNPUJWBEPQPSTÞQMJDBEFMBWÓDUJNB
"SUÓDVMP )PNJDJEJP DVMQPTP "SUÓDVMP
4VJDJEJP"SUÓDVMP.VFSUFJOEJSFDUB
QPSFTUBEPEFOFDFTJEBEFOFMQBSUP
PERSPETIVADELABIOETICAINDD
t
t
t
1FOBM Z FM ÞOJDP QFSNJTP RVF TF
PUPSHBBMPTNÏEJDPTQPSFKFNQMP
QBSB TPNFUFS B VOB DJSVHÓB B VO
QBDJFOUFFTUÈDPOUFOJEPFOFM"SU
EFMNJTNPDVFSQPMFHBM
&M USBUBNJFOUP NÏEJDP TJO FM EF
CJEP DPOTFOUJNJFOUP TF FODVFOUSB
DPONJOBEP DPO TBODJØO QFOBM FO
WJSUVE MP QSFWJTUP QPS FM "SU EFM$ØEJHP1FOBM
-PTBUBRVFTBMBTCBTFTOBUVSBMFTEF
MBWJEBIVNBOBTFFODVFOUSBOQSF
WJTUPTFOMPTBSUÓDVMPTBEFM
$ØEJHP1FOBM
"RVFMMPTBUFOUBEPTDPOUSBMBQSVFCB
EPDVNFOUBMZRVFTFSFmFSFOBMÈSFB
EFMBTBMVEUBNCJÏOTFFODVFOUSBO
QSFWJTUPTFOFM$ØEJHP1FOBM
7BSJPTHSVQPTEFMFZFTSFHVMBOMBTBMVE
QFSPOPBCPSEBOFMUFNBEJSFDUBNFOUF
QPS FKFNQMP FM $ØEJHP EF MB /J×F[ Z
EF MB "EPMFTDFODJB FM $ØEJHP -BCPSBM
FOUSFPUSPTEFMPTRVF1BSBHVBZIBTJEP
TJHOBUBSJP
"SUÓDVMP.BMUSBUPGÓTJDP"SUÓDVMP-F
TJØO"SUÓDVMP-FTJØOHSBWF"SUÓDVMP
-FTJØODVMQPTB
"SUÓDVMP $POTFOUJNJFOUP /P IBCSÈ MF
TJØOFOFMTFOUJEPEFMPTBSUÓDVMPTZ
DVBOEPMBWÓDUJNBIBZBDPOTFOUJEPFMIFDIP
"SUÓDVMP5SBUBNJFOUPNÏEJDPTJODPOTFO
UJNJFOUP
"SUÓDVMP&OTVDJBNJFOUPZBMUFSBDJØOEFMBT
BHVBT "SUÓDVMP $POUBNJOBDJØO EFM BJSF
"SUÓDVMP.BMUSBUPEFTVFMPT"SUÓDVMP
1SPDFTBNJFOUP JMÓDJUP EF EFTFDIPT "SUÓDVMP
*OHSFTPEFTVTUBODJBTOPDJWBTFOFMUFSSJUP
SJPOBDJPOBM"SUÓDVMP1FSKVJDJPBSFTFSWBT
OBUVSBMFT
"SUÓDVMP&YQFEJDJØOEFDFSUJmDBEPTEFTB
MVEEFDPOUFOJEPGBMTP"SUÓDVMP1SPEVD
DJØOJOEFCJEBEFDFSUJmDBEPTEFTBMVE"SUÓDVMP
6TPEFDFSUJmDBEPTEFTBMVEEFDPOUFOJEP
GBMTP
)JTUPSJBEFMEFTBSSPMMPEFMBCJPÏUJDBFO1BSBHVBZ.BSUB"TDVSSB
%FVOBSFWJTJØODVJEBEPTBEFMB$POT
UJUVDJØOTFBQSFDJBRVFÏTUBOPDPOTJHOB
OPSNBFYQSFTBRVFSFHVMFMPSFGFSJEPB
JOWFTUJHBDJØO DJFOUÓmDB Z UFDOPMØHJDB
FONBUFSJBEFTBMVE&TUBBVTFODJBoFO
FTQFDJBM MB CJPNÏEJDB FO TFSFT IVNB
OPTo DPOTUJUVZF VO HSBWF QSPCMFNB TJ
DPOTJEFSBNPTFMDPOUFYUPTPDJBMEFMQBÓT
Z RVF MBT JOWFTUJHBDJPOFT UJFOFO DPNP
TVKFUPTEFJOWFTUJHBDJØOHFOFSBMNFOUFB
HSVQPTWVMOFSBCMFT
-PT TJHVJFOUFT BQBSUBEPT TF SFmFSFO B
HSVQPT EF BDUJWJEBEFT EFTBSSPMMBEBT FO
FM QBÓT 5PEBT FMMBT TF FOUSFMB[BO FO TV
DPOUSJCVDJØOBMEFTBSSPMMPEFMBCJPÏUJDB
FO1BSBHVBZ
"TPDJBDJPOFTDJWJMFT
-B QSJNFSB JOTUJUVDJØO DJWJM GVF 130
#*0²5*$"FOUJEBETJOmOFTEFMVDSP
DSFBEBFOKVOJPEF'VFDPODFCJEB
DPNP JOTUJUVDJØO QFSNBOFOUF EF FTUV
EJPBOÈMJTJTZDBQBDJUBDJØOQBSBDPPQF
SBS FO FM QSPDFTP EF OPSNBMJ[BDJØO EFM
DPNQPSUBNJFOUPEFMPTUSBCBKBEPSFTEF
MBTBMVEPUSPTQSPGFTJPOBMFTZMBQPCMB
DJØOFOHFOFSBMDPNQSPNFUJEPTDPOFM
SFTQFUPBMBWJEBZFMEFSFDIPBMBQSPUFD
DJØOEFMBTBMVEMBJOUFHSJEBEBVUPOP
NÓBZEJHOJEBEEFMBQFSTPOBIVNBOBZ
MBQSFTFSWBDJØOEFMPTFDPTJTUFNBT
4VT GVODJPOFT TPO FMBCPSBS QSPHSBNBT
EFFEVDBDJØOQFSNBOFOUFZSFBMJ[BSFKFS
DJDJPT EF EJTDVTJØO FO MB QSPCMFNÈUJDB
QSÈDUJDBEFMPTEJMFNBTCJPÏUJDPTQSPUFD
DJØOEFMBOBUVSBMF[BTBOFBNJFOUPBN
CJFOUBMFDPMPHÓBZSFTQFUPBMBEJHOJEBE
IVNBOB PSHBOJ[BS Z BQPZBS MB SFBMJ[B
PERSPETIVADELABIOETICAINDD
DJØOEFUPEPUJQPEFFWFOUPTEFFEVDB
DJØOQFSNBOFOUFDPOUFNBTEFCJPÏUJDB
DPOHSFTPTDVSTPTUBMMFSFTTFNJOBSJPTZ
PUSPT
QSPNPWFSFJNQVMTBSFMEFTBSSP
MMPEFMBCJPÏUJDBFOMBTJOTUJUVDJPOFTEF
TBMVENJOJTUFSJPTZDFOUSPTNÏEJDPTZ
BQPZBSMBDSFBDJØOEFDPNJUÏTEFCJPÏUJDB
FOIPTQJUBMFTGBDVMUBEFTZPUSPTQBSUJDJ
QBSDPOPSHBOJTNPTOBDJPOBMFTFJOUFS
OBDJPOBMFT JOUFSDBNCJBOEP FWFOUPT EF
GPSNBDJØODBQBDJUBDJØOZBDUVBMJ[BDJØO
FOCJPÏUJDBQSPNPWFSFOMBTGBDVMUBEFTZ
FTDVFMBTVOJWFSTJUBSJBTEPOEFTFJNQBSUF
GPSNBDJØO QSPGFTJPOBM QBSB MB BUFODJØO
Z FM DVJEBEP EF MB TBMVE MB FOTF×BO[B
EFMBCJPÏUJDBDPNPPCMJHBUPSJBFOQSFZ
QPTHSBEPDPPSEJOBSBDDJPOFTZSFnFYJP
OFTDPOPSHBOJTNPTOBDJPOBMFTQÞCMJDPT
Z QSJWBEPT NJOJTUFSJPT JOTUJUVDJPOFT
DPNJTJPOFT TJOEJDBUPT BHSVQBDJPOFT
FOUSFPUSPT
RVFUFOHBOSFMBDJØODPOMB
CJPÏUJDBQBSBTVTUFOUBSDSJUFSJPTZFNJ
UJS PQJOJPOFT TPCSF UFNBT HFOFSBMFT EF
CJPÏUJDBZUFNBTFNFSHFOUFTPQSJPSJUB
SJPT4*%"ESPHBEJDDJØOQMBOJmDBDJØO
GBNJMJBSSJFTHPTSFQSPEVDUJWPTÏUJDBEF
MBFEVDBDJØOTFYVBMMFHJTMBDJØOFOTBMVE
DPODPOTJEFSBDJØOEFKVTUJDJBZFRVJEBE
USBTQMBOUFZEPOBDJØOEFØSHBOPTFOUSF
MPTNÈTBDUVBMFT
FJOTUBMBSFM$FOUSPEF
*OGPSNBDJØOZ#BODPEF%BUPTFO#JP
ÏUJDBDPNPVOBEFMBTQSJNFSBTBDDJPOFT
BSFBMJ[BSTF
&MBDUBEFGVOEBDJØOGVFmSNBEBFMEF
KVOJPEFQPSFM1SFTCÓUFSP"MCFSUP
-FØOZQPS$BSMPT.3BNÓSF[#PFUU
OFS 3BNØO $PSWBMÈO .BSÓB &VHFOJB
.POUJFM EF %PMEÈO .BSUB "TDVSSB EF
%VBSUF $BSMPT "EPMGP 3JBSU &EVBSEP
1FSTQFDUJWBTEFMB#JPÏUJDBFO*CFSPBNÏSJDB
"RVJOP EFM 1VFSUP ;FOØO (PO[ÈMF[
3PNFSP .JHVFM 4ÈODIF[ (PO[ÈMF[
+VMJP .POUU .PNCFSH .BOVFM 'SFT
DP/BSDJTP(PO[ÈMF[3PNFSP+PTÏ7
"MUBNJSBOP Z $BSMPT .FSTBO $BOBMF
EVSBOUFVODVSTPEFCJPÏUJDBRVFUVWP
DPNP PSBEPS BM FTQB×PM .JHVFM 4ÈO
DIF[(PO[ÈMF[%VSBOUFNÈTEFDVBUSP
B×PT TVT NJFNCSPT TF EFEJDBSPO BM FT
UVEJP EF UFNBT EF CJPÏUJDB B USBWÏT EF
SFVOJPOFT NFOTVBMFT EF MFDUVSB FO MPT
DVBMFTUBNCJÏOTFPSHBOJ[BSPOEPTHSBO
EFTDPOGFSFODJBT1BTBEPTFTUPTB×PTTVT
NJFNCSPToRVFGPSNBCBOQBSUFEFPUSBT
PSHBOJ[BDJPOFTEFCJPÏUJDBo EFKBSPOEF
SFVOJSTFZFMHSVQPTFEJTPMWJØ
&OMB6OJWFSTJEBE$BUØMJDB/VFT
USB4F×PSBEFMB"TVODJØOEFMBNBOP
EF 3PTBMJOP 1JOUP EPDUPS FO .FEJDJ
OBZQSPGFTPSEF²UJDB1FSTPOBMDSFBFM
$FOUSPEF&TUVEJPT#JPÏUJDPTRVFJOT
UJUVDJPOBMNFOUFEFQFOEFEFM%FQBSUB
NFOUPEF5FPMPHÓBZ"DDJØO1BTUPSBMEF
MBVOJWFSTJEBE5JFOFFOUSFTVTBDUJWJEB
EFTQSJODJQBMFTMBQSPNPDJØOZFMFTUVEJP
EF MB CJPÏUJDB DPO WJTJØO QFSTPOBMJTUB
DVFOUB FOUSF TVT JOUFHSBOUFT B QSPGFTP
SFTEFEJTUJOUBTÈSFBTEFMB6OJWFSTJEBE
$BUØMJDBQFSTPOBTEFFYQFSJFODJBFOFM
DBNQPCJPÏUJDPDPNPMPTTBDFSEPUFT"M
CFSUP-FØOZ4JMWJP4VÈSF[ZMPTEPDUPSFT
.JHVFM 'SFTDP I
NÏEJDP QTJRVJBUSB
"OUPOJB #FOÓUF[ 3JWBT NÏEJDP QFEJB
USBZEPDFOUFEFMB6OJEBE1FEBHØHJDB
EF 7JMMBSSJDB Z FM QSPGFTPS *MEF 4JMWF
SP QFSJPEJTUB Z EFDBOP EF MB 'BDVMUBE
EF'JMPTPGÓBZ$JFODJBT)VNBOBTEFMB
NJTNBVOJWFSTJEBE'VFSPOTVNÈOEPTF
B FTUF HSVQP $BSPMJOB 3PESÓHVF[ BCP
PERSPETIVADELABIOETICAINDD
HBEBZ.BHEBMFOB(FOFTUFOGFSNFSBZ
EJSFDUPSBEFMB&TDVFMBEF1PTUHSBEPEF
&OGFSNFSÓBEFMB6OJWFSTJEBE$BUØMJDB
5BNCJÏO IB EFTBSSPMMBEP DPOGFSFODJBT
FOFMÈSFBEFMBNBDSPCJPÏUJDB
0USPTHSVQPTEFBTPDJBDJPOFTDJWJMFTZB
OPSFMBDJPOBEPTDPOFMÈSFBEFMBTBMVE
GVFSPOGPSNBEPTEVSBOUFFTUPTÞMUJNPT
B×PTMPDVBMFTVOJOEJDBUJWPEFMBJN
QPSUBODJBRVFFTUBEJTDJQMJOBWBDPCSBO
EPFOFMQBÓT
$PNJUÏTEFÏUJDBZEFCJPÏUJDB
-BGPSNBDJØOEFDPNJUÏTOPFTFTUJNV
MBEBOJSFDPOPDJEBQPSMBTBVUPSJEBEFT
" QFTBS EF FMMP FYJTUFO FO 1BSBHVBZ
USFT UJQPT EF DPNJUÏT DPOTUJUVJEPT FO
TV NBZPSÓB QPS QSPGFTJPOBMFT EF MB TB
MVEBVUPEJEBDUBTFOFMUFNBMPTDPNJUÏT
EF CJPÏUJDB IPTQJUBMBSJPT DSFBEPT QBSB
FM BOÈMJTJT EF MPT EJMFNBT ÏUJDP DMÓOJDPT
EFMPTQBDJFOUFTZFMFTUBCMFDJNJFOUPEF
OPSNBUJWBT P QSPUPDPMPT BTJTUFODJBMFT
FOFTQFDJBMQBSBBRVFMMPTUFNBTEFDPO
nJDUP GSFDVFOUF TVQFSBEPT DPO DSFDFT
FOOÞNFSPQPSMPTFTUBCMFDJNJFOUPTEF
TBMVEQÞCMJDBZQSJWBEBMPTEFÏUJDBFO
JOWFTUJHBDJØO FODBSHBEPT EF MB FWBMVB
DJØOEFMPTQSPUPDPMPTEFJOWFTUJHBDJØO
ZVOB$PNJTJØO/BDJPOBMQBSBFM%FTB
SSPMMPEFMB#JPÏUJDBFO1BSBHVBZ"DBS
HPEFFTUPTDPNJUÏTmHVSBOUBNCJÏOMBT
UBSFBTEFEPDFODJBZEJGVTJØOEFMBCJPÏ
UJDBEFOUSPZGVFSBEFTVTJOTUJUVDJPOFT
QBSB MP DVBM TF PSHBOJ[BO TFNJOBSJPT
KPSOBEBTVPUSPTFWFOUPTDPOFYQPTJUP
SFTOBDJPOBMFTPFYUSBOKFSPT&OBMHVOPT
DBTPTTFJOWPMVDSBOUBNCJÏOBDUJWJEBEFT
SFMBDJPOBEBTDPOÏUJDBQSPGFTJPOBM
)JTUPSJBEFMEFTBSSPMMPEFMBCJPÏUJDBFO1BSBHVBZ.BSUB"TDVSSB
&OUSF MPT DPNJUÏT EF ÏUJDB IPTQJUBMBSJB
TFQVFEFOOPNCSBSoQPSPSEFOEFDSFB
DJØOoFMEFM)PTQJUBM.BUFSOP*OGBOUJM
3FJOB4PGÓBEFMB$SV[3PKBQBSBHVBZB
DSFBEPFMEFBHPTUPEFRVFUJFOF
BTVDBSHPFMBTFTPSBNJFOUPFODBTPTEF
EJMFNBTÏUJDPTTPCSFUPEPFOFMÈSFBNB
UFSOPJOGBOUJMZEFTBSSPMMBBOVBMNFOUF
DIBSMBTZDVSTPTQBSBTVTQSPGFTJPOBMFT
&M EF NBS[P EF TF DSFØ FO MB
$ÈUFESBZ4FSWJDJPEF1FEJBUSÓBEFM)PT
QJUBMEF$MÓOJDBTEFMB'BDVMUBEEF$JFO
DJBT .ÏEJDBTEFMB 6OJWFSTJEBE/BDJP
OBMEF"TVODJØO6/"
VO$PNJUÏEF
#JPÏUJDBTJFOEPTVQSFDVSTPS+PTÏ-VJT
%FMHBEJMMP &TUBCB EFEJDBEP BM BOÈMJTJT
EFEJMFNBTÏUJDPTSFGFSFOUFTBMÈSFBEFMB
QFEJBUSÓB Z TVT NJFNCSPT QBSUJDJQBCBO
FO MB EJTDVTJØO EF DBTPT DMÓOJDPT 3F
DJÏOFOMVFHPEFMBWJTJUBEF&MFOB
-VHPZEFSFVOJPOFTEFBVUPFEVDBDJØO
TFDPOGPSNØFM$PNJUÏEF#JPÏUJDBEFM
)PTQJUBM EF $MÓOJDBT FODBCF[BEP QPS
&OSJRVFEF.FTUSBM
&OPDUVCSFEFGVFDSFBEPFM$P
NJUÏEF²UJDBEFM$ÓSDVMP1BSBHVBZPEF
.ÏEJDPT &OUSF TVT GVOEBEPSFT TF FO
DPOUSBCBOFMQSFTCÓUFSP"MCFSUP-FØOZ
MPT EPDUPSFT +VMJB 3JWBSPMB .BSÓB &V
HFOJB.POUJFMEF%PMEÈO*HOBDJP*SB
NBÓOZPUSPT4VTQSJODJQBMFTGVODJPOFT
TPOBCPSEBSTJUVBDJPOFTÏUJDBTQVOUVBMFT
BTPMJDJUVEEFMPTTFSWJDJPTBTJTUFODJBMFT
ZSFBMJ[BSBOÈMJTJTEFMFZFTPSFHMBNFOUPT
SFMBDJPOBEPTDPOFMUFNB&M$PNJUÏTF
SFÞOFSFHVMBSNFOUFZIBSFBMJ[BEPEPT
DVSTPTFOMPTÞMUJNPTB×PTi"OÈMJTJTEF
4FSWJDJPT"TJTUFODJBMFTZ&TUVEJPZ1SP
PERSPETIVADELABIOETICAINDD
QVFTUBTTPCSFMB-FZ/BDJPOBMEF"CMB
DJØOZ5SBTQMBOUFTwZi3FEBDDJØOEFMB
/PSNBUJ[BDJØOEFMPT$SJUFSJPTEF"E
NJTJØOEF1BDJFOUFTFOMBT6OJEBEFTEF
5FSBQJB*OUFOTJWBEF/J×PTZ"EVMUPTw
&M*OTUJUVUPEFM$ÈODFSMVFHPEFVODVS
TPJNQBSUJEPQPSNJFNCSPTEFM$PNJUÏ
EF #JPÏUJDB EFM )PTQJUBM EF $MÓOJDBT
DPOGPSNB TV QSPQJP $PNJUÏ FM DVBM
BVORVF JOJDJB TVT BDUJWJEBEFT PmDJBM
NFOUFFMEFKVOJPEFBÞOOP
IBTJEPSFDPOPDJEPQPSMBTBVUPSJEBEFT
EFMBJOTUJUVDJØO'PSNBOQBSUFEFM$P
NJUÏ &MFOB 0TOBHIJ CJPRVÓNJDB 3P
CFSUP3JFDIFSUFTQFDJBMJTUBFONFEJDJOB
QBMJBUJWB8BMUFS$ÈDFSFTNÏEJDP(VT
UBWP (VHJBSJ NÏEJDP FTQFDJBMJ[BEP FO
PODPMPHÓB%FPMJOEB#FOÓUF[EF.BDJFM
FOGFSNFSB-BVEFMJOB#PSKBFOGFSNFSB
Z3BRVFM.PMJOBTQTJDØMPHB&OUSFTVT
GVODJPOFTTFFODVFOUSBOBEFNÈTEFMBT
RVFDPNQFUFOBVODPNJUÏEFCJPÏUJDB
CSFHBSQPSVOBNVFSUFEJHOBTJOEPMPS
Z QPS UBOUP FM TVNJOJTUSP EF NFEJDB
NFOUPTDPNPMBNPSmOB
&OTFDPOGPSNØFM$PNJUÏEF#JP
ÏUJDBEFM)PTQJUBM#BSSJP0CSFSPDPOMB
QBSUJDJQBDJØOEF3JDBSEP3JWFSPTNÏEJ
DP DJSVKBOP +FSØOJNP #BVEP NÏEJDP
QFEJBUSB.JHVFM«OHFM3PMØONÏEJDP
QFEJBUSB1BVMJOB$VM[POJFOGFSNFSBZ
.BSÓB4BOUBOEFSTJDØMPHB&TUFFTVOP
EFMPTIPTQJUBMFTEF"TVODJØORVFBUJFO
EF MB NBZPS QPCMBDJØO EF QFSTPOBT EF
FTDBTPT SFDVSTPT QVFT TF IBMMB VCJDBEP
DFSDBEFVOPEFMPTQSJODJQBMFTDPSEPOFT
EFQPCSF[BEFMQBÓT
1FSTQFDUJWBTEFMB#JPÏUJDBFO*CFSPBNÏSJDB
&M*OTUJUVUPEF1SFWJTJØO4PDJBMFOUJEBE
FODBSHBEBEFMBTFHVSJEBETPDJBMEFMPT
USBCBKBEPSFT EFM ÈNCJUP QSJWBEP MVFHP
EF WBSJBT SFVOJPOFT Z B×PT EF USBCBKP
FOQSPEFMBCJPÏUJDBMPHSØTVSFDPOPDJ
NJFOUPFONBZPEFM&OFTUFHSV
QPTFEFTUBDBO4BSB'MPSFOUÓO$BSNFO
'SVUPTEF"MNBEB$BSMPT0SUJ[&TUFMB
&MÓBT*NFMEB.BSUÓOF[EF/Þ×F['SBO
DJTDP 1FSSPUB 7JDFODJB 5FKFSB Z 0MHB
#FOÓUF[
&M)PTQJUBM/BDJPOBMEF*UBVHVBFTVO
IPTQJUBM EF BMUB DPNQMFKJEBE EFQFO
EJFOUF EFM .JOJTUFSJP EF 4BMVE .BH
EBMFOB 5BUUFS FHSFTBEB EF MPT DVSTPT
EF .BFTUSÓB FO #JPÏUJDB EJDUBEPT QPS
MB 0SHBOJ[BDJØO 1BOBNFSJDBOB EF MB
4BMVE 0140.4 FO 4BOUJBHP EF $IJ
MF USBCBKB FO GVODJØO EF MB BDFQUBDJØO
JOTUJUVDJPOBMEFM$PNJUÏEF#JPÏUJDBFM
RVF oEFCJEP BM FMFWBEP OÞNFSP MB EJ
WFSTJEBE DVMUVSBM Z QSJODJQBMNFOUF MB
TJUVBDJØO EF QPCSF[B EF MB NBZPSÓB EF
TVTQBDJFOUFToDPOTUJUVZFVOBOFDFTJEBE
BMBIPSBEFQSFWFOJSZSFTPMWFSDPOnJD
UPTRVFQVFEFOBGFDUBSMPTEFSFDIPTEF
ÏTUPT
&M QSJNFS $PNJUÏ EF ²UJDB FO *OWFTUJ
HBDJØO EFM *OTUJUVUP EF *OWFTUJHBDJPOFT
FO$JFODJBTEFMB4BMVEPSHBOJTNPEF
QFOEJFOUF EF MB 6OJWFSTJEBE /BDJPOBM
EF"TVODJØO**$46/"
TFDPOGPSNØ
FM EF NBS[P EF QPS SFTPMVDJØO
EFM FOUPODFT EJSFDUPS .BSUÓO $IJPMB
4VT GVODJPOFT DPNQSFOEFO FM BOÈMJTJT
Z BQSPCBDJØO EF QSPUPDPMPT EF JOWFT
UJHBDJØO MB SFWJTJØO EF BSUÓDVMPT BOUFT
EFTVQSFTFOUBDJØOBDPOHSFTPTPEFTV
PERSPETIVADELABIOETICAINDD
FOWÓPQBSBQVCMJDBDJØOMBGPSNBDJØOEF
QSPGFTJPOBMFTEFM*OTUJUVUPPEFBRVFMMBT
FOUJEBEFTPQFSTPOBTRVFMPTPMJDJUFOB
USBWÏTEFMBSFBMJ[BDJØOEFTFNJOBSJPTZ
DVSTPTTPCSFFMUFNB-PTNJFNCSPTEFM
$PNJUÏGPSNBOQBSUFEFMDVFSQPEPDFO
UFEFMDVSTPEFQPTHSBEPTPCSF.FUPEP
MPHÓB EF MB *OWFTUJHBDJØO EFTBSSPMMBEP
EFTEFIBDFWBSJPTB×PTFOMBJOTUJUVDJØO
6OTFHVOEP$PNJUÏEF²UJDBFO*OWFT
UJHBDJØODPOTUJUVJEPQPS&TUFCBO'FSSP
"OUPOJP$VCJMMBTZ"HVFEB$BCFMMPTF
GPSNØFODPNPQBSUFEFMB'BDVM
UBE EF $JFODJBT .ÏEJDBT EF MB 6/"
4F SFFTUSVDUVSØ MVFHP QPS 3FTPMVDJØO
EFM)POPSBCMF$POTFKP%JSFDUJWPEFMB
'BDVMUBE EVSBOUF JODMVZFOEP B
*NFMEB /Þ×F[ 'ÈUJNB "ZBMB &OSJRVF
EF.FTUSBMZ$SJTUJOB+JNÏOF[
&M*OTUJUVUP/BDJPOBMEF4BMVEEFQFO
EJFOUFEFM.JOJTUFSJPEF4BMVE1ÞCMJDB
FTVOPSHBOJTNPEFEJDBEPBMBFOTF×BO
[BDPOUJOÞBEFMPTQSPGFTJPOBMFT$VFOUB
DPOVO$PNJUÏEF#JPÏUJDBFOUSFMPTRVF
mHVSBO +PTÏ .BSÓO .BTTPMP (VTUBWP
$SJTUBMEP-VJT4JNBODBTZ-VJT1BWFUUJ
RVFUJFOFFOUSFTVTGVODJPOFTMBFWBMVB
DJØOEFQSPZFDUPTEFJOWFTUJHBDJØO
" QBSUJS EF MB DSFBDJØO EFM 1SPHSBNB
3FHJPOBMEF#JPÏUJDB13#
EFMB0SHB
OJ[BDJØO1BOBNFSJDBOBEFMB4BMVEFO
TV QSJNFS EJSFDUPS +VMJP .POUU
.PNCFSH JNQVMTØ OPUBCMFNFOUF MBT
BDUJWJEBEFTEFCJPÏUJDBTFO1BSBHVBZTF
HVJEPQPS)FSOÈO.ÈMBHBNÏEJDPTB
MVCSJTUBRVJFOEVSBOUFTVFTUBEÓBDPNP
3FQSFTFOUBOUFEFMB0140.4FO1BSB
HVBZPSHBOJ[ØFOKVOJPEFMDPO
)JTUPSJBEFMEFTBSSPMMPEFMBCJPÏUJDBFO1BSBHVBZ.BSUB"TDVSSB
KVOUBNFOUF DPO FM *OTUJUVUP /BDJPOBM
EF"TVODJØOEFQFOEJFOUFEFM.JOJTUF
SJPEF4BMVE1ÞCMJDBZ#JFOFTUBS4PDJBM
.41Z#4
VO5BMMFSEF"OÈMJTJTEF4J
UVBDJØO Z &MBCPSBDJØO EF VO 1SPZFDUP
QBSBFM%FTBSSPMMP/BDJPOBMEFMB#JPÏUJ
DB&MFWFOUPJOWPMVDSØBEJGFSFOUFTJOT
UJUVDJPOFTEFMQBÓTDVZPTSFQSFTFOUBOUFT
TJHVJFSPOSFVOJÏOEPTFEVSBOUFUSFTB×PT
NÈTIBTUBTFSSFDPOPDJEPTDPNPNJFN
CSPT EF MB $PNJTJØO /BDJPOBM QBSB FM
%FTBSSPMMP EF MB #JPÏUJDB QPS 3FTPMV
DJØOEFM.41Z#4/EFMEF
PDUVCSF EF B QFEJEP EF )FSOÈO
.ÈMBHBBMFOUPODFT.JOJTUSPEF4BMVE
+VMJP$ÏTBS7FMÈTRVF[$POGPSNBOFTUB
DPNJTJØO.BSUB"TDVSSBTFDSFUBSJBEFMB
$PNJTJØO FO SFQSFTFOUBDJØO EFM *OTUJ
UVUPEF*OWFTUJHBDJPOFTFO$JFODJBTEFMB
4BMVE$PNJUÏEF²UJDBFO*OWFTUJHBDJØO
**$4
&TUFMB&MÓBTNÏEJDBQFEJBUSBEFM
$PNJUÏEF#JPÏUJDBEFM*OTUJUVUPEF1SF
WJTJØO4PDJBM.BSÓB.BHEBMFOB5BUUFS
NÏEJDB QFEJBUSB .BHÓTUFS EF #JPÏUJDB
)PTQJUBM /BDJPOBM EF *UBVHVB &MFOB
0TOBHIJ%PSJBCJPRVÓNJDBEFM$PNJUÏ
EF #JPÏUJDB EFM *OTUJUVUP /BDJPOBM EFM
$ÈODFS +VMJB .BSÓB EFM 1JMBS 3JWBSPMB
NÏEJDBQFEJBUSBEFM$PNJUÏEF#JPÏUJDB
EFM )PTQJUBM EF $MÓOJDBT Z EFM $ÓSDVMP
1BSBHVBZPEF.ÏEJDPT0MHBEF-ØQF[
FOGFSNFSB EFM $PNJUÏ EF #JPÏUJDB EFM
*OTUJUVUPEF1SFWJTJØO4PDJBM"TDFODJØO
%FPMJOEB #FOÓUF[ EF .BDJFM FOGFSNF
SB PCTUFUSB EFM $PNJUÏ EF #JPÏUJDB EFM
*OTUJUVUP /BDJPOBM EFM $ÈODFS +VMJB
$BSNFO .PSFM EF 'FTUOFS FOGFSNFSB
PCTUFUSB EF MB &TDVFMB EF &OGFSNFSÓB
EFM *OTUJUVUP %S "OESÏT #BSCFSP FM
QSFTCÓUFSP&EHBS#PCBEJMMB.BHÓTUFSEF
PERSPETIVADELABIOETICAINDD
#JPÏUJDBZ5FØMPHPVONJFNCSPEFMB
4PDJFEBE $JFOUÓmDB EF &TUVEJBOUFT EF
.FEJDJOB EF MB 6/" Z VO SFQSFTFO
UBOUFEFM.JOJTUFSJPEF4BMVE1ÞCMJDBZ
#JFOFTUBS4PDJBM5JFOFMBUBSFBEFFMBCP
SBS MBT OPSNBT OBDJPOBMFT BDUVBMNFOUF
FO QSPDFTP EF DPOTUSVDDJØO UFOJFOEP
FO DVFOUB FM DSFDJFOUF OÞNFSP EF QFS
TPOBTRVFUSBCBKBOFOJOWFTUJHBDJØOFO
NVDIPTDBTPTDPOHSVQPTWVMOFSBCMFT
&OTF×BO[B
&O FM ÈNCJUP FTDPMBS GPSNBM QSJNBSJP
Z TFDVOEBSJP MB FOTF×BO[B FT FTQPSÈEJ
DBZMBQÏSEJEBEFWBMPSFTDPOTUJUVZFVO
HSBWF QSPCMFNB FO FTUB QPCMBDJØO &O
QSFHSBEP VOJWFSTJUBSJP MB ÏUJDB FT USBUB
EBTØMPFOBMHVOBTDBSSFSBTFOFTQFDJBM
FOMBTSFGFSJEBTBMBTDJFODJBTEFMBTBMVE
-PT SFGFSFOUFT BDBEÏNJDPT UFOFNPT MB
SFTQPOTBCJMJEBEEFMJEFSBSMBFEVDBDJØO
EFQSPGFTJPOBMFTEFMBTEJGFSFOUFTDBSSF
SBTZEFMQÞCMJDPFOHFOFSBMDPNPMBÞOJ
DB GPSNB EF BTFHVSBS RVF MPT EFSFDIPT
IVNBOPTTFBOSFTQFUBEPT
&OFOMBDBSSFSBEF.FEJDJOBEF
MB6/"MB²UJDB.ÏEJDBFSBDPOTJEFSB
EBVOPEFMPTUFNBTFOMBTDÈUFESBTEF
.FEJDJOB-FHBMZ%FPOUPMPHÓB.ÏEJDB
%VSBOUF FTF NJTNP B×P FO MB &TDVFMB
EF&OGFSNFSÓBEFMB6OJWFSTJEBE$BUØMJ
DBTFFNQJF[BOBEFTBSSPMMBSMBTDÈUFESBT
EF²UJDB1SPGFTJPOBM²UJDB(FOFSBM²UJ
DB .ÏEJDB Z #JPÏUJDB DPNP DVSTPT EF
QPTHSBEP&OTFJODPSQPSBMBDÈUF
ESBEF#JPÏUJDBDPNPNBUFSJBDVSSJDVMBS
FOMB&TDVFMBEF&OGFSNFSÓBZ0CTUFUSJ
DJB *OTUJUVUP "OESÏT #BSCFSP FOUJEBE
EFQFOEJFOUFEFMB6/"
1FSTQFDUJWBTEFMB#JPÏUJDBFO*CFSPBNÏSJDB
%FTEFTFEFTBSSPMMBSPODVSTPTEF
QPTHSBEP FO CJPÏUJDB QBSB MPT NÏEJDPT
SFTJEFOUFTEFMBDÈUFESBEF1FEJBUSÓBEF
MB 'BDVMUBE EF $JFODJBT .ÏEJDBT EF MB
6/" Z QBSB MPT NÏEJDPT SFTJEFOUFT
FO 1FEJBUSÓB EFM *OTUJUVUP EF 1SFWJTJØO
4PDJBM QSPWFOJFOUFT EF MB 6OJWFSTJEBE
$BUØMJDB EF 7JMMBSSJDB %FQBSUBNFOUP
EFM(VBJSB
$POMBSFGPSNBDVSSJDVMBSEFFO
MB 'BDVMUBE EF $JFODJBT .ÏEJDBT EF MB
6/" F JNQVMTBEP QPS FM $PNJUÏ EF
#JPÏUJDB EFM )PTQJUBM EF $MÓOJDBT TF
JOUSPEVKFSPOFOFMQMBOEFFTUVEJPTMBT
NBUFSJBTEF²UJDB.ÏEJDBZ#JPÏUJDBFO
FMTFHVOEPDVSTPZDPOVOBDBSHBEF
IPSBT
1VCMJDBDJPOFT
(JMEBEF'BUJNB#VSHTUBMMFSEF+VTUJOJB
OPFEJUØFOFMMJCSPi3FTQPOTB
CJMJEBE 1FOBM EF MPT .ÏEJDPT -FHJTMB
DJØO%PDUSJOBZ+VSJTQSVEFODJBwFOFM
DVBM WBSJPT EF TVT DBQÓUVMPT TF SFmFSFO
BUFNBTEFCJPÏUJDBDPNPFMBCPSUPMB
FVUBOBTJB MB FVHFOFTJB BZVEB BM TVJDJ
EJP Z DPOTFOUJNJFOUP 4J CJFO NVDIPT
EF FTUPT UFNBT OP TF IBMMBO UJQJmDBEPT
FOMBMFHJTMBDJØOQBSBHVBZBMBBVUPSBMPT
FODBSBOPTØMPEFTEFQVOUPEFWJTUBMFHBM
TJOPCJPÏUJDP#VSHTUBMMFS
&OKVOJPEFFM$FOUSPEF&TUVEJPT
EF #JPÏUJDB EF MB 6OJWFSTJEBE $BUØMJDB
/VFTUSB 4F×PSB EF "TVODJØO MBO[Ø MB
QVCMJDBDJØO FTQFDJBMJ[BEB #JPÏUJDB DPO
VOB QFSJPEJDJEBE EF EPT OÞNFSPT QPS
B×PZBSUÓDVMPTEFBVUPSFTOBDJPOBMFTF
JOUFSOBDJPOBMFT
PERSPETIVADELABIOETICAINDD
%VSBOUF FM 7* $POHSFTP #SBTJMFSP EF
#JPÏUJDB*$POHSFTPEFM.&3$0463
Z'PSVNEFMB3FE#JPÏUJDBEF6/&4
$0GVFMBO[BEBMBQSJNFSBQVCMJDBDJØO
DJFOUÓmDB EF FTUB SFE i&TUBUVUP &QJTUF
NPMØHJDP EF MB #JPÏUJDBw DPPSEJOBEB
QPS 7PMOFJ (BSSBGB EF #SBTJM .JHVFM
,PUUPX EF $IJMF Z "MZB 4BBEB SFT
QPOTBCMFEFM1SPHSBNBEF#JPÏUJDBEFMB
0mDJOBEF6/&4$0FO.ÏYJDP
&O KVMJP EF FO FM .JOJTUFSJP EF
4BMVE 1ÞCMJDB Z #JFOFTUBS 4PDJBM GVF
QSFTFOUBEPFMMJCSPi4BMVE1ÞCMJDB&O
GPRVF #JPÏUJDPw EF )FSOÈO .ÈMBHB Z
DPMBCPSBEPSFT&TUFWPMVNFODVFOUBDPO
MBDPOUSJCVDJØOEF+VBO$BSMPT;BOPUUJ
RVÓNJDPJOEVTUSJBMQBSBHVBZP
&O GVF QSFTFOUBEB MB UFSDFSB QV
CMJDBDJØO EF MB 3FE -BUJOPBNFSJDBOB Z
EFM$BSJCF#JPÏUJDB6/&4$0i1BOP
SBNBTPCSFMBMFHJTMBDJØOFONBUFSJBEF
HFOPNB IVNBOP FO "NÏSJDB -BUJOB Z
FM$BSJCFwDPPSEJOBEBQPS"MZBB4BBEB
Z%JFHP7BMBEÏT$POUJFOFMBDPOUSJCV
DJØO EF +PSHF 4FBMM4BTJBJO DBUFESÈUJDP
EF %FSFDIP $POTUJUVDJPOBM /BDJPOBM
Z$PNQBSBEPFOMBTGBDVMUBEFTEF%F
SFDIP EF MB 6OJWFSTJEBE /BDJPOBM EF
"TVODJØOZEFMB6OJWFSTJEBE$BUØMJDB
EF"TVODJØOBDFSDBEFMBMFHJTMBDJØOFO
NBUFSJB EF HFOPNB IVNBOP FO 1BSB
HVBZ
&MEFNBS[PEFMTFQSFTFOUØFM
i.BOVBMEF#JPÏUJDBiBEBQUBEPBM1SP
HSBNBEF1SFHSBEPEF#JPÏUJDBFTDSJUP
QPS&OSJRVFEF.FTUSBMZDPMBCPSBEPSFT
&OFTUFQVFEFOMFFSTFDBQÓUVMPTTPCSFFM
JOJDJPZmOBMEFMBWJEBQMBOJmDBDJØOGB
)JTUPSJBEFMEFTBSSPMMPEFMBCJPÏUJDBFO1BSBHVBZ.BSUB"TDVSSB
NJMJBSDVJEBEPTQBMJBUJWPTHFOPNBIV
NBOP FDPMPHÓB ÏUJDB FO JOWFTUJHBDJØO
FOUSFPUSPT
$VSTPTKPSOBEBTZDPOHSFTPT
%FTEFMBTBDUJWJEBEFTSFGFSFOUFTB
CJPÏUJDBIBOJEPFOBVNFOUPPSHBOJ[B
EBTFOTVNBZPSÓBQPSMPTDPNJUÏTEFÏUJ
DBZCJPÏUJDBEFOUSPEFTVTGVODJPOFTEF
FEVDBDJØO DPOUJOVB &O VO JOJDJP GVF
SPOEJSJHJEBTBQSPGFTJPOBMFTEFMBTBMVE
TJO FNCBSHP EVSBOUF MPT ÞMUJNPT B×PT
IBOTJEPBCJFSUBTBMQÞCMJDPFOHFOFSBM
&OKVOJPEFTFMMFWØBDBCPFOMB
'BDVMUBEEF.FEJDJOBEF7JMMBSSJDB%F
QBSUBNFOUPEFM(VBJSBFMQSJNFSDVSTP
EFCJPÏUJDB$POMBEPDFODJBEFMPTEPD
UPSFT +VMJB 3JWBSPMB Z %BOJFM %PNJOJ
Z EFM QBESF "MCFSUP #FSUBDDJOJ FTUVWP
EJSJHJEPFTQFDJBMNFOUFBFTUVEJBOUFTEF
.FEJDJOB0CTUFUSJDJBZ&OGFSNFSÓB
&M1SJNFS4FNJOBSJPEF#JPÏUJDBTFMMFWØ
BDBCPFOUSFFMZFMEFOPWJFNCSF
EF0SHBOJ[BEPQPSFM$PNJUÏEF
²UJDB FO *OWFTUJHBDJØO EFM *OTUJUVUP EF
*OWFTUJHBDJPOFTFO$JFODJBTEFMB4BMVE
EF MB 6/" DPOUØ DPO MB BTJTUFODJB EF
OVNFSPTPTQSPGFTJPOBMFTEFMBTBMVE
-B "DBEFNJB EF .FEJDJOB SFDPOPDJEB
FOUJEBEEFEJDBEBBMBEJGVTJØOEFDPOP
DJNJFOUPT B NÏEJDPT HSBEVBEPT QSFTJ
EJEBQPS$BSMPT.FSTÈO$BOBMFEJPVO
GVFSUFSFTQBMEPBMBCJPÏUJDBDPOFMEFTB
SSPMMPEFWBSJBTDPOGFSFODJBTFOUSF
Z
"QBSUJSEFBJOTUBODJBTEFMB"TP
PERSPETIVADELABIOETICAINDD
DJBDJØOEF1SPGFTPSFTEFMB'BDVMUBEEF
$JFODJBT.ÏEJDBTEFMB6/"FTJOWJUB
EBMBQSPGFTPSB.BSÓB&MFOB-VHPRVJFO
oEFTEFFOUPODFToIBQBSUJDJQBEPBOVBM
NFOUFDPNPDPOGFSFODJTUBJOWJUBEBDPO
UFNBTTPCSFMBDPOGPSNBDJØOEFDPNJUÏT
EF CJPÏUJDB BVUPFEVDBDJØO Z EJMFNBT
ÏUJDPTBTPDJBEPTPOPBQSPCMFNBTIPT
QJUBMBSJPTFOMPTOVNFSPTPTTFNJOBSJPT
Z KPSOBEBT PSHBOJ[BEPT QPS FM $PNJUÏ
EF #JPÏUJDB EFM )PTQJUBM EF $MÓOJDBT
-PT QSPGFTPSFT $BSMPT %ÓB[ Z +PTÏ %P
NÓOHVF[BNCPTFTQB×PMFTQBSUJDJQBSPO
FOBHPTUPEFMFOFMTFNJOBSJPi-B
#JPÏUJDBZFMWBMPSEFMBWJEB)VNBOB
.BOJQVMBDJØO(FOÏUJDB)VNBOBZ&Y
QFSJNFOUBDJØODPO4FSFT)VNBOPT$F
NFOUFSJPEF$PODJFODJBTw&TUFFWFOUP
GVFPSHBOJ[BEPQPSFM*OTUJUVUP&NNB
OVFM.PVOJFSEFMB6OJWFSTJEBE$BUØMJ
DBEF"TVODJØOFM$PNJUÏEF#JPÏUJDB
EFM)PTQJUBMEF$MÓOJDBTZMB$PNJTJØO
/BDJPOBM QBSB FM %FTBSSPMMP EF MB #JP
ÏUJDB
&OUSFFMZFMEFKVMJPEFDPO
FMmOEFGPSUBMFDFSMPTDPNJUÏTEFÏUJDB
FOJOWFTUJHBDJØOFOFM)PTQJUBM#BVUJTUB
EF "TVODJØO TF MMFWØ B DBCP VO DVSTP
EFCJPÏUJDBEFPDIPIPSBTEFEVSBDJØO
EJDUBEPDPONÏUPEPTEFFTUVEJPEF*OT
UJUVUJPOBM 3FWJFX #PBSE 6OJWFSTJUZ PG
/FX.FYJDPZ0ĆDFPG)VNBO3FTFBSDI
1SPUFDUJPO
-B$PNJTJØO/BDJPOBMQBSBFM%FTBSSP
MMPEFMB#JPÏUJDBFO1BSBHVBZIBPSHBOJ
[BEPMBTSBZEBKPSOBEBTOBDJPOBMFTFM
EFPDUVCSFEFZFMOPWJFNCSF
EFMSFTQFDUJWBNFOUF&OBNCBTTF
1FSTQFDUJWBTEFMB#JPÏUJDBFO*CFSPBNÏSJDB
IBDPOUBEPDPONÈTEFQBSUJDJQBO
UFT FOUSF MPT RVF TF EFTUBDBO QSPGFTJP
OBMFTEFMBTBMVEFTUVEJBOUFTEFOJWFMTF
DVOEBSJPZNJFNCSPTEFMBDJVEBEBOÓB
%FTEFIBDFWBSJPTB×PTFMUFNBCJPÏUJDP
WJFOFTJFOEPJODMVJEPFTQFDJBMNFOUFFO
MPTDPOHSFTPTEF1FEJBUSÓB(JOFDPMPHÓB
&OGFSNFSÓB Z &OGFSNFSÓB 0ODPMØHJDB
QPS OPNCSBS TØMP BMHVOPT &OUSF MPT
JOWJUBEPTTFFODVFOUSB7ÓDUPS1FODIBT
[BEFINÏEJDPHFOFUJTUBBSHFOUJOPRVF
QBSUJDJQØ DPO WBSJPT UFNBT EVSBOUF FM
$POHSFTPEF1FEJBUSÓBEF
1BSBHVBZGVFQBÓTDPPSHBOJ[BEPSEFM7*
$POHSFTP#SBTJMFSPEF#JPÏUJDB*$PO
HSFTPEFM.&3$0463Z'ØSVNEFMB
3FE -BUJOPBNFSJDBOB Z EFM $BSJCF EF
#JPÏUJDB6/&4$0CBKPFMMFNBi#JPÏ
UJDB.FJP"NCJFOUFF7JEB)VNBOBw
MMFWBEP B DBCP FO 'P[ EF *HVB[Þ #SB
TJMFOUSFFMEFBHPTUPZFMEFTFQ
UJFNCSFEF/VNFSPTPTGVFSPOMPT
QBSBHVBZPTRVFQBSUJDJQBSPODPOUFNBT
DFOUSBMFTZUFNBTMJCSFT
&MFS$POHSFTP*OUFSOBDJPOBMEF#JPÏ
UJDB PSHBOJ[BEP FO 1BSBHVBZ i#JPÏUJDB
1FSTPOBMJTUB FO VO .VOEP (MPCBMJ[B
EPw GVF PSHBOJ[BEP QPS FM $POTPSDJP
EF .ÏEJDPT $BUØMJDPT Z MB 1POUJmDJB
"DBEFNJB QPS MB 7JEB 4F MMFWØ B DBCP
FOUSFFMZFMEFKVMJPEFZBTJT
UJFSPO NÈT EF RVJOJFOUPT QBSUJDJQBOUFT
EF MPT ÈNCJUPT SFMJHJPTP FEVDBUJWP EF
MB TBMVE FOUSF PUSPT JOUFSFTBEPT 1BSUJ
DJQBSPO.POT&MJP4HSFDDJBQSFTJEFOUF
EF MB 1POUJmDJB "DBEFNJB QPS MB 7JEB
1"7
EFM 7BUJDBOP .POT .BVSJDJP
$BMJQBSJ PmDJBM EF FTUVEJP EF MB 1"7
PERSPETIVADELABIOETICAINDD
.POT'FSOBOEP$IPNBMÓEF$IJMFZ
3VCÏO3FWFMMPEF"SHFOUJOB
%FDMBSBDJØO6OJWFSTBMTPCSF
#JPÏUJDBZ%FSFDIPT)VNBOPT
&M EF OPWJFNCSF EF TF SFBMJ[Ø
FM 4FNJOBSJP 3FHJPOBM i#JPÏUJDB VO
%FTBGÓP *OUFSOBDJPOBM )BDJB VOB %F
DMBSBDJØO 6OJWFSTBMw DPOWPDBEP QPS FM
.JOJTUFSJP EF +VTUJDJB Z %FSFDIPT )V
NBOPTEF"SHFOUJOBEVSBOUFFMDVBMTF
SFEBDUØMB$BSUBEF#VFOPT"JSFTTPCSF
#JPÏUJDBZ%FSFDIPT)VNBOPTVOQSP
OVODJBNJFOUP TPCSF DVFTUJPOFT GVO
EBNFOUBMFT EFTEF FM DPOUFYUP QPMÓUJDP
TPDJPFDPOØNJDP Z DVMUVSBM EF "NÏSJDB
-BUJOBZFM$BSJCF-BNJTJWBGVFFOWJBEB
BMB4FDSFUBSÓBEFM$PNJUÏ*OUFSOBDJPOBM
EF#JPÏUJDBEFMB6/&4$0DPOTJEFSBO
EPRVFVOJOTUSVNFOUPEFCJPÏUJDBDPO
QSFUFOTJPOFT EF VOJWFSTBMJEBE OP QP
ESÓBEFKBSEFMBEPFMEFSFDIPBMBTBMVE
BMBHVBQPUBCMFMBQPCSF[BOJBWBMBSMB
JOFRVJEBEZMBEFTJHVBMEBERVFBGFDUBB
MBNBZPSÓBEFOVFTUSPTQBÓTFT-B$BSUB
GVF BDPNQB×BEB EF PUSBT FOWJBEBT QPS
MBTDBODJMMFSÓBTEFMPTQBÓTFTEFMBSFHJØOB
MBTFEFEFMB6/&4$0-B%FDMBSBDJØO
6OJWFSTBM TPCSF #JPÏUJDB Z %FSFDIPT
)VNBOPTGVFBQSPCBEBQPSMBVOBOJNJ
EBEEFMPTQBÓTFTDPNQPOFOUFTEFMB
PSHBOJ[BDJØOFMEFPDUVCSFEF
EVSBOUF MB $POGFSFODJB (FOFSBM EF MB
6/&4$0 SFBMJ[BEB FO 1BSÓT 'SBODJB
$PO TVT BSUÓDVMPT RVF JODMVZFO MBT
NPEJmDBDJPOFT TPMJDJUBEBT DPOTUJUVZF
VO JOTUSVNFOUP FO FM RVF TF QFSDJCF FM
DPNQSPNJTPDPOMBTQPCMBDJPOFTWVMOF
SBCMFTZMPTEFSFDIPTIVNBOPT
)JTUPSJBEFMEFTBSSPMMPEFMBCJPÏUJDBFO1BSBHVBZ.BSUB"TDVSSB
$PODMVTJØO
&O 1BSBHVBZ EFTQVÏT EF DBTJ RVJODF
B×PTEFEFTBSSPMMPMBCJPÏUJDBTFFOGSFO
UBOPTØMPBMBGBMUBEFEJGVTJØOEFTVUF
NÈUJDBFOFMNFEJPSVSBMEFGPSNBDJØO
EFSFGFSFODJBMFTBDBEÏNJDPTEFDPNJUÏT
EF CJPÏUJDB IPTQJUBMBSJPT EF SFDPOPDJ
NJFOUPQPSQBSUFMBTBVUPSJEBEFTFOUP
EPTMPTÈNCJUPTEFVOTJTUFNBOBDJPOBM
EF FWBMVBDJØO ÏUJDB EF JOWFTUJHBDJØO
TJOPUBNCJÏOBPUSPTEFTBGÓPTDPNPMB
EFTOVUSJDJØOMBQPCSF[BMBEFTUSVDDJØO
EFMNFEJPBNCJFOUFZMPTFMFWBEPTJOEJ
DBEPSFTEFNPSUBMJEBEJOGBOUJMZNBUFS
OB&TUBTDBSFODJBTFTQFSBOVOBSFTQVFT
UB CBTBEB FO MB CJPÏUJDB Z MPT EFSFDIPT
IVNBOPT
3FGFSFODJBT
"TDVSSB."3PTBMFT$
"OÈMJTJTZ1FSGJM#JPÏUJDPEFMB*OWFTUJHBDJØOFO
4BMVE 1ÞCMJDB &O .ÈMBHB )FSOÈO 4BMVE 1ÞCMJDB &OGPRVF #JPÏUJDP $BSBDBT
%*4*/-*.&%QQ
"TDVSSB."3PTBMFT$
'PSNBDJØOZ$BQBDJUBDJØOEF3FDVSTPT)VNBOPT
EF MB #JPÏUJDB FO 4BMVE 1ÞCMJDB &O .ÈMBHB )FSOÈO 4BMVE 1ÞCMJDB &OGPRVF
#JPÏUJDP$BSBDBT%*4*/-*.&%QQ
"TDVSSB ." $PNFOUBSJPT B MB 1POFODJB EF -FØO 0MJWÏ &O (BSSBGB 7
,PUUPX.4BBEB"&TUBUVUP&QJTUFNPMØHJDPEFMB#JPÏUJDB.ÏYJDP6/".
6/&4$0Q
#VSHTUBMMFSEF+VTUJOJBOP(
3FTQPOTBCJMJEBE1FOBMEFMPT.ÏEJDPT-FHJTMBDJØO
%PDUSJOBZ+VSJTQSVEFODJB"TVODJØO(SBQIJT
%F.FTUSBM&OSJRVF
.BOVBMEF#JPÏUJDB"TVODJØO&EJDJØOEFM"VUPS
%JSFDDJØO (FOFSBM EF &TUBEÓTUJDBT &ODVFTUBT Z $FOTPT %(&&$
1SJODJQBMFT
3FTVMUBEPT&ODVFTUB*OUFHSBEBEF)PHBSFT1BSBHVBZ'FSOBOEPEFMB.PSB
014«SFBEF"OÈMJTJTEF4BMVEZ4JTUFNBTEF*OGPSNBDJØO4BOJUBSJB
*OJDJBUJWB
3FHJPOBM EF %BUPT #ÈTJDPT FO 4BMVE 4JTUFNBT EF *OGPSNBDJPOFT 5ÏDOJDBT FO 4BMVE
8BTIJOHUPO%$&E014
1BSBHVBZ$POTUJUVDJØO/BDJPOBMEFM1BSBHVBZ+VOJP
1BSBHVBZ&YDMVTJØO4PDJBMFO4BMVE0DUVCSF
1BSBHVBZ3FTPMVDJØOEFM.JOJTUFSJPEF4BMVE1ÞCMJDBZ#JFOFTUBS4PDJBMEFPDUVCSFEF
1SP#JPÏUJDB"DUBEF'VOEBDJØOEF1SP#JPÏUJDB+VOJP
4FBMM4BTJBJO+
1BOPSBNBTPCSFMBMFHJTMBDJØOFONBUFSJBEFHFOPNBIVNBOP
FO1BSBHVBZ&O4BBEB"7BMBEÏT(1BOPSBNBTPCSFMBMFHJTMBDJØOFONBUFSJB
EFHFOPNBIVNBOPFO"NÏSJDB-BUJOBZFM$BSJCF1VCMJDBDJØO$JFOUÓGJDB/¡3FE
-BUJOPBNFSJDBOBZEFM$BSJCF#JPÏUJDB6/&4$0QQ
6/&4$0 %FDMBSBDJØO 6OJWFSTBM TPCSF #JPÏUJDB Z %FSFDIPT )VNBOPT 1BSÓT
6/&4$0
PERSPETIVADELABIOETICAINDD
PERSPETIVADELABIOETICAINDD
#JPÏUJDBFO1FSÞ
3PCFSUP-MBOPT;VMPBHB
*OUSPEVDDJØO
&
O 1FSÞ MB CJPÏUJDB OP IB BERVJSJEP
UPEBWÓB JEFOUJEBE QSPQJB &MMB FT
BMHPNÈTRVFMPTQSPCMFNBTÏUJDPTEFMB
QSÈDUJDBNÏEJDB6OBEFTVTDPORVJTUBT
FT RVF FO UPEBT MBT FOUJEBEFT EF TBMVE
FYJTUB FM $PNJUÏ )PTQJUBMBSJP EF ²UJDB
$)&
NJFOUSBT RVF FOUSF OPTPUSPT
UPEBWÓBTFEFTFBRVFFMDPNJUÏEF²UJDB
EFM $PMFHJP .ÏEJDP SFTVFMWB UPEPT MPT
QSPCMFNBT JHVBMNFOUF RVF MB $PNJ
TJØO/BDJPOBMEF-VDIBDPOUSBFM4*%"
TPMVDJPOFUPEPMPSFMBUJWPBFTUBQBOEF
NJB
-BQSJNFSBUFTJTTPCSFFVUBOBTJBZMBQV
CMJDBDJØO EFM MJCSP DPOTJHVJFOUF QPS MB
6OJWFSTJEBE 1FSVBOB $BZFUBOP )FSF
EJBZBFTVOBSFBMJEBE.POUPSJ5VEF
MB
1PSPUSBQBSUFMPTNFEJPTEF
DPNVOJDBDJØO DPO SFMBUJWB GSFDVFODJB
USBUBO EF NFOUBMJ[BS B MB QPCMBDJØO FO
TVT QSFKVJDJPT EF OP QFSNJUJS RVF TVT
ØSHBOPTTFBOFYUSBÓEPTQBSBTBMWBSPUSBT
WJEBT&TQFSBNPTMMFHBSBTFSUFTUJHPTEF
MPTGSVUPTEFFTUFNPWJNJFOUP
&T OFDFTBSJP DSFBS DPNJUÏT EF CJPÏUJDB
RVF SFHVMFO MBT BDDJPOFT NÏEJDBT SFMB
DJPOBEBTDPOMPTUSBTQMBOUFTEFØSHBOPT
PERSPETIVADELABIOETICAINDD
&TUF IFDIP VOJEP B PUSPT OVNFSPTPT
IBDFOWFSRVFFO1FSÞTFIBJOJDJBEPMB
FUBQB EF SFDPOPDJNJFOUP EF FTUB EJTDJ
QMJOB
-BUFDOPMPHÓBNÏEJDBTFIBUPSOBEPTV
NBNFOUFDPTUPTBFOTVBDDJØOBNCJHVB
FODVBOUPBBZVEBTPDJBMFJODJFSUBDPO
SFMBDJØOBTVFmDBDJB)BQSPEVDJEPJO
UFOTB QPMÏNJDB FO MPT QBÓTFT EFM PSCF
)BEBEPMVHBSBMOBDJNJFOUPEFMBCJPÏ
UJDBNPEFSOBZIBDSFBEPDPODJFODJBEF
MBVSHFODJBEFTVSFHVMBDJØO1FSÞOPTF
FYDMVZFEFMBUPNBEFDPODJFODJBOJEF
MB VSHFODJB EF FTUB SFHVMBDJØO -MBOPT
-BUSJQMFEJNFOTJØOEFMBNFEJDJOBEJP
PSJHFOBMBCJPÏUJDBTPCSFMBTCBTFTEFMB
ÏUJDB NÏEJDB MB DVBM WJTUB EFTEF PUSP
ÈOHVMP FT FM FTUVEJP TJTUFNÈUJDP EF MB
DPOEVDUB IVNBOB FO FM DBNQP EF MBT
DJFODJBTEFMBWJEBZMBBUFODJØOEFMBTB
MVEEFTEFFMGVOEBNFOUPEFMPTWBMPSFT
ZQSJODJQJPTNPSBMFT
-BCJPÏUJDBFO1FSÞOPIBEBEPMVHBSBM
FKFSDJDJP QSPGFTJPOBM FYDMVTJWP EF FTUB
SBNBEFMTBCFSIVNBOP4VFOTF×BO[BTF
JNQBSUF FO MBT GBDVMUBEFT EF .FEJDJOB
1TJDPMPHÓB'JMPTPGÓBZ5FPMPHÓBZIBJEP
1FSTQFDUJWBTEFMB#JPÏUJDBFO*CFSPBNÏSJDB
HBOBOEPUFSSFOPZDPOTFHVJEPTVQSPQJB
JEFOUJEBE 5BNCJÏO IB FMFWBEP MB JN
QPSUBODJBEFNBUFSJBTUBMFTDPNP'JMPTP
GÓBEFMB.FEJDJOB"OUSPQPMPHÓB.ÏEJDB
Z&QJTUFNPMPHÓB.ÏEJDB$POTFHVJEBTV
QSPQJBJEFOUJEBERVFEBQFOEJFOUFFMDB
NJOPEFTVSFDPOPDJNJFOUPZEJGVTJØO
"DDJPOFT NÏEJDBT FTFODJBMFT FO MB DB
MJEBE EF WJEB RVFEBO B MB FTQFSB EF MB
CJPÏUJDB-BMFZEFUSBTQMBOUFTFTVOBEF
FMMBT JHVBMNFOUF VOB NBZPS DSFBDJØO
EFDPNJUÏTEFÏUJDBJOTUJUVDJPOBMFTZEF
JOWFTUJHBDJØO-BÏUJDBQSFWFOUJWBFTUÈB
MBFTQFSBEFTVQFSBSBMBiÏUJDBEFTBMWB
WJEBTw QSPQJB EF QBÓTFT DPO QPCMBDJØO
DSFDJFOUFZSFDVSTPTFDPOØNJDPTEFDSF
DJFOUFT 'FMJ[NFOUF FM DPOTFOUJNJFOUP
JOGPSNBEPBWBO[BEÓBBEÓBFOTVBDFQ
UBDJØO -B QBUFSOJEBE SFTQPOTBCMF Z MB
QMBOJmDBDJØOGBNJMJBSTFEFTBSSPMMBOMFO
UBNFOUFZOPBMDBO[BOBÞOOJWFMFTØQUJ
NPT&MOÞNFSPEFBEPMFTDFOUFTFNCB
SB[BEBTZEFNBESFTTPMUFSBTTFNBOUJFOF
BMSFEFEPSEFMZMMFHBSBMBBEVMUF[
QSFTVQPOFNVDIBTWFDFTUFOFSZBUSFT
IJKPTZVOQBSEFBCPSUPTFOMBIJTUPSJB
QFSTPOBM-BQÓMEPSBBOUJDPODFQUJWBZMB
EFMEÓBTJHVJFOUFTFNBOUJFOFOFOMBQP
MÏNJDB Z MB PQJOJØO EF MB NVKFS OP FT
UPEBWÓBNBZPSJUBSJB
&MBCPSUPJMFHBMTFTJHVFQSBDUJDBOEPFO
NFEJPEFHSBWFTEFmDJFODJBTEFBTFQTJBZ
DPOQFMJHSPEFNVFSUFFONVKFSFTKØWF
OFT -PT DÓSDVMPT BDBEÏNJDPT Z TPDJBMFT
NBOUJFOFO TJMFODJP GSFOUF B MB WBTFDUP
NÓBMJHBEVSBZTFDDJØOEFUSPNQBT$PO
NBZPS SB[ØO MB NVKFS HVBSEB TJMFODJP
GSFOUFBUPEPTFTUPTBDUPTEFTBMVE
PERSPETIVADELABIOETICAINDD
&OSFMBDJØODPOMBFVUBOBTJBTFEJTDVUF
BDUVBMNFOUF TJ FM BTFTJOBUP DPNQBTJWP
DSFBSÈNÈTQSPCMFNBTRVFMPTRVFQVFEB
TPMVDJPOBS *HVBMNFOUF FM iUFTUBNFOUP
WJUBMw TF FODVFOUSB FO EJTDVTJØO .VZ
FTQPSÈEJDBNFOUF TF SFBMJ[BO NFTBT SF
EPOEBTPTFTJPOFTDJFOUÓmDBTTPCSFFTUF
UFNB
1SPCMFNBBQBSUFFTMBFOTF×BO[BBMPTOJ
×PTEJTDBQBDJUBEPTFTEJGÓDJMMPHSBSTVJO
UFHSBDJØOFOFTDVFMBTDPNVOFTOPFYJTUF
VO OÞNFSP TVmDJFOUF EF FTDVFMBT FTQF
DJBMFTZUPEBWÓBRVFEBVODBNJOPQPSSF
DPSSFSFOMBBDFQUBDJØOZBZVEBTPDJBM
$PO SFMBDJØO BM 4*%" TF CVTDB oDPO
ÏYJUPQBSDJBMoRVFTFTVQFSFMBEJTDSJNJ
OBDJØOTPDJBMZEFBUFODJØOIPTQJUBMBSJB
EF FTUPT QBDJFOUFT &M UFNPS Z MB JHOP
SBODJBIBDJBFTUBFOGFSNFEBEFTUPEBWÓB
NVZMMBNBUJWP
)POPSJP%FMHBEPQSFDVSTPS
)POPSJP%FMHBEPQSPGFTPSQFSVBOPEF
1TJRVJBUSÓBQSJNFSSFDUPSEFMB6OJWFS
TJEBE1FSVBOB$BZFUBOP)FSFEJBBOUF
SJPSNFOUF EF MB 6OJWFSTJEBE /BDJPOBM
.BZPSEF4BO.BSDPTFJHVBMNFOUFFY
NJOJTUSPEF&EVDBDJØOFO1FSÞSFQSF
TFOUØoEFTEFIBTUBoMBWJTJØO
IVNBOÓTUJDBEFMB.FEJDJOBZMBTJEFBT
FVSPQFBT FO MB DVMUVSB EF MB TBMVE 1B
SBGSBTFBCB TJFNQSF B 4DIJMMFS Z BDUVBM
NFOUF TF QVFEF QSPCBS GÈDJMNFOUF RVF
BQMJDBCBTVBOÈMJTJTNPSBMFOFMFTUVEJP
EFMQBDJFOUFQTJRVJÈUSJDP
)POPSJP%FMHBEPTJOUJØVOBHSBOJEFO
UJmDBDJØO DPO MB DVMUVSB Z QTJRVJBUSÓB
#JPÏUJDBFO1FSÞ3PCFSUP-MBOPT;VMPBHB
BMFNBOBT &O TV BSUÓDVMP i&O UPSOP BM
BMNBBKFOBwDJUBB4DIJMMFSSFmSJÏOEPTF
BMQSPDFTPEFDPNQSFOTJØOi4JRVJFSFT
DPNQSFOEFSUFBUÓNJTNPNJSBDPNPTF
DPOEVDFOMPTPUSPTw
&YQMJDØ TJFNQSF oFO TVT DMBTFT MJCSPT
ZFOMBDPNVOJDBDJØOQFSTPOBMoRVFMB
NFEJDJOB UJFOF VOB EJNFOTJØO USJQMF
DJFOUÓmDB QSPGFTJPOBM Z BTJTUFODJBM Z
BEFNÈTKVFHBVOSPMEFDJTJWPFOFMDBN
CJPUFDOPMØHJDPZBYJPMØHJDPEFOVFTUSB
DVMUVSB
&TUPTQSJODJQJPTRVFSFTQPOEÓBOBMQFO
TBNJFOUP IVNBOÓTUJDP EF TV UJFNQP
PGSFDÓBO MB CBTF QBSB RVF IBDF USFJOUB
B×PT FO FM SFTUP EFM NVOEP FNQF[BSB
B EFTBSSPMMBSTF MB QPTJDJØO QPMÏNJDB EF
MB CJPÏUJDB &MMB FT FM DPOKVOUP EF DP
OPDJNJFOUPTDJFOUÓmDPTRVFFTUVEJBOMB
USBOTGPSNBDJØOUFDOPMØHJDBEFMBNFEJ
DJOB"EFNÈTFTMBSFTQVFTUBSBDJPOBMB
MPTQSPCMFNBTNPSBMFTQPMÓUJDPTZTPDJB
MFTRVFQMBOUFBOMBTGPSNBTEFBUFODJØOB
MBTBMVEIVNBOBDPOMBÞOJDBmOBMJEBE
EF QSPEVDJS CFOFmDJPT FO MBT JOUFSWFO
DJPOFTCJPNÏEJDBT
)POPSJP %FMHBEP CSJOEØ FO DMBTFT Z
MJCSPT MB JOGPSNBDJØO OFDFTBSJB QBSB
DPOTJEFSBS MP RVF IPZ FO EÓB TF DPOP
DF DPNP MPT USFT OJWFMFT EF MB CJPÏUJDB
BTBCFS
NBDSPÏUJDBÏUJDBBNCJFOUBM
FDPMØHJDB CJPNÏEJDB Z QMBOFUBSJB NFTPCJPÏUJDB ÏUJDB EF MB JOUFSWFODJØO
CJPUÏDOJDBTPCSFMBWJEBIVNBOBJODMV
ZFOEP QSJODJQBMNFOUF BM OBDJNJFOUP
EFTBSSPMMPIVNBOPMBNVFSUFFMBCPS
UPZBMBFVUBOBTJBZ
NJDSPCJPÏUJDB
ÏUJDB NÏEJDB QSPQJBNFOUF EJDIB RVF
PERSPETIVADELABIOETICAINDD
DPNQSFOEF MB SFMBDJØO UFSBQÏVUJDB Z MB
BUFODJØOEFMBTBMVE
"USBWÏTEFTVTFOTF×BO[BTTPCSFMBTSFMB
DJPOFTFOUSFmMPTPGÓBNFEJDJOBFQJTUF
NPMPHÓBZBOUSPQPMPHÓBNÏEJDBJOHSFTB
BMBCJPÏUJDBQSJODJQBMNFOUFBMBNFTP
Z NJDSPCJPÏUJDB "MHVOBT EF TVT FOTF
×BO[BTQSJODJQBMFTUVWJFSPOSFMBDJØODPO
MB NFEJDJOB Z MB mMPTPGÓB &TUB ÞMUJNB
DVBOEPJOHSFTBBMBNFEJDJOBSFDPSSFMPT
QMBOPTDMÈTJDPTEFMBPOUPMPHÓBHOPTFP
MPHÓBZÏUJDBTFHÞOTFUSBUFEFQBUPMPHÓB
DMÓOJDBPUFSBQÏVUJDB)POPSJP%FMHBEP
QSPQJDJØFTUBFOTF×BO[BFO1FSÞZEFKØ
FMSFUPEFTVDPOUJOVBDJØOBMBTVOJWFSTJ
EBEFTQFSVBOBT
-FHØMBFOTF×BO[BEFRVFNFEJDJOBTJH
OJmDBNFEJUBDJØOZDVSBEFMIPNCSFFO
GFSNP -B WJEB NÏEJDB TJO NFEJUBDJØO
OPFTWJEB-BWJEBNÏEJDBFTNFUBGÓTJDB
MØHJDBZNPSBMWBMFEFDJSmMPTPGÓBNÏ
EJDB FO FKFSDJDJP .JFOUSBT FYJTUB NÈT
UFDOPMPHÓBNÈTJNQPSUBOUFTFSÈFMQFO
TBNJFOUPDSÓUJDP.JFOUSBTFYJTUBNFOPT
QFOTBNJFOUP DSÓUJDP NÈT QFMJHSPTP Z
DPTUPTPTFSÈFMFKFSDJDJPEFMBNFEJDJOB
*OJDJPTEFMNPWJNJFOUPCJPÏUJDP
QFSVBOP
&MNPWJNJFOUPCJPÏUJDPFO1FSÞTFJOJ
DJBFODVBOEPMB+VOUB%JSFDUJWB
EFM$PMFHJP.ÏEJDPJOJDJØMBDPOWPDBUP
SJBBNFTBTSFEPOEBTBVOBWFJOUFOBEF
NÏEJDPT DPO WPDBDJØO ÏUJDB CJPÏUJDB Z
EFPOUPMØHJDBFOSFBMJEBETFGPSNØVOB
DPNJTJØOJOUFHSBEBFOUSFPUSPTQPS(VJ
MMFSNP$POUSFSBTZ4BMPNØO;BWBMBQFSP
RVF OP DPOUJOVBSPO MB MBCPS JOJDJBEB
1FSTQFDUJWBTEFMB#JPÏUJDBFO*CFSPBNÏSJDB
&OKVOJPEFTFGVOEØFO$BSBDBT
MB 'FEFSBDJØO -BUJOPBNFSJDBOB EF *OT
UJUVDJPOFT EF #JPÏUJDB '&-"*#&
QPS
JOUFSWFODJØO EF 1BCMP 1VMJEP NÏEJDP
WFOF[PMBOPEJSFDUPSFKFDVUJWPEFMB'F
EFSBDJØO 1BOBNFSJDBOB EF 'BDVMUBEFT
Z &TDVFMBT EF .FEJDJOB +PTÏ "MCFSUP
.BJOFUUJIVNBOJTUBBSHFOUJOPEJSFDUPS
EFM $FOUSP 0ODPMØHJDP EF &YDFMFODJB
$0&
Z "MGPOTP -MBOP &TDPCBS 4+
EJSFDUPSEFM$FOUSP/BDJPOBMEF#JPÏUJ
DB$&/"-#&
EF$PMPNCJB
)BTUB 1FSÞ OP UFOÓB SFQSFTFOUB
DJØO DPOUJOFOUBM Z TØMP DPO QPTUFSJPSJ
EBEBM$POHSFTPEF1TJRVJBUSÓBFO$IJ
MFFTFNJTNPB×PFM%JSFDUPSEFM$0&
QPS SFDPNFOEBDJØO EF MPT FTQFDJBMJTUBT
DIJMFOPT'FSOBOEP-PMBTFOUSFPUSPT
NFJOWJUBQBSBFMTJHVJFOUFFODVFOUSP
&OEJDJFNCSFEFTFSFBMJ[ØFO"S
HFOUJOBCBKPMPTBVTQJDJPTEFM$0&FM
QSJNFSFODVFOUSP"MMÓSFDJCÓEFMB0S
HBOJ[BDJØO 1BOBNFSJDBOB EF MB 4BMVE
014
FMQFEJEPEFSFEBDUBSVOBSUÓDVMP
TPCSFMBCJPÏUJDBFO1FSÞRVFGVFQVCMJ
DBEPFOJOHMÏTZFTQB×PMFOFM#PMFUÓO
EFMB0mDJOB4BOJUBSJB1BOBNFSJDBOBFO
4FHVJEBNFOUFSFDJCÓFMFODBSHPEFEJDUBS
DIBSMBTTPCSFCJPÏUJDBFO1FSÞZEFPSHB
OJ[BSFMHSVQPEFUSBCBKPEFNJQBÓT
&OTFMMFWØBDBCPFM**&ODVFOUSP
FO7JMMBEF-FZWB$PMPNCJBFOEPOEF
TFUFSNJOØFMQSPDFTPEFGVOEBDJØOZTF
IJ[PVO1MBO5SJFOBMEF5SBCBKP&OÏTUF
TFNFQJEJØRVFPSHBOJ[BTFMBTJHVJFOUF
SFVOJØO$POFTUFNPUJWPGVOEÏMB"TP
PERSPETIVADELABIOETICAINDD
DJBDJØO1FSVBOBEF#JPÏUJDB"41&#*0
FOUJEBE RVF SFDJCJØ MB SFQSFTFOUBDJØO
PmDJBMEF1FSÞBOUF'&-"*#&
&O TF SFBMJ[Ø FO -JNB FM *** &O
DVFOUSPFOFMDBNQVTEFMB6OJWFSTJEBE
EFM 4BHSBEP $PSB[ØO &O FM *7
FO (VBOBKVBUP .ÏYJDP PSHBOJ[BEP
QPS (BCSJFM $PSUÏT (BMMP &M 7 TF MMF
WØBDBCPFOFO4BP1BVMP#SBTJM
PSHBOJ[BEPQPS"MGPOTP3FOBUP.FJSB
$PJODJEJFOEPDPOFTUBSFVOJØOTFSFB
MJ[ØFM1SJNFS$POHSFTPEF#JPÏUJDBEF
"NÏSJDB-BUJOBZFM$BSJCFZTFBEPQUØ
MBEFDJTJØOEFTFHVJSSFBMJ[BOEPFODVFO
USPTQPSMPNFOPTDBEBEPTB×PT
-B"TPDJBDJØO1FSVBOBEF
#JPÏUJDB"41&#*0
#VTDBGPNFOUBSFMFTUVEJPJOUFSEJTDJQMJ
OBSJP EF MPT QSPCMFNBT DSFBEPT QPS MB
UFDOPMPHÓBNPEFSOBZTVTPMVDJØOÏUJDB
QSPNVFWFBQPZBZEJGVOEFMBFOTF×BO[B
EF MB CJPÏUJDB FO MBT GBDVMUBEFT EF .F
EJDJOB F JOTUJUVDJPOFT EF TBMVE %FTEF
GPNFOUBMBDSFBDJØOEFJOTUJUVUPT
ZDFOUSPTEFCJPÏUJDBZMBJOWFTUJHBDJØOZ
EJGVTJØOEFFTUFNPWJNJFOUPIVNBOJTUB
&ONBS[PEFTFSFBMJ[ØMBQSJNFSB
SFVOJØO QSFQBSBUPSJB EF "41&#*0 &M
EFNBZPEFTFBDPSEØGVOEBSMB
"TPDJBDJØOBmMJBEBBM'&-"*#&ZBMB
"TPDJBDJØO*OUFSOBDJPOBMEF#JPÏUJDB"
QBSUJS EF FOUPODFT TF IBO WFOJEP SFBMJ
[BOEP FO GPSNB JOJOUFSSVNQJEB DPO
GFSFODJBTDJFOUÓmDBTNFOTVBMFTFMQSJNFS
MVOFTEFDBEBNFT&OVODPNJFO[PTF
MMFWBSPO B DBCP FO FM BVEJUØSJVN EF MB
$MÓOJDB 4BOUB *TBCFM Z EFTEF FO
#JPÏUJDBFO1FSÞ3PCFSUP-MBOPT;VMPBHB
FMEFMB$MÓOJDB3JDBSEP1BMNBZEFMPT
-BCPSBUPSJPT(MBYP5FDOPGBSNBZ'BS
NJOEVTUSJB-BTDPOGFSFODJBTJOUFSOBDJP
OBMFTGVFSPOEJDUBEBTQPSMPTQSPGFTPSFT
+PBRVÓO $MPUFU #SBTJM
3VUI .BDLMJO
&&66
.BIBM %BDPTUB 'FSOBOEP
-PMBTZ3PCFSUP.BODJOJ$IJMF
%BG
OB'FJOIPM[.ÏYJDP
Z&EVBSEP4PV[B
-FOOPY1BOBNÈ
-PTUFNBTUSBUBEPTIBOTJEPMPTTJHVJFO
UFT5ÏDOJDBTSFQSPEVDUJWBTFOJOHFOJFSÓB
HFOÏUJDB%FSFDIPTEFMQBDJFOUF#JPÏUJDB
ZNPSJS5SBTQMBOUFEFØSHBOPT#JPÏUJDB
EFJOWBMJEF[4JHMP99*ZCJPÏUJDB"OUJ
DPODFQDJØO'BSNBDPEFQFOEFODJBZESP
HBTQMBDFOUFSBT'VOEBNFOUPTEFMBCJP
ÏUJDB#JPÏUJDBWJPMFODJBQTJDPTJTZTBMVE
NFOUBM &DPMPHÓB 'JMPTPGÓB Z CJPÏUJDB
7JEB )VNBOB Z CJPÏUJDB 1TJDPUFSBQJB
"VUPOPNÓB DPOTFOUJNJFOUP JOGPSNBEP
ZCJPÏUJDB"CPSUP%JBHOØTUJDPQTJRVJÈ
USJDP%BOUF-B%JWJOB$PNFEJB#JP
ÏUJDBFOFMQBDJFOUFQTJRVJÈUSJDPJOTUJUV
DJPOBMJ[BEP "VUPQTJB NÏEJDB 5FSDFSB
FEBE *OWFTUJHBDJØO FO TFSFT IVNBOPT
4JEB²UJDBNÏEJDBZDzBOBUPT%JÈMPHPT
EFMDVFSQPZCJPÏUJDB)POPSJP%FMHBEP
ZMBIJTUPSJBEFMBCJPÏUJDB3FQSPEVDDJØO
BTJTUJEB)VNBOJTNPWJUBMTVCWFSTJØOZ
EFTBSSPMMP7JPMBDJØOZCJPÏUJDB1VFCMPT
BNB[ØOJDPT 4FDSFUP QSPGFTJPOBM /BDFS
DPO EJHOJEBE 1SPZFDUP HFOPNB 4BMVE
NFOUBMJOGBOUJM
&M 5FSDFS &ODVFOUSP -BUJOPBNFSJDBOP
EF#JPÏUJDBUVWPMVHBSFO-JNBFOUSFFM
ZFMEFTFQUJFNCSFEFFOFM
DVBMTFUSBUBSPOMPTUFNBT#JPÏUJDB.Ï
EJDB Z 1TJDPMPHÓB 'FDVOEBDJØO "CPS
PERSPETIVADELABIOETICAINDD
UP3FUBSEP.FOUBM5SBTQMBOUFEF»S
HBOPT&VUBOBTJB*OHFOJFSÓB(FOÏUJDBZ
.PSJSDPOEJHOJEBE4FMMFWØBDBCPFO
FMDBNQVTEFMB6OJWFSTJEBEEFM4BHSB
EP$PSB[ØOZMB"TPDJBDJØO1FSVBOBEF
#JPÏUJDBDPOUØDPOFMBQPZPEFMB"TP
DJBDJØO .ÏEJDB 1FSVBOP"MFNBOB MB
6OJWFSTJEBE EFM 4BHSBEP $PSB[ØO Z FM
$PMFHJP.ÏEJDPEFM1FSÞ'VFSPOJOWJ
UBEPTQPS"SHFOUJOB3FZOBEF,MPUJL
$FMJB #PSEJN .BSUB 'SBDBQBOJ -JMJB
OB (JBOODBSJOJ +VBO $BSMPT 5FBMEJ Z
"MCFSUP #PDIBUFZ QPS #SBTJM "MGPOTP
3FOBUP.FZSB+'SBODJTDPOJZ+PBRVÓO
$MPUFU QPS $PMPNCJB "MGPOTP -MBOP
$ÏTBS4ÈODIF[.BSÓB.BSDIBOE.B
SÓB .FSDFEFT )BDLFTQJFHFM 3JDBSEP
$FMZZ)4FNJOBSJP3FQSFTFOUBSPOB
.ÏYJDP+PSHF)FSOÈOEF[Z-VJT%ÓB[
-B "TPDJBDJØO 1FSVBOB EF #JPÏUJDB IB
FTUBCMFDJEP SFMBDJPOFT DPO EJWFSTBT FO
UJEBEFTGPSÈOFBT%FFTUBGPSNBSFDJCF
QVCMJDBDJPOFT QFSJØEJDBT UBMFT DPNP
.FEJDJOB Z ²UJDB EF MB 6OJWFSTJEBE EF
"OBIVBD FEJUBEB DPOKVOUBNFOUF DPO
MB 6OJWFSTJEBE EFM 4BHSBEP $PSB[ØO
EF3PNB#JPÏUJDBEFMB6OJWFSTJEBEEF
3ÓP(SBOEFEP4VM#SBTJM#JPÏUJDBEFM
$POTFKP'FEFSBMEF.FEJDJOBEF#SBTJ
MJB#SBTJMZ"DUB#JPFUIJDBEFM1SPHSBNB
EF#JPÏUJDBEF0140.4
-B$PNJTJØOEF#JPÏUJDBEFM4FOBEPEF
&TUBEPT6OJEPTSFDJCFJOGPSNBDJØOQF
SJØEJDBEFOVFTUSBTBDUJWJEBEFTZFM1SP
HSBNBEF#JPÏUJDBEFMB0144BOUJBHP
EF$IJMF
FOWÓBTVTQVCMJDBDJPOFTQFSJØ
EJDBT*HVBMNFOUFMB6OJWFSTJEBEEF1B
EVBFO*UBMJBZEF1BSÓTFO'SBODJB
1FSTQFDUJWBTEFMB#JPÏUJDBFO*CFSPBNÏSJDB
"TQFDUPTMFHBMFT
4POOVNFSPTBTMBTMFZFTBQSPCBEBTFOMB
ÞMUJNBEÏDBEBDPOSFMBDJØOBMBCJPÏUJDB
FO1FSÞ1PSFKFNQMPMBQSPQVFTUBEF
MFHJTMBDJØOJOEÓHFOBMBUJOPBNFSJDBOBEF
DPOTVMUBDPMFDUJWBQBSBFTUVEJPTHFOÏUJ
DPTTFTF×BMØFMEFSFDIPEFMPTQVFCMPT
JOEÓHFOBT B QSPUFHFS Z EJTGSVUBS EF TV
QBUSJNPOJP DVMUVSBM CBTÈOEPTF FO MB
%FDMBSBDJØO 6OJWFSTBM EF %FSFDIPT
)VNBOPT MPT 1BDUPT *OUFSOBDJPOBMFT
EF %FSFDIPT &DPOØNJDPT 4PDJBMFT Z
$VMUVSBMFTZEF%FSFDIPT$JWJMFTZ1P
MÓUJDPTZFM$POWFOJP/¡EFMB0S
HBOJ[BDJØO*OUFSOBDJPOBMEFM5SBCBKP
-B-FZ/¡EFKVMJPEF
FTUBCMFDF VO SÏHJNFO EF QSPUFDDJØO EF
MPTDPOPDJNJFOUPTDPMFDUJWPTEFMPTQVF
CMPTJOEÓHFOBTWJODVMBEPTBMPTSFDVSTPT
CJPMØHJDPT -PT JOUFSFTBEPT FO BDDFEFS
B MPT DPOPDJNJFOUPT DPMFDUJWPT DPO m
OFTEFBQMJDBDJØODJFOUÓmDBDPNFSDJBMF
JOEVTUSJBMEFCFSÈOTPMJDJUBSFMDPOTFOUJ
NJFOUPJOGPSNBEPEFMBTPSHBOJ[BDJPOFT
SFQSFTFOUBUJWBTEFMPTQVFCMPTZDPNV
OJEBEFT JOEÓHFOBT RVF MP QPTFBO -B
JOGPSNBDJØO RVF TF QSPQPSDJPOF TF MJ
NJUBSÈBMSFDVSTPCJPMØHJDPTPCSFFMDVBM
WFSTB FM DPOPDJNJFOUP DPMFDUJWP PCKFUP
EFMBOFHPDJBDJØOFOTBMWBHVBSEBEFMB
DPOUSBQBSUF
-PTDPNJUÏTEFÏUJDBEFMB
JOWFTUJHBDJØOFOTBMVEFO1FSÞ
%FTEFIBRVFEBEPDPOTUJUVJEBMB
$PNJTJØO /BDJPOBM EF ²UJDB FO *OWFT
UJHBDJØO 4V DPNQPTJDJØO FT NÞMUJQMF
ZUSBOTEJTDJQMJOBSJB&MNBOEBUPEFTVT
PERSPETIVADELABIOETICAINDD
NJFNCSPTFTEFEPTB×PTZFMOÞNFSPEF
ÏTUPTFTEFWFJOUF4VTBUSJCVDJPOFTTPO
FTUJNVMBSMBDSFBDJØOEFDPNJUÏTEFÏUJDB
FOJOWFTUJHBDJØOZSFHJTUSBSBMPTDPNJUÏT
JOTUJUVDJPOBMFT
-BTDJODVFOUBQFSTPOBTRVFTFEFEJDBO
B MB CJPÏUJDB FO 1FSÞ TF IBO SFQBSUJEP
TV BDDJØO FO DJODP HSVQPT EF USBCBKP
BDDJØO QPMÓUJDB FODBSHBEB BM $PMFHJP
.ÏEJDPEFM1FSÞGPSNBDJØOFOSFDVS
TPT IVNBOPT BDBEÏNJDPT
FODBSHBEB
B "MCFSUP 1FSBMFT QSFTUBDJØO EF TFSWJ
DJPT EF TBMVE FODBSHBEB B $ÏTBS 3J
WFSB JOWFTUJHBDJØO TF IB EJWJEJEP FO
CJPÏUJDBFOJOWFTUJHBDJØOoFODBSHBEBB
$ÏTBS.PMFSPoFJOWFTUJHBDJØOFOCJPÏ
UJDBoFODBSHBEBB3PCFSUP-MBOPToDP
NVOJDBDJØOCJPÏUJDBFODBSHBEBB&MTB
#FOBWFOUF
-BT JOTUJUVDJPOFT RVF TF IBO DPNQSP
NFUJEP B USBCBKBS DPOKVOUBNFOUF QPS
MBÏUJDBFOJOWFTUJHBDJØOFO1FSÞTPOMBT
VOJWFSTJEBEFT/BDJPOBMEF4BO.BSDPT
*OHFOJFSÓB$BZFUBOP)FSFEJB4BHSBEP
$PSB[ØO $BUØMJDB Z 3JDBSEP 1BMNB
-VFHP FM $PMFHJP .ÏEJDP EF 1FSÞ MB
0SEFO EF 4BO $BNJMP MB 0/( 4BO
$ISJTUPQIPSVT MB "TPDJBDJØO 1FSVBOB
EF#JPÏUJDBMPTIPTQJUBMFT&EHBSEP3F
CBHMJBUJ (VJMMFSNP "MNFOBSB %PT EF
.BZP Z "S[PCJTQP -PBZ[B FM $FOUSP
1FSVBOP EF #JPÏUJDB MPT -BCPSBUPSJPT
.FSDL 4IBSQ BOE %PINF Z MBT 0/(T
1SJTNBZ²UJDBQPSMB7JEB
*OUFHSBOUFTEFM(SVQP1FSVBOPEF²UJDB
FO *OWFTUJHBDJØO TPO MPT EPDUPSFT 3P
CFSUP-MBOPT3BGBFM"SDF1FESP3VJ[
'SBODJTDP3JWFSB#FSUB3FZFT$BSNFO
#JPÏUJDBFO1FSÞ3PCFSUP-MBOPT;VMPBHB
#SBWP (VTUBWP "SBVKP 3PCFSUP &TQJ
OP[B.BOVFM1B[Z"MPJT,FOOFSOFDIU
%FTEFFYJTUFFO1FSÞMB$PNJTJØO
/BDJPOBM EF #JPÏUJDB )BTUB FTB GFDIB
FYJTUÓBO OVFWF DPNJUÏT BTJTUFODJBMFT EF
ÏUJDB &O FSBO Z BDUVBMNFOUF
TPO&OIBCÓBTFJTDPNJUÏTEF
ÏUJDBEFJOWFTUJHBDJØOFOTBMVEFO
FSBOoB×PFORVFTFDSFBFM$BQÓUVMP
1FSVBOP EFM 'PSP -BUJOPBNFSJDBOP EF
$PNJUÏT EF ²UJDB EF *OWFTUJHBDJØO FO
4BMVE'-"$&*4
&O1FSÞFYJTUFOFO
DPOTFDVFODJBWFJOUJUSÏTDPNJUÏTEFÏUJDB
EFMBJOWFTUJHBDJØO
B
$PNJUÏ EF ²UJDB EF *OWFTUJHBDJØO
EFM )PTQJUBM &EHBSEP 3FCBHMJBUUJ
.BSUJOT &TUF IPTQJUBM QFSUFOFDF
B MB SFE IPTQJUBMBSJB EF MB TFHVSJ
EBE TPDJBM &44"-6%
&O DPOUBCB DPO QSPZFDUPT EF JO
WFTUJHBDJØO&M$PNJUÏEF²UJDBFO
*OWFTUJHBDJØO TF JOTUBMØ FO BHPTUP
EF Z FTUÈ GPSNBEP QPS PODF
NJFNCSPTDJODPEFMPTDVBMFTTPO
NÏEJDPT EPT FOGFSNFSBT VO BCP
HBEP VO TBDFSEPUF VO BTJTUFOUF
TPDJBMZVOSFQSFTFOUBOUFEFMBDP
NVOJEBE )B SFWJTBEP QSPUPDPMPT
EFPUSBTJOTUJUVDJPOFTFOFMEF
TVTTFTJPOFT
C
*OTUJUVUP /BDJPOBM EF 4BMVE 4F
JOTUBMØFOGFCSFSPEFZTFSF
FTUSVDUVSØFOKVOJPEFM&TUÈ
GPSNBEPQPSJOUFHSBOUFTIBSF
WJTBEPQSPUPDPMPTZTFIBOBQSP
CBEP4FIBBEFDVBEPBM3FHJT
USP*OUFSOBDJPOBMZFEJUBMB3FWJTUB
1FSVBOBEF.FEJDJOB&YQFSJNFOUBM
PERSPETIVADELABIOETICAINDD
Z4BMVE1ÞCMJDB4VJOGPSNBDJØOTF
FODVFOUSBFO-*-"$4Z.&
%-*/&
D
$FOUSP 1FSVBOP EF #JPÏUJDB $&
1&#*0
4VDPNJUÏEFÏUJDBTFJOT
UBMØ FM EF KVMJP EF Z FTUÈ
GPSNBEP QPS DJODP QFSTPOBT )B
DPMBCPSBEP FO MPT USFT DPOHSFTPT
PSHBOJ[BEPTQPS$&1&#*0oFOUSF
Z o F JHVBMNFOUF FO
FM UBMMFS QBSB GPSNBDJØO EF WPMVO
UBSJPTEJDUBEPBQFSTPOBTMBJDBT
ZBTBDFSEPUFT)BEJDUBEPDVB
USPDVSTPTEFÏUJDBFOJOWFTUJHBDJØO
oFOUSFZoZVODVSTPEF
GVOEBNFOUPTEFCJPÏUJDBDPOBTJT
UFODJBEFUSFJOUBQBSUJDJQBOUFT
E
0mDJOB(FOFSBMEF&QJEFNJPMPHÓB
0(&3&/"$&
4V DPNJUÏ FTUÈ
DPOGPSNBEP QPS DVBUSP QFSTPOBT
)BTUB IBCÓB SFWJTBEP QSPZFDUPT mOBODJBEPT )B SFBMJ[B
EPBDUJWJEBEFTEFMBTDVBMFTFM
TFEFEJDBSPOBJOWFTUJHBDJØO
F
0/( 1SJTNB 'VOEBEB FO JOTUBMB TV DPNJUÏ EF ÏUJDB FO JO
WFTUJHBDJØOFO4VFTUSVDUVSB
BDUVBMTFEFEJDBBMFTUVEJPQSJWBEP
EFQSPUPDPMPTEFJOWFTUJHBDJØOBTF
TPSÓBZNPOJUPSFP
&M*OTUJUVUPEF4BMVE$SJTUØGPSJT
%FOFLF*4%&/
QPSMBTFOEB
EFMBCJPÏUJDB
-BSFMJHJPTB.BSÓB7BOEFS-JOEFEJSFD
UPSBEF*4%&/EFTEFTVGVOEBDJØOFO
TF×BMBi-BJORVJFUVEQPSMBIV
NBOJ[BDJØOFOTBMVEMBÏUJDBMBCJPÏUJDB
BOUFMBSFBMJEBETBOJUBSJBEFMQBÓTFTUBCB
1FSTQFDUJWBTEFMB#JPÏUJDBFO*CFSPBNÏSJDB
QSFTFOUFFOOPTPUSPTEFTEFBOUFTEFRVF
FM *4%&/ TF DPOTUJUVZFSB 5SBCBKÈCB
NPTFOUPODFTFOMB1BTUPSBMEFMB4BMVE
EF MB $POGFSFODJB &QJTDPQBM 1FSVBOB
%FTEFBMMÓZEFTEFMBQSFPDVQBDJØOQPS
MPTFOGFSNPTEFUVCFSDVMPTJTFOMPTB×PT
BEFTBSSPMMBNPTPDIPUBMMFSFTGPS
NBUJWPTWJWFODJBMFTDPOFMQFSTPOBMEF
TBMVE EFM 1SPHSBNB EF $POUSPM EF 5#
EF MBT 6OJEBEFT 5FSSJUPSJBMFT EF 4BMVE
EF$PNBTZEFM)PTQJUBM4FSHJP&#FS
OBMFT BCBSDBOEP BMSFEFEPS EF FTUB
CMFDJNJFOUPT EF TBMVE Z DJODP EJTUSJUPT
EF-JNB/PSUFZ$BOUBEFM.*/4"DPO
FM UFNB EF i7BMPSFT FO FM QFSmM EF MB
BUFODJØOJOUFHSBMEF5VCFSDVMPTJTw
ZOPQPESÓBTFSEFPUSBNBOFSB&TUPOPT
BOJNØ B PSHBOJ[BS VO FODVFOUSP FO FM
RVFNÈTQSPGFTJPOBMFTEFMBTBMVEZEF
PUSPTDBNQPTQVEJFSBOOVUSJSTFEFFTUBT
SFnFYJPOFTQVFTIBCÓBNVZQPDBEJGV
TJØOZEFCBUFEFFTUPTUFNBTFOFMQBÓT
QPSFOUPODFT
&OGFCSFSPEFFOFMBVEJUPSJPEFMB
$MÓOJDB4UFMMB.BSJTSFBMJ[BNPTVOQSJ
NFSGPSPTPCSFi"TQFDUPT*OUSPEVDUPSJPT
EF#JPÏUJDBwDPOMBQBSUJDJQBDJØOEF-FP
1FTTJOJFM1-VEPMGP0KFEBEF1FSÞZ
QFSTPOBMEFTBMVEZEFPUSBTEJTDJQMJOBT
BmOFTQSPWFOJFOUFTEF-JNBZ$BMMBP
&ODPOPDBTJØOEFMBWJTJUBB1FSÞ
EF 1BPMP .PDBSFMMJ CJPFUJDJTUB JUBMJBOP
JOWJUBEP QPS FM QSPZFDUP i&EVDBDJØO
Z DVMUVSB EF QB[w RVF EFTBSSPMMBCB MB
1POUJmDJB 6OJWFSTJEBE $BUØMJDB EFM
1FSÞ TF PSHBOJ[Ø FO FM BVEJUPSJP EF MB
.VOJDJQBMJEBEEF+FTÞT.BSÓBFODPPS
EJOBDJØODPOMB"TPDJBDJØOEF.ÏEJDPT
$BUØMJDPTVOBDPOGFSFODJBGØSVNUJUVMB
EBi²UJDBEFMB7JEBw-BQSFTFOUBDJØO
EFMEPDUPS.PDBSFMMJBCSJØMBQFSTQFDUJ
WBIBDJBMBCJPÏUJDB)VCPTJOUPOÓBDPO
MBTJEFBTQSFTFOUBEBTFOTVJOUFSWFODJØO
RVFOPTØMPUPDBCBMPÏUJDPFOSFMBDJØO
DPOMBUFDOPMPHÓBZFMIPTQJUBMTJOPUBN
CJÏOMPDPNVOJUBSJPZTPDJBM
&OUSFZMMFWBNPTBDBCPMPT
UBMMFSFT TPCSF i7BMPSFT FO FM QFSmM EFM
USBCBKBEPS EF TBMVE QBSB VOB BUFODJØO
EFDBMJEBEwFOWBSJPTMVHBSFTEF-JNBZ
QSPWJODJBT QPS NFEJP EF VO DPOWFOJP
DPO FM 4FHVSP 4PDJBM EF 4BMVE EF 1FSÞ
IPZ MMBNBEP &44"-6%
Z IBDJÏOEP
MP FYUFOTJWP B QFSTPOBM EFM .JOJTUFSJP
EF4BMVEFOPUSBTDJVEBEFT&ONÈTEF
UBMMFSFTMPHSBNPTJOWPMVDSBSB
QFSTPOBT HSVQPT NVMUJEJTDJQMJOBSJPT
QSPGFTJPOBMFT UÏDOJDPT Z FO PDBTJPOFT
QFSTPOBM BENJOJTUSBUJWP UPEPT FO VO
NJTNPFTQBDJPEFSFnFYJØO1PSMBTFWB
MVBDJPOFT DPOTUBUBNPT RVF MPT QBSUJDJ
QBOUFTWBMPSBCBONVDIPMBPQPSUVOJEBE
EFNJSBSTVUSBCBKPFOVOBQFSTQFDUJWB
IVNBOJTUB
&O FO 2VJUP &DVBEPS DPOPDJ
NPTB-FP1FTTJOJEF#SBTJMRVFZBUSB
CBKBCBFMUFNBCJPÏUJDPFOVOBQFSTQFD
UJWBMBUJOPBNFSJDBOBFOMBDVBMMPTUFNBT
TPDJBMFTZEFTBMVEQÞCMJDBTPOPCMJHBEPT
%FTEFZBDPOMBSB[ØOTPDJBMEFM
*OTUJUVUP TF EFDJEJØ USBCBKBS FO MB GPS
NBDJØOFOÏUJDBZCJPÏUJDBEFTEFFMi«SFB
EF)VNBOJ[BDJØOFO4BMVEw
PERSPETIVADELABIOETICAINDD
#JPÏUJDBFO1FSÞ3PCFSUP-MBOPT;VMPBHB
$PODMVTJPOFT
-B CJPÏUJDB FO 1FSÞ IB FYQFSJNFOUBEP
HSBOEFTBWBODFT4FIBODSFBEPEJWFSTBT
JOTUJUVDJPOFT RVF USBCBKBO JOUFOTBNFO
UFTFDVFOUBDPOVOHSVQPIVNBOPEF
QPS MP NFOPT DJODVFOUB QFSTPOBT DPO
MJEFSB[HPCJPÏUJDPEFFMMPTQPSMPNF
OPTMBNJUBEUJFOFOFMNÏSJUPEFIBCFS
DVSTBEP MB NBFTUSÓB FO CJPÏUJDB ZB TFB
FO1FSÞ4VEBNÏSJDBP&VSPQB/PPCT
UBOUFFYJTUFOBMHVOPTSFUPT
t
t
t
&OFMBTQFDUPTPDJBMTPDJBMTFFTQFSB
RVFMPTHSVQPTEFQPCMBDJØOQBSUJDJ
QFOZQSPQVHOFOEJTDVTJPOFTTPCSF
UFNBT DPNP EPOBDJØO EF ØSHBOPT
QBSBUSBTQMBOUFTBCPSUPFVUBOBTJB
NFEJPBNCJFOUFGFDVOEBDJØOBTJT
UJEBUSBOTHÏOJDPTFOUSFPUSPT
&O MP BDBEÏNJDP TF FTQFSB VOB
NBZPSSFTQVFTUBVOJWFSTJUBSJBZEF
FOUJEBEFT EF FOTF×BO[B DPNP MB
6OJWFSTJEBE EF 4BO .BSDPT Z MB
1BTUPSBMEF4BMVEEFMPT)FSNBOPT
EF4BO$BNJMP
3FTQFDUP EF MP DJFOUÓmDP DPOTUJ
UVJEPT MPT DPNJUÏT EF ÏUJDB EF
JOWFTUJHBDJØO Z FM DBQÓUVMP QFSVB
OP EFM 'PSP -BUJOPBNFSJDBOP EF
$PNJUÏT EF ²UJDB EF MB *OWFTUJ
t
t
t
HBDJØO GPSNBEP IBTUB BIPSB QPS
JOUFHSBOUFT TF IB JOJDJBEP VOB
HSBO MBCPS DPO MB PSHBOJ[BDJØO EF
TFNJOBSJPT FOTF×BO[B FTUVEJP Z
BQSPCBDJØO EF QSPUPDPMPT NPOJ
UPSFPEFJOWFTUJHBDJPOFTZMBCPSEF
DPOTFKFSÓBZBTFTPSÓB
4F IB JOHSFTBEP MFOUBNFOUF B MPT
NFEJPT EF DPNVOJDBDJØO DPO FM
MFOHVBKF CJPÏUJDP :B QFSJØEJDPT
SBEJPT Z DBOBMFT EF UFMFWJTJØO TP
MJDJUBO FOUSFWJTUBT DPNFOUBSJPT P
BSUÓDVMPTRVFQFSUFOFDFOBFTUFMFO
HVBKFZRVFTFSÈVTBEPQSPHSFTJWB
NFOUFQPSMBDPNVOJEBE
3FTQFDUPEFMJOWPMVDSBNJFOUPEFMB
TPDJFEBE DJWJM IBTUB IPZ TF FTQFSB
RVFMB$PNJTJØO/BDJPOBMEF#JP
ÏUJDB DPNQSPNFUB B MBT JOTUJUVDJP
OFTEJSFDUBNFOUFPJOEJSFDUBNFOUF
JOWPMVDSBEBTDPOMBWJEBZPCUFOHB
EFFMMBTFMSFDPOPDJNJFOUPEFMBJN
QPSUBODJBEFMBCJPÏUJDB
4PCSF MB NPUJWBDJØO DPNVOJUBSJB
TFIBMPHSBEPJOGPSNBSBMPTHSVQPT
DJWJMFTEFBVUPBZVEB&OMBNFEJEB
FO RVF MPT MÓEFSFT SFDJCBO JOGPS
NBDJØO BDBEÏNJDB TF HBSBOUJ[B MB
QPTJCJMJEBE EF JOJDJBS Z NBOUFOFS
DPNVOJDBDJØOEFCVFOBDBMJEBE
3FGFSFODJBT
"MDBMÈ;BNPSB+FUBM
0CUFODJØOEFMDPOTFOUJNJFOUPJOGPSNBEP$*
FONFEJDJOB
JOUFOTJWB#VFOPT"JSFT"OBMFT
#VOHF . .FEJDJOB Z 'JMPTPGÓB &M $PNFSDJP 4FDDJØO %PNJOJDBM EF
TFQUJFNCSF-JNBQ
$FMZ(
#JPÏUJDBZ6OJWFSTJEBE#PHPUÈ$FOUSP&EJUPSJBM+BWFSJBOPQQ
$&1 $FOUSP EF &TUVEJPT Z 1VCMJDBDJPOFT
-B 7JEB 7BMF #JPÏUJDB OVFWPT
DBNJOPT-JNB6OJWFSTJEBEEFM1BDÓGJDP
PERSPETIVADELABIOETICAINDD
1FSTQFDUJWBTEFMB#JPÏUJDBFO*CFSPBNÏSJDB
$MPUFU+
{2VÏUJQPEFDPOTFOUJNJFOUPJOGPSNBEPQVFEFTFSVTBEPQBSBMBTQFSTPOBT
EFMPTQBÓTFTFOWÓBTEFEFTBSSPMMP #VFOPT"JSFT"OBMFT
%FMHBEP)
&MNÏEJDPMBNFEJDJOBZFMBMNB-JNB61$)
%JBT.
#JPÏUJDBVNBOPWBWJTÍPJOUFSEJTDJQMJOBS#SBTÓMJB+PSOBMEP$'.
'JOT+
&YQFSJFODJBOPSUFBNFSJDBOBEFMBFOTF×BO[BEFMB#JPÏUJDB$VBEFSOPTEF
#JPÏUJDBQQ
(FWFST4
1IZTJDJBOBTTJTUFETVJDJEFOFXEFWFMPQNFOUTJOUIF/FUIFSMBOET*O
"OBMFTEFM**$POHSFTP*OUFSOBDJPOBMEF#JPÏUJDB#VFOPT"JSFTQ
(SBDJB%
1SJODJQJPTEFMB#JPÏUJDB"OBMFTEFM**$POHSFTP.VOEJBMEF#JPÏUJDB
#VFOPT"JSFTQQ
(SPT)
3FQPSUPGUIF-FHBM$PNNJTTJPOPGUIF*#$*O*OUFSOBUJPOBM#JPFUIJDT
$PNNJUUFFPG6OFTDP1BSJT6OFTDP7PM*Q
-FØO#BSÞB3
#BTFTCJPMØHJDBTEFMBÏUJDB%JBHOØTUJDP
TFQUJFNCSFPDUV
CSFQQ
-MBOP"
&M.PSJSIVNBOPIBDBNCJBEP#PMFUÓOEFMB0GJDJOB4BOJUBSJB1BOB
NFSJDBOB
NBZPKVOJPQQ
-MBOPT3
#JPÏUJDBFOFM1FSÞ#PMFUÓOEFMB0GJDJOB4BOJUBSJB1BOBNFSJDBOB
NBZPKVOJPQQ
.JSØ 2VFTBEB 0 #JPÏUJDB NPNFOUP EF EFGJOJDJPOFT &M $PNFSDJP EF
OPWJFNCSFEFQ
/PWPB ' $POTJEFSBDJPOFT ÏUJDBT FO QBDJFOUFT DPO EB×P DFSFCSBM .ÏYJDP &E
*OUFSBNFSJDBOB
1FSBMFT"3JWFSB'8V%
$JWJMJ[BDJØOZ.FEJDJOB-JNB6/.4.
QQ
4BSUPSJVT/
5IF.FOUBM)FBMUI1SPHSBNNFPGUIF8PSME)FBMUI0SHBOJ[BUJPO
*O"OBMFTEF4BMVE.FOUBM7PM-JNB6/.4.
PERSPETIVADELABIOETICAINDD
#JPÏUJDBFO1PSUVHBM
+PSHF#JTDBJBZ8BMUFS0TTXBME
4
J DPOTJEFSBNPT MBT GBTFT UFNQSBOBT
EFM EFTBSSPMMP EF MB CJPÏUJDB DPNP
OVFWB ÈSFB EF MB DJFODJB Z EF MB NPSBM
FO BDFMFSBEP DSFDJNJFOUP MB DVBM JO
EFQFOEJFOUFNFOUFEFTVTTFNJMMBTOPS
UFBNFSJDBOBT IB NPTUSBEP VOB NBSDB
EB UFOEFODJB B EJGVOEJSTF FO EJWFSTPT
DPOUJOFOUFT EFCFNPT JOEJDBS RVF TVT
DPNJFO[PTFO1PSUVHBMIBOTJEPSFMBUJ
WBNFOUFUBSEÓPT&OFGFDUPFMQSJNFSP
HSVQP EF FTUVEJP PSHBOJ[BEP Z FTUSVD
UVSBEPRVFTFEFEJDØBDVFTUJPOFTCJP
ÏUJDBT GVF FTUBCMFDJEP FO $PJNCSB FO
DPNPVOBPSHBOJ[BDJØOOPMVDSB
UJWBJOEFQFOEJFOUF$FOUSPEF&TUVEJPT
EF #JPÏUJDB
EFTQVÏT EF RVF FM HSVQP
GVOEBEPS TF SFVOJFSB JOGPSNBMNFOUF
EVSBOUF EPT B×PT %FTEF FOUPODFT TJO
FNCBSHPIVCPVOBFWPMVDJØOOPUBCMF
VOBSÈQJEBEJTFNJOBDJØODPOVOOÞNF
SP SFMBUJWBNFOUF HSBOEF EF HSBEVBEPT
RVFTFBMJTUBOFOFTUVEJPTEFQPTHSBEP
/VFTUSBNFUBOPFTQSFTFOUBSVOBQFST
QFDUJWBIJTUØSJDBPVOBSFWJTJØOFYIBVT
UJWB EF MB USBZFDUPSJB EF MB CJPÏUJDB FO
1PSUVHBM TJOP SFBMJ[BS VOB BQSPYJNB
DJØOBUFNBTRVFIBOTJEPZTJHVFOTJFO
EPQSPNJOFOUFTFOMBEJTDVTJØOCJPÏUJDB
BMHVOPTEFFMMPTBUSBZFOEPFMJOUFSÏTEF
PERSPETIVADELABIOETICAINDD
HSBOEFT TFDUPSFT EF MB QPCMBDJØO 1BSB
FTUP UFOFNPT RVF EFTDSJCJS MBT JOTUJUV
DJPOFTFOEPOEFTFEJTDVUFTFFOTF×BP
TFJOWFTUJHBMBCJPÏUJDBZTVTNVDIBTBD
UJWJEBEFT $PNP SFTVMUBEP MB DPODJFO
DJBQÞCMJDBEFMPTQSPCMFNBTCJPÏUJDPTFT
NVDIPNÈTBNQMJBZMBTPQJOJPOFTEFM
DJVEBEBOP FO FTUBT NBUFSJBT FTUÈO FO
QSPDFTPEFUFOFSDPOTFDVFODJBTQPMÓUJDBT
Z MFHBMFT EF TVQSFNB JNQPSUBODJB &O
FTUBDPOUSJCVDJØOOPTDFOUSBSFNPTQSJO
DJQBMNFOUFFOMBTJUVBDJØOEFMBEÏDBEB
QBTBEB QVFTUP RVF MBT JOGPSNBDJPOFT
SFGFSFOUFT B B×PT BOUFSJPSFT TF QVFEFO
FODPOUSBSFOUFYUPTQBOPSÈNJDPTZBQV
CMJDBEPT/VOF[Z"CFM#JTDBJBZ
0TTXBME
*OTUJUVDJPOFT
-PTGPSPTQSJODJQBMFTEFEJTDVTJØOCJPÏ
UJDBFTUÈOFOJOTUJUVDJPOFTBDBEÏNJDBTZ
FOTPDJFEBEFTRVFSFÞOFOHFOUFJOUFSFTB
EB$VSJPTBNFOUFMBVOJWFSTJEBEDPNP
VOUPEPIBSFDPOPDJEPTØMPMFOUBNFOUF
MBOFDFTJEBEEFDSFBSJOTUJUVDJPOFTCJP
ÏUJDBTFOTVQSPQJBFTUSVDUVSB-BQSJO
DJQBMZQSJNFSBJOTUJUVDJØOSFTQPOTBCMF
EFTVBDFQUBDJØOZEJGVTJØOFO1PSUVHBM
GVF DPNP EJKJNPT FM $&# VOB PSHB
1FSTQFDUJWBTEFMB#JPÏUJDBFO*CFSPBNÏSJDB
OJ[BDJØOJOEFQFOEJFOUFOPDPOGFTJPOBM
OPMVDSBUJWBDPOVOMBSHPDVSSÓDVMPEF
BDUJWJEBEFTWÏBTFNÈTBEFMBOUF
&M $POTFKP /BDJPOBM EF ²UJDB FO MBT
$JFODJBT EF MB 7JEB $/&$7
FT VO
ØSHBOP DPOTVMUJWP QBSB FM HPCJFSOP FO
UPEBT MBT DVFTUJPOFT CJPÏUJDBT FM 1BSMB
NFOUP/BDJPOBMMB"TTFNCMÏJBEB3FQÞ
CMJDB
Z FM QSFTJEFOUF 'VF GVOEBEP FO
ZNVDIPTEFTVTNJFNCSPTJODMV
TP USFT QSFTJEFOUFT
TF SFDMVUBSPO FOUSF
MPT NJFNCSPT EFM $&# &M $/&$7
IBQSPEVDJEPIBTUBBIPSBQBSFDFSFT
TPCSF VOB WBSJFEBE EF UFNBT EFTEF MB
SFQSPEVDDJØONÏEJDBNFOUFBTJTUJEBPFM
VTPEFFNCSJPOFTFOFYQFSJNFOUPTDJFO
UÓmDPT IBTUB MB QSVFCB PCMJHBUPSJB EF
)*7"*%4EFTEFMBHFSFODJBEFEBUPT
HFOÏUJDPT IBTUB MBT DVFTUJPOFT EFM mOBM
EF MB WJEB EFTEF MB QPMÓUJDB SFMBUJWB BM
BCVTPEFESPHBTIBTUBMPTDSJUFSJPTEFMB
NVFSUFZUSBTQMBOUFT
&TVOØSHBOPBMUBNFOUFSFTQFUBEPZIB
FKFSDJEPJOnVFODJBBQSFDJBCMFFOMBTMF
ZFTBQSPCBEBTQPSFMQBSMBNFOUP&MQSJ
NFSNJOJTUSPOPNJOBBMQSFTJEFOUFMPT
PUSPTNJFNCSPTTPOOPNJOBEPTQPS
FOUJEBEFT EJTUJOUBT FM 1BSMBNFOUP
MPTNJOJTUFSJPTZBTPDJBDJPOFTEFBCPHB
EPTNÏEJDPTCJØMPHPTMB"DBEFNJBEF
$JFODJBPSHBOJ[BDJPOFTEFDJVEBEBOPT
FOUSFPUSPT
&M $FOUSP EF %FSFDIP #JPNÏEJDP
$%#
JOTUJUVUPEFJOWFTUJHBDJØOEFMB
'BDVMUBEEF%FSFDIPEFMB6OJWFSTJEBE
EF$PJNCSBUJFOFVOBQSFTFODJBSFMBUJ
WBNFOUFFYUFOTBZEFTEFIBDPO
USJCVJEP B SFTPMWFS DVFTUJPOFT DPNP FM
PERSPETIVADELABIOETICAINDD
DPOnJDUPEFJOUFSFTFTMPTDØEJHPTEFMBT
QSPGFTJPOFT NÏEJDBT Z GBSNBDÏVUJDBT
Z MPT BTQFDUPT MFHBMFT RVF HPCJFSOBO FM
FKFSDJDJPEFFTUBTQSPGFTJPOFT
-BTFTDVFMBTEF.FEJDJOBTJUVBEBTFOMB
6OJWFSTJEBEEF-JTCPBEF$PJNCSBZEFM
1PSUPUFOÓBOEJWFSTPTUJQPTEFFOTF×BO
[BEFMBÏUJDBNÏEJDBTØMPIBDJBMB
&TDVFMBEF.FEJDJOBEFMB6OJWFSTJEBE
EFM1PSUPDSFØVO4FSWJDJPEF#JPÏUJDBZ
²UJDB.ÏEJDB4#&.
ZGVFMBQSJNFSB
WF[RVFMBQBMBCSBiCJPÏUJDBwBQBSFDJØFO
FMQMBOEFFTUVEJPTZFOMBPSHBOJ[BDJØO
EFVOBFTDVFMBNÏEJDB-FTJHVJØMB&T
DVFMBEF.FEJDJOBFO-JTCPBDSFBOEP
FOVO$FOUSPEF#JPÏUJDB
4JO FNCBSHP FM ÞOJDP EFQBSUBNFOUP
VOJWFSTJUBSJPRVFTFPDVQBEFMBCJPÏUJDB
FOVOTFOUJEPNÈTBNQMJPFTEFDJSTJO
BDPQMBNJFOUPT DPODFQUVBMFT OJ JOTUJUV
DJPOBMFTDPOMBFOTF×BO[BNÏEJDBFTFM
*OTUJUVUPEF#JPÏUJDBEFMB6OJWFSTJEBE
$BUØMJDB 1PSUVHVFTB DSFBEP FO EFTEFVOHSVQPQSFFYJTUFOUFEFJOWFTUJ
HBDJØOCJPÏUJDBGVOEBEPFO
&TUPOPFYDMVZFRVFPUSPTEFQBSUBNFOUPT
EFMBVOJWFSTJEBEDPOUSJCVZBOEFNBOFSB
DBMJmDBEBBMQFOTBNJFOUPCJPÏUJDP1PEF
NPTNFODJPOBSQPSFKFNQMPMPTEFQBS
UBNFOUPT EF mMPTPGÓB EF MB 6OJWFSTJEBE
EF"[PSFTFO1POUB%FMHBEB
ZFMEFMB
'BDVMUBE EF 'JMPTPGÓB EF MB 6OJWFSTJEBE
$BUØMJDB1PSUVHVFTBTJUVBEPFO#SBHB
"NCPT UJFOFO VO QMBO EF FTUVEJPT RVF
JODMVZFMBCJPÏUJDBZIBOQVCMJDBEPMJCSPT
BDFSDB EF MB NBUFSJB FM EF "[PSFT UBN
CJÏOIBBZVEBEPBMPTDPNJUÏTEFÏUJDBZ
BMBTPSHBOJ[BDJPOFTEFFOGFSNFSPT
#JPÏUJDBFO1PSUVHBM+PSHF#JTDBJBZ8BMUFS0TTXBME
-B "TPDJBDJØO 1PSUVHVFTB EF #JPÏUJDB
"1#
TF GPSNØ FO VOB NPNFOUP SF
MBUJWBNFOUF UBSEÓP Z NBOUJFOF
WÓODVMPT QFSTPOBMFT F JOTUJUVDJPOBMFT
NVZDFSDBOPTDPOFM4#&.5PEBTFTBT
JOTUJUVDJPOFTEFTBSSPMMBOBDUJWJEBEFTEF
DJTJWBTQBSBMBFWPMVDJØOOBDJPOBMEFMB
CJPÏUJDB MBT RVF JOUFOUBSFNPT SFTVNJS
FOMBTFDDJØOTJHVJFOUF
"DUJWJEBEFTQSJODJQBMFT
-BT SFVOJPOFT PSHBOJ[BEBT QPS FM $&#
ZFM*OTUJUVUPEF#JPÏUJDBFODVFTUJPOFT
EF JNQPSUBODJB OBDJPOBM Z DPO JNQMJ
DBDJPOFT JNQPSUBOUFT FO MBT QPMÓUJDBT
QÞCMJDBT TPO QBSBEJHNÈUJDBT EF FTUF
BDFSDBNJFOUP B MB QPCMBDJØO FO HFOF
SBM"EFNÈTFM$&#PSHBOJ[ØFO
FM $POHSFTP &VSPQFP EF $FOUSPT EF
²UJDB .ÏEJDB &O TV TFEF FO $PJNCSB
ZFOMBTEFMFHBDJPOFTEF-JTCPB1PSUP
"[PSFT ²WPSB .BEFJSB Z #SBHB IVCP
SFVOJPOFTSFHVMBSFTTPCSFDVFTUJPOFTEF
JOUFSÏTCJPÏUJDP1PSPUSBQBSUFFM$PO
HSFTP/BDJPOBMEF#JPÏUJDBDPOMBTÞM
UJNBTDVBUSPFEJDJPOFTPSHBOJ[BEBTQPS
MB "TPDJBDJØO 1PSUVHVFTB EF #JPÏUJDB
BTÓDPNPMPTTFNJOBSJPTBOVBMFTPSHBOJ
[BEPTQPSFM$POTFKP/BDJPOBMEF²UJDB
FOMBT$JFODJBTEFMB7JEBSFQSFTFOUBO
PUSPTBDPOUFDJNJFOUPTJNQPSUBOUFTRVF
HFOFSBMNFOUFDVFOUBODPOVOHSBOQÞ
CMJDP5PEBWÓBIBZVOBHSBODBOUJEBEEF
SFVOJPOFT Z EF UBMMFSFT NÈT QFRVF×PT
PDVQÈOEPTFEFÈSFBTFTQFDJBMJ[BEBTQPS
FKFNQMPWVMOFSBCJMJEBEBMQSJODJQJPZBM
mOBMEFMBWJEBFOTF×BO[BEFMBCJPÏUJDB
FOFTDVFMBTTFDVOEBSJBTQSPCMFNBTFOFM
DVJEBEPEFOJ×PTQSFNBUVSPTQBDJFOUFT
PERSPETIVADELABIOETICAINDD
UFSNJOBMFT Z DVJEBEPT QBMJBUJWPT DPO
TFSWBDJØOEFMPTSFDVSTPTEFBHVBFOUSF
PUSPT
" NFOVEP MBT TPDJFEBEFT DJFOUÓmDBT
BTPDJBDJPOFT EF MPT BCPHBEPT Z PSHBOJ
[BDJPOFTMBJDBTZDPOGFTJPOBMFTJODMVZFO
FOTVTDPOHSFTPTTFTJPOFTRVFTFPDVQBO
EFDVFTUJPOFTCJPÏUJDBTJOWJUBOEPBCJP
FUJDJTUBTRVFQSFTFOUBOZEJTDVUFOUFNBT
SFMFWBOUFT
1VCMJDBDJPOFT
/PFTTPSQSFTBRVFFMBVNFOUPEFBDUJ
WJEBEFTZFMJOUFSÏTQPSMBCJPÏUJDBIBZBO
EBEPMVHBSBVOOÞNFSPDSFDJFOUFEFQV
CMJDBDJPOFT$BEFSOPTEF#JPÏUJDB3FWJT
UB1PSUVHVFTBEF#JPÏUJDB
DPPSEJOBEB
QPSFM$&#FTMBÞOJDBQVCMJDBDJØOQF
SJØEJDBSFHVMBSEFEJDBEBBMBCJPÏUJDB
OÞNFSPT
1PSTVQVFTUPDPOUSJCVDJPOFT
RVF TF PDVQBO EF DVFTUJPOFT CJPÏUJDBT
TFQVCMJDBOSFHVMBSNFOUFFOQFSJØEJDPT
NÏEJDPTØSHBOPTEFMBTBTPDJBDJPOFTEF
NÏEJDPT Z BCPHBEPT QFSJØEJDPT DPOGF
TJPOBMFTZSFWJTUBTDVMUVSBMFT-PTEJBSJPT
ZDBOBMFTEFUFMFWJTJØOTFPDVQBOBWFDFT
EFNBOFSBTFOTBDJPOBMJTUB
EFMPTDBTPT
DPOTJEFSBEPTQBSBEJHNÈUJDPTDPNPQPS
FKFNQMP FM DBTP 4DIJBWP P MB EFDMBSBEB
DMPOBDJØO EF TFSFT IVNBOPT "VORVF
QFSTPOBT DPO DPOPDJNJFOUP CJPÏUJDP
TPO FOUSFWJTUBEPT HFOFSBMNFOUF FO FTUF
DPOUFYUPMBNBZPSÓBEFFTUPTJOGPSNFT
UJFOFNBMBDBMJEBE
$POTJEFSBEPT FO VO TFOUJEP FTUSJDUP
DPNPQFSUFOFDJFOUFTBMBCJPÏUJDBTFQV
CMJDBSPODBTJMJCSPTFOMBEÏDBEBQBTB
EB&TUPTUSBCBKPTWBOEFTEFNBOVBMFTB
1FSTQFDUJWBTEFMB#JPÏUJDBFO*CFSPBNÏSJDB
MJCSPTFTQFDJBMJ[BEPTZBCPSEBOWBSJBEPT
UFNBT DPNP CJPÏUJDB QBSB FOGFSNFSPT
QBSB MPT NJFNCSPT EF DPNJUÏT JOTUJUV
DJPOBMFT EF ÏUJDB PCMJHBUPSJPT FO UPEP
IPTQJUBM
EF MB HFOÏUJDB EF MBT FUBQBT
JOJDJBMFTEFMBWJEBIVNBOBEFMBDMPOB
DJØOEFMCJFODPNÞOZEFMJOUFSÏTJOEJ
WJEVBMFOTBZPTDMÓOJDPTÏUJDBBNCJFOUBM
SFQSPEVDDJØOBTJTUJEBQPSFKFNQMP
%PT WPMÞNFOFT EF DPNFOUBSJPT B MB
$POWFODJØO&VSPQFBEF%FSFDIPT)V
NBOPTZ#JPNFEJDJOBSFTVMUBOUFTEFMPT
UBMMFSFT PSHBOJ[BEPT QPS FM *OTUJUVUP EF
#JPÏUJDBSFnFKBOFMJOUFSÏTQPSMBEJTDV
TJØOEFEPDVNFOUPTKVSÓEJDPT1PSUVHBM
IBBEPQUBEPEJDIBTDPOWFODJPOFT
DPO
BNQMJBT JNQMJDBDJPOFT FO MPT DVJEBEPT
EF TBMVE Z MB TBOBDJØO 1PS ÞMUJNP BM
HVOBTNPOPHSBGÓBTQSFTFOUBEBTFODPO
HSFTPT P RVF SFQSFTFOUBO FM USBCBKP EF
VOÞOJDPBVUPSDPNQMFUBOFMDPOKVOUP
EFQVCMJDBDJPOFT&OFTUBÈSFBFM$/&
$7 IB MBO[BEP VOB TFSJF EF PDIP FEJ
DJPOFT RVF JODMVZFO MBT DPOUSJCVDJPOFT
QSFTFOUBEBT FO TVT TFNJOBSJPT BEFNÈT
EF OVFWF MJCSPT RVF DPOUJFOFO MBT PQJ
OJPOFTQSFTFOUBEBTQPSFTUFDVFSQP
-BFOTF×BO[BEFMBCJPÏUJDB
$PNP IFNPT BmSNBEP MB VOJWFSTJEBE
IB TJEP BMHP MFOUB FO FM SFDPOPDJNJFO
UPEFTVNJTJØOEFFOTF×BSZEJGVOEJSFM
DPOPDJNJFOUP CJPÏUJDP &O FGFDUP TØMP
FO TF DSFØ FM QSJNFS DVSTP EF
QPTHSBEPFOCJPÏUJDBRVFTFPDVQBEFM
UFNB EF MB SFQSPEVDDJØO NÏEJDBNFOUF
BTJTUJEB
FO MB 'BDVMUBE EF 'JMPTPGÓB EF
MB 6OJWFSTJEBE $BUØMJDB %FTEF FOUPO
PERSPETIVADELABIOETICAINDD
DFTMBTVOJWFSTJEBEFTBOUFEJDIBTPSHBOJ
[BODVSTPTEFQPTHSBEPZNBFTUSÓBTRVF
BCBSDBOVOBHSBOWBSJFEBEEFDVFTUJPOFT
CJPÏUJDBT&M*OTUJUVUPEF#JPÏUJDBEFMB
6OJWFSTJEBE$BUØMJDBZFM4FSWJDJPEF#JP
ÏUJDBZ²UJDB.ÏEJDBEFMB&TDVFMB.ÏEJ
DB EF MB 6OJWFSTJEBE EF 1PSUP DVFOUBO
DBEB DVBM DPO TJFUF NBFTUSÓBT NJFOUSBT
RVFMB'BDVMUBEEF'JMPTPGÓBEFMB6OJ
WFSTJEBE $BUØMJDB Z FM $FOUSP EF ²UJDB
EFMB&TDVFMB.ÏEJDBEFMB6OJWFSTJEBE
EF -JTCPB DPO DJODP DVSTPT DBEB VOP
&O FM OJWFM EF QPTHSBEP MBT FTDVFMBT
NÏEJDBT MB NBZPSÓB EF MPT DPMFHJPT EF
BCPHBEPT Z MBT FTDVFMBT EF FOGFSNFSBT
SFTFSWBOVOMVHBSFOTVQMBOEFFTUVEJPT
QBSB MB FOTF×BO[B EF MB CJPÏUJDB $V
SJPTBNFOUFMBTGBDVMUBEFTEFCJPMPHÓBZ
DJFODJBTBmOFTTØMPJODMVZFOMBFOTF×BO
[BEFMBCJPÏUJDBFOBMHVOPTDVSTPTEFTVT
QMBOFTEFFTUVEJPTSFTQFDUJWPT
"MHVOBTJOWFTUJHBDJPOFTIBOJOTJTUJEPFO
MB OFDFTJEBE EF FOTF×BS FTUBT NBUFSJBT
B NPEP EF JOUSPEVDDJØO FO MBT FTDVF
MBT TFDVOEBSJBT Z TF IBO IFDIP BMHVOBT
QSPQVFTUBT DPODSFUBT BM .JOJTUFSJP EF
&EVDBDJØOQFSPOPIBOUFOJEPFGFDUPBM
HVOP4FFTQFSBRVFMBTBVUPSJEBEFTSFDP
OP[DBORVFPGSFDFSEFNPEPUSBOTWFSTBM
VOQSJNFSDPOUBDUPDPOMPTUFNBTQSJODJ
QBMFTEFMBCJPÏUJDBHFOFSBMTFSÓBEFHSBO
WBMPS QPS FKFNQMP DVFTUJPOFT RVF TF
QVFEBOBCPSEBSEFTEFMBTBTJHOBUVSBTEF
CJPMPHÓBmMPTPGÓBSFMJHJØOPDJVEBEBOÓB
*OWFTUJHBDJØOCJPNÏEJDB
-BFMBCPSBDJØOEFVOBUFTJTEFNBFTUSÓB
JNQMJDBDJFSUPHSBEPEFJOWFTUJHBDJØOZ
#JPÏUJDBFO1PSUVHBM+PSHF#JTDBJBZ8BMUFS0TTXBME
FTP DJFSUBNFOUF TVDFEF DPO MBT UFTJT ZB
BQSPCBEBT4FFTQFSBRVFVOHSBEPNV
DIPNÈTBMUPEFJOWFTUJHBDJØOEFDBMJEBE
TFBBTVNJEPQPSMBTFTDVFMBTRVFPGSFDFO
VOQSPHSBNBEFEPDUPSBEP"DUVBMNFO
UFFMÞOJDPJOTUJUVUPRVFDPODFEFFMHSB
EPEF%PDUPSFO#JPÏUJDBFTFM*OTUJUVUP
EF#JPÏUJDBEFMB6OJWFSTJEBE$BUØMJDB
"EFNÈT EF MB JOWFTUJHBDJØO JOEJWJEVBM
JNQMJDBEBFOMBQSFQBSBDJØOEFVOBUF
TJTEFNBFTUSÓBPEFEPDUPSBEPBMHVOPT
QSPZFDUPT EF JOWFTUJHBDJØO UBOUP EF
OBUVSBMF[B OBDJPOBM DPNP JOUFSOBDJP
OBM Z DPPQFSBUJWB
TPO DPOEVDJEPT QPS
EPT JOTUJUVDJPOFT FM *OTUJUVUP EF #JPÏ
UJDB6OJWFSTJEBE$BUØMJDB
ZFM4FSWJDJP
EF#JPÏUJDBZ²UJDB.ÏEJDB&TDVFMBEF
.FEJDJOBEFMB6OJWFSTJEBEEF1PSUP
&MMPTJOWFTUJHBOQPSFKFNQMPMBNVFS
UFEFOJ×PTQSFNBUVSPTFMTÓOESPNFEF
EFTHBTUFFOEFQBSUBNFOUPTEFDVJEBEPT
QBMJBUJWPT F JOUFOTJWPT MB JOWFTUJHBDJØO
EF DÏMVMBT NBESF MB FOTF×BO[B EF MB
CJPÏUJDB FO FTDVFMBT TFDVOEBSJBT MB OB
UVSBMF[B Z MB ÏUJDB MB SFDVQFSBDJØO EF
TPSEPNVEPT Z MPT QSPCMFNBT ÏUJDPT FM
YFOPUSBTQMBOUFMBÏUJDBEFMBBTJHOBDJØO
EF SFDVSTPT B MPT TFSWJDJPT EF DVJEBEPT
NÏEJDPTFOUSFPUSPTUFNBT
-BQFSTQFDUJWBEFMBEFEJDBDJØOQSPHSF
TJWBEFCJPFUJDJTUBTQPSUVHVFTFTZFTQF
DJBMNFOUFEFMPTNÈTKØWFOFTBMBJOWFT
UJHBDJØOFOÏUJDBGVOEBNFOUBMZBQMJDBEB
QVFEFKVTUJmDBSVODJFSUPPQUJNJTNP
JNQPSUBODJBCJPÏUJDB/VFTUSBJOUFODJØO
FT NFODJPOBS TØMP BRVFMMBT EF FYUSFNB
JNQPSUBODJB FO MB NBUFSJB ZP RVF TF
IBO TPNFUJEP BM QBSFDFS EF $/&$7
ØSHBOP EF OBUVSBMF[B DPOTVMUJWB Z OP
WJODVMBOUF QFSP RVF FKFSDF DMBSBNFOUF
VOBJOnVFODJBFOFMUFYUPMFHBM
%FFTUBNBOFSBFMBCPSUPFTDPOTJEFSBEP
VODSJNFODBTUJHBEPDPOQSJTJØOEFB
B×PT
FYDFQUPCBKPDJFSUBTDPOEJDJPOFT
QFMJHSPEFEB×PGÓTJDPTPNFOUBMFTQBSB
MB NVKFS FNCBSB[BEB QSFTFODJB EF FO
GFSNFEBEHSBWFZOPDVSBCMFFOFMGFUP
FNCBSB[P EFTQVÏT EF DSJNFO TFYVBM
&M USBTQMBOUF FT QPTJCMF TJ MPT EPOBOUFT
FTUÈO NVFSUPT EFTQVÏT EF MB EJBHOPTJT
EFNVFSUFDFSFCSBM
PWJWPTMJNJUBEPB
QBSJFOUFT QSØYJNPT
Z IBZ VO SFHJTUSP
EFOPEPOBOUFTQVFTUPRVFTFQSFTVNF
RVFUPEPTBDFQUBOEPOBSTVTØSHBOPT
-PT FOTBZPT DMÓOJDPT TF SFHVMBO FTUSJD
UBNFOUFZMB%JSFDUJWB&VSPQFBIBTJEP
BEPQUBEB SFDJFOUFNFOUF QPS FM QBÓT MB
-FZFTVOBUSBTDSJQDJØOEFFTUB
%JSFDUJWB$&
-PTDBEÈWFSFTTFQVFEFOVUJMJ[BSQBSBMB
FOTF×BO[B Z JOWFTUJHBDJØO CBKP DPOEJ
DJPOFTCJFOSFTUSJOHJEBTZFTOFDFTBSJPFM
QSFWJPDPOTFOUJNJFOUPJOGPSNBEPEFMB
QFSTPOBWJWB
-B SFQSPEVDDJØO NÏEJDBNFOUF BTJTUJEB
3."
IB TJEP mOBMNFOUF SFHVMBEB
EFTQVÏTEFEÏDBEBTEFQSÈDUJDBTJONBS
DPMFHBM-BBDUVBMMFZSFTUSJOHFMB3."
-FZFTEFJNQPSUBODJBCJPNÏEJDB
&TDPNQSFOTJCMFRVFUPEBTMBTMFZFTRVF
BGFDUBO MB TBMVE Z FM BNCJFOUF TFBO EF
PERSPETIVADELABIOETICAINDD
&MEFNBS[PEFFM1BSMBNFOUPEF1PSUV
HBMBQSPCØFMBCPSUPIBTUBMBEÏDJNBTFNBOBEF
FNCBSB[P/5
1FSTQFDUJWBTEFMB#JPÏUJDBFO*CFSPBNÏSJDB
BMPTQBSFTIFUFSPTFYVBMFTDBTBEPTPOP
QFSP QFSNJUF FO DBTPT FYDFQDJPOBMFT
MB GFDVOEBDJØO IFUFSØMPHB F JODMVTPMBT
NBESFT TVTUJUVUBT -PT FNCSJPOFT EF
TPCSB QVFEFO TFS VUJMJ[BEPT QBSB MB JO
WFTUJHBDJØODPOMBBVUPSJ[BDJØOQBSFOUBM
Z EFTQVÏT EF EPT B×PT EF FTUBS DPOHF
MBEPT
-BBEPQDJØODPNPMFZOBDJPOBMEFSJWBEB
EFMB$POWFODJØO&VSPQFBEF%FSFDIPT
)VNBOPTZ#JPNFEJDJOBSFQSFTFOUBVO
KBMØOJNQPSUBOUFFOMBUSBZFDUPSJBEFMB
CJPÏUJDBFO1PSUVHBM$POTVJOTJTUFODJB
SFTQFDUPEFMDPOTFOUJNJFOUPJOGPSNBEP
MB EJHOJEBE EF MB QFSTPOB IVNBOB MB
QSJPSJEBE EFM JOUFSÏT JOEJWJEVBM GSFOUF
BMJOUFSÏTDPNÞOZMBQSPIJCJDJØOEFMB
QSPEVDDJØOEFFNCSJPOFTIVNBOPTQBSB
QSPQØTJUPT EF JOWFTUJHBDJØO JODPSQPSB
VO DPOKVOUP JNQPSUBOUF EF OPDJPOFT
CJPÏUJDBTRVFJOnVFODJBSÈOGVFSUFNFOUF
MBMFHJTMBDJØOGVUVSB
7ÓODVMPTJOUFSOBDJPOBMFT
%FCJEPBTVTDBSBDUFSÓTUJDBTMBCJPÏUJDB
UJFOEFBTFSNÈTJOUFSOBDJPOBMFOTVBM
DBODFRVFNVDIBTPUSBTEJTDJQMJOBT-B
NFUBRVFNVDIPTUJMEBSÈOEFVUØQJDB
EF MPHSBS VO DPOTFOTP VOJWFSTBM FO MB
CJPÏUJDB RVF QVFEB EJSJHJS BDUJUVEFT Z
BDDJPOFT FO ÈSFBT FYUFOTBT EF MBT DJFO
DJBT EF MB WJEB Z MB QSFTFSWBDJØO EF MB
CJPTGFSBOPFTBMDBO[BCMFTJMBHFOUFEF
EJWFSTPT QBÓTFT Z DPOUJOFOUFT OP JOUFS
DBNCJB TVT PQJOJPOFT OP EJTDVUF TVT
CBTFTDVMUVSBMFTOPDPNQBSBTVTQJMBSFT
CÈTJDPT Z OP JOUFOUB FODPOUSBS BMHÞO
UFSSJUPSJPDPNÞO&OFTUFDPOUFYUPOP
FTTPSQSFTBRVFEFTEFFMQSJODJQJPEFMB
PERSPETIVADELABIOETICAINDD
iFSB CJPÏUJDBi RVF FO 1PSUVHBM PDVS
SJØBNFEJBEPTEFMPTPDIFOUB
FSVEJUPT
QPSUVHVFTFTIBZBOJOUFOUBEPFTUBCMFDFS
ZNBOUFOFSWÓODVMPTDPODPMFHBTFJOTUJ
UVDJPOFTEFPUSPTQBÓTFT
1PS NPUJWPT EF MFOHVB Z DVMUVSB TF
FTUBCMFDJFSPO DPOUBDUPT SFHVMBSFT DPO
#SBTJMZQBÓTFTMBUJOPT&TQB×BF*UBMJB
-PTFTUVEJPTPTQPSUVHVFTFTZCSBTJMF×PT
IBO DPNQBSUJEP DPOGFSFODJBT Z DVSTPT
Z EF FTB DPPQFSBDJØO TVSHJØ MB TFSJF EF
FODVFOUSPT -VTP#SBTJMFSPT EF CJPÏUJDB
RVF SFDJFOUFNFOUF IBO BMDBO[BEP ZB
TVDVBSUBFEJDJØOTFQUJFNCSFEF
FO 4ÍP 1BVMP &T VOB PDBTJØO QBSB JO
UFSDBNCJBSQVOUPTEFWJTUBDPOMBWFO
UBKB EF UFOFS VO QBUSJNPOJP DVMUVSBM Z
MJOHàÓTUJDP DPNVOFT 1PS PUSB QBSUF
BMHVOPT FTUVEJBOUFT HSBEVBEPT WJTJUBO
PUSPT QBÓTFT 4ÍP 1BVMP oZ FO &VSPQB
#BSDFMPOB3PNB1BEPWBZ1BSÓToIBO
TJEP MPT QVOUPT DFOUSBMFT EF FTUF JOUFS
DBNCJPJOUFSOBDJPOBM
$PNPTFIBEJDIPFM$&#FTNJFNCSP
EFM $POTFKP EF MB "TPDJBDJØO &VSPQFB
EFMPT$FOUSPTEF²UJDB.ÏEJDB#JPFUJ
DJTUBT QPSUVHVFTFT IBO TJEP EFTUJOBEPT
SFHVMBSNFOUF B MPT DVFSQPT FTQFDJBMJ[B
EPTEFM$POTFKPEF&VSPQBEFMB6OJØO
&VSPQFBZEFMB6/&4$0RVFTFPDV
QBOEFDVFTUJPOFTCJPÏUJDBT$PNJUÏ%J
SFDUFVS QPVS MB #JPÏUIJRVF (SVQP &V
SPQFPEF²UJDBEFMB$JFODJBZ/VFWBT
5FDOPMPHÓBTZ$PNJUÏ*OUFSOBDJPOBMEF
#JPÏUJDB
6O OÞNFSP JNQPSUBOUF EF CJPFUJDJT
UBT EF PUSPT QBÓTFT IBO TJEP JOWJUBEPT
B EJDUBS DPOGFSFODJBT Z TFNJOBSJPT FO
#JPÏUJDBFO1PSUVHBM+PSHF#JTDBJBZ8BMUFS0TTXBME
1PSUVHBM Z EF FTF NPEP DPOUSJCVJS
FO MB EJSFDDJØO EF FTUVEJBOUFT HSBEVB
EPT RVF QSFQBSBCBO TVT UFTJT "EFNÈT
DJFOUÓmDPTQPSUVHVFTFTQBSUJDJQBOEFMPT
DPOTFKPTEFTPDJFEBEFTJOUFSOBDJPOBMFTP
BTPDJBDJPOFTEFCJPÏUJDBZVOPEFFMMPT
FTNJFNCSPEFMBQSFTUJHJPTB"DBEFNJB
1POUJmDJBQPSMB7JEB
6OB DPOUSJCVDJØO NVZ JNQPSUBOUF BM
SFDPOPDJNJFOUP JOUFSOBDJPOBM EFM USB
CBKP EF MPT QPSUVHVFTFT FO FTUB ÈSFB
EFQFOEF EF MB QVCMJDBDJØO FO QFSJØEJ
DPTJOUFSOBDJPOBMFT&TUPTVDFEFBDUVBM
NFOUFFOVOBFTDBMBBMHPNPEFTUBZQPS
MPUBOUPOFDFTJUBTFSBOJNBEPZGPNFO
UBEP
3FGFSFODJBT
#JTDBJB + Z 0TTXBME 8 #JPÏUJDB JO 1PSUVHBM &O -VTUJH #
"OESFX $PPSE
#JPFUIJDT :FBSCPPL 7PM "NTUFSEBN ,MVXFS "DBEFNJD
1VCMJTIFSTQQ
/VOF[.1"CFM'
#JPFUIJDTJO1PSUVHBM-VTUJH#"$PPSE
#JPFUIJDT:FBSCPPL7PM"NTUFSEBN,MVXFS"DBEFNJD1VCMJTIFSTQQ
%JSFDDJPOFT
$FOUSP EF #JPÏUJDB 'BDVMEBEF EF .FEJDJOB EB 6OJWFSTJEBEF EF -JTCPB %JSFDUPS
" #BSCPTB
"W 1SPGFTTPS &HBT .POJ[ -JTCPB 5FMÏGPOP 'BY
&NBJMGNM!GNVMQU
$FOUSP EF %JSFJUP #JPNÏEJDP 'BDVMEBEF EF %JSFJUP EB 6OJWFSTJEBEF EF $PJNCSB
%JSFDUPS(EF0MJWFJSB
1ÈUJPEB6OJWFSTJEBEF$PJNCSB1PSUVHBM
5FMÏGPOP 'BY &NBJM GEVD!GE
VDQU
$FOUSP EF &TUVEPT EF #JPÏUJDB %JSFDUPS +PSHF #JTDBJB
3VB (FOFSBM )VNCFSUP
%FMHBEP%$PJNCSB5FMÏGPOP
&NBJM
KPSHFCJTDBJB!OFUDBCPQU
$POTFMIP /BDJPOBM EF ²UJDB QBSB BT $JÐODJBT EB 7JEB $/&$7 1SFTJEFOUF 1BVMB
.BSUJOIP EB 4JMWB
1SPG (PNFT 5FJYFJSB &EJG 1$.  -JTCPB
5FMÏGPOP
'BY
&NBJMQSFTDOFDW!THQDN
HPWQU
*OTUJUVUP EF #JPÏUJDB EB 6OJWFSTJEBEF $BUØMJDB 1PSUVHVFTB %JSFDUPS "OB 4PGJB
$BSWBMIP
3VB EF %JPHP #PUFMIP 1PSUP 1PSUVHBM 5FMÏGPOP
'BY
&NBJMJC!QPSUPVDQQU
'BDVMEBEFEF'JMPTPGJBEB6OJWFSTJEBEF$BUØMJDB1PSUVHVFTB#JPÏUJDB(FSBM%JSFDUPS
+)4JMWFJSBEF#SJUP
1SBÎBEB'BDVMEBEF#SBHB5FMÏGPOP
'BY
&NBJMTFDSFUBSJBGBDGJM!CSBHBVDQQU
4FSWJÎPEF#JPÏUJDBF²UJDB.ÏEJDBEB'BDVMEBEFEF.FEJDJOBEB6OJWFSTJEBEFEP1PSUP
%JSFDUPS3VJ/VOFT
"MBNFEB1SPG)FSOÉOJ.POUFJSP1PSUP1PSUVHBM
5FMÏGPOP 'BY &NBJM SVJOVOFT!NFE
VQQU
PERSPETIVADELABIOETICAINDD
1FSTQFDUJWBTEFMB#JPÏUJDBFO*CFSPBNÏSJDB
6OJWFSTJEBEFEPT"ÎPSFT%FQBSUBNFOUPEF'JMPTPGJB%JSFDUPS.BSJBEP$ÏV1BUSÍP
/FWFT
$BNQVTEF1POUB%FMHBEB"QBSUBEP1POUB%FMHBEB4
.JHVFM"ÎPSFT1PSUVHBM5FMÏGPOP
'BY
&NBJMQBUSBP!OPUFTVBDQU
#JCMJPHSBGÓB
"MNFJEB'
²UJDBFN1FEJBUSJBVNBOPWBEJOÉNJDBOVNSFMBDJPOBNFOUPWJUBM 1PSUP&EJÎÍPEP"VUPS
"OUVOFT+
4PCSFB.ÍPF0VUSPT&OTBJPT-JTCPB(SBEJWB
"SDIFS-
%B(FOÏUJDBË#JØUJDB$PJNCSB(SÈGJDBEF$PJNCSB
"SDIFS-#JTDBJB+Z0TTXBME8$PPSET
#JPÏUJDB-JTCPB&EJUPSJBM7FSCP
"SDIFS-#JTDBJB+0TTXBME83FOBVE.$PPSET
/PWPTEFTBGJPTË
#JPÏUJDB1PSUP1PSUP&EJUPSB
#JTDBJB + $PPSE
#FN EB 1FTTPB #FN $PNVN $PJNCSB (SÈGJDB EF
$PJNCSB
#JTDBJB+
1FSEFSQBSBFODPOUSBS$PJNCSB(SÈGJDBEF$PJNCSB
#JTDBJB+
"PFODPOUSPEBUFSOVSB$PJNCSB(SÈGJDBEF$PJNCSB
#SJUP+)4JMWFJSB$PPSE
#JPÏUJDBRVFTUÜFTFNEFCBUF#SBHB'BDVMEBEFEF
'JMPTPGJBEB6OJWFSTJEBEF$BUØMJDB1PSUVHVFTB
$BCSBM3
5FNBTEF²UJDB#SBHB6OJWFSTJEBEF$BUØMJDB1PSUVHVFTB
$BSWBMIP " 4 $PPSE
$MPOBHFN P SJTDP F P EFTBGJP 1PSUP (BCJOFUF EF
*OWFTUJHBÎÍPEF#JPÏUJDBEB6OJWFSTJEBEF$BUØMJDB1PSUVHVFTB
$PVUJOIP7
#JPÏUJDBF5FPMPHJB2VFQBSBEJHNBEFJOUFSBDÎÍP $PJNCSB(SÈGJDB
EF$PJNCSB
$VOIB+5FJYFJSB
#JPÏUJDBCSFWF"QFMBÎÍP1PSUVHBM
1BVMVT&EJUPSB
-FPOF41SJWJUFSB4$VOIB+5
%JDJPOÈSJPEF#JPÏUJDB7JMB/PWB(BJB
&EJUPSJBM1FSQÏUVP4PDPSSP
/FWFT.$1BUSÍP$PPSE
$PNJTTÜFTEF²UJDBEBTCBTFTUFØSJDBTËBDUJWJEBEF
RVPUJEJBOB$PJNCSB(SÈGJDBEF$PJNCSB
/FWFT.$1BUSÍP1BDIFDP4$PPSET
1BSBVN²UJDBEB&OGFSNBHFN
%FTBGJPT$PJNCSB(SÈGJDBEF$PJNCSB
/FWFT .$ 1BUSÍP $PPSE
#JPÏUJDB PV #JPÏUJDBT $PJNCSB (SÈGJDB EF
$PJNCSB
/VOFT 3 2VFTUÜFT ÏUJDBT EP EJBHOØTUJDP QSÏOBUBM EB EPFOÎB HFOÏUJDB 1PSUP
&EJÎÍPEP"VUPS
/VOFT 3 .FMP ) /VOFT $ $PPSET
(FOPNB F EJHOJEBEF IVNBOB
$PJNCSB(SÈGJDBEF$PJNCSB
PERSPETIVADELABIOETICAINDD
#JPÏUJDBFO1PSUVHBM+PSHF#JTDBJBZ8BMUFS0TTXBME
/VOFT 3 .FMP ) /VOFT $ $PPSET
(FOPNB F SFQSPEVÎÍP IVNBOB
$PJNCSB(SÈGJDBEF$PJNCSB
/VOFT3.FMP)/VOFT$$PPSET
"ÏUJDBFPEJSFJUPOPJOÓDJPEBWJEB
IVNBOB$PJNCSB(SÈGJDBEF$PJNCSB
/VOFT33FHP($PPSET
1SJPSJEBEFTOBTBÞEF-JTCPB.D(SBX)JMM
0MJWFJSB(
5FNBTEF%JSFJUPEB.FEJDJOB$PJNCSB$PJNCSB&EJUPSB
0TTXBME8$PPSE
%JSFJUPTEP)PNFNF#JPNFEJDJOB1PSUP6OJWFSTJEBEF
$BUØMJDB&EJUPSB
0TTXBME8
6NGJPEF²UJDB$PJNCSB(SÈGJDBEF$PJNCSB
1JOUP+3$PTUB
2VFTUÜFTBDUVBJTEB²UJDB.ÏEJDB‹&EJÎÍP#SBHB&EJUPSJBM"0
4FSSÍP % /VOFT 3 $PPSET
²UJDB FN DVJEBEPT EF TBÞEF 1PSUP 1PSUP
&EJUPSB
4JMWB+3JCFJSP#BSCPTB"7BMF'$PPSET
$POUSJCVUPTQBSBB#JPÏUJDBFN
1PSUVHBM-JTCPB$PTNPT
PERSPETIVADELABIOETICAINDD
PERSPETIVADELABIOETICAINDD
-BIJTUPSJBEFMBCJPÏUJDBFO3FQÞCMJDB%PNJOJDBOB
.JHVFM4VB[P
"OUFDFEFOUFTFMOBDJNJFOUP
&
O TF QSPEVDF FM JOJDJP EF MB
CJPÏUJDBQBSBFMQBÓT1BSBFTBGFDIB
MB0SHBOJ[BDJØO1BOBNFSJDBOBEFMB4B
MVE 014
FO 3FQÞCMJDB %PNJOJDBOB
DPOWPDØBMNVOEPBDBEÏNJDPZEFMBTB
MVEQBSBDPNQBSUJSDPOVOJOWJUBEPRVF
IBCMBSÓBTPCSFVOUFNBoCJPÏUJDBoOVF
WPZBKFOPQBSBOPTPUSPT&MJOWJUBEPFSB
&EVBSEP EFM $B×P BSHFOUJOP -B DPO
WPDBUPSJBDBMØGVOEBNFOUBMNFOUFFOUSF
MPTBDBEÏNJDPTRVJFOFTFTUVWJNPTFOMB
QSJNFSBMÓOFBMVFHPFM.JOJTUFSJPEF4B
MVEJOUFSFTBEPTSFMJHJPTPTGVODJPOBSJPT
QÞCMJDPT Z QSJWBEPT -B QSPQVFTUB OP
GVFDPNQSFOEJEBFOUPEBTVNBHOJUVE
EFTEFFTUFQSJNFSNPNFOUPTJOFNCBS
HP IPZ QPEFNPT BmSNBS RVF DBZØ FO
UFSSFOPGÏSUJM
-PT BSHFOUJOPT UFOÓBO ZB NVDIB FYQF
SJFODJBFOFTFNPNFOUP/PNCSFTDPNP
MPTEF+".BJOFUUJFSBOIJTUPSJBDVBOEP
OPTPUSPTBQFOBTJOUFOUÈCBNPTBTPNBSOPT
B FTUB WFOUBOB -PT JOTUJUVUPT Z DFOUSPT
BSHFOUJOPTEFCJPÏUJDBFSBOVOBSFBMJEBE
BQBSUBEBZEJTUBOUFQBSBOPTPUSPT
%VSBOUFFTUPTB×PTMBCBUBMMBIBTJEPMBS
HB3FVOJPOFTTFNJOBSJPTFODVFOUSPT
PERSPETIVADELABIOETICAINDD
IBTUBDPOGPSNBSVOB$PNJTJØO/BDJP
OBMEF#JPÏUJDB$/#
JOJDJÈOEPTFDPO
VODPNJUÏHFTUPSRVFEFCÓBDPOEVDJSB
VOBT FMFDDJPOFT FOUSF MPT JOUFSFTBEPT Z
MBT JOTUJUVDJPOFT QSFTFOUFT &TUP USBKP
DPNPSFTVMUBEPBTVQSJNFSQSFTJEFOUF
.JMDJBEFT "MCFSU EJSFDUPS FKFDVUJWP FO
FTF FOUPODFT EFM *OTUJUVUP "DDJØO 1SP
&EVDBDJØO Z $VMUVSB "1&$
EF FEV
DBDJØO TFYVBM Z "OESÏT 1FSBMUB DPNP
WJDFQSFTJEFOUF
"MPTQPDPTNFTFTTFJOJDJØVOQSPDFTP
EFDPOTPMJEBDJØOZVOBTFSJFEFFODVFO
USPTFOVOJWFSTJEBEFTZNJOJTUFSJPTQÞ
CMJDPTIBTUBDPODMVJSFOFM1SJNFS$PO
HSFTP%PNJOJDBOPEF#JPÏUJDB
5PEP FTUF UJFNQP DPOEVKP B MB FMBCP
SBDJØO EF SFHMBNFOUPT JODPSQPSBDJØO
MFHBMQPSFMQPEFSFKFDVUJWPDPNJTJPOFT
EF USBCBKP JOWJUBEPT JOUFSOBDJPOBMFT Z
DPOHSFTPTOBDJPOBMFTIBTUBMMFHBSBMNP
NFOUPEFMBDBQBDJUBDJØOBMJOUFSJPSEF
MBQSPQJBDPNJTJØOBMBRVFZBTFIBCÓB
EBEPVOBFTUSVDUVSBGPSNBMZSFTQPOTB
CJMJEBEFTQPSÈSFBTDPNJUÏTEFCJPÏUJDB
BTJTUFODJBM NFEJP BNCJFOUF JOWFTUJHB
DJØOEPDFODJBSFMJHJØOmMPTPGÓBFOUSF
PUSBT
1FSTQFDUJWBTEFMB#JPÏUJDBFO*CFSPBNÏSJDB
&TUPTJOJDJPTGVFSPOGVOEBNFOUBEPTDPO
FMBVUPFTUVEJPZMBUPNBEFDPOUBDUPDPO
PSHBOJTNPT JOUFSOBDJPOBMFT DPNP FM
1SPHSBNB 3FHJPOBM EF #JPÏUJDB 13#
EFMB014FO$IJMFZTVTEJSFDUJWPT
EBT QSFTUBSPO VO BQPZP JNQPSUBOUF B
FTUF QSPDFTP EF CÞTRVFEB Z FODVFOUSP
4JSWJFSPO EF TFEF EF BQPZP EF mOBO
DJBEPSBTZBMHVOBTBÞOTJHVFOTJÏOEPMP
IBTUBIPZ
&UBQBEFGPSNBMJ[BDJØO
EFTBSSPMMP
*OUFSOBDJPOBMJ[BDJØO
"FTUBGFDIBZBIBCÓBOPDVSSJEPFWFOUPT
EFJNQPSUBODJBFOMBWJEBEFMBCJPÏUJDB
EPNJOJDBOB FO DVBOUP TF IBCÓB MPHSB
EPTFOTJCJMJ[BSBEJTUJOUPTTFDUPSFTIBDFS
DPOUBDUPTJOUFSOBDJPOBMFTDPOMB'FEFSB
DJØO -BUJOPBNFSJDBOB EF *OTUJUVDJPOFT
EF#JPÏUJDB'&-"*#&
DPOFM13#EF
MB014FO$IJMFZDPOPUSBTJOTUJUVDJP
OFTEFFTFÈNCJUP4FIBCÓBODFMFCSBEP
EPT DPOHSFTPT OBDJPOBMFT NÈT Z IBCÓB
NPT UPNBEP QBSUF FO VO DPOTPSDJP EF
DPNJTJPOFTEFCJPÏUJDBEFM$BSJCFGPS
NBOEP MB $POGFEFSBDJØO $BSJCF×B EF
#JPÏUJDBKVOUPB$VCBZ1VFSUP3JDP
&OFTFB×PNFQSFTFOUÏDPNPDBOEJEBUP
EFM *OTUJUVUP 5FDOPMØHJDP */5&$
BM
.BHÓTUFSEF#JPÏUJDBEFMB6OJWFSTJEBE
EF$IJMFoDPOMPTBVTQJDJPTEFM13#o
NJFOUSBT "OESÏT 1FSBMUB QSFTJEFOUF EF
MB $/# QBSUJDJQBCB FO DVSTPT JOUFS
OBDJPOBMFT EF CJPÏUJDB DPO DPOOPUBEPT
QSPGFTPSFTFO1VFSUP3JDPTJFNQSFDPO
FMBQPZPEFM13#EF014
1PEFNPTEFDJSRVFFOFTUBFUBQBEFGPS
NBDJØOFNQF[BNPTBEBSOPTDVFOUBEF
RVÏ FSB MB CJPÏUJDB TPCSF UPEP FOUFO
EJFOEPRVFIBCÓBNPTFNQF[BEPBPSHB
OJ[BSOPTBUSBWÏTEFMPBDBEÏNJDP
"MHVOBTEFMBTVOJWFSTJEBEFTJOWPMVDSB
PERSPETIVADELABIOETICAINDD
&O FM $POTFKP "DBEÏNJDP EFM
*OTUJUVUP 5FDOPMØHJDP EF 4BOUP %P
NJOHPBDPHFVOBTPMJDJUVEEFM«SFBEF
4BMVE Z NÓB oRVF IBCÓB TJEP TV EFDB
OPoQBSBDPOGPSNBSFM$FOUSP*OUFDEF
#JPÏUJDB$&/*/#*0
FMDVBMDPODJUB
MB QBSUJDJQBDJØO EF WBSJPT QSPGFTJPOBMFT
WJODVMBEPTBMÈSFB4VPCKFUJWPFSBTFSWJS
EFBQPZPDPOTVMUBZSFGFSFODJBQBSBMB
EJTFNJOBDJØOEFMBCJPÏUJDBFOFMNFEJP
EPNJOJDBOPZQBSBJOJDJBSVOQSPDFTPEF
TFOTJCJMJ[BDJØOZEJWVMHBDJØOFOFMQBÓT
"M UÏSNJOP EFM TFHVOEP .BHÓTUFS EF
#JPÏUJDB FO $IJMF Z CBKP MB EJSFDDJØO
EF%JFHP(SBDJBZTVFRVJQPEFMB6OJ
WFSTJEBE$PNQMVUFOTFZEFPUSPTQBÓTFT
MBUJOPBNFSJDBOPT FM */5&$ EF 3FQÞ
CMJDB %PNJOJDBOB BDFQUØ TFS TFEF EFM
QSJNFSPEFFTUPTNBHÓTUFSFTGVFSBEFUF
SSJUPSJPDIJMFOP
"M $FOUSP EF #JPÏUJDB TF MF FODBSHB MB
SFTQPOTBCJMJEBEEFBTVNJSMBDPPSEJOB
DJØO UÏDOJDB EFM OVFWP NBHÓTUFS PCUF
OJFOEP MB QBSUJDJQBDJØO EF FTUVEJBOUFT
EF $PMPNCJB $IJMF 1FSÞ &DVBEPS
"SHFOUJOB&M4BMWBEPS.ÏYJDP$VCB
3FQÞCMJDB%PNJOJDBOBFOUSFPUSPT
-B $PNJTJØO /BDJPOBM EF #JPÏUJDB
QSFTJEJEB FO FTF NPNFOUP QPS "OESÏT
1FSBMUB KVFHB VO QBQFM QSFQPOEFSBOUF
-BIJTUPSJBEFMBCJPÏUJDBFO3FQÞCMJDB%PNJOJDBOB.JHVFM4VB[P
FO MBT OFHPDJBDJPOFT Z HBSBOUÓBT QBSB
JOTUBMBSFMNBHÓTUFSFO3FQÞCMJDB%PNJ
OJDBOBTPCSFUPEPQPSRVFEJDIBVOJWFS
TJEBE FT QSJWBEB Z 014 TJFNQSF IBCÓB
DPPSEJOBEPBDUJWJEBEFTDPOVOJWFSTJEB
EFTQÞCMJDBT
$SFDJNJFOUPFYUFOTJØOZ
EFTBSSPMMP
&M$FOUSPEF#JPÏUJDBSFDJCFVOFTQBMEB
SB[PEFQBSUFEFMBSFDUPSBEFM*/5&$
FO FTF QFSÓPEP "MUBHSBDJB -ØQF[ EÈO
EPMFBUSJCVDJPOFTEFHFSFOUFBDBEÏNJDP
DPNP DPOUSBQBSUF BM DVFSQP EPDFOUF Z
UÏDOJDPEFMB014
$PNP QBSUF EF TVT UBSFBT TF MF BTJHOB
CBO
t
t
t
t
t
t
t
$PPSEJOBS FM .BHÓTUFS *OUFSOBDJP
OBMFO#JPÏUJDBDPOFM13#EVSBOUF
FMQFSÓPEPB
$BQBDJUBSBMPTDPNJUÏTEFCJPÏUJDB
IPTQJUBMBSJB
'PSNBS FM 'PSP */5&$ EF #JPÏ
UJDBFOFMOJWFMEFQSFHSBEPFOMB
DBSSFSBEF.FEJDJOBEFM*/5&$
0SHBOJ[BSDPOGFSFODJBTFOFMNFEJP
EPNJOJDBOP
*NQMFNFOUBSFMDVSSÓDVMPEFMBCJP
ÏUJDBDPNPFKFUSBOTWFSTBMEFMBDB
SSFSBEF.FEJDJOBEFM*/5&$
&TUBCMFDFSBDVFSEPTDPOFM13#EF
014
"QPZBSBMB$PNJTJØO/BDJPOBMEF
#JPÏUJDB
%FTEF FTB GFDIB FM $FOUSP TF DPNQSP
NFUJØDPOFTUPTBTVOUPTDPOWJSUJÏOEPTF
FOQVOUPEFSFGFSFODJBOBDJPOBM
PERSPETIVADELABIOETICAINDD
.JFOUSBTTFEFTBSSPMMBCBOFTUPTQSPDFTPT
BDBEÏNJDPT MB $PNJTJØO /BDJPOBM EF
#JPÏUJDB DPOUJOVØ TV EFTBSSPMMP %FT
QVÏT EF EPT NBOEBUPT DPOTFDVUJWPT EF
"OESÏT 1FSBMUB GVF FMFDUP DPNP QSFTJ
EFOUFFMSFDUPSEFMB6OJWFSTJEBE$BUØ
MJDB4BOUP%PNJOHP.POTF×PS3BNØO
"MPOTPRVJFOEJPTFEFBMB$PNJTJØO
&OFTUFQFSÓPEPFMHPCJFSOPEPNJOJDB
OPFNJUFVOEFDSFUPSFDPOPDJFOEPBMB
$/# DPNP FOUJEBE BTFTPSB EFM QPEFS
FKFDVUJWPFONBUFSJBEFCJPÏUJDBZBMB
WF[TPMJDJUBOEPMBFMBCPSBDJØOEFVOSF
HMBNFOUPQBSBÏTUB
1PTUFSJPSNFOUFZIBTUBMBGFDIBMB$PNJ
TJØONFIBFMFHJEPDPNPTVQSFTJEFOUF
"DUJWJEBE BDBEÏNJDB */5&$ DPO
FM BQPZP EF MB $/# BTVNF FM SFUP EF
EBS DPOUJOVJEBE BM QSPDFTP BDBEÏNJDP
JOJDJBEPZMBO[BTV.BFTUSÓBFO#JPÏUJ
DBDPNPUÓUVMPQSPQJPFTUBOEPFOFTUF
NPNFOUP FO TV TFHVOEP QFSÓPEP DPO
VO HSVQP EF BMVNOPT QSPWFOJFOUFT EF
NÞMUMJQMFTEJTDJQMJOBTBmOFT&OMBNF
EJEBFORVFFTUPTQSPDFTPTTFGVFSPOEF
TBSSPMMBOEPMPTFHSFTBEPTTFJOUFHSBSPO
EFTEFMB$PNJTJØO/BDJPOBMEF#JPÏUJ
DBZFOMBTSFDJFOUFTFMFDDJPOFTRVFEØ
DPOTUJUVJEBVOBQMBUBGPSNBDPOGPSNBEB
QPSFHSFTBEPTZQSFTJEJEBQPS5PHBSNB
3PESÓHVF[
3FQSFTFOUBDJØO$PNPMB$/#FTZB
SFDPOPDJEB OBDJPOBM F JOUFSOBDJPOBM
NFOUF MBT SFMBDJPOFT DPO MB 014 IBO
TJEPUBOFTUSFDIBTRVFFTUBÞMUJNBBDUÞB
DPNP BTFTPSB Z TFEF EF EJDIB $PNJ
TJØO
1FSTQFDUJWBTEFMB#JPÏUJDBFO*CFSPBNÏSJDB
&OMBTBDUJWJEBEFTEF6/&4$0IFNPT
UFOJEP GSFDVFOUF SFQSFTFOUBDJØO UBOUP
FO NÞMUJQMFT FWFOUPT JOUFSOBDJPOBMFT
EPOEF TF IBO EJTDVUJEP TVT QSPQVFTUBT
SFMBUJWBTBCJPÏUJDBZEFSFDIPTIVNBOPT
DPNPFOFMQMBOPMPDBMDPOTVTFEFFO
FMQBÓT
&O TVT SFMBDJPOFT DPO FM HPCJFSOP MB
$/# IB TJEP MMBNBEB B IBDFS BTFTPSÓB
FOMB4FDSFUBSÓBEF4BMVEZFOFM$POTFKP
/BDJPOBMEF*OWFTUJHBDJPOFTFO4BMVE
$PNJTJØO $BSJCF×B EF #JPÏUJDB 3F
HJPOBMNFOUFTFMFIBEBEPWJHFODJBBMB
$PNJTJØO $BSJCF×B EF #JPÏUJDB BHSF
HÈOEPTFBMBNJTNB7FOF[VFMBBEFNÈT
EF1VFSUP3JDP$VCBZ3FQÞCMJDB%P
NJOJDBOB
"TQFDUPTMFHBMFT
-B $/# BQPZB TV NBSDP MFHBM FO TVT
FTUBUVUPT FTUBCMFDJEPT FO TV BTBNCMFB
EFMEFPDUVCSFEFMZTVSFDPOP
DJNJFOUPQPSQBSUFEFMQPEFSFKFDVUJWP
NFEJBOUFEFDSFUPEFMQSFTJEFOUF-FPOFM
'FSOÈOEF[
#BKPFTUBDPOTJEFSBDJØOMFHBMTFBNQMJB
FMNBSDPEFBDDJØOEFMBCJPÏUJDBBNQB
SBEBFOMB$/#RVFSFÞOFCBKPTVUF
DIPBUPEBQFSTPOBWJODVMBEBPJOUFSFTB
EBFOFMUFNB$PNPUBMMBCJPÏUJDBOBDF
ZFODVFOUSBVOQBOPSBNBIVÏSGBOPEF
MFHJTMBDJPOFTNPEFSOBTFOMPSFGFSFOUFB
MBWJEBPBUFNBTDPNPFMBCPSUPJOWFT
UJHBDJPOFTFOTFSFTIVNBOPTSFQSPEVD
DJØOBTJTUJEBFOUSFPUSPT
&OTFBQSVFCBMB-FZ(FOFSBMEF
PERSPETIVADELABIOETICAINDD
4BMVE MB DVBM SFTQBMEB MPT EFSFDIPT EF
MPTQBDJFOUFTZFOUSFFMMPToBVORVFTJO
MMBNBSMPQPSTVOPNCSFoFMEFSFDIPEF
MPTQBDJFOUFTBTFSJOGPSNBEPT"MUPDBS
FM UFNB CJPÏUJDP MP SFEVDF EF NBOFSB
FYDMVTJWBBMNVOEPEFMBTJOWFTUJHBDJP
OFT FO TFSFT IVNBOPT TF×BMBOEP FO
VOBSFGFSFODJBNVZBNQMJBRVFEFCFO
BDPHFSTFBMPTDØEJHPTJOUFSOBDJPOBMFTEF
ÏUJDBDPNP/VSFNCFSH)FMTJOLJFOUSF
PUSPT
-PTUFNBTWJODVMBEPTBMBWJEBTFYVBMZ
SFQSPEVDUJWB Z BM BCPSUP GVFSPO PCKFUP
EF HSBOEFT EFCBUFT Z QSFTJPOFT TPCSF
UPEP EF UJQP SFMJHJPTP MP RVF JNQJEJØ
RVF JOHSFTBSBO FO MB MFHJTMBDJØO DPO
OPNCSFQSPQJP&MBCPSUPQPSFKFNQMP
TF WJODVMB EF JONFEJBUP BM $ØEJHP 1F
OBMEFTEFFMNPNFOUPRVFTBODJPOBDPO
DÈSDFMBUPEBTMBTQFSTPOBTJNQMJDBEBT-P
DSJNJOBMJ[BQFSPBMBWF[EFKBFYDMVJEB
MBQPTJCJMJEBEEFMBCPSUPUFSBQÏVUJDP
-B HSBO QBSBEPKB EFM UFYUP FT RVF VOB
TPMB EF MBT NBUFSOJEBEFT EF MB DBQJUBM
MMFHØ B SFQPSUBS NÈT EF DBTPT
BMDBCPEFVOB×PMPTDVBMFTMBMFZOP
DPOUFNQMBOJTBODJPOBQPSRVFFTMÓDJUP
DPODMVJSMPTDPOMBJOUFODJØOEFTBMWBSMB
WJEBEFMBNBESF&TUPUSBKPDPNPDPO
TFDVFODJBRVFNVDIBTEFMBTFNCBSB[B
EBT JOUFSFTBEBT FO JOUFSSVNQJS FM FN
CBSB[P QPS FTB WÓB JOJDJBSBO NBOJPCSBT
BCPSUJWBTQBSBQPEFSPCUFOFSMBBUFODJØO
NÏEJDBZFMBNQBSPEFMBMFZ
:BFOZFOSFTQFDUJWBNFOUF
TF IBCÓBO FNJUJEP MFZFT SFGFSFOUFT B MB
EPOBDJØOEFØSHBOPT-FZ
ZTPCSF
EPOBDJØO Z USBTQMBOUF EF DØSOFBT -FZ
-BIJTUPSJBEFMBCJPÏUJDBFO3FQÞCMJDB%PNJOJDBOB.JHVFM4VB[P
%JDIPT DVFSQPT MFHBMFT TJHVFO
WJHFOUFTQFSPBÞOOPIBODBMBEPFOMB
QPCMBDJØO QSPEVDJFOEP MPT SFTVMUBEPT
FTQFSBEPT -MFWBSÈ UJFNQP NPEJmDBS MB
DVMUVSB EF MB EPOBDJØO ZB RVF FYJTUFO
NJUPTSFMJHJØOZDSFFODJBTRVFTFNVF
WFO FO FTUF NBSDP UBNQPDP IBZ VOB
DBNQB×B FmDB[ QBSB EFWFMBS FTUBT TV
QFSTUJDJPOFT
MBTÈSFBTEFJOWFTUJHBDJØOQPMÓUJDBZCJP
ÏUJDB
-B$/#IBFTUBEPCBTUBOUFEFTMJHBEBEF
FTUPTUFNBTQPSRVFOBDFNVZBMVOÓTP
OPEFFTUPTDBNCJPTZFMMBNJTNBDPNP
UBMOPUJFOFVOOPNCSFFOMBTPDJFEBE
OJMBCJPÏUJDBVOFTUBUVUPQSPQJPRVFTFB
TV DBSUB EF QSFTFOUBDJØO &T VO QSPDF
TPMFOUPEFJODPSQPSBDJØOBMBWJEBDJWJM
RVFZBFNQJF[BBUFOFSSFDPOPDJNJFOUP
&MQSPQJPNJOJTUSPEF4BMVEIBFODBSHB
EPBMB$/#IBDFSVOBQSPQVFTUBTPCSF
NFEJDBDJPOFT Z NBOFKP EF DBTPT QPS
FKFNQMPFMEFFNCBSB[PTNÞMUJQMFTTJO
TFS VOB PQDJØO CVTDBEB P EFTFBEB QPS
MPTQBESFT
1SPCBCMFNFOUF FM «SFB EF 4BMVE Z MB
4FDSFUBSÓBEF&TUBEPEF4BMVE1ÞCMJDBZ
"TJTUFODJB4PDJBM4&41"4
IBOTJEPFM
FTDFOBSJPEPOEFIBDSFDJEPZTFIBSFDP
OPDJEPBMBCJPÏUJDB:BIFNPTTF×BMBEP
DPNP IJUPTFM OBDJNJFOUP ZEFTBSSPMMP
EF VOB JOTUBODJB PmDJBM EF FWBMVBDJØO
CJPÏUJDBEFQSPUPDPMPTEFJOWFTUJHBDJØO
FOFM$POTFKP/BDJPOBMEF#JPÏUJDBFO
4BMVE $0/"#*04
MB BQBSJDJØO EF
BDÈQJUFTRVFMFHJUJNBOBMBCJPÏUJDBFOMB
MFZHFOFSBMEFTBMVEUBOUPQBSBMPDMÓOJ
DPDPNPFOFMDBTPEFMDPOTFOUJNJFOUP
JOGPSNBEPZFMSFTQFUPBMBEJHOJEBEZ
WBMPSFTFOMBJOWFTUJHBDJØO
&M$0/"#*04UJFOFVOBJEFOUJEBEMF
HBMRVFMFBDSFEJUBQBSBFWBMVBSUPEBTMBT
JOWFTUJHBDJPOFTFOTFSFTIVNBOPTEFTEF
MBQFSTQFDUJWBCJPÏUJDB$VFOUBDPOVOB
QSFTFODJB PmDJBM FO FM NFEJP Z DPO VO
HSVQP FRVJMJCSBEP EF QSPGFTJPOBMFT EF
PERSPETIVADELABIOETICAINDD
&HSFTBEPT Z QSPGFTPSFT EF MB .BFTUSÓB
FO #JPÏUJDB EF MB 6OJWFSTJEBE */5&$
IBOJOUFHSBEP$0/"#*04FOMBUBSFB
EF FWBMVBS FTUPT QSPUPDPMPT Z IBO DP
PQFSBEPFOMBGPSNBDJØOUÏDOJDBEFTVT
NJFNCSPT
%BEBT MBT GVFSUFT SBÓDFT SFMJHJPTBT EF MB
QPCMBDJØO Z FM QPEFS EF MBT DÞQVMBT SF
MJHJPTBT IBZ UFNBT OP UPDBEPT EFTEF FM
QVOUPEFWJTUBMFHBMUBOUPRVFFOFTUPT
NPNFOUPTIBZVOOVFWP$ØEJHP1SPDF
TBM1FOBMZUBNQPDPIBDFOJOHVOBDPODF
TJØOBMBCPSUPUFSBQÏVUJDPDSJNJOBMJ[BO
EPDVBMRVJFSBEFTVTGPSNBT-PNJTNP
TVDFEFDPOMBFVUBOBTJBIBOTVSHJEPBM
HVOBTWPDFTTPMJDJUBOEPRVFFMUFNBTFB
EFCBUJEPPMMFWBEPBM$POHSFTPTJOPCUF
OFSTFSFTVMUBEPTNÈTCJFOTJMFODJP
-B QSPQJB $/# IB QMBOUFBEP BCSJS FM
EFCBUF TJSWJFOEP EF QMBUBGPSNB QBSB MB
HFOFSBDJØOEFVOQFOTBNJFOUPTFDVMBS
QFSPOPTFIBQPEJEPQBTBSEFMBTJOUFO
DJPOFTEBEBMBQMVSBMJEBEEFTVTNJFN
CSPT
-BTJUVBDJØOBDUVBMEFMBCJPÏUJDB
FO3FQÞCMJDB%PNJOJDBOB
&OFTUPTNPNFOUPTDPOUBNPTDPOVOB
DJFSUB IJTUPSJB Z VO SFDPOPDJNJFOUP EF
1FSTQFDUJWBTEFMB#JPÏUJDBFO*CFSPBNÏSJDB
MB EJTDJQMJOB FO FM NFEJP EPNJOJDBOP
&YJTUFO TVCDPNJUÏT EFQFOEJFOUFT EF MB
$/# FO ÈSFBT DPNP NFEJP BNCJFOUF
DPNJUÏT EF ÏUJDB Z CJPÏUJDB FEVDBDJØO
FOUSFPUSBTEBOEPVOBWJTJØOJOUFSEJTDJ
QMJOBSJBEFMUFNB
&O FM ÈNCJUP BDBEÏNJDP B EJGFSFODJB
EF MPT JOJDJPT IBZ QPS MPT NFOPT TFJT
DBSSFSBTEF.FEJDJOBEFJHVBMOÞNFSP
EF VOJWFSTJEBEFT RVF IBO JNQMBOUBEP
MB CJPÏUJDB DPNP BTJHOBUVSB DPO NP
EBMJEBEFT QFEBHØHJDBT Z NFUPEPMØHJDBT
JOOPWBEPSBT-BVOJWFSTJEBEEFM&TUBEP
"VUØOPNBEF4BOUP%PNJOHP
IBSFB
MJ[BEPEJQMPNBEPTFOCJPÏUJDBQBSBTVT
QSPGFTPSFTMBTTPDJFEBEFTNÏEJDBTFTQF
DJBMJ[BEBTEFM$PMFHJP.ÏEJDPEPNJOJ
DBOPIBOJODMVJEPFMUFNBFOTVTDPO
HSFTPTBTÓDPNPFOPUSBTJOTUBODJBTEFM
NVOEPBDBEÏNJDPZMBTPDJFEBEDJWJM
5BOUP FM $FOUSP */5&$ EF #JPÏUJDB
DPNPMB$/#TPOSFGFSFOUFTPCMJHBEPT
EFM UFNB FO FM DPOUFYUP OBDJPOBM "D
UVBMNFOUF VOB HFOFSBDJØO VOB HFOF
SBDJØO EF QSPGFTJPOBMFT FTUÈ DVSTBOEP
MB .BFTUSÓB FO FM */5&$ TF FTUÈ BTF
TPSBOEP BM HPCJFSOP EPNJOJDBOP FO MB
IVNBOJ[BDJØOEFMPTTFSWJDJPTEFTBMVE
BDBCBO EF DFMFCSBSTF FMFDDJPOFT FO MB
$/#ZTVEJSFDUJWBFTUÈDPNQVFTUBQPS
FHSFTBEPTEFEJDIBNBFTUSÓBMPRVFDPO
mFSFNBZPSDBMJEBEBTVTFSWJDJP
1PS NFEJP EFM BQPZP EF PSHBOJTNPT
JOUFSOBDJPOBMFTIFNPTEFTBSSPMMBEPUB
MMFSFTEFGPSNBDJØOEFDPNJUÏTEFÏUJDB
BTJTUFODJBMFOFMJOUFSJPSEFMQBÓTZBTFTP
SÓBTFTQFDJBMJ[BEBTQBTBOEPQPSVOUBMMFS
JOUFSOBDJPOBMBVTQJDJBEPQPSMB014Z
PERSPETIVADELABIOETICAINDD
TV1SPHSBNBEF#JPÏUJDBTPCSFMBEJEÈD
UJDBEFMBFOTF×BO[BEFMBCJPÏUJDBFO3F
QÞCMJDB%PNJOJDBOB
/VFTUSPTTPDJPTZFHSFTBEPTIBODPOUSJ
CVJEPDPOVOBDFSWPCJCMJPHSÈmDPFOUSF
MPT RVF DPOUBNPT i#JPÏUJDB QBSB OVF
WPTw EF .JHVFM 4VB[P i$PBVUPSÓB FO
#JPÏUJDBQBSBMBTVTUFOUBCJMJEBEwEF"O
ESÏT 1FSBMUB Z .JHVFM 4VB[P i#JPÏUJDB
Z(FTUJØOEFMPT4FSWJDJPTEF4BMVEiEF
3BGBFM.POUFSP.JHVFM4VB[PZ'SBO
DJB 3FZOPTP Z i"EPMFTDFSÏ 6O OVFWP
NBSDPBYJPMØHJDPwEF.JHVFM4VB[P
4JCJFOFOFMNVOEPMFHJTMBUJWPMBCJPÏ
UJDBOPUJFOFBDUVBMNFOUFVOBQSFTFODJB
QVOUVBMFOMPTÞMUJNPTRVJODFB×PTIB
DSFDJEP FO MB GPSNBDJØO EF VOB NBTB
DSÓUJDBEFVOHSVQPEFFTQFDJBMJTUBTFO
FMUFNBZEFVOHFSNFOQPUFODJBMQBSB
EFTBSSPMMBSFMUFNBFOFMÈNCJUPQSPGF
TJPOBMZTPDJBM
4BCFNPT RVF MB CJPÏUJDB OP FT TØMP VO
JOTUSVNFOUP QBSB FM ÈSFB EF MB TBMVE
TJOPUBNCJÏOQBSBFMNVOEPEFMBTQSP
GFTJPOFTZTVJOUFSBDDJØODPOFMNVOEP
EFMPTWBMPSFT
&M JOWFOUBSJP BDUVBM EF MB CJPÏUJDB FO
3FQÞCMJDB %PNJOJDBOB UJFOF RVF DPO
UBCJMJ[BSTVTNBZPSFTMPHSPTFOFMÈNCJUP
BDBEÏNJDPDPOMBGPSNBDJØOEFQSPGF
TJPOBMFTQBSBFOUSBSFOFTUFQSPDFTPTP
DJBMZBQPSUFTFOFMÈNCJUPFTUBUBMQPS
RVF VOB WF[ MPHSBEB TV JODPSQPSBDJØO
MFHBMMB$/#GVFEFTJHOBEBDPNPBTF
TPSB EFM QPEFS FKFDVUJWP FO NBUFSJB EF
CJPÏUJDB5SFTHPCJFSOPTDPOTFDVUJWPTMF
IBOJEPEBOEPFTQBDJPMFHBMZBRVFFO
-BIJTUPSJBEFMBCJPÏUJDBFO3FQÞCMJDB%PNJOJDBOB.JHVFM4VB[P
MBQSÈDUJDBOPIBTJEPTPMJDJUBEPTVKVJ
DJPFYQFSUPNÈTRVFJOEJSFDUBNFOUFQPS
NFEJPEFMB4FDSFUBSÓBEF4BMVE
/VFTUSBIJTUPSJBIBIFDIPVOSFDPSSJEP
MØHJDPZEFVOBJOJDJBUJWBMFKBOB4JODFS
UF[BT IFNPT QPEJEP DPOTUSVJS VO QSP
ZFDUPRVFZBFMQBÓTSFDPOPDF
3FGFSFODJBT
"TPDJBDJØOEF#JPÏUJDB'VOEBNFOUBMZ$MÓOJDB
-B&EVDBDJØOFO#JPÏUJDBEFMPT
QSPGFTJPOBMFTTBOJUBSJPTFO&TQB×B.BESJE
$PNJTJØO /BDJPOBM EF #JPÏUJDB &TUBUVUPT 4BOUP %PNJOHP 3FQÞCMJDB
%PNJOJDBOB
$PVDFJSP"
#JPÏUJDBQBSB$MÓOJDPT.BESJE&EJUPSJBM5SJBDBTUFMB
'BDVMUBEEF&EVDBDJØO6OJWFSTJEBE&M#PTRVF
#JPÏUJDB0SJHFOZ5FOEFODJBT
#PHPUÈ6OJWFSTJEBEB%JTUBODJB1SPHSBNBEF#JPÏUJDB
(SBDJB%
1SPGFTJØONÏEJDBJOWFTUJHBDJØOZKVTUJDJBTBOJUBSJB#PHPUÈ&EJUPSJBM
&M#ÞIP
1JDIBSEP"
3FTQPOTBCJMJEBEDJWJMZQFOBMEFMNÏEJDP4BOUP%PNJOHP&EJUPSB
*NQSFUVS4"
1SFTJEFODJBEFMB3FQÞCMJDB%PNJOJDBOB
3FHMBNFOUPTEFMB-FZ(FOFSBMEF4BMVE
7PMVNFO**$&3444BOUP%PNJOHP3FQÞCMJDB%PNJOJDBOB
3FCPSFEP+
*OTFSDJØOEFMPTDPNJUÏTEF²UJDBFOMPT)PTQJUBMFT1ÞCMJDPT#VFOPT
"JSFT
4FDSFUBSÓB EF &TUBEP EF 4BMVE 1ÞCMJDB -FZ (FOFSBM EF 4BMVE EF MB 3FQÞCMJDB
%PNJOJDBOB
4FDSFUBSÓB EF &TUBEP EF 4BMVE 1ÞCMJDB 3FHMBNFOUP )PTQJUBMBSJP EF MB 3FQÞCMJDB
%PNJOJDBOB
4VB[P.
#JPÏUJDBQBSBOVFWPT4BOUP%PNJOHP*OTUJUVUP5FDOPMØHJDPEF4BOUP
%PNJOHP
4VB[P.
"EPMFTDFSÏVOOVFWPNBSDPBYJPMØHJDP4BOUP%PNJOHP*NQSFOUB-B
6OJØO
PERSPETIVADELABIOETICAINDD
PERSPETIVADELABIOETICAINDD
1ĒģĥĖ***
$VFTUJPOFTFTQFDÓmDBTSFMJHJØOZNVKFSFT
PERSPETIVADELABIOETICAINDD
PERSPETIVADELABIOETICAINDD
#JPÏUJDBZSFMJHJØOFO"NÏSJDB-BUJOB
.ÈSDJP'BCSJEPT"OKPT
-
BSFMBDJØOFOUSFCJPÏUJDBZSFMJHJØOFT
VOUFNBJOUSJHBOUFEJWJEJEPFONV
DIBTQSFHVOUBT6TBOEPFTUFUÓUVMPEFTFP
NPEFTUBNFOUF EJTDVUJS BQFOBT BMHVOPT
BTQFDUPT EPOEF MB SFMJHJØO TF FOUSFMB[B
DPOMBCJPÏUJDBFOFTUBGBTFEFDPOTPMJ
EBDJØOEFÏTUBFO"NÏSJDB-BUJOB$PO
MPTPKPTEFVOUFØMPHPDSJTUJBOPNJUFO
EFODJBFTBDFOUVBSMBTDPOUSJCVDJPOFTEF
MBSFMJHJØOBMBCJPÏUJDBQFSPVOBNJSBEB
DSÓUJDBOPTFPMWJEBSÓBEFMPTQVOUPTEPO
EFFTUÈOFOEFTBDVFSEPZTFJOUFSSPHBO
4JOFNCBSHPMBTHSBOEFTQSFHVOUBTQBSB
BNCBT WJFOFO EF VO NPWJNJFOUP NÈT
BNQMJP EF DBSÈDUFS DVMUVSBM RVF FYJHF
VOB SFEFmOJDJØO EF MBT SB[POFT EF MBT
ÏUJDBTZMPTGVOEBNFOUPTEFMBSFMJHJØO
&O WJSUVE EF FTUP QBSB MBT EPT PDVSSF
TJNVMUÈOFBNFOUF VO DBNCJP FO MPT FT
QBDJPTTPDJBMFTZDVMUVSBMFT
&OUJFOEPRVFVOQVOUPEFQBSUJEBTFSÓB
EFTDVCSJS MPT EFTBGÓPT DPNVOFT Z EFT
QVÏTDPNQSPCBSFORVÏHSBEPQVFEFO
USBCBKBS KVOUBT QBSB FOGSFOUBS MPT SFUPT
EFMBWJEBBDUVBM
-BCJPÏUJDBDPNPÏUJDBFOHFOFSBMQSF
TFOUB NVDIBT DPSSJFOUFT Z UFOEFODJBT
EF VOB NBOFSB FTQFDÓmDB MP NJTNP MB
EJWFSTJEBESFMJHJPTB&OFTUFFTUVEJPFT
PERSPETIVADELABIOETICAINDD
UPZ JODMJOBEP B QSFHVOUBSNF BDFSDB EF
MB DMBTF EF CJPÏUJDB RVF TFB BQSPQJBEB
BMDPOUFYUPMBUJOPBNFSJDBOP:DVBOEP
IBCMP EF SFMJHJØO NF SFmFSP QBSUJDV
MBSNFOUFBMDSJTUJBOJTNPFOVOBMFDUVSB
UFPMØHJDBDBUØMJDBQFSPBCJFSUBBMEFTB
GÓPEFMBSFOPWBDJØORVFFTDPNÞOBMBT
EJWFSTBTDPOGFTJPOFTSFMJHJPTBT5BNCJÏO
JOUFOUBSÏDPOTJEFSBSMBSJRVF[BEFUSBEJ
DJPOFTSFMJHJPTBTRVFQSFDFEFOBMDSJTUJB
OJTNPFOFMDPOUJOFOUF
i1VFOUFTBMGVUVSPwQVFOUFT
DPNVOFT
4J DPOTJEFSBNPT MBT QSFPDVQBDJPOFT EF
1PUUFS SFTQFDUP EF MB TVQFSWJ
WFODJBEFMBIVNBOJEBEMBCJPÏUJDBFO
DVFOUSBFOMBTSFMJHJPOFTFOHFOFSBMBMHP
RVF FMMBT FTUÈO BDPTUVNCSBEBT B IBDFS
QFOTBS BDFSDB EF MB WJEB Z DPOTJEFSBSMB
FOSFMBDJØODPOFMGVUVSP"VORVFQSPO
UPBQBSF[DBOFOPSNFTEJGFSFODJBTFOMP
RVFDPODJFSOFBMBTNBOFSBTEFPDVQBSTF
EFFTUBQSFHVOUBOPTFQVFEFOFHBSMB
JNQPSUBODJB EF FTUF IFDIP -MFHB B TFS
NÈT QPEFSPTP BVO DVBOEP TF QFSDJCF
RVFMBTSFMJHJPOFTQBSUJDJQBOBDUJWBNFO
UFFOMBDPOTUSVDDJØODVMUVSBMDPOMBDVBM
MBHFOUFFOUJFOEFFMNVOEPMBWJEBZTV
IJTUPSJBIBDJBFMGVUVSP&TUFFTUBNCJÏO
1FSTQFDUJWBTEFMB#JPÏUJDBFO*CFSPBNÏSJDB
FMDPOUFYUPFOEPOEFMBCJPÏUJDBJOTFSUB
TVT JOUFSSPHBOUFT .JFOUSBT MBT SFMJHJP
OFT QFSTJTUFO FO FTUB UBSFB MB CJPÏUJDB
EFCJFSBDPOTJEFSBSMP
%FTEF FTUB QPTJDJØO FTQFDÓmDB "NÏSJ
DB-BUJOBSFDJCJØEFTVTBCPSÓHFOFTVOB
IFSFODJBDVMUVSBMZSFMJHJPTBFYUSFNBEB
NFOUFSJDB&OEJDIBIFSFODJBFODPOUSB
NPTMPTWBMPSFTRVFMBCJPÏUJDBBDUVBMDP
NJFO[B B EFTBSSPMMBS FTQFDJBMNFOUF FO
MBNBOFSBDPNPUSBUBNPTMBJOUFHSBDJØO
EFMPTTFSFTIVNBOPTFOFMTJTUFNBNÈT
BNQMJP EFM NVOEP Z DPO FM BNCJFOUF
-BTDVMUVSBTNBZBTZB[UFDBTQPSFKFN
QMPEFTBSSPMMBSPOTJTUFNBTEFDPNQSFO
TJØO JODMVZFOEP QSÈDUJDBT DVMUVSBMFT Z
SFMJHJPTBTFOMPTDVBMFTMPTTFSFTIVNB
OPTTFJOUFHSBOZEJTGSVUBODPNPQBSUJ
DJQBOUFTEFFTUFNVOEPNÈTBNQMJP%F
MBNJTNBNBOFSBNVDIPTPUSPTQVFCMPT
BNFSJOEJPT TPTUJFOFO IBTUB IPZ VOB
DPNQSFOTJØONÈTBCBSDBEPSBEFMBWJEB
4VTDPODMVTJPOFTÏUJDBTMMFHBSPOBTFSFm
DJFOUFTFODVJEBSZQSPUFHFSFMBNCJFOUF
Z DVMUJWBS SFMBDJPOFT TPDJBMFT GBWPSBCMFT
BMBWJEB/PTFQVFEFTFSUBOJOPDFOUF
F JHOPSBS BTJNFUSÓBT F JOKVTUJDJBT FO MBT
DVMUVSBT Z SFMJHJPOFT EF MPT BCPSÓHFOFT
QFSPTVT TJTUFNBTTPO UBNCJÏO QSPGVO
EBNFOUF BENJSBCMFT FO HBSBOUJ[BS MB
FRVJEBEZDVMUJWBSMBSFDJQSPDJEBEFOMBT
SFMBDJPOFT
4JOEVEBIPZIBDFNPTGSFOUFBVOBSB
EJDBMUSBOTGPSNBDJØODVMUVSBM5PEBTMBT
SFGFSFODJBT TF QPOFO FO DVFTUJØO Z MBT
DVMUVSBTPSJHJOBSJBTMPTTJTUFNBTSFMJHJP
TPTBCPSÓHFOFTFOFTQFDJBM
TPOFOHSBO
NFEJEB TPCSFQBTBEBT QPS VOB DVMUVSB
PERSPETIVADELABIOETICAINDD
IFHFNØOJDBNBSDBEBQPSMBDJFODJBZMB
UFDOPMPHÓB 1FSP QVFEF EFDJSTF RVF FO
FMJNBHJOBSJPUPEBWÓBQFSNBOFDFMBTB
CJEVSÓBEFTVTPSHBOJ[BDJPOFT-BCJPÏUJ
DBBÞOFTNVZKPWFOQBSBIBDFSVOBMFD
UVSBRVFTFCFOFmDJFEFFTUBTBCJEVSÓB
4JO FNCBSHP TVSHFO BMHVOBT TF×BMFT
FOUSF PUSBT MB DBQBDJEBE EF MB CJPÏUJDB
QBSBIBDFSVOBDSÓUJDBEFMBEFWBTUBDJØO
EFM BNCJFOUF Z EF QPTUVMBSMB DPNP VO
SFRVJTJUPÏUJDPQBSBEFGFOEFSMP
-B DPOUSJCVDJØO EFM DSJTUJBOJTNP FO
"NÏSJDB-BUJOBUPNBVOBGPSNBJODJFSUB
QPSRVFTVDFEFFOVODMJNBEFDPORVJTUB
ZEFDPMPOJ[BDJØOFDPOØNJDBZQPMÓUJDB
&O FTUF DPOUFYUP BMHVOPT BOBMJTUBT OP
UFNFO DPOTJEFSBS MB BQBSJDJØO DSJTUJBOB
FO FM DPOUJOFOUF DPNP iDPORVJTUB FT
QÓSJUVBMw4VFTT
-BDSÓUJDBBFTF
QSPDFTPGVFEJTDVUJEBFYUFOTBNFOUFDPO
PDBTJØOEFMPTB×PTEFMBMMFHBEBEF
$PMØO B MBT "NÏSJDBT &O FTUB
Z PUSBT DSÓUJDBT B MPT TJTUFNBT SFMJHJPTPT
WFNPT BMHP JHVBMNFOUF GSFDVFOUF FO
PSHBOJ[BDJPOFTIVNBOBTVOBBTJNFUSÓB
FOUSFMPRVFTFFOTF×BZMPRVFTFQSBD
UJDB.ÈTBEFMBOUFQPESFNPTSFWJTBSFTUF
BTQFDUP QBSB DPOTJEFSBS MB SFOPWBDJØO
UFPMØHJDBFOÏQPDBTSFDJFOUFT
4JO FNCBSHP NÈT BMMÈ EF MBT TPNCSBT
PBÞOSPEFBEPQPSFMMBTFMDSJTUJBOJTNP
TFDPOWJFSUFFOVOJNQPSUBOUFBNCJFOUF
QBSBMBCJPÏUJDBNPEFSOBFOFMDPOUFYUP
MBUJOPBNFSJDBOP1PSNFEJPEFMDSJTUJB
OJTNP TF DPOTPMJEB MB ÏUJDB EF MB WJEB
JOTQJSBEBQPSVOIPSJ[POUFNÈTBMMÈEF
MBNVFSUF-PTNBOEBNJFOUPTEFMBNPS
Z FM SFTQFDUP B MB WJEB QFSTJTUFO DPNP
#JPÏUJDBZSFMJHJØOFO"NÏSJDB-BUJOB.ÈSDJP'BCSJEPT"OKPT
SFGFSFODJBT QBSB MBT SFMBDJPOFT Z TPCSF
UPEP MB JNBHFO TVGSJEPSB EFM TBMWBEPS
DSJTUJBOPTFSFQJUFFOFMTVGSJNJFOUPEF
MBHFOUFDPMPOJ[BEB"VORVFMBTPMVDJP
OFTSFMBDJPOBMFTQBSBFMTVGSJSUFOHBOVO
DBSÈDUFS BTJTUFODJBM QSPEVDFO VOB TFO
TBDJØOEFTPMJEBSJEBEZDPNQBTJØO)PZ
TFSÓBEJGÓDJMFOUFOEFSQSPGVOEBNFOUFFM
BMDBODFEFMPTDPODFQUPTEFiEJHOJEBEw
Z iTPMJEBSJEBEw FO "NÏSJDB -BUJOB TJO
FDIBSNBOPEFMPTDPODFQUPTSFMJHJPTPT
RVFTPOQBSUFEFFTBDPOTUSVDDJØO
%FTEF VOB QFSTQFDUJWB UFØSJDB FM DSJT
UJBOJTNP EF JOTQJSBDJØO DBUØMJDB BQPS
UB MPT NBOVBMFT EF UFPMPHÓB NPSBM RVF
DPOUJFOFOOFDFTBSJBNFOUFMBQSPUFDDJØO
EFMBWJEB"VORVFHFOFSBMNFOUFSFQSP
EV[DBOMPTNBOVBMFTFVSPQFPTZTFSFT
USJOKBOCÈTJDBNFOUFBMDMFSPIBDFOOF
DFTBSJBTJOFNCBSHPVOBSFnFYJØOÏUJDB
BDFSDB EF MBT DVFTUJPOFT SFMBDJPOBEBT
DPOMBWJEB"TÓMBMMFHBEBEFMBCJPÏUJDB
NPEFSOBFO"NÏSJDB-BUJOBFODPOUSBSÈ
QBSUJDVMBSNFOUF FOUSF FM DMFSP VOB SF
nFYJØOÏUJDBTPCSFMBWJEBUFØSJDBNFOUF
BMJNFOUBEBZGPSNVMBEBBVORVFEFOUSP
EFTVTMÓNJUFTFTQFDÓmDPT
&TBNJTNBUSBEJDJØOSFnFYJWBIBQFSNJ
UJEPMBFYQMPSBDJØORVFPDVSSFUBNCJÏO
BDUVBMNFOUF EF BMHVOPT EJÈMPHPT EFM
1BQB1ÓP9*
DPOMPTEPD
UPSFTZMPTQSPGFTJPOBMFTEFMBTBMVEEFTV
UJFNQPQBSUJDVMBSNFOUFBDFSDBEFUFNBT
DPNPMBFVUBOBTJBZFMNPSJS1FSNJUF
JHVBMNFOUF FOUFOEFS mHVSBT DPNP MB
EFM UFØMPHP BMFNÈO #FSOIBSE )ÊSJOH
RVFTFDPOWJFSUFFOVOBSFGFSFODJBQBSB
FMEJÈMPHPUFPMØHJDPDPOMPTQSPHSFTPTEF
MBNFEJDJOBFOMPTB×PTZ
PERSPETIVADELABIOETICAINDD
4JOQSFQPOFSNFIBDFSVOBTÓOUFTJTIJT
UØSJDBDPOFTUPTQPDPTCPTRVFKPTEFTFP
TPMBNFOUF SFDPSEBS DØNP MB SFMJHJØO
oEFOUSPEFMPTQSPDFTPTDVMUVSBMFTQP
MÓUJDPT Z FDPOØNJDPTo DPOUSJCVZF B MB
GPSNBDJØO EF VO FUIPT QBSB MB CJPÏUJDB
NPEFSOB FO "NÏSJDB -BUJOB &O HSBO
NFEJEB MPT iQVFOUFT QBSB FM GVUVSPw
RVFFTBCJPÏUJDBJOUFOUBDPOTUSVJSUJFOFO
WBSJPTBTQFDUPTDPNVOFTDPOMBSFMJHJØO
RVFEFCFOTFSDPOTJEFSBEPT
{&YJTUFVODPOnJDUPFOUSFMB
SB[ØOZMBSFMJHJØOFOMBCJPÏUJDB
-PT BSHVNFOUPT UFØSJDPT EF MB CJPÏUJDB
DVFTUJPOBO TVT SFMBDJPOFT DPO MB SFMJ
HJØONJFOUSBTMBSFMJHJØOTJHVFMBGFMB
CJPÏUJDB TJHVF MB SB[ØO 1PS MP NFOPT
FTBEJWFSHFODJBFOTVTSBÓDFTMMFWBSÓBBMB
CJPÏUJDBBEJTUJOHVJSSBEJDBMNFOUFFOUSF
VOB CJPÏUJDB MBJDB Z PUSB SFMJHJPTB UFO
ESÓBO TJNJMJUVEFT P EJWFSHFODJBT FO MP
RVF DPODJFSOF B TV TJTUFNB EF SFHMBT
QFSP FO TVT CBTFT TFSÓBO TJFNQSF iFY
USB×PT NPSBMFTw &TB DVFTUJØO QBSFDF
DSVDJBM QBSB TV SFMBDJØO NVUVB &GFD
UJWBNFOUF MB DVFTUJØO TF EFTEPCMB FO
EPTQSFTVQVFTUPTMBGFFTEJTUBOUFEFMB
SB[ØOZMBSB[ØOFTUÈTFQBSBEBEFNPUJ
WBDJPOFTFTQÓSJUVBMFTPEFMBGF1FSP{FO
RVÏHSBEPPNFEJEBTPOWFSEBEFTFTUPT
TVQVFTUPT &TDJFSUPRVFFMDSJTUJBOJTNPBMSFWFMBS
TVFYQFSJFODJBEFMBGFUJFOFVOBMBSHB
IJTUPSJB EF EJWFSTPT MVHBSFT DPNP QBSB
NPTUSBS MB SB[ØO FO MBT DSFFODJBT Z MBT
DSFFODJBTFOMBSB[ØO&OTVJOJDJPEFCJ
EPBMDPOUFYUPDVMUVSBMEPOEFOBDJØFM
DSJTUJBOJTNPGVFNBSDBEPQPSVOÏOGBTJT
1FSTQFDUJWBTEFMB#JPÏUJDBFO*CFSPBNÏSJDB
FOFMTFHVJNJFOUPEFM.BFTUSPUBOUPFO
TVTQSÈDUJDBTEFWJEBDPNPFOMPTIPSJ
[POUFTEFTJHOJmDBEP1FSPNVZQSPOUP
UPNBDPOUBDUPDPOFMQFOTBNJFOUPmMP
TØmDPHSJFHPMPRVFMBPCMJHBBDMBSJmDBS
MBT SB[POFT EF MB GF QBSB UPNBS OVFWBT
SVUBT "VORVF BMHVOPT BVUPSFT &OHFM
IBSEU
FOQBSUJDVMBSBSHVNFOUBO
DPOUSB FTUF BDFSDBNJFOUP FM DSJTUJBOJT
NP QBSUJDVMBSNFOUF FO 0DDJEFOUF
DPNJFO[B B GPSNVMBS EBUPT EF MB GF FO
VOBJOUFSBDDJØOÓOUJNBDPOMBmMPTPGÓB
&OUSF UBOUPT QFOTBEPSFT JNQPSUBOUFT
TF EFTUBDBO 4BO "HVTUÓO Z
4BOUP5PNÈTEF"RVJOP
"HVTUÓO SFGPSNBOEP MB IFSFODJB EFM
QFOTBNJFOUPHSJFHPDPOUSJCVZØEFDJEJ
EBNFOUFBMBiTÓOUFTJTEFVOBNFUBGÓTJDB
EF MB OBUVSBMF[B DPO VOB NFUBGÓTJDB EF
MB MJCFSUBE QVFTUP RVF MB MJCFSUBE QPS
NFEJP EFM DSJTUJBOJTNP SFDPOWJFSUF MB
NBUFSJBNJTNBEFMBmMPTPGÓBw0MJWFJSB
"RVJOPTFEFTUBDBEFCJEPBMB
TÓOUFTJTEFTVFMBCPSBDJØOUFPMØHJDBRVF
CVTDBVOBDPNQSFOTJØOEFMBUPUBMJEBE
EFMPTTFSFTEFMNVOEPZEFTVSFMBDJØO
DPOFMUSBTDFOEFOUF5PNÈTFTUBCMFDFVO
EJÈMPHPQSPGVOEPDPOMPTQFOTBEPSFTFO
HFOFSBMZQBSUJDVMBSNFOUFDPOFMQFO
TBNJFOUP BHVTUJOP Z MB mMPTPGÓB BSJTUP
UÏMJDB0MJWFJSB
$POP
DJEP QPS TVT GSBTFT CJFO FMBCPSBEBT ZB
FO FM TJHMP 7 "HVTUÓO BmSNBCB i-FKPT
EFOPTPUSPTQFOTBSRVFMBGFOPTJNQF
MFBSFDIB[BSPQBSBSEFCVTDBSMBSB[ØO
QPSRVF OP QPESÓBNPT OJ TJRVJFSB DSFFS
TJOTFSSBDJPOBMFTw&OOVFTUSPUJFNQP
FM1BQB#FOFEJDUP97*
FOVO
EJTDVSTPBMBDPNVOJEBEDJFOUÓmDBEFMB
PERSPETIVADELABIOETICAINDD
6OJWFSTJEBEEF3FHFOTCVSH"MFNBOJB
EFDMBSBCBiOPBDUVBSTFHÞOMBSB[ØOOP
BDUVBS TFHÞO FM MPHPT FT DPOUSBSJP B MB
OBUVSBMF[BEF%JPTw
-B IJTUPSJB NVFTUSB MBT UFOTJPOFT RVF
TJHVFO B MBT NBOFSBT DPODSFUBT EF MMF
WBS FTB JOUFSBDDJØO &MMBT IBO PDVSSJEP
ZIBDFOEJGÓDJMUPEBWÓBFOOVFTUSPTEÓBT
FMEJÈMPHPEFMBGFDSJTUJBOBDPOFMQFO
TBNJFOUPNPEFSOP1FSPFMDSJTUJBOJTNP
OPTFSFTUSJOHFBMPTHSVQPTRVFSFDIB[BO
MBSBDJPOBMJEBEQPSRVFTFEFTBSSPMMBQFS
DFQUJCMFNFOUFFOPUSPTFOUJEP%FVOB
NBOFSBBÞONÈTBNQMJBMBJOUFSBDDJØO
FOUSF GF Z SB[ØO TF UPNB FO OVFTUSPT
EÓBTDPNPVOBJOUFSSPHBDJØOOPTØMPB
MBT SFMJHJPOFT TJOP UBNCJÏO B MB SB[ØO
NPEFSOB DPNP EFNVFTUSB CJFO FOUSF
PUSPT BVUPSFT . 0MJWFJSB /P
EJTDVUJSFNPTBRVÓMBTEFOTBTDVFTUJPOFT
RVFFMUFNBJNQMJDBQFSPEFTFPTVHFSJS
RVF MB GF Z MB SB[ØO OP TPO OFDFTBSJB
NFOUF iFYUSB×PT NPSBMFTw FYDFQUP FO
MBTDPZVOUVSBTRVFJNQFMFOTVTSFTQFDUJ
WPTEJTDVSTPTFOTFOUJEPTEJTUJOUPT
&MDSJTUJBOJTNPFO"NÏSJDB-BUJOBQBS
UJDJQBEFFTBBNQMJBFGFSWFTDFODJBEFMB
GFRVFCVTDBSB[POFT-BUFPMPHÓBEFMB
MJCFSBDJØOoGPSNVMBEBBQBSUJSEFo
FT VOB FYQSFTJØO DMBSB EF FTF EJÈMPHP
DPNP WFSFNPT NÈT BEFMBOUF 4VT PQJ
OJPOFTZQSPQVFTUBTQBSFDFODPOUSJCVJS
QFSDFQUJCMFNFOUF FO BMHVOBT SVUBT RVF
MBCJPÏUJDBMBUJOPBNFSJDBOBTJHVFFTQF
DJBMNFOUFFOTVSFDFQUJWJEBEBUFNBTTP
DJBMFTZBMBTDVFTUJPOFTQFSTJTUFOUFTRVF
MBEFTBGÓBO
#JPÏUJDBZSFMJHJØOFO"NÏSJDB-BUJOB.ÈSDJP'BCSJEPT"OKPT
3FMJHJØOZCJPÏUJDBFOVO
DPOUFYUPEFJOKVTUJDJBT
QFSTJTUFOUFT
3FMJHJØOZCJPÏUJDBOPTFQVFEFOFOUFO
EFS FO FM DPOUFYUP MBUJOPBNFSJDBOP TJO
DPOTJEFSBSVOBIJTUPSJBNBSDBEBQPSJO
KVTUJDJBTTPDJBMFTQSPGVOEBT.FODJPOB
NPTZBMBFYQFSJFODJBEFMDPMPOJBMJTNP
&TDJFSUPRVFOPTFQVFEFSFEVDJSTØMPB
TVTBTQFDUPTOFHBUJWPTQFSPFTEJGÓDJMPM
WJEBSMBTNBSDBTEFMBTBTJNFUSÓBTTPDJBMFT
QSPGVOEBTRVFTFEFSJWBOEFÏTUF&MWFS
EBEFSPHFOPDJEJPBMDVBMTFIBTPNFUJEP
B MBT HFOUFT BCPSÓHFOFT MB FYQMPUBDJØO
EFMUSBCBKPFTDMBWJ[BEPMBWPSBDJEBEDPO
MB DVBM FM DPMPOJBMJTNP MMFHB BM DPOUJ
OFOUFQBSBFYQMPUBSTVBCVOEBODJBTPO
BMHVOPTQVOUPTTBMJFOUFTRVFNBSDBOMB
IJTUPSJBZDSFBOVOBQFTBEBIFSFODJBDVM
UVSBMRVFBMDBO[BOVFTUSPUJFNQP4VFTT
$IBTUFFO
"TÓ FM DPOUFYUP MBUJOPBNFSJDBOP EF
UBOUBDPSEJBMJEBEBMFHSÓBZDFMFCSBDJØO
QSFTFOUB BM NJTNP UJFNQP VOB JMJNJ
UBEB DPSSVQDJØO F JOKVTUJDJBT TPDJBMFT
RVF BGFDUBO EJSFDUBNFOUF MBT DPOEJDJP
OFTEFWJEBEFMBHFOUFZTVTBMVEIB
CJUBDJØO FEVDBDJØO USBCBKP TBMBSJPT Z
FTQFSBO[B EF WJEB &T TJOUPNÈUJDP RVF
QPSMPNFOPTMBNJUBEEFMBTQPCMBDJP
OFT QPS EFCBKP EF MB MÓOFB EF QPCSF[B
FO "NÏSJDB -BUJOB TFBO BCPSÓHFOFT P
BGSPEFTDFOEJFOUFT &M #BODP *OUFSBNF
SJDBOP EF %FTBSSPMMP #*%
DPODMVZFRVFiMBQPCSF[BEFMPTHSVQPT
TPDJBMFT FYDMVJEPT FT QFSNBOFOUF Z OP
USBOTJUPSJBw"NÏSJDB-BUJOBOPFTDJFS
UBNFOUF VO DPOUJOFOUF QPCSF TJOP VO
DPOUJOFOUFEFJOKVTUJDJBTQSPGVOEBT-BT
PERSPETIVADELABIOETICAINDD
BTJNFUSÓBTQVFEFOUBNCJÏOSFnFKBSTFFO
MBTSFMBDJPOFTJOUFSOBDJPOBMFTVOBMBSHB
IJTUPSJB EF EFQFOEFODJB EFVEBT JOUFS
OBDJPOBMFTZQSPNFTBTOVODBSFBMJ[BEBT
EFFTUBSiFOEFTBSSPMMPw-BBDUVBMJEBE
ÏQPDB EF ÏOGBTJT FO MB BVUPOPNÓB BM
BGFDUBS B TPDJFEBEFT EFCJMJUBEBT FO UÏS
NJOPTEFDJVEBEBOÓBFTBMmOBMOFPMJ
CFSBMJTNP RVF TF PMWJEB UPUBMNFOUF EF
MBT QFSTPOBT Z MFHJUJNB JOKVTUJDJBT -B
WJPMFODJBBVNFOUBZIBZVOBSFEVDDJØO
EFMBDPOmBO[BFOUSFMBHFOUFZFOUSFMBT
JOTUJUVDJPOFT&TJNQPSUBOUFOPPMWJEBS
TFEFFTBSFBMJEBEBVORVFBRVÓOPFTMV
HBSQBSBIBDFSMBNÈTFYQMÓDJUB
{$ØNPMBUFPMPHÓBEFMBMJCFSBDJØOZMB
CJPÏUJDBBDUÞBOEFTEFGVFSBZEFTEFEFO
USPEFFTBSFBMJEBE -BQSJNFSBBDFOUÞB
EFOUSP EF MB FYQFSJFODJB SFMJHJPTB MB
QSFHVOUBTPCSFMBDPIFSFODJBFOUSFMBGF
QSPGFTBEB Z MBT QSÈDUJDBT EF MB WJEB TP
DJBM:IBCMBFOUPODFTDPOJOEJHOBDJØO
EFVOBSFBMJEBEGPSNBEBQPSJOKVTUJDJBT
TPDJBMFTFJODMVTPSFMJHJPTBT4VBDDJØO
TF FOUJFOEF EFOUSP EF VO QSPDFTP NÈT
BNQMJPZNVOEJBMFOMPRVFDPODJFSOFB
NBOFSBTEFDPOPDFSMBSFBMJEBE/PQSF
HVOUBNPTTJMBUFPMPHÓBDSJTUJBOBJOUFSBD
UÞBDPOMBTDJFODJBTZQBSUJDVMBSNFOUF
DPOMBmMPTPGÓBTJOPDVÈMFTTPOMBTmMP
TPGÓBT Z DJFODJBT DPO MBT RVF EJBMPHB Z
B QBSUJS EF MBT DVBMFT DPOTUSVZF FM GVO
EBNFOUP SBDJPOBM EF MB GF -B UFPMPHÓB
QFSDJCFRVFOPTFQVFEFEFTFONBTDBSBS
MBSFEEFMBIJTUPSJBIVNBOBZEFMBTJO
KVTUJDJBT TPDJBMFT TPMBNFOUF DPO mMPTP
GÓBTFTFODJBMJTUBT&OUPODFTTFBQSPYJNB
BMBTmMPTPGÓBTDBQBDFTEFEFTFONBTDBSBS
NÈT ÈHJMNFOUF MBT FTUSVDUVSBT JOKVTUBT
1FSTQFDUJWBTEFMB#JPÏUJDBFO*CFSPBNÏSJDB
OP QFSDJCJEBT QPS PUSPT BDFSDBNJFOUPT
UBNCJÏO DBQBDFT EF DPOUSJCVJS FO VOB
ÏQPDB NBSDBEB QPS UFOEFODJBT JOEJWJ
EVBMJTUBTZEFQFSDJCJSMPTWÓODVMPTJOOF
HBCMFTFOUSFMBJOUFSTVCKFUJWJEBEIVNB
OBZTVTDPNQSPNJTPTTPDJBMFT
/PFTEJGÓDJMQFSDJCJSRVFFTFQBTPUFP
MØHJDPUBNCJÏOTFSFMBDJPOBGVFSUFNFOUF
DPOMBDPOTUSVDDJØOEFMPTGVOEBNFOUPT
EFMBCJPÏUJDBRVFTFUSBEVDFFODVFTUJP
OBSMPTDPODFQUPTDPOMPTRVFTFBDFSDB
BMBSFBMJEBE$VBOEPFMQSJODJQJBMJTNP
OPSUFBNFSJDBOP DPNFO[Ø B TFS DSJUJDB
EPNFQJEJFSPORVFQSFTFOUBTFFTBPQJ
OJØO MBUJOPBNFSJDBOB Z UFPMØHJDB QBSB
FOSJRVFDFS MPT GVOEBNFOUPT EF MB CJP
ÏUJDB"OKPT
1FSPUBMFT
DPOUSJCVDJPOFT UBNCJÏO FNFSHFO FO MB
NFUPEPMPHÓBQBSBBDFSDBSTFBUFNBTFT
QFDÓmDPT DPNP TVDFEF FO MBT MFDUVSBT
RVF1FTTJOJIBDFBDFSDBEFMBEJTUBOBTJB
ZMBFVUBOBTJB
&OFTFTFOUJEPMBUFPMPHÓBMBUJOPBNFSJ
DBOBQPSMPNFOPTDPNPFMFNFOUPEF
DPOTPMJEBDJØOIBDPOUSJCVJEPBMBGPS
NBDJØO EF MB CJPÏUJDB MBUJOPBNFSJDBOB
)BBZVEBEPDJFSUBNFOUFBHBSBOUJ[BSMB
TVmDJFOUFJOEJHOBDJØOÏUJDBGSFOUFBJO
KVTUJDJBTDPOFMDPSPMBSJPEFCVTDBSNF
EJPT BEFDVBEPT QBSB EFTFONBTDBSBS MBT
HSBOEFTJOFRVJEBEFTBSSBJHBEBTQSPGVO
EBNFOUF FO MB TPDJFEBE &M QBUSPDJOJP
EFM 7* $POHSFTP .VOEJBM EF #JPÏUJDB
FO#SBTJMFODPOFMUFNBi#JPÏUJ
DBQPEFSFJOKVTUJDJBw(BSSBGBZ1FTTJ
OJ
DBSBDUFSJ[BCJFOFTUFQFSmMOP
TØMPEFCJEPBMBPQDJØOQPSFTUFUFNB
TJOPUBNCJÏOBMUPOPBHVEPEFMBTDPO
GFSFODJBTQSPOVODJBEBTBMMÓ
PERSPETIVADELABIOETICAINDD
.ÈTBMMÈEFMEPHNBUJTNP
"VORVFOPQSFUFOEPQSFTFOUBSVOBTÓO
UFTJT EF MB UFPMPHÓB EF MB MJCFSBDJØO FT
CFOFmDJPTPPCTFSWBSRVFFMEJÈMPHPDJFO
UÓmDPIBEBEPBMBUFPMPHÓBDPOEJDJPOFT
QBSB SFMFFS TVT QSPQJPT QVOUPT EF SFGF
SFODJBZGVOEBNFOUPT&OFTUVEJPTEFMB
#JCMJBQPSFKFNQMPMBUFPMPHÓBUPNBMB
IJTUPSJBEFMBDPOTUSVDDJØOEFMPTUFYUPT
DPNPQBTPCÈTJDPFJNQSFTDJOEJCMFQBSB
FOUFOEFS FM DPOUFOJEP EF TV NFOTBKF
-PTDPOUFYUPTTPDJPDVMUVSBMFTTPOEFDJTJ
WPTQBSBFWBMVBSFMBMDBODFEFMPTUÏSNJ
OPTZEFMBTEFDMBSBDJPOFT&OSFTVNFO
FMUFYUPFMDPOUFYUPZFMNFOTBKFTFQSFTFO
UBODPNPUSFTBTQFDUPTJOTFQBSBCMFTQBSB
MB FYQMPSBDJØO UFPMØHJDB EF SFGFSFODJBT
CÓCMJDBT&TPTJHOJmDBRVFFMEFTDPOPDJ
NJFOUP EF MPT DPOUFYUPT TPDJPDVMUVSBMFT
MBTUSBEJDJPOFTWFSCBMFT
QSFTFOUFTFOMB
FMBCPSBDJØOEFMPTUFYUPTDPOEVDFBGVO
EBNFOUBMJTNPTSFMJHJPTPT1PSPUSBQBSUF
BMBOBMJ[BSMPTDPOUFYUPTQBSUJDVMBSNFO
UFMPTBSSBJHBEPTNÈTQSPGVOEBNFOUFFO
TJTUFNBTZFTUSVDUVSBTTPDJPDVMUVSBMFTFM
BMDBODFQBSBMBWJEBEFMBTQSPQVFTUBTEF
MBGFMMFHBBTFSNÈTDMBSP
&TF QSPDFTP FTUÈ QSFTFOUF UBNCJÏO FO
MB DPNQSFOTJØO EF MPT NJTNPT EPHNBT
EFMBGF²TUPTDFTBOEFTFSFYQSFTJPOFT
EFM GVOEBNFOUBMJTNP DVBOEP VOP FTUÈ
FOUFSBEP EFM DPOUFYUP TPDJPDVMUVSBM EF
TV GPSNVMBDJØO QBSUJDVMBSNFOUF DVBO
EP TF DPOTJEFSBO MBT QSFHVOUBT FTQFDÓ
mDBT RVF TF QSPQVTJFSPO DPOUFTUBS 4F
SFDPOPDFIPZJODMVTPPmDJBMNFOUFRVF
FYJTUF VOB FWPMVDJØO FO MPT EPHNBT Z
UBNCJÏO MPT MÓNJUFT Z FM DBSÈDUFS QSP
HSFTJWPEFMDPOPDJNJFOUPIVNBOPZEF
#JPÏUJDBZSFMJHJØOFO"NÏSJDB-BUJOB.ÈSDJP'BCSJEPT"OKPT
TVTPQJOJPOFT&TUPTCSFWFTDPNFOUBSJPT
QFSNJUFO RVF DPOTJEFSFNPT DØNP MB
UFPMPHÓB FO DVBOUP NPNFOUP SBDJPOBM
EFMBGFQFSNJUFVOBDFSDBNJFOUPDFSDB
OPBMBTDJFODJBTQBSBFOUFOEFSMPTEJWFS
TPTQSPDFTPTEFMBWJEB&OTVNÏUPEP
MBUFPMPHÓBEFMBMJCFSBDJØOIBDPOTBHSB
EPDPNPJOEJTQFOTBCMFFMNPNFOUPEF
iBOÈMJTJTEFMBSFBMJEBEw²TUFFNQMFBMBT
NFEJBDJPOFTTPDJPBOBMÓUJDBTFTEFDJSMBT
DJFODJBTDPOMBTDVBMFTTFQVFEFFOUFOEFS
BEFDVBEBNFOUF MB SFBMJEBE Z EFTQVÏT
IBDFSVOBMFDUVSBSFMJHJPTBDSÓUJDBZVOB
QSPQVFTUB
4JDSJUJDBNPTEPHNBUJTNPTFOMBSFMJHJØO
ZMBUFPMPHÓBQPEFNPTUBNCJÏOQSFHVO
UBS TJ IBZ EPHNBUJTNPT FO MB CJPÏUJDB
1BSFDFWFOUBKPTPDPOTJEFSBSFTBQSFHVO
UBQPSMPNFOPTDPNPSFDVSTPNBZÏVUJ
DPQBSBBMHVOBTDJSDVOTUBODJBT
#JPÏUJDBZUFPMPHÓBFOMBDVFTUJØO
EFMBUSBTDFOEFODJB
-B DVFTUJØO EF MB USBTDFOEFODJB FT VO
QVOUPEPOEFMBCJPÏUJDBZMBUFPMPHÓBTF
FODVFOUSBOFOFMDPOUFYUPMBUJOPBNFSJ
DBOP 1PEFNPT UPNBS BRVÓ FM DPODFQ
UP EF iUSBTDFOEFODJBw FO TFOUJEP NVZ
BNQMJPoBCBSDBOEPUPEPMPRVFWBNÈT
BMMÈEFMTFSoZMMFHBNPTBMBDVFTUJØOEF
DØNPMPTTFSFTIVNBOPTTPCSFWJWFOZTF
BVUPSSFBMJ[BO"VORVFOPWBNPTBFYB
NJOBS QSPGVOEBNFOUF MBT NVDIBT UFP
SÓBT RVF EFTEF MB BOUJHàFEBE CVTDBO
VOB SFTQVFTUB QBSB FTP FT JNQPSUBOUF
TF×BMBS MBT QPTJCJMJEBEFT EF FOSJRVFDJ
NJFOUPNVUVPFOUSFMBUFPMPHÓBZFMEJT
DVSTPEFMBCJPÏUJDBFOMPRVFDPODJFSOF
BFTUFQVOUP
PERSPETIVADELABIOETICAINDD
&TCJFOTBCJEPRVFFMDSJTUJBOJTNPUPNB
QPS DJFSUP RVF MB WJEB TØMP TF BDUVBMJ[B
SFBMJ[B
DPNQMFUBNFOUF NÈT BMMÈ EF MB
IJTUPSJBFOVOFODVFOUSPEFmOJUJWPDPO
FMBCTPMVUP1BSBMPTRVFOPUFOHBOUBM
DFSUF[B P GF FTF ÏOGBTJT FO MB BDUVBMJ
[BDJØO EF MB WJEB NÈT BMMÈ EF MB NVFS
UF IBDF FM EJÈMPHP EJGÓDJM TJO OJOHVOB
EVEB -B UFPMPHÓB MBUJOPBNFSJDBOB EB
VO QBTP JNQPSUBOUF EF QSPNPDJØO EFM
EJÈMPHP QSFDJTBNFOUF QPSRVF SFTDBUB FM
ÏOGBTJTFOSFBMJ[BDJPOFTIVNBOBTEFOUSP
EFMBQSPQJBIJTUPSJBFOMPTQSPDFTPTEF
WJEBJOEJWJEVBMZTPDJBM*ODMVTPTJOQFS
EFSEFWJTUBFMIPSJ[POUFEFMBWJEBEFT
QVÏT EF MB NVFSUF PUPSHB B MB SFMJHJØO
VOBWJHPSPTBGVFS[BJOUSBIJTUØSJDBUSBOT
GPSNBEPSB RVF FT KVTUBNFOUF MB SB[ØO
EF TFS EF VOB UFPMPHÓB EF MB MJCFSBDJØO
ZFTFFTVOFTQBDJPQSPEVDUJWPQBSBRVF
TFBDFSRVFMBCJPÏUJDB7FBNPTBMHVOPT
QVOUPT TJHOJmDBUJWPT EF BQSPYJNBDJØO
FOFTUFTFOUJEP
-BUFPMPHÓBMBUJOPBNFSJDBOBCVTDBJEFO
UJmDBSKVOUPDPOMBTDJFODJBTFMEFTBGÓP
EF MB TVQFSWJWFODJB EF MPT TFSFT IVNB
OPTOPTØMPFOTVDPOEJDJØOEFmOJUVE
TJOP UBNCJÏO FO MBT TJUVBDJPOFT GBWPSB
CMFTPBEWFSTBTFOTVTSFMBDJPOFTTPDJBMFT
ZBNCJFOUBMFT*OUFSQSFUBFTBDPOEJDJØO
IVNBOBDPNPFMHSBOFTQBDJPEFMBHFT
UBDJØOEFMBWJEBNJTNBEFMBBVUPQPJFTJT
FOFMDVBMMPTTFSFTIVNBOPTTPODSJBUV
SBTZDSFBEPSFTBMNJTNPUJFNQP&OFTUF
TFOUJEPMBFYQSFTJØOiIBDFSFMQBQFMEF
%JPTwOPTFEFCFFOUFOEFSDPNPVTVS
QBDJØOEFMBFOFSHÓBEJWJOBQPSFMDPO
USBSJPMBQPUFODJBMJEBEDSFBUJWBFTDJFS
UBNFOUFVOBQSFSSPHBUJWBIVNBOBVOB
1FSTQFDUJWBTEFMB#JPÏUJDBFO*CFSPBNÏSJDB
RVFMBQSPQJBUFPMPHÓBDPOTJEFSBVOBEÈ
EJWBBMPTTFSFTIVNBOPT%FFTUPTFEF
EVDFOPVOBQSPIJCJDJØOTJOPVOEFTBGÓP
BBDUVBSSFTQPOTBCMFNFOUF{RVÏWBNPT
BIBDFSDPOVOQPEFSUBOHSBOEF +VOUP
DPOMBTDJFODJBTMBUFPMPHÓBFYBNJOBMBT
EJWFSTBT UFOUBUJWBT IVNBOBT EF PDVQBS
TFEFFTFQPEFSBUSBWÏTEFMBIJTUPSJB:
SFQBSB FO HSBOEFT DPODFOUSBDJPOFT EF
QPEFSEFPQSFTJØOZEFGPSNBTEFTUSVD
UJWBT EF WJPMFODJB &O ÞMUJNP BOÈMJTJT
TPONBOFSBTEFCVTDBSMBBVUPBmSNBDJØO
QBSBHBSBOUJ[BSFTBBVUPQPJFTJTGPSNBTEF
BDUVBMJ[BDJØOZTVQFSWJWFODJB
-B DPOUSJCVDJØO FTQFDÓmDB EF MB UFPMP
HÓB DSJTUJBOB FT BRVÓ NVZ TPSQSFOEFOUF
"OKPT QPSRVF JOWJUB
BRVFFOUFOEBNPTFMFKFSDJDJPEFMQPEFS
FOVOTFOUJEPFNJOFOUFNFOUFDPNVOJ
DBUJWPZOPDPODFOUSBEPS7BDPOUSBMB
DPODFOUSBDJØO EFM QPEFS Z MB PQSFTJØO
"RVÓMBWVMOFSBCJMJEBEOPFTVODBNQP
RVF EFCBNPT FYQMPUBS TJOP VO EFTBGÓP
BM FTQÓSJUV DSFBUJWP Z QPUFODJBEPS -P
PUSP RVF FODPOUSBNPT FO MBT SFMBDJPOFT
OPEFCFTFSUPNBEPDPNPDPNQFUJEPS
QFSPTÓCVTDBEPDPNPDPNQB×FSPQVFT
TVT DBSFODJBT Z TVGSJNJFOUPT TPO VOB
QSPUFTUB QSPWPDBUJWB -B TVQFSWJWFODJB
QPS MP UBOUP OP TJHOJmDB FYQMPUBS P
FYDMVJSFMPUSPTJOPTVJODMVTJØOSFTQF
UVPTBZTPMJEBSJBGVOEBEBFOSFMBDJPOFT
NVUVBTZEJSJHJEBQPSFMBNPS"RVÓFTUÈ
VODPODFQUPDMBWFRVFSFTVNFFMTJTUF
NB EF TVT QSPQPTJDJPOFT +PO 4PCSJOP
BM DPOTJEFSBS PQSFTJPOFT Z TV
GSJNJFOUPTMPEFDMBSBDPNPFMQSJODJQJP
EFMBNJTFSJDPSEJB0CWJBNFOUFTFUSBUB
EFVOQSJODJQJPRVFFTUBCMFDFVOBEJSFD
PERSPETIVADELABIOETICAINDD
DJØOQBSBUPEBTMBTBDUJUVEFTZPQDJPOFT
RVFQSFTJEFOMBBDDJØO
&TOFDFTBSJPFOGBUJ[BSRVFFTBQFSTQFDUJ
WBUFPMØHJDBJNQMJDBMBJNBHFORVFUFOF
NPTEF%JPT&MBCTPMVUPOPFTJNQPTJ
UJWPTJOPDPNVOJDBUJWP/PHPCJFSOBMB
IJTUPSJB IVNBOB EFTEF GVFSB TJOP RVF
MB JODPSQPSB QBSB NBOJGFTUBSTF EFOUSP
EFFMMBDPOTVTTJHOPT4FQPTUVMBDPNP
FTQÓSJUVRVFEJSJHFZEFTQJFSUBQPUFODJB
MJEBEFTIVNBOBTZMJCFSUBEFTGSÈHJMFTFO
MBDPOTUSVDDJØOEFNPEPTEFWJEB
&OFTUFTFOUJEPTFEFCFIBDFSVOBDSÓUJ
DBBMBUSBOTGPSNBDJØOEFMBmHVSBEF+F
TÞT$SJTUPFOMFHJTMBEPSZDPORVJTUBEPS
PNVDIBTWFDFTUBNCJÏOFOFMFYQJBEPS
EFMBTEFTPCFEJFODJBTEFMBIVNBOJEBE
GSFOUFBVO%JPTFOPKBEP&ODPOUSBQP
TJDJØO FTUÈ FO QSJNFS MVHBS MB JNBHFO
EF VO NBFTUSP RVF FOTF×B QPS NFEJP
EFTVTQSÈDUJDBTZUFPSÓBTMBTNBOFSBTFO
RVFFMFTQÓSJUVQSPQPOFBMBIVNBOJEBE
MBDPOTUSVDDJØOEFMBWJEB
1BSB VOB QFSTQFDUJWB CJPÏUJDB QPS MP
UBOUPFTWBMJPTPDPNFOUBSRVFFMUFNB
EF MB USBTDFOEFODJB OP IBDF OFDFTBSJB
NFOUFEFMBSFMJHJØOFNQSFTBQBSBFMNÈT
BMMÈEJTUBOUFZFYUSB×BBMBIJTUPSJDJEBE
4V DPNQSPNJTP DPO MB IJTUPSJB JHVBM
RVFDPOMBWJEBEFDBEBEÓBQFSNJUFRVF
JEFOUJmRVFNPT CJPÏUJDB Z SFMJHJØO FO
VOB CVFOB DPOnVFODJB EF PQJOJPOFT Z
EFQSPQVFTUBT1PSPUSBQBSUFMBSFMJHJØO
JOUFSSPHB B MB QSPQJB CJPÏUJDB TPCSF TV
NBOFSBEFUSBUBSMBUSBTDFOEFODJBTPCSF
FMFTQÓSJUVRVFQSFTJEFTVTDSJUFSJPTQBSB
FWBMVBSZQSPQPOFSFMFKFSDJDJPEFMBBV
UPOPNÓBZMBMJCFSUBE
#JPÏUJDBZSFMJHJØOFO"NÏSJDB-BUJOB.ÈSDJP'BCSJEPT"OKPT
{)BCSÈVOBSFMJHJØOJNQMÓDJUBFO
MBCJPÏUJDB
"M QSPQPOFS FTUB QSFHVOUB FTUBNPT UP
NBOEPMBSFMJHJØOFOVOTFOUJEPBNQMJP
RVFQSFDFEFBDBEBJOTUJUVDJØOSFMJHJPTB
FTQFDÓmDB $POTJEFSBOEP RVF MB DPO
EJDJØO IVNBOB TF TJUÞB FO FM UJFNQP
SPEFBEB EF DBSFODJBT EF UPEBT DMBTFT Z
EJSJHJEBIBDJBFMEFTFPEFBDUVBMJ[BDJØO
VOPQVFEFBENJUJSMBOFDFTJEBERVFUJF
OFOMPTTFSFTIVNBOPTEFJSNÈTBMMÈEF
TÓNJTNPTPQPSMPNFOPTNÈTBMMÈEF
MBTJUVBDJØOFOMBDVBMFTUÈO)BZFOFTP
VOBDMBTFEFUSBTDFOEFODJB-B#JCMJBIB
CMBEFVOBTFEEF%JPT-BBOBMPHÓBEF
MB TFE FT EPCMFNFOUF JOUFSFTBOUF QPS
RVFSFDVFSEBQSJNFSPMBOFDFTJEBERVF
UFOFNPTEFTBMJSEFOPTPUSPTNJTNPTZ
CVTDBSMBBMJNFOUBDJØOZMVFHPQPSRVF
QPTUVMBMBDVFTUJØOEFRVÏPRVJÏOQVFEF
SFBMNFOUFTBUJTGBDFSOPTZBDUVBMJ[BSOPT
&TF QSPDFTP JODMVZF EJNFOTJPOFT EF
DJFODJB Z EF VO UJQP EF GF 1PSRVF FM
DPOPDJNJFOUPIVNBOPFTMJNJUBEPZFM
EFTBGÓPEFWJWJSOPTFYJHFJSNÈTBMMÈEF
FTUF DPOPDJNJFOUP Z FOUSBS FO FM FTQB
DJP EF MB BEIFTJØO DPOmEFOUF EPOEF
MBT FWJEFODJBT DJFOUÓmDBT TPO QSFDBSJBT
%FFTUPTFEFEVDFVOTJTUFNBFOFMDVBM
DSFFNPT JOEJWJEVBMNFOUF P DPMFDUJWB
NFOUF &O FTUB DPOEJDJØO RVF JOUFHSF
DJFODJB Z GF DPOTUSVJNPT QSPZFDUPT EF
WJEBOPTPDVQBNPTEFOVFTUSPTEFTFPT
UPNBNPT PQDJPOFT Z OPT QSPQPOFNPT
PCKFUJWPT1BVM5JMMJDIUJFOFSB[ØODVBO
EPEJDF
RVFMBiSFMJHJØOFTUB
JODPOEJDJPOBMNFOUFVOJEBBMTFOUJEPEF
MBWJEBEFMJOEJWJEVPwZBMNJTNPUJFN
PERSPETIVADELABIOETICAINDD
QPMBDPOEVDFBUFOFSFYQSFTJØOFOVO
iHSVQP TPDJBM DPO TÓNCPMPT EF QFOTB
NJFOUPZEFBDDJØOw
+FBO#BSUPMJ
SFBMJ[ØFOMBDJVEBE
EF4ÍP1BVMP#SBTJM
VOBJOUFSFTBOUFJO
WFTUJHBDJØOTPCSFMBTQSPQVFTUBTEFWJEB
QBSBMPTFKFDVUJWPTQVCMJDBEBFOFMFEJUP
SJBMEFVOBSFWJTUBFTQFDJBMJ[BEB-PTSF
TVMUBEPTEFNVFTUSBORVFMBTQSPQVFTUBT
BQBSFOUFNFOUFMBJDBTZQSBHNÈUJDBTEJ
SJHJEBTBMPTQSPGFTJPOBMFTEFMBFNQSFTB
UJFOFODPNQPOFOUFTSFMJHJPTPTRVFUSBT
DJFOEFOVOBTJNQMFBMFHPSÓB"MMÓVOPWF
RVFMPTJEFBMFTEFQFSGFDDJØOQSPQVFTUPT
QBSB DPOEVDJS MB WJEB EF FKFDVUJWPT MFT
JNQPOFOVOBKFSBSRVÓBEFWBMPSFTVOB
SVUB BTDÏUJDB MMFOB EF SFTJHOBDJØO Z TB
DSJmDJPFJODMVTPSJUVBMJEBETJNJMBSBMB
RVFQSPQPOFOMBTSFMJHJPOFTDPOWFODJP
OBMFT4VHFTUJWBNFOUFFMBVUPSUJUVMBTV
USBCBKPDPOMBQSFHVOUBi{&TTFSFKFDVUJ
WPVOJEFBMVOBSFMJHJØO w
-B UFPMPHÓB MBUJOPBNFSJDBOB EFTBSSPMMØ
VOB BOUJHVB USBEJDJØO RVF DPOTJTUÓB FO
MBSFQSFTFOUBDJØOFOUÏSNJOPTEFEJPTFT
EF MPT JEFBMFT RVF QSFTJEFO PQDJPOFT
QSPZFDUPTZSFBMJ[BDJPOFTIVNBOPT3V
CFN"MWFT
IBPCTFSWBEPRVF
iMBTNJTNBTDVFTUJPOFTSFMJHJPTBTEFMQB
TBEP BIPSB TF BSUJDVMBO BMUFSBEBT QPS
TÓNCPMPT TFDVMBSJ[BEPT -PT OPNCSFT
QBTBOQPSVOBNFUBNPSGPTJT-BNJTNB
GVODJØOSFMJHJPTBQFSTJTUF
4JFTUPFT
WFSEBE OPT WFNPT GPS[BEPT B DPODMVJS
OPRVFOVFTUSPNVOEPTFIBTFDVMBSJ[B
EPTJOPRVFTFIBOEBEPOVFWPTOPN
CSFTZOVFWBTFUJRVFUBTBMPTEJPTFTZB
MBTFTQFSBO[BTSFMJHJPTBTZSPQBTOVFWBT
1FSTQFDUJWBTEFMB#JPÏUJDBFO*CFSPBNÏSJDB
OVFWPT MVHBSFT Z OVFWPT USBCBKPT B TVT
TBDFSEPUFTZQSPGFUBTw
&OUSFMBTUBSFBTSFMFWBOUFTRVFFTPJNQMJ
DBFTUÈOMPTEFTBGÓPTEFJEFOUJmDBSBMPT
EJPTFTZBTVTQSPNFTBTZSFRVJTJUPTQFSP
UBNCJÏO TVT DBQBDJEBEFT EF TBUJTGBDFS
TVTQSPNFTBT-BUFPMPHÓBMMBNBMBBUFO
DJØO BM MBEP JMVTPSJP EF MBT QSPNFTBT
RVFTPOBUSBDUJWBTQFSPRVFOVODBTFSÈO
TBUJTGFDIBTZMPTEJPTFTEFFTUPTÓEPMPTEF
MBQBMBCSBEFMHSJFHPÏJEPMPOTJNVMBDSPT
JNBHJOBDJPOFT FTQFDUSPT
TPO FOHB×P
TPT EF MBT QSPNFTBT &TB MFOHVB NBS
DBEBNFOUF SFMJHJPTB PDVMUB QSFHVOUBT
FYUSFNBEBNFOUF QSÈDUJDBT RVF FYJHFO
FYBNFOZSFnFYJØOBDFSDBEFMBDPOTJT
UFODJB EF MPT TFOUJEPT Z EF MPT JEFBMFT
RVF EJSJHFO MB WJEB JOEJWJEVBM Z TPDJBM
&MMBIBBOJNBEPBMBUFPMPHÓBMBUJOPBNF
SJDBOBBEFTFONBTDBSBSFMTBDSJmDJBMJTNP
DPOFMDVBMBMHVOPTKVTUJmDBOMBTHSBOEFT
JOKVTUJDJBTFOMPTTJTUFNBTTPDJBMFTZRVF
TFNBOJmFTUBOFOQPCSF[BIBNCSFEJT
DSJNJOBDJØOZFYDMVTJØO
-B CJPÏUJDB DPNP EJTDVSTP SBDJPOBM
QVFEF DPOTJEFSBS DPOWFOJFOUFNFOUF
FTPT WFTUJHJPT JOFWJUBCMFT EF MB SFMJHJØO
JNQMÓDJUPT FO MPT TJTUFNBT TPDJBMFT :
DPNP MBT DJFODJBT OP TPO TJNQMFNFOUF
OFVUSBMFTOPTFSÓBNBMPRVFFOFMDBN
QPEFMBCJPÏUJDBUVWJÏTFNPTFMDPSBKFEF
EJTDVUJS BDFSDB EF MPT EJPTFT RVF QSFTJ
EFOOVFTUSBTDFSUF[BTZEJTDVSTPT
#JPÏUJDBMBJDBZCJPÏUJDB
SFMJHJPTBFMEFTBGÓPEFMEJTDVSTP
&OVOBEFMBTSFVOJPOFTEPOEFTFQSFQB
SØMBGVOEBDJØOEFMB4PDJFEBE#SBTJMF×B
PERSPETIVADELABIOETICAINDD
EF #JPÏUJDB TVDFEJØ VO IFDIP JOUFSF
TBOUFÞUJMBMJOUSPEVDJSFTUFUFNB&OMBT
EJTDVTJPOFTBQBSFDJØMBQSFHVOUBBDFSDB
EF MB SFMJHJØO FO MB CJPÏUJDB Z BMHVJFO
GVF FOGÈUJDP FO EFDJS iDPNP QBSB NÓ
%JPTOPFYJTUFZPOPWFPQPSRVÏDPOTJ
EFSBSMBSFMJHJØOFOMBCJPÏUJDBw&OVOB
SFBDDJØO DPSEJBM PCTFSWÏ TJNQMFNFOUF
iFOUPODFTCJFOWFOJEPBMDMVCEFMBUFP
MPHÓBw6OUBOUPTPSQSFOEJEPDPOUJOVØ
i{RVÏEJDFT w0CTFSWÏRVFMBUFPMPHÓBFT
VOEJTDVSTPTPCSF%JPTBHSFHBOEPRVF
OFHBSMBFYJTUFODJBEF%JPTFTVOBDMBTF
EFEJTDVSTPUFPMØHJDP"DFQUBOEPMBMØ
HJDBEFMDPNFOUBSJPÏMDPSSJHJØi#VFOP
FTEFDJSTPZVOBHOØTUJDPOPDPOP[DPB
%JPTw1FSPMBTFHVOEBDPODMVTJØOGVF
iTJFTUFFTFMDBTP`CJFOWFOJEPBMEJÈMPHP
*OUFSDBNCJFNPTFMDPOPDJNJFOUPBDFSDB
EFFTUPFOFMDBNQPEFMBCJPÏUJDBw
-B QPMBSJ[BDJØO FOUSF VO CJPÏUJDB MBJDB
Z PUSB SFMJHJPTB NFSFDF VOB BUFODJØO
QBSUJDVMBS FTQFDJBMNFOUF FO FM DPO
UFYUP MBUJOPBNFSJDBOP )BCMBS EF FTP
SFRVJFSF TPCSF UPEP MB DPOTJEFSBDJØO
EF DØNP MB CJPÏUJDB EFTBSSPMMB TV SF
nFYJØOEFTEFFMDPOUFYUPQBSUJDVMBSRVF
MB DBSBDUFSJ[B ²TB FT MB GVODJØO EF MPT
BEKFUJWPT RVF DBMJmDBO PDBTJPOBMNFOUF
MB CJPÏUJDB "DFOUÞBO HFOFSBMNFOUF FM
UJQPEFSFGFSFODJBTVTBEPQPSMPTTVKFUPT
RVFMBFMBCPSBOZPTF×BMBOFMÈSFBIBDJB
EPOEFMBSFnFYJØODPOWFSHF&TBFTVOB
DPOEJDJØO EFM QFOTBNJFOUP IVNBOP
VO QVOUP EFTEF FM DVBM WB B CVTDBS MBT
EJNFOTJPOFTEFVOJWFSTBMJEBE&MEJÈMP
HPFOUSFMPTEJGFSFOUFTNPEPTGVFOUFTZ
DPOUFYUPTEFDPOPDJNJFOUPTFDPOWJFSUF
FOVOSFDVSTPCÈTJDPQBSBMBDPOTPMJEB
#JPÏUJDBZSFMJHJØOFO"NÏSJDB-BUJOB.ÈSDJP'BCSJEPT"OKPT
DJØO EF DPODFQUPT &O FTF TFOUJEP MB
EJTUJODJØOFOUSFCJPÏUJDBMBJDBZSFMJHJP
TBOPTFSÓBFYDMVZFOUFTJOPBCJFSUPBMB
DPNQMFNFOUBSJFEBE
4JOFNCBSHPFYJTUFOMMBNBTWJWBTQPSEF
CBKPEFFTBTDFOJ[BT-BIJTUPSJBNVFTUSB
VOB MBSHB IFHFNPOÓB EFM QFOTBNJFOUP
SFMJHJPTPFOMBDPOTUSVDDJØOEFTFOUJEPT
FJOUFSQSFUBDJØOEFSFBMJEBEFTDPOVOB
JOnVFODJBQSPGVOEBFO MB PSHBOJ[BDJØO
TPDJBM&TBIFHFNPOÓBOPIBDPOMMFWBEP
TPMBNFOUFFMQPEFSEFMQFOTBNJFOUPSF
MJHJPTPTJOPUBNCJÏOFMQPEFSQPMÓUJDP
-FPOBSEP#PĊQMBOUFØMBDVFTUJØOEFTEF
EFOUSPEFMBQSPQJBDPNVOJEBESFMJHJP
TB-BIFHFNPOÓBEFMQPEFSSFMJHJPTPIB
TJEPRVFCSBEBQPSMBJSSVQDJØOEFMBNP
EFSOJEBE RVF BUSJCVZF B MB BVUPOPNÓB
EFMBSB[ØOMBDPOTUSVDDJØOEFMVOJWFSTP
EFTJHOJmDBDJPOFTRVFEJSJHFOMPTTFOUJ
EPTEFMBFYJTUFODJBFMQFOTBNJFOUPZFM
BDUVBSEFTPDJFEBEFTZEFJOEJWJEVPT-B
SFMJHJØOTFSFMFHBBMBFTGFSBQSJWBEB
&O"NÏSJDB-BUJOBFTBJSSVQDJØOBQBSF
DFDPOBMHÞOSFUBSEPEFCJEPQSJODJQBM
NFOUF B MB VOJØO FOUSF MB *HMFTJB Z FM
&TUBEPRVFIBQFSTJTUJEPEFTEFÏQPDBT
DPMPOJBMFTIBTUBFMTJHMP9*9-PTBKVT
UFTRVFFTBUSBOTGPSNBDJØOIBSFRVFSJEP
UPEBWÓBFTUÈOFODVSTPFOFMDPOUJOFOUF
MBUJOPBNFSJDBOP BÞO QSFTFOUBO DJFSUB
WBSJBDJØO FO MBT EJWFSTBT FYQFSJFODJBT
SFHJPOBMFT"TÓFTDPNQSFOTJCMFZKVTUP
RVFBUSBWÏTEFMBPQPTJDJØOFOUSFMBJDP
ZSFMJHJPTPTFQPTUVMFMBBVUPOPNÓBEFMB
SB[ØO GSFOUF BM BVUPSJUBSJTNP SFMJHJPTP
FOMBSFnFYJØOCJPÏUJDB
PERSPETIVADELABIOETICAINDD
1BSBTPCSFQBTBSFTFDPOnJDUPFOMBTSFMB
DJPOFTMBUFPMPHÓBEFCFTFSoFOMBCJPÏUJ
DBZFOMBTPDJFEBEQMVSBMoVOBiUFPMPHÓB
QÞCMJDBi FT EFDJS VOB UFPMPHÓB RVF TF
QSFTFOUF DPO TVT SB[POFT FOUFOEJEBT Z
EJTDVUJEBTBCJFSUBNFOUFZQPSMPUBOUP
DPO VO EJTDVSTP BCJFSUP B DPOUSBBSHV
NFOUPT&MEJTDVSTPEFMBTDPNVOJEBEFT
EFGFoFOMBTRVFFMQFTPEFSFGFSFODJBT
SFMJHJPTBTZBVUPSJEBEEFTVTMÓEFSFTUJF
OFOPUSPWBMPSoOPFTQBSBMBCJPÏUJDBVO
EJTDVSTP BSHVNFOUBUJWP BVORVF QVF
EB FWFOUVBMNFOUF DMBSJmDBS BDUJUVEFT Z
DPNQPSUBNJFOUPT
&T OFDFTBSJP FOUPODFT SFDPOPDFS RVF
OP UPEPT MPT EJTDVSTPT UFPMØHJDPT QVF
EFO EJBMPHBS FO CJPÏUJDB QFSP UBN
CJÏO FT JOEJTQFOTBCMF EJTUJOHVJS BVO
RVF TPMBNFOUF VO QPDP MPT EJWFSTPT
NPEFMPTUFPMØHJDPTQBSBOPJEFOUJmDBS
UPEPTFTUPTEJTDVSTPTDPNPBVUPSJUBSJPT
Z DFSSBEPT 1PS PUSB QBSUF NF QBSFDF
JHVBMNFOUF JNQSFTDJOEJCMF TPCSFQBTBS
FM EPHNBUJTNP DJFOUÓmDP QPSRVF IBZ
DPODJFODJB EF RVF MBT DJFODJBT OP TPO
OFVUSBMFT Z OP DPOTUJUVZFO MBT ÞOJDBT
GPSNBTEFDPOPDJNJFOUPIVNBOP
#JPÏUJDBZSFMJHJØOFMEFTBGÓPEF
TVTMVHBSFTFOMBTPDJFEBE
&YJTUFBRVÓVOQSPDFTPNÈTQSPGVOEPZ
SBEJDBMRVFEFTBGÓBMBCJPÏUJDBZMBSFMJ
HJØO(BVDIFUBQVE/FVU[MJOH
PCTFSWB RVF FM DSJTUJBOJTNP
FT MB SFMJHJØO EF MB TBMJEB EF MB SFMJHJØO
QPSQFSNJUJSHSBEVBMNFOUFRVFMBFTGFSB
QPMÓUJDB SFOVODJF B TV MFHJUJNBDJØO SF
MJHJPTB Z FODVFOUSF PUSPT NPEFMPT QBSB
MFHJUJNBSTF&MQSPUFTUBOUJTNPIJTUØSJDP
1FSTQFDUJWBTEFMB#JPÏUJDBFO*CFSPBNÏSJDB
IB DPOUSJCVJEP HSBOEFNFOUF B FTP
/FVU[MJOH
BDFOUÞBMBJN
QPSUBODJB EF MBT OVFWBT EJSFDDJPOFT TF
HVJEBTQPSFMDBUPMJDJTNPSPNBOPFOMB
TFHVOEBNJUBEEFMTJHMP99ZQPSMBUFP
MPHÓBEFMBMJCFSBDJØOFOTVDPOUBDUPDPO
MBDVMUVSBNPEFSOB&TFQSPDFTPMMFWBBM
mOEFMBTFYQMJDBDJPOFTZMBTMFHJUJNBDJP
OFT SFMJHJPTBT QBSB MBT FTUSVDUVSBT EF MB
WJEBTPDJBM)FSWJFV-ÏHFS
IBCMB
EFVOQSPDFTPEFFYDVMUVSBDJØOEFMDSJT
UJBOJTNPZEFMBTSFMJHJPOFTFOHFOFSBM
FO MB TPDJFEBE QPTNPEFSOB /FVU[MJOH
QSFTFOUBVOBTÓOUFTJTEFMQFO
TBNJFOUPEF)FSWJFV-ÏHFSEJDJFOEP
i1BSB)FSWJFV-ÏHFSMBMØHJDBEFMBFY
DVMUVSBDJØO DPOTJTUF BTÓ FO FM QSPDFTP
QPS FM RVF MPT TJHOJmDBEPT SFMJHJPTPT
EBEPT DPMFDUJWBNFOUF B MB BDDJØO FO FM
NVOEP QJFSEFO HSBEVBMNFOUF UPEB MB
DPOTJTUFODJB QBSB MPT QSPQJPT BHFOUFT
RVFQPSBTÓEFDJSMPTPOJOIBMBEPTQPS
MB MØHJDB FDPOØNJDB F JOFYPSBCMFNFOUF
TFDVMBSEFMBBDDJØO&TPOPTJHOJmDBRVF
FTPTBHFOUFTIBOQFSEJEPOFDFTBSJBNFO
UFDPNPJOEJWJEVPTUPEPFMJOUFSÏTSFMJ
HJPTPTJOPRVFMPTEJTQPTJUJWPTRVFQFS
NJUJFSPORVFEJFSBOVOTFOUJEPSFMJHJPTP
BTVFYQFSJFODJBFOFMNVOEPoZFOQSJ
NFSMVHBSBTVFYQFSJFODJBQSPGFTJPOBMo
IBOQFSEJEPTVDBQBDJEBEEFEBSMFTVO
TJHOJmDBEP DPMFDUJWP QFSDJCJEP DPNP
UBMQPSFMMPTZQPSMBTPDJFEBEw
)BZ BRVÓ FOUPODFT VOB JNQMPTJØO EF
MPT TJHOJmDBEPT DPMFDUJWPT HBSBOUJ[B
PERSPETIVADELABIOETICAINDD
EPTQSFWJBNFOUFQPSMBSFMJHJØO4FHÞO
#MVNFOCFSH BQVE /FVU[MJOH
FTF QSPDFTP IBDF RVF FM TJO
TFOUJEP TFB DPOTUSVJEP DPO VO OVF
WP DPOUFOJEP : MB TPMVDJØO QBSB FTF
iOVFWPwFTUÈFOFMBOÈMJTJTCBTBEPFOMB
BVUPBmSNBDJØO EFM JOEJWJEVP 4FMCTCF
IBVQUVOH
UPNBEPEFTEFFTFNPNFOUP
DPNPSFGFSFODJBQBSBMBDPOTUSVDDJØOEF
TJHOJmDBEPT
&TUPQSFTFOUBVOEFTBGÓPSBEJDBMOPTØMP
BMBSFMJHJØOTJOPBIPSBQBSUJDVMBSNFO
UFBMBCJPÏUJDBDVBOEPÏTUBTJHVJFOEP
MBQSJNFSBJOUVJDJØOEF1PUUFS
TFQSPQPOFTFSFOMBTPDJFEBEQMVSBMVO
BHFOUFEFMBTBCJEVSÓBDPNPHVÓBQBSBMB
BDDJØOEFMDPOPDJNJFOUPEFDØNPVUJ
MJ[BSFMDPOPDJNJFOUPFOCFOFmDJPEFMB
TPDJFEBE{2VÏMVHBSPDVQBSFBMNFOUFMB
CJP
ÏUJDBFOMBTPDJFEBEQMVSBM &ONV
DIPTDPOUFYUPTTFWFDPNPVOPCTUÈDVMP
BM EFTBSSPMMP DJFOUÓmDP P DPNP VO NBM
OFDFTBSJP EF UPMFSBSTF EFCJEP B MB QSF
TJØOEFHSVQPTTPDJBMFT
&WJUBOEP DBFS FO FM JOEJWJEVBMJTNP MB
UFPMPHÓB MBUJOPBNFSJDBOB Z MB CJPÏUJDB
WBO IBDJB VOB JOUFSTVCKFUJWJEBE DBQB[
EFEJBMPHBSEFTFSQBSUFEFVOBSFEEF
CVTDBSZEFFODPOUSBSOVFTUSBTSB[POFT
DPNQBSUJEBT DPNQBSUJS TJHOJmDBEPT Z
WJWJSMPT FO MB TPDJFEBE "RVÓ TF EJCVKB
VO FTQBDJP EPOEF MB UFPMPHÓB Z MB CJP
ÏUJDBQVFEFOBQSFOEFSVOBEFMBPUSBZ
USBCBKBSFOMBTPDJFEBEQBSBFMCJFOEFMB
IVNBOJEBE
#JPÏUJDBZSFMJHJØOFO"NÏSJDB-BUJOB.ÈSDJP'BCSJEPT"OKPT
3FGFSFODJBT
"MWFT3VCFN
0RVFÏ3FMJHJÍP4ÍP1BVMP$ÓSDVMPEP-JWSP
"OKPT.'
#JPFUIJDTJOB-JCFSBUJPOJTU,FZ*O%V#PTF&3)BNFM3
0w$POOFMM-+&E
".BUUFSPG1SJODJQMFT 'FSNFOUJO64#JPFUIJDT7BMMFZ'PSHF
5SJOJUZ1SFTT*OUFSOBUJPOBMQQ
"OKPT.'
#JPÏUJDBFNQFSTQFDUJWBEFMJCFSUBÎÍP&O(BSSBGB71FTTJOJ
-FP0SH
#JPÏUJDBQPEFSFJOKVTUJÎB4ÍP1BVMP4##-PZPMB4$BNJMPQQ
#BODP*OUFSBNFSJDBOPEF%FTFOWPMWJNFOUPOB"NÏSJDB-BUJOB
*ODMVTÍPTPDJBMF
EFTFOWPMWJNFOUPFDPOÙNJDPOB"NÏSJDB-BUJOB3JPEF+BOFJSP$BNQVT
#BSUPMJ+FBO
4FSFYFDVUJWPVNJEFBMVNBSFMJHJÍP "QBSFDJEB*EÏJBT-FUSBT
#MVNFOCFSH)BOT
-BMÏHJUJNJUÏEFT5FNQT.PEFSOFT1BSJT(BMMJNBSE
#PGG-FPOBSEP
*HSFKBDBSJTNBFQPEFS1FUSØQPMJT&E7P[FT
$IBTUFFO+$
"NÏSJDB-BUJOBVNBIJTUØSJBEFTBOHVFFGPHP5FSDFSB&EJDJØO
3JPEF+BOFJSP$BNQVT
(BSSBGB71FTTJOJ-FP0SH
#JPÏUJDBQPEFSFJOKVTUJÎB4ÍP1BVMP-PZPMB
(BVDIFU.BSDFM
-BDPOEJUJPOIJTUPSJRVF1BSJT4UPDL
)FSWJFV-ÏHFS%BOJÒMF
$BUIPMJDJTNFMBGJOEwVONPOEF1BSJT#BZBSE
4PCSJOP+PO
&MQSJODJQJPNJTFSJDPSEJB#BKBSEFMBDSV[BMPTQVFCMPTDSVDJGJDBEPT
4BOUBOEFS4BM5FSSBF
/FVU[MJOH*OÈDJP
5FPMPHJBFTPDJFEBEFSFMFWÉODJBFGVOÎÜFT"MHVNBTBOPUBÎÜFT
&O 'SFJUBT . $BSNFMJUB 0SH
5FPMPHJB F 4PDJFEBEF SFMFWÉODJB F GVOÎÜFT 4ÍP
1BVMP1BVMJOBTQQ
0MJWFJSB.BOGSFEP"SBÞKP
%JÈMPHPTFOUSFSB[ÍPFGÏ4ÍP1BVMP&E1BVMJOBT
1BQB #FOUP 97* $POGFSÐODJB FN 3FHFOTCVSH 0TTFSWBUPSF 3PNBOP &E 1PSUVHVÐT
EFTFUFNCSPEFQQ
1FTTJOJ-
&VUBOÈTJBQPSRVFBCSFWJBSBWJEB 4ÍP1BVMP&E-PZPMB
1PUUFS 7BO 3FOTTFMBFS #JPFUIJDT CSJEHF UP UIF GVUVSF &OHMFXPPE $MJGGT /FX
+FSTFZ1SFOUJDF)BMM
4VFTT1BVMP
"$PORVJTUBFTQÓSJUVBMEB"NÏSJDB&TQBOIPMBEPDVNFOUPTTÏDVMP
97*1FUSØQPMJT&E7P[FT
5JMMJDI 1BVM 5IF TQJSJUVBM TJUVBUJPO JO PVS UFDIOJDBM TPDJFUZ .BDPO (FPSHJB
.FSDFS6OJWFSTJUZ1SFTT
PERSPETIVADELABIOETICAINDD
PERSPETIVADELABIOETICAINDD
-BCJPÏUJDBZMBTNVKFSFTFO"NÏSJDB-BUJOBVO
FOTBZPCJPHSÈmDPZHFOFBMØHJDP
%FCPSB%JOJ[Z%JSDF(VJMIFN
-
BCJPÏUJDBTFDPOTPMJEØFO#SBTJMBm
OFTEFMBEÏDBEBEFMPT6OGFOØ
NFOPTFNFKBOUFTVDFEJØFOPUSPTQBÓTFT
EF "NÏSJDB -BUJOB FTQFDJBMNFOUF FO
"SHFOUJOB $IJMF Z .ÏYJDP EPOEF FT
OPUBCMFTVJOTFSDJØOBDBEÏNJDB%JOJ[
(VJMIFN (BSSBGB 014 6/&4$0 7FMBT
DP4VÈSF[ &O FTF QSPDFTP EF
DPOTPMJEBDJØO MBT NVKFSFT BTVNJFSPO
EJGFSFOUFT QBQFMFT ZB TFB DPNP QSPUB
HPOJTUBTBDBEÏNJDBTPDPNPJOUFSMPDV
UPSBTFOFMFTQBDJPQÞCMJDP&TUBEPCMF
JOTFSDJØO FT DBSBDUFSÓTUJDB FO MB CJPÏUJ
DBMBUJOPBNFSJDBOBZGPSNBQBSUFEFMB
CJPHSBGÓBEFMBTBVUPSBTEFFTUFFOTBZP
&TUFDBQÓUVMPFTVOBQJF[BCJPHSÈmDBZ
HFOFBMØHJDBEFMBCJPÏUJDBMBUJOPBNFSJ
DBOBZQBSUJDVMBSNFOUFEFMBCSBTJMF×B
4FCBTBFOFYQFSJFODJBTWJWJEBTQPSMBT
BVUPSBT Z FO NFOPS JOUFOTJEBE QFSP
OP NFOPT JNQPSUBOUF FO MPT SFMBUPT
EF PUSBT NVKFSFT TPCSF FTF QSPDFTP EF
DPOTPMJEBDJØO BDBEÏNJDB FO "NÏSJDB
-BT BVUPSBT BHSBEFDFO MPT DPNFOUBSJPT EF
$SJTUJBOP (VFEFT 'BCJBOB 1BSBOIPT Z 4FSHJP
$PTUB5SBEVDDJØO7BMFOUJOB'FSSB[3FWJTJØO
"EBJM4PCSBM
PERSPETIVADELABIOETICAINDD
-BUJOBBVODVBOEPMBJOUFSQSFUBDJØOEF
MPTIFDIPTFTEFOVFTUSBDPNQMFUBSFT
QPOTBCJMJEBE
6OQBOPSBNBHFOFBMØHJDP
&YJTUFVOBDSFDJFOUFGFNJOJ[BDJØOEFMBT
BDUJWJEBEFTBDBEÏNJDBTFO"NÏSJDB-BUJ
OB-BTNVKFSFTZBTPONBZPSÓBFOHSBO
QBSUF EF MBT DBSSFSBT VOJWFSTJUBSJBT DPO
FYDFQDJØO EF mMPTPGÓB Z UFPMPHÓB EFO
USP EF MBT IVNBOJEBEFT FO UBOUP RVF
MBT JOHFOJFSÓBT HSBEVBMNFOUF IBO DFEJ
EP FTQBDJPT B MBT NVKFSFT .FEJDJOB B
QFTBSEFMDSFDJFOUFOÞNFSPEFNVKFSFT
FTUÈNBSDBEBQPSFMHÏOFSP&OHFOFSBM
MBTNVKFSFTNÏEJDPTTFEFEJDBOBMBTBD
UJWJEBEFTEFDVJEBEPZQPDBTPQUBOQPS
FTQFDJBMJEBEFT DPNP MB NFEJDJOB MFHBM
MBÏUJDBNÏEJDBPJODMVTPMBQPMÓUJDBEF
DMBTF %JOJ[ &TB EJ
1BSB DPOPDFS MBT QVCMJDBDJPOFT EF MBT NVKFSFT
MBUJOPBNFSJDBOBTFOCJPÏUJDBGVFSFBMJ[BEBVOB
JOWFTUJHBDJØOFOEPTCBTFTEFEBUPT-JUFSBUVSB
-BUJOPBNFSJDBOBZEFM$BSJCFFO$JFODJBTEFMB
4BMVE-JMBDT
ZFMDzF4DJFOUJmD&MFDUSPOJD-J
CSBSZ 0OMJOF 4DJFMP
'VFSPO SFDVQFSBEBT QVCMJDBDJPOFT EF NVKFSFT BVUPSBT FO CJPÏUJDB
"QBSUJSEFBMMÓGVFSPOJEFOUJmDBEBTBVUPSBTDMB
WFQBSBMBCJPÏUJDBMBUJOPBNFSJDBOBZDPOFMMBT
GVFSPO SFBMJ[BEBT FOUSFWJTUBT FO QSPGVOEJEBE
"SHFOUJOB#SBTJM$IJMFZ.ÏYJDP
1FSTQFDUJWBTEFMB#JPÏUJDBFO*CFSPBNÏSJDB
WJTJØO TPDJBM EFM USBCBKP BDBEÏNJDP FO
NFEJDJOB HFOFSØ DBSBDUFSÓTUJDBT JNQPS
UBOUFTFOMBQBSUJDJQBDJØOEFMBTNVKFSFT
FOMBCJPÏUJDBMBUJOPBNFSJDBOB
-B HÏOFTJT EF MB CJPÏUJDB CSBTJMF×B GVF
CBTUBOUF TFNFKBOUF B MB EF PUSPT QBÓTFT
EF MB SFHJØO (FOFSBMNFOUF FM JNQVM
TPJOJDJBMTFEJPBUSBWÏTEFEPTDBNQPT
NBTDVMJOPTMBQPMÓUJDBEFMBDMBTFNÏEJ
DBZMBUFPMPHÓBDBUØMJDB-PZPMB
$PSSÐB
-BTQSJNFSBTJOJDJB
UJWBTEFDPOTPMJEBDJØOEFMBCJPÏUJDBFO
#SBTJMGVFSPOEFSFTQPOTBCJMJEBEEFFO
UJEBEFTNÏEJDBTFOFTQFDJBMEFM$POTFKP
'FEFSBMEF.FEJDJOB-BSFWJTUB#JPÏUJDB
QPSFKFNQMPFTMBRVFUJFOFNÈTB×PTFO
DJSDVMBDJØOFOFMQBÓTZFTUÈCBKPMBSFT
QPOTBCJMJEBEFEJUPSJBMEFFTUF$POTFKP
%FMPTNJFNCSPTEFMBDUVBMDPOTFKP
FEJUPSJBMTPOIPNCSFTMBNBZPSÓB
NÏEJDPT $.' 6OB JOJDJBUJWB
QJPOFSBEFFEVDBDJØOCJPÏUJDBBEJTUBO
DJBQPSNFEJPEFMBUFMFWJTJØOGVFUBN
CJÏOQSPNPWJEBQPSFM$POTFKPBmOBMFT
EFMBEÏDBEBEFMPT%JOJ[(VJM
-PTDPODFQUPTEFDBNQPDBNQPFOEJTQVUBF
JOUFSFTFT TPO EF 1JFSSF #PVSEJFV 7ÏBTF QPS
FKFNQMPMBTJEFBTEFMBVUPSFOMPTMJCSPTUJUV
MBEPT&M1PEFS4JNCØMJDP
Z-B&DPOPNÓB
EFMPT$BNCJPT4JNCØMJDPT
&MQSJNFSOÞNFSPEFMBSFWJTUBGVFQVCMJDBEP
FO /P IBZ OJOHVOB SFWJTUB DJFOUÓmDB
FTQFDJBMJ[BEBFOCJPÏUJDBFO#SBTJMDPOJOEFYB
DJØOJOUFSOBDJPOBMZMBQFSJPEJDJEBEEFUPEBTFT
CBTUBOUFJSSFHVMBS4FHÞO,ÈUJB4PBSFT#SBHBFM
DBSÈDUFSBNBUFVSEFMBDPNVOJDBDJØODJFOUÓmDB
FO CJPÏUJDB FO #SBTJM oZ FO DJFSUB NFEJEB FO
"NÏSJDB-BUJOBoJNQSJNFNBSDBTJNQPSUBOUFT
BMDBNQP#SBHB
PERSPETIVADELABIOETICAINDD
IFN 1PS PUSP MBEP FM QSJNFS
DVSTPEFNBFTUSÓBFOCJPÏUJDBGVFPGSFDJ
EPQPSVOBJOTUJUVDJØOEFFOTF×BO[BTV
QFSJPSDBUØMJDB&OMBQSJNFSBEÏDBEBEF
FTUSVDUVSBDJØOEFMBCJPÏUJDBFO#SBTJMMB
USÓBEBNFEJDJOBUFPMPHÓBDBUØMJDBZCJP
ÏUJDBIJ[PEJGÓDJMMBEJGFSFODJBDJØOEFMPT
EJTDVSTPTFJOUFSFTFTEFMPTBDUPSFT
-BBQSPYJNBDJØOEFMBCJPÏUJDBBMBNF
EJDJOBZNÈTQBSUJDVMBSNFOUFBMBQP
MÓUJDB NÏEJDB EFMJOFØ VOB EPCMF JEFO
UJEBEBMBCJPÏUJDBCSBTJMF×BEFMPTB×PT
FSBVOUFNBEFJOUFSÏTEFMBNFEJDJ
OBZQSBDUJDBEBQPSNÏEJDPTEFEJDBEPT
BMBQPMÓUJDBNÏEJDBPQSPGFTPSFTFOWÓBT
EFKVCJMBDJØO%VSBOUFVOCSFWFQFSÓP
EPMBCJPÏUJDBGVFFOUFOEJEBDPNPVOB
FTQFDJBMJEBEEFMBÏUJDBNÏEJDBZOPGVF
DBTVBMJEBE MB NJHSBDJØO EFM DBNQP EF
MB NFEJDJOB MFHBM Z EF MB ÏUJDB NÏEJDB
IBDJB MB CJPÏUJDB -B JOTFSDJØO VOJWFS
TJUBSJB EF MB CJPÏUJDB FTUVWP WJODVMBEB
QSJODJQBMNFOUF DPO QSPHSBNBT EF QPT
HSBEPFONFEJDJOBMFHBM4JRVFJSBFUBM
%VSBOUFEPTB×PTFM$POTFKP'FEFSBMEF.FEJ
DJOBQSPEVKPVOQSPHSBNBEFUFMFWJTJØOi#JPÏ
UJDB$JFODJBZ$JVEBEBOÓBwDVZPPCKFUJWPFSB
TFOTJCJMJ[BSBUPEPTMPTNÏEJDPTEFMQBÓTQBSBMBT
DVFTUJPOFTCJPÏUJDBT%FCPSB%JOJ[GVFVOBEF
MBTSFTQPOTBCMFTQPSFMQSPHSBNB
$FOUSP6OJWFSTJUBSJP4ÍP$BNJMP.BFTUSÓBFO
#JPÏUJDB&MDVSTPTFJOJDJØFOBHPTUPEF
Z UPEBWÓB FT FM ÞOJDP FO FM QBÓT 4ÍP $BNJMP
&TBDPNQSFTJØOEFMBCJPÏUJDBDPNPVOBFTQF
DJBMJEBEEFMBÏUJDBNÏEJDBFTUPEBWÓBIFHFNØ
OJDB3FDJFOUFNFOUFMBSFWJTUB#JPÏUJDBFNQF[Ø
BMMBNBSTF#JPÏUJDBVOBSFWJTUBEF#JPÏUJDBZ²UJ
DB.ÏEJDB
-BCJPÏUJDBZMBTNVKFSFTFO"NÏSJDB-BUJOB%FCPSB%JOJ[Z%JSDF(VJMIFN
-B DPNQSFOTJØO JOJDJBM EF MB CJPÏUJDB
DPNPVOBDVFTUJØOEFGPSNBDJØONÏEJ
DB Z EF QPMÓUJDB EF MB NFEJDJOB JNQSJ
NJØ USFT DBSBDUFSÓTUJDBT RVF UPEBWÓB TF
NBOUJFOFO GVFSUF ÏOGBTJT FO FM SBDJP
DJOJP ÏUJDP QBSB MB TPMVDJØO EF QSPCMF
NBT QPS FTP MB GBTDJOBDJØO QPS UFPSÓBT
EF GÈDJM BQSFOEJ[BKF Z EPNJOJP QPS OP
FTQFDJBMJTUBTFOIVNBOJEBEFTDPNPGVF
FMDBTPEFMBUFPSÓBEFMPTDVBUSPQSJODJ
QJPTDPNQSFOTJØOEFMBCJPÏUJDBDPNP
NBUFSJBEFJOUFSÏTEFMPTNÏEJDPTZEFM
FKFSDJDJP QSPGFTJPOBM EF MB NFEJDJOB Z
BHFOEBCJPÏUJDBNPEFMBEBQPSFMRVFIB
DFSNÏEJDP
&TUB BSUJDVMBDJØO GVF NÈT NBSDBEB FO
MPTQSJNFSPTB×PTFOFTQFDJBMDVBOEPMB
BDUVBDJØO EF MBT FOUJEBEFT NÏEJDBT FSB
IFHFNØOJDB4JOFNCBSHPEBEBMBJOTFS
DJØOQPMÓUJDBEFMBQSPGFTJØONÏEJDBFO
MBTPDJFEBECSBTJMF×BFMFOUFOEJNJFOUP
EF MB CJPÏUJDB DPNP VOB DVFTUJØO NÏ
EJDB Z OP DPNP VO DBNQP BOBMÓUJDP Z
UFØSJDPTPCSFMBCJPNFEJDJOBZMBDJFODJB
UPEBWÓBQFSTJTUF%JOJ[(VJMIFN(B
SSBGB
1FSPMBBQSPYJNBDJØOEFMBCJPÏUJDBBMB
NFEJDJOBGVFJNQPSUBOUFQBSBMBDPOTP
MJEBDJØOEFBRVFMMB3ÈQJEBNFOUFBTDFO
EJØ B EJTDJQMJOB EF FMJUF DPNQSFOTJØO
RVF TF WJP GPSUBMFDJEB QPS MB QSFTFODJB
EF MB UFPMPHÓB DBUØMJDB "M DPOUSBSJP EF
MPRVFPDVSSJØFOPUSPTQBÓTFTEF"NÏ
SJDB -BUJOB MPT HSVQPT UFPMØHJDPT RVF
TFJOUFSFTBSPOQPSMBCJPÏUJDBGVFSPOEF
WBOHVBSEJBZDPOFTQÓSJUVQMVSBMQBSBFM
EFCBUFQÞCMJDP1FSPUBMDPNPMPTNÏ
EJDPTMPTUFØMPHPTDBUØMJDPTUBNCJÏOFT
PERSPETIVADELABIOETICAINDD
UBCMFDJFSPOTVBHFOEBEFJOWFTUJHBDJØOF
JOUFSWFODJØOCBTBEBFOMPTJOUFSFTFTEF
TV DPNVOJEBE DJFOUÓmDB MP RVF EFUFS
NJOØ USFT DBSBDUFSÓTUJDBT SFUPSOP EF MB
CJPÏUJDB B MBT IVNBOJEBEFT BQMJDBEBT B
MBTBMVEBHFOEBUFNÈUJDBBNQMJBEBIB
DJBUFNBTSFMBDJPOBEPTDPOMBQB[ZTJO
FNCBSHPSFTUSJDUJWBFODVFTUJPOFTSFMB
DJPOBEBTDPOMBSFQSPEVDDJØOCJPMØHJDB
FJODFOUJWPBMBFTUSVDUVSBDJØOBDBEÏNJ
DBEFMBCJPÏUJDBMPRVFSFQSFTFOUØVOB
QÏSEJEBEFMBIFHFNPOÓBEFMBTFOUJEB
EFTNÏEJDBTEFDMBTFDPNPEJTDVSTPMFHJ
UJNBEPSEFMBCJPÏUJDB
" QFTBS EF MBT SFTUSJDDJPOFT UFNÈUJDBT
JOIFSFOUFTBMBEPHNÈUJDBDBUØMJDBFOFM
EFCBUFCJPÏUJDPMBFOUSBEBZQFSNBOFO
DJB EF MPT UFØMPHPT GPS[Ø FM SFHSFTP EF
MB CJPÏUJDB B MBT IVNBOJEBEFT "M DPO
USBSJPEFMPTQBÓTFTEF"NÏSJDB$FOUSBM
EPOEFFTVOBFTQFDJBMJEBEEFMBmMPTPGÓB
BOUFT RVF EF MB NFEJDJOB FO "NÏSJDB
EFM4VSFMGFOØNFOPGVFJOWFSTP"OESF
(BSSBGB %JOJ[ (VJM
IFN
*OJDJBMNFOUFFTUVWP
FONBOPTEFMBUFPMPHÓBNBOUFOFSBDUJWP
FTFWÓODVMPUFØSJDP
4J FM FODVFOUSP FOUSF MB NFEJDJOB Z MB
UFPMPHÓBDBUØMJDBGBDJMJUØQPSVOMBEPFM
TVSHJNJFOUP EF MB CJPÏUJDB FO MB FTGFSB
EF MPT QPEFSFT TJNCØMJDPT EF FTBT EPT
EJTDJQMJOBTFOMBTPDJFEBECSBTJMF×BQPS
PUSPGVFVOBBMJBO[BFTUSBUÏHJDBQBSBMPT
QSJNFSPT B×PT EF MB CJPÏUJDB FO #SBTJM
RVFHSBEVBMNFOUFTFIBJEPEJMVZFOEP
-BFOUSBEBZQFSNBOFODJBEFMBTNVKF
SFTFOMBCJPÏUJDBGVFDSVDJBMQBSBMBSF
EFTDSJQDJØOEFMBUSÓBEBJOJDJBMCJPÏUJDB
1FSTQFDUJWBTEFMB#JPÏUJDBFO*CFSPBNÏSJDB
UFPMPHÓBDBUØMJDBZNFEJDJOB&OMPTQSJ
NFSPTB×PTEFTVSHJNJFOUPFO"NÏSJDB
-BUJOBMBTNVKFSFTUSBKFSPOUBNCJÏOFM
GFNJOJTNPDPNPVOBIFSSBNJFOUBBOB
MÓUJDBZQPMÓUJDBBMUFSOBUJWBBMBTUFPSÓBT
EPNJOBOUFTQBSBMBDPNQSFOTJØOEFMPT
DPOnJDUPTNPSBMFT
&OUSFNÏEJDPTZUFØMPHPTMBT
NVKFSFTGFNJOJTUBT
&YJTUF MB GBMTB QSFTVODJØO EF RVF TFS
VOB NVKFS BDUJWB FO MB JOWFTUJHBDJØO
CJPÏUJDB TJHOJmDB TFS GFNJOJTUB FTQF
DJBMJ[BEB FO UFNBT SFMBDJPOBEPT DPO MB
SFQSPEVDDJØO CJPMØHJDB Z TPDJBM P BM
NFOPTVOBJOWFTUJHBEPSBEFDVFTUJPOFT
SFMBUJWBTBMDVJEBEPZMBWVMOFSBCJMJEBE
&TUP QSPWPDB VOB EJTUSJCVDJØO EF HÏ
OFSP EF MBT FTQFDJBMJEBEFT DVFTUJPOFT
SFMBDJPOBEBT B MP GFNFOJOP DPNP MB
SFQSPEVDDJØO Z MB TFYVBMJEBE TFSÓBO
MPTUFNBTEFMBTNVKFSFTFOMBCJPÏUJDB
)VCP FGFDUJWBNFOUF VOB DPOWFSHFODJB
EFJOUFSFTFTEFMBTQSJNFSBTNVKFSFTFO
MBCJPÏUJDBMBUJOPBNFSJDBOBDPOFTPTUF
NBT QFSP FTP OP TJHOJmDB RVF FTB TFB
VOB SFHMB DPNÞO B UPEBT MBT JOWFTUJHB
EPSBT $PSSÐB $PSSÐB
%JOJ[ 7FMF[ %JOJ[ 7FMF[ %J
OJ[ (VJMIFN %J
OJ[ (VJMIFN %J
OJ[ (PNFT (VJMIFN
-VOB &T QPTJCMF SFDPOPDFS MB QSFTFODJB EF BMHVOBT
NVKFSFTFOMBHÏOFTJTEFMBCJPÏUJDBRVFOPTF
DPOGVOEÓBO DPO FM GFNJOJTNP 4JO FNCBSHP
FMMBTOPGVFSPONVKFSFTQSPUBHPOJTUBTPJOUFSMP
DVUPSBTEFMBCJPÏUJDBRVFQFSNBOFDJFSBOFOMB
ÞMUJNBEÏDBEB
PERSPETIVADELABIOETICAINDD
0MJWFJSB4PNNFS
3PUBOJB Z 7BMEFCFOJUP FU
BM 1FSP FTB GBMTB QSF
TVODJØOGVFUBNCJÏOFTUSBUÏHJDBQBSBMB
SFVCJDBDJØO EFM ÈNCJUP QSPWPDBEP QPS
MB FOUSBEB EF MBT NVKFSFT FO FTQFDJBM
EF MBT NVKFSFT FGFDUJWBNFOUF GFNJOJT
UBT"TVNJSRVFUFNBTDPNPFMBCPSUP
UFDOPMPHÓBT SFQSPEVDUJWBT V IPNPTF
YVBMJEBEFSBODVFTUJPOFTEFMBTNVKFSFT
GFNJOJTUBT FO MB CJPÏUJDB SFTPMWJØ VOB
TFSJF EF QSPCMFNBT QPMÓUJDPT QBSB MPT
QJPOFSPT EF MB EJTDJQMJOB UBOUP EF MPT
NÏEJDPToQVFTTPOUFNBTEFQPDPDPO
TFOTPNPSBMZTPCSFDVFTUJPOFTQPMÓUJDBT
EJTPOBOUFToDPNPEFMPTUFØMPHPTDBUØ
MJDPTQPSUSBUBSTFEFDVFTUJPOFTCÈTJDBT
EFMBEPHNÈUJDBDPOQPDPFTQBDJPQBSB
MBBSHVNFOUBDJØO6OBFWJEFODJBEFFTB
OVFWBEJTUSJCVDJØOUFNÈUJDBQPSHÏOFSP
FOCJPÏUJDBGVFSPOMBTQSJNFSBTQVCMJDB
DJPOFTEFNVKFSFTFO#SBTJM1FTTJOJ
#BSDIJGPOUBJOF$PTUB0TFMLB
(BSSBGB 4PSPLJO (FOF
SBMNFOUF FSBO PCSBT SFDPQJMBUPSJBT FO
MBT DVBMFT MPT DBQÓUVMPT BOBMÓUJDPT TPCSF
SFQSPEVDDJØOCJPMØHJDBZTPDJBMFSBOIF
DIPTQPSNVKFSFTNJFOUSBTRVFQBSBMPT
IPNCSFT TF SFTFSWBCBO MBT EJTDVTJPOFT
UFØSJDBT
$PO MB FOUSBEB EF MBT NVKFSFT MB CJPÏ
UJDBFO#SBTJMFYQFSJNFOUØVOBSFEJTUSJ
CVDJØOQPMÓUJDBZUFNÈUJDBMPTUFØMPHPT
DBUØMJDPT BTVNJFSPO QBSB TÓ MB UBSFB EF
BDBEFNJ[BDJØOZMBDPOGSPOUBDJØOEFUF
NBT DPNP FM FOWFKFDJNJFOUP QPCMBDJP
OBM Z FM mO EF MB WJEB #BSDIJGPOUBJOF
"OKPT1FTTJOJ
#FSUBDIJOJ MPT NÏEJ
-BCJPÏUJDBZMBTNVKFSFTFO"NÏSJDB-BUJOB%FCPSB%JOJ[Z%JSDF(VJMIFN
DPT SFTJTUJFSPO FM EJTUBODJBNJFOUP EF MB
CJPÏUJDB DPO SFMBDJØO B MB ÏUJDB NÏEJDB
Z TF FTGPS[BSPO QPS NBOUFOFS TV DPO
USPMQPMÓUJDPGSFOUFBMBJOWBTJØOKVSÓEJDB
(SJTBSE Z MBT NVKFSFT
GFNJOJTUBTTFQPTJDJPOBSPODPNPQSPUB
HPOJTUBTBDBEÏNJDBTEFMBFQJTUFNPMPHÓB
GFNJOJTUB F JOUFSMPDVUPSBT QÞCMJDBT EF
MB CJPÏUJDB JOUSPEVDJFOEP VOB OVFWB
JEFOUJEBEBMBCJPÏUJDBMBUJOPBNFSJDBOB
DPNPIFSSBNJFOUBEFBEWPDBDZZEFDSÓ
UJDB TPDJBM %JOJ[ 7FMF[ 0MJWFJSB.PUB
&TP OP TJHOJmDB TJO FNCBSHP RVF
UFØMPHPTDBUØMJDPTPNÏEJDPTEFEJDBEPT
B MB QPMÓUJDB EF DMBTF TF IBZBO DBMMBEP
EFMBOUF EF UFNBT DPNP FM BCPSUP P MBT
UFDOPMPHÓBT SFQSPEVDUJWBT -B SFEJTUSJ
CVDJØO EF DPNQFUFODJBT FO MB NBUFSJB
PDVSSJØ FO FM JOUFSJPS EF MB FNFSHFOUF
DPNVOJEBEEFFTQFDJBMJTUBTFOCJPÏUJDB
FOMBDVBMTFWFSJmDBDPONÈTOJUJEF[FTB
PSHBOJ[BDJØOEFMBTFTQFDJBMJEBEFT
-BQFSNBOFOUFDPOTUSVDDJØOEFMBCJPÏ
UJDBFO"NÏSJDB-BUJOBQFSNJUFRVFMBT
GSPOUFSBTFOUSFFTPTEJGFSFOUFTBDUPSFTOP
TFBOUBOOÓUJEBT/PTJHOJmDBUBNQPDP
-B DVFTUJØO EF MB BOFODFGBMJB FO #SBTJM FT VO
FKFNQMPEFFTBSFEJTUSJCVDJØOEFDPNQFUFODJBT
-PTUFØMPHPTDBUØMJDPTRVFTFQSPOVODJBSPOFO
FMEFCBUFQÞCMJDPOPTPOFTQFDJBMJTUBTFOCJPÏ
UJDB&TFEFCBUFJOWPMVDSØBMPTSFQSFTFOUBOUFT
PmDJBMFTEFMB*HMFTJB$BUØMJDBCSBTJMF×BZOPB
MPTJOUFMFDUVBMFTDBUØMJDPTEFMBDPNVOJEBEEF
CJPÏUJDB
-B 4PDJFEBE #SBTJMF×B EF #JPÏUJDB FT VOP EF
FTPT FTQBDJPT EF PSHBOJ[BDJØO EF MBT DPNQF
UFODJBT FO FM NBSDP EF MB CJPÏUJDB CSBTJMF×B
&M'PSP-BUJOPBNFSJDBOPEF$PNJUÏTEF²UJDB
FO*OWFTUJHBDJØOFO4BMVE'-"$&*4
FTPUSP
FKFNQMPFOFMÈNCJUPSFHJPOBM
PERSPETIVADELABIOETICAINDD
RVF TØMP FYJTUBO FTPT HSVQPT FTQFDJBM
NFOUFDPOTJEFSBOEPFMDSFDJNJFOUPEFMB
CJPÏUJDBFOFMVOJWFSTPKVSÓEJDP&O#SB
TJMIVCPDBTPTEFNVKFSFTGFNJOJTUBTFO
CJPÏUJDBRVFFSBOUBNCJÏOBDUJWBTQBSUJD
JQBOUFTEFMBQPMÓUJDBFOTBMVEPEFNV
KFSFTGFNJOJTUBTUFØMPHBTDVZBTPCSBTGVFS
PO SFGFSFODJB QBSB FM TVSHJNJFOUP EF MB
CJPÏUJDB(FCBSBZ0MJWFJSB
0MJWFJSB 0MJWFJSB 'FSSB[ 'FSSFJSB /PPCTUBOUFFTQPTJCMFSFDPOPDFS
EJGFSFODJBTEFJOUFSFTFTFOUSFMPTHSVQPT
ZRVFFMDBSÈDUFSUPEBWÓBFOGPSNBDJØOEF
MBTGSPOUFSBTEJTDJQMJOBSJBTEFMBCJPÏUJDB
GBWPSFDFFMBOÈMJTJTEFTEFFTBTEJGFSFOUFT
QFSTQFDUJWBT
&OUSFQSPUBHPOJTUBTBDBEÏNJDBT
FJOUFSMPDVUPSBTQÞCMJDBT
-BCJPÏUJDBFTVOOVFWPTBCFSFOMBJO
UFSGB[ EFM DPOPDJNJFOUP BDBEÏNJDP Z
EFMBBDDJØOQPMÓUJDB1PSTFSVOÈNCJUP
UPEBWÓBFOGPSNBDJØOMBTEJTQVUBTFQJT
UFNPMØHJDBTTPOJOUFOTBTFTQFDJBMNFOUF
FO QBÓTFT EPOEF MB JOTUJUVDJPOBMJ[BDJØO
BDBEÏNJDBFTSFDJFOUF&O"NÏSJDB-B
UJOBFTQPTJCMFJEFOUJmDBSEPTFTDFOBSJPT
EJGFSFOUFT EF EJTQVUBT QPS MB DPOmHV
SBDJØO EJTDJQMJOBSJB EF MB CJPÏUJDB Z FO
BNCPT FM QBQFM EF MBT NVKFSFT IB TJEP
GVOEBNFOUBM
&OFMFTDFOBSJPBDBEÏNJDPFMQSPUBHP
OJTNPEFMBTNVKFSFTTFFYQSFTBEFEPT
NBOFSBT1PSVOMBEPDPNPQBSUFEFMB
DPNVOJEBEEFEJDBEBBJOTUJUVDJPOBMJ[BS
MB CJPÏUJDB FO MBT VOJWFSTJEBEFT $PNP
VOB QSPGFDÓB BVUPDVNQMJEB HSBO QBSUF
EFMBTNVKFSFTEFEJDBEBTBMBCJPÏUJDBTF
1FSTQFDUJWBTEFMB#JPÏUJDBFO*CFSPBNÏSJDB
FTQFDJBMJ[ØFOUFNBTSFMBDJPOBEPTDPOMB
SFQSPEVDDJØOCJPMØHJDBZTPDJBM&MQSJ
NFSDPODVSTPQÞCMJDPQBSBMBEPDFODJB
FO CJPÏUJDB FO #SBTJM GVF SFBMJ[BEP FO
FOMB6OJWFSTJEBEEFM&TUBEPEF
3ÓP EF +BOFJSP QBSB MB DÈUFESB EF 3F
QSPEVDDJØO #JPMØHJDB 4PDJBM .FEJDB
MJ[BDJØO Z #JPÏUJDB Z FM TFHVOEP QBSB
#JPÏUJDB7VMOFSBCJMJEBEZ²UJDBFO*O
WFTUJHBDJØO DPO 4FSFT )VNBOPT QBSB
MB 6OJWFSTJEBE $BUØMJDB EF #SBTJMJB FO
&O "NÏSJDB -BUJOB MB QSJNF
SB UFTJT EF EPDUPSBEP FTQFDÓmDBNFOUF
TPCSF CJPÏUJDB oi/VFWBT 5FDOPMPHÓBT
3FQSPEVDUJWBTZ(FOÏUJDBT²UJDBZ'F
NJOJTNP-B$FMFCSBDJØOEFM5FNPSwo
GVF EFGFOEJEB FO &O MB
0SHBOJ[BDJØO 1BOBNFSJDBOB EF 4BMVE
JOTUJUVZØ FM QSFNJP i.BOVFM 7FMBTDP
4VÈSF[ EF #JPÏUJDBw DPO FM QSPQØTJUP
EF QSFNJBS KØWFOFT JOWFTUJHBEPSFT MBUJ
OPBNFSJDBOPTEFCJPÏUJDB&MQSFNJPZB
IBTJEPPUPSHBEPDVBUSPWFDFTTJFNQSF
QBSBNVKFSFT
&OFMQSJNFSDPODVSTPGVFBQSPCBEB.BSJMFOB
$PSSÐB Z %FCPSB %JOJ[ GVF VOB EF MBT FWB
MVBEPSBT EFM KVSBEP &O FM TFHVOEP DPODVSTP
%FCPSB%JOJ[GVFMBDBOEJEBUBBQSPCBEB-PT
DPODVSTPT SFQSFTFOUBO VO NBSDP JNQPSUBOUF
QBSB MB JOTUJUVDJPOBMJ[BDJØO EF MB EJTDJQMJOB
QVFT TJHOJmDB FM SFDPOPDJNJFOUP EF MB DPNV
OJEBEBDBEÏNJDBBMTVSHJNJFOUPEFVOBOVFWB
FTQFDJBMJEBE
3PUBOJB " /PWBT 5FDOPMPHJBT 3FQSP
EVUJWBTF(FOÏUJDBT²UJDBF'FNJOJTNP"$FMF
CSBÎÍPEP5FNPS3JPEF+BOFJSP6'3+*OTUJ
UVUP"MCFSUP-VJ[$PJNCSBEF1PT(SBEVBÎÍP
F1FTRVJTBEF&OHFOIBSJBo$011&<5FTFEF
%PVUPSBEP 1SPHSBNB EF 1PT(SBEVBÎÍP FN
&OHFOIBSJB>
&OMBQSJNFSBFEJDJØOFO%FCPSB%JOJ[
CSBTJMF×BGVFMBHBOBEPSBDPOFMUFNBi*OGPSNB
DJØOHFOÏUJDBZKVTUJDJBVOEFTBGÓPCJPÏUJDPwFO
MBTFHVOEB3PTB"OHFMJOB1BDFBSHFOUJOBDPO
FMUFNBi5SBTQMBOUFTEFØSHBOPTZMBFOTF×BO[B
PERSPETIVADELABIOETICAINDD
0USP BTQFDUP EFM QSPUBHPOJTNP BDBEÏ
NJDPEFMBTNVKFSFTQBSBMBQSPNPDJØO
EF MB CJPÏUJDB BDFSDB B #SBTJM B PUSPT
QBÓTFT EF MB SFHJØO FO FTQFDJBM "SHFO
UJOB $IJMF Z $PMPNCJB %FCJEP B MB
FTDBTBQSPEVDDJØOEFMJUFSBUVSBCJPÏUJDB
FO "NÏSJDB -BUJOB MB QSJNFSB EÏDBEB
EF JOTUJUVDJPOBMJ[BDJØO GVF EF JOUFOTP
JOUFSDBNCJP EF JEFBT FOUSF MB SFHJØO Z
MPT QBÓTFT DFOUSBMFT EF MB EJTDJQMJOB FO
FTQFDJBM&TUBEPT6OJEPT&OFMDBTPFT
UBEPVOJEFOTFMBCJPÏUJDBOPTPMBNFOUF
FTUBCBDPOTPMJEBEBFOMBTVOJWFSTJEBEFT
Z FO FM EFCBUF QÞCMJDP TJOP RVF UBN
CJÏOMBEFJOTQJSBDJØOGFNJOJTUBFSBZB
QBSUFEFMBPSHBOJ[BDJØOZEJTUSJCVDJØO
EFMDBNQP-BEJTUSJCVDJØOSFHJPOBMEFM
DPOPDJNJFOUP BTPDJBEB B MB JNQPSUB
DJØO EF UFPSÓBT DSÓUJDBT GFNJOJTUBT IJ[P
RVFSÈQJEBNFOUFMBCJPÏUJDBGFNJOJTUB
UBNCJÏO DSFDJFSB FO "NÏSJDB -BUJOB
FTQFDJBMNFOUF FO MPT QBÓTFT DPO QPT
HSBEPFTUSVDUVSBEP"SHFOUJOB#SBTJMZ
.ÏYJDP
&M JOUFSDBNCJP EF JEFBT PDVSSJØ CÈTJ
DBNFOUF QPS NFEJP EF MBT FOUJEBEFT
DJFOUÓmDBTFOCJPÏUJDBRVFTVSHÓBOFOMPT
B×PT-PTFODVFOUSPTJOUFSOBDJPOBMFT
FSBO FTQBDJPT QSPQJDJPT QBSB MB GPSNB
DJØO EF BMJBO[BT -B 3FE *OUFSOBDJPOBM
EF1FSTQFDUJWBT'FNJOJTUBTQBSBMB#JP
ÏUJDB'"#
QBSUJDJQBBDUJWBNFOUFFOMB
EF MB CJPÏUJDBw FO MB UFSDFSB .BSÓB (SBDJFMB
0SUÞ[BSBSHFOUJOBDPOi+VTUJDJBJOUFSOBDJPOBM
EFSFDIP B MB TBMVE QSPQJFEBE JOUFMFDUVBM Z FM
HFOPNBIVNBOPwZFOMBDVBSUBFOMB
BSHFOUJOB1BUSJDJB4PSPLJODPOMBQSPQVFTUBEF
USBCBKPUJUVMBEBi5SBUBNJFOUPEFMPTEBUPTQFS
TPOBMFTFOMBJOWFTUJHBDJØOHFOØNJDBBTQFDUPT
CJPÏUJDPTMFHBMFTZTPDJBMFTw1")&'
-BCJPÏUJDBZMBTNVKFSFTFO"NÏSJDB-BUJOB%FCPSB%JOJ[Z%JSDF(VJMIFN
QSJODJQBM FOUJEBE DJFOUÓmDB JOUFSOBDJP
OBM EF CJPÏUJDB MB "TPDJBDJØO *OUFSOB
DJPOBMEF#JPÏUJDB*"#
EFTEFTVGVO
EBDJØOFO:BFOMB'"#
PSHBOJ[Ø FM QSJNFS DPOHSFTP TBUÏMJUF BM
DPOHSFTP EF MB *"# Z EFTEF FOUPODFT
FTMBSFENÈTBDUJWBZDPONÈTQBSUJDJ
QBOUFT-BFOUSBEBEF'"#FO"NÏSJDB
-BUJOB BDPNQB×Ø MB QSPQJB GPSNBDJØO
EFMBSFEDPO"MFKBOESB3PUBOJBDPNP
QSJNFSBSFQSFTFOUBOUFFO)BTUB
BIPSB '"# DVFOUB DPO SFQSFTFOUBOUFT
EF"SHFOUJOB#SBTJM$IJMF$PMPNCJBZ
.ÏYJDPBEFNÈT#SBTJMGVFTFEFEFVOP
EFMPTDPOHSFTPTNVOEJBMFTFO
-B JOTFSDJØO EF MBT JOWFTUJHBEPSBT MBUJ
OPBNFSJDBOBT FO '"# GVF VO QBTP EF
DJTJWPQBSBMBQSPGFDÓBBVUPDVNQMJEBEF
MBTNVKFSFTDPNPFTQFDJBMJTUBTFOUFNBT
SFQSPEVDUJWPT'"#FTVOBSFEEFJOWFT
UJHBEPSBT Z BDBEÏNJDBT EFEJDBEBT B MB
UFNÈUJDBEFMBSFQSPEVDDJØOMBÏUJDBZMB
CJPÏUJDBCBKPMBQFSTQFDUJWBUFØSJDBEFM
GFNJOJTNP
&M GFNJOJTNP DPNP VOB IFSSBNJFOUB
FQJTUFNPMØHJDB QBSB MBT IVNBOJEBEFT
FNFSHJØ FO MPT B×PT Z MPT DBNQPT
EF MB ÏUJDB Z EF MB mMPTPGÓB NPSBM GVF
SPO MPT NÈT EJSFDUBNFOUF QSPWPDBEPT
QPS TVT QFSTQFDUJWBT DSÓUJDBT )BSEJOH
)BZVOJOUFOTPJOUFSDBNCJPEFJEFBTFOUSFMB
*"# Z MB '"# 'MPSFODJB -VOB QPS FKFNQMP
FTVOBEFMBTFYQSFTJEFOUBTEF*"#ZQBSUJDJQB
BDUJWBNFOUFEF'"#
"NÏSJDB-BUJOBZBDPOUØDPOSFQSFTFOUBOUFTEF
QBÓT %FCPSB %JOJ[ #SBTJM
GVF SFQSFTFOUBOUF
EFMBEJSFDUJWBEFB4VTBOB4PN
NFS"SHFOUJOB
EFBZBDUVBMNFO
UF "OB $SJTUJOB (PO[ÈMF[ 7FMÏ[ $PMPNCJB
'"#
PERSPETIVADELABIOETICAINDD
)BSBXBZ )BSBXBZ FU BM
3ÈQJEBNFOUF MBT DPOUSJCVDJP
OFT GFNJOJTUBT DPNFO[BSPO UBNCJÏO
B GPSNBS QBSUF EFM EFCBUF CSBTJMF×P FO
CJPÏUJDBMPRVFSFQSFTFOUØBTVWF[VOB
SFTJTUFODJBBMBNBTJmDBDJØOEFMBUFPSÓB
EFMPTDVBUSPQSJODJQJPTEF5PN#FBV
DIBNQZ+BNFT$IJMESFTT8PMG
%JOJ[ (VJMIFN #FBVDIBNQ
$IJMESFTT $PO MB BDUVBDJØO
EFMBTJOWFTUJHBEPSBTFO'"#ZFO*"#
TFBNQMJØFMIPSJ[POUFEFEFCBUFUFØSJDP
ZUFNÈUJDPMPRVFGPSUBMFDJØFMFTGVFS[P
EFMPTUFØMPHPTDBUØMJDPTEFEFWPMWFSMB
CJPÏUJDBBMBTIVNBOJEBEFTFOFTQFDJBM
BMBÏUJDBTPDJBM
1FSP VOP EF MPT QSJODJQBMFT EFTBGÓPT
QBSB MB FOUSBEB EF MBT QFSTQFDUJWBT GF
NJOJTUBTFOMBCJPÏUJDBMBUJOPBNFSJDBOB
GVF TVQFSBS MB SFTJTUFODJB B MB DBUFHPSÓB
iGFNJOJTNPw %JOJ[ &M NPWJ
NJFOUP GFNJOJTUB MBUJOPBNFSJDBOP QP
TFF VOB BNQMJB IJTUPSJB EF DPORVJTUBT
TPDJBMFT FTQFDJBMNFOUF BM QBSUJDJQBS FO
DPOUSPWFSTJBT RVF HBSBOUJ[BO MPT EFSF
DIPTQPMÓUJDPTZTPDJBMFT4JOFNCBSHPMB
FTUSBUFHJBEFBDDJØOEFMPTNPWJNJFOUPT
TPDJBMFTGVFNBZPSJUBSJBNFOUFQPMÓUJDBZ
FMFTQBDJPEFBDUVBDJØOGVFMBTPDJFEBE
DJWJMZMBTJOTUJUVDJPOFTCÈTJDBTEFM&TUB
EP -B JOTFSDJØO EFM GFNJOJTNP FO MBT
VOJWFSTJEBEFT OP GVF DPOTJEFSBEB VOB
QSJPSJEBEFOMBTBDDJPOFTQPMÓUJDBTEFMBT
NVKFSFT EVSBOUF VO MBSHP QFSÓPEP /P
FTFYBHFSBEPBmSNBSRVFMBFOUSBEBEF
MBCJPÏUJDBGFNJOJTUBFO"NÏSJDB-BUJOB
DPJODJEJØDPOFMTVSHJNJFOUPEFMBFQJT
UFNPMPHÓB GFNJOJTUB FO MBT VOJWFSTJEB
EFT
1FSTQFDUJWBTEFMB#JPÏUJDBFO*CFSPBNÏSJDB
&OUSFZVOBFTUSBUFHJBBEPQ
UBEB QPS BMHVOPT HSVQPT EF NVKFSFT FO
MBTVOJWFSTJEBEFTGVFEFmOJSTFDPNPFT
QFDJBMJTUBTFOHÏOFSPFWJUBOEPBTÓMBSF
GFSFODJBBMGFNJOJTNP%JOJ['PMUSBO
-B TVCTUJUVDJØO EF MB
DBUFHPSÓB iGFNJOJTNPw QPS MB EF iHÏOF
SPwQFSNJUÓBMBEFCJEBJOTFSDJØOEJTDJQMJ
OBSEFMBTJOWFTUJHBEPSBTFOMPTFTUVEJPT
TPCSF NVKFSFT QFSP EFTWJBCB FM FOGSFO
UBNJFOUP BSHVNFOUBUJWP QSPWPDBEP QPS
MBSFGFSFODJBBMGFNJOJTNP&TBGVFQP
TJCMFNFOUFVOBEFDJTJØOEFTVQFSWJWFO
DJBBDBEÏNJDBDPNÞOBWBSJBTJOWFTUJHB
EPSBTMBUJOPBNFSJDBOBTFOFTQFDJBMBMBT
JOTFSUBT FO VOJWFSTJEBEFT DPOGFTJPOBMFT
%JOJ[
-BFOUSBEBEFMB
CJPÏUJDBGFNJOJTUBFO"NÏSJDB-BUJOBDP
JODJEJØDPOVOBGBTFEFSFDPOPDJNJFOUP
EFMBTGSPOUFSBTFQJTUFNPMØHJDBTFOUSFFM
GFNJOJTNPZFMHÏOFSPMPRVFGBDJMJUØMB
QSPQJBJEFOUJmDBDJØOEFMBTKØWFOFTJOWFT
UJHBEPSBTEFCJPÏUJDBDPNPGFNJOJTUBT
)BZ EJGFSFODJBT JNQPSUBOUFT FOUSF MBT
QFSTQFDUJWBTGFNJOJTUBTZEFHÏOFSPFOFM
QFOTBNJFOUPDJFOUÓmDP8PMG
&M
GFNJOJTNPQBSUFEFVODPNQSPNJTPEF
DSÓUJDBQPMÓUJDBBMBTVQVFTUBOFVUSBMJEBE
EFHÏOFSPEFMBDJFODJBZBTVNFMBUBSFB
EF SFEFTDSJCJS FM EJTDVSTP BDBEÏNJDP
FOUÏSNJOPTNÈTKVTUPTQBSBMPTHSVQPT
TVCBMUFSOPT 1PS FTP MB DBUFHPSÓB WVM
OFSBCJMJEBEFTUBOTFEVDUPSBQBSBMBTJO
WFTUJHBEPSBTGFNJOJTUBTEFMBCJPÏUJDBBM
NJTNPUJFNQPRVFSFTVNFMBGSBHJMJEBE
EFBMHVOPTHSVQPTEFNBOEBQSPUFDDJØO
ZDVJEBEPBMPTRVFWJWFOFTBEFTJHVBM
EBE (VJMIFN "M DPOUSBSJP EF
MPT FTUVEJPT EF HÏOFSP MBT QFSTQFDUJWBT
PERSPETIVADELABIOETICAINDD
GFNJOJTUBT TPO DPNQSPNFUJEBT DPO MB
JOUFSWFODJØO FO FM NVOEP SFBM : GVF
FYBDUBNFOUFFTFFOGPRVFUFØSJDPZNFUP
EPMØHJDPEFMBCJPÏUJDBGFNJOJTUBMPRVF
MBIJ[PUBOTFEVDUPSBBMBTKØWFOFTJOWFT
UJHBEPSBTEFMBCJPÏUJDBMBUJOPBNFSJDBOB
-BTQFSTQFDUJWBTGFNJOJTUBTEFMBCJPÏUJDB
GPSUBMFDJFSPOFMFTGVFS[PEFEJÈMPHPQPMÓ
UJDPZBJOJDJBEPQPSMPTNPWJNJFOUPTEF
NVKFSFTFO"NÏSJDB-BUJOB-BCJPÏUJDB
GFNJOJTUB TF USBOTGPSNØ FO VOB OVFWB
IFSSBNJFOUBBSHVNFOUBUJWBFOFTQFDJBM
QPSMBDSFDJFOUFMBJDJ[BDJØOEFMPTFTQB
DJPTQÞCMJDPTFOMBSFHJØO"MDPOUSBSJP
EFMPTQBÓTFTDFOUSBMFTEFMBCJPÏUJDBFO
MPTDVBMFTFMTVSHJNJFOUPEFMBEJTDJQMJ
OBTFEJPFODPOUFYUPTDPOTUJUVDJPOBMFT
EF TFDVMBSJ[BDJØO EFM &TUBEP FO "NÏ
SJDB -BUJOB FYJTUFO QBÓTFT FO MPT RVF FM
FKFSDJDJP EF MB QMVSJDPOGFTJPOBMJEBE EFM
&TUBEPEFTFTUBCJMJ[BBMBEFNPDSBDJB&O
FTUFDPOUFYUPMPTUFNBTCJPÏUJDPTEFFT
QFDJBMJEBEEFMBTJOWFTUJHBEPSBTGFNJOJT
UBTTPOMPTRVFFYJHFONÈTFTGVFS[PEF
JOUFSMPDVDJØOQÞCMJDB
-BEFmOJDJØOEFVOBBHFOEBSFHJPOBMEF
JOWFTUJHBDJØO Z QSPEVDDJØO JOUFMFDUVBM
GFNJOJTUB FO MB CJPÏUJDB DPOTJEFSØ FTB
EPCMF JOTFSDJØO EF MBT JOWFTUJHBEPSBT
QSPUBHPOJTUBT BDBEÏNJDBT F JOUFSMPDV
UPSBTQÞCMJDBT$JFSUPTUFNBTDPNPFM
6OFTQBDJPQSJWJMFHJBEPQBSBBOBMJ[BSFTBEPCMF
JOTFSDJØOEFMBTNVKFSFTFOMBCJPÏUJDBCSBTJMF
×BQVFEFTFSMBIJTUPSJBEFMBQBSUJDJQBDJØOFO
MPT DPNJUÏT EF ÏUJDB FO JOWFTUJHBDJØO Z FO MB
$PNJTJØO/BDJPOBMEF²UJDBFO*OWFTUJHBDJØO
#SBTJM Z -BT NVKFSFT UVWJFSPO
QBSUJDJQBDJØO EFDJTJWB EFTEF MB GPSNBDJØO EFM
HSVQPNVMUJEJTDJQMJOBSJPEFUSBCBKPJOTUJUVJEP
QBSBFMBCPSBSMB3FTPMVDJØO
-BCJPÏUJDBZMBTNVKFSFTFO"NÏSJDB-BUJOB%FCPSB%JOJ[Z%JSDF(VJMIFN
BCPSUPTJFNQSFFTUVWJFSPOFOFMFTDFOB
SJPEFMBTEJTDVTJPOFTCJPÏUJDBTJOUFSOB
DJPOBMFTQFSPMBSFBMJEBEMBUJOPBNFSJDB
OB FYJHÓB EF MBT NVKFSFT FO MB CJPÏUJDB
VOB SFEFTDSJQDJØO EF MBT QFSTQFDUJWBT
JOUFSOBDJPOBMFT "M DPOUSBSJP RVF FO FM
EFCBUF CJPÏUJDP FTUBEPVOJEFOTF P GSBO
DÏT TPCSF FM BCPSUP EPOEF TF BWBO[B
FOVOBBSHVNFOUBDJØOSB[POBCMFTPCSF
FM FTUBUVUP EFM FNCSJØO Z EFM GFUP FO
"NÏSJDB-BUJOBFMNBSDPUFØSJDPUPEBWÓB
FTMBOFDFTJEBEEFMBJDJ[BDJØOEFM&TUBEP
QBSBFMEFCBUFQÞCMJDPTPCSFDVFTUJPOFT
SFQSPEVDUJWBT0TFBBMNJTNPUJFNQP
RVFNVZQSFDP[NFOUFTFFTUSVDUVSBCBO
MB[PT BDBEÏNJDPT FOUSF JOWFTUJHBEPSBT
GFNJOJTUBT MBUJOPBNFSJDBOBT Z PUSBT EF
QBÓTFT DFOUSBMFT UBNCJÏO TF QSPNPWÓB
VO FTQÓSJUV DSÓUJDP Z QMVSBM GSFOUF B MBT
FTUSBUFHJBTBSHVNFOUBUJWBT6OBQPTJCMF
DPOTFDVFODJBEFFTFFKFSDJDJPBSHVNFO
UBUJWPTFOTJCMFBMBTQBSUJDVMBSJEBEFTDVM
UVSBMFT FT MB BQSPYJNBDJØO DSFDJFOUF EF
KØWFOFT JOWFTUJHBEPSBT QSPWFOJFOUFT EF
MBT IVNBOJEBEFT B MB CJPÏUJDB MBUJOPB
NFSJDBOB
.VKFSFTZOVFWPTEFTBGÓPT
&MIFDIPEFRVFMBCJPÏUJDBTFBVODBN
QP FNFSHFOUF BCSF FTQBDJP QBSB RVF
EJGFSFOUFTHSVQPTMFOHVBKFTZEJTDVSTPT
CVTRVFO SFDPOPDJNJFOUP FO MB DPNV
OJEBE&TFDBSÈDUFSMBUSBOTGPSNBFOVO
FTQBDJP JMJNJUBEP EF QPTJCJMJEBEFT EF
EJÈMPHPZEFFYQSFTJØOBSHVNFOUBUJWB
&T DSFDJFOUF TV UFOUBUJWB EF EFmOJSTF
DPNP VOB EJTDJQMJOB BDBEÏNJDB Z QPS
UBOUP FM FTGVFS[P QFSNBOFOUF EF MBT
PERSPETIVADELABIOETICAINDD
NVKFSFT FO MB CJPÏUJDB FT UBNCJÏO QPS
HBSBOUJ[BS MB JODMVTJØO EFM GFNJOJTNP
DPNPIFSSBNJFOUBBOBMÓUJDB)PZHSBO
QBSUFEFMPTQSPHSBNBTEFQPTHSBEPFO
TBMVE P IVNBOJEBEFT DPO BTJHOBUVSBT
EF CJPÏUJDB FO MPT DVSSÓDVMPT JODMVZF
SFGFSFODJBT GFNJOJTUBT JOUFSOBDJPOBMFT Z
SFHJPOBMFT &TB FT VOB USBOTGPSNBDJØO
JNQPSUBOUFFYQFSJNFOUBEBFOMBÞMUJNB
EÏDBEBEFJOTUJUVDJPOBMJ[BDJØOEFMBCJP
ÏUJDBFO"NÏSJDB-BUJOB
&O FTUF FTGVFS[P EF QFSNBOFODJB Z FY
QBOTJØOVOBEFMBTQSJODJQBMFTDPOUSJCV
DJPOFT EF MBT NVKFSFT MBUJOPBNFSJDBOBT
IBTJEPFMSFDPOPDJNJFOUPEFEJGFSFOUFT
FTQBDJPT EF EJTDVTJØO Z FTUSBUFHJBT EF
EJÈMPHPZOPTPMBNFOUFMBTVOJWFSTJEB
EFTZMBTQVCMJDBDJPOFTFOUSFQBSFT*OJ
DJBUJWBTDPNPMBTCSBTJMF×BTZNFYJDBOBT
EFQSPEVDDJØOEFWJEFPTZEPDVNFOUB
MFTTPOVOFKFNQMPEFFTFFTGVFS[PQPS
BNQMJBS FM IPSJ[POUF EF QSPUBHPOJTNP
BDBEÏNJDP Z EF JOUFSMPDVDJØO QÞCMJDB
GBDJMJUBOEP MB DPNQSFOTJØO EF MPT BS
HVNFOUPT CJPÏUJDPT %JOJ[ #SVN
$'' 0USP FKFNQMP EF
FTB EJWFSTJEBE EF MFOHVBKFT FT MB JOTFS
DJØO FO JOTUJUVDJPOFT EF JOWFTUJHBDJØO
VOJWFSTJEBEFT NPWJNJFOUPT TPDJBMFT Z
PSHBOJ[BDJPOFTOPHVCFSOBNFOUBMFTVO
GFOØNFOPPCTFSWBEPFOUSFUPEBTMBTJO
WFTUJHBEPSBTGFNJOJTUBTNÈTBDUJWBTEFMB
CJPÏUJDBMBUJOPBNFSJDBOB
$PO UPEP MB BDUJWJEBE DVFOUB UPEBWÓB
DPO QPDBT NVKFSFT &TB FYQSFTJØO EF
TJHVBM EF HÏOFSP FT VO SFTRVJDJP EF TV
HÏOFTJTDVZBBQSPYJNBDJØODPOMBTEJT
DJQMJOBT NÏEJDBT Z UFPMØHJDBT SFTUSJOHÓB
1FSTQFDUJWBTEFMB#JPÏUJDBFO*CFSPBNÏSJDB
MB QBSUJDJQBDJØO EF MBT NVKFSFT 0USB
QPTJCMFFYQMJDBDJØOFTRVFMBBDUVBDJØO
QSPGFTJPOBMFYDMVTJWBFOCJPÏUJDBFTSBSB
UPEBWÓBFOMBSFHJØOMBmHVSBEFMCJPFUJ
DJTUBQSPGFTJPOBMFTUÈQPSTFSJOTUJUVJEB
-B QSJNFSB HFOFSBDJØO EF FTQFDJBMJTUBT
FO CJPÏUJDB PSJVOEB EF VOJWFSTJEBEFT
MBUJOPBNFSJDBOBT FTUÈ TJFOEP GPSNB
EB$POMBFYQBOTJØOFOMBSFHJØOZMB
DSFDJFOUFQSPGFTJPOBMJ[BDJØOEFMBTNV
KFSFTFTEFFTQFSBSVOSÈQJEPDBNCJPFO
MBDPOmHVSBDJØOEFHÏOFSP
3FGFSFODJBT
"OESF+
#JPFUIJDTBTTPNFUIJOHOFX#JPFUIJDTBTBUFSSJUPSZBOBMMFHPSZ5IF
MBOHVBHFPGCJPFUIJDT#JPFUIJDTBTQSBDUJDF*O"OESF+#JPFUIJDTBT1SBDUJDF/PSUI
$BSPMJOB5IF6OJWFSTJUZPG/PSUI$BSPMJOB1SFTTQQ
"OKPT.'
0DPSQPOPFTQFMIPEBEJHOJEBEFFEBWVMOFSBCJMJEBEF0.VOEP
EB4BÞEF
QQ
#BSDIJGPOUBJOF$1
#JPÏUJDBF*OÓDJPEB7JEB"MHVOT%FTBGJPT4ÍP1BVMP*EÏJBT
F-FUSBT
#FBVDIBNQ5$IJMESFTT+
1SJODJQBMTPG#JPNFEJDBM&UIJDT0YGPSE0YGPSE
6OJWFSTJUZ1SFTT
#PVSEJFV1
"HÐOFTFEPTDPODFJUPTEFIBCJUVTFDBNQP&O#PVSEJFV10
1PEFS4JNCØMJDP3JPEF+BOFJSP#FSUSBOE#SBTJMQQ
#PVSEJFV 1 $BNQP EP QPEFS DBNQP JOUFMFDUVBM F IBCJUVT EF DMBTTF &O
#PVSEJFV1"&DPOPNJBEBT5SPDBT4JNCØMJDBT4ÍP1BVMP1FSTQFDUJWBQQ
#SBHB ,4 " $PNVOJDBÎÍP $JFOUÓGJDB F B #JPÏUJDB #SBTJMFJSB #SBTÓMJB 6O# %FQBSUBNFOUPEF$JÐODJBEB*OGPSNBÎÍPF%PDVNFOUBÎÍP<1SPKFUPEF%PVUPSBEP
1SPHSBNBEF1ØT(SBEVBÎÍPFN$JÐODJBEB*OGPSNBÎÍP>
#SBTJM .JOJTUÏSJP EB 4BÞEF $POTFMIP /BDJPOBM EF 4BÞEF /PSNBT
3FHVMBNFOUBEPSBT4PCSF1FTRVJTBT&OWPMWFOEP4FSFT)VNBOPT#SBTJM$/4
#SBTJM.JOJTUÏSJPEB4BÞEF$POTFMIP/BDJPOBMEF4BÞEF
$PNPGVODJPOBB
$POFQ$BEFSOPTEF²UJDBFN1FTRVJTB
$BUIPMJDJTGPSB'SFF$IPJDF
/P&TUÈT4PMB8BTIJOHUPO%$$BUIPMJDJTGPSB
'SFF$IPJDF<%PDVNFOUÈSJP>
$FOUSP6OJWFSTJUÈSJP4ÍP$BNJMP
$VSTPTEF1ØT(SBEVBÎÍP<0OMJOF>%JTQPOJCMF
FOIUUQXXXTDBNJMPFEVCS
$POTFMIP'FEFSBMEF.FEJDJOB
3FWJTUB#JPÏUJDB<0OMJOF>%JTQPOJCMFFOIUUQ
XXXQPSUBMNFEJDPPSHCSSFWJTUBCJPWJOEFYIUN
%FCFFOUFOEFSTFQPSFTQFDJBMJTUBTFOFTUBEJTDJQMJOBBMPTKØWFOFTJOWFTUJHBEPSFTDPOEPDUPSBEPFOCJPÏ
UJDBPTPCSFCJPÏUJDB
PERSPETIVADELABIOETICAINDD
-BCJPÏUJDBZMBTNVKFSFTFO"NÏSJDB-BUJOB%FCPSB%JOJ[Z%JSDF(VJMIFN
$PSSÐB.
/PWBTUFDOPMPHJBTSFQSPEVUJWBTEPBÎÍPEFØWVMPT0RVFQPEFTFS
OPWPOFTTFDBNQP $BEFSOPTEF4BÞEF1ÞCMJDB
QQ
$PSSÐB.
/PWBT5FDOPMPHJBT3FQSPEVUJWBT-JNJUFTEB#JPMPHJBPV#JPMPHJB4FN
-JNJUFT 3JPEF+BOFJSP&E6&3+
$PSSÐB.
1FSTQFDUJWBTEBCJPÏUJDBOP#SBTJM1PMÐNJDBQQ
$PTUB4*'0TFMLB((BSSBGB7
*OJDJBÎÍPË#JPÏUJDB#SBTÓMJB$POTFMIP
'FEFSBMEF.FEJDJOB
%JOJ[ % &EJUPSJBM
&EVDBÎÍP NÏEJDB UBNCÏN VNB RVFTUÍP EF HÐOFSP
3FWJTUBEF&EVDBÎÍP.ÏEJDB
QQ
%JOJ[%
2VBOEPBWFSEBEFÏQPTUBFNEÞWJEB&O%JOJ[%#VHMJPOF4
3JPT330SHT
&OUSFB%ÞWJEBFP%PHNB-JCFSEBEFEF$ÈUFESBF6OJWFSTJEBEFT
$POGFTTJPOBJT#SBTÓMJB-FUSBT-JWSFT1PSUP"MFHSF-JWSBSJBEP"EWPHBEPQQ
%JOJ[%
0%FTBGJPEB#JPÏUJDB'FNJOJTUBOP#SBTJM/PQSFMP
%JOJ[ % #SVN & 6NB )JTUØSJB 4FWFSJOB #SBTÓMJB *NBHFOT-JWSFT
<%PDVNFOUÈSJP>
%JOJ[%(PNFT3
*OGFSUJMJEBEFJOGFDVOEJEBEBDFTTPBOVFWBTUFDOPMPHÓBT
SFQSPEVDUJWBT &O $ÈDFSFT $ $BSFBHB ( 'SBTDB 5 1FDIFOZ . 0SHT
4FYVBMJEBE &TUJHNB Z %FSFDIPT )VNBOPT %FTBGJPT QBSB FM "DFTTP B MB 4BMVE FO
"NÏSJDB-BUJOB-JNB'"41"61$)QQ
%JOJ[%'PMUSBO1
(ÐOFSPFGFNJOJTNPOP#SBTJMVNBBOÈMJTFEB3FWJTUB
&TUVEPT'FNJOJTUBT3FWJTUBEF&TUVEPT'FNJOJTUBT/¡FTQFD
QQ
%JOJ[%(VJMIFN%
#JPÏUJDBGFNJOJTUBPSFTHBUFQPMÓUJDPEPDPODFJUPEF
WVMOFSBCJMJEBEF#JPÏUJDB
QQ
%JOJ[%(VJMIFN%
'FNJOJTNPCJPÏUJDBFWVMOFSBCJMJEBEF3FWJTUB&TUVEPT
'FNJOJTUBT
QQ
%JOJ[%(VJMIFN%
02VFÏ#JPÏUJDB4ÍP1BVMP#SBTJMJFOTF
%JOJ[%(VJMIFN%(BSSBGB7
#JPFUIJDTJO#SB[JM#JPFUIJDTQQ
%JOJ[%7FMF["$(
#JPÏUJDBGFNJOJTUBBFNFSHÐODJBEBEJGFSFOÎB3FWJTUB
&TUVEPT'FNJOJTUBT
QQ
%JOJ[%7FMF["$(
"CPSUPZSB[ØOQÞCMJDBFMEFTBGÓPEFMBBOFODFGBMJB
FO#SBTJM&O$IFDB40SH
3FBMJEBEFTZ$PZVOUVSBTEFM"CPSUP#VFOPT"JSFT
1BJEØTQQ
'FNJOJTU"QQSPBDIFTUP#JPFUIJDT
/FXTMFUUFS<0OMJOF>%JTQPOJCMFFOIUUQ
XXXGBCOFUPSH
(BSSBGB7%JOJ[%(VJMIFN%
#JPFUIJDBMMBOHVBHFBOEJUTEJBMFDUTBOE
JEJPMFDUT$BEFSOPTEF4BÞEF1ÞCMJDBTVQM
QQ
(FCBSB*
3PNQFOEPP4JMÐODJP1FUSØQPMJT7P[FT
PERSPETIVADELABIOETICAINDD
1FSTQFDUJWBTEFMB#JPÏUJDBFO*CFSPBNÏSJDB
(FCBSB*
/PWBTSFMBÎÜFTEFHÐOFSPTÍPQPTTÓWFJT<0OMJOF>%JTQPOJCMFFOIUUQ
MBUJOPBNFSJDBOBPSHUFYUPTQPSUVHVFT(FCBSBIUN
(SJTBSE/
²UJDBNÏEJDBFCJPÏUJDBBEJTDJQMJOBRVFGBMUBOBHSBEVBÎÍPNÏEJDB
#JPÏUJDB
QQ
(VJMIFN%
#JPÏUJDBGFNJOJTUBFPDPODFJUPEFWVMOFSBCJMJEBEFOBTQFTRVJTBT
CJPNÏEJDBTFOWPMWFOEPTFSFTIVNBOPT&O4PSPLJO10SH
#JPÏUJDB&OUSF6UPQÓBT
Z%FTBSSBJHPT-JCSP)PNFOBKFBMB1SPG%SB(MBEZT+.BDLJOTPO#VFOPT"JSFT
&EJUPSB"E)PDQQ
(VJMIFN%
&TDSBWBTEP3JTDP#JPÏUJDB.VMIFSFTF"*%4#SBTÓMJB&EJUPSB6O#
'JOBUFD
)BSBXBZ%
4JNJBOT$ZCPSHTBOE8PNFO5IF3FJOWFOUJPOPG/BUVSF/FX
:PSL3PVUMFEHF
)BSBXBZ%4IFMMFZ.1FSLJOT(FUBM
6OGBNJMJBM#POET5FDIOPMPHJDBM
'JDUJPOBOEUIF3FJNBHJOBUJPOPG(FOEFS"OO"SCPS1SP2VFTU6.*
)BSEJOH4
4DJFODFBOE4PDJBM*OFRVBMJUZ'FNJOJTUBOE1PTUDPMPOJBM*TTVFT3BDF
BOE(FOEFSJO4DJFODF
$IJDBHP$IBNQBJO6OJWFSTJUZPG*MMJOPJT1SFTT
-PZPMB . 1JFSSF #PVSEJFV &OUSFWJTUBEP QPS .BSJB "OESÏB -PZPMB 3JP EF
+BOFJSP&E6&3+
-VOB'
3B[POFTJOUFSOBTZMBEJTDVTJØOBDFSDBEFMBCPSUP.PSB
QQ
<6OJWFSTJEBEEF#VFOPT"JSFT>
0MJWFJSB ' 'JMIPT EB 5FDOPMPHJB RVFTUÜFT ÏUJDBT EB QSPDSJBÎÍP BTTJTUJEB 0
.VOEPEB4BÞEF
QQ
0MJWFJSB ' "T OPWBT UFDOPMPHJBT SFQSPEVUJWBT DPODFQUJWBT B TFSWJÎP EB
NBUFSJBMJ[BÎÊPEFEFTFKPTTFYJTUBTSBDJTUBTFFVHÐOJDPT #JPÏUJDB
QQ
0MJWFJSB ' 'FNJOJTNP SBÎBFUOJB QPCSF[B F CJPÏUJDB B CVTDB EB KVTUJÎB EF
HÐOFSPBOUJSBDJTUBFEFDMBTTF&O(BSSBGB71FTTJOJ-0SHT
#JPÏUJDB1PEFS
F*OKVTUJÎB4ÍP1BVMP-PZPMBQQ
0MJWFJSB''FSSB[5$'FSSFJSB-$0
*EÏJBTGFNJOJTUBTTPCSFCJPÏUJDB
3FWJTUBEF&TUVEPT'FNJOJTUBT
QQ
0MJWFJSB'.PUB+"$
#JPÏUJDBFBTNVMIFSFT&O3FEF/BDJPOBM'FNJOJTUB
EF4BÞEFF%JSFJUPT3FQSPEVUJWPT4BÞEFEB.VMIFSF%JSFJUPT3FQSPEVUJWPT%PTTJÐT
4ÍP1BVMP3FEF4BÞEFQQ
0SHBOJ[BDJØO 1BOBNFSJDBOB EF MB 4BMVE 1SPHSBNB EF #JPÏUJDB <0OMJOF>
%JTQPOJCMFFOIUUQXXXQBIPPSHTQBOJTICJPIPNFIUN
1BO "NFSJDBO )FBMUI BOE &EVDBUJPO 'PVOEBUJPO 1SFNJP .BOVFM 7FMBTDP
4VÈSF[%JTQPOJCMFFOIUUQXXXQBIFGPSHBXBSETCJPFUIJDT@FTPWFSWJFX
1FTTJOJ-#BSDIGPOUBJOF$1
'VOEBNFOUPTEF#JPÏUJDB4ÍP1BVMP-PZPMB
PERSPETIVADELABIOETICAINDD
-BCJPÏUJDBZMBTNVKFSFTFO"NÏSJDB-BUJOB%FCPSB%JOJ[Z%JSDF(VJMIFN
1FTTJOJ-#FSUBDIJOJ-
/PWBTQFSTQFDUJWBTFNDVJEBEPTQBMJBUJWPTÏUJDB
HFSJBUSJBHFSPOUPMPHJBDPNVOJDBÎÍPFFTQÓSJUVBMJEBEF0.VOEPEB4BÞEF
QQ
3PUBOJB " /PWBT 5FDOPMPHJBT 3FQSPEVUJWBT F (FOÏUJDBT ²UJDB F 'FNJOJTNP "
$FMFCSBÎÍPEP5FNPS3JPEF+BOFJSP6'3+*OTUJUVUP"MCFSUP-VJ[$PJNCSBEF1ØT
(SBEVBÎÍPF1FTRVJTBEF&OHFOIBSJB$011&<5FTFEF%PVUPSBEPo1SPHSBNBEF
1ØT(SBEVBÎÍPFN&OHFOIBSJB>
3PUBOJB " 'PSNBT BUVBJT EF JOUFSWFOÎÍP OP DPSQP EBT NVMIFSFT VN
RVFTUJPOBNFOUP$BEFSOPEB4FNQSF7JWB.VMIFSFT$PSQPF4BÞEFQQ<0O
MJOF>%JTQPOJCMFFOIUUQXXXCPFMMMBUJOPBNFSJDBPSHEPXOMPBE@QU
4JRVFJSB+&4BLBJ.)&JTFMF3-
0&OTJOPEBÏUJDBOPDVSTPEF.FEJ
DJOBBFYQFSJÐODJBEB6OJWFSTJEBEF&TUBEVBMEF-POESJOB6&-
#JPÏUJDB
QQ
4PNNFS4
(FOÏUJDB$MPOBDJØOZ#JPÏUJDB{$ØNP"GFDUBMB$JFODJB/VFTUSBT7J
EBT #VFOPT"JSFT#JCMPT
4PSPLJO1
#JPÏUJDB&OUSF6UPQÓBTZ%FTBSSBJHPT-JCSP)PNFOBKFBMB1SPG%SB
(MBEZT+.BDLJOTPO#VFOPT"JSFT&EJUPSJBM"E)PD
6OJUFE/BUJPOT&EVDBUJPOBM4DJFOUJGJDBOE$VMUVSBM0SHBOJ[BUJPO
6/&4$0
$IBJST<0OMJOF>%JTQPOJCMFFOIUUQQPSUBMVOFTDPPSHFEVDBUJPOFTFW
7BMEFCFOJUP$-BNB"-PMBT'
3FMBDJØONVKFSZCJPUFDOPMPHÓBBQSPYJ
NBDJØOBMJNQBDUPEFMBCJPÏUJDB"DUB#JPFUIJDB
QQ
7FMBTDP4VÈSF[.
*9"OJWFSTBSJPEFMB$PNJTJØO/BDJPOBMEF#JPÏUJDB$JVEBE
EF .ÏYJDP <0OMJOF> %JTQPOJCMF FO IUUQXXXTBMVEHPCNYVOJEBEFTEHDT
TBMB@OPUJDJBTEJTDVSTPT
8PMG4
'FNJOJTN#JPFUIJDT#FZPOE3FQSPEVDUJPO0YGPSE0YGPSE6OJWFSTJUZ
1SFTT
PERSPETIVADELABIOETICAINDD
PERSPETIVADELABIOETICAINDD
1ĒģĥĖ*7
1BTBEPQSFTFOUFZEFTBGÓPTGVUVSPT
PERSPETIVADELABIOETICAINDD
PERSPETIVADELABIOETICAINDD
6OBMFDUVSBDSÓUJDBEFMBCJPÏUJDBMBUJOPBNFSJDBOB
(FSNÈO$BMEFSØO-FHBSEB
*EFOUJmDBOEPVOBQFSTQFDUJWBEF
BDFSDBNJFOUP
&
MUÓUVMPEFFTUFBSUÓDVMPQVFEFQBSF
DFS QSFUFODJPTP Z FM DBSHP OP TFSÓB
EFM UPEP JOGVOEBEP UBMWF[ TF QVFEB
NBUJ[BS EJDJFOEP RVF MB JOUFODJØO OP
DPOTJTUFFOIJTUPSJBSMBCJPÏUJDBFO"NÏ
SJDB-BUJOBTJOPFOEFTUBDBSBMHVOPTEF
TVT SBTHPT TPCSFTBMJFOUFT Z DØNP TVT
GPSUBMF[BTPEFCJMJEBEFTIBOJOnVJEPFO
EFTBSSPMMPT QPTUFSJPSFT $VBMRVJFS WFS
EBEFSPJOUFOUPTFSJPEFDSÓUJDBUJFOFRVF
TFS OFDFTBSJBNFOUF EJBMØHJDP Z QPS
UBOUPFTUÈFOEFVEBEFTEFFMDPNJFO[P
DPORVJFOFTOPTQMBOUFBOMBTQSFHVOUBT
%FCFFOUFOEFSTFRVFTJTFQSPQPOFVOB
MFDUVSBDSÓUJDBUBNCJÏOFTVOIPNFOB
KFBUPEPTBRVFMMPTRVFFTUBCMFDJFSPOMB
SFnFYJØO CJPÏUJDB FO "NÏSJDB -BUJOB
/P TF BTVNF RVF TFSÓB JOUFSFTBOUF OJ
UBNQPDP QPTJCMF BDPOTFKBS B FTUPT BV
UPSFT TPCSF DØNP iEFCJØ IBCFS TJEP FM
DPNJFO[P EF TV USBCBKP FO CJPÏUJDB FO
FTUFDPOUJOFOUFw-BWÓBRVFTFTJHVFFT
EJGFSFOUF TF QSPQPOF RVF QBSUJFOEP
EFM SFDPOPDJNJFOUP EF MB JNQPSUBODJB
EFTVMBCPSSFDPNFOEFNPTVOBMFDUVSB
EFMEFTBSSPMMPEFMBCJPÏUJDBFO"NÏSJDB
-BUJOB DPO TVT GPSUBMF[BT Z EFCJMJEBEFT
ZTPCSFUPEPTJFOEPQSPQPTJUJWPTTPCSF
PERSPETIVADELABIOETICAINDD
MBGPSNBZDPOUFOJEPTRVFFTFEFTBSSPMMP
EFCFBEPQUBS-BIJTUPSJBEFMBCJPÏUJDB
FOOVFTUSPDPOUJOFOUFTFIBDPNFO[BEP
ZBBFTDSJCJSZBSFFTDSJCJSZIPZUFOFNPT
MBQPTJCJMJEBEEFFTDVDIBSiPUSBTWPDFTw
-PMBT 4UFQLF RVF DPOTUJUV
ZFO TV QSFIJTUPSJB /P QPEFNPT TJOP
TFOUJSBENJSBDJØOZSFTQFUPQPSBRVFMMPT
RVFMBJOJDJBSPOQFSPQSFDJTBNFOUFQPS
FTPMFSFOEJSÓBNPTVOQPCSFIPNFOBKF
TJDPOWJSUJÏSBNPTOVFTUSBSFWFSFODJBFO
TBDSBMJ[BDJØO Z OVFTUSBT QSFHVOUBT FO
GØSNVMBTZBDPOWFOJEBT4JQPSBMHPFTUÈ
QSFTFOUFMBCJPÏUJDBFOOVFTUSBSFHJØOFT
QSFDJTBNFOUFQPSRVFRVJFOFTMBJOJDJB
SPO CVTDBCBO QSPGVOEJ[BS FM FKFSDJDJP
EFMBDBQBDJEBEDSÓUJDB-BNJTNBDPOMB
RVFQPEFNPTIBDFSIPZVOBMFDUVSBEF
TVUSBCBKP
&MUSBCBKPEFMPTQJPOFSPTEFM
IVNBOJTNPNÏEJDP
.ÈTRVFVOBUFOEFODJBEFmOJEBMPRVF
TFQVFEFWFSFOMBGBTFJOJDJBMFTVOBTJ
UVBDJØOFOMBDVBMMBCJPÏUJDBTFWBHFT
UBOEP EJTDSFUBNFOUF DPNP VO NPWJ
NJFOUPZRVFSFTQPOEFBVOBJORVJFUVE
KVTUJmDBEB EF DPOUFTUBS OP TØMP B QSP
CMFNBTiBDBEÏNJDPTwTJOPBQSPCMFNBT
iSFBMFTw FO VO FTDFOBSJP DPNQMFKP OP
1FSTQFDUJWBTEFMB#JPÏUJDBFO*CFSPBNÏSJDB
BKFOP B DPOnJDUPT TPDJBMFT Z QPMÓUJDPT
1PSDPOTJHVJFOUFOPFTDBTVBMJEBERVF
MB UFOTJØO FOUSF VOB QPTJCMF BEPQDJØO
DSÓUJDBEFVOBCJPÏUJDBOPSUFBNFSJDBOB
DPOTVÏOGBTJTFOMBBVUPOPNÓBZMPTEF
SFDIPTJOEJWJEVBMFTEFMQBDJFOUFZVOB
BDUJUVE NVDIP NÈT QBUFSOBMJTUB FO MB
RVF QSFEPNJOBCB VOB WJTJØO DBUØMJDP
SPNBOBFOMBQSÈDUJDBNÏEJDBTFIJDJFSB
QSFTFOUFBMDPNJFO[PEFFTUFNPWJNJFO
UP DPNP CJFO MP BOPUB + " .BJOFUUJ
.BJOFUUJ
-BCÞTRVFEBEFVOiIVNBOJTNPNÏEJ
DPwoOPTJFNQSFPSJHJOBEPFOVOBUSBEJ
DJØOBOHMPTBKPOBoBMJNFOUØMBSFnFYJØO
TPCSF MB QSÈDUJDB TPDJBM EF MB NFEJDJOB
&TNÏSJUPEFRVJFOFTMJEFSBSPOFTUFNP
WJNJFOUP IBCFS JOWPMVDSBEP FO MB SF
nFYJØO UBOUP MB USBEJDJØO NFEJUFSSÈOFB
EF VOB BOUSPQPMPHÓB NÏEJDB mMPTØmDB
-BÓO &OUSBMHP
DPNP MPT BQPSUFT NÈT
FTQFDÓmDBNFOUF CJPÏUJDPT EF RVJFOFT
EFTEF/PSUFBNÏSJDBTFPDVQBCBOEFMBT
IVNBOJEBEFTNÏEJDBT+5&OHFMIBSEU
& 1FMMFHSJOP
/P FT ÏTUF FM MVHBS QBSB
DBMJmDBS FTF JOUFOUP EF DPOTUJUVJS VOB
GPSNB EF QFOTBNJFOUP TJOP NÈT CJFO
QBSBTF×BMBSRVFBRVFMMPRVFDPOFMQBTP
EFMUJFNQPTFDPOTUJUVZØDPNPVOBCJP
ÏUJDBMBUJOPBNFSJDBOBMBFYQSFTJØOQVF
EF UFOFS WBSJPT TFOUJEPT
UVWP EFTEF FM
DPNJFO[PVOBMUPDPOUFOJEPEFSFnFYJØO
UFØSJDPmMPTØmDBZFOPDBTJPOFTmMPTØ
mDBKVSÓEJDBNÏEJDPTIVNBOJTUBT
&TUBQFSDFQDJØOHFOFSBMDPOUSPWJFSUFVO
QPDPMBUFTJTEFRVFMBBVTFODJBEFVOB
USBEJDJØO mMPTØmDB MBUJOPBNFSJDBOB SF
UBSEBSÓBMBMMFHBEBEFMBCJPÏUJDB'JHVF
SPBZ'VFO[BMJEB
PERSPETIVADELABIOETICAINDD
t
t
t
2VJFOFT FTUBCMFDJFSPO FM NPWJ
NJFOUPEFMBTIVNBOJEBEFTNÏEJ
DBT Z QPTUFSJPSNFOUF MB CJPÏUJDB
OP FSBO mMØTPGPT QSPGFTJPOBMFT FO
FMTFOUJEPFORVFTFFOUFOEFSÓBIPZ
OPPCTUBOUFFSBOQFSTPOBTDPOVOB
CVFOB GPSNBDJØO JOUFMFDUVBM FO
NBSDBEB FO VOB USBEJDJØO IVNB
OJTUBFOTVTFOUJEPDMÈTJDP
-PT FMFNFOUPT UFØSJDPT FTUVWJFSPO
QSFTFOUFTEFTEFFMDPNJFO[PZFTUP
TFIBSFnFKBEPFOFMNPEPEFIBDFS
CJPÏUJDBFO-BUJOPBNÏSJDBVOQPDP
NÈTnFYJCMFZBNQMJBDPOMBTGPSUB
MF[BTZEFCJMJEBEFTRVFFTUPPGSFDF
-BT SFBMJEBEFT QPMÓUJDBT Z TPDJBMFT
MBUJOPBNFSJDBOBT OP GVFSPO BKFOBT
BFTUFUJQPEFSFnFYJØOQPSNVDIP
RVFBMHVOPTEFMPTQSPUBHPOJTUBTEF
MBOBDJFOUFCJPÏUJDBRVJTJFSBOBEPQ
UBSFMNPEFMPEFMBCJPÏUJDBOPSUF
BNFSJDBOB
6O FUIPT QBSUJDVMBS oOP TJFNQSF DPO
EVDFOUF B MB EFNBSDBDJØO FTUSJDUB EF
QSPCMFNBTOJBMBFTQFDJBMJ[BDJØOEJTDJ
QMJOBSJBOJBKFOPBMBJODMVTJØOEFQSP
CMFNBTTPDJBMFTRVFFOPUSBTMBUJUVEFTOP
TFSFDPOPDÓBODPNPQFSUFOFDJFOUFTBMB
CJPÏUJDBoMFEJPBFTUFUJQPEFSFnFYJØO
DJFSUB BQFSUVSB FO OVFTUSP DPOUJOFOUF
"VORVF QVFEF SFTVMUBS QPMÏNJDP Z TV
GSJS MPT SJFTHPT EF VOB HFOFSBMJ[BDJØO
TJONÈTTFQPESÓBOEFTDSJCJSUSFTSBTHPT
DBSBDUFSÓTUJDPTEFMBOBDJFOUFCJPÏUJDBMB
UJOPBNFSJDBOBRVFBVORVFNVDIPNÈT
NBUJ[BEPT TF NBOUJFOFO IPZ FO EÓB
QBSBCJFOPQBSBNBM
t
4V DBSÈDUFS UFØSJDP FTUSFDIBNFOUF
WJODVMBEPBMBTiIVNBOJEBEFTw
6OBMFDUVSBDSÓUJDBEFMBCJPÏUJDBMBUJOPBNFSJDBOB(FSNÈO$BMEFSØO-FHBSEB
t
t
4FSCBTUBOUFJODMVZFOUFMPRVFGB
WPSFDF MB QBSUJDJQBDJØO EF VO BN
QMJPHSVQPEFUFNBTZQSPCMFNBT
4FS VO NPWJNJFOUP TPDJBM RVF
BDPNQB×BDJFSUBTGPSNBTEFBDUJWJT
NP"RVÓTFQVFEFOFODPOUSBSEJT
DVSTPTEFEJGFSFOUFUFOPSRVFWBO
QPSFKFNQMPEFTEFQFSTQFDUJWBTGF
NJOJTUBTPEFRVJFOFTEFmFOEFOMPT
EFSFDIPTEFMBTNJOPSÓBTÏUOJDBTMBT
QSFPDVQBDJPOFTFDPMØHJDBTIBTUBMB
EFGFOTBEFMPTHSFNJPTQBSUJDVMBS
NFOUF EF MPT QSPGFTJPOBMFT EF MB
TBMVERVJFOFTTFWJFSPOBCPDBEPTB
SFnFYJPOBSTPCSFFMVOJWFSTPTPDJBM
ZQPMÓUJDPRVFBMCFSHBCBMBQSÈDUJDB
EFTVTQSPGFTJPOFTFOQBSUFDPNP
DPOTFDVFODJB EF DPNP FMMPT NJT
NPTMPEFOPNJOBSPOMBQSPMFUBSJ
[BDJØOEFMBNFEJDJOB
&O PDBTJPOFT MPT JOUFSFTFT RVF BMJNFO
UBOFMFKFSDJDJPEFMBCJPÏUJDBOPIBOTJEP
QVSBNFOUF JOUFMFDUVBMFT TJOP RVF IBO
UFOJEPRVFWFSDPOPUSPTGBDUPSFT1FSP
FTUPOPMFSFTUBJNQPSUBODJBBMFKFSDJDJP
EFSFnFYJØOOJKVTUJDJBBMBTDBVTBTRVFTF
IBZBOEFGFOEJEPBRVÓ)FNPTEJDIPZB
RVFMBIJTUPSJBEFMBCJPÏUJDBFO"NÏSJDB
-BUJOBIBTJEPPQPSMPNFOPTIBDP
NFO[BEPBTFSFTDSJUBEFTEFEJWFSTPTBV
UPSFTZÏQPDBT+BNFT%SBOF1FESP-BÓO
&OUSBMHP%JFHP(SBDJB"MGPOTP-MBOP
+PTÏ".BJOFUUJZ'FSOBOEP-PMBT
6OBSFTQFUVPTBNJSBEB
SFUSPTQFDUJWB
4FHVSBNFOUFBMNJSBSFOSFUSPTQFDUJWB
MBSFTUBVSBDJØOEFMBEFNPDSBDJBGBWPSF
DJØ FM SFTVSHJS EF EFCBUFT NÈT BNQMJPT
PERSPETIVADELABIOETICAINDD
Z EFMJCFSBDJPOFT TPCSF FM FUIPT NÏEJDP
Z MPT TJTUFNBT EF TBMVE EF MB NJTNB
NBOFSB RVF MB JOUSPEVDDJØO EF OVFWBT
UFDOPMPHÓBTNÏEJDBTQPTJCJMJUBCBVOFT
DFOBSJP RVF SFnFKBCB FM EF MB CJPÏUJDB
OPSUFBNFSJDBOB 1FSP QPS TVQVFTUP
TØMPQBSDJBMNFOUFQVFTMBDPOTUBUBDJØO
EFMBTSFBMJEBEFTEFFTUFDPOUJOFOUFoEF
QSPGVOEBTJOFRVJEBEFTZEJGFSFODJBTFO
DBMJEBEEFWJEBEPOEFFTQPTJCMFFODPO
USBSFOVOBNJTNBDJVEBEVOBVOJEBEEF
DVJEBEPTJOUFOTJWPTBMUBNFOUFTPmTUJDB
EBZVOIPTQJUBMFO[POBTEFQSJNJEBTTJO
FMFNFOUPTCÈTJDPTQBSBMBBUFODJØOoEF
CJØIBCFSHFOFSBEPBMHÞOUJQPEFDPO
nJDUPNPSBMTFHVSBNFOUFGVFDMBSPQBSB
RVJFOFTMJEFSBCBOMBSFnFYJØOFOBRVFMMB
ÏQPDBRVFVOBCJPÏUJDBMBUJOPBNFSJDBOB
OPQPESÓBTFSVOTJNQMFSFnFKPEFMBRVF
TFIBDÓBFO/PSUFBNÏSJDB&MMPTJODPO
UBSDPORVFJODMVTP&TUBEPT6OJEPTEF
"NÏSJDBUJFOFTVQSPQJPVOJWFSTPUFSDFS
NVOEJTUBDPNPRVFEØDMBSPEFTQVÏTEF
/VFWB 0SMFBOT EF TJNJMBS NBOFSB VO
CVFOOÞNFSPEFDJVEBEBOPTFTUBEPVOJ
EFOTFTOPFTUÈOQSPUFHJEPTQPSFMTJTUF
NB EF TBMVE &TUP QBSB BOPUBS RVF MPT
QSPCMFNBTEFQPCSF[BFJOKVTUJDJBUJFOFO
MVHBSFOFMNVOEPEFTBSSPMMBEP
1FSPWPMWJFOEPBMVOJWFSTPEF"NÏSJDB
-BUJOBEFCJØTFOUJSTFMBJOFWJUBCMFUFO
TJØOFOUSFVOBBQVFTUBQPSMPTEFSFDIPT
JOEJWJEVBMFT EF DPSUF NBSDBEBNFOUF
MJCFSBM UBO JNQPSUBOUFT QBSB FM FUIPT
NÏEJDPOPSUFBNFSJDBOPZMPTEFSFDIPT
FDPOØNJDPTZTPDJBMFTEFOPNJOBEPToEF
NBOFSB VO QPDP JNQSFDJTBo EF TFHVO
EBHFOFSBDJØOZRVFDPOTUJUVÓBOCVFOB
QBSUFEFMBTQSFPDVQBDJPOFTEFMEFWFOJS
1FSTQFDUJWBTEFMB#JPÏUJDBFO*CFSPBNÏSJDB
QPMÓUJDP MBUJOPBNFSJDBOP 2VJFOFT MV
DIBCBOQPSJOTUBVSBSMBCJPÏUJDBOPDBSF
DÓBOEFTFOTJCJMJEBENPSBM4FHVSBNFOUF
TBCÓBORVFOPQPEÓBOQMBOUFBSVOBRVF
GVFSBTJNQMFSFnFKPEFMBOPSUFBNFSJDBOB
PMBFVSPQFBBKFOBBMBTSFBMJEBEFTEFTVT
QBÓTFT 1FSP UBNQPDP QPESÓBO BCBOEP
OBSMBQPTJCJMJEBEEFCFOFmDJBSTFDPOVO
OVFWPDBNQPRVFBMNFOPTJOUFOUBCB
BDPSUBSMBTEJTUBODJBTFOUSFMBTDJFODJBTZ
MBTIVNBOJEBEFT
&O SFBMJEBE FT NÏSJUP EF IPNCSFT
DPNP.BJOFUUJFO"SHFOUJOB"VHVTUP
-FØO FO 7FOF[VFMB "MGPOTP -MBOP Z
'FSOBOEP 4ÈODIF[ 5PSSFT FO $PMPN
CJB"SNBOEP3PBFO$IJMFZ.BOVFM
7FMBTDP4VÈSF[FO.ÏYJDP%FTBGPSUV
OBEBNFOUF RVFEBO NVDIPT TJO NFO
DJPOBSBRVÓZMBÞOJDBNBOFSBEFEFGFO
EFSTF EF FTB PNJTJØO FT EFDJS RVF FTUB
IJTUPSJB IB TJEP NVDIP NFKPS DPOUBEB
FO PUSB QBSUF -PMBT 4UFQLF Z
RVF FM QSPQØTJUP EF FTUF BSUÓDVMP OP FT
IJTUPSJBSMBCJPÏUJDB1FSPFTUPTIPNCSFT
UVWJFSPOMBJOUVJDJØOCÈTJDBEFJOUFHSBS
MBT IVNBOJEBEFT Z MBT DJFODJBT TPDJBMFT
BMBUFPSÓBZMBQSÈDUJDBNÏEJDBTFOTVT
QSPQJPT DPOUFYUPT QPMÓUJDPT Z HFPHSÈm
DPTBMBWF[RVFCFOFmDJBSTFEFMOVFWP
GFOØNFOPDVMUVSBMEFMBCJPÏUJDB"VO
RVF EBEB TV QBSB FOUPODFT
SFDJFOUF
DSFBDJØOOPTJFNQSFTFQPESÓBEFNBSDBS
TVmDJFOUFNFOUFFMÈNCJUPEFTVQSPCMF
NÈUJDB
" QBSUJS EF BRVÓ TF QPESÓBO WJTVBMJ[BS
DJFSUBT UFOEFODJBT RVF SFTQPOEFO B MB
OFDFTJEBE EF TJUVBS JOUFSEJTDJQMJOBSJB
NFOUFFMBOÈMJTJTEFBMHVOPTQSPCMFNBT
PERSPETIVADELABIOETICAINDD
DPNVOFTBOVFTUSPTQBÓTFT7FJOUFB×PT
EFTQVÏT RVJ[ÈT TF QVFEF JOUFOUBS FM
FKFSDJDJP SFUSPTQFDUJWP EF NJSBS DVÈOUP
TF IB FWPMVDJPOBEP FO FTF QSPZFDUP EF
DPOTPMJEBS VO NPWJNJFOUP CJPÏUJDP MB
UJOPBNFSJDBOP
&TFFKFSDJDJPDMBSPFTUÈEFCFIBDFSTFEF
GPSNB SFTQFUVPTB RVJFOFT DPNFO[BSPO
MB SFnFYJØO CJPÏUJDB OP UFOÓBO MBT WFO
UBKBTDPNQBSBUJWBTEFRVJFOFTTFJOJDJBO
IPZ FO EÓB JOTUJUVDJPOFT EFEJDBEBT B
MBFOTF×BO[BEFMBNBUFSJBQPSUBMFTFO
MBSFECBTFTEFEBUPTCJCMJPUFDBTFTQF
DJBMJ[BEBT DPOHSFTPT Z TFNJOBSJPT EF
CJPÏUJDBFOUSFPUSBT&TEFDJSUPEBVOB
OPSNBMJ[BDJØOEFMBEJTDJQMJOBFOQBSUF
DPNP DPOTFDVFODJB EF TV JNQVMTP JOJ
DJBMFOFMRVFJOEVEBCMFNFOUFTÓIVCP
HSBO DPSBKF Z QFSTJTUFODJB &M FKFSDJDJP
SFUSPTQFDUJWP EFCF TFSWJSOPT UBNCJÏO
QBSBSFnFYJPOBSTPCSFFMQSFTFOUFEFMB
CJPÏUJDBZQSPTFHVJSIBDJBVOBQSPTQFD
UJWB RVF DPOUFOHB MPT FMFNFOUPT DSÓUJ
DPTOFDFTBSJPToJODMVTPRVFQPTUVMFVO
EFCFS TFS EF MB CJPÏUJDBo QFSNJUJFOEP
RVFDPFYJTUBOEJWFSTBTDPODFQDJPOFTFO
EJÈMPHPZBQSPWFDIFOMBFYQFSJFODJBEFM
DBNJOPSFDPSSJEP
-BFNFSHFODJBEFMBSFnFYJØO
CJPÏUJDBBDFSDBEFDVFTUJPOFT
MBUJOPBNFSJDBOBT
&O FTUF TFOUJEP FT JOEVEBCMF RVF MB
CJPÏUJDB DPOGSPOUØ B MPT NÏEJDPT Z FO
HFOFSBM B MPT QSPGFTJPOBMFT EF MB TBMVE
DPO MBT SFBMJEBEFT QPMÓUJDBT Z FDPOØNJ
DBTFOMBTRVFFTUBCBJONFSTBTVQSÈDUJDB
QSPGFTJPOBM&OBMHVOPTDBTPTDPNPFO
$PMPNCJBMBTBTPDJBDJPOFTEFFOGFSNF
6OBMFDUVSBDSÓUJDBEFMBCJPÏUJDBMBUJOPBNFSJDBOB(FSNÈO$BMEFSØO-FHBSEB
SBTQSPGFTJPOBMFTKVHBSPOoZDPOUJOÞBO
IBDJÏOEPMPo VO QBQFM GVOEBNFOUBM 4J
CJFOFTDJFSUPMBSFnFYJØOCJPÏUJDBQFS
NJUJØQPOFSFOFMDFOUSPEFMBQSFPDV
QBDJØO FM UFNB EF MPT EFSFDIPT EF MPT
QBDJFOUFT Z MPT BTVOUPT EF BVUPOPNÓB
Z CFOFmDFODJB MPT UFNBT NÈT HMPCBMFT
EFKVTUJDJBTBOJUBSJBoBDDFTPBMPTTFSWJ
DJPTCÈTJDPTQPMÓUJDBTEFTBMVEQÞCMJDBo
BVORVF OP DPNQMFUBNFOUF EFTBUFOEJ
EPT OP MPHSBSPO OJ IBO MPHSBEP BSUJ
DVMBSTF FO VOB SFnFYJØO NÈT QSPGVOEB
ZEVSBEFSBNFEJBEPSBEFMEJÈMPHPFOUSF
MBFDPOPNÓBMBTBMVEDPNPCJFOQÞCMJDP
QVCMJD HPPE
Z MBT UFPSÓBT EF MB KVTUJDJB
(BSHBSFMMB
2VJ[ÈTVOFYDFTJWP
ÏOGBTJTFOFMQSJODJQJBMJTNPPFODJFSUBT
MFDUVSBTEFÏTUFIBDPOGVOEJEPVOQPDP
MBNJSBEBQVFTOPIBQFSNJUJEPQFSDJCJS
RVFUPEBEJTDVTJØOTPCSFKVTUJDJBTBOJUB
SJB EFCF TFS SFGFSJEB Z DPOUFYUVBMJ[BEB
SFTQFDUPEFMBTSFBMJEBEFTEFMNVOEPFO
EFTBSSPMMPZMBTSFMBDJPOFTJOUFSOBDJPOB
MFT-BKVTUJDJBOPQVFEFWFSTFDPNPVO
QSJODJQJPFOUSFPUSPTTJOPRVFoEFKBOEP
QSPWJTJPOBMNFOUFEFMBEPFMUFNBEFMBT
KFSBSRVÓBT FOUSF QSJODJQJPTo FT FM HSBO
UFNBQPSSFTPMWFSFOOVFTUSBTTPDJFEBEFT
#FSMJOHVFS
%FNBOFSBJOEFQFOEJFOUFBMHVOPTBV
UPSFT IBO TPTUFOJEP RVF MB CJPÏUJDB OP
SFBMJ[B VOB TVNB TJNQMF EF EPT P NÈT
DPOPDJNJFOUPTQBSBPCUFOFSVOUFSDFSP
$BMEFSØO 4F SFRVJFSF NVDIP
NÈTZFOFMDBTPFTQFDÓmDPEFMBKVTUJDJB
TBOJUBSJB IBDF GBMUB NBZPS BSUJDVMBDJØO
Z QSPGVOEJ[BDJØO FO MB SFMBDJØO FOUSF
PERSPETIVADELABIOETICAINDD
FDPOPNÓB GÈSNBDPFDPOPNÓB mMPTPGÓB
QPMÓUJDB TBMVE QÞCMJDB FOUSF PUSBT &T
DJFSUP RVF MB CJPÏUJDB MBUJOPBNFSJDBOB
NPTUSØEFTEFFMDPNJFO[PDJFSUBJODMJOB
DJØOQPSMPTBTVOUPTHMPCBMFT1FSPFTUP
OPEFCFTPSQSFOEFSOPTZFTTJOMVHBSB
EVEBTVOTJHOPFTQFSBO[BEPSIBDJBEF
TBSSPMMPTGVUVSPT"VORVFTVFOFUSJWJBMo
ZTFIBSFQFUJEPUBOUBTWFDFToRVFMBCJP
ÏUJDBFTiVOBÏUJDBEFMBWJEBwFMMPOPT
PCMJHBBUFOFSVOBNJSBEBJOUFHSBEPSBZ
MMFHBBDPOTUJUVJSTFFOVOBBDUJUVENP
SBMMPBCMF%FTQVÏTEFUPEPMBCJPÏUJDB
EFCFTFSWJSBMPTDJVEBEBOPTEFMBQPMJTZ
DPOUSJCVJSBMBDSFBDJØOEFVOiFUIPTDP
NVOJUBSJPw4JOFNCBSHPIBZRVFUFOFS
QSFTFOUFRVFMBTPMBBQFMBDJØOBJEFBMFT
NPSBMFT DPNP MB FRVJEBE Z MB KVTUJDJB
TPDJBM OP DPOTUJUVZF FO TÓ NJTNB VO
BOÈMJTJTSJHVSPTPEFMBSFBMJEBERVFTJSWB
QBSBQSPGVOEJ[BSFOTVDPOPDJNJFOUPZ
RVFFWFOUVBMNFOUFOPTBZVEFBUSBOT
GPSNBSMB/PMFGBMUBSB[ØOB'FSOBOEP
-PMBT DVBOEP FYQSFTB RVF MB iTJNQMF
FOVODJBDJØOEFCVFOPTmOFToMBCJPÏUJDB
MPT UJFOFo QBSFDF CBTUBS QBSB BUSJCVJSMF
QVSF[BEFNFEJPTBRVJFOFTEJDFODVMUJ
WBSMBwMPDVBMOPTJFNQSFFTFMDBTP-B
OPDJØOEFVOBEJTDJQMJOBJOUFMFDUVBMDPO
TVT DPSSFTQPOEJFOUFT iTBCJPT FYQFSUPT
Z QPMÓUJDPTw OFDFTJUB TFS DMBSJmDBEB FO
VODBNQPUBOMÈCJMDPNPFMRVFMBCJP
ÏUJDB IB EFNPTUSBEP TFS -PMBT 4UFQLF
ZRVFiMBTMVDFTJOUFMFDUVBMFT
OPTPOHBSBOUÓBEFCPOEBENPSBM1FSP
ÏTUBUBNQPDPMPFTEFQFOTBNJFOUPSJHV
SPTPw-PMBT4UFQLF
1FSTQFDUJWBTEFMB#JPÏUJDBFO*CFSPBNÏSJDB
-BBmSNBDJØOEFJEFBMFTNPSBMFT
ZFMSJFTHPEFMiQBOnFUJTNPw
CJPÏUJDP
-BBQFMBDJØOBQSJODJQJPTNVZHFOFSBMFT
Z TPCSF UPEP MB TVQMBOUBDJØO EFM BOÈ
MJTJTÏUJDPQPMÓUJDPSJHVSPTPoBTÓTFIBHB
DPO MBT QFTBEBT IFSSBNJFOUBT EF VOB
QMVSBMJEBEEFMFOHVBKFTZTBCFSFTRVFOP
TFDPNVOJDBOFOUSFTÓDPOGBDJMJEBEoQPS
MBNFSBFOVODJBDJØOEFJEFBMFTNPSBMFT
oDPNP MB DPOEFOB B MB JOKVTUJDJB Z MB
EFOVODJBEFMBJOFRVJEBEoOPTJFNQSF
DPOEVDFOBVOBWBODFSFBM.ÈTUPEBWÓB
DJFSUP QBOnFUJTNP UFSDFSNVOEJTUB RVF
UPEPMPDPOEFOBTJONÈTQVFEFTFSTV
NBNFOUFEB×JOPQVFTOPTMMFWBBMFOHB
×PEFDSFFSRVFMBTJNQMFEFOVODJBEFMB
QPCSF[BRVFQBEFDFOMPTQBÓTFTEFMTVS
FM EB×P NFEJPBNCJFOUBM P MB JOKVTUJDJB
FOMBTSFMBDJPOFTJOUFSOBDJPOBMFTTFDPOT
UJUVZFOTJONÈTFOVOBQPSUFJOUFMFDUVBM
/PCBTUBDPOSFQFUJSVOMFOHVBKFiQPMÓ
UJDBNFOUFDPSSFDUPwQBSBDPOTJEFSBSRVF
TFIBBWBO[BEPFOFMBOÈMJTJTPRVFFTUP
SFBMNFOUF DPOUSJCVZF B EJOBNJ[BS MPT
NPWJNJFOUPTTPDJBMFTBGBWPSEFBMHVOB
DBVTB4PSQSFOEFFODPOUSBSBWFDFTFO
BMHVOPT GPSPT Z DPOHSFTPT EF CJPÏUJDB
oQPSGPSUVOBOPFOUPEPToMBSFQFUJDJØO
EF MVHBSFT DPNVOFT BDPNQB×BEPT EF
FYQSFTJPOFT EF BQBSFOUF BTPNCSP QPS
MPT BUBRVFT B MB EJHOJEBE F JOUFHSJEBE
IVNBOB FO BMHVOB QBSUF EFM QMBOFUB P
FOOVFTUSPTQSPQJPTQBÓTFT
/PPCTUBOUFFTUPOPEFCFTFSNPUJWPEF
EFTBMJFOUP MBT QSFPDVQBDJPOFT HMPCBMFT
MFIBOQFSNJUJEPBRVJFOFTTFPDVQBOEF
CJPÏUJDBTJUVBSTFNVDIPNÈTFOFMDPO
UFYUPEFVOBSFBMJEBEEJGÓDJMBWFDFTJO
PERSPETIVADELABIOETICAINDD
DMVTPB[BSPTBRVFOPQVFEFTJNQMFNFOUF
TFSQFOTBEBEFTEFFMFUIPTMJCFSBMOPSUF
BNFSJDBOP$VBOEPTFIBCMFFO"NÏSJDB
-BUJOBEFFRVJEBEEFSFDVSTPTTBOJUBSJPT
oBENJUJFOEPRVFMPHSBSQSFDJTJØOBDFSDB
EFFTUPTFSÓBZBVOBHBOBODJBoFMUFNB
EFMBKVTUJDJBOPQVFEFTFSVOQSJODJQJP
FOUSFPUSPTDPNPQBSFDFSÓBOTVHFSJSBM
HVOBTMFDUVSBTEFMQSJODJQJBMJTNP2VJ[ÈT
FMHSBOUFNBEFMBKVTUJDJBEFCBJODMVJSOP
TØMP TV TFOUJEP EJTUSJCVUJWP TJOP UBN
CJÏOTVTFOUJEPSFTUBVSBUJWPZSFQBSBUJ
WPBMNFOPTFOBRVFMMBTSFHJPOFTFOMBT
DVBMFTMPTDJVEBEBOPTIBOTJEPWJDUJNJ
[BEPTQPSMBWJPMFODJBEFVODPOnJDUPBS
NBEPRVFDJFSUPTJEFBMFTNPSBMFToQBSB
EFKBSEFIBCMBSQPSBIPSBEFQSJODJQJPT
ZWBMPSFToFTUÏOQSFTFOUFTFOFMEFTBSSP
MMPEFMBCJPÏUJDBMBUJOPBNFSJDBOBOPTFB
VOEFGFDUPTJOPNÈTCJFOVOBWJSUVE-P
QSFPDVQBOUFFTRVFFTUPDPOEV[DBBDJFS
UBTGPSNBTEFQSPTFMJUJTNPBWFDFTEFNB
HØHJDPRVFQSFUFOEFSÓBTVQMBOUBSFMBOÈ
MJTJTTFSJPZTFSFOPEFMPTQSPCMFNBTQPS
MBSFQFUJDJØOEFNFSBTDPOTJHOBT1PSMP
EFNÈT FO UBOUP QVFEB IBDFSTF VO VTP
BEFDVBEP EFM BOÈMJTJT oQSPEVDUP EF MBT
EJWFSTBT EJTDJQMJOBT RVF TF JNCSJDBOo Z
TFNBOUFOHBFMSJHPSEFMPTEJTDVSTPTBDB
EÏNJDPTOPTFWFQPSRVÏMBCJPÏUJDBOP
IBEFBMJNFOUBSDJFSUPUJQPEFBDUJWJTNP
PDJFSUBTBTQJSBDJPOFTEFSFGPSNBTPDJBM
PJODMVTPDPOUSJCVJSBMPHSBSVOBMFHJT
MBDJØONÈTBEFDVBEBTPCSFDJFSUPTUFNBT
"FTUFSFTQFDUPFTZBNVZDPOPDJEPFM
NBMDBTJFOEÏNJDPEFOVFTUSBTTPDJFEB
EFT MBUJOPBNFSJDBOBT Z RVF TF QSFTFOUB
EFTEFMPTBMCPSFTEFOVFTUSBTSFQÞCMJDBT
MPTEFTBSSPMMPTKVSÓEJDPTOPDPJODJEFOP
OPQBSFDFOFTUBSQFOTBEPTQBSBMBTSFBMJ
6OBMFDUVSBDSÓUJDBEFMBCJPÏUJDBMBUJOPBNFSJDBOB(FSNÈO$BMEFSØO-FHBSEB
EBEFTRVFTFWJWFO/PTJOSB[ØOFYQSF
TBCBVOSFQVUBEPHFOFUJTUBDPMPNCJBOP
RVF TF FTUBCB MFHJTMBOEP FO FTF QBÓT oZ
QSPCBCMFNFOUF FO PUSPTo TPCSF DMPOB
DJØO EF TFSFT IVNBOPT TJO IBCFS PCUF
OJEPVOBDPNQSFOTJØOCÈTJDBEFMPRVF
TJHOJmDBSÓBOFTUPTQSPDFEJNJFOUPTZTVT
QPTJCJMJEBEFTSFBMFTEFBQMJDBDJØO"OFD
EØUJDPFJOFYBDUPDPNPQVFEFBQBSFDFS
SFnFKB TJO FNCBSHP VOB SFBMJEBE RVF
BDPNQB×B MB GPSNB DPNP TF QSPDFEF B
EJTDVUJSEFDJEJSZBWFDFTMFHJTMBSTPCSF
DJFSUPT UFNBT 5BNQPDP FT BDPOTFKBCMF
FODPHFS MPT IPNCSPT BOUF FM QFTP EF
OVFTUSP TVQVFTUP iSFBMJTNP NÈHJDPw OJ
BQFMBSBOVFTUSPiUSPQJDBMJTNPwQVFTFT
UBTTPODBSJDBUVSBTRVFSFTVMUBOEB×JOBT
1FSPTÓFTOFDFTBSJPSFDPSEBSRVFNVDIPT
EFMPTEFCBUFTRVFMMFWBOFMBEKFUJWPEF
CJPÏUJDPT BEFNÈT EFM TFOTBDJPOBMJTNP
NFEJÈUJDPRVFTVFMFOUSBFSDPOTJHPEFT
DPOPDFO FO CVFOB NFEJEB MPT IFDIPT
DJFOUÓmDPTSFMFWBOUFTZMPTQSPCMFNBTÏUJ
DPTJOWPMVDSBEPT
-BBQFSUVSBEFMBCJPÏUJDBIBDJB
MPTHSBOEFTUFNBTEFMBWJEB
-BJODMJOBDJØOBFYBNJOBSMPTUFNBTEF
CJPUFDOPMPHÓBFMJNQBDUPNFEJPBNCJFO
UBMZMBTJNQMJDBDJPOFTEFMBTQSÈDUJDBTEF
MPT QSPGFTJPOBMFT EF MB TBMVE EFOUSP EF
TJTUFNBT FTUBUBMFT P QSJWBEPT QFSNJUF
RVF MB CJPÏUJDB TF FYQSFTF DPNP NPWJ
NJFOUPDVMUVSBMZQPMÓUJDPZPCUFOHBVOB
HSBOSFQFSDVTJØONFEJÈUJDBRVFQVFEF
BWFDFTDBVTBSDPOGVTJØO&OFTUFTFOUJ
EPEFCFDFMFCSBSTFRVFZBIBZBUFOJEP
MVHBS MB FUBQB RVF .BJOFUUJ EFOPNJOB
iSFDSFBDJØOw Z RVF DPSSFTQPOEF BM DP
PERSPETIVADELABIOETICAINDD
NJFO[P EF MB JOTUJUVDJPOBMJ[BDJØO EF MB
CJPÏUJDBFO"NÏSJDB-BUJOBBMDPNJFO[P
EFMPTB×PTOPWFOUBVOQSPDFTPDPOSBT
HPT DPNVOFT QFSP RVF UBNCJÏO SFWFMB
MBTQBSUJDVMBSJEBEFTEFDBEBQBÓT
.BJOFUUJQPSPUSPMBEPTPTUJFOFRVFMB
iCJPÏUJDBTFIBDPOWFSUJEPFOMBBSFOBEF
OVFWPTEFTBGÓPTFO"NÏSJDB-BUJOB6OB
BQBSFOUF VOJGPSNJEBE FTDPOEF SJDBT Z
IFUFSPHÏOFBT BDUJWJEBEFTw /P TØMP MBT
JOnVFODJBTFVSPQFBTZDSJTUJBOBTJOPMBT
USBEJDJPOFT JOUFMFDUVBMFT JOEÓHFOBT TPO
NVZJNQPSUBOUFTFOFMEFTBSSPMMPEFMB
CJPÏUJDB MBUJOPBNFSJDBOB /P UJFOF TV
QSPQJBmMPTPGÓBDPNPMBBOHMPBNFSJDBOB
QBSFDFUFOFSQFSPTÓTVQSPQJBMJUFSBUVSB
ZFTUJMPOBSSBUJWPw.BJOFUUJ
6OBGPSNBEFEBSMFWJBCJMJEBEBFTUBMFD
UVSBQPESÓBTFSJOUFSQSFUÈOEPMBDPNPVO
MMBNBEPEFBUFODJØOTPCSFMBOFDFTJEBE
EFJOUFHSBSEJWFSTPTFOGPRVFTZBCPSEBS
MBCJPÏUJDBDPOMBBDUJUVESFTQFUVPTBEF
RVJFO FTUÈ EJTQVFTUP B QFOTBS Z BDUVBS
FO VOB TPDJFEBE NVMUJDVMUVSBM "QBSUF
EFM EJTDVSTP EF MBT DJFODJBT NFEJPBN
CJFOUBMFToIPZNVDIPNÈTBSUJDVMBEPo
MBBOUSPQPMPHÓBDVMUVSBMZFMFTGVFS[PEF
BMHVOPTTFDUPSFTFOBSBTEFDPNQSFOEFS
MB NFEJDJOB Z QSÈDUJDBT DPNVOJUBSJBT
EF MPT QVFCMPT JOEÓHFOBT OP TF QVF
EFEFDJSRVFFTUBTUSBEJDJPOFTTFIBZBO
DPOWFSUJEPFOQBSUFEFMEFTBSSPMMPEFMB
CJPÏUJDB MBUJOPBNFSJDBOB $JFSUBNFOUF
FT NVZ JNQPSUBOUF MMBNBS MB BUFODJØO
TPCSF FMMP QFSP IBCSÓB RVF SFDPOPDFS
RVF FT VOB UBSFB BÞO QFOEJFOUF .ÈT
JOUFSFTBOUFFTRVFTFQSPQPOHBMBMJUFSB
UVSB Z FM FTUJMP OBSSBUJWP DPNP GVFOUFT
1FSTQFDUJWBTEFMB#JPÏUJDBFO*CFSPBNÏSJDB
EFDPOPDJNJFOUP%FTEFVOBQFSTQFDUJ
WBDFSDBOBQFSPOPJEÏOUJDB'FSOBOEP
-PMBT IB QSPQVFTUP RVF MB CJPÏUJDB TFB
DPOTJEFSBEB DPNP OBSSBUJWB DSÓUJDB -B
CJPÏUJDBTFDPODJCFBTÓBOUFUPEPDPNP
VOEJTDVSTPBOUJEPHNÈUJDPFTEFDJSVO
EJTDVSTP FTFODJBMNFOUF DSÓUJDP DBSBD
UFSJ[BEP QPS VOB BDUJUVE EJBMØHJDB RVF
QFSNJUFMBQMVSBMJEBEZMBEJTDSFQBODJB
%FTEFFTUBQFSTQFDUJWBMBCJPÏUJDBEFTB
SSPMMBSÓBVOBNFUBOBSSBUJWBRVFQVFEF
iIPSJ[POUBMJ[BSw MPT BSHVNFOUPT Z QPS
UBOUPEFWFMBSMBBSRVJUFDUVSBBYJPMØHJDB
EFRVJFOFTQBSUJDJQBOFOFMEJÈMPHP
1PS DJFSUP DPOTUJUVZF VO SFUP NVZ TV
HFSFOUF QFOTBS RVF FM CJPFUJDJTUB FT VO
FYQFSUPRVFTBCFiUSBEVDJSEJTDVSTPTw4F
USBUBTJOEVEBEFVOBCFMMBJNBHFOZFO
SFBMJEBE VO QSPZFDUP QSPCBCMFNFOUF
BMDBO[BCMF
QBSBMPTCJPFUJDJTUBTEFMGVUV
SPNÈTRVFVOBSFBMJEBEQSFTFOUFQFSP
FTEJGÓDJMOPFTUBSEFBDVFSEPDPO-PMBT
FODVBOUPBMQBQFMNFEJBEPSEFMBCJPÏUJ
DB-BCJPÏUJDBQPTJCJMJUBFMEJÈMPHPFOUSF
TBCFSFT Z EJTDJQMJOBT Z TF QPESÓB EFDJS
UBNCJÏO iFOUSF SFBMJEBEFTw $BMEFSØO
&O FTUF TFOUJEP FT QPS MP NF
OPT DPNQSFOTJCMF FM UFNPS EF 7JDUPSJB
$BNQTBMFYQSFTBSRVFFMUÏSNJOPiCJP
FUJDJTUBwTFBVOIÓCSJEPRVFRVJFSFVOJS
BMDJFOUÓmDPZBMIVNBOJTUBQVFTTFHÞO
FMMB MP RVF FO SFBMJEBE EFCF IBDFSTF
EFTEFMBCJPÏUJDBFTNBOUFOFSFMEJÈMPHP
iQSPQJDJBOEPMBDPNQSFOTJØOFOUSFMFO
HVBKFTZNVOEPTRVFIBOFWPMVDJPOBEP
JOEFQFOEJFOUFNFOUF FM VOP EFM PUSPw
$BNQT
*OEFQFOEJFOUFNFOUFEF
RVFBDFQUFNPTPOPFTUBTEVEBTFTNÈT
EJGÓDJMUFOFSMBTTPCSFFMQBQFMEFMBCJPÏ
PERSPETIVADELABIOETICAINDD
UJDBFOMBJNCSJDBDJØOQSÈDUJDBEFIFDIPT
Z WBMPSFT Z SFTVMUB FTUJNVMBOUF Z oQPS
RVÏOPEFDJSMPoMJCFSBEPSRVFTFQJFOTF
MBCJPÏUJDBDPNPVODPOKVOUPEFIFSSB
NJFOUBT DPODFQUVBMFT RVF QFSNJUFO FM
EJÈMPHPFOUSFEJTDJQMJOBTZFOUSFEJWFSTPT
TFDUPSFTEFMBSFBMJEBE1PSFMMPOPQVF
EF TFS MB NFSB BQMJDBDJØO EF QSJODJQJPT
BCTUSBDUPT B TJUVBDJPOFT DPODSFUBT &M
UÏSNJOPÏUJDBBQMJDBEBDJFSUBNFOUFDPO
GVOEF MBT DPTBT UBNQPDP CBTUB BRVÓ MB
TJNQMF BQFMBDJØO BM SFMBUJWJTNP DVMUVSBM
P B GPSNBT EF DPOUFYUVBMJTNP TJO NÈT
QVFT VO SFMBUJWJTNP ÏUJDP DVMUVSBM FY
USFNPQVFEFSFTVMUBSUBOWBDÓPDPNPMB
BCTPMVUJ[BDJØOEFQSJODJQJPTDPOQSFUFO
TJPOFT EF WBMJEF[ VOJWFSTBM -B CJPÏUJDB
EFCFPQFSBSDPODPODFQUPTRVFBENJUBO
NBUJDFT[POBTHSJTFTJOUFSQSFUBDJPOFTZ
ÏOGBTJT EJGFSFOUFT 4BCFNPT RVF OPDJP
OFTDPNPMBEJHOJEBEZFMSFTQFUPNVUVP
FTUÈO QSFTFOUFT FO UPEBT MBT TPDJFEBEFT
ZRVFMBTSFMBDJPOFTmMJBMFTQPSFKFNQMP
KVFHBOVOQBQFMNVZJNQPSUBOUFQFSP
MBFTUSVDUVSBZGPSNBRVFFTUBTBTVNFO
WBSÓBOHSBOEFNFOUFEFVODPOUFYUPDVM
UVSBMBPUSP"VORVFFMFKFNQMPFTNVZ
FMFNFOUBMOØUFTFMPTNÞMUJQMFTTJHOJmDB
EPTRVFQVFEFUFOFSFMUÏSNJOPiGBNJMJBw
FODPOUFYUPTHFPHSÈmDPTEJGFSFOUFTZFO
PDBTJPOFTEFOUSPEFVONJTNPQBÓT%F
TJNJMBS NBOFSB IBZ TPDJFEBEFT FO MBT
RVF MPT BODJBOPT TPO DPOTVMUBEPT QBSB
MBT EFDJTJPOFT NÈT JNQPSUBOUFT Z PUSBT
FOMBTRVFOPTPOUFOJEPTFODVFOUBCBKP
OJOHVOBDJSDVOTUBODJBMPRVFTVDFEFFT
RVFEJGFSFOUFTTPDJFEBEFTUJFOFOQFSDFQ
DJPOFT EJGFSFOUFT EF MP RVF DPOTJEFSBO
WBMJPTP QFSP UPEBT IBDFO WBMPSBDJPOFT
EFBMHÞOUJQP
6OBMFDUVSBDSÓUJDBEFMBCJPÏUJDBMBUJOPBNFSJDBOB(FSNÈO$BMEFSØO-FHBSEB
&TUBOPFTMBJOTUBODJBBQSPQJBEBQBSBEF
mOJSVOEFCFSTFSEFMBCJPÏUJDBQFSPIBZ
RVF UFOFS QSFTFOUF RVF OVFTUSPT DPOP
DJNJFOUPTTJFNQSFGBMJCMFTFJOTVmDJFO
UFT FO EJGFSFOUFT DPOUFYUPT DVMUVSBMFT
EFCFOQFSNJUJSOPTPQUBSQPSVOSFMBUJ
WJTNP NPEFSBEP QVFT MBT BTQJSBDJPOFT
DPNVOFTEFMBIVNBOJEBEoRVFTVFMFO
EFOPNJOBSTF iWBMPSFT VOJWFSTBMFTwo FT
UÈOQSFTFOUFTEFBMHVOBNBOFSB"RVÓMB
SFnFYJØOCJPÏUJDBFKFSDFTVQSJNFSBHSBO
NFEJBDJØOBMOPBDFQUBSMBJNQPTJDJØO
EF QSJODJQJPT BCTPMVUPT QFSP UBNQPDP
QBSBMJ[ÈOEPTF P FYUSBWJÈOEPTF BOUF MB
QMVSBMJEBEEFDVMUVSBTZNPEPTEFWJEB
/VTTCBVN.BDLMJO
4FQVFEFDPNQSFOEFSRVFVOBCJPÏUJDB
GPSNVMBEB EFTEF FM FUIPT MJCFSBM DMÈTJDP
EFM QSJODJQJBMJTNP OPSUFBNFSJDBOP SF
TVMUB VO UBOUP FYØUJDB BVORVF OP QPS
FMMPEFCFEFKBSEFFTUVEJBSTFFOVODPO
UFYUP MBUJOPBNFSJDBOP NÈT QSØYJNP B
MBTUSBEJDJPOFTDBUØMJDBTZNFEJUFSSÈOFBT
$PNPCJFOMPBOPUB-PMBTiVOPEFMPT
HSBOEFTQSPCMFNBTEFSJWBEPTEFAJNQPS
UBSEJTDJQMJOBTJOUFMFDUVBMFTDPOTJTUFQSF
DJTBNFOUFFORVFQVFEFOTFSEJGÓDJMNFOUF
BSNPOJ[BCMFTDPOMBUSBEJDJØOZDVMUVSB
MPDBMFTw-PMBT4UFQLF
/ØUFTFRVFBRVÓOPTFUSBUBEFVOBUFPSÓB
EFMBWFSEBEEFEFDJEJSTJMBWFSEBEFTUÈ
FO FM QSJODJQJBMJTNP P FO VOBiÏUJDBEF
TJUVBDJØOwTJOPEFMJOUFOUPEFEFMJCFSBS
TPCSFBRVFMMPRVFQVFEFJMVNJOBSPOP
VOBTPDJFEBEPVOBÏQPDBEFUFSNJOBEBB
WFDFTTVFMFPMWJEBSTFMBEJNFOTJØOUFNQP
SBMFOMPTEFCBUFTÏUJDPT
EFTEFVOBUFPSÓB
QBSUJDVMBS%JNFOTJPOBSEFTEFPUSPTDPO
UFYUPTDVMUVSBMFTRVFQVFEBODPNQBSBSTF
PERSPETIVADELABIOETICAINDD
FOUSFTÓFYBNJOBSTVTGPSUBMF[BTZEFCJMJ
EBEFTBSHVNFOUBUJWBTEJMVDJEBSQPSRVÏ
GVODJPOBFODJFSUPTDPOUFYUPTDVMUVSBMFT
Z OP FO PUSPT DPNQBSBS DØNP TF IBDF
DPNQBUJCMF P OP DPO PUSBT USBEJDJPOFT
JOUFMFDUVBMFTFTVOFKFSDJDJPIPOFTUPRVF
OPTØMPEFCFTFSDFSDBOPBMBCJPÏUJDBTJOP
RVFRVJ[ÈTTFBFTUFFKFSDJDJPEFMJCFSBUJWP
MBGVODJØOQSJODJQBMEFÏTUB
1PSPUSPMBEPTFPCTFSWBRVFFOMBMJUF
SBUVSBCJPÏUJDBMBUJOPBNFSJDBOBoFJODMV
TP FO MB FVSPQFBo DPOUJOÞB VOB GVFSUF
UFOEFODJB B VUJMJ[BS FM UÏSNJOP iEJMFNB
ÏUJDPw-PTEJMFNBTPCJFODPOEVDFOB
OVFWPT QSPCMFNBT FO DVZP DBTP TF EJ
MVZFO P CJFO DPMPDBO B RVJFO JOUFOUB
SFTPMWFSMPT FO TJUVBDJPOFT RVF JNQMJDBO
VO TBMEP USÈHJDP OJOHVOP EF MPT SFTVM
UBEPTDPOTJEFSBEPTQBSFDFTFSTBUJTGBDUP
SJP&TUSJDUBNFOUFIBCMBOEPMBCJPÏUJDB
FYBNJOBQSPCMFNBTRVFDPOUJFOFOUBOUP
FMFNFOUPT WBMPSBUJWPT DPNP FMFNFOUPT
FNQÓSJDPT UBOUP MFOHVBKF EFTDSJQUJWP
DPNP QSFTDSJQUJWP 2VJFOFT EF FOUSBEB
CBVUJ[BO UPEPT MPT QSPCMFNBT CJPÏUJDPT
DPNP iEJMFNBTw DPSSFO FM SJFTHP EF UP
NBSSVUBTTJOTBMJEB)BDFBMHVOPTB×PT
VOP EF MPT NÈT BMUPT GVODJPOBSJPT EFM
.JOJTUFSJP EF 4BMVE EF VO QBÓT MBUJOP
BNFSJDBOPBmSNØRVFTJÏMMMFHBSBBFO
DPOUSBSTF FO FM iEJMFNBw EF QSPWFFS MB
EPTJT OFDFTBSJB EF NFEJDBNFOUPT B VO
QBDJFOUF BEVMUP DPO 7*)4*%" P EF
BQMJDBSWBDVOBTBVOHSVQPEFOJ×PTQBSB
QSFWFOJSMBPDVSSFODJBEFBMHÞOUJQPEF
FOGFSNFEBEDPOPDJEBÏMPQUBSÓBQPSFTUP
ÞMUJNP 2VJ[È NVDIPT QFOTBCBO DPNP
FM GVODJPOBSJP TF USBUBCB EF VO EJMFNB
CJPÏUJDP1FSPTJTFBOBMJ[BNÈTDVJEBEP
1FSTQFDUJWBTEFMB#JPÏUJDBFO*CFSPBNÏSJDB
TBNFOUFTFWFSÈRVFOPFYJTUFOJOHÞOEJ
MFNB TJOP MB EFTDPOUFYUVBMJ[BDJØO TJN
QMFZMMBOBEFQSPCMFNBTRVFUJFOFORVF
WFSDPOMBEJTUSJCVDJØOEFSFDVSTPTFOHF
OFSBM%FJHVBMNBOFSBFMNFODJPOBEP
GVODJPOBSJPQPESÓBIBCFSUFOJEPVOEJ
MFNBFOUSFQSPWFFSTJTUFNBTEFBHVBQP
UBCMFQBSBBMHVOBTQPCMBDJPOFTPJOWFSUJS
FOMPTFTUVEJPTEFFTQFDJBMJEBEFTNÏEJDBT
EFBMHVOPTFTUVEJBOUFTEFMBTVOJWFSTJEB
EFT FTUBUBMFT &M NBOFKP DBTJ ESBNÈUJDP
EF FTUPT EJMFNBT iJOTPMVCMFTw BVOBEPT
DPO MB FTQFDUBDVMBSJEBE NFEJÈUJDB OP
DPOUSJCVZFBVOBNFKPSDPNQSFOTJØOEF
MBSFBMJEBE-PTQSPCMFNBTRVFFOGSFOUB
MB CJPÏUJDB TPO EF OBUVSBMF[B DPNQMFKB
SFRVJFSFO EFM DPODVSTP EF NÈT EF VOB
EJTDJQMJOBDPOGSFDVFODJBQSFTFOUBODJFS
UBiVSHFODJBwQPSTFSSFTVFMUPTZMPRVFTF
CVTDB OP FT TØMP SFBMJ[BS VOB EJTDVTJØO
UFØSJDBTPCSFQSJODJQJPTHFOFSBMFTMPRVF
FOTÓNJTNPFTNVZJNQPSUBOUF
TJOP
ZTPCSFUPEPPGSFDFSDSJUFSJPTQBSBPQUBS
QPSDJFSUPTDVSTPTEFBDDJØO
1PSPUSPMBEPTJTFIBCMBEFMPTEJMFNBT
DPNP MPT QSPCMFNBT RVF RVFEBO VOB
WF[ BOBMJ[BEB MB TJUVBDJØO JOJDJBM FO
UPODFT FM QBQFM EF MB CJPÏUJDB TFSÈ ÞUJM
FO UBOUP EFTQMJFHVF MBT IFSSBNJFOUBT
DPODFQUVBMFT OFDFTBSJBT QBSB BOBMJ[BS Z
SFTQPOEFSBTJUVBDJPOFTQBSUJDVMBSNFOUF
EJGÓDJMFTFOMBTDVBMFTTFNF[DMFOKVJDJPT
WBMPSBUJWPTOPSNBUJWPTZEFFYQFSJFODJB
.PVMJOFTT3FTDIFS
-BCÞTRVFEBEFMFTUBUVUP
FQJTUFNPMØHJDPEFMBCJPÏUJDB
2VFEBONVDIPTPUSPTBTVOUPTQPSFYB
NJOBS6OPEFFMMPTRVFNVFTUSBBMFO
PERSPETIVADELABIOETICAINDD
UBEPSFT TJHOPT EF NBEVSF[ B USBWÏT EF
VOEFCBUFIPZNVDIPNÈTFOGPDBEPFO
MPTBTVOUPTEFGPOEPFTFMEFMFTUBUVUP
FQJTUFNPMØHJDP EF MB CJPÏUJDB 4PCSF
FTUPZBQVFEFSFHJTUSBSTFMBFYJTUFODJBEF
QSPEVDUPT EF SFnFYJØO DPMFDUJWB (B
SSBGB ,PUUPX Z 4BBEB 4J CJFO
EFTQVÏTEFNÈTEFUSFJOUBB×PTEFFYJT
UFODJB EF MB EJTDJQMJOB FO FM NVOEP Z
DFSDBEFWFJOUFB×PTFO"NÏSJDB-BUJOB
TFSÓBEFNBTJBEPJOHFOVPQSFUFOEFSFO
DPOUSBSVOBFQJTUFNPMPHÓBEFMBCJPÏUJDB
DPODFCJEB EF NBOFSB VOÓWPDB 1SJNF
SPQPSRVFFTUBFTVOEJTDJQMJOBUPEBWÓB
FO DPOTUSVDDJØO QFSP BEFNÈT Z TPCSF
UPEPQPSRVFOPIBZVOTPMPPCKFUPEF
DPOPDJNJFOUPEFmOJEPEFMRVFTFPDVQF
MBCJPÏUJDBZRVFFYDMVZBBMPTPUSPT
5BNQPDP MPT QSPCMFNBT EF MPT RVF TF
PDVQBTPOFYDMVTJWBNFOUFTVZPTQVFTFT
DMBSPRVFOFDFTJUBEFMDPODVSTPEFPUSBT
EJTDJQMJOBT4JMBCJPÏUJDBEFCFSFnFYJP
OBS TPCSF TV FTUBUVUP FQJTUFNPMØHJDP Z
TVRVFIBDFSDPNPEJTDJQMJOBUFOESÈRVF
IBDFSTFFOMBEJOÈNJDBEFVONPWJNJFO
UPQSPHSFTJWPFOFMRVFTFBQPTJCMFSFWJ
TBSQSFTVQVFTUPTZTJFTFMDBTPGPSNVMBS
OVFWBTQPTJCJMJEBEFTFQJTUÏNJDBTTJORVF
TFUFOHBRVFQBSBMJ[BSFMSJHPSZFMWBMPS
EFMPTBOÈMJTJTOJFMDPOUBDUPnVJEPDPO
PUSBTEJTDJQMJOBT"MJHVBMRVFMBTPCSBT
FODPOTUSVDDJØOIBZRVFQSPDVSBSRVF
QVFEBOIBDFSTFTJOBGFDUBSFMUSÈmDPEF
MBDJVEBE
&M FTUBUVUP FQJTUFNPMØHJDP EF MB CJP
ÏUJDBOPFTSFTVMUBEPEFVOBDVFSEPOJ
MMFHØBTFSQSPEVDUPEFVOFKFSDJDJPRVF
MB PSJFOUBSB FYQMÓDJUBNFOUF IBDJB FTUP
6OBMFDUVSBDSÓUJDBEFMBCJPÏUJDBMBUJOPBNFSJDBOB(FSNÈO$BMEFSØO-FHBSEB
.ÈTCJFOFTVOFODVFOUSPEFEJGFSFOUFT
EJTDVSTPTRVFUJFOEFOBIPSJ[POUBMJ[BSTF
MP DVBM QFSNJUF VOB BNQMJBDJØO EF MPT
IPSJ[POUFTDPHOJUJWPTQFSPRVFOPEFCF
JEFOUJmDBSTF DPO MB JNQMFNFOUBDJØO
BDBCBEB EF VOB QSÈDUJDB JOUFSEJTDJQMJ
OBSJBDPNPUBM-BFTUSFDIBDPOFYJØOEF
MBCJPÏUJDBDPOMBTDJFODJBTEFMBWJEBMB
mMPTPGÓBEFMBNFEJDJOBMBUSBEJDJØOEF
VOB BOUSPQPMPHÓB mMPTØmDB Z MB OFDFTJ
EBEEFSFnFYJPOBSTPCSFMPTEFTBSSPMMPT
CJPUFDOPMØHJDPT IBO QFSNJUJEP MB QSP
EVDDJØOEFVOEJTDVSTPRVFQVFEFNÈT
PNFOPTJEFOUJmDBSTFPRVFFTJEFOUJm
DBCMFQFSPRVFOVODBSFTPMWJØEFTEFFM
DPNJFO[P FM QSPCMFNB EF MB JODMVTJØO
RVÏQPESÓBDPOTJEFSBSTFDPNPQFSUFOF
DJFOUFBMBCJPÏUJDBZRVÏOP
1FSPMBQSFHVOUBTPCSB/BEJFSFTVFMWF
EFVOBTPMBWF[MBJORVJFUVEEFMPRVF
QVFEFPOPQVFEFTFSQBSUFEFVOBOB
DJFOUF EJTDJQMJOB FTP TF WB EFDBOUBOEP
DPOFMUJFNQPZMPRVFMBEFmOFDPNP
UBMFTFOCVFOBQBSUFFMSFTVMUBEPEFMPT
JOUFSFTFTZQSPCMFNÈUJDBTDPNVOFTRVF
FOVONPNFOUPEBEPTFDPODSFUBOFO
VO DBNQP EF FTUVEJPT Z FO EJTDVSTPT
RVFMPHSBOBmODBSSBÓDFT1SPCBCMFNFO
UF DPNP EJTDJQMJOB MB CJPÏUJDB UFOHB
BOUFDFEFOUFT NÈT QSPGVOEPT Z MF EFCB
NÈTBPUSBTDPSSJFOUFTJOUFMFDUVBMFTEFMP
RVFOPSNBMNFOUFTFIBBENJUJEP-PMBT
4UFQLF
4FIBEJDIPZBRVFMBCJPÏUJDBOPFTVOB
TVNBTJNQMFFOMBDVBMEPTPNÈTEJTDJ
QMJOBTQSPEVDFOVOBUFSDFSB4FSFRVJFSF
NVDIP NÈT QBSB BSUJDVMBS VO DPOPDJ
NJFOUP RVF TFB QPS VO MBEP QSPEVD
PERSPETIVADELABIOETICAINDD
UP EFM EJÈMPHP FOUSF EJTDJQMJOBT Z QPS
PUSP NFEJP QBSB BDPSUBS MBT EJTUBODJBT
FOUSFUFPSÓBZQSÈDUJDB6OBNVFTUSBEF
FTUF UJQP EF SFnFYJØO OPT MB EBO BVUP
SFTDPNP.JHVFM,PUUPXRVFFOGSFOUB
FM QSPCMFNB EF MB FQJTUFNPMPHÓB NPSBM
ZFMBCPSBVOBDSÓUJDBTPCSFMBBEPQDJØO
TJO NÈT EFM QSJODJQJBMJTNP FO "NÏSJDB
-BUJOB 7PMOFJ (BSSBGB RVJFO JOUFOUB
QSFWFOJSOPTTPCSFDJFSUBTGPSNBTEFSF
EVDDJPOJTNPTJNQMFDPOUSBSJPBMOVFWP
QBSBEJHNBEFMBDPNQMFKJEBE-FØO0MJ
WÏ RVF BM IBCMBS EF MB EJNFOTJØO EFT
DSJQUJWBZOPSNBUJWBEFMBÏUJDBCJPÏUJDB
ZFQJTUFNPMPHÓBEFmFOEFVOBGPSNBEF
iOPSNBUJWJTNP OBUVSBMJ[BEPw RVF SF
DPOPDFRVFMBTOPSNBTDBNCJBOZFTUÈO
EFOUSPEFVOEFTBSSPMMPQPSUBOUPUPEP
BQSJPSJFTSFMBUJWPFIJTUØSJDPRVFEBOEP
MBCJPÏUJDBWJODVMBEBBQSÈDUJDBTDPHOJ
UJWBT'FSNJO3PMBOE4DISBNNBENJUF
RVFIBZNVDIBTWFSTJPOFTMFHÓUJNBTEF
MBCJPÏUJDBQFSPCVTDBVOBFTQFDJmDJEBE
FO"NÏSJDB-BUJOB:FTUPTFDPOTUJUVZF
FOVOBNVFTUSBEFRVFSFDPOPDFSMBSFB
MJEBEEFOVFTUSPTQBÓTFTEFMTVSOPTJH
OJmDBQFSEFSFMSJHPSBDBEÏNJDPOJDBFS
FOFMQBSSPRVJBMJTNPEFSFDIB[BSUPEPMP
RVFWFOHBEFMNVOEPEFTBSSPMMBEPDPO
FMBSHVNFOUPTJNQMJTUBEFRVFFTUPPCF
EFDFBGPSNBTEFJNQFSJBMJTNPTFBÏTUF
QPMÓUJDPFDPOØNJDPPDVMUVSBM
6OBPCTFSWBDJØOmOBM
3FTVMUBNVDIPNÈTNFSJUPSJPSFnFYJP
OBS Z FOUSBS FO EJÈMPHP DSFBUJWP DPO
PUSBT USBEJDJPOFT Z PUSBT OBSSBUJWBT Z
CFOFmDJBSTF EF MP RVF DPNP QSPEVDUP
EFVOBBQSPQJBDJØOSFBMQVFEBFOSJRVF
1FSTQFDUJWBTEFMB#JPÏUJDBFO*CFSPBNÏSJDB
DFSOVFTUSBNJSBEBZOPTQFSNJUBoIBTUB
EPOEF TFB QPTJCMFo DPNQSFOEFS PUSPT
DPOUFYUPT DVMUVSBMFT 4JO RVFSFS FYUFO
EFSMBNFUÈGPSBNVZMFKPTTFQPESÓBEF
DJSRVFFMEJÈMPHPFOUSFDVMUVSBTFTUBO
EJGÓDJM DPNP FOUSF EJTDJQMJOBT QFSP OP
JNQPTJCMF -B CJPÏUJDB MBUJOPBNFSJDB
OBUJFOFIPZNVDIBNÈTDPODJFODJBEF
FTUFSFUPZQPSGPSUVOBDVFOUBDPOVO
CVFO OÞNFSP EF DVMUPSFT DBMJmDBEPT Z
EJTQVFTUPTBBTVNJSMP
3FGFSFODJBT
#FSMJOHVFS ( #JPFUIJDT 1PXFS BOE *OKVTUJDF *O (BSSBGB 7 1FTTJOJ -
0SHT
#JPÏUJDB1PEFSFJOKVTUJÎB4ÍP1BVMP&E-PZPMBF$FOUSP6OJWFSTJUÈSJP
4ÍP$BNJMPQQ
$BMEFSØO-FHBSEB(
-BBNCJWBMÐODJBEFMB#JPÏUJDBDJODPUFTJTQBSBTVQFSBSMB
WFSHVFO[B0SJFOUBDJPOFT6OJWFSTJUÈSJBTNBSÎP
$BNQT7
6NBWJEBEFDBMJEBESFGMFYJPOFTTPCSFCJPÏUJDB#BSDFMPOB"SF[Z.BSFT
'JHVFSPB13BOE'VFO[BMJEB)
#JPFUIJDTJO*CFSP"NFSJDBBOEUIF$BSJCCFBO
5IF+PVSOBMPG.FEJDJOFBOE1IJMPTPQIZ
%FDFNCFSQQ
(BSSBGB7,PUUPX.Z4BBEB"
&TUBUVUPFQJTUFNPMØHJDPEFMB#JPÏUJDB.ÏYJDP
*OTUJUVUPEFJOWFTUJHBDJPOFT+VSÓEJDBT3FE-BUJOPBNFSJDBOBZEFM$BSJCFEF#JPÏUJDB
EFMB6/&4$0
(BSHBSFMMB 3 -BT UFPSÓBT EF MB KVTUJDJB EFTQVÏT EF 3BXMT VO CSFWF NBOVBM EF
GJMPTPGÓBQPMÓUJDB#BSDFMPOB1BJEØT
)FMMFS"
.ÈTBMMÈEFMBKVTUJDJB#BSDFMPOB$SÓUJDBQQ
-PMBT4UFQLF'
#JPÏUJDBFMEJÈMPHPNPSBMFOMBTDJFODJBTEFMBWJEB4BOUJBHPEF
$IJMF6OJWFSTJUBSJB
-PMBT 4UFQLF ' #JPÏUJDB Z BOUSPQPMPHÓB NÏEJDB 4BOUJBHP EF $IJMF
.FEJUFSSÈOFP
-PMBT4UFQLF'
3FIJTUPSJBSMB#JPÏUJDBFO-BUJOPBNÏSJDB-BDPOUSJCVDJØOEF
+BNFT%SBOF"DUB#JPFUIJDB
Q
.BJOFUUJ+"
%FTBSSPMMPEFMB#JPÏUJDBFO"NÏSJDB-BUJOB3FWJTUB&MFDUSØOJDB
EF#JPÏUJDB
BHPTUP
.BDLMJO3
"HBJOTUSFMBUJWJTNDVMUVSBMEJWFSTJUZBOEUIFTFBSDIGPSFUIJDBMVOJWFSTBMT
JONFEJDJOF/FX:PSL0YGPSE6OJWFSTJUZ1SFTTQ
.PVMJOFTT 6 )FDIPT F WBMPSFT GBMBDJBT F NFUBGBMBDJBT 6O FKFSDJDJP
JOUFHSBDJPOJTUB*TFHPSJB3FWJTUBEFGJMPTPGÓBNPSBMZQPMÓUJDB
BCSJM
/VTTCBVN.$
8PNFOBOE)VNBO%FWFMPQNFOUUIFDBQBCJMJUJFT"QQSPBDI
/FX:PSL$BNCSJEHF6OJWFSTJUZ1SFTTQQ
3FTDIFS/
3B[ØOZWBMPSFTFOMBFSBDJFOUÓmDPUFDOPMØHJDB#BSDFMPOB1BJEØTQ
PERSPETIVADELABIOETICAINDD
6OBNJSBEBQSPTQFDUJWBQBSBJEFOUJmDBSEFTBGÓPTB
QBSUJSEFMDPOUFYUPIJTUØSJDPIJTQBOPBNFSJDBOP
)VCFSU-FQBSHOFVS
*OUSPEVDDJØOTJUVBOEPFM
DPOUFYUPIJTUØSJDP
1BSB DPNQSFOEFS NFKPS MPT JOJDJPT EF
MB CJPÏUJDB FO )JTQBOPBNÏSJDB Z #SBTJM
SFTVMUB JOEJTQFOTBCMF DPOPDFS MBT QFDV
MJBSJEBEFTEFMBTDPOEJDJPOFTEFWJEBEF
FTUFTVCDPOUJOFOUFBENJSBCMFNFOUFFY
QVFTUBTFOMBTSFnFYJPOFTEF%JFHP(SB
DJB " QFTBS EF MPT SFDJFOUFT QSPHSFTPT
MB NBZPSÓB EF MBT QPCMBDJPOFT WJWÓBO Z
DPOUJOÞBOWJWJFOEPCBKPMBMÓOFBEFQP
CSF[BPDFSDBEFFMMBMPRVFTJHOJmDBRVF
MBQSFPDVQBDJØOQSJNPSEJBMDPOTJTUFFO
MB TVQFSWJWFODJB TPDJPFDPOØNJDB RVF
BOUFDFEFBDVBMRVJFSEJTDVTJØODJFOUÓmDB
TPCSFCJPÏUJDBBMFTUJMPEFMPTDPNJUÏTBE
IPDEFMIFNJTGFSJPOPSUF
&OFTUFDPOUFYUPFTJNQPTJCMFSFGFSJSOPT
FYQMÓDJUBNFOUFBMBTDPOEJDJPOFTDVJEB
EPTBNFOUFEFTDSJUBTFOFTUBTQÈHJOBQPS
FTQFDJBMJTUBT EFM UFNB 1PS FTP OVFTUSB
DPODMVTJØOGPS[PTBNFOUFTJOUÏUJDBUFO
ESÈQSJNFSPMBUBSFBEFDPODMVJSQBSBFM
QSFTFOUF Z QBSB FM GVUVSP BMHVOBT MFD
DJPOFTDVZBCBTFBOBMÓUJDBTJUVBEBFOMB
IJTUPSJBQBTBEBZBEFTDSJUBOPEFCFTFS
SFQFUJEB%FFTUFNPEPQPEFNPTWJTVB
MJ[BS VOB PSJFOUBDJØO NÈT QSPTQFDUJWB
FT EFDJS DPOTUSVDUJWB UPEP GVUVSP TF
PERSPETIVADELABIOETICAINDD
DPOTUSVZFTPCSFMPTÏYJUPTZMBTGBMMBTEFM
QBTBEP
TJOEFTDPOPDFSRVFQBSUFEFFT
UBTUJFSSBTBÞOUJFOFONVDIBTEJmDVMUB
EFTQBSBFYUJSQBSMPTGVOFTUPTNFBOESPT
EFMQBTBEP4FFTQFSBRVFOJOHÞODBQÓ
UVMPSFTVMUFJOÞUJMQBSBOVFTUSBQSFTFOUF
FEJmDBDJØO UFOJFOEP TJFNQSF DVJEBEP
EF SFGFSJSOPT B MBT QBSUJDVMBSJEBEFT EFM
DPOUFYUPFTUVEJBEP/PPDVMUBNPTRVF
MBNFKPSMFDDJØOEFMBIJTUPSJBFTTJFNQSF
MBEFSFBOJNBSFMJEFBMJTNPQBSBBMDBO[BS
VONFKPSGVUVSP
-BQFSTQFDUJWBVOJWFSTBMJTUBEFMB
CJPÏUJDBSFTVSHFSFMBUJWJ[BEBQFSP
DPOGVFS[B
%FUSÈT EF MPT JEFBMJTNPT VUPQÓBT TV
QVFTUBT SFMJHJPOFT VOJWFSTBMFT GSBUFS
OJEBEFT Z DPNQBTJPOFT JMJNJUBEBT TF
FOUSFWÏVOJEFBMPFMTVF×PEFVOBIV
NBOJEBE NÈT IVNBOJ[BEB Z TPMJEBSJB
BKFOB B UPEB HMPCBMJ[BDJØO mOBODJFSB
Z DPNVOJDBDJPOBM NFKPS SFDPODJMJBEB
DPO TV QSPQJB EJWFSTJEBE &O FTUB IJT
UPSJB NVMUJTFDVMBS MB CJPÏUJDB JOJDJB EF
BIPSB FO BEFMBOUF VOB JNQPSUBOUF FUB
QB DPO DBTJ NFEJP TJHMP EF QSPHSFTJWB
QSFQBSBDJØOPBOUJDJQBDJØO-PTDSJTUJB
OPTQPTFFOVOBQBMBCSBQBSBTJNCPMJ[BS
MB TVQSFNB VOJEBE EF VOB IVNBOJEBE
1FSTQFDUJWBTEFMB#JPÏUJDBFO*CFSPBNÏSJDB
UPUBMNFOUF SFDPODJMJBEB QFSP i1MFSP
NBw TØMP UJFOF TFOUJEP FO MB ØSCJUB EF
MBGFDSJTUJBOB&OTVMBSHBDBNJOBUBMB
CJPÏUJDB TF FODVFOUSB FO VOB FUBQB EF
FYDFQDJPOBM SFMFWBODJB /BDJØ DPNP
VOB WJTJØO BCBSDBEPSB VOJWFSTBMJTUB
EFTFBOEPNFKPSBSMBWJEBTPCSFOVFTUSP
QMBOFUB MP RVF TVQPOÓB NFKPS DBMJm
DBDJØO Z FYQBOTJØO EF MB WPMVOUBE EFM
CJFODPNÞODVBOEPOPTJFNQSFFTUBCB
TVmDJFOUFNFOUFBTFHVSBEPFOFMTFMMPEF
DBEBOBDJØO/PQPDBTEFDFQDJPOFTOPT
QSPCBSÓBORVFFTUFDPODFQUPOPFSBUBO
BDDFTJCMFOJHFOFSBMJ[BEP)BMMFHBEPFM
NPNFOUPEFSFUPNBSFMUFNBDPOBZVEB
EFUPEBTMBTCVFOBTWPMVOUBEFTDJFOUÓm
DBTQPMÓUJDBTDVMUVSBMFTSFMJHJPTBTVOB
DBNJOBUBTJOmO
&MQSFTFOUFUSBUBEPEFMDBNJOPSFDPSSJ
EPQPSMBCJPÏUJDBJCFSPBNFSJDBOBEFTEF
BVORVFOPTFBFYIBVTUJWPNFSFDF
VOBBDPHJEBFYDFQDJPOBMQPSTVBMDBODF
ZTFSJFEBE&TUPTEPDVNFOUPTTFSÈOEF
BZVEBFOVOGVUVSPQSØYJNPUBOUPQBSB
MBJOWFTUJHBDJØODPNPQBSBJOUFSDBNCJPT
EFJOGPSNBDJØOZDPMBCPSBDJØO1FSDJCJS
MBSJRVF[BZMBEJWFSTJEBEEFMBTUSBZFDUP
SJBTZBSFDPSSJEBTBOJNBBDVBMRVJFSHSV
QPEFQFSTPOBTJOUFSFTBEBTFOCJPÏUJDB
FTEFDJSFOFMGVUVSPEFMBIVNBOJEBE
-PT NFEJPT RVF OP TF EFTUSVZFO P TF
DPNCBUFO TF BZVEBO QPS NFEJP EF MB
DPNQMFNFOUBDJØO
/P EFCFNPT FYUSB×BS MB QPMBSJEBE EF
VOB ÏUJDB VOJWFSTBM BDUJWB FO FM TFDUPS
CJPÏUJDPBVORVFUBMJEFBMQBSF[DBMFKBOP
ZVUØQJDPQPSRVFMBCJPÏUJDBTFSFMBDJPOB
DPOUPEPTMPTEFNÈTTFDUPSFTEFMBDVM
PERSPETIVADELABIOETICAINDD
UVSBFYQSFTJØOEFWJEBEFMTFSIVNBOP
*ODMVTPJOBMDBO[BCMFFYDFQUPFOTFDUP
SFTMJNJUBEPTUBMJEFBMFYJHFJOUFOTPTZ
DPOTUBOUFTFTGVFS[PTEFMBTDPNVOJEBEFT
CJFOJOUFODJPOBEBT"QSFDJBNPTVOBFY
QSFTJØOJOUFSSPHBUJWBEFMDBQÓUVMPEFMB
CJPÏUJDB FO $VCB i-B CJPÏUJDB DPNP
OVFWP TBCFS {ÏUJDB BQMJDBEB P NFUBÏUJ
DB w &M DPODFQUP EF NPSBM DPNÞO SF
NJUFBMBJEFBEFVOBOBUVSBMF[BIVNBOB
VOJWFSTBMZBQBSUJSEFFTPEFVOCJFO
DPNÞOQSPNPUPSEFVOEFSFDIPOBUV
SBMRVFEFCFTFSDPOTUSVJEPFJOWFTUJHB
EPJODFOUJWBEPZBDUVBMJ[BEP
-BIJTUPSJBUBOUPMBBOUJHVBDPNPMBSF
DJFOUFFYIJCFTFSJBTEVEBTFOFTUBÈSFB
FTQFDJBMNFOUFDVBOEPFOMBMVDIBFOUSF
QBMFTUJOPTFJTSBFMÓFTOPTFDPOTJHVFVO
DPOTFOTPUFØSJDPZQSÈDUJDPQBSBVODFTF
EFMGVFHPRVFQFSNJUBUSB[BSMBTDPOEJ
DJPOFTEFVOBQB[EFMBSHPBMDBODFDPO
EJDJPOFTBMJBO[BTWBSJBTWFDFTBDMBSBEBT
Z QPDP SFTQFUBEBT
#BTUB DPNQSPCBS
MBPCTUJOBDJØOEFMQBSUJEP)BNBTQSF
QPOEFSBOUFBIPSBFOMBJEFPMPHÓBQBMFT
UJOBFOOPBDFQUBSMBTUSFTDPOEJDJPOFT
ZFYJHFODJBTJOUFSOBDJPOBMFTRVFQPTJCJ
MJUBSÓBOVOBDVFSEPEFQB[FMSFDPOPDJ
NJFOUP EF MB FYJTUFODJB EF *TSBFM DPNP
OBDJØO SFBM F JOEFQFOEJFOUF SFOVODJB
BTVNJEBBMUFSSPSJTNPZBMBWJPMFODJBZ
BEIFTJØOBMPTBDVFSEPTQPMÓUJDBZKVSÓ
EJDBNFOUFDPODMVJEPTOPTJOFTGVFS[PT
FOUSFMPTSFQSFTFOUBOUFTEFMBTEPTFOUJ
EBEFT
{$ØNP BWBO[BS FO BHVBT NÈT QSPGVO
EBT TJ SPDBT UBO TFEJNFOUBEBT JNQJEFO
MPTQSJNFSPTQBTPTDPOmBCMFT &MBNPS
6OBNJSBEBQSPTQFDUJWB)VCFSU-FQBSHOFVS
FTVOBGVFS[BDPOTJEFSBCMFZKVTUBNFOUF
DFMFCSBEB QFSP MB PCTUJOBDJØO DFSDBEB
QPSFMPEJPOPBDPTUVNCSBTFSSFDPOP
DJEB FO TV SFBM GVFS[B IJTUØSJDB 5BMWF[
IBCSÓB NFOPT HVFSSBT FO MB IJTUPSJB TJ
MBT NFOUBMJEBEFT oMBT QTJDPMPHÓBTo GVF
TFOEJGFSFOUFT-BCJPÏUJDBQVFEFZEFCF
DPOUSJCVJSFOMBBQSPYJNBDJØOBVOJEFBM
EFFOUFOEJNJFOUPZQB[
&OVOBEFDMBSBDJØOEFFMFTDSJUPS
4BMNBO3VTIEJFBQVOUBi)PZDPNQSP
CBNPTVOBQSPMJGFSBDJØOEFWJTJPOFTEFM
NVOEPJSSFDPODJMJBCMFTRVFEJTQVUBOFM
NJTNPFTQBDJP"TJTUJNPTBVODPOnJDUP
RVFPQPOFNFOPTDVMUVSBTPSFMJHJPOFT
RVF QFSDFQDJPOFT EJTÓNJMFT EF MP SFBM
7JWJNPTVONVOEPGSBDUVSBEP/PTPZ
DSFZFOUFFOUSFMBSB[ØOZMBGFSFMJHJPTB
FTDPKPTJFNQSFMBSB[ØO.BTDSFZFOUFT
P BUFPT OP QPEFNPT DPOUFOUBSOPT DPO
VOB WJTJØO EFM IPNCSF DPNP DSJBUVSB
SBDJPOBM5BNCJÏOTPNPTTP×BEPSFTMP
RVFOPTBCSFBPUSBEJNFOTJØO{$ØNP
JOUFHSBS FTUB JEFB EF RVF FYJTUF PUSB
DPTB BEFNÈT EF MB DBSOF Z MB TBOHSF w
3VTIEJF
-BTEFTJHVBMEBEFTOPFTUÈOBVTFOUFTFO
MB[POBJCFSPBNFSJDBOB-BCJPÏUJDBFYJ
HFTPCSFQBTBSMPTBTQFDUPTFTUSJDUBNFOUF
mTJPMØHJDPT EFM TFS IVNBOP QBSB FN
QMFBSMBDBQBDJEBETJNCØMJDBEFMBQBMB
CSB Z FM QFOTBNJFOUP IVNBOPT DPO FM
mOEFSFnFYJPOBSTPCSFMBTWJSUVBMJEBEFT
JSSFEVDJCMFT B NBUFSJB RVF DPOEVDFO B
VOPTQPDPTBBTDFOEFSIBDJBMVDFTSFMJ
HJPTBT:BFOFMQMBOPEFMIVNBOJTNP
OPGVFSPOSFBMJ[BEBTUPEBTMBTDPOFYJP
OFTPQPSUVOBTDPNPOPTSFDVFSEB9JDP
PERSPETIVADELABIOETICAINDD
(SBDJBOPBMBmSNBSRVFiMBTFOTJCJMJEBE
BNCJFOUBMEFMPTNPWJNJFOUPTMMBNBEPT
TPDJBMFTBMDBO[BDBTJBDFSPw(SB[JBOP
1BSB#PMJWJBQBSFDFNVZJNQPSUBSUFSF
TBMUBS MB IFUFSPHFOFJEBE EF MB CJPÏUJDB
OBDJPOBM P MBUJOPBNFSJDBOB &YJTUJSÓB
BRVÓ VOB PQPSUVOJEBE QBSB QSPGVOEJ
[BS MP FRVÓWPDP EFM UÏSNJOP iTBMVEw P
iWJEB CVFOBw /P UPEPT DPNQBSUJNPT
MPT NJTNPT FMFNFOUPT 1PS FKFNQMP
{RVÏ FT NFKPS {6OB WJEB JOUFOTBNFO
UF GFMJ[ QFSP DPSUB P VOB WJEB NFEJP
DSF Z MBSHB {1SFGFSJNPT GVNBS NVDIP
DPOMPTSJFTHPTBOFYPTZNPSJSKØWFOFT
POPTJNQPSUBVOBWJEBBTDÏUJDBZWJWJS
NÈT 0USP QVOUP RVF EJGÓDJMNFOUF PC
UFOESÈVOBOJNJEBEBNFOPTRVFFYJTUB
JOUFSWFODJPOJTNP iMB CJPÏUJDB EVSBw
ÞUJMQBSBFMCJFODPNÞOOBDJPOBMPJO
UFSOBDJPOBM -BT DPODFQDJPOFT EFM CJFO
DPNÞO EJWFSHFO Z SFQFSDVUFO TPCSF MB
JOTUJUVDJPOBMJ[BDJØOEFMBCJPÏUJDB{2VÏ
QFOTBSQPSFKFNQMPEFMBHSBEVBMQSP
IJCJDJØO FVSPQFB EF GVNBS FO MPDBMFT
QÞCMJDPT {&TDPODFCJCMFQSPIJCJSFMVTP
EF DPDB FO #PMJWJB P MB QSPEVDDJØO EF
BNBQPMBTFO5BJMBOEJBPFO"GHBOJTUÈO
&TWFSEBERVFEFTEFMB0SHBOJ
[BDJØO1BOBNFSJDBOBEFMB4BMVEFMHP
CJFSOPDIJMFOPZMB6OJWFSTJEBEEF$IJ
MF DSFBSPO VO i1SPHSBNB 3FHJPOBM EF
#JPÏUJDBwEFTUJOBEPFOQSJODJQJPBUPEB
"NÏSJDB -BUJOB Z FM $BSJCF QSFWJFOEP
WBSJBT BDUJWJEBEFT Z QVCMJDBDJPOFT -B
4PDJFEBE $IJMFOB EF #JPÏUJDB FT BOUF
SJPSBMSFHJTUSPEFMPTQSJNFSPTDPNJUÏT
EF CJPÏUJDB FO MPT IPTQJUBMFT DIJMFOPT
1FSTQFDUJWBTEFMB#JPÏUJDBFO*CFSPBNÏSJDB
RVF TF SFNPOUB BM JOJDJP EF MB EÏDBEB
QFSPEFNPSBSPOCBTUBOUFFOGVODJPOBS
0CTFSWBNPTBTJNJTNPRVFTJCJFOMBT
JOTUJUVDJPOFTDBUØMJDBTEF$IJMFTFJOUF
SFTBSPOSÈQJEBNFOUFQPSMBCJPÏUJDBMBT
FTUSFDIBT OPSNBT DBUØMJDBT DPOmFSFO B
FTUFQBÓTiNVZDBUØMJDPwVOTFMMPCBTUBO
UFDPOTFSWBEPSQBSBNFKPSPQBSBQFPS
QSPUFDDJØO EF MB GBNJMJB Z PQPTJDJØO BM
BCPSUP Z EJTUBODJB BOUF MBT JOWFTUJHB
DJPOFTNÈTBWBO[BEBTFOFTUFTFDUPSEF
MB SFQSPEVDDJØO P FO MB JOWFTUJHBDJØO
FO DÏMVMBT USPODP FNCSJPOBSJBT
-B
$PNJTJØO /BDJPOBM EF #JPÏUJDB FYJTUF
FO$IJMFEFTQVÏTEFNVDIPTEFCBUFTZ
PQPTJDJPOFTQFSPFTQPDPSFQSFTFOUBUJWB
ZTVGVODJPOBNJFOUPEFKBRVFEFTFBS&M
QSJODJQJBMJTNPOPSUFBNFSJDBOPGVFSFDJ
CJEPBOUFTRVFFOPUSPTQBÓTFTQFSPMB
BQBUÓB EFM FYUSFNP DPOTFSWBOUJTNP OP
FTUÈ DPNQFOTBEB QPS MB JSSVQDJØO EF
HSBOEFTGVFS[BTEFMNFSDBEP6OBDPTB
FT FM DPNQPSUBNJFOUP EF MBT FMJUFT EFM
QPEFSNÏEJDPZPUSBMBFWPMVDJØONÈT
MFOUBEFMBTNFOUBMJEBEFTQPQVMBSFT"M
mOBMDBEBVOBEFMBTOBDJPOFTMBUJOPB
NFSJDBOBT FTUÈ NVZ TVCEJWJEJEB TPDJBM
ZDVMUVSBMNFOUFQPSMPTSFDVSTPTFDPOØ
NJDPT B QFTBS EF BQSFDJBCMFT FTGVFS[PT
IVNBOJUBSJPT
.JFOUSBT UBOUP OP EFCFNPT FYUSB×BS
MBBUSBDDJØOEFMBÏUJDBVOJWFSTBMKVTUB
NFOUFJODFOUJWBEBQPSMBTPCSBTZNP
WJNJFOUPTJOJDJBEPTQPS)BOT,àOHZ
RVFQSFDJTBNFOUFQFSNFBOBMBCJPÏUJ
DBQVFTUPRVFFTUBÞMUJNBFTUÈSFMBDJP
OBEBDPOUPEPTMPTPUSPTTFDUPSFTEFMB
DVMUVSB IVNBOB WJSUVBM Z SFBMNFOUF
JODMVTPTJOTVmDJFOUFDPPSEJOBDJØOTJO
PERSPETIVADELABIOETICAINDD
UÏUJDB 5BM JEFBM DBTJ JOBMDBO[BCMF OP
QPSFTPFYJHFNFOPTFTGVFS[PTJOUFOTPT
Z DPOTUBOUFT FO UPEBT MBT DPNVOJEBEFT
FOJOUFSDBNCJP$VÈOQPTJUJWPTFSÓBEBS
UFTUJNPOJPEFVOBDPNQFUFODJBBNJHB
CMFFOUSFMPTFTGVFS[PTEFDPPSEJOBDJØO
RVFMMFWBBDBCPMB6OJØO&VSPQFBoOP
TJOEJmDVMUBEFTQJPOFSBFOFTUPFOSFMB
DJØODPOPUSPTDPOUJOFOUFToZVONPWJ
NJFOUPTJNJMBSTVTDJUBEPPJODFOUJWBEP
QPS MB QSFTFOUF PCSB TJO NFOPTQSFDJBS
MPT JOTVTUJUVJCMFT TFSWJDJPT EF MB 0SHB
OJ[BDJØO .VOEJBM EF MB 4BMVE Z EF MPT
PSHBOJTNPT RVF ZB FTUÈO BDUVBOEP FO
"NÏSJDB-BUJOB
-BT FNCFTUJEBT EF MBT DPOUSBGVFS[BT EF
MBIJTUPSJBOPPDVMUBOMBTDPOWFSHFODJBT
EFNVDIPTUSBCBKPTEFCJPÏUJDBFGFDUVB
EPTFTQFDJBMNFOUFFOFMHSVQPIJTQBOP
BNFSJDBOPZQPSUVHVÏTFOFMTFOUJEPEF
JNQVMTBS FM QSPHSFTP EF VOB DJFODJB Z
VOBSUFRVFFTUÏOSFBMNFOUFBMTFSWJDJP
EFMIPNCSFZFOMPQPTJCMFEFUPEPTMPT
TFSFTIVNBOPTZRVFBOUFFMPCTUÈDVMP
oMBEJmDVMUBERVFTVSHFGSFOUFBMBDSFB
UJWJEBEOVODBFTHSBUVJUBoFTUÏTJFNQSF
QSFQBSBEB QBSB MPT DPNCBUFT FO HFOF
SBM TJMFODJBEPT 1PS FTP WBMPSJ[BNPT FM
USBCBKPEFIPSNJHBTRVFDVNQMFOUBOUPT
JOWFTUJHBEPSFTZFRVJQPTEFCJPÏUJDBTB
CJFOEPRVFVOEÓBEFTQVÏTEFNVDIBTZ
EJTDSFUBTFUBQBTTVSHJSÈVOOVFWPQSP
HSFTPQBSBMBIVNBOJEBE{/PTBCFNPT
BDBTP RVF UPEB TÓOUFTJT TFSJB EFCF TFS
QSFDFEJEBQPSNVDIPTEFUBMMFTZBOÈMJTJT
EFDBTPT -PRVFEJTUJOHVFBMTFSIVNB
OPEFMBNBZPSÓBEFMPTBOJNBMFTFTTV
HSBO DBQBDJEBE EF BDVNVMBS TV DBQJUBM
EFTBCFSZEFLOPXIPXEFHFOFSBDJØO
6OBNJSBEBQSPTQFDUJWB)VCFSU-FQBSHOFVS
FO HFOFSBDJØO 4BMUPT EFDJTJWPT GVFSPO
FGFDUVBEPT DBTJ QPS DBTVBMJEBE CBKP MB
QSFTJØO EF VSHFODJBT JOTPTMBZBCMFT RVF
OP IVCJÏSBNPT JNBHJOBEP QSPWPDBS
QFSPRVFFYJTUJSÈOTJFNQSF%FTUBDBNPT
RVF FO UBMFT FNCBUFT FM DFSUBNFO OP
FTBQFOBTFOUSFQSPGFTJPOBMFTZMBOBUV
SBMF[B CJPGÓTJDB TJOP UBNCJÏO FOUSF MPT
EJWFSTPTDSJUFSJPTEFWBMPSBDJØOFOUSFMPT
QSPGFTJPOBMFT UPDBOEP BIPSB MPT mOFT
BIPSBMPTNFEJPTEFTVUSBCBKP
-BDPNQMFNFOUBDJØOZFM
QBSBMFMJTNPEFMPTOÞDMFPT
CJPÏUJDPTJEFOUJmDBEPT
&TQSPCBCMFRVFFODBEBOBDJØOPSFHJØO
MBCJPÏUJDBSFnFKFNFKPSEFMPRVFQBSF
DFMBDVMUVSBEFMQBÓTPEFMNFEJPPCWJB
NFOUFTJOOFHBSMPTPCKFUJWPTDPNVOFT
4JOFYQMJDJUBSFMQMVSBMJTNPEFMBTDPNV
OJEBEFT DBEB VOB QVFEF SFDJCJS BMHP
BTÓDPNPQVFEFQSPQPSDJPOBSBMHPRVF
QPTFB /JOHVOB QVFEF FOGSFOUBS TPMB
FMDPOKVOUPEFVOBTJUVBDJØODPNQMFKB
5BM QMVSBMJTNP TF QSFmHVSB GSFDVFOUF
NFOUFFOMPTNJFNCSPTQBSUJDJQBOUFTFO
FMDPNJUÏEFCJPÏUJDBQFSPOPTJFNQSF
MPTQBÓTFTQPCSFTMPHSBOSFVOJSVOFRVJ
QP EJWFSTJmDBEP Z BEFDVBEP .VDIPT
NÏEJDPTQSFmFSFOEJTDVUJSFOUSFTÓEFT
DPOmBOEP EF MBT BCFSSBDJPOFT RVF QP
ESÓBOTVSHJSEFMBCPDBEFFYUSB×PT-B
QSÈDUJDBEFMBCJPÏUJDBFTVOBFTDVFMBEF
IVNJMEBE 5PEB DVMUVSB FT QPMJWBMFOUF
ZMBCJPÏUJDBUSBCBKBQSFDJTBNFOUFDPO
VO DPOKVOUP EF DVMUVSBT -B NJOVDJB
BOBMÓUJDBEFMBTNVKFSFTEFCFDPNQMFUBS
MBTWJTJPOFTTJOUÏUJDBTRVFDPOTUJUVZFOFM
GVFSUFEFMIPNCSF-BQSFTFODJBEFKVSJT
PERSPETIVADELABIOETICAINDD
UBTSFDVFSEBRVFMPTOFHPDJPTIVNBOPT
TPO TPDJBMNFOUF DPNQMFKPT FO DPSUP
UJFNQPBMBCJPÏUJDBTFHVJSÈVOCJPEF
SFDIPQFSPMBQSJTBTFEFTBDPOTFKBTPCSF
UPEPFOVODMJNBNVZQPMJUJ[BEP
4FSÓB BSSJFTHBEP FWPDBS BRVÓ B FDPOP
NJTUBT QPSRVF MB CJPÏUJDB BDPTUVNCSB
QMBOFBS QPS FODJNB EF MBT DPOUJOHFO
DJBT QSFTVQVFTUBSJBT &T JOÞUJM NFODJP
OBS DVÈOUP TF OFDFTJUBSÓB MB QSFTFODJB
EFSFQSFTFOUBOUFTEFWBSJBTSFMJHJPOFTP
BOUSPQPMPHÓBT WJWFODJBEBT FO MB SFHJØO
EFUFSBQFVUBTEFPUSPTFTUJMPTPEFPUSBT
FTQFDJBMJEBEFTUFSBQÏVUJDBTZQSPGFTJPOB
MFT-BSFQSFTFOUBDJØOEFMPTFOGFSNPTFT
NÈTFTDBTBZEJGÓDJMEFFODPOUSBSDVBOEP
OPFTEFTDBSUBEBBQSJPSJTJOFNCBSHP
{OPTPOFMMPTMPTRVFDPOPDFOTVTNBMFT
QPSEFOUSPZOPFTUÈOEFTFPTPTEFNFKP
SBS 3FTVMUBGPS[PTPBENJUJSRVFDVBOUP
NBZPS TFB FM OÞNFSP EF QBSUJDJQBOUFT
TFSÈ NÈT EJGÓDJM P JNQPTJCMF BMDBO[BS
VOBOJNJEBE B WFDFT QBSFDF TVmDJFOUF
VO DJFSUP HSBEP EF DPOWFSHFODJB QBSB
KVTUJmDBSEFUFSNJOBEBEFDJTJØO6OBEF
DJTJØONVZSÈQJEBQVFEFTVHFSJSRVFMB
TPMVDJØOOPPGSFDFVOBSFTQVFTUBTØMJEB
PDPNPPDVSSFFOBTBNCMFBTEJQMPNÈ
UJDBTRVFTVTUÏSNJOPTTPOMPTVmDJFO
UFNFOUF nFYJCMFT DPNP QBSB QFSNJUJS
WBSJBTJOUFSQSFUBDJPOFT
-BQSÈDUJDBQBSFDFSFWFMBSRVFFMFNCB
UFFOUSFNÏEJDPTZKVSJTUBTFTGSFDVFOUF
TJOFNCBSHPFTJOFWJUBCMFPUSBDPOGSPO
UBDJØOTFUSBUBEFMBEJTDPSEBODJBFOUSF
DJFSUBT QPTJDJPOFT SFMJHJPTBT Z MB NBZP
SÓBEFMPTDJFOUÓmDPTRVFEFIFDIPTPO
BHOØTUJDPT -B SB[ØO EFM DPOnJDUP FT
1FSTQFDUJWBTEFMB#JPÏUJDBFO*CFSPBNÏSJDB
PCWJB Z TF NBOJGFTUBSÈ DBEB WF[ NÈT B
NFEJEB RVF QSPMJGFSFO FTQFDJBMNFOUF
MPT GVOEBNFOUBMJTNPT SFMJHJPTPT DPNP
MB FYQBOTJØO EF MB JOnVFODJB JTMÈNJ
DB 6OB SFMJHJØO JNQPOF EPHNBT DVZB
GVFOUFEFTVTUFOUBDJØOFTVOBSFWFMBDJØO
iTPCSFOBUVSBMwRVFFMDSFZFOUFOPQVF
EFDPOUSBEFDJSQFSPRVFOPUJFOFWBMPS
BQPEÓDUJDPQBSBFMDJFOUÓmDPEBEPRVFMB
CBTFEFTVTUFOUBDJØOEFMBDJFODJBFTDPO
BZVEBEFMBNBUFNÈUJDBMBPCTFSWBDJØO
EF IFDIPT GÈDUJDPT MB DPNQSPCBDJØO
QPSMBFYQFSJFODJBPMBFYQFSJNFOUBDJØO
$BCF PCTFSWBS RVF IPZ GVFSB EF BMHV
OPTSFEVDUPTEFMDJFOUJTNPEFDBEFOUFMB
DJFODJBFTUÈNVDIPNFOPTTFHVSBEFTV
QPTJDJØOiEFmOJUJWBwRVFFMDSFZFOUFTV
NJTPEFTVTEPHNBTEFSFMJHJØO1FSPFM
DJFOUÓmDPDPNPUBMOVODBBENJUJSÈMBJO
UFSWFODJØOEFTVGFTJMBUVWJFSBTPCSFFM
TBCFSDJFOUÓmDPDVBOEPFMMBJOUFSWFOHB
FO MB JOUFSQSFUBDJØO EF EBUPT PGSFDJEPT
QPSMBIJTUPSJBPQPSMBOBUVSBMF[B
-BDPNQMFNFOUBDJØOEFFOGPRVFTEFCF
QSFWFOJSPDPSSFHJSBNFOB[BTEFNJPQÓB
FOFMUSBUBNJFOUPTCJPÏUJDPPBWFOUVSBT
CJPHFOÏUJDBT RVF QSFUFOEFSÓBO TPCSF
QBTBS MP HFOÏUJDB P NPSGPMØHJDBNFOUF
EBEPQPSMBOBUVSBMF[BIVNBOB-PTNÏ
UPEPT QSPQJPT EF MB CJPÏUJDB EFQFOEFO
EFMEFTBSSPMMPEFMBEFNPDSBDJBDVBOUP
NÈT EFNPDSÈUJDB TFB MB DVMUVSB EF VOB
OBDJØO NÈT QSFQBSBEB FTUBSÈ QBSB FN
QSFOEFS MPT DBNJOPT EF MB CJPÏUJDB -B
NBZPSÓB EF MPT HSBOEFT EFTDVCSJNJFO
UPT DPOUFNQPSÈOFPT OP TPO QSPEVDUP
EFM DFSFCSP EF VO TPMP IPNCSF BVO
RVFVOPTDVBOUPTDJFOUÓmDPTSFDJCBOFM
QSFNJP /PCFM QPS UBM P DVBM EFTDVCSJ
PERSPETIVADELABIOETICAINDD
NJFOUPTPOFMSFTVMUBEPEFMUSBCBKPEF
FRVJQPT EF JOWFTUJHBEPSFT RVF TF DPN
QMFNFOUBOUSBCBKBOEPPOPFODPOKVO
UP%FFTUFNPEPFMFKFSDJDJPNJTNPEF
MBCJPÏUJDBPCMJHBBCVTDBSMBDPOWFSHFO
DJBEFMPTIBMMB[HPTJOEJWJEVBMFTPDPMFD
UJWPT BM TFSWJDJP EF MB JOUFHSJEBE EF MBT
QFSTPOBT&TUPOPOPTMMFWBBDPOGVOEJS
MBTDJFODJBTCJPNÏEJDBTDPOMBmMPTPGÓBP
DPOMBSFMJHJØOTPCSFUPEPQPSRVFDJFSUP
DPODFQUPBOUSPQPMØHJDPFTEFDJSEFMB
OBUVSBMF[BQSPGVOEBEFMTFSIVNBOPTF
FODVFOUSB TJFNQSF QSFTFOUF -B EJWFS
TJEBE EF QVOUPT EF WJTUB EF DVBMRVJFS
FRVJQP FTQFDJBMNFOUF FO FM DPNJFO[P
EFMFYBNFOEFEFUFSNJOBEPTEFTBGÓPTFT
OPSNBM EFTFBCMF Z QPS MP HFOFSBM GF
DVOEBTJFNQSFRVFFMBOUBHPOJTNPOP
EFHFOFSFFOIPTUJMJEBEPFOQSFDPODFQUP
TFEJNFOUBEP 5PEPT EFCFO FNQMFBS MB
SB[ØOVOBSB[ØOBCJFSUBBUPEBWFSEBE
JODMVTPDVBOEPOPTJFNQSFTFBJHVBMMB
CJPÏUJDBFTFTDVFMBEFUPMFSBODJBRVFOP
EFCFPCTUSVJSMBBQFSUVSBBMBWFSEBEEF
DVBMRVJFSPSJHFOTJFNQSFRVFTFQSFTFO
UFDPOTFSJFEBE/BEJFQPTFFMBWFSEBE
UPUBM Z DPNQMFUB FTUB DPODJFODJB FWJUB
DPOTUSVJSCBSSFSBTQBSBMBBDFQUBDJØOEF
MPOVFWP
2VFEFWF[FODVBOEPMBTJOOPWBDJPOFT
OPTDPOEV[DBOBIBCMBSEFVOOVFWPQB
SBEJHNBEFQFOTBNJFOUPPEFPSHBOJ[B
DJØOFOMBJOWFTUJHBDJØOFTNVZOPSNBM
QFSPFMQSPHSFTPOVODBTVSHFEFMBOBEB
Z MB IJTUPSJB JODMVZF DJFSUB NFNPSJB
RVFOPDPSUBGÈDJMNFOUFTVQSPQJPIJMP
&YJTUFDJFSUBTBCJEVSÓBFOSFDPOPDFSFTUB
DPOUJOVJEBEEFMBTEJTDPOUJOVJEBEFTIJT
UØSJDBTBTÓDPNPMBFMFWBDJØOEFMBUSBT
6OBNJSBEBQSPTQFDUJWB)VCFSU-FQBSHOFVS
DFOEFODJBSFMJHJPTBBUSBWÏTEFMQMVSBMJT
NPEFMBTSFMJHJPOFTPMBTFSJFEBEEFMPT
JOWFTUJHBEPSFTEFTFDUPSFTNVZEJGFSFO
UFTEFMBSFBMJEBE-BIJTUPSJBOVODBSF
QJUFFYBDUBNFOUFMPTNJTNPTQBTPTQPS
FTPDPOmBNPTFORVFEFBMHÞONPEP
FMQPSWFOJSTJFNQSFTFSÈNÈTJOUFSFTBO
UF&MCJPFUJDJTUBTBCFSFDPOPDFSFMGPO
EPDPNÞOFOUSFEFTBGÓPTNVZEJTUJOUPT
TFBO P OP EF MB NJTNB ÈSFB BTÓ DPNP
MBTDBSBDUFSÓTUJDBTQSPQJBTEFDBEBDBTP
RVFFYJHFVOBSFQVFTUBBQSPQJBEBZOP
VOBEFDPOGFDDJØOQSFFTUBCMFDJEB5PEP
TFSFTPSJHJOBMUBOUPNÈTUPEBQFSTPOB
'SFOUF B DVBMRVJFS DBTP MB QSFHVOUB FT
{DVÈMFTMBFYQFSJFODJBRVFQVFEFBQPSUBS
BFTUFFWFOUPZDPORVÏOPWFEBEPGBDUP
SFTFYDFQDJPOBMFTDPOUSJCVZF
$PTUPTFDPOØNJDPTZTPDJBMFT
%FBMHVOBNBOFSBGVFTBCJPQSPDMBNBS
VO OVFWP PSEFO TPDJPTBOJUBSJP B QBSUJS
EFM MFJUNPUJW FM DJVEBEBOP iUJFOF EF
SFDIP B MB TBMVEw FYBHFSBDJØO VUØQJ
DBQFSPDPOWFODJPOBM
ZDPNQFUFBMBT
JOTUJUVDJPOFT QÞCMJDBT QSPWFFS TJ GVFTF
OFDFTBSJPZmOBODJBSUBMFTTJTUFNBT-B
QSÈDUJDBSFWFMBRVFFTUFQSPZFDUPSBEJDBM
TPDJBMJTUB FT QSÈDUJDBNFOUF JSSFBMJ[BCMF
FOFMNVOEPBDUVBM/PGVFFYJUPTPFO
MB 6OJØO 4PWJÏUJDB Z TVT MPHSPT UBMWF[
SFMBUJWPT FO $VCB TPO EVSBNFOUF QB
HBEPTQPSPUSPTTFDUPSFTEFOFDFTJEBEFT
TPDJBMFTZEFMBWJEBQÞCMJDB-BTNJTNBT
JOUFSSPHBOUFTCJPÏUJDBTOPQVFEFOJHOP
SBSTVTJODJEFODJBTFDPOØNJDBTJODMVTP
TJMBIBCJMJEBEQPMÓUJDBPMBJODPOTDJFODJB
QSFTVQVFTUBSJBSFDPNJFOEFODBMMBSTPCSF
UBMFT BTQFDUPT EF MPT EFTBGÓPT CJPÏUJDPT
PERSPETIVADELABIOETICAINDD
{"RVJÏOMFJNQPSUBOSFBMNFOUFMPTNJ
MMPOFTPCJMMPOFTEFMBEFVEBEFTFHVSJ
EBE TPDJBM 5PEP QSPHSFTP TPDJBM UJFOF
VODPTUPFDPOØNJDPFMQSPCMFNBSFTJEF
FOBDFSUBSDVÈMFTGVFOUFTQBHBEPSBTTPO
MBTNÈTDPOWFOJFOUFTZFmDBDFT
"TÓ VOB WF[ RVF SFQBSBNPT FO MB IJT
UPSJBEFMBCJPÏUJDBBQSFDJBNPTVOWBJ
WÏOFOUSFFMQSPZFDUPZMBSFBMJ[BDJØOFM
JEFBMZMBGBDUJCJMJEBEMBWJTJØOmOBMEF
MBSHP QMB[P Z MBT DPOEJDJPOFT DPODSFUBT
EFNFKPSÓBJONFEJBUBPSÈQJEBEFMDBTP
RVFFOGSFOUBNPTIPZFOEÓB4JMBTBMVE
FYJHFDBEBWF[NÈTJOWFSTJPOFTZHBTUPT
VSHFFTDPHFSDØNPEJTDFSOJSZTFMFDDJP
OBSMBTGVFOUFTQBHBEPSBTZDØNPFYJHJS
FDPOPNÓBT FO TFDUPSFT NBSHJOBMFT &O
NVDIPTQBÓTFTTFPCTFSWBVOBNVMUJQMJ
DBDJØOJOÞUJMEFFYÈNFOFTSFQFUJUJWPTZ
DPOTVMUBT JOTJHOJmDBOUFT 6O QBÓT DVZB
EFVEB FYUFSOB TVQFSB FM P EF
TV1*#OPEFCFSÓBEFTQSFDJBSNPEFTUPT
BIPSSPTTVQSJNJFOEPWJBKFTJOÞUJMFT)BZ
RVFJNBHJOBSTFDUPSFTGVFSBEFMBTBMVE
QÞCMJDBDPNPFMEFFEVDBDJØOZGPSNB
DJØOFOMPTDVBMFTMPTBIPSSPTEFCFSÓBO
DVNQMJSTFTJOQSFKVJDJPT-BNBEVSF[EF
VOBOBDJØOEFTBSSPMMBEBTFNJEFNVDIP
QPSMBUBTBEFTVJOWFSTJØOFOJOWFTUJHB
DJØODJFOUÓmDBFTQFDJBMNFOUFCJPNÏEJ
DB QFSP FMMB FTUÈ DBTJ QPS DPNQMFUP BM
TFSWJDJPEFMPTNÈTSJDPT
3FDPSEFNPTMBTPMJEBSJEBEEFMBCJPNF
EJDJOBDPOMBTEFNÈTEFQFOEFODJBTQÞ
CMJDBTUBMDPNPTFSFDVFSEBOMBTQSPQP
TJDJPOFTHVCFSOBNFOUBMFTEFMFDPMPHJTUB
GSBODÏT/JDPMBT)VMPUQPOFSFMNFEJP
BNCJFOUFFOFMDPSB[ØOEFM&TUBEPDPO
1FSTQFDUJWBTEFMB#JPÏUJDBFO*CFSPBNÏSJDB
VO WJDFQSJNFS NJOJTUSP FODBSHBEP EFM
EFTBSSPMMP TVTUFOUBCMF DSFBS VOB UB[B
EFDBSCPOPIBTUBSFEVDJSQPSDVBUSPMBT
FNJTJPOFT EF HBT DBSCØOJDP DPOTVMUBS
B MB HFOUF BDFSDB EF MB PSJFOUBDJØO EFM
EFTBSSPMMPTVTUFOUBCMFQSPNPWFSMBTFO
TJCJMJ[BDJØO FEVDBUJWB EFM QÞCMJDP SFMB
DJPOBEB DPO MB FDPMPHÓB Z MB TBMVE QÞ
CMJDB5BMDPNPEJDF4ÏHPMÒOF3PZBMiFM
WFSEBEFSP EFTBGÓP DPOTJTUF FO DPODJMJBS
MBMVDIBQPSVONFKPSBNCJFOUFDPOVOB
VSHFODJBTPDJBMZVOEFTBSSPMMPTVTUFOUB
CMFwMPRVFQFSNJUJSÓBTVQSJNJSSFHBMÓBT
QSPEJHJPTBT QBSB QBHBS B QSFDJP EF PSP
BMHVOPT NFTFT P B×PT EF TVQFSWJWFODJB
BSUJmDJBM B CFCÏT EF GBNJMJBT QPMÓUJDB Z
FDPOØNJDBNFOUF TPCSFQSPUFHJEBT -B
FY DBOEJEBUB TPDJBMJTUB B MB QSFTJEFODJB
EFMBSFQÞCMJDBGSBODFTBUFOÓBUSFTUFNBT
QSJPSJUBSJPT MB FYDFMFODJB EFM NFEJP
BNCJFOUF Z MBT QSFPDVQBDJPOFT TPDJBMFT
ZFDPOØNJDBTFOMBTDVBMFTMBTBOJUBSJB
PDVQBCBVOBQPTJDJØODSFDJFOUF3FTVMUB
DVSJPTPDPOTUBUBSMPTQSFKVJDJPTMBUJOPB
NFSJDBOPTDPOUSB$IJMFQBÓTEFMBNFKPS
TBMVE QPMÓUJDPTPDJBM MPT FSSPSFT DSJNJ
OBMFTEF1JOPDIFUOPFOUSBOBRVÓ
DPO
MB NÈT EJGVOEJEB PQJOJØO EF SFDIB[BS
MBQSFWJTJØOTPDJBMQPSDBQJUBMJ[BDJØOMB
GØSNVMB FYJUPTB FO $IJMF Z RVF FYJHF
FWJEFOUFNFOUF VOB DPNQMFNFOUBDJØO
FTUBUBMQBSBMPTNÈTQPCSFT
NVOEJBMEFMBQSPEVDDJØOEFBVUPNØWJ
MFTFWJUBMPTHSBWFTJODPOWFOJFOUFTQBSB
FMQSFTFOUFZFMGVUVSPEFMBTBMVE-BTP
DJFEBE#PFJOH4QFDUSPMBCBQPZBEBQPSFM
EFQBSUBNFOUPOPSUFBNFSJDBOPEFFOFS
HÓB JOOPWØ DPO NPEFMPT GPUPWPMUÈJDPT
RVFUSBOTGPSNBOMBSBEJBDJØOTPMBSDPO
VO JODSFÓCMF SFOEJNJFOUP EF DVBOEP FM SÏDPSE FVSPQFP OP TPCSFQB
TBCBFM&WJEFOUFNFOUFUPEPFTUP
UJFOFTVDPTUPZEFQFOEFEFPQDJPOFTEF
JOWFTUJHBDJØOFJOWFSTJØORVFOPTPOBD
DFTJCMFTQBSBUPEPTMPTQBÓTFT
$POFMQSPQØTJUPEFQSPUFHFSTVNFEJP
BNCJFOUF *TMBOEJB EFDJEJØ FNQMFBS FM
USBOTQPSUF QÞCMJDP B IJESØHFOP CVFO
DBOEJEBUP QBSB TVTUJUVJS BM QFUSØMFP
DVBOEPÏTUFTFUFSNJOF&OQPDPUJFNQP
UBMFTJOOPWBDJPOFTWBOBUFOFSTVTDPTUPT
BIPSBZBFMFWBEPT5BNQPDPFMBVNFOUP
"QFTBSEFVOPTDVBOUPTHFTUPTOPCMFT
BMHVOPT EF MPT DVBMFT TPO KVTUBNFOUF
DÏMFCSFT QPS DSFBS GVOEBDJPOFT EF BZV
EB TPDJBM JOUFSOBDJPOBM V PSHBOJTNPT
OPHVCFSOBNFOUBMFT0/(
FTQSFDJTP
SFDPOPDFSRVFMPTBWBODFTNPEFSOPTEF
MBCJPNFEJDJOBCFOFmDJBONÈTSÈQJEBZ
PERSPETIVADELABIOETICAINDD
-B DPODFOUSBDJØO EF GPSUVOBT Z SFOUBT
UBOUP FOUSF OBDJPOFT DPNP EFOUSP EF
DBEBQBÓTDPOTUJUVZFVOGBDUPSQPDPBOJ
NBEPSQBSBOVFTUSBQSPTQFDUJWB&YJTUF
FMSJFTHPEFUFOFSBGVUVSPEPTNFEJDJ
OBT VOB QBSB MPT SJDPT Z PUSB QBSB MPT
QPCSFT #BTUB PCTFSWBS MB FWPMVDJØO EF
MBEJTUSJCVDJØOEFMBTSFOUBTTPCSFUPEP
FOMPTQBÓTFTNÈTEFTBSSPMMBEPTRVJFOZB
UJFOFNVDIPNB×BOBTJOEVEBUFOESÈ
NVDIPNÈTPQFSBDJØOBDFMFSBEBDVBO
EP MPT HSBOEFT QBUSPOFT TF BVUPBUSJCV
ZFO VO TUPDL EF PQDJPOFT B QSPGVTJØO
&MNVOEPFDPOØNJDPDBNCJØMBTSFHMBT
MPRVFNÈTJNQPSUBQBSBMBTHSBOEFTmS
NBTZBOPFTMBSFMBDJØOFOUSFQBUSPOFT
ZBTBMBSJBEPTTJOPFMSFOEJNJFOUPEFTVT
BDDJPOFTFOMBTCPMTBT
6OBNJSBEBQSPTQFDUJWB)VCFSU-FQBSHOFVS
BNQMJBNFOUFBMBTGBNJMJBTNÈTBEJOFSB
EBT -B TPMJEBSJEBE TF FYQBOEF NÈT GÈ
DJMNFOUFFOMPTEJTDVSTPTRVFFOMBTBZV
EBTNÈTOFDFTJUBEBT-BNJTNBSFMBDJØO
FOUSF MPT TFDUPSFT QÞCMJDPT Z QSJWBEPT
FODBEBQBÓTZFOFMNVOEPOPFTFTUB
CMFZSFTVMUBQFMJHSPTPNBOJGFTUBSBMHÞO
EPHNBUJTNP TPCSF MB NFKPS TPMVDJØO
RVF EFQFOEF EF MPT DPOUFYUPT /VODB
GVFSBEF.ØOBDPZEFVOBTQPDBTJTMBT
EF FYUSFNB SJRVF[B VO &TUBEP QPESÈ
QSPNFUFSBTVTSFTJEFOUFTPDJVEBEBOPT
Z DVNQMJS SFBMNFOUF UPEPT MPT DPTUPT
FYJHJEPT QBSB MB NBOVUFODJØO EF UPEB
TV QPCMBDJØO FO VO OJWFM SB[POBCMF EF
CJFOFTUBS
-BSJHVSPTBJHVBMEBEEFUSBUPOPQBTBEF
TFSVOTVF×PPVOBQSPNFTBEFDBNQB
×B-PTJOEVTUSJBMFTPQSPGFTJPOBMFTEFM
TFDUPSQÞCMJDPPQSJWBEPRVFHBOBOQPS
NFTNÈTEFVONJMMØOEFFVSPTPUSFT
NJMMPOFT EF EØMBSFT TPO FWJEFOUFNFO
UFFTDBTPTFOMB[POBMBUJOPBNFSJDBOBTJ
FT RVF FYJTUFO "MHVOPT EF MPT EVF×PT
EF HSBOEFT GPSUVOBT EF PSÓHFOFT CJFO
EJWFSTPT USBEJDJPOBMFT P SFDJFOUFT IP
OFTUPT P GSBVEVMFOUPT
QSPQJDJBO TJO
FNCBSHP PCSBT P GVOEBDJPOFT DVZB
VUJMJEBE Z HFOFSPTJEBE QPESÓB FYQBO
EJSTFFODVBMRVJFSOBDJØO&TQFSBSUPEP
EF VO HPCJFSOP FTQFDJBMNFOUF DVBOEP
TVTNJFNCSPTTFTJFOUFOHBOBEPSFTOP
TJSWF B MB EJOÈNJDB EFM EFCJEP QSPHSF
TPTBOJUBSJPZTPDJBM%PN'SBHPTPRVF
GVF PCJTQP EF $SBUFVT FO FM OPSEFT
UF EF #SBTJM SFRVJTØ MBT EPOBDJPOFT EF
VOBSJDBEJØDFTJTBMFNBOBRVFTFHÞOÏM
USBOTGPSNBSÓBBTVTQBSSPRVJBOPTQPCSFT
FONFOEJHPT
PERSPETIVADELABIOETICAINDD
{"RVÏUJQPEFFYQMPTJØOTFFYQPOFOMBT
CPMTBTEFDPODFOUSBDJØOEFSJRVF[BTRVF
TF GPSNBO FO UPSOP EF BMHVOBT mSNBT
QFSTPOBMJEBEFT P GBNJMJBT 5SBT FM BHP
UBNJFOUP EF MBT SFTFSWBT EF QFUSØMFP Z
MB QÏSEJEB EF FOFSHÓB Z EJOBNJTNP EF
MB OPUBCMF DJWJMJ[BDJØO OPSUFBNFSJDBOB
EFTEFZBBGFDUBEBQPSMBUJOPTOPTJFNQSF
UBODSFBUJWPTZHFOJBMFT{DØNPTFDPN
QPSUBSÈMBEPNJOBDJØODIJOB {$ØNPTF
DPNQPSUBSÈFMJNQFSJBMJTNPGVOEBNFO
UBMJTUBEFVO*TMBNDVZPTPQMPOPEBTF
×BMFTEFBHPUBNJFOUP 0{RVÏPDVSSJSÈ
DPO FM FODVFOUSP JOFWJUBCMF EF FTUBT
EPTGVFS[BTFOVOGVUVSPSFMBUJWBNFOUF
QSØYJNP {2VÏDVMUJWPIBSÈVOBZPUSB
EF MBT DPORVJTUBT ZB SFBMJ[BEBT QPS MB
CJPÏUJDB #JPÏUJDB FDPMPHÓB Z FDPOPNÓB TF FO
DVFOUSBODPOFDUBEBT%FCFONPTUSBSTF
BMBSHPQMB[PDPNPGBDUPSFTEFQSPNP
DJØOEFVOCJFODPNÞOVOJWFSTBMQFSP
QBMQBCMF B QFTBS EF MB USBEJDJPOBM DF
HVFSBEFMPTQPUFOUBEPT1PSMPHFOFSBM
FYJTUFVOBNJTUFSJPTBDPOFYJØOFOUSFMP
NÈTDFSDBOPZMPNÈTMFKBOPNÈTEFVOB
JOWFODJØOTVSHFEFMBSFQFOUJOBZDBTVBM
BQSPYJNBDJØOEFEBUPTRVFOPBDPTUVN
CSBNPTBDPOTJEFSBSKVOUPT
&O TV DBQÓUVMP EF JOUSPEVDDJØO IJTUØ
SJDB %JFHP (SBDJB MMBNB MB BUFODJØO
BDFSDB EF MB FWFOUVBM PQPSUVOJEBE EF
QSPGVOEJ[BS MPT QSJODJQJPT EF KVTUJDJB
ZEFOPNBMFmDFODJBRVFQBSFDFONÈT
BQSPQJBEPT BM DPOUFYUP BRVÓ FTUVEJBEP
&TUBQFSUJOFOUFSFnFYJØONFSFDFDPOTJ
EFSBDJØOQFSPOPFTEFDJTJWB/PTPUSPT
NJTNPT IFNPT QMBOUFBEP BRVÓ FM UFNB
1FSTQFDUJWBTEFMB#JPÏUJDBFO*CFSPBNÏSJDB
FDPOØNJDPRVFQFTBDBEBWF[NÈTTPCSF
FMEFTBGÓPTBOJUBSJPOPUBOUPFOSB[ØOEF
MBNVMUJQMJDBDJØOEFMBQPCMBDJØOFTQF
DJBMNFOUFEFMPTJOGPSUVOBEPTFNJHSBO
UFT RVF IVZFO EF TV QBÓT NJTFSBCMF P
HPCFSOBEPQPSQPMÓUJDPTTJOFTDSÞQVMPT
DPO MPT DVBMFT MPT HPCJFSOPT EFM OPSUF
OP QVFEFO FWJUBS USBUBS
DPNP EF MPT
DSFDJFOUFT DPTUPT TBOJUBSJPT DVSBUJWPT Z
QSFWFOUJWPT&MUFNBEFMBKVTUJDJBFTVO
UFNB EF ÏUJDB HFOFSBM EF MB QPCMBDJØO
QPSUBOUPDPNQMFKBZQSÈDUJDBNFOUFJO
TPMVCMF TJ FM QVFCMP DPNQSVFCB MB JN
QVOJEBE EF MPT HSBOEFT EF MPT JNQPS
UBOUFTEFMPTQPMÓUJDPTVPUSPTTF×PSFT
JODMVTP DVBOEP TPO TPSQSFOEJEPT DPO
iMBTNBOPTFOMBNBTBwZTPOUSBUBEPTFO
FMUSJCVOBMPFOMBDPNJTJØOEFÏUJDBFO
TFTJPOFTRVFUFSNJOBOUSBEJDJPOBMNFOUF
FOOBEB.JFOUSBTUBOUPBRVÓTFFYQMJDJ
UBVOBWF[NÈTMBSFMBDJØOFOUSFVOBTB
CJBQSFWJTJØOTPDJBMVOSFTHVBSEPKVTUP
EFMPTQSFTVQVFTUPTTBOJUBSJPTQBSBSJDPT
ZQPCSFTFOMPQPTJCMFTJOFMUSBEJDJPOBM
QSJWJMFHJPEFMPTSJDPTRVFQPESÓBOQBHBS
EFTVCPMTJMMPDVFOUBTHSBOEFTPQFRVF
×BT/PQPEFNPTBCSJSBRVÓVOEPTTJFS
GVOEBNFOUBM EF QSFWJTJØO TPDJBM EF TV
DPTUPZPSHBOJ[BDJØOGVODJPOBMFGFDUJWP
PEFmDJFOUF&MEFTBGÓPEFCFTFSUSBUBEP
QBÓT QPS QBÓT &TUBEP QPS &TUBEP DPO
QFSJDJBTQSPQJBT
&ODVBOUPBMBSHVNFOUPEFMBiOPNBMF
mDFODJBwUBNQPDPTFUSBUBEFVOBTVOUP
TJNQMFQPSRVFHSBOEFTNBMFmDFODJBTEF
MPTQPUFOUBEPTQBSFDFONÈTTPQPSUBCMFT
RVF NÓOJNBT JOGSBDDJPOFT EF HFOUF TJO
QPEFS OJ EJOFSP QBSB SFTQBMEBSTF -PT
QSPDFTPTEFJOEFNOJ[BDJPOFTTPOEJGÓDJ
PERSPETIVADELABIOETICAINDD
MFTMBSHPTZBSSJFTHBEPTQBSBMPTQPCSFT
&M UFNB DPNQSFOEF BNQMJPT NÈSHFOFT
EFQSPDFTPQFOBMZOPFYDFQUÞBMBTSFBD
DJPOFT EFGFOTJWBT EF MBT PSHBOJ[BDJPOFT
NÏEJDBT 5BNCJÏO JOWPMVDSB FM QSJODJ
QJPEFBVUPOPNÓBEFMQBDJFOUF"MIBCMBS
EFBVUPOPNÓBEFCFNPTQSFTUBSBUFODJØO
BMBJNQPSUBODJBEFMDPOUFYUPTPDJPMØHJ
DPZBMBTDPOEJDJPOFTEFMQBDJFOUFRVF
MJNJUBO TV SFBM BVUPOPNÓB MB DVBM EF
DVBMRVJFS NPEP EFQFOEF EF MBT JOGPS
NBDJPOFTRVFIBZBSFDJCJEPFOSFMBDJØO
DPOTVDBTP&ODVBOUPBMBTDPOEJDJPOFT
EFNJTFSJBTBOJUBSJBEFMQVFCMPIVNJMEF
EFUJFNQPTQBTBEPTFYJTUFBCVOEBOUFF
JOUFSFTBOUFCJCMJPHSBGÓBRVFGBUBMNFOUF
QPS PCWJPT DPOEJDJPOBNJFOUPT DVMUV
SBMFTFTNÈTDPNQMFUBZBCVOEBOUFFO
QBÓTFTEFMIFNJTGFSJPOPSUF-FQBSHOFVS
&M QSJODJQJBMJTNP QFOFUSØ FO MB $VCB
EF 'JEFM TJO NVDIB EJmDVMUBE TPCSF
UPEPBQBSUJSEFMBFEJDJØOFOEF
i#JPÏUJDBQBSBMBTVTUFOUBCJMJEBEwPCSB
DPMFDUJWB DPPSEJOBEB QPS + 3 "DPTUB
EFTUBDBOEP FM DBQÓUVMP i1SPZFDUPT QBSB
VOBCJPÏUJDBHMPCBMwEF+".BSUÓOF[
(ØNF[ %JDIB BTJNJMBDJØO TF QSPEVKP
OP TJO QSPUFDDJPOFT HMPCBMFT F JOEJWJ
EVBMFTFTEFDJSNBUJ[BOEPFMQSJODJQJP
EFBVUPOPNÓBJOEJWJEVBMZQVOUVBMJ[BO
EPRVFMPTQSJODJQJPTEFCFOFmDFODJBZ
EF TPMJEBSJEBE DPOTUJUVZFO MB NÈYJNB
FYQSFTJØO EF KVTUJDJB &M SÏHJNFO TBOJ
UBSJPDPOTUJUVZFFMÈSFBGVFSUFEF$VCB
QPTJCMFNFOUFFOQFSKVJDJPEFPUSPTTFD
UPSFTTPDJPFDPOØNJDPTEFMBNJTNBDVM
UVSBQFSPFMSÏHJNFONFSFDFNÈTEFVOB
NFEBMMBQPSTVBMUSVJTNPBMBZVEBSTBOJ
6OBNJSBEBQSPTQFDUJWB)VCFSU-FQBSHOFVS
UBSJBNFOUFFONPNFOUPTEFEJmDVMUBE
BPUSPTQBÓTFTDPODBSFODJBEFNÏEJDPT
$IJMF FO "SHFMJB FO $B
DIFNJSB FO *OEPOFTJB FO 7FOF[VFMB FO "SBVKP QSPQVTP
TVTUJUVJSMBUSÓBEBiCFOFmDFODJBBVUPOP
NÓBZKVTUJDJBwQPSiBDDFTJCJMJEBEQBSUJ
DJQBDJØOZFRVJEBEwQFSPTPOEFUBMMFT
&WBMVBDJØOHFOFSBM
4FSÓB TVQFSnVP BM UÏSNJOP EF UBO EF
NPSBEBJOWFTUJHBDJØOIJTUØSJDBEFTUBDBS
MBPQPSUVOJEBEZDBMJEBEEFFTUFBDVDJP
TPQSPZFDUPDPODMVJEPFOUJFNQPPQPS
UVOP USFJOUB B×PT EF EFOTB Z GFDVOEB
JOWFTUJHBDJØO JOOPWBEPSB FO "NÏSJDB
IJTQBOPCSBTJMF×B5SFJOUBB×PTEFDPO
RVJTUBTFOUFSSFOPTOPTJFNQSFQSFQBSB
EPTQBSBUBMFNQBMNFEFJOWFTUJHBDJØOZ
EJTDVTJØOQSPWFDIPTBTDPOMBmOBMJEBE
EFVOCJFODPNÞORVFFYJKBBÞOOVFWPT
FTGVFS[PTEFFYQBOTJØO4JOEVEBUBMFT
FTGVFS[PT ZB UVWJFSPO BMHVOB FmDBDJB
OPTØMPFODVBOUPBMBTBMVEEFMBTQP
CMBDJPOFTTJOPUBNCJÏOFOFMEFTBSSPMMP
QPMÓUJDPDVMUVSBMEFFTBTTPDJFEBEFT-BT
NPOPHSBGÓBTZCJPHSBGÓBTEFUBMMBEBTQSF
TFOUBO ZB VOB TPCFSCJB EFOTJEBE Z VO
IPOSPTP WPMVNFO FO UPSOP EF MBT USFT
QSJODJQBMFTMFOHVBT
)BZBPOPMBJOnVFODJBEFMBOUJBNFSJDB
OJTNPRVFQSFWBMFDJØFOOVFTUSBÏQPDB
FO FM NVOEP QPS EJWFSTBT SB[POFT FM
DBSÈDUFSMBUJOPTJFNQSFGVFEJGFSFOUFEFM
OPSUFBNFSJDBOP
FTFWJEFOUFMBEJmDVM
UBE BDUVBM FO WBSJPT QBÓTFT EF "NÏSJDB
-BUJOB QBSB SFDJCJS FOUFOEFS Z BQMJDBS
MPT GBNPTPT DVBUSP iQSJODJQJPTw EF MB
PERSPETIVADELABIOETICAINDD
QSÈDUJDB CJPÏUJDB FO &TUBEPT 6OJEPT
BVUPOPNÓB CFOFmDFODJB OP NBMFm
DFODJB Z KVTUJDJB 4PO EF DBSÈDUFS NÈT
JOEJWJEVBMJTUB Z BOBMÓUJDP RVF MP RVF
BDPTUVNCSBFMDPNVOJUBSJTNPMBUJOPZ
UBNCJÏOBGSJDBOPZBTJÈUJDP
$BEBQBÓT
QPTFF DPODFQUPT Z QSFDPODFQUPT QSP
QJPT$BNCJBSWBMPSFTFTNÈTEJGÓDJMRVF
BDFQUBS VOB JOWFODJØO UFDOPMØHJDB FO
DBTPEFRVFIVCJFTFVOmOBODJBNJFOUP
PQPSUVOP
&OFTUBPCSBTPCSFMBIJTUPSJBEFMBCJP
ÏUJDBFO*CFSPBNÏSJDBDPNPFSBQSFWJ
TJCMFZOPSNBMNÈTEFVODPMBCPSBEPS
EFTUBDBMBPSJHJOBMJEBEEFTVQBÓTEFTV
SFHJØOZFWFOUVBMNFOUFTVQSPQJBDPO
USJCVDJØOIBDJFOEPOPUBSMBTBCJBFMFD
DJØO EF RVJFOFT BDFQUBSPO QBSUJDJQBS
%FFTUPTQBTPTTVEBNFSJDBOPTOPTFQP
ESÓBEFTDPOPDFSFMUSJCVUPJOJDJBMEFMIF
NJTGFSJPOPSUFFNJOFOUFNFOUFEFMBGF
EFSBDJØOOPSUFBNFSJDBOBTPCSFUPEPFO
OVFTUSBÏQPDBEFHMPCBMJ[BDJØOFOMBDVBM
FMDPOPDJNJFOUPUFDOPMØHJDPTFEJGVOEF
SÈQJEBNFOUF OP TJO VOB EFQFOEFO
DJBEFMBTJOWFSTJPOFTEJTQPOJCMFTQFSP
UBNCJÏOHSBDJBTBMOÞNFSPDSFDJFOUFEF
SFWJTUBT Z DPOHSFTPT FTQFDJBMJ[BEPT Z B
PUSBT JOTUBODJBT EF JOUFSDBNCJP DPNP
TPO*OUFSOFURVFMMFHBBBOUJDJQBSZDBTJ
QFSKVEJDBS MBT OPWFEBEFT PGSFDJEBT QPS
MBT SFWJTUBT FTQFDJBMJ[BEBT *OnVFODJBT
DVMUVSBMFTZUBNCJÏOIJTUØSJDBTJOUFSmF
SFOGBUBMZBGPSUVOBEBNFOUFDBEBQBÓT
DBEB DPOUSJCVZFOUF TF TJFOUF PSHVMMPTP
EFMQBUSJNPOJPRVFQPSWFOUVSBÏMBZV
EØ B JOJDJBS Z EFTBSSPMMBS Z EFM DVBM TF
TJFOUFTPMJEBSJP
1FSTQFDUJWBTEFMB#JPÏUJDBFO*CFSPBNÏSJDB
"EFNÈT EF "SHFOUJOB oRVF FO FM DPO
UJOFOUF GVF FM QJPOFSP JOTUJUVDJPOBM EF
MB CJPÏUJDBo NFSFDFO EFTUBDBSTF 7FOF
[VFMB Z $PMPNCJB FTUB ÞMUJNB QPS TVT
FTGVFS[PT QSFDPDFT QBSB BQSPYJNBS FM
IVNBOJTNPBMFKFSDJDJPEFMBNFEJDJOB
ZBMBGPSNBDJØOJOUFHSBMEFMPTNÏEJDPT
" QFTBS EFM BMUP JOUFSÏT EFM JEFBM EF MB
NFEJDJOBDPNÞOFMQMVSBMJTNPDVMUVSBM
TJFNQSF JNQFEJSÈ DPNQMFUBSMP FO SB
[ØOQSFDJTBNFOUFEFMQBQFMDFOUSBMEF
MB NFEJDJOB FO DVBMRVJFS DVMUVSB UPEP
IPNCSFUPEPQVFCMPEFCFEFGFOEFSTV
QSPQJB WJUBMJEBE Z TVQFSWJWFODJB &TUBT
DVMUVSBT FTUÈO EJWFSTBNFOUF QSFQBSBEBT
QBSBBDFQUBSZFOUFOEFSMPTBWBODFTNÈT
SFDJFOUFTEFMBCJPÏUJDB&MSÈQJEPÏYJUP
EFMPTUSBTQMBOUFTFO"NÏSJDB-BUJOBZ
TPCSF UPEP FO #SBTJM OP FSB FWJEFOUF
ÏM TF EFCF OP QPDP B MB JODVFTUJPOBCMF
IBCJMJEBE NBOVBM EF DJFSUPT DJSVKBOPT
BTÓ DPNP BM HVTUP QPS FM SJFTHP NÈT
QSPOVODJBEPBRVÓRVFFOFMDPOUJOFOUF
FVSPQFP
-B JOnVFODJB EF MB NPSBM DBUØMJDB FO
"NÏSJDB -BUJOB UBNCJÏO QPESÓB TFS
DVFTUJPOBEBZBTFBQBSBBZVEBSBUSBWÏT
EF MB DPOUSJCVDJØO QPTJUJWB EF BMHVOBT
GBDVMUBEFTZEFBMHVOPTUFØMPHPT
ZBTFB
QBSBJNQPSUVOBS%FDVBMRVJFSNBOFSB
QBSFDFoTFHÞOMBOPUBCMFTÓOUFTJTEF"M
GPOTP -MBOP &TDPCBSo RVF FM PSEFO EF
BQBSJDJØO EF MB CJPÏUJDB FO FTUB SFHJØO
GVFFMTJHVJFOUF"SHFOUJOBRVFSFBMJ[Ø
FM**$POHSFTP.VOEJBMEF#JPÏUJDBFO
$PMPNCJB1FSÞ$IJMF.ÏYJDP
Z#SBTJMQBÓTRVFTFEFTUBDØBMIPTQFEBS
FM 1SJNFS $POHSFTP -BUJOPBNFSJDBOP
EF #JPÏUJDB FO M Z FM 7* $POHSFTP
PERSPETIVADELABIOETICAINDD
.VOEJBMEF#JPÏUJDBFO#SBTJMJB
%'
-B0SHBOJ[BDJØO1BOBNFSJDBOBEF
MB4BMVEUJFOFGVFSUFJOnVFODJBQPTJUJWB
KVOUPDPO$IJMFZTVQSJODJQBMVOJWFSTJ
EBEFOEPOEFmKØTVTFEF
&M NVOEP FOUFSP OFDFTJUB DPMBCPSB
DJØOEFMDPOUJOFOUFBRVÓFOFYBNFOFO
DVBOUPBTVQBTBEPSFDJFOUFQPSRVFMPT
MVHBSFT NÈT BWBO[BEPT EF MB UJFSSB TF
FODVFOUSBO DPNP UPEP FM QMBOFUB FO
TJUVBDJØO EF SJFTHP #JPÏUJDB Z QSFPDV
QBDJPOFTFDPMØHJDBTBVORVFTFBBUÓUVMP
EFQSFWFODJØOEFTBMVEQÞCMJDBBDBCBO
QPSUPSOBSTFTPMJEBSJBT/PIBDFNVDIPT
B×PTVOBHSØOPNPEFWBTUBFYQFSJFODJB
3FOÏ%VNPOUFTDSJCÓBi-BTBNFOB[BT
TFFTUÈOQSFDJTBOEP4POTFSJBTZQPOFO
FO QFMJHSP MB FYJTUFODJB NJTNB EF MPT
IPNCSFT FO MB 5JFSSB &M BHPUBNJFOUP
EFMPTSFDVSTPTFTUÈJMVTUSBEPQPSFMBM[B
EFMQSFDJPEFMQFUSØMFPZEFMBTNBUFSJBT
QSJNBT-PTTVFMPTFMBJSFZFMBHVBFTUÈO
DPOUBNJOBEPT B WFDFT EF NBOFSB JSSF
WFSTJCMF FTQFDJFT WFHFUBMFT Z BOJNBMFT
JOEJTQFOTBCMFTQBSBMBWJEBEFTBQBSFDFO
FO OÞNFSP DSFDJFOUF #JMMPOFT EF TFSFT
IVNBOPT NÈT EF TFJT CJMMPOFT BDUVBM
NFOUF
USFTDVBSUPTWJWFOFOHSBOQP
CSF[BDVBOEPMPTQBÓTFTSJDPTDBTJNP
OPQPMJ[BOMPTSFDVSTPTIVNBOPTw
.ÈTSFDJFOUFNFOUFi1BSBDVBUSPCJMMP
OFTEFTFSFTIVNBOPTMBGBMUBEFBHVBZ
PUSPTTPOQSPWPDBEPTQPSJOVOEBDJPOFT
4VHFSFODJBT FYJTUFO QPS FKFNQMP EFM
FDPMPHJTUB /JDPMÈT )VMPU DPNP OPN
CSBS VO WJDFQSJNFSNJOJTUSP FODBSHBEP
EFMEFTBSSPMMPTVTUFOUBCMFJOTUBVSBSVOB
iUBTBDBSCPOPwIBTUBEJWJEJSQPSDVBUSP
6OBNJSBEBQSPTQFDUJWB)VCFSU-FQBSHOFVS
MBTFNJTJPOFTEFHBTDBSCØOJDPSFGPSNBS
MPTTJUJPTBHSÓDPMBTDPOTVMUBSBMQÞCMJDP
BDFSDBEFMBTPSJFOUBDJPOFTEFMEFTBSSP
MMPJOGPSNBOEPTPCSFTVBEIFTJØOBMBT
SFTUSJDDJPOFT NFKPSBS P HFOFSBMJ[BS MB
FEVDBDJØO Z MB GPSNBDJØO QSPGFTJPOBMw
)VMPU
5PEPFTUPUPSOBOPNF
OPT FWJEFOUF MB JOUFSEFQFOEFODJB FOUSF
MBCJPÏUJDBZMBQPMÓUJDBFOHFOFSBMRVF
EFCF BCBSDBS DPNP FM ÓUFN NÈT JODØ
NPEPEFMBQPMÓUJDBEFTBMVEFMBVNFO
UP BMBSNBOUF EF TV DPTUP FO UPEPT MPT
QBÓTFT MPT JOWFTUJHBEPSFT QJEFO NBZPS
QSFTVQVFTUPQBSBMBNBOUFODJØOEFTVT
USBCBKPT Z EF TVT MBCPSBUPSJPT /ØUFTF
RVFBIÓSFTJEFOQSFDJTBNFOUFMBTFOUJ
EBEFTGBSNBDPMØHJDBTQFSPOPUFOFNPT
RVFDPNFOUBSBRVÓTVTSÓHJEBTQFSTQFDUJ
WBTEFBVUPEFTBSSPMMPFDPOØNJDP
0CTFSWBNPT BTJNJTNP MB WJODVMBDJØO
FOUSFMBTQSÈDUJDBTDBTJDPOTFOTVBMFTRVF
NBOUJFOF MB CJPÏUJDB DPO MBT FWPMVDJP
OFT TPDJPQPMÓUJDBT FO HFOFSBM GBWPSB
CMFTQPSMPNFOPTFOBMHVOPTQBÓTFTEF
"NÏSJDB -BUJOB /ØUFTF QPS FKFNQMP
DØNP FO CJPÏUJDB MB HFTUJØO BVUPSJUBSJB
EFMFTQBDJPEFMBTBMVEDFEFMVHBSQPDP
B QPDP B QSÈDUJDBT EFNPDSÈUJDBT 4JO
FYBHFSBS QPSRVF DPNP EJDF 'SBODJT
DP #BUJTUB +S i&M DPOUSPM TPDJBM FT VO
QSPZFDUP FO DPOTUSVDDJØOw *E
Z RVF
USBUÈOEPTFEF"*%4FO#SBTJMiUFOFNPT
NVDIBDIBT QBSB EJF[ NVDIBDIPTw
%F DVBMRVJFS NBOFSB i&T QSFDJTP GPS
NBS VOB QFSTQFDUJWB EF TPMJEBSJEBE MB
UJOPBNFSJDBOBDPOQSPZFDUPTDPODSFUPT
DPNPFMQSPCMFNBBNCJFOUBMRVFBGFD
UBFTQFDJBMNFOUFBMBQPCMBDJØOQPCSFw
"SZ$BSWBMIP*E
{$POTFHVJSÈOUBMFT
PERSPETIVADELABIOETICAINDD
QSFPDVQBDJPOFT JOUFHSBS BMHÞO EÓB VO
QSPHSBNBNÈTFYUFOTJWPEFM.FSDPTVS 3BEJT
$POMBEPDVNFOUBDJØORVFZBDPOTFHVJ
NPTQFSDJCJNPTRVFMBTQSJODJQBMFTEJ
GFSFODJBTFOUSFVOQBÓTZPUSPUJFOFORVF
WFSTPCSFUPEPDPOMBJOTFSDJØOTPDJPKV
SÓEJDBFTEFDJSJOTUJUVDJPOBMEFMBCJPÏ
UJDBUPNBOEPFODVFOUBQPSTVQVFTUP
MBTQSPQPSDJPOFTSFMBUJWBTEFMBTEJWFSTBT
EPMFODJBTVPQFSBDJPOFTPQPSUVOBT/P
NFOPT FWJEFOUFT TPO MBT EJGFSFODJBT FO
MBGSFDVFODJBEFMBTSFVOJPOFTQSPGFTJP
OBMFT Z MB EFOTJEBE EF MPT OÞDMFPT BTÓ
DPNPMBSBQJEF[EFMBTUSBOTGPSNBDJPOFT
RVFQVFEFUSBOTDVSSJSEFTEFMBFWPMVDJØO
EFMBTNFOUBMJEBEFTBMBBQFSUVSBBOVF
WBT WJTJPOFT DJFOUÓmDBT MB BDDFTJCJMJEBE
B OVFWPT BQSFOEJ[BKFT Z MB nFYJCJMJEBE
EFMBTJOTUJUVDJPOFTQBSBBDPHFSOPWFEB
EFTRVFRVJFCSFOMBSVUJOB&YJTUJSÈMV
HBSQBSBNPOPHSBGÓBTDPNQBSBUJWBTRVF
DPNQMFUBSÈO MBT JOGPSNBDJPOFT MPDBMFT
ZOBDJPOBMFT0CTFSWBOEPBEFNÈTBMPT
QJPOFSPT RVF DPNFO[BSPO DPO MB CJPÏ
UJDB FO FM DPOUJOFOUF MBUJOPBNFSJDBOP
DPNP "SHFOUJOB Z #SBTJM FODPOUSBNPT
OPSNBMRVFFTUBEJTDJQMJOBTFBTPMJEBSJB
DPOFMSFTUPEFMBFWPMVDJØOFDPOØNJDP
DVMUVSBM $PO MB NVMUJQMJDBDJØO EF MPT
DPNJUÏTDPOTFKPTPDPNJTJPOFT
OBDJP
OBMFT EF CJPÏUJDB TVSHJSÈ UBSEF P UFN
QSBOP VOB $PNJTJØO *OUFSBNFSJDBOB
*CFSPCSBTJMF×BEFJOUFSDBNCJPEFJOGPS
NBDJPOFT Z SFHMBNFOUPT DPNVOFT UBM
DPNPFYJTUFFOMB6OJØO&VSPQFBDVZB
BDUJWJEBESFWFMBMBEJmDVMUBEEFDPODJMJBS
EJGFSFOUFTUSBEJDJPOFTTBOJUBSJBTZIBTUB
ÏUJDBT&OUSFUBOUPFMMFDUPSTBCFRVFZB
1FSTQFDUJWBTEFMB#JPÏUJDBFO*CFSPBNÏSJDB
FYJTUF VOB 0SHBOJ[BDJØO 1BOBNFSJDBOB
EFMB4BMVERVFSFBMJ[BVOCVFOUSBCBKP
TJONVDIBQSPQBHBOEBMBVEBUPSJB
&O&TUBEPT6OJEPTFYJTUFBNQMJBMJUFSB
UVSBTPCSFMPTQSPDFEJNJFOUPTEFTFBCMFT
QBSBSFQBSUJSMBTTJFNQSFFTDBTBTBTJHOB
DJPOFT EF SFDVSTPT TBOJUBSJPT FO EFUFS
NJOBEPTDPOUFYUPTPDJSDVOTUBODJBT%F
NPEP RVF OP OPT QBSFDF FWJEFOUF RVF
GBMUFO DPOTJEFSBDJPOFT UFØSJDBT Z QSJO
DJQJBMJTUBT TPCSF MB NBUFSJB &O "NÏ
SJDB-BUJOBOPTQBSFDFRVFFMOVEPEF
MBDVFTUJØOFTQPMÓUJDPFYJTUFOQSÈDUJDBT
FWBTJWBTDVBOEPTFUSBUBEFBQMJDBSPOP
SFHMBTFYJTUFOUFTQBSBBUFOEFSOFDFTJEB
EFT PCWJBT -BT QPCMBDJPOFT FTUÈO EFT
JHVBMNFOUFSFQSFTFOUBEBTZFMQPEFSEF
MPT MPCCJFT FT UBO JNQPSUBOUF DPNP FO
&TUBEPT 6OJEPT BVORVF OP FTUÈ SFHMB
NFOUBEP DPNP FO FTF QBÓT 4F QSJWJMF
HJBNÈTBDJFSUBTDBUFHPSÓBTTPDJBMFTRVF
B MPT NÈT OFDFTJUBEPT GSFDVFOUFNFOUF
FTDPOEJEPTGBWPSFDJFOEPBDJFSUPT&TUB
EPTNÈTRVFBPUSPTEFMNJTNPQBÓTP
BDBTPTJOEJWJEVBMFTUPDBOEPBQPMÓUJDPT
QPEFSPTPT P B QSPQBHBOEB EF EFUFSNJ
OBEPQBSUJEP&OUPODFTFONJPQJOJØO
FM QSPCMFNB FT FTFODJBMNFOUF QPMÓUJDP
Z DVMUVSBM QPS UBOUP MJHBEP B MB FEV
DBDJØO
ZOPTFDBNCJBOGÈDJMNFOUFMPT
IÈCJUPTQPMÓUJDPTOJTJRVJFSBDPOMFZFTP
SFHMBNFOUPTDPOPTJOBQMJDBDJØOJOUFS
QSFUBEPTBMHVTUPEFMBTDPODJFODJBTEF
MPTKVFDFTZEFMPTQPMÓUJDPTOPTJFNQSF
NVZQSPCPTFJOPDFOUFT
&M DPOUFYUP EF MB BQMJDBDJØO EFM QSJO
DJQJP EF OP NBMFmDFODJB BM FOGFSNP P
BMDJVEBEBOPFTFMNJTNP-PTSFDVSTPT
PERSPETIVADELABIOETICAINDD
DPOUSB NÏEJDPT TPO HFOFSBMNFOUF KV[
HBEPTFODPNJTJPOFTQSPGFTJPOBMFTDVZB
BVUPJOEVMHFODJB DPSQPSBUJWB OP QSFDJ
TB EFNPTUSBDJØO QBSUJDVMBS &O WBSJPT
QBÓTFTQSÈDUJDBTBTJEVBTEFUPSUVSBCBKP
DPCFSUVSBEFHPCJFSOPTBVUPSJUBSJPTJO
DMVTPEFTQVÏTEFMmOEFUBMFTHPCJFSOPT
JODMVTP DPO TPNFUJEPT B QSPDFTPT BDB
CBOFOBNOJTUÓBTPBCTPMVDJPOFTPBQMB
[BNJFOUP JOEFmOJEP EFM KV[HBNJFOUP
mOBMBOUFTEFMBNVFSUFEFMPTDVMQBCMFT
PEFMmOEFMPTQMB[PTEFMBQSFTDSJQDJØO
&MUFNBEFMBTQSVFCBTFMDPTUPZMBQSP
MPOHBDJØOEFJOUFSSPHBUPSJPTFTUÏSJMFTMB
QSPUFDDJØOZMBWFSBDJEBEEFMPTUFTUJNP
OJPTZMPTDIBOUBKFTEFWBSJPTUJQPTEJm
DVMUBORVFMPTQPCSFTBGFDUBEPTTFBOEF
CJEBNFOUFBTJTUJEPTUBOUPRVFBMHVOPT
BCPHBEPTDPOTJHVFOQBSBMFTJPOFTJOTJH
OJmDBOUFTPiQFSKVJDJPTMMBNBEPTNPSB
MFTwJOEFNOJ[BDJPOFTEFNPOUPDPMPTBM
&MBTVOUPUBNCJÏOUJFOFSFMBDJØODPOFM
QSJODJQJPEFBVUPOPNÓBSFTQFUPQPSFM
DVBMUVWFMBPQPSUVOJEBEEFEFTUBDBSFO
PUSBPCSBTFHÞOMBJNQPSUBODJBEFMDPO
UFYUPTPDJPMØHJDPFOFMRVFWJWFPWJWJØ
FMQBDJFOUF-FQBSHOFVS
/PFTJNQPTJCMFRVFMBDVFTUJØOFDPOØ
NJDBJOUFSWFOHBFOFMGVUVSPFO"NÏSJDB
-BUJOBUBMDPNPFTUÈJOUFSWJOJFOEPBIP
SBFO*OEJBBVODVBOEPMBNBZPSÓBEF
TVQPCMBDJØOFTUBCBZBCBKPMBMÓOFBEF
QPCSF[B&O#SBTJMBQFTBSEFMBTMJTUBT
EFFTQFSBMPTUSBTQMBOUFTEFØSHBOPTZB
TPOOPUPSJBNFOUFOVNFSPTPTUBOUPRVF
TVT DPTUPT JOGFSJPSFT B MPT OPSUFBNFSJ
DBOPTTPOBQSPQJBEPTQBSBBUSBFSBFO
GFSNPTFYUSBOKFSPT%FTEFZBFO*OEJB
VOBUSFJOUFOBEFIPTQJUBMFTQSJWBEPTEF
6OBNJSBEBQSPTQFDUJWB)VCFSU-FQBSHOFVS
CVFOQSFTUJHJPBDPHJFSPOFOBDFS
DBEFiUVSJTUBTTBOJUBSJPTwRVF
RVFSÓBO CFOFmDJBSTF DPO TVT QSFDJPT B WFDFT JOGFSJPSFT RVF MPT DPCSBEPT
FO&TUBEPT6OJEPTPFO(SBO#SFUB×B
4FFTUJNBRVFFODJODPB×PTFMiUVSJTNP
NÏEJDPwQSPQPSDJPOBSÈBMB*OEJBEPTP
USFTCJMMPOFTEFEØMBSFTFTEFDJSMBNJ
UBEEFMPRVFJOHSFTBIPZQPSTViUFSDF
SJ[BDJØOwJOGPSNÈUJDB
'SFOUFBMBTBNFOB[BT
QMBOFUBSJBTNFEJBOUFMBCJPÏUJDB
ZBEFNÈTEFFMMB
3FUPNBNPT MB JEFB RVF FYQSFTBNPT BM
JOJDJPEFMUFYUPSFTQFDUPEFMBWVFMUBBM
IJQPUÏUJDP IPSJ[POUF EF VOB NPSBM DP
NÞOEFMBDVBMMBCJPÏUJDBDPOTUJUVJSÓB
VOTFSJPGVOEBNFOUPQPSRVFFTNFOPT
NBOJQVMBCMF QPS JEFPMPHÓBT RVF PUSPT
TFDUPSFTEFMBDVMUVSB$POTVBNQMJBJO
GPSNBDJØOZTVKVJDJPTFHVSPFMQFSJPEJT
UBFJOWFTUJHBEPSFDPMØHJDP8BTIJOHUPO
/PWBT OPT IB BEWFSUJEP TPCSF BMHVOPT
QVOUPT SFDPSEBEPT FTQFDJBMNFOUF QPS
,Pm"OOBOQPDPBOUFTEFRVFEFKBSBFM
DBSHPEFTFDSFUBSJPHFOFSBMEFMB0/6
FYJTUFO QFMJHSPT QPUFODJBMFT EF SÈQJEP
DSFDJNJFOUP EF MB JOEVTUSJB CJPUFDOP
MØHJDBWJODVMBEPTBMDPNCBUFEFMFWFO
UVBMCJPUFSSPSJTNP4FSFGFSÓBBQPTJCMFT
iSFTVMUBEPT DBUBTUSØmDPTw EF SFDJFOUFT
BWBODFTEFMBCJPUFDOPMPHÓBRVFQPESÓBO
DBFS FO NBOPT FSSBEBT QSJODJQBMNFOUF
EF NBOJQVMBDJØO HFOÏUJDB Z EF JOWFT
UJHBDJPOFT DPO WJSVT 4FHÞO "OOBO FO
FOFSPEFUBMFTBNFOB[BTDSFDFSÓBO
FYQPOFODJBMNFOUFZOPIBCSÓBQBÓTQP
CSFPSJDPQSPUFHJEPBQSJPSJ-BEJTUSJ
PERSPETIVADELABIOETICAINDD
CVDJØOFOUJFNQPÞUJMEFMPTJOTUSVNFO
UPTQSFWFOUJWPTPMPTSFNFEJPTBDFSUBEPT
OP FTUÈ BTFHVSBEB -PT SJFTHPT EF MBT
NJTNBTJOWFTUJHBDJPOFTZMBEJTQPTJDJØO
EFMBTHSBOEFTmSNBTGBSNBDÏVUJDBTQBSB
BZVEBSBMBTSFHJPOFTQPCSFTFOTVTQF
MJHSPTQSPQJPTFTUÈMFKPTEFFTUBSBTFHV
SBEBBQFTBSEFOPQPDBTDPOWFODJPOFT
Z SFVOJPOFT -B NJTNB 0SHBOJ[BDJØO
.VOEJBM EF MB 4BMVE TF TJFOUF VO UBO
UPBJTMBEBFOTVQSFPDVQBDJØOQPSFWJUBS
VOBQBOEFNJBEFMUJQPEFMBHSJQFBWJBS
"OUF MB EFCJMJEBE EF MB BVUPEFGFOTB EF
MPT QBÓTFT SJDPT FO NBUFSJB EF SJFTHPT
QBOEÏNJDPT {DØNP FTQFSBS VOB HSBO
BZVEB EJSJHJEB FTQFDJBMNFOUF IBDJB MPT
QBÓTFTNFOPTQSØTQFSPTEF"NÏSJDB-B
UJOBPEF«GSJDB 0USPTQFMJHSPTWJFOFO
EF MB OFPOBOPUFDOPMPHÓB RVF FTDBQB
EF OVFTUSP ÈNCJUP QSFTFOUF /PWBFT
-B JOFWJUBCMF MJNJUBDJØO EF MB CJPÏUJDB
JODFOUJWB OVFTUSB SFnFYJØO BDFSDB EF
DØNPTBMWBSMBWJEBGÓTJDBDMBWFFWJEFO
UF QBSB VO NBZPS P NÈT FMFWBEP OJWFM
EFWJEBRVFTFQVFEBQFSNJUJSBMPTTF
SFT IVNBOPT .BT {DVÈM FT FM NPUJWP
QSPGVOEP QBSB SFDPOPDFS UBOUB JNQPS
UBODJBBOVFTUSPTQPDPTB×PTCJPMØHJDPT
EFQFSNBOFODJBTPCSFFTUFQMBOFUB &O
MB JOGBODJB EF NVDIPT TFSFT IVNBOPT
TVSHF MB JOUVJDJØO EF RVF EFCF FYJTUJS
BMHVOB mOBMJEBE NÈT FMFWBEB RVF MB
QFSNBOFODJB FO CVFOB TBMVE GÓTJDB VO
NVOEP JOWJTJCMF EF WBMPSFT FTQJSJUVBMFT
RVF FMFWFO BM IPNCSF QPS FODJNB EF
MBT PUSBT FTQFDJFT RVF MP UPSOF NÈT GF
MJ[ZPNÈTJOGFMJ[NÈTFYJHFOUFZNÈT
TP×BEPSVOBUSBTDFOEFODJBRVFBMHVOPT
1FSTQFDUJWBTEFMB#JPÏUJDBFO*CFSPBNÏSJDB
SFDPOPDFOFOMBSFMJHJPTJEBEOPSFEVDJ
EB B FNPUJWJEBE EF VO TVF×P VUØQJDP
Z RVF BMHVOPT FODVFOUSBO DPOWFOJFOUF
JOWFSUJS FO BMHVOB SFMJHJØO DPOTUJUVJEB
&MBSHVNFOUPEFMTFOUJEPEFMBWJEBZEF
QPSRVÏMBCJPÏUJDBEFCFSÓBTFSFYUSB×BB
UBM QFSTQFDUJWB FMMB RVF TBCF RVF UPEP
TFSIVNBOPWVFMWFBMBUJFSSBEFEPOEF
QSPWJFOF7VFMWFQPSFOUFSPPOPÏTUF
FTFMQSPCMFNBPNFKPSFMNJTUFSJPRVF
MBSB[ØOPMBDJFODJBOPQVFEFSFTPMWFSZ
RVFDPOmBNPTBOVFTUSBJOUVJDJØONÓT
UJDBPBOUJNÓTUJDBBUSBWÏTEFMBGFPEF
MBOPDSFFODJBOPQPDPTQSFmSJFOEPMB
QSVEFODJB Z EFDMBSBSTF DPNP EF GBDUP
MB NBZPSÓB NVOEJBM EF MPT DJFOUÓmDPT
BHOØTUJDPT
-BEJmDVMUBEQBSBBEIFSJSBVOBGFSFMJ
HJPTBSFTJEFFORVFFMMPTJFNQSFJNQMJDB
FYJHFODJBTÏUJDBTZSJUVBMFTRVFTPCSFQB
TBO MP RVF EFNBOEB VOB TJNQMF QFSP
OFDFTBSJB Z CÈTJDB ÏUJDB TPDJBM QSPGBOB
ÏUJDBEFDPOWJWFODJBZBSNPOÓBFOVOB
DPNVOJEBE 5BM JOUVJDJØO FT DBQB[ EF
BZVEBSQPEFSPTBNFOUFBDPOGFSJSTFOUJ
EPBMBWJEBBVORVFMFKPTEFFYQMJDBSZ
KVTUJmDBSUPEPMPRVFOPTSPEFB&TUBJO
UVJDJØORVFQVFEFWFOJSTFSSFDIB[BEBZ
OPWPMWFSDPOGBDJMJEBEQBSFDFTFSDPNP
FM WJFOUP OP TBCFNPT EF EØOEF WJFOF
OJBEØOEFWB&TMBQSPQJBZNJTNÓTJNB
QSFHVOUBQPSFMTFOUJEPEFMBWJEBZUBM
WF[EFMNVOEP5PEPQBSFDFEFQFOEFS
EFTEFFMJOJDJPEFOVFTUSBQFSDFQDJØOF
JOUFSQSFUBDJØOEFMBCFMMF[BZEFMBWJEB
PEFMTVGSJNJFOUPEFMBFOGFSNFEBEEFM
DBSÈDUFSGBUBMEFMBNVFSUF/BEJFOFHBSÈ
RVFUBMFTJOUFSSPHBOUFTFTUÈOJNQMÓDJUPT
FOMBCJPÏUJDBFOMBTPQFSBDJPOFTZDPO
PERSPETIVADELABIOETICAINDD
WJWFODJBTEFMBTBMVEZEFMBFOGFSNFEBE
QFSPFOFMUFSSFOPQSPQJPEFMBCJPÏUJDB
DPOWJFOF BMFKBS TV PCDFDBDJØO QBSB OP
DPOGVOEJSFMUSBCBKPPFMDVFTUJPOBNJFO
UP JONFEJBUP QBSB OP JOUSPEVDJS EJ
WFSHFODJBTRVFQFSKVEJDBSÓBOFMTFSWJDJP
NÈTVSHFOUF
%VSBOUFMB&EBE.FEJBMBUFPMPHÓBGVF
DPOTJEFSBEB MB SFJOB EF MBT EJTDJQMJOBT
MBNÈTBOUJHVBKVOUPDPOMBNFEJDJOB
FO MB GPSNBDJØO EF MBT QSJNFSBT VOJ
WFSTJEBEFT 1PS VOB QBSUF KV[HBOEP FM
EVBMJTNPNJTUFSJPTPEFMTFSZEFMBOBEB
FOFMDPOUFYUPEFMBNFUBGÓTJDBQPSPUSB
PQJOBOEP TPCSF FM EVBMJTNP OP NFOPT
NJTUFSJPTPEFMBWJEBZMBNVFSUF&OUSF
MPTEPTQPMPTTFFYUJFOEFFM5JFNQPFM
NJTUFSJPTP UJFNQP EFM TFS Z EF MB WJEB
{/PQPESÓBNPTJNBHJOBSRVFMBCJPÏUJ
DB GVFTF QBSB MB DVMUVSB NPEFSOB FTUF
DFOUSP EF MBT EJTDJQMJOBT RVF JSSBEJBSBO
EFTEFFMMBDPNPEFVOBFTUSFMMBQSJNPS
EJBMEFMBHBMBYJBEFMTFSZEFMTBCFS "M
UFTUJNPOJBSMPTQSPHSFTPTEFMBTJSSBEJB
DJPOFT EF MB CJPÏUJDB Z TVT SBNJmDBDJP
OFT oFTQFDJBMNFOUF EF MB FDPMPHÓB RVF
UBOUPQSFPDVQBBOVFTUSBDJWJMJ[BDJØOZ
DPOEJDJPOB MB TBMVE Z TVQFSWJWFODJB EF
MB IVNBOJEBEo JNBHJOFNPT FM FGFDUP
EFFTUFMVHBSEFTUBDBEPEFMBCJPÏUJDBBM
MBEPEFMBGÓTJDBEFMBTQBSUÓDVMBTFMFNFO
UBMFTFMMBNJTNBSFMBDJPOBEBDPOMBDPT
NPMPHÓB FWPMVUJWB FT EFDJS FM NJTUFSJP
EFM$PTNPTFOTVUPUBMJEBEZFWPMVDJØO
-BCJPÏUJDBFYQSFTBEFNBOFSBQBSUJDV
MBSNFOUF PCWJB MB USBOTJUPSJFEBE Z GSB
HJMJEBEEFOVFTUSBTDPOEJDJPOFTUFNQP
SBMFTEFWJEBFODPOTUBOUFMVDIBDPOUSB
MBTGVFS[BTEFEFTUSVDDJØOZNVFSUFRVF
6OBNJSBEBQSPTQFDUJWB)VCFSU-FQBSHOFVS
OPBDPTUVNCSBOTPTFHBSTF5PEPMPRVF
TF SFWFMB QSPHSFTJWBNFOUF EFTDVCSF VO
QPDPNÈTDVÈOUPOPTBCFNPTQBSBFO
USFUFOFSOPTØMPOVFTUSBDVSJPTJEBETJOP
UBNCJÏO OVFTUSPT FTGVFS[PT EF JOWFTUJ
HBDJØOZDJFODJBZRVJ[ÈTOVFTUSBBTQJ
SBDJØOSFMJHJPTBEFDSFFSFOBMHÞOiBMMÈw
RVF FTUBSÈ TJFNQSF PDVMUP DPNP WJTJØO
EJSFDUBBMPTWJBKBOUFTEFFTUFUJFNQPZ
QMBOFUB
{/PTFSÓBUPOUFSÓBDSFFSRVFMBCJPÏUJDB
RVF VOF UBM DPNP VOB JOWFTUJHBDJØO
GBSNBDPMØHJDB QFSP TJO TV TFTHP RVÓ
NJDP
VOBQFSTQFDUJWBCJPMØHJDBGVOEB
NFOUBM EF DPOPDJNJFOUP Z VOB BDDJØO
EFTBMWBWJEBTWJEBTTBOBTFOMPQPTJCMF
QBSBEFSSPUBSBMBNVFSUFPBMBEFDSFQJ
UVEFOFMGPOEPSFBMJ[BFMJEFBMEF)FOSJ
#FSHTPO RVF DPOTJTUF FO MPHSBS RVF FM
IPNCSF EF BDDJØO QJFOTF Z FM IPNCSF
EF QFOTBNJFOUP BDUÞF "M DPODJMJBS FM
QFOTBNJFOUP SBDJPOBM Z DSÓUJDP DPO MB
BDDJØO {OP TFSÈ RVF UBOUP FO MB EJT
DVTJØOBCTUSBDUBTPCSFMBWJEBDPNPFO
EFDJTJPOFT DPODSFUBT FO MPT DPNJUÏT FM
WFSEBEFSPCJPFUJDJTUBQJFOTBFOFMOJWFM
EFIVNBOJEBEBTQJSBDJØOBMBVOJWFSTB
MJEBE
QFSPBDUÞBQBSBQSFTFSWBSMBWJEB
PMBTBMVEEFEFUFSNJOBEBT
QFSTPOBT
IVNBOBT
3FGFSFODJBT
%F-BWPS"
"TBÞEFOBQPMÓUJDBFBQPMÓUJDBOBTBÞEF3BEJTKBOFJSPQQ
(SB[JBOP9
1PCSF[BFFDPMPHJB0&TUBEPEF4ÍP1BVMPEFKBOFJSP
)VMPU//PVWFM0CTFSWBUFVS
-FQBSHOFVS)
1SJODÓQJPEBBVUPOPNJB&O6SCBO$"0SH
#JPÏUJDBDMÓOJDB
3JPEF+BOFJSP3FWJOUFSQQ
/PWBFT8
"TBNFBÎBTRVFWÐNEPNVOEPJOWJTÓWFM0&TUBEPEF4ÍP1BVMP
EFKBOFJSP
3VTIEJF4
-F/PVWFM0CTFSWBUFVSEFKBOFJSP
PERSPETIVADELABIOETICAINDD
PERSPETIVADELABIOETICAINDD
"MHVOPTSFUPTQBSBFMGVUVSPEFMBCJPÏUJDBFO
*CFSPBNÏSJDB
-FP1FTTJOJZ$ISJTUJBOEF1BVMEF#BSDIJGPOUBJOF
$
VBOEP FYBNJOBNPT SFUSPTQFDUJWB
NFOUF FM EFTBSSPMMP EF MB CJPÏUJDB
FO"NÏSJDB-BUJOBRVFTFEJGFSFODJBFO
BMHVOPTBTQFDUPTEFMBQFSTQFDUJWBEFMB
1FOÓOTVMB *CÏSJDB &TQB×B Z 1PSUVHBM
QPEFNPTQFSDJCJSVOBDPOUJOVJEBEOP
TJOPCTUÈDVMPTRVFBCBSDBUSFTGBTFTJN
QPSUBOUFTMPTB×PTFOMPTRVFMBCJP
ÏUJDB OPSUFBNFSJDBOB GVF USBTQMBOUBEB
ZBDFQUBEBMPTB×PTEFBTJNJMBDJØO
Z FWPMVDJØO DPO VOB QFSTPOBMJEBE MBUJ
OPBNFSJDBOB Z B QBSUJS EF MPT EF
SFDPOTUSVDDJØO MB QSPQPTJDJØO EF VO
QFOTBNJFOUPZEFVOBQSÈDUJDBPSJHJOB
MFTRVFTJOSFDIB[BSMBTDPOUSJCVDJPOFT
EFPUSBTQBSUFTEFMNVOEPMBTJOUFSQSFUB
BTVNBOFSBZDPOUSJCVZFBDBNCJBSMBT
FO VO FOSJRVFDFEPS QSPDFTP EJBMØHJDP
1PSFTPFTGVOEBNFOUBMVOBDPNQSFO
TJØOQSPGVOEBEFMBTCBTFTFQJTUFNPMØHJ
DBTEFMBQFSTQFDUJWBBTÓDSFBEB(BSSBGB
,PUUPXZ4BBEB
QBSBEFUFSNJOBS
DVÈMFTTPOMPTWFSEBEFSPTSFUPTRVFEF
CFNPTFOGSFOUBS&OUSFÏTUPTMBFDPMPHÓB
ZFMBNCJFOUFMBJOWFTUJHBDJØOFOTFSFT
IVNBOPTQPMÓUJDBTQÞCMJDBTMFHJTMBDJØO
Z EFSFDIP Z FO VO DPOUFYUP TJFNQSF
NÈTQMVSBMJTUBFMEJÈMPHPNVOEPTFDV
MBSNVOEPSFMJHJPTP
PERSPETIVADELABIOETICAINDD
&O TVT QSJODJQJPT FO MPT &&66 MB
CJPÏUJDBFOGSFOUØEJMFNBTÏUJDPTDSFBEPT
QPS MPT FYUSBPSEJOBSJPT QSPHSFTPT UFD
OPDJFOUÓmDPT FO MBT DJFODJBT EF MB WJEB
ZEFMBTBMVE-BJOWFTUJHBDJØOFOTFSFT
IVNBOPT FM VTP IVNBOP EF MB UFDOP
MPHÓBMBTDVFTUJPOFTEFMBNVFSUFZEFM
NPSJSGVFSPOBMHVOBTÈSFBTTFOTJCMFTFO
MPT B×PT -BT DVFTUJPOFT PSJHJOBMFT
TFBNQMJBSPOBQSPCMFNBTEFWBMPSFTFO
EJWFSTBTÈSFBTUBMFTDPNPNFEJDJOBFO
GFSNFSÓB TBMVE QÞCMJDB TBMVE NFOUBM
FOUSFPUSBT.VDIBTDVFTUJPOFTTPDJBMFT
GVFSPOJOUSPEVDJEBTFOFMBNQMJPUFNB
EFMBCJPÏUJDBDPNPMPTSFDVSTPTQÞCMJ
DPTMBTBMVEEFMBTNVKFSFTMBTDVFTUJP
OFTEFMBTQPCMBDJPOFTZMBFDPMPHÓBQPS
TØMPNFODJPOBSBMHVOBT
4F EJDF RVF MB UFDOPMPHÓB NÏEJDB JN
QVMTØFMEFTBSSPMMPEFMBCJPÏUJDBDMÓOJDB
ZFTPTVDFEJØUBOUPFO"NÏSJDB-BUJOB
DPNPFO&TUBEPT6OJEPT"MQSJODJQJP
MBTQSFHVOUBTNÈTGSFDVFOUFTTFSFGFSÓBO
B MB JOWFTUJHBDJØO FO TFSFT IVNBOPT Z
OVFWBTUFDOPMPHÓBTFMVTPEFEJTQPTJUJ
WPTNÏEJDPTMBBDFQUBDJØOPOPEFMDPO
TFOUJNJFOUPJOGPSNBEP
1FSTQFDUJWBTEFMB#JPÏUJDBFO*CFSPBNÏSJDB
&O BMHVOPT QBÓTFT MBUJOPBNFSJDBOPT MB
TJNQMF FYJTUFODJB EF DFOUSPT BWBO[BEPT
EF BTJTUFODJB NÏEJDB RVF PGSFDFO BMUB
UFDOPMPHÓB PSJHJOB DVFTUJPOFT BDFSDB EF
MB EJTDSJNJOBDJØO MB JOKVTUJDJB Z MB FY
DMVTJØOFOFMDVJEBEPNÏEJDP-BTDVFT
UJPOFT NÈT EJGÓDJMFT EF SFTQPOEFS FO MB
SFHJØO OP TF SFmFSFO B DØNP TF VUJMJ[B
MB UFDOPMPHÓB NÏEJDB TJOP RVJÏO UJFOF
BDDFTPBFTBUFDOPMPHÓB6OGVFSUFQFO
TBNJFOUP TPDJBM JNQSFHOB MB CJPÏUJDB
MBUJOPBNFSJDBOB "SSBJHBEPT DPODFQUPT
DVMUVSBMFT oKVTUJDJB FRVJEBE Z TPMJEBSJ
EBEoEFCFOUFOFSVOMVHBSFOFTUBCJPÏ
UJDBVODPOUSBQVOUPBMBBVUPOPNÓBFO
MPT&TUBEPT6OJEPT
4FHÞO +BNFT %SBOF MPT MBUJOPBNF
SJDBOPT OP TPO UBO JOEJWJEVBMJTUBT Z
DJFSUBNFOUF FTUÈO NFOPT JODMJOBEPT BM
DPOTVNJTNP FO TVT SFMBDJPOFT DPO MPT
NÏEJDPT RVF MPT OPSUFBNFSJDBOPT 4JO
FNCBSHPTFSÓBVOFSSPSQFOTBSRVFFTF
DPOTFOUJNJFOUP JOGPSNBEP Z UPEP MP
RVF FYJHF OP TFB JNQPSUBOUF QBSB OP
TPUSPT &M EFTBGÓP FT BQSFOEFS DPO MPT
&&66 Z MPT FVSPQFPT TJO JOUFOUBS
JNJUBS JOHFOVBNFOUF F JNQPSUBS TVT
QSPHSBNBTBEFDVBEPTQBSBVOBSFBMJEBE
EJWFSTB%SBOF
"MHVOPTQVOUPTEJHOPTEF
SFnFYJØO
B
"NQMJBSMBSFnFYJØOÏUJDBEFM
OJWFMiNJDSPwBMOJWFMiNBDSPw
4FEFCFQSPQPOFSVOBCJPÏUJDBQFOTBEB
EFTEFVOOJWFMiNBDSPwMBTPDJFEBEFO
TV UPUBMJEBE
DPNP BMUFSOBUJWB B PUSB
EFTEF VO OJWFM iNJDSPw TPMVDJØO EF
PERSPETIVADELABIOETICAINDD
DVFTUJPOFT DMÓOJDBT
EF MB USBEJDJØO BO
HMPBNFSJDBOB&TEFDJSVOBCJPÏUJDBSFT
USJOHJEBBVOBiCJPTwEFBMUBUFDOPMPHÓB
ZBVOiFUIPTwJOEJWJEVBMJTUBQSJWBDJEBE
DPOTFOUJNJFOUP JOGPSNBEP
OFDFTJUB
TFS JOUFHSBEB FO "NÏSJDB -BUJOB B VOB
iCJPTwIVNBOJTUBZVOiFUIPTwDPNVOJ
UBSJPTPMJEBSJEBEFRVJEBEFMPUSP
&MHSBOEFTBGÓPFTEFTBSSPMMBSVOBCJPÏUJ
DBMBUJOPBNFSJDBOBRVFSFQBSFMBTFYBHF
SBDJPOFTEFPUSBTQFSTQFDUJWBTZFOBMUF[
DBMBDVMUVSBMBUJOBFOTVTBTQFDUPTNÈT
QFDVMJBSFT VOB WJTJØO WFSEBEFSBNFOUF
BMUFSOBUJWBQBSBVOEJÈMPHPNVMUJDVMUV
SBM/PQPEFNPTPMWJEBSRVFFTUBCJPÏ
UJDBTVGSFFMJNQBDUPEFMBQPCSF[BZEF
MBFYDMVTJØOTPDJBM&MBCPSBSMBTPMBNFOUF
FOFMOJWFMiNJDSPwoFOFTUVEJPTEFDBTP
PSJFOUBEPT BM BOBMJTJT EFPOUPMØHJDP TJO
DPOTJEFSBS FTUB SFBMJEBEo OP IBDF KVT
UJDJB B MPT EFTFPT Z OFDFTJEBEFT EF VOB
WJEBEJHOJmDBEB/PTFEJTDVUFFMWBMPS
JOOFHBCMF RVF NFSFDFO UPEBT MBT WJEBT
IVNBOBT UPEBT EFCFO TFS NBOUFOJEBT
DVJEBEBT Z QSPUFHJEBT -P RVF OP QP
EFNPTIBDFSTJOFNCBSHPFTPMWJEBSMB
WJTJØOHMPCBMEFMBSFBMJEBEMBUJOPBNFSJ
DBOBVOBSFBMJEBEEFFYDMVTJØOZMJNJ
UBDJPOFT
&OFMNPNFOUPFORVFQBSBMBTBDUVB
MFT DVMUVSBT MB NFEJDJOB NPEFSOB TF
DPOWJFSUFFOMPRVFGVFMBSFMJHJØOFOMB
&EBE.FEJBMBTDVFTUJPOFTRVFBGFDUBO
BMBCJPÏUJDBTFIBDFONÈTDFOUSBMFTZHF
OFSBO VO JOUFSÏT QÞCMJDP DBEB WF[ NB
ZPS &O FM VNCSBM EF MBT DPOUSPWFSTJBT
CJPÏUJDBT MPT TJHOJmDBEPT CÈTJDPT FTUÈO
DBNCJBOEPFOUPEPFMQMBOFUBFMTJHOJ
"MHVOPTSFUPTQBSBFMGVUVSPEFMBCJPÏUJDBFO*CFSPBNÏSJDB-FP1FTTJOJZ$ISJTUJBOEF1BVMEF#BSDIJGPOUBJOF
mDBEPEFMBWJEBZMBNVFSUFMBGBNJMJB
MBFOGFSNFEBERVJÏOFTVOQBESFPVOB
NBESFQPSFKFNQMP-BNBZPSDPNVOJ
DBDJØO Z FM EJÈMPHP FOUSF QFSTPOBT DPO
EJWFSTPT QVOUPT EF WJTUB TPO JONFOTB
NFOUFWFOUBKPTPTQPSRVFDPOUSJCVZFOB
VOBDPNQSFOTJØONÈTQSPGVOEBEFDBEB
DVMUVSBZQSPQPOFONFKPSFTTPMVDJPOFT
B QSPCMFNBT DSÓUJDPT TJNJMBSFT -B HFO
UFEFEJWFSTBTSFHJPOFTZDVMUVSBTQVFEF
USBCBKBSQBSBJOUFHSBSEJGFSFODJBTTPDJP
MØHJDBT IJTUØSJDBT Z mMPTØmDBT Z UBMWF[
VO EÓB HFOFSBS VO TJTUFNB EF FTUÈOEB
SFT CJPÏUJDPT SFTQFUVPTPT Z DPIFSFOUFT
DPNQBSUJEPTJHVBMNFOUFQPSUPEPT
4FHÞO + " .BJOFUUJ "NÏSJDB
-BUJOBQVFEFPGSFDFSVOBWJTJØOCJPÏUJDB
EJTUJOUBEFMBEFPUSBTSFHJPOFTEFMHMPCP
EFCJEPBTVTUSBEJDJPOFTIVNBOJTUBTZB
DBVTBEFTVTDPOEJDJPOFTTPDJBMFTDPNP
HSVQP EF QBÓTFT QFSJGÏSJDPT 1BSB FTUF
CJPFUJDJTUBBSHFOUJOPMBEJTDJQMJOBFVSP
QFB EF MB mMPTPGÓB NÏEJDB DPO TVT USFT
SBNBTQSJODJQBMFTBOUSPQPMPHÓBFQJTUF
NPMPHÓBZBYJPMPHÓBNÏEJDBT
QPESÓBTFS
WJSQBSBUSBOTGPSNBSMBNFEJDJOBDJFOUÓ
mDBZBDBEÏNJDBFOVOOVFWPQBSBEJHNB
CJPNÏEJDPIVNBOJTUB5BMBDFSDBNJFO
UPFWJUBSÓBMBTBDVTBDJPOFTEJSJHJEBTDPO
GSFDVFODJBBMBNFEJDJOBTFHÞOMBTDVBMFT
QBSFDFPMWJEBSPOPTFDFOUSBFOMBWFS
EBEFSB EFTIVNBOJ[BDJØO EFM TJTUFNB
1PSFKFNQMPFMEJTDVSTPCJPÏUJDPTPCSF
MBBVUPOPNÓBQVFEFFONBTDBSBSMBEFT
QFSTPOBMJ[BDJØOEFMBBTJTUFODJBNÏEJDBZ
TVTSJFTHPTEFJBUSPHFOJBFYQMPUBDJØOEFM
DVFSQPZFOBKFOBDJØOEFMBTBMVE$PNP
SFTQVFTUBBMEFTBSSPMMPEFMBCJPNFEJDJOB
FOVOBFSBUFDOPMØHJDBMBCJPÏUJDBEFCF
PERSPETIVADELABIOETICAINDD
TFSNFOPTPQUJNJTUBDPOSFMBDJØOBMQSP
HSFTPZEFTFNQF×BSVOQBQFMDSÓUJDPFO
FTUFDPOUFYUP
-BSFBMJEBEMBUJOPBNFSJDBOBEFMBCJPÏ
UJDBFOVOBÏQPDBEFDØMFSB)*7ZTB
SBNQJØOFYJHFVOQVOUPEFWJTUBTPDJBM
RVF EFmFOEB FM CJFOFTUBS MB KVTUJDJB Z
MBFRVJEBEBOUFTRVFMPTEFSFDIPTJOEJ
WJEVBMFT Z MBT WJSUVEFT QFSTPOBMFT 6OB
iNBDSPÏUJDBwFOTBMVEQÞCMJDBTFQVFEF
QSPQPOFSDPNPBMUFSOBUJWBBMBUSBEJDJØO
BOHMPBNFSJDBOBEFiNJDSPÏUJDBwPÏUJDB
DMÓOJDB/VFTUSBOFDFTJEBENÈTJNQFSJP
TBFOQBÓTFTQPCSFTFTMBFRVJEBEFOMB
BTJHOBDJØOEFSFDVSTPTZMBEJTUSJCVDJØO
EFMPTTFSWJDJPTNÏEJDPT
%JFHP (SBDJB BDMBSB i-PT MBUJOPBNFSJ
DBOPT TF TJFOUFO QSPGVOEBNFOUF JODØ
NPEPT DPO FM EJTDVSTP EF MPT EFSFDIPT
Z MPT QSJODJQJPT 5JFOFO MB DPTUVNCSF
EFKV[HBSMBTDPTBTZMBTBDDJPOFTDPNP
ACVFOBT P ANBMBT FO WF[ EF ADJFSUBT P
AFSSBEBT1SFmFSFOMBCFOFWPMFODJBBMB
KVTUJDJBMBBNJTUBEBMSFTQFUPNVUVPMB
FYDFMFODJBBMPTEFSFDIPTy
#VTDBOB
MB WJSUVE Z MB FYDFMFODJB /P DSFP RVF
SFDIBDFO P EFTQSFDJFO MPT QSJODJQJPT
y
$PNP MBT DVMUVSBT MBUJOBT GVFSPO
PSJFOUBEBTUSBEJDJPOBMNFOUFQPSMBÏUJDB
EFMBTWJSUVEFTFMBDFSDBNJFOUPQSJODJ
QJBMJTUBQVFEFTFSNVZQSPWFDIPTPQBSB
FWJUBSBMHVOPTEFGFDUPTUSBEJDJPOBMFTEF
OVFTUSBWJEBNPSBMUBMFTDPNPFMQBUFS
OBMJTNP MB DBSFODJB EF SFTQFUP QPS MBT
MFZFT Z MB UPMFSBODJB &O MB CÞTRVFEB
EF MB WJSUVE Z MB FYDFMFODJB MPT QBÓTFT
MBUJOPBNFSJDBOPT IBO TJEP USBEJDJPOBM
NFOUFJOUPMFSBOUFT-BUPMFSBODJBOPTF
1FSTQFDUJWBTEFMB#JPÏUJDBFO*CFSPBNÏSJDB
IBJODMVJEPDPNPWJSUVEFOFMDBUÈMPHP
BOUJHVPEFMBTWJSUVEFTMBUJOBT-BWJSUVE
WFSEBEFSB FSB MB JOUPMFSBODJB Z MB UPMF
SBODJBFSBDPOTJEFSBEBVOWJDJP
-PT
BOHMPTBKPOFTIBOEFTDVCJFSUPMBUPMFSBO
DJBDPNPWJSUVEFOFMTJHMP97**2VJ[ÈT
FTUBFTMBEJGFSFODJBNÈTTJHOJmDBUJWBSFT
QFUPEFPUSBTDVMUVSBT-BDVFTUJØONP
SBMNÈTJNQPSUBOUFOPFTMBMFOHVBRVF
VUJMJ[BNPT FO MB FYQSFTJØO EF OVFTUSBT
TFOTBDJPOFTNPSBMFTTJOPFMSFTQFUPQPS
MB EJWFSTJEBE NPSBM MB PQDJØO FOUSF FM
QMVSBMJTNPZFMGBOBUJTNP&MGBOBUJTNP
BmSNB RVF MPT WBMPSFT TPO UPUBMFT BC
TPMVUPTZPCKFUJWPTZTFEFCFOJNQPOFS
QPSMBGVFS[BBPUSPTNJFOUSBTMBUPMFSBO
DJBEFmFOEFMBBVUPOPNÓBZMBMJCFSUBE
NPSBM QBSB UPEPT MPT TFSFT IVNBOPT Z
MB CÞTRVFEB EF VO BDVFSEP NPSBM QPS
DPOTFOTPw
%BOJFM 8JLMFS BOUJHVP QSFTJEFOUF EF
MB "TPDJBDJØO *OUFSOBDJPOBM EF #JPÏ
UJDB *"#
FO FM EJTDVSTP EF DJFSSF EFM
***$POHSFTP.VOEJBMEF#JPÏUJDB4BO
'SBODJTDP&&66
RVFUSBUØFM
UFNB i#JPÏUJDB Z SFTQPOTBCJMJEBE TP
DJBMwIBEJDIPRVFDVBOEPNJSBNPTFM
OBDJNJFOUPZFMEFTBSSPMMPEFMBCJPÏUJDB
EFUFDUBNPTDMBSBNFOUFDVBUSPGBTFT
5FOFNPTMPTDØEJHPTEFDPO
EVDUBEFMPTQSPGFTJPOBMFT-B
CJPÏUJDB TF FOUJFOEF QSÈDUJDB
NFOUFDPNPÏUJDBNÏEJDB
-B SFMBDJØO NÏEJDPQBDJFOUF
FOUSBFOFTDFOB$PNCBUJNPT
FMQBUFSOBMJTNPZMPTEFSFDIPT
EF MPT QBDJFOUFT DPNJFO[BO B
TFS EJTDVUJEPT BVUPOPNÓB MJ
CFSUBEWFSEBEFUD
PERSPETIVADELABIOETICAINDD
4F QSFHVOUB TPCSF MPT TJTUF
NBT EF TBMVE JODMVZFOEP TV
FTUSVDUVSB Z PSHBOJ[BDJØO m
OBODJBNJFOUP Z HFSFODJB -PT
CJPFUJDJTUBT EFCFO FTUVEJBS MB
FDPOPNÓB Z MB QPMÓUJDB EF MB
TBMVE$BMMBIBO
$PNFO[BNPTFTUBGBTFBMmOBM
EF MPT B×PT -B CJPÏUJDB
TF PDVQB QSJPSJUBSJBNFOUF EF
MB TBMVE EF MBT QPCMBDJPOFT Z
TF JODPSQPSBO BM FTDFOBSJP MBT
DJFODJBT TPDJBMFT MBT IVNBOJ
EBEFTMBTBMVEQÞCMJDBMPTEF
SFDIPTIVNBOPTMBFRVJEBEZ
MBBTJHOBDJØOEFSFDVSTPTFO
USFPUSBTDVFTUJPOFTDBOEFOUFT
&TFQSPHSBNBFTQFSUJOFOUFFO
FMNPNFOUPÏUJDPEF"NÏSJDB
-BUJOB
C
&MEFTBGÓPEFEFTBSSPMMBSVO
IPSJ[POUFEFTFOUJEPQBSBMB
CJPÏUJDB
/VFTUSBSFnFYJØOTFSÓBJODPNQMFUBTJOP
NFODJPOÈSBNPT MB OFDFTJEBE EF EFTB
SSPMMBSVOIPSJ[POUFNÈTBNQMJPPVOB
NÓTUJDB QBSB MB CJPÏUJDB 1VFEF QBSFDFS
FYUSB×PQBSBVOBMÓOFBEFQFOTBNJFOUP
NBSDBEBQPSFMQSBHNBUJTNPZFMDVMUP
EFMBFmDBDJBTVHFSJSRVFMBCJPÏUJDBOF
DFTJUBNÓTUJDB-BCJPÏUJDBQSFDJTBVOIP
SJ[POUFEFTFOUJEPoPEFTJHOJmDBEPoZ
OPJNQPSUBTJFTFTUSFDIPPBNQMJPQBSB
EFTBSSPMMBSTVTSFnFYJPOFTZQSPQVFTUBT
4JNVMUÈOFBNFOUF OP QPEFNPT IBDFS
CJPÏUJDBTJOPQUBSQPSVONVOEPEFSF
MBDJPOFTIVNBOBT&TPFTFOTÓNJTNP
JOEJDBDJØOEFMBOFDFTJEBEEFVODJFSUP
"MHVOPTSFUPTQBSBFMGVUVSPEFMBCJPÏUJDBFO*CFSPBNÏSJDB-FP1FTTJOJZ$ISJTUJBOEF1BVMEF#BSDIJGPOUBJOF
UJQPEFNÓTUJDBPEFVOTJTUFNBEFTJHOJ
mDBEPT GVOEBNFOUBMFT RVF BDFQUBNPT
#BTBEPT FO ÏTUF DVMUJWBSFNPT OVFTUSP
JEFBMJTNPIBSFNPTOVFTUSBTPQDJPOFTZ
PSHBOJ[BSFNPTOVFTUSBTQSÈDUJDBT
/P FT GÈDJM EFmOJS FO QPDBT QBMBCSBT
FTUF IPSJ[POUF NÈT BNQMJP EF TFOUJEP
QBSBMBCJPÏUJDB*ODMVZFOFDFTBSJBNFOUF
MB DPOWJDDJØO FO MB USBTDFOEFODJB EF MB
WJEBRVFSFDIB[BMBOPDJØOEFFOGFSNF
EBEEFTVGSJNJFOUPZEFNVFSUFDPNP
BCTPMVUPTRVFOPQVFEFOTFSUPMFSBEPT
*ODMVZF MB PQJOJØO EF MPT PUSPT DPNP
DPNQB×FSPTDBQBDFTEFWJWJSFOTPMJEB
SJEBE Z EF FOUFOEFS Z BDFQUBS MB WJEB
DPNP VOB EÈEJWB &TUF IPSJ[POUF FT
TJO EVEB VO UFTUJNPOJP FO FM TFOUJEP
EF OP QFSNJUJS RVF QSFWBMF[DBO JOUFSF
TFT JOEJWJEVBMFT FHPÓTUBT OJ TJMFODJBS MB
WP[ EF MPT WVMOFSBCMFT P MPT FYDMVJEPT
OJFONBTDBSBSTVTOFDFTJEBEFT&TUFIP
SJ[POUFQSPDMBNBBOUFUPEPTMPTEFTDV
CSJNJFOUPT EF MBT DJFODJBT EF MB WJEB Z
EFM DVJEBEP NÏEJDP RVF FM JNQFSBUJWP
UFDOPDJFOUÓmDP iZP QVFEP IBDFSw UFO
ESÓB RVF EFQFOEFS OFDFTBSJBNFOUF EF
iQPSMPUBOUP{EFCPIBDFSMP w.ÈTRVF
FTUPNPUJWBBMBHFOUFZBHSVQPTEFMBT
NÈT EJWFSTBT TJUVBDJPOFT TPDJBMFT QPMÓ
UJDBT FDPOØNJDBT Z DVMUVSBMFT B VOJSTF
FOMBUBSFBEFHBSBOUJ[BSVOBWJEBEJHOB
QBSBUPEPTDPOTUSVJSVOQBSBEJHNBFDP
OØNJDPUÏDOJDPZDJFOUÓmDPSFHJEPQPS
MBTEFNBOEBTEFMBTPMJEBSJEBEIVNBOB
"OKPT
D
.ÈTBMMÈEFMQSJODJQJBMJTNP
&MNPEFMPQSJODJQJBMJTUBEFBOÈMJTJTUFØ
SJDPJOJDJBEPDPOFM*OGPSNF#FMNPOUZ
PERSPETIVADELABIOETICAINDD
QVFTUP FO FKFDVDJØO QPS #FBVDIBNQ Z
$IJMESFTTFTTØMPVOPFOUSFPUSPTJEJP
NBTÏUJDPT-BFYQFSJFODJBÏUJDBTFQVFEF
FYQSFTBS FO EJWFSTPT JEJPNBT QBSBEJH
NBT P NPEFMPT UFØSJDPT 0CWJBNFOUF
DPOWJWJS DPO FTUF QMVSBMJTNP FYJHF VO
EJÈMPHPSFTQFUVPTPEFMBTEJGFSFODJBTFO
FMRVFMBUPMFSBODJBFTFTFODJBM&TUPTNP
EFMPTPJEJPNBTTFDPSSFMBDJPOBOJOUSÓO
TFDBNFOUF QFSP DBEB VOP FT UBNCJÏO
JOUSÓOTFDBNFOUFJODPNQMFUPZMJNJUBEP
6ONPEFMPQVFEFPDVQBSTFCJFOEFVO
BTQFDUPEFmOJEPEFMBWJEBNPSBMQFSP
OPTJNVMUÈOFBNFOUFEFUPEPT/PQPEF
NPTDPOTJEFSBSMPTFYDMVTJWPTTJOPDPN
QMFNFOUBSJPT&TUPOPEFCFTPSQSFOEFS
QPSRVFMBBNQMJUVEZMBBCVOEBODJBEF
MB FYQFSJFODJB IVNBOB FTUÈO TJFNQSF
NÈTBMMÈEFMBMDBODFEFDVBMRVJFSTJTUFNB
mMPTØmDP P UFPMØHJDP %JDIB NPEFTUJB
RVFWJFOFEFMBTBCJEVSÓBOPTIBSÈMJCSFT
EFMWJSVTEFMPTiJTNPTiEFMBTJEFPMP
HÓBTRVFUPNBOVOBQBSUFEFMBSFBMJEBE
QPSUPEBMBSFBMJEBE
E
-BKVTUJDJBZMBFRVJEBEFOFM
ÈSFBEFMDVJEBEPNÏEJDP
-PTQSPCMFNBTCJPÏUJDPTEFJNQPSUBODJB
FYUSFNBFO"NÏSJDB-BUJOBZFM$BSJCF
TFSFMBDJPOBODPOMBKVTUJDJBMBFRVJEBE
ZMBBTJHOBDJØOEFSFDVSTPTFOFMÈSFBEFM
DVJEBEPNÏEJDP
-BCJPÏUJDBEFMNVOEPEFTBSSPMMBEP&&
66Z&VSPQB
IJ[PDBTPPNJTPEFDVFT
UJPOFTCÈTJDBTRVFBnJHFOBNJMMPOFTEF
FYDMVJEPTFOFTUFDPOUJOFOUFZTFFOGPDØ
FOBMHVOBTRVFQBSBOPTPUSPTTPONBS
HJOBMFT P JOFYJTUFOUFT 1PS FKFNQMP FO
FMNVOEPEFTBSSPMMBEPTFIBCMBNVDIP
1FSTQFDUJWBTEFMB#JPÏUJDBFO*CFSPBNÏSJDB
EFNPSJSDPOEJHOJEBEBRVÓOPTJNQVM
TBOBQSPDMBNBSRVFMBEJHOJEBEIVNB
OBEFCFQSJNFSPHBSBOUJ[BSMBWJEBZOP
TJNQMFNFOUFVOBTVQFSWJWFODJBRVFEF
HSBEB&OUSFOPTPUSPTMPRVFTVDFEFFT
MBNVFSUFQSFNBUVSBRVFFTJOKVTUBRVF
FOMVUBZEFTUSVZFNJMMBSFTEFWJEBTEFT
EFMBOJ×F[NJFOUSBTRVFFOFMNVOEP
EFTBSSPMMBEPTFNVFSFEFTQVÏTEFWJWJSZ
HP[BS MB WJEB DPO FMFHBODJB JODMVTP FO
MB WFKF[ {6OB TVQFSWJWFODJB EPMPSPTB
HBSBOUJ[BSÓBMBEJHOJEBEBMNPNFOUPEF
NPSJS 3FnFYJPOBOEP QSPTQFDUJWBNFOUF DPO
"MBJTUBJS7$BNQCFMM
oBOUJHVP
QSFTJEFOUFEFMB"TPDJBDJØO*OUFSOBDJP
OBM EF #JPÏUJDB o SFTQFDUP
EF MB CJPÏUJDB EFM GVUVSP VOB DVFTUJØO
DMBWF B FOGSFOUBSFTMB KVTUJDJBFOTBMVE
ZFODVJEBEPTNÏEJDPT-BCJPÏUJDBOP
QVFEF DPOWFSUJSTF FO VOB FTQFDJF EF
iDBQFMMÈO FO FM SFJOBEP EF MB DJFODJBw
QFSEJFOEPTVQBQFMDSÓUJDPGSFOUFBMQSP
HSFTPUFDOPDJFOUÓmDP
F
#JPÏUJDBZSFMJHJØO
6OB DBSBDUFSÓTUJDB EF MBT SFHJPOFT MB
UJOPBNFSJDBOB Z DBSJCF×B FT MB IFSFO
DJB DSJTUJBOP DBUØMJDB IPZ GVFSUFNFOUF
BGFDUBEB QPS TFDUBT GVOEBNFOUBMJTUBT Z
TV BSTFOBM EF NFEJPT FMFDUSØOJDPT &M
QSPDFTP EF TFDVMBSJ[BDJØO IB BMDBO[B
EP B MB CVSHVFTÓB FEVDBEB NBT OP BM
QVFCMP -B NPSBM TPDJBM DPOUJOÞB TJFO
EPCÈTJDBNFOUFSFMJHJPTBZDPOGFTJPOBM
&TB TPDJFEBE OP DPOPDF FM QMVSBMJTNP
DBSBDUFSÓTUJDB GVFSUF EF NVDIPT QBÓTFT
EFTBSSPMMBEPT4JOEVEBBRVÓTFQSFTFO
UBVOEFTBGÓPBMEJÈMPHPFOUSFMBCJPÏUJDB
PERSPETIVADELABIOETICAINDD
ZMBUFPMPHÓBFOUSFFMVOJWFSTPCJPÏUJDP
TFDVMBS oDJWJM QMVSBMJTUB BVUØOPNP Z
SBDJPOBMoZFMSFMJHJPTPQSPGVOEBNFOUF
BSSBJHBEPFOFTUBTUJFSSBT
&ENVOE%1FMMFHSJOP&&66
QMBO
UFBUSFTQSFHVOUBT{DØNPEFDJEJSFOUSF
MBEJWFSTJEBEEFPQJOJPOFTTPCSFRVÏFT
CJPÏUJDBZTVDBNQP {$ØNPSFMBDJPOBS
WBSJPT NPEFMPT CJPÏUJDPT {$VÈM FT FM
MVHBSEFMBSFMJHJØOZEFMBCJPÏUJDBUFP
MØHJDB FO MPT EFCBUFT QÞCMJDPT TPCSF FM
BCPSUPFMDVJEBEPBENJOJTUSBEPMBFV
UBOBTJBFUD )BTUBBIPSBMBCJPÏUJDBSF
MJHJPTBFTUBCBFOMBQFOVNCSBEFMBCJP
ÏUJDBmMPTØmDBɨPNBTNBZ1FMMFHSJOP
QSFEJDFOMBBQBSJDJØOEFWBMPSFT
SFMJHJPTPT FO MB EJTDVTJØO QÞCMJDB FO MB
NFEJEBFORVFOVFTUSBDPODJFODJBEFMB
EJWFSTJEBE DVMUVSBM BVNFOUB /PT BE
WJFSUFOEFMBOFDFTJEBEEFVOBNFUPEP
MPHÓBDBQB[EFPDVQBSTFEFMBDPOUJOVB
QPMBSJ[BDJØORVFUSBFOMBTDPOWJDDJPOFT
BVUÏOUJDBTZQSPQPOFORVFEFCFNPTWJ
WJS Z USBCBKBS KVOUPT DPNP JHVBMFT BVO
DVBOEPMBNBZPSÓBEFMBTWFDFTOVFTUSBT
DPOWJDDJPOFTmMPTØmDBTZSFMJHJPTBTTPCSF
MPWFSEBEFSPZMPGBMTPFTUÏOFODPOnJDUP
PTFBOJSSFDPODJMJBCMFT
6OBPCTFSWBDJØOmOBM
)BZOFDFTJEBEEFDVMUJWBSVOBTBCJEVSÓB
RVF EFTBGÓF QSPGÏUJDBNFOUF FM JNQFSJB
MJTNPÏUJDPEFRVJFOFTVUJMJ[BOMBGVFS
[BQBSBJNQPOFSTVQSPQJBNPSBMDPNP
TJ GVFSB MB ÞOJDB WFSEBE Z UBNCJÏO FM
GVOEBNFOUBMJTNP EF RVJFOFT SFDIB[BO
FOUSBSFOVOEJÈMPHPBCJFSUPZHFOVJOP
DPOPUSPTFOVODPOUFYUPNÈTQMVSBMJTUB
ZTFDVMBS
"MHVOPTSFUPTQBSBFMGVUVSPEFMBCJPÏUJDBFO*CFSPBNÏSJDB-FP1FTTJOJZ$ISJTUJBOEF1BVMEF#BSDIJGPOUBJOF
2VJÏO TBCF TJ MB JOUVJDJØO QJPOFSB EF
73 1PUUFS DVBOEP BDV×Ø MB
CJPÏUJDBDPNPVOQVFOUFIBDJBFMGVUVSP
OFDFTJUFTFSPUSBWF[FTUVEJBEBZUSBCBKB
EB EF PUSBT NBOFSBT FO FM OVFWP NJMF
OJPQBSBTFSUBNCJÏOVOQVFOUFIBDJBFM
EJÈMPHPNVMUJDVMUVSBMZUSBTDVMUVSBMVO
QVFOUFQBSBSFDVQFSBSOVFTUSBUSBEJDJØO
IVNBOJTUBOVFTUSPTFOUJEPEFMBWJEBZ
OVFTUSPSFTQFUPQPSMBUSBTDFOEFODJBEF
MBWJEBFOTVNBHOJUVENÈYJNBDØTNJ
DBZFDPMØHJDB
ZHP[BSEFFMMBDPNPVOB
EÈEJWBZVOBDPORVJTUBDPOEJHOJEBEZ
TPMJEBSJEBE
3FGFSFODJBT
"OKPT.'
#JPFUIJDTJOBMJCFSBUJPOJTULFZ*O%VCPTF&3)BNFM31
0$POOFMM -+ $PPSET
" NBUUFS PG QSJODJQMFT GFSNFOU JO 64 CJPFUIJDT 7BMMFZ
'PSHF1FOOTZMWBOJB5SJOJUZ1SFTT*OUFSOBUJPOBMQQ
"OKPT .' .FEJDBM FUIJDT JO UIF EFWFMPQJOH XPSME B MJCFSBUJPO UIFPMPHZ
QFSTQFDUJWF 5IF +PVSOBM PG .FEJDJOF BOE 1IJMPTPQIZ %FDFNCFS QQ #BSDIJGPOUBJOF$EF1Z1FTTJOJ-
#JPÏUJDBBQBSUJSEF"NÏSJDB-BUJOB&O
-BWJEBWBMF#JPÏUJDBOVFWPTDBNJOPT-JNB$FOUSPEF&TUVEJPTZ1VCMJDBDJPOFT
$&1
QQ
$BNQCFMM"7
"#JPÏUJDBOPTÏDVMP99*4BÞEF)FMJØQPMJT"QSJM.BJQQ
%SBOF+'
#JPFUIJDBM1FSTQFDUJWFTGSPN*CFSP"NFSJDB5IF+PVSOBMPG.FEJDJOF
BOE1IJMPTPQIZ
%FDFNCFSQQ
(BSSBGB7,PUUPX.4BBEB"&ET
#BTFTDPODFJUVBJTEB#JPÏUJDBFOGPRVF
MBUJOPBNFSJDBOP4ÍP1BVMP&EJUPSB(BJB
(SBDJB%)BSE5JNFTIBSEDIPJDFTGPVOEJOHCJPFUIJDTUPEBZ#JPFUIJDT
+VMZ
QQ
.BJOFUUJ+"
)JTUPSZPGNFEJDBMFUIJDT5IF"NFSJDBTE-BUJO"NFSJDB*O
3FJDI 85 &E
&ODZDMPQFEJB PG #JPFUIJDT SFWJTFE FEJUJPO 7PM /FX :PSL
.D.JMMBOQQ
1FTTJOJ-
#JPFUIJDT1PXFSBOE*OKVTUJDFTPNFQFSTPOBMUIPVHIUTGSPNB-BUJO
"NFSJDBO QFSTQFDUJWF *"# /&84 *TTVF 'FCSVBSZ QQ "WBJMBCMF BU
IUUQXXXCJPFUIJDTJOUFSOBUJPOBMPSHOFXTJBCOFXTGFCQEG
1FTTJOJ-#BSDIJGPOUBJOF$EF1&ET
'VOEBNFOUPTEB#JPÏUJDBOE&E
4ÍP1BVMP1BVMVTQQ
1FTTJOJ - #JPFUIJDT B IPSJ[PO PG IPQF GPS B OFX UJNF 0 .VOEP EB 4BÞEF
4FQU0DUQQ
1FTTJOJ-
#VJMEJOHB/FX$VMUVSFPG&UIJDTJO3FTFBSDI*OWPMWJOH)VNBOTJO
#SB[JM/PUJ[JFEJ1PMJUÏJB
QQ
1FTTJOJ - #JPÏUJDB F TFV GVUVSP BMHVOT EFTBGJPT B QBSUJS EF VNB QFSTQFDUJWB
-BUJOPBNFSJDBOB &O /FWFT . -JNB . #JPÏUJDB PV #JPÏUJDBT
PERSPETIVADELABIOETICAINDD
1FSTQFDUJWBTEFMB#JPÏUJDBFO*CFSPBNÏSJDB
OB FWPMVÎÍP EBT TPDJFEBEFT &EJÎÍP -VTPCSBTJMFJSB (SÈGJDB EF $PJNCSB$FOUSP
6OJWFSTJUÈSJP4ÍP$BNJMPQQ
5IPNBTNB %$ BOE 1FMMFHSJOP &% 5IF 'VUVSF PG #JPFUIJDT 2VBSUFSMZ PG
)FBMUIBOE&UIJDTQQ
8JLMFS%
#JPFUIJDTBOETPDJBMSFTQPOTJCJMJUZ#JPFUIJDT
QQ
PERSPETIVADELABIOETICAINDD
"QÏOEJDFT
PERSPETIVADELABIOETICAINDD
PERSPETIVADELABIOETICAINDD
4FMFDDJØOEFQSPHSBNBTGPSNBUJWPTFOCJPÏUJDB
"3(&/5*/"
.BFTUSÓBFO#JPÏUJDB
6OJWFSTJEBE/BDJPOBMEF$ØSEPCB
'BDVMUBEEF$JFODJBT.ÏEJDBT
4FDSFUBSÓBEF(SBEVBEPTFO$JFODJBTEF
MB4BMVE
5FM
JOUBM
THDT!GDNVODFEVBS
1SPHSBNBEF.BFTUSÓBFO#JPÏUJDB
6OJWFSTJEBE/BDJPOBMEF$VZP
4FDSFUBSÓBEF1PTHSBEP'BDVMUBEEF
$JFODJBT.ÏEJDBT5FM
'BY
CJPFUJDB!GDNVODVFEVBS
$)*-&
.BHÓTUFSFO#JPÏUJDB
6OJWFSTJEBEEF$IJMF'BDVMUBEEF
'JMPTPGÓBZ)VNBOJEBEFT
$BQJUÈO*HOBDJP$BSSFSB1JOUP
QJTPºV×PB4BOUJBHP
5FMÏGPOP
'BY
BMSFZFT!VDIJMFDM
.BHÓTUFSFO#JPÏUJDB
6OJWFSTJEBEEF$IJMF'BDVMUBEEF
.FEJDJOB
"W*OEFQFOEFODJB
*OEFQFOEFODJB4BOUJBHP
5FMÏGPOP
'BY
QHBNFE!NFEVDIJMFDM
.BHÓTUFSFO#JPÏUJDB
6OJWFSTJEBEEFM%FTBSSPMMP'BDVMUBE
EF.FEJDJOBEF$MÓOJDB"MFNBOB
"W7JUBDVSB7JUBDVSB4BOUJBHP
5FMÏGPOP
ĊSFEFT!VEEDM
IUUQXXXVEEDMQSPOUVT@
QPTUHSBEPT
.BHÓTUFSFO#JPÏUJDB
1POUJmDJB6OJWFSTJEBE$BUØMJDBEF
$IJMF'BDVMUBEEF.FEJDJOB$FOUSP
EF#JPÏUJDB
"MBNFEBFEJmDJP
(BTUSPFOUFSPMPHÓBUPQJTP4BOUJBHP
5FMÏGPOP'BY
CJPFUJDB!NFEQVDDM
1SPHSBNB*OUFSOBDJPOBMEF'PSNBDJØO
²UJDBEFMB*OWFTUJHBDJØO#JPNÏEJDBZ
1TJDPTPDJBM
6OJWFSTJEBEEF$IJMF$FOUSP
*OUFSEJTDJQMJOBSJPEF&TUVEJPTFO
#JPÏUJDB
%JBHPOBM1BSBHVBZ5PSSF0G
4BOUJBHP
5FMÏGPOP
DCJP!VDIJMFDM
IUUQXXXVDIJMFDMCJPFUJDBDVSTPT
QSPHSBNBIUN
$0-0.#*"
%PDUPSBEPFO#JPÏUJDB
6OJWFSTJEBE&M#PTRVF
5PEBFTUBTFDDJØOEF"QÏOEJDFTGVFQSFQBSBEBQPS"OESFB«HVJMBCJCMJPUFDBSJBEPDVNFOUBMJTUBEFM1SP
HSBNBEF#JPÏUJDB0140.4
PERSPETIVADELABIOETICAINDD
1FSTQFDUJWBTEFMB#JPÏUJDBFO*CFSPBNÏSJDB
%JSFDDJØO$BSSFSBE#JT/P
#PHPUÈ
5FMT'BY
$PONVUBEPS&YUT
CJPFUJDB!VOCPTRVFFEVDP
IUUQXXXVOCPTRVFFEVDP
.BHÓTUFSFO#JPÏUJDB
6OJWFSTJEBE&M#PTRVF
$BSSFSBE#JT/P#PHPUÈ
5FMT'BY
$PONVUBEPS&YUT
CJPFUJDB!VOCPTRVFFEVDP
IUUQXXXVOCPTRVFFEVDP
&41"º"
.BHÓTUFSFO#JPÏUJDB
6OJWFSTJEBE$PNQMVUFOTFEF.BESJE
'BDVMUBEEF.FEJDJOB6OJEBEEF
)JTUPSJBEFMB.FEJDJOB%FQBSUBNFOUP
EF.FEJDJOB1SFWFOUJWB4BMVE1ÞCMJDB
F)JTUPSJBEFMB$JFODJB
$JVEBE6OJWFSTJUBSJB.BESJE
5FMT
NTUCJPFU!NFEVDNFT
IUUQXXXVDNFTJOGPCJPFUJDB
JOEFYNIUN
PERSPETIVADELABIOETICAINDD
.BHÓTUFSFO#JPÏUJDB
6OJWFSTJEBE$PNQMVUFOTFEF.BESJE
"WEB$PNQMVUFOTFTO7JDFSSFDUPSBEP
EF"MVNOPT.BESJE
5FMÏGPOP'BY
JOGPDPN!VDNFT
IUUQXXXVDNFT
1&3Á
.BFTUSÓBFO#JPÏUJDB
6OJWFSTJEBE/BDJPOBM.BZPSEF4BO
.BSDPT
"W1F[FU.BHEBMFOBEFM.BS
-JNB
3FGFSFODJB"MU$ESBEF"WFOJEB
4BMBWFSSZ
5FMÏGPOPT"OFYP
FQHBENJTJPO!VONTNFEVQF
IUUQXXXVONTNFEVQF&QH
7&/&;6&-"
1PTUHSBEP#JPÏUJDB$MÓOJDB
'BDVMUBEEF.FEJDJOB$FOUSP
/BDJPOBMEF#JPÏUJDB&TDVFMB
&YQFSJNFOUBMEF&OGFSNFSÓB
"W.JHVFM0UFSP4JMWB4FCVDÈO
$BSBDBT
5FMÏGPOP
NFEJDJOB!QPTUHSBEPVDWWF
IUUQXXXQPTUHSBEPVDWWFDVSTP
DVSTPBTQ JENFE
4FMFDDJØOEFJOTUJUVDJPOFTEFCJPÏUJDB
"-&."/*"
%FVUTDIF(FTFMMTDIBGUGàS
3FDIUTNFEJ[JO%(3.
(FSNBO
4PDJFUZGPS-FHBM.FEJDJOF
'SBVFOMPCTUSBTTFB.VODIFO
IUUQXXXEHSNEF
EHSN!VOJNVFOTUFSEF
%FVUDIFT3FGFSFO[[FOUSVNGàS&UIJL
JOEFO#JPXJTTFOTDIBGUFO(FSNBO
3FGFSFODF$FOUSFGPS&UIJDTJOUIF-JGF
4DJFODFT%3;&
/JFCVISTUSBTTF%#POO
5FM'BY
IUUQXXXES[FEF
JOGP!ES[FEF
(FSNBO/BUJPOBM&UIJDT$PVODJM
/BUJPOBMFS&UIJLSBU
(FTDIBGUTTUFMMF
EFT/BUJPOBMFO&UIJLSBUFT4JU[#FSMJO
#SBOEFOCVSHJTDIF"LBEFNJFEFS
8JTTFOTDIBGUFO
+BHFSTUSBTTF
#FSMJO
5FM'BY
IUUQXXXFUIJLSBUPSH
LPOUBLU!FUIJLSBUPSH
*OTUJUVUGàS(FTDIJDIUFEFS.FEJ[JO
"LBEFNJFGàS&UIJLJOEFS.FEJ[JO
)VNCPMEUBMMFF%(PFUUJOHFO
5FM
'"9
IUUQXXXBFNPOMJOFEFNBJOIUN
TJNPO!BFNPOMJOFEF
PERSPETIVADELABIOETICAINDD
6OJWFSTJUZPG5àFCJOHFO$FOUFS
GPS&UIJDTJOUIF4DJFODFTBOEUIF
)VNBOJUJFT*OUFSGBLVMUÊSFT;FOUSVN
GàS&UIJLJOEFO8JTTFOTDIBGUFO
*;&8
8JMIFMNTUS%5VFCJOHFO
5FM'BY
IUUQXXXJ[FXVOJUVFCJOHFOEF
J[FXEPLVNFOUBUJPO!VOJUVFCJOHFOEF
;FOUSVNGàSNFEJ[JOJTDIF&UIJL
3VIS6OJWFSTJUBFU#PDIVN
6OJWFSTJUBFUTTUS(FCBFVEF("
&CFOF
;JNNFS%#PDIVN
5FM
'BY
.FE&UIJDT!SVISVOJCPDIVNEF
"3(&/5*/"
"TPDJBDJØO"SHFOUJOBEF#JPÏUJDB
$BMMFEFNBZP¡1JTP'BDVMUBE
EF%FSFDIP
.BSEFM1MBUB
IUUQXXXBBCJPFUJDBPSH
IPPGUQG!JOGPWJBDPNBS
#JP4VS3FE3FHJPOBMEF$PNJUÏTEF
²UJDBFO4BMVE
SFECJPTVS!ZBIPPDPNBS
$FOUSPEF*OWFTUJHBDJØOZ&OTF×BO[B
IUUQXXXCJPFUJDBPSH
TDZQV!BSHFOFUDPNBS
*OTUJUVUPEF#JPÏUJDBZ)VNBOJEBEFT
.ÏEJDBT
-B1MBUB1SPWJODJBEF#VFOPT"JSFT
1FSTQFDUJWBTEFMB#JPÏUJDBFO*CFSPBNÏSJDB
IUUQXXXFMBCFCJPFUJDBPSH
FMBCF!TBUMJOLDPN
1POUJmDJB6OJWFSTJEBE$BUØMJDB
"SHFOUJOB*OTUJUVUPEF#JPÏUJDB
"W"MJDJB.EF+VTUP#VFOPT
"JSFT
5FM
'BY
IUUQXXXVDBFEVBSFTQTFDCJPFUJDB
JOEFYQIQ
CJPFUJDB!VDBFEVBS
6OJWFSTJEBE"VTUSBM'BDVMUBEEF
%FSFDIP%FQBSUBNFOUPEF#JPÏUJDB
GFC!DBTBVTUSBMFEVBS
6OJWFSTJEBE/BDJPOBMEF$VZP
'BDVMUBEEF$JFODJBT.ÏEJDBT
.BFTUSÓBFO#JPÏUJDB
QPTHSBEP!GDNVODVFEVBS
6OJWFSTJEBE/BDJPOBMEF-BOÞT
.BFTUSÓBFO²UJDB"QMJDBEB
EF4FQUJFNCSF
3FNFEJPT
EF&TDBMBEB-BOÞT1SPWJODJBEF#VFOPT
"JSFT
6OJWFSTJEBE/BDJPOBMEF.BSEFM1MBUB
&TQFDJBMJ[BDJØOFO#JPÏUJDB
IUUQXXXNEQFEVBS
"6453"-*"
"VTUSBMJBO#JPFUIJDT"TTPDJBUJPO"#"
,PLJMB%F4JMWB"#"4FDSFUBSZDP
3FTFBSDI
0ċDF#ME&"
.BDRVBSJF6OJWFSTJUZ
/FX4PVUI8BMFT
5FM'BY
IUUQXXXBVTUSBMBTJBOCJPFUIJDTPSHBV
LEFTJMWB!WDNRFEVBV
"VTUSBMJBO$BUIPMJD6OJWFSTJUZ+PIO
1MVOLFUU$FOUSFGPS&UIJDTJO)FBMUI
$BSF
4U7JODFOUT)PTQJUBM7JDUPSJB4USFFU
%BSMJOHIVSTU/FX4PVUI8BMFT
5FM'BY
QMVOLFUU!QMVOLFUUFEVBV
PERSPETIVADELABIOETICAINDD
"VTUSBMJBO)FBMUI&UIJDT$PNNJUUFF
/BUJPOBM)FBMUIBOE.FEJDBM3FTFBSDI
$PVODJM/).3$
.%1(10
#PY$BOCFSSB"$5
5FM'BY
IUUQXXXIFBMUIHPWBVOINSD
FYFDTFD!OINSDHPWBV
$ISJTUJBO$FOUSFGPS#JPFUIJDT4ZEOFZ
"EWFOUJTU)PTQJUBM
'PY7BMMFZ3PBE-FWFM
8BISPPOHB/FX4PVUI8BMFT
5FM'BY
IUUQXXXTBIPSHBVFEVDBUJPOMJCSBSZ
BTQ
MJCSBSZ!TBIPSHBV
-BUSPCF6OJWFSTJUZ)FBMUI*TTVFT
$FOUSF-FWFM)FBMUI4DJFODFT
.FMCPVSOF7JDUPSJB
5FM'BY
IUUQXXXIFBMUIJTTVFTDFOUSFPSHBV
IJD!MBUSPCFFEVBV
-+(PPEZ#JPFUIJDT$FOUSF
+VHBO4USFFU(MFOEBMPVHI8FTUFSO
"VTUSBMJB
5FM'BY
IUUQXXXMKHCDQFSUIDBUIPMJDPSHBV
MKHCD!QFSUIDBUIPMJDPSHBV
.POBTI6OJWFSTJUZ
$FOUSFGPS)VNBO#JPFUIJDT
$MBZUPO.FMCPVSOF7JDUPSJB
5FM'BY
IUUQXXXBSUTNPOBTIFEVBV
CJPFUIJDT
+VTUJO0BLMFZ!BSUTNPOBTIFEVBV
2VFFOTMBOE#JPFUIJDT$FOUSF
10#PY4PVUI#SJTCBOF2
5FM'BY
IUUQXXXCOFDBUIPMJDOFUBVRCD
JOEFYQIQ
RCD!NBUFSPSHBV
"QÏOEJDFT
4PVUIFSO$SPTT#JPFUIJDT*OTUJUVUF
.BSJPO3PBE10#PY/PSUI
1MZNQUPO4PVUI"EFMBJEF
5FM'BY
TFXJOH!CJPFUIJDTPSHBV
6OJWFSTJUZPG2VFFOTMBOE4U+PIOT
$PMMFHF$PMMFHF3PBE"VTUSBMJBO
*OTUJUVUFPG&UIJDTBOEUIF1SPGFTTJPOT
4U-VDJB2VFFOTMBOE
5FM'BY
IUUQXXXVRFEVBVBJFQ
INVOSP!NBJMCPYVRFEVBV
"6453*"
"VTUSJBO$PNNJTTJPOPO#JPFUIJDT
#VOEFTLBO[MFSBNU)PIFOTUBVGFOHBTTF
7JFOOB
5FM'BY
SPCFSUHNFJOFS!CLBHWBU
HBCSJFMBTDIXFIMB!CLBHWBU
#²-(*$"
$PNJUÏ$POTVMUBUJGEF#JPÏUIJRVFEF
#FMHJRVF
$"&#BUJNFOU7FTBMFÏNFFUBHF#VS
DP.NF.POJRVF#PTTPO#E
1BDIFDPCUF#SVYFMMFT
5FM'BY
IUUQXXXIFBMUIGHPWCFCJPFUI
CJPFUIJOGP!IFBMUIGHPWCF
.POJRVF#PTTPO!IFBMUIGHPWCF
&VSPQFBO$PNNJTTJPO&VSPQFBO
(SPVQPO&UIJDTJO4DJFODFBOE/FX
5FDIOPMPHJFT&(&
#SFZ##SVTTFMT
5FM'BY
HPQBFUIJDTHSPVQ!DFDFVJOU
$ISJTUJBOF#BSEPVY!DFDFVJOU
&VSPQFBO.FEJDBM4UVEFOUT"TTPDJBUJPO
$PNNJUUFFPO.FEJDBM&UIJDT&.4"
1FSNBOFOU0ċDFDP$1.&4UBOEJOH
$PNNJUUFPG&VSPQFBO%PDUPST
3VFEF$IBUFBV#SVTTFMT
5FM
FUIJDT!FNTBFVSPQFPSH
PERSPETIVADELABIOETICAINDD
,BUIPMJFLF6OJWFSTJUFJU-FVWFO'BDVMUFJU
EFS(FOFFTLVOEF$FOUSVNWPS#JP
.FEJTDIF&UIJFLFO3FDIU$FOUSFGPS
#JPNFEJDBM&UIJDTBOE-BX
,BQVDJKOFOWPFS-FVWFO
5FM4FDSFUBSJBBU'BY
IUUQXXXLVMFVWFOBDCFDCNFS
6OJWFSTJUÏ-JCSFEF#SVYFMMFT'BDVMUÏ
EF1IJMPTPQIJFFU-FUUSFT$FOUSFEF
3FDIFSDIFT*OUFSEJTDJQMJOBJSFTFO
#JPÏUIJRVF$3*#
6OJUÏ6-#
$1BWFOVF'%3PPTFWFMU
#SVYFMMFT
5FM'BY
IUUQXXXVMCBDCFSFDIJOWFOUBJSF
VOJUFT6-#IUNM
DSJC!VMCBDCF
#0-*7*"
$PNJUÏ/BDJPOBMEF#JPÏUJDBEF#PMJWJB
5FM
JOU
CJPFUJDB!DPMNFEMQPSH
6OJWFSTJEBE$BUØMJDB#PMJWJBOB4BO
1BCMP$FOUSPEF#JPÏUJDB
"W(SBM(BMJOEPFTR"W"NÏSJDB
5FM'BY
IUUQXXXVDCDCBFEVCP
#3"4*-
$FOUSP6OJWFSTJUÈSJP4ÍP$BNJMP
"W/B[BSÏ#BJSSP*QJSBOHB41
$FQ4ÍP1BVMP
5FM
'BY
IUUQXXXTDBNJMPCS
SFJUPSJB!TDBNJMPFEVCS
*OTUJUVUPEF#JPÏUJDB%FSFDIPT
)VNBOPTZ(ÏOFSP
$BJYB1PTUBM#SBTÓMJB%'
5FM'BY
IUUQXXXBOJTPSHCS
*OTUJUVUP0TDBS'SFJSF
3VB5FPEPSP4BNQBJP#BJSSP
1JOIFJSPT4ÍP1BVMP
$FQ
5FM
1FSTQFDUJWBTEFMB#JPÏUJDBFO*CFSPBNÏSJDB
IUUQXXXVTQCSGNNFEMFHJOEFY
IUNM
NMT!JPGGNVTQCS
.JOJTUÏSJPEB4BÞEF$PNJTTÍP/BDJPOBM
EF²UJDBFN1FTRVJTB$0/&1
&TQMBOBEBEPT.JOJTUÏSJPT#M(&E
"OFYP"MB#4MTB#SBTÓMJB
o%'$FQ
5FM
5FMFGBY
DPOFQ!TBVEFHPWCS
1POUJGÓDJB6OJWFSTJEBEF$BUØMJDB16$
1PSUP"MFHSF'BDVMEBEFEF.FEJDJOB
/ÞDMFPEF&TUVEPTFN#JPÏUJDB
"WFOJEB*QJSBOHB1PSUP"MFHSF
$FQ
QFEJBUSJB!QVDSTCS
&TDPMB/BDJPOBMEF4BÞEF1ÞCMJDB
&/41
%FQBSUBNFOUPEF$JÐODJBT
4PDJBJT/ÞDMFPEF²UJDB"QMJDBEBF
#JPÏUJDB'JPDSV[
3VB-FPQPMEPEF#VMIÜFT
BOEBSTBMB.BOHVJOIPT3JPEF
+BOFJSP
$FQ
5FM
SPMBOE!FOTQmPDSV[CS
4PDJFEBEF#SBTJMFJSBEF#JPÏUJDB
$BJYB1PTUBM#SBTÓMJB
$FQ
5FM
'BY
IUUQXXXTCCJPFUJDBPSHCS
TCCJPFUJDB!TCCJPFUJDBPSHCS
6OJWFSTJEBEFEF#SBTÓMJB$BNQVT
6OJWFSTJUÈSJP%BSDZ3JCFJSP
$FQ
5FM
'BY
CJPFUJDB!VOCCS
6OJWFSTJEBEFEF4ÍP1BVMP'BDVMEBEF
EF.FEJDJOB'.641
$PNJTTÍPEF
#JPÏUJDBEP)PTQJUBMEBT$MÓOJDBT
*OGPSNBÎÜFT
'BY
DPNJTTBPCJPFUJDB!IDOFUVTQCS
PERSPETIVADELABIOETICAINDD
6OJWFSTJEBEF&TUBEVBMEF-POESJOB
)PTQJUBM6OJWFSTJUÈSJP3FHJPOBMEP
/PSUFEP1BSBOÈ/ÞDMFPEF#JPÏUJDB
"W3PCFSU,PDL7JMB0QFSÈSJB
-POESJOB
$&1
5FMGBY
IUUQXXXVFMCSVFMIPNFQUQPSUBM
IUNM
IVSOQ!VFMCS
6OJWFSTJEBEF'FEFSBMEP3JP(SBOEFEP
4VM*OTUJUVUPEF'JMPTPGJBF$JFODJBT
)VNBOBT6'3(4
$BNQVTEP7BMF"WFOVF#FOUP
(PODBMWFT$BJYB1PTUBM
"HSPOPNJB
1PSUP"MFHSF
5FMFQIPOF'BY
IUUQXXXVGSHTCSQQHmM
QQHmMP!JGDIVGSHTCS
6OJWFSTJEBEF'FEFSBMEP3JP(SBOEFEP
4VM)PTQJUBMEF$MÓOJDBTEF1PSUP"MFHSF
/ÞDMFP*OUFSJOTUJUVDJPOBMEF#JPÏUJDB
3VB3BNJSP#BSDFMMPTTBMBG
1PSUP"MFHSF
$FQ
IUUQXXXCJPFUJDBVGSHTCS
HPMEJN!PSJPOVGSHTCS
$"/"%«
$BOBEJBO#JPFUIJDT4PDJFUZ$#4
DP-ZEJB3JEEFMM$PSSFTQPOEJOH
4FDSFUBSZ
3PDLZ3JEHF#BZ/8$BMHBSZ
"MCFSUB5(&
5FM
IUUQXXXCJPFUIJDTDB
MNSJEEFMM!TIBXDB
$BOBEJBO$BUIPMJD#JPFUIJDT*OTUJUVUF
*OTUJUVU$BOBEJFO$BUIPMJRVFEF
#JPFUIJRVF
4U.BSZ4USFFU5PSPOUP0OUBSJP
.4+
5FM'BY
IUUQXXXVUPSPOUPDBTUNJLFT
CJPFUIJDT
CJPFUIJDTVTND!VUPSPOUPDB
"QÏOEJDFT
$BOBEJBO*OTUJUVUFTPG)FBMUI3FTFBSDI
$*)3*OTUJUVUEFSFDIFSDIFFOTBOUÏEV
$BOBEB*34$
-BVSJFS"WFOVF8UI'MPPS
"EESFTT-PDBUPS"0UUBXB
0OUBSJP,"8
5FM
'BY
IUUQXXXDJISJSTDHDDBJOEFYIUNM
JOGP!DJISJSTDHDDB
$MJOJDBM3FTFBSDI*OTUJUVUFPG.POUSFBM
$FOUFSGPS#JPFUIJDT
1JOF"WFOVF8FTU.POUSFBM
2VFCFD)83
5FM'BY
IUUQXXXJSDNRDDBCJPFUIJRVF
SPZE!JSDNRDDB
$PNNJTTJPOEFMÏUIJRVFEFMBTDJFODFFU
EFMBUFDIOPMPHJF
SPVUFEFM&HMJTFSEnPPS4VJUF
4BJOUF'PZ2VFCFD(7;
5FM'BY
IUUQXXXFUIJRVFHPVWRDDB
FUIJRVF!FUIJRVFHPVWRDDB
%F7FCFS*OTUJUVUFGPS#JPFUIJDTBOE
4PDJBM3FTFBSDI
#BUIVSTU4USFFU4VJUF
5PSPOUP0OUBSJP.""
5FM'BY
IUUQXXXEFWFCFSPSH
CJPFUIJDT!EFWFCFSPSH
.D(JMM6OJWFSTJUZ'BDVMUZPG-BX
.D(JMM$FOUSFGPS.FEJDJOF&UIJDTBOE
-BX
1FFM4USFFU.POUSFBM2VFCFD
)"8
5FM'BY
IUUQXXXJJSFCPSH
JOGPMBX!NDHJMMDB
/BUJPOBM$PVODJMPO&UIJDTJO)VNBO
3FTFBSDI/$&)3
-F$POTFJM/BUJPOBM
EÏUIJRVFFOSFDIFSDIFDIF[MIVNBJO
$/&3)
&DIP%SJWF0UUBXB0OUBSJP,4/
PERSPETIVADELABIOETICAINDD
5FM'BY
IUUQODFISDOFSIPSH
PċDF!ODFISDOFSIPSH
ɨF)PTQJUBMGPS4JDL$IJMESFO
%FQBSUNFOUPG#JPFUIJDT
6OJWFSTJUZ"WFOVF5PSPOUP
0OUBSJP.(9
5FM'BY
NJDIFMJOFDPY!TJDLLJETDB
ɨF3PZBM$PMMFHFPG1IZTJDJBOTBOE
4VSHFPOTPG$BOBEB#JPNFEJDBM&UIJDT
$PNNJUUFF
&DIP%SJWF0UUBXB0OUBSJP,4
/
5FM'BY
IUUQSDQTDNFEJDBMPSHJOEFY
QIQ QBTT
KIJDLFZ!SDQTDFEV
6OJWFSTJUFEF.POUSFBM$FOUSFEF
SFDIFSDIFFOESPJUQVCMJD*OTUJUVU
*OUFSOBUJPOBMEF3FDIFSDIFFO²UIJRVF
#JPNFEJDBMF**3&#
$14VDDVSTBMF$FOUSF7JMMF
DIFNJOEFMB5PVS.POUSFBM2VFCFD
)$+
5FM'BY
IUUQXXXJJSFCPSH
DPPSE!JJSFCPSH
6OJWFSTJUÏEF.POUSFBM1SPHSBNNFTEF
CJPÏUIJRVF
$1TVDDVSTBMF$FOUSFWJMMF
.POUSFBM2VFCFD)$+
5FM
'BY
IUUQXXXGFTVNPOUSFBMDBCJPFUIJRVF
BOESFFEVQMBOUJF!VNPOUSFBMDBPEFUUF
MBOHMPJT!VNPOUSFBMDB
6OJWFSTJUÏ-BWBM'BDVMUÏEF1IJMPTPQIJF
(SPVQFEFSFDIFSDIFFO²UIJRVF
.FEJDBMF
#VSFBV2VFCFD$JUZ2VFCFD(,
1
5FM
1FSTQFDUJWBTEFMB#JPÏUJDBFO*CFSPBNÏSJDB
'BY
IUUQXXXGQVMBWBMDBGQEFGBVMU
BTQ CIDQ
GQ!GQVMBWBMDB
6OJWFSTJUZPG"MCFSUB-BX$FOUSF
)FBMUI-BX*OTUJUVUF
&ENPOUPO"MCFSUB5()
5FM'BY
IUUQXXXMBXVBMCFSUBDBDFOUSFTIMJ
IMJ!MBXVBMCFSUBDB
6OJWFSTJUZPG"MCFSUB+PIO%PTTFUPS
)FBMUI&UIJDT$FOUSF
6OJWFSTJUZ&YUFOTJPO$FOUSF
&ENPOUPO"MCFSUB5(5
5FM'BY
IUUQXXXVBMCFSUBDB#*0&5)*$4
%PTTFUPS$FOUSF!VBMCFSUBDB
6OJWFSTJUZPG5PSPOUP
+PJOU$FOUSFGPS#JPFUIJDT
$PMMFHF4USFFU5PSPOUP0OUBSJP
.(-
5FM'BY
IUUQXXXVUPSPOUPDBKDCIPNFNBJO
IUN
KDCJOGP!VUPSPOUPDB
$)*-&
1POUJmDJB6OJWFSTJEBE$BUØMJDBEF$IJMF
$FOUSPEF#JPÏUJDB
"W-JCFSUBEPS#0)JHHJOT4BOUJBHP
5FM
IUUQFTDVFMBNFEQVDDMEFQUPT
#JPFUJDB
CJPFUJDB!NFEQVDDM
6OJWFSTJEBE"MCFSUP)VSUBEP
$FOUSPEF²UJDB
"MNJSBOUF#BSSPTP4BOUJBHP
5FM'BY
IUUQFUJDBVBIVSUBEPDMOVFTUSP@DFOUSP
DPOUFYUPIUN
UNJGTVE!VBIVSUBEPDM
6OJWFSTJEBEEFM%FTBSSPMMP'BDVMUBEEF
.FEJDJOB$FOUSPEF#JPÏUJDB
PERSPETIVADELABIOETICAINDD
"W7JUBDVSB7JUBDVSB4BOUJBHP
5FM
IUUQXXXVEEDM
6OJWFSTJEBEEF$IJMF'BDVMUBEEF
.FEJDJOB%FQBSUBNFOUPEF#JPÏUJDBZ
)VNBOJEBEFT.ÏEJDBT
"WEB*OEFQFOEFODJB/DVBSUP
QJTP*OEFQFOEFODJB4BOUJBHP
5FM
IUUQXXXNFEVDIJMFDM
EFQBSUBNFOUPTCJPFUJDB@IVNBOJEBEFT@
NFEJDBTIUNM
EFQUPCJPFUJDB!NFEVDIJMFDM
NCSBWP!NFEVDIJMFDM
6OJWFSTJEBEEF$IJMF$FOUSP
*OUFSEJTDJQMJOBSJPEF&TUVEJPTFO
#JPÏUJDB$*&#
%JBHPOBM1BSBHVBZ5PSSFPG
4BOUJBHP
5FM'BY
IUUQXXXVDIJMFDMCJPFUJDB
DCJP!VDIJMFDM
6OJWFSTJEBEEF4BOUJBHPEF$IJMF
1SPHSBNBEF#JPÏUJDB
"WFOJEB-JCFSUBEPS#FSOBSEP0)JHHJOT
&TUBDJØO$FOUSBM4BOUJBHP
5FM
IUUQXXXGDNVTBDIDM
JCBSSVFU!VTBDIDM
8PSME)FBMUI0SHBOJ[BUJPO8)0
1BO"NFSJDBO)FBMUI0SHBOJ[BUJPO
1")0
1SPHSBNBEF#JPÏUJDB
1SPWJEFODJB1JTP4BOUJBHP
5FM'BY
IUUQXXXQBIPCJPFUJDB
CJPFUJDB!DIJPQTPNTPSHMPMBTG!DIJ
PQTPNTPSH
$)*/"
$IJOFTF.FEJDBM"TTPDJBUJPO%JWPG
*OUFSOBUJPOBM.FEJDBM$POWFOUJPOT
'PSFJHO3FMBUJPOT%FQBSUNFOU
%POHTJ9JEBKJF#FJKJOH
5FM==
'BY
IUUQXXXDIJOBNFEDPNDO
JOGPS!DIJOBNFEDPNDO
"QÏOEJDFT
6OJWFSTJUZ)FBMUI4DJFODF$FOUFS
%JWJTJPOPG4PDJBM4DJFODFTBOE
)VNBOJUJFT#FJKJOH.FEJDBM6OJWFSTJUZ
1FLJOH%FQBSUNFOUPG.FEJDBM&UIJDT
9VFZVBO3PBE)BJEJBO%JTUSJDU
#FJKJOH
IUUQXXXCKNVFEVDOJOEFY
IUN
$0-0.#*"
"DBEFNJB/BDJPOBMEF.FEJDJOBEF
$PMPNCJB*OTUJUVUP$PMPNCJBOPEF
&TUVEJPT#JPFUJDPT*$&#
$SB/P#PHPUB
5FM
IUUQBONFODPMPNCJBDPNJDFCIUN
JDFC@DPMPNCJB!IPUNBJMDPN
"TPDJBDJØO/BDJPOBMEF#JPÏUJDB
5SBOTW‹/¡RVJOUPQJTP
BOBMCF!IPUNBJMDPN
1POUJmDJB6OJWFSTJEBE+BWFSJBOB
*OTUJUVUPEF#JPÏUJDB
5SBOTWFSTBM¡/P2VJOUP1JTP
&EJmDJP+PTÏ3BGBFM"SCPMFEB
#PHPUÈ
5FM
&YUFOTJØO
IUUQXXXKBWFSJBOBFEVDPCJPFUJDB
CJPFUJDB!KBWFSJBOBFEVDP
6OJWFSTJEBEEFMB4BCBOB$IÓB
$FOUSP
EF#JPÏUJDB
CJPÏUJDB!VOJTBCBOBFEVDP
6OJWFSTJEBE&M#PTRVF*OTUJUVUPEF
#JPÏUJDB
5SBOTW‹#JT/#PHPUÈ
5FM
6OJWFSTJEBE/BDJPOBMEF$PMPNCJB3FE
EF#JPÏUJDB
&EJmDJP.BOVFM"ODÓ[BS
5FM
&YU
IUUQXXXVOBMFEVDPCJPFUJDB
SFEC@CPH!VOBMFEVDP
$03&"
4FPOHTBO$FOUFSGPS#JPNFEJDBM&UIJDT
JO,PSFB
5FM
PERSPETIVADELABIOETICAINDD
IUUQXXXCJPFUIJDTPSLS
TDCF!CJPFUIJDTPSLS
6OJWFSTJUZPG6MTBO$PMMFHFPG
.FEJDJOF%FQUPG.FEJDBM)VNBOJUJFT
BOE4PDJBM4DJFODFT,PSFBO#JPFUIJDT
"TTPDJBUJPO,#"
4FPVM
5FM
'BY
IUUQXXXLPSFBCJPFUIJDTOFU
FUIJDT!OFUTHPDPN
TPOHTZ!IPUNBJMDPN
$6#"
"DBEFNJBEF$JFODJBTEF$VCB$PNJUÏ
/BDJPOBM$VCBOPEF#JPÏUJDB
$BQJUPMJP/BDJPOBM1SBEPZ4BO+PTÏ
)BCBOB7JFKB-B)BCBOB
QJFESB!DFOJBJJOGDV
%*/"."3$"
%BOJTI$PVODJMPG&UIJDT
3BWOTCPSHHBEF%,
$PQFOIBHFO
5FM'BY
IUUQXXXFUJTLSBBEELTXBTQ
JOGP!FUJTLSBBEEL
&$6"%03
1POUJmDJB6OJWFSTJEBE$BUØMJDBEF
&DVBEPS(SVQPEF#JPÏUJDB
&EJmDJPEFMB'BDVMUBEEF$JFODJBT
&YBDUBTZ/BUVSBMFT
1JTP"WEF0DUVCSFZ"W1BUSJB
2VJUP
IUUQXXXQVDFFEVFD
4PDJFEBE&DVBUPSJBOBEF#JPÏUJDB
IUUQXXXCJPFUJDBPSHFDNPEVMFT
OFXT
&41"º"
*OTUJUVUP#PSKBEF#JPÏUJDB
-MBTFSFTD4BOUB3PTB
&TQMVHVFTEF-MPCSFHBU#BSDFMPOB
5FM
1FSTQFDUJWBTEFMB#JPÏUJDBFO*CFSPBNÏSJDB
IUUQXXXJCCJPFUJDBPSH
CJPFUJDB!JCCITKECDOPSH
*OUFSOBUJPOBM4PDJFUZPG#JPFUIJDT
4PDJFEBE*OUFSOBDJPOBMEF#JPÏUJDB
1MB[BEFM)VNFEBM&EJG(PUBEF
-FDIF
(JKPO"TUVSJBT
5FM'BY
IUUQXXXTJCJPSH
CJPFUJDB!TJCJPSH
&45"%046/*%04
"NFSJDBO/VSTFT"TTPDJBUJPO$FOUFS
GPS&UIJDTBOE)VNBO3JHIUT
4VJUF8FTU.BSZMBOE"WFOVF
488BTIJOHUPO%JTUSJDUPG$PMVNCJB
5FM'BY
IUUQXXXOVSTJOHXPSMEPSHFUIJDT
"NFSJDBO4PDJFUZGPS#JPFUIJDTBOE
)VNBOJUJFT"4#)
8FTU-BLF4USFFU(MFOWJFX
*MMJOPJT
5FM'BY
IUUQXXXBTCIPSH
JOGP!BTCIPSH
"[VTB1BDJmD6OJWFSTJUZ$FOUFSGPS
3FTFBSDIPO&UIJDTBOE7BMVFT
&"MPTUB"WF10#PY
"[VTB$BMJGPSOJB
5FM'BY
IUUQXXXBQVFEVFEVDBCTDSFW
TUBOGPSE!BQVFEV
#BMM4UBUF6OJWFSTJUZ%FQBSUNFOUPG
#JPMPHZ)VNBO(FOFUJDTBOE#JPFUIJDT
&EVDBUJPOBM-BCPSBUPSZ)("#&-
6OJWFSTJUZ"WF.VODJF*OEJBOB
5FM'BY
+3)FOESJY!#467$#46&EV
$FOUFSGPS#JPFUIJDTBOE$VMUVSF
10#PY0BLMBOE$BMJGPSOJB
PERSPETIVADELABIOETICAINDD
5FM'BY
IUUQXXXUIFDCDPSH
KFOOJGFSMBIM!UIFDCDPSHCBSCBSB
RVJHMFZ!UIFDCDPSH
$FOUFSGPS&UIJDTBOE"EWPDBDZJO
)FBMUIDBSF
8BVLFHBO3PBE10#PY
5FDIOZ*MMJOPJT
5FM
IUUQXXXIFBMUIDBSFFUIJDTPSH
$FOUFSGPS#JPFUIJDTBOE)VNBO
%JHOJUZ
)BMG%BZ3PBE#BOOPDLCVSO
*MMJOPJT
5FM'BY
IUUQXXXDCIEPSH
JOGP!DCIEPSH
$PVODJMGPS3FTQPOTJCMF(FOFUJDT
$3(
6QMBOE3PBE4VJUF$BNCSJEHF
.BTTBDIVTFUUT
5FM'BY
IUUQXXXHFOFXBUDIPSH
DSH!HFOFXBUDIPSH
%F1BVM6OJWFSTJUZ$PMMFHFPG-BX
)FBMUI-BX*OTUJUVUF
&BTU+BDLTPO#MWE$IJDBHP*-
5FM'BY
NHPPEXJO!EFQBVMFEV
&NPSZ6OJWFSTJUZ$FOUFSGPS&UIJDT
%FOUBM#VJMEJOH$MJGUPO3PBE/&
"UMBOUB(FPSHJB
5FM'BY
IUUQXXXFUIJDTFNPSZFEV
KGPXMFS!FNPSZFEV+BNFT'PXMFS
LLJOMBX!FNPSZFEV,BUIMFFO,JOMBX
'MPSJEB#JPFUIJDT/FUXPSL'#/
10#PY.
.JBNJ
'MPSJEB
"QÏOEJDFT
5FM
IUUQXXXNJBNJFEVFUIJDTGCO
GCO!DIGNVnFEVFUIJDT!NJBNJFEV
(FPSHFUPXO6OJWFSTJUZ,FOOFEZ
*OTUJUVUFPG&UIJDT
#PY8BTIJOHUPO%JTUSJDUPG
$PMVNCJB
5FM'BY
IUUQLFOOFEZJOTUJUVUFHFPSHFUPXO
FEVJOEFYIUN
LJDPVSTF!HFPSHFUPXOFEV
(FPSHFUPXO6OJWFSTJUZ.FEJDBM$FOUFS
$FOUFSGPS$MJOJDBM#JPFUIJDT
3PPN#VJMEJOH%3FTFSWPJS
3E/88BTIJOHUPO%JTUSJDUPG
$PMVNCJB
5FM'BY
IUUQDMJOJDBMCJPFUIJDTHFPSHFUPXOFEV
QBUDIFMN!HFPSHFUPXOFEV
)BSWBSE6OJWFSTJUZ.FEJDBM4DIPPM
%JWJTJPOPG.FEJDBM&UIJDT
)VOUJOHUPO"WFOVF#PTUPO
.BTTBDIVTFUUT
5FM
'"9
%.&!INTIBSWBSEFEV
+PIOT)PQLJOT6OJWFSTJUZ1IPFCF3
#FSNBO#JPFUIJDT*OTUJUVUF
#SPBEXBZ)BNQUPO)PVTF
#BMUJNPSF.BSZMBOE
5FM'BY
IUUQXXXIPQLJOTNFEJDJOFPSH
CJPFUIJDT
CJPFUIJDT!KITQIFEV
-PZPMB.BSZNPVOU6OJWFSTJUZ#JPFUIJDT
*OTUJUVUF
6OJWFSTJUZ)BMM0OF-.6%SJWF4VJUF
-PT"OHFMFT$BMJGPSOJB
5FM
'BY
KXBMUFS!MNVFEV
PERSPETIVADELABIOETICAINDD
.JDIJHBO4UBUF6OJWFSTJUZ%FQBSUNFOU
PG1IJMPTPQIZ*OUFSOBUJPOBM/FUXPSL
PO'FNJOJTU"QQSPBDIFTUP#JPFUIJDT
DP)JMEF/FMTPO4PVUI,FE[JF)BMM
-BOTJOH.JDIJHBO
5FM
IMOFMTPO!NTVFEV
/BUJPOBM*OTUJUVUFTPG)FBMUI
%FQBSUNFOUPG$MJOJDBM#JPFUIJDT
$FOUFS%SJWF#MEH3PPN
$#FUIFTEB.BSZMBOE
5FM'BY
IUUQXXXCJPFUIJDTOJIHPW
CJPFUIJDT!OJIHPW
/FX:PSL.FEJDBM$PMMFHF#JPFUIJDT
*OTUJUVUFPG/FX:PSL.FEJDBM$PMMFHF
"ENJOJTUSBUJPO#VJMEJOH7BMIBMMB
/FX:PSL
5FM
IUUQXXXOZNDFEV')1JOTUJUVUFT
#JPFUIJDTNJTTJPOBTQ
1BDJmD4DIPPMPG3FMJHJPO1SPHSBNJO
#JPFUIJDT
4DFOJD"WFOVF#FSLFMFZ
$BMJGPSOJB
5FM
IUUQXXXQTSFEV
QTSJOGP!QTSFEV
1SFTJEFOUT$PVODJMPO#JPFUIJDT
1FOOTZMWBOJB"WFOVF/84VJUF
8BTIJOHUPO%JDUSJDUPG$PMVNCJB
5FM
IUUQXXXCJPFUIJDTHPW
JOGP!CJPFUIJDTHPW
4UBOGPSE6OJWFSTJUZ$FOUFSGPS
#JPNFEJDBM&UIJDT
8FMDI3PBE#VJMEJOH"4VJUF
1BMP"MUP$BMJGPSOJB
5FM'BY
IUUQTDCFTUBOGPSEFEV
4$#&JOGP!NFETUBOGPSEFEV
1FSTQFDUJWBTEFMB#JPÏUJDBFO*CFSPBNÏSJDB
5IF)BTUJOHT$FOUFS
3PVUF%.BMDPMN(PSEPO3E
(BSSJTPO/FX:PSL
5FM'BY
IUUQXXXUIFIBTUJOHTDFOUFSPSH
NBJM!UIFIBTUJOHTDFOUFSPSH
5IF)BTUJOHT$FOUFS8FTUFSO0GGJDF
)PMZPLF4USFFU4BO'SBODJTDP
$BMJGPSOJB
5FM
IUUQXXXUIFIBTUJOHTDFOUFSPSH
NBJM!UIFIBTUJOHTDFOUFSPSH
6OJWFSTJUZPG$POOFDUJDVU4DIPPMPG
.FEJDJOF%FQBSUNFOUPG$PNNVOJUZ
.FEJDJOFBOE)FBMUI$BSF%JWJTJPOPG
.FEJDBM)VNBOJUJFT)FBMUI-BXBOE
&UIJDT
'BSNJOHUPO"WFOVF.$
'BSNJOHUPO$POOFDUJDVU
5FM'BY
IUUQXXXDPNNFEVDIDFEV
NFEJDBMIVNBOJUJFT
EQTNJUI!OTPVDIDFEV
6OJWFSTJUZPG'MPSJEB$PMMFHFPG
.FEJDJOF%FQBSUNFOUPG$PNNVOJUZ
)FBMUIBOE
'BNJMZ.FEJDJOF1SPHSBNJO#JPFUIJDT
-BXBOE.FEJDBM1SPGFTTJPOBMJTN
1#-.1
10#PY(BJOFTWJMMF'MPSJEB
5FM'BY
IUUQXXXDIGNVnFEVQSPHSBNT
CMNQ
6OJWFSTJUZPG.JBNJ#JPFUIJDT1SPHSBN
10#PY.
.JBNJ
'MPSJEB
5FM'BY
IUUQXXXNJBNJFEVFUIJDT
CJPFUIJDT@QSPHSBNIUN
FUIJDT!NJBNJFEV
6OJWFSTJUZPG4PVUI'MPSJEB$PMMFHF
PG.FEJDJOF%FQBSUNFOUPG*OUFSOBM
PERSPETIVADELABIOETICAINDD
.FEJDJOF%JWJTJPOPG.FEJDBM&UIJDT
BOE)VNBOJUJFT
.%$#PY#SVDF#%PXOT
#PVMFWBSE5BNQB'MPSJEB
5FM'BY
IUUQXXXNFEVTGFEV*/5.&%
FUIJDT
SPXBMLFS!DPNNFEVTGFEV
6OJWFSTJUZPG4PVUI'MPSJEB$PMMFHF
PG.FEJDJOF%FQBSUNFOUPG*OUFSOBM
.FEJDJOF1SPHSBNJO#JPFUIJDTBOE
.FEJDBM)VNBOJUJFT
.%$#PY#SVDF#%PXOT
#PVMFWBSE5BNQB'MPSJEB
5FM
IUUQITDVTGFEVNFEJDJOF
JOUFSOBMNFEJDJOFCJPFUIJDT
L[BIO!ITDVTGFEV
64%FQBSUNFOUPG&OFSHZ0ċDFPG
4DJFODF&UIJDBM-FHBMBOE4PDJBM*TTVFT
*OEFQFOEFODF"WFOVF48
8BTIJOHUPO%JTUSJDUPG$PMVNCJB
5VTLFHFF6OJWFSTJUZ/BUJPOBM$FOUFS
GPS#JPFUIJDTJO3FTFBSDIBOE)FBMUI
$BSF
%SFX)BMM3PPN5VTLFHFF
"MBCBNB
5FM'BY
IUUQXXXUVTLFHFFFEV(MPCBM
DBUFHPSZBTQ
CJPFUIJDT!UVTLFHFFFEV
64%FQBSUNFOUPG)FBMUIBOE)VNBO
4FSWJDFT0GGJDFGPS)VNBO3FTFBSDI
1SPUFDUJPOT
*OEFQFOEFODF"WFOVF48
8BTIJOHUPO%$
5FM
IUUQXXXIITHPWPISQ
8PSME)FBMUI0SHBOJ[BUJPO8)0
1BO"NFSJDBO)FBMUI0SHBOJ[BUJPO
1")0
1BO"NFSJDBO4BOJUBSZ
#VSFBV%JWJTJPOPG)FBMUIBOE)VNBO
%FWFMPQNFOU1SPHSBNPO#JPFUIJDT
5XFOUZUIJSE4USFFU/8
"QÏOEJDFT
8BTIJOHUPO%JTUSJDUPG$PMVNCJB
5FM'BY
IUUQXXXQBIPPSH
XFCNBTUFS!QBIPPSH
'*-*1*/"4
%FQBSUNFOUPG4DJFODFBOE5FDIOPMPHZ
1IJMJQQJOF$PVODJMGPS)FBMUI3FTFBSDI
BOE%FWFMPQNFOU1$)3%
'%045.BJO#MEH%045
$PNQPVOE(FO4BOUPT"WF#JDVUBO
5BHJH.FUSP.BOJMB
5FM%-
UP'BY
5-
MPDBMUP
IUUQXXXQDISEEPTUHPWQI
OFXQDISE
JOGP!QDISEEPTUHPWQI
6OJWFSTJUZPGUIF1IJMJQQJOFT#JPFUIJDT
5SBJOJOH1SPKFDU$VSSJDVMVN
%FWFMPQNFOUBOE*OUFOTJWF5SBJOJOHJO
3FTFBSDI&UIJDT
OE'MPPS#FOUPO)BMM10#PY
%JMJNBO2VF[PO$JUZ
5FM'BY
IUUQXXXCJPFUIJDTUSBJOJOHPSH
DPOUBDU!CJPFUIJDTUSBJOJOHPSH
CJPFUIJDTUSBJOJOH!LTTQVQEFEVQI
'*/-"/%*"
'JOOJTI/BUJPOBM1VCMJD)FBMUI
*OTUJUVUF/BUJPOBM"EWJTPSZ#PBSE
GPS#JPUFDIOPMPHZ#JPUFLOJJLBO
/FVWPUUFMVLVOUB
.BOOFSIFJNJOUJF'*/
)FMTJOTLJ
5FM'BY
IUUQXXXCJPUFLOJJLBOOFVWPUUFMVLVO
UBm
TJIUFFSJ!CJPUFLOJJLBOOFVWPUUFMVLVOUBm
/PSEJD$PNNJUUFFPO#JPFUIJDT
/PSEJTL,PNNJUFGPS#JPFUJL
DP4FDSFUBSZ)FMFOBWPO5SPJM3JLIBSE
/ZNBOTWBH#)FMTJOHGPST
5FM'BY
PERSPETIVADELABIOETICAINDD
IUUQXXXODCJPPSH
TFDSFUBSZ!ODCJPPSH
4FDSFUBSZ(FOFSBM4BMMB-PUKPOFO
/BUJPOBM"EWJTPSZ#PBSEPO
3FTFBSDI&UIJDT5VULJNVTFFUUJOFO
/FVWPUUFMVLVOUB
.BSJBOLBUV'*/)FMTJOLJ
5FM'BY
IUUQQSPUTWmUFOL
TBMMBMPUKPOFO!UTWm
'3"/$*"
$PVODJMPG&VSPQF4UFFSJOH$PNNJUUFF
PO#JPFUIJDT$PNJUF
%JSFDUFVSEF#JPFUIJRVF$%#*
1JFDF4USBTCPVSH$FEFY
5FM
IUUQXXXDPFJOU
DBSMPTEFTPMB!DPFJOU
*OTUJUVU/BUJPOBMEFMB4BOUÏFUEFMB
3FDIFSDIF.FEJDBMF*/4&3.
$FOUSF
EF%PDVNFOUBUJPOFO²UIJRVFEFT
4DJFODFTEFMB7JFFUEFMB4BOUÏ
SVF4BJOU%PNJOJRVF1BSJT
5FM'BY
IUUQXXXDDOFFUIJRVFGSGSBODBJT
IUNQSFTFOUIUN
DEFJ!LCJOTFSNGS
*OTUJUVU/BUJPOBMEFMB4BOUÏFUEFMB
3FDIFSDIF.FEJDBMF*/4&3.
$PNJUÏ
$POTVMUBUJG/BUJPOBME²UIJRVFQPVSMFT
4DJFODFTEFMB7JFFUEFMB4BOUÏ
SVF4BJOU%PNJOJRVF1BSJT
5FM'BY
IUUQXXXDDOFFUIJRVFGS
DPOUBDU!DPNJUFFUIJRVFGS
6OJUFE/BUJPOT&EVDBUJPOBM4DJFOUJmD
BOE$VMUVSBM0SHBOJ[BUJPO6/&4$0
*OUFSOBUJPOBM#JPFUIJDT$PNNJUUFF
1MBDFEF'POUFOPZ1BSJT
5FM'BY
1FSTQFDUJWBTEFMB#JPÏUJDBFO*CFSPBNÏSJDB
(3&$*"
/BUJPOBM#JPFUIJDT$PNNJTTJPO
&WFMQJEPO"UIFOT
5FM'BY
IUUQXXXCJPFUIJDTHS
TFDSFUBSJBU!CJPFUIJDT
HS57JEBMJT!CJPFUIJDTHS
,.BOPMBLPV!CJPFUIJDTHS
)6/(3¶"
$FOUSBMBOE&BTU&VSPQFBO"TTPDJBUJPO
PG#JPFUIJDT$&&"#
1FDT#VEBJ/BHZ"V
5FM
'BY
$IFMB!NBJMNBUBWIV
*/%*"
"MM*OEJB"TTPDJBUJPOPG#JPFUIJDT
"*#"
/PUI-BOFUI$SPTT4USFFU*OEJSB
/BHBS$IFOOBJ
'BY
KB[BSJBI!VOJNBEFSOFUJO
'PSVNGPS.FEJDBM&UIJDT4PDJFUZ
1SBCIV%BSTIBO44BJOJL
/BHBS"NCPMJ"OEIFSJ8
.VNCBJ
5FM
*OEJBO$PVODJMPG.FEJDBM3FTFBSDI
*$.3
73BNBMJOHBTXBNJ#IBXBO"OTBSJ
/BHBS10#PY//FX%FMIJ
5FM
'BY
IUUQJDNSOJDJO
JDNSIRET!TBOTBEOJDJO
4U1JVT9$PMMFHF*OUFSOBUJPOBM
'FEFSBUJPOPG$BUIPMJD.FEJDBM
"TTPDJBUJPOT'*".$
#JP.FEJDBM
&UIJDT$FOUSF
"BSFZ3PBE(PSFHBPO&BTU.VNCBJ
5FM
PERSPETIVADELABIOETICAINDD
IUUQNFNCFSTSFEJĊDPNGCNFD
GCNFDCJP!CPNWTOMOFUJO
*3-"/%"
*SJTI$PVODJMGPS#JPFUIJDT$PNIBJSMF
#JUIFJUJDFOBI&JSFBOO
"DBEFNZ)PVTF%BXTPO4USFFU
%VCMJO
5FM'BY
IUUQXXXCJPFUIJDTJF
JOGP!CJPFUIJDTJF
*43"&-
#FO(VSJPO6OJWFSTJUZ/FHFW'BDVMUZ
PG)FBMUI4DJFODFT-PSE*NNBOVFM
+BDPLPWJUT$FOUFSPG+FXJTI.FEJDBM
&UIJDT
1PTU0ċDF#PY#FFS4IFWB
5FM
HTIJNPO!CHVNBJMCHVBDJM
%S'BML4DIMFTJOHFS*OTUJUVUFGPS
.FEJDBM)BMBDIJD3FTFBSDI
4IBBSF;FEFL.FEJDBM$FOUFS+FSVTBMFN
#BZJU4USFFU10#PY
+FSVTBMFN
5FM'BY
IUUQXXXNFEFUIJDTPSHJM
JOGP!NFEFUIJDTPSHJM
*TSBFM"DBEFNZPG4DJFODFTBOE
)VNBOJUJFT#JPFUIJDT"EWJTPSZ
$PNNJUUFF
DP%FQBSUNFOUPG4DJFODF5FBDIJOH
ɨF8FJ[NBOO*OTUJUVUFPG4DJFODF
3FIPWPU
5FM'BY
IUUQXXXBDBEFNZBDJMCJPFUIJDT
IFCSFXJOEFYIUNM
JMBOBIPQGFME!XFJ[NBOOBDJM
6OJWFSTJUZPG)BJGB'BDVMUZPG-BX
*OUFSOBUJPOBM$FOUFSGPS)FBMUI-BX
BOE&UIJDT
10#*#.#VJMEJOH0ċDFT/PT
)B$BSNFM.PVOUBJO
5FM'BY
"QÏOEJDFT
IUUQNFEMBXIBJGBBDJM
TJFHBM!SFTFBSDIIBJGBBDJM%S(JM4JFHBM
6OJWFSTJUZPGUIF/FHFW'BDVMUZPG
)FBMUI4DJFODFT#FO(VSJPO$FOUFSGPS
"TJBOBOE*OUFSOBUJPOBM#JPFUIJDT
#FFS4IFWB
5FM
ZFSVIBN!CHVNBJMCHVBDJM
8PSME"TTPDJBUJPOGPS.FEJDBM-BX
4UFJS(SPVQ-UE)BZFU[JSB4USFFU
3BNBU(BO
5FM
'BY
IUUQXBNMIBJGBBDJM
XBNM!SFTFBSDIIBJGBBDJM
*5"-*"
$PNJUBUP/B[JPOBMFQFSMB#JPFUJDB
7JB7FOFUP3PNF
5FM'BY
IUUQXXXQBMB[[PDIJHJJUCJPFUJDB
DOCJPFUJDB!QBMB[[PDIJHJJU
$POTJHMJP/B[JPOBMFEFMMF3JDFSDIF
1JB[[BMF"MEP.PSP3PNB
5FM'BY
IUUQXXXDOSJUTJUPDOSIPNFIUNM
VSQ!VSQDOSJU
'BDPMUB5FPMPHJDBEJ4JDJMJB*OTUJUVUP
4JDJMJBOPEJ#JPFUJDB
1JB[[B4%PNFOJDP"DJSFBMF
5FM'BY
IUUQXXXHUFJUJTC
TBMQSJJTC!NBJMHUFJU
'POEB[JPOF-BO[B
7JB%BOUF1BEPWB
5FM'BY
IUUQXXXGPOEB[JPOFMBO[BJU
JOGP!GPOEB[JPOFMBO[BJU
PERSPETIVADELABIOETICAINDD
/BUJPOBM#JPFUIJDT$PNNJUUFF
$PNJUBUP/B[UJPOBMF*UBMJBOPEJ
#JPFUJDB
7JB7FOFUP3PNB
5FM'BY
DOCJPFUJDB!QBMB[[PDIJHJJU
+"1»/
"TJBO#JPFUIJDT"TTPDJBUJPO"#"
,VEBO.JOBNJ$IJZPEBLV
5PLZP
5FM'BY
TBLBNPUP!DITOJIPOVBDKQ
+BQBOFTF"TTPDJBUJPOGPS1IJMPTPQIJDBM
BOE&UIJDBM3FTFBSDIJO.FEJDJOF
DP,ZPJDIJ0;",*4BJUBNB(BLVFO
6OJWFSTJUZ
,JTPSP,BXBHVDIJTIJ
IUUQQMB[BVNJOBDKQ_QFNFEJOEFY@
FOHIUNM
LP[BLJ!TBJHBLVBDKQ
6OJWFSTJUZPG5TVLVCB*OTUJUVUFPG
#JPMPHJDBM4DJFODFT&VCJPT&UIJDT
*OTUJUVUF
10#PY5TVLVCB4DJFODF$JUZ
*CBSBLJ
5FM'BY
IUUQXXXVOFTDPCLLPSHFVCJPT
NBDFS!TBLVSBDDUTVLVCBBDKQ
8BTFEB6OJWFSTJUZ"EWBODFE3FTFBSDI
$FOUFSGPS)VNBO4DJFODFT#JPFUIJDT
3FTFBSDI1SPKFDU
/JTIJXBTFEB4IJOKVLZLV5PLZP
5FMFYU
'BY
IUUQXXXCJPFUIJDTKQ
SJIJUP!XBTFEBKQJOGP!CJPFUIJDTKQ
-*56"/*"
-JUIVBOJBO#JPFUIJDT$PNNJUUFF
-JFUVWPT#JPFUJLPT,PNJUFUBT
7JMOJBVTH7JMOJVT
5FM'BY
MCFL!TBNMU
1FSTQFDUJWBTEFMB#JPÏUJDBFO*CFSPBNÏSJDB
."-5"
%FQBSUNFOUPG)FBMUI#JPFUIJDT
$POTVMUBUJWF$PNNJUUFF
.FSDIBOUT4USFFU7BMMFUUB
5FM'BY
NDBV!VNFEVNU
.²9*$0
"DBEFNJB/BDJPOBM.FYJDBOBEF
#JPÏUJDB"$
"OUJHVP$MBVTUSPEFM)PTQJUBM+VÈSF[
1"1MB[B4BO1BCMP$FOUSP.ÏYJDP
%'
5FMT
WTVBSF[!TFSWJEPSVOBNNY
"TPDJBDJØO1BOBNFSJDBOBEF#JPÏUJDB4$
"QBSUBEP1PTUBM.ÏYJDP%'
$1
IUUQXXXBOBIVBDNYBQBCFJOEFY
IUN
FIBNJMM!BOBIVBDNY
$FOUSPEF&TUVEJPTF*OWFTUJHBDJØOFO
#JPÏUJDB$&*#
"W&TQB×B$PM.PEFSOB
(VBEBMBKBSB0/(+BMJTDP
5FM
DFJO!JOGPTFMOFUNY
$PMFHJPEF#JPÏUJDBEF/VFWP-FØO
5FM
IUUQXXXCJPFUJDBDPNNYJOEFY
QIQ *UFNJE
OFMMZDBSMPT!CJPFUJDBDPNNY
$PNJTJØO.FYJDBOBEF%FSFDIPT
)VNBOPT
5FIVBOUFQFD$PM3PNB4VS
%FMFHBDJØO$VBVIUÏNPD
5FMrr
'BY
IUUQXXXMBOFUBBQDPSHDNEQEI
EJSFDDJPO!DNEQEIPSH
$0/"4*%"
$PNFSDJPZ"ENJOJTUSBDJØO/$PM
$PQJMDP6OJWFSTJEBE$JVEBEEF.ÏYJDP
0USB%FQFOEFODJB(VCFSOBNFOUBM%'
5FM
PERSPETIVADELABIOETICAINDD
'BDVMUBE.FYJDBOBEF.FEJDJOB
"DBEFNJB.FYJDBOBEF#JPÏUJDB"$
Z"W4BO'FSOBOEP5MBMQBO
'-"$&*4-BUJO"NFSJDBO'PSVNPG
&UIJDT$PNNJUUFFTJO)FBMUI3FTFBSDI
5FMGBY
IUUQXXXnBDFJTPSH
6OJWFSTJEBE"OBIVBD'BDVMUBEEF#JPÏUJDB
"W-PNBT"OÈIVBDTO-PNBT
"OÈIVBD.ÏYJDP$1
5FM
&YU
IUUQXXXBOBIVBDNYCJPFUJDB
PKNBSUJO!BOBIVBDNY
6OJWFSTJEBEEF(VBOBKVBUP$FOUSPEF
*OWFTUJHBDJPOFTFO#JPÏUJDB
EF&OFSP$PMPOJB0CSFHØO
(VBOBKVBUP*OTUJUVDJØO&EVDBUJWB
-FØO
5FM
/6&7";&-"/%"
.JOJTUSZPG)FBMUI/BUJPOBM&UIJDT
$PNNJUUFFPO"TTJTUFE)VNBO
3FQSPEVDUJPO/&$")3
.PMFTXPSUI4U10#PY
8FMMJOHUPO
5FM'BY
IUUQXXXOFXIFBMUIHPWUO[OFDBIS
IUN
6OJWFSTJUZPG0UBHP#JPFUIJDT3FTFBSDI
$FOUSF
10#PY%VOFEJO
5FM'BY
IUUQCJPFUIJDTPUBHPBDO[
CJPFUIJDT!PUBHPBDO[
/036&("
#JPUFDLOPMPHJOFNOEB/PSXFHJBO
#JPUFDIOPMPHZ"EWJTPSZ#PBSE
1SJOTFOTHU#PLT4FOUSVN
0TMP
5FM'BY
IUUQXXXCJPOOP
CJPUFLOPMPHJOFNOEB!CJPOOP
"QÏOEJDFT
/BUJPOBM$PNNJUUFFGPS.FEJDBM
3FTFBSDI&UIJDT/&./BUJPOBM
$PNNJUUFFTGPS3FTFBSDI&UIJDT
1SJOTFOTHBUF10#PY4FOUSVN
/0TMP
5FM'BY
IUUQXXXFUJLLPNOP&OHFMTL/&.
QPTU!FUJLLPNOPLOVUSVZUFS!FUJLLPN
OP
/BUJPOBM$PNNJUUFFGPS3FTFBSDI&UIJDT
JO4DJFODFBOE5FDIOPMPHZ/&/5
/BUJPOBM$PNNJUUFFTGPS3FTFBSDI&UIJDT
1SJOTFOTHBUF10#PY4FOUSVN
/0TMP
5FM'BY
IUUQXXXFUJLLPNOP&OHFMTL/&/5
QPTU!FUJLLPNOPNBUUIJBT
LBJTFS!FUJLLPNOP
/BUJPOBM$PNNJUUFFGPS3FTFBSDI
&UIJDTJOUIF4PDJBM4DJFODFTBOE
UIF)VNBOJUJFT/&4)/BUJPOBM
$PNNJUUFFTGPS3FTFBSDI&UIJDT
1SJOTFOTHBUF10#PY4FOUSVN
/0TMP
5FM'BY
IUUQXXXFUJLLPNOP&OHFMTL/&4)
&NBJMQPTU!FUJLLPNOPIJMEF
OBHFMM!FUJLLPNOP
/PSXFHJBO#JPUFDIOPMPHZ"EWJTPSZ
#PBSE#JPUFLOPMPHJOFNOEB
1SJOTFOTHU#PLT4FOUSVN
0TMP
5FM'BY
IUUQXXXCJPOOP
CJPUFLOPMPHJOFNOEB!CJPOOP
6OJWFSTJUZPG0TMP4FOUFSGPS.FEJTJOTL
&UJLL$FOUFSGPS.FEJDBM&UIJDT
1PTUCPLT#MJOEFSO0TMP
5FM'BY
IUUQXXXNFEVJPOPJBTBNTNF
KITPMCBLL!NFEFUJLLVJPOP
1"¶4&4#"+04
$FOUSVNWPPS.FEJTDIF&UIJFL$FOUSF
GPS.FEJDBM&UIJDT
1SPG%S("
PERSPETIVADELABIOETICAINDD
-JOEFCPPN*OTUJUVU
1PTUCVT10#PY
/-
#&&EF
5FM'BY
IUUQXXXMJOEFCPPNJOTUJUVVUOM
MJOEJOTU!DIFOM
&VSPQFBO"TTPDJBUJPOPG$FOUSFTPG
.FEJDBM&UIJDT&"$.&
"TTPDJBUJPO
&VSPQÏFOOFEFT$FOUSFTE²UIJRVF
.FEJDBMF
DP.ST"OHFMJRVF)FJKOFO*OTUJUVVU
WPPS
(F[POEIFJETFUIJFL
10#PY.%.BBTUSJDIU
5FM'BY
IUUQXXXFBDNFXFCDPN
TFDSFUBSJBBUJHF!JHFVOJNBBTOM
)FBMUI$PVODJM4UBOEJOH$PNNJUUFF
PO.FEJDBM&UIJDTBOE)FBMUI-BX
10#PY##ɨF)BHVF
5FM'BY
IUUQXXXHSOM
XKEPOEPSQ!HSOM%S8+%POEPSQ
*OUFSOBUJPOBM"TTPDJBUJPOPG#JPFUIJDT
*"#
6USFDIU6OJWFSTJUZ$FOUSFGPS#JPFUIJDT
BOE)FBMUI-BX
)FJEFMCFSHMBBO$46USFDIU
5FM'BY
*"#!UIFPVVOMNNPMFOLBNQ!UIFP
VVOM
6OJWFSTJUZ.FEJDBM$FOUSF/JKNFHFO
%FQBSUNFOUPG&UIJDT1IJMPTPQIZBOE
)JTUPSZPG.FEJDJOF
10#PY&'(
)#
/JKNFHFO)#
5FM'BY
IUUQXXXVNDOOMTDJFOUJTU
TFDSFUBSJBBU!FGHVNDOOM
6USFDIU6OJWFSTJUZ$FOUSVNWPPS#JP
&UIJFLFO(F[POEIFJETSFDIU$FOUFSGPS
#JP&UIJDTBOE)FBMUI-BX
1FSTQFDUJWBTEFMB#JPÏUJDBFO*CFSPBNÏSJDB
)FJEFMCFSHMBBO1PTUCVT/-
$46USFDIU
5FM'BY
IUUQXXXFUIJDTVVOM
DCH!UIFPVVOM
1"/".«
'FEFSBDJØO-BUJOPBNFSJDBOBZEFM
$BSJCFEF*OTUJUVDJPOFTEF#JPÏUJDB
'&-"*#&
1JTP0mDJOB
5FM
5FMFGBY
IUUQXXXGFMBJCFPSH
'&-"*#&!DXQBOBNBOFU
1&3Á
*OTUJUVUPEF.FEJDJOB-FHBMi-FPOJEBT
"WFOEB×P6SFUBw
%JSFDDJØO&TRVJOBEF"W3BZNPOEJ
DPO"W1BTFPEFMB3FQÞCMJDBTJO/¡-B
7JDUPSJB-JNB
5FM'BY
IUUQXXXNQGOHPCQFJNM
EFDMJG!ZBIPPFT
6OJWFSTJEBE/BDJPOBM.BZPSEF4BO
.BSDPT'BDVMUBEEF.FEJDJOB$PNJUÏ
EF²UJDBFO*OWFTUJHBDJØO
"W(SBV-JNB
5FM"Y
QFSBMFTBMCFSUP!UFSSBDPNQF
6OJWFSTJEBE/BDJPOBM.BZPSEF4BO
.BSDPT'BDVMUBEEF.FEJDJOB*OTUJUVUP
EF²UJDBFO4BMVE
"W(SBV-JNB
5FM"Y
QFSBMFTBMCFSUP!UFSSBDPNQF
6OJWFSTJEBE1FSVBOB$BZFUBOP)FSFEJB
'BDVMUBEEF.FEJDJOB6OJEBEEF
#JPÏUJDB
"W)POPSJP%FMHBEP6SC
*OHFOJFSÓB4.1-JNB1FSÞ
5FM
BOFYP
IUUQXXXVQDIFEVQFGBNFEBDFSDB
QSFTFOUBDJPOBTQ
!VQDIFEVQF
PERSPETIVADELABIOETICAINDD
10356("-
$POTFMIP/BDJPOBMEF&UJDBQBSBBT
$JFODJBTEB7JEB/BUJPOBM&UIJDBM
$PVODJMGPSUIF-JGF4DJFODFT
3VB1SPGFTTPS(PNFT5FJYFJSB/
-JTCPB
5FM'BY
IUUQXXXDOFDWHPWQU$/&$7
4JUF&OUSZ
DOFDW!THQDNHPWQU
3&*/06/*%0
#SJUJTI.FEJDBM"TTPDJBUJPO.FEJDBM
&UIJDT$PNNJUUFF
#.")PVTF5BWJTUPDL4RVBSF-POEPO
8$)+1
5FM'BY
IUUQXXXCNBPSHVLBQOTG
$POUFOU@@)VCFUIJDT
JOGPXFC!CNBPSHVL
$FOUSBM0GGJDFGPS3FTFBSDI&UIJDT
$PNNJUUFFT$03&$
3PPN##MPDL&BTUCPVSOF
5FSSBDF-POEPO823
5FM'BY
IUUQXXXDPSFDPSHVL
RVFSJFT!DPSFDPSHVL
$FOUSFGPS#JPFUIJDTBOE1VCMJD1PMJDZ
$#11
3PNOFZ4USFFU-POEPO4813'
5FM
IUUQXXXCJPFUIJDTBDVL
mPOBHSFHTPO!CJPFUIJDTBDVL
$&3&4$POTVNFSTGPS&UIJDTJO
3FTFBSDI
10#PY-POEPO/#8
5FM
IUUQXXXDFSFTPSHVL
JOGP!DFSFTPSHVL
$ISJTUJBO.FEJDBM'FMMPXTIJQ$.'
1BSUOFSTIJQ)PVTF8BUFSMPP3PBE
-POEPO4&9/
5FM'BY
"QÏOEJDFT
IUUQXXXDNGPSHVL
BENJO!DNGPSHVLJOGP!DNGPSHVL
)VNBO'FSUJMJTBUJPOBOE&NCSZPMPHZ
"VUIPSJUZ)'&"
1BYUPO)PVTF"SUJMMFSZ-BOF
-POEPO&-4
5FM'BY
IUUQXXXIGFBHPWVL)PNF
BENJO!IGFBHPWVL
,JOHT$PMMFHF-POEPO,$-
$FOUSFPG
.FEJDBM-BXBOE&UIJDT
4USBOE-POEPO8$3-4
5FM'BY
IUUQXXXLDMBDVLEFQTUBMBX
SFTFBSDIDNMF
DNMFFOH!LDMBDVL
-BODBTUFS6OJWFSTJUZ'VSOFTT$PMMFHF
*OTUJUVUFGPS&OWJSPONFOU1IJMPTPQIZ
BOE1VCMJD1PMJDZ*&111
-BODBTUFS-":(
5FM'BY
IUUQXXXMBODTBDVLGTTJFQQQJOEFY
IUN
KQFBSDZ!MBODBTUFSBDVL
DEVOEBT!MBODBTUFSBDVL
OQBSLFS!MBODBTUFSBDVL
-JOBDSF$FOUSFGPS)FBMUI$BSF&UIJDT
(SPWF&OE3PBE4U+PIOT8PPE
-POEPO/8/)
5FM
IUUQXXXMJOBDSFPSH
BENJO!MJOBDSFPSHEJSFDUPS!MJOBDSFPSH
/VGGJFME$PVODJMPO#JPFUIJDT
#FEGPSE4RVBSF-POEPO8$#+4
5FM'BY
IUUQXXXOVċFMECJPFUIJDTPSH
CJPFUIJDT!OVċFMEGPVOEBUJPOPSH
4FDSFUBSJBU%FQBSUNFOUPG)FBMUI6,
9FOPUSBOTQMBOUBUJPO*OUFSJN3FHVMBUPSZ
"VUIPSJUZ6,9*3"
3PPN8FMMJOHUPO)PVTF
8BUFSMPP3PBE-POEPO4&6(
PERSPETIVADELABIOETICAINDD
5FM'BY
EINBJM!EPIHTJHPWVL.BLFJUDMFBS
UIBUNFTTBHFJTGPS6,9*3"
6OJWFSTJUZPG-JWFSQPPM-JWFSQPPM-BX
4DIPPM*OTUJUVUFPG.FEJDJOF-BXBOE
#JPFUIJDT*.-"#
-JWFSQPPM-;4
5FM'BY
IUUQXXXMJWBDVLMBXVOJUTJNMBCIUN
MBX!MJWFSQPPMBDVL
6OJWFSTJUZPG.BODIFTUFS$FOUSFGPS
4PDJBM&UIJDTBOE1PMJDZ
0YGPSE3PBE.BODIFTUFS.15FM
IUUQXXXMBXNBODIFTUFSBDVL
SFTFBSDIDTFQIUN
HFNNBHSJNTIBX!NBOBDVL
6OJWFSTJUZPG0YGPSE*OTUJUVUFPG)FBMUI
4DJFODFT0YGPSE$FOUSFGPS&UIJDTBOE
$PNNVOJDBUJPOJO)FBMUI$BSF1SBDUJDF
ɨF&UIPY$FOUSF
0ME3PBE0YGPSE09-'
5FM'BY
IUUQXXXFUIPYPSHVL
BENJO!FUIPYPYBDVL
4*/("163
#JPFUIJDT"EWJTPSZ$PNNJUUFF#"$
#JPQPMJT8BZ$FOUSPT
'BY
IUUQXXXCJPFUIJDTTJOHBQPSFPSH
DPOUBDUVT!CJPFUIJDTTJOHBQPSFPSH
.JOJTUSZPG)FBMUI$PMMFHFPG.FEJDJOF
/BUJPOBM.FEJDBM&UIJDT$PNNJUUFF
/.&$
#VJMEJOH$PMMFHF3PBE
5FM'BY
1SFEFFCIB@,BOOBO!NPIHPWTH%S
1SFEFFCIB,BOOBO
46%«'3*$"
.FEJDBM3FTFBSDI$PVODJMPG4PVUI
"GSJDB
10#PY5ZHFSCFSH
1FSTQFDUJWBTEFMB#JPÏUJDBFO*CFSPBNÏSJDB
5FM'BY
IUUQXXXNSDBD[BFUIJDT
FUIJDTIVNBOIUN
JOGP!NSDBD[B
4UPDLIPMN
5FM'BY
IUUQXXXHFOUFLOJLTF
HFOUFLOJL!HFOUFLOJLTF
6OJWFSTJUZPG$BQFUPXO%FQBSUNFOUPG
.FEJDJOF#JPFUIJDT$FOUSF
+'MPPS0ME.BJO#VJMEJOH(SPPUF
4DIVVS)PTQJUBM$BQF5PXO
0CTFSWBUPSZ
5FM'BY
IUUQXFCVDUBD[BEFQUTNFEJDJOF
NBJOCJPFUIJDTIUN
DEFLPLFS!VDUHTIVDUBD[B
4XFEJTI/BUJPOBM$PVODJMPO.FEJDBM
&UIJDT4.&3
4UBUFOT.FEJDJOTL
&UJTLB3BE.JOJTUSZPG)FBMUIBOE4PDJBM
"ĊBJST
4&4UPDLIPMN
5FM
IUUQXXXTNFSHPWTF
BOODIBSMPUUFTNFEMFS!TPDJBMNJOJTUSZTF
MPUUBFSJLTTPO!TPDJBMNJOJTUSZTF
46&$*"
(PUFCPSH6OJWFSTJUZ$FOUSFGPS
3FTFBSDI&UIJDT$FOUSVNGPS
'PSTLOJOHTFUJL
#PY(PUFCPSH
5FM'BY
TXFMJO!DSFHVTF4UFMMBO8FMJO
FIBHCFSH!DSFHVTF&JOB)BHCFSH
-VOE6OJWFSTJUZ&OIFUFOGPS.FEJDJOTL
&UJL%FQBSUNFOUPG.FEJDBM&UIJDT
4UPSB(SBCSPEFSTHBUBO)44&
-VOE
5FM'BY
IUUQXXXNFEFUJLMVTF
*MHB-JMKFOCFSH!NFEFUJLMVTF
CJCMJPUFLFU!NFEFUJLMVTF
.JOJTUSZPG)FBMUIBOE4PDJBM"ĊBJST
4UBUFOT.FEJDJOTL&UJTLB3BE4.&3
4XFEJTI/BUJPOBM$PVODJMPO.FEJDBM
&UIJDT
44UPDLIPMN
5FM'BY
IUUQXXXTNFSHPWTF
MPUUBFSJLTTPO!TPDJBMNJOJTUSZTFCJSHJUUB
TKPP!TPDJBMNJOJTUSZTF
4XFEJTI(FOF5FDIOPMPHZ"EWJTPSZ
#PBSE
(FOUFLOJLOBNOEFO3FU[JVTWBH"
PERSPETIVADELABIOETICAINDD
6QQTBMB6OJWFSTJUFU%FQBSUNFOUPG
1VCMJD)FBMUIBOE$BSJOH3FTFBSDI
1SPHSBN&UIJDTJO#JPNFEJDJOF
4&6QQTBMB
5FM'BY
IUUQXXXCJPFUIJDTVVTF
JOGP!CJPFUIJDTVVTF
46*;"
$PVODJMGPS*OUFSOBUJPOBM0SHBOJ[BUJPOT
PG.FEJDBM4DJFODFT$*0.4
DP8PSME)FBMUI0SHBOJ[BUJPO
$)(FOFWB
5FM
'BY
IUUQXXXDJPNTDI
DJPNT!XIPJOU
4PDJÏUÏ4VJTTFE²UIJRVF#JPNFEJDBMF
4DIXFJ[FSJTDIF(FTFMMTDIBGUGàS
#JPNFEJ[JOJTDIF&UIJL
44&#4(#&
4FLSFUBSJBU4(#&44&#3&)"##BTFM
1PTUGBDI$)#BTFM
5FM'BY
IUUQXXXCJPFUIJDTDIDPOUFOUEFGBVMU
IUN
TTFC!CJPFUIJDTDI
4XJTT/BUJPOBM"EWJTPSZ$PNNJTTJPO
PO#JPNFEJDBM&UIJDT
DP4XJTT'FEFSBM0ċDFPG1VCMJD)FBMUI
#FSOF
"QÏOEJDFT
5FM'BY
IUUQXXXOFLDOFDI
OFLDOF!CBHBENJODI
6OJUFÏEF3FDIFSDIFFUE&OTFJHOFNFOU
FO#JPFUIJRVF$FOUSF.FEJDBM
6OJWFSTJUBJSF
3VF.JDIFM4FSWFU(FOFWF
5FM'BY
8PSME)FBMUI0SHBOJ[BUJPO8)0
&UIJDTBOE)FBMUI&5)
"WFOVF"QQJB(FOFWB
5FM'BY
IUUQXXXXIPJOUFUIJDTFO
JOG!XIPJOU
5"*-"/%*"
"4&"/*OTUJUVUFGPS)FBMUI
%FWFMPQNFOU"*)%
.BIJEPM
6OJWFSTJUZBU4BMBZB$FOUFSGPS
#JPFUIJDT3FTFBSDI
1IVUUIBNPOUIPO/BLIPSO1BUIPN
5FMT
'BY
EJSFDUBE!NBIJEPMBDUIBETMT!NBIJEPM
BDUI
6OJWFSTJUZ3BOHTJU$BNQVT)FBMUI
4DJFODF$FOUFS'BDVMUZPG"MMJFE)FBMUI
4DJFODFT'PSVNGPS&UIJDBM3FWJFX
$PNNJUUFFTJO"TJBOBOE8FTUFSO
PERSPETIVADELABIOETICAINDD
1BDJGJD3FHJPO'&3$"1
1BIPMZPUIJO3PBE,MPOH-VBOH
1SBUVNUBOFF
5FM'BY
IUUQXXXGFSDBQTJEDFSPSHIPNFBTQ
OLFTBSB!UVBDUIOLFTBSB!IPUNBJMDPN
56326¶"
#JPFUIJDT"E)PD$PNNJUUFFGPSUIF
5VSLJTI/BUJPOBM$PNNJTTJPOGPS
6/&4$0
#JZPFUJL:IUJTBT,PNJUFTJ
(PSFNF4PLBL,BWBLMJEFSF
"OLBSB
5FM
'BY
IUUQXXXVOFTDPPSHUS
XFCNBTUFS!VOFTDPPSHUS
636(6":
6OJWFSTJEBE$BUPMJDBEFM6SVHVBZ
'BDVMUBEEF$JFODJBT)VNBOBT*OTUJUVUP
EF#JPÏUJDB
"WEF0DUVCSF/P
.POUFWJEFP$1
5FMJOU'BY
FUJDB!VDVFEVVZ
7&/&;6&-"
&TDVFMBEF&OGFSNFSÓB
$FOUSP/BDJPOBMEF#JPÏUJDB
6SC4FCVDÈOTVCJFOEPQPSMB"W
1SJODJQBM"W.JHVFM0UFSP4JMWB1JTP
$BSBDBT
5FM
PERSPETIVADELABIOETICAINDD
4FMFDDJØOEFQVCMJDBDJPOFTQFSJØEJDBTEFCJPÏUJDB
"DUB#JPFUIJDB3FWJTUBEFM1SPHSBNBEF
#JPÏUJDB 0140.4 4BOUJBHP EF $IJ
MF *44/ *NQSFTP *44/
&O MÓOFB 9 %JTQPOJCMF FO
IUUQXXXQBIPPSH4QBOJTICJPQV
CMJDBIUN
"NFSJDBO +PVSOBM PG #JPFUIJDT 5BZMPS
BOE 'SBODJT (SPVQ #JPFUIJDT &EV
DBUJPO /FUXPSL &EJUFE JO UIF "MEFO
.BSDI #JPFUIJDT *OTUJUVUF PG "MCBOZ
.FEJDBM $FOUFS 6OJUFE 4UBUFT *44/
"WBJMBCMF BU IUUQXXX
CJPFUIJDTOFUKPVSOBM
"ST.FEJDB3FWJTUBEF&TUVEJPT.ÏEJ
DPT )VNBOÓTUJDPT 1POUJmDJB 6OJWFSTJ
EBE$BUØMJDB4BOUJBHPEF$IJMF*44/
%JTQPOJCMFFOIUUQFTDVF
MBNFEQVDDMQVCM"ST.FEJDB"ST
.FEJDBIUNM
#JPFUIJDT +PVSOBM PG UIF *OUFSOBUJPOBM
"TTPDJBUJPO PG #JPFUIJDT &EJUFE CZ
3VUI $IBEXJDL BOE 6EP 4DIàLMFOL
"WBJMBCMF BU IUUQXXXCMBDLXFMMQV
CMJTIJOHDPNKPVSOBMT#*0&5)*$4
#JPFUIJDT#VMMFUJO6OJWFSTJUZPG#VĊBMP
$FOUFSGPS$MJOJDBM&UIJDTBOE)VNBOJ
UJFTJO)FBMUI$BSF/FX:PSL6OJUFE
4UBUFT "WBJMBCMF BU IUUQXXXXJOHT
CVĊBMPFEVGBDVMUZSFTFBSDICJPFUIJDT
OFXTIUNM
#JPÏUJDB3FWJTUBEF#JPÏUJDBF²UJDB.Ï
EJDBQVCMJDBEBQFMP$POTFMIP'FEFSBM
EF.FEJDJOB4("4o-PUF#SB
TÓMJB%'$&1
%JTQPOJCMFFOIUUQXXXDGNPSHCS
PERSPETIVADELABIOETICAINDD
#JPÏUJDB %FCBU 6OJWFSTJUBU 3BNØO
-MVMM$BUBMV×B&TQB×B%JTQPOJCMFFO
IUUQXXXCJPFUJDBEFCBUPSH
FNBJMSFWJTUBCJPFUJDB!HXDGNPSHCS
#JPÏUJDB 4FMFDDJPOFT 6OJWFSTJEBE +BWF
SJBOB$PMPNCJB%JTQPOJCMFFOXXX
KBWFSJBOBFEVDPCJPFUJDBQVCMJDBDJP
OFT@SFWJTUBTIUN
#JPNFEJDBM&UIJDT/FXTMFUUFSPGɨF&V
SPQFBO/FUXPSLGPS#JPNFEJDBM&UIJDT
*OUFSGBLVMUÊSFT ;FOUSVN GàS &UIJL JO
EFO 8JTTFOTDIBGUFO PG UIF 6OJWFSTJUZ
PG 5àCJOHFO (FSNBOZ *44/ #VMMFUJO PG .FEJDBM &UIJDT 3PZBM 4PDJF
UZ PG .FEJDJOF 1SFTT -POEPO 6OJUFE
,JOHEPN*44/"WBJMBCMFBU
IUUQXXXCVMMNFEFUIJOGPDVSSFOU
IUN
$BNCSJEHF 2VBSUFSMZ PG )FBMUIDBSF
&UIJDT ɨF *OUFSOBUJPOBM +PVSOBM GPS
)FBMUIDBSF&UIJDTBOE&UIJDT$PNNJU
UFFT &EJUFE CZ ɨPNBTJOF ,VTIOFS
6OJWFSTJUZPG$BMJGPSOJB#FSLFMFZ64"
Z4UFWF)FJMJH4BO'SBODJTDP.FEJDBM
$FOUFS 6OJUFE 4UBUFT 1SJOU *44/
0OMJOF *44/ "WBJMBCMFBUIUUQKPVSOBMTDBNCSJEHF
PSHBDUJPOEJTQMBZ+PVSOBM KJE$2)
$VBEFSOPTEF#JPÏUJDB&EJUPSJBM"E)PD
"SHFOUJOB *44/ %JTQPOJ
CMF FO IUUQXXXDVBEFSOPTCJPFUJDB
PSH
1FSTQFDUJWBTEFMB#JPÏUJDBFO*CFSPBNÏSJDB
&UIJDT.FEJDJOF"O*OUFSOBUJPOBM+P
VSOBM PG #JPFUIJDT ɨF #JPFUIJDT 1SFTT
*MMJOPJT 6OJUFE 4UBUFT "WBJMB
CMF BU IUUQXXXFUIJDTBOENFEJDJOF
DPN
&VCJPT +PVSOBM PG "TJBO BOE *OUFSOBUJP
OBM#JPFUIJDT&+"*#
"TJBO#JPFUIJDT
"TTPDJBUJPO +BQBO *44/ "WBJMBCMF BU IUUQXXXVOFTDPCLL
PSHJOEFYQIQ JE^
)BTUJOHT $FOUFS 3FQPSU )BTUJOHT $FO
UFS /FX :PSL 6OJUFE 4UBUFT *44/
"WBJMBCMF BU IUUQXXX
UIFIBTUJOHTDFOUFSPSHQVCMJDBUJPOTIDS
IDSBTQ
)FBMUI.BUSJY+PVSOBMPG-BX.FEJDJOF
'MPSJEB 4UBUF 6OJWFSTJUZ -BX 3FWJFX
6OJUFE 4UBUFT "WBJMBCMF BU IUUQMBX
DBTFFEVTUVEFOU@MJGFKPVSOBMTIFBMUI@
NBUSJYEFGBVMUIUN
)VNBO3FTFBSDI3FQPSU%FFN$PSQP
SBUJPO0NBIB/FCSBTLB6OJUFE4UB
UFT"WBJMBCMFBUIUUQXXXIVNBOSF
TFBSDISFQPSUDPN
*OWFTUJHBDJØO $MÓOJDB Z #JPÏUJDB 4PDJF
EBE&TQB×PMBEF'BSNBDPMPHÓB$MÓOJDB
&TQB×B*44/%JTQPOJCMF
FOIUUQXXXJDGVBCFTJDCEJHJUBM
*3# &UIJDT )VNBO 3FTFBSDI )BT
UJOHT$FOUFS/FX:PSL6OJUFE4UBUFT
*44/ "WBJMBCMF BU IUUQ
XXXUIFIBTUJOHTDFOUFSPSHQVCMJDBUJP
OTJSCJSCBTQ
+PVSOBM PG $MJOJDBM &UIJDT )BHFSTUPXO
.BSZMBOE6OJUFE4UBUFT*44/
"WBJMBCMFBUIUUQXXXDMJOJDB
MFUIJDTDPN
+PVSOBM PG -BX .FEJDJOF &UIJDT
"NFSJDBO 4PDJFUZ PG -BX .FEJDJOF
&UIJDT 6OJUFE 4UBUFT "WBJMBCMF BU
IUUQXXXBTMNFPSHQVCKMNF
+PVSOBM PG .FEJDBM &UIJDT #.+ 1VCMJT
IJOH(SPVQBOEUIF*OTUJUVUFPG.FEJDBM
PERSPETIVADELABIOETICAINDD
&UIJDT 6OJUFE ,JOHEPN 1SJOU *44/
0OMJOF"WBJ
MBCMFBUIUUQKNFCNKKPVSOBMTDPN
,FOOFEZ *OTUJUVUF PG &UIJDT +PVSOBM +P
IOT )PQLJOT 6OJWFSTJUZ 1SFTT ,FO
OFEZ *OTUJUVUF PG &UIJDT (FPSHFUPXO
6OJWFSTJUZ8BTIJOHUPO6OJUFE4UBUFT
1SJOU*44/0OMJOF*44/
"WBJMBCMF BU IUUQNVTF
KIVFEVKPVSOBMTLFOOFEZ@JOTUJUVUF@
PG@FUIJDT@KPVSOBM
.FEJDBM )VNBOJUJFT #.+ 1VCMJTIJOH
(SPVQ BOE UIF *OTUJUVUF PG .FEJDBM
&UIJDT 6OJUFE ,JOHEPN 1SJOU *44/
90OMJOF"WBJ
MBCMFBUIUUQKNFCNKKPVSOBMTDPN
.FEJDJOBZ²UJDB6OJWFSTJEBEEF"OB
IVBD .ÏYJDP *44/ %JT
QPOJCMF FO IUUQXXXBOBIVBDNY
DPOUFOJEPTIUNM
/VSTJOH &UIJDT "SOPME &E 6OJUFE
,JOHEPO 1SJOU *44/ 0OMJOF*44/"WBJMBCMFBU
IUUQXXXBSOPMEQVCMJTIFSTDPNKP
VSOBMTQBHFTOVS@FUIIUN
1FSTPOB Z #JPÏUJDB 6OJWFSTJEBE EF MB
4BCBOB $PMPNCJB *44/ %JTQPOJCMF FO IUUQHFNNBVOJTB
CBOBFEVDPQVCMJDBDJPOFTQTJOPQTJT
BTQ JE
3FWJTUB $VBEFSOPT EF #JPÏUJDB "TPDJB
DJØO&TQB×PMBEF#JPÏUJDBZ²UJDB.ÏEJ
DB&TQB×B*44/%JTQPOJ
CMFFOIUUQXXXBFCJPFUJDBPSH
3FWJTUB EF %FSFDIP Z (FOPNB )VNB
OP 'VOEBDJØO ##7" &TQB×B *44/
%JTQPOJCMFFOIUUQXXX
EFSFDIPVOFYFTCJCMJPUFDB4VNBSJPT
HFOPNBIUN
3FWJTUB -BUJOPBNFSJDBOB EF #JPÏUJDB
&EJUBEB QPS FM 1SPHSBNB EF #JPÏUJDB
%FQBSUBNFOUPEF&EVDBDJØO)VNBOJ
EBEFT&TUVEJPT"WBO[BEPTZ1SPHSBNBT
&TQFDJBMFT EF MB 6OJWFSTJEBE .JMJUBS
"QÏOEJDFT
i/VFWB(SBOBEBw$BSSFSB/
#PHPUÈ $PMPNCJB %JTQPOJCMF FO
IUUQXXXVNOHFEVDPXXXTFD
UJPOKTQ
FNBJMSFWCJP!VNOHFEVDP
3FWJTUB1FSTQFDUJWBTEF#JPÏUJDB'BDVMUBE
-BUJOPBNFSJDBOB EF $JFODJBT 4PDJBMFT
'-"$40
"SHFOUJOB *44/ %JTQPOJCMF FO IUUQXXX
nBDTPPSHBSBSFBTZQSPZFDUPTQSPZFDUPT
QCSFWJTUBKTQ
3FWJTUB 2VJSØO *OTUJUVUP EF #JPÏUJDB Z
)VNBOJEBEFT.ÏEJDBT'VOEBDJØO%S
+PTÏ..BJOFUUJQBSBFM1SPHSFTPEFMB
.FEJDJOB $0&"SHFOUJOB%JTQPOJ
CMF FO XXXGVOEBDJPONBJOFUUJDPN
BSCJPFUJDBIUN
3FWJTUB 4*#* 'VOEBDJØO 4PDJFEBE *O
UFSOBDJPOBMEF#JPÏUJDB&TQB×B*44/
%JTQPOJCMFFOIUUQXXXTJCJPSH
4PDJBM4DJFODF.FEJDJOF&MTFWJFS-UE
/FUIFSMBOET *44/ "WBJ
PERSPETIVADELABIOETICAINDD
MBCMFBUIUUQXXXTDJFODFEJSFDUDPN
TDJFODFKPVSOBM
4VNNB #JPÏUJDB EJTDPOUJOVBEB
$P
NJTJØO /BDJPOBM EF #JPÏUJDB EF .ÏYJ
DP *44/ %JTQPOJCMF FO
IUUQCJPFUJDBTBMVEHPCNYSFWJTUB
IUNM
DzFPSFUJDBM.FEJDJOFBOE#JPFUIJDT1IJ
MPTPQIZPG.FEJDBM3FTFBSDIBOE1SBDUJDF
4QSJOHFS 4DJFODF #VTJOFTT .FEJB
#7 /FUIFSMBOET 1SJOU *44/ 0OMJOF"WBJMBCMFBU
IUUQXXXTQSJOHFSMJOLDPN
7JEB Z ²UJDB *OTUJUVUP EF #JPÏUJDB 'B
DVMUBEEF$JFODJBT.FEJDBT6$""S
HFOUJOB %JTQPOJCMF FO IUUQXXX
VDBFEVBSFTQTFDCJPFUJDBFTQQBHF
QIQ TVCTFDQVCMJDBDJPOFT
:BMF+PVSOBMPG)FBMUI1PMJDZ-BXBOE
&UIJDT :BMF 6OJWFSTJUZ /FX )BWFO
$POOFDUJDVU 6OJUFE 4UBUFT "WBJMBCMF
BUIUUQXXXZBMFFEVZKIQMF
PERSPETIVADELABIOETICAINDD
1VCMJDBDJPOFTEFM1SPHSBNBEF#JPÏUJDB0140.4
"DUB#JPFUIJDB
)BTUB MB QVCMJDBDJØO PmDJBM EFM
1SPHSBNB 3FHJPOBM EF #JPÏUJDB QBSB
"NÏSJDB-BUJOBZFM$BSJCFFSB$VBEFS
OPTEFM1SPHSBNB3FHJPOBMEF#JPFUJDB-B
SFWJTUB TFNFTUSBM "DUB #JPFUIJDB *44/
FT EFTEF MB DPOUJ
OVBEPSB EF MPT $VBEFSOPT $POTUJUVZF
VOB GVFOUF QMVSBMJTUB EF QFSTQFDUJWBT Z
USJCVOBRVFBDPHFMBTDPOUSJCVDJPOFTEF
DBMJmDBEPTBVUPSFT DPNQSPNFUJEPTDPO
MBFNQSFTBCJPÏUJDB
-PT OÞNFSPT EF FTUB SFWJTUB FTUÈO
EJTQPOJCMFTFOGPSNBUP1%'FOIUUQ
XXXQBIPPSH4QBOJTICJPQVCMJDB
IUN Z FO 4DJFOUJmD &MFDUSPOJD -JCSBSZ
0OMJOF4DJ&-0IUUQXXXTDJFMPDM
"×P 7PM /¡ 5ÓUVMP
7*
$VJEBEPT1BMJBUJWPTZ
#JPÏUJDB
7*
1FSTQFDUJWBT#JPÏUJDBTZ
1VCMJDBDJPOFT#JPNÏEJDBT
7**
&OWFKFDJNJFOUPZ$BMJEBE
EF7JEB
7**
/PDJWJEBE"NCJFOUBMZ
"MJNFOUBSJB
7***
%FCBUF²UJDPZ$JFODJBT
4PDJBMFT
7***
*9
*9
%FSFDIPZ#JPÏUJDB
#JPUFDOPMPHÓBZ²UJDB
#JPÏUJDBZ4BMVE1ÞCMJDB
#JPÏUJDBF*OWFTUJHBDJØOFO
4FSFT)VNBOPT
9
PERSPETIVADELABIOETICAINDD
9
9*
#JPÏUJDBZ(FOØNJDB
1PMÓUJDBT1ÞCMJDBT
9*
5FDOPMPHÓBTEFMB
*OGPSNBDJØO
9**
#JPÏUJDBZ
0EPOUPFTUPNBUPMPHÓB
9**
#JPÏUJDBZ(ÏOFSP
9***
&YQFSJNFOUBDJØODPO
"OJNBMFTZ#JPÏUJDB
#JPÏUJDB*OGPSNB
#PMFUÓORVFBQBSFDFUSFTWFDFTFOFMB×PZ
RVFEJGVOEFBHFOEBEFBDUJWJEBEFTQV
CMJDBDJPOFTFJOGPSNBDJØOEFMBDPOUFDFS
CJPÏUJDPEFMPTQBÓTFTEF-BUJOPBNÏSJDB
ZFM$BSJCF*44/
%JTQP
OJCMF EFTEF FM OÞNFSP DPSSFTQPO
EJFOUFBEJDJFNCSFEFFOGPSNBUP
1%'FOFMTJUJPIUUQXXXQBIPPSH
4QBOJTICJPQVCMJDBIUN
4BMVE0SBM#JPÏUJDB
#PMFUÓO BOVBM EF EJWVMHBDJØO EJSJHJEP
B MPT QSPGFTJPOBMFT EF MB 4BMVE 0SBM
FO -BUJOPBNÏSJDB JOUFSFTBEPT FO MB
JOUFSSFMBDJØOFOUSFDJFODJBJOWFTUJHBDJØO
ZTFSWJDJPBMBDPNVOJEBEUFOJFOEPBMB
CJPÏUJDBDPNPJOUÏSQSFUF*44/
&TFMBCPSBEPFODPOKVOUPDPOFM
$FOUSP*OUFSEJTDJQMJOBSJPEF&TUVEJPTFO
#JPÏUJDBEFMB6OJWFSTJEBEEF$IJMF4F
FODVFOUSBOEJTQPOJCMFTTVTEPTQSJNFSPT
OÞNFSPT FO FM TJUJP IUUQXXXQBIP
PSH4QBOJTICJPQVCMJDBIUN
1FSTQFDUJWBTEFMB#JPÏUJDBFO*CFSPBNÏSJDB
4FSJF1VCMJDBDJPOFT
i*OWFTUJHBDJØO FO 4VKFUPT )VNBOPT
&YQFSJFODJB *OUFSOBDJPOBM3FTFBSDI PO
)VNBO 4VCKFDUT *OUFSOBDJPOBM &YQF
SJFODFw"MCFSUP1FMMFHSJOJ'JMIPZ3VUI
.BDLMJOFEJUPSFT
*4#/
*ODMVZFMPTBSUÓDVMPTQSFTFO
UBEPTFOMBQSJNFSBSFVOJØOEFM$PNJUÏ
"TFTPS *OUFSOBDJPOBM FO #JPÏUJDB EF MB
0SHBOJ[BDJØO1BOBNFSJDBOBEFMB4BMVE
0140.4
DFMFCSBEBFOUSFFMZFM
EF NBZP EF FO 8BTIJOHUPO
%$
i#JPÏUJDBZ$VJEBEPEFMB4BMVE&RVJ
EBE $BMJEBE %FSFDIPTw 'FSOBOEP
-PMBT 4UFQLF FEJUPS
*4#/
1POFODJBT EF BMHVOPT
QBSUJDJQBOUFTFOMBTFHVOEBSFVOJØOEFM
$PNJUÏ "TFTPS *OUFSOBDJPOBM FO #JPÏ
UJDB EF MB 0SHBOJ[BDJØO 1BOBNFSJDBOB
EFMB4BMVE0140.4
SFBMJ[BEPFO
USFFMZEFNBZPEFFO$JVEBE
EF1BOBNÈ
i*OUFSGBDFT #FUXFFO #JPFUIJDT BOE UIF
&NQJSJDBM 4PDJBM 4DJFODFTw 'FSOBOEP
-PMBT4UFQLF-PSFO[P"HBS$PSCJOPT
FEJUPST
*4#/
ɨJSE .FFUJOH PG UIF *OUFSOBUJPOBM
"EWJTPSZ #PBSE PO #JPFUIJDT 1BO
"NFSJDBO)FBMUI0SHBOJ[BUJPO8PSME
)FBMUI 0SHBOJ[BUJPO 0DUPCFS OE
oUI#VFOPT"JSFT"SHFOUJOB
i1BVUBT ²UJDBT EF *OWFTUJHBDJØO FO 4V
KFUPT )VNBOPT /VFWBT 1FSTQFDUJWBTw
'FSOBOEP -PMBT 4UFQLF Z «MWBSP 2VF
[BEB 4 FEJUPSFT
*4#/ 3FFEJDJØO BNQMJBEB EF
i*OWFTUJHBDJØO FO 4VKFUPT )VNBOPT
&YQFSJFODJB *OUFSOBDJPOBMw *ODMVZF SF
nFYJPOFT Z DPNFOUBSJPT TPCSF SFWJTJØO
EF MBT i1BVUBT ²UJDBT *OUFSOBDJP
OBMFT QBSB MB *OWFTUJHBDJØO #JPNÏEJDB
FO 4FSFT )VNBOPTw $*0.4 *4#/
USBEVDDJØOEFM
UFYUP FO JOHMÏT SFBMJ[BEB QPS QSPGFTJP
OBMFTEFM1SPHSBNB3FHJPOBMEF#JPÏUJDB
0140.4
PERSPETIVADELABIOETICAINDD
i%JÈMPHPZDPPQFSBDJØOFO4BMVE%JF[
B×PTEF#JPÏUJDBFOMB014w'FSOBOEP
-PMBT 4UFQLF FEJUPS
*4#/
3FDPHFMBTQSFTFOUBDJP
OFTEFMPTJOUFHSBOUFTEFM$PNJUÏ"TFTPS
*OUFSOBDJPOBMFO#JPÏUJDBEFMB0SHBOJ
[BDJØO1BOBNFSJDBOBEFMB4BMVE014
0.4
FOTVDVBSUBSFVOJØODFMFCSBEB
DPOPDBTJØOEFMPTEJF[B×PTEFM1SPHSB
NB3FHJPOBMEF#JPÏUJDB0140.4
4FSJF&TDSJUPTEF#JPÏUJDB1VCMJDBEB
FODPOKVOUPDPOFM$FOUSP
*OUFSEJTDJQMJOBSJPEF&TUVEJPTFO
#JPÏUJDBEFMB6OJWFSTJEBEEF$IJMF
$*&#
i*OWFTUJHBDJØO FO 4BMVE %JNFOTJØO
²UJDBw 'FSOBOEP -PMBT «MWBSP 2VF
[BEB Z &EVBSEP 3PESÓHVF[ FEJUPSFT
/¡ *4#/ $PNQSFOEF MPT USBCBKPT EF VO HSV
QP EF DPMBCPSBEPSFT Z EF MPT CFDBSJPT
Z CFDBSJBT EFM 1SPHSBNB EF 'PSNBDJØO
FO²UJDBEFMB*OWFTUJHBDJØO#JPNÏEJDB
Z1TJDPTPDJBMmOBODJBEPQPSFM'PHBSUZ
*OUFSOBUJPOBM $FOUFS Z PUSPT JOTUJUVUPT
EF MPT /BUJPOBM *OTUJUVUFT PG )FBMUI EF
MPT &TUBEPT 6OJEPT Z SFBMJ[BEP QPS FM
$*&# FO 4BOUJBHP EF $IJMF FO DVBUSP
WFSTJPOFTDPOTFDVUJWBT
i²UJDB Z 0EPOUPMPHÓB 6OB *OUSPEVD
DJØOw $BSNFO $BSEP[P &EVBSEP
3PESÓHVF[ 'FSOBOEP -PMBT Z «MWBSP
2VF[BEBPSHBOJ[BEPSFT
/¡
*4#/
1VCMJDBEPTØMP
FO GPSNBUP 1%' QPS FM NPNFOUP SF
ÞOFDPOUSJCVDJPOFTEFFTQFDJBMJTUBTUBMFT
DPNP $ÏTBS "CBEÓB $BSPMJOB «MWBSF[
EF MB $BEFOB $MFNFODJB #FSNÞEF[
#MBODB #PIØSRVF[ "OB #VFOEÓB -VJT
$JPDDB $SJTUJOB %FBOHFMJMMP 'SBODZ
(BSDÓB3JOB(VFSSB3PCFSUP*SSJCBSSB
"MJDJB-PTPWJ['FSOBOEP3PNP.BSÓB
"OHÏMJDB 5PSSFT2VJOUBOB +PSHF 5SJB
OBZ$BSPMJOB7BMEFCFOJUP
"QÏOEJDFT
0USPTMJCSPTQVCMJDBEPTFO
DPMBCPSBDJØODPOFM$*&#EFMB
6OJWFSTJEBEEF$IJMF
i²UJDBF*OOPWBDJØO5FDOPMØHJDBw'FS
OBOEP -PMBT 4UFQLF FEJUPS
*4#/ *ODMVZF MBT
QSFTFOUBDJPOFTEFEFTUBDBEPTFTQFDJBMJT
UBTRVFQBSUJDJQBSPOFOMBTEPTKPSOBEBT
EFM TFNJOBSJP i²UJDB EF MB *OOPWBDJØO
5FDOPMØHJDBwSFBMJ[BEPFMEFBHPTUP
ZFMEFOPWJFNCSFEFFOFMNBS
DPEFM1SPZFDUP#JDFOUFOBSJPFO$JFODJB
Z5FDOPMPHÓBQBUSPDJOBEPQPS$0/*
$:5$IJMFZFM#BODP.VOEJBM
i&M BOJNBM DPNP TVKFUP FYQFSJNFOUBM
"TQFDUPT UÏDOJDPT Z ÏUJDPTw $BSNFO
$BSEP[P "mGF .SBE $POTUBO[B .BS
UÓOF[ &EVBSEP 3PESJHVF[ Z 'FSOBOEP
-PMBT *4#/ 3FDPHF BMHVOPT DPODFQUPT
GVOEBNFOUBMFT oFO MP UÏDOJDP Z FO MP
ÏUJDPo QBSB VO BEFDVBEP USBUBNJFOUP
EFM TVKFUP FYQFSJNFOUBM iBOJNBMw FO FM
USBCBKPDJFOUÓmDP
5PEPT MPT MJCSPT NFODJPOBEPT TF
FODVFOUSBO EJTQPOJCMFT HSBUVJUBNFOUF
FO GPSNBUP 1%' FO MPT TJUJPT IUUQ
XXXQBIPPSH4QBOJTICJPQVCMJDB
IUNZIUUQXXXVDIJMFDMCJPFUJDB
)JTUPSJFUBTJMVTUSBEBTDPNJDT
i7JBKFSPT WJSUVBMFT &YQMPSBDJØO CJPÏUJ
DBQPSMBIJTUPSJBEFMBTDJFODJBTw$MBSB
.JTSBDIJ'FMJQF"MMJFOEF%BSÓP0TFTZ
'FSOBOEP -PMBT *4#/ 3FnFYJPOB TPCSF FM TFOUJEP NPSBM
RVFFODJFSSBOTFJTDBTPTQBSBEJHNÈUJDPT
FOMBIJTUPSJBEFMBDJFODJB
i&OUSFUFDIP $POWFSTBDJPOFT CJPÏUJ
DBT TPCSF TFYVBMJEBEw 'FSOBOEP -PMBT
(VJMMFSNP 'VFOUFT «MWBSP 2VF[BEB
%BSÓP0TFT3BGBFM/BOHBSÓZ(FSNÈO
"ESJB[PMB*4#/
"OB
MJ[BMPTEJMFNBTÏUJDPTQSFTFOUFTFODJODP
UFNBTEFTFYVBMJEBEIVNBOB
4JUJPT8FCSFDPNFOEBEPT
#JCMJPUFDB7JSUVBM#JPÏUJDB
IUUQCJPFUJDBCWTBMVEPSHIUNMFT
IPNFIUNM
$FOUSP *OUFSEJTDJQMJOBSJP EF &TUVEJPT
FO#JPÏUJDBEFMB6OJWFSTJEBEEF$IJMF
IUUQXXXVDIJMFDMCJPFUJDB
1SPHSBNB EF #JPÏUJDB EF MB 0SHBOJ[B
DJØO 1BOBNFSJDBOB EF MB 4BMVE 014
0.4
IUUQXXXQBIPPSH4QBOJTICJP
IPNFIUN
ɨF*OUFSOBUJPOBM$PNQJMBUJPOPG)V
NBO4VCKFDU3FTFBSDI1SPUFDUJPOT
IUUQXXXIITHPWPISQJOUFSOBUJPO
BMJOEFYIUNM/BUM1PM
PERSPETIVADELABIOETICAINDD
PERSPETIVADELABIOETICAINDD
4PCSFMPTBVUPSFTZUSBEVDUPSFT
"VUPSFT
'SBODFTD"CFMFTKFTVJUBEPDUPSFO.F
EJDJOB&&66
ZBVUPSEFVOBUFTJTFO
mTJPMPHÓB GFUBMQMBDFOUBSJB 'VOEBEPS Z
QSFTJEFOUF BDUVBM EFM QSJNFS JOTUJUVUP
FVSPQFP EF CJPÏUJDB FM *OTUJUVUP #PSKB
EF#JPÏUJDB
&M$FOUSPFTUÈTJUVB
EPFO4BOU$VHBUEFM7BMMÒT#BSDFMPOB
&TQB×B
ZFTEFTEFDPNPJOTUJUV
UPBDBEÏNJDPVOBVOJEBEEFMB6OJWFS
TJEBE3BNØO-MVMM#BSDFMPOB
+PTÏ 3BNØO "DPTUB 4BSJFHP NÏEJDP
FTQFDJBMJTUB FO TBMVE QÞCMJDB $ÈUFESB
EF #JPÏUJDB EF MB 6OJWFSTJEBE .ÏEJDB
EF -B )BCBOB .BFTUSP FO #JPÏUJDB
1SPHSBNBEF#JPÏUJDBEF0144BOUJB
HP$IJMF
&EJUPSDJFOUÓmDPEF#JPÏUJDB
%FTEF VOB QFSTQFDUJWB DVCBOB 1VCMJ
DBDJPOFT "DVBSJP $FOUSP 'ÏMJY 7BSFMB
-B)BCBOB
&TVOQJPOFSPFOMB
FEVDBDJØOCJPÏUJDBFO$VCB
"MCFSUP"SFMMBOP.ÏOEF[FTHSBEVBEP
EFM$PMFHJPEF"CPHBEPTEFMB6OJWFS
TJEBE "VUØOPNB /BDJPOBM EF .ÏYJDP
6/".
FJOWFTUJHBEPSFOFMDBNQPEF
MB TBMVE Z EFM EFSFDIP EFM *OTUJUVUP EF
*OWFTUJHBDJPOFT +VSÓEJDBT **+6/".
'VFDPOGFSFODJTUBFOFM$PMFHJPEF"CP
HBEPTEF6/".
PERSPETIVADELABIOETICAINDD
.BSUB "TDVSSB FT CJPRVÓNJDB FTQFDJB
MJ[BEBFOHFOÏUJDB*OWFTUJHBEPSBZQSP
GFTPSBEFM*OTUJUVUPEF*OWFTUJHBDJØOFO
$JFODJBT EF MB 4BMVE EF "TVODJØO 1B
SBHVBZ NJFNCSP EF MB $PNJTJØO /B
DJPOBMQBSBFM%FTBSSPMMPEFMB#JPÏUJDB
FO1BSBHVBZ$POTVMUPSBEFMB3FE-B
UJOPBNFSJDBOBZEFM$BSJCFEF#JPÏUJDB
3&%#*046/&4$0
$ISJTUJBO EF 1BVM EF #BSDIJGPOUBJOF
FTFOGFSNFSP.BFTUSPEF(FTUJØO)PT
QJUBMBSJBZ(FSFODJBEFMB4BMVE&TBV
UPSEFWBSJPTMJCSPTFOUSFFMMPT#JPÏUJDBF
*OÓDJPEB7JEB"MHVOT%FTBmPT4ÍP1BV
MP *EÏJBT F -FUSBT DPBVUPS EFM
QSJNFSUSBCBKPEJEÈDUJDPTPCSFCJPÏUJDB
FO #SBTJM 1SPCMFNBT BUVBJT EF CJPÏUJDB
&E-PZPMB‹&E
DPPSEJOB
EPSEF#JPÏUJDBBMHVOTEFTBmPT4ÍP1BV
MP -PZPMB SP &E 1SFTJEFOUF
EFM $FOUSP 6OJWFSTJUÈSJP 4ÍP $BNJMP
41$PPSEJOBEPSEFFTUFWPMVNFO
+PSHF #JTDBJB NÏEJDP EJSFDUPS EFM
$FOUSPEF&TUVEJPT#JPÏUJDPTEF$PJN
CSB1PSUVHBM
"VUPSZDPPSEJOBEPSEF
WBSJPT USBCBKPT EF #JPÏUJDB JODMVZFOEP
/PWPTEFTBmPTË#JPÏUJDB/FX$IBMMFO
HFT UP #JPFUIJDT 1PSUP &EJUPSB 1PSUP
#FN EB 1FTTPB #FN $PNVN
1FSTQFDUJWBTEFMB#JPÏUJDBFO*CFSPBNÏSJDB
1FPQMFT(PPE$PNNPO(PPE(SÈmDB
EF $PJNCSB $PJNCSB 1FSEFS
QBSBFODPOUSBS-PTFUP'JOE0VU$PJN
CSB(SÈmDBEF$PJNCSB
"PFO
DPOUSP EB UFSOVSB 5PXBSET 5FOEFSOFTT
(SÈmDBEF$PJNCSB$PJNCSB
(FSNÈO$BMEFSØO-FHBSEBFTEJSFDUPS
EFM*OTUJUVUPEF#JPÏUJDBEFMB6OJWFSTJ
EBE+BWFSJBOBEF#PHPUÈ'JMØTPGP5SJ
OJUZ $PMMFHF 6OJWFSTJEBE EF %VCMÓO
*SMBOEB
HSBEVBEP QPS MB 6OJWFSTJEBE
/BDJPOBM EF $PMPNCJB Z .BFTUSP FO
#JPÏUJDB 1SPHSBNB EF #JPÏUJDB 0SHB
OJ[BDJØO 1BOBNFSJDBOB EF MB 4BMVE F
*/5&$EF4BOUP%PNJOHP3FQÞCMJDB
%PNJOJDBOB
5SBCBKB QSJODJQBMNFO
UF FO MBT ÈSFBT EF UFPSÓB ÏUJDB CJPÏUJDB
Z EFSFDIPT IVNBOPT Z KVTUJDJB 3FBMJ[B
BDUVBMNFOUFJOWFTUJHBDJPOFTEFCJPÏUJDB
ZNVMUJDVMUVSBMJTNP
%FCPSB %JOJ[ FT %PDUPSB FO "OUSP
QPMPHÓB QSPGFTPSB EF MB 6OJWFSTJEBE EF
#SBTJMJBZEJSFDUPSBEFMBPSHBOJ[BDJØOOP
HVCFSOBNFOUBM"OJT*OTUJUVUPEF#JPÏUJ
DB%FSFDIPT)VNBOPTZ(ÏOFSP&TBV
UPSBEFBSUÓDVMPTDJFOUÓmDPTMJCSPTZEP
DVNFOUBMFT TPCSF CJPÏUJDB "DUVBMNFOUF
QFSUFOFDFBMDPOTFKPEJSFDUJWPEFMB*OUFS
OBUJPOBM"TTPDJBUJPOPG#JPFUIJDT*"#
+BNFT%SBOFFTEJSFDUPSEFM$FOUSPEF
#JPÏUJDB EF MB 6OJWFSTJEBE &EJOCPSP
1FOOTZMWBOJB &&66
&T DPOGFSFO
DJTUB JOUFSOBDJPOBM BVUPS EF WBSJPT MJ
CSPTEF#JPÏUJDBNJFNCSPEFM$PNJUÏ
"TFTPS EFM 1SPHSBNB TF #JPÏUJDB EF MB
014 EFTEF TV FTUBCMFDJNJFOUP &T BVUPS EF .PSF )VNBOF .FEJDJOF
PERSPETIVADELABIOETICAINDD
"-JCFSBM$BUIPMJD#JPFUIJDT&EJOCPSP
&EJOCPSP6OJWFSTJUZ1SFTT1"
.ÈSDJP'BCSJEPT"OKPTFTUFØMPHPNP
SBMJOWFTUJHBEPSZQSPGFTPSEF#JPÏUJDB
EFM $FOUSP 6OJWFSTJUBSJP 4ÍP $BNJMP
.JFNCSP EF MB 4PDJFEBE #SBTJMF×B EF
#JPÏUJDBZBOUJHVPQSFTJEFOUFEFMB4P
DJFEBE#SBTJMF×BEF5FPMPHÓBZ$JFODJBT
EFMB3FMJHJØO$PPSEJOBEPSZBVUPSEF
WBSJBEPT MJCSPT FOUSF FMMPT 5FPMPHÓB Z
OVFWPT QBSBEJHNBT /PWBT (F
SBÎÜFT F 7JEB 3FMJHJPTB i1PXFS
BOE7VMOFSBCJMJUZ"DPOUSJCVUJPOPGEF
WFMPQJOHDPVOUSJFTUPUIFFUIJDBMEFCBUFPO
HFOFUJDTw *O $BIJMM -JTB 4PXMF (FOF
UJDTDzFPMPHZ&UIJDT"OJOUFSEJTDJQMJOBSZ
DPOWFSTBUJPO
%JFHP (SBDJB (VJMMÏO FT QSPGFTPS EF
MB $ÈUFESB EF )JTUPSJB EF MB .FEJDJOB
Z ²UJDB .ÏEJDB FO MB &TDVFMB .ÏEJDB
EFMB6OJWFSTJEBE$PNQMVUFOTFEF.B
ESJE&TQB×B
&TNJFNCSPEFM$PNJUÏ
"TFTPS EFM 1SPHSBNB EF #JPÏUJDB EF MB
0SHBOJ[BDJØO 1BOBNFSJDBOB EF MB 4B
MVE0SHBOJ[BDJØO.VOEJBMEFMB4BMVE
4BOUJBHP $IJMF
&T BVUPS EF WBSJPT
USBCBKPT EF SFGFSFODJB TPCSF CJPÏUJDB
FOUSF FMMPT 'VOEBNFOUPT EF MB CJPÏUJDB
1SPDFEJNJFOUPTEFEFDJTJØOFOÏUJ
DB$MÓOJDB
Z$POUSJCVDJØOEFMBT
)VNBOJEBEFT.ÏEJDBTBMBGPSNBDJØOEFM
NÏEJDP
%JSDF(VJMIFNFTEPDUPSBFO$JFODJBT
EFMB4BMVEZQSPGFTPSBEFMB6OJWFSTJEBE
EF#SBTJMJB&TBVUPSBEFBSUÓDVMPTDJFOUÓ
mDPTZMJCSPTTPCSFCJPÏUJDB"DUVBMNFO
UFFTEJSFDUPSBEFM'PSP-BUJOPBNFSJDBOP
"QÏOEJDFT
EF$PNJUÏTEF²UJDBFO*OWFTUJHBDJØOFO
4BMVE '-"$&*4
"VUPSB EF &TDSBWBT
EP3JTDP#JPÏUJDB.VMIFSFTF"JET#SB
TÓMJB&EJUPSB6O#'JOBUFD
(FSBSEP +JNÏOF[ 4ÈODIF[ FT EPDUPS
FO .FEJDJOB +PIOT )PQLJOT 6OJWFSTJ
UZ .JFNCSP BmMJBEP EFM *OTUJUVUP EF
.FEJDJOB(FOÏUJDBEFMB+PIOT)PQLJOT
6OJWFSTJUZ#BMUJNPSF&&661SPGFTPS
EF(FOØNJDBEFMB6OJWFSTJEBE/BDJP
OBM "VUØOPNB EF .ÏYJDP 6/".
F
JOWFTUJHBEPS SFTJEFOUF EF MB 'VOEBDJØO
.FYJDBOBEFMB4BMVE'6/4"-6%
.JHVFM ,PUUPX mMØTPGP QSPGFTPS EFM
%FQBSUBNFOUPEF'JMPTPGÓBEFMB'BDVM
UBE EF 'JMPTPGÓB Z )VNBOJEBEFT EF MB
6OJWFSTJEBEEF$IJMF4BOUJBHP
"VUPS
EFNVDIPTBSUÓDVMPTZMJCSPTFOFMÈSFB
EFCJPÏUJDB6OPEFTVTUSBCBKPTNÈTSF
DJFOUFTRVFÏMUBNCJÏOPSHBOJ[ØFT#BTFT
DPODFJUVBJT EB CJPÏUJDB FOGPRVF MBUJOP
BNFSJDBOP4ÍP1BVMP(BJB
$ÏTBS'SBODJTDP-BSB«MWBSF[FT.BFT
USPFO²UJDBEFMB*OWFTUJHBDJØO#JPNÏ
EJDB6OJWFSTJEBEEF$IJMF-FDPODFEJØ
VOBCFDBFM'PHBSUZ/BUJPOBM*OTUJUVUFTPG
)FBMUI/*)
64"%JSFDUPSEFQSPHSB
NBT FEVDBUJWPT EFM *OTUJUVUP /BDJPOBM
EF .FEJDJOB (FOØNJDB */.&(&/
.ÏYJDP$PPSEJOBEPSEFJOWFTUJHBDJPOFT
EFDVFTUJPOFTÏUJDBTMFHBMFTZTPDJBMFTEFM
$FOUSP EF .FEJDJOB (FOØNJDB .ÏYJ
DP 1SPGFTPS EFM 1SPHSBNB EF .BFTUSÓB
FO#JPÏUJDB*1/$JVEBEEF.ÏYJDP
)VCFSU -FQBSHOFVS %PDUPS FO 5FP
MPHÓB.PSBMZ%FSFDIPQPSMB6OJWFSTJ
EBEEF1BSÓT'VFVOPEFMPTGVOEBEPSFT
PERSPETIVADELABIOETICAINDD
Z QSJNFS FEJUPS FO KFGF EF MB SFWJTUB 0
.VOEPEB4BÞEFEFM$FOUSP6OJWFSTJUB
SJP4ÍP$BNJMP4ÍP1BVMP
"VUPSEFVO
TJOOÞNFSPEFBSUÓDVMPTZPCSBTEFUFPMP
HÓBNPSBMZCJPÏUJDB&OUSFPUSBT0MVHBS
BUVBM EB NPSUF "OUSPQPMPHJB EP
TPGSJNFOUP
#JPÏUJDBOPWPDPODFJ
UPBDBNJOIPEFVNDPOTFOTP
'FSOBOEP-PMBTFTQSPGFTPSUJUVMBSFOMB
6OJWFSTJEBEEF$IJMF%JSFDUPSEFM1SP
HSBNB EF #JPÏUJDB EF MB 0SHBOJ[BDJØO
1BOBNFSJDBOB EF MB 4BMVE 4BOUJBHP
$IJMF
Z EFM $FOUSP *OUFSEJTDJQMJOBSJP
EF &TUVEJPT FO #JPÏUJDB EF MB 6OJWFS
TJEBE EF $IJMF "VUPS EF WBSJPT MJCSPT
FOUSF FMMPT #JPÏUJDB Z NFEJDJOB BTQFDUPT
EFVOBSFMBDJØO4BOUJBHPEF$IJMF#J
CMJPUFDB "NFSJDBOB Z .ÈT BMMÈ
EFMDVFSQPMBDPOTUSVDDJØOOBSSBUJWBEFMB
TBMVE4BOUJBHPEF$IJMF&EJUPSJBM"O
ESÏT#FMMP
"MGPOTP -MBOP &TDPCBS FT UFØMPHP KF
TVJUB BOUJHVP %JSFDUPS Z GVOEBEPS EFM
$FOUSPEF#JPÏUJDBEFMB6OJWFSTJEBE+B
WFSJBOB#PHPUÈ$PMPNCJB
'VOEBEPS
EF MB 'FEFSBDJØO -BUJOPBNFSJDBOB EF
*OTUJUVDJPOFTEF#JPÏUJDB'&-"*#&
3PCFSUP-MBOPT;VMPBHBFTQTJRVJBUSB
Z QTJDPUFSBQFVUB FTQFDJBMJTUB FO QTJ
RVJBUSÓB DMÓOJDB KFGF EFM %FQBSUBNFOUP
EF 1TJDPUFSBQJB EF MB $MÓOJDB 3JDBSEP
1BMNB 'VOEBEPS Z QSFTJEFOUF BDUVBM
EF MB "TPDJBDJØO 1FSVBOB EF #JPÏUJDB
&TQSPGFTPSZDPPSEJOBEPSEFM%PDUPSB
EPFO1TJDPMPHÓBEFMB6OJWFSTJEBEEFM
4BHSBEP$PSB[ØO1SPGFTPSJOWJUBEPEF
#JPÏUJDB FO MB VOJWFSTJEBEFT /BDJPOBM
EF4BO.BSDPTZ$BZFUBOP)FSFEJB
1FSTQFDUJWBTEFMB#JPÏUJDBFO*CFSPBNÏSJDB
+PTÏ"MCFSUP.BJOFUUJEPDUPSFO.F
EJDJOBZ'JMPTPGÓB1SFTJEFOUFEFMB'VO
EBDJØO +PTÏ .BJOFUUJ #POOFU #VFOPT
"JSFT "SHFOUJOB
%JSFDUPS Z QSPGFTPS
EFM*OTUJUVUPEF#JPÏUJDBZ)VNBOJEB
EFT.ÏEJDBTEFMB'VOEBDJØO+PTÏ.BJ
OFUUJ QBSB FM 1SPHSFTP EF MB .FEJDJOB
FO-B1MBUB"SHFOUJOB
'VFVOPEFMPT
GVOEBEPSFTEF'&-"*#&0SHBOJ[ØDPO
+VBO$BSMPT5FBMEJFM**$POHSFTP.VO
EJBMEF#JPÏUJDBFO#VFOPT"JSFT
8BMUFS0TTXBMEFYEJSFDUPSEFM*OTUJ
UVUP EF #JPÏUJDB 6OJWFSTJEBE $BUØMJDB
1PSUVHVFTB 1PSUP
Z FY QSFTJEFOUF EF
MB"TPDJBDJØO.VOEJBMEF.ÏEJDPT$B
UØMJDPTFTBVUPSZDPPSEJOBEPSEFNV
DIPTUSBCBKPTFOFMÈSFBEFÏUJDBNÏEJDB
ZCJPÏUJDBFOUSFFMMPT%JSFJUPTEP)PNFN
F#JPNFEJDJOB1PSUP6OJWFSTJEBEF$B
UØMJDB&EJUPSB
6NmPEF²UJDB
$PJNCSB(SÈmDBEF$PJNCSB
.BSUB-VDÓB1ÏSF[FTMJDFODJBEBFO'JMP
TPGÓBEFTBSSPMMBUSBCBKPTMJHBEPTBMB$È
UFESBEF'JMPTPGÓB.ÏEJDBEFMB'BDVMUBE
EF$JFODJBT.ÏEJDBTEFMB6OJWFSTJEBE
/BDJPOBMEF-B1MBUB"SHFOUJOB
-FP1FTTJOJ%PDUPSFO5FPMPHÓB.P
SBM*OWFTUJHBEPSZQSPGFTPSFOFMDVSTP
EF.BFTUSÓBTUSJDUPTFOTVFO#JPÏUJDBEFM
$FOUSP6OJWFSTJUBSJP4ÍP$BNJMP7JDF
QSFTJEFOUFEFMB4PDJFEBEEF#JPÏUJDBEF
4ÍP 1BVMP .JFNCSP EFM
DPNJUÏ PSHBOJ[BEPS EFM 7* $POHSFTP
.VOEJBMEF#JPÏUJDBFO#SBTJMJB
RVF BCPSEØ FM UFNB i#JPÏUJDB QPEFS F
JOKVTUJDJBw "VUPS EF EJWFSTPT MJCSPT FO
FMÈSFBEFÏUJDBCJPÏUJDBZUFPMPHÓBNP
SBMBMHVOPTUSBEVDJEPTBMFTQB×PMFOUSF
PERSPETIVADELABIOETICAINDD
PUSPT%JTUBOÈTJBBUÏRVBOEPQSPMPOHBSB
WJEB41BVMP&E-PZPMB
&VUB
OÈTJBQPSRVFBCSFWJBSBWJEB41BVMP
&E-PZPMB
DPBVUPSEF)VNBOJ
[BÎÍP F DVJEBEPT QBMJBUJWPT )VNBOJ[B
UJPOBOEQBMMJBUJWFDBSF41BVMP-PZP
MB DPBVUPS EF 1SPCMFNBT BUVBJT
EF CJPÏUJDB 4 1BVMP -PZPMB B &E
$PPSEJOBEPSEFFTUFWPMVNFO
.JHVFM 4VB[P NÏEJDP FTUVEJØ FO MB
6OJWFSTJEBE "VUØOPNB EF 4BOUP %P
NJOHP 3FQÞCMJDB %PNJOJDBOB
4F
FTQFDJBMJ[Ø FO FEVDBDJØO TFYVBM Z FT
.BFTUSP FO 4FYPMPHÓB 3FQÞCMJDB %P
NJOJDBOB
&T .BFTUSP FO #JPÏUJDB
6OJWFSTJEBE EF $IJMF 014 &TBDUVBMNFOUFEFDBOPEFM*OT
UJUVUP5FDOPMØHJDPEF4BOUP%PNJOHP
*OUFD
Z FT EJSFDUPS EFM $FOUSP *OUFD
EF#JPÏUJDBZDPPSEJOBEPSEFMDVSTPEF
&TQFDJBMJ[BDJØOFO#JPÏUJDBFOMBNJTNB
JOTUJUVDJØO
/VSJB5FSSJCBTFTBCPHBEBFJOWFTUJHB
EPSBFONBUFSJBTEFEFSFDIP%JSFDUPSB
EFM *OTUJUVUP #PSKB EFM #JPÏUJDB *##
EFTEF TVDFEJFOEP B 'SBODFTD
"CFM &OTF×B FO FM *## Z DPPSEJOB FM
DVSTP EF .BFTUSÓB FO #JPÏUJDB %FTEF
FEJUBMBSFWJTUB#JPÏUJDBZ%FCBUZ
FTDPOTVMUPSBEF%FSFDIPFODPNJTJPOFT
EFM (PWFSOP "VUÙOPNP EF $BUBMV×B
QBSBDVFTUJPOFTCJPÏUJDBT
5SBEVDUPSFT
"EBJM4PCSBMFTUSBEVDUPSEFJOHMÏTGSBO
DÏT Z FTQB×PM QSJODJQBMNFOUF FO DJFO
DJBTIVNBOBTmMPTPGÓBZTBMVE%PDUPS
FO -JOHàÓTUJDB "QMJDBEB Z DPO FTUVEJPT
"QÏOEJDFT
EFMMFOHVBKF1POUJmDJB6OJWFSTJEBE$B
UØMJDBEF4ÍP1BVMP
FTBVUPSEFMJCSPT
BDFSDB EFM EJTDVSTP Z EF MB USBEVDDJØO
Z USBEVDUPS EF MB SFWJTUB 0 .VOEP EB
4BÞEFQVCMJDBEBQPSFM$FOUSP6OJWFS
TJUBSJP4ÍP$BNJMP&TUBNCJÏOSFWJTPS
EF MFOHVB JOHMFTB EF MB SFWJTUB "QQMJFE
$BODFS3FTFBSDIQVCMJDBEBQPS)PTQJUBM
EFM$ÈODFS"$$BNBSHP
.BSJB4UFMB(POÎBMWFTFTUSBEVDUPSBEF
FTQB×PMGSBODÏTFJOHMÏTQSJODJQBMNFO
UFFOFMÈSFBEFMBTDJFODJBTIVNBOBTZEF
MBTBMVE.BFTUSBFO-JOHàÓTUJDB6/*
PERSPETIVADELABIOETICAINDD
$".1
FT USBEVDUPSB EF MB SFWJTUB 0
.VOEPEB4BÞEFQVCMJDBEPQPSFM$FO
USP6OJWFSTJUBSJP4ÍP$BNJMP
.BSUB(MVLNBO4BMJUBFTQSPGFTPSBEF
'SBODÏT 7JTJUJOH 1SPGFTTPS %VLF 6OJ
WFSTJUZ%VSIBN/PSUI$BSPMJOB%FT
FNQF×Ø EJWFSTPT DBSHPT FO MB 'BDVMUBE
EF'JMPTPGÓBZ-FUSBTEFMB6OJWFSTJEBE
EF $IJMF Z BDUVBMNFOUF DPMBCPSB DPO
FM$FOUSP*OUFSEJTDJQMJOBSJPEF&TUVEJPT
FO#JPÏUJDBEFMBNJTNBVOJWFSTJEBEZFO
MBFEJDJØOEF"DUB#JPFUIJDBSFWJTUBEFM
QSPHSBNBEF#JPÏUJDBEF0140.4