Margarita Zamora. Language, Authority, and Indigenous History in

Dissidences
Hispanic Journal of Theory and Criticism
Volume 1 | Issue 2
Article 20
11-29-2012
Margarita Zamora. Language, Authority, and
Indigenous History in the Comentarios Reales de
los Incas
Leila Gómez
University of Colorado at Boulder
Follow this and additional works at: http://digitalcommons.bowdoin.edu/dissidences
Recommended Citation
Gómez, Leila (2006) "Margarita Zamora. Language, Authority, and Indigenous History in the Comentarios Reales de los Incas,"
Dissidences: Vol. 1: Iss. 2, Article 20.
Available at: http://digitalcommons.bowdoin.edu/dissidences/vol1/iss2/20
This Review / Reseña is brought to you for free and open access by the Journals at Bowdoin Digital Commons. It has been accepted for inclusion in
Dissidences by an authorized administrator of Bowdoin Digital Commons. For more information, please contact jmontgom@bowdoin.edu.
Margarita Zamora. Language, Authority, and Indigenous History in the
Comentarios Reales de los Incas
Keywords / Palabras clave
Inca Garcilaso, Comentarios reales, Indígenas, Autoridad
This review / reseña is available in Dissidences: http://digitalcommons.bowdoin.edu/dissidences/vol1/iss2/20


 







 
!"#$%&'()*++,



 !  " # $"


%&' () & "$*  *   +", "
-&,.," $!,"/ .$,,"0$!$"$1 
""$( ,2&, ",$ "$,$$$" "' 30$"( 
&$"*"&34$",$,"   ",
.$), ,,"" ,"0$.5*,$,",$.&" 
, "-&,$"( , ,$ "(,"62,
")&($"  ,,"(   0$,()$  "$,  3' 
70$, 3(" ",", , "3*$,, ,,"
($  (7  ,, ,(,",$$. ", (
0$25"2( "" ($"  ,,"&$,"$ 3
, 5"2"12&! &,"0$,.$  " 
",$ " &, "( *2( ,(!,$"$,,, ,  



" $ ,$$3,  &2 ,5, " ,  3$ ()$, ,(,
( ",". 8  *4 "* , "!,"9$$9
, , :,  6   4 ; : ( *, " &, 0$
(("""  "$, ((," ,"" ,
( "$,,"$,  ,  ,3$"" )(  ( <%&  3
, "  4 ; 3 =>2+ 6"  3  8  *3
5"' 3(,(1$., 3&"", "!,
*&"($"  (,

&$" ,()$ 3?&$&"@ A+,.$".(.  &,
", B3$ 1,"""0$"( !  &)+, 3 *
 " ,$ $" " 1 *)*, ;,,"""1$ "3 
! & ,)0$, &!," ? &B" 1 2"$" 
"  $&$ &.*  && "", $(,")
"$,, "#*$&$ 1 " "4(   *4  "  &)
! &,"  -3"  36  "8*4!$" " 
0$" &5,  !$((,*", *(5, 0$ ' 
70$?&$&( ""..$,, .. ,("(.  &C.
,, !&$&C.,.".,  !.($.,! ( *B
,$(,"$(" ., ,$2, *,, 2"$" 
! &, "0$,.$,  ?&$ &B$   "1(,, "
(,$""5,&,"&$" ,3$ 312&"$,,
"  &)0$,.$(" ( , ,  ! $ "",$
(,5( ("?""B". ,, 1 ,

,,()$ 3?&$&"@ .  +B3' , (
", , " ! & $"" ,()$  ,),
, $,,", ,  $ ""1$&,$.*""&D),"0$,.$
$,,  & "( ,A) ", 3& (,:
"",  " ,$ &4$",",  (7 :3(("& 
,$ (" 8  *3$ """,  "(' $
"&  """ 2(",  "$(" 3



!$,"0$(E "",, , $)$
!&$,  "$ "$, "$!$ $ 70$
"" "!) ", ", ,,"",$$ .*, ( " 
"" $ """.  &5!,!$ ,$ 0$)0$
$  ( !$0$( , 3,   0$($
" 0$(2$) 3"!) 0$,  &)(
, ,(,",$,  ! (&"", ,"  ,""
,,"

,$ ,()$ 3?;.  &3 3".$,.  B3$ 
 " 0$!  &)!$, "" ! ,". ,' 
1,$"" ,,"$,," 2 0$,.$0$, , 
!" ,  , 0$" , (7  , (" . 3&
,$$,( $",  , "&$ " 2  0$(
' :,  F;GH3FH F.$,H: *1(,,"&!," "F;,.,,H
$,,   ) ,' , A? *, ($ ";,.30$
$" $ 3",3(,( ("* ,0$3,$* 
""$" *,0$5;,.,,0$"0$"5$" $ 3
 "$( (&!,,0$"0$., $  0$5, 
,$( BI1(,,"2 !$"&$,",  *
  ) " ,' "   A?;$)30$ " 
, ,, 3( !, "3(&$. ,  $
&$J);,.,,BII$""(!,, (""
1& !+, 3, "$, ,,
.  &5!,.2$,"* ,," *&", 

0$ ,()$ ? 1"1A.", $ .$ !.6,""
.  B3G, "5 & ,  5(  &  
""* *.$"", , " ")&' ".,
$" (),,0$, $""5 & 1$, E,, "- 3
#  2"3/$2"(G"/ 2"6, ;' 3, (,
, ,", (G",$ **,  4$!,,",$"&$



,  ")&() " (),. ,,(,  , ",
$1(,,( ", ( !$""( $, '  0$
", , %, 5(,, $$(( &2,(&""
 (7 !,"*" 9.(!,  !,$ 9K,$ 
;,.,,,  """$( ",()$  )$ " (,(
&$ " 0$"),  $(( &,3$ ,,)
, ,(,,"?*5*  B,.), "," " ,$ (& ,  
*""  0$ )6, 

1 ,()$ 3?8 C. C.A.  ". ( "B3
' &$0$ "  , ( ), "$ ()G, "( *!"& 
L-(( ,""(&, ( 5$$! *$ ()
,$) ,,  $2 ?"" B3.*" ""$,,, , "
, 6)3",' A? (", $, ( ! ..$,
&.  . ", (1,$$&*"
,,(* .$ ($",BM' (,,),$(,"
, 0$, A,  4*" ", $""3$,"
( (""("3*4 "?,B, $, " 0$,G, 
"$7 "3  ) ,  ((,"" ", 
(,"$""$ ," 0$",** 3,   ($* "%  
%, 5(,   ;' 3, ( (  3("
,&,, (", %  $&$" * 3"($, ,,
, ,),0$,  , " ,""$ (,  ,""$(,,"( 
,;' 3,  &)$(,( ? $&B"$ ()
N.$$$

* "' ($,$"$(5""0$,",()$ ( 
1(" *! ,("" ,()$  "$
*"$, ., $3"&"","2,$" ", 1 
! &, ,"$&5"&",$"$ " 
  $, 1 '  1(,"($,",$



" *"$ ,  ,,"O 1,$" J "  * $0$"
. 


